id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17914v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17914v2
|
Extracting Lexical Features from Dialects via Interpretable Dialect Classifiers
| 2024-02-27T22:06:55 | 2024-03-23T20:21:04 |
Roy Xie, Orevaoghene Ahia, Yulia Tsvetkov, Antonios Anastasopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Identifying linguistic differences between dialects of a language often
requires expert knowledge and meticulous human analysis. This is largely due to
the complexity and nuance involved in studying various dialects. We present a
novel approach to extract distinguishing lexical features of dialects by
utilizing interpretable dialect classifiers, even in the absence of human
experts. We explore both post-hoc and intrinsic approaches to interpretability,
conduct experiments on Mandarin, Italian, and Low Saxon, and experimentally
demonstrate that our method successfully identifies key language-specific
lexical features that contribute to dialectal variations.
|
[
-0.6002749800682068,
-0.4126055836677551,
0.5856265425682068,
0.11619962751865387,
-0.04654591158032417,
-0.03730266913771629,
-0.4209751486778259,
-0.7777549624443054,
0.5027620792388916,
0.5971255302429199,
-0.23679715394973755,
-0.16195303201675415,
-0.468946635723114,
0.0650983601808548,
-0.2078130841255188,
0.697729766368866,
0.5088021755218506,
-0.06049676612019539,
0.26941776275634766,
-0.31429460644721985,
-0.21051698923110962,
-0.5894141793251038,
-0.3404642939567566,
-0.2008287012577057,
0.29215067625045776,
0.38858556747436523,
0.9607763886451721,
0.47466734051704407,
0.2507736384868622,
0.31822603940963745,
-0.5035790801048279,
0.2076505422592163,
-0.026220310479402542,
-0.10151597112417221,
-0.3394034802913666,
-0.5797811150550842,
-0.3380943238735199,
-0.2503824234008789,
0.5158414244651794,
1.0260082483291626,
0.09125760197639465,
-0.09031503647565842,
0.10420358180999756,
0.5761186480522156,
-0.5525326132774353,
0.40819892287254333,
-0.8689159750938416,
-0.017748981714248657,
-0.715572714805603,
-0.03562154248356819,
-0.3040059506893158,
-0.3496145009994507,
0.3228118419647217,
-0.48939743638038635,
0.6514379382133484,
-0.241119846701622,
0.8938882946968079,
-0.1825558990240097,
-0.21971064805984497,
-0.15534861385822296,
-0.485859751701355,
0.5700081586837769,
-0.8059242963790894,
0.41134998202323914,
0.21308286488056183,
0.43956300616264343,
0.08240222185850143,
-0.4988376796245575,
-0.4700978696346283,
-0.28405192494392395,
-0.3941279649734497,
0.06051735579967499,
0.26337510347366333,
-0.01121179573237896,
0.07068289816379547,
0.5322041511535645,
-0.26730167865753174,
0.02934439107775688,
-0.1851058155298233,
-0.23758581280708313,
0.6182929873466492,
0.051923878490924835,
0.2506321370601654,
-0.4725588858127594,
0.13022039830684662,
0.18084800243377686,
-0.5875314474105835,
0.3243478238582611,
0.2660323679447174,
0.6555275321006775,
0.04519789293408394,
0.1714194267988205,
-0.5049466490745544,
0.4631032645702362,
0.009177396073937416,
0.16219104826450348,
0.2378488928079605,
-0.09353365749120712,
0.27568018436431885,
-0.01606130413711071,
0.37680932879447937,
-0.20590560138225555,
0.38755592703819275,
-0.16904211044311523,
-0.4403766393661499,
-0.47993651032447815,
0.10341234505176544,
-0.36092454195022583,
-0.539886474609375,
-0.16328172385692596,
-0.49303165078163147,
-0.5200082659721375,
0.36618712544441223,
-1.0473451614379883,
-0.5908809900283813,
0.02040938101708889,
0.2707599699497223,
-0.2933439314365387,
-0.8280174732208252,
-0.011982958763837814,
-0.5750746726989746,
0.5110064148902893,
0.22658413648605347,
-1.3264219760894775,
0.4592038094997406,
0.7380087375640869,
0.8587023615837097,
-0.06856614351272583,
-0.2123342752456665,
-0.19747500121593475,
-0.17996329069137573,
-0.4880521893501282,
0.6872208118438721,
-0.8017089366912842,
-0.2873261570930481,
-0.10529165714979172,
0.04678195342421532,
-0.04350629821419716,
-0.8402923941612244,
0.18193641304969788,
-0.6067121624946594,
-0.2375718653202057,
-0.21702945232391357,
-0.30999499559402466,
-0.407840758562088,
-0.10990401357412338,
-0.9338107109069824,
0.9976977109909058,
0.6266202926635742,
-0.6901131868362427,
0.23326905071735382,
-0.42040976881980896,
-0.49462035298347473,
0.2701131999492645,
-0.12495462596416473,
-0.0402289479970932,
0.7508112192153931,
0.192278191447258,
0.17773066461086273,
-0.2216903418302536,
0.18470431864261627,
-0.1926177442073822,
-0.18993599712848663,
0.515410840511322,
-0.4449951946735382,
0.9152485132217407,
0.2492271363735199,
-0.5575944781303406,
-0.030552878975868225,
-1.1066256761550903,
0.3043287694454193,
0.10341163724660873,
0.03105347976088524,
-0.42335131764411926,
0.2871432304382324,
0.22186219692230225,
-0.029752254486083984,
0.23901337385177612,
-0.3135262131690979,
-0.07664458453655243,
-0.6259832382202148,
0.4625954329967499,
0.6252214312553406,
-0.24738480150699615,
0.4643044173717499,
-0.15635304152965546,
0.46842333674430847,
-0.03289744630455971,
-0.23453237116336823,
0.055471207946538925,
-0.38804569840431213,
-0.9396969079971313,
-0.34858429431915283,
0.4113553762435913,
0.5478742122650146,
-0.8049650192260742,
0.5367515087127686,
-0.20873777568340302,
-0.8104913234710693,
-0.2710801661014557,
0.1632366180419922,
0.5025640726089478,
0.26558011770248413,
0.3225085437297821,
-0.49936532974243164,
-0.24540382623672485,
-0.7064651250839233,
-0.41353338956832886,
-0.3139585852622986,
-0.14537860453128815,
0.2763429284095764,
0.1265089511871338,
-0.022511832416057587,
1.0739189386367798,
-0.6074326634407043,
0.023945199325680733,
-0.7634171843528748,
0.2270333170890808,
0.1356988102197647,
0.1018378734588623,
0.7045088410377502,
-0.67579585313797,
-0.3790236711502075,
0.6455027461051941,
-0.5551087856292725,
-0.7177209854125977,
-0.16528581082820892,
0.03401428088545799,
0.01663525216281414,
0.617050051689148,
-0.16337786614894867,
0.3085562288761139,
0.17138230800628662,
-0.22614210844039917,
0.7388185262680054,
0.06081199273467064,
-0.11683180928230286,
-0.57502681016922,
-0.18144376575946808,
-0.09159763157367706,
-0.3240862786769867,
-0.8081450462341309,
0.22383959591388702,
0.1826547533273697,
0.05411198362708092,
-0.33417412638664246,
0.7574647665023804,
-0.4436875283718109,
-0.07133892923593521,
0.05394024774432182,
0.08131927251815796,
0.18743647634983063,
0.2943529486656189,
0.561854362487793,
0.3996635973453522,
0.4520597755908966,
-0.3438888192176819,
0.18553940951824188,
0.09341220557689667,
-0.4702036380767822,
0.3312269449234009,
-0.4516352117061615,
0.04236253350973129,
0.0013000589096918702,
-0.3727918267250061,
-1.068428874015808,
-0.4096260666847229,
-0.01482953317463398,
-0.49269187450408936,
0.15626117587089539,
-0.2770921587944031,
0.1406245231628418,
0.23702141642570496,
-0.06000401824712753,
0.23355846107006073,
0.3610116243362427,
-0.5326330661773682,
0.6278218626976013,
0.2606586813926697,
-0.5259817838668823,
-0.23421160876750946,
-0.5223878026008606,
-0.07596306502819061,
-0.37180811166763306,
-0.38956186175346375,
-0.09540484100580215,
0.6115867495536804,
-0.6303344964981079,
-0.025706520304083824,
-0.0912875086069107,
-0.5774233341217041,
0.3197886049747467,
0.12048415094614029,
0.030475903302431107,
-0.5905314683914185,
0.13591621816158295,
-0.011714411899447441,
-0.07578805834054947,
-0.029776571318507195,
-0.19719943404197693,
0.43168550729751587,
-0.22653836011886597,
-0.09501815587282181,
-0.48470181226730347,
0.37020012736320496,
0.46703481674194336,
-0.29313740134239197,
0.5601716637611389,
0.6304635405540466,
-0.1864784210920334,
-0.34580135345458984,
-0.5938552618026733,
-0.07935632020235062,
-0.5094346404075623,
0.5321515202522278,
-0.7156596183776855,
-0.547286868095398,
0.7052325010299683,
-0.16518262028694153,
-0.28210216760635376,
0.4618079960346222,
0.20242148637771606,
0.008079900406301022,
0.7331305146217346,
0.6266266703605652,
-0.16204625368118286,
0.7448136210441589,
0.2682335376739502,
0.04819667339324951,
-0.3828746974468231,
0.0645136684179306,
-0.7299684286117554,
0.07385382056236267,
-0.5991787314414978,
-0.11902855336666107,
0.44572779536247253,
0.07325072586536407,
0.07519789040088654,
0.25509974360466003,
-0.11251747608184814,
0.6567643880844116,
0.45726919174194336,
0.1561516970396042,
0.1340503990650177,
-0.20037372410297394,
-0.13067154586315155,
-0.1267104595899582,
-0.22342701256275177,
-0.46735289692878723,
0.7144164443016052,
0.15480326116085052,
0.6729361414909363,
0.5386520624160767,
0.5990400314331055,
0.3582572042942047,
-0.032653626054525375,
-1.008942723274231,
0.506506085395813,
-0.22941534221172333,
-0.5295959711074829,
-0.44529229402542114,
-0.5942866206169128,
-0.6434845924377441,
0.5403181910514832,
-0.3089344799518585,
-0.6009796857833862,
0.34646305441856384,
0.07611232250928879,
-0.20830129086971283,
0.16376233100891113,
-0.9429114460945129,
0.9415131211280823,
-0.3362312614917755,
0.09027544409036636,
0.0335552915930748,
-0.7692670226097107,
-0.10002120584249496,
-0.2725326120853424,
0.5975853800773621,
0.08857033401727676,
0.078241728246212,
0.4240911304950714,
-0.5799711346626282,
0.8602018356323242,
-0.3283239006996155,
0.06228093430399895,
0.1244802251458168,
0.37904196977615356,
0.004218386951833963,
-0.06476399302482605,
-0.31555622816085815,
0.578080415725708,
0.3617171049118042,
-0.5278151035308838,
-0.7159504890441895,
0.06009748578071594,
-0.8424978256225586,
-0.7404285073280334,
-0.3695317804813385,
-0.35099244117736816,
-0.39001885056495667,
0.4284226596355438,
0.27807292342185974,
0.7972177267074585,
-0.5126326680183411,
-0.24891261756420135,
0.39986929297447205,
-0.12421288341283798,
0.4061543941497803,
0.47208142280578613,
-0.15122757852077484,
-0.3002467453479767,
1.1572917699813843,
0.12015610188245773,
0.6439172625541687,
0.4196643531322479,
0.5495687127113342,
-0.13485465943813324,
-0.9943376779556274,
-0.5771619081497192,
0.10914970934391022,
-0.636033833026886,
0.491561621427536,
-0.13874496519565582,
-0.3632661998271942,
-0.60801762342453,
-0.32849788665771484,
-0.44590896368026733,
-0.8260027170181274,
-0.20706428587436676,
0.08747425675392151,
-0.04287853464484215,
1.187387466430664,
-0.17368043959140778,
0.5123119950294495,
-1.0827598571777344,
0.037042923271656036,
0.35933852195739746,
-0.17046700417995453,
-0.00742625817656517,
-0.6317864656448364,
-0.13411659002304077,
-0.17396362125873566,
-0.020960064604878426,
-1.1021496057510376,
0.5516037344932556,
0.6424187421798706,
0.6680924296379089,
0.9752184152603149,
0.08617375791072845,
0.7337656021118164,
-0.3280940353870392,
0.8334530591964722,
-0.07655283063650131,
-1.456419587135315,
0.47822102904319763,
-0.12932676076889038,
0.06741757690906525,
0.621465265750885,
0.30270108580589294,
-0.674554705619812,
-0.43518686294555664,
-0.3155716359615326,
-0.8218125104904175,
0.8134722709655762,
0.09258227795362473,
0.007013168651610613,
-0.06049658730626106,
0.4460548162460327,
0.30369389057159424,
0.08433420211076736,
-0.5305795073509216,
0.13121728599071503,
-0.2113209217786789,
-0.20677302777767181,
-0.3347702622413635,
-0.29389023780822754,
0.020507188513875008,
-0.22880670428276062,
0.1915663778781891,
-0.16691799461841583,
-0.09157964587211609,
0.08742981404066086,
-0.5989300012588501,
0.34485676884651184,
0.4370768666267395,
0.16912899911403656,
0.7854414582252502,
-0.14961133897304535,
0.673831582069397,
0.2243436723947525,
-0.5386959910392761,
0.007274278439581394,
0.00119216984603554,
0.040762364864349365,
0.19388309121131897,
0.7939773201942444,
0.5137493014335632,
0.060493964701890945,
-0.69572913646698,
0.5338240265846252,
0.008789105340838432,
0.18559283018112183,
-0.43387115001678467,
0.1691845953464508,
-0.11772409826517105,
0.347173810005188,
0.08061530441045761,
0.18806175887584686,
0.44678422808647156,
-0.7213897705078125,
0.11293918639421463,
0.26077792048454285,
-0.7021692991256714,
-0.5865710377693176,
0.24748358130455017,
0.23105672001838684,
-0.09394019097089767,
0.45708948373794556,
-0.4753277003765106,
-0.7701573371887207,
0.8423572182655334,
0.33166682720184326,
0.6975792646408081,
-0.2853643596172333,
0.27670034766197205,
0.030989162623882294,
0.10801825672388077,
0.11659567803144455,
0.03860848397016525,
-0.36094173789024353,
-1.0049834251403809,
0.1779244840145111,
-0.5561978220939636,
-0.5737207531929016,
-0.3321433663368225,
-1.2784940004348755,
0.309333473443985,
-0.2956046462059021,
0.21802948415279388,
0.5592538714408875,
-0.42405760288238525,
-0.30401191115379333,
0.004517919383943081,
0.25598543882369995,
0.6742165088653564,
-1.1006276607513428,
0.7980250716209412,
0.6877070665359497,
-0.03024008497595787,
-0.7220431566238403,
0.2670997381210327,
0.3957204818725586,
-0.8449216485023499,
0.6831766366958618,
0.16484951972961426,
-0.3370581567287445,
-0.17289379239082336,
-0.17138974368572235,
-0.516507089138031,
0.31245630979537964,
0.11923205852508545,
-0.2993803322315216,
0.07218526303768158,
0.502718985080719,
0.6622989773750305,
-0.03843535855412483,
0.6574878692626953,
1.0440986156463623,
0.27657341957092285,
0.2011907994747162,
-1.040902018547058,
-0.11620587855577469,
-0.350119024515152,
0.024533966556191444,
0.2733948528766632,
-0.488237202167511,
0.9646404385566711,
-0.047198984771966934,
-0.12194962799549103,
0.1526164412498474,
0.4643789827823639,
-0.31333547830581665,
0.35381680727005005,
0.6932469606399536,
0.27734723687171936,
0.8573459982872009,
-0.21214640140533447,
0.46114349365234375,
-0.20234251022338867,
0.44426167011260986,
1.0491890907287598,
-0.24683965742588043,
0.8985387682914734,
0.09601152688264847,
-0.3323170244693756,
0.39684584736824036,
0.7388294339179993,
0.40032362937927246,
0.6237830519676208,
0.03360174223780632,
-0.6499442458152771,
-0.5251103639602661,
0.10773007571697235,
-0.3619323968887329,
0.8870657086372375,
0.6925824284553528,
-0.16344504058361053,
-0.12787485122680664,
-0.13252639770507812,
0.22237591445446014,
-0.08997388929128647,
-0.36963796615600586,
0.9514248967170715,
-0.11786860972642899,
-0.4855632483959198,
0.664746880531311,
-0.34146153926849365,
0.5827071666717529,
-0.6124446392059326,
-0.10020395368337631,
-0.21553513407707214,
0.27828940749168396,
-0.516135573387146,
-0.7005284428596497,
0.5537050366401672,
-0.10433387011289597,
0.04796156659722328,
0.09401531517505646,
0.515015721321106,
-0.1562402993440628,
-0.3608757555484772,
0.3515596389770508,
0.7976038455963135,
0.3496640920639038,
-0.1766926646232605,
-0.1139092668890953,
-0.26443877816200256,
0.10203259438276291,
-0.10831742733716965,
0.1115216538310051,
0.8105475902557373,
-0.055312033742666245,
0.2538102865219116,
0.2190820276737213,
0.5167530179023743,
0.0729529857635498,
0.027875039726495743,
0.801500678062439,
-1.077886700630188,
-0.45031723380088806,
-0.7892386317253113,
0.1788606345653534,
0.016552122309803963,
-0.38349270820617676,
0.571544885635376,
0.13024668395519257,
0.8723589777946472,
-0.10219013690948486,
0.9981616735458374,
-0.4747747480869293,
0.5868726968765259,
-0.5548270344734192,
0.7256858348846436,
-0.6022981405258179,
0.40819403529167175,
-0.19072431325912476,
-0.6204153299331665,
-0.233669713139534,
0.7620286345481873,
-0.2676049470901489,
-0.10438740253448486,
0.7053114175796509,
0.9488775134086609,
0.0325520783662796,
0.382673978805542,
0.31749850511550903,
0.34032899141311646,
0.3225403130054474,
0.20376868546009064,
1.2026211023330688,
0.3608097434043884,
0.300956666469574,
-0.42697620391845703,
-0.47597476840019226,
-0.05228875204920769,
-0.633133053779602,
-0.9865260720252991,
-0.4554991126060486,
0.09287437796592712,
-0.3685985207557678,
0.032909002155065536,
0.9209755659103394,
0.7468767166137695,
-1.2220863103866577,
-0.28049954771995544,
0.09082301706075668,
0.35698094964027405,
-0.6208154559135437,
-0.3303879201412201,
0.21553988754749298,
-0.5018782615661621,
-0.789644181728363,
0.29540133476257324,
0.016332292929291725,
-0.3345794081687927,
-0.11985447257757187,
0.38408422470092773,
0.310585081577301,
0.2571428716182709,
0.49686768651008606,
0.37874534726142883,
-0.698747456073761,
-0.7447392344474792,
-0.27311891317367554,
0.1214994415640831,
0.1663951724767685,
0.9306448698043823,
-0.5051242113113403,
0.7554032802581787,
0.5904144048690796,
0.45035964250564575,
0.23596736788749695,
-0.03494421765208244,
0.3099067509174347,
-0.7300100326538086,
0.4741896688938141,
0.16899289190769196,
0.3858662545681,
0.11193139106035233,
-0.26510050892829895,
0.5339559316635132,
0.499634712934494,
-0.3100492060184479,
-0.4089675545692444,
0.2976985275745392,
-1.229621410369873,
-0.22039806842803955,
1.079842448234558,
-0.5977699756622314,
-0.003161064349114895,
-0.7461473345756531,
-0.23086631298065186,
-0.15008601546287537,
-0.09624892473220825,
0.7596734166145325,
0.7397561073303223,
-0.34547796845436096,
-0.22946268320083618,
-0.475873738527298,
0.4473738372325897,
0.21062307059764862,
-0.6969967484474182,
-0.02408272959291935,
0.375392884016037,
0.43891066312789917,
0.2582363188266754,
0.2853512763977051,
-0.18391208350658417,
0.11941596865653992,
0.23317979276180267,
-0.08491875976324081,
0.22241979837417603,
-0.35248079895973206,
-0.5763750076293945,
0.09869588166475296,
0.49701762199401855,
0.10187259316444397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17897v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17897v2
|
A Language Model based Framework for New Concept Placement in Ontologies
| 2024-02-27T21:27:35 | 2024-03-04T14:06:42 |
Hang Dong, Jiaoyan Chen, Yuan He, Yongsheng Gao, Ian Horrocks
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2.7; I.2.4
|
We investigate the task of inserting new concepts extracted from texts into
an ontology using language models. We explore an approach with three steps:
edge search which is to find a set of candidate locations to insert (i.e.,
subsumptions between concepts), edge formation and enrichment which leverages
the ontological structure to produce and enhance the edge candidates, and edge
selection which eventually locates the edge to be placed into. In all steps, we
propose to leverage neural methods, where we apply embedding-based methods and
contrastive learning with Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) such as BERT for
edge search, and adapt a BERT fine-tuning-based multi-label Edge-Cross-encoder,
and Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT series, FLAN-T5, and Llama 2, for
edge selection. We evaluate the methods on recent datasets created using the
SNOMED CT ontology and the MedMentions entity linking benchmark. The best
settings in our framework use fine-tuned PLM for search and a multi-label
Cross-encoder for selection. Zero-shot prompting of LLMs is still not adequate
for the task, and we propose explainable instruction tuning of LLMs for
improved performance. Our study shows the advantages of PLMs and highlights the
encouraging performance of LLMs that motivates future studies.
|
[
-0.42164185643196106,
-0.8823781609535217,
0.7288405895233154,
-0.28153613209724426,
0.0028270245529711246,
0.04741023853421211,
-0.06232787296175957,
-0.33888670802116394,
0.13384464383125305,
0.8573314547538757,
-0.502776563167572,
-0.7922679781913757,
-0.47078490257263184,
-0.04712036997079849,
-0.3586452603340149,
0.8614475727081299,
0.09556348621845245,
0.012845726683735847,
-0.0770854726433754,
0.08465565741062164,
-0.264769583940506,
-0.3477284610271454,
-0.6354176998138428,
-0.583171546459198,
0.32542097568511963,
0.311200886964798,
0.7499253749847412,
1.0399935245513916,
0.6551442742347717,
0.2668835520744324,
-0.4780605137348175,
0.19964268803596497,
-0.25281083583831787,
0.006524316500872374,
-0.4905099868774414,
-0.46600037813186646,
-0.44231486320495605,
-0.040391068905591965,
0.5685523748397827,
0.6631805300712585,
-0.13995234668254852,
-0.2708510756492615,
-0.22207005321979523,
0.15521502494812012,
-0.47224584221839905,
-0.12950344383716583,
-0.8122613430023193,
0.11847442388534546,
-0.17507560551166534,
-0.18612869083881378,
-0.20254164934158325,
-0.3892788290977478,
0.7008503079414368,
-0.7234949469566345,
0.09511787444353104,
-0.19231106340885162,
0.8983787298202515,
0.08928114175796509,
-0.2742593288421631,
-0.6772738695144653,
-0.29013651609420776,
0.8449772000312805,
-0.741085946559906,
0.4895559549331665,
0.07147234678268433,
0.06607446819543839,
-0.11453292518854141,
-0.9487278461456299,
-0.6238086223602295,
-0.12551207840442657,
0.20417755842208862,
-0.0744747743010521,
0.21051251888275146,
0.17475344240665436,
-0.13116106390953064,
0.2576688826084137,
-0.24376581609249115,
0.5510225892066956,
0.0940946415066719,
-0.049323949962854385,
0.5237293243408203,
0.11642832309007645,
0.42874497175216675,
-0.24195744097232819,
-0.4408092200756073,
-0.23627208173274994,
-0.8917192816734314,
-0.29039332270622253,
0.23050527274608612,
0.7347974181175232,
0.08630625903606415,
0.530985951423645,
-0.0969613641500473,
0.6975067257881165,
-0.13478662073612213,
-0.3984878659248352,
0.2812672257423401,
-0.5347039699554443,
0.13223066926002502,
0.07064522802829742,
0.41723495721817017,
0.36588403582572937,
0.08417720347642899,
-0.11073598265647888,
-0.3439100384712219,
0.17946600914001465,
0.11397408694028854,
-0.5379234552383423,
-0.18629030883312225,
0.15288978815078735,
-0.4382365942001343,
-0.45098963379859924,
-0.27741706371307373,
-0.39720556139945984,
-0.4041133224964142,
-0.20375317335128784,
0.47613638639450073,
-0.7649475932121277,
-0.3676685094833374,
0.14279651641845703,
-0.24949398636817932,
0.2539163827896118,
0.2882479429244995,
-0.8773767352104187,
0.4071945548057556,
0.8109649419784546,
0.6829564571380615,
-0.12773673236370087,
-0.14425018429756165,
-0.09814581274986267,
0.23947186768054962,
-0.3718295097351074,
1.0586903095245361,
-0.8138294816017151,
-0.3587593734264374,
0.4109000861644745,
-0.2727137804031372,
0.13532043993473053,
-0.3603213131427765,
0.5738320350646973,
-0.675723671913147,
0.16553346812725067,
-0.26496613025665283,
-0.8935078978538513,
-0.3042627274990082,
0.3562001585960388,
-0.4197320342063904,
1.0375115871429443,
0.06600986421108246,
-0.7082116603851318,
0.1377418488264084,
-1.0572209358215332,
-0.380339652299881,
0.08573015034198761,
-0.296487957239151,
-0.05976749584078789,
-0.06197762116789818,
-0.06239404156804085,
0.42828133702278137,
-0.3744943141937256,
-0.07733103632926941,
-0.017063982784748077,
-0.14698275923728943,
0.3356829881668091,
0.039926134049892426,
0.7734547853469849,
0.34473371505737305,
-0.03681883215904236,
-0.06672132760286331,
-0.534487247467041,
0.24399103224277496,
0.09442973881959915,
-0.14113149046897888,
-0.5661874413490295,
0.12092951685190201,
-0.003026955993846059,
0.38726261258125305,
0.31343895196914673,
-0.6850282549858093,
0.3631220757961273,
-0.6065444350242615,
0.570299506187439,
0.5238232612609863,
-0.13017906248569489,
0.5673326849937439,
-0.17029894888401031,
0.3126896917819977,
-0.022717365995049477,
0.04036194458603859,
-0.2572675049304962,
-0.27175089716911316,
-0.6867760419845581,
0.17132370173931122,
0.561332643032074,
0.6195924878120422,
-0.8529455065727234,
0.5845469832420349,
-0.33575350046157837,
-0.23973555862903595,
-0.5327332019805908,
0.26153844594955444,
0.4092477858066559,
0.5419577956199646,
0.37340790033340454,
-0.27622100710868835,
-0.32222044467926025,
-0.6579881906509399,
0.37820965051651,
0.09045585989952087,
0.10473031550645828,
0.18108929693698883,
0.28900930285453796,
-0.38975989818573,
1.1402156352996826,
-0.8553038239479065,
-0.5003613233566284,
-0.24062596261501312,
0.047718510031700134,
-0.012445544824004173,
0.4037727415561676,
0.19214773178100586,
-1.0478242635726929,
-0.20264966785907745,
0.1159868910908699,
-0.6785913109779358,
-0.11811472475528717,
0.3009646236896515,
-0.03506152331829071,
0.12690337002277374,
0.62689608335495,
-0.4337027072906494,
0.205022394657135,
0.48045048117637634,
-0.0370652973651886,
0.23420779407024384,
-0.235158309340477,
-0.3085848093032837,
-1.4759087562561035,
-0.21825610101222992,
-0.03129768744111061,
0.1451708972454071,
-0.6867572069168091,
0.2539600729942322,
-0.15080809593200684,
0.019316300749778748,
-0.6793823838233948,
0.6350780129432678,
-0.3981104791164398,
-0.10538601875305176,
-0.4689598083496094,
0.8082476854324341,
0.19023343920707703,
0.09989974647760391,
0.38578733801841736,
0.25550606846809387,
0.578734815120697,
-0.8982272148132324,
0.199720099568367,
0.8360224366188049,
-0.39376184344291687,
0.4749547839164734,
-0.4362264573574066,
0.036869388073682785,
0.06914142519235611,
0.19985082745552063,
-0.7856062650680542,
0.28209614753723145,
0.06346756964921951,
-0.3191261887550354,
0.1803482472896576,
-0.1825741082429886,
-0.4767661392688751,
-0.09774602949619293,
-0.14989015460014343,
0.17005106806755066,
0.4475756287574768,
-0.5223086476325989,
0.4593431055545807,
0.6615853905677795,
-0.41766226291656494,
-0.5364174246788025,
-0.7564904689788818,
0.020594069734215736,
0.08323079347610474,
-0.7323082089424133,
0.922389805316925,
0.20607921481132507,
-0.2364496886730194,
0.31706422567367554,
0.14315545558929443,
-0.04343447834253311,
0.13832497596740723,
-0.04607580602169037,
0.09028863161802292,
-0.32612308859825134,
0.6609426736831665,
0.15958981215953827,
-0.2597309648990631,
-0.160262331366539,
-0.6311937570571899,
0.5748122930526733,
0.138137087225914,
-0.18729422986507416,
-0.14135096967220306,
0.3355587422847748,
-0.13399361073970795,
-0.5042914152145386,
0.4933891296386719,
0.3951658308506012,
-0.4048635959625244,
-0.3150699734687805,
-0.6123613715171814,
-0.3570849895477295,
-0.4684096872806549,
0.5090171098709106,
-0.49021056294441223,
-0.9537291526794434,
0.40731504559516907,
-0.3979531228542328,
0.27511948347091675,
0.37032005190849304,
0.3284425735473633,
-0.17215490341186523,
1.0540353059768677,
0.9756596684455872,
0.446841835975647,
0.5911972522735596,
-0.5371608734130859,
0.3185337781906128,
-0.9391419291496277,
-0.15860161185264587,
-0.4629453420639038,
-0.04751453921198845,
-0.9461196064949036,
-0.6240599155426025,
0.1630876660346985,
0.1076062023639679,
0.1368485987186432,
0.08986347913742065,
-0.483977347612381,
0.25284966826438904,
0.39444059133529663,
-0.11565949767827988,
0.3801285922527313,
-0.02769876830279827,
-0.5145640969276428,
0.11596529930830002,
-0.8942373394966125,
-0.708385705947876,
1.0807054042816162,
0.39162641763687134,
0.8273459076881409,
0.06515072286128998,
0.7437799572944641,
-0.10683896392583847,
0.2714097201824188,
-0.5803308486938477,
0.6015123724937439,
-0.6314132213592529,
-0.5520938038825989,
-0.6900597810745239,
-0.1828380972146988,
-0.9300746917724609,
0.054534733295440674,
-0.43803292512893677,
-0.767299473285675,
0.04051833972334862,
-0.011410211212933064,
-0.5366246104240417,
0.39570242166519165,
-0.32088702917099,
0.6055171489715576,
-0.3797050714492798,
-0.20006178319454193,
-0.19088634848594666,
-0.7393582463264465,
-0.005059551913291216,
0.03496653959155083,
0.0693657174706459,
-0.26344677805900574,
-0.21091490983963013,
0.5201286673545837,
-0.38429030776023865,
0.6533468961715698,
-0.03290931135416031,
-0.5289580821990967,
0.3491685390472412,
-0.17859748005867004,
0.41128942370414734,
-0.15617415308952332,
-0.38861191272735596,
0.05375991016626358,
-0.12022370845079422,
-0.12849530577659607,
-0.7463751435279846,
0.7982986569404602,
-0.6334303617477417,
-0.6532307267189026,
-0.058134034276008606,
-0.5658139586448669,
-0.09835661202669144,
0.13174575567245483,
0.388962060213089,
0.40616047382354736,
-0.18582652509212494,
0.002118511125445366,
1.0183497667312622,
-0.36696329712867737,
0.3869534432888031,
0.5769065618515015,
-0.3898148238658905,
-0.17442023754119873,
1.0429085493087769,
0.48045897483825684,
0.2983255684375763,
0.7729683518409729,
0.3304346203804016,
-0.6733980774879456,
-0.6867080330848694,
-0.18188446760177612,
0.09103097766637802,
-0.8197824954986572,
-0.16367031633853912,
-1.0074951648712158,
-0.5227991342544556,
-0.6747373342514038,
-0.2725328505039215,
-0.5202068090438843,
-0.37745019793510437,
-0.025582384318113327,
-0.1589951068162918,
0.5451456904411316,
0.7047035694122314,
-0.052865710109472275,
0.6467222571372986,
-0.8309747576713562,
-0.05771153047680855,
0.1835087388753891,
0.42832106351852417,
-0.06990903615951538,
-0.5190512537956238,
-0.3116969168186188,
0.017613966017961502,
-0.4025038778781891,
-0.46811267733573914,
0.19862721860408783,
0.07391265779733658,
0.7346617579460144,
0.5264975428581238,
-0.03551192954182625,
0.26904532313346863,
-0.44105204939842224,
0.47344839572906494,
0.11203103512525558,
-0.9952359795570374,
0.7537599205970764,
-0.33932244777679443,
0.15482759475708008,
0.506377637386322,
0.5321733355522156,
-0.6451290845870972,
-0.1280795782804489,
-0.6358910202980042,
-0.6863811016082764,
0.45898935198783875,
0.03779991343617439,
0.30413153767585754,
-0.05100689455866814,
0.47595688700675964,
0.1662183552980423,
0.14347371459007263,
-0.7508838176727295,
-0.21569058299064636,
-0.055793292820453644,
-0.25733682513237,
0.11557426303625107,
-0.2291666716337204,
-0.07062380760908127,
0.14970368146896362,
0.6151605248451233,
-0.32173559069633484,
0.14725792407989502,
0.08350051939487457,
-0.14643338322639465,
0.2384696751832962,
0.1351500302553177,
0.3433741629123688,
0.6948011517524719,
-0.08775938302278519,
0.09531433135271072,
0.2539407014846802,
-0.05099093168973923,
0.16948910057544708,
0.28632235527038574,
-0.36764776706695557,
-0.0003763860440813005,
0.23209154605865479,
0.7141281366348267,
0.2463843822479248,
-0.6140121221542358,
0.38181811571121216,
0.22286835312843323,
-0.17569398880004883,
-0.22171750664710999,
0.04448717460036278,
0.24208274483680725,
0.21197931468486786,
0.15067532658576965,
-0.46834248304367065,
0.17537131905555725,
-0.4920822083950043,
0.31651070713996887,
0.37895750999450684,
-0.4043421745300293,
-0.19825784862041473,
0.1939462125301361,
0.4531576633453369,
-0.44426238536834717,
0.7141085267066956,
-0.36188048124313354,
-0.6748498678207397,
0.32916128635406494,
0.5485684275627136,
0.5983565449714661,
-0.5402081608772278,
0.4635217785835266,
-0.028607018291950226,
0.11453821510076523,
-0.10899903625249863,
0.48562759160995483,
0.28936585783958435,
-1.4074058532714844,
-0.4859757125377655,
-0.5584514737129211,
-0.43793782591819763,
-0.031861793249845505,
-0.34087666869163513,
0.4703507125377655,
-0.3125498592853546,
-0.3702647387981415,
0.03285370394587517,
0.15376663208007812,
-0.5671230554580688,
0.40737229585647583,
0.29050546884536743,
1.0259615182876587,
-0.9104112982749939,
0.8994696140289307,
0.8199759125709534,
-0.4821920692920685,
-0.5775771737098694,
-0.016833648085594177,
-0.12488166987895966,
-0.6220045685768127,
0.6913797855377197,
-0.006466403137892485,
-0.10024365037679672,
0.2064255326986313,
-0.28092828392982483,
-1.1908754110336304,
0.9948962330818176,
0.1090380996465683,
-0.24524874985218048,
-0.31311529874801636,
0.11629480868577957,
0.6531380414962769,
-0.7634507417678833,
0.30156853795051575,
0.39407289028167725,
0.3324766755104065,
0.1923423409461975,
-0.4227060377597809,
-0.055406928062438965,
-0.04882356524467468,
0.39677074551582336,
0.25094103813171387,
-0.564117431640625,
1.1151511669158936,
-0.22988052666187286,
-0.09288542717695236,
0.15873999893665314,
0.46107396483421326,
0.26982492208480835,
0.0025086975656449795,
0.5054874420166016,
0.8290952444076538,
0.6335905194282532,
-0.004589438438415527,
0.930940568447113,
-0.4153911769390106,
0.048574917018413544,
1.1165357828140259,
-0.619123637676239,
0.9806771874427795,
0.4026011526584625,
0.09786460548639297,
0.7947334051132202,
0.7604079842567444,
0.03429071232676506,
0.7543578147888184,
0.4836357533931732,
-0.11803390830755234,
-0.15440988540649414,
-0.7774487137794495,
-0.4536983370780945,
0.6805829405784607,
0.7482808232307434,
-0.4405275881290436,
-0.17172661423683167,
0.14605717360973358,
-0.13817864656448364,
0.16480813920497894,
-0.1483745276927948,
0.8646882176399231,
0.2263297587633133,
-0.5178530812263489,
0.1404161900281906,
0.25671955943107605,
0.6489740014076233,
-0.6965977549552917,
-0.21947814524173737,
-0.15119174122810364,
0.09012337774038315,
-0.1774909645318985,
-0.7334982752799988,
0.01846746727824211,
-0.40964773297309875,
-0.09039746969938278,
-0.2527986168861389,
0.7812085747718811,
-0.4634413719177246,
-0.5709524750709534,
0.6510356068611145,
0.656364917755127,
0.051572974771261215,
0.3455730080604553,
-0.6609549522399902,
0.02599543146789074,
-0.22531920671463013,
-0.07930681854486465,
0.21838465332984924,
0.6372203826904297,
-0.20475877821445465,
0.7380626201629639,
0.6979004144668579,
0.10141948610544205,
-0.184414803981781,
0.20377469062805176,
0.8461127877235413,
-0.7514387369155884,
-0.788320004940033,
-0.5751082301139832,
0.3204113841056824,
-0.10420374572277069,
-0.5266245603561401,
0.4609064757823944,
0.3721114695072174,
0.9395615458488464,
0.41434192657470703,
0.8716447949409485,
0.030663147568702698,
0.6071484088897705,
-0.8191980719566345,
0.49702131748199463,
-0.525780439376831,
0.3785209059715271,
-0.42101940512657166,
-0.9598144292831421,
-0.12471926212310791,
0.5989943146705627,
-0.2985796630382538,
-0.003826512023806572,
0.6551922559738159,
1.0328137874603271,
0.17229513823986053,
0.043207671493291855,
0.28384220600128174,
0.04578543081879616,
0.07518824934959412,
0.2835013270378113,
0.9122442603111267,
-0.3422309458255768,
0.5592281818389893,
-0.13957548141479492,
-0.1522379219532013,
-0.3264910876750946,
-0.8986280560493469,
-0.5427902340888977,
-0.49845656752586365,
-0.424742728471756,
-0.07794984430074692,
0.21552126109600067,
1.04583740234375,
0.792453408241272,
-0.7544214129447937,
-0.3995441198348999,
-0.04604239761829376,
0.391930490732193,
-0.12236671149730682,
-0.1619003266096115,
0.31817004084587097,
-0.44046667218208313,
-0.7577436566352844,
0.39869990944862366,
0.2823966145515442,
0.19816778600215912,
-0.38881415128707886,
-0.10589834302663803,
-0.6741396188735962,
-0.04084177315235138,
0.5965282320976257,
-0.09797168523073196,
-0.8208935260772705,
-0.3277474641799927,
0.06226874142885208,
-0.26646316051483154,
0.10509850829839706,
0.6627138257026672,
-0.5223889946937561,
0.3354521691799164,
0.49451944231987,
0.9426272511482239,
0.2626553475856781,
-0.15700624883174896,
0.8280554413795471,
-0.7116572260856628,
-0.019388895481824875,
0.21755863726139069,
0.1689477562904358,
0.49230632185935974,
-0.09365705400705338,
0.6969999670982361,
-0.012916715815663338,
-0.09049200266599655,
-0.7728845477104187,
0.25316211581230164,
-0.4729992747306824,
-0.5547416806221008,
1.0449942350387573,
-0.1055595874786377,
0.04157533869147301,
-0.2439539134502411,
0.03786604106426239,
0.3730473220348358,
-0.09655369073152542,
0.5915994048118591,
0.5859016180038452,
-0.3373206555843353,
-0.04568387195467949,
-0.2395561784505844,
0.5525947213172913,
0.5424659252166748,
-0.684583306312561,
-0.2874460220336914,
0.08226161450147629,
0.24552324414253235,
0.7188746929168701,
0.452729195356369,
-0.09979413449764252,
0.014012759551405907,
0.055277708917856216,
0.6434950232505798,
0.08205052465200424,
-0.14923754334449768,
-0.24631719291210175,
0.06947600096464157,
0.042925529181957245,
-0.14002403616905212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17896v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17896v1
|
Researchy Questions: A Dataset of Multi-Perspective, Decompositional Questions for LLM Web Agents
| 2024-02-27T21:27:16 | 2024-02-27T21:27:16 |
Corby Rosset, Ho-Lam Chung, Guanghui Qin, Ethan C. Chau, Zhuo Feng, Ahmed Awadallah, Jennifer Neville, Nikhil Rao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Existing question answering (QA) datasets are no longer challenging to most
powerful Large Language Models (LLMs). Traditional QA benchmarks like TriviaQA,
NaturalQuestions, ELI5 and HotpotQA mainly study ``known unknowns'' with clear
indications of both what information is missing, and how to find it to answer
the question. Hence, good performance on these benchmarks provides a false
sense of security. A yet unmet need of the NLP community is a bank of
non-factoid, multi-perspective questions involving a great deal of unclear
information needs, i.e. ``unknown uknowns''. We claim we can find such
questions in search engine logs, which is surprising because most
question-intent queries are indeed factoid. We present Researchy Questions, a
dataset of search engine queries tediously filtered to be non-factoid,
``decompositional'' and multi-perspective. We show that users spend a lot of
``effort'' on these questions in terms of signals like clicks and session
length, and that they are also challenging for GPT-4. We also show that ``slow
thinking'' answering techniques, like decomposition into sub-questions shows
benefit over answering directly. We release $\sim$ 100k Researchy Questions,
along with the Clueweb22 URLs that were clicked.
|
[
-0.6637935042381287,
-0.8821631073951721,
0.7099366784095764,
-0.07720290869474411,
-0.07044100016355515,
0.091681107878685,
0.08369548618793488,
-0.5728252530097961,
0.37833526730537415,
0.3343997299671173,
-0.8790174126625061,
-0.26042088866233826,
-0.07758232951164246,
0.21730314195156097,
-0.35060128569602966,
0.930152416229248,
0.053796570748090744,
-0.17316417396068573,
-0.3392105996608734,
-0.1233230009675026,
0.10786884278059006,
-0.44960400462150574,
-0.7816720008850098,
0.0945228561758995,
0.9722354412078857,
0.06178447604179382,
0.6104981899261475,
0.5676842927932739,
0.6733028292655945,
0.24455063045024872,
-0.08555679768323898,
0.22508782148361206,
-0.5107748508453369,
0.2613874673843384,
-0.2292427271604538,
-0.744212806224823,
-0.13966502249240875,
0.2748759090900421,
0.19347409904003143,
0.7836385369300842,
-0.19491419196128845,
0.3148340582847595,
-0.13252845406532288,
0.5423948764801025,
-0.7592852711677551,
0.0007122937822714448,
-0.595714271068573,
-0.06683851033449173,
-0.00860906857997179,
-0.30775371193885803,
-0.11859363317489624,
-0.5098440647125244,
0.34137162566185,
-0.7284656763076782,
0.5506316423416138,
0.07846822589635849,
0.8186866641044617,
0.2831943929195404,
-0.49926379323005676,
-0.4100249409675598,
-0.7105213403701782,
0.7882792353630066,
-0.5378353595733643,
0.24321898818016052,
0.4302295744419098,
0.17942850291728973,
-0.2501111328601837,
-0.5673704743385315,
-0.35329508781433105,
0.09656360000371933,
-0.08077727258205414,
0.09695974737405777,
-0.2317970097064972,
-0.05467939376831055,
0.18740931153297424,
0.3571951687335968,
-0.8233634829521179,
-0.17180387675762177,
-0.24680718779563904,
-0.23115479946136475,
0.6180475354194641,
0.2331971675157547,
0.3836948573589325,
-0.044667404145002365,
-0.24796150624752045,
-0.1728925108909607,
-0.5287192463874817,
0.06772609800100327,
0.4101925194263458,
-0.008885516785085201,
0.2529691159725189,
0.4757494032382965,
-0.21577195823192596,
0.5960337519645691,
-0.043706152588129044,
-0.21636836230754852,
0.13022363185882568,
-0.626591145992279,
0.05667053908109665,
-0.4807918071746826,
0.502210259437561,
0.3073740303516388,
0.05135369300842285,
-0.43773460388183594,
-0.042039673775434494,
-0.0781746581196785,
0.4379546344280243,
-0.6504549980163574,
-0.21603985130786896,
0.6723049283027649,
-0.2656109929084778,
-0.03711400181055069,
-0.11569872498512268,
-0.5511427521705627,
-0.2456924021244049,
-0.023882241919636726,
0.34055742621421814,
-0.3233564496040344,
-0.5190802812576294,
0.06157999858260155,
-0.5188159346580505,
0.7757741212844849,
0.4258267879486084,
-0.6284670233726501,
0.2195902317762375,
0.5605009198188782,
0.506131112575531,
-0.22400951385498047,
-0.24053099751472473,
-0.10536836087703705,
-0.01996559649705887,
-0.45681115984916687,
0.8090519905090332,
-0.44590288400650024,
-0.17661358416080475,
0.12436718493700027,
0.07355084270238876,
-0.32143399119377136,
-0.6193017363548279,
0.40732043981552124,
-1.0433722734451294,
0.5427286624908447,
-0.525981605052948,
-0.44465672969818115,
-0.1640165001153946,
0.7478957772254944,
-0.785575270652771,
0.8837075233459473,
-0.09703045338392258,
-0.9835596680641174,
0.10823678225278854,
-0.6491303443908691,
-0.12302222102880478,
0.011207075789570808,
-0.047017455101013184,
0.16589613258838654,
0.061706945300102234,
0.33263450860977173,
0.2959408760070801,
-0.3466449975967407,
0.12753891944885254,
-0.4056343734264374,
0.03473413735628128,
0.6106318235397339,
-0.4366532564163208,
0.6306055188179016,
0.26665744185447693,
-0.1250206083059311,
-0.24605031311511993,
-0.8871105909347534,
0.3882753849029541,
0.1925548017024994,
-0.34602615237236023,
-0.5574179887771606,
-0.23288001120090485,
-0.15159349143505096,
0.15460333228111267,
0.4124022126197815,
-0.490579217672348,
0.07232342660427094,
-0.45864322781562805,
0.3334508538246155,
0.5602505207061768,
0.2688840329647064,
0.17801257967948914,
-0.33632558584213257,
0.8933594822883606,
-0.12019960582256317,
0.3310815393924713,
0.19942550361156464,
-0.5511835217475891,
-0.7598642110824585,
0.05502841994166374,
0.1369718611240387,
0.389676034450531,
-0.8386602997779846,
-0.2551215887069702,
0.08391023427248001,
-0.4283595383167267,
-0.7404510974884033,
-0.02604271098971367,
0.3063373863697052,
0.4449112117290497,
0.33750560879707336,
0.07801160961389542,
-0.19564507901668549,
-1.1494816541671753,
-0.46499553322792053,
-0.12314125895500183,
-0.2834785282611847,
0.40561237931251526,
0.4635697603225708,
0.1391860395669937,
0.685846209526062,
-0.5848963260650635,
0.12639494240283966,
-0.059502679854631424,
0.17021889984607697,
0.15088891983032227,
-0.02409636229276657,
0.16830426454544067,
-1.1562684774398804,
-0.23806385695934296,
-0.4275538921356201,
-0.7857380509376526,
0.169916570186615,
0.12497424334287643,
-0.08771472424268723,
-0.1453419029712677,
0.29944100975990295,
-1.0425459146499634,
0.1665068119764328,
0.3904059827327728,
-0.06031769514083862,
0.42246198654174805,
-0.13824151456356049,
0.047026026993989944,
-0.9284190535545349,
0.17540857195854187,
-0.03071437031030655,
-0.005113800521939993,
-0.7329737544059753,
0.4336791932582855,
-0.009201710112392902,
-0.03959427773952484,
-0.5760108232498169,
0.4136243462562561,
-0.5857506394386292,
-0.06602112203836441,
-0.20853163301944733,
0.3602474629878998,
0.09799762815237045,
0.5277143716812134,
-0.12176261097192764,
0.9592273235321045,
0.48671698570251465,
-0.7662515640258789,
0.2229902297258377,
0.1483280211687088,
0.014088652096688747,
0.22012068331241608,
-0.46256154775619507,
0.5072711110115051,
-0.20465542376041412,
0.10049106180667877,
-1.089511752128601,
-0.30054420232772827,
0.15182580053806305,
-0.5040058493614197,
-0.07397894561290741,
-0.18781882524490356,
-0.4012453556060791,
-0.24753324687480927,
-0.6357396245002747,
0.6135934591293335,
0.2298659235239029,
-0.42206043004989624,
0.6245196461677551,
0.5412943363189697,
-0.11274966597557068,
-0.9809538722038269,
-0.40712544322013855,
0.07252492755651474,
-0.2928577661514282,
-0.6590742468833923,
0.13092337548732758,
-0.25002700090408325,
-0.4690345525741577,
0.3712526857852936,
-0.1613067239522934,
-0.21451781690120697,
0.16001594066619873,
0.04672965779900551,
0.19376613199710846,
-0.1794721782207489,
0.006238746922463179,
-0.4434816539287567,
-0.01616596058011055,
0.4839423894882202,
-0.16767266392707825,
0.5250859260559082,
0.01942375861108303,
-0.2502809762954712,
-0.14382174611091614,
0.3839481770992279,
0.2933388948440552,
-0.221002459526062,
0.4069240093231201,
0.6014562249183655,
-0.27365079522132874,
-0.3019137382507324,
-0.7137550115585327,
-0.14391925930976868,
-0.4196774959564209,
0.023637477308511734,
-0.42892029881477356,
-1.129722237586975,
0.6737409830093384,
-0.045818526297807693,
0.18131715059280396,
0.5324366092681885,
0.5323309898376465,
-0.3008463680744171,
0.939498245716095,
0.441114604473114,
0.036263223737478256,
0.02014726586639881,
-0.32090070843696594,
0.20043621957302094,
-0.6673780083656311,
-0.3678117096424103,
-0.6048486828804016,
-0.24488089978694916,
-0.8366760611534119,
-0.6278990507125854,
0.43872687220573425,
-0.2085506170988083,
0.3008361756801605,
-0.07852496206760406,
-0.3286568820476532,
0.4821546673774719,
0.8356521129608154,
0.06565168499946594,
0.17406423389911652,
-0.30653125047683716,
0.2065868079662323,
0.1514711230993271,
-0.573784589767456,
-0.3668668866157532,
1.400124192237854,
0.08389051258563995,
0.9322826862335205,
0.15458622574806213,
0.744199275970459,
0.10424242913722992,
-0.17321796715259552,
-0.7409265637397766,
0.5786054730415344,
0.4600837528705597,
-1.1289162635803223,
-0.4699598252773285,
-0.445214182138443,
-1.1739068031311035,
0.4742736220359802,
0.1860365867614746,
-0.6505561470985413,
0.21141164004802704,
0.03358519822359085,
-0.4456888437271118,
0.23217549920082092,
-0.6270244717597961,
0.4915233552455902,
-0.13762791454792023,
-0.5656203627586365,
-0.23201696574687958,
-0.7836942076683044,
0.3827667832374573,
0.18622498214244843,
0.2072131633758545,
-0.19328923523426056,
-0.1510525494813919,
0.9822980165481567,
-0.3849107623100281,
0.6163925528526306,
-0.2916375994682312,
-0.07060936093330383,
0.5346624255180359,
0.01290587056428194,
0.4461904466152191,
0.2541294991970062,
0.2827267348766327,
-0.2054605484008789,
0.31899359822273254,
-0.5244101285934448,
-0.6221136450767517,
0.6449690461158752,
-0.8152984976768494,
-0.8902689218521118,
-0.5801234841346741,
-0.5700070261955261,
-0.543775737285614,
0.03347148001194,
-0.08739880472421646,
0.16736607253551483,
-0.19025903940200806,
0.06507762521505356,
1.1956957578659058,
-0.17320206761360168,
0.3658250570297241,
0.5069639682769775,
-0.14573907852172852,
-0.14348608255386353,
0.5991625189781189,
-0.03688311576843262,
0.024910682812333107,
0.5802360773086548,
0.09063897281885147,
-0.55074143409729,
-0.7248952388763428,
-0.3285973370075226,
0.4669341444969177,
-0.5988740921020508,
-0.004609364550560713,
-0.8577703833580017,
-0.16773878037929535,
-0.36458131670951843,
0.2787112891674042,
-0.3228231370449066,
-0.5262147784233093,
-0.21388322114944458,
-0.27781325578689575,
0.1277269721031189,
0.6831310391426086,
-0.15369801223278046,
-0.17834043502807617,
-0.3717156946659088,
0.8443989157676697,
0.714322030544281,
0.10491921007633209,
-0.1504007875919342,
-0.23836275935173035,
-0.09775621443986893,
-0.23334580659866333,
-0.06205298379063606,
-0.8470902442932129,
0.21139143407344818,
-0.13196292519569397,
0.5778080224990845,
0.284803569316864,
0.27602696418762207,
0.5154366493225098,
-0.2095918506383896,
0.6446273922920227,
-0.15306662023067474,
-0.2649455964565277,
0.4531647562980652,
-0.42887091636657715,
0.09623336046934128,
0.8208311200141907,
0.9511275291442871,
-0.4167231321334839,
-0.4067431092262268,
-0.6118674874305725,
-0.8970690965652466,
0.83311527967453,
0.13037815690040588,
0.10885835438966751,
0.19429922103881836,
0.4731542766094208,
0.18770931661128998,
0.265489399433136,
-0.6407107710838318,
-0.5406153202056885,
-0.07552118599414825,
0.23202712833881378,
0.15582944452762604,
-0.49817439913749695,
-0.49277567863464355,
-0.06849846988916397,
0.5333390831947327,
-0.18970099091529846,
0.277506023645401,
0.22584117949008942,
-0.07347643375396729,
0.007992960512638092,
0.5354535579681396,
0.14347463846206665,
1.0718380212783813,
-0.701647162437439,
0.2653111517429352,
-0.13557696342468262,
-0.36337578296661377,
0.28033584356307983,
0.14705023169517517,
-0.28000378608703613,
-0.19693981111049652,
0.24726594984531403,
0.3458655774593353,
-0.15668796002864838,
-0.6278817653656006,
0.4976924955844879,
-0.5348036289215088,
-0.4699787497520447,
-0.5286924839019775,
0.15267926454544067,
0.4603062868118286,
0.2377900332212448,
0.6280711889266968,
-0.3024007976055145,
0.35568302869796753,
-0.714556097984314,
0.05205680802464485,
0.5733503699302673,
-0.22905582189559937,
-0.42545849084854126,
0.5755760669708252,
0.0505361407995224,
-0.27546608448028564,
0.5464356541633606,
-0.2495371401309967,
-0.29850926995277405,
0.4692642390727997,
0.3388259708881378,
0.747519850730896,
0.03240911662578583,
0.5788030624389648,
0.15518303215503693,
0.4796777665615082,
0.1881047785282135,
0.7672609090805054,
0.10823676735162735,
-0.7546504735946655,
-0.2796383500099182,
-0.5073962211608887,
-0.7337250113487244,
0.700907826423645,
-0.7441048622131348,
-0.22786162793636322,
-0.5479873418807983,
-0.06232175976037979,
0.22140301764011383,
0.14521990716457367,
-0.9370718598365784,
0.3528699576854706,
-0.04840634763240814,
0.8083909153938293,
-0.5555906295776367,
0.6238093376159668,
0.7445385456085205,
-0.5678806304931641,
-0.8129493594169617,
0.11361497640609741,
-0.09616635739803314,
-0.9230318665504456,
0.4156796932220459,
0.11351828277111053,
-0.12382010370492935,
-0.06269707530736923,
-0.7625577449798584,
-1.0467276573181152,
0.9203799366950989,
0.21136899292469025,
-0.23500694334506989,
-0.4452059864997864,
0.34446388483047485,
0.6506707072257996,
0.015431457199156284,
0.5041260123252869,
0.3534996807575226,
0.5689648985862732,
-0.0181867778301239,
-0.5903989672660828,
0.08246742188930511,
-0.40396779775619507,
-0.3991740345954895,
0.004180150106549263,
-0.8135231137275696,
1.0286424160003662,
-0.06891915202140808,
-0.279867947101593,
-0.29711148142814636,
0.272698312997818,
0.05923555791378021,
0.5832847952842712,
0.4358076751232147,
0.5373270511627197,
0.7951382994651794,
0.06635811179876328,
1.0032744407653809,
-0.27632611989974976,
0.13464514911174774,
0.8625388145446777,
-0.1379617601633072,
0.6511701345443726,
0.7146235108375549,
-0.454653799533844,
0.351142019033432,
0.7792876958847046,
0.23447798192501068,
0.5227976441383362,
0.27745288610458374,
-0.1022190973162651,
-0.39577072858810425,
-0.21067281067371368,
-0.33232519030570984,
0.43177029490470886,
0.25991976261138916,
0.05915815010666847,
-0.3215233087539673,
-0.28661400079727173,
0.11845569312572479,
-0.10776731371879578,
0.11376368999481201,
0.9542012810707092,
0.03432512283325195,
-0.6902281641960144,
0.5048370361328125,
0.010637159459292889,
0.5838952660560608,
-0.8630948662757874,
0.15184500813484192,
-0.7305485010147095,
-0.041345156729221344,
-0.08320735394954681,
-0.6216665506362915,
-0.021700190380215645,
-0.17143738269805908,
-0.24210327863693237,
-0.05712013319134712,
0.7647802829742432,
-0.1617235243320465,
-0.24971480667591095,
0.40573686361312866,
1.1663784980773926,
0.4010581374168396,
-0.4126676023006439,
-0.860028862953186,
-0.3669706881046295,
-0.07475514709949493,
-0.5419507622718811,
0.5469526648521423,
0.6237270832061768,
0.022771338000893593,
0.9941686391830444,
0.627899169921875,
0.0003912246902473271,
0.33587977290153503,
-0.042807042598724365,
1.0322723388671875,
-0.821863055229187,
-0.25433817505836487,
-0.5082318782806396,
0.058599360287189484,
-0.02152111381292343,
-0.37838277220726013,
1.0434976816177368,
0.7031891345977783,
0.9740917682647705,
0.17716248333454132,
0.9535903930664062,
-0.061525095254182816,
0.7377008199691772,
-0.5073272585868835,
0.3841637969017029,
-0.7908958196640015,
0.05533383786678314,
0.025002434849739075,
-0.812743604183197,
0.013409765437245369,
0.027429286390542984,
-0.11437752097845078,
-0.05604882538318634,
0.9071739912033081,
0.8569207787513733,
-0.0623774528503418,
0.17552678287029266,
0.3260539174079895,
-0.03133781999349594,
0.36813974380493164,
0.5312626957893372,
1.2828941345214844,
-0.3511022627353668,
0.8697574138641357,
-0.39980748295783997,
0.027231495827436447,
-0.1435737907886505,
-0.36339905858039856,
-0.9010669589042664,
-0.5018054842948914,
-0.2569573223590851,
-0.16746214032173157,
0.0980176106095314,
0.6308659911155701,
0.48930075764656067,
-0.783150315284729,
-0.17699244618415833,
0.2951171398162842,
0.30954262614250183,
-0.1027076467871666,
-0.21748843789100647,
0.4784867465496063,
-0.405565083026886,
-0.5889196991920471,
0.567655086517334,
0.12450709939002991,
-0.2329791933298111,
-0.5798330307006836,
0.28137072920799255,
-0.6326816082000732,
0.10415011644363403,
0.2328120470046997,
0.25006017088890076,
-0.5867885947227478,
-0.17295290529727936,
0.38161441683769226,
0.07500975579023361,
0.1556948870420456,
0.9614894986152649,
-0.582155168056488,
0.21562425792217255,
0.4335172474384308,
0.8650928139686584,
0.7509079575538635,
0.19593007862567902,
0.18626460433006287,
-0.6769933104515076,
-0.12869183719158173,
0.4347456097602844,
0.02207898162305355,
0.21376723051071167,
-0.33115437626838684,
0.677313506603241,
0.3003246784210205,
-0.44159287214279175,
-0.6440380811691284,
0.07994326949119568,
-0.8066242933273315,
-0.518183708190918,
1.1002378463745117,
-0.1504954993724823,
-0.43861672282218933,
-0.41230422258377075,
0.11347585916519165,
-0.08287106454372406,
-0.4311448335647583,
0.8473933339118958,
0.7903608679771423,
-0.5078938007354736,
-0.15339501202106476,
-0.7909822463989258,
0.6733856201171875,
0.4027683734893799,
-0.9197431206703186,
0.10848578065633774,
0.6509000062942505,
0.3991307020187378,
0.3456917703151703,
0.8902969360351562,
-0.06345149874687195,
0.006138897966593504,
0.1354874074459076,
-0.06439091265201569,
0.12419898808002472,
-0.2989788055419922,
-0.012990128248929977,
0.7815897464752197,
0.2607935667037964,
-0.3532394766807556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17887v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17887v4
|
JMLR: Joint Medical LLM and Retrieval Training for Enhancing Reasoning and Professional Question Answering Capability
| 2024-02-27T21:01:41 | 2024-06-28T13:23:31 |
Junda Wang, Zhichao Yang, Zonghai Yao, Hong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated a remarkable potential in
medical knowledge acquisition and question-answering. However, LLMs can
potentially hallucinate and yield factually incorrect outcomes, even with
domain-specific pretraining. Previously, retrieval augmented generation (RAG)
has limited success in addressing hallucinations. Unlike previous methods in
RAG where the retrieval model was trained separately from the LLM, we introduce
JMLR (for Jointly trains LLM and information Retrieval) during the fine-tuning
phase. The synchronized training mechanism enhances JMLR's ability to retrieve
clinical guidelines and leverage medical knowledge to reason and answer
questions and reduces the demand for computational resources. We evaluated JMLR
on the important medical question-answering application. Our experimental
results demonstrate that JMLR-13B (70.5%) outperforms a previous
state-of-the-art open-source model using conventional pre-training and
fine-tuning Meditron-70B (68.9%) and Llama2-13B with RAG (67.7%) on a medical
question-answering dataset. Comprehensive evaluations reveal JMLR-13B enhances
reasoning quality and reduces hallucinations better than Claude3-Opus.
Additionally, JMLR-13B (148 GPU hours) also trains much faster than
Meditron-70B (42630 GPU hours). Through this work, we provide a new and
efficient knowledge enhancement method for healthcare, demonstrating the
potential of integrating retrieval and LLM training for medical
question-answering systems.
|
[
-0.3559751808643341,
-0.9117727875709534,
0.7797756791114807,
-0.1803756058216095,
-0.36242663860321045,
0.14808489382266998,
-0.21787086129188538,
-0.5671244263648987,
0.06066140532493591,
0.690523624420166,
-0.37788715958595276,
-0.28358376026153564,
-0.6737135648727417,
0.1702120304107666,
-0.08204090595245361,
0.9505352973937988,
-0.010487865656614304,
0.7740013003349304,
-0.3867761790752411,
-0.1327110230922699,
-0.5828314423561096,
-0.6199572086334229,
-0.6862631440162659,
-0.46387025713920593,
0.6723310947418213,
-0.006695874966681004,
0.5875715017318726,
0.452072411775589,
0.996621310710907,
0.26046183705329895,
-0.0804702565073967,
0.5809115171432495,
-0.441910982131958,
0.32082492113113403,
-0.11997295171022415,
-0.4406493008136749,
-0.37508752942085266,
-0.4485017657279968,
0.34841302037239075,
0.7349843978881836,
-0.35988450050354004,
0.1387014091014862,
-0.15317662060260773,
0.8278509378433228,
-0.7450417876243591,
-0.07620320469141006,
-0.601418673992157,
0.22157840430736542,
0.04342736676335335,
-0.7760834097862244,
-0.4024968147277832,
-0.4821317493915558,
0.13218535482883453,
-0.6548010110855103,
0.09598308056592941,
0.23193880915641785,
0.7445518970489502,
0.6130937337875366,
-0.1319963037967682,
-0.3489069938659668,
-0.636385977268219,
0.48168906569480896,
-0.45774367451667786,
0.6247382164001465,
0.2849052846431732,
0.5487631559371948,
-0.08658940345048904,
-0.8178441524505615,
-0.653499960899353,
-0.20232300460338593,
-0.2399621307849884,
0.29897192120552063,
0.31927692890167236,
0.19936636090278625,
0.31570059061050415,
0.4193432033061981,
-0.649934709072113,
-0.33554965257644653,
-0.5478450655937195,
-0.005637486930936575,
0.4856215715408325,
0.4866119623184204,
0.2930730879306793,
-0.044018812477588654,
-0.3104649782180786,
0.04531126841902733,
-0.6136269569396973,
-0.2571014165878296,
-0.3433985412120819,
0.09232790768146515,
0.28370070457458496,
0.6215803623199463,
-0.053015824407339096,
0.7903216481208801,
0.1377866268157959,
-0.6147796511650085,
0.19595319032669067,
-0.2849756181240082,
-0.23521549999713898,
0.06962794810533524,
0.45184701681137085,
0.36406564712524414,
0.0330035574734211,
-0.38915205001831055,
-0.19439424574375153,
-0.04514307156205177,
0.5298511981964111,
-0.6835306882858276,
-0.2574600279331207,
0.14815157651901245,
-0.5546695590019226,
-0.018902253359556198,
0.08266649395227432,
-0.5636758804321289,
-0.6754071116447449,
-0.610103964805603,
0.7595040202140808,
-0.41621047258377075,
-0.21300429105758667,
0.39977338910102844,
-0.16422539949417114,
0.4619124233722687,
0.5580873489379883,
-0.5849471688270569,
0.4237763583660126,
0.7855062484741211,
0.34474942088127136,
-0.41974300146102905,
-0.04889434576034546,
-0.4427020847797394,
0.17128467559814453,
-0.2906888723373413,
0.5860021114349365,
-0.49920234084129333,
-0.376775860786438,
-0.15490804612636566,
-0.0019261641427874565,
-0.3508296310901642,
-1.0693823099136353,
0.3500763177871704,
-0.7049657106399536,
0.3706108331680298,
-0.28347650170326233,
-0.6274033188819885,
-0.02404850721359253,
0.3700389862060547,
-0.2739790678024292,
0.6807206273078918,
0.026393037289381027,
-0.8246099352836609,
0.35911935567855835,
-0.4550650119781494,
-0.3874729573726654,
0.209579199552536,
-0.35450026392936707,
-0.39788612723350525,
-0.07633551955223083,
0.4292174279689789,
0.3388296067714691,
-0.39043039083480835,
0.37295907735824585,
-0.028256114572286606,
-0.5836572647094727,
0.35092613101005554,
-0.2845458686351776,
0.4707724452018738,
0.2622038424015045,
-0.027421848848462105,
-0.03993558883666992,
-0.592690110206604,
0.10417649149894714,
0.2606763243675232,
-0.45436277985572815,
-0.38108816742897034,
-0.2983393967151642,
-0.24700996279716492,
0.11800503730773926,
0.30433547496795654,
-0.362727552652359,
-0.08305749297142029,
-0.5101615786552429,
-0.31747937202453613,
0.29332825541496277,
0.4231624901294708,
0.2286319136619568,
-0.701456606388092,
0.5544467568397522,
0.12319863587617874,
0.27493417263031006,
0.036587975919246674,
-0.23496891558170319,
-0.9514294266700745,
-0.043363187462091446,
0.0353471003472805,
0.7110992670059204,
-0.9760758876800537,
0.35495999455451965,
-0.08184217661619186,
-0.29758572578430176,
-1.1267893314361572,
-0.010313628241419792,
0.7281205654144287,
0.912239134311676,
0.8540052175521851,
-0.18378843367099762,
-0.6981512904167175,
-0.6144964098930359,
-0.2622000277042389,
-0.005708301439881325,
-0.0044707972556352615,
0.5085505247116089,
0.24339312314987183,
-0.06337250769138336,
0.4049980640411377,
-0.432539165019989,
-0.3807333707809448,
-0.4431949257850647,
-0.18227504193782806,
0.26287853717803955,
0.265895277261734,
-0.07688193023204803,
-0.7362220883369446,
-0.4109596908092499,
-0.030605081468820572,
-0.9387565851211548,
0.0031993011943995953,
-0.24752452969551086,
-0.1258646845817566,
0.3241982161998749,
0.47414517402648926,
-0.6195058822631836,
0.18355539441108704,
0.14888295531272888,
-0.14147797226905823,
0.39976710081100464,
-0.3090090751647949,
0.4610985517501831,
-1.3034391403198242,
0.23178501427173615,
-0.47151196002960205,
-0.16211529076099396,
-0.5526685118675232,
0.2632294297218323,
-0.02072960138320923,
0.20240239799022675,
-0.3286454379558563,
0.5587881207466125,
-0.4813533127307892,
0.09135663509368896,
-0.2920735478401184,
0.2947845160961151,
0.10587743669748306,
0.14209729433059692,
-0.13159742951393127,
0.9959957599639893,
0.35903945565223694,
-0.5196071863174438,
0.11125068366527557,
0.47525984048843384,
-0.3369462788105011,
0.5320903062820435,
-0.5971748232841492,
0.2391194850206375,
-0.4157813787460327,
-0.10865660756826401,
-0.4852372407913208,
-0.3502659201622009,
0.2089937925338745,
-0.41916900873184204,
0.5943054556846619,
0.0679258406162262,
-0.3972041606903076,
-0.518106997013092,
0.025329388678073883,
0.053495991975069046,
0.7020182609558105,
-0.6255044937133789,
0.4860912263393402,
0.5025108456611633,
-0.05590342357754707,
-0.8280239701271057,
-0.4725281596183777,
-0.18410515785217285,
-0.033045340329408646,
-0.3129708766937256,
0.17376463115215302,
-0.08507537096738815,
-0.25971633195877075,
-0.07841052114963531,
-0.4360460340976715,
-0.058279283344745636,
-0.028459457680583,
0.1256490796804428,
0.41614675521850586,
-0.1935698688030243,
0.15320205688476562,
0.17962586879730225,
-0.17621572315692902,
0.2432393729686737,
0.153916597366333,
0.6742997169494629,
0.15051808953285217,
-0.5252854824066162,
-0.4210318922996521,
0.15312735736370087,
0.2914541959762573,
-0.2649495303630829,
0.8012896776199341,
0.5992077589035034,
-0.2151414304971695,
0.06866589188575745,
-0.9141730666160583,
-0.49065127968788147,
-0.4436213970184326,
0.4202500581741333,
-0.33019617199897766,
-1.116422176361084,
0.12517352402210236,
-0.04095396399497986,
-0.23318655788898468,
0.2736145257949829,
0.7341582775115967,
-0.11970821022987366,
1.061358094215393,
0.13633987307548523,
0.16614069044589996,
-0.029446939006447792,
0.08712778985500336,
0.08988457173109055,
-0.9412218332290649,
-0.5242546200752258,
-0.20783977210521698,
0.016515983268618584,
-0.2522486746311188,
-0.5472008585929871,
0.7936962842941284,
0.22271624207496643,
-0.1359831690788269,
-0.2484586387872696,
-0.7288097143173218,
0.7543771266937256,
0.3555760383605957,
0.5193054676055908,
0.5065184235572815,
-0.16326190531253815,
-0.25699180364608765,
-0.06616094708442688,
-0.5810828804969788,
-0.20126648247241974,
1.0783785581588745,
0.11321047693490982,
0.7712153196334839,
-0.04813387617468834,
0.7595449686050415,
-0.1244746670126915,
0.1702233850955963,
-0.47853830456733704,
0.6892011165618896,
-0.05359097942709923,
-0.6410751938819885,
-0.05486685037612915,
-0.44546398520469666,
-0.8456666469573975,
0.23180438578128815,
-0.5040076375007629,
-0.3902815878391266,
-0.26850295066833496,
0.1443583071231842,
-0.3747803866863251,
0.27405887842178345,
-0.4587976932525635,
0.47866418957710266,
-0.09242507070302963,
-0.27926087379455566,
-0.26561498641967773,
-0.9918390512466431,
0.38112756609916687,
-0.15258602797985077,
-0.2027878761291504,
0.04051222652196884,
0.0349346362054348,
0.4740244150161743,
-0.2331990748643875,
0.443154901266098,
-0.41025522351264954,
0.22665251791477203,
0.06087251752614975,
-0.01930064894258976,
0.40200284123420715,
0.19343693554401398,
0.030129708349704742,
-0.1443810760974884,
0.14975398778915405,
-0.03606293722987175,
-0.8015884757041931,
0.44394776225090027,
-0.7603633999824524,
-0.8901914954185486,
-0.3663562536239624,
-0.7545686960220337,
-0.4203055799007416,
0.06162998080253601,
0.0870741680264473,
0.19751282036304474,
-0.050539419054985046,
0.25580883026123047,
0.899655282497406,
-0.36945152282714844,
-0.09224491566419601,
0.5748028755187988,
-0.4608977138996124,
-0.6742057800292969,
0.6857427358627319,
-0.057533059269189835,
0.281798392534256,
0.6341267824172974,
0.11770129203796387,
-0.3348820209503174,
-0.6974173188209534,
-0.2959308922290802,
0.5097557902336121,
-0.622491717338562,
-0.3255903720855713,
-1.0326085090637207,
-0.79262375831604,
-0.18654264509677887,
-0.01172271091490984,
-0.09048289805650711,
-0.33772367238998413,
-0.3253832459449768,
0.16327373683452606,
0.3981022834777832,
0.4731704890727997,
0.21249888837337494,
0.02744404971599579,
-0.8531058430671692,
0.5618900656700134,
0.16697198152542114,
0.2049206793308258,
-0.09800829738378525,
-0.5549184083938599,
-0.21037854254245758,
-0.19462670385837555,
-0.12623395025730133,
-0.5165026187896729,
0.3004380762577057,
-0.10851606726646423,
0.5342617034912109,
0.19967776536941528,
0.1549559235572815,
1.077666163444519,
-0.5397852659225464,
0.47411131858825684,
0.110305555164814,
-0.4002176821231842,
0.556643545627594,
-0.07151348143815994,
0.2604420781135559,
0.8582318425178528,
0.5986769199371338,
-0.4114317297935486,
-0.5622678399085999,
-0.3140816390514374,
-0.5824607610702515,
0.3802565634250641,
-0.16111290454864502,
-0.07604113966226578,
-0.1426694244146347,
0.6283017992973328,
0.28816863894462585,
0.1653682291507721,
-0.3157864511013031,
-0.28718695044517517,
0.27159184217453003,
-0.3232724070549011,
0.12903977930545807,
-0.2621612846851349,
-0.3592519164085388,
-0.6452810168266296,
0.6517136693000793,
-0.04135281220078468,
0.43537020683288574,
0.6161041259765625,
-0.1701868325471878,
-0.06962259858846664,
0.3682762682437897,
0.41941651701927185,
0.6752421855926514,
-0.3589336574077606,
0.08923766016960144,
0.48102787137031555,
-0.6937353014945984,
0.011243438348174095,
0.3308984041213989,
-0.05016687884926796,
-0.09806828945875168,
0.13221648335456848,
0.716484546661377,
-0.2928759455680847,
-0.8076990842819214,
0.45381441712379456,
-0.20807543396949768,
-0.30792704224586487,
-0.5235034823417664,
0.4578002691268921,
0.05673787742853165,
0.5387421250343323,
0.1641649454832077,
0.04456036165356636,
0.3076372742652893,
0.010648900642991066,
0.39012327790260315,
0.4722524583339691,
-0.29865872859954834,
0.12962308526039124,
0.9086114764213562,
-0.19875358045101166,
-0.09088634699583054,
0.4420003592967987,
-0.10551973432302475,
-0.129907488822937,
0.26518210768699646,
0.8806958794593811,
0.46513187885284424,
-0.09535149484872818,
-0.11002229154109955,
0.4071041941642761,
0.07086663693189621,
-0.18358370661735535,
0.784354567527771,
0.09748642146587372,
-0.6431912183761597,
-0.4525038003921509,
-0.6999233961105347,
-0.619661271572113,
0.13181687891483307,
-0.8229246139526367,
0.17929667234420776,
-0.5402076840400696,
-0.049983393400907516,
-0.18925395607948303,
-0.02720729634165764,
-0.3827935755252838,
0.19267205893993378,
-0.03263230249285698,
0.8044642210006714,
-0.17805643379688263,
0.9314519166946411,
0.6716728806495667,
-0.3798719644546509,
-0.8474588394165039,
0.08027583360671997,
-0.07899824529886246,
-0.9773286581039429,
0.4889359176158905,
0.07348155230283737,
-0.055272772908210754,
0.0875253826379776,
-0.2688557505607605,
-0.7230522632598877,
1.3374912738800049,
0.10596811771392822,
-0.5999016165733337,
-0.07724476605653763,
0.19641521573066711,
0.7216820120811462,
-0.2696259319782257,
0.12951971590518951,
0.5954099893569946,
0.1869708150625229,
0.2125808298587799,
-0.8876635432243347,
0.17816990613937378,
-0.24950508773326874,
-0.09347784519195557,
0.37462928891181946,
-0.3631962835788727,
0.46529629826545715,
-0.5674396753311157,
-0.10733912140130997,
0.28877195715904236,
0.2678132951259613,
0.7563917636871338,
0.4536389410495758,
0.31175777316093445,
0.6261354088783264,
1.0167756080627441,
-0.19563889503479004,
1.1502740383148193,
-0.542945384979248,
0.037576206028461456,
1.0981099605560303,
-0.3724411427974701,
0.8736276030540466,
0.7871948480606079,
-0.04967176541686058,
0.19919858872890472,
0.1846354752779007,
0.0189785435795784,
0.5921370387077332,
0.10427165776491165,
-0.5856094360351562,
-0.34284329414367676,
-0.3036193549633026,
-0.622434139251709,
0.0819622054696083,
0.3966163992881775,
-0.4418611526489258,
0.1793484091758728,
0.1563846468925476,
0.18275021016597748,
0.06530752778053284,
-0.19787587225437164,
1.128937840461731,
0.24046598374843597,
-0.7122103571891785,
0.8101149797439575,
-0.47963905334472656,
0.35310280323028564,
-0.4958585202693939,
-0.0060745603404939175,
-0.22485190629959106,
0.39227503538131714,
-0.007470312062650919,
-0.6409990787506104,
0.38195541501045227,
-0.18411120772361755,
-0.10065733641386032,
0.05487468093633652,
0.941497266292572,
-0.46229788661003113,
-0.39437147974967957,
0.25944316387176514,
0.8506817817687988,
0.08706923574209213,
0.2988762855529785,
-0.6887173056602478,
-0.1348770558834076,
-0.14626362919807434,
-0.03720635548233986,
0.35501179099082947,
0.41530534625053406,
0.3797096908092499,
0.6954747438430786,
0.6587143540382385,
0.30187952518463135,
0.030318252742290497,
0.3754488527774811,
1.104466438293457,
-0.6548129320144653,
0.08448905497789383,
-0.638283371925354,
0.3264468014240265,
-0.14515449106693268,
-0.06867879629135132,
0.46958068013191223,
0.5588479042053223,
0.8777737021446228,
-0.19301147758960724,
0.5492116212844849,
0.09468920528888702,
0.9798073768615723,
-0.7367717027664185,
0.9759100079536438,
-0.8213432431221008,
0.30098626017570496,
-0.0869268849492073,
-0.6657117009162903,
-0.7846981287002563,
0.5408766269683838,
-0.26429206132888794,
0.045646969228982925,
0.8344390392303467,
1.0515131950378418,
0.07532728463411331,
-0.043157704174518585,
0.4654853343963623,
0.2702348530292511,
0.01188181433826685,
0.5550882816314697,
0.9983315467834473,
-0.34151631593704224,
0.46961238980293274,
-0.3101441264152527,
0.12068182975053787,
-0.12103408575057983,
-0.23773550987243652,
-1.1451658010482788,
-0.2168601006269455,
-0.1185823380947113,
-0.5644232630729675,
0.6131848096847534,
1.2813432216644287,
0.45801112055778503,
-0.7491697072982788,
0.07188870757818222,
-0.04471404850482941,
-0.10981640219688416,
-0.048329468816518784,
-0.21075336635112762,
0.32483604550361633,
-0.6801807284355164,
-0.25786131620407104,
0.4423677623271942,
0.35624659061431885,
0.06094985082745552,
-0.061931878328323364,
-0.4284234344959259,
-0.1137871965765953,
-0.09740016609430313,
0.3760039508342743,
-0.04200078174471855,
-0.7773441672325134,
-0.10051525384187698,
0.3821103274822235,
-0.2963694930076599,
0.37374347448349,
0.6836771965026855,
-0.7580888271331787,
0.5335550308227539,
0.3438471257686615,
1.0278425216674805,
0.4304066300392151,
0.15650853514671326,
0.28496053814888,
-0.4853682816028595,
0.027659622952342033,
0.33301910758018494,
0.21708710491657257,
0.25522759556770325,
-0.38756129145622253,
0.5065695643424988,
0.19646690785884857,
-0.8217700123786926,
-0.6329492330551147,
-0.10338771343231201,
-1.016190767288208,
-0.3494824469089508,
0.985321581363678,
0.1578671932220459,
-0.0241987407207489,
-0.3537871241569519,
-0.4513686001300812,
0.38958704471588135,
-0.09695398807525635,
1.0277704000473022,
0.22375653684139252,
-0.2946362793445587,
-0.4412716329097748,
-0.7520766258239746,
0.6004385352134705,
0.6163625717163086,
-1.0308842658996582,
-0.13620375096797943,
0.3027935028076172,
0.18032018840312958,
0.019595971331000328,
0.8245403170585632,
-0.5098698735237122,
0.4519559144973755,
-0.14294683933258057,
0.06596013903617859,
-0.14439953863620758,
-0.4573383927345276,
-0.21480722725391388,
0.13901516795158386,
0.2678982615470886,
0.013872294686734676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17882v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17882v2
|
BlendSQL: A Scalable Dialect for Unifying Hybrid Question Answering in Relational Algebra
| 2024-02-27T20:48:24 | 2024-06-10T20:27:28 |
Parker Glenn, Parag Pravin Dakle, Liang Wang, Preethi Raghavan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Many existing end-to-end systems for hybrid question answering tasks can
often be boiled down to a "prompt-and-pray" paradigm, where the user has
limited control and insight into the intermediate reasoning steps used to
achieve the final result. Additionally, due to the context size limitation of
many transformer-based LLMs, it is often not reasonable to expect that the full
structured and unstructured context will fit into a given prompt in a zero-shot
setting, let alone a few-shot setting. We introduce BlendSQL, a superset of
SQLite to act as a unified dialect for orchestrating reasoning across both
unstructured and structured data. For hybrid question answering tasks involving
multi-hop reasoning, we encode the full decomposed reasoning roadmap into a
single interpretable BlendSQL query. Notably, we show that BlendSQL can scale
to massive datasets and improve the performance of end-to-end systems while
using 35% fewer tokens. Our code is available and installable as a package at
https://github.com/parkervg/blendsql.
|
[
-0.3285570740699768,
-1.076491117477417,
0.7718557119369507,
0.4072449803352356,
-0.2743724584579468,
0.6818565726280212,
0.05256526917219162,
-0.21845325827598572,
0.46096715331077576,
0.6639514565467834,
-0.7746614217758179,
-0.331501305103302,
-0.11849839985370636,
0.1481202393770218,
-0.49382340908050537,
0.9592552781105042,
0.10470167547464371,
-0.0068672290071845055,
-0.6896743178367615,
-0.38380488753318787,
-0.31580018997192383,
-0.5458939075469971,
-0.40589216351509094,
-0.30738601088523865,
0.07134350389242172,
0.30204829573631287,
1.1063836812973022,
0.18233516812324524,
0.16628003120422363,
0.2065056711435318,
-0.1725822389125824,
0.2400520145893097,
-0.5560556650161743,
0.5156658291816711,
-0.230591282248497,
-0.5249297022819519,
-0.13346822559833527,
-0.4325067102909088,
0.5040531754493713,
1.0380858182907104,
-0.42775288224220276,
0.0065622832626104355,
-0.26512110233306885,
0.5065627098083496,
-0.49646756052970886,
-0.10714326053857803,
-0.6445425748825073,
0.1964433491230011,
-0.06035606935620308,
-0.08726107329130173,
-0.2233608514070511,
-0.26317745447158813,
-0.009343639016151428,
-0.8880064487457275,
-0.19053183495998383,
0.3165312111377716,
0.4213767349720001,
0.036404095590114594,
-0.5961307287216187,
0.282105416059494,
-0.7836577892303467,
0.833774983882904,
-0.23673929274082184,
0.17930306494235992,
-0.15852998197078705,
0.6739842295646667,
-0.38009363412857056,
-0.6857587099075317,
-0.6870492100715637,
0.3204277753829956,
-0.18159730732440948,
0.18603922426700592,
-0.013239807449281216,
0.21995046734809875,
0.11458604782819748,
0.6849125027656555,
-0.7295495867729187,
-0.48049721121788025,
-0.09347248822450638,
-0.13870806992053986,
0.4989057779312134,
0.496119886636734,
0.3001924455165863,
0.08609123528003693,
-0.22058233618736267,
0.19056783616542816,
-0.7177821397781372,
-0.1813712865114212,
-0.11155220866203308,
0.192949116230011,
0.2279881089925766,
0.5836862921714783,
-0.538344144821167,
0.9884501695632935,
0.012333068065345287,
0.19983869791030884,
-0.25666898488998413,
-0.4774581491947174,
-0.28966596722602844,
-0.23675577342510223,
0.9378295540809631,
0.33458977937698364,
0.08862152695655823,
-0.3847590684890747,
-0.09317478537559509,
0.11780980974435806,
0.03488195687532425,
-0.562436044216156,
-0.13294608891010284,
0.5547003149986267,
-0.11810518801212311,
0.1254209578037262,
-0.24676325917243958,
-0.8043918013572693,
-0.36297643184661865,
-0.39510849118232727,
0.5338892936706543,
-0.37750110030174255,
-0.1463165581226349,
0.21309179067611694,
-0.1021660715341568,
0.4064197540283203,
0.4427343010902405,
-0.8167740702629089,
0.7249915599822998,
0.5824408531188965,
0.6896660327911377,
-0.10613636672496796,
-0.06205351650714874,
-0.3761804401874542,
0.10256487131118774,
-0.49295875430107117,
0.9080806970596313,
-0.6384841203689575,
-0.6284971833229065,
-0.10598396509885788,
-0.44117432832717896,
-0.2624289393424988,
-0.7481437921524048,
0.1934906542301178,
-0.701619029045105,
0.40396058559417725,
-0.123499296605587,
-0.5219060182571411,
0.0003511293325573206,
0.3068447709083557,
-0.2504550814628601,
1.3804502487182617,
0.5070276260375977,
-0.22967734932899475,
0.11476040631532669,
-0.5485036969184875,
-0.6548065543174744,
0.4201345443725586,
-0.5093864798545837,
0.08123154193162918,
0.08438216149806976,
0.31161025166511536,
0.07195769250392914,
-0.7717500329017639,
0.3504585921764374,
-0.2927597463130951,
-0.38273802399635315,
0.29355770349502563,
0.1088637262582779,
0.8603583574295044,
0.31208276748657227,
0.10235462337732315,
0.16119614243507385,
-0.6249456405639648,
0.41045454144477844,
0.21526944637298584,
-0.22318828105926514,
-0.06480024009943008,
-0.17341667413711548,
0.021028144285082817,
0.24313300848007202,
0.1625385582447052,
-0.679199755191803,
0.2710893452167511,
-0.20855394005775452,
0.39477965235710144,
0.4929285943508148,
-0.05656416714191437,
0.4933124780654907,
-0.20652854442596436,
0.7410023808479309,
-0.10272512584924698,
0.24209491908550262,
-0.2373838871717453,
-0.41919538378715515,
-0.6615521311759949,
-0.14645400643348694,
0.1276681125164032,
0.7560008764266968,
-0.9660305976867676,
0.2375425398349762,
-0.23427334427833557,
-0.12797050178050995,
-0.42667731642723083,
0.14713191986083984,
0.21588024497032166,
0.5134595632553101,
0.5830141305923462,
-0.052878204733133316,
-0.5485792756080627,
-1.0186885595321655,
-0.5507351756095886,
0.06139325350522995,
-0.18969586491584778,
0.512535810470581,
0.41802746057510376,
0.09072152525186539,
1.1610080003738403,
-0.667336642742157,
-0.020708434283733368,
-0.47365379333496094,
-0.06335989385843277,
0.5620157718658447,
0.245928093791008,
0.20423440635204315,
-0.755961000919342,
-0.7806340456008911,
0.08938713371753693,
-1.0496002435684204,
0.14447122812271118,
-0.16012071073055267,
-0.5740703344345093,
-0.24811863899230957,
0.4047155976295471,
-1.0286916494369507,
-0.041454024612903595,
0.25200361013412476,
-0.3279828131198883,
0.5563843250274658,
0.06826689839363098,
0.16787585616111755,
-1.1111265420913696,
-0.1396915763616562,
-0.39286819100379944,
-0.21411415934562683,
-0.564941942691803,
0.3384040296077728,
-0.20283225178718567,
-0.2587648034095764,
-0.24075870215892792,
0.2880944013595581,
-0.32950833439826965,
-0.2017814815044403,
0.17902110517024994,
-0.07741555571556091,
0.1471826285123825,
0.3177602291107178,
0.10510020703077316,
0.997003436088562,
0.8300905227661133,
-0.3073643743991852,
0.7083743810653687,
0.4433421790599823,
-0.009429543279111385,
0.9535150527954102,
-0.6928231120109558,
0.04284822940826416,
-0.14159762859344482,
0.5510023236274719,
-0.897912859916687,
-0.32653847336769104,
-0.05963236466050148,
-0.21724969148635864,
0.11256399005651474,
-0.2711019814014435,
-0.4626922607421875,
-0.23001354932785034,
-0.22863873839378357,
0.3526889681816101,
0.4314539432525635,
-0.558194637298584,
1.1195085048675537,
0.2523748278617859,
0.053507253527641296,
-0.34493568539619446,
-0.46188944578170776,
0.25915369391441345,
-0.1288875937461853,
-0.8701695203781128,
0.29106417298316956,
-0.2254241555929184,
-0.30987489223480225,
0.08543451875448227,
-0.35980531573295593,
-0.33043840527534485,
-0.03820059448480606,
0.018335238099098206,
0.4275382459163666,
-0.3448258638381958,
0.023280831053853035,
0.37798845767974854,
-0.14839337766170502,
0.10347573459148407,
-0.5646399259567261,
0.33173584938049316,
-0.2193412333726883,
-0.10995830595493317,
0.007320272270590067,
0.8496454954147339,
0.7618755102157593,
-0.08565612137317657,
0.9209948182106018,
-0.20909123122692108,
-0.186687633395195,
-0.3043106496334076,
-0.1733078807592392,
-0.26683199405670166,
-0.42869627475738525,
0.0033144690096378326,
-0.4169575273990631,
-1.0776572227478027,
0.4141709506511688,
-0.33512312173843384,
0.15416774153709412,
0.41689422726631165,
0.3741576671600342,
-0.3505944311618805,
0.8225691914558411,
0.20017413794994354,
0.2067301720380783,
-0.0025448808446526527,
-0.18136583268642426,
0.2529657185077667,
-0.6815596222877502,
-0.40101078152656555,
-0.33333268761634827,
-0.1934119462966919,
-0.1273762285709381,
-0.6990458369255066,
0.7736576795578003,
0.14751410484313965,
-0.1876707226037979,
0.1485462486743927,
-0.41859662532806396,
1.0955700874328613,
0.510972797870636,
-0.1211518943309784,
0.5770437717437744,
-0.09312475472688675,
-0.19260622560977936,
0.16262951493263245,
-0.7335614562034607,
-0.030794532969594002,
1.1700925827026367,
-0.4066154360771179,
0.7910860180854797,
0.23394618928432465,
0.6178810596466064,
0.09448149800300598,
-0.025045959278941154,
-0.5155601501464844,
0.6366186738014221,
0.15895144641399384,
-0.9990708827972412,
-0.22682970762252808,
-0.5228092670440674,
-0.6837989687919617,
0.6971232295036316,
-0.5036671161651611,
-0.7100496292114258,
-0.09954722225666046,
0.34078195691108704,
-0.6938486099243164,
0.17362380027770996,
-0.5774485468864441,
0.9087924361228943,
-0.18612225353717804,
-0.28939950466156006,
0.02313200756907463,
-0.8535465002059937,
0.4394397735595703,
0.07450151443481445,
0.12156759202480316,
0.06537225842475891,
0.24065181612968445,
0.3814921975135803,
-0.618649959564209,
0.2796771228313446,
0.2608988285064697,
0.38175228238105774,
0.5578541159629822,
0.48445025086402893,
0.30315032601356506,
0.09674318134784698,
0.3083173632621765,
0.0785166323184967,
0.3553787171840668,
-0.5118570327758789,
-1.0392777919769287,
0.6934148073196411,
-0.4626029133796692,
-0.5217280387878418,
-0.5066704750061035,
-0.7881468534469604,
-0.6113536953926086,
-0.04691071808338165,
0.27063441276550293,
0.34969374537467957,
0.052889350801706314,
0.3876590430736542,
0.9621909260749817,
0.06365008652210236,
0.019432267174124718,
0.2344246357679367,
-0.5404765605926514,
-0.16029107570648193,
0.8105400800704956,
-0.10348392277956009,
0.4613509476184845,
0.6451177000999451,
-0.024489955976605415,
-0.6960415244102478,
-0.3096235394477844,
-0.9028567671775818,
0.1807115077972412,
-0.5193610191345215,
-0.2091342657804489,
-0.6120648980140686,
-0.10196073353290558,
-0.19471710920333862,
-0.31612545251846313,
-0.4099123179912567,
-0.9527679085731506,
-0.007637035101652145,
0.03446301817893982,
0.3843950927257538,
0.3931101858615875,
0.3029225766658783,
0.30604618787765503,
-0.7451170682907104,
0.35545361042022705,
0.5330032706260681,
0.3751150667667389,
-0.31826111674308777,
-0.4109446704387665,
0.008019457571208477,
-0.33701854944229126,
-0.1559300720691681,
-0.8112927675247192,
0.02479533851146698,
0.3220486044883728,
0.3761366307735443,
0.1556985229253769,
0.19624049961566925,
0.5782759785652161,
-0.33097848296165466,
0.7106433510780334,
0.24658462405204773,
-0.7446948885917664,
0.5172538161277771,
-0.4485401213169098,
0.3105922043323517,
0.7165165543556213,
0.5046495795249939,
-0.7358556985855103,
-0.30338308215141296,
-0.39730361104011536,
-0.7979754209518433,
0.6364703178405762,
0.19557222723960876,
0.01667041704058647,
0.11693446338176727,
0.22306133806705475,
0.050774965435266495,
0.3059413433074951,
-0.5842151045799255,
-0.4826098084449768,
-0.20956097543239594,
-0.2897508442401886,
0.1536012589931488,
-0.09178225696086884,
-0.519312858581543,
-0.27361148595809937,
0.4006916284561157,
-0.32714956998825073,
0.06651996076107025,
-0.12653017044067383,
-0.1159651130437851,
-0.27809467911720276,
0.5947432518005371,
-0.0022104973904788494,
0.6893246173858643,
-0.2609054744243622,
0.10015092045068741,
0.10042668133974075,
-0.07763750851154327,
0.07782862335443497,
0.21993570029735565,
-0.4875291883945465,
-0.270300030708313,
0.11732801049947739,
0.3989124298095703,
0.017857136204838753,
-0.984843373298645,
0.2071751356124878,
-0.02579806186258793,
-0.23227350413799286,
0.04189587011933327,
0.08854706585407257,
0.2600201666355133,
0.17733100056648254,
0.3949626684188843,
-0.2472267895936966,
0.41706937551498413,
-0.6986253261566162,
-0.14528271555900574,
0.6782577037811279,
-0.08714501559734344,
-0.058329589664936066,
0.6888128519058228,
0.16408248245716095,
-0.011821737512946129,
0.8037179112434387,
-0.16504837572574615,
-0.463072806596756,
0.24910815060138702,
0.6702048182487488,
0.5294599533081055,
-0.09678571671247482,
0.34448426961898804,
0.028733639046549797,
0.23703999817371368,
0.19914674758911133,
0.5895691514015198,
-0.17692968249320984,
-0.732820451259613,
-0.5764209032058716,
-0.857191264629364,
-0.612372875213623,
-0.10344699770212173,
-0.4504106938838959,
-0.39565542340278625,
-0.5918297171592712,
0.3126768171787262,
0.08918686211109161,
-0.37031811475753784,
-0.06667454540729523,
0.14243049919605255,
-0.17074497044086456,
0.7194800972938538,
-0.9287571310997009,
0.3577933609485626,
0.871807336807251,
-0.2791770100593567,
-0.6802999973297119,
-0.5006013512611389,
0.2757907509803772,
-0.5569591522216797,
0.07744510471820831,
-0.24777047336101532,
-0.09966068714857101,
-0.04992182180285454,
-0.4484120309352875,
-0.7933286428451538,
0.934052050113678,
0.4231385588645935,
-0.26494479179382324,
0.14420771598815918,
0.3731083273887634,
0.5261810421943665,
-0.3087625801563263,
0.3726973235607147,
0.8963044285774231,
0.1407516896724701,
0.765792727470398,
-0.7391205430030823,
-0.08088283985853195,
-0.07009187340736389,
-0.06441206485033035,
0.7214124202728271,
-0.397578626871109,
0.9229342341423035,
-0.1589260995388031,
-0.2116777002811432,
-0.09236511588096619,
0.5339380502700806,
0.17371615767478943,
0.2778700888156891,
0.263881117105484,
0.7837300300598145,
0.5270047187805176,
-0.37638941407203674,
1.331716537475586,
-0.0806054025888443,
0.34538549184799194,
1.138060212135315,
-0.33071014285087585,
0.431907594203949,
0.4758342206478119,
-0.7243672013282776,
0.664545476436615,
0.5415626764297485,
0.5513623356819153,
0.25649023056030273,
-0.08337855339050293,
-0.7344253063201904,
-0.7982139587402344,
-0.2548906207084656,
-0.26980748772621155,
0.13243427872657776,
0.4167923033237457,
0.14638903737068176,
-0.5291129946708679,
-0.4616255760192871,
-0.14135871827602386,
0.25163257122039795,
-0.21815437078475952,
0.5516212582588196,
0.16028796136379242,
-0.6641442179679871,
0.4302472472190857,
-0.3465559482574463,
0.13335828483104706,
-0.636407196521759,
-0.15994548797607422,
-0.5527405142784119,
-0.14614395797252655,
-0.24318505823612213,
-1.0525486469268799,
0.43284329771995544,
-0.38678786158561707,
-0.0444161631166935,
-0.13633817434310913,
0.4437859356403351,
-0.460106760263443,
-0.31238681077957153,
0.029108339920639992,
0.686459481716156,
0.06374185532331467,
-0.28396785259246826,
-0.8245653510093689,
-0.20572730898857117,
-0.2235565483570099,
-0.03469563275575638,
0.5061363577842712,
0.5774446129798889,
-0.22819849848747253,
0.6913708448410034,
0.8894059062004089,
-0.21354365348815918,
0.12961460649967194,
-0.012011043727397919,
1.119893193244934,
-0.5412388443946838,
-0.4224250018596649,
-0.4821579158306122,
0.32680124044418335,
-0.26040780544281006,
-0.3105398118495941,
0.7669932842254639,
0.7852610945701599,
0.4912046194076538,
0.04548348858952522,
0.49351534247398376,
-0.209123894572258,
0.49024492502212524,
-0.36990460753440857,
0.14512386918067932,
-0.5531564354896545,
0.13188466429710388,
0.020286163315176964,
-0.9513654112815857,
-0.6173875331878662,
0.43668755888938904,
-0.007001813035458326,
0.045265067368745804,
0.7237156629562378,
0.7756012082099915,
-0.156558558344841,
0.2702661454677582,
0.4012700319290161,
0.15137508511543274,
0.08179686218500137,
0.6913811564445496,
1.042544960975647,
-0.05143618956208229,
0.6572772264480591,
-0.018770501017570496,
-0.17654335498809814,
-0.20678210258483887,
-0.45909398794174194,
-0.5105796456336975,
-0.15311984717845917,
-0.2042321413755417,
-0.5683563351631165,
-0.01597921922802925,
0.8025450110435486,
0.5938348174095154,
-0.8660094141960144,
-0.38431859016418457,
-0.19911353290081024,
0.3134249746799469,
-0.30941063165664673,
-0.2582184076309204,
0.22377435863018036,
-0.10981331020593643,
-0.28315451741218567,
0.5550478100776672,
0.8179274797439575,
-0.21935994923114777,
-0.07957623898983002,
0.03250698745250702,
-0.2883746027946472,
0.355855256319046,
0.7738536596298218,
0.6793924570083618,
-0.5091903209686279,
0.0691162496805191,
0.3163640797138214,
0.19074063003063202,
0.13378652930259705,
0.8068658113479614,
-0.9481539726257324,
0.6901640295982361,
0.2792406976222992,
0.7563037872314453,
0.6576176285743713,
0.07384486496448517,
0.3895655870437622,
-0.649558961391449,
-0.2914196848869324,
0.5304098725318909,
0.2320973128080368,
0.14366872608661652,
-0.4139460623264313,
0.5460224151611328,
0.5214186906814575,
-0.4172555208206177,
-0.39946287870407104,
0.4235107898712158,
-1.1977747678756714,
-0.3898601830005646,
0.8287639617919922,
0.28393056988716125,
-0.23151534795761108,
-0.42995381355285645,
-0.15707902610301971,
-0.42178475856781006,
-0.42779356241226196,
0.32590699195861816,
0.43836379051208496,
-0.7714576125144958,
-0.1916297823190689,
-0.30083853006362915,
0.14582706987857819,
0.5817238688468933,
-1.0228453874588013,
0.033817365765571594,
0.9776440262794495,
0.21701741218566895,
0.11703083664178848,
0.8880301713943481,
-0.06442443281412125,
0.45006585121154785,
0.21287479996681213,
-0.21718794107437134,
0.17369577288627625,
-0.44855111837387085,
-0.10564262419939041,
0.19473068416118622,
-0.1439589112997055,
0.05936853587627411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17879v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17879v2
|
Automated Statistical Model Discovery with Language Models
| 2024-02-27T20:33:22 | 2024-06-22T05:08:30 |
Michael Y. Li, Emily B. Fox, Noah D. Goodman
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Statistical model discovery is a challenging search over a vast space of
models subject to domain-specific constraints. Efficiently searching over this
space requires expertise in modeling and the problem domain. Motivated by the
domain knowledge and programming capabilities of large language models (LMs),
we introduce a method for language model driven automated statistical model
discovery. We cast our automated procedure within the principled framework of
Box's Loop: the LM iterates between proposing statistical models represented as
probabilistic programs, acting as a modeler, and critiquing those models,
acting as a domain expert. By leveraging LMs, we do not have to define a
domain-specific language of models or design a handcrafted search procedure,
which are key restrictions of previous systems. We evaluate our method in three
settings in probabilistic modeling: searching within a restricted space of
models, searching over an open-ended space, and improving expert models under
natural language constraints (e.g., this model should be interpretable to an
ecologist). Our method identifies models on par with human expert designed
models and extends classic models in interpretable ways. Our results highlight
the promise of LM-driven model discovery.
|
[
-0.22502487897872925,
-0.9903642535209656,
0.9753172993659973,
-0.13235868513584137,
0.05783114582300186,
0.0748448371887207,
-0.17186537384986877,
-0.09188287705183029,
0.09593621641397476,
0.970065176486969,
-0.5989293456077576,
-0.7879042625427246,
-0.5007010102272034,
0.06551390141248703,
-0.4645879864692688,
0.4671385884284973,
-0.27168798446655273,
0.21721208095550537,
-0.09824606776237488,
0.1751721203327179,
-0.4454120397567749,
-0.4547320604324341,
-0.2363343983888626,
-0.35073181986808777,
0.20763498544692993,
0.2110571563243866,
0.8924741744995117,
0.8326236605644226,
0.6804201006889343,
0.3426922559738159,
0.13959519565105438,
0.3019033670425415,
-0.2589437663555145,
0.17533889412879944,
-0.27525943517684937,
-0.7055919766426086,
-0.511220395565033,
-0.15650352835655212,
0.4591057300567627,
0.9552756547927856,
-0.3098941147327423,
0.07649175077676773,
-0.17525595426559448,
0.4431973993778229,
-0.4340507686138153,
0.5748947262763977,
-0.8094135522842407,
-0.0016706729074940085,
-0.34413254261016846,
-0.5818239450454712,
-0.5162951946258545,
-0.35731011629104614,
0.19862793385982513,
-0.5820634365081787,
0.7447192072868347,
0.19922737777233124,
0.42360493540763855,
0.16053622961044312,
-0.4666118919849396,
-0.4442286491394043,
-0.8546469211578369,
0.8708061575889587,
-0.5939241051673889,
0.40869271755218506,
0.6824542284011841,
0.5201564431190491,
-0.5972294807434082,
-0.20318257808685303,
-0.3696856200695038,
-0.3312133848667145,
-0.04494456201791763,
-0.4001131057739258,
-0.18527540564537048,
-0.09808279573917389,
0.10787400603294373,
0.07282718271017075,
-0.7919958233833313,
-0.08364689350128174,
-0.32932063937187195,
-0.19209372997283936,
0.8300914168357849,
0.29283618927001953,
0.23891617357730865,
0.08047918230295181,
0.19637571275234222,
-0.049986738711595535,
-0.5100371241569519,
-0.2680763900279999,
0.2609296143054962,
0.6288040280342102,
0.2798191010951996,
0.8444846272468567,
-0.27507367730140686,
0.7255126237869263,
-0.520800769329071,
0.0281800776720047,
-0.1441185623407364,
0.012388196773827076,
-0.05445261299610138,
-0.3383341133594513,
0.6330676078796387,
0.11439897119998932,
0.4401514232158661,
-0.08468154817819595,
-0.46877002716064453,
0.07055621594190598,
0.10633675009012222,
-0.3292447626590729,
-0.6227167248725891,
0.08524513989686966,
-0.4712192714214325,
-0.21408063173294067,
0.0799391120672226,
-0.7186472415924072,
-0.39316901564598083,
-0.3623235523700714,
0.5346403121948242,
-0.2902566194534302,
-0.4171806275844574,
0.25946763157844543,
-0.1621907651424408,
-0.2771911025047302,
0.1859186887741089,
-0.5215983390808105,
0.41734984517097473,
0.6963152885437012,
0.6890133023262024,
0.008282188326120377,
0.027594363316893578,
-0.44096240401268005,
0.1560084968805313,
-0.9928861856460571,
0.8863487839698792,
-0.9366649389266968,
-0.2663699984550476,
0.08712324500083923,
0.28141289949417114,
0.09277013689279556,
-0.849195659160614,
0.11104107648134232,
-0.828915536403656,
-0.17629371583461761,
-0.10520075261592865,
-0.8438061475753784,
-0.28839242458343506,
-0.4279592037200928,
-0.6521270871162415,
0.7759858965873718,
0.02386552281677723,
-0.3303738832473755,
0.4450783133506775,
-0.7249606251716614,
-0.10202978551387787,
0.2515791356563568,
-0.23814435303211212,
-0.5919945240020752,
0.1445721983909607,
0.16241741180419922,
0.6662392020225525,
-0.3499482572078705,
0.6703673005104065,
-0.7568053603172302,
-0.17132796347141266,
0.4541414976119995,
-0.10085561871528625,
0.7791481018066406,
0.3176994025707245,
-0.23923176527023315,
0.06353170424699783,
-0.9117552638053894,
0.042786356061697006,
0.3750765323638916,
0.11624611169099808,
-0.47958043217658997,
0.405952513217926,
-0.03036547638475895,
-0.3993445932865143,
-0.06308146566152573,
-0.09428868442773819,
0.3766225278377533,
-0.10049145668745041,
0.3310183882713318,
0.6441563963890076,
-0.13376384973526,
0.5841262340545654,
-0.14848938584327698,
0.689883828163147,
-0.13335175812244415,
-0.0721062421798706,
-0.34244877099990845,
-0.395287424325943,
-0.6039037704467773,
-0.2421705424785614,
0.1704397201538086,
0.6718990802764893,
-0.3735215663909912,
0.6615729331970215,
0.1211225837469101,
-0.4179656207561493,
-0.5311866998672485,
0.192238450050354,
0.10564051568508148,
0.0009520233143121004,
0.36931222677230835,
-0.3420362174510956,
-0.4971851706504822,
-0.9754905700683594,
-0.13434287905693054,
0.0456300787627697,
-0.22287417948246002,
0.2732512950897217,
0.6656086444854736,
-0.5995242595672607,
1.1777111291885376,
-0.7868298888206482,
-0.39358505606651306,
-0.247417151927948,
0.23277318477630615,
0.3392500579357147,
0.29636746644973755,
0.33495858311653137,
-0.4869532585144043,
-0.2118385136127472,
0.0013355069095268846,
-0.9013832211494446,
-0.35064956545829773,
0.3173351287841797,
-0.06980700045824051,
0.10698636621236801,
0.465041846036911,
-0.42195919156074524,
0.6533472537994385,
0.18048132956027985,
-0.08382044732570648,
0.49885526299476624,
-0.4072217643260956,
-0.05200562998652458,
-0.6980423927307129,
-0.01895306259393692,
0.20769596099853516,
-0.13635115325450897,
-0.6268244981765747,
0.38644686341285706,
0.1626962274312973,
-0.34611913561820984,
0.2842135727405548,
0.631875216960907,
-0.6547636985778809,
-0.22489163279533386,
-0.39972543716430664,
-0.14107972383499146,
-0.24156533181667328,
0.16368404030799866,
0.47860804200172424,
0.515501081943512,
0.8647530674934387,
-0.7168881297111511,
0.3338903486728668,
0.04582794010639191,
-0.4087042212486267,
0.2608465850353241,
-0.5122299790382385,
0.06989757716655731,
-0.26427552103996277,
0.3204778730869293,
-0.8543927073478699,
-0.3614402115345001,
0.03202133625745773,
-0.15365265309810638,
0.02628074400126934,
-0.1017901822924614,
-0.40575796365737915,
-0.36940866708755493,
0.21104328334331512,
0.39232298731803894,
0.47831058502197266,
-0.45713010430336,
0.37987595796585083,
0.6025839447975159,
-0.34304168820381165,
-0.16418328881263733,
-0.05683330073952675,
0.14767636358737946,
-0.10743637382984161,
-0.5117304921150208,
0.026917193084955215,
-0.16255038976669312,
-0.6346836686134338,
-0.15468628704547882,
-0.0745048001408577,
-0.30831947922706604,
0.20088787376880646,
-0.07659850269556046,
0.060212891548871994,
-0.3082403838634491,
0.24484054744243622,
-0.2708035111427307,
-0.2655799984931946,
0.04288192093372345,
-0.2930043041706085,
0.5153906941413879,
-0.01863349787890911,
-0.4407937526702881,
-0.2514660656452179,
0.614324152469635,
0.16329242289066315,
-0.34451329708099365,
0.32118260860443115,
0.13810379803180695,
-0.7489530444145203,
-0.7275437116622925,
-0.5291269421577454,
-0.36873698234558105,
-0.43935370445251465,
0.4605098068714142,
-0.5753276944160461,
-0.5878135561943054,
0.5389259457588196,
0.011071250773966312,
-0.29883334040641785,
0.3451547920703888,
0.5088220238685608,
-0.02588551491498947,
1.5124287605285645,
1.1447510719299316,
0.042931169271469116,
0.16581209003925323,
-0.2808109223842621,
0.5945959687232971,
-0.17247124016284943,
-0.09989761561155319,
-0.6862592101097107,
0.17082177102565765,
-0.38543474674224854,
-0.7171025276184082,
0.49733251333236694,
0.1676293909549713,
-0.1544109284877777,
0.37936580181121826,
-0.5486893057823181,
0.5179108381271362,
0.7150100469589233,
0.298391193151474,
0.35849887132644653,
-0.12741319835186005,
-0.12671412527561188,
0.053396958857774734,
-0.8348248600959778,
-0.8218136429786682,
1.1591558456420898,
0.5094394683837891,
1.1281344890594482,
-0.15521353483200073,
0.7311574816703796,
0.3224242925643921,
0.3572753369808197,
-0.6123672723770142,
0.6787954568862915,
0.022655079141259193,
-0.6843421459197998,
-0.4214836657047272,
-0.5400039553642273,
-0.9945328235626221,
-0.18510591983795166,
0.04117323458194733,
-0.7782643437385559,
0.23358848690986633,
0.35037338733673096,
-0.2718234956264496,
0.18190650641918182,
-0.44995298981666565,
0.8249348998069763,
-0.2930924594402313,
-0.17130394279956818,
-0.3890824019908905,
-0.26458510756492615,
0.40235161781311035,
-0.2982986569404602,
0.6287559866905212,
-0.14361096918582916,
0.14826703071594238,
0.5700019001960754,
-0.566214919090271,
0.859228253364563,
-0.11441877484321594,
-0.2845830023288727,
0.16732345521450043,
0.699853241443634,
0.6227570176124573,
-0.061075564473867416,
-0.05694146454334259,
-0.07234614342451096,
0.1514679491519928,
-0.3414415717124939,
-0.48357638716697693,
0.2430468499660492,
-0.4027647376060486,
-0.6774569153785706,
-0.3915909230709076,
-0.5815027356147766,
-0.13293679058551788,
0.1313575804233551,
-0.16308477520942688,
0.3663969337940216,
-0.17144469916820526,
0.07631054520606995,
0.8302173614501953,
-0.4329220652580261,
0.03735475242137909,
0.8083108067512512,
-0.5354211330413818,
0.0840769037604332,
0.7564228773117065,
0.1586277186870575,
-0.11705290526151657,
0.6030107736587524,
0.33510729670524597,
-0.3250214457511902,
-0.4526481032371521,
-0.22734925150871277,
0.09360118955373764,
-0.6555719375610352,
-0.33067670464515686,
-0.7513689994812012,
-0.1071930080652237,
-0.4200604259967804,
-0.14617805182933807,
-0.2649661898612976,
-0.021351389586925507,
-0.19365571439266205,
0.01904144510626793,
0.594395637512207,
0.750914990901947,
0.036397431045770645,
0.30230021476745605,
-0.6184764504432678,
0.47735047340393066,
0.18536390364170074,
0.6223419308662415,
-0.1514255255460739,
-0.18743428587913513,
-0.34000539779663086,
0.004083320498466492,
-0.13115669786930084,
-1.1807891130447388,
0.8400777578353882,
0.12905414402484894,
0.6879033446311951,
0.4549109935760498,
0.13787150382995605,
0.6566163301467896,
-0.491871178150177,
0.35459572076797485,
-0.27518582344055176,
-0.8575118184089661,
0.6791673302650452,
-0.5236525535583496,
-0.06356684118509293,
-0.14714987576007843,
0.4945412874221802,
-0.1337316781282425,
-0.6396552920341492,
-0.5671132206916809,
-0.6726722717285156,
0.4370310306549072,
-0.0641612559556961,
-0.3767258822917938,
-0.09297437965869904,
0.10802420228719711,
0.405462384223938,
0.2681691646575928,
-0.573988139629364,
0.007017223164439201,
0.24720172584056854,
-0.2526402771472931,
-0.43952372670173645,
-0.06832293421030045,
-0.24490410089492798,
-0.20584169030189514,
0.7829029560089111,
-0.36880844831466675,
0.2496856451034546,
0.16233906149864197,
-0.26203352212905884,
-0.529570460319519,
0.0789169892668724,
0.3209978938102722,
0.9358157515525818,
-0.3682992458343506,
0.24036464095115662,
-0.032990843057632446,
0.19633261859416962,
0.02768995426595211,
0.23903189599514008,
-0.12850165367126465,
0.26621702313423157,
0.43649834394454956,
0.7710919380187988,
0.24117544293403625,
-0.9757145047187805,
0.10620593279600143,
0.1841239482164383,
-0.10914436727762222,
-0.6060585379600525,
0.2795988619327545,
-0.05508608743548393,
0.5499504804611206,
0.596933126449585,
-0.11438606679439545,
0.290446013212204,
-0.7992894053459167,
0.5245418548583984,
0.7713017463684082,
0.18425986170768738,
-0.2807905972003937,
0.9460957050323486,
-0.24508216977119446,
-0.7414185404777527,
0.3224145472049713,
-0.23175399005413055,
-0.6234936118125916,
0.8612818121910095,
0.4892190098762512,
0.9138188362121582,
-0.2932291626930237,
0.39666157960891724,
0.17625129222869873,
0.18230852484703064,
-0.47697553038597107,
0.3217901587486267,
-0.012944351881742477,
-0.7797699570655823,
-0.03673413768410683,
-0.554021418094635,
-0.46092480421066284,
0.18635837733745575,
-0.5499367117881775,
0.5025482773780823,
-0.02787581831216812,
-0.04396672919392586,
0.2369263768196106,
0.06942326575517654,
-0.9150204062461853,
0.1782434582710266,
-0.0760844424366951,
0.7646355628967285,
-1.0182143449783325,
0.7577129602432251,
0.4262999892234802,
-0.08064815402030945,
-0.520050585269928,
-0.24936281144618988,
0.07980170100927353,
-1.0447065830230713,
0.7007318139076233,
-0.03842240199446678,
0.2234058976173401,
-0.09807167947292328,
-0.551389217376709,
-0.9534152150154114,
0.8039427399635315,
0.06313084810972214,
-0.8869843482971191,
0.2646695673465729,
0.2062826156616211,
0.7023147344589233,
-0.7184725999832153,
0.4901820719242096,
0.6845670938491821,
0.2992534637451172,
-0.3506467342376709,
-0.9581219553947449,
-0.043699391186237335,
-0.15538573265075684,
0.11550458520650864,
0.19969667494297028,
-0.053160279989242554,
0.7648186683654785,
-0.393012136220932,
-0.03961719200015068,
0.23616230487823486,
0.5610122084617615,
0.4295349717140198,
0.7048045992851257,
0.4868687689304352,
0.32097408175468445,
0.8741194605827332,
0.1383027732372284,
0.8082473874092102,
-0.2662551701068878,
0.47876036167144775,
0.8086287379264832,
-0.6093586683273315,
0.9450562596321106,
0.062478598207235336,
-0.4489125609397888,
0.20568054914474487,
0.8774297833442688,
-0.11941710114479065,
0.4024977385997772,
0.6099459528923035,
-0.12843996286392212,
-0.48429444432258606,
0.1660938858985901,
-0.10900551825761795,
0.10644343495368958,
0.3793744146823883,
-0.48771923780441284,
-0.2217050939798355,
-0.09604140371084213,
-0.1816013753414154,
0.3499627411365509,
-0.2677062451839447,
0.6921889185905457,
-0.06633055210113525,
-0.6923153400421143,
0.4693475365638733,
0.1470528095960617,
0.2355407476425171,
-0.4942144453525543,
-0.20502984523773193,
-0.19530250132083893,
0.3502589762210846,
0.049334459006786346,
-0.6106257438659668,
0.23022709786891937,
-0.02681022323668003,
-0.2736310362815857,
-0.2015029937028885,
0.7322736978530884,
-0.7199844717979431,
-0.9656772017478943,
0.3605952560901642,
0.6889916658401489,
0.3551325500011444,
-0.08924733102321625,
-0.3722272217273712,
-0.06214561685919762,
-0.2057914137840271,
-0.24669282138347626,
0.058709923177957535,
0.5876178741455078,
-0.47036489844322205,
1.0204654932022095,
0.45682767033576965,
0.12366586923599243,
0.04938632994890213,
0.0896555483341217,
0.35863399505615234,
-0.796494722366333,
-0.45038968324661255,
-0.6875420808792114,
0.12096764892339706,
0.14859764277935028,
0.3092938959598541,
0.4355218708515167,
0.7203460335731506,
0.7452160120010376,
-0.3880217671394348,
1.1578291654586792,
0.15674810111522675,
0.8258138298988342,
-0.5265001654624939,
0.39478349685668945,
-0.5143944025039673,
0.47096163034439087,
-0.2902844548225403,
-0.8418110013008118,
-0.32241711020469666,
0.8641364574432373,
-0.3379429280757904,
-0.01943536289036274,
0.5654592514038086,
1.3496580123901367,
-0.23618288338184357,
-0.0035910531878471375,
0.225486159324646,
0.3046015202999115,
0.3797191381454468,
0.1994827538728714,
0.6650566458702087,
-0.0506257601082325,
0.2522631287574768,
-0.3086993396282196,
-0.660106360912323,
-0.32499831914901733,
-0.9599425196647644,
-0.8547297120094299,
-0.8946931958198547,
-0.45055854320526123,
-0.030573157593607903,
0.25889164209365845,
1.088600516319275,
0.7840792536735535,
-0.9109400510787964,
-0.6532419323921204,
-0.2676839232444763,
0.19757165014743805,
-0.4547475576400757,
-0.314932256937027,
0.25991007685661316,
-0.3325902819633484,
-0.6760967373847961,
0.5552860498428345,
0.19525189697742462,
-0.16214774549007416,
-0.4471643269062042,
0.020292749628424644,
0.24170473217964172,
0.29057320952415466,
0.36293280124664307,
0.2229773998260498,
-0.6834208965301514,
-0.10243818908929825,
0.18747469782829285,
0.2712893784046173,
-0.22074009478092194,
1.0587189197540283,
-0.5690082907676697,
0.5316146016120911,
0.417440801858902,
0.5407682657241821,
0.3118438720703125,
-0.3459375202655792,
1.0916551351547241,
-0.4597707986831665,
-0.11329919099807739,
0.18231937289237976,
0.5062419772148132,
-0.009270306676626205,
-0.19918027520179749,
0.584353506565094,
0.33438265323638916,
-0.7325642108917236,
-1.1838891506195068,
0.3056710958480835,
-0.7996343970298767,
-0.47413766384124756,
1.026731014251709,
0.23879899084568024,
-0.08399353176355362,
-0.21584446728229523,
-0.20810410380363464,
0.12979981303215027,
-0.2658683955669403,
1.0652073621749878,
0.5300431847572327,
-0.11882057785987854,
-0.2555203437805176,
-0.976324737071991,
0.4498348832130432,
0.1537165641784668,
-0.48663821816444397,
0.2647222578525543,
0.2559215724468231,
0.32615652680397034,
-0.029030311852693558,
0.5693828463554382,
0.16196146607398987,
0.032082054764032364,
-0.1516120582818985,
0.22595982253551483,
0.25546973943710327,
-0.5003839731216431,
-0.05207689106464386,
0.09582362323999405,
-0.022365357726812363,
0.286159485578537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00828v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00828v1
|
Deep Learning Detection Method for Large Language Models-Generated Scientific Content
| 2024-02-27T19:16:39 | 2024-02-27T19:16:39 |
Bushra Alhijawi, Rawan Jarrar, Aseel AbuAlRub, Arwa Bader
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), such as GPT-3 and BERT, reshape how textual
content is written and communicated. These models have the potential to
generate scientific content that is indistinguishable from that written by
humans. Hence, LLMs carry severe consequences for the scientific community,
which relies on the integrity and reliability of publications. This research
paper presents a novel ChatGPT-generated scientific text detection method,
AI-Catcher. AI-Catcher integrates two deep learning models, multilayer
perceptron (MLP) and convolutional neural networks (CNN). The MLP learns the
feature representations of the linguistic and statistical features. The CNN
extracts high-level representations of the sequential patterns from the textual
content. AI-Catcher is a multimodal model that fuses hidden patterns derived
from MLP and CNN. In addition, a new ChatGPT-Generated scientific text dataset
is collected to enhance AI-generated text detection tools, AIGTxt. AIGTxt
contains 3000 records collected from published academic articles across ten
domains and divided into three classes: Human-written, ChatGPT-generated, and
Mixed text. Several experiments are conducted to evaluate the performance of
AI-Catcher. The comparative results demonstrate the capability of AI-Catcher to
distinguish between human-written and ChatGPT-generated scientific text more
accurately than alternative methods. On average, AI-Catcher improved accuracy
by 37.4%.
|
[
-0.14981374144554138,
-1.0260906219482422,
0.49188488721847534,
0.14156189560890198,
-0.41881877183914185,
0.40325167775154114,
-0.32328134775161743,
-0.7016152143478394,
0.07388587296009064,
0.4938097894191742,
-0.19362519681453705,
-0.7687883973121643,
-0.7990257740020752,
0.4876062273979187,
-0.6044963002204895,
0.9639508724212646,
0.24025487899780273,
-0.05819717049598694,
-0.23261673748493195,
0.4146210849285126,
-0.24664723873138428,
-0.24646762013435364,
-0.7395281195640564,
-0.39388081431388855,
0.4250485897064209,
0.2504909932613373,
0.41392889618873596,
0.5435188412666321,
0.7803075313568115,
0.3510439991950989,
-0.15008316934108734,
0.433845192193985,
-0.2321273386478424,
0.22307385504245758,
0.04091667756438255,
-0.4038707911968231,
-0.0954747200012207,
-0.12233079224824905,
0.8592085838317871,
0.15276624262332916,
0.1385926902294159,
-0.07659868896007538,
0.18340688943862915,
0.3676668405532837,
-0.17692461609840393,
0.36617961525917053,
-0.8745237588882446,
0.2868029475212097,
-0.43279245495796204,
-0.3084094226360321,
-0.6542177796363831,
-0.15020766854286194,
-0.019945694133639336,
-0.4444042444229126,
0.4559328258037567,
0.15443198382854462,
0.7252687215805054,
0.18441513180732727,
-0.41444236040115356,
-0.4647705554962158,
-0.4201982021331787,
0.8116334676742554,
-0.9137807488441467,
0.16827858984470367,
0.3070681691169739,
0.13346338272094727,
-0.45193952322006226,
-0.6748889088630676,
-1.1853803396224976,
-0.4527803361415863,
-0.17832191288471222,
0.21924355626106262,
-0.046810299158096313,
-0.19871950149536133,
0.008408721536397934,
0.025280889123678207,
-0.9843306541442871,
0.36391469836235046,
-0.25442832708358765,
-0.1491614282131195,
0.6295892000198364,
-0.04960981756448746,
0.4441179037094116,
-0.3583289086818695,
-0.16672803461551666,
-0.3940839171409607,
-0.5920114517211914,
-0.21684321761131287,
0.27395549416542053,
0.15948358178138733,
0.06896641850471497,
0.6047295928001404,
0.13059741258621216,
0.23329868912696838,
-0.21879498660564423,
-0.19113686680793762,
0.2531055212020874,
-0.2090311050415039,
-0.031149493530392647,
0.3493652939796448,
1.2832344770431519,
0.10122829675674438,
0.24265743792057037,
0.1274760216474533,
0.026107972487807274,
-0.05383792519569397,
-0.14162395894527435,
-0.9336898326873779,
-0.3153579533100128,
-0.10382341593503952,
-0.6661749482154846,
-0.5339162945747375,
-0.09639724344015121,
-0.6295986175537109,
-0.7380567193031311,
0.016960011795163155,
-0.04811495915055275,
-0.49387112259864807,
-0.39231741428375244,
0.18338793516159058,
0.01589309051632881,
0.20077592134475708,
0.23737847805023193,
-0.8062645792961121,
-0.0034324571024626493,
0.8589573502540588,
1.1194894313812256,
-0.2882130742073059,
-0.13844239711761475,
-0.4269806146621704,
0.09393662214279175,
-0.06335091590881348,
1.0967004299163818,
-0.5724614262580872,
-0.21512925624847412,
-0.28548771142959595,
-0.1165228933095932,
0.07047662138938904,
-0.3040800392627716,
0.4889328181743622,
-0.6695366501808167,
0.2303808331489563,
0.24899955093860626,
-0.7953725457191467,
-0.3558267056941986,
0.3835233747959137,
-0.6505173444747925,
0.8605945110321045,
-0.39091524481773376,
-0.8406803607940674,
0.5455958843231201,
-0.6584975123405457,
-0.5104921460151672,
0.4573281705379486,
-0.25598856806755066,
-0.9296853542327881,
-0.33776628971099854,
0.4012854993343353,
0.6606229543685913,
-0.1795715093612671,
0.578781247138977,
-0.40716153383255005,
-0.3582667410373688,
0.5469301342964172,
-0.9631903767585754,
0.6827570199966431,
0.3682008683681488,
-0.26363125443458557,
0.06838510185480118,
-0.7566030621528625,
-0.16311021149158478,
0.20470833778381348,
-0.43431469798088074,
-0.3729284703731537,
0.299293577671051,
0.22822539508342743,
-0.09944556653499603,
0.12027544528245926,
-0.9968879222869873,
0.298951655626297,
-0.30452606081962585,
0.5070796012878418,
0.522098183631897,
0.04628615081310272,
0.013626900501549244,
0.06706445664167404,
0.2386041134595871,
-0.039054255932569504,
-0.1204589307308197,
-0.31278344988822937,
-0.7095133662223816,
-0.3468022346496582,
-0.48167306184768677,
0.1935904622077942,
0.564206600189209,
-0.7132375240325928,
0.801148533821106,
-0.01663186401128769,
-0.5352146029472351,
-0.5421319603919983,
0.10512476414442062,
0.2973988652229309,
0.421171635389328,
0.4351530373096466,
-0.14301910996437073,
-0.43446674942970276,
-0.6171839833259583,
-0.4189258813858032,
-0.07433325797319412,
-0.1459536850452423,
0.12996987998485565,
0.7975786924362183,
-0.3168758749961853,
0.5950191617012024,
-0.3829665780067444,
-0.3424421548843384,
0.033304303884506226,
0.43800172209739685,
0.4467223286628723,
0.59296053647995,
0.40764448046684265,
-0.9221006035804749,
-0.8794622421264648,
0.2752487361431122,
-1.0115753412246704,
0.05760439485311508,
-0.07891099900007248,
0.2353462427854538,
0.14494159817695618,
0.693992555141449,
-0.6830790638923645,
0.29000186920166016,
0.3642212748527527,
-0.3958994746208191,
0.4923725724220276,
-0.148626908659935,
0.22400817275047302,
-0.9418574571609497,
0.162643164396286,
0.2017473429441452,
-0.2962963879108429,
-0.38759714365005493,
-0.06308910250663757,
0.14823660254478455,
-0.07467170804738998,
-0.3067590594291687,
0.5383639335632324,
-0.3012332320213318,
0.3763425648212433,
-0.5890805721282959,
-0.023916326463222504,
0.09161657840013504,
-0.019450457766652107,
0.3442534804344177,
0.7465588450431824,
0.22109954059123993,
-0.32860857248306274,
0.38211601972579956,
0.31672289967536926,
-0.5855012536048889,
0.21298950910568237,
-0.6805298328399658,
0.18221233785152435,
-0.3114889860153198,
0.4891429543495178,
-1.0963431596755981,
-0.20575039088726044,
0.405944287776947,
-0.6522156000137329,
0.34759530425071716,
-0.016215315088629723,
-0.8032363057136536,
-0.3775745630264282,
-0.2459731251001358,
0.38250023126602173,
0.2915092408657074,
-0.4770241379737854,
0.39696627855300903,
0.09804630279541016,
-0.5002870559692383,
-0.6981931924819946,
-0.6846062541007996,
0.4423535168170929,
0.0167501550167799,
-0.5243273377418518,
0.23912853002548218,
-0.09987045079469681,
-0.07047943025827408,
0.0984988883137703,
0.09330534189939499,
0.005656518507748842,
0.14415836334228516,
0.03374005854129791,
0.2573891580104828,
-0.3370463252067566,
0.1617821753025055,
0.3160742521286011,
-0.04322657734155655,
-0.023716462776064873,
-0.21734261512756348,
0.7052619457244873,
-0.152548149228096,
-0.35796597599983215,
-0.626789927482605,
0.3549466133117676,
0.48027509450912476,
-0.23222289979457855,
0.7390100955963135,
1.0938390493392944,
-0.1842387616634369,
0.02427135407924652,
-0.489013671875,
-0.3256073296070099,
-0.5183089971542358,
0.5726484656333923,
-0.09339474141597748,
-0.8867580890655518,
0.2340250462293625,
0.27848517894744873,
-0.02835831791162491,
0.5554944276809692,
0.5134971737861633,
-0.23846955597400665,
1.1841849088668823,
0.42187780141830444,
-0.15779978036880493,
0.4694928228855133,
-0.05691654607653618,
0.47504791617393494,
-0.5996009707450867,
-0.3544299006462097,
-0.8095139861106873,
-0.11827730387449265,
-0.5212554335594177,
-0.14989420771598816,
0.21183648705482483,
-0.17282941937446594,
-0.3783068358898163,
0.20243804156780243,
-1.014373540878296,
0.6987576484680176,
0.7852782011032104,
0.19997915625572205,
0.673577606678009,
0.16721533238887787,
0.08542601019144058,
0.026551295071840286,
-0.32769614458084106,
-0.6751922369003296,
1.1119369268417358,
0.3474881649017334,
0.6973066329956055,
-0.10740545392036438,
0.5691449046134949,
0.514645516872406,
0.5402327179908752,
-0.6869004368782043,
0.41205963492393494,
-0.2398843616247177,
-0.431178480386734,
-0.2819870710372925,
-0.4841533899307251,
-1.0725078582763672,
0.4540538787841797,
-0.4940606951713562,
-0.459400475025177,
-0.1630590260028839,
-0.08232332020998001,
-0.08535937964916229,
0.4440838396549225,
-0.6789884567260742,
0.562279999256134,
-0.289268434047699,
-0.09465166926383972,
-0.25760143995285034,
-0.4307445287704468,
0.39454203844070435,
-0.19195933640003204,
0.14488071203231812,
-0.21469815075397491,
0.202370285987854,
0.8037391304969788,
0.11462408304214478,
0.967753529548645,
-0.11022932082414627,
-0.1283867508172989,
0.32763704657554626,
0.10664303600788116,
0.68947833776474,
0.4229806959629059,
-0.016708340495824814,
0.323912650346756,
-0.12181336432695389,
-0.21430763602256775,
-0.027398731559515,
0.6432257890701294,
-0.7381656169891357,
-0.5091195702552795,
-0.7184361815452576,
-0.6606382131576538,
0.28640326857566833,
0.6624617576599121,
0.2613030672073364,
-0.09373965859413147,
-0.03695405647158623,
0.47059130668640137,
0.6794732213020325,
-0.5870146155357361,
0.6449228525161743,
0.7892863750457764,
0.003647773526608944,
-0.2167890965938568,
0.8439651727676392,
-0.3052651882171631,
-0.21857531368732452,
0.5334340929985046,
0.2692188620567322,
-0.1765294224023819,
-0.9764547348022461,
-0.22644484043121338,
0.15554334223270416,
-0.3168588876724243,
-0.5563807487487793,
-0.9327316880226135,
-0.4318966865539551,
-0.5675598382949829,
-0.013345293700695038,
-0.11727192252874374,
0.06553570926189423,
-0.48372408747673035,
0.0485316701233387,
0.5101904273033142,
0.44350361824035645,
0.19701199233531952,
0.4451489746570587,
-0.9353333711624146,
0.29715943336486816,
-0.12559276819229126,
0.11027783155441284,
0.059404727071523666,
-0.2856875956058502,
-0.013115567155182362,
0.0772104412317276,
-0.37559500336647034,
-0.4450429379940033,
0.7780060172080994,
0.20682194828987122,
0.2992734909057617,
0.5318169593811035,
-0.2602488398551941,
-0.0011197056155651808,
-0.48808151483535767,
0.6349136233329773,
0.2864401936531067,
-0.6889472603797913,
0.4120049774646759,
-0.4154461920261383,
0.3074263334274292,
0.2632100284099579,
0.29521581530570984,
-0.621738612651825,
-0.6109906435012817,
-0.18444311618804932,
-0.6770122051239014,
0.3711278438568115,
0.03049156442284584,
0.17579154670238495,
-0.1586211919784546,
0.22139234840869904,
0.3738943040370941,
0.1911858320236206,
-1.099299430847168,
0.20020586252212524,
-0.17805922031402588,
-0.47247669100761414,
-0.08596961200237274,
0.006402045022696257,
0.19289752840995789,
-0.1345488280057907,
0.7458595037460327,
-0.18392416834831238,
0.25421324372291565,
0.14499406516551971,
-0.1424860656261444,
0.09318343549966812,
0.1357908993959427,
0.5729997158050537,
0.17017081379890442,
-0.17937126755714417,
0.1745835840702057,
-0.27821940183639526,
-0.9400587677955627,
-0.04799482226371765,
0.3188084065914154,
-0.4876892566680908,
-0.061072345823049545,
0.6851087212562561,
0.4309622645378113,
-0.27691414952278137,
-0.7168578505516052,
0.42039626836776733,
-0.16370777785778046,
-0.2574767470359802,
-0.32110145688056946,
0.16667307913303375,
-0.040481407195329666,
0.5102092027664185,
0.6121063828468323,
0.2491329461336136,
0.37016260623931885,
-0.3626985549926758,
0.19943834841251373,
0.692257285118103,
-0.04769088700413704,
-0.1469721496105194,
0.6434247493743896,
-0.04503145068883896,
-0.22034096717834473,
0.7483201622962952,
0.0005223356420174241,
-0.49549993872642517,
0.8268965482711792,
0.7234800457954407,
0.6695371270179749,
-0.035524964332580566,
0.3114856481552124,
0.17269764840602875,
0.2752329111099243,
0.049543511122465134,
0.0712701827287674,
-0.05757748335599899,
-0.8656620979309082,
-0.6619290113449097,
-0.7252481579780579,
-0.30101096630096436,
0.4535958766937256,
-0.14367838203907013,
0.2076999396085739,
-0.3014468252658844,
0.06906569749116898,
0.4456680715084076,
0.1546347737312317,
-0.6067953109741211,
-0.12335377931594849,
0.2778584659099579,
0.6262583136558533,
-0.8225613832473755,
0.8229784965515137,
0.2507621645927429,
-0.3308910131454468,
-0.4046810567378998,
-0.18174047768115997,
0.04979785904288292,
-0.8721848130226135,
0.5796153545379639,
0.2834075689315796,
-0.028683476150035858,
0.037868253886699677,
-0.9316562414169312,
-0.8402718901634216,
0.8574610352516174,
0.15210644900798798,
-0.8204019665718079,
0.2105688899755478,
0.0931968167424202,
0.6174735426902771,
-0.08481656759977341,
0.34550929069519043,
0.31169790029525757,
0.7479454278945923,
-0.004158482886850834,
-0.751130998134613,
-0.026093805208802223,
-0.39582929015159607,
-0.4258410632610321,
0.11962588876485825,
-0.5783147215843201,
0.7614733576774597,
0.1147531196475029,
-0.0488148108124733,
0.2214241623878479,
0.7499725818634033,
0.5286044478416443,
0.42153283953666687,
0.21819312870502472,
0.24340103566646576,
0.992996335029602,
0.014433912932872772,
0.7563633322715759,
0.1504381150007248,
0.45587074756622314,
0.7987914681434631,
-0.4669141471385956,
0.6600484848022461,
0.3645949959754944,
-0.03965175524353981,
0.47568243741989136,
0.5568752288818359,
-0.7365090847015381,
0.505768895149231,
0.26522091031074524,
-0.5379014015197754,
0.04404545575380325,
-0.17034903168678284,
-0.5016649961471558,
0.5712988972663879,
0.5716111063957214,
-0.503938615322113,
-0.07575317472219467,
0.423052042722702,
0.2507575452327728,
0.10548118501901627,
-0.1901945322751999,
0.7811727523803711,
0.17282801866531372,
-0.650759220123291,
0.34208422899246216,
0.13439376652240753,
0.9969193935394287,
-0.39887735247612,
-0.23359709978103638,
0.004272032994776964,
0.4620206654071808,
-0.2505834102630615,
-1.044682502746582,
0.04223271459341049,
0.15947574377059937,
-0.13768959045410156,
0.04745260253548622,
1.0667954683303833,
-0.5471515655517578,
-0.6199687719345093,
0.11511069536209106,
0.17836350202560425,
0.28694596886634827,
-0.13758224248886108,
-0.5741979479789734,
-0.019871070981025696,
-0.14935101568698883,
-0.4932134747505188,
0.17057250440120697,
0.4303862750530243,
-0.042850058525800705,
0.6020840406417847,
1.0003437995910645,
0.06355711817741394,
0.009902875870466232,
0.0647503063082695,
0.6530209183692932,
-0.5044952034950256,
-0.38092243671417236,
-1.0477714538574219,
0.00989642646163702,
-0.3757554292678833,
-0.020257355645298958,
0.7949594259262085,
0.6851733326911926,
0.7014670968055725,
-0.23822656273841858,
1.0395427942276,
-0.04188186302781105,
0.3568130135536194,
-0.5360345840454102,
1.1914165019989014,
-0.14579838514328003,
0.18123255670070648,
-0.35356244444847107,
-0.8263626098632812,
-0.8802223205566406,
0.7043424248695374,
-0.10413286834955215,
-0.1799042522907257,
0.7324126958847046,
0.5888205170631409,
-0.10831210017204285,
0.1432267278432846,
-0.006243405397981405,
0.22999022901058197,
0.8051342964172363,
0.3433718681335449,
0.7817916870117188,
-0.317423939704895,
0.6275317668914795,
0.09683717787265778,
-0.16292919218540192,
-0.1906481236219406,
-1.0462592840194702,
-1.1510629653930664,
-0.27820995450019836,
-0.30071794986724854,
-0.2666665017604828,
-0.024106301367282867,
0.5897433161735535,
0.5744948983192444,
-1.0038211345672607,
0.12528003752231598,
-0.29907190799713135,
0.08689620345830917,
-0.1745501309633255,
-0.2923058867454529,
0.7964125275611877,
-0.21458221971988678,
-0.7118239402770996,
0.5501719117164612,
0.18924134969711304,
0.00487428018823266,
-0.20967397093772888,
0.17667889595031738,
-0.3967253565788269,
-0.08277643471956253,
0.642733097076416,
0.276862233877182,
-0.4711693227291107,
-0.2852812707424164,
0.08301365375518799,
-0.17039579153060913,
0.003487466601654887,
0.578151524066925,
-0.602901816368103,
0.24871879816055298,
0.5392076373100281,
0.7276857495307922,
0.8717788457870483,
-0.3434976041316986,
0.17881576716899872,
-0.6920045018196106,
0.23452895879745483,
0.5520415306091309,
0.31478098034858704,
0.3094639480113983,
-0.7316315174102783,
0.34035372734069824,
0.27202191948890686,
-0.9032158255577087,
-0.8377320766448975,
-0.14454619586467743,
-0.9559504985809326,
-0.5361199975013733,
0.8204615712165833,
-0.08068273961544037,
-0.17943315207958221,
-0.0774681493639946,
-0.2559686303138733,
0.3666672110557556,
-0.5979582071304321,
1.1188040971755981,
0.560147225856781,
0.018466051667928696,
-0.2470623403787613,
-0.520015299320221,
0.26836976408958435,
0.2226806879043579,
-0.7290674448013306,
-0.24067015945911407,
0.32274332642555237,
0.14453142881393433,
0.1902778297662735,
0.33181846141815186,
-0.1611170917749405,
0.16529220342636108,
-0.06335284560918808,
0.2761511206626892,
-0.35666173696517944,
-0.3017965853214264,
0.103152796626091,
0.2334236353635788,
-0.21122266352176666,
0.08433225750923157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00827v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00827v1
|
Self-Refinement of Language Models from External Proxy Metrics Feedback
| 2024-02-27T19:13:01 | 2024-02-27T19:13:01 |
Keshav Ramji, Young-Suk Lee, Ramón Fernandez Astudillo, Md Arafat Sultan, Tahira Naseem, Asim Munawar, Radu Florian, Salim Roukos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
It is often desirable for Large Language Models (LLMs) to capture multiple
objectives when providing a response. In document-grounded response generation,
for example, agent responses are expected to be relevant to a user's query
while also being grounded in a given document. In this paper, we introduce
Proxy Metric-based Self-Refinement (ProMiSe), which enables an LLM to refine
its own initial response along key dimensions of quality guided by external
metrics feedback, yielding an overall better final response. ProMiSe leverages
feedback on response quality through principle-specific proxy metrics, and
iteratively refines its response one principle at a time. We apply ProMiSe to
open source language models Flan-T5-XXL and Llama-2-13B-Chat, to evaluate its
performance on document-grounded question answering datasets, MultiDoc2Dial and
QuAC, demonstrating that self-refinement improves response quality. We further
show that fine-tuning Llama-2-13B-Chat on the synthetic dialogue data generated
by ProMiSe yields significant performance improvements over the zero-shot
baseline as well as a supervised fine-tuned model on human annotated data.
|
[
-0.31516969203948975,
-0.5082935690879822,
0.6653923988342285,
-0.013655541464686394,
0.004268107935786247,
0.3425482511520386,
-0.13544894754886627,
-0.4951062798500061,
0.3895987868309021,
0.7380220293998718,
-0.7250871062278748,
-0.48518043756484985,
-0.21709086000919342,
0.15491893887519836,
-0.4085839092731476,
0.9782801866531372,
0.09288220852613449,
0.11871686577796936,
-0.2084520161151886,
-0.2443884313106537,
-0.6311768889427185,
-0.2963842451572418,
-0.7363294363021851,
-0.2183723747730255,
0.4909093677997589,
0.6763099431991577,
0.7210100889205933,
0.7730364799499512,
0.4049285650253296,
0.3516780138015747,
0.2793017029762268,
0.19435258209705353,
-0.6500089168548584,
0.20078082382678986,
-0.4526086747646332,
-0.6279333233833313,
-0.4984070956707001,
0.11083566397428513,
0.5578634142875671,
0.47494736313819885,
-0.07769345492124557,
0.48723873496055603,
0.25439512729644775,
0.5832063555717468,
-0.2285510152578354,
0.24019160866737366,
-0.7141196727752686,
-0.3061160743236542,
0.11175467073917389,
-0.08015532046556473,
-0.24700582027435303,
-0.21699583530426025,
0.06336183100938797,
-0.6755449175834656,
0.7402582764625549,
0.04923401027917862,
0.9218499660491943,
0.3125952482223511,
-0.04754439741373062,
-0.30077898502349854,
-0.6670824885368347,
0.511890709400177,
-0.9267358779907227,
0.4090729355812073,
0.341495543718338,
0.45954495668411255,
-0.4747816026210785,
-0.857403039932251,
-0.48763737082481384,
-0.35618990659713745,
-0.2220153659582138,
0.14478833973407745,
0.19513148069381714,
0.09416135400533676,
-0.04403473809361458,
0.5026643872261047,
-0.3078113794326782,
0.33999550342559814,
-0.5043261051177979,
-0.4250362515449524,
0.6594694256782532,
0.20501820743083954,
-0.10320846736431122,
-0.0011981078423559666,
-0.1546546369791031,
-0.16385607421398163,
-0.6952402591705322,
0.21435698866844177,
0.4588983356952667,
0.7611852884292603,
0.05917781963944435,
0.5076444149017334,
-0.7090166807174683,
0.2498323619365692,
0.10339446365833282,
-0.263306200504303,
0.1797599494457245,
-0.37998104095458984,
0.09062571078538895,
-0.2876995801925659,
0.7408462762832642,
0.35194820165634155,
0.11226508766412735,
-0.07822408527135849,
-0.38182345032691956,
0.08225837349891663,
0.4193425178527832,
-0.7364705801010132,
0.07788492739200592,
0.5574641227722168,
-0.5377572774887085,
-0.10677090287208557,
-0.08365984261035919,
-0.7237856984138489,
-0.2035631239414215,
-0.4875211715698242,
0.29710501432418823,
-0.20240843296051025,
-0.3174237012863159,
0.08114197105169296,
0.21502785384655,
0.11274862289428711,
0.5405747294425964,
-0.5784950852394104,
0.5157991647720337,
0.7566992044448853,
0.8012067079544067,
0.1428157538175583,
-0.2869938313961029,
-0.8282678127288818,
-0.16693666577339172,
-0.5562450289726257,
0.8065218329429626,
-0.3370770812034607,
-0.361614853143692,
0.2743304967880249,
0.014440436847507954,
0.32424819469451904,
-0.34869781136512756,
0.6253156065940857,
-0.37733685970306396,
0.26740890741348267,
-0.21625906229019165,
-0.4973048269748688,
0.00455891527235508,
0.2943360209465027,
-0.5624313950538635,
1.0166212320327759,
0.0836493968963623,
-0.45009738206863403,
0.1004224643111229,
-0.5502528548240662,
-0.15299920737743378,
-0.09062733501195908,
-0.182164266705513,
-0.18498677015304565,
0.4972677230834961,
0.1915615200996399,
0.2465635985136032,
-0.6497207283973694,
0.2671886682510376,
-0.5175235867500305,
-0.2196195423603058,
0.22735804319381714,
-0.25558432936668396,
-0.029754120856523514,
0.4104692041873932,
-0.1675792634487152,
0.3370349705219269,
-1.017327070236206,
0.3264142572879791,
0.16757631301879883,
-0.08976906538009644,
0.036810316145420074,
0.12490428239107132,
-0.3966778814792633,
0.28266045451164246,
0.3247382938861847,
-0.7897322773933411,
0.06304764747619629,
-0.7347795963287354,
0.3734898567199707,
0.7088895440101624,
-0.2769933342933655,
0.2168733775615692,
-0.43725472688674927,
0.44626978039741516,
-0.16443808376789093,
0.12211983650922775,
-0.6408842206001282,
-0.3438263237476349,
-0.9826967120170593,
-0.11925414204597473,
0.22470822930335999,
0.12556788325309753,
-0.4953521192073822,
0.011413284577429295,
-0.3143256902694702,
-0.4335289001464844,
-1.249617099761963,
0.2815980017185211,
0.57156902551651,
0.6704638600349426,
0.4536841809749603,
-0.3896699845790863,
-0.19735130667686462,
-1.0729758739471436,
-0.2580901086330414,
-0.6331326961517334,
-0.10175908356904984,
0.21922096610069275,
0.2062397599220276,
0.07352445274591446,
1.211603045463562,
-0.4959935247898102,
-0.5202975869178772,
0.03478151187300682,
0.16680288314819336,
0.15043388307094574,
0.2925463914871216,
0.3785379230976105,
-0.40238597989082336,
-0.3830474615097046,
-0.14006307721138,
-0.3566236197948456,
-0.538806676864624,
-0.09170155227184296,
0.06994215399026871,
0.2510659098625183,
0.5918205380439758,
-0.4669893682003021,
0.39772829413414,
0.5423918962478638,
-0.2707558870315552,
0.5446149706840515,
-0.30817943811416626,
0.17393730580806732,
-1.0951467752456665,
-0.04818161576986313,
-0.18663905560970306,
-0.3736034333705902,
-0.5893861055374146,
0.32812291383743286,
0.0483689047396183,
-0.12242735177278519,
-0.40912750363349915,
0.958125650882721,
-0.3508962392807007,
-0.13292759656906128,
-0.7087647914886475,
0.39296817779541016,
0.12865199148654938,
0.31434181332588196,
-0.04253575950860977,
0.7351782321929932,
0.41181981563568115,
-0.5799007415771484,
0.25868740677833557,
0.23429547250270844,
0.06715711951255798,
0.41195058822631836,
-0.8985018134117126,
0.42089933156967163,
-0.22976164519786835,
0.3322784900665283,
-1.363816261291504,
-0.10319705307483673,
0.16040721535682678,
-0.5345495343208313,
-0.037386998534202576,
-0.2134985327720642,
-0.5494413375854492,
-0.5311883687973022,
-0.28225967288017273,
0.1065969318151474,
0.3340376913547516,
-0.7221693396568298,
0.6055889129638672,
-0.028405241668224335,
-0.036354243755340576,
-0.4257698357105255,
-0.4140297472476959,
-0.02648618072271347,
-0.01157582737505436,
-0.611737072467804,
0.3522704541683197,
-0.3504992425441742,
-0.17287832498550415,
-0.07664821296930313,
-0.17934033274650574,
0.2042909860610962,
-0.07387024909257889,
0.3202953636646271,
-0.08339979499578476,
-0.17258217930793762,
0.29156455397605896,
-0.060201145708560944,
-0.2713432013988495,
0.03166868910193443,
-0.42370134592056274,
0.6535905599594116,
-0.14696325361728668,
-0.47141650319099426,
-0.4899430572986603,
0.2112164944410324,
0.634685218334198,
-0.45837709307670593,
0.5778157114982605,
0.4342692196369171,
-0.06774595379829407,
-0.1371936947107315,
-0.9694427251815796,
-0.5293749570846558,
-0.5358251929283142,
-0.04161250963807106,
-0.8854313492774963,
-1.1634094715118408,
0.9180088639259338,
-0.08376295864582062,
0.1769091933965683,
0.47051382064819336,
0.40970396995544434,
0.045444000512361526,
0.8606815338134766,
0.6770870089530945,
-0.08327378332614899,
0.18710047006607056,
-0.06500670313835144,
0.051063962280750275,
-0.6541274189949036,
-0.09988779574632645,
-0.8527180552482605,
-0.02118060737848282,
-0.8281997442245483,
-0.2560425400733948,
-0.003457837738096714,
-0.027330253273248672,
-0.01967857964336872,
0.2664632797241211,
-0.2381017804145813,
0.2309747040271759,
0.5926361680030823,
-0.06381616741418839,
0.31017398834228516,
-0.0683053731918335,
-0.34864258766174316,
-0.07927464693784714,
-0.3764105439186096,
-0.6472790837287903,
1.0594452619552612,
0.8052589297294617,
0.8474525809288025,
0.06337040662765503,
0.7793267965316772,
0.08943920582532883,
0.3251647353172302,
-0.5225476622581482,
0.5892471671104431,
0.04651439189910889,
-0.45552751421928406,
-0.19586996734142303,
-0.5285927653312683,
-0.784758985042572,
0.3959536552429199,
-0.015324710868299007,
-0.6753553152084351,
-0.1589168906211853,
0.24496877193450928,
-0.25227925181388855,
-0.10112737864255905,
-0.5618715882301331,
0.5806143283843994,
-0.10129047185182571,
-0.39456233382225037,
-0.4713239073753357,
-0.4684409499168396,
0.035686030983924866,
-0.2328086495399475,
0.1880725920200348,
-0.6514809131622314,
0.13731108605861664,
0.30743128061294556,
-0.6747618913650513,
1.0108222961425781,
-0.13151563704013824,
-0.4641529321670532,
0.5369440913200378,
0.3671621084213257,
0.5187033414840698,
0.29699796438217163,
-0.16952039301395416,
0.11917149275541306,
0.12001938372850418,
-0.2452615201473236,
-0.8970608711242676,
0.8295230269432068,
-0.641545832157135,
-1.134966254234314,
-0.07613696902990341,
-0.3184413015842438,
-0.341373473405838,
0.2644024193286896,
-0.012762508355081081,
0.4536649286746979,
-0.13975246250629425,
0.014947446063160896,
0.10021620988845825,
-0.20650018751621246,
0.41806191205978394,
1.270339012145996,
-0.555536687374115,
-0.49307626485824585,
0.5114401578903198,
0.02382293902337551,
0.5251405835151672,
0.14556071162223816,
0.3609370291233063,
-0.6514438986778259,
-0.36571210622787476,
-0.31039851903915405,
0.43087413907051086,
-0.6744111180305481,
-0.43981197476387024,
-0.2956570088863373,
-0.24569745361804962,
-0.7302129864692688,
0.17918971180915833,
-0.8461683392524719,
-0.4607868790626526,
-0.25199100375175476,
-0.12655915319919586,
0.3346171975135803,
0.6301754117012024,
-0.12576135993003845,
0.5321480631828308,
-0.8274475336074829,
0.4210880696773529,
-0.01143310684710741,
0.627524733543396,
-0.21014630794525146,
-0.879917562007904,
-0.10513785481452942,
0.3088688254356384,
-0.2036437839269638,
-0.5234106779098511,
0.39707085490226746,
0.3205224275588989,
0.46247220039367676,
0.20158298313617706,
0.17557509243488312,
0.7436274886131287,
-0.7377116084098816,
0.7368916273117065,
-0.03501687943935394,
-0.8242394924163818,
0.7973232865333557,
-0.26802682876586914,
0.43173110485076904,
0.6192864179611206,
0.16128304600715637,
-0.486386775970459,
-0.8257006406784058,
-0.5339833498001099,
-0.6149525046348572,
0.5988218188285828,
0.24163176119327545,
0.5278408527374268,
-0.05713299661874771,
0.8904610276222229,
0.26590093970298767,
0.27480125427246094,
-0.5249434113502502,
-0.17146627604961395,
-0.20221397280693054,
-0.09732401371002197,
-0.1339147835969925,
-0.1938520222902298,
-0.1867399662733078,
0.12226755172014236,
0.6151076555252075,
-0.6887810230255127,
0.16460473835468292,
0.3196529448032379,
0.29203730821609497,
-0.27017074823379517,
0.3160422742366791,
0.32125556468963623,
0.638641893863678,
-0.05761593207716942,
-0.11568037420511246,
0.025062320753932,
-0.042955994606018066,
0.27644655108451843,
0.047696348279714584,
-0.06274502724409103,
-0.13145479559898376,
0.21511264145374298,
0.5485069751739502,
-0.09614778310060501,
-0.5083602666854858,
0.21037817001342773,
-0.2985863983631134,
0.0041625299490988255,
-0.22339674830436707,
0.1836228370666504,
-0.28992143273353577,
0.40119025111198425,
0.33057576417922974,
-0.39032530784606934,
0.13889369368553162,
-0.5983024835586548,
0.2753079831600189,
0.44728171825408936,
-0.16707433760166168,
-0.33279216289520264,
0.7095217108726501,
0.17474786937236786,
-0.40802669525146484,
0.536868155002594,
-0.09046149253845215,
-0.26901090145111084,
0.29375067353248596,
0.9122506976127625,
0.8492136001586914,
-0.37535616755485535,
0.5388493537902832,
0.5043637752532959,
0.13085415959358215,
-0.09005031734704971,
0.2332385629415512,
0.15934135019779205,
-0.8379071354866028,
-0.5603580474853516,
-0.7460520267486572,
-0.31137073040008545,
0.3514648377895355,
-0.5748995542526245,
0.15383215248584747,
-0.5902402400970459,
-0.37531352043151855,
-0.25368085503578186,
0.07826605439186096,
-0.7307109832763672,
0.3854060769081116,
-0.19772900640964508,
0.8169475197792053,
-0.43513554334640503,
0.6901225447654724,
0.4954581558704376,
-0.5668532848358154,
-0.8390082716941833,
0.1073608249425888,
0.06433213502168655,
-0.7874571084976196,
0.6680168509483337,
0.35939884185791016,
-0.4385994076728821,
0.01636037789285183,
-0.3963156044483185,
-1.2944133281707764,
0.8578111529350281,
0.5775779485702515,
-0.7066030502319336,
0.07551178336143494,
0.5280100107192993,
0.9359880685806274,
-0.5017295479774475,
0.4165620803833008,
0.4955996572971344,
0.03814629837870598,
0.1435302048921585,
-1.2414416074752808,
0.06693083047866821,
-0.13989025354385376,
0.17652180790901184,
-0.03718895837664604,
-1.0773873329162598,
0.42195215821266174,
-0.04573674499988556,
-0.23741982877254486,
0.36397239565849304,
1.0644301176071167,
0.07591234147548676,
0.021770738065242767,
0.32198622822761536,
0.6300303936004639,
0.6520847678184509,
-0.13528664410114288,
0.926170289516449,
-0.5892850160598755,
0.25436899065971375,
1.40053391456604,
-0.3511591851711273,
0.9390270709991455,
0.20395135879516602,
0.11113173514604568,
0.456468403339386,
0.5350821018218994,
0.22399351000785828,
0.3591082990169525,
0.28087955713272095,
-0.001076974323950708,
0.11174487322568893,
-0.34300318360328674,
-0.15978945791721344,
0.6367747187614441,
0.35663098096847534,
-0.14980971813201904,
-0.20847943425178528,
-0.11353439837694168,
-0.1349489837884903,
0.3403439521789551,
-0.32635706663131714,
0.732789158821106,
0.02439238131046295,
-1.0173968076705933,
0.5113264322280884,
0.2554619312286377,
0.24824069440364838,
-0.4994826018810272,
-0.003546680323779583,
-0.6702091097831726,
0.27708324790000916,
-0.0671263337135315,
-0.7052024602890015,
0.1818162351846695,
-0.07102018594741821,
-0.06589566916227341,
-0.12769395112991333,
0.6620513796806335,
-0.482580304145813,
-0.2437385767698288,
0.6677031517028809,
0.45067352056503296,
0.05217723548412323,
-0.04641520604491234,
-0.813165545463562,
0.10932774841785431,
-0.17840979993343353,
-0.15388043224811554,
0.17816320061683655,
0.33810028433799744,
0.10039196163415909,
1.1080865859985352,
0.7199299931526184,
0.09340343624353409,
0.01582796312868595,
0.36259037256240845,
0.9043649435043335,
-0.4101603627204895,
-0.5468926429748535,
-0.5519493222236633,
0.48513373732566833,
0.11660834401845932,
-0.1871240735054016,
0.7494309544563293,
0.3982042372226715,
0.956247091293335,
0.054547786712646484,
0.46724313497543335,
0.2973591387271881,
0.9545696377754211,
-0.7003478407859802,
0.3847988545894623,
-0.5941635966300964,
0.34822916984558105,
-0.0903240218758583,
-0.9611267447471619,
0.04190497472882271,
0.3576032817363739,
-0.09760591387748718,
0.13418595492839813,
0.5169863104820251,
1.0504417419433594,
0.09856685996055603,
-0.27321502566337585,
0.36787843704223633,
0.17030777037143707,
0.7083193063735962,
-0.12535373866558075,
0.7520747780799866,
-0.3660787343978882,
0.5207565426826477,
-0.09450263530015945,
0.02262442745268345,
-0.051536642014980316,
-0.7078020572662354,
-0.796590268611908,
-0.7470638751983643,
-0.42896223068237305,
-0.579470694065094,
0.05885741114616394,
0.8351859450340271,
0.7691411375999451,
-0.725411057472229,
-0.3148030638694763,
-0.013927924446761608,
-0.29378843307495117,
0.18930847942829132,
-0.27598807215690613,
0.20972681045532227,
-1.0479034185409546,
-0.6611153483390808,
0.7159718871116638,
0.11220267415046692,
0.06338028609752655,
-0.5173963904380798,
-0.16095633804798126,
0.20797725021839142,
0.3879166543483734,
0.3432283401489258,
0.4387495517730713,
-1.0442005395889282,
-0.5379989743232727,
-0.04245343059301376,
-0.11885761469602585,
0.23371487855911255,
0.8815085291862488,
-0.9522767663002014,
0.7002997398376465,
0.1669173240661621,
0.7020947337150574,
0.4543807804584503,
0.20665094256401062,
0.8106876611709595,
-0.9686434268951416,
0.0533662885427475,
-0.17450278997421265,
0.2914867401123047,
0.3802306056022644,
-0.4098968505859375,
0.6070964336395264,
-0.07051686942577362,
-0.5486397743225098,
-0.5361745953559875,
0.3231711983680725,
-0.4063483774662018,
-0.17595668137073517,
1.0613980293273926,
-0.31882500648498535,
-0.12322430312633514,
0.08509594947099686,
-0.34486109018325806,
0.14299625158309937,
-0.5955432653427124,
0.8384554982185364,
0.7359257340431213,
-0.010743636637926102,
-0.289255291223526,
-0.5429551005363464,
0.4774242043495178,
0.5179775953292847,
-0.8700730204582214,
0.22349290549755096,
0.7222210168838501,
0.36069387197494507,
0.4199579656124115,
0.9024093747138977,
-0.1287223845720291,
-0.04059452936053276,
-0.17931391298770905,
-0.03212011232972145,
0.044231582432985306,
-0.650648295879364,
-0.3049536347389221,
0.14540626108646393,
0.3998730480670929,
-0.1035454049706459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17840v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17840v2
|
Follow My Instruction and Spill the Beans: Scalable Data Extraction from Retrieval-Augmented Generation Systems
| 2024-02-27T19:08:05 | 2024-06-20T21:32:35 |
Zhenting Qi, Hanlin Zhang, Eric Xing, Sham Kakade, Himabindu Lakkaraju
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) improves pre-trained models by
incorporating external knowledge at test time to enable customized adaptation.
We study the risk of datastore leakage in Retrieval-In-Context RAG Language
Models (LMs). We show that an adversary can exploit LMs' instruction-following
capabilities to easily extract text data verbatim from the datastore of RAG
systems built with instruction-tuned LMs via prompt injection. The
vulnerability exists for a wide range of modern LMs that span Llama2,
Mistral/Mixtral, Vicuna, SOLAR, WizardLM, Qwen1.5, and Platypus2, and the
exploitability exacerbates as the model size scales up. Extending our study to
production RAG models GPTs, we design an attack that can cause datastore
leakage with a 100% success rate on 25 randomly selected customized GPTs with
at most 2 queries, and we extract text data verbatim at a rate of 41% from a
book of 77,000 words and 3% from a corpus of 1,569,000 words by prompting the
GPTs with only 100 queries generated by themselves.
|
[
-0.21501798927783966,
-0.8032982349395752,
0.5525835156440735,
-0.06590424478054047,
0.0660397857427597,
0.13429686427116394,
0.20389829576015472,
-0.4681030809879303,
-0.08462438732385635,
1.1227631568908691,
-0.4153798520565033,
-0.03541514277458191,
-0.7901589870452881,
-0.2361600399017334,
-0.6777675151824951,
1.3167544603347778,
0.07305559515953064,
-0.21492093801498413,
-0.1895243525505066,
0.2158927023410797,
-0.8694947361946106,
-0.5163456797599792,
-0.49627411365509033,
0.30517128109931946,
0.28002044558525085,
0.36779308319091797,
0.7370298504829407,
0.6021752953529358,
0.5563536286354065,
0.295943021774292,
0.08523932099342346,
0.12778683006763458,
-0.6582006812095642,
0.5752376317977905,
-0.40928131341934204,
-0.575023889541626,
-0.3344053328037262,
-0.044321537017822266,
0.38305017352104187,
0.21896976232528687,
-0.14342303574085236,
0.4010171592235565,
0.09114129841327667,
0.7781913876533508,
-0.8609707951545715,
-0.12403731048107147,
-1.0242952108383179,
-0.10822966694831848,
-0.40071457624435425,
-0.3972075283527374,
-0.9730443954467773,
-0.19609178602695465,
0.05672850459814072,
-0.4748431146144867,
0.30387237668037415,
0.12355184555053711,
0.8281059265136719,
0.25203076004981995,
-0.05727946013212204,
-0.5678259134292603,
-0.7408642768859863,
0.7312051057815552,
-0.24040180444717407,
0.24418234825134277,
0.4990757703781128,
0.5694897770881653,
-0.35113346576690674,
-0.946484386920929,
-0.32110193371772766,
-0.10231227427721024,
-0.22286134958267212,
-0.09792392700910568,
-0.07641912251710892,
-0.22541792690753937,
0.5391128063201904,
0.40258780121803284,
-0.5989232659339905,
-0.2546272575855255,
-0.28246021270751953,
0.26939722895622253,
0.46513569355010986,
0.1783670336008072,
0.36446675658226013,
-0.4338630437850952,
-0.6615113615989685,
-0.2789933979511261,
-0.8113360404968262,
-0.4604973793029785,
0.3090253174304962,
0.4781516492366791,
0.15160107612609863,
0.4572506844997406,
0.32063186168670654,
0.7778854370117188,
0.03704691305756569,
0.15066108107566833,
-0.0800822451710701,
-0.2531402111053467,
-0.3535180687904358,
-0.3574298024177551,
0.6574988961219788,
-0.17299704253673553,
0.08219793438911438,
-0.5583134889602661,
-0.5048722624778748,
-0.6082273721694946,
0.8271133303642273,
-0.8435505032539368,
-0.07088369131088257,
0.18749038875102997,
-0.13566595315933228,
-0.5755353569984436,
0.2255687564611435,
-1.2158212661743164,
-0.7098388671875,
0.16114801168441772,
0.8475667238235474,
-0.42150431871414185,
-0.08178921043872833,
-0.06732570379972458,
-0.3321596086025238,
0.3337959945201874,
-0.0928509309887886,
-1.0804998874664307,
0.4429558515548706,
0.8399203419685364,
0.8576062917709351,
-0.2897966504096985,
0.03159711882472038,
-0.8870325088500977,
0.5146867036819458,
-0.3851262629032135,
0.5619611740112305,
-0.5137374401092529,
-0.7664966583251953,
0.01884760893881321,
0.19922351837158203,
-0.1421317756175995,
-0.7356377243995667,
0.5032854676246643,
-1.0187768936157227,
0.20780012011528015,
-0.4191715717315674,
-0.6830140948295593,
0.28640317916870117,
0.012718944810330868,
-0.7820141315460205,
0.7987737059593201,
0.23544734716415405,
-0.8463618755340576,
0.2426317185163498,
-0.45663905143737793,
-0.262683629989624,
0.14263854920864105,
-0.2215864062309265,
-0.17554940283298492,
0.07663197070360184,
0.28393417596817017,
0.41816800832748413,
-0.09154274314641953,
-0.10384984314441681,
-0.11561208963394165,
-0.41999655961990356,
0.2665470838546753,
-0.6615869998931885,
0.8171721696853638,
0.1915062963962555,
-0.3084487020969391,
-0.46182042360305786,
-0.6010952591896057,
0.21992184221744537,
0.23078469932079315,
-0.1293308585882187,
-0.5231738686561584,
-0.09058056771755219,
-0.14031267166137695,
-0.25010451674461365,
0.22954894602298737,
-0.2086811512708664,
0.43549931049346924,
-0.23518183827400208,
-0.16832289099693298,
0.9663510918617249,
0.4975471794605255,
0.5755842328071594,
-0.3052205443382263,
0.7345946431159973,
-0.23857994377613068,
0.07987990230321884,
-0.3527143895626068,
-0.17404885590076447,
-0.4235813617706299,
-0.4084881544113159,
0.34769901633262634,
0.7004212141036987,
-1.0915570259094238,
0.01892707683146,
-0.25772446393966675,
-0.5143744349479675,
-0.27349740266799927,
0.05550428107380867,
0.45713016390800476,
0.7530583739280701,
0.3373293876647949,
0.14111527800559998,
-0.2221602201461792,
-0.6060172915458679,
-0.8114022016525269,
0.06434040516614914,
-0.3171592354774475,
0.5176581740379333,
0.32052409648895264,
-0.21466359496116638,
0.8380082845687866,
-0.7475089430809021,
-0.08841779083013535,
-0.016579553484916687,
-0.059657417237758636,
0.3663126528263092,
0.7178093791007996,
0.5440218448638916,
-0.74635910987854,
-0.4602125585079193,
0.04407916218042374,
-0.734181821346283,
-0.143785759806633,
-0.23365609347820282,
-0.42579585313796997,
0.20079028606414795,
0.4663679301738739,
-0.7324369549751282,
0.4191620647907257,
0.40085265040397644,
-0.3099154829978943,
0.7734665870666504,
-0.2777380347251892,
0.20059503614902496,
-1.2111626863479614,
-0.048296768218278885,
-0.37048062682151794,
-0.2638068199157715,
-0.6180823445320129,
0.4981611669063568,
0.2622283697128296,
-0.26054617762565613,
-0.25280770659446716,
0.47267481684684753,
-0.6515815258026123,
-0.3120802938938141,
-0.28233182430267334,
0.02834189683198929,
0.18615826964378357,
-0.06973868608474731,
-0.3056632876396179,
1.211427092552185,
0.39037957787513733,
-0.8447914123535156,
0.07427956163883209,
0.27997463941574097,
-0.26435932517051697,
0.183663472533226,
-0.5900365710258484,
0.5479838848114014,
-0.014283002354204655,
-0.020938357338309288,
-0.492825448513031,
-0.3570849597454071,
0.1887878030538559,
-0.46782219409942627,
0.9925283193588257,
-0.4211914837360382,
-0.41532352566719055,
-0.023956917226314545,
-0.25319749116897583,
-0.12791307270526886,
0.5762247443199158,
-0.9328505396842957,
0.4449155628681183,
0.45327383279800415,
-0.2912778854370117,
-0.8117076754570007,
-0.8668784499168396,
0.11450833827257156,
-0.26570719480514526,
-0.4913608431816101,
0.1352677047252655,
0.09592349082231522,
-0.18225178122520447,
0.023232830688357353,
-0.0462970994412899,
-0.13509605824947357,
0.027919650077819824,
0.17635560035705566,
0.41959142684936523,
-0.033492494374513626,
0.29034045338630676,
0.1312064528465271,
-0.02230675332248211,
0.10892196744680405,
-0.1579844355583191,
0.41184699535369873,
-0.04545329138636589,
-0.5240564346313477,
-0.005082142539322376,
0.5167669653892517,
0.32560136914253235,
-0.04174055904150009,
0.9452682137489319,
0.3884226083755493,
-0.2933442294597626,
-0.307893306016922,
-0.35558444261550903,
-0.341996431350708,
-0.6132761240005493,
0.5270767211914062,
-0.4610496461391449,
-0.2901260256767273,
0.28805312514305115,
-0.013177704997360706,
0.15184536576271057,
0.25505468249320984,
0.12502259016036987,
-0.06924069672822952,
0.8222395777702332,
0.7352215051651001,
-0.05054055526852608,
0.5876070261001587,
-0.39041778445243835,
-0.08661018311977386,
-0.7215015292167664,
-0.10454554855823517,
-0.5940646529197693,
-0.0278164092451334,
-0.8477288484573364,
-0.743410587310791,
0.20843520760536194,
0.12115779519081116,
-0.2601083219051361,
0.4282912015914917,
-0.44443461298942566,
0.7988225221633911,
0.23904843628406525,
0.07252811640501022,
0.11342727392911911,
0.22463293373584747,
0.2487054020166397,
-0.17722898721694946,
-0.5538743734359741,
-0.6629367470741272,
1.2222851514816284,
0.2865915894508362,
1.019455909729004,
0.32798171043395996,
0.9501378536224365,
0.5250635147094727,
0.2933618128299713,
-0.5716502070426941,
0.43213945627212524,
-0.22290779650211334,
-0.7685956358909607,
-0.17836551368236542,
-0.5675769448280334,
-0.8847285509109497,
0.15767692029476166,
0.07128001004457474,
-0.7927839159965515,
0.3854575753211975,
-0.007636728696525097,
0.05409833416342735,
0.3699830174446106,
-1.1026217937469482,
0.5998837947845459,
-0.10838158428668976,
-0.482094943523407,
0.18104445934295654,
-0.40876200795173645,
0.46277233958244324,
-0.2796803414821625,
0.2537480890750885,
0.3426893353462219,
-0.32614269852638245,
0.5927124619483948,
-0.5134552121162415,
0.5758986473083496,
-0.41214945912361145,
0.07100678980350494,
0.3275974690914154,
0.3942066431045532,
0.9925044775009155,
0.12280864268541336,
-0.046345073729753494,
-0.20360863208770752,
-0.015078634954988956,
-0.5882086157798767,
-0.7882800698280334,
0.663715124130249,
-0.4948575496673584,
-0.9078714847564697,
-0.4991273283958435,
-0.4926213026046753,
-0.46008726954460144,
0.13684934377670288,
0.4592379927635193,
0.4253266155719757,
-0.0738518014550209,
0.12400344014167786,
1.011918306350708,
-0.18599796295166016,
0.4240249991416931,
0.45804405212402344,
-0.26962727308273315,
-0.2375308871269226,
1.2990769147872925,
0.15500763058662415,
0.7109884023666382,
0.16834984719753265,
0.212535560131073,
-0.10170811414718628,
-0.398518443107605,
-0.7551487684249878,
0.04642178490757942,
-0.6444078683853149,
-0.4498956501483917,
-0.5821981430053711,
-0.24097831547260284,
-0.21928520500659943,
-0.09557120501995087,
-0.3959096372127533,
-0.34637486934661865,
-0.5185064673423767,
-0.13241484761238098,
0.5709693431854248,
1.0507651567459106,
0.2261294722557068,
0.37796321511268616,
-1.0980982780456543,
0.25966668128967285,
0.30854901671409607,
0.08802887797355652,
-0.10772128403186798,
-0.8803249001502991,
-0.07702858746051788,
-0.1102110743522644,
-0.34222540259361267,
-1.3956525325775146,
0.5480702519416809,
0.03465284779667854,
0.37077540159225464,
0.32632046937942505,
0.02939019724726677,
0.7210955023765564,
-0.6906042695045471,
0.7374908328056335,
-0.2567359507083893,
-0.7712708115577698,
0.4926982820034027,
-0.4044365882873535,
0.15022872388362885,
0.4467925429344177,
0.6363847255706787,
-0.18351587653160095,
-0.5298233032226562,
-0.6945231556892395,
-0.9479326605796814,
0.6711977124214172,
-0.11044199019670486,
0.33714568614959717,
-0.1438373476266861,
0.5768822431564331,
0.314413845539093,
0.0857778862118721,
-0.3866196274757385,
-0.1968628168106079,
0.07306628674268723,
-0.022586936131119728,
0.28259050846099854,
-0.4168406128883362,
-0.05944548919796944,
0.22069522738456726,
0.6365809440612793,
0.10282491147518158,
0.17190803587436676,
0.07782027125358582,
-0.25304532051086426,
0.11849013715982437,
0.19193515181541443,
0.15002073347568512,
0.43939632177352905,
-0.09933606535196304,
0.10924959927797318,
0.15113620460033417,
-0.9746454954147339,
0.05255768075585365,
0.14283780753612518,
-0.43213748931884766,
0.07612664997577667,
0.36251527070999146,
0.5832957625389099,
0.10546404868364334,
-0.6309347152709961,
0.32267749309539795,
-0.17139998078346252,
0.3154231607913971,
-0.20879565179347992,
0.05767783150076866,
-0.13518951833248138,
0.265972375869751,
0.5762403607368469,
0.0027424627915024757,
0.33009418845176697,
-0.3858354687690735,
0.5342485308647156,
0.4903191030025482,
-0.24095137417316437,
-0.07274312525987625,
0.417631059885025,
-0.20656006038188934,
-0.08978793025016785,
0.2620827257633209,
-0.17036746442317963,
-0.20063242316246033,
0.45826485753059387,
0.7527663707733154,
0.920322597026825,
-0.4265405535697937,
0.12180931866168976,
0.2711474299430847,
0.4394543468952179,
0.010917996987700462,
0.07079653441905975,
0.1847497522830963,
-0.2061326652765274,
-0.24791842699050903,
-0.6298537850379944,
-0.42090940475463867,
0.13331511616706848,
-0.8708421587944031,
0.22733040153980255,
-0.33834707736968994,
-0.029659809544682503,
-0.29320216178894043,
-0.24139267206192017,
-0.5041393637657166,
-0.15253424644470215,
-0.2634522318840027,
0.7709833383560181,
-0.5649608373641968,
0.5204662084579468,
0.27888157963752747,
-0.38397613167762756,
-0.8227829933166504,
0.3059194087982178,
-0.2071024477481842,
-0.8019282817840576,
0.5493127107620239,
-0.08185781538486481,
0.13386432826519012,
-0.16759039461612701,
-0.4897787570953369,
-1.0284734964370728,
1.0208081007003784,
0.5389377474784851,
-0.4364783465862274,
-0.13001039624214172,
-0.024849986657500267,
0.1940162181854248,
-0.15289556980133057,
0.23006734251976013,
0.8156916499137878,
0.1501224935054779,
0.02252900041639805,
-0.4319356381893158,
0.10529137402772903,
0.22936317324638367,
-0.021668151021003723,
0.33811965584754944,
-0.23698842525482178,
0.8596050143241882,
-0.34702450037002563,
-0.46085813641548157,
0.0048025185242295265,
0.5201537013053894,
0.21800942718982697,
0.04295411333441734,
0.36546480655670166,
0.4246067404747009,
0.8922438025474548,
0.22926859557628632,
1.5061148405075073,
0.0883774533867836,
0.10702456533908844,
1.3889832496643066,
-0.10180158913135529,
1.1255489587783813,
0.5203782320022583,
-0.11982809007167816,
0.3507886826992035,
0.31719720363616943,
0.23032228648662567,
0.6039881110191345,
0.001072941580787301,
-0.4361954927444458,
0.4283638000488281,
0.16276735067367554,
-0.5260354280471802,
0.18882440030574799,
0.6091837882995605,
-0.5465964078903198,
0.01712980680167675,
-0.06215658038854599,
0.2307145893573761,
-0.08539729565382004,
-0.18013913929462433,
0.8722661733627319,
0.07883651554584503,
-0.38177603483200073,
0.7150309681892395,
-0.4122407138347626,
0.16433626413345337,
-0.4738173186779022,
-0.056408271193504333,
-0.18417316675186157,
0.06841479241847992,
-0.29191088676452637,
-0.7445129752159119,
0.4613616466522217,
0.40183091163635254,
-0.26813754439353943,
-0.20312075316905975,
1.0373204946517944,
-0.26100730895996094,
-0.2892139256000519,
0.1565687209367752,
0.5292887687683105,
0.22843003273010254,
-0.13671104609966278,
-0.35689544677734375,
0.12526819109916687,
-0.09483186155557632,
-0.8185365796089172,
0.7102662920951843,
0.5712093710899353,
-0.043453115969896317,
0.6234499216079712,
0.6058405637741089,
0.22887125611305237,
0.45727524161338806,
-0.11323234438896179,
1.0728611946105957,
-0.5961624383926392,
-0.09998530149459839,
-0.8058414459228516,
0.2441263198852539,
-0.2539461851119995,
0.2540315091609955,
0.9003159403800964,
0.416355162858963,
0.5641148686408997,
-0.2808719277381897,
0.7682502865791321,
-0.0747266411781311,
0.6613733768463135,
-0.5254600048065186,
0.9744205474853516,
-0.3394845426082611,
0.5443218350410461,
-0.17152726650238037,
-0.7624585628509521,
0.4009323716163635,
-0.00355508946813643,
-0.30594566464424133,
0.1387416124343872,
0.653957188129425,
0.7454422116279602,
0.056885674595832825,
-0.024212244898080826,
0.23997625708580017,
0.2876083552837372,
0.5459277629852295,
0.13340505957603455,
0.48628026247024536,
-0.4963241517543793,
0.7161146998405457,
-0.05857338756322861,
-0.43223538994789124,
0.054930221289396286,
-0.8168824315071106,
-0.5106900930404663,
-0.3112851679325104,
0.022024990990757942,
-0.34703004360198975,
0.26141640543937683,
0.08251335471868515,
0.3945924937725067,
-0.6445351839065552,
0.005574497394263744,
-0.27915817499160767,
0.23106206953525543,
0.052977465093135834,
-0.3362884819507599,
0.3475685119628906,
-0.8070207238197327,
-0.8442420363426208,
0.578244686126709,
-0.08126237988471985,
0.153892382979393,
-0.2214231938123703,
0.1571660041809082,
-0.05442025139927864,
0.15201765298843384,
0.3752419948577881,
0.382414311170578,
-0.18769432604312897,
-0.3774356544017792,
0.1212635338306427,
-0.1858844757080078,
-0.4409041702747345,
0.5922282934188843,
-0.8005452752113342,
0.6195917725563049,
0.6178497672080994,
1.1746103763580322,
0.5640411972999573,
0.12155629694461823,
0.5910501480102539,
-1.1524657011032104,
0.2887296974658966,
0.4782182276248932,
0.10419289022684097,
0.17054003477096558,
-0.704633891582489,
0.4614499807357788,
0.16607555747032166,
-0.8467823266983032,
-1.1829568147659302,
0.3294980823993683,
-0.5626534223556519,
-0.23665504157543182,
1.1724581718444824,
-0.3035234808921814,
-0.4975903332233429,
0.08392859250307083,
-0.024785229936242104,
-0.05654394254088402,
-0.21252039074897766,
0.5564627051353455,
0.45335081219673157,
0.11643858999013901,
0.04317657649517059,
-1.3402847051620483,
0.6525394320487976,
0.24132926762104034,
-0.9220077395439148,
0.27984675765037537,
0.28271055221557617,
0.2309388369321823,
0.1800890564918518,
0.3671708405017853,
-0.4399983882904053,
0.20643943548202515,
0.3539084196090698,
-0.11481047421693802,
0.06478597968816757,
-0.29363763332366943,
-0.26829975843429565,
0.18115226924419403,
0.0705328956246376,
-0.4921732246875763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17834v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17834v1
|
Stable LM 2 1.6B Technical Report
| 2024-02-27T19:00:07 | 2024-02-27T19:00:07 |
Marco Bellagente, Jonathan Tow, Dakota Mahan, Duy Phung, Maksym Zhuravinskyi, Reshinth Adithyan, James Baicoianu, Ben Brooks, Nathan Cooper, Ashish Datta, Meng Lee, Emad Mostaque, Michael Pieler, Nikhil Pinnaparju, Paulo Rocha, Harry Saini, Hannah Teufel, Niccolo Zanichelli, Carlos Riquelme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.ML
|
We introduce StableLM 2 1.6B, the first in a new generation of our language
model series. In this technical report, we present in detail the data and
training procedure leading to the base and instruction-tuned versions of
StableLM 2 1.6B. The weights for both models are available via Hugging Face for
anyone to download and use. The report contains thorough evaluations of these
models, including zero- and few-shot benchmarks, multilingual benchmarks, and
the MT benchmark focusing on multi-turn dialogues. At the time of publishing
this report, StableLM 2 1.6B was the state-of-the-art open model under 2B
parameters by a significant margin. Given its appealing small size, we also
provide throughput measurements on a number of edge devices. In addition, we
open source several quantized checkpoints and provide their performance metrics
compared to the original model.
|
[
-0.1904618889093399,
-0.9801200032234192,
0.11445359140634537,
0.17060191929340363,
-0.2573241889476776,
-0.0811738520860672,
-0.07020401954650879,
-0.7833393216133118,
-0.025963081046938896,
0.6848618984222412,
-0.4628826975822449,
-0.404163122177124,
-0.45294633507728577,
-0.3692416548728943,
-0.2724063992500305,
0.8493746519088745,
0.0761774331331253,
0.3881852328777313,
-0.1666688621044159,
-0.562949001789093,
-0.47670382261276245,
-0.6044754981994629,
-0.8324622511863708,
-0.4181988537311554,
0.7168084383010864,
0.33816877007484436,
0.97678542137146,
0.5333411693572998,
0.5538944005966187,
0.16089153289794922,
-0.28751057386398315,
-0.3009069561958313,
-0.6696962714195251,
0.24630378186702728,
0.04829768091440201,
-0.18785180151462555,
-0.8550902009010315,
-0.03663155063986778,
0.8803315162658691,
0.6035189032554626,
-0.2985536754131317,
0.2741580307483673,
-0.23550674319267273,
0.8533363342285156,
-0.2894552946090698,
0.020760947838425636,
-0.8482071161270142,
-0.14617037773132324,
-0.39804649353027344,
0.4142604470252991,
-0.8512919545173645,
-0.18853266537189484,
-0.06547485291957855,
-0.314227432012558,
-0.21479256451129913,
-0.3710072934627533,
0.9112192988395691,
0.2510969340801239,
-0.3588962256908417,
-0.08919618278741837,
-0.41668394207954407,
0.7381801009178162,
-0.7341352105140686,
0.6551792621612549,
0.44985881447792053,
0.5325644612312317,
0.027740688994526863,
-0.9969637393951416,
-0.06460295617580414,
-0.35633569955825806,
0.15506142377853394,
-0.10983242839574814,
-0.22266964614391327,
0.03134920075535774,
0.13288378715515137,
0.11544156074523926,
-0.5384259819984436,
0.4854813516139984,
-0.6272712349891663,
-0.26315680146217346,
0.49394986033439636,
0.24928432703018188,
-0.004004600923508406,
0.333517462015152,
-0.3195466697216034,
0.06482737511396408,
-0.8093294501304626,
0.10848864167928696,
0.07907312363386154,
0.47204554080963135,
-0.33193904161453247,
0.39342427253723145,
-0.29076260328292847,
0.707282543182373,
-0.278889536857605,
-0.14451837539672852,
0.17488491535186768,
-0.4677601754665375,
-0.07257857173681259,
0.07453318685293198,
0.5588408708572388,
0.5904221534729004,
-0.03706961125135422,
-0.13143682479858398,
-0.4064050018787384,
-0.05348594859242439,
0.07551498711109161,
-1.069831371307373,
-0.31423237919807434,
0.2738129794597626,
-0.6187822818756104,
-0.22761744260787964,
-0.21777409315109253,
-0.35886746644973755,
-0.32144173979759216,
-0.12004730850458145,
0.462541401386261,
-0.2678881287574768,
-0.6629700660705566,
-0.03354146331548691,
0.15133941173553467,
0.2586677670478821,
0.42352160811424255,
-0.8876524567604065,
0.5016174912452698,
0.6315006017684937,
0.8729076385498047,
-0.16315822303295135,
-0.05982576310634613,
-0.7571954131126404,
-0.13417506217956543,
-0.27418753504753113,
0.5412968993186951,
-0.16930735111236572,
-0.2714834213256836,
0.24770362675189972,
-0.12417297810316086,
0.16986975073814392,
-0.542137861251831,
0.4765915870666504,
-0.6381804347038269,
0.16985836625099182,
-0.19892653822898865,
-0.3829435408115387,
-0.03613588958978653,
0.40757742524147034,
-0.7603566646575928,
1.2249865531921387,
0.4767652750015259,
-0.6250045895576477,
0.11814769357442856,
-0.4664718806743622,
-0.3227600157260895,
0.13262994587421417,
0.041977617889642715,
-0.5580936074256897,
-0.048666033893823624,
-0.34696677327156067,
-0.08155470341444016,
-0.196146622300148,
0.010625534690916538,
-0.4528304934501648,
-0.13906055688858032,
0.1116371899843216,
-0.10806445777416229,
0.804493248462677,
0.3521070182323456,
-0.06411837041378021,
0.23181861639022827,
-0.643668532371521,
0.4761875867843628,
0.07224816083908081,
-0.4377749264240265,
0.20086301863193512,
0.28605881333351135,
0.1782449334859848,
0.3644987642765045,
0.45522457361221313,
-0.37505459785461426,
0.12987613677978516,
-0.19643473625183105,
0.41417863965034485,
0.3736055791378021,
-0.25927168130874634,
0.32276055216789246,
-0.1746937483549118,
0.2796630859375,
0.13282053172588348,
0.30480116605758667,
-0.40984857082366943,
-0.46695518493652344,
-0.7840672731399536,
-0.1929939091205597,
0.47478726506233215,
0.6108670234680176,
-0.292515367269516,
0.10082834959030151,
-0.1693417727947235,
-0.5009715557098389,
-0.6454243659973145,
0.257686972618103,
0.5751508474349976,
0.38043051958084106,
0.28084003925323486,
-0.10920549184083939,
-0.5681362152099609,
-1.027794361114502,
-0.03783748298883438,
-0.4076707065105438,
0.20955713093280792,
-0.24948494136333466,
0.06959385424852371,
-0.1530941128730774,
0.9086282849311829,
-0.02832062728703022,
0.08486834168434143,
-0.4181217849254608,
0.12832330167293549,
0.026876751333475113,
0.5171574354171753,
0.7052410840988159,
-0.3865634799003601,
-0.49512913823127747,
0.016596734523773193,
-0.7520246505737305,
-0.1070682555437088,
0.24341709911823273,
-0.14625221490859985,
0.7384589910507202,
0.571648120880127,
-0.5658267736434937,
0.13137999176979065,
0.7132908701896667,
-0.4286954402923584,
0.2644428014755249,
0.16628585755825043,
-0.30532306432724,
-0.9311398267745972,
-0.09130226820707321,
-0.16448800265789032,
-0.5903437733650208,
-0.7216687798500061,
0.1693081259727478,
0.3063433766365051,
-0.021855086088180542,
-0.8010470867156982,
0.6742076277732849,
-0.58551025390625,
-0.137562558054924,
-0.304219126701355,
0.24206815659999847,
-0.16615375876426697,
0.175012469291687,
-0.22628581523895264,
0.5549938082695007,
0.6306548118591309,
-0.4524111747741699,
-0.001346756354905665,
0.06856060028076172,
-0.26118725538253784,
-0.04552992805838585,
-0.8758885860443115,
0.4582124352455139,
-0.015899449586868286,
0.1348131150007248,
-0.825756311416626,
0.030921442434191704,
0.2066238969564438,
-0.49071812629699707,
0.513867974281311,
-0.32403993606567383,
-0.4637352526187897,
-0.20341338217258453,
-0.28040099143981934,
0.029768915846943855,
0.9345504641532898,
-0.12226483970880508,
0.23930814862251282,
0.8153062462806702,
-0.28540584444999695,
-0.2133340835571289,
-0.6063125133514404,
-0.1172153502702713,
0.16536679863929749,
-0.8211274147033691,
-0.015858953818678856,
-0.07812205702066422,
-0.5800549983978271,
-0.2584752142429352,
-0.06786864250898361,
-0.23062342405319214,
0.31630778312683105,
0.27005645632743835,
0.21057377755641937,
-0.42949995398521423,
-0.10622577369213104,
0.047488629817962646,
-0.2615959942340851,
0.13276955485343933,
-0.19368316233158112,
0.4941551983356476,
-0.28569087386131287,
0.014304101467132568,
-0.4046763777732849,
0.23265361785888672,
0.6946122646331787,
-0.3543223440647125,
1.057541847229004,
0.5615783929824829,
-0.6113776564598083,
0.0683770552277565,
-0.3070050776004791,
-0.08496110141277313,
-0.4736555814743042,
0.5258256793022156,
-0.3183971047401428,
-0.780799388885498,
0.6822274327278137,
0.15931466221809387,
0.4425651431083679,
0.42175453901290894,
0.7397540807723999,
0.007327521685510874,
1.206131935119629,
0.6264833807945251,
0.06671293824911118,
0.5307450890541077,
-0.036072712391614914,
-0.1663552075624466,
-0.425106018781662,
-0.44125598669052124,
-0.5897138714790344,
-0.25351259112358093,
-0.22157227993011475,
-0.3413509726524353,
0.2570353150367737,
0.8015486598014832,
-0.3271040916442871,
0.14230488240718842,
-0.15905006229877472,
0.37232035398483276,
0.40474194288253784,
0.11641598492860794,
0.06602701544761658,
0.022751322016119957,
-0.15120792388916016,
-0.13204166293144226,
-0.7395969033241272,
-0.7824580669403076,
0.916876494884491,
0.810630738735199,
0.6691833138465881,
0.28068608045578003,
0.19499839842319489,
0.24241290986537933,
0.5392685532569885,
-0.6168088912963867,
0.6015930771827698,
-0.22959931194782257,
-0.8062965869903564,
-0.2774040102958679,
-0.24674318730831146,
-0.6813708543777466,
0.151047021150589,
0.031055714935064316,
-0.7442307472229004,
-0.5630909204483032,
0.3170328140258789,
-0.060913603752851486,
0.2458520233631134,
-0.5598728656768799,
1.02256178855896,
-0.3485769033432007,
-0.5421503186225891,
-0.32314783334732056,
-1.0578258037567139,
0.4884607195854187,
0.16993042826652527,
-0.06549961864948273,
-0.4953670799732208,
0.08419142663478851,
0.6632885932922363,
-0.4969833493232727,
0.5533818006515503,
-0.4943361282348633,
-0.1017008051276207,
0.3500508964061737,
0.17976370453834534,
0.4797295033931732,
0.09165756404399872,
-0.6205666661262512,
0.4816989600658417,
0.042703911662101746,
-0.45247793197631836,
-0.26133155822753906,
0.5867002010345459,
-0.7447357773780823,
-0.259143590927124,
-0.24004676938056946,
-0.489931583404541,
-0.05102268606424332,
0.39477941393852234,
0.15558429062366486,
0.7501147389411926,
-0.3245483338832855,
0.40607208013534546,
0.6843307018280029,
0.04143950343132019,
0.4741716682910919,
0.8328078985214233,
-0.7924680709838867,
-0.5225911140441895,
0.504278302192688,
0.22306102514266968,
0.8060986399650574,
0.2963801920413971,
-0.1638122797012329,
-0.4291422367095947,
-0.7866798043251038,
-0.7554882764816284,
0.01834462210536003,
-0.8123040795326233,
-0.2088540494441986,
-0.752069354057312,
-0.39180871844291687,
-0.3999881148338318,
0.15070660412311554,
-0.741421103477478,
-0.7056035995483398,
-0.10990250110626221,
-0.023090025410056114,
0.34670162200927734,
0.8084036111831665,
0.20272588729858398,
0.4316771328449249,
-0.8864164352416992,
0.20540277659893036,
-0.17314933240413666,
0.441763311624527,
-0.3985942602157593,
-0.5889689922332764,
-0.6597321629524231,
0.3326108455657959,
-0.4384116530418396,
-0.6958888173103333,
-0.03454208746552467,
0.28902462124824524,
0.7039061784744263,
0.4408653676509857,
0.07514534145593643,
0.25932034850120544,
-0.4302442669868469,
0.9840448498725891,
0.22627590596675873,
-0.797577977180481,
0.598051905632019,
-0.4921807646751404,
0.4595004618167877,
0.8281451463699341,
0.044508542865514755,
-0.35356637835502625,
-0.36762118339538574,
-0.120550736784935,
-0.6593232154846191,
0.7602564096450806,
0.12301196157932281,
0.1587752401828766,
-0.04423179477453232,
0.2963283956050873,
0.3085900545120239,
0.09986907988786697,
-0.6888097524642944,
-0.47238388657569885,
-0.22066131234169006,
-0.2291494607925415,
0.03276079148054123,
-0.45011335611343384,
-0.04932132363319397,
-0.3220728635787964,
0.6072059273719788,
0.07654890418052673,
0.16205376386642456,
-0.12390203773975372,
-0.2981497347354889,
-0.4108336567878723,
0.07347036898136139,
0.8692877888679504,
1.0243374109268188,
-0.45917120575904846,
0.11582645773887634,
0.1448567807674408,
-0.5175089836120605,
-0.027671480551362038,
0.09244309365749359,
-0.4918125867843628,
0.3458544611930847,
0.07495370507240295,
1.0674302577972412,
0.3190096914768219,
-0.6413588523864746,
0.10856085270643234,
0.04881050065159798,
-0.2972392439842224,
-0.15504874289035797,
-0.07979891449213028,
0.1378796100616455,
0.12062929570674896,
0.16026104986667633,
-0.08912880718708038,
-0.25047609210014343,
-0.5936279892921448,
0.323623389005661,
0.5554733276367188,
-0.636134147644043,
-0.4949272572994232,
0.8755851984024048,
0.39531227946281433,
-0.4523879885673523,
0.8494934439659119,
-0.4008445143699646,
-0.5164818167686462,
0.30182215571403503,
0.774648129940033,
0.8861021995544434,
-0.15223585069179535,
0.24240772426128387,
0.43236809968948364,
0.5662434101104736,
-0.23751194775104523,
0.5422092080116272,
0.3853883743286133,
-0.4847278594970703,
-0.060937535017728806,
-0.6387240886688232,
-0.5424556136131287,
-0.021617596969008446,
-0.801887571811676,
0.5425871014595032,
-0.5677751898765564,
-0.26741671562194824,
-0.35926389694213867,
0.08196678012609482,
-0.14764833450317383,
-0.06736315041780472,
0.2787255346775055,
1.3328102827072144,
-0.4053114950656891,
1.2550700902938843,
0.80048006772995,
-0.22631783783435822,
-0.6097701787948608,
-0.4711677134037018,
0.05005723983049393,
-0.5687186121940613,
0.46974918246269226,
0.34462618827819824,
-0.15882886946201324,
0.0836104229092598,
-0.568292498588562,
-0.8002997636795044,
1.2379871606826782,
0.4654054641723633,
-0.6392803192138672,
0.2309356927871704,
-0.06430276483297348,
0.3194262981414795,
-0.2798910439014435,
0.20421692728996277,
0.27881959080696106,
0.381835401058197,
-0.04774695634841919,
-1.0878928899765015,
-0.09188612550497055,
-0.4557945728302002,
-0.05866739898920059,
0.6225805878639221,
-0.828381359577179,
1.1747887134552002,
-0.1922050565481186,
-0.2154664695262909,
0.3695620894432068,
0.8005319237709045,
0.37856391072273254,
0.5683279633522034,
0.379635751247406,
0.6999980211257935,
0.5683577656745911,
-0.14893391728401184,
0.8299649357795715,
-0.6137539148330688,
0.3888758420944214,
1.2580790519714355,
-0.6671398878097534,
1.210303544998169,
0.35485556721687317,
-0.09518507122993469,
0.5084835290908813,
0.6926528811454773,
0.15401750802993774,
0.6346628665924072,
0.056832216680049896,
-0.16124747693538666,
-0.1710001826286316,
-0.0872265100479126,
-0.622857928276062,
0.0006348888855427504,
0.16881000995635986,
-0.14156274497509003,
-0.22346842288970947,
-0.1125483363866806,
0.14032307267189026,
-0.17721164226531982,
-0.5119577050209045,
0.7668105959892273,
0.08983052521944046,
-0.7186363935470581,
0.7943937182426453,
0.30087804794311523,
0.36691221594810486,
-0.9643680453300476,
0.15472152829170227,
-0.3354637622833252,
0.3958587646484375,
0.048157982528209686,
-0.7474033236503601,
0.3219839036464691,
-0.01741393655538559,
-0.3097364604473114,
-0.36466729640960693,
0.8569968342781067,
-0.4996776580810547,
-0.47205495834350586,
0.274808794260025,
0.2728017270565033,
0.3481066823005676,
0.12309983372688293,
-0.6961765289306641,
0.560672402381897,
-0.14416678249835968,
-0.21319586038589478,
0.3043466806411743,
0.04879584535956383,
-0.21206016838550568,
0.7052735686302185,
0.2401655912399292,
-0.2656441330909729,
0.47260984778404236,
0.34832578897476196,
0.7673987150192261,
-0.5885130763053894,
-0.253119558095932,
-0.6090789437294006,
0.971123218536377,
0.02416353113949299,
-0.39053210616111755,
0.7187096476554871,
0.8162997364997864,
0.710448145866394,
0.17889007925987244,
0.6176972389221191,
-0.10952624678611755,
0.5019811987876892,
-0.7560165524482727,
0.7601262331008911,
-0.44248852133750916,
0.17177964746952057,
0.2349366396665573,
-0.6964312791824341,
0.002640875056385994,
0.2965679466724396,
0.3179366886615753,
0.10500185936689377,
0.6349179148674011,
0.8012381196022034,
0.1707887053489685,
-0.012790719047188759,
0.2891111969947815,
0.3933389186859131,
0.11966290324926376,
0.41050294041633606,
0.7426515221595764,
-0.7691080570220947,
0.57656329870224,
-0.13953769207000732,
-0.12074849009513855,
-0.3375193476676941,
-0.740895688533783,
-0.9584822654724121,
-0.2375296652317047,
-0.42579329013824463,
-0.7101699709892273,
0.14690133929252625,
0.7070984840393066,
0.8933330178260803,
-0.7499626874923706,
-0.28912553191185,
-0.05547076836228371,
0.1143239364027977,
0.020087605342268944,
-0.12479960173368454,
-0.25898945331573486,
-0.32942596077919006,
-0.4992155432701111,
0.5486091375350952,
0.44620323181152344,
0.11686064302921295,
-0.46746426820755005,
-0.6908459067344666,
-0.1659194380044937,
-0.1040671095252037,
0.5477190613746643,
0.2903757393360138,
-0.7673353552818298,
-0.07154379040002823,
0.19665786623954773,
-0.5124062299728394,
0.09858854115009308,
0.6232600808143616,
-0.5278094410896301,
0.25307273864746094,
0.4749303460121155,
0.3029285967350006,
0.5056326985359192,
-0.03045308217406273,
0.5032715797424316,
-0.5571635961532593,
0.3946724534034729,
0.037180639803409576,
0.2194816768169403,
0.2943257987499237,
0.13881056010723114,
0.514637291431427,
-0.08554582297801971,
-0.5746344327926636,
-1.2446006536483765,
0.44281354546546936,
-1.3389002084732056,
-0.033206138759851456,
1.0462507009506226,
-0.1418636590242386,
0.19681397080421448,
0.021706415340304375,
-0.06883276998996735,
0.265713095664978,
-0.22952881455421448,
0.20354071259498596,
0.7099210023880005,
0.13974246382713318,
-0.5029548406600952,
-0.6941226720809937,
0.21339739859104156,
0.442949116230011,
-0.7599019408226013,
-0.01854461245238781,
0.4809184670448303,
0.2683459222316742,
-0.1089363694190979,
0.7775783538818359,
-0.3891505002975464,
0.3252319395542145,
0.292688250541687,
0.04440221190452576,
-0.20783881843090057,
-0.3538053631782532,
-0.40487897396087646,
0.06451623886823654,
0.42169496417045593,
-0.09998387843370438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17826v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17826v2
|
Prediction-Powered Ranking of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-27T19:00:01 | 2024-05-23T16:50:21 |
Ivi Chatzi, Eleni Straitouri, Suhas Thejaswi, Manuel Gomez Rodriguez
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, stat.ML
|
Large language models are often ranked according to their level of alignment
with human preferences -- a model is better than other models if its outputs
are more frequently preferred by humans. One of the popular ways to elicit
human preferences utilizes pairwise comparisons between the outputs provided by
different models to the same inputs. However, since gathering pairwise
comparisons by humans is costly and time-consuming, it has become a common
practice to gather pairwise comparisons by a strong large language model -- a
model strongly aligned with human preferences. Surprisingly, practitioners
cannot currently measure the uncertainty that any mismatch between human and
model preferences may introduce in the constructed rankings. In this work, we
develop a statistical framework to bridge this gap. Given a (small) set of
pairwise comparisons by humans and a large set of pairwise comparisons by a
model, our framework provides a rank-set -- a set of possible ranking positions
-- for each of the models under comparison. Moreover, it guarantees that, with
a probability greater than or equal to a user-specified value, the rank-sets
cover the true ranking consistent with the distribution of human pairwise
preferences asymptotically. Using pairwise comparisons made by humans in the
LMSYS Chatbot Arena platform and pairwise comparisons made by three strong
large language models, we empirically demonstrate the effectivity of our
framework and show that the rank-sets constructed using only pairwise
comparisons by the strong large language models are often inconsistent with
(the distribution of) human pairwise preferences.
|
[
-0.2693311274051666,
-0.35923877358436584,
0.5965223908424377,
0.32590293884277344,
0.023912327364087105,
0.09663612395524979,
-0.5964455008506775,
-0.5618854761123657,
0.29011300206184387,
0.36076265573501587,
-0.011780530214309692,
-0.4198077321052551,
-0.7418321967124939,
-0.10488226264715195,
-0.2803565263748169,
0.7408118844032288,
0.4211159646511078,
0.07197673618793488,
-0.35567882657051086,
-0.18790777027606964,
-0.3498457372188568,
-0.6368991136550903,
-0.43766987323760986,
-0.44477176666259766,
0.5860642790794373,
0.3828788995742798,
1.3865306377410889,
0.5200238823890686,
0.6781811118125916,
0.26443102955818176,
-0.03284880518913269,
-0.061519574373960495,
-0.46413078904151917,
0.434621125459671,
-0.13213440775871277,
-0.26640456914901733,
-0.6303630471229553,
0.05232726410031319,
0.7868406772613525,
0.9121649861335754,
-0.08929464221000671,
0.17191731929779053,
0.12367188185453415,
0.5103955268859863,
-0.6030684113502502,
0.17247192561626434,
-0.846347451210022,
-0.19942903518676758,
-0.4351155757904053,
-0.10435277968645096,
-0.5273438692092896,
-0.3527807295322418,
0.10432346910238266,
-0.25128522515296936,
-0.0970190167427063,
0.42254748940467834,
0.7949174046516418,
0.1461835652589798,
-0.3185676038265228,
0.25410938262939453,
-0.5665371417999268,
0.94541996717453,
-0.8205233216285706,
0.5912365913391113,
0.7642868161201477,
0.399114727973938,
-0.27327826619148254,
-0.19364458322525024,
-0.37417230010032654,
-0.3940960764884949,
-0.07748471200466156,
-0.1309850960969925,
-0.047375816851854324,
0.16921435296535492,
0.11703244596719742,
0.17383962869644165,
-0.6936774253845215,
0.5483377575874329,
-0.04451732337474823,
-0.02514905296266079,
0.9444637894630432,
-0.035462819039821625,
0.15408073365688324,
-0.1897180825471878,
-0.011828325688838959,
-0.3843633234500885,
-0.7390074729919434,
0.05960948392748833,
0.6188773512840271,
0.7353036403656006,
0.19971835613250732,
0.6472716927528381,
-0.4392085075378418,
0.8952907919883728,
0.024840187281370163,
-0.07992672920227051,
0.27627211809158325,
-0.04699665307998657,
-0.037209730595350266,
0.1382049322128296,
1.0185920000076294,
0.7426721453666687,
0.2917994260787964,
-0.42027515172958374,
-0.37584495544433594,
-0.0007242492283694446,
-0.034819044172763824,
-0.7912645936012268,
-0.33709943294525146,
0.3192583918571472,
-0.4618895351886749,
-0.5442933440208435,
0.19957882165908813,
-0.76313316822052,
-0.7118091583251953,
-0.16287091374397278,
0.6303958892822266,
0.07860890030860901,
-0.38458362221717834,
0.08467227965593338,
0.07496191561222076,
-0.22613117098808289,
0.07815981656312943,
-1.0797157287597656,
0.33457711338996887,
0.845032811164856,
0.7566699981689453,
-0.32298552989959717,
-0.3615940511226654,
-0.5048056244850159,
-0.1524006575345993,
-0.45086249709129333,
0.7618560791015625,
-0.8474267721176147,
-0.2356872856616974,
-0.07481656223535538,
-0.409288614988327,
0.1467301994562149,
-0.6010364294052124,
0.5550299882888794,
-0.5509485006332397,
0.18898123502731323,
-0.2610337734222412,
-0.7907585501670837,
0.31561020016670227,
0.04126153886318207,
-0.5844224691390991,
0.9548195004463196,
-0.22695116698741913,
-0.7515892386436462,
0.5782716274261475,
-0.28695419430732727,
-0.33508995175361633,
-0.03281371295452118,
-0.12193730473518372,
-0.5403825044631958,
-0.14621204137802124,
0.03682722896337509,
0.7369365692138672,
-0.4831770062446594,
0.5763062834739685,
-0.7579097747802734,
-0.33514195680618286,
0.42940554022789,
-0.24642248451709747,
0.6826104521751404,
0.15135455131530762,
-0.32840752601623535,
0.318173348903656,
-0.5042029023170471,
0.2564188241958618,
0.04682259261608124,
-0.11914914846420288,
-0.47918567061424255,
0.3340989947319031,
-0.0975499078631401,
0.24994586408138275,
0.3045675456523895,
-0.25619322061538696,
0.4277394413948059,
-0.40150517225265503,
0.30830898880958557,
0.8472535610198975,
-0.17389129102230072,
0.7134131789207458,
-0.29658299684524536,
0.3122739791870117,
-0.3255663216114044,
0.17568419873714447,
0.46776458621025085,
-0.7509835362434387,
-0.5680266618728638,
0.02627432532608509,
0.5498512387275696,
0.43093180656433105,
-0.18217334151268005,
0.6534997224807739,
-0.5639246106147766,
-0.6930556893348694,
-0.6131689548492432,
0.09599147737026215,
0.4361487329006195,
0.11704988032579422,
0.18347106873989105,
0.033279139548540115,
-0.3823637068271637,
-1.0421171188354492,
-0.3347851634025574,
-0.4536029100418091,
-0.12970636785030365,
0.21555021405220032,
0.221322163939476,
0.11198100447654724,
0.8599567413330078,
-0.624916672706604,
0.09206244349479675,
-0.023853929713368416,
-0.03650146350264549,
0.4833568036556244,
0.42441901564598083,
0.3892841935157776,
-0.7992868423461914,
-0.43413397669792175,
0.007096942514181137,
-0.4296521544456482,
-0.0792514830827713,
0.3862425982952118,
-0.28207311034202576,
0.19029392302036285,
0.2606622874736786,
-0.41446593403816223,
0.2761259078979492,
0.8160868883132935,
-0.36042192578315735,
0.4967042803764343,
-0.2550605237483978,
0.3976418972015381,
-1.2267467975616455,
0.18112455308437347,
-0.004993135575205088,
-0.19079461693763733,
-0.36214175820350647,
-0.23418746888637543,
-0.00820457749068737,
-0.0005716598243452609,
0.07410909980535507,
0.7727965116500854,
-0.03888368606567383,
-0.4032672941684723,
0.023702217265963554,
0.10676228255033493,
-0.11230926215648651,
0.283277690410614,
0.3286907970905304,
0.5866004824638367,
0.5154038667678833,
-0.45713239908218384,
0.36606451869010925,
0.35339921712875366,
-0.460286021232605,
0.357756644487381,
-0.736382007598877,
0.07300398498773575,
0.2574496567249298,
0.17884381115436554,
-0.9810739755630493,
-0.30303677916526794,
-0.07348144054412842,
-0.5811987519264221,
0.18958327174186707,
-0.20845818519592285,
-0.6530094146728516,
-0.09340077638626099,
-0.23890657722949982,
0.5110289454460144,
0.44596537947654724,
-0.5385099649429321,
-0.036487288773059845,
0.6147512793540955,
-0.3699222803115845,
-0.6993699073791504,
-0.24487483501434326,
0.1227465495467186,
-0.29971063137054443,
-0.7746909260749817,
0.38942408561706543,
-0.2663635015487671,
-0.7083237767219543,
-0.18780946731567383,
0.0884384736418724,
0.19201815128326416,
0.19491516053676605,
0.42634317278862,
0.3039913475513458,
0.025904811918735504,
0.3896584212779999,
-0.2188313603401184,
-0.2295416295528412,
-0.2347695380449295,
-0.3243568539619446,
0.61014723777771,
-0.34143587946891785,
-0.4250670373439789,
0.0892305001616478,
0.13785094022750854,
0.7092236876487732,
-0.2933202385902405,
0.7270743250846863,
0.17090468108654022,
-0.41950729489326477,
-0.04687174782156944,
-0.6194499731063843,
-0.3058854937553406,
-0.4186144471168518,
0.39096319675445557,
-0.33495819568634033,
-0.654329240322113,
0.5584224462509155,
0.5853639841079712,
0.159096822142601,
0.3717038631439209,
0.5065281391143799,
-0.04401503503322601,
1.6413280963897705,
0.29007866978645325,
-0.4406413733959198,
0.4575011730194092,
0.23758895695209503,
0.2814309000968933,
-0.3265702426433563,
0.018451450392603874,
-0.7913782000541687,
-0.5470109581947327,
-0.9469491243362427,
-0.12963378429412842,
0.4429619312286377,
0.06871752440929413,
-0.35927754640579224,
0.33107757568359375,
-0.39061859250068665,
0.5707625150680542,
0.7508646249771118,
-0.05453191697597504,
0.312408983707428,
-0.04879968240857124,
-0.08331265300512314,
0.008437030017375946,
-0.7072538733482361,
-0.3587273359298706,
1.2264195680618286,
0.1794779896736145,
0.6762589812278748,
0.4611389935016632,
0.6899621486663818,
0.3375481367111206,
0.05000396445393562,
-0.7055012583732605,
0.45739737153053284,
-0.10771068185567856,
-0.5942129492759705,
-0.7640155553817749,
-0.6576871275901794,
-1.1803480386734009,
0.277251273393631,
-0.6484164595603943,
-0.9320763945579529,
-0.09662681818008423,
0.2807515263557434,
-0.4322406053543091,
0.3907255232334137,
-0.5634404420852661,
1.0140901803970337,
-0.337363064289093,
-0.5470120906829834,
-0.25592705607414246,
-0.8123248815536499,
0.19913364946842194,
0.025674128904938698,
0.21371503174304962,
-0.1537269949913025,
0.35407015681266785,
0.8490692377090454,
-0.38517093658447266,
0.42982810735702515,
0.08360005915164948,
-0.026851249858736992,
-0.2890978753566742,
0.31525763869285583,
0.424662709236145,
0.08939312398433685,
-0.45708829164505005,
0.16464033722877502,
0.07615920901298523,
-0.45684096217155457,
-0.5427672266960144,
0.9115418791770935,
-0.8648279905319214,
-0.5680434703826904,
-0.3967767655849457,
-0.47582581639289856,
-0.46804162859916687,
0.24163639545440674,
0.34401556849479675,
0.5391339063644409,
-0.00639640586450696,
0.24323365092277527,
0.5469806790351868,
-0.18259458243846893,
0.17242075502872467,
0.1378350853919983,
-0.6697781682014465,
-0.2614251375198364,
1.048196792602539,
0.22505535185337067,
0.42213767766952515,
0.5651912689208984,
0.4300272464752197,
-0.4852844476699829,
-0.4936613142490387,
-0.2400752156972885,
0.08515828847885132,
-0.4696958661079407,
-0.27532899379730225,
-0.2504807710647583,
-0.16147640347480774,
-0.618735134601593,
-0.16582904756069183,
-0.34290140867233276,
-0.5923647284507751,
0.2057114541530609,
-0.024227628484368324,
0.25358766317367554,
0.7994074821472168,
0.05662635713815689,
-0.05051947385072708,
-0.5899748206138611,
0.067509226500988,
0.45128896832466125,
0.7833377718925476,
0.01824021339416504,
-0.4534119665622711,
-0.13709014654159546,
0.0018253129674121737,
-0.013799134641885757,
-0.6051139235496521,
0.35839205980300903,
0.0683021992444992,
0.6892425417900085,
0.5285451412200928,
0.16565990447998047,
0.4614356458187103,
-0.2605368196964264,
0.5699201226234436,
0.14921413362026215,
-0.7157535552978516,
0.38932856917381287,
-0.5851372480392456,
0.06374168395996094,
0.613759458065033,
0.06463275104761124,
-0.6767181754112244,
-0.41140878200531006,
-0.9002640843391418,
-0.7806580066680908,
0.6540634632110596,
0.3292981684207916,
-0.295261949300766,
0.045704327523708344,
-0.04090048745274544,
0.09391292929649353,
0.29167816042900085,
-0.5149657726287842,
-0.21629521250724792,
0.06803415715694427,
-0.20496788620948792,
-0.47391775250434875,
-0.09470410645008087,
0.039949916303157806,
-0.28329798579216003,
0.8695514798164368,
0.025935906916856766,
0.10638599097728729,
-0.4937146008014679,
0.011401576921343803,
-0.2608436048030853,
0.26582100987434387,
0.39795154333114624,
0.7201513648033142,
-0.6715803742408752,
0.37321770191192627,
0.04400169849395752,
-0.1203508973121643,
-0.10192573070526123,
0.21835225820541382,
-0.09170456975698471,
-0.1563977152109146,
0.15522749722003937,
0.8078916668891907,
0.5756742358207703,
-0.7766377329826355,
0.6207173466682434,
-0.055061642080545425,
0.20228463411331177,
-0.31398648023605347,
-0.06467278301715851,
0.3181011974811554,
0.208563894033432,
0.1288495659828186,
0.19499340653419495,
0.12519998848438263,
-0.4308909773826599,
0.05954534932971001,
0.5761452913284302,
-0.26806187629699707,
-0.2578248679637909,
0.49720802903175354,
0.2790825068950653,
-0.53631991147995,
0.5380803942680359,
-0.2453957051038742,
-0.7072809934616089,
0.4364468455314636,
0.2537698745727539,
0.49150964617729187,
-0.279669851064682,
0.12900018692016602,
0.434660404920578,
0.0708223506808281,
-0.5845637321472168,
-0.04636087268590927,
0.008719238452613354,
-0.924800455570221,
-0.1260118931531906,
-0.7430957555770874,
-0.5620346665382385,
-0.07357556372880936,
-0.693126380443573,
0.4747573137283325,
-0.19361501932144165,
-0.32286587357521057,
0.1948670595884323,
0.1951056867837906,
-0.55533766746521,
-0.039499398320913315,
0.2955784201622009,
0.5416339039802551,
-0.8733924031257629,
0.7545213103294373,
0.54269939661026,
-0.2676548659801483,
-0.698416531085968,
0.08507675677537918,
-0.07831018418073654,
-0.7006801962852478,
0.4075988531112671,
0.08930297195911407,
-0.09623073786497116,
-0.12985630333423615,
-0.42143163084983826,
-1.1446284055709839,
0.995598316192627,
0.4194604456424713,
-0.5867940187454224,
0.10256409645080566,
-0.04970690980553627,
0.41447004675865173,
-0.18068040907382965,
0.3396146893501282,
0.46459320187568665,
0.5138243436813354,
-0.05391603708267212,
-1.371288776397705,
-0.06171950697898865,
-0.27633896470069885,
-0.2581130862236023,
0.5452996492385864,
-0.6044707298278809,
0.6729626059532166,
-0.2271139919757843,
0.036442432552576065,
0.012428861111402512,
0.5577809810638428,
0.5071170926094055,
0.26657989621162415,
0.8014362454414368,
0.3102978765964508,
0.9989948272705078,
0.004670893307775259,
1.006564736366272,
-0.4429247975349426,
0.4759778380393982,
1.1532015800476074,
-0.39651069045066833,
1.2673892974853516,
0.21456803381443024,
-0.4046207368373871,
0.1737828254699707,
0.7664162516593933,
0.12370288372039795,
0.2587917447090149,
0.11279784888029099,
0.0523531399667263,
-0.8545221090316772,
-0.06880220770835876,
-0.4129015803337097,
0.39739474654197693,
0.15345045924186707,
-0.3096711039543152,
0.13027864694595337,
-0.47331663966178894,
0.017304837703704834,
0.13035999238491058,
-0.2095666527748108,
0.6810024380683899,
0.020190317183732986,
-1.0101585388183594,
0.5940708518028259,
-0.09785885363817215,
0.7228320837020874,
-0.4737633764743805,
0.10455246269702911,
-0.03208763524889946,
0.03208553045988083,
-0.2432073950767517,
-1.024759292602539,
-0.2836530804634094,
-0.1182384043931961,
-0.29125434160232544,
-0.24496330320835114,
0.6752020716667175,
-0.6862599849700928,
-0.5888901948928833,
0.3203040063381195,
0.41912180185317993,
0.17061886191368103,
-0.24065543711185455,
-0.40344640612602234,
-0.013859854079782963,
-0.21502062678337097,
-0.2724264860153198,
0.6583326458930969,
-0.14026673138141632,
-0.357095867395401,
0.6758642792701721,
0.5141660571098328,
0.1618785560131073,
-0.23013520240783691,
0.19849851727485657,
0.4825669229030609,
-0.31845366954803467,
-0.6766782402992249,
-0.9385947585105896,
0.11852528899908066,
-0.36659476161003113,
-0.2485780417919159,
0.614285945892334,
0.55967777967453,
0.5712655186653137,
0.3673573136329651,
0.8650729060173035,
0.09900553524494171,
0.3918253481388092,
-0.33220145106315613,
0.939242959022522,
-0.5677843689918518,
0.28730258345603943,
-0.4479275047779083,
-1.1464909315109253,
-0.2988680899143219,
0.6184912919998169,
-0.5919113755226135,
-0.006975934375077486,
0.3054775297641754,
0.9625144600868225,
-0.11210097372531891,
-0.11796992272138596,
0.6195944547653198,
0.23659993708133698,
0.18059271574020386,
0.3787940442562103,
0.6305006742477417,
-0.015295435674488544,
0.3477467894554138,
-0.2647322118282318,
-0.3798730671405792,
-0.5099477767944336,
-0.9440802931785583,
-0.7913799285888672,
-0.7890725135803223,
0.0067947967909276485,
-0.6627885103225708,
0.022456059232354164,
1.4976900815963745,
0.8696905374526978,
-0.8993083834648132,
-0.42090341448783875,
0.449468731880188,
0.3364730179309845,
-0.36678004264831543,
-0.14180085062980652,
0.4740275740623474,
0.10823562741279602,
-0.8239536285400391,
0.32682421803474426,
0.04494696483016014,
-0.16649122536182404,
-0.33118483424186707,
-0.27981746196746826,
-0.0018157000886276364,
-0.014997770078480244,
0.3695990741252899,
0.14552399516105652,
-0.7424117922782898,
-0.524645984172821,
0.036621686071157455,
-0.21621909737586975,
-0.026902560144662857,
0.4944995939731598,
-0.5348861813545227,
0.4429665207862854,
0.707472026348114,
0.3909044861793518,
0.16528944671154022,
-0.0001889361592475325,
0.7849549055099487,
-0.888334333896637,
-0.04939619079232216,
0.09395474195480347,
0.49728548526763916,
0.44871318340301514,
-0.20926833152770996,
0.3422538638114929,
-0.034470755606889725,
-0.7790536284446716,
-0.9893917441368103,
0.22760865092277527,
-1.1286782026290894,
-0.2156299352645874,
1.4559569358825684,
0.12171408534049988,
0.17463216185569763,
0.11770826578140259,
-0.02605811506509781,
0.05236480385065079,
-0.7049566507339478,
1.0074151754379272,
0.7857418656349182,
-0.09467480331659317,
0.3200993239879608,
-0.40130379796028137,
0.5138197541236877,
0.38732123374938965,
-0.5843116641044617,
0.29515498876571655,
0.34754398465156555,
0.2838689982891083,
0.14394822716712952,
0.36472880840301514,
0.2011525183916092,
0.029517164453864098,
-0.20010246336460114,
0.02728375606238842,
0.13085536658763885,
-0.26342207193374634,
-0.23963312804698944,
0.2513490915298462,
0.5579860210418701,
0.1927674412727356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17764v1
|
The Era of 1-bit LLMs: All Large Language Models are in 1.58 Bits
| 2024-02-27T18:56:19 | 2024-02-27T18:56:19 |
Shuming Ma, Hongyu Wang, Lingxiao Ma, Lei Wang, Wenhui Wang, Shaohan Huang, Li Dong, Ruiping Wang, Jilong Xue, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent research, such as BitNet, is paving the way for a new era of 1-bit
Large Language Models (LLMs). In this work, we introduce a 1-bit LLM variant,
namely BitNet b1.58, in which every single parameter (or weight) of the LLM is
ternary {-1, 0, 1}. It matches the full-precision (i.e., FP16 or BF16)
Transformer LLM with the same model size and training tokens in terms of both
perplexity and end-task performance, while being significantly more
cost-effective in terms of latency, memory, throughput, and energy consumption.
More profoundly, the 1.58-bit LLM defines a new scaling law and recipe for
training new generations of LLMs that are both high-performance and
cost-effective. Furthermore, it enables a new computation paradigm and opens
the door for designing specific hardware optimized for 1-bit LLMs.
|
[
-0.3678825795650482,
-0.6067934036254883,
0.29912373423576355,
0.5040371417999268,
-0.3904808461666107,
-0.16221199929714203,
-0.28678256273269653,
-0.37950292229652405,
0.38778072595596313,
0.6921868920326233,
-0.46816834807395935,
-0.2111353874206543,
-0.6688393950462341,
-0.13627435266971588,
-0.4032219350337982,
0.4388726055622101,
0.2787844240665436,
0.014140152372419834,
0.10467085242271423,
-0.01867484487593174,
-0.08470956236124039,
-0.4460277259349823,
-0.856432318687439,
-0.44148796796798706,
0.7243406176567078,
0.4810830354690552,
0.7808610796928406,
0.7909300327301025,
0.7155303359031677,
0.28382933139801025,
-0.17791005969047546,
-0.3621099591255188,
-0.3179154098033905,
-0.02594161219894886,
0.03655325621366501,
-0.5761412382125854,
-0.8311813473701477,
-0.026222681626677513,
0.8818172216415405,
0.9391308426856995,
-0.05754701420664787,
0.37197238206863403,
-0.34938302636146545,
1.0036752223968506,
-0.3077526092529297,
-0.1984158307313919,
-0.8593876361846924,
0.12116854637861252,
-0.2613043189048767,
-0.255304217338562,
-0.5593723654747009,
-0.2153775990009308,
-0.06127650663256645,
-0.4114072322845459,
0.1773548424243927,
0.10544024407863617,
0.7025541067123413,
0.30127376317977905,
-0.16600745916366577,
0.08177623152732849,
-0.6132773160934448,
0.6985033750534058,
-0.9300069808959961,
0.6257109642028809,
-0.04303492605686188,
0.3351772427558899,
-0.0504242405295372,
-0.804382860660553,
-0.3666995167732239,
0.11196602880954742,
0.24623547494411469,
-0.5256562232971191,
-0.6230016350746155,
0.2561880350112915,
0.13261868059635162,
0.45503515005111694,
-0.49291637539863586,
0.37130215764045715,
-0.5286524295806885,
-0.012124869972467422,
0.39383840560913086,
0.2191707044839859,
-0.12992718815803528,
0.08694279938936234,
-0.45351892709732056,
0.2519083619117737,
-1.034912109375,
-0.1829189658164978,
0.44275689125061035,
0.6808898448944092,
-0.23627705872058868,
0.19215869903564453,
-0.22784140706062317,
0.5238131284713745,
0.21911394596099854,
-0.07945585995912552,
0.11026304960250854,
-0.10873442143201828,
-0.28789225220680237,
0.309260755777359,
0.8386914730072021,
0.12933793663978577,
0.39219439029693604,
-0.2664174437522888,
-0.17580123245716095,
-0.15869688987731934,
0.43957626819610596,
-1.0820550918579102,
-0.19823795557022095,
0.019292742013931274,
-0.4341801702976227,
-0.5893735289573669,
-0.07505030184984207,
-0.37398165464401245,
-0.3469310402870178,
-0.14301401376724243,
0.6248809695243835,
-0.17990988492965698,
-0.476922869682312,
0.5390880107879639,
-0.019445929676294327,
0.4084930121898651,
0.3648737370967865,
-0.9929506182670593,
0.531425416469574,
0.9286134243011475,
0.6952924728393555,
-0.000004119343429920264,
-0.029694464057683945,
-0.15079791843891144,
-0.2907106280326843,
-0.5202397108078003,
0.24411389231681824,
-0.49915528297424316,
-0.18871262669563293,
-0.13811679184436798,
-0.07005885988473892,
0.4892812967300415,
-0.6362965703010559,
-0.09761674702167511,
-0.8009772896766663,
-0.10079367458820343,
-0.1216612383723259,
-0.4387456178665161,
-0.08826035261154175,
0.34648820757865906,
-0.9100366830825806,
0.9244543313980103,
0.3029358685016632,
-0.7166756391525269,
0.24528256058692932,
-0.5453289747238159,
-0.6079041957855225,
0.2876089811325073,
-0.08341174572706223,
-0.36331966519355774,
0.3408798575401306,
-0.3138042390346527,
0.3153352439403534,
-0.7481849789619446,
0.14801932871341705,
-0.27898353338241577,
-0.7031540870666504,
0.2533932030200958,
-0.9555365443229675,
1.1144816875457764,
0.005426454357802868,
-0.45406869053840637,
-0.09548180550336838,
-0.7730276584625244,
0.021718915551900864,
0.13142593204975128,
-0.6983819007873535,
0.22706468403339386,
-0.15130004286766052,
-0.12072497606277466,
0.2057001143693924,
0.6921407580375671,
-0.7254010438919067,
0.21081379055976868,
-0.45060786604881287,
0.4713427722454071,
0.9342091679573059,
-0.2961153984069824,
0.33242782950401306,
-0.3080326318740845,
0.5659741759300232,
0.041506800800561905,
0.3415524661540985,
-0.3132933974266052,
-0.2024616152048111,
-1.0139917135238647,
-0.17227371037006378,
0.5601798892021179,
0.26803526282310486,
-0.405135840177536,
0.5348449945449829,
-0.7372165322303772,
-0.5895199179649353,
-0.6191375851631165,
0.04862181842327118,
0.21573519706726074,
0.08576750755310059,
0.27850696444511414,
-0.14863114058971405,
-0.6688846945762634,
-1.0447626113891602,
0.19288761913776398,
-0.30671632289886475,
-0.04473329707980156,
0.2355271279811859,
0.12944680452346802,
-0.00570961507037282,
0.8577771782875061,
-0.15275368094444275,
0.2848207652568817,
-0.38147208094596863,
-0.11930568516254425,
0.44468656182289124,
0.6502442359924316,
0.24083009362220764,
-0.7525497674942017,
-0.38828983902931213,
-0.04580191150307655,
-0.5102773308753967,
-0.09557090699672699,
0.0021685860119760036,
0.07514271140098572,
0.3730979263782501,
0.5865203738212585,
-0.3371926546096802,
0.3140648603439331,
0.6012126207351685,
-0.4019297957420349,
0.6013013124465942,
-0.1975403130054474,
-0.07407402992248535,
-0.9401341676712036,
0.0025201928801834583,
-0.004956102464348078,
-0.404552161693573,
-0.6610184907913208,
-0.008119996637105942,
0.22600650787353516,
0.20164898037910461,
-0.8579139709472656,
0.599917471408844,
-0.21936966478824615,
0.08107729256153107,
-0.26701703667640686,
-0.24995264410972595,
-0.19626609981060028,
0.4770963788032532,
-0.34309032559394836,
0.9979051947593689,
0.7486681938171387,
-0.598567545413971,
0.3790551722049713,
-0.1927327811717987,
0.002242480404675007,
0.3152287006378174,
-0.8353158235549927,
0.09829653054475784,
-0.2175266146659851,
0.02780694141983986,
-0.8045526742935181,
0.389213889837265,
-0.2260800153017044,
-0.5119232535362244,
0.594169020652771,
-0.3146389126777649,
-0.6157964468002319,
-0.12032143771648407,
-0.46006208658218384,
0.5116420984268188,
0.48816820979118347,
-0.5576027631759644,
0.7112287878990173,
0.1983800232410431,
0.001708716037683189,
-0.4890781342983246,
-0.9424455165863037,
0.2894470691680908,
-0.1933138370513916,
-0.7245712876319885,
0.2336941510438919,
-0.05579846352338791,
-0.15913531184196472,
-0.1782863289117813,
-0.23929302394390106,
0.014569655060768127,
0.3116505742073059,
0.18160834908485413,
0.41206228733062744,
-0.7187191843986511,
0.06721705943346024,
-0.1950540691614151,
-0.3814237117767334,
0.27545392513275146,
-0.6987752914428711,
0.7778679728507996,
-0.3127739131450653,
-0.07394169270992279,
0.023713404312729836,
0.2666112780570984,
0.5627456307411194,
-0.009650046937167645,
0.617810845375061,
0.308224618434906,
-0.4115186929702759,
-0.061689890921115875,
-0.7140301465988159,
-0.018219729885458946,
-0.6177977919578552,
0.4632617235183716,
-0.5256028771400452,
-1.1845365762710571,
0.2815379202365875,
-0.005327844526618719,
0.1399165391921997,
0.3698567748069763,
0.4141387343406677,
0.00272879539988935,
0.3039149045944214,
0.7126977443695068,
-0.24270187318325043,
0.5990082025527954,
-0.2308601438999176,
0.2721734046936035,
-0.7619608044624329,
0.11609269678592682,
-0.45679447054862976,
-0.6761584877967834,
-1.0675263404846191,
-0.5422627925872803,
0.5386149883270264,
-0.165963277220726,
-0.79001784324646,
0.5437320470809937,
-0.2918745279312134,
0.7443990111351013,
0.6523089408874512,
0.3911314606666565,
0.1689305603504181,
-0.022627918049693108,
0.10100935399532318,
0.11430329084396362,
-0.8065697550773621,
-0.6556711196899414,
1.3176906108856201,
0.5852290391921997,
0.9390102028846741,
0.28610533475875854,
0.5669552087783813,
0.2410079389810562,
0.023003648966550827,
-0.6602376103401184,
0.9254666566848755,
-0.7204304933547974,
-0.983231246471405,
-0.5826745629310608,
-0.6104816794395447,
-1.0526185035705566,
0.11158409714698792,
-0.06514051556587219,
-0.7391311526298523,
-0.1697680801153183,
0.13163040578365326,
-0.1589687466621399,
0.8215982913970947,
-0.403604120016098,
0.9611569046974182,
-0.05948460102081299,
-0.30368906259536743,
-0.3542584180831909,
-0.8415441513061523,
-0.0181711595505476,
0.10362069308757782,
-0.2874077558517456,
-0.2625022828578949,
-0.21577446162700653,
0.5816952586174011,
-0.1221916675567627,
0.812030553817749,
-0.03940463066101074,
-0.06441480666399002,
0.19036062061786652,
0.5420693159103394,
0.48975756764411926,
-0.2161640077829361,
-0.2293754518032074,
0.4754486680030823,
-0.24554456770420074,
-0.5901172161102295,
-0.3548959493637085,
0.6303622722625732,
-0.5800511837005615,
-0.5960229635238647,
-0.037014808505773544,
-0.5058915019035339,
-0.051747359335422516,
0.04902990162372589,
0.1486770063638687,
0.7774054408073425,
-0.056847602128982544,
0.5513159036636353,
1.161399245262146,
-0.07783083617687225,
0.6191151738166809,
0.6215579509735107,
-0.10007689893245697,
-0.23423020541667938,
0.9326326251029968,
0.12012705206871033,
0.5990464687347412,
0.9319809079170227,
0.26841509342193604,
-0.0414184033870697,
-0.6455153822898865,
-0.42487719655036926,
0.15604038536548615,
-0.8015254139900208,
-0.22011764347553253,
-0.4439813494682312,
-0.32329854369163513,
-0.24573513865470886,
-0.27312275767326355,
-0.6697937250137329,
-0.7051012516021729,
-0.2970143258571625,
0.012024608440697193,
0.2650885581970215,
0.5431798696517944,
-0.028622057288885117,
0.5384633541107178,
-0.6182628870010376,
-0.1348855048418045,
0.5530024170875549,
0.8005229234695435,
-0.060052625834941864,
-0.9039360880851746,
-0.3038683533668518,
-0.36042365431785583,
-0.17647740244865417,
-0.5757753252983093,
-0.2173255980014801,
-0.010055800899863243,
0.24671022593975067,
0.3753424882888794,
-0.35344651341438293,
0.10653626918792725,
-0.6680061221122742,
0.7722516059875488,
0.40081357955932617,
-0.8968330025672913,
0.052428558468818665,
-0.20917943120002747,
0.4442129135131836,
0.5242490768432617,
0.3054884374141693,
-0.7122876644134521,
0.018535848706960678,
-0.7196794748306274,
-0.8016253113746643,
0.6118912696838379,
-0.1353953778743744,
0.41760480403900146,
0.14874546229839325,
0.2365380823612213,
0.2991526424884796,
0.3811136782169342,
-0.7134292721748352,
-0.8516968488693237,
0.13028664886951447,
-0.4129536747932434,
0.12746009230613708,
-0.3648777902126312,
0.3736519515514374,
-0.2114260345697403,
0.798947811126709,
-0.15414774417877197,
0.45851412415504456,
-0.3265046179294586,
0.03774840757250786,
-0.25156310200691223,
0.410092294216156,
0.339018851518631,
0.7681407332420349,
-0.17948158085346222,
0.659252941608429,
0.3330574929714203,
-0.4092455506324768,
0.36768975853919983,
0.051129791885614395,
-0.2619577944278717,
0.007120937574654818,
0.2482234388589859,
0.9512845873832703,
0.4004438817501068,
-0.4568833112716675,
0.4900830090045929,
0.16411161422729492,
-0.23521031439304352,
-0.1397661715745926,
0.20911112427711487,
0.14849846065044403,
0.3174113929271698,
0.3214475214481354,
-0.34409308433532715,
0.08633258193731308,
-0.30382686853408813,
0.22981254756450653,
0.5501217842102051,
-0.39352288842201233,
-0.3995515704154968,
0.2957880198955536,
0.16032296419143677,
-0.5549051761627197,
0.39252498745918274,
-0.503266453742981,
-0.5810079574584961,
0.4960804283618927,
0.5902162790298462,
0.9763026833534241,
0.05821874365210533,
0.06170681118965149,
0.3270881772041321,
0.7249683141708374,
0.20565766096115112,
0.37231016159057617,
0.10019981861114502,
-0.5696339011192322,
-0.41436946392059326,
-0.7413729429244995,
-0.41664424538612366,
-0.06964684277772903,
-0.19453594088554382,
0.3593898117542267,
-0.7155810594558716,
-0.0512407049536705,
0.13267819583415985,
0.16395916044712067,
-0.638704776763916,
0.42364659905433655,
0.44396135210990906,
1.1355805397033691,
-0.4425564110279083,
0.7480499148368835,
0.5881304740905762,
0.010903229005634785,
-0.5768505334854126,
-0.5211536884307861,
-0.13979744911193848,
-0.8701491355895996,
0.46809062361717224,
-0.002916766330599785,
-0.021395135670900345,
0.03752801939845085,
-0.7218761444091797,
-0.8804859519004822,
0.957532525062561,
0.5824703574180603,
-0.7995656132698059,
-0.1114514172077179,
0.5653777718544006,
0.13354411721229553,
-0.15261565148830414,
0.27424564957618713,
0.6862092614173889,
0.4222317039966583,
0.12294259667396545,
-0.9967567324638367,
0.16838836669921875,
-0.12389067560434341,
0.1191745176911354,
0.8854427933692932,
-0.7831437587738037,
1.0829881429672241,
0.003276411909610033,
-0.0267011858522892,
-0.23225001990795135,
0.6972344517707825,
0.05514029040932655,
-0.1112893596291542,
0.5878127217292786,
0.5257683396339417,
0.5042863488197327,
-0.206620454788208,
0.6302051544189453,
-0.5211724042892456,
0.19072650372982025,
1.0879366397857666,
0.2071993201971054,
0.740906834602356,
0.6987794041633606,
-0.6770646572113037,
0.22907525300979614,
0.2847302556037903,
0.22333620488643646,
-0.012530376203358173,
0.5342392921447754,
-0.4357715845108032,
-0.5786910653114319,
0.09129607677459717,
-0.02912932075560093,
0.18044261634349823,
0.06727191060781479,
-0.15969769656658173,
-0.12327010929584503,
-0.3816527724266052,
0.18594537675380707,
-0.29502567648887634,
-0.35328954458236694,
0.7477756142616272,
-0.0016102653462439775,
-0.09812702238559723,
0.4699687957763672,
0.16893525421619415,
1.0297479629516602,
-0.7309156656265259,
0.17984440922737122,
-0.36967840790748596,
-0.0524999164044857,
0.025877458974719048,
-0.836615264415741,
0.0174347423017025,
0.02330409176647663,
-0.35824358463287354,
-0.06616732478141785,
0.6203268766403198,
-0.34472477436065674,
-0.8240370154380798,
-0.014881686307489872,
0.2372875064611435,
0.20928184688091278,
-0.2728121876716614,
-0.39263567328453064,
0.3760650157928467,
-0.11672188341617584,
-0.20801028609275818,
0.18931619822978973,
0.7715262174606323,
0.32706496119499207,
0.7605920433998108,
0.1753343939781189,
0.312730073928833,
0.4853147864341736,
-0.10046800225973129,
0.8564779758453369,
-0.958899199962616,
-0.4000775218009949,
-0.8948222398757935,
0.40444132685661316,
0.31817784905433655,
-0.40704622864723206,
0.2251182496547699,
0.6320843696594238,
0.6969755291938782,
0.336729496717453,
0.667851448059082,
-0.12332307547330856,
0.0814506858587265,
-0.3635271489620209,
0.31569477915763855,
-0.6479397416114807,
0.25020840764045715,
0.14158110320568085,
-0.6677449345588684,
-0.06339941173791885,
0.3653825521469116,
0.08930801600217819,
0.23880857229232788,
0.48886966705322266,
0.9262484312057495,
-0.08663627505302429,
0.12558165192604065,
0.4463534355163574,
0.024144381284713745,
0.4246448576450348,
0.6937474012374878,
0.25466153025627136,
-0.7583242654800415,
0.5626052021980286,
-0.3772667646408081,
-0.13738605380058289,
-0.25303053855895996,
-1.06361722946167,
-0.6751336455345154,
-0.3474898934364319,
-0.4150852560997009,
-0.28361502289772034,
-0.037128642201423645,
1.451645016670227,
0.8666742444038391,
-0.5925667881965637,
-0.3716343939304352,
-0.05586102977395058,
0.06986778974533081,
0.08826056867837906,
-0.15511375665664673,
-0.12288879603147507,
-0.41772979497909546,
-0.3037828505039215,
0.25954341888427734,
0.5288418531417847,
0.311122328042984,
-0.7559205889701843,
-0.23687823116779327,
-0.057964250445365906,
0.3913566470146179,
0.47344887256622314,
-0.09887970238924026,
-0.5605818033218384,
-0.1457756757736206,
0.10905961692333221,
-0.24681641161441803,
0.6057643890380859,
0.865653932094574,
-0.5767093300819397,
0.29497915506362915,
0.2299528568983078,
0.8335253000259399,
0.7019391655921936,
-0.4794386923313141,
0.23046550154685974,
-0.8780617713928223,
0.07371378690004349,
0.25321587920188904,
0.26194876432418823,
0.45933911204338074,
-0.05817803740501404,
0.4495435357093811,
0.013927768915891647,
-0.4430992007255554,
-0.6283155679702759,
0.15026473999023438,
-1.007045865058899,
-0.13408078253269196,
1.158754587173462,
0.1240011602640152,
-0.3991619646549225,
0.3279586136341095,
0.052433159202337265,
0.08809459209442139,
-0.3073073625564575,
0.5112572908401489,
0.5844915509223938,
0.459490567445755,
-0.14311908185482025,
-0.2548266351222992,
-0.0784672275185585,
0.40099024772644043,
-0.6327018737792969,
0.19960738718509674,
0.14168310165405273,
0.25792834162712097,
0.03405498340725899,
0.5751268267631531,
-0.008627171628177166,
0.2738739252090454,
0.2930443286895752,
0.24476474523544312,
-0.21710219979286194,
-0.6435860395431519,
-0.48712754249572754,
0.16319407522678375,
0.23690825700759888,
-0.21422623097896576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17762v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17762v1
|
Massive Activations in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-27T18:55:17 | 2024-02-27T18:55:17 |
Mingjie Sun, Xinlei Chen, J. Zico Kolter, Zhuang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We observe an empirical phenomenon in Large Language Models (LLMs) -- very
few activations exhibit significantly larger values than others (e.g., 100,000
times larger). We call them massive activations. First, we demonstrate the
widespread existence of massive activations across various LLMs and
characterize their locations. Second, we find their values largely stay
constant regardless of the input, and they function as indispensable bias terms
in LLMs. Third, these massive activations lead to the concentration of
attention probabilities to their corresponding tokens, and further, implicit
bias terms in the self-attention output. Last, we also study massive
activations in Vision Transformers.
|
[
-0.45345839858055115,
-0.8534539937973022,
0.844787061214447,
0.328335702419281,
0.12866704165935516,
-0.18345588445663452,
-0.4264085292816162,
-0.5371899604797363,
0.416878342628479,
0.42094549536705017,
-0.39833635091781616,
-0.08449316024780273,
-0.8526118993759155,
-0.06163005903363228,
-0.7403650879859924,
0.6334484219551086,
0.16139371693134308,
0.1582292914390564,
-0.1034708321094513,
-0.4094561040401459,
-0.20933189988136292,
-0.7372375726699829,
-0.5745518207550049,
-0.41391927003860474,
0.7761554718017578,
-0.03483255207538605,
0.40892940759658813,
0.2781982123851776,
0.4413171410560608,
0.33508503437042236,
-0.21386726200580597,
-0.2428409606218338,
-0.6134628057479858,
0.14835278689861298,
-0.09317250549793243,
-0.4906063377857208,
-0.25760066509246826,
-0.09829527884721756,
1.1952950954437256,
1.1251462697982788,
0.18323352932929993,
0.16256384551525116,
0.05072683468461037,
0.6165064573287964,
-0.5680345892906189,
0.22564010322093964,
-0.6574146747589111,
-0.006858928129076958,
-0.12864889204502106,
-0.1180136501789093,
-0.5785521268844604,
-0.2608480453491211,
0.16132819652557373,
-0.08985378593206406,
0.0040787807665765285,
-0.13125480711460114,
0.5596415400505066,
0.23089182376861572,
-0.4684615135192871,
-0.069005087018013,
-0.7237048745155334,
0.9049004912376404,
-0.470089316368103,
0.35559871792793274,
0.0669940710067749,
-0.036745619028806686,
-0.26601412892341614,
-0.5078914761543274,
-0.5230062007904053,
-0.5610989332199097,
-0.12218064814805984,
-0.1444898545742035,
-0.34341689944267273,
0.2797966003417969,
0.7896308898925781,
0.4337325096130371,
-0.1939850002527237,
0.4003724455833435,
-0.30228090286254883,
-0.011157607659697533,
0.4372825026512146,
0.319064199924469,
0.3723445534706116,
0.19913499057292938,
-0.22767949104309082,
0.18995091319084167,
-0.9783971905708313,
-0.2909136414527893,
0.31615281105041504,
0.017386125400662422,
0.0018088013166561723,
0.8641564846038818,
-0.12161444127559662,
0.7275773882865906,
0.32343024015426636,
0.005250985734164715,
0.2717110216617584,
-0.19223496317863464,
-0.3732522130012512,
-0.007477230858057737,
0.7060770988464355,
0.11018683016300201,
0.5030810832977295,
-0.18953749537467957,
-0.21813172101974487,
-0.018310407176613808,
0.12106308341026306,
-0.7213743925094604,
0.26044750213623047,
0.3096286654472351,
-0.40408751368522644,
-0.20057271420955658,
-0.14811107516288757,
-0.3732888400554657,
-0.45030567049980164,
-0.25370585918426514,
0.5272279381752014,
0.044022612273693085,
-0.372672438621521,
-0.01957770064473152,
-0.14929042756557465,
0.40663155913352966,
-0.07862813770771027,
-1.3105027675628662,
0.19583241641521454,
0.4495512843132019,
0.6888124346733093,
-0.23010505735874176,
-0.42716899514198303,
-0.5239103436470032,
0.060184936970472336,
-0.4630233645439148,
0.7174243927001953,
-0.5788252949714661,
-0.21874041855335236,
0.3942224681377411,
0.14594697952270508,
-0.05789274722337723,
-0.7576076984405518,
0.18354426324367523,
-0.9037151336669922,
-0.11818896979093552,
-0.2949835956096649,
-0.5634332299232483,
-0.12510213255882263,
0.09886009991168976,
-0.8101855516433716,
0.989606499671936,
0.056430332362651825,
-0.4023105800151825,
0.5263159275054932,
-0.7665678262710571,
-0.3900015354156494,
0.2010495364665985,
-0.07309138029813766,
-0.11437665671110153,
0.6276195049285889,
-0.27207157015800476,
0.5477359294891357,
-0.2240469604730606,
0.2379533350467682,
-0.44593262672424316,
-0.2619140148162842,
0.6530720591545105,
-0.5298519134521484,
0.6925947070121765,
-0.19709868729114532,
-0.5312387943267822,
0.34634050726890564,
-0.4009353816509247,
-0.19958120584487915,
0.1575496941804886,
-0.3346744477748871,
-0.30276986956596375,
-0.0101857865229249,
-0.027562113478779793,
0.32346057891845703,
0.27400773763656616,
-0.3808598220348358,
0.42876216769218445,
-0.3622462749481201,
0.4211045205593109,
0.6800892949104309,
0.21807220578193665,
0.6496140360832214,
0.22894111275672913,
0.46551138162612915,
0.23473376035690308,
0.0039620003663003445,
-0.2889605760574341,
-0.43045100569725037,
-0.9882055521011353,
-0.3946359157562256,
0.20780478417873383,
0.07242559641599655,
-0.25696438550949097,
0.5105284452438354,
-0.32842543721199036,
-0.20248165726661682,
0.01290934905409813,
0.30541279911994934,
0.107492595911026,
0.12470301240682602,
-0.03191240131855011,
-0.12246646732091904,
-0.2352149486541748,
-1.2651267051696777,
-0.16795094311237335,
0.1952866017818451,
-0.24603624641895294,
0.18028393387794495,
0.5398810505867004,
-0.5490942597389221,
0.852545440196991,
-0.4484088718891144,
-0.4243621826171875,
-0.44007202982902527,
0.23954910039901733,
0.31801366806030273,
0.19090916216373444,
0.48772040009498596,
-0.6683072447776794,
-0.3301035761833191,
-0.1364019811153412,
-0.6786889433860779,
-0.36597371101379395,
-0.3946211338043213,
0.046231430023908615,
0.29607290029525757,
0.8516713976860046,
-0.6419643759727478,
0.2909621298313141,
0.6946863532066345,
-0.28437885642051697,
0.47639307379722595,
-0.2036365419626236,
-0.15920259058475494,
-0.7242446541786194,
0.10783582180738449,
0.2944314181804657,
-0.18253272771835327,
-0.7806861996650696,
0.003194183809682727,
0.16529060900211334,
0.2785102427005768,
-0.5782923698425293,
0.658017098903656,
-0.638216495513916,
-0.5128050446510315,
-0.4009130001068115,
0.15903976559638977,
-0.40252798795700073,
0.5359774231910706,
0.01022398006170988,
0.5913618206977844,
0.7164704203605652,
-0.5906372666358948,
0.5306124091148376,
-0.05186332017183304,
-0.5737080574035645,
0.16204865276813507,
-0.7426905035972595,
-0.18158477544784546,
-0.29341474175453186,
0.3899001479148865,
-1.185397982597351,
-0.4144468307495117,
-0.10821500420570374,
-0.04986954480409622,
0.3115864396095276,
-0.22646324336528778,
-0.8333334922790527,
-0.3963167369365692,
-0.2588452398777008,
0.5654699802398682,
0.4426536560058594,
-0.5500236749649048,
0.5878894925117493,
0.584137499332428,
-0.08827672153711319,
-0.48066070675849915,
-0.6656718254089355,
0.09947068244218826,
-0.3009287714958191,
-0.4660739004611969,
-0.17624270915985107,
0.014953448437154293,
-0.41448482871055603,
-0.011381596326828003,
0.13341861963272095,
0.09256915748119354,
0.013058848679065704,
0.605251133441925,
0.26517003774642944,
-0.15520384907722473,
0.19266967475414276,
-0.0635964572429657,
-0.0744391530752182,
0.35204723477363586,
-0.4371972680091858,
0.9526790380477905,
-0.050422463566064835,
-0.5704073309898376,
-0.3787829577922821,
0.3259161114692688,
1.0391554832458496,
-0.20949538052082062,
0.8593351244926453,
0.4201596677303314,
-0.3901664614677429,
-0.02031240612268448,
-0.7830673456192017,
-0.3273894786834717,
-0.5028865337371826,
0.7060216069221497,
-0.21919044852256775,
-1.1593992710113525,
0.9199811816215515,
-0.0619395449757576,
0.03588314354419708,
0.6447056531906128,
1.1214139461517334,
0.29518604278564453,
1.444375991821289,
0.3553024232387543,
-0.08919510245323181,
0.920001745223999,
-0.20382492244243622,
0.1826697587966919,
-1.1832154989242554,
-0.25190097093582153,
-0.08957145363092422,
-0.49426931142807007,
-0.35597744584083557,
-0.37170982360839844,
0.46410226821899414,
-0.1451554149389267,
-0.23952631652355194,
-0.11769167333841324,
-0.149673730134964,
0.7234185338020325,
0.48300716280937195,
-0.11725263297557831,
-0.07414092868566513,
0.15281344950199127,
0.0547403022646904,
-0.010522015392780304,
-0.6174640655517578,
-0.13003970682621002,
1.2537096738815308,
0.5956895351409912,
0.7896292209625244,
0.010907638818025589,
0.2842743694782257,
0.2787229120731354,
0.7104461193084717,
-0.9923835396766663,
0.5868393182754517,
0.1451951563358307,
-0.9976723194122314,
-0.5200324058532715,
-0.16008880734443665,
-1.1280996799468994,
0.1481279581785202,
-0.3084723949432373,
-0.858966052532196,
0.14375802874565125,
-0.049108315259218216,
-0.2521025240421295,
0.09132764488458633,
-0.6571725606918335,
0.8021542429924011,
-0.24196670949459076,
-0.6322661638259888,
-0.4433634877204895,
-0.20874105393886566,
0.5004323124885559,
-0.24762628972530365,
0.04532017558813095,
-0.03099067322909832,
-0.10159668326377869,
0.6653239130973816,
-0.03917146846652031,
0.9465087652206421,
-0.09100248664617538,
-0.44489577412605286,
0.23479868471622467,
-0.020367367193102837,
0.6566280126571655,
-0.11203265190124512,
0.34092533588409424,
0.2771279513835907,
-0.6569716930389404,
-0.5072373747825623,
-0.36260268092155457,
0.955886960029602,
-0.6311163902282715,
-0.7080588936805725,
-0.27628418803215027,
-0.6516194343566895,
-0.16119129955768585,
0.34488463401794434,
0.1971278041601181,
0.7065230011940002,
-0.09802859276533127,
0.3012259304523468,
0.9350276589393616,
-0.19660502672195435,
0.43515631556510925,
0.33168619871139526,
-0.4955902695655823,
-0.07396657764911652,
0.7676542401313782,
0.3631656765937805,
0.6886685490608215,
0.06747298687696457,
0.005407476332038641,
-0.35598137974739075,
-0.5422433018684387,
-0.2729872167110443,
0.4869323670864105,
-0.7663823962211609,
0.25530704855918884,
-0.9012747406959534,
-0.19117861986160278,
-0.046937622129917145,
-0.17266206443309784,
-0.21678118407726288,
-0.35562241077423096,
-0.11521433293819427,
-0.21877436339855194,
0.028754977509379387,
0.8856631517410278,
-0.018002640455961227,
0.37641024589538574,
-0.7248842120170593,
0.3789210319519043,
0.724825382232666,
0.48748108744621277,
0.2175823450088501,
-0.6476501822471619,
-0.4938860535621643,
-0.13381703197956085,
0.028597990050911903,
-0.8147956132888794,
0.3769993484020233,
-0.019227853044867516,
0.6934439539909363,
0.8952210545539856,
-0.5477671027183533,
0.32141366600990295,
-0.6841859221458435,
0.8803852200508118,
0.30512893199920654,
-0.8213251233100891,
-0.06552557647228241,
-0.6650125980377197,
0.5430225729942322,
0.18067556619644165,
0.36882150173187256,
-0.5677475929260254,
-0.5884971022605896,
-0.684028148651123,
-0.9344078302383423,
0.6673616766929626,
-0.23611889779567719,
0.6545528173446655,
-0.09951362758874893,
0.3678518533706665,
-0.1804572492837906,
0.10995546728372574,
-0.9134118556976318,
-0.41382643580436707,
0.43284857273101807,
-0.019743124023079872,
-0.03167720139026642,
-0.811566174030304,
-0.3154732584953308,
-0.1288326531648636,
0.35667359828948975,
-0.07074489444494247,
0.34176892042160034,
-0.1813891977071762,
-0.25915199518203735,
-0.3661753535270691,
0.12413285672664642,
0.8149654865264893,
0.8322410583496094,
-0.03777552768588066,
0.2423180639743805,
0.502851128578186,
-0.5314162969589233,
0.034351080656051636,
-0.41682061553001404,
0.017182165756821632,
-0.15856994688510895,
0.4047483205795288,
0.8031243681907654,
0.4667978286743164,
-0.7750735282897949,
0.5791666507720947,
0.11434070765972137,
-0.2686828076839447,
-0.6507338881492615,
0.13938717544078827,
0.2826799154281616,
0.301477313041687,
0.6281179189682007,
-0.1736726611852646,
0.0455961748957634,
-0.6926147937774658,
0.06838425993919373,
0.7940787076950073,
-0.5301032066345215,
-0.37066954374313354,
0.7398639917373657,
0.2711566984653473,
0.11861400306224823,
0.5212289094924927,
-0.15369386970996857,
-0.8753094673156738,
0.7108122110366821,
0.5847130417823792,
1.1422452926635742,
-0.04307674244046211,
-0.12527288496494293,
0.2782551944255829,
0.4860615134239197,
-0.19916965067386627,
-0.029758989810943604,
0.148267462849617,
-0.6652937531471252,
-0.911008894443512,
-0.5514775514602661,
-0.15977634489536285,
0.4108133316040039,
-0.3893863260746002,
0.16370472311973572,
-0.39156386256217957,
-0.051294516772031784,
0.3358493149280548,
-0.2839914560317993,
-0.47884100675582886,
0.09604038298130035,
0.6869555711746216,
0.6816442608833313,
-1.1969265937805176,
0.8819407224655151,
0.5892009735107422,
-0.13986830413341522,
-0.43652525544166565,
-0.007989156059920788,
-0.16229955852031708,
-0.88718181848526,
1.2767796516418457,
0.21807411313056946,
0.12685388326644897,
0.04503675550222397,
-0.7536435723304749,
-1.103333830833435,
0.7196477651596069,
0.24251689016819,
-0.567442774772644,
0.12843795120716095,
0.4154503643512726,
0.667138397693634,
-0.49092647433280945,
0.2042951136827469,
0.5852990746498108,
0.6269649863243103,
0.004898194223642349,
-0.5786060690879822,
0.03186902776360512,
0.06866376847028732,
-0.07896630465984344,
0.47896912693977356,
-0.7647502422332764,
0.7143958806991577,
-0.07819931209087372,
-0.12109684944152832,
-0.2676791846752167,
0.46025803685188293,
0.010093459859490395,
-0.20745469629764557,
0.5405282974243164,
0.5879855751991272,
0.33778172731399536,
-0.10593380779027939,
1.2451494932174683,
-0.4665922522544861,
0.35931694507598877,
0.5764368176460266,
-0.16370443999767303,
0.5831841826438904,
0.45167016983032227,
-0.22260072827339172,
0.21018560230731964,
0.29387861490249634,
-0.009884935803711414,
0.08648218214511871,
0.28180253505706787,
-0.42325466871261597,
-0.6260421872138977,
-0.14325019717216492,
-0.22442270815372467,
0.0495116300880909,
0.6672991514205933,
-0.5629847645759583,
0.1177898645401001,
0.02351425401866436,
0.0795782133936882,
-0.5406932830810547,
-0.529101550579071,
0.6687155365943909,
0.06042252853512764,
-0.5561351776123047,
0.5761593580245972,
-0.3634313642978668,
0.5022374391555786,
-0.7869884967803955,
0.24369747936725616,
-0.22121624648571014,
0.20008842647075653,
-0.30208197236061096,
-0.8763009905815125,
0.045757271349430084,
0.030307427048683167,
-0.4784366488456726,
-0.14846272766590118,
0.6084892749786377,
-0.40268635749816895,
-0.384568452835083,
0.4115288555622101,
0.10081187635660172,
0.03775423765182495,
-0.3394796848297119,
-0.19848935306072235,
0.24050875008106232,
-0.019978713244199753,
-0.6950278282165527,
0.7274691462516785,
0.41000688076019287,
-0.09167013317346573,
0.6490443348884583,
0.8154211640357971,
0.16253532469272614,
0.5582156777381897,
0.1028054803609848,
0.9041981101036072,
-0.6914868354797363,
-0.25069111585617065,
-0.9746561646461487,
0.41784363985061646,
-0.19345982372760773,
-0.2248399555683136,
0.9187885522842407,
0.5952290296554565,
0.4604102075099945,
-0.15118929743766785,
0.6768271923065186,
0.1368752419948578,
-0.05399724468588829,
-0.276851087808609,
0.5732606649398804,
-0.6065963506698608,
0.12891432642936707,
-0.11373064666986465,
-1.4840809106826782,
-0.468892365694046,
0.18687929213047028,
-0.6634477376937866,
-0.14388969540596008,
0.6404850482940674,
0.5808049440383911,
0.12637916207313538,
-0.32914724946022034,
0.5514214038848877,
0.6246589422225952,
0.21776387095451355,
0.35250937938690186,
1.0087463855743408,
0.0037456639111042023,
0.2571955621242523,
0.3209802210330963,
-0.37291398644447327,
-0.6096047759056091,
-0.7237374186515808,
-0.8604700565338135,
-0.48550739884376526,
-0.2699154317378998,
-0.35469985008239746,
-0.38302499055862427,
0.7877129316329956,
0.5758630037307739,
-0.8511378765106201,
-0.1073034405708313,
-0.00908895954489708,
0.11532723903656006,
-0.010250196792185307,
-0.17327474057674408,
0.23944605886936188,
-0.47655078768730164,
-1.0466587543487549,
0.1688210517168045,
0.5702212452888489,
0.02792692743241787,
-0.6677268743515015,
0.26280951499938965,
-0.0392843633890152,
0.4034622311592102,
0.9050478935241699,
0.3656150698661804,
-0.45550718903541565,
-0.32193389534950256,
-0.09041384607553482,
-0.35483017563819885,
-0.017596587538719177,
0.7310556173324585,
-0.7230684757232666,
0.22577844560146332,
0.5305176377296448,
0.4922278821468353,
0.5666606426239014,
-0.2254582792520523,
0.394736111164093,
-0.6259739398956299,
0.48694509267807007,
-0.002386883134022355,
0.5273323059082031,
0.011315392330288887,
-0.001977180363610387,
0.34233492612838745,
0.07639176398515701,
-0.6824679374694824,
-0.9777542352676392,
0.45309025049209595,
-1.1724263429641724,
-0.04455964267253876,
1.6871155500411987,
0.20873580873012543,
-0.2553447484970093,
0.09664943814277649,
-0.1840893030166626,
-0.13738319277763367,
-0.11267063021659851,
0.7537274360656738,
0.9170271754264832,
-0.12462867796421051,
0.09985804557800293,
-0.7598071098327637,
0.30350348353385925,
0.6729156970977783,
-0.6048009991645813,
0.32637664675712585,
0.7174049615859985,
0.2261296808719635,
0.4850142002105713,
0.139044851064682,
-0.15835623443126678,
0.17485514283180237,
0.011074479669332504,
-0.05028987675905228,
0.3150945007801056,
-0.12680475413799286,
-0.6802924871444702,
0.42769521474838257,
0.2558148205280304,
0.15380455553531647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17759v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17759v2
|
Towards Optimal Learning of Language Models
| 2024-02-27T18:52:19 | 2024-03-03T15:07:50 |
Yuxian Gu, Li Dong, Yaru Hao, Qingxiu Dong, Minlie Huang, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This work studies the general principles of improving the learning of
language models (LMs), which aims at reducing the necessary training steps for
achieving superior performance. Specifically, we present a theory for the
optimal learning of LMs. We first propose an objective that optimizes LM
learning by maximizing the data compression ratio in an
"LM-training-as-lossless-compression" view. Then, we derive a theorem, named
Learning Law, to reveal the properties of the dynamics in the optimal learning
process under our objective. The theorem is then validated by experiments on a
linear classification and a real-world language modeling task. Finally, we
empirically verify that the optimal learning of LMs essentially stems from the
improvement of the coefficients in the scaling law of LMs, indicating great
promise and significance for designing practical learning acceleration methods.
Our code can be found at https://aka.ms/LearningLaw.
|
[
-0.18452633917331696,
-0.664453387260437,
0.4667874276638031,
-0.11430712789297104,
-0.13430190086364746,
-0.1256507784128189,
-0.5527751445770264,
-0.12471999228000641,
-0.10169251263141632,
0.345950722694397,
-0.4509570002555847,
-0.3275085687637329,
-0.450182169675827,
-0.17143847048282623,
-0.47548946738243103,
0.7609059810638428,
0.09960302710533142,
0.4141993224620819,
-0.21833384037017822,
0.03896592929959297,
-0.14278125762939453,
-0.3779436945915222,
-0.767207682132721,
-0.3680596649646759,
0.4194931983947754,
0.39071905612945557,
0.47259142994880676,
1.135706901550293,
0.28067049384117126,
0.24949480593204498,
-0.23850950598716736,
-0.0007437625899910927,
-0.761307954788208,
0.18469740450382233,
0.05051069334149361,
-0.7744891047477722,
0.007353435270488262,
-0.08237842470407486,
0.6732322573661804,
0.7919893860816956,
-0.5392156839370728,
0.06284637004137039,
0.26286426186561584,
0.8407008647918701,
-0.5617668628692627,
0.2974125146865845,
-0.46009066700935364,
-0.03420987352728844,
0.17659738659858704,
-0.44570034742355347,
-0.524074912071228,
-0.5439339876174927,
-0.08165103197097778,
-0.43671149015426636,
0.2526834011077881,
0.10328014194965363,
0.869486927986145,
0.0793958455324173,
-0.3247303366661072,
-0.37292858958244324,
-0.624997615814209,
0.775017261505127,
-0.3607375919818878,
0.682030439376831,
0.33332252502441406,
0.3814884126186371,
-0.026499120518565178,
-0.36654195189476013,
-0.1844056248664856,
-0.4019486904144287,
0.21262721717357635,
-0.2738029658794403,
-0.09629279375076294,
0.33198678493499756,
0.24932682514190674,
0.430587500333786,
-0.6174803376197815,
0.3163378834724426,
-0.5502640604972839,
-0.18228620290756226,
0.5686127543449402,
0.17161960899829865,
0.43585577607154846,
0.5102013349533081,
0.0148775028064847,
-0.06593924015760422,
-0.8277246952056885,
0.19504527747631073,
0.4075303077697754,
0.5423744916915894,
-0.14576421678066254,
0.11184164136648178,
-0.1842464953660965,
0.6566088795661926,
-0.3003515899181366,
-0.4622124135494232,
0.29723864793777466,
-0.03907214105129242,
-0.13526833057403564,
-0.32066312432289124,
0.40185457468032837,
0.18510881066322327,
0.4644722044467926,
-0.3939376771450043,
-0.505676805973053,
-0.021980494260787964,
0.31669387221336365,
-0.7559384703636169,
-0.049246419221162796,
-0.11257190257310867,
-0.422104150056839,
-0.5368170142173767,
-0.2358418107032776,
-0.3891608715057373,
-0.2041131556034088,
-0.7142811417579651,
0.6979599595069885,
-0.22257062792778015,
-0.33540594577789307,
0.3243860602378845,
0.20555199682712555,
0.0036659601610153913,
0.1600738763809204,
-1.1475000381469727,
0.5852113962173462,
0.5376318097114563,
0.6132969856262207,
0.18852782249450684,
-0.12075124680995941,
-0.5694566369056702,
-0.28270411491394043,
-0.5757746696472168,
0.4362512230873108,
-0.38002267479896545,
-0.24250026047229767,
0.42903751134872437,
-0.23546931147575378,
0.008886865340173244,
-0.5794029831886292,
0.6918762922286987,
-0.6457544565200806,
0.08153541386127472,
-0.17271003127098083,
-0.9541376829147339,
-0.19416166841983795,
-0.07811544090509415,
-0.4919363558292389,
0.8050910830497742,
-0.002786681056022644,
-0.17699119448661804,
0.3487870395183563,
-0.9314079880714417,
-0.40896162390708923,
-0.0895838662981987,
0.0299278162419796,
-0.360678493976593,
0.5019803047180176,
-0.2908746898174286,
0.514339804649353,
-0.35020336508750916,
0.14489005506038666,
-0.11900997906923294,
-0.20395813882350922,
-0.016933755949139595,
-0.03419367969036102,
0.6928387880325317,
0.61320960521698,
-0.026000333949923515,
-0.04144260659813881,
-0.7973242998123169,
0.026606416329741478,
0.5018008351325989,
-0.8565590381622314,
-0.37510791420936584,
0.24512989819049835,
-0.2122388631105423,
-0.17040926218032837,
-0.07166209071874619,
-0.3850380778312683,
0.27853530645370483,
-0.4909144341945648,
0.15565183758735657,
0.8530621528625488,
-0.19147102534770966,
0.7781814932823181,
-0.19032719731330872,
0.49472329020500183,
-0.27966833114624023,
0.2894037663936615,
-0.1665443331003189,
0.1174059584736824,
-0.9136927723884583,
-0.06773118674755096,
0.4792923927307129,
0.3153064548969269,
-0.35340526700019836,
0.046887874603271484,
-0.16082260012626648,
-0.07111108303070068,
-0.32531479001045227,
0.5291004776954651,
0.3966479003429413,
0.2791139781475067,
0.37687936425209045,
-0.2867586314678192,
-0.6650494933128357,
-0.5416608452796936,
-0.4967021048069,
-0.2261800915002823,
0.15608592331409454,
0.10214290022850037,
0.19953231513500214,
-0.046913888305425644,
0.7195054888725281,
-0.37764254212379456,
0.18839378654956818,
-0.48039135336875916,
-0.10700155049562454,
0.218192920088768,
0.35915607213974,
0.6858921647071838,
-0.7857955098152161,
-0.6190311908721924,
-0.16090941429138184,
-0.5809402465820312,
-0.49517735838890076,
0.23863175511360168,
0.05737600848078728,
0.15556281805038452,
0.6836973428726196,
-0.21651659905910492,
0.18798016011714935,
0.24440985918045044,
-0.008322302252054214,
0.5589028596878052,
-0.4074659049510956,
-0.3099146783351898,
-0.7654978036880493,
-0.40267014503479004,
0.2959078252315521,
-0.45548683404922485,
-1.1235809326171875,
0.3755722939968109,
0.19699643552303314,
0.12134551256895065,
-0.36603426933288574,
0.4729095697402954,
-0.606511652469635,
0.14225202798843384,
-0.664472222328186,
0.12488140165805817,
-0.4095700681209564,
0.625988245010376,
-0.06656697392463684,
0.5235521793365479,
0.9334976077079773,
-1.0964765548706055,
0.16037216782569885,
-0.46459078788757324,
-0.4323650300502777,
0.14789286255836487,
-0.4766194820404053,
-0.044316671788692474,
-0.4643348753452301,
-0.5297929644584656,
-0.6744814515113831,
0.09962533414363861,
0.0283235851675272,
-0.3038020133972168,
0.6196675300598145,
-0.11866452544927597,
-0.42532211542129517,
-0.17169952392578125,
0.0016733972588554025,
0.08087113499641418,
0.9169023633003235,
-0.6212646961212158,
0.481444388628006,
0.5773977041244507,
0.20112749934196472,
-0.6396351456642151,
-0.2843792736530304,
-0.4105125069618225,
-0.2910270690917969,
-0.055884748697280884,
0.06801404058933258,
-0.25881966948509216,
-0.4340847432613373,
-0.19409115612506866,
-0.04777910187840462,
-0.13948024809360504,
0.2578483521938324,
-0.07072915881872177,
0.07281757146120071,
-0.27118197083473206,
0.48079144954681396,
-0.21461854875087738,
-0.05965733528137207,
0.1652282029390335,
-0.511002242565155,
0.6405332684516907,
-0.12906132638454437,
-0.03906279057264328,
-0.2842659056186676,
-0.09677816182374954,
0.20560868084430695,
0.12641088664531708,
0.8112363219261169,
0.3052305579185486,
-0.290033757686615,
-0.5061511397361755,
-0.4425594210624695,
-0.13059088587760925,
-0.4726581871509552,
0.6140316724777222,
-0.4785628318786621,
-0.7409153580665588,
0.1527927964925766,
-0.2669966220855713,
0.22680014371871948,
0.39666470885276794,
0.6076846122741699,
0.006048102863132954,
1.101047158241272,
1.2465403079986572,
-0.5091394186019897,
0.6857895851135254,
-0.3830937445163727,
0.07021251320838928,
-0.4356280267238617,
-0.09219247102737427,
-0.8067179918289185,
-0.0751555860042572,
-0.3282622992992401,
-0.3801501393318176,
0.16912446916103363,
0.5023897290229797,
-0.371736615896225,
0.39374107122421265,
-0.1618553251028061,
0.8996040225028992,
0.36417093873023987,
0.15513594448566437,
0.049437135457992554,
0.21927055716514587,
-0.6320276260375977,
0.008209338411688805,
-0.9560783505439758,
-0.45243996381759644,
1.050391674041748,
0.6211678385734558,
0.8866190910339355,
0.2591123878955841,
0.7636054158210754,
0.1934085190296173,
0.20210252702236176,
-0.8725866079330444,
0.6018199920654297,
0.1678590178489685,
-0.4519084095954895,
-0.3320515751838684,
-0.7808147072792053,
-0.9727995991706848,
0.2659110724925995,
-0.13382111489772797,
-0.7029955983161926,
-0.10153087973594666,
0.31872448325157166,
0.10019618272781372,
0.5380207896232605,
-0.523827314376831,
0.606697678565979,
-0.3851161599159241,
-0.3953762352466583,
-0.6186042428016663,
-0.551733672618866,
-0.04593723267316818,
-0.10717073082923889,
0.5652281045913696,
-0.03575048968195915,
-0.20160047709941864,
0.58062744140625,
-0.4499179422855377,
0.904405951499939,
-0.4510350525379181,
-0.06974686682224274,
0.29093044996261597,
0.2613722085952759,
0.34074780344963074,
-0.427432119846344,
0.12549977004528046,
-0.26635757088661194,
-0.3107365369796753,
-0.4777994751930237,
-0.6341155171394348,
0.15661177039146423,
-0.6988192200660706,
-0.3179590106010437,
-0.049286942929029465,
-0.4925568997859955,
-0.11141181737184525,
0.1412791758775711,
-0.0033952316734939814,
0.5265994071960449,
-0.30650344491004944,
0.16959184408187866,
0.8569959402084351,
-0.13959971070289612,
0.44822439551353455,
0.8582102060317993,
-0.6928326487541199,
-0.020484041422605515,
1.1152702569961548,
0.07047238945960999,
0.5122208595275879,
0.6931803226470947,
0.532651424407959,
-0.3455979526042938,
-0.9722317457199097,
-0.026862984523177147,
0.3885752260684967,
-0.9839439392089844,
0.06451798975467682,
-0.22753746807575226,
-0.13087594509124756,
-0.2279234677553177,
0.23293709754943848,
-0.3570784330368042,
-0.3124128580093384,
-0.25468626618385315,
-0.13813461363315582,
0.08414781093597412,
0.7753632068634033,
-0.4684070944786072,
0.355599045753479,
-0.49067792296409607,
-0.09274203330278397,
0.2848615348339081,
0.20613829791545868,
-0.10353446751832962,
-0.8878286480903625,
-0.6007182002067566,
0.13579800724983215,
-0.46432948112487793,
-0.39864832162857056,
0.41216179728507996,
0.5740808844566345,
0.8995022177696228,
0.5622743368148804,
-0.10333909839391708,
0.40013858675956726,
-0.6617927551269531,
0.35807499289512634,
0.4250287711620331,
-0.7955655455589294,
0.5394641160964966,
-0.06690973788499832,
-0.09273243695497513,
0.30154550075531006,
0.6970847249031067,
-0.5716890096664429,
-0.25180724263191223,
-0.5718920230865479,
-0.5516126751899719,
0.3831348121166229,
0.01780807226896286,
0.5024508833885193,
0.23120614886283875,
0.760351836681366,
0.08082686364650726,
0.2252444177865982,
-0.9198011159896851,
-0.4744504690170288,
0.33233773708343506,
-0.4305516481399536,
-0.267609179019928,
-0.29949766397476196,
0.16862769424915314,
-0.2786920964717865,
0.902726411819458,
-0.2764948904514313,
0.24448765814304352,
-0.18104377388954163,
-0.4402906000614166,
-0.25689616799354553,
0.06036519631743431,
0.8369061946868896,
0.8233538269996643,
0.01855509728193283,
0.07955429702997208,
0.26168638467788696,
-0.3666130304336548,
0.2592446208000183,
-0.47737258672714233,
-0.20267164707183838,
-0.08860696107149124,
0.1831740140914917,
1.1575367450714111,
0.15854576230049133,
-0.6788370013237,
0.43329471349716187,
-0.16827715933322906,
-0.24035440385341644,
-0.04490057751536369,
0.4148719608783722,
-0.05090958625078201,
0.345647394657135,
0.48886942863464355,
-0.10500334948301315,
-0.04943171143531799,
-0.5229601263999939,
0.2768236994743347,
0.32074636220932007,
-0.29687488079071045,
-0.3561556339263916,
0.6050507426261902,
0.033542782068252563,
-0.6518223285675049,
0.1813228726387024,
-0.07561922073364258,
-0.6376418471336365,
0.28424644470214844,
0.5439761281013489,
0.6388911008834839,
-0.4478018581867218,
0.1113448515534401,
0.4599419832229614,
0.29131564497947693,
-0.39814043045043945,
0.12327006459236145,
-0.2111152857542038,
-0.8344029784202576,
-0.29363617300987244,
-0.8415517807006836,
-0.38979825377464294,
-0.04665755107998848,
-0.5872308611869812,
0.43042436242103577,
-0.36534324288368225,
0.10453929007053375,
-0.17237728834152222,
-0.018437601625919342,
-0.41447558999061584,
0.34864214062690735,
0.11441666632890701,
0.9834927320480347,
-0.6090610027313232,
0.956974446773529,
0.25051480531692505,
-0.3899648189544678,
-0.8621960282325745,
-0.25847604870796204,
0.12789781391620636,
-1.1834285259246826,
0.8645797967910767,
-0.0581817589700222,
-0.09283918142318726,
0.06744381040334702,
-0.801512598991394,
-0.608255922794342,
0.5040758848190308,
0.7351095080375671,
-0.6962484121322632,
-0.11122751981019974,
0.13872437179088593,
0.5170006155967712,
-0.695124089717865,
0.0506725013256073,
0.36028242111206055,
-0.09450501948595047,
-0.09497646242380142,
-0.7855743169784546,
-0.5191168785095215,
-0.26560425758361816,
-0.05808183178305626,
0.4476105868816376,
-0.368270605802536,
0.6621246337890625,
-0.4188039004802704,
-0.17536886036396027,
0.13157203793525696,
0.6342524886131287,
-0.12710104882717133,
0.05450346693396568,
0.5503908395767212,
0.6322069764137268,
0.8008180856704712,
-0.14483389258384705,
1.196483850479126,
-0.41446632146835327,
0.7960809469223022,
0.8400487899780273,
0.0926804170012474,
0.7607335448265076,
0.2839440405368805,
-0.3918966054916382,
0.4202561378479004,
0.7151442766189575,
0.2089233547449112,
0.6061334609985352,
0.6178767681121826,
-0.2503513693809509,
-0.15557333827018738,
0.05478232726454735,
-0.17692622542381287,
0.12481226027011871,
0.21133564412593842,
-0.6254993081092834,
-0.01766054891049862,
0.1171458289027214,
0.1310841143131256,
0.3008344769477844,
-0.5941183567047119,
0.7957255840301514,
0.0031024347990751266,
-0.20297446846961975,
1.0118135213851929,
0.06987695395946503,
0.3971661925315857,
-0.5778895616531372,
0.2684584856033325,
-0.07448536157608032,
0.3301423192024231,
0.13002696633338928,
-0.24449290335178375,
0.04348685219883919,
-0.061782389879226685,
-0.1274467408657074,
-0.2235352098941803,
0.6007354259490967,
-0.7139177918434143,
-0.3159635365009308,
0.47226816415786743,
0.3611820340156555,
0.5330457091331482,
0.30514389276504517,
-0.7783174514770508,
0.11169696599245071,
0.033147815614938736,
-0.24188834428787231,
0.4381824731826782,
0.053150445222854614,
0.5181194543838501,
0.9499737620353699,
0.4615538418292999,
0.5040193200111389,
0.23399123549461365,
0.2431328445672989,
0.5726034641265869,
-0.49169984459877014,
-0.5046457052230835,
-0.9851250052452087,
0.3108046054840088,
-0.015377696603536606,
0.08483555167913437,
0.5163917541503906,
0.5692894458770752,
1.0498687028884888,
0.04857476428151131,
0.6782709956169128,
0.23812715709209442,
0.7115938663482666,
-0.7775803208351135,
0.42356234788894653,
-0.8263306617736816,
0.3043297827243805,
0.033794939517974854,
-0.8855745792388916,
-0.4338161051273346,
0.8036051988601685,
-0.12516264617443085,
0.26369377970695496,
0.7108362913131714,
0.9870343208312988,
0.04486473649740219,
0.06765187531709671,
0.5567864179611206,
0.16931162774562836,
0.11927521973848343,
0.630734920501709,
0.6784114241600037,
-0.5677750110626221,
0.4220220744609833,
-0.44850239157676697,
-0.09934467077255249,
-0.15663684904575348,
-0.727595329284668,
-0.8746442198753357,
-0.6201543211936951,
-0.4506225883960724,
-0.3161660134792328,
0.15736079216003418,
1.263507604598999,
0.8280621767044067,
-0.5691161155700684,
-0.8861954212188721,
-0.3473154902458191,
0.09678911417722702,
-0.14499357342720032,
-0.11998856067657471,
0.07827159017324448,
-0.9300760626792908,
-0.8296804428100586,
0.3789260685443878,
0.1587735265493393,
0.19509173929691315,
-0.18768273293972015,
-0.8033151626586914,
-0.07238230109214783,
0.14350533485412598,
0.566216766834259,
0.5742839574813843,
-0.40438297390937805,
0.009120275266468525,
-0.23898933827877045,
-0.20012913644313812,
0.25072935223579407,
1.0827467441558838,
-0.37970492243766785,
0.5346002578735352,
0.3871495723724365,
0.7550433278083801,
0.36401569843292236,
-0.39982977509498596,
0.5012356042861938,
-0.6446139812469482,
0.16553694009780884,
-0.06527771055698395,
0.47960221767425537,
0.06763800233602524,
-0.04605304077267647,
0.7253015637397766,
0.4132658839225769,
-0.5966806411743164,
-1.2486194372177124,
0.15284475684165955,
-0.39182141423225403,
-0.2861871123313904,
1.0474681854248047,
-0.02770139090716839,
-0.4715966284275055,
0.08098827302455902,
-0.01676534302532673,
0.3163869380950928,
-0.16044726967811584,
0.5353835821151733,
0.49471229314804077,
-0.16230066120624542,
-0.44813305139541626,
-0.7960637807846069,
0.6817023754119873,
0.4301503598690033,
-0.5594415664672852,
0.0471370592713356,
0.17227435111999512,
0.46992555260658264,
0.04938679188489914,
0.3401409089565277,
0.0675293579697609,
0.1667138636112213,
-0.21978026628494263,
0.09317941218614578,
0.08747422695159912,
-0.5097941160202026,
-0.7437636852264404,
0.25295281410217285,
0.4276588559150696,
-0.07535145431756973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17753v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17753v1
|
Evaluating Very Long-Term Conversational Memory of LLM Agents
| 2024-02-27T18:42:31 | 2024-02-27T18:42:31 |
Adyasha Maharana, Dong-Ho Lee, Sergey Tulyakov, Mohit Bansal, Francesco Barbieri, Yuwei Fang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Existing works on long-term open-domain dialogues focus on evaluating model
responses within contexts spanning no more than five chat sessions. Despite
advancements in long-context large language models (LLMs) and retrieval
augmented generation (RAG) techniques, their efficacy in very long-term
dialogues remains unexplored. To address this research gap, we introduce a
machine-human pipeline to generate high-quality, very long-term dialogues by
leveraging LLM-based agent architectures and grounding their dialogues on
personas and temporal event graphs. Moreover, we equip each agent with the
capability of sharing and reacting to images. The generated conversations are
verified and edited by human annotators for long-range consistency and
grounding to the event graphs. Using this pipeline, we collect LoCoMo, a
dataset of very long-term conversations, each encompassing 300 turns and 9K
tokens on avg., over up to 35 sessions. Based on LoCoMo, we present a
comprehensive evaluation benchmark to measure long-term memory in models,
encompassing question answering, event summarization, and multi-modal dialogue
generation tasks. Our experimental results indicate that LLMs exhibit
challenges in understanding lengthy conversations and comprehending long-range
temporal and causal dynamics within dialogues. Employing strategies like
long-context LLMs or RAG can offer improvements but these models still
substantially lag behind human performance.
|
[
-0.3132176101207733,
-0.8749807476997375,
0.6852900385856628,
0.08892222493886948,
-0.2575215995311737,
0.22259929776191711,
-0.45593416690826416,
-0.6286720633506775,
0.1927991509437561,
0.7694324254989624,
-0.5492315292358398,
-0.4294070303440094,
-0.02917836792767048,
-0.09018748253583908,
-0.20742011070251465,
0.8590059280395508,
0.22344478964805603,
-0.15145404636859894,
-0.3102824091911316,
-0.2588658034801483,
-0.5735507011413574,
-0.7754650712013245,
-0.850059986114502,
-0.44010108709335327,
0.6775348782539368,
-0.07476026564836502,
0.6323245763778687,
0.29803529381752014,
0.07621577382087708,
0.27360445261001587,
-0.2808472216129303,
0.5146477818489075,
-0.8582637310028076,
0.4722811281681061,
-0.1921650618314743,
-0.2838223874568939,
-0.7127130627632141,
-0.11129473894834518,
0.6377406120300293,
0.5035456418991089,
-0.09977588802576065,
-0.11505813896656036,
-0.031704727560281754,
0.49192550778388977,
-0.5644412040710449,
0.14698903262615204,
-0.7039387226104736,
0.042564041912555695,
0.019280390813946724,
-0.42271262407302856,
-0.7634935975074768,
0.13309375941753387,
0.12545311450958252,
-0.2780042886734009,
-0.18804657459259033,
-0.04358379915356636,
0.825259268283844,
-0.01607486605644226,
-0.43154048919677734,
-0.41555890440940857,
-1.03026282787323,
0.7914977669715881,
-0.5734462738037109,
0.260518342256546,
0.5068478584289551,
0.44695916771888733,
-0.48472779989242554,
-0.6129970550537109,
-0.2999213933944702,
-0.5964932441711426,
0.18075037002563477,
0.12311286479234695,
-0.14131443202495575,
0.03424876928329468,
0.22718171775341034,
-0.11982318758964539,
-0.27422279119491577,
0.12535962462425232,
-0.12751436233520508,
-0.2042969912290573,
0.5407165884971619,
0.6098271012306213,
-0.022635135799646378,
-0.08952055871486664,
-0.520106852054596,
0.12773887813091278,
-0.5227179527282715,
-0.13792328536510468,
0.2896917462348938,
0.11287613213062286,
0.0780046358704567,
0.39909470081329346,
-0.01486778911203146,
0.4854772984981537,
-0.11199761182069778,
-0.2661444842815399,
-0.006929398979991674,
-0.2945566475391388,
-0.08606722950935364,
-0.370484322309494,
0.9610867500305176,
0.5917463302612305,
0.2970718741416931,
-0.5877460837364197,
-0.2460605651140213,
-0.19964253902435303,
0.232490673661232,
-0.9006316661834717,
0.1531965136528015,
0.23364707827568054,
-0.23694641888141632,
-0.07090667635202408,
-0.31452324986457825,
-0.670648992061615,
-0.42847761511802673,
-0.04598841443657875,
0.16335730254650116,
-0.2999652028083801,
0.019084306433796883,
0.08493099361658096,
-0.04509132355451584,
0.4105769395828247,
0.30776962637901306,
-0.4621149003505707,
0.32430148124694824,
0.6067960262298584,
0.6267570853233337,
-0.3434664011001587,
-0.37511152029037476,
-0.7713676691055298,
0.3453817069530487,
-0.387360155582428,
0.7711387276649475,
-0.5253560543060303,
-0.5162439942359924,
0.1401297003030777,
0.11927574127912521,
0.07390643656253815,
-0.722570538520813,
0.5708015561103821,
-0.6368216276168823,
0.14382362365722656,
0.1973724663257599,
-0.4716452360153198,
0.21161296963691711,
0.5078076720237732,
-0.39257916808128357,
0.8556457757949829,
-0.052746303379535675,
-0.36942026019096375,
0.007631557062268257,
-0.5669925212860107,
-0.2209034264087677,
0.09257004410028458,
-0.25115469098091125,
-0.5076624155044556,
-0.01984258182346821,
0.06684701889753342,
0.6991521716117859,
-0.6148918271064758,
0.5915509462356567,
-0.19849881529808044,
-0.34697410464286804,
0.6507231593132019,
-0.7102241516113281,
0.2977229058742523,
0.08850887417793274,
-0.18818926811218262,
0.017050879076123238,
-0.6674113273620605,
-0.1410069465637207,
0.14267706871032715,
-0.2755715847015381,
-0.17745868861675262,
0.14921200275421143,
-0.1349857598543167,
0.20040743052959442,
0.13407503068447113,
-0.4178994297981262,
0.11142154037952423,
-0.26045191287994385,
0.7565317749977112,
0.8015855550765991,
0.0994507297873497,
0.23138216137886047,
-0.495950311422348,
0.3354797959327698,
0.24033232033252716,
0.09407419711351395,
-0.7898043394088745,
-0.2314734011888504,
-0.9765589833259583,
-0.18362678587436676,
-0.2531711459159851,
0.30233603715896606,
-0.49834108352661133,
0.2648829519748688,
-0.5431801080703735,
-0.2562205493450165,
-0.03431115299463272,
0.14411872625350952,
0.4953552186489105,
0.3518140912055969,
0.19493050873279572,
-0.5156973600387573,
-0.32647407054901123,
-0.797011137008667,
0.047325555235147476,
-0.30367764830589294,
-0.09299931675195694,
0.9145344495773315,
0.4044455289840698,
-0.5050686001777649,
1.0615575313568115,
-0.29530325531959534,
0.05359592288732529,
-0.06949636340141296,
0.2056041955947876,
-0.05852493643760681,
0.05459048971533775,
0.24570345878601074,
-0.37889522314071655,
-0.13920365273952484,
-0.1791255921125412,
-0.671576738357544,
0.26496565341949463,
-0.42073869705200195,
-0.18046462535858154,
0.6627638936042786,
0.509127140045166,
-1.0958129167556763,
0.2772921323776245,
0.3799251616001129,
-0.36139023303985596,
0.4744096100330353,
-0.1431311070919037,
0.05522708594799042,
-1.0478922128677368,
0.09828750789165497,
-0.25461527705192566,
-0.5361731052398682,
-0.4749818444252014,
-0.3010665774345398,
-0.13293865323066711,
-0.2948738634586334,
-0.6968116164207458,
0.9076303243637085,
-0.6701963543891907,
-0.26004737615585327,
-0.2415546476840973,
0.39774760603904724,
-0.09000886976718903,
0.8160881400108337,
0.04090888425707817,
0.757031261920929,
0.18805307149887085,
-0.6457518339157104,
0.3999497890472412,
0.06914564967155457,
-0.38910821080207825,
0.4509046673774719,
-0.6138431429862976,
0.8730509281158447,
-0.10180447995662689,
0.7113007307052612,
-1.0553717613220215,
-0.12518051266670227,
0.1562550961971283,
-0.33451852202415466,
0.27059638500213623,
-0.2863824963569641,
-0.4058235287666321,
-0.24887798726558685,
-0.23063838481903076,
0.20969337224960327,
0.5535159111022949,
-0.314939945936203,
0.6997117400169373,
0.3355100750923157,
-0.1322387456893921,
-0.5026969909667969,
-0.23320892453193665,
0.576411247253418,
-0.41297397017478943,
-0.6957957148551941,
0.0712718665599823,
-0.15207399427890778,
-0.20749545097351074,
-0.32726845145225525,
0.06468761712312698,
0.1332429200410843,
-0.020131312310695648,
0.49191713333129883,
0.1660577356815338,
-0.07435142993927002,
0.2004731446504593,
-0.31594279408454895,
-0.1268806904554367,
0.21111299097537994,
-0.2158031314611435,
0.9211583137512207,
-0.0071643684059381485,
-0.3619661033153534,
-0.29644179344177246,
0.2817752957344055,
0.8282178044319153,
-0.03563430905342102,
0.6590532660484314,
0.5290864109992981,
-0.08919402956962585,
-0.14527422189712524,
-0.8422771096229553,
-0.10087496042251587,
-0.40836167335510254,
0.44922178983688354,
-0.35328802466392517,
-0.8929193019866943,
0.7156415581703186,
-0.2539982199668884,
0.1222522035241127,
0.08481654524803162,
0.7762799859046936,
-0.30530956387519836,
0.6841372847557068,
0.07494309544563293,
-0.30628010630607605,
0.41211992502212524,
-0.35966894030570984,
-0.023959001526236534,
-0.9377903938293457,
-0.2505970001220703,
-0.18433530628681183,
-0.12417498975992203,
-0.29097405076026917,
-0.9246702790260315,
0.1873401254415512,
-0.016216397285461426,
-0.3513982594013214,
0.059477582573890686,
0.01684417948126793,
0.5716431140899658,
0.13864068686962128,
0.10866574943065643,
0.09716513007879257,
-0.19056881964206696,
0.2569015324115753,
0.09748572111129761,
-0.36710068583488464,
-0.7430661916732788,
1.141000509262085,
0.5441884994506836,
0.7730391621589661,
-0.09626378864049911,
0.464295893907547,
0.3041013181209564,
0.10249926894903183,
-0.7995880246162415,
0.877263069152832,
0.33971619606018066,
-0.43790075182914734,
-0.4446089267730713,
-0.24542298913002014,
-1.2576940059661865,
0.10761956870555878,
0.007514765951782465,
-0.7509313821792603,
-0.3224024176597595,
-0.0990152657032013,
-0.1938672661781311,
0.14845474064350128,
-0.3350498378276825,
0.5609644651412964,
-0.3255394399166107,
-0.77126544713974,
-0.3144598603248596,
-0.8056279420852661,
0.13892516493797302,
0.16930262744426727,
-0.050959404557943344,
-0.19664494693279266,
0.0219174362719059,
0.6378828883171082,
-0.1759270429611206,
0.9467243552207947,
-0.03929376229643822,
-0.17082156240940094,
0.681398332118988,
-0.025985591113567352,
0.7780628204345703,
0.048408593982458115,
0.1176706999540329,
0.17227217555046082,
-0.3971257209777832,
-0.35510194301605225,
-0.5812692046165466,
0.6747198104858398,
-0.7935566306114197,
-0.6294734477996826,
-0.10571657866239548,
-0.5090723037719727,
-0.3909838795661926,
-0.21320265531539917,
-0.28194063901901245,
0.4371607005596161,
-0.5450180172920227,
0.2880478799343109,
0.704642653465271,
-0.4008685052394867,
0.5116729140281677,
0.5168796181678772,
-0.32405930757522583,
-0.3706272840499878,
0.7102727293968201,
-0.17073334753513336,
0.4433524012565613,
0.3054918944835663,
0.06960008293390274,
-0.10097290575504303,
-0.3299148678779602,
-0.4465019702911377,
0.2969324290752411,
-0.5133610367774963,
-0.19070878624916077,
-0.8642659187316895,
-0.271720826625824,
-0.10281941294670105,
0.12566712498664856,
-0.3729080855846405,
-0.22002777457237244,
-0.35243529081344604,
0.11275535076856613,
0.22655406594276428,
0.3905445635318756,
0.3289589583873749,
0.02901502698659897,
-0.8648127913475037,
0.44338181614875793,
0.4953392446041107,
-0.037084128707647324,
0.07836928218603134,
-0.49120989441871643,
-0.407781183719635,
0.2445976585149765,
-0.5348982214927673,
-0.6538312435150146,
0.4522475004196167,
0.20747923851013184,
0.4091406762599945,
0.2929709255695343,
-0.2203998863697052,
0.9038399457931519,
-0.5627235174179077,
0.9918415546417236,
0.06630989909172058,
-0.5486665368080139,
0.3636658787727356,
-0.5895919799804688,
0.22493937611579895,
0.12325131893157959,
0.1438649594783783,
-0.5356312990188599,
-0.4733102023601532,
-0.46693089604377747,
-0.8731883764266968,
0.4887230694293976,
0.14150819182395935,
0.5246369242668152,
-0.3528240919113159,
0.3589904308319092,
-0.14821748435497284,
0.07124435901641846,
-0.31469815969467163,
0.008393033407628536,
0.1866569072008133,
0.37991228699684143,
-0.3090723156929016,
-0.530485212802887,
-0.4062083065509796,
0.16076794266700745,
0.2707189917564392,
-0.20463241636753082,
0.5082274079322815,
0.010550476610660553,
-0.06635463237762451,
-0.0460381954908371,
0.5662220120429993,
0.8020030856132507,
0.7765871286392212,
-0.33532923460006714,
-0.10477703809738159,
0.3100767433643341,
-0.07241056859493256,
0.0174937155097723,
-0.16821159422397614,
0.3950170576572418,
0.018602609634399414,
0.27416473627090454,
0.9803810119628906,
0.24836471676826477,
-1.0594624280929565,
0.415621817111969,
-0.07789386808872223,
0.02928873524069786,
-0.6838908195495605,
-0.005973020102828741,
0.5789756774902344,
0.43562212586402893,
0.44895675778388977,
-0.41384702920913696,
-0.11674299091100693,
-0.984520435333252,
0.12412683665752411,
0.5446071028709412,
-0.3664743900299072,
-0.2563730776309967,
0.5238351225852966,
0.4310765862464905,
-0.4823942482471466,
0.8676503896713257,
-0.09327714145183563,
-0.2939021587371826,
0.46787792444229126,
0.6260645389556885,
0.9539077877998352,
0.0911123976111412,
0.05614333227276802,
0.13874326646327972,
-0.19406767189502716,
-0.002056955825537443,
-0.16557924449443817,
-0.3094893991947174,
-0.5334084630012512,
-0.5668949484825134,
-0.46675243973731995,
-0.49005958437919617,
0.39460474252700806,
-0.42983222007751465,
0.17344777286052704,
-0.161179319024086,
-0.48005980253219604,
-0.34359535574913025,
0.1411459743976593,
-0.571169912815094,
-0.07706447690725327,
0.30653154850006104,
0.6196710467338562,
-0.5717040300369263,
0.8559508323669434,
0.46380749344825745,
-0.00047128807636909187,
-0.3227583169937134,
-0.24855944514274597,
-0.2810373604297638,
-0.7841006517410278,
0.8151968717575073,
0.192723348736763,
-0.4865930676460266,
-0.3395247757434845,
-0.6694719791412354,
-0.34072086215019226,
1.4136171340942383,
0.35999175906181335,
-0.7100174427032471,
-0.35947951674461365,
0.21680158376693726,
0.9042628407478333,
-0.46669140458106995,
0.47036924958229065,
0.35073310136795044,
0.03975123539566994,
0.4327538013458252,
-1.0113753080368042,
-0.29224535822868347,
-0.07891212403774261,
0.006620342377573252,
0.3015914261341095,
-0.973114013671875,
0.5255951285362244,
-0.14095301926136017,
-0.3221137821674347,
0.2555883228778839,
0.7586786150932312,
0.4196810722351074,
0.585789144039154,
0.3635094463825226,
0.5100150108337402,
0.57296222448349,
0.2554912269115448,
0.8240653276443481,
-0.45859912037849426,
0.16140666604042053,
1.4207085371017456,
-0.3450269401073456,
0.7736358046531677,
0.5163021087646484,
0.1007903441786766,
0.35452261567115784,
0.16364769637584686,
0.33831438422203064,
0.20281122624874115,
0.3707180619239807,
-0.3105672001838684,
-0.519900381565094,
-0.27967342734336853,
-0.10315662622451782,
0.35161659121513367,
0.4334481954574585,
-0.36727768182754517,
0.03697352483868599,
0.01285762432962656,
0.14271055161952972,
-0.05467638000845909,
-0.01628524623811245,
0.8875922560691833,
0.17027145624160767,
-0.7952442765235901,
0.7549751996994019,
-0.23900216817855835,
0.5428244471549988,
-0.4138047397136688,
-0.18304003775119781,
-0.5174714922904968,
0.08575809001922607,
0.241734579205513,
-0.7039759755134583,
-0.03374359756708145,
0.16061478853225708,
0.06886924803256989,
-0.2508018910884857,
0.6247941255569458,
-0.4588431715965271,
-0.019519200548529625,
0.41854768991470337,
0.5987218022346497,
0.5300711989402771,
0.12963637709617615,
-0.46629059314727783,
0.3095025420188904,
-0.24286659061908722,
-0.47889113426208496,
0.5439354777336121,
0.5276091694831848,
-0.24373432993888855,
1.1847978830337524,
0.4138217568397522,
-0.12749232351779938,
-0.07162076979875565,
0.13495299220085144,
0.9766560196876526,
-0.8405294418334961,
-0.04776160046458244,
-0.8699449300765991,
0.48609763383865356,
0.005882429890334606,
-0.24063444137573242,
0.4815613925457001,
0.7831280827522278,
0.5261038541793823,
0.11929207295179367,
0.449555903673172,
0.3884432017803192,
0.3141513764858246,
-0.5593764185905457,
0.49348005652427673,
-0.2655458450317383,
0.31749269366264343,
-0.1224977895617485,
-0.8677160143852234,
0.14993301033973694,
0.30809181928634644,
-0.10475841164588928,
-0.04503287002444267,
0.4107682704925537,
0.8666998147964478,
-0.015132836066186428,
-0.3567295968532562,
0.6471838355064392,
0.35180339217185974,
0.5833624601364136,
0.9378671646118164,
1.4399619102478027,
-0.3447062373161316,
0.6934854984283447,
0.18425843119621277,
0.2202930450439453,
-0.31641703844070435,
-0.7620723247528076,
-1.2261162996292114,
-0.6807413101196289,
-0.11635012924671173,
-0.4515816867351532,
0.5060489177703857,
0.9222939610481262,
0.6155496835708618,
-0.20236986875534058,
-0.5199309587478638,
0.25511640310287476,
-0.1373409628868103,
0.257768839597702,
-0.17728941142559052,
0.21937033534049988,
-0.3281245529651642,
-0.8667219877243042,
0.5174306035041809,
0.5282449126243591,
-0.011870305053889751,
-0.515457272529602,
-0.42627274990081787,
0.06797969341278076,
0.2842569053173065,
0.8615322113037109,
0.37019607424736023,
-0.5865694880485535,
-0.3975861668586731,
0.09368053078651428,
-0.3813522458076477,
0.2856060862541199,
0.7927038073539734,
-0.9544369578361511,
0.5208896398544312,
0.16412505507469177,
0.5416902899742126,
0.8069040179252625,
0.11615577340126038,
0.602932870388031,
-0.37461864948272705,
0.2173786759376526,
0.4826262891292572,
0.029062112793326378,
0.29516714811325073,
0.06081204116344452,
0.4530114233493805,
-0.133627250790596,
-0.902836263179779,
-0.8867588639259338,
0.13875968754291534,
-1.123457670211792,
-0.10627236217260361,
1.4085525274276733,
-0.3399006724357605,
-0.24221333861351013,
-0.12796379625797272,
-0.37312084436416626,
0.18659161031246185,
-0.5194087624549866,
0.7624732851982117,
0.7281563878059387,
-0.3056243658065796,
-0.13277508318424225,
-0.5220628380775452,
0.2576397955417633,
0.17690636217594147,
-0.7415944933891296,
0.29228368401527405,
0.8150061964988708,
0.0507369339466095,
0.20375967025756836,
0.8935132026672363,
-0.0939728319644928,
0.006039003375917673,
-0.20516924560070038,
-0.16045428812503815,
0.005044171586632729,
-0.503690242767334,
-0.04146425426006317,
0.05456463620066643,
0.08632688224315643,
0.05161866173148155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17733v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17733v1
|
Tower: An Open Multilingual Large Language Model for Translation-Related Tasks
| 2024-02-27T18:09:36 | 2024-02-27T18:09:36 |
Duarte M. Alves, José Pombal, Nuno M. Guerreiro, Pedro H. Martins, João Alves, Amin Farajian, Ben Peters, Ricardo Rei, Patrick Fernandes, Sweta Agrawal, Pierre Colombo, José G. C. de Souza, André F. T. Martins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While general-purpose large language models (LLMs) demonstrate proficiency on
multiple tasks within the domain of translation, approaches based on open LLMs
are competitive only when specializing on a single task. In this paper, we
propose a recipe for tailoring LLMs to multiple tasks present in translation
workflows. We perform continued pretraining on a multilingual mixture of
monolingual and parallel data, creating TowerBase, followed by finetuning on
instructions relevant for translation processes, creating TowerInstruct. Our
final model surpasses open alternatives on several tasks relevant to
translation workflows and is competitive with general-purpose closed LLMs. To
facilitate future research, we release the Tower models, our specialization
dataset, an evaluation framework for LLMs focusing on the translation
ecosystem, and a collection of model generations, including ours, on our
benchmark.
|
[
-0.11061395704746246,
-0.5190883278846741,
0.2123648226261139,
0.348844438791275,
-0.06023770570755005,
-0.09305663406848907,
-0.5831859111785889,
-0.2102462649345398,
0.1887413114309311,
0.9661492109298706,
-0.4956606328487396,
-0.7041819095611572,
-0.5466834902763367,
0.18596602976322174,
-0.3905726373195648,
1.1476608514785767,
-0.34832167625427246,
0.044653359800577164,
-0.10701420158147812,
-0.2605832815170288,
-0.5443539023399353,
-0.7644296884536743,
-0.33954358100891113,
-0.33467602729797363,
0.5124698877334595,
0.6609421968460083,
0.8366719484329224,
0.6349067687988281,
0.6247043013572693,
0.2797991633415222,
0.0899457111954689,
0.010003688745200634,
-0.7263872027397156,
0.1550063043832779,
-0.14296677708625793,
-0.3872002363204956,
-0.8050833344459534,
-0.005085980053991079,
0.6567491888999939,
0.8089740872383118,
-0.250403493642807,
0.40665844082832336,
0.17621032893657684,
0.6882501840591431,
-0.40252235531806946,
0.14153549075126648,
-0.7790518403053284,
0.07859821617603302,
-0.5246272683143616,
-0.03681522235274315,
-0.4090822637081146,
-0.06936489045619965,
-0.005893563851714134,
-0.49348214268684387,
0.29664796590805054,
0.22570759057998657,
0.5609409213066101,
0.0533718504011631,
-0.42192909121513367,
-0.21564806997776031,
-0.531785786151886,
0.908636212348938,
-0.406326562166214,
0.5384162068367004,
0.08587048202753067,
0.41948872804641724,
0.024726802483201027,
-0.7524716258049011,
-0.12860871851444244,
-0.3922603130340576,
0.08420366793870926,
0.24403825402259827,
0.00016192741168197244,
-0.018443699926137924,
-0.03333691507577896,
0.4512694180011749,
-0.6430325508117676,
0.24932363629341125,
-0.2603233754634857,
0.2407120317220688,
0.3781525492668152,
0.17583197355270386,
0.31716758012771606,
0.019951818510890007,
-0.3297843337059021,
-0.026121484115719795,
-0.9344412088394165,
0.049187663942575455,
0.37184473872184753,
0.4636591970920563,
-0.18047425150871277,
0.6059004068374634,
-0.20171743631362915,
0.6942493319511414,
-0.3366243839263916,
-0.24847747385501862,
0.34693583846092224,
-0.20995678007602692,
-0.39688459038734436,
-0.07009072601795197,
0.719394862651825,
0.11562289297580719,
0.6490383744239807,
-0.4848954677581787,
-0.1508997231721878,
-0.24767537415027618,
0.42079442739486694,
-0.8218712210655212,
0.06588120013475418,
0.3269156515598297,
-0.47221845388412476,
-0.16587281227111816,
-0.12650485336780548,
-0.5138081312179565,
0.12172076851129532,
-0.3866983652114868,
0.09167028963565826,
-0.02407473884522915,
-0.37986481189727783,
0.353569358587265,
0.12553104758262634,
-0.3530750870704651,
0.16878709197044373,
-0.8425047993659973,
0.3013581335544586,
0.5672172904014587,
1.0332961082458496,
-0.5476234555244446,
-0.7394643425941467,
-0.7770556807518005,
0.45417383313179016,
-0.3810727596282959,
0.5121239423751831,
-0.4858011305332184,
-0.3893533945083618,
0.42745280265808105,
0.08464816957712173,
-0.09034845978021622,
-0.6932331323623657,
0.802850604057312,
-0.5731976628303528,
-0.13922008872032166,
0.013671607710421085,
-0.06591670215129852,
-0.05319402739405632,
0.45546239614486694,
-0.6749643087387085,
0.9941452741622925,
-0.02934424951672554,
-0.6212051510810852,
0.01464123371988535,
-0.6788470149040222,
-0.6560401320457458,
0.09499464184045792,
-0.005404963623732328,
-0.2630387246608734,
0.29269346594810486,
0.15073274075984955,
0.6881241798400879,
-0.6231368780136108,
0.44289231300354004,
-0.33034512400627136,
-0.021239910274744034,
-0.15181265771389008,
0.009793483652174473,
0.6421571373939514,
0.39271360635757446,
0.16766807436943054,
0.41846948862075806,
-0.33591169118881226,
-0.09668287634849548,
-0.12113166600465775,
-0.41549375653266907,
-0.08781887590885162,
0.12320372462272644,
0.16031233966350555,
0.3062330186367035,
0.31236889958381653,
-0.4279279112815857,
0.2968783676624298,
-0.13930824398994446,
0.5633870363235474,
0.3413555324077606,
-0.5537816286087036,
0.30104267597198486,
-0.467864990234375,
0.7106132507324219,
0.17923660576343536,
0.016954919323325157,
-0.06025580316781998,
-0.3967369794845581,
-0.6517690420150757,
-0.4144643545150757,
0.008933459408581257,
0.6950167417526245,
-0.5008822679519653,
0.15522025525569916,
-0.7425363659858704,
-0.5943488478660583,
-0.4483394920825958,
0.25676143169403076,
0.4413331151008606,
0.31219589710235596,
0.4903714954853058,
-0.15439791977405548,
-0.3424987494945526,
-0.9916335344314575,
-0.16646894812583923,
0.3552872836589813,
0.09074756503105164,
-0.18288925290107727,
0.6192176342010498,
-0.010149342007935047,
0.4276891052722931,
-0.3915958106517792,
-0.8023686408996582,
-0.441423624753952,
0.0657571405172348,
0.6168443560600281,
0.5040199160575867,
0.582416296005249,
-0.648250937461853,
-0.7414398789405823,
0.4900108873844147,
-0.7916402816772461,
-0.13551464676856995,
0.17308154702186584,
-0.1919238567352295,
-0.32250627875328064,
0.814647912979126,
-0.5622008442878723,
0.12730291485786438,
0.8200641870498657,
0.33482593297958374,
0.710340678691864,
-0.2784743309020996,
0.2897703945636749,
-1.3792943954467773,
0.06853702664375305,
-0.09153906255960464,
-0.055513471364974976,
-0.8909463286399841,
0.3951677978038788,
0.05642766132950783,
-0.3017462491989136,
-0.5185116529464722,
0.5500045418739319,
-0.6845476031303406,
-0.15377576649188995,
-0.24619148671627045,
0.14026038348674774,
-0.11506353318691254,
0.36300480365753174,
0.3973067104816437,
0.5831480026245117,
0.8492417931556702,
-0.4186340570449829,
0.2495240569114685,
0.3495439887046814,
-0.5542638897895813,
0.5428109169006348,
-0.7358814477920532,
0.0480152852833271,
-0.13710056245326996,
0.11043396592140198,
-0.7894676923751831,
-0.24213577806949615,
-0.22868269681930542,
-0.14526154100894928,
0.021013958379626274,
-0.43361055850982666,
-0.7006782293319702,
-0.45855462551116943,
-0.02960188314318657,
0.5240267515182495,
0.3163174092769623,
-0.4748149812221527,
0.6075767874717712,
0.14762142300605774,
-0.32570821046829224,
-0.767560601234436,
-0.8809329271316528,
0.14324593544006348,
-0.2668299078941345,
-0.9188737273216248,
0.6935985684394836,
-0.10404446721076965,
-0.14184588193893433,
-0.18574725091457367,
0.2140728086233139,
-0.28013157844543457,
-0.019683778285980225,
0.2805974781513214,
-0.011842962354421616,
-0.42563655972480774,
0.14054323732852936,
-0.20301030576229095,
0.05637061595916748,
-0.25181108713150024,
-0.5361641049385071,
0.3411388695240021,
-0.1034141257405281,
-0.4958115816116333,
-0.15133844316005707,
0.6488291025161743,
0.8993120193481445,
-0.8346010446548462,
0.6867815852165222,
0.4567130506038666,
-0.4811227321624756,
-0.30646127462387085,
-0.644565224647522,
0.26298609375953674,
-0.4202897548675537,
0.6364486217498779,
-0.9305189251899719,
-1.0353894233703613,
0.5671449303627014,
-0.046307288110256195,
0.4258173704147339,
0.2607312500476837,
0.879642128944397,
0.1698637157678604,
0.9000067710876465,
0.6550597548484802,
-0.1396009624004364,
0.25210773944854736,
-0.01561715081334114,
0.28501424193382263,
-0.7658040523529053,
-0.09061379730701447,
-0.8031787872314453,
-0.25795674324035645,
-0.2626570165157318,
-0.5263602137565613,
0.6803008913993835,
0.4587576389312744,
-0.21749520301818848,
0.3705834448337555,
-0.28152310848236084,
0.42435142397880554,
0.41489484906196594,
-0.23963956534862518,
0.5975818037986755,
0.3015066087245941,
-0.27781832218170166,
-0.03625205531716347,
-0.8911384344100952,
-0.5441524982452393,
1.0913749933242798,
0.09917459636926651,
0.5016385912895203,
0.43450257182121277,
0.5674874782562256,
-0.07768038660287857,
0.8300513029098511,
-0.5472456812858582,
0.2935769557952881,
-0.6434381008148193,
-0.7633718848228455,
-0.20419025421142578,
-0.35895201563835144,
-1.0797654390335083,
0.5000351667404175,
-0.08529181033372879,
-0.6522767543792725,
-0.457593709230423,
-0.011891243048012257,
-0.06597962230443954,
0.5131428241729736,
-0.5027202367782593,
1.2918215990066528,
-0.44868770241737366,
-0.25467005372047424,
-0.5022757053375244,
-0.22015461325645447,
0.4986202120780945,
-0.3922605812549591,
0.5412408709526062,
-0.20804379880428314,
0.10982994735240936,
0.3662947118282318,
-0.36611711978912354,
0.6127127408981323,
0.1541961431503296,
0.07637906074523926,
0.18942566215991974,
0.1399078518152237,
0.45219358801841736,
-0.09386314451694489,
-0.5316908955574036,
0.16109655797481537,
-0.01290049683302641,
-0.46318942308425903,
-0.17081798613071442,
0.8234366178512573,
-0.7987493276596069,
-0.6371459364891052,
-0.10326919704675674,
-0.7306480407714844,
-0.2304256558418274,
0.3066053092479706,
0.24795424938201904,
0.32978180050849915,
-0.5464679002761841,
0.2988038659095764,
0.37485596537590027,
-0.12443345785140991,
0.3718600869178772,
0.5008753538131714,
-0.4514966309070587,
-0.31898048520088196,
0.5408861041069031,
0.019888006150722504,
0.35354506969451904,
0.6874495148658752,
0.05707605928182602,
-0.19024775922298431,
-1.0967110395431519,
-0.4574313461780548,
0.05247969925403595,
-0.6059592366218567,
-0.03897220641374588,
-0.5827369689941406,
0.035816553980112076,
-0.3890233337879181,
-0.42409080266952515,
-0.4269098937511444,
0.010813173837959766,
-0.08179141581058502,
0.05188721790909767,
0.014302347786724567,
0.8393290042877197,
0.10983699560165405,
0.4491056799888611,
-1.0886766910552979,
0.4802631139755249,
0.12709183990955353,
0.3055168092250824,
0.024834029376506805,
-0.5842231512069702,
-0.536823570728302,
-0.05351916328072548,
-0.16940736770629883,
-0.7470415234565735,
0.41525834798812866,
0.1856033205986023,
0.6785555481910706,
0.2028210610151291,
-0.28638067841529846,
0.5525954365730286,
-0.9318835735321045,
0.5520926117897034,
0.5270318984985352,
-0.8121171593666077,
0.19611826539039612,
-0.5109747648239136,
0.5027645826339722,
0.5457329750061035,
0.631641149520874,
-0.6915353536605835,
-0.18468528985977173,
-0.0894017443060875,
-0.5277479290962219,
0.507727861404419,
0.11554458737373352,
0.183481365442276,
-0.0394737534224987,
0.2360527664422989,
0.16545096039772034,
0.3512864112854004,
-0.9714248180389404,
0.060475904494524,
-0.10786736756563187,
-0.12664909660816193,
-0.30511799454689026,
0.013400574214756489,
-0.12573294341564178,
-0.1531762182712555,
0.5354858636856079,
-0.1893727034330368,
-0.23713603615760803,
-0.18076111376285553,
-0.31311073899269104,
-0.0246965903788805,
0.2649548053741455,
0.4362371563911438,
0.6428807973861694,
0.052201155573129654,
0.04774845764040947,
0.15262751281261444,
-0.22316506505012512,
0.08223845064640045,
-0.018729643896222115,
0.10715534538030624,
-0.11378730833530426,
0.5601345896720886,
0.6266120672225952,
0.06280170381069183,
-0.5299584269523621,
0.4264678657054901,
0.3504219651222229,
-0.36243775486946106,
-0.25630754232406616,
-0.23012788593769073,
0.3415887653827667,
0.08270364254713058,
0.22902832925319672,
-0.029952673241496086,
-0.3505328893661499,
-0.5962390899658203,
0.10805045813322067,
0.4253062605857849,
-0.2506251633167267,
-0.4277591407299042,
0.8129419684410095,
0.36996644735336304,
-0.30259206891059875,
0.5245749354362488,
-0.06383969634771347,
-0.5223163366317749,
0.43084895610809326,
0.2827855944633484,
1.0324156284332275,
-0.3830179274082184,
0.015080696903169155,
0.4850497841835022,
0.547249436378479,
-0.49406418204307556,
0.2058754712343216,
0.3523702025413513,
-0.7197951078414917,
-0.6837913990020752,
-0.8065359592437744,
-0.05979600548744202,
0.16984407603740692,
-0.5897554159164429,
0.4595281481742859,
-0.11752349138259888,
-0.037850625813007355,
-0.0796143114566803,
-0.4515171945095062,
-0.9114302396774292,
0.1101125031709671,
-0.0038369002286344767,
1.0845715999603271,
-0.6920808553695679,
1.2417683601379395,
0.8386415243148804,
-0.3270477056503296,
-0.33485373854637146,
-0.145351380109787,
-0.18720462918281555,
-0.7784662842750549,
0.815479040145874,
0.21855077147483826,
-0.21886245906352997,
0.044799476861953735,
-0.027716966345906258,
-0.8580394983291626,
0.7293717265129089,
0.3862447142601013,
-0.6270391941070557,
-0.15654341876506805,
0.5876701474189758,
0.5574483275413513,
-0.7979825139045715,
0.15786907076835632,
0.2592843472957611,
0.4860678017139435,
-0.18941350281238556,
-1.2720447778701782,
-0.25875967741012573,
-0.24035167694091797,
-0.04811733216047287,
0.19421318173408508,
-0.7943634390830994,
0.8975025415420532,
-0.14999721944332123,
0.036669645458459854,
0.2584705352783203,
0.602057695388794,
0.011294921860098839,
-0.27201536297798157,
0.41244858503341675,
0.732219934463501,
0.514415442943573,
-0.0884089469909668,
1.0018619298934937,
-0.5504155158996582,
0.08796598762273788,
1.252557635307312,
-0.44663989543914795,
1.0988610982894897,
0.3202510178089142,
0.05641835555434227,
0.4255087077617645,
0.6206901669502258,
0.08253473043441772,
0.39885836839675903,
0.6445801258087158,
-0.0016769651556387544,
-0.3843294382095337,
-0.2550216019153595,
-0.469328910112381,
0.3360552489757538,
0.26793625950813293,
-0.1279892474412918,
-0.3452809154987335,
0.09912828356027603,
0.15547874569892883,
0.1505943089723587,
-0.4058375358581543,
0.23318782448768616,
0.1306953728199005,
-1.2184163331985474,
0.7024850249290466,
0.37808066606521606,
0.5239660739898682,
-0.9280937910079956,
0.2689998149871826,
-0.16091369092464447,
0.1575351059436798,
-0.22178615629673004,
-0.6330533623695374,
0.3530007004737854,
-0.005720952525734901,
-0.2804459035396576,
-0.7263646721839905,
0.25095146894454956,
-0.6903111338615417,
-0.5492780804634094,
0.43393051624298096,
0.7786686420440674,
0.19296734035015106,
-0.4324760138988495,
-0.5698402523994446,
0.14734669029712677,
-0.1364169865846634,
-0.17046891152858734,
0.30860063433647156,
0.536327600479126,
-0.15484128892421722,
0.6381607055664062,
0.5748393535614014,
0.08456292748451233,
0.21240517497062683,
0.3701845407485962,
0.45636725425720215,
-0.44965001940727234,
-0.5208616852760315,
-0.5989614129066467,
0.4882015883922577,
0.1036483570933342,
-0.6604284644126892,
0.6141178607940674,
0.8165252804756165,
0.9565352201461792,
-0.3336675763130188,
0.8843506574630737,
0.1941312551498413,
0.2739841639995575,
-0.5661121010780334,
0.4621962010860443,
-0.780561089515686,
0.009706512093544006,
-0.03020639531314373,
-1.171776294708252,
-0.26269614696502686,
0.038351744413375854,
-0.23985746502876282,
-0.06498944759368896,
1.046654462814331,
0.6975321173667908,
-0.42510107159614563,
-0.0426451601088047,
0.36574438214302063,
0.13181890547275543,
0.12652038037776947,
0.8741343021392822,
0.6641799807548523,
0.003506458131596446,
0.8572659492492676,
0.1804761439561844,
-0.3672850430011749,
-0.19887256622314453,
-1.045064926147461,
-1.3297035694122314,
-0.5413461923599243,
-0.21628570556640625,
0.052120961248874664,
0.01731839030981064,
0.5849888324737549,
1.1005545854568481,
-0.8930369019508362,
-0.9476975202560425,
0.011602207086980343,
-0.11078138649463654,
-0.45547613501548767,
-0.06787468492984772,
0.26849064230918884,
-0.49839428067207336,
-0.8202648162841797,
0.5994009971618652,
0.37408697605133057,
0.014108957722783089,
-0.2981323301792145,
-0.05939109995961189,
-0.08993257582187653,
-0.21280217170715332,
0.6179887652397156,
-0.010605319403111935,
-0.7505313158035278,
-0.06241872161626816,
0.07688849419355392,
-0.17175772786140442,
0.30581340193748474,
1.0419154167175293,
-0.08918877691030502,
0.4071544110774994,
0.4254535436630249,
0.7446008920669556,
0.8533445596694946,
-0.3503476679325104,
0.6903390884399414,
-0.8404770493507385,
0.3685373067855835,
-0.01414137240499258,
0.47537195682525635,
0.2905539274215698,
0.041946928948163986,
0.6105406284332275,
0.012121173553168774,
-0.41187649965286255,
-0.5134157538414001,
0.5667490363121033,
-0.8541020154953003,
-0.33852601051330566,
1.0025336742401123,
-0.20317815244197845,
0.19168440997600555,
-0.048909395933151245,
0.24114343523979187,
0.028090286999940872,
-0.0007312772213481367,
0.42365068197250366,
1.1649357080459595,
0.2076330929994583,
0.15168865025043488,
-1.187727928161621,
0.4378921091556549,
0.708129346370697,
-0.9837766289710999,
0.16100311279296875,
0.2983093857765198,
0.059341881424188614,
0.10628978163003922,
0.578330934047699,
-0.10267744958400726,
0.021294331178069115,
-0.2782312035560608,
0.12771689891815186,
-0.14939521253108978,
-0.6801221966743469,
0.009409666992723942,
0.6293652057647705,
0.21342293918132782,
0.017849333584308624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17717v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17717v1
|
AmbigNLG: Addressing Task Ambiguity in Instruction for NLG
| 2024-02-27T17:52:33 | 2024-02-27T17:52:33 |
Ayana Niwa, Hayate Iso
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study, we introduce AmbigNLG, a new task designed to tackle the
challenge of task ambiguity in instructions for Natural Language Generation
(NLG) tasks. Despite the impressive capabilities of Large Language Models
(LLMs) in understanding and executing a wide range of tasks through natural
language interaction, their performance is significantly hindered by the
ambiguity present in real-world instructions. To address this, AmbigNLG seeks
to identify and mitigate such ambiguities, aiming to refine instructions to
match user expectations better. We introduce a dataset, AmbigSNI-NLG,
consisting of 2,500 instances, and develop an ambiguity taxonomy for
categorizing and annotating instruction ambiguities. Our approach demonstrates
substantial improvements in text generation quality, highlighting the critical
role of clear and specific instructions in enhancing LLM performance in NLG
tasks.
|
[
-0.1367766559123993,
-1.3078358173370361,
0.17693959176540375,
0.4975963234901428,
-0.2976256310939789,
0.3073604702949524,
-0.20612747967243195,
-0.5567129850387573,
-0.03981634974479675,
0.5222911834716797,
-1.1510957479476929,
-0.805668830871582,
-0.8803361654281616,
0.149656742811203,
-0.16383883357048035,
0.6270758509635925,
-0.138161763548851,
-0.17269815504550934,
-0.2562068998813629,
0.3160594701766968,
-0.8465251326560974,
-0.1573987752199173,
-0.8213456869125366,
-0.5762819051742554,
0.30601128935813904,
0.6004558205604553,
1.0241527557373047,
0.8225473761558533,
0.4209006130695343,
0.28265783190727234,
0.060767583549022675,
0.6082099080085754,
-0.3369797170162201,
0.37434783577919006,
0.009378086775541306,
-0.30170443654060364,
-0.5555348992347717,
-0.1494731307029724,
0.5768578052520752,
0.7572357058525085,
-0.1387641578912735,
0.3520931601524353,
-0.040679942816495895,
0.5949802994728088,
-0.6321085691452026,
0.11148564517498016,
-0.36025774478912354,
0.31881222128868103,
-0.35121819376945496,
-0.22821755707263947,
-0.45063281059265137,
-0.13451510667800903,
0.13285253942012787,
-0.8272618055343628,
0.4368104338645935,
0.38109636306762695,
0.8831593990325928,
0.5625568628311157,
-0.3409184515476227,
-0.6615943312644958,
-0.596371054649353,
0.7900100350379944,
-0.980931282043457,
0.21388064324855804,
0.00931182038038969,
0.007797862868756056,
-0.524036169052124,
-0.5763309001922607,
-0.5185239911079407,
0.12282917648553848,
-0.11308956146240234,
0.07131952047348022,
-0.4563436806201935,
0.3282260596752167,
0.4831570088863373,
0.1309777796268463,
-0.8100315928459167,
0.3265610933303833,
-0.3032362461090088,
-0.1985771358013153,
0.6530128121376038,
0.21358942985534668,
0.3449530005455017,
-0.5319355130195618,
-0.636797308921814,
0.2401166707277298,
-0.7405838966369629,
-0.028532152995467186,
0.9036204814910889,
0.23379528522491455,
-0.009329489432275295,
0.779553234577179,
-0.22604823112487793,
1.1095319986343384,
0.09120400249958038,
0.22505682706832886,
0.3145347237586975,
-0.2803443670272827,
-0.1956859678030014,
0.5871955156326294,
0.7593722343444824,
0.4369545876979828,
-0.010517526417970657,
-0.1690794825553894,
-0.03836870938539505,
-0.2849436402320862,
0.7149567604064941,
-0.3221496343612671,
-0.04827645421028137,
-0.013960964977741241,
-0.2756476402282715,
-0.037388719618320465,
-0.05105022341012955,
-0.8778408765792847,
-0.3209647834300995,
-0.5224302411079407,
0.4469151794910431,
-0.28328877687454224,
0.040851254016160965,
0.22866611182689667,
0.010088709183037281,
0.27409854531288147,
0.4150049686431885,
-0.899505078792572,
-0.014638797380030155,
0.8405770063400269,
0.4182634651660919,
-0.08354457467794418,
-0.09552835673093796,
-0.6844291090965271,
0.4863261878490448,
0.0806020125746727,
0.44773784279823303,
-0.8139696717262268,
-0.47285935282707214,
-0.08665907382965088,
-0.1222473531961441,
-0.14152875542640686,
-0.436185359954834,
0.6604070067405701,
-0.2532872259616852,
0.5197486281394958,
-0.16482526063919067,
-0.7027254700660706,
-0.3068256080150604,
0.27376124262809753,
-0.5076846480369568,
1.178056001663208,
0.14202652871608734,
-0.7670521140098572,
0.21824227273464203,
-0.8632997870445251,
-0.4911622703075409,
0.46965813636779785,
-0.2826383411884308,
-0.43868714570999146,
0.19352079927921295,
0.15664131939411163,
0.32661569118499756,
-0.3574214577674866,
0.24519957602024078,
0.1939679980278015,
-0.49877551198005676,
-0.07676275074481964,
-0.5668449997901917,
0.7132934927940369,
0.027135426178574562,
-0.4536839425563812,
0.2620212733745575,
-0.6066979169845581,
0.2436230182647705,
-0.08374404907226562,
-0.5389559864997864,
-0.07867875695228577,
-0.0348798930644989,
-0.26010504364967346,
-0.04696453735232353,
0.6131616830825806,
-0.45668110251426697,
0.35832786560058594,
-0.5429753065109253,
0.1485130488872528,
0.5153203010559082,
0.08682755380868912,
0.38691529631614685,
-0.18613795936107635,
0.8774576187133789,
-0.08700889348983765,
0.1251426488161087,
-0.05003120005130768,
-0.8724965453147888,
-0.9491336345672607,
0.3366089165210724,
0.45955759286880493,
0.870140552520752,
-0.7881740927696228,
0.656213641166687,
-0.19638699293136597,
-0.13500387966632843,
-0.9185311198234558,
0.39967775344848633,
0.6763419508934021,
0.46961551904678345,
0.46398642659187317,
-0.16538730263710022,
-0.6916114091873169,
-1.0381108522415161,
-0.35384050011634827,
-0.12966971099376678,
-0.19832485914230347,
0.27836331725120544,
0.13631145656108856,
-0.3802765905857086,
0.7850714921951294,
-0.46561142802238464,
0.011607274413108826,
-0.07509832084178925,
0.9510064125061035,
-0.08389584720134735,
0.49815699458122253,
0.06359860301017761,
-0.8001809120178223,
-0.28898006677627563,
-0.16207130253314972,
-0.7453460097312927,
-0.536919891834259,
-0.34968772530555725,
-0.34159669280052185,
0.27455803751945496,
0.7197916507720947,
-0.5608240365982056,
0.45593640208244324,
0.6137381196022034,
-0.13757698237895966,
0.5434666275978088,
-0.36034446954727173,
0.12368650734424591,
-0.7986225485801697,
-0.2852633595466614,
-0.21258610486984253,
0.029481306672096252,
-0.7507827281951904,
-0.06374423950910568,
0.10721929371356964,
-0.039774153381586075,
-0.462215393781662,
0.6290771961212158,
-0.6529830694198608,
0.24094370007514954,
-0.28835219144821167,
0.3758001923561096,
0.09716462343931198,
0.4229162633419037,
-0.2290864884853363,
0.5224224925041199,
0.4365200400352478,
-0.48846322298049927,
0.5999560356140137,
0.344155490398407,
-0.035550542175769806,
0.348768025636673,
-0.36950406432151794,
0.053542282432317734,
-0.16465948522090912,
-0.1446794718503952,
-0.8988625407218933,
-0.39343106746673584,
0.7694389820098877,
-0.3887976109981537,
0.693778395652771,
-0.026515664532780647,
-0.5800794363021851,
-0.5454062223434448,
0.2332964986562729,
0.413663387298584,
0.27600470185279846,
-0.42966780066490173,
0.5368736982345581,
-0.015682758763432503,
-0.028460295870900154,
-0.9352765083312988,
-0.4766755700111389,
0.17706209421157837,
-0.24365109205245972,
-0.8080978989601135,
0.3414475619792938,
0.11389625072479248,
-0.14434263110160828,
0.15572893619537354,
-0.3153291642665863,
0.2522788345813751,
0.13901078701019287,
0.3559151589870453,
-0.016861222684383392,
-0.2273237407207489,
0.2726961672306061,
0.12800808250904083,
-0.19751770794391632,
0.30862337350845337,
-0.03145091235637665,
0.3202117085456848,
0.17298832535743713,
-0.6241795420646667,
0.10748659074306488,
0.4713974893093109,
-0.2041017711162567,
-0.3570535480976105,
0.45287835597991943,
1.064926028251648,
-0.36695247888565063,
-0.5108855962753296,
-0.325569748878479,
0.18828526139259338,
-0.5631045699119568,
0.2302936315536499,
-0.005219995975494385,
-0.7152193784713745,
0.29953882098197937,
-0.163368359208107,
0.2236764132976532,
0.07600723952054977,
0.30086734890937805,
-0.13759002089500427,
0.9234351515769958,
0.442960262298584,
0.5428637862205505,
0.2782970368862152,
0.2626666724681854,
0.6729280948638916,
-0.8911512494087219,
-0.3567233979701996,
-0.0918181762099266,
-0.7287405133247375,
-0.519271731376648,
-0.7317373156547546,
0.18305015563964844,
0.37889009714126587,
0.1934237778186798,
0.16696178913116455,
-0.7679348587989807,
0.5377317667007446,
0.8064320087432861,
0.1342877745628357,
0.031058356165885925,
-0.2743007242679596,
0.1120542511343956,
0.03339404612779617,
-0.8116714358329773,
-0.8113369941711426,
0.9495894908905029,
0.03817593306303024,
0.7368683218955994,
0.3032822012901306,
0.8884966373443604,
0.4577292203903198,
0.09373123943805695,
-0.6540187001228333,
0.6291808485984802,
-0.3089650273323059,
-0.6055096983909607,
-0.2749624252319336,
-0.5605911016464233,
-1.313614010810852,
0.12997816503047943,
-0.43999212980270386,
-0.7171540260314941,
-0.18124738335609436,
0.40286484360694885,
-0.45116934180259705,
0.18775969743728638,
-1.1144837141036987,
1.2835444211959839,
-0.46235665678977966,
-0.3609888255596161,
0.21173512935638428,
-0.803311824798584,
0.6225664615631104,
0.2565637230873108,
0.08480901271104813,
-0.383722186088562,
-0.11180480569601059,
0.5968433618545532,
-0.09685156494379044,
0.8363720774650574,
-0.08930402249097824,
-0.24087682366371155,
0.44640180468559265,
-0.022784169763326645,
0.4473247528076172,
-0.13592422008514404,
-0.17952552437782288,
-0.07551737874746323,
-0.5564899444580078,
-0.40377601981163025,
-0.5482825636863708,
0.65130215883255,
-0.35370635986328125,
-0.997593343257904,
-0.1269546002149582,
-0.9231148362159729,
-0.14558762311935425,
0.10165908187627792,
0.44305163621902466,
0.4752941131591797,
-0.05456574633717537,
0.01871969923377037,
0.9147722721099854,
-0.5568881630897522,
0.3250732719898224,
0.2201274037361145,
0.05697673559188843,
0.21447035670280457,
0.8518640995025635,
0.027086690068244934,
0.2881031334400177,
0.5181131362915039,
0.005028308369219303,
-0.3405565917491913,
-0.6780785322189331,
-0.6387016773223877,
-0.04558311030268669,
-0.8261213302612305,
-0.30626559257507324,
-0.4639434516429901,
-0.22167426347732544,
-0.31552428007125854,
-0.25863128900527954,
0.0703866258263588,
-0.3084407448768616,
-0.64858078956604,
0.01759178750216961,
0.2619253396987915,
0.7961146831512451,
0.1735868602991104,
0.8525469303131104,
-0.7871487140655518,
0.3934984803199768,
0.12245431542396545,
0.26804307103157043,
-0.23644515872001648,
-0.3544761836528778,
-0.17602501809597015,
0.28096988797187805,
-0.5313619375228882,
-1.1858434677124023,
0.2798222601413727,
0.1432211995124817,
0.7734304666519165,
0.17121373116970062,
0.19933727383613586,
0.7074214220046997,
-0.7176476120948792,
0.7974507212638855,
0.20197072625160217,
-1.0399442911148071,
0.5610887408256531,
-0.358913391828537,
0.7754109501838684,
0.09850342571735382,
0.2372022122144699,
-0.6097564697265625,
-0.7388131022453308,
-0.8135823607444763,
-1.4355554580688477,
0.8091881275177002,
0.22393213212490082,
-0.029730837792158127,
-0.10190407186746597,
0.545708179473877,
0.04250115901231766,
0.4420842230319977,
-0.6105096340179443,
-0.4573415219783783,
-0.07948148995637894,
-0.434878945350647,
0.19052046537399292,
-0.31374821066856384,
-0.25516849756240845,
0.33039921522140503,
0.5595108270645142,
0.04025891423225403,
0.2436867505311966,
-0.16133853793144226,
-0.1886412501335144,
-0.3329998850822449,
0.5020194053649902,
0.7300987243652344,
0.5545408725738525,
-0.03856385871767998,
0.3425595760345459,
0.0889497771859169,
-0.27162352204322815,
0.03255871310830116,
0.1506773978471756,
-0.16627587378025055,
0.14164908230304718,
0.42409148812294006,
0.9279552102088928,
0.6217491030693054,
-0.8370157480239868,
0.3014011085033417,
0.04235050454735756,
-0.2849023640155792,
-0.1514652520418167,
0.48743322491645813,
0.06754351407289505,
0.1396545171737671,
0.27568328380584717,
0.02596895769238472,
0.15988685190677643,
-0.05566564202308655,
0.2555888295173645,
0.455132395029068,
-0.19145852327346802,
0.13585194945335388,
0.7188725471496582,
0.4292641580104828,
-0.777391791343689,
0.6177741289138794,
-0.8073379397392273,
-0.456849068403244,
0.6291193962097168,
0.4205169379711151,
0.7027568221092224,
-0.020418940111994743,
0.2249303013086319,
0.3092430531978607,
0.5304818749427795,
0.14851880073547363,
0.2690817713737488,
0.2240770310163498,
-0.4758414030075073,
-0.4973977506160736,
-0.5323588252067566,
-0.569938600063324,
-0.12435270845890045,
-0.6807220578193665,
0.27968886494636536,
-0.38501104712486267,
-0.128750279545784,
-0.07216162979602814,
-0.09653396159410477,
-0.5277612805366516,
0.10301613062620163,
0.5199661254882812,
0.5870644450187683,
-0.6377953290939331,
0.4458317756652832,
0.7307032346725464,
0.013593930751085281,
-0.6864707469940186,
-0.0586712546646595,
0.18701030313968658,
-0.728661298751831,
0.5909056663513184,
0.2939361333847046,
-0.10868160426616669,
0.06846083700656891,
-0.29884856939315796,
-0.5265350937843323,
1.063088297843933,
0.38313615322113037,
-0.4626654088497162,
-0.3278849422931671,
0.39392396807670593,
0.40363192558288574,
-0.4073903262615204,
-0.025987472385168076,
0.38268721103668213,
0.7445055246353149,
0.1725315898656845,
-0.6344059705734253,
0.11444082111120224,
-0.16674304008483887,
-0.1385132372379303,
0.6473300457000732,
-0.3305782079696655,
0.4861016571521759,
-0.2345615178346634,
-0.4816758632659912,
-0.049569450318813324,
0.6476132273674011,
0.18825462460517883,
0.21881000697612762,
0.45547041296958923,
0.518021821975708,
1.072061538696289,
-0.6432034373283386,
0.7329625487327576,
-0.05687626078724861,
-0.1186109110713005,
1.489599585533142,
-0.0014015220804139972,
0.5426815152168274,
0.48198431730270386,
0.18030613660812378,
0.33855438232421875,
0.7704260945320129,
-0.23326441645622253,
-0.11027956753969193,
0.5578407645225525,
-0.48823055624961853,
-0.4472573399543762,
0.05677755922079086,
-0.18840473890304565,
0.4585689306259155,
0.5608760118484497,
-0.2223600298166275,
-0.5673662424087524,
-0.04681246727705002,
-0.02649477869272232,
0.27754420042037964,
-0.22589543461799622,
0.48918676376342773,
-0.3541682958602905,
-0.6151830554008484,
0.43703120946884155,
0.21445640921592712,
0.6998547911643982,
-0.7065737843513489,
-0.23882001638412476,
0.24416178464889526,
-0.11002187430858612,
-0.35001564025878906,
-0.8929899334907532,
0.328998863697052,
0.016005389392375946,
-0.19274228811264038,
-0.611457109451294,
0.47728413343429565,
-0.7628549933433533,
-0.5300232768058777,
0.17200128734111786,
0.38593149185180664,
0.12923340499401093,
0.3356417715549469,
-1.0019245147705078,
0.1910676807165146,
0.37275412678718567,
-0.12846022844314575,
-0.1196853294968605,
0.8757951855659485,
0.07609938830137253,
0.7101240158081055,
0.12871426343917847,
-0.2429049164056778,
0.9167636036872864,
-0.21949833631515503,
0.2880362570285797,
-0.5387443900108337,
-0.01883070357143879,
-0.7095184326171875,
0.6306238174438477,
0.022782256826758385,
-0.4250389039516449,
0.9629636406898499,
0.5282946228981018,
0.7691779136657715,
0.0474141463637352,
0.6061563491821289,
-0.32186979055404663,
0.3537972867488861,
-0.6839631795883179,
0.2085396647453308,
-0.4444471001625061,
0.6338944435119629,
0.07685354351997375,
-0.6520221829414368,
-0.4030721187591553,
0.5689358115196228,
-0.5014777183532715,
-0.11095508188009262,
0.3752492070198059,
0.8721386790275574,
-0.16645042598247528,
0.27276208996772766,
0.10127515345811844,
0.014134314842522144,
0.3317973017692566,
0.6582212448120117,
0.8173514604568481,
-0.41071367263793945,
0.6878411173820496,
-0.13515296578407288,
0.06865032762289047,
-0.22336697578430176,
-1.121554970741272,
-0.8239283561706543,
-0.15434445440769196,
-0.6734099388122559,
0.009672020561993122,
0.13070473074913025,
1.035541296005249,
0.4994862675666809,
-0.4531654715538025,
-0.21656829118728638,
-0.17420220375061035,
0.5482457876205444,
-0.2540338933467865,
-0.23640117049217224,
0.05710182711482048,
-0.6227442026138306,
-0.889361560344696,
0.43339794874191284,
0.06387471407651901,
0.14781484007835388,
-0.12340790033340454,
-0.15230412781238556,
-0.5106702446937561,
-0.028333107009530067,
0.26589441299438477,
0.21410934627056122,
-0.8136445879936218,
-0.3987188935279846,
-0.11648865044116974,
0.02040410228073597,
-0.03309270367026329,
0.6856516003608704,
-0.35102128982543945,
0.7262418866157532,
0.37913960218429565,
0.675929069519043,
0.17046119272708893,
0.2925117313861847,
0.8544183969497681,
-1.6457239389419556,
-0.06504273414611816,
0.15872900187969208,
-0.019811827689409256,
0.4009230136871338,
-0.5554073452949524,
0.41883769631385803,
-0.14826679229736328,
-0.5161346197128296,
-0.7753669023513794,
0.478340744972229,
-1.012925386428833,
-0.30719563364982605,
1.1732782125473022,
-0.11941356211900711,
-0.1769263595342636,
-0.18920040130615234,
-0.2620558440685272,
0.49909231066703796,
-0.30839991569519043,
0.6285527944564819,
0.9109407663345337,
-0.43071606755256653,
-0.2747058570384979,
-0.8621087074279785,
0.5236379504203796,
0.4751014709472656,
-0.7849366068840027,
0.38225626945495605,
0.5455167293548584,
-0.3198898732662201,
0.2727137506008148,
-0.04257066547870636,
0.1656944453716278,
0.357327401638031,
-0.12029056996107101,
0.2407873123884201,
-0.24952825903892517,
-0.10934086889028549,
-0.1646696925163269,
0.21088187396526337,
-0.04193202778697014,
-0.23841577768325806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17709v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17709v2
|
Case-Based or Rule-Based: How Do Transformers Do the Math?
| 2024-02-27T17:41:58 | 2024-06-26T09:25:07 |
Yi Hu, Xiaojuan Tang, Haotong Yang, Muhan Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Despite the impressive performance in a variety of complex tasks, modern
large language models (LLMs) still have trouble dealing with some math problems
that are simple and intuitive for humans, such as addition. While we can easily
learn basic rules of addition and apply them to new problems of any length,
LLMs struggle to do the same. Instead, they may rely on similar cases seen in
the training corpus for help. We define these two different reasoning
mechanisms as "rule-based reasoning" and "case-based reasoning". Since
rule-based reasoning is essential for acquiring systematic generalization
ability, we aim to explore exactly whether transformers use rule-based or
case-based reasoning for math problems. Through carefully designed intervention
experiments on five math tasks, we confirm that transformers are performing
case-based reasoning, no matter whether scratchpad is used, which aligns with
the previous observations that transformers use subgraph matching/shortcut
learning to reason. To mitigate such problems, we propose a Rule-Following
Fine-Tuning (RFFT) technique to teach transformers to perform rule-based
reasoning. Specifically, we provide explicit rules in the input and then
instruct transformers to recite and follow the rules step by step. Through
RFFT, we successfully enable LLMs fine-tuned on 1-5 digit addition to
generalize to up to 12-digit addition with over 95% accuracy, which is over 40%
higher than scratchpad. The significant improvement demonstrates that teaching
LLMs to use rules explicitly helps them learn rule-based reasoning and
generalize better in length.
|
[
-0.6316529512405396,
-0.9678695201873779,
0.7236247658729553,
0.23746658861637115,
-0.24992837011814117,
0.19433002173900604,
-0.21134677529335022,
-0.07381434738636017,
-0.0458899550139904,
0.6913027763366699,
-0.8132807612419128,
-0.1684361696243286,
-0.536590576171875,
0.07010797411203384,
-0.35993778705596924,
1.0637654066085815,
-0.004356473684310913,
0.10914594680070877,
-0.4709891974925995,
-0.06556915491819382,
-0.7302713990211487,
-0.7391795516014099,
-0.49505889415740967,
-0.677574098110199,
0.41027629375457764,
0.8189021348953247,
0.9250643849372864,
0.5666924715042114,
0.984437882900238,
0.25608888268470764,
-0.04904565587639809,
0.11972299963235855,
-0.16439922153949738,
-0.19048811495304108,
-0.26947495341300964,
-0.8441224098205566,
-0.3155129551887512,
-0.1647353619337082,
-0.030196094885468483,
0.8687825798988342,
-0.4481172561645508,
0.10223405063152313,
-0.5311716198921204,
0.7576920986175537,
-0.2656954824924469,
0.15717297792434692,
-0.4867704510688782,
0.3824214041233063,
0.026418296620249748,
-0.45418328046798706,
-0.5349776744842529,
-0.3047938346862793,
0.002118132309988141,
-0.5292909741401672,
0.5748211741447449,
-0.018441570922732353,
0.5717031955718994,
0.49202391505241394,
-0.3408895432949066,
-0.5072872638702393,
-1.0921125411987305,
0.8880752921104431,
-0.35496896505355835,
0.5283022522926331,
0.35215914249420166,
0.4323444664478302,
-0.15276741981506348,
-0.5311778783798218,
-0.5526195764541626,
-0.012318980880081654,
-0.32092538475990295,
0.09444176405668259,
-0.2169579416513443,
0.07197966426610947,
0.9628282785415649,
0.1331859529018402,
-0.13701537251472473,
-0.14139628410339355,
-0.5695711374282837,
-0.06627468019723892,
0.41158151626586914,
0.09374524652957916,
0.17891956865787506,
0.0926654189825058,
-0.14030909538269043,
-0.24994222819805145,
-0.8115980625152588,
0.07043693214654922,
0.10742795467376709,
0.25654399394989014,
-0.04766975715756416,
0.7949199080467224,
-0.01770447939634323,
0.5935652852058411,
0.3389938473701477,
-0.17570340633392334,
-0.11653556674718857,
-0.09180065244436264,
-0.2818719446659088,
0.06238994002342224,
0.13387656211853027,
0.40886518359184265,
1.0282599925994873,
-0.14630120992660522,
-0.2830376923084259,
0.2672054171562195,
0.3428342044353485,
-0.7019210457801819,
0.024094732478260994,
-0.18419428169727325,
-0.41323381662368774,
-0.2324865609407425,
-0.0649222806096077,
-0.5524485111236572,
-0.21719355881214142,
-0.8085902333259583,
0.7720198631286621,
-0.3857118785381317,
0.09672139585018158,
0.5436710119247437,
-0.3572794497013092,
0.4578566551208496,
0.5850110054016113,
-1.02682626247406,
0.5563315153121948,
0.9477974772453308,
0.3725298047065735,
0.18868419528007507,
-0.07624036818742752,
-0.7466999292373657,
-0.013272510841488838,
-0.33395665884017944,
1.1042356491088867,
-0.5267543792724609,
-0.41579607129096985,
-0.017619663849473,
-0.2192346453666687,
-0.09405586123466492,
-0.8102807402610779,
0.817450761795044,
-0.45745062828063965,
0.18717549741268158,
-0.20257896184921265,
-0.5119167566299438,
0.02740643173456192,
-0.011491739191114902,
-0.3678032457828522,
0.7241960167884827,
0.09634248912334442,
-0.28980621695518494,
0.5235936045646667,
-0.658303439617157,
-0.9856904745101929,
-0.06535304337739944,
-0.04437868669629097,
-0.5190867781639099,
0.3911873996257782,
0.308133065700531,
0.4452594220638275,
-0.2839275598526001,
0.3072650730609894,
-0.16151487827301025,
-0.7325703501701355,
0.21297039091587067,
-0.4025895893573761,
0.47242113947868347,
0.1116950511932373,
-0.27098217606544495,
0.012246362864971161,
-0.42718976736068726,
-0.2069331705570221,
0.10841885209083557,
-0.18066824972629547,
-0.1439584493637085,
0.32138076424598694,
-0.43437084555625916,
0.1675756275653839,
-0.14279569685459137,
-0.37574106454849243,
0.3820241093635559,
-0.18265880644321442,
0.3503766655921936,
0.6750310659408569,
-0.1601325124502182,
0.5045840740203857,
-0.6785728335380554,
0.35014408826828003,
-0.04402649775147438,
0.2231549322605133,
-0.22079169750213623,
-0.4412148594856262,
-1.269216775894165,
-0.08235402405261993,
0.3248225450515747,
0.7085648775100708,
-0.6483421325683594,
0.44831934571266174,
-0.1948401778936386,
-0.2803736925125122,
-0.1829061508178711,
-0.004292892757803202,
-0.09547457844018936,
0.5921680927276611,
0.822314441204071,
-0.11850185692310333,
-0.5227741003036499,
-0.8895256519317627,
-0.24542342126369476,
0.08881007879972458,
-0.08539358526468277,
0.2304256558418274,
0.46589577198028564,
-0.2023264765739441,
0.9881284832954407,
-0.6756290793418884,
-0.42578503489494324,
-0.44673264026641846,
-0.022182539105415344,
0.4603174328804016,
0.1965399533510208,
0.42508208751678467,
-0.6225041151046753,
-0.40717658400535583,
-0.19630584120750427,
-0.5300887823104858,
-0.2542332410812378,
-0.5217231512069702,
0.024193502962589264,
0.1016993448138237,
0.7556519508361816,
-0.6864686012268066,
0.5359095931053162,
-0.16799390316009521,
-0.490584135055542,
0.4142201840877533,
-0.20536425709724426,
-0.12863986194133759,
-0.5229597687721252,
-0.5202666521072388,
0.24959370493888855,
-0.2783602178096771,
-0.6429609656333923,
0.03822450339794159,
0.0461377315223217,
0.06500387191772461,
-0.25230681896209717,
0.25616511702537537,
-0.07915263622999191,
-0.04135974869132042,
-0.26151978969573975,
-0.3029322624206543,
-0.02122020162642002,
0.6516731381416321,
0.078136146068573,
0.8196597099304199,
0.365163654088974,
-0.5559167265892029,
0.3493214547634125,
0.029861312359571457,
-0.23252205550670624,
0.7623512744903564,
-0.6350077390670776,
-0.08053858578205109,
-0.1771230399608612,
0.1333639770746231,
-0.5461302995681763,
0.21041597425937653,
0.06408829241991043,
-0.14884750545024872,
0.23862046003341675,
-0.3063403367996216,
-0.7451062798500061,
-0.42932164669036865,
-0.11023955047130585,
0.07704955339431763,
0.9451519846916199,
-0.7052684426307678,
1.0373066663742065,
-0.04271650314331055,
0.006626779213547707,
-0.34179145097732544,
-0.45104703307151794,
-0.1551092267036438,
-0.3538520932197571,
-0.5722678899765015,
0.47354552149772644,
-0.1852087378501892,
-0.5467603802680969,
-0.15274688601493835,
-0.3886193335056305,
-0.1681952327489853,
0.19700752198696136,
0.04100538417696953,
0.12798702716827393,
-0.11992548406124115,
0.06427620351314545,
0.3429158627986908,
-0.20689657330513,
0.31372755765914917,
0.33050718903541565,
0.5454316735267639,
-0.1300029158592224,
-0.5853390693664551,
-0.08055691421031952,
0.3874412178993225,
0.6218918561935425,
-0.19872796535491943,
0.35335472226142883,
0.20100893080234528,
-0.2741762697696686,
-0.539963960647583,
-0.6425774097442627,
-0.5644946694374084,
-0.5461614727973938,
0.07089775800704956,
-0.5637855529785156,
-0.7576783895492554,
0.39496538043022156,
-0.3048318922519684,
0.13355350494384766,
0.5139243006706238,
0.598449170589447,
-0.41891372203826904,
1.001902461051941,
0.6182802319526672,
0.29816046357154846,
0.4709450900554657,
-0.1859891265630722,
0.22377587854862213,
-0.47983893752098083,
-0.16984957456588745,
-0.4519033133983612,
-0.2734220623970032,
-0.27146944403648376,
-0.528474748134613,
0.20613384246826172,
0.13274221122264862,
-0.2487022876739502,
0.43362778425216675,
-0.4704929292201996,
0.7313711643218994,
0.6721084117889404,
0.10838520526885986,
0.40965035557746887,
0.19379715621471405,
-0.32065972685813904,
-0.02353750728070736,
-0.6297159194946289,
-0.0770791620016098,
0.928865373134613,
0.2942051291465759,
0.9747181534767151,
0.1530909687280655,
0.58613520860672,
0.46480995416641235,
0.4351571798324585,
-1.2649331092834473,
0.6911630630493164,
-0.2098439484834671,
-0.4088383615016937,
-0.09062573313713074,
-0.5168958902359009,
-0.7384706735610962,
0.15650025010108948,
-0.32455140352249146,
-0.12535834312438965,
0.029335225000977516,
-0.07970843464136124,
-0.2389499843120575,
0.18021132051944733,
-1.0550901889801025,
0.4733622670173645,
-0.34719181060791016,
-0.07300586998462677,
-0.5139715075492859,
-0.3709542155265808,
0.11366986483335495,
-0.07838823646306992,
0.33126354217529297,
-0.023810893297195435,
0.41019555926322937,
0.5202056765556335,
-0.7855095863342285,
0.7711728811264038,
-0.03492233157157898,
-0.09788617491722107,
0.2907451391220093,
0.17232546210289001,
0.363294392824173,
-0.1467830240726471,
0.30750927329063416,
0.06076149642467499,
0.026744922623038292,
-0.08863551169633865,
-0.97784823179245,
0.327814519405365,
-0.6322293877601624,
-0.9224737286567688,
-0.5536571145057678,
-0.5333894491195679,
-0.37433865666389465,
0.08436161279678345,
-0.05300283804535866,
0.4158489406108856,
0.26668182015419006,
0.3044845163822174,
0.8687531352043152,
-0.054316196590662,
0.3716679811477661,
0.7203266620635986,
-0.15487024188041687,
-0.15682832896709442,
0.9602124691009521,
0.15745112299919128,
0.126443013548851,
0.6303573250770569,
0.45210888981819153,
-0.2929636538028717,
-0.14613798260688782,
-0.46657299995422363,
0.35564014315605164,
-0.7134345769882202,
-0.21852819621562958,
-0.2881300151348114,
-0.3573305904865265,
0.05104997381567955,
-0.47428837418556213,
0.021636437624692917,
-0.5985868573188782,
0.0017361972713842988,
-0.05881190299987793,
0.5495771169662476,
0.42230042815208435,
0.016256771981716156,
0.22162598371505737,
-0.5837928652763367,
0.6788325309753418,
0.6787285804748535,
0.5709118843078613,
-0.2397059053182602,
-0.5794139504432678,
-0.08690725266933441,
-0.08734838664531708,
-0.35222765803337097,
-0.4498867094516754,
-0.1622471660375595,
0.01828467845916748,
0.4438667893409729,
0.13279257714748383,
-0.21741078794002533,
0.7308581471443176,
-0.8608314394950867,
0.042137596756219864,
0.03445840999484062,
-0.964539110660553,
0.31045788526535034,
-0.2565203011035919,
0.06244748458266258,
0.24793562293052673,
-0.0718599185347557,
-0.6853024959564209,
-0.09644214808940887,
-0.6237748861312866,
-0.3525819778442383,
0.6821197271347046,
0.1596771478652954,
0.31425395607948303,
0.07380855083465576,
0.49606606364250183,
-0.0902736634016037,
0.19230340421199799,
-0.2490871548652649,
-0.397229939699173,
-0.2776721715927124,
-0.3661682605743408,
0.14126434922218323,
-0.05459372699260712,
-0.1653585135936737,
-0.6861218214035034,
0.2314358353614807,
-0.2696392834186554,
0.48682719469070435,
-0.026442036032676697,
-0.17167502641677856,
-0.2732873260974884,
0.3552151024341583,
0.9564604759216309,
0.5084711313247681,
-0.20604629814624786,
-0.041711241006851196,
0.28027987480163574,
-0.3760817050933838,
0.04822149500250816,
0.1406162828207016,
-0.20227117836475372,
-0.14114521443843842,
0.40339937806129456,
0.5516953468322754,
0.14675240218639374,
-0.7654783725738525,
0.44452157616615295,
-0.23783987760543823,
-0.6574841141700745,
-0.40346115827560425,
0.36182329058647156,
0.16986915469169617,
0.08030405640602112,
0.5317493677139282,
0.29590728878974915,
-0.02032935619354248,
-0.5745469331741333,
0.3818013370037079,
0.5067564249038696,
-0.10987690836191177,
-0.0789150819182396,
0.3058401346206665,
0.1926107257604599,
-0.6374778747558594,
0.5540916919708252,
0.26881086826324463,
-0.5939729809761047,
1.0793660879135132,
0.5683945417404175,
0.5928056836128235,
0.2598229646682739,
0.23351837694644928,
0.05972130969166756,
0.5066916346549988,
-0.20345348119735718,
0.33115866780281067,
-0.14869636297225952,
-1.0823431015014648,
-0.8255016207695007,
-0.39914920926094055,
-0.8964446187019348,
-0.15426090359687805,
-0.6226500272750854,
0.45432522892951965,
-0.7835583090782166,
0.08457369357347488,
0.1510424017906189,
-0.15258294343948364,
-0.7232155799865723,
0.35653144121170044,
-0.06002800539135933,
0.9694344401359558,
-0.5906791687011719,
0.47164013981819153,
0.5909883379936218,
-0.1624632328748703,
-0.8057149052619934,
-0.10203977674245834,
-0.24752284586429596,
-0.9377322793006897,
0.5275364518165588,
0.2545637786388397,
-0.09662030637264252,
-0.09988296777009964,
-0.4833163619041443,
-0.5802503824234009,
0.7054156064987183,
0.24513453245162964,
-0.5684732794761658,
0.09695978462696075,
0.377259224653244,
0.7864632606506348,
-0.1404997706413269,
0.36994364857673645,
0.631694495677948,
0.5041890740394592,
0.37150707840919495,
-0.7447201013565063,
-0.22473680973052979,
-0.10385316610336304,
-0.5116310715675354,
0.678337037563324,
-0.6947358846664429,
0.5444774627685547,
-0.4703245162963867,
0.018015174195170403,
-0.3077901303768158,
0.40878546237945557,
0.1580495685338974,
0.34491848945617676,
0.5499270558357239,
0.8223439455032349,
0.4209812879562378,
-0.4399150609970093,
0.9868698716163635,
-0.13335131108760834,
0.379119873046875,
0.8521156907081604,
-0.20668764412403107,
0.462958425283432,
0.4840970039367676,
-0.2695431709289551,
0.773760974407196,
0.2089364230632782,
-0.40626978874206543,
0.3184938132762909,
0.26601287722587585,
-0.08241133391857147,
-0.6742269992828369,
-0.011670314706861973,
-0.14751343429088593,
0.41952356696128845,
0.5556672215461731,
-0.22533144056797028,
-0.32863298058509827,
-0.15618544816970825,
0.010542741976678371,
0.09100086241960526,
-0.40933001041412354,
0.7430889010429382,
0.11460166424512863,
-0.6891564726829529,
0.2893413305282593,
0.25214746594429016,
0.6122338771820068,
-0.46063315868377686,
-0.3813035786151886,
-0.31700772047042847,
0.3350038528442383,
-0.21328315138816833,
-0.8678644299507141,
0.5065493583679199,
-0.02940373867750168,
-0.4154740273952484,
-0.40302178263664246,
0.6668541431427002,
-0.1293705403804779,
-0.8427767753601074,
0.031064212322235107,
0.6594613194465637,
-0.246133953332901,
0.18457667529582977,
-0.6087731122970581,
-0.25368833541870117,
-0.07344922423362732,
0.1296968311071396,
0.31186559796333313,
0.439241498708725,
-0.4455154538154602,
0.8084751963615417,
0.8218516707420349,
-0.13383136689662933,
-0.13145874440670013,
0.5067451000213623,
0.7950573563575745,
-0.8106632232666016,
0.03004574589431286,
-0.9458276033401489,
0.32798781991004944,
0.1727253645658493,
-0.1687510907649994,
0.470435231924057,
0.49990054965019226,
0.8474888801574707,
-0.21956662833690643,
0.5720186829566956,
0.19668860733509064,
0.544826090335846,
-0.5659059286117554,
0.2464347630739212,
-0.4337601065635681,
0.21095587313175201,
-0.16444820165634155,
-0.9386038184165955,
-0.6524642705917358,
1.0236480236053467,
-0.3657090961933136,
0.16918730735778809,
0.757952868938446,
0.5665109157562256,
-0.2676931917667389,
0.10554684698581696,
0.2555617690086365,
-0.14741714298725128,
0.43512865900993347,
0.5169998407363892,
0.7799561619758606,
-0.17164762318134308,
0.6819944977760315,
-0.43201881647109985,
-0.07557957619428635,
-0.21968480944633484,
-0.6489980816841125,
-1.0700925588607788,
0.00012583154602907598,
-0.22285553812980652,
-0.07787473499774933,
-0.3243027925491333,
0.8866037130355835,
0.39391183853149414,
-0.7236192226409912,
-0.2858482897281647,
-0.37273216247558594,
0.5630726218223572,
-0.3928822875022888,
-0.27668625116348267,
0.1301761269569397,
-0.21917660534381866,
-0.5269287824630737,
0.31939804553985596,
0.2898186445236206,
0.10046060383319855,
0.12077872455120087,
0.1619420051574707,
0.21092446148395538,
0.49225717782974243,
0.6863171458244324,
0.14605627954006195,
-0.5127509832382202,
-0.4928658604621887,
0.3952904939651489,
0.04033758491277695,
0.202004075050354,
1.1465282440185547,
-0.8060417175292969,
0.2204122543334961,
0.3092878758907318,
0.4524765610694885,
0.5183994174003601,
0.19663354754447937,
0.45876234769821167,
-0.37055304646492004,
-0.06736887991428375,
0.08583540469408035,
0.5543238520622253,
0.21199236810207367,
-0.16934171319007874,
0.5209017395973206,
0.49148914217948914,
-0.38552066683769226,
-0.6766455173492432,
0.47610801458358765,
-0.8257337212562561,
-0.19733937084674835,
1.0173263549804688,
0.49537575244903564,
0.14425483345985413,
-0.10749442130327225,
-0.39193522930145264,
-0.05534739047288895,
-0.35376134514808655,
0.8375738859176636,
0.695885419845581,
-0.3224581778049469,
-0.30101966857910156,
-0.17316481471061707,
0.4852010905742645,
0.6824022531509399,
-0.6920457482337952,
-0.1765112429857254,
0.3425123989582062,
0.34246179461479187,
0.3338184058666229,
0.19472280144691467,
0.11040390282869339,
0.45509573817253113,
-0.3165587782859802,
-0.20795567333698273,
-0.1552627980709076,
-0.521797776222229,
-0.13743148744106293,
0.055003419518470764,
-0.07188389450311661,
0.43714600801467896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17700v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17700v1
|
RAVEL: Evaluating Interpretability Methods on Disentangling Language Model Representations
| 2024-02-27T17:25:37 | 2024-02-27T17:25:37 |
Jing Huang, Zhengxuan Wu, Christopher Potts, Mor Geva, Atticus Geiger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Individual neurons participate in the representation of multiple high-level
concepts. To what extent can different interpretability methods successfully
disentangle these roles? To help address this question, we introduce RAVEL
(Resolving Attribute-Value Entanglements in Language Models), a dataset that
enables tightly controlled, quantitative comparisons between a variety of
existing interpretability methods. We use the resulting conceptual framework to
define the new method of Multi-task Distributed Alignment Search (MDAS), which
allows us to find distributed representations satisfying multiple causal
criteria. With Llama2-7B as the target language model, MDAS achieves
state-of-the-art results on RAVEL, demonstrating the importance of going beyond
neuron-level analyses to identify features distributed across activations. We
release our benchmark at https://github.com/explanare/ravel.
|
[
-0.1678406149148941,
-0.7552892565727234,
0.7335905432701111,
0.6002447009086609,
0.06044280529022217,
0.3513747453689575,
-0.18909722566604614,
-0.5116113424301147,
0.06772200018167496,
0.09939765185117722,
-0.3843795359134674,
-0.3142704963684082,
-0.9997285008430481,
0.14802156388759613,
-0.6445127129554749,
0.6582321524620056,
-0.23401890695095062,
0.05690966919064522,
-0.40216299891471863,
-0.23193252086639404,
-0.31283101439476013,
-0.21918606758117676,
-0.5235055088996887,
-0.6716023087501526,
0.7301895618438721,
0.11612613499164581,
0.5980279445648193,
0.6574096083641052,
0.940199613571167,
0.28414446115493774,
-0.3166428208351135,
0.2926907539367676,
-0.3242514133453369,
0.33252766728401184,
-0.2874789535999298,
-0.5705695152282715,
-0.5884211659431458,
0.1955619752407074,
0.6388639211654663,
0.7080990672111511,
-0.5802187323570251,
0.26443058252334595,
0.05899422615766525,
0.7960510849952698,
-0.7846957445144653,
0.19926676154136658,
-0.6233385801315308,
-0.13182465732097626,
-0.4705955386161804,
0.0037684051785618067,
-0.6406503915786743,
-0.27180808782577515,
0.1760830283164978,
-0.48720404505729675,
-0.0023842588998377323,
-0.05048522353172302,
0.7698941826820374,
0.33265382051467896,
-0.5474050641059875,
-0.4917943775653839,
-0.600543200969696,
0.8596173524856567,
-0.6859155297279358,
0.4315929412841797,
0.3494868874549866,
0.4189346432685852,
-0.006007803604006767,
-0.5957270860671997,
-0.665540337562561,
-0.11752676218748093,
-0.06749897450208664,
0.09431091696023941,
-0.3710479736328125,
-0.07946933060884476,
0.2409374862909317,
0.3220910429954529,
-0.4753643274307251,
0.010255430825054646,
-0.2523864805698395,
0.05412794649600983,
0.6835550665855408,
0.1635531634092331,
0.3058713376522064,
0.05804011970758438,
-0.2193465530872345,
-0.07880449295043945,
-0.49919942021369934,
-0.13032126426696777,
0.34818217158317566,
0.11747356504201889,
-0.1604853719472885,
0.6240602731704712,
-0.005446137394756079,
0.6666810512542725,
0.3571186065673828,
0.12275972962379456,
0.3385477662086487,
-0.11933423578739166,
-0.02401985228061676,
-0.03884612023830414,
0.5731006860733032,
0.04376295953989029,
0.04821318760514259,
-0.288069486618042,
-0.30233585834503174,
0.10763764381408691,
0.40209832787513733,
-0.4411872625350952,
-0.06222511827945709,
0.4408983588218689,
-0.6417043209075928,
-0.2993582785129547,
-0.1241772472858429,
-0.8203979730606079,
-0.9639525413513184,
-0.42714980244636536,
0.22243180871009827,
-0.21098704636096954,
-0.5638396143913269,
0.2788776755332947,
-0.03823096305131912,
0.22542402148246765,
0.14349626004695892,
-0.9275328516960144,
0.4870685935020447,
0.5457391738891602,
0.8794971108436584,
-0.5680611729621887,
-0.5204411745071411,
-0.29689207673072815,
0.0009089310769923031,
-0.5821326971054077,
0.7934377193450928,
-0.6952985525131226,
0.1606484204530716,
-0.1798952966928482,
-0.31211212277412415,
-0.3276683986186981,
-0.6709272265434265,
0.3946931064128876,
-0.8905201554298401,
-0.2942348122596741,
-0.1609344333410263,
-0.4525510370731354,
-0.24281561374664307,
0.23796838521957397,
-0.865889847278595,
0.88285893201828,
0.00111846299842,
-0.7126145362854004,
0.22628344595432281,
-0.6733954548835754,
-0.3430284261703491,
-0.40869417786598206,
-0.13809004426002502,
-0.31105107069015503,
0.35511401295661926,
0.21231575310230255,
0.4261997640132904,
-0.5390749573707581,
0.40175727009773254,
-0.22768113017082214,
-0.24566201865673065,
0.6188896894454956,
-0.4888109266757965,
0.5871191024780273,
0.4601042866706848,
-0.3717697262763977,
0.19392140209674835,
-0.7703580260276794,
0.022077340632677078,
0.15404528379440308,
-0.18270224332809448,
-0.26615431904792786,
0.3994504511356354,
0.010298196226358414,
0.3352304697036743,
0.48645636439323425,
-0.3478076159954071,
0.1631157547235489,
-0.23834961652755737,
0.2771792709827423,
0.8179388642311096,
-0.23394733667373657,
0.47594526410102844,
0.03866201639175415,
0.3818679749965668,
0.6227521300315857,
0.21896986663341522,
0.2641812860965729,
-0.40064504742622375,
-0.6993921399116516,
-0.30686289072036743,
-0.02366556040942669,
0.25635552406311035,
-0.48484012484550476,
0.1958356648683548,
-0.16737090051174164,
-0.5434780716896057,
-0.7373245358467102,
0.08153007924556732,
0.4098680913448334,
-0.041505828499794006,
0.3862125873565674,
-0.17069363594055176,
-0.5783168077468872,
-1.1351745128631592,
-0.4115232825279236,
0.01782846450805664,
0.2356358915567398,
0.026451686397194862,
0.3487323522567749,
-0.5514952540397644,
0.8202031850814819,
-0.49956396222114563,
-0.12949994206428528,
-0.2806580364704132,
0.2970411479473114,
0.6191887855529785,
0.20865757763385773,
0.30171331763267517,
-0.7336437702178955,
-0.5381854176521301,
0.4583419859409332,
-0.922132134437561,
-0.09037002921104431,
-0.2468869388103485,
-0.009496473707258701,
-0.18882228434085846,
0.25415825843811035,
-0.5054497718811035,
0.3335212767124176,
0.8901128768920898,
-0.26032593846321106,
0.3644181191921234,
-0.10893456637859344,
0.3099374771118164,
-0.9863353371620178,
0.04223807528614998,
0.08634041994810104,
0.056537993252277374,
-0.734378457069397,
0.116582952439785,
0.30477046966552734,
0.15679052472114563,
-0.15817512571811676,
0.2802186608314514,
-0.6541053652763367,
-0.20798027515411377,
-0.351805180311203,
0.307024747133255,
-0.11088354885578156,
0.2181837260723114,
-0.18273496627807617,
0.8461127877235413,
0.987022340297699,
-0.5692102313041687,
0.28624796867370605,
0.21467506885528564,
-0.2086157202720642,
0.7591667175292969,
-0.789480984210968,
0.28605785965919495,
-0.23986920714378357,
-0.021777458488941193,
-0.8279733657836914,
-0.08790581673383713,
0.12241992354393005,
-0.284381240606308,
0.2030942738056183,
-0.042364515364170074,
-0.26477134227752686,
0.057830810546875,
0.06574644893407822,
0.5946982502937317,
0.277914434671402,
-0.6666750907897949,
0.7937666773796082,
0.44602903723716736,
0.2517490088939667,
-0.8401854634284973,
-0.595418393611908,
0.04938511550426483,
-0.2766803205013275,
-0.35489600896835327,
0.22100579738616943,
0.06896785646677017,
-0.5276358127593994,
-0.19906391203403473,
-0.3693886399269104,
-0.31526145339012146,
0.1481824666261673,
0.2509964108467102,
0.06019943580031395,
-0.056712716817855835,
0.04924270883202553,
-0.011034688912332058,
-0.14483799040317535,
0.04974990338087082,
0.04472924768924713,
0.556511640548706,
-0.2024616003036499,
-0.6313007473945618,
-0.32858365774154663,
0.34117740392684937,
0.6416897773742676,
-0.5184457898139954,
0.9243941307067871,
0.41544458270072937,
-0.35488906502723694,
-0.4011133909225464,
-0.4037012457847595,
0.05537819862365723,
-0.5167789459228516,
0.3853531777858734,
-0.5928915143013,
-0.4778338670730591,
0.7591384649276733,
-0.23513424396514893,
-0.063939169049263,
0.4810025691986084,
0.6494208574295044,
-0.15774673223495483,
1.217590570449829,
0.49286949634552,
0.10363109409809113,
0.4306517243385315,
-0.18659541010856628,
0.32842570543289185,
-1.065990924835205,
-0.3079868257045746,
-0.48364323377609253,
-0.4069139063358307,
-0.43823927640914917,
-0.598385214805603,
0.16437622904777527,
0.24796046316623688,
-0.013011534698307514,
0.44264480471611023,
-0.5532026886940002,
0.5528356432914734,
0.15430764853954315,
0.11882703006267548,
0.4184649884700775,
-0.11019851267337799,
0.01585930958390236,
-0.06610751897096634,
-0.2900656759738922,
-0.5859735608100891,
1.0826997756958008,
0.47337865829467773,
1.0566179752349854,
0.34369900822639465,
0.603407621383667,
0.2705202102661133,
0.32280653715133667,
-0.7253698706626892,
0.4228580892086029,
-0.09463806450366974,
-0.6949657797813416,
-0.08757097274065018,
-0.41172492504119873,
-0.9931727647781372,
0.4941459596157074,
0.007474813610315323,
-0.9303212761878967,
0.39888355135917664,
-0.04773786664009094,
0.22120055556297302,
0.19883984327316284,
-0.5628751516342163,
0.6037564277648926,
-0.20261496305465698,
-0.0927138477563858,
-0.648148238658905,
-0.30556297302246094,
0.34571778774261475,
-0.08759399503469467,
0.14457766711711884,
-0.293418288230896,
-0.012308758683502674,
0.7751776576042175,
0.47835150361061096,
0.7428240776062012,
0.0124666104093194,
-0.36284562945365906,
-0.11037591844797134,
0.1180698424577713,
0.5667170286178589,
-0.05760953947901726,
-0.2657572031021118,
0.4562883675098419,
0.24252890050411224,
-0.3972920775413513,
-0.8130828142166138,
0.7542747259140015,
-0.857204258441925,
-0.3265930712223053,
-0.7257897257804871,
-0.7758176326751709,
-0.2954971194267273,
0.10605604946613312,
-0.08772298693656921,
0.36204782128334045,
-0.13579711318016052,
-0.03301963210105896,
0.6557145714759827,
0.06199008226394653,
0.2922753095626831,
0.46559131145477295,
-0.29813116788864136,
-0.14269226789474487,
1.0169155597686768,
-0.06820540875196457,
0.23661735653877258,
0.30182120203971863,
-0.09104274213314056,
-0.27318432927131653,
-0.8802935481071472,
-0.12355364114046097,
0.25630277395248413,
-0.8989130854606628,
0.15381640195846558,
-0.4144551157951355,
-0.19273580610752106,
-0.08469876646995544,
0.11984683573246002,
-0.6161698698997498,
-0.22807736694812775,
-0.3727709650993347,
0.014454315416514874,
0.06937254220247269,
1.31146240234375,
-0.06016835570335388,
0.19654540717601776,
-0.562065064907074,
0.4422418475151062,
0.046263597905635834,
0.6360324025154114,
0.19793523848056793,
-0.32573023438453674,
-0.5450050830841064,
0.1253354847431183,
-0.322026789188385,
-1.1122642755508423,
0.11045684665441513,
0.19813689589500427,
0.9112533926963806,
0.38150495290756226,
-0.10328034311532974,
0.7683789134025574,
-0.44163942337036133,
0.4838739335536957,
0.3123025894165039,
-1.2154905796051025,
0.5118575692176819,
-0.055522371083498,
0.03468036651611328,
0.26480692625045776,
0.43658456206321716,
-0.7298678755760193,
-0.3143131136894226,
-0.33134570717811584,
-0.6738914847373962,
0.5285884141921997,
0.2909560203552246,
-0.10614708065986633,
-0.14131386578083038,
0.2826131284236908,
0.12439564615488052,
-0.10715296119451523,
-0.4853316843509674,
-0.4646550118923187,
0.28244295716285706,
-0.47514617443084717,
-0.2330935150384903,
-0.17803290486335754,
-0.3648359179496765,
-0.08124686032533646,
0.380288690328598,
-0.22486038506031036,
0.3812873661518097,
0.09476105868816376,
-0.36937227845191956,
-0.03684726357460022,
0.3338167667388916,
0.27678582072257996,
1.1077866554260254,
0.028657086193561554,
0.47498181462287903,
0.0430673249065876,
-0.5703759789466858,
0.4413246810436249,
-0.08200204372406006,
0.09516674280166626,
-0.20406214892864227,
0.586300253868103,
0.6960539221763611,
-0.0837085023522377,
-0.5888940691947937,
0.17658551037311554,
-0.08462534844875336,
0.0340229757130146,
0.17265118658542633,
-0.0311653483659029,
0.10453817993402481,
0.5340109467506409,
0.35619908571243286,
0.2863423824310303,
0.27444079518318176,
-0.36408111453056335,
0.3534168004989624,
0.3814146816730499,
-0.5237635970115662,
-0.47512131929397583,
0.5281230211257935,
-0.008826438337564468,
0.008182198740541935,
0.5885751843452454,
-0.016582921147346497,
-0.1616390198469162,
0.5170110464096069,
0.5169774889945984,
0.9792953729629517,
-0.302224725484848,
0.4273461699485779,
0.2164287120103836,
0.3200315237045288,
-0.12784500420093536,
0.33958593010902405,
0.15727819502353668,
-1.0202430486679077,
-0.46549326181411743,
-0.4325962960720062,
-0.38990455865859985,
-0.46447980403900146,
-1.1442720890045166,
-0.3321833610534668,
-0.007998907007277012,
-0.22182290256023407,
0.30767518281936646,
-0.11652601510286331,
-0.5005999207496643,
-0.11772753298282623,
-0.04497026652097702,
0.5938118696212769,
-0.9651148319244385,
0.8708279132843018,
0.7303546071052551,
-0.4372393786907196,
-0.5120487809181213,
0.1878919154405594,
0.07950397580862045,
-0.7512179017066956,
0.8237527012825012,
-0.055177029222249985,
-0.3196249008178711,
-0.007257495075464249,
-0.5401673316955566,
-1.0076555013656616,
1.030531644821167,
0.5711542963981628,
-0.570521891117096,
0.09813040494918823,
0.18543238937854767,
0.5469434857368469,
-0.20514561235904694,
0.35064706206321716,
0.9815706610679626,
0.45955660939216614,
-0.029951684176921844,
-0.9476784467697144,
0.044280268251895905,
-0.22953888773918152,
-0.06857532262802124,
0.04654546082019806,
-0.29759344458580017,
0.9058815240859985,
-0.12298231571912766,
-0.3526245653629303,
-0.2954482138156891,
0.649043083190918,
0.3795822262763977,
0.27663618326187134,
0.447046160697937,
0.47873467206954956,
1.0444554090499878,
-0.13648511469364166,
0.9500827193260193,
-0.028635941445827484,
0.7406406998634338,
1.0007728338241577,
-0.3390040993690491,
0.8883824348449707,
0.7912356853485107,
-0.495599627494812,
0.39460575580596924,
0.6604008674621582,
0.38442206382751465,
0.7174714803695679,
0.31831982731819153,
-0.17058183252811432,
-0.28415653109550476,
-0.024484796449542046,
-0.0349675789475441,
0.3112197816371918,
0.31005144119262695,
-0.2341390699148178,
-0.1971987783908844,
0.07069943845272064,
-0.33744144439697266,
0.10598122328519821,
-0.04770614579319954,
0.768054187297821,
0.19026930630207062,
-0.37869560718536377,
0.5756585597991943,
-0.23473979532718658,
0.6285879015922546,
-0.45712602138519287,
-0.14177167415618896,
-0.26004016399383545,
0.5573591589927673,
-0.3260696530342102,
-0.9872849583625793,
0.4200303554534912,
-0.1346871256828308,
-0.3577076494693756,
-0.2156682163476944,
0.4546203911304474,
-0.4370349943637848,
-0.3200465142726898,
0.5451569557189941,
0.6760826110839844,
0.0666608139872551,
-0.0913313552737236,
-0.7637499570846558,
0.3087741434574127,
-0.29309359192848206,
-0.39618948101997375,
0.3684804141521454,
0.2899404764175415,
-0.007944880053400993,
1.103503704071045,
0.3629254102706909,
0.13917940855026245,
0.24017183482646942,
0.06467001140117645,
0.9438648223876953,
-0.5872173309326172,
-0.03262268006801605,
-0.9070677757263184,
0.4501533806324005,
-0.13633114099502563,
-0.25440576672554016,
0.7799452543258667,
0.32503241300582886,
0.46715694665908813,
0.008864768780767918,
0.5052852630615234,
-0.293707013130188,
0.13418442010879517,
-0.5099765658378601,
0.7972976565361023,
-0.5230962634086609,
0.3110838234424591,
-0.23503609001636505,
-0.9029489159584045,
-0.21684464812278748,
0.6953924894332886,
-0.20596033334732056,
-0.12101656943559647,
1.036763310432434,
0.8153383731842041,
-0.21472439169883728,
-0.09776336699724197,
0.3828507661819458,
0.23875465989112854,
0.45687106251716614,
0.3595203161239624,
1.137325406074524,
-0.38409101963043213,
0.17942221462726593,
-0.08879179507493973,
-0.24114903807640076,
0.16795967519283295,
-0.737002968788147,
-0.8169419765472412,
-0.9848378300666809,
-0.39050570130348206,
-0.2568722069263458,
0.0824112817645073,
0.6851218938827515,
0.8114919662475586,
-1.014845848083496,
-0.471958726644516,
-0.0011408579302951694,
0.37664923071861267,
-0.9070023894309998,
-0.14800357818603516,
0.43947550654411316,
-0.4815930128097534,
-0.8139469027519226,
0.6451653838157654,
0.24267734587192535,
-0.38235074281692505,
-0.4443637430667877,
-0.11108795553445816,
-0.3523639142513275,
0.22267678380012512,
0.4014102518558502,
-0.20920969545841217,
-0.8372114896774292,
-0.10808432102203369,
0.07938390225172043,
-0.23968949913978577,
0.101048044860363,
0.8400464057922363,
-0.21455352008342743,
0.6076145172119141,
0.4999886453151703,
0.6376376152038574,
0.45723313093185425,
-0.2041967362165451,
0.682625949382782,
-0.5253003239631653,
-0.08208393305540085,
0.1867850124835968,
0.29344019293785095,
0.0653899684548378,
-0.2372758984565735,
0.5245651006698608,
-0.2149520218372345,
-0.5362277030944824,
-0.7428234219551086,
0.3158639073371887,
-1.2475506067276,
-0.0632781907916069,
1.061083436012268,
-0.2287551313638687,
-0.1229967474937439,
-0.20335344970226288,
-0.14968588948249817,
0.14440011978149414,
-0.12752015888690948,
0.714168906211853,
0.819014310836792,
-0.21014228463172913,
-0.40458664298057556,
-0.47931021451950073,
0.3341498374938965,
0.07994965463876724,
-0.9104980230331421,
0.31795457005500793,
0.26977917551994324,
0.11186373978853226,
0.2943107783794403,
0.3361702859401703,
-0.16004678606987,
0.15273897349834442,
0.051003579050302505,
0.23029258847236633,
0.11072831600904465,
-0.34640344977378845,
-0.49580273032188416,
-0.11707340180873871,
0.25219160318374634,
-0.22059017419815063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17682v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17682v2
|
NextLevelBERT: Masked Language Modeling with Higher-Level Representations for Long Documents
| 2024-02-27T16:56:30 | 2024-06-13T10:21:03 |
Tamara Czinczoll, Christoph Hönes, Maximilian Schall, Gerard de Melo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While (large) language models have significantly improved over the last
years, they still struggle to sensibly process long sequences found, e.g., in
books, due to the quadratic scaling of the underlying attention mechanism. To
address this, we propose NextLevelBERT, a Masked Language Model operating not
on tokens, but on higher-level semantic representations in the form of text
embeddings. We pretrain NextLevelBERT to predict the vector representation of
entire masked text chunks and evaluate the effectiveness of the resulting
document vectors on three types of tasks: 1) Semantic Textual Similarity via
zero-shot document embeddings, 2) Long document classification, 3)
Multiple-choice question answering. We find that next-level Masked Language
Modeling is an effective technique to tackle long-document use cases and can
outperfor much larger embedding models as long as the required level of detail
of semantic information is not too fine. Our models and code are publicly
available online.
|
[
-0.31989577412605286,
-0.4379350543022156,
0.5171813368797302,
0.25587910413742065,
0.07869813591241837,
0.32473811507225037,
-0.1129114180803299,
-0.570168673992157,
0.1730327606201172,
0.9149628281593323,
-0.3655117452144623,
-0.9520780444145203,
-0.8472424149513245,
-0.08665312826633453,
-0.760803759098053,
0.8560313582420349,
0.017134511843323708,
-0.13719657063484192,
-0.6796522736549377,
0.16467900574207306,
-0.4544127285480499,
-0.6760267615318298,
-0.5408426523208618,
-0.3722204864025116,
0.5874180197715759,
0.39141222834587097,
0.5780798196792603,
0.38313785195350647,
0.35535362362861633,
0.2402435839176178,
-0.10907477140426636,
-0.2815752625465393,
-0.5981263518333435,
0.3090105950832367,
0.09606669098138809,
-0.530823290348053,
-0.34726911783218384,
0.10972259938716888,
0.9167541265487671,
0.5365011096000671,
0.1510644257068634,
0.05466405302286148,
-0.06356073170900345,
0.43253573775291443,
-0.6364204287528992,
0.34312835335731506,
-0.4585513174533844,
0.2128571718931198,
-0.026921089738607407,
-0.09269969910383224,
-0.5290046334266663,
-0.14082619547843933,
0.18347680568695068,
-0.5836686491966248,
0.13398055732250214,
0.11952077597379684,
0.5781721472740173,
0.051097240298986435,
-0.3035075068473816,
-0.3419002294540405,
-0.6360265016555786,
0.8174833059310913,
-0.5591464042663574,
0.6016210317611694,
0.8104498982429504,
0.15231800079345703,
0.11023811250925064,
-0.8699848651885986,
-0.4979749619960785,
-0.6990442276000977,
-0.06024349853396416,
-0.0009635112364776433,
-0.227892205119133,
0.053747378289699554,
0.3228439688682556,
-0.005962220020592213,
-0.5696383118629456,
0.15708762407302856,
-0.30558350682258606,
-0.22123704850673676,
0.3398283123970032,
-0.0059451456181705,
0.11244422942399979,
-0.09855034202337265,
-0.45519834756851196,
-0.03240257874131203,
-0.6115671992301941,
-0.039934273809194565,
0.4498797655105591,
-0.02817550115287304,
0.24264396727085114,
0.6070786118507385,
-0.2866557836532593,
0.7629491686820984,
-0.07741879671812057,
0.02060745842754841,
0.3111002445220947,
0.18850933015346527,
-0.08297757059335709,
0.12170334160327911,
0.2819611728191376,
0.3414137065410614,
0.18658241629600525,
-0.07367876172065735,
-0.3821318745613098,
-0.30477890372276306,
0.21172182261943817,
-0.9039549827575684,
-0.38558128476142883,
0.45879465341567993,
-0.3998514413833618,
-0.40440282225608826,
-0.3106706738471985,
-0.46332311630249023,
-0.6390753984451294,
-0.27595585584640503,
0.5237666964530945,
-0.35246652364730835,
-0.07846034318208694,
0.3560827672481537,
-0.10223157703876495,
0.2717825174331665,
0.40237632393836975,
-0.6867642402648926,
0.3609391748905182,
0.866037130355835,
0.9547461867332458,
-0.01621357351541519,
-0.18410129845142365,
-0.8772116899490356,
0.27394407987594604,
-0.35247427225112915,
0.6968489289283752,
-1.048560380935669,
-0.22754845023155212,
0.3915707468986511,
0.04781137406826019,
0.0923021212220192,
-0.2819031774997711,
0.7278191447257996,
-0.80584317445755,
0.3707698583602905,
0.037285979837179184,
-0.7466536164283752,
-0.0596819706261158,
0.41126593947410583,
-0.65389084815979,
1.235437273979187,
0.1912705898284912,
-0.7628937363624573,
0.027504626661539078,
-0.47994011640548706,
-0.2291989028453827,
0.36687344312667847,
-0.10020309686660767,
-0.4096573293209076,
0.01193266175687313,
0.3326798975467682,
0.8427162170410156,
-0.2834726572036743,
-0.015638934448361397,
-0.18451115489006042,
-0.3010697364807129,
0.014292328618466854,
-0.060237254947423935,
0.6736543774604797,
-0.27018189430236816,
-0.14058917760849,
0.22379645705223083,
-0.7845210433006287,
-0.13401439785957336,
-0.06832633167505264,
-0.03096097521483898,
-0.633216381072998,
-0.10374519973993301,
0.09181787818670273,
0.5031417012214661,
0.6078325510025024,
-0.8240410685539246,
0.01650644652545452,
-0.15973110496997833,
0.47833287715911865,
0.5885546803474426,
-0.25814345479011536,
0.4807851016521454,
-0.19663377106189728,
0.735470175743103,
-0.09653052687644958,
0.13752363622188568,
-0.42293858528137207,
-0.6343330144882202,
-0.785271167755127,
-0.30624282360076904,
0.4614976644515991,
0.41723501682281494,
-0.6822448968887329,
0.2738298177719116,
-0.3318409025669098,
-0.43264174461364746,
-0.22846579551696777,
-0.024061784148216248,
0.39050036668777466,
0.366951048374176,
0.27079978585243225,
-0.3041779696941376,
-0.27096688747406006,
-0.8813080787658691,
-0.028973672538995743,
-0.056755367666482925,
-0.21663187444210052,
0.1067809909582138,
0.6647807955741882,
-0.3297640085220337,
0.758424699306488,
-0.5770324468612671,
-0.5559297800064087,
-0.18521533906459808,
0.351829469203949,
-0.047378942370414734,
0.33185216784477234,
0.4491373300552368,
-0.66432785987854,
-0.3828555941581726,
-0.07917451858520508,
-0.5429917573928833,
-0.033746764063835144,
0.006324790418148041,
-0.10235888510942459,
0.20970377326011658,
1.2641913890838623,
-0.5629003643989563,
0.11074899137020111,
0.6341610550880432,
-0.08727815747261047,
0.10835740715265274,
-0.32621729373931885,
-0.3567378520965576,
-0.8981783986091614,
-0.23442372679710388,
0.03472434729337692,
-0.5277247428894043,
-0.790442168712616,
0.034373991191387177,
0.5294785499572754,
-0.6180000901222229,
-0.4693392217159271,
0.5439443588256836,
-0.639422595500946,
-0.2200668454170227,
-0.2839675843715668,
0.3557251989841461,
0.25257864594459534,
0.6137509942054749,
0.16696979105472565,
0.3209460973739624,
0.7945536375045776,
-0.1604534089565277,
0.518894612789154,
0.11184454709291458,
-0.4930494725704193,
0.398539274930954,
-0.7471677660942078,
0.18015076220035553,
-0.5573046803474426,
0.6288781762123108,
-0.8647606372833252,
-0.23991389572620392,
0.0869765430688858,
-0.5438443422317505,
0.5358338356018066,
-0.1923922300338745,
-0.5191602110862732,
-0.400804340839386,
-0.5210179686546326,
0.45831412076950073,
0.47755298018455505,
-0.3371448814868927,
0.6630364060401917,
0.49680230021476746,
-0.4150962829589844,
-0.6724290251731873,
-0.4833630621433258,
0.2421361207962036,
0.05700015276670456,
-0.5527172684669495,
0.5334746241569519,
0.15026487410068512,
0.1590280681848526,
-0.030811132863163948,
0.011622784659266472,
-0.03872767835855484,
-0.2878742516040802,
0.2002483755350113,
-0.0015470152720808983,
-0.14748702943325043,
0.4295758306980133,
-0.09569523483514786,
-0.20999115705490112,
0.13083671033382416,
-0.9340661764144897,
0.7719146609306335,
-0.08078468590974808,
-0.28616803884506226,
-0.058096133172512054,
0.8994627594947815,
0.5524320602416992,
-0.7387804985046387,
0.8658590316772461,
0.8466218709945679,
-0.8047768473625183,
-0.19859567284584045,
-0.5095245242118835,
0.232490673661232,
-0.43388134241104126,
0.6901504397392273,
-0.18959635496139526,
-1.249098777770996,
0.41685354709625244,
0.26044514775276184,
0.008124585263431072,
0.4281489849090576,
0.6427891850471497,
-0.13142997026443481,
0.941860020160675,
0.9776025414466858,
0.04002659022808075,
0.6112962365150452,
-0.29308146238327026,
0.27074679732322693,
-0.7893825173377991,
-0.6981164216995239,
-0.6014540195465088,
0.10879865288734436,
-0.4778761565685272,
-0.8288821578025818,
0.2408723384141922,
0.07670774310827255,
-0.32935163378715515,
0.5574513673782349,
-0.40215855836868286,
0.6949692368507385,
0.6523966789245605,
-0.11417490243911743,
0.06287269294261932,
0.04903153330087662,
0.11536227911710739,
0.19373397529125214,
-0.629696786403656,
-0.39751502871513367,
1.000990390777588,
0.6910660266876221,
0.7658033967018127,
-0.18151523172855377,
0.9992671012878418,
0.4427408277988434,
0.18313704431056976,
-0.8199071884155273,
0.49676936864852905,
-0.05906137079000473,
-0.49450477957725525,
-0.5861018896102905,
-0.0369185172021389,
-0.8643409013748169,
0.3071671426296234,
-0.2650400400161743,
-0.7039540410041809,
0.33312612771987915,
-0.11302098631858826,
-0.20475007593631744,
0.11675886809825897,
-0.5529013276100159,
0.8700634241104126,
0.03738928586244583,
-0.1558091789484024,
-0.05511198192834854,
-0.6560712456703186,
0.16688407957553864,
-0.3281650245189667,
0.1187087669968605,
-0.23923441767692566,
-0.38430255651474,
0.788578450679779,
-0.1331818550825119,
0.8005868792533875,
0.0709538385272026,
-0.4678409695625305,
0.13699020445346832,
-0.007883407175540924,
0.6909887194633484,
0.1522301286458969,
-0.0449102446436882,
0.3064468801021576,
-0.03532613441348076,
-0.6903327107429504,
-0.705769956111908,
0.8345478177070618,
-0.7774920463562012,
-0.6953933238983154,
-0.5861650109291077,
-0.45710670948028564,
-0.21169637143611908,
0.3044305741786957,
0.25369688868522644,
0.7651897072792053,
0.14043234288692474,
0.4814828038215637,
0.8287984728813171,
-0.3144362270832062,
0.36252856254577637,
0.25942280888557434,
-0.3694458305835724,
-0.12918470799922943,
1.1261569261550903,
-0.011804379522800446,
0.17814551293849945,
0.950289249420166,
-0.053827084600925446,
-0.4294777512550354,
-0.6372849345207214,
-0.03534075617790222,
0.020508792251348495,
-1.046739935874939,
-0.14634962379932404,
-1.1862471103668213,
-0.36562392115592957,
-0.5569882988929749,
-0.16359765827655792,
-0.18521742522716522,
-0.5763029456138611,
-0.3102879226207733,
0.056638576090335846,
0.1859571635723114,
0.8253647089004517,
0.07644340395927429,
0.11148595064878464,
-0.7513299584388733,
0.3689510226249695,
0.29717135429382324,
0.41900789737701416,
-0.11700575798749924,
-0.5050185322761536,
-0.5556744933128357,
-0.40253767371177673,
-0.18086853623390198,
-0.6500917077064514,
0.4387509226799011,
0.10687467455863953,
0.40275681018829346,
-0.08574413508176804,
0.09889248758554459,
0.01934371143579483,
-0.5861467719078064,
0.6355575323104858,
0.221907839179039,
-0.9185605645179749,
0.24735775589942932,
-0.4522349238395691,
0.37780240178108215,
0.2521871328353882,
0.756669819355011,
-0.6710246801376343,
-0.6592898368835449,
-0.3736720681190491,
-0.9790226221084595,
0.5900917053222656,
0.46789950132369995,
0.4986061155796051,
0.10028652846813202,
0.10384932160377502,
-0.06153062358498573,
0.3354765772819519,
-0.8684146404266357,
0.18091639876365662,
-0.34342825412750244,
-0.03163771703839302,
-0.3228113353252411,
-0.5001273155212402,
0.08200259506702423,
-0.20647048950195312,
0.4830678403377533,
0.04095495492219925,
0.582190990447998,
0.0014539830153807998,
-0.3046998381614685,
0.24962709844112396,
0.09335187822580338,
0.7761967778205872,
0.603827178478241,
-0.34993574023246765,
0.19248250126838684,
0.05668488144874573,
-0.5570650100708008,
-0.12019280344247818,
0.33627548813819885,
0.14404788613319397,
0.12007148563861847,
0.7970095276832581,
0.6693284511566162,
0.15908782184123993,
-0.556160032749176,
0.7982378005981445,
-0.04223843663930893,
-0.32422345876693726,
-0.6577831506729126,
-0.23480214178562164,
0.22977584600448608,
0.3395346701145172,
0.2555684447288513,
-0.27985110878944397,
-0.0005671517574228346,
-0.4930609166622162,
0.19282424449920654,
0.2363322675228119,
-0.6474355459213257,
0.23791229724884033,
0.604773759841919,
0.19240756332874298,
-0.4693949818611145,
0.4698632061481476,
-0.004668405745178461,
-0.6481422185897827,
0.49096018075942993,
0.3578948378562927,
0.8015451431274414,
-0.15226419270038605,
0.5290459394454956,
0.16241875290870667,
0.4538000524044037,
0.05358900502324104,
-0.04306177794933319,
-0.14562420547008514,
-0.3723953664302826,
-0.4558779001235962,
-0.7336905002593994,
-0.4462645351886749,
0.20471762120723724,
-0.38696348667144775,
0.25752291083335876,
-0.4158610999584198,
0.07571028918027878,
-0.010895667597651482,
-0.09614674746990204,
-0.5553739070892334,
0.20900660753250122,
0.27496370673179626,
0.8901826739311218,
-0.5769729018211365,
1.0155973434448242,
0.3018253743648529,
-0.3985385000705719,
-0.2366088181734085,
0.24864909052848816,
-0.48549020290374756,
-0.7759108543395996,
0.755895733833313,
0.3706231415271759,
-0.15419802069664001,
0.049160171300172806,
-0.5081159472465515,
-1.1299580335617065,
0.8309336304664612,
0.2751431465148926,
-0.6397390961647034,
-0.3884037435054779,
0.23944365978240967,
0.651831328868866,
-0.5384949445724487,
0.2752368450164795,
0.270652711391449,
0.21092389523983002,
0.04547155275940895,
-0.3104872703552246,
-0.12378951162099838,
-0.2665136456489563,
0.3232805132865906,
0.16455574333667755,
-0.3422870337963104,
1.1428476572036743,
0.12967047095298767,
0.04737177491188049,
-0.04994459077715874,
0.827379047870636,
-0.24070318043231964,
0.06173630803823471,
0.3191315829753876,
0.3528805673122406,
0.7421724200248718,
0.15414321422576904,
1.2132295370101929,
-0.4469776451587677,
0.3577689230442047,
1.1716282367706299,
-0.31822559237480164,
0.9200285077095032,
-0.03231899067759514,
0.33381587266921997,
0.7004497647285461,
0.5490375757217407,
0.01537097617983818,
0.45554202795028687,
0.4958423674106598,
-0.48387327790260315,
-0.48290377855300903,
-0.17866577208042145,
-0.4230891764163971,
0.2707838714122772,
0.3628551959991455,
-0.40951478481292725,
-0.19020408391952515,
0.31957584619522095,
-0.13884097337722778,
0.05417928844690323,
-0.39864906668663025,
0.44645801186561584,
0.07674099504947662,
-0.5422453284263611,
0.8200150728225708,
0.3908739387989044,
0.4385973811149597,
-0.3176703155040741,
-0.1469065099954605,
-0.14618097245693207,
0.012278074398636818,
-0.10677781701087952,
-0.9010878205299377,
-0.010075831785798073,
-0.06835247576236725,
-0.12664459645748138,
-0.4944942891597748,
0.9775017499923706,
-0.658352792263031,
-0.7675167322158813,
0.4813082814216614,
0.10032303631305695,
0.08838630467653275,
-0.2947271466255188,
-0.4514791965484619,
-0.017231326550245285,
-0.4695534408092499,
-0.18522021174430847,
0.2532452642917633,
0.41037890315055847,
-0.4389447271823883,
0.7259284853935242,
0.4409753978252411,
-0.33056578040122986,
0.33328869938850403,
0.28488263487815857,
0.8872766494750977,
-0.5836701989173889,
-0.5241253972053528,
-0.45368507504463196,
0.22574445605278015,
-0.23063382506370544,
-0.176200732588768,
0.6642531752586365,
0.5814707279205322,
1.0560907125473022,
-0.02364594303071499,
0.7358925342559814,
0.32773783802986145,
0.3734517991542816,
-0.5606951713562012,
0.6023173332214355,
-0.5751882791519165,
-0.015794772654771805,
-0.3450629711151123,
-1.1603498458862305,
-0.49037253856658936,
0.5067082047462463,
-0.3328501880168915,
0.11906341463327408,
0.756510317325592,
0.7500852942466736,
-0.07355540990829468,
0.0251094251871109,
0.7196499705314636,
0.09309055656194687,
0.31752651929855347,
0.7274652719497681,
0.9120755791664124,
-0.19664731621742249,
0.6080437302589417,
0.01360560767352581,
-0.2586655616760254,
-0.30416131019592285,
-0.9246870279312134,
-1.3620909452438354,
-0.8371159434318542,
-0.18755322694778442,
-0.2580929100513458,
0.0797768160700798,
0.7284716963768005,
0.586277425289154,
-0.4973720908164978,
0.012936897575855255,
-0.08321111649274826,
0.15420885384082794,
0.3206102252006531,
-0.07541835308074951,
0.505319356918335,
-0.32333600521087646,
-0.7008518576622009,
0.08761969208717346,
0.4616148769855499,
-0.04483840987086296,
-0.580525279045105,
0.015343048609793186,
-0.1117066890001297,
0.15247489511966705,
1.0795950889587402,
0.15074458718299866,
-0.563642680644989,
-0.426135778427124,
0.03520087152719498,
-0.293296217918396,
-0.036389369517564774,
0.9573203325271606,
-0.7256940007209778,
0.4189584255218506,
0.5796248912811279,
0.7220508456230164,
0.8873888850212097,
-0.4927767217159271,
0.5656018853187561,
-0.6963165402412415,
0.16708123683929443,
0.48937904834747314,
0.23670750856399536,
0.41439101099967957,
-0.19830240309238434,
0.08659110218286514,
-0.07870558649301529,
-0.27772530913352966,
-0.7056481242179871,
0.36316829919815063,
-0.7013209462165833,
-0.21473011374473572,
1.222273588180542,
-0.3383435308933258,
-0.1430177390575409,
-0.23485904932022095,
-0.2851421535015106,
0.20541544258594513,
-0.2948093116283417,
0.3781609833240509,
0.8471240401268005,
0.09141889959573746,
-0.5611836910247803,
-0.7885167002677917,
0.44815653562545776,
0.3203106224536896,
-0.6816354990005493,
0.060569390654563904,
0.34325000643730164,
-0.017127200961112976,
0.25850456953048706,
0.6310258507728577,
-0.20594476163387299,
0.07887674123048782,
-0.09795799106359482,
-0.14067725837230682,
-0.16193528473377228,
-0.8388070464134216,
-0.32947856187820435,
0.4102695882320404,
-0.06169771030545235,
0.0004540668160188943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17649v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17649v2
|
Beyond prompt brittleness: Evaluating the reliability and consistency of political worldviews in LLMs
| 2024-02-27T16:19:37 | 2024-06-03T22:25:08 |
Tanise Ceron, Neele Falk, Ana Barić, Dmitry Nikolaev, Sebastian Padó
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Due to the widespread use of large language models (LLMs) in ubiquitous
systems, we need to understand whether they embed a specific worldview and what
these views reflect. Recent studies report that, prompted with political
questionnaires, LLMs show left-liberal leanings (Feng et al., 2023; Motoki et
al., 2024). However, it is as yet unclear whether these leanings are reliable
(robust to prompt variations) and whether the leaning is consistent across
policies and political leaning. We propose a series of tests which assess the
reliability and consistency of LLMs' stances on political statements based on a
dataset of voting-advice questionnaires collected from seven EU countries and
annotated for policy domains. We study LLMs ranging in size from 7B to 70B
parameters and find that their reliability increases with parameter count.
Larger models show overall stronger alignment with left-leaning parties but
differ among policy programs: They evince a (left-wing) positive stance towards
environment protection, social welfare state and liberal society but also
(right-wing) law and order, with no consistent preferences in foreign policy
and migration.
|
[
-0.18418346345424652,
-0.679412841796875,
0.9350801706314087,
0.3755553066730499,
-0.13798312842845917,
-0.05698743835091591,
-0.21907323598861694,
-0.03962027654051781,
0.17734208703041077,
0.4047686755657196,
-0.5711793303489685,
-0.39906665682792664,
-0.6849119067192078,
0.3171173930168152,
-0.07164556533098221,
0.8195210695266724,
0.2370985746383667,
0.25797975063323975,
-0.23825792968273163,
-0.4168342053890228,
-0.3353302776813507,
-0.2523330748081207,
-0.24005424976348877,
-0.6412570476531982,
0.4234480559825897,
0.48421019315719604,
1.2970178127288818,
0.4637001156806946,
0.522933304309845,
0.21660304069519043,
-0.4676195979118347,
-0.019002795219421387,
-0.34575843811035156,
0.2742563486099243,
-0.6119150519371033,
-0.5934901237487793,
-0.26920875906944275,
0.25891730189323425,
0.6790966391563416,
0.6631253361701965,
-0.14505207538604736,
-0.20582394301891327,
0.38840436935424805,
0.43331822752952576,
-0.428401380777359,
-0.05456962063908577,
-0.9310556650161743,
-0.09364520013332367,
0.015563659369945526,
-0.071808360517025,
-0.5880900621414185,
-0.42048123478889465,
0.16048675775527954,
-0.17303498089313507,
-0.31714606285095215,
0.15922148525714874,
0.9869247674942017,
0.036919109523296356,
-0.7447046041488647,
-0.3275482952594757,
-0.6042073369026184,
1.0726854801177979,
-0.7388098835945129,
0.653060257434845,
0.29187458753585815,
-0.05720251798629761,
-0.7078300714492798,
-0.2350902557373047,
-0.4951063394546509,
-0.5429185628890991,
0.2663506269454956,
0.0977470874786377,
0.05086039751768112,
0.0651843473315239,
-0.00886901281774044,
0.07739610224962234,
-0.557771623134613,
0.1593645066022873,
0.26325723528862,
-0.228017657995224,
0.45584046840667725,
0.2540237009525299,
0.2910216152667999,
-0.5639602541923523,
-0.5725996494293213,
0.17106887698173523,
-1.099710464477539,
-0.08679135143756866,
0.5350233912467957,
0.5474284291267395,
-0.305796355009079,
0.6966331005096436,
0.13051314651966095,
0.6658727526664734,
0.20955562591552734,
-0.42186298966407776,
-0.19092600047588348,
-0.38366007804870605,
0.03653089702129364,
-0.4055810868740082,
0.6911817789077759,
0.5666488409042358,
0.2882418632507324,
0.03998896852135658,
-0.21867206692695618,
0.05573974549770355,
-0.031676385551691055,
-0.44786325097084045,
0.0372716560959816,
0.5187766551971436,
-0.5971006751060486,
-0.2688380181789398,
0.3122093975543976,
-0.5696170926094055,
-0.812988817691803,
-0.4126794636249542,
-0.0995110496878624,
-0.27572229504585266,
-0.3957045078277588,
-0.15727499127388,
0.057538170367479324,
0.4677894413471222,
0.23937714099884033,
-0.5003756880760193,
-0.09145942330360413,
0.9678609371185303,
0.9275470972061157,
-0.5343203544616699,
-0.197535440325737,
-0.6243467926979065,
-0.21598057448863983,
-0.49801144003868103,
0.9805622696876526,
-0.8386659622192383,
-0.4222349226474762,
0.3263665735721588,
0.35450422763824463,
0.14773055911064148,
-0.5459588170051575,
0.661037266254425,
-0.42104557156562805,
0.03939960151910782,
-0.7110283970832825,
-0.6421462893486023,
0.20272143185138702,
0.7725141644477844,
-0.6953978538513184,
0.9825589656829834,
-0.2192121148109436,
-0.9420413374900818,
0.5976855158805847,
-0.2095782309770584,
0.06400464475154877,
-0.33872905373573303,
-0.4201086461544037,
-0.10400959104299545,
0.09300433844327927,
-0.30430012941360474,
0.5976139903068542,
-0.21948842704296112,
0.7191546559333801,
-1.0994240045547485,
-0.14123181998729706,
0.5534903407096863,
-0.7679386734962463,
0.9955641031265259,
-0.07385160028934479,
-0.4302249252796173,
0.21531958878040314,
-0.945924699306488,
-0.21843846142292023,
-0.043576017022132874,
-0.4348295032978058,
-0.2974374294281006,
0.4778357744216919,
0.07520917803049088,
0.413300096988678,
0.36102333664894104,
-0.8136922121047974,
0.43390393257141113,
-0.26652398705482483,
0.43792852759361267,
1.1167858839035034,
0.055092569440603256,
0.38830462098121643,
-0.3822091817855835,
0.38586005568504333,
0.0971871092915535,
0.22704170644283295,
0.1433459371328354,
-0.5097358226776123,
-0.5991617441177368,
0.15568313002586365,
0.06663021445274353,
0.9441405534744263,
-0.5688495635986328,
0.5078157186508179,
-0.2900223135948181,
-0.3643399477005005,
0.2226104885339737,
0.11688767373561859,
0.12108203023672104,
0.11606604605913162,
-0.14706385135650635,
0.14003494381904602,
-0.46841633319854736,
-0.9699369072914124,
-0.536440908908844,
-0.7640056014060974,
0.2135729193687439,
0.25493478775024414,
0.7964791059494019,
-0.285920113325119,
0.9210204482078552,
0.1437189280986786,
0.4566064774990082,
-0.29611489176750183,
-0.31229665875434875,
0.33344370126724243,
0.08684331923723221,
0.14292772114276886,
-0.6861423850059509,
-0.2700148820877075,
-0.15755414962768555,
-0.5429110527038574,
-0.010679472237825394,
-0.053036436438560486,
0.09253699332475662,
0.5392481088638306,
0.2236839085817337,
-0.6091024279594421,
0.1846802532672882,
0.8598939180374146,
-0.7676944732666016,
0.5494934320449829,
0.04756278172135353,
0.06365744024515152,
-1.1455719470977783,
-0.0851779356598854,
0.1028270423412323,
-0.3515124022960663,
-0.36657825112342834,
-0.1305316835641861,
-0.1354897916316986,
0.30985966324806213,
-0.6027919054031372,
0.7255185842514038,
-0.24416127800941467,
0.0157413799315691,
0.008597353473305702,
0.297861248254776,
-0.0718483179807663,
-0.2925080955028534,
-0.19771641492843628,
0.5643789172172546,
0.3567745089530945,
-0.32096701860427856,
0.2725767195224762,
0.09344128519296646,
-0.29771801829338074,
1.1041810512542725,
-0.627544105052948,
0.14547884464263916,
-0.031302087008953094,
0.2536313533782959,
-1.196795105934143,
-0.38709235191345215,
0.11234782636165619,
0.03849834203720093,
-0.012579773552715778,
-0.3384822607040405,
-0.6084212064743042,
-0.1122405156493187,
-0.3077255189418793,
-0.22641591727733612,
0.2754574716091156,
-0.53883957862854,
0.7169822454452515,
0.24995487928390503,
-0.2555636465549469,
-0.8570356369018555,
-0.5811540484428406,
0.1383446305990219,
-0.4274255633354187,
-0.6596384048461914,
0.0012480122968554497,
-0.10274117439985275,
-0.9295542240142822,
-0.09171431511640549,
0.01460673101246357,
0.1957620084285736,
0.06690549850463867,
0.48530563712120056,
0.30522409081459045,
0.06502952426671982,
0.14631298184394836,
-0.1963438242673874,
0.10318321734666824,
-0.021940497681498528,
-0.3136337697505951,
0.3528018593788147,
-0.34186241030693054,
-0.4818606674671173,
-0.4071705639362335,
0.40776363015174866,
1.0463591814041138,
0.19120049476623535,
0.7667784690856934,
0.0884905755519867,
-0.17185069620609283,
-0.0917050912976265,
-0.5527843236923218,
-0.035796280950307846,
-0.4540671706199646,
0.21117135882377625,
-0.23940573632717133,
-0.782080352306366,
0.8219903707504272,
-0.013055556453764439,
0.3871080279350281,
0.4378588795661926,
0.5716699957847595,
-0.07084034383296967,
0.8929584622383118,
0.7225739359855652,
-0.1362706571817398,
0.19108512997627258,
0.1579303741455078,
-0.0906754806637764,
-0.36593931913375854,
-0.36409974098205566,
-0.5477060079574585,
0.003436480648815632,
-0.7617513537406921,
-0.3019088804721832,
0.25310182571411133,
-0.17654697597026825,
-0.5186037421226501,
-0.21002495288848877,
-0.2743080258369446,
0.4615626931190491,
0.1307232677936554,
-0.015145624987781048,
0.23397277295589447,
-0.10248887538909912,
-0.3065808415412903,
-0.23091326653957367,
-0.6687142848968506,
-1.066325068473816,
0.9404521584510803,
0.455791711807251,
0.993550181388855,
0.08511751890182495,
0.5143508911132812,
0.38687559962272644,
0.35576146841049194,
-0.672313928604126,
0.6942175030708313,
-0.009237910620868206,
-0.47724151611328125,
-0.20921897888183594,
-0.33445048332214355,
-0.75882887840271,
0.10440007597208023,
-0.3481973707675934,
-0.562592089176178,
0.3846897780895233,
0.16649229824543,
-0.2079700380563736,
0.7390362620353699,
0.04596668481826782,
0.5981610417366028,
-0.38841745257377625,
-0.5182244777679443,
0.04596814140677452,
-0.70383220911026,
0.2039937824010849,
0.32371893525123596,
0.25113996863365173,
-0.31767281889915466,
-0.4689936637878418,
0.6025819778442383,
-0.1835516393184662,
1.054451823234558,
-0.2522946298122406,
-0.6687144041061401,
0.28207018971443176,
0.19187836349010468,
0.7590197324752808,
0.1707010269165039,
-0.3745603561401367,
0.21659140288829803,
0.17187054455280304,
-0.4278503954410553,
-0.3549131751060486,
0.8289695382118225,
-0.7769608497619629,
-0.647438108921051,
-0.5028916597366333,
-0.6467267870903015,
-0.2383461445569992,
0.09353452175855637,
0.32538577914237976,
0.5375808477401733,
-0.6581533551216125,
0.3926880657672882,
0.9590988755226135,
-0.059960681945085526,
0.36267349123954773,
0.32023885846138,
-0.2837059497833252,
-0.4862612187862396,
0.44073423743247986,
0.4760577082633972,
0.5566785931587219,
0.10593213140964508,
0.33522284030914307,
-0.44903457164764404,
-0.3246283233165741,
-0.44883981347084045,
0.1584859937429428,
-0.8292328119277954,
-0.039437659084796906,
-0.3129344880580902,
0.24455052614212036,
0.11181426793336868,
-0.16216696798801422,
-0.5191298127174377,
-0.32544147968292236,
-0.1916377693414688,
-0.032165031880140305,
0.40873152017593384,
0.9895240068435669,
0.024334797635674477,
0.014761609025299549,
-0.6121683716773987,
-0.0971047654747963,
-0.004710621200501919,
0.3770483732223511,
-0.5020598769187927,
-0.6216630339622498,
0.3167720139026642,
-0.05256237834692001,
-0.22978344559669495,
-1.3364074230194092,
-0.14892840385437012,
0.18245011568069458,
0.40905511379241943,
0.7152552008628845,
0.23188932240009308,
0.17549897730350494,
-0.6282567977905273,
1.2159900665283203,
-0.011832226067781448,
-0.7418237328529358,
0.4265337884426117,
-0.5671970248222351,
0.08107886463403702,
0.5834676027297974,
0.5574012994766235,
-0.19470316171646118,
-0.718160092830658,
-0.7795096039772034,
-0.5361592173576355,
0.07438680529594421,
-0.2852438986301422,
0.38458266854286194,
-0.1687503159046173,
0.5363110899925232,
0.22925013303756714,
-0.1612844169139862,
-0.5959595441818237,
-0.24306052923202515,
-0.01298572774976492,
-0.1614912748336792,
0.02005377784371376,
-0.44438669085502625,
-0.49152418971061707,
0.23821166157722473,
0.5388880372047424,
-0.2741686999797821,
-0.018951255828142166,
0.357683926820755,
0.3579683303833008,
0.08388892561197281,
0.8125184178352356,
0.5800614356994629,
1.0806119441986084,
-0.11094965785741806,
0.4399341344833374,
0.06644278764724731,
-0.24766884744167328,
0.6279817223548889,
-0.25397989153862,
-0.2930018901824951,
0.23487542569637299,
0.3001125454902649,
0.32492128014564514,
-0.009630734100937843,
-0.4622032046318054,
0.5980383157730103,
0.1495722085237503,
-0.051948294043540955,
-0.4029981791973114,
-0.0950923040509224,
0.20454198122024536,
0.25151121616363525,
0.11889488995075226,
0.02398802526295185,
-0.19237589836120605,
-1.0470236539840698,
0.21493293344974518,
0.883396565914154,
-0.5368512868881226,
-0.45261088013648987,
0.47145384550094604,
0.25164347887039185,
-0.41378533840179443,
0.37151679396629333,
-0.2948865592479706,
-0.5457640290260315,
0.3762021064758301,
0.5417395830154419,
0.660313069820404,
-0.1465398073196411,
0.29372599720954895,
-0.03555547818541527,
0.5957736968994141,
-0.1762377768754959,
0.7939302921295166,
0.43464016914367676,
-0.6433864831924438,
-0.394069641828537,
-0.22568155825138092,
-0.8121967911720276,
0.04462635889649391,
-0.6527774930000305,
0.1513381153345108,
-0.6128944158554077,
-0.6572934985160828,
-0.5615947246551514,
0.2749260663986206,
-0.27507448196411133,
0.034052297472953796,
-0.0059367879293859005,
1.089799165725708,
-1.2810986042022705,
0.5543944835662842,
0.7364915013313293,
0.11752720922231674,
-0.7246638536453247,
0.26234206557273865,
0.4607032835483551,
-0.4637536406517029,
0.2762407958507538,
-0.07222680747509003,
-0.17928673326969147,
-0.722490131855011,
-0.8904378414154053,
-0.8797650933265686,
0.8208452463150024,
0.6200346946716309,
-0.8365594148635864,
0.029970936477184296,
0.07066527754068375,
0.05912451073527336,
-0.271867960691452,
0.063742995262146,
0.5561069250106812,
0.6762137413024902,
-0.14471758902072906,
-0.8585637211799622,
0.15859805047512054,
-0.06948257237672806,
-0.15928806364536285,
0.05754146724939346,
-0.9404647946357727,
0.7267112731933594,
-0.2535172998905182,
-0.07187283784151077,
0.14256678521633148,
0.7350360155105591,
0.7979716658592224,
0.28813424706459045,
0.7969428896903992,
0.3265306353569031,
0.9742753505706787,
-0.25223711133003235,
1.043883204460144,
-0.7024221420288086,
0.23872613906860352,
0.8615489602088928,
-0.5754151344299316,
1.0189499855041504,
0.7360683679580688,
-0.09644532203674316,
0.888322651386261,
0.6738907694816589,
0.007471179123967886,
0.09440713375806808,
-0.027887530624866486,
0.016230205073952675,
-0.4568083584308624,
-0.30149045586586,
-0.08519791066646576,
0.25849613547325134,
0.25431057810783386,
-0.10683277994394302,
-0.050665244460105896,
-0.16823558509349823,
0.3576105833053589,
0.08462172001600266,
-0.17046742141246796,
0.4102972447872162,
0.33969926834106445,
-0.8025937676429749,
0.38934656977653503,
-0.2833198606967926,
0.7605672478675842,
-0.530668318271637,
-0.06749995052814484,
-0.24651825428009033,
0.04789824038743973,
-0.42524439096450806,
-1.155498743057251,
0.28167155385017395,
0.1029425859451294,
-0.2669563293457031,
-0.0072241416200995445,
0.5745390057563782,
-0.0801909789443016,
-0.4412727653980255,
0.2736358344554901,
0.6636452078819275,
0.14672444760799408,
0.32393625378608704,
-0.8992462754249573,
0.5239375829696655,
-0.041845306754112244,
-0.5716009736061096,
0.14846143126487732,
0.5052825808525085,
-0.0228553656488657,
0.8790689706802368,
0.34911811351776123,
0.40237534046173096,
-0.1039947122335434,
-0.1908414512872696,
0.6057702302932739,
-0.4486830532550812,
-0.22017014026641846,
-0.9839376211166382,
0.5735898613929749,
-0.07590749859809875,
-0.34916070103645325,
0.9158140420913696,
0.30992889404296875,
0.43056273460388184,
0.4078063368797302,
0.6992387175559998,
-0.09639468789100647,
0.24320779740810394,
-0.6150377988815308,
0.5922725796699524,
-0.49270761013031006,
0.3501369059085846,
-0.08685050904750824,
-1.0343657732009888,
-0.2467712014913559,
0.5351994633674622,
-0.40999889373779297,
-0.01404558215290308,
0.3452143371105194,
0.8854734897613525,
-0.07532022148370743,
-0.25539830327033997,
0.23616749048233032,
0.3033590018749237,
0.2467503696680069,
0.30497869849205017,
1.2003952264785767,
0.14570985734462738,
0.43562307953834534,
0.0715593695640564,
-0.035259705036878586,
0.01344104204326868,
-1.1551662683486938,
-0.8837344646453857,
-0.30300188064575195,
-0.3703891336917877,
-0.8913203477859497,
0.1000150665640831,
1.103007435798645,
0.5890713334083557,
-0.663212239742279,
-0.18469440937042236,
0.025238756090402603,
0.3486380875110626,
0.26991990208625793,
-0.2608112692832947,
0.4669104516506195,
-0.024163242429494858,
-0.5700988173484802,
0.23200082778930664,
0.4598001539707184,
-0.021196989342570305,
-0.7133207321166992,
-0.08632069081068039,
-0.042412012815475464,
0.676642894744873,
0.4783785343170166,
0.2623191177845001,
-1.2272299528121948,
-0.7042247653007507,
0.16680563986301422,
-0.18921197950839996,
0.09684370458126068,
0.4448917508125305,
-0.32277315855026245,
0.17984774708747864,
0.47192028164863586,
0.25738653540611267,
-0.7415780425071716,
0.053167685866355896,
0.4770753085613251,
-0.2524522840976715,
0.10309712588787079,
0.26053398847579956,
0.5913581252098083,
0.612427294254303,
-0.01694733090698719,
0.26199662685394287,
0.15809276700019836,
-0.8547640442848206,
-1.089888572692871,
0.5380281805992126,
-0.9398202896118164,
0.04495137184858322,
1.5931316614151,
-0.3494483530521393,
-0.1300814300775528,
-0.32506686449050903,
-0.006020439323037863,
-0.21927645802497864,
-0.2998766005039215,
0.3716500401496887,
0.8301948308944702,
-0.16681329905986786,
-0.013470137491822243,
-0.603419840335846,
0.23796074092388153,
0.4016089141368866,
-0.4652445912361145,
0.19509364664554596,
0.42561450600624084,
0.5948918461799622,
0.2505676746368408,
0.5211908221244812,
-0.11286163330078125,
-0.06847920268774033,
-0.058610815554857254,
-0.44824185967445374,
0.5523258447647095,
-0.5072280764579773,
-0.5282415747642517,
0.2014533281326294,
0.3835379183292389,
0.3368690609931946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17645v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17645v1
|
SongComposer: A Large Language Model for Lyric and Melody Composition in Song Generation
| 2024-02-27T16:15:28 | 2024-02-27T16:15:28 |
Shuangrui Ding, Zihan Liu, Xiaoyi Dong, Pan Zhang, Rui Qian, Conghui He, Dahua Lin, Jiaqi Wang
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
We present SongComposer, an innovative LLM designed for song composition. It
could understand and generate melodies and lyrics in symbolic song
representations, by leveraging the capability of LLM. Existing music-related
LLM treated the music as quantized audio signals, while such implicit encoding
leads to inefficient encoding and poor flexibility. In contrast, we resort to
symbolic song representation, the mature and efficient way humans designed for
music, and enable LLM to explicitly compose songs like humans. In practice, we
design a novel tuple design to format lyric and three note attributes (pitch,
duration, and rest duration) in the melody, which guarantees the correct LLM
understanding of musical symbols and realizes precise alignment between lyrics
and melody. To impart basic music understanding to LLM, we carefully collected
SongCompose-PT, a large-scale song pretraining dataset that includes lyrics,
melodies, and paired lyrics-melodies in either Chinese or English. After
adequate pre-training, 10K carefully crafted QA pairs are used to empower the
LLM with the instruction-following capability and solve diverse tasks. With
extensive experiments, SongComposer demonstrates superior performance in
lyric-to-melody generation, melody-to-lyric generation, song continuation, and
text-to-song creation, outperforming advanced LLMs like GPT-4.
|
[
-0.15064941346645355,
-0.36087676882743835,
0.35096675157546997,
0.977249801158905,
-0.1996563971042633,
0.26272052526474,
-0.21951361000537872,
-0.4411904811859131,
0.2623549997806549,
0.5951299667358398,
-0.6137480735778809,
-0.49184152483940125,
-0.24085895717144012,
-0.000014439977348956745,
-0.25603583455085754,
0.8862395286560059,
0.008176805451512337,
0.05861157178878784,
-0.30855482816696167,
0.13679897785186768,
-0.7655094265937805,
-0.388598769903183,
-0.7619937658309937,
-0.3991605043411255,
0.6695292592048645,
0.38031211495399475,
0.1495572030544281,
0.3540402054786682,
0.4455210864543915,
0.40163418650627136,
-0.014276495203375816,
-0.02045566774904728,
-0.6144832372665405,
0.24125799536705017,
0.20677721500396729,
-0.6540730595588684,
-0.6501473188400269,
0.4127722382545471,
0.6232508420944214,
0.5982176661491394,
-0.06331459432840347,
0.36977264285087585,
0.05481475964188576,
0.768513560295105,
-0.15480472147464752,
0.19439376890659332,
-0.7110432982444763,
0.2659079134464264,
-0.27825647592544556,
-0.2795259952545166,
-0.31938979029655457,
-0.615792453289032,
0.14991043508052826,
-1.0297659635543823,
0.12333925813436508,
0.07007349282503128,
0.502314567565918,
0.22666360437870026,
-0.17911966145038605,
-0.4370273947715759,
-0.820359468460083,
0.7010977864265442,
-0.24768836796283722,
0.17032599449157715,
-0.019310032948851585,
0.5131595730781555,
-0.24903486669063568,
-0.9216873645782471,
-0.3080144226551056,
-0.2105303257703781,
0.19083049893379211,
0.4229458272457123,
0.12824930250644684,
0.029110513627529144,
0.30976831912994385,
0.6424816846847534,
-0.6713722348213196,
-0.33074572682380676,
-0.28157326579093933,
-0.26199448108673096,
0.6849819421768188,
0.14265161752700806,
0.5138376951217651,
-0.16948486864566803,
-0.5723557472229004,
-0.002534009050577879,
-1.027445912361145,
0.11889669299125671,
0.4617701470851898,
0.15891461074352264,
-0.1902473270893097,
0.5661548972129822,
0.38089045882225037,
0.7301530838012695,
0.33139216899871826,
-0.2731552720069885,
0.11482863128185272,
-0.15470649302005768,
-0.181404247879982,
0.35506322979927063,
1.0166658163070679,
0.10246413201093674,
0.11447881907224655,
-0.33431556820869446,
-0.4272143840789795,
0.04380935803055763,
0.11867118626832962,
-0.6584132313728333,
-0.46087872982025146,
0.09019608795642853,
-0.39404362440109253,
-0.09650936722755432,
0.19573672115802765,
-0.37190964818000793,
-0.3748965561389923,
-0.6277053952217102,
0.9342475533485413,
-0.6384480595588684,
-0.09270649403333664,
0.16605563461780548,
-0.30576321482658386,
0.004399367142468691,
-0.07812993228435516,
-0.9308954477310181,
0.11399094015359879,
0.7639586925506592,
0.9078159332275391,
-0.08610344678163528,
-0.3869571089744568,
-0.5019166469573975,
0.5897255539894104,
-0.3090628683567047,
0.6722419857978821,
-0.16445417702198029,
-0.4327184557914734,
-0.2593013048171997,
-0.11064908653497696,
-0.2418474406003952,
-0.7320360541343689,
0.35190775990486145,
-0.37108638882637024,
0.4288462996482849,
-0.31116214394569397,
-0.7030678391456604,
-0.2219826728105545,
-0.1542723923921585,
-1.050789475440979,
0.6058303117752075,
0.36895185708999634,
-0.5995309352874756,
0.2599313259124756,
-0.6520484089851379,
-0.6408398747444153,
0.1538805365562439,
-0.135442852973938,
-0.48336663842201233,
0.48854967951774597,
-0.09973420947790146,
0.3227008581161499,
-0.27205196022987366,
0.15665166079998016,
0.10546676814556122,
-0.773127019405365,
0.4898203909397125,
-0.08866589516401291,
0.6747305393218994,
0.4346862733364105,
-0.02733033522963524,
0.1694231778383255,
-0.824441134929657,
-0.051998578011989594,
0.35976457595825195,
-0.5601515173912048,
-0.23209385573863983,
-0.011773926205933094,
0.5089524388313293,
0.20140327513217926,
0.5511802434921265,
-0.4724310636520386,
-0.017244840040802956,
-0.37425363063812256,
0.7521688342094421,
0.529880166053772,
-0.13107708096504211,
0.5232386589050293,
-0.6990432143211365,
0.7983211278915405,
-0.3115280568599701,
-0.051927175372838974,
-0.20077987015247345,
-0.125993013381958,
-0.42111527919769287,
-0.08335542678833008,
0.364469438791275,
0.22027122974395752,
-0.3532995879650116,
0.5479745864868164,
-0.3041470944881439,
-0.33855709433555603,
-0.4685700237751007,
0.3593595325946808,
0.31243327260017395,
0.22600987553596497,
0.10379543155431747,
-0.16201715171337128,
-0.9084768295288086,
-0.5351625084877014,
-0.20146754384040833,
-0.16333718597888947,
-0.2595732808113098,
-0.05898614972829819,
-0.01063078735023737,
0.24687351286411285,
0.8139638304710388,
-0.2897050082683563,
-0.710068941116333,
-0.8056854605674744,
0.04353659600019455,
0.2802186906337738,
0.6661426424980164,
0.603976845741272,
-0.6978756785392761,
-0.49019619822502136,
-0.2605355381965637,
-0.4959326982498169,
-0.5115978717803955,
-0.36876532435417175,
-0.2708037793636322,
-0.13074661791324615,
0.37973177433013916,
-0.6027830243110657,
-0.6802082657814026,
0.7885786294937134,
-0.3397219479084015,
0.3888562023639679,
0.0838063657283783,
-0.03496725857257843,
-1.2269223928451538,
0.17532557249069214,
-0.1740916669368744,
-0.013039766810834408,
-0.5754339098930359,
-0.1323431134223938,
-0.009960973635315895,
-0.1784459948539734,
-0.37255850434303284,
0.04670257493853569,
-0.4552164375782013,
-0.17875413596630096,
-0.37774258852005005,
0.2744430601596832,
0.23347242176532745,
0.19584961235523224,
0.19294501841068268,
0.7572157979011536,
0.25563639402389526,
-0.21123236417770386,
0.44823962450027466,
0.2364986389875412,
-0.5570283532142639,
0.7850452661514282,
-0.884743869304657,
0.1673775464296341,
-0.024088086560368538,
0.20044198632240295,
-0.9110451936721802,
-0.2642308175563812,
-0.004255962558090687,
-0.39888057112693787,
0.39273661375045776,
-0.11444304883480072,
-0.5294976830482483,
-0.47319138050079346,
0.033994391560554504,
0.37801235914230347,
0.39743977785110474,
-0.397388756275177,
0.6834641695022583,
0.36341047286987305,
-0.13852061331272125,
0.12387944012880325,
-0.5887151956558228,
0.08424679934978485,
-0.6151100993156433,
-0.7941067814826965,
0.563025712966919,
-0.0672655999660492,
-0.014630786143243313,
-0.1689586043357849,
-0.3295649290084839,
0.35894137620925903,
0.1255386471748352,
0.45777231454849243,
0.18054817616939545,
-0.25280964374542236,
0.3584676682949066,
-0.15596328675746918,
-0.343865305185318,
0.3672511875629425,
-0.44697391986846924,
0.9374701976776123,
0.173191100358963,
-0.18963474035263062,
-0.23296289145946503,
0.537756085395813,
0.376258909702301,
-0.40445470809936523,
0.10691215842962265,
0.41351762413978577,
-0.0018101099412888288,
-0.27371206879615784,
-0.3896532952785492,
0.27265480160713196,
-0.5191994905471802,
0.35660356283187866,
-0.5241422653198242,
-0.8464740514755249,
0.46228858828544617,
-0.20122525095939636,
0.2440163493156433,
0.3532504439353943,
0.37684914469718933,
-0.4755958020687103,
0.920566976070404,
0.6928316950798035,
-0.1649918407201767,
0.6963903903961182,
-0.5479964017868042,
-0.33901000022888184,
-0.9166956543922424,
-0.3772013485431671,
-0.33128711581230164,
-0.8263499736785889,
-0.47348782420158386,
-0.25389862060546875,
0.42557209730148315,
0.005725097842514515,
-0.6395609974861145,
0.24231964349746704,
-0.6245592832565308,
0.4900636076927185,
0.6284237504005432,
-0.030019233003258705,
0.10948450863361359,
-0.2152119129896164,
0.015369516797363758,
-0.06867874413728714,
-0.4508552551269531,
-0.32973888516426086,
1.0739505290985107,
0.2145659625530243,
0.8989349007606506,
0.022973155602812767,
0.9857014417648315,
-0.17440080642700195,
-0.06702803075313568,
-0.9573821425437927,
0.4454789161682129,
-0.4041175842285156,
-0.42711132764816284,
-0.05730966851115227,
-0.3392435312271118,
-0.7094449996948242,
0.11015289276838303,
-0.040024831891059875,
-0.43268871307373047,
-0.34276503324508667,
0.09588015824556351,
-0.39615315198898315,
0.05424400791525841,
-0.708171010017395,
0.9303869605064392,
-0.6040699481964111,
0.03984478861093521,
0.07106408476829529,
-0.37233835458755493,
0.4211806356906891,
-0.18524976074695587,
-0.04634253680706024,
-0.22652478516101837,
-0.10702777653932571,
0.8211526274681091,
-0.24771516025066376,
0.7165205478668213,
-0.2626849114894867,
-0.4053918421268463,
0.2069835662841797,
0.14531034231185913,
0.31694573163986206,
-0.09925582259893417,
0.07218988239765167,
-0.2847798764705658,
-0.2390047311782837,
-0.1820923238992691,
-0.5838297605514526,
0.8073962926864624,
-0.8600239753723145,
-0.6663680076599121,
-0.11654219776391983,
-0.8965957760810852,
-0.2731531262397766,
0.02725195325911045,
0.5112109184265137,
0.22041472792625427,
-0.192328080534935,
0.3316713869571686,
0.4760901927947998,
-0.0852837860584259,
0.3967485725879669,
0.24150604009628296,
-0.29878318309783936,
-0.7656823992729187,
0.9875482320785522,
-0.024813314899802208,
0.35216233134269714,
0.6205354928970337,
0.33935222029685974,
-0.46685606241226196,
-0.5284754633903503,
-0.36260175704956055,
0.24670499563217163,
-0.374260276556015,
0.017146261408925056,
-0.37576165795326233,
-0.2864256501197815,
0.11404062062501907,
-0.07460653781890869,
-0.32328733801841736,
-0.46031907200813293,
-0.15298038721084595,
0.16724878549575806,
0.5246163606643677,
0.5895730257034302,
-0.08475803583860397,
0.6165602207183838,
-0.8116930723190308,
0.5689122080802917,
0.4249095320701599,
0.33400094509124756,
-0.19233980774879456,
-0.4606795012950897,
-0.3654787242412567,
-0.18621203303337097,
-0.4938308894634247,
-0.8084312081336975,
0.1777794063091278,
0.3243260979652405,
0.39489346742630005,
0.5064135193824768,
-0.2974642813205719,
0.814629316329956,
-0.5640119910240173,
0.7816897034645081,
0.44078725576400757,
-1.0143513679504395,
0.6752391457557678,
-0.36294302344322205,
0.2517637610435486,
0.387092262506485,
0.05015233904123306,
-0.8320448994636536,
-0.42134538292884827,
-0.060418691486120224,
-0.7710002660751343,
0.5562768578529358,
0.3000549376010895,
0.1553112119436264,
0.2789616584777832,
0.286329984664917,
0.16756831109523773,
0.1823805868625641,
-0.761696994304657,
-0.2817392945289612,
-0.7336397767066956,
-0.4922836720943451,
-0.4389951527118683,
-0.02816227823495865,
-0.061542805284261703,
-0.0639977976679802,
0.4739209711551666,
-0.09285716712474823,
0.24794265627861023,
-0.016615986824035645,
0.052708856761455536,
-0.36368420720100403,
0.14495596289634705,
0.2800382971763611,
0.34880372881889343,
0.014297221787273884,
0.12621383368968964,
-0.29567578434944153,
-0.6795541048049927,
0.3968897759914398,
0.22567380964756012,
-0.43639490008354187,
-0.24557343125343323,
0.37404635548591614,
0.7392234802246094,
0.40317678451538086,
-0.5348713397979736,
0.24318240582942963,
0.019007377326488495,
-0.20352023839950562,
-0.6277661919593811,
0.29742535948753357,
0.7320146560668945,
0.17710690200328827,
0.2947199046611786,
-0.27436816692352295,
0.0662541389465332,
-0.3550509512424469,
0.10642551630735397,
0.4221495985984802,
-0.5533725023269653,
-0.4471878409385681,
1.154545545578003,
-0.030566170811653137,
-0.17121586203575134,
0.24578382074832916,
0.1435132771730423,
-0.3324110805988312,
0.6407294273376465,
0.9910082221031189,
1.069376826286316,
-0.23375758528709412,
0.2672154903411865,
0.1471206694841385,
-0.1118214949965477,
0.17296241223812103,
0.7742197513580322,
-0.09313453733921051,
-0.395903080701828,
-0.6748560667037964,
-0.7618547677993774,
0.01635642722249031,
0.39725908637046814,
-0.4202312231063843,
0.02709123119711876,
-0.42304015159606934,
0.017150213941931725,
0.13948097825050354,
0.300979346036911,
-0.3748665452003479,
0.05365989729762077,
0.0367201492190361,
0.8697543740272522,
-0.7869952917098999,
0.6838272213935852,
0.9423174858093262,
-0.6026899814605713,
-1.185076117515564,
-0.024537982419133186,
0.14005343616008759,
-0.5668976306915283,
0.6760843396186829,
0.32583341002464294,
0.03353908658027649,
0.24799364805221558,
-0.5678956508636475,
-0.6755638122558594,
1.2542628049850464,
0.40881913900375366,
-0.7989730834960938,
0.030543779954314232,
0.5948428511619568,
0.5554432272911072,
-0.41000187397003174,
-0.2841569185256958,
0.5642220377922058,
0.4552574157714844,
0.6473497748374939,
-0.5148939490318298,
-0.09673766046762466,
-0.40602681040763855,
0.18737860023975372,
0.2641312777996063,
-0.8467735648155212,
0.9541441202163696,
0.08412235975265503,
-0.2196628749370575,
0.6925036907196045,
0.6723455190658569,
0.6845297813415527,
0.16463115811347961,
0.49359455704689026,
0.5374655723571777,
0.47085046768188477,
-0.39507925510406494,
0.7096773386001587,
-0.2901618182659149,
-0.18785294890403748,
1.1932142972946167,
-0.2400486171245575,
0.4420821964740753,
0.5104700922966003,
-0.16946153342723846,
0.18401922285556793,
0.6368679404258728,
-0.0661398321390152,
0.5094076991081238,
0.6524789929389954,
-0.47489133477211,
-0.54060298204422,
-0.11004895716905594,
-0.22372110188007355,
0.7496334910392761,
0.19037668406963348,
-0.43513256311416626,
0.09642229229211807,
-0.08988617360591888,
-0.2814589738845825,
0.2923506200313568,
-0.34873735904693604,
0.996868908405304,
0.31896594166755676,
-0.5563650131225586,
0.19732092320919037,
-0.37896543741226196,
0.4712769389152527,
-0.6222426295280457,
0.03215070441365242,
-0.23542413115501404,
0.09158234298229218,
-0.11167953908443451,
-0.8372560143470764,
-0.09109765291213989,
-0.27274659276008606,
-0.053096670657396317,
-0.12696833908557892,
0.4645381569862366,
-0.5858359932899475,
-0.5138770341873169,
0.16541369259357452,
0.44316163659095764,
-0.1460341066122055,
-0.2585403621196747,
-0.5135961771011353,
0.07606078684329987,
-0.19123882055282593,
0.042864229530096054,
0.16097238659858704,
0.8258168697357178,
0.11422747373580933,
0.555456280708313,
0.6195030808448792,
0.6334396600723267,
0.15031909942626953,
0.5797496438026428,
0.6638832688331604,
-0.8956118822097778,
-0.6388384103775024,
-0.4941612780094147,
0.33572882413864136,
0.07818230986595154,
0.04600079730153084,
0.5417422652244568,
0.9276453852653503,
0.8046664595603943,
-0.3584744334220886,
1.0494195222854614,
-0.038731932640075684,
0.44298288226127625,
-0.6664068102836609,
0.7921650409698486,
-0.5947885513305664,
0.3279607594013214,
-0.5000212788581848,
-1.191316843032837,
-0.2438649833202362,
0.45208287239074707,
0.11823812127113342,
-0.0011274373391643167,
0.19747117161750793,
0.4115326702594757,
-0.1353529989719391,
0.24408094584941864,
0.2003604620695114,
-0.01801619678735733,
0.3842126727104187,
1.1920087337493896,
1.3748948574066162,
-0.3333752155303955,
0.6573370099067688,
-0.44710835814476013,
0.11474486440420151,
0.16096821427345276,
-0.6857234835624695,
-0.8439525961875916,
-0.6175724864006042,
-0.13284075260162354,
0.20423540472984314,
-0.268513560295105,
1.0313608646392822,
0.48944297432899475,
-0.7295337915420532,
-0.4970422089099884,
-0.1902303844690323,
0.07907912135124207,
-0.44924941658973694,
-0.20810724794864655,
0.44562292098999023,
-0.38956964015960693,
-0.9219673871994019,
0.35778987407684326,
0.16064095497131348,
0.32103103399276733,
-0.4216589033603668,
-0.35598352551460266,
0.48809823393821716,
-0.1323956847190857,
0.6703389883041382,
0.034890349954366684,
-0.6844994425773621,
-0.22016538679599762,
0.183242067694664,
-0.05078013241291046,
0.12920932471752167,
1.1898750066757202,
-0.40729185938835144,
0.375671923160553,
0.650660514831543,
0.11739481985569,
0.18205899000167847,
0.009969711303710938,
0.8015542030334473,
-0.567132830619812,
-0.12305019050836563,
0.09802864491939545,
0.49952447414398193,
0.29982131719589233,
-0.04826119914650917,
0.3093927800655365,
0.09959293156862259,
-0.4392964243888855,
-0.15539616346359253,
0.2544414699077606,
-1.3519163131713867,
0.03900373354554176,
1.007271409034729,
-0.20082934200763702,
-0.02270149067044258,
-0.047604769468307495,
-0.5769848823547363,
0.4355699419975281,
-0.2849806249141693,
0.823853611946106,
0.2927207350730896,
-0.00025910077965818346,
-0.2255200445652008,
-0.3719324767589569,
0.5657255053520203,
-0.11569378525018692,
-0.5273153781890869,
0.023317459970712662,
0.7566205263137817,
0.3380874693393707,
0.13046567142009735,
0.45320454239845276,
-0.42768365144729614,
0.5906009078025818,
-0.14609992504119873,
0.26542696356773376,
-0.33789777755737305,
-0.19158093631267548,
-0.0824744775891304,
0.4965302348136902,
0.18636709451675415,
-0.43849337100982666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17644v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17644v2
|
Are LLMs Capable of Data-based Statistical and Causal Reasoning? Benchmarking Advanced Quantitative Reasoning with Data
| 2024-02-27T16:15:03 | 2024-06-09T13:54:09 |
Xiao Liu, Zirui Wu, Xueqing Wu, Pan Lu, Kai-Wei Chang, Yansong Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Quantitative reasoning is a critical skill to analyze data, yet the
assessment of such ability remains limited. To address this gap, we introduce
the Quantitative Reasoning with Data (QRData) benchmark, aiming to evaluate
Large Language Models' capability in statistical and causal reasoning with
real-world data. The benchmark comprises a carefully constructed dataset of 411
questions accompanied by data sheets from textbooks, online learning materials,
and academic papers. To compare models' quantitative reasoning abilities on
data and text, we enrich the benchmark with an auxiliary set of 290 text-only
questions, namely QRText. We evaluate natural language reasoning, program-based
reasoning, and agent reasoning methods including Chain-of-Thought,
Program-of-Thoughts, ReAct, and code interpreter assistants on diverse models.
The strongest model GPT-4 achieves an accuracy of 58%, which has much room for
improvement. Among open-source models, Deepseek-coder-instruct, a code LLM
pretrained on 2T tokens, gets the highest accuracy of 37%. Analysis reveals
that models encounter difficulties in data analysis and causal reasoning, and
struggle in using causal knowledge and provided data simultaneously. Code and
data are in https://github.com/xxxiaol/QRData.
|
[
-0.01929876022040844,
-0.7457659840583801,
0.9093054533004761,
0.2471173107624054,
-0.041741665452718735,
0.2215137928724289,
-0.017918286845088005,
-0.3412174582481384,
-0.49940863251686096,
0.386520117521286,
-0.5036656260490417,
-0.6843632459640503,
-0.16968394815921783,
0.16270112991333008,
-0.40629443526268005,
0.6525418758392334,
-0.07376105338335037,
0.48176655173301697,
-0.5009868741035461,
-0.18925297260284424,
-0.6158556938171387,
-0.5709836483001709,
-0.5681275725364685,
-0.16565445065498352,
0.5643822550773621,
0.4255109429359436,
0.8138757348060608,
0.5619770288467407,
0.7625252604484558,
0.22660312056541443,
0.21521399915218353,
0.3371598720550537,
-0.5887743830680847,
0.31925392150878906,
-0.4591314196586609,
-0.7034918665885925,
-0.5517740845680237,
0.10492576658725739,
0.7422264814376831,
0.5363969206809998,
-0.030634980648756027,
0.3534109592437744,
-0.265960693359375,
0.7023797035217285,
-0.5465234518051147,
0.2467910349369049,
-0.6723162531852722,
-0.21509473025798798,
0.11045544594526291,
-0.1322399526834488,
-0.42061111330986023,
-1.04745352268219,
-0.1204567477107048,
-0.6387825608253479,
-0.022403588518500328,
0.23122721910476685,
0.7433240413665771,
0.6743097901344299,
-0.7355831861495972,
-0.07562731206417084,
-0.7181402444839478,
0.7907885909080505,
-0.6347227692604065,
0.6654230356216431,
0.5518344640731812,
0.6787726283073425,
-0.25135570764541626,
-0.7860178351402283,
-0.4834859371185303,
-0.5182365775108337,
0.19348154962062836,
0.0940217673778534,
-0.46850261092185974,
-0.2121025025844574,
0.5948381423950195,
0.003865695558488369,
-0.9215189814567566,
0.09392373263835907,
-0.338949978351593,
-0.03576967492699623,
0.6789762377738953,
0.5379630327224731,
0.07954631000757217,
0.1504565179347992,
-0.4465329945087433,
-0.1798686981201172,
-0.9076403975486755,
-0.1871873289346695,
0.29411330819129944,
0.02307194098830223,
-0.09806019067764282,
0.6424354910850525,
-0.4622950553894043,
0.46033936738967896,
-0.47402751445770264,
0.23721560835838318,
-0.037441108375787735,
-0.3766820728778839,
-0.2791467607021332,
-0.3788085877895355,
0.6890000700950623,
0.2766948938369751,
0.6567206382751465,
-0.25399670004844666,
-0.06236937642097473,
0.23609110713005066,
0.15084291994571686,
-0.7248206734657288,
-0.3833980858325958,
0.34672313928604126,
-0.09188627451658249,
-0.003137113293632865,
-0.19647297263145447,
-0.6465234160423279,
-0.38712483644485474,
-0.4714115262031555,
0.4267187714576721,
-0.26380547881126404,
-0.057267192751169205,
0.3167819380760193,
-0.06706328690052032,
0.2804342806339264,
0.39836397767066956,
-0.37723779678344727,
0.460824579000473,
0.7540351152420044,
0.5848593711853027,
-0.09634384512901306,
-0.223910391330719,
-0.46951958537101746,
0.10827196389436722,
-0.5641955733299255,
1.2460891008377075,
-0.3090102970600128,
-0.058194514364004135,
-0.2400999218225479,
-0.2886257767677307,
-0.04839879274368286,
-0.6847956776618958,
0.6550015211105347,
-0.6807305216789246,
-0.007384488824754953,
-0.4620552062988281,
-0.8227972984313965,
-0.20386596024036407,
0.2063128501176834,
-0.6999912858009338,
1.1634498834609985,
0.10415121912956238,
-0.6738361120223999,
0.561745822429657,
-0.01523936539888382,
-0.003614414017647505,
0.004107320681214333,
-0.40527233481407166,
-0.45977842807769775,
-0.302480012178421,
0.06864498555660248,
0.41108953952789307,
-1.0377469062805176,
0.773708164691925,
-0.7571314573287964,
-0.39277565479278564,
0.7135325074195862,
-0.5054957270622253,
0.6947697997093201,
0.17654815316200256,
-0.25548675656318665,
0.1931937038898468,
-1.0701289176940918,
0.3481164276599884,
0.09940913319587708,
-0.21159221231937408,
-0.10455168038606644,
0.09822805225849152,
-0.17896921932697296,
0.16035884618759155,
-0.035570498555898666,
-0.15279722213745117,
0.37037843465805054,
0.22894585132598877,
0.27169445157051086,
0.6734657883644104,
-0.05625879019498825,
0.12389251589775085,
-0.3172851502895355,
0.6186910271644592,
-0.2116628885269165,
0.11098794639110565,
0.38267219066619873,
-0.4872027039527893,
-0.4671820104122162,
-0.33657169342041016,
0.307503879070282,
0.835999071598053,
-0.8280931115150452,
0.0919659361243248,
-0.22370049357414246,
-0.639122724533081,
-0.3699484169483185,
-0.05775405839085579,
0.5201719999313354,
0.6269164085388184,
0.426165372133255,
0.14220871031284332,
-0.5082609057426453,
-0.8672329783439636,
-0.4511213004589081,
-0.458930104970932,
-0.03699704259634018,
0.05662981793284416,
0.6673478484153748,
-0.1343783736228943,
0.9557029604911804,
-0.6729339957237244,
0.23886077105998993,
-0.09506000578403473,
0.1181555837392807,
0.17066124081611633,
0.30396631360054016,
0.26934656500816345,
-0.687007486820221,
-0.17404209077358246,
-0.1361996829509735,
-1.2525036334991455,
-0.5282754898071289,
0.10939938575029373,
-0.27359938621520996,
-0.21722787618637085,
0.59850013256073,
-0.5932453274726868,
0.38512352108955383,
0.2160630226135254,
-0.5185396075248718,
0.961754322052002,
-0.25846579670906067,
0.26703327894210815,
-0.589605450630188,
0.11863622069358826,
0.11134592443704605,
-0.09335359930992126,
-0.7219148278236389,
-0.08547452837228775,
0.33975955843925476,
-0.009937984868884087,
-0.3265119194984436,
0.8414309024810791,
-0.3197856843471527,
-0.3717953562736511,
-0.11292339861392975,
-0.12373507767915726,
0.10071918368339539,
0.3513944149017334,
-0.028628285974264145,
0.9821397662162781,
0.4587601125240326,
-0.5945525765419006,
0.509989321231842,
0.19946877658367157,
-0.5836878418922424,
0.52286297082901,
-0.8250114321708679,
0.08376128226518631,
0.12664073705673218,
0.17831909656524658,
-1.0081822872161865,
-0.07761970907449722,
0.13865093886852264,
-0.45557713508605957,
-0.12672457098960876,
-0.05773351714015007,
-0.783737301826477,
-0.22905372083187103,
-0.06839197129011154,
0.5743690729141235,
0.3939388394355774,
-0.34808069467544556,
0.24585436284542084,
0.1378544569015503,
-0.07037579268217087,
-0.42751917243003845,
-0.6179890632629395,
0.018710684031248093,
-0.45122435688972473,
-0.5215843915939331,
-0.07238803803920746,
-0.19760479032993317,
-0.7391278743743896,
0.09087323397397995,
0.035984233021736145,
-0.5239983201026917,
0.048203788697719574,
-0.03549836203455925,
0.30506977438926697,
-0.2565833330154419,
0.4436595141887665,
0.005951675586402416,
-0.3342163562774658,
0.18019241094589233,
-0.1230262890458107,
0.17065617442131042,
-0.1571238934993744,
-0.42183688282966614,
-0.3941420614719391,
0.11778534203767776,
0.4303116798400879,
-0.20987604558467865,
0.5953580141067505,
0.49580079317092896,
-0.2652427852153778,
-0.10474355518817902,
-0.6834889054298401,
-0.06892041116952896,
-0.3795147240161896,
0.21570390462875366,
-0.46217861771583557,
-0.9291532039642334,
0.6975008845329285,
-0.002703616861253977,
-0.28797581791877747,
0.25863733887672424,
0.6520245671272278,
0.02201094850897789,
1.0795884132385254,
0.16088645160198212,
-0.03971751034259796,
0.11382822692394257,
-0.1605035364627838,
-0.003863327903673053,
-0.5285051465034485,
-0.15250356495380402,
-0.6653236746788025,
0.17334553599357605,
-0.5750138163566589,
-0.6593660116195679,
0.3656308948993683,
0.1439025104045868,
-0.8588860034942627,
0.08140639960765839,
-0.16950896382331848,
0.26450449228286743,
0.654831051826477,
0.2566036880016327,
0.47464367747306824,
-0.3715435266494751,
0.11955957859754562,
0.044357359409332275,
-0.6644838452339172,
-0.7199690937995911,
1.1683754920959473,
0.37371277809143066,
0.9660187363624573,
0.08630891144275665,
0.3622789978981018,
0.38884201645851135,
0.2358202040195465,
-0.46329793334007263,
0.7888929843902588,
0.18094073235988617,
-0.5666226148605347,
-0.23291198909282684,
-0.8766706585884094,
-0.7326802611351013,
0.35991209745407104,
-0.09261193871498108,
-0.513748824596405,
0.35620585083961487,
0.040256667882204056,
-0.29297780990600586,
0.1375609040260315,
-0.7492141127586365,
0.8650009632110596,
-0.3752424716949463,
-0.8516805171966553,
-0.19673308730125427,
-0.39599087834358215,
0.5477615594863892,
-0.1150587648153305,
0.314986914396286,
-0.5759869813919067,
-0.11129940301179886,
0.6668187975883484,
-0.461147665977478,
0.7774636149406433,
-0.11493772268295288,
-0.15119226276874542,
0.4768733084201813,
0.1639787256717682,
0.5056740641593933,
0.11387154459953308,
-0.3181039094924927,
0.1366419494152069,
0.2171907126903534,
-0.6287098526954651,
-0.7572762370109558,
0.27165406942367554,
-0.5623466968536377,
-0.5198253393173218,
-0.444772869348526,
-0.4985869526863098,
-0.4961772859096527,
0.007854120805859566,
-0.23100626468658447,
0.4275282025337219,
-0.18504254519939423,
0.014682112261652946,
0.5775301456451416,
-0.20826955139636993,
-0.18897180259227753,
0.783393919467926,
-0.031061045825481415,
-0.5270938873291016,
0.7435120940208435,
-0.002403455786406994,
0.3007149398326874,
0.4851061999797821,
0.3609437644481659,
-0.4477654993534088,
-0.48536890745162964,
-0.42850372195243835,
0.2198890894651413,
-0.7849687933921814,
-0.4676295816898346,
-0.471455842256546,
0.07428676635026932,
-0.2517189085483551,
0.25316163897514343,
-0.10109592229127884,
-0.4827638864517212,
-0.0405978225171566,
-0.17063693702220917,
0.6191710829734802,
0.7403498291969299,
-0.11448245495557785,
0.10785237699747086,
-0.6771233677864075,
0.4621199369430542,
0.5676303505897522,
0.20009437203407288,
0.008209588006138802,
-0.3371388018131256,
-0.3425773084163666,
-0.023041721433401108,
0.04349015653133392,
-1.015673041343689,
0.34882423281669617,
-0.17725509405136108,
0.599632740020752,
0.22587330639362335,
-0.08356017619371414,
0.5210832953453064,
-0.44224488735198975,
0.41133973002433777,
-0.18661129474639893,
-0.7732240557670593,
0.38223007321357727,
-0.5907796621322632,
0.19205641746520996,
0.5710052251815796,
0.45969510078430176,
-0.1023683175444603,
-0.4250117540359497,
-0.2577756643295288,
-0.48715195059776306,
0.3031056523323059,
0.20565785467624664,
-0.5862756967544556,
-0.04518045857548714,
0.39327263832092285,
0.04347121715545654,
0.20140889286994934,
-0.5172234773635864,
0.07377267628908157,
0.15258033573627472,
-0.1863517463207245,
-0.04246283322572708,
-0.25090184807777405,
0.0943930521607399,
-0.4671671688556671,
0.4059861898422241,
-0.2869165241718292,
0.13521838188171387,
0.0031771676149219275,
-0.03652479499578476,
0.09037857502698898,
0.23380866646766663,
0.4976002871990204,
0.9697020053863525,
-0.3097531795501709,
0.22684502601623535,
0.22455070912837982,
-0.3717021346092224,
0.3980655074119568,
0.20839497447013855,
0.04567242041230202,
-0.4337427616119385,
0.5594730973243713,
0.489489883184433,
0.5974522233009338,
-1.0282535552978516,
0.23469343781471252,
-0.26482847332954407,
-0.18000733852386475,
-0.04003891721367836,
0.05265039950609207,
0.1420212835073471,
0.6732836365699768,
0.4186469316482544,
-0.5725386142730713,
0.23429548740386963,
-0.6155163645744324,
0.21683864295482635,
0.29625657200813293,
-0.045181673020124435,
-0.25797775387763977,
0.9220641851425171,
-0.23607340455055237,
0.21409961581230164,
0.628068208694458,
-0.17688803374767303,
-0.44055670499801636,
0.9394848942756653,
0.32293885946273804,
0.7077893018722534,
-0.16232699155807495,
0.20355774462223053,
0.37564295530319214,
0.2870730757713318,
-0.2477315217256546,
0.6918805241584778,
-0.000008701032129465602,
-0.8271148800849915,
-0.48396265506744385,
-0.2825917899608612,
-0.9060137271881104,
-0.2342892438173294,
-0.7803102731704712,
0.11231029778718948,
-0.2703671455383301,
-0.2031058818101883,
-0.012144391424953938,
0.15994563698768616,
-0.8076736927032471,
0.550980806350708,
-0.3936847448348999,
0.7961812019348145,
-0.9970934987068176,
0.9997841715812683,
0.4664621353149414,
-0.5815733075141907,
-0.7516216039657593,
-0.2829945385456085,
-0.04059388116002083,
-0.9823724031448364,
0.8706433176994324,
-0.2622830867767334,
0.0024499204009771347,
0.023348482325673103,
-0.5959020853042603,
-0.8698095083236694,
1.103311538696289,
0.4426913261413574,
-0.5567492842674255,
0.26042577624320984,
0.16674989461898804,
0.7001190185546875,
-0.040001604706048965,
0.5433914065361023,
0.8359127640724182,
0.5668675303459167,
-0.08466409891843796,
-0.7245877385139465,
0.19841277599334717,
-0.10239511728286743,
-0.2317909449338913,
0.09098862111568451,
-0.6653544306755066,
0.9578271508216858,
-0.19635874032974243,
-0.11998714506626129,
-0.007354205474257469,
0.779059112071991,
0.6094295382499695,
0.7048583626747131,
0.13604751229286194,
0.6450428366661072,
1.0492684841156006,
-0.04036782681941986,
1.0263268947601318,
-0.08814238756895065,
0.17456704378128052,
1.2105953693389893,
-0.766893208026886,
0.9087087512016296,
0.18963272869586945,
-0.5576822757720947,
0.4625128209590912,
0.6938186287879944,
-0.14840909838676453,
0.4302729666233063,
0.3550708591938019,
-0.2705995738506317,
-0.34102439880371094,
0.029320739209651947,
-0.39940252900123596,
0.24903523921966553,
0.3001221716403961,
0.10342194139957428,
-0.09800820052623749,
-0.23572902381420135,
-0.05662401020526886,
0.14081014692783356,
-0.2381495237350464,
0.6324005722999573,
0.25353291630744934,
-0.3991294503211975,
0.6214776635169983,
-0.21753661334514618,
0.049140576273202896,
-0.5405824780464172,
-0.11231876164674759,
-0.4198375940322876,
0.1520056426525116,
-0.08303122222423553,
-0.9352833032608032,
0.24183611571788788,
0.23850026726722717,
-0.037946928292512894,
-0.0090572414919734,
0.7508503794670105,
-0.2763831317424774,
-0.5091103911399841,
0.21624553203582764,
0.9832767844200134,
0.3601953685283661,
-0.13361236453056335,
-0.630469024181366,
0.05880172550678253,
-0.26680272817611694,
-0.10888539254665375,
0.2624412178993225,
0.6696873307228088,
-0.3895375430583954,
1.1147794723510742,
0.6417341232299805,
0.18034537136554718,
0.07646859437227249,
0.45951321721076965,
0.9606042504310608,
-1.0345337390899658,
-0.3225681483745575,
-0.8793163895606995,
0.12386023998260498,
0.06130627170205116,
-0.26348018646240234,
0.9249058961868286,
0.7053532004356384,
0.5495796203613281,
0.11443173140287399,
0.6672884225845337,
0.4275611340999603,
0.7115698456764221,
-0.8150890469551086,
0.49030131101608276,
-0.33568546175956726,
0.2181083858013153,
-0.15767517685890198,
-0.7833667397499084,
-0.30808958411216736,
0.42636966705322266,
-0.7331083416938782,
0.21060054004192352,
0.7653136849403381,
0.7354071140289307,
0.1355954259634018,
0.001865991740487516,
0.48647746443748474,
0.18547844886779785,
0.33222293853759766,
0.6277446746826172,
1.2287895679473877,
-0.27125880122184753,
0.3700466752052307,
0.036886606365442276,
-0.24099184572696686,
-0.026130134239792824,
-0.8631131649017334,
-0.8739767074584961,
-0.34624749422073364,
-0.36731526255607605,
-0.14917981624603271,
0.41672444343566895,
0.5554730892181396,
0.435449481010437,
-0.5895029306411743,
-0.3860583007335663,
-0.19768160581588745,
0.3504139482975006,
-0.19042736291885376,
-0.2742643356323242,
0.5170773267745972,
-0.1580180674791336,
-0.28923019766807556,
0.4838380217552185,
0.22500185668468475,
-0.015012837015092373,
-0.29925665259361267,
0.09117518365383148,
-0.13193827867507935,
0.1357249766588211,
0.5245358943939209,
0.2817685902118683,
-0.3108019232749939,
-0.1513035148382187,
-0.007796377409249544,
-0.23656615614891052,
-0.12837433815002441,
0.9823142886161804,
-0.8218059539794922,
0.18878453969955444,
0.6566305756568909,
0.528207540512085,
0.43290194869041443,
0.1822395920753479,
0.6814966797828674,
-0.14401845633983612,
0.008394877426326275,
0.3300425708293915,
0.25763946771621704,
0.19826538860797882,
-0.2034374624490738,
0.805600106716156,
0.06817027926445007,
-0.8680297136306763,
-1.0382729768753052,
0.057296499609947205,
-0.7819855213165283,
-0.3097839951515198,
1.1416481733322144,
-0.11947543919086456,
-0.12152882665395737,
-0.3082348704338074,
-0.03479081019759178,
0.2913590967655182,
-0.16944564878940582,
0.5642823576927185,
0.487387478351593,
-0.27526286244392395,
-0.22899115085601807,
-1.1006048917770386,
0.44400179386138916,
0.39172083139419556,
-1.3296579122543335,
0.13015475869178772,
0.6135939955711365,
0.1454877108335495,
-0.6765626072883606,
0.7891271114349365,
0.07967038452625275,
0.46260571479797363,
0.22522477805614471,
0.027325669303536415,
0.1294950246810913,
-0.389434278011322,
-0.3071703314781189,
-0.10320927947759628,
0.0672101378440857,
0.06964967399835587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17641v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17641v2
|
Variational Learning is Effective for Large Deep Networks
| 2024-02-27T16:11:05 | 2024-06-06T04:31:43 |
Yuesong Shen, Nico Daheim, Bai Cong, Peter Nickl, Gian Maria Marconi, Clement Bazan, Rio Yokota, Iryna Gurevych, Daniel Cremers, Mohammad Emtiyaz Khan, Thomas Möllenhoff
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.OC, stat.ML
|
We give extensive empirical evidence against the common belief that
variational learning is ineffective for large neural networks. We show that an
optimizer called Improved Variational Online Newton (IVON) consistently matches
or outperforms Adam for training large networks such as GPT-2 and ResNets from
scratch. IVON's computational costs are nearly identical to Adam but its
predictive uncertainty is better. We show several new use cases of IVON where
we improve finetuning and model merging in Large Language Models, accurately
predict generalization error, and faithfully estimate sensitivity to data. We
find overwhelming evidence that variational learning is effective.
|
[
-0.366393119096756,
-0.4334031939506531,
0.37661054730415344,
-0.028685007244348526,
-0.1893891841173172,
0.355747789144516,
-0.5097125768661499,
-0.5737606287002563,
0.08818434178829193,
-0.13379837572574615,
-0.07273780554533005,
-0.19138313829898834,
-0.5625623464584351,
0.15142719447612762,
-0.4012053310871124,
0.6629154086112976,
0.06292107701301575,
0.4596169590950012,
-0.14549677073955536,
-0.1594255417585373,
0.20813782513141632,
0.0027371584437787533,
-1.1005030870437622,
-0.48425841331481934,
0.9339432716369629,
-0.15820547938346863,
0.6339555978775024,
0.523948609828949,
0.6172261834144592,
0.3493448793888092,
-0.4611870050430298,
0.3668825626373291,
-0.6008942127227783,
0.15796056389808655,
-0.15775279700756073,
-0.6467946171760559,
0.04087105765938759,
-0.5186814069747925,
0.8631592988967896,
0.9492924213409424,
-0.5079492926597595,
-0.5045130252838135,
0.19049464166164398,
0.8459336161613464,
-0.5588043332099915,
-0.24987249076366425,
-0.694329023361206,
0.34364208579063416,
-0.11787217110395432,
0.42339351773262024,
-0.020484652370214462,
-0.44951891899108887,
0.3175401985645294,
-0.811438262462616,
0.3063110113143921,
-0.043994925916194916,
0.8428179621696472,
0.24744519591331482,
-0.4151805341243744,
-0.01722990721464157,
-0.965027391910553,
0.8801237344741821,
-0.8142092823982239,
0.333955317735672,
0.3927011489868164,
0.35399019718170166,
-0.31018945574760437,
-0.8514133095741272,
-0.33534085750579834,
-0.5910030603408813,
0.39581191539764404,
0.26393646001815796,
-0.06820103526115417,
0.4672182500362396,
0.393137663602829,
0.8151965737342834,
-0.3977322578430176,
0.39834195375442505,
-0.4123091399669647,
0.030971400439739227,
0.5413171648979187,
-0.061217520385980606,
0.0839020386338234,
0.4462951421737671,
-0.2293727546930313,
-0.13786467909812927,
-0.7780691385269165,
0.13798829913139343,
0.7956496477127075,
0.20543180406093597,
0.0465131439268589,
0.35894906520843506,
0.09139402955770493,
0.7246501445770264,
0.1273244172334671,
0.07051298767328262,
0.19487076997756958,
0.10937244445085526,
-0.2529388666152954,
-0.3924834728240967,
0.7320626974105835,
0.08444447070360184,
-0.10223892331123352,
-0.3721112012863159,
-0.34870219230651855,
-0.4864514470100403,
0.26136720180511475,
-0.7851273417472839,
-0.274508535861969,
0.16452272236347198,
-0.26193293929100037,
-0.2182885706424713,
0.1802278608083725,
-0.47181233763694763,
-0.5666020512580872,
-0.40787073969841003,
0.14232823252677917,
-0.4794800579547882,
-0.19514422118663788,
-0.13641729950904846,
-0.052556250244379044,
0.12021935731172562,
0.5457705855369568,
-0.9129656553268433,
0.3527602255344391,
0.7291295528411865,
1.0275988578796387,
-0.4085945785045624,
-0.21655820310115814,
-0.443177193403244,
-0.4438059628009796,
-0.7854340076446533,
0.47171738743782043,
-0.26514095067977905,
-0.07299574464559555,
0.040998611599206924,
-0.25123631954193115,
-0.03963364660739899,
-0.767421543598175,
0.3076184093952179,
-0.6045638918876648,
-0.09715433418750763,
-0.05516352131962776,
-0.9420320987701416,
-0.3309229910373688,
0.28381434082984924,
-0.8426305651664734,
0.6358701586723328,
0.26610222458839417,
-0.5369336605072021,
0.42246437072753906,
-0.5586276650428772,
-0.5292043685913086,
-0.05532911792397499,
-0.29387542605400085,
-0.71978759765625,
0.3555600345134735,
-0.04030809551477432,
0.2475440502166748,
-0.5075701475143433,
0.31781989336013794,
-0.5254177451133728,
-0.38472437858581543,
0.37335777282714844,
-0.5456470847129822,
0.6876165866851807,
0.537766695022583,
-0.6287196278572083,
-0.003258266020566225,
-0.706087052822113,
-0.23684121668338776,
0.02924368530511856,
-0.6300767064094543,
-0.08400198817253113,
0.20777177810668945,
-0.25220346450805664,
-0.20301009714603424,
-0.16543152928352356,
-0.6000720858573914,
0.09038905799388885,
-0.8719577789306641,
0.4242839217185974,
0.6414544582366943,
-0.3260166347026825,
0.36339133977890015,
-0.3249845802783966,
0.6311668753623962,
-0.1805156171321869,
-0.14937154948711395,
0.26462963223457336,
-0.498973548412323,
-0.6026999950408936,
-0.017998764291405678,
0.9211483001708984,
0.27873629331588745,
-0.6426457166671753,
0.5282880663871765,
-0.06294135749340057,
-0.31794339418411255,
-0.08844604343175888,
0.035843707621097565,
0.2966988682746887,
0.09637650102376938,
0.1624089479446411,
-0.4828283190727234,
-0.35207557678222656,
-0.7848625183105469,
-0.3250904083251953,
0.1468244194984436,
-0.27198418974876404,
0.6608472466468811,
0.19414596259593964,
-0.15783625841140747,
0.44763752818107605,
-0.01657971367239952,
0.2440822273492813,
-0.011514989659190178,
0.4864385724067688,
0.16899943351745605,
0.6038859486579895,
0.47623246908187866,
-0.9472550749778748,
-0.6042523980140686,
0.41203439235687256,
-0.636266827583313,
0.5072246789932251,
-0.14670683443546295,
0.46878781914711,
0.042985133826732635,
0.32508552074432373,
-0.26544809341430664,
0.45670560002326965,
0.4664718806743622,
0.31009921431541443,
0.14578726887702942,
-0.2656834125518799,
-0.0026008395943790674,
-1.1001863479614258,
-0.03485092893242836,
0.07123296707868576,
-0.6619224548339844,
-0.2628958821296692,
0.11468036472797394,
-0.11015937477350235,
-0.15518949925899506,
-0.4881075322628021,
-0.06991640478372574,
-0.3582828640937805,
-0.12769906222820282,
-0.2580370604991913,
-0.11723308265209198,
-0.2002566009759903,
0.08009110391139984,
-0.38939136266708374,
1.0622498989105225,
0.6896102428436279,
-0.39287856221199036,
0.7234826683998108,
-0.02133994549512863,
-0.5597299933433533,
0.11045226454734802,
-0.7108616232872009,
0.2325650006532669,
-0.30732548236846924,
0.22439326345920563,
-0.9536734223365784,
-0.41977596282958984,
0.04762014374136925,
-0.26126256585121155,
0.8109011650085449,
-0.16268058121204376,
0.22268147766590118,
-0.41938793659210205,
-0.38012024760246277,
0.40972641110420227,
0.43948137760162354,
-0.7350726127624512,
0.9066394567489624,
-0.03727450594305992,
0.1664341688156128,
-0.9622735977172852,
-0.8890613913536072,
0.11546003073453903,
-0.1671149581670761,
-0.27313661575317383,
0.21915161609649658,
-0.15920381247997284,
-0.09606573730707169,
0.017155511304736137,
-0.15825210511684418,
-0.22428171336650848,
0.30222147703170776,
0.09271717816591263,
-0.20908094942569733,
-0.5652749538421631,
0.22500763833522797,
-0.12931205332279205,
0.04813616722822189,
-0.11470773071050644,
-0.6275867223739624,
0.39520516991615295,
-0.24189960956573486,
-0.338044136762619,
-0.48548418283462524,
0.24668554961681366,
0.38766518235206604,
0.06979408115148544,
0.9166470766067505,
0.6228684782981873,
-0.4723343849182129,
-0.22638021409511566,
-0.41255074739456177,
-0.15522198379039764,
-0.4379582107067108,
0.577748715877533,
-0.39380136132240295,
-0.9290640950202942,
0.6499128937721252,
-0.6168868541717529,
-0.25095856189727783,
0.7902147173881531,
-0.016361424699425697,
-0.12716780602931976,
0.9335976839065552,
0.4210359454154968,
0.054953962564468384,
0.5778001546859741,
-0.6491715908050537,
0.07186667621135712,
-0.988211452960968,
-0.06174415349960327,
-0.24746344983577728,
-0.45039358735084534,
-0.8107618093490601,
0.10313418507575989,
0.03202584385871887,
0.3277372717857361,
-0.3478727340698242,
0.2502080798149109,
-0.38026973605155945,
0.9034255743026733,
0.5963149070739746,
0.3048543334007263,
-0.3721274137496948,
0.10151051729917526,
-0.14789026975631714,
0.14692921936511993,
-0.72650146484375,
-0.0063289497047662735,
1.3468245267868042,
0.3443320393562317,
0.9317681789398193,
0.23551227152347565,
0.5632847547531128,
0.13212034106254578,
0.1948079913854599,
-0.7590150237083435,
-0.0016835627611726522,
-0.466915488243103,
-0.6880351305007935,
-0.5772538781166077,
-0.755669355392456,
-1.2050203084945679,
0.14510440826416016,
-0.34691113233566284,
-0.7700583934783936,
0.4824003577232361,
0.29081258177757263,
-0.6920552253723145,
0.8424642086029053,
-0.5844544172286987,
0.49632692337036133,
-0.2075796127319336,
-0.4660753309726715,
-0.2460271716117859,
-0.880098283290863,
0.17338557541370392,
-0.20761534571647644,
-0.2469569444656372,
0.03754013776779175,
-0.10664084553718567,
0.6219339966773987,
-0.4601230323314667,
0.8000099658966064,
-0.06415493041276932,
0.07433116436004639,
0.2580847144126892,
0.05359235405921936,
0.6813134551048279,
0.1390542834997177,
-0.32135048508644104,
0.23623666167259216,
-0.6155904531478882,
-0.35808852314949036,
-0.6636515855789185,
0.6834661960601807,
-0.9685646891593933,
-0.3172522485256195,
-0.3902254104614258,
-0.328117311000824,
0.03023441880941391,
0.06639622896909714,
0.7051377892494202,
0.7009672522544861,
-0.22000408172607422,
0.6936259865760803,
0.8586437702178955,
0.03698641434311867,
0.4563078284263611,
-0.17420589923858643,
-0.021188262850046158,
-0.8761111497879028,
0.9228166341781616,
0.22673285007476807,
0.3796248137950897,
0.466866135597229,
0.465930312871933,
-0.008638575673103333,
-0.9127634763717651,
-0.49811187386512756,
-0.1655752807855606,
-0.7049740552902222,
-0.31814464926719666,
-0.32234105467796326,
-0.3711405396461487,
0.08959892392158508,
-0.16707712411880493,
-0.6525058150291443,
-0.4754849970340729,
-0.2813541293144226,
-0.008250538259744644,
0.030721260234713554,
1.0596277713775635,
-0.3736835718154907,
0.4391026794910431,
-0.3492783010005951,
-0.02481084130704403,
0.6991488933563232,
0.4261297881603241,
0.11491668224334717,
-0.47326430678367615,
-0.27485960721969604,
0.13751520216464996,
-0.33122333884239197,
-0.37247616052627563,
-0.094068244099617,
0.6170302629470825,
0.5121583938598633,
0.7885069251060486,
-0.29706355929374695,
0.18062403798103333,
-0.516011655330658,
0.861002504825592,
0.5585293173789978,
-0.826336145401001,
0.18200962245464325,
-0.4383150041103363,
0.01021328940987587,
0.5505030155181885,
0.6597802042961121,
-0.05608798563480377,
-0.05128766596317291,
-0.7066466808319092,
-1.0715941190719604,
0.5943444967269897,
0.3712689280509949,
0.19332881271839142,
0.3220270276069641,
0.6570865511894226,
0.29923388361930847,
0.33147192001342773,
-0.6584870219230652,
-0.4177533984184265,
-0.0574239045381546,
-0.12839221954345703,
-0.14258527755737305,
-0.11874420940876007,
-0.291098415851593,
-0.5595583319664001,
0.690715491771698,
-0.15199027955532074,
0.5022572875022888,
0.153402179479599,
0.2161286324262619,
-0.24383975565433502,
-0.09383214265108109,
0.9417030811309814,
1.0793110132217407,
-0.19828511774539948,
0.27188217639923096,
0.7174620032310486,
-0.36849603056907654,
0.21115757524967194,
0.3491145372390747,
-0.19347386062145233,
-0.2409346103668213,
0.39790958166122437,
1.017366647720337,
-0.1275629848241806,
-0.2880985736846924,
0.764549732208252,
-0.25986266136169434,
-0.4862176477909088,
-0.5340613722801208,
0.28569358587265015,
0.005732829682528973,
0.33450961112976074,
0.21412016451358795,
0.5571994781494141,
0.28068315982818604,
-0.2013951539993286,
0.14757026731967926,
0.33545398712158203,
-0.5628740787506104,
-0.19895127415657043,
0.7074726819992065,
0.09365426003932953,
-0.5387097001075745,
0.31343117356300354,
-0.34144628047943115,
-0.549418032169342,
0.8932121992111206,
0.7694842219352722,
0.9842950701713562,
-0.35677996277809143,
0.0345405675470829,
0.28680819272994995,
0.04930473491549492,
-0.12051910161972046,
0.10764746367931366,
-0.07065608352422714,
-0.6597714424133301,
-0.7637702822685242,
-0.26117613911628723,
-0.6512215733528137,
0.28651922941207886,
-0.3930877149105072,
-0.16126799583435059,
-0.7368770241737366,
-0.18900932371616364,
0.35879844427108765,
-0.21268439292907715,
-0.6498861312866211,
0.451469361782074,
0.006456564646214247,
0.4359727203845978,
-0.3874686360359192,
0.4037976861000061,
0.7119835615158081,
-0.30064359307289124,
-0.9982374310493469,
0.14263269305229187,
-0.19822663068771362,
-0.5755722522735596,
0.4201827347278595,
0.22759094834327698,
-0.17852367460727692,
-0.1549765169620514,
-0.8934564590454102,
-0.971520185470581,
0.8518669009208679,
0.6528496146202087,
-1.003689169883728,
0.47776174545288086,
-0.09820841997861862,
0.4278932511806488,
-0.3384990692138672,
0.43388059735298157,
0.08540879935026169,
0.16325296461582184,
0.34380799531936646,
-0.543672502040863,
-0.30337387323379517,
-0.12869171798229218,
0.24705612659454346,
0.47675296664237976,
-0.7747135758399963,
0.9499186873435974,
-0.050208400934934616,
0.07599037885665894,
0.19760610163211823,
0.6400845646858215,
-0.5557315945625305,
0.20116661489009857,
0.6571539640426636,
0.7827873229980469,
1.1616501808166504,
-0.1292860358953476,
1.2507275342941284,
0.009443276561796665,
0.5434989929199219,
0.9143843650817871,
-0.16437652707099915,
0.583894670009613,
0.0652000680565834,
-0.598059892654419,
0.4567943811416626,
0.8375276923179626,
0.06279923766851425,
0.5295482873916626,
0.6446588039398193,
-0.54843670129776,
-0.42147889733314514,
0.16725720465183258,
-0.5047485828399658,
0.09659052640199661,
0.17480529844760895,
-0.33553245663642883,
0.07705509662628174,
0.328819215297699,
-0.14153994619846344,
-0.09008394926786423,
-0.20083248615264893,
0.8723720908164978,
0.125668004155159,
-0.24552039802074432,
0.725507378578186,
-0.1350003182888031,
0.5774616003036499,
-0.4276098310947418,
0.2709484100341797,
-0.2457531988620758,
0.39141377806663513,
-0.09522689878940582,
-0.32033810019493103,
0.06451794505119324,
-0.45413029193878174,
0.10373903065919876,
0.6052587032318115,
0.6777807474136353,
-0.3438822329044342,
-0.3888545334339142,
0.15005426108837128,
0.09489914029836655,
0.32960888743400574,
0.012282120995223522,
-0.6245336532592773,
-0.41893312335014343,
-0.022002212703227997,
-0.3361866772174835,
0.15940099954605103,
0.278687983751297,
0.4338446259498596,
0.5945753455162048,
0.6436587572097778,
0.1871139109134674,
-0.1668635606765747,
0.12072964012622833,
1.0224183797836304,
-0.3660999834537506,
-0.3615645170211792,
-0.70735102891922,
0.3436955511569977,
-0.5046603083610535,
-0.5632258653640747,
0.23781797289848328,
0.7176759243011475,
0.8217628002166748,
0.27685028314590454,
0.6714703440666199,
0.17202609777450562,
0.3421570062637329,
-0.5187422037124634,
0.5626950263977051,
-0.8006055951118469,
0.14784008264541626,
0.271186888217926,
-1.2339423894882202,
-0.7799822092056274,
0.8520182967185974,
-0.23811089992523193,
0.38413774967193604,
0.8500261306762695,
0.5012185573577881,
-0.46979013085365295,
0.24491840600967407,
0.5232349634170532,
-0.010246897116303444,
0.336646169424057,
0.2915068566799164,
1.0098106861114502,
-0.48995816707611084,
0.22255364060401917,
-0.2791166305541992,
-0.29541105031967163,
-0.22801005840301514,
-0.9456053972244263,
-1.0861897468566895,
-0.36594918370246887,
-0.27085164189338684,
-0.5026414394378662,
0.42394933104515076,
1.2910454273223877,
0.842978298664093,
-1.1842297315597534,
0.10543588548898697,
-0.7748969793319702,
0.05513294041156769,
-0.3062302768230438,
-0.06773747503757477,
0.5053207874298096,
-0.40669891238212585,
-0.5494263172149658,
0.6254778504371643,
0.002384145511314273,
0.2632525563240051,
-0.07492031157016754,
-0.23818108439445496,
-0.13400539755821228,
0.04679931700229645,
0.27746057510375977,
0.5033647418022156,
-0.6591311097145081,
-0.3616500496864319,
-0.20833629369735718,
-0.01701817847788334,
0.3625781536102295,
0.786709725856781,
-0.23302224278450012,
0.6509851813316345,
0.336320161819458,
1.279612421989441,
0.8399831056594849,
-0.024416759610176086,
0.6510648131370544,
-0.5198532342910767,
0.07171208411455154,
0.4087575376033783,
0.4788596034049988,
0.5315229892730713,
-0.41885724663734436,
0.728399395942688,
0.294849693775177,
-0.8822018504142761,
-0.43053436279296875,
0.20729142427444458,
-0.5599389672279358,
-0.1569562405347824,
1.0571683645248413,
-0.5424847602844238,
-0.2880839705467224,
-0.013271227478981018,
-0.04215901345014572,
0.22745215892791748,
-0.4286479949951172,
0.7118672728538513,
0.5069892406463623,
-0.07978008687496185,
0.14197823405265808,
-0.42510029673576355,
0.5587591528892517,
0.7267480492591858,
-0.6238442659378052,
-0.39834263920783997,
0.11172059923410416,
0.11651694029569626,
0.2043740600347519,
-0.13943226635456085,
0.419342964887619,
0.19174858927726746,
0.12491326034069061,
-0.0027683330699801445,
-0.12981976568698883,
-0.454228013753891,
-0.8074796199798584,
-0.04442787170410156,
0.32426121830940247,
-0.2606201767921448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17633v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17633v1
|
From Text Segmentation to Smart Chaptering: A Novel Benchmark for Structuring Video Transcriptions
| 2024-02-27T15:59:37 | 2024-02-27T15:59:37 |
Fabian Retkowski, Alexander Waibel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text segmentation is a fundamental task in natural language processing, where
documents are split into contiguous sections. However, prior research in this
area has been constrained by limited datasets, which are either small in scale,
synthesized, or only contain well-structured documents. In this paper, we
address these limitations by introducing a novel benchmark YTSeg focusing on
spoken content that is inherently more unstructured and both topically and
structurally diverse. As part of this work, we introduce an efficient
hierarchical segmentation model MiniSeg, that outperforms state-of-the-art
baselines. Lastly, we expand the notion of text segmentation to a more
practical "smart chaptering" task that involves the segmentation of
unstructured content, the generation of meaningful segment titles, and a
potential real-time application of the models.
|
[
-0.19160108268260956,
-0.8134215474128723,
0.34319278597831726,
-0.019957223907113075,
-0.7306784391403198,
0.15396146476268768,
-0.0815533772110939,
-0.3854205310344696,
0.11103666573762894,
0.5388258099555969,
-0.8315196633338928,
-0.7375747561454773,
-0.45614537596702576,
0.1312302052974701,
-0.6765623688697815,
0.9326762557029724,
0.44845810532569885,
0.04571621119976044,
-0.17344696819782257,
-0.37304726243019104,
-0.4521447718143463,
-0.22451184689998627,
-0.24034541845321655,
0.030920889228582382,
0.1859973818063736,
0.41493600606918335,
0.5103034377098083,
1.4088094234466553,
0.46300598978996277,
0.3480033278465271,
-0.20448662340641022,
0.28727850317955017,
0.030557572841644287,
0.45517581701278687,
0.04243519529700279,
-0.37766292691230774,
-0.06559500843286514,
-0.24464865028858185,
0.9562569260597229,
0.8012540340423584,
0.04735076054930687,
0.14747653901576996,
-0.1432419866323471,
0.7591033577919006,
-0.36265453696250916,
-0.033677808940410614,
-0.5329663157463074,
0.1954025775194168,
-0.24841183423995972,
-0.1819525957107544,
-0.3247011601924896,
-0.44342201948165894,
0.32744893431663513,
-0.3656955063343048,
0.4896186590194702,
-0.12576134502887726,
0.6877066493034363,
0.42146918177604675,
-0.4482472836971283,
-0.08983006328344345,
-0.681452214717865,
0.7464529871940613,
-0.5457008481025696,
0.7499224543571472,
0.13016335666179657,
0.34237784147262573,
0.12312201410531998,
-1.034280776977539,
-0.2240409255027771,
0.10762079060077667,
0.22646598517894745,
-0.27193745970726013,
-0.06728008389472961,
0.17642343044281006,
0.12774690985679626,
0.5455285310745239,
-0.6177076101303101,
-0.08118325471878052,
-0.22020062804222107,
-0.2707447111606598,
0.2704329788684845,
0.17412027716636658,
0.6292333006858826,
-0.45322856307029724,
-0.2919580340385437,
-0.23001907765865326,
-0.12178820371627808,
0.05061408877372742,
0.3638702929019928,
0.38505440950393677,
0.16217859089374542,
0.559661865234375,
-0.1244271993637085,
0.6839873790740967,
-0.11001955717802048,
-0.612504243850708,
0.012427356094121933,
-0.43990781903266907,
-0.4728587567806244,
0.15103015303611755,
0.8792750835418701,
0.4714933931827545,
0.08014927804470062,
-0.13243180513381958,
-0.06473053246736526,
-0.06400284916162491,
0.5103343725204468,
-1.0072306394577026,
-0.39967113733291626,
-0.1071130707859993,
-0.5780308246612549,
-0.0983797162771225,
0.08091377466917038,
-0.9519974589347839,
-0.2849369943141937,
-0.3211170732975006,
0.15208375453948975,
-0.5588506460189819,
0.4635831117630005,
-0.02936847135424614,
-0.12882758677005768,
-0.014071683399379253,
0.22822299599647522,
-1.110921859741211,
0.6750862002372742,
0.7416641712188721,
1.1233505010604858,
-0.38926446437835693,
0.05538887903094292,
-0.695492684841156,
0.09799102693796158,
-0.19825974106788635,
1.0696353912353516,
-0.3644304871559143,
-0.36252561211586,
0.023152252659201622,
-0.0798824355006218,
-0.021294860169291496,
-0.6171758770942688,
0.6123312711715698,
-0.40726497769355774,
0.22111567854881287,
-0.08558064699172974,
-0.5129167437553406,
-0.15533897280693054,
0.35141998529434204,
-0.794134795665741,
1.1264586448669434,
-0.002463334007188678,
-0.570568323135376,
0.43520915508270264,
-0.26987406611442566,
-0.6374239921569824,
0.03816619887948036,
-0.4609788954257965,
-0.5890288949012756,
0.07747344672679901,
0.4091343581676483,
0.21239358186721802,
-0.5296704769134521,
0.2988341152667999,
0.09402868896722794,
-0.0503273643553257,
0.17551755905151367,
-0.5176045894622803,
0.25580453872680664,
0.04910498112440109,
-0.19203002750873566,
0.2836623191833496,
-0.8990465998649597,
0.1928035169839859,
-0.16958951950073242,
-0.09937320649623871,
-0.496418297290802,
0.217038094997406,
0.42323240637779236,
-0.14186714589595795,
0.08106143027544022,
-0.4944452941417694,
0.41660335659980774,
-0.29790225625038147,
0.5511309504508972,
0.4205375611782074,
0.2520752251148224,
0.6788674592971802,
-0.1603439897298813,
0.23971182107925415,
-0.27292943000793457,
0.2081805020570755,
-0.4690362513065338,
-0.23947489261627197,
-0.5314842462539673,
-0.7330571413040161,
0.2504412829875946,
0.3163559138774872,
-0.569959282875061,
0.38800638914108276,
-0.316952109336853,
-0.6290684938430786,
-0.30689507722854614,
0.031417202204465866,
0.500713050365448,
0.6035604476928711,
0.5648188591003418,
-0.5811894536018372,
-0.6449373364448547,
-1.1375834941864014,
-0.36819708347320557,
-0.1515740305185318,
-0.06410620361566544,
0.042111836373806,
0.20648404955863953,
-0.36867544054985046,
1.0504975318908691,
-0.8351144790649414,
-0.5913976430892944,
-0.4319770634174347,
0.542609691619873,
0.02364903688430786,
0.4408513307571411,
0.3016650080680847,
-1.040306806564331,
-0.5366334915161133,
-0.06147743761539459,
-0.5574354529380798,
-0.04953612759709358,
-0.21367250382900238,
0.3604545295238495,
-0.19551712274551392,
0.7824511528015137,
-0.38890281319618225,
0.28719383478164673,
0.20777703821659088,
-0.10516887158155441,
0.4408313035964966,
-0.45268797874450684,
0.2681424617767334,
-0.9266088604927063,
-0.2477819174528122,
0.013479040004312992,
-0.3933393359184265,
-0.7130783200263977,
-0.14686773717403412,
0.08935649693012238,
-0.09871002286672592,
-0.3927176296710968,
0.1422865390777588,
-0.2833435833454132,
-0.42099475860595703,
-0.23484468460083008,
0.0018163213972002268,
-0.07839605957269669,
0.6231485605239868,
0.15264809131622314,
0.6686905026435852,
0.2910016179084778,
-0.5182088613510132,
0.03227127715945244,
0.517228901386261,
-0.7873278260231018,
0.4208146035671234,
-0.6712011694908142,
0.07368911802768707,
-0.020887337625026703,
0.19181224703788757,
-0.9093059301376343,
-0.3319617211818695,
-0.13047944009304047,
-0.1906479150056839,
0.08997263014316559,
-0.24813660979270935,
-0.6610472798347473,
0.14829307794570923,
-0.41996124386787415,
0.8891105055809021,
0.4158848226070404,
-0.17735767364501953,
0.5021778345108032,
0.7558325529098511,
-0.4979485273361206,
-0.15766775608062744,
-0.7031587362289429,
0.05704101175069809,
-0.2281481921672821,
-0.6687452793121338,
0.8388451337814331,
-0.06507766991853714,
-0.20647522807121277,
-0.05362512171268463,
-0.5554845333099365,
-0.6356174945831299,
-0.31345149874687195,
0.1897604614496231,
0.07444020360708237,
-0.2872692048549652,
0.0011694831773638725,
0.2419223040342331,
-0.07236999273300171,
-0.3522411584854126,
-0.6138224005699158,
0.36525988578796387,
-0.018844209611415863,
-0.24677512049674988,
-0.4609474241733551,
0.5449535250663757,
0.6943753361701965,
-0.2843799591064453,
0.3385958969593048,
0.3097415864467621,
-0.48103001713752747,
-0.5711727142333984,
-0.3477965295314789,
-0.026573477312922478,
-0.4811164140701294,
0.5755247473716736,
0.033622097223997116,
-1.0528243780136108,
0.31969037652015686,
0.09700143337249756,
0.1463511884212494,
0.35542407631874084,
0.2966639995574951,
-0.09093267470598221,
0.9182572364807129,
0.8871092200279236,
-0.005372980143874884,
0.758592426776886,
-0.05087090656161308,
0.12061047554016113,
-0.46389615535736084,
-0.31900492310523987,
-0.8388428092002869,
-0.17985884845256805,
-0.8463852405548096,
-0.7551632523536682,
0.5643678307533264,
-0.08814288675785065,
0.127934992313385,
0.6563109755516052,
-0.5430042743682861,
0.6556942462921143,
0.4411802291870117,
-0.09541867673397064,
0.3895786702632904,
-0.054503314197063446,
-0.10434305667877197,
-0.3909102976322174,
-0.6582921147346497,
-0.5665112733840942,
0.5842453837394714,
0.32333001494407654,
0.4134153127670288,
-0.09545740485191345,
0.582985520362854,
0.8084855079650879,
0.07876168191432953,
-1.0690193176269531,
0.710180938243866,
-0.6120781898498535,
-0.3210945427417755,
-0.599480926990509,
-0.3734109103679657,
-0.7591072916984558,
0.5124689340591431,
0.07926911115646362,
-0.9201918840408325,
0.04586665332317352,
-0.09158352762460709,
-0.4248327910900116,
0.3817438781261444,
-0.519982099533081,
0.9247101545333862,
-0.08353474736213684,
-0.12176473438739777,
0.04184509068727493,
-0.7021237015724182,
-0.03240276873111725,
0.041565120220184326,
0.5149439573287964,
-0.029283901676535606,
0.019553132355213165,
1.1506609916687012,
-0.8087053298950195,
0.481552392244339,
-0.007070562336593866,
0.15464822947978973,
0.6689227819442749,
0.015941189602017403,
0.22256766259670258,
-0.052385956048965454,
0.17099185287952423,
-0.2603274881839752,
0.28296172618865967,
-0.07209194451570511,
-0.5919928550720215,
0.27845796942710876,
-0.5067216753959656,
-0.11681132018566132,
-0.38510966300964355,
-0.40665361285209656,
-0.5149388313293457,
0.4741295278072357,
0.2642829120159149,
0.8124523758888245,
-0.5466136932373047,
0.5551281571388245,
0.9440369009971619,
-0.10492745786905289,
0.5096668601036072,
0.18298807740211487,
0.21043896675109863,
-0.7103622555732727,
0.8595250844955444,
0.015667326748371124,
-0.08394160121679306,
0.9101910591125488,
0.2313767820596695,
-0.5075277090072632,
-0.8613147139549255,
-0.39911362528800964,
0.045202117413282394,
-0.7585487365722656,
-0.0989626944065094,
-0.7263460159301758,
-0.040849778801202774,
-0.4205232560634613,
-0.10585705190896988,
-0.859902560710907,
-0.28761300444602966,
-0.08948483318090439,
-0.270008385181427,
-0.21425218880176544,
0.6230235695838928,
0.2526414096355438,
0.4753446578979492,
-1.2564125061035156,
0.7488583326339722,
0.6338281035423279,
0.2557668089866638,
-0.28513428568840027,
-0.468381404876709,
-0.3961714208126068,
-0.4057781994342804,
-0.23620758950710297,
-0.8005428314208984,
0.3941120207309723,
0.24024826288223267,
0.41484853625297546,
0.36540162563323975,
0.1458863914012909,
0.6682868003845215,
-0.7490934133529663,
0.8394623398780823,
0.3021616041660309,
-0.9858234524726868,
0.3199933171272278,
-0.6109922528266907,
0.4867352545261383,
1.077589511871338,
0.018132930621504784,
-0.7555914521217346,
-0.13577844202518463,
-0.41296228766441345,
-1.0850387811660767,
0.6621348857879639,
0.29852643609046936,
-0.23027321696281433,
-0.10259763896465302,
-0.06314186006784439,
0.2967967987060547,
0.18753676116466522,
-0.7251673340797424,
-0.01265647355467081,
-0.033593930304050446,
-0.2441786378622055,
0.0941811203956604,
-0.2751273810863495,
0.10158565640449524,
-0.09689958393573761,
0.37898263335227966,
-0.18725454807281494,
0.17482352256774902,
0.34761351346969604,
-0.3552151322364807,
0.07867152988910675,
0.4671732485294342,
0.5495399236679077,
0.11904873698949814,
-0.2828220725059509,
0.2533644139766693,
-0.2045799344778061,
-0.7788186073303223,
0.2041352242231369,
-0.029137514531612396,
-0.33899596333503723,
0.16139978170394897,
0.869162917137146,
0.6522887945175171,
0.5250384211540222,
-0.8355292081832886,
0.37016475200653076,
-0.18486495316028595,
-0.28235501050949097,
0.10545753687620163,
-0.11242199689149857,
-0.31164318323135376,
0.20194193720817566,
0.5102041959762573,
0.045799002051353455,
0.32953906059265137,
-0.7349079251289368,
0.49002644419670105,
-0.02030722238123417,
-0.68840491771698,
-0.27901026606559753,
0.525363564491272,
0.3198283612728119,
-0.5037078261375427,
0.43167784810066223,
-0.04406880587339401,
-0.5203022956848145,
0.6779022216796875,
0.0701642706990242,
1.215788722038269,
0.192380890250206,
0.3901362419128418,
0.20735284686088562,
0.33769941329956055,
-0.2624286711215973,
0.024456443265080452,
-0.5166803598403931,
-0.23901991546154022,
-0.3993757665157318,
-0.6839618682861328,
-0.4221658706665039,
-0.0755891427397728,
-0.8320068120956421,
-0.09765064716339111,
-0.39385247230529785,
-0.1291014552116394,
0.12680979073047638,
-0.20916177332401276,
-0.36140885949134827,
0.7252122759819031,
-0.09167356789112091,
0.942401647567749,
-0.6810837984085083,
0.9466399550437927,
0.5173592567443848,
0.13727222383022308,
-0.5072162747383118,
0.34576281905174255,
0.0018342093098908663,
-0.11292026937007904,
0.32895541191101074,
0.38450077176094055,
-0.27191686630249023,
-0.3845391571521759,
-0.18882684409618378,
-0.37271350622177124,
0.9908738732337952,
0.14147715270519257,
-0.42037639021873474,
-0.2158311903476715,
0.4957858920097351,
0.7490530014038086,
-0.21150296926498413,
-0.09515548497438431,
0.5875469446182251,
0.22808104753494263,
0.11361492425203323,
-0.5555269122123718,
-0.37410467863082886,
-0.24282164871692657,
-0.07499995827674866,
0.3221345543861389,
-0.4601070284843445,
0.7023739814758301,
0.15081492066383362,
-0.30462419986724854,
0.16019998490810394,
0.925917387008667,
-0.15107998251914978,
0.5992400646209717,
0.7064381241798401,
0.34806206822395325,
0.7334938049316406,
-0.09433694183826447,
0.7976908087730408,
0.0938873291015625,
0.05374230444431305,
1.3692467212677002,
-0.011713046580553055,
0.5097362399101257,
0.46997883915901184,
-0.08356751501560211,
0.5287850499153137,
0.5025418996810913,
-0.02797326073050499,
0.9714095592498779,
-0.04233841598033905,
-0.12442423403263092,
-0.3147495985031128,
-0.41273072361946106,
-0.18362262845039368,
0.5839665532112122,
0.03027620166540146,
-0.2000655084848404,
-0.18107502162456512,
-0.15375971794128418,
-0.30885106325149536,
0.505459189414978,
-0.31321945786476135,
1.0530527830123901,
0.025727318599820137,
-0.8326706290245056,
-0.17539577186107635,
0.4314945340156555,
0.3995780646800995,
-0.913885772228241,
0.17198097705841064,
-0.22387345135211945,
0.002155332127586007,
-0.004033498000353575,
-0.5202184915542603,
0.49151110649108887,
0.3744020164012909,
-0.32269617915153503,
-0.5782999992370605,
0.7804184556007385,
-0.37105321884155273,
-0.2300584465265274,
0.08446396142244339,
0.3406118154525757,
-0.24472956359386444,
-0.13192829489707947,
-0.271345317363739,
0.06466418504714966,
0.105243019759655,
-0.14091555774211884,
0.42460837960243225,
0.7292065620422363,
-0.24986843764781952,
0.49359819293022156,
0.47454801201820374,
-0.20890112221240997,
-0.05550080165266991,
0.17380566895008087,
0.7276417016983032,
-0.8745259642601013,
-1.0667964220046997,
-0.897330105304718,
0.563270092010498,
-0.05826587975025177,
-0.4397912323474884,
0.761940598487854,
0.8904145359992981,
0.6775423288345337,
-0.17198528349399567,
0.7326705455780029,
0.093231201171875,
0.2134043425321579,
-0.5274786353111267,
0.44723841547966003,
-0.4891321361064911,
0.044128645211458206,
-0.6193250417709351,
-0.8586819767951965,
-0.2934456169605255,
0.3304985463619232,
-0.189561128616333,
-0.29337745904922485,
0.806491494178772,
0.426131010055542,
-0.09301246702671051,
0.23981794714927673,
0.2982780337333679,
-0.23119524121284485,
0.4020874798297882,
-0.021473869681358337,
0.5838935971260071,
-0.4191352427005768,
0.7473495006561279,
-0.3105429410934448,
-0.10187382251024246,
-0.13496509194374084,
-0.873738169670105,
-0.9854775667190552,
-0.7616685628890991,
-0.41360822319984436,
0.2702232897281647,
-0.09811078011989594,
0.9456503987312317,
0.9244576096534729,
-0.6988193988800049,
-0.30616340041160583,
-0.18224026262760162,
0.1585814356803894,
-0.39735451340675354,
-0.13388124108314514,
0.5033426880836487,
0.12937994301319122,
-0.6357557773590088,
0.7472137808799744,
0.6086757779121399,
0.035162266343832016,
0.20668520033359528,
0.08158933371305466,
-0.18431763350963593,
0.26058346033096313,
0.4764808714389801,
0.3994705080986023,
-0.060988135635852814,
-0.12667600810527802,
0.061442211270332336,
-0.25848257541656494,
0.22907675802707672,
1.3219512701034546,
-0.33362093567848206,
0.4094279408454895,
0.6730430722236633,
0.8310585618019104,
0.829623281955719,
0.29978957772254944,
0.3414749801158905,
-1.0918700695037842,
0.08083948493003845,
0.4048486053943634,
0.1773322969675064,
0.3848363161087036,
0.05263359844684601,
0.3746008276939392,
0.4447775185108185,
-0.2871338129043579,
-0.8386186957359314,
0.2063172310590744,
-1.3064825534820557,
-0.3863004446029663,
0.8356967568397522,
0.033480845391750336,
-0.2609175741672516,
-0.07322290539741516,
-0.3090669810771942,
0.48414790630340576,
-0.43441054224967957,
0.6324353218078613,
0.4994879961013794,
-0.13862037658691406,
-0.0800577774643898,
-0.32583045959472656,
0.5045294165611267,
0.40502724051475525,
-1.1446378231048584,
0.1085396334528923,
0.6184324026107788,
0.050812702625989914,
0.15504056215286255,
0.7027992606163025,
-0.07463423907756805,
0.27514076232910156,
0.11344737559556961,
-0.33400657773017883,
-0.2389817237854004,
-0.7757815718650818,
-0.09194405376911163,
0.6057937145233154,
-0.21418549120426178,
-0.3549550771713257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17630v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17630v1
|
Fine-Grained Natural Language Inference Based Faithfulness Evaluation for Diverse Summarisation Tasks
| 2024-02-27T15:57:11 | 2024-02-27T15:57:11 |
Huajian Zhang, Yumo Xu, Laura Perez-Beltrachini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We study existing approaches to leverage off-the-shelf Natural Language
Inference (NLI) models for the evaluation of summary faithfulness and argue
that these are sub-optimal due to the granularity level considered for premises
and hypotheses. That is, the smaller content unit considered as hypothesis is a
sentence and premises are made up of a fixed number of document sentences. We
propose a novel approach, namely InFusE, that uses a variable premise size and
simplifies summary sentences into shorter hypotheses. Departing from previous
studies which focus on single short document summarisation, we analyse NLI
based faithfulness evaluation for diverse summarisation tasks. We introduce
DiverSumm, a new benchmark comprising long form summarisation (long documents
and summaries) and diverse summarisation tasks (e.g., meeting and
multi-document summarisation). In experiments, InFusE obtains superior
performance across the different summarisation tasks. Our code and data are
available at https://github.com/HJZnlp/infuse.
|
[
-0.39111679792404175,
-0.6857917308807373,
0.441772997379303,
0.41203543543815613,
-0.5020469427108765,
0.03360721096396446,
-0.24121065437793732,
-0.4323209524154663,
0.34583884477615356,
0.5913825035095215,
-0.571309506893158,
-0.4287756681442261,
-0.4611833691596985,
0.42455095052719116,
-0.37610453367233276,
1.0597962141036987,
-0.0024042713921517134,
0.03437526896595955,
-0.7189804315567017,
-0.3770328164100647,
-0.24069124460220337,
-0.12804317474365234,
-0.22314199805259705,
-0.43039435148239136,
0.0008945677545852959,
0.36391371488571167,
0.6919428110122681,
0.21688608825206757,
0.724639356136322,
0.1954566240310669,
-0.2847231328487396,
0.6965777277946472,
-0.5967772603034973,
-0.011140907183289528,
-0.26081857085227966,
-0.4975290894508362,
-0.2955077290534973,
-0.049621544778347015,
0.7107239365577698,
0.9087581634521484,
0.004968808498233557,
0.1644158959388733,
0.5050786137580872,
0.7194052338600159,
-0.9434008598327637,
-0.12020247429609299,
-0.4682101011276245,
-0.1467159241437912,
-0.02669503167271614,
0.031356193125247955,
-0.4512367844581604,
-0.48171451687812805,
0.3488650321960449,
-0.5100001692771912,
0.3744029104709625,
-0.016492627561092377,
1.0078411102294922,
0.24424132704734802,
-0.13629871606826782,
-0.41716980934143066,
-0.4887041747570038,
1.0111780166625977,
-1.3171334266662598,
0.1851157695055008,
0.4423215091228485,
0.13580523431301117,
-0.16659444570541382,
-0.8169936537742615,
-0.31269991397857666,
-0.22866091132164001,
-0.28205159306526184,
0.36115387082099915,
-0.012922517023980618,
0.015148618258535862,
0.1169307753443718,
0.7963674068450928,
-0.5091845393180847,
-0.17290820181369781,
0.25863802433013916,
-0.04704475775361061,
0.7332560420036316,
0.1374790221452713,
0.21039989590644836,
-0.2160661220550537,
-0.290487140417099,
0.10878214240074158,
-0.36040690541267395,
-0.12340537458658218,
0.46925216913223267,
0.19637992978096008,
-0.2151164561510086,
0.6766120791435242,
-0.4248933494091034,
0.4447537958621979,
-0.03424782678484917,
-0.4703555107116699,
0.13719356060028076,
-0.917169988155365,
-0.3870760202407837,
0.07516969740390778,
0.8025944232940674,
0.4733060896396637,
0.3177679181098938,
-0.432788610458374,
0.01651834510266781,
0.01719670183956623,
0.10689307004213333,
-1.1591461896896362,
-0.002761265728622675,
0.4803515672683716,
-0.5133371353149414,
-0.12873439490795135,
0.33033260703086853,
-0.7380778193473816,
-0.24976353347301483,
-0.15664039552211761,
0.37767672538757324,
-0.7697678208351135,
0.09814892709255219,
0.34049317240715027,
-0.6603926420211792,
0.13166454434394836,
0.31803104281425476,
-0.8994688987731934,
0.7609556317329407,
0.8510252833366394,
0.8926763534545898,
-0.4252656400203705,
-0.5287577509880066,
-0.515673816204071,
0.24938862025737762,
0.02637418918311596,
0.9121877551078796,
-0.41143402457237244,
-0.5961902141571045,
-0.20288623869419098,
-0.29673177003860474,
-0.11231604218482971,
-0.7139396667480469,
0.8212918639183044,
-0.11346450448036194,
0.419744610786438,
-0.1802694946527481,
-0.9167876243591309,
-0.15235300362110138,
0.28230318427085876,
-0.6288570761680603,
0.8998258709907532,
0.27337148785591125,
-1.0522888898849487,
0.6159610152244568,
-0.6112907528877258,
-0.5914268493652344,
-0.19436711072921753,
0.032039202749729156,
-0.6648930311203003,
0.26403912901878357,
0.45546239614486694,
0.18907666206359863,
-0.10217195004224777,
0.30528467893600464,
-0.6032832860946655,
-0.4801875650882721,
0.18633264303207397,
-0.7415118217468262,
0.651669442653656,
0.055407024919986725,
-0.10853083431720734,
0.03662034869194031,
-0.6109829545021057,
-0.18411146104335785,
-0.16871652007102966,
-0.21740922331809998,
-0.48957180976867676,
0.104336217045784,
0.14050889015197754,
-0.40281665325164795,
0.12842002511024475,
-0.5106427669525146,
0.18819399178028107,
-0.8103610277175903,
0.15677863359451294,
0.03884577006101608,
0.4440729320049286,
0.6906867623329163,
-0.4645026922225952,
0.16328133642673492,
-0.19707868993282318,
0.2524155378341675,
-0.3310420513153076,
-0.583815336227417,
-0.2608564794063568,
-0.7426205277442932,
0.5027579665184021,
0.430486261844635,
-0.4859451651573181,
0.33418455719947815,
-0.5662524104118347,
-0.32636699080467224,
-0.4220825433731079,
0.2542399764060974,
0.3414265513420105,
0.308571994304657,
0.25588491559028625,
-0.3735325336456299,
-0.29110342264175415,
-1.0106719732284546,
-0.7921074628829956,
-0.027883553877472878,
-0.3613004982471466,
0.01568368636071682,
0.8382054567337036,
-0.44015389680862427,
1.2818142175674438,
-0.394111692905426,
-0.2637079656124115,
-0.5239177942276001,
0.4687269926071167,
0.4162842631340027,
0.3222995698451996,
0.6160452365875244,
-0.7963175773620605,
-0.48331549763679504,
-0.057696253061294556,
-0.7535180449485779,
-0.05211122706532478,
-0.4128670394420624,
-0.08377867192029953,
0.09691593796014786,
0.27463826537132263,
-0.677834689617157,
0.5251736044883728,
0.3206590414047241,
-0.22917355597019196,
0.4449083209037781,
-0.10666722804307938,
0.16150064766407013,
-1.1168171167373657,
-0.021695131435990334,
-0.12858617305755615,
-0.5424962043762207,
-0.4990312159061432,
0.33582550287246704,
0.21980316936969757,
0.15562878549098969,
-0.3445589244365692,
0.5306090116500854,
-0.4637278914451599,
0.0576666034758091,
-0.368642121553421,
0.23647010326385498,
0.49581027030944824,
0.2838199734687805,
-0.19133467972278595,
0.7110205888748169,
0.2753927707672119,
-0.41877445578575134,
-0.1661754846572876,
0.440084308385849,
-0.2607981562614441,
0.3715841770172119,
-0.6915008425712585,
-0.2301083356142044,
-0.13346318900585175,
0.30196455121040344,
-1.0164504051208496,
-0.48043861985206604,
-0.11220169067382812,
-0.3554578125476837,
0.3116197884082794,
-0.13305014371871948,
-0.5400405526161194,
-0.01790950447320938,
-0.7898233532905579,
0.4637305736541748,
0.33336716890335083,
-0.42835626006126404,
1.0310351848602295,
0.063421830534935,
0.025873545557260513,
-0.4369727373123169,
-1.004956603050232,
0.3293500542640686,
-0.34922176599502563,
-0.7314302325248718,
0.49070483446121216,
-0.0725586786866188,
-0.639821469783783,
0.028047198429703712,
-0.2574580907821655,
-0.16730713844299316,
0.12945596873760223,
0.09530971199274063,
-0.07348448783159256,
-0.26226910948753357,
-0.33091363310813904,
0.271345853805542,
0.08519275486469269,
-0.012029997073113918,
-0.20297682285308838,
0.24236923456192017,
-0.34674084186553955,
-0.47931817173957825,
-0.37871062755584717,
0.5673057436943054,
0.5317344069480896,
-0.3038012683391571,
0.5967382788658142,
0.39759746193885803,
-0.3965650498867035,
-0.3210076689720154,
-0.5432615280151367,
-0.06439098715782166,
-0.388997882604599,
0.12305279076099396,
-0.12817461788654327,
-0.4380660355091095,
0.7564347386360168,
-0.09207230061292648,
0.2779885232448578,
0.5818889737129211,
0.2200000286102295,
-0.09762275964021683,
0.48373943567276,
0.3963004946708679,
-0.05801418423652649,
0.1888342946767807,
-0.498358815908432,
0.0916673094034195,
-0.5939850807189941,
0.07983586192131042,
-0.3406386077404022,
0.01377895288169384,
-0.5101745128631592,
-0.35398492217063904,
0.2796226441860199,
0.3814517557621002,
0.3312753140926361,
0.1362445056438446,
-0.03352620080113411,
0.6646229028701782,
0.4251856505870819,
0.07327913492918015,
0.5866862535476685,
-0.14559462666511536,
0.2050757110118866,
0.0287946630269289,
-0.6177891492843628,
-0.7331673502922058,
0.9656255841255188,
0.23776763677597046,
0.6725102663040161,
0.29894840717315674,
0.949590802192688,
0.19783852994441986,
0.4717727601528168,
-0.8984625935554504,
0.24711281061172485,
-0.2013673037290573,
-0.36129188537597656,
-0.42441174387931824,
-0.43123507499694824,
-0.7477218508720398,
0.4146467447280884,
-0.24902009963989258,
-0.6008157730102539,
0.15031149983406067,
-0.09397327154874802,
-0.4099741280078888,
0.21270421147346497,
-0.7588534355163574,
0.6553214192390442,
0.17310717701911926,
-0.3760624825954437,
-0.1062101200222969,
-0.7092911601066589,
0.5718468427658081,
-0.19974985718727112,
0.14782831072807312,
-0.10796184092760086,
0.00590785825625062,
0.5330082178115845,
-0.6134088635444641,
0.734817624092102,
0.22778639197349548,
-0.0773920938372612,
0.4256848990917206,
-0.04979406297206879,
0.4280264675617218,
0.7164664268493652,
-0.39726951718330383,
0.3168255388736725,
0.012176339514553547,
-0.5487607717514038,
-0.8822930455207825,
0.4321484863758087,
-0.3345509171485901,
-0.32877781987190247,
-0.3058854937553406,
-0.5658908486366272,
-0.2794233560562134,
0.4133319854736328,
0.5457961559295654,
0.7995991110801697,
-0.5495829582214355,
0.2194126397371292,
0.8366047143936157,
0.060283150523900986,
0.7367590069770813,
0.05680936947464943,
-0.09568341821432114,
-0.6235901713371277,
0.6340057253837585,
-0.07552270591259003,
0.6434509754180908,
0.5495358109474182,
0.40395689010620117,
-0.2781417965888977,
-0.9327793717384338,
-0.4919077754020691,
0.17106319963932037,
-0.541784942150116,
-0.13114193081855774,
-0.6945906281471252,
-0.02635079436004162,
-0.3064500093460083,
-0.20047523081302643,
-0.4134737253189087,
-0.31829315423965454,
-0.3125736713409424,
0.20929299294948578,
0.13436131179332733,
0.522659420967102,
0.29509228467941284,
0.2945158779621124,
-0.8501649498939514,
0.7878017425537109,
0.176895871758461,
0.4977411925792694,
-0.3941580653190613,
-0.6006068587303162,
-0.1349823921918869,
0.2619767487049103,
-0.3712397813796997,
-0.7759106159210205,
0.2358824908733368,
0.5722232460975647,
0.5770004391670227,
0.6445490121841431,
0.16647766530513763,
0.7994630932807922,
-0.35739514231681824,
0.8775936961174011,
-0.018366705626249313,
-0.8711677193641663,
0.5104362368583679,
-0.3237423300743103,
0.5479562878608704,
1.2978423833847046,
0.11950749158859253,
-0.16182267665863037,
-0.8860034942626953,
-0.7114893198013306,
-0.9693819880485535,
0.17062997817993164,
0.671550452709198,
-0.037139590829610825,
-0.03413946181535721,
0.17294470965862274,
0.5756835341453552,
0.2811405062675476,
-0.36223191022872925,
-0.21438221633434296,
-0.1967916339635849,
-0.32884541153907776,
-0.057187821716070175,
-0.26789548993110657,
0.004665096290409565,
-0.04228191077709198,
0.6080329418182373,
-0.35401207208633423,
-0.0403921902179718,
0.5392494797706604,
-0.2870651185512543,
0.3743438124656677,
0.1709955483675003,
0.5781915783882141,
0.900318443775177,
-0.6569508910179138,
-0.026154376566410065,
0.6402778625488281,
-0.6725656986236572,
-0.34348586201667786,
0.07867349684238434,
-0.2835150957107544,
0.5451933741569519,
0.9249858260154724,
0.5011324882507324,
0.36303776502609253,
-0.6367003321647644,
0.7811965346336365,
-0.4349932074546814,
-0.31884607672691345,
-0.07657980918884277,
-0.0797581598162651,
-0.09168412536382675,
-0.05961023271083832,
0.3258267045021057,
0.352144330739975,
0.6742847561836243,
-0.5980072617530823,
0.27232101559638977,
0.574759840965271,
-0.19826966524124146,
-0.013852270320057869,
0.5688119530677795,
-0.04467618837952614,
-0.2061586230993271,
0.3443502187728882,
-0.3325602114200592,
-0.08980197459459305,
0.4043751657009125,
0.33003470301628113,
1.1560198068618774,
0.2634766697883606,
0.08263569325208664,
0.20823721587657928,
0.3453085720539093,
-0.24309995770454407,
0.28188690543174744,
-0.04609967768192291,
-0.4128172993659973,
-0.7786269783973694,
-0.7500623464584351,
-0.7545414566993713,
-0.1766151487827301,
-0.6738600730895996,
0.10966615378856659,
0.023039663210511208,
0.12419300526380539,
0.05911441147327423,
0.03801647201180458,
-0.2230067402124405,
0.13869130611419678,
0.0017922957194969058,
1.229612946510315,
-0.7646963596343994,
0.4705829620361328,
0.21915479004383087,
-0.2868613600730896,
-0.3643082082271576,
0.3431008458137512,
-0.30558258295059204,
-0.13747838139533997,
-0.2331514209508896,
0.1737886369228363,
-0.24256005883216858,
-0.4124489426612854,
-0.48843297362327576,
-0.6764364242553711,
0.8506688475608826,
0.650614857673645,
-0.1486574411392212,
0.14353539049625397,
0.21917824447155,
0.502615749835968,
-0.1902662217617035,
0.3948534429073334,
0.7019897103309631,
0.4888743460178375,
-0.08306929469108582,
-0.7188873291015625,
-0.1954362541437149,
-0.2719734311103821,
-0.06147921457886696,
0.16719171404838562,
-0.4400958716869354,
0.4097795784473419,
-0.25009647011756897,
-0.26323673129081726,
0.29954028129577637,
1.0683225393295288,
0.27794864773750305,
0.587538480758667,
0.3330676257610321,
0.6174529790878296,
0.8519119620323181,
-0.0662592425942421,
1.5237022638320923,
0.0024990765377879143,
0.4208114445209503,
1.4326804876327515,
-0.05749380588531494,
0.6897383332252502,
0.6903932690620422,
-0.16882315278053284,
0.40957745909690857,
0.4469945430755615,
-0.09615458548069,
0.6273389458656311,
0.0852208212018013,
-0.19882091879844666,
0.10169003158807755,
-0.12403511255979538,
-0.15374024212360382,
0.3480410575866699,
0.15797743201255798,
-0.0977378860116005,
-0.4716876149177551,
-0.16094247996807098,
-0.11290239542722702,
0.2497561275959015,
-0.20870020985603333,
0.9850794076919556,
0.1892079859972,
-0.7318041920661926,
0.5759812593460083,
-0.06363363564014435,
0.7216203212738037,
-0.7788716554641724,
-0.020802589133381844,
-0.5096259713172913,
0.18330228328704834,
-0.4764169454574585,
-0.7612367272377014,
0.6540073156356812,
-0.2154017686843872,
-0.1813991367816925,
-0.08590979874134064,
0.6580549478530884,
-0.39668482542037964,
-0.6186931729316711,
0.0000019015570842384477,
0.27390292286872864,
0.06815216690301895,
-0.3215344548225403,
-0.17186585068702698,
-0.4717878997325897,
-0.13375936448574066,
-0.31997695565223694,
0.17780476808547974,
0.5712345242500305,
-0.13144250214099884,
0.5196874141693115,
0.5139988660812378,
-0.005049507133662701,
-0.14524075388908386,
0.47247058153152466,
0.722425639629364,
-0.20956900715827942,
-0.5856598019599915,
-1.2478783130645752,
0.5364220142364502,
-0.44406622648239136,
-0.5742427110671997,
1.1997735500335693,
1.0683221817016602,
0.5904960632324219,
-0.130324125289917,
0.6787205338478088,
0.4346939027309418,
0.11749999970197678,
-0.47566208243370056,
0.6177572011947632,
-0.4825119078159332,
-0.01496480219066143,
-0.5574419498443604,
-0.9727172255516052,
-0.40909603238105774,
0.1348804384469986,
-0.1581571102142334,
-0.3100326657295227,
0.8622623682022095,
0.5451316833496094,
-0.4311031401157379,
0.46546250581741333,
0.07761311531066895,
-0.1848689764738083,
0.16226613521575928,
0.24090135097503662,
0.7348259687423706,
-0.5776910185813904,
0.2589828073978424,
-0.30161720514297485,
-0.1738717406988144,
-0.12287525832653046,
-1.0218701362609863,
-1.0533236265182495,
-0.034413911402225494,
-0.3402405381202698,
-0.23313677310943604,
-0.24948705732822418,
0.7166633009910583,
0.3920955955982208,
-0.9346786737442017,
-0.14658910036087036,
-0.28481701016426086,
0.12271042168140411,
-0.4983147084712982,
-0.1982116401195526,
0.3831453323364258,
-0.34519651532173157,
-0.6988377571105957,
0.44251009821891785,
0.5516492128372192,
0.07230152189731598,
-0.038363780826330185,
0.029907632619142532,
-0.17179444432258606,
0.3350655734539032,
0.6463177800178528,
-0.05770852044224739,
-0.6318184733390808,
0.008006894960999489,
-0.2760831415653229,
-0.045490067452192307,
0.17789192497730255,
0.6951410174369812,
-0.42431241273880005,
0.25701308250427246,
0.6071774959564209,
0.8944209814071655,
0.7679422497749329,
0.26603221893310547,
0.4705421030521393,
-0.8505846261978149,
0.02517453394830227,
0.3456742763519287,
0.5783748626708984,
0.3903399407863617,
-0.37664780020713806,
0.6475639939308167,
0.0021505814511328936,
-0.2924356460571289,
-0.8821874260902405,
0.10734762996435165,
-1.1881928443908691,
-0.377887099981308,
1.2223814725875854,
-0.14770323038101196,
-0.3539375066757202,
-0.24696774780750275,
-0.28456488251686096,
0.1516646295785904,
-0.2477286458015442,
0.6184079647064209,
0.5210558176040649,
-0.02873803861439228,
0.3968660533428192,
-0.4304378926753998,
0.5124964714050293,
0.42194458842277527,
-1.0343997478485107,
0.16694897413253784,
0.14609254896640778,
0.20248675346374512,
0.30101922154426575,
0.3741796314716339,
-0.03472625091671944,
0.16277237236499786,
0.06265458464622498,
-0.18504798412322998,
0.07681964337825775,
-0.1796461045742035,
-0.29292696714401245,
0.35847657918930054,
-0.1741078644990921,
-0.09280534833669662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17613v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17613v2
|
Neural Automated Writing Evaluation with Corrective Feedback
| 2024-02-27T15:42:33 | 2024-05-06T10:02:08 |
Izia Xiaoxiao Wang, Xihan Wu, Edith Coates, Min Zeng, Jiexin Kuang, Siliang Liu, Mengyang Qiu, Jungyeul Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The utilization of technology in second language learning and teaching has
become ubiquitous. For the assessment of writing specifically, automated
writing evaluation (AWE) and grammatical error correction (GEC) have become
immensely popular and effective methods for enhancing writing proficiency and
delivering instant and individualized feedback to learners. By leveraging the
power of natural language processing (NLP) and machine learning algorithms, AWE
and GEC systems have been developed separately to provide language learners
with automated corrective feedback and more accurate and unbiased scoring that
would otherwise be subject to examiners. In this paper, we propose an
integrated system for automated writing evaluation with corrective feedback as
a means of bridging the gap between AWE and GEC results for second language
learners. This system enables language learners to simulate the essay writing
tests: a student writes and submits an essay, and the system returns the
assessment of the writing along with suggested grammatical error corrections.
Given that automated scoring and grammatical correction are more efficient and
cost-effective than human grading, this integrated system would also alleviate
the burden of manually correcting innumerable essays.
|
[
-0.0006816834793426096,
-0.9778938889503479,
0.4420062005519867,
0.3967686891555786,
0.390047162771225,
0.4950442314147949,
-0.4686996340751648,
-0.4382390081882477,
0.21836763620376587,
0.13637734949588776,
-0.3403586149215698,
-0.46882739663124084,
-0.36357811093330383,
0.29675352573394775,
-0.3117973506450653,
0.8938722014427185,
-0.26365453004837036,
0.2917957007884979,
-0.4844959080219269,
0.005295679904520512,
-0.5021724104881287,
-0.4704548716545105,
-1.0166748762130737,
-0.36543551087379456,
0.45487067103385925,
0.4619756042957306,
0.3414905071258545,
0.11594800651073456,
0.5855918526649475,
0.5166703462600708,
0.521087646484375,
0.33987417817115784,
0.16220153868198395,
-0.06217337027192116,
-0.3139232099056244,
-0.4076199233531952,
-0.5197017192840576,
0.003365332493558526,
0.6161268353462219,
0.6963131427764893,
-0.043954428285360336,
0.07624618709087372,
0.33415812253952026,
0.5789729356765747,
-0.573199450969696,
0.007394828833639622,
-0.12113980203866959,
0.2679187059402466,
0.26600074768066406,
-0.076743483543396,
-0.6118656396865845,
-0.7988066673278809,
-0.016299204900860786,
-0.3974507451057434,
-0.06243740767240524,
-0.266679972410202,
0.6567541360855103,
0.2654736042022705,
-0.04933791607618332,
-0.5066756010055542,
-0.7667672634124756,
0.6031959652900696,
-0.7800659537315369,
-0.07737076282501221,
0.19639135897159576,
0.18093731999397278,
0.10450911521911621,
-0.5718953609466553,
-0.8658438324928284,
-0.661308228969574,
-0.1421450823545456,
0.5342728495597839,
-0.039326246827840805,
0.2931126356124878,
-0.01674594357609749,
0.32788288593292236,
-0.466973215341568,
0.26568281650543213,
-0.05862611159682274,
-0.24102473258972168,
0.7379146814346313,
0.043589092791080475,
0.6656808257102966,
0.03469584882259369,
-0.017056509852409363,
-0.023302771151065826,
-0.036597490310668945,
0.06235434487462044,
0.7368374466896057,
0.3129274249076843,
0.13141700625419617,
0.6414201259613037,
0.0901399776339531,
0.5997247099876404,
-0.027260545641183853,
0.09769150614738464,
0.1431494951248169,
-0.054200317710638046,
-0.1914421021938324,
-0.17134758830070496,
0.9004619121551514,
0.6184159517288208,
0.4103294312953949,
-0.18875528872013092,
-0.5067397356033325,
0.581719160079956,
0.5033668875694275,
-0.22043514251708984,
-0.03731405362486839,
0.09341499954462051,
-0.21778610348701477,
-0.4347376227378845,
0.2437949925661087,
-0.8636509776115417,
-0.06300490349531174,
-0.607957124710083,
0.9032126069068909,
-0.20181144773960114,
0.01866314187645912,
-0.05066831782460213,
-0.19347378611564636,
-0.12952174246311188,
0.37058931589126587,
-0.9103001952171326,
0.8382324576377869,
0.529776930809021,
0.7900205850601196,
-0.1521761268377304,
-0.5315067768096924,
-0.4339585304260254,
-0.4227549135684967,
-0.40695202350616455,
0.8846848607063293,
-0.3442152738571167,
-0.3060321509838104,
0.3422512412071228,
-0.08871403336524963,
-0.33402758836746216,
-0.38595882058143616,
0.3683813810348511,
-0.5131345987319946,
0.6278411746025085,
0.20593762397766113,
-0.695097029209137,
-0.19291742146015167,
0.18912026286125183,
-0.49837246537208557,
1.2431375980377197,
0.3251807987689972,
-0.3929910361766815,
-0.032326776534318924,
-0.8093317747116089,
-0.6459829211235046,
0.0600675605237484,
0.02089565247297287,
-0.32141628861427307,
-0.010102265514433384,
0.09254717826843262,
0.29068928956985474,
0.049952395260334015,
0.1508498340845108,
0.04104037582874298,
-0.5940790176391602,
0.10089161247015,
-0.2342648208141327,
0.521202802658081,
-0.14885839819908142,
-0.9197101593017578,
0.26786231994628906,
-0.9190394878387451,
0.5066680312156677,
-0.17732453346252441,
-0.6859705448150635,
-0.0751701220870018,
-0.3097979724407196,
0.180449977517128,
-0.04670080542564392,
0.2275007665157318,
-0.49281617999076843,
0.19821318984031677,
-0.457577645778656,
0.02469911053776741,
0.870574414730072,
-0.11992380768060684,
0.5232574343681335,
-0.2506023347377777,
0.6547815203666687,
-0.5903985500335693,
-0.11893901228904724,
0.14054006338119507,
-0.3312591016292572,
-1.169013500213623,
0.2404475212097168,
0.47376537322998047,
1.1199296712875366,
-0.5197080373764038,
0.9082749485969543,
0.13242362439632416,
-0.3192300498485565,
-0.8279889225959778,
0.2603907287120819,
0.67369544506073,
0.5888854265213013,
0.3181236982345581,
-0.22615380585193634,
-0.7225111126899719,
-0.498241662979126,
-0.28694960474967957,
-0.426165372133255,
-0.11472702026367188,
-0.026357902213931084,
0.48778533935546875,
-0.32216760516166687,
0.6339667439460754,
-0.3948224186897278,
-0.5383263230323792,
-0.4150391221046448,
0.3565378189086914,
-0.14400143921375275,
0.6527174115180969,
0.21842654049396515,
-0.07587244361639023,
-0.7906535863876343,
0.3100883364677429,
-0.7853162884712219,
-0.6004564166069031,
-0.37322402000427246,
-0.02455228939652443,
0.6070359349250793,
0.4322110414505005,
-0.10836586356163025,
0.44271615147590637,
0.44761669635772705,
-0.380584716796875,
0.8302204608917236,
-0.5152856111526489,
0.42520812153816223,
-0.7451052665710449,
0.09561651945114136,
-0.09546877443790436,
-0.04554207995533943,
-0.22032849490642548,
0.02646540105342865,
0.09299878031015396,
0.09506435692310333,
0.31143221259117126,
0.3792806565761566,
-0.16714924573898315,
0.08128482103347778,
-0.3950638771057129,
0.16892392933368683,
0.10304446518421173,
0.6253818869590759,
-0.16022087633609772,
0.6964731812477112,
0.2414524257183075,
-0.2979496717453003,
0.486921489238739,
-0.04869099333882332,
-0.18006008863449097,
0.5938952565193176,
-0.5053135752677917,
0.4297002851963043,
-0.10679420083761215,
0.06744831800460815,
-1.0188384056091309,
-0.2642527222633362,
-0.010429631918668747,
-0.7129996418952942,
0.3282899856567383,
0.39082854986190796,
-0.17114344239234924,
-0.4134993255138397,
-0.25591546297073364,
-0.3214128911495209,
0.4968889355659485,
-0.4779186248779297,
0.7120857238769531,
0.061017632484436035,
-0.4585220515727997,
-0.7552807927131653,
-0.7446165084838867,
0.31118205189704895,
0.4057360291481018,
-0.5865669250488281,
0.10794670879840851,
-0.07154776155948639,
-0.4412304759025574,
0.25504347681999207,
0.44989287853240967,
-0.0283456202596426,
-0.09043341875076294,
0.3460409939289093,
0.5438791513442993,
-0.2117171287536621,
0.36505523324012756,
0.2535208463668823,
-0.20429225265979767,
0.056581079959869385,
-0.5731421709060669,
0.2996642291545868,
-0.4600781202316284,
-0.5088927149772644,
-0.6969246864318848,
0.7249935865402222,
0.555698573589325,
-0.05382288247346878,
0.3277023136615753,
0.4897579550743103,
-0.6462734341621399,
-0.4528477191925049,
-0.7942669987678528,
-0.05280715227127075,
-0.40678462386131287,
0.3629246652126312,
-0.16515028476715088,
-0.7203284502029419,
0.3327348828315735,
0.12761250138282776,
0.06350769102573395,
0.6254457235336304,
0.535811185836792,
-0.32753676176071167,
0.8944143056869507,
0.7546437978744507,
-0.05472968518733978,
0.21775352954864502,
-0.20293587446212769,
0.294437050819397,
-0.46710023283958435,
-0.36768484115600586,
-0.7082458138465881,
-0.3781936764717102,
-0.009980776347219944,
-0.07910051196813583,
-0.018961390480399132,
-0.07193629443645477,
-0.07368781417608261,
0.0729580819606781,
-0.6142042875289917,
0.6298105716705322,
0.7250162959098816,
-0.08603490144014359,
0.24301289021968842,
-0.027016036212444305,
-0.6721201539039612,
-0.35861456394195557,
-0.33613118529319763,
-0.831051766872406,
0.9036604762077332,
0.10758902877569199,
0.5160984396934509,
-0.13178998231887817,
0.522500216960907,
0.6304501295089722,
0.6265046000480652,
-0.9145802855491638,
0.5764056444168091,
-0.33770081400871277,
-0.06222983077168465,
-0.28280526399612427,
-0.18233788013458252,
-0.21976354718208313,
0.10397990792989731,
-0.16761614382266998,
-0.539016604423523,
-0.0618133544921875,
0.07073097676038742,
-0.7239468693733215,
0.3122076988220215,
-1.112769603729248,
0.7423685789108276,
-0.26871737837791443,
-0.46412497758865356,
-0.16976626217365265,
-0.6367072463035583,
-0.20298220217227936,
0.15038925409317017,
-0.04995644837617874,
0.38985395431518555,
0.10593114793300629,
0.8028333783149719,
-0.689210832118988,
0.9133079051971436,
-0.24381275475025177,
0.03711077570915222,
0.5214319229125977,
-0.06181171536445618,
0.332958847284317,
-0.114301398396492,
-0.2717874348163605,
-0.22016017138957977,
-0.48713621497154236,
0.11998078972101212,
-0.7737306952476501,
0.8155230283737183,
-0.8424277901649475,
-0.23650327324867249,
-0.4892258942127228,
-0.15515470504760742,
-0.21710626780986786,
0.08858051151037216,
0.19296620786190033,
0.3101927936077118,
-0.4178347885608673,
-0.38133540749549866,
0.21367712318897247,
0.0766436830163002,
0.5097082257270813,
0.638016402721405,
-0.24499669671058655,
-0.7453411817550659,
0.8416218161582947,
0.15605583786964417,
0.025649933144450188,
0.3321842849254608,
0.1309995800256729,
-0.4478617310523987,
-0.3165619373321533,
-0.765833854675293,
0.07249531149864197,
-0.9009124040603638,
0.03209945559501648,
-0.7901753783226013,
-0.1895923912525177,
-0.6291761994361877,
-0.758240282535553,
-0.14445924758911133,
-0.4130415916442871,
-0.2893202304840088,
-0.3279343247413635,
-0.11366677284240723,
0.8491618633270264,
-0.416221559047699,
0.3620529770851135,
-0.6728496551513672,
0.0783454105257988,
0.41658085584640503,
0.39370185136795044,
0.148380845785141,
-0.41721490025520325,
-0.15206275880336761,
-0.33040228486061096,
-0.3483441472053528,
-0.5461242198944092,
0.22212578356266022,
0.3760286569595337,
0.1014166921377182,
0.12874451279640198,
-0.6341768503189087,
0.7269720435142517,
-0.6337299346923828,
0.7491315603256226,
0.2336277961730957,
-1.2663668394088745,
0.6538880467414856,
-0.010827691294252872,
0.33452853560447693,
0.9603244066238403,
0.02755892276763916,
-0.9332261681556702,
-0.4995286464691162,
-0.29532390832901,
-0.6615515351295471,
0.5361273288726807,
-0.17473961412906647,
0.0848982110619545,
-0.002893960103392601,
0.40001538395881653,
0.15836642682552338,
0.01914147473871708,
-0.7291410565376282,
0.28367236256599426,
0.03143669664859772,
-0.6515167951583862,
0.07245387136936188,
-0.08520686626434326,
-0.03560220077633858,
-0.3323670029640198,
1.0803792476654053,
-0.26733335852622986,
0.16176269948482513,
0.4088267982006073,
-0.05641384795308113,
-0.3960210680961609,
0.3528457581996918,
0.35379713773727417,
0.2845747172832489,
0.07492329180240631,
0.008367455564439297,
0.3456011712551117,
-0.6206629872322083,
0.24876104295253754,
0.03436479717493057,
-0.2979736030101776,
0.2457844614982605,
0.5290741920471191,
0.3670608401298523,
0.026312440633773804,
-0.7327585816383362,
0.5446327924728394,
-0.218543142080307,
-0.2734862267971039,
-0.5272215604782104,
0.1691937893629074,
-0.027345603331923485,
0.05081126093864441,
0.16463002562522888,
0.7565818428993225,
0.15273359417915344,
-0.32042327523231506,
0.22772017121315002,
0.20608361065387726,
-0.6126092076301575,
-0.29383933544158936,
0.4150615930557251,
0.499740868806839,
-0.7291173338890076,
0.690485954284668,
-0.16966713964939117,
-0.7171671986579895,
0.6966766715049744,
0.6642912030220032,
1.1946570873260498,
-0.5769965052604675,
0.46983015537261963,
0.5953495502471924,
0.4551243484020233,
-0.013551786541938782,
0.5114293694496155,
0.05193256214261055,
-0.3689023554325104,
-0.5767040848731995,
-0.7048182487487793,
-0.5341538190841675,
-0.07189089059829712,
-0.5291475057601929,
0.28618916869163513,
-0.7179145216941833,
-0.034285079687833786,
-0.121271513402462,
0.08834115415811539,
-0.3355053663253784,
0.5853787660598755,
0.12481401115655899,
0.4532149136066437,
-0.8664142489433289,
0.4007711410522461,
1.0853443145751953,
-0.37410053610801697,
-0.8670154809951782,
-0.13715364038944244,
0.11796045303344727,
-0.49586763978004456,
0.5103237628936768,
0.4846484065055847,
-0.640910267829895,
-0.1826128214597702,
-0.21227334439754486,
-0.26524072885513306,
0.5126195549964905,
0.11438294500112534,
-0.4846712052822113,
0.10267040133476257,
0.30276045203208923,
1.0870976448059082,
-0.2993376851081848,
0.619318962097168,
0.481661319732666,
0.4988012909889221,
-0.2855317294597626,
-0.9031543135643005,
-0.19262178242206573,
-0.7241173386573792,
-0.013717103749513626,
-0.02878427878022194,
-0.4492810368537903,
0.42115503549575806,
-0.40791741013526917,
-0.32786285877227783,
0.15393486618995667,
0.6655199527740479,
-0.507321834564209,
0.4281280040740967,
0.4207730293273926,
0.8326748013496399,
0.873081386089325,
-0.11741475015878677,
0.7508827447891235,
0.05223819613456726,
0.22801078855991364,
1.0659023523330688,
-0.4050035774707794,
1.0339782238006592,
0.37473711371421814,
-0.293913871049881,
0.8764135837554932,
0.2915841341018677,
0.03757908195257187,
0.13628903031349182,
0.38339143991470337,
-0.6638213396072388,
0.06823348253965378,
-0.0483957976102829,
-0.02984011545777321,
0.340241402387619,
0.14360041916370392,
-0.28081706166267395,
0.04287385568022728,
0.08166413754224777,
0.09057151526212692,
0.7132470607757568,
-0.1890343725681305,
1.0310858488082886,
-0.13388089835643768,
-1.283596158027649,
0.09090451151132584,
0.22997720539569855,
0.7857013940811157,
-0.6451808214187622,
-0.20388104021549225,
-0.17368723452091217,
0.5433915257453918,
-0.6099079847335815,
-0.7006734609603882,
0.5730694532394409,
0.35705140233039856,
-0.24892114102840424,
-0.19221097230911255,
0.8593454957008362,
-0.6140632629394531,
-0.6080260276794434,
0.5435518026351929,
0.25021713972091675,
-0.2200380563735962,
0.2646477520465851,
-0.4032284915447235,
-0.1527090221643448,
-0.06772221624851227,
-0.01592255011200905,
-0.1439094990491867,
0.02148319035768509,
0.22050093114376068,
0.351260244846344,
0.6807106137275696,
0.224261075258255,
-0.07071173191070557,
0.5906064510345459,
0.35250070691108704,
-0.4382171630859375,
-0.6212640404701233,
-0.8133425712585449,
0.6643338799476624,
-0.26359379291534424,
-0.4926435351371765,
0.5992675423622131,
0.4628797769546509,
0.7808017730712891,
-0.3354710638523102,
1.2779213190078735,
-0.1054726243019104,
0.5900104641914368,
-0.3776465654373169,
0.7812625169754028,
-0.42032167315483093,
-0.07095279544591904,
-0.4246706962585449,
-0.7582480311393738,
-0.6371224522590637,
0.7096870541572571,
-0.09592953324317932,
-0.10190778970718384,
1.0480308532714844,
0.6759945154190063,
0.43476322293281555,
0.3429633378982544,
0.1555185168981552,
-0.12353819608688354,
0.0815517008304596,
0.4007691740989685,
0.944384753704071,
-0.5997194647789001,
0.13417014479637146,
-0.37724635004997253,
-0.5956985950469971,
-0.23166492581367493,
-0.48590099811553955,
-0.7331360578536987,
-0.4814072549343109,
-0.4499659538269043,
-0.5093390941619873,
0.27324727177619934,
0.9697287678718567,
0.05859290063381195,
-0.9503987431526184,
-0.331753134727478,
-0.19275815784931183,
0.017124490812420845,
-0.3670719861984253,
-0.3384845554828644,
0.38480132818222046,
-0.7187701463699341,
-1.0423816442489624,
0.29029613733291626,
0.7573635578155518,
-0.03150128200650215,
-0.2793404459953308,
-0.04111922159790993,
-0.11540356278419495,
0.15582308173179626,
0.5195391774177551,
0.0703517496585846,
-0.4806136190891266,
-0.45336294174194336,
0.0837588682770729,
-0.34743690490722656,
-0.0734580010175705,
0.7685889601707458,
-0.573138415813446,
0.6367886066436768,
0.5737082958221436,
1.0040444135665894,
-0.3275293707847595,
-0.15900081396102905,
0.701967716217041,
-0.5548995733261108,
-0.21737147867679596,
0.5414392352104187,
0.24825380742549896,
0.5061568021774292,
-0.6182462573051453,
0.5064116716384888,
0.22398942708969116,
-0.7424497604370117,
-0.42271143198013306,
-0.3101954162120819,
-0.6633332371711731,
-0.013808914460241795,
0.7200773358345032,
-0.37939852476119995,
0.01588602364063263,
-0.03405481576919556,
-0.5285570025444031,
0.3139285743236542,
-0.15684683620929718,
1.0511510372161865,
1.0059596300125122,
-0.17428280413150787,
0.265063613653183,
-0.30001553893089294,
0.33186426758766174,
0.9258692264556885,
-1.2260693311691284,
-0.3181225061416626,
0.6079983711242676,
-0.007008114829659462,
0.41579318046569824,
0.6366622447967529,
-0.0025613000616431236,
0.47773149609565735,
0.14546100795269012,
0.3194699287414551,
0.26218754053115845,
-0.5564457178115845,
-0.6308901309967041,
0.33562490344047546,
-0.18470647931098938,
-0.1420275717973709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17608v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17608v1
|
Linguistic Knowledge Can Enhance Encoder-Decoder Models (If You Let It)
| 2024-02-27T15:34:15 | 2024-02-27T15:34:15 |
Alessio Miaschi, Felice Dell'Orletta, Giulia Venturi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we explore the impact of augmenting pre-trained
Encoder-Decoder models, specifically T5, with linguistic knowledge for the
prediction of a target task. In particular, we investigate whether fine-tuning
a T5 model on an intermediate task that predicts structural linguistic
properties of sentences modifies its performance in the target task of
predicting sentence-level complexity. Our study encompasses diverse experiments
conducted on Italian and English datasets, employing both monolingual and
multilingual T5 models at various sizes. Results obtained for both languages
and in cross-lingual configurations show that linguistically motivated
intermediate fine-tuning has generally a positive impact on target task
performance, especially when applied to smaller models and in scenarios with
limited data availability.
|
[
-0.2988584041595459,
-0.5797131657600403,
0.5106054544448853,
-0.06620168685913086,
-0.08684972673654556,
-0.18090364336967468,
-0.3603309094905853,
-0.7388596534729004,
-0.1878112107515335,
0.44947895407676697,
-0.47904837131500244,
-0.3966630697250366,
-0.9971258640289307,
0.3431199789047241,
-0.3777220547199249,
0.9232609868049622,
0.22037355601787567,
0.23420186340808868,
-0.07131900638341904,
0.07087323069572449,
-0.5952628254890442,
-0.3662666082382202,
-0.5891496539115906,
-0.4635685384273529,
0.5538657307624817,
0.39961203932762146,
0.6397936344146729,
0.7140721082687378,
0.5177904963493347,
0.3038020730018616,
-0.24200232326984406,
0.17120246589183807,
-0.6212589740753174,
-0.04023927450180054,
-0.4849833548069,
-0.9509125351905823,
-0.3383166491985321,
-0.3980032503604889,
0.38110458850860596,
0.9777762293815613,
0.20113658905029297,
0.06673084199428558,
0.23422126471996307,
0.44337114691734314,
-0.6029413342475891,
0.3114318549633026,
-0.7504710555076599,
-0.12520553171634674,
-0.11699683219194412,
-0.27688348293304443,
-0.4227510988712311,
0.04682191461324692,
0.0684448629617691,
-0.5213558673858643,
0.320339560508728,
-0.046143244951963425,
0.9769178032875061,
0.7782427072525024,
-0.3665849268436432,
-0.29576101899147034,
-0.7614327073097229,
0.5158758163452148,
-0.729427695274353,
0.5492705702781677,
0.6385732293128967,
0.0534796416759491,
-0.07001281529664993,
-0.5277307629585266,
-0.3377552330493927,
-0.06112876534461975,
-0.417391300201416,
-0.029558077454566956,
0.05910880118608475,
0.494218111038208,
0.5931739807128906,
0.3056962192058563,
-0.18073531985282898,
0.12732674181461334,
-0.8435254693031311,
0.0348023883998394,
0.3471386134624481,
0.15851984918117523,
0.5746265649795532,
-0.017126034945249557,
0.37005680799484253,
0.32010549306869507,
-0.6457041501998901,
0.16475972533226013,
0.30992716550827026,
0.38584578037261963,
-0.059618160128593445,
0.7444031834602356,
-0.4649657905101776,
0.8974853754043579,
0.3858598470687866,
0.045401494950056076,
0.19158761203289032,
-0.5945618748664856,
-0.22351744771003723,
0.18169228732585907,
0.3874090611934662,
0.02776901237666607,
0.4726075530052185,
-0.34905508160591125,
-0.20772700011730194,
0.27703770995140076,
0.33972054719924927,
-0.7670965194702148,
-0.28673961758613586,
0.03855184093117714,
-0.19544169306755066,
-0.062033411115407944,
-0.011578149162232876,
-0.1783273071050644,
-0.11688769608736038,
-0.34739676117897034,
0.45604684948921204,
-0.7870992422103882,
0.03611387312412262,
0.6293520331382751,
-0.19198915362358093,
-0.01683001220226288,
0.1812652349472046,
-1.0471620559692383,
0.17003735899925232,
0.7662555575370789,
0.6016691327095032,
0.4224005341529846,
-0.45441362261772156,
-0.5451692938804626,
0.2761740982532501,
-0.38175827264785767,
0.5340080857276917,
-1.1166311502456665,
-0.086310014128685,
-0.13970470428466797,
0.1130947396159172,
-0.08903621137142181,
-0.32052159309387207,
0.579896092414856,
-0.39634430408477783,
0.08378824591636658,
-0.3215462267398834,
-0.609371542930603,
-0.14640362560749054,
0.2501900792121887,
-0.8877428770065308,
0.6873260736465454,
-0.009708017110824585,
-0.7515684962272644,
0.703283965587616,
-0.6867926716804504,
-0.7865272760391235,
-0.06174755096435547,
0.08128099143505096,
-0.17875488102436066,
0.5276957750320435,
0.4960649907588959,
0.5545694828033447,
-0.08271443098783493,
0.12239570915699005,
-0.2664962410926819,
-0.4324248135089874,
0.11782310903072357,
-0.12117863446474075,
0.3005737066268921,
0.021641019731760025,
-0.2002163976430893,
-0.025494752451777458,
-0.7806743383407593,
-0.19809502363204956,
-0.4045494496822357,
-0.4687682092189789,
-0.23818857967853546,
0.09260722994804382,
-0.3303587734699249,
0.11494959890842438,
0.41896384954452515,
-0.6067904233932495,
0.022838162258267403,
-0.767734944820404,
0.5069485902786255,
0.4038381278514862,
0.03074437566101551,
0.5178125500679016,
-0.32281574606895447,
0.5132898688316345,
0.32789701223373413,
0.04417725279927254,
-0.4030184745788574,
-0.2877993583679199,
-1.008601427078247,
0.1324491947889328,
0.6285502910614014,
0.3431258797645569,
-1.0645413398742676,
0.2973669171333313,
-0.5055509805679321,
-0.41172361373901367,
-0.7592352032661438,
0.09621794521808624,
0.5676084160804749,
0.13785871863365173,
0.4287370443344116,
-0.12573473155498505,
-0.7602283358573914,
-0.8436840176582336,
-0.65559983253479,
0.029911218211054802,
-0.05140986293554306,
0.06325540691614151,
0.4453909993171692,
-0.130597785115242,
0.6514432430267334,
-0.2714945077896118,
-0.48258742690086365,
-0.5047099590301514,
-0.0034681428223848343,
0.3284228444099426,
0.6102256178855896,
0.3482380211353302,
-0.6376720666885376,
-0.47239914536476135,
0.22819091379642487,
-0.6187023520469666,
-0.020513834431767464,
0.0755220502614975,
0.16388066112995148,
0.018764929845929146,
0.5183982849121094,
-0.5920481085777283,
0.2512863576412201,
0.41900405287742615,
-0.5154238939285278,
0.24483999609947205,
-0.6544886231422424,
0.27838730812072754,
-1.1697189807891846,
-0.2221704125404358,
0.10042225569486618,
0.06838344782590866,
-0.9185903668403625,
0.013132310472428799,
0.11673959344625473,
0.03136347234249115,
-0.19063197076320648,
0.1753203272819519,
-0.5192744135856628,
-0.03567982092499733,
-0.06271082907915115,
-0.501742422580719,
-0.07404311746358871,
0.31292182207107544,
0.1506212055683136,
0.8319334983825684,
0.431703120470047,
-0.5721069574356079,
-0.1903432458639145,
0.043242841958999634,
-0.7372773885726929,
0.15080615878105164,
-0.9272252917289734,
0.07744881510734558,
-0.35425037145614624,
-0.3469947278499603,
-0.7109413146972656,
-0.5433247089385986,
-0.25837093591690063,
-0.6906708478927612,
0.31010350584983826,
-0.2275034487247467,
-0.47118350863456726,
-0.06250640004873276,
0.2761218249797821,
0.40443557500839233,
0.36089277267456055,
-0.2878860831260681,
0.7773739099502563,
0.17783749103546143,
0.04702230542898178,
-0.47664910554885864,
-0.9194068908691406,
0.01317298598587513,
-0.1593160182237625,
-0.5708951354026794,
0.411531001329422,
0.05586588755249977,
-0.027410408481955528,
-0.03727467358112335,
0.11566722393035889,
-0.11828342080116272,
0.028541207313537598,
0.2704719603061676,
-0.14502134919166565,
-0.1081322431564331,
0.37032464146614075,
0.26732808351516724,
-0.04005361720919609,
0.022738348692655563,
-0.3471187353134155,
0.5082990527153015,
-0.14723606407642365,
-0.04384225979447365,
-0.15161274373531342,
0.04659522697329521,
0.5383804440498352,
-0.4377850592136383,
0.8662307858467102,
0.5194580554962158,
-0.4882257282733917,
-0.2147141993045807,
-0.5427705645561218,
-0.25597572326660156,
-0.5101404190063477,
0.6278181672096252,
-1.048710584640503,
-0.9010758399963379,
0.3834950923919678,
0.21571281552314758,
-0.23650602996349335,
0.3258335590362549,
0.36528587341308594,
-0.12703433632850647,
1.0585801601409912,
0.9970360994338989,
-0.14962781965732574,
0.632814884185791,
-0.21841420233249664,
0.2491237372159958,
-0.57563316822052,
-0.2696661949157715,
-0.5820505619049072,
-0.42737001180648804,
-0.5859967470169067,
-0.3335779011249542,
0.48387911915779114,
0.07402370125055313,
-0.3609147369861603,
0.4525812864303589,
-0.24479781091213226,
0.7039514183998108,
0.33790650963783264,
0.6688734292984009,
0.43452829122543335,
-0.09196718782186508,
0.110060915350914,
-0.025833215564489365,
-1.0520542860031128,
-0.24680687487125397,
1.1646195650100708,
0.2642327547073364,
0.7252247929573059,
-0.06967556476593018,
0.46112269163131714,
0.10004410892724991,
-0.35321566462516785,
-0.5492238402366638,
0.3186374008655548,
-0.5615843534469604,
-0.48315319418907166,
-0.3913063406944275,
-0.3194839060306549,
-0.8609264492988586,
-0.17910656332969666,
-0.23109018802642822,
-0.47204717993736267,
0.34763845801353455,
0.18149471282958984,
-0.457669198513031,
0.031039265915751457,
-0.8473884463310242,
0.8062137365341187,
-0.09144379198551178,
-0.33190372586250305,
-0.4543774127960205,
-0.3988196849822998,
-0.09427236020565033,
0.018273817375302315,
0.2128268927335739,
-0.04500504955649376,
-0.30092930793762207,
0.5862563252449036,
-0.19919003546237946,
0.97354656457901,
-0.08027868717908859,
0.06572441756725311,
-0.25159627199172974,
0.07752805948257446,
0.4408056437969208,
-0.12462642788887024,
-0.39594948291778564,
0.09124815464019775,
-0.1188463494181633,
-0.5066301822662354,
-0.7678266167640686,
0.464711457490921,
-0.9137652516365051,
-0.6611686944961548,
0.25784367322921753,
-0.7318904399871826,
-0.36702123284339905,
0.3420273959636688,
0.5269426703453064,
0.5373178124427795,
0.01848633587360382,
0.46304064989089966,
0.7125421166419983,
0.13860774040222168,
0.28547370433807373,
0.4131348431110382,
0.4313402473926544,
-0.11924547702074051,
0.6442573666572571,
0.4551469087600708,
0.33946123719215393,
0.6063545942306519,
-0.06616508215665817,
0.09257445484399796,
-0.791801929473877,
-0.2134680300951004,
-0.01981285959482193,
-0.8310747146606445,
-0.03904076665639877,
-0.769110381603241,
-0.0762718990445137,
-0.2108345925807953,
-0.09656371176242828,
-0.3688526451587677,
-0.36091285943984985,
-0.43412724137306213,
-0.43990957736968994,
0.3120107054710388,
0.9721084237098694,
0.13325977325439453,
0.25812965631484985,
-0.745943546295166,
0.08800870925188065,
-0.1939757615327835,
0.5436100363731384,
-0.3441130220890045,
-0.7121701240539551,
-0.7458710670471191,
0.25864529609680176,
0.24127152562141418,
-0.5870187282562256,
0.4440329372882843,
0.5101989507675171,
0.4212612509727478,
0.24008114635944366,
-0.06990405172109604,
0.7378939390182495,
-0.47877806425094604,
0.7272855639457703,
0.0018920381553471088,
-1.062739610671997,
0.6426665186882019,
-0.4564608633518219,
0.7614240050315857,
0.5341504216194153,
0.5387647747993469,
-0.06375202536582947,
-0.49204444885253906,
-0.49540865421295166,
-0.4418093264102936,
0.6881085634231567,
0.14460749924182892,
0.17472602427005768,
0.1402289718389511,
0.46407559514045715,
0.194924995303154,
0.13087975978851318,
-0.6085454821586609,
0.35495567321777344,
-0.0953885093331337,
-0.4554382860660553,
-0.4529828131198883,
-0.4456387460231781,
0.24820607900619507,
-0.4975612461566925,
0.5260392427444458,
-0.13444000482559204,
0.18189650774002075,
0.13020643591880798,
-0.2717578113079071,
-0.06803099811077118,
0.32317882776260376,
0.4836634397506714,
0.6253573894500732,
0.014675683341920376,
-0.008997409604489803,
0.5751866102218628,
-0.25533103942871094,
-0.014674066565930843,
-0.13841262459754944,
-0.20719000697135925,
-0.06404486298561096,
0.7260486483573914,
1.1513328552246094,
0.43186885118484497,
-0.46030738949775696,
0.02000501938164234,
0.12165485322475433,
-0.28377407789230347,
-0.11409879475831985,
0.33745765686035156,
-0.05097523704171181,
0.3787911534309387,
0.10909168422222137,
0.21391353011131287,
0.30449986457824707,
-0.79753577709198,
0.12677326798439026,
0.04454030469059944,
-0.5209518074989319,
-0.5244511365890503,
0.6145721077919006,
0.08477012813091278,
-0.19671101868152618,
0.30418598651885986,
0.17321822047233582,
-0.748959481716156,
0.7352056503295898,
0.48550257086753845,
0.6494439244270325,
-0.24393118917942047,
-0.3282977342605591,
0.5420819520950317,
0.5308624505996704,
-0.12978684902191162,
0.34118223190307617,
-0.04132765531539917,
-0.9950355887413025,
-0.600812554359436,
-0.5687989592552185,
-0.049307022243738174,
-0.26591092348098755,
-0.5555986166000366,
0.46804752945899963,
-0.07174600660800934,
-0.08322089165449142,
0.13233976066112518,
-0.0075942534022033215,
-0.8647159934043884,
0.5406590104103088,
-0.07155037671327591,
0.8026635646820068,
-0.5898914933204651,
1.1365854740142822,
0.7943673729896545,
-0.4309702217578888,
-0.8951393365859985,
0.11287558823823929,
-0.6549697518348694,
-0.416980504989624,
0.8806585669517517,
0.10332059860229492,
-0.10093861073255539,
0.14639827609062195,
-0.235731840133667,
-0.9526238441467285,
0.8106439113616943,
0.5932433009147644,
-0.6444220542907715,
-0.5028347373008728,
0.5706911683082581,
0.8430720567703247,
-0.56355220079422,
0.4074561893939972,
0.8607227802276611,
0.43880027532577515,
0.0021881037391722202,
-1.331578016281128,
-0.13031788170337677,
-0.4513590931892395,
0.1371365785598755,
0.19968336820602417,
-0.26424360275268555,
0.751857340335846,
-0.41160932183265686,
-0.2217061072587967,
-0.10618895292282104,
0.689117968082428,
-0.40492185950279236,
-0.11469355970621109,
0.4083351492881775,
0.5454736948013306,
0.5468940734863281,
-0.31608909368515015,
1.1195683479309082,
-0.7807777523994446,
0.08379331231117249,
1.0866615772247314,
0.2342517226934433,
0.8852176666259766,
0.3233524262905121,
0.04282532259821892,
0.4960254430770874,
0.6555967926979065,
0.10358840227127075,
0.7086653709411621,
-0.25075098872184753,
-0.005134998820722103,
-0.45863279700279236,
-0.14624187350273132,
-0.2929152846336365,
0.5535770058631897,
0.7235761880874634,
-0.5046476721763611,
0.11695413291454315,
0.3653111457824707,
-0.23913049697875977,
0.1760561615228653,
-0.6191678643226624,
1.0899032354354858,
-0.048747576773166656,
-0.8962560892105103,
0.7105187177658081,
0.06144478917121887,
0.6495212912559509,
-0.39574167132377625,
0.15588079392910004,
-0.04031876102089882,
0.4669577181339264,
-0.4150334298610687,
-0.828836977481842,
0.6371066570281982,
-0.2273533046245575,
-0.44149452447891235,
-0.052663471549749374,
1.008942723274231,
-0.866399347782135,
-0.5188989043235779,
0.3774424195289612,
0.3105686902999878,
-0.1853368729352951,
-0.12027385830879211,
-0.26156002283096313,
0.09744349867105484,
0.0712338462471962,
-0.04206348583102226,
0.16760137677192688,
0.615598201751709,
0.27911263704299927,
0.792875349521637,
0.48139724135398865,
0.16666638851165771,
0.13925202190876007,
-0.022033492103219032,
0.9089359045028687,
-0.5815586447715759,
-0.5914396047592163,
-0.8799474835395813,
0.5860663652420044,
-0.0012044785544276237,
-0.09383484721183777,
0.5801610350608826,
0.5341039896011353,
1.1854087114334106,
-0.3644593060016632,
0.9483977556228638,
-0.05094311013817787,
0.4432472586631775,
-0.7209165096282959,
0.6147164702415466,
-0.6249681115150452,
0.3219565153121948,
0.09802919626235962,
-0.5039985775947571,
-0.14212779700756073,
0.21310396492481232,
-0.7633873224258423,
0.06055770069360733,
0.6389318108558655,
0.9538552165031433,
-0.044410720467567444,
0.11265219002962112,
0.6214780807495117,
0.4143562912940979,
0.0010667548049241304,
0.8547030091285706,
0.5152261853218079,
-0.45161205530166626,
0.4746600389480591,
-0.45274877548217773,
0.15625809133052826,
0.15789031982421875,
-0.46217289566993713,
-1.3295018672943115,
-0.6908466815948486,
-0.005489693023264408,
-0.20382322371006012,
0.5953401923179626,
0.7414405345916748,
0.6331408023834229,
-0.7049239277839661,
-0.24350164830684662,
-0.37518298625946045,
-0.05866143852472305,
-0.04700983315706253,
-0.09255705773830414,
-0.0627574622631073,
-0.7352850437164307,
-0.9406248927116394,
0.36823123693466187,
0.15163221955299377,
-0.16238735616207123,
0.09227140247821808,
-0.07275272905826569,
-0.01803593710064888,
0.07142362743616104,
0.6993910670280457,
-0.23733140528202057,
-0.7134836912155151,
-0.32685279846191406,
0.0039460440166294575,
0.033929456025362015,
0.020785223692655563,
0.7208136320114136,
-0.6372905969619751,
0.47029995918273926,
0.6883574724197388,
0.6098970770835876,
0.4990829825401306,
-0.05309133976697922,
1.2217819690704346,
-0.7390584945678711,
0.21540431678295135,
0.09790218621492386,
0.5985165238380432,
0.13441778719425201,
-0.6906906962394714,
0.6390854120254517,
-0.027927938848733902,
-0.22480934858322144,
-0.48399898409843445,
0.10608243942260742,
-0.3898897171020508,
-0.35085421800613403,
1.071856141090393,
-0.21962806582450867,
-0.2538796067237854,
-0.25365152955055237,
-0.07239705324172974,
0.32224228978157043,
-0.19446338713169098,
0.7303330302238464,
0.931435227394104,
0.2593870162963867,
-0.6488279700279236,
-0.48164623975753784,
0.7726570963859558,
0.6108740568161011,
-0.7375361323356628,
-0.23519645631313324,
0.23622336983680725,
0.18044927716255188,
-0.11896122246980667,
0.24802909791469574,
0.1597907841205597,
0.43406942486763,
0.023947272449731827,
-0.1402769684791565,
-0.31359171867370605,
-0.5343949794769287,
-0.25913310050964355,
0.431824266910553,
0.15690362453460693,
0.1863725632429123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17583v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17583v1
|
FaultProfIT: Hierarchical Fault Profiling of Incident Tickets in Large-scale Cloud Systems
| 2024-02-27T15:14:19 | 2024-02-27T15:14:19 |
Junjie Huang, Jinyang Liu, Zhuangbin Chen, Zhihan Jiang, Yichen LI, Jiazhen Gu, Cong Feng, Zengyin Yang, Yongqiang Yang, Michael R. Lyu
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Postmortem analysis is essential in the management of incidents within cloud
systems, which provides valuable insights to improve system's reliability and
robustness. At CloudA, fault pattern profiling is performed during the
postmortem phase, which involves the classification of incidents' faults into
unique categories, referred to as fault pattern. By aggregating and analyzing
these fault patterns, engineers can discern common faults, vulnerable
components and emerging fault trends. However, this process is currently
conducted by manual labeling, which has inherent drawbacks. On the one hand,
the sheer volume of incidents means only the most severe ones are analyzed,
causing a skewed overview of fault patterns. On the other hand, the complexity
of the task demands extensive domain knowledge, which leads to errors and
inconsistencies. To address these limitations, we propose an automated
approach, named FaultProfIT, for Fault pattern Profiling of Incident Tickets.
It leverages hierarchy-guided contrastive learning to train a hierarchy-aware
incident encoder and predicts fault patterns with enhanced incident
representations. We evaluate FaultProfIT using the production incidents from
CloudA. The results demonstrate that FaultProfIT outperforms state-of-the-art
methods. Our ablation study and analysis also verify the effectiveness of
hierarchy-guided contrastive learning. Additionally, we have deployed
FaultProfIT at CloudA for six months. To date, FaultProfIT has analyzed 10,000+
incidents from 30+ cloud services, successfully revealing several fault trends
that have informed system improvements.
|
[
-0.487348735332489,
-0.6913560628890991,
0.3810068666934967,
0.44508883357048035,
-0.3210529088973999,
0.06385768949985504,
0.5727562308311462,
-0.4881354868412018,
0.1993281990289688,
0.41908907890319824,
-0.8803926110267639,
-0.24759553372859955,
-0.31332746148109436,
-0.28933966159820557,
-0.4603438675403595,
1.171021819114685,
0.014226301573216915,
0.04946990683674812,
-0.49490538239479065,
0.08649562299251556,
-0.3574961721897125,
-1.0259391069412231,
-0.9600132703781128,
-0.18128898739814758,
0.33073362708091736,
0.36689284443855286,
0.5588368773460388,
0.6111515760421753,
0.9182230830192566,
0.424774706363678,
-0.03425120562314987,
0.10002116113901138,
-0.0909700021147728,
0.06511471420526505,
-0.05718338489532471,
-0.1748374104499817,
-0.3675626814365387,
-0.37526601552963257,
0.35616806149482727,
0.6344742774963379,
-0.30326980352401733,
-0.006047237664461136,
0.2315194457769394,
0.3740980923175812,
-0.8532384037971497,
0.14092114567756653,
-0.5840270519256592,
0.18898263573646545,
-0.08210194855928421,
-0.29533469676971436,
0.003491794690489769,
-0.4217536449432373,
-0.15189577639102936,
-0.5320391654968262,
0.477335661649704,
-0.09903885424137115,
0.7202019691467285,
0.428272008895874,
-0.20909295976161957,
-0.13911749422550201,
-0.6571149826049805,
0.6113225817680359,
-0.3278746008872986,
0.13322360813617706,
0.33510637283325195,
0.4777664840221405,
-0.23299148678779602,
-0.6008110642433167,
-0.25631776452064514,
0.13674522936344147,
-0.15275809168815613,
0.12692904472351074,
0.19603970646858215,
-0.03535861521959305,
0.14820073544979095,
0.46606355905532837,
-0.7536177635192871,
0.414845734834671,
-0.006182805635035038,
-0.4300346374511719,
0.606909990310669,
0.4677310287952423,
-0.0494980625808239,
-0.056511107832193375,
-0.5323824286460876,
-0.13468106091022491,
-0.4484977126121521,
0.0025263286661356688,
0.24990494549274445,
-0.16880211234092712,
0.07526139914989471,
-0.24761724472045898,
-0.2341814935207367,
0.4183572232723236,
0.13998501002788544,
-0.08543793112039566,
0.4781583249568939,
-0.03556514531373978,
-0.505643367767334,
0.20251208543777466,
0.7362857460975647,
0.07214604318141937,
-0.2504635751247406,
-0.27647367119789124,
-0.33615148067474365,
-0.057009730488061905,
0.7064263224601746,
-0.9302921295166016,
-0.5517305135726929,
0.39897608757019043,
-0.28797775506973267,
-0.5331344604492188,
0.38407766819000244,
-1.0908936262130737,
-0.91309654712677,
-0.1914481669664383,
0.46514207124710083,
-0.37957048416137695,
-0.32256782054901123,
-0.02711676061153412,
0.04590635001659393,
0.20856721699237823,
0.3095977008342743,
-0.3066534399986267,
0.09943630546331406,
0.834044873714447,
0.760831356048584,
0.014321286231279373,
-0.3558768332004547,
-0.7846782207489014,
0.14541684091091156,
-0.5044047236442566,
1.005914568901062,
-0.23773515224456787,
-0.21484778821468353,
0.3943343460559845,
0.1301185041666031,
0.04442513361573219,
-0.8463316559791565,
0.8402518033981323,
-0.5693350434303284,
-0.3107500970363617,
-0.20822837948799133,
-0.15443484485149384,
-0.27155372500419617,
0.3829244077205658,
-0.48081016540527344,
0.8828822374343872,
0.1504373997449875,
-0.5407302975654602,
0.29558104276657104,
-0.43574318289756775,
-0.44007763266563416,
0.3255370557308197,
-0.2484235316514969,
-0.8835950493812561,
0.022983599454164505,
0.17642086744308472,
0.5592766404151917,
-0.004766936879605055,
0.35981106758117676,
-0.1957148313522339,
-0.17031899094581604,
-0.24409706890583038,
0.2920316755771637,
0.6242627501487732,
0.2860821485519409,
-0.5146187543869019,
0.10685256868600845,
-0.9900467991828918,
-0.16248708963394165,
0.13262861967086792,
-0.04550717771053314,
-0.46634969115257263,
0.2618333399295807,
0.12007926404476166,
0.28620725870132446,
0.14808204770088196,
-0.5660598278045654,
-0.13621871173381805,
-0.16280044615268707,
0.0346740186214447,
0.6994257569313049,
0.3162291944026947,
0.03150058910250664,
-0.41236287355422974,
0.49398186802864075,
0.6323639750480652,
0.7319985628128052,
-0.32603925466537476,
-0.026497088372707367,
-0.9138538837432861,
-0.0637514591217041,
-0.295684814453125,
0.7275177836418152,
-0.6966878771781921,
0.6797865033149719,
0.04411396011710167,
-0.5954291224479675,
0.00696147046983242,
-0.05128968507051468,
0.4943395256996155,
0.7447382807731628,
0.5735867619514465,
-0.4596162438392639,
-1.1281793117523193,
-1.1979079246520996,
-0.013238327577710152,
-0.30693304538726807,
-0.0698581263422966,
0.04083767160773277,
0.494986355304718,
-0.4776683449745178,
0.7710732221603394,
-0.5954751372337341,
-0.6176876425743103,
0.2793318033218384,
0.6029605865478516,
-0.07527121156454086,
0.746052622795105,
0.5206875801086426,
-0.8575938940048218,
0.10705221444368362,
0.18564744293689728,
-0.7623724341392517,
-0.19331957399845123,
-0.3705877661705017,
-0.026481816545128822,
0.2617323398590088,
0.7180604338645935,
0.003349082777276635,
0.06390417367219925,
0.5386760234832764,
-0.48656755685806274,
0.6033905744552612,
-0.005117871332913637,
0.47134771943092346,
-0.7789138555526733,
0.16059251129627228,
-0.14433354139328003,
-0.07347043603658676,
-0.6364350318908691,
0.0917302668094635,
0.23319071531295776,
-0.08857312798500061,
-0.339095801115036,
-0.37243229150772095,
-0.3007836937904358,
-0.3990359902381897,
-0.2881797254085541,
-0.4352874755859375,
-0.24936453998088837,
0.5109879970550537,
-0.037694673985242844,
0.4237079620361328,
0.5432812571525574,
-0.5992159843444824,
0.1446765661239624,
0.19899976253509521,
-0.47047561407089233,
0.6942062973976135,
-0.375413715839386,
0.22533351182937622,
-0.2359171360731125,
0.0013472806895151734,
-0.9591695070266724,
-0.16354914009571075,
-0.05497366935014725,
0.010429111309349537,
-0.0002182409807574004,
-0.1724534034729004,
-0.5338852405548096,
-0.05882054939866066,
-0.049015067517757416,
0.19177158176898956,
0.39857977628707886,
-0.326406329870224,
0.7597081065177917,
0.42953118681907654,
-0.37078994512557983,
-0.3665032982826233,
-0.38612866401672363,
0.10096454620361328,
-0.21695926785469055,
-0.6868346333503723,
0.345302551984787,
-0.0248055849224329,
-0.2531111538410187,
-0.2686724066734314,
-0.24579888582229614,
-0.4618675112724304,
0.5389646887779236,
0.7828122973442078,
-0.03631281107664108,
-0.3197852671146393,
-0.05477771908044815,
-0.09559503942728043,
-0.20866453647613525,
0.09552343934774399,
-0.08134883642196655,
0.728291928768158,
-0.3064256012439728,
-0.17286226153373718,
-0.5021346807479858,
0.6077957153320312,
0.6796165704727173,
-0.14806261658668518,
0.5997304320335388,
0.3802761435508728,
-0.48919677734375,
-0.2078259140253067,
-0.681137204170227,
-0.04249413684010506,
-0.5043224096298218,
0.47413498163223267,
-0.2647795081138611,
-0.6469572186470032,
0.8207195997238159,
-0.3441518247127533,
0.1553277224302292,
0.6921787261962891,
0.14961077272891998,
-0.21594437956809998,
0.8089914917945862,
0.8287396430969238,
-0.16530553996562958,
0.6002798676490784,
-0.19177982211112976,
-0.03609928488731384,
-0.32373765110969543,
-0.5023910999298096,
-0.8817946910858154,
-0.09792406111955643,
-0.15196166932582855,
-0.10604757070541382,
0.5657333731651306,
0.3561844527721405,
-0.5949115753173828,
0.11564270406961441,
-0.18063795566558838,
0.5379061102867126,
0.007654794491827488,
0.05422540009021759,
0.33383139967918396,
-0.12358906120061874,
0.3318779766559601,
0.1760106384754181,
-0.44003862142562866,
-0.18303282558918,
0.13700434565544128,
0.19574181735515594,
0.17039881646633148,
-0.054619595408439636,
0.6823687553405762,
0.3070659041404724,
0.42658668756484985,
-0.5417740345001221,
0.3615853786468506,
-0.2312278300523758,
-0.23168599605560303,
-0.22419612109661102,
-0.391861230134964,
-0.7405197620391846,
0.09857747703790665,
0.02852223813533783,
-0.29639774560928345,
0.723615825176239,
0.25972428917884827,
-0.2986198961734772,
0.1182505190372467,
-0.6462771892547607,
0.8548726439476013,
-0.11160661280155182,
0.13238446414470673,
-0.14288701117038727,
-0.40486007928848267,
0.2743918299674988,
-0.561865508556366,
0.4624254107475281,
0.561735987663269,
0.008879709988832474,
1.028481364250183,
-0.8407341241836548,
0.8882238268852234,
-0.3756358325481415,
-0.19235070049762726,
0.10509604215621948,
0.2517774999141693,
0.8889294862747192,
-0.31486010551452637,
-0.09639859199523926,
0.280695378780365,
-0.215582937002182,
-0.34352752566337585,
-0.5241737365722656,
0.5772200226783752,
-0.7719721794128418,
-0.35091543197631836,
-0.3238774240016937,
-0.22996437549591064,
-0.4313378930091858,
0.030945973470807076,
0.2046460211277008,
0.4034983813762665,
-0.06069157272577286,
0.2293192744255066,
0.675206184387207,
-0.1915891468524933,
0.6864408850669861,
0.7496512532234192,
0.24416449666023254,
-0.3948206305503845,
0.7838507294654846,
0.31007179617881775,
-0.20960219204425812,
0.19254904985427856,
0.1134505420923233,
0.16325195133686066,
-0.969088077545166,
-0.18861204385757446,
-0.07976537197828293,
-0.5902425050735474,
-0.45985016226768494,
-0.8847359418869019,
-0.26098668575286865,
-0.25916343927383423,
-0.4892001748085022,
-0.4014381766319275,
-0.07565199583768845,
0.013713853433728218,
-0.20051458477973938,
0.22033266723155975,
0.414379358291626,
0.032249871641397476,
0.7028598785400391,
-0.7655479907989502,
0.19951483607292175,
0.11840158700942993,
0.3341810703277588,
-0.12053413689136505,
-0.30688875913619995,
-0.2847021818161011,
-0.4014436602592468,
-0.5502917766571045,
-0.7918628454208374,
0.33536314964294434,
0.42683669924736023,
0.5357157588005066,
0.689653217792511,
0.07016012817621231,
1.0961703062057495,
-0.4115760028362274,
0.8749943971633911,
0.26971912384033203,
-1.0464532375335693,
0.8992699384689331,
-0.38766810297966003,
-0.023814326152205467,
0.6615965962409973,
0.6037255525588989,
-0.4725773334503174,
-0.5308579206466675,
-0.7430421113967896,
-1.0310782194137573,
0.7712485194206238,
-0.07750387489795685,
-0.24037715792655945,
0.2451542168855667,
0.45136719942092896,
0.13449575006961823,
0.1294703185558319,
-0.2160874307155609,
-0.29624828696250916,
-0.45851871371269226,
-0.01910058967769146,
-0.3126746118068695,
-0.18163201212882996,
-0.05608587712049484,
-0.03378462791442871,
0.591827929019928,
-0.1726345717906952,
-0.06255433708429337,
0.33644747734069824,
-0.1877257078886032,
-0.4246889352798462,
-0.13105368614196777,
0.5436127781867981,
0.6327221393585205,
-0.18921639025211334,
0.20362581312656403,
0.07480712234973907,
-0.7329344153404236,
-0.06576789170503616,
0.15229034423828125,
-0.08801211416721344,
-0.06248954311013222,
0.555410623550415,
0.3794519901275635,
0.04196057841181755,
-0.6119070649147034,
0.5107869505882263,
0.3048080801963806,
-0.45536500215530396,
-0.5868222117424011,
0.05146680399775505,
-0.21946030855178833,
0.25587159395217896,
0.7014506459236145,
-0.10062510520219803,
0.4927372634410858,
-0.6519747972488403,
0.5804969072341919,
0.28061404824256897,
-0.53046715259552,
-0.055350303649902344,
0.3452785313129425,
0.1741819530725479,
-0.3149608075618744,
0.5472859740257263,
0.156169593334198,
-0.7053679823875427,
1.138669729232788,
0.22214031219482422,
1.0893491506576538,
-0.8365248441696167,
0.3313353955745697,
0.3429413139820099,
0.3979112207889557,
-0.004171090666204691,
0.19678494334220886,
-0.024580983445048332,
-0.6131707429885864,
-0.2788596451282501,
-0.9674011468887329,
-0.33810123801231384,
0.6981661319732666,
-0.5555332899093628,
-0.019981469959020615,
-0.7503453493118286,
0.30295413732528687,
0.006437042728066444,
-0.011626146733760834,
-0.34951329231262207,
0.5121912360191345,
-0.1245744377374649,
0.6556231379508972,
-1.23073410987854,
0.43672701716423035,
0.7914350628852844,
-0.2957504987716675,
-0.7011019587516785,
-0.018745286390185356,
0.042431216686964035,
-0.39565509557724,
0.5872359275817871,
0.17257361114025116,
0.21845687925815582,
-0.038881585001945496,
-0.3079526126384735,
-0.615073025226593,
1.0945039987564087,
0.25639280676841736,
-0.7317423224449158,
0.41887396574020386,
0.18782316148281097,
0.6095550060272217,
-0.2848549485206604,
0.1241353377699852,
0.5633664131164551,
0.3795013129711151,
0.22855359315872192,
-0.5525815486907959,
0.1275615692138672,
-0.30057215690612793,
-0.2282349318265915,
0.4973965585231781,
-0.5736076235771179,
0.6774161458015442,
0.18930397927761078,
-0.18031226098537445,
-0.41892287135124207,
0.44174689054489136,
0.013345791958272457,
0.5923432111740112,
0.9379780888557434,
0.5339395403862,
0.6503962874412537,
-0.0740472599864006,
0.9434954524040222,
-0.023040959611535072,
0.16922447085380554,
0.8008648157119751,
-0.10085846483707428,
0.6115410923957825,
0.5348513126373291,
0.09416934102773666,
0.7756344676017761,
0.8783947825431824,
-0.20079410076141357,
0.512547492980957,
0.08342339843511581,
-0.10184736549854279,
-0.5909905433654785,
-0.03281480446457863,
-0.2978266477584839,
0.08512653410434723,
0.12509262561798096,
-0.3573133945465088,
-0.38317352533340454,
0.08933469653129578,
-0.03916078060865402,
-0.4162779450416565,
-0.6918455958366394,
1.1133010387420654,
-0.08575080335140228,
-0.5715628862380981,
0.5952189564704895,
-0.14443635940551758,
0.47165951132774353,
-0.6124047040939331,
0.0016914826119318604,
-0.5886442065238953,
0.3114640712738037,
-0.6675384640693665,
-0.4636381268501282,
0.7922353148460388,
-0.041502732783555984,
-0.1688441038131714,
-0.16302490234375,
0.44986289739608765,
0.022642703726887703,
-0.2197524458169937,
0.22602050006389618,
0.16653841733932495,
0.1324552595615387,
-0.5200949907302856,
-0.34879499673843384,
0.11495479196310043,
-0.2540576457977295,
-0.13051526248455048,
0.543240487575531,
0.30181989073753357,
-0.4782909154891968,
0.4536755383014679,
0.5176646113395691,
-0.1794607788324356,
-0.1559993475675583,
0.04419777914881706,
0.9528868794441223,
-0.4782806634902954,
-0.7651816010475159,
-0.6794686317443848,
0.8771185278892517,
-0.1710098385810852,
-0.4113958775997162,
0.38994890451431274,
0.6134650111198425,
0.6014274954795837,
-0.14426127076148987,
0.5993970036506653,
0.061671093106269836,
0.016095055267214775,
-0.4225659966468811,
0.46030643582344055,
-0.638020932674408,
0.2521909773349762,
-0.32158589363098145,
-0.6011544466018677,
-0.4157193601131439,
0.414863258600235,
-0.0875084176659584,
-0.2487095147371292,
0.7612103223800659,
0.9094269871711731,
0.050514332950115204,
0.20077025890350342,
0.16906213760375977,
0.3497907221317291,
0.3958364725112915,
0.5135579109191895,
0.9862387776374817,
-0.5245917439460754,
0.6870596408843994,
-0.3052789270877838,
-0.629889965057373,
-0.440839946269989,
-0.8726863861083984,
-0.3929069936275482,
-0.7601208686828613,
-0.7961557507514954,
-0.08333519846200943,
0.15899713337421417,
0.21219682693481445,
0.8264731168746948,
-1.0360803604125977,
0.05277576297521591,
-0.4704248011112213,
-0.05647166445851326,
-0.5382059812545776,
-0.24030421674251556,
0.5152941942214966,
-0.5406572222709656,
-0.24415543675422668,
0.36032843589782715,
0.14167597889900208,
-0.1059369370341301,
-0.01987575739622116,
0.07179997861385345,
0.32205936312675476,
-0.1001715213060379,
0.6568878889083862,
0.1251872330904007,
0.021842727437615395,
-0.30562248826026917,
-0.4788792133331299,
-0.03889867290854454,
-0.1281621754169464,
1.174445390701294,
-0.7285589575767517,
-0.3203316628932953,
0.6596091389656067,
0.781252384185791,
0.3711899220943451,
0.1542660892009735,
0.3472871780395508,
-0.9015650153160095,
0.0676494836807251,
0.37958669662475586,
0.3489934504032135,
0.15942074358463287,
-0.8363139033317566,
0.4562450051307678,
0.49116575717926025,
-0.6448496580123901,
-1.0102221965789795,
0.30664563179016113,
-1.0838123559951782,
-0.5927513241767883,
0.9287896156311035,
-0.1012134701013565,
0.06690964102745056,
-0.6745719909667969,
-0.032777298241853714,
0.1567111760377884,
0.14888665080070496,
1.0844011306762695,
0.3727090358734131,
-0.28776460886001587,
-0.5086503028869629,
-0.18546205759048462,
0.8326575756072998,
0.29850754141807556,
-1.3172485828399658,
-0.06605733931064606,
0.6062840223312378,
0.10946639627218246,
0.543512761592865,
0.2757154703140259,
-0.31309351325035095,
0.4050537347793579,
0.06168505176901817,
0.15783926844596863,
-0.3231070637702942,
-0.50468909740448,
-0.671342670917511,
0.9092180132865906,
-0.35213160514831543,
-0.2804976999759674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17574v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17574v3
|
Agent-Pro: Learning to Evolve via Policy-Level Reflection and Optimization
| 2024-02-27T15:09:20 | 2024-06-06T18:40:47 |
Wenqi Zhang, Ke Tang, Hai Wu, Mengna Wang, Yongliang Shen, Guiyang Hou, Zeqi Tan, Peng Li, Yueting Zhuang, Weiming Lu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit robust problem-solving capabilities for
diverse tasks. However, most LLM-based agents are designed as specific task
solvers with sophisticated prompt engineering, rather than agents capable of
learning and evolving through interactions. These task solvers necessitate
manually crafted prompts to inform task rules and regulate LLM behaviors,
inherently incapacitating to address complex dynamic scenarios e.g., large
interactive games. In light of this, we propose Agent-Pro: an LLM-based Agent
with Policy-level Reflection and Optimization that can learn a wealth of
expertise from interactive experiences and progressively elevate its behavioral
policy. Specifically, it involves a dynamic belief generation and reflection
process for policy evolution. Rather than action-level reflection, Agent-Pro
iteratively reflects on past trajectories and beliefs, fine-tuning its
irrational beliefs for a better policy. Moreover, a depth-first search is
employed for policy optimization, ensuring continual enhancement in policy
payoffs. Agent-Pro is evaluated across two games: Blackjack and Texas Hold'em,
outperforming vanilla LLM and specialized models. Our results show Agent-Pro
can learn and evolve in complex and dynamic scenes, which also benefits
numerous LLM-based applications.
|
[
-0.36616674065589905,
-0.8321251273155212,
0.7122511863708496,
0.21553832292556763,
0.04546785354614258,
0.6739734411239624,
-0.24397717416286469,
-0.2936484217643738,
0.04387505725026131,
0.5503230690956116,
-0.7451245188713074,
-0.3363848328590393,
-0.27440404891967773,
0.08132237941026688,
0.5902596712112427,
1.11263906955719,
0.034359317272901535,
-0.14706605672836304,
-0.0155512485653162,
0.26985621452331543,
-0.6509355306625366,
0.02421778254210949,
-1.0707457065582275,
-0.5750826001167297,
0.3417666554450989,
0.3434910476207733,
0.78073650598526,
0.4072239398956299,
0.14162330329418182,
0.3308948576450348,
0.12474462389945984,
0.8548586964607239,
-0.6891844868659973,
0.378808856010437,
-0.46578195691108704,
-0.4167669415473938,
-0.5855311155319214,
0.012033852748572826,
0.46368205547332764,
0.10073983669281006,
-0.21187782287597656,
-0.21889813244342804,
0.05990981310606003,
0.2395118623971939,
-0.611526608467102,
0.5708529949188232,
-0.6734473705291748,
0.08483382314443588,
0.4768750071525574,
-0.4420703947544098,
-0.4374946653842926,
-0.3267342448234558,
0.23487594723701477,
-0.9238941669464111,
-0.17307578027248383,
-0.09458119422197342,
0.7005183100700378,
0.2422439157962799,
-0.3844497501850128,
-0.33385559916496277,
-1.0372899770736694,
0.5923306345939636,
-0.30809587240219116,
0.08666300773620605,
-0.05514707416296005,
0.5792887806892395,
-0.7026066184043884,
-0.3918367028236389,
-0.5962216258049011,
-0.6139597296714783,
0.3692706227302551,
0.2706804871559143,
0.0659606084227562,
0.40550097823143005,
-0.006257920991629362,
-0.0695747584104538,
-0.08675320446491241,
0.14511169493198395,
0.2923595905303955,
-0.019683636724948883,
0.7591047286987305,
0.3094354271888733,
0.11465790122747421,
0.4681073725223541,
-0.1172356829047203,
-0.3003433644771576,
-0.7028862237930298,
0.3288048207759857,
0.4189225733280182,
0.3700653612613678,
0.22561277449131012,
0.025471670553088188,
-0.07250688970088959,
0.29759734869003296,
0.14997775852680206,
-0.496598482131958,
0.10281979292631149,
0.18019971251487732,
0.28437885642051697,
-0.03553609922528267,
0.4481460750102997,
0.025030717253684998,
0.4362982213497162,
-0.23600903153419495,
-0.5267480611801147,
-0.07889792323112488,
0.6195855736732483,
-0.4054161310195923,
0.024915721267461777,
0.21366919577121735,
-0.07485795766115189,
-0.4571598470211029,
-0.008753130212426186,
-0.848106861114502,
-0.767741322517395,
-0.35661908984184265,
0.7864847779273987,
-0.1771736890077591,
-0.30150213837623596,
0.3481614589691162,
-0.12156923860311508,
0.3304609954357147,
0.5944527387619019,
-0.5192957520484924,
0.31419873237609863,
0.9014990925788879,
0.5757625102996826,
-0.207839235663414,
-0.30606609582901,
-0.773948609828949,
0.22237171232700348,
-0.52521812915802,
0.7485120296478271,
-0.8398249745368958,
-0.5518603920936584,
0.36729320883750916,
-0.034347645938396454,
0.12303006649017334,
-0.6904533505439758,
0.2609715461730957,
-0.6106317043304443,
-0.20650087296962738,
-0.22410209476947784,
-0.30456358194351196,
-0.022807233035564423,
0.5183779001235962,
-0.4564410448074341,
0.8492609858512878,
0.0848684310913086,
-0.06450130045413971,
0.6059380769729614,
-1.0938087701797485,
-0.24763710796833038,
0.4587755799293518,
-0.39076581597328186,
-0.3568415641784668,
0.3856233060359955,
-0.04814706742763519,
0.015099280513823032,
-0.1975613236427307,
0.23721836507320404,
-0.34231245517730713,
-0.3459315299987793,
0.17681054770946503,
-0.1710626184940338,
0.3165789842605591,
0.08851774036884308,
-0.5646765828132629,
0.21328578889369965,
-0.5013914704322815,
-0.23483982682228088,
0.2659291625022888,
-0.43046823143959045,
-0.06722047924995422,
0.6705000996589661,
-0.5679276585578918,
0.2658320665359497,
0.4084464907646179,
-0.6016703844070435,
0.5362949371337891,
-0.379087895154953,
0.1537030190229416,
0.8211259841918945,
0.29545268416404724,
0.34231287240982056,
-0.49747031927108765,
0.7761385440826416,
-0.08446891605854034,
0.43313172459602356,
0.03992437571287155,
-0.23834265768527985,
-0.6044765710830688,
-0.2315901815891266,
-0.3204750418663025,
0.7118832468986511,
-0.9500015377998352,
0.16304588317871094,
-0.15080814063549042,
-0.36168715357780457,
-0.4003288745880127,
-0.031614743173122406,
0.323611319065094,
0.29446157813072205,
0.38233235478401184,
-0.183913916349411,
-0.10607586055994034,
-0.6603338718414307,
-0.4083411693572998,
-0.13329315185546875,
0.2966544032096863,
0.6578526496887207,
0.5231568813323975,
-0.14744225144386292,
0.9044044613838196,
-0.5906835198402405,
-0.393261581659317,
-0.32325538992881775,
0.11150448769330978,
0.07232026755809784,
0.32721662521362305,
0.4235411584377289,
-0.49078020453453064,
-0.6034609079360962,
0.21113704144954681,
-0.5853849649429321,
-0.010074399411678314,
-0.4881858825683594,
-0.13214924931526184,
0.016018666326999664,
0.19013303518295288,
-0.7122606635093689,
0.11775168031454086,
-0.01983514428138733,
-0.4775633215904236,
0.7563918828964233,
-0.569955050945282,
-0.13851866126060486,
-0.5892452001571655,
-0.36248791217803955,
-0.14719800651073456,
-0.4571830928325653,
-0.5312671065330505,
0.2848655581474304,
-0.4502740800380707,
0.030130742117762566,
-0.19868870079517365,
0.7455745935440063,
-0.5806474685668945,
-0.16297698020935059,
-0.6939570307731628,
0.13643048703670502,
-0.04944981634616852,
0.42318353056907654,
0.3947733938694,
0.9173758625984192,
0.6925532817840576,
-0.6128631830215454,
0.2914482057094574,
0.07255272567272186,
-0.17714419960975647,
0.3047046363353729,
-0.4433309733867645,
0.20185305178165436,
-0.27869608998298645,
0.05712044611573219,
-0.5333588719367981,
0.07475366443395615,
0.14667272567749023,
-0.03804323822259903,
0.3851078450679779,
0.16632850468158722,
-0.40845340490341187,
-0.23706308007240295,
-0.35982295870780945,
-0.03410191461443901,
0.6203604936599731,
-0.3478243350982666,
0.9335025548934937,
0.4193674921989441,
-0.06500543653964996,
-0.7407722473144531,
0.12365268170833588,
0.0752716138958931,
-0.0346912145614624,
-0.18247665464878082,
0.3404596149921417,
-0.024645483121275902,
-0.34498217701911926,
-0.15203016996383667,
-0.19712340831756592,
0.4007919430732727,
0.1659332662820816,
-0.07367893308401108,
-0.05165046080946922,
-0.10386858880519867,
0.021342808380723,
0.3217617869377136,
-0.11676184087991714,
0.1547061949968338,
-0.40121397376060486,
0.5898162722587585,
-0.35096603631973267,
-0.04735209420323372,
-0.021758509799838066,
0.2115546315908432,
0.364911288022995,
-0.48109182715415955,
0.7161139845848083,
0.23365084826946259,
-0.039072275161743164,
-0.8666887879371643,
-0.4268793761730194,
-0.2868993878364563,
-0.6069657802581787,
0.5802038311958313,
-0.668671727180481,
-0.8700892329216003,
0.6885807514190674,
-0.6501312255859375,
0.4359957277774811,
0.07298257201910019,
0.42609167098999023,
-0.19139187037944794,
1.2175567150115967,
0.5890643000602722,
0.5761196613311768,
0.6043214201927185,
-0.2417420744895935,
-0.11445528268814087,
-0.4029029607772827,
-0.39908596873283386,
-0.0237595085054636,
-0.36478933691978455,
-0.6784618496894836,
-0.4689428508281708,
0.5385299921035767,
-0.17357824742794037,
-0.6622024774551392,
-0.009158434346318245,
-0.35444897413253784,
0.7809023857116699,
0.2989060580730438,
0.384244441986084,
0.08204320818185806,
-0.3226413428783417,
0.019588062539696693,
0.13190512359142303,
-0.38041648268699646,
-0.5411832332611084,
0.769384503364563,
0.5134817361831665,
0.5936663150787354,
0.22338630259037018,
0.8042688965797424,
0.628292977809906,
0.27910131216049194,
-0.6512301564216614,
0.6645694375038147,
-0.11574426293373108,
-0.4229298532009125,
-0.38481107354164124,
-0.10206247866153717,
-0.9095242023468018,
0.2868591248989105,
-0.501186192035675,
-0.6448033452033997,
0.45377853512763977,
0.3296361267566681,
-0.330425888299942,
0.05964157357811928,
-0.21562087535858154,
0.8212780356407166,
-0.49280741810798645,
-0.6237010955810547,
-0.4078148603439331,
-0.3488214612007141,
-0.008851070888340473,
-0.1048927903175354,
0.1843026876449585,
-0.08171748369932175,
-0.5483956336975098,
0.19160319864749908,
-0.38806986808776855,
0.7749404311180115,
-0.6792582273483276,
-0.316058874130249,
0.47609055042266846,
0.5851136445999146,
0.9710265398025513,
0.1216629147529602,
-0.03909733146429062,
-0.4660581350326538,
-0.21648970246315002,
-0.3088860511779785,
-0.754166305065155,
0.33834514021873474,
-0.9860970377922058,
-0.9487395882606506,
-0.29398319125175476,
-0.5732895731925964,
-0.4515845477581024,
0.12230177223682404,
-0.3157791793346405,
0.21205492317676544,
-0.24422606825828552,
-0.05323933809995651,
0.7762730121612549,
-0.3605602979660034,
0.2963675856590271,
0.8787006735801697,
-0.30678802728652954,
-0.21330325305461884,
1.2112778425216675,
-0.045564863830804825,
0.15728142857551575,
0.2903795838356018,
0.46518293023109436,
-0.3089529871940613,
-0.6657935976982117,
0.09222644567489624,
0.28641924262046814,
-0.5392935276031494,
-0.16306760907173157,
-0.2946683466434479,
0.013949807733297348,
0.0546882189810276,
-0.2430027425289154,
-0.5315515995025635,
0.21353919804096222,
-0.2048354595899582,
-0.17348600924015045,
0.18440929055213928,
0.6316196918487549,
-0.09673691540956497,
0.6262540817260742,
-0.43542587757110596,
-0.002431242261081934,
0.2734683156013489,
0.22190357744693756,
-0.20163245499134064,
-0.3578996956348419,
-0.2075798362493515,
0.004926380701363087,
-0.5275623798370361,
-1.0505794286727905,
0.4421359598636627,
0.803013265132904,
0.791751503944397,
0.6509310603141785,
0.2322694957256317,
0.2687075138092041,
-0.46798986196517944,
0.6334762573242188,
-0.2946469485759735,
-0.7534080743789673,
0.5376906991004944,
-0.5598846673965454,
0.07315365970134735,
0.6636834144592285,
0.260288268327713,
-0.10725835710763931,
-0.576022744178772,
-0.22576464712619781,
-0.43171244859695435,
0.6912035346031189,
-0.30164268612861633,
0.4280071556568146,
-0.20479898154735565,
0.7096256017684937,
0.4624128043651581,
0.48009809851646423,
-0.6628921627998352,
-0.04154323413968086,
-0.22692209482192993,
0.0016167907742783427,
-0.15600213408470154,
-0.06910507380962372,
-0.15705671906471252,
-0.14692702889442444,
0.4711308479309082,
-0.5894170999526978,
0.38061144948005676,
0.048234693706035614,
-0.058124955743551254,
0.1378311812877655,
0.09707820415496826,
0.7736993432044983,
0.5579028725624084,
-0.10423550754785538,
0.1572371870279312,
0.21302226185798645,
-0.4922347962856293,
0.34136998653411865,
-0.09493320435285568,
-0.1901630461215973,
-0.4303601086139679,
0.34394341707229614,
0.9765950441360474,
0.03747599944472313,
-0.9629817008972168,
0.496231347322464,
0.25957274436950684,
-0.3793877363204956,
-0.45322832465171814,
0.663714587688446,
-0.1758718192577362,
0.8362805843353271,
0.40541666746139526,
-0.36431851983070374,
0.08553174883127213,
-0.9039372205734253,
0.2517646551132202,
0.5383747220039368,
-0.3848389983177185,
-0.33385366201400757,
0.639898419380188,
0.2830997109413147,
-0.6627166867256165,
0.3280191421508789,
-0.6500304341316223,
-0.6043067574501038,
0.6283803582191467,
0.7549796104431152,
0.9537013173103333,
-0.2348414659500122,
0.8141814470291138,
0.0767064169049263,
0.1133294627070427,
-0.12135599553585052,
0.7331768274307251,
-0.1357351690530777,
-0.9359443783760071,
-0.4856661856174469,
-0.604168176651001,
-0.3798059821128845,
-0.017809784039855003,
-0.26181837916374207,
0.2180682271718979,
-0.6745693683624268,
-0.45332878828048706,
-0.37803253531455994,
0.3761293292045593,
-0.6217549443244934,
0.05452745407819748,
0.06004386395215988,
0.8092870712280273,
-0.691490888595581,
0.6419016122817993,
0.8820518255233765,
-0.42732444405555725,
-0.4764053523540497,
-0.05834595486521721,
-0.15599365532398224,
-1.003116250038147,
0.6435692310333252,
-0.03488399088382721,
-0.3428212106227875,
0.15289893746376038,
-0.6883494257926941,
-0.5501833558082581,
1.0713465213775635,
0.6156433820724487,
-0.5221701860427856,
-0.32169875502586365,
0.17563821375370026,
0.835008978843689,
-0.8303993940353394,
0.3293823301792145,
0.5979459285736084,
0.39212360978126526,
0.008923375979065895,
-0.6760736107826233,
-0.06327243149280548,
0.05705823749303818,
-0.19467033445835114,
0.13460305333137512,
-0.8982397317886353,
0.7052187323570251,
-0.3390029966831207,
0.12491237372159958,
-0.5148116946220398,
0.7291075587272644,
0.48116686940193176,
0.24699151515960693,
0.6620802283287048,
0.087950699031353,
0.5249629616737366,
0.0773102343082428,
0.7034296989440918,
-0.323727011680603,
0.1302763670682907,
1.0686144828796387,
-0.5227956175804138,
0.6877070069313049,
0.15979863703250885,
0.03868357837200165,
0.8861730098724365,
0.5954593420028687,
-0.04168666899204254,
0.74245285987854,
0.2875676453113556,
-0.5416895747184753,
-0.8181768655776978,
-0.2537461221218109,
0.25674858689308167,
0.7189419269561768,
0.4914103150367737,
-0.06428754329681396,
-0.23183777928352356,
0.12094666808843613,
0.005138323176652193,
0.2552652060985565,
-0.35716864466667175,
1.094261646270752,
-0.0765409842133522,
-0.8334071040153503,
0.029139768332242966,
-0.21062533557415009,
0.4410272538661957,
-0.5971711874008179,
-0.4416600465774536,
-0.23168592154979706,
0.3075888752937317,
0.15838725864887238,
-0.7690944075584412,
-0.041386160999536514,
-0.3659316301345825,
0.21259330213069916,
-0.2540301978588104,
0.7191745042800903,
-0.38170045614242554,
0.0684431791305542,
0.4437321722507477,
0.5794572830200195,
0.13479658961296082,
-0.032000832259655,
-0.8291751742362976,
-0.03540126234292984,
-0.33957260847091675,
-0.5507609844207764,
0.3579505383968353,
0.4245538115501404,
-0.07364426553249359,
0.9737509489059448,
0.2513570487499237,
0.2869158685207367,
-0.16754747927188873,
-0.21076956391334534,
0.7911388278007507,
-0.3100329339504242,
-0.7331492304801941,
-0.727027416229248,
0.4445820748806,
-0.2226337194442749,
-0.12482722848653793,
0.21285870671272278,
0.4185332655906677,
0.526073157787323,
-0.11203970015048981,
0.7083560824394226,
0.2642959654331207,
0.17623010277748108,
-0.2810800075531006,
0.6143251061439514,
-0.8111704587936401,
0.20222924649715424,
-0.05692940205335617,
-1.2026185989379883,
0.06631182879209518,
0.6831647157669067,
-0.4248942732810974,
0.2424573451280594,
0.29259464144706726,
0.6836363077163696,
0.25735169649124146,
-0.35583019256591797,
0.3145788609981537,
0.12564559280872345,
0.65840083360672,
0.4963747560977936,
0.9491569399833679,
0.1979682594537735,
0.38204720616340637,
0.1810896247625351,
-0.3859069347381592,
-0.18145102262496948,
-0.75819993019104,
-0.8204389810562134,
-0.38211673498153687,
-0.49604517221450806,
-0.26049843430519104,
0.3537304103374481,
1.211390495300293,
0.4824411869049072,
-0.5121411085128784,
-0.2603205442428589,
-0.2789078652858734,
0.029275944456458092,
-0.595656156539917,
-0.23632080852985382,
0.2046307921409607,
-0.710810661315918,
-0.6582558155059814,
0.6776424050331116,
0.2859070897102356,
-0.12735848128795624,
-0.48718059062957764,
-0.537593424320221,
0.05398344248533249,
0.6576878428459167,
0.6802628636360168,
0.6192955374717712,
-0.4897826910018921,
-0.6194226145744324,
0.05095379799604416,
0.09951727092266083,
-0.04660487547516823,
0.7092921137809753,
-0.7566465735435486,
0.7086920738220215,
0.24316085875034332,
0.614923894405365,
0.384901762008667,
-0.044938091188669205,
0.864287793636322,
-0.4573928415775299,
-0.14208777248859406,
0.47042158246040344,
-0.08179247379302979,
-0.26546958088874817,
-0.3119039833545685,
0.2804780900478363,
0.11159158498048782,
-0.6456080079078674,
-0.9831122756004333,
0.3914380371570587,
-0.7208036184310913,
-0.4375564455986023,
1.0645036697387695,
-0.2445032000541687,
-0.11655760556459427,
-0.24113303422927856,
-0.39163723587989807,
0.09016429632902145,
-0.6023357510566711,
0.7683575749397278,
0.34265774488449097,
-0.5008550882339478,
-0.5256057977676392,
-0.4432787597179413,
0.9970722198486328,
0.14227190613746643,
-0.7964481115341187,
0.035695869475603104,
0.363229364156723,
0.09086491912603378,
0.06477435678243637,
0.6099591255187988,
0.2519538998603821,
0.2273338884115219,
0.3749191164970398,
0.14395096898078918,
-0.4689202904701233,
-0.8292376399040222,
0.0022266069427132607,
0.3227244019508362,
0.4922550618648529,
-0.08748149871826172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17564v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17564v2
|
Unleashing the Potential of Large Language Models as Prompt Optimizers: An Analogical Analysis with Gradient-based Model Optimizers
| 2024-02-27T15:05:32 | 2024-04-17T03:17:58 |
Xinyu Tang, Xiaolei Wang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Siyuan Lu, Yaliang Li, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic prompt optimization is an important approach to improving the
performance of large language models (LLMs). Recent research demonstrates the
potential of using LLMs as prompt optimizers, which can generate improved task
prompts via iterative refinement. In this paper, we propose a novel perspective
to investigate the design of LLM-based prompt optimizers, by drawing an analogy
with gradient-based model optimizers. To connect these two approaches, we
identify two pivotal factors in model parameter learning: update direction and
update method. Focused on the two aspects, we borrow the theoretical framework
and learning methods from gradient-based optimization to design improved
strategies for LLM-based prompt optimizers. By systematically analyzing a rich
set of improvement strategies, we further develop a capable Gradient-inspired
LLM-based Prompt Optimizer called GPO. At each step, it first retrieves
relevant prompts from the optimization trajectory as the update direction.
Then, it utilizes the generation-based refinement strategy to perform the
update, while controlling the edit distance through a cosine-based decay
strategy. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness and efficiency of
GPO. In particular, GPO brings an additional improvement of up to 56.8% on
Big-Bench Hard and 55.3% on MMLU compared to baseline methods.
|
[
-0.29710692167282104,
-0.7566826939582825,
0.7931931614875793,
0.015898190438747406,
-0.38113877177238464,
0.019585156813263893,
-0.3530873656272888,
-0.00711627583950758,
-0.10651221871376038,
0.15217754244804382,
-0.9672020077705383,
-0.34603142738342285,
-0.19962584972381592,
0.2741932272911072,
0.19884860515594482,
0.8813712000846863,
-0.037984441965818405,
0.2954828441143036,
-0.09041028469800949,
0.05831526964902878,
-0.666907548904419,
-0.16393452882766724,
-1.30202317237854,
-0.09847883135080338,
0.6701390743255615,
0.13873206079006195,
0.5993061065673828,
0.9021768569946289,
0.08345039188861847,
0.3228931427001953,
-0.2706865966320038,
0.06113485246896744,
-0.515057384967804,
0.32780638337135315,
-0.01976761780679226,
-0.475266695022583,
-0.1817346215248108,
-0.0428931899368763,
0.7338050007820129,
0.7198529839515686,
-0.2947079539299011,
-0.03751540556550026,
0.1606651097536087,
0.751355767250061,
-0.5895037651062012,
0.24818721413612366,
-0.6342674493789673,
-0.006611361633986235,
0.20459884405136108,
-0.42233380675315857,
-0.2437134087085724,
-0.49781790375709534,
-0.09904807060956955,
-0.7767088413238525,
0.16609589755535126,
0.289614200592041,
0.46767285466194153,
0.30020982027053833,
0.09523118287324905,
-0.4494551718235016,
-0.3899822235107422,
1.0126187801361084,
-0.8368045687675476,
0.2405945211648941,
-0.19101062417030334,
0.4485280513763428,
-0.5426372289657593,
-0.450897216796875,
-0.3707362711429596,
-0.6969804763793945,
0.09884583950042725,
-0.1511552929878235,
-0.09851609915494919,
0.2256070077419281,
0.44214171171188354,
0.13906651735305786,
-0.49185237288475037,
0.5741747617721558,
-0.007793717086315155,
-0.06596128642559052,
0.5010294914245605,
0.2842614948749542,
0.4238309860229492,
0.051093462854623795,
-0.3475912809371948,
0.011330311186611652,
-0.8027943968772888,
0.46909385919570923,
0.44735923409461975,
0.4185566306114197,
0.10657890141010284,
0.06446845829486847,
-0.21169814467430115,
0.9421484470367432,
0.42511096596717834,
-0.22700351476669312,
0.18428458273410797,
-0.22909198701381683,
-0.0031363232992589474,
-0.22254543006420135,
0.7493932247161865,
0.41652244329452515,
0.24566051363945007,
-0.1503789722919464,
-0.5797517895698547,
-0.38179323077201843,
0.08973158895969391,
-0.730471134185791,
0.17863263189792633,
0.17406898736953735,
-0.4434521496295929,
-0.3238012194633484,
-0.21869155764579773,
-0.8794201016426086,
-0.4229145646095276,
-0.6965832114219666,
0.26565489172935486,
-0.16777247190475464,
0.12312351912260056,
0.07547464221715927,
0.009481087327003479,
0.11756271123886108,
0.5990452766418457,
-1.0119740962982178,
-0.0034640999510884285,
0.8028444051742554,
0.7526790499687195,
-0.07186154276132584,
-0.2980121076107025,
-0.9474074244499207,
-0.10012611746788025,
-0.4740605652332306,
0.4046609699726105,
-0.8189747333526611,
-0.5890934467315674,
0.1498197764158249,
-0.19985218346118927,
-0.033164408057928085,
-0.47216248512268066,
0.4925253987312317,
-0.598797082901001,
0.442059189081192,
-0.44694775342941284,
-0.4002200663089752,
-0.06436613202095032,
0.12394311279058456,
-0.5468372702598572,
1.0607402324676514,
0.11122161895036697,
-0.3752386271953583,
0.2054418921470642,
-0.579393744468689,
-0.03500295802950859,
-0.01112296711653471,
-0.21824337542057037,
-0.2366936206817627,
0.34063518047332764,
0.4184506833553314,
0.2940672039985657,
-0.7552663683891296,
0.4400154948234558,
-0.12421373277902603,
-0.4076610207557678,
0.15773367881774902,
-0.2970614433288574,
0.8449167013168335,
0.09260843694210052,
-0.13061648607254028,
0.5017445683479309,
-0.7583996057510376,
-0.12313567847013474,
-0.0051391045562922955,
-0.31832772493362427,
-0.1475433111190796,
-0.05385236442089081,
-0.46614059805870056,
0.19294236600399017,
0.2312886118888855,
-0.3755743205547333,
0.38949376344680786,
-0.33418649435043335,
0.5002468228340149,
0.9477782845497131,
0.1940184086561203,
0.601806640625,
-0.3213545083999634,
0.931762158870697,
-0.35498836636543274,
0.3562183976173401,
-0.5653401017189026,
-0.3023568093776703,
-0.5363590121269226,
-0.4482671022415161,
0.2688421905040741,
0.49010294675827026,
-0.7291284203529358,
0.3602598011493683,
0.020094698294997215,
-0.3261132538318634,
-0.5412085652351379,
0.10942558199167252,
0.3096190094947815,
0.9925815463066101,
0.31647369265556335,
0.08715587854385376,
-0.158058300614357,
-0.715523898601532,
-0.4365119934082031,
-0.2548092305660248,
-0.17055511474609375,
0.3214268982410431,
0.0782843753695488,
-0.042802222073078156,
0.8756280541419983,
-0.4135916233062744,
0.2334962636232376,
-0.2609667181968689,
-0.06607901304960251,
0.514203667640686,
0.49602073431015015,
0.762836754322052,
-0.47776076197624207,
-0.5213785171508789,
-0.17100463807582855,
-0.6008672118186951,
-0.5469504594802856,
-0.4077746272087097,
-0.06352671980857849,
-0.026408527046442032,
0.8597716689109802,
-0.7328567504882812,
-0.020693840458989143,
0.07942122966051102,
0.0068592834286391735,
0.7627424001693726,
-0.32692694664001465,
0.0553724505007267,
-0.804817259311676,
-0.04823599383234978,
0.23403097689151764,
0.12735410034656525,
-0.740534782409668,
0.4054943919181824,
-0.03581804782152176,
-0.46474069356918335,
-0.48328056931495667,
1.008466362953186,
-0.7596221566200256,
0.35434019565582275,
-0.2977824807167053,
0.17181740701198578,
-0.1026306301355362,
0.7322661876678467,
-0.44853127002716064,
0.8877123594284058,
0.8470688462257385,
-0.5699757933616638,
0.5168363451957703,
-0.18496441841125488,
-0.059852201491594315,
0.4658660888671875,
-0.8017003536224365,
0.2793724536895752,
-0.6266612410545349,
0.20187079906463623,
-1.2093794345855713,
0.15518444776535034,
0.464999258518219,
-0.15201452374458313,
0.5370227694511414,
-0.15287812054157257,
-0.38458481431007385,
-0.4432794749736786,
-0.7354883551597595,
0.303918719291687,
0.6860923171043396,
-0.7608802914619446,
0.778649628162384,
-0.10337469726800919,
-0.511500358581543,
-0.6146613359451294,
-0.00763679901137948,
0.08154593408107758,
-0.4329354166984558,
-0.4465647041797638,
0.1316525638103485,
-0.1818002164363861,
-0.40443381667137146,
-0.4073807895183563,
-0.00806595291942358,
0.3644191026687622,
0.20371860265731812,
-0.22226804494857788,
0.46295416355133057,
-0.06520052999258041,
0.2922324538230896,
0.15886473655700684,
-0.2876183092594147,
0.18940848112106323,
-0.43057873845100403,
0.5854794383049011,
0.27867573499679565,
-0.12157540023326874,
-0.5977910161018372,
0.33408984541893005,
0.31657934188842773,
-0.22113355994224548,
0.508295476436615,
0.2812727987766266,
-0.050739213824272156,
-0.49042537808418274,
-0.5454762578010559,
-0.350177139043808,
-0.605857789516449,
0.44859156012535095,
-0.6063189506530762,
-0.5669497847557068,
0.6157110929489136,
-0.20041069388389587,
0.11063656955957413,
0.22092199325561523,
0.4271271824836731,
0.06650593876838684,
0.8521155118942261,
0.485610693693161,
-0.2080523818731308,
0.7495675683021545,
0.06287843734025955,
-0.05061616376042366,
-0.8676655292510986,
-0.10863889008760452,
-0.7147306799888611,
-0.2187918722629547,
-0.35898634791374207,
-0.43707573413848877,
0.21043260395526886,
0.41794484853744507,
-0.36570844054222107,
0.11530829221010208,
-0.2724510729312897,
0.4255889654159546,
0.5803804993629456,
-0.0011307880049571395,
0.052027687430381775,
0.01391239371150732,
-0.2812884747982025,
-0.08523107320070267,
-0.7899719476699829,
-0.5346494317054749,
0.9518871307373047,
0.3174726963043213,
0.7395750880241394,
-0.16793884336948395,
0.4689933657646179,
0.12399700284004211,
0.18285784125328064,
-0.8461495637893677,
0.7563748955726624,
0.216909259557724,
-0.028665538877248764,
-0.28548988699913025,
-0.433916300535202,
-0.714216947555542,
0.4220879077911377,
0.009734692052006721,
-0.6303183436393738,
0.2194107323884964,
0.34575435519218445,
-0.2612307071685791,
0.07516732811927795,
-0.6241695284843445,
0.7719012498855591,
-0.10038232803344727,
-0.32110822200775146,
-0.10454003512859344,
-0.5424589514732361,
-0.1482793241739273,
-0.22118708491325378,
0.1159471943974495,
0.10842661559581757,
-0.4216735064983368,
0.3353246748447418,
-0.550156831741333,
0.7682428956031799,
-0.49574562907218933,
-0.34545227885246277,
0.3387046456336975,
0.019287405535578728,
0.9604043364524841,
0.015977391973137856,
-0.4696992337703705,
-0.08814884722232819,
-0.6631079316139221,
-0.38252222537994385,
-1.0720158815383911,
0.7526156306266785,
-0.43234869837760925,
-1.089033603668213,
-0.04016390070319176,
-0.5157947540283203,
-0.42964795231819153,
0.04866815730929375,
0.07031194865703583,
0.7550603747367859,
-0.08430739492177963,
-0.25360795855522156,
0.48076704144477844,
-0.31983059644699097,
0.8786332607269287,
0.6084998250007629,
-0.01335305254906416,
-0.3146422505378723,
0.7312057018280029,
-0.2670145332813263,
0.3303877115249634,
0.5704058408737183,
0.41476425528526306,
-0.32297444343566895,
-0.8769426345825195,
-0.6901645660400391,
0.44164973497390747,
-0.7119461894035339,
0.02583366259932518,
-0.37254324555397034,
0.24419407546520233,
-0.06610070168972015,
-0.447437584400177,
0.12113127112388611,
-0.16869023442268372,
-0.6809583902359009,
0.07281190901994705,
0.1939404159784317,
0.22667381167411804,
0.06886016577482224,
0.3713066875934601,
-0.4464765787124634,
0.07033035904169083,
0.27129048109054565,
-0.016511602327227592,
0.4066397547721863,
-0.5805759429931641,
-0.0515066534280777,
0.0935540422797203,
-0.20409676432609558,
-0.7734814286231995,
0.3848896622657776,
0.05701405555009842,
0.7643148899078369,
0.49095162749290466,
-0.16548939049243927,
0.4660719633102417,
-0.9155385494232178,
0.7590165734291077,
0.316721647977829,
-0.8728039860725403,
0.5571926236152649,
-0.6244193315505981,
0.3456422984600067,
0.5482931733131409,
0.3299351632595062,
-0.5179073214530945,
-0.18014311790466309,
-0.27829813957214355,
-0.5882925987243652,
0.6010133624076843,
-0.19751685857772827,
0.2796821594238281,
0.024564646184444427,
0.8851473331451416,
0.3104044198989868,
0.48709312081336975,
-0.329210102558136,
-0.2497883290052414,
0.06560204178094864,
-0.3054693043231964,
-0.13174884021282196,
-0.2506621778011322,
-0.0024157180450856686,
0.019115639850497246,
0.6687840819358826,
-0.34554946422576904,
0.15789014101028442,
-0.08660318702459335,
0.11337549984455109,
-0.17060260474681854,
0.3135143220424652,
0.6436856985092163,
0.7825180888175964,
0.006839302834123373,
-0.3794777989387512,
0.13181553781032562,
-0.23364858329296112,
0.1657859981060028,
0.1623297780752182,
-0.452358216047287,
0.05822013318538666,
0.26340121030807495,
1.0660167932510376,
-0.01801777072250843,
-0.6616705060005188,
0.38418614864349365,
0.2294892519712448,
0.17107540369033813,
0.11519750207662582,
0.3710894286632538,
-0.10069359838962555,
0.32550761103630066,
0.6745954751968384,
-0.04876844957470894,
0.18625104427337646,
-0.4867614209651947,
-0.14691972732543945,
0.6444928646087646,
-0.3723255395889282,
-0.4363152086734772,
0.7719213366508484,
0.33215099573135376,
-0.7048201560974121,
0.279314786195755,
-0.22506801784038544,
-0.45928314328193665,
0.7397723197937012,
0.5502652525901794,
1.0224426984786987,
-0.4360005259513855,
0.18539343774318695,
0.4088330566883087,
0.12172453850507736,
-0.12848521769046783,
0.17662861943244934,
-0.014806053601205349,
-0.3602437376976013,
-0.5536216497421265,
-0.48284757137298584,
-0.27301350235939026,
0.039475616067647934,
-0.48745813965797424,
0.46611568331718445,
-0.6591970324516296,
0.0428428053855896,
-0.19143997132778168,
-0.011934395879507065,
-0.4564482271671295,
0.20383337140083313,
-0.1344553530216217,
0.8642646074295044,
-0.5217238068580627,
0.4421536326408386,
0.6185725927352905,
-0.18935269117355347,
-0.6826939582824707,
0.16853079199790955,
0.021655915305018425,
-1.0227857828140259,
0.7335044741630554,
0.08549876511096954,
-0.14674800634384155,
0.08274001628160477,
-0.3583129942417145,
-0.7847850918769836,
0.9589760303497314,
0.5097705125808716,
-1.063889741897583,
-0.2902730703353882,
-0.1871541142463684,
0.6498421430587769,
-0.5610312819480896,
0.4131508767604828,
0.15971580147743225,
0.27488091588020325,
0.08502539247274399,
-0.7603806257247925,
0.32144540548324585,
-0.09746655821800232,
0.46747535467147827,
0.35960209369659424,
-0.6351553797721863,
0.8880134224891663,
-0.46169570088386536,
-0.2722001075744629,
0.36577266454696655,
0.5511749982833862,
0.3183460831642151,
-0.02802233025431633,
0.435641348361969,
0.3506585359573364,
0.6937233805656433,
0.13341666758060455,
1.2598377466201782,
-0.3998083174228668,
0.2995466887950897,
1.090316891670227,
-0.14221283793449402,
0.4434526860713959,
0.6060736775398254,
-0.04543573036789894,
0.3887734115123749,
0.7277396321296692,
0.006100943777710199,
0.6954355835914612,
0.51191246509552,
-0.3563053011894226,
0.06400220096111298,
-0.09784100204706192,
-0.2213520109653473,
-0.17673125863075256,
0.06661485880613327,
-0.5529381036758423,
-0.317123681306839,
0.04556109011173248,
0.19366313517093658,
0.0743071436882019,
-0.6969403624534607,
0.5954949259757996,
-0.020517760887742043,
-0.6850517988204956,
0.7147126197814941,
0.08440373092889786,
0.4570590555667877,
-0.4827965497970581,
0.04528278484940529,
-0.2699154317378998,
-0.11085107177495956,
0.26420536637306213,
-0.2718439996242523,
-0.4449361562728882,
-0.12374867498874664,
-0.15706861019134521,
-0.19726955890655518,
0.3524819016456604,
-0.5090079307556152,
-0.3865988552570343,
0.1779380738735199,
0.4447964131832123,
-0.2802630066871643,
0.03535544127225876,
-0.9095812439918518,
0.06970088183879852,
0.1739535927772522,
-0.35305702686309814,
0.08860748261213303,
0.44453954696655273,
-0.006483768578618765,
0.8868342638015747,
0.7195661664009094,
0.2253006249666214,
-0.20272135734558105,
0.21523535251617432,
0.9509692192077637,
-0.6689331531524658,
-0.6919147968292236,
-1.075823426246643,
0.44906333088874817,
0.08657654374837875,
-0.4645530581474304,
0.6870713829994202,
0.24450644850730896,
0.49332714080810547,
-0.2413569986820221,
0.5786082148551941,
0.4946137070655823,
0.43129584193229675,
-0.9106495380401611,
0.2114177942276001,
-0.5445517301559448,
0.49726518988609314,
-0.22297018766403198,
-1.362789511680603,
-0.16527286171913147,
0.3702227771282196,
-0.45669811964035034,
0.28026583790779114,
0.690336287021637,
1.0271960496902466,
0.19625961780548096,
0.023522594943642616,
0.08456233888864517,
0.12097598612308502,
0.39077019691467285,
0.4665217399597168,
0.8870261907577515,
-0.12666009366512299,
0.110341876745224,
0.15674404799938202,
-0.3736113905906677,
-0.13057708740234375,
-0.9457502365112305,
-1.1410386562347412,
-0.3916111886501312,
-0.3763335645198822,
-0.0693276897072792,
0.30218008160591125,
1.0964075326919556,
0.34021615982055664,
-0.5354562401771545,
-0.15893705189228058,
-0.26208579540252686,
-0.13448423147201538,
-0.06997504830360413,
-0.2122509926557541,
0.41817155480384827,
-0.7505174875259399,
-0.9151265025138855,
0.585849404335022,
0.22646355628967285,
0.06631751358509064,
-0.3611980378627777,
-0.034937724471092224,
0.15830731391906738,
0.16257542371749878,
0.41401389241218567,
0.3111143410205841,
-0.8587635159492493,
-0.13566268980503082,
-0.009234481491148472,
-0.07807816565036774,
0.14082472026348114,
0.9425463676452637,
-0.8509783148765564,
0.5257269144058228,
0.469553679227829,
0.8143748044967651,
0.10356089472770691,
0.19609494507312775,
0.8252042531967163,
-0.580596387386322,
0.18502183258533478,
0.16661114990711212,
0.4456009268760681,
0.38660019636154175,
-0.4542195200920105,
0.2167610079050064,
0.08178617060184479,
-0.37601417303085327,
-0.7006902098655701,
0.2717847228050232,
-0.7043973803520203,
-0.38358670473098755,
1.3267948627471924,
-0.04304959997534752,
-0.2993321418762207,
0.18800358474254608,
-0.5478267073631287,
-0.060224223881959915,
-0.8806101083755493,
0.7871240973472595,
0.5586481094360352,
0.018264135345816612,
-0.2531142830848694,
-0.43691420555114746,
0.7535147666931152,
0.430491179227829,
-0.6301766633987427,
0.12574656307697296,
0.6596547365188599,
0.13866664469242096,
-0.07770004123449326,
0.4600610136985779,
0.12875433266162872,
0.1833483725786209,
-0.23604491353034973,
-0.20646853744983673,
-0.2630751132965088,
-0.15059414505958557,
-0.8817681074142456,
0.18781951069831848,
0.010113469325006008,
-0.09749127924442291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17812v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17812v1
|
DropBP: Accelerating Fine-Tuning of Large Language Models by Dropping Backward Propagation
| 2024-02-27T14:51:11 | 2024-02-27T14:51:11 |
Sunghyeon Woo, Baeseong Park, Byeongwook Kim, Minjung Jo, Sejung Kwon, Dongsuk Jeon, Dongsoo Lee
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Training deep neural networks typically involves substantial computational
costs during both forward and backward propagation. The conventional layer
dropping techniques drop certain layers during training for reducing the
computations burden. However, dropping layers during forward propagation
adversely affects the training process by degrading accuracy. In this paper, we
propose Dropping Backward Propagation (DropBP), a novel approach designed to
reduce computational costs while maintaining accuracy. DropBP randomly drops
layers during the backward propagation, which does not deviate forward
propagation. Moreover, DropBP calculates the sensitivity of each layer to
assign appropriate drop rate, thereby stabilizing the training process. DropBP
is designed to enhance the efficiency of the training process with
backpropagation, thereby enabling the acceleration of both full fine-tuning and
parameter-efficient fine-tuning using backpropagation. Specifically, utilizing
DropBP in QLoRA reduces training time by 44%, increases the convergence speed
to the identical loss level by 1.5$\times$, and enables training with a
6.2$\times$ larger sequence length on a single NVIDIA-A100 80GiB GPU in
LLaMA2-70B. The code is available at https://github.com/WooSunghyeon/dropbp.
|
[
-0.6260133385658264,
-0.7967642545700073,
0.13151255249977112,
0.4926334619522095,
-0.2658423185348511,
0.028830109164118767,
-0.5399695038795471,
-0.3583855926990509,
-0.22928670048713684,
0.3174006938934326,
-0.7293557524681091,
-0.4952183663845062,
-0.57988041639328,
-0.4045127034187317,
-0.25519707798957825,
0.8159451484680176,
0.2985743284225464,
0.07706020772457123,
0.18826274573802948,
0.10327330976724625,
-0.8707078695297241,
-0.03945543244481087,
-1.0426911115646362,
-0.7156315445899963,
0.7575814127922058,
0.44925209879875183,
0.7384252548217773,
0.6547528505325317,
0.4234348237514496,
0.241374209523201,
-0.613426685333252,
0.2156940996646881,
-0.6273635625839233,
-0.052234143018722534,
-0.23932147026062012,
-0.5088157057762146,
-0.13654260337352753,
-0.11413920670747757,
0.7643937468528748,
0.6656477451324463,
-0.43930888175964355,
0.14148147404193878,
-0.0735902264714241,
0.7655691504478455,
-0.8989871144294739,
0.07672896981239319,
-0.527161717414856,
0.2139359563589096,
-0.1451285034418106,
-0.31803208589553833,
-0.3372458219528198,
-0.3080947995185852,
0.003249154891818762,
-0.35527822375297546,
0.2391616851091385,
-0.3255648910999298,
0.8581710457801819,
0.13159942626953125,
0.14408470690250397,
0.4167931079864502,
-0.8217161893844604,
0.42890673875808716,
-0.80340176820755,
0.649777352809906,
0.17036837339401245,
0.18536989390850067,
-0.18208131194114685,
-0.6197670102119446,
-0.5964628458023071,
-0.19194164872169495,
0.3990499973297119,
-0.025305241346359253,
0.12597458064556122,
0.24003522098064423,
0.34412452578544617,
0.40613648295402527,
-0.2804657816886902,
0.4346838593482971,
-0.4167228639125824,
-0.05374877154827118,
0.46765607595443726,
0.07750497758388519,
0.11601119488477707,
0.2367488294839859,
-0.04047900065779686,
-0.12304592877626419,
-0.9820465445518494,
-0.02898191288113594,
0.3997708261013031,
0.47754907608032227,
-0.13917841017246246,
0.060581885278224945,
-0.3262034058570862,
0.3967220187187195,
0.18815752863883972,
0.11944674700498581,
0.33660948276519775,
0.08785192668437958,
-0.34390774369239807,
0.0053855739533901215,
0.3025488555431366,
0.3352178633213043,
0.07769269496202469,
-0.14485861361026764,
0.15357129275798798,
-0.05414724722504616,
0.07254265248775482,
-1.2204586267471313,
-0.7226464152336121,
0.1536322981119156,
-0.5902671813964844,
-0.44565513730049133,
-0.4759295880794525,
-0.5154967904090881,
-0.4759248197078705,
-0.16858088970184326,
0.2765550911426544,
-0.3319537937641144,
-0.33023688197135925,
0.22297771275043488,
-0.10853195190429688,
0.1891424059867859,
0.45506492257118225,
-0.9038399457931519,
0.271624356508255,
0.7675052881240845,
0.8903887867927551,
-0.08039778470993042,
-0.29764536023139954,
-0.6947223544120789,
0.16012877225875854,
-0.5727885365486145,
0.35677090287208557,
-0.41932451725006104,
-0.31044548749923706,
-0.11725687980651855,
-0.22099584341049194,
0.09201718866825104,
-0.6079341769218445,
0.5531687140464783,
-0.622292697429657,
-0.037623681128025055,
-0.033451106399297714,
-0.47308415174484253,
-0.5390836596488953,
-0.0807267352938652,
-0.3938455581665039,
0.7521382570266724,
-0.1648537963628769,
-0.45012927055358887,
0.3108389973640442,
-0.3207748234272003,
-0.7778481245040894,
0.20324194431304932,
-0.06608975678682327,
-0.42718571424484253,
0.3508163392543793,
0.30876344442367554,
0.5166285634040833,
-0.3402073085308075,
0.20186418294906616,
-0.3289584517478943,
-0.5463958382606506,
-0.35022151470184326,
-0.4997524619102478,
0.8631803393363953,
0.23288600146770477,
-0.5773295164108276,
-0.27375441789627075,
-1.0112757682800293,
0.3621653616428375,
-0.09751944243907928,
-0.668816328048706,
-0.21619652211666107,
-0.09110553562641144,
0.3374204933643341,
0.40507858991622925,
-0.2405170202255249,
-0.5535574555397034,
0.4327799379825592,
-0.7902814149856567,
0.4660668969154358,
0.6447814106941223,
-0.11713061481714249,
0.37724119424819946,
0.10376860201358795,
0.42658695578575134,
-0.05523194000124931,
0.12932142615318298,
0.045209337025880814,
-0.5473095178604126,
-0.5873638987541199,
-0.27924710512161255,
0.25757378339767456,
0.5895939469337463,
-0.5969870090484619,
0.31465041637420654,
-0.30537277460098267,
-0.7130983471870422,
-0.5346717834472656,
0.16864019632339478,
0.822364330291748,
0.7110598087310791,
0.46445232629776,
-0.20049360394477844,
-0.43541646003723145,
-0.8962293863296509,
-0.2922091484069824,
0.009612396359443665,
0.04676699638366699,
0.22827552258968353,
0.1068088635802269,
-0.1209789589047432,
0.5687580704689026,
-0.6906731724739075,
-0.442052960395813,
-0.16879622638225555,
0.09969314187765121,
0.14943844079971313,
0.984643280506134,
0.4261501133441925,
-0.5456836223602295,
-0.04413976892828941,
0.03457488492131233,
-0.29829487204551697,
-0.14372389018535614,
0.054301731288433075,
-0.22532159090042114,
0.42090269923210144,
0.3042169511318207,
-0.8592907786369324,
0.5319021940231323,
0.6160879731178284,
0.07553640753030777,
0.4084579348564148,
-0.13729317486286163,
-0.12042097002267838,
-1.1254684925079346,
0.2279924750328064,
-0.1556372493505478,
-0.006842193193733692,
-0.5346564650535583,
0.2988273501396179,
0.18965955078601837,
-0.17809240520000458,
-0.5859256982803345,
0.4191755950450897,
-0.3865495026111603,
0.11422890424728394,
-0.3187660574913025,
0.03035692498087883,
0.3170427978038788,
0.4708593785762787,
0.12067733705043793,
0.5382615923881531,
0.3401035964488983,
-0.6743407845497131,
0.25796544551849365,
0.3259584307670593,
-0.13921810686588287,
0.13529546558856964,
-0.48120880126953125,
0.19437851011753082,
0.018680136650800705,
0.2852066159248352,
-0.7334353923797607,
0.2915530502796173,
0.40049195289611816,
-0.29862090945243835,
0.5523696541786194,
-0.46409356594085693,
-0.4029754102230072,
-0.36173275113105774,
-0.3264494240283966,
0.34073206782341003,
0.5180407166481018,
-0.7861398458480835,
0.330238401889801,
0.16152888536453247,
-0.10016731172800064,
-0.8200557231903076,
-1.105854868888855,
0.18212610483169556,
0.0750063881278038,
-0.47612622380256653,
0.505541205406189,
-0.19816434383392334,
0.29014715552330017,
-0.19723357260227203,
-0.2102789580821991,
-0.03180168196558952,
0.21801942586898804,
0.29643431305885315,
-0.14531512558460236,
-0.30602023005485535,
0.44081026315689087,
0.47132018208503723,
0.0009554413263686001,
-0.07771625369787216,
-0.584563136100769,
0.8580654263496399,
-0.0479116253554821,
0.026005974039435387,
-0.951491117477417,
0.1790597289800644,
-0.07070252299308777,
-0.185902401804924,
0.87047278881073,
0.7774831652641296,
-0.3579610586166382,
-0.5145683288574219,
-0.42593878507614136,
-0.3105272352695465,
-0.5428886413574219,
0.7517232894897461,
-0.563322126865387,
-0.6281750798225403,
0.4919743537902832,
-0.14401541650295258,
0.11077026277780533,
0.20841112732887268,
0.5300611853599548,
0.09148350358009338,
0.793937087059021,
0.7952871322631836,
-0.3260853588581085,
0.6769763827323914,
-0.7329749464988708,
0.17106041312217712,
-0.7062682509422302,
-0.2819955050945282,
-0.5155022740364075,
-0.40365883708000183,
-0.5265235900878906,
-0.33030155301094055,
-0.29212820529937744,
0.4926561415195465,
-0.22458207607269287,
0.0615241602063179,
-0.4786035418510437,
0.6438104510307312,
0.4647420346736908,
0.366351842880249,
0.19544093310832977,
-0.06793443858623505,
0.133210688829422,
0.1196172758936882,
-0.7484773397445679,
0.01823100633919239,
0.7430850863456726,
0.48249033093452454,
0.772849440574646,
-0.0818391889333725,
0.6944007873535156,
0.17001421749591827,
0.07520321011543274,
-0.6397748589515686,
0.5663481950759888,
-0.321837455034256,
-0.3251631557941437,
-0.3561178147792816,
-0.6212650537490845,
-0.6131146550178528,
0.05846161022782326,
-0.21259236335754395,
-0.4293219745159149,
0.344307541847229,
0.5963760018348694,
-0.3999215364456177,
0.43199846148490906,
-0.36103329062461853,
0.7179480195045471,
0.08083919435739517,
-0.39732682704925537,
-0.7055006623268127,
-0.6668437123298645,
0.15784958004951477,
0.3258841633796692,
-0.25688740611076355,
-0.21036265790462494,
0.007136721163988113,
0.352383017539978,
-0.4979027211666107,
0.6313446164131165,
-0.5092709064483643,
-0.5039354562759399,
0.02626950666308403,
0.4559308886528015,
0.527546226978302,
0.3645067811012268,
-0.08531610667705536,
0.5227298736572266,
-0.40735045075416565,
-0.3870954215526581,
-0.8041306138038635,
0.7526700496673584,
-0.6987372636795044,
-0.30314117670059204,
0.077372245490551,
-0.5163602828979492,
-0.06032462790608406,
0.2568413019180298,
0.2717032730579376,
0.6513505578041077,
0.22732162475585938,
0.03603256493806839,
0.42443224787712097,
-0.35610583424568176,
0.5650896430015564,
0.2750920057296753,
-0.12015368044376373,
-0.5414929389953613,
0.9455640912055969,
0.11719468235969543,
0.33250534534454346,
0.49439066648483276,
0.3632049560546875,
-0.24632839858531952,
-1.260265827178955,
-0.49831709265708923,
0.08827559649944305,
-0.7700483202934265,
-0.3574242889881134,
-0.32036370038986206,
-0.32510700821876526,
-0.2967463433742523,
0.06919753551483154,
-0.6450685262680054,
-0.7743968367576599,
-0.15163445472717285,
-0.1528022438287735,
0.29899024963378906,
0.1865929514169693,
-0.07979129254817963,
0.7697219252586365,
-0.7125793695449829,
0.21295152604579926,
0.10096915066242218,
0.5939581394195557,
0.1531945765018463,
-0.7653471231460571,
-0.4822157323360443,
0.07250507920980453,
-0.2411903738975525,
-0.35053181648254395,
0.5218449831008911,
0.6598871350288391,
0.19469963014125824,
0.4048859477043152,
-0.2608237862586975,
1.0422457456588745,
-0.5574607849121094,
0.571071982383728,
0.12126708775758743,
-1.089818000793457,
0.6797710061073303,
-0.48306843638420105,
0.45255008339881897,
0.5536792874336243,
0.014246098697185516,
-0.46828266978263855,
-0.23578914999961853,
-0.4107195734977722,
-1.0639954805374146,
0.6818240284919739,
0.12734833359718323,
0.16758514940738678,
0.25793418288230896,
0.7215843200683594,
0.11801815778017044,
0.539173424243927,
-0.27964335680007935,
-0.4290326237678528,
0.07790890336036682,
-0.02851499430835247,
-0.24264247715473175,
-0.0009350522886961699,
0.07486560940742493,
-0.43771982192993164,
0.9145376682281494,
-0.14706456661224365,
-0.10243391245603561,
-0.10900331288576126,
-0.22215348482131958,
-0.14400269091129303,
-0.1503492295742035,
0.6126078367233276,
0.7510853409767151,
-0.15407095849514008,
-0.07631468027830124,
0.16456931829452515,
-0.7574992179870605,
-0.030457628890872,
0.1475229412317276,
-0.680608332157135,
-0.16817106306552887,
0.12872855365276337,
0.9369977712631226,
0.08499103039503098,
-0.47865110635757446,
0.24005302786827087,
-0.0527404248714447,
-0.029092978686094284,
0.016258399933576584,
-0.021675698459148407,
0.17353278398513794,
0.41355401277542114,
0.30259308218955994,
0.39061403274536133,
0.31261882185935974,
-0.26682189106941223,
0.23972469568252563,
0.18714754283428192,
-0.04956386238336563,
-0.22457443177700043,
0.6244257092475891,
0.4268413782119751,
-0.3354656994342804,
1.0439035892486572,
0.21366088092327118,
-0.3911627531051636,
0.6086353063583374,
0.585004985332489,
1.1115556955337524,
-0.13927118480205536,
0.24226492643356323,
0.0023039341904222965,
0.12864600121974945,
-0.11428982019424438,
0.3609509766101837,
0.03492086008191109,
-0.637506902217865,
-0.7600801587104797,
-0.6620913743972778,
-0.30610963702201843,
0.2874915897846222,
-0.498823881149292,
0.0910836011171341,
-0.837925374507904,
-0.04268748313188553,
0.15576209127902985,
0.2991293668746948,
-0.5039026737213135,
0.4245724081993103,
0.5632895231246948,
0.9367994070053101,
-0.6132587790489197,
0.9913991093635559,
0.3810109496116638,
-0.42545491456985474,
-1.0038061141967773,
0.09627913683652878,
-0.41165122389793396,
-0.5152086615562439,
1.0278388261795044,
0.34449371695518494,
-0.35174235701560974,
0.13981893658638,
-0.5634987354278564,
-0.8085468411445618,
0.6930291056632996,
0.9697321653366089,
-0.8152244091033936,
-0.00137419777456671,
-0.2301209568977356,
0.5448499917984009,
-0.14210696518421173,
0.09229494631290436,
0.566033124923706,
0.2900506854057312,
-0.11394334584474564,
-0.7588592171669006,
0.14400960505008698,
-0.28721630573272705,
0.5190134644508362,
0.27781328558921814,
-0.8157371282577515,
0.9728328585624695,
-0.34182289242744446,
-0.13812468945980072,
0.30116772651672363,
0.6823737621307373,
0.11197300255298615,
0.3054971396923065,
0.24473074078559875,
0.7880839705467224,
0.6263750195503235,
0.07895627617835999,
0.759918212890625,
-0.3240388035774231,
0.3610711097717285,
0.9963734745979309,
0.043861377984285355,
1.045686960220337,
0.3975490927696228,
0.026876727119088173,
0.2809438705444336,
0.754256546497345,
-0.0313270278275013,
0.5841621160507202,
0.6016896367073059,
-0.09851490706205368,
-0.18769632279872894,
0.06923665851354599,
-0.469340056180954,
0.28042325377464294,
0.12704025208950043,
-0.14996054768562317,
0.07450953871011734,
0.23444174230098724,
0.29419633746147156,
0.08359742909669876,
-0.730912446975708,
0.3453719913959503,
0.13696981966495514,
-0.5117555260658264,
1.0360209941864014,
0.0810287669301033,
0.5813503265380859,
-0.25165748596191406,
-0.19802959263324738,
-0.46676018834114075,
0.6499387621879578,
-0.5561174154281616,
-0.4527337849140167,
0.009640933945775032,
-0.5660775899887085,
-0.155962273478508,
-0.034020692110061646,
0.5558985471725464,
-0.5018025636672974,
-0.34408479928970337,
0.5291936993598938,
0.2611682713031769,
0.1908426433801651,
-0.15489162504673004,
-0.5795572996139526,
0.11688832938671112,
-0.37438079714775085,
-0.45052260160446167,
0.2323465496301651,
0.17230847477912903,
-0.005975440144538879,
0.9181109666824341,
0.7213300466537476,
0.4960803985595703,
0.3616049587726593,
0.5678078532218933,
1.1675162315368652,
-0.5175784230232239,
-0.4757823646068573,
-0.8714352250099182,
0.005105162970721722,
0.060600604861974716,
-0.3360738456249237,
0.615654706954956,
0.6126037240028381,
0.9441291093826294,
-0.15639376640319824,
0.6479275226593018,
0.03663068264722824,
0.2950490713119507,
-0.619765043258667,
0.9369838833808899,
-0.4927806556224823,
0.3215106427669525,
-0.45450666546821594,
-0.8700491786003113,
-0.4375747740268707,
0.5897417664527893,
-0.018395189195871353,
0.17025215923786163,
0.3031308948993683,
0.7310190796852112,
0.05307167023420334,
0.027710307389497757,
0.23384302854537964,
0.32744044065475464,
0.5017532706260681,
0.5823391079902649,
0.5835380554199219,
-0.5880870223045349,
0.6297942996025085,
-0.8025718331336975,
0.12993796169757843,
-0.2470460683107376,
-0.7856037020683289,
-0.8397766351699829,
-0.11585520952939987,
-0.4385029375553131,
-0.2714212238788605,
0.766391932964325,
0.798803448677063,
0.999237060546875,
-0.787623941898346,
-0.2664887011051178,
-0.40820029377937317,
0.024022651836276054,
-0.5303347706794739,
-0.1909177452325821,
0.5644052028656006,
-0.32395127415657043,
-0.7365180253982544,
0.401271253824234,
0.14879833161830902,
-0.24973443150520325,
-0.28264275193214417,
-0.08611331880092621,
-0.30738571286201477,
-0.359689325094223,
0.5913796424865723,
0.44324320554733276,
-0.48437100648880005,
-0.3679477274417877,
-0.5052646398544312,
0.10890710353851318,
0.19070106744766235,
0.6205781698226929,
-1.0166631937026978,
0.1252027153968811,
0.7809739708900452,
0.9797027707099915,
0.5925511121749878,
0.14607462286949158,
0.6859301328659058,
-0.9666911363601685,
0.4472299814224243,
0.4025733768939972,
-0.24249105155467987,
0.23411811888217926,
-0.5150077939033508,
0.46708187460899353,
0.31077709794044495,
-0.4003489911556244,
-0.9996170997619629,
0.23503245413303375,
-0.7882437705993652,
-0.274203896522522,
0.9645130634307861,
-0.22180911898612976,
-0.2686137557029724,
0.2240949273109436,
-0.3092966675758362,
0.36943501234054565,
-0.6199939846992493,
0.800596296787262,
0.11581311374902725,
-0.04036130756139755,
-0.5782067775726318,
-0.39060521125793457,
0.626520037651062,
0.5992583632469177,
-0.6093086004257202,
0.2525466978549957,
0.49044254422187805,
0.245680570602417,
0.12703140079975128,
0.27361464500427246,
0.2501169443130493,
0.45858168601989746,
-0.0712914913892746,
0.39707857370376587,
-0.4087454676628113,
-0.6055757999420166,
-0.7191711068153381,
0.3570399880409241,
-0.06216415762901306,
-0.48467472195625305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17553v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17553v2
|
OmniACT: A Dataset and Benchmark for Enabling Multimodal Generalist Autonomous Agents for Desktop and Web
| 2024-02-27T14:47:53 | 2024-02-28T17:27:39 |
Raghav Kapoor, Yash Parag Butala, Melisa Russak, Jing Yu Koh, Kiran Kamble, Waseem Alshikh, Ruslan Salakhutdinov
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC
|
For decades, human-computer interaction has fundamentally been manual. Even
today, almost all productive work done on the computer necessitates human input
at every step. Autonomous virtual agents represent an exciting step in
automating many of these menial tasks. Virtual agents would empower users with
limited technical proficiency to harness the full possibilities of computer
systems. They could also enable the efficient streamlining of numerous computer
tasks, ranging from calendar management to complex travel bookings, with
minimal human intervention. In this paper, we introduce OmniACT, the
first-of-a-kind dataset and benchmark for assessing an agent's capability to
generate executable programs to accomplish computer tasks. Our scope extends
beyond traditional web automation, covering a diverse range of desktop
applications. The dataset consists of fundamental tasks such as "Play the next
song", as well as longer horizon tasks such as "Send an email to John Doe
mentioning the time and place to meet". Specifically, given a pair of screen
image and a visually-grounded natural language task, the goal is to generate a
script capable of fully executing the task. We run several strong baseline
language model agents on our benchmark. The strongest baseline, GPT-4, performs
the best on our benchmark However, its performance level still reaches only 15%
of the human proficiency in generating executable scripts capable of completing
the task, demonstrating the challenge of our task for conventional web agents.
Our benchmark provides a platform to measure and evaluate the progress of
language model agents in automating computer tasks and motivates future work
towards building multimodal models that bridge large language models and the
visual grounding of computer screens.
|
[
-0.5905871987342834,
-0.675529956817627,
0.575130045413971,
0.05316716432571411,
0.2153622806072235,
-0.07395440340042114,
-0.3779394328594208,
-0.5022863149642944,
0.08553966134786606,
0.3790434002876282,
-0.6723148822784424,
-0.5542556643486023,
-0.15554676949977875,
0.2219015210866928,
-0.5251757502555847,
0.645071804523468,
0.08474235981702805,
-0.4517013430595398,
-0.4114754796028137,
-0.2602960467338562,
-0.2892177999019623,
-0.4895313084125519,
-0.38605645298957825,
0.0658959224820137,
0.41346120834350586,
0.2748158276081085,
0.7912704944610596,
0.662807285785675,
0.34364771842956543,
0.5496959686279297,
0.7986131906509399,
0.18290358781814575,
-0.34406664967536926,
0.19337530434131622,
-0.19178228080272675,
-0.2146793156862259,
-0.3967539072036743,
0.1905546337366104,
0.42429620027542114,
0.49330881237983704,
-0.024307362735271454,
0.12569734454154968,
0.06615179777145386,
0.3680681884288788,
-0.860207200050354,
0.2794611155986786,
-0.2558777332305908,
-0.011246965266764164,
-0.05355672910809517,
-0.02228950336575508,
-0.18373875319957733,
-0.711836576461792,
0.0897531658411026,
-0.7867451906204224,
0.08553999662399292,
-0.2727189064025879,
0.6004923582077026,
0.4776211082935333,
-0.4415680170059204,
-0.08338715881109238,
-0.8001967668533325,
0.6684812903404236,
-0.4472321569919586,
0.4338575303554535,
0.23934811353683472,
0.5817961692810059,
-0.04476061463356018,
-0.8442337512969971,
-0.7245976328849792,
-0.7495302557945251,
0.18785707652568817,
0.014794787392020226,
-0.25255152583122253,
-0.06013667583465576,
0.11169736832380295,
0.15300442278385162,
-0.8031188249588013,
-0.1691744476556778,
-0.06711310893297195,
-0.18402652442455292,
0.12381611764431,
0.37749359011650085,
0.32339411973953247,
0.118615061044693,
-0.2426677793264389,
-0.45832324028015137,
-0.3126453757286072,
0.17512266337871552,
0.35300204157829285,
0.32584455609321594,
-0.11756941676139832,
0.6410108208656311,
-0.43514305353164673,
0.7860182523727417,
-0.07758524268865585,
0.0048973835073411465,
0.4289156496524811,
-0.5190473794937134,
-0.41519322991371155,
-0.33034923672676086,
0.8491681814193726,
0.30924877524375916,
0.27899059653282166,
-0.2113610953092575,
-0.10312721133232117,
0.4242246747016907,
0.5376060009002686,
-0.5643560886383057,
-0.33545154333114624,
0.21010784804821014,
-0.26165255904197693,
-0.19016322493553162,
0.30036699771881104,
-0.6801242232322693,
-0.5906752943992615,
-0.7524388432502747,
0.5804513692855835,
-0.47628191113471985,
-0.2758885324001312,
-0.033662233501672745,
-0.05967786908149719,
0.3010777235031128,
0.4513975977897644,
-0.5161176323890686,
0.3988844156265259,
0.46825042366981506,
0.5913913249969482,
-0.17755717039108276,
-0.6682799458503723,
-0.6582939028739929,
-0.006949419621378183,
-0.226552352309227,
0.8660300970077515,
-0.5061693787574768,
-0.06494320183992386,
0.2762015759944916,
0.05883963033556938,
-0.20288638770580292,
-0.3406122624874115,
0.3006571829319,
-0.14075736701488495,
0.06390843540430069,
-0.10498273372650146,
-0.13922280073165894,
-0.15377216041088104,
0.4903697073459625,
-0.778901219367981,
0.631521999835968,
0.288412868976593,
-0.07763618230819702,
0.45818662643432617,
-0.818285346031189,
-0.2980034053325653,
-0.022788353264331818,
-0.5151538252830505,
0.05390334129333496,
-0.007205040659755468,
0.061005979776382446,
0.3372287154197693,
-0.37142255902290344,
-0.23616734147071838,
-0.44565311074256897,
-0.10375989973545074,
0.21910566091537476,
-0.412650465965271,
0.43097150325775146,
-0.003256610594689846,
-0.6386308073997498,
0.19115447998046875,
-0.830549418926239,
0.4149050712585449,
0.06642040610313416,
-0.45843225717544556,
-0.15433956682682037,
-0.03335757181048393,
0.4116010367870331,
0.2912547290325165,
0.43502727150917053,
-0.5739302635192871,
0.34052684903144836,
-0.03499900549650192,
0.24120689928531647,
0.7778573036193848,
-0.514686107635498,
0.20326431095600128,
-0.17487381398677826,
0.4216667115688324,
-0.4904022514820099,
0.5256549715995789,
-0.12910664081573486,
-0.24352286756038666,
-0.6663637161254883,
-0.5372253656387329,
0.17980308830738068,
0.47995468974113464,
-0.8025594353675842,
0.4250015616416931,
-0.3753899037837982,
-0.5566604137420654,
-0.4533092677593231,
0.32145848870277405,
0.47034016251564026,
0.0809931606054306,
0.1912841796875,
-0.3982801139354706,
-0.4534229338169098,
-1.0728380680084229,
-0.03158917278051376,
-0.07471877336502075,
-0.1376068890094757,
0.28681543469429016,
0.4628150761127472,
-0.6319616436958313,
1.1433420181274414,
-0.26686468720436096,
-0.616997241973877,
-0.10882902890443802,
0.4815607964992523,
0.0857984647154808,
0.33149632811546326,
0.5484550595283508,
-0.8019804954528809,
-0.5382623076438904,
0.2744831144809723,
-1.1664061546325684,
-0.18897800147533417,
-0.033727459609508514,
0.03040793165564537,
0.3029719293117523,
0.46574005484580994,
-0.4986729919910431,
0.39818084239959717,
0.657595694065094,
-0.27735066413879395,
0.6707579493522644,
-0.5493443012237549,
0.48133429884910583,
-0.41698119044303894,
0.4906582534313202,
-0.08666732162237167,
-0.5205329060554504,
-0.6037948131561279,
0.08247201144695282,
0.12347491085529327,
-0.0875726118683815,
-0.4634294807910919,
0.2733965218067169,
-0.5013038516044617,
-0.1830178201198578,
-0.39234891533851624,
0.0172564834356308,
-0.27677983045578003,
0.6635814905166626,
-0.09091942012310028,
0.8450552225112915,
0.365041047334671,
-0.7621971964836121,
0.5694895386695862,
0.12913310527801514,
-0.13523641228675842,
0.9673986434936523,
-0.5692757368087769,
0.24930059909820557,
0.10619041323661804,
-0.10456866770982742,
-0.902156412601471,
-0.4262027144432068,
0.08978211879730225,
-0.40468764305114746,
-0.21106956899166107,
0.25206413865089417,
-0.8567648530006409,
-0.3860624134540558,
-0.2507697343826294,
0.3165832459926605,
0.2600241005420685,
-0.4734249711036682,
0.9396757483482361,
0.3639143705368042,
0.02685404010117054,
-0.3031235635280609,
-0.32281434535980225,
0.37386226654052734,
0.09635978192090988,
-0.690666139125824,
0.17280195653438568,
-0.3047330677509308,
-0.23134425282478333,
0.10472739487886429,
0.01281180139631033,
-0.1382373571395874,
-0.10346467792987823,
0.5963237881660461,
0.22339113056659698,
-0.13682463765144348,
-0.14725296199321747,
-0.26923978328704834,
-0.253104031085968,
-0.08586040139198303,
-0.31958460807800293,
0.5098862648010254,
-0.4888039529323578,
-0.6219125390052795,
-0.48591405153274536,
0.3170565068721771,
0.8704817891120911,
-0.24697600305080414,
0.3238442838191986,
0.5685245394706726,
-0.28121402859687805,
-0.030908526852726936,
-0.765941858291626,
0.10468675941228867,
-0.48121577501296997,
0.06945938616991043,
-0.5456017851829529,
-0.49057716131210327,
0.2366364449262619,
-0.03264492750167847,
0.2817603051662445,
0.31220874190330505,
0.6181263327598572,
0.22684504091739655,
1.1829800605773926,
0.9648797512054443,
-0.21545028686523438,
0.49703308939933777,
-0.13287527859210968,
-0.3668215870857239,
-0.2658904492855072,
-0.0644766092300415,
-0.5849835872650146,
-0.09181690961122513,
-0.34390753507614136,
-0.29182887077331543,
0.5951575040817261,
-0.590376615524292,
-0.3315896689891815,
0.7175416350364685,
-0.5338025689125061,
0.3580625057220459,
0.891327977180481,
0.07988753169775009,
0.22901540994644165,
-0.1613042801618576,
-0.1556638479232788,
0.2558412253856659,
-0.10336732119321823,
-0.5391077399253845,
1.204554796218872,
-0.10180865973234177,
0.8249543309211731,
0.2580426335334778,
0.2665451169013977,
0.938150942325592,
0.13898725807666779,
-0.26342064142227173,
0.5702386498451233,
0.15483497083187103,
-0.5164347887039185,
-0.4213365614414215,
-0.18402643501758575,
-1.0712991952896118,
0.41590529680252075,
-0.11890638619661331,
-0.8140252232551575,
0.21202825009822845,
0.10224807262420654,
-0.3848763108253479,
-0.0356285460293293,
-0.6946542859077454,
1.2138704061508179,
-0.3621080219745636,
-0.6379224061965942,
-0.24836739897727966,
-0.6093220710754395,
0.1810447871685028,
-0.07108820974826813,
0.06974029541015625,
0.011834327131509781,
-0.22636307775974274,
0.320317804813385,
-0.37854811549186707,
0.7953377962112427,
-0.12538741528987885,
0.16422957181930542,
0.017894268035888672,
0.20196178555488586,
0.4891776740550995,
-0.37472063302993774,
0.10023747384548187,
0.002411406487226486,
0.027468089014291763,
-0.27906468510627747,
-0.37770214676856995,
0.8344005942344666,
-0.8841049671173096,
-0.12441809475421906,
-0.46116721630096436,
-0.2411634922027588,
-0.26343321800231934,
0.2638383209705353,
0.018163306638598442,
0.5066525936126709,
-0.5956686735153198,
0.1895846426486969,
0.233994260430336,
-0.1371697634458542,
0.43072235584259033,
0.6754907369613647,
-0.11018743366003036,
-0.5126009583473206,
0.9341368079185486,
-0.21500657498836517,
0.239649698138237,
0.37855735421180725,
-0.1558840125799179,
-0.4948814809322357,
-0.23223663866519928,
-0.5515589714050293,
0.013584009371697903,
-0.7230188846588135,
0.15487340092658997,
-0.7700817584991455,
0.21113069355487823,
-0.4458673298358917,
-0.20743277668952942,
-0.45088884234428406,
0.03236953914165497,
-0.025430021807551384,
0.20614315569400787,
-0.16094447672367096,
0.8429040908813477,
-0.3103800415992737,
0.06843286752700806,
-0.45262396335601807,
0.5744847655296326,
0.7343887686729431,
0.27722060680389404,
-0.30606186389923096,
0.13814345002174377,
-0.29806917905807495,
-0.10294221341609955,
-0.5481999516487122,
-0.6417621374130249,
0.3038438558578491,
0.1966245323419571,
0.9312453866004944,
0.6851726770401001,
0.006898859050124884,
0.6842752695083618,
-0.31976184248924255,
0.6725010275840759,
0.21645861864089966,
-1.016330599784851,
0.4440203011035919,
-0.49896472692489624,
0.37468165159225464,
0.8663516640663147,
0.054301198571920395,
-0.4280010163784027,
-0.45452094078063965,
-0.3655035197734833,
-0.6760859489440918,
0.5900115370750427,
0.4807737171649933,
-0.2768738865852356,
0.07862690091133118,
-0.3258841633796692,
0.3318358361721039,
0.6907157301902771,
-0.6976549029350281,
-0.12150008976459503,
-0.4170619249343872,
-0.036950722336769104,
-0.580955445766449,
0.28102606534957886,
-0.04731938987970352,
-0.025454740971326828,
0.26668429374694824,
-0.4570233225822449,
0.47762244939804077,
0.2835283875465393,
-0.466789573431015,
-0.016850808635354042,
0.060499854385852814,
0.6902239918708801,
0.7670134902000427,
-0.40224558115005493,
0.19917750358581543,
-0.2915665805339813,
-0.399640828371048,
0.173710435628891,
0.2902502119541168,
0.23981963098049164,
-0.10928960889577866,
0.20691101253032684,
0.33756452798843384,
0.025124408304691315,
-1.04391348361969,
0.6512357592582703,
-0.2862294018268585,
-0.09637688100337982,
-0.8218602538108826,
0.13970139622688293,
-0.3463083505630493,
0.3209526538848877,
0.3511321544647217,
0.11436143517494202,
0.370252400636673,
-0.7383468747138977,
0.18884088099002838,
0.4079010486602783,
-0.5271416902542114,
-0.4188227951526642,
0.911069929599762,
0.3662489056587219,
-0.22018255293369293,
0.5063658356666565,
-0.20394568145275116,
-0.170039102435112,
0.7244828939437866,
0.04318278655409813,
1.0846890211105347,
-0.1593150645494461,
0.23738616704940796,
0.12303879857063293,
0.6025577187538147,
0.001039476366713643,
0.150785431265831,
-0.2857317626476288,
-0.33066731691360474,
-0.14152847230434418,
-0.3801248371601105,
-0.5327540040016174,
0.20429714024066925,
-0.30998238921165466,
0.014117876999080181,
-0.4667867422103882,
-0.2665848731994629,
0.13192321360111237,
-0.28659239411354065,
-1.1360300779342651,
0.14206549525260925,
0.28598394989967346,
0.7526488304138184,
-0.6642267107963562,
0.6052641868591309,
0.7290191054344177,
-0.5466873049736023,
-0.24897107481956482,
-0.196564182639122,
0.4416446089744568,
-0.4492218792438507,
0.39036500453948975,
0.5384068489074707,
-0.284890353679657,
-0.18859031796455383,
-0.4661075472831726,
-0.5861886739730835,
0.939615786075592,
0.2930009067058563,
-0.1833977997303009,
0.13900506496429443,
0.4386586546897888,
0.5840877890586853,
-0.506024956703186,
0.6165745854377747,
0.5755449533462524,
0.8324953317642212,
-0.26488256454467773,
-1.1881169080734253,
0.1564123034477234,
-0.6110801100730896,
-0.157944455742836,
0.018530482426285744,
-0.14980103075504303,
1.2160948514938354,
0.07664650678634644,
-0.19054250419139862,
0.3775721490383148,
0.37448349595069885,
-0.14742541313171387,
0.25984153151512146,
0.8313300013542175,
0.3259979486465454,
0.47853943705558777,
0.033020034432411194,
1.063198447227478,
-0.22804643213748932,
0.007356260437518358,
0.9344359636306763,
-0.5764846801757812,
0.684130072593689,
0.2497061789035797,
-0.054047659039497375,
0.4462081789970398,
0.23188269138336182,
0.006511115003377199,
0.662153959274292,
-0.02999580278992653,
-0.27740731835365295,
-0.48806336522102356,
-0.021930066868662834,
-0.22783398628234863,
0.4927419424057007,
0.10376449674367905,
-0.09719504415988922,
-0.4048425257205963,
0.5273398160934448,
-0.26953232288360596,
0.15068843960762024,
-0.15244200825691223,
0.8781548738479614,
-0.42966732382774353,
-0.9165989756584167,
0.6004723906517029,
-0.07399052381515503,
0.5410488247871399,
-0.8739544749259949,
-0.05267632007598877,
0.11981005221605301,
0.6354820132255554,
0.0399305634200573,
-0.5151403546333313,
-0.12602892518043518,
-0.004397707525640726,
-0.03450753912329674,
-0.15246453881263733,
0.49157676100730896,
-0.05940051004290581,
-0.2133408635854721,
0.38761961460113525,
0.6691980361938477,
0.18907782435417175,
-0.6525295376777649,
-0.590977668762207,
0.13904277980327606,
-0.05294913426041603,
-0.1356636881828308,
0.3425540626049042,
0.33984822034835815,
0.10683102160692215,
0.9309729337692261,
0.8003544807434082,
-0.15290366113185883,
0.12660540640354156,
-0.17894247174263,
0.8817608952522278,
-0.7065887451171875,
-0.6258524656295776,
-0.655293345451355,
0.5478810667991638,
-0.2243994027376175,
-0.34228435158729553,
0.7994183897972107,
0.8106165528297424,
0.5931662917137146,
-0.3409230709075928,
1.2006809711456299,
-0.4377816617488861,
0.3778980076313019,
-0.14577215909957886,
0.4440220892429352,
-0.7614160776138306,
-0.2941199243068695,
-0.3373894691467285,
-0.8129400610923767,
0.09126227349042892,
0.3504035472869873,
-0.11528035998344421,
0.029168477281928062,
0.7921268343925476,
0.8950760364532471,
-0.2556573748588562,
-0.13656891882419586,
0.6416504383087158,
-0.015103434212505817,
0.4267715811729431,
0.632038414478302,
0.8526761531829834,
-0.07451613992452621,
0.8752800822257996,
-0.15234334766864777,
-0.568839967250824,
-0.3867197036743164,
-0.631534993648529,
-1.0381211042404175,
-0.7377983927726746,
-0.1286497414112091,
-0.07813885062932968,
0.2294229418039322,
1.1406922340393066,
0.9057053327560425,
-0.49589458107948303,
-0.4500075876712799,
-0.09886962920427322,
-0.33274656534194946,
-0.6917322874069214,
-0.13964758813381195,
0.15647807717323303,
-0.23864145576953888,
-0.8314726948738098,
0.5737636685371399,
0.23495952785015106,
-0.07252563536167145,
-0.5350452661514282,
-0.02636345662176609,
0.03292614221572876,
0.06942444294691086,
0.6179761290550232,
0.6999284625053406,
-0.5718858242034912,
-0.2207777053117752,
-0.016306940466165543,
-0.484459787607193,
-0.027497995644807816,
0.7773824334144592,
-1.0348942279815674,
0.5669785737991333,
0.25188305974006653,
0.4365396201610565,
0.21460095047950745,
0.05532976612448692,
0.6004561185836792,
-0.4909220337867737,
-0.018366290256381035,
0.12620599567890167,
0.17737224698066711,
0.08866036683320999,
0.03851759433746338,
0.5661303400993347,
0.13809941709041595,
-0.5704894065856934,
-0.5326446294784546,
-0.01886841468513012,
-1.2197030782699585,
-0.34056538343429565,
0.9588074684143066,
0.1341002881526947,
-0.3747566044330597,
-0.4281202554702759,
-0.29119932651519775,
-0.16644683480262756,
-0.6748325228691101,
0.7936758995056152,
0.2292293757200241,
-0.031180694699287415,
0.03157564252614975,
-0.8738649487495422,
0.3782956898212433,
-0.05677652731537819,
-1.2454966306686401,
0.05776691809296608,
0.8815683126449585,
-0.007313861045986414,
0.35970231890678406,
0.6954758167266846,
0.19137029349803925,
0.589191198348999,
0.1239396408200264,
0.6322954297065735,
-0.4257679879665375,
-0.5038554072380066,
-0.021405627951025963,
0.5827072262763977,
-0.2286849319934845,
-0.5735642313957214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17811v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17811v2
|
TruthX: Alleviating Hallucinations by Editing Large Language Models in Truthful Space
| 2024-02-27T14:45:04 | 2024-06-05T11:15:04 |
Shaolei Zhang, Tian Yu, Yang Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) sometimes suffer from producing hallucinations,
especially LLMs may generate untruthful responses despite knowing the correct
knowledge. Activating the truthfulness within LLM is the key to fully unlocking
LLM's knowledge potential. In this paper, we propose TruthX, an inference-time
intervention method to activate the truthfulness of LLM by identifying and
editing the features within LLM's internal representations that govern the
truthfulness. TruthX employs an auto-encoder to map LLM's representations into
semantic and truthful latent spaces respectively, and applies contrastive
learning to identify a truthful editing direction within the truthful space.
During inference, by editing LLM's internal representations in truthful space,
TruthX effectively enhances the truthfulness of LLM. Experiments show that
TruthX improves the truthfulness of 13 advanced LLMs by an average of 20% on
TruthfulQA benchmark. Further analyses suggest that TruthX can control LLM to
produce truthful or hallucinatory responses via editing only one vector in
LLM's internal representations.
|
[
-0.1434847116470337,
-0.7963476777076721,
0.9553682208061218,
0.22877034544944763,
-0.07659917324781418,
0.18254804611206055,
-0.3994673788547516,
-0.3301122188568115,
0.1658639758825302,
0.5674719214439392,
-0.4699946939945221,
-0.6149410009384155,
-0.48992738127708435,
0.1275758445262909,
-0.31596243381500244,
0.6515628695487976,
-0.006210002116858959,
-0.08245620131492615,
-0.010580717585980892,
-0.16309557855129242,
-0.4120076596736908,
-0.7602858543395996,
-0.3986389636993408,
-0.23101863265037537,
0.3631591796875,
0.05762479454278946,
0.9996296763420105,
0.8027492165565491,
0.30045416951179504,
0.3879038691520691,
-0.162872776389122,
0.20560458302497864,
-0.5740976929664612,
0.10011374205350876,
-0.2679300010204315,
-0.664733350276947,
-0.4785784184932709,
0.10873573273420334,
0.7901349663734436,
0.8224180340766907,
-0.2741405963897705,
-0.14280372858047485,
0.002886464586481452,
0.4616522789001465,
-0.7180609703063965,
0.043842773884534836,
-0.6757288575172424,
0.3250780403614044,
0.2535363733768463,
-0.200275719165802,
-0.3648657500743866,
-0.5864746570587158,
-0.20121638476848602,
-0.6043981313705444,
0.059445951133966446,
0.04507403075695038,
0.44086796045303345,
0.7366918921470642,
-0.18926186859607697,
-0.2574935257434845,
-0.8502089381217957,
0.7369589805603027,
-0.9921891689300537,
0.7183150053024292,
0.0013997448841109872,
0.03455949202179909,
-0.31500786542892456,
-0.48294851183891296,
-1.1019245386123657,
-0.16456235945224762,
-0.19723644852638245,
0.11567315459251404,
-0.26390063762664795,
0.16896575689315796,
0.5824458599090576,
0.10235819965600967,
-0.4608863592147827,
-0.0067887213081121445,
-0.10896924883127213,
-0.2796000838279724,
0.4202592968940735,
0.23938988149166107,
0.1397973597049713,
0.00172789569478482,
-0.21325552463531494,
0.02906513214111328,
-0.47604259848594666,
-0.30961093306541443,
0.38006842136383057,
-0.006476493552327156,
0.16185370087623596,
0.7165181636810303,
-0.024745645001530647,
0.5439413189888,
0.18730896711349487,
-0.4247044324874878,
0.3296452462673187,
0.04880684241652489,
-0.2944568693637848,
0.43786364793777466,
0.5393915176391602,
0.510966420173645,
-0.11480862647294998,
-0.2699222266674042,
-0.43162742257118225,
0.35837703943252563,
0.27055424451828003,
-0.9325952529907227,
0.025511659681797028,
0.4259049892425537,
-0.5029365420341492,
-0.3232700526714325,
-0.04193072021007538,
-0.7792086601257324,
-0.7182683944702148,
-0.5033743977546692,
0.581733226776123,
-0.43329086899757385,
-0.4486258029937744,
0.5679477453231812,
-0.04838818311691284,
0.16434864699840546,
0.39308035373687744,
-0.3356798589229584,
0.37136009335517883,
0.4532628059387207,
0.7567600607872009,
-0.12574931979179382,
-0.12616953253746033,
-0.5365496277809143,
0.1880909502506256,
-0.5671532154083252,
0.4662826955318451,
-0.9581228494644165,
-0.4670909643173218,
-0.05029956251382828,
-0.13942505419254303,
0.09421131014823914,
-0.7279521226882935,
0.5741333365440369,
-0.6918638348579407,
0.10410162061452866,
-0.2112293541431427,
-0.6650669574737549,
-0.24561257660388947,
0.076231949031353,
-0.6409603357315063,
0.743084192276001,
0.02181624248623848,
-0.6249726414680481,
-0.012447012588381767,
-0.8561785817146301,
-0.22932694852352142,
-0.31956636905670166,
-0.051851578056812286,
-0.35172080993652344,
0.40842655301094055,
0.35046419501304626,
0.243644118309021,
0.4462241232395172,
0.275925874710083,
-0.24094538390636444,
-0.29373878240585327,
0.7854142189025879,
-0.40051916241645813,
0.4090307354927063,
0.1490352302789688,
-0.38674071431159973,
0.211568221449852,
-0.8052033185958862,
-0.1671406626701355,
0.13503992557525635,
-0.1477804183959961,
-0.38850393891334534,
-0.1652931272983551,
-0.16116629540920258,
0.25757989287376404,
0.2054436355829239,
-0.6828344464302063,
0.28510239720344543,
-0.5494232773780823,
0.09963823854923248,
0.8740594387054443,
0.23746941983699799,
0.29333117604255676,
-0.2626497149467468,
0.3261147737503052,
0.26133033633232117,
0.2732584774494171,
0.03601991757750511,
-0.12305569648742676,
-0.9939272403717041,
-0.11862228065729141,
0.2464209496974945,
0.46777671575546265,
-0.978579580783844,
0.5960501432418823,
-0.12434525787830353,
-0.1431242972612381,
-0.7970840930938721,
0.20682358741760254,
0.3952825665473938,
0.6137405633926392,
0.5935888290405273,
-0.19470390677452087,
-0.4658662974834442,
-0.7925148010253906,
-0.25316599011421204,
-0.11654990166425705,
0.06280294805765152,
0.11799242347478867,
0.4650259017944336,
-0.5229055881500244,
0.9034543037414551,
-0.6646474003791809,
-0.28909987211227417,
-0.02680850960314274,
0.32341939210891724,
0.21841707825660706,
0.32965582609176636,
0.36718064546585083,
-0.7800167202949524,
-0.05681656301021576,
-0.38375720381736755,
-0.8244978785514832,
-0.46832361817359924,
-0.5281127691268921,
-0.02477617748081684,
0.2527637481689453,
0.45751437544822693,
-0.3601076304912567,
0.6418067216873169,
0.4826188385486603,
-0.373017817735672,
0.6341946721076965,
-0.34822699427604675,
0.3225184381008148,
-0.8047208189964294,
-0.2230234146118164,
-0.46974706649780273,
-0.13206364214420319,
-0.4626769721508026,
-0.09319859743118286,
0.13624021410942078,
0.06381556391716003,
-0.3259854316711426,
0.5174285769462585,
-0.3959592878818512,
0.04299606382846832,
-0.5220579504966736,
0.359279602766037,
0.0346735417842865,
0.7886766195297241,
0.3404904901981354,
0.7619368433952332,
0.37944668531417847,
-0.48847994208335876,
0.2243553251028061,
0.437427282333374,
-0.25631415843963623,
0.4183385968208313,
-0.398853063583374,
0.5108479261398315,
-0.321056067943573,
0.09756676107645035,
-0.7553114295005798,
-0.0020011321175843477,
0.3111744523048401,
-0.34931761026382446,
0.0555226169526577,
0.16650131344795227,
-0.5177293419837952,
0.08396467566490173,
-0.2279604971408844,
0.18415215611457825,
0.42497289180755615,
-0.7835312485694885,
0.9005452394485474,
0.14750701189041138,
-0.02173169143497944,
-0.6071242094039917,
-0.7660446763038635,
0.45013007521629333,
-0.01900326833128929,
-0.25643813610076904,
0.20125392079353333,
-0.45073381066322327,
-0.6373535990715027,
0.14710307121276855,
-0.18713326752185822,
0.19256183505058289,
-0.10186705738306046,
0.41149988770484924,
0.246846541762352,
-0.053525086492300034,
0.15377308428287506,
0.31818464398384094,
-0.2789083421230316,
0.12304689735174179,
-0.3504107594490051,
0.33232495188713074,
-0.007243709173053503,
-0.41266825795173645,
-0.43377116322517395,
0.4171499013900757,
0.4525088369846344,
-0.3523520827293396,
0.7905575037002563,
0.31369513273239136,
-0.3692322373390198,
-0.332570344209671,
-0.8529600501060486,
-0.43380996584892273,
-0.49536630511283875,
0.31063610315322876,
-0.4591027498245239,
-1.0771769285202026,
0.372744083404541,
-0.4245374798774719,
-0.12068231403827667,
-0.057388439774513245,
0.5044298768043518,
0.18651695549488068,
0.8831354379653931,
0.6453601121902466,
-0.008783984929323196,
0.2145881950855255,
-0.20851251482963562,
0.3388015329837799,
-1.0097978115081787,
-0.017575956881046295,
-0.299829363822937,
-0.26805710792541504,
-0.2785585820674896,
-0.8332797288894653,
0.5724218487739563,
-0.28215715289115906,
0.12951967120170593,
-0.14558781683444977,
-0.4470560848712921,
0.5597934722900391,
0.19592440128326416,
0.35874536633491516,
0.5169207453727722,
-0.27592581510543823,
-0.07109718769788742,
-0.460519403219223,
-0.5226610898971558,
-0.42596304416656494,
1.0638058185577393,
0.25234583020210266,
1.0291430950164795,
0.18307846784591675,
0.5219660997390747,
0.2148892730474472,
0.20947881042957306,
-0.7643930912017822,
0.627739429473877,
0.14372345805168152,
-0.3517019748687744,
-0.2091343104839325,
-0.3629150986671448,
-0.46690672636032104,
0.0664563924074173,
-0.45400092005729675,
-0.4439547061920166,
0.5859983563423157,
0.03911783918738365,
-0.5758243203163147,
0.5008828639984131,
-0.42832472920417786,
0.4814852476119995,
-0.2309778481721878,
-0.5005296468734741,
-0.552084743976593,
-0.6147568821907043,
0.30878910422325134,
-0.3832468092441559,
0.3437323570251465,
0.3017767071723938,
-0.2934074103832245,
0.5873035192489624,
-0.12393227964639664,
1.0463134050369263,
-0.17704345285892487,
-0.2884405553340912,
-0.15804442763328552,
0.5112131834030151,
0.6826843023300171,
0.02185029722750187,
-0.22436106204986572,
0.2803991734981537,
-0.39447399973869324,
-0.01904628425836563,
-1.125045895576477,
0.6143333911895752,
-0.7659744024276733,
-0.7396548986434937,
-0.3319578468799591,
-0.6578013896942139,
-0.4070422053337097,
-0.06556744128465652,
-0.15058617293834686,
0.36829671263694763,
-0.17308969795703888,
0.1339520812034607,
1.201658844947815,
-0.49563077092170715,
0.47166046500205994,
0.6414068341255188,
-0.5237483382225037,
-0.4277195632457733,
0.6909403800964355,
0.0644725114107132,
0.316587895154953,
0.4184510409832001,
0.3497184216976166,
-0.4636814594268799,
-0.6158849596977234,
0.15119566023349762,
0.39276325702667236,
-0.8786018490791321,
0.04231489822268486,
-1.0059126615524292,
-0.272299200296402,
-0.4534982144832611,
-0.2501634955406189,
-0.4692896902561188,
-0.5007874369621277,
0.04046548530459404,
-0.2898891568183899,
0.13653779029846191,
0.6013618111610413,
-0.5243906378746033,
0.3962371051311493,
-0.6098105907440186,
0.6361235976219177,
0.6059012413024902,
0.28386759757995605,
-0.25057053565979004,
-0.6955606341362,
-0.1744617521762848,
-0.15406768023967743,
-0.011147948913276196,
-0.8236914873123169,
0.4315158724784851,
0.026769645512104034,
0.42861539125442505,
0.5357319712638855,
0.18403597176074982,
0.6615430116653442,
-0.4519977569580078,
0.7230846285820007,
0.046085502952337265,
-1.351770043373108,
0.5144360065460205,
0.14388634264469147,
0.29921984672546387,
0.16983217000961304,
0.20941853523254395,
-0.7217592597007751,
-0.7050014138221741,
-0.4555385708808899,
-0.39497292041778564,
0.4102989435195923,
0.20232681930065155,
0.24095332622528076,
0.3564684987068176,
0.5469923615455627,
0.3653396666049957,
0.44181138277053833,
-0.7194432616233826,
-0.16362306475639343,
-0.5330133438110352,
-0.0703100860118866,
0.21477676928043365,
-0.6199313998222351,
-0.4403710663318634,
-0.3023332357406616,
0.7390393018722534,
-0.3019416034221649,
0.2833639979362488,
0.4434095323085785,
-0.069186732172966,
-0.24362419545650482,
0.43413135409355164,
0.5691617727279663,
0.7684433460235596,
-0.1471295803785324,
0.39225757122039795,
0.3019106388092041,
-0.4089745879173279,
0.05701807141304016,
-0.07212658226490021,
-0.14362823963165283,
0.051012493669986725,
0.5571551322937012,
1.0437290668487549,
0.016317641362547874,
-0.5005043148994446,
0.3901258409023285,
-0.2741129398345947,
-0.17823879420757294,
-0.13946901261806488,
0.44979649782180786,
-0.1550702452659607,
0.5821685791015625,
0.10238315910100937,
0.1267448216676712,
0.2669590711593628,
-0.3991018533706665,
0.111642986536026,
0.31023913621902466,
-0.38787946105003357,
-0.161719411611557,
0.8352575898170471,
-0.1991938054561615,
-0.24673926830291748,
0.514290452003479,
0.01237795501947403,
-0.6818678379058838,
0.08561383187770844,
0.7056449055671692,
1.0132375955581665,
-0.5727897882461548,
0.09407833963632584,
0.3968464136123657,
0.43452873826026917,
0.3423174023628235,
0.17318996787071228,
0.049774110317230225,
-1.0791069269180298,
-0.5358618497848511,
-0.5729048252105713,
-0.5276815295219421,
0.3835599422454834,
-0.3899248242378235,
-0.07003215700387955,
-0.4759352207183838,
0.056673381477594376,
-0.30722805857658386,
-0.16674970090389252,
-0.16569900512695312,
0.37691187858581543,
0.225858673453331,
0.842490553855896,
-0.6465928554534912,
0.9858753085136414,
0.30697813630104065,
-0.10590151697397232,
-0.803226113319397,
0.3850668966770172,
0.09685737639665604,
-0.6880449652671814,
0.4489947557449341,
-0.10168072581291199,
-0.44901835918426514,
-0.03529410436749458,
-1.0813894271850586,
-0.5661999583244324,
0.7280480861663818,
0.5459538698196411,
-0.7576162219047546,
0.2395402193069458,
0.3589908182621002,
0.4348430633544922,
-0.3781110644340515,
-0.01142159104347229,
0.6942315697669983,
0.7716270685195923,
0.402188777923584,
-0.5981587767601013,
0.35083311796188354,
-0.23497870564460754,
0.056003887206315994,
-0.13475477695465088,
-0.4597243666648865,
0.5095941424369812,
-0.4400264620780945,
-0.09646013379096985,
-0.14720463752746582,
0.860780656337738,
0.2168942242860794,
-0.127619668841362,
0.8380374908447266,
0.5582541823387146,
0.9094440340995789,
-0.03921116515994072,
0.6432917714118958,
-0.4820508062839508,
-0.09628251940011978,
1.2325807809829712,
-0.41203534603118896,
0.5872673988342285,
0.6176825165748596,
0.17548617720603943,
0.5030090808868408,
0.23695392906665802,
0.006828341633081436,
0.5691887140274048,
0.0817948505282402,
-0.5826401114463806,
-0.5030221939086914,
-0.09342142939567566,
-0.42873072624206543,
0.2607593536376953,
0.533376157283783,
-0.013617228716611862,
-0.06898391991853714,
0.42345836758613586,
0.4730512499809265,
0.30530232191085815,
-0.0547543540596962,
0.8623689413070679,
0.04529073089361191,
-0.39722341299057007,
0.49836674332618713,
-0.02323773317039013,
0.41392311453819275,
-0.6737198233604431,
-0.49541378021240234,
-0.30601319670677185,
0.1807309091091156,
-0.2018217146396637,
-0.9195561408996582,
0.27985745668411255,
-0.10633032023906708,
-0.0048487368039786816,
-0.1637675166130066,
0.6520863175392151,
-0.5951402187347412,
-0.41207000613212585,
0.564594030380249,
0.23643085360527039,
-0.042323242872953415,
-0.37632572650909424,
-0.5613155364990234,
0.4890879988670349,
0.0100464578717947,
-0.2897713780403137,
-0.10619570314884186,
0.6763498783111572,
0.20145578682422638,
0.6146130561828613,
0.7483148574829102,
0.3970884680747986,
-0.0638885647058487,
0.06281769275665283,
1.0557531118392944,
-0.7956405282020569,
-0.4779980480670929,
-0.8402820825576782,
0.5152884125709534,
-0.14043188095092773,
0.12070544809103012,
0.6537487506866455,
0.5551884174346924,
0.6305663585662842,
-0.09277861565351486,
1.041712999343872,
0.0843375027179718,
0.42523276805877686,
-0.8532283902168274,
0.7049846053123474,
-0.5828362107276917,
0.2604025900363922,
-0.12105009704828262,
-0.832868218421936,
-0.39022096991539,
0.5507974028587341,
-0.43514344096183777,
-0.3419722020626068,
0.9236977696418762,
1.3285971879959106,
0.1477516144514084,
0.10831208527088165,
0.662573516368866,
1.1028192043304443,
0.3222610056400299,
0.431143194437027,
0.9647711515426636,
-0.11168167740106583,
0.39212486147880554,
-0.44022735953330994,
-0.5028907656669617,
0.05399651452898979,
-0.8186241984367371,
-1.0557671785354614,
-0.5535072684288025,
-0.4227310121059418,
-0.43254122138023376,
0.16782541573047638,
1.0745552778244019,
0.4521925449371338,
-0.8190736770629883,
-0.14181141555309296,
0.3050726652145386,
0.2971924841403961,
-0.28626105189323425,
-0.21472926437854767,
0.4992353916168213,
-0.3898971974849701,
-0.7454462647438049,
0.6524435877799988,
0.5076889395713806,
-0.05687211826443672,
-0.417263001203537,
-0.15784575045108795,
0.08573497831821442,
0.4030516743659973,
0.448265939950943,
-0.20404647290706635,
-0.5846534967422485,
-0.4881156384944916,
-0.005304605700075626,
-0.029870325699448586,
0.3417063057422638,
0.8003240823745728,
-0.9014797806739807,
0.7776461839675903,
0.11485008895397186,
0.48244965076446533,
0.29500216245651245,
-0.18516887724399567,
0.4879903197288513,
-0.6446865797042847,
0.22928950190544128,
0.24584993720054626,
0.2793421447277069,
0.39144834876060486,
-0.6202109456062317,
0.4961299002170563,
0.48761436343193054,
-0.33306455612182617,
-0.6707115769386292,
0.09855759143829346,
-0.9444320201873779,
-0.5137828588485718,
1.1838046312332153,
0.18263675272464752,
-0.40400999784469604,
-0.20238521695137024,
-0.6246879696846008,
0.35606110095977783,
-0.2791523039340973,
1.1168272495269775,
0.7017581462860107,
-0.08226746320724487,
-0.16508892178535461,
-0.5851287841796875,
0.575262188911438,
0.19528348743915558,
-0.870580792427063,
0.2925606966018677,
0.6870719790458679,
0.01814824715256691,
0.33335474133491516,
0.2929932475090027,
-0.19769684970378876,
0.041316621005535126,
0.02356051281094551,
0.41432878375053406,
-0.21299603581428528,
-0.38821762800216675,
-0.42156895995140076,
0.20071521401405334,
-0.23975570499897003,
0.010275577194988728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17546v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17546v1
|
COCOA: CBT-based Conversational Counseling Agent using Memory Specialized in Cognitive Distortions and Dynamic Prompt
| 2024-02-27T14:38:47 | 2024-02-27T14:38:47 |
Suyeon Lee, Jieun Kang, Harim Kim, Kyoung-Mee Chung, Dongha Lee, Jinyoung Yeo
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The demand for conversational agents that provide mental health care is
consistently increasing. In this work, we develop a psychological counseling
agent, referred to as CoCoA, that applies Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT)
techniques to identify and address cognitive distortions inherent in the
client's statements. Specifically, we construct a memory system to efficiently
manage information necessary for counseling while extracting high-level
insights about the client from their utterances. Additionally, to ensure that
the counseling agent generates appropriate responses, we introduce dynamic
prompting to flexibly apply CBT techniques and facilitate the appropriate
retrieval of information. We conducted dialogues between CoCoA and characters
from Character.ai, creating a dataset for evaluation. Then, we asked GPT to
evaluate the constructed counseling dataset, and our model demonstrated a
statistically significant difference from other models.
|
[
-0.32996928691864014,
-1.3518521785736084,
0.7089865803718567,
0.6405923962593079,
0.09010089188814163,
0.5155231356620789,
-0.046938762068748474,
-0.5380262136459351,
0.36489278078079224,
0.49597522616386414,
-0.7246657013893127,
-0.2459937483072281,
-0.5157460570335388,
-0.2002972960472107,
-0.141191303730011,
0.9350994229316711,
0.1738373190164566,
0.06592950224876404,
-0.15671834349632263,
0.19289301335811615,
-1.440906286239624,
-0.47311314940452576,
-1.2735263109207153,
-0.46907415986061096,
0.2762593924999237,
0.4236389696598053,
1.0897611379623413,
0.069871686398983,
0.09125789999961853,
0.34290453791618347,
-0.04217751696705818,
0.14353211224079132,
-0.3874029517173767,
0.43211695551872253,
-0.21888095140457153,
-0.38747021555900574,
-0.7574611902236938,
-0.10361067950725555,
0.09706968069076538,
0.41345566511154175,
-0.5087692141532898,
-0.02115953527390957,
-0.21427074074745178,
0.3257299065589905,
-0.48543840646743774,
0.5061202645301819,
-0.7691648602485657,
0.1613115817308426,
0.18905162811279297,
-0.23102176189422607,
-0.5920438766479492,
-0.40019312500953674,
0.1586843729019165,
-0.7217082381248474,
0.44587549567222595,
0.060700710862874985,
0.5970677137374878,
0.21813815832138062,
-0.5482274889945984,
-0.5248677134513855,
-0.8515661358833313,
0.5340456962585449,
-0.376620352268219,
0.1402868777513504,
1.0223188400268555,
0.6056404709815979,
-0.2520447075366974,
-0.6111487150192261,
-0.16107089817523956,
-0.6142960786819458,
-0.022709188982844353,
0.35569387674331665,
0.04843929037451744,
0.11808588355779648,
0.2467510998249054,
0.2771914303302765,
-0.41219866275787354,
-0.3021102845668793,
-0.021957315504550934,
-0.3860098421573639,
0.5793936848640442,
0.5865772366523743,
0.422292560338974,
0.15884356200695038,
0.07401371002197266,
0.048572003841400146,
0.027274342253804207,
-0.1285974234342575,
0.1278723031282425,
0.021225452423095703,
0.20405229926109314,
0.4026000499725342,
0.2260477989912033,
0.47437649965286255,
0.39747223258018494,
-0.19200433790683746,
-0.2645871341228485,
0.12073919177055359,
-0.31262698769569397,
0.6868341565132141,
0.6043905019760132,
0.4534144103527069,
0.34548550844192505,
-0.14960184693336487,
0.0329626128077507,
0.20279072225093842,
0.7934495210647583,
-0.5564789175987244,
-0.44322869181632996,
0.07122047245502472,
-0.2690146863460541,
-0.25071579217910767,
-0.20231030881404877,
-0.6512346267700195,
-0.5604225993156433,
-0.2706158757209778,
-0.2588854432106018,
-0.9338692426681519,
-0.357411652803421,
-0.02390524558722973,
-0.280880331993103,
-0.058433838188648224,
0.5049712061882019,
-1.0677196979522705,
0.5850773453712463,
0.25779351592063904,
0.7049556970596313,
0.01382263284176588,
0.18540292978286743,
-0.16544198989868164,
0.4123116135597229,
-0.38210922479629517,
0.7872690558433533,
-0.8013099431991577,
-0.781960129737854,
-0.05774668976664543,
0.025499600917100906,
-0.004402401857078075,
-0.6190509796142578,
0.31135043501853943,
-0.4327784776687622,
-0.18892474472522736,
-0.6561211347579956,
-0.24786952137947083,
-0.006635128520429134,
0.7965543866157532,
-0.5960355997085571,
1.3278394937515259,
0.5444471836090088,
-0.5734142661094666,
0.19758161902427673,
-0.6876862049102783,
-0.4748819172382355,
0.22972793877124786,
-0.17583972215652466,
0.04123178496956825,
0.1950192153453827,
0.39033210277557373,
0.061906274408102036,
-0.4172367751598358,
0.27462756633758545,
-0.24349237978458405,
-0.2806738018989563,
0.8033055663108826,
-0.8726299405097961,
0.5078747868537903,
0.2707371413707733,
-0.04481646046042442,
-0.03624192997813225,
-0.8886673450469971,
0.1404981017112732,
0.36921975016593933,
-0.371201753616333,
-0.3957134485244751,
-0.1659749150276184,
0.061158593744039536,
-0.016677582636475563,
0.0639449954032898,
-0.4371175467967987,
0.4618525207042694,
-0.01083163358271122,
0.44135648012161255,
0.6170063018798828,
0.3786913752555847,
-0.09462746232748032,
-0.47604992985725403,
0.8077401518821716,
-0.03768961504101753,
0.29545629024505615,
-0.16033336520195007,
-0.7610600590705872,
-0.45928290486335754,
-0.42583638429641724,
-0.2810891568660736,
0.7171965837478638,
-0.7997236847877502,
0.2971234619617462,
0.2089024782180786,
-0.3814558982849121,
-0.4125838279724121,
-0.27829787135124207,
0.31534627079963684,
0.6770082116127014,
0.4257346987724304,
-0.500959575176239,
-0.2669743001461029,
-0.6229400038719177,
-0.15367546677589417,
-0.13467197120189667,
0.33318132162094116,
0.33407631516456604,
-0.027463769540190697,
-0.3841985762119293,
1.1523550748825073,
-0.6454598307609558,
-0.02998184598982334,
-0.11446115374565125,
0.4351610839366913,
-0.03612161800265312,
0.4086151123046875,
0.6059296131134033,
-0.491108775138855,
-0.7154077291488647,
-0.1005413681268692,
-0.7330759167671204,
-0.2431180626153946,
-0.4088703393936157,
-0.22876815497875214,
-0.1782996952533722,
0.4389961063861847,
-0.6494886875152588,
0.6133620142936707,
0.18619875609874725,
-0.5072120428085327,
1.0125948190689087,
-0.4438256323337555,
0.20587033033370972,
-0.8324549198150635,
-0.17930808663368225,
-0.5087845325469971,
-0.4649103581905365,
-0.393971711397171,
-0.5987565517425537,
-0.11003105342388153,
-0.29997897148132324,
-0.3909401595592499,
0.5088660717010498,
-0.69586181640625,
0.06206771358847618,
-0.414471298456192,
0.04075043275952339,
-0.08030103147029877,
0.5013196468353271,
-0.04596230760216713,
0.7894416451454163,
0.5357451438903809,
-0.5717644095420837,
0.8193843364715576,
0.5377480387687683,
-0.06562936305999756,
1.0945910215377808,
-0.41899409890174866,
0.42939621210098267,
0.0620252750813961,
0.4503551721572876,
-0.6801928281784058,
0.04865320399403572,
0.49039116501808167,
-0.09996677190065384,
0.338401198387146,
0.03633248060941696,
-0.2894744277000427,
-0.49559587240219116,
0.10945530235767365,
0.6747371554374695,
0.18404924869537354,
-0.14745748043060303,
0.4268758296966553,
-0.008724060840904713,
-0.3585531413555145,
-0.5026053786277771,
-0.8829625248908997,
0.23154424130916595,
0.06617335975170135,
-0.46169719099998474,
0.2619938552379608,
-0.38538092374801636,
-0.061719849705696106,
0.19885680079460144,
-0.15296107530593872,
0.04780242592096329,
-0.05545305833220482,
0.3276927173137665,
0.06843197345733643,
-0.1345454305410385,
0.18252508342266083,
0.33753302693367004,
-0.31416285037994385,
0.18779534101486206,
-0.2002827674150467,
0.9449244141578674,
-0.2713494896888733,
-0.5301661491394043,
-0.47750982642173767,
0.4768478274345398,
0.6278132200241089,
-0.28073838353157043,
0.8802834153175354,
0.47884005308151245,
-0.18458835780620575,
0.07059991359710693,
-0.6784193515777588,
-0.005935508292168379,
-0.5045800805091858,
0.26604974269866943,
-0.4848014712333679,
-0.4009121358394623,
0.8351672291755676,
-0.039793144911527634,
-0.4704624116420746,
-0.20582044124603271,
0.7472105026245117,
0.2346011996269226,
1.3083888292312622,
0.14040890336036682,
0.09926721453666687,
0.9534648060798645,
-0.29816266894340515,
0.126190185546875,
-0.8673581480979919,
-0.09940781444311142,
0.02005036547780037,
-0.19956590235233307,
-0.10903140157461166,
-0.2365216463804245,
0.10282585769891739,
0.05290700122714043,
-0.5658909678459167,
0.10967107117176056,
-0.821972131729126,
0.34125375747680664,
0.524575412273407,
0.39033764600753784,
0.2323748618364334,
-0.30724313855171204,
-0.40323367714881897,
-0.010540228337049484,
-0.4201202690601349,
-0.46882468461990356,
0.7164230942726135,
0.2341081202030182,
0.7201982736587524,
0.14476506412029266,
0.1903054267168045,
0.4618731439113617,
0.5390714406967163,
-1.040514349937439,
0.6021089553833008,
0.49681350588798523,
-0.9062308073043823,
-0.02615446411073208,
-0.220052570104599,
-1.1324964761734009,
0.0015580280451104045,
-0.0592648945748806,
-1.049979329109192,
0.21604812145233154,
0.11906106024980545,
-0.22999697923660278,
-0.18814365565776825,
-0.5248943567276001,
0.8177511692047119,
-0.5976760983467102,
-0.04076788201928139,
-0.3597927689552307,
-0.49587830901145935,
0.3066781163215637,
-0.14477679133415222,
-0.11394912004470825,
-0.2827240824699402,
0.3116368353366852,
0.46865835785865784,
-0.8294088840484619,
0.8600137233734131,
-0.25488150119781494,
0.06500175595283508,
0.5221565961837769,
0.5331832766532898,
0.5076642036437988,
0.4161764085292816,
-0.20648837089538574,
-0.2833734452724457,
0.5396815538406372,
-0.5795026421546936,
-1.072497844696045,
0.42639222741127014,
-0.7397453784942627,
-0.5136561393737793,
-0.5660627484321594,
-0.962454080581665,
-0.578744113445282,
0.2769968807697296,
0.03800490126013756,
0.3598777949810028,
-0.8364187479019165,
-0.10477017611265182,
0.33602023124694824,
-0.5568630695343018,
0.1252710074186325,
0.7581230998039246,
-0.2626597285270691,
-0.45927995443344116,
0.7623826265335083,
0.0040646200068295,
0.36463090777397156,
-0.06868868321180344,
0.27795395255088806,
0.05534602329134941,
-0.3806704580783844,
0.06698804348707199,
0.35197436809539795,
-0.7245997190475464,
-0.15920992195606232,
-0.3895737826824188,
-0.16276930272579193,
-0.6173074841499329,
-0.4745161831378937,
-0.5439292192459106,
-0.11760184913873672,
-0.11103778332471848,
-0.2878335118293762,
0.46368318796157837,
0.5428040623664856,
0.2833225727081299,
0.7988451719284058,
-0.8395297527313232,
0.28292369842529297,
0.17988252639770508,
0.0989580824971199,
0.1738228052854538,
0.2083004117012024,
-0.2109290063381195,
0.25968703627586365,
-0.8838536739349365,
-1.3320295810699463,
0.5890364050865173,
-0.026857398450374603,
0.5585665106773376,
0.6429610848426819,
0.25519147515296936,
0.9533880949020386,
-0.20140472054481506,
0.8900063037872314,
0.42492514848709106,
-0.950125515460968,
0.7344184517860413,
-0.3792852759361267,
0.33665165305137634,
0.611821174621582,
-0.02512800320982933,
-0.9308497905731201,
-0.6910367608070374,
-0.7631361484527588,
-0.6664481163024902,
0.9067817330360413,
0.1775839924812317,
0.12061567604541779,
-0.49429458379745483,
0.6542266607284546,
-0.10841812193393707,
0.26903435587882996,
-0.20617353916168213,
-0.07584947347640991,
-0.4367351531982422,
-0.495400995016098,
0.23816733062267303,
-0.21629005670547485,
-0.30157092213630676,
-0.16564792394638062,
0.6626231670379639,
-0.2992633879184723,
0.7570123672485352,
0.29042327404022217,
-0.10718236118555069,
-0.1990266740322113,
0.14450305700302124,
0.3494454324245453,
0.4639619290828705,
-0.3621085584163666,
-0.024016130715608597,
0.32060685753822327,
-0.934777021408081,
0.2704307734966278,
-0.0740627646446228,
0.09745702147483826,
-0.26921916007995605,
0.2947867810726166,
0.8827123641967773,
0.15805643796920776,
-0.6707689166069031,
0.2737756669521332,
-0.4757365584373474,
0.07870234549045563,
-0.5000309348106384,
0.19683526456356049,
-0.014031892642378807,
0.26822710037231445,
-0.10605258494615555,
-0.04989790916442871,
0.027745641767978668,
-1.0935388803482056,
0.004240215290337801,
0.3739134967327118,
-0.7291564345359802,
-0.142078697681427,
0.5913698673248291,
-0.09464605152606964,
-0.7134888768196106,
1.2280253171920776,
0.0084846131503582,
-0.4217015504837036,
0.7574058175086975,
1.184836983680725,
0.7648642659187317,
-0.45626088976860046,
0.48632800579071045,
-0.18666891753673553,
0.03949901834130287,
-0.224859818816185,
0.25405430793762207,
-0.24644869565963745,
-0.8016538619995117,
0.04607006162405014,
-0.22067660093307495,
-0.5456971526145935,
-0.04705863073468208,
-1.0516270399093628,
0.07035324722528458,
-0.7953452467918396,
-0.5785638093948364,
-0.2893025279045105,
0.0038071677554398775,
-0.698470413684845,
0.2836121618747711,
-0.026503300294280052,
0.8759188055992126,
-0.5747500658035278,
1.1063132286071777,
0.7291461825370789,
-0.6759157180786133,
-0.9487414956092834,
-0.06001269444823265,
0.15879462659358978,
-1.0030466318130493,
0.3103172779083252,
0.02570893056690693,
-0.11311175674200058,
-0.13957718014717102,
-0.3624037802219391,
-0.7418004274368286,
1.3402812480926514,
0.8203561902046204,
-0.25036072731018066,
-0.20802317559719086,
0.2619716227054596,
0.6318169832229614,
-0.3263586163520813,
0.8138787150382996,
0.7963022589683533,
0.7179690003395081,
0.3610343337059021,
-0.7820680141448975,
0.3811989724636078,
-0.314498633146286,
0.1316867470741272,
-0.0471377931535244,
-0.7205532789230347,
0.42349910736083984,
0.21690939366817474,
-0.04450539872050285,
0.18472403287887573,
0.47045400738716125,
0.26771852374076843,
0.49668464064598083,
0.32576245069503784,
0.08813928812742233,
1.3372511863708496,
0.05771132931113243,
1.033860445022583,
-0.27880242466926575,
0.22489289939403534,
1.343115210533142,
-0.2478284239768982,
0.12869279086589813,
0.16210034489631653,
0.17012812197208405,
0.5117385983467102,
0.8313179016113281,
-0.014849724248051643,
0.3509650230407715,
0.01020723395049572,
-0.19907592236995697,
-0.09112033247947693,
-0.1724315881729126,
-0.23818425834178925,
0.01270234677940607,
0.8183824419975281,
-0.2500911056995392,
0.20968933403491974,
0.4365224838256836,
0.12928298115730286,
-0.15212482213974,
-0.07748091965913773,
0.6824073791503906,
0.3221071660518646,
-0.7935135364532471,
0.698422908782959,
-0.21767139434814453,
-0.0025748845655471087,
-0.7898101806640625,
0.08200347423553467,
-0.20057612657546997,
0.390421062707901,
-0.13411641120910645,
-0.4751516878604889,
0.5345922708511353,
-0.2376377135515213,
-0.18278390169143677,
-0.3343294858932495,
0.7055395245552063,
-0.3016745150089264,
-0.42449232935905457,
0.42270174622535706,
0.17516842484474182,
0.2207212746143341,
-0.3958674967288971,
-1.2161513566970825,
0.06518041342496872,
-0.42236754298210144,
-0.34374919533729553,
0.20546549558639526,
0.6339060068130493,
-0.3768065571784973,
0.7879051566123962,
0.5085057020187378,
0.11357221752405167,
0.004853540565818548,
0.1828932911157608,
0.6872082948684692,
-0.8206064701080322,
-0.6341078281402588,
-0.5400190949440002,
0.23372940719127655,
-0.21044383943080902,
-0.15548020601272583,
0.708653450012207,
0.321274071931839,
0.05919855460524559,
0.027284933254122734,
0.7326585650444031,
-0.14196814596652985,
0.15846355259418488,
-0.36167028546333313,
0.4732900559902191,
-0.2547401189804077,
0.23636354506015778,
-0.3844740092754364,
-1.0236315727233887,
-0.18718063831329346,
0.7466463446617126,
-0.5389140248298645,
0.20276299118995667,
1.0524128675460815,
0.8543183207511902,
-0.14578627049922943,
0.3587600290775299,
0.3574014902114868,
0.4813840985298157,
0.9437518119812012,
0.4899449944496155,
1.0858210325241089,
-0.07876696437597275,
0.4196690320968628,
0.21272604167461395,
-0.3190615773200989,
-0.3819277882575989,
-0.7685127854347229,
-0.7792676091194153,
-0.2692985534667969,
-0.37193092703819275,
-0.5541006326675415,
0.21301484107971191,
0.97374027967453,
0.8088982105255127,
-0.625934898853302,
0.037072863429784775,
-0.32250821590423584,
-0.17202310264110565,
-0.8121512532234192,
-0.2979313135147095,
0.26556649804115295,
-0.31785982847213745,
-0.4049949049949646,
0.6334722638130188,
0.1233043223619461,
-0.01480139885097742,
-0.0672084167599678,
-0.2093474566936493,
-0.04948509857058525,
0.6671994924545288,
0.43543359637260437,
0.2957766652107239,
-0.500787615776062,
-0.364483118057251,
-0.3401055932044983,
-0.0691143348813057,
0.2964954078197479,
1.2259695529937744,
-0.7065039277076721,
0.653532087802887,
0.07810628414154053,
0.44248080253601074,
1.0151045322418213,
0.17689363658428192,
0.8715106844902039,
-0.5759086608886719,
0.33850595355033875,
0.32202351093292236,
0.1587393432855606,
0.2619002163410187,
-0.8610814809799194,
0.2712405323982239,
0.215066596865654,
-0.6621373891830444,
-0.543222188949585,
0.32957568764686584,
-1.391283631324768,
-0.4489319622516632,
0.9230833053588867,
-0.21854664385318756,
-0.17401690781116486,
-0.6065222024917603,
-1.2100504636764526,
0.5400059223175049,
-0.6924704313278198,
0.7479233145713806,
0.8321380615234375,
-0.5795904994010925,
-0.19401153922080994,
-0.5131971836090088,
0.2820121645927429,
0.3120131492614746,
-0.6879284381866455,
0.08704832196235657,
0.40707796812057495,
0.32684919238090515,
0.10671740025281906,
1.1025112867355347,
-0.0728149265050888,
0.035301417112350464,
0.22578974068164825,
-0.059404414147138596,
-0.24869683384895325,
-0.019911177456378937,
0.1603570133447647,
0.07849184423685074,
0.08757883310317993,
0.073660708963871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17532v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17532v3
|
Retrieval is Accurate Generation
| 2024-02-27T14:16:19 | 2024-03-16T04:31:47 |
Bowen Cao, Deng Cai, Leyang Cui, Xuxin Cheng, Wei Bi, Yuexian Zou, Shuming Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Standard language models generate text by selecting tokens from a fixed,
finite, and standalone vocabulary. We introduce a novel method that selects
context-aware phrases from a collection of supporting documents. One of the
most significant challenges for this paradigm shift is determining the training
oracles, because a string of text can be segmented in various ways and each
segment can be retrieved from numerous possible documents. To address this, we
propose to initialize the training oracles using linguistic heuristics and,
more importantly, bootstrap the oracles through iterative self-reinforcement.
Extensive experiments show that our model not only outperforms standard
language models on a variety of knowledge-intensive tasks but also demonstrates
improved generation quality in open-ended text generation. For instance,
compared to the standard language model counterpart, our model raises the
accuracy from 23.47% to 36.27% on OpenbookQA, and improves the MAUVE score from
42.61% to 81.58% in open-ended text generation. Remarkably, our model also
achieves the best performance and the lowest latency among several
retrieval-augmented baselines. In conclusion, we assert that retrieval is more
accurate generation and hope that our work will encourage further research on
this new paradigm shift.
|
[
-0.07013607025146484,
-0.6982883214950562,
0.5385597944259644,
0.08043942600488663,
-0.38616421818733215,
-0.05252447351813316,
-0.32095953822135925,
-0.23951782286167145,
0.12287072837352753,
0.6337078213691711,
-0.369234561920166,
-0.41187578439712524,
-0.3036595284938812,
0.15045873820781708,
-0.6707204580307007,
0.9229772090911865,
0.12662220001220703,
-0.1128983348608017,
-0.18765608966350555,
-0.17969807982444763,
-0.4779106080532074,
-0.35702797770500183,
-0.40980643033981323,
-0.30115774273872375,
0.24752801656723022,
0.183688685297966,
0.35410386323928833,
0.9872028827667236,
0.19216808676719666,
0.17820027470588684,
-0.16061317920684814,
0.08462713658809662,
-0.40839022397994995,
0.5160546898841858,
-0.24210795760154724,
-0.2641032934188843,
0.10767584294080734,
-0.07757043093442917,
0.7072679400444031,
0.6250535249710083,
-0.43795785307884216,
0.10865375399589539,
0.026737820357084274,
0.766261875629425,
-0.9211733937263489,
-0.09980190545320511,
-1.184789776802063,
-0.16955846548080444,
-0.3693324625492096,
-0.30199354887008667,
-0.8213449120521545,
-0.15125463902950287,
0.23023302853107452,
-0.8650451302528381,
0.3707379400730133,
0.05236629769206047,
0.9065229296684265,
0.33932989835739136,
-0.3135887086391449,
-0.5253732204437256,
-0.49303704500198364,
0.9259499311447144,
-0.4719754457473755,
0.4080697298049927,
0.31854262948036194,
0.39580923318862915,
0.003639772767201066,
-1.07083261013031,
-0.4714825749397278,
-0.33876100182533264,
-0.0957612618803978,
-0.014664627611637115,
0.0783078521490097,
-0.19100219011306763,
0.010262973606586456,
0.3310917913913727,
-0.2715320289134979,
-0.14442797005176544,
-0.4586537480354309,
-0.1412401795387268,
0.539204478263855,
0.01951279118657112,
0.1656307727098465,
-0.6365992426872253,
-0.5823084712028503,
-0.1826905459165573,
-0.8319302201271057,
-0.2219964861869812,
0.08038776367902756,
0.7452262043952942,
0.4680272936820984,
0.4989594519138336,
-0.35709133744239807,
0.9168803095817566,
0.06081851199269295,
-0.012883891351521015,
0.2676035165786743,
-0.5023168325424194,
-0.24232475459575653,
0.11643823236227036,
0.6258809566497803,
0.04506092146039009,
0.0249098502099514,
-0.14507627487182617,
-0.38818681240081787,
-0.21147239208221436,
0.669538676738739,
-0.653352677822113,
-0.027123847976326942,
0.07083097845315933,
-0.3368791341781616,
-0.3895095884799957,
-0.15491417050361633,
-0.607321560382843,
-0.1921476423740387,
-0.31774526834487915,
0.44084399938583374,
-0.8852745890617371,
0.033098943531513214,
0.03985416516661644,
-0.08762174844741821,
0.29661068320274353,
0.23470163345336914,
-1.0409702062606812,
0.10930255055427551,
0.5130180716514587,
0.6844131350517273,
-0.17416398227214813,
-0.1447342336177826,
-0.7572673559188843,
0.16473551094532013,
-0.5683481693267822,
0.6471583843231201,
-0.5884400606155396,
-0.4385000765323639,
0.28250277042388916,
-0.3834252953529358,
-0.14856205880641937,
-0.6697537302970886,
0.49663951992988586,
-0.5730039477348328,
0.48071786761283875,
-0.40894001722335815,
-0.6418388485908508,
0.23348915576934814,
0.3091762363910675,
-0.6110066771507263,
1.5713788270950317,
0.14093030989170074,
-0.689190685749054,
0.6323562860488892,
-0.4807039499282837,
-0.36556801199913025,
0.14588545262813568,
-0.3790566921234131,
-0.13207754492759705,
0.07646943628787994,
0.2064051479101181,
0.30790725350379944,
-0.4086382985115051,
0.2860003113746643,
0.3163018524646759,
-0.28112247586250305,
-0.19095635414123535,
-0.03881298750638962,
0.6968633532524109,
0.525772750377655,
-0.40508800745010376,
-0.059455081820487976,
-0.9455639719963074,
0.30497318506240845,
0.048595722764730453,
-0.6451650857925415,
-0.8139875531196594,
0.03633587434887886,
0.01378188282251358,
0.14511838555335999,
0.17884007096290588,
-0.6167032122612,
0.26209691166877747,
-0.5981712937355042,
0.22794035077095032,
0.6642888784408569,
0.07795243710279465,
0.6987732648849487,
0.06632354855537415,
0.17673183977603912,
-0.20319189131259918,
-0.13470222055912018,
-0.7021400332450867,
-0.19192038476467133,
-0.734667181968689,
-0.28175923228263855,
0.38450199365615845,
0.27064409852027893,
-0.9970920085906982,
0.5296630263328552,
-0.2343495488166809,
-0.38046589493751526,
-0.6169558763504028,
0.03987598046660423,
0.659479558467865,
0.7682735919952393,
0.6631511449813843,
-0.2731039226055145,
-0.40749600529670715,
-0.8512119650840759,
-0.39909887313842773,
-0.25113654136657715,
-0.04197606444358826,
0.24217964708805084,
0.47841838002204895,
0.13257603347301483,
1.1498576402664185,
-0.4479498565196991,
-0.012438199482858181,
-0.11004484444856644,
0.40158671140670776,
-0.11325953900814056,
0.5311170816421509,
0.45521286129951477,
-0.7051823735237122,
-0.6276144981384277,
-0.147576704621315,
-0.7343284487724304,
-0.030918316915631294,
-0.2005438357591629,
-0.23626044392585754,
0.37422260642051697,
0.7084577679634094,
-0.42903563380241394,
0.2751748561859131,
-0.04054740071296692,
-0.3007277548313141,
0.4680187702178955,
-0.20364795625209808,
-0.12397827953100204,
-1.3102716207504272,
0.3905732333660126,
-0.22373323142528534,
-0.0801408588886261,
-0.5246347784996033,
0.47341305017471313,
0.27852749824523926,
0.1291934996843338,
-0.3773033618927002,
0.8578230142593384,
-0.6466847658157349,
-0.005215638782829046,
-0.2239920198917389,
0.2594977617263794,
-0.00946475937962532,
0.10618215054273605,
0.08077188581228256,
1.0032724142074585,
0.251273512840271,
-0.7490909099578857,
-0.13601826131343842,
0.45405474305152893,
-0.5820962190628052,
0.5007116198539734,
-0.443210244178772,
0.20366963744163513,
-0.2505916953086853,
0.07914922386407852,
-0.813237190246582,
-0.08172868937253952,
-0.09771155565977097,
-0.29955142736434937,
0.3327281177043915,
0.23243407905101776,
-0.48442304134368896,
-0.19832104444503784,
-0.01919066347181797,
0.15640586614608765,
0.6224062442779541,
-0.8124514222145081,
0.5069788694381714,
0.1397901475429535,
0.06140775978565216,
-1.0007741451263428,
-0.29478946328163147,
0.12858878076076508,
0.004217722453176975,
-0.4025585353374481,
0.4020993113517761,
0.0558091476559639,
-0.19494858384132385,
-0.17657417058944702,
-0.1995910257101059,
0.00962760578840971,
0.08677923679351807,
-0.30896085500717163,
0.07246094942092896,
-0.165303573012352,
0.4717690944671631,
0.09910694509744644,
-0.023188985884189606,
-0.20735794305801392,
-0.5530314445495605,
0.6312694549560547,
0.026854300871491432,
-0.03205331042408943,
0.06967850029468536,
0.21473878622055054,
0.14274030923843384,
-0.5661957263946533,
0.7723597884178162,
0.5190765857696533,
-0.2554212510585785,
-0.4117581248283386,
-0.5733164548873901,
-0.34905797243118286,
-0.46805089712142944,
0.3434402644634247,
-0.3619425892829895,
-0.7378606796264648,
0.19002853333950043,
0.0931781604886055,
0.15321263670921326,
0.35370975732803345,
0.4505864381790161,
0.17153698205947876,
0.7261987924575806,
0.9075498580932617,
0.20026706159114838,
0.5744780898094177,
-0.0454239547252655,
-0.04905491694808006,
-0.8110321164131165,
-0.25667744874954224,
-0.6831246614456177,
0.11919822543859482,
-0.3625795841217041,
-0.44184330105781555,
0.2923804223537445,
0.21369847655296326,
-0.23981043696403503,
0.41357341408729553,
-0.7334837317466736,
0.4628695249557495,
0.7390161752700806,
-0.06282331049442291,
0.3115091025829315,
0.11608365178108215,
-0.7180464267730713,
-0.07694579660892487,
-0.6409475207328796,
-0.7193180918693542,
1.1608381271362305,
-0.050949450582265854,
0.42662230134010315,
-0.0317520797252655,
0.9917069673538208,
0.06116591393947601,
0.4350770115852356,
-0.4599912166595459,
0.6199678182601929,
-0.07366947829723358,
-0.9471702575683594,
-0.43045708537101746,
-0.34157103300094604,
-1.217880129814148,
0.2597210705280304,
-0.19333188235759735,
-0.8913792371749878,
0.018877560272812843,
0.09130717813968658,
-0.3169460594654083,
-0.03613791987299919,
-0.29183468222618103,
0.8417162895202637,
-0.07777391374111176,
-0.5544893741607666,
-0.08989901840686798,
-0.8890028595924377,
0.3189661502838135,
-0.20631064474582672,
-0.035975709557533264,
0.03932972624897957,
-0.13944558799266815,
0.6378292441368103,
-0.4404664635658264,
0.5210521221160889,
-0.12859198451042175,
-0.0641108825802803,
0.5862340927124023,
0.16187462210655212,
0.2936803102493286,
-0.2192317396402359,
-0.42365825176239014,
-0.445736825466156,
-0.0700744092464447,
-0.49556681513786316,
-0.5338224172592163,
0.4507324695587158,
-0.430955171585083,
-0.5193647146224976,
-0.39600661396980286,
-0.4139138460159302,
-0.11507164686918259,
0.5617672204971313,
0.47209644317626953,
0.334258109331131,
-0.5435227751731873,
0.4386639893054962,
0.7082788944244385,
-0.3447587192058563,
0.46613314747810364,
0.5943818688392639,
-0.317232608795166,
-0.31946438550949097,
0.7749249339103699,
0.13071869313716888,
0.33018532395362854,
0.5749842524528503,
0.12867330014705658,
-0.39246299862861633,
-0.42280682921409607,
-0.6994584202766418,
0.15970103442668915,
-0.80743408203125,
-0.17839311063289642,
-0.6253069043159485,
-0.09181588143110275,
-0.24413403868675232,
-0.060023657977581024,
-0.5291615724563599,
-0.45179739594459534,
-0.17849521338939667,
-0.1568102240562439,
0.09349675476551056,
0.676578938961029,
0.12576356530189514,
0.45428597927093506,
-0.796644389629364,
-0.11670327186584473,
0.24403677880764008,
0.1236022338271141,
-0.08080007880926132,
-0.43432408571243286,
-0.2887018322944641,
-0.2975989878177643,
-0.305775910615921,
-1.0573269128799438,
0.5234531760215759,
0.2921770513057709,
0.6467618942260742,
0.06888747215270996,
0.1431872546672821,
0.41788962483406067,
-0.7422297596931458,
0.9804681539535522,
0.06661658734083176,
-0.8805675506591797,
0.7208380103111267,
-0.5500788688659668,
0.2185823619365692,
0.941002607345581,
0.3072715401649475,
-0.41445958614349365,
-0.14787495136260986,
-0.7706179618835449,
-1.1159522533416748,
0.643099308013916,
0.2969617247581482,
0.2990218997001648,
-0.5373053550720215,
0.7169514894485474,
0.14523430168628693,
0.6069196462631226,
-0.5512150526046753,
-0.16924574971199036,
-0.2191910743713379,
-0.26917946338653564,
0.04478744789958,
-0.16357959806919098,
-0.07477709650993347,
0.0731205940246582,
0.7708196640014648,
-0.3597089350223541,
0.19334323704242706,
0.2443609982728958,
-0.09928284585475922,
-0.1546294093132019,
0.33035629987716675,
0.2098856419324875,
0.618466854095459,
-0.20425300300121307,
-0.050465475767850876,
-0.08788346499204636,
-0.27227887511253357,
0.0692346915602684,
0.14778630435466766,
-0.6798588037490845,
0.25934308767318726,
0.12075808644294739,
0.7060422897338867,
0.2931424379348755,
-0.8150522112846375,
0.5508758425712585,
0.12148727476596832,
-0.0729897990822792,
-0.3179234266281128,
0.09676912426948547,
-0.12031721323728561,
-0.025281492620706558,
0.6138458847999573,
-0.11616384238004684,
0.1644601821899414,
-0.5876626968383789,
0.5807234644889832,
0.6061047911643982,
-0.32559090852737427,
-0.04023316875100136,
0.8493792414665222,
0.18924883008003235,
-0.2535780072212219,
0.8520607352256775,
-0.30184608697891235,
-0.20448970794677734,
0.3307284414768219,
0.7029598951339722,
0.7748839855194092,
-0.28415340185165405,
0.37235409021377563,
0.7200937867164612,
0.24265407025814056,
-0.4290415644645691,
0.17196807265281677,
-0.2064427137374878,
-0.7263925075531006,
-0.2951619625091553,
-0.9659191966056824,
-0.17367543280124664,
0.009459936991333961,
-0.8869066834449768,
0.20054596662521362,
-0.37361830472946167,
-0.058115217834711075,
-0.14031270146369934,
-0.07583580911159515,
-0.4502148926258087,
0.36676985025405884,
0.01820647343993187,
1.319779396057129,
-0.5395934581756592,
0.9206882119178772,
0.6817815899848938,
-0.7120388150215149,
-0.8415160179138184,
0.16719651222229004,
-0.14437657594680786,
-0.777225136756897,
0.6570031046867371,
0.1931867152452469,
0.15049846470355988,
0.196560800075531,
-0.5829047560691833,
-1.0712306499481201,
1.2152715921401978,
0.21665646135807037,
-0.37357816100120544,
-0.29487869143486023,
-0.26276829838752747,
0.664094090461731,
-0.5359665751457214,
0.22505879402160645,
0.6648605465888977,
0.25489088892936707,
0.24249276518821716,
-0.8848686814308167,
0.1428772211074829,
-0.25205889344215393,
0.16352544724941254,
0.28606659173965454,
-0.6209215521812439,
0.9806957840919495,
0.05450114980340004,
-0.3712470233440399,
0.5389973521232605,
0.7785217761993408,
0.45171111822128296,
0.15625077486038208,
0.44342663884162903,
0.4808846414089203,
0.9996481537818909,
0.0936022624373436,
1.269008994102478,
-0.47135862708091736,
0.1361108273267746,
1.1472222805023193,
-0.2876484990119934,
1.1515824794769287,
0.68262779712677,
0.3095746338367462,
0.7122541666030884,
0.4293045401573181,
0.38957419991493225,
0.702532172203064,
0.0863044485449791,
-0.3079124093055725,
-0.3158077001571655,
-0.0900360494852066,
-0.33319684863090515,
0.4680357277393341,
0.25686609745025635,
-0.6380637884140015,
-0.3063443899154663,
-0.09844273328781128,
0.012100107036530972,
0.600913405418396,
-0.00908738188445568,
0.7741298675537109,
-0.07743921875953674,
-1.1790305376052856,
0.8572760820388794,
0.13757063448429108,
0.45600971579551697,
-0.5908606648445129,
0.0589757077395916,
-0.16714680194854736,
0.08412162214517593,
0.13765013217926025,
-0.36990320682525635,
0.20221944153308868,
-0.07562179863452911,
-0.011462828144431114,
-0.34038814902305603,
0.7208942174911499,
-0.5154521465301514,
-0.3071495592594147,
0.19033971428871155,
0.9156977534294128,
0.08686584234237671,
-0.038890257477760315,
-0.6325779557228088,
-0.12692709267139435,
0.11939872056245804,
-0.4445028603076935,
0.4018583595752716,
0.374711811542511,
-0.11284682154655457,
0.4161335825920105,
0.5309951901435852,
-0.12164035439491272,
0.2932334244251251,
-0.10404618829488754,
0.8850589990615845,
-0.6780617237091064,
-0.6011503338813782,
-0.5981975197792053,
0.5862370729446411,
-0.3129693567752838,
-0.5150930285453796,
0.6880981922149658,
0.5606780052185059,
0.8628491163253784,
0.011900615878403187,
0.8861597776412964,
-0.19095946848392487,
0.6929057836532593,
-0.6942936778068542,
0.5180082321166992,
-0.7552691102027893,
0.3861692249774933,
-0.2061740756034851,
-1.037047266960144,
-0.0821201354265213,
0.8069750666618347,
-0.31930944323539734,
0.0015947523061186075,
0.8316468000411987,
0.6709364652633667,
0.023121284320950508,
-0.012353403493762016,
0.0718669518828392,
0.1014203280210495,
0.2846681475639343,
0.1025005355477333,
0.6342529058456421,
-0.5800275206565857,
0.6139612197875977,
-0.15148863196372986,
-0.06635597348213196,
-0.1355160027742386,
-0.9397299885749817,
-0.7295389771461487,
-0.8051884770393372,
0.03962605074048042,
-0.4869435727596283,
0.3280251920223236,
1.036731481552124,
0.7204309105873108,
-0.5032444596290588,
-0.22649520635604858,
-0.2923315465450287,
-0.12424702942371368,
-0.15392908453941345,
-0.21144849061965942,
0.24386930465698242,
-1.01809823513031,
-0.6864742040634155,
0.7499756217002869,
0.05103112384676933,
-0.3001435697078705,
-0.15495431423187256,
-0.12105508893728256,
-0.5275194048881531,
0.28826630115509033,
0.510678768157959,
0.4002155363559723,
-0.6389360427856445,
-0.4190763533115387,
0.20983479917049408,
-0.44968509674072266,
0.12961024045944214,
0.7923851609230042,
-1.1124669313430786,
0.6773732900619507,
0.4419931471347809,
0.8506730794906616,
0.6591498851776123,
0.19869494438171387,
0.7415199875831604,
-1.3170827627182007,
0.1116393432021141,
0.3154698312282562,
0.2673642933368683,
0.5417789220809937,
-0.23316740989685059,
0.7362987995147705,
0.2258455902338028,
-0.45241600275039673,
-0.9579141139984131,
0.3520168364048004,
-0.5705600380897522,
-0.43095582723617554,
1.063869595527649,
0.12938633561134338,
-0.49593526124954224,
0.0980156660079956,
-0.1851327270269394,
0.21801090240478516,
-0.4098784923553467,
0.9137550592422485,
0.4210723042488098,
0.007739709690213203,
0.07477252930402756,
-0.3952937126159668,
0.6477922201156616,
0.7334063053131104,
-0.5396798849105835,
0.13313741981983185,
0.6075854301452637,
0.24310238659381866,
0.5441629886627197,
1.090796709060669,
-0.07618822902441025,
0.19262966513633728,
0.10980487614870071,
0.22626391053199768,
0.08763644844293594,
-0.43635794520378113,
-0.12752781808376312,
0.2986195981502533,
0.13363216817378998,
-0.03673412278294563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17531v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17531v2
|
Nissist: An Incident Mitigation Copilot based on Troubleshooting Guides
| 2024-02-27T14:14:23 | 2024-05-10T11:57:46 |
Kaikai An, Fangkai Yang, Junting Lu, Liqun Li, Zhixing Ren, Hao Huang, Lu Wang, Pu Zhao, Yu Kang, Hua Ding, Qingwei Lin, Saravan Rajmohan, Dongmei Zhang, Qi Zhang
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Effective incident management is pivotal for the smooth operation of
enterprises-level cloud services. In order to expedite incident mitigation,
service teams compile troubleshooting knowledge into Troubleshooting Guides
(TSGs) accessible to on-call engineers (OCEs). While automated pipelines are
enabled to resolve the most frequent and easy incidents, there still exist
complex incidents that require OCEs' intervention. However, TSGs are often
unstructured and incomplete, which requires manual interpretation by OCEs,
leading to on-call fatigue and decreased productivity, especially among
new-hire OCEs. In this work, we propose Nissist which leverages TSGs and
incident mitigation histories to provide proactive suggestions, reducing human
intervention. Leveraging Large Language Models (LLM), Nissist extracts insights
from unstructured TSGs and historical incident mitigation discussions, forming
a comprehensive knowledge base. Its multi-agent system design enhances
proficiency in precisely discerning user queries, retrieving relevant
information, and delivering systematic plans consecutively. Through our user
case and experiment, we demonstrate that Nissist significant reduce Time to
Mitigate (TTM) in incident mitigation, alleviating operational burdens on OCEs
and improving service reliability. Our demo is available at
https://aka.ms/nissist_demo.
|
[
-0.5288981199264526,
-0.6798128485679626,
0.4721072018146515,
0.20160475373268127,
-0.4698077142238617,
0.328887015581131,
0.22085416316986084,
-0.26613688468933105,
0.3667134940624237,
0.5101114511489868,
-1.214568018913269,
-0.12035162001848221,
-0.003422846319153905,
-0.1823149174451828,
-0.3031882047653198,
1.260900855064392,
0.01481153815984726,
-0.1596061885356903,
0.10220303386449814,
0.23982828855514526,
-0.40243661403656006,
-0.38436123728752136,
-1.2644760608673096,
0.17594176530838013,
0.42413681745529175,
0.7144505977630615,
0.46318769454956055,
-0.042429856956005096,
0.4439178705215454,
0.16526292264461517,
-0.21045289933681488,
0.2306615710258484,
-0.12051036953926086,
0.25615939497947693,
0.08271501213312149,
-0.1739264577627182,
-0.517515242099762,
-0.7647607326507568,
0.573189914226532,
0.4560753107070923,
-0.47598767280578613,
-0.22334519028663635,
0.26596522331237793,
0.41752269864082336,
-0.7115829586982727,
-0.07773127406835556,
-0.45935651659965515,
0.061644189059734344,
0.04639056324958801,
-0.36491289734840393,
-0.09859675168991089,
-0.18127073347568512,
0.3210701048374176,
-0.7545190453529358,
0.35948872566223145,
-0.10650940984487534,
0.6851555705070496,
0.42394500970840454,
-0.3226848542690277,
0.014133070595562458,
-0.7554477453231812,
0.8299772143363953,
-0.6087352633476257,
-0.11492353677749634,
0.40180426836013794,
0.7053061127662659,
-0.22591359913349152,
-0.36949819326400757,
-0.13012373447418213,
0.05923495814204216,
-0.1534949541091919,
0.2516317665576935,
-0.04920240491628647,
0.05349542945623398,
0.24530570209026337,
-0.04458361119031906,
-0.5128083825111389,
0.015166188590228558,
-0.11854465305805206,
-0.5459678173065186,
0.6110641360282898,
0.674494206905365,
0.26055148243904114,
-0.08642888814210892,
-0.5968592166900635,
0.21763747930526733,
-0.6164440512657166,
-0.09195543825626373,
0.37355008721351624,
-0.04991062358021736,
0.044155627489089966,
-0.06758236885070801,
-0.283496230840683,
0.6978617310523987,
0.020530706271529198,
-0.09869050979614258,
-0.2337215542793274,
-0.38617855310440063,
-0.12218543887138367,
0.361079603433609,
0.5387240052223206,
0.3886323869228363,
-0.27990514039993286,
-0.6262655854225159,
-0.09585360437631607,
-0.27538028359413147,
0.7725391983985901,
-0.8892210721969604,
-0.13291093707084656,
0.19762910902500153,
0.07185107469558716,
-0.3348122835159302,
0.06791321188211441,
-0.7954039573669434,
-0.5597404837608337,
-0.08707574754953384,
0.2500426769256592,
-0.6537768840789795,
-0.49948999285697937,
0.11263100057840347,
-0.2857416272163391,
-0.002867697039619088,
0.582859456539154,
-0.012964384630322456,
0.14024411141872406,
0.6901118159294128,
0.9893069267272949,
0.5117220282554626,
-0.14157520234584808,
-0.9085411429405212,
0.6419432163238525,
-0.3297783136367798,
0.9780562520027161,
0.018536077812314034,
-0.3449750542640686,
0.00829297211021185,
0.047752395272254944,
0.050335843116045,
-0.24414986371994019,
0.8610348701477051,
-0.20102046430110931,
0.0881950780749321,
-0.11286929994821548,
-0.40768498182296753,
-0.1688976138830185,
0.3143126964569092,
-0.5591989159584045,
0.6483720541000366,
-0.025716952979564667,
-0.8661923408508301,
0.2813142240047455,
-1.074138879776001,
-0.1673542857170105,
0.5839228630065918,
-0.22754189372062683,
-0.6528765559196472,
0.09065842628479004,
0.08750876039266586,
0.2710609436035156,
-0.3951941132545471,
0.32907524704933167,
-0.1784220188856125,
-0.18112900853157043,
-0.3288847804069519,
0.156251460313797,
0.9983556270599365,
0.09038335084915161,
-0.4530647397041321,
-0.06317010521888733,
-0.4275050759315491,
0.2743673324584961,
0.010220125317573547,
0.03750133141875267,
-0.49054741859436035,
0.048622552305459976,
-0.008904499933123589,
0.0771036297082901,
-0.17917606234550476,
-0.6077088713645935,
0.050308503210544586,
-0.08124980330467224,
0.5808865427970886,
0.5870146155357361,
0.6108499765396118,
0.3421546518802643,
-0.5757471323013306,
0.6727563142776489,
-0.09205709397792816,
0.5499818325042725,
0.07135026901960373,
-0.14437447488307953,
-0.7894502282142639,
-0.2767406105995178,
-0.3389453589916229,
0.5608761310577393,
-1.2252483367919922,
0.2707507312297821,
-0.1999650001525879,
-0.5946752429008484,
-0.17508986592292786,
-0.0973285436630249,
0.5356746315956116,
0.5837415456771851,
0.20302094519138336,
-0.10074391961097717,
-0.6906204223632812,
-1.0904428958892822,
-0.30599772930145264,
-0.15202432870864868,
-0.22823619842529297,
0.0828453078866005,
0.09698199480772018,
-0.1791176050901413,
1.109526515007019,
-0.5069724321365356,
-0.49753817915916443,
-0.2721060514450073,
0.5946683287620544,
-0.1784438192844391,
0.11609853804111481,
0.9215513467788696,
-0.6941968202590942,
-0.34636735916137695,
-0.2760533392429352,
-0.40772128105163574,
-0.28242361545562744,
-0.14691683650016785,
-0.14963087439537048,
0.5010754466056824,
0.4723835289478302,
-0.1604502946138382,
0.4827800691127777,
0.07014482468366623,
-0.6163192391395569,
0.68535315990448,
-0.17653034627437592,
0.10533516854047775,
-0.9578257203102112,
0.1529380828142166,
-0.2043347954750061,
-0.06507135927677155,
-0.908109724521637,
-0.118393674492836,
0.27640673518180847,
-0.1956319361925125,
-0.6523218154907227,
0.3300655782222748,
-0.39701980352401733,
0.004614793695509434,
-0.024094533175230026,
0.1282798945903778,
0.06360651552677155,
0.5304850935935974,
0.14838241040706635,
0.781256914138794,
0.2714349627494812,
-0.8535885214805603,
-0.0009901244193315506,
0.3149191737174988,
-0.45891645550727844,
1.074555516242981,
-0.4102652072906494,
0.29375481605529785,
-0.28490450978279114,
-0.07308194786310196,
-0.733768105506897,
-0.13402852416038513,
0.06301163136959076,
-0.16724427044391632,
-0.13958469033241272,
-0.5826612114906311,
-0.7049182653427124,
-0.07639801502227783,
-0.36011195182800293,
0.006259221117943525,
-0.05214688181877136,
-0.3178884983062744,
0.7687973976135254,
0.2799520194530487,
-0.5767636299133301,
-0.05996982380747795,
-0.6250287890434265,
0.264156699180603,
-0.3815693259239197,
-0.8862658739089966,
0.4416187107563019,
-0.3915369510650635,
-0.24580548703670502,
-0.03970556706190109,
-0.3002378046512604,
-0.7559670805931091,
0.5407516956329346,
0.38897156715393066,
0.3406262695789337,
-0.03969758376479149,
0.40883517265319824,
-0.08436554670333862,
-0.31847333908081055,
0.006632643286138773,
-0.019333988428115845,
0.5835660099983215,
-0.28980669379234314,
-0.1714726984500885,
-0.26051783561706543,
0.7220923900604248,
0.526394784450531,
0.06755968928337097,
0.8027604222297668,
0.44279250502586365,
-0.37483859062194824,
0.06238279864192009,
-0.6463987231254578,
-0.5387499928474426,
-0.4359199106693268,
0.2655929625034332,
-0.014265828765928745,
-0.635516345500946,
0.3678532838821411,
-0.12941376864910126,
0.5922592878341675,
0.36957183480262756,
-0.11480637639760971,
-0.2772357761859894,
0.7291383743286133,
0.6176773309707642,
-0.22814501821994781,
0.811040461063385,
-0.4029291570186615,
0.5337892770767212,
-0.8114258050918579,
-0.23875881731510162,
-0.8291007280349731,
0.016877073794603348,
0.20456217229366302,
0.10856698453426361,
0.963901698589325,
0.21024829149246216,
-0.3931845724582672,
0.3760857582092285,
-0.11044908314943314,
0.42513635754585266,
0.12753793597221375,
0.0324103981256485,
0.39617273211479187,
0.03572374954819679,
0.05837392061948776,
-0.07650882005691528,
-1.0388561487197876,
-0.4301034212112427,
0.28535500168800354,
-0.06030448153614998,
0.359849750995636,
0.5279259085655212,
0.7551456689834595,
0.3621024489402771,
0.08479852229356766,
-0.5179129242897034,
0.5424250364303589,
0.06132419407367706,
-0.7182230353355408,
-0.298170268535614,
-0.5089756846427917,
-0.755024254322052,
-0.20058593153953552,
-0.08794091641902924,
-0.7212969660758972,
0.037552978843450546,
0.35977038741111755,
-0.7230595350265503,
0.33738258481025696,
-0.8326321840286255,
0.5825363993644714,
-0.37760481238365173,
-0.3278184235095978,
-0.2407076060771942,
-0.26125550270080566,
0.18775396049022675,
0.02390262857079506,
0.5191468596458435,
0.21502068638801575,
-0.16543449461460114,
0.835522472858429,
-0.7803466320037842,
0.8280186653137207,
-0.28878918290138245,
0.1304260790348053,
0.16589856147766113,
0.207595556974411,
0.719826877117157,
-0.08411520719528198,
-0.16019533574581146,
-0.007542104460299015,
-0.07331550866365433,
-0.4272529184818268,
-0.5738821625709534,
0.6210992932319641,
-0.4761509299278259,
-0.23881347477436066,
-0.1237008199095726,
-0.40379178524017334,
-0.10294487327337265,
0.10943746566772461,
0.315911203622818,
0.81488037109375,
0.01627461612224579,
0.347036749124527,
0.49152636528015137,
-0.008552618324756622,
0.7753731608390808,
1.0194541215896606,
0.04007531329989433,
-0.5267112255096436,
0.6958144307136536,
0.5032558441162109,
0.42070481181144714,
0.017140833660960197,
0.11928819864988327,
-0.06516093760728836,
-0.24751552939414978,
-0.44901421666145325,
0.021977461874485016,
-0.3984481394290924,
-0.45496657490730286,
-0.8054379820823669,
-0.27962547540664673,
-0.17732428014278412,
-0.33568525314331055,
-0.15624862909317017,
-0.6035257577896118,
0.024566011503338814,
-0.20101693272590637,
0.6023766994476318,
0.36220741271972656,
0.2004561722278595,
0.809829831123352,
-0.8248450756072998,
0.12765564024448395,
0.0830591470003128,
0.34577128291130066,
-0.10237407684326172,
-0.28589513897895813,
-0.45611658692359924,
-0.085953488945961,
-0.4722606837749481,
-0.8612695336341858,
0.4013636112213135,
0.35116395354270935,
0.752251923084259,
0.3975101709365845,
0.5889599323272705,
0.8308632373809814,
-0.059002045542001724,
0.6719534993171692,
0.20514558255672455,
-0.8787800073623657,
0.6429346203804016,
-0.4447628855705261,
0.12617000937461853,
0.5367363095283508,
0.268887460231781,
-0.646355152130127,
-0.5077636241912842,
-1.0103793144226074,
-1.088174819946289,
0.9692068696022034,
0.27158740162849426,
-0.6347024440765381,
0.23335273563861847,
0.19946108758449554,
-0.19544284045696259,
0.3533858358860016,
-0.014360794797539711,
-0.1572711318731308,
0.03266482055187225,
0.15944314002990723,
-0.17227540910243988,
-0.39193081855773926,
-0.26346614956855774,
0.2583581805229187,
0.9607831835746765,
-0.11501876264810562,
0.24265769124031067,
0.1766813099384308,
-0.22108349204063416,
-0.11083504557609558,
0.5237221717834473,
0.6730507016181946,
0.311898797750473,
-0.2615913450717926,
-0.16297923028469086,
0.22916889190673828,
-0.38480910658836365,
-0.20621170103549957,
-0.04740586131811142,
-0.40975499153137207,
0.14546886086463928,
0.28860586881637573,
0.6369234323501587,
0.31888067722320557,
-0.6152425408363342,
0.23855261504650116,
-0.15261302888393402,
-0.3135799467563629,
-0.635272204875946,
0.2644929587841034,
-0.008443295024335384,
0.0776931643486023,
0.5593504905700684,
-0.2950915992259979,
0.25757575035095215,
-0.40899473428726196,
-0.027098190039396286,
0.44859227538108826,
-0.4399804472923279,
0.07555239647626877,
-0.08483101427555084,
0.3387753367424011,
-0.6546923518180847,
0.30611640214920044,
-0.1815822422504425,
-0.6413413882255554,
0.8784619569778442,
0.16873937845230103,
1.081363320350647,
-0.38812991976737976,
0.3152829706668854,
0.27947095036506653,
0.6556320190429688,
0.005170080345124006,
0.31022757291793823,
0.024027731269598007,
-0.2571156620979309,
-0.26011350750923157,
-0.05989956483244896,
-0.6138352155685425,
0.34399211406707764,
-0.7920877933502197,
0.36951565742492676,
-0.7828868627548218,
-0.10606200248003006,
-0.09065565466880798,
0.13774681091308594,
-0.5864327549934387,
-0.20043177902698517,
-0.554731547832489,
1.0026906728744507,
-0.7903807759284973,
0.22605803608894348,
0.8829705119132996,
-0.31909170746803284,
-0.8719758987426758,
0.16531020402908325,
0.15959161520004272,
-0.12491028755903244,
0.10886010527610779,
-0.04114188253879547,
-0.10029692202806473,
0.01226666010916233,
-0.30554336309432983,
-0.4211011528968811,
1.2713693380355835,
0.6716071963310242,
-0.6296342015266418,
0.27833637595176697,
-0.09657271951436996,
0.38587135076522827,
0.025071104988455772,
0.6002360582351685,
0.3388623595237732,
0.4887523949146271,
-0.10995914787054062,
-0.9031500816345215,
-0.1957516372203827,
-0.2498861402273178,
-0.42760950326919556,
0.7740086317062378,
-0.5550870299339294,
0.53778475522995,
0.05453948676586151,
-0.33716848492622375,
-0.19043521583080292,
-0.17071864008903503,
-0.021673765033483505,
0.5155425667762756,
0.8061462640762329,
0.48344793915748596,
0.6464046835899353,
0.004814725834876299,
1.1335995197296143,
0.04333914816379547,
0.05640866979956627,
1.2897419929504395,
0.1507679522037506,
0.41029754281044006,
0.7856752276420593,
0.16300068795681,
0.6204914450645447,
0.3596123456954956,
0.5803937911987305,
0.6984912753105164,
-0.3066631853580475,
-0.6293322443962097,
-0.6344271302223206,
-0.4566006362438202,
-0.27376124262809753,
-0.2386871874332428,
0.2759767472743988,
0.24214161932468414,
-0.8031887412071228,
0.10045935958623886,
0.39301490783691406,
-0.34027349948883057,
-0.39152953028678894,
1.1342958211898804,
-0.16330201923847198,
-0.5138732194900513,
0.4724808633327484,
-0.13470643758773804,
0.23291631042957306,
-0.6856613755226135,
0.057804957032203674,
-0.3788180649280548,
0.22558096051216125,
-0.42115458846092224,
-0.617801308631897,
0.7880902290344238,
0.241559699177742,
-0.24152833223342896,
-0.1577126681804657,
0.5910945534706116,
-0.1399068683385849,
-0.2644575536251068,
0.36841368675231934,
0.10342550277709961,
0.13940584659576416,
-0.56298828125,
-0.3324553966522217,
-0.13064849376678467,
0.016319410875439644,
0.21328125894069672,
0.3201894164085388,
0.4858866333961487,
-0.41985875368118286,
0.9138027429580688,
0.42321261763572693,
-0.027630968019366264,
0.05243191495537758,
-0.059003110975027084,
1.0178366899490356,
-0.3672499656677246,
-0.786687433719635,
-0.5569329261779785,
0.8786255717277527,
-0.5905121564865112,
-0.009358493611216545,
0.3273843824863434,
0.5096557140350342,
0.42330533266067505,
-0.005283970385789871,
0.9801464080810547,
-0.019838932901620865,
0.8274218440055847,
-0.43146589398384094,
0.5792250633239746,
-0.6313995718955994,
0.44375789165496826,
-0.3851153552532196,
-0.3474661409854889,
-0.13135582208633423,
0.5811343193054199,
-0.34556835889816284,
-0.5522611737251282,
0.5951082110404968,
0.8647224307060242,
0.0058321827091276646,
0.13555073738098145,
0.14545942842960358,
0.11461664736270905,
0.6477507948875427,
0.495391845703125,
0.9208564162254333,
-0.353117972612381,
0.8227034211158752,
-0.5079804062843323,
-0.30646082758903503,
-0.6366736888885498,
-1.3105920553207397,
-0.6434053182601929,
-0.4278668165206909,
-0.5706309676170349,
0.13063940405845642,
0.356387197971344,
0.593846321105957,
0.6307376027107239,
-0.495366632938385,
0.039536427706480026,
-0.39915135502815247,
0.171741783618927,
-0.2724493145942688,
-0.251016229391098,
-0.004121948499232531,
-0.3063122034072876,
-0.011466949246823788,
0.35231471061706543,
0.25016289949417114,
0.022938737645745277,
-0.18206055462360382,
-0.330625057220459,
0.027259401977062225,
-0.17961356043815613,
0.21577776968479156,
0.06130988523364067,
-0.30371901392936707,
-0.3361704349517822,
-0.19304022192955017,
0.01967644691467285,
-0.2729467749595642,
1.061176061630249,
-0.5382526516914368,
-0.05111076310276985,
0.2950466573238373,
0.5531085133552551,
0.3164100646972656,
-0.3749576508998871,
0.48137229681015015,
-1.046636700630188,
0.2720482051372528,
0.4444355070590973,
0.40298089385032654,
0.1087624654173851,
-0.6142511963844299,
0.7430127263069153,
0.057303279638290405,
-0.26893696188926697,
-0.9608168601989746,
0.3101351261138916,
-0.7699580192565918,
-0.11641999334096909,
0.8388860821723938,
-0.33159273862838745,
0.05186675861477852,
-0.7505292296409607,
-0.6342549920082092,
0.09607406705617905,
-0.5264025330543518,
0.9760240316390991,
0.5333722233772278,
0.03226926550269127,
-0.4941956400871277,
-0.5696181058883667,
0.46607571840286255,
0.6253827214241028,
-1.289167881011963,
-0.16807959973812103,
0.5216554999351501,
0.3158389627933502,
0.4431830048561096,
0.4263668954372406,
0.2966066300868988,
0.5547888875007629,
-0.5080791115760803,
0.04494772106409073,
-0.22987426817417145,
-0.6840416193008423,
-0.21083572506904602,
0.04825533926486969,
-0.05308258533477783,
-0.26511698961257935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17527v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17527v2
|
Predict the Next Word: Humans exhibit uncertainty in this task and language models _____
| 2024-02-27T14:11:32 | 2024-03-18T16:21:24 |
Evgenia Ilia, Wilker Aziz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Language models (LMs) are statistical models trained to assign probability to
human-generated text. As such, it is reasonable to question whether they
approximate linguistic variability exhibited by humans well. This form of
statistical assessment is difficult to perform at the passage level, for it
requires acceptability judgements (i.e., human evaluation) or a robust
automated proxy (which is non-trivial). At the word level, however, given some
context, samples from an LM can be assessed via exact matching against a
prerecorded dataset of alternative single-word continuations of the available
context. We exploit this fact and evaluate the LM's ability to reproduce
variability that humans (in particular, a population of English speakers)
exhibit in the 'next word prediction' task. This can be seen as assessing a
form of calibration, which, in the context of text classification, Baan et al.
(2022) termed calibration to human uncertainty. We assess GPT2, BLOOM and
ChatGPT and find that they exhibit fairly low calibration to human uncertainty.
We also verify the failure of expected calibration error (ECE) to reflect this,
and as such, advise the community against relying on it in this setting.
|
[
-0.08762027323246002,
-0.531745433807373,
0.6100170016288757,
-0.02945193462073803,
0.015926865860819817,
0.10516606271266937,
-0.1718222051858902,
-0.5474841594696045,
-0.19067151844501495,
0.6076917052268982,
-0.701589047908783,
-0.4363866150379181,
-0.5351075530052185,
0.1913524568080902,
-0.32297787070274353,
0.7196027636528015,
-0.0996076837182045,
0.10943599045276642,
-0.24992923438549042,
0.12850874662399292,
-0.7949398159980774,
-0.4706670343875885,
-0.6868985891342163,
-0.6025600433349609,
0.5784608721733093,
0.4846263527870178,
1.0132595300674438,
0.44411471486091614,
0.3893798291683197,
0.27352380752563477,
-0.003648974932730198,
-0.23235298693180084,
-0.4722403287887573,
-0.014288904145359993,
-0.1710534691810608,
-0.7865588068962097,
-0.17864741384983063,
0.28055882453918457,
0.3042815625667572,
0.8856590390205383,
-0.03153945878148079,
0.13331447541713715,
0.02635737508535385,
0.5128116607666016,
-0.47128212451934814,
0.06722943484783173,
-0.9102215766906738,
-0.08274352550506592,
-0.3243621289730072,
-0.154783234000206,
-0.4360422194004059,
-0.3589210510253906,
0.41526705026626587,
-0.3881778419017792,
0.22305786609649658,
0.1961393803358078,
0.7448179721832275,
0.33300039172172546,
-0.20035934448242188,
-0.22024528682231903,
-0.7212974429130554,
0.7218115329742432,
-0.7153390049934387,
0.4499017894268036,
1.056261658668518,
0.21075472235679626,
-0.35415998101234436,
-0.6861248016357422,
-0.6988648772239685,
-0.3616240322589874,
0.14079460501670837,
0.1293390691280365,
0.1365160495042801,
0.013872958719730377,
-0.14010103046894073,
0.057878438383340836,
-0.7650527954101562,
0.21709701418876648,
-0.48873573541641235,
-0.39362937211990356,
0.47914353013038635,
0.2098427563905716,
0.23632144927978516,
0.07901141047477722,
-0.20049089193344116,
-0.2838272452354431,
-0.6608467102050781,
-0.03571563586592674,
0.4844971299171448,
0.40410661697387695,
0.23549556732177734,
0.5674149990081787,
-0.04022878035902977,
0.6325694918632507,
-0.2692236006259918,
0.11486455798149109,
0.381736695766449,
-0.19538861513137817,
-0.13709613680839539,
-0.1220070868730545,
0.7094403505325317,
0.5443882942199707,
0.24653351306915283,
-0.004373128060251474,
-0.17114439606666565,
0.23390372097492218,
0.28497689962387085,
-0.41187483072280884,
-0.3892465829849243,
0.27096882462501526,
-0.07144658267498016,
-0.35628512501716614,
-0.017866546288132668,
-0.8407453298568726,
-0.41928428411483765,
-0.08185166865587234,
0.7196847796440125,
-0.4195629060268402,
-0.00704170111566782,
0.12805229425430298,
0.010882977396249771,
0.09801512211561203,
0.253307580947876,
-0.7656335234642029,
0.400790274143219,
0.6423747539520264,
0.7155069708824158,
-0.046342190355062485,
-0.6161377429962158,
-0.11665642261505127,
-0.1967354267835617,
-0.6649745106697083,
0.8286907076835632,
-0.46851876378059387,
-0.6988893747329712,
-0.019876467064023018,
0.050240278244018555,
0.06528899818658829,
-0.2948209345340729,
0.8698880076408386,
-0.5305406451225281,
0.6225309371948242,
-0.4296163022518158,
-0.8166145086288452,
-0.3943292200565338,
-0.004467040300369263,
-0.6001553535461426,
0.8215548992156982,
0.36687198281288147,
-0.9078102111816406,
0.5749461054801941,
-0.37152546644210815,
-0.10934391617774963,
0.375172883272171,
-0.16146717965602875,
-0.372301310300827,
0.09082084894180298,
-0.11523668467998505,
0.2689042091369629,
-0.1303890347480774,
-0.14636188745498657,
-0.46023643016815186,
-0.5001657605171204,
0.34266775846481323,
-0.6484849452972412,
0.38371649384498596,
0.06560105830430984,
-0.24544328451156616,
-0.1470639407634735,
-0.5561732649803162,
0.21578995883464813,
-0.02925826609134674,
-0.3237498104572296,
-0.3257615864276886,
0.5332187414169312,
0.1419755220413208,
0.1019480973482132,
0.22368811070919037,
-0.40610867738723755,
-0.08545812219381332,
-0.6469495296478271,
0.15966632962226868,
0.8200951218605042,
-0.06832636147737503,
0.3137325644493103,
-0.6569861173629761,
0.7347807884216309,
-0.3086392879486084,
-0.1456940919160843,
-0.1752447932958603,
-0.783500075340271,
-0.3710312843322754,
0.28538957238197327,
0.3786593973636627,
0.9165424704551697,
-0.4096328914165497,
0.35579121112823486,
-0.4831186830997467,
-0.6793980598449707,
-0.42075493931770325,
0.27270057797431946,
0.44786667823791504,
0.39436501264572144,
0.19246824085712433,
-0.3566875457763672,
-0.7065006494522095,
-0.5886534452438354,
-0.5930368304252625,
-0.5384680032730103,
-0.15043312311172485,
0.20322276651859283,
0.356649786233902,
-0.3698623776435852,
1.0201671123504639,
-0.40269923210144043,
-0.2324441373348236,
-0.08224695175886154,
0.4863109588623047,
0.14797177910804749,
0.2080685794353485,
0.10054891556501389,
-0.7082957029342651,
-0.41027846932411194,
0.023967979475855827,
-0.2684887647628784,
-0.16730207204818726,
0.0947633609175682,
0.09987706691026688,
0.23576731979846954,
0.5506432056427002,
-0.2957249581813812,
0.5429650545120239,
0.6932703852653503,
-0.4528667628765106,
0.6917943358421326,
-0.43757978081703186,
0.06237276270985603,
-1.0315431356430054,
-0.2574247717857361,
-0.045672304928302765,
-0.2783108651638031,
-0.5758891701698303,
-0.23873312771320343,
-0.026470443233847618,
0.19845546782016754,
-0.1344470977783203,
0.7258330583572388,
-0.3568505048751831,
-0.01855156384408474,
-0.40512505173683167,
0.09449821710586548,
-0.305213063955307,
0.039462704211473465,
0.07468757778406143,
0.8576784133911133,
0.40373408794403076,
-0.412448525428772,
0.25604307651519775,
0.052116166800260544,
-0.5119699835777283,
0.21016322076320648,
-0.5466349720954895,
0.19701898097991943,
-0.16824030876159668,
0.23616427183151245,
-1.2476942539215088,
-0.5210781097412109,
-0.14917965233325958,
-0.8260715007781982,
0.20398695766925812,
0.42510250210762024,
-0.360773503780365,
-0.7350227236747742,
-0.22776299715042114,
0.31999483704566956,
0.6837261915206909,
-0.13563810288906097,
0.20754581689834595,
0.3258220851421356,
-0.32759031653404236,
-0.5356155633926392,
-1.0054525136947632,
0.14731204509735107,
-0.17889739573001862,
-0.3094128370285034,
0.09402300417423248,
-0.2381058782339096,
-0.39321351051330566,
-0.05529410019516945,
0.13030663132667542,
-0.1337646245956421,
0.10663657635450363,
0.36168819665908813,
0.32790815830230713,
-0.008610909804701805,
0.2879159450531006,
-0.2716919183731079,
0.017105091363191605,
0.128132164478302,
-0.1972123682498932,
0.5218191146850586,
0.06230275705456734,
-0.47268402576446533,
-0.4295232594013214,
0.18166391551494598,
0.41943204402923584,
0.19483591616153717,
0.5619418025016785,
0.5714166164398193,
-0.7047060132026672,
0.10307444632053375,
-0.6647869348526001,
-0.09909316897392273,
-0.4567682147026062,
0.9320752024650574,
-0.4801526963710785,
-0.5602707266807556,
0.35871756076812744,
0.2935000956058502,
-0.056058939546346664,
0.5258216857910156,
0.6866478323936462,
-0.17052891850471497,
1.0821293592453003,
0.7425369620323181,
-0.21627715229988098,
0.2860076129436493,
0.28589630126953125,
-0.0026450464501976967,
-0.42984670400619507,
-0.06095631793141365,
-0.5665347576141357,
0.012593637220561504,
-0.7583945393562317,
-0.5470417141914368,
0.020006386563181877,
0.11169753223657608,
-0.1774621158838272,
0.5503947734832764,
-0.16524477303028107,
0.5980177521705627,
0.5018689036369324,
0.2139277160167694,
0.055903661996126175,
-0.11151862144470215,
-0.0942005142569542,
-0.2557348310947418,
-0.42390570044517517,
-0.754396378993988,
1.2830629348754883,
0.3044692575931549,
0.7118415832519531,
-0.007444984279572964,
0.5632906556129456,
0.30935052037239075,
0.5351805686950684,
-0.8050619959831238,
0.43473929166793823,
-0.15839572250843048,
-0.6842517256736755,
-0.5043947100639343,
-0.35470664501190186,
-0.9879173636436462,
0.0532766692340374,
-0.14363038539886475,
-1.3024202585220337,
-0.029589353129267693,
0.06087571009993553,
-0.5504701137542725,
0.21355439722537994,
-0.8117703795433044,
0.6696817874908447,
-0.05012195184826851,
-0.17657692730426788,
-0.11414966732263565,
-0.6716716289520264,
0.20188409090042114,
-0.6446980237960815,
0.5980157256126404,
-0.20012575387954712,
-0.44509240984916687,
0.6293274164199829,
-0.2213762402534485,
0.7545202374458313,
0.2531103193759918,
-0.10713832825422287,
0.3209640383720398,
0.2795904576778412,
0.33710235357284546,
-0.23241116106510162,
-0.3385162055492401,
-0.16749145090579987,
0.22497183084487915,
-0.3055611848831177,
-0.3428007662296295,
0.38198089599609375,
-0.7282015085220337,
-0.5452798008918762,
-0.4495130181312561,
-0.4863206446170807,
-0.5809134244918823,
0.05408032238483429,
0.7279828190803528,
0.1899639070034027,
-0.45850884914398193,
-0.14147523045539856,
0.23183369636535645,
-0.1673615276813507,
0.3939895033836365,
0.30025559663772583,
-0.4555310904979706,
-0.34535300731658936,
0.8423284292221069,
0.0734538584947586,
0.44859614968299866,
0.39400532841682434,
0.4158906638622284,
-0.6079738140106201,
-0.44716355204582214,
0.01524598989635706,
0.08401362597942352,
-0.6602684855461121,
-0.03035891242325306,
-0.2949749827384949,
-0.09439082443714142,
-0.4618646204471588,
-0.04575096443295479,
-0.14617976546287537,
0.01339748129248619,
-0.5374190807342529,
-0.09705333411693573,
0.1893729865550995,
1.0544586181640625,
0.020230159163475037,
0.5640304684638977,
-0.8260408043861389,
-0.1574811190366745,
0.43598225712776184,
0.23401907086372375,
-0.44691652059555054,
-0.9749311804771423,
0.03472290560603142,
0.2252635955810547,
-0.2694168984889984,
-1.1945607662200928,
0.5285142660140991,
0.44807809591293335,
0.39476117491722107,
0.2686397433280945,
-0.22421595454216003,
0.5964843034744263,
-0.6995237469673157,
0.9396337270736694,
0.20170286297798157,
-0.9567788243293762,
0.47237804532051086,
-0.21479898691177368,
0.4322245717048645,
0.7966902256011963,
0.5553693771362305,
-0.7017742991447449,
-0.44284144043922424,
-0.6684752702713013,
-0.7870396971702576,
0.5706977248191833,
0.07928773015737534,
0.41111165285110474,
-0.0355885811150074,
0.4402218759059906,
0.11518736928701401,
0.09900536388158798,
-0.6670188307762146,
-0.004386629909276962,
0.19309541583061218,
-0.2503089904785156,
-0.6452553868293762,
-0.43478861451148987,
0.3119100332260132,
-0.14015817642211914,
0.7256676554679871,
-0.08374157547950745,
0.19638244807720184,
0.1431082785129547,
0.049870725721120834,
-0.3323827385902405,
0.18548502027988434,
0.6103183627128601,
0.7500967979431152,
-0.33792033791542053,
0.0411406010389328,
0.4642193913459778,
-0.7350764870643616,
0.02403891086578369,
0.03062734380364418,
-0.1007646843791008,
0.29122307896614075,
0.49621275067329407,
0.729873776435852,
0.16739358007907867,
-0.8147695064544678,
0.7626470327377319,
-0.149551659822464,
-0.2306213676929474,
-0.5580477714538574,
-0.15725953876972198,
0.10179547220468521,
0.04030967503786087,
0.33925244212150574,
0.23043718934059143,
0.1093917042016983,
-0.7176660299301147,
0.43379244208335876,
0.2878481447696686,
-0.7334340810775757,
-0.4954206645488739,
0.6794780492782593,
-0.18652452528476715,
-0.7171039581298828,
0.28644242882728577,
-0.4649564027786255,
-0.8785718083381653,
0.4600750207901001,
0.41856473684310913,
0.846935510635376,
-0.6475204229354858,
0.03029334917664528,
0.4898623526096344,
0.42604777216911316,
-0.5169346332550049,
0.476502388715744,
0.5322499871253967,
-0.9514405131340027,
-0.5388244390487671,
-0.7220973372459412,
-0.48812347650527954,
0.19810113310813904,
-0.5643756985664368,
0.49597102403640747,
-0.15754534304141998,
-0.40878549218177795,
-0.20428656041622162,
0.03206367418169975,
-0.7538507580757141,
0.4331580102443695,
0.40562987327575684,
0.9195224046707153,
-1.0115278959274292,
0.8190751671791077,
0.6887256503105164,
-0.16150100529193878,
-0.9310213327407837,
0.30209973454475403,
0.20990006625652313,
-0.7840374112129211,
0.4607045650482178,
0.2817956209182739,
0.07173173874616623,
-0.16278982162475586,
-0.36446720361709595,
-0.7720680236816406,
0.9771397113800049,
0.1782233864068985,
-0.6462793350219727,
-0.1011158898472786,
0.14175058901309967,
0.7014135718345642,
-0.12157446891069412,
0.5090794563293457,
0.7354041934013367,
0.5010594725608826,
0.13857446610927582,
-1.1144448518753052,
-0.15857529640197754,
0.0423334576189518,
0.2854028642177582,
-0.10576266795396805,
-0.13338689506053925,
0.8975481390953064,
-0.5339403748512268,
-0.20483985543251038,
0.4883301854133606,
0.7588114142417908,
-0.03945436701178551,
0.10728772729635239,
0.7487817406654358,
0.38784468173980713,
1.0090423822402954,
-0.15983064472675323,
1.1571166515350342,
-0.1924172341823578,
0.4924525320529938,
1.514115333557129,
-0.16182605922222137,
1.3407585620880127,
0.37535011768341064,
-0.7220984101295471,
0.47331422567367554,
1.0411702394485474,
0.18029408156871796,
0.5145955681800842,
0.42588287591934204,
-0.3915131092071533,
-0.142172172665596,
0.16037854552268982,
-0.24106600880622864,
0.7396840453147888,
0.5081639289855957,
-0.35226157307624817,
-0.015444980934262276,
-0.13004758954048157,
-0.127470463514328,
0.2428015172481537,
-0.34782958030700684,
0.6575402021408081,
-0.0039446549490094185,
-0.7968747615814209,
0.27933868765830994,
-0.13209789991378784,
0.6748300790786743,
-0.44398632645606995,
0.17050381004810333,
0.01055966131389141,
0.26696211099624634,
-0.10068484395742416,
-0.8786284923553467,
0.3004387617111206,
-0.2957102954387665,
0.10127907246351242,
0.21738189458847046,
0.5757825970649719,
-0.5434980988502502,
-0.6773437261581421,
0.30447226762771606,
0.5962667465209961,
0.43535444140434265,
-0.11321988701820374,
-0.6390748023986816,
-0.23332224786281586,
0.05545936897397041,
-0.39152082800865173,
0.15530139207839966,
0.29959404468536377,
0.06570899486541748,
0.8740342855453491,
0.3981812596321106,
0.3614382743835449,
0.24163968861103058,
-0.026704734191298485,
0.24502091109752655,
-0.5236393213272095,
-0.34721797704696655,
-0.9566522240638733,
0.14018107950687408,
0.16503308713436127,
-0.4643137454986572,
0.5127878785133362,
0.3801429271697998,
0.8246793150901794,
0.12153568118810654,
0.8709183931350708,
0.1980467289686203,
0.7451468110084534,
-0.19853027164936066,
0.5272905230522156,
-0.5468257069587708,
0.21373052895069122,
-0.42125487327575684,
-0.7834203839302063,
-0.2783803641796112,
0.6257116198539734,
-0.3551127016544342,
0.11925668269395828,
0.8690977692604065,
0.8674301505088806,
0.28766730427742004,
0.28716525435447693,
0.6279790997505188,
0.2502492368221283,
-0.12040970474481583,
0.6219351291656494,
0.5970055460929871,
-0.4273739159107208,
0.5328917503356934,
-0.1548748016357422,
-0.3303550183773041,
0.05765480175614357,
-0.9296199083328247,
-0.5878524780273438,
-0.8180466294288635,
-0.16750027239322662,
-0.5886402130126953,
-0.027732500806450844,
1.0172374248504639,
0.5045967698097229,
-0.9075360298156738,
-0.29056763648986816,
-0.4502117335796356,
-0.1316646933555603,
0.004087128676474094,
-0.22002387046813965,
0.18377970159053802,
-0.35834529995918274,
-0.9161767959594727,
0.10253464430570602,
-0.01942359283566475,
0.25677821040153503,
-0.3097411096096039,
-0.11127348989248276,
-0.008105695247650146,
0.24027886986732483,
0.34497177600860596,
0.2350817769765854,
-0.8842679858207703,
-0.5492808818817139,
-0.12653790414333344,
-0.33345159888267517,
-0.10719463974237442,
0.3050863742828369,
-0.7063649892807007,
0.5413777232170105,
0.4486997425556183,
0.7362684011459351,
0.13959971070289612,
-0.14063729345798492,
0.8796439170837402,
-0.4483685791492462,
-0.05663503333926201,
0.34648382663726807,
0.5396649837493896,
0.39871838688850403,
-0.20525236427783966,
0.42605531215667725,
0.2942907512187958,
-0.7050909399986267,
-0.6341167688369751,
0.2755751311779022,
-0.7014740705490112,
-0.20542699098587036,
1.2466264963150024,
-0.2731618285179138,
-0.2906687259674072,
-0.23406697809696198,
-0.21416544914245605,
0.18595238029956818,
-0.17493461072444916,
0.676950216293335,
1.1594351530075073,
0.16977769136428833,
-0.06905245035886765,
-0.804551899433136,
0.5296300053596497,
0.5525208115577698,
-0.6268571019172668,
0.0017910217866301537,
0.23369722068309784,
0.4325237274169922,
0.20377209782600403,
0.6408487558364868,
0.06638742983341217,
0.165084108710289,
0.13469000160694122,
-0.02451428398489952,
0.4908662736415863,
0.1517023891210556,
-0.43322861194610596,
-0.06848093867301941,
0.27006611227989197,
-0.14453570544719696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17512v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17512v2
|
Latent Attention for Linear Time Transformers
| 2024-02-27T13:54:48 | 2024-03-04T12:21:52 |
Rares Dolga, Marius Cobzarenco, David Barber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.ML
|
The time complexity of the standard attention mechanism in a transformer
scales quadratically with the length of the sequence. We introduce a method to
reduce this to linear scaling with time, based on defining attention via latent
vectors. The method is readily usable as a drop-in replacement for the standard
attention mechanism. Our "Latte Transformer" model can be implemented for both
bidirectional and unidirectional tasks, with the causal version allowing a
recurrent implementation which is memory and time-efficient during inference of
language generation tasks. Whilst next token prediction scales linearly with
the sequence length for a standard transformer, a Latte Transformer requires
constant time to compute the next token. The empirical performance of our
method is comparable to standard attention, yet allows scaling to context
windows much larger than practical in standard attention.
|
[
-0.16118016839027405,
-0.5958685874938965,
0.4445874094963074,
0.455486536026001,
-0.041766200214624405,
0.06098567694425583,
-0.12337793409824371,
-0.18666818737983704,
0.2605205774307251,
0.2595409154891968,
-0.7330631613731384,
0.29722100496292114,
-0.5027254819869995,
-0.11409733444452286,
-0.4528313875198364,
1.230300784111023,
-0.20079529285430908,
-0.28634703159332275,
-0.027299175038933754,
0.01434954535216093,
-0.2404865324497223,
-0.3588317632675171,
-0.9232946038246155,
-0.5809974074363708,
1.1462719440460205,
0.10076020658016205,
0.8400417566299438,
0.45735788345336914,
0.7022535800933838,
0.2508343756198883,
-0.3290086090564728,
-0.229847714304924,
-0.9087520241737366,
-0.17341509461402893,
-0.3177303671836853,
-0.7083481550216675,
-0.4725267291069031,
0.20119847357273102,
0.5796343088150024,
1.0235403776168823,
0.2044392228126526,
0.5484790802001953,
0.10733428597450256,
0.5725674629211426,
-0.5736867189407349,
0.16812075674533844,
-0.4994814097881317,
0.4318132698535919,
-0.04545974358916283,
-0.4546419680118561,
-0.4894523024559021,
-0.21237565577030182,
0.22031861543655396,
-0.4222804307937622,
0.6271246075630188,
0.0024476461112499237,
0.5708909630775452,
0.6576159000396729,
-0.3261603116989136,
0.2640160620212555,
-1.2528009414672852,
1.0868055820465088,
-0.23552732169628143,
0.4072644114494324,
0.07857296615839005,
0.3559080958366394,
0.043256498873233795,
-1.145126461982727,
-0.5551881790161133,
-0.18701443076133728,
-0.250057190656662,
-0.03897901996970177,
-0.351766973733902,
-0.03332674875855446,
0.5278566479682922,
0.39840981364250183,
-0.369431734085083,
-0.2393236607313156,
-0.43331485986709595,
-0.08754239231348038,
0.23276762664318085,
0.36652565002441406,
0.05520607903599739,
0.06916360557079315,
-0.31505087018013,
0.1995783895254135,
-0.7020164728164673,
0.2534918487071991,
0.1643306016921997,
0.14615309238433838,
-0.052737727761268616,
0.4921785295009613,
0.021452154964208603,
0.4738331735134125,
0.5755864977836609,
0.04472770169377327,
0.1271980255842209,
-0.318841814994812,
-0.0758940652012825,
-0.07229385524988174,
0.47988468408584595,
0.4542126953601837,
0.1133042424917221,
-0.5011563301086426,
-0.10632652789354324,
0.2311653345823288,
0.5876946449279785,
-0.8530677556991577,
-0.15973158180713654,
0.11782176047563553,
-0.49603742361068726,
-0.37943750619888306,
-0.46939533948898315,
-0.6848381161689758,
0.16468064486980438,
-0.3580559194087982,
0.4819447696208954,
0.11639101803302765,
0.11911718547344208,
-0.11514680832624435,
0.17260822653770447,
0.3233131468296051,
0.3435361087322235,
-0.9853502511978149,
0.366351455450058,
0.5416402220726013,
0.9832079410552979,
-0.2922782599925995,
0.11629333347082138,
-0.8211632966995239,
0.04975660517811775,
-0.3241150677204132,
0.6370636224746704,
-0.48031991720199585,
-0.25207290053367615,
-0.11021058261394501,
0.2032443732023239,
-0.20722290873527527,
-0.16928541660308838,
0.5896077752113342,
-0.6962130069732666,
0.45723897218704224,
-0.08322247862815857,
-0.25055408477783203,
-0.04531586170196533,
-0.17467239499092102,
-0.7426692247390747,
1.153366208076477,
0.4645315110683441,
-0.8450406789779663,
0.04286620393395424,
-0.7254632711410522,
-0.6378893852233887,
0.10241208970546722,
-0.005215054377913475,
-0.5235338807106018,
0.22348350286483765,
0.3187560439109802,
0.4346827268600464,
-0.30550503730773926,
0.030556749552488327,
-0.04350942000746727,
-0.4791680872440338,
0.20992235839366913,
-0.540959894657135,
0.6002339124679565,
0.2285851687192917,
-0.6751267313957214,
0.13378728926181793,
-0.749301552772522,
-0.13563568890094757,
0.3673767149448395,
-0.1876600682735443,
0.0265522263944149,
0.14982429146766663,
0.33562254905700684,
0.2504483163356781,
0.5065512657165527,
-0.5366316437721252,
0.03763405606150627,
-0.792806088924408,
0.7758690118789673,
0.7794252634048462,
0.0032909978181123734,
0.7974052429199219,
-0.05383048206567764,
0.5525209307670593,
-0.02613731659948826,
0.41723692417144775,
-0.1935543715953827,
-0.21674862504005432,
-1.3342149257659912,
0.239040806889534,
0.18596184253692627,
0.38955116271972656,
-0.5701249241828918,
0.40487682819366455,
-0.4584467113018036,
-0.3041874170303345,
-0.2932845652103424,
-0.06915586441755295,
0.38625526428222656,
0.5449930429458618,
0.2995936870574951,
-0.14747771620750427,
-0.21112480759620667,
-0.946156919002533,
0.016965990886092186,
-0.020998090505599976,
-0.3905194401741028,
0.2575762867927551,
0.30008047819137573,
-0.07507315278053284,
0.9731961488723755,
-0.6847704648971558,
-0.05112230032682419,
-0.09560685604810715,
0.29852181673049927,
0.36415547132492065,
0.19214418530464172,
0.5905755162239075,
-0.761664867401123,
-0.43995600938796997,
0.06919921934604645,
-0.4139736294746399,
-0.009841270744800568,
-0.06282392889261246,
0.19264428317546844,
0.2083330750465393,
0.7780932188034058,
-0.46609658002853394,
0.6565253734588623,
0.4425911009311676,
-0.35980868339538574,
0.04335097223520279,
0.006991582456976175,
-0.06611626595258713,
-1.0692875385284424,
0.22486090660095215,
-0.1708758920431137,
-0.3500000238418579,
-0.852137565612793,
-0.29380738735198975,
0.20993682742118835,
-0.314672589302063,
-0.638950526714325,
0.5225276947021484,
-0.23820683360099792,
-0.06781750917434692,
-0.1691131442785263,
0.05157284438610077,
-0.0042759510688483715,
0.9304569959640503,
-0.07160309702157974,
0.8053057193756104,
-0.13026151061058044,
-0.5352843403816223,
0.310392290353775,
-0.13255232572555542,
0.039970822632312775,
0.516934871673584,
-1.1975568532943726,
0.44970130920410156,
-0.21368177235126495,
0.02013454958796501,
-1.232630729675293,
0.09290005266666412,
0.17533107101917267,
-0.46242889761924744,
0.34161436557769775,
0.035907547920942307,
-0.28580835461616516,
-0.6971051096916199,
-0.13540300726890564,
0.5733833312988281,
0.41054677963256836,
-0.5632724165916443,
0.5999261736869812,
-0.08305417001247406,
-0.3313271105289459,
-0.5773714780807495,
-0.5402824878692627,
-0.1199222281575203,
-0.2300463765859604,
-0.4919934868812561,
0.516946017742157,
-0.07053399831056595,
0.00184701441321522,
0.05729255452752113,
-0.19110596179962158,
0.2212614268064499,
-0.16365227103233337,
0.09305458515882492,
0.06312882155179977,
-0.21504414081573486,
0.2423243522644043,
-0.07577056437730789,
-0.38217851519584656,
0.08581502735614777,
-0.2829435169696808,
0.5800588726997375,
0.03272279351949692,
-0.09092185646295547,
-0.49017781019210815,
0.4179709553718567,
0.8152468204498291,
-0.41063180565834045,
0.6533722281455994,
0.812056303024292,
-0.3646211326122284,
-0.04637761414051056,
-0.5063981413841248,
-0.3674718141555786,
-0.4744529128074646,
0.3707137405872345,
-0.30484476685523987,
-0.9430667161941528,
0.5753477811813354,
0.12980498373508453,
0.17484615743160248,
0.5212184190750122,
0.7364547848701477,
0.0035459273494780064,
0.9904745221138,
0.883728563785553,
-0.1852903813123703,
0.6425940990447998,
-0.2418680340051651,
0.753445565700531,
-0.8390470147132874,
-0.10786819458007812,
-0.5377298593521118,
-0.6082563996315002,
-0.3038737177848816,
-0.6965286731719971,
0.3294643759727478,
-0.1573382467031479,
-0.20125387609004974,
0.3463778793811798,
-0.6230693459510803,
0.3969641625881195,
0.33440810441970825,
0.097127765417099,
0.0773402601480484,
-0.03650841861963272,
0.28599831461906433,
-0.4174467623233795,
-0.5139569044113159,
-0.35054507851600647,
1.1466426849365234,
0.5846552848815918,
0.8008487224578857,
0.05974583327770233,
0.3361107110977173,
0.34215113520622253,
0.210597425699234,
-0.9087300300598145,
0.3552038073539734,
-0.004754586610943079,
-0.40641099214553833,
-0.5321943163871765,
-0.4114611744880676,
-1.2093364000320435,
-0.0658239871263504,
0.04033217951655388,
-0.8235204815864563,
0.038364630192518234,
0.19736437499523163,
-0.6471372842788696,
0.16898252069950104,
-0.6411334276199341,
0.7760587334632874,
-0.08171812444925308,
-0.6112388968467712,
-0.2589609622955322,
-0.7395180463790894,
-0.11678731441497803,
-0.1454094797372818,
-0.17390525341033936,
-0.07146596163511276,
-0.22469082474708557,
0.8734582662582397,
-0.39093300700187683,
0.996502697467804,
-0.053930968046188354,
-0.09934911131858826,
0.07453251630067825,
-0.04507069289684296,
0.7669075131416321,
0.053415246307849884,
0.5737191438674927,
-0.03902891278266907,
-0.5124684572219849,
-0.5411858558654785,
-0.927272617816925,
0.5890279412269592,
-0.9075471758842468,
-0.523040235042572,
-0.276095449924469,
-0.7161914110183716,
-0.026082709431648254,
0.09997682273387909,
0.31047916412353516,
0.34523093700408936,
-0.274541974067688,
0.2235053926706314,
0.9630897045135498,
0.12143338471651077,
0.806701123714447,
0.3141726553440094,
-0.05828777700662613,
-0.098099485039711,
0.6463753581047058,
0.2650983929634094,
0.1952962875366211,
0.8359361886978149,
0.1088762953877449,
-0.4175441265106201,
-0.13500694930553436,
0.00415731081739068,
0.19852988421916962,
-0.42019733786582947,
0.08454375714063644,
-0.9779238700866699,
-0.42112821340560913,
-0.3951528072357178,
-0.2344582974910736,
-0.6398652195930481,
-0.7048990726470947,
-0.45928943157196045,
0.1585516333580017,
0.2492729276418686,
0.6853325963020325,
0.29737529158592224,
0.5640587210655212,
-0.43748408555984497,
0.39359670877456665,
0.7689219117164612,
0.31749090552330017,
0.07566175609827042,
-0.9631978869438171,
-0.2900002896785736,
-0.38226860761642456,
-0.43453389406204224,
-0.5589738488197327,
0.26430973410606384,
0.028300832957029343,
0.5054875016212463,
0.5811399221420288,
-0.18589067459106445,
0.2337508499622345,
-0.9196122288703918,
0.7771525382995605,
0.503757655620575,
-0.9455158710479736,
0.5757479071617126,
-0.38372349739074707,
0.4518035054206848,
-0.07215887308120728,
0.46125805377960205,
-0.5749576687812805,
-0.158877894282341,
-0.7133926749229431,
-0.8641605973243713,
0.6377990245819092,
0.6095249652862549,
0.2867441475391388,
0.1322568655014038,
0.48226532340049744,
-0.2582952082157135,
0.08515595644712448,
-0.7574829459190369,
-0.39039739966392517,
-0.04817700758576393,
-0.04747984930872917,
-0.7521497011184692,
-0.5091322660446167,
-0.08704055845737457,
-0.19335757195949554,
0.2572461664676666,
-0.0015203412622213364,
0.627497136592865,
0.17425034940242767,
0.031149491667747498,
-0.3527486324310303,
0.2529223561286926,
0.7612807154655457,
0.6079280376434326,
-0.2592748999595642,
0.17393220961093903,
0.14917457103729248,
-0.4879160225391388,
0.3336855471134186,
0.039528828114271164,
-0.24762801826000214,
0.09870290756225586,
0.2635778784751892,
0.8449403643608093,
0.49192875623703003,
-0.1143946424126625,
0.40963321924209595,
-0.23738089203834534,
-0.1071169376373291,
-0.42648693919181824,
-0.1371157169342041,
0.2206660807132721,
0.344841867685318,
0.3557138442993164,
0.07271324098110199,
0.19686557352542877,
-0.04378790780901909,
0.2662498652935028,
-0.05349985137581825,
-0.842800498008728,
-0.41719722747802734,
1.0434470176696777,
0.4533504247665405,
-0.6684325337409973,
0.3714018166065216,
0.07944680750370026,
-0.232480987906456,
0.6186130046844482,
0.5522745251655579,
0.9802875518798828,
-0.6412442326545715,
0.051580995321273804,
0.33389025926589966,
0.44515275955200195,
0.14507976174354553,
-0.03905334323644638,
-0.07466588169336319,
-0.4220639765262604,
-0.5792713761329651,
-0.6766143441200256,
-0.12040597200393677,
0.40261805057525635,
-0.6807277798652649,
0.17598305642604828,
-0.58441561460495,
-0.5372171998023987,
0.4527130126953125,
-0.18048475682735443,
-0.7111866474151611,
0.061710380017757416,
-0.047167934477329254,
0.3710364103317261,
-0.8406468629837036,
0.6059707999229431,
0.5266619920730591,
-0.33465850353240967,
-0.5127739310264587,
0.05798867344856262,
-0.1503959447145462,
-0.5862537622451782,
0.8574811816215515,
0.15640486776828766,
-0.3178096115589142,
-0.06943215429782867,
-0.31836482882499695,
-1.0877203941345215,
0.780338704586029,
0.26707080006599426,
-0.8095374703407288,
-0.21187390387058258,
0.1950579732656479,
0.7057693600654602,
-0.3198521137237549,
0.09906592220067978,
0.6257010102272034,
0.06565707921981812,
0.14031486213207245,
-0.9012526273727417,
-0.1372489631175995,
-0.2823883891105652,
0.4746772348880768,
0.4119810461997986,
-0.8457197546958923,
1.1777397394180298,
-0.29889124631881714,
-0.13599535822868347,
-0.22563251852989197,
0.9875794053077698,
-0.521417498588562,
0.17837701737880707,
0.5486225485801697,
0.47043338418006897,
0.4896460175514221,
-0.1191682294011116,
0.8087353706359863,
-0.39050155878067017,
0.5530049800872803,
1.1442240476608276,
-0.14860403537750244,
0.6934272050857544,
0.8558104038238525,
-0.5851017236709595,
0.30289220809936523,
0.5079557299613953,
0.20625820755958557,
0.4869478642940521,
0.2806988060474396,
-0.2858192026615143,
-0.08742289990186691,
-0.16877681016921997,
-0.29252544045448303,
0.30135196447372437,
0.35586851835250854,
-0.508941113948822,
-0.16132718324661255,
-0.0982714369893074,
0.1504967361688614,
0.12896116077899933,
-0.4541398882865906,
0.45402470231056213,
0.03577326983213425,
-0.7077962756156921,
0.6873618364334106,
-0.1956411898136139,
0.2822090983390808,
-0.2376781553030014,
-0.08080596476793289,
-0.24673619866371155,
0.5440419316291809,
-0.06807231158018112,
-0.4988100826740265,
0.3860321342945099,
-0.2216101884841919,
-0.6208799481391907,
-0.12976111471652985,
0.4899035394191742,
-0.3221241235733032,
-0.7218398451805115,
0.4285368025302887,
0.14555767178535461,
-0.03905104100704193,
0.07940920442342758,
-0.46354395151138306,
-0.1109066903591156,
0.06753335893154144,
-0.5167440176010132,
-0.04357514530420303,
0.28721538186073303,
-0.04760201275348663,
0.6175041198730469,
0.4278090000152588,
-0.2665942907333374,
0.26942798495292664,
0.36607325077056885,
0.8456502556800842,
-0.5692511796951294,
-0.5938823819160461,
-0.5711537003517151,
0.27584609389305115,
-0.039465077221393585,
-0.06232607737183571,
0.47767969965934753,
0.5112136006355286,
0.6146718859672546,
-0.19893589615821838,
0.6817458271980286,
0.05632222816348076,
0.6010128259658813,
-0.3658114969730377,
0.4782232642173767,
-0.6644538640975952,
0.04384373500943184,
-0.11720514297485352,
-1.2240341901779175,
-0.2857487201690674,
0.586266279220581,
-0.45037513971328735,
0.11558359116315842,
0.9768760204315186,
0.7049155235290527,
-0.10382954776287079,
-0.2050863802433014,
0.4249846339225769,
0.11361771821975708,
0.23814435303211212,
0.9390293955802917,
0.5618124604225159,
-0.4991413652896881,
0.7165402770042419,
-0.2863311767578125,
-0.39406466484069824,
-0.33886247873306274,
-0.6630426049232483,
-1.345280408859253,
-0.5733623504638672,
-0.2415710985660553,
-0.3366064429283142,
-0.01549671869724989,
0.5273104906082153,
0.6074009537696838,
-0.779011607170105,
0.02815011702477932,
0.05282860994338989,
-0.05370543524622917,
-0.16661426424980164,
-0.25550347566604614,
0.6022577285766602,
-0.7227312922477722,
-1.054339051246643,
-0.11669038981199265,
0.5460619330406189,
0.01712709292769432,
-0.579613447189331,
0.22969874739646912,
0.04073014855384827,
0.11603374779224396,
0.8467084169387817,
0.1776190549135208,
-0.7142722606658936,
-0.44440844655036926,
0.24395975470542908,
-0.20166170597076416,
0.1548537313938141,
1.112222671508789,
-0.4550706148147583,
0.36356449127197266,
0.49488773941993713,
0.4026277959346771,
0.8342714309692383,
-0.36935722827911377,
0.6170401573181152,
-0.8737941980361938,
0.6996190547943115,
0.3510713577270508,
0.3060917854309082,
0.11458612233400345,
-0.606950044631958,
0.512401282787323,
0.3516498804092407,
-0.6653681993484497,
-0.396236777305603,
0.348305344581604,
-1.065568447113037,
0.10150160640478134,
0.9441701769828796,
-0.13761785626411438,
-0.6325598359107971,
-0.32219794392585754,
-0.1212378442287445,
0.3225640654563904,
-0.4221927523612976,
0.66135174036026,
0.4102633595466614,
-0.027029018849134445,
-0.4138694703578949,
-0.40765783190727234,
0.45651671290397644,
0.568420946598053,
-0.3990509510040283,
0.20559416711330414,
0.08743442595005035,
0.07555454969406128,
0.7050366401672363,
0.5975048542022705,
-0.2521646022796631,
0.29851722717285156,
0.02384556271135807,
0.1150187999010086,
0.496502548456192,
-0.5808799862861633,
-0.2901252210140228,
0.18592147529125214,
-0.17858992516994476,
-0.17657679319381714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17509v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17509v2
|
Extreme Miscalibration and the Illusion of Adversarial Robustness
| 2024-02-27T13:49:12 | 2024-05-31T00:09:56 |
Vyas Raina, Samson Tan, Volkan Cevher, Aditya Rawal, Sheng Zha, George Karypis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Deep learning-based Natural Language Processing (NLP) models are vulnerable
to adversarial attacks, where small perturbations can cause a model to
misclassify. Adversarial Training (AT) is often used to increase model
robustness. However, we have discovered an intriguing phenomenon: deliberately
or accidentally miscalibrating models masks gradients in a way that interferes
with adversarial attack search methods, giving rise to an apparent increase in
robustness. We show that this observed gain in robustness is an illusion of
robustness (IOR), and demonstrate how an adversary can perform various forms of
test-time temperature calibration to nullify the aforementioned interference
and allow the adversarial attack to find adversarial examples. Hence, we urge
the NLP community to incorporate test-time temperature scaling into their
robustness evaluations to ensure that any observed gains are genuine. Finally,
we show how the temperature can be scaled during \textit{training} to improve
genuine robustness.
|
[
-0.3631174862384796,
-0.8767176270484924,
-0.0009482032619416714,
-0.19357527792453766,
-0.07554083317518234,
0.0768350139260292,
-0.06201743334531784,
-0.4203108549118042,
-0.15714818239212036,
0.35126689076423645,
-0.367190957069397,
0.011714671738445759,
-0.7515745759010315,
-0.254382848739624,
-0.4858466684818268,
1.0998945236206055,
0.28572985529899597,
0.2936412990093231,
0.07326699048280716,
-0.2820312976837158,
-0.14908315241336823,
-0.7187542915344238,
-0.5961146950721741,
-0.5083917379379272,
0.16891780495643616,
-0.1721513420343399,
1.4252969026565552,
0.5939475893974304,
0.5796219110488892,
0.2156766802072525,
-0.05071672797203064,
-0.021395578980445862,
-0.5652260184288025,
0.20820626616477966,
0.020047767087817192,
-0.896833062171936,
-0.3282974660396576,
0.0819191038608551,
0.5601897835731506,
0.6507530212402344,
-0.09093385189771652,
-0.07726917415857315,
0.3075372874736786,
0.6750102043151855,
-0.9333186149597168,
-0.3244520425796509,
-1.1170755624771118,
0.31952422857284546,
-0.08585620671510696,
-0.23985715210437775,
-0.2927379906177521,
-0.08242963254451752,
0.11111760884523392,
-0.3945674002170563,
0.6198708415031433,
-0.11074917763471603,
0.9175524115562439,
0.655310332775116,
-0.15616363286972046,
-0.12916815280914307,
-0.9310228824615479,
0.8769456148147583,
-0.8192527890205383,
0.20358306169509888,
0.5189386606216431,
0.25682124495506287,
-0.25293660163879395,
-0.4450702369213104,
-0.5407882928848267,
-0.16262957453727722,
0.20351064205169678,
0.11761545389890671,
-0.6040914058685303,
0.09709884971380234,
0.5441760420799255,
0.3780581057071686,
-0.6750015020370483,
0.07782917469739914,
0.03382569178938866,
-0.28421223163604736,
0.3534769117832184,
0.16205008327960968,
0.4132380485534668,
0.19233746826648712,
-0.33793631196022034,
-0.38023287057876587,
-0.43948784470558167,
-0.03739098832011223,
0.6840912103652954,
0.42102333903312683,
0.20153771340847015,
0.4306788444519043,
0.33697274327278137,
0.5986743569374084,
-0.09053122252225876,
0.26608994603157043,
-0.1143689751625061,
-0.14724552631378174,
-0.4267579913139343,
-0.010994919575750828,
0.6868963241577148,
0.3778316378593445,
0.13829642534255981,
-0.360202431678772,
-0.2688665986061096,
0.4065648019313812,
0.5234180092811584,
-0.5972687602043152,
-0.42645367980003357,
-0.007846410386264324,
-0.04872952774167061,
-0.786232590675354,
-0.12370864301919937,
-0.7294448614120483,
-0.5450419783592224,
0.025388745591044426,
0.4444567561149597,
-0.21648110449314117,
-0.10341419279575348,
0.13725367188453674,
-0.2576838433742523,
0.04199141636490822,
0.09228940308094025,
-0.8626810312271118,
0.2608228027820587,
0.5397136807441711,
0.5945996642112732,
0.3256424069404602,
-0.38873815536499023,
-0.304691344499588,
-0.12551161646842957,
-0.5560246109962463,
0.41229021549224854,
-0.5693360567092896,
-0.3757433593273163,
-0.05384215712547302,
-0.2799173593521118,
-0.17018276453018188,
-0.5147789120674133,
0.5176430344581604,
-0.8119617700576782,
0.20186693966388702,
-0.09211303293704987,
-0.10327954590320587,
-0.15818944573402405,
0.631466269493103,
-0.6684239506721497,
1.107118010520935,
-0.24352292716503143,
-0.9522552490234375,
0.4164612293243408,
-0.6104294061660767,
-0.19336573779582977,
-0.2853505313396454,
0.10000447183847427,
-0.5379723310470581,
0.18332797288894653,
0.35791853070259094,
0.2865540087223053,
-0.22265757620334625,
-0.12332549691200256,
-0.6584209203720093,
-0.20971868932247162,
0.49129465222358704,
-1.0972422361373901,
1.034631609916687,
0.19574882090091705,
-0.46864813566207886,
-0.21565118432044983,
-0.8756102323532104,
0.22799386084079742,
0.27564963698387146,
-0.2485484778881073,
-0.6232121586799622,
-0.0011767405085265636,
-0.2519143521785736,
-0.09125708788633347,
0.10177864134311676,
-0.20080441236495972,
0.13772502541542053,
-0.8882739543914795,
0.417743444442749,
0.6877695322036743,
-0.046814605593681335,
0.6074324250221252,
-0.38406333327293396,
0.5758877396583557,
-0.06974198669195175,
0.1487210988998413,
0.1204923763871193,
-0.3693735599517822,
-0.8315584659576416,
0.14084085822105408,
0.17697688937187195,
0.8718628883361816,
-0.6589551568031311,
0.19040006399154663,
-0.031114770099520683,
-0.656348466873169,
-0.4590592682361603,
0.2444256842136383,
0.40201056003570557,
0.6988996267318726,
0.40459224581718445,
-0.047866594046354294,
-0.34587180614471436,
-0.7443106174468994,
-0.6956840753555298,
-0.1667296588420868,
-0.2885514497756958,
-0.005761061795055866,
0.4635540544986725,
-0.21977470815181732,
0.6474514603614807,
-0.30589625239372253,
-0.12423311918973923,
0.0862472653388977,
0.2623636722564697,
0.009184828959405422,
0.6212000250816345,
0.6366658210754395,
-0.9929601550102234,
-0.19082647562026978,
-0.19541306793689728,
-0.6824239492416382,
0.21626321971416473,
-0.1953740417957306,
-0.08378857374191284,
0.08603814244270325,
0.5869068503379822,
-0.2130175530910492,
0.6201688647270203,
0.44479280710220337,
-0.1024177223443985,
0.4976262152194977,
-0.27559006214141846,
0.04350799694657326,
-0.9747190475463867,
0.014503688551485538,
0.06801410019397736,
-0.29275044798851013,
-0.8476751446723938,
0.42709997296333313,
0.076970174908638,
-0.07831089943647385,
-0.35494744777679443,
0.14602841436862946,
-0.2480325996875763,
0.25071007013320923,
-0.2506110966205597,
-0.04403078183531761,
0.20519192516803741,
0.21506693959236145,
-0.4600902497768402,
0.6872140169143677,
0.7048763036727905,
-0.5034707188606262,
0.46692776679992676,
-0.062404487282037735,
0.021852953359484673,
0.588217556476593,
-0.5323541760444641,
0.23494067788124084,
-0.12231268733739853,
0.15204478800296783,
-0.7533659934997559,
-0.15131627023220062,
0.1745147556066513,
-0.6584966778755188,
0.5862782597541809,
-0.210563063621521,
-0.44680002331733704,
-0.09544435143470764,
-0.47900334000587463,
0.43028753995895386,
0.20675604045391083,
-0.6108763813972473,
0.6641257405281067,
0.14382044970989227,
0.45699062943458557,
-0.9652659893035889,
-1.1348685026168823,
0.26450926065444946,
-0.4452924132347107,
-0.48443320393562317,
0.21639634668827057,
-0.16207964718341827,
-0.44161859154701233,
-0.21098178625106812,
-0.029278339818120003,
-0.1957983374595642,
0.47781217098236084,
0.14768610894680023,
0.23820891976356506,
-0.30995774269104004,
-0.2723511755466461,
-0.3991362154483795,
-0.016487475484609604,
0.41623038053512573,
-0.16135025024414062,
0.5022322535514832,
-0.4114309847354889,
-0.46625417470932007,
-0.46780166029930115,
0.2837444543838501,
0.6407734155654907,
0.08639082312583923,
0.8393354415893555,
0.7070546746253967,
-0.8548553586006165,
-0.14552128314971924,
-0.47998684644699097,
-0.31248727440834045,
-0.5025883913040161,
0.4737767279148102,
-0.2619571089744568,
-0.29639187455177307,
0.7554392218589783,
0.24709591269493103,
0.11393849551677704,
0.634145975112915,
0.10659539699554443,
-0.11407224833965302,
1.561279296875,
0.6782638430595398,
-0.1731307953596115,
0.40869349241256714,
-0.40032005310058594,
0.11958186328411102,
-0.8944030404090881,
-0.09925609827041626,
-0.7178255319595337,
-0.32809656858444214,
-0.49436530470848083,
-0.15043407678604126,
0.268541157245636,
0.16990189254283905,
-0.4114730954170227,
0.23171715438365936,
-0.43160685896873474,
0.7942128777503967,
0.7378541827201843,
0.34042540192604065,
-0.1263696253299713,
0.032010436058044434,
-0.13157539069652557,
-0.5488669872283936,
-0.8189619779586792,
-0.3912983536720276,
1.150024652481079,
0.3727007508277893,
0.9964465498924255,
0.1884356588125229,
0.18061745166778564,
0.3290092349052429,
0.09585734456777573,
-0.7349762916564941,
0.2884334325790405,
-0.3033335506916046,
-0.7637178301811218,
-0.18449018895626068,
-0.4045190215110779,
-0.8184967041015625,
0.1092313826084137,
-0.3014894723892212,
-0.7336477041244507,
0.23709586262702942,
0.3429635763168335,
-0.3905080556869507,
0.707701563835144,
-0.7456053495407104,
0.8641477823257446,
-0.221878319978714,
-0.23571963608264923,
0.09597405046224594,
-0.7278065085411072,
0.15921801328659058,
-0.07858563959598541,
0.20616135001182556,
0.2657405436038971,
0.06259093433618546,
0.5919499397277832,
-0.24950067698955536,
1.015423059463501,
-0.22184480726718903,
0.06296280026435852,
-0.15584437549114227,
0.6291808485984802,
0.6249171495437622,
0.06864727288484573,
-0.19935019314289093,
0.01899639517068863,
-0.1856304407119751,
-0.7122469544410706,
-0.7438625693321228,
0.6794613003730774,
-0.8180714249610901,
-0.7523953914642334,
-0.576050341129303,
-0.6842840909957886,
-0.3882724940776825,
0.16055908799171448,
0.5267555713653564,
0.480368047952652,
-0.2399330735206604,
0.16799692809581757,
0.812085747718811,
-0.00828943308442831,
0.41544052958488464,
0.21000434458255768,
0.21530066430568695,
-0.22918061912059784,
0.91574627161026,
0.06530579924583435,
0.7440850138664246,
0.3350154757499695,
0.2352680116891861,
-0.046042367815971375,
-0.6863455772399902,
-0.42215725779533386,
-0.21533575654029846,
-0.873068630695343,
-0.2636599838733673,
-0.34282422065734863,
-0.3178943395614624,
-0.5663711428642273,
-0.4137859344482422,
-0.49621832370758057,
-0.34355628490448,
-0.7411477565765381,
0.04093430936336517,
-0.05176829919219017,
0.498242050409317,
-0.19836926460266113,
0.4019048511981964,
-0.508418619632721,
0.13408255577087402,
0.3571208417415619,
-0.13257350027561188,
-0.19979090988636017,
-0.8645213842391968,
-0.11684620380401611,
0.4127820134162903,
-0.4462415874004364,
-0.7098684906959534,
0.42472848296165466,
0.5097395777702332,
0.4298526644706726,
0.7352137565612793,
0.3212863802909851,
0.7105550169944763,
-0.22675447165966034,
0.8739222884178162,
0.18590736389160156,
-0.7897659540176392,
0.5812314748764038,
-0.18645508587360382,
0.6335140466690063,
0.5265253782272339,
0.29499152302742004,
-0.17664876580238342,
-0.6664369106292725,
-0.793730616569519,
-0.9507855772972107,
0.4849805533885956,
0.042482730001211166,
0.48600903153419495,
0.3786967694759369,
0.3402344584465027,
-0.08491513133049011,
-0.07813365012407303,
-0.8890438675880432,
-0.5918737053871155,
-0.545799732208252,
0.12526829540729523,
-0.03701067715883255,
-0.3175157904624939,
-0.6191044449806213,
0.08086537569761276,
0.8276033401489258,
-0.2667238116264343,
0.13996101915836334,
0.24765844643115997,
-0.08843744546175003,
-0.09064324200153351,
0.1548675298690796,
0.5733398199081421,
0.4438058137893677,
-0.26753926277160645,
0.4427081346511841,
0.4529123604297638,
-0.5753605961799622,
-0.07477036863565445,
0.27763932943344116,
-0.18220177292823792,
-0.2238781601190567,
0.4689677655696869,
0.7555903792381287,
-0.03998304158449173,
-0.24556484818458557,
0.487188458442688,
-0.4315575957298279,
-0.05865595117211342,
-0.22801539301872253,
0.23434554040431976,
-0.4008534848690033,
0.2458709478378296,
0.5152505040168762,
1.059107780456543,
0.15137465298175812,
-0.463291734457016,
0.03534412756562233,
0.9116746783256531,
-0.6984606981277466,
-0.33691948652267456,
1.0257270336151123,
-0.38041502237319946,
-0.28126174211502075,
0.4232398569583893,
-0.017096631228923798,
-1.010697841644287,
0.5884512066841125,
0.6584921479225159,
0.7803503274917603,
-0.3786337673664093,
-0.033996596932411194,
0.1507001668214798,
0.9225512146949768,
0.005067100282758474,
-0.0457666739821434,
0.04632033407688141,
-0.8181059956550598,
0.08464166522026062,
-0.38275039196014404,
-0.35371971130371094,
0.26986032724380493,
-0.9328524470329285,
0.07160603255033493,
-0.6443310976028442,
-0.26194486021995544,
0.14558352530002594,
-0.28472599387168884,
-0.6303318738937378,
0.5093042254447937,
0.06394456326961517,
0.6719200015068054,
-0.8432409763336182,
0.5872750282287598,
0.5949108600616455,
0.039197541773319244,
-0.4145798981189728,
0.29781877994537354,
0.2861914038658142,
-0.9979322552680969,
0.2830633819103241,
0.002692094538360834,
-0.27114808559417725,
-0.3611399233341217,
-0.5588439702987671,
-0.5744668841362,
0.5948898792266846,
0.7997178435325623,
-0.14685505628585815,
-0.30469995737075806,
0.32261744141578674,
0.6667077541351318,
0.06917346268892288,
0.11537083983421326,
0.5225505828857422,
0.18524715304374695,
-0.1052660271525383,
-0.7107316851615906,
-0.010280914604663849,
-0.3649725914001465,
-0.08909609913825989,
0.16283674538135529,
-0.38186514377593994,
0.6069127917289734,
-0.1945047825574875,
-0.19263336062431335,
-0.1633455753326416,
0.5120358467102051,
-0.39277732372283936,
0.3589758574962616,
0.5816595554351807,
0.7994069457054138,
0.7714048624038696,
-0.19813016057014465,
1.0940279960632324,
-0.25385990738868713,
0.13098900020122528,
1.070891261100769,
0.1156875267624855,
0.6678868532180786,
0.44252827763557434,
-0.07292221486568451,
-0.09435262531042099,
0.5294234156608582,
-0.10423269867897034,
0.5543510317802429,
0.05632306635379791,
-0.35790467262268066,
-0.2569155991077423,
-0.05210423097014427,
-0.5958895087242126,
0.2565881013870239,
0.5392479300498962,
-0.2926749885082245,
-0.1292056143283844,
0.29288384318351746,
0.3764139711856842,
0.2226923257112503,
-0.21880459785461426,
0.5450778007507324,
-0.11476246267557144,
-0.37721624970436096,
0.8530086874961853,
-0.14013458788394928,
0.7724103331565857,
-0.5913795232772827,
0.3874976634979248,
0.011696276254951954,
0.4952649772167206,
-0.29274848103523254,
-0.47145235538482666,
0.46213066577911377,
-0.08680936694145203,
-0.22181960940361023,
-0.058882687240839005,
0.5459215044975281,
-0.03525124117732048,
-0.5305608510971069,
0.2853006422519684,
0.03934371843934059,
-0.0688289999961853,
-0.20280197262763977,
-0.981519341468811,
-0.17123089730739594,
0.12125157564878464,
-0.47666704654693604,
0.43279585242271423,
0.2423599362373352,
0.47371089458465576,
0.7703684568405151,
0.709122896194458,
0.3355772793292999,
0.21592164039611816,
0.0027169506065547466,
0.8919888734817505,
-0.25993362069129944,
-0.2082061767578125,
-1.094874382019043,
0.15430013835430145,
0.018560437485575676,
-0.44344189763069153,
0.8197495937347412,
0.6129385828971863,
0.9955987334251404,
0.3561386168003082,
0.7047675848007202,
0.28937506675720215,
0.26287639141082764,
-0.5585538148880005,
0.8831132650375366,
-0.6852848529815674,
0.5251628160476685,
-0.21950525045394897,
-0.7536199688911438,
-0.7945299744606018,
0.41485315561294556,
-0.25932231545448303,
0.015358895994722843,
0.5188460350036621,
1.0263237953186035,
-0.1330132633447647,
0.1505228728055954,
0.4289153814315796,
0.3850383460521698,
0.49411845207214355,
0.2857707440853119,
0.6169871091842651,
-0.7611499428749084,
0.8682708144187927,
-0.6553848385810852,
-0.29473814368247986,
0.09196455776691437,
-0.8351961374282837,
-0.9984492063522339,
-0.5096709728240967,
-0.3867979645729065,
-0.7819055318832397,
0.190462127327919,
0.6128092408180237,
0.6286478042602539,
-0.8177604675292969,
0.20865607261657715,
-0.15664225816726685,
-0.1222572848200798,
-0.17960400879383087,
-0.27341529726982117,
0.22113850712776184,
-0.19202959537506104,
-0.7557052969932556,
0.5754712820053101,
-0.0783139169216156,
0.38895004987716675,
-0.5081772804260254,
0.28473684191703796,
0.01876768097281456,
0.26850512623786926,
0.014977398328483105,
0.38897210359573364,
-0.4543130695819855,
-0.06721004843711853,
-0.18992620706558228,
-0.16555249691009521,
0.07454145699739456,
0.46341055631637573,
-0.5750275254249573,
0.774038553237915,
0.23616290092468262,
0.7527499198913574,
0.0666465312242508,
-0.2885774075984955,
0.6293095946311951,
-0.7621698975563049,
0.196097269654274,
0.5321106910705566,
0.32977360486984253,
0.4264198839664459,
-0.6198257803916931,
0.27256542444229126,
0.21346978843212128,
-0.6419022679328918,
-1.3514506816864014,
0.2486153542995453,
-0.5501828789710999,
-0.26027023792266846,
0.7989468574523926,
-0.22130133211612701,
-0.29031091928482056,
0.02679525315761566,
-0.04249100759625435,
0.1942252516746521,
-0.2579455077648163,
1.1003013849258423,
0.7458663582801819,
0.10927047580480576,
0.37502583861351013,
-0.8395106196403503,
0.5999578237533569,
0.6323861479759216,
-0.43425703048706055,
0.1106305867433548,
0.06727752089500427,
0.017799491062760353,
0.3882509768009186,
-0.14331717789173126,
0.13596776127815247,
0.18918776512145996,
0.3196326494216919,
-0.5253869891166687,
-0.04359269142150879,
-0.1865144968032837,
-0.5430354475975037,
0.2721722722053528,
0.03321686014533043,
-0.1272510439157486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17505v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17505v1
|
BASES: Large-scale Web Search User Simulation with Large Language Model based Agents
| 2024-02-27T13:44:09 | 2024-02-27T13:44:09 |
Ruiyang Ren, Peng Qiu, Yingqi Qu, Jing Liu, Wayne Xin Zhao, Hua Wu, Ji-Rong Wen, Haifeng Wang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Due to the excellent capacities of large language models (LLMs), it becomes
feasible to develop LLM-based agents for reliable user simulation. Considering
the scarcity and limit (e.g., privacy issues) of real user data, in this paper,
we conduct large-scale user simulation for web search, to improve the analysis
and modeling of user search behavior. Specially, we propose BASES, a novel user
simulation framework with LLM-based agents, designed to facilitate
comprehensive simulations of web search user behaviors. Our simulation
framework can generate unique user profiles at scale, which subsequently leads
to diverse search behaviors. To demonstrate the effectiveness of BASES, we
conduct evaluation experiments based on two human benchmarks in both Chinese
and English, demonstrating that BASES can effectively simulate large-scale
human-like search behaviors. To further accommodate the research on web search,
we develop WARRIORS, a new large-scale dataset encompassing web search user
behaviors, including both Chinese and English versions, which can greatly
bolster research in the field of information retrieval. Our code and data will
be publicly released soon.
|
[
-0.48372071981430054,
-0.8016424179077148,
0.33211037516593933,
0.334559828042984,
0.22497038543224335,
0.09318733960390091,
-0.2391253113746643,
-0.22445261478424072,
0.46974050998687744,
0.6337863206863403,
-0.4986790716648102,
-0.24341891705989838,
-0.11160928755998611,
0.08877169340848923,
-0.36048424243927,
0.1329464465379715,
0.15328294038772583,
-0.035130538046360016,
-0.12527787685394287,
0.1583101749420166,
-0.14443160593509674,
-0.9338906407356262,
-0.47742947936058044,
-0.023460514843463898,
0.4022643268108368,
0.4574296772480011,
0.9252466559410095,
0.5460199117660522,
0.4583289623260498,
0.35894259810447693,
-0.0018629702972248197,
0.1464054137468338,
-0.8878999948501587,
0.49703308939933777,
-0.5027393102645874,
-0.4163212478160858,
-0.5000790953636169,
-0.09298697113990784,
0.7781587839126587,
0.6142335534095764,
-0.3721699118614197,
-0.04424077644944191,
-0.3285994231700897,
0.5847971439361572,
-0.6809932589530945,
0.015176762826740742,
-0.3148433268070221,
-0.03429006040096283,
-0.09788128733634949,
-0.3407604396343231,
-0.5577995181083679,
-0.21488401293754578,
0.18194115161895752,
-0.5398491621017456,
0.21544170379638672,
0.10820437967777252,
0.5595857501029968,
-0.19661641120910645,
-0.7801356315612793,
0.16069479286670685,
-0.48070597648620605,
0.7118495106697083,
-0.7665479779243469,
0.6328562498092651,
0.3672758936882019,
0.3970676362514496,
-0.7440468668937683,
-0.7244817614555359,
-0.5589028596878052,
-0.5058717727661133,
0.28441908955574036,
-0.29020851850509644,
-0.03333744779229164,
-0.04814724251627922,
0.4311012029647827,
0.18848860263824463,
-0.7156107425689697,
0.10386966168880463,
-0.16048046946525574,
-0.003678129054605961,
0.8507123589515686,
0.30501753091812134,
0.5109310746192932,
0.1639918088912964,
-0.27947163581848145,
-0.38023364543914795,
-0.7946375608444214,
0.06682660430669785,
0.3618524372577667,
0.4598294496536255,
-0.04383385181427002,
0.6629523634910583,
-0.856755793094635,
0.4555061459541321,
0.08778079599142075,
-0.3335799276828766,
0.4787038564682007,
0.09361112117767334,
-0.04686189070343971,
-0.2984525263309479,
0.5358679294586182,
0.7563972473144531,
0.6141965389251709,
-0.4256443381309509,
-0.25000467896461487,
-0.11972811073064804,
0.15259021520614624,
-1.2411986589431763,
0.03964140638709068,
0.21402862668037415,
-0.7973511219024658,
-0.14375120401382446,
0.06896376609802246,
-0.6985015273094177,
-0.7379530668258667,
-0.24900946021080017,
0.23110508918762207,
-0.20792712271213531,
-0.6636561751365662,
0.1757500320672989,
-0.15011294186115265,
0.14689061045646667,
0.23266206681728363,
-0.8397283554077148,
0.7423655986785889,
0.31766918301582336,
0.4251094460487366,
-0.5090465545654297,
-0.6499490737915039,
-0.681857705116272,
0.10811544209718704,
-0.13991108536720276,
0.36613887548446655,
-0.610830545425415,
-0.64167320728302,
0.20051845908164978,
0.017598610371351242,
0.21697087585926056,
-0.6245423555374146,
-0.0715365931391716,
-1.0369881391525269,
-0.30849385261535645,
-0.4747920334339142,
-0.426814466714859,
-0.1339876651763916,
0.4695548415184021,
-1.1243982315063477,
0.9305185079574585,
0.12267255038022995,
-0.35051339864730835,
-0.20449082553386688,
-0.6745437979698181,
-0.5130103230476379,
0.13198398053646088,
0.0007174867205321789,
0.07332181930541992,
-0.02747263014316559,
-0.07640576362609863,
0.5708848834037781,
-0.38401246070861816,
0.138156458735466,
-0.40925970673561096,
-0.7013307213783264,
0.364275187253952,
-0.08925570547580719,
0.7833223342895508,
0.06966911256313324,
-0.36038127541542053,
-0.15645328164100647,
-0.553364098072052,
0.18628869950771332,
0.32287177443504333,
-0.3967917263507843,
-0.12930691242218018,
0.23789949715137482,
0.37066349387168884,
0.22950077056884766,
0.5587974190711975,
-0.4489828646183014,
0.6183177828788757,
-0.324480801820755,
0.030076278373599052,
0.5086201429367065,
0.03371867537498474,
0.4890371859073639,
0.03358430415391922,
0.6810187101364136,
-0.3863052725791931,
0.08392176777124405,
0.005381317343562841,
-0.43197742104530334,
-0.20196078717708588,
0.11316078901290894,
0.19197459518909454,
0.4694109857082367,
-0.40350455045700073,
0.2532579302787781,
-0.40999478101730347,
-0.4662329852581024,
0.24115414917469025,
0.23454272747039795,
0.2034687101840973,
-0.011164401657879353,
0.19344809651374817,
-0.45747557282447815,
-0.7251086831092834,
-0.7355475425720215,
-0.16681258380413055,
-0.302407443523407,
-0.023329008370637894,
0.5294655561447144,
0.38893938064575195,
-0.7262733578681946,
1.0865275859832764,
-0.6007269024848938,
0.0584934800863266,
-0.35428136587142944,
-0.09348254650831223,
-0.1559530794620514,
0.23363621532917023,
0.5653461813926697,
-1.3036813735961914,
-0.5355368852615356,
-0.1579218953847885,
-0.6980140209197998,
0.06885344535112381,
0.2582072615623474,
-0.21671360731124878,
0.07438193261623383,
0.5580474138259888,
-0.7229731678962708,
0.2816866934299469,
0.4941014349460602,
-0.2904331088066101,
0.6284886598587036,
0.09166093915700912,
0.17154225707054138,
-0.9829294681549072,
0.30606770515441895,
0.20369479060173035,
-0.21316838264465332,
-0.478904128074646,
0.5993037223815918,
0.17764067649841309,
-0.13338132202625275,
-0.3851228654384613,
0.904395580291748,
-0.5297605395317078,
-0.19966550171375275,
-0.46317657828330994,
-0.21202842891216278,
-0.19843733310699463,
0.41487595438957214,
-0.05682205781340599,
1.168426275253296,
0.3114820718765259,
-0.7335636019706726,
0.5759456753730774,
0.03315466642379761,
0.09708293527364731,
0.09072685241699219,
-0.346794456243515,
0.05259421840310097,
0.05936344340443611,
0.5566579103469849,
-0.901675820350647,
-0.6774305701255798,
-0.3157627582550049,
-0.3871608078479767,
0.08910282701253891,
-0.1730419546365738,
-0.9676026701927185,
-0.5512546896934509,
-0.6188161373138428,
0.3219601809978485,
0.580137312412262,
-0.5022225975990295,
0.6382370591163635,
0.6603270173072815,
-0.014331764541566372,
-0.7637220025062561,
-0.22263240814208984,
0.41557034850120544,
-0.018892817199230194,
-0.6826401352882385,
0.31375452876091003,
-0.48651373386383057,
-0.42902886867523193,
-0.18502335250377655,
0.06610412150621414,
-0.36269572377204895,
0.5029425024986267,
0.18302059173583984,
0.11630067974328995,
-0.2554129362106323,
-0.18444521725177765,
-0.3455953896045685,
0.2378678172826767,
0.08161146193742752,
-0.04141611233353615,
0.8525170087814331,
-0.201760396361351,
-0.2976478338241577,
-0.15639418363571167,
0.3874487280845642,
0.6995111107826233,
-0.17289569973945618,
0.5762572884559631,
0.14571939408779144,
-0.4662168323993683,
-0.2319793850183487,
-0.7009596824645996,
-0.19931957125663757,
-0.5334636569023132,
0.4097023904323578,
-0.3749198019504547,
-0.9166306257247925,
0.5960707068443298,
-0.4025244116783142,
-0.06302940845489502,
0.29034024477005005,
0.7356128096580505,
-0.016313521191477776,
1.251868724822998,
0.8424187898635864,
-0.30545100569725037,
0.23599402606487274,
-0.1300549954175949,
-0.12190172076225281,
-0.5129876136779785,
-0.10317924618721008,
-0.25029951333999634,
-0.363114595413208,
-0.5769522190093994,
-0.2861112654209137,
0.14903727173805237,
-0.0023036946076899767,
-0.4157028794288635,
0.3133220076560974,
-0.2844458818435669,
0.6144636869430542,
0.5819521546363831,
0.05547745153307915,
0.033114202320575714,
0.3506963849067688,
-0.25266844034194946,
-0.03264965862035751,
-0.021383609622716904,
-0.18699480593204498,
1.0765295028686523,
-0.07556930929422379,
1.038759708404541,
0.3486400544643402,
0.4061858057975769,
0.5558854937553406,
0.02552403137087822,
-0.7263182401657104,
0.660110354423523,
0.008131897076964378,
-0.9338154792785645,
-0.46607840061187744,
-0.39362144470214844,
-1.0249559879302979,
0.34783047437667847,
0.19196489453315735,
-0.8510460257530212,
0.007459232583642006,
0.07651536166667938,
0.04809188470244408,
0.375669926404953,
-0.49563127756118774,
0.6232041120529175,
-0.4201984107494354,
-0.5207816958427429,
-0.17591211199760437,
-0.7633974552154541,
0.1977219432592392,
0.11817333102226257,
0.04017926752567291,
0.09745466709136963,
0.010498072020709515,
0.5249791741371155,
-0.38220569491386414,
0.8905159831047058,
-0.35007765889167786,
0.09210161119699478,
0.22336262464523315,
0.3534933626651764,
0.8316178321838379,
-0.14946042001247406,
-0.23044222593307495,
-0.18432924151420593,
-0.42595845460891724,
-0.3676990270614624,
-0.3730619251728058,
0.7554693222045898,
-0.7806094288825989,
-0.6722922325134277,
-0.19310452044010162,
-0.3424391448497772,
-0.3807084560394287,
0.496171236038208,
-0.024422574788331985,
0.01878936216235161,
-0.4756237864494324,
0.3876245319843292,
0.7436575889587402,
-0.06766551733016968,
0.08218755573034286,
0.9198870658874512,
-0.5344900488853455,
-0.09523782134056091,
0.8505722880363464,
0.039868585765361786,
-0.3254031538963318,
0.47422313690185547,
0.15224631130695343,
-0.2404332458972931,
-0.39552947878837585,
-0.5816360712051392,
0.3350748121738434,
-0.48587411642074585,
-0.1448046714067459,
-0.5073197484016418,
-0.32266515493392944,
-0.44352152943611145,
-0.15877623856067657,
-0.36443570256233215,
-0.0757802277803421,
0.06099608168005943,
-0.010418944992125034,
0.4179891049861908,
0.5570627450942993,
0.15634405612945557,
0.5744456648826599,
-0.48496147990226746,
0.581585705280304,
0.23163136839866638,
0.5431960225105286,
0.28109636902809143,
-0.13485115766525269,
-0.516778826713562,
-0.04748000204563141,
-0.21404899656772614,
-0.7875015735626221,
0.5337787866592407,
-0.34763410687446594,
0.6899967193603516,
0.42588818073272705,
-0.06488285958766937,
0.5702193379402161,
-0.5458540320396423,
0.8703125715255737,
-0.000005416667136159958,
-0.6944509148597717,
0.16092278063297272,
-0.5060024261474609,
-0.021665118634700775,
0.7089025974273682,
0.32907742261886597,
-0.6728017330169678,
0.2337878942489624,
-0.38855084776878357,
-0.8001978397369385,
0.7545960545539856,
0.17640210688114166,
0.1396275758743286,
0.15895210206508636,
0.341905802488327,
-0.05934318155050278,
0.1804010421037674,
-0.371577650308609,
-0.5107805728912354,
0.11323394626379013,
0.13036270439624786,
0.1564161777496338,
-0.44594982266426086,
0.2445896416902542,
-0.05237732082605362,
0.6958663463592529,
-0.09856011718511581,
-0.027115246281027794,
-0.14243635535240173,
-0.26353710889816284,
-0.32685086131095886,
-0.06571882218122482,
0.2666008174419403,
0.649942934513092,
-0.4704037606716156,
0.028634965419769287,
0.2405042052268982,
-0.7334205508232117,
0.3464234471321106,
0.20801258087158203,
-0.03705852851271629,
-0.15937425196170807,
-0.2533285915851593,
0.18249298632144928,
0.17945517599582672,
-1.2175637483596802,
0.682235598564148,
-0.3407960832118988,
0.002728383056819439,
-0.6062729358673096,
0.14305758476257324,
0.5462900400161743,
0.1294136792421341,
0.5535139441490173,
-0.13968762755393982,
0.6403152942657471,
-0.4623335301876068,
0.3131387233734131,
0.2753106951713562,
0.08491690456867218,
-0.29806846380233765,
0.5812950134277344,
0.3422071635723114,
-0.4356798231601715,
0.6041690111160278,
-0.22441093623638153,
-0.5549048185348511,
0.8498125672340393,
0.6714184880256653,
0.6429840922355652,
-0.6470374464988708,
-0.20717164874076843,
0.2174258679151535,
0.06185419112443924,
-0.7492654919624329,
0.41587573289871216,
0.05016235262155533,
-0.560093879699707,
-0.3178510069847107,
-0.35639631748199463,
-0.8463807702064514,
0.40673312544822693,
-0.3486957252025604,
0.1664624810218811,
-0.38957977294921875,
-0.09816723316907883,
-0.18837112188339233,
0.4846794903278351,
-0.5791351199150085,
0.2741026282310486,
0.4209790825843811,
1.0510921478271484,
-0.36167699098587036,
0.75909423828125,
1.0452147722244263,
-0.35108235478401184,
-0.6107737421989441,
0.13247203826904297,
0.15634948015213013,
-0.6486900448799133,
0.6831367611885071,
0.33933043479919434,
-0.45966026186943054,
-0.07576476037502289,
-0.8201099634170532,
-1.1793829202651978,
0.9984806776046753,
0.4236130714416504,
-0.45492544770240784,
-0.3172907531261444,
0.02454792521893978,
0.4463236331939697,
-0.17614427208900452,
0.28154873847961426,
0.18990053236484528,
0.4330287575721741,
0.030900366604328156,
-0.9456435441970825,
0.12266968935728073,
-0.5500569343566895,
0.13648714125156403,
-0.16001540422439575,
-0.8989131450653076,
1.2254371643066406,
0.08429501205682755,
-0.07000184804201126,
0.2579820454120636,
0.51669842004776,
0.605178713798523,
0.24328337609767914,
0.5500723719596863,
0.31489619612693787,
0.7290982604026794,
0.7514364719390869,
1.0113825798034668,
-0.3473491966724396,
0.3740444779396057,
0.6860532760620117,
-0.9746109247207642,
0.9821312427520752,
0.058906346559524536,
-0.15854386985301971,
0.44996821880340576,
0.2692002058029175,
-0.04278526455163956,
0.2001449316740036,
0.4586383104324341,
-0.3605991303920746,
-0.34593942761421204,
0.07595553249120712,
-0.3462473154067993,
0.49399131536483765,
0.43634581565856934,
-0.25234898924827576,
-0.2767183482646942,
-0.2306508868932724,
0.16076040267944336,
0.21444553136825562,
-0.15444634854793549,
0.4148998260498047,
-0.18447118997573853,
-0.5191694498062134,
0.5515455603599548,
0.5890492796897888,
0.8332542777061462,
-0.6105231642723083,
-0.04712173715233803,
-0.27538079023361206,
0.11364946514368057,
-0.2022017240524292,
-0.6798073649406433,
-0.5113644599914551,
0.13872167468070984,
-0.524341344833374,
-0.05339774861931801,
0.9745115637779236,
0.06262160837650299,
-0.0869809091091156,
0.558740496635437,
0.6914873719215393,
0.4199720323085785,
-0.5038995742797852,
-0.5436643958091736,
0.13548791408538818,
0.024382587522268295,
-0.7262405753135681,
0.5991860032081604,
0.3614547848701477,
-0.5047233700752258,
0.7149629592895508,
0.8457017540931702,
-0.05897624418139458,
0.10523992776870728,
-0.008178682997822762,
0.9641890525817871,
-0.981295108795166,
-0.6763221621513367,
-0.711636483669281,
-0.0629846379160881,
-0.32281509041786194,
0.040916621685028076,
0.7977666854858398,
1.018225073814392,
0.6288473606109619,
-0.22733095288276672,
1.06996750831604,
0.03295183926820755,
0.5731500387191772,
-0.06099405512213707,
0.9365716576576233,
-0.5716221332550049,
-0.1530131846666336,
0.10671422630548477,
-0.8773278594017029,
-0.10217112302780151,
0.4108692705631256,
0.23479042947292328,
0.2725408673286438,
0.19010990858078003,
0.7646167278289795,
-0.4696394205093384,
-0.21885213255882263,
0.41530898213386536,
0.2366468608379364,
0.27716416120529175,
0.3300156593322754,
0.6468355655670166,
-0.2604726552963257,
0.47305360436439514,
-0.06842314451932907,
-0.08460462838411331,
-1.0187665224075317,
-0.32666170597076416,
-0.949479877948761,
-0.3270038664340973,
0.3746829032897949,
-0.43564584851264954,
0.04106313735246658,
1.0970383882522583,
0.8717274069786072,
-0.5994952321052551,
-0.6998258829116821,
0.18410678207874298,
-0.16976000368595123,
0.07007413357496262,
-0.18978184461593628,
0.1576595902442932,
-0.08617917448282242,
-0.7073430418968201,
0.5575690269470215,
-0.08646684139966965,
-0.09069531410932541,
-0.42130574584007263,
-0.40734127163887024,
-0.19226709008216858,
0.09650539606809616,
0.6034501194953918,
0.7428156137466431,
-0.6284663677215576,
0.06965503841638565,
0.40369534492492676,
-0.6086426973342896,
0.006032231729477644,
0.7367533445358276,
-1.1845496892929077,
0.4945966899394989,
0.47690582275390625,
0.6868970990180969,
0.5021756887435913,
0.34325724840164185,
0.692745566368103,
-0.7597731351852417,
0.0015722924144938588,
0.04943060129880905,
0.3338873088359833,
0.2667710781097412,
-0.6066400408744812,
0.635395348072052,
0.07836563140153885,
-0.24604183435440063,
-0.7968615889549255,
0.047773443162441254,
-1.2427335977554321,
-0.47674891352653503,
1.4554568529129028,
0.08240992575883865,
-0.1461622714996338,
0.06467989832162857,
-0.23090611398220062,
0.16092446446418762,
-0.71996009349823,
0.6515881419181824,
0.6124582886695862,
-0.024094214662909508,
0.22960616648197174,
-0.6058060526847839,
0.1909194141626358,
0.09618953615427017,
-0.6179102063179016,
0.16229766607284546,
0.5213913321495056,
0.4315420687198639,
0.16462910175323486,
0.703828752040863,
0.14857839047908783,
0.5878638625144958,
-0.010637505911290646,
0.37345483899116516,
-0.11348938941955566,
-0.16066652536392212,
0.07005658000707626,
0.4061238169670105,
0.1537662297487259,
0.2418527901172638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17497v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17497v1
|
REAR: A Relevance-Aware Retrieval-Augmented Framework for Open-Domain Question Answering
| 2024-02-27T13:22:51 | 2024-02-27T13:22:51 |
Yuhao Wang, Ruiyang Ren, Junyi Li, Wayne Xin Zhao, Jing Liu, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Considering the limited internal parametric knowledge, retrieval-augmented
generation (RAG) has been widely used to extend the knowledge scope of large
language models (LLMs). Despite the extensive efforts on RAG research, in
existing methods, LLMs cannot precisely assess the relevance of retrieved
documents, thus likely leading to misleading or even incorrect utilization of
external knowledge (i.e., retrieved documents). To address this issue, in this
paper, we propose REAR, a RElevance-Aware Retrieval-augmented approach for
open-domain question answering (QA). As the key motivation, we aim to enhance
the self-awareness of source relevance for LLMs, so as to adaptively utilize
external knowledge in RAG systems. Specially, we develop a new architecture for
LLM based RAG system, by incorporating a specially designed rank head that
precisely assesses the relevance of retrieved documents. Furthermore, we
propose an improved training method based on bi-granularity relevance fusion
and noise-resistant training. By combining the improvements in both
architecture and training, our proposed REAR can better utilize external
knowledge by effectively perceiving the relevance of retrieved documents.
Experiments on four open-domain QA tasks show that REAR significantly
outperforms previous a number of competitive RAG approaches. Our code and data
can be accessed at https://github.com/RUCAIBox/REAR.
|
[
-0.4543779790401459,
-0.430263489484787,
0.45520249009132385,
0.05138397961854935,
0.024128897115588188,
0.17112527787685394,
-0.18787534534931183,
-0.36361414194107056,
0.2852309048175812,
0.41316139698028564,
-0.4057334363460541,
-0.32101693749427795,
-0.3365532457828522,
0.1243365928530693,
-0.23657843470573425,
0.8432343006134033,
0.1558665633201599,
0.00516451196745038,
-0.47802677750587463,
-0.49852433800697327,
-0.7322843670845032,
-0.4672052562236786,
-0.5820596814155579,
0.12862394750118256,
0.5232467651367188,
0.2554033696651459,
0.4191906154155731,
0.1453140527009964,
0.4899964928627014,
0.2136659026145935,
-0.02338753081858158,
0.21531203389167786,
-0.7509946823120117,
0.4518831968307495,
-0.7395474314689636,
-0.3193420171737671,
-0.3756618797779083,
-0.18573793768882751,
0.7769007682800293,
0.34250539541244507,
-0.061549294739961624,
0.40889987349510193,
-0.1896371990442276,
0.6520631909370422,
-1.0513617992401123,
-0.21895107626914978,
-0.8889409899711609,
-0.365423321723938,
-0.13389143347740173,
-0.4986060857772827,
-0.3482068181037903,
-0.16266559064388275,
-0.1624654084444046,
-0.7366262674331665,
0.04491399973630905,
0.35645437240600586,
0.8298248052597046,
0.31985628604888916,
-0.10038943588733673,
-0.17451339960098267,
-0.6322482824325562,
0.610032856464386,
-0.5897126197814941,
0.9023417830467224,
0.32849037647247314,
0.5622789859771729,
-0.07977817952632904,
-0.7491761445999146,
-0.6813241243362427,
0.22994907200336456,
-0.01660507544875145,
0.44738924503326416,
0.09147991985082626,
-0.32481780648231506,
-0.09423699229955673,
0.5795847177505493,
-0.6815113425254822,
-0.06271862238645554,
-0.1728685200214386,
0.04344668239355087,
0.31093668937683105,
-0.07076121866703033,
0.1988678276538849,
0.1426176130771637,
-0.3023786246776581,
-0.006870393641293049,
-0.8222464323043823,
-0.01924811862409115,
0.10477396845817566,
0.611737847328186,
0.19138188660144806,
0.7035229206085205,
-0.39012402296066284,
0.717028021812439,
0.33969783782958984,
-0.11217828094959259,
0.1542205512523651,
-0.34014418721199036,
-0.16262175142765045,
-0.2502887547016144,
0.3826506435871124,
-0.06252646446228027,
-0.19633546471595764,
-0.4209314286708832,
-0.34137511253356934,
-0.5901059508323669,
0.658630907535553,
-0.6951233148574829,
0.2726299464702606,
0.2132669985294342,
-0.18641482293605804,
0.13325290381908417,
0.06343923509120941,
-0.8572906851768494,
-0.2815106511116028,
-0.1648705005645752,
0.8433699011802673,
-0.39175188541412354,
-0.2069837749004364,
-0.11007502675056458,
0.016603941097855568,
0.486404150724411,
0.33372169733047485,
-0.5738860964775085,
0.097060427069664,
0.8278723955154419,
0.4112772047519684,
-0.09315326064825058,
-0.08687743544578552,
-0.8912127614021301,
0.2925609350204468,
-0.4140918254852295,
0.9344971179962158,
-0.735266387462616,
-0.37319549918174744,
0.11687476187944412,
-0.15003374218940735,
-0.049621693789958954,
-0.5974178314208984,
0.6830103993415833,
-1.3963731527328491,
0.5342733263969421,
-0.24980933964252472,
-0.26238957047462463,
-0.11038552969694138,
0.5140876173973083,
-0.30696746706962585,
1.0557918548583984,
0.40924015641212463,
-0.8741737604141235,
0.20554697513580322,
-0.20917527377605438,
-0.28229036927223206,
0.14143462479114532,
-0.12107988446950912,
-0.3115442395210266,
0.03613179177045822,
0.28099119663238525,
0.15739639103412628,
-0.2877344787120819,
0.029091544449329376,
-0.09872802346944809,
-0.47746995091438293,
-0.05638355761766434,
-0.021266376599669456,
0.3554746210575104,
0.20731128752231598,
0.20495590567588806,
0.029090406373143196,
-0.6028860807418823,
0.07506395876407623,
0.09815113991498947,
-0.43645942211151123,
-0.7988115549087524,
-0.41722872853279114,
-0.6130790710449219,
0.07778584957122803,
0.4465850293636322,
-0.537729799747467,
0.1583375781774521,
-0.7446839809417725,
-0.34323447942733765,
0.5827479362487793,
0.3464173674583435,
0.5991089940071106,
-0.39689120650291443,
0.5101535320281982,
-0.07447714358568192,
-0.1603602021932602,
-0.012885336764156818,
-0.5072519183158875,
-0.44888508319854736,
-0.23499158024787903,
0.3205462396144867,
0.5503516793251038,
-0.822781503200531,
0.19835498929023743,
-0.33795809745788574,
-0.16969065368175507,
-0.5648087859153748,
-0.030688317492604256,
0.6493647694587708,
0.7599159479141235,
0.6295503973960876,
-0.24454672634601593,
-0.5315473675727844,
-0.42866915464401245,
-0.4429517090320587,
-0.07075893878936768,
0.06345203518867493,
0.6024309992790222,
0.26715368032455444,
-0.16776150465011597,
1.099725365638733,
-0.48913517594337463,
-0.40359434485435486,
0.062352534383535385,
-0.14915944635868073,
0.11157736927270889,
0.24010735750198364,
0.28785672783851624,
-1.070178747177124,
-0.4467356204986572,
0.0330299474298954,
-0.6699075698852539,
-0.17142605781555176,
0.23575285077095032,
-0.5647230744361877,
0.1655678153038025,
0.340572714805603,
-0.5533630847930908,
0.2572452127933502,
0.3046964704990387,
-0.12817466259002686,
0.6872093677520752,
-0.22383305430412292,
0.4442863166332245,
-1.3280434608459473,
0.39236798882484436,
-0.20075233280658722,
-0.03909580409526825,
-0.35283416509628296,
0.38372746109962463,
0.057008448988199234,
-0.20079076290130615,
-0.2797222435474396,
1.056448221206665,
-0.40936753153800964,
-0.5298966765403748,
-0.3992329239845276,
0.5985704064369202,
0.1752929985523224,
0.5327189564704895,
-0.06458871811628342,
1.418670892715454,
0.21955928206443787,
-0.7217661142349243,
-0.10632390528917313,
0.5671179890632629,
0.03265201672911644,
0.818313717842102,
-0.20815590023994446,
0.07890605926513672,
-0.2781696617603302,
-0.021890468895435333,
-0.9822269082069397,
-0.199855238199234,
0.19629929959774017,
-0.7308260202407837,
0.6442242860794067,
-0.25501927733421326,
-0.24572300910949707,
-0.33067619800567627,
-0.07897248864173889,
0.5407872796058655,
0.44429895281791687,
-0.7080348134040833,
0.6928442716598511,
0.5161707997322083,
-0.31599387526512146,
-0.9755392670631409,
-0.27596697211265564,
-0.19010421633720398,
-0.04370648041367531,
-0.37889230251312256,
0.45090705156326294,
-0.0841996893286705,
-0.2963741421699524,
-0.05992968752980232,
-0.4767357110977173,
-0.23089271783828735,
-0.11381080001592636,
0.033996861428022385,
0.01562790386378765,
-0.3225712776184082,
0.44324880838394165,
0.12253457307815552,
0.0031350268982350826,
-0.22364018857479095,
-0.44856834411621094,
0.3385685086250305,
-0.09574992954730988,
-0.33239877223968506,
0.04094051197171211,
0.24397166073322296,
0.2339925616979599,
-0.7832768559455872,
0.725975513458252,
0.4936682879924774,
-0.3313828706741333,
-0.14085310697555542,
-0.6190270185470581,
-0.17958785593509674,
-0.4718701243400574,
0.11868216097354889,
-0.6214030385017395,
-1.0136029720306396,
0.4795462489128113,
-0.19979555904865265,
0.08116932213306427,
0.4657214283943176,
0.618852972984314,
-0.0973963588476181,
0.5198962688446045,
0.6130561232566833,
0.1375923603773117,
0.33124345541000366,
-0.04523753002285957,
0.2729896306991577,
-1.333788514137268,
-0.25132226943969727,
-0.7763252854347229,
0.19002743065357208,
-0.29477763175964355,
-0.6021367907524109,
0.5109224915504456,
0.4173465371131897,
-0.4688607156276703,
0.2416180819272995,
-0.5499821901321411,
0.20911386609077454,
0.5462737083435059,
0.005500664934515953,
0.5121745467185974,
-0.19339771568775177,
-0.086066335439682,
0.22401943802833557,
-0.71075040102005,
-0.1738312840461731,
0.8686953783035278,
-0.058587271720170975,
0.7234217524528503,
0.22834272682666779,
0.6731705069541931,
0.16029852628707886,
0.4289732575416565,
-0.47115251421928406,
0.5219641923904419,
-0.08586989343166351,
-0.567655622959137,
-0.2823292315006256,
-0.43188002705574036,
-1.0731122493743896,
0.373934805393219,
-0.1350158005952835,
-0.5564654469490051,
0.33147692680358887,
0.028068451210856438,
-0.44996774196624756,
0.20401108264923096,
-0.39333397150039673,
0.7726099491119385,
-0.05176911875605583,
-0.5159542560577393,
-0.1041235476732254,
-0.6214215755462646,
0.30697473883628845,
-0.16506731510162354,
0.26382946968078613,
0.20797058939933777,
-0.279350608587265,
0.6194109916687012,
-0.15338706970214844,
0.4434528052806854,
-0.13665896654129028,
-0.40465402603149414,
0.5341646671295166,
0.19179998338222504,
0.47219592332839966,
0.3259492516517639,
-0.28829023241996765,
-0.1571331024169922,
-0.02198674902319908,
-0.14450478553771973,
-0.7972888946533203,
0.8955310583114624,
-0.5891242623329163,
-0.9275356531143188,
-0.30664145946502686,
-0.6535758376121521,
-0.733891487121582,
0.4234781563282013,
-0.05798235535621643,
0.48238688707351685,
-0.08358587324619293,
0.05155657231807709,
0.8249407410621643,
-0.41545426845550537,
0.0377320870757103,
0.7903508543968201,
-0.4797202944755554,
-0.496359646320343,
1.09718656539917,
-0.030036795884370804,
0.09828734397888184,
0.9181124567985535,
0.21959933638572693,
-0.4699733555316925,
-0.5449188947677612,
-0.4490199685096741,
0.29355210065841675,
-0.7170277833938599,
-0.5431460738182068,
-0.7043991684913635,
-0.1656820923089981,
-0.8322188258171082,
-0.05520213395357132,
-0.2213488072156906,
-0.3607689142227173,
-0.2099175900220871,
0.35574740171432495,
0.38324254751205444,
0.39663925766944885,
0.05337315797805786,
0.09451814740896225,
-0.8236387372016907,
0.5686309337615967,
0.36567556858062744,
0.6974453926086426,
-0.16545218229293823,
-0.9729470610618591,
-0.3560144603252411,
0.14457297325134277,
-0.26882511377334595,
-0.5947721004486084,
0.4068601727485657,
0.17681929469108582,
0.706586480140686,
-0.04046459496021271,
0.27187079191207886,
0.46007096767425537,
-0.4460332691669464,
0.589756190776825,
-0.3251798748970032,
-0.47155240178108215,
0.5263794660568237,
-0.4932084381580353,
0.23276551067829132,
0.7046198844909668,
0.5489830374717712,
-0.2666953504085541,
-0.40454015135765076,
-0.4414031207561493,
-0.6970555186271667,
0.4296579658985138,
-0.11423566937446594,
-0.11452747136354446,
-0.04211563244462013,
0.672075629234314,
0.1703273206949234,
0.3897154927253723,
-0.2769424617290497,
0.01820017211139202,
-0.19334450364112854,
-0.21241135895252228,
0.2031211107969284,
-0.17261531949043274,
-0.12502805888652802,
0.0748741552233696,
1.0678058862686157,
-0.3457968533039093,
0.5010536909103394,
0.36659660935401917,
-0.06543336063623428,
-0.19476427137851715,
0.3267320990562439,
0.43984001874923706,
0.784582257270813,
-0.2933107614517212,
-0.21820533275604248,
0.20005381107330322,
-0.4161209166049957,
-0.011930553242564201,
0.09369752556085587,
-0.31499192118644714,
-0.234201118350029,
-0.06463681161403656,
0.38706082105636597,
0.22323232889175415,
-0.7603663802146912,
0.5704977512359619,
0.07078820466995239,
0.18193688988685608,
-0.20198020339012146,
-0.06953427940607071,
-0.06149984151124954,
0.42959654331207275,
0.5920817852020264,
0.0020524582359939814,
0.15453267097473145,
-0.5301277041435242,
0.4101192057132721,
0.6410345435142517,
-0.2468804121017456,
-0.09166029840707779,
0.6827713847160339,
0.05501663312315941,
-0.45715779066085815,
0.2547997534275055,
-0.1507834941148758,
-0.43970248103141785,
0.22011709213256836,
0.6065486073493958,
0.6430113315582275,
-0.28978240489959717,
-0.07162298262119293,
0.3632291257381439,
-0.038347817957401276,
0.20765134692192078,
0.41224703192710876,
0.08473453670740128,
-0.6471368074417114,
-0.5817630290985107,
-0.9024173021316528,
-0.5243792533874512,
-0.10798197984695435,
-0.5964431166648865,
0.02537573128938675,
-0.17882205545902252,
0.00975931715220213,
-0.44954606890678406,
0.046895161271095276,
-0.38944727182388306,
0.45343631505966187,
-0.38784295320510864,
0.9995256662368774,
0.060984041541814804,
0.6328794956207275,
0.8476612567901611,
-0.5909891724586487,
-0.5167052149772644,
0.4366825222969055,
-0.560050368309021,
-0.8015233874320984,
0.7198294401168823,
-0.12371953576803207,
-0.3373016119003296,
0.2377714365720749,
-0.1995418518781662,
-1.0965572595596313,
1.0733634233474731,
0.20330841839313507,
-0.07870730757713318,
-0.10758320987224579,
-0.26877108216285706,
0.6263834834098816,
-0.26362547278404236,
0.18360523879528046,
0.0015465962933376431,
0.29612213373184204,
0.38982924818992615,
-0.8087807297706604,
-0.026597801595926285,
0.04028361663222313,
-0.03414077311754227,
0.34843677282333374,
-0.8533773422241211,
0.5193246006965637,
-0.3851795792579651,
-0.34616056084632874,
0.362984836101532,
1.035262107849121,
0.2906170189380646,
0.5118678212165833,
0.10555046796798706,
0.7585566639900208,
0.6409704089164734,
0.050591714680194855,
0.9940925240516663,
-0.49919384717941284,
0.15757055580615997,
1.3604340553283691,
-0.44122371077537537,
1.2441465854644775,
0.3628319203853607,
0.009570782072842121,
0.617206335067749,
0.27489879727363586,
0.43628743290901184,
0.7022013068199158,
-0.03868689760565758,
-0.33757656812667847,
-0.23379531502723694,
-0.0824216827750206,
-0.5139567852020264,
0.3383652865886688,
0.36546891927719116,
-0.08312375843524933,
-0.32503247261047363,
0.26123738288879395,
-0.4750975966453552,
0.4488981068134308,
-0.5700888633728027,
0.9507859945297241,
0.059138644486665726,
-0.867240309715271,
0.5940157771110535,
0.0672779306769371,
0.5129958987236023,
-0.6225289702415466,
-0.10455939173698425,
-0.326243132352829,
0.13344517350196838,
-0.043430961668491364,
-0.930802583694458,
0.4926680624485016,
-0.21955819427967072,
-0.18790610134601593,
-0.05654700845479965,
1.0529191493988037,
-0.4073921740055084,
-0.02986060455441475,
0.12374985963106155,
0.7593629360198975,
0.03251085430383682,
-0.33682799339294434,
-0.36309945583343506,
-0.11054760962724686,
-0.33700472116470337,
-0.14560261368751526,
0.6801608800888062,
0.5760560631752014,
-0.0932028517127037,
0.795803964138031,
0.5129918456077576,
-0.20268525183200836,
0.05590450018644333,
-0.05974269658327103,
0.9922413229942322,
-0.4409065246582031,
-0.42013540863990784,
-0.041463401168584824,
0.23364882171154022,
0.05135923996567726,
-0.14840875566005707,
0.8517845869064331,
0.690606415271759,
0.9393076300621033,
-0.021015886217355728,
0.5019418597221375,
-0.08691304922103882,
1.1610108613967896,
-0.3500255346298218,
0.5661582946777344,
-0.8877635598182678,
0.2691655457019806,
-0.017305908724665642,
-0.8033220171928406,
-0.19882656633853912,
0.35443755984306335,
-0.5478552579879761,
0.35237807035446167,
0.3800680637359619,
0.9156793355941772,
-0.07092203199863434,
0.004905573558062315,
0.46883681416511536,
0.2141263335943222,
-0.049012668430805206,
0.2864554226398468,
0.5563536286354065,
-0.6050412654876709,
0.6504582762718201,
-0.04367377609014511,
-0.06599044799804688,
-0.23158623278141022,
-0.531594455242157,
-0.5571225881576538,
-0.7411728501319885,
-0.058723580092191696,
-0.5410251617431641,
0.46240562200546265,
0.476434588432312,
0.45628267526626587,
-0.6994526982307434,
0.1590055525302887,
0.12931174039840698,
0.17835645377635956,
-0.2741115689277649,
-0.26983100175857544,
0.3985113799571991,
-0.6942551136016846,
-0.5511341691017151,
0.7224053740501404,
0.3236110806465149,
-0.25127169489860535,
-0.22636915743350983,
-0.06510340422391891,
-0.638708770275116,
0.19825997948646545,
0.7293617129325867,
0.6733987927436829,
-0.39484065771102905,
-0.41451624035835266,
0.11452221125364304,
-0.20174355804920197,
0.259156733751297,
0.7783825397491455,
-1.1846450567245483,
0.3923831284046173,
0.7112711668014526,
1.184101939201355,
0.18615686893463135,
0.4906034469604492,
0.4722011983394623,
-0.9854657053947449,
-0.1951475888490677,
0.4450189769268036,
0.1554941087961197,
0.31219547986984253,
-0.6049208641052246,
0.6117688417434692,
0.3064686059951782,
-0.7055090069770813,
-0.7414681911468506,
0.15684011578559875,
-0.9254144430160522,
-0.33408868312835693,
1.1822477579116821,
-0.17651426792144775,
-0.1918201744556427,
-0.11495354771614075,
-0.2628858685493469,
0.27821964025497437,
-0.2628658711910248,
0.6127074360847473,
0.062046218663454056,
0.07156385481357574,
-0.21838943660259247,
-0.3839941918849945,
0.2917231321334839,
0.3593279719352722,
-0.8730037212371826,
0.09898185729980469,
0.38891661167144775,
0.15140090882778168,
0.35547664761543274,
0.6169218420982361,
-0.32397475838661194,
0.2989492118358612,
-0.17075714468955994,
-0.08126690238714218,
-0.11390358954668045,
-0.474139004945755,
-0.13545574247837067,
0.46567657589912415,
0.09764881432056427,
-0.111394003033638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17496v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17496v2
|
Emotional Voice Messages (EMOVOME) database: emotion recognition in spontaneous voice messages
| 2024-02-27T13:22:47 | 2024-06-13T13:09:48 |
Lucía Gómez Zaragozá, Rocío del Amor, Elena Parra Vargas, Valery Naranjo, Mariano Alcañiz Raya, Javier Marín-Morales
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS, I.5.1; I.5.4; I.2.7
|
Emotional Voice Messages (EMOVOME) is a spontaneous speech dataset containing
999 audio messages from real conversations on a messaging app from 100 Spanish
speakers, gender balanced. Voice messages were produced in-the-wild conditions
before participants were recruited, avoiding any conscious bias due to
laboratory environment. Audios were labeled in valence and arousal dimensions
by three non-experts and two experts, which were then combined to obtain a
final label per dimension. The experts also provided an extra label
corresponding to seven emotion categories. To set a baseline for future
investigations using EMOVOME, we implemented emotion recognition models using
both speech and audio transcriptions. For speech, we used the standard eGeMAPS
feature set and support vector machines, obtaining 49.27% and 44.71% unweighted
accuracy for valence and arousal respectively. For text, we fine-tuned a
multilingual BERT model and achieved 61.15% and 47.43% unweighted accuracy for
valence and arousal respectively. This database will significantly contribute
to research on emotion recognition in the wild, while also providing a unique
natural and freely accessible resource for Spanish.
|
[
-0.36222487688064575,
-0.7506246566772461,
0.40088316798210144,
0.7141970992088318,
-0.18837417662143707,
-0.06109850853681564,
-0.3735949397087097,
-0.4325858950614929,
0.5545138120651245,
0.32783806324005127,
-0.7824914455413818,
-0.8182963728904724,
-0.3566080331802368,
0.27418917417526245,
-0.3014950752258301,
0.6480002403259277,
0.21363237500190735,
0.3913019597530365,
0.10094942897558212,
-0.18521279096603394,
-0.3439953625202179,
-0.5485032796859741,
-0.5537630915641785,
0.07092946767807007,
0.4710642993450165,
0.662680983543396,
0.007598866242915392,
0.06382440775632858,
0.12044565379619598,
0.34073737263679504,
-0.06092994660139084,
-0.05093466117978096,
-0.5171859264373779,
0.6102074384689331,
0.21886716783046722,
-0.5863727331161499,
-0.5972705483436584,
-0.14250439405441284,
0.440483033657074,
0.020019792020320892,
-0.4644385874271393,
-0.0885571613907814,
-0.12780511379241943,
0.5566814541816711,
-0.5193167328834534,
0.01907302439212799,
-0.5120394229888916,
0.5825427174568176,
0.04379810765385628,
-0.30360788106918335,
-0.5035610198974609,
-0.6248205900192261,
0.27835559844970703,
-0.154835507273674,
-0.04740911349654198,
0.1450963169336319,
0.5063963532447815,
0.17822740972042084,
-0.6575684547424316,
-0.7075997591018677,
-0.8946471810340881,
0.6493625044822693,
-0.41796189546585083,
0.4364785850048065,
0.42990750074386597,
0.34037113189697266,
-0.134467214345932,
-0.1580173820257187,
-0.47525474429130554,
-0.16917169094085693,
0.32752087712287903,
0.441208153963089,
-0.729293942451477,
0.15221373736858368,
0.08920896798372269,
0.3908120095729828,
-0.4760400056838989,
0.3414459228515625,
-0.07407142221927643,
-0.13630501925945282,
0.47547125816345215,
0.4663325250148773,
0.4701439440250397,
-0.21703201532363892,
-0.24769404530525208,
-0.16711071133613586,
-0.5639530420303345,
-0.023731820285320282,
0.4733829200267792,
0.18458522856235504,
-0.2637884020805359,
0.6921421885490417,
0.08825048804283142,
0.4616553783416748,
-0.0068919723853468895,
-0.0638003721833229,
0.2434123009443283,
0.22708001732826233,
-0.5363652110099792,
0.5011498332023621,
0.9293828010559082,
0.26097390055656433,
-0.035481009632349014,
0.03680159151554108,
-0.09452750533819199,
-0.10157328099012375,
0.1690518856048584,
-0.8289443254470825,
0.138437882065773,
0.640125572681427,
-0.3390199840068817,
-0.31720873713493347,
-0.22539940476417542,
-1.1705827713012695,
-0.5270310044288635,
-0.16805920004844666,
0.30843454599380493,
-0.37644052505493164,
-0.20161983370780945,
-0.08402823656797409,
0.10326968133449554,
-0.02587740309536457,
0.5795719623565674,
-0.7882746458053589,
0.2560388147830963,
0.4137198030948639,
0.9200212955474854,
0.36258167028427124,
0.12974987924098969,
-0.12163371592760086,
-0.262585312128067,
-0.15549829602241516,
0.5889433026313782,
-0.466471403837204,
-0.5865984559059143,
0.07832591235637665,
0.3153218626976013,
-0.17147459089756012,
-0.4977085590362549,
0.8014591336250305,
0.06320343911647797,
0.2187984734773636,
-0.25862622261047363,
-0.7171558141708374,
-0.3582758903503418,
0.08090101927518845,
-0.5874053239822388,
1.0663989782333374,
-0.24126602709293365,
-0.35724809765815735,
0.081741563975811,
-0.3431317210197449,
-0.1788967400789261,
-0.13391296565532684,
-0.3105323910713196,
-0.34764713048934937,
0.33361709117889404,
-0.030356889590620995,
0.726625382900238,
-0.4163171947002411,
-0.05244670808315277,
-0.1690046191215515,
0.01264791190624237,
0.5310443639755249,
-0.27944397926330566,
0.610282301902771,
0.3821221590042114,
-0.5328552722930908,
-0.11951218545436859,
-0.9494844079017639,
0.012123921886086464,
-0.025642871856689453,
-0.24626654386520386,
-0.3471853733062744,
-0.06502652168273926,
0.12254338711500168,
0.4901885986328125,
-0.018405288457870483,
-1.0356940031051636,
-0.0013261946151033044,
-0.22001507878303528,
0.27124056220054626,
0.5431938767433167,
-0.052399877458810806,
0.2720358967781067,
0.04754207655787468,
0.7625042796134949,
0.09219914674758911,
0.11624138057231903,
-0.37094178795814514,
-0.6563096642494202,
-0.6464591026306152,
-0.3748762905597687,
-0.36008745431900024,
0.9818211793899536,
0.10772491991519928,
0.6070654392242432,
-0.0020441915839910507,
-0.9397401809692383,
-0.8061928153038025,
-0.1893148124217987,
0.40003976225852966,
0.5503573417663574,
0.0822124034166336,
0.20725278556346893,
-0.7962436676025391,
-0.9057444930076599,
-0.08567887544631958,
-0.35551396012306213,
-0.13006432354450226,
1.1249127388000488,
0.24182423949241638,
-0.29694992303848267,
0.6273354291915894,
-0.3127191960811615,
-0.39248836040496826,
0.023103218525648117,
0.5491818785667419,
0.07543659210205078,
0.3799871802330017,
0.6227299571037292,
-0.48307856917381287,
-0.37678855657577515,
0.1556054800748825,
-0.8089657425880432,
-0.4963947832584381,
-0.006045708432793617,
-0.11567173153162003,
0.10315648466348648,
0.08149164915084839,
-0.40111014246940613,
0.3606798052787781,
0.6314393877983093,
-0.37910205125808716,
0.0676131546497345,
-0.0330493189394474,
0.740532636642456,
-1.2272754907608032,
-0.2954240143299103,
0.10351096838712692,
-0.12191420048475266,
-0.7263050079345703,
-0.7547647356987,
0.10767335444688797,
-0.23128516972064972,
-0.8010205626487732,
0.23363329470157623,
-0.48662206530570984,
-0.2041102945804596,
0.0026737393345683813,
0.25179392099380493,
-0.18983227014541626,
0.31388500332832336,
-0.05717381462454796,
0.355146586894989,
0.6660184264183044,
-0.3517034351825714,
0.8648547530174255,
0.5199162364006042,
-0.1783381998538971,
0.9968758821487427,
-0.5630019903182983,
0.49393853545188904,
-0.192862868309021,
0.1488412320613861,
-1.074353575706482,
-0.26406562328338623,
0.05531312897801399,
-0.5262671113014221,
0.2222413271665573,
-0.24544982612133026,
-0.13642771542072296,
-0.21273553371429443,
-0.13394831120967865,
0.023745324462652206,
0.5278627872467041,
-0.5419997572898865,
0.8480313420295715,
0.6914752125740051,
-0.42986610531806946,
-0.2977231442928314,
-0.8331647515296936,
0.23675985634326935,
-0.31564876437187195,
-0.7828091979026794,
0.029519101604819298,
0.22546258568763733,
-0.13987098634243011,
-0.08483227342367172,
0.16100701689720154,
-0.1626613885164261,
-0.031748395413160324,
0.9261351227760315,
-0.04164279252290726,
-0.1031435877084732,
0.36351174116134644,
0.2274370789527893,
0.4061344861984253,
0.1499338448047638,
0.10989370942115784,
0.5645999312400818,
-0.4603038430213928,
0.045683130621910095,
-0.5170719027519226,
0.5435601472854614,
0.7194016575813293,
0.22585387527942657,
0.9432759284973145,
0.6536449790000916,
-0.7690094113349915,
-0.2696917951107025,
-0.6180402040481567,
-0.016491906717419624,
-0.3830499053001404,
0.24276192486286163,
-0.32778188586235046,
-1.0200486183166504,
0.981052577495575,
-0.1624290943145752,
-0.22228600084781647,
0.23015882074832916,
0.8064590096473694,
-0.26253542304039,
1.2081612348556519,
0.2431817352771759,
-0.07601488381624222,
0.4713168442249298,
0.17293226718902588,
0.010245868004858494,
-0.6773087382316589,
-1.0038729906082153,
-1.0816166400909424,
-0.3105754554271698,
-0.5283958911895752,
-0.19396670162677765,
0.23113484680652618,
-0.34074166417121887,
-0.03276539593935013,
0.19356858730316162,
-0.41484275460243225,
0.23606081306934357,
0.14815303683280945,
0.1787051111459732,
-0.1411849409341812,
0.07846853882074356,
0.024929579347372055,
-0.48260989785194397,
-0.35951074957847595,
-0.7211704850196838,
0.8719038963317871,
0.33368372917175293,
0.9301825761795044,
0.303377628326416,
0.5548642873764038,
0.324813574552536,
0.2099904865026474,
-0.8665894865989685,
0.5862986445426941,
-0.06648507714271545,
-0.6793675422668457,
-0.08576728403568268,
-0.606173038482666,
-0.9557682871818542,
0.09373095631599426,
-0.3623964190483093,
-1.095842957496643,
0.42664870619773865,
0.028440777212381363,
-0.2995220422744751,
0.18324407935142517,
-0.7413005828857422,
0.7136589884757996,
-0.44325682520866394,
-0.1887771487236023,
-0.14739878475666046,
-0.5323094129562378,
0.24370825290679932,
-0.05978835001587868,
0.1655196249485016,
-0.5399580001831055,
-0.044543758034706116,
1.0025032758712769,
-0.6248050332069397,
0.8026764988899231,
-0.12573015689849854,
-0.20622409880161285,
0.34592297673225403,
0.1952023059129715,
0.3901746869087219,
-0.016240067780017853,
-0.0663863867521286,
0.10521109402179718,
-0.2568912208080292,
-0.14104340970516205,
-0.4940109848976135,
0.8772051930427551,
-0.9887462258338928,
-0.16959236562252045,
-0.3403657376766205,
0.07416784763336182,
-0.1364215612411499,
-0.01838567852973938,
0.4469127058982849,
0.4103294909000397,
-0.7579779028892517,
0.34693560004234314,
0.6875109076499939,
-0.7745169401168823,
0.12784284353256226,
0.8368002772331238,
-0.13184690475463867,
-0.6438381671905518,
0.6350235939025879,
0.1141444519162178,
-0.06809762120246887,
0.4220440983772278,
0.09861460328102112,
-0.3582511246204376,
0.13689330220222473,
-0.26837095618247986,
-0.050009116530418396,
-0.7122112512588501,
-0.1942070573568344,
-1.21993887424469,
0.28726962208747864,
-0.42037880420684814,
-0.05784046649932861,
-0.6009683012962341,
-0.46522432565689087,
-0.4266248047351837,
-0.41213077306747437,
0.6934839487075806,
0.8317130208015442,
-0.06081710383296013,
0.30109357833862305,
-1.0850359201431274,
0.045073699206113815,
0.4180091917514801,
-0.009865696541965008,
-0.22916065156459808,
-0.4885614514350891,
-0.07426179200410843,
0.18252448737621307,
-0.07159053534269333,
-1.6397981643676758,
0.8299341201782227,
0.5814669132232666,
0.23245668411254883,
0.58668452501297,
-0.00429524015635252,
0.5310216546058655,
-0.3131285011768341,
0.7737091183662415,
0.09604267030954361,
-1.220296859741211,
1.090720534324646,
-0.35888350009918213,
-0.11308779567480087,
0.3341973125934601,
0.48954689502716064,
-0.7600919008255005,
-0.29225337505340576,
-0.6444916129112244,
-0.9385848045349121,
0.7775272130966187,
0.5331586599349976,
0.2188236266374588,
-0.06465782970190048,
0.1552060842514038,
-0.007484623230993748,
0.3615032434463501,
-0.2567231357097626,
-0.3769613802433014,
-0.1541294902563095,
-0.48566558957099915,
0.2266865372657776,
-0.3146582841873169,
-0.0027038936968892813,
-0.35946813225746155,
0.5979042649269104,
0.2923228144645691,
0.9543054103851318,
0.2642899751663208,
-0.1052783876657486,
-0.4274247884750366,
0.503363311290741,
0.677312433719635,
-0.23180963099002838,
-0.6821251511573792,
0.2145785689353943,
0.30250614881515503,
-0.768587052822113,
0.4592647850513458,
-0.17528077960014343,
0.32605603337287903,
0.2850431203842163,
-0.0036024325527250767,
1.274099349975586,
0.3251364529132843,
-0.8617083430290222,
0.47981634736061096,
-0.4311927855014801,
0.07313574850559235,
-0.6338436603546143,
-0.16520053148269653,
-0.03169392794370651,
0.13036738336086273,
0.4039077162742615,
-0.031613074243068695,
0.3538624346256256,
-0.6253894567489624,
-0.0655231848359108,
-0.07291191071271896,
-0.5892104506492615,
-0.6717803478240967,
0.6783807277679443,
0.43215715885162354,
-0.2847905158996582,
0.7303926944732666,
0.05554597079753876,
-0.7128153443336487,
0.9781977534294128,
0.48717209696769714,
1.2720727920532227,
-0.838398814201355,
0.36522790789604187,
0.5577728152275085,
0.40554097294807434,
0.015044055879116058,
0.7465076446533203,
0.13607220351696014,
-0.8415831327438354,
0.22380591928958893,
-0.4384794533252716,
-0.8452989459037781,
-0.044302187860012054,
-0.9357681274414062,
0.1832474172115326,
-0.554871678352356,
-0.4264424741268158,
0.01012287475168705,
-0.32058948278427124,
-0.7946412563323975,
0.45797669887542725,
0.35843977332115173,
0.5465443730354309,
-1.2786104679107666,
0.4179714024066925,
0.9541007280349731,
-0.1096561849117279,
-0.8361730575561523,
-0.746589720249176,
0.3999875485897064,
-0.604578971862793,
0.48042577505111694,
0.259804904460907,
-0.213423490524292,
0.017580877989530563,
-0.5149072408676147,
-0.38980528712272644,
0.960307240486145,
0.4492759704589844,
-0.8435511589050293,
0.688187837600708,
-0.07011179625988007,
0.8318499326705933,
-0.6308482885360718,
0.6565143465995789,
0.37182605266571045,
0.3180241882801056,
0.01873188093304634,
-0.770363986492157,
-0.08162055164575577,
-0.6686635613441467,
-0.4692411422729492,
0.1958719789981842,
-0.6883184313774109,
0.7233296036720276,
0.026669248938560486,
-0.35509228706359863,
-0.2576506733894348,
0.39056289196014404,
0.06508111208677292,
0.511186420917511,
0.48543182015419006,
0.6783630847930908,
1.1132806539535522,
-0.3713815212249756,
0.842136800289154,
-0.07317948341369629,
0.23998808860778809,
0.8341565132141113,
-0.4745537340641022,
0.914006769657135,
0.08624459058046341,
-0.2737995386123657,
0.41463932394981384,
0.7808500528335571,
0.1625073105096817,
0.17393086850643158,
-0.07253047823905945,
-0.6685938239097595,
-0.12164688110351562,
-0.3869032561779022,
-0.3589472472667694,
0.4207008183002472,
0.6817455291748047,
-0.5273631811141968,
0.4308655858039856,
0.5150637030601501,
0.29010313749313354,
-0.3875860273838043,
-0.1597871035337448,
0.8697571158409119,
0.22670908272266388,
-0.28297847509384155,
0.4038451910018921,
-0.2271367609500885,
0.4075395166873932,
-0.1441088169813156,
0.23748904466629028,
-0.2945138216018677,
0.03540962561964989,
-0.5461245179176331,
-0.6303285956382751,
0.04251120984554291,
0.569354772567749,
0.06624738872051239,
-0.1732843518257141,
0.6154221892356873,
-0.7070116400718689,
-0.36075595021247864,
0.36168721318244934,
0.439458966255188,
0.6193379759788513,
-0.05624578148126602,
-0.6011215448379517,
0.20558200776576996,
0.03894270956516266,
-0.3738171458244324,
-0.006453399546444416,
0.9902505874633789,
0.4382748007774353,
0.6898899078369141,
0.3573499321937561,
0.26069724559783936,
0.43724849820137024,
0.31853219866752625,
0.6829105019569397,
-0.883418619632721,
-0.7941060066223145,
-0.82496577501297,
0.3126417398452759,
-0.2082289308309555,
-0.4707035720348358,
0.9341702461242676,
0.5489564538002014,
0.22664380073547363,
-0.21751795709133148,
0.6468947529792786,
-0.020381668582558632,
0.4113488793373108,
-0.3128703236579895,
0.40875014662742615,
-0.5914803743362427,
0.15850308537483215,
-0.7155545353889465,
-0.9022420644760132,
-0.10777419805526733,
0.7450072169303894,
0.011142155155539513,
-0.10096991062164307,
0.38671228289604187,
0.8107293844223022,
0.3197547197341919,
0.49025294184684753,
0.3402232229709625,
0.5487680435180664,
0.09062075614929199,
0.7477419972419739,
1.193942904472351,
-0.28525596857070923,
0.22312994301319122,
-0.2269354611635208,
-0.1966557502746582,
-0.5332347750663757,
-0.7783150672912598,
-0.7677410840988159,
-0.46846213936805725,
-0.5288582444190979,
-0.3700208067893982,
-0.013827992603182793,
1.3699873685836792,
0.49634987115859985,
-0.8954739570617676,
-0.15771575272083282,
0.027626344934105873,
-0.1255110800266266,
0.22185301780700684,
-0.1773136407136917,
-0.011963718570768833,
0.3349702060222626,
-0.87496417760849,
0.5758272409439087,
0.5485626459121704,
0.4860144555568695,
-0.004889515228569508,
-0.3288830518722534,
0.12341234087944031,
0.4021015465259552,
0.4315052628517151,
0.465825617313385,
-0.3275296986103058,
0.060637909919023514,
0.22001364827156067,
-0.3314568102359772,
0.08266334235668182,
0.7816808819770813,
-0.30970847606658936,
0.6468802094459534,
0.7125185132026672,
0.28771668672561646,
0.5467715263366699,
-0.2144206166267395,
0.5660045146942139,
-0.8465957045555115,
0.5361406803131104,
0.5035853981971741,
0.5612483024597168,
0.406011164188385,
-0.5816701650619507,
0.37627488374710083,
0.03312226012349129,
-0.6130321025848389,
-1.083093285560608,
-0.0969124436378479,
-1.2268071174621582,
0.30083736777305603,
1.0036121606826782,
-0.4316490888595581,
-0.3059293329715729,
-0.08443808555603027,
-0.5613628625869751,
0.392560750246048,
-0.8003973960876465,
0.5728415250778198,
0.7611352205276489,
-0.1464124321937561,
-0.4820261597633362,
-0.49867233633995056,
0.42747998237609863,
0.5742024779319763,
-0.9962381720542908,
-0.2529686391353607,
0.7374317049980164,
-0.08463118970394135,
-0.05544118583202362,
0.5871821045875549,
-0.10744225233793259,
0.1566842496395111,
-0.02184463106095791,
0.43728017807006836,
0.3099389374256134,
-0.2878134548664093,
-0.6677119135856628,
0.17491886019706726,
-0.43254005908966064,
-0.17564737796783447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17493v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17493v4
|
Predicting postoperative risks using large language models
| 2024-02-27T13:18:00 | 2024-05-05T04:07:44 |
Bing Xue, Charles Alba, Joanna Abraham, Thomas Kannampallil, Chenyang Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, J.3; I.2.7
|
Predicting postoperative risk can inform effective care management &
planning. We explored large language models (LLMs) in predicting postoperative
risk through clinical texts using various tuning strategies. Records spanning
84,875 patients from Barnes Jewish Hospital (BJH) between 2018 & 2021, with a
mean duration of follow-up based on the length of postoperative ICU stay less
than 7 days, were utilized. Methods were replicated on the MIMIC-III dataset.
Outcomes included 30-day mortality, pulmonary embolism (PE) & pneumonia. Three
domain adaptation & finetuning strategies were implemented for three LLMs
(BioGPT, ClinicalBERT & BioClinicalBERT): self-supervised objectives;
incorporating labels with semi-supervised fine-tuning; & foundational modelling
through multi-task learning. Model performance was compared using the AUROC &
AUPRC for classification tasks & MSE & R2 for regression tasks. Cohort had a
mean age of 56.9 (sd: 16.8) years; 50.3% male; 74% White. Pre-trained LLMs
outperformed traditional word embeddings, with absolute maximal gains of 38.3%
for AUROC & 14% for AUPRC. Adapting models through self-supervised finetuning
further improved performance by 3.2% for AUROC & 1.5% for AUPRC Incorporating
labels into the finetuning procedure further boosted performances, with
semi-supervised finetuning improving by 1.8% for AUROC & 2% for AUPRC &
foundational modelling improving by 3.6% for AUROC & 2.6% for AUPRC compared to
self-supervised finetuning. Pre-trained clinical LLMs offer opportunities for
postoperative risk predictions with unseen data, & further improvements from
finetuning suggests benefits in adapting pre-trained models to note-specific
perioperative use cases. Incorporating labels can further boost performance.
The superior performance of foundational models suggests the potential of
task-agnostic learning towards the generalizable LLMs in perioperative care.
|
[
0.0492134690284729,
-0.4753505289554596,
0.6873392462730408,
-0.07333988696336746,
-0.3114999234676361,
0.003778262296691537,
-0.10431621968746185,
-0.6046095490455627,
0.060151707381010056,
0.9209849238395691,
-0.5264055132865906,
-0.7537964582443237,
-0.8911507725715637,
-0.1211429014801979,
-0.05394267663359642,
1.3189973831176758,
-0.18224669992923737,
0.3166014850139618,
-0.012055045925080776,
0.1493884027004242,
-0.5648435354232788,
-0.7801351547241211,
-0.43532201647758484,
-0.16624654829502106,
0.5520209074020386,
0.3289085030555725,
0.6094737648963928,
0.5003042817115784,
0.7464460730552673,
0.2410704642534256,
0.13271625339984894,
-0.011930891312658787,
-0.362235963344574,
-0.2522754371166229,
0.03625469282269478,
-0.5981821417808533,
-0.2021801471710205,
-0.22645708918571472,
0.3311510980129242,
0.8904741406440735,
-0.42685121297836304,
0.008559650741517544,
-0.0794440507888794,
0.6676928400993347,
-0.5140025019645691,
0.13038015365600586,
-0.7831510901451111,
0.3450087904930115,
-0.08917007595300674,
-0.45314034819602966,
-0.16899557411670685,
-0.3447937071323395,
0.3842735290527344,
-0.5575135350227356,
-0.2472677379846573,
0.08840687572956085,
0.4960325062274933,
0.390979140996933,
-0.3923361301422119,
-0.39750513434410095,
-0.7332572340965271,
0.5437130331993103,
-0.5569856762886047,
0.5706762075424194,
0.45207929611206055,
0.2988494038581848,
0.028953248634934425,
-0.656631588935852,
-0.041399504989385605,
-0.29093265533447266,
-0.04515281692147255,
0.15318050980567932,
-0.18253453075885773,
0.39673227071762085,
0.3968462347984314,
0.3976077139377594,
-0.4540042281150818,
0.26590457558631897,
-0.47632619738578796,
-0.26746925711631775,
0.5136222243309021,
0.276406466960907,
0.13026177883148193,
0.051486264914274216,
-0.6365470886230469,
0.008737015537917614,
-0.7963749766349792,
0.04484356567263603,
0.2708072364330292,
0.13633228838443756,
-0.1702164262533188,
0.5519677400588989,
-0.20325271785259247,
0.5449353456497192,
0.1342509239912033,
-0.05380208417773247,
0.44011545181274414,
-0.25526323914527893,
-0.2235558032989502,
0.07545076310634613,
0.682320773601532,
0.3506786823272705,
0.704944908618927,
-0.10257812589406967,
-0.07642035186290741,
0.06610476970672607,
0.49127599596977234,
-0.655796468257904,
-0.42412418127059937,
0.0012802992714568973,
-0.4928085207939148,
-0.38047805428504944,
-0.11867235600948334,
-0.4254942536354065,
-0.45169925689697266,
-0.3193061351776123,
0.4296371042728424,
-0.4769391119480133,
-0.05776333063840866,
0.36231380701065063,
0.4700745940208435,
0.008805935271084309,
0.40414994955062866,
-0.6236869096755981,
0.35401496291160583,
0.4141153395175934,
0.7423704266548157,
-0.10321241617202759,
-0.09944834560155869,
-0.4967631995677948,
0.1742277890443802,
-0.5917501449584961,
0.6728650331497192,
-0.15918298065662384,
-0.5159584879875183,
0.3125576972961426,
0.18893277645111084,
-0.08412648737430573,
-0.4148917496204376,
0.6857182383537292,
-0.15504370629787445,
-0.14892861247062683,
0.16965261101722717,
-0.5542604923248291,
-0.12324830144643784,
-0.01609422266483307,
-0.6649352312088013,
0.33804771304130554,
0.05382045730948448,
-0.5956117510795593,
0.37695401906967163,
-0.4251510798931122,
-0.8466421961784363,
-0.12000594288110733,
-0.11175537109375,
-0.6977285146713257,
0.1346329003572464,
0.3389585316181183,
0.8534247279167175,
-0.07886795699596405,
0.2753526568412781,
-0.10337141901254654,
-0.07667297124862671,
0.2705092132091522,
-0.18482623994350433,
0.22001798450946808,
0.23712463676929474,
0.001985788345336914,
0.22222992777824402,
-0.4467996060848236,
-0.17442235350608826,
-0.1835072785615921,
-0.21541844308376312,
-0.09745568782091141,
-0.027807192876935005,
-0.08024389296770096,
0.34916359186172485,
0.18378353118896484,
-0.5553743243217468,
0.06523346900939941,
-0.49838659167289734,
0.328134685754776,
0.3526187241077423,
0.3394286036491394,
0.3370124399662018,
-0.5440788865089417,
0.7279554009437561,
-0.17308947443962097,
0.3835732638835907,
0.15010987222194672,
-0.14137914776802063,
-0.286803662776947,
0.11030822992324829,
0.23473115265369415,
0.8294349908828735,
-0.6060044169425964,
0.2689540684223175,
-0.20329535007476807,
-0.6821425557136536,
-0.3338557183742523,
0.06264090538024902,
0.6191167831420898,
0.5637266039848328,
0.3226603865623474,
-0.2819890081882477,
-0.7540584802627563,
-0.8307818174362183,
-0.1020897775888443,
-0.23470567166805267,
-0.10352708399295807,
0.5739302039146423,
0.17705991864204407,
-0.5486515760421753,
0.016675064340233803,
-0.9006572961807251,
-0.6863541007041931,
-0.24430958926677704,
0.15508882701396942,
0.3298523724079132,
0.49970129132270813,
0.23272690176963806,
-0.43875250220298767,
-0.38289499282836914,
0.3129449784755707,
-0.5900945663452148,
-0.040701888501644135,
-0.19477789103984833,
-0.06338424235582352,
0.46127551794052124,
0.7594875693321228,
-0.37479692697525024,
0.4533465802669525,
0.7333402633666992,
0.22466878592967987,
0.47867754101753235,
-0.3227185606956482,
0.14625120162963867,
-0.8610726594924927,
-0.0002167906059185043,
0.15067173540592194,
-0.12124393880367279,
-0.6669424772262573,
-0.298697292804718,
-0.05785856023430824,
-0.32173243165016174,
-0.5221300721168518,
0.23870714008808136,
-0.5431761741638184,
0.31063005328178406,
-0.019821319729089737,
-0.4668363034725189,
-0.20278142392635345,
0.2058921903371811,
0.4106126129627228,
0.3058749735355377,
0.6005234122276306,
-0.49943023920059204,
-0.18108364939689636,
0.15894576907157898,
-0.638299822807312,
-0.0004634857177734375,
-0.7947989702224731,
-0.11582959443330765,
0.26914557814598083,
0.2538740336894989,
-1.03042733669281,
-0.1161845326423645,
-0.1289406567811966,
-0.273069828748703,
0.7258452773094177,
-0.20462462306022644,
-0.2026701271533966,
-0.43602871894836426,
-0.057204388082027435,
0.16220252215862274,
0.3291275203227997,
0.14522989094257355,
0.5916413068771362,
0.4768591523170471,
-0.6147022843360901,
-0.41208961606025696,
-0.667236328125,
-0.0712263360619545,
-0.15877950191497803,
-0.27840131521224976,
0.22678616642951965,
-0.21114090085029602,
0.08717931807041168,
-0.1627683937549591,
-0.18835046887397766,
0.0641494020819664,
0.15408430993556976,
0.4921761155128479,
0.43941572308540344,
0.03900755196809769,
0.41916030645370483,
0.042310625314712524,
-0.15637342631816864,
-0.11298590898513794,
-0.3076629638671875,
0.5661052465438843,
-0.13922737538814545,
-0.04948621988296509,
-0.4848394989967346,
0.3098001480102539,
0.41732004284858704,
-0.19416801631450653,
0.7551842927932739,
0.7783307433128357,
-0.6143297553062439,
0.20946185290813446,
-0.9577447175979614,
-0.25994187593460083,
-0.2650543749332428,
0.4876365661621094,
-0.20081058144569397,
-0.9999062418937683,
0.6084489822387695,
-0.24089522659778595,
-0.08707093447446823,
0.44467490911483765,
0.6662343144416809,
-0.3312811255455017,
0.73841392993927,
0.7051478028297424,
-0.04955197498202324,
0.5307692885398865,
-0.2929043173789978,
0.170828178524971,
-0.739272952079773,
-0.1837131679058075,
-0.2933904230594635,
0.020368749275803566,
-0.8545055389404297,
-0.6894600987434387,
0.6080536246299744,
0.039192501455545425,
-0.014507626183331013,
0.2634080946445465,
-0.39204010367393494,
0.08788247406482697,
0.048525381833314896,
0.2615337669849396,
0.030883654952049255,
0.07577991485595703,
-0.04078639671206474,
0.15953633189201355,
-0.6410576701164246,
-0.1317710280418396,
1.6587105989456177,
0.6166990399360657,
0.9997667670249939,
-0.35929393768310547,
0.6915990114212036,
0.0691148117184639,
0.1996842473745346,
-0.7340296506881714,
0.09436126053333282,
-0.5099443197250366,
-0.3798326551914215,
-0.33501318097114563,
-0.361734539270401,
-0.8798208236694336,
-0.20979520678520203,
-0.5798243284225464,
-0.566317081451416,
-0.03903204947710037,
0.24476221203804016,
-0.7346819043159485,
0.18697714805603027,
-0.7109895348548889,
0.7427430152893066,
-0.4765704572200775,
-0.33112335205078125,
-0.27515071630477905,
-0.8922789692878723,
0.025405725464224815,
-0.3625957667827606,
0.33278486132621765,
0.07355058193206787,
-0.17894664406776428,
0.6060876846313477,
-0.33954042196273804,
0.8000572323799133,
0.17669232189655304,
-0.15612711012363434,
0.05583791062235832,
-0.018716616556048393,
0.5988858342170715,
0.09085315465927124,
-0.16518042981624603,
0.5906942486763,
0.24631479382514954,
-0.0029244464822113514,
-0.4337513744831085,
0.8768075108528137,
-0.9044073820114136,
-0.5264278650283813,
-0.3884497284889221,
-0.5573393702507019,
-0.3774232864379883,
-0.06019672378897667,
0.4068755805492401,
0.5635725855827332,
-0.27986642718315125,
0.34822699427604675,
0.5905709862709045,
-0.5024126172065735,
-0.049161262810230255,
0.6482497453689575,
0.14056755602359772,
-0.5126767158508301,
0.5500565767288208,
0.40751102566719055,
0.20627839863300323,
0.7935484051704407,
0.37655144929885864,
-0.5548161268234253,
-0.9321420788764954,
-0.08686874061822891,
0.17482028901576996,
-0.36567988991737366,
-0.39383962750434875,
-1.0032769441604614,
-0.38248422741889954,
-0.5315315127372742,
-0.40274718403816223,
-0.1200173944234848,
-0.04549547657370567,
-0.18950478732585907,
-0.38039630651474,
0.3205493986606598,
0.4974348843097687,
0.008050577715039253,
0.37742456793785095,
-0.802614688873291,
0.04909989982843399,
0.030334651470184326,
0.4020102322101593,
-0.3857128322124481,
-0.3758079409599304,
-0.4836232364177704,
-0.21102401614189148,
-0.08100520074367523,
-0.7647944688796997,
0.4276371896266937,
0.2575445771217346,
0.6271376013755798,
0.43472984433174133,
0.04105503112077713,
0.5826534628868103,
-0.8063993453979492,
0.44426366686820984,
0.5279898643493652,
-0.7377610802650452,
0.7293146848678589,
-0.42150360345840454,
0.25676968693733215,
0.7021424174308777,
0.6825207471847534,
-0.3937097191810608,
0.06389699131250381,
-0.5513038635253906,
-0.8245569467544556,
0.5279068946838379,
-0.2527596056461334,
-0.06363343447446823,
-0.11414463818073273,
0.4411875605583191,
0.19682295620441437,
0.5675297379493713,
-0.6847496032714844,
0.0523841418325901,
0.10877282172441483,
-0.0955343022942543,
-0.589042603969574,
-0.28303012251853943,
-0.2969713807106018,
-0.17912575602531433,
0.41949892044067383,
-0.3767738938331604,
0.1806638240814209,
0.2277267873287201,
-0.12653762102127075,
-0.47496455907821655,
0.2312641441822052,
0.5852621793746948,
0.6226682662963867,
-0.21571294963359833,
-0.11745993047952652,
0.4104691445827484,
-0.38382357358932495,
-0.24959686398506165,
0.28911834955215454,
0.3788764178752899,
-0.3590715825557709,
0.6956272125244141,
1.0766496658325195,
0.3745926320552826,
-0.6565049290657043,
0.4728719890117645,
0.05454353243112564,
-0.22690686583518982,
-0.5607491731643677,
-0.1301233023405075,
-0.06160920113325119,
0.07231957465410233,
-0.0070413947105407715,
0.2727208137512207,
0.3252387046813965,
-0.48134613037109375,
0.34925270080566406,
0.28847917914390564,
-0.6692447662353516,
-0.19245359301567078,
0.4628320336341858,
0.11869557946920395,
0.006478582043200731,
0.03380408510565758,
0.31497570872306824,
-0.31303444504737854,
0.49584367871284485,
0.4530913531780243,
0.5530695915222168,
-0.5092916488647461,
0.22523066401481628,
0.40505948662757874,
0.37657779455184937,
-0.14429764449596405,
0.14594261348247528,
0.21611140668392181,
-0.4716813862323761,
-0.6065598130226135,
-0.703313946723938,
-0.12180139869451523,
0.15313686430454254,
-0.5779026746749878,
0.3148258626461029,
-0.6369052529335022,
-0.1462099701166153,
-0.20842565596103668,
0.23617932200431824,
-0.8870965242385864,
0.41325268149375916,
0.3412002921104431,
0.6563124060630798,
-0.9312225580215454,
0.7119359374046326,
0.9108678102493286,
-0.20908787846565247,
-1.1398131847381592,
0.15834994614124298,
-0.019821403548121452,
-0.7530435919761658,
0.31575292348861694,
0.21077097952365875,
-0.024178961291909218,
-0.2103917896747589,
0.0002934123913291842,
-0.9439629316329956,
0.9426335096359253,
0.16762587428092957,
-1.0037784576416016,
-0.08205860108137131,
0.016944294795393944,
0.9045460820198059,
-0.5691004395484924,
0.0920042023062706,
0.36236026883125305,
0.02195589803159237,
0.21821260452270508,
-1.0515519380569458,
-0.05867581441998482,
0.0930757150053978,
-0.09181319177150726,
0.3672676086425781,
-0.34303611516952515,
0.550495445728302,
-0.6655953526496887,
-0.0007974521140567958,
0.012818814255297184,
0.2730570137500763,
-0.058630041778087616,
0.30043476819992065,
0.6293163299560547,
0.7470889687538147,
0.3859270513057709,
-0.14702865481376648,
1.36162269115448,
-0.43600019812583923,
0.05633895844221115,
0.865213930606842,
-0.3372077941894531,
0.9117927551269531,
0.32110947370529175,
-0.1790391355752945,
0.49742522835731506,
0.428088903427124,
0.17971304059028625,
0.6845363974571228,
0.3604631721973419,
0.05323700234293938,
-0.3604063093662262,
-0.23801982402801514,
-0.454556405544281,
0.4791968762874603,
0.64216548204422,
-0.42816904187202454,
0.27591344714164734,
0.2913915812969208,
-0.008460789918899536,
0.06880108267068863,
-0.5012189149856567,
1.1283906698226929,
0.2723354399204254,
-0.8673582077026367,
0.6521314382553101,
-0.37605491280555725,
0.4354341924190521,
-0.7948506474494934,
-0.05144822970032692,
0.20858609676361084,
0.41564151644706726,
-0.38129550218582153,
-0.7998056411743164,
0.26572591066360474,
-0.45186296105384827,
-0.056237395852804184,
-0.11113099008798599,
0.7094963788986206,
-0.6020540595054626,
-0.8258365988731384,
0.47269752621650696,
0.3791218101978302,
-0.12594076991081238,
0.012922270223498344,
-0.5994474291801453,
0.2361501157283783,
0.09378739446401596,
-0.022153019905090332,
0.3514203429222107,
0.38233646750450134,
-0.21810045838356018,
0.6869516372680664,
0.6720712780952454,
0.5776503682136536,
-0.3525589108467102,
0.20509997010231018,
0.8695374727249146,
-0.06727628409862518,
-0.43080443143844604,
-0.4376334547996521,
0.3168509304523468,
0.3970017433166504,
-0.3512153625488281,
0.34148693084716797,
0.16577064990997314,
0.8189885020256042,
-0.3548927903175354,
0.5773249864578247,
0.4202449917793274,
0.6296156644821167,
-0.7876189351081848,
0.6085849404335022,
-0.6883424520492554,
0.10583126544952393,
-0.700994610786438,
-0.36991724371910095,
-0.53790283203125,
0.5730227828025818,
-1.0001630783081055,
-0.16978542506694794,
0.6750662922859192,
0.6359299421310425,
0.24095021188259125,
-0.4161011278629303,
0.5924476981163025,
0.20995715260505676,
0.09997106343507767,
0.7507969737052917,
0.5005543828010559,
-0.2502000033855438,
0.44910186529159546,
-0.21700818836688995,
-0.3321073055267334,
-0.5780354738235474,
-0.6923168301582336,
-0.7554717659950256,
-0.30461087822914124,
-0.41332751512527466,
-0.1025572419166565,
0.344632089138031,
0.7500002980232239,
0.8648134469985962,
-0.6909685134887695,
-0.10030519962310791,
0.08193280547857285,
-0.36871522665023804,
-0.1971362978219986,
-0.07250792533159256,
0.5686485171318054,
-0.09742578119039536,
-0.21416155993938446,
0.06538068503141403,
0.2719893753528595,
0.017474237829446793,
0.16515834629535675,
0.001461286679841578,
-0.2747783064842224,
-0.24619150161743164,
0.6202346086502075,
0.017177574336528778,
-0.7607453465461731,
-0.33483365178108215,
0.15440978109836578,
-0.042546071112155914,
-0.21773584187030792,
0.7711164355278015,
-0.39969635009765625,
0.37370565533638,
0.19985727965831757,
0.7092441916465759,
0.44752851128578186,
0.032867930829524994,
0.5957416892051697,
-0.5377628803253174,
-0.016235368326306343,
0.41007599234580994,
0.6394625902175903,
0.2615606486797333,
-0.8732181191444397,
0.44710037112236023,
0.04740196838974953,
-0.7471615672111511,
-0.43539127707481384,
0.27375367283821106,
-0.9706550240516663,
-0.07989392429590225,
1.0753414630889893,
-0.3200860023498535,
0.22308483719825745,
-0.020287882536649704,
-0.2635374367237091,
0.42973724007606506,
-0.35905489325523376,
0.5999364256858826,
0.5318591594696045,
-0.3025088310241699,
-0.1866120547056198,
-0.7489289045333862,
0.7599087953567505,
0.5060631036758423,
-0.7938808798789978,
-0.21371492743492126,
0.49385547637939453,
0.5378214120864868,
0.21847017109394073,
0.628802478313446,
-0.3227100372314453,
0.38214948773384094,
-0.5203438401222229,
0.20498976111412048,
-0.053962234407663345,
-0.5720900893211365,
-0.35924801230430603,
0.12081358581781387,
0.14950008690357208,
-0.07337602227926254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17478v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17478v1
|
Can GPT-4 Identify Propaganda? Annotation and Detection of Propaganda Spans in News Articles
| 2024-02-27T13:02:19 | 2024-02-27T13:02:19 |
Maram Hasanain, Fatema Ahmed, Firoj Alam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The use of propaganda has spiked on mainstream and social media, aiming to
manipulate or mislead users. While efforts to automatically detect propaganda
techniques in textual, visual, or multimodal content have increased, most of
them primarily focus on English content. The majority of the recent initiatives
targeting medium to low-resource languages produced relatively small annotated
datasets, with a skewed distribution, posing challenges for the development of
sophisticated propaganda detection models. To address this challenge, we
carefully develop the largest propaganda dataset to date, ArPro, comprised of
8K paragraphs from newspaper articles, labeled at the text span level following
a taxonomy of 23 propagandistic techniques. Furthermore, our work offers the
first attempt to understand the performance of large language models (LLMs),
using GPT-4, for fine-grained propaganda detection from text. Results showed
that GPT-4's performance degrades as the task moves from simply classifying a
paragraph as propagandistic or not, to the fine-grained task of detecting
propaganda techniques and their manifestation in text. Compared to models
fine-tuned on the dataset for propaganda detection at different classification
granularities, GPT-4 is still far behind. Finally, we evaluate GPT-4 on a
dataset consisting of six other languages for span detection, and results
suggest that the model struggles with the task across languages. Our dataset
and resources will be released to the community.
|
[
-0.560824990272522,
-0.943468451499939,
0.5559840798377991,
0.24207456409931183,
-0.3189280927181244,
0.018506305292248726,
-0.30519095063209534,
-0.5410176515579224,
0.010609469376504421,
0.4323410391807556,
-0.24698902666568756,
-0.4255654811859131,
-1.0068100690841675,
0.4651561379432678,
-0.5769426822662354,
1.2602696418762207,
-0.2029396891593933,
-0.24262268841266632,
0.23589394986629486,
-0.01781395822763443,
0.2415488064289093,
-0.49346908926963806,
-0.6648007035255432,
-0.24373503029346466,
0.6322916150093079,
0.220449298620224,
0.6220837235450745,
0.8222731947898865,
0.40577903389930725,
0.25349268317222595,
0.09793537855148315,
0.2372574806213379,
-0.45053917169570923,
-0.3434157073497772,
-0.10453782975673676,
-0.3125677704811096,
-0.13846032321453094,
0.46388277411460876,
0.7876103520393372,
0.0736982673406601,
0.23571385443210602,
0.18875187635421753,
0.018478998914361,
0.3868403434753418,
-0.36664915084838867,
0.18073709309101105,
-0.6646215915679932,
-0.1732603907585144,
-0.7087417840957642,
-0.13599734008312225,
-0.2618497312068939,
-0.17399491369724274,
0.03853311389684677,
-0.5648053884506226,
0.33126309514045715,
0.18419991433620453,
1.0672290325164795,
-0.009824290871620178,
-0.5576441884040833,
-0.4566690921783447,
-0.6449990272521973,
0.7350135445594788,
-0.4469694495201111,
0.24898703396320343,
0.42875662446022034,
0.019626310095191002,
0.1170821562409401,
-0.7801586985588074,
-0.6923465132713318,
-0.14610682427883148,
0.011341093108057976,
0.02673681266605854,
-0.5237124562263489,
-0.14768622815608978,
0.24189725518226624,
0.3328215777873993,
-0.7233728170394897,
0.10548161715269089,
-0.6602091193199158,
-0.6595074534416199,
0.3835862874984741,
-0.21936434507369995,
0.37132760882377625,
-0.4095326066017151,
-0.6125604510307312,
0.08934736996889114,
-0.6879813075065613,
-0.4737666845321655,
0.8784161806106567,
0.009967515245079994,
-0.09480713307857513,
0.6937251091003418,
-0.12612108886241913,
0.7091082334518433,
0.019836431369185448,
-0.28505751490592957,
0.24388115108013153,
-0.31717702746391296,
-0.08816301822662354,
-0.07587193697690964,
0.97928786277771,
0.38646918535232544,
0.3760877251625061,
0.18096891045570374,
-0.30914437770843506,
0.3903768062591553,
0.20978830754756927,
-0.5186957716941833,
-0.46330758929252625,
-0.26422014832496643,
-0.30161938071250916,
-0.4386311173439026,
-0.14997607469558716,
-0.8118844628334045,
-0.290188729763031,
0.10725420713424683,
0.5230916142463684,
-0.518696129322052,
-0.22170977294445038,
0.012994089163839817,
-0.1437070518732071,
0.2941378355026245,
0.04009076580405235,
-0.8122814893722534,
0.22857946157455444,
0.7054167985916138,
1.1327738761901855,
-0.26961320638656616,
-0.31023284792900085,
-0.47026094794273376,
-0.009654136374592781,
-0.4966920018196106,
1.218130350112915,
-0.6815336346626282,
-0.00467686215415597,
0.2529047131538391,
0.02882940135896206,
-0.09167342633008957,
-0.37838175892829895,
0.8348866105079651,
-0.5493212342262268,
0.34003397822380066,
-0.3504778742790222,
-0.5412194132804871,
-0.039729103446006775,
0.5767436623573303,
-1.0733249187469482,
0.8040682673454285,
0.3661206066608429,
-0.9947988986968994,
0.32546183466911316,
-0.3966464400291443,
-0.4693548083305359,
-0.08324645459651947,
-0.09636477380990982,
-0.7026869654655457,
-0.03405218943953514,
0.4075835049152374,
0.359574556350708,
-0.006961598061025143,
-0.06387872248888016,
-0.04195738956332207,
-0.38810044527053833,
0.1698717474937439,
-0.8747040033340454,
0.161738783121109,
0.3417621850967407,
-0.17715638875961304,
-0.12953956425189972,
-0.45798438787460327,
-0.43365147709846497,
-0.032726600766181946,
-0.49715718626976013,
-0.37320762872695923,
-0.239778071641922,
0.05146931856870651,
0.3355734348297119,
0.34067484736442566,
-0.4008335471153259,
0.3194361627101898,
-0.14679794013500214,
0.3199028968811035,
0.6856785416603088,
0.20309166610240936,
0.36665138602256775,
-0.26130834221839905,
0.6326765418052673,
0.05191425606608391,
0.1301621049642563,
-0.19634400308132172,
-0.6312940120697021,
-0.4985032081604004,
-0.23958396911621094,
0.10256625711917877,
0.46443066000938416,
-1.0262974500656128,
-0.22852207720279694,
-0.14710882306098938,
-0.3321620523929596,
-0.18783697485923767,
0.07017924636602402,
0.4412636160850525,
0.556620717048645,
0.4577544927597046,
0.07698559015989304,
-0.6695159077644348,
-1.2181199789047241,
-0.6265156269073486,
-0.2652031183242798,
0.03425988554954529,
-0.3667232394218445,
0.6553366184234619,
-0.08206956833600998,
0.5305448174476624,
-0.4370003342628479,
-0.4584639072418213,
-0.46649327874183655,
0.542156994342804,
-0.01453690230846405,
-0.032320890575647354,
0.4305402636528015,
-0.9654350876808167,
-0.4974881708621979,
-0.03728501871228218,
-0.5351805686950684,
-0.4273472726345062,
-0.04651173576712608,
0.031173434108495712,
0.37619876861572266,
0.32884788513183594,
-0.49561235308647156,
0.1260550171136856,
0.7707957625389099,
-0.32354187965393066,
0.8308562636375427,
0.01908775046467781,
0.2564825117588043,
-0.7864894270896912,
-0.14677761495113373,
0.5303473472595215,
-0.14043399691581726,
-0.8705071210861206,
-0.4580192565917969,
0.26400065422058105,
0.19063670933246613,
-0.375828355550766,
0.45088329911231995,
-0.3130171597003937,
-0.06753600388765335,
-0.2913627326488495,
0.12975595891475677,
0.2035788893699646,
0.26614537835121155,
0.019384516403079033,
0.928397536277771,
0.29199114441871643,
-0.2579481601715088,
0.2523247301578522,
0.14282839000225067,
-0.5070014595985413,
0.6873464584350586,
-0.2394692599773407,
-0.21416117250919342,
0.009603476151823997,
0.42887789011001587,
-0.829179048538208,
-0.5973871946334839,
0.672271192073822,
-0.24273772537708282,
0.22433309257030487,
-0.3311154246330261,
-0.5458908677101135,
-0.32720649242401123,
-0.40386757254600525,
0.18866674602031708,
0.28148743510246277,
-0.36485329270362854,
0.38059908151626587,
0.3231937885284424,
-0.0337434783577919,
-0.6611614227294922,
-0.5232364535331726,
0.15521368384361267,
-0.5085780024528503,
-0.3735952377319336,
0.16108231246471405,
0.3662700057029724,
-0.1585853099822998,
-0.012536723166704178,
-0.35841622948646545,
-0.19958361983299255,
-0.31453022360801697,
-0.2043508142232895,
0.17215390503406525,
-0.04437265917658806,
0.10991749167442322,
-0.07882843911647797,
-0.04552194103598595,
0.12617835402488708,
-0.3086720407009125,
0.46608367562294006,
-0.21682323515415192,
-0.3453187048435211,
-0.42302051186561584,
0.29372158646583557,
0.5865077376365662,
-0.3469866216182709,
0.5193243026733398,
1.105421781539917,
-0.16148506104946136,
-0.021358607336878777,
-0.7664318680763245,
0.05715946480631828,
-0.4186513423919678,
0.5204450488090515,
-0.22438599169254303,
-0.7202271819114685,
0.42273619771003723,
0.008853066712617874,
-0.13036814332008362,
0.7120972871780396,
0.47285139560699463,
0.20936109125614166,
1.106755256652832,
0.5083763003349304,
-0.37007761001586914,
0.46502256393432617,
-0.27507302165031433,
0.08229853957891464,
-0.706660807132721,
-0.1508042812347412,
-0.3551993668079376,
-0.16901570558547974,
-0.528793215751648,
-0.3787600100040436,
0.4596607983112335,
-0.21116942167282104,
-0.23628056049346924,
0.05447620898485184,
-0.4620628356933594,
0.35031673312187195,
0.3352952003479004,
-0.11727434396743774,
0.44526243209838867,
0.16263335943222046,
0.3896200656890869,
0.07589629292488098,
-0.4638013243675232,
-0.7699214220046997,
0.9724825024604797,
0.5066357254981995,
0.6211943626403809,
-0.16040818393230438,
0.4389888048171997,
0.428540974855423,
0.7160962820053101,
-0.6002647280693054,
0.4740769565105438,
-0.21081392467021942,
-0.6244628429412842,
0.007543659303337336,
-0.3752981424331665,
-0.8139363527297974,
0.22099368274211884,
0.059539545327425,
-0.47859475016593933,
-0.08857958763837814,
0.23880158364772797,
-0.04961959645152092,
0.40789929032325745,
-0.7668563723564148,
0.9442883133888245,
-0.17109712958335876,
-0.11010625213384628,
0.011675362475216389,
-0.31463250517845154,
0.5675260424613953,
-0.33510342240333557,
0.4448104798793793,
-0.2794325351715088,
-0.27476581931114197,
0.8635676503181458,
0.11121617257595062,
0.7246970534324646,
-0.12349572032690048,
-0.3457885682582855,
0.2148543745279312,
-0.17504075169563293,
0.609978437423706,
-0.06092797964811325,
0.13135188817977905,
0.1878904104232788,
-0.14952075481414795,
-0.3665968179702759,
-0.21173128485679626,
0.7605369687080383,
-0.7538180351257324,
-0.5833457112312317,
-0.5758938789367676,
-0.46445319056510925,
-0.01654989644885063,
0.2652439475059509,
0.64510178565979,
0.4990549683570862,
-0.10625872761011124,
-0.008359532803297043,
0.5626132488250732,
-0.1104835495352745,
0.2758553922176361,
0.42373204231262207,
-0.23099716007709503,
-0.31396958231925964,
0.9809832572937012,
0.40800940990448,
0.2555958032608032,
0.11152574419975281,
0.10588488727807999,
-0.42330560088157654,
-0.6988486647605896,
-0.3808458745479584,
0.3979651927947998,
-0.6538895964622498,
-0.16410543024539948,
-0.4288344085216522,
-0.0052558546885848045,
-0.1442323625087738,
-0.053445182740688324,
-0.38133934140205383,
-0.03535103425383568,
-0.24330849945545197,
-0.1947793960571289,
0.28332722187042236,
0.9064232707023621,
-0.1215164065361023,
0.521097719669342,
-0.46247342228889465,
0.4951070547103882,
0.04132893681526184,
0.3838433027267456,
-0.6607507467269897,
-0.5102487206459045,
-0.5082775354385376,
-0.05566655099391937,
-0.40273532271385193,
-1.1192165613174438,
0.5742104053497314,
0.059470321983098984,
0.3598572909832001,
0.6015045046806335,
-0.050751086324453354,
0.42305824160575867,
-0.5797441601753235,
0.9656988978385925,
-0.13228139281272888,
-0.715747058391571,
0.1743878424167633,
-0.6271822452545166,
0.07893260568380356,
0.0614386647939682,
0.714719831943512,
-0.40983596444129944,
-0.6390628218650818,
-0.5474055409431458,
-0.635216474533081,
0.5540937781333923,
0.26092293858528137,
0.14759179949760437,
-0.47176817059516907,
0.186642587184906,
0.06997030228376389,
0.11431729048490524,
-0.8868729472160339,
0.02145317569375038,
-0.4274660646915436,
-0.19007116556167603,
-0.09793228656053543,
-0.3772831857204437,
-0.24683265388011932,
0.16810937225818634,
0.7078719139099121,
-0.2044186294078827,
0.35762590169906616,
0.2840283215045929,
-0.1012786477804184,
-0.11291738599538803,
0.23167161643505096,
0.6480439901351929,
0.7342877388000488,
0.09556184709072113,
0.35130739212036133,
0.010887164622545242,
-0.735190212726593,
0.0022772233933210373,
0.3381305932998657,
-0.00945900846272707,
0.15883807837963104,
0.6111778616905212,
0.664117157459259,
0.16604435443878174,
-0.4188668131828308,
0.6837336421012878,
0.0990588590502739,
-0.46893739700317383,
-0.6178567409515381,
-0.19784240424633026,
-0.1706065684556961,
0.43434426188468933,
0.7189076542854309,
-0.09134304523468018,
0.102935791015625,
-0.44613245129585266,
0.32144826650619507,
0.5678020715713501,
-0.06018685922026634,
-0.6364142298698425,
0.5957570672035217,
-0.01392589882016182,
-0.0164143405854702,
0.3636764883995056,
-0.11970777064561844,
-0.779481053352356,
0.3778056204319,
0.5257557034492493,
0.4061463475227356,
-0.30982252955436707,
0.54151451587677,
0.01001085713505745,
0.6504148840904236,
-0.5423534512519836,
0.07495318353176117,
0.4223528206348419,
-0.8341043591499329,
-0.6834356188774109,
-0.5224593877792358,
-0.1948675662279129,
0.7903414368629456,
-0.5138238072395325,
0.11418037116527557,
-0.10210642218589783,
-0.07719346880912781,
0.1396147459745407,
0.1392388641834259,
-0.5007991194725037,
0.16718000173568726,
0.5182440876960754,
0.8604468703269958,
-1.444059133529663,
0.8573400974273682,
0.4969644546508789,
-0.3626188039779663,
-0.6916102170944214,
0.26870056986808777,
0.2497311234474182,
-0.6472183465957642,
0.40209946036338806,
0.4557674825191498,
0.040843259543180466,
0.15187615156173706,
-0.7246390581130981,
-0.7443845868110657,
0.7483639121055603,
0.34100401401519775,
-0.1477614790201187,
-0.17992627620697021,
0.20405535399913788,
0.5129995346069336,
-0.3076973855495453,
-0.05787979066371918,
0.8546836972236633,
0.8159486055374146,
-0.18041157722473145,
-0.8115027546882629,
-0.2184567153453827,
0.023645058274269104,
-0.19752274453639984,
0.32427114248275757,
-0.607878565788269,
1.0237585306167603,
0.4261058568954468,
-0.14626272022724152,
-0.05912347882986069,
0.5040004849433899,
0.04017991945147514,
0.39909791946411133,
0.5050404071807861,
0.4352436065673828,
0.42567160725593567,
-0.2925194203853607,
1.0614057779312134,
-0.17448385059833527,
0.3641396164894104,
0.5187983512878418,
-0.034511104226112366,
0.5762015581130981,
0.39648303389549255,
0.08359631896018982,
0.503566563129425,
0.5675970315933228,
-0.20535989105701447,
0.4487290680408478,
-0.17949871718883514,
-0.4901542067527771,
-0.05704926326870918,
0.08945277333259583,
0.013653848320245743,
0.4753049612045288,
0.6899173259735107,
-0.5649471282958984,
-0.413640558719635,
0.37660908699035645,
0.48359283804893494,
0.048031557351350784,
-0.4779135584831238,
0.4579337239265442,
-0.1049904152750969,
-0.7392163872718811,
0.5631337761878967,
0.09502887725830078,
0.572854220867157,
-0.7796819806098938,
-0.026548603549599648,
-0.11024057865142822,
0.18801337480545044,
-0.12398959696292877,
-0.8520599603652954,
0.41858741641044617,
0.077776700258255,
0.08855870366096497,
-0.21124687790870667,
0.9638203382492065,
-0.5414600372314453,
-0.2761684060096741,
-0.0035228251945227385,
0.5814778208732605,
0.2515614330768585,
-0.27462342381477356,
-0.47631537914276123,
0.4843118488788605,
0.06844580173492432,
-0.7002277374267578,
0.39664018154144287,
0.5445812940597534,
-0.2771978974342346,
0.5205858945846558,
0.6219581961631775,
0.13508488237857819,
-0.025219477713108063,
-0.15824970602989197,
0.8950492143630981,
-0.24930919706821442,
-0.2552022635936737,
-0.9861931204795837,
0.07999058812856674,
-0.29944106936454773,
-0.12488660961389542,
1.0003107786178589,
0.6697832345962524,
0.9800832271575928,
-0.16105933487415314,
1.0440181493759155,
-0.008943001739680767,
0.4054478704929352,
-0.5064921379089355,
0.5287860035896301,
-0.2634102702140808,
0.16379182040691376,
-0.2807765603065491,
-0.7695987224578857,
-0.4359387159347534,
0.6705940365791321,
-0.6984987854957581,
-0.12210577726364136,
0.7279849052429199,
0.7010130882263184,
-0.1898023933172226,
-0.11118526756763458,
0.2915555536746979,
0.31649571657180786,
0.46356073021888733,
0.26374638080596924,
0.8972697854042053,
-0.0012533284025266767,
1.0211087465286255,
-0.19894999265670776,
-0.23749513924121857,
-0.08904770016670227,
-0.936670184135437,
-0.90423184633255,
-0.7288907170295715,
-0.10753414034843445,
-0.13120968639850616,
0.16938579082489014,
0.5023975968360901,
0.3943770229816437,
-0.30822423100471497,
0.19736777245998383,
0.018298480659723282,
-0.07180110365152359,
-0.2712472677230835,
-0.22684995830059052,
0.5044004321098328,
-0.3045693635940552,
-0.9382418990135193,
0.3048112988471985,
0.2777128219604492,
-0.09020769596099854,
-0.4763554632663727,
0.1761409044265747,
-0.30892476439476013,
0.18951310217380524,
0.4802987575531006,
0.36939752101898193,
-0.7057530879974365,
-0.7166141271591187,
-0.1773844212293625,
0.07583572715520859,
-0.0327080637216568,
0.688100278377533,
-0.6530709862709045,
0.24680151045322418,
0.18266727030277252,
0.3178061544895172,
0.39276018738746643,
0.3067970275878906,
0.35519152879714966,
-1.0607022047042847,
0.09408687800168991,
0.10313963145017624,
0.2966057360172272,
0.4831984341144562,
-0.32633519172668457,
0.38118669390678406,
0.3744805157184601,
-0.8424155712127686,
-0.6761304140090942,
0.319389671087265,
-0.6801024675369263,
-0.06892877072095871,
1.5136915445327759,
-0.2634170353412628,
-0.20595286786556244,
-0.3879305422306061,
-0.39612114429473877,
0.37013569474220276,
-0.41698378324508667,
0.6921464800834656,
0.8977590203285217,
-0.15932582318782806,
-0.3583270311355591,
-0.8937640190124512,
0.7383118271827698,
-0.14552122354507446,
-0.6279399394989014,
-0.014267200604081154,
0.7946957349777222,
0.5328296422958374,
0.2137179672718048,
0.6417574882507324,
0.0012462146114557981,
0.03586069494485855,
-0.164383202791214,
-0.37047621607780457,
-0.18535126745700836,
-0.2947920560836792,
-0.10554230213165283,
0.35612887144088745,
-0.20977118611335754,
-0.13965022563934326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17463v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17463v2
|
Training-Free Long-Context Scaling of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-27T12:39:23 | 2024-05-29T05:44:58 |
Chenxin An, Fei Huang, Jun Zhang, Shansan Gong, Xipeng Qiu, Chang Zhou, Lingpeng Kong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to process and generate coherent
text is markedly weakened when the number of input tokens exceeds their
pretraining length. Given the expensive overhead of finetuning large-scale
models with longer sequences, we propose Dual Chunk Attention (DCA), which
enables Llama2 70B to support context windows of more than 100k tokens without
continual training. By decomposing the attention computation for long sequences
into chunk-based modules, DCA manages to effectively capture the relative
positional information of tokens within the same chunk (Intra-Chunk) and across
distinct chunks (Inter-Chunk), as well as integrates seamlessly with Flash
Attention. In addition to its impressive extrapolation capability, DCA achieves
performance on practical long-context tasks that is comparable to or even
better than that of finetuned models. When compared with proprietary models,
our training-free 70B model attains 94% of the performance of gpt-3.5-16k,
indicating it is a viable open-source alternative. All code and data used in
this work are released at \url{https://github.com/HKUNLP/ChunkLlama}.
|
[
-0.2771061062812805,
-0.6709014773368835,
0.6389859318733215,
0.531389594078064,
-0.6759850382804871,
-0.18756787478923798,
-0.5150617361068726,
-0.6288865208625793,
0.19455213844776154,
0.42849868535995483,
-0.4461837112903595,
-0.190603107213974,
-0.5884056091308594,
-0.06101042404770851,
-0.5386434197425842,
0.8116769194602966,
0.0007890281267464161,
-0.020366886630654335,
-0.06610139459371567,
-0.06274957954883575,
-0.5292508006095886,
-0.3568738102912903,
-0.8918384909629822,
-0.028819503262639046,
0.7185286283493042,
0.2742363512516022,
0.40687042474746704,
0.7714239954948425,
0.43196216225624084,
0.2605220079421997,
-0.33344000577926636,
0.05105876550078392,
-0.553022563457489,
0.030615314841270447,
-0.22455258667469025,
-0.364265501499176,
-0.8190381526947021,
-0.17971114814281464,
0.8813987970352173,
0.44078874588012695,
0.008337710984051228,
0.3264121413230896,
0.08860006928443909,
0.847274899482727,
-0.4534206986427307,
0.27486222982406616,
-0.8885458111763,
-0.23976144194602966,
-0.3000662624835968,
-0.0005656667053699493,
-0.5210602879524231,
0.17761974036693573,
0.14878065884113312,
-0.4111308157444,
0.13534563779830933,
-0.07150690257549286,
0.558150589466095,
0.43299975991249084,
-0.6590330004692078,
-0.10756540298461914,
-0.42928802967071533,
0.8356688618659973,
-0.600174605846405,
0.22216320037841797,
0.27277320623397827,
0.20737943053245544,
-0.049507420510053635,
-0.5761691927909851,
-0.4100051522254944,
-0.0780278667807579,
0.23883822560310364,
-0.2143847942352295,
-0.03821055218577385,
0.17703649401664734,
0.13579173386096954,
0.4746544361114502,
-0.44444552063941956,
0.18994243443012238,
-0.4720941483974457,
-0.01119988039135933,
0.5297238230705261,
0.011609562672674656,
0.13374216854572296,
0.15654298663139343,
-0.5189098119735718,
-0.03446643427014351,
-0.9163128137588501,
-0.1406628042459488,
0.13806188106536865,
0.49358069896698,
-0.3717277944087982,
0.44143810868263245,
-0.2565575838088989,
0.7491331100463867,
0.33893021941185,
-0.02681613713502884,
0.09719991683959961,
-0.2807864546775818,
-0.47481945157051086,
0.11426272243261337,
0.637834370136261,
0.19537782669067383,
0.15260092914104462,
-0.26103514432907104,
-0.11916244029998779,
-0.011523202061653137,
0.3545801341533661,
-0.8718796968460083,
0.194291889667511,
0.5007281303405762,
-0.12145448476076126,
0.006806476972997189,
-0.26150643825531006,
-0.7618662118911743,
-0.23131242394447327,
-0.5751673579216003,
0.19511522352695465,
-0.07993953675031662,
-0.3340606689453125,
-0.018292032182216644,
0.1747240424156189,
0.20377254486083984,
0.43760260939598083,
-1.0860689878463745,
0.0151382926851511,
0.8042846918106079,
1.0757092237472534,
-0.35024964809417725,
-0.23506779968738556,
-0.6501321792602539,
0.304936945438385,
-0.33287313580513,
0.8001706600189209,
-0.36376678943634033,
-0.07275344431400299,
-0.017440490424633026,
0.07630960643291473,
0.13652895390987396,
-0.6572920083999634,
0.07468365132808685,
-0.7630653381347656,
-0.202421173453331,
-0.18855425715446472,
-0.3208504617214203,
-0.18951334059238434,
0.21298564970493317,
-0.7275489568710327,
0.9932340383529663,
0.24979962408542633,
-0.6923936605453491,
0.3856833279132843,
-0.4146527051925659,
-0.5759406685829163,
0.0399068184196949,
0.006019434425979853,
-0.09415694326162338,
0.289685994386673,
0.1894340217113495,
0.5719010829925537,
-0.37712404131889343,
0.5003507137298584,
-0.42703545093536377,
-0.38523125648498535,
-0.10253629833459854,
-0.5145881772041321,
0.5019176602363586,
0.04815319553017616,
-0.6035256385803223,
0.4897081255912781,
-0.7981374859809875,
-0.10241539031267166,
0.10201840102672577,
-0.6720690131187439,
-0.3098795413970947,
-0.2144240140914917,
0.27558818459510803,
0.38629570603370667,
0.37269100546836853,
-0.3061542510986328,
0.15659959614276886,
-0.44064319133758545,
0.5158501267433167,
0.9097946882247925,
-0.5384902358055115,
0.42531710863113403,
0.027719363570213318,
0.45187655091285706,
0.22507457435131073,
-0.1476827710866928,
-0.21137188374996185,
-0.24595189094543457,
-0.8845561146736145,
-0.5455005764961243,
0.2128789871931076,
0.1700170785188675,
-0.4153294861316681,
0.5146787762641907,
-0.5067678093910217,
-0.21927446126937866,
-0.45361828804016113,
0.2587748169898987,
0.3297971785068512,
0.2494306117296219,
0.4789304733276367,
-0.7020937204360962,
-0.4753706753253937,
-0.8501948118209839,
0.10239089280366898,
0.026226796209812164,
-0.19155319035053253,
0.15307600796222687,
0.3065633475780487,
-0.20694157481193542,
0.9285446405410767,
-0.2772631347179413,
-0.41987404227256775,
-0.44632604718208313,
-0.20994600653648376,
-0.010295231826603413,
0.28283360600471497,
0.26559069752693176,
-0.6848902702331543,
-0.5679909586906433,
-0.009050731547176838,
-0.4102366864681244,
0.03060324117541313,
-0.08307318389415741,
-0.17843450605869293,
0.46431368589401245,
0.5551560521125793,
-0.6270552277565002,
0.22841483354568481,
0.9411800503730774,
-0.3536017835140228,
0.4607868194580078,
-0.09785207360982895,
-0.23499415814876556,
-1.4279145002365112,
0.3636913001537323,
0.021679053083062172,
-0.5404656529426575,
-0.5634446144104004,
0.22520819306373596,
0.4680896997451782,
0.11742629110813141,
-0.77568519115448,
0.812958300113678,
-0.700588583946228,
-0.17524681985378265,
-0.5942760109901428,
0.31412118673324585,
-0.10445640236139297,
0.6290891170501709,
0.24080964922904968,
0.9090238213539124,
0.4336218535900116,
-0.567631721496582,
0.2167709469795227,
-0.1620146632194519,
-0.4928622245788574,
0.41959431767463684,
-0.7271808981895447,
0.31002265214920044,
-0.10136646032333374,
0.626981794834137,
-0.9916685819625854,
-0.41875848174095154,
-0.09299764782190323,
0.05056115612387657,
0.6894809007644653,
-0.20506742596626282,
-0.4384286105632782,
-0.38659408688545227,
-0.3709792196750641,
0.7832732200622559,
0.3543549180030823,
-0.7218814492225647,
0.3466702401638031,
0.512527346611023,
-0.20178665220737457,
-0.6986427903175354,
-0.6822282671928406,
0.2174796760082245,
-0.32047387957572937,
-0.541276752948761,
0.10989228636026382,
-0.13287633657455444,
-0.08509226143360138,
-0.3097228705883026,
-0.15669234097003937,
-0.14804208278656006,
-0.02430051565170288,
0.2831374704837799,
0.16880396008491516,
-0.1554141789674759,
0.12881998717784882,
0.183290034532547,
0.029011892154812813,
-0.10620175302028656,
-0.3562728762626648,
0.8994200229644775,
-0.011571657843887806,
-0.083293616771698,
-0.5498303174972534,
0.38292285799980164,
0.7850243449211121,
-0.202515110373497,
0.8312748670578003,
0.49074381589889526,
-0.2527667284011841,
-0.28834623098373413,
-0.6080968976020813,
0.008284689858555794,
-0.4878690242767334,
0.7315000891685486,
-0.25689399242401123,
-1.1593807935714722,
0.3824545443058014,
0.18123508989810944,
-0.0027602945920079947,
0.4354570508003235,
0.9107494950294495,
0.43709152936935425,
0.7641496658325195,
0.7862938642501831,
-0.485440194606781,
0.5693625211715698,
-0.03408633545041084,
-0.04352244734764099,
-1.1844013929367065,
-0.027228476479649544,
-0.17733411490917206,
-0.2878207564353943,
-0.04612097889184952,
-0.8993783593177795,
0.15478743612766266,
0.04679849371314049,
-0.15795858204364777,
0.31223446130752563,
-0.4581568241119385,
0.6510651111602783,
0.4078643321990967,
-0.11881858855485916,
0.2437441200017929,
0.013884483836591244,
0.15365146100521088,
0.38743680715560913,
-0.4251427948474884,
-0.37806129455566406,
1.220797061920166,
0.5306190252304077,
0.7384974360466003,
0.03703365474939346,
0.4293108284473419,
-0.04577241092920303,
0.44789910316467285,
-0.9735830426216125,
0.5404913425445557,
-0.10172572731971741,
-0.8521140813827515,
-0.38219884037971497,
-0.4267781674861908,
-0.7605571150779724,
0.4917686879634857,
0.48266130685806274,
-0.7494761347770691,
-0.19426260888576508,
0.24742069840431213,
-0.38900837302207947,
0.3693045973777771,
-0.6706770658493042,
0.731108546257019,
0.08012991398572922,
-0.4132833182811737,
-0.5056201815605164,
-0.7001605033874512,
0.5623406767845154,
-0.3477543294429779,
0.17520390450954437,
-0.33021074533462524,
-0.09929937869310379,
0.7286815643310547,
-0.09352052211761475,
1.129259705543518,
-0.07101795077323914,
-0.6121647357940674,
0.4877999722957611,
-0.1293698102235794,
0.5633114576339722,
0.18727648258209229,
0.23822717368602753,
0.14515557885169983,
0.0016297014662995934,
-0.5165127515792847,
-0.04530609771609306,
0.8508139848709106,
-0.5676233768463135,
-0.6125357151031494,
-0.3936273753643036,
-0.9078947901725769,
-0.24980191886425018,
0.30690982937812805,
-0.029572386294603348,
0.46602287888526917,
-0.11791098862886429,
0.27537739276885986,
0.5746368169784546,
0.07218607515096664,
0.6233952045440674,
0.39095115661621094,
-0.03995540738105774,
-0.3801749646663666,
0.5953460335731506,
0.060023605823516846,
0.48067110776901245,
0.4906156063079834,
-0.11575780063867569,
-0.35271644592285156,
-0.572959840297699,
-0.6812761425971985,
0.4630557894706726,
-0.5907844305038452,
-0.31219246983528137,
-0.6673246026039124,
0.01902436651289463,
-0.512712299823761,
-0.028556281700730324,
-0.5521936416625977,
-0.3569715917110443,
-0.4797767996788025,
0.0004108409339096397,
0.03695838153362274,
0.7324172854423523,
0.08320958912372589,
0.28434163331985474,
-0.6883475184440613,
0.20301975309848785,
0.5295953154563904,
0.3439386785030365,
0.45902344584465027,
-0.6791770458221436,
-0.5764404535293579,
-0.06861267983913422,
-0.24972465634346008,
-0.48513472080230713,
0.41046038269996643,
0.022327451035380363,
-0.054057277739048004,
0.4774566888809204,
-0.25124356150627136,
0.767428457736969,
-0.7967430353164673,
0.8532159924507141,
0.3259374797344208,
-0.970393717288971,
0.17679060995578766,
-0.5014830231666565,
0.749197244644165,
0.5489354729652405,
0.15325069427490234,
-0.6061742305755615,
-0.39253735542297363,
-0.17191046476364136,
-1.10470712184906,
0.9444694519042969,
-0.30320245027542114,
0.32453250885009766,
-0.1845972239971161,
0.4447559416294098,
0.1253790259361267,
0.12913595139980316,
-0.6617108583450317,
0.023593734949827194,
0.11017730832099915,
-0.39747047424316406,
-0.317952036857605,
-0.6816669702529907,
-0.22964546084403992,
-0.07936354726552963,
0.6445788145065308,
-0.5142458081245422,
0.19473223388195038,
0.12018068879842758,
-0.2565709352493286,
-0.17046219110488892,
0.30163541436195374,
0.8268826603889465,
0.7842687368392944,
-0.07455474138259888,
0.34537070989608765,
0.24342888593673706,
-0.6318683624267578,
0.2090791016817093,
0.014329595491290092,
0.040108129382133484,
-0.41435813903808594,
0.34253939986228943,
0.7179158329963684,
0.29091426730155945,
-0.899273157119751,
0.38492679595947266,
-0.035595428198575974,
0.04868113994598389,
-0.15799887478351593,
-0.1133742406964302,
0.4538221061229706,
0.3309207260608673,
0.3725346326828003,
-0.4449034333229065,
-0.031284645199775696,
-0.529361367225647,
0.1611941009759903,
0.48808082938194275,
-0.6707454323768616,
-0.6782296895980835,
0.8093959093093872,
0.2681082785129547,
0.17128753662109375,
0.5295798182487488,
0.004059650003910065,
-0.24437347054481506,
0.7937338948249817,
0.7975730299949646,
0.928141176700592,
-0.11394968628883362,
-0.029194556176662445,
0.26504433155059814,
0.16504831612110138,
-0.3652540445327759,
-0.017120573669672012,
-0.16166388988494873,
-0.318172812461853,
-0.7012444138526917,
-0.8422612547874451,
-0.24708835780620575,
0.32953155040740967,
-0.5775126814842224,
0.13784795999526978,
-0.45948413014411926,
-0.13377486169338226,
-0.2786310315132141,
-0.030056454241275787,
-0.509763240814209,
0.3449477255344391,
0.3920169174671173,
1.0369715690612793,
-0.5113638639450073,
1.2632101774215698,
0.5104430913925171,
-0.08761106431484222,
-0.7646023035049438,
0.10145396739244461,
-0.022056203335523605,
-0.7903856635093689,
0.47456949949264526,
0.7526745796203613,
-0.023474665358662605,
-0.062456704676151276,
-0.3357371389865875,
-1.094366192817688,
1.2037887573242188,
0.4483303129673004,
-0.9146695733070374,
-0.2830915153026581,
0.003688654163852334,
0.4085814654827118,
-0.2593678832054138,
-0.004370420705527067,
0.536848783493042,
0.11254379898309708,
0.01079182792454958,
-1.082502841949463,
0.22583188116550446,
0.12933559715747833,
0.04960458725690842,
0.30706799030303955,
-1.2826077938079834,
0.7692942023277283,
-0.1941598355770111,
-0.2705683708190918,
0.09659890830516815,
0.9752398133277893,
0.14602437615394592,
0.05280667915940285,
0.5279104709625244,
0.6716819405555725,
0.5632524490356445,
0.1812983602285385,
1.037135362625122,
-0.3420274257659912,
0.44448891282081604,
1.2804784774780273,
-0.31453973054885864,
1.0658798217773438,
0.7696075439453125,
-0.25487497448921204,
0.3211687207221985,
0.6363275051116943,
0.4761541485786438,
0.5889626145362854,
0.27286168932914734,
-0.38509270548820496,
-0.16369369626045227,
-0.01721942238509655,
-0.38287442922592163,
0.19143350422382355,
0.10562330484390259,
-0.31181827187538147,
-0.019933389499783516,
-0.21715499460697174,
0.1367311328649521,
-0.3771273195743561,
-0.4662140905857086,
0.6316490173339844,
0.3907128572463989,
-0.7310904860496521,
0.6364662051200867,
0.10530418157577515,
0.8808040618896484,
-0.7685737609863281,
0.42675355076789856,
-0.3791691064834595,
0.29980844259262085,
0.06294452399015427,
-0.3633406460285187,
0.31136152148246765,
0.1508236974477768,
-0.2944333553314209,
-0.02010492794215679,
0.32786825299263,
-0.7223408818244934,
-0.3716253340244293,
0.4049380123615265,
0.02535228431224823,
0.05502401664853096,
-0.4471292197704315,
-0.2777997851371765,
0.2102234661579132,
-0.08057332038879395,
-0.6052769422531128,
0.8564324378967285,
0.3253669738769531,
-0.11196906119585037,
0.619694173336029,
0.445273220539093,
0.020686697214841843,
0.2591204345226288,
-0.0071620699018239975,
0.9323559403419495,
-0.627804696559906,
-0.5524991154670715,
-0.8944421410560608,
0.3826447129249573,
0.1646534502506256,
-0.2392806112766266,
0.5728976130485535,
0.5850203037261963,
0.7442797422409058,
-0.0583987757563591,
0.5764330625534058,
0.07563918083906174,
0.14165127277374268,
-0.5620490908622742,
0.6430202722549438,
-0.7149316668510437,
-0.11243123561143875,
0.018728386610746384,
-1.0716067552566528,
-0.3479236662387848,
0.1995835155248642,
-0.20381714403629303,
-0.0221567265689373,
0.7252313494682312,
0.5487923622131348,
-0.29304346442222595,
-0.30638816952705383,
0.3776487112045288,
0.12036421149969101,
0.44695141911506653,
0.8725393414497375,
0.454572856426239,
-0.16176852583885193,
0.5044217705726624,
-0.07928863167762756,
-0.3122197091579437,
-0.3056367039680481,
-0.7800152897834778,
-1.0775291919708252,
-0.4599206745624542,
-0.1480586677789688,
-0.22319377958774567,
-0.22364774346351624,
0.9031206965446472,
1.0124144554138184,
-0.7951192259788513,
-0.25141921639442444,
0.05575447157025337,
-0.1422262191772461,
-0.10884279012680054,
-0.2020965814590454,
0.6081782579421997,
-0.5529006123542786,
-1.094580888748169,
0.7584049701690674,
0.5289573669433594,
0.1349039524793625,
-0.5250675082206726,
0.09480014443397522,
-0.020086169242858887,
0.3342558741569519,
0.8241316676139832,
0.1263311356306076,
-0.7353397011756897,
-0.3295104205608368,
-0.3422659933567047,
-0.24735216796398163,
0.09937601536512375,
0.7300698161125183,
-0.6046028137207031,
0.3448345363140106,
0.3231635093688965,
0.6809921264648438,
0.5359764695167542,
0.10129448026418686,
0.5106906294822693,
-0.7965218424797058,
0.6546294689178467,
-0.056900374591350555,
0.18560023605823517,
0.43965160846710205,
-0.3674018383026123,
0.4101862609386444,
-0.02992013469338417,
-0.5867884159088135,
-0.9289848804473877,
0.20040009915828705,
-1.3406569957733154,
-0.24960243701934814,
1.5795798301696777,
-0.17958012223243713,
-0.49315345287323,
0.06298010796308517,
-0.2599230110645294,
0.20116005837917328,
-0.5702062845230103,
0.832234263420105,
0.6926813125610352,
0.2795410454273224,
0.13101935386657715,
-0.4301953613758087,
0.41204744577407837,
0.49543049931526184,
-0.8167886137962341,
0.4658016264438629,
0.4471128284931183,
0.415935218334198,
-0.03152533248066902,
0.860385537147522,
-0.127888485789299,
0.09514911472797394,
-0.09410469979047775,
-0.004226893186569214,
-0.07587108761072159,
-0.657168984413147,
-0.6320297718048096,
0.42739835381507874,
0.1816420555114746,
0.030076611787080765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17456v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17456v1
|
A Piece of Theatre: Investigating How Teachers Design LLM Chatbots to Assist Adolescent Cyberbullying Education
| 2024-02-27T12:27:51 | 2024-02-27T12:27:51 |
Michael A. Hedderich, Natalie N. Bazarova, Wenting Zou, Ryun Shim, Xinda Ma, Qian Yang
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Cyberbullying harms teenagers' mental health, and teaching them upstanding
intervention is crucial. Wizard-of-Oz studies show chatbots can scale up
personalized and interactive cyberbullying education, but implementing such
chatbots is a challenging and delicate task. We created a no-code chatbot
design tool for K-12 teachers. Using large language models and prompt chaining,
our tool allows teachers to prototype bespoke dialogue flows and chatbot
utterances. In offering this tool, we explore teachers' distinctive needs when
designing chatbots to assist their teaching, and how chatbot design tools might
better support them. Our findings reveal that teachers welcome the tool
enthusiastically. Moreover, they see themselves as playwrights guiding both the
students' and the chatbot's behaviors, while allowing for some improvisation.
Their goal is to enable students to rehearse both desirable and undesirable
reactions to cyberbullying in a safe environment. We discuss the design
opportunities LLM-Chains offer for empowering teachers and the research
opportunities this work opens up.
|
[
-0.23040442168712616,
-0.8879682421684265,
0.25846269726753235,
0.23839904367923737,
-0.16414955258369446,
0.7187755107879639,
0.08852941542863846,
-0.15873827040195465,
0.4118390679359436,
0.5749255418777466,
-0.5834034085273743,
-0.26579341292381287,
-0.5494886636734009,
-0.015600841492414474,
-0.6994800567626953,
0.915988028049469,
0.14134445786476135,
0.21597912907600403,
-0.22119353711605072,
0.5827094912528992,
-0.6409698128700256,
-0.03685503453016281,
-0.7735592126846313,
-0.17255036532878876,
0.7094584703445435,
0.8261330723762512,
0.6311813592910767,
0.04918624088168144,
0.5521995425224304,
0.4069160521030426,
0.12315066903829575,
0.027767568826675415,
-0.7742172479629517,
0.26632559299468994,
-0.37509986758232117,
-0.47086191177368164,
-0.20584484934806824,
-0.22383852303028107,
0.3194289803504944,
0.42527833580970764,
-0.0885627269744873,
-0.1214347630739212,
0.2891409695148468,
0.3117409646511078,
-0.27196744084358215,
-0.29322734475135803,
-0.4102136492729187,
0.48842933773994446,
0.16846725344657898,
-0.14753387868404388,
-0.26435285806655884,
-0.6918118000030518,
-0.10369595140218735,
-0.499137818813324,
-0.31445735692977905,
0.0046347202733159065,
0.4003210961818695,
0.17875513434410095,
-0.502142608165741,
-0.3479149639606476,
-0.7944841980934143,
0.2868332266807556,
-0.3795221149921417,
0.020346641540527344,
0.37955284118652344,
0.5001456141471863,
-0.42063742876052856,
-0.8385573029518127,
-0.3127111792564392,
0.03290492296218872,
0.14765532314777374,
0.1892792135477066,
-0.16003447771072388,
0.3645463287830353,
0.014769886620342731,
0.4199606776237488,
-0.583755612373352,
0.392640084028244,
-0.7670437693595886,
-0.2680390477180481,
0.575475811958313,
0.4381944537162781,
0.49943339824676514,
-0.1664716601371765,
-0.4456087052822113,
-0.10435811430215836,
-0.5304268002510071,
0.11940028518438339,
0.4758678078651428,
0.20195849239826202,
-0.45665067434310913,
0.46589896082878113,
0.19675876200199127,
0.40914425253868103,
0.018731802701950073,
-0.3088085353374481,
-0.4482404589653015,
-0.028859933838248253,
-0.046460725367069244,
0.27851399779319763,
0.9097049832344055,
0.6978126168251038,
0.5459466576576233,
-0.13575966656208038,
0.01401269156485796,
0.3153322637081146,
0.6075804233551025,
-0.9795588254928589,
-0.554793655872345,
0.1372915655374527,
-0.06602557003498077,
-0.764664888381958,
-0.19863872230052948,
-0.8992114663124084,
-0.8837927579879761,
-0.11885835230350494,
0.8186007738113403,
-0.2990274727344513,
-0.36453089118003845,
-0.26883506774902344,
-0.47069862484931946,
-0.3024860620498657,
0.10028401762247086,
-0.7646514773368835,
0.4717029333114624,
0.5723301768302917,
0.7716224789619446,
0.16502745449543,
-0.015870312228798866,
-0.16108225286006927,
-0.230177640914917,
-0.5540978312492371,
0.7681103944778442,
-0.8195527791976929,
-0.7853887677192688,
0.07940151542425156,
0.15506309270858765,
0.07528553158044815,
-0.34546276926994324,
0.31631097197532654,
-0.0007276892429217696,
0.22153343260288239,
0.5915787220001221,
-0.5080527663230896,
0.17682744562625885,
0.2003365457057953,
-0.2509269118309021,
0.44879263639450073,
-0.02291073463857174,
-0.31988829374313354,
-0.10002855956554413,
-0.4847024083137512,
-0.45287635922431946,
0.17842356860637665,
-0.2509159743785858,
-0.08636961877346039,
0.17004184424877167,
0.18242545425891876,
0.33701324462890625,
-0.2850528359413147,
0.1274442821741104,
-0.30150070786476135,
-0.6585760712623596,
0.5887169241905212,
-0.35929128527641296,
0.5961778163909912,
0.11638019979000092,
-0.016612738370895386,
0.2740546464920044,
-0.5581446290016174,
0.1995747983455658,
0.08353623747825623,
0.04052908346056938,
0.13854975998401642,
-0.06705846637487411,
0.13098302483558655,
0.3839249908924103,
-0.03723035007715225,
-0.4673548638820648,
0.02823791839182377,
-0.29513078927993774,
0.49244993925094604,
1.0670135021209717,
0.011955632828176022,
0.278469979763031,
-0.8257486820220947,
1.0647215843200684,
-0.2429570108652115,
0.3016495406627655,
-0.17104534804821014,
-0.3971644639968872,
-0.5026261210441589,
-0.30588287115097046,
0.10968682169914246,
0.5557907819747925,
-0.8319053649902344,
0.031054195016622543,
0.1072477474808693,
-0.6846743822097778,
-0.8576867580413818,
0.0955968052148819,
0.3578532934188843,
0.36172497272491455,
-0.19134345650672913,
-0.5063463449478149,
-0.8355779647827148,
-0.642629086971283,
-0.1334168016910553,
-0.1524922251701355,
-0.24803033471107483,
0.2563934028148651,
0.13547611236572266,
0.15917982161045074,
0.8366006016731262,
-0.31467410922050476,
-0.28713053464889526,
-0.12583528459072113,
-0.030821021646261215,
0.18362171947956085,
0.3487388789653778,
0.24924252927303314,
-0.5296042561531067,
-0.7946360111236572,
-0.17818668484687805,
-0.5852047204971313,
-0.3714107871055603,
-0.10797477513551712,
-0.011042920872569084,
-0.360580712556839,
0.3416993319988251,
-0.34099242091178894,
0.5761072635650635,
0.5604882836341858,
-0.29513153433799744,
0.5803035497665405,
0.08783760666847229,
0.18926310539245605,
-0.7920161485671997,
-0.16551421582698822,
-0.23642760515213013,
-0.3081366717815399,
-0.9502744078636169,
-0.16996625065803528,
-0.400823175907135,
-0.723166286945343,
-0.7085962295532227,
0.4113224446773529,
0.03837545961141586,
0.23660044372081757,
-0.7254610061645508,
0.8192770481109619,
-0.10148738324642181,
0.3891752064228058,
-0.1600356101989746,
0.592348039150238,
0.6342145204544067,
-0.7221847772598267,
0.4953811764717102,
0.19015754759311676,
-0.3567010760307312,
1.2540074586868286,
-0.7187174558639526,
0.36431995034217834,
0.08737952262163162,
0.2474619448184967,
-1.153266191482544,
-0.23138569295406342,
0.5996952652931213,
-0.7217710018157959,
0.05345843732357025,
-0.28912267088890076,
-0.5465690493583679,
-0.7218818664550781,
-0.26488959789276123,
-0.13613057136535645,
0.3700794577598572,
-0.37610000371932983,
0.180694118142128,
0.9690840840339661,
-0.2540139853954315,
-0.19204501807689667,
-0.60822993516922,
0.2867254316806793,
-0.3666518032550812,
-0.6485428214073181,
0.48435381054878235,
-0.46813488006591797,
-0.24750089645385742,
-0.12217117100954056,
-0.1582069844007492,
-0.363138347864151,
0.36056968569755554,
0.5705116987228394,
0.005498962011188269,
0.05150304734706879,
0.13514123857021332,
0.015018829144537449,
-0.08158273994922638,
0.16570250689983368,
0.12089552730321884,
0.7255670428276062,
0.22768165171146393,
-0.1446996033191681,
-0.6507709622383118,
0.18058475852012634,
0.2987036108970642,
0.4588336944580078,
0.2235526442527771,
0.6040872931480408,
-0.33625808358192444,
-0.13077613711357117,
-0.24250398576259613,
-0.4323071241378784,
-0.5664076209068298,
-0.04603787511587143,
-0.04170902445912361,
-1.191581130027771,
0.1191708967089653,
-0.22929511964321136,
0.08525782078504562,
-0.3665434718132019,
0.5508800745010376,
-0.3022237718105316,
0.6540755033493042,
0.37078818678855896,
0.13812491297721863,
0.6451520323753357,
0.10019930452108383,
0.38886070251464844,
-0.5467584133148193,
-0.099677175283432,
-0.15250030159950256,
-0.7657578587532043,
-0.6348878741264343,
-0.10116998106241226,
0.40875089168548584,
-0.2229813188314438,
-0.3057604134082794,
0.414657324552536,
-0.7141596674919128,
0.5259596705436707,
0.4266318678855896,
0.34088999032974243,
-0.06916320323944092,
-0.19598035514354706,
-0.1153397485613823,
0.028795655816793442,
-0.5860827565193176,
-0.4743204712867737,
0.8343133926391602,
0.15006664395332336,
0.8962924480438232,
0.46149367094039917,
0.7254924178123474,
0.25183790922164917,
0.06446363776922226,
-0.5894029140472412,
0.6688445210456848,
0.14734597504138947,
-0.95694500207901,
-0.3440690338611603,
-0.06543630361557007,
-1.2212474346160889,
0.4528231918811798,
-0.3029612898826599,
-1.0949876308441162,
-0.20091310143470764,
0.05127366632223129,
-0.456732839345932,
0.2870248258113861,
-0.7012168765068054,
0.7729767560958862,
0.06911742687225342,
-0.6943295001983643,
-0.480891615152359,
-0.5773099064826965,
0.26614752411842346,
-0.016759412363171577,
0.4736882448196411,
0.04622996971011162,
0.3560660481452942,
0.5158804059028625,
-0.5495632290840149,
1.4884846210479736,
0.13714538514614105,
-0.12088586390018463,
0.7449427843093872,
0.4621695876121521,
0.22291134297847748,
-0.20763874053955078,
0.12592431902885437,
-0.5646256804466248,
0.07947922497987747,
-0.20428180694580078,
-0.5778049826622009,
0.8963457942008972,
-0.609725832939148,
-0.9550758004188538,
-0.15949039161205292,
-0.40618330240249634,
-0.03730234131217003,
0.04109884798526764,
-0.3028406798839569,
0.24547654390335083,
-0.180044025182724,
0.4841327369213104,
0.3018280267715454,
-0.06991515308618546,
0.6636106967926025,
0.4045000970363617,
-0.5333610773086548,
-0.6532997488975525,
1.0940781831741333,
0.07601408660411835,
0.21325670182704926,
0.34792259335517883,
0.4656199812889099,
-0.1938820481300354,
0.172074556350708,
-0.23060840368270874,
-0.17863129079341888,
-0.48565420508384705,
-0.18866126239299774,
-0.34490424394607544,
-0.44691002368927,
-0.4773070514202118,
-0.5545492768287659,
-0.008620933629572392,
-0.5663673281669617,
-0.32724490761756897,
-0.35374850034713745,
0.6185774207115173,
0.9163496494293213,
-0.6036831140518188,
0.8561875224113464,
-0.5299581289291382,
0.08539928495883942,
0.6761531233787537,
0.24700190126895905,
0.18320046365261078,
-0.6633779406547546,
-0.1440805047750473,
-0.31540536880493164,
-1.0957268476486206,
-0.8928322196006775,
0.41263920068740845,
-0.006173199974000454,
0.09618520736694336,
0.48490145802497864,
0.22824285924434662,
0.6270140409469604,
-0.5532315373420715,
0.8542554378509521,
0.4313175082206726,
-0.6201885938644409,
0.4946194589138031,
-0.27253851294517517,
0.16312354803085327,
0.08976482599973679,
0.4557797312736511,
-1.0910332202911377,
-0.46229708194732666,
-0.8063092827796936,
-0.5202681422233582,
0.7287212610244751,
0.17009671032428741,
0.5473782420158386,
-0.09844927489757538,
-0.38919198513031006,
0.03138675540685654,
0.7355794906616211,
-0.5976712107658386,
-0.29921022057533264,
-0.25761616230010986,
-0.21260733902454376,
0.1171475276350975,
-0.3864278793334961,
-0.35045135021209717,
0.22721002995967865,
0.3934566080570221,
0.1424771398305893,
0.27139320969581604,
-0.17882351577281952,
0.012113851495087147,
-0.18106715381145477,
0.3181430995464325,
0.3637629449367523,
0.5260488390922546,
0.15300004184246063,
0.3794715702533722,
0.14937493205070496,
-0.3918171525001526,
0.22704418003559113,
-0.3253343999385834,
0.39025554060935974,
-0.20852454006671906,
0.004937283229082823,
0.7375098466873169,
0.6185435056686401,
-0.701721727848053,
0.5257344245910645,
0.04652821645140648,
-0.1766027957201004,
-0.45963969826698303,
0.41093847155570984,
0.13716979324817657,
0.5505725145339966,
-0.018963675945997238,
-0.5074028968811035,
0.010609732940793037,
-0.4793913960456848,
0.5162565112113953,
0.14952081441879272,
-0.494394987821579,
-0.3442275822162628,
0.5205267667770386,
0.3846913278102875,
-1.260272741317749,
0.46953386068344116,
0.06698182225227356,
-0.3386934697628021,
0.5690987706184387,
0.8631468415260315,
0.7411780953407288,
-0.35533109307289124,
0.7954823970794678,
-0.006676367949694395,
0.17948344349861145,
0.5878371000289917,
0.21226516366004944,
0.048365917056798935,
-0.41761454939842224,
-0.04227564111351967,
0.025870315730571747,
-0.866962194442749,
0.00803012028336525,
0.003288552165031433,
0.4475727081298828,
-0.9912410378456116,
-0.21566618978977203,
-0.1578679382801056,
-0.13961338996887207,
-0.4399483799934387,
0.251393586397171,
0.19611965119838715,
0.3477071523666382,
-0.5026023983955383,
0.2879195511341095,
0.3800555169582367,
-0.27376487851142883,
-0.24382904171943665,
-0.36071857810020447,
0.5986831784248352,
-0.9236319661140442,
0.3305874466896057,
0.07774277776479721,
0.15043020248413086,
0.1068163588643074,
-0.5876038074493408,
-0.576752245426178,
0.8312767148017883,
0.024958431720733643,
-0.5876982808113098,
0.07813294231891632,
0.525296151638031,
0.6797229647636414,
-0.3664223253726959,
0.7384012937545776,
0.01868588849902153,
0.17648561298847198,
0.3338872194290161,
-0.8065735697746277,
-0.19505047798156738,
-0.09319762140512466,
-0.16748546063899994,
0.12572599947452545,
-0.7939900159835815,
0.27946868538856506,
0.056049346923828125,
-0.25454702973365784,
0.14226001501083374,
0.3335767984390259,
0.18648599088191986,
0.2966342866420746,
0.3320516347885132,
0.31559035181999207,
0.8168357610702515,
0.07517340034246445,
0.6264609694480896,
-0.471517950296402,
-0.1548977941274643,
0.9293598532676697,
0.252442866563797,
0.5115450024604797,
0.31231874227523804,
-0.1998300552368164,
0.6219404339790344,
0.5849765539169312,
0.14930200576782227,
0.33106181025505066,
0.963931679725647,
-0.5731610655784607,
-0.23823174834251404,
-0.6759907603263855,
0.024197926744818687,
0.18254803121089935,
0.5194942951202393,
0.03240356594324112,
-0.06905078142881393,
0.25551384687423706,
0.47966471314430237,
0.19098369777202606,
-0.3599655330181122,
0.48863887786865234,
0.5798733830451965,
-0.384124219417572,
0.19251494109630585,
-0.4678068459033966,
0.3966677784919739,
-0.3685143291950226,
0.1414996236562729,
-0.09883909672498703,
0.11415419727563858,
-0.1772432029247284,
-1.0381041765213013,
-0.02844603918492794,
-0.09109368920326233,
0.4193137288093567,
-0.2138405740261078,
0.7450443506240845,
-0.25922465324401855,
-0.47533118724823,
0.026923589408397675,
0.12818150222301483,
0.5381123423576355,
0.31610390543937683,
-0.7375789284706116,
0.25108465552330017,
-0.28992995619773865,
0.31103718280792236,
0.4907223880290985,
0.6437361240386963,
0.20297761261463165,
0.8630285263061523,
0.3954397141933441,
-0.2178608477115631,
-0.2685624957084656,
0.08053924143314362,
0.9048080444335938,
-0.5609286427497864,
-0.27472230792045593,
-0.753863513469696,
1.0211032629013062,
-0.23194535076618195,
-0.35394567251205444,
0.6233212351799011,
0.1957276314496994,
0.6857990026473999,
-0.04552702233195305,
0.43736377358436584,
-0.13340358436107635,
0.5053558945655823,
-0.09107522666454315,
0.5673273801803589,
-0.35301145911216736,
-0.1466587483882904,
-0.5205391645431519,
-0.48583507537841797,
-0.23146028816699982,
0.5909368395805359,
-0.06546490639448166,
-0.13431237637996674,
0.5816158056259155,
0.9626864790916443,
0.31169742345809937,
0.2422838658094406,
0.7889358997344971,
0.19665424525737762,
0.5208286643028259,
0.501794695854187,
1.197453260421753,
-0.28064531087875366,
0.7694618105888367,
-0.40184080600738525,
-0.16791629791259766,
-0.273641437292099,
-0.4917917847633362,
-1.4172509908676147,
-0.39222899079322815,
-0.38279029726982117,
-0.3576848804950714,
0.37547391653060913,
1.0570621490478516,
0.4694381654262543,
-0.3303731083869934,
-0.6454195380210876,
0.031349457800388336,
0.6711417436599731,
0.12869328260421753,
-0.23986247181892395,
-0.2273494154214859,
-0.35372406244277954,
-0.7823801040649414,
0.7515053153038025,
-0.022158917039632797,
0.09271565079689026,
-0.4347403645515442,
0.3343961536884308,
-0.13440914452075958,
0.3045707643032074,
0.703571081161499,
0.17596246302127838,
-0.45535141229629517,
-0.41243332624435425,
-0.14659996330738068,
0.06518664956092834,
-0.061320893466472626,
0.5146197080612183,
-0.5475978851318359,
0.5763232111930847,
0.33914265036582947,
0.591956377029419,
0.2910641133785248,
-0.4177001416683197,
0.5936415195465088,
-0.6984384655952454,
-0.0827992707490921,
0.11590401083230972,
-0.01950312778353691,
0.25160372257232666,
-0.1085517406463623,
0.660716712474823,
0.3032689690589905,
-0.7261508107185364,
-0.9309942722320557,
0.09633253514766693,
-0.41057559847831726,
-0.2247576266527176,
0.7884052991867065,
0.04666983708739281,
-0.33290109038352966,
0.07821924984455109,
-0.6235929131507874,
0.01354662049561739,
-0.4176686108112335,
0.8199904561042786,
0.7708297967910767,
0.20143766701221466,
-0.6358565092086792,
-0.33671119809150696,
0.2870982885360718,
-0.021240416914224625,
-0.36388736963272095,
-0.46578794717788696,
0.16665448248386383,
0.010490466840565205,
-0.04781518876552582,
0.34071919322013855,
0.06493350863456726,
0.1409408450126648,
0.07469726353883743,
0.12411605566740036,
0.26160967350006104,
-0.5851989984512329,
-0.12251927703619003,
0.22600407898426056,
-0.09440533816814423,
-0.18373465538024902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17447v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17447v2
|
Deep Learning Based Named Entity Recognition Models for Recipes
| 2024-02-27T12:03:56 | 2024-06-06T07:41:21 |
Mansi Goel, Ayush Agarwal, Shubham Agrawal, Janak Kapuriya, Akhil Vamshi Konam, Rishabh Gupta, Shrey Rastogi, Niharika, Ganesh Bagler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Food touches our lives through various endeavors, including flavor,
nourishment, health, and sustainability. Recipes are cultural capsules
transmitted across generations via unstructured text. Automated protocols for
recognizing named entities, the building blocks of recipe text, are of immense
value for various applications ranging from information extraction to novel
recipe generation. Named entity recognition is a technique for extracting
information from unstructured or semi-structured data with known labels.
Starting with manually-annotated data of 6,611 ingredient phrases, we created
an augmented dataset of 26,445 phrases cumulatively. Simultaneously, we
systematically cleaned and analyzed ingredient phrases from RecipeDB, the
gold-standard recipe data repository, and annotated them using the Stanford
NER. Based on the analysis, we sampled a subset of 88,526 phrases using a
clustering-based approach while preserving the diversity to create the
machine-annotated dataset. A thorough investigation of NER approaches on these
three datasets involving statistical, fine-tuning of deep learning-based
language models and few-shot prompting on large language models (LLMs) provides
deep insights. We conclude that few-shot prompting on LLMs has abysmal
performance, whereas the fine-tuned spaCy-transformer emerges as the best model
with macro-F1 scores of 95.9%, 96.04%, and 95.71% for the manually-annotated,
augmented, and machine-annotated datasets, respectively.
|
[
-0.2265147566795349,
-0.9411356449127197,
0.4240563213825226,
-0.015070650726556778,
0.08783723413944244,
0.006889153737574816,
-0.2853337228298187,
-0.48907268047332764,
0.14476266503334045,
0.7727283835411072,
-0.5967525839805603,
-0.604408323764801,
-0.6948833465576172,
0.5262681245803833,
-0.45537030696868896,
0.9203735589981079,
-0.1149320900440216,
0.28151947259902954,
0.051527198404073715,
0.042352233082056046,
-0.5602594614028931,
-0.28406932950019836,
-0.7431058883666992,
-0.29057687520980835,
0.5885687470436096,
0.5433517098426819,
0.29350998997688293,
0.7107851505279541,
0.5110158920288086,
0.21591167151927948,
-0.28619760274887085,
0.4785793423652649,
-0.17728397250175476,
0.4105500876903534,
0.06734105944633484,
-0.307168185710907,
-0.21136189997196198,
-0.11338665336370468,
0.37060078978538513,
0.8311227560043335,
0.22301456332206726,
0.20939359068870544,
0.11390427500009537,
0.684072732925415,
-0.40204527974128723,
0.19093438982963562,
-0.8817062377929688,
0.273500919342041,
-0.16425791382789612,
-0.07883298397064209,
-0.3119352161884308,
-0.33887025713920593,
0.23765867948532104,
-0.5359230041503906,
0.23151127994060516,
-0.02707313559949398,
0.7339691519737244,
0.22291800379753113,
-0.2971176505088806,
-0.5384203195571899,
-0.8664900064468384,
0.7979521155357361,
-0.7784504890441895,
0.36002418398857117,
0.3849804103374481,
0.22472220659255981,
-0.7246054410934448,
-0.6796682476997375,
-0.7605524063110352,
-0.16721946001052856,
0.1277061402797699,
-0.1849484145641327,
-0.031682226806879044,
-0.18157722055912018,
0.3575342297554016,
0.31741002202033997,
-0.4040854573249817,
0.5188287496566772,
-0.07190254330635071,
0.1499517858028412,
0.5176100134849548,
0.39816203713417053,
0.3932991623878479,
-0.2827405035495758,
-0.43991634249687195,
0.0673026591539383,
-0.7871645092964172,
0.04942421615123749,
0.007291450630873442,
0.5508397817611694,
0.15376032888889313,
0.6691464185714722,
-0.4110017418861389,
0.7260109186172485,
0.23809216916561127,
-0.19895990192890167,
0.0909094586968422,
-0.1012883260846138,
-0.475673645734787,
0.2119457870721817,
0.8098096251487732,
0.48183760046958923,
0.3745914697647095,
-0.15263287723064423,
-0.11534108966588974,
-0.16615650057792664,
-0.12918981909751892,
-0.8173059821128845,
-0.48890459537506104,
-0.12955377995967865,
-0.19805507361888885,
-0.1620595008134842,
-0.00199852604418993,
-0.6901524066925049,
-0.7836062908172607,
-0.2556021809577942,
0.07579092681407928,
-0.35777321457862854,
-0.0010993669275194407,
-0.205314040184021,
-0.24269960820674896,
0.5449167490005493,
0.32905644178390503,
-1.0791919231414795,
0.43219026923179626,
0.7492333054542542,
0.6402336359024048,
-0.002981716999784112,
-0.21612033247947693,
-0.4559352993965149,
0.16374142467975616,
-0.3870391845703125,
0.9033677577972412,
-0.7874097228050232,
-0.32108813524246216,
-0.3487624526023865,
0.3679075241088867,
-0.061554960906505585,
-0.8474596738815308,
0.4170294404029846,
-0.5060596466064453,
-0.21665485203266144,
-0.6464975476264954,
-1.150006890296936,
-0.2191716879606247,
0.2783430814743042,
-0.8998633623123169,
0.859055757522583,
-0.26919126510620117,
-0.48668214678764343,
0.9325965046882629,
-0.3228745460510254,
-0.6078473329544067,
0.4563024044036865,
-0.4306650757789612,
-0.30521586537361145,
0.28510504961013794,
0.41552993655204773,
0.6725117564201355,
-0.5177971124649048,
0.32220035791397095,
-0.2262386530637741,
-0.24678435921669006,
0.44485965371131897,
-0.6041585803031921,
0.24953757226467133,
0.24854688346385956,
-0.21535907685756683,
-0.08980834484100342,
-0.8214854598045349,
0.023049021139740944,
0.2915964126586914,
-0.37000489234924316,
-0.3687259554862976,
-0.014371920377016068,
0.0926399677991867,
-0.08289873600006104,
-0.24088917672634125,
-0.3534599840641022,
0.3239216208457947,
-0.5099962949752808,
0.4992036521434784,
0.5414415597915649,
0.29505929350852966,
0.4921918213367462,
-0.03396189585328102,
0.2079296112060547,
0.18011526763439178,
-0.2478005737066269,
-0.2988262176513672,
-0.6232876181602478,
-0.7917437553405762,
-0.2025945484638214,
0.607609748840332,
0.7550747394561768,
-0.5303031802177429,
0.5227178931236267,
-0.18943668901920319,
-0.4640752375125885,
-0.38097482919692993,
0.2616659998893738,
0.13665243983268738,
0.6445322036743164,
0.3868952989578247,
-0.1140783503651619,
-0.6392905712127686,
-0.7686851024627686,
-0.35246598720550537,
0.3512173593044281,
-0.021803172305226326,
0.407362163066864,
0.590499758720398,
-0.17012782394886017,
0.6913378238677979,
-0.4697425961494446,
-0.3043056130409241,
-0.5394517779350281,
0.16480402648448944,
0.43103480339050293,
0.507662296295166,
0.1557171493768692,
-0.6580929756164551,
-0.7777166962623596,
0.16046245396137238,
-0.7978124618530273,
0.23052768409252167,
-0.08744573593139648,
0.2925559878349304,
0.14327780902385712,
0.4455891251564026,
-0.6659790277481079,
0.3971238136291504,
0.16025160253047943,
0.02786145731806755,
0.17717790603637695,
0.20702765882015228,
0.16710691154003143,
-1.2228306531906128,
-0.2535948157310486,
0.1432853788137436,
0.17705745995044708,
-0.559662938117981,
-0.27511411905288696,
0.04996862635016441,
-0.10676605999469757,
-0.580426037311554,
0.8013705015182495,
-0.655036985874176,
0.04973939061164856,
-0.24012944102287292,
-0.398815780878067,
0.15809959173202515,
0.21537695825099945,
0.3085549771785736,
0.5231824517250061,
0.4912545084953308,
-0.675404965877533,
0.5362016558647156,
-0.03773169964551926,
-0.5509366989135742,
0.4852139949798584,
-0.5873128771781921,
0.16146142780780792,
-0.14500348269939423,
0.2334941327571869,
-0.7782477140426636,
-0.40534165501594543,
0.5098932981491089,
-0.3349384367465973,
0.5393210053443909,
-0.37083864212036133,
-0.7826186418533325,
-0.2525271773338318,
0.09027456492185593,
0.21740299463272095,
0.15732188522815704,
-0.5343636870384216,
0.5664699077606201,
0.3030277192592621,
-0.04114706814289093,
-0.3293580412864685,
-0.7124821543693542,
0.31925463676452637,
-0.271568238735199,
-0.1668190211057663,
0.2167399823665619,
0.05524712800979614,
-0.017427871003746986,
0.0902094915509224,
-0.15305571258068085,
-0.27261996269226074,
0.07837066054344177,
0.49893370270729065,
0.07600029557943344,
-0.2722092568874359,
0.2625025808811188,
0.20059169828891754,
-0.1465618759393692,
-0.18231232464313507,
-0.2606975734233856,
0.4027198255062103,
-0.11539582908153534,
0.17483305931091309,
-0.5792489051818848,
0.3369068503379822,
0.2392551600933075,
-0.14061596989631653,
0.9281348586082458,
0.695868968963623,
-0.7706300020217896,
-0.10804261267185211,
-0.554787278175354,
-0.21824109554290771,
-0.42790690064430237,
0.10052941739559174,
-0.5542224645614624,
-0.761457085609436,
0.3901049494743347,
-0.25841081142425537,
-0.18893343210220337,
0.4380796551704407,
0.26704874634742737,
-0.20472389459609985,
0.5960298776626587,
0.3110347092151642,
-0.13763172924518585,
0.22363105416297913,
-0.12425294518470764,
0.12491996586322784,
-0.7502697706222534,
-0.4497031271457672,
-0.48199284076690674,
-0.3246884047985077,
-0.6803022623062134,
-0.36503866314888,
0.0538872666656971,
-0.08850681036710739,
-0.15459232032299042,
0.5084112286567688,
-0.6099114418029785,
0.8948801159858704,
0.4809119403362274,
-0.09435171633958817,
0.17560915648937225,
0.10832127928733826,
-0.3505408465862274,
-0.26459360122680664,
-0.40838566422462463,
-0.5536653995513916,
0.8563540577888489,
0.2662545442581177,
0.9222011566162109,
-0.18900614976882935,
0.9875303506851196,
0.2246372401714325,
-0.03240402415394783,
-1.0010507106781006,
0.6568373441696167,
-0.287180095911026,
-0.5842396020889282,
-0.3463512659072876,
-0.5530980229377747,
-0.8957613110542297,
-0.11563447117805481,
-0.4310009181499481,
-0.6420408487319946,
0.14229074120521545,
-0.002513699699193239,
-0.48444104194641113,
0.3787462115287781,
-0.9706220626831055,
0.9026406407356262,
-0.5789617896080017,
-0.17187006771564484,
0.6155107617378235,
-0.4854849874973297,
-0.012424297630786896,
0.14354602992534637,
-0.03592357784509659,
-0.08910343050956726,
0.1789536029100418,
0.6965274810791016,
-0.05648162215948105,
0.9781844615936279,
0.028959322720766068,
0.13679754734039307,
0.04172179102897644,
0.13312527537345886,
0.55329829454422,
0.19347022473812103,
-0.05473214015364647,
0.2489490658044815,
-0.12288167327642441,
-0.06841880828142166,
-0.7528383135795593,
1.0729584693908691,
-0.39472562074661255,
-0.2545771598815918,
-0.44109874963760376,
-0.1580454260110855,
0.13258446753025055,
0.49896591901779175,
0.44315654039382935,
0.13286535441875458,
-0.21428711712360382,
0.18985670804977417,
0.7304872274398804,
-0.27984654903411865,
0.31645381450653076,
0.43662673234939575,
0.04634614661335945,
-0.4345884621143341,
0.9347144365310669,
0.3239920735359192,
-0.26142725348472595,
0.7511072754859924,
-0.021694306284189224,
0.10635346919298172,
-0.3997277021408081,
-0.5107113718986511,
-0.020198766142129898,
-0.5720791816711426,
-0.4254801571369171,
-0.7262884378433228,
-0.2754126787185669,
-0.3542514741420746,
-0.12723219394683838,
-0.36006978154182434,
-0.22594991326332092,
-0.7934085130691528,
-0.3704928457736969,
0.33382704854011536,
0.7064904570579529,
0.3585428297519684,
-0.01449656579643488,
-0.8158606886863708,
0.32312482595443726,
0.1615583300590515,
0.3434308171272278,
0.13786429166793823,
-0.17298391461372375,
-0.13312365114688873,
-0.05828232690691948,
-0.10655554383993149,
-1.0626721382141113,
0.6871356964111328,
0.3469643294811249,
0.43867069482803345,
0.24875518679618835,
-0.06907764822244644,
0.6474793553352356,
-0.6427249312400818,
0.7052710652351379,
0.04513337090611458,
-0.6911088228225708,
0.68968266248703,
0.14569814503192902,
0.26521432399749756,
0.5906394720077515,
0.5485073328018188,
-0.5069658756256104,
-0.02334684692323208,
-0.24976931512355804,
-1.1109898090362549,
0.260701060295105,
-0.07134956121444702,
0.18218128383159637,
-0.45525017380714417,
0.45726194977760315,
0.46422070264816284,
0.13329719007015228,
-0.7345786094665527,
-0.21005018055438995,
0.037361036986112595,
-0.2061557173728943,
0.243909552693367,
-0.1756228506565094,
0.2659907639026642,
-0.43228062987327576,
0.6308329105377197,
0.11781291663646698,
0.07046400755643845,
-0.019292550161480904,
-0.16236133873462677,
-0.18433719873428345,
0.5732231140136719,
0.36093834042549133,
0.118811696767807,
-0.19169659912586212,
0.17847470939159393,
0.3865397572517395,
-0.1526276022195816,
0.08604808896780014,
0.22687917947769165,
-0.22161047160625458,
-0.03479912132024765,
0.33084312081336975,
0.8539171814918518,
0.18053872883319855,
-0.45860642194747925,
0.08348336815834045,
-0.3917383551597595,
0.05750351771712303,
-0.5854360461235046,
0.23904649913311005,
0.012712722644209862,
0.4121590554714203,
0.3798351287841797,
-0.08566861599683762,
0.4609619081020355,
-0.3629712760448456,
0.1410723179578781,
0.47245293855667114,
-0.3738471269607544,
-0.229622483253479,
0.3111162781715393,
0.13949157297611237,
-0.12932491302490234,
0.9470914006233215,
-0.19554340839385986,
-0.23636537790298462,
0.6871652603149414,
0.5892008543014526,
0.8518357276916504,
-0.07973584532737732,
0.2245209962129593,
0.35994577407836914,
0.31263086199760437,
-0.038045160472393036,
0.04678255692124367,
-0.11009448766708374,
-0.7149568796157837,
-0.008447782136499882,
-0.7887821793556213,
-0.28561002016067505,
0.5047376155853271,
-0.49778327345848083,
0.2755040228366852,
-0.48639586567878723,
-0.24911068379878998,
0.5641391277313232,
0.034571580588817596,
-1.0758851766586304,
0.3385607600212097,
0.48859739303588867,
0.7391861081123352,
-1.0093601942062378,
0.5817849040031433,
0.8689191937446594,
-0.5019477605819702,
-0.8812467455863953,
0.037328384816646576,
0.09483308345079422,
-0.5810742378234863,
0.8207817077636719,
0.4343256950378418,
0.29754841327667236,
-0.094678595662117,
-0.5659693479537964,
-0.8139957189559937,
0.8521901965141296,
0.22508729994297028,
-0.710324764251709,
-0.25839248299598694,
0.23418423533439636,
0.5030784010887146,
-0.534076452255249,
0.09052246809005737,
0.4346581697463989,
0.5320878624916077,
0.38227060437202454,
-0.6531965136528015,
0.03315078839659691,
-0.3213062584400177,
0.16067814826965332,
0.21895837783813477,
-0.07860209047794342,
0.6100803017616272,
-0.3612936735153198,
-0.3723757863044739,
0.19403116405010223,
0.717099666595459,
0.07051747292280197,
0.6517788767814636,
-0.03673018515110016,
0.6325827240943909,
0.7048512101173401,
-0.1536758542060852,
0.8111522197723389,
0.10760150104761124,
0.2599993646144867,
1.40567946434021,
-0.6191375255584717,
0.7320431470870972,
0.4521881341934204,
0.051578786224126816,
0.3428560793399811,
0.77681565284729,
-0.5172597765922546,
0.71225506067276,
0.21641486883163452,
-0.09455131739377975,
-0.038500119000673294,
-0.3056665062904358,
-0.3500697910785675,
0.3720395565032959,
0.5576483011245728,
-0.8691479563713074,
-0.156183660030365,
0.08779188990592957,
0.07676266878843307,
-0.1458105742931366,
-0.0734785869717598,
1.2055398225784302,
0.3779202401638031,
-0.45593011379241943,
0.4507458806037903,
0.03036459907889366,
0.2761368751525879,
-0.1524423360824585,
-0.4430396556854248,
-0.2162577211856842,
-0.03557615727186203,
-0.34015724062919617,
-0.7716507911682129,
-0.03341285139322281,
0.0404379665851593,
-0.4272342920303345,
0.19253811240196228,
0.7407936453819275,
-0.4118143916130066,
-0.8110557794570923,
0.10776901245117188,
0.33577120304107666,
0.08471734076738358,
0.0248962864279747,
-0.5962977409362793,
0.09795424342155457,
-0.4216981530189514,
-0.09485477209091187,
0.1848427802324295,
0.5932934880256653,
0.23392435908317566,
0.345401406288147,
0.5550829768180847,
0.10454639047384262,
0.08994635939598083,
0.1464899182319641,
0.8951833844184875,
-0.9726974368095398,
-0.3407846987247467,
-1.0234181880950928,
0.3061138987541199,
0.07022595405578613,
-0.13932247459888458,
0.7461453080177307,
0.45073288679122925,
1.0064752101898193,
-0.3446080982685089,
0.6757102012634277,
0.09513682872056961,
0.46201014518737793,
-0.8323620557785034,
0.43936750292778015,
-0.40892788767814636,
0.584743857383728,
-0.394193559885025,
-0.927913248538971,
-0.44395703077316284,
0.4585503041744232,
-0.49757805466651917,
0.19300076365470886,
0.3568306267261505,
0.7304287552833557,
-0.06164238601922989,
0.035923071205616,
0.2800365090370178,
0.13615766167640686,
0.132308229804039,
0.498494952917099,
0.8458142280578613,
-0.40226098895072937,
-0.07548737525939941,
-0.10122819989919662,
0.053568385541439056,
-0.32914403080940247,
-0.9502149224281311,
-0.9020707011222839,
-0.3595470190048218,
-0.2963370084762573,
-0.018333453685045242,
0.3079831004142761,
1.2247940301895142,
0.6831244230270386,
-0.9928506016731262,
0.08098237216472626,
-0.26817166805267334,
0.21939508616924286,
-0.4201655387878418,
-0.27185553312301636,
0.21982704102993011,
-0.09722109884023666,
-0.49848055839538574,
0.6248651146888733,
0.3020550310611725,
0.07513891160488129,
0.17359983921051025,
0.03739859163761139,
-0.0713610053062439,
0.03555045276880264,
0.5704872608184814,
0.511457085609436,
-0.8966900110244751,
0.05997774004936218,
0.08497364819049835,
0.04558252543210983,
-0.01965838111937046,
0.6253295540809631,
-0.6864298582077026,
0.46717897057533264,
0.23013301193714142,
0.8297070860862732,
0.27292102575302124,
-0.26445433497428894,
0.19949576258659363,
-0.8374394178390503,
-0.29555651545524597,
0.2065252959728241,
0.2965594530105591,
0.5666204690933228,
-0.6338364481925964,
0.2747482359409332,
0.10061141103506088,
-0.5210581421852112,
-0.7051279544830322,
0.25489866733551025,
-0.8909282684326172,
-0.12042036652565002,
1.0794036388397217,
0.0010627933079376817,
-0.4043600857257843,
0.15366651117801666,
0.10159725695848465,
0.397040992975235,
-0.6275726556777954,
0.5144343972206116,
0.369046688079834,
-0.21279031038284302,
-0.4917546808719635,
-0.4931538701057434,
0.3027871549129486,
-0.004454050213098526,
-0.746540904045105,
-0.20401650667190552,
0.6241523623466492,
0.4928024113178253,
-0.040506936609745026,
0.23756855726242065,
0.10639632493257523,
0.061983343213796616,
-0.2906469404697418,
-0.09572156518697739,
-0.08497685939073563,
-0.6915208697319031,
-0.23531298339366913,
0.1523849368095398,
0.2004963457584381,
-0.10595472157001495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17437v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17437v1
|
Exploiting Emotion-Semantic Correlations for Empathetic Response Generation
| 2024-02-27T11:50:05 | 2024-02-27T11:50:05 |
Zhou Yang, Zhaochun Ren, Yufeng Wang, Xiaofei Zhu, Zhihao Chen, Tiecheng Cai, Yunbing Wu, Yisong Su, Sibo Ju, Xiangwen Liao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Empathetic response generation aims to generate empathetic responses by
understanding the speaker's emotional feelings from the language of dialogue.
Recent methods capture emotional words in the language of communicators and
construct them as static vectors to perceive nuanced emotions. However,
linguistic research has shown that emotional words in language are dynamic and
have correlations with other grammar semantic roles, i.e., words with semantic
meanings, in grammar. Previous methods overlook these two characteristics,
which easily lead to misunderstandings of emotions and neglect of key
semantics. To address this issue, we propose a dynamical Emotion-Semantic
Correlation Model (ESCM) for empathetic dialogue generation tasks. ESCM
constructs dynamic emotion-semantic vectors through the interaction of context
and emotions. We introduce dependency trees to reflect the correlations between
emotions and semantics. Based on dynamic emotion-semantic vectors and
dependency trees, we propose a dynamic correlation graph convolutional network
to guide the model in learning context meanings in dialogue and generating
empathetic responses. Experimental results on the EMPATHETIC-DIALOGUES dataset
show that ESCM understands semantics and emotions more accurately and expresses
fluent and informative empathetic responses. Our analysis results also indicate
that the correlations between emotions and semantics are frequently used in
dialogues, which is of great significance for empathetic perception and
expression.
|
[
-0.32045069336891174,
-1.0727791786193848,
0.6804972290992737,
0.3190300762653351,
-0.26995861530303955,
0.011605772189795971,
-0.09515951573848724,
-0.28718504309654236,
0.5716455578804016,
0.20167681574821472,
-0.916438102722168,
-0.3662211000919342,
-0.514159619808197,
0.2732182443141937,
-0.30308857560157776,
0.9121523499488831,
-0.07560819387435913,
-0.0761556327342987,
-0.3560957908630371,
-0.1736549288034439,
-0.19837477803230286,
-0.5260835289955139,
-0.48453065752983093,
-0.19771456718444824,
0.7122538685798645,
0.4040027856826782,
0.25513654947280884,
0.24408477544784546,
0.46135085821151733,
0.42425090074539185,
-0.23824411630630493,
0.0531826950609684,
-0.29441311955451965,
0.9047515392303467,
0.16299445927143097,
-0.16094940900802612,
-0.5010902285575867,
-0.1860400289297104,
0.26847606897354126,
0.20870256423950195,
-0.17930138111114502,
-0.02886723354458809,
-0.11285041272640228,
0.46757203340530396,
-0.6124793887138367,
0.48849567770957947,
-0.5148059725761414,
0.4457639455795288,
0.2770288586616516,
-0.6658182740211487,
-0.3458867073059082,
-0.16230660676956177,
0.3450847566127777,
-0.48448121547698975,
-0.16784365475177765,
-0.020404918119311333,
0.632497251033783,
0.3139970600605011,
-0.7534133195877075,
-0.6616536378860474,
-0.3979763388633728,
0.6104212403297424,
-0.384287029504776,
0.06953340768814087,
0.08108040690422058,
0.19780799746513367,
-0.02406219206750393,
-0.5293038487434387,
-0.48429328203201294,
-0.2675217092037201,
-0.09777559340000153,
0.6138200163841248,
-0.07564355432987213,
0.12395578622817993,
0.3489672839641571,
0.046725962311029434,
-0.24291138350963593,
-0.24055688083171844,
0.3009774386882782,
0.08959305286407471,
0.37750133872032166,
0.7012597918510437,
0.4142199754714966,
-0.38887470960617065,
-0.1980302333831787,
-0.18625757098197937,
-0.30965039134025574,
-0.12228729575872421,
0.2276078313589096,
0.3929026126861572,
-0.30165114998817444,
0.5387603044509888,
-0.013790742494165897,
0.7053514122962952,
0.36367708444595337,
-0.20373126864433289,
0.16789130866527557,
-0.35753753781318665,
-0.25169020891189575,
0.35009852051734924,
0.7990535497665405,
0.5807827711105347,
0.24281130731105804,
-0.009024364873766899,
0.29383584856987,
0.460678368806839,
0.29743489623069763,
-1.1032384634017944,
-0.04939329996705055,
0.444602906703949,
-0.2940406799316406,
-0.7245509028434753,
-0.27965015172958374,
-1.1600139141082764,
-0.07246293872594833,
-0.24031683802604675,
0.09437011927366257,
-0.4163445234298706,
-0.3382432460784912,
-0.1376701295375824,
-0.20310479402542114,
0.23799017071723938,
0.32312342524528503,
-0.8688107132911682,
0.36098048090934753,
0.4448663294315338,
0.5605151653289795,
0.3332148492336273,
-0.17828518152236938,
-0.7189316153526306,
0.21489638090133667,
0.2654111981391907,
0.7193964123725891,
-0.8262460827827454,
-0.40943601727485657,
0.18251387774944305,
0.05310288444161415,
-0.08070481568574905,
-0.04283291473984718,
0.42504584789276123,
-0.15359294414520264,
0.0411643423140049,
-0.1484432816505432,
-0.5258552432060242,
-0.08973611146211624,
0.36967000365257263,
-0.5522320866584778,
0.5388807058334351,
0.028663605451583862,
-1.0731511116027832,
0.0737294852733612,
-0.24030593037605286,
-0.4536101520061493,
-0.21533136069774628,
-0.24995167553424835,
-0.45048990845680237,
0.17952071130275726,
-0.20159155130386353,
0.5342886447906494,
-0.35787656903266907,
0.282438725233078,
-0.4522738456726074,
0.2559032142162323,
0.4682239592075348,
-0.12362395972013474,
0.2988302707672119,
0.4276774525642395,
-0.35114312171936035,
-0.28090521693229675,
-0.9757023453712463,
0.043263550847768784,
0.09735961258411407,
-0.08934549987316132,
-0.2767435908317566,
0.3145073354244232,
-0.12904566526412964,
0.5617566108703613,
-0.04368205368518829,
-0.7388209104537964,
-0.5148818492889404,
-0.29190903902053833,
0.2728496491909027,
0.4361031949520111,
0.22164444625377655,
0.388442724943161,
0.036999814212322235,
0.48940321803092957,
0.37665989995002747,
-0.03720260411500931,
-0.4721607267856598,
-0.2441309243440628,
-0.7456347346305847,
0.003729109186679125,
-0.38986384868621826,
0.44664284586906433,
-0.26528170704841614,
0.7132968902587891,
0.025257986038923264,
-0.5540057420730591,
-0.29972225427627563,
-0.370519757270813,
0.539772093296051,
0.8752488493919373,
0.1553184539079666,
-0.24792523682117462,
-0.5539747476577759,
-0.5040010213851929,
-0.17365825176239014,
-0.3353954255580902,
0.2865271270275116,
0.6759074926376343,
0.13098251819610596,
-0.09869597107172012,
0.7903130054473877,
-0.60152667760849,
0.03187326714396477,
-0.04886756092309952,
0.37630391120910645,
-0.23164133727550507,
0.29220542311668396,
0.45916640758514404,
-0.7589330673217773,
-0.4959656596183777,
0.048237595707178116,
-0.7468711137771606,
-0.47747308015823364,
-0.05014771968126297,
-0.43164825439453125,
0.09009698778390884,
0.3713386058807373,
-0.5654535293579102,
0.2608690559864044,
0.7234392762184143,
-0.6066596508026123,
0.0764523297548294,
0.15825125575065613,
0.10474268347024918,
-1.317209005355835,
-0.031172901391983032,
-0.2636951506137848,
0.018927913159132004,
-0.5167710781097412,
-0.13278144598007202,
-0.22648407518863678,
-0.08711431175470352,
-0.6310577392578125,
0.3430216312408447,
-0.26650482416152954,
0.08924546092748642,
0.04260602965950966,
0.41453564167022705,
0.1645790934562683,
0.34784770011901855,
0.11419916898012161,
-0.17197410762310028,
0.6780673861503601,
-0.44290706515312195,
0.8661968111991882,
0.6731038093566895,
0.11269973963499069,
0.9825723171234131,
-0.39207568764686584,
-0.1542762964963913,
-0.20264828205108643,
0.48469096422195435,
-0.8754730224609375,
-0.27085310220718384,
0.1254018396139145,
-0.45812222361564636,
0.303728848695755,
0.15832000970840454,
-0.35769668221473694,
-0.2305857390165329,
-0.04689989238977432,
0.3940284550189972,
0.4712238311767578,
-0.34961578249931335,
1.039139747619629,
0.28082743287086487,
-0.1021503210067749,
-0.18196186423301697,
-0.9556148648262024,
-0.3081890642642975,
-0.2730189263820648,
-0.8475241661071777,
-0.10166032612323761,
-0.058526162058115005,
-0.30377766489982605,
0.025909816846251488,
0.14703890681266785,
0.2189633548259735,
0.19173979759216309,
0.48545145988464355,
-0.1582111120223999,
0.02923945151269436,
0.27056363224983215,
0.1734405905008316,
-0.2069264054298401,
0.39214181900024414,
0.3192934989929199,
0.5744712948799133,
-0.12041176855564117,
-0.40611597895622253,
-0.28869131207466125,
0.5080214142799377,
0.6810281276702881,
-0.25513795018196106,
0.640599250793457,
0.6104611754417419,
0.0396340973675251,
0.1214217096567154,
-0.07634077221155167,
-0.3447243273258209,
-0.4070785343647003,
0.3672807216644287,
-0.45991989970207214,
-0.7378961443901062,
0.7119783759117126,
-0.2606203556060791,
-0.32207268476486206,
0.2393357753753662,
1.0088938474655151,
0.16059306263923645,
1.2436363697052002,
-0.04746447876095772,
0.39263901114463806,
0.6455012559890747,
0.12047649919986725,
0.5849498510360718,
-0.9449676871299744,
-0.32079482078552246,
-0.4181396961212158,
-0.25130796432495117,
-0.977857232093811,
0.03713776543736458,
0.1922602504491806,
-0.492474228143692,
-0.43354833126068115,
0.12167120724916458,
-0.21067659556865692,
-0.1547187715768814,
0.09357895702123642,
0.11019445955753326,
-0.048893846571445465,
-0.0049461605958640575,
-0.2966335713863373,
-0.08511059731245041,
-0.522691547870636,
-0.2732962369918823,
0.5326934456825256,
0.27844375371932983,
0.9680687189102173,
0.27162331342697144,
0.8079578280448914,
-0.3604990839958191,
0.07771838456392288,
-0.9738737344741821,
0.5447147488594055,
0.006820411421358585,
-0.0834197923541069,
0.07074710726737976,
-0.3213418126106262,
-0.9658483862876892,
0.12665677070617676,
-0.35261332988739014,
-0.8767937421798706,
-0.02060193009674549,
0.14669007062911987,
-0.4929778277873993,
-0.03067924827337265,
-0.7206620573997498,
0.6079162955284119,
-0.22026920318603516,
-0.49522000551223755,
-0.11392264068126678,
-0.980937659740448,
0.18257948756217957,
-0.30207931995391846,
-0.010283895768225193,
-0.37913548946380615,
0.19382122159004211,
0.3239702582359314,
-0.8047933578491211,
0.9385265111923218,
0.05595996230840683,
-0.004971054382622242,
0.40109482407569885,
0.5217273831367493,
0.5327842831611633,
-0.13217954337596893,
-0.1450756937265396,
-0.4960289001464844,
-0.06646095216274261,
-0.10459554195404053,
-0.7402462959289551,
0.9059038758277893,
-0.6634125709533691,
-0.3171710968017578,
-0.37461405992507935,
-0.4851083755493164,
-0.22300377488136292,
-0.2169354259967804,
-0.025334976613521576,
0.5920558571815491,
-0.49161723256111145,
0.02369224838912487,
0.30093619227409363,
-0.449239045381546,
0.12659041583538055,
0.6615033745765686,
-0.055346373468637466,
-0.23507659137248993,
0.6535131335258484,
-0.20893506705760956,
0.5256032943725586,
0.46015238761901855,
0.4156252443790436,
0.026220016181468964,
0.575835645198822,
-0.10911014676094055,
0.1654389202594757,
-0.5336707830429077,
-0.30256450176239014,
-1.157158613204956,
-0.11408539116382599,
-0.28401288390159607,
-0.4112279415130615,
-0.2708158791065216,
-0.3449609875679016,
-0.1816433221101761,
-0.2921735942363739,
0.9690396785736084,
0.5787798762321472,
-0.07405471801757812,
0.21189771592617035,
-0.9871656894683838,
-0.024941466748714447,
0.43006306886672974,
0.05862037464976311,
0.35705727338790894,
-0.25070852041244507,
-0.0745428279042244,
-0.053196534514427185,
-0.46777328848838806,
-1.0245708227157593,
0.8052456378936768,
0.19776904582977295,
0.10806619375944138,
0.4058976173400879,
0.07011616230010986,
0.5432637929916382,
-0.6759649515151978,
0.779041051864624,
0.35066497325897217,
-0.9716129302978516,
0.7000197768211365,
-0.33344224095344543,
0.14847411215305328,
0.20518118143081665,
0.11975973844528198,
-0.7629168033599854,
-0.792134702205658,
-1.0494924783706665,
-1.051005244255066,
0.7090343832969666,
0.2757413387298584,
0.36898139119148254,
-0.5459606647491455,
0.07893425226211548,
-0.25396019220352173,
0.19795407354831696,
-0.11572019755840302,
0.009147374890744686,
-0.07950416952371597,
-0.6253352761268616,
0.20194780826568604,
-0.3516857326030731,
-0.2821730077266693,
-0.03413825109601021,
0.13997270166873932,
-0.09098519384860992,
0.6793550252914429,
0.0528394877910614,
0.07997628301382065,
-0.6608161330223083,
-0.07459847629070282,
0.4002954363822937,
-0.27660876512527466,
-0.3703966438770294,
0.3936401605606079,
0.13784052431583405,
-0.1137724444270134,
0.06169027462601662,
-0.10617229342460632,
0.3670381009578705,
-0.054708331823349,
0.2753758132457733,
0.991240382194519,
0.5574746131896973,
-0.6139695644378662,
0.7132683396339417,
-0.19951705634593964,
0.20330314338207245,
-0.28018903732299805,
-0.11418550461530685,
0.33063238859176636,
0.22480730712413788,
-0.5693072080612183,
-0.1453273594379425,
0.15538741648197174,
-0.6425829529762268,
0.4342508912086487,
0.16943082213401794,
-0.3544539213180542,
-0.4783492684364319,
0.4226178228855133,
0.5137784481048584,
-0.2571756839752197,
0.586985170841217,
0.2421121597290039,
-0.7483483552932739,
0.8241380453109741,
0.8063340187072754,
0.9715550541877747,
-0.5197259187698364,
0.21394288539886475,
0.5062764286994934,
-0.6023091673851013,
0.2894414961338043,
0.4851452112197876,
-0.21597765386104584,
-0.824815034866333,
0.04965967684984207,
-0.703088104724884,
-0.596781849861145,
-0.5934181213378906,
-0.9039607644081116,
0.2544908821582794,
-0.29030174016952515,
-0.10931109637022018,
-0.07651905715465546,
-0.274038165807724,
-0.7420398592948914,
0.36889562010765076,
0.17054657638072968,
0.6258072257041931,
-1.1126142740249634,
0.45982420444488525,
0.541777491569519,
-0.6899061799049377,
-0.9788150787353516,
-0.0843387246131897,
0.21466708183288574,
-0.8009846806526184,
0.945763111114502,
0.15588833391666412,
-0.3066476285457611,
0.041436173021793365,
-0.3126109540462494,
-0.7492645978927612,
1.12801992893219,
-0.03754387050867081,
-0.3186533749103546,
0.24402232468128204,
0.08846415579319,
0.9072021245956421,
-0.7639098763465881,
0.7726900577545166,
0.3862677812576294,
0.4307900369167328,
0.37834200263023376,
-0.4299585223197937,
0.24901431798934937,
-0.2979210615158081,
0.06544532626867294,
0.3902117908000946,
-1.0293335914611816,
0.8491970300674438,
0.12835432589054108,
-0.16844230890274048,
0.2751297056674957,
0.21906697750091553,
0.31302163004875183,
0.10164110362529755,
0.3357880413532257,
0.630231499671936,
0.372178852558136,
-0.0862026959657669,
1.1764310598373413,
-0.8413273096084595,
0.34980541467666626,
0.951153576374054,
-0.47251471877098083,
0.864126443862915,
0.617721676826477,
0.19300676882266998,
0.7764376401901245,
0.5818579196929932,
0.16142910718917847,
0.4995841383934021,
0.3461821377277374,
-0.680916428565979,
-0.26144152879714966,
-0.4867553114891052,
-0.020344672724604607,
0.5432145595550537,
0.5843735933303833,
-0.7473376393318176,
-0.37007829546928406,
-0.12175767868757248,
0.20392073690891266,
-0.12149430811405182,
0.08671906590461731,
0.9533523321151733,
0.44011032581329346,
-0.6109563708305359,
0.10044396668672562,
-0.46227675676345825,
0.11153652518987656,
-0.6024193167686462,
-0.0418187640607357,
-0.1644228845834732,
0.09658621996641159,
-0.17410807311534882,
-0.9499673247337341,
0.38784918189048767,
0.2513986825942993,
0.08407816290855408,
-0.22564809024333954,
0.6591041088104248,
-0.794910192489624,
-0.24862037599086761,
0.8595974445343018,
0.5889627933502197,
0.24031098186969757,
0.42670366168022156,
-0.4955172538757324,
0.15539172291755676,
-0.2838195860385895,
-0.37255942821502686,
0.3617272973060608,
1.0433039665222168,
0.4117301404476166,
0.40367391705513,
0.2695372402667999,
-0.1453123241662979,
-0.20804789662361145,
0.2698216438293457,
0.947997510433197,
-0.693329393863678,
-0.39080336689949036,
-0.8465577363967896,
0.6016585826873779,
0.0022562139201909304,
-0.06556495279073715,
0.4242005944252014,
0.02194811962544918,
0.3265138864517212,
0.026324179023504257,
0.578531801700592,
-0.3203669786453247,
0.29196617007255554,
-0.4150391221046448,
0.26591506600379944,
-0.6861343383789062,
-0.29757165908813477,
-0.6245870590209961,
-0.6442731022834778,
-0.41283300518989563,
0.6728390455245972,
-0.1788938343524933,
-0.01859816163778305,
0.8696860074996948,
0.8530344367027283,
0.15084294974803925,
0.1912025362253189,
0.4035820960998535,
0.5303792953491211,
0.27961698174476624,
0.8399703502655029,
1.0591309070587158,
-0.14274415373802185,
0.1489523947238922,
-0.02361089549958706,
-0.1557873785495758,
-0.3112473785877228,
-1.170419454574585,
-0.6372003555297852,
-0.48086461424827576,
-0.21722029149532318,
-0.6491654515266418,
-0.11005067825317383,
1.1261216402053833,
0.0907546877861023,
-0.656236469745636,
-0.08799687772989273,
-0.32727137207984924,
-0.15143759548664093,
0.18898582458496094,
-0.273490309715271,
0.13713350892066956,
-0.5364658236503601,
-0.8295076489448547,
-0.178022101521492,
0.5599337816238403,
0.0898643508553505,
-0.038043223321437836,
-0.2848748564720154,
-0.0030229880940169096,
0.3758920729160309,
0.7715033888816833,
0.04459456354379654,
-0.450546532869339,
-0.4079568684101105,
-0.15779945254325867,
-0.259728342294693,
0.0034642734099179506,
0.8217779397964478,
-0.49307000637054443,
0.7142081260681152,
0.697628915309906,
0.40991243720054626,
0.24131248891353607,
-0.11119871586561203,
0.8763455748558044,
-0.5149307250976562,
0.30311232805252075,
0.029453350231051445,
0.4330652356147766,
0.3752548396587372,
-0.4120030403137207,
0.33646827936172485,
0.2385009080171585,
-0.5915245413780212,
-0.4460279643535614,
0.7216759920120239,
-1.2633862495422363,
0.23311705887317657,
1.4254076480865479,
-0.3269956111907959,
-0.39188897609710693,
0.2797451913356781,
-0.33187565207481384,
0.6928585171699524,
-0.4997057616710663,
0.514202892780304,
0.6585203409194946,
-0.536942720413208,
-0.0029810015112161636,
0.09929624944925308,
0.42272886633872986,
0.627888023853302,
-0.7830699682235718,
0.17941750586032867,
0.4597727954387665,
-0.16489294171333313,
0.13611124455928802,
0.300845742225647,
-0.08078286796808243,
0.04818882420659065,
0.1709766834974289,
0.05185016989707947,
0.43301379680633545,
0.13651984930038452,
-0.14028343558311462,
-0.1739906519651413,
-0.10262097418308258,
-0.06262975931167603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17433v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17433v3
|
Enhancing EEG-to-Text Decoding through Transferable Representations from Pre-trained Contrastive EEG-Text Masked Autoencoder
| 2024-02-27T11:45:21 | 2024-06-10T09:51:50 |
Jiaqi Wang, Zhenxi Song, Zhengyu Ma, Xipeng Qiu, Min Zhang, Zhiguo Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reconstructing natural language from non-invasive electroencephalography
(EEG) holds great promise as a language decoding technology for brain-computer
interfaces (BCIs). However, EEG-based language decoding is still in its nascent
stages, facing several technical issues such as: 1) Absence of a hybrid
strategy that can effectively integrate cross-modality (between EEG and text)
self-learning with intra-modality self-reconstruction of EEG features or
textual sequences; 2) Under-utilization of large language models (LLMs) to
enhance EEG-based language decoding. To address above issues, we propose the
Contrastive EEG-Text Masked Autoencoder (CET-MAE), a novel model that
orchestrates compound self-supervised learning across and within EEG and text
through a dedicated multi-stream encoder. Furthermore, we develop a framework
called E2T-PTR (EEG-to-Text decoding using Pretrained Transferable
Representations), which leverages pre-trained modules alongside the EEG stream
from CET-MAE and further enables an LLM (specifically BART) to decode text from
EEG sequences. Comprehensive experiments conducted on the popular text-evoked
EEG database, ZuCo, demonstrate the superiority of E2T-PTR, which outperforms
the state-of-the-art in ROUGE-1 F1 and BLEU-4 scores by 8.34% and 32.21%,
respectively. These results indicate significant advancements in the field and
underscores the proposed framework's potential to enable more powerful and
widespread BCI applications.
|
[
-0.19876575469970703,
-0.6875084042549133,
0.5220988988876343,
0.5464103817939758,
-0.22206732630729675,
0.11741535365581512,
-0.23951782286167145,
-0.5954464077949524,
0.3932642340660095,
0.23696868121623993,
-0.22078397870063782,
-0.4133055508136749,
-0.71299147605896,
0.3552148640155792,
-0.439802885055542,
0.6981030702590942,
-0.2560848295688629,
-0.11761583387851715,
0.031424377113580704,
0.021998967975378036,
-0.6834991574287415,
-0.7503156065940857,
-0.5425550937652588,
-0.24982592463493347,
0.21481508016586304,
0.04787040129303932,
-0.011711194179952145,
0.3335484266281128,
0.1630074381828308,
0.24331068992614746,
0.1787245124578476,
0.1718922108411789,
-0.2781536877155304,
-0.09228888899087906,
-0.11218123883008957,
-0.38508522510528564,
-0.6056069135665894,
-0.4320172369480133,
0.4113239049911499,
0.5914344191551208,
-0.1462087780237198,
-0.37222060561180115,
0.5386292934417725,
0.5832225680351257,
-0.8366760015487671,
0.27523481845855713,
-0.40392187237739563,
-0.16530771553516388,
0.1719607412815094,
-0.14885832369327545,
-0.7046213746070862,
0.054275043308734894,
0.12264146655797958,
-0.4984683692455292,
0.032216258347034454,
-0.021307647228240967,
0.5691380500793457,
-0.0201703067868948,
-0.6057901382446289,
-0.19762229919433594,
-0.5608503222465515,
0.5322211980819702,
-0.6161444783210754,
0.6057769656181335,
0.5262048244476318,
-0.06484844535589218,
0.021030711010098457,
-0.7211682200431824,
-0.541718065738678,
-0.1379249095916748,
-0.2822589874267578,
0.4645674526691437,
-0.2517949342727661,
0.12561023235321045,
-0.19617947936058044,
0.3897192180156708,
-0.6829503774642944,
0.17580144107341766,
-0.1040613204240799,
-0.26482895016670227,
0.28553125262260437,
0.07822813838720322,
0.3317347764968872,
-0.09007225185632706,
-0.2522539794445038,
-0.21519923210144043,
-0.4077148735523224,
-0.24863937497138977,
0.0179551113396883,
-0.17130912840366364,
-0.2980288565158844,
0.18750227987766266,
-0.06427246332168579,
0.3008965849876404,
0.4066118001937866,
0.23715616762638092,
0.5562279224395752,
-0.39157211780548096,
-0.11906293034553528,
0.2035003900527954,
0.8153243064880371,
0.3683862090110779,
0.005217146128416061,
-0.3768644630908966,
-0.3350346088409424,
0.22398485243320465,
-0.010464638471603394,
-0.7600604295730591,
-0.5672931671142578,
0.13820365071296692,
-0.6961248517036438,
0.11511199921369553,
-0.04773055016994476,
-0.913651704788208,
-0.11020809412002563,
-0.2567537724971771,
0.6702076196670532,
-0.5217139720916748,
-0.5047553181648254,
0.4093624949455261,
0.19866158068180084,
0.3567388355731964,
0.16765621304512024,
-0.9363405704498291,
0.4065648913383484,
0.10752244293689728,
0.6781371831893921,
-0.5322306156158447,
-0.15421004593372345,
-0.2947697937488556,
0.35578951239585876,
-0.14079037308692932,
0.6784258484840393,
-0.27022168040275574,
-0.52712082862854,
0.019702963531017303,
0.2088695913553238,
-0.29706382751464844,
-0.30336621403694153,
0.42868053913116455,
-0.43042412400245667,
0.30080753564834595,
-0.11610309779644012,
-0.6576481461524963,
0.08733205497264862,
0.013723066076636314,
-0.7282334566116333,
0.7241955995559692,
-0.2859303057193756,
-0.592377245426178,
-0.08003462851047516,
-0.6833775043487549,
-0.6888291835784912,
-0.07943590730428696,
-0.20297911763191223,
-0.32682809233665466,
0.08195064961910248,
0.5969882607460022,
0.47781968116760254,
-0.11725135147571564,
0.12310124933719635,
-0.08172015845775604,
-0.30691996216773987,
0.24537107348442078,
-0.6062881350517273,
0.4978828430175781,
0.2714546024799347,
-0.47889673709869385,
-0.33436185121536255,
-0.9225882291793823,
-0.044827383011579514,
0.09976856410503387,
-0.1905195116996765,
-0.32843419909477234,
-0.12254513800144196,
0.3580392897129059,
0.14773975312709808,
0.27737101912498474,
-0.6043615341186523,
-0.3659531772136688,
-0.39728212356567383,
0.46852296590805054,
0.47984588146209717,
-0.022321294993162155,
0.5073601007461548,
-0.04894062131643295,
0.18160992860794067,
0.13010971248149872,
-0.18397684395313263,
-0.7312475442886353,
-0.23560674488544464,
-0.9332961440086365,
-0.25740334391593933,
0.30721384286880493,
0.7025042772293091,
-0.9344640970230103,
0.8397459983825684,
-0.19409841299057007,
-0.091037318110466,
-0.6324357390403748,
-0.21043497323989868,
0.3892360329627991,
0.6394166946411133,
0.718428373336792,
-0.2764620780944824,
-0.3887113630771637,
-0.947359561920166,
-0.1633053570985794,
-0.10741090029478073,
-0.14720554649829865,
0.02485319972038269,
0.30674096941947937,
-0.5947900414466858,
0.6690942645072937,
-0.1959090679883957,
-0.33818337321281433,
-0.17561690509319305,
0.5405049920082092,
-0.07536818087100983,
0.7015452980995178,
0.31545400619506836,
-0.5386237502098083,
-0.5774962902069092,
0.25650858879089355,
-0.7689480185508728,
-0.36739957332611084,
-0.2762008309364319,
0.03746116906404495,
0.3336375057697296,
0.7792882919311523,
-0.13951341807842255,
0.2556408643722534,
0.6154872179031372,
-0.3923895061016083,
0.26617592573165894,
-0.6165611743927002,
0.5138832330703735,
-0.9820165038108826,
0.18032941222190857,
-0.1044287383556366,
-0.2488512098789215,
-0.6172131299972534,
-0.39298176765441895,
0.40514251589775085,
0.09215984493494034,
-0.045407991856336594,
0.3395114243030548,
-0.7100813388824463,
0.3099816143512726,
-0.6001347899436951,
0.040081292390823364,
0.1597558856010437,
0.47825169563293457,
0.35981979966163635,
0.8326845169067383,
0.5874976515769958,
-0.6292779445648193,
-0.11667705327272415,
0.2671894431114197,
0.1923912912607193,
0.6243854761123657,
-0.5731885433197021,
0.38191404938697815,
-0.26243487000465393,
0.16193737089633942,
-0.7465937733650208,
0.022961217910051346,
-0.042432740330696106,
-0.29394951462745667,
0.7308895587921143,
0.14230889081954956,
-0.3898645341396332,
0.004696990828961134,
-0.15022221207618713,
0.7726911902427673,
0.8167637586593628,
-0.7473521828651428,
0.8322743773460388,
0.3887745440006256,
-0.2003527581691742,
-0.24542094767093658,
-1.1369649171829224,
0.42466679215431213,
0.21277309954166412,
-0.42169299721717834,
0.6675887107849121,
-0.06194589287042618,
0.3182642161846161,
0.011082842014729977,
-0.1768920123577118,
-0.031801410019397736,
-0.2735150158405304,
-0.1454298347234726,
0.18175636231899261,
-0.059271544218063354,
0.05014284327626228,
0.29083698987960815,
-0.4091397821903229,
0.2736274302005768,
-0.42929932475090027,
0.33834564685821533,
-0.13944678008556366,
-0.3919045925140381,
-0.27868932485580444,
0.5228464603424072,
0.16312363743782043,
-0.2528846859931946,
0.5378015637397766,
0.5400469899177551,
-0.42532843351364136,
-0.21227839589118958,
-0.7062007784843445,
-0.23814044892787933,
-0.49399280548095703,
0.6123977899551392,
-0.4815047085285187,
-0.9853721261024475,
0.2556588649749756,
-0.1916113644838333,
-0.32745206356048584,
0.3237871527671814,
0.5252257585525513,
-0.24755366146564484,
0.822943925857544,
0.8008961081504822,
0.053359996527433395,
0.5017536282539368,
-0.01262388750910759,
0.18515203893184662,
-0.7437493801116943,
-0.3980944752693176,
-0.010462986305356026,
0.08560781925916672,
-0.5827142596244812,
-0.20979556441307068,
0.1666143387556076,
-0.14678247272968292,
0.2154240608215332,
0.41625112295150757,
-0.46068382263183594,
0.5140179991722107,
0.1994720995426178,
0.3699527680873871,
0.32023903727531433,
0.17275770008563995,
-0.15737229585647583,
-0.2540091872215271,
-0.6300265192985535,
-0.37672269344329834,
1.1170847415924072,
0.35271039605140686,
0.7704232335090637,
-0.28867894411087036,
0.7616860270500183,
0.4011525809764862,
0.032109521329402924,
-0.2968124747276306,
0.4676457345485687,
-0.2825677990913391,
-0.14160604774951935,
0.20961658656597137,
-0.37280914187431335,
-0.9272825121879578,
0.30276042222976685,
-0.18089662492275238,
-0.6045017242431641,
0.5671817064285278,
0.19895686209201813,
-0.11268288642168045,
0.23458991944789886,
-0.9546777606010437,
0.6822227835655212,
-0.27959707379341125,
-0.5191228985786438,
-0.30050933361053467,
-0.6602742075920105,
0.10087721049785614,
-0.23323339223861694,
0.11460838466882706,
0.38346827030181885,
-0.10120406001806259,
0.702285647392273,
-0.11299396306276321,
0.7367702722549438,
0.05193283036351204,
-0.28709447383880615,
0.20299024879932404,
0.13710112869739532,
0.4054854214191437,
-0.18862316012382507,
0.07948392629623413,
0.2779746949672699,
0.06803732365369797,
-0.4792870283126831,
-0.5113773941993713,
0.8251454830169678,
-0.7604621052742004,
-0.23646636307239532,
-0.41131648421287537,
-0.10962452739477158,
-0.3053613305091858,
0.05167268216609955,
0.42403656244277954,
0.44000187516212463,
-0.45834001898765564,
-0.014376213774085045,
0.9727720022201538,
-0.366155207157135,
0.6767520308494568,
0.32214227318763733,
-0.023549241945147514,
-0.7187824249267578,
1.0988438129425049,
-0.15565817058086395,
0.18985706567764282,
0.6794752478599548,
-0.3643925189971924,
-0.3223347067832947,
-0.6042946577072144,
-0.09737534075975418,
0.3268919289112091,
-0.7187991738319397,
-0.06662079691886902,
-0.8518726229667664,
-0.2237730622291565,
-0.1654474437236786,
-0.3538910448551178,
-0.48676925897598267,
-0.05028331279754639,
-0.3554098904132843,
-0.128839910030365,
0.0009234806057065725,
0.4530312716960907,
-0.29490724205970764,
0.3223280906677246,
-0.7568356990814209,
0.5881556272506714,
0.35057878494262695,
0.4898008704185486,
-0.26387643814086914,
-0.49751609563827515,
-0.4102177023887634,
-0.08865267038345337,
0.07668346911668777,
-0.9986916780471802,
0.6146326661109924,
0.021725500002503395,
0.3629782497882843,
0.14383763074874878,
0.0794157087802887,
0.41171133518218994,
-0.4194658696651459,
0.5156149864196777,
0.6009521484375,
-1.0199321508407593,
0.4334535002708435,
-0.10241580754518509,
0.33611446619033813,
0.6204582452774048,
-0.0005774510791525245,
-0.31187552213668823,
-0.14467492699623108,
-0.21267607808113098,
-0.8852586150169373,
0.6662812232971191,
0.6770675778388977,
0.18610824644565582,
-0.17665770649909973,
0.2921047508716583,
0.31276774406433105,
-0.02497924491763115,
-1.0215821266174316,
-0.35400474071502686,
-0.5468719005584717,
-0.5526074767112732,
0.096482053399086,
-0.43893030285835266,
0.2955278754234314,
-0.05218593403697014,
0.39329928159713745,
-0.046560581773519516,
0.8593713641166687,
0.49958476424217224,
-0.503685474395752,
0.20579388737678528,
0.5285595059394836,
0.10991514474153519,
0.25391677021980286,
-0.16867589950561523,
0.36091700196266174,
0.4156251549720764,
-0.6911336779594421,
0.1551634967327118,
0.4661862850189209,
0.021475965157151222,
0.02176823280751705,
0.21141935884952545,
0.7065633535385132,
0.10451691597700119,
-0.5010309219360352,
0.5958959460258484,
-0.10271307826042175,
-0.18836820125579834,
-0.042489875108003616,
-0.27726873755455017,
-0.09893901646137238,
0.05215815082192421,
0.31592753529548645,
-0.15612369775772095,
0.3926936089992523,
-0.2156556397676468,
0.07259918749332428,
0.08796540647745132,
-0.12978656589984894,
-0.4957585632801056,
0.7140085101127625,
0.5648565292358398,
-0.1344147026538849,
0.22889238595962524,
-0.17708854377269745,
-0.3766315281391144,
0.41243791580200195,
0.9482540488243103,
1.2030460834503174,
-0.2223532497882843,
-0.1482403725385666,
0.33200979232788086,
0.3883293867111206,
-0.1584136188030243,
0.2899217903614044,
-0.14388740062713623,
-0.5855526924133301,
-0.5096153020858765,
-0.2778587341308594,
-0.1631912738084793,
0.20525045692920685,
-0.45486706495285034,
0.1394743174314499,
-0.042034395039081573,
0.0050715371035039425,
-0.6206248998641968,
-0.38779473304748535,
-0.6523945331573486,
0.2753193974494934,
0.37279829382896423,
0.6345435976982117,
-0.6282348036766052,
0.9577338099479675,
0.5006253123283386,
-0.2324845939874649,
-0.3171989917755127,
0.2162860482931137,
-0.5988009572029114,
-0.4262843430042267,
0.3308408558368683,
0.2458336502313614,
-0.46136391162872314,
0.2522793412208557,
-0.26804783940315247,
-0.48717761039733887,
1.0918622016906738,
0.4281432628631592,
-0.9305883646011353,
-0.05628914758563042,
0.12546956539154053,
0.5054178833961487,
-0.3108847737312317,
0.3629879951477051,
0.4768311679363251,
0.259950190782547,
-0.31981608271598816,
-0.8922510743141174,
0.13659341633319855,
-0.4688963294029236,
0.0559065155684948,
0.17890508472919464,
-0.4717577397823334,
0.4626450836658478,
0.2594478130340576,
-0.3430246412754059,
-0.23121976852416992,
0.8788324594497681,
0.014062418602406979,
0.3666914105415344,
0.2162853330373764,
0.30378440022468567,
0.401375412940979,
0.1339966058731079,
0.794115424156189,
-0.5092738270759583,
0.13778865337371826,
0.8817529678344727,
-0.11760689318180084,
0.8164445757865906,
0.4641697406768799,
-0.018966348841786385,
0.5693864822387695,
0.21623966097831726,
0.12273591011762619,
0.8057799339294434,
-0.2798437178134918,
-0.38363730907440186,
-0.27280378341674805,
0.44444531202316284,
-0.43066808581352234,
0.12477832287549973,
0.35952091217041016,
-0.37481752038002014,
-0.15435148775577545,
0.29169243574142456,
-0.25436052680015564,
0.3684616982936859,
-0.26896950602531433,
0.7030786275863647,
0.3370199203491211,
-0.33528703451156616,
0.3373107314109802,
0.17610721290111542,
1.0232110023498535,
-0.5346731543540955,
-0.20166529715061188,
-0.17079146206378937,
0.1865261048078537,
-0.026128418743610382,
-0.5507718920707703,
0.11120212823152542,
0.00907857809215784,
0.03665410354733467,
-0.3349374234676361,
0.9992668628692627,
-0.6453201770782471,
-0.20508027076721191,
0.7246706485748291,
0.7289487719535828,
-0.17882628738880157,
0.03904308006167412,
-0.4550167918205261,
-0.1638001650571823,
-0.22228772938251495,
-0.050506725907325745,
0.40508782863616943,
0.49182453751564026,
0.25777655839920044,
0.3498736619949341,
0.4057605564594269,
-0.20013993978500366,
0.08034755289554596,
-0.021137217059731483,
0.7930721640586853,
-0.7869471907615662,
-0.8635892868041992,
-0.9410679936408997,
0.44171249866485596,
-0.0268092043697834,
0.12619179487228394,
0.5773682594299316,
0.4611662030220032,
0.6623879075050354,
-0.19181960821151733,
0.8316515684127808,
0.05109095945954323,
0.13478948175907135,
-0.7199801802635193,
0.6794565320014954,
-0.2826836407184601,
0.2240041196346283,
-0.19749581813812256,
-0.7255917191505432,
-0.15176811814308167,
0.6153034567832947,
-0.1263565570116043,
0.18028292059898376,
0.9992580413818359,
0.6896578669548035,
-0.14657902717590332,
-0.05228045582771301,
0.46040818095207214,
0.19697819650173187,
0.09506070613861084,
0.8221248984336853,
0.712792158126831,
-0.5895944833755493,
0.7414697408676147,
0.08054307848215103,
-0.3354809880256653,
-0.17373323440551758,
-0.9060509204864502,
-0.9091286659240723,
-0.5270236730575562,
-0.5671105980873108,
-0.3628741502761841,
0.28180354833602905,
0.8791438341140747,
0.4385751187801361,
-0.9873316884040833,
-0.1656021922826767,
-0.5007317066192627,
-0.3561885356903076,
0.014789722859859467,
-0.12101862579584122,
0.5664826035499573,
-0.3961198031902313,
-0.5862950682640076,
0.5066186785697937,
0.47479939460754395,
0.21046681702136993,
-0.1298549920320511,
-0.25821343064308167,
-0.016196055337786674,
0.14616899192333221,
0.8439593315124512,
0.35609951615333557,
-0.3791409730911255,
0.06045160070061684,
0.22089527547359467,
-0.3033005893230438,
0.27391570806503296,
0.624954104423523,
-0.9630482196807861,
0.5499619245529175,
0.37266451120376587,
0.9771491885185242,
0.859440803527832,
-0.4337056279182434,
0.7438226938247681,
-0.464286208152771,
-0.18173223733901978,
0.07113125920295715,
0.4429777264595032,
0.3993850648403168,
-0.28105810284614563,
0.1907271146774292,
0.18170464038848877,
-0.42989692091941833,
-0.4382517635822296,
0.08560989797115326,
-1.0765645503997803,
-0.33266937732696533,
1.2168235778808594,
-0.09083741903305054,
-0.12721386551856995,
-0.42132219672203064,
-0.43118545413017273,
0.14409784972667694,
-0.37280017137527466,
0.7896057963371277,
0.5723040103912354,
-0.17595991492271423,
-0.5083149075508118,
-0.14101752638816833,
0.27577105164527893,
0.6593512892723083,
-1.0322656631469727,
-0.035613130778074265,
0.5121805667877197,
0.1706158071756363,
-0.11879924684762955,
0.7777838110923767,
-0.2976625859737396,
0.3086422085762024,
0.09211763739585876,
0.2326175421476364,
-0.16531766951084137,
-0.12135057151317596,
-0.6508849263191223,
0.12395123392343521,
-0.11882100254297256,
-0.38710132241249084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17411v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17411v2
|
Consistency Matters: Explore LLMs Consistency From a Black-Box Perspective
| 2024-02-27T11:02:12 | 2024-03-02T14:08:06 |
Fufangchen Zhao, Guoqiang Jin, Jiaheng Huang, Rui Zhao, Fei Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Nowadays both commercial and open-source academic LLM have become the
mainstream models of NLP. However, there is still a lack of research on LLM
consistency, meaning that throughout the various stages of LLM research and
deployment, its internal parameters and capabilities should remain unchanged.
This issue exists in both the industrial and academic sectors. The solution to
this problem is often time-consuming and labor-intensive, and there is also an
additional cost of secondary deployment, resulting in economic and time losses.
To fill this gap, we build an LLM consistency task dataset and design several
baselines. Additionally, we choose models of diverse scales for the main
experiments. Specifically, in the LightGBM experiment, we used traditional NLG
metrics (i.e., ROUGE, BLEU, METEOR) as the features needed for model training.
The final result exceeds the manual evaluation and GPT3.5 as well as other
models in the main experiment, achieving the best performance. In the end, we
use the best performing LightGBM model as the base model to build the
evaluation tool, which can effectively assist in the deployment of business
models. Our code and tool demo are available at
https://github.com/heavenhellchen/Consistency.git
|
[
-0.0753619372844696,
-0.6136144399642944,
0.5692682266235352,
0.4411951005458832,
-0.11838822811841965,
-0.01899535395205021,
-0.4160815477371216,
-0.7967196702957153,
-0.028550561517477036,
0.45021721720695496,
-0.25511351227760315,
-0.5354098081588745,
-0.5397993922233582,
0.1649227738380432,
-0.3167131245136261,
1.1770758628845215,
-0.26246148347854614,
0.060264602303504944,
-0.33479732275009155,
-0.4699721038341522,
-0.7024370431900024,
-0.16221986711025238,
-0.6822721362113953,
-0.706749677658081,
0.4728451371192932,
0.13316981494426727,
1.0813928842544556,
0.7777657508850098,
0.5872266888618469,
0.15631020069122314,
-0.294185608625412,
0.2201632708311081,
-0.625338613986969,
0.09956210851669312,
-0.45434141159057617,
-0.5340883731842041,
-0.42895567417144775,
-0.007977615110576153,
0.5391539335250854,
0.7443552613258362,
-0.5760483741760254,
0.1490207016468048,
0.31303369998931885,
0.5249105095863342,
-0.44576185941696167,
0.11495059728622437,
-0.8202798366546631,
0.000595632242038846,
0.08130916953086853,
0.09728974103927612,
-0.33713266253471375,
-0.32492151856422424,
-0.20745868980884552,
-0.6959130764007568,
0.37078097462654114,
0.048284273594617844,
1.100330114364624,
0.28087353706359863,
-0.34887614846229553,
0.06678878515958786,
-1.0189180374145508,
0.7642660140991211,
-0.8803215622901917,
0.4354895353317261,
0.14410661160945892,
0.08450259268283844,
-0.30435454845428467,
-0.6299523115158081,
-0.4099935293197632,
-0.21191120147705078,
0.03480023890733719,
0.1814102679491043,
-0.12397576868534088,
-0.060300737619400024,
0.14713354408740997,
0.24028491973876953,
-0.5095320343971252,
0.42062661051750183,
-0.20005574822425842,
-0.0756116658449173,
0.6403831243515015,
0.25664395093917847,
-0.03163555637001991,
0.25259894132614136,
-0.39457976818084717,
0.17708934843540192,
-0.8819255828857422,
-0.14431537687778473,
0.28797292709350586,
0.03982838988304138,
-0.08886421471834183,
0.7931897640228271,
-0.12127858400344849,
0.6382664442062378,
0.12570446729660034,
-0.12645676732063293,
0.03847438097000122,
-0.5777611136436462,
-0.32542097568511963,
-0.17259815335273743,
0.7307581901550293,
0.4378216564655304,
-0.06941370666027069,
-0.4679080843925476,
-0.5000556707382202,
0.2561209201812744,
0.7289889454841614,
-0.480453222990036,
-0.19858418405056,
0.26582255959510803,
-0.3283001184463501,
-0.11584147065877914,
-0.34264421463012695,
-0.2549743056297302,
-0.5157074332237244,
-0.6814591884613037,
0.7325600385665894,
-0.22564801573753357,
-0.36873379349708557,
0.2699335217475891,
0.17770926654338837,
0.23820188641548157,
0.5664848685264587,
-1.0165283679962158,
0.2529580593109131,
1.0699870586395264,
0.8822878003120422,
-0.36491137742996216,
-0.22484363615512848,
0.03009287267923355,
0.19642405211925507,
-0.5774734616279602,
0.33696499466896057,
0.091315358877182,
-0.2635786235332489,
0.03510843217372894,
0.0659075528383255,
0.07617641240358353,
-0.8891223669052124,
0.43715032935142517,
-0.23771923780441284,
-0.13900426030158997,
-0.15183459222316742,
-0.8264495134353638,
-0.001718967454507947,
0.4754829704761505,
-0.2608697712421417,
1.0051288604736328,
0.06277848780155182,
-0.6361403465270996,
0.516785740852356,
-0.37673085927963257,
0.08440344035625458,
0.33658871054649353,
-0.44108089804649353,
-0.7763370275497437,
0.32693710923194885,
-0.47279125452041626,
0.44795024394989014,
0.016028137877583504,
0.5416674017906189,
-0.32066190242767334,
-0.6273811459541321,
0.14492614567279816,
-0.22552070021629333,
0.8215514421463013,
0.05126345530152321,
-0.42098408937454224,
0.08251754194498062,
-0.8545522093772888,
-0.04577090963721275,
0.14513427019119263,
-0.4022897481918335,
-0.01926981471478939,
0.19626116752624512,
0.13778547942638397,
-0.01419264730066061,
0.4959239959716797,
-0.6567844748497009,
0.32475268840789795,
0.010696619749069214,
0.2835511863231659,
0.8050771355628967,
-0.1650954782962799,
0.31665924191474915,
-0.5643459558486938,
0.3970905542373657,
-0.03177988901734352,
0.1303388923406601,
0.14523668587207794,
-0.5901368856430054,
-0.7682555317878723,
0.0429387129843235,
0.3219245970249176,
0.34789544343948364,
-0.27559521794319153,
0.4958270490169525,
-0.2777867615222931,
-0.588618278503418,
-0.7861796021461487,
0.3862684369087219,
0.13114778697490692,
0.6033021807670593,
0.2756424844264984,
-0.23342689871788025,
-0.4348519742488861,
-1.0758790969848633,
-0.07481854408979416,
-0.2776498794555664,
-0.1487124264240265,
0.06635165959596634,
0.46345117688179016,
-0.6910276412963867,
1.1198207139968872,
-0.3228995203971863,
-0.21100148558616638,
-0.13268283009529114,
0.03906342759728432,
0.3703153431415558,
0.6056501865386963,
0.34995630383491516,
-0.7142740488052368,
-0.4065295159816742,
0.14151832461357117,
-0.9674949049949646,
-0.1853335052728653,
-0.13074557483196259,
-0.24276426434516907,
0.16621065139770508,
0.35505038499832153,
-0.5723533034324646,
0.35217684507369995,
0.7873290181159973,
-0.2456691563129425,
0.7503600716590881,
-0.45505622029304504,
-0.07207344472408295,
-0.8313778042793274,
0.03460489958524704,
0.27933162450790405,
-0.3766171336174011,
-0.6557457447052002,
-0.015460497699677944,
0.37622231245040894,
0.026065468788146973,
-0.41275086998939514,
0.6121343970298767,
-0.2506525218486786,
-0.045181017369031906,
-0.3637296259403229,
0.03999035805463791,
0.32654574513435364,
0.3654794991016388,
0.04166245087981224,
0.8880718946456909,
0.3907967507839203,
-0.6283823847770691,
-0.02994040958583355,
0.21213775873184204,
-0.2582884132862091,
0.7592922449111938,
-1.0102710723876953,
0.17398948967456818,
0.2024524062871933,
-0.07977902889251709,
-0.7745323181152344,
0.15903595089912415,
0.29924580454826355,
-0.08002809435129166,
0.3704689145088196,
-0.27463850378990173,
-0.9340787529945374,
0.12763138115406036,
0.043900564312934875,
0.04894213750958443,
0.6164505481719971,
-0.41997045278549194,
0.456855446100235,
0.3570546507835388,
0.025107920169830322,
-0.5532039999961853,
-0.8098903894424438,
0.10019887238740921,
-0.0007229564944282174,
-0.7067394256591797,
0.463221937417984,
-0.3911367654800415,
-0.30614519119262695,
-0.005397050175815821,
-0.5582693219184875,
0.017360461875796318,
0.36188530921936035,
0.30029812455177307,
0.24928319454193115,
-0.2536051571369171,
-0.04369869455695152,
-0.3589881658554077,
0.06788545101881027,
0.028933394700288773,
-0.42161476612091064,
0.061221811920404434,
-0.1755473017692566,
-0.5430441498756409,
-0.3888837695121765,
-0.024447904899716377,
0.21253463625907898,
0.2666532099246979,
0.9538324475288391,
0.5603306889533997,
-0.31110256910324097,
-0.29189178347587585,
-0.5749748945236206,
0.0010068068513646722,
-0.49889814853668213,
0.1426447033882141,
-0.005553844850510359,
-0.6648747324943542,
0.5534660816192627,
0.1387997716665268,
0.5725648403167725,
0.17312131822109222,
0.42828568816185,
-0.3344341516494751,
0.7366105318069458,
1.1263790130615234,
0.23845012485980988,
0.33779215812683105,
-0.1370343714952469,
0.22520317137241364,
-0.8763351440429688,
-0.4250408411026001,
-0.3875909447669983,
-0.3147341012954712,
-0.4983314573764801,
-0.2566950023174286,
0.31839829683303833,
0.468522846698761,
-0.06711431592702866,
0.4000566601753235,
-0.5406498312950134,
0.4214155375957489,
0.23789682984352112,
0.15676890313625336,
0.494377076625824,
-0.10935023427009583,
-0.07676699757575989,
-0.15294687449932098,
-0.778572142124176,
-0.7975893616676331,
1.132092833518982,
0.4280267059803009,
0.874352216720581,
0.11228860914707184,
0.8079841136932373,
0.16688860952854156,
0.5180744528770447,
-0.6283687949180603,
0.5973359942436218,
0.0650472566485405,
-0.5887443423271179,
-0.1640905737876892,
-0.6312665343284607,
-1.3844681978225708,
0.38929060101509094,
-0.23991622030735016,
-0.6082413196563721,
0.12995794415473938,
0.3046971261501312,
0.08396929502487183,
0.30524519085884094,
-0.5616152286529541,
0.9223551750183105,
-0.40094462037086487,
-0.7805836796760559,
-0.018197916448116302,
-0.34601426124572754,
0.18403229117393494,
-0.11163081228733063,
0.05198918282985687,
-0.37509509921073914,
-0.19525587558746338,
0.6235868334770203,
-0.20681942999362946,
0.8506028056144714,
0.07468216121196747,
-0.31705525517463684,
-0.0330563485622406,
0.13054440915584564,
0.5630355477333069,
0.1193370372056961,
-0.05207688733935356,
0.7143442034721375,
-0.2505352199077606,
-0.5933827757835388,
-0.5269073247909546,
0.5637906193733215,
-0.7930967211723328,
-0.6322471499443054,
-0.26526641845703125,
-0.6118434071540833,
-0.17374259233474731,
0.2535146176815033,
0.11965036392211914,
0.013516251929104328,
-0.31072020530700684,
0.4489355981349945,
1.0744348764419556,
0.013207264244556427,
0.3587482273578644,
0.74336177110672,
-0.3290571868419647,
-0.1178092509508133,
0.5548191666603088,
0.3575611412525177,
0.4315268099308014,
0.09613542258739471,
0.01742534153163433,
-0.26539918780326843,
-1.1291272640228271,
-0.27787235379219055,
0.20161162316799164,
-0.7064921259880066,
-0.1683463752269745,
-0.5826500058174133,
-0.2773473560810089,
-0.2157982438802719,
-0.3200226426124573,
-0.518108069896698,
-0.150506854057312,
-0.29484260082244873,
-0.03455163165926933,
0.16437208652496338,
0.9036172032356262,
0.03545112907886505,
0.282328337430954,
-0.4798530042171478,
0.4588980972766876,
0.07517989724874496,
0.6796109676361084,
-0.28110772371292114,
-0.6090824007987976,
-0.6929399967193604,
0.1215754896402359,
-0.5428098440170288,
-0.5433235168457031,
0.10430503636598587,
-0.06989273428916931,
0.8231398463249207,
0.1108887791633606,
-0.20929758250713348,
0.4975934624671936,
-0.44226059317588806,
0.7154839634895325,
0.2049407660961151,
-0.8357293605804443,
0.37429186701774597,
-0.5985767841339111,
0.38917097449302673,
0.6934964656829834,
0.24146103858947754,
-0.6874325275421143,
-0.591773509979248,
-0.9581500291824341,
-1.0055030584335327,
0.3889633119106293,
0.37531617283821106,
-0.2083568423986435,
0.32316505908966064,
0.46552595496177673,
0.261487752199173,
0.4506481885910034,
-1.1103185415267944,
-0.3390003442764282,
-0.023527471348643303,
-0.3284603953361511,
-0.2584819793701172,
-0.11673005670309067,
-0.40598464012145996,
0.19986791908740997,
0.6569575071334839,
0.02352754957973957,
-0.08974610269069672,
-0.09586349874734879,
-0.18949291110038757,
0.11039570719003677,
0.18199273943901062,
0.5644316077232361,
1.1784553527832031,
-0.3246707022190094,
0.08959022909402847,
0.025149067863821983,
-0.4464145004749298,
0.4558066725730896,
-0.07250677049160004,
-0.6577708125114441,
0.21573331952095032,
0.1579902470111847,
0.5209792852401733,
0.4095715284347534,
-0.45553597807884216,
0.30926546454429626,
0.11027120053768158,
-0.3159571886062622,
-0.23067030310630798,
0.35205718874931335,
0.23516878485679626,
0.17209593951702118,
0.2254510521888733,
0.2711353302001953,
-0.2323610782623291,
-0.4605698883533478,
0.12274186313152313,
0.3588706851005554,
-0.11830510944128036,
-0.05036443844437599,
0.9110382795333862,
-0.051048342138528824,
-0.4214329719543457,
0.4079764485359192,
-0.21117240190505981,
-0.013316873461008072,
0.726799488067627,
0.4501730799674988,
0.7426363825798035,
0.15112608671188354,
0.21564926207065582,
-0.10663611441850662,
0.5908564925193787,
-0.763392984867096,
0.20035456120967865,
0.29128071665763855,
-0.8035610318183899,
-0.3142092227935791,
-0.5220940113067627,
-0.9211643934249878,
0.17486447095870972,
-0.5340359807014465,
0.3834356963634491,
-0.6429742574691772,
-0.12975521385669708,
-0.10891293734312057,
0.2842056155204773,
-0.7775880098342896,
0.14119969308376312,
0.08523764461278915,
0.7291763424873352,
-0.744749128818512,
0.7251793146133423,
0.4778101146221161,
-0.30938684940338135,
-0.6226760149002075,
-0.3591693043708801,
0.12531715631484985,
-0.5277798771858215,
0.23718802630901337,
0.03727753087878227,
0.0033112468663603067,
-0.27106133103370667,
-0.5309751033782959,
-0.757724940776825,
1.2193015813827515,
0.6181307435035706,
-1.0108108520507812,
0.33535638451576233,
-0.03586577624082565,
0.7434764504432678,
-0.3242328464984894,
0.10182961821556091,
0.22753296792507172,
0.45695415139198303,
-0.3143950402736664,
-0.9150276184082031,
-0.24001498520374298,
0.10946173220872879,
0.09500842541456223,
0.14886988699436188,
-0.6633050441741943,
0.5057843923568726,
-0.0037404673639684916,
-0.1803734451532364,
-0.2003488391637802,
0.6350484490394592,
0.7294765114784241,
0.5821685194969177,
0.17223016917705536,
0.6795230507850647,
0.932304322719574,
-0.1729978322982788,
0.9001561403274536,
-0.2393961399793625,
0.3350525200366974,
1.334599494934082,
-0.569244921207428,
0.7415463924407959,
0.3720315992832184,
-0.2070847600698471,
0.1428464949131012,
0.6493500471115112,
-0.5640121698379517,
0.15321046113967896,
0.2925429940223694,
0.025814177468419075,
0.20790815353393555,
-0.06152097508311272,
-0.2940478026866913,
0.07928112149238586,
-0.017297042533755302,
-0.015437861904501915,
-0.043310921639204025,
-0.28561776876449585,
0.10071239620447159,
0.11687327176332474,
-0.3561747372150421,
0.6084047555923462,
0.13643644750118256,
-0.421592116355896,
0.6334272623062134,
-0.005351785104721785,
0.8312714099884033,
-0.865523636341095,
0.18364331126213074,
-0.3487924039363861,
0.23425620794296265,
-0.35285842418670654,
-0.8621380925178528,
0.4361988604068756,
-0.17767402529716492,
-0.2655637264251709,
-0.5504975318908691,
0.4078797399997711,
-0.7790542840957642,
-0.3906044363975525,
0.4330134987831116,
0.4463612735271454,
0.16666391491889954,
0.24352174997329712,
-0.7937278747558594,
0.3036845922470093,
-0.19636249542236328,
-0.08609259128570557,
0.6034397482872009,
0.5389002561569214,
0.2593281865119934,
0.7766938209533691,
0.4684434235095978,
0.47215476632118225,
0.20016203820705414,
0.05695457383990288,
0.29035672545433044,
-0.5166128873825073,
-0.16098226606845856,
-0.7057187557220459,
0.5657482147216797,
-0.009691414423286915,
-0.27835896611213684,
1.0168735980987549,
0.7092100381851196,
0.9154544472694397,
0.13165844976902008,
0.5583720803260803,
0.3166266679763794,
0.1565537303686142,
-0.5549396276473999,
0.5878457427024841,
-0.5593109726905823,
0.5669658184051514,
-0.12236284464597702,
-1.1368392705917358,
-0.13522721827030182,
0.4785178005695343,
0.11101004481315613,
-0.0419401153922081,
0.45368754863739014,
0.8018181324005127,
-0.16005438566207886,
-0.23733261227607727,
0.5464871525764465,
0.1578557938337326,
0.37953925132751465,
0.28129997849464417,
0.6620452404022217,
-0.3904491364955902,
0.38384708762168884,
-0.17914870381355286,
0.07278051972389221,
-0.2632181644439697,
-1.2109885215759277,
-0.3987925052642822,
-0.20919571816921234,
-0.9613456726074219,
-0.61854088306427,
0.11492294818162918,
0.7348973155021667,
0.887102484703064,
-0.5561821460723877,
-0.49335628747940063,
-0.2707720100879669,
0.3350560963153839,
-0.5024813413619995,
-0.23265321552753448,
-0.06290717422962189,
-0.4423712193965912,
-0.49173036217689514,
0.30344754457473755,
0.488386332988739,
0.340588241815567,
-0.3419433832168579,
0.0512569285929203,
-0.15276499092578888,
0.05665956065058708,
0.26897820830345154,
0.1881154179573059,
-0.603725254535675,
-0.15716169774532318,
-0.21022938191890717,
-0.3681483268737793,
0.4293869435787201,
0.6779004335403442,
-0.36910480260849,
0.2702084481716156,
0.25198543071746826,
0.9171306490898132,
0.5464839935302734,
-0.1383781135082245,
0.7186340689659119,
-0.7526793479919434,
0.022460009902715683,
0.2480551153421402,
0.5287682414054871,
0.5898134708404541,
-0.5056232213973999,
0.886432409286499,
0.23168706893920898,
-0.9541109204292297,
-0.8561035394668579,
0.2332700788974762,
-1.0633145570755005,
-0.25430023670196533,
1.103041648864746,
-0.2937522530555725,
0.05587446317076683,
-0.33410316705703735,
0.0833497866988182,
-0.021430589258670807,
-0.19267506897449493,
0.937431812286377,
0.8740655779838562,
-0.19282051920890808,
-0.18582385778427124,
-0.7635548114776611,
0.3734510540962219,
0.5570595860481262,
-0.6163478493690491,
0.09852317720651627,
0.2908925712108612,
0.5738234519958496,
0.22077889740467072,
0.6466503143310547,
0.13952374458312988,
-0.02773275226354599,
0.039765674620866776,
0.2463933229446411,
0.012750637717545033,
-0.383240669965744,
-0.6641106009483337,
0.17670129239559174,
0.1261482685804367,
0.046205032616853714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17407v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17407v1
|
A Neural Rewriting System to Solve Algorithmic Problems
| 2024-02-27T10:57:07 | 2024-02-27T10:57:07 |
Flavio Petruzzellis, Alberto Testolin, Alessandro Sperduti
|
cs.NE
|
cs.NE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Modern neural network architectures still struggle to learn algorithmic
procedures that require to systematically apply compositional rules to solve
out-of-distribution problem instances. In this work, we propose an original
approach to learn algorithmic tasks inspired by rewriting systems, a classic
framework in symbolic artificial intelligence. We show that a rewriting system
can be implemented as a neural architecture composed by specialized modules:
the Selector identifies the target sub-expression to process, the Solver
simplifies the sub-expression by computing the corresponding result, and the
Combiner produces a new version of the original expression by replacing the
sub-expression with the solution provided. We evaluate our model on three types
of algorithmic tasks that require simplifying symbolic formulas involving
lists, arithmetic, and algebraic expressions. We test the extrapolation
capabilities of the proposed architecture using formulas involving a higher
number of operands and nesting levels than those seen during training, and we
benchmark its performance against the Neural Data Router, a recent model
specialized for systematic generalization, and a state-of-the-art large
language model (GPT-4) probed with advanced prompting strategies.
|
[
0.1439383327960968,
-0.7310764789581299,
0.4609013795852661,
0.1808253675699234,
-0.13113266229629517,
0.08031608909368515,
-0.06850374490022659,
-0.19090530276298523,
0.5953060388565063,
0.3915129005908966,
-0.7913693785667419,
-0.2502761781215668,
-0.43660682439804077,
0.09485705941915512,
-0.39575543999671936,
0.8354570269584656,
-0.292202889919281,
0.0579226016998291,
0.008213702589273453,
0.11475326120853424,
-0.5325562357902527,
-0.45056504011154175,
-0.8177348375320435,
-0.664686918258667,
0.6185894012451172,
0.0753188356757164,
0.44165030121803284,
0.8450888991355896,
0.4438396394252777,
0.49972930550575256,
0.06363103538751602,
0.1306988149881363,
-0.051316458731889725,
0.29027312994003296,
0.03974708542227745,
-0.7443436980247498,
-0.3173072934150696,
-0.32515406608581543,
0.5694666504859924,
0.7879312634468079,
-0.4614063501358032,
0.10076254606246948,
-0.32222115993499756,
0.6748631596565247,
-0.39952540397644043,
0.580379068851471,
-0.7002204060554504,
0.2578571140766144,
0.24807806313037872,
-0.23674297332763672,
-0.38012295961380005,
-0.2950912415981293,
0.11025667190551758,
-0.7965825200080872,
0.20301346480846405,
-0.23391114175319672,
0.21567392349243164,
0.6089950799942017,
-0.019627513363957405,
-0.29348495602607727,
-0.5898671746253967,
0.6087138056755066,
-0.4535098671913147,
0.2286369502544403,
-0.016995083540678024,
0.5287162065505981,
-0.23985081911087036,
-0.860511302947998,
-0.3361242413520813,
-0.2794520854949951,
-0.003571279812604189,
-0.12812559306621552,
-0.38233673572540283,
-0.08313657343387604,
0.14111028611660004,
0.09712822735309601,
-0.3561755418777466,
-0.31550076603889465,
-0.6447136402130127,
-0.10514584928750992,
0.6399062275886536,
0.36249980330467224,
0.19719946384429932,
0.05895290896296501,
-0.06468448042869568,
0.0401945561170578,
-0.7429069876670837,
-0.2298283576965332,
0.2722789943218231,
0.11517000198364258,
0.3867698907852173,
0.3421139419078827,
-0.26859691739082336,
0.4983406364917755,
-0.02654162235558033,
0.3379581868648529,
0.3128673732280731,
0.04715466871857643,
-0.37469327449798584,
-0.08849339187145233,
0.364151269197464,
-0.10661284625530243,
0.4184158444404602,
-0.2535130977630615,
-0.6117274761199951,
0.02073233760893345,
0.6357371211051941,
-0.41470223665237427,
-0.4295859932899475,
-0.12776388227939606,
-0.5298687815666199,
-0.22284923493862152,
-0.46540769934654236,
-0.24508757889270782,
-0.11453798413276672,
-0.7112507820129395,
0.649560272693634,
-0.49395301938056946,
0.12230697274208069,
0.252973347902298,
-0.16908851265907288,
0.003245340660214424,
0.3688773810863495,
-0.9103261232376099,
0.44758546352386475,
0.8944177627563477,
0.7245447039604187,
0.16382694244384766,
-0.48879939317703247,
-0.1875630021095276,
-0.036861009895801544,
-0.36495742201805115,
0.5790101885795593,
-0.5373438000679016,
0.0731404572725296,
-0.1207229495048523,
-0.24651393294334412,
-0.2647225558757782,
-0.45449531078338623,
0.21248775720596313,
-0.8273361921310425,
-0.24244874715805054,
0.029557377099990845,
-0.4304446578025818,
-0.28229331970214844,
0.2846134305000305,
-0.8323673009872437,
0.45935389399528503,
0.08866029232740402,
-0.24761374294757843,
-0.14964158833026886,
-0.6932212114334106,
-0.6113996505737305,
-0.024572795256972313,
-0.2117987871170044,
-0.3505689203739166,
0.5936892032623291,
0.01928684674203396,
0.10221163183450699,
-0.2981721758842468,
0.35249757766723633,
0.2280057966709137,
-0.6214999556541443,
0.12821771204471588,
-0.5645648837089539,
0.5436335206031799,
0.15362520515918732,
-0.5237129330635071,
0.3671010732650757,
-0.6525973677635193,
0.2522681653499603,
0.07863223552703857,
-0.49572640657424927,
-0.09642726927995682,
0.16018374264240265,
-0.39063113927841187,
0.13664031028747559,
0.38934317231178284,
-0.5904302597045898,
0.32565709948539734,
-0.5567573308944702,
0.8395904898643494,
0.8800503611564636,
-0.3046007454395294,
0.35974758863449097,
-0.43188509345054626,
0.5019156336784363,
-0.2077244371175766,
-0.035258952528238297,
-0.2683112323284149,
-0.48353245854377747,
-0.8159642219543457,
0.06721178442239761,
0.11781691759824753,
0.4898947477340698,
-0.8793370723724365,
0.20664316415786743,
-0.27511289715766907,
-0.5456815958023071,
-0.5466475486755371,
0.04595840349793434,
0.6990626454353333,
0.31511390209198,
0.36448442935943604,
0.00018872351211030036,
-0.5179682970046997,
-1.2348524332046509,
-0.30105525255203247,
-0.01820683293044567,
0.04375004023313522,
0.21178826689720154,
0.521504282951355,
0.07827930152416229,
0.2844945788383484,
-0.5702505111694336,
-0.07497026026248932,
-0.17092575132846832,
0.11155011504888535,
0.3164505362510681,
0.5759508013725281,
-0.15396571159362793,
-0.5931122303009033,
-0.2717711627483368,
0.04277927428483963,
-0.7384560108184814,
-0.007802248932421207,
-0.15412865579128265,
0.04477468505501747,
0.0057412744499742985,
0.761124849319458,
-0.7777104377746582,
0.46809807419776917,
0.14671827852725983,
0.003685661358758807,
0.6104012727737427,
-0.5581273436546326,
-0.21233385801315308,
-0.9000770449638367,
-0.04891947656869888,
-0.24736791849136353,
0.28629475831985474,
-0.5706428289413452,
0.577582061290741,
-0.13747242093086243,
-0.14637868106365204,
-0.332650750875473,
0.11559002101421356,
-0.3405747413635254,
-0.04261650890111923,
-0.42307770252227783,
-0.39326685667037964,
-0.2710692286491394,
0.8254042267799377,
-0.013837437145411968,
0.4336087703704834,
0.5757114291191101,
-0.3786679208278656,
0.6429295539855957,
0.12195072323083878,
-0.05825062841176987,
0.13431231677532196,
-0.9584317207336426,
0.1990060806274414,
-0.4534081518650055,
0.39775869250297546,
-0.7547205686569214,
-0.02761744149029255,
0.2800612151622772,
-0.1777980625629425,
-0.059926457703113556,
-0.0659402459859848,
-0.31466543674468994,
-0.09769152849912643,
-0.05064192786812782,
0.7393821477890015,
0.4950362741947174,
-0.30804574489593506,
1.1287187337875366,
-0.08853941410779953,
0.022805295884609222,
-0.5997248888015747,
-0.7025581002235413,
0.12796640396118164,
0.075712189078331,
-0.5766952633857727,
0.6343027353286743,
0.04499073699116707,
-0.08986365795135498,
0.04690691828727722,
0.04503689706325531,
-0.11892127990722656,
0.034606460481882095,
0.09059067815542221,
-0.10219242423772812,
-0.340539813041687,
0.13893134891986847,
0.17979131639003754,
-0.26678889989852905,
0.3012215793132782,
-0.524090588092804,
0.7632438540458679,
0.0005814442993141711,
-0.5939410924911499,
-0.7189568281173706,
0.7433992624282837,
0.610399067401886,
-0.4051489531993866,
0.35838156938552856,
0.014648889191448689,
-0.5539354085922241,
-0.6131565570831299,
-0.05296802520751953,
-0.22725781798362732,
-0.5065919756889343,
0.6045889258384705,
-0.727862536907196,
-0.4455450177192688,
0.4546454846858978,
0.22109955549240112,
0.28068625926971436,
0.3263498544692993,
0.5519040822982788,
0.20211881399154663,
0.9064757227897644,
0.5147464871406555,
0.015894856303930283,
0.522226095199585,
-0.34305229783058167,
0.2666056752204895,
-0.5257365703582764,
-0.3789873421192169,
-0.2592279613018036,
-1.0080162286758423,
-0.49307066202163696,
-0.20940163731575012,
0.20823706686496735,
-0.2990027964115143,
-0.31978315114974976,
0.4591175317764282,
-0.6104104518890381,
0.5707229375839233,
0.9563330411911011,
0.3772541880607605,
0.022442903369665146,
0.2595968246459961,
-0.01875944994390011,
0.3050726354122162,
-0.6479176878929138,
-0.22148889303207397,
1.1001983880996704,
0.10981854051351547,
0.7377885580062866,
0.06103060394525528,
0.8325290679931641,
0.11591272056102753,
0.4701240360736847,
-0.7338634729385376,
0.6259046792984009,
-0.4222528040409088,
-0.39046549797058105,
-0.23925895988941193,
-0.4512619972229004,
-0.7793938517570496,
0.1923888772726059,
0.28076136112213135,
-0.4353101849555969,
0.13013629615306854,
0.22933615744113922,
-0.3596557378768921,
0.24643826484680176,
-0.8449522852897644,
0.5163812637329102,
-0.231734037399292,
-0.04370106756687164,
-0.45838794112205505,
-0.5261467695236206,
0.13731132447719574,
-0.008989677764475346,
-0.22865986824035645,
0.3842218220233917,
-0.09937155991792679,
0.610275149345398,
-0.5838050842285156,
1.035690188407898,
-0.13489937782287598,
-0.03586674854159355,
0.15951956808567047,
0.22248417139053345,
0.4544200003147125,
-0.26652365922927856,
-0.35181987285614014,
-0.1883375644683838,
-0.19466643035411835,
-0.2747941315174103,
-1.0775213241577148,
0.6944872736930847,
-0.6955386996269226,
-0.7256131172180176,
-0.027556249871850014,
-0.7616519331932068,
0.16566281020641327,
0.20377130806446075,
-0.01384015940129757,
0.5248098969459534,
-0.005541843827813864,
-0.042138490825891495,
0.34237051010131836,
0.14380259811878204,
0.3891565203666687,
0.22256499528884888,
0.2950775921344757,
-0.4060088098049164,
1.0351890325546265,
0.11310570687055588,
0.07549920678138733,
0.44436222314834595,
0.1762736290693283,
-0.12513838708400726,
-0.767595112323761,
-0.5221306085586548,
-0.04130258411169052,
-0.8630589842796326,
-0.21396520733833313,
-0.520783543586731,
-0.3230655789375305,
-0.1842019110918045,
-0.16681332886219025,
-0.18968042731285095,
-0.45599719882011414,
-0.13286374509334564,
0.04778525233268738,
0.07229509949684143,
0.8693334460258484,
0.14212310314178467,
0.4356476962566376,
-0.5281842947006226,
0.19932526350021362,
0.2618766129016876,
0.3693811297416687,
0.2460397481918335,
-0.25504088401794434,
-0.08292459696531296,
0.03313940763473511,
-0.34967800974845886,
-0.7420310974121094,
0.3771817684173584,
0.2477312684059143,
0.49161821603775024,
0.04101810231804848,
-0.35121050477027893,
0.5274964570999146,
-1.0645729303359985,
0.23602032661437988,
-0.08579783886671066,
-0.844167172908783,
0.12936349213123322,
-0.12365559488534927,
-0.027252554893493652,
0.4964519143104553,
0.09521948546171188,
-0.47080546617507935,
0.039354924112558365,
-0.5685856342315674,
-0.7013835906982422,
0.4376737177371979,
0.18776382505893707,
0.36641791462898254,
-0.06238038092851639,
0.9168321490287781,
-0.08319540321826935,
0.34850186109542847,
-0.5132545232772827,
-0.3088424503803253,
-0.2502252161502838,
-0.5060870051383972,
-0.08610446751117706,
0.12525980174541473,
0.014089254662394524,
-0.21320542693138123,
0.5108345150947571,
-0.11304298043251038,
0.4026382565498352,
0.10144566744565964,
-0.025529785081744194,
0.11935949325561523,
0.16852182149887085,
0.637441873550415,
0.5264942646026611,
0.2832881212234497,
0.21519310772418976,
-0.08199123293161392,
-0.18394193053245544,
0.31881773471832275,
0.11825380474328995,
-0.4988800287246704,
-0.1548302322626114,
0.3896348178386688,
0.6595199704170227,
0.22807763516902924,
-0.5547891855239868,
0.1487545371055603,
0.11123722791671753,
-0.44200897216796875,
-0.3551214039325714,
0.3400707244873047,
0.2762981057167053,
0.4014183282852173,
0.23608572781085968,
0.2660037875175476,
0.25129926204681396,
-0.4679153561592102,
0.37595927715301514,
0.4392975866794586,
-0.19810539484024048,
-0.5174170732498169,
0.4119580090045929,
-0.0000222915241465671,
-1.0514061450958252,
0.7224293947219849,
-0.034878864884376526,
-0.7287429571151733,
0.9464183449745178,
1.001804232597351,
0.9069028496742249,
-0.17874844372272491,
0.19887632131576538,
-0.059578802436590195,
0.44211968779563904,
-0.04718305170536041,
0.5850028991699219,
-0.12461164593696594,
-0.5736808776855469,
-0.5419053435325623,
-0.6230089068412781,
-0.08888591825962067,
-0.1087823212146759,
-0.15318119525909424,
-0.13370823860168457,
-0.7721722722053528,
0.3311578333377838,
0.27658611536026,
-0.28160950541496277,
-0.4434703290462494,
0.18486130237579346,
-0.23916606605052948,
0.9259263873100281,
-0.7345232963562012,
0.44885262846946716,
0.8729783296585083,
-0.4052075445652008,
-1.1071118116378784,
-0.3418527841567993,
-0.21273668110370636,
-0.8166466355323792,
0.9577608108520508,
0.03420117124915123,
-0.22074437141418457,
0.060200285166502,
-0.2842172384262085,
-0.8936913013458252,
0.8499904870986938,
0.6242395043373108,
-0.3488695025444031,
-0.44026660919189453,
0.0922061949968338,
0.80406254529953,
-0.6254624128341675,
0.16997623443603516,
0.4529323875904083,
0.34862056374549866,
0.07646884024143219,
-0.7259159088134766,
0.1399429440498352,
-0.699334442615509,
-0.22506152093410492,
0.2580551505088806,
-0.440055251121521,
1.3765819072723389,
0.04436349496245384,
0.13763634860515594,
0.4455747902393341,
0.5081450343132019,
0.08481210470199585,
0.22457578778266907,
0.3442206382751465,
0.624815046787262,
0.38546156883239746,
0.10818690806627274,
0.9871448278427124,
-0.11844814568758011,
-0.08480578660964966,
1.0219051837921143,
-0.07531414926052094,
0.8256808519363403,
0.5831058621406555,
0.1641169935464859,
0.6538482904434204,
0.19357067346572876,
0.048536285758018494,
0.42937585711479187,
1.0007174015045166,
-0.3362603187561035,
-0.23511870205402374,
0.2094278484582901,
-0.018193040043115616,
0.5648994445800781,
0.08952051401138306,
-0.6970441937446594,
-0.5247437357902527,
-0.1993827223777771,
-0.40712523460388184,
0.13908633589744568,
-0.3844755291938782,
0.6470391154289246,
-0.027826722711324692,
-0.9112429618835449,
0.4783782958984375,
0.27836117148399353,
0.39705750346183777,
-0.4934453070163727,
-0.3894699513912201,
-0.0023962499108165503,
0.5511513948440552,
-0.12570755183696747,
-0.3338961899280548,
0.6259118914604187,
-0.3560754060745239,
-0.24110683798789978,
-0.22506676614284515,
0.38519155979156494,
-0.1631087213754654,
-0.7765335440635681,
-0.07231862843036652,
0.478196918964386,
0.13742683827877045,
-0.3230474293231964,
-0.6114005446434021,
-0.11087805777788162,
0.06476228684186935,
-0.13474756479263306,
0.0036978810094296932,
0.3963903486728668,
-0.3121773302555084,
0.9159579277038574,
0.7406168580055237,
0.08750364929437637,
0.3538162112236023,
-0.04128937050700188,
1.0770819187164307,
-0.5691649913787842,
-0.5771880149841309,
-0.7612870931625366,
0.12114559859037399,
0.19439274072647095,
-0.35814371705055237,
0.3112359642982483,
0.2901730239391327,
0.6454966068267822,
-0.172405406832695,
0.6136143803596497,
0.16158635914325714,
-0.11679898202419281,
-0.46880990266799927,
0.6388100385665894,
-0.4833788573741913,
0.32153064012527466,
0.044454582035541534,
-0.8249730467796326,
-0.5394800901412964,
0.6896702647209167,
-0.3393601179122925,
0.10046019405126572,
0.5332273840904236,
0.8767141103744507,
-0.1552295833826065,
0.15028198063373566,
0.1795325130224228,
-0.04128574579954147,
0.4631381630897522,
0.9442713260650635,
0.8406535983085632,
-0.3320923447608948,
0.409566193819046,
-0.16886687278747559,
-0.1982848048210144,
0.1208857074379921,
-0.5308956503868103,
-0.5722320675849915,
-0.4559069871902466,
-0.10382448881864548,
-0.0696418434381485,
0.36185571551322937,
0.9286003708839417,
0.5133107900619507,
-0.5542554259300232,
-0.0800841897726059,
-0.5596812963485718,
0.14350765943527222,
-0.48269397020339966,
-0.11446753144264221,
0.584669291973114,
-0.474388062953949,
-0.5989844799041748,
0.6157556772232056,
0.07333506643772125,
-0.42370593547821045,
-0.3362393379211426,
0.05316421017050743,
0.06777707487344742,
0.2075510025024414,
0.45565685629844666,
0.2418491393327713,
-0.5555735230445862,
-0.19924050569534302,
0.348676860332489,
0.15585535764694214,
-0.1047823429107666,
1.2412493228912354,
-0.6957629323005676,
0.108546681702137,
0.5454888343811035,
1.083545207977295,
0.10330616682767868,
-0.2691915035247803,
0.6482350826263428,
-0.5338216423988342,
-0.2730574309825897,
0.33322855830192566,
0.5665093064308167,
0.02950657159090042,
-0.2838502526283264,
-0.0591520257294178,
0.17500296235084534,
-0.27094602584838867,
-0.3858361840248108,
0.6527625918388367,
-0.43487349152565,
-0.3820112645626068,
0.6141521334648132,
-0.16597017645835876,
-0.7124118208885193,
-0.11018109321594238,
-0.200643390417099,
0.15714141726493835,
-0.22298218309879303,
0.9693921804428101,
0.28534048795700073,
-0.2822875380516052,
0.008059671148657799,
-0.04363870993256569,
0.14995239675045013,
0.6965031027793884,
-0.6285494565963745,
0.22921496629714966,
0.5312684178352356,
0.3753592371940613,
0.4177769720554352,
0.6181777715682983,
0.05961023271083832,
0.5356754064559937,
0.017892420291900635,
0.008635696023702621,
-0.5547424554824829,
-0.6297565698623657,
-0.4513348937034607,
0.4718126654624939,
-0.4283998906612396,
-0.17235302925109863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17400v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17400v1
|
Investigating Continual Pretraining in Large Language Models: Insights and Implications
| 2024-02-27T10:47:24 | 2024-02-27T10:47:24 |
Çağatay Yıldız, Nishaanth Kanna Ravichandran, Prishruit Punia, Matthias Bethge, Beyza Ermis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper studies the evolving domain of Continual Learning (CL) in large
language models (LLMs), with a focus on developing strategies for efficient and
sustainable training. Our primary emphasis is on continual domain-adaptive
pretraining, a process designed to equip LLMs with the ability to integrate new
information from various domains while retaining previously learned knowledge
and enhancing cross-domain knowledge transfer without relying on
domain-specific identification. Unlike previous studies, which mostly
concentrate on a limited selection of tasks or domains and primarily aim to
address the issue of forgetting, our research evaluates the adaptability and
capabilities of LLMs to changing data landscapes in practical scenarios. To
this end, we introduce a new benchmark designed to measure the adaptability of
LLMs to these evolving data environments, offering a comprehensive framework
for evaluation. We examine the impact of model size on learning efficacy and
forgetting, as well as how the progression and similarity of emerging domains
affect the knowledge transfer within these models. Our findings uncover several
key insights: (i) when the sequence of domains shows semantic similarity,
continual pretraining enables LLMs to better specialize in the current domain
compared to stand-alone fine-tuning, (ii) training across a diverse range of
domains enhances both backward and forward knowledge transfer, and (iii)
smaller models are particularly sensitive to continual pretraining, showing the
most significant rates of both forgetting and learning. We posit that our
research marks a shift towards establishing a more realistic benchmark for
investigating CL in LLMs, and has the potential to play a key role in guiding
the direction of future research in the field.
|
[
-0.30693984031677246,
-0.5687798857688904,
0.6052701473236084,
0.07035765051841736,
-0.21983931958675385,
0.14066773653030396,
-0.5862367749214172,
-0.34806981682777405,
-0.2950306236743927,
0.3758768141269684,
-0.5809034705162048,
-0.27710089087486267,
-0.7023613452911377,
0.043364621698856354,
-0.28546878695487976,
0.8775129318237305,
-0.26447802782058716,
-0.03688506409525871,
-0.41781601309776306,
-0.2696426808834076,
-0.9251760244369507,
-0.7046297192573547,
-0.8215802907943726,
-0.3722416162490845,
0.6449764966964722,
0.2115674763917923,
0.19237326085567474,
0.370903879404068,
0.29355841875076294,
0.21431905031204224,
0.09074122458696365,
-0.017433932051062584,
-1.0849708318710327,
0.15224426984786987,
-0.4659755825996399,
-0.39925989508628845,
-0.4300267696380615,
-0.07466110587120056,
1.1905878782272339,
1.050873041152954,
-0.12759394943714142,
0.23349373042583466,
0.4608810842037201,
0.7255027890205383,
-0.6924197673797607,
-0.09914145618677139,
-1.0997198820114136,
-0.1695718914270401,
-0.2790026068687439,
-0.22050537168979645,
-0.4188551604747772,
-0.13703610002994537,
0.4338566064834595,
-0.7089941501617432,
0.023063594475388527,
0.03140346333384514,
0.6680927276611328,
0.17562875151634216,
-0.14286848902702332,
-0.37662968039512634,
-0.7645941376686096,
0.9755162000656128,
-0.5732325911521912,
0.6262922883033752,
0.03371206298470497,
0.17037063837051392,
-0.2446962296962738,
-0.9281468391418457,
-0.3961597681045532,
-0.27487608790397644,
0.25462326407432556,
-0.01242833398282528,
-0.05008154362440109,
-0.33372750878334045,
0.09506513178348541,
0.10478043556213379,
-0.6256346106529236,
0.2920547127723694,
-0.1251729279756546,
-0.03941157087683678,
0.38840365409851074,
0.14476463198661804,
0.2955862283706665,
0.8296410441398621,
-0.35552340745925903,
0.09712520241737366,
-1.0996530055999756,
-0.17509759962558746,
-0.06359069794416428,
0.07653836905956268,
-0.08128151297569275,
-0.08687951415777206,
0.07046095281839371,
0.6742591261863708,
-0.11931922286748886,
-0.062200333923101425,
0.1817542314529419,
-0.3392648696899414,
-0.072390615940094,
-0.11195304244756699,
0.39985111355781555,
0.1133786290884018,
0.6890910267829895,
-0.30040040612220764,
-0.276985764503479,
-0.2307143211364746,
0.5379577875137329,
-0.5941480994224548,
-0.3676433265209198,
-0.20363260805606842,
-0.26344603300094604,
0.285366952419281,
-0.1987970471382141,
-0.5515437126159668,
-0.02590046264231205,
-0.579633891582489,
0.5587329864501953,
-0.5285914540290833,
-0.38466495275497437,
0.3347083032131195,
0.24517495930194855,
0.20448455214500427,
0.4130549132823944,
-0.815963625907898,
0.42524173855781555,
0.66761714220047,
0.9890589714050293,
-0.7106726169586182,
-0.7550594806671143,
-0.28332385420799255,
0.17514431476593018,
-0.5434314608573914,
0.6996865272521973,
-0.48854127526283264,
-0.4313274025917053,
0.04442640021443367,
0.2586316466331482,
-0.6085326075553894,
-0.9069337248802185,
0.007571736350655556,
-0.7220662832260132,
-0.2142389863729477,
-0.2890987694263458,
-0.670955240726471,
0.06983551383018494,
0.3442099690437317,
-0.3576522469520569,
0.7735641598701477,
0.20245356857776642,
-0.3849369287490845,
0.580793023109436,
-0.43027356266975403,
-0.2122601866722107,
0.10021600127220154,
0.21891750395298004,
-0.6092607975006104,
0.1673167198896408,
-0.31644612550735474,
0.3159753680229187,
-0.22035062313079834,
0.33069688081741333,
-0.5784510374069214,
-0.2425099015235901,
0.3369767665863037,
-0.28479358553886414,
0.403838574886322,
-0.029442554339766502,
-0.14690159261226654,
0.011706454679369926,
-0.6552063226699829,
-0.05960414186120033,
0.293811172246933,
-0.12572504580020905,
-0.42484530806541443,
0.04843740910291672,
-0.2838866114616394,
0.3425178825855255,
0.33039769530296326,
-0.27359703183174133,
0.3129469156265259,
-0.1028871089220047,
0.28095588088035583,
0.8438186645507812,
0.3747923970222473,
0.4051631689071655,
-0.57209712266922,
0.4261559545993805,
0.11185816675424576,
0.15215826034545898,
-0.22349432110786438,
0.05645051598548889,
-0.8482751846313477,
0.02668141946196556,
0.3671625852584839,
0.2515835464000702,
-0.5473551750183105,
0.26506149768829346,
-0.6789201498031616,
-0.48028019070625305,
-0.003764009801670909,
0.48157498240470886,
0.30106133222579956,
0.25389572978019714,
0.4221982955932617,
-0.7104074954986572,
-0.4789443910121918,
-0.38224098086357117,
-0.21143141388893127,
0.08906751126050949,
0.19684387743473053,
0.22356285154819489,
0.8563721776008606,
-0.34620070457458496,
0.7440689206123352,
-0.17332035303115845,
-0.19795285165309906,
-0.21025577187538147,
-0.11463713645935059,
-0.015672238543629646,
0.5975425243377686,
0.7138535976409912,
-0.4986407458782196,
-0.5997162461280823,
0.030564114451408386,
-0.7573343515396118,
0.11739027500152588,
-0.40511655807495117,
-0.1464054137468338,
0.04469403997063637,
0.5635792016983032,
-0.4475836455821991,
-0.015610736794769764,
0.530938982963562,
-0.029408972710371017,
0.8768451809883118,
-0.15880779922008514,
-0.17043568193912506,
-0.5651892423629761,
0.2157570868730545,
-0.3248334228992462,
-0.16536836326122284,
-0.794616162776947,
-0.19849158823490143,
0.010429969988763332,
0.17761391401290894,
-0.42262881994247437,
0.8386107683181763,
-0.613567054271698,
-0.08478306978940964,
-0.2880687415599823,
0.24252896010875702,
-0.3177144229412079,
0.33145463466644287,
0.08735080808401108,
0.9123347401618958,
0.7849445343017578,
-1.1084840297698975,
-0.06089940294623375,
0.01400295365601778,
-0.45042884349823,
0.4507519602775574,
-0.5636070370674133,
0.3206070363521576,
0.1524219959974289,
0.2909356653690338,
-0.7082977294921875,
0.1712644398212433,
-0.042401667684316635,
-0.3105883002281189,
0.44095689058303833,
-0.019870376214385033,
-0.35776907205581665,
-0.3041718304157257,
0.09999146312475204,
0.4561055600643158,
0.560980498790741,
-0.4464612603187561,
0.44856423139572144,
0.26926010847091675,
-0.5093790292739868,
-0.35096144676208496,
-0.23696483671665192,
0.032294951379299164,
-0.3441210389137268,
-0.3621232509613037,
0.3713712692260742,
-0.28036192059516907,
-0.09915433824062347,
-0.1429489701986313,
-0.36363843083381653,
0.022586263716220856,
0.48172256350517273,
0.058895379304885864,
0.20124760270118713,
-0.46614813804626465,
0.28027719259262085,
-0.2705793082714081,
-0.06103155389428139,
0.23916572332382202,
-0.8763071298599243,
0.7227462530136108,
-0.005090752150863409,
-0.21445180475711823,
-0.24542605876922607,
-0.029040582478046417,
0.5320988297462463,
-0.15431031584739685,
1.0650644302368164,
0.329619824886322,
-0.25590717792510986,
-0.5828834176063538,
-0.5354044437408447,
-0.06716258078813553,
-0.4480276107788086,
0.4519661068916321,
-0.4840938150882721,
-1.1155421733856201,
0.49419906735420227,
-0.669036328792572,
0.09780377149581909,
0.5695377588272095,
0.5780764222145081,
-0.10226620733737946,
0.3656471371650696,
1.0291218757629395,
-0.17420923709869385,
0.5386974811553955,
-0.17089161276817322,
-0.048867903649806976,
-0.9083603024482727,
-0.1361059993505478,
-0.2757650911808014,
-0.04945937171578407,
-0.07454543560743332,
-0.2798900902271271,
0.0804114043712616,
0.3575023114681244,
-0.4589071273803711,
0.12164449691772461,
0.04260052368044853,
0.3778885304927826,
-0.006806544028222561,
-0.087075375020504,
0.0812101811170578,
-0.2183784693479538,
0.07946163415908813,
0.08724826574325562,
-0.8652544021606445,
-0.36313191056251526,
1.2550419569015503,
0.34253108501434326,
0.5496618747711182,
0.0697626918554306,
0.5293021202087402,
0.2641952931880951,
0.5981727838516235,
-0.36069321632385254,
0.3906136453151703,
-0.06465526670217514,
-0.2650693356990814,
-0.3875042796134949,
-0.34527692198753357,
-1.1339778900146484,
0.010253055021166801,
-0.03853267803788185,
-0.6137223839759827,
0.07285250723361969,
0.27518653869628906,
-0.22168058156967163,
0.33082154393196106,
-0.38300684094429016,
0.9830561876296997,
-0.5502893328666687,
-0.45885390043258667,
-0.2913280725479126,
-0.44073787331581116,
0.13428018987178802,
-0.76814866065979,
0.10250433534383774,
-0.07609020173549652,
0.006091982126235962,
0.8638629913330078,
-0.019962184131145477,
0.9096817374229431,
-0.2292102426290512,
-0.20341196656227112,
0.306375116109848,
-0.019714612513780594,
0.39310309290885925,
-0.14665931463241577,
0.063077911734581,
0.3523558974266052,
-0.008420988917350769,
-0.5777364373207092,
-0.4649119973182678,
0.6821805238723755,
-0.8043016791343689,
-0.5790511965751648,
-0.2733480632305145,
-0.42213642597198486,
-0.6635371446609497,
0.38986119627952576,
0.03185329958796501,
0.2525440454483032,
-0.5049245357513428,
0.3532834053039551,
1.147886872291565,
-0.2703497111797333,
0.16097187995910645,
0.6852231025695801,
-0.22268158197402954,
0.05012156441807747,
1.0983152389526367,
0.31650030612945557,
0.6895964741706848,
0.1956762671470642,
-0.011571894399821758,
-0.1804586946964264,
-0.9701639413833618,
-0.11833219975233078,
0.4021703898906708,
-0.6338621973991394,
0.014809940941631794,
-0.6336009502410889,
-0.2662194073200226,
-0.3796367943286896,
-0.2544926702976227,
-0.5043472051620483,
0.14153744280338287,
-0.39978697896003723,
0.16912642121315002,
0.08448220044374466,
0.7157254219055176,
0.14202557504177094,
0.4057549238204956,
-0.77787184715271,
0.012902741320431232,
0.3260919153690338,
0.4551386535167694,
0.25814348459243774,
-1.0877822637557983,
-0.505795419216156,
-0.0779281035065651,
-0.20822186768054962,
-0.2389584481716156,
0.280475378036499,
0.5694639086723328,
0.9109322428703308,
0.08802089095115662,
-0.17645250260829926,
0.6863183379173279,
-0.7435881495475769,
0.8587622046470642,
0.19105775654315948,
-0.8181270360946655,
0.316855251789093,
-0.32588523626327515,
0.6060493588447571,
0.6681445837020874,
0.7488583326339722,
-0.5205037593841553,
-0.048339199274778366,
-0.48553815484046936,
-0.7372413873672485,
0.3884825110435486,
-0.25693076848983765,
0.21136139333248138,
0.23401738703250885,
0.618155837059021,
0.3523724377155304,
0.07507486641407013,
-0.5679844617843628,
-0.13465212285518646,
0.10826267302036285,
0.05759407579898834,
-0.3856585919857025,
-0.3442540764808655,
0.05453348159790039,
-0.2319924384355545,
0.7449539303779602,
-0.11660570651292801,
0.26527345180511475,
-0.2643031179904938,
-0.6249762177467346,
0.20982587337493896,
0.12111197412014008,
0.5916759967803955,
1.2375357151031494,
0.0015257474733516574,
-0.04362178593873978,
0.7093415260314941,
-0.5898048877716064,
0.18677806854248047,
-0.23842313885688782,
0.10954277962446213,
-0.11863669008016586,
0.6118119955062866,
0.8678858876228333,
0.40524059534072876,
-0.6757075786590576,
0.3580282926559448,
0.08995676040649414,
-0.30256736278533936,
-0.6184942722320557,
0.24283497035503387,
0.01039390079677105,
-0.028650937601923943,
0.2944488525390625,
0.11159908026456833,
-0.4241275191307068,
-0.6251511573791504,
0.45789116621017456,
0.22239220142364502,
-0.46172356605529785,
-0.449054479598999,
0.3481239974498749,
-0.050706811249256134,
-0.039530232548713684,
0.6551089286804199,
-0.003092055441811681,
-0.4804498255252838,
0.39050397276878357,
0.7139132618904114,
0.6992456316947937,
-0.33239245414733887,
-0.19940851628780365,
0.3134535253047943,
0.2126416265964508,
-0.39087262749671936,
-0.23317277431488037,
-0.08081367611885071,
-0.8400511741638184,
-0.3435439467430115,
-0.8047699928283691,
-0.33000051975250244,
0.24107886850833893,
-0.6534537076950073,
0.01862434297800064,
-0.4798291325569153,
-0.0666787177324295,
-0.18454666435718536,
-0.08616901189088821,
-0.8547512888908386,
0.3681175112724304,
0.2005850225687027,
0.9041798114776611,
-0.7442662715911865,
1.254170298576355,
0.4044383764266968,
0.006655667908489704,
-0.4829142391681671,
0.08363732695579529,
0.045347701758146286,
-0.8112832307815552,
0.6771288514137268,
0.1261598765850067,
-0.40503546595573425,
0.23000122606754303,
-0.5893549919128418,
-1.104800820350647,
1.1887869834899902,
0.17477285861968994,
-0.8650011420249939,
0.02331986464560032,
0.009130860678851604,
0.5476863384246826,
-0.6271108388900757,
-0.23934000730514526,
0.8328968286514282,
0.2001313418149948,
-0.04147438332438469,
-0.8599681854248047,
-0.16388919949531555,
-0.1713627725839615,
0.05633793771266937,
0.16189521551132202,
-0.6168442368507385,
0.704798698425293,
-0.04732726514339447,
-0.3532423675060272,
0.21371708810329437,
0.6508965492248535,
0.20778776705265045,
0.266886830329895,
0.4973243474960327,
0.4300627112388611,
0.7529574036598206,
-0.12032832950353622,
0.8275914192199707,
-0.439914345741272,
0.3301630914211273,
1.2687128782272339,
-0.6012396812438965,
0.8375022411346436,
0.2783658504486084,
-0.25666993856430054,
0.5620915293693542,
0.597007691860199,
-0.0031014459673315287,
0.4816008508205414,
0.39845719933509827,
-0.2406255304813385,
-0.34762153029441833,
0.07796519994735718,
-0.5005105137825012,
0.09172596037387848,
0.6407663822174072,
-0.10691336542367935,
0.03603556752204895,
0.31724196672439575,
-0.06285228580236435,
-0.05610794946551323,
-0.5023276805877686,
0.7727623581886292,
0.3660997450351715,
-0.6826050281524658,
0.7412217259407043,
-0.394095242023468,
0.6527979969978333,
-1.0277013778686523,
0.23316356539726257,
-0.21466121077537537,
0.33753570914268494,
0.19258618354797363,
-0.5171679854393005,
0.24431832134723663,
-0.07637801766395569,
-0.18326404690742493,
-0.43281474709510803,
0.6046280264854431,
-0.34659019112586975,
-0.05884750187397003,
0.48382559418678284,
0.5111048817634583,
0.1884484887123108,
0.06322886049747467,
-0.7863067984580994,
0.43438711762428284,
-0.11663450300693512,
-0.23432797193527222,
0.8204966187477112,
0.5751986503601074,
-0.09273936599493027,
0.8414379954338074,
0.6199108362197876,
0.29691752791404724,
0.19032931327819824,
0.1102236732840538,
0.8888171911239624,
-0.5945324301719666,
-0.26604244112968445,
-0.6982094049453735,
0.2764612138271332,
0.17114776372909546,
-0.5875825881958008,
0.8161849975585938,
0.3539862632751465,
1.171250581741333,
-0.15329618752002716,
0.7725898027420044,
0.306804358959198,
0.37034401297569275,
-0.7998203635215759,
0.7085152268409729,
-0.5733020305633545,
0.33156511187553406,
-0.0037107188254594803,
-1.0483230352401733,
-0.18737858533859253,
0.31098267436027527,
-0.6328992247581482,
0.2784714698791504,
0.8399232029914856,
0.4659706652164459,
-0.019384169951081276,
-0.31390380859375,
0.39587393403053284,
0.3424914479255676,
0.16250890493392944,
0.7035749554634094,
0.922789454460144,
-0.029554370790719986,
0.16747084259986877,
0.204970121383667,
0.008282067254185677,
0.015928486362099648,
-0.6768476366996765,
-0.8263760805130005,
-0.6825856566429138,
-0.40889081358909607,
-0.10076717287302017,
0.5088562369346619,
0.6598100662231445,
0.6266301870346069,
-0.8508942723274231,
-0.22857995331287384,
-0.10148292034864426,
-0.23981189727783203,
-0.28426429629325867,
-0.11345157772302628,
0.34153106808662415,
-0.6841704249382019,
-0.2604255974292755,
0.2910875380039215,
0.3708522319793701,
0.011111223138868809,
-0.20948462188243866,
-0.23882828652858734,
-0.29324254393577576,
0.01958867721259594,
0.661420464515686,
0.5713112354278564,
-0.38096749782562256,
-0.4600468575954437,
-0.11047224700450897,
0.056559063494205475,
-0.03249813988804817,
0.925011932849884,
-0.7025738954544067,
0.30671927332878113,
-0.17005765438079834,
1.0459730625152588,
0.522781252861023,
-0.20379768311977386,
0.5810864567756653,
-0.48110032081604004,
-0.0385376438498497,
0.17663703858852386,
0.24354730546474457,
0.35092005133628845,
0.025601407513022423,
0.3125481903553009,
0.4602835774421692,
-0.8245535492897034,
-0.7590892910957336,
0.17361415922641754,
-0.7307736277580261,
-0.390208899974823,
1.0998727083206177,
-0.5360668301582336,
-0.13045594096183777,
-0.4246513843536377,
0.2753152847290039,
-0.0025453204289078712,
0.19377443194389343,
0.5952479839324951,
0.7285345792770386,
0.026762573048472404,
-0.24969521164894104,
-0.6838575601577759,
0.46955016255378723,
0.46823933720588684,
-0.7718396782875061,
0.2097148299217224,
0.2786913514137268,
0.7728543281555176,
-0.12246137112379074,
0.7730116844177246,
0.05114619806408882,
0.27421125769615173,
0.12454536557197571,
-0.13155129551887512,
0.24850623309612274,
-0.7285822033882141,
-0.46777334809303284,
-0.056586772203445435,
0.33995214104652405,
0.22336719930171967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17396v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17396v1
|
Benchmarking GPT-4 on Algorithmic Problems: A Systematic Evaluation of Prompting Strategies
| 2024-02-27T10:44:52 | 2024-02-27T10:44:52 |
Flavio Petruzzellis, Alberto Testolin, Alessandro Sperduti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.NE
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized the field of Natural
Language Processing thanks to their ability to reuse knowledge acquired on
massive text corpora on a wide variety of downstream tasks, with minimal (if
any) tuning steps. At the same time, it has been repeatedly shown that LLMs
lack systematic generalization, which allows to extrapolate the learned
statistical regularities outside the training distribution. In this work, we
offer a systematic benchmarking of GPT-4, one of the most advanced LLMs
available, on three algorithmic tasks characterized by the possibility to
control the problem difficulty with two parameters. We compare the performance
of GPT-4 with that of its predecessor (GPT-3.5) and with a variant of the
Transformer-Encoder architecture recently introduced to solve similar tasks,
the Neural Data Router. We find that the deployment of advanced prompting
techniques allows GPT-4 to reach superior accuracy on all tasks, demonstrating
that state-of-the-art LLMs constitute a very strong baseline also in
challenging tasks that require systematic generalization.
|
[
-0.31132176518440247,
-0.8831399083137512,
0.7934876680374146,
0.3686382472515106,
-0.09953586012125015,
0.034661177545785904,
-0.5549153685569763,
-0.15147078037261963,
-0.26268529891967773,
0.07924254983663559,
-0.5645023584365845,
-0.5620629787445068,
-0.6804550886154175,
0.6466438174247742,
-0.3551389276981354,
1.0057554244995117,
-0.3873451054096222,
0.2015472650527954,
-0.039665695279836655,
0.10833370685577393,
-0.6651296019554138,
-0.38134676218032837,
-0.9097476005554199,
-0.413419246673584,
0.5352314710617065,
0.16478155553340912,
0.5624752044677734,
0.5215233564376831,
0.6195691227912903,
0.3319987952709198,
-0.030504057183861732,
-0.14021167159080505,
-0.3648393452167511,
0.36022672057151794,
-0.0024730199947953224,
-0.4797224700450897,
-0.27484914660453796,
-0.05455571785569191,
0.6967960000038147,
0.6588543057441711,
-0.22560715675354004,
-0.0012640058994293213,
0.11847223341464996,
0.7305421829223633,
-0.2354782074689865,
0.3178676962852478,
-0.531108021736145,
0.050146594643592834,
-0.2731274664402008,
-0.14994320273399353,
-0.14164254069328308,
-0.7090266942977905,
0.1970982700586319,
-0.743101954460144,
0.5281916260719299,
-0.01861354522407055,
0.6095757484436035,
0.4825344383716583,
-0.12225346267223358,
-0.4869441092014313,
-0.7331652045249939,
0.6252820491790771,
-0.5156040787696838,
0.5610278248786926,
0.37309759855270386,
0.32143479585647583,
-0.1422831267118454,
-0.8820869326591492,
-0.4453245997428894,
-0.34018197655677795,
0.37210217118263245,
0.045907068997621536,
-0.4606359601020813,
0.06582196056842804,
0.6237701177597046,
0.276603102684021,
-0.6486284136772156,
0.08263851702213287,
-0.36703377962112427,
-0.207168310880661,
0.1888439655303955,
0.07322172075510025,
-0.048288412392139435,
0.16025111079216003,
-0.178294375538826,
-0.1603350043296814,
-0.7694485783576965,
-0.06720093637704849,
0.4483036398887634,
0.07027868926525116,
0.1640446037054062,
0.20833100378513336,
-0.48222672939300537,
0.6941043734550476,
0.1775975227355957,
0.3053124248981476,
0.4358411729335785,
-0.38523927330970764,
0.053692903369665146,
-0.3603386878967285,
0.9087277054786682,
0.32303449511528015,
0.4418458044528961,
-0.1967255026102066,
-0.4342055320739746,
0.1205519288778305,
0.27463412284851074,
-0.6454367637634277,
-0.42174988985061646,
0.01009401585906744,
-0.22699026763439178,
0.057947419583797455,
-0.37372174859046936,
-0.883086085319519,
-0.24356141686439514,
-0.25147321820259094,
0.34759587049484253,
-0.4141710102558136,
0.015951478853821754,
0.08642950654029846,
-0.08424896746873856,
0.43972527980804443,
0.20306913554668427,
-1.1581882238388062,
0.6085827350616455,
0.8306959271430969,
1.0775753259658813,
-0.4287314713001251,
-0.2196846455335617,
-0.6309103965759277,
-0.12976953387260437,
-0.4413006603717804,
0.7558890581130981,
-0.6266652345657349,
-0.2448405921459198,
0.12720683217048645,
-0.2141076773405075,
-0.13457250595092773,
-0.6463743448257446,
1.0426453351974487,
-0.593398928642273,
0.13844777643680573,
-0.6669745445251465,
-0.6191514134407043,
-0.09407024830579758,
0.5738357901573181,
-0.6981928944587708,
1.0527927875518799,
0.057597726583480835,
-0.627580463886261,
0.253740131855011,
-0.6578654646873474,
-0.20859117805957794,
0.22228743135929108,
-0.3482508659362793,
-0.2672383785247803,
0.13341926038265228,
0.42603951692581177,
0.33321380615234375,
-0.5171887874603271,
0.2518337070941925,
0.013513429090380669,
-0.49651116132736206,
-0.13020963966846466,
-0.581608235836029,
0.2400396168231964,
0.030115162953734398,
-0.6446139216423035,
0.18641120195388794,
-0.430845707654953,
-0.005999648477882147,
0.18308673799037933,
-0.4583219587802887,
-0.07026921212673187,
-0.03584873676300049,
-0.41993826627731323,
0.10654762387275696,
0.3038053810596466,
-0.38359200954437256,
0.3067438304424286,
-0.21938331425189972,
0.5194810032844543,
0.7320030927658081,
-0.034716833382844925,
0.17762576043605804,
-0.34078317880630493,
0.7126594185829163,
-0.29901066422462463,
0.08432751148939133,
-0.14979007840156555,
-0.7657686471939087,
-0.631607174873352,
-0.01791219599545002,
0.43652868270874023,
0.6026190519332886,
-0.9104508757591248,
0.0955016016960144,
-0.35843709111213684,
-0.30013009905815125,
-0.41787803173065186,
0.29048168659210205,
0.35524043440818787,
0.44463050365448,
0.49717018008232117,
-0.24922725558280945,
-0.2231760323047638,
-0.863784909248352,
-0.3704962730407715,
0.07005702704191208,
-0.28961583971977234,
0.16861045360565186,
0.25338974595069885,
-0.10846817493438721,
0.683718740940094,
-0.20700526237487793,
-0.06454616039991379,
-0.2622207999229431,
0.3464503288269043,
0.38018694519996643,
0.2715614140033722,
0.08277314901351929,
-0.5806424021720886,
-0.4728860855102539,
-0.17016971111297607,
-0.7175164818763733,
-0.3655882477760315,
0.10946089029312134,
0.329013466835022,
0.12636569142341614,
0.6580830812454224,
-0.7289912104606628,
0.08064620941877365,
0.6097297072410583,
0.08980783820152283,
0.6158461570739746,
-0.42233914136886597,
0.12051189690828323,
-0.5655383467674255,
0.022558340802788734,
0.09272526204586029,
0.05477549508213997,
-0.9695903062820435,
-0.19895122945308685,
0.19748380780220032,
-0.029479123651981354,
-0.04332256689667702,
0.26121246814727783,
-0.5410950183868408,
-0.05909413844347,
-0.1252135932445526,
0.12506194412708282,
-0.2905122935771942,
0.5253055691719055,
0.032519977539777756,
0.8078643083572388,
0.6260042786598206,
-0.5702481269836426,
0.6403961777687073,
0.12566350400447845,
-0.08676939457654953,
0.39214780926704407,
-0.8989644050598145,
0.5738791227340698,
-0.046089209616184235,
0.26800957322120667,
-1.0588815212249756,
-0.06717187166213989,
0.2056317925453186,
-0.272783100605011,
0.1989208608865738,
0.018449584022164345,
-0.6714937090873718,
-0.5494587421417236,
-0.3779508173465729,
0.4895569980144501,
0.680747389793396,
-0.4331282377243042,
0.43592238426208496,
-0.22488585114479065,
-0.5405539274215698,
-0.25013306736946106,
-0.30412757396698,
0.30322501063346863,
-0.2635192275047302,
-0.32881560921669006,
0.40060320496559143,
-0.1974625438451767,
-0.016776137053966522,
-0.2586747407913208,
-0.041960347443819046,
0.11446285247802734,
-0.19170553982257843,
-0.041091348975896835,
0.0649278312921524,
-0.0717104822397232,
-0.006673565600067377,
-0.17114998400211334,
-0.31399601697921753,
0.3513396382331848,
-0.30772683024406433,
0.6654008626937866,
-0.2155381143093109,
-0.5894923210144043,
-0.3852469325065613,
0.15967032313346863,
0.14868740737438202,
-0.09201841801404953,
0.06281936168670654,
0.4379715025424957,
-0.20565295219421387,
-0.06565554440021515,
-0.7360033988952637,
-0.34153398871421814,
-0.49920132756233215,
0.2564889192581177,
-0.49226635694503784,
-0.8010926246643066,
0.4645337760448456,
-0.3443402349948883,
0.08888323605060577,
0.17427892982959747,
0.4807700216770172,
0.2784474492073059,
1.1603940725326538,
0.3342002332210541,
-0.35122331976890564,
0.40658366680145264,
-0.0927780419588089,
0.145578995347023,
-0.7133354544639587,
-0.11534296721220016,
-0.6249571442604065,
-0.32206815481185913,
-0.6943829655647278,
-0.3830282390117645,
0.49155861139297485,
-0.00700445007532835,
-0.28109055757522583,
0.13544093072414398,
-0.4701860547065735,
0.4209909439086914,
0.69378262758255,
-0.10088260471820831,
0.36184439063072205,
-0.09389971196651459,
-0.2207293063402176,
-0.008303183130919933,
-0.7957886457443237,
-0.4214245676994324,
1.1435096263885498,
0.3903909921646118,
0.6389904618263245,
0.021838078275322914,
0.6793124079704285,
-0.09700825065374374,
0.287759929895401,
-0.6686725616455078,
0.5586333870887756,
0.10135718435049057,
-0.2512178122997284,
-0.28006452322006226,
-0.5996518731117249,
-1.0915250778198242,
0.07346510142087936,
0.09342989325523376,
-0.5489817261695862,
-0.1220499724149704,
0.2727057635784149,
-0.2766432464122772,
0.062217772006988525,
-0.5832227468490601,
0.7064405679702759,
-0.12430772930383682,
-0.2996421456336975,
-0.002453651512041688,
-0.5367162823677063,
0.15757471323013306,
-0.24942849576473236,
0.2470821887254715,
0.055254675447940826,
-0.2842479348182678,
0.7344503402709961,
0.008425381034612656,
0.6678429245948792,
-0.3336024284362793,
-0.05855286121368408,
-0.033864375203847885,
0.019254254177212715,
0.8923740386962891,
-0.29346999526023865,
-0.1369589865207672,
0.17193974554538727,
-0.34711921215057373,
-0.2718801498413086,
-0.6397389769554138,
0.7074348330497742,
-0.5404094457626343,
-0.5637130737304688,
-0.38548389077186584,
-0.43264040350914,
-0.5287675261497498,
0.29239264130592346,
0.5026010274887085,
0.5860825777053833,
-0.15302713215351105,
0.07136178761720657,
0.8015649914741516,
-0.08242854475975037,
0.6153350472450256,
0.2567899823188782,
0.08882059901952744,
-0.3650631904602051,
0.8508719801902771,
0.10594535619020462,
0.2645697593688965,
0.15018750727176666,
0.30859702825546265,
-0.5100759863853455,
-1.0617111921310425,
-0.5768337249755859,
0.08729824423789978,
-0.648478627204895,
-0.17201223969459534,
-0.47374075651168823,
-0.008554704487323761,
-0.1777624636888504,
0.0324145182967186,
-0.1967952996492386,
0.015601939521729946,
0.0006607103277929127,
-0.03796585649251938,
0.3252764642238617,
1.1821411848068237,
0.1154547929763794,
0.19510619342327118,
-0.5884957313537598,
0.2901020646095276,
0.4740188717842102,
0.667290449142456,
-0.1892782300710678,
-0.4720456600189209,
-0.004109813366085291,
-0.2970276474952698,
-0.49430230259895325,
-0.8793182969093323,
0.15095803141593933,
0.054475776851177216,
0.6920490264892578,
0.1521395593881607,
-0.13182279467582703,
0.28030872344970703,
-0.8871712684631348,
0.8009645938873291,
0.02972347103059292,
-0.8589097857475281,
0.380963534116745,
-0.6476996541023254,
0.6267680525779724,
0.5944799184799194,
0.5715728998184204,
-0.5195772647857666,
-0.32285380363464355,
-0.5329980254173279,
-0.8012783527374268,
0.40319353342056274,
0.3091743290424347,
0.05456101521849632,
-0.15662045776844025,
0.4962500333786011,
-0.010324105620384216,
0.2306714951992035,
-0.5433271527290344,
0.026835089549422264,
-0.23957344889640808,
-0.3469940423965454,
-0.06102270632982254,
-0.059379540383815765,
-0.01592716947197914,
-0.021065570414066315,
0.5362566113471985,
-0.17907647788524628,
0.3082415461540222,
0.1465112566947937,
0.04732751473784447,
0.10911443084478378,
0.30363988876342773,
0.5988149642944336,
0.6774007081985474,
-0.010474562644958496,
0.14748413860797882,
0.5070143938064575,
-0.508201539516449,
0.09229535609483719,
0.39062219858169556,
-0.20977945625782013,
-0.0016377173596993089,
0.39528679847717285,
0.7554662227630615,
0.31439366936683655,
-0.4609871506690979,
0.4655596613883972,
-0.23458261787891388,
-0.5388533473014832,
0.07974187284708023,
0.040226537734270096,
0.07865140587091446,
0.17998239398002625,
0.5339451432228088,
-0.26994588971138,
0.38520848751068115,
-0.11940474063158035,
0.016833381727337837,
0.452724426984787,
-0.27580031752586365,
-0.48348718881607056,
0.4838606119155884,
0.2622119188308716,
-0.5415265560150146,
0.5715288519859314,
-0.3582291603088379,
-0.646895706653595,
0.3139270842075348,
0.5617252588272095,
0.9159880876541138,
-0.32489827275276184,
-0.05975664407014847,
0.34728777408599854,
0.3804805874824524,
-0.5221090912818909,
0.3314242660999298,
-0.10037466883659363,
-0.558221161365509,
-0.6576166749000549,
-0.3229881227016449,
-0.6785528659820557,
0.1827821433544159,
-0.5646325945854187,
0.03183500096201897,
-0.5266432166099548,
-0.15002453327178955,
-0.07477430999279022,
0.05820614472031593,
-0.7976000905036926,
-0.09634663164615631,
-0.05119672790169716,
0.9641147255897522,
-0.6477522253990173,
0.5838012099266052,
0.49950656294822693,
-0.015160271897912025,
-0.8299965858459473,
0.14028702676296234,
0.12628912925720215,
-0.6807741522789001,
0.44443294405937195,
0.267213374376297,
-0.1233665943145752,
0.21346761286258698,
-0.4166408181190491,
-0.7318049073219299,
0.9569507837295532,
0.34386131167411804,
-0.857735276222229,
0.03218812867999077,
0.0048820385709404945,
0.5894140601158142,
-0.023262890055775642,
0.3497348427772522,
0.8662348389625549,
0.6703501343727112,
0.04448273405432701,
-1.0445460081100464,
0.1734791249036789,
-0.21490147709846497,
0.16259726881980896,
0.3005010783672333,
-0.4524499475955963,
0.7969616055488586,
0.08793208748102188,
-0.08878710865974426,
0.021594829857349396,
0.4802256226539612,
0.3723360598087311,
0.18329907953739166,
0.6367078423500061,
0.3310195803642273,
0.8751549124717712,
-0.23872920870780945,
0.983244776725769,
-0.2687968909740448,
0.16411732137203217,
0.8774985074996948,
-0.41223111748695374,
0.736201822757721,
0.3012728989124298,
-0.2935381531715393,
0.3116511106491089,
0.5755285024642944,
0.007168869487941265,
0.4650270342826843,
0.5187502503395081,
-0.4307217001914978,
0.19401568174362183,
0.27788886427879333,
-0.36155930161476135,
0.12047171592712402,
0.23004403710365295,
-0.05754997581243515,
-0.4014458954334259,
-0.07335154712200165,
-0.03311607986688614,
-0.020910929888486862,
-0.3137315511703491,
1.0098801851272583,
-0.07595837861299515,
-0.9851120710372925,
0.6172800660133362,
-0.1499919593334198,
0.7477083206176758,
-0.7428970336914062,
-0.06659327447414398,
-0.32316458225250244,
0.046399638056755066,
0.05791091546416283,
-0.6288800835609436,
0.14739938080310822,
0.13962090015411377,
-0.09306371212005615,
-0.2777683436870575,
0.515929102897644,
-0.3461194336414337,
-0.2511803209781647,
0.22446508705615997,
0.44018882513046265,
0.25968366861343384,
-0.22751128673553467,
-0.7319270372390747,
0.3924623429775238,
-0.14011093974113464,
-0.4388659596443176,
0.22806580364704132,
0.4976552426815033,
-0.1782885491847992,
0.6975080370903015,
0.6099737286567688,
0.16476193070411682,
0.16868256032466888,
0.4084740877151489,
0.9412858486175537,
-0.7329891324043274,
-0.2532529830932617,
-0.9030439853668213,
-0.14569911360740662,
-0.0431026816368103,
-0.34298744797706604,
0.8241159915924072,
0.3659806549549103,
0.6255766749382019,
0.1957809329032898,
0.8168984055519104,
0.16651105880737305,
0.48790687322616577,
-0.6237509250640869,
0.021022459492087364,
0.07308736443519592,
0.30595308542251587,
-0.23775921761989594,
-1.175857424736023,
-0.332154244184494,
0.5289242267608643,
-0.5604154467582703,
0.4212798476219177,
0.7674785852432251,
0.7527751922607422,
0.05691371485590935,
0.2755686342716217,
0.16046501696109772,
0.09541688114404678,
0.46035709977149963,
0.6305866837501526,
0.9253405332565308,
-0.12575408816337585,
0.6465396285057068,
0.05409717187285423,
-0.45619699358940125,
0.06697448343038559,
-0.9989439845085144,
-0.7870854735374451,
-0.42594102025032043,
-0.07476659119129181,
-0.01737823896110058,
0.3182480037212372,
0.8006852269172668,
0.5957496166229248,
-0.774904727935791,
-0.11438050866127014,
-0.41597095131874084,
-0.07143829017877579,
-0.32801148295402527,
-0.10376424342393875,
0.2571367025375366,
-0.6139075756072998,
-0.752239465713501,
0.707165539264679,
0.14110295474529266,
-0.10739533603191376,
-0.2861298620700836,
-0.15985162556171417,
0.0683424174785614,
-0.14381223917007446,
0.27103424072265625,
0.23049408197402954,
-0.5786581039428711,
-0.2788065969944,
0.02607857994735241,
0.10038980841636658,
0.09738010168075562,
0.9470561742782593,
-0.7140487432479858,
0.34752023220062256,
0.5218939781188965,
0.8416070938110352,
0.6342369914054871,
0.15744969248771667,
0.7977129817008972,
-0.6209231019020081,
-0.3790178596973419,
0.2872161269187927,
0.2652422785758972,
0.5976930856704712,
-0.13939444720745087,
0.500278651714325,
0.0852850079536438,
-0.8807455897331238,
-0.6134113073348999,
0.14201560616493225,
-0.5258931517601013,
0.0385623574256897,
1.1764439344406128,
-0.020018991082906723,
0.105172298848629,
-0.36455079913139343,
-0.16986140608787537,
-0.004629010800272226,
-0.5688602328300476,
0.4652531147003174,
0.8135419487953186,
-0.3309091627597809,
-0.2559073567390442,
-1.1035783290863037,
0.7673975825309753,
0.5796107649803162,
-0.7448451519012451,
0.1714920997619629,
0.3904414176940918,
0.4515182375907898,
0.0024028748739510775,
0.9009611010551453,
0.0388995036482811,
0.16426412761211395,
-0.1495724618434906,
-0.1290436089038849,
-0.0370422899723053,
-0.3368295431137085,
-0.8733747601509094,
0.14383549988269806,
0.13839538395404816,
-0.02560087852180004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17392v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17392v1
|
Spot the bot: Coarse-Grained Partition of Semantic Paths for Bots and Humans
| 2024-02-27T10:38:37 | 2024-02-27T10:38:37 |
Vasilii A. Gromov, Alexandra S. Kogan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Nowadays, technology is rapidly advancing: bots are writing comments,
articles, and reviews. Due to this fact, it is crucial to know if the text was
written by a human or by a bot. This paper focuses on comparing structures of
the coarse-grained partitions of semantic paths for human-written and
bot-generated texts. We compare the clusterizations of datasets of n-grams from
literary texts and texts generated by several bots. The hypothesis is that the
structures and clusterizations are different. Our research supports the
hypothesis. As the semantic structure may be different for different languages,
we investigate Russian, English, German, and Vietnamese languages.
|
[
-0.14881981909275055,
-1.0887407064437866,
0.7739606499671936,
-0.007007706444710493,
0.05293819308280945,
0.1568002998828888,
-0.10331554710865021,
-0.4131583273410797,
0.2702116072177887,
0.47889748215675354,
-0.5628477334976196,
-0.7136936783790588,
-0.4812362790107727,
0.3218739628791809,
-0.48864448070526123,
0.9736306071281433,
0.2775762975215912,
0.011076542548835278,
-0.43567168712615967,
-0.10129275172948837,
-0.35477370023727417,
-0.3500867187976837,
-0.4259309470653534,
-0.08552475273609161,
0.8679905533790588,
0.11119472235441208,
0.7965526580810547,
0.6835368275642395,
0.6695408821105957,
0.4924410581588745,
-0.13704617321491241,
-0.12378612905740738,
-0.015201562084257603,
0.2858055830001831,
-0.2598201334476471,
-0.5866231322288513,
-0.07562440633773804,
-0.23910748958587646,
0.883389413356781,
0.7332518100738525,
0.2860787808895111,
0.04352759197354317,
-0.12393106520175934,
0.8399053812026978,
-0.4138132631778717,
-0.13525111973285675,
-0.47775477170944214,
-0.015803134068846703,
-0.5246214270591736,
-0.14612145721912384,
-0.272205114364624,
-0.4844651520252228,
0.1131533831357956,
-0.5168107151985168,
0.7521177530288696,
0.003838819684460759,
0.9676939249038696,
0.30543047189712524,
-0.39583802223205566,
-0.41213148832321167,
-0.5448945164680481,
0.9408796429634094,
-0.5355185866355896,
0.1537563055753708,
0.32743704319000244,
0.2813520133495331,
-0.46094053983688354,
-0.5155487060546875,
-0.536144495010376,
-0.3563297390937805,
-0.28005316853523254,
-0.17632344365119934,
-0.044066958129405975,
-0.1806817203760147,
0.09323351085186005,
0.30944937467575073,
-0.6370763182640076,
-0.018057065084576607,
-0.3060877323150635,
-0.6046936511993408,
0.6521922945976257,
0.08488462120294571,
0.63690185546875,
-0.4738764464855194,
-0.47333961725234985,
-0.3389824628829956,
-0.4965234398841858,
-0.01855066791176796,
0.5780037045478821,
0.34222906827926636,
-0.0286770798265934,
0.5424293875694275,
-0.3862464129924774,
0.9436076879501343,
-0.3460935354232788,
-0.4616797864437103,
0.31308162212371826,
-0.5795589089393616,
0.09108804166316986,
-0.03708718344569206,
1.0388022661209106,
0.43500664830207825,
0.3439885675907135,
-0.4789614677429199,
-0.10299676656723022,
0.25575146079063416,
0.2744612395763397,
-0.3115673065185547,
-0.23103122413158417,
0.07459043711423874,
-0.5313694477081299,
-0.3858829140663147,
0.320252388715744,
-0.6580711603164673,
-0.7695577144622803,
-0.01483945269137621,
0.32540982961654663,
-0.4476870894432068,
-0.12363515049219131,
-0.038042280822992325,
-0.5656487345695496,
0.48919960856437683,
0.41127628087997437,
-0.5512384176254272,
0.3631136417388916,
0.7196351885795593,
1.1175941228866577,
-0.16885708272457123,
-0.4497983753681183,
-0.29248324036598206,
0.09418602287769318,
-0.3162769079208374,
1.2385183572769165,
-0.46590787172317505,
-0.2311941385269165,
0.026765767484903336,
-0.02406829036772251,
0.10357026755809784,
-0.4487764537334442,
0.6898683309555054,
-0.3323538303375244,
0.25536492466926575,
-0.3706261217594147,
-0.6272749304771423,
-0.4511226713657379,
0.2996196746826172,
-0.5910120606422424,
1.112166166305542,
0.22902004420757294,
-0.901811957359314,
0.6322605609893799,
-0.5089355111122131,
-0.6169591546058655,
0.11411488801240921,
-0.3798372745513916,
-0.15589827299118042,
-0.03092029131948948,
-0.0644858330488205,
0.37665438652038574,
-0.13835278153419495,
0.2453499585390091,
-0.1385931819677353,
-0.16951969265937805,
0.3226189613342285,
-0.20411820709705353,
0.6863821148872375,
0.10881417989730835,
-0.3603868782520294,
0.29871588945388794,
-1.0260519981384277,
-0.10359780490398407,
0.2044440656900406,
-0.34538140892982483,
-0.511254072189331,
0.6282640099525452,
0.32338178157806396,
0.06614097952842712,
0.32668688893318176,
-0.8331001996994019,
0.25610509514808655,
-0.27057206630706787,
0.4772210717201233,
0.8374629020690918,
-0.03901153430342674,
0.6356424689292908,
-0.5090375542640686,
0.36622899770736694,
0.049942534416913986,
-0.05779707804322243,
-0.32069915533065796,
-0.7310858964920044,
-0.6137852668762207,
-0.15578578412532806,
0.37855398654937744,
0.5080716609954834,
-0.4622935354709625,
0.5396885275840759,
-0.29288649559020996,
-0.6091377139091492,
-0.46584758162498474,
-0.123483806848526,
0.3591829836368561,
0.2976001799106598,
0.1554698497056961,
-0.32622230052948,
-0.16093319654464722,
-0.6978897452354431,
-0.47524863481521606,
-0.269527792930603,
-0.24906320869922638,
0.32611361145973206,
0.3923252522945404,
-0.09302159398794174,
1.1361631155014038,
-0.6747337579727173,
-0.28906065225601196,
-0.16193023324012756,
0.09086735546588898,
-0.14707694947719574,
0.4948042929172516,
0.6503700613975525,
-0.6914005279541016,
-0.7057145237922668,
0.08299225568771362,
-0.46195992827415466,
-0.1894368976354599,
-0.07353827357292175,
-0.3271619975566864,
0.27227944135665894,
0.7391441464424133,
-0.4150419533252716,
0.58095782995224,
0.22587069869041443,
-0.6551938056945801,
0.34808114171028137,
-0.2930498421192169,
0.07746335119009018,
-0.9354390501976013,
-0.020526068285107613,
-0.16128863394260406,
-0.3890751600265503,
-0.6312510371208191,
-0.12106829136610031,
-0.32123681902885437,
0.256771445274353,
-0.22395439445972443,
0.6554194688796997,
-0.24309135973453522,
-0.2579512298107147,
-0.3291431665420532,
0.43100738525390625,
-0.17468982934951782,
0.4058474004268646,
0.1530488133430481,
0.44394704699516296,
0.5126310586929321,
-0.4620799720287323,
0.01964493654668331,
0.059650421142578125,
-0.45624855160713196,
0.5114521384239197,
-0.7359700798988342,
0.22062434256076813,
-0.058222439140081406,
0.35782140493392944,
-1.3156167268753052,
-0.3757297992706299,
0.25145676732063293,
-0.5669487118721008,
-0.17039550840854645,
-0.014822914265096188,
-0.95419842004776,
-0.010399490594863892,
-0.3687703609466553,
0.37926843762397766,
0.2862551212310791,
0.1415451318025589,
0.48837509751319885,
0.5448532104492188,
-0.11465674638748169,
-0.22415058314800262,
-0.3690313994884491,
0.23241950571537018,
-0.14604730904102325,
-0.9658693075180054,
0.1783721148967743,
-0.004073341842740774,
-0.5155771374702454,
0.07229968160390854,
0.15495258569717407,
-0.2629021406173706,
0.2599295973777771,
0.3479122817516327,
-0.027354832738637924,
-0.28443264961242676,
0.13925957679748535,
-0.09663902968168259,
-0.13631011545658112,
-0.13233312964439392,
-0.05584542453289032,
0.7858448624610901,
0.05893455445766449,
-0.05867445096373558,
-0.4438035786151886,
0.45705747604370117,
0.4239582121372223,
0.10275346040725708,
0.7492923140525818,
0.7585228085517883,
-0.07237478345632553,
0.06047697737812996,
-0.47546830773353577,
-0.05247019976377487,
-0.4788241982460022,
0.07490500807762146,
-0.15490016341209412,
-0.8943784832954407,
0.5353513360023499,
0.16054390370845795,
-0.007990716956555843,
0.8145507574081421,
0.61606764793396,
-0.04739126190543175,
0.8041856288909912,
0.854971706867218,
-0.17411814630031586,
0.5177233815193176,
0.1635846197605133,
0.13728010654449463,
-0.48049890995025635,
-0.07156594097614288,
-0.9214852452278137,
-0.49474966526031494,
-1.0157583951950073,
-0.3319232165813446,
0.18048079311847687,
-0.19382783770561218,
-0.11823824793100357,
0.43319597840309143,
-0.6518205404281616,
0.5378003716468811,
0.9365774989128113,
-0.09353160113096237,
0.2750575840473175,
-0.12169118970632553,
-0.10912910103797913,
0.16583169996738434,
-0.6836519837379456,
-0.8325294852256775,
0.8962395191192627,
-0.08416832983493805,
0.29758527874946594,
-0.006731902249157429,
0.5469487905502319,
0.6277515888214111,
-0.1067388579249382,
-0.7539438605308533,
0.6435105800628662,
-0.1070316880941391,
-0.894655704498291,
-0.4298083186149597,
-0.23197203874588013,
-1.2460806369781494,
0.20148786902427673,
-0.03884660452604294,
-0.86226487159729,
0.05986256152391434,
-0.21926183998584747,
-0.07669764757156372,
0.27831122279167175,
-0.891455352306366,
0.9806330800056458,
0.1269153207540512,
0.07192534953355789,
-0.11364718526601791,
-1.0801382064819336,
-0.12304967641830444,
0.10911673307418823,
0.3344699740409851,
-0.3745556175708771,
-0.13281983137130737,
0.9951284527778625,
-0.6532694697380066,
0.9092521667480469,
-0.06415681540966034,
-0.1442674845457077,
0.7178930044174194,
0.19494576752185822,
0.22873739898204803,
-0.24069857597351074,
0.11194249987602234,
0.2948693037033081,
-0.010620271787047386,
-0.5773991346359253,
-0.3040699064731598,
0.41334059834480286,
-0.7818591594696045,
-0.36228448152542114,
-0.4426136910915375,
-0.6715101599693298,
0.11808458715677261,
0.36801642179489136,
0.4504912495613098,
0.4247967600822449,
-0.2036442756652832,
-0.002087367232888937,
0.12446001917123795,
-0.3433501124382019,
0.6875757575035095,
0.3732246160507202,
-0.003062029369175434,
-0.13432401418685913,
0.7979384660720825,
0.10527335107326508,
0.21713224053382874,
0.5905531048774719,
0.40599745512008667,
-0.03337054327130318,
-0.34795165061950684,
-0.39514344930648804,
0.25918447971343994,
-0.5365098118782043,
0.08281370997428894,
-0.6730710864067078,
-0.1507347971200943,
-0.4125785231590271,
-0.7042266130447388,
-0.17774616181850433,
-0.371017724275589,
-0.04503769055008888,
0.22874176502227783,
0.570208728313446,
1.0642502307891846,
0.07059220969676971,
0.5508375763893127,
-0.8067982196807861,
0.10102769732475281,
-0.02519802562892437,
0.18305200338363647,
0.14215940237045288,
-0.19321468472480774,
-0.15112461149692535,
-0.11919195204973221,
-0.3272112309932709,
-0.8377522230148315,
0.1031501367688179,
-0.018540039658546448,
0.21003000438213348,
0.4668475389480591,
-0.08916077017784119,
0.5091651082038879,
-0.8156821727752686,
0.9929459691047668,
0.052509333938360214,
-0.7774084210395813,
0.5634936094284058,
-0.6789292693138123,
0.37136152386665344,
0.5367259383201599,
0.1389136016368866,
-0.8074310421943665,
-0.7757189869880676,
-0.6959067583084106,
-0.9125933647155762,
0.7902553677558899,
0.374162495136261,
-0.014236112125217915,
-0.08341584354639053,
0.01808168925344944,
0.4480985403060913,
0.08410435914993286,
-0.817690908908844,
-0.22949153184890747,
0.16022412478923798,
-0.15518954396247864,
-0.1866084635257721,
-0.12022892385721207,
-0.03636191785335541,
-0.07122097164392471,
0.08591233938932419,
0.17438606917858124,
0.24585676193237305,
0.2833947241306305,
-0.2730819582939148,
0.17705775797367096,
-0.0180545412003994,
0.5229744911193848,
0.5542685985565186,
-0.07752393186092377,
0.23595331609249115,
-0.3336561620235443,
-0.7475077509880066,
0.07050487399101257,
-0.5154154300689697,
-0.5244693160057068,
0.3963921070098877,
0.6821095943450928,
0.6421020030975342,
0.11918534338474274,
-0.7080701589584351,
0.45295968651771545,
0.09865442663431168,
-0.2258760780096054,
-0.2289896160364151,
0.2799454927444458,
-0.017445925623178482,
0.23015910387039185,
0.0863524079322815,
0.16905196011066437,
0.19866862893104553,
-0.6405357718467712,
0.11819318681955338,
0.23635722696781158,
-0.42243099212646484,
-0.5509764552116394,
0.390903502702713,
0.10914720594882965,
-0.7460409998893738,
0.3849206864833832,
-0.43552517890930176,
-0.4879796504974365,
0.6163961291313171,
0.34400656819343567,
1.1010202169418335,
0.1956465244293213,
0.536830484867096,
0.24912691116333008,
0.18784885108470917,
0.06870056688785553,
0.1445295810699463,
-0.37487220764160156,
-0.6408216953277588,
-0.3337588608264923,
-0.7115198373794556,
-0.20791012048721313,
-0.4340287148952484,
-0.27627846598625183,
0.23858846724033356,
-0.24142681062221527,
-0.2167266458272934,
0.27200645208358765,
-0.0664941817522049,
-0.4121800363063812,
-0.06457334011793137,
-0.06740071624517441,
0.5159798860549927,
-0.8379262089729309,
0.45168712735176086,
0.8785905241966248,
-0.2141941487789154,
-0.39520329236984253,
0.3125367760658264,
0.02828926220536232,
-0.5785269737243652,
0.5647403001785278,
0.06213783472776413,
-0.10907286405563354,
-0.03908480331301689,
-0.6749347448348999,
-1.06820809841156,
0.895478367805481,
-0.1282627433538437,
-0.08698432147502899,
0.20073485374450684,
0.38764315843582153,
0.7690995931625366,
-0.0378958098590374,
0.09617868065834045,
0.357023149728775,
0.5205174684524536,
-0.02593393623828888,
-0.7183482646942139,
-0.14236973226070404,
-0.02345982939004898,
-0.129095196723938,
0.5503584742546082,
-0.740340530872345,
0.9522598385810852,
0.1514558494091034,
-0.372014582157135,
0.2389199286699295,
0.4438280463218689,
0.041551023721694946,
0.3778820037841797,
0.6182860732078552,
0.43228644132614136,
0.7043081521987915,
-0.23960483074188232,
1.1239537000656128,
-0.1550409346818924,
0.1474887579679489,
0.8348047733306885,
-0.1444678157567978,
0.7053192853927612,
0.24576912820339203,
-0.5207017660140991,
0.9456274509429932,
0.5126329064369202,
-0.010884702205657959,
0.43948593735694885,
0.29019495844841003,
-0.1838926374912262,
-0.0005398918874561787,
-0.17367415130138397,
-0.04414921626448631,
0.5639143586158752,
0.08121820539236069,
0.03275108337402344,
-0.45467841625213623,
-0.21551799774169922,
0.3445744514465332,
0.11519106477499008,
-0.22274461388587952,
1.0340088605880737,
-0.18784701824188232,
-0.6349705457687378,
0.079447440803051,
0.16755850613117218,
0.5824469327926636,
-0.3792341947555542,
0.32399845123291016,
-0.1266927570104599,
0.11405111849308014,
-0.2301110476255417,
-0.830891489982605,
0.2859915494918823,
0.30410251021385193,
-0.42501482367515564,
0.017603863030672073,
0.8333130478858948,
-0.041875261813402176,
-0.6458076238632202,
0.15038791298866272,
0.5195222496986389,
0.417664498090744,
-0.24042558670043945,
-0.4122135043144226,
-0.23344957828521729,
-0.23789314925670624,
-0.14405666291713715,
0.3037232756614685,
0.7340800762176514,
-0.3911711275577545,
0.5565339922904968,
0.7222208380699158,
-0.07567968964576721,
0.477838397026062,
0.0623101070523262,
0.5780477523803711,
-1.0129684209823608,
-0.6128817796707153,
-1.0827633142471313,
0.44836026430130005,
-0.1762368530035019,
-0.4921987056732178,
1.0789769887924194,
0.5981041789054871,
0.7162384390830994,
-0.01735120825469494,
0.6163849830627441,
-0.49121931195259094,
0.6628355979919434,
-0.23853975534439087,
0.7837198972702026,
-0.5858209133148193,
-0.27349942922592163,
-0.6427661180496216,
-0.944389283657074,
-0.42144450545310974,
0.525596022605896,
-0.07853488624095917,
-0.1607903689146042,
0.8451150059700012,
0.698106050491333,
0.33439239859580994,
-0.402545690536499,
0.11875250190496445,
0.08257963508367538,
0.14996206760406494,
0.19309411942958832,
0.8818214535713196,
-0.32221853733062744,
0.42696574330329895,
0.005277725402265787,
-0.07580254226922989,
-0.20808763802051544,
-0.6777052283287048,
-0.8222010135650635,
-0.7910336256027222,
-0.31431517004966736,
-0.17011849582195282,
-0.3147309124469757,
0.1947101503610611,
0.337708979845047,
-0.6591947674751282,
-0.3934554159641266,
-0.4361899495124817,
0.6252670288085938,
0.03851450979709625,
-0.27094969153404236,
0.5484355688095093,
-0.6195768117904663,
-0.7349125742912292,
0.06524477899074554,
0.5332412123680115,
-0.07500100135803223,
-0.3365567624568939,
0.14235085248947144,
-0.3183601498603821,
0.2529405653476715,
0.4943532645702362,
-0.02553481049835682,
-0.748159646987915,
-0.5406211018562317,
0.27500903606414795,
-0.33687329292297363,
0.3774581253528595,
0.8984207510948181,
-0.7786598801612854,
0.37581315636634827,
0.9668492078781128,
0.2329840064048767,
-0.009817622601985931,
0.025926480069756508,
0.4531037509441376,
-0.6547595858573914,
0.30430492758750916,
0.012846281751990318,
0.1837558001279831,
0.31250542402267456,
-0.06474725902080536,
0.6339859366416931,
0.5174720883369446,
-0.8102055191993713,
-0.7020664811134338,
0.13272279500961304,
-1.1982022523880005,
-0.4936995804309845,
1.300771713256836,
0.005088501609861851,
-0.45990902185440063,
-0.30306556820869446,
-0.4109865427017212,
0.34358689188957214,
-0.21759013831615448,
0.8285093307495117,
0.9624081254005432,
0.10199298709630966,
0.6727052330970764,
-0.4611310362815857,
0.5745518207550049,
0.1641448438167572,
-0.574805736541748,
-0.29719942808151245,
0.5638957023620605,
0.16932789981365204,
0.3936527669429779,
0.8441609144210815,
-0.06924556940793991,
0.11858797073364258,
0.26440513134002686,
0.10048861056566238,
0.5839571952819824,
-0.3101218342781067,
0.039545271545648575,
0.2498551458120346,
-0.24807041883468628,
-0.3126625120639801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17389v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17389v1
|
FairBelief -- Assessing Harmful Beliefs in Language Models
| 2024-02-27T10:31:00 | 2024-02-27T10:31:00 |
Mattia Setzu, Marta Marchiori Manerba, Pasquale Minervini, Debora Nozza
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Language Models (LMs) have been shown to inherit undesired biases that might
hurt minorities and underrepresented groups if such systems were integrated
into real-world applications without careful fairness auditing. This paper
proposes FairBelief, an analytical approach to capture and assess beliefs,
i.e., propositions that an LM may embed with different degrees of confidence
and that covertly influence its predictions. With FairBelief, we leverage
prompting to study the behavior of several state-of-the-art LMs across
different previously neglected axes, such as model scale and likelihood,
assessing predictions on a fairness dataset specifically designed to quantify
LMs' outputs' hurtfulness. Finally, we conclude with an in-depth qualitative
assessment of the beliefs emitted by the models. We apply FairBelief to English
LMs, revealing that, although these architectures enable high performances on
diverse natural language processing tasks, they show hurtful beliefs about
specific genders. Interestingly, training procedure and dataset, model scale,
and architecture induce beliefs of different degrees of hurtfulness.
|
[
-0.4258245527744293,
-0.801925003528595,
0.49762314558029175,
0.3244282901287079,
0.27507495880126953,
-0.2645006775856018,
0.06520654261112213,
-0.5454157590866089,
-0.30952784419059753,
0.31548163294792175,
-0.318972647190094,
-0.3234361410140991,
-0.915276825428009,
0.06212620064616203,
-0.3882847726345062,
0.8432742953300476,
0.04254737123847008,
0.3146508038043976,
-0.11610279977321625,
-0.42554956674575806,
-0.6969701647758484,
-0.35932299494743347,
-0.3205520808696747,
-0.3824671804904938,
0.37775567173957825,
0.10782866925001144,
1.0537418127059937,
0.153048574924469,
0.3642840087413788,
0.14914420247077942,
-0.086954765021801,
-0.32138949632644653,
-0.47044187784194946,
0.21895869076251984,
-0.4867383539676666,
-0.8253501057624817,
-0.2695670425891876,
0.38304880261421204,
0.5346168875694275,
0.9059702157974243,
-0.30596286058425903,
0.4343174993991852,
0.10824365168809891,
0.40096181631088257,
-0.8678959012031555,
-0.01586681604385376,
-0.7327697277069092,
0.25581514835357666,
-0.06590485572814941,
0.27758675813674927,
-0.5654255747795105,
-0.834783673286438,
0.06516023725271225,
0.0722724199295044,
-0.03817969933152199,
0.17197656631469727,
0.6910112500190735,
0.33562037348747253,
-0.6394102573394775,
-0.48033538460731506,
-0.40346720814704895,
1.1090842485427856,
-0.9559244513511658,
0.4982956349849701,
0.42541688680648804,
0.3910011649131775,
-0.28681138157844543,
-0.33677273988723755,
-0.640572726726532,
-0.15890462696552277,
-0.20792007446289062,
-0.10413956642150879,
-0.5004635453224182,
-0.02561589889228344,
0.42296302318573,
0.24132156372070312,
-0.6311308145523071,
0.17912568151950836,
-0.14497502148151398,
-0.139296755194664,
0.558532178401947,
0.14296674728393555,
0.4435390532016754,
-0.34812435507774353,
-0.1920185536146164,
0.11833349615335464,
-0.8892489671707153,
0.18541833758354187,
0.5581520795822144,
0.4988629221916199,
0.00026625103782862425,
0.2585553824901581,
0.12896133959293365,
0.3758615255355835,
-0.028422001749277115,
-0.1390438973903656,
0.30466413497924805,
0.3275468647480011,
-0.4901200234889984,
0.19100293517112732,
0.6276964545249939,
0.5654194951057434,
0.4041992425918579,
-0.12768259644508362,
-0.41629311442375183,
0.5200170874595642,
0.14924579858779907,
-1.006098985671997,
0.20312805473804474,
0.3700406849384308,
-0.6228731274604797,
-0.5266641974449158,
-0.18258900940418243,
-0.7301331758499146,
-0.6455995440483093,
0.08729233592748642,
0.37501561641693115,
-0.3002738356590271,
-0.3691348135471344,
0.2972656190395355,
-0.11820770055055618,
0.09584026783704758,
0.10408966988325119,
-0.8004780411720276,
0.38374537229537964,
0.7451450228691101,
0.3331758379936218,
0.013688975013792515,
-0.028356576338410378,
-0.6363555788993835,
-0.08016403019428253,
-0.3993224799633026,
0.5084506869316101,
-0.6833199858665466,
-0.3663024604320526,
0.2619312107563019,
0.11296401172876358,
0.24193648993968964,
-0.5622117519378662,
0.9509599208831787,
-0.3182159662246704,
0.40885815024375916,
-0.40426287055015564,
-0.6622408032417297,
-0.40570104122161865,
0.3197263777256012,
-0.5916996598243713,
0.7650137543678284,
0.003945283126085997,
-1.0749127864837646,
0.595183789730072,
-0.49434763193130493,
-0.2772960066795349,
-0.06681668013334274,
-0.47201886773109436,
-0.1393306404352188,
0.4291876256465912,
-0.056829310953617096,
0.42869850993156433,
-0.2613615095615387,
0.6751530170440674,
-0.7358267307281494,
-0.13443106412887573,
0.3840830624103546,
-0.8306179046630859,
1.069907307624817,
0.31048619747161865,
-0.534959614276886,
-0.2512916624546051,
-0.6546618938446045,
-0.1495397835969925,
0.23108437657356262,
-0.04519360885024071,
-0.6285213828086853,
0.2297268807888031,
-0.1823737472295761,
0.27720385789871216,
-0.14092285931110382,
-0.5702475905418396,
-0.16023357212543488,
-0.4536806344985962,
-0.18813291192054749,
0.8232616186141968,
-0.18463458120822906,
0.550557553768158,
-0.3888879716396332,
0.5916703343391418,
-0.14456743001937866,
0.31507545709609985,
0.31240805983543396,
-0.43353286385536194,
-0.512127697467804,
0.15874657034873962,
0.294732928276062,
0.3765111565589905,
-0.2729240655899048,
-0.07317731529474258,
0.06766457110643387,
-0.2877179980278015,
-0.7458968758583069,
0.02728993445634842,
0.3570016920566559,
0.4805799424648285,
0.07207184284925461,
-0.21837425231933594,
-0.2786209285259247,
-1.1626206636428833,
-0.7713707089424133,
-0.3574182689189911,
0.1069696918129921,
0.3151151239871979,
0.5279629230499268,
-0.21537406742572784,
0.8705174326896667,
-0.37501123547554016,
-0.03049827180802822,
0.10698208957910538,
0.41722044348716736,
0.19660267233848572,
0.3913850486278534,
0.9438790082931519,
-0.7864074110984802,
-0.24283167719841003,
-0.33062198758125305,
-0.7701852917671204,
-0.38885167241096497,
0.14165988564491272,
0.06846241652965546,
0.18928176164627075,
0.024508412927389145,
-0.43879446387290955,
0.5993332266807556,
0.7067528367042542,
-0.7261857390403748,
0.5732558369636536,
0.30840185284614563,
0.33837684988975525,
-0.6013328433036804,
-0.2882196307182312,
-0.04038425162434578,
-0.34356701374053955,
-0.4771716296672821,
0.15529422461986542,
0.029115624725818634,
0.34763118624687195,
-0.6143540143966675,
0.6851842999458313,
-0.23405250906944275,
0.12442098557949066,
-0.20131631195545197,
0.07402700930833817,
-0.02341172844171524,
0.09663653373718262,
-0.17083607614040375,
0.3540413975715637,
0.36244097352027893,
-0.37230587005615234,
-0.10017015039920807,
-0.006895861122757196,
-0.22643086314201355,
0.5116108655929565,
-0.25886547565460205,
0.012267245911061764,
-0.45409995317459106,
-0.1786588877439499,
-0.7452515363693237,
-0.07083939015865326,
0.21401329338550568,
-0.4910639822483063,
0.10403890907764435,
-0.2370305061340332,
-0.3204883933067322,
-0.08358735591173172,
-0.20332655310630798,
0.40787965059280396,
0.6312878727912903,
-0.515468955039978,
0.6483227014541626,
0.5796486139297485,
-0.2154143899679184,
-0.7303235530853271,
-0.8825727701187134,
-0.04116787016391754,
-0.564889132976532,
-0.45163971185684204,
0.036984045058488846,
-0.06410320848226547,
-1.0136151313781738,
-0.13309423625469208,
-0.022017406299710274,
0.012275060638785362,
0.36953654885292053,
0.5428404211997986,
0.11203864216804504,
-0.049844350665807724,
0.345811665058136,
0.44265446066856384,
0.18229742348194122,
0.4065210521221161,
0.0570107027888298,
0.1626768559217453,
-0.3479541540145874,
-0.4251600503921509,
0.10999201983213425,
0.5019016265869141,
0.3190494179725647,
0.08062881976366043,
0.824660062789917,
0.3636728525161743,
-0.8173357248306274,
-0.48651695251464844,
-0.6457641124725342,
-0.12160839140415192,
-0.4451582133769989,
0.3958554267883301,
-0.22745709121227264,
-1.061738133430481,
0.4764153063297272,
-0.1147036999464035,
0.15607476234436035,
0.4010647237300873,
0.5470109581947327,
-0.18048135936260223,
1.2961124181747437,
0.727739691734314,
-0.07155299931764603,
0.04139896109700203,
0.2652229964733124,
0.22384007275104523,
-0.13612525165081024,
-0.09594301134347916,
-0.874210000038147,
-0.07496438920497894,
-0.8135696053504944,
-0.44340962171554565,
-0.09405253827571869,
0.4121140241622925,
-0.5261977910995483,
-0.1164586991071701,
-0.14456644654273987,
0.4742369055747986,
-0.07823405414819717,
-0.42258164286613464,
0.2766331136226654,
-0.23728419840335846,
-0.09550575166940689,
-0.35866543650627136,
-0.6570046544075012,
-1.123131275177002,
0.8689646124839783,
0.8220502138137817,
0.8348300457000732,
0.39629265666007996,
0.5809953808784485,
0.6162601709365845,
0.9291724562644958,
-0.8435810804367065,
0.30831658840179443,
-0.11510071903467178,
-1.17251455783844,
-0.03631703183054924,
-0.46488863229751587,
-0.5959615111351013,
0.23853334784507751,
-0.028644148260354996,
-0.9699669480323792,
0.48341262340545654,
0.40462005138397217,
-0.10718467831611633,
0.38849076628685,
-0.6500377655029297,
0.86441969871521,
-0.35287272930145264,
-0.26407867670059204,
-0.25007376074790955,
-0.3201965093612671,
0.6597537398338318,
-0.1479833722114563,
0.7174444198608398,
-0.321363627910614,
0.17609478533267975,
0.9241941571235657,
-0.06865617632865906,
0.9218670725822449,
-0.5499466061592102,
-0.6039503812789917,
0.28199946880340576,
0.8139078617095947,
0.3367064595222473,
-0.0008877547807060182,
-0.5538866519927979,
0.3060131371021271,
0.1503010094165802,
-0.3106456995010376,
-0.6014014482498169,
0.5825223922729492,
-0.4291256368160248,
-0.5927547812461853,
-0.4180832803249359,
-0.4200591444969177,
-0.44331663846969604,
0.11129835247993469,
-0.05652396008372307,
0.3173781633377075,
-0.6536934971809387,
-0.012130459770560265,
0.5279822945594788,
-0.45496997237205505,
0.345647931098938,
0.47848373651504517,
-0.6110309362411499,
0.12887071073055267,
0.7151315808296204,
-0.04241059720516205,
0.4213264584541321,
-0.02638566493988037,
0.17674566805362701,
-0.27574092149734497,
-0.6209102869033813,
-0.05041026696562767,
-0.14635202288627625,
-0.9718155264854431,
-0.3125213086605072,
-0.30823639035224915,
0.3470020592212677,
-0.4328254163265228,
0.08928199857473373,
-0.464878648519516,
-0.19962099194526672,
-0.05289050564169884,
-0.2209782600402832,
0.0268723014742136,
0.8397302627563477,
-0.016535503789782524,
0.27408015727996826,
-0.8227456212043762,
0.10155346989631653,
0.20913273096084595,
0.4825739562511444,
-0.08108796924352646,
-0.5399873852729797,
0.0702504888176918,
0.24896971881389618,
-0.174748957157135,
-1.0373660326004028,
0.4249187111854553,
-0.05998245254158974,
0.7438535690307617,
0.5516709685325623,
0.23590196669101715,
0.1758347600698471,
-0.5397564172744751,
0.6878916621208191,
0.5039376020431519,
-1.0220228433609009,
0.3361928164958954,
-0.08949699252843857,
-0.06302423030138016,
0.5907046794891357,
0.7015422582626343,
-0.7158831357955933,
-0.6802578568458557,
-0.46120211482048035,
-0.13103795051574707,
0.6124628782272339,
-0.060324717313051224,
0.28188592195510864,
-0.18453601002693176,
0.19678357243537903,
0.6105546951293945,
0.10093214362859726,
-0.9852731823921204,
-0.25794053077697754,
-0.387794554233551,
-0.5838024020195007,
0.21916058659553528,
-0.2382490336894989,
-0.07914173603057861,
-0.0786159411072731,
0.5480921268463135,
-0.2734077274799347,
0.104364775121212,
-0.15172798931598663,
-0.5006819367408752,
-0.1230761706829071,
0.6372735500335693,
0.07821883261203766,
0.6143962144851685,
-0.378574013710022,
0.3674958348274231,
0.3527708649635315,
-0.3152325749397278,
0.26090580224990845,
0.03868566453456879,
-0.25016090273857117,
0.006431812886148691,
0.3145265281200409,
0.6611896753311157,
-0.09423864632844925,
-0.8007547855377197,
0.8121067881584167,
-0.32451292872428894,
-0.001890208339318633,
0.06909533590078354,
0.07175402343273163,
0.24094577133655548,
0.4620702862739563,
0.1887352168560028,
0.04158792272210121,
0.40486234426498413,
-0.6421011090278625,
0.06108715385198593,
0.44075775146484375,
-0.8075024485588074,
-0.42739132046699524,
0.33430367708206177,
0.1493617743253708,
-0.3172002136707306,
0.11965235322713852,
-0.47242528200149536,
-0.6588011980056763,
0.3245372474193573,
0.4339885711669922,
0.8545359969139099,
-0.38709360361099243,
0.15627959370613098,
0.2264733910560608,
0.6106509566307068,
0.09614908695220947,
0.23014327883720398,
0.30010634660720825,
-1.0160173177719116,
-0.3095208704471588,
-0.7757992148399353,
-0.11024201661348343,
0.1327977329492569,
-0.6923492550849915,
0.06106046959757805,
-0.3280864953994751,
-0.37281855940818787,
-0.14299677312374115,
-0.17059186100959778,
-0.8487806916236877,
0.3833981156349182,
0.5111092329025269,
0.9585473537445068,
-1.02051842212677,
0.35719388723373413,
0.2901950478553772,
-0.41541215777397156,
-0.7153704762458801,
0.28172919154167175,
0.24126729369163513,
-0.817222535610199,
0.8251470923423767,
0.041268620640039444,
-0.2263893187046051,
-0.5728563070297241,
-0.7948368787765503,
-0.33977699279785156,
0.5292568802833557,
0.7418935298919678,
-0.8134677410125732,
-0.009918448515236378,
0.3200644552707672,
0.21037355065345764,
-0.3885383605957031,
0.39529433846473694,
0.7363020181655884,
0.41148844361305237,
-0.4631217420101166,
-0.871367871761322,
0.29159417748451233,
-0.040246859192848206,
-0.22737188637256622,
0.03962954506278038,
-0.3211347460746765,
0.8059200644493103,
-0.17447523772716522,
-0.31993529200553894,
-0.21417124569416046,
0.6293140053749084,
0.13863784074783325,
0.24287137389183044,
0.787459135055542,
0.3013496398925781,
0.9295613765716553,
-0.037962496280670166,
0.9286081194877625,
0.08459917455911636,
0.4599139094352722,
1.1175917387008667,
-0.3344820737838745,
0.7284877300262451,
0.4824223518371582,
-0.2783965468406677,
0.39698219299316406,
0.3856487572193146,
0.22715114057064056,
0.5502455234527588,
0.4378485083580017,
-0.17008288204669952,
-0.22759321331977844,
-0.3541901707649231,
-0.24042485654354095,
0.5040097832679749,
0.39529532194137573,
-0.24595385789871216,
-0.4007076621055603,
0.18800334632396698,
0.17866726219654083,
0.25967806577682495,
-0.21566075086593628,
0.49345120787620544,
0.5032573938369751,
-0.5320469737052917,
0.47559353709220886,
0.26771819591522217,
0.9603434801101685,
-0.21538743376731873,
-0.18434485793113708,
-0.30169442296028137,
-0.00422254903241992,
-0.19741718471050262,
-0.893234372138977,
0.2897079288959503,
0.3086485266685486,
-0.15003594756126404,
-0.15804418921470642,
1.0158116817474365,
-0.24919989705085754,
-0.3749447166919708,
0.7359015941619873,
0.7087161540985107,
0.10193674266338348,
0.020192062482237816,
-0.731728196144104,
0.1567326933145523,
0.1298709660768509,
-0.277437686920166,
0.3672432601451874,
0.43983200192451477,
-0.14465583860874176,
0.5634857416152954,
0.14984630048274994,
0.178864985704422,
-0.061726365238428116,
0.48360559344291687,
0.39883020520210266,
-0.7386472821235657,
-0.3042854964733124,
-0.8844321370124817,
0.4178648591041565,
0.24346093833446503,
-0.09521231055259705,
0.5644676685333252,
0.17290908098220825,
0.7994416356086731,
0.4016572833061218,
0.8474045395851135,
0.04583129659295082,
0.5268325805664062,
-0.28343427181243896,
0.9522581696510315,
-0.6310325860977173,
0.19016647338867188,
-0.5720779299736023,
-0.75669264793396,
-0.19375476241111755,
0.6940183639526367,
-0.48221829533576965,
0.2242959588766098,
0.4345693290233612,
0.7247173190116882,
-0.033878669142723083,
0.622397243976593,
0.382385790348053,
0.5049100518226624,
0.5403929948806763,
0.35987338423728943,
1.3250348567962646,
-0.3142246603965759,
0.4304378926753998,
-0.04155430570244789,
-0.33617740869522095,
-0.05001465976238251,
-1.140178918838501,
-0.8525313138961792,
-0.22890199720859528,
-0.3431471884250641,
-0.4193974435329437,
-0.10282240062952042,
0.8867748975753784,
0.3735978901386261,
-0.9206182956695557,
-0.15713685750961304,
0.19159895181655884,
0.23495765030384064,
0.2595672607421875,
-0.2928708493709564,
0.22107161581516266,
-0.2259216606616974,
-0.682692289352417,
0.0718216747045517,
0.001835207105614245,
0.0378565713763237,
-0.3423137664794922,
-0.44989803433418274,
0.05226179584860802,
0.29569366574287415,
0.6009293794631958,
-0.1051769033074379,
-0.7186319828033447,
-0.620728611946106,
-0.35788631439208984,
-0.18615370988845825,
-0.21108508110046387,
0.47621652483940125,
-0.6711780428886414,
0.24468305706977844,
0.32359200716018677,
0.5128130912780762,
-0.037097685039043427,
-0.40231752395629883,
0.5779207944869995,
-0.5820366144180298,
0.029970280826091766,
0.6373488306999207,
0.6268828511238098,
0.34068456292152405,
-0.18435153365135193,
0.03492782637476921,
0.013464134186506271,
-0.17996804416179657,
-1.3120671510696411,
0.12939830124378204,
-0.4035307765007019,
-0.5714033246040344,
0.9433745741844177,
-0.17783650755882263,
-0.23596127331256866,
-0.018081987276673317,
-0.08890721946954727,
0.18176592886447906,
-0.4504002034664154,
0.6648674011230469,
0.8536117076873779,
0.1936747431755066,
0.22627048194408417,
-0.8363999724388123,
0.6379715204238892,
0.7680904269218445,
-0.733791172504425,
0.29192987084388733,
0.5802726745605469,
0.4721032977104187,
0.13221172988414764,
0.3976133465766907,
-0.3557243347167969,
0.23043401539325714,
0.10183753818273544,
0.14292195439338684,
0.2887883484363556,
-0.08845549076795578,
-0.5041992664337158,
0.40639784932136536,
0.3017168641090393,
0.20354634523391724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00826v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00826v1
|
LLMGuard: Guarding Against Unsafe LLM Behavior
| 2024-02-27T10:22:45 | 2024-02-27T10:22:45 |
Shubh Goyal, Medha Hira, Shubham Mishra, Sukriti Goyal, Arnav Goel, Niharika Dadu, Kirushikesh DB, Sameep Mehta, Nishtha Madaan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Although the rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) in enterprise settings
brings new opportunities and capabilities, it also brings challenges, such as
the risk of generating inappropriate, biased, or misleading content that
violates regulations and can have legal concerns. To alleviate this, we present
"LLMGuard", a tool that monitors user interactions with an LLM application and
flags content against specific behaviours or conversation topics. To do this
robustly, LLMGuard employs an ensemble of detectors.
|
[
-0.44969332218170166,
-1.0894159078598022,
0.35506486892700195,
0.08279576152563095,
-0.16351860761642456,
0.21065612137317657,
0.2300521433353424,
-0.49952733516693115,
0.26162081956863403,
0.9442443251609802,
-0.5668594241142273,
-0.6621254682540894,
-0.6891292929649353,
-0.17175620794296265,
-0.6662823557853699,
1.1237990856170654,
-0.014841693453490734,
-0.33274418115615845,
-0.2703515887260437,
0.10063230246305466,
-0.49608314037323,
-0.864403486251831,
-1.0291324853897095,
-0.6849212646484375,
0.6075617671012878,
0.6072678565979004,
0.7522206902503967,
0.2515161335468292,
0.7133825421333313,
0.37244418263435364,
0.03692801669239998,
-0.023970460519194603,
-0.714317798614502,
0.5512334704399109,
-0.15269538760185242,
-0.4120485782623291,
-0.9141015410423279,
-0.2716825008392334,
0.2702537178993225,
0.0744682252407074,
-0.44401443004608154,
0.10721486806869507,
0.11691363155841827,
0.2988458573818207,
-0.4749262034893036,
-0.02295694500207901,
-0.5514712929725647,
-0.02393767237663269,
-0.6240432262420654,
-0.3955379128456116,
-0.43489471077919006,
-0.2981897294521332,
-0.2129640281200409,
-0.15080489218235016,
-0.35773590207099915,
0.3690566420555115,
0.7850571870803833,
0.13375134766101837,
-0.6403756737709045,
-0.150821715593338,
-0.3768197000026703,
0.6008197069168091,
-0.6057915687561035,
0.2945250868797302,
0.847126841545105,
0.3408389389514923,
-0.5917555689811707,
-0.7005946040153503,
-0.5269252061843872,
-0.29539498686790466,
0.05823938921093941,
-0.10488623380661011,
-0.6874322295188904,
0.34210389852523804,
0.22385312616825104,
0.246143639087677,
-0.536531388759613,
0.6097413301467896,
-0.2336682379245758,
-0.582400381565094,
0.7537349462509155,
0.39073631167411804,
0.7419449090957642,
-0.01007142011076212,
-0.3418756425380707,
-0.06716632097959518,
-1.1056774854660034,
-0.22766636312007904,
0.49214276671409607,
-0.1934003382921219,
-0.03899455815553665,
0.8284540176391602,
-0.11705398559570312,
0.6611568927764893,
-0.04558676853775978,
-0.41874563694000244,
0.16393370926380157,
0.3632330894470215,
-0.36013761162757874,
0.2864046096801758,
0.8786057233810425,
0.6427823901176453,
0.30773070454597473,
0.04124409332871437,
-0.46620431542396545,
0.05429650470614433,
0.19890055060386658,
-0.7034639120101929,
-0.2563139796257019,
0.46508410573005676,
-0.15011775493621826,
-0.6055364012718201,
-0.0741945207118988,
-0.6205599904060364,
-0.7340453863143921,
-0.01382437627762556,
0.24536094069480896,
-0.32412269711494446,
-0.3613109886646271,
0.01012869831174612,
0.22630564868450165,
0.11413384228944778,
0.22496183216571808,
-0.8895118236541748,
0.289293497800827,
0.876862645149231,
0.6927453875541687,
-0.5928782820701599,
-0.362785279750824,
-0.842933177947998,
0.4705147445201874,
-0.25601083040237427,
1.035287618637085,
-0.3921014964580536,
-0.801023006439209,
0.1394098699092865,
0.13820217549800873,
0.3372690677642822,
-0.47382283210754395,
0.5118069648742676,
-0.7858399748802185,
-0.12750573456287384,
-0.12638095021247864,
-0.4957273602485657,
-0.236183762550354,
0.6258975863456726,
-0.7650158405303955,
1.1350374221801758,
0.15187305212020874,
-0.8869268298149109,
0.36983537673950195,
-0.5911100506782532,
-0.5305720567703247,
0.17455126345157623,
-0.2551942467689514,
-0.5029529333114624,
-0.2114323377609253,
0.024211052805185318,
0.45424073934555054,
0.009127002209424973,
0.2621089220046997,
-0.35755547881126404,
-0.13996388018131256,
0.606166422367096,
-0.50441974401474,
0.7701811790466309,
0.32922664284706116,
-0.1256713718175888,
0.5305485725402832,
-0.46315330266952515,
-0.3470630347728729,
0.024384213611483574,
-0.7232799530029297,
-0.3447830080986023,
0.09339138120412827,
0.03337548300623894,
0.04734765365719795,
0.41964462399482727,
-0.34777602553367615,
-0.011670226231217384,
-0.0019034129800274968,
0.15883611142635345,
1.0412427186965942,
0.15745121240615845,
0.15646061301231384,
-0.5632739067077637,
0.8619990348815918,
0.0633963793516159,
0.14691077172756195,
0.04774731770157814,
-0.7063781023025513,
-0.6261667013168335,
-0.24693793058395386,
-0.024637697264552116,
0.8268579840660095,
-0.8101257085800171,
0.5658189058303833,
-0.06678072363138199,
-0.3991628587245941,
-0.2553536891937256,
0.5802979469299316,
0.36607086658477783,
0.4221744239330292,
-0.13245338201522827,
-0.2683808207511902,
-0.4991820752620697,
-0.7237610220909119,
0.03267330676317215,
-0.5020861625671387,
-0.24973426759243011,
0.1968502253293991,
0.18709927797317505,
-0.5809457302093506,
0.6964602470397949,
-0.42632317543029785,
-0.255293607711792,
-0.44423770904541016,
0.16451624035835266,
-0.007306125480681658,
0.31245148181915283,
0.6900677680969238,
-0.5191549062728882,
-0.23291043937206268,
0.017231572419404984,
-0.7650028467178345,
-0.6637741327285767,
-0.024124961346387863,
-0.4768681824207306,
0.26211100816726685,
1.0143846273422241,
-0.5721750855445862,
0.25206759572029114,
0.8560919761657715,
-0.5601105093955994,
0.46459028124809265,
-0.012814371846616268,
0.012616469524800777,
-1.078978180885315,
-0.16489532589912415,
0.01054405327886343,
-0.6192428469657898,
-0.7017797231674194,
0.09360562264919281,
-0.16569069027900696,
0.0547817125916481,
-0.6781557202339172,
0.4682506024837494,
-0.2793664038181305,
-0.09401563555002213,
-0.35601887106895447,
0.29893600940704346,
-0.02525368332862854,
-0.18689104914665222,
-0.08164408057928085,
1.0820804834365845,
0.6108216047286987,
-0.7256967425346375,
0.5857945084571838,
0.3678815960884094,
-0.5550495386123657,
0.8696854114532471,
-0.4690324366092682,
0.13883592188358307,
-0.04595709964632988,
0.030727382749319077,
-0.8690970540046692,
-0.43878811597824097,
0.046798527240753174,
-0.3069969713687897,
0.3072873651981354,
-0.18919439613819122,
-0.5168110132217407,
-0.4092371463775635,
-0.3257460594177246,
-0.07892712205648422,
0.3899604380130768,
-0.4878069758415222,
0.7316402196884155,
0.9416742324829102,
-0.38984256982803345,
-0.4885910153388977,
-0.9949813485145569,
0.437417596578598,
-0.618250846862793,
-0.7924789786338806,
-0.1169242337346077,
-0.03995354846119881,
-0.7288364171981812,
-0.24107789993286133,
0.0781169906258583,
-0.12341733276844025,
0.5456807613372803,
0.4294963479042053,
0.5343396663665771,
-0.1732105314731598,
-0.05963033065199852,
-0.05158139020204544,
0.04164097458124161,
0.39483878016471863,
0.2435876727104187,
0.8271636962890625,
-0.05416387319564819,
-0.6561431884765625,
-0.030490245670080185,
0.3301757574081421,
0.5335831642150879,
0.010044186376035213,
0.6029822826385498,
0.6438524127006531,
-0.22349973022937775,
-0.197832852602005,
-0.6566402912139893,
-0.20646469295024872,
-0.7119953036308289,
0.3685249388217926,
-0.11862864345312119,
-1.1409028768539429,
0.4495048224925995,
-0.007408691570162773,
0.040080443024635315,
0.08890330046415329,
0.7329039573669434,
-0.061191100627183914,
0.8661227822303772,
0.7782435417175293,
-0.4236678183078766,
0.6394394040107727,
0.35231050848960876,
0.207628071308136,
-0.7677410840988159,
-0.43801093101501465,
-0.22085276246070862,
-0.2298942655324936,
-0.524685800075531,
-0.20078399777412415,
0.40054959058761597,
-0.09997206181287766,
-0.25215038657188416,
0.2704666554927826,
-0.21175169944763184,
0.6423126459121704,
0.653217077255249,
0.06300186365842819,
0.5092136859893799,
0.05330875143408775,
-0.12614025175571442,
0.12568692862987518,
-0.43259453773498535,
-0.8217504620552063,
1.0040942430496216,
0.4135005474090576,
1.520020604133606,
0.6064947843551636,
0.6953729391098022,
0.6549026370048523,
0.7879035472869873,
-0.8882666826248169,
0.8751921653747559,
0.11141777783632278,
-0.8118350505828857,
-0.14921674132347107,
-0.2932354211807251,
-1.1349011659622192,
0.002140355296432972,
-0.43353554606437683,
-1.3268154859542847,
-0.05476244539022446,
0.37781569361686707,
-0.2839456796646118,
0.5054418444633484,
-0.6097507476806641,
0.644119918346405,
-0.5798484086990356,
-0.39669376611709595,
-0.03348682075738907,
-0.02275479957461357,
0.666851282119751,
-0.2606814503669739,
0.1306651532649994,
-0.45652589201927185,
0.015204528346657753,
0.5392815470695496,
-0.2235451489686966,
1.0806151628494263,
0.21049955487251282,
-0.45186033844947815,
0.5834494233131409,
0.7833016514778137,
0.6696165204048157,
-0.020866187289357185,
-0.015390935353934765,
0.21123844385147095,
-0.27962377667427063,
0.12389791011810303,
0.07823003828525543,
0.9020593762397766,
-0.46915867924690247,
-1.0103437900543213,
-0.5317328572273254,
-0.6033456325531006,
-0.08957914263010025,
0.31329861283302307,
0.14903445541858673,
0.012912697158753872,
-0.4328429698944092,
0.20555320382118225,
0.8442233800888062,
-0.3761913478374481,
0.39103543758392334,
0.6932472586631775,
-0.7003316283226013,
-0.047280412167310715,
0.6346487402915955,
-0.24209484457969666,
0.3001730442047119,
0.21394944190979004,
0.08452262729406357,
-0.31825903058052063,
-0.6138677597045898,
-0.2189664989709854,
-0.11320493370294571,
-0.8364237546920776,
-0.4396224021911621,
-0.5708547234535217,
-0.28245458006858826,
-0.1716686338186264,
-0.21393059194087982,
0.24385373294353485,
-0.3210914134979248,
-0.30845707654953003,
-0.5378108620643616,
0.7611112594604492,
0.7316813468933105,
-0.04069921746850014,
0.6426252126693726,
-0.742397129535675,
0.16261345148086548,
0.5506373643875122,
0.32509541511535645,
-0.3871243894100189,
-0.36933064460754395,
0.1110650897026062,
-0.48606613278388977,
-0.43409964442253113,
-0.724394679069519,
0.4618854820728302,
-0.028618652373552322,
0.8113052845001221,
0.7795947194099426,
0.02922014519572258,
0.19767023622989655,
-0.5172162055969238,
0.7652077078819275,
0.23947612941265106,
-0.7571014165878296,
0.6884720921516418,
-0.5874415636062622,
0.09509684145450592,
0.3259345591068268,
0.28316137194633484,
-0.5959089994430542,
-0.6499294638633728,
-0.41294601559638977,
-0.8777026534080505,
0.36844587326049805,
-0.03601910546422005,
0.2270561158657074,
-0.37247559428215027,
-0.16125817596912384,
-0.3519493341445923,
0.24027374386787415,
-0.7756208777427673,
0.0769665464758873,
0.02536437287926674,
-0.13258133828639984,
0.15364661812782288,
-0.5373561382293701,
-0.527249276638031,
0.26976826786994934,
0.6187743544578552,
-0.041631124913692474,
0.07239807397127151,
-0.16104134917259216,
-0.3240806758403778,
-0.20804087817668915,
0.43972545862197876,
0.42831265926361084,
0.5253258347511292,
-0.15085899829864502,
0.4555005133152008,
0.4340100884437561,
-0.8744388818740845,
0.11798394471406937,
-0.1414753645658493,
-0.23097917437553406,
-0.2539807856082916,
0.1685134768486023,
0.4196554124355316,
0.05735817179083824,
-0.8490764498710632,
0.5826626420021057,
0.10926614701747894,
-0.06903207302093506,
-0.5031631588935852,
0.42768019437789917,
0.16888651251792908,
0.14490748941898346,
-0.023050080984830856,
-0.36459630727767944,
0.23575840890407562,
-0.5461894869804382,
0.5298105478286743,
0.44303563237190247,
-0.2980385422706604,
0.08780408650636673,
0.847568690776825,
0.3379349708557129,
-0.37566012144088745,
0.4852864742279053,
-0.057394400238990784,
-0.4247778356075287,
0.50533127784729,
0.6941859722137451,
0.9650497436523438,
-0.6738536953926086,
-0.017918821424245834,
-0.0953906998038292,
0.6234151124954224,
-0.13705794513225555,
0.607333779335022,
0.4556417763233185,
-0.968430757522583,
-0.36732161045074463,
-0.49603062868118286,
-0.7189462184906006,
0.34318679571151733,
-0.5495879054069519,
0.3221178650856018,
-0.724101722240448,
-0.7025273442268372,
-0.14476536214351654,
-0.5690292119979858,
-0.22068572044372559,
-0.08063843101263046,
0.519880473613739,
1.0180658102035522,
-0.7285537719726562,
0.9881846308708191,
0.5400269031524658,
-0.143138587474823,
-0.3820805549621582,
-0.20049312710762024,
0.7467383146286011,
-1.1359566450119019,
0.5242552161216736,
0.006452187430113554,
-0.5468928217887878,
-0.3628634214401245,
-0.40671634674072266,
-0.7142196893692017,
1.1025692224502563,
0.357035756111145,
-0.750967264175415,
0.4921874701976776,
0.28242501616477966,
0.23376718163490295,
-0.19992439448833466,
-0.19218498468399048,
0.835610032081604,
0.5825507044792175,
-0.060435086488723755,
-0.736183762550354,
0.08980008959770203,
-0.25845399498939514,
-0.21327754855155945,
0.39728742837905884,
-0.5769290924072266,
0.7623165845870972,
-0.0015647208783775568,
-0.19638819992542267,
-0.1997065544128418,
0.5011804103851318,
0.42875945568084717,
0.20340389013290405,
0.4865480661392212,
0.500601053237915,
0.9040746092796326,
-0.32626181840896606,
1.1852704286575317,
-0.31251874566078186,
-0.091582290828228,
1.2112480401992798,
-0.5520498156547546,
0.8942579030990601,
0.418766587972641,
0.004694236908107996,
0.6093285083770752,
0.48510998487472534,
-0.22059182822704315,
0.2262612283229828,
0.2773303687572479,
-0.7275827527046204,
-0.3741789162158966,
-0.23146116733551025,
-0.0590062253177166,
0.4028388559818268,
0.9540129899978638,
-0.1413046419620514,
-0.14714987576007843,
-0.18839190900325775,
0.5649152398109436,
0.08681406080722809,
-0.5409730672836304,
0.8008407354354858,
0.2622423470020294,
-0.5292035341262817,
0.2203204184770584,
0.048909224569797516,
0.8103264570236206,
-0.7418746948242188,
0.13215215504169464,
-0.2268727868795395,
0.25282740592956543,
-0.4468129873275757,
-1.3143576383590698,
0.3492793142795563,
0.31699138879776,
0.447994589805603,
-0.09755558520555496,
1.1029874086380005,
-0.19630810618400574,
-0.42848971486091614,
0.4650304913520813,
0.47944241762161255,
0.09917376190423965,
0.16120731830596924,
-0.6221075057983398,
0.29932349920272827,
-0.14942488074302673,
-0.3992794454097748,
0.4079325497150421,
0.3967874050140381,
-0.4321727156639099,
1.117189645767212,
0.6637634038925171,
0.04501346871256828,
0.12929560244083405,
0.2942230701446533,
0.9618831872940063,
-0.41899076104164124,
-0.6287535429000854,
-1.005973219871521,
0.2619924247264862,
-0.33340322971343994,
-0.18713310360908508,
1.0170289278030396,
0.5409541130065918,
0.6190246939659119,
0.31417423486709595,
0.8008614778518677,
0.02606309950351715,
0.20218558609485626,
-0.708827793598175,
0.9688203930854797,
-0.17342162132263184,
0.6796245574951172,
-0.14107510447502136,
-0.7522553205490112,
-0.3758453130722046,
0.5842987298965454,
-0.2638094425201416,
-0.14344383776187897,
0.4047907590866089,
1.0811450481414795,
-0.2136000394821167,
-0.28387191891670227,
0.5547102689743042,
0.2699352204799652,
0.43265607953071594,
0.3339153528213501,
1.0738757848739624,
0.21791231632232666,
0.7591200470924377,
0.14034950733184814,
-0.1628258228302002,
-0.3575995862483978,
-1.1912142038345337,
-1.3146156072616577,
0.09400811046361923,
-0.3008805811405182,
-0.6427566409111023,
-0.05749119445681572,
0.693531334400177,
0.5901942253112793,
-0.9163569808006287,
-0.6009993553161621,
0.1366463005542755,
0.1034582331776619,
0.24987860023975372,
-0.17364485561847687,
-0.11802209168672562,
-0.10167772322893143,
-0.44384846091270447,
0.49278560280799866,
0.3503454625606537,
0.4729410707950592,
-0.4986128807067871,
-0.08245918154716492,
-0.07068992406129837,
0.2982088625431061,
0.7215877771377563,
0.41359394788742065,
-0.38200342655181885,
-0.27828744053840637,
-0.3896072208881378,
-0.24708816409111023,
0.06880249083042145,
0.5207251906394958,
-0.24495165050029755,
0.09662768989801407,
0.5148993134498596,
0.4443064332008362,
0.5579359531402588,
-0.06271994113922119,
0.7392909526824951,
-0.8566586375236511,
0.29416850209236145,
0.005591989494860172,
0.8132328987121582,
0.5701825022697449,
-0.6000655293464661,
0.504955530166626,
-0.33128535747528076,
-0.640591025352478,
-0.7281401753425598,
0.5064996480941772,
-1.008810043334961,
-0.14563331007957458,
1.3019793033599854,
-0.08522103726863861,
-0.40193769335746765,
-0.3704928159713745,
-0.3217141032218933,
-0.35018664598464966,
-0.6751199960708618,
0.9200544953346252,
0.6953008770942688,
-0.019976312294602394,
-0.20330388844013214,
-1.0333127975463867,
0.5725194811820984,
-0.08488662540912628,
-1.2302860021591187,
0.014761850237846375,
0.6447067260742188,
0.6255797743797302,
0.045470718294382095,
0.6901093125343323,
-0.24362511932849884,
0.21774867177009583,
-0.10293831676244736,
0.009456937201321125,
-0.06756240874528885,
-0.128789484500885,
-0.1303444355726242,
-0.19626034796237946,
0.4675235152244568,
0.0584314726293087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17377v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17377v2
|
KoDialogBench: Evaluating Conversational Understanding of Language Models with Korean Dialogue Benchmark
| 2024-02-27T10:14:57 | 2024-06-17T05:12:56 |
Seongbo Jang, Seonghyeon Lee, Hwanjo Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As language models are often deployed as chatbot assistants, it becomes a
virtue for models to engage in conversations in a user's first language. While
these models are trained on a wide range of languages, a comprehensive
evaluation of their proficiency in low-resource languages such as Korean has
been lacking. In this work, we introduce KoDialogBench, a benchmark designed to
assess language models' conversational capabilities in Korean. To this end, we
collect native Korean dialogues on daily topics from public sources, or
translate dialogues from other languages. We then structure these conversations
into diverse test datasets, spanning from dialogue comprehension to response
selection tasks. Leveraging the proposed benchmark, we conduct extensive
evaluations and analyses of various language models to measure a foundational
understanding of Korean dialogues. Experimental results indicate that there
exists significant room for improvement in models' conversation skills.
Furthermore, our in-depth comparisons across different language models
highlight the effectiveness of recent training techniques in enhancing
conversational proficiency. We anticipate that KoDialogBench will promote the
progress towards conversation-aware Korean language models.
|
[
-0.36422473192214966,
-0.6963323950767517,
0.5710576772689819,
0.14718908071517944,
-0.27985647320747375,
0.3318745195865631,
-0.3214517831802368,
-0.3495463728904724,
-0.17851898074150085,
0.7675783634185791,
-0.45315197110176086,
-0.5964369773864746,
-0.2933262288570404,
0.06622139364480972,
-0.03557892516255379,
0.5955562591552734,
0.053613413125276566,
0.3960345387458801,
-0.5940101742744446,
-0.4045058786869049,
-0.6649401187896729,
-0.3355427384376526,
-0.4985347092151642,
-0.6546988487243652,
0.07217854261398315,
0.38826504349708557,
0.8004107475280762,
0.30572181940078735,
0.1843516081571579,
0.36113524436950684,
-0.19567042589187622,
-0.1431281715631485,
-0.6540966629981995,
0.29179754853248596,
-0.07131518423557281,
-0.6415162682533264,
-0.30885234475135803,
0.003983319271355867,
0.5306055545806885,
1.2394176721572876,
0.010788403451442719,
0.3203149437904358,
-0.09280943125486374,
0.6914424896240234,
-0.43374231457710266,
0.5951895713806152,
-0.5398374795913696,
0.03365779668092728,
0.2405911386013031,
0.24279218912124634,
-0.42902010679244995,
-0.48610126972198486,
0.35597681999206543,
-0.43350324034690857,
0.07348854839801788,
-0.11232659965753555,
0.6062526106834412,
0.057239897549152374,
-0.595536470413208,
-0.3207162618637085,
-0.5530455112457275,
0.5854402780532837,
-0.8081033229827881,
0.828217625617981,
0.5289987921714783,
0.6190274953842163,
-0.02103775553405285,
-0.48187607526779175,
-0.4133909344673157,
-0.8891014456748962,
-0.01929481141269207,
0.3522433638572693,
-0.1715434342622757,
0.23657023906707764,
0.2569918632507324,
0.3907438814640045,
-0.6348137259483337,
-0.1772129386663437,
-0.23748423159122467,
-0.3023303747177124,
0.4867875277996063,
0.2840069830417633,
0.2900378406047821,
-0.5498881340026855,
-0.04300505295395851,
-0.20166145265102386,
-0.20696301758289337,
0.14786840975284576,
0.5682277679443359,
0.3943946063518524,
-0.07476909458637238,
0.520774781703949,
-0.690788209438324,
0.7208027839660645,
-0.11171617358922958,
-0.2632503807544708,
0.19781185686588287,
-0.6872246861457825,
-0.10772455483675003,
0.10149560123682022,
0.44875261187553406,
0.7143542766571045,
0.35271474719047546,
-0.3204571306705475,
0.22825220227241516,
0.30961236357688904,
0.1541738659143448,
-0.8986709117889404,
-0.6069598197937012,
0.13884809613227844,
-0.6846279501914978,
-0.36433666944503784,
-0.29162752628326416,
-0.8112793564796448,
-0.528200626373291,
-0.264302521944046,
0.0073321484960615635,
0.007123375311493874,
-0.5786240696907043,
0.19065365195274353,
0.03190270811319351,
0.02384665235877037,
0.33514195680618286,
-0.3853212296962738,
0.4630153179168701,
0.5720920562744141,
0.6925170421600342,
0.02126227132976055,
0.000843735528178513,
-0.45095720887184143,
-0.4513881206512451,
-0.5360534191131592,
0.6857455372810364,
-0.6069650053977966,
-0.7808458805084229,
0.08086824417114258,
0.05839773267507553,
-0.3797135651111603,
-0.933614194393158,
0.516205906867981,
-0.41132915019989014,
-0.01699015684425831,
0.0036541882436722517,
-0.6443307995796204,
-0.23108966648578644,
0.3044552505016327,
-0.5534741878509521,
0.8847630023956299,
0.35366201400756836,
-0.327101469039917,
-0.0571504570543766,
-0.5552217364311218,
-0.18505741655826569,
0.1954459547996521,
-0.09093130379915237,
-0.03924471139907837,
0.15700632333755493,
0.007695615757256746,
0.27780550718307495,
-0.20555618405342102,
0.2941259443759918,
-0.5239095687866211,
0.06282589584589005,
0.5056595802307129,
-0.3056548833847046,
0.6481434106826782,
0.34252336621284485,
0.19603990018367767,
0.006379154045134783,
-0.8318987488746643,
0.5931214690208435,
0.15283410251140594,
-0.154450923204422,
-0.26904013752937317,
-0.3822890818119049,
0.09783417731523514,
0.2922830581665039,
0.2573380768299103,
-0.5498620271682739,
-0.016852641478180885,
-0.49470415711402893,
0.17459966242313385,
0.4194088280200958,
-0.013336366042494774,
0.6710786819458008,
-0.12118938565254211,
0.7066364884376526,
-0.23582762479782104,
-0.08572737872600555,
-0.6031985878944397,
-0.35909223556518555,
-0.6976385116577148,
0.03022639825940132,
0.5932165384292603,
0.6642404794692993,
-0.6788510680198669,
0.22841575741767883,
-0.3681303858757019,
-0.708869457244873,
-0.6323745250701904,
0.32100892066955566,
0.7283779978752136,
0.644648015499115,
-0.02977316826581955,
-0.43369922041893005,
-0.37139421701431274,
-0.9172576069831848,
-0.4848472774028778,
-0.509605884552002,
-0.2907838523387909,
0.8933234214782715,
0.299537718296051,
0.014506421983242035,
0.8203137516975403,
-0.43020743131637573,
0.3461196720600128,
-0.6631144881248474,
0.19510413706302643,
0.08470304310321808,
0.22148403525352478,
0.36110615730285645,
-0.5909411907196045,
-0.8252010345458984,
0.3198474943637848,
-0.558363139629364,
-0.41210776567459106,
0.18665729463100433,
-0.09120114892721176,
0.11728622764348984,
0.6793196797370911,
-0.5849916338920593,
0.4011533558368683,
0.7006826400756836,
-0.2490955889225006,
0.6590482592582703,
0.14108704030513763,
0.2555655539035797,
-1.0471253395080566,
0.16671498119831085,
-0.3618427515029907,
-0.4805143177509308,
-1.0080318450927734,
-0.13279186189174652,
-0.042718153446912766,
-0.5668986439704895,
-0.2828299105167389,
0.9259722828865051,
-0.05622300133109093,
-0.279001384973526,
-0.44266465306282043,
0.41205543279647827,
-0.16237583756446838,
0.5073939561843872,
0.09530336409807205,
0.6876650452613831,
0.16720722615718842,
-0.5221405625343323,
0.2713141441345215,
0.4287130832672119,
-0.7153745293617249,
0.7267317175865173,
-0.7868872880935669,
0.4253902733325958,
0.16056077182292938,
0.3018800616264343,
-1.2532488107681274,
-0.4936157464981079,
0.2713268995285034,
-0.4961712658405304,
-0.13189475238323212,
-0.6650301814079285,
-0.3198899030685425,
-0.24112844467163086,
0.222426638007164,
0.0584479458630085,
0.3445180058479309,
-0.37004804611206055,
0.6536755561828613,
0.44100144505500793,
-0.646073043346405,
-0.015135325491428375,
0.008380483835935593,
-0.06090845540165901,
-0.01120696309953928,
-0.7342478036880493,
-0.04179922118782997,
-0.2898467481136322,
-0.4375649392604828,
-0.16232432425022125,
-0.4810577929019928,
-0.2641445994377136,
0.12292405962944031,
0.21073243021965027,
0.30610373616218567,
-0.34156888723373413,
0.11266075819730759,
-0.17968414723873138,
-0.3137940466403961,
0.1268477588891983,
-0.008555768057703972,
0.9734537601470947,
-0.32814547419548035,
-0.5413585901260376,
-0.4830954968929291,
0.04207734391093254,
0.580021321773529,
0.011960617266595364,
0.3217618465423584,
0.274288535118103,
-0.06363014131784439,
0.3296044170856476,
-0.6604137420654297,
-0.19424554705619812,
-0.4336153268814087,
0.7097015380859375,
-0.461270272731781,
-0.7532654404640198,
0.7114183306694031,
-0.6195557117462158,
-0.1759442389011383,
0.02026122435927391,
0.4304404854774475,
0.0714569017291069,
1.3825514316558838,
0.42151087522506714,
-0.2474125772714615,
0.5304521918296814,
0.17301659286022186,
0.3960734009742737,
-0.6443747878074646,
-0.04447734355926514,
-0.6540243029594421,
0.16187331080436707,
-0.5466134548187256,
-0.48409005999565125,
0.1201346144080162,
0.24445010721683502,
-0.004060404375195503,
0.48707786202430725,
0.23461921513080597,
0.6561481952667236,
0.2739861309528351,
-0.02497169002890587,
0.37555351853370667,
-0.2943345308303833,
0.02934347093105316,
-0.09150277823209763,
-0.659821629524231,
-0.7275110483169556,
0.9808239936828613,
0.32189562916755676,
0.5477879047393799,
-0.2705127000808716,
0.3532482981681824,
0.027135850861668587,
0.010067477822303772,
-0.7613738179206848,
0.7677075862884521,
0.27428749203681946,
-0.35388970375061035,
-0.1868034154176712,
-0.6325883269309998,
-0.8319641947746277,
0.441596120595932,
0.23754893243312836,
-0.9636180400848389,
-0.15152031183242798,
0.11586171388626099,
-0.20022545754909515,
-0.21180115640163422,
-0.8794434070587158,
1.3862719535827637,
-0.1506480872631073,
-0.020484089851379395,
-0.31146499514579773,
-0.461530864238739,
0.20225879549980164,
0.27307596802711487,
-0.08915673196315765,
-0.47806355357170105,
0.311222106218338,
0.4701390266418457,
-0.1629246473312378,
0.7285319566726685,
-0.27717265486717224,
0.029015131294727325,
0.20108027756214142,
0.29136842489242554,
0.4818171560764313,
0.3319805860519409,
0.08452139794826508,
0.1708044409751892,
0.13183742761611938,
-0.4798176884651184,
-0.7376837730407715,
0.4355231821537018,
-0.5085539221763611,
-0.3080832362174988,
0.06860674917697906,
-0.6620948314666748,
-0.6271170377731323,
0.16854843497276306,
-0.08233147114515305,
0.28349751234054565,
-0.5537187457084656,
0.3008873462677002,
0.49604174494743347,
-0.19437375664710999,
-0.05049319192767143,
0.7592484951019287,
-0.6060414910316467,
-0.40413591265678406,
0.7915682196617126,
-0.13991767168045044,
0.7991998791694641,
-0.26452791690826416,
0.07672037929296494,
-0.3470677137374878,
-0.26342833042144775,
-0.4906165599822998,
-0.09518630802631378,
-0.8852699398994446,
0.038049694150686264,
-0.755304217338562,
-0.31251490116119385,
-0.2592994272708893,
-0.003101261332631111,
-0.7131223678588867,
-0.42065924406051636,
0.3405272364616394,
0.02005535550415516,
0.06684458255767822,
0.5436854958534241,
0.30252698063850403,
0.3576743006706238,
-0.8119388818740845,
0.2793450653553009,
0.39534518122673035,
0.45016831159591675,
-0.00214835861697793,
-0.4990873336791992,
-0.11672355979681015,
0.178330659866333,
-0.17695219814777374,
-0.6713418960571289,
0.3147752285003662,
-0.10519074648618698,
0.7677938938140869,
0.24131987988948822,
-0.022078560665249825,
0.708986759185791,
-0.37923017144203186,
0.6421708464622498,
-0.01907367818057537,
-0.9156034588813782,
0.5466843247413635,
-0.3612266778945923,
0.706555187702179,
0.8995500206947327,
0.0278828926384449,
-1.0833345651626587,
-0.48067161440849304,
-0.7815116047859192,
-0.5681189298629761,
0.6982718706130981,
0.44484809041023254,
0.3651793301105499,
0.2129703164100647,
-0.06588730216026306,
0.10843264311552048,
0.4353034794330597,
-0.42784494161605835,
0.004250322002917528,
-0.15993502736091614,
-0.08901596814393997,
-0.1684800237417221,
-0.04803549125790596,
-0.05432037264108658,
-0.1216575875878334,
0.4217926263809204,
-0.23420441150665283,
0.17224347591400146,
-0.17326147854328156,
-0.4294794797897339,
0.057584963738918304,
0.3214584290981293,
0.3816659152507782,
0.6847542524337769,
-0.13535870611667633,
-0.1665601283311844,
0.4094357490539551,
-0.4212104380130768,
-0.1322154849767685,
0.24657246470451355,
0.11543665081262589,
0.18953916430473328,
0.1942804753780365,
0.8225505948066711,
0.6200563907623291,
-1.0451631546020508,
0.17015327513217926,
-0.15143433213233948,
-0.030733618885278702,
-0.02352338656783104,
0.10038545727729797,
0.3142983913421631,
0.3419518768787384,
-0.13235953450202942,
0.04107935354113579,
0.17404288053512573,
-0.4808841943740845,
-0.045630112290382385,
0.2974514663219452,
-0.450427770614624,
-0.32326963543891907,
0.2379705160856247,
0.3662552833557129,
-0.5133087038993835,
0.7076507806777954,
-0.28942614793777466,
-0.7899340391159058,
0.7226606011390686,
0.45498237013816833,
0.8760128021240234,
-0.23488378524780273,
0.41931724548339844,
0.564447283744812,
-0.025858938694000244,
-0.06487030535936356,
0.15526503324508667,
-0.3323403000831604,
-0.8225305080413818,
-0.17922227084636688,
-0.34492558240890503,
-0.8903990983963013,
0.2553076148033142,
-0.7519674897193909,
-0.0015601894119754434,
-0.04332723096013069,
-0.0680016353726387,
0.07254411280155182,
0.16073349118232727,
-0.6770359873771667,
-0.3905552327632904,
0.04204258322715759,
0.7254043221473694,
-0.8793783783912659,
0.5542512536048889,
0.604087769985199,
-0.18344005942344666,
-0.29922667145729065,
0.0270548053085804,
-0.07397592067718506,
-0.6732752919197083,
0.629453182220459,
0.4063114821910858,
-0.0833410695195198,
-0.07360262423753738,
-0.44078510999679565,
-0.6612356305122375,
0.7008289694786072,
0.4144558608531952,
-0.33475810289382935,
0.4278445839881897,
0.34390923380851746,
0.6382623910903931,
-0.49300554394721985,
0.1775871068239212,
0.7961063385009766,
0.24767686426639557,
-0.0928175076842308,
-1.2945107221603394,
-0.3746505379676819,
-0.5778405070304871,
0.1620643436908722,
0.006885697599500418,
-0.4969896376132965,
0.4911334812641144,
0.24395571649074554,
-0.18787357211112976,
0.4864160716533661,
0.47906777262687683,
0.2570759057998657,
0.6669251322746277,
0.7010707259178162,
0.3073762059211731,
0.8215131163597107,
0.009780648164451122,
0.9301889538764954,
-0.5514105558395386,
0.22120480239391327,
1.4473198652267456,
-0.525154173374176,
0.7586665749549866,
0.09504944831132889,
-0.32017782330513,
0.3385010063648224,
0.4037898778915405,
0.2398761510848999,
0.4986116886138916,
0.15674099326133728,
-0.4259547293186188,
-0.5433952808380127,
-0.4673542380332947,
-0.1958797574043274,
0.6122214198112488,
0.2163069248199463,
-0.10074722021818161,
-0.3279680013656616,
0.19141237437725067,
0.14957024157047272,
0.2842596471309662,
-0.2500621974468231,
0.8718603253364563,
-0.0972447320818901,
-0.8096039295196533,
0.3694431483745575,
-0.36860817670822144,
-0.05402179807424545,
-0.5122750997543335,
-0.05006024241447449,
-0.3557417690753937,
0.3239491283893585,
0.3100995123386383,
-0.5289806723594666,
-0.00683490140363574,
0.05203607678413391,
-0.07669008523225784,
-0.0656198188662529,
0.981178343296051,
-0.5779448747634888,
-0.36963582038879395,
0.1652965247631073,
0.7030830383300781,
0.3429100811481476,
-0.1853073239326477,
-0.7399682402610779,
0.16970518231391907,
-0.10887572914361954,
-0.03458282724022865,
0.42606157064437866,
0.10184670984745026,
0.014624050818383694,
0.673855721950531,
0.6503198146820068,
-0.25520971417427063,
0.01261377427726984,
0.4056718647480011,
0.7863350510597229,
-0.3022909164428711,
-0.531639575958252,
-0.38664594292640686,
0.3140157163143158,
-0.567612886428833,
-0.36523711681365967,
0.9156340956687927,
0.6609311103820801,
1.1379683017730713,
-0.23343536257743835,
0.8652864098548889,
0.14091408252716064,
0.6344610452651978,
-0.4514560401439667,
0.6771352887153625,
-0.10295936465263367,
-0.10587496310472488,
-0.3724891245365143,
-0.8114573359489441,
0.20667900145053864,
0.994219958782196,
-0.48840925097465515,
0.06700321286916733,
0.42583826184272766,
0.9096401929855347,
-0.15493357181549072,
0.387492835521698,
0.4621617794036865,
0.12459398806095123,
0.13129916787147522,
0.15284645557403564,
1.1006501913070679,
-0.32335594296455383,
0.7299935221672058,
-0.521049976348877,
0.02425565756857395,
-0.388994425535202,
-0.7398379445075989,
-1.28730046749115,
-0.5016958713531494,
-0.24701657891273499,
-0.3841093182563782,
0.11628200113773346,
1.0389935970306396,
0.7241302728652954,
-0.8243992328643799,
-0.5628097057342529,
-0.19224373996257782,
0.077384814620018,
-0.11305877566337585,
-0.2128130942583084,
0.010452665388584137,
-0.6221129298210144,
-0.8481676578521729,
0.6819761991500854,
0.19769109785556793,
0.04932770878076553,
-0.1331992745399475,
-0.2521880269050598,
0.27507108449935913,
0.12626150250434875,
0.5900471210479736,
0.44813913106918335,
-0.7174378633499146,
-0.01963246986269951,
0.3580061197280884,
-0.11348988115787506,
-0.06598744541406631,
0.9049107432365417,
-0.7533956170082092,
1.0044752359390259,
0.5232897996902466,
0.7312765121459961,
0.4612140953540802,
0.04854020103812218,
0.7446555495262146,
-0.44231653213500977,
0.2784258723258972,
0.1880394071340561,
0.04737958684563637,
0.3116442561149597,
0.05089245364069939,
0.6934282779693604,
0.09076565504074097,
-0.5906815528869629,
-1.1915736198425293,
0.2988393008708954,
-0.823431134223938,
-0.02334291860461235,
0.858385443687439,
-0.25012990832328796,
-0.06111603230237961,
-0.4334748685359955,
-0.5192651748657227,
0.092298224568367,
-0.34167519211769104,
0.7607221007347107,
1.0722682476043701,
-0.0866783857345581,
-0.01363795530050993,
-1.2823225259780884,
0.3664224147796631,
0.46796733140945435,
-0.8798855543136597,
0.6007380485534668,
0.37208661437034607,
0.1435876041650772,
0.23373208940029144,
0.7181487679481506,
0.024377943947911263,
0.6274033188819885,
0.24736909568309784,
-0.18495085835456848,
0.20121024549007416,
-0.18805645406246185,
-0.26077884435653687,
-0.2264316976070404,
-0.0676196813583374,
-0.10822359472513199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17371v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17371v1
|
A Dataset for Metaphor Detection in Early Medieval Hebrew Poetry
| 2024-02-27T10:09:40 | 2024-02-27T10:09:40 |
Michael Toker, Oren Mishali, Ophir Münz-Manor, Benny Kimelfeld, Yonatan Belinkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
There is a large volume of late antique and medieval Hebrew texts. They
represent a crucial linguistic and cultural bridge between Biblical and modern
Hebrew. Poetry is prominent in these texts and one of its main haracteristics
is the frequent use of metaphor. Distinguishing figurative and literal language
use is a major task for scholars of the Humanities, especially in the fields of
literature, linguistics, and hermeneutics. This paper presents a new,
challenging dataset of late antique and medieval Hebrew poetry with expert
annotations of metaphor, as well as some baseline results, which we hope will
facilitate further research in this area.
|
[
-0.38156336545944214,
-0.4401593804359436,
0.2616231441497803,
0.03396383672952652,
-0.5352410078048706,
-0.3552796244621277,
-0.03058094158768654,
-0.5618211627006531,
0.35054388642311096,
0.4982846677303314,
-0.2823448181152344,
-0.36228856444358826,
-0.6694531440734863,
0.14862060546875,
-0.4143369793891907,
0.7062543630599976,
-0.07981652021408081,
-0.06905528903007507,
0.17801696062088013,
-0.39730411767959595,
-0.7383411526679993,
-0.3285661041736603,
-0.5001311302185059,
-0.31771987676620483,
0.5602863430976868,
0.06096770614385605,
1.154954433441162,
0.6327114701271057,
0.5204976797103882,
0.4389960765838623,
-0.011594122275710106,
0.1309298276901245,
-0.22067171335220337,
0.6151019334793091,
-0.0777004286646843,
-0.6902508735656738,
-0.04393588751554489,
0.4477463364601135,
0.8309439420700073,
0.47276878356933594,
-0.14860594272613525,
0.21457640826702118,
-0.4087594449520111,
0.4517616033554077,
-0.8148060441017151,
0.3375556170940399,
-1.197459101676941,
0.5297250151634216,
-1.1095834970474243,
-0.8219889998435974,
-0.43516749143600464,
-0.1817876547574997,
-0.06252287328243256,
-0.8085587024688721,
-0.04426514729857445,
0.7566615343093872,
0.7856196761131287,
0.3197624087333679,
-0.1674690842628479,
-0.27938103675842285,
-0.30636394023895264,
1.0407761335372925,
-0.3415413200855255,
0.2539452910423279,
0.6854114532470703,
0.8819231390953064,
-0.47856107354164124,
-1.0088822841644287,
-0.46092885732650757,
-0.3949322998523712,
-0.32254618406295776,
0.05602026730775833,
-0.8168840408325195,
-0.6490617394447327,
0.4116250276565552,
0.25317710638046265,
-0.5768726468086243,
0.07705146074295044,
-0.3587356507778168,
-0.4655916690826416,
0.09183746576309204,
0.3801248073577881,
0.6224477887153625,
-0.3204238712787628,
-0.38287705183029175,
-0.16918055713176727,
-0.6384441256523132,
-0.10152585804462433,
0.4136587679386139,
0.06880410015583038,
-0.10587979108095169,
0.5642783641815186,
0.21653321385383606,
0.8697628378868103,
-0.5702499747276306,
-0.14248712360858917,
0.4697735011577606,
0.038115572184324265,
-0.11488453298807144,
0.2308422327041626,
0.535157322883606,
0.36511096358299255,
0.7415865063667297,
-0.123869389295578,
0.0023134322836995125,
0.4413278102874756,
0.467084676027298,
-0.402756005525589,
-0.4444437325000763,
-0.6140146851539612,
-0.7109803557395935,
-0.2767255902290344,
-0.08148963749408722,
-0.4043770432472229,
-0.5557844638824463,
-0.1516968011856079,
-0.27003875374794006,
-0.4252995252609253,
0.1191699206829071,
0.17298907041549683,
-0.7229252457618713,
0.05270088091492653,
0.342389851808548,
-0.5926290154457092,
0.1993127167224884,
0.5880381464958191,
0.6661808490753174,
0.02856130711734295,
-0.4680958390235901,
-0.7241691946983337,
0.3143409490585327,
-0.4648556113243103,
0.9687113761901855,
-0.9544637203216553,
0.19461281597614288,
-0.11023721843957901,
0.07543957233428955,
0.3253796100616455,
-0.7198570966720581,
1.099608302116394,
-0.7605641484260559,
0.258430540561676,
0.013509774580597878,
-0.6146833896636963,
-0.3263819217681885,
0.18398505449295044,
-1.1011818647384644,
0.9860642552375793,
0.26562952995300293,
-1.275648832321167,
0.03491337224841118,
0.056071192026138306,
-0.017980195581912994,
0.43491819500923157,
-0.8653722405433655,
-0.07740537822246552,
0.44197097420692444,
-0.03353986144065857,
0.3253995180130005,
-0.9035657644271851,
-0.09137894213199615,
-0.06488964706659317,
-0.8111720681190491,
0.603934645652771,
-0.5585134625434875,
0.9687135219573975,
0.4349873960018158,
-0.19332686066627502,
-0.419399231672287,
-0.7174328565597534,
0.050382100045681,
0.31653454899787903,
0.22099485993385315,
-0.9079312682151794,
-0.04456831514835358,
0.4478057622909546,
0.05675743520259857,
-0.09176328778266907,
-0.4182523787021637,
-0.05553508549928665,
-0.416049987077713,
0.19068218767642975,
0.4872303009033203,
-0.36859819293022156,
-0.15489867329597473,
-0.6576573252677917,
0.705956757068634,
-0.07704988867044449,
-0.35421741008758545,
-0.22679130733013153,
-0.5721361637115479,
-0.1453535109758377,
-0.3844289183616638,
0.4546091556549072,
0.39074328541755676,
-0.9314103126525879,
0.4876112639904022,
-0.34347793459892273,
-0.526939332485199,
-0.592008650302887,
-0.11456335335969925,
0.044432852417230606,
0.5724139213562012,
0.42881983518600464,
-0.39911165833473206,
-0.2540434002876282,
-1.1285940408706665,
-0.6153725385665894,
-0.2525654435157776,
-0.22998598217964172,
0.24215440452098846,
0.3381200134754181,
0.09764952957630157,
0.9022298455238342,
-0.4840538799762726,
-0.40313059091567993,
0.1951293647289276,
0.28597643971443176,
0.013238544575870037,
0.25578880310058594,
1.1099814176559448,
-0.9819644689559937,
-0.3812345862388611,
-0.026859857141971588,
-0.6643357276916504,
-0.3502337336540222,
-0.003303246572613716,
-0.25325122475624084,
-0.45477715134620667,
0.5383350253105164,
-0.1895897388458252,
0.5584321022033691,
0.38754668831825256,
-0.5240373015403748,
0.44284966588020325,
0.043756451457738876,
0.1842896193265915,
-0.7905964851379395,
0.14071273803710938,
-0.18855708837509155,
-0.023719262331724167,
-0.5429509282112122,
-0.16564077138900757,
0.02090018428862095,
0.19725535809993744,
-0.5322471261024475,
0.8043420910835266,
-0.21543394029140472,
0.283265620470047,
-0.45792490243911743,
0.08812730014324188,
-0.1742599457502365,
-0.11861617118120193,
0.09994985163211823,
0.6392216682434082,
0.5490137934684753,
0.17203029990196228,
0.7585505843162537,
0.45049595832824707,
-0.3289218544960022,
0.8593946099281311,
-0.47800999879837036,
0.039114806801080704,
-0.3361310660839081,
0.4351223111152649,
-0.884381115436554,
-0.19294796884059906,
0.44878894090652466,
-0.3809467554092407,
-0.0023734725546091795,
-0.058484774082899094,
-0.8409526944160461,
-0.11854403465986252,
-0.35768985748291016,
1.1744416952133179,
0.5820939540863037,
-0.2626059949398041,
0.3619428873062134,
0.17562973499298096,
-0.03475174307823181,
-0.6617006063461304,
-0.7966715097427368,
0.25614964962005615,
-0.5113571286201477,
-0.59725022315979,
0.5300886034965515,
0.27387043833732605,
-0.4299652874469757,
0.14632761478424072,
-0.012606559321284294,
-0.31930723786354065,
0.05588801950216293,
0.07737720012664795,
0.25426560640335083,
-0.15956160426139832,
0.01419476605951786,
-0.06386614590883255,
-0.45014968514442444,
-0.04222937673330307,
-0.033606499433517456,
0.5551775693893433,
-0.09030470997095108,
-0.44152626395225525,
-0.6951992511749268,
0.439762681722641,
0.6930894255638123,
-0.15422925353050232,
0.5691890716552734,
0.7243117094039917,
-0.6378821730613708,
0.13437649607658386,
-0.6426162719726562,
-0.019215213134884834,
-0.43753114342689514,
-0.018525613471865654,
-0.2430633306503296,
-0.5828791260719299,
0.49083957076072693,
-0.07983158528804779,
-0.3330530822277069,
0.533602774143219,
0.5109394192695618,
-0.14664563536643982,
0.1879051923751831,
-0.07738685607910156,
-0.33745619654655457,
0.20770792663097382,
0.2587072551250458,
-0.048924271017313004,
-0.5777894258499146,
0.07683414965867996,
-0.8992390036582947,
-0.6389926075935364,
-0.8901270031929016,
-0.5216796398162842,
0.356896311044693,
-0.20500734448432922,
-0.16460393369197845,
0.10197942703962326,
-0.24238291382789612,
0.34804654121398926,
0.5467992424964905,
-0.4035722315311432,
0.26127731800079346,
0.5928322672843933,
-0.16481567919254303,
-0.5480308532714844,
-0.33226874470710754,
-0.6020409464836121,
0.7856038808822632,
0.40442636609077454,
0.44001248478889465,
-0.023685676977038383,
0.4812379777431488,
0.5592381358146667,
0.005733314901590347,
-0.6498103141784668,
0.4232078492641449,
-0.31294703483581543,
-0.5872122049331665,
0.1432042419910431,
-0.42762741446495056,
-1.3217523097991943,
0.30338916182518005,
-0.1255725622177124,
-0.7932021021842957,
-0.07700662314891815,
0.04357874393463135,
-0.19342617690563202,
0.13988202810287476,
0.028748691082000732,
0.7830655574798584,
0.21785323321819305,
0.16555596888065338,
-0.14530742168426514,
-0.8229156732559204,
-0.04114168509840965,
0.005267845466732979,
0.3009805679321289,
-0.22337590157985687,
-0.22342181205749512,
0.7706429362297058,
-0.07145411521196365,
0.5894318222999573,
0.1405295729637146,
0.15896449983119965,
0.4114488363265991,
0.4456840455532074,
0.6891202330589294,
-0.5334364771842957,
-0.03138984739780426,
0.044450096786022186,
0.29397037625312805,
-0.5853490233421326,
-0.5238781571388245,
0.49773508310317993,
-0.2769697606563568,
0.0624069944024086,
-0.8958577513694763,
-0.7768880128860474,
0.070407435297966,
0.041973136365413666,
0.27883780002593994,
0.29608944058418274,
0.07535234093666077,
0.530318021774292,
0.06048929691314697,
-0.18148508667945862,
0.16877293586730957,
0.21249783039093018,
0.02783517725765705,
-0.2994104325771332,
0.5609809160232544,
0.20080341398715973,
-0.35599246621131897,
0.017444824799895287,
0.31819993257522583,
-0.03916368633508682,
-0.41514620184898376,
-0.34775349497795105,
0.12769412994384766,
-0.6777307987213135,
-0.22662849724292755,
-0.03000161610543728,
-0.21033506095409393,
0.14713194966316223,
-0.2244410365819931,
-0.23243366181850433,
-0.22571517527103424,
-0.22125780582427979,
0.32906806468963623,
0.4984992444515228,
0.29531797766685486,
0.4187823235988617,
0.44976550340652466,
-0.8799415826797485,
0.30573511123657227,
0.10740189254283905,
0.004512048792093992,
0.05436214804649353,
-0.29898136854171753,
0.25301727652549744,
-0.3352389633655548,
-0.03983774408698082,
-1.213678002357483,
0.13187646865844727,
0.03097277507185936,
0.47393760085105896,
0.39554673433303833,
0.06992898881435394,
0.3441806733608246,
-1.0375744104385376,
0.6941283345222473,
0.45656466484069824,
-0.46559664607048035,
0.2300199568271637,
-0.48159095644950867,
0.04532807320356369,
0.48068687319755554,
0.5004830956459045,
-0.9796867370605469,
-0.4457300901412964,
-0.62469881772995,
-0.6136012077331543,
0.46981969475746155,
0.8066743016242981,
0.36039066314697266,
-0.2611868977546692,
0.45802319049835205,
0.40868234634399414,
0.34721335768699646,
-0.5616855621337891,
-0.6012469530105591,
0.10643664002418518,
-0.40234798192977905,
0.18800948560237885,
-0.1009795218706131,
-0.29296475648880005,
-0.5519739985466003,
0.08697140961885452,
0.12384296953678131,
0.14019976556301117,
-0.4690958261489868,
-0.1492091417312622,
0.053893908858299255,
0.2459195852279663,
0.13221336901187897,
0.7308433055877686,
0.27200376987457275,
0.74049973487854,
0.1347937285900116,
-0.6341002583503723,
0.024764947593212128,
0.08525625616312027,
-0.368251770734787,
0.10958122462034225,
0.7506438493728638,
0.7964462637901306,
0.13445399701595306,
-0.5968683362007141,
0.39138278365135193,
0.25468939542770386,
0.2755706310272217,
-0.8296433091163635,
-0.029600631445646286,
-0.13245801627635956,
0.4759230315685272,
0.4951492249965668,
0.11074262857437134,
0.3260314464569092,
-0.4644966125488281,
0.13352583348751068,
0.3788703680038452,
-0.23929736018180847,
-0.24671106040477753,
0.37477755546569824,
-0.5566134452819824,
-0.20729754865169525,
0.677553653717041,
-0.32957175374031067,
-0.466289222240448,
0.39280104637145996,
0.679113507270813,
0.6016373038291931,
-0.11063195019960403,
0.2135925441980362,
-0.1718641072511673,
0.14259357750415802,
0.20060262084007263,
0.2962968051433563,
0.2747872471809387,
-0.7473843097686768,
-0.06955067813396454,
-0.7322311997413635,
0.13213932514190674,
0.3006225824356079,
-0.6244133114814758,
0.2551642656326294,
0.08530610799789429,
-0.2497144341468811,
0.37463879585266113,
-0.3970361053943634,
-0.9639228582382202,
0.04670635983347893,
0.2592960596084595,
0.836757481098175,
-1.1236311197280884,
0.6873296499252319,
0.8404567241668701,
-0.1302339881658554,
-0.4332653880119324,
0.05789695680141449,
0.21745693683624268,
-0.7782201766967773,
1.1373828649520874,
-0.0029402892105281353,
-0.4131482243537903,
0.060552287846803665,
-0.39706987142562866,
-0.339670330286026,
0.9377908110618591,
0.5563854575157166,
-0.19144763052463531,
-0.08807430416345596,
-0.10225876420736313,
0.6925257444381714,
-0.394803524017334,
0.3816685378551483,
0.7771378755569458,
0.7155331969261169,
0.12308098375797272,
-0.7901967763900757,
0.040548175573349,
-0.3558015823364258,
0.21460409462451935,
0.2865491807460785,
-0.35515040159225464,
0.9478073120117188,
0.7575005292892456,
-0.15327967703342438,
0.2771708369255066,
0.8161373138427734,
0.4935455322265625,
0.5123022794723511,
0.6491245031356812,
0.7314623594284058,
0.678422749042511,
0.007394242100417614,
0.8531911969184875,
-0.13566480576992035,
0.02808487042784691,
0.9683577418327332,
-0.1456346958875656,
0.7320136427879333,
0.5909231305122375,
-0.23106351494789124,
0.5135889649391174,
0.60323166847229,
-0.379686564207077,
0.4591025710105896,
0.7098933458328247,
-0.47015801072120667,
-0.26516032218933105,
-0.6170595288276672,
-0.7506240010261536,
0.7992200255393982,
0.2178090661764145,
-0.5072417259216309,
-0.48890894651412964,
-0.012252427637577057,
0.3270432949066162,
0.19484910368919373,
-0.12829989194869995,
0.2694861590862274,
0.11760473251342773,
-0.26989737153053284,
0.4504806697368622,
0.09513849020004272,
0.34657853841781616,
-0.3471625745296478,
-0.23998285830020905,
0.31690654158592224,
-0.150875523686409,
0.07761391252279282,
-0.39819273352622986,
0.19536522030830383,
-0.0045209345407783985,
0.10936557501554489,
0.2524770200252533,
0.8777246475219727,
-0.2497144341468811,
-0.5619836449623108,
0.35780927538871765,
0.7964322566986084,
0.5940601825714111,
0.023681625723838806,
-0.36645087599754333,
0.09322735667228699,
-0.42742374539375305,
-0.177466481924057,
-0.04224178567528725,
0.7882192730903625,
-0.39595600962638855,
0.3752950429916382,
0.22376930713653564,
0.44182583689689636,
0.1570516973733902,
0.09815613180398941,
0.8823859691619873,
-0.6485118269920349,
-0.4669642150402069,
-0.8166787624359131,
0.08660652488470078,
-0.12675368785858154,
-0.361604779958725,
0.6410439610481262,
0.352390319108963,
0.7039523720741272,
-0.1273309886455536,
0.5854308605194092,
-0.0101717384532094,
0.13252857327461243,
-0.4849163591861725,
0.8957298994064331,
-0.7552353739738464,
-0.1087455153465271,
-0.3079317808151245,
-0.8256528377532959,
-0.38558417558670044,
1.0365699529647827,
-0.27774322032928467,
0.09787861257791519,
0.8799443244934082,
0.30556750297546387,
-0.4648148715496063,
0.39610421657562256,
0.11583193391561508,
-0.04192883148789406,
-0.08792146295309067,
0.2247379720211029,
1.2069138288497925,
-0.3940843641757965,
0.04633025452494621,
-0.0045247445814311504,
-0.05676239728927612,
-0.154580757021904,
-1.0834776163101196,
-0.8709220886230469,
-0.7106834053993225,
-0.25381216406822205,
-0.21034333109855652,
-0.11119930446147919,
1.2607084512710571,
0.18079829216003418,
-0.8024017810821533,
-0.011467326432466507,
0.20646785199642181,
-0.44679081439971924,
-0.21714232861995697,
-0.0699213370680809,
0.6429604291915894,
-0.3548530340194702,
-0.6693184971809387,
0.41893261671066284,
0.05428207665681839,
0.16268499195575714,
0.02648511901497841,
0.04012047499418259,
0.022138532251119614,
-0.06592367589473724,
0.24150550365447998,
-0.07349516451358795,
-0.9951022863388062,
-0.4856775999069214,
-0.258156418800354,
-0.04382023215293884,
0.09668070077896118,
1.0325844287872314,
-0.5413240194320679,
0.502230167388916,
0.6986284255981445,
0.7460232377052307,
0.1330024152994156,
-0.0697469562292099,
0.1493033468723297,
-0.9528209567070007,
0.6997999548912048,
0.5547659993171692,
0.5985588431358337,
0.07220714539289474,
-0.011543788015842438,
0.43394598364830017,
0.6276283264160156,
-0.12898296117782593,
-0.8013574481010437,
0.3721144199371338,
-0.9394521713256836,
-0.16951550543308258,
0.6366989016532898,
-0.3544916808605194,
0.07870372384786606,
-0.2647169232368469,
-0.3328702449798584,
0.2850612699985504,
-0.07640942186117172,
0.7593555450439453,
1.2924295663833618,
0.2096220999956131,
0.006431322544813156,
-1.151038646697998,
0.4699067175388336,
0.6498246192932129,
-0.469463586807251,
-0.2121015191078186,
0.7895019054412842,
-0.06161319464445114,
0.31767499446868896,
0.4283263683319092,
-0.19530697166919708,
0.34689605236053467,
-0.024924809113144875,
-0.19773441553115845,
-0.06516331434249878,
-0.6573447585105896,
0.048855822533369064,
0.5119849443435669,
0.05128328874707222,
-0.25721174478530884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17358v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17358v1
|
SoFA: Shielded On-the-fly Alignment via Priority Rule Following
| 2024-02-27T09:52:27 | 2024-02-27T09:52:27 |
Xinyu Lu, Bowen Yu, Yaojie Lu, Hongyu Lin, Haiyang Yu, Le Sun, Xianpei Han, Yongbin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The alignment problem in Large Language Models (LLMs) involves adapting them
to the broad spectrum of human values. This requirement challenges existing
alignment methods due to diversity of preferences and regulatory standards.
This paper introduces a novel alignment paradigm, priority rule following,
which defines rules as the primary control mechanism in each dialog,
prioritizing them over user instructions. Our preliminary analysis reveals that
even the advanced LLMs, such as GPT-4, exhibit shortcomings in understanding
and prioritizing the rules. Therefore, we present PriorityDistill, a
semi-automated approach for distilling priority following signals from LLM
simulations to ensure robust rule integration and adherence. Our experiments
show that this method not only effectively minimizes misalignments utilizing
only one general rule but also adapts smoothly to various unseen rules,
ensuring they are shielded from hijacking and that the model responds
appropriately.
|
[
-0.21429678797721863,
-0.7813095450401306,
0.5851759910583496,
0.24955591559410095,
-0.034385863691568375,
0.21616211533546448,
0.019812146201729774,
0.021176401525735855,
-0.030136864632368088,
0.8056382536888123,
-0.6724420785903931,
-0.3848429024219513,
-0.47345811128616333,
-0.08179488778114319,
-0.34451034665107727,
0.8789646029472351,
-0.0670977234840393,
-0.3159162402153015,
-0.15421269834041595,
0.02995750866830349,
-0.4785683751106262,
-0.5173093676567078,
-0.30754727125167847,
-0.09678056091070175,
0.48231974244117737,
0.6046450734138489,
0.9852436780929565,
0.9256608486175537,
0.625423789024353,
0.3082720637321472,
-0.17315644025802612,
0.043188273906707764,
-0.4149361550807953,
0.12550188601016998,
-0.15797832608222961,
-0.49700605869293213,
-0.8320778012275696,
-0.061968713998794556,
0.5930209755897522,
0.37154561281204224,
-0.34273406863212585,
-0.09586039185523987,
0.30747708678245544,
0.6087941527366638,
-0.47341006994247437,
-0.2874770164489746,
-0.49193882942199707,
0.05634298175573349,
-0.46300649642944336,
-0.26534613966941833,
-0.40245920419692993,
-0.4323575496673584,
-0.02952827885746956,
-0.5430048704147339,
-0.18267551064491272,
0.11011148989200592,
1.1259403228759766,
0.704707145690918,
-0.5221887826919556,
0.020661702379584312,
-0.5274770855903625,
0.7317859530448914,
-0.6636180281639099,
0.24135009944438934,
0.35217350721359253,
0.2182314395904541,
-0.4542405903339386,
-0.36399710178375244,
-0.5896766781806946,
0.06414102017879486,
-0.14102789759635925,
0.037991661578416824,
0.013476123102009296,
0.22865743935108185,
0.34606340527534485,
0.08735383301973343,
-0.7116822004318237,
0.3418729603290558,
0.08005822449922562,
-0.25251132249832153,
0.4248274564743042,
0.15945486724376678,
0.34661927819252014,
0.02931792661547661,
-0.4257642924785614,
0.029746798798441887,
-0.8317162394523621,
0.18633486330509186,
0.2615901529788971,
0.1849910169839859,
-0.13689781725406647,
0.6430761814117432,
-0.21931837499141693,
0.8647589683532715,
0.7392234206199646,
-0.21369105577468872,
0.16230612993240356,
-0.44560280442237854,
-0.33217132091522217,
0.2045835703611374,
0.5788670778274536,
0.5994827151298523,
0.10123144090175629,
-0.1156097874045372,
-0.12525340914726257,
-0.1943056881427765,
0.4336394965648651,
-0.44039109349250793,
0.060073189437389374,
0.29223617911338806,
-0.17427553236484528,
-0.5708169341087341,
-0.2492634654045105,
-0.9019457101821899,
-0.5549290180206299,
-0.48038458824157715,
0.2683248817920685,
0.12185297161340714,
-0.11499176919460297,
0.10803844034671783,
0.3676920533180237,
0.5418089032173157,
0.18943236768245697,
-1.0937328338623047,
0.3522753417491913,
0.7991200685501099,
0.8360641598701477,
-0.2893325686454773,
-0.042607635259628296,
-0.7571701407432556,
0.6404492259025574,
-0.3469173014163971,
0.7617313265800476,
-0.4154002070426941,
-0.1341906487941742,
-0.07633043825626373,
0.20052768290042877,
-0.014046508818864822,
-0.0657682791352272,
0.8261259198188782,
-0.6739767789840698,
0.08065980672836304,
-0.18496298789978027,
-0.6120463609695435,
0.0846872329711914,
0.11777932941913605,
-0.6739850640296936,
0.7249741554260254,
-0.12756869196891785,
-0.6651833653450012,
0.36661848425865173,
-0.5006561279296875,
-0.5869411826133728,
0.013404487632215023,
-0.2257520705461502,
-0.5521944761276245,
-0.06723552942276001,
0.2090136557817459,
0.3464198410511017,
0.004119849763810635,
0.3298490345478058,
-0.3622550666332245,
-0.14741989970207214,
0.14232689142227173,
-0.29188627004623413,
0.8205071687698364,
0.16426126658916473,
-0.5530579686164856,
0.4255569577217102,
-0.39450010657310486,
0.034596748650074005,
-0.11284071952104568,
-0.217474102973938,
-0.20922033488750458,
0.1881718933582306,
-0.17187920212745667,
0.4621019661426544,
0.2677740454673767,
-0.1011795923113823,
0.47635573148727417,
-0.19140014052391052,
0.41304656863212585,
1.1939876079559326,
-0.13819511234760284,
0.9703644514083862,
-0.5454229712486267,
0.6065049171447754,
-0.3671222925186157,
0.2564851641654968,
0.3015769422054291,
-0.2746123671531677,
-0.7409810423851013,
-0.4050905704498291,
0.4185144007205963,
0.7647640705108643,
-0.3139629065990448,
0.9462116956710815,
-0.169593945145607,
-0.24450455605983734,
-0.7618361711502075,
0.29105305671691895,
0.28716233372688293,
0.3234190344810486,
0.1573762148618698,
-0.03570041060447693,
-0.4074493944644928,
-0.9302064776420593,
0.05467363819479942,
0.03399468958377838,
0.053100552409887314,
0.04952288046479225,
-0.21196720004081726,
-0.13533636927604675,
0.9665056467056274,
-0.456108957529068,
-0.2992769181728363,
-0.281613826751709,
-0.023221494629979134,
0.19648377597332,
0.6064854264259338,
0.5354391932487488,
-0.9011422991752625,
-0.5676805377006531,
-0.0601632259786129,
-0.5320925712585449,
-0.696637749671936,
-0.3046281039714813,
-0.7116397023200989,
0.4509109556674957,
0.9356235861778259,
-0.5485450625419617,
0.4407421350479126,
0.6793395280838013,
-0.353933721780777,
0.18940025568008423,
0.05409568175673485,
0.22029007971286774,
-1.1479926109313965,
0.034257058054208755,
-0.09303365647792816,
-0.43286198377609253,
-0.6884422898292542,
-0.1425325721502304,
0.22273628413677216,
0.24824915826320648,
-0.2833996117115021,
0.41750645637512207,
-0.48397335410118103,
0.0893360897898674,
-0.3241114914417267,
-0.07193168997764587,
0.09985917061567307,
0.25327354669570923,
0.22698964178562164,
0.6945411562919617,
0.4731055200099945,
-0.6196665167808533,
0.12028467655181885,
0.3762056827545166,
-0.21035213768482208,
0.6454839110374451,
-0.4561627209186554,
0.07224416732788086,
0.02242586575448513,
0.18742981553077698,
-1.0807092189788818,
-0.1998024582862854,
0.23685592412948608,
-0.00324878073297441,
0.5908381938934326,
-0.42475324869155884,
-0.3641122281551361,
-0.21915726363658905,
-0.030266113579273224,
0.259916216135025,
0.6236146688461304,
-0.12357906252145767,
0.6057139039039612,
0.7891085147857666,
-0.46567192673683167,
-0.6975898146629333,
-0.4015055000782013,
0.06200776994228363,
-0.5963112711906433,
-0.33656197786331177,
0.549782395362854,
-0.3729930818080902,
-0.3518291413784027,
-0.2668987512588501,
-0.20400650799274445,
0.09481685608625412,
0.3312497138977051,
0.35386887192726135,
0.35874122381210327,
0.12228044867515564,
-0.19216270744800568,
0.10095060616731644,
-0.11364976316690445,
-0.28273001313209534,
-0.38367903232574463,
0.47473108768463135,
0.17243877053260803,
-0.3323938548564911,
-0.7576684355735779,
0.3597339391708374,
0.8581815958023071,
-0.13093054294586182,
0.27501726150512695,
0.10697314888238907,
-0.1671595573425293,
-0.13027805089950562,
-0.6536389589309692,
-0.16445468366146088,
-0.5266819000244141,
0.13294997811317444,
-0.36851441860198975,
-0.7308897972106934,
0.3378361165523529,
0.15598493814468384,
0.28105780482292175,
0.08728127926588058,
0.6665074229240417,
-0.36809802055358887,
0.9998823404312134,
1.093858003616333,
-0.37852922081947327,
0.6755788922309875,
0.5652830600738525,
0.2966521680355072,
-0.5205424427986145,
0.11281141638755798,
-0.5477293133735657,
-0.5568119883537292,
-0.5730867385864258,
-0.5531034469604492,
0.15034951269626617,
0.19127494096755981,
-0.14754553139209747,
0.6322845220565796,
-0.4997842609882355,
0.730374276638031,
0.3911498486995697,
-0.18420341610908508,
0.2646510899066925,
-0.10010252147912979,
-0.2673006057739258,
0.07609117031097412,
-0.6255607604980469,
-0.6322532892227173,
0.9303832650184631,
0.28949591517448425,
0.9412170648574829,
0.2752396762371063,
0.6612117290496826,
0.3811454772949219,
0.28360515832901,
-0.5387341380119324,
0.6038456559181213,
0.05277886241674423,
-0.6157596707344055,
-0.42962533235549927,
-0.30028918385505676,
-0.6576741933822632,
0.07675028592348099,
-0.024959895759820938,
-0.810601532459259,
0.06207874044775963,
0.2491762489080429,
-0.7971019148826599,
0.0047202343121171,
-0.47716575860977173,
0.9379010796546936,
-0.5059759616851807,
-0.6330092549324036,
0.08716949820518494,
-0.8834503889083862,
0.23243388533592224,
-0.15873436629772186,
0.14185300469398499,
-0.29395008087158203,
-0.035701874643564224,
0.5505372881889343,
-0.2438361793756485,
0.8240154385566711,
0.005594563204795122,
-0.2537778615951538,
0.031838905066251755,
0.2023700475692749,
0.44514352083206177,
-0.2197236269712448,
-0.03535056114196777,
-0.05990508198738098,
-0.07868644595146179,
-0.45133599638938904,
-0.26068177819252014,
0.7709866762161255,
-0.511457085609436,
-0.8497781157493591,
-0.462802529335022,
-0.5705130100250244,
-0.23508420586585999,
0.35836178064346313,
0.263430655002594,
-0.05372460186481476,
-0.11008276045322418,
-0.005673176143318415,
0.7011179327964783,
0.04294493794441223,
0.5402150750160217,
0.6787126064300537,
-0.07926473766565323,
-0.26839980483055115,
0.5430735349655151,
0.1867581605911255,
0.4487990140914917,
0.49043941497802734,
-0.0028141553048044443,
-0.4868622124195099,
-0.5386540293693542,
-0.4475472569465637,
-0.035182129591703415,
-0.46306437253952026,
-0.2614865303039551,
-0.6387149095535278,
-0.10293795168399811,
-0.5351567268371582,
-0.6968661546707153,
-0.1774839609861374,
-0.42200571298599243,
-0.11886686831712723,
-0.2568948566913605,
0.15299932658672333,
0.5377057194709778,
0.07783108949661255,
0.3026236295700073,
-0.6970497369766235,
0.24876125156879425,
0.20796671509742737,
0.31135156750679016,
-0.47337043285369873,
-0.5876925587654114,
0.15158553421497345,
-0.2813447117805481,
-0.46179547905921936,
-0.7274163365364075,
0.1854572892189026,
-0.24225744605064392,
0.8199670314788818,
0.5631875991821289,
0.20970438420772552,
0.8122413158416748,
-0.7111781239509583,
0.3588193953037262,
-0.035610049962997437,
-1.0226341485977173,
0.33539053797721863,
-0.37726929783821106,
0.2493065446615219,
0.7663677930831909,
0.2632925510406494,
-0.44623863697052,
-0.6474799513816833,
-0.39379358291625977,
-0.8588458299636841,
0.6533316969871521,
0.13052435219287872,
-0.13614578545093536,
0.26027926802635193,
0.2464773803949356,
-0.11182790249586105,
0.20028015971183777,
-0.6347542405128479,
0.32565316557884216,
0.19980256259441376,
-0.5819060206413269,
-0.08545448631048203,
-0.10754360258579254,
-0.3386475443840027,
-0.0770120918750763,
0.5927823185920715,
-0.16538861393928528,
-0.05242658406496048,
-0.0634235367178917,
-0.26392823457717896,
-0.22661127150058746,
0.21334674954414368,
0.8395702838897705,
0.41143685579299927,
-0.13785895705223083,
-0.05126379430294037,
-0.1407322883605957,
-0.23255488276481628,
0.3634451627731323,
0.09465157985687256,
-0.32059192657470703,
-0.49646806716918945,
0.10495579242706299,
0.398330956697464,
0.23958146572113037,
-0.4130169153213501,
0.5239908695220947,
-0.0626683458685875,
-0.09177133440971375,
-0.08796098828315735,
0.05640726909041405,
0.08364123106002808,
0.19677452743053436,
0.007746834307909012,
-0.03923405706882477,
-0.04139973968267441,
-0.18892264366149902,
0.5951439738273621,
0.4289776086807251,
-0.3432564437389374,
-0.1337326467037201,
0.6702319383621216,
0.4250361919403076,
-0.05173679068684578,
0.4209635257720947,
0.009893951937556267,
-0.44463929533958435,
0.7203860878944397,
0.2642682194709778,
0.874007523059845,
-0.3746843934059143,
-0.021854691207408905,
0.012550384737551212,
0.3991955518722534,
-0.25560227036476135,
0.12533968687057495,
0.025682203471660614,
-0.7962208986282349,
-0.4389532804489136,
-0.7021377682685852,
-0.29766425490379333,
-0.012897780165076256,
-0.5737457871437073,
0.47778773307800293,
-0.4409124255180359,
-0.21853293478488922,
0.019272025674581528,
-0.3854134678840637,
-0.26126495003700256,
-0.3315788805484772,
0.3132875859737396,
0.8586905598640442,
-0.926232635974884,
0.9621362686157227,
0.46228647232055664,
-0.17045184969902039,
-0.7113228440284729,
0.637513279914856,
0.5903937220573425,
-0.5305719375610352,
0.27532070875167847,
0.18921102583408356,
-0.031393181532621384,
0.22582077980041504,
-0.4084945023059845,
-0.955317497253418,
0.9975539445877075,
0.168848916888237,
-0.8276934027671814,
-0.13344672322273254,
-0.10714682191610336,
0.24570411443710327,
-0.2407994568347931,
0.06111203879117966,
0.7236696481704712,
0.6477982401847839,
0.09900302439928055,
-1.145943284034729,
0.16824081540107727,
-0.11620479077100754,
-0.2724962830543518,
0.39828169345855713,
-0.7534971833229065,
0.3694310188293457,
-0.11002510786056519,
-0.1922650933265686,
0.22823813557624817,
0.28885769844055176,
0.035545505583286285,
0.002246036659926176,
0.6215283274650574,
0.6599389910697937,
0.691558301448822,
-0.17312924563884735,
0.7353692054748535,
-0.31775185465812683,
0.07015211880207062,
1.2372037172317505,
-0.9169129133224487,
0.6340847611427307,
0.6061505079269409,
0.05955785885453224,
0.18881556391716003,
0.7046538591384888,
0.16719670593738556,
0.8236989378929138,
0.2144014984369278,
-0.07668301463127136,
-0.4140304625034332,
-0.0349966362118721,
-0.08747334778308868,
0.43294575810432434,
0.19657506048679352,
-0.04020122066140175,
-0.05864957347512245,
-0.1656934767961502,
0.014055099338293076,
0.1082366555929184,
-0.3391300141811371,
1.2261345386505127,
-0.22613856196403503,
-1.0474586486816406,
0.6983360052108765,
-0.30311787128448486,
0.4018605947494507,
-0.5621095299720764,
0.04945068806409836,
-0.18698908388614655,
0.3096557855606079,
-0.2320682257413864,
-0.8817914724349976,
0.08782994747161865,
-0.06131260097026825,
-0.24276304244995117,
-0.536822497844696,
0.3028624951839447,
-0.5985360145568848,
-0.2727472186088562,
0.22838301956653595,
0.13379345834255219,
-0.25190263986587524,
0.3242684602737427,
-0.6963498592376709,
0.23128797113895416,
0.1466371864080429,
-0.34642618894577026,
0.39601072669029236,
0.3318839371204376,
-0.5617587566375732,
0.5820950269699097,
0.510669469833374,
-0.12147712707519531,
0.05888223648071289,
-0.04735461622476578,
0.8766926527023315,
-0.5386351346969604,
-0.743039071559906,
-0.9787400364875793,
0.7470831274986267,
-0.3006557822227478,
0.08918527513742447,
0.5825119614601135,
0.3498319387435913,
0.6273036003112793,
0.19265814125537872,
0.7888396978378296,
-0.07760275155305862,
0.2300128936767578,
-0.7210177183151245,
0.860287606716156,
-0.4717968702316284,
0.2963615655899048,
-0.39367368817329407,
-0.8158525824546814,
-0.5507382154464722,
0.5843219757080078,
-0.2884814739227295,
-0.3437464237213135,
0.5695957541465759,
1.1098202466964722,
-0.06916756927967072,
-0.3005872070789337,
0.36216452717781067,
0.23823478817939758,
0.29781007766723633,
0.46350088715553284,
0.6249512434005737,
0.22833621501922607,
0.4078660011291504,
-0.018045315518975258,
-0.6269757151603699,
-0.5485793352127075,
-1.179452896118164,
-0.7255494594573975,
-0.4597899913787842,
-0.32745733857154846,
-0.37977489829063416,
0.19400252401828766,
0.9774891138076782,
0.906972348690033,
-0.8297727108001709,
-0.30098092555999756,
-0.2508929967880249,
0.247144877910614,
-0.39925265312194824,
-0.20120272040367126,
0.1892794966697693,
-0.35544633865356445,
-0.7271274924278259,
0.4614945650100708,
0.44539743661880493,
0.3668215572834015,
0.1736655831336975,
-0.0934784784913063,
-0.37615299224853516,
0.2356427162885666,
0.02502318285405636,
0.32735297083854675,
-0.752892792224884,
-0.26194456219673157,
-0.0031334254890680313,
-0.6283544301986694,
0.04329876974225044,
0.8958439230918884,
-0.281379759311676,
0.2755832374095917,
0.580635130405426,
0.6413159966468811,
-0.03282838687300682,
0.428519606590271,
0.8689572811126709,
-0.5095211863517761,
0.24517612159252167,
0.27629634737968445,
0.3736436665058136,
0.06386500597000122,
-0.585482656955719,
0.3304256498813629,
0.045574601739645004,
-0.7560776472091675,
-0.8005109429359436,
0.46982672810554504,
-1.2287777662277222,
-0.12612995505332947,
1.176579236984253,
-0.017600877210497856,
-0.23447075486183167,
-0.247343972325325,
-0.36358749866485596,
0.16240951418876648,
-0.4667264521121979,
0.8873640298843384,
0.9043952822685242,
0.030517742037773132,
-0.1721755415201187,
-0.6733428239822388,
0.9334306120872498,
0.6745055913925171,
-0.7698898315429688,
0.43088775873184204,
0.5635397434234619,
0.3146343529224396,
-0.011915156617760658,
0.5814206004142761,
-0.20047220587730408,
0.19431950151920319,
-0.6062381267547607,
0.09214367717504501,
0.3251912295818329,
-0.4271056056022644,
-0.5547557473182678,
0.12969206273555756,
0.1935366988182068,
-0.09532935172319412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17355v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17355v1
|
RECOST: External Knowledge Guided Data-efficient Instruction Tuning
| 2024-02-27T09:47:36 | 2024-02-27T09:47:36 |
Qi Zhang, Yiming Zhang, Haobo Wang, Junbo Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the current landscape of large language models (LLMs), the process of
instruction tuning serves as an essential step. Considering the high computing
power overhead, data-efficient instruction tuning was proposed to reduce the
training data size in this process, aiming at selecting high-quality
instructional data. Nevertheless, we argue that most current data-efficient
instruction-tuning methods are highly dependent on the quality of the original
instruction-tuning dataset. When it comes to datasets synthesized by LLMs, a
common scenario in this field, dirty samples will even be selected with a
higher probability than other samples. To address these challenges, we utilized
external knowledge (relevant examples or paragraphs) to evaluate those samples
synthesized by LLMs with an in-context-based relative predictive entropy. Based
on the new metric, we proposed a framework, dubbed as \textbf{RECOST}, which
integrates external-knowledge-base re-ranking and diversity-consistent sampling
into a single pipeline. Through extensive experiments on several synthetic
datasets (Alpaca and Alpaca-gpt4), we demonstrate the effectiveness of our
method and achieve even better results with only \textbf{1\%} of the full
dataset.
|
[
-0.29188233613967896,
-0.4770764112472534,
0.37641632556915283,
-0.048610132187604904,
-0.10499940067529678,
-0.016566244885325432,
-0.40642714500427246,
-0.30893635749816895,
0.06488698720932007,
0.4925559163093567,
-0.6796129941940308,
-0.6516560316085815,
-0.5124669075012207,
0.005754828918725252,
-0.4019019901752472,
0.8211666941642761,
-0.043380726128816605,
0.11183492094278336,
-0.35000354051589966,
0.0248948372900486,
-0.4638274610042572,
-0.1127847358584404,
-0.6873918771743774,
-0.2623465955257416,
0.36889737844467163,
0.6259089708328247,
0.29522812366485596,
0.9610090851783752,
0.4121546149253845,
0.3651890456676483,
0.14038607478141785,
0.5385704040527344,
-0.6592057943344116,
0.18996921181678772,
-0.24712631106376648,
-0.6164408922195435,
-0.14315956830978394,
-0.02833371050655842,
0.8291207551956177,
0.5538203120231628,
-0.3936587870121002,
0.37415987253189087,
0.14521069824695587,
0.8835327625274658,
-0.7216026186943054,
0.11292175948619843,
-1.12662672996521,
-0.04097827896475792,
-0.06481214612722397,
-0.45627111196517944,
-0.3608132600784302,
-0.7115110158920288,
-0.12774232029914856,
-0.6117126941680908,
0.5767387747764587,
0.13660302758216858,
0.4398329555988312,
0.5186871886253357,
-0.1364157646894455,
-0.08080422878265381,
-0.4991787075996399,
0.8941847085952759,
-0.41860470175743103,
0.73818439245224,
0.4388728737831116,
0.07209134846925735,
-0.3803669512271881,
-0.5490133166313171,
-0.375033974647522,
0.20613819360733032,
0.17306600511074066,
-0.09117762744426727,
-0.1227603331208229,
-0.11871796101331711,
0.07007846981287003,
0.4976193904876709,
-0.34233158826828003,
0.11863002926111221,
-0.4066326320171356,
-0.09405124187469482,
0.37668415904045105,
0.24447791278362274,
-0.023160792887210846,
0.4094035029411316,
-0.2128405123949051,
-0.18853433430194855,
-1.0773849487304688,
-0.05811800807714462,
0.37945881485939026,
0.3824160397052765,
0.08005102723836899,
0.26658952236175537,
-0.3050343692302704,
0.9004687070846558,
0.2779920697212219,
-0.16191595792770386,
0.33634063601493835,
-0.49682512879371643,
-0.3295305371284485,
0.007920113392174244,
0.4513436257839203,
0.5008096694946289,
0.11857246607542038,
-0.2561497092247009,
-0.16718511283397675,
-0.35456952452659607,
0.39348089694976807,
-0.828391432762146,
-0.3863353133201599,
-0.1282365471124649,
-0.1833813339471817,
-0.26932525634765625,
0.17827530205249786,
-0.9240728616714478,
-0.28333044052124023,
-0.6440747380256653,
0.13861367106437683,
-0.43027713894844055,
0.08715946972370148,
-0.04617299884557724,
-0.019543448463082314,
0.22458715736865997,
0.3856446444988251,
-1.0686126947402954,
0.05060267075896263,
0.7365981340408325,
0.6695239543914795,
-0.18947044014930725,
-0.2194247543811798,
-0.6046046614646912,
0.10443262755870819,
-0.44034287333488464,
0.8098969459533691,
-0.7474929690361023,
-0.22285516560077667,
-0.07226122915744781,
0.153503879904747,
0.07718595117330551,
-0.6763410568237305,
0.24030649662017822,
-0.7217156291007996,
0.21266649663448334,
-0.529991865158081,
-0.6629459857940674,
-0.18179260194301605,
0.12774325907230377,
-0.5630357265472412,
0.8546203374862671,
0.2339286208152771,
-0.5837629437446594,
0.6809666752815247,
-0.12530486285686493,
-0.45221248269081116,
-0.3213323652744293,
-0.1258702129125595,
-0.4015563130378723,
0.1337236911058426,
0.3359528183937073,
0.13371488451957703,
-0.4729580879211426,
0.06339450180530548,
-0.23010540008544922,
-0.5847179889678955,
-0.06422105431556702,
-0.5263382196426392,
0.5154008269309998,
0.2175436168909073,
-0.23339343070983887,
-0.12544138729572296,
-0.8995799422264099,
0.39518988132476807,
-0.15127839148044586,
-0.7611479163169861,
-0.4131569564342499,
-0.1170620247721672,
-0.7093222737312317,
-0.15015964210033417,
0.2687072157859802,
-0.6058438420295715,
0.27195900678634644,
-0.4383716583251953,
0.0619409941136837,
1.107825517654419,
0.025949127972126007,
0.44836464524269104,
-0.47909483313560486,
0.5184979438781738,
-0.26761361956596375,
-0.07979333400726318,
-0.1540425717830658,
-0.36517617106437683,
-0.607908308506012,
-0.40706565976142883,
0.209482803940773,
0.6619094610214233,
-0.7311641573905945,
0.5423640012741089,
-0.32115328311920166,
-0.4705371856689453,
-0.8480618596076965,
0.6259481906890869,
0.4354951083660126,
0.5171938538551331,
0.4011727273464203,
-0.13018587231636047,
-0.6314278244972229,
-0.6998230814933777,
-0.2280530333518982,
0.047598253935575485,
-0.12885870039463043,
0.27464058995246887,
0.1170337051153183,
-0.17153751850128174,
0.6372807621955872,
-0.5881795287132263,
-0.011896058917045593,
0.026210974901914597,
-0.0855964869260788,
0.335941880941391,
0.5131845474243164,
0.2257714718580246,
-0.2977353632450104,
-0.3135116994380951,
-0.06569606810808182,
-0.6427308917045593,
-0.19487527012825012,
0.1954430341720581,
-0.4790842533111572,
0.21987327933311462,
0.6074537038803101,
-0.35728150606155396,
0.023840732872486115,
0.5781325697898865,
0.00832844153046608,
0.383644163608551,
-0.2593247592449188,
0.43959134817123413,
-0.9815533757209778,
-0.1184471845626831,
-0.1334933191537857,
-0.04100559279322624,
-0.19616658985614777,
0.12983860075473785,
0.1269952356815338,
0.10657482594251633,
-0.18419401347637177,
0.2953436076641083,
-0.3927135467529297,
0.08614291995763779,
-0.35226449370384216,
-0.2701666057109833,
0.0460977740585804,
0.44841867685317993,
0.0028650129679590464,
0.8757946491241455,
0.4157145321369171,
-0.6747761964797974,
0.5390480756759644,
0.06365519762039185,
-0.8511505722999573,
0.39381882548332214,
-0.43796104192733765,
0.22946713864803314,
-0.1626472771167755,
0.20736750960350037,
-0.8350905776023865,
-0.10342465341091156,
0.20794160664081573,
-0.18950968980789185,
0.6097085475921631,
-0.25443899631500244,
-0.582015335559845,
-0.05485067889094353,
-0.4480419158935547,
0.41814371943473816,
0.5144616365432739,
-0.9344999194145203,
0.09381412714719772,
0.36407116055488586,
-0.13057556748390198,
-0.7926828265190125,
-0.6428210139274597,
-0.3554173707962036,
-0.25652626156806946,
-0.5299097299575806,
0.457638680934906,
-0.0016087694093585014,
-0.15750563144683838,
-0.060363832861185074,
-0.21624630689620972,
0.153828427195549,
-0.18214717507362366,
-0.033887192606925964,
0.07382628321647644,
-0.3158498704433441,
0.3212398886680603,
0.30013343691825867,
-0.0007930643623694777,
0.021369753405451775,
-0.4631897807121277,
0.27760037779808044,
0.11732286959886551,
-0.43022993206977844,
-0.41875433921813965,
0.07647275924682617,
0.3001686632633209,
0.16425985097885132,
0.7986029386520386,
0.5097787380218506,
-0.2061595767736435,
-0.44499653577804565,
-0.48936909437179565,
-0.3597440719604492,
-0.5423567891120911,
0.32955610752105713,
-0.0333465076982975,
-0.5558087229728699,
0.17124022543430328,
0.028681030496954918,
0.5280749201774597,
-0.0018408093601465225,
0.4173392057418823,
-0.20049890875816345,
0.6584255695343018,
0.5442923307418823,
-0.22767002880573273,
0.8156193494796753,
-0.20635256171226501,
-0.030554916709661484,
-0.7783905267715454,
-0.17377835512161255,
-0.3898313045501709,
-0.3990320861339569,
-0.831722617149353,
-0.5220819115638733,
0.2358435094356537,
-0.23342202603816986,
-0.4277243912220001,
0.28162553906440735,
-0.5553646087646484,
0.5896419882774353,
0.948794960975647,
0.258745402097702,
0.3553493916988373,
0.4919685125350952,
0.1334107518196106,
-0.02656431309878826,
-0.8696161508560181,
-0.14350014925003052,
1.3156349658966064,
0.023922665044665337,
1.0993232727050781,
-0.02312813512980938,
0.7857786417007446,
0.13207291066646576,
0.3826812505722046,
-0.39812007546424866,
0.45174574851989746,
-0.30835604667663574,
-0.4266769587993622,
-0.2955687940120697,
-0.8150351643562317,
-1.0710840225219727,
0.17919759452342987,
-0.06684864312410355,
-0.44641563296318054,
0.12117210775613785,
0.3200705349445343,
-0.19422563910484314,
0.5753681659698486,
-0.9037109613418579,
0.471158504486084,
-0.06949200481176376,
-0.5198782086372375,
-0.267007440328598,
-0.35913026332855225,
0.4319090247154236,
-0.10377829521894455,
0.19972772896289825,
0.09056491404771805,
-0.011993375606834888,
0.6598191261291504,
-0.4350522458553314,
0.8764296770095825,
-0.1863040030002594,
-0.49521178007125854,
0.4354167580604553,
0.03669682890176773,
0.6136759519577026,
-0.012053243815898895,
-0.3258630335330963,
0.15659712255001068,
-0.10571972280740738,
-0.18053719401359558,
-0.7273714542388916,
0.9600882530212402,
-0.7681000828742981,
-0.6951456665992737,
-0.05083237215876579,
-0.47499972581863403,
-0.3427344560623169,
-0.045971326529979706,
0.4499887228012085,
0.4965417981147766,
0.0948706641793251,
0.3838680684566498,
0.8027151226997375,
-0.39154109358787537,
-0.08310463279485703,
0.5585448741912842,
0.13032758235931396,
-0.5046792030334473,
1.3069754838943481,
0.14434979856014252,
0.31711602210998535,
0.7241963744163513,
0.09740688651800156,
-0.20092563331127167,
-0.5056647062301636,
-0.41948992013931274,
0.07806263118982315,
-0.7391210794448853,
-0.5862976312637329,
-0.14634014666080475,
-0.11182851344347,
-0.3915146291255951,
-0.20988309383392334,
-0.48033085465431213,
-0.17530862987041473,
-0.31303489208221436,
-0.20572443306446075,
0.48152098059654236,
0.4451058804988861,
-0.19970020651817322,
0.14684368669986725,
-0.7577975392341614,
0.2111087590456009,
0.2784726023674011,
0.6537319421768188,
-0.13183091580867767,
-0.771888792514801,
-0.3220391869544983,
0.2991395592689514,
-0.4071274399757385,
-0.3810823857784271,
0.1325778067111969,
0.37988999485969543,
0.6652515530586243,
0.3304324746131897,
-0.020644836127758026,
0.6793035864830017,
-0.5005823969841003,
0.48914673924446106,
-0.09474172443151474,
-0.47005224227905273,
0.5258610248565674,
-0.08640164136886597,
0.3427461087703705,
0.7727334499359131,
0.21749688684940338,
-0.13768114149570465,
-0.5522873401641846,
-0.4841654598712921,
-0.973471999168396,
0.6221629977226257,
-0.07219581305980682,
0.20612001419067383,
0.00839987862855196,
0.4009878635406494,
0.5889946818351746,
0.3607694208621979,
-0.40919065475463867,
-0.39322584867477417,
-0.05305732414126396,
-0.4194517433643341,
0.0744226798415184,
0.024671543389558792,
-0.05976582318544388,
-0.382912278175354,
0.8624791502952576,
0.04038427025079727,
0.3942031264305115,
-0.1833837330341339,
0.09859861433506012,
-0.21463285386562347,
0.09403424710035324,
0.40121132135391235,
0.6054235100746155,
-0.285606324672699,
0.1442987024784088,
0.3076525330543518,
-0.48931458592414856,
0.14351613819599152,
-0.1765453815460205,
-0.27587488293647766,
-0.11715126037597656,
0.4658434987068176,
0.5401101112365723,
0.3207094073295593,
-0.5222549438476562,
0.0415550135076046,
0.01775905303657055,
-0.06757625937461853,
-0.1690545231103897,
0.573056697845459,
-0.1768992841243744,
0.22980889678001404,
0.14094658195972443,
0.04311133921146393,
-0.08918114751577377,
-0.49370020627975464,
0.3735826909542084,
0.4761005938053131,
-0.022477293387055397,
-0.21481990814208984,
0.2618963122367859,
0.2744692265987396,
-0.06633597612380981,
0.9098412394523621,
-0.19021694362163544,
0.007546938490122557,
0.5476856827735901,
0.5304811596870422,
0.5073055624961853,
-0.2612530291080475,
-0.08020221441984177,
0.7005543112754822,
0.3734491169452667,
-0.13828794658184052,
0.22224679589271545,
-0.15343788266181946,
-0.8992125988006592,
-0.3080656826496124,
-0.667598307132721,
-0.28121471405029297,
0.37208765745162964,
-0.642128050327301,
0.3026198446750641,
-0.44941407442092896,
0.06696312129497528,
-0.4475911855697632,
-0.14605791866779327,
-0.6933258175849915,
0.24740515649318695,
-0.11510807275772095,
0.9048746228218079,
-0.6037832498550415,
0.8560051321983337,
0.36830687522888184,
0.09252694994211197,
-0.3867487609386444,
0.0920078381896019,
0.0027247376274317503,
-1.1069982051849365,
0.43091848492622375,
-0.01285022497177124,
-0.4511690139770508,
0.023471442982554436,
-0.5218060612678528,
-1.0846173763275146,
1.0961740016937256,
0.6819239258766174,
-0.6651111841201782,
0.0895007997751236,
-0.226736381649971,
0.3921680450439453,
-0.2644599676132202,
-0.11945659667253494,
0.7098949551582336,
0.38446226716041565,
0.24691152572631836,
-0.4049123227596283,
0.0500272698700428,
-0.20418855547904968,
-0.28815072774887085,
0.2774525582790375,
-0.5526812672615051,
0.4349643588066101,
-0.41223210096359253,
-0.24280700087547302,
-0.01368685532361269,
0.7963921427726746,
0.4290773868560791,
0.24917413294315338,
0.4051347076892853,
0.5998165011405945,
1.0151265859603882,
0.017033422365784645,
0.9527863264083862,
-0.4812238812446594,
-0.0070549556985497475,
1.4042837619781494,
-0.03203509747982025,
0.7469457983970642,
0.40005797147750854,
-0.2814556062221527,
0.5881176590919495,
0.6475526690483093,
-0.1652040183544159,
0.8530676960945129,
0.33317631483078003,
-0.19280362129211426,
-0.1393265277147293,
0.11895657330751419,
-0.5861752033233643,
0.44181734323501587,
0.3108951449394226,
-0.5685036182403564,
-0.14469313621520996,
-0.4020209312438965,
-0.14448627829551697,
-0.014862176962196827,
-0.37699955701828003,
0.8606568574905396,
0.00024543123436160386,
-0.848381519317627,
0.7786933183670044,
0.08284272253513336,
0.7850542068481445,
-0.6127836108207703,
-0.11011287569999695,
-0.3305075764656067,
0.18479187786579132,
-0.11431871354579926,
-0.9489936232566833,
0.3471052944660187,
0.036567192524671555,
-0.28109246492385864,
-0.2731649875640869,
0.4071587920188904,
-0.6226012110710144,
-0.6459996700286865,
-0.07737933844327927,
0.2764435112476349,
0.11206965148448944,
0.11431139707565308,
-0.3564686179161072,
-0.1403598040342331,
0.13198040425777435,
-0.27716153860092163,
0.4966734051704407,
0.6129910945892334,
0.2901425361633301,
0.7826986312866211,
0.7285071015357971,
0.2608718276023865,
-0.0170174278318882,
-0.0907125174999237,
0.6665259003639221,
-0.5502474904060364,
-0.3138620853424072,
-0.7912256121635437,
0.046035826206207275,
0.06923486292362213,
-0.2889542281627655,
0.6436276435852051,
0.5206074118614197,
1.0939381122589111,
0.05008314177393913,
0.8429067730903625,
0.18195313215255737,
0.39641618728637695,
-0.8654284477233887,
0.47963473200798035,
-0.5555891394615173,
0.41106095910072327,
-0.13856090605258942,
-0.7411283254623413,
0.08372384309768677,
0.609791100025177,
-0.21520759165287018,
0.2869917154312134,
0.4464556872844696,
1.0559206008911133,
-0.1525850147008896,
0.11770995706319809,
0.11399512737989426,
-0.055617887526750565,
-0.024260487407445908,
0.6615649461746216,
0.5177092552185059,
-0.24950769543647766,
0.5170783400535583,
-0.25442320108413696,
-0.16555467247962952,
-0.15516994893550873,
-0.8745551705360413,
-0.558778703212738,
-0.582546055316925,
-0.276653915643692,
-0.07209959626197815,
0.005049124360084534,
1.0169849395751953,
0.6474691033363342,
-0.8150774836540222,
0.006022618152201176,
-0.17009776830673218,
0.4845269024372101,
-0.41839295625686646,
-0.20662985742092133,
0.2854364216327667,
-0.3969251811504364,
-0.7032884955406189,
0.5769145488739014,
-0.09268917143344879,
-0.07450345158576965,
-0.009863760322332382,
0.1203313022851944,
0.19512790441513062,
-0.008704609237611294,
0.5475940704345703,
0.22774982452392578,
-0.33328020572662354,
-0.33564677834510803,
-0.0700165256857872,
-0.06289220601320267,
0.019190175458788872,
0.8510726094245911,
-0.6270191073417664,
0.39525097608566284,
0.6024335026741028,
0.8310915231704712,
0.24201641976833344,
0.1670621633529663,
0.8804735541343689,
-0.9945168495178223,
-0.11451688408851624,
-0.19035278260707855,
0.31954389810562134,
0.405811607837677,
-0.5228939652442932,
0.40314602851867676,
0.31252944469451904,
-0.4574858546257019,
-0.697898268699646,
0.10647454112768173,
-0.42258867621421814,
-0.31161263585090637,
1.2804774045944214,
-0.1816871464252472,
-0.13227063417434692,
0.11467956006526947,
0.020469704642891884,
0.2564038932323456,
-0.5466209650039673,
1.2657289505004883,
0.5929315686225891,
-0.13346925377845764,
-0.08918756246566772,
-0.4302423596382141,
0.4942440092563629,
0.25379860401153564,
-0.8401721715927124,
0.3440697491168976,
0.41819432377815247,
0.5449718832969666,
-0.23275905847549438,
0.37130966782569885,
0.03303065523505211,
0.24128040671348572,
0.03313145413994789,
0.04503408446907997,
-0.2656821012496948,
-0.3936680853366852,
-0.05862286314368248,
0.1272325962781906,
-0.04216505214571953,
-0.42120200395584106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17333v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17333v1
|
Unsupervised multiple choices question answering via universal corpus
| 2024-02-27T09:10:28 | 2024-02-27T09:10:28 |
Qin Zhang, Hao Ge, Xiaojun Chen, Meng Fang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Unsupervised question answering is a promising yet challenging task, which
alleviates the burden of building large-scale annotated data in a new domain.
It motivates us to study the unsupervised multiple-choice question answering
(MCQA) problem. In this paper, we propose a novel framework designed to
generate synthetic MCQA data barely based on contexts from the universal domain
without relying on any form of manual annotation. Possible answers are
extracted and used to produce related questions, then we leverage both named
entities (NE) and knowledge graphs to discover plausible distractors to form
complete synthetic samples. Experiments on multiple MCQA datasets demonstrate
the effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.9396135210990906,
-0.8416285514831543,
0.8143720626831055,
-0.1956108659505844,
-0.058632031083106995,
0.26973432302474976,
0.04921182245016098,
-0.3438408076763153,
0.40533125400543213,
0.8716581463813782,
-0.9417233467102051,
-0.2458161562681198,
-0.11818121373653412,
0.24995896220207214,
-0.18137982487678528,
0.8529435396194458,
0.026182251051068306,
0.1548275500535965,
-0.4709677994251251,
-0.27567556500434875,
-0.240248903632164,
-0.7296621203422546,
-0.5190954804420471,
0.04361822083592415,
0.5735507011413574,
0.5332980155944824,
0.426390677690506,
0.10795821994543076,
0.00435822457075119,
0.2155991792678833,
0.11125022917985916,
0.5770138502120972,
0.029608044773340225,
0.11168008297681808,
-0.30409231781959534,
-0.07390834391117096,
-0.008403751999139786,
-0.1056382805109024,
0.613041877746582,
1.1878061294555664,
0.15189915895462036,
0.5420939326286316,
0.05971246585249901,
0.3619186282157898,
-0.6844500303268433,
-0.32149213552474976,
-0.8759770393371582,
-0.08782763034105301,
-0.13031233847141266,
-0.23250053822994232,
-0.2915506958961487,
0.04039567708969116,
-0.002262076595798135,
-0.8609344363212585,
0.3017106056213379,
-0.05322425812482834,
0.4211566746234894,
0.33119839429855347,
-0.8466311693191528,
-0.18267495930194855,
-0.672287106513977,
0.6273123025894165,
0.008578586392104626,
0.15443523228168488,
0.06941495835781097,
0.5009853839874268,
-0.28311213850975037,
-0.7579188346862793,
-0.6315107941627502,
0.14808915555477142,
0.04803737625479698,
0.2740488648414612,
-0.03657782822847366,
-0.21364617347717285,
0.09917724132537842,
-0.12233776599168777,
-0.34467145800590515,
-0.3439429700374603,
-0.43831247091293335,
-0.45581886172294617,
0.5462223887443542,
0.0862724706530571,
0.41262122988700867,
-0.38314852118492126,
-0.4235087037086487,
0.08929508924484253,
-0.5776903629302979,
0.2805802822113037,
0.1173001304268837,
0.21014292538166046,
0.6184268593788147,
0.8368610739707947,
-0.5594172477722168,
0.6858963966369629,
-0.08068777620792389,
0.2078896015882492,
-0.020360123366117477,
-0.023045526817440987,
-0.1998811811208725,
-0.05390549823641777,
0.5221332311630249,
0.2903316617012024,
0.4917885363101959,
-0.35222578048706055,
0.2686777710914612,
0.04642907530069351,
0.32922980189323425,
-0.6417096853256226,
-0.2088521271944046,
0.5038723349571228,
0.10336288809776306,
-0.2492588758468628,
0.0564049631357193,
-0.8998880386352539,
-0.12551133334636688,
-0.41920220851898193,
0.3456500470638275,
-0.260724812746048,
-0.12127304077148438,
-0.18005309998989105,
-0.1988372802734375,
0.03679276630282402,
0.21920543909072876,
-0.5053255558013916,
0.19689011573791504,
0.03953252732753754,
0.3108159899711609,
-0.30584636330604553,
-0.21704840660095215,
-0.6639615297317505,
0.3520524799823761,
-0.2904713749885559,
1.013616919517517,
-0.48837509751319885,
-0.36153215169906616,
-0.13418594002723694,
0.10689882189035416,
-0.2758256494998932,
-0.5744403004646301,
0.5161199569702148,
-0.7890693545341492,
0.1886875480413437,
-0.41406092047691345,
-0.5654256939888,
-0.3229511082172394,
0.16604067385196686,
-0.6986861228942871,
1.0999207496643066,
0.2230791449546814,
-0.8664961457252502,
0.15240247547626495,
-1.094090223312378,
-0.048579875379800797,
-0.002583444816991687,
-0.2602434754371643,
0.244301900267601,
-0.14718113839626312,
0.7700878977775574,
0.4731503427028656,
-0.12814459204673767,
0.6365229487419128,
-0.3600073456764221,
-0.14148575067520142,
0.7823300361633301,
-0.45335105061531067,
1.0689579248428345,
0.15246453881263733,
-0.20984821021556854,
-0.040536068379879,
-1.0011463165283203,
0.31679239869117737,
-0.03962139040231705,
-0.21745292842388153,
-0.3734891712665558,
-0.2599148750305176,
0.10423225909471512,
0.38391822576522827,
-0.20170748233795166,
-0.8891516327857971,
-0.063695527613163,
0.11895910650491714,
0.2966211140155792,
0.5653502345085144,
0.4636751711368561,
0.3235150873661041,
-0.42870384454727173,
0.63232421875,
0.2269035279750824,
-0.1320069432258606,
0.2564815282821655,
-0.6562739014625549,
-0.6223564743995667,
-0.4968286156654358,
0.5953871011734009,
0.4160385727882385,
-1.1413497924804688,
-0.04377054423093796,
-0.10726194083690643,
-0.16237829625606537,
-0.5712814927101135,
-0.08285130560398102,
0.1967386156320572,
0.7054992914199829,
0.7623329758644104,
0.028908977285027504,
-0.8406076431274414,
-0.955027163028717,
-0.1794755458831787,
0.3646470606327057,
-0.46718358993530273,
0.4073621332645416,
0.4994875490665436,
-0.30926117300987244,
1.3581178188323975,
-0.7454797029495239,
-0.13808374106884003,
0.008862524293363094,
-0.0706583559513092,
-0.2072066068649292,
0.39393991231918335,
0.3464853763580322,
-1.1069148778915405,
-0.14635197818279266,
-0.5382078289985657,
-0.6233632564544678,
-0.11247972398996353,
-0.2294357270002365,
-0.6278678178787231,
-0.12340271472930908,
0.6720817685127258,
-0.724540114402771,
0.21259520947933197,
0.124904103577137,
-0.07197509706020355,
0.9136075973510742,
0.16366825997829437,
0.12049642950296402,
-1.2283377647399902,
0.3734213411808014,
-0.38500434160232544,
-0.05291002243757248,
-0.6086249351501465,
0.23951683938503265,
-0.018743835389614105,
-0.07173901051282883,
-0.9044044613838196,
0.9611914157867432,
-0.37588658928871155,
-0.017174934968352318,
0.17119227349758148,
0.33232322335243225,
0.06580586731433868,
0.7041071653366089,
0.20675896108150482,
0.6902098059654236,
0.47943153977394104,
-0.8825960159301758,
0.1623314917087555,
0.5179395079612732,
-0.15084044635295868,
0.5053357481956482,
-0.44588518142700195,
0.022543389350175858,
-0.3984779417514801,
0.347424179315567,
-1.1364094018936157,
-0.7433261871337891,
0.17310398817062378,
-0.5926781892776489,
-0.18845459818840027,
-0.23493526875972748,
-0.28848502039909363,
-0.46692153811454773,
-0.1687978059053421,
0.4630853831768036,
0.16923710703849792,
-0.8235176205635071,
0.5816739201545715,
0.5604448318481445,
0.014401612803339958,
-0.724270761013031,
-0.6863767504692078,
-0.12685424089431763,
-0.24993309378623962,
-0.35466593503952026,
0.4044826328754425,
-0.5797777771949768,
-0.21402260661125183,
-0.024910828098654747,
-0.2520805299282074,
-0.4098793864250183,
0.047802217304706573,
0.40271010994911194,
0.3483421504497528,
-0.05716412514448166,
0.1798248589038849,
0.3466290235519409,
0.14176936447620392,
0.2351495325565338,
-0.37624943256378174,
0.30248287320137024,
0.20237715542316437,
-0.24568058550357819,
0.1179024875164032,
0.8586082458496094,
0.5720300674438477,
-0.30216121673583984,
0.40414831042289734,
0.6687904000282288,
-0.44482505321502686,
-0.27501603960990906,
-0.3847856819629669,
0.046976592391729355,
-0.4590313136577606,
0.06272133439779282,
-0.658412516117096,
-1.209342360496521,
0.5561178922653198,
-0.22974048554897308,
0.09050281345844269,
0.5545524954795837,
0.6398965716362,
-0.1815820038318634,
0.9992302060127258,
0.1517682820558548,
0.46441930532455444,
-0.14105556905269623,
-0.06929188221693039,
-0.21555624902248383,
-1.112508773803711,
-0.33221709728240967,
-0.20035985112190247,
-0.09028290212154388,
-0.390840083360672,
-0.4499262273311615,
0.48928430676460266,
0.28341758251190186,
-0.4389861524105072,
0.015323628671467304,
-0.768936276435852,
0.646771252155304,
0.8901461958885193,
-0.015103593468666077,
0.31366443634033203,
0.028142599388957024,
-0.8239220976829529,
0.3278675079345703,
-0.5447724461555481,
-0.5312216877937317,
1.5626004934310913,
-0.3733205795288086,
0.12937311828136444,
0.23010383546352386,
0.6571546792984009,
0.04021238163113594,
0.533353328704834,
-0.31403297185897827,
0.7039715051651001,
0.28463098406791687,
-1.1048238277435303,
-0.4671785831451416,
-0.43703222274780273,
-1.0963318347930908,
0.6611506342887878,
-0.3610587418079376,
-0.9708726406097412,
0.07752382010221481,
-0.007178137078881264,
-0.7542033791542053,
0.34771448373794556,
-0.4897720515727997,
0.7768049836158752,
0.13650012016296387,
0.1218266636133194,
0.6423925757408142,
-0.7085451483726501,
0.6112396121025085,
-0.20561423897743225,
0.25501206517219543,
-0.06090276688337326,
0.056486137211322784,
0.9443292617797852,
-0.217637300491333,
0.5985047221183777,
-0.03405582532286644,
0.23243683576583862,
0.8667495846748352,
0.07841558009386063,
-0.22673487663269043,
0.7147966623306274,
-0.006784419063478708,
-0.0290804672986269,
0.4229277968406677,
-0.5665226578712463,
-0.5790806412696838,
0.7466967701911926,
-0.6090053915977478,
-0.47936350107192993,
-0.23944449424743652,
-0.8464369177818298,
-0.749253511428833,
0.4190232753753662,
0.5125859379768372,
0.45598724484443665,
-0.40860649943351746,
-0.077196404337883,
0.5313214063644409,
0.0704442635178566,
0.6994951963424683,
0.3595470190048218,
-0.26150789856910706,
-0.6049678325653076,
0.48868614435195923,
0.09353086352348328,
-0.07567597925662994,
0.3666316568851471,
-0.08135640621185303,
-0.7346867918968201,
-0.08397786319255829,
-0.9528804421424866,
-0.022882524877786636,
-0.7420996427536011,
-0.20724010467529297,
-1.026530385017395,
-0.31244027614593506,
-0.3287666141986847,
-0.1318047195672989,
-0.10688396543264389,
-0.7639061212539673,
-0.2738376259803772,
-0.17935241758823395,
0.15408648550510406,
0.23676590621471405,
-0.04411018639802933,
-0.0568564236164093,
-0.779830813407898,
0.6124359965324402,
0.9273091554641724,
0.0015583711210638285,
-0.18284456431865692,
-0.07701242715120316,
0.3058774769306183,
0.5469988584518433,
-0.3382105529308319,
-0.9564897418022156,
0.16256192326545715,
0.08184795826673508,
0.546325147151947,
0.05718409642577171,
0.6597399711608887,
0.6783809065818787,
-0.5950917601585388,
0.681244969367981,
-0.0019609208684414625,
-0.7404477000236511,
0.3661749064922333,
-0.3249586522579193,
0.31874704360961914,
0.7415099143981934,
0.7323402166366577,
-0.2907892167568207,
-0.32905516028404236,
-0.9303077459335327,
-0.7267751693725586,
0.3391581177711487,
0.4019864499568939,
-0.01607087254524231,
-0.2408936768770218,
0.39242976903915405,
0.024794641882181168,
0.2993893623352051,
-0.5672226548194885,
-0.37088537216186523,
-0.13921183347702026,
-0.0025375348050147295,
-0.059620607644319534,
-0.04459013789892197,
-0.3329846262931824,
-0.3451080322265625,
0.4923628866672516,
-0.3540572226047516,
0.329099178314209,
0.5796183347702026,
-0.27749767899513245,
-0.022627748548984528,
0.49543482065200806,
0.3767249882221222,
0.6091567277908325,
-0.2521894872188568,
0.371828556060791,
0.27102145552635193,
-0.3447960615158081,
0.2601930499076843,
0.12972809374332428,
-0.45122548937797546,
0.155142679810524,
-0.14861755073070526,
0.057517681270837784,
-0.02296537160873413,
-1.0402977466583252,
0.21634791791439056,
-0.03878926485776901,
-0.4475087821483612,
-0.6719033122062683,
0.03640332445502281,
0.43967336416244507,
0.027478132396936417,
0.48052504658699036,
0.26275283098220825,
0.3368552625179291,
-0.541631281375885,
0.6618824601173401,
0.5151847004890442,
-0.4717692732810974,
-0.05281173810362816,
0.8099492192268372,
-0.07253901660442352,
0.011454658582806587,
0.5169728398323059,
-0.22299803793430328,
-0.43681463599205017,
0.678462564945221,
0.5215401649475098,
0.32750120759010315,
-0.21786479651927948,
0.5994588136672974,
0.29278311133384705,
-0.0008031110628508031,
0.2563766837120056,
0.44388848543167114,
-0.1533096581697464,
-0.878528892993927,
-0.4053230285644531,
-0.7060757279396057,
-0.49926233291625977,
0.3826310634613037,
-0.8105774521827698,
-0.32756656408309937,
-0.27840980887413025,
-0.07736704498529434,
0.5271657705307007,
-0.11687485128641129,
-0.780331552028656,
0.6461743116378784,
0.06934130936861038,
0.5716722011566162,
-0.48544561862945557,
0.8610703945159912,
0.9830245971679688,
-0.4522247314453125,
-0.7186819911003113,
-0.042523130774497986,
0.00036155260750092566,
-0.5044687390327454,
0.4143133759498596,
0.2801070511341095,
-0.015393712557852268,
0.24445518851280212,
-0.5627669095993042,
-1.065945029258728,
0.9815914630889893,
0.3342956006526947,
0.056023236364126205,
0.09681499749422073,
0.37742647528648376,
0.29303911328315735,
-0.5561432838439941,
0.3321496546268463,
0.6335093379020691,
0.39471980929374695,
0.318072646856308,
-0.33449849486351013,
0.13560530543327332,
-0.40733054280281067,
-0.19040295481681824,
0.09186885505914688,
-0.31569603085517883,
0.7819769978523254,
-0.41502076387405396,
-0.19509266316890717,
0.08623997867107391,
0.5420311689376831,
0.4874769449234009,
0.3297175168991089,
0.5118094086647034,
0.3867652416229248,
0.9183674454689026,
0.1341811865568161,
0.6157346367835999,
-0.04186691716313362,
0.21093913912773132,
1.2807190418243408,
-0.10797792673110962,
0.7474251985549927,
0.5531307458877563,
-0.042457569390535355,
0.4272097945213318,
0.8352212905883789,
0.19783885776996613,
0.2677067816257477,
0.5238386392593384,
-0.3151717483997345,
-0.644663393497467,
-0.143789604306221,
-0.07910893857479095,
0.5984042882919312,
0.17778272926807404,
0.10810878872871399,
-0.33074045181274414,
0.16554512083530426,
-0.07883148640394211,
-0.062326811254024506,
-0.35571160912513733,
0.403786301612854,
-0.0479857511818409,
-1.0019534826278687,
0.6467775106430054,
-0.11696929484605789,
0.44363927841186523,
-0.26929640769958496,
0.037651557475328445,
-0.21100281178951263,
-0.20034390687942505,
0.01861816830933094,
-0.7639521360397339,
0.3808228075504303,
-0.006633174605667591,
-0.21627002954483032,
0.08596722036600113,
0.4791639745235443,
-0.5755312442779541,
-0.6742509603500366,
0.04413873702287674,
0.8958753943443298,
0.12367996573448181,
-0.5012627243995667,
-0.5473392605781555,
-0.7568944096565247,
0.04234970360994339,
-0.27774399518966675,
0.5036060810089111,
0.4377988576889038,
-0.2864409387111664,
0.7456517219543457,
1.0436581373214722,
-0.37820684909820557,
0.15327654778957367,
-0.11579810827970505,
0.7975475192070007,
-0.6100788116455078,
-0.47973936796188354,
-0.3609890937805176,
0.7000769376754761,
-0.2226509004831314,
-0.4580499231815338,
0.7040771245956421,
0.43156668543815613,
0.8992841839790344,
-0.2596870958805084,
0.8221664428710938,
-0.02626180276274681,
0.8070092797279358,
-0.36166784167289734,
0.588794469833374,
-0.7194969654083252,
0.015577557496726513,
-0.2784481644630432,
-0.9744270443916321,
-0.46131622791290283,
-0.007169204764068127,
0.13503070175647736,
-0.1292751580476761,
0.7223445773124695,
0.7207103371620178,
-0.25719186663627625,
0.07483126223087311,
0.4058055281639099,
-0.23055443167686462,
-0.0205991193652153,
0.6352760791778564,
0.803970992565155,
-0.1903565526008606,
0.861778736114502,
-0.361433207988739,
0.01578620821237564,
0.06305180490016937,
-0.5726805329322815,
-1.0520299673080444,
-0.8647749423980713,
-0.3481440842151642,
-0.2256954163312912,
-0.2319464534521103,
0.7481175065040588,
0.6607013940811157,
-0.9975551962852478,
0.2925567030906677,
0.08256845921278,
0.13555781543254852,
-0.12062431871891022,
-0.2555919885635376,
0.7523440718650818,
-0.12711286544799805,
-0.5871348977088928,
0.4097929298877716,
-0.053035516291856766,
0.055502213537693024,
0.007992176339030266,
0.3714047372341156,
-0.34660565853118896,
0.44887399673461914,
0.6280667781829834,
0.3960862159729004,
-0.714402973651886,
-0.485933780670166,
0.16837875545024872,
0.26471996307373047,
-0.04913974553346634,
0.7447448968887329,
-0.9615643620491028,
0.2611216902732849,
-0.14324437081813812,
0.8112022280693054,
0.37351706624031067,
0.2195444405078888,
0.08875341713428497,
-1.026330828666687,
-0.1505064070224762,
0.28199389576911926,
0.32224589586257935,
0.24570396542549133,
-0.3674195408821106,
0.4669783115386963,
0.1858959048986435,
-0.38055822253227234,
-0.55948406457901,
0.5179640650749207,
-1.178628921508789,
-0.737914502620697,
1.2598416805267334,
0.11811775714159012,
-0.1881769448518753,
-0.5687810182571411,
-0.34801244735717773,
0.24142108857631683,
-0.12568850815296173,
0.46222609281539917,
0.40419885516166687,
-0.4196297228336334,
0.08849278837442398,
-0.6228395104408264,
0.6086560487747192,
0.46310022473335266,
-0.8925485014915466,
-0.11635156720876694,
0.6559145450592041,
0.6781102418899536,
0.3250110447406769,
0.8558160066604614,
-0.0474005788564682,
0.29848894476890564,
0.02316979505121708,
0.09415837377309799,
-0.21033091843128204,
-0.4770745635032654,
0.1924329251050949,
0.6263832449913025,
-0.5177636742591858,
-0.38702571392059326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17311v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17311v1
|
SKT5SciSumm -- A Hybrid Generative Approach for Multi-Document Scientific Summarization
| 2024-02-27T08:33:31 | 2024-02-27T08:33:31 |
Huy Quoc To, Hung-Nghiep Tran, Andr'e Greiner-Petter, Felix Beierle, Akiko Aizawa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Summarization for scientific text has shown significant benefits both for the
research community and human society. Given the fact that the nature of
scientific text is distinctive and the input of the multi-document
summarization task is substantially long, the task requires sufficient
embedding generation and text truncation without losing important information.
To tackle these issues, in this paper, we propose SKT5SciSumm - a hybrid
framework for multi-document scientific summarization (MDSS). We leverage the
Sentence-Transformer version of Scientific Paper Embeddings using
Citation-Informed Transformers (SPECTER) to encode and represent textual
sentences, allowing for efficient extractive summarization using k-means
clustering. We employ the T5 family of models to generate abstractive summaries
using extracted sentences. SKT5SciSumm achieves state-of-the-art performance on
the Multi-XScience dataset. Through extensive experiments and evaluation, we
showcase the benefits of our model by using less complicated models to achieve
remarkable results, thereby highlighting its potential in advancing the field
of multi-document summarization for scientific text.
|
[
-0.15368035435676575,
0.07299961894750595,
0.6168159246444702,
0.1701827347278595,
-0.6387776136398315,
0.6681618690490723,
-0.11426835507154465,
-0.20773199200630188,
0.6286237835884094,
0.11320957541465759,
-0.32518479228019714,
-0.629701554775238,
-0.7656728625297546,
0.5268088579177856,
-0.5032956004142761,
1.2972556352615356,
0.07125759869813919,
0.02303788997232914,
-0.5645368695259094,
-0.11502586305141449,
0.16640575230121613,
-0.3522320091724396,
0.27726396918296814,
-0.2522708475589752,
0.5788795351982117,
0.39940181374549866,
0.0833263024687767,
0.5055567026138306,
0.7705491185188293,
0.2634658217430115,
-0.18375058472156525,
0.2631562352180481,
-0.29039981961250305,
0.19856594502925873,
-0.1591539829969406,
-0.5015031099319458,
-0.4730113446712494,
-0.04181242734193802,
0.7567466497421265,
0.5878928303718567,
-0.07927646487951279,
0.2218044102191925,
-0.0706774964928627,
0.32608962059020996,
-0.2961061894893646,
0.3340691328048706,
-0.27671974897384644,
-0.013916145078837872,
-0.006389373913407326,
-0.26465773582458496,
-0.3855816125869751,
-0.45808085799217224,
0.09975171834230423,
-0.581332266330719,
0.692040205001831,
-0.05841658636927605,
0.5780856013298035,
0.183480903506279,
-0.5197441577911377,
-0.15063172578811646,
-0.7278131246566772,
0.696451723575592,
-0.8182809948921204,
0.2672801613807678,
-0.4078265130519867,
0.3275766670703888,
0.15089018642902374,
-1.003003716468811,
-0.5018712878227234,
-0.1813543736934662,
-0.21900124847888947,
0.7521403431892395,
0.2359110713005066,
0.12635928392410278,
0.03294971585273743,
0.6482015252113342,
-0.6313338279724121,
-0.38394057750701904,
-1.03457772731781,
0.03875526785850525,
0.41483068466186523,
0.21873672306537628,
-0.011069584637880325,
-0.389952689409256,
-0.3321264386177063,
-0.24401114881038666,
-0.3631928861141205,
-0.5052645206451416,
-0.030047696083784103,
0.13565506041049957,
-0.2590862810611725,
0.9009720087051392,
0.04645445942878723,
-0.023271534591913223,
-0.030911942943930626,
-0.39726075530052185,
0.2607225179672241,
-0.7540087699890137,
0.1087815910577774,
0.1857704520225525,
0.7064835429191589,
0.4603578746318817,
-0.3190242648124695,
-0.3903801739215851,
0.22852592170238495,
0.665230393409729,
0.1969730406999588,
-0.8168372511863708,
-0.19519329071044922,
0.4432905316352844,
-0.5630960464477539,
-0.5377888679504395,
0.2664320766925812,
-0.8322774171829224,
-0.2091377079486847,
0.028728215023875237,
-0.05171553045511246,
-0.6439321637153625,
-0.22399279475212097,
-0.09740874916315079,
-0.6985962986946106,
-0.30675503611564636,
0.15060098469257355,
-0.6033838987350464,
0.30345097184181213,
0.26316583156585693,
1.1501377820968628,
-0.4232122302055359,
-0.3011203408241272,
0.0485062412917614,
0.7717655897140503,
0.03378145769238472,
0.8085507154464722,
-0.31792861223220825,
-0.745452344417572,
-0.6933739185333252,
-0.20847788453102112,
-0.15525783598423004,
-0.16380921006202698,
0.4983902871608734,
-0.16893382370471954,
0.24838823080062866,
-0.09381216019392014,
-0.5580520629882812,
-0.2605203688144684,
-0.017511190846562386,
-0.5579067468643188,
1.0554672479629517,
0.062268055975437164,
-0.8030190467834473,
0.4879112243652344,
-1.181833028793335,
-0.4788663387298584,
0.27299824357032776,
-0.12014134228229523,
-0.5505138635635376,
0.38191846013069153,
0.1125364825129509,
0.5432661175727844,
0.03376550227403641,
0.39339926838874817,
-0.3095208406448364,
0.026455949991941452,
0.04751058667898178,
0.09268874675035477,
0.04422170668840408,
0.1947212815284729,
-0.035890061408281326,
0.34049901366233826,
-0.8076122999191284,
-0.2564178705215454,
0.04569568112492561,
-0.1985033005475998,
-0.4446829557418823,
0.185367152094841,
0.16755694150924683,
0.4933456480503082,
0.07935722172260284,
-0.9814561605453491,
0.2475297898054123,
-0.22145113348960876,
0.7466676831245422,
0.39921316504478455,
0.12426140904426575,
0.39210405945777893,
-0.45794886350631714,
0.49194517731666565,
0.259274959564209,
-0.19459380209445953,
-0.8541463613510132,
-0.15359602868556976,
-0.3410809338092804,
-0.6933930516242981,
0.35585474967956543,
0.2107892483472824,
-0.6718564033508301,
0.28587740659713745,
-0.5990163087844849,
-0.7553648948669434,
-0.5978851914405823,
-0.331327885389328,
0.20239734649658203,
0.32891517877578735,
0.6597798466682434,
0.012510188855230808,
-0.6790018081665039,
-0.833235502243042,
-0.13824458420276642,
0.19158633053302765,
0.1094345971941948,
-0.18576402962207794,
0.924865186214447,
-0.06933730095624924,
1.0424597263336182,
-0.7487762570381165,
-0.21710428595542908,
-0.6761101484298706,
0.3867487907409668,
-0.013880087062716484,
0.3221328854560852,
0.44790396094322205,
-0.8368709087371826,
-0.37475502490997314,
-0.06636026501655579,
-0.8919627070426941,
0.12669944763183594,
-0.13112379610538483,
0.36423519253730774,
0.013549682684242725,
0.27484777569770813,
-0.8135849237442017,
0.1893351972103119,
0.38776934146881104,
0.0030608195811510086,
0.7890207171440125,
-0.5313998460769653,
0.26612961292266846,
-1.5752043724060059,
0.2991056442260742,
0.19372038543224335,
-0.2657828629016876,
-0.45627057552337646,
0.24053817987442017,
0.296874463558197,
-0.15952129662036896,
-0.2650969922542572,
-0.0959138423204422,
-0.6001110672950745,
-0.0702526792883873,
-0.2402677685022354,
0.09833361208438873,
0.02671651728451252,
0.13568133115768433,
0.23401154577732086,
0.6139041185379028,
0.030204173177480698,
-0.414422869682312,
0.06319373100996017,
0.282804936170578,
0.06432870775461197,
0.5180748105049133,
-0.7216078639030457,
-0.24830962717533112,
-0.3283076286315918,
0.8227131962776184,
-0.8002782464027405,
-0.409553200006485,
-0.13963010907173157,
-0.5004810690879822,
0.018979687243700027,
0.2701491713523865,
-0.691613495349884,
-0.5553969740867615,
-0.6443257927894592,
0.2030627280473709,
0.2687869966030121,
-0.40168309211730957,
0.853556752204895,
0.04521621763706207,
-0.4751986861228943,
-0.00910989474505186,
-0.340035080909729,
0.25709256529808044,
-0.31605103611946106,
-0.6874237060546875,
0.7954444885253906,
-0.18209326267242432,
0.11198577284812927,
0.09089675545692444,
-0.21286191046237946,
0.5255270004272461,
-0.2646889090538025,
0.24722498655319214,
0.4242437481880188,
-0.02321874350309372,
-0.18888124823570251,
0.5853015780448914,
-0.3812727630138397,
-0.07595489919185638,
-0.3315131962299347,
0.3346988260746002,
-0.02867782488465309,
-0.15527060627937317,
-0.2089468538761139,
0.809208333492279,
0.9969702959060669,
-0.21972040832042694,
0.5403150320053101,
0.3333992660045624,
-0.23322148621082306,
0.020480269566178322,
-0.22303229570388794,
-0.39940476417541504,
-0.3711607754230499,
0.5289497971534729,
-0.3013102114200592,
-0.8292566537857056,
0.4658169150352478,
-0.28122925758361816,
0.30831965804100037,
0.6252908110618591,
0.34400174021720886,
-0.4111620783805847,
1.2037156820297241,
0.7383460998535156,
0.23025132715702057,
-0.061411429196596146,
-0.1978638619184494,
0.21856261789798737,
-0.754607617855072,
-0.5785152316093445,
-0.5654537081718445,
-0.017078302800655365,
-0.26607176661491394,
-0.2344452440738678,
0.8395784497261047,
-0.2864995002746582,
0.37883996963500977,
0.3389827609062195,
-0.5790485143661499,
0.2193266600370407,
0.2943323850631714,
-0.14104075729846954,
0.587780237197876,
-0.05764808505773544,
-0.4199948310852051,
-0.316639244556427,
-0.9200688600540161,
-0.6229777336120605,
0.7825942635536194,
0.1500534564256668,
0.6755996942520142,
0.019312649965286255,
0.823150634765625,
0.3215024769306183,
0.21309085190296173,
-0.4033814072608948,
0.4615970551967621,
-0.27524951100349426,
-0.17006520926952362,
0.08809849619865417,
-0.419284462928772,
-0.5770401954650879,
0.6897454857826233,
-0.14909499883651733,
-0.2409333735704422,
-0.14852797985076904,
0.004970017354935408,
-0.3703007102012634,
0.24324455857276917,
-0.7518123984336853,
0.319225937128067,
-0.03921118378639221,
0.2037108838558197,
-0.3497808873653412,
-0.9469323754310608,
0.6389851570129395,
-0.11036326736211777,
0.307819128036499,
0.128253772854805,
-0.0006764487479813397,
0.7816261053085327,
-0.34297987818717957,
0.7200953364372253,
0.07021551579236984,
0.33073538541793823,
-0.3220786154270172,
-0.22021378576755524,
0.30521026253700256,
-0.010505939833819866,
0.38154423236846924,
-0.04406307637691498,
0.464851438999176,
-0.3333030343055725,
-0.4389027953147888,
0.6706196665763855,
-0.5099626183509827,
-0.2107970267534256,
-0.9038563966751099,
-0.8170104622840881,
0.12585455179214478,
0.1623295545578003,
0.2701285779476166,
0.17238633334636688,
-0.13252988457679749,
0.21787600219249725,
0.6050332188606262,
-0.05574415624141693,
0.44793596863746643,
0.40221914649009705,
-0.035421811044216156,
-0.647925615310669,
0.9936404228210449,
0.1929207742214203,
0.44528862833976746,
0.16150563955307007,
0.09756143391132355,
-0.19919806718826294,
-0.4243249297142029,
-0.40527021884918213,
0.6379185318946838,
-0.41325318813323975,
-0.2535043954849243,
-1.0447677373886108,
-0.23744480311870575,
-0.7873306274414062,
-0.39819812774658203,
-0.24735209345817566,
-0.721544086933136,
-0.2841976284980774,
-0.36070066690444946,
0.3532432019710541,
0.8269509673118591,
-0.07335127890110016,
0.26885032653808594,
-1.0161409378051758,
0.5522058010101318,
-0.5293663740158081,
0.07044824957847595,
-0.13697116076946259,
-0.0982503741979599,
-0.25314319133758545,
-0.16940052807331085,
-0.37471988797187805,
-0.8072616457939148,
0.5279302000999451,
0.2170749008655548,
0.5666019916534424,
0.3236081600189209,
0.014808982610702515,
0.45559099316596985,
-0.3193238079547882,
0.9050201773643494,
0.5681150555610657,
-0.5927399396896362,
0.3739154636859894,
-0.4391121566295624,
0.5632326006889343,
0.33016738295555115,
0.25860166549682617,
-0.7096116542816162,
-0.8353273868560791,
-0.832564651966095,
-0.9382295608520508,
0.6432316899299622,
0.24441438913345337,
-0.29700055718421936,
0.060260869562625885,
0.04914223030209541,
0.5219059586524963,
0.3249865472316742,
-0.5034434199333191,
-0.18843507766723633,
-0.655841052532196,
-0.45912349224090576,
-0.1596865952014923,
-0.09275340288877487,
-0.15691451728343964,
-0.12609772384166718,
0.7372138500213623,
-0.3408758044242859,
0.24366545677185059,
0.13291913270950317,
-0.34680184721946716,
0.18288540840148926,
0.39423656463623047,
1.101233720779419,
0.43182358145713806,
-0.2559071183204651,
0.35339489579200745,
0.04816266521811485,
-0.7189723253250122,
-0.03196075186133385,
0.34666502475738525,
-0.25875306129455566,
0.18686600029468536,
0.25025102496147156,
0.3046247959136963,
0.2589532136917114,
-0.3393639922142029,
0.17928756773471832,
0.030571160838007927,
-0.562109649181366,
-0.0367605984210968,
-0.04641960933804512,
0.30873537063598633,
0.024626541882753372,
0.8117188811302185,
0.3247721791267395,
0.21864230930805206,
-0.15815046429634094,
0.0924190804362297,
0.11537306755781174,
0.023704012855887413,
-0.6020721793174744,
0.8328961133956909,
0.06407332420349121,
0.34043100476264954,
-0.07917550206184387,
0.09567047655582428,
-0.6942293047904968,
0.5297006368637085,
0.7831358313560486,
0.5416370034217834,
-0.23556701838970184,
0.4497626721858978,
0.23721018433570862,
0.2620750069618225,
-0.06034104898571968,
0.29018905758857727,
0.008685803040862083,
-0.13266701996326447,
-0.4131240248680115,
-0.410761296749115,
-0.39232683181762695,
-0.15622596442699432,
-0.6459189653396606,
0.13487519323825836,
-0.09445665031671524,
0.0900116115808487,
0.45429709553718567,
-0.11162405461072922,
0.0018716772319748998,
0.12462689727544785,
-0.2540428340435028,
0.9263163805007935,
-0.949761688709259,
0.5041608810424805,
0.5913786292076111,
-0.6574479937553406,
-0.2414344996213913,
-0.4841190576553345,
0.01980671100318432,
0.03021392598748207,
0.12126745283603668,
-0.03431408107280731,
-0.31164202094078064,
0.11444912105798721,
-0.648271381855011,
-0.7767876386642456,
1.4330711364746094,
0.12071322649717331,
-0.3055812120437622,
-0.17559151351451874,
0.14565221965312958,
0.5298627614974976,
-0.4366321861743927,
0.35099804401397705,
0.3752661645412445,
0.4612557590007782,
0.44383788108825684,
-0.5896096229553223,
0.05169885978102684,
-0.4342237114906311,
-0.10924380272626877,
0.3849674463272095,
-0.8418360948562622,
0.5501115322113037,
-0.36225107312202454,
-0.17903201282024384,
0.12315122038125992,
0.9796591997146606,
0.7021046280860901,
0.3521089553833008,
0.09841114282608032,
0.4393230974674225,
0.6422663927078247,
-0.11848815530538559,
0.9752575755119324,
-0.2657591700553894,
0.2577272653579712,
1.0641814470291138,
-0.3984827995300293,
0.23183107376098633,
0.6893600225448608,
-0.1296711415052414,
0.3931184411048889,
0.5385385155677795,
-0.21892885863780975,
0.7166552543640137,
-0.10278671979904175,
-0.33520233631134033,
0.07567507773637772,
0.03761649876832962,
-0.6103955507278442,
0.1449183076620102,
0.6017614603042603,
-0.5876867175102234,
-0.5498127937316895,
0.18484532833099365,
0.08589521795511246,
-0.020802782848477364,
-0.007315270137041807,
0.6645329594612122,
0.3355908989906311,
-0.44147059321403503,
-0.08762645721435547,
0.44631001353263855,
0.7658443450927734,
-0.7457255125045776,
-0.08403381705284119,
-0.03272503986954689,
0.20025843381881714,
-0.3521369397640228,
-0.42061349749565125,
0.35602033138275146,
-0.08305592089891434,
-0.595203161239624,
-0.24240967631340027,
0.6632148027420044,
-0.5199762582778931,
-0.6033259034156799,
0.03203285112977028,
0.29639628529548645,
0.19096219539642334,
0.4045296609401703,
-0.26785042881965637,
-0.29982224106788635,
-0.31977787613868713,
0.1492743343114853,
0.2754531800746918,
0.021220864728093147,
-0.34833160042762756,
0.45660609006881714,
0.9101197123527527,
0.1664113998413086,
0.10374720394611359,
0.06785553693771362,
1.024227499961853,
-0.5929948091506958,
-0.9928117394447327,
-0.5866827368736267,
0.5366590023040771,
-0.31549838185310364,
-0.23594802618026733,
0.8663429021835327,
1.0591695308685303,
0.20861348509788513,
-0.23114556074142456,
1.3848899602890015,
-0.13112427294254303,
0.7121112942695618,
-0.13282693922519684,
0.8335756063461304,
-0.22774362564086914,
-0.07122677564620972,
-0.4274890720844269,
-0.66633540391922,
-0.482173353433609,
0.23258183896541595,
-0.05865149199962616,
0.016280148178339005,
1.0099902153015137,
0.5011404752731323,
-0.3286034166812897,
0.49645525217056274,
0.04315619915723801,
0.15684953331947327,
0.3831974267959595,
0.046080414205789566,
0.5602007508277893,
-0.1449541300535202,
0.5528188943862915,
-0.13779498636722565,
-0.17681030929088593,
-0.18662093579769135,
-0.8506291508674622,
-0.7679973840713501,
-0.7774563431739807,
-0.3016822040081024,
-0.2778919041156769,
0.11058046668767929,
0.8795216083526611,
0.6022642254829407,
-0.7141141295433044,
0.039897508919239044,
0.10809478163719177,
-0.29524582624435425,
-0.25868090987205505,
-0.20553311705589294,
0.513238787651062,
-0.14176760613918304,
-0.40430545806884766,
0.49916931986808777,
0.581548273563385,
0.08398504555225372,
-0.4021727740764618,
-0.050186607986688614,
-0.2903389036655426,
0.059162113815546036,
0.691491961479187,
0.09322913736104965,
-0.49154263734817505,
-0.009880769066512585,
0.2314673215150833,
-0.1263473778963089,
0.18966147303581238,
0.9330673217773438,
-0.6568239331245422,
0.2510606050491333,
0.30390670895576477,
0.21238656342029572,
1.0919692516326904,
-0.024191703647375107,
0.6661227345466614,
-0.6859005689620972,
-0.27066656947135925,
0.17550501227378845,
0.20327632129192352,
0.35723215341567993,
-0.41112637519836426,
0.34152883291244507,
0.500705897808075,
-0.18656712770462036,
-0.825082004070282,
-0.19036298990249634,
-1.2077372074127197,
-0.18233011662960052,
0.9081457257270813,
0.02978709526360035,
-0.1572459638118744,
-0.2217484563589096,
-0.19651536643505096,
0.4189002215862274,
-0.6309455633163452,
0.9756202101707458,
0.6873641014099121,
-0.10025293380022049,
-0.3195870816707611,
-0.11905133724212646,
0.1552124172449112,
0.252302348613739,
-1.0847651958465576,
-0.20476646721363068,
0.4214928150177002,
0.3562697172164917,
0.46496284008026123,
0.18974949419498444,
-0.4238128960132599,
0.4011290371417999,
-0.036215104162693024,
0.35198113322257996,
-0.4330236613750458,
-0.33212006092071533,
-0.10924974828958511,
0.6146281361579895,
-0.6019730567932129,
0.029901275411248207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17304v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17304v2
|
Probing Multimodal Large Language Models for Global and Local Semantic Representations
| 2024-02-27T08:27:15 | 2024-03-27T02:59:57 |
Mingxu Tao, Quzhe Huang, Kun Xu, Liwei Chen, Yansong Feng, Dongyan Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advancement of Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) has greatly
accelerated the development of applications in understanding integrated texts
and images. Recent works leverage image-caption datasets to train MLLMs,
achieving state-of-the-art performance on image-to-text tasks. However, there
are few studies exploring which layers of MLLMs make the most effort to the
global image information, which plays vital roles in multimodal comprehension
and generation. In this study, we find that the intermediate layers of models
can encode more global semantic information, whose representation vectors
perform better on visual-language entailment tasks, rather than the topmost
layers. We further probe models regarding local semantic representations
through object recognition tasks. We find that the topmost layers may
excessively focus on local information, leading to a diminished ability to
encode global information. Our code and data are released via
https://github.com/kobayashikanna01/probing_MLLM_rep.
|
[
-0.5165462493896484,
-0.6889333724975586,
0.6297281980514526,
-0.11861837655305862,
-0.03870193660259247,
-0.27425530552864075,
-0.39437657594680786,
-0.6570591926574707,
-0.27759644389152527,
0.6521903872489929,
-0.4483465552330017,
-0.4666881263256073,
-0.6930386424064636,
0.07579099386930466,
-0.29924318194389343,
0.6691362261772156,
-0.13364021480083466,
0.15576030313968658,
-0.7416455149650574,
-0.1754513531923294,
-0.24917326867580414,
-0.7237728238105774,
-0.5246413946151733,
-0.3150460422039032,
0.5970322489738464,
0.1916757971048355,
0.6994625329971313,
0.3794839382171631,
0.6177929043769836,
0.35622870922088623,
0.015794891864061356,
0.2099735140800476,
-0.3699094355106354,
0.1288977861404419,
-0.1620524674654007,
-0.49536803364753723,
-0.06694777309894562,
-0.14843738079071045,
0.9128525853157043,
0.5119840502738953,
0.24598465859889984,
0.1656949818134308,
-0.13891810178756714,
0.453896701335907,
-0.7149575352668762,
0.45921820402145386,
-0.7316226959228516,
0.0997326523065567,
-0.06725500524044037,
-0.23536333441734314,
-0.6072479486465454,
0.356937974691391,
0.2934724688529968,
-0.5291162729263306,
0.31354960799217224,
0.13013136386871338,
0.8829056620597839,
0.1352248340845108,
-0.8219045996665955,
-0.2056976705789566,
-0.628552258014679,
0.8762347102165222,
-0.4673234522342682,
0.5162365436553955,
0.4891608953475952,
0.32825160026550293,
-0.02035813219845295,
-0.4698200523853302,
-0.559341311454773,
-0.605181872844696,
-0.3613872230052948,
0.018298368901014328,
-0.21588757634162903,
0.012052264995872974,
0.2633283734321594,
0.31193262338638306,
-0.5374346375465393,
-0.0070678903721272945,
-0.35389769077301025,
-0.40953800082206726,
0.34312868118286133,
0.07456623017787933,
0.43521732091903687,
-0.2852828800678253,
-0.6831955909729004,
-0.2185317724943161,
-0.7099527716636658,
0.18597163259983063,
0.09785421937704086,
0.12851683795452118,
-0.2386617809534073,
0.8305245041847229,
-0.1551593393087387,
0.8355650305747986,
-0.4308095872402191,
-0.06985165923833847,
0.15210308134555817,
-0.6373558640480042,
-0.2269059121608734,
-0.07141833007335663,
0.5340421199798584,
0.5436258912086487,
0.3462817370891571,
-0.24924291670322418,
-0.199740931391716,
0.1825438141822815,
0.12953723967075348,
-0.7341625690460205,
0.11491746455430984,
0.24912582337856293,
-0.4442988336086273,
-0.1613410860300064,
0.0749095156788826,
-0.27824726700782776,
-0.513978898525238,
-0.6864187717437744,
0.4343617856502533,
-0.31504321098327637,
-0.21779073774814606,
0.2860107719898224,
-0.14320117235183716,
0.5348325371742249,
0.2199084609746933,
-0.6357741951942444,
0.12874655425548553,
0.3357711732387543,
0.6510301828384399,
0.020092429593205452,
-0.5442498922348022,
-0.5553327798843384,
0.45836341381073,
-0.2630082964897156,
0.7927014827728271,
-0.8191426396369934,
0.06935199350118637,
0.04251513257622719,
0.2735283672809601,
-0.23397453129291534,
-0.5416424870491028,
0.43055716156959534,
-0.5109155178070068,
0.10603883117437363,
-0.29541170597076416,
-0.32901814579963684,
-0.3026092052459717,
0.4765087068080902,
-0.8187592625617981,
0.8933300971984863,
-0.19274774193763733,
-0.9825750589370728,
0.1909189671278,
-0.49416476488113403,
-0.17394906282424927,
-0.34617069363594055,
-0.27852848172187805,
-0.23002678155899048,
0.2379818856716156,
0.6335940957069397,
0.9956725239753723,
-0.34213578701019287,
0.06023823842406273,
-0.20488999783992767,
-0.29147547483444214,
0.4056716859340668,
-0.44332391023635864,
0.4207940995693207,
0.010339584201574326,
-0.07310088723897934,
0.23999887704849243,
-0.5907391309738159,
-0.31858888268470764,
0.4475167393684387,
-0.17861634492874146,
-0.4488241374492645,
-0.028423817828297615,
0.08184894919395447,
0.3799484670162201,
0.3187316358089447,
-0.7268185019493103,
0.08725208044052124,
-0.034912850707769394,
0.37457868456840515,
0.6196328401565552,
-0.08255167305469513,
0.6334500312805176,
-0.15397939085960388,
0.16575516760349274,
0.5175386071205139,
0.1286345273256302,
-0.5785834789276123,
-0.5096153020858765,
-0.7877389788627625,
-0.07557810097932816,
0.021464310586452484,
0.3869541883468628,
-0.8320861458778381,
-0.19761785864830017,
-0.32034066319465637,
-0.2934456765651703,
-0.44850534200668335,
0.1910744607448578,
0.3856172263622284,
0.32522907853126526,
0.2789032757282257,
-0.18243321776390076,
-0.24081608653068542,
-1.2495185136795044,
0.06773879379034042,
0.1576799601316452,
-0.037417829036712646,
0.3168129622936249,
0.6021053791046143,
-0.39687758684158325,
0.8361278772354126,
-0.2991750240325928,
-0.47605371475219727,
-0.1890150010585785,
0.07719705998897552,
-0.08130352944135666,
0.3241159915924072,
0.6092973351478577,
-1.0298235416412354,
-0.38801437616348267,
0.22387506067752838,
-0.6703617572784424,
0.3969668447971344,
-0.21121563017368317,
-0.3604968786239624,
0.21629548072814941,
0.5097681879997253,
-0.9035314917564392,
0.2599636912345886,
0.5865687131881714,
-0.38777896761894226,
0.31021904945373535,
-0.47864004969596863,
0.1154354065656662,
-0.6752846240997314,
0.11648470163345337,
0.11757552623748779,
-0.18146464228630066,
-0.6616228222846985,
0.30862748622894287,
0.35097429156303406,
-0.1676897257566452,
-0.31399035453796387,
0.5015193223953247,
-0.9208270907402039,
-0.279811829328537,
-0.0009180409833788872,
0.32215026021003723,
0.19524075090885162,
0.635664165019989,
0.15914520621299744,
0.6390393972396851,
0.9637396335601807,
-0.42608314752578735,
0.34919145703315735,
-0.054255031049251556,
-0.6512932181358337,
0.21208204329013824,
-0.5477426648139954,
0.08692178130149841,
-0.689468264579773,
0.2803298532962799,
-1.053604245185852,
-0.5242016911506653,
-0.04241689667105675,
-0.2983045279979706,
0.39868372678756714,
-0.07897062599658966,
-0.7601195573806763,
-0.19337743520736694,
-0.2685394883155823,
0.44888901710510254,
0.3163658380508423,
-0.4020206928253174,
0.7424102425575256,
0.4345284104347229,
0.05803065001964569,
-0.6030932664871216,
-0.7791835069656372,
-0.05112915486097336,
0.016149654984474182,
-0.7155078649520874,
0.33322659134864807,
0.2570323050022125,
-0.059911422431468964,
-0.04028154909610748,
0.004078741651028395,
0.04471133276820183,
-0.23627589643001556,
0.12382040172815323,
0.20307834446430206,
-0.22565561532974243,
0.2141980081796646,
-0.2670673727989197,
-0.028028065338730812,
0.15471819043159485,
-0.134108766913414,
0.6916021108627319,
-0.2961117625236511,
-0.5543345212936401,
-0.292052298784256,
0.5412711501121521,
0.8336063623428345,
-0.7405978441238403,
0.822496235370636,
0.9123508930206299,
-0.439225971698761,
0.021301640197634697,
-0.575124979019165,
-0.14979040622711182,
-0.4319128394126892,
0.6230630278587341,
-0.37345653772354126,
-0.6871297359466553,
0.7519047260284424,
0.21817834675312042,
-0.18635620176792145,
0.3523949682712555,
0.4537501931190491,
-0.07398727536201477,
1.1694279909133911,
0.461966872215271,
-0.01711294800043106,
0.34778064489364624,
-0.5252401232719421,
-0.08794248849153519,
-0.9160794615745544,
-0.4087466299533844,
-0.28308820724487305,
-0.04005599394440651,
-0.3285866677761078,
-0.9636749625205994,
0.33968085050582886,
0.019989311695098877,
-0.1591508686542511,
0.03019341081380844,
-0.33952203392982483,
0.5950785279273987,
0.5042498707771301,
0.17817319929599762,
0.24492773413658142,
0.29052892327308655,
-0.20841728150844574,
-0.016681989654898643,
-0.5963571667671204,
-0.3653438091278076,
0.8105624914169312,
0.5479321479797363,
0.763346254825592,
-0.06431622058153152,
0.276783287525177,
-0.019000953063368797,
-0.00807262398302555,
-0.6025528907775879,
0.6427373290061951,
-0.3363634943962097,
-0.5565756559371948,
-0.14006517827510834,
-0.2747662365436554,
-0.9468139410018921,
0.5067585110664368,
-0.0944480299949646,
-0.5109612941741943,
0.08571997284889221,
0.05078735202550888,
0.06732533872127533,
0.4236657917499542,
-0.7150291800498962,
1.1217788457870483,
-0.15710072219371796,
-0.19596795737743378,
-0.11548612266778946,
-0.6396646499633789,
0.2239241749048233,
0.22148241102695465,
0.4107470214366913,
-0.20379704236984253,
-0.19773463904857635,
0.38836783170700073,
0.10074389725923538,
1.0067062377929688,
-0.27732977271080017,
-0.5360493659973145,
0.3054541051387787,
0.01851511001586914,
0.505020797252655,
-0.21925748884677887,
0.2822807729244232,
0.22066816687583923,
-0.23045645654201508,
-0.4853818118572235,
-0.6206565499305725,
0.7058017253875732,
-0.6866722106933594,
-0.4311017394065857,
-0.12252070754766464,
-0.6689640879631042,
-0.2457481324672699,
-0.004880993627011776,
0.11848638206720352,
0.9285848736763,
0.3041340112686157,
0.49702537059783936,
0.68430495262146,
-0.33358463644981384,
0.31864580512046814,
0.04915209114551544,
-0.4347553849220276,
-0.05850277841091156,
1.0034420490264893,
0.06493299454450607,
0.47812530398368835,
0.7157952785491943,
0.04581858962774277,
-0.3805217146873474,
-0.37978655099868774,
-0.5976933240890503,
0.2928325831890106,
-1.143802285194397,
-0.16258467733860016,
-0.5253191590309143,
-0.11551859229803085,
-0.2376386672258377,
-0.003960908390581608,
-0.271732896566391,
-0.24442671239376068,
-0.08969051390886307,
0.09215761721134186,
0.25940003991127014,
0.788322925567627,
0.35283616185188293,
0.05710366368293762,
-0.8395782113075256,
0.3674238324165344,
0.21595342457294464,
0.24247924983501434,
0.2519090175628662,
-0.28423795104026794,
-0.4020988643169403,
0.06019635498523712,
0.09760865569114685,
-0.6915841698646545,
0.09031115472316742,
0.32127633690834045,
0.8182555437088013,
0.3221501111984253,
-0.11420586705207825,
0.6850507259368896,
-0.5433177947998047,
0.822988748550415,
0.06668418645858765,
-0.691263735294342,
0.43169671297073364,
-0.43652042746543884,
0.7151675224304199,
0.030429624021053314,
0.5077135562896729,
-0.4007115066051483,
-0.7504335045814514,
-0.06594157218933105,
-0.7488164305686951,
0.6393215656280518,
0.16515016555786133,
0.5815089344978333,
0.11287333816289902,
0.06473197042942047,
0.053966719657182693,
-0.07322609424591064,
-0.9577468037605286,
0.010240988805890083,
-0.06659378111362457,
-0.1413513422012329,
0.048341020941734314,
-0.2620168626308441,
-0.034796055406332016,
-0.13495726883411407,
0.15090470016002655,
-0.3046623468399048,
0.6474814414978027,
0.4107550382614136,
-0.34469324350357056,
0.16456742584705353,
0.23457424342632294,
0.6165909767150879,
0.46881452202796936,
-0.1151043102145195,
0.5380330681800842,
0.04991420730948448,
-0.42773672938346863,
-0.169939786195755,
-0.007141083013266325,
-0.0038586838636547327,
0.04625861719250679,
0.8494455218315125,
1.0544203519821167,
0.43612077832221985,
-0.8065759539604187,
0.5692585110664368,
-0.010766650550067425,
0.05022580549120903,
-0.19158296287059784,
-0.014845240861177444,
0.05121392384171486,
0.2484551966190338,
0.43651631474494934,
0.1806899905204773,
0.0744733139872551,
-0.7249994277954102,
0.04258430376648903,
0.5865315794944763,
-0.19820424914360046,
-0.18018971383571625,
0.38263773918151855,
-0.16168808937072754,
0.3846900761127472,
0.4384065568447113,
0.013544186018407345,
-0.6108343601226807,
0.6060693264007568,
0.49746108055114746,
0.4411291182041168,
0.0611598864197731,
0.1922565996646881,
0.40826326608657837,
0.3085174858570099,
0.21240323781967163,
0.2777418792247772,
-0.3072490394115448,
-0.789678156375885,
-0.6983269453048706,
-0.5557519793510437,
-0.18096517026424408,
-0.12284396588802338,
-0.5845457911491394,
0.06731387972831726,
-0.09847745299339294,
-0.09626244753599167,
-0.1391574740409851,
-0.4034702777862549,
-0.8389139771461487,
0.09309130162000656,
0.5050597786903381,
0.6945419907569885,
-0.5084981322288513,
0.9420899748802185,
0.9306110143661499,
-0.4185880422592163,
-0.3805820345878601,
-0.018110103905200958,
-0.3827066421508789,
-0.7164812088012695,
1.0403411388397217,
0.5402815937995911,
-0.22054335474967957,
-0.16207528114318848,
-0.6164541840553284,
-1.055701732635498,
1.0583088397979736,
0.4466474652290344,
-0.37174350023269653,
-0.2682804763317108,
0.4302065372467041,
0.3737403452396393,
-0.5081243515014648,
0.23698385059833527,
0.017904680222272873,
0.38515451550483704,
0.0864274874329567,
-0.9671432971954346,
0.0663837343454361,
-0.19662320613861084,
0.30295461416244507,
0.013655207119882107,
-0.4707735478878021,
1.0406897068023682,
-0.3637663424015045,
-0.3513910174369812,
-0.06771331280469894,
0.48673713207244873,
0.08339386433362961,
0.020615173503756523,
0.430672287940979,
0.34662795066833496,
0.45522692799568176,
-0.16439741849899292,
1.414411187171936,
-0.1502380222082138,
0.3296045958995819,
0.9547579884529114,
-0.07937633991241455,
1.1535183191299438,
0.4848669469356537,
0.09633462131023407,
0.3903366029262543,
0.5383179187774658,
0.019107365980744362,
0.6046309471130371,
0.044777389615774155,
-0.15814056992530823,
-0.42041015625,
-0.23732298612594604,
-0.2511669993400574,
0.6079315543174744,
0.31099435687065125,
-0.3445625603199005,
-0.36302244663238525,
0.5518627166748047,
-0.10900252312421799,
-0.12515810132026672,
-0.5161080956459045,
0.7156522870063782,
-0.12171963602304459,
-0.529850423336029,
0.7695614695549011,
0.023343287408351898,
0.5701963305473328,
-0.6018788814544678,
-0.09011776000261307,
-0.10348699241876602,
0.2595878839492798,
-0.026591671630740166,
-0.9678955078125,
0.17906485497951508,
-0.18723876774311066,
-0.1434873640537262,
-0.2428242564201355,
1.0353885889053345,
-0.7040528655052185,
-0.46921101212501526,
0.5855873227119446,
0.1992543488740921,
0.00008111193892545998,
-0.22471389174461365,
-0.5524689555168152,
0.42900538444519043,
-0.2035471647977829,
-0.3308763802051544,
0.27593472599983215,
0.5040536522865295,
-0.12370163947343826,
0.652204155921936,
0.5950209498405457,
-0.1777345985174179,
0.45279935002326965,
0.24296244978904724,
0.8548613786697388,
-0.5285141468048096,
-0.15337364375591278,
-0.7813782095909119,
0.8395398855209351,
-0.17867518961429596,
-0.05894039571285248,
0.7567342519760132,
0.47391465306282043,
1.2061104774475098,
-0.4113379418849945,
0.42486217617988586,
0.17119792103767395,
-0.02319437637925148,
-0.9702510237693787,
0.5906044244766235,
-0.8143738508224487,
-0.10058119148015976,
-0.11365079879760742,
-0.8841256499290466,
-0.43142127990722656,
0.6137710213661194,
-0.28098851442337036,
-0.10303308814764023,
0.5468276143074036,
0.7789342403411865,
-0.2896086275577545,
-0.06460168957710266,
0.4888797700405121,
0.2928266227245331,
0.13269677758216858,
0.581512987613678,
1.1437222957611084,
-0.4363803565502167,
0.531211793422699,
-0.37336722016334534,
0.18628308176994324,
0.024106690660119057,
-0.7202336192131042,
-1.141953706741333,
-0.8939879536628723,
-0.07978064566850662,
0.08180215954780579,
-0.36580270528793335,
0.683887243270874,
0.6611729860305786,
-0.6969793438911438,
-0.11345552653074265,
0.076358862221241,
-0.1965438723564148,
0.17314571142196655,
-0.16645729541778564,
0.4417899250984192,
-0.42986905574798584,
-0.7598064541816711,
0.15156736969947815,
0.2759626507759094,
0.11257749050855637,
-0.644334614276886,
-0.04922221973538399,
-0.14120706915855408,
-0.14095935225486755,
1.0390031337738037,
-0.3309812545776367,
-1.1014939546585083,
-0.25981155037879944,
0.10778618603944778,
-0.2385835200548172,
0.0955866128206253,
0.9297300577163696,
-0.5595374703407288,
0.5194683074951172,
0.42954567074775696,
0.6331009268760681,
0.5722681283950806,
-0.3487318158149719,
0.3832230269908905,
-0.9141090512275696,
0.37899866700172424,
-0.03752060979604721,
0.7311297655105591,
0.6195195317268372,
-0.21508382260799408,
0.2559671103954315,
-0.004868375603109598,
-0.37244802713394165,
-0.7513673305511475,
0.18431730568408966,
-0.9231294393539429,
-0.2900765836238861,
1.1850248575210571,
-0.11068287491798401,
-0.3745734691619873,
0.1179974153637886,
-0.61623615026474,
-0.04877830669283867,
-0.09972461313009262,
0.04685157537460327,
0.8634005188941956,
-0.07754755020141602,
-0.5094755291938782,
-0.9951390624046326,
0.15547172725200653,
0.18543487787246704,
-0.5757615566253662,
0.24939550459384918,
0.6042037010192871,
0.02234015241265297,
0.4777901768684387,
0.4305680990219116,
-0.20777064561843872,
0.17583245038986206,
0.03881083428859711,
-0.154354527592659,
-0.06704933196306229,
-0.5109468102455139,
-0.12706948816776276,
0.36622512340545654,
-0.09600869566202164,
-0.10057699680328369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17302v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17302v2
|
Can LLM Generate Culturally Relevant Commonsense QA Data? Case Study in Indonesian and Sundanese
| 2024-02-27T08:24:32 | 2024-04-16T07:41:12 |
Rifki Afina Putri, Faiz Ghifari Haznitrama, Dea Adhista, Alice Oh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly being used to generate
synthetic data for training and evaluating models. However, it is unclear
whether they can generate a good quality of question answering (QA) dataset
that incorporates knowledge and cultural nuance embedded in a language,
especially for low-resource languages. In this study, we investigate the
effectiveness of using LLMs in generating culturally relevant commonsense QA
datasets for Indonesian and Sundanese languages. To do so, we create datasets
for these languages using various methods involving both LLMs and human
annotators, resulting in ~4.5K questions per language (~9K in total), making
our dataset the largest of its kind. Our experiments show that automatic data
adaptation from an existing English dataset is less effective for Sundanese.
Interestingly, using the direct generation method on the target language, GPT-4
Turbo can generate questions with adequate general knowledge in both languages,
albeit not as culturally 'deep' as humans. We also observe a higher occurrence
of fluency errors in the Sundanese dataset, highlighting the discrepancy
between medium- and lower-resource languages.
|
[
-0.40473583340644836,
-0.587592363357544,
0.3683277666568756,
-0.003336598165333271,
-0.23444382846355438,
-0.12285850942134857,
-0.40743783116340637,
-0.6333639025688171,
0.05554424226284027,
0.5328572392463684,
-0.2783590257167816,
-0.47408533096313477,
-0.06651367992162704,
0.6031126976013184,
-0.04084670543670654,
0.9178364276885986,
-0.07122204452753067,
0.034196216613054276,
-0.23257797956466675,
-0.49481329321861267,
-0.40066635608673096,
-0.48543795943260193,
-0.7675328254699707,
-0.02923361212015152,
0.5703142285346985,
0.591806173324585,
0.5881248712539673,
0.4652373790740967,
0.2760224938392639,
0.24945472180843353,
-0.16620449721813202,
0.3447183668613434,
-0.5458982586860657,
0.19707129895687103,
-0.3072222173213959,
-0.7591623663902283,
-0.047027260065078735,
-0.14084739983081818,
0.5048947334289551,
0.5583859086036682,
0.0762476697564125,
0.5541614294052124,
-0.07732044905424118,
0.5952157378196716,
-0.5085488557815552,
0.060571618378162384,
-0.711438000202179,
-0.009236326441168785,
-0.23214302957057953,
-0.1772758811712265,
0.07894234359264374,
-0.7307755947113037,
0.030105914920568466,
-0.6436992287635803,
0.06621705740690231,
-0.17668816447257996,
0.771324634552002,
0.4192548394203186,
-0.6262649297714233,
-0.3283803462982178,
-0.7168864011764526,
0.7670945525169373,
-0.8648544549942017,
0.09068886190652847,
0.4873426854610443,
0.3913668394088745,
-0.05385618284344673,
-0.3858119547367096,
-0.8992277383804321,
-0.049819156527519226,
-0.03632155805826187,
0.1967800110578537,
-0.010410931892693043,
-0.21018081903457642,
0.46583202481269836,
0.35213524103164673,
-0.5829237699508667,
0.42148667573928833,
-0.5312283039093018,
-0.0458197258412838,
0.830824077129364,
0.2954613268375397,
0.3976597189903259,
-0.6131298542022705,
-0.10196000337600708,
-0.13199560344219208,
-0.8763082027435303,
0.18418286740779877,
0.5474306344985962,
0.18853148818016052,
0.03274941071867943,
0.5260328054428101,
-0.4163394570350647,
0.5973308086395264,
-0.15874111652374268,
-0.29228898882865906,
0.13596707582473755,
-0.5619550943374634,
-0.023971769958734512,
-0.19945789873600006,
0.645253598690033,
0.41623765230178833,
0.653962254524231,
0.09337937831878662,
-0.1908697485923767,
-0.09330061823129654,
-0.16567690670490265,
-0.6235262751579285,
-0.08401815593242645,
0.32858672738075256,
-0.20547303557395935,
-0.27371785044670105,
-0.025140119716525078,
-0.6411277055740356,
-0.3208603858947754,
-0.312799334526062,
0.12310075014829636,
-0.16240014135837555,
-0.7058948874473572,
-0.12834666669368744,
-0.0607723705470562,
0.7810640931129456,
0.18576093018054962,
-0.7194743156433105,
0.027241777628660202,
0.36678051948547363,
0.47871288657188416,
-0.11391294002532959,
-0.05525904893875122,
-0.11805667728185654,
0.11666931957006454,
-0.5799362063407898,
0.5987470149993896,
-0.40441644191741943,
-0.29211774468421936,
-0.004217410925775766,
-0.09789444506168365,
-0.00559721514582634,
-0.8680498003959656,
0.3445262014865875,
-0.6807344555854797,
0.33189037442207336,
-0.6639957427978516,
-0.295444130897522,
-0.12167645990848541,
0.3778758943080902,
-0.7309741377830505,
1.1781291961669922,
0.11351951956748962,
-0.8039929270744324,
0.4386240839958191,
-0.45919933915138245,
-0.39656075835227966,
0.17692306637763977,
-0.3651551306247711,
-0.23501956462860107,
0.04309326410293579,
0.49926576018333435,
0.5895978808403015,
-0.3749575912952423,
0.3247365653514862,
-0.22394521534442902,
-0.5303420424461365,
0.7852886319160461,
-0.5835168957710266,
0.7810319066047668,
0.5166285634040833,
-0.30307719111442566,
-0.40864098072052,
-0.6472059488296509,
-0.04129853844642639,
0.29471996426582336,
-0.3754124045372009,
-0.5347458124160767,
-0.3311813175678253,
0.009538582526147366,
0.34729522466659546,
0.21812370419502258,
-0.4396268129348755,
0.038801439106464386,
-0.2698112726211548,
0.18548151850700378,
0.7431819438934326,
0.27143022418022156,
0.03866271674633026,
-0.44026950001716614,
0.8117262125015259,
0.0065045286901295185,
-0.24560990929603577,
0.04158991947770119,
-0.4503253698348999,
-0.5824366807937622,
-0.08074898272752762,
0.09718465805053711,
0.7169081568717957,
-1.191859483718872,
0.10780727118253708,
-0.3941348195075989,
-0.4271349608898163,
-0.49949559569358826,
0.35712629556655884,
0.31019070744514465,
0.5516434907913208,
0.035267964005470276,
-0.13409002125263214,
-0.38605526089668274,
-0.7684975266456604,
-0.2257072627544403,
-0.3118261992931366,
-0.16708484292030334,
0.7018566131591797,
0.35374224185943604,
0.09930248558521271,
0.9570870399475098,
-0.33398765325546265,
-0.02004653587937355,
-0.38721752166748047,
0.012240658514201641,
0.4213768243789673,
0.2577667534351349,
0.680294930934906,
-0.7997526526451111,
-0.40424293279647827,
-0.028729546815156937,
-0.9250743389129639,
-0.20794767141342163,
-0.05084198713302612,
-0.010820016264915466,
0.38727453351020813,
0.3103678226470947,
-0.16269299387931824,
0.00585567532107234,
0.6630647778511047,
-0.01960972137749195,
0.5358963012695312,
-0.13643284142017365,
0.45110026001930237,
-1.6252557039260864,
0.22345024347305298,
0.015214932151138783,
0.02175142429769039,
-0.6396996974945068,
-0.1591297686100006,
-0.07185380160808563,
-0.26827797293663025,
-0.6168538928031921,
0.7257871031761169,
-0.31495729088783264,
-0.2386176735162735,
-0.09125790745019913,
0.034682728350162506,
-0.24956749379634857,
0.4977765381336212,
0.25575318932533264,
1.1746865510940552,
0.32680821418762207,
-0.5272562503814697,
0.4078645408153534,
0.18245339393615723,
-0.553957462310791,
0.7424906492233276,
-0.6184592247009277,
0.2044064700603485,
-0.18042588233947754,
0.1438075751066208,
-0.994010865688324,
-0.6176074147224426,
0.11904750764369965,
-0.2997545599937439,
-0.09706384688615799,
-0.27051669359207153,
-0.6144960522651672,
-0.3471202552318573,
-0.1429244726896286,
0.7857545614242554,
0.7327947020530701,
-0.6195773482322693,
0.03421990945935249,
0.256251722574234,
-0.5318816304206848,
-0.5784996747970581,
-0.8701651692390442,
0.056937821209430695,
-0.5189202427864075,
-0.6457705497741699,
-0.3712485134601593,
0.18316765129566193,
-0.27687984704971313,
-0.044673897325992584,
0.08353640884160995,
-0.21854503452777863,
0.20110787451267242,
-0.1375415325164795,
0.1489703506231308,
-0.46705904603004456,
0.27784883975982666,
0.07046739757061005,
0.18882210552692413,
0.18216992914676666,
-0.23160144686698914,
0.32262659072875977,
-0.06176208332180977,
-0.3486019968986511,
-0.49967828392982483,
0.11042286455631256,
0.41706833243370056,
-0.3614113926887512,
0.5852206349372864,
0.7430746555328369,
-0.28648751974105835,
-0.11858124285936356,
-0.7132984399795532,
-0.20076850056648254,
-0.46162793040275574,
0.34604981541633606,
-0.4579126834869385,
-0.9815678596496582,
0.6913581490516663,
-0.03727736696600914,
-0.013142616488039494,
0.45251160860061646,
0.5177254676818848,
-0.3334658145904541,
0.692130982875824,
0.3452872037887573,
-0.16011041402816772,
0.33004188537597656,
-0.17976386845111847,
-0.057405296713113785,
-0.710631787776947,
0.11973223090171814,
-0.5480971336364746,
-0.32284921407699585,
-1.0805540084838867,
-0.4527275562286377,
0.7284583449363708,
-0.11498061567544937,
-0.0708957239985466,
-0.07400476932525635,
-0.1953217089176178,
0.7211487293243408,
0.434459924697876,
-0.007255611941218376,
0.3950920104980469,
0.15289802849292755,
0.2145410031080246,
0.0627710372209549,
-0.928999125957489,
-0.6750741004943848,
1.4176082611083984,
0.08665326237678528,
0.6771700382232666,
0.19841112196445465,
0.7822962999343872,
0.0024838647805154324,
0.37545713782310486,
-0.25122949481010437,
0.40610355138778687,
-0.2575569152832031,
-0.6825617551803589,
-0.4791690409183502,
-0.7606489658355713,
-0.9926431775093079,
0.13614024221897125,
-0.06822260469198227,
-0.32177552580833435,
0.22869248688220978,
0.11771763116121292,
-0.26347461342811584,
0.30785468220710754,
-0.6248269081115723,
0.690093994140625,
-0.2886504828929901,
-0.2956300973892212,
-0.045170072466135025,
-0.4424467086791992,
0.6544786691665649,
-0.1890040636062622,
0.17468120157718658,
-0.2991531789302826,
-0.02349766530096531,
0.9925775527954102,
-0.01730215549468994,
0.9446872472763062,
-0.2606407105922699,
-0.39780834317207336,
0.46629393100738525,
-0.14980041980743408,
0.3472742438316345,
0.39182230830192566,
-0.28169700503349304,
0.12862642109394073,
0.23482801020145416,
-0.6916404366493225,
-0.5579448938369751,
0.5716902017593384,
-1.0212998390197754,
-0.6930040121078491,
-0.3384961485862732,
-0.6479116678237915,
-0.3463941812515259,
-0.014615481719374657,
0.0065963417291641235,
0.28751763701438904,
-0.12761731445789337,
-0.02605743333697319,
0.7466201186180115,
-0.6494985818862915,
0.09285490214824677,
0.48664557933807373,
0.11735210567712784,
-0.3955228328704834,
0.9706110954284668,
0.17626795172691345,
0.36588072776794434,
0.007131601218134165,
0.20568430423736572,
-0.3769482374191284,
-0.45588603615760803,
-0.6286808848381042,
0.4872738718986511,
-0.7504671812057495,
-0.16782882809638977,
-0.34483614563941956,
-0.07005316019058228,
-0.34453684091567993,
-0.0971926674246788,
-0.060742855072021484,
-0.4642442464828491,
-0.11396116018295288,
-0.09901291877031326,
0.6343805193901062,
0.7508718967437744,
-0.013505236245691776,
-0.17824475467205048,
-0.6929186582565308,
0.31971338391304016,
0.5765182375907898,
0.19813214242458344,
-0.1739731729030609,
-0.45110201835632324,
-0.09604007005691528,
0.2340536117553711,
0.2687740623950958,
-0.7859357595443726,
0.18562781810760498,
0.1167733445763588,
0.45373696088790894,
0.14705224335193634,
0.20338502526283264,
0.656969428062439,
0.12146466225385666,
0.9621922373771667,
-0.2005859613418579,
-0.43209221959114075,
0.5721369981765747,
-0.49488988518714905,
0.5707893967628479,
0.6286957263946533,
0.46816983819007874,
-0.8828364610671997,
-0.6523582339286804,
-0.4138222634792328,
-0.6594935655593872,
0.6221212148666382,
0.032276079058647156,
0.4463348984718323,
-0.05666354298591614,
0.6066750288009644,
0.34180817008018494,
0.09818645566701889,
-0.6677671670913696,
0.0358874648809433,
-0.09923145174980164,
-0.3701302707195282,
0.038637854158878326,
-0.2575662434101105,
-0.10448615252971649,
-0.022335167974233627,
0.5084740519523621,
-0.3953101634979248,
-0.05280599370598793,
0.16483727097511292,
-0.22380229830741882,
-0.10718077421188354,
0.5257188677787781,
0.3868366479873657,
0.6917696595191956,
-0.0683896392583847,
0.0032432000152766705,
0.6747580170631409,
-0.3692934215068817,
0.26926228404045105,
0.015122013166546822,
-0.3328331708908081,
-0.28687524795532227,
0.35535719990730286,
0.4558016359806061,
-0.06378383934497833,
-0.8428141474723816,
0.29828792810440063,
-0.12137569487094879,
-0.038641463965177536,
-0.4377610981464386,
0.1678827553987503,
0.012740331701934338,
0.2127106636762619,
0.37745946645736694,
-0.4938063323497772,
-0.22315675020217896,
-0.4294673204421997,
0.06295150518417358,
0.27370429039001465,
0.1542321741580963,
-0.2560621500015259,
0.5812227725982666,
0.45977842807769775,
0.44498494267463684,
0.8636768460273743,
-0.11057910323143005,
-0.4048815071582794,
0.6874266862869263,
0.337873637676239,
0.61476069688797,
-0.18214179575443268,
0.32600775361061096,
0.5147078037261963,
0.2706592082977295,
0.15095029771327972,
0.5762103199958801,
-0.17494052648544312,
-0.8499124646186829,
-0.6097853183746338,
-0.607215404510498,
-0.5392512679100037,
0.15443463623523712,
-0.7128457427024841,
-0.006547735072672367,
-0.30462658405303955,
0.0555548369884491,
-0.578413188457489,
0.2942502498626709,
-0.9478227496147156,
0.30992501974105835,
0.08596298098564148,
0.6330728530883789,
-1.2179161310195923,
0.7777020931243896,
0.8690134882926941,
-0.6063792705535889,
-0.8803175687789917,
0.014653203077614307,
-0.21583674848079681,
-0.924608588218689,
0.805302619934082,
-0.04179928079247475,
0.18253695964813232,
-0.06610508263111115,
-0.4368809759616852,
-1.0311602354049683,
1.3459768295288086,
0.29420438408851624,
-0.2620355784893036,
0.21669410169124603,
0.7369232773780823,
0.8260998725891113,
-0.09101743251085281,
0.18364763259887695,
0.6175761222839355,
0.5261735916137695,
0.15127263963222504,
-0.9146662354469299,
0.17568626999855042,
-0.2186163365840912,
0.16729064285755157,
-0.15512070059776306,
-0.6453941464424133,
0.45696043968200684,
-0.22513103485107422,
-0.3324240446090698,
0.1459314525127411,
0.8474019169807434,
0.45333176851272583,
0.21476590633392334,
0.4587650001049042,
0.45779097080230713,
0.8785564303398132,
-0.16303305327892303,
1.051602840423584,
-0.10469495505094528,
-0.17054736614227295,
0.8010059595108032,
-0.38106295466423035,
0.7171056270599365,
0.43247419595718384,
-0.09843627363443375,
0.20541469752788544,
0.717628002166748,
0.04448823630809784,
0.07646357268095016,
0.27966615557670593,
-0.10712762922048569,
-0.10504093021154404,
-0.3236108422279358,
-0.3650074005126953,
0.5552566647529602,
0.20297124981880188,
-0.04686637967824936,
-0.07079300284385681,
0.011670966632664204,
0.23190806806087494,
-0.023171795532107353,
-0.19515778124332428,
0.9660478234291077,
-0.08870475739240646,
-0.7653929591178894,
0.8825397491455078,
-0.12938091158866882,
0.6461349725723267,
-0.4251457154750824,
0.08707531541585922,
-0.8990806341171265,
-0.2270786166191101,
-0.2427544891834259,
-0.8990268111228943,
0.2233719825744629,
0.41693824529647827,
0.17303375899791718,
-0.0759308859705925,
0.5127866268157959,
-0.6829899549484253,
-0.5207790732383728,
-0.4050596058368683,
0.7576173543930054,
0.3640822470188141,
0.21742278337478638,
-0.4687984585762024,
-0.11286374181509018,
-0.05228690057992935,
-0.19627264142036438,
0.19263415038585663,
0.5946603417396545,
-0.34883561730384827,
0.5996911525726318,
0.8583255410194397,
0.3779400587081909,
0.1353980004787445,
0.03788096830248833,
0.6524859070777893,
-0.7414788007736206,
-0.4007440209388733,
-0.2914397418498993,
0.3173312246799469,
-0.09726154804229736,
-0.5000330805778503,
0.713817298412323,
0.2867503762245178,
1.1433604955673218,
-0.04390116035938263,
1.0053023099899292,
0.06060000881552696,
0.3938455283641815,
-0.6875209808349609,
0.6544855237007141,
-0.6223205327987671,
0.278525173664093,
-0.17042537033557892,
-1.0536338090896606,
-0.17413011193275452,
0.3227500915527344,
-0.44845378398895264,
0.19554489850997925,
0.40394389629364014,
0.9765070080757141,
0.01131229568272829,
0.025764450430870056,
0.36524301767349243,
0.23130156099796295,
0.4068031907081604,
0.775215744972229,
0.935994029045105,
-0.1821189820766449,
0.6359309554100037,
-0.2262597382068634,
-0.1684749573469162,
0.07366912811994553,
-0.6515541672706604,
-0.9696148633956909,
-0.6146069169044495,
-0.21227285265922546,
-0.035626620054244995,
0.044353317469358444,
0.8753948211669922,
0.22899019718170166,
-0.7815540432929993,
-0.35758480429649353,
0.335815966129303,
0.06576569378376007,
-0.18293412029743195,
-0.24424098432064056,
0.5886560082435608,
-0.32590243220329285,
-0.8273183107376099,
0.17463137209415436,
-0.061966802924871445,
0.1343817561864853,
-0.42556190490722656,
-0.045773398131132126,
0.00636346684768796,
0.04384703189134598,
0.37652644515037537,
0.5292453765869141,
-0.6391836404800415,
-0.32557207345962524,
0.08680343627929688,
-0.10807639360427856,
-0.1569056212902069,
0.7032754421234131,
-0.8230885863304138,
0.3457658588886261,
0.5168256163597107,
0.9424269795417786,
0.3085786998271942,
-0.03328848257660866,
0.6921511292457581,
-0.7974727749824524,
0.10631927102804184,
0.24087874591350555,
0.1341245025396347,
0.5917800068855286,
-0.2734231948852539,
0.6256406307220459,
0.1503322869539261,
-0.39889904856681824,
-0.6241534352302551,
0.24747733771800995,
-0.604333221912384,
-0.1113685593008995,
1.5619059801101685,
-0.029856916517019272,
-0.29139918088912964,
-0.21473382413387299,
-0.13622340559959412,
0.18272903561592102,
-0.11588288843631744,
0.9771052598953247,
0.5905896425247192,
-0.035689808428287506,
-0.1473078727722168,
-0.47882556915283203,
0.5894118547439575,
0.6143803000450134,
-1.1152578592300415,
0.08885916322469711,
0.5472733974456787,
0.5342792272567749,
-0.21450388431549072,
0.5794583559036255,
-0.10371187329292297,
0.5564804077148438,
-0.41379088163375854,
-0.13335150480270386,
-0.1568017303943634,
0.19031669199466705,
-0.283427894115448,
-0.011756657622754574,
0.25710099935531616,
0.08659538626670837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18926v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18926v2
|
XMoE: Sparse Models with Fine-grained and Adaptive Expert Selection
| 2024-02-27T08:18:02 | 2024-05-24T10:14:55 |
Yuanhang Yang, Shiyi Qi, Wenchao Gu, Chaozheng Wang, Cuiyun Gao, Zenglin Xu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Sparse models, including sparse Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) models, have emerged
as an effective approach for scaling Transformer models. However, they often
suffer from computational inefficiency since a significant number of parameters
are unnecessarily involved in computations via multiplying values by zero or
low activation values. To address this issue, we present \tool, a novel MoE
designed to enhance both the efficacy and efficiency of sparse MoE models.
\tool leverages small experts and a threshold-based router to enable tokens to
selectively engage only essential parameters. Our extensive experiments on
language modeling and machine translation tasks demonstrate that \tool can
enhance model performance while decreasing the computation load at MoE layers
by over 50\% without sacrificing performance. Furthermore, we present the
versatility of \tool by applying it to dense models, enabling sparse
computation during inference. We provide a comprehensive analysis and make our
code available at https://github.com/ysngki/XMoE.
|
[
-0.7040765285491943,
-0.6682841181755066,
0.3839142918586731,
0.15247507393360138,
-0.13110385835170746,
-0.15550605952739716,
-0.23504650592803955,
-0.2157396525144577,
0.3582695722579956,
0.39907601475715637,
-0.649498701095581,
-0.022911831736564636,
-0.7360799908638,
-0.11246523261070251,
-0.3884187340736389,
0.7218378782272339,
0.3227193057537079,
0.05262969806790352,
-0.13749182224273682,
-0.13754300773143768,
-0.5864888429641724,
0.25743070244789124,
-0.8276238441467285,
-0.3090285360813141,
0.42948129773139954,
0.577542781829834,
1.0216504335403442,
0.6785556674003601,
0.40707525610923767,
0.45100805163383484,
0.08742726594209671,
0.15492212772369385,
-0.7158031463623047,
0.3128322958946228,
-0.2622119188308716,
-0.6351584196090698,
-0.7698357701301575,
-0.12641166150569916,
0.5875113606452942,
0.7723641395568848,
-0.10767759382724762,
0.09328821301460266,
0.13538303971290588,
0.24652457237243652,
-0.651561975479126,
0.03204391524195671,
-1.1532840728759766,
-0.24124722182750702,
-0.09798342734575272,
-0.07333899289369583,
-0.5421807169914246,
0.1603737622499466,
0.1658545732498169,
-0.7488120198249817,
0.46405571699142456,
0.19286508858203888,
0.7729750871658325,
0.6612284183502197,
-0.33675238490104675,
0.20747371017932892,
-0.45397135615348816,
1.107487678527832,
-0.5591183304786682,
0.4393584728240967,
0.363142728805542,
0.3379005193710327,
-0.07383418083190918,
-0.7361114025115967,
-0.28872838616371155,
-0.13114924728870392,
-0.04251349717378616,
0.010473597794771194,
-0.3238942325115204,
0.19573970139026642,
0.17947256565093994,
0.3534708023071289,
-0.2006223052740097,
0.19771231710910797,
-0.2352059930562973,
-0.04007415845990181,
0.6500189900398254,
0.4757271409034729,
-0.019685938954353333,
-0.30831989645957947,
-0.2520867884159088,
-0.05215230956673622,
-0.3782084882259369,
-0.10073362290859222,
0.1476546972990036,
0.16483737528324127,
0.028840146958827972,
0.2697780132293701,
-0.14779888093471527,
0.6391971707344055,
0.2997840940952301,
-0.20144884288311005,
0.0893217921257019,
0.01901530846953392,
-0.2523658275604248,
-0.36180925369262695,
0.918960690498352,
0.2059318870306015,
-0.15879829227924347,
-0.34410393238067627,
-0.392905592918396,
-0.4087602496147156,
0.4081917107105255,
-0.9872137904167175,
-0.5124574303627014,
0.049247968941926956,
-0.28989291191101074,
-0.4858689308166504,
-0.05540631711483002,
-0.9892515540122986,
-0.31837764382362366,
-0.05133180692791939,
0.7096447348594666,
-0.29112061858177185,
-0.3016597330570221,
0.11012742668390274,
-0.27464234828948975,
-0.4257662296295166,
0.4440983533859253,
-0.9866443276405334,
0.4735744893550873,
0.46210092306137085,
0.905951738357544,
-0.07827585935592651,
-0.07419745624065399,
-0.641788125038147,
-0.037368807941675186,
-0.2795826494693756,
0.6598119139671326,
-0.811180591583252,
-0.7705590128898621,
-0.5447782874107361,
-0.1918805092573166,
-0.279634952545166,
-0.5248450636863708,
0.7199549078941345,
-0.5443404316902161,
-0.1465359628200531,
-0.034945592284202576,
-0.41779813170433044,
-0.3283383250236511,
-0.09122923761606216,
-0.8951274156570435,
1.359678030014038,
0.5449947714805603,
-0.47835373878479004,
0.5676626563072205,
-0.7996670603752136,
-0.22397448122501373,
0.013601097278296947,
-0.1028798446059227,
-0.411493718624115,
0.4193878471851349,
0.24866728484630585,
0.6524232029914856,
-0.5088761448860168,
0.03889792039990425,
-0.5466321110725403,
-0.2412179857492447,
0.03632252663373947,
-0.7555500268936157,
0.6866669058799744,
0.08661643415689468,
-0.33078932762145996,
0.43800681829452515,
-1.0502201318740845,
0.01039374340325594,
-0.009251601062715054,
-0.10693737119436264,
-0.5018263459205627,
0.11430267244577408,
0.1393694132566452,
0.15023984014987946,
0.04329916089773178,
-0.5912222862243652,
0.39534425735473633,
-0.38406556844711304,
0.5811165571212769,
0.8551482558250427,
-0.12142352014780045,
0.7590648531913757,
-0.37321850657463074,
0.5236406922340393,
-0.23488730192184448,
0.004342102445662022,
-0.11689364165067673,
-0.6624011993408203,
-0.9365647435188293,
-0.8368418216705322,
0.5960987210273743,
0.4203486442565918,
-0.7358442544937134,
0.5117965340614319,
-0.53462153673172,
-0.8024380207061768,
-0.9014827013015747,
0.4071034789085388,
0.08649716526269913,
0.4636223614215851,
0.39771121740341187,
-0.03388429060578346,
-0.3565736413002014,
-0.7986089587211609,
0.09407895058393478,
0.15831005573272705,
-0.5184539556503296,
0.4975036382675171,
0.3146577775478363,
-0.213981494307518,
1.2560309171676636,
-0.6546311378479004,
-0.3658491373062134,
-0.3180634379386902,
0.27417439222335815,
0.024747036397457123,
0.7334792613983154,
0.6899164319038391,
-0.7653035521507263,
-0.646609365940094,
0.2925368845462799,
-0.3642425835132599,
-0.4109397232532501,
-0.2477182000875473,
-0.15294893085956573,
-0.36217963695526123,
0.3826039135456085,
-0.5772657990455627,
0.1589699238538742,
0.6201843619346619,
-0.12603813409805298,
0.16595125198364258,
-0.14084896445274353,
0.03602033108472824,
-1.008604884147644,
-0.11231682449579239,
0.1222429946064949,
-0.5643599033355713,
-0.36464470624923706,
0.24564270675182343,
0.23045416176319122,
-0.05422041937708855,
-0.22846069931983948,
0.8681844472885132,
-0.38395681977272034,
0.3812304437160492,
-0.27553942799568176,
-0.011003420688211918,
0.06366994231939316,
0.5558266639709473,
-0.05713862553238869,
0.92020583152771,
0.7258114814758301,
-0.20783869922161102,
0.02721342444419861,
0.09042779356241226,
-0.31652823090553284,
0.4036940038204193,
-0.7907537221908569,
0.03836686536669731,
0.26762688159942627,
-0.2540191411972046,
-0.8475229740142822,
-0.2929884195327759,
0.17456625401973724,
-0.30767714977264404,
0.46390482783317566,
-0.35584011673927307,
-0.5149835348129272,
-0.08523796498775482,
-0.4085192084312439,
0.40939024090766907,
0.6776605248451233,
-0.18687748908996582,
1.1552146673202515,
0.4210434854030609,
-0.33366408944129944,
-0.1485299915075302,
-0.478413850069046,
0.037156589329242706,
-0.03179684281349182,
-0.9416187405586243,
0.26705098152160645,
-0.21327854692935944,
-0.16058450937271118,
0.08801764249801636,
-0.03920096531510353,
-0.6360117197036743,
0.30445513129234314,
0.2774916887283325,
0.16877365112304688,
-0.40437713265419006,
-0.1998421549797058,
0.6845108270645142,
-0.4292605221271515,
0.10719974339008331,
-0.11667371541261673,
0.3437473475933075,
0.12401020526885986,
-0.4435012638568878,
-0.284699410200119,
0.4757407307624817,
0.7476204633712769,
-0.07383731752634048,
0.5953521728515625,
0.5858505368232727,
-0.19207708537578583,
-0.41905584931373596,
-0.6926049590110779,
-0.27974453568458557,
-0.5792089700698853,
0.644174337387085,
-0.503210186958313,
-0.7741143107414246,
0.35636916756629944,
-0.04636308550834656,
0.2916661202907562,
0.46364858746528625,
0.683769941329956,
0.34270867705345154,
1.4277050495147705,
0.8190110325813293,
-0.21272318065166473,
0.5466164350509644,
-0.3336455225944519,
0.10149512439966202,
-0.7060791254043579,
0.11918172240257263,
-0.42867109179496765,
-0.4598575830459595,
-0.2143564671278,
-0.7304272651672363,
0.701282262802124,
-0.08441463112831116,
0.3037382960319519,
0.2876330018043518,
-0.3785500228404999,
0.4625575840473175,
0.6007949709892273,
0.1401243358850479,
0.2005799412727356,
-0.055146533995866776,
0.025630664080381393,
-0.028694989159703255,
-1.199842929840088,
-0.3487508296966553,
0.9086032509803772,
0.2903760075569153,
1.0078080892562866,
-0.27444738149642944,
0.2722024917602539,
0.2414536029100418,
0.27126559615135193,
-0.875369668006897,
0.6064891815185547,
-0.13618089258670807,
-0.894990086555481,
-0.5144861936569214,
-0.43284621834754944,
-0.7823847532272339,
0.6308652758598328,
-0.3180089592933655,
-0.6518571376800537,
0.5537026524543762,
0.20811393857002258,
-0.7232449054718018,
0.5940341949462891,
-0.9101965427398682,
0.7629226446151733,
0.269132524728775,
-0.489622563123703,
-0.45591455698013306,
-0.46588659286499023,
0.2307971715927124,
-0.5704233050346375,
-0.07189210504293442,
-0.1633845567703247,
-0.3303132951259613,
0.5416659712791443,
-0.6545579433441162,
0.8566150665283203,
-0.14828112721443176,
0.10426215082406998,
0.2662871181964874,
0.3583065867424011,
0.5616778135299683,
0.3137877881526947,
-0.6202691197395325,
0.29516229033470154,
-0.15163807570934296,
-0.5800800919532776,
-0.740215539932251,
0.7435979247093201,
-0.7283040285110474,
-0.622072160243988,
0.24735620617866516,
-1.1820210218429565,
-0.1422184258699417,
0.44776079058647156,
0.30132773518562317,
0.47762224078178406,
0.11191964149475098,
0.6212761402130127,
0.7450318336486816,
0.3551194667816162,
0.1319134682416916,
0.3695952594280243,
0.21124178171157837,
-0.3084796369075775,
1.053293228149414,
0.5339025259017944,
0.3120790123939514,
0.38284778594970703,
0.23423737287521362,
0.22540560364723206,
-0.5829214453697205,
-0.6300686001777649,
-0.17293794453144073,
-0.5967552661895752,
-0.40724629163742065,
-0.9162464141845703,
-0.03936605900526047,
-0.0242011696100235,
-0.6592922210693359,
-0.4334595501422882,
-0.5824571847915649,
-0.33678072690963745,
0.04711685702204704,
0.27002444863319397,
0.5205435156822205,
0.05662538856267929,
0.7368251085281372,
-0.8967434167861938,
0.3419364094734192,
0.4099421501159668,
0.24451671540737152,
0.2408081591129303,
-0.4966144263744354,
-0.3862701654434204,
0.021037651225924492,
-0.36423736810684204,
-0.44358548521995544,
0.21409209072589874,
0.19467772543430328,
0.6304363012313843,
0.8365630507469177,
0.2133021056652069,
0.7746334075927734,
-0.5038252472877502,
0.5492962002754211,
-0.06887855380773544,
-1.0731201171875,
0.09350094944238663,
-0.32270514965057373,
-0.015705090016126633,
0.4608568549156189,
0.3162234127521515,
0.04820674657821655,
-0.6758095622062683,
-0.627382755279541,
-0.8859910368919373,
0.7122493982315063,
0.3304167091846466,
0.36041051149368286,
0.060033880174160004,
0.11355052888393402,
0.4991948902606964,
0.0797148197889328,
-0.3389050364494324,
-0.10244689136743546,
-0.07340525090694427,
-0.13957452774047852,
0.3567725419998169,
-0.5129507184028625,
0.0192494485527277,
-0.35726192593574524,
0.8326535224914551,
-0.1679248958826065,
0.04220738634467125,
0.014283118769526482,
-0.20463500916957855,
-0.4607948064804077,
0.03041829727590084,
0.3191874921321869,
0.523747980594635,
-0.1751183271408081,
-0.12344563752412796,
0.7247925400733948,
-0.5005849003791809,
-0.01827351376414299,
0.15165071189403534,
-0.33768460154533386,
0.19380693137645721,
0.38426437973976135,
0.8747004866600037,
0.7707085609436035,
-0.49859926104545593,
0.5531957745552063,
-0.02040356956422329,
-0.34146353602409363,
0.1362614631652832,
0.5764548182487488,
-0.22100301086902618,
0.179932102560997,
0.4109886884689331,
0.8189763426780701,
0.23486368358135223,
0.32754239439964294,
0.1585112065076828,
0.4514593482017517,
-0.495019793510437,
-0.46579498052597046,
0.9199702143669128,
0.6297179460525513,
-0.15674708783626556,
0.3829208314418793,
-0.3239133059978485,
-0.032676368951797485,
0.3834531605243683,
0.1372555047273636,
0.8967818021774292,
-0.14525845646858215,
-0.22772538661956787,
0.00451496010646224,
0.4264656603336334,
0.1286548525094986,
-0.12731687724590302,
-0.18156374990940094,
-0.5683247447013855,
-0.5709166526794434,
-0.31365519762039185,
-0.2460583597421646,
-0.1624349057674408,
-0.6378549337387085,
0.6228342056274414,
-0.3670872151851654,
-0.24422955513000488,
0.028823064640164375,
-0.0863516554236412,
-0.5645920634269714,
0.07850539684295654,
-0.30622366070747375,
1.3712248802185059,
-0.8240237236022949,
0.9637042880058289,
0.5132359266281128,
-0.15359921753406525,
-0.6809747219085693,
-0.24851873517036438,
-0.06122434139251709,
-0.7883336544036865,
0.3785887658596039,
-0.1825181543827057,
-0.2132214903831482,
0.3878117501735687,
-0.29361599683761597,
-0.7502722144126892,
1.0110093355178833,
0.5535692572593689,
-0.47326162457466125,
0.015325111337006092,
-0.17829565703868866,
0.14698325097560883,
-0.07657702267169952,
0.6466168165206909,
0.2909599244594574,
0.5679805874824524,
0.10358116775751114,
-0.9431416988372803,
-0.13433337211608887,
-0.39081940054893494,
-0.032438162714242935,
0.47564369440078735,
-0.6039615273475647,
0.981089174747467,
-0.06920964270830154,
0.13635113835334778,
0.37191712856292725,
0.9326265454292297,
-0.1730363965034485,
0.06829681992530823,
0.9562065601348877,
0.43750134110450745,
0.6924082636833191,
0.100383460521698,
0.9751825332641602,
-0.5608636736869812,
0.5312239527702332,
0.8175775408744812,
-0.17078539729118347,
0.6747085452079773,
0.3313165307044983,
-0.11548677086830139,
0.39038315415382385,
0.3255799114704132,
-0.233012855052948,
0.3446420431137085,
-0.36118680238723755,
-0.3033933937549591,
-0.6139222383499146,
0.08705775439739227,
-0.1214282363653183,
0.1437077522277832,
0.3433178961277008,
-0.21525931358337402,
-0.4254494607448578,
0.10027451813220978,
0.13824628293514252,
-0.30691519379615784,
-0.47120949625968933,
0.5716889500617981,
-0.02796078659594059,
-0.3143887221813202,
0.44624584913253784,
0.09075692296028137,
0.7308241128921509,
-0.9400414228439331,
0.01176047045737505,
0.09326839447021484,
0.16454064846038818,
-0.2927452623844147,
-0.5969734787940979,
0.18257750570774078,
-0.29333987832069397,
-0.5994452834129333,
-0.12690778076648712,
0.8989397287368774,
-0.25937619805336,
-0.8940094709396362,
0.10531563311815262,
0.44196850061416626,
-0.1281203031539917,
-0.35690611600875854,
-0.6517025232315063,
-0.1150049939751625,
-0.12331973016262054,
-0.5707996487617493,
0.30845317244529724,
0.8660697340965271,
-0.23898103833198547,
1.0114668607711792,
0.6722605228424072,
0.10085609555244446,
0.36592957377433777,
-0.1374383568763733,
1.1287758350372314,
-0.14512194693088531,
-0.48329660296440125,
-0.6888399124145508,
0.9029297232627869,
-0.1346898227930069,
-0.26877790689468384,
0.919711172580719,
0.36977988481521606,
0.7838292121887207,
-0.19567936658859253,
0.6990805268287659,
-0.293572336435318,
0.3353784680366516,
-0.3007436692714691,
0.7509357929229736,
-0.70902419090271,
0.1537700593471527,
-0.28102046251296997,
-0.688582181930542,
-0.3307529091835022,
0.4931005835533142,
-0.36642858386039734,
0.17674914002418518,
0.43370917439460754,
1.0687543153762817,
-0.5363726615905762,
-0.2010556161403656,
0.7458291053771973,
0.3417302072048187,
0.20213593542575836,
0.08289998769760132,
0.4001867175102234,
-0.33299848437309265,
0.7417349219322205,
-0.5088003277778625,
-0.38031452894210815,
-0.49927565455436707,
-0.7682576179504395,
-1.0241529941558838,
-0.397413432598114,
-0.26334118843078613,
0.14474093914031982,
-0.4688679277896881,
1.2922306060791016,
1.4083000421524048,
-0.7334159016609192,
-0.07722734659910202,
0.030177809298038483,
0.2935229539871216,
-0.3859497904777527,
-0.20732861757278442,
-0.007569190580397844,
-0.56305992603302,
-1.046109914779663,
0.4558505117893219,
0.3485115170478821,
-0.466081827878952,
-0.3386726677417755,
-0.046757686883211136,
0.3428201675415039,
0.2511844038963318,
0.6675865650177002,
-0.25776320695877075,
-0.6266530752182007,
-0.15737026929855347,
-0.08212728053331375,
0.07943249493837357,
0.12507887184619904,
0.8883411884307861,
-0.7646302580833435,
0.5305637717247009,
0.7344815135002136,
0.7711012959480286,
0.037320006638765335,
-0.21560846269130707,
0.5802505016326904,
-0.7492029666900635,
0.3453010320663452,
0.13737374544143677,
0.7204293608665466,
-0.09257836639881134,
-0.48676276206970215,
0.41292622685432434,
0.33744484186172485,
-0.6450932025909424,
-0.9339393973350525,
-0.11301873624324799,
-1.1146066188812256,
-0.24334999918937683,
0.9036460518836975,
-0.012173520401120186,
-0.2024749517440796,
-0.26474571228027344,
-0.7513214349746704,
-0.2094038724899292,
-0.7672858238220215,
0.7268297076225281,
0.5503215193748474,
0.21493443846702576,
-0.14730417728424072,
-0.780735433101654,
0.0013403644552454352,
0.625347912311554,
-0.41240179538726807,
-0.08744309097528458,
0.10037493705749512,
0.3164186179637909,
0.16457366943359375,
0.2676193416118622,
0.2410067766904831,
0.29469335079193115,
0.25948604941368103,
-0.00873623602092266,
-0.36036217212677,
-0.21683542430400848,
-0.09654015302658081,
0.3201034665107727,
0.2580243647098541,
0.005746600683778524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00825v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00825v1
|
Comparing effectiveness of regularization methods on text classification: Simple and complex model in data shortage situation
| 2024-02-27T07:26:16 | 2024-02-27T07:26:16 |
Jongga Lee, Jaeseung Yim, Seohee Park, Changwon Lim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text classification is the task of assigning a document to a predefined
class. However, it is expensive to acquire enough labeled documents or to label
them. In this paper, we study the regularization methods' effects on various
classification models when only a few labeled data are available. We compare a
simple word embedding-based model, which is simple but effective, with complex
models (CNN and BiLSTM). In supervised learning, adversarial training can
further regularize the model. When an unlabeled dataset is available, we can
regularize the model using semi-supervised learning methods such as the Pi
model and virtual adversarial training. We evaluate the regularization effects
on four text classification datasets (AG news, DBpedia, Yahoo! Answers, Yelp
Polarity), using only 0.1% to 0.5% of the original labeled training documents.
The simple model performs relatively well in fully supervised learning, but
with the help of adversarial training and semi-supervised learning, both simple
and complex models can be regularized, showing better results for complex
models. Although the simple model is robust to overfitting, a complex model
with well-designed prior beliefs can be also robust to overfitting.
|
[
-0.20093747973442078,
-1.0385310649871826,
0.388062059879303,
0.1215054839849472,
-0.23398075997829437,
-0.02016170509159565,
-0.41002729535102844,
-0.472389280796051,
-0.21626324951648712,
0.20210963487625122,
0.10280633717775345,
-0.41076958179473877,
-0.7449108362197876,
0.18656687438488007,
-0.5283282399177551,
1.2004073858261108,
-0.055300913751125336,
0.3295828700065613,
-0.2852177917957306,
0.08777669817209244,
-0.326882004737854,
-0.7060685753822327,
-0.5065282583236694,
-0.3820699453353882,
0.41398489475250244,
0.25236615538597107,
0.7097168564796448,
0.6091877222061157,
0.7297602295875549,
0.32665714621543884,
-0.42217564582824707,
0.054247476160526276,
-0.5236205458641052,
-0.010225214995443821,
0.02322244644165039,
-0.6114669442176819,
-0.08252046257257462,
0.2924797832965851,
0.5649388432502747,
0.8639578223228455,
0.006326506845653057,
-0.0857657864689827,
0.2699734568595886,
0.6011039018630981,
-0.744439959526062,
-0.05529073253273964,
-0.3988949656486511,
0.09109239280223846,
-0.164520725607872,
0.09397855401039124,
-0.245258629322052,
-0.33416852355003357,
0.42323705554008484,
-0.489482045173645,
0.6182905435562134,
0.21860161423683167,
1.0560518503189087,
0.351048082113266,
-0.5813201069831848,
-0.5569641590118408,
-1.23108971118927,
0.8031174540519714,
-0.6119765639305115,
0.3534747064113617,
0.4143649935722351,
0.1289183497428894,
-0.1584635227918625,
-0.9041372537612915,
-0.5023313760757446,
-0.2547696530818939,
-0.06376446038484573,
0.4189046323299408,
-0.24268051981925964,
0.21629922091960907,
0.378286749124527,
0.4952510595321655,
-0.45320072770118713,
0.13665440678596497,
-0.6108407974243164,
-0.14196044206619263,
0.4270940124988556,
-0.18857760727405548,
0.21979793906211853,
-0.04589354619383812,
-0.5951767563819885,
-0.16935575008392334,
-0.33224231004714966,
0.1003781333565712,
0.4243793487548828,
0.30147144198417664,
0.1307147890329361,
0.7810947895050049,
-0.10305093973875046,
0.931220531463623,
-0.06508522480726242,
-0.21874231100082397,
-0.07995633780956268,
-0.5456650257110596,
-0.533416211605072,
0.13072365522384644,
0.6545109152793884,
0.21002979576587677,
0.3230378031730652,
-0.1432855874300003,
-0.19588801264762878,
0.29854264855384827,
0.21456027030944824,
-0.7039059996604919,
-0.42026737332344055,
-0.02689974009990692,
-0.49353140592575073,
-0.3782529830932617,
0.3145732879638672,
-0.6252735257148743,
-0.48464012145996094,
-0.32454395294189453,
0.553360641002655,
-0.0627153068780899,
0.31968817114830017,
0.38402101397514343,
-0.3589918613433838,
-0.1138024851679802,
0.635502815246582,
-0.6086591482162476,
0.2849496006965637,
0.3815092444419861,
0.8981632590293884,
-0.13061290979385376,
-0.024985725060105324,
-0.3160744607448578,
-0.004845024086534977,
-0.32531049847602844,
0.8176631331443787,
-0.3927004039287567,
-0.26474568247795105,
0.060362137854099274,
-0.09013718366622925,
-0.11376354098320007,
-0.4412241280078888,
0.9250999093055725,
-0.4223106801509857,
0.4567808210849762,
-0.005554082337766886,
-0.7477585077285767,
-0.29631906747817993,
0.4526918828487396,
-0.7589104771614075,
0.8784804344177246,
-0.22377504408359528,
-1.097555160522461,
0.25900334119796753,
-0.32408058643341064,
-0.4279322922229767,
-0.19366955757141113,
-0.0011363638332113624,
-0.7842965722084045,
-0.010632888413965702,
-0.009622165001928806,
0.741771399974823,
-0.44282105565071106,
0.07739651948213577,
-0.4541451334953308,
-0.5058974623680115,
0.28483766317367554,
-0.5758926868438721,
0.6558076739311218,
0.1285056620836258,
-0.28864648938179016,
-0.26489830017089844,
-0.6978371143341064,
-0.11851909756660461,
0.15690502524375916,
-0.7802829742431641,
-0.7132222056388855,
-0.0423763208091259,
0.3062821626663208,
0.010198038071393967,
0.15951167047023773,
-0.6961831450462341,
0.41259872913360596,
-0.4801945686340332,
0.1983073502779007,
0.4475761353969574,
0.10431304574012756,
0.5536216497421265,
-0.34496182203292847,
0.24720655381679535,
0.06698592007160187,
0.10285795480012894,
0.06749236583709717,
-0.5594475269317627,
-0.8893692493438721,
-0.44764840602874756,
0.954138457775116,
0.6453613042831421,
-0.4569806456565857,
0.22251959145069122,
-0.09979166835546494,
-0.588663637638092,
-0.3697333037853241,
0.03571433946490288,
0.4272872507572174,
0.3193216919898987,
0.3337918519973755,
0.014205016195774078,
-0.15812727808952332,
-0.9197501540184021,
-0.30747997760772705,
0.1077369749546051,
-0.14257679879665375,
-0.005412916652858257,
0.5043588876724243,
-0.35587555170059204,
0.9339820146560669,
-0.5847012400627136,
-0.5446662306785583,
-0.20033009350299835,
0.2490881234407425,
-0.2989714741706848,
0.47430962324142456,
0.6017718315124512,
-1.1019763946533203,
-0.586227297782898,
0.06306049972772598,
-0.5403645634651184,
0.12451447546482086,
-0.27798858284950256,
0.2237115502357483,
0.24602548778057098,
0.23026318848133087,
-0.4009131193161011,
0.8207127451896667,
0.3666198253631592,
-0.13823634386062622,
0.12767256796360016,
-0.44180452823638916,
-0.028814543038606644,
-0.8966699838638306,
-0.018966661766171455,
0.2041795402765274,
-0.3106379508972168,
-0.9878859519958496,
-0.3140883147716522,
0.15343077480793,
-0.29198452830314636,
-0.20314475893974304,
0.3327181041240692,
-0.5383898019790649,
0.07376385480165482,
-0.339486300945282,
0.20737634599208832,
0.21056276559829712,
0.3898954391479492,
0.05555441603064537,
0.3860054016113281,
0.44841718673706055,
-0.6379410624504089,
0.32162949442863464,
0.12229141592979431,
-0.15713055431842804,
0.02065822295844555,
-0.8070483207702637,
0.01968148723244667,
-0.3212388753890991,
0.22923049330711365,
-0.999242901802063,
-0.07916181534528732,
0.38303375244140625,
-0.25724780559539795,
0.6502901911735535,
-0.043296027928590775,
-0.6773801445960999,
-0.14529578387737274,
-0.49119919538497925,
0.020888006314635277,
0.22207647562026978,
-0.40589141845703125,
0.38647785782814026,
0.1831979751586914,
-0.1857156604528427,
-0.22232188284397125,
-0.691964328289032,
-0.0047598229721188545,
-0.040328819304704666,
-0.33013150095939636,
0.399152010679245,
-0.22268682718276978,
0.02379695326089859,
0.1825859695672989,
-0.2541351914405823,
-0.3012092411518097,
0.33770760893821716,
0.0607677698135376,
0.289482444524765,
0.04309705272316933,
0.3024613559246063,
0.22636795043945312,
-0.12724751234054565,
-0.29334184527397156,
-0.00419942382723093,
0.24037538468837738,
-0.2903195321559906,
-0.33465439081192017,
-0.44042113423347473,
0.32265767455101013,
0.469501793384552,
-0.2890629470348358,
0.8568318486213684,
0.5354034900665283,
-0.7229829430580139,
0.0028553432784974575,
-0.5141737461090088,
-0.07461045682430267,
-0.3736974895000458,
0.26556605100631714,
-0.031047973781824112,
-0.6614709496498108,
0.16021735966205597,
-0.3532365560531616,
-0.003900874638929963,
0.5506938099861145,
0.39944127202033997,
-0.24281376600265503,
1.2414158582687378,
0.7843906879425049,
0.0071594445034861565,
0.49703845381736755,
-0.44912612438201904,
0.31012964248657227,
-0.3958240747451782,
-0.4103109538555145,
-0.8341187238693237,
-0.29382237792015076,
-0.6499415636062622,
0.06381557881832123,
0.17625606060028076,
0.4528926908969879,
0.10268279910087585,
0.06431463360786438,
-0.6452884674072266,
0.2700921893119812,
0.7433004379272461,
0.20505787432193756,
0.35172805190086365,
0.24330836534500122,
0.2885570228099823,
-0.10793105512857437,
-1.0159919261932373,
-0.6789830923080444,
0.9219033718109131,
0.4013356864452362,
0.8363751173019409,
0.020442506298422813,
0.5393583178520203,
0.32789963483810425,
0.28783753514289856,
-0.9512879848480225,
0.0023816528264433146,
-0.23125262558460236,
-0.5156876444816589,
-0.2805634140968323,
-0.5501281023025513,
-1.086678147315979,
0.12927944958209991,
-0.8133144378662109,
-0.2466430962085724,
0.5506099462509155,
0.03313262015581131,
-0.38780784606933594,
0.2266189306974411,
-0.8598363399505615,
0.850919246673584,
-0.203364297747612,
0.08702277392148972,
-0.0037319085095077753,
-0.531309187412262,
0.10449913889169693,
-0.5174598097801208,
0.2587457001209259,
0.33101847767829895,
-0.1171051487326622,
1.085762619972229,
-0.2934384346008301,
0.9120880365371704,
0.058733925223350525,
0.27792689204216003,
0.22893796861171722,
-0.413943886756897,
0.6042622327804565,
-0.2876276671886444,
0.16381505131721497,
0.05948518589138985,
0.11036517471075058,
-0.5330288410186768,
-0.6533834338188171,
0.39554908871650696,
-0.8152862787246704,
-0.37938955426216125,
-0.6855801939964294,
-0.12474364787340164,
-0.036449745297431946,
0.45928171277046204,
0.7267646789550781,
0.5925487279891968,
-0.0400330126285553,
0.5862871408462524,
0.9964451193809509,
-0.08707519620656967,
0.3060924708843231,
0.3409518897533417,
0.1534978151321411,
-0.2690608501434326,
0.8935500383377075,
0.5648292899131775,
0.13931536674499512,
0.17972703278064728,
0.5132161378860474,
0.003940733615309,
-0.5966194272041321,
-0.1229807436466217,
0.16309215128421783,
-0.5562658309936523,
-0.4504692554473877,
-0.7259398102760315,
-0.32125192880630493,
-0.42118245363235474,
-0.13781937956809998,
-0.3937508463859558,
-0.354509562253952,
-0.5480523705482483,
0.016221629455685616,
0.053010426461696625,
0.8296937346458435,
0.2058153599500656,
0.39165952801704407,
-0.8445239663124084,
0.2605029344558716,
0.31290555000305176,
0.14663921296596527,
-0.1167641207575798,
-0.4934026896953583,
-0.4967489540576935,
0.17593473196029663,
-0.31697770953178406,
-1.0090950727462769,
0.04065833240747452,
0.17913763225078583,
0.42477548122406006,
0.5239766836166382,
0.45799726247787476,
0.4441205859184265,
-0.35324227809906006,
0.44494906067848206,
0.24171869456768036,
-0.6849919557571411,
0.4483354687690735,
-0.04133305698633194,
0.06567414849996567,
0.3996731638908386,
0.5761228203773499,
-0.3835587799549103,
-0.4643564522266388,
-0.692798912525177,
-0.6334617137908936,
0.6759771704673767,
0.6120367646217346,
-0.07220206409692764,
0.19661845266819,
0.3872314691543579,
-0.05835164338350296,
0.30631503462791443,
-0.6489698886871338,
-0.4460916519165039,
-0.18829567730426788,
-0.26113054156303406,
0.04811858758330345,
-0.4815492033958435,
-0.017540903761982918,
-0.11648846417665482,
0.6713332533836365,
0.41205307841300964,
0.21874012053012848,
0.40604615211486816,
-0.03851316496729851,
0.15726567804813385,
0.31858620047569275,
0.5917130708694458,
0.08520381897687912,
-0.1882125586271286,
0.19336076080799103,
0.0947876125574112,
-0.6249685883522034,
0.009846946224570274,
0.209275022149086,
-0.5353149771690369,
0.25489673018455505,
0.4925547242164612,
0.7201932072639465,
0.1404971033334732,
-0.3918960392475128,
0.7460810542106628,
-0.3013710677623749,
-0.12464957684278488,
-0.07954135537147522,
0.009097871370613575,
-0.16918620467185974,
0.29086458683013916,
0.2371128499507904,
0.4726141393184662,
0.40459030866622925,
-0.5008866190910339,
-0.1750337928533554,
0.26076260209083557,
-0.2618045210838318,
-0.042306218296289444,
0.4365362524986267,
0.041156377643346786,
-0.3330984115600586,
0.5143552422523499,
-0.1461009532213211,
-0.7543795704841614,
0.5988369584083557,
0.6359394192695618,
0.5204262137413025,
-0.0803857296705246,
0.09013251960277557,
0.19207704067230225,
0.4586661159992218,
-0.5748953223228455,
-0.164326474070549,
0.07624908536672592,
-0.5434879660606384,
-0.03833746537566185,
-0.3173139691352844,
-0.4116361737251282,
-0.03448142111301422,
-0.6647812724113464,
0.24608400464057922,
-0.4895375669002533,
-0.2965885400772095,
0.10879725962877274,
0.426098108291626,
-0.6248287558555603,
0.4202393591403961,
-0.05389919504523277,
0.8078628778457642,
-1.0593148469924927,
0.6724762916564941,
1.0426009893417358,
-0.37924444675445557,
-0.5718799233436584,
0.21548622846603394,
-0.16254840791225433,
0.03166581690311432,
0.3751767873764038,
0.18129712343215942,
-0.036397937685251236,
0.06763393431901932,
-0.680217444896698,
-0.7561720609664917,
0.8219066262245178,
0.1509471982717514,
-0.6287351846694946,
0.09851129353046417,
-0.058541156351566315,
0.8068966865539551,
0.03765854611992836,
-0.2643968462944031,
0.1371379941701889,
0.4259033799171448,
-0.07783978432416916,
-0.5821657776832581,
-0.25729233026504517,
-0.2058630883693695,
0.11311810463666916,
0.10837732255458832,
-0.5724610090255737,
0.6437657475471497,
-0.13219206035137177,
-0.5208246111869812,
0.026886530220508575,
0.48152798414230347,
-0.11356008797883987,
0.7336853742599487,
0.46008333563804626,
0.3341583013534546,
0.919801652431488,
-0.15511910617351532,
1.1107208728790283,
0.06368230283260345,
0.7796145677566528,
0.8128915429115295,
0.08003842830657959,
0.731619119644165,
0.09269110858440399,
-0.07695557922124863,
-0.056569043546915054,
0.8985283970832825,
-0.252819687128067,
0.5482101440429688,
0.1053621917963028,
-0.02738432213664055,
-0.2673504054546356,
-0.11903883516788483,
-0.30786964297294617,
0.2209715098142624,
0.1958431899547577,
-0.056026291102170944,
-0.3035900890827179,
0.5074718594551086,
0.18354398012161255,
0.11961294710636139,
-0.16697080433368683,
0.7200753688812256,
0.05652899667620659,
-0.1608574241399765,
0.33653318881988525,
0.5169268846511841,
0.5351237058639526,
-0.31665468215942383,
0.21460998058319092,
-0.25380057096481323,
0.22898811101913452,
-0.29075103998184204,
-0.47944939136505127,
0.183604896068573,
0.18577955663204193,
-0.5075933337211609,
0.04131597653031349,
1.0367274284362793,
-0.7912072539329529,
-0.6459353566169739,
0.11184568703174591,
0.23322701454162598,
0.1847904920578003,
-0.1382557898759842,
-0.6992852091789246,
-0.15813231468200684,
-0.0839870348572731,
-0.38936999440193176,
0.23736390471458435,
0.3325009047985077,
-0.08701103180646896,
0.6356602311134338,
0.6950250267982483,
0.10706210881471634,
0.1395362913608551,
-0.1291777491569519,
0.8269036412239075,
-0.35037603974342346,
-0.2962733805179596,
-0.7505555152893066,
0.17059950530529022,
-0.2396867871284485,
-0.09726687520742416,
0.8797139525413513,
0.6743422746658325,
0.8854385018348694,
-0.09036965668201447,
0.6119862198829651,
0.19109997153282166,
0.5524291396141052,
-0.4864034056663513,
0.6652250289916992,
-0.7230141758918762,
0.27165135741233826,
-0.25932714343070984,
-0.9941707253456116,
-0.6588448882102966,
0.6375851631164551,
-0.2810669541358948,
-0.046642154455184937,
0.6515675783157349,
0.3527064621448517,
-0.23186439275741577,
-0.000567461596801877,
0.21908290684223175,
0.1636728048324585,
0.08914478868246078,
0.019430775195360184,
0.7467408180236816,
-0.551082193851471,
0.6299912333488464,
-0.40470829606056213,
-0.4466613829135895,
-0.3333578109741211,
-0.5565964579582214,
-1.093679428100586,
-0.45152708888053894,
-0.5646775960922241,
-0.19121180474758148,
0.059589628130197525,
0.5870951414108276,
0.35311591625213623,
-0.5995665192604065,
0.3007369637489319,
0.010985065251588821,
0.2506297528743744,
-0.03565823659300804,
-0.2038443237543106,
0.6483347415924072,
-0.23421575129032135,
-0.8853910565376282,
0.05683470889925957,
0.03366468474268913,
0.6045554280281067,
0.00032968385494314134,
0.1825578361749649,
-0.22689035534858704,
0.06240133196115494,
0.5295495390892029,
0.15591934323310852,
-0.356582909822464,
-0.16709791123867035,
0.04889006167650223,
-0.5101163387298584,
-0.13816578686237335,
0.6306326985359192,
-0.41319042444229126,
0.6346201300621033,
0.6990010142326355,
0.8396268486976624,
0.49720391631126404,
0.2063160389661789,
0.2541126310825348,
-0.5541657209396362,
0.005554109811782837,
0.10020184516906738,
0.3048945665359497,
0.3205649256706238,
-0.49090296030044556,
0.4934844374656677,
0.41263216733932495,
-0.5530596971511841,
-0.916498601436615,
0.04661017283797264,
-0.8411610126495361,
-0.5328273773193359,
0.9812783598899841,
-0.28323447704315186,
0.0812501534819603,
-0.13948430120944977,
-0.39021036028862,
0.5643879175186157,
-0.12807485461235046,
0.9043731689453125,
0.7304768562316895,
0.1961868703365326,
0.21178211271762848,
-0.580527126789093,
0.4345959722995758,
0.3015928864479065,
-0.6375055313110352,
-0.22996942698955536,
0.35634517669677734,
0.0988549143075943,
0.31751176714897156,
0.2039744257926941,
0.28088146448135376,
0.02099967934191227,
-0.18547798693180084,
-0.1086646169424057,
-0.1384669840335846,
-0.6029666662216187,
-0.5316057801246643,
0.08165469020605087,
-0.17229457199573517,
-0.3115014433860779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17263v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17263v2
|
MELoRA: Mini-Ensemble Low-Rank Adapters for Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning
| 2024-02-27T07:14:12 | 2024-06-24T12:45:27 |
Pengjie Ren, Chengshun Shi, Shiguang Wu, Mengqi Zhang, Zhaochun Ren, Maarten de Rijke, Zhumin Chen, Jiahuan Pei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) is a popular method for tailoring
pre-trained large language models (LLMs), especially as the models' scale and
the diversity of tasks increase. Low-rank adaptation (LoRA) is based on the
idea that the adaptation process is intrinsically low-dimensional, i.e.,
significant model changes can be represented with relatively few parameters.
However, decreasing the rank encounters challenges with generalization errors
for specific tasks when compared to full-parameter fine-tuning. We present
MELoRA, a mini-ensemble low-rank adapters that uses fewer trainable parameters
while maintaining a higher rank, thereby offering improved performance
potential. The core idea is to freeze original pretrained weights and train a
group of mini LoRAs with only a small number of parameters. This can capture a
significant degree of diversity among mini LoRAs, thus promoting better
generalization ability. We conduct a theoretical analysis and empirical studies
on various NLP tasks. Our experimental results show that, compared to LoRA,
MELoRA achieves better performance with 8 times fewer trainable parameters on
natural language understanding tasks and 36 times fewer trainable parameters on
instruction following tasks, which demonstrates the effectiveness of MELoRA.
|
[
-0.5657891631126404,
-0.7251715660095215,
0.32769525051116943,
0.1319969743490219,
-0.3615417778491974,
0.03484392911195755,
-0.47403937578201294,
-0.38618823885917664,
0.17644092440605164,
0.36289241909980774,
-0.32370272278785706,
-0.6154725551605225,
-0.695812463760376,
0.2049512267112732,
-0.21096105873584747,
1.1431162357330322,
0.2520328164100647,
-0.3782809376716614,
0.07568832486867905,
-0.26288166642189026,
-0.3957182765007019,
-0.1761297732591629,
-1.021079182624817,
-0.06362496316432953,
0.897029459476471,
0.745999813079834,
0.5908020734786987,
0.46676379442214966,
0.45279359817504883,
0.2721122205257416,
-0.17533272504806519,
0.16330841183662415,
-0.6045093536376953,
0.09708922356367111,
-0.11648567765951157,
-0.878303050994873,
-0.7692012786865234,
-0.1138286367058754,
0.658301055431366,
0.615792989730835,
-0.17983487248420715,
0.4730978012084961,
0.162650004029274,
0.8240345120429993,
-0.855086088180542,
-0.1441267430782318,
-0.9224759340286255,
0.029314596205949783,
-0.26773637533187866,
-0.010813673958182335,
-0.24657349288463593,
-0.2767672836780548,
0.0635295882821083,
-0.8154484629631042,
0.06756774336099625,
0.21854303777217865,
0.5079147815704346,
0.6087066531181335,
-0.005272701848298311,
-0.00281909410841763,
-0.8478221893310547,
0.9193626046180725,
-1.0090776681900024,
-0.021201852709054947,
0.45496585965156555,
0.3994418680667877,
0.08549167215824127,
-0.4298718273639679,
-0.33881697058677673,
0.04097209498286247,
-0.07340534776449203,
0.01770617440342903,
-0.2914346754550934,
0.19122314453125,
0.20377618074417114,
0.406133770942688,
-0.4816756844520569,
0.45656684041023254,
-0.2169397622346878,
0.1539396047592163,
0.45539629459381104,
0.06941705197095871,
0.1415628045797348,
0.0868699923157692,
0.02472352609038353,
-0.07560573518276215,
-0.5760603547096252,
0.17189866304397583,
0.2660151422023773,
0.46299150586128235,
-0.29380571842193604,
0.3161875605583191,
-0.2259683758020401,
0.9173043370246887,
0.3171177804470062,
-0.37197938561439514,
-0.0940159484744072,
-0.1557846963405609,
-0.5608565211296082,
-0.11954858154058456,
0.47540268301963806,
-0.05219255015254021,
0.1335987001657486,
-0.0978754386305809,
-0.0939277932047844,
0.11736329644918442,
-0.03325999900698662,
-0.9337202906608582,
-0.5947930812835693,
-0.1145293265581131,
-0.5720610618591309,
-0.4597131609916687,
-0.29425254464149475,
-1.191956639289856,
-0.18323853611946106,
-0.2422085404396057,
0.766981840133667,
-0.31696125864982605,
0.15148432552814484,
-0.027145277708768845,
-0.10352226346731186,
0.16826951503753662,
0.6177082061767578,
-1.2896745204925537,
0.739902913570404,
0.280251145362854,
0.6886657476425171,
-0.3427376449108124,
-0.22833271324634552,
-0.855839192867279,
0.0341719426214695,
-0.12238394469022751,
0.8719460964202881,
-0.6549790501594543,
-0.23243407905101776,
-0.5075275897979736,
0.022349655628204346,
-0.6845938563346863,
-0.8119208216667175,
0.4913322627544403,
-0.5056800842285156,
0.15750573575496674,
-0.05936647951602936,
-0.198185995221138,
-0.03573751077055931,
0.08339369297027588,
-0.5058727264404297,
0.924932599067688,
0.15256758034229279,
-0.4745124280452728,
0.4336492419242859,
-1.0375069379806519,
-0.38340693712234497,
-0.20160697400569916,
0.02809603326022625,
-0.3477734327316284,
0.32866382598876953,
0.3988136053085327,
0.18112681806087494,
-0.2896132171154022,
-0.4711420238018036,
-0.3243686854839325,
-0.6284375190734863,
-0.14628556370735168,
-0.4278407692909241,
0.3980724513530731,
0.05456893891096115,
-0.3547917306423187,
0.04231363162398338,
-0.9076836705207825,
-0.15231414139270782,
0.004600750748068094,
-0.668722927570343,
-0.7171257138252258,
-0.03742258623242378,
-0.15232518315315247,
-0.11383624374866486,
0.28686878085136414,
-0.18294782936573029,
0.3347621262073517,
-0.7073708772659302,
0.39069870114326477,
0.8425115942955017,
-0.21090984344482422,
0.8523233532905579,
-0.4099911153316498,
0.6138153672218323,
-0.08910956978797913,
0.22082911431789398,
0.22401586174964905,
-0.6164771318435669,
-1.0435317754745483,
-0.5359063744544983,
0.6976500153541565,
0.5713710784912109,
-0.5437525510787964,
0.36351484060287476,
-0.18539956212043762,
-0.5507267117500305,
-0.6706423759460449,
0.6395359039306641,
0.2169254571199417,
0.3810823857784271,
0.38888251781463623,
0.07376942038536072,
-0.4212090075016022,
-0.9264359474182129,
-0.17755521833896637,
-0.04501543939113617,
-0.053426776081323624,
0.19664622843265533,
0.44915178418159485,
-0.3684011399745941,
0.8966030478477478,
-0.3271498382091522,
-0.2606344223022461,
-0.14545126259326935,
0.256896048784256,
0.5015543103218079,
0.4464997351169586,
0.981602132320404,
-0.5796048045158386,
-0.6861546635627747,
0.16726480424404144,
-0.29834651947021484,
-0.057265449315309525,
0.29559963941574097,
-0.2845994532108307,
0.10046903043985367,
0.20836754143238068,
-0.23751243948936462,
0.18895433843135834,
1.1339839696884155,
-0.23196198046207428,
0.10033901035785675,
-0.31710365414619446,
0.10708870738744736,
-0.9798570275306702,
0.07126597315073013,
-0.2272397130727768,
-0.3275734484195709,
-0.5614908337593079,
-0.17118893563747406,
-0.23091386258602142,
-0.12556825578212738,
-0.31108856201171875,
0.5768774747848511,
-0.18276171386241913,
-0.06836404651403427,
-0.3286254107952118,
0.038131892681121826,
0.03507380187511444,
0.6238617300987244,
-0.27552691102027893,
1.033746361732483,
0.3779173195362091,
-0.845310628414154,
0.009116312488913536,
0.2880900502204895,
-0.1458018273115158,
0.6197322010993958,
-0.38002902269363403,
0.3137826919555664,
-0.08871597796678543,
-0.2268589586019516,
-0.716987133026123,
-0.1464494913816452,
0.1512218862771988,
-0.025524236261844635,
0.06335213780403137,
-0.4147849977016449,
-0.31626832485198975,
-0.06010393425822258,
-0.49091556668281555,
0.5724759101867676,
0.7590412497520447,
-0.6135825514793396,
0.7197338342666626,
0.2046404778957367,
-0.37813279032707214,
-0.3035171627998352,
-0.6242518424987793,
-0.22896601259708405,
-0.6311305165290833,
-0.44408929347991943,
0.6351602077484131,
-0.45852288603782654,
-0.3916454613208771,
-0.09155300259590149,
-0.08733530342578888,
-0.01111042220145464,
0.3028434216976166,
0.13588616251945496,
-0.09466537088155746,
-0.5641283988952637,
0.031081274151802063,
0.583203911781311,
-0.004873114172369242,
-0.493122398853302,
-0.06528860330581665,
0.45510134100914,
-0.31058236956596375,
-0.13303479552268982,
-0.34624582529067993,
0.16621828079223633,
0.8235900402069092,
0.0846085324883461,
0.9397054314613342,
0.5947849750518799,
-0.34868618845939636,
-0.4515359103679657,
-0.2999267578125,
-0.176044762134552,
-0.47863614559173584,
0.025701148435473442,
-0.39910441637039185,
-0.8937761783599854,
0.5306572318077087,
-0.14675764739513397,
0.17206783592700958,
0.6388488411903381,
0.37094128131866455,
-0.42402535676956177,
0.9112964272499084,
0.9599191546440125,
-0.3162703812122345,
0.5619196891784668,
-0.06925532966852188,
0.03622440621256828,
-0.7020168900489807,
0.2502824664115906,
-0.6851761937141418,
-0.7848959565162659,
-0.5896775126457214,
-0.41106364130973816,
0.4880189597606659,
0.3991257846355438,
-0.14371241629123688,
0.3918538987636566,
-0.3846946954727173,
0.3214000165462494,
0.6346251964569092,
0.05704214423894882,
0.5702695846557617,
0.07379686087369919,
0.16486325860023499,
-0.0011995781678706408,
-0.9151097536087036,
-0.5041247010231018,
1.0283195972442627,
0.1963421106338501,
0.8631759881973267,
0.3226737976074219,
0.7335150241851807,
0.5901092886924744,
0.3775103688240051,
-0.8232812285423279,
0.4461093544960022,
-0.7400002479553223,
-0.32946789264678955,
-0.5080000162124634,
-0.2573796510696411,
-0.9721987247467041,
0.2949378788471222,
-0.4399678707122803,
-0.6911391615867615,
0.4498547911643982,
0.5146886110305786,
-0.8744694590568542,
0.21815906465053558,
-0.7688594460487366,
0.839515209197998,
-0.13218742609024048,
0.03389935940504074,
-0.38381877541542053,
-0.3783796727657318,
0.2699907124042511,
-0.49164363741874695,
0.35571950674057007,
-0.2636663615703583,
-0.0861775130033493,
1.036258578300476,
-0.1917884349822998,
0.8582636713981628,
-0.2582562565803528,
0.07255004346370697,
-0.06416217982769012,
-0.06680651009082794,
0.6125559210777283,
0.19882439076900482,
-0.4302653968334198,
-0.20955078303813934,
0.4228505492210388,
-0.5114555954933167,
-0.6471890211105347,
0.7491759061813354,
-1.0245554447174072,
-0.5284255743026733,
-0.033442649990320206,
-0.5303317904472351,
-0.4189935028553009,
0.026895007118582726,
0.1713400036096573,
0.11301425099372864,
-0.24212180078029633,
0.2056916207075119,
0.8525630831718445,
-0.12030543386936188,
0.4714747965335846,
0.3327178955078125,
-0.29086869955062866,
-0.3434629738330841,
0.8095690608024597,
-0.07363446801900864,
0.23429444432258606,
0.6531857848167419,
0.22190305590629578,
0.3257603049278259,
-0.7427831888198853,
-0.4776419401168823,
0.16223298013210297,
-0.4683709740638733,
-0.15352082252502441,
-0.34037432074546814,
-0.10035020112991333,
-0.1649763584136963,
-0.17276495695114136,
-0.34075620770454407,
-0.4777224659919739,
-0.5738973617553711,
0.32333314418792725,
0.5533879995346069,
0.48333409428596497,
0.021287132054567337,
0.8307511806488037,
-0.6342055201530457,
0.48827242851257324,
0.8572425842285156,
0.061181582510471344,
-0.3457619547843933,
-0.924354612827301,
-0.312991201877594,
-0.11994744837284088,
0.056732889264822006,
-0.6674356460571289,
0.20904508233070374,
0.6017918586730957,
0.5802651643753052,
0.44312208890914917,
0.03059201128780842,
0.768966019153595,
-0.2747214734554291,
0.3371189534664154,
-0.1706906408071518,
-0.8216554522514343,
0.6843377351760864,
-0.40648743510246277,
0.23115862905979156,
0.9819350838661194,
-0.13966882228851318,
-0.008598503656685352,
-0.09803251177072525,
-0.2567327320575714,
-0.511262059211731,
0.5555687546730042,
0.21199242770671844,
0.13677866756916046,
0.4075648784637451,
0.3741098940372467,
0.3490632474422455,
0.29480111598968506,
-0.6091017127037048,
-0.12660707533359528,
0.16812124848365784,
-0.40623533725738525,
-0.26445019245147705,
-0.2679169476032257,
-0.3627795875072479,
-0.5045177936553955,
0.6123238205909729,
-0.4205305576324463,
0.36192479729652405,
-0.13154582679271698,
-0.37386417388916016,
-0.2137976437807083,
0.43199825286865234,
0.6938894391059875,
0.42555224895477295,
-0.5024161338806152,
0.22812670469284058,
0.8021999001502991,
-0.34443315863609314,
0.029665030539035797,
0.2384663224220276,
-0.204386904835701,
-0.0625612735748291,
0.11379531025886536,
0.7479016780853271,
0.5457720756530762,
-0.5030340552330017,
0.19967834651470184,
0.0013490092242136598,
-0.11896144598722458,
-0.09050183743238449,
0.45488694310188293,
-0.022112831473350525,
0.3395979404449463,
0.21579700708389282,
0.5901444554328918,
-0.03820137679576874,
-0.5618695020675659,
-0.1597824990749359,
0.3055696189403534,
-0.14474529027938843,
-0.4353111684322357,
0.49887415766716003,
0.2864035665988922,
-0.36363062262535095,
0.10347315669059753,
-0.035182517021894455,
-0.0005140713765285909,
0.4826248586177826,
0.4258787930011749,
0.5061656832695007,
-0.22705517709255219,
0.17915953695774078,
-0.009192286990582943,
0.4647318124771118,
-0.00451775873079896,
0.05876849219202995,
-0.10447356849908829,
-0.6274152994155884,
-0.3986341655254364,
-1.0767873525619507,
-0.44297894835472107,
0.13599951565265656,
-0.5978546142578125,
0.2878349721431732,
-0.7287412285804749,
-0.264130175113678,
-0.08026988059282303,
-0.1612689346075058,
-0.676491379737854,
0.10294844210147858,
0.130893275141716,
1.0985140800476074,
-0.973173201084137,
1.0206180810928345,
0.7641743421554565,
-0.03385172039270401,
-0.38535651564598083,
0.08353525400161743,
-0.2541230320930481,
-0.8232191205024719,
0.288982093334198,
-0.2558068037033081,
-0.2393578141927719,
0.27172020077705383,
-0.1953073889017105,
-0.9517106413841248,
1.280787706375122,
0.7139468789100647,
-0.6836278438568115,
-0.3662448823451996,
-0.06361987441778183,
0.5300458669662476,
-0.35235828161239624,
-0.19736722111701965,
0.8158581852912903,
0.6179922819137573,
-0.31936925649642944,
-0.9674506187438965,
-0.2853228449821472,
-0.18213891983032227,
0.06201428920030594,
0.08871917426586151,
-0.6124990582466125,
0.8541275262832642,
0.17573019862174988,
0.17873536050319672,
0.4549369812011719,
0.39662647247314453,
0.37363237142562866,
0.3761458396911621,
0.7662872076034546,
0.5675729513168335,
0.8658968806266785,
0.09542359411716461,
0.695299506187439,
-0.16066868603229523,
0.15109772980213165,
0.9926809072494507,
0.07567073404788971,
1.0526561737060547,
0.6087421774864197,
-0.3043716847896576,
0.7819586396217346,
0.5095959901809692,
0.14389581978321075,
0.8338333964347839,
-0.12750302255153656,
-0.28342822194099426,
-0.3462173640727997,
0.20627491176128387,
-0.22697989642620087,
0.4098362624645233,
0.45041897892951965,
-0.46888190507888794,
-0.025683732703328133,
0.23682202398777008,
-0.1339307576417923,
0.09068284928798676,
-0.697270929813385,
0.7568666934967041,
0.1880096048116684,
-0.46014460921287537,
0.44138339161872864,
0.021915659308433533,
0.9652154445648193,
-0.4227926731109619,
0.1403573751449585,
-0.22065387666225433,
0.24862465262413025,
-0.19229836761951447,
-0.11603368073701859,
0.22803384065628052,
-0.03626302629709244,
-0.5216005444526672,
0.015317676588892937,
0.8399560451507568,
-0.09831772744655609,
-0.5863996148109436,
0.42383429408073425,
0.6027342081069946,
-0.005406894255429506,
-0.09078901261091232,
-0.7039878964424133,
-0.030867071822285652,
-0.2929980158805847,
-0.21145844459533691,
0.656859815120697,
0.07811766862869263,
0.10573996603488922,
0.3344959616661072,
0.5758683681488037,
0.15812547504901886,
0.1483304798603058,
0.05732600390911102,
0.7746058106422424,
-0.44185006618499756,
-0.27581825852394104,
-0.7435888648033142,
0.3213076591491699,
0.09381720423698425,
-0.2432183474302292,
0.44156795740127563,
0.3158252537250519,
0.5242172479629517,
-0.17093680799007416,
0.7336481809616089,
0.06355797499418259,
0.5565547943115234,
-0.7255619168281555,
0.6588427424430847,
-0.6799853444099426,
0.28084126114845276,
-0.1837526261806488,
-1.1495791673660278,
-0.30578649044036865,
0.5574353933334351,
-0.5539001822471619,
0.025520170107483864,
0.5565842390060425,
0.6549394130706787,
-0.3981219232082367,
-0.19055461883544922,
0.6392457485198975,
0.20225423574447632,
-0.0828649178147316,
0.557804524898529,
0.6075424551963806,
-0.3920494019985199,
0.722051203250885,
-0.2354065626859665,
-0.2032911479473114,
-0.47100475430488586,
-0.6720998287200928,
-1.0696017742156982,
-0.17540085315704346,
-0.16331535577774048,
0.10329297184944153,
0.2975689768791199,
0.8400204181671143,
0.9667483568191528,
-1.0225125551223755,
-0.02997485175728798,
-0.09560826420783997,
0.17869921028614044,
-0.2950884997844696,
-0.15800465643405914,
0.2181030809879303,
-0.1926833987236023,
-0.940453052520752,
0.7443177103996277,
0.5390069484710693,
0.03203396871685982,
0.018193300813436508,
-0.15959532558918,
0.05007178708910942,
0.2298077642917633,
0.6674292683601379,
0.4782121479511261,
-0.6261879801750183,
-0.30223342776298523,
-0.05952160805463791,
0.01939358375966549,
0.1724698841571808,
0.4271129071712494,
-0.6816988587379456,
0.043070483952760696,
0.3739834725856781,
0.5849234461784363,
0.7053858041763306,
-0.0492546409368515,
0.44974860548973083,
-0.5002499222755432,
0.17118079960346222,
0.17167457938194275,
0.36261898279190063,
0.055032625794410706,
-0.07737903296947479,
0.342529833316803,
0.15843434631824493,
-0.5098832249641418,
-0.7575597167015076,
0.10652633756399155,
-1.2559281587600708,
-0.14037927985191345,
0.8754297494888306,
0.07377459853887558,
-0.18420715630054474,
0.028330881148576736,
-0.28522032499313354,
0.04369444400072098,
-0.3069855272769928,
0.882061779499054,
0.21986812353134155,
-0.2417873591184616,
-0.4031820297241211,
-0.5662168264389038,
0.667020320892334,
0.6819609999656677,
-1.157921552658081,
-0.38922151923179626,
-0.09723345190286636,
0.43178442120552063,
0.11307603120803833,
0.6783421039581299,
0.2566799223423004,
0.21617576479911804,
-0.33422890305519104,
-0.3881288170814514,
0.3204917311668396,
-0.36940082907676697,
-0.39125514030456543,
0.34293004870414734,
0.6951436400413513,
-0.1842546910047531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17262v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17262v1
|
Speak Out of Turn: Safety Vulnerability of Large Language Models in Multi-turn Dialogue
| 2024-02-27T07:11:59 | 2024-02-27T07:11:59 |
Zhenhong Zhou, Jiuyang Xiang, Haopeng Chen, Quan Liu, Zherui Li, Sen Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have been demonstrated to generate illegal or
unethical responses, particularly when subjected to "jailbreak." Research on
jailbreak has highlighted the safety issues of LLMs. However, prior studies
have predominantly focused on single-turn dialogue, ignoring the potential
complexities and risks presented by multi-turn dialogue, a crucial mode through
which humans derive information from LLMs. In this paper, we argue that humans
could exploit multi-turn dialogue to induce LLMs into generating harmful
information. LLMs may not intend to reject cautionary or borderline unsafe
queries, even if each turn is closely served for one malicious purpose in a
multi-turn dialogue. Therefore, by decomposing an unsafe query into several
sub-queries for multi-turn dialogue, we induced LLMs to answer harmful
sub-questions incrementally, culminating in an overall harmful response. Our
experiments, conducted across a wide range of LLMs, indicate current
inadequacies in the safety mechanisms of LLMs in multi-turn dialogue. Our
findings expose vulnerabilities of LLMs in complex scenarios involving
multi-turn dialogue, presenting new challenges for the safety of LLMs.
|
[
-0.2763802409172058,
-0.8950541019439697,
0.7855858206748962,
-0.0015468719648197293,
-0.26424098014831543,
0.24176526069641113,
-0.12755025923252106,
-0.654796838760376,
-0.04763004183769226,
1.1061782836914062,
-0.6582735776901245,
-0.21384410560131073,
-0.5284601449966431,
-0.24224872887134552,
-0.5842033624649048,
0.9773886203765869,
0.45821115374565125,
0.023588741198182106,
-0.14560961723327637,
-0.14421287178993225,
-0.3327249586582184,
-0.9233814477920532,
-0.5991032719612122,
-0.17673344910144806,
0.45550858974456787,
0.6117581129074097,
0.7579835057258606,
-0.18761426210403442,
0.4259724020957947,
0.3820939064025879,
0.12957027554512024,
-0.04694269225001335,
-0.707015872001648,
0.5467119812965393,
-0.06076071411371231,
-0.6887879967689514,
-0.43575921654701233,
0.02791857160627842,
0.3285617530345917,
0.5757938623428345,
-0.3094172775745392,
-0.0394711047410965,
-0.0022794597316533327,
0.797933042049408,
-0.31486013531684875,
-0.18201139569282532,
-1.0422955751419067,
-0.21464459598064423,
-0.29727938771247864,
-0.1663888692855835,
-0.8326925039291382,
-0.42210838198661804,
0.1092410683631897,
-0.08334329724311829,
0.037156619131565094,
0.20865637063980103,
0.31460294127464294,
0.2363961935043335,
-0.22584721446037292,
-0.37156572937965393,
-0.9109058380126953,
0.47012948989868164,
-0.9256659746170044,
0.1923495978116989,
0.34356778860092163,
0.23079809546470642,
-0.5183762311935425,
-0.3621552586555481,
-0.8522233366966248,
-0.3782675862312317,
0.00012780202087014914,
-0.1185588389635086,
-0.24735377728939056,
0.03879287838935852,
0.23231486976146698,
0.056736160069704056,
-0.46703001856803894,
0.26276445388793945,
-0.3059672713279724,
-0.05668458342552185,
0.7485896944999695,
0.4135032892227173,
0.5662431716918945,
-0.07349599152803421,
-0.37874963879585266,
-0.31566882133483887,
-1.2547399997711182,
0.030824359506368637,
0.7105622291564941,
0.5269331336021423,
-0.0756952092051506,
0.570519208908081,
0.28815793991088867,
0.47570982575416565,
-0.04713686928153038,
-0.24196405708789825,
0.01608821377158165,
-0.2727653980255127,
-0.08973496407270432,
0.20607949793338776,
1.235419511795044,
0.6270484328269958,
0.2842194139957428,
-0.2029380351305008,
0.15964962542057037,
-0.32313865423202515,
0.4875890016555786,
-0.6437424421310425,
0.08219694346189499,
0.45129725337028503,
-0.26826009154319763,
-0.4773128628730774,
0.11863020807504654,
-1.0810015201568604,
-0.8343594074249268,
0.4306729733943939,
0.38127774000167847,
-0.3150918185710907,
-0.37090378999710083,
0.16743406653404236,
0.18671150505542755,
0.3047066926956177,
-0.04717140272259712,
-0.7433880567550659,
0.3587704300880432,
0.41436463594436646,
0.6741909980773926,
-0.08664458990097046,
-0.24596460163593292,
-0.5551332831382751,
0.06955813616514206,
-0.25738242268562317,
0.4250200092792511,
-0.23470619320869446,
-0.954724907875061,
0.06885767728090286,
0.18525907397270203,
0.11590234935283661,
-0.6223557591438293,
0.4670819044113159,
-0.4860553443431854,
-0.11887999624013901,
-0.19226033985614777,
0.18086838722229004,
-0.10115689784288406,
0.010928030125796795,
-0.5684471726417542,
0.6285322904586792,
-0.38651761412620544,
-0.8863903880119324,
0.09339650720357895,
-0.6071202158927917,
-0.7526389360427856,
-0.22601783275604248,
-0.13769100606441498,
-0.528774619102478,
0.11103388667106628,
0.08487493544816971,
0.20697467029094696,
-0.262754887342453,
0.25609061121940613,
-0.4941175878047943,
0.10681990534067154,
0.8420385718345642,
-0.7072617411613464,
0.9120208621025085,
0.03006933443248272,
-0.5383334755897522,
0.16545547544956207,
-0.42323681712150574,
-0.10267305374145508,
0.2862354516983032,
-0.27197331190109253,
-0.5543245077133179,
0.1285313367843628,
-0.3240431547164917,
0.4316677153110504,
-0.15812988579273224,
-0.7941501140594482,
0.054439473897218704,
-0.6305766701698303,
0.4583382308483124,
0.6079375147819519,
0.17276480793952942,
0.449685275554657,
-0.3062283396720886,
0.3080942630767822,
0.30733776092529297,
0.44344356656074524,
-0.3124494254589081,
-0.6976138353347778,
-0.7831538319587708,
0.08089739829301834,
-0.37856268882751465,
0.6831762194633484,
-0.6121642589569092,
0.11149819195270538,
0.04278745874762535,
-0.5864629745483398,
-0.40661582350730896,
-0.11523855477571487,
0.5017961263656616,
0.30226272344589233,
0.34543851017951965,
-0.011060886085033417,
-0.39105790853500366,
-0.7829526662826538,
-0.48111289739608765,
-0.46298640966415405,
0.23335516452789307,
0.3786040246486664,
0.2840624153614044,
-0.27334415912628174,
0.8114679455757141,
-0.46176621317863464,
-0.007775685749948025,
-0.5070619583129883,
0.24508629739284515,
0.015952996909618378,
0.4266512095928192,
0.3344978392124176,
-0.6809345483779907,
-0.2279467135667801,
-0.25470733642578125,
-0.6614494919776917,
0.05002284422516823,
-0.35319623351097107,
-0.13448213040828705,
0.32216882705688477,
0.7776014804840088,
-0.8562582731246948,
0.5496180057525635,
0.5644283294677734,
-0.1662847101688385,
0.4909060001373291,
-0.1264141947031021,
-0.05815843865275383,
-1.0886608362197876,
-0.4070085883140564,
-0.3451002836227417,
-0.035609934478998184,
-0.8638391494750977,
-0.07140236347913742,
-0.10639483481645584,
-0.23861832916736603,
-0.5359061360359192,
0.07081470638513565,
-0.4881879389286041,
-0.01750526763498783,
-0.20732878148555756,
0.2573279142379761,
-0.07615688443183899,
0.12995658814907074,
-0.07508978247642517,
0.6366034746170044,
0.5294357538223267,
-0.607700526714325,
0.39813002943992615,
0.26190343499183655,
-0.3793877959251404,
0.1811986118555069,
-0.6124284863471985,
0.5031951665878296,
-0.14236509799957275,
0.18656523525714874,
-1.0420247316360474,
-0.3375788629055023,
0.288600355386734,
-0.3696943521499634,
0.4261089265346527,
-0.17322826385498047,
-0.41751039028167725,
-0.2863858938217163,
-0.38401010632514954,
0.2500528395175934,
0.35710608959198,
-0.4872452914714813,
0.48168572783470154,
0.839229941368103,
-0.6081050634384155,
-0.3305239677429199,
-0.8595446348190308,
0.35394078493118286,
-0.4516672194004059,
-0.793206512928009,
-0.1238882914185524,
-0.011436160653829575,
-0.647571325302124,
-0.41432830691337585,
0.08765244483947754,
0.18701383471488953,
0.07147017866373062,
0.6690902709960938,
0.2845907509326935,
0.23364247381687164,
0.07746942341327667,
0.08791428059339523,
0.010219432413578033,
0.5022358894348145,
0.06431830674409866,
0.6438344120979309,
-0.17279280722141266,
-0.84219890832901,
-0.059870120137929916,
0.9606348872184753,
1.228255033493042,
-0.16043855249881744,
0.8459048867225647,
-0.09566919505596161,
-0.05466345697641373,
0.017141999676823616,
-0.5593984723091125,
-0.45509767532348633,
-0.5442607998847961,
0.4273512363433838,
0.03801338002085686,
-0.841065526008606,
0.43908432126045227,
-0.16847597062587738,
0.1576288491487503,
-0.04840036481618881,
0.684363067150116,
-0.14241795241832733,
1.1226789951324463,
0.6938574314117432,
-0.08412342518568039,
0.20041720569133759,
-0.012308928184211254,
0.5845286250114441,
-0.673539936542511,
-0.6132006049156189,
-0.7387794852256775,
0.010582742281258106,
-0.8678804039955139,
-0.4834356904029846,
0.8029277324676514,
-0.20041437447071075,
-0.16621460020542145,
0.2463037073612213,
-0.258902370929718,
0.26647621393203735,
0.46653008460998535,
0.15740253031253815,
0.46807757019996643,
-0.27892357110977173,
-0.1365206241607666,
-0.055651918053627014,
-0.5828139185905457,
-0.48870548605918884,
1.0130475759506226,
0.36895668506622314,
1.397727131843567,
0.34150761365890503,
0.7671971321105957,
-0.20537607371807098,
0.3492118716239929,
-0.7507191896438599,
0.6033679246902466,
0.26683807373046875,
-0.931594967842102,
-0.6000717282295227,
-0.15661592781543732,
-0.8692405223846436,
0.3390100300312042,
-0.2645376920700073,
-0.9172106385231018,
0.1834995597600937,
0.0533253438770771,
-0.40516746044158936,
0.44540271162986755,
-0.8747871518135071,
0.5927507281303406,
-0.6798282861709595,
-0.2050284892320633,
-0.1409372091293335,
-1.0044662952423096,
0.6470150947570801,
-0.15299151837825775,
0.7867894768714905,
0.003872801549732685,
0.49863383173942566,
0.5806964039802551,
-0.5053160190582275,
1.357724905014038,
-0.11419365555047989,
-0.28759491443634033,
0.5159099102020264,
0.21071533858776093,
0.779309868812561,
0.3737390637397766,
0.022360337898135185,
0.04211360961198807,
-0.18448100984096527,
0.03914748132228851,
-0.3979983925819397,
0.7215330004692078,
-0.7431462407112122,
-0.9485177397727966,
-0.4716053903102875,
-0.4160032868385315,
-0.5161756873130798,
0.026049574837088585,
0.5141333341598511,
0.27793997526168823,
-0.19139312207698822,
-0.04449322447180748,
0.7122464776039124,
-0.5178208351135254,
0.7219404578208923,
0.5662973523139954,
-0.37422826886177063,
-0.19128923118114471,
0.713665783405304,
-0.15203134715557098,
0.679582417011261,
-0.10779969394207001,
0.27020156383514404,
-0.4379061758518219,
-0.6535823345184326,
-0.38740676641464233,
0.15256111323833466,
-0.5630137920379639,
-0.2433645874261856,
-0.7052973508834839,
-0.10946056246757507,
-0.31417518854141235,
0.19158819317817688,
-0.4774722456932068,
-0.079938605427742,
-0.002358479890972376,
-0.34358635544776917,
0.3462073504924774,
0.7821075916290283,
-0.21774151921272278,
0.21627146005630493,
-1.2856839895248413,
0.3093079626560211,
0.5202736258506775,
0.03435680270195007,
-0.09514865279197693,
-0.42967143654823303,
0.01339883916079998,
0.09357795864343643,
-0.34734636545181274,
-1.1156525611877441,
0.34212595224380493,
-0.015538918785750866,
0.6371727585792542,
0.4427638351917267,
0.5739901065826416,
0.36717844009399414,
-0.7492570281028748,
0.7026522755622864,
0.4467991888523102,
-0.7637144327163696,
0.5058341026306152,
-0.342846542596817,
0.15053367614746094,
0.5267713069915771,
0.5257665514945984,
-0.6011826395988464,
-0.8943045139312744,
-0.4874677062034607,
-1.213334560394287,
0.5553950071334839,
-0.002518902299925685,
0.547883927822113,
-0.1826752871274948,
0.030574379488825798,
0.2903047204017639,
0.18294993042945862,
-0.8376143574714661,
-0.28216254711151123,
-0.250740110874176,
0.4346855878829956,
0.04866583272814751,
-0.5965945720672607,
-0.4801686406135559,
-0.08279620856046677,
0.44119423627853394,
0.06325473636388779,
0.15638701617717743,
0.1809823215007782,
-0.12786149978637695,
-0.3142983913421631,
0.6641325950622559,
0.7142530083656311,
0.2974076271057129,
-0.03515557199716568,
0.31564319133758545,
0.16603048145771027,
-0.6157873272895813,
0.21587549149990082,
-0.35691407322883606,
-0.04295499995350838,
-0.251127690076828,
0.42133888602256775,
0.7350138425827026,
0.20717228949069977,
-0.7015935182571411,
0.2978226840496063,
-0.16219712793827057,
0.07757654786109924,
-0.26397016644477844,
-0.02680906094610691,
0.19071762263774872,
0.2267930805683136,
0.36631834506988525,
0.131402388215065,
-0.03264301270246506,
-1.0725836753845215,
0.09724391996860504,
0.6544285416603088,
-0.30243927240371704,
-0.32067668437957764,
0.41854530572891235,
0.40073516964912415,
-0.41449761390686035,
0.6384062170982361,
0.06957869231700897,
-0.5808463096618652,
0.042973414063453674,
0.6340767741203308,
0.9823456406593323,
-0.34090280532836914,
0.22709988057613373,
0.1835494190454483,
0.7005785703659058,
0.14941129088401794,
0.23913131654262543,
0.3994550108909607,
-0.8936965465545654,
-0.5404669642448425,
-0.430149108171463,
-0.6638831496238708,
0.34495094418525696,
-0.6996568441390991,
-0.20112234354019165,
-0.34184056520462036,
-0.43536481261253357,
-0.30775466561317444,
-0.7606185674667358,
-0.054353345185518265,
-0.12240952998399734,
0.22651179134845734,
0.5615146160125732,
-0.7719955444335938,
0.7055829763412476,
0.39583030343055725,
-0.15028880536556244,
-0.5667327642440796,
0.2935641407966614,
0.12805134057998657,
-0.5778067708015442,
0.5126579999923706,
0.0905921459197998,
-0.6353978514671326,
-0.36870357394218445,
-0.8769689798355103,
-0.5729765892028809,
0.5507490634918213,
0.47113192081451416,
-0.7235432863235474,
0.08449868112802505,
0.6009445786476135,
0.23873360455036163,
-0.254231333732605,
-0.07321057468652725,
0.7785524129867554,
0.39460110664367676,
0.09198456257581711,
-1.1243783235549927,
0.2280256748199463,
0.10596395283937454,
-0.22777977585792542,
0.2692197263240814,
-0.6533166170120239,
0.796961784362793,
-0.8692024350166321,
-0.14817968010902405,
-0.08799292892217636,
0.18958155810832977,
0.15329670906066895,
0.2005264312028885,
0.5741755962371826,
0.37638625502586365,
0.5776050090789795,
-0.13374340534210205,
1.0112577676773071,
0.02386457473039627,
-0.03742152452468872,
1.2182024717330933,
-0.4988000988960266,
0.7942216396331787,
0.6888209581375122,
-0.1183348074555397,
0.34686461091041565,
0.056759659200906754,
0.6324887871742249,
0.6490447521209717,
0.3761913776397705,
-0.5143879652023315,
-0.4788617491722107,
0.3998439610004425,
-0.25821906328201294,
0.6932811141014099,
0.6614392399787903,
-0.02453877218067646,
-0.16325469315052032,
0.22845138609409332,
0.358817458152771,
0.013958250172436237,
0.020175326615571976,
0.9608782529830933,
0.3352836072444916,
-0.5749495029449463,
0.4086447060108185,
-0.08015169203281403,
0.5147886276245117,
-0.36367127299308777,
0.13194036483764648,
-0.2487807422876358,
0.11465314030647278,
-0.18071237206459045,
-0.7526091933250427,
0.5344353318214417,
-0.01143642794340849,
0.05087972432374954,
0.002017244463786483,
0.6067477464675903,
-0.28935232758522034,
-0.25329580903053284,
0.4758642017841339,
0.5036419034004211,
0.15531925857067108,
-0.2780173420906067,
-0.44924861192703247,
0.2554932236671448,
-0.06559649854898453,
-0.20701377093791962,
0.67060786485672,
0.38581839203834534,
-0.19995896518230438,
0.9116028547286987,
0.8949546217918396,
-0.08778093755245209,
0.45521754026412964,
0.11758582293987274,
1.2191271781921387,
-0.7743571996688843,
-0.18430264294147491,
-1.124038577079773,
0.5979339480400085,
-0.17861014604568481,
-0.02781166508793831,
0.6782101392745972,
0.23483195900917053,
0.6049141883850098,
0.07500108331441879,
1.1170339584350586,
0.029476843774318695,
0.454104483127594,
-0.5598171353340149,
1.1369781494140625,
-0.12890540063381195,
0.40827295184135437,
-0.4339279532432556,
-0.5448334813117981,
-0.00018620255286805332,
0.28804272413253784,
-0.34072503447532654,
-0.10858415067195892,
0.743074893951416,
0.8222492337226868,
0.5109233856201172,
0.06048275902867317,
0.5016185641288757,
0.5107486844062805,
0.5399524569511414,
0.3641948401927948,
1.108733892440796,
-0.06746360659599304,
1.002892255783081,
-0.11523272842168808,
-0.24884472787380219,
-0.3533693253993988,
-0.8309848308563232,
-1.1306606531143188,
-0.5589190721511841,
-0.08967921882867813,
-0.5061986446380615,
-0.09984322637319565,
0.5370970368385315,
0.5749948620796204,
-0.8403075933456421,
-0.30644792318344116,
0.054717857390642166,
0.2766014635562897,
0.20792877674102783,
-0.20571786165237427,
-0.09351571649312973,
-0.1903514266014099,
-0.583438515663147,
0.8954486846923828,
0.5888156890869141,
0.17454130947589874,
-0.4709239602088928,
0.03250668942928314,
-0.1531173288822174,
0.1699741929769516,
0.7140699028968811,
0.4584636986255646,
-0.6520419716835022,
-0.45083439350128174,
-0.02092617377638817,
-0.005556657910346985,
-0.06356737017631531,
1.1225969791412354,
-0.47533267736434937,
0.48356640338897705,
0.28991425037384033,
0.26384255290031433,
0.5303786993026733,
-0.13047634065151215,
0.7728005051612854,
-0.5919135212898254,
0.3466867208480835,
0.3027832806110382,
0.2508578598499298,
0.43091756105422974,
-0.44067373871803284,
-0.00600901385769248,
-0.025325557217001915,
-0.5294068455696106,
-0.9699966311454773,
0.7139980792999268,
-0.8359031081199646,
-0.10009444504976273,
1.2273937463760376,
-0.14843489229679108,
-0.1509585976600647,
-0.5799601674079895,
-0.4108153283596039,
0.09351920336484909,
-0.4285932779312134,
0.7638890147209167,
0.506483793258667,
-0.4237980544567108,
-0.1268807351589203,
-0.618208110332489,
0.5640830993652344,
-0.003909938037395477,
-0.9893051981925964,
0.5489118695259094,
0.19474156200885773,
0.27194303274154663,
0.38695666193962097,
0.6198083162307739,
-0.6075899004936218,
-0.032335832715034485,
0.008305191993713379,
-0.06766343861818314,
0.04161269590258598,
-0.3563723862171173,
0.07127131521701813,
0.22372974455356598,
0.40746405720710754,
-0.16661472618579865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17256v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17256v2
|
Beyond the Known: Investigating LLMs Performance on Out-of-Domain Intent Detection
| 2024-02-27T07:02:10 | 2024-03-04T06:04:32 |
Pei Wang, Keqing He, Yejie Wang, Xiaoshuai Song, Yutao Mou, Jingang Wang, Yunsen Xian, Xunliang Cai, Weiran Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Out-of-domain (OOD) intent detection aims to examine whether the user's query
falls outside the predefined domain of the system, which is crucial for the
proper functioning of task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems. Previous methods
address it by fine-tuning discriminative models. Recently, some studies have
been exploring the application of large language models (LLMs) represented by
ChatGPT to various downstream tasks, but it is still unclear for their ability
on OOD detection task.This paper conducts a comprehensive evaluation of LLMs
under various experimental settings, and then outline the strengths and
weaknesses of LLMs. We find that LLMs exhibit strong zero-shot and few-shot
capabilities, but is still at a disadvantage compared to models fine-tuned with
full resource. More deeply, through a series of additional analysis
experiments, we discuss and summarize the challenges faced by LLMs and provide
guidance for future work including injecting domain knowledge, strengthening
knowledge transfer from IND(In-domain) to OOD, and understanding long
instructions.
|
[
-0.5087978839874268,
-0.8650768995285034,
0.8899049162864685,
-0.39511945843696594,
-0.164447620511055,
0.035210657864809036,
-0.27984532713890076,
-0.5851311683654785,
-0.41098880767822266,
0.8433145880699158,
-0.6290115714073181,
-0.43279504776000977,
-0.7331359386444092,
-0.12332555651664734,
-0.36122822761535645,
0.7896031737327576,
-0.1723366379737854,
-0.18922428786754608,
-0.22637921571731567,
-0.049924496561288834,
-0.7048499584197998,
-0.5503518581390381,
-0.7872435450553894,
-0.24019858241081238,
0.040418535470962524,
0.5198924541473389,
0.32198309898376465,
-0.07998839020729065,
0.658337414264679,
0.21079108119010925,
-0.09617860615253448,
0.42868849635124207,
-0.9690222144126892,
0.22563719749450684,
-0.13474708795547485,
-0.6333125233650208,
-0.4889293611049652,
-0.11795442551374435,
0.5886185765266418,
0.633838951587677,
0.04710395261645317,
-0.06367045640945435,
0.05107223615050316,
0.5972559452056885,
-0.5400219559669495,
0.2059578150510788,
-0.8194921016693115,
-0.15302549302577972,
-0.33896613121032715,
-0.37300366163253784,
-0.7018824815750122,
-0.1262504756450653,
0.4208018183708191,
-0.3294196128845215,
0.09126926958560944,
0.3198242783546448,
0.5730518102645874,
0.15036766231060028,
-0.577674388885498,
-0.6688523292541504,
-0.770792543888092,
0.935227632522583,
-0.802668571472168,
0.38976457715034485,
0.4915899932384491,
0.3616267740726471,
-0.8196286559104919,
-0.38909968733787537,
-0.5143077373504639,
-0.3544169068336487,
0.030411355197429657,
-0.06205185502767563,
-0.2996409833431244,
0.19892963767051697,
0.16319414973258972,
0.3902226984500885,
-0.528969943523407,
0.1881287693977356,
-0.24795401096343994,
0.16187529265880585,
0.6141428351402283,
0.20037883520126343,
0.35243454575538635,
0.18896391987800598,
-0.4005815088748932,
0.41498643159866333,
-0.9387255907058716,
0.0963703840970993,
0.2009693831205368,
0.2555422782897949,
0.17679351568222046,
0.8276433944702148,
-0.1512189656496048,
0.8324077725410461,
0.11188313364982605,
-0.11335087567567825,
-0.2937656044960022,
-0.23235905170440674,
-0.2387578785419464,
-0.037599965929985046,
0.5937904715538025,
0.25602197647094727,
0.21941594779491425,
-0.2373286932706833,
-0.3841462731361389,
-0.2721412479877472,
0.14017778635025024,
-0.7831923961639404,
0.10275328904390335,
0.4158651530742645,
-0.49986544251441956,
0.2626606523990631,
-0.3269352912902832,
-0.18415163457393646,
-0.5721783638000488,
-0.1493796706199646,
0.4742385447025299,
-0.6424722671508789,
-0.3486286997795105,
0.4155745208263397,
-0.10492600500583649,
0.18900066614151,
0.3222864866256714,
-0.6720319986343384,
0.3022082448005676,
0.8923956155776978,
0.8402119874954224,
-0.5315483808517456,
-0.0781472846865654,
-0.48247194290161133,
0.015688909217715263,
-0.30507898330688477,
0.790570080280304,
-0.5643149614334106,
-0.5877593755722046,
-0.0009267984423786402,
-0.09695553034543991,
-0.42642396688461304,
-0.7239844799041748,
0.5094103813171387,
-0.8299612402915955,
0.06430920213460922,
-0.17869338393211365,
-0.9996415376663208,
-0.3343316912651062,
0.2899518311023712,
-0.3870435059070587,
0.8915133476257324,
0.1607133150100708,
-0.4250272512435913,
0.45735543966293335,
-1.0312210321426392,
-0.2833136022090912,
0.10968733578920364,
-0.09492381662130356,
-0.08090818673372269,
0.4723168909549713,
-0.15656574070453644,
0.48263978958129883,
-0.3234761357307434,
0.12662898004055023,
-0.2507554292678833,
-0.49243777990341187,
0.36270445585250854,
-0.42754387855529785,
0.5814956426620483,
0.10715226829051971,
-0.33864206075668335,
-0.00460452027618885,
-0.5451577305793762,
-0.09144861996173859,
0.1422685980796814,
-0.24716244637966156,
-0.4232962131500244,
0.09318046271800995,
-0.5271044373512268,
0.15202857553958893,
0.07648947089910507,
-0.774958074092865,
0.3251435160636902,
-0.41869136691093445,
0.607505202293396,
0.49653464555740356,
-0.04946295917034149,
0.38466235995292664,
-0.2761830687522888,
0.60658198595047,
-0.09940844029188156,
0.3335535228252411,
-0.26463714241981506,
-0.8395345211029053,
-0.705942690372467,
-0.363029807806015,
-0.04800740256905556,
0.27097734808921814,
-0.8194558024406433,
0.18620802462100983,
-0.17466819286346436,
-0.21556782722473145,
-0.13729257881641388,
0.10398077964782715,
0.4311894476413727,
0.2560621201992035,
0.0735638216137886,
-0.5072919726371765,
-0.20628654956817627,
-0.35988950729370117,
-0.20532111823558807,
-0.2759423553943634,
0.24407270550727844,
0.59763103723526,
0.5685836672782898,
-0.25880759954452515,
1.1441618204116821,
-0.5410458445549011,
-0.6627320647239685,
-0.4991987645626068,
0.06640501320362091,
0.19345584511756897,
-0.05111062899231911,
0.3175502419471741,
-0.6151471138000488,
-0.5752969980239868,
0.21901720762252808,
-0.601162314414978,
-0.0343446359038353,
0.18166399002075195,
0.060867488384246826,
0.43171870708465576,
0.7135211229324341,
-0.8935860395431519,
0.5567867755889893,
0.521440863609314,
-0.17454908788204193,
0.5239066481590271,
-0.19637231528759003,
0.05265236273407936,
-0.4909031093120575,
-0.15889841318130493,
-0.12163233757019043,
-0.1495363563299179,
-0.8611437082290649,
-0.06318061053752899,
-0.032988015562295914,
-0.17130206525325775,
-0.7291263937950134,
0.6039179563522339,
-0.6014949679374695,
-0.21255835890769958,
-0.5202038288116455,
0.3267439901828766,
0.06629879772663116,
0.444272518157959,
0.22396822273731232,
0.8667910099029541,
0.4397870898246765,
-0.7297931909561157,
0.33446067571640015,
0.11540474742650986,
-0.5793546438217163,
0.6220585703849792,
-0.4357841908931732,
0.2214304804801941,
-0.08153723925352097,
0.36633187532424927,
-1.4761048555374146,
-0.2166152000427246,
0.21320940554141998,
-0.4291025996208191,
0.2804831564426422,
-0.6224746108055115,
-0.4884762465953827,
-0.21040929853916168,
-0.27420976758003235,
0.7162675857543945,
0.38939592242240906,
-0.6276264190673828,
0.598362386226654,
0.4313535690307617,
-0.09541779011487961,
-0.2602657675743103,
-0.48866260051727295,
-0.0197516530752182,
-0.3938550055027008,
-0.7308014035224915,
0.21562814712524414,
0.11884377151727676,
-0.31331783533096313,
-0.26305684447288513,
0.02282574586570263,
-0.19313710927963257,
-0.0979556292295456,
0.33412572741508484,
0.0813576728105545,
-0.40982428193092346,
0.20222987234592438,
-0.14504563808441162,
0.17308442294597626,
0.1308479905128479,
-0.2896527647972107,
0.7029653191566467,
0.07622930407524109,
-0.7905023097991943,
-0.4983944594860077,
0.23457351326942444,
0.5969718098640442,
-0.11855337768793106,
0.5621206760406494,
0.27084216475486755,
0.02962857484817505,
-0.37287604808807373,
-0.5071665048599243,
-0.15304164588451385,
-0.48082420229911804,
0.3579268157482147,
-0.2682429552078247,
-0.7975326180458069,
0.39565640687942505,
-0.2945694923400879,
-0.008831440471112728,
0.0412287637591362,
0.45551615953445435,
0.03281766548752785,
1.000996470451355,
0.6735212802886963,
0.12285461276769638,
0.5734084248542786,
-0.35309866070747375,
0.5310885310173035,
-1.0703455209732056,
-0.172930508852005,
-0.2501562833786011,
0.06785202026367188,
-0.40480172634124756,
-0.5296845436096191,
0.45661449432373047,
0.04948354512453079,
0.14254634082317352,
0.27596092224121094,
-0.12950728833675385,
0.39928895235061646,
0.3570413887500763,
0.022381380200386047,
0.5435757040977478,
-0.2581319808959961,
0.2466529756784439,
0.34368667006492615,
-0.6903934478759766,
-0.5441846251487732,
1.3146824836730957,
0.4869421124458313,
0.8893657922744751,
0.2579587697982788,
0.38398921489715576,
0.2575232684612274,
0.07373005151748657,
-1.164965033531189,
0.6379936337471008,
-0.19977900385856628,
-0.8801933526992798,
-0.5009157657623291,
-0.23641662299633026,
-0.9883167743682861,
0.2909010946750641,
0.32890862226486206,
-0.8775933384895325,
0.1864817887544632,
0.032373521476984024,
-0.6639748215675354,
0.3924786150455475,
-0.9818054437637329,
0.6596040725708008,
-0.3485802412033081,
-0.10619596391916275,
-0.0017935174982994795,
-0.26210513710975647,
0.5046902894973755,
-0.06611248850822449,
0.0875295102596283,
-0.4241619408130646,
0.1429920494556427,
0.46824023127555847,
-0.17867276072502136,
1.0201568603515625,
-0.12850965559482574,
-0.5673706531524658,
0.5641932487487793,
0.00791463814675808,
0.631003737449646,
-0.08504971116781235,
0.04337455704808235,
0.22170662879943848,
-0.06175814941525459,
-0.09460102766752243,
-0.43502113223075867,
0.6394631266593933,
-0.3188334107398987,
-0.6496502757072449,
-0.1741151213645935,
-0.6604005694389343,
-0.4589059054851532,
0.19003930687904358,
0.2795373499393463,
0.6593447327613831,
-0.30197927355766296,
0.13194294273853302,
1.0734748840332031,
-0.4227796494960785,
0.40562742948532104,
0.7479991316795349,
-0.4557710886001587,
0.37490591406822205,
0.876263439655304,
0.050537701696157455,
0.6385157108306885,
0.36122629046440125,
0.06108812615275383,
-0.550616443157196,
-0.9921650290489197,
-0.6295236349105835,
0.046583447605371475,
-0.6775670051574707,
-0.042943648993968964,
-0.47068679332733154,
-0.14340975880622864,
-0.33063432574272156,
0.2526358664035797,
-0.3936102092266083,
-0.11823124438524246,
-0.21403470635414124,
0.321370929479599,
0.31400781869888306,
0.8211151957511902,
0.4666433334350586,
0.6021075248718262,
-0.6471803784370422,
0.39494356513023376,
0.10796558111906052,
0.41027235984802246,
-0.05849366635084152,
-0.9001271724700928,
-0.08430881053209305,
0.07523947209119797,
-0.37998566031455994,
-0.32357797026634216,
0.3217330574989319,
0.3099690079689026,
0.6106744408607483,
0.6040070056915283,
0.25938767194747925,
0.44417309761047363,
-0.3343517780303955,
0.7424163222312927,
-0.09990216791629791,
-0.7447961568832397,
0.48359447717666626,
-0.34450143575668335,
0.1436121165752411,
0.21269917488098145,
0.5211160778999329,
-0.28475916385650635,
-0.38643476366996765,
-0.12017137557268143,
-0.6822274923324585,
1.026504635810852,
0.23000885546207428,
0.10715656727552414,
-0.009378042072057724,
0.2803828716278076,
0.33566826581954956,
0.02565041556954384,
-0.3259662389755249,
-0.05947946757078171,
0.4614662230014801,
0.20594459772109985,
-0.12033345550298691,
-0.3032701313495636,
-0.06926220655441284,
0.11304407566785812,
0.5097717046737671,
-0.0654764324426651,
0.3316812217235565,
0.07781706750392914,
-0.3383544683456421,
-0.1369217336177826,
0.3394239842891693,
0.7370814085006714,
0.7814078330993652,
-0.4644593298435211,
-0.10849972814321518,
0.03774308040738106,
-0.4275536835193634,
-0.026855019852519035,
-0.1678081750869751,
0.0636303648352623,
-0.05695825070142746,
0.2840927541255951,
0.8231126666069031,
-0.11431613564491272,
-1.0396455526351929,
0.6875300407409668,
-0.24161812663078308,
0.08929140120744705,
-0.17053745687007904,
0.225796639919281,
-0.3707461953163147,
0.2662797272205353,
0.32816746830940247,
-0.12341643869876862,
0.34925925731658936,
-0.9302927851676941,
-0.10999276489019394,
0.8997132182121277,
-0.6099060773849487,
-0.3312130272388458,
0.13658981025218964,
0.29496678709983826,
-0.1610356867313385,
0.3125860095024109,
-0.3000633418560028,
-0.47146034240722656,
0.5724610686302185,
0.5109059810638428,
0.632767915725708,
-0.026413341984152794,
-0.0008754466543905437,
-0.4066283404827118,
0.1688907891511917,
-0.11687242239713669,
0.23089967668056488,
-0.11377168446779251,
-0.7634117007255554,
-0.5163697004318237,
-0.15133844316005707,
-0.5536162257194519,
0.3763568103313446,
-0.4699268043041229,
0.24408192932605743,
-0.11779196560382843,
-0.3665222227573395,
0.04562252387404442,
-0.053520869463682175,
-0.5125552415847778,
-0.03388344123959541,
0.10658685863018036,
0.663408637046814,
-0.34139594435691833,
0.9165113568305969,
0.5973425507545471,
0.0021362171974033117,
-0.2827436923980713,
0.03157031163573265,
0.09643367677927017,
-1.0563488006591797,
0.9304540753364563,
0.05818118527531624,
-0.48286667466163635,
-0.12289220094680786,
-0.26307329535484314,
-0.6579703688621521,
0.8494421243667603,
0.2954401671886444,
-0.5706003904342651,
0.04166349396109581,
0.445991575717926,
0.4233194887638092,
-0.3160487115383148,
0.42511633038520813,
0.8833973407745361,
0.22207114100456238,
0.14400117099285126,
-1.2207025289535522,
-0.14010700583457947,
0.2846592962741852,
-0.142521470785141,
0.42562106251716614,
-0.4982718229293823,
0.841097891330719,
-0.27504706382751465,
-0.3478269577026367,
0.23385383188724518,
0.16600610315799713,
0.08564223349094391,
0.5885782837867737,
0.29104822874069214,
0.3149451017379761,
0.43650752305984497,
-0.015829425305128098,
1.0296125411987305,
-0.11651518195867538,
0.24661919474601746,
1.064163327217102,
-0.5991097092628479,
0.8421229124069214,
0.4935634434223175,
-0.08782386034727097,
0.07229223847389221,
0.37314921617507935,
0.4488702118396759,
0.5945116877555847,
0.2132752239704132,
-0.46091967821121216,
-0.06069458648562431,
-0.27211567759513855,
-0.36866652965545654,
0.6520678400993347,
0.6737788915634155,
-0.25380122661590576,
-0.21017473936080933,
0.17991548776626587,
-0.1832742989063263,
-0.24537254869937897,
-0.4912462830543518,
0.9171656966209412,
0.21713972091674805,
-0.796285092830658,
0.7502085566520691,
-0.13252170383930206,
0.7623618841171265,
-0.48780930042266846,
-0.009356551803648472,
-0.25521594285964966,
0.5196726322174072,
-0.1154564842581749,
-0.8902536034584045,
0.18785688281059265,
-0.08808299899101257,
0.04341796785593033,
-0.06353483349084854,
0.9320534467697144,
-0.18505021929740906,
0.05265749990940094,
0.47805359959602356,
0.47222164273262024,
0.33527514338493347,
-0.5703359246253967,
-0.36530327796936035,
0.2933359742164612,
-0.1030135378241539,
-0.14939777553081512,
0.4327295124530792,
0.9109945297241211,
-0.1764795035123825,
0.8578357100486755,
0.5804933309555054,
-0.04558124765753746,
0.1520218402147293,
0.05550083890557289,
0.8214637041091919,
-0.5037669539451599,
-0.06806521862745285,
-0.9648285508155823,
0.06414008140563965,
0.06474939733743668,
-0.3987905979156494,
0.9256938099861145,
0.4481140077114105,
1.022199273109436,
0.0021834038197994232,
0.7706131339073181,
0.14639905095100403,
0.4154564142227173,
-0.6587068438529968,
0.49546128511428833,
-0.4444986581802368,
0.51084965467453,
0.03859144449234009,
-0.6303857564926147,
-0.03518671542406082,
0.161003977060318,
-0.6747645735740662,
0.07818279415369034,
0.5021964311599731,
0.7767125964164734,
-0.1494593322277069,
-0.00920844916254282,
0.754335343837738,
0.1054627001285553,
0.4926193952560425,
0.7242844104766846,
1.571373462677002,
-0.29428941011428833,
0.646754801273346,
0.02696394734084606,
-0.26578018069267273,
-0.7238950729370117,
-0.7870831489562988,
-1.3216348886489868,
-0.4140770137310028,
-0.12801183760166168,
0.10507819056510925,
0.14139573276042938,
0.6198421120643616,
0.9603525400161743,
-0.825832724571228,
-0.37914085388183594,
-0.19486235082149506,
0.11418776959180832,
0.07221712172031403,
-0.1636076122522354,
0.14202259480953217,
-0.5240330696105957,
-0.5944363474845886,
0.5692399144172668,
0.5444021224975586,
-0.06605713069438934,
-0.18714462220668793,
-0.05978379771113396,
-0.016451014205813408,
0.37087199091911316,
1.1140862703323364,
0.3026537299156189,
-0.7424773573875427,
-0.1298799067735672,
0.013992855325341225,
0.023557834327220917,
0.02489871345460415,
1.120959997177124,
-0.41833198070526123,
0.3878493010997772,
0.3626886308193207,
0.412985622882843,
0.31776946783065796,
0.03715422376990318,
0.5443199872970581,
-0.637730062007904,
-0.13232755661010742,
0.27991360425949097,
0.3199983537197113,
0.13861171901226044,
-0.4086604714393616,
0.3198208510875702,
-0.1765521615743637,
-0.8250276446342468,
-0.9344961047172546,
0.36830446124076843,
-0.914975106716156,
-0.376022070646286,
1.4802333116531372,
-0.3780446946620941,
-0.06969818472862244,
-0.7844043374061584,
-0.6124104857444763,
-0.08087456226348877,
-0.6216355562210083,
0.6984766125679016,
0.5536105036735535,
-0.6566231846809387,
0.059845734387636185,
-0.8622315526008606,
0.7144115567207336,
0.2354758232831955,
-0.7463403344154358,
0.3451559245586395,
0.3431552052497864,
0.13262487947940826,
0.03346269205212593,
0.7980642914772034,
-0.14197205007076263,
0.10634366422891617,
-0.38043564558029175,
-0.23700277507305145,
-0.00437599653378129,
-0.20904327929019928,
-0.24117206037044525,
-0.003727853996679187,
0.4845396876335144,
-0.41492506861686707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17237v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17237v1
|
Image-Text Matching with Multi-View Attention
| 2024-02-27T06:11:54 | 2024-02-27T06:11:54 |
Rui Cheng, Wanqing Cui
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Existing two-stream models for image-text matching show good performance
while ensuring retrieval speed and have received extensive attention from
industry and academia. These methods use a single representation to encode
image and text separately and get a matching score with cosine similarity or
the inner product of vectors. However, the performance of the two-stream model
is often sub-optimal. On the one hand, a single representation is challenging
to cover complex content comprehensively. On the other hand, in this framework
of lack of interaction, it is challenging to match multiple meanings which
leads to information being ignored. To address the problems mentioned above and
facilitate the performance of the two-stream model, we propose a multi-view
attention approach for two-stream image-text matching MVAM
(\textbf{M}ulti-\textbf{V}iew \textbf{A}ttention \textbf{M}odel). It first
learns multiple image and text representations by diverse attention heads with
different view codes. And then concatenate these representations into one for
matching. A diversity objective is also used to promote diversity between
attention heads. With this method, models are able to encode images and text
from different views and attend to more key points. So we can get
representations that contain more information. When doing retrieval tasks, the
matching scores between images and texts can be calculated from different
aspects, leading to better matching performance. Experiment results on MSCOCO
and Flickr30K show that our proposed model brings improvements over existing
models. Further case studies show that different attention heads can focus on
different contents and finally obtain a more comprehensive representation.
|
[
-0.37393325567245483,
-0.2382393479347229,
0.7242158651351929,
0.3105456531047821,
-0.7276164889335632,
-0.2193613052368164,
0.25360751152038574,
-0.6870230436325073,
0.31762829422950745,
0.6769813895225525,
-0.4317956268787384,
-0.012410130351781845,
-0.7663226127624512,
-0.0182692501693964,
-0.3481452763080597,
0.6067502498626709,
-0.28826606273651123,
-0.07720789313316345,
-0.4348609745502472,
-0.5743964910507202,
-0.7462591528892517,
-0.13244976103305817,
-0.4164639711380005,
0.03645547106862068,
0.6636098027229309,
0.2222413271665573,
0.3345475494861603,
0.8477939963340759,
1.1177067756652832,
0.2926153540611267,
0.05098504200577736,
0.5312346816062927,
-0.6066710948944092,
0.2846700847148895,
-0.2581867575645447,
-0.1116371676325798,
-0.24005641043186188,
0.19925066828727722,
0.6675382852554321,
0.11490678042173386,
0.1984192132949829,
0.3207024335861206,
0.17114579677581787,
0.8577113747596741,
-0.9354887008666992,
0.09271695464849472,
-0.6930878162384033,
0.06107453629374504,
-0.009092355147004128,
-0.5777879953384399,
-0.4823402464389801,
-0.15172508358955383,
0.2659186124801636,
-0.4587599039077759,
0.049397725611925125,
0.28255966305732727,
1.002756118774414,
0.3254990875720978,
-0.5716681480407715,
-0.10307922214269638,
-0.4379670023918152,
0.8149005770683289,
-0.1735832244157791,
0.30220940709114075,
0.15433785319328308,
0.22404533624649048,
0.3983663320541382,
-0.2541743218898773,
-0.37930622696876526,
0.41368040442466736,
-0.13336797058582306,
0.5573252439498901,
-0.026595493778586388,
-0.22195523977279663,
-0.11957822740077972,
0.4170738160610199,
-0.4478827714920044,
-0.23358610272407532,
-0.22200888395309448,
0.026067441329360008,
0.31859320402145386,
0.04040408506989479,
0.14652428030967712,
-0.0007675715605728328,
-0.8270921111106873,
-0.2378728836774826,
-0.20403054356575012,
-0.20013558864593506,
0.29738691449165344,
0.07477585971355438,
-0.050204087048769,
0.6118724346160889,
-0.10346915572881699,
0.5964900255203247,
-0.007707467768341303,
-0.1865539699792862,
0.26435548067092896,
-0.4213820993900299,
-0.17047445476055145,
-0.20546962320804596,
0.5289890170097351,
0.8612228035926819,
0.3287622332572937,
0.01408335380256176,
0.017961734905838966,
0.15065649151802063,
0.37903282046318054,
-0.9122006893157959,
-0.016749264672398567,
0.036195531487464905,
-0.9193952679634094,
-0.12926824390888214,
-0.030994132161140442,
-1.0182493925094604,
-0.4094286262989044,
-0.35942554473876953,
0.7921745777130127,
-0.2685844600200653,
-0.2747226059436798,
-0.009876740165054798,
-0.2585814893245697,
0.3909023702144623,
0.4681851267814636,
-0.7718920707702637,
0.03675081208348274,
0.36460164189338684,
0.9700174927711487,
-0.2395452857017517,
-0.24738940596580505,
-0.6993640661239624,
0.2281624972820282,
-0.10512574017047882,
1.1326631307601929,
-0.7377363443374634,
0.09875304996967316,
-0.0056058368645608425,
-0.40087026357650757,
-0.2050144225358963,
-0.3496955335140228,
0.3315771222114563,
-0.713180661201477,
0.2358476221561432,
-0.20110931992530823,
-0.5134961009025574,
-0.3939959406852722,
0.4474891126155853,
-0.8676891326904297,
0.8647782802581787,
-0.00914682261645794,
-1.0291495323181152,
0.04631172493100166,
-0.550837516784668,
-0.3413334786891937,
-0.04106197506189346,
-0.144941508769989,
-0.5697281360626221,
0.06964309513568878,
0.3867725729942322,
0.4084879755973816,
-0.27467167377471924,
-0.36032888293266296,
-0.5054638981819153,
-0.3986481726169586,
-0.021573079749941826,
-0.30100956559181213,
0.19418199360370636,
-0.08535666763782501,
0.09102273732423782,
-0.026679616421461105,
-0.47206297516822815,
0.061571020632982254,
0.12105128914117813,
-0.3784545958042145,
-0.5867900252342224,
0.15134386718273163,
0.606140673160553,
0.4149843454360962,
0.30668625235557556,
-0.2330162525177002,
-0.025928637012839317,
-0.2635107934474945,
0.10911337286233902,
0.5736322999000549,
0.043807901442050934,
0.5521188974380493,
-0.24264967441558838,
0.3547731935977936,
0.3898833692073822,
0.06970793008804321,
-0.8447475433349609,
-0.5257598757743835,
-0.6052927374839783,
-0.25415781140327454,
0.19183656573295593,
0.5659208297729492,
-0.6629981398582458,
-0.0023944121785461903,
-0.09367898106575012,
-0.19696226716041565,
-0.9685421586036682,
0.006366332992911339,
0.6230419874191284,
0.38818359375,
0.6156085729598999,
-0.7135687470436096,
-0.36472833156585693,
-1.0557706356048584,
-0.5415701866149902,
0.34025970101356506,
0.11151642352342606,
0.7311874032020569,
0.3494259715080261,
0.009909387677907944,
0.6217571496963501,
-0.67188960313797,
-0.8407145142555237,
-0.10703018307685852,
-0.12305960059165955,
-0.08101631700992584,
0.2919277846813202,
0.7981370687484741,
-1.2257602214813232,
-0.6923945546150208,
0.1387903392314911,
-0.5976715683937073,
0.2904769778251648,
0.004354517441242933,
-0.46406710147857666,
0.05758966878056526,
0.024450108408927917,
-0.1139010563492775,
0.4703318476676941,
0.7447770237922668,
-0.21247465908527374,
0.125403493642807,
-0.16557802259922028,
0.6615124344825745,
-1.3702938556671143,
-0.177669495344162,
0.38206157088279724,
-0.270525723695755,
-0.44354069232940674,
0.32075509428977966,
0.3737468123435974,
0.0968749076128006,
-0.5900421738624573,
0.5027931928634644,
-0.6218898892402649,
-0.12336326390504837,
-0.5971574187278748,
0.4003432095050812,
0.3652200996875763,
0.7488137483596802,
0.21213564276695251,
0.5007110834121704,
0.7196815609931946,
-0.4282276928424835,
0.18000727891921997,
0.19149397313594818,
-0.07978940010070801,
0.9183616638183594,
-0.5981205105781555,
0.3957047462463379,
-0.49765023589134216,
0.048564571887254715,
-1.3108844757080078,
-0.2752783000469208,
0.24418681859970093,
-0.4248877763748169,
0.3095361590385437,
-0.24754446744918823,
-0.4178466796875,
-0.18080158531665802,
-0.5619705319404602,
0.727921187877655,
0.16199250519275665,
-0.5566283464431763,
0.7966785430908203,
0.3654523491859436,
-0.011634734459221363,
-0.6304391622543335,
-0.5295159220695496,
0.10848233848810196,
0.032606977969408035,
-0.6302518844604492,
0.45467686653137207,
-0.07289291173219681,
0.3292096257209778,
0.12938722968101501,
-0.1531670093536377,
-0.28253546357154846,
-0.20976285636425018,
0.015117642469704151,
0.4070312976837158,
-0.0982980951666832,
-0.07730250805616379,
0.18506008386611938,
-0.12975385785102844,
-0.40534451603889465,
-0.3837748169898987,
0.3398266136646271,
0.12431786209344864,
-0.32827845215797424,
-0.45158565044403076,
1.0425102710723877,
0.5717746615409851,
-0.604185938835144,
0.7685936689376831,
0.5882211327552795,
-0.473783940076828,
0.4070989191532135,
-0.6999439001083374,
0.031982988119125366,
-0.4204727113246918,
0.5307168364524841,
-0.38981854915618896,
-0.7455214858055115,
0.3121793270111084,
0.20905959606170654,
0.1351580172777176,
0.26993754506111145,
0.553622841835022,
-0.32702621817588806,
1.1253941059112549,
0.9080591797828674,
-0.006233287509530783,
0.5019070506095886,
0.0009149824036285281,
0.11191452294588089,
-1.0624172687530518,
-0.3438502252101898,
-0.45167407393455505,
-0.6448347568511963,
-0.32541704177856445,
-0.5250680446624756,
0.2118687778711319,
-0.22600118815898895,
0.2933257818222046,
0.581646203994751,
-0.7537372708320618,
0.7421003580093384,
0.5928510427474976,
0.233188197016716,
0.3469173014163971,
0.17678368091583252,
0.05548621714115143,
-0.3372708857059479,
-0.3119463324546814,
-0.4407707750797272,
0.876788854598999,
0.15590627491474152,
0.7759596109390259,
0.190399631857872,
0.4790264964103699,
-0.08388713002204895,
0.21304288506507874,
-0.7247277498245239,
0.314910352230072,
-0.4649331569671631,
-0.3702675402164459,
0.26776450872421265,
-0.42331963777542114,
-0.7773730158805847,
0.914108395576477,
-0.2466561198234558,
-0.6675752997398376,
0.20664480328559875,
0.3024289011955261,
0.012521876953542233,
0.11258139461278915,
-0.8876575231552124,
0.847262442111969,
0.04905731976032257,
-0.3589213788509369,
-0.3192409574985504,
-0.6977648735046387,
0.4459034502506256,
-0.06787725538015366,
0.24591070413589478,
-0.14892791211605072,
-0.08517417311668396,
0.5380827188491821,
0.3175572454929352,
0.4341420531272888,
0.11233963072299957,
0.00471891276538372,
-0.054872963577508926,
-0.18144351243972778,
0.25263288617134094,
0.034848980605602264,
0.2117040604352951,
-0.18799924850463867,
0.0556262843310833,
-0.44284528493881226,
-0.2936980724334717,
0.5081961750984192,
-0.5571005940437317,
-0.27302706241607666,
-0.45087745785713196,
-0.5879133343696594,
0.10141000896692276,
0.33038854598999023,
0.38665878772735596,
0.4775632321834564,
0.07617148756980896,
0.16013216972351074,
0.9059990048408508,
0.062076106667518616,
0.4809992015361786,
0.3597637116909027,
-0.1641528308391571,
-0.3650034964084625,
0.61284339427948,
-0.2987362742424011,
0.2293495237827301,
0.8869422674179077,
-0.1653706133365631,
-0.35636261105537415,
-0.27374815940856934,
-0.3561680316925049,
0.14827735722064972,
-0.7614970207214355,
-0.38082796335220337,
-0.8527470827102661,
-0.06355710327625275,
-0.2953186333179474,
0.09861001372337341,
-0.3520558476448059,
0.19446758925914764,
-0.5050926804542542,
0.5655449628829956,
0.20374871790409088,
0.2921126186847687,
0.3956962525844574,
0.17054758965969086,
-0.9131332635879517,
0.8230849504470825,
0.4569491147994995,
0.5746797919273376,
0.18271112442016602,
-0.6357530355453491,
-0.327280730009079,
-0.21045748889446259,
-0.5959389805793762,
-1.107397437095642,
0.22613246738910675,
0.309162437915802,
0.3957761526107788,
0.33685851097106934,
-0.10927532613277435,
0.6361904144287109,
-0.7006999850273132,
0.13408122956752777,
0.42573800683021545,
-0.7106850147247314,
0.6684677004814148,
-0.06365212053060532,
0.524619460105896,
0.5203619003295898,
0.16521140933036804,
-0.7114905714988708,
-0.48771706223487854,
-0.2067616879940033,
-0.843258798122406,
0.8382443189620972,
0.4086102545261383,
0.2840268313884735,
0.2911572754383087,
0.3054601848125458,
-0.011272653006017208,
0.035760506987571716,
-0.719957172870636,
-0.217776820063591,
-0.1280064433813095,
-0.48744916915893555,
0.27033257484436035,
-0.24983446300029755,
0.12047174572944641,
0.04957081750035286,
0.4239645302295685,
-0.305473268032074,
0.5106224417686462,
0.13290509581565857,
-0.2505177855491638,
-0.14680658280849457,
-0.00309099187143147,
0.403812050819397,
0.3560890257358551,
-0.053670454770326614,
0.18469753861427307,
-0.2975009083747864,
-0.8038992285728455,
0.08585838973522186,
0.1980111002922058,
-0.05753987655043602,
-0.09393824636936188,
0.2685868442058563,
0.86567622423172,
0.09098692238330841,
-0.5800400376319885,
0.531372606754303,
-0.2985549867153168,
-0.1619434356689453,
0.20982876420021057,
0.03822491317987442,
0.36553311347961426,
0.38951805233955383,
0.617656946182251,
0.648269772529602,
0.38518887758255005,
-0.45687171816825867,
0.09785468131303787,
0.4304082691669464,
-0.447174996137619,
0.04513714462518692,
0.844514787197113,
0.25467053055763245,
-0.33980461955070496,
0.3543755114078522,
-0.11904661357402802,
-0.5535621643066406,
0.7565782070159912,
0.18265891075134277,
0.7779591083526611,
0.0027462372090667486,
-0.12002642452716827,
0.24946224689483643,
0.17541033029556274,
-0.21923276782035828,
0.35963794589042664,
0.025100644677877426,
-0.6828040480613708,
-0.5336710214614868,
-0.4165097773075104,
-0.39174017310142517,
-0.11369745433330536,
-0.7848951816558838,
0.1929023414850235,
0.06224583834409714,
0.09794113785028458,
0.18871665000915527,
-0.1291709691286087,
-0.6809374690055847,
0.23563097417354584,
0.3422127664089203,
0.6206080317497253,
-0.6748813390731812,
0.7088876366615295,
0.8739433884620667,
-0.32902589440345764,
-0.570523202419281,
0.26964494585990906,
-0.04643374681472778,
-0.5472031235694885,
-0.02166227251291275,
0.673048198223114,
-0.218556746840477,
0.08773092925548553,
-0.2852042317390442,
-0.9045212864875793,
0.9605438113212585,
0.24271917343139648,
-0.7632812857627869,
0.21075977385044098,
-0.42593854665756226,
0.2664965093135834,
-0.6060110926628113,
0.3623729646205902,
0.17031122744083405,
0.26341545581817627,
0.329632431268692,
-0.6386561989784241,
-0.17216546833515167,
-0.23854412138462067,
0.2624618709087372,
0.35299405455589294,
-0.9247303009033203,
0.7389127612113953,
-0.3526553809642792,
-0.28707778453826904,
0.08839714527130127,
0.7621057629585266,
0.3370235562324524,
0.3473828434944153,
0.36856523156166077,
0.44195419549942017,
0.2694048285484314,
0.0685056746006012,
0.8493002653121948,
-0.005233542062342167,
0.759242832660675,
0.9926164150238037,
-0.4106457829475403,
1.0487521886825562,
0.6141706705093384,
-0.07737334072589874,
0.09456036239862442,
0.6346806883811951,
-0.06694106757640839,
1.0178312063217163,
-0.36406710743904114,
0.10685025900602341,
-0.31336137652397156,
0.01007729023694992,
-0.2730239927768707,
0.33396413922309875,
0.0021354136988520622,
-0.5896026492118835,
-0.39802315831184387,
0.05713581293821335,
-0.41539156436920166,
0.4812832176685333,
-0.33369889855384827,
0.7383649945259094,
-0.025105983018875122,
-0.6941751837730408,
0.1089787632226944,
0.19947846233844757,
0.781784176826477,
-0.18749742209911346,
-0.08818531781435013,
-0.1703435778617859,
0.40384551882743835,
0.1758490651845932,
-0.921787440776825,
0.21098409593105316,
-0.1276487410068512,
-0.6380235552787781,
-0.19770245254039764,
0.8645357489585876,
-0.7840744256973267,
-0.5331742167472839,
0.40533891320228577,
0.07611547410488129,
0.05138656497001648,
-0.37889331579208374,
-0.6582582592964172,
0.07578012347221375,
0.0070658777840435505,
-0.14592096209526062,
0.38864371180534363,
0.21493743360042572,
0.07967435568571091,
0.3368771970272064,
0.11261918395757675,
-0.4600135087966919,
0.1029055267572403,
0.12312687188386917,
0.624052107334137,
-0.2905159592628479,
-0.6253020167350769,
-0.8633480072021484,
0.29515185952186584,
-0.18083640933036804,
-0.44007015228271484,
0.31095895171165466,
0.6867449879646301,
0.45168209075927734,
-0.1820303052663803,
0.6949948668479919,
0.17587655782699585,
0.37438154220581055,
-0.4774931073188782,
0.5788845419883728,
-0.9974851012229919,
-0.34364935755729675,
-0.5575592517852783,
-1.2706118822097778,
-0.2630905210971832,
0.6523452401161194,
0.3240341246128082,
0.08266466110944748,
0.8543140888214111,
0.5033495426177979,
-0.3652099668979645,
-0.18439213931560516,
0.1886289268732071,
-0.294225811958313,
0.06772099435329437,
1.0600671768188477,
0.577812910079956,
-0.9206317067146301,
0.9018896222114563,
0.12740127742290497,
-0.25300267338752747,
-0.4860789179801941,
-0.8247597217559814,
-0.8827441930770874,
-0.7229445576667786,
-0.4874439239501953,
-0.13118882477283478,
-0.07322821021080017,
0.40328818559646606,
0.7559120655059814,
-0.4347924292087555,
0.28779879212379456,
0.45077449083328247,
0.0600501149892807,
-0.5175381302833557,
-0.1435774266719818,
0.437004417181015,
0.045197535306215286,
-0.9821438193321228,
-0.16296392679214478,
0.9600555896759033,
0.08641745150089264,
-0.18859852850437164,
0.06581676006317139,
-0.5413504838943481,
0.3606373965740204,
0.698668897151947,
-0.16126398742198944,
-0.638397753238678,
-0.1951228529214859,
0.19237567484378815,
-0.3711874485015869,
0.3292945623397827,
0.618934154510498,
-0.5392002463340759,
0.4902915954589844,
0.5352608561515808,
0.7774137854576111,
0.8482709527015686,
0.012564385309815407,
0.03778615966439247,
-0.9406185746192932,
0.1506337821483612,
0.12961965799331665,
0.3642745912075043,
0.47354769706726074,
-0.40786951780319214,
0.22633139789104462,
0.16771705448627472,
-0.32630643248558044,
-0.43281978368759155,
0.39022305607795715,
-1.3844634294509888,
-0.14068715274333954,
0.942020058631897,
-0.05446280539035797,
-0.13480599224567413,
0.1313621550798416,
-0.5030549764633179,
0.1926414966583252,
-0.343201220035553,
0.7973935604095459,
0.8240481019020081,
0.13870300352573395,
-0.7026116251945496,
-0.4272427558898926,
-0.17854228615760803,
0.38907942175865173,
-0.7730942368507385,
-0.3189537525177002,
0.21203826367855072,
0.13549742102622986,
0.22423025965690613,
0.5925746560096741,
-0.03638667240738869,
0.5017786622047424,
-0.27063947916030884,
-0.041450221091508865,
0.1997743397951126,
-0.33866891264915466,
-0.08126670867204666,
0.30020642280578613,
-0.3736259639263153,
-0.7906515598297119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17231v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17231v3
|
MATHSENSEI: A Tool-Augmented Large Language Model for Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-02-27T05:50:35 | 2024-04-03T15:22:35 |
Debrup Das, Debopriyo Banerjee, Somak Aditya, Ashish Kulkarni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Tool-augmented Large Language Models (TALMs) are known to enhance the
skillset of large language models (LLMs), thereby, leading to their improved
reasoning abilities across many tasks. While, TALMs have been successfully
employed in different question-answering benchmarks, their efficacy on complex
mathematical reasoning benchmarks, and the potential complementary benefits
offered by tools for knowledge retrieval and mathematical equation solving are
open research questions. In this work, we present MathSensei, a tool-augmented
large language model for mathematical reasoning. We study the complementary
benefits of the tools - knowledge retriever (Bing Web Search), program
generator + executor (Python), and symbolic equation solver (Wolfram-Alpha API)
through evaluations on mathematical reasoning datasets. We perform exhaustive
ablations on MATH, a popular dataset for evaluating mathematical reasoning on
diverse mathematical disciplines. We also conduct experiments involving
well-known tool planners to study the impact of tool sequencing on the model
performance. MathSensei achieves 13.5% better accuracy over gpt-3.5-turbo with
Chain-of-Thought on the MATH dataset. We further observe that TALMs are not as
effective for simpler math word problems (in GSM-8K), and the benefit increases
as the complexity and required knowledge increases (progressively over AQuA,
MMLU-Math, and higher level complex questions in MATH). The code and data are
available at https://github.com/Debrup-61/MathSensei.
|
[
-0.34488844871520996,
-0.8281168341636658,
0.510783314704895,
0.23813746869564056,
-0.2590845227241516,
0.10589620471000671,
-0.30844801664352417,
-0.26192280650138855,
-0.09493019431829453,
0.36236557364463806,
-0.37355226278305054,
-0.51268070936203,
-0.6227043271064758,
0.08704261481761932,
-0.36524006724357605,
0.5935639142990112,
-0.1583913415670395,
0.33928942680358887,
-0.3433960974216461,
-0.055226828902959824,
-0.6112781763076782,
-0.5202861428260803,
-0.6505220532417297,
-0.6043277382850647,
0.40359193086624146,
0.08798877894878387,
1.006069302558899,
0.2392219603061676,
0.6193370223045349,
0.3404184579849243,
-0.10364442318677902,
0.029359273612499237,
-0.22237439453601837,
0.21023108065128326,
-0.21927666664123535,
-0.9707335233688354,
-0.27884989976882935,
-0.14587101340293884,
0.39953288435935974,
0.9397604465484619,
-0.15235461294651031,
0.09379225969314575,
-0.20852988958358765,
0.47333067655563354,
-0.7727370858192444,
0.23222748935222626,
-0.5276147127151489,
-0.014413329772651196,
-0.18528570234775543,
0.1551322638988495,
-0.2772364616394043,
-0.6268479824066162,
0.10716529935598373,
-0.7495366930961609,
0.02349063940346241,
-0.13810011744499207,
0.37802961468696594,
0.49948370456695557,
-0.23644043505191803,
-0.3625810444355011,
-0.5399160981178284,
0.9863874316215515,
-0.7183747291564941,
0.5608375072479248,
0.5483282208442688,
0.524154543876648,
-0.21721234917640686,
-0.5203929543495178,
-0.3437860608100891,
0.027281232178211212,
0.00725397327914834,
0.11500708758831024,
-0.11889069527387619,
-0.34986746311187744,
0.7002318501472473,
0.25037986040115356,
-0.589514970779419,
0.030940670520067215,
-0.20018403232097626,
-0.20790164172649384,
0.4539966881275177,
0.37226319313049316,
0.3184134364128113,
-0.10425347089767456,
0.18430860340595245,
-0.2715721130371094,
-0.8240574598312378,
-0.04455893114209175,
0.14020952582359314,
0.041238557547330856,
-0.07016988843679428,
0.8544502258300781,
-0.026883602142333984,
0.6726658940315247,
-0.5204264521598816,
-0.06545286625623703,
0.25901880860328674,
-0.07895873486995697,
-0.16517409682273865,
0.25086453557014465,
0.520302951335907,
-0.12122385203838348,
0.3672604262828827,
-0.10024674236774445,
-0.17462247610092163,
0.3235087990760803,
0.056309718638658524,
-0.9869440197944641,
-0.11955120414495468,
0.11515231430530548,
-0.16679973900318146,
-0.06666823476552963,
-0.017563067376613617,
-0.5037407279014587,
-0.45292964577674866,
-0.541886568069458,
0.43935921788215637,
-0.6355841755867004,
-0.2956044375896454,
0.5506947040557861,
-0.3570234775543213,
-0.09047646075487137,
0.7868400812149048,
-0.1957942545413971,
0.10888566821813583,
0.9017289876937866,
0.829760730266571,
0.11351780593395233,
-0.003705389564856887,
-0.8011709451675415,
-0.0656149685382843,
-0.4813108444213867,
0.47259101271629333,
-0.9157669544219971,
-0.619767963886261,
-0.11784353852272034,
-0.2558368444442749,
-0.004527456127107143,
-0.5732322335243225,
0.5532388687133789,
-0.6512265801429749,
0.39565032720565796,
-0.3289852738380432,
-0.5393051505088806,
-0.2534448206424713,
0.13980570435523987,
-0.8087929487228394,
0.9983999729156494,
-0.09217310696840286,
-0.6384786367416382,
-0.0156340803951025,
-0.8212075233459473,
-0.37203505635261536,
0.11008547246456146,
-0.13045215606689453,
-0.2868843674659729,
0.2657283544540405,
0.31753411889076233,
0.10410218685865402,
-0.8500921726226807,
0.4033033847808838,
-0.4558490216732025,
-0.36001700162887573,
0.47538095712661743,
-0.4900864064693451,
0.893129825592041,
0.31124404072761536,
-0.34934699535369873,
-0.22792430222034454,
-0.4649205207824707,
-0.020759373903274536,
0.4441737234592438,
0.06745284050703049,
-0.5283650755882263,
-0.19935795664787292,
-0.44911637902259827,
0.21036173403263092,
0.37639591097831726,
-0.6823469400405884,
0.04929499328136444,
-0.4901324510574341,
-0.008521622978150845,
0.6588159799575806,
-0.23065488040447235,
0.2460424304008484,
-0.15600766241550446,
0.7494685053825378,
-0.0002338091580895707,
-0.10344668477773666,
-0.26278847455978394,
-0.5614194273948669,
-0.571096658706665,
-0.14837205410003662,
0.4920401871204376,
0.44352880120277405,
-0.9670376777648926,
0.17217226326465607,
-0.3282712399959564,
-0.5153891444206238,
-0.3186664581298828,
0.0229183416813612,
0.47291648387908936,
0.5062338709831238,
0.24768096208572388,
0.20413538813591003,
-0.12346363812685013,
-0.7498951554298401,
-0.4829310476779938,
0.2779068946838379,
-0.19801922142505646,
0.24603506922721863,
0.44719061255455017,
0.010085299611091614,
0.9058145880699158,
-0.9495653510093689,
-0.007972454652190208,
-0.10348214954137802,
0.337001234292984,
0.5526569485664368,
-0.012953972443938255,
0.4178865849971771,
-0.8769794702529907,
-0.474064439535141,
0.019823107868433,
-0.8074018955230713,
-0.4442669451236725,
0.21089641749858856,
-0.20692667365074158,
-0.05568086355924606,
0.18546488881111145,
-0.7220568060874939,
0.5856426954269409,
0.2520683705806732,
-0.23929230868816376,
0.7304157614707947,
0.10952012985944748,
0.10027716308832169,
-1.0090842247009277,
0.3498167097568512,
0.2031567245721817,
-0.05188242718577385,
-0.4073062241077423,
0.09157805889844894,
0.055773116648197174,
-0.36736029386520386,
-0.2900645434856415,
0.8625773787498474,
-0.10302916914224625,
-0.07940326631069183,
-0.32799845933914185,
0.34465840458869934,
-0.05842944234609604,
0.3262779116630554,
-0.027296029031276703,
1.242119312286377,
0.4748590588569641,
-0.4444521963596344,
0.3780832588672638,
0.2815130650997162,
-0.323982834815979,
0.5008665323257446,
-0.8983398675918579,
0.01571565866470337,
-0.11127710342407227,
0.006517026573419571,
-0.7023019790649414,
-0.04343738406896591,
-0.029811235144734383,
-0.44862860441207886,
0.039703045040369034,
-0.12713630497455597,
-1.04205322265625,
-0.31611281633377075,
-0.11808072030544281,
0.5146476626396179,
0.5501529574394226,
-0.6212974190711975,
0.8615989089012146,
0.2760515511035919,
-0.5977499485015869,
-0.49638962745666504,
-0.2303801327943802,
-0.04784012958407402,
-0.08264970034360886,
-0.5012224316596985,
-0.06540122628211975,
-0.02588469162583351,
-0.4978177547454834,
0.1486242413520813,
-0.2555866539478302,
0.047359317541122437,
0.1459721028804779,
0.15337760746479034,
0.5319353342056274,
-0.03498842194676399,
0.48266810178756714,
0.36879152059555054,
-0.430458664894104,
0.21643796563148499,
-0.0036017338279634714,
0.9083172678947449,
-0.2701568007469177,
-0.6811211109161377,
0.01155202928930521,
0.05653536319732666,
0.4949221611022949,
-0.5525302886962891,
0.620033860206604,
0.4496820271015167,
-0.5151562094688416,
0.15873947739601135,
-0.5961898565292358,
-0.2113880068063736,
-0.428828626871109,
0.2265116572380066,
-0.6872382164001465,
-0.7911854982376099,
0.495797723531723,
-0.47881871461868286,
0.3787444233894348,
0.5299726128578186,
0.506733238697052,
0.25820639729499817,
1.5977078676223755,
-0.22405065596103668,
-0.09804043918848038,
0.13612738251686096,
-0.27741849422454834,
0.11449804902076721,
-0.7430826425552368,
-0.14787641167640686,
-0.8098780512809753,
-0.2640840411186218,
0.11228630691766739,
-0.2566351592540741,
0.5814904570579529,
0.19691629707813263,
-0.3275641202926636,
0.26841139793395996,
-0.28836145997047424,
0.4567948281764984,
0.4871250092983246,
0.019215038046240807,
0.5146669149398804,
0.09956896305084229,
-0.4831663966178894,
-0.2125513255596161,
-0.6454277038574219,
-0.2921137809753418,
1.0092002153396606,
0.06761400401592255,
1.0175328254699707,
0.32183554768562317,
0.24102497100830078,
0.0028158577624708414,
0.3689292073249817,
-0.7231582403182983,
0.6557472944259644,
-0.18984781205654144,
-0.4536961317062378,
-0.18819203972816467,
-0.8555333018302917,
-1.0603631734848022,
0.41596299409866333,
0.011991257779300213,
-0.6475278735160828,
-0.32972195744514465,
-0.19538435339927673,
-0.04150071740150452,
0.2198813259601593,
-0.7176855802536011,
0.5587601065635681,
-0.4180709421634674,
-0.4078713655471802,
-0.5965380072593689,
-0.3090266287326813,
0.35153311491012573,
-0.4386323392391205,
0.2958548963069916,
-0.13233649730682373,
-0.012007791548967361,
0.6514089703559875,
-0.5782198309898376,
0.6324895024299622,
-0.19986923038959503,
-0.4578112065792084,
-0.018382713198661804,
0.40612348914146423,
0.5376319885253906,
0.04913778603076935,
-0.27910318970680237,
0.26570290327072144,
0.05239317938685417,
-0.08681105077266693,
-1.116285800933838,
0.8608925342559814,
-0.6899811029434204,
-0.8292140960693359,
-0.31930893659591675,
-0.9099252223968506,
-0.2682011127471924,
0.5033562183380127,
-0.16720212996006012,
0.9159361720085144,
0.41472816467285156,
0.3655894100666046,
0.6602262258529663,
-0.3616655170917511,
0.13940472900867462,
0.3095988631248474,
-0.6066043972969055,
-0.6199266910552979,
0.5443559288978577,
0.10384417325258255,
0.09184513986110687,
0.3135389983654022,
0.351082980632782,
-0.6457922458648682,
0.061889540404081345,
-0.46651726961135864,
0.5112059116363525,
-0.7195956110954285,
-0.37946847081184387,
-0.6333852410316467,
-0.25938451290130615,
-0.04861164838075638,
-0.08511218428611755,
-0.26063618063926697,
-0.7501062750816345,
0.05753566697239876,
0.318433552980423,
0.5505592823028564,
0.24860922992229462,
0.20817264914512634,
0.17510168254375458,
-0.8305253386497498,
0.4392116069793701,
0.07539726048707962,
0.48828643560409546,
0.14810499548912048,
-0.2838684022426605,
-0.22870303690433502,
0.5243619680404663,
-0.14529772102832794,
-0.5356621146202087,
0.17401641607284546,
-0.1924072504043579,
0.5270823836326599,
0.21914157271385193,
0.03404557332396507,
0.7164096832275391,
-0.43380042910575867,
0.3206746280193329,
0.3589879274368286,
-0.9099266529083252,
0.5504288077354431,
-0.152963325381279,
0.8138225078582764,
0.17611749470233917,
0.3535098135471344,
-0.44415485858917236,
-0.33629631996154785,
-0.5304759740829468,
-0.19802550971508026,
0.6713882684707642,
0.53406822681427,
-0.13038885593414307,
0.08160492777824402,
0.22823794186115265,
0.16083602607250214,
0.31163352727890015,
-0.007818012498319149,
-0.1392340064048767,
-0.06272095441818237,
-0.39907190203666687,
-0.003970195539295673,
0.23474150896072388,
-0.2524474263191223,
-0.2629064917564392,
0.8048075437545776,
-0.0916488766670227,
0.16207388043403625,
-0.19016984105110168,
-0.36920586228370667,
-0.031783152371644974,
0.2743135690689087,
0.46491938829421997,
0.7385817170143127,
0.11163302510976791,
0.2565281391143799,
0.19740702211856842,
-0.5883702039718628,
-0.012711171992123127,
0.5819849371910095,
0.014602698385715485,
0.18796813488006592,
0.12404628098011017,
0.5976389646530151,
0.2771977186203003,
-0.9600858688354492,
0.3630472719669342,
-0.09826517850160599,
-0.22097589075565338,
-0.2279726266860962,
0.2650207281112671,
0.13132236897945404,
0.18146532773971558,
0.4496176838874817,
-0.12707017362117767,
0.04135318100452423,
-0.07493612915277481,
-0.12639543414115906,
0.5904396772384644,
0.0325004979968071,
-0.19649283587932587,
0.6639057397842407,
-0.08821508288383484,
-0.33789515495300293,
0.6185154914855957,
0.07317544519901276,
-0.7149035930633545,
0.6396109461784363,
0.6633971929550171,
0.5136756896972656,
-0.14308229088783264,
0.0843517929315567,
0.2823317348957062,
0.07008294016122818,
-0.029870091006159782,
0.38477861881256104,
0.03762439265847206,
-0.5906950235366821,
-0.8201716542243958,
-0.4668358862400055,
-0.33852526545524597,
-0.02351469360291958,
-0.43990978598594666,
0.4034518301486969,
-0.31305596232414246,
-0.3016114830970764,
-0.05541194602847099,
0.030841199681162834,
-0.7845314741134644,
-0.056841108947992325,
-0.2840796411037445,
1.0988805294036865,
-0.4344664514064789,
0.3903109133243561,
0.8187316060066223,
-0.21812480688095093,
-0.7079010009765625,
-0.3749747574329376,
-0.035174544900655746,
-0.9026888608932495,
0.733782947063446,
0.26033467054367065,
-0.2908170819282532,
0.2199493944644928,
-0.37360790371894836,
-0.9075721502304077,
0.9801304936408997,
0.5575600266456604,
-0.547733724117279,
0.1752568483352661,
0.455161988735199,
0.39932501316070557,
0.1673058718442917,
0.3407658338546753,
0.19057482481002808,
0.4428086578845978,
0.5229193568229675,
-1.0010689496994019,
0.08216792345046997,
-0.49858537316322327,
-0.10043280571699142,
1.0138353109359741,
-0.179852694272995,
0.4586910307407379,
-0.015593266114592552,
-0.07385555654764175,
0.14288823306560516,
0.24180029332637787,
0.6109758615493774,
0.23667676746845245,
0.41621968150138855,
1.1455398797988892,
0.624443769454956,
-0.19532226026058197,
1.0232343673706055,
-0.2892424464225769,
0.2543680965900421,
1.005092740058899,
-0.3481905162334442,
0.560943067073822,
0.15342673659324646,
-0.28332918882369995,
0.4579371213912964,
0.1456972360610962,
0.07000040262937546,
0.2220257818698883,
-0.013434190303087234,
-0.3242250978946686,
-0.6325050592422485,
-0.3055700957775116,
-0.6122128367424011,
0.23142394423484802,
0.5685297846794128,
-0.06365714967250824,
-0.705631673336029,
0.094442218542099,
0.22517897188663483,
-0.07381661981344223,
-0.3210628628730774,
0.5019405484199524,
0.31939488649368286,
-0.5343259572982788,
0.41375046968460083,
0.0010071350261569023,
0.09178724884986877,
-0.6147261261940002,
-0.24490515887737274,
0.012236385606229305,
0.27605539560317993,
0.054291870445013046,
-1.0117526054382324,
0.11339867115020752,
0.12528684735298157,
0.14866377413272858,
0.20313507318496704,
0.8420946598052979,
-0.14852464199066162,
-0.8207349181175232,
-0.19380658864974976,
0.6955142617225647,
0.0053203050047159195,
-0.20373886823654175,
-0.7975550889968872,
0.026813874021172523,
-0.4030587375164032,
0.11055372655391693,
0.21666964888572693,
0.4970972239971161,
-0.16873067617416382,
0.901552140712738,
1.0682071447372437,
-0.038554802536964417,
-0.009831182658672333,
0.4870679974555969,
0.9950801730155945,
-0.4173397123813629,
-0.3751116096973419,
-0.8095107674598694,
0.4033157229423523,
-0.3246377110481262,
-0.0502639077603817,
0.9530178904533386,
0.8079423308372498,
0.5063344240188599,
0.03675488382577896,
0.634186327457428,
0.22657985985279083,
0.6197031736373901,
-0.5316852927207947,
0.25577405095100403,
-0.6109213829040527,
0.31533902883529663,
-0.3502843379974365,
-1.1720550060272217,
-0.5668498873710632,
0.6016560196876526,
-0.8052411675453186,
0.10588134825229645,
0.624926745891571,
0.5256949067115784,
-0.31271249055862427,
0.35360434651374817,
0.12749943137168884,
-0.02861282415688038,
0.42855843901634216,
0.45817750692367554,
0.9029358625411987,
-0.24818064272403717,
0.4809384346008301,
-0.1544785499572754,
-0.2302015870809555,
0.018446415662765503,
-0.5621777176856995,
-1.0593911409378052,
-0.2515462338924408,
-0.13395018875598907,
-0.20398765802383423,
-0.2633494436740875,
0.9324480295181274,
0.16492484509944916,
-0.32201460003852844,
-0.08289740234613419,
-0.16024596989154816,
0.14472807943820953,
0.1057487279176712,
-0.2482708841562271,
0.3448236584663391,
-0.40742817521095276,
-0.7096666097640991,
0.06307218968868256,
0.3256532549858093,
-0.18610455095767975,
-0.12797796726226807,
-0.05031823739409447,
0.059335749596357346,
-0.08050993084907532,
0.7251825332641602,
0.017936794087290764,
-0.5026087164878845,
0.09065447747707367,
0.38700708746910095,
0.20550194382667542,
-0.2381676584482193,
0.955517590045929,
-0.7871719598770142,
0.5217234492301941,
0.44106122851371765,
1.001628041267395,
0.4937998056411743,
-0.08216685801744461,
0.5900673270225525,
-0.3278551399707794,
0.10212194174528122,
0.14459864795207977,
0.6822712421417236,
0.07599788159132004,
-0.15065991878509521,
0.6945402026176453,
0.1343701034784317,
-0.1957232803106308,
-0.7387038469314575,
0.2874223589897156,
-0.43554484844207764,
-0.3983612060546875,
1.0722846984863281,
0.17486120760440826,
-0.021267445757985115,
-0.02360309660434723,
-0.36505675315856934,
0.14503894746303558,
-0.29848799109458923,
0.7419629693031311,
0.8396821022033691,
0.1348034292459488,
-0.27763670682907104,
-0.42322278022766113,
-0.16319845616817474,
0.6276194453239441,
-0.9416124820709229,
-0.09268084913492203,
0.5874675512313843,
-0.014993051066994667,
0.2997359037399292,
-0.0340033657848835,
-0.4729025959968567,
0.48791974782943726,
-0.2884678840637207,
-0.13983242213726044,
-0.3352460563182831,
-0.24103710055351257,
-0.09069186449050903,
0.08175840973854065,
-0.09439992904663086,
0.24440224468708038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17226v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17226v1
|
Reasoning in Conversation: Solving Subjective Tasks through Dialogue Simulation for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-27T05:37:10 | 2024-02-27T05:37:10 |
Xiaolong Wang, Yile Wang, Yuanchi Zhang, Fuwen Luo, Peng Li, Maosong Sun, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable performance in
objective tasks such as open-domain question answering and mathematical
reasoning, which can often be solved through recalling learned factual
knowledge or chain-of-thought style reasoning. However, we find that the
performance of LLMs in subjective tasks is still unsatisfactory, such as
metaphor recognition, dark humor detection, etc. Compared to objective tasks,
subjective tasks focus more on interpretation or emotional response rather than
a universally accepted reasoning pathway. Based on the characteristics of the
tasks and the strong dialogue-generation capabilities of LLMs, we propose RiC
(Reasoning in Conversation), a method that focuses on solving subjective tasks
through dialogue simulation. The motivation of RiC is to mine useful contextual
information by simulating dialogues instead of supplying chain-of-thought style
rationales, thereby offering potential useful knowledge behind dialogues for
giving the final answers. We evaluate both API-based and open-source LLMs
including GPT-4, ChatGPT, and OpenChat across twelve tasks. Experimental
results show that RiC can yield significant improvement compared with various
baselines.
|
[
-0.4668918550014496,
-0.9531944394111633,
0.8564972877502441,
0.25338709354400635,
-0.3079850971698761,
0.10558471083641052,
-0.5311990976333618,
-0.41031813621520996,
-0.046313244849443436,
0.5443233847618103,
-0.5450828671455383,
-0.6513976454734802,
-0.2050890177488327,
0.042770158499479294,
0.07747741788625717,
0.7318212389945984,
0.0389326736330986,
0.3165086507797241,
-0.6843099594116211,
0.10439004749059677,
-0.5174565315246582,
-0.71406489610672,
-0.7345057129859924,
-0.409016489982605,
0.28686341643333435,
0.6474553346633911,
0.36311838030815125,
-0.1094827800989151,
0.6379925012588501,
0.37185007333755493,
0.05128583684563637,
0.18567776679992676,
-0.5329471826553345,
0.39595669507980347,
-0.2807329595088959,
-0.7274162769317627,
-0.33103519678115845,
-0.1312866061925888,
0.4699503779411316,
0.683196485042572,
-0.19516268372535706,
0.0066032917238771915,
0.02818709798157215,
0.4297570288181305,
-0.31760770082473755,
0.4819096028804779,
-0.704170286655426,
-0.005660569295287132,
0.07798536121845245,
-0.4036094844341278,
-0.40292245149612427,
-0.187995046377182,
0.22127163410186768,
-0.4395948350429535,
-0.06443262845277786,
0.2691739797592163,
0.4329829216003418,
0.18166835606098175,
-0.10169040411710739,
-0.4874404966831207,
-1.1141294240951538,
1.0295825004577637,
-1.052493691444397,
0.2051246017217636,
0.3272574543952942,
0.24062658846378326,
-0.3364979922771454,
-0.2764889895915985,
-0.6346077919006348,
-0.5582859516143799,
0.205565944314003,
0.2303880751132965,
-0.13797049224376678,
0.3091922998428345,
0.3708009123802185,
0.29541897773742676,
-0.3399869501590729,
-0.10142043977975845,
-0.13904058933258057,
0.006806808523833752,
0.4149235785007477,
0.3498205840587616,
0.23499980568885803,
-0.08676151931285858,
-0.07498592883348465,
0.12139026075601578,
-0.6121776103973389,
0.062190085649490356,
0.1158759593963623,
0.31343457102775574,
-0.15147854387760162,
0.5887532830238342,
-0.23504546284675598,
0.5542569160461426,
-0.13518404960632324,
-0.4911317229270935,
0.019161174073815346,
-0.17644965648651123,
-0.2559317350387573,
-0.03897832706570625,
0.7204163074493408,
0.3251844346523285,
0.2526039779186249,
-0.14726361632347107,
-0.007075911853462458,
0.03880362585186958,
0.1427953690290451,
-0.6302133798599243,
0.021559065207839012,
0.41495341062545776,
-0.39337244629859924,
-0.10246047377586365,
-0.4862390458583832,
-0.4509407579898834,
0.022316383197903633,
-0.7404441237449646,
0.22055383026599884,
-0.44882509112358093,
-0.25369077920913696,
0.2521606981754303,
0.07166509330272675,
0.17107197642326355,
0.7418773770332336,
-0.44043195247650146,
0.3236594498157501,
0.7834820747375488,
0.8016937375068665,
0.013760876841843128,
0.14551541209220886,
-0.4112691581249237,
0.10542542487382889,
-0.22469626367092133,
0.9057891368865967,
-0.743014395236969,
-0.6312311291694641,
-0.1016547903418541,
-0.38983187079429626,
0.28394120931625366,
-0.6410926580429077,
0.7031868696212769,
-0.26067590713500977,
0.21666277945041656,
-0.46937406063079834,
-0.6002724170684814,
0.02509177289903164,
0.718401312828064,
-0.23840945959091187,
0.8766235709190369,
-0.13680985569953918,
-0.7391201257705688,
-0.08221273869276047,
-0.7356182932853699,
-0.2083033174276352,
0.1317196786403656,
-0.24521614611148834,
0.015967998653650284,
0.07342889904975891,
-0.004167961422353983,
0.45846012234687805,
-0.6970705986022949,
0.44598397612571716,
-0.4770645201206207,
-0.40695807337760925,
0.5322539806365967,
-0.2689111530780792,
0.45659640431404114,
0.29339513182640076,
-0.31645989418029785,
-0.04153214767575264,
-0.31419575214385986,
0.06015941500663757,
-0.007898605428636074,
-0.1374090015888214,
-0.27028900384902954,
0.2564392387866974,
-0.4283149540424347,
0.22340889275074005,
-0.0023297963198274374,
-0.7560372352600098,
0.16313593089580536,
-0.45546841621398926,
0.3722150921821594,
0.5276745557785034,
-0.06783176958560944,
0.43695202469825745,
-0.3036470413208008,
0.4906458258628845,
0.304110586643219,
0.15793806314468384,
0.04687568172812462,
-0.7396366000175476,
-0.957901120185852,
-0.14166517555713654,
0.17702752351760864,
0.6677744388580322,
-1.021539330482483,
0.15342290699481964,
-0.22573041915893555,
-0.4258480668067932,
-0.2915116846561432,
0.041364025324583054,
0.4862072765827179,
0.5938615202903748,
0.0841524749994278,
-0.5132598280906677,
-0.4299537241458893,
-0.8083422780036926,
-0.19511310756206512,
-0.6103832721710205,
-0.03339363634586334,
0.6529534459114075,
0.3669261038303375,
-0.04614228382706642,
1.08999502658844,
-0.510421097278595,
-0.14204542338848114,
-0.40797626972198486,
0.40414902567863464,
0.19953343272209167,
0.303484708070755,
0.281288206577301,
-0.4598575234413147,
-0.31570810079574585,
-0.09516914933919907,
-0.8822963833808899,
-0.20919851958751678,
-0.07568765431642532,
-0.25328245759010315,
0.11527413129806519,
0.5723537802696228,
-0.6986854076385498,
0.18505160510540009,
0.43540647625923157,
0.1836102306842804,
0.7244438529014587,
-0.06045105308294296,
0.07646645605564117,
-0.8963326811790466,
0.05272109806537628,
0.2589944005012512,
-0.5274456739425659,
-0.5796554684638977,
-0.27950599789619446,
-0.5063309669494629,
-0.3744913339614868,
-0.5701209902763367,
0.6588019728660583,
-0.3761712610721588,
-0.33199068903923035,
-0.3644554316997528,
0.45583099126815796,
-0.18562713265419006,
0.7109248638153076,
0.22298935055732727,
0.7986616492271423,
0.493038535118103,
-0.5706851482391357,
0.5569385290145874,
0.1644389033317566,
-0.5381473302841187,
0.6372334361076355,
-0.6443744897842407,
0.3424926996231079,
-0.29542699456214905,
0.4382246434688568,
-0.8148924112319946,
-0.029576469212770462,
0.5090140700340271,
-0.4035208821296692,
0.14262117445468903,
-0.1650206744670868,
-0.4557375907897949,
-0.3585180640220642,
-0.0219503715634346,
0.3980262279510498,
0.5150701403617859,
-0.26392608880996704,
0.6908729076385498,
0.3471836745738983,
-0.4403305947780609,
-0.5248685479164124,
-0.4676568806171417,
0.22803731262683868,
-0.16991457343101501,
-0.47791892290115356,
0.12746219336986542,
-0.29889976978302,
-0.6667107939720154,
-0.03758767992258072,
0.03726748004555702,
0.1063137799501419,
-0.023116348311305046,
0.1329582929611206,
0.21790574491024017,
-0.0675964280962944,
0.10102174431085587,
-0.1488514095544815,
-0.09320524334907532,
0.3067695200443268,
-0.20885129272937775,
0.587379515171051,
-0.30359959602355957,
-0.5515552163124084,
-0.5962111353874207,
0.4546429216861725,
0.4261060059070587,
-0.01113321166485548,
0.4882907569408417,
0.14322467148303986,
-0.16077333688735962,
-0.3070642054080963,
-0.6507366895675659,
-0.16136565804481506,
-0.4694885313510895,
0.16786180436611176,
-0.5435521602630615,
-1.012634515762329,
0.4627901315689087,
-0.4002605378627777,
0.12132405489683151,
-0.2165963053703308,
0.7260973453521729,
-0.3618985414505005,
1.0714057683944702,
0.15736821293830872,
-0.02753966487944126,
0.39446303248405457,
-0.046771273016929626,
0.6785640716552734,
-0.8251285552978516,
-0.29843464493751526,
-0.6146150231361389,
-0.19268372654914856,
-0.2835004925727844,
-0.8525366187095642,
0.6404825448989868,
0.006055466365069151,
-0.18042856454849243,
-0.0478910356760025,
-0.3244969844818115,
0.5838376879692078,
0.7464717030525208,
0.17517982423305511,
0.4668692648410797,
-0.11914432048797607,
-0.07611449062824249,
0.013384394347667694,
-0.5153317451477051,
-0.785087525844574,
0.8892194628715515,
0.2851165235042572,
0.862636923789978,
0.015863800421357155,
0.5674251317977905,
-0.026300176978111267,
0.6276201605796814,
-0.9415475726127625,
0.9722931385040283,
0.14002397656440735,
-0.6317046284675598,
-0.12991099059581757,
-0.7067481875419617,
-0.4009163975715637,
0.14558374881744385,
-0.041327279061079025,
-0.8034565448760986,
-0.18901033699512482,
0.22010739147663116,
-0.03909633681178093,
0.31236809492111206,
-0.5725829005241394,
0.5553520321846008,
-0.1837056577205658,
-0.32901710271835327,
-0.34909188747406006,
-0.5611660480499268,
0.503000795841217,
0.3060910403728485,
0.2540605664253235,
-0.42799872159957886,
0.3266316056251526,
0.3932381570339203,
-0.3545002341270447,
1.045925259590149,
-0.25078335404396057,
-0.23302794992923737,
0.6340610980987549,
0.32920557260513306,
0.4599531292915344,
0.22117486596107483,
-0.017427442595362663,
0.14341925084590912,
-0.13894429802894592,
-0.3343546390533447,
-0.9810078144073486,
0.635799765586853,
-0.6493122577667236,
-0.9150221347808838,
-0.27282753586769104,
-0.49935969710350037,
-0.573766827583313,
-0.18813954293727875,
-0.07251085340976715,
0.5270138382911682,
-0.4709705412387848,
0.06708227843046188,
0.5668613910675049,
-0.38761600852012634,
0.18623964488506317,
0.5129479169845581,
-0.20658919215202332,
-0.2593121826648712,
0.7420851588249207,
-0.36879631876945496,
0.4074021279811859,
0.48893052339553833,
0.06646626442670822,
-0.24630750715732574,
-0.4270387589931488,
-0.33245131373405457,
0.4068010449409485,
-0.7409401535987854,
-0.3106175363063812,
-0.7027517557144165,
-0.021907733753323555,
-0.13316938281059265,
-0.04768577590584755,
-0.3053855299949646,
-0.32672908902168274,
-0.1612319052219391,
0.13893894851207733,
0.024380747228860855,
0.49447348713874817,
-0.07518594712018967,
0.04227093234658241,
-0.6372934579849243,
0.14200614392757416,
0.42797356843948364,
0.19607409834861755,
0.09038043022155762,
-0.16910336911678314,
-0.17323744297027588,
0.48749402165412903,
-0.5447406768798828,
-0.5752795338630676,
0.2956527769565582,
-0.12789878249168396,
0.27333158254623413,
0.46123310923576355,
0.05647826939821243,
0.6413472294807434,
-0.5058349967002869,
0.8372024297714233,
0.33044418692588806,
-1.1808017492294312,
0.5066710710525513,
-0.4738709628582001,
0.23532234132289886,
0.4817103445529938,
0.3550545573234558,
-0.6047446131706238,
-0.7217902541160583,
-0.42951977252960205,
-0.31098055839538574,
0.6816922426223755,
0.3962133526802063,
0.24545268714427948,
-0.1439157873392105,
0.3902209401130676,
-0.10202766954898834,
0.3177773058414459,
-0.5123447179794312,
-0.08807457238435745,
-0.05349496752023697,
-0.12417594343423843,
-0.21390707790851593,
-0.247824564576149,
-0.10624153167009354,
-0.44513434171676636,
0.6667665243148804,
-0.271907776594162,
0.7569853663444519,
0.37889137864112854,
0.17817921936511993,
-0.028045671060681343,
0.3837096095085144,
0.6250377893447876,
0.47328847646713257,
-0.2927008867263794,
0.11775564402341843,
0.23235243558883667,
0.015727734193205833,
0.03549663722515106,
-0.38295623660087585,
0.2440280020236969,
0.10387353599071503,
0.07937629520893097,
0.8633332848548889,
0.48260167241096497,
-1.026273488998413,
0.4804215431213379,
-0.2379845827817917,
-0.30164793133735657,
-0.4570264518260956,
0.12841251492500305,
0.33218368887901306,
0.36854633688926697,
0.05740244686603546,
-0.16711057722568512,
0.25720253586769104,
-1.0603675842285156,
-0.28376591205596924,
0.7043642997741699,
-0.189299076795578,
-0.288788765668869,
0.4604376256465912,
0.5127305388450623,
-0.36679384112358093,
0.6771341562271118,
-0.11162640899419785,
-0.6700159907341003,
0.5584000945091248,
0.6218296885490417,
0.6958677172660828,
-0.07791203260421753,
0.3686204254627228,
0.2332618236541748,
-0.04319778457283974,
-0.1517019420862198,
0.34504109621047974,
-0.29255983233451843,
-1.0606716871261597,
-0.6919496655464172,
-0.44204095005989075,
-1.1716012954711914,
0.05149347335100174,
-0.3693266212940216,
0.22525744140148163,
-0.3058963716030121,
-0.2181806117296219,
-0.1457093209028244,
-0.10720623284578323,
-0.5681836009025574,
0.14436691999435425,
0.30350181460380554,
0.6392353177070618,
-0.4309457540512085,
0.610259473323822,
0.6111020445823669,
-0.15754853188991547,
-0.6543891429901123,
-0.102011539041996,
-0.12554967403411865,
-0.5841076374053955,
0.80556720495224,
-0.03389545902609825,
-0.3955312669277191,
-0.11543528735637665,
-0.8584311604499817,
-0.6614795923233032,
0.721545398235321,
0.5635070204734802,
-0.6205800175666809,
-0.18366247415542603,
0.3784612715244293,
0.5911234021186829,
-0.3971386253833771,
0.6685839295387268,
0.325096070766449,
0.34682759642601013,
0.3918741047382355,
-1.02682363986969,
-0.278396874666214,
-0.29969435930252075,
-0.017713047564029694,
0.041067928075790405,
-0.7481086254119873,
0.5198264122009277,
-0.03800255060195923,
-0.10506810992956161,
0.08584894984960556,
0.6214288473129272,
0.3943668603897095,
0.3928656578063965,
0.45103201270103455,
0.572576105594635,
0.5997694730758667,
-0.1608511060476303,
0.9946151971817017,
-0.33793556690216064,
0.30464377999305725,
1.09583580493927,
-0.7405843138694763,
0.7354377508163452,
0.24345465004444122,
0.017506012693047523,
0.7013223767280579,
0.38246476650238037,
0.4474988579750061,
0.3614928424358368,
0.2871191203594208,
-0.6734044551849365,
-0.5818766355514526,
-0.20078450441360474,
-0.19007067382335663,
0.6163851022720337,
0.43353691697120667,
0.07144830375909805,
-0.12156832963228226,
0.18557293713092804,
0.13024422526359558,
-0.11004830151796341,
-0.2338545173406601,
0.8540241122245789,
0.4083838164806366,
-0.8520540595054626,
0.4587517976760864,
0.0902182012796402,
0.5102018713951111,
-0.2950739860534668,
-0.10381779074668884,
-0.19698448479175568,
0.16110582649707794,
0.09671927988529205,
-0.637671947479248,
0.22933383285999298,
0.18823587894439697,
0.028639182448387146,
-0.4527937173843384,
0.725237250328064,
-0.33382749557495117,
-0.3203010559082031,
0.16337041556835175,
0.6568503379821777,
0.43821439146995544,
-0.1152544766664505,
-0.7124311327934265,
0.13479241728782654,
-0.07490839809179306,
-0.11975464224815369,
0.25495341420173645,
0.690319836139679,
0.18404729664325714,
0.9378968477249146,
0.61758953332901,
0.010910164564847946,
-0.39243823289871216,
0.18807967007160187,
1.1967809200286865,
-0.7505820989608765,
-0.43381693959236145,
-0.6374188661575317,
0.28908276557922363,
-0.2202063649892807,
-0.06315705180168152,
0.6636129021644592,
0.5565482974052429,
0.8066713213920593,
-0.07659836113452911,
0.8354455232620239,
0.14011092483997345,
0.6454434990882874,
-0.6216206550598145,
0.13188554346561432,
-0.41515105962753296,
0.2617345154285431,
-0.5273526906967163,
-1.057820200920105,
-0.22132264077663422,
0.6995686292648315,
-0.6445370316505432,
0.03109027072787285,
0.8128825426101685,
0.8077157735824585,
-0.03920777142047882,
0.4639986753463745,
0.4229954183101654,
0.2736196517944336,
0.44332727789878845,
0.7080734372138977,
1.2439172267913818,
0.07352257519960403,
0.3155921697616577,
-0.10886521637439728,
-0.2220303863286972,
-0.14711344242095947,
-0.782839834690094,
-1.1667379140853882,
-0.4589139521121979,
-0.2778022885322571,
-0.23217511177062988,
0.043738123029470444,
1.0021342039108276,
0.6260362267494202,
-0.492446631193161,
-0.48610609769821167,
-0.25354456901550293,
-0.02614077553153038,
0.16883385181427002,
-0.25985080003738403,
-0.2956838309764862,
-0.6772774457931519,
-0.9940404891967773,
0.5001202821731567,
0.3873634934425354,
-0.2155291885137558,
-0.28131425380706787,
-0.1130712628364563,
0.17558692395687103,
0.3327380120754242,
0.6774752736091614,
0.25647181272506714,
-0.7340613603591919,
-0.2748776376247406,
-0.1453968584537506,
0.05889106169342995,
0.25502458214759827,
1.2878408432006836,
-0.8188629150390625,
0.35672807693481445,
0.403614342212677,
0.3078238368034363,
0.5797204971313477,
0.2565651535987854,
0.6952213048934937,
-0.48238399624824524,
0.25853243470191956,
0.6031445860862732,
0.3335460424423218,
0.35493114590644836,
-0.1153784692287445,
0.27762800455093384,
0.13198082149028778,
-0.6551386713981628,
-0.8608542084693909,
0.30795231461524963,
-1.1147596836090088,
-0.3600790798664093,
1.258073329925537,
-0.1408897489309311,
-0.2902109622955322,
-0.38371556997299194,
-0.4339393377304077,
0.1063212901353836,
-0.544937789440155,
0.6258212327957153,
0.7844507694244385,
-0.30395108461380005,
-0.22090382874011993,
-0.5246814489364624,
0.48329612612724304,
0.5792103409767151,
-0.9883895516395569,
0.0745706632733345,
0.4856165647506714,
0.12819691002368927,
0.12307927012443542,
0.9915637969970703,
-0.14277389645576477,
-0.09944646060466766,
-0.3292812407016754,
0.17131353914737701,
0.21918825805187225,
-0.2079453468322754,
0.0941474512219429,
-0.005737625062465668,
0.3046592175960541,
0.20441538095474243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17205v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17205v3
|
Measuring Vision-Language STEM Skills of Neural Models
| 2024-02-27T04:55:03 | 2024-05-22T05:11:56 |
Jianhao Shen, Ye Yuan, Srbuhi Mirzoyan, Ming Zhang, Chenguang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We introduce a new challenge to test the STEM skills of neural models. The
problems in the real world often require solutions, combining knowledge from
STEM (science, technology, engineering, and math). Unlike existing datasets,
our dataset requires the understanding of multimodal vision-language
information of STEM. Our dataset features one of the largest and most
comprehensive datasets for the challenge. It includes 448 skills and 1,073,146
questions spanning all STEM subjects. Compared to existing datasets that often
focus on examining expert-level ability, our dataset includes fundamental
skills and questions designed based on the K-12 curriculum. We also add
state-of-the-art foundation models such as CLIP and GPT-3.5-Turbo to our
benchmark. Results show that the recent model advances only help master a very
limited number of lower grade-level skills (2.5% in the third grade) in our
dataset. In fact, these models are still well below (averaging 54.7%) the
performance of elementary students, not to mention near expert-level
performance. To understand and increase the performance on our dataset, we
teach the models on a training split of our dataset. Even though we observe
improved performance, the model performance remains relatively low compared to
average elementary students. To solve STEM problems, we will need novel
algorithmic innovations from the community.
|
[
-0.3095608651638031,
-0.6805118322372437,
0.3117840588092804,
0.1564626544713974,
-0.022867312654852867,
0.4470635652542114,
-0.11240363866090775,
-0.4101063311100006,
0.113983154296875,
0.18574197590351105,
-0.7316446304321289,
-0.476580947637558,
-0.6750644445419312,
-0.1943165510892868,
-0.49819231033325195,
0.4891762137413025,
0.13362739980220795,
0.49197396636009216,
-0.4420895576477051,
0.1575743854045868,
-0.7070691585540771,
-0.25861021876335144,
-0.5651068687438965,
-0.21408449113368988,
0.4172461926937103,
0.685590386390686,
0.24518688023090363,
0.6107032895088196,
0.9281687140464783,
0.19545291364192963,
-0.30763792991638184,
0.051151253283023834,
-0.1846485286951065,
-0.14875762164592743,
-0.10735028982162476,
-0.5193110108375549,
-0.4082350432872772,
0.09793797135353088,
0.4213019907474518,
1.2923142910003662,
0.1867586076259613,
0.14865490794181824,
-0.10897480696439743,
0.6932446956634521,
-0.3024759888648987,
0.28881436586380005,
-0.8124545216560364,
0.12081149965524673,
-0.06576729565858841,
0.03299979120492935,
-0.279518723487854,
-0.4714885652065277,
0.36901214718818665,
-0.5163417458534241,
0.48518458008766174,
-0.1473570615053177,
0.8588898181915283,
0.29581326246261597,
-0.35249969363212585,
0.06524807959794998,
-0.47053223848342896,
0.7536624670028687,
-0.2974378764629364,
0.3896295130252838,
0.20682097971439362,
0.4550303816795349,
0.13755284249782562,
-0.4338048994541168,
-0.3477378785610199,
-0.3269158601760864,
0.5304012298583984,
0.2932673990726471,
-0.1359976828098297,
-0.09419765323400497,
0.15688996016979218,
0.26893138885498047,
-0.5970227718353271,
0.16362276673316956,
-0.8812355399131775,
-0.1908549666404724,
0.5285985469818115,
0.3018527626991272,
0.09442092478275299,
-0.11005332320928574,
-0.28540661931037903,
-0.5136929154396057,
-0.6715757846832275,
0.24782957136631012,
0.40787217020988464,
0.30306005477905273,
0.20422612130641937,
0.7282567024230957,
-0.2778262197971344,
0.6783878803253174,
-0.15682095289230347,
-0.022947847843170166,
0.2992568910121918,
-0.6478304266929626,
0.10744352638721466,
-0.35249263048171997,
0.3588542938232422,
0.5915170907974243,
0.6550557017326355,
-0.0014207307249307632,
-0.031101662665605545,
0.24342992901802063,
-0.0034567546099424362,
-0.5975641012191772,
-0.4945377707481384,
-0.2752459943294525,
-0.33792662620544434,
-0.27301281690597534,
-0.20371556282043457,
-0.6508958339691162,
-0.4261232912540436,
-0.4762647747993469,
0.2849588990211487,
-0.6415783762931824,
-0.46212995052337646,
0.20592688024044037,
-0.28346842527389526,
0.07680202275514603,
0.38289785385131836,
-0.960551381111145,
0.36537373065948486,
0.6888601779937744,
0.835777223110199,
-0.49700063467025757,
-0.6250251531600952,
0.005472126416862011,
-0.5694530010223389,
-0.44816115498542786,
0.72502201795578,
-0.5053846836090088,
-0.16222083568572998,
-0.25922858715057373,
-0.22387272119522095,
-0.3411332070827484,
-0.6695165038108826,
0.195010706782341,
-0.2475154846906662,
-0.23105528950691223,
-0.4200291335582733,
-0.5585756897926331,
-0.13977424800395966,
0.20023663341999054,
-0.4809809625148773,
1.0072168111801147,
0.24154126644134521,
-0.36929771304130554,
0.5371966361999512,
-0.7923176884651184,
-0.36586302518844604,
0.13970056176185608,
-0.1510283201932907,
-0.12154049426317215,
0.3226422667503357,
0.2833668887615204,
0.41101762652397156,
-0.15002785623073578,
0.4432888329029083,
-0.2806268036365509,
-0.12543551623821259,
0.11790856719017029,
-0.5251200795173645,
0.8376809358596802,
-0.105808325111866,
-0.06844569742679596,
0.19739146530628204,
-0.8433244824409485,
0.16512100398540497,
0.04477187618613243,
0.014192374423146248,
-0.18748563528060913,
0.021367160603404045,
0.29780855774879456,
0.27580034732818604,
0.2087439000606537,
-0.7515032887458801,
0.13532480597496033,
-0.4419180154800415,
0.6059646606445312,
0.8881077766418457,
-0.17710456252098083,
0.3190038800239563,
-0.11318689584732056,
0.5935964584350586,
0.12649141252040863,
0.30901339650154114,
-0.23584109544754028,
-0.8720610737800598,
-0.7927840352058411,
-0.09742865711450577,
0.2856820225715637,
0.49488988518714905,
-0.5962936282157898,
0.25511372089385986,
-0.27105817198753357,
-0.8030218482017517,
-0.6291566491127014,
-0.061281729489564896,
0.3631610572338104,
0.9111425876617432,
0.5660909414291382,
-0.43859046697616577,
-0.38056209683418274,
-1.0542525053024292,
0.027588821947574615,
-0.08373453468084335,
0.11085556447505951,
0.3373994529247284,
0.906164824962616,
0.36943310499191284,
1.1294220685958862,
-0.6975983381271362,
-0.11855567991733551,
-0.11034354567527771,
0.22983908653259277,
0.18720543384552002,
0.6298612356185913,
0.5562689900398254,
-0.8909002542495728,
-0.3034777343273163,
-0.04147966206073761,
-0.7680975198745728,
0.1575220823287964,
0.32231441140174866,
0.1491074413061142,
-0.18537501990795135,
0.3125108778476715,
-0.3991259038448334,
0.504782497882843,
0.41659343242645264,
-0.5118401646614075,
0.6334335803985596,
0.0033998850267380476,
0.07238012552261353,
-0.8328593969345093,
-0.011270815506577492,
0.024441545829176903,
0.2774752080440521,
-0.5862694978713989,
0.0343647338449955,
0.22784462571144104,
-0.4123331606388092,
-0.6608371734619141,
0.4032178223133087,
-0.30199843645095825,
-0.34638509154319763,
-0.16594967246055603,
-0.10919123888015747,
-0.17516644299030304,
0.4413430094718933,
0.11229894310235977,
0.8624622821807861,
0.9008591771125793,
-0.4222908318042755,
0.5939100980758667,
0.09980481117963791,
-0.6300597786903381,
0.6470950841903687,
-0.9313175678253174,
-0.018813112750649452,
-0.03162556141614914,
-0.20189787447452545,
-0.9728868007659912,
-0.2820695638656616,
-0.2799849510192871,
-0.6237725019454956,
-0.10679885745048523,
-0.12749654054641724,
-0.39246436953544617,
-0.5932028293609619,
0.046036235988140106,
0.22030001878738403,
0.4415556490421295,
-0.3581446707248688,
0.5917773246765137,
0.27209436893463135,
-0.22910621762275696,
-0.6865034699440002,
-0.7050802707672119,
0.06889385730028152,
0.12791460752487183,
-0.9893814325332642,
0.3383841812610626,
-0.2604998052120209,
0.0018440561834722757,
0.27459773421287537,
-0.13086974620819092,
-0.5716016292572021,
0.4058206081390381,
0.11410976201295853,
0.5234113335609436,
-0.4487929940223694,
0.1465752124786377,
-0.0018674146849662066,
-0.23144285380840302,
0.14946016669273376,
-0.3135996460914612,
0.4899318814277649,
-0.3643015921115875,
-0.6760329604148865,
-0.36992400884628296,
0.20348376035690308,
0.7980495095252991,
-0.5396901965141296,
0.40098947286605835,
0.23338137567043304,
-0.5120393633842468,
-0.012542901560664177,
-0.46527326107025146,
-0.5065132975578308,
-0.41386741399765015,
0.8848047852516174,
-0.4957261383533478,
-0.8331702351570129,
0.4828294813632965,
0.14805491268634796,
-0.02909982018172741,
0.23686985671520233,
0.31419920921325684,
-0.15293645858764648,
1.061618685722351,
0.7537669539451599,
0.005237521603703499,
0.24186979234218597,
-0.48953765630722046,
0.19521941244602203,
-0.6143718957901001,
-0.5882558226585388,
-0.27850672602653503,
-0.44384148716926575,
0.007285434287041426,
-0.35488593578338623,
0.2773028016090393,
0.035380326211452484,
0.08613123744726181,
0.3745948076248169,
-0.6002180576324463,
0.6717311143875122,
0.7911294102668762,
0.17857477068901062,
0.24275264143943787,
0.056302618235349655,
-0.13396324217319489,
-0.3399061858654022,
-0.6668347120285034,
-0.08030768483877182,
1.2275022268295288,
0.3836323320865631,
0.5598281621932983,
-0.3448880612850189,
0.28566551208496094,
-0.20938807725906372,
0.08702489733695984,
-1.0326865911483765,
0.6781301498413086,
-0.2811262309551239,
-0.7803714871406555,
-0.22781454026699066,
-0.3492227792739868,
-0.5505114197731018,
0.16379877924919128,
-0.13600260019302368,
-0.26961567997932434,
0.2840801179409027,
0.23860004544258118,
-0.339529812335968,
0.39613980054855347,
-0.9425965547561646,
0.9855713248252869,
-0.2748299241065979,
-0.1783994883298874,
-0.17312337458133698,
-0.5272952914237976,
0.1865566223859787,
-0.056787386536598206,
-0.05253865197300911,
-0.3470165729522705,
0.05888965725898743,
0.8308531045913696,
-0.13587114214897156,
0.932127058506012,
-0.2902207672595978,
0.3323466181755066,
0.2883438169956207,
-0.23066303133964539,
-0.12108608335256577,
-0.24788019061088562,
0.11496175825595856,
0.10736411809921265,
-0.18476814031600952,
-0.44955578446388245,
-0.47766122221946716,
0.6029717326164246,
-0.7674089670181274,
-0.43104127049446106,
-0.4477219879627228,
-0.8429225087165833,
-0.3356415331363678,
0.21118465065956116,
0.21070361137390137,
0.384368896484375,
-0.008582272566854954,
0.6034291386604309,
0.8532335758209229,
0.19192954897880554,
0.39450305700302124,
0.48697659373283386,
-0.21509724855422974,
-0.3189869225025177,
1.2185555696487427,
0.48280343413352966,
0.3313697874546051,
0.04220465570688248,
0.2974749207496643,
-0.11718416213989258,
-0.8762739300727844,
-0.3298752009868622,
0.014283510856330395,
-0.7787042856216431,
-0.15228433907032013,
-0.5053287148475647,
-0.37681466341018677,
-0.3937465250492096,
-0.04931233450770378,
-0.5581062436103821,
-0.5217799544334412,
-0.2778626084327698,
-0.32208865880966187,
0.4108377695083618,
0.7284060716629028,
-0.0002538026019465178,
0.1847781240940094,
-0.49898761510849,
0.10597463697195053,
0.45911678671836853,
0.322053998708725,
0.0400463305413723,
-0.39346638321876526,
-0.13190238177776337,
-0.034135852009058,
-0.2684977948665619,
-0.8031076788902283,
0.2685486376285553,
0.25173312425613403,
0.45065075159072876,
0.11676590889692307,
-0.4635198414325714,
0.6914700865745544,
-0.5943652391433716,
0.7711086273193359,
0.3189372718334198,
-0.8429054617881775,
0.6823181509971619,
-0.25269177556037903,
0.07726596295833588,
0.6995207071304321,
0.40799498558044434,
-0.35237327218055725,
-0.21605253219604492,
-0.5497896075248718,
-0.6727616786956787,
0.6250740885734558,
0.046591516584157944,
0.1448361873626709,
0.12672889232635498,
0.26720377802848816,
-0.07502686232328415,
0.237723708152771,
-0.4549739956855774,
-0.2765943109989166,
-0.4687938690185547,
-0.36382433772087097,
0.16697388887405396,
0.14514368772506714,
0.10173502564430237,
-0.6891682147979736,
0.31881722807884216,
-0.25923582911491394,
-0.06376606971025467,
-0.0788152813911438,
0.1738836169242859,
0.12096630781888962,
-0.05703222379088402,
0.6318201422691345,
0.9700754284858704,
-0.11345979571342468,
0.014283159747719765,
0.14379936456680298,
-0.8926774859428406,
-0.014469468034803867,
-0.00688422005623579,
-0.26502928137779236,
-0.1838364452123642,
0.4237639307975769,
0.650652289390564,
0.21540488302707672,
-0.7872726917266846,
0.6911565661430359,
0.0367291197180748,
-0.5614071488380432,
-0.3531785011291504,
0.15515199303627014,
0.2681756913661957,
-0.050148479640483856,
0.734126627445221,
0.7562255859375,
-0.06388683617115021,
-0.23622071743011475,
0.37106451392173767,
0.2242027372121811,
-0.5507039427757263,
-0.39326298236846924,
0.4053599238395691,
0.2786850929260254,
-0.1890093833208084,
0.7173640131950378,
0.04774713143706322,
-0.5517784953117371,
1.2345101833343506,
0.4201008677482605,
0.4956166744232178,
-0.20034177601337433,
0.23418724536895752,
0.5223654508590698,
0.5645755529403687,
-0.19365620613098145,
0.5639523267745972,
0.3275415301322937,
-0.8481447696685791,
-0.6353380084037781,
-0.2563038468360901,
-0.5063839554786682,
0.16005584597587585,
-0.6798639893531799,
0.11384310573339462,
-0.44187265634536743,
-0.08310628682374954,
0.06234430521726608,
-0.20223566889762878,
-0.6534730792045593,
0.4796271026134491,
-0.22356463968753815,
1.2019414901733398,
-1.1829732656478882,
0.8204723596572876,
0.6945362091064453,
-0.5236980319023132,
-0.6487048268318176,
-0.5242903828620911,
-0.03650180995464325,
-1.00343656539917,
1.171111822128296,
0.17258411645889282,
-0.011863990686833858,
0.21045061945915222,
-0.6552748680114746,
-0.9125729203224182,
1.0094413757324219,
0.4084985554218292,
-0.48512494564056396,
-0.3133241832256317,
0.013513048179447651,
0.5609560608863831,
-0.5884285569190979,
0.21427308022975922,
0.35900720953941345,
0.29334598779678345,
0.26351216435432434,
-0.854775071144104,
-0.6149245500564575,
-0.3998600244522095,
-0.027796657755970955,
-0.13025987148284912,
-0.33994320034980774,
1.0243831872940063,
-0.2755555510520935,
0.08540521562099457,
-0.032974716275930405,
0.8552932143211365,
0.314319908618927,
0.4239484965801239,
0.5116382241249084,
0.6417626738548279,
0.7746319770812988,
-0.4781807065010071,
0.703981876373291,
-0.2575835883617401,
0.2998769283294678,
0.9869200587272644,
-0.06839019060134888,
1.0281312465667725,
0.6402248740196228,
-0.036941759288311005,
0.06965099275112152,
0.67597496509552,
-0.40505510568618774,
0.4491635859012604,
0.3504812717437744,
0.010751839727163315,
-0.5286593437194824,
-0.3527989685535431,
-0.4413914084434509,
0.4811009466648102,
0.2878322899341583,
-0.0946761816740036,
-0.02002888172864914,
0.4376230537891388,
-0.23867787420749664,
0.3763812482357025,
-0.4314662516117096,
0.15344054996967316,
-0.11380831897258759,
-0.6307891011238098,
0.36475610733032227,
-0.259239137172699,
0.7970911860466003,
-0.5135781168937683,
-0.23060834407806396,
-0.17176590859889984,
0.25135260820388794,
-0.029652612283825874,
-1.0875669717788696,
0.3130147159099579,
-0.006846877280622721,
-0.38856905698776245,
-0.2218635082244873,
0.5799505114555359,
-0.31256067752838135,
-0.8370344638824463,
0.3182188868522644,
0.49306902289390564,
0.12703494727611542,
-0.08328745514154434,
-0.5894900560379028,
-0.07997379451990128,
-0.0932328850030899,
0.1811106652021408,
0.03159987926483154,
0.09527035802602768,
0.09067699313163757,
0.8711711168289185,
0.6429449319839478,
0.2508232295513153,
0.5588797330856323,
0.019296783953905106,
0.8698318600654602,
-0.389384925365448,
-0.14089855551719666,
-0.533703088760376,
0.561055064201355,
-0.292580783367157,
-0.9115636348724365,
0.5979946851730347,
0.6310998201370239,
1.0523223876953125,
-0.22222261130809784,
0.6908602714538574,
0.030865570530295372,
0.5905309319496155,
-0.4026981592178345,
0.6540780663490295,
-0.5429612994194031,
-0.14633871614933014,
-0.10605055093765259,
-0.7277024388313293,
-0.2737988829612732,
0.6444279551506042,
-0.3493977189064026,
0.10568509250879288,
0.8993669748306274,
0.7242342829704285,
-0.11839395761489868,
0.13396301865577698,
0.47109174728393555,
-0.06840359419584274,
0.1569899022579193,
0.8988567590713501,
0.9565503597259521,
-0.4238146245479584,
0.5644508004188538,
-0.5995083451271057,
-0.47286391258239746,
-0.022206803783774376,
-0.6888372302055359,
-1.150542974472046,
-0.6198791861534119,
-0.4012622535228729,
0.0691705048084259,
0.1105223223567009,
0.6127909421920776,
1.0285303592681885,
-0.788523256778717,
-0.2539653182029724,
-0.4220966100692749,
-0.018888743594288826,
-0.5490514039993286,
-0.19478000700473785,
0.4065042734146118,
-0.22201846539974213,
-0.7118975520133972,
0.9154679775238037,
0.012050509452819824,
0.09354591369628906,
-0.4691990911960602,
0.2788248658180237,
-0.13611437380313873,
-0.3662083148956299,
0.4661306142807007,
0.15899160504341125,
-0.7041600346565247,
-0.28208422660827637,
0.7921828031539917,
0.033598948270082474,
0.08664455264806747,
0.6937218904495239,
-0.6222959160804749,
0.4483289122581482,
0.6385239958763123,
0.8404374718666077,
0.2853390872478485,
-0.30961525440216064,
0.2909907400608063,
-0.6187121272087097,
-0.07957135140895844,
0.5459352135658264,
0.43303075432777405,
0.3633642792701721,
-0.02575184777379036,
0.5824646949768066,
0.6703411340713501,
-0.2242107391357422,
-0.7487430572509766,
0.3700498342514038,
-0.8431994915008545,
-0.16504152119159698,
0.583993136882782,
-0.26451224088668823,
-0.1770302653312683,
-0.15745238959789276,
-0.05186073109507561,
-0.14116601645946503,
-0.22137610614299774,
0.499251127243042,
0.9811900854110718,
-0.1264803409576416,
-0.24903948605060577,
-0.6557780504226685,
0.1726466864347458,
0.6867761015892029,
-0.7187631726264954,
-0.08700057119131088,
0.3411584198474884,
0.25073015689849854,
0.46695756912231445,
0.32863304018974304,
-0.10479316115379333,
0.5872548818588257,
0.0975724458694458,
0.2130161076784134,
-0.48058342933654785,
-1.0018463134765625,
-0.30911552906036377,
0.4716150462627411,
-0.07880807667970657,
-0.3057768642902374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17193v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17193v1
|
When Scaling Meets LLM Finetuning: The Effect of Data, Model and Finetuning Method
| 2024-02-27T04:18:49 | 2024-02-27T04:18:49 |
Biao Zhang, Zhongtao Liu, Colin Cherry, Orhan Firat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While large language models (LLMs) often adopt finetuning to unlock their
capabilities for downstream applications, our understanding on the inductive
biases (especially the scaling properties) of different finetuning methods is
still limited. To fill this gap, we conduct systematic experiments studying
whether and how different scaling factors, including LLM model size,
pretraining data size, new finetuning parameter size and finetuning data size,
affect the finetuning performance. We consider two types of finetuning --
full-model tuning (FMT) and parameter efficient tuning (PET, including prompt
tuning and LoRA), and explore their scaling behaviors in the data-limited
regime where the LLM model size substantially outweighs the finetuning data
size. Based on two sets of pretrained bilingual LLMs from 1B to 16B and
experiments on bilingual machine translation and multilingual summarization
benchmarks, we find that 1) LLM finetuning follows a powerbased multiplicative
joint scaling law between finetuning data size and each other scaling factor;
2) LLM finetuning benefits more from LLM model scaling than pretraining data
scaling, and PET parameter scaling is generally ineffective; and 3) the optimal
finetuning method is highly task- and finetuning data-dependent. We hope our
findings could shed light on understanding, selecting and developing LLM
finetuning methods.
|
[
-0.7606684565544128,
-0.8323110342025757,
0.3468859791755676,
0.39380210638046265,
-0.36459624767303467,
-0.4005849063396454,
-0.7278554439544678,
-0.35904762148857117,
-0.07933076471090317,
0.5292536020278931,
-0.5023915767669678,
0.06161350756883621,
-0.570098876953125,
0.3416381776332855,
-0.13395501673221588,
1.2023197412490845,
0.01646924391388893,
0.5282472968101501,
-0.08655793964862823,
-0.2372264266014099,
-0.2576747238636017,
-0.39385005831718445,
-0.6526820063591003,
-0.666103184223175,
0.5914334654808044,
0.7366824150085449,
0.8847174048423767,
1.058829426765442,
0.7736937999725342,
0.25220999121665955,
-0.21589919924736023,
0.022201301530003548,
-0.7018675804138184,
-0.1515398621559143,
-0.021638372913002968,
-0.9040510058403015,
-0.5257805585861206,
0.13709236681461334,
0.7025657892227173,
0.8643600344657898,
-0.011452079750597477,
0.26222512125968933,
0.3928748369216919,
0.7206377387046814,
-0.42140689492225647,
0.12613561749458313,
-0.5782400965690613,
-0.21959683299064636,
-0.3144136965274811,
-0.16092482209205627,
-0.19748644530773163,
-0.27080467343330383,
-0.10595963150262833,
-0.40284979343414307,
0.3737567067146301,
-0.04337243363261223,
0.809967577457428,
0.4859313368797302,
-0.5671862363815308,
-0.17134276032447815,
-0.7180373072624207,
0.8619981408119202,
-0.9723954200744629,
0.37217336893081665,
0.32133784890174866,
0.13262304663658142,
0.06778548657894135,
-0.4720458388328552,
-0.38482993841171265,
-0.25911960005760193,
-0.19547510147094727,
-0.2761649191379547,
0.15233470499515533,
0.26208195090293884,
0.6276923418045044,
0.9083511233329773,
-0.24181343615055084,
0.6611596345901489,
-0.3343399465084076,
-0.04260392114520073,
0.5387245416641235,
0.23048590123653412,
0.07443320006132126,
0.0030458110850304365,
-0.2169453352689743,
-0.06678721308708191,
-0.920242190361023,
-0.06245514750480652,
0.27152150869369507,
0.797049880027771,
-0.2785071134567261,
0.6219744086265564,
-0.2669357657432556,
0.6183364987373352,
0.3328686058521271,
-0.1750984489917755,
0.008866407908499241,
-0.7123213410377502,
-0.3619389235973358,
-0.08604047447443008,
0.7947588562965393,
0.7215884327888489,
0.4620082974433899,
-0.14671164751052856,
-0.24323666095733643,
-0.30237820744514465,
-0.1606726348400116,
-1.1484227180480957,
0.13058383762836456,
-0.10539642721414566,
-0.4210490882396698,
-0.2096359133720398,
-0.162295863032341,
-0.43831950426101685,
-0.48022499680519104,
-0.8059381246566772,
0.6656351089477539,
-0.2200232297182083,
-0.30482280254364014,
-0.0369153767824173,
0.2106095850467682,
0.5003429055213928,
0.18529078364372253,
-1.3137338161468506,
0.3488614857196808,
0.6881083846092224,
0.8789260983467102,
-0.2158845067024231,
-0.29149043560028076,
-0.5844309329986572,
-0.37336239218711853,
-0.3071959316730499,
0.4566965699195862,
-0.008521677926182747,
-0.100939080119133,
-0.17763791978359222,
0.1817854642868042,
-0.09094809740781784,
-0.7691006660461426,
0.5318506956100464,
-0.3523041903972626,
-0.29819101095199585,
-0.4336220324039459,
-0.47230350971221924,
0.011460711248219013,
0.08562508225440979,
-0.9207130074501038,
0.4995831549167633,
-0.10354762524366379,
-0.7299709320068359,
0.6577521562576294,
-0.27178382873535156,
-0.5464279055595398,
-0.34391868114471436,
0.0058578262105584145,
-0.36527058482170105,
0.31481456756591797,
0.16757120192050934,
0.7497698664665222,
-0.6579674482345581,
0.03837618976831436,
-0.31034812331199646,
-0.2599563002586365,
0.17577287554740906,
-0.6325892806053162,
0.6646987199783325,
0.15272119641304016,
-0.10459376126527786,
0.06180901825428009,
-0.8393479585647583,
0.016025565564632416,
0.10790867358446121,
-0.6214606761932373,
-0.2777901291847229,
-0.100591279566288,
0.2469664216041565,
0.09540971368551254,
0.30386924743652344,
-0.612829327583313,
0.18691344559192657,
-0.48096880316734314,
0.610100507736206,
0.5446191430091858,
-0.05215948075056076,
0.6585128903388977,
-0.4991762638092041,
0.3913724720478058,
-0.25679585337638855,
-0.02838614024221897,
-0.0665942057967186,
0.03542976453900337,
-0.8790736198425293,
-0.12315153330564499,
0.5375901460647583,
0.34400373697280884,
-0.26882413029670715,
-0.03264669328927994,
-0.21229776740074158,
-0.44191765785217285,
-0.4861624240875244,
0.22274309396743774,
0.28229543566703796,
0.17516182363033295,
0.31272363662719727,
-0.13467642664909363,
-0.3766947090625763,
-1.0727665424346924,
-0.2671516537666321,
0.3810558319091797,
-0.28623494505882263,
0.12977518141269684,
0.14872421324253082,
-0.0032234282698482275,
0.6665445566177368,
-0.14460480213165283,
-0.2852616310119629,
-0.4207644760608673,
0.11568927019834518,
0.259418249130249,
0.5110377073287964,
0.6026606559753418,
-0.49981680512428284,
-0.6134823560714722,
0.1512841284275055,
-0.2698378264904022,
-0.23539060354232788,
-0.1652435064315796,
0.2845441997051239,
0.22823581099510193,
0.6971890330314636,
-0.4363277852535248,
0.0037537910975515842,
0.6362913250923157,
-0.06553567200899124,
0.48287755250930786,
-0.3013688623905182,
0.06370929628610611,
-0.7724927067756653,
-0.3342609703540802,
0.08672026544809341,
-0.2398170679807663,
-0.714747428894043,
0.2227344810962677,
0.24203287065029144,
0.27615872025489807,
-0.380075067281723,
0.15988260507583618,
-0.45028817653656006,
-0.10952219367027283,
-0.22638390958309174,
-0.04756569862365723,
-0.12426915764808655,
0.322409451007843,
-0.22694207727909088,
0.9048373699188232,
0.3613404333591461,
-0.6277081370353699,
-0.013611647300422192,
-0.1796898990869522,
-0.4167114496231079,
0.41607317328453064,
-0.6020738482475281,
-0.15811511874198914,
0.011592065915465355,
-0.09492452442646027,
-0.8671221733093262,
-0.10355481505393982,
-0.4003657102584839,
-0.11595887690782547,
0.546747088432312,
-0.1426878273487091,
-0.8334738612174988,
0.02090321108698845,
-0.3494291603565216,
0.38103991746902466,
0.11881440877914429,
-0.6357057094573975,
0.4220845401287079,
-0.060804884880781174,
-0.2000763714313507,
-0.07395443320274353,
-0.8657454252243042,
-0.2984519600868225,
-0.5820817351341248,
-0.6139696836471558,
0.22669169306755066,
-0.19619156420230865,
-0.40969839692115784,
-0.6017864942550659,
-0.17450545728206635,
-0.08497373759746552,
0.11886636912822723,
0.13536560535430908,
0.13301004469394684,
-0.48795589804649353,
-0.022739607840776443,
0.023953141644597054,
-0.006681779399514198,
0.12577754259109497,
0.1314345747232437,
0.6689081788063049,
-0.348958820104599,
0.07443434000015259,
-0.38675761222839355,
0.08154061436653137,
0.8696065545082092,
-0.36960139870643616,
0.7359526753425598,
0.6401662230491638,
0.00739225372672081,
0.0031858948059380054,
-0.6164836287498474,
-0.34866324067115784,
-0.486152321100235,
0.3336441218852997,
-0.3716925382614136,
-0.7952649593353271,
0.7112874984741211,
-0.21412253379821777,
0.30927735567092896,
0.6525702476501465,
0.8002033829689026,
-0.004599747247993946,
1.0279728174209595,
0.8818690776824951,
0.04273037239909172,
0.5838572978973389,
-0.25066930055618286,
-0.06706324219703674,
-0.9166989922523499,
0.322474867105484,
-0.510820746421814,
-0.5852099657058716,
-1.1010202169418335,
-0.30888012051582336,
0.17172512412071228,
0.3308318555355072,
-0.35060712695121765,
0.10970848053693771,
-0.1081530824303627,
0.6813334822654724,
0.39455336332321167,
-0.028613200411200523,
0.5894166827201843,
0.020229894667863846,
-0.09214092791080475,
-0.12414242327213287,
-0.6299494504928589,
-0.262320339679718,
1.4679759740829468,
0.3520154058933258,
0.9879063963890076,
0.05165506899356842,
0.38380229473114014,
-0.18942412734031677,
0.2799243628978729,
-1.030079960823059,
0.2658848464488983,
-0.36332833766937256,
-0.5354570746421814,
-0.5758258104324341,
-0.32328471541404724,
-0.8426046371459961,
0.41594594717025757,
-0.2951186001300812,
-0.3829393684864044,
0.08886497467756271,
0.013556853868067265,
-0.43566110730171204,
0.2587149441242218,
-0.8367748856544495,
0.572974443435669,
-0.2875306308269501,
-0.43468597531318665,
-0.3055800795555115,
-0.6123465895652771,
0.1597314029932022,
-0.26717644929885864,
0.3371787965297699,
-0.11476553231477737,
0.026215581223368645,
0.6873193979263306,
-0.4440440237522125,
0.7338346242904663,
0.02252199873328209,
-0.38498204946517944,
-0.004705166444182396,
0.10059349983930588,
0.49063441157341003,
0.01850922964513302,
-0.07395657896995544,
0.17982318997383118,
0.07197083532810211,
-0.19910404086112976,
-0.36166349053382874,
0.8807986378669739,
-0.8704385161399841,
-0.544514536857605,
0.14950038492679596,
-0.7830667495727539,
-0.4165748953819275,
0.3195820152759552,
0.47776153683662415,
0.30083200335502625,
-0.02299877442419529,
0.6073476076126099,
0.661413311958313,
0.14793923497200012,
0.5105437636375427,
0.7400854825973511,
-0.23944108188152313,
-0.10327202081680298,
0.8199836015701294,
0.5751426815986633,
0.8833661675453186,
0.35258838534355164,
0.31636422872543335,
0.08336726576089859,
-0.6487638354301453,
-0.3653056025505066,
0.4331852197647095,
-0.36839503049850464,
-0.1303166002035141,
-0.1689479649066925,
-0.19593264162540436,
-0.06823104619979858,
-0.05109157785773277,
-0.6778602004051208,
-0.5602930784225464,
-0.2568936347961426,
-0.18058523535728455,
0.44061076641082764,
0.45948174595832825,
-0.13385486602783203,
0.47330576181411743,
-0.3982897400856018,
0.2864626348018646,
0.31712624430656433,
0.4963248074054718,
-0.01990588568150997,
-0.48729434609413147,
-0.5114957690238953,
0.13444434106349945,
-0.22698377072811127,
-0.3359740376472473,
-0.05013661086559296,
0.33712655305862427,
0.25491705536842346,
0.5753043293952942,
-0.13108541071414948,
0.5256950259208679,
-0.6292396187782288,
0.5095238089561462,
-0.03942513093352318,
-0.5239142179489136,
0.23907077312469482,
-0.5691589713096619,
0.4816752076148987,
0.5104345679283142,
0.3314853012561798,
-0.2810223698616028,
-0.38985347747802734,
-0.27245160937309265,
-0.8526358604431152,
0.5451686382293701,
0.030223743990063667,
0.17671310901641846,
0.27151674032211304,
0.5167325139045715,
0.42055055499076843,
-0.05842301622033119,
-0.781378984451294,
-0.39518600702285767,
0.10500878840684891,
0.20637215673923492,
-0.5121976137161255,
-0.25265347957611084,
-0.011563987471163273,
-0.37480443716049194,
0.3185160756111145,
-0.13025973737239838,
0.09812178462743759,
-0.02696169726550579,
-0.084529347717762,
-0.2787145972251892,
0.4685381352901459,
0.5635342597961426,
0.5330567955970764,
-0.27207034826278687,
-0.03778519108891487,
0.30051669478416443,
-0.37909266352653503,
-0.04494884982705116,
0.1354203224182129,
-0.17713536322116852,
-0.23286350071430206,
0.441946417093277,
0.8089671730995178,
0.17448337376117706,
-0.43661168217658997,
0.16547736525535583,
-0.11327394843101501,
-0.4150640368461609,
0.15529119968414307,
0.22402305901050568,
0.1756444275379181,
0.314225435256958,
0.09498479217290878,
-0.15821626782417297,
-0.03882110118865967,
-0.41837358474731445,
-0.03697872534394264,
0.45324254035949707,
-0.22671355307102203,
-0.15435859560966492,
0.6448107361793518,
0.005153147503733635,
0.007355656009167433,
0.4705144166946411,
0.21683181822299957,
-0.009849071502685547,
0.7111207246780396,
0.5765554904937744,
0.3203033208847046,
-0.2501886188983917,
-0.23646683990955353,
0.4218272268772125,
0.4596959948539734,
-0.14161138236522675,
-0.07055823504924774,
-0.11465229094028473,
-0.612828254699707,
-0.6085090041160583,
-0.6617109179496765,
-0.26165783405303955,
0.40812066197395325,
-0.9510895609855652,
0.3323478102684021,
-0.47713226079940796,
-0.27376261353492737,
0.23705503344535828,
0.2238059788942337,
-0.7692594528198242,
0.22538691759109497,
0.0625310018658638,
0.7562070488929749,
-0.8127105832099915,
0.7076939940452576,
0.5007243156433105,
-0.3562612235546112,
-0.8761758208274841,
0.08770879358053207,
0.16196945309638977,
-0.6740713715553284,
0.4204280376434326,
0.13007178902626038,
-0.01607343927025795,
0.1714443862438202,
-0.38894885778427124,
-1.1161985397338867,
1.0956743955612183,
0.4928095042705536,
-0.7835813760757446,
-0.012793774716556072,
0.48963773250579834,
0.5051368474960327,
-0.17216448485851288,
0.011700186878442764,
0.986467719078064,
0.30801922082901,
-0.08998885750770569,
-1.471572995185852,
0.01182211097329855,
0.05464601889252663,
-0.15795373916625977,
0.2631794810295105,
-0.9816768169403076,
1.0873723030090332,
-0.19793790578842163,
0.016986390575766563,
0.05366893485188484,
0.4486956298351288,
-0.09670577943325043,
-0.042871974408626556,
0.4469740092754364,
0.46698129177093506,
0.58000648021698,
-0.05652661621570587,
0.8773810267448425,
-0.22055916488170624,
0.530266523361206,
1.1560437679290771,
0.0533960796892643,
0.7543959617614746,
0.6775684952735901,
-0.3685494065284729,
0.006028370466083288,
0.6805155873298645,
-0.01470185536891222,
0.39062178134918213,
0.3421422243118286,
0.09437274187803268,
-0.09455498307943344,
-0.1954132318496704,
-0.48563152551651,
0.3486565351486206,
0.35744813084602356,
-0.39413076639175415,
-0.3204687833786011,
0.47688618302345276,
0.24802830815315247,
-0.10719921439886093,
-0.7347509264945984,
0.6999197602272034,
0.15806922316551208,
-0.4660506546497345,
0.9509067535400391,
0.20837193727493286,
0.830947995185852,
-0.3974197804927826,
0.46629416942596436,
-0.5959794521331787,
0.28762951493263245,
-0.2291872799396515,
-0.6114896535873413,
0.21521292626857758,
0.07504305243492126,
-0.40623390674591064,
-0.3279169499874115,
0.31244197487831116,
-0.3644353151321411,
-0.3745957016944885,
0.12150030583143234,
0.32528963685035706,
-0.0048724450170993805,
-0.10523205995559692,
-0.20234233140945435,
0.04740762338042259,
0.014810607768595219,
-0.3845941126346588,
0.6182394623756409,
0.5652576684951782,
-0.05907536298036575,
0.6491855382919312,
0.3642156422138214,
0.2949354350566864,
0.13404066860675812,
0.31505513191223145,
0.6862661838531494,
-0.37674468755722046,
-0.2059372514486313,
-0.9722228050231934,
0.24067345261573792,
0.33091703057289124,
-0.05708537623286247,
0.9088672399520874,
0.6509483456611633,
0.9397421479225159,
0.015431375242769718,
0.3283003270626068,
0.06854446232318878,
0.32596316933631897,
-0.6592838764190674,
0.6707141995429993,
-0.5703648924827576,
0.1110079437494278,
-0.03364713490009308,
-1.0218687057495117,
-0.3340073823928833,
0.3282374441623688,
-0.4290456175804138,
0.02877233922481537,
0.5930508375167847,
0.7231566905975342,
-0.16792288422584534,
0.007328533101826906,
0.29115280508995056,
0.5060994625091553,
0.10954535007476807,
0.3412454128265381,
0.34053099155426025,
-0.24839593470096588,
0.4473591148853302,
-0.37496697902679443,
-0.21511340141296387,
-0.2159782201051712,
-0.6121350526809692,
-0.9861302375793457,
-0.4525330662727356,
-0.16967003047466278,
-0.0445450022816658,
-0.39659327268600464,
0.8054388165473938,
0.5810312628746033,
-0.582476019859314,
-0.3735049366950989,
-0.21564702689647675,
0.0060841720551252365,
-0.17468658089637756,
-0.24397015571594238,
0.21089483797550201,
-0.41143175959587097,
-0.7046884894371033,
0.06649049371480942,
-0.024580970406532288,
0.2263820618391037,
-0.2847789227962494,
0.03862466290593147,
0.042287275195121765,
0.15392865240573883,
0.6137639284133911,
0.13402314484119415,
-0.6638597249984741,
0.00387016823515296,
-0.2667345106601715,
-0.2115071564912796,
0.19365055859088898,
0.8331776857376099,
-0.38665536046028137,
0.31004559993743896,
0.2956909239292145,
0.4721616506576538,
0.6831929087638855,
-0.1312417984008789,
0.5993283987045288,
-0.5825559496879578,
0.162874236702919,
-0.2437681406736374,
0.11090219020843506,
0.2089705765247345,
-0.3135387897491455,
0.4290454089641571,
-0.26769906282424927,
-0.7675848007202148,
-0.6962331533432007,
0.0658305212855339,
-0.7425625920295715,
-0.03376944363117218,
1.2029656171798706,
0.21136540174484253,
0.12924081087112427,
0.4312160909175873,
-0.26439782977104187,
0.2442854642868042,
0.00342172640375793,
0.3863123655319214,
0.9042799472808838,
-0.29957616329193115,
-0.16144585609436035,
-1.0890731811523438,
0.6499245762825012,
0.504020094871521,
-0.42774978280067444,
0.5425889492034912,
0.37678852677345276,
0.3818982243537903,
-0.087035171687603,
0.30852946639060974,
0.04872134327888489,
0.09093811362981796,
-0.23669885098934174,
-0.33267122507095337,
0.02525940351188183,
-0.11129909008741379,
-0.5394192934036255,
-0.024667805060744286,
0.407091349363327,
0.19106866419315338
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14657v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14657v1
|
A Synergistic Approach to Wildfire Prevention and Management Using AI, ML, and 5G Technology in the United States
| 2024-02-27T04:09:30 | 2024-02-27T04:09:30 |
Stanley Chinedu Okoro, Alexander Lopez, Austine Unuriode
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
Over the past few years, wildfires have become a worldwide environmental
emergency, resulting in substantial harm to natural habitats and playing a part
in the acceleration of climate change. Wildfire management methods involve
prevention, response, and recovery efforts. Despite improvements in detection
techniques, the rising occurrence of wildfires demands creative solutions for
prompt identification and effective control. This research investigates
proactive methods for detecting and handling wildfires in the United States,
utilizing Artificial Intelligence (AI), Machine Learning (ML), and 5G
technology. The specific objective of this research covers proactive detection
and prevention of wildfires using advanced technology; Active monitoring and
mapping with remote sensing and signaling leveraging on 5G technology; and
Advanced response mechanisms to wildfire using drones and IOT devices. This
study was based on secondary data collected from government databases and
analyzed using descriptive statistics. In addition, past publications were
reviewed through content analysis, and narrative synthesis was used to present
the observations from various studies. The results showed that developing new
technology presents an opportunity to detect and manage wildfires proactively.
Utilizing advanced technology could save lives and prevent significant economic
losses caused by wildfires. Various methods, such as AI-enabled remote sensing
and 5G-based active monitoring, can enhance proactive wildfire detection and
management. In addition, super intelligent drones and IOT devices can be used
for safer responses to wildfires. This forms the core of the recommendation to
the fire Management Agencies and the government.
|
[
-0.17959895730018616,
-0.9206530451774597,
-0.034604042768478394,
0.21669749915599823,
-0.2569428086280823,
0.2205771803855896,
0.12045172601938248,
-0.43175336718559265,
0.01681867428123951,
0.5262869596481323,
-0.7363355159759521,
-0.2559109330177307,
-0.07036897540092468,
-0.14552859961986542,
-0.4815315902233124,
0.6784785985946655,
-0.0008653168333694339,
-0.3449546992778778,
0.1789228767156601,
-0.09236357361078262,
-0.75411057472229,
-0.37489184737205505,
-0.38850921392440796,
-0.25256893038749695,
0.7268390655517578,
0.4264342486858368,
0.9157342314720154,
0.04615970700979233,
1.2311596870422363,
0.3576890826225281,
0.24637539684772491,
-0.14628468453884125,
0.023600881919264793,
-0.007411469705402851,
0.3720897138118744,
-0.44871288537979126,
-0.2128896713256836,
0.4140092134475708,
0.11834439635276794,
0.025718389078974724,
-0.385891318321228,
-0.09579913318157196,
-0.5022678375244141,
0.6213309168815613,
-0.6423277854919434,
-0.12282967567443848,
-0.7543496489524841,
0.20807918906211853,
-0.11080914735794067,
-0.6484934687614441,
0.16531799733638763,
-0.45689424872398376,
0.215432807803154,
-0.682071328163147,
0.34242281317710876,
0.024987421929836273,
0.3290693461894989,
0.5022853016853333,
-0.6008981466293335,
-0.4285837709903717,
-1.345661997795105,
0.48652511835098267,
-0.5253390073776245,
-0.14121104776859283,
0.2409149557352066,
0.7549536228179932,
-0.4937160015106201,
-0.7471281886100769,
-0.9378408193588257,
-0.016848204657435417,
0.17678731679916382,
0.5066709518432617,
-0.18048647046089172,
-0.11341562867164612,
0.04252400994300842,
0.3001367151737213,
-0.8363249897956848,
0.10460904240608215,
-0.4067528247833252,
-0.3813912570476532,
1.1774786710739136,
0.0315871424973011,
0.09957733750343323,
0.10438214242458344,
-0.5659404993057251,
-0.05255195125937462,
-0.9247254133224487,
0.33204716444015503,
0.7953411936759949,
-0.17463964223861694,
0.1409509927034378,
0.26682254672050476,
-0.08401226997375488,
0.6452988386154175,
-0.37228506803512573,
-0.26880645751953125,
-0.04479182884097099,
-0.7827221751213074,
-0.6868104338645935,
0.04412653297185898,
0.35508137941360474,
0.5019226670265198,
-0.045992638915777206,
-0.19227349758148193,
-0.143670454621315,
0.4204564094543457,
0.47973015904426575,
-0.4522353708744049,
-0.3998454809188843,
0.38696959614753723,
-0.6735601425170898,
-0.6341073513031006,
0.08244328200817108,
-0.4487117528915405,
-0.3881509006023407,
-0.2366039901971817,
0.6889829039573669,
0.18124568462371826,
-0.7014884948730469,
-0.09759960323572159,
-0.18899430334568024,
-0.22158920764923096,
0.15877191722393036,
-0.8635525107383728,
-0.04261983558535576,
0.316174179315567,
0.6007644534111023,
0.3678123950958252,
-0.04922208562493324,
-0.04460573196411133,
0.02312389202415943,
-0.035311903804540634,
0.5122178196907043,
-0.47237417101860046,
-0.5350190997123718,
-0.0865088403224945,
0.020269468426704407,
0.08550801873207092,
-0.6807491779327393,
0.694641649723053,
-0.7566991448402405,
0.06097706779837608,
-0.18984735012054443,
-0.07096544653177261,
-0.7559701800346375,
0.2870095372200012,
-0.7305496335029602,
0.9581224918365479,
-0.3577355742454529,
-0.48396095633506775,
0.5358452796936035,
-0.4863350987434387,
-0.42096808552742004,
-0.041285544633865356,
0.2280714362859726,
-0.9162713885307312,
0.17237284779548645,
0.03220720961689949,
0.4027431905269623,
-0.03571124002337456,
0.23342099785804749,
0.0409490168094635,
-0.29019996523857117,
-0.005269188433885574,
-0.5139989852905273,
0.7077670693397522,
0.6408077478408813,
-0.443998247385025,
0.46595075726509094,
-0.49099254608154297,
0.11076952517032623,
0.06514166295528412,
-0.053551480174064636,
-0.26599496603012085,
0.2748110890388489,
0.05964697524905205,
0.2037903070449829,
-0.22661617398262024,
-0.5547373294830322,
-0.06052636355161667,
0.21508777141571045,
0.33978793025016785,
0.4245285093784332,
0.0739055797457695,
0.15406690537929535,
-0.6941766738891602,
0.11902769654989243,
0.03445835039019585,
0.4038168787956238,
-0.4802314043045044,
-0.29521679878234863,
-0.2982979714870453,
-0.10399118810892105,
-0.2612888813018799,
1.1889890432357788,
-0.44824352860450745,
0.7334323525428772,
0.3753768503665924,
-0.8203426599502563,
0.1348571926355362,
0.0322221964597702,
-0.23644207417964935,
0.26847022771835327,
0.39888542890548706,
-0.08902963995933533,
-0.449895977973938,
-0.1555255502462387,
-0.36749032139778137,
0.20957894623279572,
0.42827433347702026,
-0.07871104776859283,
0.3386317789554596,
0.1090749204158783,
1.0482419729232788,
-0.1551414132118225,
-0.43156111240386963,
-0.07742194086313248,
0.09333017468452454,
0.10956314206123352,
0.47437864542007446,
0.7459824681282043,
-1.5890343189239502,
-0.2700289487838745,
0.08580715954303741,
-1.0338298082351685,
0.14640790224075317,
-0.4327085614204407,
0.40535813570022583,
-0.6185165047645569,
0.4263051450252533,
-0.43361660838127136,
0.6839057803153992,
0.3307759463787079,
-0.42462772130966187,
0.3416939675807953,
-0.3422691524028778,
0.08208122104406357,
-0.4943871796131134,
-0.03739830106496811,
-0.06592715531587601,
0.3728272020816803,
-0.9622986316680908,
0.021104557439684868,
-0.21098275482654572,
-0.13099941611289978,
-0.4356727600097656,
0.3212658166885376,
-0.2142592817544937,
-0.09719885140657425,
-0.4823247194290161,
-0.48275500535964966,
-0.24282801151275635,
0.009092438034713268,
0.06613629311323166,
0.6807065010070801,
0.5287702083587646,
-0.346891850233078,
0.9857484102249146,
0.041842713952064514,
-0.007709354627877474,
0.2274104356765747,
-0.5131634473800659,
-0.2380208969116211,
-0.10786230862140656,
0.6514749526977539,
-0.6468204259872437,
-0.24815025925636292,
-0.014299927279353142,
-0.25895237922668457,
-0.1430632323026657,
0.3379473090171814,
-0.3490533232688904,
-0.7439921498298645,
-0.09877505898475647,
-0.36393076181411743,
0.4493221044540405,
-0.21969343721866608,
0.770814836025238,
-0.03424452617764473,
-0.1837373524904251,
-0.34030723571777344,
-0.6373922228813171,
0.27014270424842834,
-0.679720401763916,
-0.5048936009407043,
0.3219752311706543,
-0.038560766726732254,
-0.33015507459640503,
-0.04608263820409775,
-0.4861167371273041,
0.021857641637325287,
0.6412059664726257,
0.3279303312301636,
-0.24155573546886444,
0.2830532491207123,
0.08614832907915115,
-0.5980888605117798,
-0.4549609124660492,
0.22197923064231873,
-0.33062925934791565,
-0.19919219613075256,
0.5184258818626404,
-0.20736122131347656,
-0.8343437314033508,
0.651314914226532,
0.7034851312637329,
-0.4501267671585083,
0.5151581764221191,
1.0696998834609985,
-0.4545334577560425,
0.21568553149700165,
-0.6391023993492126,
-0.4782874584197998,
-0.501115620136261,
-0.314375638961792,
-0.05916605517268181,
-0.5003510117530823,
0.4690729081630707,
-0.8523586988449097,
0.44668444991111755,
0.11816763877868652,
0.4670204222202301,
-0.2496575564146042,
0.7488113641738892,
0.7660725712776184,
-0.014745866879820824,
0.9004833102226257,
-0.3241705596446991,
0.6975370645523071,
-0.2407989501953125,
-0.6790167093276978,
-0.45582908391952515,
-0.599830687046051,
-0.49298304319381714,
0.027775319293141365,
0.540278434753418,
0.3294612467288971,
-0.2536895275115967,
0.33098509907722473,
-0.7117205858230591,
0.272582471370697,
0.6041387915611267,
0.2607230246067047,
0.4322689473628998,
0.16596418619155884,
0.1942622810602188,
0.16228710114955902,
-0.5037057995796204,
-0.3940998911857605,
0.9971444010734558,
0.050256308168172836,
0.7033939361572266,
0.4197652041912079,
0.6828739643096924,
0.48742029070854187,
0.4127497673034668,
-0.43246936798095703,
0.2397472858428955,
0.09706868976354599,
-0.8180639147758484,
-0.33148154616355896,
-0.2760734558105469,
-0.8812735080718994,
0.13962143659591675,
-0.5496273636817932,
-0.1812209039926529,
0.04113328456878662,
0.11564871668815613,
-0.46218234300613403,
0.05394824594259262,
-1.0486403703689575,
0.7091436386108398,
-0.7549709677696228,
-0.2299010157585144,
-0.6165482401847839,
-0.7271131277084351,
0.08140348643064499,
-0.16241438686847687,
0.3048676550388336,
-0.360430508852005,
0.247329980134964,
0.3604113757610321,
-0.38083481788635254,
0.6296506524085999,
-0.4593689739704132,
0.1981869488954544,
0.8787461519241333,
-0.2908214032649994,
0.9874686002731323,
-0.11328604072332382,
-0.17428407073020935,
-0.17442846298217773,
-0.3368784487247467,
-0.5761146545410156,
-0.2967364490032196,
0.5648676753044128,
-0.6678231358528137,
-0.15261666476726532,
-0.433788537979126,
-0.5105970501899719,
0.042705778032541275,
0.3086225986480713,
0.22263072431087494,
0.35205531120300293,
-0.2684050500392914,
0.0943748950958252,
0.4509933292865753,
-0.05765252932906151,
0.8873369097709656,
0.14788082242012024,
0.24860918521881104,
-0.2193685919046402,
0.8048419952392578,
0.2854069173336029,
-0.028923867270350456,
0.022255850955843925,
0.44173330068588257,
-0.19755226373672485,
-0.8054638504981995,
-0.08348583430051804,
-0.5882151126861572,
-0.22507749497890472,
-0.3825891315937042,
-0.6349303722381592,
-0.17429019510746002,
-0.10828999429941177,
-0.3180873692035675,
0.4774671792984009,
0.1038753017783165,
0.12822751700878143,
-0.19551566243171692,
0.6176580190658569,
0.5258532762527466,
-0.08196569234132767,
0.9530234932899475,
-0.725723147392273,
0.4929499626159668,
0.6581521034240723,
-0.1571740210056305,
-0.10909143090248108,
0.48248252272605896,
-0.034271202981472015,
-0.06365062296390533,
-0.6828663945198059,
-0.35197994112968445,
0.6744023561477661,
0.36681196093559265,
0.6529347896575928,
0.32976529002189636,
0.30463284254074097,
0.283137708902359,
-0.03872817009687424,
0.6626061201095581,
0.3898501396179199,
-0.3242543339729309,
0.4880155324935913,
-0.5290233492851257,
0.29114633798599243,
0.12461411207914352,
0.26703527569770813,
-0.06633343547582626,
0.08354073762893677,
-0.6235658526420593,
-0.41945770382881165,
0.29675477743148804,
0.316481351852417,
0.20622724294662476,
0.36371660232543945,
-0.24355389177799225,
-0.10970745980739594,
0.47213730216026306,
-0.47834113240242004,
0.3533053398132324,
-0.5493332147598267,
-0.13465885818004608,
0.09537038207054138,
0.3858368694782257,
-0.4830430746078491,
-0.12141556292772293,
0.1546124368906021,
-0.12695401906967163,
0.2588258683681488,
-0.09562802314758301,
0.07984776049852371,
-0.043171387165784836,
0.32895106077194214,
0.7399646639823914,
0.282344788312912,
-0.30917391180992126,
0.24894574284553528,
0.09378258883953094,
-0.7050838470458984,
0.15546464920043945,
0.0555480420589447,
-0.2347671389579773,
-0.24287734925746918,
0.38345059752464294,
0.35566893219947815,
-0.4560561180114746,
-0.3034672439098358,
0.31560689210891724,
0.05943818762898445,
-0.3069107234477997,
-0.27046024799346924,
0.07446210086345673,
0.006997393444180489,
0.5382258296012878,
1.0288749933242798,
0.5599778890609741,
0.373169481754303,
-0.7265950441360474,
-0.10080242156982422,
0.5515786409378052,
0.20614667236804962,
-0.26310232281684875,
0.8241462111473083,
0.822759211063385,
-0.2458799183368683,
0.051885783672332764,
0.03485001251101494,
-0.5161561369895935,
1.177207112312317,
0.653131902217865,
0.6607517004013062,
-0.2996266186237335,
-0.1335049867630005,
0.13571563363075256,
0.52736496925354,
0.03324474021792412,
0.7752828598022461,
-0.3549576699733734,
-0.6334856152534485,
0.022806083783507347,
-0.17742109298706055,
-0.02713095024228096,
0.06386346369981766,
-0.10595591366291046,
0.028161976486444473,
-0.6945769190788269,
-0.32403793931007385,
0.05058547109365463,
0.294808954000473,
-0.7562478184700012,
0.5173255205154419,
0.016216516494750977,
0.9223867654800415,
-1.0690869092941284,
0.355926513671875,
0.4777636229991913,
0.11292799562215805,
-0.7204037308692932,
0.2361367791891098,
0.41140443086624146,
-0.4571126699447632,
0.3359191119670868,
0.41108256578445435,
0.1361985206604004,
0.4488717019557953,
-0.3835064768791199,
-0.5580734014511108,
1.422696828842163,
-0.2477828860282898,
-0.4816059470176697,
0.40259701013565063,
-0.3035302460193634,
0.4561116695404053,
0.17709682881832123,
0.4080771505832672,
0.4145689010620117,
0.8197290301322937,
0.44528311491012573,
-0.6881505250930786,
-0.3048992156982422,
0.025323912501335144,
-0.18968383967876434,
0.4178142249584198,
-0.7855187654495239,
0.12129634618759155,
-0.47074300050735474,
-0.13965927064418793,
-0.08438614010810852,
0.5760860443115234,
-0.34036365151405334,
1.1235485076904297,
0.32573530077934265,
0.6283864974975586,
0.4956848621368408,
-0.2472897320985794,
0.2216433733701706,
0.01937974989414215,
0.2446608990430832,
0.2768484950065613,
-0.39326635003089905,
0.42622312903404236,
0.2618566155433655,
-0.07484839856624603,
0.16046547889709473,
0.6599753499031067,
0.032745085656642914,
1.0809459686279297,
-0.11387336254119873,
-1.0771008729934692,
-0.1546795815229416,
-0.40136241912841797,
-0.35172876715660095,
0.5489791631698608,
0.6697152853012085,
-0.028215058147907257,
-0.452851802110672,
0.5127252340316772,
-0.08161637932062149,
0.003721881890669465,
-0.21687021851539612,
0.8977135419845581,
-0.1727713942527771,
-0.6235700845718384,
0.16527359187602997,
0.17268866300582886,
0.739741325378418,
-0.4312618672847748,
-0.08303409069776535,
-0.15975576639175415,
0.39382579922676086,
-0.7890618443489075,
-0.7967857122421265,
0.9887842535972595,
0.022583846002817154,
-0.015864524990320206,
-0.27774500846862793,
0.752619743347168,
-0.08577252179384232,
-0.30073118209838867,
0.062486037611961365,
0.12846310436725616,
-0.10253524780273438,
0.13842947781085968,
-0.3810954689979553,
0.10376925021409988,
-0.3409532308578491,
-0.07347427308559418,
0.010751624591648579,
0.13805057108402252,
-0.5453706979751587,
0.5587545037269592,
1.1900088787078857,
-0.031923774629831314,
0.18885250389575958,
-0.4042259454727173,
0.8804661631584167,
-0.6001231074333191,
-0.44676944613456726,
-0.4976782500743866,
0.2903120219707489,
-0.27008864283561707,
-0.30567246675491333,
0.7815865278244019,
-0.022111037746071815,
0.5377823114395142,
0.19566400349140167,
1.0979650020599365,
-0.54798823595047,
0.14529192447662354,
-0.26026806235313416,
0.09975814819335938,
-0.06356550008058548,
0.17485420405864716,
0.23634058237075806,
-1.0419517755508423,
-0.6381131410598755,
0.5026394128799438,
-0.1476535052061081,
0.031946029514074326,
0.002938009100034833,
0.7811020016670227,
0.031322840601205826,
0.167840376496315,
0.3390899896621704,
-0.25445958971977234,
0.6196480989456177,
0.231361985206604,
0.5110698938369751,
-0.4583809971809387,
0.45093628764152527,
-0.038136329501867294,
-0.6114726066589355,
-0.6730213165283203,
-0.9064958691596985,
-0.5647599697113037,
0.04105418175458908,
0.050338175147771835,
0.15563781559467316,
0.09456545114517212,
0.5967894196510315,
0.9183629155158997,
-0.7974956631660461,
0.29044243693351746,
-0.40142014622688293,
0.23321138322353363,
-0.7301859855651855,
-0.16892357170581818,
0.07434794306755066,
0.07617995887994766,
-0.10331714153289795,
0.6589553356170654,
0.5803676843643188,
-0.018952015787363052,
-0.4260673224925995,
-0.07215873897075653,
-0.2934272885322571,
0.08506138622760773,
0.45607370138168335,
0.6287558078765869,
-0.668229341506958,
-0.17271822690963745,
0.2067403793334961,
-0.1327037364244461,
-0.674365758895874,
0.6724511384963989,
-0.9549031257629395,
0.531397819519043,
0.778010368347168,
0.5955964922904968,
0.10635663568973541,
0.09745880961418152,
0.2507972717285156,
-0.488090455532074,
0.447192519903183,
0.34020012617111206,
-0.2320115566253662,
0.26517054438591003,
-0.7081539630889893,
0.7139984965324402,
0.6127920746803284,
-0.9048632383346558,
-0.4277704060077667,
0.2545834481716156,
-0.7104597091674805,
-0.029192479327321053,
0.4150353670120239,
-0.26033419370651245,
0.49313288927078247,
-0.4276230037212372,
-0.36269664764404297,
0.03949631005525589,
0.07665815949440002,
0.7106655240058899,
0.28765884041786194,
-0.24659401178359985,
-0.42885449528694153,
-0.5225682854652405,
0.2208871990442276,
0.26558932662010193,
-0.8695028424263,
-0.19839322566986084,
0.3217563033103943,
-0.08175501227378845,
0.3303886353969574,
0.2867657542228699,
0.34841781854629517,
0.4542941153049469,
0.21776533126831055,
-0.12913069128990173,
-0.2537892162799835,
-0.8076440095901489,
-0.22212861478328705,
-0.08897951245307922,
-0.33392930030822754,
-0.33573684096336365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17189v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17189v1
|
An Effective Mixture-Of-Experts Approach For Code-Switching Speech Recognition Leveraging Encoder Disentanglement
| 2024-02-27T04:08:59 | 2024-02-27T04:08:59 |
Tzu-Ting Yang, Hsin-Wei Wang, Yi-Cheng Wang, Chi-Han Lin, Berlin Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
With the massive developments of end-to-end (E2E) neural networks, recent
years have witnessed unprecedented breakthroughs in automatic speech
recognition (ASR). However, the codeswitching phenomenon remains a major
obstacle that hinders ASR from perfection, as the lack of labeled data and the
variations between languages often lead to degradation of ASR performance. In
this paper, we focus exclusively on improving the acoustic encoder of E2E ASR
to tackle the challenge caused by the codeswitching phenomenon. Our main
contributions are threefold: First, we introduce a novel disentanglement loss
to enable the lower-layer of the encoder to capture inter-lingual acoustic
information while mitigating linguistic confusion at the higher-layer of the
encoder. Second, through comprehensive experiments, we verify that our proposed
method outperforms the prior-art methods using pretrained dual-encoders,
meanwhile having access only to the codeswitching corpus and consuming half of
the parameterization. Third, the apparent differentiation of the encoders'
output features also corroborates the complementarity between the
disentanglement loss and the mixture-of-experts (MoE) architecture.
|
[
-0.4491368532180786,
-0.2503558099269867,
-0.021859802305698395,
0.012354538775980473,
-0.24090076982975006,
0.6910764575004578,
-0.08237210661172867,
-0.4085499346256256,
0.1500789076089859,
0.10298646241426468,
-0.21348261833190918,
0.007439045235514641,
-1.1238172054290771,
0.1761324554681778,
-0.6535615921020508,
0.5629696846008301,
-0.008153479546308517,
-0.004326817579567432,
0.01395352091640234,
-0.0665869265794754,
-0.32131227850914,
-0.3041534721851349,
-0.7870272994041443,
-0.5352942943572998,
0.13857197761535645,
0.10940755903720856,
0.5119422674179077,
0.4031880795955658,
0.034722134470939636,
0.31932970881462097,
-0.4144113063812256,
0.3508853018283844,
-0.352213054895401,
-0.23251739144325256,
-0.014348885975778103,
-0.5544664263725281,
-0.180491641163826,
-0.2963223159313202,
0.37683093547821045,
0.39256221055984497,
-0.5031322836875916,
-0.16592277586460114,
0.25165703892707825,
0.632434070110321,
-0.5654586553573608,
0.03298690542578697,
-0.8966014981269836,
0.2898190915584564,
-0.431400865316391,
-0.4887273907661438,
-0.325531929731369,
0.07676471024751663,
0.016348890960216522,
-0.35526058077812195,
0.07920126616954803,
-0.14857152104377747,
0.5294681191444397,
0.8443097472190857,
-0.4143579304218292,
-0.3087385594844818,
-0.7806190848350525,
0.4703878164291382,
-0.7806587219238281,
0.7511286735534668,
0.39978596568107605,
0.24123960733413696,
0.06422580033540726,
-0.3752742409706116,
-0.5970824360847473,
0.13281220197677612,
0.1149970218539238,
0.3994741439819336,
-0.34240731596946716,
-0.11554080247879028,
0.013614637777209282,
0.3425067067146301,
-0.5150799751281738,
0.2739337980747223,
-0.394140362739563,
-0.4792829751968384,
0.6941543221473694,
-0.2736150026321411,
0.23439158499240875,
0.4553382396697998,
-0.20313198864459991,
0.026525745168328285,
-0.4809598922729492,
0.09864335507154465,
0.4879208207130432,
-0.08737631142139435,
-0.0048065632581710815,
0.0694965198636055,
0.048425011336803436,
0.7245420217514038,
0.6950847506523132,
-0.07000035047531128,
0.5238810777664185,
-0.035345256328582764,
0.09359585493803024,
0.6090587973594666,
0.6196418404579163,
0.24981367588043213,
-0.018529554829001427,
-0.45328888297080994,
-0.297263503074646,
0.005472916644066572,
-0.07583741098642349,
-0.49236196279525757,
-0.48645278811454773,
0.2932188808917999,
-0.19295309484004974,
-0.13354697823524475,
0.10569551587104797,
-0.5479865074157715,
-0.25303196907043457,
-0.2743740379810333,
0.47405603528022766,
-0.25311121344566345,
-0.7783792018890381,
0.36638233065605164,
-0.29082852602005005,
0.1464628428220749,
0.02256467379629612,
-0.9980220794677734,
0.4044465720653534,
0.48435071110725403,
0.6998863816261292,
-0.0401616096496582,
-0.23382750153541565,
-0.5195996761322021,
0.24139173328876495,
-0.2782844305038452,
0.4695329964160919,
-0.4597031772136688,
-0.44872918725013733,
-0.32658320665359497,
-0.47332698106765747,
-0.23775413632392883,
-0.8406710028648376,
0.07068618386983871,
-0.6492725014686584,
-0.06569365411996841,
0.033805761486291885,
-0.5666030645370483,
0.007265967782586813,
-0.12405749410390854,
-0.6016976237297058,
0.8481732606887817,
-0.4293055236339569,
-0.6406722068786621,
0.3335285782814026,
-0.34747713804244995,
-0.4715885818004608,
0.024942614138126373,
-0.592086911201477,
-0.5647924542427063,
0.05660897493362427,
0.3085140585899353,
0.11614163964986801,
-0.04310384765267372,
0.1466865986585617,
0.2195725291967392,
-0.48642292618751526,
0.48138192296028137,
-0.5158585906028748,
0.918022632598877,
0.2659932076931,
-0.6314419507980347,
-0.4095800518989563,
-0.7042325735092163,
0.03319583833217621,
-0.02501056343317032,
-0.49658000469207764,
-0.3134019374847412,
0.16697059571743011,
0.04295423999428749,
0.3451724052429199,
0.33191919326782227,
-0.4605732858181,
-0.2646537125110626,
-0.27699100971221924,
0.624239981174469,
0.47353994846343994,
-0.15079346299171448,
0.5034441351890564,
-0.2265145480632782,
0.24458098411560059,
0.49926894903182983,
-0.04621089622378349,
0.1381625384092331,
-0.5883240103721619,
-0.6837518215179443,
-0.1499779373407364,
0.48361608386039734,
0.7706183791160583,
-0.8893741965293884,
0.9803692698478699,
0.013853056356310844,
-0.3263002336025238,
-0.9698593020439148,
0.11575541645288467,
0.7838373780250549,
0.40856561064720154,
0.425363689661026,
-0.5140078663825989,
-0.5699393153190613,
-0.6543123126029968,
-0.5255539417266846,
-0.021033452823758125,
-0.21413828432559967,
0.1159660816192627,
0.1702863574028015,
-0.3029977083206177,
1.154443621635437,
-0.2979441285133362,
-0.20416449010372162,
-0.046986233443021774,
0.1511649638414383,
0.10086663067340851,
0.6332141160964966,
0.2945050299167633,
-1.0341275930404663,
-0.5105890035629272,
0.12722453474998474,
-0.4094146490097046,
-0.026325112208724022,
-0.28634217381477356,
0.1204361617565155,
0.12231794744729996,
0.6523792743682861,
-0.23231610655784607,
0.3615553677082062,
0.4698854982852936,
-0.024673234671354294,
0.26465433835983276,
-0.2246840000152588,
0.2082427740097046,
-0.9930151104927063,
-0.25930240750312805,
-0.0804874375462532,
-0.0635112076997757,
-0.7980790138244629,
-0.22019962966442108,
0.11874253302812576,
0.10737458616495132,
-0.2223251461982727,
0.005843692924827337,
-0.6311913728713989,
-0.005096734035760164,
-0.018732542172074318,
-0.10594752430915833,
0.012419084087014198,
0.4863322973251343,
-0.068956658244133,
0.7575814127922058,
0.7826181650161743,
-0.4821769595146179,
0.3115731179714203,
0.38756927847862244,
-0.0478496290743351,
0.3278336524963379,
-0.5111863613128662,
0.6857361197471619,
-0.16287334263324738,
0.243413046002388,
-0.874046802520752,
0.09476736932992935,
-0.01134240161627531,
-0.8694663643836975,
0.7615195512771606,
-0.42341282963752747,
-0.42491066455841064,
-0.24646392464637756,
-0.057051680982112885,
0.5034306645393372,
0.8232809901237488,
-0.6816278100013733,
0.635835587978363,
0.6843135952949524,
-0.17963652312755585,
-0.42798128724098206,
-1.0011861324310303,
0.39397895336151123,
-0.15346553921699524,
-0.49775707721710205,
0.6017470359802246,
-0.12024891376495361,
-0.03806586563587189,
-0.2301311045885086,
-0.6069843173027039,
-0.46548956632614136,
-0.14786061644554138,
-0.2774147391319275,
-0.04965127259492874,
-0.10331041365861893,
-0.11120868474245071,
0.5255782008171082,
-0.5033115148544312,
0.05675264820456505,
-0.3308105170726776,
0.38592657446861267,
0.01651826500892639,
-0.5550180077552795,
-0.3884842097759247,
0.40968313813209534,
0.354196161031723,
-0.7239922881126404,
0.18962030112743378,
0.6229406595230103,
-0.49111199378967285,
-0.2907947301864624,
-0.6318552494049072,
-0.1865207850933075,
-0.528873860836029,
0.7354466319084167,
-0.38197076320648193,
-0.6975252032279968,
0.5206360816955566,
-0.21534618735313416,
0.005921795032918453,
-0.022117067128419876,
0.4384825527667999,
-0.07571209967136383,
0.8534965515136719,
0.315812349319458,
-0.40627461671829224,
0.22937385737895966,
-0.21868784725666046,
0.5269299149513245,
-0.7081729769706726,
-0.3668142259120941,
-0.3158662021160126,
-0.2473108172416687,
-0.3073742091655731,
-0.5021546483039856,
0.5940963625907898,
0.15064388513565063,
0.07566358149051666,
0.2846907079219818,
-0.7436797618865967,
0.6609375476837158,
0.3121235966682434,
0.4776599109172821,
0.2602241337299347,
0.0573737770318985,
0.19212861359119415,
0.0014559155097231269,
-0.7683344483375549,
-0.07059186697006226,
0.8427823185920715,
0.3455667793750763,
0.8746307492256165,
0.2170267105102539,
1.097208023071289,
0.21539855003356934,
-0.7064871191978455,
-0.4592036008834839,
0.3967903256416321,
-0.3121201694011688,
-0.2629714608192444,
-0.3892940878868103,
-0.4612311124801636,
-0.6303625702857971,
0.26064005494117737,
0.09238570928573608,
-0.22379560768604279,
0.5169957280158997,
0.5105802416801453,
-0.477628618478775,
0.3874920904636383,
-0.5867750644683838,
0.26629602909088135,
-0.3818241357803345,
-0.10706585645675659,
-0.22443726658821106,
-0.817008912563324,
-0.09065496921539307,
-0.2435172200202942,
0.15062615275382996,
0.34601274132728577,
-0.03731558844447136,
0.8414632678031921,
-0.3762933015823364,
0.8152607679367065,
-0.42715415358543396,
-0.2321261763572693,
0.2034541517496109,
-0.13055792450904846,
0.3386126756668091,
-0.12784545123577118,
0.13023224472999573,
0.4539661407470703,
-0.5123691558837891,
-0.20718809962272644,
-0.476813405752182,
0.4037918150424957,
-0.8954809308052063,
-0.1479235142469406,
-0.12746800482273102,
-0.26403647661209106,
-0.4752528965473175,
-0.0619472973048687,
0.6098319888114929,
0.8737553358078003,
0.16083896160125732,
-0.046126753091812134,
1.1848366260528564,
-0.12596702575683594,
0.3840082883834839,
0.6209108233451843,
0.23530347645282745,
-0.3796118497848511,
1.2165032625198364,
0.35867610573768616,
0.3258548974990845,
0.49090951681137085,
0.07129009068012238,
-0.2973504066467285,
-0.7627476453781128,
-0.6437709927558899,
-0.25161120295524597,
-0.4290120303630829,
-0.2000923901796341,
-0.5287798643112183,
-0.5429335236549377,
-0.36576026678085327,
-0.31211134791374207,
-0.6745903491973877,
-0.13732415437698364,
-0.3448328375816345,
-0.15462562441825867,
0.3501179814338684,
0.4040936827659607,
-0.16175059974193573,
-0.10617304593324661,
-0.7304306626319885,
0.34469521045684814,
0.5768712162971497,
0.2823233902454376,
-0.006470599211752415,
-0.8744125962257385,
-0.4264451861381531,
0.24173571169376373,
0.09205922484397888,
-0.903868556022644,
0.09599774330854416,
0.5002328753471375,
0.735560953617096,
0.4930732250213623,
0.15445034205913544,
0.7420254945755005,
-0.5886306762695312,
0.429021954536438,
0.4550343453884125,
-1.139798641204834,
0.2622032165527344,
-0.16726776957511902,
0.3681083023548126,
0.5540940165519714,
0.054064907133579254,
-0.3520280718803406,
-0.5284618735313416,
-0.33935338258743286,
-1.1066983938217163,
0.6075998544692993,
0.2941029667854309,
-0.049919214099645615,
0.25641435384750366,
-0.011299466714262962,
0.2142917960882187,
0.25355398654937744,
-0.31205880641937256,
-0.4034340977668762,
-0.5735436677932739,
-0.33614349365234375,
-0.004895303398370743,
-0.10652659833431244,
-0.0696454644203186,
-0.47614291310310364,
0.42906519770622253,
0.17162692546844482,
0.3028576970100403,
0.05156539008021355,
-0.4447762072086334,
0.053515464067459106,
0.39831677079200745,
0.5072169303894043,
0.4499582350254059,
-0.0998031497001648,
0.17827409505844116,
0.42691749334335327,
-0.520707905292511,
0.2561633288860321,
0.3197953402996063,
-0.034498315304517746,
0.241291806101799,
0.11169428378343582,
0.8432060480117798,
0.4698009788990021,
-0.3929584324359894,
0.5626435279846191,
0.24151383340358734,
-0.29805225133895874,
-0.4762420654296875,
0.034825317561626434,
0.28379136323928833,
0.16693150997161865,
0.737117350101471,
0.6309694647789001,
0.45817944407463074,
-0.18392567336559296,
0.4203324317932129,
-0.1377152055501938,
-0.22456270456314087,
-0.2271868884563446,
0.6263264417648315,
0.6449312567710876,
-0.49363356828689575,
0.5795037746429443,
-0.3269537091255188,
-0.5498471260070801,
0.9249809384346008,
0.6339069604873657,
0.9757062196731567,
-0.8612987995147705,
-0.1096295416355133,
0.12485487759113312,
0.3416012227535248,
-0.07821962982416153,
0.15503564476966858,
-0.28787094354629517,
-0.8612117171287537,
-0.10198992490768433,
-0.10858110338449478,
-0.39264392852783203,
-0.2620508372783661,
-1.1260422468185425,
0.22047093510627747,
-0.031070522964000702,
0.16302204132080078,
-0.3150670826435089,
-0.6118900775909424,
-0.43848586082458496,
0.13315540552139282,
0.3876349925994873,
0.6525895595550537,
-0.6372677683830261,
0.8200049996376038,
0.5718992948532104,
-0.1939777433872223,
-0.5243211388587952,
0.2083011418581009,
0.22421929240226746,
-0.7612471580505371,
0.1260705143213272,
0.09685507416725159,
-0.42808935046195984,
0.20652568340301514,
-0.21752412617206573,
-0.6723671555519104,
1.2203208208084106,
0.3050880432128906,
-1.2251663208007812,
0.01026075892150402,
0.21017296612262726,
0.34923362731933594,
-0.03617164492607117,
0.3152645528316498,
0.8037009239196777,
0.25413718819618225,
-0.03721887990832329,
-1.319208025932312,
-0.3202143907546997,
-0.625223696231842,
-0.01855619251728058,
0.23080721497535706,
-0.618846595287323,
0.7140185832977295,
-0.21727123856544495,
-0.052574221044778824,
-0.49051135778427124,
0.43957096338272095,
0.30538690090179443,
0.4150337874889374,
0.9297564625740051,
0.37365028262138367,
0.6674636006355286,
0.0740208849310875,
0.2863718271255493,
-0.41505250334739685,
0.2255728393793106,
1.0140259265899658,
-0.2966553270816803,
1.0399116277694702,
0.4028119742870331,
-0.44403254985809326,
0.030065227299928665,
0.369086354970932,
0.07557804137468338,
0.9591799378395081,
0.09321847558021545,
-0.39045917987823486,
-0.21334373950958252,
0.5978633761405945,
-0.7614288330078125,
0.5450848340988159,
0.334318071603775,
-0.017484379932284355,
-0.0904286652803421,
0.21657976508140564,
0.06735411286354065,
0.02809366211295128,
-0.2197447419166565,
1.133471965789795,
0.16373293101787567,
-0.0862673670053482,
0.7080295085906982,
-0.2878081798553467,
1.197648286819458,
-0.6123068928718567,
-0.011938931420445442,
0.03880865499377251,
0.047713711857795715,
-0.5735093355178833,
-0.528457522392273,
0.37800687551498413,
-0.07249046862125397,
-0.24585109949111938,
-0.30766069889068604,
0.6188677549362183,
-0.9651641249656677,
-0.3056057393550873,
0.5703756213188171,
0.21617311239242554,
0.2260252684354782,
-0.09569677710533142,
-0.6240048408508301,
0.19931572675704956,
0.10002773255109787,
0.16762985289096832,
0.5199920535087585,
0.31723496317863464,
0.5242459177970886,
0.1821349710226059,
0.49066537618637085,
-0.04233474284410477,
0.3961096704006195,
0.23346827924251556,
1.0592068433761597,
-0.25240060687065125,
-0.8935081958770752,
-0.6755580902099609,
0.6860913634300232,
-0.13928672671318054,
-0.19632060825824738,
0.4855404496192932,
0.7152154445648193,
0.9161511659622192,
-0.21008487045764923,
1.0207141637802124,
-0.010320564731955528,
0.5249237418174744,
-0.5509920716285706,
1.1994140148162842,
-0.34467384219169617,
0.3485160171985626,
-0.2718193233013153,
-0.3348125219345093,
-0.003095194697380066,
0.715668797492981,
0.04464608058333397,
0.13488124310970306,
0.3304240107536316,
1.008926510810852,
-0.1335839480161667,
-0.05801314488053322,
0.46296587586402893,
0.35639718174934387,
0.3357270658016205,
0.6424316763877869,
0.7053199410438538,
-0.6133321523666382,
0.6149886846542358,
-0.05301673710346222,
-0.6078509092330933,
-0.17689555883407593,
-0.46859824657440186,
-0.671173095703125,
-0.8258481025695801,
-0.6238660216331482,
0.021570445969700813,
0.35700592398643494,
0.7348838448524475,
0.6678766012191772,
-0.8819477558135986,
-0.24715271592140198,
-0.16785895824432373,
-0.2568702697753906,
-0.4119148254394531,
-0.1629677265882492,
0.018289875239133835,
0.00011337535397615284,
-0.5147063732147217,
0.742777407169342,
0.3721108138561249,
-0.18735258281230927,
-0.06752773374319077,
-0.5756242871284485,
0.17852234840393066,
0.09247943013906479,
0.41957220435142517,
0.28998517990112305,
-0.668647050857544,
-0.0070047578774392605,
-0.31497639417648315,
0.19192001223564148,
0.060049545019865036,
0.6863886713981628,
-0.49096590280532837,
0.7567959427833557,
0.38908883929252625,
0.9073598384857178,
0.3402041494846344,
-0.2696567475795746,
0.4600471258163452,
-0.718621015548706,
0.10275617986917496,
0.35796844959259033,
0.4652363955974579,
0.2374720424413681,
-0.3395172655582428,
0.06353189051151276,
0.11221206188201904,
-0.5454397797584534,
-0.7659350037574768,
0.17319625616073608,
-0.9372366666793823,
-0.05912959203124046,
0.88809734582901,
-0.0877913311123848,
0.18396462500095367,
-0.6124017238616943,
-0.2588183879852295,
0.2107221782207489,
-0.5429295897483826,
0.9475152492523193,
0.31957441568374634,
-0.2333928495645523,
-0.2963801622390747,
-0.1317635178565979,
0.3259691596031189,
0.43446478247642517,
-0.6715152859687805,
-0.19113224744796753,
0.16054204106330872,
0.3956185281276703,
0.18105852603912354,
0.8722603917121887,
-0.14692877233028412,
0.45245039463043213,
0.20796732604503632,
0.2113090306520462,
-0.4971892833709717,
-0.2923574149608612,
-0.5670391917228699,
-0.30752938985824585,
0.0356828011572361,
-0.6417977213859558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17184v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17184v1
|
Extreme Encoder Output Frame Rate Reduction: Improving Computational Latencies of Large End-to-End Models
| 2024-02-27T03:40:44 | 2024-02-27T03:40:44 |
Rohit Prabhavalkar, Zhong Meng, Weiran Wang, Adam Stooke, Xingyu Cai, Yanzhang He, Arun Narayanan, Dongseong Hwang, Tara N. Sainath, Pedro J. Moreno
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The accuracy of end-to-end (E2E) automatic speech recognition (ASR) models
continues to improve as they are scaled to larger sizes, with some now reaching
billions of parameters. Widespread deployment and adoption of these models,
however, requires computationally efficient strategies for decoding. In the
present work, we study one such strategy: applying multiple frame reduction
layers in the encoder to compress encoder outputs into a small number of output
frames. While similar techniques have been investigated in previous work, we
achieve dramatically more reduction than has previously been demonstrated
through the use of multiple funnel reduction layers. Through ablations, we
study the impact of various architectural choices in the encoder to identify
the most effective strategies. We demonstrate that we can generate one encoder
output frame for every 2.56 sec of input speech, without significantly
affecting word error rate on a large-scale voice search task, while improving
encoder and decoder latencies by 48% and 92% respectively, relative to a strong
but computationally expensive baseline.
|
[
-0.7697004675865173,
-0.7445405721664429,
0.043410319834947586,
-0.04367577284574509,
-0.2987244725227356,
-0.028801683336496353,
-0.16422432661056519,
-0.4379132390022278,
-0.004270086996257305,
0.44335103034973145,
-0.40721559524536133,
-0.0699717327952385,
-0.5622009634971619,
0.15757517516613007,
-0.7531662583351135,
0.4522061347961426,
0.11516362428665161,
0.06421203911304474,
0.11309245228767395,
0.16142462193965912,
-0.07370337098836899,
-0.7556954026222229,
-1.0305516719818115,
-0.4683164358139038,
0.01577574573457241,
0.2563447952270508,
0.462807834148407,
0.8893991112709045,
0.5101400017738342,
0.23490944504737854,
-0.3666836619377136,
-0.009615243412554264,
-0.3836528956890106,
0.2374669909477234,
0.2883484661579132,
-0.22791241109371185,
-0.2748509347438812,
-0.44010359048843384,
0.8309476375579834,
0.5207110047340393,
-0.3235265910625458,
0.25022709369659424,
-0.0033323776442557573,
0.6992610096931458,
-0.6932510733604431,
0.0010189501335844398,
-0.33480527997016907,
0.21327491104602814,
-0.25854113698005676,
-0.3718223571777344,
-0.5663978457450867,
0.151872918009758,
-0.2583080530166626,
-0.22338034212589264,
0.28600063920021057,
0.042795732617378235,
0.5375902056694031,
0.507422924041748,
-0.14923125505447388,
-0.11800413578748703,
-1.022727131843567,
0.16403643786907196,
-0.6845625042915344,
0.7597947716712952,
0.2299283891916275,
0.27386265993118286,
0.07145258039236069,
-0.4983052909374237,
-0.6411414742469788,
0.32322943210601807,
0.3117925822734833,
0.06966947019100189,
-0.6442806720733643,
0.20995603501796722,
0.4641813039779663,
0.2698402404785156,
-0.7047902941703796,
0.24822762608528137,
-0.34331417083740234,
-0.3249836564064026,
0.41289615631103516,
0.002042914740741253,
0.01419295184314251,
0.1443955898284912,
0.16091714799404144,
-0.33457350730895996,
-0.7237737774848938,
0.3129652738571167,
0.3973414897918701,
0.05898416042327881,
0.058236222714185715,
0.5993428230285645,
-0.188661590218544,
0.5855464935302734,
0.1525665670633316,
0.09396623075008392,
0.1822947859764099,
-0.1299830973148346,
-0.23828229308128357,
0.33885350823402405,
0.4024833142757416,
0.4206259846687317,
-0.14655889570713043,
0.007481032982468605,
-0.38742226362228394,
0.4692091941833496,
0.253531277179718,
-1.0953329801559448,
-0.049479831010103226,
0.35080304741859436,
-0.5641592144966125,
0.016141850501298904,
-0.24699842929840088,
-0.6492462158203125,
-0.08803530782461166,
-0.0568869523704052,
0.311081200838089,
-0.18178580701351166,
-0.07313316315412521,
0.1599622219800949,
-0.37647807598114014,
0.5413129329681396,
0.2278931587934494,
-0.6693307161331177,
0.7207819223403931,
0.38181549310684204,
0.9045318961143494,
0.03684525564312935,
0.28809916973114014,
-1.001104712486267,
0.19206972420215607,
-0.5515543222427368,
0.742851197719574,
-0.6098995208740234,
-0.5029240250587463,
-0.16105253994464874,
-0.33542054891586304,
0.15511710941791534,
-0.7113928198814392,
0.6456956267356873,
-0.7119652032852173,
-0.20273874700069427,
0.05577132850885391,
-0.6000385880470276,
-0.35990336537361145,
-0.24465912580490112,
-0.7003293037414551,
0.6355505585670471,
-0.18814268708229065,
-0.14267703890800476,
-0.09644395112991333,
-0.9107786417007446,
-0.6189988851547241,
-0.21941062808036804,
0.05673430114984512,
-0.6031436920166016,
0.5517498850822449,
0.4982123374938965,
0.40366631746292114,
-0.47119784355163574,
-0.2827339172363281,
0.1135421171784401,
-0.42016273736953735,
0.18654532730579376,
-0.5746451616287231,
0.4204574525356293,
0.4425663948059082,
-0.5842549204826355,
-0.11831478774547577,
-0.9445115327835083,
0.0854402482509613,
0.07194770872592926,
-0.4405588209629059,
-0.002965167397633195,
-0.12442535161972046,
0.18942435085773468,
0.1925281435251236,
-0.32597121596336365,
-0.6745736002922058,
-0.33954328298568726,
-0.5008174777030945,
0.7336975932121277,
0.4842849671840668,
-0.1501118540763855,
0.4508717656135559,
-0.1982540488243103,
0.3741089999675751,
-0.09931742399930954,
-0.05486902594566345,
-0.4595130681991577,
-0.3553297519683838,
-0.9839380979537964,
-0.1985749900341034,
0.13424193859100342,
0.3716793358325958,
-0.5501510500907898,
0.4948974847793579,
-0.21186739206314087,
-0.41783377528190613,
-0.6362795829772949,
-0.15829257667064667,
0.7487586736679077,
0.3146064579486847,
0.3798759877681732,
-0.6402544379234314,
-0.5876978635787964,
-0.8185873031616211,
-0.16546931862831116,
-0.12728610634803772,
-0.2968093752861023,
0.27705278992652893,
0.3159879446029663,
-0.06643928587436676,
0.6849402785301208,
-0.3819025158882141,
-0.1930481195449829,
-0.0832970142364502,
-0.07584352791309357,
0.08919776231050491,
0.536780595779419,
0.18366773426532745,
-0.6679455637931824,
-0.3177960515022278,
-0.011807458475232124,
-0.31719106435775757,
-0.10067825019359589,
-0.052842725068330765,
0.18085870146751404,
0.422776460647583,
0.3775700032711029,
-0.474985808134079,
0.515602171421051,
0.5325929522514343,
-0.13176043331623077,
0.264195054769516,
-0.24815256893634796,
0.160207137465477,
-0.5195841789245605,
-0.11505144089460373,
-0.09669400006532669,
-0.14724189043045044,
-1.1398926973342896,
0.027500640600919724,
0.0033309890422970057,
-0.33360162377357483,
-0.34762969613075256,
0.10968059301376343,
-0.68350750207901,
-0.3426814377307892,
-0.24799597263336182,
-0.25199586153030396,
0.05617428943514824,
0.5394916534423828,
0.11601234972476959,
0.9290841221809387,
0.47290804982185364,
-0.5821409225463867,
0.3364686667919159,
0.4533141553401947,
0.1332746148109436,
0.22805577516555786,
-0.8799073100090027,
0.6933271884918213,
-0.3753252327442169,
0.5323163866996765,
-1.0607774257659912,
-0.12456697225570679,
-0.04142337292432785,
-0.8280701637268066,
0.4428887367248535,
-0.1675853431224823,
-0.3541124761104584,
-0.2684481143951416,
-0.3486312925815582,
0.24664707481861115,
0.940895676612854,
-0.6604634523391724,
0.6210909485816956,
0.6029350757598877,
-0.1786428540945053,
-0.24859847128391266,
-1.1041958332061768,
0.1388152688741684,
-0.042692434042692184,
-0.6464285254478455,
0.5873255133628845,
-0.09482686221599579,
0.03481472283601761,
-0.05115104466676712,
-0.25633108615875244,
-0.07902927696704865,
-0.2535015940666199,
0.19311752915382385,
-0.12752826511859894,
-0.22884653508663177,
-0.32199913263320923,
0.1876893788576126,
-0.29555612802505493,
0.03712696209549904,
-0.4295444190502167,
0.673466145992279,
0.18951351940631866,
-0.43001165986061096,
-0.5463494658470154,
0.8471617102622986,
0.6450644135475159,
-0.3636834919452667,
0.658932089805603,
0.705944836139679,
-0.779832124710083,
-0.2862653136253357,
-0.7581408619880676,
-0.1260773092508316,
-0.4525405764579773,
0.5098189115524292,
-0.5439293384552002,
-0.787907063961029,
0.7197089195251465,
0.0364256277680397,
0.13836196064949036,
0.1805233508348465,
0.49713096022605896,
0.3188307583332062,
1.0846500396728516,
0.4043067693710327,
0.13957710564136505,
0.43027547001838684,
-0.4729013442993164,
0.375580370426178,
-1.1902539730072021,
-0.3236953020095825,
-0.6434022188186646,
-0.17737486958503723,
-0.008687111549079418,
-0.7704727053642273,
0.5888180136680603,
-0.015660153701901436,
-0.2341884821653366,
0.3013983964920044,
-0.6696446537971497,
0.4773108959197998,
0.5373761057853699,
0.20465542376041412,
0.07029444724321365,
0.3808394968509674,
0.21700254082679749,
0.10219535231590271,
-0.8801718950271606,
-0.43702730536460876,
1.03866708278656,
0.3403433561325073,
0.5804921388626099,
0.35181689262390137,
0.5318648219108582,
0.2973479926586151,
-0.3430943787097931,
-0.6108545064926147,
0.48085448145866394,
-0.5134741067886353,
-0.2077450305223465,
-0.5131906867027283,
-0.3825301229953766,
-0.5013412833213806,
0.23142720758914948,
-0.16594311594963074,
-0.25566497445106506,
0.14377564191818237,
0.3335902690887451,
-0.6126479506492615,
0.3332681357860565,
-0.5497570037841797,
0.3807224631309509,
0.06029805541038513,
-0.5112068057060242,
-0.31463879346847534,
-0.7180022597312927,
-0.2202281355857849,
-0.09935671091079712,
0.24338895082473755,
0.21440806984901428,
-0.20083291828632355,
0.8024913668632507,
-0.32295161485671997,
0.4672885239124298,
-0.4320071339607239,
0.07793620228767395,
0.21877717971801758,
-0.1206013634800911,
0.7731282711029053,
-0.32861000299453735,
-0.21564054489135742,
0.15619347989559174,
-0.4631311893463135,
-0.06467196345329285,
-0.5917454957962036,
0.25973543524742126,
-0.8651842474937439,
-0.2626427710056305,
0.1275792419910431,
-0.19977891445159912,
-0.043247420340776443,
-0.1661120504140854,
0.47257447242736816,
1.2537606954574585,
-0.0811171904206276,
0.2901540696620941,
0.7890434861183167,
-0.33261364698410034,
0.4870789349079132,
0.26093387603759766,
0.2066764533519745,
-0.4852634370326996,
0.7217011451721191,
0.380887895822525,
0.32675090432167053,
0.4621891975402832,
-0.04110444337129593,
-0.6079437732696533,
-0.8716225624084473,
-0.513151228427887,
-0.11447075754404068,
-0.7180191278457642,
-0.24250712990760803,
-0.7691268920898438,
-0.41457054018974304,
-0.6850834488868713,
-0.37400928139686584,
-0.7211217284202576,
-0.5154553055763245,
-0.29710835218429565,
0.15020163357257843,
0.19070608913898468,
0.4119398295879364,
-0.16340991854667664,
0.6410504579544067,
-0.8026314973831177,
0.3899056911468506,
0.07428613305091858,
0.1586662232875824,
0.07593805342912674,
-0.8312872052192688,
-0.1897668093442917,
-0.03629002720117569,
0.012750481255352497,
-0.7095662951469421,
0.7365767359733582,
0.7212228775024414,
0.6266587972640991,
0.3324698805809021,
0.32518815994262695,
0.9436829090118408,
-0.7576839327812195,
0.7059367895126343,
0.504779040813446,
-1.0933276414871216,
0.3957238495349884,
0.18579423427581787,
0.3988039493560791,
-0.012187166139483452,
-0.031803619116544724,
-0.48174282908439636,
-0.07370076328516006,
-0.3612159192562103,
-1.1415733098983765,
0.6408071517944336,
0.4511469602584839,
0.04461342841386795,
0.21572478115558624,
0.20270299911499023,
-0.019269408658146858,
-0.02592637948691845,
0.0004632563213817775,
-0.3693130910396576,
-0.1190730482339859,
-0.024280469864606857,
-0.07625948637723923,
-0.3569244146347046,
-0.09785778075456619,
-0.18808892369270325,
0.6836274266242981,
-0.10899035632610321,
0.6579909324645996,
0.45932093262672424,
-0.2597880959510803,
-0.15489307045936584,
0.4883737862110138,
0.486336350440979,
0.06362484395503998,
0.06897212564945221,
0.3226892352104187,
0.3456666171550751,
-0.3350565731525421,
0.25895658135414124,
0.12611724436283112,
-0.1417744904756546,
0.18709968030452728,
0.029005974531173706,
1.1541401147842407,
0.03973282873630524,
-0.5646184086799622,
0.42405375838279724,
-0.0400671511888504,
-0.09782848507165909,
-0.5090655088424683,
-0.03912756219506264,
-0.09819304943084717,
0.3286725878715515,
0.5454221367835999,
0.42987358570098877,
0.5875844359397888,
-0.24965770542621613,
0.25914695858955383,
0.32865381240844727,
-0.06398622691631317,
-0.3635602295398712,
1.013792872428894,
0.5663208365440369,
-0.6150358319282532,
0.7639316320419312,
-0.00041069992585107684,
-0.6095895171165466,
0.5782265663146973,
0.7529556751251221,
1.036589503288269,
-0.37349575757980347,
-0.2728646993637085,
0.3737662732601166,
0.2847331762313843,
-0.19076429307460785,
-0.013507559895515442,
-0.19930386543273926,
-0.6494085192680359,
-0.5176578760147095,
-0.6559139490127563,
-0.502058744430542,
-0.17692497372627258,
-0.7639688849449158,
0.22542783617973328,
-0.1466027945280075,
-0.2252267301082611,
0.054273318499326706,
-0.3048403561115265,
-0.49325600266456604,
0.0009385208250023425,
0.5393832325935364,
0.7166019678115845,
-0.4936731457710266,
0.5623337030410767,
0.5266187787055969,
-0.04265836253762245,
-0.7135476469993591,
-0.34771159291267395,
0.290971577167511,
-0.523712158203125,
0.24224455654621124,
0.3257339894771576,
-0.45035845041275024,
0.2548944354057312,
-0.2161424160003662,
-0.6994508504867554,
0.8601028919219971,
0.42148253321647644,
-0.9251484870910645,
-0.10624906420707703,
0.1771371066570282,
0.34486889839172363,
-0.5369582176208496,
0.516876757144928,
0.7550445199012756,
0.2684261202812195,
0.29131999611854553,
-1.1339138746261597,
-0.09314259141683578,
-0.6439768075942993,
0.3393644690513611,
0.12954695522785187,
-0.47233882546424866,
0.5792027711868286,
-0.35133492946624756,
-0.3363950252532959,
-0.29003143310546875,
0.43979987502098083,
0.11692585796117783,
0.2939612865447998,
0.5638214945793152,
0.4293472468852997,
0.3778652250766754,
0.02882571890950203,
0.7255244255065918,
-0.5265989899635315,
0.10127199441194534,
0.5530419945716858,
-0.2340153008699417,
1.080331802368164,
0.4464389383792877,
-0.11983706802129745,
-0.1468978226184845,
0.38993754982948303,
0.12108243256807327,
0.583893358707428,
0.2432074099779129,
-0.20901328325271606,
-0.1719510406255722,
-0.0858784019947052,
-0.33622750639915466,
0.4933755099773407,
0.3810359537601471,
-0.3045852482318878,
0.14818733930587769,
0.3799072802066803,
0.17164060473442078,
0.02058873325586319,
-0.41753339767456055,
0.8260505199432373,
-0.133677139878273,
-0.3224409818649292,
0.7780038714408875,
-0.09644661098718643,
0.90663743019104,
-0.5889322757720947,
-0.20082981884479523,
-0.015401755459606647,
0.4288059175014496,
-0.45196399092674255,
-0.4376528561115265,
0.5660392045974731,
0.39763495326042175,
-0.20846343040466309,
-0.3621094524860382,
0.6534569263458252,
-0.4503040015697479,
-0.289886474609375,
0.33783379197120667,
0.4356677234172821,
0.42937636375427246,
-0.25034990906715393,
-0.18827316164970398,
0.6067066788673401,
0.061940163373947144,
-0.5008723139762878,
0.17834053933620453,
-0.0059343306347727776,
0.38412365317344666,
0.4241182804107666,
0.9495919942855835,
0.2934695780277252,
0.3976442217826843,
0.04154719412326813,
1.072860836982727,
-0.4340918958187103,
-0.6312035322189331,
-0.6056762933731079,
0.4751485586166382,
-0.03425782918930054,
-0.0462755523622036,
0.4054231643676758,
0.8750191330909729,
0.8187770247459412,
0.07529044151306152,
0.8491962552070618,
-0.1329048126935959,
0.3909491300582886,
-0.5033156275749207,
0.5358532667160034,
-0.45739373564720154,
0.5039553046226501,
-0.14850002527236938,
-0.6938046813011169,
-0.42061159014701843,
0.7959147691726685,
0.40411505103111267,
-0.19169174134731293,
0.473652720451355,
1.0012661218643188,
0.3411167562007904,
0.1589542031288147,
0.5329240560531616,
0.19615381956100464,
0.616436243057251,
0.5853605270385742,
0.5014687776565552,
-0.6471843719482422,
0.8245077133178711,
-0.4050044119358063,
-0.4377557039260864,
-0.017854642122983932,
-0.4380975663661957,
-0.5504003763198853,
-0.5485010743141174,
-0.43105271458625793,
-0.19305336475372314,
0.4257189631462097,
0.9412851333618164,
0.762837827205658,
-0.664841890335083,
-0.35343897342681885,
0.07621684670448303,
-0.5979412198066711,
-0.46393507719039917,
-0.09618932753801346,
0.29556044936180115,
0.04604464769363403,
-0.785133421421051,
0.5237931609153748,
0.4755692780017853,
-0.24320903420448303,
-0.01623934507369995,
-0.28969496488571167,
0.36997994780540466,
0.15453492105007172,
0.7374876141548157,
0.12632565200328827,
-0.6894367933273315,
-0.42830124497413635,
0.2971848249435425,
0.27462321519851685,
0.12269627302885056,
0.83335942029953,
-0.6739583015441895,
0.5974593758583069,
0.6450157761573792,
0.751609206199646,
0.7275919914245605,
0.036049649119377136,
0.5660224556922913,
-0.36686766147613525,
-0.02445249632000923,
0.3158789873123169,
0.24099473655223846,
0.2960885763168335,
-0.3092055022716522,
0.5733221769332886,
0.05203060805797577,
-0.6260010004043579,
-0.8946727514266968,
0.02914213389158249,
-0.7983388304710388,
-0.07149465382099152,
1.1582714319229126,
-0.14314112067222595,
-0.3083323538303375,
-0.3170666992664337,
-0.13948723673820496,
0.49053725600242615,
-0.6675921082496643,
0.21247003972530365,
0.3382199704647064,
-0.7868565320968628,
-0.46752312779426575,
-0.48431888222694397,
0.04243449866771698,
0.17203488945960999,
-0.5435537695884705,
0.33529987931251526,
0.7735933661460876,
0.09298370033502579,
0.16609205305576324,
0.7188645601272583,
-0.2047511786222458,
0.4120606780052185,
0.547615647315979,
0.15969516336917877,
-0.4740387499332428,
-0.2595353424549103,
-0.8040807843208313,
0.40489158034324646,
-0.2554992735385895,
-0.3224627375602722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17168v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17168v1
|
Benchmarking Data Science Agents
| 2024-02-27T03:03:06 | 2024-02-27T03:03:06 |
Yuge Zhang, Qiyang Jiang, Xingyu Han, Nan Chen, Yuqing Yang, Kan Ren
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the era of data-driven decision-making, the complexity of data analysis
necessitates advanced expertise and tools of data science, presenting
significant challenges even for specialists. Large Language Models (LLMs) have
emerged as promising aids as data science agents, assisting humans in data
analysis and processing. Yet their practical efficacy remains constrained by
the varied demands of real-world applications and complicated analytical
process. In this paper, we introduce DSEval -- a novel evaluation paradigm, as
well as a series of innovative benchmarks tailored for assessing the
performance of these agents throughout the entire data science lifecycle.
Incorporating a novel bootstrapped annotation method, we streamline dataset
preparation, improve the evaluation coverage, and expand benchmarking
comprehensiveness. Our findings uncover prevalent obstacles and provide
critical insights to inform future advancements in the field.
|
[
-0.2031412124633789,
-0.562290370464325,
0.6252875924110413,
0.17247143387794495,
-0.04235300049185753,
0.6950230002403259,
-0.312219500541687,
-0.4787885248661041,
0.028068330138921738,
0.2756068706512451,
-0.6541274189949036,
-0.6935962438583374,
-0.5330362915992737,
0.2806697189807892,
-0.5036835670471191,
0.968524694442749,
0.052056729793548584,
0.07412571460008621,
-0.5989688634872437,
-0.14286193251609802,
-0.09099438041448593,
-0.38942983746528625,
-0.38482654094696045,
-0.27463096380233765,
0.42651525139808655,
0.27065184712409973,
0.8948960304260254,
0.9390058517456055,
0.6156355142593384,
0.3806411027908325,
0.12108996510505676,
0.13614793121814728,
-0.3976249098777771,
0.6344307065010071,
-0.17502716183662415,
-0.43052464723587036,
-0.6436569690704346,
0.19300580024719238,
0.7800531387329102,
1.1402026414871216,
-0.16913993656635284,
0.36370575428009033,
-0.17202481627464294,
0.9088477492332458,
-0.7739388942718506,
0.5636249780654907,
-0.7384772300720215,
-0.07799704372882843,
-0.2551945745944977,
0.044866614043712616,
-0.25879523158073425,
-0.5271859765052795,
0.09571632742881775,
-0.5495052933692932,
-0.07499437779188156,
-0.08726750314235687,
0.3661223351955414,
0.5916637182235718,
-0.24883131682872772,
-0.17391939461231232,
-0.6324019432067871,
0.94073885679245,
-0.4845944344997406,
0.26895642280578613,
0.2635529935359955,
0.8525014519691467,
-0.33892571926116943,
-0.7217651009559631,
-0.32179099321365356,
-0.5040470957756042,
0.1737108677625656,
-0.35591766238212585,
-0.09306257963180542,
-0.2088451236486435,
0.24437129497528076,
0.10905726253986359,
-0.20649684965610504,
0.2725660502910614,
-0.3790786862373352,
-0.12775570154190063,
1.138092041015625,
0.5862460732460022,
-0.07229284197092056,
0.2104460895061493,
-0.25381526350975037,
-0.1475621610879898,
-0.572664201259613,
-0.33577170968055725,
0.1294640749692917,
0.7695804238319397,
0.1673789769411087,
0.31587716937065125,
-0.5511520504951477,
0.5314127802848816,
-0.34271761775016785,
0.03831551969051361,
0.6110478639602661,
-0.21688033640384674,
-0.17555664479732513,
-0.15944413840770721,
0.6196520328521729,
0.3462618589401245,
0.1495465487241745,
-0.4325714409351349,
-0.37488311529159546,
0.1939670592546463,
0.1903214305639267,
-0.8866984844207764,
-0.0837860032916069,
0.53090900182724,
-0.036136284470558167,
-0.6835801005363464,
-0.3096921145915985,
-1.0507497787475586,
-1.154969573020935,
-0.38511183857917786,
0.3249536454677582,
-0.10972489416599274,
-0.2985078990459442,
-0.1352654993534088,
0.10482282191514969,
0.07665414363145828,
0.32537201046943665,
-0.5379592776298523,
0.6821176409721375,
0.832636296749115,
0.7160448431968689,
-0.38763466477394104,
-0.46214988827705383,
-0.5668980479240417,
-0.175983265042305,
-0.7106711268424988,
0.9076770544052124,
-0.8941004276275635,
-0.24451321363449097,
-0.060921233147382736,
-0.06668314337730408,
-0.043669212609529495,
-0.4766042232513428,
0.5406979322433472,
-0.5587959289550781,
-0.5260158777236938,
-0.5281670689582825,
-0.5876025557518005,
0.04361014440655708,
0.1828957200050354,
-0.6928456425666809,
1.2811777591705322,
0.21299876272678375,
-0.4851957857608795,
0.815466582775116,
-0.5747770667076111,
-0.2607881426811218,
0.5447173714637756,
-0.4639117419719696,
-0.4350755512714386,
-0.09327462315559387,
0.08648530393838882,
0.6840536594390869,
-0.8417269587516785,
0.38645321130752563,
-0.4090658128261566,
-0.29703375697135925,
0.44089505076408386,
-0.17398788034915924,
0.431866854429245,
0.3286561071872711,
-0.301534503698349,
0.24518702924251556,
-1.161787986755371,
0.19717317819595337,
0.19999468326568604,
-0.062299035489559174,
-0.2110181599855423,
0.31990116834640503,
0.15463516116142273,
0.1895110011100769,
-0.011493632569909096,
-0.4539271593093872,
0.3052106499671936,
0.16679291427135468,
0.5087293386459351,
0.8524956703186035,
-0.2503710985183716,
0.017801934853196144,
-0.20687179267406464,
0.6833786368370056,
-0.12730854749679565,
0.014322820119559765,
-0.016166340559720993,
0.04719921573996544,
-0.4763830602169037,
-0.6446025967597961,
0.46290716528892517,
0.2242947518825531,
-0.7691402435302734,
0.37090885639190674,
-0.5584070086479187,
-1.0503487586975098,
-0.853241503238678,
0.018010929226875305,
0.199171781539917,
0.5082066059112549,
0.3771359324455261,
-0.03978411853313446,
-0.39716804027557373,
-0.9858571290969849,
-0.20593290030956268,
-0.0494849793612957,
0.0902540311217308,
0.10923495143651962,
0.7079929113388062,
-0.36171427369117737,
0.9124321341514587,
-0.4323470890522003,
0.10200349241495132,
-0.3829617202281952,
0.007048376370221376,
0.07431211322546005,
0.195221409201622,
0.35465919971466064,
-0.6037439107894897,
-0.4131758213043213,
-0.05787346512079239,
-0.8731546401977539,
-0.45328283309936523,
0.005744533613324165,
0.2337353229522705,
0.22945702075958252,
0.5590291619300842,
-0.3369846045970917,
0.29052281379699707,
0.2358243763446808,
-0.24247264862060547,
0.5996201634407043,
-0.16427965462207794,
0.263437420129776,
-0.5165307521820068,
0.29963865876197815,
0.010344014503061771,
-0.1878587156534195,
-0.7632305026054382,
-0.18316087126731873,
0.2468670904636383,
-0.011582811363041401,
-0.19246149063110352,
0.43407684564590454,
-0.5202999114990234,
-0.44351065158843994,
-0.14522606134414673,
0.2517850399017334,
-0.16606701910495758,
0.0105202067643404,
0.004512075800448656,
0.9419595003128052,
0.8491310477256775,
-0.5480540990829468,
0.6166095733642578,
0.12923522293567657,
-0.4311210513114929,
0.6860013008117676,
-0.7547082304954529,
0.09906315803527832,
-0.19777464866638184,
0.3455626368522644,
-0.9948397874832153,
-0.06729953736066818,
-0.14135690033435822,
-0.02929641678929329,
0.2704973518848419,
-0.07739318907260895,
-0.7441532611846924,
-0.408176988363266,
-0.6482362747192383,
0.26543691754341125,
0.2648116648197174,
-0.5188394784927368,
0.3269684314727783,
0.4983263611793518,
-0.23487597703933716,
-0.5625032782554626,
-0.4416874349117279,
0.3644215762615204,
-0.38116294145584106,
-0.5148388743400574,
0.15699955821037292,
-0.07110413163900375,
-0.5235471725463867,
-0.14927604794502258,
-0.1522188037633896,
0.026115331798791885,
0.23941639065742493,
0.19436658918857574,
0.42809075117111206,
-0.02970658428966999,
0.32980552315711975,
-0.13877716660499573,
-0.4080033600330353,
0.03347108140587807,
0.10641622543334961,
0.23484602570533752,
-0.28620418906211853,
-0.3784520626068115,
-0.1995038539171219,
0.04525220766663551,
0.9150267243385315,
-0.37110260128974915,
0.7053948044776917,
0.1967240422964096,
-0.2803053855895996,
-0.3993910551071167,
-0.7460480332374573,
-0.04874802753329277,
-0.47227996587753296,
0.7602058053016663,
-0.40724873542785645,
-0.1265125274658203,
0.42506054043769836,
-0.33245059847831726,
-0.0449240542948246,
0.4024914503097534,
0.42812180519104004,
0.33139461278915405,
0.8240354657173157,
0.35332199931144714,
-0.24607324600219727,
0.00917186588048935,
-0.18522867560386658,
-0.12525959312915802,
-0.7473741173744202,
-0.15808790922164917,
-0.6558412313461304,
-0.022501332685351372,
-0.6367906332015991,
-0.4353565573692322,
0.35928788781166077,
-0.29719898104667664,
-0.3243103325366974,
0.2950776517391205,
-0.45193222165107727,
0.4787059724330902,
0.028699049726128578,
-0.24519763886928558,
0.4261268675327301,
-0.19114269316196442,
0.2725422978401184,
-0.03736310452222824,
-0.38536232709884644,
-0.8408032655715942,
1.5526888370513916,
0.5338934063911438,
0.8504931926727295,
-0.31710368394851685,
0.5251628756523132,
0.7064638733863831,
0.29041847586631775,
-0.6221848130226135,
0.8017324209213257,
0.11260268837213516,
-0.46516290307044983,
-0.3627030849456787,
-0.34159785509109497,
-0.9447900652885437,
0.4886273741722107,
-0.25513461232185364,
-0.8920470476150513,
0.03788942098617554,
-0.31908300518989563,
-0.06516759842634201,
0.036119915544986725,
-0.4405035078525543,
0.664152204990387,
-0.3204640746116638,
-0.7597880363464355,
-0.21067017316818237,
-0.6581306457519531,
-0.1740444153547287,
-0.23849882185459137,
0.40300503373146057,
-0.5123733878135681,
-0.3926471769809723,
0.759240448474884,
-0.5438557863235474,
0.576838493347168,
-0.3675341010093689,
-0.05325556546449661,
0.08332591503858566,
-0.10421723127365112,
0.6026535034179688,
-0.1489631086587906,
-0.6416077017784119,
0.11563052982091904,
0.25465476512908936,
-0.46759697794914246,
-0.41927602887153625,
0.7082474231719971,
-0.4796355366706848,
-0.34190359711647034,
-0.6835586428642273,
-0.6635659337043762,
-0.6267362833023071,
0.033114586025476456,
-0.3521493971347809,
0.22895541787147522,
-0.30860838294029236,
0.15731105208396912,
0.2950117290019989,
0.05026615783572197,
0.34229981899261475,
0.8304704427719116,
-0.074421726167202,
-0.23568637669086456,
0.8004695773124695,
0.31037217378616333,
0.28861764073371887,
-0.0834706649184227,
-0.015406041406095028,
-0.38047510385513306,
-0.8657446503639221,
-0.48245328664779663,
0.15580260753631592,
-0.8148175477981567,
-0.22128178179264069,
-0.49244424700737,
0.02090654894709587,
-0.08358971029520035,
-0.06494587659835815,
-0.749807596206665,
-0.4391869008541107,
0.22979246079921722,
-0.11568479984998703,
0.44978800415992737,
1.0102596282958984,
0.011327975429594517,
-0.22796377539634705,
-0.38514161109924316,
0.1082543432712555,
0.08012202382087708,
0.5262461304664612,
0.12142357230186462,
0.06981732696294785,
-0.32104265689849854,
-0.12417562305927277,
0.01291279774159193,
-0.6242291927337646,
0.14725160598754883,
0.030044028535485268,
0.8556730151176453,
-0.004277732223272324,
0.07670453935861588,
0.4797479212284088,
-0.4589642584323883,
0.5261380672454834,
-0.37353524565696716,
-0.7606048583984375,
0.40512725710868835,
-0.2783181965351105,
-0.12097245454788208,
0.930731475353241,
0.40273749828338623,
-0.3885369896888733,
-0.04282373562455177,
-0.24957914650440216,
-1.0781344175338745,
0.7383018136024475,
0.2591548562049866,
-0.31934794783592224,
0.10993187874555588,
0.17174114286899567,
0.4278879761695862,
0.5347701907157898,
-0.22967208921909332,
-0.28725486993789673,
0.19701820611953735,
-0.10206107795238495,
-0.14948338270187378,
0.06710845977067947,
-0.14345002174377441,
-0.17385342717170715,
0.7619456648826599,
-0.24968257546424866,
-0.2426833063364029,
-0.03262954205274582,
-0.286588579416275,
-0.024085532873868942,
0.43610191345214844,
0.1940992772579193,
0.94755619764328,
-0.18063752353191376,
-0.09860335290431976,
0.18292705714702606,
-0.5222213268280029,
0.13228130340576172,
0.6740970015525818,
0.02548426389694214,
-0.3668782413005829,
0.49137333035469055,
0.3404218852519989,
-0.051158249378204346,
-0.8944486379623413,
0.4404022693634033,
-0.021748531609773636,
0.14051854610443115,
-0.06516263633966446,
0.03734345734119415,
0.0001505599939264357,
0.41538482904434204,
0.8018780946731567,
-0.3209657371044159,
0.18494538962841034,
-0.39813897013664246,
0.10606299340724945,
0.48174166679382324,
-0.2650562524795532,
-0.25642696022987366,
0.491364449262619,
0.22743164002895355,
-0.03138972818851471,
0.4453500807285309,
-0.2448696792125702,
-0.36677658557891846,
0.814314067363739,
0.2049991935491562,
0.9003902077674866,
-0.22324085235595703,
0.2516738176345825,
0.052933186292648315,
0.28916749358177185,
-0.021179720759391785,
0.21471816301345825,
-0.161297008395195,
-0.3273043632507324,
-0.12836933135986328,
-0.6020746827125549,
-0.6499242782592773,
0.05518082156777382,
-0.7375923991203308,
0.3237009644508362,
-0.24589648842811584,
0.04272514581680298,
0.4646429419517517,
0.4712761342525482,
-0.9588767886161804,
0.26443156599998474,
0.0965578705072403,
0.9201157093048096,
-1.058423399925232,
0.6799595952033997,
0.6036768555641174,
-0.4083150625228882,
-0.1329110711812973,
-0.14321018755435944,
0.19389581680297852,
-0.811115026473999,
0.6521333456039429,
0.18723079562187195,
-0.14574480056762695,
-0.4203335642814636,
-0.47383615374565125,
-0.7522577047348022,
1.3604010343551636,
0.2908327281475067,
-0.5322784185409546,
0.3999080955982208,
0.3576519191265106,
0.9717258214950562,
-0.7106629014015198,
0.5548200607299805,
1.1537965536117554,
0.615856409072876,
-0.005674986634403467,
-0.8129674196243286,
0.3770985007286072,
-0.3619862198829651,
0.11583422869443893,
0.12121192365884781,
-0.6490863561630249,
0.711580753326416,
-0.12027178704738617,
-0.10876472294330597,
0.03161921724677086,
0.3985210061073303,
0.3724465072154999,
0.5758734941482544,
0.41193240880966187,
0.020572645589709282,
0.9414223432540894,
0.07983028888702393,
0.9834297895431519,
-0.24093292653560638,
0.2173825204372406,
1.0695979595184326,
-0.8819248676300049,
0.7464845776557922,
0.3601853847503662,
-0.764102041721344,
0.45693403482437134,
0.5901524424552917,
-0.2749190628528595,
0.38875749707221985,
0.5500063896179199,
-0.13397379219532013,
-0.20810458064079285,
-0.3383564054965973,
-0.40320250391960144,
0.40203383564949036,
0.6595707535743713,
-0.18286339938640594,
-0.25651437044143677,
-0.20667664706707,
-0.09335574507713318,
0.37890002131462097,
-0.30928894877433777,
0.5609628558158875,
-0.35828885436058044,
-0.2800379991531372,
0.5786251425743103,
-0.40940770506858826,
0.3325277268886566,
-0.5779893398284912,
-0.03870430961251259,
-0.12382499873638153,
0.08665355294942856,
-0.3099566400051117,
-0.6545424461364746,
0.06865271180868149,
0.03895871341228485,
0.22872933745384216,
0.16476240754127502,
0.4722772538661957,
-0.1922498345375061,
-0.6255781650543213,
0.3906283974647522,
0.5377938747406006,
0.281121164560318,
0.025408713147044182,
-0.7104525566101074,
0.4140622019767761,
-0.43306684494018555,
-0.41731321811676025,
0.247691348195076,
0.34854745864868164,
-0.27481186389923096,
1.0275795459747314,
0.2852358818054199,
0.3319379687309265,
-0.3808336853981018,
0.24413572251796722,
1.2255525588989258,
-0.7569075226783752,
-0.2708550691604614,
-0.8803992867469788,
0.5699095129966736,
-0.34357520937919617,
0.08961311727762222,
0.6438170671463013,
0.6610196232795715,
0.26930302381515503,
0.18999755382537842,
1.020646572113037,
-0.036668356508016586,
0.7853623032569885,
-0.12987136840820312,
0.7703799605369568,
-0.3508692979812622,
0.7236210703849792,
-0.6303261518478394,
-0.9272081851959229,
-0.1658022105693817,
0.11973844468593597,
-0.6349471211433411,
0.28461670875549316,
0.599608838558197,
0.7597531676292419,
0.1870613992214203,
0.08733022212982178,
0.2734176218509674,
0.2536521852016449,
0.4443439841270447,
0.27109766006469727,
0.8871394991874695,
-0.35914474725723267,
0.3588945269584656,
-0.13424807786941528,
-0.41076192259788513,
-0.0838378369808197,
-1.0731335878372192,
-1.1068212985992432,
-0.719529390335083,
-0.5047614574432373,
-0.16130612790584564,
0.33741894364356995,
1.1204447746276855,
0.652917206287384,
-0.6671591997146606,
-0.18415617942810059,
0.012145147658884525,
0.0004105323168914765,
-0.27911576628685,
-0.14550074934959412,
0.6410242915153503,
-0.39821574091911316,
-0.6543711423873901,
0.6004144549369812,
0.3316623568534851,
-0.11489301174879074,
-0.5642926096916199,
0.15893396735191345,
-0.030524658039212227,
0.12677861750125885,
0.3742448687553406,
0.1403416097164154,
-0.35408973693847656,
-0.014789042063057423,
-0.3171449303627014,
-0.12750038504600525,
-0.05032895877957344,
0.5936216711997986,
-0.9923663139343262,
0.5275134444236755,
0.16334761679172516,
0.9345436096191406,
0.5166455507278442,
-0.010610801167786121,
0.4517837166786194,
-0.5162870287895203,
-0.012885806150734425,
0.30645883083343506,
0.047154076397418976,
0.7311325669288635,
-0.20228126645088196,
0.9141610264778137,
-0.12564882636070251,
-0.6480422019958496,
-1.1926723718643188,
-0.06370994448661804,
-0.5920273661613464,
-0.20364132523536682,
1.1269711256027222,
-0.05524875596165657,
-0.12618668377399445,
-0.16832296550273895,
0.050353024154901505,
-0.12700790166854858,
-0.5178799629211426,
0.9807949662208557,
0.6584295630455017,
-0.17816586792469025,
0.27480342984199524,
-0.6557376980781555,
0.6273255348205566,
0.2965192496776581,
-1.1534653902053833,
0.6072713732719421,
0.4677349925041199,
0.1867736279964447,
-0.09267979860305786,
0.4887007772922516,
-0.13360686600208282,
0.11813473701477051,
0.29052218794822693,
-0.1544388234615326,
-0.27449652552604675,
-0.34023383259773254,
-0.4878605604171753,
-0.022107021883130074,
0.3434556722640991,
-0.10772762447595596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17151v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17151v2
|
Clustering Document Parts: Detecting and Characterizing Influence Campaigns from Documents
| 2024-02-27T02:36:43 | 2024-04-26T20:01:28 |
Zhengxiang Wang, Owen Rambow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose a novel clustering pipeline to detect and characterize influence
campaigns from documents. This approach clusters parts of document, detects
clusters that likely reflect an influence campaign, and then identifies
documents linked to an influence campaign via their association with the
high-influence clusters. Our approach outperforms both the direct
document-level classification and the direct document-level clustering approach
in predicting if a document is part of an influence campaign. We propose
various novel techniques to enhance our pipeline, including using an existing
event factuality prediction system to obtain document parts, and aggregating
multiple clustering experiments to improve the performance of both cluster and
document classification. Classifying documents after clustering not only
accurately extracts the parts of the documents that are relevant to influence
campaigns, but also captures influence campaigns as a coordinated and holistic
phenomenon. Our approach makes possible more fine-grained and interpretable
characterizations of influence campaigns from documents.
|
[
-0.2912408709526062,
-0.7563675045967102,
0.8372088670730591,
0.08100461214780807,
-0.20773692429065704,
0.12936481833457947,
-0.08891131728887558,
-0.26272666454315186,
0.7401708364486694,
0.5843222141265869,
-0.6396622657775879,
-0.9058025479316711,
-1.1254667043685913,
-0.33967044949531555,
-0.9082571268081665,
1.1148797273635864,
0.2800944745540619,
0.038111746311187744,
-0.3977544903755188,
-0.09277034550905228,
-0.1553184688091278,
-0.25023627281188965,
-0.6290633082389832,
-0.18684978783130646,
0.8701481819152832,
0.44129908084869385,
0.04215569421648979,
0.6660833954811096,
0.3843538761138916,
0.2626597583293915,
-0.15916454792022705,
-0.1567244678735733,
-0.7855498790740967,
0.11828387528657913,
-0.4341066777706146,
-0.6549690365791321,
-0.05758020281791687,
0.31455543637275696,
0.7875889539718628,
0.14976990222930908,
-0.15758177638053894,
0.10050695389509201,
-0.14634765684604645,
0.36791476607322693,
-0.6133057475090027,
0.4076768755912781,
-0.9721549153327942,
-0.284128338098526,
-0.6317647695541382,
-0.06789441406726837,
-0.5995081067085266,
-0.27107271552085876,
-0.23318174481391907,
-0.5423913598060608,
0.9073115587234497,
0.2438962757587433,
0.4971306622028351,
0.013960153795778751,
-0.6199599504470825,
-0.6910268664360046,
-0.7960995435714722,
0.7582999467849731,
-0.550643801689148,
0.1776222288608551,
0.20211513340473175,
-0.012437310069799423,
-0.13025224208831787,
-1.0680123567581177,
-0.616172730922699,
0.293449729681015,
-0.23078477382659912,
0.17175912857055664,
-0.21290920674800873,
-0.12166599184274673,
0.02459731139242649,
0.2737945318222046,
-0.22923974692821503,
0.11326765269041061,
-0.33908241987228394,
-0.26201435923576355,
0.5205291509628296,
-0.13511794805526733,
0.2378939986228943,
-0.37218552827835083,
-0.31030941009521484,
-0.3239595890045166,
-0.7349415421485901,
-0.04655701294541359,
0.5006778836250305,
0.23554326593875885,
0.03204554691910744,
0.34100082516670227,
-0.32454463839530945,
0.27817487716674805,
0.5879727602005005,
-0.005150703713297844,
-0.17220421135425568,
-0.6025628447532654,
-0.03888994827866554,
0.48741844296455383,
0.6748561263084412,
0.14278794825077057,
-0.5936626195907593,
0.008404459804296494,
0.21404580771923065,
0.18272188305854797,
0.24934548139572144,
-1.1483659744262695,
-0.15952572226524353,
0.018275581300258636,
-0.708289623260498,
-0.573746383190155,
0.7242910861968994,
-0.8528739213943481,
-1.0230627059936523,
-0.22532713413238525,
0.25093093514442444,
-0.11511307954788208,
-0.30747780203819275,
-0.3154335618019104,
-0.7201145887374878,
0.1281503438949585,
0.4575021266937256,
-0.7775788307189941,
-0.006213271524757147,
1.3430095911026,
0.8270456790924072,
-0.3479122221469879,
-0.1067943125963211,
-0.6408706903457642,
0.1240931898355484,
-0.44337013363838196,
1.1867214441299438,
-0.8704615831375122,
-0.607621431350708,
0.24682706594467163,
0.4928968548774719,
-0.07019944489002228,
-0.41031622886657715,
0.8138308525085449,
-0.5831584334373474,
0.29769599437713623,
-0.5256078839302063,
-0.8446632623672485,
-0.14108645915985107,
0.12746651470661163,
-0.9011996388435364,
0.8293492794036865,
0.17771217226982117,
-0.8772943019866943,
0.7782534956932068,
-0.5124089121818542,
-0.48572686314582825,
-0.07377293705940247,
-0.2347496598958969,
-0.35778796672821045,
0.1607639342546463,
-0.04354461655020714,
0.577802836894989,
-0.19732524454593658,
0.22197286784648895,
-0.31682610511779785,
-0.11514152586460114,
-0.13387495279312134,
-0.058564428240060806,
0.6099245548248291,
-0.22110170125961304,
-0.37863394618034363,
0.4458186626434326,
-0.763767421245575,
-0.6235852837562561,
-0.23332956433296204,
-0.13802514970302582,
-0.7275083065032959,
0.2909694015979767,
-0.127382293343544,
0.015166939236223698,
0.2997259795665741,
-0.7593138813972473,
0.3104792833328247,
-0.0243978351354599,
0.03036859817802906,
0.7456763386726379,
0.7002264261245728,
0.9195384383201599,
-0.09218364953994751,
0.3824896216392517,
0.07324009388685226,
0.15010185539722443,
-0.23393182456493378,
-0.6099146604537964,
-0.9627693295478821,
-0.046873513609170914,
0.2054544985294342,
0.14807675778865814,
-0.4469674825668335,
0.5575875639915466,
-0.10558993369340897,
-0.867413341999054,
-0.11500658094882965,
-0.03417216241359711,
0.02346811257302761,
0.45144450664520264,
0.1688838005065918,
-0.2945527732372284,
-0.3409067392349243,
-0.6543802618980408,
-0.3294655978679657,
-0.34506839513778687,
-0.051894307136535645,
-0.0643366351723671,
0.5361840724945068,
-0.1102961078286171,
0.799825131893158,
-0.5933104753494263,
-0.6144559979438782,
0.2739921808242798,
0.5860274434089661,
0.22761374711990356,
0.23391376435756683,
0.6517382264137268,
-0.8717822432518005,
-0.5630989670753479,
0.29065510630607605,
-0.22879859805107117,
-0.09952816367149353,
-0.18746218085289001,
-0.26026812195777893,
-0.18357285857200623,
0.9989759922027588,
-0.25058209896087646,
0.4109058678150177,
0.2692570388317108,
-0.7872017025947571,
0.4021357297897339,
0.010226803831756115,
0.4412815570831299,
-1.0206128358840942,
-0.3300964832305908,
0.21696899831295013,
0.19804152846336365,
-0.6138073205947876,
-0.25948840379714966,
0.034383129328489304,
0.034285686910152435,
-0.216221421957016,
0.3961780071258545,
-0.19440051913261414,
0.24239592254161835,
-0.421730637550354,
-0.025670848786830902,
0.329240620136261,
0.10145565867424011,
-0.010647735558450222,
0.20917324721813202,
0.5693762302398682,
-0.17848294973373413,
0.48648780584335327,
0.09401489049196243,
-0.5997284054756165,
0.9743385910987854,
-0.4974803626537323,
0.08407957851886749,
-0.2826688289642334,
0.7064311504364014,
-1.071196436882019,
-0.20567426085472107,
0.21514476835727692,
-0.1375739574432373,
0.4443442225456238,
-0.6504946351051331,
-0.4871464669704437,
0.014679188840091228,
-0.22629253566265106,
-0.25335437059402466,
0.20458915829658508,
-0.4150961935520172,
0.8470864295959473,
0.5061349272727966,
-0.1021689623594284,
-0.2208147644996643,
-0.1764262169599533,
-0.1345612108707428,
-0.4783094823360443,
-0.48556262254714966,
0.5430905222892761,
0.22515657544136047,
-0.1016339659690857,
0.27427244186401367,
-0.08705301582813263,
-0.30699869990348816,
-0.3254065215587616,
0.7542116045951843,
-0.08684875816106796,
-0.13656874001026154,
0.19856703281402588,
0.3292774260044098,
0.00007269501656992361,
0.203028604388237,
-0.6585710048675537,
0.23386825621128082,
0.2381756752729416,
-0.46988609433174133,
-0.13548998534679413,
0.5564271211624146,
0.7945613861083984,
-0.23656560480594635,
0.8378653526306152,
1.2714245319366455,
-0.18692167103290558,
-0.38093093037605286,
-0.7480496764183044,
-0.4445972144603729,
-0.40892326831817627,
0.2172262966632843,
0.1307343691587448,
-0.7471991181373596,
0.5619483590126038,
-0.3745741546154022,
0.0007434964063577354,
0.8616901636123657,
0.6184409856796265,
-0.042977262288331985,
0.849252462387085,
0.796674907207489,
-0.47626209259033203,
0.9338929653167725,
-0.5887441039085388,
0.11660582572221756,
-0.5672461986541748,
-0.4468923807144165,
-0.8924933671951294,
-0.2637734115123749,
-0.5593925714492798,
-0.8822209239006042,
0.39036428928375244,
-0.011698197573423386,
0.39200860261917114,
0.2268156111240387,
-0.43061232566833496,
0.38565993309020996,
0.7591875195503235,
-0.04165693372488022,
0.24892424046993256,
0.0840638279914856,
0.21405181288719177,
0.28041204810142517,
-0.7284403443336487,
-0.20362907648086548,
0.8694406151771545,
-0.06958212703466415,
0.663104236125946,
-0.0509941391646862,
0.7180260419845581,
0.7929219007492065,
0.5509035587310791,
-0.8727802038192749,
0.2708175778388977,
-0.18222714960575104,
-0.7444131374359131,
-0.2714370787143707,
-0.04412582889199257,
-1.1719688177108765,
0.10811671614646912,
-0.42890647053718567,
-0.6157466769218445,
0.7269645929336548,
-0.28724318742752075,
0.18281669914722443,
0.3776800036430359,
-0.6731594204902649,
0.8598477244377136,
0.2226182520389557,
-0.23002615571022034,
-0.7654072046279907,
-0.27911368012428284,
0.00884825550019741,
-0.19787032902240753,
0.29238301515579224,
-0.10356426239013672,
0.05969306454062462,
1.0922454595565796,
-0.16666629910469055,
0.997938334941864,
-0.26256218552589417,
-0.08318440616130829,
0.49316704273223877,
-0.062039103358983994,
0.6627486944198608,
-0.1037314385175705,
-0.350627601146698,
0.09159331023693085,
0.15791547298431396,
-0.38971221446990967,
-0.8445283770561218,
0.9022560715675354,
-0.35848328471183777,
-0.5362765789031982,
-0.1985529661178589,
-0.36400920152664185,
0.1480870395898819,
0.6365155577659607,
0.35630321502685547,
0.6739019155502319,
-0.7177712917327881,
0.4929887354373932,
0.48730483651161194,
0.5627050995826721,
0.39604100584983826,
0.5283145904541016,
0.11176133155822754,
-0.18883547186851501,
1.208530068397522,
0.13126514852046967,
-0.09200510382652283,
0.4664446711540222,
0.554882824420929,
-0.4792673587799072,
-0.7490005493164062,
-0.22555308043956757,
0.32938238978385925,
-0.7711582183837891,
0.03557504341006279,
-0.48630961775779724,
0.2979431450366974,
-0.7766496539115906,
-0.12740059196949005,
-0.2325391173362732,
-0.2345837652683258,
-0.38984906673431396,
-0.09793141484260559,
0.14113707840442657,
1.3490324020385742,
-0.06398721784353256,
0.6543157696723938,
-0.765224277973175,
-0.16452427208423615,
0.33803316950798035,
0.14731287956237793,
-0.17481161653995514,
-0.29932665824890137,
-0.7322227358818054,
-0.43423470854759216,
-0.37557080388069153,
-1.1134995222091675,
-0.023878498002886772,
0.11348959803581238,
0.521414577960968,
1.1091599464416504,
0.34320327639579773,
-0.1295333057641983,
-0.3365991711616516,
0.8301942348480225,
0.16566261649131775,
-0.7728450298309326,
0.5726234316825867,
-0.644062340259552,
0.0725632831454277,
0.688809871673584,
0.6436365246772766,
-0.2955886423587799,
-0.34788763523101807,
-1.2205978631973267,
-0.5003718137741089,
0.5824118852615356,
0.22060422599315643,
-0.17848087847232819,
0.05206935107707977,
0.14179456233978271,
-0.13478970527648926,
0.3540087938308716,
-0.24641618132591248,
0.09268572926521301,
0.057301200926303864,
0.03494292125105858,
0.0853666216135025,
-0.2599899470806122,
-0.403676301240921,
0.06427289545536041,
0.8966337442398071,
-0.18984276056289673,
-0.3428014814853668,
0.2281782180070877,
0.38720113039016724,
-0.209645077586174,
-0.023596210405230522,
0.14820918440818787,
0.8188138604164124,
-0.2685791254043579,
0.03522432595491409,
-0.22768506407737732,
-0.4579138159751892,
-0.04497455433011055,
0.03539509326219559,
-0.3221989870071411,
0.4023574888706207,
0.6552678942680359,
0.7133187651634216,
0.04734984040260315,
0.09221874177455902,
0.6000819206237793,
-0.06779902428388596,
-0.23364804685115814,
-0.05336305499076843,
0.05780617892742157,
0.19817472994327545,
0.2763117849826813,
0.27746427059173584,
0.06818211823701859,
0.39676380157470703,
-0.8932527899742126,
0.32327818870544434,
0.4777148365974426,
-1.0484057664871216,
-0.43671032786369324,
0.27511125802993774,
0.5437467694282532,
-0.14179940521717072,
0.04040829837322235,
-0.19939012825489044,
-0.6242164373397827,
1.0017123222351074,
0.22325237095355988,
0.6725454926490784,
-0.32405906915664673,
0.4046052098274231,
0.3777013421058655,
0.23519954085350037,
-0.028123440220952034,
-0.7061083316802979,
-0.21501797437667847,
-0.7034814357757568,
-0.25123730301856995,
-0.4061395227909088,
-0.49316179752349854,
-0.05987013876438141,
-0.6520764231681824,
0.44616183638572693,
-0.3277333080768585,
-0.1466781497001648,
0.3733394742012024,
0.2019241899251938,
-0.248885378241539,
0.07445155829191208,
-0.13029806315898895,
0.7757465839385986,
-1.1592928171157837,
0.9102969169616699,
0.5328380465507507,
0.04864346981048584,
-0.6179495453834534,
0.23930387198925018,
0.27952298521995544,
-0.3804049789905548,
0.22776105999946594,
0.0036871028132736683,
-0.16740138828754425,
0.08066114783287048,
-0.43343478441238403,
-0.6435715556144714,
1.1085660457611084,
-0.21840080618858337,
-0.3124265670776367,
0.01460263878107071,
-0.2986847758293152,
0.1669291853904724,
-0.5369665026664734,
-0.05970200523734093,
0.7066663503646851,
0.6917700171470642,
0.22424474358558655,
-0.10005597770214081,
0.06953418999910355,
0.03642173111438751,
-0.4571876525878906,
0.5698010921478271,
-0.6238871216773987,
0.5714357495307922,
0.28791889548301697,
-0.41285884380340576,
-0.20800888538360596,
0.7454326152801514,
-0.13646744191646576,
0.8675768375396729,
0.9324005842208862,
0.4389556050300598,
1.0134556293487549,
-0.08035360276699066,
1.1814347505569458,
-0.3119821846485138,
0.4185236990451813,
0.9305490851402283,
-0.026364367455244064,
0.570325493812561,
0.38517624139785767,
-0.03183779865503311,
0.9228532910346985,
0.39958685636520386,
0.023344736546278,
0.3875572681427002,
0.08407314121723175,
-0.5913358926773071,
-0.10612961649894714,
-0.5203031301498413,
-0.27581170201301575,
0.4589000940322876,
0.6724250316619873,
-0.4249488413333893,
-0.15495948493480682,
-0.14060162007808685,
0.18786145746707916,
0.11732712388038635,
-0.1293967366218567,
0.8164193630218506,
-0.0927799791097641,
-0.8206392526626587,
-0.3469901382923126,
0.008543609641492367,
0.5198690891265869,
-0.8205875158309937,
-0.1396661251783371,
0.044591549783945084,
0.11863452196121216,
-0.3003333806991577,
-0.6688084602355957,
0.25681525468826294,
-0.2606712579727173,
-0.6581921577453613,
-0.1037139967083931,
1.2618392705917358,
-0.5495637655258179,
-0.6656831502914429,
0.2740129232406616,
0.3772979974746704,
-0.06996379047632217,
-0.39393720030784607,
-0.4106524586677551,
0.01356064435094595,
0.0061613935977220535,
-0.03698517382144928,
0.3626701235771179,
0.7452406883239746,
0.017024317756295204,
-0.007383987307548523,
1.089586615562439,
0.29690343141555786,
-0.08646835386753082,
0.21082530915737152,
0.7763609290122986,
-0.3094103932380676,
-0.5972816348075867,
-0.5704944729804993,
0.1583966165781021,
-0.6995915770530701,
-0.15077048540115356,
0.9679797887802124,
0.5745025873184204,
0.5752798318862915,
0.012497439049184322,
0.677834689617157,
-0.2863686978816986,
0.45538902282714844,
-0.28983864188194275,
0.92380690574646,
-0.34406185150146484,
-0.050705742090940475,
-0.2617378532886505,
-0.7831606864929199,
0.02532459795475006,
0.041720401495695114,
-0.2878398001194,
-0.5570662021636963,
0.822378933429718,
1.0201826095581055,
-0.23894178867340088,
0.10623114556074142,
0.06226484850049019,
0.23966634273529053,
0.6519815325737,
-0.22338677942752838,
0.7176966071128845,
-0.08917522430419922,
0.6049479842185974,
-0.2491118609905243,
-0.39376118779182434,
-0.16207939386367798,
-1.1304014921188354,
-0.7645351886749268,
-1.0052509307861328,
-0.4692673981189728,
-0.511792004108429,
-0.35094571113586426,
0.15508030354976654,
1.2796151638031006,
-0.8143266439437866,
-0.15871573984622955,
-0.26305246353149414,
0.7876704335212708,
-0.0021180720068514347,
-0.32530727982521057,
0.5680558085441589,
-0.10539622604846954,
-1.0281106233596802,
0.5995634198188782,
0.2687487304210663,
-0.30550989508628845,
-0.4639337956905365,
0.3006192743778229,
-0.33312180638313293,
0.25747960805892944,
0.6648738384246826,
0.08388844132423401,
-0.366379976272583,
-0.14666272699832916,
-0.17746780812740326,
0.21477024257183075,
-0.18820223212242126,
1.476128101348877,
-0.4747353792190552,
0.4963415563106537,
0.9132640361785889,
0.41993945837020874,
0.9641126394271851,
0.2917313277721405,
0.2636483311653137,
-0.8348554372787476,
0.2658866047859192,
0.052203621715307236,
0.19689783453941345,
0.2416851967573166,
-0.5353481769561768,
0.5166720151901245,
0.6740768551826477,
-0.5973594188690186,
-0.3300146162509918,
0.12970101833343506,
-1.2101950645446777,
-0.2894602417945862,
1.2208867073059082,
-0.11839255690574646,
-0.3662964701652527,
-0.20611143112182617,
-0.2907405495643616,
0.15410690009593964,
-0.7459784150123596,
0.5915848016738892,
0.6747756004333496,
-0.20342513918876648,
0.24381183087825775,
-0.08460933715105057,
0.2762530744075775,
0.08259347081184387,
-0.9480230212211609,
-0.2694178521633148,
0.7520219683647156,
0.14941377937793732,
0.7458411455154419,
0.6968637704849243,
0.004057569429278374,
-0.2559095621109009,
0.13142624497413635,
-0.37405118346214294,
0.3882216215133667,
-0.45701709389686584,
0.17124882340431213,
0.41977447271347046,
-0.21763040125370026,
-0.12254359573125839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07910v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07910v2
|
MAGPIE: Multi-Task Media-Bias Analysis Generalization for Pre-Trained Identification of Expressions
| 2024-02-27T02:00:28 | 2024-03-15T09:30:29 |
Tomáš Horych, Martin Wessel, Jan Philip Wahle, Terry Ruas, Jerome Waßmuth, André Greiner-Petter, Akiko Aizawa, Bela Gipp, Timo Spinde
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
Media bias detection poses a complex, multifaceted problem traditionally
tackled using single-task models and small in-domain datasets, consequently
lacking generalizability. To address this, we introduce MAGPIE, the first
large-scale multi-task pre-training approach explicitly tailored for media bias
detection. To enable pre-training at scale, we present Large Bias Mixture
(LBM), a compilation of 59 bias-related tasks. MAGPIE outperforms previous
approaches in media bias detection on the Bias Annotation By Experts (BABE)
dataset, with a relative improvement of 3.3% F1-score. MAGPIE also performs
better than previous models on 5 out of 8 tasks in the Media Bias
Identification Benchmark (MBIB). Using a RoBERTa encoder, MAGPIE needs only 15%
of finetuning steps compared to single-task approaches. Our evaluation shows,
for instance, that tasks like sentiment and emotionality boost all learning,
all tasks enhance fake news detection, and scaling tasks leads to the best
results. MAGPIE confirms that MTL is a promising approach for addressing media
bias detection, enhancing the accuracy and efficiency of existing models.
Furthermore, LBM is the first available resource collection focused on media
bias MTL.
|
[
-0.8065952062606812,
-0.6804702877998352,
0.08270630985498428,
0.5617398619651794,
-0.0802474394440651,
-0.04358617216348648,
-0.3763602674007416,
-0.1181713342666626,
0.29035496711730957,
0.2458209991455078,
-0.8166630864143372,
-0.08179671317338943,
-1.0868556499481201,
-0.033060554414987564,
-0.3904151916503906,
1.1010806560516357,
0.3097167909145355,
0.3889220952987671,
-0.04019828885793686,
-0.1733391433954239,
-0.3295753598213196,
-0.3334690034389496,
-0.2052675485610962,
-0.21351651847362518,
0.37071046233177185,
0.30225250124931335,
0.5033225417137146,
-0.0706867054104805,
0.3560870289802551,
0.21903695166110992,
0.03660743311047554,
0.727393627166748,
-0.5260283946990967,
-0.404509961605072,
-0.21431788802146912,
-0.24058419466018677,
-0.4001695215702057,
0.7867515683174133,
0.5240508317947388,
0.2474125474691391,
0.20655089616775513,
0.7363731861114502,
-0.05443096533417702,
0.9234755635261536,
-1.0900112390518188,
-0.29929402470588684,
-0.5672053694725037,
0.5249441862106323,
-0.39063161611557007,
-0.44079843163490295,
-0.6852734088897705,
-0.08779316395521164,
-0.28569895029067993,
-0.6347616314888,
0.37121373414993286,
0.0487072691321373,
0.9348496198654175,
0.2725246846675873,
-0.6866170167922974,
-0.4368610084056854,
-0.8206742405891418,
0.8562254905700684,
-0.3242602050304413,
0.41962292790412903,
0.27597108483314514,
0.2225084900856018,
-0.14170655608177185,
-0.49394604563713074,
-0.7501874566078186,
0.13489983975887299,
-0.06915930658578873,
0.2455306202173233,
-0.2555675208568573,
-0.3526315689086914,
0.34917014837265015,
0.40155529975891113,
-0.48293963074684143,
-0.12650421261787415,
-0.4612303674221039,
-0.37164703011512756,
0.44141885638237,
-0.19726097583770752,
0.17706288397312164,
-0.18311554193496704,
-0.2590690851211548,
0.1669638752937317,
-0.594396710395813,
-0.133407324552536,
0.4171927571296692,
0.15801730751991272,
0.08450101315975189,
0.3403289318084717,
-0.22143568098545074,
0.7547780275344849,
0.5257900357246399,
-0.2782421410083771,
0.5923120379447937,
-0.216598778963089,
-0.4519886076450348,
-0.09932650625705719,
1.1589637994766235,
0.3593067526817322,
0.11422231048345566,
0.22023671865463257,
-0.0005431600147858262,
-0.0034482297487556934,
0.49771860241889954,
-1.0090519189834595,
-0.09830188751220703,
0.03333926945924759,
-0.7262892723083496,
-0.43765658140182495,
0.20022885501384735,
-1.0721476078033447,
-0.829483151435852,
-0.11351904273033142,
0.6374704241752625,
-0.06272391229867935,
-0.5358998775482178,
-0.04237782210111618,
0.047424085438251495,
0.09027321636676788,
0.12352742999792099,
-0.4790233373641968,
0.11653914302587509,
0.3306286334991455,
0.7207746505737305,
-0.06935566663742065,
-0.11907949298620224,
-1.0963373184204102,
-0.09758966416120529,
-0.3989696800708771,
0.7748359441757202,
-0.6638690829277039,
0.03364576771855354,
0.021566541865468025,
0.03832148388028145,
-0.0399768091738224,
-0.6799324154853821,
0.7825777530670166,
-0.7059940695762634,
0.6230207681655884,
-0.43844351172447205,
-0.2886849641799927,
0.007947476580739021,
0.47672757506370544,
-0.8648895621299744,
0.9363471865653992,
0.3064334988594055,
-1.1048641204833984,
0.8014799952507019,
-0.9887266755104065,
-0.36718639731407166,
-0.43096300959587097,
0.08362050354480743,
-0.5080748200416565,
0.05477939173579216,
0.6915347576141357,
0.4598512053489685,
-0.39105916023254395,
0.06691503524780273,
-0.35238417983055115,
-0.4524478316307068,
0.09037642180919647,
-0.41099825501441956,
0.8881469964981079,
0.4917709529399872,
-0.40922728180885315,
0.1598866730928421,
-0.49612942337989807,
-0.14410819113254547,
0.037006739526987076,
-0.1530466079711914,
-0.1139441654086113,
-0.1266002357006073,
0.19919076561927795,
0.5855947136878967,
0.04379771277308464,
-0.5017725825309753,
0.18682792782783508,
0.3740050494670868,
0.24317501485347748,
0.6463824510574341,
-0.3301164209842682,
0.47754722833633423,
-0.008983747102320194,
0.44693341851234436,
0.5156054496765137,
0.44813117384910583,
-0.22634679079055786,
-0.10054579377174377,
-0.4719246029853821,
-0.5627055168151855,
0.47712424397468567,
0.4720694124698639,
-0.6398183703422546,
0.3162221312522888,
-0.21914991736412048,
-0.5119965672492981,
-0.549818754196167,
0.4987168312072754,
0.35159406065940857,
0.36801064014434814,
0.45825231075286865,
-0.3295563757419586,
-0.5083739161491394,
-0.9654955863952637,
-0.5889976620674133,
0.40120697021484375,
-0.11894670128822327,
0.04307705909013748,
0.20657497644424438,
-0.3669169545173645,
0.8910375833511353,
-0.30059775710105896,
-1.0136418342590332,
-0.0856684073805809,
0.3496730327606201,
0.301474392414093,
0.2861694395542145,
0.6397231221199036,
-1.1996017694473267,
-0.4275783896446228,
-0.28463980555534363,
-0.6941275596618652,
-0.4012772738933563,
-0.1993556171655655,
-0.014192339964210987,
-0.05059129744768143,
0.478044718503952,
-0.7541510462760925,
0.05110400170087814,
0.6877028346061707,
-0.34040695428848267,
0.48602795600891113,
0.1367303729057312,
0.3622940182685852,
-0.8976596593856812,
-0.18061085045337677,
0.4089500904083252,
-0.3170238435268402,
-0.6680918335914612,
-0.16983485221862793,
0.23147833347320557,
0.09903255850076675,
-0.6131694912910461,
0.17135712504386902,
-0.523573100566864,
-0.2666878402233124,
-0.5122302770614624,
0.014649514108896255,
0.1737423986196518,
0.27754881978034973,
-0.14211203157901764,
1.0816411972045898,
0.4622623920440674,
-0.38083508610725403,
0.20033228397369385,
0.02492346055805683,
-0.21919219195842743,
0.7148138880729675,
-0.25839924812316895,
0.234455406665802,
-0.40745556354522705,
0.4247104525566101,
-0.7990403175354004,
-0.14532184600830078,
0.4295549690723419,
-0.6263855695724487,
0.2781500816345215,
-0.15710382163524628,
-0.6679081916809082,
-0.5375167727470398,
-0.3134418725967407,
0.27079322934150696,
0.2653849124908447,
-0.5645143985748291,
0.9925520420074463,
0.5462120771408081,
0.307317852973938,
-0.9273395538330078,
-0.20657820999622345,
-0.142143115401268,
-0.36481979489326477,
-0.23409631848335266,
0.109856978058815,
-0.09092636406421661,
0.0680982917547226,
-0.27209946513175964,
-0.2490738481283188,
-0.222523495554924,
-0.20750324428081512,
0.27619412541389465,
0.07290011644363403,
-0.03632098436355591,
0.21175497770309448,
0.044344689697027206,
0.17834250628948212,
0.08498436957597733,
-0.13957878947257996,
0.6811352372169495,
-0.28335052728652954,
-0.13517612218856812,
-0.28148940205574036,
0.2415749579668045,
0.7200689911842346,
-0.5576834082603455,
0.47967684268951416,
1.5390489101409912,
-0.1897931843996048,
-0.06508930027484894,
-0.9188333749771118,
-0.008191436529159546,
-0.4525468349456787,
0.3835262656211853,
-0.1660294532775879,
-0.5516021251678467,
0.14295163750648499,
-0.22814084589481354,
-0.009857317432761192,
0.311393678188324,
0.7447883486747742,
0.18234409391880035,
0.9875844717025757,
0.7115437984466553,
-0.5473887920379639,
0.6380010843276978,
-0.10227935016155243,
-0.023090414702892303,
-0.730247974395752,
0.02177591063082218,
-0.016816480085253716,
-0.4215383231639862,
-0.09478423744440079,
-0.507331371307373,
0.20903842151165009,
-0.012330589815974236,
-0.22781828045845032,
-0.0277614314109087,
-0.7021160125732422,
0.6670182347297668,
0.6703439950942993,
0.26380455493927,
0.1735379844903946,
-0.20224173367023468,
0.3569755256175995,
0.02685162052512169,
-0.4065052568912506,
-0.3811803162097931,
1.3790991306304932,
0.19332362711429596,
0.4501020312309265,
-0.17002595961093903,
0.40448370575904846,
0.8407355546951294,
1.0455166101455688,
-0.5817385315895081,
0.3644165098667145,
-0.034688111394643784,
-1.061172366142273,
-0.034813664853572845,
-0.3327273726463318,
-0.5360701084136963,
0.6870951652526855,
-0.6316875219345093,
-0.2600245773792267,
-0.07536353915929794,
0.3218652606010437,
-0.27742913365364075,
0.2465028464794159,
-0.9313147068023682,
0.9520015120506287,
-0.1547558605670929,
-0.5234840512275696,
-0.14442966878414154,
-0.48635736107826233,
0.7146939039230347,
-0.4578595459461212,
0.6952308416366577,
-0.2058309018611908,
0.15669743716716766,
0.7838301658630371,
0.02737000398337841,
0.6755344271659851,
-0.5138404369354248,
0.33353474736213684,
0.14882898330688477,
-0.1038254126906395,
0.2177819311618805,
-0.07963301241397858,
0.07124307751655579,
0.05319429934024811,
-0.07252834737300873,
-0.5058407783508301,
-0.4072914123535156,
0.47023963928222656,
-0.8393012285232544,
-0.4514451324939728,
-0.3642060160636902,
-0.8252832293510437,
-0.28410521149635315,
0.5498536825180054,
0.31468409299850464,
0.16282273828983307,
0.0002821207162924111,
0.088632732629776,
0.6932674050331116,
-0.22045721113681793,
0.2739502489566803,
0.6112590432167053,
-0.391597718000412,
-0.345903217792511,
0.7169154286384583,
-0.03810729458928108,
-0.09218008071184158,
-0.016195710748434067,
0.18229518830776215,
0.25891146063804626,
-0.20590902864933014,
-0.5009999871253967,
0.04579632356762886,
-0.5523071885108948,
-0.3239181935787201,
-0.6254034638404846,
0.10828337073326111,
-0.22354455292224884,
0.15364935994148254,
-0.6620168089866638,
0.21189171075820923,
-0.23630373179912567,
0.13871286809444427,
-0.2123309224843979,
0.5209214091300964,
-0.199762761592865,
0.6367061138153076,
-0.8585763573646545,
0.7241808176040649,
0.26673269271850586,
0.07246584445238113,
-0.28185519576072693,
-0.49612370133399963,
-0.3569572865962982,
0.08925079554319382,
-0.842304527759552,
-1.0940805673599243,
0.6128512620925903,
0.2756992280483246,
0.3036002814769745,
0.8426828384399414,
0.15713292360305786,
0.5963982939720154,
-0.6330839991569519,
0.593062162399292,
0.3161258101463318,
-0.9736889600753784,
0.4795219302177429,
-0.22547492384910583,
0.024596191942691803,
0.4676302969455719,
0.8229835629463196,
-0.06194644421339035,
-0.2548622488975525,
-0.3885941207408905,
-0.3614448010921478,
0.5145419239997864,
-0.13950678706169128,
0.2140619456768036,
-0.06905102729797363,
-0.04378841817378998,
0.180697962641716,
0.47899529337882996,
-1.0687570571899414,
-0.2145509421825409,
-0.4197450280189514,
-0.07161998748779297,
-0.028619419783353806,
-0.21847259998321533,
-0.5034518837928772,
-0.48098576068878174,
0.5455743670463562,
-0.17688700556755066,
0.4484402537345886,
0.1672622114419937,
-0.6847257614135742,
-0.3168124854564667,
0.20300382375717163,
0.7968258261680603,
0.7646334171295166,
-0.16220776736736298,
0.08236555755138397,
-0.06511729210615158,
-0.6543946266174316,
0.09457138180732727,
0.12010719627141953,
0.09978868067264557,
0.2185479700565338,
0.14247682690620422,
0.3693191707134247,
-0.1751285046339035,
-0.6900829076766968,
1.16028892993927,
0.16046473383903503,
-0.24166196584701538,
-0.6264532208442688,
-0.2026858627796173,
0.00801560003310442,
0.5601928234100342,
0.8015726208686829,
0.14737215638160706,
0.4017893970012665,
-0.5566301941871643,
0.22097377479076385,
0.6847236752510071,
-0.6227462291717529,
-0.3083203434944153,
0.7612099051475525,
0.1247473731637001,
0.13316524028778076,
0.45242127776145935,
-0.4350544810295105,
-0.6622564792633057,
0.4003627896308899,
0.4943728446960449,
0.5042060017585754,
-0.1639677733182907,
0.38284608721733093,
0.08811874687671661,
0.5410269498825073,
-0.06849779933691025,
-0.05605272576212883,
0.07626093924045563,
-1.0573476552963257,
-0.5998249053955078,
-0.47323429584503174,
-0.14728154242038727,
0.3508897125720978,
-0.8436737656593323,
0.24626369774341583,
-0.44134292006492615,
-0.5068992972373962,
0.2873148024082184,
0.04584485664963722,
-0.763685941696167,
0.34673818945884705,
0.4169550836086273,
0.8282482028007507,
-1.4433413743972778,
0.8807270526885986,
0.683008074760437,
-0.345163494348526,
-0.5851505994796753,
-0.019591644406318665,
0.3204297721385956,
-0.5639659762382507,
1.139499306678772,
0.6396428346633911,
0.12351429462432861,
-0.28487977385520935,
-0.5301927328109741,
-0.4162432849407196,
0.8711002469062805,
0.34026432037353516,
-0.3371465802192688,
0.015991002321243286,
-0.18853703141212463,
0.1600409746170044,
-0.6997901797294617,
0.5552433133125305,
0.5164483785629272,
0.48219433426856995,
-0.07149918377399445,
-0.8528395295143127,
-0.05017009377479553,
-0.3854841887950897,
-0.44002148509025574,
0.3111201524734497,
-0.7723026871681213,
1.0066803693771362,
-0.02543593756854534,
0.15820620954036713,
-0.6077054142951965,
0.735450029373169,
-0.018397845327854156,
0.5735070109367371,
0.7805295586585999,
0.4179602563381195,
0.8037834763526917,
-0.037460729479789734,
0.7534053325653076,
-0.32915788888931274,
0.4400966167449951,
0.9431847929954529,
-0.2121628224849701,
0.47467485070228577,
0.5141377449035645,
-0.10922545939683914,
0.39357995986938477,
0.6332718133926392,
-0.2543613314628601,
0.5880940556526184,
0.03365498036146164,
-0.27883854508399963,
-0.2828308343887329,
0.060628607869148254,
-0.27243608236312866,
0.2644146978855133,
0.47923266887664795,
-0.6273615956306458,
-0.046950165182352066,
0.5963893532752991,
0.2838937044143677,
-0.10332036018371582,
-0.7571433186531067,
0.3384714722633362,
-0.28043121099472046,
-0.33224722743034363,
0.42290279269218445,
-0.3672724664211273,
1.1957612037658691,
-0.4877878725528717,
0.24113419651985168,
-0.021094825118780136,
0.22549505531787872,
-0.5211079120635986,
-0.29746168851852417,
0.18773511052131653,
-0.2364719808101654,
-0.5115694999694824,
-0.084093376994133,
0.9339908957481384,
-0.4117223024368286,
-0.5047364234924316,
0.07953225076198578,
0.48787370324134827,
-0.05523122102022171,
-0.5677365064620972,
-0.5924962759017944,
0.29703018069267273,
-0.12010563164949417,
-0.6085934638977051,
0.4733259677886963,
0.2768501341342926,
0.1264667809009552,
0.6305106282234192,
0.6385461688041687,
0.14717330038547516,
0.3002853989601135,
-0.1453927755355835,
1.0910780429840088,
-0.26688483357429504,
-0.12078482657670975,
-0.6931486129760742,
0.18578703701496124,
-0.5004725456237793,
-0.21091726422309875,
0.7869589328765869,
0.4959282875061035,
0.8206775784492493,
-0.47180718183517456,
0.6750837564468384,
-0.221729576587677,
0.5767296552658081,
-0.30549946427345276,
0.7555283308029175,
-0.6136425733566284,
-0.20547983050346375,
-0.5400650501251221,
-1.0602208375930786,
-0.27940914034843445,
0.6970646381378174,
-0.5064737200737,
0.06366047263145447,
0.6512598395347595,
0.8251999616622925,
-0.3584790527820587,
-0.04483946040272713,
0.18593616783618927,
-0.03785628825426102,
0.2515230178833008,
0.4476889669895172,
0.6967211365699768,
-0.38674792647361755,
0.6135724782943726,
-0.13373549282550812,
-0.4293343424797058,
-0.26955172419548035,
-0.8827544450759888,
-1.1171706914901733,
-0.2843729853630066,
-0.11133842915296555,
-0.3637511730194092,
-0.13686804473400116,
1.1968803405761719,
1.1121906042099,
-0.6192392706871033,
0.06303095072507858,
0.5392619371414185,
0.02912854216992855,
-0.4759185314178467,
-0.27211862802505493,
0.2434055358171463,
-0.4455322325229645,
-0.9090725779533386,
0.24866311252117157,
0.011846823617815971,
-0.6342989802360535,
-0.16624519228935242,
0.009695437736809254,
-0.17385351657867432,
0.0717305839061737,
0.871618926525116,
0.292731374502182,
-0.36773163080215454,
-0.2545381784439087,
-0.13485001027584076,
0.10056757181882858,
0.15444277226924896,
1.0539640188217163,
-0.7186253070831299,
0.4388381242752075,
0.06257785111665726,
0.7030742764472961,
0.5518456101417542,
0.11829628795385361,
0.29234620928764343,
-0.7838160991668701,
0.46313613653182983,
0.02685551904141903,
0.35787099599838257,
0.2785058617591858,
-0.2552139163017273,
0.3772151470184326,
0.20479713380336761,
-0.6392456889152527,
-0.9849371910095215,
0.3138407766819,
-1.0469673871994019,
-0.2180517613887787,
1.037541389465332,
-0.04970720410346985,
-0.03583603724837303,
0.18032734096050262,
-0.33904147148132324,
0.16396382451057434,
-0.20830939710140228,
0.8103047609329224,
0.7234591841697693,
0.110068179666996,
-0.5000540614128113,
-0.7938048243522644,
0.2839941084384918,
0.27421486377716064,
-0.720642626285553,
-0.18200160562992096,
0.6400007605552673,
0.477041631937027,
0.4618178606033325,
0.8353572487831116,
-0.31776201725006104,
0.3115614056587219,
-0.28656867146492004,
0.22632470726966858,
-0.5939119458198547,
-0.3835013508796692,
0.0970999151468277,
0.40885084867477417,
-0.21255718171596527,
-0.2828587293624878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17128v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17128v4
|
OSCaR: Object State Captioning and State Change Representation
| 2024-02-27T01:48:19 | 2024-04-02T23:14:42 |
Nguyen Nguyen, Jing Bi, Ali Vosoughi, Yapeng Tian, Pooyan Fazli, Chenliang Xu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The capability of intelligent models to extrapolate and comprehend changes in
object states is a crucial yet demanding aspect of AI research, particularly
through the lens of human interaction in real-world settings. This task
involves describing complex visual environments, identifying active objects,
and interpreting their changes as conveyed through language. Traditional
methods, which isolate object captioning and state change detection, offer a
limited view of dynamic environments. Moreover, relying on a small set of
symbolic words to represent changes has restricted the expressiveness of the
language. To address these challenges, in this paper, we introduce the Object
State Captioning and State Change Representation (OSCaR) dataset and benchmark.
OSCaR consists of 14,084 annotated video segments with nearly 1,000 unique
objects from various egocentric video collections. It sets a new testbed for
evaluating multimodal large language models (MLLMs). Our experiments
demonstrate that while MLLMs show some skill, they lack a full understanding of
object state changes. The benchmark includes a fine-tuned model that, despite
initial capabilities, requires significant improvements in accuracy and
generalization ability for effective understanding of these changes. Our code
and dataset are available at https://github.com/nguyennm1024/OSCaR.
|
[
-0.39911046624183655,
-0.45402291417121887,
0.3213704228401184,
-0.16022169589996338,
-0.24028053879737854,
0.059809137135744095,
-0.09205450117588043,
-0.5919519066810608,
-0.01182881835848093,
0.09116781502962112,
-0.3441256582736969,
-0.22557257115840912,
-0.713817834854126,
0.19536569714546204,
-0.6103003621101379,
0.6185763478279114,
-0.3448411226272583,
0.22732682526111603,
-0.16925977170467377,
-0.32312360405921936,
-0.3764532506465912,
-0.23822997510433197,
-0.2115500420331955,
-0.07615500688552856,
0.18128785490989685,
0.26327261328697205,
0.6594163179397583,
0.8051581382751465,
0.6220366954803467,
0.3286460340023041,
0.13347303867340088,
0.17560450732707977,
-0.23864863812923431,
0.0036592502146959305,
-0.25818580389022827,
-0.5255396962165833,
-0.16353841125965118,
0.08501669764518738,
0.8882960081100464,
0.2723890542984009,
-0.08405876159667969,
0.5021136403083801,
-0.3087227940559387,
0.6565544009208679,
-0.7933661937713623,
0.9704777002334595,
-1.0293959379196167,
0.28470543026924133,
-0.08190661668777466,
0.16996194422245026,
-0.05974474921822548,
0.3730214536190033,
0.04617270827293396,
-0.7088612914085388,
0.24566780030727386,
0.37331852316856384,
1.192244529724121,
0.5194504857063293,
-0.09035380184650421,
0.13166476786136627,
-0.8390216827392578,
0.8004924058914185,
-0.5577543377876282,
0.7162352204322815,
0.13750126957893372,
0.6723058819770813,
0.05722757801413536,
-0.575579822063446,
-0.8755792379379272,
-0.6137343645095825,
0.09851574897766113,
-0.16467778384685516,
-0.26006484031677246,
-0.1354416310787201,
0.2781915068626404,
0.22523564100265503,
0.01921292208135128,
0.05909310281276703,
-0.540553629398346,
-0.2127465009689331,
0.648542046546936,
0.2585189640522003,
0.0998016893863678,
-0.21078529953956604,
-0.35229596495628357,
-0.6743401288986206,
-0.5171019434928894,
0.22061502933502197,
0.033856503665447235,
0.16951511800289154,
0.05189509317278862,
0.7181628942489624,
-0.2701256275177002,
0.6780004501342773,
-0.18096911907196045,
0.014525542967021465,
0.3171197474002838,
-0.1570127308368683,
-0.450273722410202,
-0.100909024477005,
0.5650778412818909,
0.530299961566925,
0.1808830052614212,
0.09377928078174591,
-0.32701510190963745,
0.2593846023082733,
0.294402539730072,
-0.602157711982727,
-0.07713838666677475,
0.30790701508522034,
-0.41002824902534485,
0.05866895243525505,
0.33654192090034485,
-0.5477360486984253,
-0.7740930914878845,
-0.650981068611145,
0.4291447699069977,
-0.21923059225082397,
-0.10504455119371414,
0.19826211035251617,
-0.007711747195571661,
0.4879395663738251,
0.6129297614097595,
-0.5772778391838074,
0.2089337855577469,
0.7506265044212341,
0.7635107636451721,
-0.1766316294670105,
-0.5244714021682739,
-0.5572001338005066,
0.161228746175766,
-0.6870137453079224,
0.8220645189285278,
-0.6400821208953857,
0.23268219828605652,
0.0029374395962804556,
0.048426125198602676,
0.08515545725822449,
-0.7391158938407898,
0.05853688344359398,
-0.3645632565021515,
-0.33835798501968384,
0.06223786622285843,
-0.4905802309513092,
-0.28982874751091003,
0.41538453102111816,
-0.8686634302139282,
0.6538276076316833,
-0.14145083725452423,
-0.1996961236000061,
0.5574344992637634,
-0.8680287599563599,
-0.07413076609373093,
-0.2118614912033081,
-0.26121121644973755,
-0.5710111856460571,
0.24665212631225586,
0.3804622292518616,
0.8228631019592285,
-0.1508907675743103,
0.3680970370769501,
-0.2600180208683014,
-0.2763482332229614,
0.35994261503219604,
-0.1272404044866562,
-0.14561983942985535,
0.28879615664482117,
-0.21448342502117157,
0.3841889202594757,
-0.6737579703330994,
-0.3731895983219147,
0.005678544752299786,
-0.143983393907547,
0.11013633012771606,
0.3758884072303772,
0.09338372945785522,
0.13154025375843048,
0.25749391317367554,
-0.6010607481002808,
0.07910997420549393,
0.1254252940416336,
0.4877162277698517,
0.7450374364852905,
-0.4069293439388275,
0.22956769168376923,
-0.18483611941337585,
0.47196274995803833,
0.4118305742740631,
0.2083471566438675,
-0.438256174325943,
-0.3822551965713501,
-0.6673543453216553,
-0.16131635010242462,
0.06176494061946869,
0.3798799514770508,
-0.5858478546142578,
-0.16144683957099915,
-0.21220678091049194,
-0.2642638087272644,
-0.9163753986358643,
0.10819816589355469,
0.16775958240032196,
0.3242148160934448,
0.5530003905296326,
-0.21037696301937103,
-0.5455120801925659,
-1.1781898736953735,
-0.22429125010967255,
-0.19747936725616455,
0.06092149391770363,
0.20587192475795746,
0.7027514576911926,
-0.06924206018447876,
0.7658196687698364,
-0.42676252126693726,
-0.6226897239685059,
0.006952777039259672,
0.16178113222122192,
-0.03743448853492737,
0.4554854929447174,
0.2453252077102661,
-0.9561458826065063,
-0.14943566918373108,
0.04767589643597603,
-0.6524929404258728,
0.3295820355415344,
-0.388385534286499,
0.13625743985176086,
0.1003064513206482,
0.9113134741783142,
-0.31528908014297485,
0.41180285811424255,
0.5041912794113159,
-0.17808014154434204,
0.679378092288971,
-0.151881143450737,
0.3672151267528534,
-0.5818397402763367,
0.20721325278282166,
-0.009069710969924927,
-0.2686467170715332,
-0.4003685414791107,
0.3157733678817749,
0.07715639472007751,
-0.4215489625930786,
-0.8516144752502441,
0.598632276058197,
-0.6326718926429749,
-0.4640065133571625,
-0.15158236026763916,
0.05408477410674095,
-0.2229565680027008,
0.6444221138954163,
0.18216054141521454,
0.681748628616333,
0.8383733630180359,
-0.4259450435638428,
0.6417413353919983,
0.19910570979118347,
-0.6641339659690857,
0.46433088183403015,
-0.5785921812057495,
-0.0792330875992775,
-0.5640735626220703,
0.2525859773159027,
-0.7742027044296265,
-0.17039765417575836,
0.3373990058898926,
-0.21804574131965637,
0.055839113891124725,
-0.11479197442531586,
-0.6279413104057312,
-0.04420333355665207,
-0.3302059769630432,
0.15728890895843506,
0.21681487560272217,
-0.2536041736602783,
0.6656373143196106,
0.443149209022522,
0.14816085994243622,
-0.564916729927063,
-0.4802033603191376,
0.31769949197769165,
-0.049405597150325775,
-0.12004418671131134,
0.1345740705728531,
-0.025121135637164116,
-0.268505334854126,
0.21926099061965942,
-0.08128334581851959,
-0.14127451181411743,
0.020969167351722717,
0.22914496064186096,
0.23671996593475342,
-0.13806070387363434,
0.3465065062046051,
-0.12103427201509476,
0.020553477108478546,
-0.014992795884609222,
0.09088025242090225,
0.4735940396785736,
-0.5210259556770325,
-0.3697369694709778,
-0.7768120765686035,
0.22712112963199615,
0.857514500617981,
-0.7159426808357239,
0.725591778755188,
0.6800268888473511,
-0.47251200675964355,
0.07501806318759918,
-0.3582472503185272,
-0.08838757127523422,
-0.41296273469924927,
0.8717319965362549,
-0.4617026746273041,
-0.7132622599601746,
0.5630569458007812,
-0.05983802303671837,
0.2862791121006012,
0.2937845289707184,
0.5104790329933167,
-0.14661048352718353,
1.1414391994476318,
0.31455618143081665,
-0.1819854974746704,
0.7746188044548035,
-0.4147401452064514,
-0.19586783647537231,
-1.185502052307129,
-0.3298005163669586,
-0.3088178336620331,
-0.6525416374206543,
-0.3779701888561249,
-0.8289641737937927,
0.31521931290626526,
0.04096320644021034,
-0.3447767496109009,
0.23690277338027954,
-0.23665489256381989,
0.45312947034835815,
0.2553721070289612,
0.11712009459733963,
0.2138826996088028,
0.05951534956693649,
0.24556103348731995,
0.03150871768593788,
-0.3960086703300476,
-0.4152893126010895,
1.129784107208252,
0.4233297109603882,
0.893058717250824,
0.15217483043670654,
0.2285308688879013,
0.6731844544410706,
0.3462538719177246,
-0.8959840536117554,
0.7879296541213989,
-0.19193261861801147,
-0.41673916578292847,
-0.43408235907554626,
-0.17135664820671082,
-1.0711772441864014,
0.5299042463302612,
-0.3889262080192566,
-0.6525558829307556,
0.08033280074596405,
0.45726242661476135,
-0.02558731846511364,
0.46931642293930054,
-0.39959216117858887,
0.843400239944458,
-0.11759469658136368,
-0.17972427606582642,
-0.4890506863594055,
-0.4145386815071106,
-0.0033784883562475443,
0.1064794734120369,
0.07356825470924377,
-0.4368407130241394,
-0.2959778904914856,
0.5940984487533569,
-0.16678686439990997,
0.6691511869430542,
-0.16981260478496552,
-0.009444368071854115,
0.25404515862464905,
0.3263927698135376,
0.6834769248962402,
-0.032767683267593384,
-0.056020960211753845,
0.16616109013557434,
-0.06586269289255142,
-0.3654720187187195,
-0.6082854270935059,
0.416201114654541,
-0.643490195274353,
-0.6460550427436829,
-0.38621580600738525,
-0.6468279361724854,
-0.16932350397109985,
0.003968873992562294,
-0.4106025695800781,
0.45656609535217285,
-0.08009126782417297,
0.230826735496521,
0.3553880751132965,
-0.21169711649417877,
0.19678734242916107,
0.6593042612075806,
-0.45403438806533813,
0.1154547855257988,
0.924045741558075,
-0.11863023042678833,
0.10836148262023926,
0.46555766463279724,
0.2073076367378235,
-0.4484879672527313,
-0.42089635133743286,
-0.8487707376480103,
0.1621437519788742,
-0.7556910514831543,
-0.05475452542304993,
-0.1780301332473755,
0.20538657903671265,
-0.3668152093887329,
0.07109396904706955,
-0.594092071056366,
-0.21798263490200043,
-0.3201814889907837,
-0.05028379335999489,
0.31434011459350586,
0.7589461803436279,
-0.005334165878593922,
-0.24161970615386963,
-0.6950353384017944,
0.45317357778549194,
0.3912418782711029,
0.40990832448005676,
0.08363399654626846,
-0.3862636983394623,
-0.32654866576194763,
-0.03455584868788719,
0.0318436324596405,
-0.6960575580596924,
0.17666490375995636,
0.6644167900085449,
0.6859386563301086,
0.45668911933898926,
-0.049473732709884644,
0.853159487247467,
-0.6151489615440369,
0.8206642270088196,
0.05891122668981552,
-1.016571044921875,
0.6051586866378784,
-0.07319173961877823,
0.5250148773193359,
0.26938486099243164,
0.17350424826145172,
-0.7617324590682983,
-0.48731809854507446,
-0.3410255014896393,
-0.515957772731781,
0.7380640506744385,
-0.07366914302110672,
0.20399527251720428,
0.35080838203430176,
-0.02372194454073906,
-0.06223146989941597,
0.544543445110321,
-0.4704163372516632,
-0.09167446941137314,
-0.3352632224559784,
-0.08836808800697327,
-0.16346663236618042,
0.25439342856407166,
-0.14877697825431824,
-0.32796740531921387,
0.4222447872161865,
-0.19590744376182556,
0.39153555035591125,
0.16389721632003784,
-0.3755481243133545,
-0.03994378820061684,
0.22568808495998383,
0.8177475929260254,
0.7337226867675781,
-0.17582112550735474,
0.15461166203022003,
0.060214512050151825,
-0.27818527817726135,
0.13086161017417908,
0.250480592250824,
0.05077413469552994,
-0.027655135840177536,
0.4037694036960602,
1.1044352054595947,
0.19462846219539642,
-1.1989145278930664,
0.3179456889629364,
0.16122519969940186,
0.14439783990383148,
-0.3057377338409424,
0.12168518453836441,
-0.26508986949920654,
0.25942420959472656,
0.3678297698497772,
0.30429205298423767,
0.19170373678207397,
-0.8845423460006714,
0.15421800315380096,
0.26945286989212036,
-0.5816462635993958,
-0.38670605421066284,
0.8254976868629456,
0.08514957875013351,
-0.0691339373588562,
0.4722737669944763,
-0.2801538109779358,
-0.5008590817451477,
0.7535902857780457,
0.21592341363430023,
0.5924533009529114,
0.00005212776886764914,
0.4498671591281891,
0.3340075612068176,
0.2361012101173401,
-0.23495660722255707,
0.021944312378764153,
-0.19465240836143494,
-1.0586880445480347,
-0.18441979587078094,
-0.4725278317928314,
-0.5024672150611877,
0.2213142067193985,
-0.6962881684303284,
0.09500320255756378,
-0.4704521894454956,
0.0895705297589302,
-0.0750298798084259,
-0.360755980014801,
-0.8429800271987915,
0.10220681875944138,
0.4049158990383148,
0.6092315316200256,
-0.8304324150085449,
0.6309523582458496,
1.2858113050460815,
-0.19791007041931152,
-0.5956090688705444,
-0.2843534052371979,
0.10297022759914398,
-0.8621562123298645,
0.7014675736427307,
0.19209600985050201,
-0.15186786651611328,
-0.25876474380493164,
-0.7568154335021973,
-0.8381571769714355,
0.9822090268135071,
0.3936763107776642,
-0.6293971538543701,
0.4218544661998749,
0.27178287506103516,
0.6332921385765076,
-0.4237249195575714,
-0.06349270790815353,
0.5057430863380432,
0.4831334352493286,
-0.1251944750547409,
-0.9054750204086304,
-0.16686755418777466,
-0.19028232991695404,
0.15074077248573303,
0.19989369809627533,
-0.6890231370925903,
1.0976687669754028,
-0.26182523369789124,
-0.24582278728485107,
-0.06721622496843338,
0.8621669411659241,
0.36212944984436035,
0.17432904243469238,
0.774203896522522,
0.5332793593406677,
0.478228896856308,
-0.004808141849935055,
0.9406788945198059,
-0.10340579599142075,
0.4002971649169922,
1.04460608959198,
-0.3669726848602295,
1.133392572402954,
0.4741305112838745,
-0.1775008887052536,
0.43050694465637207,
0.2813083529472351,
-0.36317938566207886,
0.28993314504623413,
0.41958484053611755,
-0.021237250417470932,
-0.34060150384902954,
-0.19804231822490692,
-0.13577337563037872,
0.789751410484314,
0.15795528888702393,
-0.2524416148662567,
-0.16863524913787842,
0.4614267945289612,
0.09737945348024368,
-0.038302160799503326,
-0.5718401074409485,
0.5276184678077698,
-0.3231225907802582,
-0.6848637461662292,
0.40304020047187805,
-0.10596797615289688,
0.43792465329170227,
-0.6042994260787964,
-0.5664477944374084,
-0.12280616909265518,
0.3084607422351837,
0.10471617430448532,
-0.8351254463195801,
-0.00008100095874397084,
0.11190755665302277,
-0.04260878264904022,
-0.15674689412117004,
0.2817416787147522,
-0.4578869342803955,
-0.6962385177612305,
0.05633579567074776,
0.09338699281215668,
0.45686793327331543,
-0.13925905525684357,
-0.9708638787269592,
0.5735156536102295,
-0.11793400347232819,
-0.11483430862426758,
0.1685931533575058,
0.05429581180214882,
-0.3379981517791748,
1.0169904232025146,
0.477455198764801,
0.34155580401420593,
0.09067067503929138,
-0.016890278086066246,
0.5832015872001648,
-0.42602086067199707,
-0.3621145784854889,
-0.49889424443244934,
0.43482184410095215,
-0.010425126180052757,
-0.40828508138656616,
0.3678396940231323,
0.4682721197605133,
1.0783252716064453,
-0.5186712145805359,
0.44088008999824524,
-0.34134113788604736,
0.21599087119102478,
-0.6966750025749207,
0.5849658846855164,
-0.8381081819534302,
0.21697771549224854,
-0.2693410813808441,
-0.8120561838150024,
-0.22198373079299927,
0.599362850189209,
-0.01155130285769701,
-0.2884270250797272,
0.45972633361816406,
0.9069752097129822,
-0.037880510091781616,
-0.402360200881958,
0.5064515471458435,
0.3981703221797943,
0.5244220495223999,
0.2567833960056305,
0.8447219133377075,
-0.5065624117851257,
0.5189629793167114,
-0.13384905457496643,
0.05856885761022568,
-0.212513729929924,
-0.8900120854377747,
-0.4589327871799469,
-1.061997413635254,
-0.5426148772239685,
0.14656005799770355,
0.08372341096401215,
0.973520040512085,
0.8923210501670837,
-0.9837362766265869,
-0.3779047131538391,
0.2632255256175995,
-0.09290138632059097,
-0.7241154313087463,
-0.1983831524848938,
0.48036497831344604,
-0.03327976539731026,
-1.0667905807495117,
0.4242459833621979,
0.13620147109031677,
-0.18350578844547272,
-0.6766560673713684,
-0.11643638461828232,
-0.22829647362232208,
0.010135173797607422,
0.6657337546348572,
0.4390484094619751,
-0.9022060036659241,
-0.579484224319458,
-0.32999932765960693,
0.2875699996948242,
0.1481504589319229,
0.8275315165519714,
-1.013731837272644,
0.8670177459716797,
0.32151079177856445,
0.5310942530632019,
0.45520615577697754,
0.06259273737668991,
0.3761240541934967,
-0.6107015609741211,
0.29774969816207886,
0.0045346966944634914,
0.5130404233932495,
0.4708333909511566,
0.029436247423291206,
0.34921756386756897,
0.11205524951219559,
-0.25022703409194946,
-0.7876764535903931,
0.2664867639541626,
-0.9595792293548584,
-0.3487817049026489,
0.7650687098503113,
-0.23097114264965057,
-0.31827014684677124,
0.09101936966180801,
-0.34427276253700256,
0.0846988633275032,
-0.6680939793586731,
0.9742665886878967,
0.6385306119918823,
-0.3301539123058319,
-0.6310995817184448,
-0.5260313749313354,
0.36977115273475647,
0.301475465297699,
-0.9556962251663208,
-0.01662828028202057,
0.5993861556053162,
0.06445849686861038,
0.2474886178970337,
0.16338880360126495,
-0.1493682712316513,
0.28109508752822876,
-0.06635468453168869,
0.10895685851573944,
-0.5220840573310852,
-0.5293549299240112,
-0.28185784816741943,
0.001768385642208159,
-0.08510863035917282,
-0.613227903842926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17124v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17124v1
|
Fact-and-Reflection (FaR) Improves Confidence Calibration of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-27T01:37:23 | 2024-02-27T01:37:23 |
Xinran Zhao, Hongming Zhang, Xiaoman Pan, Wenlin Yao, Dong Yu, Tongshuang Wu, Jianshu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
For a LLM to be trustworthy, its confidence level should be well-calibrated
with its actual performance. While it is now common sense that LLM performances
are greatly impacted by prompts, the confidence calibration in prompting LLMs
has yet to be thoroughly explored. In this paper, we explore how different
prompting strategies influence LLM confidence calibration and how it could be
improved. We conduct extensive experiments on six prompting methods in the
question-answering context and we observe that, while these methods help
improve the expected LLM calibration, they also trigger LLMs to be
over-confident when responding to some instances. Inspired by human cognition,
we propose Fact-and-Reflection (FaR) prompting, which improves the LLM
calibration in two steps. First, FaR elicits the known "facts" that are
relevant to the input prompt from the LLM. And then it asks the model to
"reflect" over them to generate the final answer. Experiments show that FaR
prompting achieves significantly better calibration; it lowers the Expected
Calibration Error by 23.5% on our multi-purpose QA tasks. Notably, FaR
prompting even elicits the capability of verbally expressing concerns in less
confident scenarios, which helps trigger retrieval augmentation for solving
these harder instances.
|
[
-0.3597571551799774,
-0.7936737537384033,
1.1866525411605835,
0.29177552461624146,
-0.224631205201149,
-0.05167458951473236,
-0.1930404156446457,
-0.13905008137226105,
-0.0330490916967392,
0.3513478934764862,
-0.49194836616516113,
-0.2981359362602234,
-0.3133462071418762,
0.21247637271881104,
-0.06709259003400803,
0.9171954989433289,
0.22886840999126434,
0.4853903651237488,
-0.48121920228004456,
0.15843912959098816,
-0.6287722587585449,
-0.37786832451820374,
-0.5247795581817627,
-0.4041796028614044,
0.8607964515686035,
0.5447661876678467,
0.5576216578483582,
0.06451444327831268,
-0.012160221114754677,
0.21097655594348907,
0.07260030508041382,
0.5786126852035522,
-0.6308259963989258,
0.19282226264476776,
-0.01294214092195034,
-0.8883818984031677,
-0.09823441505432129,
0.37126466631889343,
0.6019757986068726,
0.4289844334125519,
-0.3943239748477936,
0.26070186495780945,
0.38798776268959045,
0.7288323640823364,
-0.8085688948631287,
0.25970497727394104,
-0.3488069474697113,
-0.38419362902641296,
0.2348783016204834,
-0.6898004412651062,
-0.7177139520645142,
-0.7083487510681152,
0.11579012125730515,
-0.48420634865760803,
0.1267699897289276,
0.22883467376232147,
0.5318001508712769,
0.35470327734947205,
-0.4251382648944855,
-0.33977076411247253,
-0.6162722110748291,
0.8570873737335205,
-0.537487804889679,
0.47584250569343567,
0.19067305326461792,
0.22233854234218597,
-0.32419779896736145,
-0.1906912475824356,
-0.464343398809433,
-0.28972315788269043,
-0.007363517303019762,
0.33616870641708374,
0.23293769359588623,
0.04889962822198868,
0.3891678750514984,
0.11373011022806168,
-0.1746576726436615,
-0.18324187397956848,
-0.22612179815769196,
-0.34449559450149536,
0.45355847477912903,
-0.008362974040210247,
-0.057357389479875565,
0.023778703063726425,
-0.3971133828163147,
-0.41346389055252075,
-1.2261439561843872,
0.3931232690811157,
0.27007296681404114,
0.5069553256034851,
0.18995513021945953,
0.20217113196849823,
-0.17748872935771942,
0.8331059813499451,
0.21115852892398834,
-0.29128190875053406,
-0.03239639475941658,
-0.21489715576171875,
0.07119619101285934,
0.21213176846504211,
0.29183894395828247,
0.6834172606468201,
0.21998143196105957,
0.12593689560890198,
-0.15697349607944489,
-0.17161285877227783,
0.09608849138021469,
-0.9324439764022827,
0.0015453058294951916,
0.24418985843658447,
0.01270134188234806,
-0.14445346593856812,
0.3197628855705261,
-0.8362404108047485,
-0.7715259790420532,
-0.4771694540977478,
0.8897663354873657,
-0.14544640481472015,
0.03204306215047836,
0.3086400628089905,
0.015329087153077126,
0.6058168411254883,
0.8803116679191589,
-0.5062968134880066,
0.06517775356769562,
0.8281991481781006,
0.6274264454841614,
0.08709750324487686,
-0.13240833580493927,
-1.0321944952011108,
-0.15655075013637543,
-0.5655105113983154,
0.7526428699493408,
-0.19180548191070557,
-0.3225162923336029,
0.12557916343212128,
-0.167743980884552,
-0.054046619683504105,
-0.42631036043167114,
0.5438335537910461,
-0.6036162972450256,
0.5621153116226196,
-1.0645318031311035,
-0.3100864291191101,
-0.40943658351898193,
0.5019833445549011,
-0.7206708788871765,
1.0063245296478271,
-0.20417606830596924,
-0.41922295093536377,
0.35142406821250916,
-0.3719451427459717,
-0.22980092465877533,
-0.17136317491531372,
-0.2955284118652344,
-0.03796849027276039,
0.14392687380313873,
0.5577905178070068,
0.7238176465034485,
-0.49280673265457153,
0.20779892802238464,
-0.007371954619884491,
-0.7619103789329529,
0.39366135001182556,
-0.6678622364997864,
0.47666749358177185,
-0.03433176875114441,
-0.17296102643013,
-0.33767053484916687,
-0.49303221702575684,
0.20612499117851257,
-0.22549095749855042,
-0.3983609080314636,
-0.29103052616119385,
0.001237103366293013,
-0.6266095638275146,
0.26925307512283325,
0.05311470851302147,
-0.8615136742591858,
-0.08216751366853714,
-0.5604801774024963,
0.10638919472694397,
0.8031817078590393,
0.28486743569374084,
0.15103881061077118,
-0.8290835022926331,
0.5579524636268616,
0.0010712927905842662,
0.03064427711069584,
-0.26823893189430237,
-0.7617670893669128,
-0.6983010172843933,
-0.20231564342975616,
0.1732761263847351,
0.6220957636833191,
-0.8262276649475098,
-0.052841346710920334,
-0.21324533224105835,
-0.3724314868450165,
-0.7742130160331726,
0.18287506699562073,
0.6039104461669922,
0.8890588879585266,
0.3284263610839844,
-0.06725320219993591,
-0.3095647692680359,
-0.45992234349250793,
-0.28030461072921753,
-0.319951593875885,
0.03478167951107025,
0.422817587852478,
0.12599211931228638,
0.628193736076355,
1.052485466003418,
-0.6691552996635437,
-0.13328668475151062,
0.11683914065361023,
0.1576278954744339,
0.3120006322860718,
0.04711892828345299,
0.29178547859191895,
-0.8016395568847656,
-0.47834527492523193,
-0.5929499864578247,
-0.32211071252822876,
-0.11961232125759125,
-0.09836986660957336,
0.006156108807772398,
0.13982315361499786,
0.40203234553337097,
-0.41093945503234863,
0.3095548152923584,
0.48934537172317505,
-0.04315802454948425,
0.6863454580307007,
-0.08532334864139557,
0.6695988178253174,
-0.8789001703262329,
-0.18379586935043335,
-0.03380903601646423,
-0.313079297542572,
-0.49187174439430237,
0.04904293641448021,
0.08350010961294174,
0.35626542568206787,
-0.7310822606086731,
0.5735750198364258,
-0.4801696836948395,
0.2116447389125824,
-0.0736832320690155,
0.29231175780296326,
0.6426353454589844,
0.20651322603225708,
0.02041412517428398,
1.292771339416504,
0.4879542887210846,
-0.9383276104927063,
0.28173863887786865,
0.20053021609783173,
-0.4504404067993164,
0.6323514580726624,
-0.46551066637039185,
0.2299456149339676,
-0.2903235852718353,
0.4063069820404053,
-1.5240864753723145,
-0.003976763691753149,
0.11783043295145035,
-0.3796823024749756,
0.31681355834007263,
-0.008878836408257484,
-0.45292967557907104,
-0.3816084563732147,
-0.8622004389762878,
0.2108916938304901,
0.6151129007339478,
-0.867499589920044,
0.6871660351753235,
-0.44245800375938416,
-0.02145242504775524,
-0.7319172024726868,
-0.733906626701355,
-0.012256118468940258,
-0.021008726209402084,
-0.5337051153182983,
0.042524997144937515,
-0.3949868679046631,
-0.2947430908679962,
-0.6683959364891052,
-0.13326188921928406,
0.29389408230781555,
-0.003766438690945506,
0.3970527648925781,
0.4791976511478424,
-0.2379453480243683,
0.19360190629959106,
-0.10200929641723633,
0.05349120870232582,
0.4057236611843109,
0.05014617741107941,
0.39704158902168274,
-0.2259325087070465,
-0.5684782862663269,
-0.47496020793914795,
0.0138730239123106,
0.2002200484275818,
-0.0708230584859848,
0.7709553837776184,
0.2933640480041504,
0.21548333764076233,
-0.17589889466762543,
-1.1781257390975952,
-0.8819615840911865,
-0.5361703634262085,
-0.00314198131673038,
-0.29210951924324036,
-0.9041972160339355,
0.34872299432754517,
-0.16817209124565125,
0.1685093194246292,
-0.03964463993906975,
0.5012174844741821,
-0.2278466373682022,
1.1632726192474365,
0.3446734547615051,
0.05652399733662605,
0.23335117101669312,
0.062064725905656815,
0.2743851840496063,
-0.8708710074424744,
-0.23880010843276978,
-0.5981968641281128,
-0.011153975501656532,
-0.28803250193595886,
-0.6985329985618591,
0.4079413414001465,
-0.23432576656341553,
0.1937447190284729,
-0.245756596326828,
-0.5212951898574829,
0.5966678857803345,
0.42241841554641724,
0.49684903025627136,
0.41100984811782837,
-0.042005110532045364,
-0.1800679713487625,
-0.146279975771904,
-0.5627589225769043,
-0.5652130842208862,
0.8696471452713013,
0.2140454351902008,
0.9352414011955261,
-0.015790076926350594,
0.8367717266082764,
-0.06688930839300156,
0.4690845310688019,
-0.942059338092804,
0.6846197843551636,
0.29860377311706543,
-0.8296871185302734,
-0.16466745734214783,
-0.38602229952812195,
-0.5204750895500183,
0.12158935517072678,
-0.009551407769322395,
-0.4374924600124359,
0.3694514334201813,
0.28303438425064087,
-0.959321141242981,
0.014597301371395588,
-0.7461534738540649,
0.088548943400383,
-0.07299607247114182,
-0.39887210726737976,
-0.09300060570240021,
-0.6662117838859558,
0.28385889530181885,
0.042346447706222534,
0.33637791872024536,
0.022110991179943085,
-0.12508581578731537,
0.5473868250846863,
-0.043757129460573196,
1.1554192304611206,
-0.4024026095867157,
-0.5214378833770752,
0.5658847689628601,
0.21055763959884644,
0.6805548071861267,
0.07162559032440186,
-0.3981911242008209,
-0.4115431308746338,
0.040000129491090775,
-0.12014055252075195,
-0.9690312743186951,
0.4612720310688019,
-0.28025299310684204,
-1.1228638887405396,
-0.31222212314605713,
-0.5068897604942322,
-0.5602762699127197,
-0.18156123161315918,
0.19422180950641632,
0.5118080973625183,
-0.12009304016828537,
0.07435184717178345,
1.2447084188461304,
-0.11050460487604141,
0.2117968201637268,
0.8823214769363403,
-0.3274020552635193,
-0.21284137666225433,
0.9528083205223083,
0.16863195598125458,
0.5928400158882141,
0.3697037100791931,
0.40609216690063477,
-0.5568069815635681,
-0.15919840335845947,
-0.3146367371082306,
0.33233025670051575,
-0.882961630821228,
-0.28838086128234863,
-0.23117022216320038,
-0.003568351035937667,
-0.3475921154022217,
-0.015407977625727654,
-0.11482886224985123,
-0.4166898727416992,
-0.34222617745399475,
-0.32131630182266235,
0.5846273899078369,
0.6615760922431946,
0.02718285843729973,
0.08428982645273209,
-0.7149173021316528,
0.05476336553692818,
0.730143129825592,
0.11102857440710068,
0.05662024766206741,
-0.63167804479599,
0.05829928070306778,
0.3772575259208679,
-0.14405030012130737,
-0.7995204925537109,
-0.1967291682958603,
0.25695961713790894,
0.29573848843574524,
0.41417014598846436,
0.3496690094470978,
0.7846212387084961,
-0.4291131794452667,
1.0306707620620728,
-0.06033547967672348,
-0.6116801500320435,
0.32014593482017517,
-0.04741252586245537,
0.16111615300178528,
0.8504850268363953,
0.24317802488803864,
-0.4762185513973236,
-0.4749414026737213,
-0.1680268943309784,
-0.34818771481513977,
0.606866180896759,
-0.346622109413147,
0.5015298128128052,
-0.030401933938264847,
0.5899729132652283,
0.10630597174167633,
0.32208603620529175,
-0.48892509937286377,
-0.2926671504974365,
-0.1665307730436325,
0.012462247163057327,
-0.1436764895915985,
-0.509177565574646,
-0.39798983931541443,
-0.1750648319721222,
0.8538853526115417,
-0.417328804731369,
0.23906965553760529,
0.5972691178321838,
0.07633553445339203,
-0.25369489192962646,
0.5383303761482239,
0.7581632733345032,
0.5747985243797302,
-0.19629064202308655,
0.2306108921766281,
0.2844887375831604,
-0.4377063810825348,
0.23048095405101776,
-0.0987992137670517,
-0.4299769699573517,
-0.10231012850999832,
0.12006713449954987,
0.4422609508037567,
0.10865884274244308,
-0.41181913018226624,
0.7654246687889099,
-0.07870612293481827,
-0.3283489942550659,
0.22382362186908722,
0.39742282032966614,
0.18104948103427887,
0.18135033547878265,
0.6122790575027466,
-0.30022215843200684,
0.0895836353302002,
-0.5216668844223022,
0.06893887370824814,
0.5319117903709412,
-0.3384816646575928,
-0.1539773792028427,
0.38565051555633545,
0.1267617791891098,
-0.10215133428573608,
0.4743829369544983,
-0.10743814706802368,
-0.877393901348114,
0.32408663630485535,
0.5525979399681091,
0.331836462020874,
-0.43436917662620544,
0.49411091208457947,
0.4081840515136719,
0.0898708626627922,
-0.4215971529483795,
0.8630425333976746,
-0.0668279305100441,
-0.6788144111633301,
-0.861656665802002,
-0.41396230459213257,
-0.6808990836143494,
-0.19993051886558533,
-0.6372270584106445,
0.10891501605510712,
-0.5000883936882019,
-0.11110076308250427,
-0.3349536657333374,
0.33234506845474243,
-0.46211183071136475,
0.4192872941493988,
0.06880488246679306,
1.0876115560531616,
-0.8663622736930847,
0.5138096809387207,
0.5585873126983643,
-0.3090238869190216,
-1.4442062377929688,
-0.023417167365550995,
0.24371640384197235,
-1.0612729787826538,
0.4061167240142822,
0.4293607473373413,
-0.6880605816841125,
0.2479727864265442,
-0.9708120226860046,
-0.6453981995582581,
1.1033861637115479,
0.6235533952713013,
-0.5058143138885498,
0.04294499754905701,
0.10319267958402634,
0.45932766795158386,
-0.24235935509204865,
0.3545025885105133,
0.35361698269844055,
0.7559383511543274,
0.42069920897483826,
-0.6668902039527893,
0.4781692922115326,
0.1445218026638031,
-0.2859556972980499,
-0.01901099644601345,
-0.839268684387207,
0.649980366230011,
-0.4539342522621155,
-0.11039203405380249,
0.2573479413986206,
0.5562273263931274,
0.6199537515640259,
0.3724125325679779,
0.6334070563316345,
0.16575480997562408,
0.8309285044670105,
-0.2920253574848175,
0.8693873286247253,
-0.20520518720149994,
-0.060307763516902924,
1.1034748554229736,
-0.4936446249485016,
0.9220727682113647,
0.8464018106460571,
-0.10541416704654694,
0.8072845339775085,
0.4032827913761139,
0.04743926227092743,
0.3184566795825958,
0.006359672639518976,
-0.35259950160980225,
-0.4400094747543335,
-0.3881620168685913,
-0.3027149736881256,
0.15692290663719177,
0.31530824303627014,
-0.11707764118909836,
-0.2970711588859558,
0.031038766726851463,
0.14599692821502686,
0.15601933002471924,
-0.23807057738304138,
0.527360737323761,
0.3632272183895111,
-1.242936611175537,
0.55882728099823,
-0.37312954664230347,
0.5748687386512756,
-0.4136500954627991,
-0.28100746870040894,
-0.09751729667186737,
-0.16275544464588165,
-0.3871317207813263,
-0.8582125902175903,
-0.2994430959224701,
-0.3928253948688507,
-0.1592334359884262,
-0.4846121370792389,
0.5623617768287659,
-0.559950590133667,
-0.04001666232943535,
0.08113763481378555,
0.6213168501853943,
0.20672360062599182,
-0.4358835220336914,
-0.5774081945419312,
-0.26244300603866577,
-0.015682512894272804,
-0.4522782564163208,
0.12879711389541626,
0.3837461769580841,
0.07917850464582443,
0.6259217262268066,
0.7759750485420227,
0.021996518597006798,
-0.03293877840042114,
0.3861657381057739,
0.852489173412323,
-0.3845158517360687,
-0.2609209716320038,
-0.8858672380447388,
0.4354062080383301,
0.14187699556350708,
0.20016847550868988,
1.0859293937683105,
0.40733110904693604,
0.29385435581207275,
0.10600418597459793,
0.23224708437919617,
0.2462795376777649,
0.76139897108078,
-0.6371041536331177,
0.5715557932853699,
-0.5392701029777527,
0.42868489027023315,
-0.12884902954101562,
-0.8269280791282654,
-0.18725024163722992,
0.4392848610877991,
-0.5106000304222107,
0.2075626701116562,
0.6346703767776489,
1.3188005685806274,
0.3884724974632263,
0.22357845306396484,
0.4331611394882202,
0.17872239649295807,
0.26206648349761963,
0.4181763529777527,
1.121127724647522,
-0.26941120624542236,
0.49148234724998474,
-0.1952800750732422,
-0.22142019867897034,
-0.2735176384449005,
-1.2097729444503784,
-0.8182100653648376,
-0.4301557242870331,
-0.27238768339157104,
-0.5589267611503601,
0.08863253891468048,
0.8905923962593079,
0.7373688220977783,
-0.8196449279785156,
0.03253873810172081,
0.15470202267169952,
0.16463282704353333,
-0.22128014266490936,
-0.2019565850496292,
0.16594545543193817,
-0.20029468834400177,
-0.43566054105758667,
0.48052123188972473,
0.05739462748169899,
0.061042286455631256,
-0.428534597158432,
-0.2368190437555313,
-0.26643237471580505,
0.42249739170074463,
0.3723215162754059,
0.15626145899295807,
-0.6713816523551941,
-0.5483757257461548,
0.22746232151985168,
-0.2342398464679718,
0.3658139705657959,
0.575059711933136,
-1.113944172859192,
0.49941813945770264,
0.44413113594055176,
0.3794582784175873,
0.17069852352142334,
0.47349414229393005,
0.7168059945106506,
-0.9943402409553528,
-0.23320868611335754,
0.258567750453949,
-0.03197433426976204,
0.49236422777175903,
-0.7434930205345154,
0.38011589646339417,
-0.1391216665506363,
-0.6228874921798706,
-0.8197271823883057,
0.11901383846998215,
-0.5724213123321533,
-0.0683041363954544,
1.1067663431167603,
-0.13670526444911957,
-0.3456348180770874,
-0.165155291557312,
-0.5551627278327942,
0.026710350066423416,
-0.6857740879058838,
0.8762814402580261,
1.1504544019699097,
-0.08506642282009125,
-0.18820245563983917,
-0.5485076308250427,
0.6749290823936462,
0.8544437289237976,
-0.4520931541919708,
0.29649046063423157,
0.5067048072814941,
0.35855114459991455,
0.41322609782218933,
0.6177092790603638,
0.023746125400066376,
0.7343795895576477,
-0.49685731530189514,
-0.31083402037620544,
-0.13856159150600433,
-0.5118263959884644,
-0.5098726749420166,
-0.01014405395835638,
0.43314746022224426,
0.24304836988449097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17119v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17119v1
|
Creating Suspenseful Stories: Iterative Planning with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-27T01:25:52 | 2024-02-27T01:25:52 |
Kaige Xie, Mark Riedl
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automated story generation has been one of the long-standing challenges in
NLP. Among all dimensions of stories, suspense is very common in human-written
stories but relatively under-explored in AI-generated stories. While recent
advances in large language models (LLMs) have greatly promoted language
generation in general, state-of-the-art LLMs are still unreliable when it comes
to suspenseful story generation. We propose a novel iterative-prompting-based
planning method that is grounded in two theoretical foundations of story
suspense from cognitive psychology and narratology. This theory-grounded method
works in a fully zero-shot manner and does not rely on any supervised story
corpora. To the best of our knowledge, this paper is the first attempt at
suspenseful story generation with LLMs. Extensive human evaluations of the
generated suspenseful stories demonstrate the effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.3175837993621826,
-0.8915202021598816,
0.8892577290534973,
0.660104513168335,
-0.16434311866760254,
0.09980577230453491,
-0.47592994570732117,
-0.30681735277175903,
0.44321975111961365,
0.2501656711101532,
-0.8189924359321594,
-0.73665851354599,
-0.1342446506023407,
0.13394320011138916,
-0.5157911777496338,
0.7983902096748352,
-0.0838923305273056,
-0.36669856309890747,
-0.003644660348072648,
0.303547739982605,
-0.42738789319992065,
-0.621565580368042,
-0.3932187557220459,
-0.1801328957080841,
0.5515416860580444,
0.3654138147830963,
0.7116920948028564,
0.736388623714447,
-0.04842620715498924,
0.13247384130954742,
0.06507556140422821,
0.2816805839538574,
-0.2658746540546417,
0.5181174278259277,
0.10229591280221939,
-0.07319460809230804,
0.04092961922287941,
-0.31475141644477844,
0.4845116436481476,
0.620019793510437,
-0.4763782322406769,
-0.14853602647781372,
-0.34312692284584045,
0.6105273365974426,
-0.6352280974388123,
-0.19109119474887848,
-0.5759313702583313,
0.37448424100875854,
-0.09075311571359634,
-0.6575210690498352,
-0.5195996761322021,
-0.27305370569229126,
0.22139166295528412,
-0.42414724826812744,
0.2916843295097351,
0.140728160738945,
0.4988531768321991,
0.14455395936965942,
-0.16826055943965912,
-0.6547962427139282,
-0.9763378500938416,
0.5965025424957275,
-0.5881125926971436,
-0.10062485933303833,
0.493089497089386,
0.06336770206689835,
-0.21401439607143402,
-0.3883857727050781,
-0.5727633833885193,
-0.748858630657196,
0.34564903378486633,
-0.04237722232937813,
-0.07452262938022614,
-0.375881165266037,
0.4024662971496582,
0.1311010867357254,
-0.7273455262184143,
0.35189735889434814,
-0.2840019464492798,
0.12192903459072113,
0.8555203676223755,
0.5469582676887512,
-0.06274367868900299,
-0.1714259535074234,
-0.29910048842430115,
-0.1082027330994606,
-0.6321946382522583,
0.05047650635242462,
0.4381343722343445,
0.23648127913475037,
-0.10122331231832504,
0.6284540891647339,
-0.31356120109558105,
0.5019851922988892,
0.0755428597331047,
-0.37015849351882935,
-0.00044039174099452794,
-0.018253182992339134,
0.11758965253829956,
0.4250844419002533,
0.899301290512085,
0.6469419598579407,
0.4162485599517822,
-0.13183477520942688,
-0.12962478399276733,
0.4547545909881592,
0.5068432092666626,
-0.47760725021362305,
-0.006791385356336832,
0.6177355051040649,
0.07419774681329727,
-0.8777364492416382,
-0.4748181700706482,
-0.641192615032196,
-0.35578227043151855,
0.19189569354057312,
-0.011004282161593437,
-0.8367244005203247,
-0.25183382630348206,
0.3019460439682007,
0.0017025796696543694,
0.39330577850341797,
0.07957017421722412,
-1.1081465482711792,
0.19724537432193756,
0.458732008934021,
0.7334057688713074,
-0.37345850467681885,
-0.46611031889915466,
-0.3065742552280426,
0.33361756801605225,
-0.9243496656417847,
0.7506223320960999,
-0.13187222182750702,
-0.45167437195777893,
0.4355495274066925,
-0.63116055727005,
0.361859530210495,
-0.1695294827222824,
0.6186431646347046,
-0.39664238691329956,
0.16656820476055145,
0.08808119595050812,
-0.43942344188690186,
0.20353737473487854,
0.6086513996124268,
-0.19739380478858948,
0.9479250311851501,
-0.1190352588891983,
-0.49751245975494385,
0.37873393297195435,
-0.5218057036399841,
-0.7360716462135315,
0.05460837483406067,
-0.23351818323135376,
-0.335488498210907,
0.22342197597026825,
0.5277261137962341,
0.31020867824554443,
-0.22794783115386963,
0.9787482023239136,
0.2673322558403015,
-0.0744388997554779,
0.2819838523864746,
-0.3638167977333069,
0.5416260361671448,
0.2426813691854477,
-0.26784753799438477,
0.10577840358018875,
-0.8189267516136169,
0.26573848724365234,
0.5925626158714294,
-0.15952104330062866,
0.13860885798931122,
0.0443558506667614,
-0.04739391803741455,
0.0752539411187172,
0.03383095934987068,
-0.3269401490688324,
0.48532408475875854,
-0.4745747745037079,
0.20710772275924683,
0.6101940274238586,
0.274246484041214,
0.5367242693901062,
-0.5021034479141235,
0.8078936338424683,
-0.21085384488105774,
-0.09935355186462402,
-0.890460193157196,
-0.3483509123325348,
-0.6132488250732422,
-0.03546318784356117,
0.024997489526867867,
0.4717139005661011,
-0.9407246708869934,
0.319805383682251,
0.13787692785263062,
-0.5339152812957764,
0.07562507688999176,
-0.19348855316638947,
0.28378668427467346,
0.41968318819999695,
0.22478091716766357,
-0.06061220169067383,
-0.6018343567848206,
-0.4781726896762848,
-0.04459001496434212,
-0.21982280910015106,
-0.12162968516349792,
-0.11713947355747223,
0.13272520899772644,
0.17300380766391754,
0.9236111044883728,
-0.601005494594574,
-0.20320765674114227,
-0.44102180004119873,
0.4136914312839508,
0.19374683499336243,
0.4859292209148407,
0.5557239651679993,
-0.4342980682849884,
-0.38318923115730286,
-0.5495204925537109,
-0.9065059423446655,
-0.10539078712463379,
-0.48941296339035034,
0.14780166745185852,
0.5343002676963806,
0.3915420472621918,
-0.8650436401367188,
0.5990139842033386,
0.26191726326942444,
-0.10841462016105652,
0.8841302394866943,
-0.11662295460700989,
-0.29557734727859497,
-1.0509997606277466,
-0.18635520339012146,
-0.02194543369114399,
-0.01216647494584322,
-0.7274367213249207,
0.26170164346694946,
-0.18164564669132233,
-0.31798821687698364,
-0.18626482784748077,
0.5611659288406372,
-0.6590242385864258,
0.06659266352653503,
-0.17104391753673553,
0.1024402529001236,
-0.25221186876296997,
0.6365728974342346,
0.4530126750469208,
0.26604437828063965,
0.724892795085907,
-0.8690829873085022,
0.08695092797279358,
0.4219057857990265,
-0.39428019523620605,
0.3102176785469055,
-0.35617294907569885,
0.21727173030376434,
-0.011568747460842133,
0.1908808797597885,
-0.5951212644577026,
-0.561286985874176,
0.050529807806015015,
-0.5050219297409058,
0.3539300262928009,
0.022288240492343903,
-0.6523874998092651,
-0.5664460062980652,
-0.3143198788166046,
0.040342558175325394,
0.6626269221305847,
-0.33249250054359436,
0.4667413830757141,
-0.08392906188964844,
-0.5163485407829285,
-0.32828232645988464,
-0.393264502286911,
0.5968451499938965,
-0.25214746594429016,
-0.6192641854286194,
0.23534923791885376,
-0.2844746708869934,
-0.44530755281448364,
-0.2883812487125397,
-0.0077108885161578655,
-0.05404035747051239,
-0.005279638804495335,
0.23810403048992157,
0.1684434562921524,
-0.23291797935962677,
-0.07463889569044113,
0.1383609175682068,
-0.32012781500816345,
0.16020062565803528,
-0.39912959933280945,
0.7515127062797546,
0.13144473731517792,
-0.27403080463409424,
-0.29392558336257935,
0.7655304670333862,
0.20166358351707458,
-0.019214626401662827,
0.4525962471961975,
0.37896832823753357,
-0.1994536966085434,
-0.3898733854293823,
-0.5440584421157837,
-0.2705836296081543,
-0.43185263872146606,
0.0276806503534317,
-0.23390331864356995,
-0.8465086817741394,
0.16771984100341797,
-0.14475470781326294,
0.2652227282524109,
0.1345956027507782,
0.7083789110183716,
-0.011827916838228703,
1.024340033531189,
0.9356950521469116,
0.2106565237045288,
0.2434840202331543,
0.13189096748828888,
0.2157527357339859,
-0.2023322433233261,
0.021654389798641205,
-0.31035903096199036,
-0.03120564855635166,
-0.12774410843849182,
-0.13044078648090363,
0.467733770608902,
0.16553907096385956,
-0.03657887503504753,
0.08011025190353394,
-0.44054192304611206,
0.528697669506073,
0.6337049007415771,
-0.41707831621170044,
0.4423055648803711,
0.25219208002090454,
-0.3981340527534485,
-0.14879384636878967,
-0.8492172956466675,
-0.640221357345581,
1.0129978656768799,
0.0994706079363823,
0.5535376667976379,
0.07116314768791199,
0.8211275339126587,
0.06983402371406555,
0.02342342585325241,
-0.7458744049072266,
0.5848726034164429,
0.3776070773601532,
-0.47266730666160583,
-0.458299458026886,
-0.02358543686568737,
-0.852030873298645,
-0.1223498210310936,
-0.3660444915294647,
-1.2710620164871216,
0.06380823254585266,
0.10644640028476715,
-0.7188544273376465,
0.022049246355891228,
-0.36233624815940857,
0.17427489161491394,
-0.5259173512458801,
-0.4371865391731262,
-0.06923490017652512,
-0.727053165435791,
0.5135974287986755,
-0.10596757382154465,
-0.06716741621494293,
-0.04367518052458763,
0.24017956852912903,
0.3767348825931549,
-0.502269983291626,
0.6074914336204529,
-0.06184014305472374,
-0.3105960786342621,
0.5041329264640808,
0.7215659022331238,
0.5423533916473389,
0.17779575288295746,
-0.2566528022289276,
-0.13997933268547058,
-0.4843278229236603,
-0.3254736363887787,
-0.35964661836624146,
0.5364493727684021,
-0.23585104942321777,
-0.7794249057769775,
-0.5434839725494385,
-1.0474053621292114,
-0.4528121054172516,
0.16696691513061523,
0.5197427272796631,
0.33333155512809753,
-0.42107877135276794,
-0.18860799074172974,
0.5521904826164246,
-0.27453669905662537,
0.9842092990875244,
0.5400884747505188,
-0.5367068648338318,
-0.25110411643981934,
0.5259563326835632,
-0.019599666818976402,
0.0901782214641571,
0.16810961067676544,
0.28925877809524536,
-0.07941000908613205,
-0.872812032699585,
-0.46168723702430725,
-0.1468014121055603,
-0.2677626311779022,
-0.07633363455533981,
-1.0315675735473633,
-0.2839791178703308,
-0.24974402785301208,
-0.9470605254173279,
-0.3080737888813019,
-0.44465523958206177,
0.04001162573695183,
-0.5206820964813232,
0.6055971384048462,
0.7554723620414734,
-0.3664233684539795,
0.36839088797569275,
-0.552685558795929,
0.38667207956314087,
-0.09254458546638489,
-0.16529963910579681,
0.10313648730516434,
-0.20632870495319366,
-0.11854945868253708,
-0.39434805512428284,
-0.4168959856033325,
-0.6566084027290344,
0.9968273043632507,
-0.27756327390670776,
0.23271606862545013,
0.45700350403785706,
0.5153366327285767,
0.48532673716545105,
-0.6268311142921448,
0.9769131541252136,
0.29170525074005127,
-0.5629591941833496,
0.6641335487365723,
-0.772221028804779,
0.40698134899139404,
0.38134071230888367,
0.41155001521110535,
-0.20557823777198792,
-0.43581312894821167,
-0.7729989886283875,
-1.2830597162246704,
0.5462727546691895,
0.3411442041397095,
0.3388793468475342,
-0.24828442931175232,
0.2508017420768738,
0.25096622109413147,
0.45893624424934387,
-0.7444615960121155,
-0.1211128756403923,
-0.05460232123732567,
0.1865207850933075,
-0.17580105364322662,
-0.6016009449958801,
-0.45056629180908203,
0.07375600934028625,
0.5182832479476929,
-0.3099801540374756,
0.17962884902954102,
0.2617488205432892,
0.023535532876849174,
-0.3992800712585449,
0.3142910301685333,
0.9250795245170593,
0.7711262106895447,
-0.29078006744384766,
-0.15453238785266876,
0.02993376925587654,
-0.07325038313865662,
0.21340689063072205,
-0.03687236085534096,
-0.552384078502655,
0.11925062537193298,
0.4092600643634796,
0.833981454372406,
0.08500055223703384,
-0.7153916954994202,
0.39021772146224976,
-0.06296756863594055,
-0.5241364240646362,
-0.8754369020462036,
-0.08727551251649857,
0.1454123556613922,
0.26817816495895386,
0.6949902772903442,
-0.15432514250278473,
-0.28066587448120117,
-0.5431417226791382,
0.10931577533483505,
0.16929449141025543,
-0.09500852972269058,
-0.06913390010595322,
0.5245776772499084,
-0.06874198466539383,
-0.5993328094482422,
0.6190488338470459,
-0.49076810479164124,
-0.3307710886001587,
0.5547364950180054,
1.004797339439392,
1.0458053350448608,
-0.040989357978105545,
0.6052491068840027,
0.4637368321418762,
0.5229361653327942,
-0.1524234116077423,
0.39302122592926025,
-0.06486442685127258,
-0.7487198114395142,
-0.4575921297073364,
-0.5505818724632263,
-0.5898342728614807,
0.16085755825042725,
-0.6378403306007385,
0.20584751665592194,
-0.6588578224182129,
0.09824463725090027,
-0.2800626754760742,
-0.13453546166419983,
-0.1342216432094574,
-0.027453163638710976,
0.28127697110176086,
0.9934610724449158,
-0.41181400418281555,
0.3759360909461975,
0.38280045986175537,
-0.2137024700641632,
-0.9341549277305603,
0.458901584148407,
0.13583436608314514,
-0.6738324761390686,
0.182768777012825,
0.1461023986339569,
0.044209063053131104,
0.03875046968460083,
-0.9421379566192627,
-0.663472592830658,
0.9675896167755127,
0.14076025784015656,
-0.5997498631477356,
-0.3819655478000641,
-0.0645788386464119,
0.5732390284538269,
-0.637177050113678,
-0.33651846647262573,
0.25026610493659973,
0.45949989557266235,
0.4789634346961975,
-0.529156506061554,
0.023962339386343956,
-0.09701168537139893,
0.006060208659619093,
-0.05500791594386101,
-0.3539644777774811,
0.6659092903137207,
-0.83978670835495,
-0.2122880220413208,
0.6086716055870056,
0.5483787059783936,
0.7006837725639343,
0.6058560609817505,
0.3197603225708008,
0.520442545413971,
0.6880035400390625,
0.09290822595357895,
1.2859165668487549,
-0.2772010266780853,
-0.21423190832138062,
1.4047129154205322,
-0.8554056882858276,
0.6529322862625122,
0.3714497685432434,
0.25260379910469055,
0.5173283815383911,
0.5504032969474792,
0.12284328788518906,
0.46369630098342896,
0.3898502588272095,
-0.20844943821430206,
-0.24894531071186066,
-0.16497927904129028,
-0.17300137877464294,
0.48327726125717163,
0.3634258508682251,
-0.17261885106563568,
-0.34820854663848877,
0.050876326858997345,
0.23130328953266144,
0.29843664169311523,
-0.22146503627300262,
0.8562726378440857,
0.22406788170337677,
-0.930870532989502,
0.5672547817230225,
0.03876939043402672,
0.40689945220947266,
-0.7337426543235779,
0.18641917407512665,
-0.1956399381160736,
-0.30175402760505676,
0.14613041281700134,
-0.6039886474609375,
0.10790117084980011,
0.42785516381263733,
-0.2399638593196869,
-0.44611361622810364,
0.591629147529602,
-0.35788798332214355,
-0.3219837546348572,
0.09220167249441147,
0.695057213306427,
-0.05101139843463898,
-0.18665891885757446,
-0.25940850377082825,
-0.03880871832370758,
-0.08706162124872208,
-0.40369585156440735,
0.3011515736579895,
0.624751627445221,
-0.45013177394866943,
0.7022984027862549,
0.9369500279426575,
-0.08899735659360886,
-0.14070120453834534,
0.03538425266742706,
0.8840112686157227,
-1.0444906949996948,
-0.9347788095474243,
-0.9160072803497314,
0.6202306151390076,
0.032528094947338104,
-0.37671589851379395,
0.5225993990898132,
0.3544466495513916,
0.23761160671710968,
-0.062295928597450256,
0.7293530106544495,
-0.024900032207369804,
0.2618848383426666,
-0.7841551303863525,
0.3765574097633362,
-0.01088928896933794,
0.298962265253067,
-0.43050116300582886,
-0.994480550289154,
-0.3805396258831024,
0.39958685636520386,
-0.09742537885904312,
-0.2970636188983917,
1.004057765007019,
0.6857524514198303,
0.617344081401825,
-0.05778516083955765,
0.6606289744377136,
0.3250991106033325,
0.03154314309358597,
0.4718542695045471,
1.2110334634780884,
0.12432542443275452,
0.40380141139030457,
-0.28354182839393616,
-0.13183222711086273,
-0.1951766312122345,
-1.2968443632125854,
-0.9977643489837646,
-0.5387375950813293,
-0.15051813423633575,
-0.38003355264663696,
0.03883765637874603,
0.8731174468994141,
0.4922722578048706,
-0.41891905665397644,
-0.23821069300174713,
-0.29762300848960876,
-0.09335468709468842,
-0.21913844347000122,
-0.24769480526447296,
0.01826765574514866,
-0.23387612402439117,
-0.3824699819087982,
0.9723479151725769,
0.41651028394699097,
0.13367420434951782,
-0.5390641093254089,
-0.053412195295095444,
-0.3349979519844055,
0.35182279348373413,
0.49001505970954895,
0.6078267693519592,
-0.5595099329948425,
0.07668925821781158,
-0.08812832087278366,
-0.035526301711797714,
0.012786954641342163,
1.0211800336837769,
-0.8819769620895386,
0.24344517290592194,
-0.10913137346506119,
0.3711310923099518,
0.7692455649375916,
-0.13283579051494598,
1.052282691001892,
-1.1763163805007935,
0.37802955508232117,
0.5325676202774048,
0.15943112969398499,
0.286722868680954,
-0.6267208456993103,
0.7731354832649231,
-0.21214275062084198,
-0.33240067958831787,
-1.0137466192245483,
0.453138530254364,
-1.0044958591461182,
-0.1343671977519989,
1.227875828742981,
0.23457008600234985,
-0.09054576605558395,
0.008406917564570904,
-0.35282599925994873,
-0.1657390594482422,
-0.5941510796546936,
0.9302895069122314,
0.7287156581878662,
-0.19796331226825714,
-0.3304336965084076,
-0.40810105204582214,
0.5560614466667175,
0.45086511969566345,
-0.5966691970825195,
0.1692572385072708,
0.49213752150535583,
-0.24508188664913177,
0.6804283261299133,
0.9846946597099304,
0.1083260253071785,
0.2896873354911804,
0.25515732169151306,
0.193238765001297,
-0.3048621416091919,
-0.568853497505188,
-0.20251159369945526,
0.4679560959339142,
0.05056840926408768,
0.4746244251728058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17110v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17110v1
|
Sinkhorn Distance Minimization for Knowledge Distillation
| 2024-02-27T01:13:58 | 2024-02-27T01:13:58 |
Xiao Cui, Yulei Qin, Yuting Gao, Enwei Zhang, Zihan Xu, Tong Wu, Ke Li, Xing Sun, Wengang Zhou, Houqiang Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Knowledge distillation (KD) has been widely adopted to compress large
language models (LLMs). Existing KD methods investigate various divergence
measures including the Kullback-Leibler (KL), reverse Kullback-Leibler (RKL),
and Jensen-Shannon (JS) divergences. However, due to limitations inherent in
their assumptions and definitions, these measures fail to deliver effective
supervision when few distribution overlap exists between the teacher and the
student. In this paper, we show that the aforementioned KL, RKL, and JS
divergences respectively suffer from issues of mode-averaging, mode-collapsing,
and mode-underestimation, which deteriorates logits-based KD for diverse NLP
tasks. We propose the Sinkhorn Knowledge Distillation (SinKD) that exploits the
Sinkhorn distance to ensure a nuanced and precise assessment of the disparity
between teacher and student distributions. Besides, profit by properties of the
Sinkhorn metric, we can get rid of sample-wise KD that restricts the perception
of divergence in each teacher-student sample pair. Instead, we propose a
batch-wise reformulation to capture geometric intricacies of distributions
across samples in the high-dimensional space. Comprehensive evaluation on GLUE
and SuperGLUE, in terms of comparability, validity, and generalizability,
highlights our superiority over state-of-the-art methods on all kinds of LLMs
with encoder-only, encoder-decoder, and decoder-only architectures.
|
[
-0.4839301109313965,
-0.6895698308944702,
0.4524564743041992,
0.0839802697300911,
-0.32804152369499207,
0.3228171765804291,
-0.5203956365585327,
-0.08817686140537262,
0.2780284285545349,
-0.03047073259949684,
-0.22422254085540771,
-0.6505450010299683,
-1.11699378490448,
-0.09417127817869186,
-0.3536504805088043,
0.9709370136260986,
0.10437256097793579,
-0.08573682606220245,
-0.442376971244812,
-0.08562249690294266,
-0.32643449306488037,
-0.08999787271022797,
-0.49475282430648804,
-0.3499261438846588,
0.25238037109375,
0.12803271412849426,
0.5397151112556458,
0.5080441832542419,
0.4611230790615082,
0.2708451747894287,
-0.640200674533844,
0.2444196343421936,
-0.5256953239440918,
0.2952461242675781,
-0.045344337821006775,
-0.5811677575111389,
-0.11237209290266037,
-0.09031867980957031,
0.2887212336063385,
1.0339385271072388,
-0.46931368112564087,
0.06325671076774597,
0.30697309970855713,
0.8242971897125244,
-0.8888285756111145,
0.2855042815208435,
-0.5093896985054016,
0.20292030274868011,
-0.13617749512195587,
0.21246866881847382,
-0.264883428812027,
-0.6805453300476074,
0.4891504645347595,
-0.4681645631790161,
0.29133304953575134,
-0.3439311385154724,
0.5325494408607483,
0.5499444603919983,
-0.36537766456604004,
-0.5879197716712952,
-0.7629969120025635,
1.0483146905899048,
-0.841656506061554,
0.5970194935798645,
0.3631717264652252,
0.4334121644496918,
-0.11975622922182083,
-0.5308758020401001,
-0.2669951915740967,
0.10531950742006302,
-0.11574459075927734,
0.17686428129673004,
-0.05613718554377556,
-0.053727418184280396,
0.1429154872894287,
0.3369259238243103,
-0.19309040904045105,
0.10092329233884811,
-0.5324970483779907,
-0.08911740034818649,
0.40696486830711365,
0.011524312198162079,
-0.07039947807788849,
0.013863462954759598,
-0.5476506948471069,
-0.3762587308883667,
-0.5067524909973145,
0.09438773989677429,
0.2534031271934509,
0.05392985790967941,
-0.07549859583377838,
0.20475412905216217,
-0.17371493577957153,
0.3516480028629303,
-0.1262313574552536,
-0.6284899711608887,
0.00045510739437304437,
0.04707080498337746,
-0.24926696717739105,
0.2557045519351959,
0.7256197929382324,
0.37671971321105957,
0.2643732726573944,
-0.09991440176963806,
-0.04084767773747444,
0.03210745006799698,
-0.1925511360168457,
-0.8438496589660645,
-0.5076640248298645,
0.16470453143119812,
-0.33665236830711365,
-0.36522606015205383,
-0.14343562722206116,
-1.0269231796264648,
-0.5419301986694336,
-0.3130161464214325,
0.2688319683074951,
-0.29517441987991333,
-0.501960277557373,
0.2628927230834961,
-0.3210207223892212,
-0.1771182268857956,
0.1968783587217331,
-0.8900726437568665,
0.39465636014938354,
0.6387692093849182,
0.8161916136741638,
-0.29531893134117126,
-0.27860990166664124,
-0.1289556324481964,
0.1392098069190979,
-0.36042287945747375,
0.47080186009407043,
-0.4016447961330414,
-0.4681856036186218,
-0.16303953528404236,
-0.4197026789188385,
0.09908246248960495,
-0.8929350972175598,
0.3752240836620331,
-0.600773811340332,
0.08513721823692322,
-0.15923796594142914,
-0.9055458307266235,
-0.3235248029232025,
0.08649954199790955,
-0.5452897548675537,
0.8355849385261536,
0.14408141374588013,
-0.8626856207847595,
0.653090238571167,
-0.22721293568611145,
-0.3479093313217163,
-0.07115763425827026,
-0.32349225878715515,
-0.4835074841976166,
0.28819817304611206,
0.44435766339302063,
0.5495410561561584,
-0.278055340051651,
0.44600990414619446,
-0.37725433707237244,
-0.2902543544769287,
-0.011944670230150223,
-0.6507351398468018,
0.9123355746269226,
0.05399610847234726,
-0.2761676013469696,
-0.3750261664390564,
-0.5090252161026001,
-0.15944822132587433,
-0.2074570208787918,
-0.6110146045684814,
-0.7983696460723877,
-0.018414486199617386,
-0.2896382808685303,
-0.3073052763938904,
0.08844093978404999,
-0.319381982088089,
0.40231555700302124,
-0.3962312638759613,
0.27667713165283203,
0.7957702875137329,
-0.10686676949262619,
0.5027831792831421,
-0.05583556741476059,
0.47097742557525635,
0.43392935395240784,
0.08333756029605865,
0.002468040445819497,
-0.2617298364639282,
-0.5185427069664001,
-0.5540396571159363,
0.5096702575683594,
0.39519110321998596,
-0.7718266248703003,
0.25967979431152344,
-0.44898897409439087,
-0.6577281951904297,
-0.500330924987793,
0.30915164947509766,
0.29793351888656616,
0.5371417999267578,
0.5542458295822144,
-0.01726791076362133,
-0.28814998269081116,
-0.5704817771911621,
-0.2976122796535492,
0.03120511770248413,
-0.18630874156951904,
-0.06261643767356873,
0.23348887264728546,
-0.16992326080799103,
1.1935851573944092,
-1.0375571250915527,
-0.558295726776123,
-0.031371042132377625,
-0.09093125909566879,
0.43745484948158264,
0.2473352700471878,
0.5411468744277954,
-0.5172598958015442,
-0.7489439845085144,
-0.07456362247467041,
-0.7798485159873962,
-0.05439896881580353,
0.18247045576572418,
0.1954815536737442,
0.28689342737197876,
0.6882955431938171,
-0.8945225477218628,
0.44181129336357117,
0.44893017411231995,
-0.18830521404743195,
0.6227021813392639,
-0.0972084254026413,
0.0014101981651037931,
-1.0768994092941284,
-0.39170679450035095,
0.00832296721637249,
-0.20118442177772522,
-0.5151224732398987,
-0.06361556798219681,
-0.0720931813120842,
0.37784266471862793,
-0.36216849088668823,
0.33531785011291504,
-0.3801797330379486,
0.21055154502391815,
-0.06813658773899078,
0.354699045419693,
-0.03797416388988495,
0.1489664912223816,
0.032653920352458954,
0.3856699466705322,
0.8066914081573486,
-0.5798017382621765,
0.5359649658203125,
0.10896995663642883,
-0.4453725516796112,
0.6255929470062256,
-0.6162228584289551,
-0.13614219427108765,
-0.18215548992156982,
0.22350531816482544,
-0.9075835943222046,
0.11422590166330338,
-0.10350273549556732,
-0.2278604805469513,
0.5068396925926208,
-0.281928688287735,
-0.10690417885780334,
-0.1520579755306244,
-0.6347789764404297,
0.48493853211402893,
0.9457645416259766,
-0.7948837280273438,
0.5011721253395081,
0.10163439810276031,
-0.14353451132774353,
-0.9121538996696472,
-0.7861884832382202,
-0.13357941806316376,
-0.6668689250946045,
-0.5180172920227051,
0.06571243703365326,
0.032944537699222565,
-0.4778643846511841,
0.006901314482092857,
-0.5246415734291077,
-0.15236049890518188,
-0.24229519069194794,
-0.0192304365336895,
0.1198020726442337,
-0.18776413798332214,
0.22709135711193085,
0.5876702666282654,
0.06371292471885681,
0.10526499152183533,
-0.37073275446891785,
0.3427039086818695,
0.1468324363231659,
-0.3814292848110199,
-0.10023844242095947,
0.045592594891786575,
0.5385324954986572,
0.28335097432136536,
0.7109007835388184,
0.6953603625297546,
-0.10755758732557297,
-0.7219186425209045,
-0.6565027236938477,
-0.4843400716781616,
-0.5204343199729919,
0.24658051133155823,
-0.25023576617240906,
-0.8149529099464417,
0.41894054412841797,
-0.39998796582221985,
-0.011143316514790058,
-0.010602707043290138,
0.37500524520874023,
-0.0945730060338974,
0.3336617350578308,
0.38214173913002014,
-0.23599790036678314,
-0.1175515428185463,
-0.4817945659160614,
0.35356998443603516,
-0.6844663023948669,
-0.152423694729805,
-0.257491797208786,
-0.44368502497673035,
-0.3882042467594147,
-0.3793703317642212,
0.5006776452064514,
0.6168155670166016,
0.2499825656414032,
0.2003975212574005,
-0.45159798860549927,
0.8036089539527893,
0.4842485189437866,
-0.1423443704843521,
0.40801477432250977,
0.1826978325843811,
-0.2902853488922119,
-0.39862310886383057,
-0.7473719716072083,
-0.2068844586610794,
1.0885738134384155,
0.33304622769355774,
1.207431435585022,
0.1958843469619751,
1.1558152437210083,
0.26526761054992676,
-0.05350763723254204,
-0.8689702749252319,
0.4696146845817566,
-0.25248983502388,
-0.14832165837287903,
-0.5646025538444519,
-0.5422311425209045,
-0.8737453818321228,
0.5097790956497192,
0.2826310694217682,
-0.5548773407936096,
0.15952521562576294,
-0.017366038635373116,
-0.1896210014820099,
0.4670414626598358,
-0.7724311351776123,
0.38786378502845764,
0.38967621326446533,
0.04340974614024162,
0.012282983399927616,
-0.4706997573375702,
0.523242175579071,
-0.22844207286834717,
0.4128662645816803,
-0.06367423385381699,
0.029855893924832344,
0.6099570989608765,
-0.5640363097190857,
0.7990655303001404,
-0.4117599427700043,
-0.4873741567134857,
0.3518773317337036,
0.5002118945121765,
0.314689040184021,
0.2868291437625885,
0.2897029519081116,
0.3487909138202667,
0.2740565240383148,
-0.10994049161672592,
-0.7204787135124207,
0.8325870037078857,
-0.6595981121063232,
-0.6391757726669312,
-0.05541263893246651,
-0.5809077620506287,
-0.11336807161569595,
0.04406443610787392,
0.18905042111873627,
0.46061331033706665,
0.2905076742172241,
0.31114131212234497,
0.8639957308769226,
0.04829026386141777,
0.9037954211235046,
0.3211183249950409,
-0.2567652463912964,
-0.31565532088279724,
0.9183180928230286,
0.27340167760849,
0.34725475311279297,
0.1900215595960617,
0.500540554523468,
-0.6199851036071777,
-0.43419045209884644,
-0.26727181673049927,
0.025921283289790154,
-0.9859692454338074,
-0.29268452525138855,
-0.3933927118778229,
-0.016501564532518387,
-0.6154415607452393,
-0.30081209540367126,
-0.6277089715003967,
-0.46598201990127563,
-0.3202533423900604,
0.06231429800391197,
0.3736818730831146,
0.6491763591766357,
-0.1491302102804184,
0.043552055954933167,
-0.667851448059082,
0.19996917247772217,
0.5061596035957336,
0.3105098605155945,
0.225155308842659,
-0.5547589063644409,
-0.018836602568626404,
-0.009952785447239876,
-0.15761451423168182,
-0.6709034442901611,
0.25649601221084595,
0.39772284030914307,
0.3409438133239746,
0.6989647150039673,
0.4071611166000366,
0.6563027501106262,
-0.3729245960712433,
0.6886783242225647,
0.3082541227340698,
-0.8071081042289734,
0.4375634491443634,
-0.09992523491382599,
0.3468741774559021,
0.46606841683387756,
0.6926062107086182,
-0.36566027998924255,
-0.668045163154602,
-0.22870156168937683,
-0.9382327795028687,
0.36284777522087097,
0.08453191071748734,
0.033800072968006134,
0.0044819810427725315,
0.1484736055135727,
0.2716574966907501,
0.11515038460493088,
-0.5752722024917603,
-0.382656991481781,
0.12067896127700806,
-0.348135381937027,
0.051830604672431946,
-0.08947921544313431,
-0.23854383826255798,
-0.32635733485221863,
0.5419363975524902,
0.0003213636518921703,
-0.434588760137558,
0.17771317064762115,
-0.10958966612815857,
0.3355053961277008,
0.3055334985256195,
0.4104040265083313,
0.6128902435302734,
-0.06148010864853859,
0.5681024789810181,
0.533489465713501,
-0.9627581238746643,
0.378183513879776,
-0.0856185108423233,
-0.13611333072185516,
0.2097744643688202,
0.5806716084480286,
0.3088844120502472,
-0.016997192054986954,
-0.3617520332336426,
0.5840051174163818,
-0.04514428973197937,
-0.3178060054779053,
-0.09644197672605515,
0.04629310593008995,
0.48418906331062317,
0.5008057355880737,
0.2874666750431061,
0.01617260091006756,
0.11448916047811508,
0.04414680227637291,
0.07448894530534744,
0.23129570484161377,
-0.3773152828216553,
-0.055887773633003235,
0.4332738518714905,
0.022205481305718422,
-0.04578131437301636,
0.5388697981834412,
-0.3608703017234802,
-0.2327207624912262,
0.4781537652015686,
0.34097838401794434,
0.7947116494178772,
-0.3795486390590668,
0.15992853045463562,
0.21118693053722382,
0.2528972923755646,
-0.2226274609565735,
-0.006008479278534651,
-0.22426393628120422,
-0.5549800992012024,
-0.4203149676322937,
-0.8775439858436584,
-0.004627457819879055,
-0.01926386170089245,
-0.7086178064346313,
0.39277052879333496,
-0.30981558561325073,
-0.008956370875239372,
-0.10061836242675781,
-0.22675670683383942,
-0.2528870403766632,
0.002568017691373825,
-0.17979887127876282,
0.7678749561309814,
-0.8499255180358887,
0.6677209138870239,
0.481547087430954,
-0.01625920832157135,
-0.8137437701225281,
0.043376851826906204,
0.06204714626073837,
-0.34096044301986694,
0.8437145352363586,
-0.04694164916872978,
-0.22584640979766846,
-0.09043129533529282,
-0.15357069671154022,
-0.6214797496795654,
1.3418890237808228,
0.4202616214752197,
-0.8282875418663025,
0.06399348378181458,
0.3691042363643646,
0.44912177324295044,
-0.01994909904897213,
0.19533950090408325,
0.8103845119476318,
0.1672002226114273,
0.16252799332141876,
-0.9223009943962097,
-0.010502208955585957,
0.33135172724723816,
0.19723430275917053,
0.34154367446899414,
-0.44410645961761475,
0.800384521484375,
-0.15338565409183502,
-0.19743625819683075,
-0.5741829872131348,
0.38094362616539,
0.239858016371727,
0.1868577003479004,
0.6076738238334656,
1.0167899131774902,
0.5581681132316589,
-0.23381002247333527,
0.4683949947357178,
-0.10584137588739395,
0.8554163575172424,
1.1266822814941406,
0.05237516015768051,
0.6434605121612549,
0.7666192650794983,
-0.702370285987854,
0.2579112648963928,
0.234561949968338,
0.08868014067411423,
0.6285656094551086,
0.34664586186408997,
-0.46324121952056885,
0.03195716813206673,
0.047701116651296616,
-0.52045738697052,
0.42692017555236816,
0.22453007102012634,
-0.012773402035236359,
-0.5257617831230164,
0.05802622437477112,
0.280748575925827,
0.19078342616558075,
-0.14787234365940094,
0.788189172744751,
0.3194614052772522,
-0.3626843988895416,
0.8934118151664734,
-0.3419328033924103,
0.9724756479263306,
-0.37640106678009033,
0.10722999274730682,
-0.5468742847442627,
0.31468042731285095,
-0.28021109104156494,
-0.723362386226654,
0.40110719203948975,
-0.36788564920425415,
-0.05009693652391434,
0.050025805830955505,
0.8428131341934204,
-0.7616195678710938,
-0.29868319630622864,
0.4030623435974121,
0.41524383425712585,
0.18092043697834015,
0.18146803975105286,
-0.29573437571525574,
0.2180463671684265,
-0.13847380876541138,
-0.37402984499931335,
0.16877306997776031,
0.39623287320137024,
0.30825310945510864,
0.7355020642280579,
0.2795266807079315,
0.30772244930267334,
0.3096116781234741,
0.2769795060157776,
0.8552025556564331,
-0.20432206988334656,
-0.3347852826118469,
-1.330101728439331,
0.29734358191490173,
-0.0631738007068634,
-0.09377537667751312,
0.8562605977058411,
0.5181975960731506,
0.9451102018356323,
-0.35389113426208496,
0.6286473870277405,
0.04066071659326553,
0.4959728419780731,
-0.5268533825874329,
0.877093493938446,
-0.4478099048137665,
0.42598679661750793,
-0.4605492949485779,
-1.1761574745178223,
-0.1469256430864334,
0.4241192638874054,
-0.07856209576129913,
-0.009235850535333157,
0.7394870519638062,
0.5923876762390137,
-0.3121729791164398,
-0.1476336270570755,
0.40873974561691284,
0.07820617407560349,
0.4262961447238922,
0.5940022468566895,
0.9482125639915466,
-0.34290510416030884,
0.6820294260978699,
-0.3054092824459076,
-0.18464937806129456,
-0.019591836258769035,
-0.8890939354896545,
-1.130002498626709,
-0.4535291790962219,
-0.6205605268478394,
-0.034325048327445984,
-0.21100065112113953,
0.5888438820838928,
0.8086308240890503,
-0.6305216550827026,
-0.2094196081161499,
-0.1910749077796936,
0.3311323821544647,
-0.1442146748304367,
-0.30324921011924744,
0.5191035270690918,
-0.5338148474693298,
-0.7985477447509766,
0.20892299711704254,
0.2547646164894104,
0.1490677148103714,
-0.6086666584014893,
0.01590721495449543,
0.10847675055265427,
-0.021459558978676796,
0.667385995388031,
-0.2966775894165039,
-0.7648380994796753,
-0.1441570222377777,
-0.24015720188617706,
0.10717008262872696,
-0.23356296122074127,
0.3481452167034149,
-0.6351901888847351,
0.5153374671936035,
0.4991312325000763,
0.6611546874046326,
0.44107913970947266,
-0.2159898579120636,
0.10324516147375107,
-1.0436317920684814,
0.21224656701087952,
0.1169310212135315,
0.014361252076923847,
0.15793494880199432,
-0.22392792999744415,
0.5498278737068176,
0.29693707823753357,
-0.5878089666366577,
-0.8556292653083801,
0.26229235529899597,
-0.604502260684967,
-0.46197518706321716,
1.145918846130371,
-0.4642128348350525,
0.03171244636178017,
-0.06296408176422119,
-0.11456635594367981,
0.08523492515087128,
-0.30195313692092896,
1.084924578666687,
0.8332000970840454,
0.024949798360466957,
0.022378118708729744,
-0.48055028915405273,
0.8594227433204651,
0.3425559997558594,
-0.6310214996337891,
0.12964600324630737,
0.2568945288658142,
0.6006156206130981,
0.25404462218284607,
0.3123725354671478,
-0.0006213749293237925,
-0.15411044657230377,
0.24845531582832336,
-0.12639768421649933,
0.0070433057844638824,
-0.352612167596817,
-0.3150303363800049,
0.20981141924858093,
-0.07909858971834183,
-0.1055719256401062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00824v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00824v2
|
Information Flow Routes: Automatically Interpreting Language Models at Scale
| 2024-02-27T00:24:42 | 2024-04-16T23:32:38 |
Javier Ferrando, Elena Voita
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Information flows by routes inside the network via mechanisms implemented in
the model. These routes can be represented as graphs where nodes correspond to
token representations and edges to operations inside the network. We
automatically build these graphs in a top-down manner, for each prediction
leaving only the most important nodes and edges. In contrast to the existing
workflows relying on activation patching, we do this through attribution: this
allows us to efficiently uncover existing circuits with just a single forward
pass. Additionally, the applicability of our method is far beyond patching: we
do not need a human to carefully design prediction templates, and we can
extract information flow routes for any prediction (not just the ones among the
allowed templates). As a result, we can talk about model behavior in general,
for specific types of predictions, or different domains. We experiment with
Llama 2 and show that the role of some attention heads is overall important,
e.g. previous token heads and subword merging heads. Next, we find similarities
in Llama 2 behavior when handling tokens of the same part of speech. Finally,
we show that some model components can be specialized on domains such as coding
or multilingual texts.
|
[
-0.1594230830669403,
-0.6818094849586487,
0.4817854166030884,
0.27086395025253296,
-0.21282029151916504,
-0.03793789818882942,
-0.004985550884157419,
-0.5269823670387268,
0.36174193024635315,
0.7170777916908264,
-0.570127546787262,
-0.2554709017276764,
-0.701465368270874,
-0.15969739854335785,
-0.7482797503471375,
0.8179301023483276,
-0.06694035977125168,
-0.04076531156897545,
-0.10287394374608994,
0.0016124197281897068,
-0.16921469569206238,
-0.4831213355064392,
-1.132651925086975,
-0.6369081735610962,
0.8527488112449646,
0.3347194492816925,
0.5853326320648193,
1.206581950187683,
0.6394132971763611,
0.2945674657821655,
-0.20388168096542358,
-0.11728085577487946,
-0.3156365156173706,
0.09458482265472412,
-0.4002234935760498,
-0.5853447318077087,
-0.4511297643184662,
-0.17971426248550415,
0.6913321018218994,
0.8351384997367859,
-0.29124534130096436,
0.18115133047103882,
-0.009716514497995377,
0.7317701578140259,
-0.30549460649490356,
0.26088640093803406,
-0.6237733364105225,
-0.1309700757265091,
-0.5059813857078552,
-0.2325495034456253,
-0.44081515073776245,
-0.2004532665014267,
-0.09971814602613449,
-0.4680279493331909,
-0.23395715653896332,
0.23642197251319885,
0.6497918963432312,
0.37423184514045715,
-0.5801492929458618,
-0.5099654793739319,
-0.6012200713157654,
0.5958754420280457,
-0.676784336566925,
0.22231075167655945,
0.3942220211029053,
0.4461261034011841,
-0.2898658514022827,
-1.061856746673584,
-0.4626046121120453,
0.17840860784053802,
-0.15797275304794312,
-0.33038732409477234,
-0.6356493830680847,
0.1512991338968277,
0.24111521244049072,
0.25704941153526306,
-0.35022538900375366,
0.28635331988334656,
-0.6264186501502991,
-0.16564889252185822,
0.3967896103858948,
0.08201716095209122,
0.32111042737960815,
-0.00352258188650012,
-0.1560833901166916,
0.05361296236515045,
-0.9064536690711975,
0.07142390310764313,
0.47280699014663696,
0.4290313124656677,
-0.12939760088920593,
0.6149811744689941,
-0.24275170266628265,
1.04523503780365,
-0.003703897586092353,
-0.13594359159469604,
0.2403034269809723,
-0.22469614446163177,
-0.20255330204963684,
-0.06870292127132416,
0.7387562990188599,
0.010551942512392998,
0.5261544585227966,
-0.26913365721702576,
-0.05166372284293175,
-0.4004402160644531,
0.32197093963623047,
-0.62272047996521,
-0.24645689129829407,
0.12353096157312393,
-0.5756757259368896,
-0.47240206599235535,
-0.28358256816864014,
-0.5873799324035645,
-0.6368464827537537,
-0.4821218252182007,
0.192467600107193,
-0.1560537964105606,
-0.6728197932243347,
-0.13230077922344208,
-0.039131857454776764,
0.1715700924396515,
0.32810986042022705,
-0.9106446504592896,
0.4257355034351349,
0.7641397714614868,
1.0569101572036743,
-0.4066888689994812,
-0.3429908752441406,
-0.5389606356620789,
0.10613255947828293,
-0.26930364966392517,
1.0164191722869873,
-0.7160354256629944,
0.07451725006103516,
-0.1444007009267807,
-0.04750099405646324,
-0.19017718732357025,
-0.48266711831092834,
0.20917199552059174,
-0.693225622177124,
-0.20598995685577393,
-0.16248561441898346,
-0.5309519171714783,
-0.2939537465572357,
0.08744774013757706,
-0.9145335555076599,
0.753986120223999,
0.0925758108496666,
-0.9510232210159302,
-0.02260110341012478,
-1.0109574794769287,
-0.5624105930328369,
-0.28348371386528015,
0.03828054293990135,
0.12026461213827133,
0.012165609747171402,
-0.04179004207253456,
0.2471681833267212,
-0.4880889356136322,
0.10047803819179535,
-0.17216183245182037,
-0.07717634737491608,
0.10548679530620575,
-0.30074119567871094,
1.0482631921768188,
0.28811851143836975,
-0.30945536494255066,
0.1963665783405304,
-0.7870767712593079,
-0.05293326452374458,
0.04782292619347572,
-0.33652809262275696,
-0.24932041764259338,
0.28418824076652527,
-0.06515015661716461,
0.2390677034854889,
0.03334008529782295,
-0.3500029444694519,
0.35831931233406067,
-0.41456300020217896,
0.8170983195304871,
0.9116823673248291,
0.05704566463828087,
0.5716843008995056,
-0.010023502632975578,
0.6230872869491577,
0.2657786011695862,
0.23160851001739502,
-0.3068021833896637,
-0.8438814282417297,
-0.7689653635025024,
-0.044125545769929886,
0.3310650587081909,
0.5146302580833435,
-0.6032848954200745,
-0.019068198278546333,
-0.3352417051792145,
-0.6963619589805603,
-0.5105603933334351,
0.18978668749332428,
0.24059322476387024,
0.5099644660949707,
-0.011396732181310654,
-0.19720523059368134,
-0.5234549641609192,
-0.871151328086853,
-0.3069104254245758,
-0.6109390258789062,
0.09632629156112671,
0.14298582077026367,
0.2035166174173355,
-0.11020343750715256,
0.8634629249572754,
-0.4209049940109253,
0.028402328491210938,
-0.472928524017334,
0.26922181248664856,
0.2795204222202301,
0.4418838322162628,
0.39045533537864685,
-0.8756709098815918,
-0.3822750151157379,
0.03645657002925873,
-0.5455586314201355,
-0.21469277143478394,
0.12218067795038223,
-0.2242383062839508,
-0.2698126435279846,
0.7616352438926697,
-0.43017318844795227,
0.3826921880245209,
0.6988403797149658,
-0.47600284218788147,
0.14212678372859955,
0.010058799758553505,
-0.1142980307340622,
-0.9575231075286865,
0.0019189071608707309,
-0.077566958963871,
-0.33400189876556396,
-0.969085156917572,
0.08686822652816772,
-0.08715958148241043,
0.011573715135455132,
-0.40446096658706665,
0.8166728019714355,
-0.28707155585289,
-0.33346500992774963,
-0.36427047848701477,
0.02699555642902851,
0.056411951780319214,
0.5452194809913635,
-0.0379212461411953,
0.7694433927536011,
0.7500112056732178,
-0.6135059595108032,
0.46562883257865906,
-0.209611177444458,
-0.28441014885902405,
0.3630155026912689,
-0.6561762094497681,
0.24890771508216858,
-0.1982787847518921,
0.19702962040901184,
-1.187132716178894,
-0.31998857855796814,
0.24462047219276428,
-0.4201190769672394,
0.2943389117717743,
-0.27260133624076843,
-0.8333473801612854,
-0.16887657344341278,
0.06853001564741135,
0.5023636817932129,
0.42331475019454956,
-0.4884258508682251,
0.6324600577354431,
0.8898752331733704,
-0.17197395861148834,
-0.33483603596687317,
-0.8704838156700134,
0.15482984483242035,
-0.3325105309486389,
-0.631942868232727,
0.09070935100317001,
-0.024146169424057007,
-0.40772292017936707,
-0.06181091442704201,
0.32899168133735657,
-0.5798631310462952,
0.3087417483329773,
0.4046485424041748,
-0.14004503190517426,
-0.3161661624908447,
0.20626668632030487,
0.03749717026948929,
-0.03561908379197121,
0.07957688719034195,
-0.5658437609672546,
0.5252096056938171,
-0.08123958855867386,
-0.4982406795024872,
-0.4983389973640442,
0.4362547695636749,
0.9171212315559387,
-0.1581888347864151,
0.6886276602745056,
0.5042847990989685,
-0.5696570873260498,
0.17252494394779205,
-0.3802748918533325,
-0.10608455538749695,
-0.4719656705856323,
0.13911454379558563,
-0.3159147799015045,
-0.6653114557266235,
0.6417809128761292,
-0.2915074825286865,
0.09314869344234467,
0.5057314038276672,
0.5985384583473206,
-0.010622657835483551,
1.0154986381530762,
1.0514585971832275,
-0.21978600323200226,
0.5308911800384521,
-0.0970153734087944,
0.44563475251197815,
-0.9043559432029724,
-0.20565858483314514,
-0.49214738607406616,
-0.3328772783279419,
-0.5679647326469421,
-0.4805004298686981,
0.2387748658657074,
0.33104926347732544,
-0.1098489761352539,
0.5164312124252319,
-0.24165494740009308,
0.4896519184112549,
0.643048882484436,
-0.31035536527633667,
0.3717459738254547,
0.22908683121204376,
-0.19237753748893738,
0.18487593531608582,
-0.8765552639961243,
-0.5173212289810181,
1.0526132583618164,
0.5729088187217712,
0.764442503452301,
0.05203130468726158,
0.38850998878479004,
0.3736771047115326,
0.5626738667488098,
-0.8349024653434753,
0.3489334285259247,
-0.005854001734405756,
-0.5896486043930054,
-0.47420111298561096,
-0.2839927673339844,
-0.8820342421531677,
0.0230194553732872,
0.2595376670360565,
-1.1013323068618774,
0.14678123593330383,
0.35464099049568176,
-0.07589561492204666,
0.6294479370117188,
-0.7076630592346191,
0.7327654957771301,
0.108991838991642,
-0.0633358284831047,
-0.22628548741340637,
-0.611011803150177,
0.16813622415065765,
-0.1130276545882225,
0.48681968450546265,
0.059294674545526505,
-0.03500153124332428,
0.8858811259269714,
-0.2934683859348297,
0.9524738192558289,
0.007367387413978577,
-0.14385868608951569,
0.5252323150634766,
0.1475011259317398,
0.6440002918243408,
-0.4320489168167114,
-0.393229216337204,
0.4083884060382843,
-0.3094538152217865,
-0.20234838128089905,
-0.5967991948127747,
0.5592243671417236,
-0.6370713710784912,
-0.3840397000312805,
-0.023082518950104713,
-0.4422447085380554,
-0.04984111338853836,
0.324781596660614,
0.27317166328430176,
0.6433560848236084,
0.25754478573799133,
-0.04354728385806084,
0.449321448802948,
0.11830542236566544,
0.38116079568862915,
0.30209875106811523,
-0.26012882590293884,
-0.09158837050199509,
0.8396477103233337,
0.06477683037519455,
0.447307288646698,
0.4390052556991577,
0.31401386857032776,
-0.34603315591812134,
-0.6077298521995544,
-0.6262276768684387,
0.35675138235092163,
-1.0674123764038086,
-0.09558064490556717,
-0.6866356730461121,
-0.28844836354255676,
-0.3720018267631531,
0.1246209517121315,
-0.4466899335384369,
-0.7781203985214233,
-0.22587302327156067,
-0.22907030582427979,
0.382302463054657,
1.1544790267944336,
-0.2069397121667862,
0.593144953250885,
-0.46907106041908264,
-0.06618200242519379,
0.19994735717773438,
0.3231019079685211,
0.265996515750885,
-0.5898827314376831,
-0.3598642647266388,
-0.24485205113887787,
-0.2633688151836395,
-0.975482165813446,
0.1362985223531723,
0.1604047268629074,
0.5167388916015625,
0.5012797117233276,
-0.24336585402488708,
0.6827589273452759,
-0.7627795338630676,
0.8553586602210999,
0.24220937490463257,
-0.9431078433990479,
0.6580553650856018,
-0.16092868149280548,
0.09510014206171036,
0.21343958377838135,
0.27526023983955383,
-0.6402568221092224,
-0.6048950552940369,
-0.5251284241676331,
-0.7922797799110413,
0.6393680572509766,
0.237714946269989,
0.012881224974989891,
-0.009897109121084213,
0.4789597988128662,
-0.0693344697356224,
0.31819483637809753,
-0.6813860535621643,
-0.3867845833301544,
-0.09805995970964432,
-0.24099157750606537,
0.21520423889160156,
-0.15728631615638733,
-0.09832566231489182,
-0.07432837039232254,
0.31094464659690857,
-0.13462775945663452,
0.5038648843765259,
-0.11023328453302383,
0.03604718670248985,
-0.2679087221622467,
-0.027179153636097908,
0.6230835914611816,
1.0718516111373901,
0.21047188341617584,
0.3326163589954376,
-0.173984095454216,
-0.345246821641922,
0.07702165096998215,
-0.3611372113227844,
-0.05924149975180626,
0.09085206687450409,
0.7403293251991272,
1.0551115274429321,
-0.00597509928047657,
-0.5574057102203369,
0.4761973023414612,
0.06411156803369522,
0.1474676877260208,
-0.15538254380226135,
0.13657553493976593,
0.19566766917705536,
0.4569319486618042,
0.1739214062690735,
0.06047411262989044,
0.417298823595047,
-0.6480190753936768,
0.13564996421337128,
0.06802550703287125,
-0.6233841180801392,
-0.5331993699073792,
0.5879610180854797,
-0.019666871055960655,
-0.6056956648826599,
0.5276941061019897,
-0.09536087512969971,
-0.5272042155265808,
0.7187498211860657,
0.5562781095504761,
0.8775903582572937,
-0.2436995953321457,
0.12539365887641907,
0.4091612696647644,
0.40349081158638,
0.020059162750840187,
0.0678439736366272,
-0.05733024328947067,
-0.4624108672142029,
-0.5063457489013672,
-0.5616294741630554,
-0.4001525938510895,
0.05487050116062164,
-0.6686164736747742,
0.11136685311794281,
-0.38403648138046265,
-0.21333225071430206,
0.10310518741607666,
-0.48984503746032715,
-0.7284218072891235,
0.13631252944469452,
0.23400552570819855,
1.303486704826355,
-0.9454835057258606,
1.0220887660980225,
0.9550484418869019,
-0.25210896134376526,
-0.852480947971344,
0.026652783155441284,
0.07948669046163559,
-0.9418640732765198,
1.03605055809021,
-0.013867185451090336,
-0.23416361212730408,
0.1836925745010376,
-0.28758326172828674,
-1.3409926891326904,
1.0933866500854492,
0.3038652837276459,
-0.32236167788505554,
-0.34713509678840637,
0.09915152192115784,
0.3560199439525604,
-0.6177652478218079,
0.3808329999446869,
0.4224473834037781,
0.406838059425354,
0.31832680106163025,
-1.0959066152572632,
0.0526457279920578,
-0.2261519879102707,
-0.05052685737609863,
0.10494507849216461,
-0.48640570044517517,
1.1033763885498047,
-0.20051421225070953,
-0.19019490480422974,
-0.21451663970947266,
0.48791393637657166,
-0.07476376742124557,
0.044704217463731766,
0.7849186062812805,
0.30351918935775757,
0.9606879949569702,
0.08909297734498978,
1.162373423576355,
-0.36116981506347656,
0.10111967474222183,
0.9947262406349182,
0.09838025271892548,
0.8677740693092346,
0.6766639947891235,
-0.10669323801994324,
0.7413037419319153,
0.7211838960647583,
0.6191269755363464,
0.8195704221725464,
0.4335332214832306,
0.1651887595653534,
-0.09956511110067368,
-0.20891627669334412,
-0.06461974233388901,
0.47368067502975464,
0.4949778914451599,
-0.3061332702636719,
-0.37165307998657227,
0.025592047721147537,
0.142469123005867,
-0.362481027841568,
-0.5327187180519104,
0.7486799359321594,
0.16661545634269714,
-0.7202072143554688,
0.31545957922935486,
0.2205844521522522,
0.14880366623401642,
-0.6149322986602783,
-0.14021554589271545,
-0.19567091763019562,
-0.020734203979372978,
-0.14529083669185638,
-0.8751218914985657,
0.5667980313301086,
0.16412271559238434,
-0.21553416550159454,
-0.273017942905426,
0.7023336291313171,
-0.19359329342842102,
-0.31230026483535767,
0.4184037148952484,
0.2880162298679352,
0.4938870370388031,
-0.11053258925676346,
-0.7153851389884949,
0.2639004588127136,
0.0036583878099918365,
-0.5223943591117859,
0.24431651830673218,
0.7655961513519287,
-0.20070262253284454,
0.9797770977020264,
0.494818776845932,
0.45646101236343384,
0.3456524610519409,
0.2227124273777008,
0.9846624135971069,
-0.5354322195053101,
-0.5984620451927185,
-0.9170454144477844,
0.5596188902854919,
-0.23655205965042114,
-0.16287653148174286,
0.40735360980033875,
0.25277385115623474,
0.5401835441589355,
0.29592493176460266,
0.7481881380081177,
0.09584859013557434,
0.49814116954803467,
-0.6791087985038757,
0.4477328956127167,
-0.6331910490989685,
0.36497756838798523,
-0.002668461063876748,
-0.6675251126289368,
-0.1426009088754654,
0.598304033279419,
-0.0847681313753128,
-0.29108601808547974,
0.6879404187202454,
0.6635057926177979,
-0.24920743703842163,
-0.15127252042293549,
0.05380028486251831,
0.14958986639976501,
0.4089927673339844,
0.43681082129478455,
0.5754476189613342,
-0.3131393492221832,
0.49849632382392883,
-0.09550835937261581,
-0.4174947440624237,
-0.264879435300827,
-1.1281825304031372,
-0.8352186679840088,
-0.6974869966506958,
-0.4140948951244354,
-0.2675116956233978,
-0.20927564799785614,
0.6400841474533081,
0.931950569152832,
-0.6975356340408325,
-0.47569382190704346,
-0.3613174259662628,
0.4607656002044678,
-0.20299819111824036,
-0.17427729070186615,
0.3061171770095825,
-0.37855902314186096,
-0.49351704120635986,
0.2703571021556854,
0.5473101735115051,
-0.07427088171243668,
-0.5721497535705566,
0.11295229941606522,
-0.017700476571917534,
0.272245854139328,
0.5245763063430786,
0.32175496220588684,
-0.6834650039672852,
-0.15984264016151428,
-0.08605904877185822,
-0.10180730372667313,
0.10334592312574387,
1.1207438707351685,
-0.5462652444839478,
0.4208495616912842,
0.5995612740516663,
0.6676350235939026,
0.40341100096702576,
-0.09381242841482162,
0.7836570143699646,
-0.5324767827987671,
0.15390177071094513,
0.0010353493271395564,
0.33454596996307373,
0.4159066081047058,
-0.29470503330230713,
0.5692235231399536,
0.15538489818572998,
-0.3227117359638214,
-0.912094235420227,
0.5655848383903503,
-0.6964722275733948,
-0.11522205919027328,
1.3686771392822266,
-0.3972737491130829,
-0.4965091645717621,
-0.1416342705488205,
0.07651662081480026,
0.17131803929805756,
-0.04394175484776497,
0.5066397786140442,
0.8243119716644287,
-0.2456919401884079,
-0.1977916955947876,
-0.8346641063690186,
0.5325779914855957,
-0.15351808071136475,
-0.7174965739250183,
0.1951286941766739,
0.0223004799336195,
0.31633350253105164,
0.38080111145973206,
1.0000871419906616,
-0.04847446829080582,
-0.15952982008457184,
-0.0910797268152237,
-0.22710704803466797,
-0.027721421793103218,
-0.5811013579368591,
-0.1225569024682045,
-0.022745124995708466,
0.23542137444019318,
-0.1605294644832611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17097v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17097v2
|
Re-Ex: Revising after Explanation Reduces the Factual Errors in LLM Responses
| 2024-02-27T00:22:18 | 2024-04-12T11:37:44 |
Juyeon Kim, Jeongeun Lee, Yoonho Chang, Chanyeol Choi, Junseong Kim, Jy-yong Sohn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Mitigating hallucination issues is a key challenge that must be overcome to
reliably deploy large language models (LLMs) in real-world scenarios. Recently,
various methods have been proposed to detect and revise factual errors in
LLM-generated texts, in order to reduce hallucination. In this paper, we
propose Re-Ex, a method for post-editing LLM-generated responses. Re-Ex
introduces a novel reasoning step dubbed as the factual error explanation step.
Re-Ex revises the initial response of LLMs using 3-steps : first, external
tools are used to retrieve the evidences of the factual errors in the initial
LLM response; next, LLM is instructed to explain the problematic parts of the
response based on the gathered evidence; finally, LLM revises the initial
response using the explanations provided in the previous step. In addition to
the explanation step, Re-Ex also incorporates new prompting techniques to
reduce the token count and inference time required for the response revision
process. Compared with existing methods including FacTool, CoVE, and RARR,
Re-Ex provides better detection and revision performance with less inference
time and fewer tokens in multiple benchmarks.
|
[
-0.27890804409980774,
-1.007067322731018,
0.700363039970398,
-0.07822727411985397,
-0.39733192324638367,
0.03398332744836807,
-0.19395413994789124,
-0.29331615567207336,
0.30961060523986816,
0.7212222814559937,
-0.9199962615966797,
-0.4019574224948883,
-0.3394297957420349,
0.41227906942367554,
-0.4184776246547699,
0.9876096248626709,
-0.3431030809879303,
-0.1934785097837448,
-0.24485987424850464,
0.05319162458181381,
-0.5626752376556396,
-0.37938299775123596,
-0.888444721698761,
-0.15663295984268188,
0.6880951523780823,
0.5001706480979919,
0.5074763298034668,
0.41392308473587036,
0.3258970081806183,
0.3322322964668274,
-0.07807037979364395,
0.34219062328338623,
-0.5643141865730286,
0.2721029818058014,
-0.2512218654155731,
-0.6774151921272278,
-0.593535304069519,
-0.14146563410758972,
0.6553699374198914,
0.6424707174301147,
-0.10107804089784622,
0.11570260673761368,
-0.12939900159835815,
0.6722480058670044,
-0.518071711063385,
-0.11392723768949509,
-0.7096762657165527,
0.06836290657520294,
0.3594709634780884,
-0.6204820275306702,
-0.799380362033844,
-0.5260025858879089,
-0.12894469499588013,
-0.6431685090065002,
0.7223178744316101,
0.05243391916155815,
0.6855942606925964,
0.4987673759460449,
-0.07774880528450012,
-0.12717357277870178,
-0.8657238483428955,
0.5662856101989746,
-0.8728640675544739,
0.6014696359634399,
-0.07318398356437683,
0.12220797687768936,
-0.4577540457248688,
-0.8674103021621704,
-0.9383745789527893,
-0.10870625078678131,
-0.202771857380867,
-0.060262568295001984,
0.05124613270163536,
-0.1618730127811432,
0.40319931507110596,
0.318184494972229,
-0.4823266863822937,
-0.15534701943397522,
-0.2369450181722641,
-0.49789586663246155,
0.5195288062095642,
0.18105773627758026,
0.07736773788928986,
0.043417032808065414,
-0.23487520217895508,
-0.09617146849632263,
-0.9834515452384949,
-0.14268720149993896,
0.11457086354494095,
0.09231729805469513,
0.35144171118736267,
0.6206462979316711,
-0.18324118852615356,
0.36604997515678406,
0.18762844800949097,
-0.14165788888931274,
0.3398975133895874,
-0.5610891580581665,
-0.4774271845817566,
0.17275357246398926,
0.30643248558044434,
0.4084814488887787,
-0.049611326307058334,
-0.03199426457285881,
-0.45014771819114685,
0.030051127076148987,
0.32147058844566345,
-0.666516900062561,
-0.008915050886571407,
0.4136222302913666,
-0.5330671072006226,
-0.22158032655715942,
-0.2717512249946594,
-0.8714601397514343,
-0.5104169845581055,
-0.5676683187484741,
0.33294668793678284,
-0.27588608860969543,
-0.27398568391799927,
0.4286527931690216,
0.08801047503948212,
0.21798722445964813,
0.9620476961135864,
-0.5098770260810852,
0.19752028584480286,
0.8296281099319458,
0.549353837966919,
0.13669832050800323,
-0.2947837710380554,
-0.7370026707649231,
0.027646508067846298,
-0.42575952410697937,
1.0966334342956543,
-0.39281031489372253,
-0.384554922580719,
0.03727149963378906,
0.22490964829921722,
0.07676480710506439,
-0.5087021589279175,
0.8404589891433716,
-0.6930192708969116,
0.42528730630874634,
-0.5005014538764954,
-0.40963253378868103,
-0.46958768367767334,
0.3956283628940582,
-0.5521389842033386,
0.9061954617500305,
-0.0838627964258194,
-0.8292540311813354,
0.510952889919281,
-0.33986327052116394,
-0.43881532549858093,
-0.4218147099018097,
0.059689633548259735,
-0.43179967999458313,
0.44718289375305176,
0.4130878448486328,
0.11431318521499634,
-0.08366771042346954,
0.08909095078706741,
-0.004785690922290087,
-0.6347694993019104,
0.26173415780067444,
-0.4145349860191345,
0.6175904870033264,
0.021382786333560944,
-0.40903767943382263,
0.43062400817871094,
-0.7853095531463623,
-0.09777335822582245,
0.10658624768257141,
-0.426852822303772,
-0.01104717142879963,
0.07310360670089722,
-0.4342290163040161,
0.14607693254947662,
0.18315377831459045,
-0.6526364088058472,
0.15278147161006927,
-0.48012563586235046,
0.035784054547548294,
0.8361288905143738,
0.14315421879291534,
0.0634232684969902,
-0.34807026386260986,
0.46558648347854614,
-0.11765331029891968,
0.1307835578918457,
-0.4764508008956909,
-0.43822142481803894,
-0.9247884750366211,
-0.04439738020300865,
0.04226454347372055,
0.566594123840332,
-0.881681501865387,
0.253376841545105,
-0.42803385853767395,
-0.2354406863451004,
-0.7226817607879639,
-0.01292636152356863,
0.4215605556964874,
0.6356788277626038,
0.5032670497894287,
0.13627409934997559,
-0.9204261302947998,
-0.6979522705078125,
-0.534684956073761,
-0.5109385848045349,
0.0860089510679245,
0.02664187364280224,
0.5589244961738586,
-0.4215734302997589,
0.8371706604957581,
-0.4629305899143219,
0.14466388523578644,
-0.27898961305618286,
0.38049760460853577,
-0.05748908221721649,
0.23036973178386688,
0.06932761520147324,
-0.6344435811042786,
-0.12411488592624664,
-0.10684280842542648,
-0.6893146634101868,
-0.5010905861854553,
-0.6350449919700623,
0.05818327143788338,
0.6923462152481079,
0.7480077147483826,
-0.6780155897140503,
0.671288251876831,
0.12007784843444824,
-0.23840047419071198,
0.9459837675094604,
-0.3257850706577301,
0.5475894212722778,
-0.716237485408783,
-0.1284496784210205,
-0.42002180218696594,
-0.25105082988739014,
-0.41114792227745056,
0.18706901371479034,
-0.15999990701675415,
0.050517261028289795,
-0.2977074384689331,
0.28317877650260925,
-0.5461392998695374,
-0.04038101062178612,
-0.441879004240036,
0.43393391370773315,
0.14300169050693512,
0.4417453706264496,
0.039628006517887115,
0.554865837097168,
0.13876791298389435,
-0.44323647022247314,
0.45201826095581055,
0.3402929902076721,
-0.03425302356481552,
0.3207066059112549,
-0.5818471312522888,
0.32130998373031616,
-0.46650221943855286,
0.455291748046875,
-1.4956623315811157,
-0.09378105401992798,
0.6113495826721191,
-0.6425782442092896,
0.2573162019252777,
-0.041373588144779205,
-0.4788821041584015,
-0.301249235868454,
-0.5783885717391968,
0.21893683075904846,
0.22939081490039825,
-0.7438184022903442,
0.795732855796814,
-0.20590975880622864,
-0.17474620044231415,
-0.5967453122138977,
-0.6120349168777466,
0.34785059094429016,
-0.07781804352998734,
-0.7167630791664124,
0.37400534749031067,
-0.09612300992012024,
-0.39299070835113525,
0.0840236023068428,
-0.26801198720932007,
0.25566333532333374,
0.05287209525704384,
-0.09420710802078247,
0.20038382709026337,
-0.2841813266277313,
0.028383074328303337,
0.1554412543773651,
-0.3461587429046631,
0.4650264084339142,
0.2674376666545868,
0.4484688341617584,
0.21816270053386688,
-0.38919585943222046,
-0.7321186661720276,
0.3567386865615845,
0.7649374008178711,
-0.04491632431745529,
0.8186057806015015,
0.4395402669906616,
-0.4684354364871979,
-0.064215749502182,
-0.8292719721794128,
-0.5226553082466125,
-0.42672237753868103,
0.342633992433548,
-0.47558721899986267,
-0.5931553840637207,
0.3857317268848419,
-0.11095747351646423,
0.4586351215839386,
0.16780443489551544,
0.48843538761138916,
0.056061696261167526,
0.7821899652481079,
0.35821548104286194,
0.3715786039829254,
0.22368404269218445,
0.2488471120595932,
0.71433424949646,
-0.9010811448097229,
-0.368369460105896,
-0.4122880697250366,
-0.17180803418159485,
-0.2788209617137909,
-0.5370277166366577,
-0.03965134918689728,
-0.1919693946838379,
0.11466702073812485,
0.18156838417053223,
-0.24685856699943542,
0.2756967544555664,
0.1488887518644333,
0.1804398149251938,
0.4177187979221344,
0.11633507162332535,
0.20486655831336975,
-0.1539437621831894,
-0.3835025131702423,
-0.5717725157737732,
0.8335072994232178,
0.3165414035320282,
0.8361548185348511,
0.25500643253326416,
0.7992926836013794,
0.12212403118610382,
0.6665078401565552,
-0.7604974508285522,
0.8429862856864929,
0.36245012283325195,
-0.36652904748916626,
-0.28210529685020447,
-0.45421236753463745,
-0.6458799242973328,
0.49828118085861206,
-0.43137070536613464,
-0.4985853135585785,
0.10359063744544983,
0.19181036949157715,
-0.5063791871070862,
0.4239071309566498,
-0.7394205331802368,
0.5425175428390503,
0.02410997450351715,
-0.45175907015800476,
-0.41597288846969604,
-0.4823977053165436,
0.5966346859931946,
-0.27018019556999207,
0.2875019907951355,
0.41034790873527527,
-0.1079370528459549,
0.7158033847808838,
-0.5348213911056519,
0.8619266748428345,
-0.32471659779548645,
-0.3697340488433838,
0.31917163729667664,
0.4089391827583313,
0.8973151445388794,
0.08219881355762482,
-0.017323819920420647,
-0.3651800751686096,
-0.1702735424041748,
0.12434850633144379,
-1.0197436809539795,
0.6223266124725342,
-0.26115912199020386,
-1.181943655014038,
-0.2378767877817154,
-0.37444955110549927,
0.014798067510128021,
-0.12996426224708557,
0.17080499231815338,
0.42287907004356384,
-0.04490125924348831,
0.17631244659423828,
0.7835680246353149,
-0.6554877161979675,
0.19601193070411682,
0.6795757412910461,
-0.621909499168396,
-0.3243210017681122,
0.4908760190010071,
0.06579216569662094,
0.19899161159992218,
0.33494219183921814,
0.08158405125141144,
-0.49237293004989624,
-0.7380638718605042,
-0.1383754312992096,
0.4775030314922333,
-0.861392080783844,
-0.04115458205342293,
-0.9406151175498962,
0.12434663623571396,
-0.7125914692878723,
-0.19454042613506317,
-0.29702726006507874,
-0.3502032458782196,
-0.11921843886375427,
-0.3612244129180908,
0.28969213366508484,
0.5493510365486145,
-0.3259817361831665,
0.2785656452178955,
-0.6683562397956848,
0.6482699513435364,
-0.013069555163383484,
0.12066133320331573,
0.10059230029582977,
-1.0598633289337158,
-0.13241705298423767,
0.1717802882194519,
0.05217580497264862,
-0.9637542366981506,
0.3061363101005554,
-0.07920701801776886,
0.4710853695869446,
0.23877327144145966,
-0.05644518509507179,
0.905023455619812,
-0.6104803085327148,
0.7813653349876404,
-0.07604356110095978,
-0.9550760984420776,
0.6162532567977905,
0.11977451294660568,
-0.15849615633487701,
0.33236008882522583,
0.13490068912506104,
-0.7351502776145935,
-0.26828059554100037,
-0.5287016034126282,
-0.8596345782279968,
0.4944678544998169,
0.09022650122642517,
0.05326570197939873,
-0.13753563165664673,
0.8010811805725098,
0.24562197923660278,
0.08585377037525177,
-0.6288281083106995,
-0.23150265216827393,
-0.047292400151491165,
0.25640004873275757,
0.10227158665657043,
-0.7767796516418457,
-0.12524716556072235,
-0.33954504132270813,
0.9726219177246094,
0.0626385435461998,
0.3560735583305359,
0.6799229979515076,
-0.36891359090805054,
-0.23247942328453064,
0.31956300139427185,
0.9093607068061829,
0.6841158270835876,
-0.26655521988868713,
0.3442266285419464,
0.3478285074234009,
-0.3035896420478821,
0.1788526028394699,
-0.2764909267425537,
-0.014742132276296616,
0.29328224062919617,
0.5809728503227234,
0.4786628782749176,
0.2362280935049057,
-0.6090341806411743,
0.25485411286354065,
-0.1711960881948471,
-0.0846976712346077,
-0.21782562136650085,
-0.09990227967500687,
-0.01504892110824585,
0.055151328444480896,
0.22825950384140015,
0.07822782546281815,
0.036496181041002274,
-0.6657772064208984,
0.4638993442058563,
0.05948635935783386,
0.03435991331934929,
-0.4212070405483246,
0.6299390196800232,
0.030255572870373726,
-0.4219506084918976,
0.5547828674316406,
-0.27195820212364197,
-0.608562707901001,
0.3822564482688904,
0.7511148452758789,
0.9467211961746216,
-0.4050730764865875,
0.34311607480049133,
0.5971556305885315,
0.5343614816665649,
0.09727205336093903,
0.39316824078559875,
0.26746484637260437,
-0.9472822546958923,
-0.8154968023300171,
-0.1032339408993721,
-0.3215489983558655,
0.1252436637878418,
-0.6190519332885742,
0.14812472462654114,
-0.6964868307113647,
0.1324363648891449,
-0.2554853856563568,
-0.32975804805755615,
-0.2612922787666321,
0.36774393916130066,
0.03671833127737045,
0.9591646790504456,
-0.8017789125442505,
0.370730996131897,
0.5072215795516968,
-0.3490096926689148,
-0.5282290577888489,
0.17899787425994873,
0.27597299218177795,
-0.7750035524368286,
0.6356098651885986,
0.10646012425422668,
-0.4492744505405426,
-0.22496739029884338,
-0.5295817852020264,
-0.6385639905929565,
0.8093385696411133,
0.30988672375679016,
-0.5920799374580383,
0.3188169002532959,
-0.0252725537866354,
0.6047173142433167,
-0.13926038146018982,
0.1889122724533081,
0.8077170848846436,
0.5408205389976501,
0.19543373584747314,
-0.4500635266304016,
0.5374624133110046,
-0.07046691328287125,
-0.2747999131679535,
0.025950482115149498,
-0.19922669231891632,
0.7594070434570312,
-0.6211317777633667,
-0.3546290099620819,
0.11937054246664047,
0.906410276889801,
0.398225337266922,
0.2627025842666626,
0.7327470183372498,
0.691716194152832,
1.033890724182129,
-0.11612534523010254,
0.9498136639595032,
-0.03316676244139671,
0.24247576296329498,
1.3784288167953491,
-0.5021985769271851,
0.7709414958953857,
0.7868912220001221,
-0.06574095040559769,
0.7665987014770508,
0.7674427032470703,
0.23021496832370758,
0.3322336673736572,
0.2754811644554138,
-0.47780776023864746,
-0.2728254795074463,
-0.005718943662941456,
-0.44834133982658386,
0.13951346278190613,
0.2681244909763336,
-0.13663144409656525,
-0.2784576714038849,
-0.03700153902173042,
0.3548634946346283,
0.03195394575595856,
-0.22231845557689667,
0.5205796360969543,
-0.20822294056415558,
-0.7250020503997803,
0.6947712302207947,
-0.012431065551936626,
0.40654346346855164,
-0.15783372521400452,
-0.31455013155937195,
-0.6173690557479858,
0.2054820954799652,
-0.41566333174705505,
-0.7762654423713684,
0.6723766326904297,
0.15397556126117706,
-0.2869092524051666,
-0.25901907682418823,
0.5919564962387085,
-0.34752213954925537,
-0.32659608125686646,
0.26960480213165283,
0.30703604221343994,
0.3554420471191406,
-0.3181559145450592,
-0.6247036457061768,
0.3295234143733978,
0.3901165723800659,
-0.41960978507995605,
-0.2595131993293762,
0.8361251354217529,
0.03158141300082207,
0.7755134701728821,
0.7857055068016052,
-0.10886308550834656,
0.05190685763955116,
0.18114377558231354,
0.9046998620033264,
-0.7513067126274109,
-0.16719794273376465,
-0.8610190749168396,
0.6453501582145691,
-0.005697472486644983,
0.06297136098146439,
0.5589336156845093,
0.4907929301261902,
0.6561543345451355,
-0.18364942073822021,
0.7217226028442383,
0.13223198056221008,
0.659648597240448,
-0.7538521885871887,
0.3241880238056183,
-0.5904861092567444,
0.6317126750946045,
-0.20973514020442963,
-0.8541643023490906,
-0.4791334569454193,
0.5810997486114502,
-0.3295637369155884,
-0.06179878115653992,
1.1520111560821533,
1.2133986949920654,
0.321696013212204,
0.1177457794547081,
0.23575402796268463,
0.6694682836532593,
0.5065976977348328,
0.306322306394577,
0.884032666683197,
-0.6074230074882507,
0.5233070254325867,
-0.039068061858415604,
-0.17690473794937134,
-0.25325828790664673,
-0.8756353855133057,
-0.6768373250961304,
-0.2725171446800232,
-0.6987033486366272,
-0.5867049694061279,
0.0007598274969495833,
0.915952205657959,
-0.01402051467448473,
-0.805851399898529,
0.271812379360199,
-0.008225205354392529,
0.43537330627441406,
-0.2801721394062042,
-0.2434925138950348,
0.39002132415771484,
-0.37949636578559875,
-0.4974696636199951,
0.5227294564247131,
0.26192477345466614,
-0.14158415794372559,
-0.11476437747478485,
0.04006916284561157,
-0.23895272612571716,
0.19898776710033417,
0.7149296402931213,
0.14376209676265717,
-0.9396612048149109,
-0.8211067914962769,
0.04829811304807663,
0.2150311917066574,
0.17839573323726654,
1.007481575012207,
-0.9447470307350159,
0.48284220695495605,
0.6698810458183289,
0.6779460906982422,
0.18797165155410767,
-0.0857585072517395,
0.5380747318267822,
-0.513205885887146,
-0.03465498611330986,
-0.10370754450559616,
0.6337714791297913,
0.5054295659065247,
-0.5296163558959961,
0.5638266205787659,
0.6284814476966858,
-0.34041628241539,
-1.0826092958450317,
0.15078727900981903,
-0.8404857516288757,
-0.3097226321697235,
1.0702320337295532,
-0.21638484299182892,
-0.31333446502685547,
-0.298637330532074,
-0.6926114559173584,
0.44674941897392273,
-0.04549999162554741,
1.050481915473938,
0.7033658623695374,
-0.022507131099700928,
-0.5399144291877747,
-0.26427891850471497,
0.3937925696372986,
0.5039453506469727,
-0.927608847618103,
0.5785322189331055,
0.5489209890365601,
0.31347745656967163,
0.10015662014484406,
0.520748496055603,
-0.27195295691490173,
0.38830217719078064,
0.11869096755981445,
0.18024614453315735,
-0.04048505425453186,
-0.4581368565559387,
-0.23873411118984222,
-0.23404258489608765,
-0.20162975788116455,
-0.21244993805885315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00823v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00823v1
|
Adapting to Teammates in a Cooperative Language Game
| 2024-02-26T23:15:07 | 2024-02-26T23:15:07 |
Christopher Archibald, Spencer Brosnahan
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The game of Codenames has recently emerged as a domain of interest for
intelligent agent design. The game is unique due to the way that language and
coordination between teammates play important roles. Previous approaches to
designing agents for this game have utilized a single internal language model
to determine action choices. This often leads to good performance with some
teammates and inferior performance with other teammates, as the agent cannot
adapt to any specific teammate. In this paper we present the first adaptive
agent for playing Codenames. We adopt an ensemble approach with the goal of
determining, during the course of interacting with a specific teammate, which
of our internal expert agents, each potentially with its own language model, is
the best match. One difficulty faced in this approach is the lack of a single
numerical metric that accurately captures the performance of a Codenames team.
Prior Codenames research has utilized a handful of different metrics to
evaluate agent teams. We propose a novel single metric to evaluate the
performance of a Codenames team, whether playing a single team (solitaire)
game, or a competitive game against another team. We then present and analyze
an ensemble agent which selects an internal expert on each turn in order to
maximize this proposed metric. Experimental analysis shows that this ensemble
approach adapts to individual teammates and often performs nearly as well as
the best internal expert with a teammate. Crucially, this success does not
depend on any previous knowledge about the teammates, the ensemble agents, or
their compatibility. This research represents an important step to making
language-based agents for cooperative language settings like Codenames more
adaptable to individual teammates.
|
[
-0.3495412766933441,
-0.2316799908876419,
0.2316192239522934,
0.5723329782485962,
0.0333397313952446,
0.9318283200263977,
-0.4928096532821655,
-0.48712456226348877,
0.45091500878334045,
0.27149248123168945,
-0.2660713791847229,
-0.40629857778549194,
-0.44235777854919434,
0.25980037450790405,
0.09618061780929565,
1.1499613523483276,
-0.034973833709955215,
-0.13723908364772797,
-0.164505735039711,
-0.6221727728843689,
-0.7531265616416931,
-0.24608324468135834,
-1.0152329206466675,
-0.2225651741027832,
0.2404814511537552,
0.6528692841529846,
0.7169356346130371,
0.33502358198165894,
0.585821270942688,
0.555717945098877,
0.3997277021408081,
0.05465016886591911,
-0.5191653370857239,
0.3621726632118225,
-0.2908179461956024,
-0.6769760251045227,
-0.5196234583854675,
-0.2762635350227356,
0.6732625365257263,
0.17950376868247986,
0.015113425441086292,
0.23017391562461853,
-0.07273609936237335,
0.6645023226737976,
-0.3141638934612274,
0.3775142431259155,
-0.7328166365623474,
0.11409314721822739,
0.09401855617761612,
-0.419893741607666,
-0.3876284956932068,
-0.3681811988353729,
0.1166752353310585,
-0.9880384206771851,
0.02814438007771969,
-0.039548493921756744,
0.268527626991272,
0.3247920274734497,
0.1949503868818283,
-0.4225463271141052,
-0.5025222301483154,
0.5251789093017578,
-0.4906356930732727,
-0.13648974895477295,
0.025680769234895706,
0.6115388870239258,
-0.2135995328426361,
-0.2945164740085602,
-0.0750747099518776,
-0.1654704213142395,
0.0012326326686888933,
0.38340243697166443,
-0.3557572364807129,
-0.04903491586446762,
-0.2101047933101654,
-0.029629966244101524,
-0.7018561959266663,
0.20712123811244965,
-0.21317058801651,
-0.34317612648010254,
1.0770756006240845,
0.28521984815597534,
0.45719462633132935,
0.7047907114028931,
-0.7042964696884155,
0.06269451230764389,
0.21606433391571045,
0.35282766819000244,
0.38051867485046387,
0.40329015254974365,
-0.25616398453712463,
-0.19281038641929626,
-0.06373963505029678,
0.4672427475452423,
0.39189597964286804,
-0.16974766552448273,
0.1373577117919922,
0.015332572162151337,
-0.0767769068479538,
0.4802475571632385,
0.7297812104225159,
0.391526460647583,
0.4529229998588562,
-0.794337809085846,
-0.292198121547699,
0.34045538306236267,
0.20240165293216705,
-0.490019291639328,
-0.6873568296432495,
0.10744361579418182,
-0.2826767861843109,
-0.58456951379776,
-0.04864562675356865,
-0.6996521353721619,
-0.3947034180164337,
0.13811182975769043,
0.6291599273681641,
-0.2993088662624359,
-0.35125887393951416,
-0.11463400721549988,
-0.48558950424194336,
0.16979902982711792,
0.29097098112106323,
-0.8184130787849426,
0.7555057406425476,
0.46323931217193604,
0.7030990719795227,
-0.43739986419677734,
-0.7414907217025757,
-0.5924442410469055,
-0.10844868421554565,
-0.6928685307502747,
1.1821616888046265,
-0.49451538920402527,
-0.46549537777900696,
-0.35606613755226135,
-0.1175471842288971,
-0.2475171834230423,
-0.4299941956996918,
-0.0038753272965550423,
-0.5861173272132874,
-0.0802539736032486,
-0.018089009448885918,
-0.5754454135894775,
0.11027969419956207,
0.1265944242477417,
-0.4155938923358917,
0.5911322832107544,
0.2846647799015045,
-0.4774307310581207,
0.40342044830322266,
-0.8582497239112854,
-0.32035523653030396,
0.7034852504730225,
-0.16590917110443115,
-0.06546913832426071,
0.03840912505984306,
-0.0485762283205986,
0.0992971882224083,
-0.02187257446348667,
-0.20828823745250702,
-0.263318806886673,
-0.5609292387962341,
0.42350491881370544,
0.15564016997814178,
0.5219400525093079,
0.10812535136938095,
0.02280702441930771,
0.37112683057785034,
-0.41582995653152466,
0.5964308381080627,
-0.04091920331120491,
-0.19376800954341888,
-0.35738375782966614,
0.2682275176048279,
-0.16559246182441711,
-0.04727962240576744,
0.016924863681197166,
-0.15400362014770508,
0.2959950566291809,
-0.21807552874088287,
0.13656197488307953,
1.1268155574798584,
-0.06374159455299377,
0.9974127411842346,
-0.7983731031417847,
0.8615687489509583,
-0.3450554311275482,
0.07756694406270981,
0.024358151480555534,
-0.40860670804977417,
-0.35839220881462097,
-0.5144425630569458,
0.39554691314697266,
0.5179955363273621,
-1.0516575574874878,
0.3568204939365387,
-0.27650147676467896,
-0.821739673614502,
-0.4226103723049164,
0.009339644573628902,
0.46688112616539,
-0.15270812809467316,
0.025080062448978424,
-0.8089614510536194,
-0.45533767342567444,
-0.6288856863975525,
-0.6425511240959167,
-0.6502715945243835,
0.13803812861442566,
0.40444454550743103,
0.2841689884662628,
0.06451133638620377,
0.9121766686439514,
-0.29286208748817444,
-0.3444427251815796,
-0.17726559937000275,
-0.07622436434030533,
0.046759381890296936,
0.412066251039505,
1.0276224613189697,
-0.5338644981384277,
-0.9600655436515808,
0.18966186046600342,
-0.6494997143745422,
-0.14242863655090332,
-0.16290996968746185,
-0.32541269063949585,
0.14583107829093933,
0.07844411581754684,
-0.0067330109886825085,
0.11138191819190979,
1.0530951023101807,
-0.801361083984375,
0.5500593781471252,
-0.34660014510154724,
0.2526854872703552,
-0.9836912751197815,
-0.03232813999056816,
-0.14084868133068085,
-0.2562025487422943,
-0.6222596764564514,
0.45699843764305115,
-0.3411385416984558,
0.3304762542247772,
-0.04172509163618088,
0.7299190759658813,
-0.5818155407905579,
-0.26131168007850647,
-0.3093508183956146,
0.3629271388053894,
-0.40207284688949585,
0.4782775938510895,
0.00035776899312622845,
0.8675662875175476,
0.9451106190681458,
-0.7223435640335083,
0.5354502201080322,
0.17617034912109375,
-0.3767980933189392,
0.8440419435501099,
-0.5476685166358948,
0.4650612473487854,
0.12220476567745209,
0.24000655114650726,
-0.9522067904472351,
-0.08021719753742218,
0.1647467315196991,
-0.8752768635749817,
0.0006009325734339654,
-0.1215994581580162,
-0.2571093440055847,
-0.1262623816728592,
-0.048207905143499374,
0.7133798003196716,
0.4743143916130066,
-0.4490477740764618,
0.5984357595443726,
0.5969115495681763,
-0.08528389781713486,
-0.1690717488527298,
-0.40266114473342896,
0.3654636740684509,
-0.3377026617527008,
-0.669566810131073,
0.4949239194393158,
-0.7698658108711243,
-0.5946967601776123,
-0.07579012960195541,
-0.1433642953634262,
-0.6331751346588135,
0.3569990396499634,
0.07779873162508011,
0.03775115683674812,
-0.4735916256904602,
0.41322171688079834,
-0.3587457537651062,
-0.318147212266922,
-0.1344662606716156,
-0.15728510916233063,
0.27132681012153625,
-0.3643057346343994,
0.517583429813385,
-0.1698431521654129,
0.3315773904323578,
0.6120065450668335,
-0.3767443299293518,
0.7022495865821838,
0.26716163754463196,
-0.07257319986820221,
-0.7092026472091675,
-0.2599320113658905,
0.060122691094875336,
-0.4701351523399353,
0.4794546067714691,
-0.5342763066291809,
-0.5698447227478027,
0.9430894255638123,
0.052662286907434464,
-0.099707692861557,
0.14429792761802673,
0.4972744286060333,
0.12182464450597763,
0.7592076063156128,
0.7758862376213074,
-0.4334873855113983,
0.25936293601989746,
0.2463025003671646,
-0.10362318158149719,
-0.5026914477348328,
0.03593367338180542,
-0.6765793561935425,
-0.5252132415771484,
-0.6993308067321777,
-0.4186764359474182,
0.34404534101486206,
-0.17606493830680847,
-0.24113944172859192,
0.6080693602561951,
-0.6803939938545227,
0.784546434879303,
0.12628021836280823,
0.22121714055538177,
0.23000161349773407,
-0.30693018436431885,
0.22945447266101837,
0.20408926904201508,
-0.7185347080230713,
-0.2891274094581604,
0.5877991318702698,
0.13311733305454254,
0.7061833739280701,
0.5697073936462402,
0.8836389780044556,
0.6072521209716797,
0.25807955861091614,
-0.6194234490394592,
0.43136459589004517,
0.0367543026804924,
-0.42400625348091125,
-0.42185404896736145,
-0.4511631429195404,
-0.8177810907363892,
0.15807242691516876,
-0.23915418982505798,
-0.7726606726646423,
-0.09423620253801346,
-0.1102181077003479,
-0.6650717854499817,
0.12313637882471085,
-0.7295247912406921,
0.7446827292442322,
-0.2874900996685028,
-0.3422335088253021,
-0.09822472929954529,
-0.47053471207618713,
0.11831565946340561,
-0.20928557217121124,
0.4492412805557251,
-0.050766490399837494,
-0.3083008825778961,
0.5820335745811462,
-0.005314501468092203,
0.46920961141586304,
-0.12862680852413177,
0.09844335168600082,
0.36380648612976074,
0.6182496547698975,
0.4105739891529083,
0.0915110781788826,
-0.34623464941978455,
-0.006239345297217369,
0.18961112201213837,
-0.6865696907043457,
-0.6144517660140991,
0.7663842439651489,
-0.795825719833374,
-0.28287872672080994,
-0.3086813688278198,
-0.6886749267578125,
-0.17243468761444092,
0.14193056523799896,
0.08337891101837158,
0.23647360503673553,
-0.5418984293937683,
-0.051219090819358826,
0.25341832637786865,
-0.2616034746170044,
0.7082647085189819,
0.9388914108276367,
-0.17103925347328186,
-0.25589805841445923,
0.8687123656272888,
-0.13119783997535706,
0.37216007709503174,
0.2667378783226013,
0.3158082067966461,
0.1989404559135437,
-0.456220418214798,
-0.4884984493255615,
-0.3971952795982361,
-0.4675557613372803,
-0.3596718907356262,
-0.18521703779697418,
0.06242823228240013,
-0.21754372119903564,
-0.43767353892326355,
-0.232806995511055,
-0.0262988843023777,
-0.025346161797642708,
0.2816396951675415,
0.3590555191040039,
0.7355732917785645,
-0.04536278918385506,
0.20904584228992462,
-0.8080019950866699,
-0.00792677141726017,
0.30189085006713867,
0.739646315574646,
-0.3136798143386841,
-0.4997759759426117,
-0.15424229204654694,
-0.21219146251678467,
0.26164835691452026,
-1.021996259689331,
0.15306980907917023,
0.34893766045570374,
0.9182852506637573,
-0.0352187342941761,
0.31779277324676514,
0.542641818523407,
-0.28246983885765076,
0.6571070551872253,
0.07649736851453781,
-0.9184544682502747,
0.11612200736999512,
-0.4491860270500183,
0.3825395107269287,
0.7323393225669861,
-0.18972215056419373,
-0.49298250675201416,
-0.48516106605529785,
-0.5104978084564209,
-0.27036136388778687,
0.8960111737251282,
0.3740384578704834,
0.16034002602100372,
0.056922733783721924,
0.20120882987976074,
0.16862404346466064,
-0.10017700493335724,
-0.4440065324306488,
-0.1416608691215515,
0.32148173451423645,
-0.2940898537635803,
-0.31398677825927734,
0.4794139564037323,
-0.043892234563827515,
-0.0779862031340599,
0.5661556720733643,
-0.5436354279518127,
0.5769747495651245,
0.17983002960681915,
-0.11977693438529968,
-0.4854351282119751,
-0.0778505727648735,
0.5691757798194885,
0.545633852481842,
0.2192033976316452,
-0.1888224184513092,
0.5444642305374146,
-0.09733619540929794,
0.04053432494401932,
-0.151882603764534,
0.3508208394050598,
0.02990291267633438,
0.5937886834144592,
0.42284590005874634,
0.46164196729660034,
-0.5641834139823914,
0.5694184899330139,
-0.3253958523273468,
-0.28657788038253784,
-0.2568740248680115,
0.33535391092300415,
-0.11329585313796997,
0.6387076377868652,
0.2697577178478241,
0.8071085214614868,
-0.17217127978801727,
-0.8378826975822449,
0.42821577191352844,
0.293556272983551,
-0.6488369703292847,
-0.34538164734840393,
0.24922768771648407,
0.4237132668495178,
-1.0907630920410156,
-0.039623331278562546,
-0.4466455280780792,
-0.8266513347625732,
1.2735350131988525,
0.4897904098033905,
1.0593900680541992,
-0.6329479217529297,
0.438603013753891,
0.301990807056427,
0.24652408063411713,
-0.01758684776723385,
-0.13738763332366943,
-0.03219584375619888,
-0.8340978026390076,
0.03242344409227371,
-0.33629530668258667,
-0.11049168556928635,
-0.8431704640388489,
-0.39382246136665344,
0.10691235959529877,
-0.4694675803184509,
-0.022858956828713417,
-0.03551514819264412,
0.00788888055831194,
-0.8058912754058838,
-0.04206604138016701,
0.06718816608190536,
0.9683470129966736,
-0.7357466220855713,
0.7851372957229614,
0.7742029428482056,
-0.2799827456474304,
-0.7860637903213501,
0.06575286388397217,
-0.15147541463375092,
-0.9776855111122131,
0.17387598752975464,
-0.26989442110061646,
-0.08828079700469971,
0.2586384415626526,
-0.5441234707832336,
-0.6844341158866882,
1.1167426109313965,
0.0382847785949707,
-0.4601280391216278,
-0.015185683965682983,
-0.3722769021987915,
0.9320658445358276,
-0.6564880609512329,
0.5576452016830444,
0.4031297266483307,
0.5317668914794922,
-0.11905095726251602,
-1.0369657278060913,
0.014379225671291351,
-0.2957407832145691,
-0.2500264644622803,
0.24322396516799927,
-1.2251152992248535,
0.6651628017425537,
-0.38038304448127747,
-0.20420630276203156,
0.6295421719551086,
0.42142513394355774,
-0.05859413370490074,
0.41661012172698975,
0.7251672744750977,
0.09463883936405182,
0.7115916609764099,
0.10070892423391342,
0.7632973194122314,
-0.45853713154792786,
0.46020984649658203,
1.1020963191986084,
-0.26796597242355347,
0.5340956449508667,
0.10844147950410843,
-0.2697593867778778,
0.610567569732666,
0.1861114203929901,
-0.026213418692350388,
0.6202490925788879,
0.4971342384815216,
-0.29309216141700745,
-0.4412238895893097,
0.23804236948490143,
-0.2009652853012085,
0.8400232791900635,
0.11975402384996414,
-0.2820109724998474,
-0.11870210617780685,
-0.29008328914642334,
-0.2572185695171356,
0.5421249866485596,
-0.35983291268348694,
1.1803820133209229,
-0.3570324182510376,
-1.0020278692245483,
0.001170982839539647,
-0.20738686621189117,
0.5859832763671875,
-0.5779291391372681,
-0.10103335231542587,
-0.3302249312400818,
0.3904525637626648,
-0.30823394656181335,
-0.6367016434669495,
-0.043655481189489365,
-0.1781424582004547,
-0.07204247266054153,
0.15654687583446503,
0.5920947194099426,
-0.4382510483264923,
-0.4769192337989807,
0.5816071033477783,
0.3786378800868988,
0.21213586628437042,
0.02664690650999546,
-0.642913281917572,
0.12595349550247192,
-0.1247914656996727,
0.41181913018226624,
0.4384337365627289,
0.3307895064353943,
0.19633008539676666,
0.5105872750282288,
0.191254660487175,
-0.11148274689912796,
-0.04041804000735283,
-0.38747671246528625,
0.6588170528411865,
-0.3081146478652954,
-0.573774516582489,
-0.5980923771858215,
0.4549623131752014,
0.012053107842803001,
-0.44167134165763855,
0.6893453598022461,
0.4097580909729004,
0.5813382863998413,
0.011278563179075718,
0.8623429536819458,
-0.05561908334493637,
0.06759501248598099,
-0.10746616870164871,
0.853365957736969,
-0.28097787499427795,
0.11259163916110992,
-0.691066324710846,
-0.9050693511962891,
-0.2556498646736145,
0.5618089437484741,
0.2687656283378601,
0.05963851138949394,
0.5878307223320007,
0.7387067675590515,
0.3530600368976593,
0.15501441061496735,
0.5468883514404297,
0.2484525591135025,
0.23901817202568054,
1.0320899486541748,
0.6979215145111084,
-0.514306902885437,
0.5372056365013123,
0.046650778502225876,
-0.6762087941169739,
-0.053335558623075485,
-0.7116143703460693,
-0.9750301241874695,
-0.35766974091529846,
-0.41986167430877686,
-0.08662079274654388,
0.5781887173652649,
1.0202865600585938,
0.6061864495277405,
-0.6531736254692078,
-0.3411014676094055,
0.041714586317539215,
0.13113124668598175,
-0.7025192379951477,
-0.24499309062957764,
-0.006225167773663998,
-0.4374450445175171,
-0.49621719121932983,
0.6323416233062744,
0.0781431645154953,
-0.458388090133667,
0.02490547113120556,
-0.6913344860076904,
0.16963915526866913,
0.23124970495700836,
0.2960814833641052,
0.4101400375366211,
-0.3867473304271698,
-0.6665564179420471,
0.06816761195659637,
-0.15312400460243225,
0.014003532938659191,
0.7294567227363586,
-0.8315783739089966,
0.8855211138725281,
0.2460174560546875,
0.5509966015815735,
-0.181731715798378,
-0.0018454226665198803,
0.7200039625167847,
-0.5326617360115051,
-0.02969493716955185,
0.36499524116516113,
-0.0320335328578949,
-0.1386137306690216,
-0.33235153555870056,
0.4856846332550049,
0.11346793174743652,
-0.9287519454956055,
-0.4911085069179535,
-0.049484580755233765,
-0.9430006742477417,
-0.24330589175224304,
0.9803768992424011,
-0.2287699282169342,
0.030002467334270477,
-0.1388186514377594,
-0.3738144040107727,
0.06374046206474304,
-0.648139476776123,
0.8833404779434204,
0.689020574092865,
-0.022953450679779053,
0.1519039273262024,
-0.11704450845718384,
0.3971690833568573,
0.15548941493034363,
-0.6641921997070312,
-0.1583746075630188,
0.1181795746088028,
0.3031047284603119,
0.07234599441289902,
0.871979296207428,
0.23121631145477295,
0.6760600209236145,
0.4127661883831024,
0.07548563182353973,
0.24914948642253876,
-0.28596800565719604,
-0.312409907579422,
-0.01938135176897049,
0.2817380130290985,
-0.3369337320327759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17019v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17019v4
|
Leveraging Large Language Models for Learning Complex Legal Concepts through Storytelling
| 2024-02-26T20:56:06 | 2024-07-02T17:50:42 |
Hang Jiang, Xiajie Zhang, Robert Mahari, Daniel Kessler, Eric Ma, Tal August, Irene Li, Alex 'Sandy' Pentland, Yoon Kim, Deb Roy, Jad Kabbara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Making legal knowledge accessible to non-experts is crucial for enhancing
general legal literacy and encouraging civic participation in democracy.
However, legal documents are often challenging to understand for people without
legal backgrounds. In this paper, we present a novel application of large
language models (LLMs) in legal education to help non-experts learn intricate
legal concepts through storytelling, an effective pedagogical tool in conveying
complex and abstract concepts. We also introduce a new dataset LegalStories,
which consists of 294 complex legal doctrines, each accompanied by a story and
a set of multiple-choice questions generated by LLMs. To construct the dataset,
we experiment with various LLMs to generate legal stories explaining these
concepts. Furthermore, we use an expert-in-the-loop approach to iteratively
design multiple-choice questions. Then, we evaluate the effectiveness of
storytelling with LLMs through randomized controlled trials (RCTs) with legal
novices on 10 samples from the dataset. We find that LLM-generated stories
enhance comprehension of legal concepts and interest in law among non-native
speakers compared to only definitions. Moreover, stories consistently help
participants relate legal concepts to their lives. Finally, we find that
learning with stories shows a higher retention rate for non-native speakers in
the follow-up assessment. Our work has strong implications for using LLMs in
promoting teaching and learning in the legal field and beyond.
|
[
-0.04462425783276558,
-0.6993172764778137,
0.8077762126922607,
-0.22374963760375977,
-0.6285472512245178,
0.2720484733581543,
-0.4562224745750427,
-0.30756378173828125,
0.30074620246887207,
0.6734820604324341,
0.016623113304376602,
-0.627697229385376,
-0.41538479924201965,
-0.283964604139328,
-0.33893463015556335,
0.9273337125778198,
-0.1105373278260231,
0.18684549629688263,
0.0019274496007710695,
-0.16832293570041656,
-0.6279187202453613,
-0.2560868263244629,
-0.36310288310050964,
-0.25451144576072693,
0.4780304729938507,
0.44494229555130005,
0.5659220814704895,
0.6267553567886353,
-0.03972731530666351,
0.1755160242319107,
-0.040510330349206924,
0.06791625171899796,
-0.6600003242492676,
0.1250292956829071,
-0.3221759796142578,
-0.9765104055404663,
0.13446393609046936,
-0.1554490625858307,
0.4371776580810547,
0.6857720017433167,
-0.5094886422157288,
0.015320396050810814,
-0.43921834230422974,
0.5739952921867371,
-0.4363066852092743,
0.27071982622146606,
-0.573894739151001,
0.43324577808380127,
-0.11342200636863708,
-0.2197088897228241,
-0.29863205552101135,
-0.416696161031723,
0.22976727783679962,
-0.6704274415969849,
0.10835394263267517,
0.24910803139209747,
0.44262057542800903,
0.012500181794166565,
-0.6469553709030151,
-0.750355064868927,
-0.5786872506141663,
0.2664923667907715,
-0.7721999287605286,
0.34845811128616333,
0.23091281950473785,
0.4012475907802582,
-0.08006531000137329,
-0.4266129434108734,
-0.8316690921783447,
-0.6081395745277405,
0.1312968134880066,
0.09973840415477753,
-0.010888448916375637,
-0.03709648922085762,
0.32393139600753784,
0.17625293135643005,
-0.5981904864311218,
0.6428537964820862,
-0.37389039993286133,
-0.08781737089157104,
0.64305180311203,
0.39701834321022034,
0.30862078070640564,
-0.22448083758354187,
0.028235310688614845,
0.1403423547744751,
-0.9000484347343445,
0.35284847021102905,
0.5694368481636047,
0.39639389514923096,
-0.39121854305267334,
0.7640572786331177,
0.24876658618450165,
0.5355693697929382,
0.025558287277817726,
-0.7016426920890808,
0.2034437656402588,
0.14267602562904358,
0.014203225262463093,
0.3375212848186493,
0.69502192735672,
0.22451813519001007,
0.5453511476516724,
-0.17196612060070038,
-0.21251407265663147,
-0.5544844269752502,
-0.06557340174913406,
-0.6857588291168213,
0.052097298204898834,
0.08999184519052505,
-0.4601048529148102,
-0.37519145011901855,
0.014072668738663197,
-0.7874268293380737,
-0.8556590676307678,
-0.5206816792488098,
0.2693448066711426,
-0.3368639051914215,
-0.18006354570388794,
0.4362834692001343,
-0.03284130617976189,
0.21299682557582855,
0.3700576722621918,
-1.0306682586669922,
0.06532303243875504,
0.6580466032028198,
0.6612063050270081,
0.2770020067691803,
0.1041899248957634,
-0.7562622427940369,
0.4221610724925995,
-0.632900059223175,
0.4398120939731598,
-0.6292893886566162,
-0.33567580580711365,
0.35947054624557495,
-0.22707295417785645,
0.2256198525428772,
-0.4875621199607849,
0.4777466654777527,
-0.45357054471969604,
-0.1175866425037384,
0.04941178113222122,
-0.6996690034866333,
-0.27442917227745056,
0.37517550587654114,
-0.5855147242546082,
0.2613476514816284,
-0.22024531662464142,
-0.41250211000442505,
0.4905613362789154,
-0.5577218532562256,
-0.7870176434516907,
0.3394933044910431,
-0.6402615904808044,
-0.32098323106765747,
0.42333948612213135,
0.26512137055397034,
0.4959941804409027,
-0.31763502955436707,
0.7951464056968689,
0.14848646521568298,
-0.1508890986442566,
0.20968656241893768,
-0.3476260006427765,
0.6104854941368103,
0.16394302248954773,
-0.29415401816368103,
0.0041793412528932095,
-0.4507256746292114,
-0.27739250659942627,
0.3508065938949585,
-0.4655141234397888,
-0.2688238024711609,
-0.05049002170562744,
-0.16394074261188507,
0.18842671811580658,
-0.08309585601091385,
-0.4721390902996063,
0.43304443359375,
-0.42542216181755066,
0.452670693397522,
0.4731224477291107,
0.14361163973808289,
0.3085364103317261,
-0.3889859914779663,
0.7492957711219788,
-0.042648423463106155,
-0.2363651692867279,
-0.557989239692688,
-0.33418500423431396,
-0.5464808940887451,
-0.04424965754151344,
0.24926231801509857,
0.4277225732803345,
-0.7887154817581177,
-0.0553869903087616,
-0.25134602189064026,
-0.49959689378738403,
-0.4224627912044525,
0.325143426656723,
0.19464915990829468,
0.35769498348236084,
0.11609186977148056,
0.15074953436851501,
-0.305038183927536,
-0.7341660261154175,
-0.45860376954078674,
-0.4377652704715729,
-0.03044051118195057,
0.46213436126708984,
0.7464300394058228,
0.18303759396076202,
0.7743990421295166,
-0.3122713565826416,
-0.27449941635131836,
-0.6599695682525635,
0.3342529833316803,
0.22594614326953888,
-0.0015177197055891156,
0.4733934998512268,
-0.8111142516136169,
-0.4667675495147705,
0.27254718542099,
-0.7932900786399841,
0.10712744295597076,
-0.6063361167907715,
0.46168750524520874,
0.06155897676944733,
0.2366061806678772,
-0.7558926343917847,
0.19549492001533508,
-0.1317991018295288,
-0.42913785576820374,
0.8622512817382812,
-0.5349038243293762,
0.05487266555428505,
-1.0120488405227661,
-0.22479397058486938,
0.05229322612285614,
-0.2288707196712494,
-0.36640653014183044,
0.25525516271591187,
0.031147776171565056,
-0.24847987294197083,
-0.7599526643753052,
0.5363997220993042,
-0.5466647744178772,
-0.14989197254180908,
-0.06474706530570984,
0.2652839720249176,
-0.1382807493209839,
0.2428494095802307,
0.12255550175905228,
0.5452026724815369,
0.43858301639556885,
-0.3161703944206238,
0.4818263649940491,
0.27911660075187683,
-0.7577400207519531,
0.6292359828948975,
-0.16334111988544464,
-0.10986257344484329,
-0.37029311060905457,
0.30297961831092834,
-0.21091780066490173,
-0.37082791328430176,
0.012274294160306454,
-0.1416005790233612,
0.3278747498989105,
-0.46035757660865784,
-0.9713973999023438,
-0.3565620481967926,
0.05174559727311134,
-0.2419118881225586,
0.42900243401527405,
-0.3524114787578583,
0.7703148722648621,
0.5758401155471802,
-0.21397219598293304,
-0.513983964920044,
-0.5627061128616333,
0.5504934787750244,
-0.5882933139801025,
-0.3932478725910187,
-0.21090549230575562,
0.0824790820479393,
-0.44500043988227844,
-0.029192352667450905,
0.16733203828334808,
-0.16708114743232727,
-0.026029152795672417,
0.27149632573127747,
0.01000174693763256,
-0.2944893538951874,
0.6343963146209717,
0.34528908133506775,
0.17613989114761353,
0.3387397229671478,
-0.37024348974227905,
0.3490838408470154,
-0.03899773955345154,
-0.45923811197280884,
-0.2839486300945282,
0.27942028641700745,
0.6440848708152771,
-0.28087201714515686,
0.6503034234046936,
0.20405955612659454,
-0.191599041223526,
-0.30025312304496765,
-0.7275164723396301,
-0.1197868138551712,
-0.3816613554954529,
0.6202145218849182,
-0.3695283532142639,
-1.191659688949585,
0.370646595954895,
-0.1478688269853592,
0.34731927514076233,
0.12570232152938843,
0.7763631939888,
-0.24162019789218903,
0.25751635432243347,
0.45623770356178284,
-0.006817077752202749,
0.06563325226306915,
-0.08179459720849991,
0.5130180716514587,
-0.2614906430244446,
-0.4370720386505127,
-0.21399196982383728,
-0.1274566948413849,
-0.14251860976219177,
-0.5903478264808655,
0.23694546520709991,
0.13857479393482208,
-0.1959746927022934,
0.062135521322488785,
0.20804812014102936,
0.830671489238739,
0.23737764358520508,
-0.04741942882537842,
0.6801956295967102,
0.09606590867042542,
-0.3682941794395447,
-0.08703262358903885,
-0.6125260591506958,
-0.7741075158119202,
1.2152568101882935,
0.5287183523178101,
0.8743664026260376,
0.15378715097904205,
0.7782717347145081,
0.2587108314037323,
0.06882784515619278,
-0.9984052777290344,
0.44147926568984985,
-0.12289119511842728,
-0.4759741425514221,
-0.4039119482040405,
-0.38379865884780884,
-0.769812822341919,
0.2988196611404419,
-0.5333156585693359,
-0.4616280496120453,
0.054160524159669876,
-0.1330278515815735,
-0.6365206837654114,
0.7383967638015747,
-0.33301591873168945,
0.49369463324546814,
-0.6834288239479065,
-0.3012544810771942,
-0.2837987244129181,
-0.6625974178314209,
0.28002867102622986,
-0.4529455304145813,
0.48846107721328735,
0.10434097796678543,
0.056864865124225616,
0.720720112323761,
-0.3009048104286194,
0.9476270079612732,
-0.05903318524360657,
-0.20611754059791565,
0.6572210192680359,
0.20358818769454956,
0.5082476139068604,
0.2359207421541214,
0.06682205200195312,
-0.2098732739686966,
-0.2239876240491867,
-0.019663529470562935,
-0.6518664360046387,
0.4822656512260437,
-0.5734977722167969,
-0.846384584903717,
-0.16163553297519684,
-0.9584038257598877,
-0.12327896803617477,
0.16625341773033142,
-0.28291574120521545,
0.16840679943561554,
0.022012824192643166,
0.41090479493141174,
0.7618589997291565,
-0.4238559603691101,
0.30037379264831543,
1.1383633613586426,
-0.12106729298830032,
-0.04311160370707512,
0.8368133902549744,
0.43103858828544617,
0.09620608389377594,
0.40358489751815796,
0.5278070569038391,
-0.5473670959472656,
-0.8795364499092102,
-0.3787974417209625,
0.3750581741333008,
-0.917142927646637,
-0.08344769477844238,
-0.9285770654678345,
-0.01897430419921875,
-0.04181623458862305,
-0.24444320797920227,
-0.017399318516254425,
-0.29310640692710876,
0.003012656467035413,
-0.6082838773727417,
0.3180208206176758,
0.7679990530014038,
-0.15268082916736603,
0.16435028612613678,
-0.6813977956771851,
0.270126074552536,
0.4011766314506531,
0.014060772024095058,
0.052109986543655396,
-0.7021760940551758,
-0.08399607241153717,
-0.05721859633922577,
-0.11744674295186996,
-0.6720588207244873,
0.30544736981391907,
-0.012193866074085236,
0.7519897222518921,
0.519934892654419,
0.00635824678465724,
0.6080979704856873,
-0.7193613052368164,
0.5058515667915344,
0.27698758244514465,
-0.6742812991142273,
0.41422444581985474,
-0.6847910284996033,
-0.09693549573421478,
0.45956242084503174,
0.31456682085990906,
-0.6222729086875916,
-0.54856276512146,
-0.28933921456336975,
-0.8643805980682373,
0.38942649960517883,
0.018626146018505096,
0.7077073454856873,
0.21729065477848053,
0.5708397030830383,
0.41211363673210144,
0.40550509095191956,
-0.8697113990783691,
0.07684081792831421,
0.005037696100771427,
-0.22351592779159546,
-0.1164771169424057,
-0.21916306018829346,
-0.12371831387281418,
-0.21303479373455048,
0.36288943886756897,
-0.06015334650874138,
-0.2463918924331665,
-0.21521809697151184,
-0.4666615426540375,
-0.1315441131591797,
0.6214628219604492,
0.7310494780540466,
0.7997092008590698,
0.09598833322525024,
0.12261606752872467,
0.2692797780036926,
-0.35853880643844604,
0.16688519716262817,
-0.29094159603118896,
0.05828532949090004,
-0.04909525811672211,
0.6038771867752075,
1.0029575824737549,
0.25511616468429565,
-1.1280105113983154,
0.6007457971572876,
0.03150445595383644,
-0.45659783482551575,
-0.3554813861846924,
-0.08448192477226257,
0.7141515612602234,
0.5640776753425598,
0.4558370113372803,
-0.33529597520828247,
-0.16199469566345215,
-0.7800284624099731,
0.24358829855918884,
0.11873140931129456,
-0.16586939990520477,
0.1215335950255394,
0.5512592792510986,
0.15140652656555176,
-0.3104688227176666,
0.4017930328845978,
-0.04770732671022415,
-0.30279141664505005,
0.7976226806640625,
0.6614168286323547,
0.3926328718662262,
0.19986554980278015,
0.43851858377456665,
0.32241761684417725,
0.3679283559322357,
-0.3895499110221863,
-0.15009331703186035,
0.002071460010483861,
-0.41676846146583557,
-0.5100974440574646,
-0.5145468711853027,
-0.43323656916618347,
0.2808339595794678,
-0.3968513011932373,
0.30982789397239685,
-0.4455694258213043,
0.3935992419719696,
-0.21752376854419708,
-0.13054828345775604,
-0.5050135254859924,
-0.01682407595217228,
0.27114853262901306,
0.8816342353820801,
-1.0720946788787842,
0.6992218494415283,
0.39855024218559265,
-0.5838821530342102,
-0.9663182497024536,
0.1013161689043045,
0.03814250975847244,
-0.6179496049880981,
0.7416563034057617,
-0.045023396611213684,
0.3483421206474304,
-0.06756597012281418,
-0.4695926308631897,
-0.20635701715946198,
1.0669609308242798,
0.5544062256813049,
-1.1481703519821167,
-0.17302340269088745,
0.46067702770233154,
0.7106025815010071,
-0.6750605702400208,
0.19433028995990753,
0.3160884380340576,
0.4308681786060333,
0.46226024627685547,
-0.7307823300361633,
-0.11581747233867645,
0.11857829988002777,
-0.3501751720905304,
-0.09162995219230652,
-0.12726473808288574,
0.6995887160301208,
-0.7352619767189026,
0.13238394260406494,
-0.15571022033691406,
0.579483151435852,
0.48616331815719604,
0.293338805437088,
0.291793555021286,
0.49123260378837585,
1.0176491737365723,
0.13719303905963898,
0.923009991645813,
-0.012574664317071438,
0.3267553150653839,
1.3988407850265503,
-0.20708827674388885,
0.6728693246841431,
0.390108197927475,
0.10881972312927246,
0.4456530809402466,
0.49467816948890686,
-0.27453115582466125,
0.1549876630306244,
0.5611961483955383,
-0.19674380123615265,
-0.46034061908721924,
-0.21825534105300903,
-0.1473219394683838,
0.37413984537124634,
0.3689028024673462,
-0.3644668757915497,
-0.4973967969417572,
0.43432679772377014,
0.15660154819488525,
0.47895315289497375,
-0.6043389439582825,
0.6755426526069641,
0.26684829592704773,
-0.3030168414115906,
0.1519203782081604,
-0.04030710086226463,
0.39485281705856323,
-0.34113746881484985,
-0.10620307177305222,
-0.11476371437311172,
-0.2584760785102844,
-0.15961317718029022,
-1.2249380350112915,
-0.13645122945308685,
0.36341845989227295,
-0.037464361637830734,
-0.034293632954359055,
0.21554942429065704,
-0.6108437180519104,
-0.5314427614212036,
0.1672333925962448,
0.48846861720085144,
0.3814738392829895,
0.16808238625526428,
-0.6370019316673279,
-0.17759396135807037,
-0.23579108715057373,
0.040599316358566284,
0.2884178161621094,
0.6246317625045776,
-0.43486732244491577,
0.8110126256942749,
0.5675954222679138,
0.10016800463199615,
0.15592220425605774,
0.3430301249027252,
0.8134871125221252,
-0.5822314023971558,
-0.8043162822723389,
-0.7425687909126282,
0.7353427410125732,
0.09688878059387207,
0.02202525921165943,
0.5326135158538818,
0.7262988090515137,
0.6669334173202515,
-0.23090927302837372,
0.8088830709457397,
0.0709037035703659,
0.267238587141037,
-0.7268298864364624,
0.8319894671440125,
-0.2703078091144562,
0.2816818058490753,
0.0016194614581763744,
-0.784260094165802,
-0.216056689620018,
0.47247862815856934,
-0.4608301818370819,
-0.17399150133132935,
0.5975724458694458,
0.4017258584499359,
-0.050711069256067276,
-0.17366860806941986,
0.7742035984992981,
0.31141096353530884,
0.5924189686775208,
0.507198691368103,
0.8358712792396545,
0.07881302386522293,
0.5809797048568726,
0.1917586624622345,
0.11285006999969482,
-0.19505764544010162,
-0.6238093972206116,
-1.4539015293121338,
-0.2888292372226715,
-0.09522592276334763,
-0.031181855127215385,
0.16973325610160828,
0.9689450263977051,
0.37096303701400757,
-0.5094248056411743,
-0.3510601222515106,
-0.039735350757837296,
0.016221052035689354,
0.39141368865966797,
-0.15588369965553284,
0.23121096193790436,
-0.37677764892578125,
-0.5066312551498413,
0.36256179213523865,
0.23111887276172638,
0.010536639019846916,
-0.22663503885269165,
-0.30563047528266907,
-0.29772061109542847,
0.1766197681427002,
0.5615939497947693,
0.29230746626853943,
-0.9260858297348022,
-0.1335364133119583,
-0.40955623984336853,
0.0911872610449791,
0.031100988388061523,
1.117242455482483,
-0.540162205696106,
0.6937552094459534,
0.23974794149398804,
0.7413378357887268,
0.660964846611023,
-0.23145993053913116,
0.43166986107826233,
-0.4649365246295929,
0.22635550796985626,
0.4285827875137329,
0.4769098460674286,
0.10579035431146622,
-0.34141120314598083,
0.2591995596885681,
-0.08535683900117874,
-0.009298743680119514,
-0.6818737983703613,
0.14793261885643005,
-0.5652400851249695,
-0.5247308015823364,
1.088520884513855,
-0.3793182075023651,
-0.029948873445391655,
-0.42131319642066956,
-0.3297598361968994,
0.03358824923634529,
-0.43255749344825745,
0.8260645866394043,
0.8236323595046997,
0.32879194617271423,
-0.471845418214798,
-1.000562310218811,
0.11641445010900497,
0.04600610211491585,
-0.8694307804107666,
0.015848465263843536,
0.3874528110027313,
0.6382359862327576,
-0.09899941831827164,
0.30082109570503235,
-0.3108360171318054,
0.2154991775751114,
-0.23269976675510406,
0.0049405787140131,
-0.6216800808906555,
-0.2683902978897095,
-0.33098554611206055,
0.3113848567008972,
0.014461060985922813,
0.4039037823677063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17016v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17016v1
|
Multi-Task Contrastive Learning for 8192-Token Bilingual Text Embeddings
| 2024-02-26T20:53:12 | 2024-02-26T20:53:12 |
Isabelle Mohr, Markus Krimmel, Saba Sturua, Mohammad Kalim Akram, Andreas Koukounas, Michael Günther, Georgios Mastrapas, Vinit Ravishankar, Joan Fontanals Martínez, Feng Wang, Qi Liu, Ziniu Yu, Jie Fu, Saahil Ognawala, Susana Guzman, Bo Wang, Maximilian Werk, Nan Wang, Han Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, 68T50, I.2.7
|
We introduce a novel suite of state-of-the-art bilingual text embedding
models that are designed to support English and another target language. These
models are capable of processing lengthy text inputs with up to 8192 tokens,
making them highly versatile for a range of natural language processing tasks
such as text retrieval, clustering, and semantic textual similarity (STS)
calculations.
By focusing on bilingual models and introducing a unique multi-task learning
objective, we have significantly improved the model performance on STS tasks,
which outperforms the capabilities of existing multilingual models in both
target language understanding and cross-lingual evaluation tasks. Moreover, our
bilingual models are more efficient, requiring fewer parameters and less memory
due to their smaller vocabulary needs. Furthermore, we have expanded the
Massive Text Embedding Benchmark (MTEB) to include benchmarks for German and
Spanish embedding models. This integration aims to stimulate further research
and advancement in text embedding technologies for these languages.
|
[
-0.19681794941425323,
-0.5911809802055359,
0.46132901310920715,
0.522453248500824,
-0.3323001563549042,
0.12834908068180084,
-0.10470418632030487,
-0.5203744173049927,
0.19339604675769806,
0.48723822832107544,
-0.30134227871894836,
-0.5626804828643799,
-0.8050323724746704,
0.32508382201194763,
-0.026104440912604332,
0.8774480223655701,
-0.19525770843029022,
0.4747602045536041,
-0.1944279819726944,
-0.39243629574775696,
-0.5592814683914185,
-0.4988725781440735,
-0.6804520487785339,
-0.17879202961921692,
0.5855544209480286,
0.4721713662147522,
0.3026905059814453,
0.5240195989608765,
0.38206911087036133,
0.35998815298080444,
-0.022860929369926453,
0.2431166023015976,
-0.38541075587272644,
0.10162034630775452,
-0.31645312905311584,
-0.49172690510749817,
-0.4875027537345886,
-0.22555816173553467,
0.7530380487442017,
0.7434980273246765,
0.12208440899848938,
-0.020316410809755325,
0.3142237663269043,
0.4155815839767456,
-0.6090589761734009,
0.35872381925582886,
-0.5553210377693176,
0.13115011155605316,
-0.22636252641677856,
0.047882553189992905,
-0.7355154752731323,
0.22441336512565613,
0.07302480936050415,
-0.4700940251350403,
0.12408783286809921,
0.19633084535598755,
0.37647026777267456,
-0.10498248040676117,
-0.9169618487358093,
-0.19969439506530762,
-0.10667867958545685,
1.182031273841858,
-0.47887974977493286,
0.7020484209060669,
0.4368380606174469,
-0.09894741326570511,
0.356766015291214,
-0.5875201225280762,
-0.4229491949081421,
-0.07649606466293335,
-0.046524010598659515,
0.1705130636692047,
-0.1302933394908905,
-0.16402126848697662,
-0.019984640181064606,
0.27716273069381714,
-0.717729926109314,
0.27596646547317505,
-0.3696470856666565,
-0.19246147572994232,
0.12332617491483688,
0.3076229691505432,
0.08275429159402847,
-0.2769775688648224,
-0.5918622612953186,
-0.07666107267141342,
-0.4898776412010193,
-0.13051383197307587,
0.39250093698501587,
0.4958319664001465,
-0.4295428395271301,
0.2603437304496765,
0.05857997015118599,
0.35846075415611267,
-0.050637584179639816,
-0.013415073975920677,
0.7229218482971191,
-0.4833943843841553,
-0.17109090089797974,
-0.3250407576560974,
0.7868071794509888,
0.34916582703590393,
-0.23730935156345367,
-0.35935860872268677,
-0.21135039627552032,
-0.2207021862268448,
0.20364058017730713,
-0.8146071434020996,
0.16606539487838745,
0.05841268226504326,
-0.5481483936309814,
-0.20336797833442688,
0.04010028392076492,
-0.7916170358657837,
-0.3449254035949707,
-0.25456181168556213,
0.41513335704803467,
-0.3663042485713959,
-0.2414667308330536,
0.20134545862674713,
-0.2863737940788269,
-0.0031403368338942528,
0.21489772200584412,
-0.7572232484817505,
0.39115625619888306,
0.691344678401947,
0.8746264576911926,
-0.6279389262199402,
-0.6188758611679077,
-0.5757033228874207,
0.21807748079299927,
-0.21934127807617188,
0.5253282189369202,
-0.5692392587661743,
-0.5709868669509888,
0.16629920899868011,
0.2739364504814148,
-0.2892032563686371,
-0.5964481830596924,
0.7714096903800964,
-0.5015795826911926,
0.31760361790657043,
-0.25260862708091736,
-0.245290607213974,
-0.410510390996933,
0.4232460856437683,
-1.1031471490859985,
1.431134819984436,
-0.09948328882455826,
-0.9312739372253418,
0.02253798209130764,
-0.6592200398445129,
-0.582570493221283,
-0.07328129559755325,
0.1004054993391037,
-0.3430260121822357,
0.06547844409942627,
0.13629527390003204,
0.5952861309051514,
-0.5076862573623657,
0.24604712426662445,
-0.1331421434879303,
-0.2422019988298416,
-0.23658587038516998,
-0.37773051857948303,
0.8622715473175049,
0.06448632478713989,
-0.44118890166282654,
0.2696181833744049,
-0.5244647860527039,
-0.3056272566318512,
0.08150582760572433,
-0.3444473147392273,
-0.5466144680976868,
-0.14734545350074768,
0.6155837774276733,
0.38980400562286377,
0.4840032160282135,
-0.7083351016044617,
-0.2989480495452881,
-0.3078632056713104,
0.30559441447257996,
0.7196367979049683,
-0.40455085039138794,
0.42084431648254395,
-0.31116023659706116,
0.445616215467453,
0.4010452330112457,
-0.10467226058244705,
-0.5986172556877136,
-0.5680412650108337,
-0.6872029304504395,
-0.4309478998184204,
0.4009988605976105,
0.7716688513755798,
-0.7507100105285645,
0.5673154592514038,
-0.2019214928150177,
-0.4146325886249542,
-0.5130130648612976,
0.2469414919614792,
0.6861343383789062,
0.5381902456283569,
0.6327272653579712,
-0.3462199866771698,
-0.5680365562438965,
-1.0378071069717407,
-0.20972874760627747,
0.26427024602890015,
0.16686183214187622,
0.22839578986167908,
0.8043212890625,
-0.26541703939437866,
0.26329782605171204,
-0.229050412774086,
-0.409339040517807,
-0.44284123182296753,
0.2791109085083008,
0.035248950123786926,
0.7219114303588867,
0.6204411387443542,
-1.0497515201568604,
-0.8757205009460449,
0.31244784593582153,
-0.61932373046875,
0.32064759731292725,
0.2528607249259949,
-0.07818105071783066,
0.16365234553813934,
0.6550076603889465,
-0.3119904398918152,
0.24102701246738434,
0.8060623407363892,
-0.3801310658454895,
0.30355727672576904,
-0.43145641684532166,
0.42601636052131653,
-1.5111650228500366,
0.07996432483196259,
0.10187096148729324,
-0.46265384554862976,
-0.6226670145988464,
0.26719826459884644,
0.5491650104522705,
0.010696840472519398,
-0.5931711792945862,
0.7491306066513062,
-0.3878095746040344,
0.2908051013946533,
-0.29096096754074097,
0.12289424985647202,
0.17771601676940918,
0.4838699996471405,
0.047084882855415344,
0.6378602981567383,
0.6444770097732544,
-0.30167147517204285,
0.14285309612751007,
0.0957205593585968,
-0.18472766876220703,
0.7660824060440063,
-0.6902633905410767,
0.018704762682318687,
-0.20690879225730896,
0.3376087546348572,
-1.1116995811462402,
0.14595134556293488,
0.027434367686510086,
-0.14242418110370636,
0.22821646928787231,
0.09635630249977112,
-0.7019678354263306,
-0.1721802055835724,
-0.6735809445381165,
0.7671275734901428,
0.24701322615146637,
-0.5724735856056213,
0.8581129312515259,
0.4942905306816101,
-0.5266559720039368,
-0.660275936126709,
-0.8849171996116638,
0.05280500277876854,
-0.1790652871131897,
-0.2727520763874054,
0.8950852751731873,
-0.050244759768247604,
0.1451789140701294,
0.0680360272526741,
0.11906943470239639,
-0.2367211878299713,
-0.08576109260320663,
0.23570746183395386,
0.3638768196105957,
-0.15380354225635529,
0.2467440515756607,
0.3190557360649109,
-0.18650269508361816,
-0.2514689862728119,
-0.2381836324930191,
0.5011152625083923,
-0.012024779804050922,
-0.40217965841293335,
-0.33138155937194824,
0.935514509677887,
0.5110047459602356,
-0.5988419055938721,
0.9682281017303467,
0.7946905493736267,
-0.6944109201431274,
-0.06411407142877579,
-0.6129945516586304,
0.050494223833084106,
-0.4292948544025421,
0.7820959687232971,
-0.6343607902526855,
-1.0423390865325928,
0.6416719555854797,
0.08143960684537888,
0.19196300208568573,
0.6027631163597107,
0.6792729496955872,
0.16429172456264496,
1.1067973375320435,
0.758660078048706,
-0.09448784589767456,
0.4434714615345001,
-0.05557650700211525,
-0.03827851638197899,
-0.7036258578300476,
-0.3969264328479767,
-0.7002772688865662,
-0.21236136555671692,
-0.6232553720474243,
-0.9025824666023254,
0.07849740236997604,
-0.2805387079715729,
-0.2122431993484497,
0.4184556305408478,
-0.12979458272457123,
0.5459578633308411,
0.6313617825508118,
0.20469193160533905,
0.16077202558517456,
-0.06386222690343857,
-0.7005913257598877,
-0.23238131403923035,
-0.5280144214630127,
-0.3905917704105377,
1.2343344688415527,
0.2960200011730194,
0.3633292317390442,
0.09861019998788834,
0.7160098552703857,
0.3140220642089844,
0.26324462890625,
-0.5486061573028564,
0.37184780836105347,
-0.543070375919342,
-0.560652494430542,
0.006329407915472984,
-0.327910453081131,
-0.9182819128036499,
0.6965896487236023,
-0.2080799788236618,
-0.6436831951141357,
-0.012719910591840744,
-0.017999030649662018,
0.1283828318119049,
0.42609164118766785,
-0.8693583607673645,
1.2075493335723877,
-0.06784190982580185,
-0.46239739656448364,
-0.6388943195343018,
-0.4157053828239441,
0.017205307260155678,
-0.19050011038780212,
0.4161751866340637,
0.07193832099437714,
-0.4950025677680969,
0.9523841738700867,
0.21824485063552856,
1.0685911178588867,
-0.06425827741622925,
-0.052015285938978195,
-0.11233066767454147,
-0.0227676909416914,
0.5003883242607117,
-0.18010015785694122,
-0.35113805532455444,
0.16778774559497833,
-0.08749133348464966,
-0.6529783606529236,
-0.08794897049665451,
1.1096431016921997,
-0.5106140375137329,
-0.34116196632385254,
-0.36139151453971863,
-0.672416627407074,
-0.2628605365753174,
0.4083532392978668,
-0.06702812016010284,
0.4579596519470215,
-0.34292811155319214,
0.3249650001525879,
0.5078418850898743,
-0.20597746968269348,
0.5919144153594971,
0.4317901134490967,
0.002879043109714985,
-0.6688138842582703,
1.0213403701782227,
-0.1704583764076233,
0.07484747469425201,
0.785245954990387,
-0.035231687128543854,
-0.5432530045509338,
-0.39858725666999817,
-0.19619101285934448,
0.48769867420196533,
-0.8215177655220032,
-0.11304021626710892,
-0.8130460381507874,
0.32800018787384033,
-0.4273180663585663,
-0.21353453397750854,
-0.3748633563518524,
-0.22295869886875153,
-0.27485769987106323,
-0.2566698491573334,
-0.12796977162361145,
0.8928312659263611,
0.1252046376466751,
0.07677500694990158,
-0.9206368327140808,
0.439116507768631,
0.07287703454494476,
0.4175512492656708,
0.1801956743001938,
-0.5005757212638855,
-0.564252495765686,
-0.21332189440727234,
-0.557500958442688,
-0.974193274974823,
0.3472898304462433,
0.00709184305742383,
0.7591971755027771,
0.24521304666996002,
-0.12102571129798889,
0.4985455274581909,
-0.8911082744598389,
0.6721513271331787,
0.37099090218544006,
-1.1736410856246948,
0.0746818259358406,
-0.1465388834476471,
0.33179688453674316,
0.4311234652996063,
0.7326400876045227,
-0.4226130545139313,
-0.335875540971756,
-0.5440337657928467,
-0.7765252590179443,
0.6262797117233276,
-0.09106680005788803,
0.35132986307144165,
-0.100011445581913,
-0.23496408760547638,
0.5015168190002441,
0.22921812534332275,
-0.981147289276123,
-0.3458917737007141,
-0.0592179037630558,
-0.49112749099731445,
-0.27019405364990234,
-0.2825313210487366,
-0.012558084912598133,
-0.22681844234466553,
0.5548590421676636,
-0.2609817385673523,
0.23056462407112122,
-0.21816888451576233,
-0.3269096314907074,
0.21095579862594604,
0.3421039581298828,
0.5396929979324341,
0.4496331214904785,
0.1098446175456047,
0.3474075198173523,
0.5209525227546692,
-0.33038273453712463,
-0.10080747306346893,
0.4896533489227295,
0.12352899461984634,
0.14720749855041504,
0.3171052038669586,
0.7902604341506958,
0.6976456642150879,
-0.8458568453788757,
0.5840886235237122,
0.11251111328601837,
-0.29971233010292053,
0.12801297008991241,
-0.5693334341049194,
0.35564830899238586,
0.35162878036499023,
0.47298258543014526,
0.006881032604724169,
0.18962374329566956,
-0.45730409026145935,
0.19496501982212067,
0.5339298248291016,
-0.480668842792511,
-0.4690989553928375,
0.6836552023887634,
0.4981570243835449,
-0.2961071729660034,
0.15748269855976105,
-0.23879483342170715,
-0.7322287559509277,
0.554255485534668,
0.7441516518592834,
0.7851129174232483,
-0.2663901448249817,
0.17504200339317322,
0.4388324022293091,
0.16480720043182373,
-0.07358063757419586,
0.3817216455936432,
-0.16800659894943237,
-0.5901158452033997,
-0.4167817234992981,
-0.3306032121181488,
-0.4806334674358368,
-0.2042195051908493,
-0.7115783095359802,
0.2753005027770996,
-0.048161160200834274,
-0.13024650514125824,
0.026341276243329048,
-0.12309639900922775,
-0.8861753344535828,
0.07486458122730255,
0.03214668855071068,
0.7874691486358643,
-0.9128889441490173,
0.8315144777297974,
0.8723152279853821,
-0.11410004645586014,
-0.2363353967666626,
-0.16687680780887604,
-0.06377796083688736,
-0.7113732695579529,
0.6610153913497925,
0.5476580858230591,
-0.0072935461066663265,
-0.012274978682398796,
0.12070894241333008,
-0.38311222195625305,
0.9815071821212769,
0.4505837559700012,
-0.2952449321746826,
-0.23497876524925232,
0.1869160383939743,
0.3744812607765198,
-0.489179790019989,
0.42197945713996887,
0.1549876183271408,
0.32051777839660645,
-0.3984583914279938,
-1.1904881000518799,
0.03839126229286194,
-0.34071701765060425,
-0.20402748882770538,
0.24804924428462982,
-0.5847892761230469,
0.9541995525360107,
-0.06048113480210304,
0.005477428436279297,
0.008553492836654186,
0.5210265517234802,
0.14879897236824036,
0.21036724746227264,
0.528339147567749,
0.7000807523727417,
0.5547435283660889,
-0.05738475173711777,
0.86902916431427,
-0.4514843821525574,
0.3263261020183563,
0.9739655256271362,
-0.3097359538078308,
1.2099055051803589,
0.672722339630127,
-0.06808487325906754,
0.5359231233596802,
0.31847208738327026,
0.2079625278711319,
0.5103722810745239,
-0.2530054748058319,
-0.3135538697242737,
-0.3462236523628235,
-0.3055003881454468,
-0.25011739134788513,
0.19152039289474487,
0.23853114247322083,
-0.46986037492752075,
-0.34493786096572876,
0.33387091755867004,
0.0007972240564413369,
0.19817546010017395,
-0.19105947017669678,
0.5959853529930115,
-0.003781335661187768,
-0.611652672290802,
0.2018105536699295,
0.4903157353401184,
1.0244394540786743,
-0.5557247996330261,
-0.04521245136857033,
-0.09893213957548141,
0.2376101016998291,
0.10302116721868515,
-0.6366778016090393,
0.1271316260099411,
-0.027542036026716232,
-0.23384541273117065,
-0.6277852058410645,
0.3065010905265808,
-0.6744405031204224,
-0.5094406604766846,
0.6909644603729248,
0.6868218183517456,
-0.3307304084300995,
0.005202684551477432,
-0.8510521054267883,
0.059558600187301636,
-0.02945508249104023,
-0.03401723504066467,
0.5202414393424988,
0.4584844708442688,
0.03929373621940613,
0.41282206773757935,
0.37550631165504456,
-0.13551954925060272,
0.18666322529315948,
0.03695761412382126,
0.7053402066230774,
-0.784689724445343,
-0.8516520857810974,
-0.7431353330612183,
0.7882117033004761,
-0.08518839627504349,
-0.3389209806919098,
0.760104238986969,
0.9694219827651978,
0.9151785969734192,
-0.3491531014442444,
0.7603341341018677,
0.18827183544635773,
0.6805287599563599,
-0.3266260027885437,
0.24248671531677246,
-0.7992761135101318,
-0.08899825811386108,
-0.153005912899971,
-0.6808943748474121,
-0.29566121101379395,
0.2884626090526581,
-0.05075002461671829,
-0.02228011190891266,
1.0074000358581543,
0.7024220824241638,
-0.22620593011379242,
-0.08320903778076172,
0.3518722951412201,
-0.26851704716682434,
0.13866332173347473,
0.8110139966011047,
0.47282636165618896,
-0.6532017588615417,
0.6606771349906921,
-0.30521661043167114,
-0.1381693184375763,
-0.026424966752529144,
-0.8700342178344727,
-1.081774115562439,
-0.8965635299682617,
-0.23706308007240295,
0.027001630514860153,
-0.010278979316353798,
0.8622439503669739,
0.7038961052894592,
-0.9751981496810913,
-0.3731950521469116,
0.06169126555323601,
0.19712139666080475,
-0.18029479682445526,
-0.17990554869174957,
0.4528118073940277,
-0.3943626284599304,
-1.289967656135559,
0.3916500508785248,
0.3700000047683716,
-0.047777123749256134,
-0.1240735650062561,
-0.21482990682125092,
-0.35090163350105286,
0.03469567000865936,
0.6978038549423218,
0.044696517288684845,
-0.6838515996932983,
0.06125988811254501,
0.12683077156543732,
-0.4333938658237457,
0.050715941935777664,
0.7754032611846924,
-0.5527034997940063,
0.46548905968666077,
0.5938398838043213,
0.980320930480957,
0.45872873067855835,
-0.3316724896430969,
0.38933342695236206,
-0.7747679948806763,
0.5465056300163269,
0.1264946013689041,
0.6634626984596252,
0.36951059103012085,
0.06660022586584091,
0.12052521854639053,
0.22497671842575073,
-0.19186829030513763,
-0.8352458477020264,
0.007828205823898315,
-0.9944642782211304,
-0.17554984986782074,
0.7856919765472412,
-0.32150784134864807,
0.19944347441196442,
-0.22232778370380402,
-0.34447181224823,
0.041937049478292465,
-0.32108739018440247,
0.3802638053894043,
0.7359589338302612,
0.1810704469680786,
-0.26342588663101196,
-0.41786685585975647,
0.11437972635030746,
0.6605802178382874,
-0.8533985018730164,
-0.22782093286514282,
0.1549815833568573,
0.05214420333504677,
0.21978305280208588,
0.3825097978115082,
-0.19130505621433258,
0.46404460072517395,
0.1170659065246582,
-0.06192151829600334,
-0.03808422014117241,
-0.26693713665008545,
-0.2871774435043335,
0.5604628920555115,
0.00021247321274131536,
-0.2827482521533966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17014v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17014v2
|
Z-AGI Labs at ClimateActivism 2024: Stance and Hate Event Detection on Social Media
| 2024-02-26T20:43:48 | 2024-04-14T13:43:39 |
Nikhil Narayan, Mrutyunjay Biswal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the digital realm, rich data serves as a crucial source of insights into
the complexities of social, political, and economic landscapes. Addressing the
growing need for high-quality information on events and the imperative to
combat hate speech, this research led to the establishment of the Shared Task
on Climate Activism Stance and Hate Event Detection at CASE 2024. Focused on
climate activists contending with hate speech on social media, our study
contributes to hate speech identification from tweets. Analyzing three
sub-tasks - Hate Speech Detection (Sub-task A), Targets of Hate Speech
Identification (Sub-task B), and Stance Detection (Sub-task C) - Team Z-AGI
Labs evaluated various models, including LSTM, Xgboost, and LGBM based on
Tf-Idf. Results unveiled intriguing variations, with Catboost excelling in
Subtask-B (F1: 0.5604) and Subtask-C (F1: 0.7081), while LGBM emerged as the
top-performing model for Subtask-A (F1: 0.8684). This research provides
valuable insights into the suitability of classical machine learning models for
climate hate speech and stance detection, aiding informed model selection for
robust mechanisms.
|
[
-0.40473833680152893,
-0.8493574261665344,
0.4388715326786041,
-0.12277784198522568,
-0.35812655091285706,
0.45000597834587097,
-0.04524380341172218,
-0.6198881268501282,
0.2705254554748535,
0.14651112258434296,
-0.8686701655387878,
-0.6218294501304626,
-0.8543654084205627,
-0.39111849665641785,
-0.5436846017837524,
1.0826045274734497,
0.25856319069862366,
0.059321217238903046,
0.07825440168380737,
-0.1672971099615097,
-0.09284307807683945,
-0.425695538520813,
-0.7250180840492249,
-0.41570836305618286,
0.7379263043403625,
0.2697509825229645,
0.7868339419364929,
0.5031740069389343,
0.17344078421592712,
0.2504967153072357,
-0.11919459700584412,
-0.3904077708721161,
-0.44875189661979675,
-0.0013924131635576487,
-0.18213674426078796,
-0.030185813084244728,
-0.3449510633945465,
0.2579546272754669,
0.4898073971271515,
0.04840447008609772,
-0.08949562162160873,
0.20681823790073395,
-0.28344085812568665,
0.17393049597740173,
-0.4982677400112152,
-0.0675925612449646,
-0.9996146559715271,
0.0770302340388298,
-0.28803277015686035,
0.15039682388305664,
-0.1978996843099594,
-0.07087386399507523,
-0.2040736824274063,
-0.3356076180934906,
0.7113820314407349,
0.11341391503810883,
0.8963102698326111,
0.22718080878257751,
-0.22138462960720062,
-0.29627108573913574,
-0.4854195713996887,
0.9997982978820801,
-0.6658470630645752,
0.5331160426139832,
0.12253035604953766,
0.09550505876541138,
-0.04604637622833252,
-0.35886648297309875,
-0.9523726105690002,
0.02287578582763672,
0.2602567672729492,
0.14962594211101532,
-0.45251110196113586,
-0.09775042533874512,
-0.05616651847958565,
0.1909370869398117,
-0.5321708917617798,
0.5057317614555359,
-0.2823847234249115,
-0.27348944544792175,
0.8116115927696228,
0.22633887827396393,
0.306068480014801,
-0.4426017105579376,
-0.42450466752052307,
-0.025564005598425865,
-0.2471424639225006,
-0.02868424914777279,
0.6830893158912659,
0.6119290590286255,
-0.10401033610105515,
0.333723783493042,
-0.15316417813301086,
0.39166009426116943,
0.09420359879732132,
0.06964361667633057,
0.04459494352340698,
-0.36327069997787476,
-0.24401530623435974,
0.1696116179227829,
0.8803974986076355,
0.32497110962867737,
0.0412338487803936,
-0.1759730726480484,
-0.06628904491662979,
0.20931755006313324,
0.3964713215827942,
-0.7967411875724792,
-0.27521419525146484,
0.29364100098609924,
-0.3914279043674469,
-0.5675243139266968,
-0.11810258775949478,
-0.9381447434425354,
-0.9912462830543518,
-0.37687045335769653,
0.2406926155090332,
-0.07673369348049164,
-0.39853590726852417,
-0.2527267634868622,
-0.42984697222709656,
0.3687106966972351,
0.41671180725097656,
-0.5077438950538635,
0.06298211961984634,
0.8822705149650574,
0.8827822208404541,
-0.609910786151886,
0.0243392251431942,
-0.509316623210907,
-0.0893242210149765,
-0.1323375403881073,
0.6019916534423828,
-0.802352786064148,
-0.30467984080314636,
-0.1802435666322708,
-0.055615365505218506,
-0.030388329178094864,
-0.2689433693885803,
0.6426863074302673,
-0.63652104139328,
-0.13666391372680664,
-0.1944476068019867,
-0.49701622128486633,
-0.24722319841384888,
0.20762969553470612,
-0.5175740122795105,
0.8714267015457153,
-0.030403567478060722,
-0.7672930955886841,
0.6656783819198608,
-0.752177894115448,
-0.1704235076904297,
0.26493212580680847,
-0.10099557787179947,
-0.8999403715133667,
-0.008223598822951317,
-0.22403068840503693,
0.6336765289306641,
-0.05239638313651085,
0.39762401580810547,
-0.6899967193603516,
0.11696203052997589,
-0.058820709586143494,
-0.1410341113805771,
0.9514973759651184,
0.20116785168647766,
-0.6531524658203125,
0.6633330583572388,
-0.6531553864479065,
-0.2695440351963043,
0.3710545003414154,
-0.03234320506453514,
-0.17462913691997528,
0.22363901138305664,
0.26549196243286133,
0.26703622937202454,
0.10356586426496506,
-0.9221082925796509,
-0.13825994729995728,
0.26578494906425476,
0.588907778263092,
1.0404013395309448,
-0.10038863122463226,
0.16544540226459503,
-0.06885094940662384,
0.7033453583717346,
0.045218877494335175,
0.20982006192207336,
0.6358640789985657,
-0.6084800362586975,
-0.5054095387458801,
-0.15842849016189575,
-0.23642781376838684,
0.6711452603340149,
-0.40317484736442566,
-0.07137253135442734,
-0.09888383001089096,
-0.9021690487861633,
-0.0732201412320137,
0.16874144971370697,
0.2540161609649658,
0.43434450030326843,
0.3674755096435547,
0.09330455213785172,
-0.729533314704895,
-0.7907764315605164,
-0.503281831741333,
-0.3483935594558716,
0.4336230754852295,
0.1817629039287567,
0.7197743654251099,
-0.2885652184486389,
0.8647720217704773,
-0.20726798474788666,
0.1003289520740509,
-0.488799124956131,
0.3959823250770569,
-0.1262541115283966,
0.15352490544319153,
0.9380127787590027,
-1.3633854389190674,
-0.5761873722076416,
-0.08617932349443436,
-0.07362806051969528,
-0.10998471826314926,
0.25917163491249084,
-0.10802695155143738,
0.2760079801082611,
0.4010230600833893,
-0.28956693410873413,
0.5220468640327454,
0.5811458826065063,
-0.6216822862625122,
0.411507785320282,
0.6773733496665955,
0.3281692862510681,
-1.0571796894073486,
-0.19666719436645508,
0.35606130957603455,
-0.3374684154987335,
-1.1564688682556152,
-0.10252469033002853,
-0.322034627199173,
-0.05494741350412369,
-0.7274354696273804,
0.45257768034935,
0.002752911066636443,
0.0416930690407753,
-0.4031859040260315,
-0.026611562818288803,
-0.4963591694831848,
0.25707128643989563,
0.31452953815460205,
0.5746893286705017,
0.3480687141418457,
-0.5064271092414856,
0.3526662588119507,
0.19126027822494507,
-0.3046605587005615,
0.23548470437526703,
-0.3193773031234741,
0.34658682346343994,
-0.12368334084749222,
0.16088064014911652,
-1.113460898399353,
-0.2100623995065689,
0.5687516331672668,
-0.5682412385940552,
-0.12105374783277512,
-0.13958744704723358,
-0.5413036942481995,
-0.39555972814559937,
-0.2604738175868988,
0.3141077160835266,
0.26848071813583374,
-0.4117305874824524,
0.8209042549133301,
0.8549383878707886,
-0.1667713224887848,
-0.41202667355537415,
-0.4614441990852356,
0.06721523404121399,
-0.6390007138252258,
-0.34114378690719604,
0.33756232261657715,
-0.11886770278215408,
-0.4970628023147583,
-0.12645745277404785,
-0.09700746834278107,
-0.22790095210075378,
0.2581927180290222,
0.5955655574798584,
-0.023903094232082367,
0.05807431414723396,
-0.22305606305599213,
-0.2228843867778778,
0.27719956636428833,
0.11674351990222931,
0.015603028237819672,
0.6218932271003723,
-0.18430034816265106,
0.07316437363624573,
-0.47782570123672485,
0.4359026849269867,
0.7523806095123291,
0.1395009607076645,
0.8502563238143921,
1.025329351425171,
-0.5900892019271851,
0.0045435428619384766,
-0.38162946701049805,
0.1724313646554947,
-0.4341358542442322,
0.14889006316661835,
0.23788990080356598,
-1.1143574714660645,
0.6572555899620056,
0.31355395913124084,
0.23759815096855164,
0.4836898446083069,
0.6767559051513672,
0.10997570306062698,
1.055878758430481,
0.6395716071128845,
-0.40841206908226013,
0.7973446846008301,
-0.04681200906634331,
0.37088844180107117,
-0.32794713973999023,
-0.1837419867515564,
-0.7208476662635803,
-0.15725722908973694,
-0.4289451241493225,
-0.45093363523483276,
0.14757630228996277,
-0.3100552260875702,
-0.19941698014736176,
0.49891895055770874,
-0.37291133403778076,
0.15129920840263367,
0.33765941858291626,
-0.041698846966028214,
-0.02253316529095173,
-0.03731685131788254,
0.4514126181602478,
-0.013535641133785248,
-0.44557058811187744,
-0.38148918747901917,
0.5463228225708008,
0.2993606925010681,
0.029340004548430443,
0.12896978855133057,
0.48585742712020874,
0.8437381386756897,
0.5221824049949646,
-0.9302496314048767,
0.8517088890075684,
-0.19460828602313995,
-0.7347545623779297,
-0.39887523651123047,
-0.16562385857105255,
-0.6656639575958252,
0.24977079033851624,
-0.1317882388830185,
-0.7307470440864563,
0.19139306247234344,
0.24692538380622864,
-0.21210171282291412,
0.5689321756362915,
-0.3756674826145172,
0.9534502625465393,
0.008280192501842976,
-0.32749056816101074,
-0.4554472863674164,
-0.3884420692920685,
0.08474709838628769,
-0.12863661348819733,
0.6119892001152039,
-0.4178496301174164,
0.0021609182003885508,
0.898158073425293,
-0.12117892503738403,
1.1275840997695923,
-0.5115349888801575,
-0.16723765432834625,
0.3942062258720398,
-0.254028856754303,
0.49336209893226624,
-0.2580546438694,
-0.4603073298931122,
0.3646608293056488,
-0.3092498779296875,
-0.3355487585067749,
-0.09490413218736649,
0.5568086504936218,
-0.5962941646575928,
-0.6529946327209473,
-0.33054038882255554,
-0.3997112512588501,
-0.047691136598587036,
0.19052506983280182,
0.18318799138069153,
0.08760876208543777,
-0.563477635383606,
0.17496438324451447,
0.43998128175735474,
-0.057434819638729095,
0.505869448184967,
0.518284022808075,
-0.0040748026221990585,
-0.3363087475299835,
1.049778938293457,
0.1594100445508957,
0.19005048274993896,
0.1312045305967331,
0.4998036324977875,
-0.06514417380094528,
-0.8615840673446655,
-0.27247709035873413,
-0.16822415590286255,
-0.6555297374725342,
-0.161534383893013,
-0.8767430186271667,
-0.07338100671768188,
-0.6498078107833862,
-0.1744687408208847,
-0.22759196162223816,
-0.3049148917198181,
-0.4104279577732086,
-0.3945460617542267,
0.500546932220459,
0.587543249130249,
-0.25638526678085327,
0.45812365412712097,
-0.4194867014884949,
0.4630488455295563,
0.11979365348815918,
-0.1452001929283142,
-0.17882218956947327,
-0.42970818281173706,
-0.1581319272518158,
0.13302363455295563,
-0.42883673310279846,
-0.9543851613998413,
0.5402172803878784,
0.18313562870025635,
0.47231367230415344,
0.46230003237724304,
0.20331044495105743,
0.5906903147697449,
-0.42824870347976685,
1.0902841091156006,
0.13656727969646454,
-1.0750192403793335,
0.6773061752319336,
-0.7195560932159424,
-0.23792245984077454,
0.32806137204170227,
0.6307496428489685,
-0.23774805665016174,
-0.7643380761146545,
-0.8811722993850708,
-0.7714155912399292,
0.7487143874168396,
0.24684199690818787,
0.17378579080104828,
-0.07803245633840561,
0.24069982767105103,
0.18597468733787537,
0.45397093892097473,
-0.8609888553619385,
-0.2048049122095108,
-0.5174479484558105,
-0.022021709010004997,
-0.22259566187858582,
-0.1284787505865097,
-0.09184639900922775,
-0.3898623287677765,
0.8061160445213318,
-0.09914155304431915,
0.060726918280124664,
-0.14599330723285675,
0.27902916073799133,
-0.263250470161438,
0.4076555669307709,
0.7328168749809265,
0.4463163912296295,
-0.07148100435733795,
-0.039981625974178314,
0.09004859626293182,
-0.49013519287109375,
-0.03296272084116936,
-0.0028329298365861177,
-0.20280280709266663,
0.12851475179195404,
0.21348461508750916,
0.9725175499916077,
-0.2020864337682724,
-0.4583178162574768,
0.4098958969116211,
0.08487194031476974,
-0.3358747363090515,
-0.6294977068901062,
0.2518407702445984,
-0.06241222843527794,
0.3517940938472748,
0.35296905040740967,
-0.08580151200294495,
0.3962373435497284,
-0.7264241576194763,
-0.007288054563105106,
0.737166166305542,
-0.630664050579071,
-0.5749424695968628,
0.7072543501853943,
-0.04039933159947395,
-0.3073504865169525,
0.22837768495082855,
-0.18443085253238678,
-1.0518039464950562,
0.869073212146759,
0.1989067792892456,
0.8247008323669434,
-0.34017959237098694,
0.5197922587394714,
0.3806804418563843,
0.13826526701450348,
0.32018423080444336,
0.27275964617729187,
-0.18606151640415192,
-1.0681278705596924,
0.04663389176130295,
-0.6336610317230225,
-0.524951696395874,
0.4749862253665924,
-0.6911612749099731,
0.16678334772586823,
-0.6078634858131409,
-0.3132617473602295,
0.331103652715683,
0.04602935537695885,
-0.47125256061553955,
0.27564242482185364,
0.29200729727745056,
0.5265636444091797,
-1.1636383533477783,
0.5421658754348755,
0.7204174399375916,
0.04883703216910362,
-0.514785885810852,
0.08030728995800018,
0.48444098234176636,
-0.6232117414474487,
0.48611778020858765,
0.15791162848472595,
-0.44901272654533386,
0.04785812646150589,
-1.0340924263000488,
-0.43217551708221436,
0.9490404725074768,
0.18290488421916962,
-0.41728436946868896,
0.32114341855049133,
0.13987860083580017,
0.6184238195419312,
-0.37209653854370117,
-0.3877497911453247,
0.48470795154571533,
0.6334623694419861,
0.14773811399936676,
-0.6636349558830261,
0.04052023962140083,
-0.21664616465568542,
-0.2982011139392853,
0.3281499445438385,
-0.9918127059936523,
0.6698543429374695,
0.01899445615708828,
-0.42145177721977234,
-0.2305976152420044,
0.8073951005935669,
0.2547040581703186,
0.8174623847007751,
0.9115319848060608,
0.4504551291465759,
0.6115844249725342,
-0.006991478614509106,
0.8305100798606873,
0.00889600906521082,
0.18657593429088593,
0.7932127118110657,
-0.15741972625255585,
0.7181954383850098,
0.3839946389198303,
0.1310356855392456,
0.44131413102149963,
0.7742063999176025,
-0.14919418096542358,
0.4798372685909271,
0.2687980830669403,
-0.4482867419719696,
-0.7270717024803162,
-0.571910560131073,
0.0890851840376854,
0.3614470660686493,
0.6351231932640076,
-0.06445566564798355,
-0.1736914962530136,
0.20491641759872437,
0.1900174617767334,
0.1112641915678978,
-0.6633658409118652,
0.6216197609901428,
-0.08518510311841965,
-0.4740505516529083,
0.060807764530181885,
0.04133189097046852,
0.6167055368423462,
-0.2630142867565155,
0.09632658213376999,
0.3945332467556,
0.045071326196193695,
-0.3066384196281433,
-0.7586597800254822,
0.6174271106719971,
0.1938462257385254,
-0.3772517740726471,
-0.49695447087287903,
0.6590387225151062,
-0.19807521998882294,
-0.2446667104959488,
0.6075353622436523,
0.019156448543071747,
0.09777464717626572,
-0.07650882750749588,
-0.9240825772285461,
0.4071122705936432,
0.03300090879201889,
-0.31480079889297485,
0.3840460479259491,
0.11207570135593414,
-0.21080127358436584,
0.5343870520591736,
0.6114369630813599,
-0.1984407752752304,
0.21453219652175903,
0.21355967223644257,
0.767658531665802,
-0.46260780096054077,
-0.43349307775497437,
-0.8600307106971741,
0.20968370139598846,
-0.14498306810855865,
-0.17743200063705444,
0.8236840963363647,
0.5583528280258179,
0.6914467215538025,
0.03567277267575264,
0.8871548175811768,
-0.2829645276069641,
0.6968255639076233,
-0.35936298966407776,
0.5275105834007263,
-0.7501146197319031,
-0.3333391845226288,
-0.42084044218063354,
-0.42847779393196106,
-0.23856866359710693,
0.2974933981895447,
-0.4293561279773712,
-0.05081046000123024,
0.15071028470993042,
0.7048370838165283,
0.03148698806762695,
0.20339243113994598,
0.11344277113676071,
0.16762882471084595,
0.6345212459564209,
0.13429410755634308,
0.7044050097465515,
-0.09304849803447723,
0.5272818803787231,
-0.1889452040195465,
0.08814297616481781,
-0.2157112956047058,
-1.0356018543243408,
-0.8591213226318359,
-0.7173212170600891,
-0.8175737857818604,
-0.3609607219696045,
0.034344423562288284,
0.7376275658607483,
0.6297406554222107,
-1.002938151359558,
-0.0020149804186075926,
-0.2908897399902344,
0.25156450271606445,
-0.09338682144880295,
-0.2774182856082916,
0.19857007265090942,
0.24006877839565277,
-0.8692831993103027,
0.555718719959259,
0.0580395832657814,
0.03252639248967171,
0.07000238448381424,
0.016667885705828667,
-0.3657815158367157,
0.31746941804885864,
0.4589986801147461,
0.4800671935081482,
-0.8417326211929321,
-0.5424321293830872,
-0.21212135255336761,
0.11564286798238754,
-0.04920278489589691,
0.86479651927948,
-0.4151972532272339,
-0.11565695703029633,
0.6324523091316223,
0.5137475728988647,
0.23323556780815125,
0.20605720579624176,
0.25391092896461487,
-0.42749983072280884,
0.09007041156291962,
0.31769347190856934,
0.2409333437681198,
0.34313029050827026,
-0.5395753383636475,
0.43230974674224854,
0.4370971918106079,
-0.4220770597457886,
-0.9827974438667297,
0.2700709402561188,
-1.146525263786316,
-0.21761369705200195,
1.2347991466522217,
0.09930086880922318,
-0.1929982751607895,
-0.33500930666923523,
0.08039814233779907,
0.31796982884407043,
-0.5956462621688843,
0.6128233671188354,
0.9960918426513672,
-0.2875116765499115,
-0.36244988441467285,
-0.5705400109291077,
0.4825936555862427,
0.27641910314559937,
-0.5508805513381958,
0.11053770035505295,
0.5969632863998413,
0.20669831335544586,
0.42249026894569397,
0.559014081954956,
0.21180017292499542,
0.20405107736587524,
-0.3595961630344391,
0.026502491906285286,
-0.02548123523592949,
-0.3791549801826477,
-0.15456293523311615,
0.4046575129032135,
-0.4086378216743469,
-0.1047258973121643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17013v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17013v1
|
Towards Explainability and Fairness in Swiss Judgement Prediction: Benchmarking on a Multilingual Dataset
| 2024-02-26T20:42:40 | 2024-02-26T20:42:40 |
Santosh T. Y. S. S, Nina Baumgartner, Matthias Stürmer, Matthias Grabmair, Joel Niklaus
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2
|
The assessment of explainability in Legal Judgement Prediction (LJP) systems
is of paramount importance in building trustworthy and transparent systems,
particularly considering the reliance of these systems on factors that may lack
legal relevance or involve sensitive attributes. This study delves into the
realm of explainability and fairness in LJP models, utilizing Swiss Judgement
Prediction (SJP), the only available multilingual LJP dataset. We curate a
comprehensive collection of rationales that `support' and `oppose' judgement
from legal experts for 108 cases in German, French, and Italian. By employing
an occlusion-based explainability approach, we evaluate the explainability
performance of state-of-the-art monolingual and multilingual BERT-based LJP
models, as well as models developed with techniques such as data augmentation
and cross-lingual transfer, which demonstrated prediction performance
improvement. Notably, our findings reveal that improved prediction performance
does not necessarily correspond to enhanced explainability performance,
underscoring the significance of evaluating models from an explainability
perspective. Additionally, we introduce a novel evaluation framework, Lower
Court Insertion (LCI), which allows us to quantify the influence of lower court
information on model predictions, exposing current models' biases.
|
[
-0.544216513633728,
-0.3317246437072754,
0.7760270237922668,
0.1233624741435051,
-0.18891653418540955,
-0.20314565300941467,
-0.19552825391292572,
-0.8505454659461975,
-0.08796800673007965,
0.34212809801101685,
-0.4038824439048767,
-0.28286904096603394,
-0.7509486079216003,
-0.21663208305835724,
-0.28940510749816895,
1.1006526947021484,
-0.051409486681222916,
0.6792435050010681,
-0.32663267850875854,
-0.5591443777084351,
-0.27875107526779175,
-0.5380499958992004,
-0.30563241243362427,
-0.5084947347640991,
0.437850683927536,
0.16298647224903107,
0.8586673140525818,
0.49038881063461304,
0.1921018362045288,
0.23262958228588104,
-0.22006075084209442,
-0.4110673666000366,
-0.22684696316719055,
-0.12087782472372055,
-0.4997980296611786,
-0.6278916597366333,
-0.3778785765171051,
-0.3543386161327362,
0.5388083457946777,
1.0037901401519775,
-0.5181095004081726,
-0.027942176908254623,
-0.18705931305885315,
1.081026554107666,
-0.789250373840332,
0.17646749317646027,
-0.5532585978507996,
0.5252730846405029,
-0.07157589495182037,
0.21689756214618683,
-0.4514962434768677,
-0.37998372316360474,
0.07400745153427124,
-0.5238788723945618,
0.30600306391716003,
0.22673337161540985,
0.6022903919219971,
-0.06220781430602074,
-0.19594593346118927,
-0.2903648316860199,
-0.3639508783817291,
0.49125468730926514,
-0.8756968379020691,
0.5564417243003845,
0.08077138662338257,
0.905244767665863,
0.008666519075632095,
-0.46694111824035645,
-0.4929078221321106,
-0.17711687088012695,
-0.19541524350643158,
0.4502190947532654,
-0.34564533829689026,
-0.1461656093597412,
0.48647353053092957,
-0.011520239524543285,
-0.5999549031257629,
0.4026682674884796,
-0.21577827632427216,
-0.2315356731414795,
0.5994494557380676,
-0.3036669194698334,
0.09765702486038208,
-0.0710650235414505,
-0.26261401176452637,
0.20778018236160278,
-0.6076252460479736,
0.4641941487789154,
0.7648119330406189,
0.4920683801174164,
-0.046930886805057526,
0.4464612305164337,
-0.3334495723247528,
0.5643371343612671,
0.11457531899213791,
-0.07240712642669678,
0.17909185588359833,
-0.11740132421255112,
-0.10499992966651917,
0.6290156841278076,
0.5087548494338989,
0.4854130446910858,
0.38023269176483154,
-0.1685379147529602,
-0.060097768902778625,
-0.21016475558280945,
-0.023740053176879883,
-0.9006375074386597,
0.18093548715114594,
0.24029023945331573,
-0.8039846420288086,
-0.15571945905685425,
0.23487906157970428,
-0.6188830733299255,
-0.7469286322593689,
-0.23350627720355988,
-0.059240736067295074,
-0.42962437868118286,
-0.31800928711891174,
0.48508355021476746,
-0.17910687625408173,
0.14627668261528015,
0.4320758879184723,
-0.7389332056045532,
0.32994160056114197,
0.5380241274833679,
0.2714560031890869,
0.029714222997426987,
-0.20978406071662903,
-0.49511054158210754,
0.15909212827682495,
-0.09208978712558746,
0.783085823059082,
-0.30525603890419006,
-0.2834815979003906,
0.33441558480262756,
0.1945652961730957,
0.09123203903436661,
-0.5159398317337036,
0.8803591728210449,
-0.5542942881584167,
0.18028318881988525,
-0.33350101113319397,
-0.37847593426704407,
-0.4868062138557434,
-0.023935582488775253,
-0.7411198019981384,
0.42217347025871277,
0.031620245426893234,
-0.9627752900123596,
0.9121735095977783,
-0.7035676836967468,
-0.684459388256073,
0.10727406293153763,
-0.13397693634033203,
-0.3972007930278778,
0.3157244324684143,
0.3649844527244568,
0.36880794167518616,
-0.15111374855041504,
0.772709846496582,
-0.8221843242645264,
-0.4228443503379822,
0.262033611536026,
-0.49511829018592834,
1.022530198097229,
0.2936457097530365,
-0.3014426529407501,
-0.1000988632440567,
-0.7286562323570251,
0.04457293078303337,
0.09968806803226471,
-0.003127551870420575,
-0.0329320952296257,
0.24752426147460938,
-0.016402097418904305,
0.38918057084083557,
0.04995798319578171,
-0.49307751655578613,
-0.2762289345264435,
-0.545369029045105,
0.35211652517318726,
0.8936144113540649,
-0.44455328583717346,
0.396475613117218,
-0.20538052916526794,
0.7224622368812561,
0.09233777970075607,
0.2855137288570404,
-0.1236748993396759,
-0.4402882158756256,
-0.4467363655567169,
0.08965137600898743,
0.652815580368042,
0.6288869380950928,
-0.6039489507675171,
0.04852114990353584,
-0.6455737352371216,
-0.2693423926830292,
-0.5607660412788391,
-0.09617660939693451,
0.4244396686553955,
0.5277639031410217,
0.04060095548629761,
-0.3202199935913086,
-0.3781406581401825,
-1.4682399034500122,
-0.798924446105957,
-0.33368751406669617,
0.13024082779884338,
0.38854172825813293,
0.6364501118659973,
0.2914736270904541,
0.7571945190429688,
0.09642618149518967,
0.19486168026924133,
-0.47584593296051025,
-0.020136771723628044,
0.6198564767837524,
0.2563985586166382,
0.8268323540687561,
-1.0123475790023804,
-0.3872738182544708,
0.25814148783683777,
-0.8252241015434265,
-0.06123674288392067,
0.06382688879966736,
0.05290541052818298,
0.23110175132751465,
0.17437556385993958,
-0.0070198229514062405,
0.6062917113304138,
0.003323158249258995,
-0.48830848932266235,
0.6528835892677307,
-0.33255356550216675,
0.2867873013019562,
-0.4484647810459137,
-0.12840376794338226,
0.0033258055336773396,
-0.3691693842411041,
-0.46021172404289246,
0.208945170044899,
0.21149420738220215,
0.011480345390737057,
-0.8284836411476135,
0.4337782859802246,
-0.1698075830936432,
-0.5076208710670471,
0.0015805517323315144,
0.2271709442138672,
0.11185044795274734,
0.3440714478492737,
-0.05101313069462776,
0.33732783794403076,
0.5513019561767578,
-0.36406591534614563,
0.036234669387340546,
-0.07120373100042343,
-0.7235199809074402,
1.0172258615493774,
-0.4881574213504791,
-0.46238794922828674,
-0.3349197506904602,
0.19462499022483826,
-0.5612421631813049,
-0.20290736854076385,
0.10255894064903259,
-0.4164562225341797,
0.3293095827102661,
-0.49323001503944397,
-0.6944875717163086,
-0.2813904583454132,
-0.10485293716192245,
0.33715206384658813,
0.29950982332229614,
-0.6380031108856201,
0.8251830339431763,
0.32793527841567993,
-0.3130072057247162,
-0.8923665881156921,
-0.8676394820213318,
0.09476342052221298,
-0.5334138870239258,
-0.7006190419197083,
0.3764176368713379,
-0.2016557902097702,
-0.4876689314842224,
-0.022543445229530334,
-0.004245081916451454,
-0.2709645628929138,
0.3581978976726532,
0.37778303027153015,
0.03797781467437744,
-0.18364377319812775,
0.10967492312192917,
0.3275997042655945,
-0.07406175881624222,
0.3677344024181366,
0.025218989700078964,
0.05715423449873924,
-0.3106542229652405,
-0.7277034521102905,
-0.5976918935775757,
0.46822085976600647,
0.1637495458126068,
0.10962840169668198,
0.47988826036453247,
0.3557135760784149,
-0.394095778465271,
-0.048581913113594055,
-0.39577990770339966,
0.24663636088371277,
-0.3363580107688904,
0.22554999589920044,
-0.7478920817375183,
-0.6999602913856506,
0.8500275611877441,
0.11493457853794098,
-0.13435541093349457,
0.7309613823890686,
0.4158902168273926,
0.08556833118200302,
1.3059163093566895,
0.47823280096054077,
-0.01544852927327156,
0.2306050956249237,
0.2587078809738159,
0.3964041769504547,
-0.17260463535785675,
-0.18891483545303345,
-0.6443994641304016,
0.06557194888591766,
-0.8993355631828308,
0.026495670899748802,
0.10671178996562958,
0.3983827233314514,
-0.15609705448150635,
0.05189664661884308,
-0.2711416184902191,
0.5895978212356567,
0.45670533180236816,
0.013546654023230076,
0.4568142890930176,
0.0572722852230072,
-0.48212695121765137,
-0.06580261141061783,
-0.9312662482261658,
-0.415170818567276,
0.9927324652671814,
0.44945526123046875,
0.4246334135532379,
0.20587258040905,
0.5917152166366577,
0.36099761724472046,
0.2808417081832886,
-0.5579745769500732,
0.28124770522117615,
-0.2998080551624298,
-0.6517557501792908,
-0.051902759820222855,
-0.24096989631652832,
-0.454033762216568,
0.45627328753471375,
-0.4209249019622803,
-0.8016005158424377,
0.41117075085639954,
-0.06181495636701584,
-0.5576750040054321,
0.21931815147399902,
-0.7025260329246521,
0.7640978097915649,
-0.44175729155540466,
-0.6002368330955505,
-0.3048316538333893,
-0.6539779305458069,
0.46670737862586975,
-0.17400816082954407,
1.0024038553237915,
-0.24866610765457153,
0.2962108850479126,
0.5993665456771851,
-0.3857367932796478,
0.47752243280410767,
-0.41118866205215454,
-0.25533416867256165,
-0.03543367236852646,
0.12108127027750015,
0.2080075442790985,
0.21442048251628876,
-0.5713496804237366,
0.30057716369628906,
0.3113909065723419,
-0.3892311751842499,
-0.8859853148460388,
0.8325444459915161,
-0.3227151930332184,
-0.5392805933952332,
-0.49496862292289734,
-0.38162580132484436,
-0.08380461484193802,
0.17717674374580383,
-0.002780004870146513,
0.16347253322601318,
-0.27755847573280334,
-0.04445555433630943,
0.46422991156578064,
-0.4357307255268097,
0.34147214889526367,
0.9134975075721741,
-0.35321497917175293,
-0.2392609715461731,
0.8954261541366577,
0.33289194107055664,
-0.041024383157491684,
0.10330830514431,
0.19896061718463898,
-0.5048103332519531,
-0.7895402312278748,
-0.6168802976608276,
0.029519466683268547,
-1.068947196006775,
0.15052731335163116,
-0.3137415945529938,
0.004375859629362822,
-0.3372647166252136,
-0.31754446029663086,
-0.12825536727905273,
-0.915287435054779,
0.331082820892334,
-0.2851913571357727,
-0.05385139212012291,
0.6269358992576599,
-0.3572060763835907,
0.1618482917547226,
-0.3380182683467865,
0.22274157404899597,
0.032435342669487,
0.7402988076210022,
-0.1815910041332245,
-0.7695780992507935,
-0.3070699870586395,
-0.03080718219280243,
0.07161477953195572,
-0.44173797965049744,
0.10506957024335861,
-0.04595931991934776,
0.7451236248016357,
0.6485483646392822,
0.15968279540538788,
0.706782341003418,
-0.7402787804603577,
0.6350964307785034,
0.4101906716823578,
-0.9710376262664795,
0.6613060832023621,
-0.21877045929431915,
-0.03766332566738129,
0.6890762448310852,
0.16414332389831543,
-0.12636269629001617,
-0.38742756843566895,
-0.7376794815063477,
-0.7712802290916443,
1.0095463991165161,
-0.059131525456905365,
-0.10606638342142105,
0.4547027051448822,
0.4054536521434784,
0.7264306545257568,
0.2636917233467102,
-1.018043875694275,
-0.05741887912154198,
-0.2391299605369568,
0.17858752608299255,
-0.13131578266620636,
-0.2356472760438919,
-0.21549364924430847,
-0.1663709580898285,
0.7127156257629395,
-0.03772830218076706,
0.12934747338294983,
-0.11109540611505508,
-0.2608042061328888,
0.08222705125808716,
0.573632538318634,
0.4977194666862488,
1.1400651931762695,
-0.38516876101493835,
-0.11658138781785965,
0.19284923374652863,
0.15320713818073273,
-0.1443294882774353,
0.5564702153205872,
-0.13115684688091278,
0.13006669282913208,
0.5676339864730835,
0.7163271903991699,
0.02105128765106201,
-0.7928489446640015,
0.6331872940063477,
-0.24733726680278778,
-0.5761309862136841,
-0.5543882250785828,
0.048143524676561356,
-0.1458209753036499,
0.4527587294578552,
0.15411576628684998,
0.08685082942247391,
0.5994325280189514,
-0.5133056044578552,
0.0631418228149414,
0.27549105882644653,
-0.7806971669197083,
0.0453590489923954,
0.8642688393592834,
-0.17259371280670166,
0.05633104220032692,
0.044047627598047256,
-0.07009667158126831,
-0.3431466221809387,
0.6100428104400635,
0.07578420639038086,
0.48218265175819397,
0.028442488983273506,
0.24905940890312195,
0.2745876610279083,
0.12057989835739136,
-0.15072588622570038,
0.25214630365371704,
-0.0630294680595398,
-0.7248880863189697,
-0.4048057794570923,
-0.3362457752227783,
-0.28661590814590454,
-0.20336143672466278,
-1.1934804916381836,
-0.0040076118893921375,
-0.218793585896492,
-0.060580063611269,
0.4067092835903168,
-0.21072234213352203,
-0.8018266558647156,
0.2176537811756134,
0.08342815190553665,
1.1180438995361328,
-0.8066890239715576,
0.7168193459510803,
0.25564736127853394,
-0.3718520402908325,
-0.0953027680516243,
-0.15460649132728577,
-0.10550782084465027,
-1.0693066120147705,
0.6454249024391174,
0.3741898834705353,
-0.13290688395500183,
-0.6877228617668152,
-0.3226231038570404,
-0.188851460814476,
0.7676582932472229,
0.8069040775299072,
-0.6801454424858093,
0.11476222425699234,
0.18505597114562988,
0.5443575382232666,
-0.31656891107559204,
0.3095569610595703,
0.6147368550300598,
0.8907228708267212,
-0.051809269934892654,
-0.7316921353340149,
0.04278963804244995,
-0.2423952966928482,
0.010407873429358006,
-0.1377403736114502,
-0.22415706515312195,
0.2717297375202179,
-0.5230532884597778,
-0.1868705004453659,
0.007351098582148552,
0.4442788362503052,
0.17009136080741882,
0.6036439538002014,
0.6747561097145081,
0.6234085559844971,
0.6794765591621399,
-0.38660019636154175,
1.4784352779388428,
-0.39122474193573,
0.09274329990148544,
1.3182148933410645,
-0.45433640480041504,
0.7131378650665283,
0.6350044012069702,
-0.3259497284889221,
0.7299947142601013,
0.7427712678909302,
-0.04296785965561867,
0.5865744352340698,
0.43411925435066223,
0.03745540231466293,
-0.40973609685897827,
-0.36066940426826477,
-0.4069637656211853,
0.33006781339645386,
0.040909718722105026,
-0.5410574674606323,
-0.18923096358776093,
0.04262956976890564,
-0.0284062922000885,
0.40463685989379883,
-0.4463256895542145,
0.6244750618934631,
-0.17153917253017426,
-0.700189471244812,
0.22448882460594177,
0.1684093326330185,
0.1740778684616089,
-0.44935235381126404,
-0.019660435616970062,
-0.09946102648973465,
0.20390625298023224,
-0.22216419875621796,
-0.9729628562927246,
0.12313155084848404,
-0.23828157782554626,
-0.5096923112869263,
-0.4844774007797241,
0.4364146888256073,
-0.010091475211083889,
-0.6994598507881165,
0.7056471705436707,
0.6535343527793884,
0.2218032032251358,
0.1795724630355835,
-1.1779308319091797,
-0.23840051889419556,
0.012197459116578102,
-0.056572578847408295,
0.636188805103302,
0.6934423446655273,
-0.08723980188369751,
0.735050618648529,
0.35665544867515564,
0.08336079120635986,
-0.2843201756477356,
0.550510048866272,
0.7856164574623108,
-0.6078978180885315,
-0.5384001135826111,
-0.789867103099823,
0.6960783004760742,
-0.10191022604703903,
0.14698518812656403,
0.49592775106430054,
0.5937248468399048,
0.774410605430603,
0.14258144795894623,
0.993053674697876,
0.05642452836036682,
0.7708132266998291,
-0.7847829461097717,
0.6981623768806458,
-0.6241199970245361,
0.37007632851600647,
-0.07696603983640671,
-0.4624573290348053,
-0.2605629861354828,
0.5923358798027039,
-0.35813888907432556,
0.2448093444108963,
0.4956822097301483,
0.4481446444988251,
-0.11685976386070251,
0.24679821729660034,
0.41239792108535767,
0.19163767993450165,
0.03611081838607788,
0.5734620094299316,
0.7236735224723816,
-0.14539845287799835,
0.5598320960998535,
-0.24188239872455597,
-0.13731029629707336,
-0.27373597025871277,
-1.1813210248947144,
-0.7441859841346741,
-0.07052268832921982,
-0.04090847820043564,
-0.39365944266319275,
0.24881866574287415,
0.07807295769453049,
0.6197601556777954,
-1.165173888206482,
-0.27644777297973633,
-0.03460222855210304,
0.44966426491737366,
-0.24875949323177338,
-0.2222253978252411,
0.3564739525318146,
-0.23763078451156616,
-0.4805636703968048,
0.3726089298725128,
0.16744360327720642,
-0.03834299370646477,
-0.11119182407855988,
-0.28997695446014404,
0.022173728793859482,
-0.1376243382692337,
0.4793684184551239,
0.19128267467021942,
-1.019980549812317,
-0.14807401597499847,
-0.694273054599762,
0.5088618993759155,
0.12949109077453613,
0.6825484037399292,
-0.583724856376648,
0.9648398160934448,
0.1691242754459381,
0.23597730696201324,
0.4461157023906708,
-0.2319013625383377,
0.9999154210090637,
-0.23078766465187073,
0.2710433006286621,
0.009411304257810116,
0.9969320297241211,
0.13833539187908173,
-0.1490563601255417,
0.6774580478668213,
-0.05895412340760231,
-0.1818840503692627,
-0.866718053817749,
0.2873859405517578,
-0.6664637327194214,
-0.6288938522338867,
0.47953954339027405,
-0.5786119103431702,
-0.026570241898298264,
-0.2737274169921875,
0.031934041529893875,
-0.15582799911499023,
-0.5071590542793274,
0.6037731170654297,
1.0562949180603027,
-0.09173153340816498,
-0.0455341599881649,
-1.0965595245361328,
0.4014686346054077,
0.3456951677799225,
-0.4860139489173889,
0.1262613981962204,
0.5726040601730347,
0.158781498670578,
0.07831526547670364,
0.27128762006759644,
-0.2866092324256897,
0.4940461218357086,
-0.29481205344200134,
0.026702865958213806,
-0.021136699244379997,
-0.07960296422243118,
-0.6666136980056763,
0.42612069845199585,
-0.005466175265610218,
0.47122639417648315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17011v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17011v1
|
DiffuCOMET: Contextual Commonsense Knowledge Diffusion
| 2024-02-26T20:35:34 | 2024-02-26T20:35:34 |
Silin Gao, Mete Ismayilzada, Mengjie Zhao, Hiromi Wakaki, Yuki Mitsufuji, Antoine Bosselut
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Inferring contextually-relevant and diverse commonsense to understand
narratives remains challenging for knowledge models. In this work, we develop a
series of knowledge models, DiffuCOMET, that leverage diffusion to learn to
reconstruct the implicit semantic connections between narrative contexts and
relevant commonsense knowledge. Across multiple diffusion steps, our method
progressively refines a representation of commonsense facts that is anchored to
a narrative, producing contextually-relevant and diverse commonsense inferences
for an input context. To evaluate DiffuCOMET, we introduce new metrics for
commonsense inference that more closely measure knowledge diversity and
contextual relevance. Our results on two different benchmarks, ComFact and
WebNLG+, show that knowledge generated by DiffuCOMET achieves a better
trade-off between commonsense diversity, contextual relevance and alignment to
known gold references, compared to baseline knowledge models.
|
[
-0.15641139447689056,
-0.5556231141090393,
0.7259687781333923,
-0.15111438930034637,
-0.11616376787424088,
0.0013359744334593415,
0.23045510053634644,
-0.2841583788394928,
-0.2206113040447235,
0.03344563767313957,
-0.6906169652938843,
-0.3193216025829315,
-0.8374922871589661,
-0.11669664084911346,
-0.5450606942176819,
1.1739403009414673,
0.12402419000864029,
-0.10827847570180893,
-0.43032294511795044,
-0.364300400018692,
-0.2916114628314972,
0.016179006546735764,
-0.1668645143508911,
-0.46295619010925293,
0.5971775054931641,
0.17019614577293396,
0.6656509041786194,
0.33500581979751587,
0.09614824503660202,
0.28949153423309326,
-0.46167832612991333,
0.17032493650913239,
-0.7880098223686218,
0.17276686429977417,
-0.613982617855072,
-0.12955260276794434,
0.09902649372816086,
0.07045750319957733,
0.31672340631484985,
1.1481298208236694,
-0.3302910625934601,
0.2334972769021988,
0.19437070190906525,
0.7016646265983582,
-0.6343268156051636,
-0.2236078530550003,
-0.47324588894844055,
-0.1261294186115265,
-0.01987493596971035,
0.2906518876552582,
-0.13849210739135742,
-0.5798501968383789,
0.6460816264152527,
-1.0457918643951416,
0.4888773560523987,
-0.09952416270971298,
0.4871166944503784,
0.450535386800766,
-0.8346596956253052,
-0.525581955909729,
-0.5040804743766785,
0.6751380562782288,
-0.5536375641822815,
0.294772744178772,
0.22329513728618622,
0.3039393723011017,
0.09576668590307236,
-1.1298528909683228,
-0.6933808922767639,
-0.21750491857528687,
-0.4228384792804718,
0.2305499166250229,
-0.41070735454559326,
-0.4463474154472351,
0.11286509782075882,
0.3336781859397888,
-0.4916073679924011,
-0.25147348642349243,
-0.34972110390663147,
-0.02244744636118412,
0.41980624198913574,
0.10523760318756104,
0.320375919342041,
-0.08441752940416336,
-0.7667522430419922,
0.0108356773853302,
-0.4221305549144745,
-0.3673233985900879,
0.39623868465423584,
-0.2613449990749359,
-0.12737122178077698,
0.16873575747013092,
-0.32959651947021484,
0.6941223740577698,
0.1806279718875885,
-0.39048901200294495,
0.4377308189868927,
-0.36363619565963745,
0.03427378460764885,
0.1662573218345642,
0.3274911344051361,
0.5291344523429871,
-0.1725287288427353,
-0.14973478019237518,
0.05763047933578491,
-0.16176865994930267,
0.13447508215904236,
-0.5207051038742065,
-0.24765731394290924,
0.007154372520744801,
-0.3882368206977844,
-0.11619456857442856,
-0.006700574886053801,
-0.7919756174087524,
-0.5671190023422241,
-0.33819347620010376,
0.47960084676742554,
-0.5408653616905212,
-0.6245816349983215,
0.23937854170799255,
-0.9503923654556274,
-0.03799420967698097,
0.7685800194740295,
-0.7019121050834656,
0.1714218407869339,
0.535751223564148,
0.9763302206993103,
-0.5238812565803528,
-0.28771400451660156,
-0.1804858297109604,
0.3079708516597748,
-0.026882659643888474,
0.7789687514305115,
-0.3296935260295868,
-0.19236962497234344,
0.0003356355591677129,
-0.15390656888484955,
-0.15953905880451202,
-0.5593916773796082,
0.39605221152305603,
-0.6265291571617126,
0.20008935034275055,
-0.6206900477409363,
-0.9185747504234314,
-0.47021204233169556,
0.2937183380126953,
-0.8350819945335388,
0.6471154689788818,
0.3462485373020172,
-0.8851457238197327,
0.6962799429893494,
-0.8732918500900269,
-0.49306735396385193,
0.12823103368282318,
0.4120933413505554,
0.07537607848644257,
0.059180859476327896,
-0.01608896069228649,
0.37233537435531616,
0.15502211451530457,
0.34103596210479736,
-0.32785865664482117,
-0.1488599181175232,
0.1552012711763382,
-0.6463533043861389,
0.8428180813789368,
0.38791540265083313,
-0.1197507232427597,
-0.4238996207714081,
-0.4874139130115509,
-0.927976131439209,
0.020559733733534813,
-0.05018921196460724,
-0.7126907706260681,
-0.17233799397945404,
-0.018360136076807976,
-0.13713383674621582,
0.06353048980236053,
-0.3579833507537842,
0.18488050997257233,
0.1377963274717331,
0.48705407977104187,
0.4208751618862152,
0.2079048603773117,
0.736498236656189,
-0.5671325325965881,
0.198448047041893,
0.37153854966163635,
0.1024981141090393,
0.0537080392241478,
-0.5882994532585144,
-0.19668810069561005,
-0.18779726326465607,
0.07606316357851028,
0.422507107257843,
-0.7650269865989685,
-0.22009190917015076,
-0.1213972344994545,
-0.43398088216781616,
-0.14493627846240997,
0.11215268075466156,
-0.016280878335237503,
1.0375288724899292,
0.5096972584724426,
0.0566675178706646,
-0.061292290687561035,
-0.6177528500556946,
-0.30164721608161926,
-0.06706792861223221,
-0.003612204920500517,
0.12984929978847504,
0.6970978379249573,
-0.26858898997306824,
1.0241146087646484,
-0.8465890884399414,
-0.0668347030878067,
-0.20789775252342224,
0.46698683500289917,
0.15394972264766693,
0.306580513715744,
0.6777417063713074,
-1.2541486024856567,
-0.32693716883659363,
-0.10382182896137238,
-0.5799559354782104,
-0.15445969998836517,
-0.14633968472480774,
-0.15642677247524261,
-0.3719061017036438,
0.5125992894172668,
-0.5295655131340027,
0.3537668287754059,
0.5107330083847046,
-0.5964707136154175,
0.492280513048172,
0.010536663234233856,
0.5114921927452087,
-1.022411584854126,
0.09067515283823013,
-0.19213177263736725,
-0.27364927530288696,
-0.556642472743988,
-0.1810968816280365,
-0.023038921877741814,
0.39205923676490784,
-0.8087013363838196,
0.9470230937004089,
-0.30913954973220825,
-0.050254933536052704,
0.2319335788488388,
0.6034095287322998,
0.2709333002567291,
0.13315241038799286,
0.1085735335946083,
0.5047386288642883,
0.27187907695770264,
-0.6820921301841736,
0.3666256070137024,
0.41324007511138916,
-0.510421872138977,
0.9552579522132874,
-0.30969351530075073,
-0.3459916412830353,
-0.1159718930721283,
0.29818665981292725,
-1.3796964883804321,
-0.2032853364944458,
-0.041978124529123306,
-0.2853730320930481,
-0.13558679819107056,
-0.6008551716804504,
-0.5112514495849609,
-0.04648677632212639,
-0.06956708431243896,
0.7183372974395752,
0.5959013104438782,
-0.8154628872871399,
0.4478679299354553,
0.04743075370788574,
-0.14285285770893097,
-0.5692591667175293,
-0.7677886486053467,
-0.3370289206504822,
-0.6008786559104919,
-0.61042320728302,
0.39222589135169983,
-0.14094889163970947,
-0.5282583832740784,
0.21072396636009216,
-0.16001218557357788,
-0.3726104497909546,
0.1856372207403183,
-0.02853553742170334,
-0.10012416541576385,
-0.14268110692501068,
0.5072004199028015,
0.6013579964637756,
0.044428516179323196,
-0.20218123495578766,
-0.4000808298587799,
0.09801884740591049,
0.2446313500404358,
-0.5687083601951599,
-0.08690398186445236,
0.23543819785118103,
0.4648257791996002,
0.10014989227056503,
0.7083415985107422,
0.902565598487854,
-0.03961489722132683,
-0.11914205551147461,
-0.5501410961151123,
-0.12326735258102417,
-0.39107272028923035,
0.189473494887352,
-0.07560044527053833,
-0.9513291120529175,
0.618082582950592,
-0.6593067049980164,
0.3248727321624756,
0.47613653540611267,
0.31979119777679443,
-0.24535220861434937,
0.20855732262134552,
0.17358709871768951,
0.3518562614917755,
0.3051563501358032,
-0.2767172157764435,
-0.15779004991054535,
-0.824201226234436,
-0.08568213135004044,
0.009895472787320614,
-0.3515571057796478,
-0.23827584087848663,
-0.5007176399230957,
0.16351169347763062,
0.3819721043109894,
-0.27789440751075745,
0.09306823462247849,
-0.25267109274864197,
0.5913237929344177,
0.44459134340286255,
0.20902085304260254,
0.905976414680481,
-0.1749052256345749,
-0.10556938499212265,
0.23729893565177917,
-0.7705538868904114,
-0.40965184569358826,
0.7887672185897827,
0.12951792776584625,
0.5690134763717651,
0.7918434143066406,
0.8245756030082703,
0.6037700772285461,
0.4629097878932953,
-0.3404909074306488,
0.014429260976612568,
-0.26613089442253113,
-0.685742974281311,
-0.27107590436935425,
-0.4303889274597168,
-0.9269101023674011,
0.34414616227149963,
-0.07888838648796082,
-0.6192586421966553,
0.18433646857738495,
0.1548205018043518,
-0.5333849191665649,
0.3500641882419586,
-0.9217711091041565,
0.857604444026947,
0.2428697645664215,
-0.5500303506851196,
-0.213099405169487,
-0.6047927737236023,
0.7041678428649902,
0.07145070284605026,
0.4155657887458801,
-0.1225438192486763,
-0.10672102868556976,
0.6305425763130188,
-0.2548723518848419,
0.9454973340034485,
-0.10495925694704056,
-0.0865514725446701,
0.35474613308906555,
0.4159312844276428,
0.10501663386821747,
0.5172327756881714,
-0.013203737325966358,
0.26699113845825195,
0.11544384807348251,
-0.4564023017883301,
-0.6219419836997986,
0.5598708391189575,
-0.5611016750335693,
-0.45240387320518494,
-0.36750614643096924,
-0.5968431234359741,
0.01215073186904192,
0.11403306573629379,
0.32415083050727844,
0.35268816351890564,
-0.4133314788341522,
0.001454077661037445,
0.8833455443382263,
-0.19406941533088684,
0.48611316084861755,
0.5254039764404297,
0.13051126897335052,
-0.1837121546268463,
0.43657973408699036,
-0.038762450218200684,
0.6116501688957214,
0.38558584451675415,
0.4422200918197632,
-0.6518051028251648,
-0.3671337366104126,
-0.4997116029262543,
0.07567387819290161,
-0.9159390330314636,
-0.320923388004303,
-0.6818602681159973,
0.05928622558712959,
-0.289175420999527,
-0.42470407485961914,
-0.23950104415416718,
-0.5140430331230164,
-0.278176873922348,
-0.34870806336402893,
0.8071386814117432,
0.9873601198196411,
-0.5644314885139465,
0.2346576303243637,
-0.6652131080627441,
0.4171549081802368,
0.5953359603881836,
0.14475418627262115,
0.19012147188186646,
-0.604852557182312,
-0.08136814087629318,
0.033485740423202515,
-0.2981387674808502,
-1.0847018957138062,
0.10420943796634674,
0.07456137984991074,
0.8137612342834473,
0.4161148965358734,
0.3182547688484192,
0.5541937351226807,
-0.3132518529891968,
0.9900795221328735,
0.28723347187042236,
-0.8055221438407898,
0.4595506191253662,
-0.46814078092575073,
0.5307148694992065,
0.6529659032821655,
0.6278496384620667,
-0.5155738592147827,
-0.23059594631195068,
-0.7240510582923889,
-0.8501814603805542,
0.2924407720565796,
0.31979888677597046,
0.248388409614563,
-0.21008294820785522,
0.23159213364124298,
0.6663652658462524,
0.20709501206874847,
-0.6128129363059998,
-0.2546736001968384,
-0.39868640899658203,
-0.3234911262989044,
0.1740076243877411,
-0.11858197301626205,
-0.2829626798629761,
-0.2590683102607727,
0.2597463130950928,
0.026680979877710342,
-0.24806265532970428,
0.2949460446834564,
-0.6155598759651184,
0.5521782040596008,
0.07632286101579666,
0.6276264190673828,
0.8610297441482544,
-0.06769092381000519,
0.2978051006793976,
0.4377797245979309,
-0.7394446134567261,
0.09342446178197861,
0.1569964736700058,
-0.20708581805229187,
0.08843781054019928,
0.733834981918335,
0.4362342059612274,
0.4622916281223297,
-0.48325681686401367,
0.6565068364143372,
-0.12260992079973221,
-0.43366146087646484,
0.034949373453855515,
0.14754365384578705,
0.5731862783432007,
0.6276596188545227,
0.4130859076976776,
0.14267437160015106,
0.6161449551582336,
-0.26243627071380615,
0.6076828837394714,
0.02194708213210106,
-0.19020378589630127,
0.19206076860427856,
0.35049617290496826,
0.42553043365478516,
0.2774502635002136,
0.5840198397636414,
-0.44142916798591614,
-0.35476163029670715,
0.46526584029197693,
0.15791629254817963,
0.5245058536529541,
-0.13055583834648132,
0.5443633794784546,
0.5950543284416199,
0.009672091342508793,
-0.37042883038520813,
-0.43946966528892517,
-0.4957687556743622,
-0.7819961309432983,
-0.12413351237773895,
-0.5064714550971985,
-0.18582656979560852,
-0.22783520817756653,
-0.6442109942436218,
-0.18334561586380005,
-0.02949482947587967,
-0.022629326209425926,
-0.12287748605012894,
-0.21149833500385284,
-0.697939932346344,
-0.02548317424952984,
-0.05600396916270256,
0.8251957893371582,
-1.0422146320343018,
0.5489553213119507,
0.2660844624042511,
-0.4680536985397339,
-0.3559792637825012,
0.146827831864357,
0.3248811662197113,
-0.5548784732818604,
0.9022930860519409,
-0.09966051578521729,
-0.029085859656333923,
-0.025250444188714027,
-0.15737700462341309,
-0.8638010025024414,
1.5977375507354736,
0.29897698760032654,
-0.6386690139770508,
0.2882861793041229,
-0.10159934312105179,
0.22500582039356232,
-0.2808856964111328,
0.42187851667404175,
0.5554580092430115,
0.47470664978027344,
0.6649293303489685,
-0.6127566695213318,
0.019699180498719215,
0.160923570394516,
-0.10137748718261719,
-0.056483592838048935,
-0.3283011019229889,
0.6281945705413818,
-0.36674076318740845,
-0.33519408106803894,
-0.06321647763252258,
0.5006549954414368,
0.35829174518585205,
0.6782689690589905,
0.5694300532341003,
0.7810089588165283,
0.908241868019104,
-0.025989847257733345,
0.6358288526535034,
0.1775301694869995,
0.3856201171875,
1.4243110418319702,
-0.1607368439435959,
0.602243959903717,
0.4887012243270874,
-0.07983831316232681,
0.8619098663330078,
0.5885080695152283,
-0.019024405628442764,
0.7614588141441345,
0.03403105586767197,
-0.44422006607055664,
-0.058313727378845215,
0.047670282423496246,
-0.3582826554775238,
0.18347419798374176,
0.11463414877653122,
-0.21840448677539825,
-0.6496551632881165,
-0.025554051622748375,
0.006889600306749344,
0.144990935921669,
-0.1096789762377739,
0.9715367555618286,
-0.024042930454015732,
-0.6461657285690308,
0.1940324455499649,
-0.617430567741394,
0.662645697593689,
-0.5498113632202148,
-0.40748482942581177,
-0.7663483619689941,
-0.04273170605301857,
-0.1642150729894638,
-1.0595226287841797,
0.39225444197654724,
-0.3292180597782135,
-0.2503289580345154,
-0.23055392503738403,
0.4944217801094055,
-0.5984914302825928,
-0.23444122076034546,
0.285100519657135,
0.6597788333892822,
-0.008495701476931572,
0.05438195541501045,
-0.6763041615486145,
-0.2856433689594269,
-0.03655534237623215,
-0.18868805468082428,
0.285221129655838,
0.8886746764183044,
0.2750284671783447,
0.49860239028930664,
0.6523318290710449,
-0.3154919147491455,
0.07669397443532944,
0.14904214441776276,
0.6620016098022461,
-0.3264603316783905,
-0.5103469491004944,
-0.9237150549888611,
0.908216655254364,
-0.4125773310661316,
-0.49259281158447266,
0.6199274063110352,
0.3064022660255432,
0.7458751201629639,
-0.17844946682453156,
0.6476874351501465,
-0.06233614310622215,
0.4554683566093445,
-0.5672638416290283,
1.0019605159759521,
-0.7456905841827393,
0.3492564857006073,
-0.43931931257247925,
-0.6178452372550964,
0.06109872832894325,
0.5473480820655823,
-0.15689358115196228,
0.07337608933448792,
0.578228235244751,
0.5448863506317139,
-0.43959441781044006,
-0.0083809494972229,
0.4098658263683319,
0.10982271283864975,
0.01873674988746643,
0.48357313871383667,
1.095847249031067,
-0.3294472396373749,
0.2726231515407562,
-0.001599509152583778,
-0.41160061955451965,
-0.12766024470329285,
-1.1023622751235962,
-0.589191198348999,
-0.8782997131347656,
-0.5270153284072876,
-0.03487025573849678,
0.11780936270952225,
0.22361288964748383,
0.741274356842041,
-0.28681957721710205,
0.04266577214002609,
-0.14730171859264374,
0.5856369137763977,
-0.3455888628959656,
-0.30014756321907043,
0.27074649930000305,
-0.20596280694007874,
-0.33985862135887146,
-0.02686084434390068,
0.0622936449944973,
0.16467583179473877,
-0.12418430298566818,
-0.18193764984607697,
-0.43779081106185913,
0.17196352779865265,
0.7750076055526733,
-0.17895402014255524,
-0.6949558854103088,
0.002033750992268324,
-0.2433713674545288,
0.17101798951625824,
-0.22838282585144043,
0.7245498299598694,
-0.8598959445953369,
0.22460994124412537,
0.580036461353302,
0.38934123516082764,
0.7322679758071899,
-0.011285030283033848,
0.46446171402931213,
-0.6817505955696106,
0.0804910883307457,
0.13534997403621674,
0.3690069019794464,
0.4164878726005554,
-0.4192616045475006,
0.5732390880584717,
0.480840265750885,
-0.28447747230529785,
-0.46376967430114746,
0.5125466585159302,
-0.9757387042045593,
-0.7973517179489136,
1.3320817947387695,
-0.25322091579437256,
0.005200166255235672,
-0.5537070631980896,
-0.012475877068936825,
0.15473125874996185,
-0.5343204736709595,
0.6198212504386902,
0.5809709429740906,
-0.08454038947820663,
-0.35724714398384094,
-0.4841402769088745,
0.7788025736808777,
-0.06828437000513077,
-0.737942636013031,
0.3014177680015564,
0.6367955207824707,
0.7431970834732056,
0.2369789332151413,
0.4658729135990143,
-0.06177712604403496,
0.33609509468078613,
0.38366663455963135,
-0.44458502531051636,
-0.06661336869001389,
0.06051097437739372,
0.09980695694684982,
0.13481810688972473,
-0.16566695272922516,
0.2031918317079544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17010v1
|
Can Large Language Models Recall Reference Location Like Humans?
| 2024-02-26T20:35:32 | 2024-02-26T20:35:32 |
Ye Wang, Xinrun Xu, Rui Xie, Wenxin Hu, Wei Ye
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
When completing knowledge-intensive tasks, humans sometimes need not just an
answer but also a corresponding reference passage for auxiliary reading.
Previous methods required obtaining pre-segmented article chunks through
additional retrieval models. This paper explores leveraging the parameterized
knowledge stored during the pre-training phase of large language models (LLMs)
to independently recall reference passage from any starting position. We
propose a two-stage framework that simulates the scenario of humans recalling
easily forgotten references. Initially, the LLM is prompted to recall document
title identifiers to obtain a coarse-grained document set. Then, based on the
acquired coarse-grained document set, it recalls fine-grained passage. In the
two-stage recall process, we use constrained decoding to ensure that content
outside of the stored documents is not generated. To increase speed, we only
recall a short prefix in the second stage, then locate its position to retrieve
a complete passage. Experiments on KILT knowledge-sensitive tasks have verified
that LLMs can independently recall reference passage location in various task
forms, and the obtained reference significantly assist downstream tasks.
|
[
-0.06554747372865677,
-0.42948517203330994,
0.8397943377494812,
-0.08777879178524017,
-0.30667251348495483,
-0.3069073259830475,
-0.23930850625038147,
-0.5055688619613647,
0.008759635500609875,
0.715425431728363,
-0.4519604742527008,
-0.26858341693878174,
-0.4894944131374359,
0.0757475197315216,
-0.473226934671402,
0.7074657082557678,
-0.031092412769794464,
-0.2175375521183014,
-0.2850759029388428,
0.16023777425289154,
-0.16245947778224945,
-0.6762205362319946,
-0.810820460319519,
-0.4989977180957794,
0.8467530012130737,
0.3891231119632721,
0.35497117042541504,
0.8074250221252441,
0.23580673336982727,
0.2483801692724228,
0.03230184316635132,
0.14853155612945557,
-0.3776434659957886,
0.2254115641117096,
-0.47520384192466736,
-0.6568392515182495,
-0.09828248620033264,
-0.03605261817574501,
0.8761037588119507,
0.5936744809150696,
-0.209796741604805,
-0.11460983753204346,
0.10058228671550751,
0.5256639719009399,
-0.5836894512176514,
0.15338945388793945,
-0.9269912838935852,
-0.16781966388225555,
-0.11136975884437561,
-0.3557824492454529,
-0.5610107779502869,
-0.11361232399940491,
0.17558524012565613,
-0.5174698829650879,
0.48972415924072266,
0.14299583435058594,
0.8710951805114746,
0.16765573620796204,
-0.5074818134307861,
-0.35765358805656433,
-0.7419716715812683,
0.5705460906028748,
-0.5176026225090027,
0.6027055978775024,
0.9527269601821899,
-0.05843351408839226,
-0.03843092545866966,
-0.6793432235717773,
-0.5314396619796753,
-0.23889778554439545,
-0.3417772352695465,
-0.31533515453338623,
0.4330746531486511,
-0.16804470121860504,
0.2003515511751175,
-0.28637000918388367,
-0.1737930029630661,
-0.06487898528575897,
-0.5160679817199707,
-0.25058096647262573,
0.39025381207466125,
-0.06630481779575348,
-0.016847919672727585,
-0.24088630080223083,
-0.2699555456638336,
-0.3259226083755493,
-0.8601787090301514,
0.05107204243540764,
0.16120654344558716,
0.36938005685806274,
0.1016845628619194,
0.16972658038139343,
-0.1747523546218872,
0.5473856329917908,
0.28226932883262634,
-0.2774326503276825,
0.18269918859004974,
-0.31245338916778564,
0.11274390667676926,
-0.07316466420888901,
0.621260941028595,
-0.2374507635831833,
0.3167165517807007,
-0.439008891582489,
-0.2906261384487152,
-0.7779368758201599,
0.6102756857872009,
-0.5981303453445435,
-0.25894343852996826,
-0.23313623666763306,
-0.19972363114356995,
0.2768653929233551,
0.010723354294896126,
-0.29792138934135437,
-0.4772967994213104,
-0.4307706654071808,
0.3028578460216522,
-0.546407163143158,
0.02423960156738758,
-0.015996398404240608,
0.06989508122205734,
0.24379248917102814,
0.33406001329421997,
-1.1297245025634766,
0.10595233738422394,
0.6187850832939148,
0.5301733613014221,
-0.06639833003282547,
-0.6458903551101685,
-0.5540752410888672,
0.6923257112503052,
-0.24492791295051575,
0.7082185745239258,
-0.7253638505935669,
-0.35589584708213806,
-0.04775024577975273,
0.04241399094462395,
-0.19396349787712097,
-0.5264090299606323,
0.5022627115249634,
-1.0162885189056396,
-0.1695479303598404,
-0.5625759959220886,
-0.4146840572357178,
-0.24457846581935883,
0.42567014694213867,
-0.6159711480140686,
0.9353089928627014,
-0.09670590609312057,
-0.7856791615486145,
0.16007785499095917,
0.08490272611379623,
-0.4713520407676697,
-0.36682990193367004,
-0.3518482744693756,
-0.17509129643440247,
0.048466961830854416,
0.1518055945634842,
0.427638441324234,
-0.2750268578529358,
0.17584961652755737,
-0.0951780304312706,
-0.30805715918540955,
0.08310233056545258,
-0.28786367177963257,
0.3236856162548065,
-0.13690511882305145,
-0.029212454333901405,
-0.19986900687217712,
-0.7227556109428406,
-0.036927975714206696,
-0.02422495372593403,
-0.70211261510849,
-0.9194931387901306,
0.21045096218585968,
-0.46772176027297974,
0.4020101726055145,
0.35359862446784973,
-0.3990676701068878,
0.10587642341852188,
0.0588371604681015,
0.1293584555387497,
0.5265206694602966,
0.25331392884254456,
0.5917339324951172,
-0.21257396042346954,
0.21393346786499023,
0.1607232242822647,
-0.2732016444206238,
-0.3357885777950287,
0.12865129113197327,
-1.0851589441299438,
0.1114526093006134,
0.15246015787124634,
0.4865652918815613,
-0.8754284977912903,
0.26151514053344727,
-0.3480890989303589,
-0.22014471888542175,
-0.10480067133903503,
0.42823630571365356,
0.5270324945449829,
0.5567837357521057,
0.23257514834403992,
-0.025900131091475487,
-0.4440673291683197,
-0.8202433586120605,
0.16556695103645325,
-0.4307597577571869,
-0.2738516330718994,
0.27869656682014465,
0.4446828365325928,
0.14509403705596924,
0.7818940281867981,
-0.5329001545906067,
-0.23450419306755066,
-0.07657252997159958,
0.2347533404827118,
0.07549535483121872,
0.5609275102615356,
0.15090462565422058,
-0.8251197338104248,
-0.11283355951309204,
-0.25714781880378723,
-0.6972675919532776,
-0.04781639203429222,
-0.310935378074646,
-0.34815704822540283,
-0.06904473900794983,
1.04053795337677,
-0.7065098285675049,
-0.03304462879896164,
0.15748438239097595,
-0.35949182510375977,
0.532974123954773,
-0.6439695954322815,
-0.04931919276714325,
-1.0177372694015503,
0.36252477765083313,
-0.27649006247520447,
-0.2434401512145996,
-0.41453880071640015,
0.023485001176595688,
0.51073157787323,
0.22565223276615143,
-0.14424514770507812,
0.5885040163993835,
-0.7946128249168396,
-0.022996367886662483,
-0.36559218168258667,
0.21110452711582184,
0.16831830143928528,
0.5415564179420471,
0.5499304533004761,
0.7260541319847107,
0.10757704824209213,
-0.810714066028595,
-0.27608248591423035,
0.26662781834602356,
-0.3368241488933563,
0.4729901850223541,
-0.3810679018497467,
0.5120445489883423,
-0.45486482977867126,
0.4655786156654358,
-0.7020697593688965,
-0.10814682394266129,
-0.12674450874328613,
-0.1458313763141632,
0.5393370985984802,
-0.09603866189718246,
-0.6341564059257507,
-0.2728310227394104,
0.10740884393453598,
0.49952977895736694,
0.3258322775363922,
-0.13151367008686066,
0.49941378831863403,
0.33037787675857544,
-0.5850085616111755,
-0.5779867172241211,
-0.2492608278989792,
-0.16565057635307312,
-0.024203287437558174,
-0.15757666528224945,
0.05447753518819809,
0.17973877489566803,
0.1264726221561432,
-0.1838824450969696,
-0.11368674039840698,
-0.37898674607276917,
-0.048012908548116684,
0.21557430922985077,
0.20197023451328278,
0.16307705640792847,
0.41364210844039917,
-0.2517743408679962,
-0.08544106781482697,
0.0637122243642807,
-0.53774094581604,
0.5184399485588074,
0.3183932900428772,
-0.45644450187683105,
-0.07891334593296051,
0.45990240573883057,
0.523482620716095,
-0.34597882628440857,
0.6006087064743042,
0.5677977800369263,
-0.4576728641986847,
0.006760753225535154,
-0.912189781665802,
-0.4281400442123413,
-0.432940274477005,
0.6540166735649109,
-0.4190579056739807,
-0.731193482875824,
0.4283025562763214,
0.21232442557811737,
-0.017249707132577896,
0.08229793608188629,
0.25955620408058167,
-0.20342238247394562,
0.49385887384414673,
0.6830499172210693,
-0.2923271059989929,
0.466016948223114,
-0.03154588118195534,
0.01655089110136032,
-0.9734709858894348,
-0.5187955498695374,
-0.7603441476821899,
-0.3744829297065735,
0.22765788435935974,
-0.7424001693725586,
0.4583854675292969,
0.6219393610954285,
-0.27859625220298767,
0.36846601963043213,
0.14561596512794495,
0.6601906418800354,
0.913423478603363,
0.317143976688385,
0.41977834701538086,
-0.011047560721635818,
-0.5871852040290833,
0.06495723873376846,
-0.630731999874115,
-0.32848286628723145,
0.8629459738731384,
0.14559367299079895,
0.7172839641571045,
-0.31990379095077515,
0.8451973795890808,
-0.17779476940631866,
0.24052220582962036,
-0.4462703764438629,
0.612507700920105,
-0.02662772685289383,
-0.7640074491500854,
-0.5077180862426758,
-0.23702800273895264,
-0.8553434610366821,
0.2357829362154007,
0.014977732673287392,
-0.9310429096221924,
0.1530350297689438,
0.14100761711597443,
-0.5460465550422668,
0.33896756172180176,
-0.4345821440219879,
0.4011012613773346,
-0.04085302725434303,
-0.5643627047538757,
-0.2729651629924774,
-0.8279514908790588,
0.21662959456443787,
-0.3459527790546417,
0.25109079480171204,
-0.017608894035220146,
-0.016713285818696022,
0.6722379922866821,
-0.17445363104343414,
0.9877201914787292,
-0.28776249289512634,
-0.12626107037067413,
0.40926438570022583,
0.15808673202991486,
0.8027804493904114,
-0.06929484009742737,
-0.31547120213508606,
-0.21543902158737183,
-0.07115976512432098,
-0.3014362156391144,
-0.49516060948371887,
0.6273922324180603,
-0.6731669306755066,
-0.6755204200744629,
-0.09486885368824005,
-0.6897714734077454,
-0.451040118932724,
0.38179904222488403,
0.0969778448343277,
0.3338487446308136,
0.007528792135417461,
0.21370108425617218,
0.79860520362854,
0.0685400515794754,
0.596697211265564,
0.9510005116462708,
0.1221436932682991,
-0.08861493319272995,
0.6755272746086121,
0.04195927828550339,
0.21370893716812134,
0.7800812125205994,
-0.030504988506436348,
-0.5068482756614685,
-0.6726746559143066,
-0.25514811277389526,
0.41952332854270935,
-0.6996675729751587,
-0.1475915163755417,
-0.7530449032783508,
-0.2170085906982422,
-0.22290779650211334,
-0.18752729892730713,
-0.45514580607414246,
-0.05173905938863754,
-0.19647067785263062,
-0.1137603148818016,
0.0019543415401130915,
0.6348475217819214,
-0.08778916299343109,
0.16534997522830963,
-1.1179174184799194,
0.20980922877788544,
0.4110039472579956,
0.23035520315170288,
0.36161744594573975,
-0.4675821363925934,
-0.36194494366645813,
0.020239224657416344,
-0.20529840886592865,
-0.37393540143966675,
0.30842602252960205,
0.17110569775104523,
0.545078694820404,
0.452435165643692,
0.04663269221782684,
0.6008728742599487,
-0.7659006118774414,
0.47626328468322754,
0.09527680277824402,
-0.43424636125564575,
0.2547316551208496,
-0.4162260890007019,
0.6564206480979919,
0.873619556427002,
0.513287365436554,
-0.6245105862617493,
-0.19654713571071625,
-0.22025156021118164,
-0.8546189069747925,
0.7940850257873535,
-0.00033637703745625913,
0.0025547193363308907,
-0.2566906809806824,
0.7545985579490662,
0.1213703453540802,
0.02905847318470478,
-0.6800633668899536,
0.2026096135377884,
0.352672815322876,
-0.01715702749788761,
-0.2631135582923889,
-0.4251621663570404,
-0.06846953183412552,
-0.1757555902004242,
0.6473954916000366,
0.007655284367501736,
0.11173079907894135,
0.4524989724159241,
-0.28737008571624756,
0.06959328055381775,
0.30676746368408203,
0.3034094572067261,
0.666473388671875,
-0.21047019958496094,
0.53461754322052,
0.17926788330078125,
-0.591742753982544,
0.37133240699768066,
0.13525672256946564,
-0.4782446324825287,
-0.07934396713972092,
0.45550188422203064,
0.6681297421455383,
0.6754244565963745,
-0.6065323948860168,
0.36641931533813477,
0.27696681022644043,
0.06512714922428131,
-0.4937385022640228,
-0.01692146435379982,
0.48955079913139343,
0.5135042071342468,
0.5901589393615723,
-0.21320486068725586,
-0.1638154536485672,
-0.5164796113967896,
0.41052258014678955,
0.2369953989982605,
-0.44425708055496216,
-0.3728310167789459,
0.7609503269195557,
0.13874180614948273,
-0.22252465784549713,
0.8659222722053528,
-0.24491100013256073,
-0.3593028783798218,
0.4072142243385315,
0.7065069675445557,
0.5884939432144165,
-0.25651785731315613,
0.0608380064368248,
0.5031683444976807,
0.023521259427070618,
-0.43207988142967224,
0.16163113713264465,
-0.2149195820093155,
-0.7455636858940125,
-0.2689645290374756,
-0.9080983996391296,
0.08185242116451263,
-0.06463710218667984,
-0.57222580909729,
0.13969141244888306,
-0.29069435596466064,
0.02036713808774948,
-0.35244879126548767,
-0.20333656668663025,
-0.8501969575881958,
0.22448991239070892,
0.4275604784488678,
0.9461220502853394,
-0.5396715998649597,
1.38028883934021,
0.5323565602302551,
-0.21740862727165222,
-1.1030372381210327,
0.21564510464668274,
-0.13678859174251556,
-0.9089652299880981,
0.6881688237190247,
-0.009062874130904675,
-0.3631979823112488,
0.07655324786901474,
-0.2790021598339081,
-1.1205224990844727,
1.2814580202102661,
0.1666811853647232,
-0.6481241583824158,
-0.7993271946907043,
0.04209999367594719,
0.4217161238193512,
-0.17692628502845764,
0.2715710997581482,
0.6706450581550598,
0.22309163212776184,
0.45704686641693115,
-0.9907622337341309,
0.19770506024360657,
-0.06588313728570938,
0.05766110494732857,
0.23004785180091858,
-0.611655056476593,
0.9182498455047607,
-0.36572304368019104,
-0.005030081141740084,
0.14550158381462097,
0.46632206439971924,
0.3307371735572815,
-0.008174339309334755,
0.6121754050254822,
0.45142853260040283,
0.7755006551742554,
0.3737112581729889,
1.1334155797958374,
-0.18957342207431793,
0.14575421810150146,
1.5407830476760864,
-0.1573900729417801,
1.2618483304977417,
0.6087948679924011,
-0.0025339743588119745,
0.47552385926246643,
0.2598324120044708,
0.5468112826347351,
0.9047051072120667,
-0.029250111430883408,
-0.35930973291397095,
-0.5474998950958252,
-0.02405872568488121,
-0.16718338429927826,
0.4854501783847809,
0.37816089391708374,
-0.6395393013954163,
-0.3856166899204254,
0.011251211166381836,
0.20144245028495789,
-0.08525165915489197,
-0.370684951543808,
0.8076791167259216,
0.3253285884857178,
-1.025377631187439,
0.6435257792472839,
-0.06339196115732193,
0.34704264998435974,
-1.0759612321853638,
0.10963277518749237,
-0.19176815450191498,
0.2617557644844055,
0.2787924110889435,
-0.48052942752838135,
0.14735570549964905,
-0.36665382981300354,
-0.537776529788971,
-0.3239157199859619,
0.6047154068946838,
-0.9235596656799316,
-0.4656773805618286,
0.1810520738363266,
0.388192743062973,
0.14245331287384033,
-0.2595924735069275,
-0.18965715169906616,
-0.20180878043174744,
0.06557117402553558,
-0.3639592230319977,
0.5125024914741516,
0.4867416024208069,
-0.3064746558666229,
0.7289260029792786,
0.3639884889125824,
-0.06479161977767944,
0.14016464352607727,
0.028056321665644646,
0.7597095370292664,
-0.7646437287330627,
-0.6688605546951294,
-0.596681535243988,
0.0810587927699089,
-0.033104535192251205,
-0.08148759603500366,
0.4270188808441162,
0.40253645181655884,
0.8713173866271973,
-0.2543288469314575,
0.6598003506660461,
-0.024922635406255722,
0.5777968764305115,
-0.7740129232406616,
0.7294741272926331,
-0.36351850628852844,
0.18550729751586914,
-0.09514334797859192,
-0.8586203455924988,
-0.035397469997406006,
0.5222952961921692,
-0.4202177822589874,
-0.14382904767990112,
0.9349315166473389,
0.8020119071006775,
-0.2224346548318863,
-0.24207253754138947,
0.23260600864887238,
0.23637163639068604,
0.09132673591375351,
0.9647096991539001,
0.6805292367935181,
-0.09092225134372711,
0.831171989440918,
-0.13892778754234314,
0.13951468467712402,
-0.13088268041610718,
-0.7519055008888245,
-0.8038828372955322,
-0.8298898935317993,
0.04824652150273323,
-0.1728888601064682,
0.12714552879333496,
0.8728722929954529,
0.9133135676383972,
-0.6455321311950684,
-0.1270935833454132,
0.10412091761827469,
-0.07208510488271713,
-0.015118317678570747,
-0.123164102435112,
0.34911099076271057,
-0.4118616282939911,
-0.7492595314979553,
0.4513375461101532,
0.19738255441188812,
0.10652796924114227,
-0.12017263472080231,
-0.11454091966152191,
-0.464703768491745,
-0.0986902043223381,
0.2927926182746887,
0.41124197840690613,
-0.632879376411438,
-0.7499492764472961,
-0.07464917749166489,
-0.4370678961277008,
-0.03311517462134361,
1.1815321445465088,
-0.9038143157958984,
0.2568800151348114,
0.4442589282989502,
0.612714409828186,
0.7740870714187622,
0.16881948709487915,
0.7081523537635803,
-1.039657473564148,
0.4758360683917999,
0.12419016659259796,
0.40313205122947693,
0.2600450813770294,
-0.28793999552726746,
0.2820127010345459,
0.007853680290281773,
-0.3779618442058563,
-0.1468408852815628,
0.19502131640911102,
-0.771591067314148,
-0.3499997556209564,
1.3301783800125122,
-0.5085053443908691,
-0.04694129899144173,
-0.18258021771907806,
-0.25387248396873474,
0.23366107046604156,
-0.24520215392112732,
0.9618896245956421,
0.8611926436424255,
0.213402658700943,
-0.24215978384017944,
-0.4718034565448761,
0.40242254734039307,
0.31727805733680725,
-0.6153110861778259,
0.08462122827768326,
0.6492387652397156,
0.6676307320594788,
0.17953883111476898,
0.9634678363800049,
-0.13430678844451904,
-0.04419371858239174,
0.05876593664288521,
-0.13533449172973633,
-0.18975046277046204,
-0.5889554023742676,
0.1209661141037941,
0.3930445909500122,
0.23703522980213165,
-0.051072049885988235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17008v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17008v1
|
Benchmarking LLMs on the Semantic Overlap Summarization Task
| 2024-02-26T20:33:50 | 2024-02-26T20:33:50 |
John Salvador, Naman Bansal, Mousumi Akter, Souvika Sarkar, Anupam Das, Shubhra Kanti Karmaker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Semantic Overlap Summarization (SOS) is a constrained multi-document
summarization task, where the constraint is to capture the common/overlapping
information between two alternative narratives. While recent advancements in
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved superior performance in numerous
summarization tasks, a benchmarking study of the SOS task using LLMs is yet to
be performed. As LLMs' responses are sensitive to slight variations in prompt
design, a major challenge in conducting such a benchmarking study is to
systematically explore a variety of prompts before drawing a reliable
conclusion. Fortunately, very recently, the TELeR taxonomy has been proposed
which can be used to design and explore various prompts for LLMs. Using this
TELeR taxonomy and 15 popular LLMs, this paper comprehensively evaluates LLMs
on the SOS Task, assessing their ability to summarize overlapping information
from multiple alternative narratives. For evaluation, we report
well-established metrics like ROUGE, BERTscore, and SEM-F1$ on two different
datasets of alternative narratives. We conclude the paper by analyzing the
strengths and limitations of various LLMs in terms of their capabilities in
capturing overlapping information The code and datasets used to conduct this
study are available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/llm_eval-E16D.
|
[
-0.4934341311454773,
-0.4098759889602661,
0.5390571355819702,
0.1889754831790924,
-0.15924863517284393,
0.15108732879161835,
0.01947649009525776,
-0.5510965585708618,
0.27220746874809265,
0.29436641931533813,
-0.8444379568099976,
-0.5665872693061829,
-0.8499858379364014,
0.5879438519477844,
-0.28704702854156494,
0.9567698240280151,
-0.42418262362480164,
0.033299244940280914,
-0.48204898834228516,
-0.36941537261009216,
-0.3121097981929779,
-0.21159930527210236,
-0.07114201039075851,
-0.02284674346446991,
0.45395463705062866,
0.3534376323223114,
0.5197039246559143,
0.5345237255096436,
0.7257574796676636,
0.2609919607639313,
-0.25257155299186707,
0.42805612087249756,
-0.6502881646156311,
0.2320421189069748,
-0.149909108877182,
-0.34619203209877014,
-0.41455578804016113,
-0.13146056234836578,
0.8848980069160461,
0.725421667098999,
0.28872257471084595,
0.41385313868522644,
0.1691957712173462,
0.4134868383407593,
-0.79305100440979,
-0.08646782487630844,
-0.2536938786506653,
0.12409081310033798,
-0.2469235062599182,
-0.0904979407787323,
0.06006866320967674,
-0.6706194281578064,
0.40359795093536377,
-0.5505311489105225,
0.16744965314865112,
0.004720899276435375,
0.8746153712272644,
0.29978713393211365,
-0.43390706181526184,
-0.21005935966968536,
-0.5182836651802063,
0.795701801776886,
-0.8660534620285034,
0.25643810629844666,
0.003174729645252228,
0.28597745299339294,
-0.08869245648384094,
-0.6430619955062866,
-0.4884289801120758,
-0.095230333507061,
-0.12033234536647797,
0.46110841631889343,
-0.4491341710090637,
-0.08850332349538803,
0.2751286029815674,
0.35685309767723083,
-0.6186016201972961,
0.5243791341781616,
-0.3544236421585083,
-0.19888722896575928,
0.4696577787399292,
0.9627504348754883,
0.0992705449461937,
-0.3678831160068512,
-0.7801467180252075,
0.005806077271699905,
-0.7340665459632874,
0.19503621757030487,
0.4068147838115692,
0.023920811712741852,
-0.09447745233774185,
0.691122829914093,
-0.4994076192378998,
0.7318452596664429,
-0.549872875213623,
-0.12497935444116592,
0.37822815775871277,
-0.5798411965370178,
-0.1012028157711029,
-0.022569719702005386,
0.9330968260765076,
0.931721568107605,
0.02744465135037899,
-0.03174597769975662,
-0.09893598407506943,
0.06778658926486969,
-0.014403297565877438,
-0.4854757785797119,
0.5923336148262024,
0.12194623798131943,
-0.48038122057914734,
0.16818633675575256,
0.04151040315628052,
-0.8047392964363098,
-0.4571259319782257,
-0.26548096537590027,
0.21999327838420868,
-0.4356900751590729,
0.025076253339648247,
0.1825707107782364,
-0.6076886057853699,
0.24681338667869568,
0.2547888159751892,
-0.5345011949539185,
0.6870172619819641,
0.7011324763298035,
0.9393776059150696,
-0.5983781814575195,
-0.6405147314071655,
-0.5459616184234619,
0.1512010544538498,
-0.288723886013031,
0.9515390396118164,
-0.4816303849220276,
-0.42728257179260254,
0.012112188152968884,
-0.1893465518951416,
-0.29532331228256226,
-0.5108287334442139,
0.5513485074043274,
-0.46573230624198914,
0.17954763770103455,
-0.41215237975120544,
-1.0024436712265015,
-0.11650761216878891,
0.3165876269340515,
-0.6459392309188843,
1.2496490478515625,
0.10919366031885147,
-0.7451054453849792,
0.19413164258003235,
-0.22840431332588196,
-0.1385270655155182,
-0.04874136298894882,
-0.4267544448375702,
-0.16422998905181885,
0.19497613608837128,
-0.11365798115730286,
0.3891220986843109,
-0.6396762728691101,
0.20548707246780396,
-0.04449615254998207,
-0.49335983395576477,
0.15633614361286163,
-0.03479205444455147,
0.2289324551820755,
0.13894090056419373,
-0.11492510885000229,
0.347502201795578,
-0.7629144787788391,
-0.07871076464653015,
-0.006008965894579887,
-0.052946388721466064,
-0.368613064289093,
-0.30644217133522034,
-0.03381132334470749,
0.04878736287355423,
0.2898973524570465,
-0.4408429265022278,
0.022262291982769966,
-0.25575339794158936,
0.07321254163980484,
0.551240861415863,
-0.04021120071411133,
0.11456208676099777,
-0.7927166223526001,
0.7392168045043945,
-0.29234635829925537,
-0.12642355263233185,
-0.44952622056007385,
-0.28640249371528625,
-0.45794677734375,
-0.36928465962409973,
0.3654499053955078,
0.5452314019203186,
-0.3811001181602478,
0.45360562205314636,
-0.5859555602073669,
-0.7191736698150635,
-0.34783872961997986,
-0.12006841599941254,
0.4356563985347748,
0.3044212758541107,
0.26146504282951355,
-0.4181836247444153,
-0.612228512763977,
-0.8574977517127991,
-0.6419029831886292,
0.2720789909362793,
-0.38675060868263245,
0.258046954870224,
0.4774700701236725,
0.17475341260433197,
1.315028190612793,
-0.529204785823822,
-0.49311745166778564,
-0.3725302815437317,
0.1946210414171219,
0.2984101176261902,
0.03784502297639847,
0.22526326775550842,
-0.45902374386787415,
-0.3781203329563141,
-0.49428629875183105,
-0.9922997951507568,
-0.41194993257522583,
-0.02406863309442997,
0.4580133259296417,
0.02315043844282627,
0.7973324656486511,
-0.6526982188224792,
0.4624532163143158,
0.43171289563179016,
-0.17830587923526764,
0.8172386884689331,
-0.218588188290596,
0.1932012140750885,
-0.857387363910675,
-0.05737646296620369,
-0.12394139170646667,
0.019779225811362267,
-0.6856222152709961,
-0.12458839267492294,
0.071061871945858,
0.1967857927083969,
-0.5394051671028137,
0.6096664667129517,
-0.6233834028244019,
-0.4379120469093323,
-0.10150172561407089,
0.6149421334266663,
-0.10638564825057983,
0.21335148811340332,
0.05231403559446335,
0.5298281908035278,
0.4302389919757843,
-0.4761672914028168,
0.4455356001853943,
0.3513723611831665,
-0.5122009515762329,
0.5412453413009644,
-0.7589429616928101,
-0.15645401179790497,
-0.25123846530914307,
0.5387173295021057,
-1.1574164628982544,
0.04268437251448631,
0.05409097298979759,
-0.128579780459404,
-0.18939925730228424,
0.17788593471050262,
-0.5728408694267273,
-0.11128182709217072,
-0.7542729377746582,
0.42197540402412415,
0.22320061922073364,
-0.37787818908691406,
0.9038150310516357,
0.08227677643299103,
-0.39705321192741394,
-0.5140960216522217,
-0.36158180236816406,
0.2721637487411499,
-0.48738670349121094,
-0.7471529841423035,
0.6941665410995483,
0.1534818708896637,
-0.35733118653297424,
0.1116470992565155,
-0.39256617426872253,
0.4067140221595764,
-0.31505635380744934,
0.20891337096691132,
0.4317435622215271,
-0.350853830575943,
0.054566655308008194,
-0.2095494121313095,
-0.40684235095977783,
-0.04216857627034187,
0.11220632493495941,
0.594448983669281,
-0.17663359642028809,
-0.4395735263824463,
-0.31991350650787354,
0.22793185710906982,
0.354792058467865,
-0.09418042004108429,
0.4829508662223816,
0.25390487909317017,
-0.18359877169132233,
0.2897203266620636,
-0.7639974355697632,
0.08127628266811371,
-0.3694998025894165,
0.2681669294834137,
-0.5371938943862915,
-1.0681242942810059,
0.8311371803283691,
-0.2813553512096405,
0.1816069483757019,
0.6594833731651306,
0.3336814343929291,
0.1524214744567871,
0.33656343817710876,
0.3125547766685486,
-0.035682953894138336,
0.31912654638290405,
-0.18665684759616852,
-0.2123391032218933,
-0.8588489890098572,
-0.2231311798095703,
-0.4239538609981537,
-0.4145471751689911,
-0.444013774394989,
-0.4143781363964081,
0.5413233637809753,
-0.007770644035190344,
0.09040504693984985,
0.40740635991096497,
0.08672179281711578,
0.6653407216072083,
0.5511646270751953,
-0.13095615804195404,
0.6530824899673462,
-0.4391305446624756,
-0.08693208545446396,
-0.04139229655265808,
-0.832780659198761,
-0.6349378228187561,
1.0093960762023926,
0.26882678270339966,
0.7717320322990417,
0.18463455140590668,
0.7459896206855774,
0.2518121600151062,
-0.2480018585920334,
-0.40028461813926697,
0.7394017577171326,
-0.10976321250200272,
-0.294788658618927,
-0.5377776026725769,
-0.2965051531791687,
-1.159053921699524,
0.4673979580402374,
-0.27814608812332153,
-1.0507878065109253,
0.09697125852108002,
-0.45235133171081543,
-0.6151956915855408,
0.1175878718495369,
-0.5185756683349609,
0.7699747681617737,
0.0072007374837994576,
-0.32159721851348877,
-0.1779766082763672,
-1.0958621501922607,
0.1439482569694519,
0.015569521114230156,
0.13636493682861328,
-0.3977326452732086,
-0.44354772567749023,
0.8078123331069946,
-0.3480464816093445,
0.9926420450210571,
0.4327593743801117,
0.044248249381780624,
0.17304804921150208,
-0.07703179121017456,
0.4879493713378906,
-0.3042649030685425,
0.11546268314123154,
0.39882001280784607,
0.1298018842935562,
-0.18804197013378143,
-0.38760319352149963,
0.5478290915489197,
-0.5098785161972046,
-0.5397979617118835,
-0.5933704972267151,
-0.6876596808433533,
-0.36233556270599365,
0.29640713334083557,
0.4420638978481293,
0.6854162216186523,
-0.5152667164802551,
-0.06534517556428909,
0.47084322571754456,
-0.09226631373167038,
0.5742334127426147,
0.798443078994751,
0.03887125849723816,
-0.2708517909049988,
0.6082793474197388,
0.24856838583946228,
0.32059839367866516,
0.4426657557487488,
0.22634705901145935,
-0.40750452876091003,
-0.5868562459945679,
-0.5606023669242859,
0.0856931284070015,
-0.7434038519859314,
-0.27558302879333496,
-0.892346978187561,
-0.4109005033969879,
-0.3157339096069336,
-0.12062887847423553,
-0.19124870002269745,
-0.5524566769599915,
-0.08011665940284729,
-0.08639336377382278,
0.4435472786426544,
0.9579840898513794,
0.0259085800498724,
0.35465458035469055,
-1.095345377922058,
0.3752838671207428,
-0.09229487925767899,
0.44442734122276306,
0.013953677378594875,
-0.42743945121765137,
0.06832484900951385,
-0.5483595728874207,
-0.131712406873703,
-0.8836874961853027,
-0.006302244495600462,
-0.13996250927448273,
0.9150668978691101,
0.30248862504959106,
0.3457857668399811,
0.5461564660072327,
-0.41736093163490295,
0.816558837890625,
0.4165075123310089,
-0.8683117628097534,
0.22804825007915497,
-0.37339094281196594,
0.6135826110839844,
0.540248692035675,
0.5811924934387207,
-0.6636075973510742,
-0.730869710445404,
-0.6260573267936707,
-0.9903702735900879,
0.7994884848594666,
0.3850238621234894,
-0.057005345821380615,
0.10985153913497925,
-0.1294517070055008,
0.40960556268692017,
-0.0050089252181351185,
-0.25563904643058777,
-0.27764075994491577,
0.3187822103500366,
-0.3541675806045532,
-0.1557816118001938,
-0.4755679666996002,
-0.1945391148328781,
0.3030054569244385,
0.28596609830856323,
0.10119017958641052,
-0.3143450617790222,
0.20403477549552917,
-0.07876292616128922,
0.11152445524930954,
0.3520967662334442,
0.5977581739425659,
0.6848328113555908,
-0.18173468112945557,
0.3762432634830475,
0.6991324424743652,
-0.2400529384613037,
-0.11018453538417816,
0.4009580910205841,
0.017352089285850525,
0.21471509337425232,
0.762541651725769,
0.6847549080848694,
0.2980160713195801,
-1.0340555906295776,
0.53351891040802,
-0.17560742795467377,
-0.24891899526119232,
-0.01804877258837223,
0.15232479572296143,
0.0824018120765686,
0.4700600802898407,
0.32334083318710327,
-0.047633133828639984,
0.23911257088184357,
-0.37336209416389465,
0.07242314517498016,
0.27596986293792725,
-0.1962183117866516,
0.09910290688276291,
0.3708709478378296,
0.10347791761159897,
-0.3278997242450714,
0.14633966982364655,
-0.04638524726033211,
-0.4393273591995239,
0.6722376942634583,
0.31647989153862,
0.5860906839370728,
-0.06108975410461426,
-0.2484137862920761,
0.17044934630393982,
0.21472017467021942,
-0.04220619797706604,
0.07326625287532806,
0.05009213835000992,
-0.587836742401123,
-0.3665100336074829,
-0.15225714445114136,
-0.6352038383483887,
-0.0053040566854178905,
-0.7271861433982849,
0.5474062561988831,
-0.008693416602909565,
-0.14052309095859528,
0.14441610872745514,
-0.22661077976226807,
-0.521266520023346,
-0.0084991455078125,
-0.11651113629341125,
1.2555395364761353,
-0.8146547079086304,
0.018950365483760834,
0.622698187828064,
-0.1986718624830246,
-0.3248269259929657,
0.09921462833881378,
0.4522343575954437,
-0.8829840421676636,
0.40254122018814087,
0.20372168719768524,
-0.4244610369205475,
-0.13468308746814728,
0.24110008776187897,
-0.916825532913208,
1.1363344192504883,
0.09834305942058563,
-0.5206239223480225,
0.00417748186737299,
0.367320716381073,
0.5769942998886108,
-0.46350982785224915,
0.5732625722885132,
0.7837917804718018,
0.2618216276168823,
0.30005282163619995,
-1.0180920362472534,
0.25390756130218506,
-0.1473194658756256,
0.0030766045674681664,
0.16658522188663483,
-0.7612506151199341,
0.3687736690044403,
-0.28817692399024963,
-0.2586173117160797,
0.43586310744285583,
0.49280962347984314,
0.46285444498062134,
0.7403618693351746,
0.6497196555137634,
0.429235577583313,
0.5542932152748108,
-0.09811236709356308,
0.8483740091323853,
-0.11988437175750732,
0.162197083234787,
1.4183955192565918,
-0.35853493213653564,
0.6271077394485474,
0.30882954597473145,
-0.3243122398853302,
0.22882933914661407,
0.7678020000457764,
-0.1538270264863968,
0.2565075755119324,
0.44079267978668213,
-0.07135455310344696,
-0.011166409589350224,
-0.4193965494632721,
-0.6886814832687378,
0.5354815125465393,
0.15189717710018158,
-0.2111193835735321,
-0.6259042024612427,
-0.2787867784500122,
-0.11295029520988464,
0.07393193244934082,
-0.12150323390960693,
0.9650794267654419,
0.012484008446335793,
-0.7385272979736328,
0.2815341651439667,
-0.13740913569927216,
0.550969123840332,
-0.8951274156570435,
0.2092571258544922,
-0.26638686656951904,
-0.06692788749933243,
-0.1800558865070343,
-0.884746789932251,
0.27667585015296936,
0.09703999012708664,
-0.0848073735833168,
-0.22082063555717468,
0.7398275136947632,
-0.2205054610967636,
-0.26457875967025757,
0.33645063638687134,
0.7280358076095581,
0.31068527698516846,
0.28909051418304443,
-0.16716168820858002,
0.32738053798675537,
-0.3639485836029053,
-0.17613056302070618,
0.3155963122844696,
0.4393399655818939,
-0.06430880725383759,
0.5551673769950867,
0.3417178988456726,
0.02398555539548397,
0.049733225256204605,
0.38669344782829285,
1.007538914680481,
-0.8365099430084229,
-0.7849189639091492,
-1.0331593751907349,
0.154962956905365,
-0.23333263397216797,
-0.5802976489067078,
1.131224513053894,
1.040661096572876,
0.6865625381469727,
0.11933986097574234,
0.6005792617797852,
0.1646626591682434,
0.6694192290306091,
-0.6705403923988342,
0.07476325333118439,
-0.5037811398506165,
0.48289754986763,
-0.4651855230331421,
-0.8753693103790283,
-0.1743653416633606,
0.10845651477575302,
-0.44884711503982544,
-0.06805027276277542,
0.8070760369300842,
0.695990264415741,
0.15864495933055878,
0.6183609366416931,
0.10677628219127655,
-0.03721728175878525,
-0.14349277317523956,
0.5033771395683289,
1.5604115724563599,
-0.136580690741539,
0.6502652168273926,
0.27990326285362244,
-0.39850571751594543,
-0.2930836081504822,
-1.0632450580596924,
-0.7828654646873474,
-0.38770198822021484,
-0.09039060026407242,
-0.22280608117580414,
0.0857405960559845,
0.6930258274078369,
0.4358678162097931,
-0.5566781163215637,
-0.3458508551120758,
0.11715509742498398,
0.22789300978183746,
-0.38563576340675354,
-0.16916599869728088,
0.4137362241744995,
-0.27116596698760986,
-0.6289010047912598,
0.17089307308197021,
0.4175059199333191,
0.10116768628358841,
0.09101803600788116,
-0.02047661878168583,
0.09160437434911728,
0.020244425162672997,
0.3018893003463745,
0.00782698579132557,
-0.7648655772209167,
0.04690270125865936,
0.26556387543678284,
-0.06838309019804001,
-0.08603743463754654,
1.0870329141616821,
-0.6297802925109863,
0.3659243881702423,
0.543073296546936,
0.7212735414505005,
0.5943411588668823,
0.01892525888979435,
0.5083141326904297,
-0.7372114658355713,
-0.36157551407814026,
0.03756092116236687,
0.3528701364994049,
0.026092080399394035,
-0.1277158111333847,
0.7204295992851257,
0.1877339482307434,
-0.25141531229019165,
-0.6582154631614685,
0.09972470253705978,
-1.066049575805664,
-0.35725387930870056,
1.3143198490142822,
-0.07744719088077545,
0.18625596165657043,
-0.20147520303726196,
-0.11045373976230621,
0.08631402999162674,
-0.28561168909072876,
0.7217651605606079,
0.714250385761261,
-0.512824535369873,
0.1369752138853073,
-0.38972020149230957,
0.19673669338226318,
0.5560818314552307,
-0.7610759139060974,
0.16172800958156586,
0.4612487554550171,
0.18883004784584045,
0.20898014307022095,
0.796079158782959,
-0.002612711163237691,
0.1841796487569809,
0.1552504301071167,
-0.27837419509887695,
-0.12475578486919403,
-0.11979664862155914,
-0.34602877497673035,
0.10239391028881073,
-0.4555516242980957,
-0.20055319368839264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16998v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16998v1
|
What Do Language Models Hear? Probing for Auditory Representations in Language Models
| 2024-02-26T20:13:58 | 2024-02-26T20:13:58 |
Jerry Ngo, Yoon Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
This work explores whether language models encode meaningfully grounded
representations of sounds of objects. We learn a linear probe that retrieves
the correct text representation of an object given a snippet of audio related
to that object, where the sound representation is given by a pretrained audio
model. This probe is trained via a contrastive loss that pushes the language
representations and sound representations of an object to be close to one
another. After training, the probe is tested on its ability to generalize to
objects that were not seen during training. Across different language models
and audio models, we find that the probe generalization is above chance in many
cases, indicating that despite being trained only on raw text, language models
encode grounded knowledge of sounds for some objects.
|
[
-0.36701199412345886,
-0.5151256918907166,
0.8078941106796265,
-0.16757901012897491,
-0.082112155854702,
-0.11228442937135696,
-0.24055704474449158,
-0.7007326483726501,
0.047092702239751816,
0.4423065185546875,
-0.5207025408744812,
-0.4423472285270691,
-0.478300541639328,
-0.2845471203327179,
-0.7195306420326233,
0.6892322897911072,
0.4106367528438568,
0.3833027780056,
-0.17397159337997437,
-0.18359129130840302,
-0.48284897208213806,
-0.630964457988739,
-0.44691696763038635,
-0.551436722278595,
0.20884795486927032,
0.17210684716701508,
0.5217738151550293,
0.6845532059669495,
0.30459389090538025,
0.2937069535255432,
-0.5519945025444031,
-0.4665917456150055,
-0.4305519163608551,
0.04920697212219238,
-0.20420828461647034,
-0.8907616138458252,
0.016828935593366623,
0.458362877368927,
0.44066399335861206,
1.157370924949646,
-0.15338009595870972,
0.12717768549919128,
-0.05999645218253136,
0.29216280579566956,
-0.42721179127693176,
0.1806029975414276,
-0.5989003777503967,
0.23491474986076355,
0.14158815145492554,
-0.29113659262657166,
-0.6721060276031494,
0.04065312072634697,
0.3509562313556671,
-0.40654507279396057,
0.37275171279907227,
0.16671594977378845,
1.0303092002868652,
0.10821621119976044,
-0.6367799639701843,
-0.5394964218139648,
-0.8275576829910278,
0.9394612312316895,
-0.6921384930610657,
0.9795566201210022,
0.6827282309532166,
0.4232243001461029,
0.26734939217567444,
-0.6466795206069946,
-0.4001239240169525,
-0.4967450797557831,
-0.17523548007011414,
0.2210664302110672,
0.13329260051250458,
0.1365712285041809,
0.2405746579170227,
0.7627630829811096,
-0.3096185028553009,
-0.16377931833267212,
-0.28103676438331604,
-0.055193062871694565,
0.3396088182926178,
-0.18244141340255737,
0.40855100750923157,
0.02357637695968151,
-0.10480842739343643,
-0.33288195729255676,
-0.553987443447113,
0.019213398918509483,
0.5262240767478943,
0.1790003925561905,
-0.2142585963010788,
0.5261132717132568,
0.09835946559906006,
0.6583325266838074,
0.009149343706667423,
-0.048856113106012344,
0.17099353671073914,
-0.25404635071754456,
-0.017102617770433426,
0.1905849128961563,
0.4119570255279541,
0.32869675755500793,
0.43671366572380066,
-0.3238264322280884,
-0.5618309378623962,
0.16703295707702637,
0.12756887078285217,
-0.505827784538269,
-0.20396484434604645,
-0.06085601821541786,
-0.7846412062644958,
-0.3522604703903198,
0.0716850534081459,
-0.10930468887090683,
-0.27300962805747986,
-0.5876482725143433,
0.46000832319259644,
-0.41418227553367615,
-0.5537622570991516,
0.7188463807106018,
-0.3097786009311676,
0.2977805435657501,
0.10173521190881729,
-1.2870664596557617,
0.6692615151405334,
0.6662515997886658,
0.48263952136039734,
0.443861186504364,
-0.12821175158023834,
-0.6544710993766785,
-0.019199708476662636,
-0.5712292194366455,
0.882485032081604,
-0.623811662197113,
-0.6163614392280579,
0.03726540133357048,
0.02924503944814205,
0.02843659743666649,
-0.6905990242958069,
0.43150269985198975,
-0.3438718318939209,
0.27752000093460083,
-0.5063801407814026,
-0.662929892539978,
-0.3958440124988556,
0.13332904875278473,
-0.657417356967926,
0.9069545269012451,
0.09028436243534088,
-0.7803824543952942,
0.5351510643959045,
-0.2455168217420578,
-0.010952035896480083,
-0.31480872631073,
-0.655441164970398,
-0.10167939960956573,
0.5366965532302856,
0.23423989117145538,
0.3113274872303009,
-0.3300931453704834,
0.06407663226127625,
-0.20126770436763763,
-0.690113365650177,
0.4130339026451111,
-0.04665951058268547,
0.4116380512714386,
0.043108828365802765,
-0.3145676255226135,
0.025566373020410538,
-0.7093698978424072,
-0.2555837631225586,
0.2767390012741089,
-0.4178486466407776,
-0.5568594932556152,
0.30990028381347656,
0.3087703585624695,
-0.12491239607334137,
-0.116825632750988,
-0.8581365942955017,
-0.050501417368650436,
-0.7430652379989624,
0.32033559679985046,
0.4555392563343048,
-0.11503738909959793,
0.5926039218902588,
-0.3443475067615509,
0.17977610230445862,
0.17284490168094635,
-0.20100738108158112,
-0.6733114123344421,
-0.2790047228336334,
-0.8410997986793518,
0.1979328840970993,
0.25183942914009094,
0.18258331716060638,
-0.015860112383961678,
0.08016008138656616,
0.08403124660253525,
-0.3193356990814209,
-0.7599125504493713,
-0.07612311094999313,
0.2941892147064209,
0.6629166007041931,
0.10559935122728348,
-0.1508614867925644,
-0.6942404508590698,
-0.891435980796814,
-0.36417120695114136,
-0.5210055112838745,
-0.2884290814399719,
0.4600198268890381,
0.32982680201530457,
-0.4327148497104645,
0.8453852534294128,
-0.4652452766895294,
-0.23801305890083313,
-0.12338417768478394,
0.38509565591812134,
0.46447762846946716,
0.5186625719070435,
0.8887600302696228,
-0.8830330967903137,
0.040280573070049286,
0.3215777575969696,
-0.843459963798523,
-0.05404459685087204,
0.06068050488829613,
0.3538858890533447,
-0.4455103576183319,
0.989165723323822,
-0.332956999540329,
0.31157103180885315,
0.5998163819313049,
-0.4682605266571045,
0.39161109924316406,
0.024627411738038063,
0.07663340866565704,
-0.8629266619682312,
-0.05881734564900398,
-0.3640730082988739,
-0.2910798192024231,
-0.549289882183075,
-0.18519484996795654,
0.11751393228769302,
-0.3447313904762268,
-0.3955073952674866,
0.510515570640564,
-0.6711243391036987,
-0.45495134592056274,
-0.41808009147644043,
0.08380420506000519,
0.1469409465789795,
0.062246158719062805,
0.30638420581817627,
0.8497600555419922,
0.8673050999641418,
-0.7140544652938843,
0.24248872697353363,
0.08129291981458664,
-0.41043227910995483,
0.42270463705062866,
-0.8961910009384155,
0.42001786828041077,
-0.36198729276657104,
-0.19098509848117828,
-0.9546141624450684,
-0.009153349325060844,
-0.18300119042396545,
-0.61879962682724,
0.08365510404109955,
-0.27045726776123047,
-0.3713153302669525,
-0.016969308257102966,
0.11481617391109467,
0.8020666241645813,
0.5392356514930725,
-0.6531395316123962,
0.7087711095809937,
0.640302300453186,
0.06732004880905151,
-0.19103798270225525,
-0.9355364441871643,
-0.39297303557395935,
-0.015407808125019073,
-0.4006970226764679,
-0.05741378664970398,
-0.036437321454286575,
-0.5309526920318604,
0.014687805436551571,
-0.31564852595329285,
-0.1384386271238327,
0.22278954088687897,
0.40776047110557556,
-0.25337865948677063,
-0.873101532459259,
0.3703640401363373,
-0.3127051591873169,
0.00914884451776743,
0.5205812454223633,
-0.23760513961315155,
0.7029613852500916,
-0.398935467004776,
-0.9441900253295898,
-0.17348821461200714,
0.2805679738521576,
0.3479025959968567,
-0.2299404889345169,
0.3530154526233673,
0.4887157082557678,
-0.547464907169342,
-0.07371843606233597,
-0.6938046216964722,
-0.6077827215194702,
-0.5834121704101562,
0.4042571187019348,
-0.6131619811058044,
-0.6999029517173767,
0.836034893989563,
-0.218607559800148,
-0.24598878622055054,
0.23959359526634216,
0.14819644391536713,
-0.3443891108036041,
1.1589103937149048,
0.6865509152412415,
-0.14293122291564941,
0.326672226190567,
-0.3025291860103607,
0.041616883128881454,
-0.7123302817344666,
-0.5458566546440125,
-0.8770108819007874,
-0.018242454156279564,
-0.3243367373943329,
-0.2612200081348419,
-0.1660560816526413,
0.2597840428352356,
0.0008616240229457617,
0.19311587512493134,
-0.23297007381916046,
0.7632763385772705,
0.7180393934249878,
0.13010457158088684,
0.2341957986354828,
-0.2807333171367645,
-0.26688215136528015,
-0.3026009202003479,
-0.3619441092014313,
-0.4805348515510559,
0.9543185830116272,
0.69577556848526,
0.807489812374115,
-0.08024138957262039,
0.6372185349464417,
0.04368750751018524,
0.017542507499456406,
-1.1058883666992188,
0.29039838910102844,
0.21494683623313904,
-0.6162433624267578,
-0.12496495991945267,
-0.08746064454317093,
-0.92779940366745,
0.2707687318325043,
-0.034068744629621506,
-0.6104915738105774,
0.43999290466308594,
0.012028354220092297,
0.15976692736148834,
0.32614511251449585,
-0.4188534915447235,
0.526393473148346,
-0.28288304805755615,
0.17520704865455627,
-0.1761939823627472,
-0.16806922852993011,
0.11631354689598083,
0.15251758694648743,
0.36367782950401306,
-0.07083727419376373,
0.22483128309249878,
0.9179190397262573,
0.06618593633174896,
0.6610090136528015,
-0.10144282877445221,
-0.3047334551811218,
0.20976905524730682,
0.3889240026473999,
0.19735944271087646,
0.14995259046554565,
-0.07236543297767639,
-0.07224580645561218,
-0.1653144657611847,
-0.5026645660400391,
-0.5483114123344421,
0.34289559721946716,
-0.6002525091171265,
-0.567010223865509,
-0.2917012572288513,
-0.5362793803215027,
-0.38683146238327026,
0.31338199973106384,
0.285626083612442,
0.3827224373817444,
-0.45003220438957214,
0.37859514355659485,
0.8303075432777405,
-0.32447490096092224,
0.23039190471172333,
0.7015374302864075,
-0.542270302772522,
0.19222712516784668,
0.6163281798362732,
-0.31679585576057434,
0.12415198236703873,
0.4190777540206909,
0.23429132997989655,
-0.34400081634521484,
-0.5728468894958496,
-0.1572090983390808,
0.33934178948402405,
-1.0470229387283325,
0.35590532422065735,
-0.49229952692985535,
-0.3120485246181488,
-0.34614628553390503,
0.049718838185071945,
-0.6089659333229065,
0.10378957539796829,
-0.4893277883529663,
-0.6355916261672974,
0.2196348011493683,
1.2201255559921265,
-0.0951363667845726,
0.40780556201934814,
-0.773739755153656,
0.36792340874671936,
0.5785192847251892,
0.42320120334625244,
-0.16611424088478088,
-0.6539173126220703,
-0.3564445376396179,
0.20271386206150055,
0.19048751890659332,
-1.0790594816207886,
0.36558371782302856,
0.17166775465011597,
0.6434499621391296,
0.5929505825042725,
-0.20408561825752258,
0.38801077008247375,
-0.644829511642456,
0.6554704904556274,
0.033328551799058914,
-1.2314966917037964,
0.7576572895050049,
-0.7790746688842773,
0.387283056974411,
0.4454333484172821,
0.1287887990474701,
-0.8085463047027588,
-0.43155637383461,
-0.4671424329280853,
-0.49825775623321533,
0.6662672758102417,
-0.016712868586182594,
0.4523736238479614,
-0.03012043796479702,
0.14267438650131226,
0.06563734263181686,
0.2591974139213562,
-0.839296817779541,
-0.10284987092018127,
-0.36344441771507263,
0.08524686098098755,
-0.18149006366729736,
-0.5457981824874878,
-0.22090110182762146,
-0.10733933001756668,
-0.13181889057159424,
0.11769549548625946,
0.5363423228263855,
0.13588251173496246,
-0.2079944759607315,
-0.1637295037508011,
0.044931452721357346,
0.5417665243148804,
0.32503899931907654,
-0.5751773715019226,
0.5524799823760986,
0.18819282948970795,
-0.547416090965271,
0.26258575916290283,
-0.36406707763671875,
0.19071345031261444,
0.4547545313835144,
0.7906129360198975,
1.0822674036026,
0.6582810878753662,
-0.796349048614502,
0.5242109298706055,
-0.08526799082756042,
-0.4088466763496399,
-0.3452083468437195,
0.002941280836239457,
0.37255918979644775,
0.15260832011699677,
0.4855838716030121,
0.06352601945400238,
0.5453543663024902,
-0.811790943145752,
0.2855514585971832,
0.03356466069817543,
-0.768742561340332,
-0.6050272583961487,
0.8012679815292358,
-0.05354626104235649,
-0.14823311567306519,
0.6936612129211426,
0.29550376534461975,
-0.5422496795654297,
0.731809139251709,
0.6699419617652893,
0.8245991468429565,
-0.35746830701828003,
-0.02642795443534851,
0.2478533238172531,
0.3580947816371918,
-0.11936763674020767,
0.4816407561302185,
-0.10000697523355484,
-0.8537713885307312,
-0.2679422199726105,
-0.5113757252693176,
-0.6172006130218506,
0.31703194975852966,
-1.0304170846939087,
0.06416374444961548,
-0.3392636775970459,
0.04484112560749054,
-0.1761074811220169,
-0.47250691056251526,
-0.7437109351158142,
0.5467575192451477,
0.24078913033008575,
0.8310666680335999,
-1.1831419467926025,
0.6949502229690552,
0.7533518075942993,
-0.4085364043712616,
-0.893648087978363,
-0.005342012271285057,
-0.20476973056793213,
-0.6496264338493347,
1.174757480621338,
0.3279111385345459,
-0.27591896057128906,
-0.19277143478393555,
-0.5476180911064148,
-1.0721851587295532,
0.6440272927284241,
0.6718365550041199,
-0.5897771120071411,
0.11042234301567078,
0.22784745693206787,
0.5729959607124329,
-0.37469449639320374,
0.520744800567627,
0.3218349516391754,
0.39567360281944275,
-0.3133111894130707,
-1.098069190979004,
-0.14710144698619843,
-0.45240601897239685,
-0.11987567692995071,
-0.28766515851020813,
-0.26528602838516235,
1.2819714546203613,
0.05425070598721504,
-0.3007396161556244,
-0.20628014206886292,
0.7579168081283569,
0.3812611401081085,
0.4269217848777771,
0.5688258409500122,
0.40349963307380676,
0.6584358215332031,
-0.3293987810611725,
1.1929166316986084,
-0.13386520743370056,
0.2700565457344055,
1.007973074913025,
-0.16352958977222443,
0.7815963625907898,
0.5050292611122131,
-0.011382518336176872,
0.22344468533992767,
0.6509618163108826,
0.23478013277053833,
0.6597920656204224,
0.45309412479400635,
-0.16090527176856995,
-0.23663069307804108,
-0.28040000796318054,
-0.6353473663330078,
0.6034696102142334,
0.2538484036922455,
-0.4542856812477112,
0.02376796305179596,
0.3664871156215668,
-0.37535032629966736,
0.482559472322464,
-0.16132698953151703,
0.910868227481842,
0.2392348051071167,
-0.22199459373950958,
0.6193991303443909,
-0.25274601578712463,
0.43447646498680115,
-0.3625354468822479,
-0.16191068291664124,
-0.29988691210746765,
0.16584929823875427,
0.03171219676733017,
-0.6233828067779541,
0.2766978144645691,
-0.5016883611679077,
-0.3797109127044678,
-0.2802058160305023,
0.6217470169067383,
-0.45061013102531433,
-0.2202892154455185,
0.8575620651245117,
0.33464381098747253,
0.3281044065952301,
-0.2619745433330536,
-0.20604752004146576,
0.429296612739563,
-0.0659777969121933,
-0.3566879332065582,
0.11546379327774048,
0.5184859037399292,
0.23672005534172058,
0.8117749094963074,
0.5310834050178528,
0.42019063234329224,
0.2532493770122528,
0.5330052375793457,
0.8447738289833069,
-0.8858453631401062,
-0.4816972315311432,
-0.42313143610954285,
0.36191827058792114,
0.05558949336409569,
-0.013561748899519444,
0.5117178559303284,
0.6641479730606079,
1.0591918230056763,
-0.5514839291572571,
0.5227146148681641,
0.5953030586242676,
0.7605763673782349,
-0.7983003854751587,
0.8300946354866028,
-0.522662341594696,
0.26062968373298645,
-0.240878626704216,
-0.9430672526359558,
0.01255082618445158,
1.058917760848999,
-0.22617630660533905,
-0.0427728109061718,
0.7728976011276245,
0.6628929376602173,
-0.5963011384010315,
0.1543499082326889,
0.6763378977775574,
0.22425854206085205,
0.14851640164852142,
0.09443512558937073,
1.1913559436798096,
-0.6483145356178284,
0.313790500164032,
-0.09822118282318115,
0.40107306838035583,
-0.16830989718437195,
-0.4260457158088684,
-1.080896258354187,
-0.7444965839385986,
-0.07848767936229706,
-0.02544393576681614,
0.1110924556851387,
0.37129685282707214,
1.140194058418274,
-1.0438331365585327,
-0.776334822177887,
-0.3315032720565796,
-0.3098060190677643,
-0.045254215598106384,
-0.20981396734714508,
0.24226024746894836,
-0.33432865142822266,
-0.9420310258865356,
0.9976471066474915,
-0.003569194581359625,
0.3386225998401642,
-0.09832532703876495,
-0.22636733949184418,
-0.07219970226287842,
0.07784287631511688,
0.20719802379608154,
0.20918911695480347,
-0.697913646697998,
-0.4113817512989044,
0.18447108566761017,
-0.16974064707756042,
-0.04776401445269585,
0.8756152987480164,
-0.8437710404396057,
0.5533847212791443,
0.6407063007354736,
0.6999437808990479,
0.7482082843780518,
-0.31972455978393555,
0.9851179122924805,
-0.8545963764190674,
0.9086944460868835,
0.5447635054588318,
0.6976601481437683,
0.3521568179130554,
-0.16755692660808563,
0.4141506850719452,
0.042598046362400055,
-0.24136587977409363,
-1.0963454246520996,
0.4209473133087158,
-0.904445230960846,
-0.3318976163864136,
1.0885494947433472,
-0.08889433741569519,
-0.16822773218154907,
-0.08567123115062714,
-0.6158860921859741,
0.27379336953163147,
-0.14657272398471832,
0.5079146027565002,
0.773051917552948,
0.301260769367218,
-0.6319550275802612,
-0.5537973046302795,
0.5273398756980896,
0.8376301527023315,
-0.2369658350944519,
-0.28703925013542175,
0.20545917749404907,
0.24130423367023468,
0.27861738204956055,
0.4930829703807831,
-0.03766785189509392,
0.4175935387611389,
0.32476773858070374,
0.14041417837142944,
0.11859186738729477,
-0.18883267045021057,
-0.24592328071594238,
-0.008799505420029163,
0.4256928861141205,
-0.384832501411438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16986v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16986v1
|
Long Dialog Summarization: An Analysis
| 2024-02-26T19:35:45 | 2024-02-26T19:35:45 |
Ankan Mullick, Ayan Kumar Bhowmick, Raghav R, Ravi Kokku, Prasenjit Dey, Pawan Goyal, Niloy Ganguly
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Dialog summarization has become increasingly important in managing and
comprehending large-scale conversations across various domains. This task
presents unique challenges in capturing the key points, context, and nuances of
multi-turn long conversations for summarization. It is worth noting that the
summarization techniques may vary based on specific requirements such as in a
shopping-chatbot scenario, the dialog summary helps to learn user preferences,
whereas in the case of a customer call center, the summary may involve the
problem attributes that a user specified, and the final resolution provided.
This work emphasizes the significance of creating coherent and contextually
rich summaries for effective communication in various applications. We explore
current state-of-the-art approaches for long dialog summarization in different
domains and benchmark metrics based evaluations show that one single model does
not perform well across various areas for distinct summarization tasks.
|
[
-0.5922530293464661,
-1.0161254405975342,
0.36126095056533813,
0.33836624026298523,
-0.2713436782360077,
0.21691849827766418,
-0.24830478429794312,
-0.8495880961418152,
0.3021351993083954,
0.5905088186264038,
-0.3566920757293701,
-0.3011307120323181,
-0.3036838471889496,
0.10843774676322937,
-0.2475973665714264,
1.2410633563995361,
0.10614166408777237,
-0.19388046860694885,
-0.3027659058570862,
-0.26296266913414,
-0.6895706653594971,
-0.861476719379425,
-0.6503310203552246,
-0.2433650642633438,
0.20766419172286987,
0.46449267864227295,
0.6364558935165405,
-0.15144340693950653,
0.3826943337917328,
0.3664938509464264,
-0.26997411251068115,
0.3314844071865082,
-0.7866193652153015,
0.3583427965641022,
0.21856747567653656,
-0.30325567722320557,
-0.9221544861793518,
-0.19768981635570526,
0.592301070690155,
1.0291125774383545,
0.08480796962976456,
0.19896434247493744,
0.22462782263755798,
0.8058456778526306,
-0.23064780235290527,
0.2635290026664734,
-0.3096895217895508,
0.10103224962949753,
0.022063981741666794,
-0.40283381938934326,
-0.15595494210720062,
-0.267813116312027,
0.6303918957710266,
-0.40412113070487976,
0.12029478698968887,
-0.01522234920412302,
0.5526321530342102,
-0.14430451393127441,
-0.7773272395133972,
-0.6696935296058655,
-1.059457778930664,
0.9112337827682495,
-0.7870950698852539,
-0.13560986518859863,
0.2073374092578888,
0.6076946258544922,
0.038959335535764694,
-0.43861088156700134,
-0.11280035972595215,
0.10975352674722672,
-0.11013906449079514,
0.46746474504470825,
-0.27021580934524536,
0.03014185279607773,
0.1717679798603058,
0.44574713706970215,
-0.23396651446819305,
0.044573865830898285,
-0.6248164772987366,
-0.1784900724887848,
0.6288105249404907,
0.6826387643814087,
-0.15799833834171295,
-0.17893318831920624,
-0.289124071598053,
0.358267217874527,
-0.3133685290813446,
0.1416555494070053,
0.22512909770011902,
0.18901732563972473,
-0.2279924601316452,
0.36248037219047546,
-0.600384533405304,
0.536298930644989,
-0.09631112217903137,
-0.5531018972396851,
0.09614599496126175,
-0.6601278185844421,
-0.07367467880249023,
-0.04485601931810379,
0.660064160823822,
1.1226751804351807,
0.38924986124038696,
-0.023689674213528633,
-0.032060544937849045,
-0.5579839944839478,
0.07462738454341888,
-0.8942465782165527,
0.3903152346611023,
0.600702166557312,
-0.7086622714996338,
0.0004890551790595055,
-0.05112627521157265,
-1.0928727388381958,
-0.09196857362985611,
-0.6599941849708557,
-0.16059528291225433,
-0.0773029699921608,
-0.11638582497835159,
0.0915464460849762,
-0.19721148908138275,
0.3098793923854828,
0.8176389336585999,
-0.5466164350509644,
0.3590903580188751,
0.7990630269050598,
0.8401234745979309,
-0.23287227749824524,
-0.1568557769060135,
-0.05023081973195076,
0.05885661765933037,
-0.17423097789287567,
0.6737566590309143,
-0.279192179441452,
-0.7122614979743958,
0.3114534318447113,
0.022558268159627914,
-0.08341041207313538,
-0.6455509662628174,
0.1472598761320114,
-0.37968072295188904,
0.45813897252082825,
-0.13531051576137543,
-0.542717456817627,
-0.2581495940685272,
0.41243696212768555,
-0.33322417736053467,
0.5211763381958008,
0.09142117947340012,
-0.5721759796142578,
0.039413899183273315,
-0.7293608784675598,
-0.6720741987228394,
-0.0774071216583252,
0.1343190222978592,
-0.4706324636936188,
0.34459465742111206,
0.0847231075167656,
0.6660453081130981,
-0.013679198920726776,
0.06783859431743622,
0.05103204771876335,
-0.32857027649879456,
0.6152200698852539,
-0.33570778369903564,
0.5727440118789673,
0.2550334930419922,
-0.13813607394695282,
0.13856783509254456,
-0.34077179431915283,
-0.03756758198142052,
0.05257703363895416,
-0.043434444814920425,
0.0029326549265533686,
-0.14015400409698486,
0.04136022925376892,
0.07739494740962982,
0.34395623207092285,
-0.17073789238929749,
0.25414177775382996,
0.09291227906942368,
0.48512446880340576,
0.2837136685848236,
0.24934156239032745,
0.27382931113243103,
-0.4128555655479431,
0.6833188533782959,
-0.0017078432720154524,
0.23141756653785706,
-0.6929126977920532,
-0.43445298075675964,
-0.5648678541183472,
-0.3110806345939636,
0.15393836796283722,
0.6151127219200134,
-0.3407011330127716,
0.36762291193008423,
-0.3905058205127716,
-0.251149445772171,
-0.06724003702402115,
0.028464850038290024,
0.39255449175834656,
0.35987618565559387,
0.14202067255973816,
-0.50204998254776,
-0.19549205899238586,
-0.8542370200157166,
-0.0380513034760952,
-0.055138710886240005,
0.08296246826648712,
0.48133936524391174,
0.49137789011001587,
-0.08185124397277832,
1.0602649450302124,
-0.8627413511276245,
-0.48250603675842285,
-0.7944103479385376,
0.08685757219791412,
0.06406521052122116,
0.07965826988220215,
0.6770458221435547,
-0.6868563890457153,
-0.5488809943199158,
-0.11480435729026794,
-0.7239517569541931,
0.18064968287944794,
-0.4769907593727112,
-0.0743887722492218,
0.13932260870933533,
0.4746580719947815,
-0.9289341568946838,
0.6872511506080627,
0.22374993562698364,
-0.04366463050246239,
0.841142475605011,
-0.2856168746948242,
0.37346547842025757,
-1.105217695236206,
0.054554786533117294,
-0.08269811421632767,
-0.47890135645866394,
-0.9495441317558289,
-0.2558586597442627,
-0.2871794104576111,
-0.4047960042953491,
-0.2482099086046219,
0.26521167159080505,
-0.2989480197429657,
-0.17205584049224854,
-0.4982015788555145,
0.2920748293399811,
0.13197071850299835,
0.6430564522743225,
0.05503761023283005,
0.6903931498527527,
0.2831322252750397,
-0.633007287979126,
0.4668111205101013,
0.46562933921813965,
-0.174921452999115,
0.6177676320075989,
-0.9350188970565796,
-0.16275519132614136,
-0.136699840426445,
0.7983555197715759,
-0.9005253911018372,
-0.3840043544769287,
0.14940544962882996,
-0.5262712836265564,
0.1505519598722458,
-0.03439858928322792,
-0.2340376079082489,
-0.2596905529499054,
-0.34097036719322205,
0.48548436164855957,
0.5329304933547974,
-0.19196689128875732,
0.5216132998466492,
0.4079189896583557,
-0.6052401661872864,
-0.24496003985404968,
-0.4817788898944855,
0.3843047618865967,
-0.5813289284706116,
-0.5350242853164673,
0.04493996500968933,
-0.12040096521377563,
-0.35973024368286133,
-0.661647379398346,
-0.11170616000890732,
-0.1002059355378151,
0.12162498384714127,
0.2616971731185913,
0.02478550374507904,
-0.03665057569742203,
0.09940717369318008,
-0.1803419291973114,
-0.3384386897087097,
0.25990885496139526,
0.17250002920627594,
0.5045319199562073,
-0.18041780591011047,
-0.3921298682689667,
-0.6678785085678101,
1.2207727432250977,
0.9033135771751404,
-0.10725709795951843,
0.47495704889297485,
0.27008336782455444,
-0.13802532851696014,
-0.02478707954287529,
-0.5678213834762573,
-0.06980308145284653,
-0.36857590079307556,
0.47933486104011536,
-0.19968053698539734,
-0.7848933339118958,
0.7652802467346191,
-0.4225272834300995,
0.2359265834093094,
0.16221323609352112,
0.44168752431869507,
-0.35910046100616455,
0.9398548007011414,
0.6804549694061279,
-0.21302658319473267,
0.40212228894233704,
-0.1632576882839203,
0.6927593350410461,
-0.7634719610214233,
-0.17753295600414276,
-0.5327045321464539,
0.05175447836518288,
-0.30412501096725464,
-0.08844446390867233,
0.4337075352668762,
0.003470274619758129,
0.43303078413009644,
0.2210170030593872,
-0.10126855969429016,
0.3518950343132019,
0.339009165763855,
-0.20361492037773132,
0.41043052077293396,
-0.2108319252729416,
0.6399288177490234,
0.14217957854270935,
-0.45471131801605225,
-0.7501330971717834,
0.6470809578895569,
0.42519164085388184,
0.4847283363342285,
0.27540096640586853,
0.6488640904426575,
0.18883384764194489,
-0.1515992134809494,
-1.0694241523742676,
0.5570772290229797,
0.2637590765953064,
-0.41780179738998413,
-0.46753770112991333,
-0.38132137060165405,
-1.1424660682678223,
0.37139201164245605,
0.07425536215305328,
-0.6799651980400085,
-0.32548466324806213,
0.31215113401412964,
-0.41999492049217224,
-0.12345700711011887,
-0.7948777675628662,
0.8142324686050415,
-0.23104777932167053,
0.10176104307174683,
-0.33166804909706116,
-0.8398324251174927,
0.1918339729309082,
0.03174668923020363,
0.12183182686567307,
-0.18534615635871887,
0.3548910617828369,
0.5772144198417664,
-0.33923161029815674,
1.0234123468399048,
0.0178716741502285,
-0.2219453901052475,
0.49574539065361023,
-0.2654740512371063,
0.2117304801940918,
0.14060744643211365,
0.3915635347366333,
0.044273875653743744,
0.028235426172614098,
-0.6650037169456482,
-0.5970267057418823,
0.2936926484107971,
-0.4598129689693451,
-0.6069511771202087,
-0.21301981806755066,
-0.455567866563797,
-0.29777291417121887,
0.011932533234357834,
0.11554959416389465,
0.9171122312545776,
-0.4417169392108917,
0.12968863546848297,
0.5899350643157959,
-0.23262818157672882,
0.5332120060920715,
0.22316041588783264,
-0.27977511286735535,
-0.2415722757577896,
0.6868326663970947,
0.08411688357591629,
0.5472570061683655,
0.13767559826374054,
-0.03669402748346329,
-0.03599553555250168,
-0.5680280923843384,
-0.2108021229505539,
0.19079497456550598,
-0.8522048592567444,
-0.25451943278312683,
-0.6837685704231262,
-0.14931705594062805,
-0.37225645780563354,
-0.35358867049217224,
-0.184770405292511,
-0.5508763790130615,
-0.12929458916187286,
0.12783168256282806,
0.08630267530679703,
0.7931441068649292,
0.49282386898994446,
0.4776275157928467,
-0.9215180277824402,
0.4842737317085266,
0.4652428925037384,
0.05209031701087952,
0.32304084300994873,
-0.14115150272846222,
-0.4308820962905884,
0.14306527376174927,
-0.3815373480319977,
-0.5105581879615784,
0.3330560624599457,
0.14768342673778534,
0.422949880361557,
0.42916595935821533,
-0.014897744171321392,
0.8844144344329834,
-0.2741580605506897,
1.1495697498321533,
0.4043094217777252,
-0.8827851414680481,
0.43857496976852417,
-0.36256763339042664,
0.840191662311554,
0.5837221741676331,
0.30927711725234985,
-0.857542872428894,
-0.37918519973754883,
-0.4689232409000397,
-1.0899841785430908,
0.3445351719856262,
0.18859051167964935,
0.4077354371547699,
0.09056638926267624,
0.07545895129442215,
0.32735148072242737,
0.2623538076877594,
-0.10905721783638,
-0.15073618292808533,
-0.18047866225242615,
-0.0009224824607372284,
-0.20313094556331635,
-0.33419010043144226,
-0.39209723472595215,
0.007687206845730543,
0.3664642870426178,
-0.11673323065042496,
0.30815860629081726,
0.04187151417136192,
-0.24767647683620453,
0.430057555437088,
0.5937099456787109,
0.966643214225769,
1.2342913150787354,
-0.12167032063007355,
-0.3034737706184387,
0.22468078136444092,
-0.26574692130088806,
-0.5328670144081116,
-0.21309134364128113,
0.1825435310602188,
0.16634038090705872,
0.5603953003883362,
0.6553247570991516,
0.08807510137557983,
-0.6123046278953552,
0.6619285345077515,
-0.3135680854320526,
-0.1642492562532425,
-0.44238021969795227,
-0.2774827778339386,
-0.0281868614256382,
0.18972152471542358,
0.5045546293258667,
-0.11024683713912964,
0.3821505010128021,
-0.7857083678245544,
-0.21517673134803772,
0.4343827962875366,
-0.23927249014377594,
-0.4091912806034088,
0.014495291747152805,
0.6838012933731079,
-0.12262474745512009,
0.5485228300094604,
0.10489998012781143,
-0.6537789106369019,
0.537411630153656,
0.5059691071510315,
0.8558353781700134,
0.1815672069787979,
0.07841115444898605,
0.0636003315448761,
-0.36719951033592224,
0.24418458342552185,
-0.18245792388916016,
-0.5616590976715088,
-0.27443453669548035,
-0.4670746922492981,
0.026222316548228264,
-0.8795868158340454,
-0.17047807574272156,
-0.7581973075866699,
-0.2569355368614197,
0.020373431965708733,
-0.4930160939693451,
0.09889518469572067,
-0.07109730690717697,
-0.5225154161453247,
-0.06800150126218796,
-0.15949147939682007,
0.6336556673049927,
-0.49466830492019653,
-0.014863706193864346,
0.2409157156944275,
0.036290157586336136,
-0.14958927035331726,
-0.09239160269498825,
-0.01022348366677761,
-0.3784313499927521,
0.2865756154060364,
0.3161811828613281,
-0.35575008392333984,
-0.6617943644523621,
-0.3830043375492096,
-0.3451286852359772,
1.0975371599197388,
-0.3358985185623169,
-0.40405356884002686,
-0.17715683579444885,
0.3679347038269043,
0.7273377776145935,
-0.5948003530502319,
0.4130665957927704,
0.593273401260376,
0.17583823204040527,
0.06376409530639648,
-1.369796872138977,
-0.25313034653663635,
-0.12165369093418121,
-0.09075986593961716,
0.3083045184612274,
-1.0848925113677979,
0.36774834990501404,
-0.13868556916713715,
-0.20022684335708618,
0.17368128895759583,
0.6485307812690735,
-0.09387081116437912,
0.6046886444091797,
0.33158639073371887,
-0.021049078553915024,
0.4354366660118103,
-0.10025925934314728,
0.7411692142486572,
-0.2762809097766876,
0.30247172713279724,
1.2592673301696777,
-0.2497258186340332,
0.5306653380393982,
0.4286022484302521,
0.040868934243917465,
-0.07803046703338623,
0.31741347908973694,
0.30804646015167236,
0.08437884598970413,
0.25496751070022583,
-0.20707237720489502,
-0.10623256117105484,
-0.12556390464305878,
-0.4963865876197815,
0.587536096572876,
0.5612956285476685,
-0.05941929295659065,
-0.36184176802635193,
0.0069801295176148415,
0.23368385434150696,
-0.24850507080554962,
-0.13671086728572845,
1.116123914718628,
0.17941880226135254,
-0.9020313620567322,
0.349948525428772,
-0.41463831067085266,
0.5048272609710693,
-0.49098944664001465,
-0.0684012845158577,
-0.22391308844089508,
0.13992939889431,
-0.2108742892742157,
-0.567547082901001,
0.22926729917526245,
0.1099100261926651,
-0.11452478170394897,
-0.4093745946884155,
0.39110448956489563,
-0.33110350370407104,
0.03853567689657211,
0.04858062416315079,
0.7066967487335205,
0.4839346408843994,
-0.03899146243929863,
-0.440265953540802,
0.24310366809368134,
0.030924396589398384,
-0.2785816192626953,
0.23271486163139343,
0.4755817651748657,
-0.15789933502674103,
0.7120303511619568,
0.35580694675445557,
-0.1995462030172348,
-0.07828034460544586,
0.35012996196746826,
0.7021511793136597,
-0.8690782785415649,
-0.4867325723171234,
-0.4257899224758148,
0.8375340104103088,
-0.4548996090888977,
-0.6836240291595459,
0.9541791081428528,
0.6339223384857178,
0.42248350381851196,
-0.036200620234012604,
0.8700408339500427,
0.19390292465686798,
0.6515569686889648,
-0.44191262125968933,
0.4110091030597687,
-0.04127586632966995,
0.18459470570087433,
-0.0694403201341629,
-1.0609651803970337,
-0.16514979302883148,
0.28833988308906555,
-0.08015259355306625,
0.05083606392145157,
0.598986804485321,
0.24550171196460724,
0.11408843100070953,
0.17149335145950317,
0.24703161418437958,
-0.01875448040664196,
0.582897961139679,
0.4701944887638092,
1.0502245426177979,
-0.2947119176387787,
0.5151199102401733,
-0.04740051552653313,
-0.3330237865447998,
-0.6796879172325134,
-0.8030281066894531,
-1.1302117109298706,
-0.5647467374801636,
-0.528796911239624,
-0.16114848852157593,
-0.06290779262781143,
0.6593418717384338,
0.7735771536827087,
-0.7167470455169678,
-0.4574466943740845,
0.6566990613937378,
0.028353191912174225,
-0.1987166553735733,
-0.2602683901786804,
0.16591495275497437,
-0.459722638130188,
-0.7985992431640625,
0.022899135947227478,
0.44973400235176086,
0.5771143436431885,
-0.1219431534409523,
0.2019595354795456,
0.41245728731155396,
0.1837969273328781,
1.000664234161377,
0.37499311566352844,
-0.6042917370796204,
-0.1963653713464737,
-0.08310791105031967,
-0.034917619079351425,
0.17216698825359344,
1.0802565813064575,
-0.45005524158477783,
0.40673545002937317,
0.2786219120025635,
0.3434831202030182,
0.7246541380882263,
0.2977474629878998,
0.7463040947914124,
-0.6108400225639343,
-0.06854574382305145,
0.15291282534599304,
0.24842147529125214,
0.23247039318084717,
-0.25449731945991516,
0.17036104202270508,
-0.3855063319206238,
-0.7309731245040894,
-0.6471909880638123,
0.36819231510162354,
-1.4628826379776,
-0.32102495431900024,
0.9957438707351685,
-0.1913997232913971,
0.006785911973565817,
-0.40854811668395996,
-0.5877376794815063,
0.035729240626096725,
-0.5452808737754822,
0.7974653840065002,
0.683810830116272,
-0.43913733959198,
0.19717775285243988,
-0.5350489020347595,
0.4716850221157074,
0.2158619612455368,
-1.1004587411880493,
0.4712330996990204,
0.7758233547210693,
0.05644175037741661,
0.3850306570529938,
0.5814130902290344,
-0.091871477663517,
0.11962952464818954,
-0.28685611486434937,
-0.5212427973747253,
0.10981331765651703,
-0.4100833237171173,
-0.28047123551368713,
0.4891272783279419,
-0.1777428835630417,
-0.026912890374660492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16977v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16977v2
|
Dealing with Data for RE: Mitigating Challenges while using NLP and Generative AI
| 2024-02-26T19:19:47 | 2024-02-28T11:12:07 |
Smita Ghaisas, Anmol Singhal
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Across the dynamic business landscape today, enterprises face an
ever-increasing range of challenges. These include the constantly evolving
regulatory environment, the growing demand for personalization within software
applications, and the heightened emphasis on governance. In response to these
multifaceted demands, large enterprises have been adopting automation that
spans from the optimization of core business processes to the enhancement of
customer experiences. Indeed, Artificial Intelligence (AI) has emerged as a
pivotal element of modern software systems. In this context, data plays an
indispensable role. AI-centric software systems based on supervised learning
and operating at an industrial scale require large volumes of training data to
perform effectively. Moreover, the incorporation of generative AI has led to a
growing demand for adequate evaluation benchmarks. Our experience in this field
has revealed that the requirement for large datasets for training and
evaluation introduces a host of intricate challenges. This book chapter
explores the evolving landscape of Software Engineering (SE) in general, and
Requirements Engineering (RE) in particular, in this era marked by AI
integration. We discuss challenges that arise while integrating Natural
Language Processing (NLP) and generative AI into enterprise-critical software
systems. The chapter provides practical insights, solutions, and examples to
equip readers with the knowledge and tools necessary for effectively building
solutions with NLP at their cores. We also reflect on how these text
data-centric tasks sit together with the traditional RE process. We also
highlight new RE tasks that may be necessary for handling the increasingly
important text data-centricity involved in developing software systems.
|
[
-0.46606969833374023,
-0.6596324443817139,
0.3209858536720276,
0.44258445501327515,
0.4315495193004608,
0.2257685363292694,
0.050914615392684937,
-0.60845547914505,
-0.10632310807704926,
0.8090362548828125,
-0.8828608393669128,
-0.19486336410045624,
-0.38806581497192383,
0.25061118602752686,
-0.6375712156295776,
1.0995895862579346,
-0.31778472661972046,
-0.414700984954834,
-0.5941717624664307,
-0.17561495304107666,
-0.7880505919456482,
-0.8018723726272583,
-0.6867174506187439,
-0.5267466306686401,
0.15421909093856812,
0.4986976981163025,
0.7181902527809143,
0.41408035159111023,
0.7563416957855225,
0.30757173895835876,
0.1989923119544983,
0.0691797062754631,
-0.18276864290237427,
0.5532379150390625,
-0.0191942285746336,
-0.6281191110610962,
-0.342292845249176,
-0.11027967929840088,
0.4456614851951599,
0.7510389089584351,
-0.1932229995727539,
0.2598710060119629,
0.14724010229110718,
1.065151572227478,
-0.5005143284797668,
0.39876237511634827,
-0.5624464750289917,
0.47380751371383667,
-0.04595624655485153,
-0.295026957988739,
-0.32868269085884094,
-0.05158395320177078,
0.3012305796146393,
-0.8039748072624207,
0.19293171167373657,
0.32444825768470764,
1.0316299200057983,
0.7454099655151367,
-0.2725379467010498,
-0.487794429063797,
-1.0769251585006714,
1.075403094291687,
-0.22960713505744934,
0.3664538562297821,
0.30781659483909607,
0.13103117048740387,
-0.2893452048301697,
-0.7835944890975952,
-0.28485122323036194,
-0.06424525380134583,
0.15137943625450134,
0.03448516130447388,
-0.2010534554719925,
-0.011039495468139648,
0.45073169469833374,
0.5136792063713074,
-0.6170878410339355,
0.1549658477306366,
-0.36169737577438354,
0.10665132850408554,
0.9117565751075745,
0.40719491243362427,
0.4579724669456482,
0.18790695071220398,
-0.15124806761741638,
-0.0753665491938591,
-0.5256788730621338,
-0.3445781171321869,
0.3334793448448181,
0.207840695977211,
0.23778735101222992,
0.640529215335846,
-0.03311775624752045,
0.6478198766708374,
-0.17938821017742157,
0.45556384325027466,
0.49325698614120483,
-0.3906634747982025,
-0.43346866965293884,
-0.15729476511478424,
0.33731505274772644,
0.0018673257436603308,
0.34583228826522827,
-0.2916930019855499,
-0.4474242925643921,
0.07360663264989853,
0.9798304438591003,
-0.13113535940647125,
-0.09829001873731613,
0.62370365858078,
-0.3365382254123688,
-0.19066032767295837,
-0.25502753257751465,
-0.8327362537384033,
-0.5267012119293213,
-0.723646879196167,
0.11434122174978256,
-0.33166614174842834,
-0.04323841258883476,
0.0883440151810646,
-0.4106179475784302,
0.7571215629577637,
0.16537612676620483,
-1.048372507095337,
0.21102751791477203,
0.9588852524757385,
0.6189941763877869,
0.0757475271821022,
-0.2579573690891266,
-0.2740003764629364,
0.3269246816635132,
-0.480754554271698,
0.4985646605491638,
-0.2948480248451233,
-0.360481321811676,
0.03998633474111557,
-0.137522354722023,
0.08395148068666458,
-0.8446175456047058,
0.7216954827308655,
-0.4618428349494934,
-0.008984511718153954,
0.18138466775417328,
-0.5844442248344421,
-0.1788904070854187,
0.37248119711875916,
-0.8806414604187012,
0.9554148316383362,
0.28899237513542175,
-0.5070924758911133,
0.46351632475852966,
-0.8679786920547485,
-0.5074306130409241,
0.15194196999073029,
-0.29273730516433716,
-0.510399341583252,
0.14650939404964447,
0.12213096767663956,
0.37750372290611267,
-0.4168664216995239,
-0.11935677379369736,
-0.1768718808889389,
0.07872452586889267,
-0.31036028265953064,
-0.20351597666740417,
0.7412804365158081,
0.2891201674938202,
-0.35831019282341003,
-0.013232930563390255,
-0.6743999123573303,
0.3687765300273895,
0.07266892492771149,
-0.24542026221752167,
-0.3595156967639923,
0.28069719672203064,
0.19895164668560028,
-0.30826833844184875,
0.22825756669044495,
-0.08924180269241333,
-0.04725254327058792,
-0.3487148582935333,
0.42081767320632935,
0.5577449202537537,
-0.046057168394327164,
0.41386377811431885,
-0.3865657448768616,
0.5415354371070862,
-0.10816019028425217,
0.34524255990982056,
0.06065238267183304,
-0.2929989993572235,
-0.6997221112251282,
0.08198228478431702,
0.19118647277355194,
1.0215717554092407,
-0.779741108417511,
0.6807777285575867,
-0.11638448387384415,
-0.5976174473762512,
-0.8291113376617432,
0.3559756577014923,
-0.18424545228481293,
0.15238916873931885,
0.4157220423221588,
-0.2836921513080597,
-0.8626144528388977,
-0.934730589389801,
-0.11949601024389267,
-0.14606738090515137,
-0.3185875117778778,
0.36110422015190125,
0.3236798644065857,
-0.551362156867981,
1.0430221557617188,
-0.497384637594223,
-0.5758249163627625,
-0.607426106929779,
0.41228288412094116,
0.20910939574241638,
0.6468307375907898,
0.28053513169288635,
-1.2678778171539307,
-0.17253275215625763,
0.14519520103931427,
-1.0195642709732056,
-0.1087995320558548,
-0.7156714797019958,
-0.05903257802128792,
0.2312488853931427,
0.46082401275634766,
-0.4205041825771332,
0.3862830102443695,
0.25301581621170044,
-0.004797430243343115,
0.3139946758747101,
-0.16532856225967407,
0.026776596903800964,
-0.8597672581672668,
0.2928072214126587,
0.2590528428554535,
-0.05576783046126366,
-0.5915130972862244,
0.1878553181886673,
-0.3179827034473419,
-0.36873361468315125,
0.07759681344032288,
0.17386673390865326,
-0.4576432406902313,
-0.11112675815820694,
-0.1698000580072403,
0.0028980164788663387,
-0.010489385575056076,
0.12984073162078857,
-0.08238380402326584,
0.7271139025688171,
0.41434159874916077,
-0.7686285376548767,
0.8658093810081482,
0.5933313369750977,
-0.4148598313331604,
0.6760125756263733,
-0.675998330116272,
-0.001143404166214168,
-0.22096586227416992,
-0.07657260447740555,
-0.2168755829334259,
-0.03828006237745285,
0.046517252922058105,
-0.3738459050655365,
0.34889426827430725,
0.08148819953203201,
-0.4881395697593689,
-0.4303116500377655,
-0.18118107318878174,
0.11119256913661957,
0.40483367443084717,
-0.3191273510456085,
0.8460676670074463,
0.46364626288414,
-0.28923308849334717,
-0.7022376656532288,
-0.8710343837738037,
0.44846534729003906,
-0.32286518812179565,
-0.598442018032074,
0.5506211519241333,
0.19808228313922882,
-0.27837082743644714,
0.17300228774547577,
-0.190288707613945,
-0.3859090209007263,
0.441195547580719,
0.21136070787906647,
0.17281760275363922,
-0.0192689448595047,
0.0335000678896904,
-0.13495247066020966,
-0.497493714094162,
0.28565385937690735,
-0.1339866667985916,
0.08513128757476807,
0.023427506908774376,
-0.35474684834480286,
-0.49743127822875977,
0.6838247776031494,
0.6077283024787903,
-0.0800957977771759,
0.6153610348701477,
0.5076809525489807,
-0.5212780833244324,
-0.4282835125923157,
-0.25489792227745056,
-0.13064323365688324,
-0.4159468114376068,
0.6044189929962158,
-0.4083455204963684,
-0.380413681268692,
0.2896791696548462,
-0.2802029550075531,
0.6228981018066406,
0.35745111107826233,
0.34820908308029175,
-0.3796311914920807,
0.6864688396453857,
1.0915579795837402,
-0.5378749370574951,
0.5282316207885742,
-0.30540114641189575,
0.6463833451271057,
-0.7556519508361816,
-0.13250012695789337,
-0.7623090147972107,
-0.38569992780685425,
-0.42819708585739136,
0.05846768617630005,
0.20389099419116974,
-0.15167218446731567,
-0.2528446316719055,
0.37962469458580017,
-0.44609472155570984,
0.33847177028656006,
0.5352189540863037,
-0.20975151658058167,
0.18228985369205475,
-0.06685102730989456,
0.5866657495498657,
-0.11231355369091034,
-0.669007420539856,
-0.4790233075618744,
0.9172667264938354,
0.469890832901001,
1.0338971614837646,
-0.07698633521795273,
0.522853672504425,
0.8448501825332642,
0.04414697736501694,
-0.6515294313430786,
0.3139333426952362,
-0.2409554421901703,
-0.7476539611816406,
-0.4109932482242584,
-0.42829442024230957,
-0.9411280155181885,
-0.15331031382083893,
-0.28783753514289856,
-0.2946866750717163,
0.08650559931993484,
0.09704583138227463,
-0.29111233353614807,
0.12281113862991333,
-0.8620864152908325,
0.8955443501472473,
-0.3642979860305786,
0.01966007798910141,
-0.31045952439308167,
-0.637913167476654,
-0.032805390655994415,
-0.10741773247718811,
-0.015795215964317322,
0.06384562700986862,
-0.09467765688896179,
0.5917457342147827,
-0.09378629177808762,
0.7112296223640442,
0.018621336668729782,
0.08930087834596634,
0.19213177263736725,
-0.33914828300476074,
0.41430577635765076,
-0.2774261236190796,
-0.15752655267715454,
0.013780076988041401,
0.2934865355491638,
-0.511039674282074,
-0.797531247138977,
0.3498348891735077,
-0.6024602055549622,
-0.5647438168525696,
-0.4418255090713501,
-0.46766480803489685,
-0.38044440746307373,
-0.08849850296974182,
0.09361404925584793,
0.13227373361587524,
-0.18430697917938232,
0.45781517028808594,
0.8539978861808777,
-0.42793652415275574,
0.06176029145717621,
-0.029922930523753166,
0.07678119093179703,
-0.1428573578596115,
0.8878612518310547,
0.12069208920001984,
0.1236807107925415,
0.3166341781616211,
-0.39103782176971436,
-0.1697816699743271,
-0.34743165969848633,
-0.4125828444957733,
-0.20657019317150116,
-0.5336765646934509,
-0.1553298383951187,
-0.3290154039859772,
-0.4883722960948944,
-0.16748040914535522,
-0.5004445314407349,
-0.3252173960208893,
-0.12241822481155396,
-0.4823838770389557,
-0.09337367862462997,
0.24674344062805176,
0.6968316435813904,
0.24291954934597015,
-0.18647721409797668,
-0.770943284034729,
0.3769281208515167,
0.020377235487103462,
0.313612699508667,
0.054383762180805206,
-0.09271351993083954,
-0.3366634249687195,
-0.131247416138649,
-0.3229830265045166,
-0.5500352382659912,
0.31627777218818665,
0.05403640866279602,
0.767835259437561,
-0.15751533210277557,
0.20218178629875183,
0.44110170006752014,
-0.3555680811405182,
0.6279363632202148,
-0.28397801518440247,
-0.883683979511261,
0.6920732259750366,
0.07699219137430191,
-0.3254079818725586,
0.7596513032913208,
0.5279784798622131,
-0.828984797000885,
-0.23621270060539246,
-0.5435547828674316,
-1.53888738155365,
0.4511643052101135,
0.22643515467643738,
0.3119308352470398,
0.4331313371658325,
0.6216757893562317,
-0.05127764120697975,
0.3576698899269104,
-0.6388184428215027,
-0.28763389587402344,
0.08380661904811859,
-0.5624715089797974,
0.1761370301246643,
0.006023361347615719,
-0.06593494117259979,
-0.0013105554971843958,
0.841267466545105,
0.08216193318367004,
0.13818857073783875,
-0.04558766633272171,
-0.15426354110240936,
0.45075175166130066,
0.2668437361717224,
0.21784892678260803,
0.40867879986763,
0.06314584612846375,
-0.35624513030052185,
0.062482498586177826,
-0.45846110582351685,
0.10309555381536484,
-0.11380088329315186,
-0.28650277853012085,
-0.11410387605428696,
0.3216327428817749,
0.5773739814758301,
-0.15113377571105957,
-0.686163067817688,
0.020798588171601295,
0.17594866454601288,
-0.1859361082315445,
-0.5787188410758972,
0.24784362316131592,
-0.2298838049173355,
0.17081624269485474,
0.45591965317726135,
-0.16570942103862762,
0.15688572824001312,
-0.5051804184913635,
0.34378358721733093,
0.30967187881469727,
-0.19001977145671844,
0.2541118264198303,
0.4963184893131256,
0.40086957812309265,
-0.17365749180316925,
1.1559336185455322,
0.08329857885837555,
-0.24614766240119934,
1.0032627582550049,
0.37247434258461,
1.1246329545974731,
-0.12647745013237,
-0.033065322786569595,
-0.08037891238927841,
0.6490745544433594,
0.2118353694677353,
0.3268556594848633,
0.20110534131526947,
-0.6682945489883423,
-0.14576879143714905,
-0.3296710252761841,
-0.7409902811050415,
0.18935322761535645,
-0.6927942037582397,
0.14010418951511383,
-0.5044550895690918,
-0.09494402259588242,
0.062016624957323074,
0.2155981957912445,
-0.6079838275909424,
0.3315567672252655,
-0.08492588996887207,
0.8603594303131104,
-0.956268310546875,
0.286030113697052,
0.7424907088279724,
-0.5905256271362305,
-0.4083643853664398,
-0.08839265257120132,
-0.008833982981741428,
-0.6324020624160767,
0.47099199891090393,
-0.05259424075484276,
0.20230191946029663,
-0.011338729411363602,
-0.3618229925632477,
-0.41906610131263733,
0.8337433338165283,
0.1369520127773285,
-0.2834603488445282,
0.04349755123257637,
0.31034472584724426,
0.5279861092567444,
-0.29945534467697144,
-0.19308508932590485,
0.8085100650787354,
0.5884894132614136,
-0.2769143581390381,
-0.3469589948654175,
-0.36045143008232117,
-0.29039740562438965,
0.1383700966835022,
0.2783639132976532,
-0.3441116213798523,
0.31086286902427673,
0.07571745663881302,
-0.2636953592300415,
-0.06960746645927429,
0.6978656649589539,
0.11103306710720062,
0.6157804131507874,
0.446492463350296,
0.5688202381134033,
0.7104816436767578,
-0.1928403079509735,
0.928180992603302,
-0.32310450077056885,
0.1252933144569397,
1.00644052028656,
-0.5779062509536743,
0.8190852403640747,
0.5888893008232117,
-0.47669777274131775,
0.4222222864627838,
0.8334906101226807,
-0.47611379623413086,
0.053773943334817886,
0.44633105397224426,
-0.29098355770111084,
0.12430757284164429,
-0.02953946776688099,
-0.274898499250412,
0.2386016845703125,
0.47069111466407776,
-0.08701980859041214,
-0.034692976623773575,
0.20168480277061462,
-0.38490965962409973,
0.06925656646490097,
-0.17496947944164276,
0.8607290387153625,
0.13327689468860626,
-0.41170281171798706,
-0.06073392555117607,
0.05999058112502098,
0.387026309967041,
-0.6152624487876892,
-0.08041908591985703,
-0.19596421718597412,
0.21507713198661804,
-0.5047928094863892,
-1.0590219497680664,
1.0400464534759521,
0.2451433688402176,
-0.6480453610420227,
-0.5565659403800964,
0.3415360450744629,
-0.015399456024169922,
-0.25941288471221924,
0.21355365216732025,
0.22244518995285034,
0.0573236383497715,
-0.08430738747119904,
-0.9001534581184387,
0.007465445436537266,
0.12062332034111023,
-0.3207881450653076,
0.15177592635154724,
0.5580694675445557,
0.005180633161216974,
1.115775465965271,
0.21023936569690704,
-0.03358747065067291,
-0.03224024921655655,
0.08147920668125153,
0.4980020225048065,
-0.8417538404464722,
-0.24147260189056396,
-0.6190969944000244,
0.34626832604408264,
-0.12673665583133698,
-0.06836386770009995,
0.43150100111961365,
0.6644448637962341,
0.624997079372406,
0.03404182940721512,
1.0178102254867554,
-0.4508228302001953,
0.4498741924762726,
-0.5913991928100586,
0.7013677954673767,
-0.6420210599899292,
0.3895494341850281,
-0.13520167768001556,
-0.93258136510849,
-0.23715025186538696,
0.5136252641677856,
-0.18957604467868805,
0.23230816423892975,
0.49687761068344116,
0.56888347864151,
0.2851419448852539,
0.1817639321088791,
0.08087125420570374,
-0.07559225708246231,
0.41969069838523865,
0.6413635611534119,
0.5730218887329102,
-0.6119728088378906,
0.44035691022872925,
0.05540988966822624,
-0.1560174822807312,
0.0073682996444404125,
-0.6519995331764221,
-0.13133502006530762,
-0.9611122012138367,
-0.5662989020347595,
-0.23306237161159515,
-0.1364651620388031,
0.7258638739585876,
0.5732194185256958,
-0.8579202890396118,
-0.22486045956611633,
-0.3148592710494995,
0.4297107458114624,
-0.45092636346817017,
-0.2900489270687103,
-0.012604247778654099,
-0.8404477834701538,
-0.7372214198112488,
0.23225592076778412,
0.39529505372047424,
0.1776970624923706,
-0.2844219207763672,
0.16118507087230682,
-0.019102798774838448,
-0.07725141197443008,
0.425487220287323,
0.6361552476882935,
-0.182627335190773,
-0.17881272733211517,
-0.2875581979751587,
-0.03704086318612099,
-0.04322252422571182,
0.8504578471183777,
-0.7002243399620056,
0.15592657029628754,
0.4006704092025757,
1.4817320108413696,
0.3314642608165741,
-0.04890277981758118,
0.9750173687934875,
-0.8347581624984741,
-0.13199076056480408,
0.44574859738349915,
0.054444570094347,
0.32953715324401855,
-0.6836091876029968,
0.8817044496536255,
0.28874725103378296,
-0.7871731519699097,
-0.8510575890541077,
0.33855265378952026,
-0.8279518485069275,
-0.16590191423892975,
0.5433074831962585,
0.051328785717487335,
-0.029930485412478447,
-0.610283613204956,
0.05402715876698494,
-0.043869953602552414,
0.1642555147409439,
0.8788740634918213,
0.9649674892425537,
-0.3552769422531128,
-0.09765667468309402,
-0.9577895402908325,
0.5865978598594666,
0.7220168709754944,
-1.3367788791656494,
0.4279521107673645,
0.35125601291656494,
-0.14250659942626953,
0.15218086540699005,
0.3194982707500458,
0.032855913043022156,
-0.012671810574829578,
0.25631964206695557,
0.18125468492507935,
0.2918000817298889,
-0.5849510431289673,
-0.36762410402297974,
0.1609562188386917,
0.023400628939270973,
-0.4070650339126587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16973v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16973v1
|
Successfully Guiding Humans with Imperfect Instructions by Highlighting Potential Errors and Suggesting Corrections
| 2024-02-26T19:16:04 | 2024-02-26T19:16:04 |
Lingjun Zhao, Khanh Nguyen, Hal Daumé III
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
This paper addresses the challenge of leveraging imperfect language models to
guide human decision-making in the context of a grounded navigation task. We
show that an imperfect instruction generation model can be complemented with an
effective communication mechanism to become more successful at guiding humans.
The communication mechanism we build comprises models that can detect potential
hallucinations in instructions and suggest practical alternatives, and an
intuitive interface to present that information to users. We show that this
approach reduces the human navigation error by up to 29% with no additional
cognitive burden. This result underscores the potential of integrating diverse
communication channels into AI systems to compensate for their imperfections
and enhance their utility for humans.
|
[
-0.1829250156879425,
-0.7323779463768005,
1.1399352550506592,
0.16935762763023376,
-0.2705683410167694,
-0.08900751918554306,
-0.2488606721162796,
-0.1051512211561203,
0.0766710638999939,
0.45447808504104614,
-0.8603371977806091,
-0.5086519122123718,
-0.31984442472457886,
-0.1434035748243332,
-0.15878020226955414,
0.4493376314640045,
0.06127505004405975,
0.15549473464488983,
-0.20462822914123535,
-0.01896246150135994,
-1.10978364944458,
-0.36112746596336365,
-0.6238672733306885,
-0.6089729070663452,
0.24568381905555725,
0.8449689745903015,
1.0734620094299316,
0.515190064907074,
0.16231055557727814,
0.297859251499176,
-0.0179416723549366,
0.5492731332778931,
-0.49613523483276367,
0.10771588981151581,
-0.5115910172462463,
-0.8173211812973022,
-0.409079372882843,
0.04403790459036827,
0.31686291098594666,
1.1467558145523071,
-0.4531792402267456,
-0.3825753629207611,
0.08626512438058853,
0.7527204751968384,
-0.34173277020454407,
0.13127563893795013,
-0.31437066197395325,
0.017321785911917686,
0.09140746295452118,
-0.5210679173469543,
-0.6601694226264954,
-0.30608266592025757,
0.20003990828990936,
-0.8422986268997192,
0.14800846576690674,
0.384815514087677,
0.7581533193588257,
0.6581833362579346,
-0.19579483568668365,
-0.5679289102554321,
-0.9613637328147888,
0.5772527456283569,
-0.5970759391784668,
0.4884185791015625,
0.8584797978401184,
0.29622524976730347,
-0.660148561000824,
-0.6160449981689453,
-0.41189223527908325,
-0.42572107911109924,
0.04445270076394081,
0.0963820293545723,
-0.03993663564324379,
0.5367009043693542,
0.13781538605690002,
-0.18988238275051117,
-0.18826919794082642,
0.12155485153198242,
-0.5432586669921875,
-0.08490791916847229,
0.4533030092716217,
0.18500959873199463,
0.5371896028518677,
-0.05085340142250061,
0.14172102510929108,
-0.2843973636627197,
-0.6380707621574402,
-0.17884477972984314,
0.49379223585128784,
0.45154911279678345,
-0.24938330054283142,
0.4074391722679138,
-0.2381010800600052,
1.0896937847137451,
0.38000115752220154,
0.1574375480413437,
-0.02119169943034649,
-0.12287551164627075,
-0.13240662217140198,
0.3233194649219513,
0.1486959457397461,
0.6806727051734924,
0.11055054515600204,
-0.42502519488334656,
-0.22122937440872192,
0.19051328301429749,
1.1489554643630981,
-0.27875396609306335,
-0.49209877848625183,
0.13036102056503296,
-0.45783889293670654,
-0.2006908655166626,
0.18131157755851746,
-0.7309118509292603,
-0.5456002950668335,
-0.4891659617424011,
0.3280960023403168,
-0.47841086983680725,
-0.06504475325345993,
0.30869045853614807,
-0.1545402854681015,
0.43350112438201904,
0.7010910511016846,
-0.8002464771270752,
0.25926581025123596,
0.5928211808204651,
0.8207259178161621,
0.33011460304260254,
-0.31920772790908813,
-0.38660427927970886,
-0.07102490961551666,
-0.6457692980766296,
0.7379573583602905,
-0.4521290957927704,
-0.7586438059806824,
-0.23529353737831116,
-0.11085166037082672,
-0.06132104620337486,
-0.3696778416633606,
1.1159179210662842,
-0.05677396059036255,
0.3103716969490051,
-0.5103756189346313,
-0.3116227090358734,
-0.7663075923919678,
0.036339227110147476,
-0.4231495261192322,
0.3498668074607849,
0.18203313648700714,
-0.19697122275829315,
0.06583772599697113,
-0.7217793464660645,
-0.6213439702987671,
0.10120289772748947,
-0.2534855604171753,
-0.2530849277973175,
0.2836001515388489,
0.18405143916606903,
0.2713835835456848,
-0.12509554624557495,
0.3462808430194855,
0.01581384427845478,
-0.7407044172286987,
-0.009981514886021614,
-0.6673112511634827,
0.7265070676803589,
0.04092102870345116,
-1.074573278427124,
0.07236330211162567,
-0.6495017409324646,
0.008299537934362888,
0.03413790464401245,
-0.43466824293136597,
-0.39813563227653503,
0.5662224292755127,
-0.23979154229164124,
0.03915246203541756,
-0.15431158244609833,
0.054128728806972504,
0.3204786777496338,
-0.5235045552253723,
0.3191729485988617,
0.88164883852005,
0.01207362674176693,
0.7112062573432922,
-0.4126422703266144,
0.3648349344730377,
0.028140146285295486,
0.39034661650657654,
-0.31692543625831604,
-0.8221418857574463,
-1.34610116481781,
0.38554874062538147,
-0.03384222090244293,
0.6986024975776672,
-0.8550286889076233,
0.5304883122444153,
-0.16497448086738586,
-0.4487491846084595,
-0.9036803245544434,
-0.14218910038471222,
0.5262513756752014,
0.6053167581558228,
0.48437148332595825,
-0.042300980538129807,
-0.5604170560836792,
-0.5760645866394043,
-0.18184128403663635,
-0.5354463458061218,
0.045176539570093155,
0.5632942318916321,
0.08108840882778168,
-0.5694030523300171,
0.6044217944145203,
-0.20513583719730377,
-0.14368706941604614,
0.04786352813243866,
0.1917790025472641,
-0.08771295845508575,
0.6849221587181091,
0.2483408898115158,
-1.0147171020507812,
0.03391822427511215,
0.15506170690059662,
-1.0748176574707031,
-0.018908856436610222,
-0.7014420628547668,
-0.28750523924827576,
0.0648290291428566,
0.5046740174293518,
-0.4800891876220703,
0.6705761551856995,
0.12468816339969635,
-0.6472018957138062,
0.14482146501541138,
-0.5510307550430298,
0.49799853563308716,
-0.6817108988761902,
-0.329452246427536,
-0.0582120344042778,
-0.2230425626039505,
-0.7728105783462524,
0.10461118817329407,
-0.0776803269982338,
0.043525323271751404,
-0.22547747194766998,
0.32643598318099976,
-0.6959554553031921,
0.23660388588905334,
-0.21350595355033875,
0.3558286428451538,
-0.13605262339115143,
0.5430659055709839,
-0.11318300664424896,
0.5585626363754272,
0.5962039828300476,
-0.5815790295600891,
0.3108256459236145,
0.39267498254776,
0.09610989689826965,
0.9652295708656311,
-0.49332624673843384,
0.32072973251342773,
-0.44600415229797363,
0.04423590749502182,
-0.8909969925880432,
-0.579687237739563,
0.7566641569137573,
-0.5572957992553711,
0.35741233825683594,
-0.17030252516269684,
0.014361035078763962,
-0.28702157735824585,
-0.004408784676343203,
0.02876671589910984,
0.6668885946273804,
-0.5782649517059326,
0.9794406294822693,
0.0532233789563179,
0.3018445074558258,
-0.08590694516897202,
-0.7139933705329895,
0.44380244612693787,
-0.15762180089950562,
-0.7128823399543762,
0.29406440258026123,
-0.17381912469863892,
-0.33301591873168945,
-0.05184539034962654,
-0.21534623205661774,
0.03297601267695427,
0.3619087338447571,
0.8677595853805542,
0.21004298329353333,
-0.21549580991268158,
-0.22342181205749512,
0.13304227590560913,
0.03787165880203247,
0.1757260262966156,
-0.5891603231430054,
0.32195138931274414,
-0.40155747532844543,
-0.7826476693153381,
-0.8640907406806946,
0.2768869996070862,
0.8907245993614197,
0.3238753378391266,
0.7628689408302307,
0.11430858820676804,
-0.43840092420578003,
-0.07442536950111389,
-0.6591689586639404,
-0.42814362049102783,
-0.5358020663261414,
0.039554305374622345,
-0.18586039543151855,
-0.2774387001991272,
0.27093377709388733,
-0.3154013752937317,
-0.023225944489240646,
-0.024818353354930878,
0.10082989931106567,
-0.2145661562681198,
1.250748872756958,
0.9000436663627625,
0.30385252833366394,
0.2283039540052414,
0.01257346011698246,
0.5029746294021606,
-0.4815596640110016,
-0.6617102026939392,
-0.4240913987159729,
-0.24117179214954376,
-0.4319835305213928,
-0.5764440894126892,
0.4166663885116577,
0.3934043049812317,
-0.01825290359556675,
0.09294679760932922,
-0.8089936375617981,
0.30958062410354614,
0.9926695823669434,
0.4358198940753937,
0.0013061420759186149,
0.024609144777059555,
-0.35390371084213257,
-0.07320248335599899,
-1.1685479879379272,
-0.9581650495529175,
0.6317468881607056,
0.24967694282531738,
0.8989847302436829,
-0.1474786251783371,
0.7400832176208496,
0.44499510526657104,
0.23764938116073608,
-0.543628454208374,
0.43205633759498596,
0.494198203086853,
-0.16901709139347076,
-0.2525639533996582,
-0.34440740942955017,
-0.7048150897026062,
0.09546232968568802,
-0.3651956617832184,
-0.6355941891670227,
0.32299965620040894,
0.3451884388923645,
-0.562431812286377,
0.19411367177963257,
-1.197655200958252,
0.8475965857505798,
-0.4883858561515808,
-0.31220072507858276,
-0.08086144179105759,
-0.8159786462783813,
0.31183919310569763,
0.08245313912630081,
0.23635952174663544,
0.3562798500061035,
0.10709764063358307,
0.6239153146743774,
-0.33242470026016235,
1.0533303022384644,
-0.31850481033325195,
0.1544170081615448,
0.2793486416339874,
0.08938784152269363,
0.5436294078826904,
-0.24459227919578552,
-0.04016605392098427,
0.09055197238922119,
-0.6825674176216125,
-0.3969925045967102,
-0.673566460609436,
0.4263823330402374,
-0.7199419736862183,
-0.8053098320960999,
-0.22115616500377655,
-0.19952180981636047,
-0.009896269999444485,
0.12290263921022415,
0.43481001257896423,
0.26159054040908813,
-0.15037278831005096,
-0.1974354237318039,
0.5844713449478149,
-0.3427133858203888,
0.2401936799287796,
0.4797264337539673,
0.26153868436813354,
-0.0885067731142044,
0.9006386995315552,
-0.1563870906829834,
0.13508076965808868,
-0.16130703687667847,
-0.10676772892475128,
-0.21875956654548645,
-0.618070125579834,
-0.6895002722740173,
0.21620182693004608,
-0.9385055303573608,
-0.03803351894021034,
-0.45149344205856323,
-0.050310976803302765,
0.08927617967128754,
-0.7221696376800537,
-0.48703518509864807,
-0.09395983070135117,
-0.8106619715690613,
-0.27406132221221924,
-0.07863028347492218,
1.0161445140838623,
-0.20889344811439514,
0.5898581743240356,
-0.6193426847457886,
0.1556341052055359,
0.13558712601661682,
0.08444831520318985,
0.28508439660072327,
-0.3482759892940521,
-0.028730979189276695,
0.7815275192260742,
-0.46378347277641296,
-1.04973566532135,
0.09109019488096237,
-0.061999354511499405,
0.8604227900505066,
0.5688459277153015,
0.1837768852710724,
0.922153890132904,
-0.7234209775924683,
0.8957580327987671,
0.2190708965063095,
-1.0874637365341187,
0.9679489135742188,
-0.2817242443561554,
0.24629893898963928,
0.4552730917930603,
0.30167001485824585,
-0.706771194934845,
-0.5450998544692993,
-0.6854432225227356,
-0.8339784741401672,
0.8005355000495911,
0.48995089530944824,
0.058392059057950974,
-0.01764926128089428,
0.5762792825698853,
-0.3382607400417328,
-0.1390821933746338,
-0.5643017888069153,
-0.40425318479537964,
-0.30443552136421204,
-0.05698230490088463,
0.18312236666679382,
-0.07382089644670486,
-0.18610209226608276,
-0.14880211651325226,
0.7025378346443176,
-0.010587788186967373,
0.3891375660896301,
0.4526105225086212,
0.0768781527876854,
-0.31041496992111206,
0.03969242796301842,
1.1796387434005737,
0.8289168477058411,
-0.022347360849380493,
0.14949718117713928,
0.07433440536260605,
-0.4342334270477295,
0.35471010208129883,
-0.13011567294597626,
-0.33278748393058777,
0.009877614676952362,
0.3441688120365143,
1.0020564794540405,
0.2999304533004761,
-0.6742219924926758,
0.2725490629673004,
-0.3498058021068573,
-0.07210913300514221,
0.014442609623074532,
0.47678157687187195,
0.09609776735305786,
0.33705559372901917,
0.45727530121803284,
0.688969075679779,
0.00669312896206975,
-0.46967801451683044,
0.3004453182220459,
0.17166519165039062,
-0.7033683061599731,
-0.3617556095123291,
0.8968451023101807,
0.6228210926055908,
-1.024039626121521,
0.8878117203712463,
-0.5094158053398132,
-0.764502763748169,
0.3931201100349426,
0.21290478110313416,
0.7919976115226746,
-0.4845806360244751,
0.4544751048088074,
0.10835195332765579,
0.8877368569374084,
-0.6562080979347229,
0.02635270170867443,
-0.22881358861923218,
-0.49635717272758484,
-0.12565656006336212,
-0.1744239330291748,
-0.4742871820926666,
-0.34379610419273376,
-0.4999302625656128,
0.19983291625976562,
-0.3707936406135559,
-0.033741794526576996,
-0.32777923345565796,
-0.6274453997612,
-0.473770409822464,
0.20754894614219666,
0.36404651403427124,
0.49693745374679565,
-0.6802008152008057,
0.37834882736206055,
0.8292851448059082,
-0.4868035316467285,
-0.9381275773048401,
0.2877896726131439,
0.06030604615807533,
-0.4364900290966034,
0.4026760458946228,
0.12976202368736267,
-0.4763023853302002,
-0.04817424714565277,
-0.6356787085533142,
-0.4620642364025116,
0.7331180572509766,
0.3212472200393677,
-0.463462769985199,
-0.3684803545475006,
-0.04276525229215622,
0.3873893916606903,
-0.22780673205852509,
0.14405670762062073,
0.5334506034851074,
0.7542709112167358,
0.06519320607185364,
-0.8025667667388916,
0.12439530342817307,
-0.1607622653245926,
-0.07018450647592545,
-0.080959253013134,
-0.35848796367645264,
0.525697648525238,
-0.5798664689064026,
-0.5564945936203003,
0.06818313151597977,
0.5802455544471741,
0.10226428508758545,
0.4071209132671356,
0.3932964503765106,
0.2722337543964386,
1.1865906715393066,
-0.209178626537323,
0.9953165650367737,
-0.045019347220659256,
-0.07266487181186676,
0.9117444753646851,
-0.020439185202121735,
0.4608319401741028,
0.5418342351913452,
0.3308636546134949,
0.6059018969535828,
0.5708572268486023,
0.3083430528640747,
0.685104489326477,
0.07092443853616714,
-0.13779032230377197,
-0.3522162139415741,
0.11616915464401245,
-0.24496328830718994,
0.46263566613197327,
0.570846438407898,
-0.11360088735818863,
-0.254065603017807,
0.2751030921936035,
-0.017825143411755562,
0.40612146258354187,
-0.24893662333488464,
0.581332802772522,
0.018723055720329285,
-1.2712138891220093,
1.0876595973968506,
0.32573580741882324,
0.5823454856872559,
-0.1542264223098755,
-0.5391829609870911,
-0.3435792922973633,
0.13581794500350952,
-0.2401427924633026,
-0.4277147948741913,
0.22073067724704742,
-0.23311375081539154,
-0.10566174238920212,
-0.23701128363609314,
0.6069554686546326,
-0.30494779348373413,
-0.2820451557636261,
0.1785360723733902,
0.41349735856056213,
0.16754432022571564,
-0.10641666501760483,
-0.6507928967475891,
0.2596207559108734,
0.4346890449523926,
0.1743399202823639,
-0.2723712921142578,
0.35452768206596375,
-0.10651658475399017,
1.0167920589447021,
0.5270056128501892,
0.026005426421761513,
0.27566155791282654,
-0.16188016533851624,
0.7639439702033997,
-0.7920354604721069,
-0.6920480132102966,
-0.8153546452522278,
0.7398816347122192,
-0.23967403173446655,
-0.1598031222820282,
0.7528926730155945,
0.15508195757865906,
0.7686475515365601,
-0.0571487732231617,
0.6802381277084351,
0.2120121866464615,
-0.014077471569180489,
-0.6117035150527954,
0.7125691771507263,
-0.40526920557022095,
0.6030737161636353,
-0.14022178947925568,
-0.8489825129508972,
-0.22567906975746155,
1.2205393314361572,
-0.08257897198200226,
0.14796335995197296,
0.6285109519958496,
0.9193232655525208,
-0.2376977801322937,
0.2528724670410156,
0.3869405686855316,
0.18718962371349335,
0.21893610060214996,
0.5887469053268433,
1.1109592914581299,
-0.47304660081863403,
0.14602769911289215,
-0.10849421471357346,
-0.3647085428237915,
-0.5615770220756531,
-0.6065948009490967,
-1.1462873220443726,
-0.5940518379211426,
-0.2845475971698761,
-0.454705148935318,
0.6489595174789429,
0.8513306379318237,
1.1630586385726929,
-0.33806687593460083,
-0.11689306050539017,
-0.6463005542755127,
0.5380578637123108,
-0.2560366094112396,
-0.16238480806350708,
-0.07598225027322769,
-0.43286755681037903,
-0.598194420337677,
0.7713154554367065,
0.435806006193161,
0.32976487278938293,
-0.43205615878105164,
-0.6118144392967224,
-0.06064900755882263,
0.16712741553783417,
0.29079917073249817,
0.28970959782600403,
-1.0837290287017822,
-0.38706356287002563,
-0.06323092430830002,
-0.09713561832904816,
0.030479634180665016,
0.844033420085907,
-0.6289842128753662,
0.5898590683937073,
-0.12054302543401718,
0.5766586661338806,
0.17750641703605652,
0.1339251548051834,
0.9153860211372375,
-0.5966123342514038,
0.3440442681312561,
0.39164450764656067,
0.0978618860244751,
0.7554318308830261,
-0.7781702280044556,
0.5133256316184998,
0.17883192002773285,
-0.46614986658096313,
-0.7615678906440735,
-0.15579800307750702,
-0.892490565776825,
-0.4832793176174164,
1.1037979125976562,
0.002141370205208659,
-0.42833584547042847,
-0.42329493165016174,
-0.614924967288971,
0.1343400925397873,
-0.3524603545665741,
0.9679819941520691,
0.7709107995033264,
-0.027120551094412804,
0.028947193175554276,
-0.7339502573013306,
0.6264551877975464,
0.4655197858810425,
-0.8122307062149048,
-0.11783382296562195,
0.7834402322769165,
-0.14444522559642792,
0.3363793194293976,
0.5114775896072388,
0.4374721646308899,
0.5795276165008545,
0.3129829168319702,
-0.2140466570854187,
0.0004992158501408994,
-0.6417608261108398,
-0.2805349826812744,
-0.12369120121002197,
0.2006291151046753,
-0.33984628319740295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16846v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16846v2
|
GROUNDHOG: Grounding Large Language Models to Holistic Segmentation
| 2024-02-26T18:59:33 | 2024-04-16T17:59:53 |
Yichi Zhang, Ziqiao Ma, Xiaofeng Gao, Suhaila Shakiah, Qiaozi Gao, Joyce Chai
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Most multimodal large language models (MLLMs) learn language-to-object
grounding through causal language modeling where grounded objects are captured
by bounding boxes as sequences of location tokens. This paradigm lacks
pixel-level representations that are important for fine-grained visual
understanding and diagnosis. In this work, we introduce GROUNDHOG, an MLLM
developed by grounding Large Language Models to holistic segmentation.
GROUNDHOG incorporates a masked feature extractor and converts extracted
features into visual entity tokens for the MLLM backbone, which then connects
groundable phrases to unified grounding masks by retrieving and merging the
entity masks. To train GROUNDHOG, we carefully curated M3G2, a grounded visual
instruction tuning dataset with Multi-Modal Multi-Grained Grounding, by
harvesting a collection of segmentation-grounded datasets with rich
annotations. Our experimental results show that GROUNDHOG achieves superior
performance on various language grounding tasks without task-specific
fine-tuning, and significantly reduces object hallucination. GROUNDHOG also
demonstrates better grounding towards complex forms of visual input and
provides easy-to-understand diagnosis in failure cases.
|
[
-0.37678173184394836,
-1.1992813348770142,
0.31425780057907104,
0.1864519715309143,
-0.5686361193656921,
-0.04905938729643822,
-0.268362820148468,
-0.3340011239051819,
-0.2430623471736908,
0.6769317984580994,
-0.2915944755077362,
-0.9263428449630737,
-0.5822111964225769,
-0.4123157560825348,
-0.05792127177119255,
0.7767097353935242,
0.26785507798194885,
0.03774602338671684,
-0.2737893760204315,
-0.3012447655200958,
-0.8817629814147949,
-0.43437957763671875,
-0.5502044558525085,
-0.362623006105423,
0.44668132066726685,
0.45079106092453003,
0.7271263003349304,
0.9568794369697571,
0.275962233543396,
0.25840720534324646,
-0.002456974470987916,
0.3138136863708496,
-0.35769107937812805,
-0.028280124068260193,
-0.2011858969926834,
-0.21519967913627625,
-0.21659614145755768,
-0.051060110330581665,
0.5225410461425781,
0.7376871705055237,
-0.11815398931503296,
0.14154541492462158,
-0.19095422327518463,
0.6440006494522095,
-0.7335934638977051,
0.29046007990837097,
-0.6817512512207031,
0.10070421546697617,
-0.18199755251407623,
-0.2202015370130539,
-0.5336143374443054,
0.23217277228832245,
-0.17286226153373718,
-0.7612043023109436,
0.11382891237735748,
0.1824432760477066,
0.972413957118988,
0.3727094233036041,
-0.26008638739585876,
0.08867780864238739,
-0.3092716932296753,
0.7274891138076782,
-0.4521210491657257,
0.49116459488868713,
0.4087899923324585,
0.4776284396648407,
-0.03446058928966522,
-0.43669241666793823,
-0.04883778467774391,
-0.2778617739677429,
0.07238352298736572,
0.024913158267736435,
-0.0015015265671536326,
0.16958832740783691,
0.4520339369773865,
0.2223920077085495,
-0.43439507484436035,
0.08712294697761536,
-0.069887675344944,
-0.35587579011917114,
0.11194826662540436,
0.11753761023283005,
0.38396647572517395,
-0.032124120742082596,
-0.14473658800125122,
-0.008207251317799091,
-0.6048904061317444,
0.15896162390708923,
0.04999067634344101,
0.23382598161697388,
0.1446830779314041,
0.547408401966095,
-0.2720155119895935,
1.2906994819641113,
0.18783576786518097,
-0.49719613790512085,
0.009240376763045788,
0.28832194209098816,
-0.4684382975101471,
0.18318819999694824,
0.3136247992515564,
0.724154531955719,
0.18382328748703003,
-0.1818837672472,
-0.08554841578006744,
0.20733126997947693,
0.08717939257621765,
-0.78825843334198,
-0.348604291677475,
-0.02733774110674858,
-0.4831223785877228,
-0.18511320650577545,
0.14071232080459595,
-0.683872401714325,
-0.49389147758483887,
-0.5740814208984375,
0.1527174413204193,
-0.5356500744819641,
-0.2993748188018799,
0.42411184310913086,
-0.2484549582004547,
0.4660484790802002,
0.5406777858734131,
-0.8437893390655518,
0.09416709095239639,
0.8461511731147766,
0.8498279452323914,
0.1378994733095169,
-0.48130932450294495,
-1.052204966545105,
0.5380770564079285,
-0.5103759765625,
0.940370500087738,
-0.770313024520874,
-0.04416029900312424,
-0.17618106305599213,
0.2992963194847107,
0.04856923595070839,
-0.6354657411575317,
0.16295716166496277,
-0.38283926248550415,
-0.049137454479932785,
-0.36853915452957153,
-0.09499840438365936,
-0.5455262064933777,
0.5729061365127563,
-0.4074970483779907,
1.0076526403427124,
0.12601162493228912,
-0.9567992091178894,
0.539059579372406,
-0.24032174050807953,
-0.5066576600074768,
0.06135614216327667,
-0.14241965115070343,
-0.3694693446159363,
0.19874607026576996,
0.27841436862945557,
0.6796378493309021,
-0.2256903499364853,
0.7336105108261108,
-0.4365861415863037,
-0.3952334523200989,
-0.4295874536037445,
-0.3023734986782074,
0.5102992653846741,
-0.14635834097862244,
-0.5508372783660889,
0.37545326352119446,
-0.906334400177002,
-0.11257071048021317,
0.17041723430156708,
-0.24219653010368347,
-0.5251733064651489,
0.1487935334444046,
0.3275529742240906,
0.4456615447998047,
-0.009611235931515694,
-0.14711816608905792,
-0.008773202076554298,
-0.3331871032714844,
0.36799177527427673,
0.4102347493171692,
-0.17138618230819702,
0.20199479162693024,
-0.22722749412059784,
0.08783137053251266,
0.265884667634964,
-0.05510633438825607,
-0.6544002890586853,
-0.6125466823577881,
-0.8839548230171204,
-0.4414062798023224,
-0.1303185522556305,
0.5474205017089844,
-0.4292506277561188,
0.7819529175758362,
-0.07823774963617325,
-0.37548407912254333,
-0.2169547975063324,
-0.061216775327920914,
0.39121443033218384,
0.7597798705101013,
0.47770604491233826,
-0.05684373527765274,
-0.5201648473739624,
-0.9845010638237,
0.04865338280797005,
-0.08910372853279114,
0.07002664357423782,
0.28998616337776184,
0.21431486308574677,
-0.5501833558082581,
0.9485377669334412,
-0.35599806904792786,
-0.3130476772785187,
-0.0037883652839809656,
0.09488952159881592,
-0.1603585034608841,
0.5715659260749817,
0.2565324008464813,
-0.5336784720420837,
-0.20979972183704376,
0.4641781747341156,
-0.9940789937973022,
-0.04987676441669464,
-0.04900675639510155,
-0.20312990248203278,
-0.06664480268955231,
0.581727921962738,
-0.7512108683586121,
0.37519189715385437,
0.48550304770469666,
-0.42693769931793213,
0.43031033873558044,
-0.16834238171577454,
0.00030513416277244687,
-0.767052173614502,
0.22994309663772583,
-0.11013001948595047,
-0.5458078384399414,
-0.31513530015945435,
0.10074722766876221,
-0.04977624490857124,
-0.4123910367488861,
-0.29835203289985657,
0.47166386246681213,
-0.6378448009490967,
-0.4225156903266907,
-0.3505837023258209,
-0.01695965975522995,
0.35078373551368713,
0.39966079592704773,
0.17855793237686157,
0.719052791595459,
0.9856582880020142,
-0.5118899941444397,
0.29035577178001404,
0.14513814449310303,
-0.07596263289451599,
0.5386178493499756,
-0.5901572108268738,
0.08325380086898804,
-0.2852307856082916,
0.10828767716884613,
-0.7202094197273254,
-0.3988395929336548,
0.3799493610858917,
-0.03556627780199051,
0.4049481153488159,
-0.33603090047836304,
-0.42110300064086914,
-0.13811637461185455,
-0.061271365731954575,
0.2420530766248703,
0.4228641390800476,
-0.5143656730651855,
0.6176485419273376,
0.5392550230026245,
0.3565739691257477,
-0.3586326837539673,
-0.4152497351169586,
0.24833910167217255,
-0.5068645477294922,
-0.7423868775367737,
-0.05399918183684349,
0.20864641666412354,
-0.2836742699146271,
-0.3231199085712433,
-0.06234782561659813,
0.055346909910440445,
0.42198535799980164,
0.47488924860954285,
-0.19516663253307343,
-0.5497201085090637,
0.2494608759880066,
-0.07656553387641907,
-0.5260292887687683,
0.051049504429101944,
-0.5530345439910889,
0.6723065972328186,
-0.32724982500076294,
-0.5815555453300476,
-0.13243505358695984,
0.454659640789032,
0.7759674191474915,
-0.5542970299720764,
0.33586668968200684,
0.892612099647522,
-0.5235783457756042,
0.09675523638725281,
-0.6504698991775513,
-0.03787713870406151,
-0.41246485710144043,
0.40887451171875,
-0.48290660977363586,
-0.7481010556221008,
0.3103220760822296,
-0.359144389629364,
-0.012630002573132515,
0.4497982859611511,
0.5442575812339783,
0.2127961963415146,
1.2481539249420166,
0.6204336881637573,
-0.03682602941989899,
0.4481332004070282,
-0.09502994269132614,
-0.17707815766334534,
-0.8582397699356079,
-0.409301221370697,
-0.1719694882631302,
0.16989079117774963,
-0.014979843981564045,
-0.789238691329956,
0.018904341384768486,
0.6684838533401489,
-0.16250993311405182,
-0.18770384788513184,
-0.6224400997161865,
0.6225923895835876,
0.37647709250450134,
0.2632642090320587,
0.08232437074184418,
0.2517952620983124,
-0.1640503704547882,
-0.06297856569290161,
-0.5225003361701965,
-0.7134703397750854,
0.546356201171875,
0.5192567110061646,
0.653145432472229,
-0.47597000002861023,
0.1894901990890503,
0.007400105707347393,
0.3275163173675537,
-1.0476824045181274,
0.36432555317878723,
-0.05992046743631363,
-0.3472718596458435,
-0.32818493247032166,
0.06931136548519135,
-0.6715868711471558,
0.5587958693504333,
0.03635216876864433,
-0.7488978505134583,
-0.10708890855312347,
0.26187393069267273,
-0.11002753674983978,
0.26050350069999695,
-0.5587648153305054,
1.1872460842132568,
-0.29512086510658264,
-0.490481972694397,
-0.08155299723148346,
-0.8198480606079102,
0.4761463403701782,
0.1441022902727127,
0.24973204731941223,
-0.500853955745697,
0.20934611558914185,
0.7821415662765503,
-0.06927675008773804,
0.9106875061988831,
-0.42146894335746765,
-0.2211304008960724,
0.18293200433254242,
0.05132966488599777,
0.39566677808761597,
0.4347018599510193,
0.25048789381980896,
0.45965102314949036,
-0.361601322889328,
-0.47945407032966614,
-0.4113835096359253,
0.43509477376937866,
-0.6367213129997253,
-0.706184983253479,
-0.20360121130943298,
-0.2869582176208496,
-0.27969861030578613,
0.46407777070999146,
0.21441121399402618,
0.6670026779174805,
-0.19613589346408844,
0.381509393453598,
0.763260006904602,
-0.2627134919166565,
0.2548840343952179,
0.3674905002117157,
-0.4368734061717987,
-0.5183623433113098,
1.0021225214004517,
-0.15862983465194702,
-0.07168077677488327,
0.39907771348953247,
0.3612116277217865,
0.055226538330316544,
-0.529877245426178,
-0.8217127323150635,
0.1873069852590561,
-0.8788207173347473,
-0.22288034856319427,
-1.0420573949813843,
0.015544427558779716,
-0.016114378347992897,
-0.34964147210121155,
-0.4645618200302124,
0.2627454400062561,
-0.5988039970397949,
-0.08651621639728546,
0.2629240155220032,
0.4854861795902252,
0.041444770991802216,
0.501154363155365,
-0.7652233839035034,
0.5789870023727417,
0.4866436719894409,
0.23884177207946777,
-0.16370144486427307,
-0.3606629967689514,
-0.44087401032447815,
0.1119658350944519,
-0.15705443918704987,
-0.7836329936981201,
0.2387983202934265,
0.21477676928043365,
0.5459522008895874,
0.6582354307174683,
-0.3845370411872864,
1.2924282550811768,
-0.7731107473373413,
0.5505111813545227,
0.4492284059524536,
-1.0339794158935547,
0.6934683918952942,
-0.6749637722969055,
0.3638729751110077,
0.45692768692970276,
-0.2365693747997284,
-0.6247608065605164,
-0.3382182717323303,
-0.24141526222229004,
-0.7138709425926208,
0.6494192481040955,
-0.2540723383426666,
-0.07667530328035355,
-0.07365027815103531,
0.0451691709458828,
0.25335437059402466,
0.21607576310634613,
-0.5357246398925781,
-0.08661609888076782,
-0.607054591178894,
-0.00294396560639143,
-0.3619596064090729,
-0.39732521772384644,
-0.3418307602405548,
-0.5252932906150818,
0.22086796164512634,
-0.4864998161792755,
0.05725868418812752,
-0.017707867547869682,
-0.4477245807647705,
-0.3223453164100647,
-0.13693782687187195,
0.6975908875465393,
0.7874137163162231,
-0.25348496437072754,
0.4285847544670105,
-0.05007787048816681,
-0.34452465176582336,
0.1568043977022171,
-0.10193230211734772,
0.04997546225786209,
0.20468099415302277,
0.5453136563301086,
1.0694750547409058,
0.43200328946113586,
-0.7118184566497803,
0.4843769073486328,
0.21171094477176666,
0.042458027601242065,
0.02625332772731781,
-0.09276524186134338,
0.037577103823423386,
0.1560104936361313,
0.2039230316877365,
0.11867131292819977,
0.22973428666591644,
-0.25972723960876465,
0.4992884695529938,
0.5747854113578796,
-0.45932430028915405,
-0.45989134907722473,
0.44613707065582275,
0.03987891972064972,
-0.23606136441230774,
0.34597834944725037,
0.10561318695545197,
-0.5629816055297852,
0.5963749885559082,
0.8596499562263489,
0.8409501314163208,
-0.07883996516466141,
0.32233670353889465,
0.19576098024845123,
0.4834618866443634,
-0.22707757353782654,
-0.1230347603559494,
-0.09837351739406586,
-0.4089270234107971,
-0.3733646869659424,
-0.5729933381080627,
-0.12829886376857758,
0.21641705930233002,
-0.6320970058441162,
0.5261362195014954,
-0.6369206309318542,
0.13632884621620178,
-0.17497840523719788,
-0.2514973282814026,
-0.4670231342315674,
0.43515080213546753,
0.3111421465873718,
0.6653671264648438,
-0.9985597729682922,
0.7318641543388367,
0.9835099577903748,
-0.019406983628869057,
-0.683120846748352,
0.031697068363428116,
-0.31581488251686096,
-0.9077100157737732,
0.6633607149124146,
1.069254755973816,
-0.1404600739479065,
0.2945703864097595,
-0.4958641827106476,
-0.7915195822715759,
0.8746099472045898,
0.4932287335395813,
-0.4201929271221161,
0.06241344287991524,
-0.22292403876781464,
0.24235855042934418,
-0.4762083888053894,
0.2101999670267105,
0.4057903289794922,
0.6699100732803345,
0.19769532978534698,
-0.5448886752128601,
-0.03863922134041786,
0.03855085372924805,
-0.04904678091406822,
0.23593822121620178,
-0.7036877870559692,
1.015753149986267,
0.04069497436285019,
-0.2854782044887543,
-0.5008882284164429,
0.3969865143299103,
0.4591003954410553,
0.6289404630661011,
0.4893490672111511,
0.8822569847106934,
0.6696025133132935,
0.04566599056124687,
0.5806972980499268,
-0.28205254673957825,
0.3465053141117096,
0.8096214532852173,
-0.25540757179260254,
0.5194569826126099,
0.42476338148117065,
0.30381736159324646,
0.38646945357322693,
0.8285207152366638,
0.07749199122190475,
0.5801416635513306,
0.1024954617023468,
0.14368905127048492,
-0.7983012199401855,
-0.1593397557735443,
-0.6007659435272217,
0.6921475529670715,
0.423311322927475,
-0.09222234785556793,
-0.7269308567047119,
0.34092822670936584,
-0.12783372402191162,
-0.15880873799324036,
-0.3101131319999695,
0.9628782272338867,
-0.030921682715415955,
-0.403792142868042,
0.8480228185653687,
0.20767906308174133,
0.30083727836608887,
-0.3500140309333801,
-0.4223407506942749,
-0.16821834444999695,
-0.0370214469730854,
-0.1445353627204895,
-0.3480936288833618,
0.3810541331768036,
-0.2809884548187256,
-0.29397937655448914,
-0.06573575735092163,
0.889910876750946,
-0.35529157519340515,
-0.4187207818031311,
0.37828657031059265,
0.32780447602272034,
0.1589956134557724,
-0.4959389567375183,
-0.6871417760848999,
0.2989993989467621,
-0.20380452275276184,
-0.23564928770065308,
0.2326415330171585,
0.8365868926048279,
-0.3798116445541382,
0.6910139322280884,
0.798012375831604,
-0.24092765152454376,
0.14649292826652527,
-0.05382615327835083,
1.1516450643539429,
-0.880086362361908,
-0.5539355874061584,
-1.0896092653274536,
0.7526403665542603,
-0.03621329739689827,
-0.20833060145378113,
0.7851902842521667,
0.6505376100540161,
0.44679972529411316,
-0.24898678064346313,
0.5684425830841064,
0.28893253207206726,
0.003266992513090372,
-0.844277024269104,
0.4076254367828369,
-0.5512321591377258,
-0.12748000025749207,
-0.05328639596700668,
-0.9167858362197876,
-0.4948749244213104,
0.9050790667533875,
-0.12609227001667023,
-0.32027915120124817,
0.6360837817192078,
0.5524961352348328,
-0.30121999979019165,
-0.5787475109100342,
0.8688727617263794,
-0.08466371893882751,
0.33183708786964417,
0.41562798619270325,
1.097232699394226,
-0.1638008952140808,
0.011726309545338154,
-0.021392520517110825,
-0.26749253273010254,
-0.5740303993225098,
-0.7226296663284302,
-1.3318157196044922,
-0.1815762221813202,
-0.25786668062210083,
-0.1643282026052475,
0.08783596754074097,
0.724967896938324,
1.1854380369186401,
-0.7148727178573608,
-0.04533949866890907,
-0.4218646287918091,
0.23918239772319794,
-0.0049257646314799786,
-0.1991100311279297,
0.18381145596504211,
-0.35219693183898926,
-0.3076852560043335,
0.37691426277160645,
0.863067090511322,
-0.11120280623435974,
-0.3434089720249176,
-0.02039516530930996,
0.037619687616825104,
-0.36826133728027344,
0.7599663138389587,
0.08838259428739548,
-1.2035883665084839,
-0.29818055033683777,
-0.16374966502189636,
-0.1539185643196106,
0.3122539520263672,
0.9587417244911194,
-0.8195050954818726,
0.4734293818473816,
-0.13419918715953827,
0.6950499415397644,
0.16120488941669464,
0.2970409095287323,
0.32510432600975037,
-0.662075400352478,
0.799691915512085,
0.15544278919696808,
0.3071523606777191,
0.598585307598114,
-0.4596957564353943,
0.0788770467042923,
0.515600323677063,
-0.2524457573890686,
-0.7534676194190979,
0.2627991735935211,
-0.9494227170944214,
-0.2540799379348755,
1.4972525835037231,
-0.12923815846443176,
-0.3443772494792938,
-0.3896714746952057,
-0.8074048161506653,
0.33926814794540405,
-0.2304704636335373,
0.43649494647979736,
0.582155168056488,
0.5040470957756042,
-0.4015985131263733,
-0.5367071628570557,
0.24963335692882538,
0.14945244789123535,
-0.9803072810173035,
0.2798091173171997,
0.8595371842384338,
0.24030636250972748,
0.16529743373394012,
0.3983597755432129,
0.2451023906469345,
0.1968865692615509,
0.10258045792579651,
0.06855916231870651,
-0.42879265546798706,
-0.6714244484901428,
-0.40748730301856995,
0.33108675479888916,
0.30407604575157166,
-0.2983550429344177
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.