id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18756v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18756v1
|
How Much Annotation is Needed to Compare Summarization Models?
| 2024-02-28T23:34:51 | 2024-02-28T23:34:51 |
Chantal Shaib, Joe Barrow, Alexa F. Siu, Byron C. Wallace, Ani Nenkova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern instruction-tuned models have become highly capable in text generation
tasks such as summarization, and are expected to be released at a steady pace.
In practice one may now wish to choose confidently, but with minimal effort,
the best performing summarization model when applied to a new domain or
purpose. In this work, we empirically investigate the test sample size
necessary to select a preferred model in the context of news summarization.
Empirical results reveal that comparative evaluation converges quickly for both
automatic and human evaluation, with clear preferences for a system emerging
from under 100 examples. The human preference data allows us to quantify how
well automatic scores can reproduce preference rankings across a variety of
downstream summarization tasks. We find that, while automatic metrics are
stable at smaller sample sizes, only some automatic metrics are able to
moderately predict model win rates according to human preference.
|
[
-0.7463390827178955,
-0.2982453405857086,
0.505212128162384,
0.32128265500068665,
-0.2576391100883484,
-0.3067121207714081,
-0.36134323477745056,
-0.5530328154563904,
0.12227897346019745,
0.15870201587677002,
-0.06943374872207642,
-0.1564243733882904,
-0.6634497046470642,
0.4295838177204132,
-0.46358877420425415,
1.357528567314148,
0.09366726130247116,
-0.06139623746275902,
-0.6446793079376221,
-0.03873174265027046,
-0.2857264280319214,
-0.41986703872680664,
-0.6265098452568054,
-0.4530867040157318,
0.5336884260177612,
0.2796446979045868,
0.7072196006774902,
0.6523369550704956,
0.8576057553291321,
0.23332040011882782,
-0.29105815291404724,
0.13891777396202087,
-0.20638743042945862,
-0.018816642463207245,
0.18199382722377777,
-0.5582069754600525,
-0.6405007839202881,
0.5890964865684509,
0.4094393253326416,
0.9675201773643494,
0.251330703496933,
0.7446804642677307,
0.02638290822505951,
0.8475530743598938,
-0.6748594641685486,
0.05457904189825058,
-0.26629120111465454,
-0.0022537459153681993,
0.21815261244773865,
-0.009862605482339859,
-0.39954787492752075,
-0.6773226261138916,
0.4705546796321869,
-0.5224964618682861,
0.34998929500579834,
0.19620639085769653,
0.8765947222709656,
0.18807056546211243,
-0.6546907424926758,
-0.028067557141184807,
-0.4415385127067566,
0.7707285284996033,
-0.7752056121826172,
0.05286369100213051,
0.38173338770866394,
0.44691669940948486,
0.27639544010162354,
-0.474055677652359,
-0.25744542479515076,
-0.5130653977394104,
-0.11995206028223038,
0.2060830444097519,
-0.15416860580444336,
-0.022112155333161354,
0.3257136046886444,
0.38520026206970215,
-0.544811487197876,
0.13464772701263428,
-0.6168608069419861,
0.025667140260338783,
1.0145241022109985,
0.22651350498199463,
0.0859559029340744,
-0.45282402634620667,
-0.12875735759735107,
-0.19941028952598572,
-0.341228187084198,
0.029781697317957878,
0.4652787148952484,
0.2353958934545517,
-0.1976279616355896,
0.6550803184509277,
-0.7281797528266907,
0.8514657020568848,
0.1892872154712677,
0.08957871794700623,
0.11965709924697876,
-0.3182554543018341,
-0.38479310274124146,
-0.02981567569077015,
0.7667028903961182,
1.169389247894287,
0.44598057866096497,
0.025261525064706802,
-0.37810108065605164,
0.0935274139046669,
0.27254149317741394,
-0.9857138991355896,
-0.26087191700935364,
0.13650652766227722,
-0.6561967134475708,
-0.4184199869632721,
0.1316898763179779,
-0.5211076140403748,
-0.32103899121284485,
-0.5727294087409973,
0.282685786485672,
-0.06741022318601608,
-0.041069578379392624,
-0.07799843698740005,
-0.6620683670043945,
-0.16680127382278442,
0.5948306322097778,
-1.0058075189590454,
0.13333334028720856,
0.5559845566749573,
1.0284628868103027,
-0.5757843255996704,
-0.14353667199611664,
-0.28376269340515137,
-0.3678116500377655,
-0.8170875310897827,
1.0450142621994019,
-0.2484237402677536,
-0.36086490750312805,
-0.4223998486995697,
-0.26009300351142883,
-0.08168721199035645,
-0.5113058686256409,
0.23529981076717377,
-0.4777851700782776,
0.40957218408584595,
-0.45094799995422363,
-0.7919953465461731,
-0.24274387955665588,
0.15839625895023346,
-0.790801465511322,
0.5975264310836792,
0.22671876847743988,
-0.9832133650779724,
0.9348680377006531,
-0.6778373122215271,
-0.44828370213508606,
-0.342324435710907,
0.1904314011335373,
-0.5785567760467529,
0.4292168915271759,
0.16304732859134674,
0.5824771523475647,
-0.04673570394515991,
-0.0019280065316706896,
-0.32463473081588745,
-0.5263983607292175,
0.08732890337705612,
-0.2865663766860962,
0.5385562181472778,
0.3336103856563568,
-0.17643187940120697,
0.19599032402038574,
-0.5426620244979858,
-0.05416040122509003,
0.031333860009908676,
-0.4680323600769043,
-0.49320417642593384,
-0.0006274144980125129,
-0.1012476459145546,
-0.12742620706558228,
0.19163329899311066,
-0.2595733106136322,
0.17349444329738617,
-0.21865488588809967,
0.2693270444869995,
0.4931454062461853,
0.14333103597164154,
0.6367203593254089,
-0.7898930311203003,
0.49065154790878296,
-0.3959701657295227,
0.07501872628927231,
-0.21263782680034637,
-0.35989460349082947,
-0.7166866660118103,
-0.08707800507545471,
0.8329885005950928,
0.3566478192806244,
0.006851716432720423,
0.3565918505191803,
-0.4257732927799225,
-0.60776686668396,
-0.38128694891929626,
-0.10909149050712585,
0.1674317717552185,
0.2982781231403351,
0.21995809674263,
-0.38906797766685486,
-0.4741402268409729,
-1.201440453529358,
-0.3034461438655853,
-0.17533110082149506,
-0.2772572636604309,
0.2291853278875351,
0.46212267875671387,
0.31653445959091187,
1.0527994632720947,
-0.558685839176178,
-0.05350326746702194,
-0.7274612784385681,
0.38161128759384155,
-0.03751051425933838,
0.11992130428552628,
0.8851788640022278,
-0.7509519457817078,
-0.23369622230529785,
-0.3026480972766876,
-0.7750347852706909,
-0.1622399538755417,
-0.11775661259889603,
0.04182233288884163,
0.31053826212882996,
0.2811668813228607,
-0.33734986186027527,
0.5395222902297974,
0.48030760884284973,
-0.11497511714696884,
0.40954864025115967,
-0.27932071685791016,
0.5590435862541199,
-0.8681861758232117,
0.21325843036174774,
0.15760768949985504,
-0.515387237071991,
-0.31128770112991333,
-0.022357214242219925,
0.20166373252868652,
0.02431371621787548,
-0.19674010574817657,
0.5039147734642029,
-0.5089632868766785,
-0.3706122636795044,
-0.5056718587875366,
0.42188161611557007,
0.09028774499893188,
0.19029034674167633,
0.1973816305398941,
0.9326403737068176,
-0.31187495589256287,
-0.8425801396369934,
0.05002288147807121,
0.2370469719171524,
-0.41988635063171387,
0.14126324653625488,
-0.8546305298805237,
-0.12852470576763153,
-0.17653395235538483,
0.33592191338539124,
-0.9745975136756897,
-0.5881974697113037,
-0.5578951835632324,
-0.6305501461029053,
0.08278723061084747,
0.1654680222272873,
-0.23192982375621796,
-0.2722174823284149,
-0.6819010376930237,
0.11622735112905502,
0.6945171356201172,
-0.2590687572956085,
0.22197458148002625,
0.41588225960731506,
-0.3095566928386688,
-0.31886887550354004,
-0.6351367831230164,
-0.05282938480377197,
-0.11921104788780212,
-0.27507051825523376,
-0.11125840246677399,
-0.10074692219495773,
-0.525825023651123,
-0.2054404765367508,
-0.1973341852426529,
0.20743216574192047,
0.4375808537006378,
0.37780797481536865,
0.345966637134552,
-0.18967369198799133,
0.24689437448978424,
0.2893681824207306,
-0.2998061180114746,
-0.021060941740870476,
0.20207245647907257,
-0.006364548113197088,
0.08026797324419022,
-0.1549932062625885,
-0.26190707087516785,
0.34873899817466736,
0.6078002452850342,
-0.39099472761154175,
0.5446023344993591,
0.012908073142170906,
-0.12839612364768982,
-0.07649195194244385,
-0.5672393441200256,
-0.284041166305542,
-0.27002373337745667,
0.43864521384239197,
-0.037683431059122086,
-0.5100008845329285,
0.26209551095962524,
0.21262551844120026,
0.4662405550479889,
0.8015437126159668,
0.5141774415969849,
-0.015080822631716728,
1.2866439819335938,
0.5624179840087891,
-0.28512102365493774,
0.4107375144958496,
-0.09840116649866104,
-0.1496971696615219,
-0.6106858849525452,
0.2303355485200882,
-0.47154879570007324,
-0.47645506262779236,
-0.32981857657432556,
0.22022709250450134,
0.5402283072471619,
-0.1494205892086029,
0.060707833617925644,
0.21647630631923676,
-0.6060214042663574,
0.648678183555603,
0.698689341545105,
-0.190748929977417,
0.5361307263374329,
-0.2481735497713089,
0.14259541034698486,
0.06306134164333344,
-0.4813021421432495,
-0.7951960563659668,
1.3015466928482056,
0.04878618195652962,
0.32997435331344604,
0.052799589931964874,
0.5998328328132629,
0.3986648917198181,
0.6862658858299255,
-0.5618978142738342,
0.4777761697769165,
-0.2921338379383087,
-0.628852128982544,
-0.39304980635643005,
-0.19765068590641022,
-0.7967555522918701,
0.3525882661342621,
-0.49642086029052734,
-0.2950115501880646,
-0.10519196838140488,
0.3558165431022644,
-0.9459356069564819,
0.13522715866565704,
-0.9564914703369141,
0.6953199505805969,
0.14536471664905548,
0.1637144833803177,
-0.03681226074695587,
-0.7369437217712402,
0.5449770092964172,
0.06721477955579758,
0.08282353729009628,
-0.2735295593738556,
-0.14110001921653748,
0.9701577425003052,
-0.11564032733440399,
0.5543022155761719,
0.04493057727813721,
0.30956682562828064,
0.06750519573688507,
-0.02032337337732315,
0.05416770651936531,
-0.09917697310447693,
-0.14294452965259552,
-0.1266452521085739,
0.0233848225325346,
-0.1738390177488327,
-0.6709008812904358,
0.21363069117069244,
-0.7072250247001648,
-0.6042073965072632,
-0.4465838074684143,
-0.45826366543769836,
0.004965950269252062,
0.14098761975765228,
0.7231696844100952,
0.5069699287414551,
-0.17115221917629242,
0.2630133032798767,
0.48707714676856995,
0.0555352158844471,
0.5811655521392822,
0.32507243752479553,
-0.4564870297908783,
-0.11033590883016586,
0.7505983114242554,
0.3480824828147888,
0.5491943955421448,
0.2424856424331665,
0.27408936619758606,
-0.06641244143247604,
-0.8292002081871033,
-0.6090927720069885,
0.016527162864804268,
-0.42823535203933716,
-0.2144743949174881,
-0.8277018666267395,
-0.23638716340065002,
-0.19316574931144714,
-0.21728290617465973,
-0.42942628264427185,
-0.7234179973602295,
-0.24688594043254852,
-0.4875621199607849,
0.12238183617591858,
0.7495933175086975,
0.04000498354434967,
0.09103578329086304,
-0.6451408267021179,
0.34214773774147034,
0.4066252112388611,
-0.03757930546998978,
-0.06607652455568314,
-0.5880340933799744,
-0.262381374835968,
-0.14853687584400177,
-0.2629627585411072,
-0.8153876066207886,
0.21775628626346588,
0.07151411473751068,
0.366980642080307,
0.3807917833328247,
0.3017049729824066,
0.346330463886261,
-0.19822163879871368,
0.9293370842933655,
-0.13869604468345642,
-0.6240405440330505,
0.594831645488739,
-0.2151225358247757,
0.3872077167034149,
0.9000667333602905,
0.33596038818359375,
-0.38705769181251526,
-0.5637238025665283,
-0.5994320511817932,
-0.7746535539627075,
0.3528117835521698,
-0.003297459799796343,
0.061839766800403595,
0.013329479843378067,
0.22361622750759125,
0.3891577422618866,
0.380913108587265,
-0.286960244178772,
-0.12109916657209396,
-0.004013624973595142,
-0.16998985409736633,
-0.27489250898361206,
-0.24644623696804047,
0.012284606695175171,
-0.151680126786232,
0.46726658940315247,
-0.08518712967634201,
0.13787788152694702,
0.25217166543006897,
-0.227252796292305,
-0.00482235848903656,
0.17756670713424683,
0.81822669506073,
0.9773327112197876,
-0.38170042634010315,
-0.0001975552731892094,
0.2518439292907715,
-0.4465152621269226,
0.04033420607447624,
0.12191915512084961,
-0.6015482544898987,
0.21642616391181946,
0.7479844093322754,
0.9689822793006897,
0.31441730260849,
-0.6327123045921326,
0.7359160780906677,
-0.17301517724990845,
-0.31798601150512695,
-0.17629308998584747,
0.37670984864234924,
-0.0667363628745079,
0.012461560778319836,
0.3695950210094452,
0.1188322976231575,
0.4998588263988495,
-0.2599499523639679,
0.16772101819515228,
0.25647807121276855,
-0.12250237166881561,
-0.1872786283493042,
0.8800532817840576,
0.2804461717605591,
-0.11263365298509598,
0.3897629678249359,
-0.3426324427127838,
-0.3436698317527771,
0.6632802486419678,
-0.033825140446424484,
0.6990513801574707,
-0.06420375406742096,
0.1844533383846283,
0.6252815127372742,
0.1323164701461792,
-0.4625297784805298,
-0.15720099210739136,
-0.022173164412379265,
-0.30212634801864624,
-0.2033463567495346,
-0.409546822309494,
-0.6226961612701416,
-0.24720995128154755,
-0.8305429220199585,
0.2172958254814148,
-0.2482537031173706,
-0.5840262174606323,
0.27391210198402405,
0.21638061106204987,
-0.2976078987121582,
0.5071510076522827,
0.052716996520757675,
1.0698388814926147,
-1.019431233406067,
0.08670085668563843,
0.5930853486061096,
-0.473007470369339,
-0.7938280701637268,
-0.23467278480529785,
0.17410658299922943,
-0.239127978682518,
0.44358399510383606,
0.21058908104896545,
0.36513733863830566,
-0.25379419326782227,
-0.342843234539032,
-0.5416244864463806,
1.0690302848815918,
0.28494301438331604,
-0.5259615778923035,
-0.2804126441478729,
-0.6483948230743408,
0.4180198609828949,
-0.5105447173118591,
0.711304247379303,
0.7425618767738342,
0.301567405462265,
-0.1177888959646225,
-1.147408366203308,
-0.2288518100976944,
-0.1582850217819214,
-0.06456737220287323,
0.24100585281848907,
-0.7327362298965454,
1.0066200494766235,
-0.6283857822418213,
-0.010591688565909863,
0.07374532520771027,
0.8320733904838562,
0.17793695628643036,
0.5586354732513428,
0.683423638343811,
0.17865274846553802,
0.5117477178573608,
-0.021905118599534035,
1.502471923828125,
-0.08468681573867798,
0.16329459846019745,
1.3313498497009277,
0.08236157149076462,
1.054635763168335,
0.0978059321641922,
-0.30264273285865784,
-0.010349848307669163,
1.019788146018982,
0.000024664954253239557,
0.3535008728504181,
0.09441842883825302,
0.22780753672122955,
-0.35136857628822327,
0.017744118347764015,
-0.45596176385879517,
0.46404504776000977,
-0.4474150240421295,
-0.5977566242218018,
-0.1823820173740387,
-0.10994156450033188,
0.10053470730781555,
0.06330551207065582,
-0.16022372245788574,
0.9127199649810791,
0.012705148197710514,
-0.9832897782325745,
0.16949337720870972,
-0.032165590673685074,
0.4252937138080597,
-0.4854978322982788,
0.1583484262228012,
-0.4710659384727478,
-0.14491134881973267,
-0.1751071959733963,
-0.3631007969379425,
0.12060534209012985,
0.07710985094308853,
-0.29424405097961426,
0.21766026318073273,
0.48214414715766907,
-0.24503932893276215,
-0.4740237295627594,
-0.17352965474128723,
0.47084420919418335,
0.2392667680978775,
-0.10381949692964554,
0.06951285898685455,
-0.024968784302473068,
-0.06667498499155045,
-0.7213248610496521,
0.47175654768943787,
-0.04713049530982971,
-0.36216336488723755,
0.5942655801773071,
0.5602760314941406,
0.3345854878425598,
0.01681782864034176,
-0.003982369787991047,
0.540861189365387,
-0.4572935402393341,
-0.7418293356895447,
-0.9049789905548096,
0.4596523940563202,
-0.5414396524429321,
-0.5712904334068298,
0.9146757125854492,
0.7893683910369873,
0.5127626061439514,
0.04087890684604645,
1.0038336515426636,
0.25402793288230896,
0.7981007695198059,
-0.3973246216773987,
0.8334711194038391,
-0.5794035792350769,
-0.014218496158719063,
-0.16797766089439392,
-0.9607706665992737,
-0.24880066514015198,
0.6134157776832581,
-0.467101126909256,
0.27328288555145264,
0.5788305997848511,
0.1903395801782608,
0.04745080694556236,
0.2515970468521118,
0.1277071088552475,
-0.3302869200706482,
0.07149689644575119,
0.48514410853385925,
0.5169535279273987,
-0.14882150292396545,
0.11862371116876602,
-0.18382643163204193,
-0.5319922566413879,
-0.48958611488342285,
-0.9801587462425232,
-1.0978748798370361,
-0.5583491921424866,
-0.4220062494277954,
0.017725128680467606,
0.027064867317676544,
1.1737933158874512,
0.8891923427581787,
-0.6349227428436279,
-0.040307726711034775,
0.43655645847320557,
0.06107637658715248,
-0.24677209556102753,
-0.13749761879444122,
0.33060288429260254,
-0.34405675530433655,
-0.8304821252822876,
-0.15335911512374878,
0.156410813331604,
0.38303524255752563,
-0.14702783524990082,
0.2382933646440506,
0.2391563206911087,
0.37372103333473206,
0.5084603428840637,
0.09828388690948486,
-0.43152040243148804,
-0.3103436827659607,
-0.1445893943309784,
-0.15296728909015656,
-0.1087275967001915,
0.8063898682594299,
-0.5932825803756714,
0.34442782402038574,
0.5589444637298584,
0.6330064535140991,
0.38039636611938477,
0.4824690818786621,
0.7833985686302185,
-0.41566839814186096,
0.0052792988717556,
-0.06609358638525009,
0.08650622516870499,
0.24735963344573975,
-0.13238076865673065,
0.662323534488678,
0.00261703017167747,
-0.6357226967811584,
-0.9560036063194275,
-0.13445903360843658,
-0.7350273132324219,
-0.2439354807138443,
1.0726253986358643,
0.054648131132125854,
-0.18685834109783173,
0.23204222321510315,
-0.30870458483695984,
0.15662658214569092,
-0.47919803857803345,
0.7570597529411316,
0.7386067509651184,
-0.2659420669078827,
-0.046095240861177444,
-0.8577381372451782,
0.6946215629577637,
0.14621728658676147,
-0.7805865406990051,
0.12129465490579605,
0.4739406108856201,
0.21059896051883698,
0.2170279175043106,
0.6513832211494446,
0.2393852025270462,
0.46553680300712585,
0.03421950340270996,
-0.04675495997071266,
-0.4178832769393921,
-0.3580622673034668,
-0.23918965458869934,
0.3508240282535553,
0.14851881563663483,
-0.24707643687725067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18747v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18747v2
|
Fine-Tuned Machine Translation Metrics Struggle in Unseen Domains
| 2024-02-28T23:01:24 | 2024-06-04T04:14:16 |
Vilém Zouhar, Shuoyang Ding, Anna Currey, Tatyana Badeka, Jenyuan Wang, Brian Thompson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce a new, extensive multidimensional quality metrics (MQM)
annotated dataset covering 11 language pairs in the biomedical domain. We use
this dataset to investigate whether machine translation (MT) metrics which are
fine-tuned on human-generated MT quality judgements are robust to domain shifts
between training and inference. We find that fine-tuned metrics exhibit a
substantial performance drop in the unseen domain scenario relative to metrics
that rely on the surface form, as well as pre-trained metrics which are not
fine-tuned on MT quality judgments.
|
[
-0.35133495926856995,
-0.5228753089904785,
0.4057347774505615,
-0.054892148822546005,
-0.29464900493621826,
0.4902898669242859,
-0.07751834392547607,
-0.48904940485954285,
-0.07656433433294296,
0.6421843767166138,
-0.6400067210197449,
-0.6536713242530823,
-0.9588799476623535,
0.30249539017677307,
-0.09145653992891312,
1.0169825553894043,
-0.1165332943201065,
0.22368153929710388,
-0.35535627603530884,
-0.6573690176010132,
-0.3723382353782654,
-0.6263739466667175,
-0.35035440325737,
-0.3867853581905365,
0.5080723166465759,
0.356342613697052,
1.1203960180282593,
0.7444922924041748,
0.9409056901931763,
0.18881018459796906,
0.07693981379270554,
0.9631571173667908,
-0.33042043447494507,
0.00046401043073274195,
-0.2376752644777298,
-0.5801812410354614,
-0.6423268914222717,
0.1278020143508911,
0.8194875121116638,
1.126707911491394,
0.27175527811050415,
0.3109976053237915,
0.20432870090007782,
0.9318697452545166,
-0.4398531913757324,
-0.022487355396151543,
-0.48000502586364746,
0.1781846582889557,
-0.4761112630367279,
-0.38534069061279297,
-0.24017854034900665,
-0.12222807109355927,
-0.06153735890984535,
-0.6916662454605103,
0.3976779580116272,
0.3090578019618988,
0.9921979904174805,
0.6885597705841064,
-0.6445364952087402,
0.2652142345905304,
-0.5904977321624756,
0.8169121146202087,
-0.5186805725097656,
0.655721127986908,
0.522096574306488,
0.3322727680206299,
-0.396742582321167,
-0.6090570688247681,
-0.23328058421611786,
0.08976183831691742,
-0.06789811700582504,
0.18288284540176392,
-0.23762986063957214,
-0.11953791975975037,
0.13456737995147705,
0.3030332028865814,
-0.5210440158843994,
0.2808276414871216,
-0.4088976979255676,
-0.3224756419658661,
0.4627422094345093,
0.5672597885131836,
0.10839395970106125,
-0.046272389590740204,
-0.18224072456359863,
-0.15460170805454254,
-1.0205988883972168,
0.12634670734405518,
0.1701841652393341,
0.3456264138221741,
-0.08249303698539734,
0.7843015789985657,
-0.2269153892993927,
0.6707303524017334,
-0.24728725850582123,
-0.15786559879779816,
0.40323004126548767,
-0.429639607667923,
-0.22007521986961365,
-0.48620471358299255,
0.8511713147163391,
0.611638069152832,
0.05259651318192482,
-0.3384290635585785,
-0.2273271679878235,
-0.059966471046209335,
0.3459363877773285,
-0.7231881618499756,
-0.4255197048187256,
0.18289247155189514,
-0.640067994594574,
-0.005556871648877859,
-0.08537567406892776,
-0.14792852103710175,
-0.09596695750951767,
-0.397501677274704,
0.34952378273010254,
-0.5631071329116821,
0.10634282231330872,
0.17913229763507843,
-0.10337038338184357,
-0.02202686481177807,
0.26848500967025757,
-0.4900474548339844,
0.2402300387620926,
0.5873558521270752,
0.9968260526657104,
-0.5787522196769714,
-0.38359972834587097,
-0.5337796807289124,
-0.0714697316288948,
-0.5009568333625793,
0.7133141160011292,
-0.42736342549324036,
-0.3602621853351593,
-0.16697673499584198,
0.33103176951408386,
-0.32447555661201477,
-0.8217642903327942,
0.779305100440979,
-0.2926633656024933,
-0.03200211375951767,
-0.00468463497236371,
-0.5554174780845642,
-0.10675947368144989,
0.044731996953487396,
-0.3614043891429901,
0.653386116027832,
0.2751290202140808,
-0.4893260598182678,
0.6461468935012817,
-0.49689558148384094,
-0.599685788154602,
-0.04789641499519348,
0.05934897065162659,
-0.6510933637619019,
0.40942081809043884,
0.09064098447561264,
0.5882927775382996,
-0.18134158849716187,
0.011803524568676949,
-0.4453456699848175,
-0.1519763022661209,
0.6145747900009155,
-0.21885384619235992,
0.35074013471603394,
0.43998920917510986,
0.0395241305232048,
-0.17283320426940918,
-0.9508602619171143,
0.39756348729133606,
-0.25020158290863037,
-0.32012277841567993,
-0.3790019750595093,
0.0018752265023067594,
0.0446675643324852,
0.39401185512542725,
0.025724288076162338,
-0.4342844486236572,
0.17396269738674164,
-0.3637453019618988,
0.6130473613739014,
0.37560147047042847,
-0.05654362589120865,
0.26530590653419495,
-0.2234373837709427,
0.4232498109340668,
0.23997806012630463,
0.10732757300138474,
0.3774140775203705,
-0.6152089834213257,
-0.5224949717521667,
-0.45408666133880615,
0.5457301139831543,
0.3416843116283417,
-0.7703087329864502,
0.39654749631881714,
-0.42043447494506836,
-0.47415709495544434,
-1.2031397819519043,
0.035807669162750244,
0.6967929005622864,
0.35985612869262695,
0.6446290016174316,
-0.4311482012271881,
0.10212213546037674,
-1.1013745069503784,
-0.5228222608566284,
0.2832410931587219,
-0.10571456700563431,
0.3464316129684448,
0.40100395679473877,
-0.5351092219352722,
0.42895132303237915,
-0.5171987414360046,
-0.47963374853134155,
0.28930097818374634,
0.17063279449939728,
0.13278652727603912,
0.7536460757255554,
0.5837881565093994,
-0.5195398330688477,
-0.28100812435150146,
0.0994686558842659,
-0.5987805128097534,
-0.20294694602489471,
0.05029863119125366,
-0.45762795209884644,
-0.03574718162417412,
0.45816728472709656,
-0.624057948589325,
0.18466274440288544,
0.8474666476249695,
-0.4069285988807678,
0.5376170873641968,
-0.33778271079063416,
0.45762312412261963,
-1.0784233808517456,
0.24815461039543152,
-0.08911771327257156,
-0.32377466559410095,
-0.4202095866203308,
-0.02401353418827057,
0.2915060818195343,
0.17574191093444824,
-0.47162526845932007,
0.5381945371627808,
-0.38478803634643555,
-0.07685842365026474,
-0.22371463477611542,
0.03560882434248924,
0.3595423996448517,
0.2986815571784973,
-0.17079666256904602,
0.9121999740600586,
0.3491992652416229,
-0.8857227563858032,
-0.17163415253162384,
0.7205674052238464,
-0.37799757719039917,
0.9771080017089844,
-0.5768247842788696,
0.06854243576526642,
0.296935498714447,
-0.017809215933084488,
-0.7099918723106384,
-0.2345253825187683,
0.11609157919883728,
-0.8282594084739685,
0.5436045527458191,
-0.15523898601531982,
-0.7161695957183838,
-0.2728872299194336,
0.0097101591527462,
0.4133622646331787,
0.22862225770950317,
-0.3420555591583252,
-0.16568873822689056,
0.37899157404899597,
0.08181273192167282,
-0.4569271206855774,
-0.7827445268630981,
0.1952543407678604,
-0.17696145176887512,
-0.36340346932411194,
0.3112466633319855,
-0.018567249178886414,
0.08860233426094055,
-0.14499501883983612,
-0.23973672091960907,
-0.15002207458019257,
0.3668050765991211,
0.4326342046260834,
-0.06945841759443283,
-0.42460012435913086,
-0.041125860065221786,
0.7041955590248108,
-0.220462366938591,
0.16245286166667938,
-0.4428274929523468,
0.06756003201007843,
0.08075080066919327,
-0.41228577494621277,
-0.45879048109054565,
0.18282058835029602,
0.7209731936454773,
-0.3775656521320343,
0.9435993432998657,
0.6802608370780945,
-0.4329865872859955,
0.007015663664788008,
-0.046570561826229095,
-0.08912235498428345,
-0.3931986093521118,
0.49496036767959595,
-0.7929003834724426,
-1.012142300605774,
0.5447891354560852,
-0.3059353828430176,
-0.05034913122653961,
0.8650196194648743,
0.43099015951156616,
-0.2482956349849701,
1.523041009902954,
0.5356074571609497,
0.2975885272026062,
-0.08276496082544327,
-0.2025110423564911,
0.13238930702209473,
-1.214077115058899,
-0.1895560473203659,
-0.6937459707260132,
-0.5211541652679443,
-0.8062564730644226,
-0.411073237657547,
0.39977312088012695,
0.34227120876312256,
-0.16191431879997253,
0.29530805349349976,
-0.37128400802612305,
0.2516331076622009,
0.6379172205924988,
0.17739693820476532,
0.43067166209220886,
0.01686442270874977,
-0.264011025428772,
-0.35928186774253845,
-0.7026452422142029,
-0.6883556842803955,
1.0568997859954834,
0.26563718914985657,
0.43523985147476196,
0.17572444677352905,
0.24556931853294373,
0.32716676592826843,
0.12615755200386047,
-0.5713474154472351,
0.04308347404003143,
-0.5282040238380432,
-0.48704952001571655,
-0.14667809009552002,
-0.7974889278411865,
-1.2272655963897705,
0.29127994179725647,
-0.45187368988990784,
-0.21370020508766174,
0.10652363300323486,
0.13019463419914246,
-0.4707707166671753,
0.3218214511871338,
-0.3679203391075134,
0.9301509857177734,
-0.3134959042072296,
-0.18744181096553802,
-0.22256359457969666,
-0.9263132214546204,
0.04250463470816612,
-0.3454233705997467,
0.06965810805559158,
-0.5938048362731934,
-0.060177285224199295,
0.5943740010261536,
-0.34262874722480774,
0.5474215149879456,
0.04877796396613121,
0.03365239128470421,
-0.17270201444625854,
0.38119015097618103,
0.027461370453238487,
0.21241582930088043,
0.06530623137950897,
0.6246098279953003,
0.18579226732254028,
-0.7333322763442993,
-0.2704024016857147,
0.5871025323867798,
-1.0171095132827759,
-0.07497507333755493,
-0.047342609614133835,
-0.45937594771385193,
-0.5973539352416992,
0.4593057930469513,
0.6858769059181213,
0.38505223393440247,
-0.2111503630876541,
0.20167085528373718,
0.4066883623600006,
-0.44174548983573914,
-0.2912054657936096,
0.687518298625946,
0.3104606568813324,
-0.5389968156814575,
0.8851180672645569,
0.11008541285991669,
0.41386136412620544,
0.46846556663513184,
0.019503707066178322,
-0.44336947798728943,
-0.9956560730934143,
-0.8033418655395508,
0.2183326631784439,
-0.4743240773677826,
-0.6875137090682983,
-0.7246432304382324,
-0.17842097580432892,
-0.24011735618114471,
0.0831739604473114,
-0.5582826137542725,
-0.6532225608825684,
-0.1599094569683075,
0.05070769414305687,
0.3440277874469757,
0.6483532786369324,
-0.0567801408469677,
0.4184728264808655,
-1.2680623531341553,
0.37057924270629883,
-0.3631327152252197,
0.47358664870262146,
-0.7041361331939697,
-1.0330867767333984,
-0.6899456977844238,
0.3954891860485077,
-0.36439406871795654,
-0.10738810896873474,
0.5475713610649109,
0.5432197451591492,
0.5011053085327148,
0.30939245223999023,
0.07130607962608337,
0.6418917775154114,
-0.6392655968666077,
0.7393594980239868,
0.06549500674009323,
-0.5984894633293152,
0.4061093330383301,
-0.29927587509155273,
0.26374223828315735,
0.6620135307312012,
0.30527985095977783,
-0.33441245555877686,
-0.8021405935287476,
-0.4489228427410126,
-0.668844997882843,
0.39235731959342957,
0.1947241872549057,
0.1356564313173294,
-0.005928883794695139,
0.5186176300048828,
0.546965479850769,
0.48921504616737366,
0.031280457973480225,
-0.6156464219093323,
0.0813128799200058,
0.044505853205919266,
-0.5933462977409363,
0.2188798040151596,
-0.11793763935565948,
-0.47685670852661133,
0.35161420702934265,
-0.3162841200828552,
0.20101521909236908,
0.04651534557342529,
-0.1672169715166092,
-0.28745728731155396,
-0.12862825393676758,
0.7245622277259827,
0.5415278673171997,
-0.11150694638490677,
0.156431645154953,
-0.06571421772241592,
-0.46243804693222046,
0.022974373772740364,
-0.030131492763757706,
-0.02854848839342594,
0.12971386313438416,
0.28641968965530396,
0.7377688884735107,
0.01538939867168665,
-0.3757775127887726,
0.2936258018016815,
-0.05741029977798462,
-0.46119192242622375,
0.23095771670341492,
-0.026516711339354515,
-0.24613478779792786,
0.18273566663265228,
0.007340806070715189,
0.7135238647460938,
0.25578567385673523,
-0.025538722053170204,
0.3073275089263916,
0.38604801893234253,
-0.6977155208587646,
-0.5080368518829346,
1.0413002967834473,
0.12545335292816162,
-0.14573657512664795,
0.7050333023071289,
-0.06461597234010696,
-0.27116891741752625,
0.2152015119791031,
0.24605782330036163,
0.6554743051528931,
0.04686788469552994,
0.06066817790269852,
0.15425914525985718,
0.3602069020271301,
-0.015348419547080994,
-0.05194992199540138,
0.34164926409721375,
-0.6262990236282349,
-0.5479466915130615,
-0.5143696665763855,
-0.6082350611686707,
0.057202860713005066,
-0.7276999950408936,
-0.03392459452152252,
-0.09302438795566559,
-0.5832690596580505,
0.0492362417280674,
0.09618574380874634,
-0.9984264969825745,
0.3545165956020355,
-0.15054377913475037,
0.5847219824790955,
-0.7151082158088684,
0.9140820503234863,
0.8229180574417114,
-0.23142041265964508,
-0.30053460597991943,
-0.28723594546318054,
-0.16042055189609528,
-0.7919623255729675,
0.3993118107318878,
-0.045035336166620255,
-0.3783951699733734,
0.02448328770697117,
-0.5264618992805481,
-0.7662996649742126,
0.828567385673523,
0.5155664086341858,
-0.22896142303943634,
0.48851996660232544,
0.5184094905853271,
0.768499493598938,
-0.17451784014701843,
-0.26750996708869934,
0.7023679614067078,
0.3133170008659363,
-0.6643164753913879,
-1.1442298889160156,
-0.15255749225616455,
-0.2739681005477905,
-0.3244931995868683,
0.4564913809299469,
-0.9464225769042969,
0.6733916401863098,
-0.22594504058361053,
-0.13451626896858215,
0.31535038352012634,
0.4009306728839874,
-0.08515043556690216,
0.4528205692768097,
-0.09419076144695282,
0.5945205688476562,
0.8300710916519165,
-0.26065388321876526,
0.9421687126159668,
-0.4820614159107208,
0.23431946337223053,
0.864482581615448,
-0.006081589963287115,
0.8816152215003967,
0.4492555558681488,
-0.2148691862821579,
-0.06303451210260391,
0.871283233165741,
0.013150247745215893,
0.4782179296016693,
0.23842188715934753,
0.1341368556022644,
-0.42104288935661316,
-0.05043534189462662,
-0.5110310912132263,
0.44798046350479126,
0.5852381587028503,
-0.32864058017730713,
0.24875794351100922,
-0.013573291711509228,
-0.16643241047859192,
0.15446722507476807,
-0.12301005423069,
0.6181321740150452,
0.42610758543014526,
-0.39453253149986267,
0.8609673380851746,
0.17280182242393494,
0.4695880115032196,
-0.19075030088424683,
0.0911509171128273,
-0.5031481981277466,
0.3244864344596863,
-0.2985055446624756,
-0.8529384732246399,
0.3694869875907898,
-0.32747381925582886,
-0.2494526505470276,
-0.18721026182174683,
0.31504154205322266,
-0.25322914123535156,
-0.2751712203025818,
0.1807946115732193,
1.2401089668273926,
0.4584506154060364,
-0.2866732180118561,
-0.734255850315094,
-0.2690271735191345,
-0.1788388043642044,
-0.11625395715236664,
0.5672094821929932,
1.124143362045288,
-0.07357269525527954,
0.7472324967384338,
0.6392241716384888,
0.22047340869903564,
0.06818397343158722,
-0.028869474306702614,
0.5819608569145203,
-0.684968888759613,
-0.06011774390935898,
-0.6302857398986816,
0.0837671160697937,
0.11589089035987854,
-0.6914495229721069,
0.7882927060127258,
0.7206379771232605,
0.9226630330085754,
-0.18926526606082916,
0.5713274478912354,
0.585536003112793,
0.8011406660079956,
-0.5463162660598755,
0.9963033199310303,
-0.8882236480712891,
-0.050551723688840866,
-0.15487171709537506,
-0.9565812349319458,
-0.6831797361373901,
0.37816953659057617,
0.2787027955055237,
-0.3097939193248749,
0.6728963851928711,
0.5326752662658691,
-0.18469807505607605,
-0.5838376879692078,
0.7219923734664917,
0.06104486808180809,
0.1544438600540161,
0.39276352524757385,
0.7048520445823669,
-0.6770159602165222,
0.29132354259490967,
-0.01080922782421112,
0.16597002744674683,
-0.29870539903640747,
-0.6186124682426453,
-0.7856621742248535,
-0.506814181804657,
-0.5083236694335938,
-0.4379943907260895,
0.1146727129817009,
0.7019607424736023,
0.8201270699501038,
-0.926799476146698,
0.12027870863676071,
0.34980058670043945,
-0.1484793871641159,
-0.38339683413505554,
-0.11105883866548538,
0.40862494707107544,
-0.3973410427570343,
-0.6397739052772522,
0.3954384922981262,
0.25440582633018494,
0.1719711720943451,
0.03102901205420494,
-0.19600611925125122,
0.36157169938087463,
-0.17355510592460632,
0.7689008116722107,
0.11999530345201492,
-0.5272862315177917,
-0.43906763195991516,
0.28920766711235046,
-0.5063387155532837,
0.238972470164299,
0.6249797344207764,
-0.3219456076622009,
0.3055060803890228,
0.13307558000087738,
0.8859163522720337,
0.06833761930465698,
0.11960334330797195,
0.7878121733665466,
-0.8601689338684082,
-0.15526247024536133,
0.06539756804704666,
0.3038756847381592,
0.4772525429725647,
-0.0974050983786583,
0.6781952381134033,
0.2629946172237396,
-0.7138960361480713,
-0.7953314185142517,
-0.03482305258512497,
-0.8130039572715759,
-0.14592695236206055,
1.0159658193588257,
-0.12643390893936157,
-0.042359549552202225,
-0.3543183207511902,
-0.03821057826280594,
0.2603338956832886,
-0.14806926250457764,
0.7372244000434875,
0.5999849438667297,
-0.361100435256958,
0.21037693321704865,
-0.9191759824752808,
0.7799376249313354,
0.6687934398651123,
-0.5387659072875977,
-0.09130150079727173,
0.4897638261318207,
0.071701280772686,
0.1264631599187851,
0.24076490104198456,
-0.23353202641010284,
0.1635999232530594,
-0.2630996108055115,
-0.048839930444955826,
0.06645090132951736,
-0.3335040211677551,
-0.16842399537563324,
-0.2757299542427063,
0.4092867374420166,
-0.5238747000694275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18734v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18734v1
|
Priority Sampling of Large Language Models for Compilers
| 2024-02-28T22:27:49 | 2024-02-28T22:27:49 |
Dejan Grubisic, Chris Cummins, Volker Seeker, Hugh Leather
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.PF
|
Large language models show great potential in generating and optimizing code.
Widely used sampling methods such as Nucleus Sampling increase the diversity of
generation but often produce repeated samples for low temperatures and
incoherent samples for high temperatures. Furthermore, the temperature
coefficient has to be tuned for each task, limiting its usability. We present
Priority Sampling, a simple and deterministic sampling technique that produces
unique samples ordered by the model's confidence. Each new sample expands the
unexpanded token with the highest probability in the augmented search tree.
Additionally, Priority Sampling supports generation based on regular expression
that provides a controllable and structured exploration process. Priority
Sampling outperforms Nucleus Sampling for any number of samples, boosting the
performance of the original model from 2.87% to 5% improvement over -Oz.
Moreover, it outperforms the autotuner used for the generation of labels for
the training of the original model in just 30 samples.
|
[
-0.39219796657562256,
-0.3711135685443878,
0.4893321096897125,
0.06489909440279007,
-0.10412860661745071,
0.13045045733451843,
-0.37310609221458435,
-0.2825635075569153,
-0.02035963349044323,
0.6287400722503662,
-0.2850953936576843,
-0.5452883839607239,
-0.5064795017242432,
-0.11313804984092712,
-0.41201066970825195,
0.6407268643379211,
0.27774086594581604,
-0.2007327526807785,
-0.002592281671240926,
0.17860321700572968,
-0.19279471039772034,
-0.8802335262298584,
-0.7354416251182556,
-0.10173641890287399,
0.3729364573955536,
0.693084180355072,
0.5786508917808533,
0.6205421686172485,
0.3283061981201172,
0.29375889897346497,
-0.20159126818180084,
-0.291950523853302,
-0.6368811130523682,
0.4830269515514374,
0.039745379239320755,
-0.4084189236164093,
-0.36366569995880127,
0.09642349183559418,
0.7450350522994995,
0.7166020274162292,
-0.2699136435985565,
0.31760984659194946,
-0.0800246149301529,
0.6745724081993103,
-0.8841818571090698,
0.04309776425361633,
-0.6459296345710754,
0.06841059029102325,
-0.532379150390625,
-0.38457155227661133,
-0.6560208201408386,
-0.34935733675956726,
-0.2523930072784424,
-0.14867277443408966,
0.45244500041007996,
-0.014364898204803467,
0.4176744818687439,
0.36327576637268066,
-0.24121229350566864,
0.06785006821155548,
-0.9283264875411987,
1.104130506515503,
-0.518474280834198,
0.19056802988052368,
0.36162620782852173,
0.25210922956466675,
-0.16603456437587738,
-0.6462303400039673,
-0.3211098313331604,
-0.3559834659099579,
0.4156973659992218,
-0.08552468568086624,
0.02817516215145588,
-0.04161178320646286,
0.527456521987915,
0.3372021019458771,
-0.6044769287109375,
0.1704758256673813,
-0.1524008959531784,
-0.12482741475105286,
0.678406834602356,
-0.027529148384928703,
0.2792304754257202,
-0.21759556233882904,
-0.10410595685243607,
-0.636539101600647,
-0.6807774901390076,
0.291841596364975,
0.6445545554161072,
0.317076176404953,
0.3939805328845978,
0.5757455825805664,
-0.4996930956840515,
1.2309646606445312,
-0.055466145277023315,
0.18341222405433655,
0.24960744380950928,
-0.3282443881034851,
-0.19251616299152374,
0.04386043921113014,
0.48050612211227417,
0.13720066845417023,
0.24194125831127167,
0.09668310731649399,
-0.12822264432907104,
-0.06868085265159607,
0.2679334878921509,
-0.7386367321014404,
-0.4810709059238434,
0.4961732029914856,
-0.2915422320365906,
-0.37862592935562134,
0.14537249505519867,
-0.8396602869033813,
0.09045042842626572,
-0.2681047320365906,
-0.34021759033203125,
-0.0595635287463665,
-0.3088405728340149,
0.22457736730575562,
-0.08030208200216293,
-0.09334609657526016,
0.11113367229700089,
-0.9521755576133728,
0.16374003887176514,
0.527488648891449,
0.3220727741718292,
-0.3566780686378479,
-0.15002818405628204,
-0.8089144229888916,
0.05399854853749275,
-0.5303319692611694,
0.9797478914260864,
-0.9149244427680969,
-0.3098399341106415,
-0.35301679372787476,
-0.33970320224761963,
0.14946259558200836,
-0.5083534121513367,
0.3165789842605591,
-0.7149286866188049,
-0.20439103245735168,
-0.1496444195508957,
-0.29583561420440674,
0.1758597493171692,
-0.1371200978755951,
-0.8916841149330139,
1.3241052627563477,
0.3696174919605255,
-0.5126879215240479,
0.5190128087997437,
-0.3552088141441345,
-0.22054454684257507,
0.190495565533638,
-0.05908733606338501,
-0.32920005917549133,
0.16425015032291412,
0.11989597976207733,
0.2603779435157776,
-0.3658965528011322,
0.30338358879089355,
-0.23452098667621613,
-0.1623494178056717,
0.23978117108345032,
-0.2797691226005554,
0.7642374038696289,
0.5981510877609253,
-0.2973950505256653,
0.27214595675468445,
-0.668439507484436,
0.6861338019371033,
-0.13569387793540955,
-0.6007135510444641,
-0.4123152792453766,
-0.02088822051882744,
0.2272188365459442,
0.45601657032966614,
0.2747442424297333,
-0.4862208962440491,
0.511712372303009,
-0.3203141987323761,
0.3175409138202667,
0.6500641703605652,
-0.07643555849790573,
0.5645859837532043,
-0.24901604652404785,
0.7973330616950989,
-0.14399290084838867,
0.13300581276416779,
0.2832832932472229,
-0.5929868221282959,
-0.6296813488006592,
-0.21233563125133514,
0.7196586728096008,
0.5027369856834412,
-0.614103376865387,
0.7724320888519287,
-0.18826723098754883,
-0.6262063384056091,
-0.3599555790424347,
0.12005424499511719,
0.4107954800128937,
0.005207523237913847,
0.20604249835014343,
-0.3919786810874939,
-0.4637840986251831,
-0.7599993944168091,
0.090762197971344,
0.014250111766159534,
-0.12319657951593399,
0.21909089386463165,
0.06425781548023224,
0.16273659467697144,
1.049921989440918,
-0.634076714515686,
0.5081108808517456,
-0.5926050543785095,
0.32992786169052124,
0.3824792504310608,
0.7028942108154297,
0.6335991024971008,
-1.0663658380508423,
-0.47265002131462097,
-0.3768264651298523,
-0.31470954418182373,
-0.37330007553100586,
0.13132108747959137,
-0.42480599880218506,
0.312751829624176,
0.6279959678649902,
-0.38037997484207153,
0.16738198697566986,
0.7859722375869751,
-0.11161180585622787,
0.29152265191078186,
0.05946695804595947,
0.18901215493679047,
-1.1138676404953003,
0.28486523032188416,
-0.3028397560119629,
-0.18059279024600983,
-0.4951847493648529,
0.5601370334625244,
-0.10316196084022522,
-0.28514766693115234,
-0.5131382346153259,
0.6109285950660706,
-0.48783013224601746,
-0.2195168435573578,
-0.34311047196388245,
-0.3506298065185547,
-0.21396078169345856,
0.07435322552919388,
0.10559473186731339,
0.7135944366455078,
0.5917190313339233,
-0.6980627179145813,
0.2431545853614807,
-0.1685890555381775,
-0.5806089043617249,
-0.09670151025056839,
-0.4175129532814026,
0.2692432105541229,
-0.018548667430877686,
0.3193438649177551,
-1.0135663747787476,
-0.11075369268655777,
-0.06359673291444778,
-0.337372362613678,
0.42926663160324097,
-0.3262776732444763,
-0.5751281976699829,
-0.6265196800231934,
-0.08348143845796585,
0.5338122248649597,
0.6302912831306458,
-0.3173614740371704,
0.3461576998233795,
0.6042258739471436,
-0.4928777515888214,
-0.7487214803695679,
-0.30016785860061646,
-0.09147254377603531,
0.07471659779548645,
-0.20069143176078796,
0.14218831062316895,
-0.44412821531295776,
-0.2788965702056885,
0.0707872062921524,
-0.09072656184434891,
-0.04041515663266182,
0.29676419496536255,
0.2083064466714859,
0.035521697252988815,
0.09234841912984848,
-0.06731249392032623,
-0.1867457926273346,
-0.3804382085800171,
-0.2988743782043457,
-0.510342538356781,
1.2478759288787842,
0.3014381229877472,
-0.35939741134643555,
0.03258383646607399,
0.6024368405342102,
0.5018095970153809,
-0.2066332995891571,
0.22319930791854858,
0.15476857125759125,
-0.25159284472465515,
-0.3079654276371002,
-0.5981668829917908,
-0.27023845911026,
-0.4310956597328186,
0.19705206155776978,
-0.42440640926361084,
-0.8768469095230103,
0.37363961338996887,
0.2720910906791687,
0.21123719215393066,
0.5481500625610352,
0.7494382858276367,
0.31455156207084656,
1.2542322874069214,
0.7084246277809143,
-0.3959699869155884,
0.5289849042892456,
-0.10099322348833084,
0.18711715936660767,
-0.5650582313537598,
0.2916059195995331,
-0.8292211294174194,
-0.33108726143836975,
-0.6273934841156006,
-0.6016417741775513,
0.22707541286945343,
0.07698110491037369,
0.028354661539196968,
0.38454970717430115,
-0.8283979892730713,
0.603992760181427,
1.2232940196990967,
-0.12022662162780762,
0.24166619777679443,
0.27002084255218506,
-0.23286116123199463,
0.11391038447618484,
-0.9455991387367249,
-0.2835741341114044,
1.2005414962768555,
-0.18167904019355774,
0.6340675354003906,
-0.10288143903017044,
1.040050983428955,
0.015258884988725185,
0.453395813703537,
-0.550328254699707,
0.7055857181549072,
-0.28149381279945374,
-0.7963606119155884,
-0.4948127269744873,
-0.6035659909248352,
-0.9416868686676025,
-0.03813870996236801,
0.08764105290174484,
-0.5931216478347778,
0.32560932636260986,
0.21907739341259003,
-0.6368175148963928,
0.2282390296459198,
-0.6350541710853577,
0.6350762248039246,
0.050684601068496704,
-0.25334402918815613,
-0.24245214462280273,
-0.3559422492980957,
0.3045828938484192,
-0.14872007071971893,
-0.09181676805019379,
-0.11756347119808197,
0.5032830834388733,
0.6011078953742981,
-0.2625959515571594,
0.5989165306091309,
-0.09187157452106476,
-0.0019320284482091665,
0.5476117134094238,
0.11083337664604187,
0.3223935663700104,
0.07728559523820877,
-0.4873799979686737,
0.046064212918281555,
-0.15519389510154724,
-0.48018404841423035,
-0.20437365770339966,
0.7040045261383057,
-0.5612227916717529,
-0.6193288564682007,
-0.6441975831985474,
-0.6869692206382751,
-0.03858998790383339,
0.15436305105686188,
0.5293965935707092,
0.35901081562042236,
0.08652191609144211,
0.30308863520622253,
0.30007702112197876,
-0.40468525886535645,
0.45755821466445923,
0.48428142070770264,
-0.11284143477678299,
-0.0846034586429596,
0.8561888933181763,
0.2074611485004425,
0.3859603703022003,
0.3565059006214142,
0.11156243830919266,
-0.00963394995778799,
-0.6524232625961304,
-0.2796543836593628,
-0.1635151356458664,
-0.5391565561294556,
-0.26611605286598206,
-0.7686840295791626,
-0.4232773184776306,
-0.5990419983863831,
-0.2333616018295288,
-0.459061861038208,
-0.6517066359519958,
0.0770745575428009,
-0.06256991624832153,
0.38119393587112427,
0.48096057772636414,
-0.24644887447357178,
0.15197592973709106,
-0.8157957196235657,
0.43144235014915466,
0.5175657868385315,
0.17588625848293304,
-0.15981748700141907,
-0.13537395000457764,
0.010534469969570637,
-0.18047697842121124,
-0.13388003408908844,
-0.4517011344432831,
0.602500319480896,
-0.12989120185375214,
0.6967018246650696,
0.110471211373806,
0.25759950280189514,
0.4183063209056854,
-0.5083675384521484,
0.8289417624473572,
-0.27684614062309265,
-0.7260503172874451,
0.5159385800361633,
-0.25009140372276306,
0.6805272102355957,
0.8569083213806152,
0.3454138934612274,
-0.2921479642391205,
-0.7597068548202515,
-0.9006029963493347,
-1.3146564960479736,
0.5947827696800232,
0.15284772217273712,
-0.15961109101772308,
-0.18816423416137695,
0.29106605052948,
-0.23465240001678467,
0.2805050313472748,
-0.427959680557251,
-0.06605632603168488,
0.09226256608963013,
-0.0791805237531662,
-0.28506550192832947,
-0.5108758211135864,
-0.11576497554779053,
-0.21413320302963257,
0.5083577036857605,
-0.08974368125200272,
0.22347041964530945,
-0.16011609137058258,
0.006940783932805061,
-0.31341850757598877,
0.4353705048561096,
0.500947892665863,
0.5614253282546997,
-0.47861558198928833,
0.08852556347846985,
-0.2888748049736023,
-0.5649709701538086,
0.12101152539253235,
0.07955312728881836,
-0.4518206715583801,
-0.11885803937911987,
-0.04845548793673515,
0.4096184968948364,
0.09226327389478683,
-0.6277427673339844,
0.08569583296775818,
-0.14307282865047455,
0.15610405802726746,
-0.3694060444831848,
0.3914770185947418,
-0.02959468401968479,
0.03976016864180565,
0.3690643310546875,
0.07598802447319031,
0.37177199125289917,
-0.5341583490371704,
0.35717684030532837,
0.30739808082580566,
0.021428033709526062,
0.12173951417207718,
0.5165875554084778,
-0.04681989178061485,
-0.045624539256095886,
0.8682355284690857,
-0.39796048402786255,
-0.43870145082473755,
0.9941474795341492,
0.413892537355423,
0.7861570715904236,
-0.4611896872520447,
0.019446851685643196,
0.7031906247138977,
0.2138722538948059,
-0.4677761197090149,
0.6978675723075867,
-0.009196584112942219,
-0.6806968450546265,
-0.5673893094062805,
-0.8781006336212158,
-0.5560831427574158,
0.08580818772315979,
-0.8385770320892334,
0.09808601438999176,
-0.25232261419296265,
-0.350056916475296,
-0.20101548731327057,
-0.1620490700006485,
-0.5662286877632141,
0.21449080109596252,
0.11183874309062958,
0.898383378982544,
-0.826097846031189,
1.008373737335205,
0.3919496238231659,
-0.09494999796152115,
-0.9091037511825562,
0.08686256408691406,
-0.13999930024147034,
-0.5219212174415588,
1.0295071601867676,
-0.002062858548015356,
-0.09068245440721512,
0.3432878851890564,
-0.5777168273925781,
-1.3810251951217651,
0.6539751887321472,
0.2260739803314209,
-0.7424442768096924,
-0.057175036519765854,
-0.14151549339294434,
0.3864794969558716,
-0.138364776968956,
0.24903446435928345,
0.5541350245475769,
0.5080267190933228,
0.1312466263771057,
-0.5586732625961304,
-0.10838260501623154,
-0.6141474843025208,
0.20616550743579865,
0.26661038398742676,
-0.4303017258644104,
1.0801947116851807,
0.06691516190767288,
-0.19859172403812408,
0.19316466152668,
0.4794180691242218,
0.5641367435455322,
-0.23554107546806335,
0.676295816898346,
0.645796537399292,
0.7157168984413147,
-0.13446882367134094,
1.4634997844696045,
-0.9222167730331421,
0.27445363998413086,
1.102179765701294,
-0.5497432351112366,
1.0007681846618652,
0.24444545805454254,
0.0543857216835022,
0.04034128040075302,
0.7282060980796814,
-0.02123669534921646,
0.4757724106311798,
0.4061073660850525,
-0.2786482870578766,
-0.5301730036735535,
-0.17524774372577667,
-0.43953937292099,
0.46094903349876404,
0.3719441890716553,
-0.163080632686615,
-0.22592462599277496,
-0.1089160144329071,
-0.26745083928108215,
-0.13242758810520172,
-0.21860182285308838,
0.5163259506225586,
-0.08282766491174698,
-1.1400796175003052,
0.6592439413070679,
-0.027187328785657883,
0.4994708299636841,
-0.4541548490524292,
-0.018967000767588615,
-0.040568429976701736,
0.03624030575156212,
-0.022945905104279518,
-0.8096653819084167,
0.05117793008685112,
0.015784135088324547,
-0.37246087193489075,
-0.6077670454978943,
0.3370160758495331,
-0.42470818758010864,
-0.6920047402381897,
0.15546660125255585,
0.22416934370994568,
0.2011343240737915,
-0.023386569693684578,
-0.3543247878551483,
0.024043379351496696,
-0.13245172798633575,
-0.5918653011322021,
0.3390803635120392,
0.14015613496303558,
-0.1281459629535675,
0.46760958433151245,
0.9289447069168091,
0.5503415465354919,
0.16452844440937042,
0.2797747552394867,
0.7773826718330383,
-0.5382528305053711,
-0.46735522150993347,
-0.6103700995445251,
0.291858047246933,
-0.20047780871391296,
-0.27075543999671936,
0.6975417137145996,
0.6473389267921448,
0.9689233899116516,
-0.2285291701555252,
0.9337491393089294,
-0.20476703345775604,
0.5954771041870117,
-0.8515884876251221,
0.6086689829826355,
-0.28600752353668213,
0.025825031101703644,
-0.2975996732711792,
-1.2308859825134277,
-0.3023451864719391,
0.6474847793579102,
-0.44332224130630493,
0.2161666303873062,
0.7915571331977844,
0.7105360627174377,
0.013977676630020142,
-0.40848004817962646,
0.2722841203212738,
0.009079995565116405,
0.25464972853660583,
0.8556454181671143,
0.6337317228317261,
-0.040067244321107864,
0.235589861869812,
-0.41808539628982544,
-0.3202414810657501,
-0.40674880146980286,
-0.9267805218696594,
-0.46978092193603516,
-0.5500858426094055,
-0.2049175202846527,
-0.3506345748901367,
-0.09001301229000092,
1.0894204378128052,
1.0060787200927734,
-1.0644575357437134,
-0.2952732741832733,
-0.06529197096824646,
-0.07543855160474777,
-0.3498947024345398,
-0.25535687804222107,
0.13495852053165436,
-0.39186954498291016,
-1.0516464710235596,
0.5137434601783752,
0.14512401819229126,
-0.0833292081952095,
-0.16084204614162445,
0.46231985092163086,
-0.08518784493207932,
-0.1834145188331604,
0.395260751247406,
0.5397106409072876,
-0.2809543013572693,
-0.1603933572769165,
0.054966896772384644,
-0.33457890152931213,
0.1421789526939392,
1.1326566934585571,
-0.562068521976471,
0.46409615874290466,
0.8673123717308044,
0.5751857757568359,
0.4811757802963257,
0.14806021749973297,
0.7467064261436462,
-0.7753795981407166,
0.38332483172416687,
0.4256853759288788,
0.3345237374305725,
0.14043645560741425,
-0.4519404172897339,
0.44748425483703613,
-0.028261439874768257,
-0.6622922420501709,
-0.7706778645515442,
0.6148637533187866,
-1.1665188074111938,
-0.4344838857650757,
1.4387754201889038,
0.2096492201089859,
-0.2222726196050644,
-0.1541365683078766,
-0.01433023065328598,
0.3487233817577362,
-0.6233825087547302,
0.9158843159675598,
0.7701029777526855,
0.003188306000083685,
-0.015076710842549801,
-1.0090034008026123,
0.4995664358139038,
0.5067580938339233,
-0.737653374671936,
0.18695946037769318,
0.44957292079925537,
0.3512253165245056,
0.35442379117012024,
0.8964295983314514,
-0.12970475852489471,
0.31322938203811646,
-0.24809695780277252,
0.46540823578834534,
0.23948214948177338,
-0.6414889693260193,
-0.3178344964981079,
0.5647804141044617,
0.3655164837837219,
0.2956225872039795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01306v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01306v3
|
NeuroPrune: A Neuro-inspired Topological Sparse Training Algorithm for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T22:21:47 | 2024-06-05T16:07:13 |
Amit Dhurandhar, Tejaswini Pedapati, Ronny Luss, Soham Dan, Aurelie Lozano, Payel Das, Georgios Kollias
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Transformer-based Language Models have become ubiquitous in Natural Language
Processing (NLP) due to their impressive performance on various tasks. However,
expensive training as well as inference remains a significant impediment to
their widespread applicability. While enforcing sparsity at various levels of
the model architecture has found promise in addressing scaling and efficiency
issues, there remains a disconnect between how sparsity affects network
topology. Inspired by brain neuronal networks, we explore sparsity approaches
through the lens of network topology. Specifically, we exploit mechanisms seen
in biological networks, such as preferential attachment and redundant synapse
pruning, and show that principled, model-agnostic sparsity approaches are
performant and efficient across diverse NLP tasks, spanning both classification
(such as natural language inference) and generation (summarization, machine
translation), despite our sole objective not being optimizing performance.
NeuroPrune is competitive with (or sometimes superior to) baselines on
performance and can be up to $10$x faster in terms of training time for a given
level of sparsity, simultaneously exhibiting measurable improvements in
inference time in many cases.
|
[
-0.3272501230239868,
-0.8355367183685303,
0.06810352206230164,
0.30691972374916077,
0.021904200315475464,
-0.3119913935661316,
-0.3790885806083679,
-0.21312063932418823,
0.6937509775161743,
0.21699663996696472,
-0.6267439126968384,
-0.0694015696644783,
-0.8585320711135864,
0.20407602190971375,
-0.6466668248176575,
1.1977088451385498,
0.5880441069602966,
-0.09402874857187271,
-0.08772983402013779,
-0.2719855010509491,
-0.33778953552246094,
-0.5381349921226501,
-0.7262352108955383,
-0.4780140519142151,
0.7105950713157654,
0.2602619230747223,
1.012325406074524,
0.5926675200462341,
0.4096965193748474,
0.3650418221950531,
-0.5407617092132568,
0.30438506603240967,
-0.6669829487800598,
0.09154845774173737,
-0.10884454846382141,
-0.197139710187912,
-0.34028249979019165,
-0.2982012927532196,
0.6792252659797668,
1.095110535621643,
-0.3870184123516083,
-0.24784283339977264,
0.32673880457878113,
0.7012683749198914,
-0.33796578645706177,
-0.41592955589294434,
-0.6487003564834595,
0.20642848312854767,
-0.08938805013895035,
-0.1611933559179306,
-0.12349852919578552,
-0.3013910949230194,
0.16613760590553284,
-0.7482395768165588,
0.5514853596687317,
0.04945974424481392,
1.0364971160888672,
0.4115432798862457,
-0.1390250027179718,
-0.023685511201620102,
-0.5478788018226624,
0.4929666817188263,
-0.6588538885116577,
0.3993400037288666,
0.21873196959495544,
0.15533164143562317,
-0.4847932755947113,
-0.7635073065757751,
-0.47395411133766174,
-0.1324775516986847,
-0.21557316184043884,
-0.24242939054965973,
-0.5169738531112671,
0.16086843609809875,
0.24033968150615692,
0.36255109310150146,
-0.9023883938789368,
0.12205672264099121,
-0.2597118318080902,
0.26142844557762146,
0.3065890371799469,
-0.019609741866588593,
0.5633881688117981,
-0.16927999258041382,
-0.04530360549688339,
-0.07372219860553741,
-0.5482868552207947,
-0.3660240173339844,
0.2721253037452698,
0.29058289527893066,
-0.05698389559984207,
0.30205172300338745,
0.09053819626569748,
0.9243188500404358,
-0.1764405071735382,
0.2337423413991928,
-0.06865976750850677,
0.14722388982772827,
-0.20360113680362701,
-0.11661888659000397,
0.8064835071563721,
-0.033384453505277634,
0.4814181923866272,
-0.8814963698387146,
-0.20886588096618652,
0.09493864327669144,
0.6086341142654419,
-0.6161189675331116,
-0.4916318655014038,
0.09553732722997665,
-0.2694489657878876,
-0.3099913001060486,
-0.2579343616962433,
-0.8356555700302124,
-0.3814913034439087,
-0.3161045014858246,
0.40151247382164,
-0.6737492680549622,
-0.5607703328132629,
0.2964070737361908,
-0.35708296298980713,
-0.12189801782369614,
0.21268324553966522,
-1.0380760431289673,
1.0481106042861938,
1.088229775428772,
1.3360992670059204,
-0.3242591321468353,
-0.5970361232757568,
-0.31188344955444336,
-0.001644657808355987,
-0.2883465886116028,
0.7978610396385193,
-0.4789770245552063,
-0.04133623465895653,
-0.4572085440158844,
-0.044211097061634064,
-0.3629339337348938,
-0.5293378233909607,
0.2768993377685547,
-0.3798206150531769,
-0.22990131378173828,
0.07590686529874802,
-0.26004040241241455,
-0.3039725720882416,
0.2616836428642273,
-0.8361092209815979,
1.0405679941177368,
-0.009099534712731838,
-0.877240777015686,
0.23403127491474152,
-0.6784822344779968,
-0.6321085095405579,
0.03753919526934624,
0.08381043374538422,
-0.3952816128730774,
0.4207252264022827,
0.04091648384928703,
0.3747490346431732,
-0.2326117753982544,
0.669933021068573,
-0.38534054160118103,
-0.5813058018684387,
0.20033155381679535,
-0.27320000529289246,
0.650818407535553,
-0.06716591864824295,
-0.3585790693759918,
0.12744945287704468,
-0.58682781457901,
-0.2831902503967285,
0.18733683228492737,
0.3026687204837799,
-0.5297607779502869,
0.1311689019203186,
0.28412705659866333,
0.06670283526182175,
-0.37309321761131287,
-0.3819565773010254,
0.32982030510902405,
-0.9628950953483582,
0.8277511596679688,
0.6889243721961975,
-0.04722735285758972,
0.6367026567459106,
-0.1418413519859314,
0.41085246205329895,
-0.28286924958229065,
0.03506674990057945,
0.6215949058532715,
-0.41757696866989136,
-0.7359936237335205,
-0.26575329899787903,
0.3705344796180725,
0.2528744339942932,
-0.3445320427417755,
0.475757896900177,
-0.5540216565132141,
-0.5937452912330627,
0.02908184379339218,
-0.09180861711502075,
0.015271027572453022,
0.3211609423160553,
0.31129878759384155,
-0.42609500885009766,
-0.34130215644836426,
-0.8054744601249695,
-0.4246676564216614,
0.4748901128768921,
0.20293927192687988,
0.3393375873565674,
0.7063323855400085,
0.03104151040315628,
0.7738009691238403,
-0.48056191205978394,
-0.1671351045370102,
-0.5086104869842529,
0.11624017357826233,
0.770146906375885,
0.6883484125137329,
0.4933284521102905,
-0.7073447704315186,
-0.005097709130495787,
0.09341869503259659,
-0.4067811369895935,
0.029736019670963287,
-0.038164760917425156,
-0.15158958733081818,
-0.19416511058807373,
0.3898566663265228,
-0.9172472357749939,
0.37757545709609985,
0.620136022567749,
-0.11299167573451996,
0.3915270268917084,
-0.1810576170682907,
-0.3563995063304901,
-0.996117353439331,
0.3744431138038635,
0.12218558043241501,
-0.09853880852460861,
-0.6899800896644592,
-0.09110740572214127,
-0.43472716212272644,
-0.5944739580154419,
0.19118881225585938,
0.5837181210517883,
-0.629550039768219,
-0.3984334468841553,
-0.36923226714134216,
0.30559083819389343,
0.006065047346055508,
0.7172805070877075,
0.22388598322868347,
0.6319375038146973,
0.5574411153793335,
-0.6465336680412292,
-0.058199986815452576,
0.2544792592525482,
0.03782491758465767,
0.3256659209728241,
-1.1500260829925537,
-0.023109497502446175,
-0.19224902987480164,
0.2647721767425537,
-0.8240483403205872,
-0.08195775747299194,
0.06869527697563171,
-0.6153572201728821,
0.4364737272262573,
-0.41389200091362,
-0.519812822341919,
0.03372133895754814,
0.17475837469100952,
0.4650917947292328,
0.252363383769989,
-0.4652768671512604,
0.5870852470397949,
0.47491946816444397,
-0.06150168180465698,
-0.6478238701820374,
-0.7838010787963867,
0.3778821527957916,
-0.17487819492816925,
-0.5635810494422913,
0.3134881556034088,
0.3910427689552307,
0.09829262644052505,
-0.01644895225763321,
-0.15310657024383545,
-0.47249650955200195,
0.366009384393692,
0.3494681417942047,
-0.11739612370729446,
-0.21307697892189026,
0.23233528435230255,
-0.01718561351299286,
-0.3537614941596985,
-0.005002331454306841,
-0.5999046564102173,
0.710538387298584,
-0.1101415604352951,
-0.21876221895217896,
-0.3420564532279968,
0.3478371500968933,
0.4786655902862549,
-0.3166761100292206,
0.6749762296676636,
0.32649436593055725,
-0.5835431814193726,
-0.608883261680603,
-0.406608521938324,
-0.7141435146331787,
-0.466321736574173,
0.5975775122642517,
-0.04945623129606247,
-0.8227816820144653,
-0.05690740793943405,
-0.1915382444858551,
-0.028127864003181458,
0.23472723364830017,
0.21646881103515625,
0.16278262436389923,
0.4849802255630493,
0.8053149580955505,
-0.19532179832458496,
0.3068612813949585,
-0.4949382245540619,
0.6513637900352478,
-0.5655426979064941,
-0.03982711583375931,
-0.7044963836669922,
-0.7995703220367432,
-0.4331555664539337,
-0.38032031059265137,
0.6044827103614807,
-0.05911405384540558,
-0.08724838495254517,
0.5753265619277954,
-0.8699286580085754,
0.3718721568584442,
0.3477460443973541,
0.13038629293441772,
0.027239760383963585,
0.48796430230140686,
0.04408835619688034,
-0.2564011514186859,
-1.5018556118011475,
-0.09617526829242706,
0.5322230458259583,
0.2181769460439682,
0.48262208700180054,
0.003349734703078866,
0.46621251106262207,
0.0625632032752037,
0.15106219053268433,
-0.7151300311088562,
0.4599572420120239,
-0.16587182879447937,
-0.31111493706703186,
-0.32462018728256226,
-0.5820374488830566,
-1.2073947191238403,
0.25254449248313904,
-0.40080222487449646,
-0.8153460621833801,
0.4650443494319916,
0.22332847118377686,
-0.15783163905143738,
0.5788747072219849,
-0.3849024772644043,
0.9982632994651794,
-0.023582497611641884,
-0.521682858467102,
-0.5543280839920044,
-0.5341300964355469,
0.2548510432243347,
0.3810727596282959,
-0.06027202308177948,
0.07919337600469589,
-0.05785825848579407,
0.6331838965415955,
-0.4246029257774353,
0.9061509966850281,
0.09681463241577148,
0.5455025434494019,
-0.044290002435445786,
0.515801191329956,
0.3710651695728302,
0.13995268940925598,
-0.10937631875276566,
0.5183761119842529,
-0.2734196186065674,
-0.3564763367176056,
-0.8001892566680908,
0.7077768445014954,
-0.7529212236404419,
-0.09509078413248062,
-0.6295832991600037,
-0.7501540780067444,
-0.3236794173717499,
0.18028268218040466,
0.29633960127830505,
0.9117199778556824,
-0.08704326301813126,
0.24215376377105713,
0.8941376209259033,
-0.3190087080001831,
0.30397024750709534,
0.046431560069322586,
0.26270270347595215,
-0.7414050698280334,
1.130814552307129,
0.2303391546010971,
0.06021682918071747,
0.5028068423271179,
0.1578274965286255,
-0.02788710594177246,
-0.6266270875930786,
-0.3199787735939026,
0.44863271713256836,
-0.17460304498672485,
-0.27670374512672424,
-1.0276745557785034,
-0.3897848129272461,
-0.2727479338645935,
-0.2819722592830658,
-0.49516868591308594,
-0.7768729329109192,
-0.07520300894975662,
0.06544262170791626,
0.6134986877441406,
0.8591727614402771,
-0.20308399200439453,
0.5386182069778442,
-0.43110743165016174,
0.27176204323768616,
0.0008788625127635896,
0.5032792687416077,
0.3162229359149933,
-0.5893939733505249,
-0.13876372575759888,
-0.2589368522167206,
-0.2667868733406067,
-0.8967422842979431,
0.6750729084014893,
0.4160899817943573,
0.3330639600753784,
0.10809805244207382,
-0.3651212155818939,
0.6968944668769836,
-0.5762938261032104,
0.3544076085090637,
0.20583391189575195,
-0.7778294682502747,
0.2716706395149231,
-0.2513936161994934,
-0.008768545463681221,
0.4249795377254486,
0.4672885835170746,
-0.8073745965957642,
-0.14393487572669983,
-0.9129499197006226,
-0.946434736251831,
0.4426440894603729,
0.2818637192249298,
0.12096602469682693,
-0.08486136049032211,
0.44233453273773193,
-0.11782040446996689,
0.19012907147407532,
-0.89032381772995,
-0.13604332506656647,
-0.1915084570646286,
0.09804074466228485,
0.05825025588274002,
-0.15854749083518982,
-0.08156608790159225,
-0.38574278354644775,
0.6305301785469055,
-0.21966904401779175,
0.22017063200473785,
0.456732839345932,
-0.01913689263164997,
0.2563684284687042,
0.026593033224344254,
0.39957505464553833,
0.5077317953109741,
0.13291557133197784,
-0.08825559914112091,
0.27705705165863037,
-0.4768994152545929,
0.05043775215744972,
0.03420427441596985,
-0.17293477058410645,
0.3255951404571533,
0.3102348744869232,
0.5833587050437927,
0.47179168462753296,
-0.35605213046073914,
0.7308852076530457,
-0.03613733500242233,
-0.33847203850746155,
-0.09664440155029297,
-0.06183668226003647,
0.15955354273319244,
0.025956904515624046,
-0.06360332667827606,
0.4871903359889984,
0.4105328917503357,
0.1300097405910492,
0.23043836653232574,
0.5604556202888489,
-0.47785496711730957,
-0.3169254660606384,
0.36830899119377136,
-0.030378440394997597,
-0.3985229730606079,
0.7594913840293884,
0.025188865140080452,
-0.40685465931892395,
0.6079232692718506,
0.5884262323379517,
1.0841959714889526,
0.08077230304479599,
0.10380607843399048,
0.5643271207809448,
0.6063156723976135,
-0.1847163289785385,
-0.16511504352092743,
-0.149230495095253,
-0.5965256690979004,
-0.5117100477218628,
-0.7350100874900818,
-0.2818969786167145,
0.04104267805814743,
-0.41126739978790283,
0.1648285835981369,
-0.7044285535812378,
-0.20826983451843262,
-0.28019943833351135,
-0.32573750615119934,
-0.017811240628361702,
0.23653294146060944,
-0.20704643428325653,
1.2303547859191895,
-0.8681371808052063,
0.5998623967170715,
0.5271539092063904,
0.043989505618810654,
-0.7471058964729309,
-0.1442795693874359,
-0.19482582807540894,
-0.34080249071121216,
0.5689675807952881,
0.19995428621768951,
-0.22499968111515045,
-0.04726797714829445,
-0.5260507464408875,
-1.0080444812774658,
0.5930856466293335,
0.5073389410972595,
-0.5099037289619446,
-0.19493059813976288,
-0.22015035152435303,
0.5273509621620178,
0.16321639716625214,
0.2240544855594635,
0.3637485206127167,
0.1376517117023468,
-0.18879707157611847,
-0.6881365776062012,
-0.12408839166164398,
-0.7196961641311646,
0.05923151597380638,
0.5001762509346008,
-0.42836475372314453,
0.6857967376708984,
0.03365446254611015,
-0.1554802507162094,
-0.0011698767775669694,
0.7698858976364136,
0.2520621418952942,
-0.008249697275459766,
0.4598805606365204,
0.8658599853515625,
0.593617856502533,
-0.21113212406635284,
1.082374095916748,
-0.6186721920967102,
0.1702808439731598,
0.9085420370101929,
0.03589223325252533,
0.5638407468795776,
0.5897548198699951,
0.127889022231102,
0.45006948709487915,
0.2518291175365448,
-0.09374918043613434,
0.17623965442180634,
0.4616295099258423,
0.13434840738773346,
-0.18295539915561676,
-0.20542320609092712,
-0.3105728328227997,
0.2953343093395233,
0.42220425605773926,
-0.0053779431618750095,
-0.40166646242141724,
-0.41248276829719543,
0.0657682791352272,
0.3682902455329895,
0.014416402205824852,
0.6702756285667419,
0.30155497789382935,
-0.6867274045944214,
0.697623074054718,
-0.09099117666482925,
0.652466893196106,
-0.8280301094055176,
-0.17840108275413513,
-0.252504825592041,
0.14181599020957947,
-0.35783851146698,
-0.23258666694164276,
0.6941956281661987,
-0.2776014506816864,
-0.07633268088102341,
-0.1546550840139389,
0.7133196592330933,
-0.053321197628974915,
-0.32687249779701233,
0.22519038617610931,
0.2613959014415741,
0.152879536151886,
-0.197686105966568,
-0.7438927292823792,
-0.08308236300945282,
-0.5471888780593872,
-0.1973874717950821,
0.3150137662887573,
0.6109557151794434,
0.1343008130788803,
0.8276479244232178,
0.5803031325340271,
0.5242146253585815,
-0.09988109767436981,
-0.12947967648506165,
1.0864485502243042,
-0.43976229429244995,
-0.5198015570640564,
-0.7451667189598083,
0.14060425758361816,
-0.39073628187179565,
-0.7408678531646729,
0.5560471415519714,
0.5628547072410583,
0.3056892454624176,
0.1878274828195572,
0.3454734981060028,
-0.04818098992109299,
0.288610577583313,
-0.3390675187110901,
0.8139587044715881,
-0.6655348539352417,
-0.027006501331925392,
-0.5043898224830627,
-0.8105196952819824,
-0.4686749577522278,
0.8571593165397644,
-0.4516024887561798,
0.07724063843488693,
0.7753826379776001,
1.2163091897964478,
-0.47511959075927734,
0.2264343649148941,
0.09699802100658417,
0.21150505542755127,
-0.11828690767288208,
0.702946662902832,
0.5376680493354797,
-0.3740924298763275,
0.2748657763004303,
-0.33211755752563477,
-0.17843706905841827,
0.036167778074741364,
-0.9135465025901794,
-0.8225082159042358,
-0.3697775602340698,
-0.07512892037630081,
-0.4427705705165863,
0.4346006214618683,
0.8351227045059204,
1.0793989896774292,
-0.5688493251800537,
-0.599500834941864,
-0.6879056096076965,
0.22827349603176117,
-0.4742423892021179,
-0.22813497483730316,
0.27352821826934814,
-0.4574647843837738,
-0.3725046217441559,
0.4637351930141449,
0.5330734252929688,
-0.26030653715133667,
-0.08495239913463593,
0.13026028871536255,
-0.2715598940849304,
-0.17774122953414917,
0.2801346480846405,
0.3763635754585266,
-0.3520878255367279,
0.35499006509780884,
0.05326700583100319,
-0.07561586052179337,
0.08061984181404114,
1.0662065744400024,
-0.5645774006843567,
-0.19192175567150116,
0.5412508845329285,
0.9515504240989685,
0.3116892874240875,
-0.21999549865722656,
0.9257734417915344,
-0.6306713819503784,
0.5509050488471985,
0.5967563390731812,
0.34920018911361694,
0.3807959258556366,
-0.37719136476516724,
0.5678550601005554,
0.5799727439880371,
-0.6977616548538208,
-1.0311721563339233,
0.05032039061188698,
-0.7989904880523682,
-0.45956552028656006,
1.0009833574295044,
0.28724321722984314,
-0.6524287462234497,
-0.07336602360010147,
0.09968369454145432,
0.004367258865386248,
-0.08573474735021591,
0.5944573879241943,
0.19747325778007507,
0.04564444720745087,
-0.12088954448699951,
-0.6345124244689941,
0.6146966814994812,
0.9190655946731567,
-0.5385986566543579,
0.1356971114873886,
0.3214782774448395,
0.3039681613445282,
0.03059864416718483,
0.33249491453170776,
0.03239142894744873,
0.46167656779289246,
0.12380393594503403,
0.1965664178133011,
-0.009431335143744946,
-0.7213209271430969,
-0.5507984757423401,
0.32599058747291565,
-0.0463971346616745,
0.41107794642448425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18700v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18700v2
|
Learning to Compress Prompt in Natural Language Formats
| 2024-02-28T20:41:21 | 2024-04-02T02:38:31 |
Yu-Neng Chuang, Tianwei Xing, Chia-Yuan Chang, Zirui Liu, Xun Chen, Xia Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are great at processing multiple natural
language processing tasks, but their abilities are constrained by inferior
performance with long context, slow inference speed, and the high cost of
computing the results. Deploying LLMs with precise and informative context
helps users process large-scale datasets more effectively and cost-efficiently.
Existing works rely on compressing long prompt contexts into soft prompts.
However, soft prompt compression encounters limitations in transferability
across different LLMs, especially API-based LLMs. To this end, this work aims
to compress lengthy prompts in the form of natural language with LLM
transferability. This poses two challenges: (i) Natural Language (NL) prompts
are incompatible with back-propagation, and (ii) NL prompts lack flexibility in
imposing length constraints. In this work, we propose a Natural Language Prompt
Encapsulation (Nano-Capsulator) framework compressing original prompts into NL
formatted Capsule Prompt while maintaining the prompt utility and
transferability. Specifically, to tackle the first challenge, the
Nano-Capsulator is optimized by a reward function that interacts with the
proposed semantics preserving loss. To address the second question, the
Nano-Capsulator is optimized by a reward function featuring length constraints.
Experimental results demonstrate that the Capsule Prompt can reduce 81.4% of
the original length, decrease inference latency up to 4.5x, and save 80.1% of
budget overheads while providing transferability across diverse LLMs and
different datasets.
|
[
-0.3320232629776001,
-0.774165689945221,
0.6615115404129028,
0.407529354095459,
-0.33770743012428284,
-0.031165041029453278,
-0.7390201687812805,
-0.2821766138076782,
0.17980875074863434,
0.45553678274154663,
-0.819912314414978,
-0.3933817446231842,
-0.5315111875534058,
0.6857213377952576,
0.24926823377609253,
0.7902373671531677,
-0.014360119588673115,
-0.5536541938781738,
-0.4121135175228119,
0.07389102876186371,
-1.01838219165802,
-0.4201221764087677,
-0.8008149862289429,
-0.06720239669084549,
0.39688119292259216,
0.49729079008102417,
0.44882088899612427,
0.5821296572685242,
0.08668278902769089,
0.31035560369491577,
-0.2357628047466278,
0.2796260714530945,
-0.2328827828168869,
0.3144683539867401,
-0.065327487885952,
-0.44900673627853394,
-0.0360565148293972,
-0.13467684388160706,
0.4993085265159607,
0.7048900127410889,
-0.12809783220291138,
-0.009143993258476257,
0.2724839746952057,
0.587878406047821,
-0.5313636064529419,
0.49538949131965637,
-0.3950200378894806,
0.16786827147006989,
0.07291221618652344,
-0.26803189516067505,
-0.5885618925094604,
-0.6174164414405823,
0.1716241091489792,
-0.8795800805091858,
-0.010064177215099335,
0.5099418759346008,
0.573711633682251,
0.39662230014801025,
-0.292411208152771,
-0.40613242983818054,
-0.368169903755188,
0.9500024318695068,
-0.645597517490387,
0.058601174503564835,
0.19970127940177917,
0.5361891388893127,
-0.1989516317844391,
-0.47718289494514465,
-0.6604194045066833,
-0.24828052520751953,
-0.2123667299747467,
-0.3463006019592285,
-0.21575626730918884,
0.24029850959777832,
0.2547731399536133,
0.2713518440723419,
-0.7835482358932495,
0.31730082631111145,
-0.11441270262002945,
-0.4411027729511261,
0.2210303246974945,
0.22884495556354523,
0.4659782648086548,
-0.4240491986274719,
-0.3740825355052948,
-0.1336536556482315,
-0.6086431741714478,
0.2517153322696686,
0.19157522916793823,
0.7800209522247314,
-0.23597285151481628,
0.3241182267665863,
-0.1420627385377884,
0.7435379028320312,
0.01927204057574272,
-0.18060261011123657,
0.21431785821914673,
-0.2914925813674927,
-0.2398340106010437,
0.2995529770851135,
0.8293811678886414,
0.38863739371299744,
0.34414204955101013,
-0.32802924513816833,
-0.04207004979252815,
-0.11969902366399765,
0.03493347764015198,
-0.9426078796386719,
0.2122061848640442,
0.27124926447868347,
-0.450177937746048,
-0.05334213376045227,
-0.12751631438732147,
-0.8051490187644958,
-0.4317725598812103,
-0.5586889386177063,
0.3417002856731415,
-0.33437108993530273,
0.3464723527431488,
0.5750118494033813,
-0.14587269723415375,
-0.23390808701515198,
0.3012199103832245,
-1.1235049962997437,
0.5151495933532715,
0.7168723940849304,
1.120003342628479,
-0.2414381355047226,
-0.02109474688768387,
-0.7948052287101746,
0.17070534825325012,
0.20318718254566193,
0.7386764287948608,
-0.3338279724121094,
-0.38427332043647766,
0.21712726354599,
0.21805772185325623,
0.022950900718569756,
-0.47684815526008606,
0.8061733841896057,
-0.10287298262119293,
0.23500394821166992,
-0.2752494812011719,
-0.6376242637634277,
0.019912218675017357,
0.45013272762298584,
-0.7766432762145996,
0.6036199331283569,
0.02721056342124939,
-0.49414926767349243,
0.08242721855640411,
-0.6149194240570068,
-0.5503864288330078,
-0.006308290176093578,
0.04048354923725128,
-0.27877697348594666,
-0.014653772115707397,
0.6532324552536011,
0.6035991311073303,
-0.5434195399284363,
0.2492041438817978,
-0.06760937720537186,
-0.6032130718231201,
0.3632882833480835,
-0.4977230727672577,
0.6128076910972595,
0.06483769416809082,
-0.12271788716316223,
0.11507284641265869,
-0.6098690629005432,
-0.4346597194671631,
-0.07255727052688599,
-0.44485148787498474,
-0.19882625341415405,
-0.5932673811912537,
-0.07741429656744003,
-0.03997509181499481,
0.2963743805885315,
-0.876953125,
0.6137598752975464,
-0.4538774788379669,
0.6830609440803528,
0.7438026070594788,
0.10614729672670364,
0.8175633549690247,
-0.34388577938079834,
0.7040759325027466,
-0.21973741054534912,
0.2460733950138092,
-0.4259638488292694,
-0.3004368841648102,
-0.43234726786613464,
-0.6566773653030396,
0.11026200652122498,
0.7077211737632751,
-0.8180675506591797,
0.7209438681602478,
-0.38385459780693054,
-0.22394144535064697,
-0.4816383719444275,
0.01961233839392662,
0.10012852400541306,
0.7839155197143555,
0.5726540684700012,
0.3384575843811035,
-0.45692989230155945,
-0.8012760877609253,
-0.17004400491714478,
0.11332322657108307,
-0.10545526444911957,
0.4449710249900818,
0.20361341536045074,
-0.009201722219586372,
0.9776831269264221,
-0.6052793264389038,
-0.3451067805290222,
-0.41911983489990234,
0.43420204520225525,
0.8268334269523621,
0.5654519200325012,
0.20619943737983704,
-0.5098791122436523,
-0.23667258024215698,
-0.4099869430065155,
-0.461249440908432,
-0.4768418073654175,
-0.45689302682876587,
0.12447074055671692,
0.05535867437720299,
0.5508049130439758,
-1.112653374671936,
0.33694595098495483,
0.3403739035129547,
-0.4499400556087494,
0.7360325455665588,
-0.4178609848022461,
0.2341034859418869,
-0.933340847492218,
0.004920036531984806,
-0.12254608422517776,
-0.2652513384819031,
-0.386106014251709,
-0.29321959614753723,
0.1645558923482895,
-0.27696219086647034,
-0.6119681000709534,
0.9082064032554626,
-0.49398157000541687,
0.25808456540107727,
-0.3386036455631256,
0.0063726045191287994,
0.42405208945274353,
0.5539183616638184,
-0.027741217985749245,
0.7601616382598877,
0.5559616684913635,
-0.913886547088623,
0.35374894738197327,
0.5775057077407837,
-0.15901871025562286,
0.782677173614502,
-0.7912664413452148,
0.04730129614472389,
-0.25854602456092834,
0.7122381925582886,
-0.646543025970459,
0.05649876594543457,
0.4992331266403198,
-0.3856823146343231,
0.3311464488506317,
-0.240541011095047,
-0.763198971748352,
-0.2661338448524475,
-0.5389389991760254,
0.43627995252609253,
0.6044765710830688,
-0.690538763999939,
0.4609350264072418,
-0.1978173553943634,
-0.4157533645629883,
-0.5014433264732361,
-1.0472975969314575,
0.27798500657081604,
-0.3806140422821045,
-0.4731420874595642,
0.5884271860122681,
-0.3946138918399811,
0.18442687392234802,
-0.09541165828704834,
0.19780445098876953,
0.29221203923225403,
0.06218290328979492,
0.4147762358188629,
0.2541663348674774,
-0.09597721695899963,
0.4486907124519348,
0.3208293616771698,
-0.3054569363594055,
-0.03503583371639252,
-0.31903132796287537,
0.5749539732933044,
0.07622207701206207,
-0.08771897107362747,
-0.6623281836509705,
0.6116501092910767,
0.34173718094825745,
0.08023671060800552,
0.9988309144973755,
0.3217763304710388,
-0.4300583004951477,
-0.39058125019073486,
-0.321591854095459,
-0.2598420977592468,
-0.5168768763542175,
-0.08503105491399765,
-0.22870831191539764,
-1.195188045501709,
0.4608932137489319,
0.027070453390479088,
-0.08340964466333389,
0.055877551436424255,
0.3193684220314026,
0.24757906794548035,
0.5831004977226257,
0.4821958541870117,
-0.0014839568175375462,
0.29539453983306885,
-0.021034393459558487,
0.2186308354139328,
-0.8659123182296753,
-0.26079174876213074,
-0.6658444404602051,
-0.3924332559108734,
-0.22923149168491364,
-0.5085532665252686,
0.18781247735023499,
0.037513963878154755,
-0.3703611493110657,
0.38704827427864075,
-0.6946172714233398,
0.5138291716575623,
0.4671640396118164,
-0.0026892588939517736,
0.10090543329715729,
-0.11644519865512848,
0.05014841631054878,
-0.14072054624557495,
-0.6123458743095398,
-0.44102880358695984,
0.5390777587890625,
0.38849177956581116,
0.684353768825531,
0.20799683034420013,
0.6603793501853943,
0.26324543356895447,
0.03126613795757294,
-0.8752514719963074,
0.5945623517036438,
-0.08091353625059128,
0.027292175218462944,
-0.3583446741104126,
-0.5481285452842712,
-1.1238592863082886,
-0.19722449779510498,
-0.24477605521678925,
-0.9011364579200745,
0.16782958805561066,
0.0613456591963768,
-0.6862307786941528,
0.09309455007314682,
-0.5542046427726746,
0.7471761107444763,
0.06312140077352524,
-0.2216969132423401,
0.22515906393527985,
-0.6289896368980408,
0.08258029073476791,
0.3061048686504364,
0.3766792118549347,
-0.2464396059513092,
-0.3058907985687256,
0.6132225394248962,
-0.5376313924789429,
0.9586176872253418,
-0.21829667687416077,
0.004604891408234835,
0.14651080965995789,
0.12405338883399963,
0.6211193799972534,
0.32335004210472107,
-0.04327535256743431,
-0.11940638720989227,
-0.34833618998527527,
-0.2833422124385834,
-1.0405827760696411,
0.7411656975746155,
-0.2976864278316498,
-0.45715537667274475,
-0.3574652373790741,
-0.7149784564971924,
-0.16109736263751984,
0.038859762251377106,
0.29610201716423035,
0.6804094314575195,
0.14685335755348206,
-0.07367154955863953,
0.7944779992103577,
-0.6689916849136353,
0.7331313490867615,
0.17237672209739685,
0.060470100492239,
-0.5560293793678284,
0.7265863418579102,
-0.07461084425449371,
0.02357557974755764,
0.5471418499946594,
0.5641860365867615,
-0.5057893991470337,
-0.4684639871120453,
-0.5091383457183838,
0.2110217809677124,
-0.6859294176101685,
-0.5906554460525513,
-0.5540762543678284,
0.14271686971187592,
-0.6543183922767639,
-0.6165686845779419,
-0.013681676238775253,
-0.46894511580467224,
-0.7658368349075317,
-0.09692356735467911,
0.6528005003929138,
0.32780757546424866,
-0.13166756927967072,
0.4585053324699402,
-0.9968124628067017,
0.3724372684955597,
0.29383352398872375,
0.2641673982143402,
-0.1054762527346611,
-0.5729473233222961,
-0.03263295814394951,
-0.3441793620586395,
0.2463105171918869,
-0.8019456267356873,
0.6595954895019531,
0.16896048188209534,
0.34796908497810364,
0.15317918360233307,
0.45107361674308777,
0.5834640860557556,
-0.44047486782073975,
0.9553915858268738,
0.3102484941482544,
-1.038032054901123,
0.4624321162700653,
-0.11976994574069977,
0.6831473112106323,
0.8170343637466431,
0.15438123047351837,
-0.6868888139724731,
-0.17254923284053802,
-0.24128343164920807,
-1.066202163696289,
0.5059801340103149,
0.007998698391020298,
0.2922123968601227,
-0.3785633146762848,
0.47115910053253174,
0.5601477026939392,
0.2148488610982895,
-0.5301719903945923,
-0.10909374803304672,
0.0936315730214119,
-0.5200706720352173,
0.07139831781387329,
-0.2515435814857483,
0.1835993379354477,
-0.020636701956391335,
0.33383333683013916,
-0.3509771525859833,
0.35671597719192505,
0.40144896507263184,
-0.34741735458374023,
0.4342697858810425,
0.5496450662612915,
0.4783477783203125,
0.019472738727927208,
-0.23723851144313812,
0.45805850625038147,
0.04918097332119942,
-0.20189359784126282,
0.25303974747657776,
0.26675793528556824,
-0.050389938056468964,
0.03148122504353523,
0.295316219329834,
0.9723898768424988,
0.5287529230117798,
-0.8632476329803467,
0.6159642338752747,
-0.2837050259113312,
0.08378403633832932,
-0.0967153012752533,
-0.24644498527050018,
-0.02103341743350029,
0.1827722191810608,
0.22523871064186096,
-0.1303611844778061,
0.4413300156593323,
-0.41910865902900696,
-0.021287092939019203,
0.19416750967502594,
-0.15916623175144196,
-0.08654117584228516,
0.4258263111114502,
0.38825249671936035,
-0.4319741129875183,
0.6352481842041016,
-0.37856778502464294,
-0.520986020565033,
0.45332032442092896,
0.6833784580230713,
0.8625113368034363,
0.17432527244091034,
0.2082376629114151,
0.45462262630462646,
0.19522146880626678,
-0.22244621813297272,
0.07411734759807587,
-0.4764070510864258,
-0.350862979888916,
-0.6492613554000854,
-0.5433889031410217,
-0.390363872051239,
-0.24551399052143097,
-0.6155538558959961,
0.23026719689369202,
-0.40986064076423645,
-0.09332962334156036,
-0.40327373147010803,
-0.023406799882650375,
-0.7482717633247375,
-0.10331548005342484,
0.37117883563041687,
1.2352112531661987,
-0.7855181694030762,
0.2823460102081299,
0.2486581653356552,
-0.17710652947425842,
-0.6357343792915344,
-0.34687188267707825,
-0.10372865945100784,
-0.4535854756832123,
0.5820680856704712,
0.7278235554695129,
0.027573291212320328,
-0.16073453426361084,
-0.45611661672592163,
-0.6245938539505005,
1.0232903957366943,
0.6965144872665405,
-0.636556088924408,
-0.030636867508292198,
0.36802613735198975,
0.18798130750656128,
-0.322514146566391,
0.21615812182426453,
0.5424224138259888,
0.7070720195770264,
0.03454522043466568,
-0.9741489887237549,
0.6047868132591248,
0.006875231862068176,
-0.01736573502421379,
0.11496838927268982,
-0.34185728430747986,
0.674415111541748,
-0.17080093920230865,
-0.3704364001750946,
0.2991747558116913,
0.6616504788398743,
0.5126036405563354,
0.32926902174949646,
0.4448831081390381,
0.41883036494255066,
0.9537415504455566,
0.04853487387299538,
1.1615865230560303,
0.0032121629919856787,
0.12391669303178787,
0.9064895510673523,
-0.0303165465593338,
0.6055127382278442,
0.7929441332817078,
0.18991823494434357,
0.5478992462158203,
0.5519458055496216,
0.13463500142097473,
0.4410262703895569,
0.6389625668525696,
-0.2885655164718628,
-0.021884014829993248,
-0.506480872631073,
0.010016903281211853,
-0.10292339324951172,
0.21126331388950348,
-0.08275768160820007,
-0.05517445504665375,
0.4832976460456848,
0.2816166877746582,
0.308591365814209,
-0.328217476606369,
0.4842045307159424,
0.1346922665834427,
-0.6948925852775574,
0.5022336840629578,
-0.16202369332313538,
1.133409857749939,
-0.45360806584358215,
-0.21865057945251465,
-0.2366674840450287,
-0.2334657907485962,
0.005991186946630478,
-0.7589185833930969,
0.25254419445991516,
-0.06946531683206558,
-0.16010712087154388,
-0.6017472147941589,
0.6929440498352051,
-0.3989372253417969,
-0.2022826224565506,
-0.09267102181911469,
0.22098974883556366,
0.10625708103179932,
-0.2014617919921875,
-0.4852818548679352,
0.3131486177444458,
-0.3766764998435974,
-0.3985813558101654,
0.16208860278129578,
0.5893942713737488,
0.24274423718452454,
0.7379692196846008,
0.7079691290855408,
0.22195056080818176,
-0.15156888961791992,
0.017967497929930687,
0.7725500464439392,
-0.8820496797561646,
-0.7670016288757324,
-0.9089606404304504,
0.4998871386051178,
-0.15604020655155182,
-0.35424336791038513,
0.5178902745246887,
0.32524335384368896,
-0.00399564066901803,
-0.1275791972875595,
0.585186779499054,
0.09739621728658676,
0.28139016032218933,
-0.9162725210189819,
0.4124106168746948,
-0.15963880717754364,
0.3322574198246002,
0.1534193605184555,
-0.7978243231773376,
-0.5799538493156433,
0.309354305267334,
-0.020401593297719955,
-0.3557865023612976,
0.6146286725997925,
0.5380933284759521,
0.2232452630996704,
-0.08842961490154266,
0.10404888540506363,
-0.09408954530954361,
0.3819752335548401,
0.9415789246559143,
0.5003567337989807,
-0.03699910268187523,
0.5536864399909973,
-0.2471413016319275,
-0.15877778828144073,
-0.3367975652217865,
-1.281694769859314,
-0.9174788594245911,
-0.3468579351902008,
-0.49215108156204224,
-0.17353127896785736,
-0.039508990943431854,
1.224001169204712,
0.7753108739852905,
-0.5322959423065186,
0.13915374875068665,
-0.21032579243183136,
0.20820333063602448,
-0.106259785592556,
-0.2818821370601654,
0.5069845914840698,
-0.4282672107219696,
-0.7160939574241638,
0.6123805642127991,
0.37851807475090027,
0.09231654554605484,
-0.1721772402524948,
-0.08214535564184189,
0.1248123049736023,
0.30951741337776184,
0.524838924407959,
0.5015257596969604,
-0.5120930075645447,
-0.4859352111816406,
0.07053695619106293,
-0.01395278051495552,
0.018023505806922913,
0.8900691270828247,
-1.2575726509094238,
0.2702586352825165,
0.5227693319320679,
0.8076677322387695,
0.1395236700773239,
-0.1610511839389801,
0.6319026350975037,
-0.9874403476715088,
0.274730384349823,
0.3133793771266937,
0.4476008415222168,
0.6454444527626038,
-0.6806122064590454,
0.17266854643821716,
-0.0012765737483277917,
-0.6060720682144165,
-0.9124522805213928,
0.15604771673679352,
-1.4039233922958374,
-0.3916489779949188,
1.264946699142456,
-0.13729095458984375,
-0.44900310039520264,
-0.10250385850667953,
-0.535193920135498,
0.36768314242362976,
-0.7478705048561096,
0.5535403490066528,
0.41802695393562317,
-0.15577346086502075,
-0.31210342049598694,
-0.2719338536262512,
0.5108141899108887,
0.274271696805954,
-0.9617322683334351,
0.3017291724681854,
0.27086108922958374,
0.06928273290395737,
0.16401690244674683,
0.17228834331035614,
0.17789217829704285,
0.21072331070899963,
-0.17064793407917023,
0.10298094898462296,
-0.5316515564918518,
-0.06357987970113754,
-0.7748885154724121,
0.28526875376701355,
-0.26668211817741394,
-0.2859942317008972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18695v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18695v1
|
Grounding Language Models for Visual Entity Recognition
| 2024-02-28T20:22:17 | 2024-02-28T20:22:17 |
Zilin Xiao, Ming Gong, Paola Cascante-Bonilla, Xingyao Zhang, Jie Wu, Vicente Ordonez
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
We introduce AutoVER, an Autoregressive model for Visual Entity Recognition.
Our model extends an autoregressive Multi-modal Large Language Model by
employing retrieval augmented constrained generation. It mitigates low
performance on out-of-domain entities while excelling in queries that require
visually-situated reasoning. Our method learns to distinguish similar entities
within a vast label space by contrastively training on hard negative pairs in
parallel with a sequence-to-sequence objective without an external retriever.
During inference, a list of retrieved candidate answers explicitly guides
language generation by removing invalid decoding paths. The proposed method
achieves significant improvements across different dataset splits in the
recently proposed Oven-Wiki benchmark. Accuracy on the Entity seen split rises
from 32.7% to 61.5%. It also demonstrates superior performance on the unseen
and query splits by a substantial double-digit margin.
|
[
-0.6239246726036072,
-0.7880688309669495,
0.3251205384731293,
-0.0758519396185875,
-0.2368641048669815,
-0.10037719458341599,
-0.22777846455574036,
-0.6361966729164124,
0.10991641879081726,
0.6031233072280884,
-0.22688975930213928,
-0.41206616163253784,
-0.5640751123428345,
0.14918841421604156,
-0.37193676829338074,
0.2887938320636749,
-0.16840265691280365,
-0.17047131061553955,
-0.1559206247329712,
-0.3168342113494873,
-0.562282145023346,
-0.3189123570919037,
-0.45065662264823914,
-0.057932887226343155,
0.08052904903888702,
0.45628243684768677,
0.6741328239440918,
0.9988844990730286,
0.42108193039894104,
0.41574668884277344,
0.40786176919937134,
0.34098929166793823,
-0.26428332924842834,
0.45221054553985596,
-0.48254531621932983,
-0.22823156416416168,
-0.00374889955855906,
0.12245676666498184,
0.7147959470748901,
0.6562359929084778,
-0.07877123355865479,
-0.04272729903459549,
-0.21451829373836517,
0.6773119568824768,
-0.9695495367050171,
0.3952775001525879,
-0.9596748352050781,
0.0014332503778859973,
-0.09446344524621964,
-0.13400574028491974,
-0.5531109571456909,
0.05194688215851784,
0.032507117837667465,
-0.5733205080032349,
0.5045276880264282,
0.35192593932151794,
1.2127587795257568,
0.5794245600700378,
-0.6116394996643066,
-0.05134279653429985,
-0.6145673990249634,
0.5101136565208435,
-0.20022542774677277,
1.0061120986938477,
0.4725709855556488,
0.3306266665458679,
-0.14479368925094604,
-0.6677170991897583,
-0.706993043422699,
-0.3265020549297333,
-0.04437681660056114,
-0.057322241365909576,
-0.15139518678188324,
-0.08504652976989746,
0.5017900466918945,
0.4868175983428955,
-0.6078346371650696,
-0.16903969645500183,
-0.03723345324397087,
-0.028194217011332512,
0.52892005443573,
0.012369673699140549,
0.46576687693595886,
-0.39454010128974915,
-0.31456905603408813,
-0.345181405544281,
-0.631861686706543,
-0.09594030678272247,
0.002207275712862611,
-0.0537431500852108,
0.28267163038253784,
0.6804264187812805,
-0.24260467290878296,
0.9152750372886658,
0.3861665725708008,
0.012129777111113071,
0.2487645298242569,
0.0402192585170269,
-0.4463539719581604,
-0.24755124747753143,
0.7303637862205505,
0.35345184803009033,
0.18076306581497192,
-0.13685958087444305,
-0.3617478609085083,
0.20008309185504913,
0.1546197533607483,
-0.7606102228164673,
-0.7835057973861694,
-0.32673320174217224,
-0.42321136593818665,
0.08671361953020096,
-0.0168470311909914,
-0.5183383822441101,
-0.28591200709342957,
-0.40936845541000366,
0.2941567301750183,
-0.5814051032066345,
-0.3648672103881836,
-0.1961165964603424,
-0.08856102079153061,
0.33009862899780273,
0.587911069393158,
-0.7975688576698303,
0.33838480710983276,
0.1467558890581131,
0.4541912078857422,
0.048665471374988556,
-0.24977990984916687,
-0.5964693427085876,
0.4155898094177246,
-0.5235742926597595,
0.7958941459655762,
-0.500575065612793,
-0.27440762519836426,
-0.3683619499206543,
0.268298476934433,
-0.1401987373828888,
-0.5798401832580566,
0.057437293231487274,
-0.8236415982246399,
0.11143218725919724,
-0.24675829708576202,
-0.6816805601119995,
-0.2657136619091034,
0.1448047161102295,
-0.9875852465629578,
0.8663588762283325,
0.1232154592871666,
-0.6954759359359741,
0.926013708114624,
-0.08510901778936386,
-0.48554396629333496,
0.30841466784477234,
-0.6175065040588379,
-0.35550621151924133,
0.10970743000507355,
0.38207924365997314,
0.3047700524330139,
-0.40231382846832275,
0.334773451089859,
-0.2964845299720764,
0.1483304351568222,
-0.08361438661813736,
-0.5724717378616333,
0.4124138057231903,
0.4396175444126129,
-0.6228707432746887,
-0.32352861762046814,
-1.1705018281936646,
0.06117210537195206,
0.29362374544143677,
-0.30223947763442993,
-0.7226346135139465,
0.17757335305213928,
0.02429591864347458,
0.3100823760032654,
0.022707296535372734,
-0.3900010585784912,
0.23484918475151062,
-0.37569016218185425,
0.2223093956708908,
0.35471582412719727,
0.12768074870109558,
0.5700601935386658,
0.39360737800598145,
0.29277950525283813,
0.11589886993169785,
-0.06510753929615021,
-0.3174475431442261,
-0.26896512508392334,
-1.0366004705429077,
-0.4028262495994568,
0.18865160644054413,
0.45047396421432495,
-1.1237276792526245,
0.39558932185173035,
-0.016481054946780205,
-0.14370200037956238,
-0.2956591248512268,
0.22443100810050964,
0.4935135543346405,
0.7122519016265869,
0.5357124209403992,
-0.5262453556060791,
-0.424783855676651,
-0.9951551556587219,
-0.10363880544900894,
-0.29922375082969666,
0.36511367559432983,
0.5994642376899719,
0.4096885919570923,
-0.29050660133361816,
0.8237820267677307,
-0.5198474526405334,
-0.10109983384609222,
0.20851176977157593,
0.2813620865345001,
-0.06690537184476852,
0.6850942373275757,
0.6050063967704773,
-1.1837598085403442,
-0.7516637444496155,
-0.12481747567653656,
-1.015890121459961,
-0.07326710969209671,
0.08650802820920944,
-0.2008473426103592,
0.34103113412857056,
0.6466472744941711,
-0.7503006458282471,
0.6583043932914734,
0.12432783097028732,
-0.48062655329704285,
-0.03192156180739403,
-0.11595740914344788,
0.3551620841026306,
-0.8998768925666809,
-0.09413491934537888,
0.20664529502391815,
-0.5482079982757568,
-0.220953568816185,
0.167330801486969,
0.35426461696624756,
-0.18074047565460205,
-0.059482887387275696,
0.6080522537231445,
-1.247004747390747,
-0.21119524538516998,
-0.4063611924648285,
-0.06977204233407974,
0.27203571796417236,
0.11838964372873306,
0.3470798432826996,
0.8601071238517761,
0.6573653221130371,
-0.7157084941864014,
0.5159953236579895,
0.29276904463768005,
-0.3069060444831848,
0.6902155876159668,
-0.4548996090888977,
-0.05403643101453781,
-0.2805791199207306,
0.18492768704891205,
-1.1190240383148193,
-0.4300060272216797,
0.161934033036232,
-0.39985859394073486,
0.7353805899620056,
-0.4520978331565857,
-0.5840045213699341,
-0.3832523822784424,
0.3945627212524414,
0.641353964805603,
0.40362221002578735,
-0.7703631520271301,
0.8036102056503296,
0.5413844585418701,
0.23273614048957825,
-0.5318149924278259,
-0.5936260223388672,
0.3020726144313812,
-0.03489316999912262,
-0.6031861901283264,
0.21627409756183624,
0.15120261907577515,
-0.26194512844085693,
0.09901498258113861,
-0.05251309275627136,
-0.13238508999347687,
-0.01912424899637699,
0.3002552092075348,
0.20679804682731628,
-0.25267043709754944,
0.2861834466457367,
-0.2417580932378769,
-0.07927116006612778,
-0.018999889492988586,
-0.5308155417442322,
0.25014185905456543,
-0.1606103479862213,
-0.3915351629257202,
-0.2762528359889984,
0.40997013449668884,
0.42820292711257935,
-0.557689905166626,
0.6233537793159485,
0.3539334535598755,
-0.5957974195480347,
-0.217450350522995,
-1.013720154762268,
0.1669526994228363,
-0.4897187650203705,
0.047257956117391586,
-0.7947860360145569,
-0.4807296395301819,
0.35804253816604614,
0.02856336534023285,
-0.33699098229408264,
0.5697770714759827,
0.374409019947052,
0.10082447528839111,
1.1273977756500244,
0.6377813220024109,
0.11625950783491135,
0.5956607460975647,
-0.3100617229938507,
-0.010850815102458,
-0.5934246182441711,
-0.18907375633716583,
-0.1909923255443573,
0.1099441722035408,
-0.5118498206138611,
-0.5054402947425842,
0.13211286067962646,
0.4240911602973938,
-0.03429090231657028,
0.5952775478363037,
-0.5853769779205322,
0.574213445186615,
0.5446361899375916,
0.10753509402275085,
0.1796094924211502,
0.028955651447176933,
-0.355345219373703,
-0.1266494244337082,
-0.4990583062171936,
-0.25136399269104004,
0.7575353980064392,
0.1480628401041031,
0.9702014923095703,
0.11091058701276779,
0.7076888680458069,
0.27435731887817383,
0.2947830557823181,
-0.5137085318565369,
0.5291813611984253,
-0.03700585290789604,
-0.5772961378097534,
-0.2899724245071411,
-0.5420592427253723,
-0.7177376747131348,
0.38720351457595825,
-0.06859851628541946,
-0.4951503872871399,
0.47270727157592773,
0.3787098228931427,
0.12585647404193878,
0.15445153415203094,
-0.8211361765861511,
0.840270459651947,
-0.26510846614837646,
-0.5964683294296265,
0.15967769920825958,
-0.5716991424560547,
0.20246267318725586,
0.2412295788526535,
-0.0007805221830494702,
-0.029909249395132065,
0.1702742725610733,
0.24679207801818848,
-0.468422532081604,
0.6403395533561707,
-0.40813806653022766,
-0.14105375111103058,
0.42166614532470703,
0.38465264439582825,
0.717393159866333,
0.22862356901168823,
0.30881255865097046,
-0.20395126938819885,
-0.42830994725227356,
-0.3094777464866638,
-0.6057698726654053,
0.8449723124504089,
-0.7181994915008545,
-0.7134276628494263,
-0.40388837456703186,
-0.25795137882232666,
-0.13812455534934998,
0.42495837807655334,
0.4818885326385498,
0.37400978803634644,
-0.23025716841220856,
0.024472525343298912,
0.9342441558837891,
-0.0748455673456192,
0.3736775517463684,
0.6862531304359436,
-0.11215104907751083,
-0.7307617664337158,
0.812150239944458,
0.25859585404396057,
0.0232359878718853,
0.49573373794555664,
-0.3402397632598877,
-0.34125691652297974,
-0.2989228665828705,
-0.8177260160446167,
0.21194632351398468,
-1.0870059728622437,
-0.27005189657211304,
-0.9559447765350342,
-0.019769538193941116,
-0.5867172479629517,
0.007785189896821976,
-0.44824978709220886,
-0.3900774121284485,
-0.3201368749141693,
-0.05490158125758171,
0.25677627325057983,
0.6454690098762512,
-0.19170795381069183,
-0.09616149216890335,
-0.5197805166244507,
0.6406763195991516,
0.5084203481674194,
0.3170973062515259,
-0.11289769411087036,
-0.37462592124938965,
-0.15739130973815918,
-0.34522250294685364,
0.06577260792255402,
-1.0085842609405518,
0.5544093251228333,
0.4245021343231201,
0.6987673044204712,
0.3710275888442993,
-0.11519768089056015,
0.7833775281906128,
-0.8850502371788025,
0.46794167160987854,
0.26062166690826416,
-0.9351990818977356,
0.8547161817550659,
-0.12689624726772308,
0.1797487735748291,
0.5222890377044678,
0.31904157996177673,
-0.15337397158145905,
-0.3359745740890503,
-0.7122483253479004,
-1.0465638637542725,
0.3308236300945282,
0.07899319380521774,
-0.18610593676567078,
-0.4984007179737091,
0.43436458706855774,
-0.0660778135061264,
0.2798660397529602,
-0.7767099142074585,
-0.2789718210697174,
-0.4581214189529419,
-0.007777283433824778,
-0.08886665105819702,
-0.16417470574378967,
-0.028170881792902946,
-0.3594575822353363,
0.6265025734901428,
-0.16826680302619934,
0.19453094899654388,
0.3704293966293335,
-0.7918437123298645,
-0.3910178542137146,
-0.05771523714065552,
0.23474149405956268,
0.5132096409797668,
-0.00966816209256649,
0.43779319524765015,
-0.02604871429502964,
-0.24008525907993317,
0.35440292954444885,
0.3420218825340271,
-0.21864628791809082,
0.23952990770339966,
0.23583927750587463,
0.8667398691177368,
-0.07755701243877411,
-0.2603566348552704,
0.6487062573432922,
-0.17203743755817413,
0.036028191447257996,
-0.5588563680648804,
0.1707122027873993,
-0.34624263644218445,
0.413074791431427,
0.40544772148132324,
0.0627012550830841,
0.4452950358390808,
-0.2956300675868988,
0.49931639432907104,
0.5200307369232178,
-0.28370431065559387,
-0.2239941656589508,
0.9825058579444885,
0.10766991227865219,
0.03829002380371094,
0.6703051924705505,
-0.30330002307891846,
-0.41706910729408264,
0.654981255531311,
0.508806049823761,
0.9604465961456299,
-0.2932268977165222,
-0.020145008340477943,
0.4257185459136963,
0.2975875437259674,
-0.0543215274810791,
0.29258179664611816,
-0.3808203637599945,
-0.7621362209320068,
-0.10510050505399704,
-0.5083822011947632,
-0.10338205099105835,
-0.025186676532030106,
-0.7086121439933777,
0.24007318913936615,
-0.5031429529190063,
-0.30769622325897217,
0.15377309918403625,
-0.23067975044250488,
-1.008819580078125,
0.7296856641769409,
0.5019251108169556,
0.7523658871650696,
-0.8442244529724121,
0.7970965504646301,
0.8873012065887451,
-0.7581231594085693,
-0.7331891059875488,
-0.15706105530261993,
-0.17479774355888367,
-0.7367671728134155,
1.1789789199829102,
0.20369026064872742,
-0.24550023674964905,
0.1172768697142601,
-0.6966818571090698,
-1.280954360961914,
0.940187931060791,
0.13449594378471375,
-0.5838650465011597,
-0.16803452372550964,
-0.32408010959625244,
0.44447335600852966,
-0.5123409032821655,
0.28869765996932983,
0.2004641592502594,
0.31011515855789185,
0.13772264122962952,
-0.7614006996154785,
0.18407033383846283,
-0.4576902687549591,
0.42395880818367004,
0.4080137014389038,
-0.7556939721107483,
0.9123693108558655,
-0.05787951871752739,
-0.5259082913398743,
-0.16470099985599518,
0.9320264458656311,
0.01875162310898304,
0.19582252204418182,
0.752552330493927,
0.8764444589614868,
0.6472249627113342,
0.021083451807498932,
0.7093701362609863,
-0.5026777386665344,
0.4342724084854126,
1.2327244281768799,
-0.5559763312339783,
0.6465103626251221,
0.43663838505744934,
0.1738453358411789,
0.4954153597354889,
0.4513624906539917,
-0.30162039399147034,
0.7924575209617615,
0.059784598648548126,
-0.13707230985164642,
-0.5628150701522827,
0.015508700162172318,
-0.4181070327758789,
0.4808250367641449,
0.5504481792449951,
-0.7783343195915222,
-0.23436439037322998,
0.29318416118621826,
-0.36222246289253235,
0.08684806525707245,
-0.07030806690454483,
0.8332430124282837,
-1.928272013174137e-7,
-0.7678561806678772,
0.8830832242965698,
-0.05438810586929321,
0.1625131070613861,
-0.030256204307079315,
-0.3586718440055847,
0.02491479553282261,
0.12333530187606812,
-0.0930476188659668,
-0.47760966420173645,
-0.08360262960195541,
-0.1398281455039978,
-0.5137462019920349,
-0.15942510962486267,
1.0798472166061401,
-0.5662023425102234,
-0.2682965397834778,
0.36424052715301514,
0.5773009061813354,
0.03155278041958809,
0.12002269178628922,
-0.7169351577758789,
-0.08681030571460724,
-0.16473469138145447,
-0.5215148329734802,
-0.005335676949471235,
0.9918632507324219,
-0.1717514544725418,
0.6596864461898804,
0.47632819414138794,
-0.16486959159374237,
0.33588817715644836,
0.12489322572946548,
0.9942429065704346,
-0.8793599009513855,
-0.5799151659011841,
-0.6020122170448303,
0.1987282782793045,
-0.19057580828666687,
-0.055009737610816956,
0.7603762149810791,
0.6428297162055969,
0.9650408625602722,
-0.059843529015779495,
0.7282620072364807,
-0.13339757919311523,
0.3953256607055664,
-0.6455564498901367,
0.49473756551742554,
-0.6673552393913269,
0.14398100972175598,
-0.3111622631549835,
-1.0117878913879395,
-0.12278575450181961,
0.7680949568748474,
-0.27294403314590454,
0.05022262781858444,
0.6029911637306213,
0.4862845540046692,
-0.22561991214752197,
-0.3727537989616394,
0.4754990041255951,
0.08782278746366501,
0.264448344707489,
0.40300557017326355,
0.9328063130378723,
-0.6182032823562622,
0.278366357088089,
-0.2870114743709564,
-0.20020310580730438,
-0.17694200575351715,
-0.6757192611694336,
-0.9134036898612976,
-0.616473913192749,
-0.504317581653595,
-0.4986177086830139,
0.13932497799396515,
0.9110406041145325,
0.8373380899429321,
-0.6385238170623779,
0.06866945326328278,
-0.3696301579475403,
-0.30318790674209595,
0.16566221415996552,
-0.2949891984462738,
0.18008191883563995,
-0.3975251615047455,
-0.6067832708358765,
0.43469664454460144,
0.33592161536216736,
0.30218350887298584,
-0.2683981955051422,
0.2539026141166687,
-0.336846262216568,
-0.09821557998657227,
0.47119367122650146,
0.5485032796859741,
-0.7639849781990051,
-0.33477115631103516,
-0.12441389262676239,
-0.43139463663101196,
0.23529623448848724,
0.6631994843482971,
-0.9407103657722473,
0.6781958341598511,
0.4165668785572052,
0.6004565358161926,
0.653056263923645,
0.02717447467148304,
0.5959841012954712,
-0.6366941332817078,
0.24131213128566742,
0.179605171084404,
0.6641502380371094,
0.5727918744087219,
-0.5725262761116028,
0.5517956614494324,
0.5066913962364197,
-0.587602972984314,
-0.5336971282958984,
0.45805901288986206,
-0.51233971118927,
-0.1889580637216568,
1.1503757238388062,
-0.15174582600593567,
-0.39488500356674194,
-0.007586583029478788,
0.20137539505958557,
0.39801326394081116,
-0.3663211166858673,
0.49073854088783264,
0.5980558395385742,
-0.007124850060790777,
-0.44957277178764343,
-0.39971768856048584,
0.46565553545951843,
0.29963016510009766,
-0.5444552898406982,
-0.09941892325878143,
1.074605941772461,
0.4486459195613861,
0.20401272177696228,
0.668731689453125,
0.022305717691779137,
0.26948121190071106,
0.08905589580535889,
0.2768723666667938,
0.04182720556855202,
-0.7463729381561279,
-0.1451108753681183,
0.06269654631614685,
0.20541371405124664,
-0.19088095426559448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00835v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00835v4
|
CLLMs: Consistency Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T20:17:04 | 2024-06-13T08:41:28 |
Siqi Kou, Lanxiang Hu, Zhezhi He, Zhijie Deng, Hao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Parallel decoding methods such as Jacobi decoding show promise for more
efficient LLM inference as it breaks the sequential nature of the LLM decoding
process and transforms it into parallelizable computation. However, in
practice, it achieves little speedup compared to traditional autoregressive
(AR) decoding, primarily because Jacobi decoding seldom accurately predicts
more than one token in a single fixed-point iteration step. To address this, we
develop a new approach aimed at realizing fast convergence from any state to
the fixed point on a Jacobi trajectory. This is accomplished by refining the
target LLM to consistently predict the fixed point given any state as input.
Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our method, showing
2.4$\times$ to 3.4$\times$ improvements in generation speed while preserving
generation quality across both domain-specific and open-domain benchmarks.
|
[
-0.10554253309965134,
-0.4558304250240326,
0.671181857585907,
0.4261032044887543,
-0.09079518914222717,
0.1148810088634491,
-0.5620425343513489,
-0.12668843567371368,
0.12355092167854309,
0.5090369582176208,
-0.4216936528682709,
-0.5639397501945496,
-0.7620527148246765,
0.3283936083316803,
-0.49472665786743164,
0.6232295632362366,
-0.18464083969593048,
0.09072836488485336,
-0.06867370009422302,
-0.075091652572155,
-0.09068190306425095,
-0.4943532943725586,
-0.6342143416404724,
-0.32400691509246826,
0.6512361764907837,
0.24465028941631317,
0.6785290837287903,
0.9535112977027893,
0.31679773330688477,
0.21538151800632477,
-0.28772616386413574,
0.44947531819343567,
-0.771701991558075,
0.45264294743537903,
-0.19002600014209747,
-0.46340107917785645,
-0.24056273698806763,
-0.43771088123321533,
1.0621154308319092,
0.7995597720146179,
-0.13354484736919403,
0.21364207565784454,
0.11904717236757278,
0.8536450862884521,
-0.9614390730857849,
0.13843633234500885,
-0.6804521083831787,
-0.18971769511699677,
-0.16612984240055084,
-0.17784465849399567,
-0.9224593639373779,
-0.7035722732543945,
-0.03382254019379616,
-0.4882597029209137,
0.22171495854854584,
0.05197181925177574,
0.8131161332130432,
0.05084303021430969,
-0.3809947073459625,
-0.18026334047317505,
-0.869856059551239,
1.076862096786499,
-0.8978142142295837,
0.5178257822990417,
0.1247406080365181,
0.15648914873600006,
-0.3463493585586548,
-0.7608467936515808,
-0.4496574401855469,
-0.022366339340806007,
-0.027288341894745827,
-0.24721437692642212,
-0.02848668582737446,
0.10114841908216476,
0.5376885533332825,
0.12026354670524597,
-0.5541151762008667,
-0.11431392282247543,
0.006886809598654509,
-0.2760300636291504,
0.7576410174369812,
0.5110382437705994,
-0.31282544136047363,
0.25624650716781616,
-0.21110375225543976,
-0.14099560678005219,
-0.905907154083252,
0.26596495509147644,
0.15922336280345917,
0.3350889980792999,
0.1343761682510376,
0.5371004939079285,
-0.22729428112506866,
0.8341624140739441,
0.11210627108812332,
-0.47572627663612366,
0.3659086525440216,
-0.46220168471336365,
-0.06253060698509216,
-0.2627960741519928,
0.44571152329444885,
0.3523806035518646,
0.26333731412887573,
-0.03427089378237724,
-0.4354245662689209,
-0.11175620555877686,
0.010024276562035084,
-0.8293817639350891,
-0.15095281600952148,
0.12847767770290375,
-0.671894371509552,
0.14796411991119385,
0.13268128037452698,
-0.48031795024871826,
-0.17148526012897491,
-0.6522837281227112,
-0.010095803998410702,
-0.5940253734588623,
-0.20584028959274292,
0.1710323691368103,
0.22296364605426788,
0.20201803743839264,
0.23465986549854279,
-1.0121707916259766,
0.3009950518608093,
0.7615258693695068,
0.844913899898529,
-0.37470558285713196,
-0.3420247733592987,
-0.6779511570930481,
0.13144709169864655,
-0.4859764873981476,
0.4228876829147339,
-0.3796132504940033,
-0.3267174959182739,
0.2095077484846115,
0.13079459965229034,
-0.23044215142726898,
-0.5417484641075134,
0.22694344818592072,
-0.5714095234870911,
-0.5378594398498535,
-0.4854031503200531,
-0.8329008221626282,
-0.1464558094739914,
0.1564992070198059,
-0.2839047908782959,
0.63319331407547,
-0.11918752640485764,
-0.5708184838294983,
0.2787451446056366,
-0.5368832945823669,
-0.41641899943351746,
-0.33783623576164246,
0.1138593852519989,
-0.49903833866119385,
0.3051989674568176,
0.15385688841342926,
0.3638788163661957,
-0.10223812609910965,
0.5376010537147522,
-0.28272661566734314,
-0.5812566876411438,
-0.01987086981534958,
-0.3867664039134979,
0.5867233872413635,
0.5499085783958435,
-0.23240981996059418,
0.15672650933265686,
-0.8357908129692078,
0.21902529895305634,
0.09274076670408249,
-0.42757198214530945,
-0.04344172403216362,
0.29293933510780334,
-0.14463748037815094,
-0.2935115098953247,
0.43513181805610657,
-0.6522504687309265,
0.32803991436958313,
-0.26997771859169006,
0.08791673183441162,
0.5133339166641235,
-0.22157907485961914,
0.32995447516441345,
-0.25247499346733093,
0.2818903923034668,
0.16322751343250275,
-0.03731931746006012,
-0.41296347975730896,
-0.259165495634079,
-0.8706066608428955,
-0.3418431580066681,
0.5466617941856384,
0.3921426832675934,
-0.7898659706115723,
0.5128914713859558,
-0.40103545784950256,
-0.351235955953598,
-0.38227713108062744,
-0.02632160484790802,
0.6209081411361694,
0.3500925600528717,
0.2528934180736542,
-0.1703903079032898,
-0.7330321669578552,
-0.8748078346252441,
-0.29794058203697205,
0.1460600048303604,
-0.13626131415367126,
-0.024128630757331848,
0.3632373511791229,
-0.253628134727478,
0.9049298763275146,
-0.3816229999065399,
0.4628063142299652,
-0.3061152994632721,
0.4133833348751068,
0.34705159068107605,
0.5974934697151184,
0.3275929391384125,
-0.4009532034397125,
-0.7391253113746643,
-0.21000432968139648,
-0.7579198479652405,
-0.028610626235604286,
0.05084824189543724,
0.09768518805503845,
0.3841158151626587,
0.4609074294567108,
-0.341376930475235,
0.377962589263916,
0.6839115023612976,
-0.3786715269088745,
0.5172931551933289,
-0.2025352120399475,
0.23105157911777496,
-0.7938608527183533,
0.05452873930335045,
-0.14132876694202423,
-0.4718357026576996,
-0.8526461720466614,
-0.038006361573934555,
0.23843149840831757,
0.045324742794036865,
-0.379495233297348,
0.22176392376422882,
-0.6947005391120911,
-0.3573358356952667,
-0.5963298082351685,
-0.04607389494776726,
0.011728172190487385,
0.1612052470445633,
-0.026374951004981995,
1.0677000284194946,
0.7493792176246643,
-0.665498673915863,
-0.03148479759693146,
0.06637122482061386,
-0.14505906403064728,
0.16778892278671265,
-0.6115785837173462,
0.14405851066112518,
-0.32434263825416565,
0.393078476190567,
-0.7215089201927185,
0.09971251338720322,
-0.15334919095039368,
-0.21858006715774536,
0.3512895107269287,
0.26036909222602844,
-0.5892346501350403,
-0.35076889395713806,
-0.07564501464366913,
0.7027547955513,
0.7751591205596924,
-0.8029918670654297,
0.7714235782623291,
0.08463349938392639,
0.22971178591251373,
-0.7360081672668457,
-0.47843536734580994,
-0.20030157268047333,
0.29110032320022583,
-0.6892102360725403,
-0.03386559337377548,
-0.12811821699142456,
-0.32832661271095276,
-0.14337953925132751,
0.17922572791576385,
0.1365332454442978,
-0.03527144715189934,
0.14145199954509735,
0.04979195073246956,
-0.4435383975505829,
-0.22852039337158203,
-0.1859550029039383,
-0.19179515540599823,
-0.1106146052479744,
-0.48054996132850647,
0.6594136357307434,
-0.4398241341114044,
-0.42950132489204407,
-0.6766814589500427,
0.46135616302490234,
0.83430415391922,
-0.1406225562095642,
0.846263587474823,
0.4021276533603668,
-0.16638417541980743,
-0.09875919669866562,
-0.5213034152984619,
-0.09373930096626282,
-0.4112280607223511,
-0.01501600444316864,
-0.6665013432502747,
-0.9473393559455872,
0.711601972579956,
-0.2443830519914627,
0.17907088994979858,
0.2949814796447754,
0.5236847996711731,
0.12236174941062927,
1.1373971700668335,
0.6513784527778625,
-0.08106472343206406,
0.057652801275253296,
-0.28990477323532104,
0.30520153045654297,
-0.673408031463623,
-0.1684347540140152,
-0.33800721168518066,
-0.3747391998767853,
-0.36069273948669434,
-0.31356003880500793,
0.048427268862724304,
0.3156006634235382,
-0.4017501771450043,
0.6245379447937012,
-0.3961697518825531,
0.5008675456047058,
0.8253597617149353,
0.020369404926896095,
0.362029105424881,
-0.08205749839544296,
-0.2353304624557495,
-0.0913868248462677,
-0.8403642177581787,
-0.3422824442386627,
1.0909018516540527,
0.47952356934547424,
0.7452682852745056,
0.008567764423787594,
0.8232017159461975,
0.1914699822664261,
0.3660617172718048,
-0.4023100435733795,
0.6276032328605652,
-0.290376752614975,
-0.3680347204208374,
-0.23357641696929932,
-0.22311097383499146,
-1.0098017454147339,
0.2188008576631546,
-0.15856283903121948,
-0.7086002230644226,
0.34007659554481506,
0.3648209869861603,
-0.20658566057682037,
0.6261481642723083,
-0.40801694989204407,
0.3473694324493408,
0.16883641481399536,
-0.3566168546676636,
-0.11273660510778427,
-0.6990058422088623,
0.5444972515106201,
-0.005223482847213745,
0.03610653057694435,
-0.25813159346580505,
0.13785359263420105,
0.4136148989200592,
-0.5696536898612976,
0.6363240480422974,
-0.36553704738616943,
-0.10571867227554321,
0.4055672585964203,
0.07190396636724472,
0.7883103489875793,
-0.12357443571090698,
-0.39820316433906555,
0.36049017310142517,
0.10813206434249878,
-0.733717143535614,
-0.6207278966903687,
0.7352333068847656,
-0.45236435532569885,
-0.5067878365516663,
-0.19834136962890625,
-0.9571254849433899,
-0.14301066100597382,
0.12985588610172272,
0.2307235598564148,
0.497294157743454,
0.18419356644153595,
0.19767101109027863,
0.7102587819099426,
0.14425373077392578,
0.5619085431098938,
0.5557106733322144,
-0.34340980648994446,
-0.4018218219280243,
0.9583279490470886,
-0.002007088391110301,
0.3893876373767853,
0.04441605880856514,
-0.14745929837226868,
-0.3469392955303192,
-0.952629566192627,
-0.21616649627685547,
0.3998848497867584,
-0.7382035851478577,
-0.27332475781440735,
-0.22585202753543854,
-0.39037635922431946,
-0.39049628376960754,
-0.38260066509246826,
-0.6376948952674866,
-0.02114463411271572,
-0.1930219531059265,
0.23048590123653412,
0.06909380108118057,
0.9283640384674072,
-0.10620581358671188,
0.33897605538368225,
-1.107925295829773,
0.14276812970638275,
-0.16456131637096405,
0.3147295415401459,
-0.08264506608247757,
-0.48353311419487,
-0.285653680562973,
-0.015363265760242939,
0.04137210547924042,
-0.34913304448127747,
0.43370321393013,
0.0795544907450676,
0.43353211879730225,
0.4841095507144928,
0.16046476364135742,
0.6942451000213623,
-0.740922749042511,
0.8738763332366943,
0.37965187430381775,
-1.1062549352645874,
0.35635828971862793,
-0.194915771484375,
0.5940006375312805,
0.6857964396476746,
0.3340664207935333,
-0.1527833789587021,
-0.40643107891082764,
-0.40878036618232727,
-0.6037369966506958,
0.33209559321403503,
0.2547565698623657,
-0.15788716077804565,
-0.4101158678531647,
0.4552294909954071,
0.29299232363700867,
0.22463232278823853,
-0.5070874691009521,
-0.48126575350761414,
-0.002919815480709076,
-0.37051674723625183,
-0.10747575759887695,
-0.7338094711303711,
-0.26832374930381775,
-0.3193061947822571,
0.5474492311477661,
-0.20025362074375153,
0.2452862709760666,
0.24635988473892212,
0.058161478489637375,
-0.17305141687393188,
0.0718236193060875,
1.0097981691360474,
1.0148463249206543,
-0.19667468965053558,
0.3384084403514862,
0.1760295033454895,
-0.20461983978748322,
0.4121832549571991,
-0.05802285671234131,
-0.6382810473442078,
0.32086488604545593,
0.22992157936096191,
0.9367668628692627,
0.10908329486846924,
-0.7165494561195374,
0.5633377432823181,
0.0034878281876444817,
-0.5342478156089783,
-0.32292309403419495,
-0.10473790764808655,
-0.09588479995727539,
0.5867868065834045,
0.3359808027744293,
0.19571489095687866,
-0.07688414305448532,
-0.2082047015428543,
0.5445508360862732,
0.4885427951812744,
0.015325960703194141,
-0.17896443605422974,
0.7170264720916748,
0.20233261585235596,
-0.39074280858039856,
0.4367996156215668,
-0.3731144368648529,
-0.2973809838294983,
0.3403581380844116,
0.7851521372795105,
0.9003417491912842,
-0.030534716323018074,
-0.20109611749649048,
0.6842617988586426,
-0.06365496665239334,
-0.6276821494102478,
0.4476144313812256,
0.13256263732910156,
-0.6579270958900452,
-0.7304059863090515,
-0.845527172088623,
-0.4150685966014862,
-0.07316247373819351,
-0.7901983261108398,
0.016914157196879387,
-0.5892186760902405,
-0.10033339262008667,
-0.47086301445961,
-0.3768540322780609,
-0.3051987588405609,
0.23039405047893524,
0.2996598780155182,
1.068484902381897,
-0.426986426115036,
1.1791911125183105,
0.07901199907064438,
0.14193610846996307,
-0.9344930648803711,
0.3228926360607147,
-0.024997273460030556,
-0.7496886253356934,
0.8273356556892395,
0.11110753566026688,
-0.4889698326587677,
0.2341005802154541,
-0.6083039045333862,
-1.3803073167800903,
1.2388802766799927,
0.2994983494281769,
-1.2025797367095947,
-0.03264659270644188,
-0.12863241136074066,
0.3422432839870453,
-0.7227868437767029,
0.0638795793056488,
0.8359212279319763,
0.4875119626522064,
0.03698026016354561,
-0.9363374710083008,
0.22084760665893555,
0.10511285066604614,
0.44097426533699036,
0.3011007606983185,
-0.3938455283641815,
0.7920483946800232,
-0.36834296584129333,
-0.22636432945728302,
0.4645170271396637,
0.9819087982177734,
0.4882248640060425,
0.4173266589641571,
0.5997123122215271,
0.6457768082618713,
0.8572813868522644,
-0.25718066096305847,
1.1521015167236328,
-0.8733908534049988,
0.6534376740455627,
0.9257200360298157,
-0.225418820977211,
1.0207886695861816,
0.40036460757255554,
-0.13129018247127533,
0.6104069352149963,
0.3586864769458771,
-0.1390831023454666,
0.6165435910224915,
0.3275142014026642,
-0.48676183819770813,
-0.334154337644577,
-0.038783010095357895,
-0.1531277447938919,
0.12972798943519592,
0.24077367782592773,
-0.5644274950027466,
-0.22334212064743042,
0.11480327695608139,
-0.012290887534618378,
0.4303227961063385,
-0.4149371385574341,
0.3493930995464325,
-0.1625075787305832,
-0.8274970650672913,
1.312396764755249,
-0.1653182953596115,
0.764532744884491,
-0.6275388598442078,
0.07571291923522949,
-0.0498899482190609,
0.2824850380420685,
-0.02098020352423191,
-0.6960455775260925,
0.5152974724769592,
-0.35800686478614807,
-0.48949065804481506,
-0.20632457733154297,
0.5729792714118958,
-0.782524049282074,
-0.3237309753894806,
0.44826337695121765,
0.19508682191371918,
0.2076943963766098,
0.33844053745269775,
-0.43894150853157043,
0.464419960975647,
0.14738738536834717,
-0.2893386483192444,
0.1535685807466507,
0.08143351227045059,
0.24121429026126862,
0.7382211685180664,
0.5564670562744141,
-0.06889384239912033,
0.19760845601558685,
0.07330838590860367,
0.6759036183357239,
-0.7368788123130798,
-0.026112793013453484,
-0.8207138180732727,
0.6096947193145752,
-0.05355453118681908,
-0.1345740407705307,
0.75099778175354,
0.5640673041343689,
0.6830855011940002,
-0.26871463656425476,
0.6121683120727539,
0.1262022703886032,
0.7489542961120605,
-0.7542872428894043,
0.38088950514793396,
-0.3821595013141632,
0.2993689179420471,
0.40798524022102356,
-0.9038503766059875,
-0.4379647672176361,
0.21684320271015167,
-0.23138755559921265,
-0.27199387550354004,
0.9365910887718201,
0.7317429184913635,
0.24482972919940948,
-0.16010789573192596,
0.6567516922950745,
0.27597060799598694,
0.25187474489212036,
0.5032472610473633,
0.49762439727783203,
-0.31830236315727234,
0.35217389464378357,
-0.2305545061826706,
-0.06549323350191116,
-0.14672383666038513,
-0.7612664699554443,
-0.7665615677833557,
-0.3046362102031708,
-0.05722562596201897,
-0.6692692637443542,
0.29257628321647644,
0.8773704171180725,
0.6926507949829102,
-1.1958776712417603,
-0.25312933325767517,
-0.46431276202201843,
-0.1788535863161087,
-0.2624957263469696,
-0.22307951748371124,
0.1532505601644516,
-0.787956178188324,
-1.004003882408142,
0.621266782283783,
0.45992815494537354,
-0.16425907611846924,
-0.2436208575963974,
-0.3328303396701813,
-0.21850837767124176,
0.25368818640708923,
0.6848969459533691,
0.4959132671356201,
-1.1611558198928833,
-0.5197312235832214,
0.04707269370555878,
-0.23294197022914886,
0.1567647010087967,
1.1750681400299072,
-0.5257987380027771,
0.3515794575214386,
0.48990580439567566,
0.9230049252510071,
0.7073460221290588,
0.37821999192237854,
0.8343268036842346,
-0.46975159645080566,
0.177053764462471,
0.1686088591814041,
0.591411828994751,
0.2570122182369232,
-0.1561068743467331,
0.3459429442882538,
0.4547542333602905,
-0.8649517893791199,
-0.6280186176300049,
0.4174899756908417,
-1.0022510290145874,
-0.3072740435600281,
1.2195833921432495,
-0.6039973497390747,
-0.42436036467552185,
-0.23056529462337494,
0.016620267182588577,
0.11315208673477173,
-0.33148613572120667,
0.42383790016174316,
0.4767165184020996,
-0.35129499435424805,
-0.16542015969753265,
-0.18852312862873077,
0.3890714645385742,
0.6938276290893555,
-0.23030240833759308,
0.2830626666545868,
0.3310253620147705,
0.4134542644023895,
0.3754183351993561,
0.6005414128303528,
0.02327689528465271,
0.05101390555500984,
0.16604691743850708,
0.10113111138343811,
-0.0400550402700901,
-0.457757830619812,
-0.38408827781677246,
0.4095301628112793,
0.19641625881195068,
-0.1942569464445114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18678v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18678v3
|
RORA: Robust Free-Text Rationale Evaluation
| 2024-02-28T19:46:21 | 2024-06-15T00:32:04 |
Zhengping Jiang, Yining Lu, Hanjie Chen, Daniel Khashabi, Benjamin Van Durme, Anqi Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Free-text rationales play a pivotal role in explainable NLP, bridging the
knowledge and reasoning gaps behind a model's decision-making. However, due to
the diversity of potential reasoning paths and a corresponding lack of
definitive ground truth, their evaluation remains a challenge. Existing
evaluation metrics rely on the degree to which a rationale supports a target
label, but we find these fall short in evaluating rationales that inadvertently
leak the labels. To address this problem, we propose RORA, a Robust free-text
Rationale evaluation against label leakage. RORA quantifies the new information
supplied by a rationale to justify the label. This is achieved by assessing the
conditional V-information \citep{hewitt-etal-2021-conditional} with a
predictive family robust against leaky features that can be exploited by a
small model. RORA consistently outperforms existing approaches in evaluating
human-written, synthetic, or model-generated rationales, particularly
demonstrating robustness against label leakage. We also show that RORA aligns
well with human judgment, providing a more reliable and accurate measurement
across diverse free-text rationales.
|
[
-0.20833805203437805,
-0.5156897306442261,
0.5563471913337708,
0.04911540821194649,
-0.21025288105010986,
-0.24238690733909607,
-0.023213613778352737,
-0.37407004833221436,
0.11860746890306473,
0.3970204293727875,
-0.7290583848953247,
-0.3225017488002777,
-0.570869505405426,
-0.03702416270971298,
-0.23034076392650604,
1.040794849395752,
-0.13506750762462616,
-0.20621007680892944,
-0.4402318000793457,
-0.6994867324829102,
-0.7720675468444824,
-0.23760367929935455,
-0.42325642704963684,
-0.5021896362304688,
0.9716820120811462,
0.35221144556999207,
0.7730802297592163,
0.8021634221076965,
0.34056222438812256,
0.14039956033229828,
-0.04046771302819252,
0.1582968384027481,
-0.1901978850364685,
0.5393903851509094,
-0.6724187135696411,
-0.5372359156608582,
-0.4260513484477997,
0.16813324391841888,
0.3983539640903473,
0.16882950067520142,
-0.18598604202270508,
0.49379971623420715,
-0.03245259448885918,
0.935160756111145,
-0.9516563415527344,
-0.07626368850469589,
-0.6459208130836487,
-0.014730812981724739,
-0.0639914721250534,
-0.23739129304885864,
-0.6914955377578735,
-0.3113434910774231,
0.3468630015850067,
-0.7677659392356873,
0.007093352265655994,
0.06871284544467926,
1.342145562171936,
0.628790557384491,
-0.06687071919441223,
-0.4059610068798065,
-0.6496372818946838,
0.8204702138900757,
-0.3443622589111328,
0.4280987083911896,
0.5724020600318909,
0.5576571822166443,
-0.07742573320865631,
-0.7197481393814087,
-0.5131679177284241,
-0.3407973051071167,
0.008264817297458649,
0.17983420193195343,
-0.5084037780761719,
-0.34583020210266113,
0.19662225246429443,
0.1374700516462326,
-0.38768965005874634,
-0.32370856404304504,
-0.028235716745257378,
-0.27722325921058655,
0.42251166701316833,
-0.10401236265897751,
0.49288755655288696,
-0.1288830041885376,
-0.8514673709869385,
-0.3542792797088623,
-0.4257682263851166,
0.0026099858805537224,
0.28067803382873535,
0.14414013922214508,
-0.003575344104319811,
0.5920272469520569,
-0.04400741681456566,
0.4632139205932617,
-0.3300682008266449,
-0.16139760613441467,
-0.06771371513605118,
-0.39906659722328186,
-0.3213936388492584,
-0.15712818503379822,
0.9814540147781372,
0.27676326036453247,
0.3147527575492859,
-0.1628626435995102,
-0.07215104252099991,
0.3928503096103668,
0.1557171493768692,
-0.7821031808853149,
-0.0650465115904808,
0.2736275792121887,
-0.4282156527042389,
-0.34531307220458984,
0.11087741702795029,
-0.8487372398376465,
-0.46853774785995483,
-0.10487275570631027,
0.3143512010574341,
-0.6064345836639404,
-0.047117989510297775,
0.15905041992664337,
-0.4408104717731476,
0.18346701562404633,
0.25811567902565,
-0.6150229573249817,
0.00996997021138668,
0.5064656734466553,
0.8149400353431702,
0.03148705139756203,
-0.04483184590935707,
-0.802862823009491,
0.2507723867893219,
-0.16333219408988953,
1.298647403717041,
-0.562428891658783,
-0.1786550134420395,
-0.35552579164505005,
-0.3221922218799591,
-0.3035445809364319,
-0.4393630027770996,
1.2170010805130005,
-0.3936989903450012,
0.3509563207626343,
-0.4220399558544159,
-0.2611328959465027,
-0.322394460439682,
0.12130128592252731,
-0.8069585561752319,
0.765002965927124,
0.2929466962814331,
-1.1737688779830933,
0.5856189727783203,
-0.697806179523468,
0.02819211408495903,
0.05697375163435936,
-0.05066833645105362,
-0.5839689373970032,
-0.14001654088497162,
0.34600120782852173,
-0.2278565764427185,
-0.4454575181007385,
0.39955902099609375,
-0.4318431317806244,
0.024572828784585,
0.6806825995445251,
-0.7436083555221558,
0.9699543714523315,
0.38996854424476624,
-0.1730271428823471,
0.7556290626525879,
-0.6373685598373413,
0.3013010323047638,
-0.041850216686725616,
-0.171063631772995,
-0.5692753791809082,
0.04169456660747528,
-0.32689666748046875,
0.14868825674057007,
-0.005076160654425621,
-0.2683389186859131,
0.04306389391422272,
-0.2116304337978363,
0.33936411142349243,
0.6563923954963684,
0.07274194061756134,
0.5669451951980591,
-0.47593364119529724,
0.8893914818763733,
-0.2888766825199127,
0.2676773965358734,
-0.1606096774339676,
-0.8067606091499329,
-0.7011173367500305,
-0.6881275177001953,
0.7135493755340576,
0.9820071458816528,
-0.5040649771690369,
0.328210711479187,
-0.16342511773109436,
-0.481528639793396,
-0.48396241664886475,
0.16644242405891418,
0.42941728234291077,
0.7993304133415222,
0.49330994486808777,
-0.14908906817436218,
-0.49604395031929016,
-1.110982894897461,
-0.7351188063621521,
-0.08888962864875793,
-0.45413705706596375,
0.16083653271198273,
0.39376336336135864,
-0.5116835236549377,
1.3156511783599854,
-0.2203109711408615,
-0.4127727746963501,
-0.30283400416374207,
0.20570982992649078,
-0.1294400840997696,
0.4149872064590454,
0.32195383310317993,
-0.35511520504951477,
-0.267167329788208,
-0.14049288630485535,
-0.8062688112258911,
-0.4399103820323944,
-0.34559717774391174,
-0.6130832433700562,
0.08695326000452042,
-0.0385529063642025,
-0.8494428396224976,
0.8050171136856079,
0.2747235596179962,
-0.7152765989303589,
0.4979759454727173,
-0.30255863070487976,
-0.3685738146305084,
-0.6185646653175354,
0.19547536969184875,
0.22401009500026703,
-0.1537812054157257,
-0.21573705971240997,
0.12841808795928955,
0.17272405326366425,
0.12977415323257446,
-0.17622438073158264,
0.702815055847168,
-0.25655537843704224,
0.04328741133213043,
-0.04046132415533066,
0.3081051707267761,
0.3611023426055908,
0.055663205683231354,
0.0006764890858903527,
0.7101579308509827,
0.16616158187389374,
-0.40380412340164185,
-0.21048270165920258,
0.2909020781517029,
-0.4637715220451355,
0.35941410064697266,
-0.7245827913284302,
0.07162859290838242,
-0.07435277104377747,
0.6003410220146179,
-0.4820714294910431,
-0.22213679552078247,
0.6705394387245178,
-0.5371249914169312,
0.010565579868853092,
-0.21912752091884613,
-0.1451009064912796,
0.02639675699174404,
-0.39468106627464294,
0.24148859083652496,
0.26743465662002563,
-0.4416882395744324,
0.8052481412887573,
0.24349088966846466,
0.01925569772720337,
-0.913763165473938,
-0.6181914806365967,
-0.02681124396622181,
-0.47686487436294556,
-0.8581680655479431,
-0.0076247467659413815,
-0.056037601083517075,
-0.5656043887138367,
0.10741078108549118,
-0.4592415690422058,
-0.2603096067905426,
0.13363079726696014,
0.09086133539676666,
0.40430647134780884,
-0.20355716347694397,
-0.20988823473453522,
0.20633471012115479,
-0.6300122737884521,
0.17735996842384338,
-0.24652144312858582,
0.2276569902896881,
-0.2735227942466736,
-0.07186205685138702,
-0.7108232378959656,
0.34002718329429626,
0.5829755663871765,
-0.3233749270439148,
0.7665164470672607,
0.4665752649307251,
-0.41399332880973816,
-0.5311506390571594,
-0.1209038719534874,
0.05491625517606735,
-0.38394343852996826,
-0.12507672607898712,
-0.1586104929447174,
-0.46187496185302734,
0.6007421016693115,
0.30413198471069336,
-0.1672096848487854,
0.6017847657203674,
0.31822243332862854,
0.08810554444789886,
0.7370679974555969,
0.5873953700065613,
0.635798454284668,
0.27504366636276245,
-0.15703734755516052,
0.4518676698207855,
-0.627220869064331,
-0.4427586495876312,
-0.5771889686584473,
-0.0906163677573204,
-0.1430719643831253,
-0.6977362036705017,
-0.047034986317157745,
0.6129868626594543,
0.11328111588954926,
0.2539951503276825,
-0.6414393782615662,
0.8006247282028198,
0.5331788063049316,
-0.1858789026737213,
0.33978623151779175,
-0.04598314315080643,
-0.2265547513961792,
-0.10974236577749252,
-0.7185603380203247,
-1.055745244026184,
0.816520631313324,
0.6679480671882629,
0.5111095309257507,
0.16635869443416595,
0.4477628469467163,
0.2767530083656311,
0.8841060996055603,
-0.8806445002555847,
0.3919825255870819,
0.30178824067115784,
-0.6347123384475708,
-0.12089046090841293,
-0.4708831012248993,
-0.8031269907951355,
0.4517632722854614,
-0.3560958802700043,
-0.8758167624473572,
0.47347015142440796,
0.21521559357643127,
-0.5217314958572388,
0.12768834829330444,
-0.7947661280632019,
1.0326471328735352,
-0.14374037086963654,
-0.4882306158542633,
0.023476002737879753,
-0.6838502883911133,
0.6490286588668823,
-0.03806277737021446,
0.3241521716117859,
-0.3130914568901062,
-0.17024783790111542,
0.8766166567802429,
-0.6711170077323914,
0.5721731781959534,
-0.10404174774885178,
-0.1907302737236023,
0.5394347906112671,
0.1928650587797165,
0.07377716153860092,
0.45657724142074585,
-0.10193607956171036,
0.10986803472042084,
0.09546691924333572,
-0.2663837671279907,
-0.7565031051635742,
0.5379639267921448,
-0.49421608448028564,
-0.19919557869434357,
-0.7704724669456482,
-0.7098217010498047,
-0.29270321130752563,
0.20791125297546387,
0.3650447428226471,
0.23959140479564667,
0.029011037200689316,
0.17410703003406525,
0.7129529714584351,
-0.33032143115997314,
0.1343502700328827,
0.21591946482658386,
-0.34892261028289795,
-0.8100305199623108,
0.969804048538208,
0.024703817442059517,
0.20064420998096466,
0.19757716357707977,
0.8151146173477173,
-0.5891472101211548,
-0.2771424651145935,
-0.6818363666534424,
0.10311270505189896,
-0.8487076759338379,
-0.5117518305778503,
-0.4782952666282654,
0.0441182404756546,
0.07748669385910034,
-0.04782780259847641,
-0.11863433569669724,
-0.8697524070739746,
-0.1835719645023346,
-0.35913199186325073,
0.31549179553985596,
0.6325188875198364,
-0.14217005670070648,
0.04775208234786987,
-0.8191134929656982,
0.45122525095939636,
0.25110119581222534,
0.4001145660877228,
-0.07485637813806534,
-0.3077632784843445,
0.2212161421775818,
0.0767272412776947,
-0.4299654960632324,
-1.1334187984466553,
0.4957379996776581,
0.02369820699095726,
0.6574826836585999,
0.4627091884613037,
0.35642245411872864,
0.3515464961528778,
-0.12968342006206512,
0.5020540356636047,
0.19235685467720032,
-1.0585955381393433,
0.5903427600860596,
-0.5319168567657471,
-0.08413054794073105,
0.7560811042785645,
0.1479102224111557,
-0.0547194667160511,
-0.18621943891048431,
-0.770314633846283,
-1.1521363258361816,
0.3885112702846527,
0.308007150888443,
-0.35559749603271484,
0.05795784667134285,
0.202085942029953,
0.1792963147163391,
-0.037330735474824905,
-0.9046375155448914,
-0.18396560847759247,
-0.5119558572769165,
-0.16914746165275574,
0.4711717367172241,
-0.5218765139579773,
-0.28575247526168823,
-0.1428288221359253,
0.6222785711288452,
0.023952648043632507,
0.05809495970606804,
0.4777173399925232,
-0.08656294643878937,
0.06876160949468613,
0.646197497844696,
0.8425610065460205,
0.6830139756202698,
-0.43475183844566345,
-0.0028254950884729624,
-0.005217257887125015,
-0.3427504301071167,
-0.04875076934695244,
-0.03198498487472534,
-0.6697759628295898,
0.11577778309583664,
0.36373370885849,
0.7966391444206238,
-0.10824745893478394,
-0.8336013555526733,
0.5016044974327087,
-0.36468949913978577,
-0.3972202241420746,
-0.17765997350215912,
0.028234681114554405,
0.05747965723276138,
-0.06881663203239441,
0.11157172918319702,
0.6270087957382202,
-0.08632799983024597,
-0.4429728090763092,
0.4355555772781372,
0.3745056688785553,
-0.6601105332374573,
-0.06701049208641052,
0.8687586784362793,
-0.06935696303844452,
-0.4019375443458557,
0.34978002309799194,
-0.18240141868591309,
-0.4221966862678528,
0.41152024269104004,
0.5494739413261414,
1.099855661392212,
-0.18016885221004486,
0.31795093417167664,
0.4590781033039093,
0.4937523901462555,
0.07578583061695099,
0.2161998301744461,
-0.10892295837402344,
-0.6477611064910889,
-0.36506012082099915,
-0.6303362250328064,
-0.5715346336364746,
0.08427080512046814,
-0.7878991961479187,
0.1170196682214737,
-0.6897321939468384,
-0.1815735548734665,
-0.22867396473884583,
-0.4096882939338684,
-0.1014818325638771,
0.12324025481939316,
-0.19520555436611176,
1.3388532400131226,
-0.6693822145462036,
0.8918779492378235,
0.16189131140708923,
-0.6372678279876709,
-0.906435489654541,
0.09202022105455399,
-0.1559714674949646,
-0.33723166584968567,
0.4751923978328705,
0.35352474451065063,
-0.6375709176063538,
-0.5782297849655151,
-0.37269461154937744,
-0.6985082030296326,
0.9951635003089905,
0.608748197555542,
-0.2641219198703766,
0.14365530014038086,
-0.25310859084129333,
0.4265565872192383,
-0.31853073835372925,
0.20942316949367523,
0.5281842350959778,
0.8594279885292053,
0.033612847328186035,
-0.4786292314529419,
0.20154587924480438,
-0.31225496530532837,
-0.22303904592990875,
0.11472593992948532,
-0.19755172729492188,
0.4326561391353607,
-0.37813013792037964,
-0.5058004856109619,
0.15481700003147125,
0.7814931273460388,
0.4553597569465637,
0.6505182385444641,
0.7481139302253723,
0.7012471556663513,
1.1811704635620117,
-0.06496546417474747,
1.3222858905792236,
0.007053425535559654,
0.09618885815143585,
1.1071585416793823,
-0.22638121247291565,
1.1937999725341797,
0.39946457743644714,
0.12640714645385742,
0.8638513684272766,
0.2126445472240448,
0.25408345460891724,
0.49165934324264526,
0.23430144786834717,
-0.39047491550445557,
-0.24769069254398346,
-0.12402960658073425,
-0.2677341103553772,
0.24898548424243927,
0.628987193107605,
-0.14545392990112305,
-0.1816156655550003,
-0.35967156291007996,
0.17304398119449615,
0.3756151497364044,
0.022342057898640633,
0.42027759552001953,
0.1811773031949997,
-0.8778595328330994,
0.5785831212997437,
0.04423835128545761,
0.4594266414642334,
-0.8361197113990784,
0.14820264279842377,
-0.070452019572258,
0.4069727063179016,
-0.4514058530330658,
-0.5794815421104431,
0.7606626749038696,
0.20745038986206055,
-0.3558308780193329,
-0.3944450914859772,
0.9475857019424438,
-0.15049080550670624,
-0.358958899974823,
0.40652674436569214,
0.4754192531108856,
-0.23585651814937592,
0.0920349508523941,
-0.7312374711036682,
0.05503743141889572,
0.09920041263103485,
-0.22247657179832458,
0.29585424065589905,
0.33975377678871155,
-0.431163489818573,
1.0897431373596191,
1.0466245412826538,
-0.19097642600536346,
-0.010868820361793041,
0.11767865717411041,
0.5957419276237488,
-0.6341391205787659,
-0.38140177726745605,
-0.7456328868865967,
0.4786597192287445,
-0.0976581946015358,
-0.4045998156070709,
0.8831857442855835,
0.5194440484046936,
0.23859836161136627,
0.1293162852525711,
0.9246330857276917,
0.23363541066646576,
0.5571575164794922,
-0.4722359776496887,
0.9189295172691345,
-0.2865496277809143,
0.457955926656723,
-0.2006770521402359,
-0.7806511521339417,
-0.5031006336212158,
1.0957831144332886,
-0.18480443954467773,
-0.35531923174858093,
0.9841657876968384,
0.4876757264137268,
-0.02814009040594101,
0.27762940526008606,
-0.17136526107788086,
-0.11720340698957443,
0.33049651980400085,
0.30722981691360474,
1.0914593935012817,
-0.34197646379470825,
0.7836071252822876,
-0.17162902653217316,
-0.46321046352386475,
0.14805960655212402,
-1.4617102146148682,
-0.6508258581161499,
-0.1380465030670166,
-0.405657559633255,
-0.68804532289505,
-0.26839274168014526,
0.5265628695487976,
0.40238887071609497,
-0.6623817086219788,
0.07494773715734482,
-0.22392341494560242,
0.5995463132858276,
-0.2957315444946289,
-0.25443214178085327,
0.2255081683397293,
-0.1924009770154953,
-0.1714658886194229,
0.6913262009620667,
0.27685922384262085,
-0.10261562466621399,
-0.09745027869939804,
-0.1239611878991127,
0.010884950868785381,
0.5911554098129272,
0.4151664674282074,
0.6257268190383911,
-0.7550691366195679,
-0.3354400098323822,
-0.06945009529590607,
0.02182314172387123,
0.044329527765512466,
0.8822808861732483,
-1.011109471321106,
0.1374541074037552,
0.7892685532569885,
0.4673682153224945,
0.00822975393384695,
0.2668260633945465,
0.8284493088722229,
-0.35790738463401794,
0.08931370079517365,
0.28397566080093384,
0.43591439723968506,
0.3650705814361572,
-0.013632582500576973,
0.5871782302856445,
0.14138810336589813,
-0.48471835255622864,
-1.0876224040985107,
0.3982563018798828,
-1.4660694599151611,
-0.2627287209033966,
1.0633491277694702,
-0.13915568590164185,
-0.2949565351009369,
-0.2742792069911957,
-0.20848989486694336,
0.0799734964966774,
-0.45384907722473145,
0.47126320004463196,
0.590861976146698,
0.008262889459729195,
0.017826005816459656,
-0.8050669431686401,
0.42412883043289185,
0.4821051359176636,
-0.694645881652832,
0.347395122051239,
0.5168637037277222,
0.36587637662887573,
0.4149121046066284,
0.678947389125824,
-0.1641785353422165,
0.17201097309589386,
0.08703459799289703,
-0.3003526031970978,
-0.09782090783119202,
-0.5269336104393005,
-0.08933665603399277,
0.2982814908027649,
0.07489847391843796,
-0.0821506604552269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18668v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18668v1
|
Simple linear attention language models balance the recall-throughput tradeoff
| 2024-02-28T19:28:27 | 2024-02-28T19:28:27 |
Simran Arora, Sabri Eyuboglu, Michael Zhang, Aman Timalsina, Silas Alberti, Dylan Zinsley, James Zou, Atri Rudra, Christopher Ré
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent work has shown that attention-based language models excel at recall,
the ability to ground generations in tokens previously seen in context.
However, the efficiency of attention-based models is bottle-necked during
inference by the KV-cache's aggressive memory consumption. In this work, we
explore whether we can improve language model efficiency (e.g. by reducing
memory consumption) without compromising on recall. By applying experiments and
theory to a broad set of architectures, we identify a key tradeoff between a
model's state size and recall ability. We show that efficient alternatives to
attention (e.g. H3, Mamba, RWKV) maintain a fixed-size recurrent state, but
struggle at recall. We propose BASED a simple architecture combining linear and
sliding window attention. By varying BASED window size and linear attention
feature dimension, we can dial the state size and traverse the pareto frontier
of the recall-memory tradeoff curve, recovering the full quality of attention
on one end and the small state size of attention-alternatives on the other. We
train language models up to 1.3b parameters and show that BASED matches the
strongest sub-quadratic models (e.g. Mamba) in perplexity and outperforms them
on real-world recall-intensive tasks by 6.22 accuracy points. Implementations
of linear attention are often less efficient than optimized standard attention
implementations. To make BASED competitive, we develop IO-aware algorithms that
enable 24x higher throughput on language generation than FlashAttention-2, when
generating 1024 tokens using 1.3b parameter models. Code for this work is
provided at: https://github.com/HazyResearch/based.
|
[
-0.21937419474124908,
-0.46632322669029236,
0.6361711025238037,
0.13721628487110138,
0.05162204056978226,
-0.34734827280044556,
-0.17778056859970093,
-0.5004594326019287,
0.30569756031036377,
0.5260144472122192,
-0.34930700063705444,
-0.031422004103660583,
-0.2818275988101959,
-0.39028051495552063,
-0.35569918155670166,
0.7643613815307617,
-0.027063516899943352,
-0.40326985716819763,
-0.19286850094795227,
-0.27355334162712097,
-0.534902811050415,
-0.4411194324493408,
-0.7467789649963379,
-0.34325146675109863,
0.7281792759895325,
0.31822723150253296,
0.5310490727424622,
0.7957254648208618,
0.3342415392398834,
0.21030938625335693,
-0.20060411095619202,
-0.1437714397907257,
-1.0523422956466675,
-0.07962744683027267,
-0.19626839458942413,
-0.4804343581199646,
-0.5723346471786499,
-0.019761232659220695,
0.5369191765785217,
0.47800925374031067,
-0.21482816338539124,
0.2127648890018463,
-0.04052570462226868,
0.7254568934440613,
-0.9496216773986816,
-0.03702634200453758,
-0.9645992517471313,
0.10881446301937103,
-0.007113978732377291,
-0.07688368111848831,
-0.7037477493286133,
-0.25427883863449097,
0.27497631311416626,
-0.39250701665878296,
0.08235251158475876,
0.01537009421736002,
0.8304293751716614,
0.3118121922016144,
0.024725206196308136,
-0.1796075403690338,
-0.8252890706062317,
0.8819484710693359,
-0.7082631587982178,
0.45133697986602783,
0.3182126581668854,
0.047403305768966675,
0.17453917860984802,
-0.8299445509910583,
-0.27739787101745605,
-0.1927490383386612,
0.023906100541353226,
0.091180220246315,
-0.3640407621860504,
0.09268072992563248,
0.31970205903053284,
0.36952728033065796,
-0.48477932810783386,
-0.07950793206691742,
-0.4623311161994934,
-0.18628156185150146,
0.1042817085981369,
0.3612839877605438,
0.08179131895303726,
0.12524303793907166,
-0.4825557470321655,
0.20468971133232117,
-0.8911108374595642,
0.20233987271785736,
-0.11468919366598129,
0.15589477121829987,
0.17902056872844696,
0.3052118420600891,
-0.11400078982114792,
0.6078261733055115,
0.16417951881885529,
-0.1515812873840332,
-0.09661713987588882,
-0.30641669034957886,
-0.3045847415924072,
-0.12190190702676773,
0.3773519992828369,
0.17147107422351837,
0.22815953195095062,
-0.18908168375492096,
-0.16589903831481934,
0.1157056912779808,
0.5594266057014465,
-0.7123882174491882,
-0.22784332931041718,
0.11361834406852722,
-0.5499736666679382,
-0.07187771052122116,
-0.3777129054069519,
-0.6610124707221985,
-0.01971594989299774,
-0.14015381038188934,
0.7484232783317566,
-0.42755764722824097,
0.10102243721485138,
0.24978314340114594,
0.06368720531463623,
0.10889676213264465,
0.38365206122398376,
-1.0304594039916992,
0.48105818033218384,
0.5349462628364563,
0.7454628944396973,
-0.06970787793397903,
-0.07649872452020645,
-0.718994140625,
0.20856469869613647,
-0.12493462860584259,
0.5356040000915527,
-0.6154330372810364,
0.006258503068238497,
-0.1900729089975357,
-0.591610312461853,
-0.3266836702823639,
-0.4459817409515381,
0.10647210478782654,
-0.5650508999824524,
0.15924173593521118,
-0.44385212659835815,
-0.5446209907531738,
-0.2545643448829651,
0.09829551726579666,
-0.6915923357009888,
1.033945918083191,
-0.19908741116523743,
-0.7307252287864685,
0.2132733315229416,
-0.38392171263694763,
-0.41340363025665283,
-0.06392916291952133,
-0.00418303906917572,
-0.3361445367336273,
0.21671123802661896,
0.08020162582397461,
0.3059573471546173,
-0.31390324234962463,
-0.12050049751996994,
-0.23229697346687317,
-0.5968929529190063,
0.10160496830940247,
-0.3724856376647949,
0.4309939444065094,
0.28049537539482117,
-0.2904818058013916,
0.08275716006755829,
-0.7767096161842346,
0.005447891540825367,
0.016951492056250572,
-0.808968186378479,
-0.45359423756599426,
0.09123227745294571,
-0.09803270548582077,
0.3039311468601227,
0.4685532748699188,
-0.41247880458831787,
0.016607115045189857,
-0.45613744854927063,
0.49291643500328064,
0.6163318753242493,
-0.22923387587070465,
0.4939849078655243,
-0.11427616328001022,
0.5172379612922668,
-0.021067600697278976,
0.19677355885505676,
-0.3658311665058136,
-0.19368386268615723,
-1.229780912399292,
-0.420424222946167,
0.31132981181144714,
0.5657088160514832,
-0.5854865908622742,
-0.0126001862809062,
-0.1947624832391739,
-0.14712712168693542,
-0.7406215071678162,
0.2801556885242462,
0.7417050004005432,
0.47475549578666687,
0.05204105004668236,
-0.46380549669265747,
-0.4299066662788391,
-1.0528866052627563,
-0.04412230849266052,
0.07989312708377838,
0.18902632594108582,
0.5378873944282532,
0.08519507944583893,
0.08005868643522263,
0.8655782341957092,
-0.5568297505378723,
-0.02597256936132908,
-0.47853192687034607,
-0.011807647533714771,
0.10515477508306503,
0.22552300989627838,
0.47204864025115967,
-0.4685209095478058,
-0.5025169849395752,
-0.08143451809883118,
-0.54743492603302,
0.016319669783115387,
-0.17921048402786255,
-0.045223843306303024,
0.3297095000743866,
0.5319689512252808,
-0.6260764002799988,
0.4735386371612549,
0.2118765115737915,
-0.18313516676425934,
0.10598275810480118,
-0.365628719329834,
-0.20223921537399292,
-0.7114003896713257,
0.508987307548523,
-0.14861775934696198,
-0.4256998896598816,
-0.8362305760383606,
0.18849559128284454,
0.2864398658275604,
-0.27282872796058655,
-0.5206683874130249,
0.6152212023735046,
-0.47706514596939087,
-0.3063223361968994,
-0.4005328416824341,
0.21619479358196259,
-0.09064576029777527,
0.8781247735023499,
0.002928895875811577,
0.7599104642868042,
0.27038317918777466,
-0.683990478515625,
-0.13572119176387787,
-0.18621431291103363,
-0.17071831226348877,
0.24548324942588806,
-0.5295682549476624,
0.3190663754940033,
-0.20263013243675232,
0.017624855041503906,
-1.0810567140579224,
0.17419753968715668,
0.03850596025586128,
-0.2684822678565979,
0.38811880350112915,
0.10706446319818497,
-0.37117958068847656,
-0.40618374943733215,
-0.4346310496330261,
0.2643949091434479,
0.62784743309021,
-0.45309674739837646,
0.5187547206878662,
0.2158498466014862,
-0.2790650427341461,
-0.7545568346977234,
-0.4897315204143524,
-0.04119015112519264,
-0.22833001613616943,
-0.5080145001411438,
-0.0010711587965488434,
-0.05404280126094818,
0.06481852382421494,
-0.0027706013061106205,
-0.27728673815727234,
0.05984567850828171,
0.08990912139415741,
-0.10185117274522781,
0.16674432158470154,
-0.3714755177497864,
0.27742815017700195,
-0.3398359417915344,
-0.294513463973999,
-0.21930696070194244,
-0.5237957239151001,
0.7605299353599548,
-0.2540355920791626,
0.11638812720775604,
-0.4090178906917572,
0.2939484715461731,
0.8039787411689758,
-0.37402909994125366,
0.5700291395187378,
0.0936322808265686,
-0.3026520013809204,
-0.023393239825963974,
-0.6815005540847778,
-0.18581849336624146,
-0.41873735189437866,
0.24078018963336945,
-0.3385891020298004,
-0.8454331755638123,
0.7224017381668091,
0.2593889832496643,
0.1209467351436615,
0.25099486112594604,
0.6409603953361511,
0.031166987493634224,
0.8046117424964905,
0.591259777545929,
-0.38624417781829834,
0.5958208441734314,
-0.01028355024755001,
0.1868027299642563,
-0.7284749150276184,
0.15068818628787994,
-0.30663156509399414,
-0.5075736045837402,
-0.10716641694307327,
-0.3396308422088623,
0.2232595682144165,
-0.16508665680885315,
-0.2086111307144165,
0.5223985314369202,
-0.1994491070508957,
0.47181838750839233,
0.7991247177124023,
0.05242539569735527,
0.2578077018260956,
0.03372964635491371,
-0.21769025921821594,
-0.33967325091362,
-1.1069552898406982,
-0.22370050847530365,
1.052709937095642,
0.5430101156234741,
0.9390405416488647,
-0.10686802119016647,
0.5754916667938232,
0.006312843412160873,
0.03301528841257095,
-0.5947797894477844,
0.6170992255210876,
-0.19611433148384094,
-0.7021872401237488,
-0.21581310033798218,
-0.4138216972351074,
-0.8391570448875427,
0.41718631982803345,
-0.025450600311160088,
-1.0639076232910156,
0.26357540488243103,
0.504963219165802,
-0.6264261603355408,
0.19480718672275543,
-0.7856914401054382,
0.8588138222694397,
-0.014798619784414768,
-0.7418395280838013,
-0.5304660797119141,
-0.5663487315177917,
0.496374249458313,
0.07566169649362564,
-0.14208902418613434,
0.17941910028457642,
0.18006935715675354,
0.36076411604881287,
-0.20445895195007324,
0.8967782258987427,
0.00029619812266901135,
0.036500200629234314,
0.2525257468223572,
0.1224307268857956,
0.612101674079895,
-0.3504258096218109,
0.09572769701480865,
-0.21292585134506226,
-0.3436601161956787,
-0.4959416091442108,
-0.4760896563529968,
0.8072097897529602,
-0.397586464881897,
-0.5100134015083313,
-0.13014133274555206,
-0.7423222661018372,
-0.04722469672560692,
0.22614212334156036,
0.16414712369441986,
0.48512622714042664,
-0.17800550162792206,
0.23448744416236877,
1.2588666677474976,
-0.21288153529167175,
0.47831133008003235,
0.5674276947975159,
-0.28378015756607056,
-0.17345556616783142,
1.2973406314849854,
0.17316830158233643,
0.5787956118583679,
0.6490758061408997,
0.14016376435756683,
-0.08899778872728348,
-0.30018535256385803,
-0.17460766434669495,
0.1810714602470398,
-0.6315093040466309,
-0.033604204654693604,
-0.7377233505249023,
-0.2058044970035553,
-0.18044252693653107,
-0.19326251745224,
-0.6786917448043823,
-0.5156503915786743,
-0.18446145951747894,
0.07763106375932693,
0.23746365308761597,
0.5893971920013428,
-0.13853710889816284,
0.2316715568304062,
-0.4235919117927551,
0.36149564385414124,
0.49433043599128723,
0.3645853102207184,
0.47058963775634766,
-0.4492548704147339,
-0.44044438004493713,
-0.32881584763526917,
-0.3004133403301239,
-0.4679093360900879,
0.4041827917098999,
0.11505500972270966,
0.5826284289360046,
0.5153780579566956,
-0.29994866251945496,
0.6138741374015808,
-0.5210853815078735,
0.3365665376186371,
0.3111167550086975,
-1.0102081298828125,
0.48632562160491943,
-0.25460320711135864,
0.5887267589569092,
0.5026625990867615,
0.038529083132743835,
-0.5601018071174622,
-0.520761251449585,
-0.5948173999786377,
-0.859561562538147,
0.9731330275535583,
0.35700714588165283,
-0.09584886580705643,
0.05397169291973114,
0.3643440902233124,
-0.0021944805048406124,
0.1447826772928238,
-0.8437426090240479,
-0.17908012866973877,
0.023569494485855103,
-0.34292691946029663,
0.08922122418880463,
-0.42556607723236084,
0.22349068522453308,
-0.07249347120523453,
0.5070578455924988,
0.23815685510635376,
0.2827053964138031,
0.027859192341566086,
-0.21495936810970306,
0.012223601341247559,
0.17610929906368256,
0.7965039610862732,
0.464046835899353,
-0.48035120964050293,
0.2289450466632843,
0.06560489535331726,
-0.5924828052520752,
-0.06622938811779022,
-0.04684238135814667,
-0.6461105346679688,
-0.2296547144651413,
0.007572287227958441,
1.0169401168823242,
0.7927371263504028,
-0.6624351143836975,
0.10627966374158859,
-0.1415361911058426,
0.07137011736631393,
0.09879603981971741,
0.21940061450004578,
0.5008645057678223,
0.1944241225719452,
0.15946175158023834,
-0.020307721570134163,
0.24309414625167847,
-0.5276018977165222,
0.21093042194843292,
0.4068603217601776,
-0.4194294810295105,
-0.09120281785726547,
0.8045453429222107,
0.38115331530570984,
-0.2780632972717285,
0.4919936954975128,
0.12957456707954407,
-0.31473153829574585,
0.5512459874153137,
0.44582265615463257,
0.6545050740242004,
-0.193500816822052,
-0.18168498575687408,
0.2926134467124939,
0.40722209215164185,
-0.023479610681533813,
0.3213023543357849,
-0.15421561896800995,
-0.5229547023773193,
-0.22848157584667206,
-0.36732709407806396,
-0.11830385029315948,
0.38313257694244385,
-0.7283738851547241,
-0.10462550818920135,
-0.7239925861358643,
-0.03374883532524109,
0.08199924975633621,
0.07333219796419144,
-0.5601315498352051,
0.10237100720405579,
0.35688942670822144,
0.9042503833770752,
-0.5570826530456543,
1.0901530981063843,
0.36621350049972534,
-0.37104126811027527,
-0.41076961159706116,
-0.060307618230581284,
-0.06216049566864967,
-0.7742580771446228,
0.40167397260665894,
0.30364689230918884,
-0.27388501167297363,
0.04417707398533821,
-0.38766923546791077,
-1.098012089729309,
1.075325608253479,
0.32965371012687683,
-0.709311842918396,
0.08767490088939667,
-0.38092556595802307,
0.5280495882034302,
-0.4008682668209076,
-0.16163726150989532,
0.6925691366195679,
0.011284087784588337,
0.1782366782426834,
-0.7908939123153687,
-0.09700092673301697,
-0.05926044285297394,
0.20738151669502258,
0.49132001399993896,
-0.7528845071792603,
0.8129407167434692,
-0.3246641159057617,
-0.2620578408241272,
0.10590965300798416,
0.7825995087623596,
0.2693711221218109,
0.3088635504245758,
0.3203141987323761,
0.8661453723907471,
0.6342484354972839,
0.21642151474952698,
1.1434260606765747,
-0.05162166431546211,
0.3615294098854065,
1.2305169105529785,
-0.3411887586116791,
1.0882736444473267,
0.5889511108398438,
-0.048854175955057144,
0.19688576459884644,
0.18540045619010925,
0.3716281056404114,
0.7697255611419678,
0.06822174042463303,
-0.1327718049287796,
-0.41359302401542664,
0.19112330675125122,
-0.022266151383519173,
0.24171891808509827,
0.4735155403614044,
-0.3555919826030731,
-0.22539734840393066,
-0.07711408287286758,
0.060354083776474,
0.11435109376907349,
-0.41831621527671814,
0.6869075894355774,
0.12952809035778046,
-0.7436035871505737,
0.5025546550750732,
-0.10596198588609695,
0.5050443410873413,
-0.5963645577430725,
0.1275646835565567,
-0.4929085373878479,
0.6342177987098694,
0.365195631980896,
-0.4459100067615509,
0.05477231740951538,
-0.03172308951616287,
-0.6833096146583557,
-0.14206282794475555,
0.8047503232955933,
-0.6818966269493103,
-0.38532471656799316,
0.35701337456703186,
0.053922656923532486,
0.06867701560258865,
0.19501760601997375,
-0.5579671859741211,
0.16280187666416168,
0.2236773818731308,
-0.2859223186969757,
0.48199206590652466,
0.0904758870601654,
0.02905888855457306,
0.8426221609115601,
0.2620006799697876,
-0.007667898666113615,
0.3232381045818329,
-0.13264867663383484,
0.6989586353302002,
-0.6986089944839478,
-0.6193718910217285,
-0.6829164624214172,
0.32854318618774414,
-0.061239637434482574,
-0.21343779563903809,
0.4904227554798126,
0.5304487943649292,
0.4597988426685333,
-0.18540826439857483,
0.6210924983024597,
0.1561104953289032,
0.6529365181922913,
-0.6136492490768433,
0.5733700394630432,
-0.6501950025558472,
0.1764993965625763,
-0.06381124258041382,
-0.676802933216095,
-0.00047457506298087537,
0.6291887760162354,
-0.2658865451812744,
-0.055351000279188156,
0.4890429675579071,
0.6986753344535828,
-0.27471503615379333,
-0.35570618510246277,
0.5705773234367371,
0.4651161730289459,
0.11253353953361511,
1.279521107673645,
0.47345006465911865,
-0.4422810673713684,
0.6422209739685059,
0.10352647304534912,
-0.24478738009929657,
-0.5821559429168701,
-0.6694896221160889,
-0.8404356837272644,
-0.29540082812309265,
-0.08433784544467926,
-0.18531160056591034,
0.1866845339536667,
0.518764317035675,
0.6931570172309875,
-0.6234423518180847,
-0.24074268341064453,
-0.017059793695807457,
0.0688246563076973,
-0.1973244845867157,
-0.21315257251262665,
0.31971073150634766,
-0.42268824577331543,
-0.6015859842300415,
0.31220659613609314,
0.7808306217193604,
-0.027894750237464905,
-0.36964404582977295,
-0.06602423638105392,
-0.3781818747520447,
0.4919762909412384,
0.7587490081787109,
0.7359911203384399,
-0.9520123600959778,
-0.2621823251247406,
0.11745361238718033,
-0.44138601422309875,
0.05527081340551376,
0.8683580160140991,
-0.835665225982666,
0.6039748787879944,
0.5278601050376892,
0.6374735236167908,
0.9659507870674133,
-0.18049955368041992,
0.7800824642181396,
-0.6835883259773254,
0.3929787278175354,
-0.008183425292372704,
0.3493943512439728,
0.19214117527008057,
-0.26954102516174316,
0.28441566228866577,
0.1224275603890419,
-0.4343920648097992,
-0.5442882776260376,
0.249275803565979,
-0.936447024345398,
-0.4249979853630066,
0.9976896047592163,
-0.24774858355522156,
-0.18239353597164154,
-0.03976348787546158,
-0.28852999210357666,
-0.24627673625946045,
-0.4142087996006012,
0.8925362825393677,
0.8127959370613098,
0.041706837713718414,
-0.4456210136413574,
-0.6008402109146118,
0.3980272710323334,
0.6849499344825745,
-0.47146323323249817,
0.31461602449417114,
0.4261527359485626,
0.2656306326389313,
0.2675888240337372,
0.9186583757400513,
0.1396043598651886,
0.5440296530723572,
0.09137652069330215,
0.16712605953216553,
0.2245679795742035,
-0.6238951683044434,
-0.3951965570449829,
0.17442011833190918,
-0.05594248324632645,
-0.1378394365310669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18667v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18667v1
|
FOFO: A Benchmark to Evaluate LLMs' Format-Following Capability
| 2024-02-28T19:23:27 | 2024-02-28T19:23:27 |
Congying Xia, Chen Xing, Jiangshu Du, Xinyi Yang, Yihao Feng, Ran Xu, Wenpeng Yin, Caiming Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents FoFo, a pioneering benchmark for evaluating large
language models' (LLMs) ability to follow complex, domain-specific formats, a
crucial yet underexamined capability for their application as AI agents.
Despite LLMs' advancements, existing benchmarks fail to assess their
format-following proficiency adequately. FoFo fills this gap with a diverse
range of real-world formats and instructions, developed through an AI-Human
collaborative method. Our evaluation across both open-source (e.g., Llama 2,
WizardLM) and closed-source (e.g., GPT-4, PALM2, Gemini) LLMs highlights three
key findings: open-source models significantly lag behind closed-source ones in
format adherence; LLMs' format-following performance is independent of their
content generation quality; and LLMs' format proficiency varies across
different domains. These insights suggest the need for specialized tuning for
format-following skills and highlight FoFo's role in guiding the selection of
domain-specific AI agents. FoFo is released here at
https://github.com/SalesforceAIResearch/FoFo.
|
[
-0.15027476847171783,
-0.43248704075813293,
0.5037295818328857,
0.5523605942726135,
-0.03984532132744789,
0.10472594946622849,
-0.3827228248119354,
-0.4481876790523529,
-0.15569864213466644,
0.5651978254318237,
-0.5451045632362366,
-0.6251360774040222,
-0.6083694100379944,
0.4083673357963562,
-0.26981449127197266,
0.6446019411087036,
-0.34768909215927124,
-0.17316557466983795,
-0.5196270942687988,
-0.17222371697425842,
-0.4938620924949646,
-0.23488236963748932,
-0.3542938530445099,
-0.40681350231170654,
0.30337804555892944,
0.39474132657051086,
0.9007896184921265,
0.9134643077850342,
0.5562379956245422,
0.34631893038749695,
0.18583007156848907,
0.37668290734291077,
-0.6072669625282288,
0.12292060256004333,
0.043731603771448135,
-0.45357272028923035,
-0.8274479508399963,
0.198893740773201,
0.9307579398155212,
0.5829046964645386,
-0.15921561419963837,
-0.15123885869979858,
-0.25055450201034546,
0.7225417494773865,
-0.6161667704582214,
0.28217896819114685,
-0.6932729482650757,
0.07341781258583069,
-0.06305420398712158,
0.06714785844087601,
-0.5321491956710815,
-0.47369176149368286,
0.13222002983093262,
-1.0212950706481934,
-0.0913587436079979,
0.1843004673719406,
0.4731591045856476,
0.4682517647743225,
-0.3014281094074249,
-0.3662702143192291,
-0.7132071256637573,
0.6399371027946472,
-0.6625993847846985,
0.7437218427658081,
0.5273093581199646,
0.41916611790657043,
-0.2590101659297943,
-0.8418920040130615,
-0.5834230184555054,
-0.4495057165622711,
0.22790314257144928,
-0.16176995635032654,
-0.08217579126358032,
-0.04996481165289879,
0.1771112084388733,
0.5301219820976257,
-0.4458288252353668,
0.043522272258996964,
-0.21153013408184052,
-0.1992824822664261,
0.8742079734802246,
0.15248018503189087,
0.06679224967956543,
0.5823525190353394,
-0.5382093787193298,
-0.2214788794517517,
-0.7181216478347778,
-0.0639958381652832,
0.3626907765865326,
0.043310247361660004,
-0.21326640248298645,
0.5134899020195007,
-0.48695021867752075,
0.6200371980667114,
-0.23104798793792725,
-0.15051740407943726,
0.403460294008255,
-0.2741994857788086,
-0.33641332387924194,
-0.1418268382549286,
0.6879711151123047,
0.44799068570137024,
0.5209596753120422,
-0.4378473460674286,
-0.6165475249290466,
-0.4265317916870117,
0.32322824001312256,
-0.8358790874481201,
0.029959190636873245,
0.17580802738666534,
-0.46961724758148193,
-0.0798833891749382,
0.29106175899505615,
-0.396278440952301,
-0.4354659616947174,
-0.24067950248718262,
0.3649883568286896,
-0.5274142026901245,
-0.15782330930233002,
-0.10573360323905945,
-0.030901974067091942,
0.4002225399017334,
0.5513964891433716,
-0.8558081388473511,
0.27761009335517883,
1.1279170513153076,
0.9519156813621521,
-0.4764280915260315,
-0.7224252820014954,
-0.872664213180542,
-0.01533521618694067,
-0.43759098649024963,
0.8371574282646179,
-0.6644194722175598,
-0.3820625841617584,
0.10308431088924408,
-0.07549449056386948,
0.09031721949577332,
-0.7618588209152222,
0.31591057777404785,
-0.453105628490448,
-0.20796623826026917,
-0.017199905589222908,
-0.6403344869613647,
-0.09757789224386215,
0.2767069637775421,
-0.7508955001831055,
0.8254500031471252,
0.4321088492870331,
-0.11503834277391434,
0.32608601450920105,
-0.39973655343055725,
-0.4361683130264282,
0.02176765725016594,
-0.23892654478549957,
-0.14326930046081543,
0.05850182846188545,
-0.1965884268283844,
0.38463160395622253,
-0.5539904832839966,
0.22866764664649963,
-0.28747835755348206,
-0.6646326780319214,
0.12599900364875793,
-0.36802971363067627,
0.29354602098464966,
0.14657223224639893,
-0.14856663346290588,
0.5124913454055786,
-0.9239259362220764,
-0.12967711687088013,
0.23245662450790405,
-0.29104113578796387,
-0.21014446020126343,
0.18621321022510529,
-0.10048842430114746,
0.10998428612947464,
0.2406969517469406,
-0.4358487129211426,
0.3465052843093872,
-0.14461171627044678,
0.31743136048316956,
0.7744577527046204,
-0.444523423910141,
0.447860985994339,
-0.5031192898750305,
0.6281712055206299,
-0.4815550744533539,
0.17902147769927979,
-0.2893483340740204,
-0.4746245741844177,
-0.33305516839027405,
-0.35604503750801086,
0.2114880084991455,
0.5392330884933472,
-0.5713996887207031,
0.31452450156211853,
-0.16425691545009613,
-0.8256282210350037,
-0.525488555431366,
0.4190581440925598,
0.41187965869903564,
0.4119618535041809,
0.29404014348983765,
-0.4170599579811096,
-0.21764464676380157,
-0.6414507627487183,
-0.0855303481221199,
-0.09987201541662216,
-0.20335182547569275,
0.26917827129364014,
0.40116581320762634,
-0.4266655445098877,
0.7553678154945374,
-0.3915090560913086,
-0.2889450490474701,
0.09722796827554703,
0.039219144731760025,
-0.05033393204212189,
0.2583421468734741,
0.6585401296615601,
-0.7978814840316772,
-0.48431915044784546,
0.11266009509563446,
-0.7297824025154114,
-0.15792520344257355,
0.16219176352024078,
-0.03772510215640068,
0.45233410596847534,
0.6831464171409607,
-0.32757458090782166,
0.23064936697483063,
0.6498846411705017,
-0.3719329237937927,
0.5158441662788391,
-0.2036794126033783,
0.15236815810203552,
-0.6082600355148315,
0.2742757797241211,
-0.21803347766399384,
-0.1443900465965271,
-0.5831089615821838,
-0.011562217958271503,
-0.021244606003165245,
0.1639069765806198,
-0.5038335919380188,
0.7424324750900269,
-0.5005490779876709,
-0.4016663432121277,
-0.2119346708059311,
0.15883883833885193,
-0.0015223333612084389,
0.2090681493282318,
0.1363859474658966,
1.1041289567947388,
0.25323086977005005,
-0.318275511264801,
0.23276594281196594,
0.26936519145965576,
-0.2885858416557312,
0.3937380909919739,
-0.716331422328949,
0.41399407386779785,
0.1903359293937683,
0.07795422524213791,
-0.9779151678085327,
-0.05729914829134941,
0.04575338587164879,
-0.14291851222515106,
0.2013377845287323,
-0.11486963927745819,
-0.7895480990409851,
0.08268338441848755,
-0.47823283076286316,
0.3067114055156708,
0.3459317982196808,
-0.13798153400421143,
0.7106644511222839,
-0.01136935967952013,
-0.02866341546177864,
-0.5923410058021545,
-0.3650076389312744,
-0.22698508203029633,
0.06603678315877914,
-0.819662868976593,
0.38840219378471375,
-0.37993940711021423,
-0.4791340231895447,
-0.33146530389785767,
-0.3083427846431732,
0.14274461567401886,
0.3631492853164673,
0.29459095001220703,
0.07854678481817245,
-0.5781895518302917,
-0.29733702540397644,
0.0028107771649956703,
0.14002808928489685,
0.10414984077215195,
-0.022691447287797928,
0.5260796546936035,
-0.3081367015838623,
-0.18978151679039001,
-0.35541263222694397,
0.27728337049484253,
0.5587001442909241,
-0.42040538787841797,
0.6650177240371704,
0.35444530844688416,
-0.2056627720594406,
-0.3402261435985565,
-0.3812529444694519,
-0.03537183627486229,
-0.4948783218860626,
0.05872950330376625,
-0.3059050142765045,
-0.708369255065918,
0.49936869740486145,
-0.043766286224126816,
0.15045179426670074,
0.3627612292766571,
0.44551882147789,
0.0883713960647583,
0.5730884671211243,
0.7833907008171082,
0.015115365386009216,
0.7369651794433594,
-0.1530454158782959,
-0.31313276290893555,
-0.5588242411613464,
-0.31741559505462646,
-0.3851478099822998,
-0.06922094523906708,
-0.501745879650116,
-0.5864927768707275,
0.03976406902074814,
0.1722833514213562,
-0.15172594785690308,
0.06363731622695923,
-0.18660224974155426,
0.34060096740722656,
0.4123310148715973,
-0.4512556493282318,
0.6132321953773499,
-0.13679926097393036,
-0.06823986768722534,
0.3572714328765869,
-0.34862077236175537,
-0.6834923028945923,
1.102682113647461,
0.561938464641571,
0.6803978085517883,
0.19000248610973358,
0.4833105504512787,
0.7362374663352966,
0.8217297792434692,
-0.8093397617340088,
0.5400168299674988,
-0.274385929107666,
-0.09902170300483704,
-0.3669925630092621,
-0.14217223227024078,
-0.7996095418930054,
0.20222428441047668,
-0.1222359836101532,
-0.5611885786056519,
-0.1721499264240265,
0.005657693836838007,
-0.15304796397686005,
0.06852995604276657,
-0.5372061133384705,
0.8388134837150574,
-0.1042732447385788,
-0.1881633698940277,
0.04540345445275307,
-0.7154965400695801,
0.1103377416729927,
-0.12469083070755005,
0.014264137484133244,
-0.31910818815231323,
-0.383565753698349,
0.6604633331298828,
-0.5911617279052734,
0.556566596031189,
-0.044108059257268906,
-0.3707434833049774,
0.3603230118751526,
0.12718527019023895,
0.3043590486049652,
-0.1145959198474884,
-0.382344514131546,
0.35400986671447754,
-0.1484842151403427,
-0.1591678261756897,
-0.5300446152687073,
0.6057365536689758,
-0.9120576977729797,
-0.5576215386390686,
-0.34466397762298584,
-0.5755355358123779,
-0.4540026783943176,
0.45696598291397095,
-0.014637199230492115,
0.14783182740211487,
-0.4491509199142456,
0.34486132860183716,
0.575480043888092,
0.2793983519077301,
0.39378881454467773,
0.588236391544342,
-0.16950799524784088,
-0.6798033118247986,
0.7467904686927795,
-0.06423225998878479,
0.38704943656921387,
0.5482896566390991,
0.15044623613357544,
-0.23748362064361572,
-0.8744392395019531,
-0.5854766368865967,
0.464143842458725,
-0.6386378407478333,
-0.2597612142562866,
-0.24364416301250458,
-0.09730089455842972,
-0.4105684459209442,
-0.2465008646249771,
-0.35100236535072327,
-0.06318584829568863,
-0.3719025254249573,
0.22284795343875885,
0.3467464745044708,
0.872198760509491,
0.3217240273952484,
0.3559230864048004,
-0.8850628137588501,
0.12594148516654968,
0.021533669903874397,
0.7011847496032715,
0.04855642467737198,
-0.41062450408935547,
-0.05495639145374298,
-0.12806008756160736,
-0.39166775345802307,
-0.6903293132781982,
-0.0441271997988224,
0.21376121044158936,
0.8021858930587769,
0.48413872718811035,
-0.0044564236886799335,
0.3430039584636688,
-0.5378431677818298,
0.5566977858543396,
-0.2165101319551468,
-0.9952229261398315,
0.5575816035270691,
-0.4686325490474701,
0.10302997380495071,
0.6016729474067688,
0.535463809967041,
-0.4861114025115967,
-0.1603754758834839,
-0.29861223697662354,
-0.6984316110610962,
0.9325167536735535,
0.32392701506614685,
-0.14868129789829254,
0.08287105709314346,
0.4247673749923706,
0.4689544141292572,
0.5358863472938538,
-0.13195078074932098,
-0.2673451900482178,
-0.2974507212638855,
-0.13332641124725342,
-0.2223566621541977,
0.09563387930393219,
-0.007584114093333483,
0.2603139579296112,
0.3966034948825836,
-0.46677467226982117,
0.20432889461517334,
0.28588491678237915,
-0.21207177639007568,
-0.20697464048862457,
-0.0747666135430336,
1.0528491735458374,
0.726353645324707,
-0.5001177191734314,
-0.3161831200122833,
-0.20164531469345093,
-0.6113523840904236,
-0.05369364842772484,
0.48913514614105225,
-0.14331495761871338,
-0.26664096117019653,
0.6062543988227844,
0.670676589012146,
-0.1219664216041565,
-1.030523419380188,
0.46171873807907104,
-0.10768318176269531,
-0.26144132018089294,
-0.39390668272972107,
0.44176116585731506,
-0.08739170432090759,
0.363849401473999,
0.6318491101264954,
-0.1737634241580963,
-0.016965635120868683,
-0.8058436512947083,
0.17431767284870148,
0.2866331934928894,
-0.34030869603157043,
-0.36885714530944824,
0.6973500847816467,
0.30233994126319885,
-0.7238056063652039,
0.7190078496932983,
-0.00849528331309557,
-0.061625100672245026,
0.8118488788604736,
0.46501973271369934,
0.7661079168319702,
-0.22532695531845093,
-0.06342992931604385,
-0.2634216547012329,
0.296223521232605,
-0.2669486999511719,
0.5354763269424438,
-0.22134938836097717,
-0.6038623452186584,
-0.23993614315986633,
-0.36689597368240356,
-0.6670966148376465,
0.16040830314159393,
-0.5327810049057007,
0.2951660454273224,
-0.7831782698631287,
0.12257205694913864,
0.03893856331706047,
0.19149844348430634,
-0.6794965267181396,
0.17794513702392578,
0.30178025364875793,
1.5808197259902954,
-0.6746907234191895,
0.8273840546607971,
0.8718233704566956,
-0.415905237197876,
-0.4785572588443756,
0.2980044186115265,
0.19620266556739807,
-0.6886671781539917,
0.2519836127758026,
0.4465528130531311,
-0.36180511116981506,
-0.12254462391138077,
-0.4931463897228241,
-0.7607371807098389,
1.5869953632354736,
0.32225844264030457,
-0.5022268891334534,
0.019877294078469276,
0.13866223394870758,
0.6403018236160278,
-0.8653596043586731,
0.3063971698284149,
0.5412152409553528,
0.46430110931396484,
0.1155162900686264,
-1.0244567394256592,
0.30109062790870667,
-0.0996830090880394,
-0.009104170836508274,
0.14336661994457245,
-1.0883045196533203,
0.5803130269050598,
-0.19755768775939941,
0.12789799273014069,
0.5127813220024109,
0.9239935278892517,
0.3001024127006531,
0.8042794466018677,
0.5796366930007935,
0.043951984494924545,
0.6908016204833984,
-0.02491239830851555,
0.9596503973007202,
-0.08930964022874832,
-0.012638538144528866,
1.014083981513977,
-0.6756025552749634,
1.1183215379714966,
0.3659634590148926,
-0.04368475452065468,
0.4165146052837372,
0.2989645004272461,
-0.15454566478729248,
0.5704929232597351,
0.1877598613500595,
0.1562821865081787,
0.06191210448741913,
-0.06929365545511246,
-0.3097314238548279,
0.5580132007598877,
0.24675999581813812,
-0.33614394068717957,
0.14561188220977783,
-0.3137066066265106,
0.14761455357074738,
0.30592280626296997,
-0.20124778151512146,
0.7528972625732422,
-0.040573202073574066,
-0.8777438402175903,
0.6427441239356995,
-0.08373221009969711,
0.5237576365470886,
-0.8022520542144775,
-0.23726364970207214,
-0.5710222125053406,
0.07523676753044128,
-0.08009908348321915,
-0.9616068601608276,
0.416422039270401,
-0.08380994200706482,
-0.17475666105747223,
-0.19715896248817444,
0.35108229517936707,
-0.12384843081235886,
-0.01566675305366516,
0.5267740488052368,
0.4556501507759094,
0.0679333433508873,
-0.22440028190612793,
-0.3912860155105591,
0.5106058120727539,
-0.08243861049413681,
-0.3097813129425049,
0.31706544756889343,
0.543422281742096,
-0.4421868622303009,
0.6342955231666565,
0.5888363122940063,
-0.1843322366476059,
-0.2169768363237381,
0.081526979804039,
0.6803404092788696,
-0.62726229429245,
-0.13706286251544952,
-0.6567952036857605,
0.30115097761154175,
0.07516368478536606,
-0.5621410608291626,
0.5613572001457214,
0.574894368648529,
1.1197150945663452,
-0.02878296747803688,
0.4916972517967224,
0.11893169581890106,
-0.08007048815488815,
-0.5308747291564941,
0.7923837304115295,
-0.7613996267318726,
0.18112939596176147,
-0.2129218578338623,
-1.0050034523010254,
-0.23803837597370148,
0.31390196084976196,
-0.22763371467590332,
0.09802844375371933,
0.37557336688041687,
0.5692827105522156,
0.03336385264992714,
0.10059680789709091,
0.43520158529281616,
0.1880858987569809,
0.2060708999633789,
0.15892039239406586,
0.8452886939048767,
-0.28665614128112793,
0.6025688648223877,
-0.1790643185377121,
-0.29854676127433777,
-0.5367536544799805,
-1.1031986474990845,
-0.8594229221343994,
-0.6575856804847717,
-0.18004059791564941,
-0.13405980169773102,
0.022454144433140755,
1.0274407863616943,
0.7363839149475098,
-0.6309924125671387,
-0.1822005957365036,
0.2512214481830597,
0.2394406497478485,
-0.5372809171676636,
-0.15187065303325653,
-0.006013812031596899,
0.07510636001825333,
-0.7963968515396118,
0.592503011226654,
0.21037453413009644,
0.046093977987766266,
-0.26433467864990234,
-0.23604810237884521,
-0.09287779778242111,
0.21651308238506317,
0.7440295815467834,
0.3908012807369232,
-0.8840792775154114,
-0.15162868797779083,
0.3374621868133545,
-0.13151556253433228,
0.30473634600639343,
0.9478400349617004,
-0.5093090534210205,
0.20520879328250885,
0.5675839185714722,
0.6172866821289062,
0.20042859017848969,
0.13403184711933136,
0.7560235261917114,
-0.7035858631134033,
-0.05954296141862869,
0.18362270295619965,
0.2281915694475174,
0.4341433048248291,
-0.3720577657222748,
0.7347941994667053,
0.16136665642261505,
-0.5423277020454407,
-0.7932882905006409,
-0.06805805116891861,
-1.0189121961593628,
-0.09190092235803604,
1.2222496271133423,
-0.33416688442230225,
-0.058283668011426926,
0.11726215481758118,
-0.02265888638794422,
0.01153649017214775,
-0.8380448818206787,
0.45143967866897583,
0.5905874967575073,
-0.1881946623325348,
0.020025311037898064,
-0.6233371496200562,
0.3640314042568207,
0.10914081335067749,
-0.7361094951629639,
0.11878655105829239,
0.5130475759506226,
0.49528592824935913,
0.1575431078672409,
0.8575615882873535,
0.16422033309936523,
0.3265701234340668,
0.026826318353414536,
-0.01820039004087448,
-0.4840472638607025,
-0.6277205944061279,
-0.4172429144382477,
-0.047472741454839706,
0.3706706464290619,
-0.05608876049518585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18659v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18659v1
|
Large Language Models and Games: A Survey and Roadmap
| 2024-02-28T19:09:08 | 2024-02-28T19:09:08 |
Roberto Gallotta, Graham Todd, Marvin Zammit, Sam Earle, Antonios Liapis, Julian Togelius, Georgios N. Yannakakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Recent years have seen an explosive increase in research on large language
models (LLMs), and accompanying public engagement on the topic. While starting
as a niche area within natural language processing, LLMs have shown remarkable
potential across a broad range of applications and domains, including games.
This paper surveys the current state of the art across the various applications
of LLMs in and for games, and identifies the different roles LLMs can take
within a game. Importantly, we discuss underexplored areas and promising
directions for future uses of LLMs in games and we reconcile the potential and
limitations of LLMs within the games domain. As the first comprehensive survey
and roadmap at the intersection of LLMs and games, we are hopeful that this
paper will serve as the basis for groundbreaking research and innovation in
this exciting new field.
|
[
-0.46285703778266907,
-0.7349541783332825,
0.7837098240852356,
0.1761382669210434,
-0.04322805255651474,
0.2835671305656433,
-0.3819412291049957,
-0.6335231065750122,
0.2327030599117279,
0.7773637175559998,
-0.5392200946807861,
-0.5981751680374146,
-0.8655835390090942,
-0.0471462607383728,
-0.5431777238845825,
0.4949776530265808,
-0.054822880774736404,
0.09207475185394287,
-0.5399704575538635,
-0.027722515165805817,
-0.38885045051574707,
-0.8534408807754517,
-0.7150349617004395,
-0.4408022165298462,
0.5913983583450317,
0.15648600459098816,
0.5616173148155212,
0.5428464412689209,
0.6752098202705383,
0.39655601978302,
-0.3561142086982727,
0.056385599076747894,
-0.7358592748641968,
0.491109162569046,
-0.021784665063023567,
-0.48940929770469666,
-0.46960723400115967,
0.08588692545890808,
0.762434184551239,
0.7186474800109863,
-0.048697348684072495,
0.17793171107769012,
0.010061943903565407,
0.3776317238807678,
-0.38208284974098206,
0.24925202131271362,
-0.2794732451438904,
0.16372711956501007,
-0.4793223440647125,
-0.17092441022396088,
-0.13318988680839539,
-0.2210840880870819,
0.17452584207057953,
-0.45497438311576843,
-0.2631133794784546,
0.05976772680878639,
0.3833514451980591,
-0.1267012655735016,
-0.3867551386356354,
-0.6349217295646667,
-0.9496518969535828,
0.9216392040252686,
-0.9189394116401672,
0.4577118456363678,
0.07167650014162064,
0.20344841480255127,
-0.5829561948776245,
-0.5463976263999939,
-0.36050254106521606,
-0.15712857246398926,
0.4420836865901947,
-0.09331204742193222,
-0.46368515491485596,
0.19645725190639496,
0.26253923773765564,
0.3406691253185272,
-0.31360548734664917,
0.6929501295089722,
-0.15631191432476044,
0.12888534367084503,
0.8610442876815796,
0.530858039855957,
0.36864572763442993,
0.3078138828277588,
-0.39023062586784363,
0.4058808982372284,
-1.0651835203170776,
0.01164020411670208,
0.21182796359062195,
0.179540753364563,
-0.07206761091947556,
0.7691624164581299,
0.004844865761697292,
0.8299104571342468,
-0.20009806752204895,
-0.2683773636817932,
-0.12743689119815826,
-0.12676061689853668,
-0.10422713309526443,
-0.204930379986763,
0.9086863994598389,
0.4930989444255829,
0.1384180635213852,
-0.2524540424346924,
-0.2866954505443573,
-0.004996407777070999,
-0.13238941133022308,
-0.6549354195594788,
0.1977611482143402,
0.3066769242286682,
-0.44790908694267273,
-0.061314720660448074,
-0.21698175370693207,
-0.9870656728744507,
-0.9443052411079407,
-0.15928266942501068,
0.03378017619252205,
0.15405471622943878,
-0.511566162109375,
0.3227628171443939,
-0.08605366945266724,
0.4231579303741455,
0.17454926669597626,
-0.9766363501548767,
0.45348113775253296,
0.9565156698226929,
0.9366387128829956,
-0.36620914936065674,
-0.1536703109741211,
-0.2241509109735489,
0.24867238104343414,
-0.46773457527160645,
0.7142859697341919,
-0.5849105715751648,
-0.7031009793281555,
0.48204904794692993,
-0.1777370274066925,
0.49498450756073,
-0.662420928478241,
0.37326356768608093,
-0.5381944179534912,
0.006940104998648167,
-0.34691599011421204,
-0.8364992737770081,
0.021908124908804893,
0.7015013098716736,
-0.6981304883956909,
0.5712994337081909,
-0.2929002642631531,
-0.45809146761894226,
0.11422868072986603,
-0.8427138328552246,
-0.5177794098854065,
0.22658324241638184,
-0.14188961684703827,
-0.1523716300725937,
0.42767658829689026,
0.007203047629445791,
0.48750749230384827,
-0.7395645976066589,
0.17485493421554565,
-0.44927430152893066,
-0.4920465052127838,
0.29019850492477417,
-0.19912414252758026,
0.6133314371109009,
0.046002089977264404,
-0.07414865493774414,
0.18596620857715607,
-0.29064661264419556,
-0.10884679108858109,
0.19070829451084137,
-0.42277616262435913,
-0.20748271048069,
0.6687788963317871,
-0.06078561395406723,
0.38051050901412964,
0.3294684886932373,
-0.4184669554233551,
0.37531426548957825,
-0.31873032450675964,
0.7245426177978516,
0.4391207993030548,
-0.0543038509786129,
0.43728867173194885,
-0.07485637813806534,
0.7097461819648743,
-0.1939927041530609,
0.20844502747058868,
-0.05084073916077614,
-0.626226007938385,
-0.42554783821105957,
-0.1290978342294693,
0.3333565294742584,
0.31804707646369934,
-0.5507228970527649,
0.346049427986145,
-0.2273910939693451,
-0.5610292553901672,
-0.1699206680059433,
-0.031310904771089554,
-0.08504856377840042,
-0.10750904679298401,
-0.08827736228704453,
-0.34126031398773193,
-0.6429193615913391,
-0.5955505967140198,
-0.19202996790409088,
-0.33163246512413025,
0.12563927471637726,
0.4719657599925995,
0.23804214596748352,
-0.34591880440711975,
0.9140654802322388,
-0.3261561989784241,
-0.4398844242095947,
-0.55055832862854,
-0.0008692301926203072,
0.16679345071315765,
0.11587531864643097,
0.3693920075893402,
-0.7607994675636292,
-0.19793260097503662,
-0.2881520092487335,
-0.6751922369003296,
-0.15289406478405,
0.2776343524456024,
0.13446569442749023,
-0.22109103202819824,
0.752094566822052,
-0.7932820320129395,
0.0404987670481205,
0.9637633562088013,
-0.2365454137325287,
0.41925889253616333,
0.03236673027276993,
0.3293423652648926,
-0.8331755995750427,
-0.17066983878612518,
-0.027552569285035133,
0.05125182867050171,
-0.9011303782463074,
0.2425173819065094,
-0.375873327255249,
-0.048442013561725616,
-0.38709041476249695,
0.7198139429092407,
-0.8459472060203552,
-0.36494356393814087,
-0.5297548770904541,
0.4797589182853699,
-0.3183371126651764,
-0.15954655408859253,
0.20211493968963623,
0.5374870896339417,
0.8208160400390625,
-0.5986456274986267,
0.7125312089920044,
0.21162830293178558,
-0.5072358846664429,
0.30779632925987244,
-0.706531286239624,
-0.11073632538318634,
0.03767041489481926,
0.24556158483028412,
-0.9606192111968994,
-0.10849654674530029,
0.10432174056768417,
-0.23666109144687653,
0.07221108675003052,
-0.17494574189186096,
-0.7456524968147278,
-0.7062029838562012,
-0.16052289307117462,
0.29108139872550964,
0.6007142066955566,
-0.23917536437511444,
0.48068931698799133,
1.2323005199432373,
-0.29728665947914124,
-0.22294984757900238,
-0.6858660578727722,
0.4489455819129944,
-0.4772574007511139,
-0.5252816081047058,
0.13040313124656677,
-0.08944667130708694,
-0.44465184211730957,
-0.3180241584777832,
0.1670055240392685,
-0.16706064343452454,
0.30537527799606323,
0.2861248552799225,
0.07700540125370026,
-0.42065829038619995,
0.040531616657972336,
-0.4240284562110901,
0.0888119786977768,
0.3069756031036377,
-0.20620758831501007,
0.6948958039283752,
0.09168627858161926,
-0.33637475967407227,
0.29454660415649414,
0.4158867299556732,
0.49836811423301697,
-0.26556992530822754,
0.3489011526107788,
0.0904523953795433,
-0.5229642391204834,
0.018415099009871483,
-0.5408925414085388,
0.14412111043930054,
-0.47397732734680176,
0.7183404564857483,
-0.11075074970722198,
-1.40139901638031,
0.574169397354126,
-0.535549521446228,
0.22859111428260803,
0.25721609592437744,
0.8464249968528748,
0.0023535622749477625,
1.086261510848999,
0.8850125074386597,
-0.3050205409526825,
0.35419294238090515,
-0.02616618014872074,
0.30095937848091125,
-0.8832724094390869,
-0.17289665341377258,
-0.5626899003982544,
-0.46131691336631775,
-0.5236106514930725,
-0.6884484887123108,
0.20461814105510712,
-0.019243337213993073,
-0.05636391043663025,
0.03977837413549423,
-0.015351567417383194,
0.6911879181861877,
0.17133118212223053,
-0.4031148850917816,
0.18936099112033844,
-0.2584344744682312,
0.2665547728538513,
-0.1654990166425705,
-0.8464111089706421,
-0.508191704750061,
0.8214226365089417,
0.5161393284797668,
0.6932828426361084,
0.2547459006309509,
0.675216794013977,
0.14756892621517181,
0.3430043160915375,
-0.778632402420044,
0.8189453482627869,
-0.17751149833202362,
-0.9745903015136719,
-0.5846763253211975,
-0.4100770950317383,
-1.054463505744934,
0.25856947898864746,
-0.3199648857116699,
-0.7574795484542847,
-0.2120191752910614,
-0.0811014324426651,
-0.3760186731815338,
0.6915618777275085,
-0.40587201714515686,
0.7909837365150452,
-0.26473504304885864,
-0.3529292941093445,
-0.05439139902591705,
-0.2438308447599411,
0.6324249505996704,
0.14942960441112518,
0.48139330744743347,
-0.244334414601326,
-0.22741644084453583,
0.7593821883201599,
0.21987445652484894,
0.7071430087089539,
-0.08634592592716217,
-0.6042750477790833,
0.4311023950576782,
0.1508854180574417,
0.3303816318511963,
-0.0752246081829071,
0.05443381890654564,
0.33147019147872925,
-0.08847538381814957,
-0.15730643272399902,
-0.1579425185918808,
0.9759426116943359,
-0.5265932679176331,
-0.7366378903388977,
-0.7235760688781738,
-0.6096627712249756,
-0.724600076675415,
0.26996544003486633,
-0.1714469939470291,
0.18426354229450226,
-0.6750946044921875,
0.19322159886360168,
0.7650895118713379,
-0.4171544909477234,
0.49447402358055115,
0.5346507430076599,
-0.4847458004951477,
0.007007885724306107,
0.8539616465568542,
-0.08439766615629196,
0.1774599254131317,
0.3207380473613739,
0.12800097465515137,
-0.43099817633628845,
-1.0815573930740356,
-0.1046379953622818,
0.19481013715267181,
-0.43860870599746704,
-0.04025387018918991,
-0.27838197350502014,
-0.18955819308757782,
-0.32159367203712463,
-0.06381543725728989,
-0.3240334689617157,
0.04251454398036003,
-0.31863933801651,
0.09888854622840881,
0.09987285733222961,
1.314670443534851,
-0.08959007263183594,
0.3503519594669342,
-0.8029059767723083,
0.26533615589141846,
0.2513122260570526,
0.6406185030937195,
0.021024325862526894,
-0.18134218454360962,
-0.10499830543994904,
0.08462104946374893,
-0.0006129704997874796,
-0.7162100672721863,
0.3792501389980316,
-0.12155171483755112,
0.7228344082832336,
0.33906325697898865,
-0.4103049039840698,
0.5904872417449951,
-0.8900696039199829,
1.2255163192749023,
0.5366639494895935,
-0.6724263429641724,
0.03281811624765396,
-0.4830651879310608,
0.374980092048645,
0.13117492198944092,
0.4525178372859955,
-0.9838058352470398,
-0.2873465120792389,
-0.3771176338195801,
-0.7479051947593689,
0.6949271559715271,
-0.18162979185581207,
0.2506162226200104,
-0.017530925571918488,
-0.03751610219478607,
-0.04770911857485771,
0.3605881631374359,
-0.5420306324958801,
-0.1765517294406891,
0.6103060245513916,
-0.01241435669362545,
-0.42837169766426086,
-0.4609822928905487,
-0.21740944683551788,
0.11592555791139603,
0.4448072612285614,
0.15015307068824768,
0.3302009701728821,
-0.5002573728561401,
0.06066930294036865,
-0.31654733419418335,
0.2222127467393875,
0.5230110883712769,
0.7271540760993958,
0.14697666466236115,
0.03419336676597595,
0.17152272164821625,
-0.4014522135257721,
0.1481149047613144,
-0.0032048269640654325,
-0.2218514084815979,
-0.14060187339782715,
0.38535329699516296,
0.5195857286453247,
0.4596100151538849,
-0.8938325643539429,
0.4506377875804901,
0.0406552329659462,
-0.27391737699508667,
-0.11520863324403763,
-0.006604696623980999,
0.5629462599754333,
0.5818384289741516,
0.1628277748823166,
-0.5414842367172241,
0.10849549621343613,
-0.7728680372238159,
-0.0356764942407608,
0.7452800869941711,
-0.3677540719509125,
-0.09724210202693939,
0.5901078581809998,
0.37804314494132996,
-0.4493185579776764,
0.19779735803604126,
0.03174864500761032,
-0.4356718361377716,
0.44806286692619324,
0.470309853553772,
0.7042236924171448,
0.08787231892347336,
0.1346917450428009,
0.0429699532687664,
0.24210302531719208,
-0.1570221334695816,
0.20500031113624573,
0.4414072334766388,
-0.6300576329231262,
-0.5163645148277283,
-0.5109475255012512,
-0.530517041683197,
0.34490126371383667,
-0.10472013056278229,
0.14952601492404938,
-0.3961823582649231,
-0.3529508411884308,
-0.21111048758029938,
0.2672371566295624,
-0.3481554687023163,
-0.10321490466594696,
0.8958679437637329,
0.8663429617881775,
-0.4866172671318054,
0.44040849804878235,
0.5159775018692017,
-0.24868139624595642,
-0.21997536718845367,
-0.06908535212278366,
0.006878761574625969,
-0.5942875146865845,
0.48317858576774597,
-0.39917615056037903,
-0.09578679502010345,
-0.06927579641342163,
-0.7175191640853882,
-0.9834659695625305,
0.9369441866874695,
0.16237004101276398,
-0.8277696371078491,
-0.3367816209793091,
0.4857748746871948,
0.4703230559825897,
-0.45746901631355286,
0.12480376660823822,
0.6151372194290161,
0.35598433017730713,
0.18641287088394165,
-0.6450340747833252,
-0.3159474730491638,
0.13581034541130066,
0.1534123718738556,
0.27679628133773804,
-0.7050201296806335,
0.7003723978996277,
-0.07952488958835602,
-0.18688461184501648,
0.4555436074733734,
0.8510783910751343,
0.3324275016784668,
0.027401329949498177,
0.3271758556365967,
0.25362229347229004,
0.3294333219528198,
-0.37943676114082336,
0.821779727935791,
-0.12249834835529327,
0.2209741324186325,
0.7094523906707764,
-0.747616708278656,
0.7393249869346619,
0.41866201162338257,
-0.4215540587902069,
0.1692882925271988,
0.5641770958900452,
0.0579071007668972,
0.24229519069194794,
0.6639864444732666,
-0.20601120591163635,
-0.3006371557712555,
-0.0017373987939208746,
-0.31959250569343567,
0.34594228863716125,
0.7181604504585266,
-0.12664295732975006,
-0.6003441214561462,
-0.17279385030269623,
-0.06895896792411804,
0.05682194605469704,
-0.6339648962020874,
0.6418176293373108,
0.1933450549840927,
-0.44216838479042053,
0.03174059838056564,
0.18170246481895447,
0.878559410572052,
-0.8690133690834045,
-0.08137059956789017,
-0.11891482025384903,
0.14420777559280396,
0.18345782160758972,
-1.0810842514038086,
-0.1371181458234787,
0.15822243690490723,
0.054318733513355255,
-0.2837918996810913,
0.7680255770683289,
-0.5054474472999573,
-0.2843474745750427,
0.39693549275398254,
0.6265373229980469,
0.12545181810855865,
0.05239950865507126,
-0.7198427319526672,
0.6468459963798523,
-0.34768590331077576,
-0.2218531370162964,
0.5017508864402771,
0.6903616189956665,
0.1395544409751892,
0.638976514339447,
0.4067346453666687,
0.3919358551502228,
0.24134252965450287,
-0.019202709197998047,
0.6006723046302795,
-0.8015785217285156,
-0.40482109785079956,
-0.7375343441963196,
0.1551280915737152,
-0.05647338554263115,
-0.5726494193077087,
0.9382702112197876,
0.6541096568107605,
0.5542336106300354,
-0.03729761019349098,
0.8574979305267334,
-0.07635652273893356,
0.402505487203598,
-0.3879271447658539,
0.718360424041748,
-0.3206460773944855,
0.033307820558547974,
-0.3118671774864197,
-0.8349801301956177,
-0.3408542275428772,
0.2700384259223938,
-0.34362924098968506,
-0.014316825196146965,
0.19993120431900024,
0.4984762966632843,
0.009776282124221325,
0.15628090500831604,
0.6336100101470947,
0.257672518491745,
0.4855228066444397,
0.7384356260299683,
1.276394009590149,
-0.11039203405380249,
0.13838501274585724,
0.26139432191848755,
-0.15956127643585205,
-0.35255736112594604,
-0.8707193732261658,
-1.0529601573944092,
-0.5912664532661438,
-0.16558581590652466,
-0.12348207831382751,
0.034676678478717804,
0.8261086940765381,
0.572152316570282,
-0.6703866124153137,
-0.8237072229385376,
0.15251901745796204,
0.19021137058734894,
-0.010694121941924095,
-0.06525614857673645,
-0.19018852710723877,
0.0175824873149395,
-0.8897255659103394,
0.48187869787216187,
0.3538638651371002,
0.020120562985539436,
-0.7700018882751465,
-0.2019689828157425,
-0.40208107233047485,
0.3720567524433136,
0.994668185710907,
0.6564674973487854,
-0.7955100536346436,
-0.03509340435266495,
0.18760612607002258,
-0.2101915180683136,
-0.11195686459541321,
1.0693140029907227,
-0.4174702763557434,
0.14090044796466827,
0.4562208354473114,
0.7953320741653442,
0.35151922702789307,
-0.48886582255363464,
0.7511382102966309,
-0.31121233105659485,
-0.002915552817285061,
0.4920315444469452,
0.33180519938468933,
0.4024663269519806,
0.10150402039289474,
0.3948594927787781,
-0.029260512441396713,
-0.3351978659629822,
-1.0134899616241455,
0.3199479877948761,
-0.7747918963432312,
-0.14099642634391785,
1.4571069478988647,
0.10402384400367737,
-0.1941850334405899,
0.07311620563268661,
-0.05802574008703232,
0.012005375698208809,
0.05447932705283165,
0.5103364586830139,
1.2063565254211426,
-0.07299947738647461,
-0.06542667746543884,
-0.5484955310821533,
0.45436152815818787,
-0.22869069874286652,
-0.7751294374465942,
0.3710271716117859,
0.6671496629714966,
-0.061512213200330734,
0.05789914354681969,
0.6527774333953857,
-0.2920539379119873,
-0.03639249876141548,
-0.1518028974533081,
0.05677487328648567,
0.08315850049257278,
-0.31200987100601196,
-0.3861905634403229,
0.23623643815517426,
0.36801156401634216,
0.10341653972864151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18571v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18571v3
|
Arithmetic Control of LLMs for Diverse User Preferences: Directional Preference Alignment with Multi-Objective Rewards
| 2024-02-28T18:58:25 | 2024-03-06T08:07:02 |
Haoxiang Wang, Yong Lin, Wei Xiong, Rui Yang, Shizhe Diao, Shuang Qiu, Han Zhao, Tong Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Fine-grained control over large language models (LLMs) remains a significant
challenge, hindering their adaptability to diverse user needs. While
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) shows promise in aligning
LLMs, its reliance on scalar rewards often limits its ability to capture
diverse user preferences in real-world applications. To address this
limitation, we introduce the Directional Preference Alignment (DPA) framework.
Unlike the scalar-reward RLHF, DPA incorporates multi-objective reward modeling
to represent diverse preference profiles. Additionally, DPA models user
preferences as directions (i.e., unit vectors) in the reward space to achieve
user-dependent preference control. Our method involves training a
multi-objective reward model and then fine-tuning the LLM with a
preference-conditioned variant of Rejection Sampling Finetuning (RSF), an RLHF
method adopted by Llama 2. This method enjoys a better performance trade-off
across various reward objectives. In comparison with the scalar-reward RLHF,
DPA offers users intuitive control over LLM generation: they can arithmetically
specify their desired trade-offs (e.g., more helpfulness with less verbosity).
We also validate the effectiveness of DPA with real-world alignment experiments
on Mistral-7B. Our method provides straightforward arithmetic control over the
trade-off between helpfulness and verbosity while maintaining competitive
performance with strong baselines such as Direct Preference Optimization (DPO).
|
[
-0.44407421350479126,
-0.5061163902282715,
0.5042411088943481,
0.3094812035560608,
-0.10687193274497986,
0.15560373663902283,
-0.2592938542366028,
-0.2345106303691864,
0.25558602809906006,
0.3445334732532501,
-0.6891573667526245,
-0.40432432293891907,
-0.6922640800476074,
0.18464425206184387,
0.2511923313140869,
0.8486647009849548,
-0.15153296291828156,
0.048721086233854294,
-0.22813251614570618,
-0.37380099296569824,
-0.5218137502670288,
-0.6162484884262085,
-0.5731569528579712,
-0.48888111114501953,
0.9415653944015503,
0.8080954551696777,
0.7506168484687805,
0.6518909931182861,
0.6163690090179443,
0.3367752730846405,
-0.05411411449313164,
0.4309157133102417,
-0.6326454281806946,
0.004746092017740011,
-0.1514255702495575,
-0.5089499354362488,
-0.5124515295028687,
-0.11000733822584152,
0.47818395495414734,
0.42021888494491577,
-0.588592529296875,
-0.009378548711538315,
-0.14236249029636383,
1.0751248598098755,
-0.6564354300498962,
0.05530061572790146,
-0.5845926403999329,
0.08271197974681854,
-0.14566713571548462,
-0.32317042350769043,
-0.2786387503147125,
-0.573853075504303,
-0.1259467601776123,
-0.6815564632415771,
-0.3694446086883545,
-0.0036969140637665987,
0.5934495329856873,
0.5619167685508728,
-0.5084711313247681,
-0.41839399933815,
-0.6353074312210083,
0.9339011311531067,
-0.655345618724823,
0.45479944348335266,
0.32709747552871704,
0.3036889135837555,
-0.25933390855789185,
-0.2010205090045929,
-0.5850130915641785,
-0.18106630444526672,
0.046830497682094574,
-0.02060592733323574,
0.00572942616418004,
0.138096883893013,
0.09237866848707199,
0.0788995698094368,
-0.37678584456443787,
0.4695030152797699,
-0.3431006968021393,
-0.1724432110786438,
0.6025534272193909,
0.35275715589523315,
0.1178697943687439,
0.028810057789087296,
-0.4847092926502228,
-0.20514532923698425,
-0.8867796063423157,
0.5084770321846008,
0.5139272212982178,
0.3253731429576874,
-0.09885790199041367,
0.7727746963500977,
-0.4696745276451111,
0.7674010992050171,
0.6045807600021362,
-0.570760190486908,
0.320180743932724,
-0.03804391622543335,
-0.018688909709453583,
0.198174849152565,
0.7645198106765747,
0.4355067014694214,
0.2209262102842331,
0.013532551936805248,
-0.44040966033935547,
0.1406889408826828,
0.20789870619773865,
-0.8669348955154419,
0.16151952743530273,
0.13608494400978088,
-0.27990394830703735,
-0.43964508175849915,
-0.13803768157958984,
-0.5463095903396606,
-0.45246919989585876,
-0.7867267727851868,
0.29974815249443054,
-0.23675738275051117,
-0.016465676948428154,
0.23829738795757294,
0.13701292872428894,
0.21169281005859375,
0.3559596836566925,
-1.5487267971038818,
0.27488529682159424,
0.8965966105461121,
0.6359914541244507,
-0.355215847492218,
-0.43210312724113464,
-0.8641387224197388,
-0.009205876849591732,
-0.12759004533290863,
0.6431031823158264,
-0.6645316481590271,
-0.2742674946784973,
-0.12419309467077255,
-0.4663269519805908,
0.04236386716365814,
-0.6206856966018677,
0.4746743142604828,
-0.6976814866065979,
0.14972412586212158,
-0.45969417691230774,
-0.3134307265281677,
-0.14379265904426575,
0.30223914980888367,
-0.4368197023868561,
0.7940265536308289,
0.00047881988575682044,
-0.5086712837219238,
0.40070629119873047,
-0.2620469331741333,
-0.20556791126728058,
-0.2680157721042633,
-0.37294670939445496,
-0.39109185338020325,
0.21642982959747314,
0.26734644174575806,
0.26097455620765686,
0.031531862914562225,
0.3636758327484131,
-0.5153403878211975,
-0.32064804434776306,
0.3943536579608917,
-0.34808358550071716,
0.44601625204086304,
0.231242373585701,
-0.3730565905570984,
0.476485013961792,
-0.7946252226829529,
-0.1596093624830246,
-0.10853218287229538,
-0.5701121687889099,
-0.31047338247299194,
0.12291654944419861,
-0.29659557342529297,
0.40597274899482727,
0.37130680680274963,
-0.40001899003982544,
0.42368462681770325,
-0.2940518856048584,
0.23318128287792206,
1.1222941875457764,
-0.3272179663181305,
0.6091715693473816,
-0.4206605553627014,
0.5253800749778748,
0.03598460555076599,
0.06097661331295967,
0.3595554530620575,
-0.17293167114257812,
-0.6495446562767029,
-0.46655476093292236,
0.11713801324367523,
0.4966323673725128,
-0.6433480978012085,
0.521986186504364,
-0.2278430312871933,
-0.14412572979927063,
-0.4544139802455902,
0.3833736479282379,
0.36971279978752136,
0.5756227970123291,
0.2732534408569336,
-0.31822311878204346,
-0.21604523062705994,
-0.9156349301338196,
0.047045864164829254,
-0.19482733309268951,
0.011454753577709198,
0.531438410282135,
-0.11883580684661865,
-0.18417194485664368,
0.8883440494537354,
-0.5393471121788025,
-0.466562420129776,
-0.24213963747024536,
0.18228186666965485,
0.12959960103034973,
0.24354124069213867,
0.42109444737434387,
-0.7608146071434021,
-0.4359045922756195,
0.0013610584428533912,
-0.3671484589576721,
-0.3808937072753906,
-0.11678818613290787,
-0.24227946996688843,
0.2262316346168518,
0.032251156866550446,
-0.5544179677963257,
0.037735436111688614,
0.7278299331665039,
-0.4462698698043823,
0.3701171278953552,
-0.12167929112911224,
0.20308344066143036,
-0.6725342869758606,
-0.0952061340212822,
0.05075393244624138,
-0.34709885716438293,
-0.4523647427558899,
-0.12278033047914505,
0.22773675620555878,
0.29511332511901855,
-0.5778793096542358,
0.48585060238838196,
-0.1002376526594162,
-0.08339009433984756,
-0.42208629846572876,
-0.05069189518690109,
-0.06829972565174103,
0.9202129244804382,
0.25329577922821045,
0.7995657324790955,
0.17354753613471985,
-0.6469348669052124,
0.26455944776535034,
0.25650861859321594,
0.1063053160905838,
0.8000814914703369,
-0.6287181973457336,
0.014020122587680817,
-0.18374980986118317,
0.2048777937889099,
-0.7682153582572937,
0.007746533956378698,
0.464287668466568,
-0.3591223657131195,
0.3514021039009094,
-0.0045392150059342384,
-0.029413066804409027,
0.16128259897232056,
-0.5294067859649658,
0.4393220543861389,
0.41297852993011475,
-0.7426071166992188,
0.6100475192070007,
0.3789004981517792,
-0.3687015175819397,
-0.8736807703971863,
-0.2792356014251709,
-0.21486619114875793,
-0.44271349906921387,
-0.35889652371406555,
0.347013920545578,
-0.2118297964334488,
-0.3119042217731476,
-0.3571386933326721,
-0.21569837629795074,
0.2593846619129181,
0.11197874695062637,
0.37898361682891846,
0.3929367661476135,
0.09847745299339294,
-0.03189786151051521,
0.2239239364862442,
-0.2977803349494934,
-0.05162807181477547,
-0.22012959420681,
0.4932175874710083,
-0.2083023190498352,
-0.47719213366508484,
-0.38269755244255066,
0.04431799799203873,
0.3935104310512543,
-0.31463149189949036,
0.36676225066185,
0.5552834868431091,
0.041940465569496155,
-0.052177783101797104,
-0.5402768850326538,
-0.19686764478683472,
-0.5340038537979126,
0.3120793104171753,
-0.42500782012939453,
-0.9285419583320618,
0.24487200379371643,
0.1362384706735611,
0.19624583423137665,
0.30113136768341064,
0.8127821683883667,
0.012159988284111023,
1.1475579738616943,
0.5365107655525208,
-0.246186763048172,
0.6602376699447632,
0.05903136357665062,
-0.16072332859039307,
-0.7127045392990112,
-0.24977348744869232,
-0.47124937176704407,
-0.6868891716003418,
-0.5267276167869568,
-0.20497368276119232,
0.28030678629875183,
0.11565589159727097,
-0.46739840507507324,
-0.058722879737615585,
-0.49190255999565125,
0.5043102502822876,
0.5855132341384888,
0.18636685609817505,
0.37225738167762756,
0.13162176311016083,
-0.027202090248465538,
-0.14949986338615417,
-0.4796483516693115,
-0.3976099193096161,
0.9824215173721313,
0.43556687235832214,
1.1395143270492554,
0.33853867650032043,
0.9414304494857788,
0.1913749873638153,
0.2752629220485687,
-0.8826979398727417,
0.3594117760658264,
-0.21470171213150024,
-0.050568439066410065,
-0.4524144232273102,
-0.6416898965835571,
-0.6423336863517761,
0.39440611004829407,
-0.12351121008396149,
-0.5717385411262512,
0.41904327273368835,
0.44356197118759155,
-0.4676315188407898,
0.11474667489528656,
-0.49743327498435974,
0.5260968804359436,
-0.6587320566177368,
-0.48957568407058716,
-0.3681480586528778,
-0.5950244665145874,
0.32264336943626404,
0.15447930991649628,
0.08854449540376663,
-0.4073411524295807,
-0.13579732179641724,
0.462995707988739,
-0.20166544616222382,
0.8885847926139832,
-0.2628600299358368,
-0.2564391493797302,
-0.15288490056991577,
0.10141558200120926,
0.6846274733543396,
0.2031897008419037,
-0.06234071031212807,
0.23509624600410461,
-0.22869972884655,
-0.246159166097641,
-0.471983939409256,
0.9299309849739075,
-1.0452766418457031,
-0.6454359292984009,
-0.5104597806930542,
-0.5962059497833252,
-0.3300603926181793,
0.2372048795223236,
-0.1048394963145256,
0.36108866333961487,
-0.04881332814693451,
-0.09662137925624847,
0.7190258502960205,
-0.05730501934885979,
0.24240808188915253,
0.6016309261322021,
-0.3840486407279968,
-0.6929698586463928,
1.0807404518127441,
-0.24394875764846802,
0.39321067929267883,
0.7864596247673035,
0.4162490963935852,
-0.568252444267273,
-0.5200900435447693,
-0.86751389503479,
0.12251311540603638,
-0.5648890733718872,
-0.1886945217847824,
-0.32607269287109375,
0.19980841875076294,
-0.15085740387439728,
-0.2621142864227295,
-0.36967337131500244,
-0.5647531747817993,
-0.4491559565067291,
-0.08775056153535843,
0.22446632385253906,
0.7498390674591064,
-0.11543334275484085,
0.17251725494861603,
-0.6575100421905518,
0.540665864944458,
0.4795944392681122,
0.5007506012916565,
-0.15807388722896576,
-0.5454211831092834,
-0.015140551142394543,
0.15787020325660706,
-0.47869807481765747,
-0.6611917614936829,
0.43346986174583435,
0.017566127702593803,
0.36035653948783875,
0.44764676690101624,
-0.08003497123718262,
0.6202471852302551,
-0.4927869141101837,
0.4075145423412323,
0.5042335987091064,
-0.7760156393051147,
0.04522686451673508,
-0.15863363444805145,
0.22856560349464417,
0.7595090270042419,
0.3249073922634125,
-0.5106335878372192,
-0.08091799169778824,
-0.11703173816204071,
-0.6535657048225403,
0.8614295125007629,
-0.23707640171051025,
-0.07176889479160309,
0.28815117478370667,
0.33652645349502563,
0.22134575247764587,
0.22707615792751312,
-0.7715421915054321,
-0.33635810017585754,
-0.30802667140960693,
-0.48952046036720276,
-0.14108946919441223,
-0.30115002393722534,
-0.4200786352157593,
0.00800548680126667,
0.5580363869667053,
-0.34413304924964905,
-0.1712615191936493,
0.028620079159736633,
-0.03476812317967415,
-0.30304741859436035,
0.3484137952327728,
0.8782697319984436,
0.7212715744972229,
-0.3013422191143036,
0.20309330523014069,
-0.003981732297688723,
-0.27869755029678345,
0.5322481989860535,
0.1275724470615387,
-0.28072288632392883,
-0.4460138976573944,
-0.1281035840511322,
0.9963605403900146,
0.242102712392807,
-0.5587126612663269,
0.30605387687683105,
-0.2103346586227417,
-0.2697199583053589,
0.04960783198475838,
0.2808569073677063,
0.1703246533870697,
0.16962754726409912,
0.14012885093688965,
0.06499651819467545,
0.11797749996185303,
-0.1364319920539856,
-0.13778482377529144,
0.6185941100120544,
-0.49481382966041565,
-0.2922554910182953,
0.4978967308998108,
0.29846516251564026,
-0.1920321136713028,
0.42795124650001526,
-0.2047150731086731,
-0.355333149433136,
0.47801315784454346,
0.4290415346622467,
0.7868561148643494,
-0.010663232766091824,
0.26158565282821655,
0.15584339201450348,
0.10057473927736282,
-0.04390003904700279,
0.21729040145874023,
-0.1730160415172577,
-0.7866163849830627,
-0.28842100501060486,
-0.7350682020187378,
-0.6291376948356628,
-0.28120431303977966,
-0.5663653612136841,
0.19945935904979706,
-0.406391978263855,
-0.04755152761936188,
0.09654249995946884,
-0.055450960993766785,
-0.4803052544593811,
-0.0768338143825531,
0.399554580450058,
0.6247388124465942,
-0.6229753494262695,
0.8797225952148438,
0.6303926110267639,
-0.38983219861984253,
-0.7762553095817566,
-0.18197490274906158,
0.31482115387916565,
-0.9493051171302795,
0.7368891835212708,
0.12005733698606491,
-0.4591990113258362,
-0.06926212459802628,
-0.20777668058872223,
-0.8276368975639343,
1.136818289756775,
0.28843966126441956,
-0.8771344423294067,
0.14729520678520203,
0.32989370822906494,
0.40516945719718933,
-0.30137577652931213,
0.21022191643714905,
0.5771194696426392,
0.5397995114326477,
0.3317989706993103,
-0.7440778613090515,
0.005089078564196825,
0.11696149408817291,
-0.03431575372815132,
0.4014360010623932,
-0.8520092964172363,
0.5469975471496582,
-0.3680688440799713,
0.01744004525244236,
-0.11859121918678284,
0.6454803347587585,
0.7233513593673706,
0.3044644296169281,
0.663851261138916,
0.7642704248428345,
0.5874767899513245,
0.031817175447940826,
0.8073387145996094,
-0.20957531034946442,
0.14896012842655182,
0.9595843553543091,
-0.4564869999885559,
0.8564333319664001,
0.8328375220298767,
-0.3024502992630005,
0.44586774706840515,
0.6323887705802917,
0.545352578163147,
0.6655316352844238,
0.18131855130195618,
-0.19933117926120758,
-0.17321114242076874,
-0.03363465517759323,
-0.26627880334854126,
0.2946576476097107,
0.18530753254890442,
0.16658832132816315,
0.02328619360923767,
-0.31944066286087036,
-0.07998798787593842,
0.13635027408599854,
-0.3566552400588989,
1.0556228160858154,
0.0516720749437809,
-0.9590949416160583,
0.6911258697509766,
0.21653223037719727,
0.9713058471679688,
-0.9007922410964966,
-0.0042457361705601215,
-0.46358445286750793,
0.4136389493942261,
-0.3459808826446533,
-0.6629979014396667,
0.046246808022260666,
-0.05516829714179039,
-0.2713422477245331,
-0.15162311494350433,
0.4761750400066376,
-0.752679169178009,
-0.3806612193584442,
0.04917113482952118,
0.1866755187511444,
-0.3958367705345154,
0.12441641092300415,
-0.669378399848938,
0.14202459156513214,
0.2419603317975998,
-0.31129515171051025,
0.6626812219619751,
0.30763450264930725,
-0.16702884435653687,
0.6536464691162109,
0.7387648224830627,
0.19934456050395966,
0.02816179022192955,
0.11600639671087265,
0.8298779726028442,
-0.655451774597168,
-0.5263156294822693,
-0.9451096653938293,
0.21493177115917206,
0.2427690476179123,
-0.34941986203193665,
0.5540986657142639,
0.3152952790260315,
0.7979833483695984,
0.034352660179138184,
0.5665967464447021,
0.12041638046503067,
0.212676003575325,
-0.6187870502471924,
0.2241964340209961,
-0.5928896069526672,
0.36927831172943115,
0.09024660289287567,
-0.7994584441184998,
-0.2355850338935852,
0.47987547516822815,
-0.13967809081077576,
-0.14215226471424103,
0.3011193871498108,
0.8542535305023193,
-0.17692255973815918,
-0.3257239758968353,
0.16622762382030487,
-0.18422169983386993,
0.4806329011917114,
0.6934806108474731,
0.8961724042892456,
0.36650487780570984,
0.38433998823165894,
-0.4829102158546448,
-0.5008520483970642,
-0.264996200799942,
-0.9567301273345947,
-0.48370328545570374,
-0.053557515144348145,
-0.008236105553805828,
-0.14104774594306946,
-0.040624137967824936,
1.3708440065383911,
0.6226208806037903,
-0.9376529455184937,
-0.5069693922996521,
-0.026307065039873123,
0.4410105347633362,
-0.3643834888935089,
-0.1607804000377655,
0.21421901881694794,
-0.5610209107398987,
-0.8492959141731262,
0.2960219383239746,
0.534997284412384,
-0.09407185018062592,
-0.47497814893722534,
-0.7185836434364319,
-0.0015135797439143062,
0.0262858085334301,
0.489279180765152,
0.5202748775482178,
-0.8338479399681091,
-0.11813446879386902,
0.0441787987947464,
-0.3742161989212036,
0.24037757515907288,
0.8386310338973999,
-0.6090852618217468,
0.4158276617527008,
0.6085227131843567,
0.7862488627433777,
0.2793079912662506,
0.34063419699668884,
0.6158673763275146,
-0.5573854446411133,
0.13226138055324554,
0.0010525926481932402,
0.3124801814556122,
0.20672565698623657,
-0.44042328000068665,
0.20663122832775116,
-0.12256132066249847,
-0.800615131855011,
-0.45554789900779724,
0.28631892800331116,
-1.141823172569275,
-0.05573219433426857,
1.4019451141357422,
0.05548015609383583,
0.027160873636603355,
0.24621908366680145,
-0.5222248435020447,
-0.1091657355427742,
-0.8108473420143127,
1.0329725742340088,
0.4664962887763977,
-0.3068063259124756,
0.14452911913394928,
0.018594985827803612,
0.6310256123542786,
0.6982346177101135,
-0.7084947824478149,
0.03947680443525314,
0.8870484232902527,
0.19748486578464508,
-0.10758063197135925,
0.7955169081687927,
-0.009006435051560402,
0.31695556640625,
-0.6033452749252319,
0.2735157310962677,
-0.3854317367076874,
-0.4672429859638214,
-0.6911842226982117,
0.10504157096147537,
0.5519565939903259,
-0.22283490002155304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18563v1
|
Approaching Human-Level Forecasting with Language Models
| 2024-02-28T18:54:18 | 2024-02-28T18:54:18 |
Danny Halawi, Fred Zhang, Chen Yueh-Han, Jacob Steinhardt
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Forecasting future events is important for policy and decision making. In
this work, we study whether language models (LMs) can forecast at the level of
competitive human forecasters. Towards this goal, we develop a
retrieval-augmented LM system designed to automatically search for relevant
information, generate forecasts, and aggregate predictions. To facilitate our
study, we collect a large dataset of questions from competitive forecasting
platforms. Under a test set published after the knowledge cut-offs of our LMs,
we evaluate the end-to-end performance of our system against the aggregates of
human forecasts. On average, the system nears the crowd aggregate of
competitive forecasters, and in some settings surpasses it. Our work suggests
that using LMs to forecast the future could provide accurate predictions at
scale and help to inform institutional decision making.
|
[
-0.2980539798736572,
-0.39882218837738037,
0.5002648830413818,
0.022411158308386803,
0.1446165293455124,
0.3132701814174652,
-0.22062940895557404,
-0.9362351894378662,
0.22755765914916992,
0.5428366661071777,
-0.4033336043357849,
-0.19486932456493378,
-0.32396647334098816,
-0.07815837115049362,
-0.749943733215332,
0.42452844977378845,
0.3075675666332245,
0.06176958605647087,
-0.23143625259399414,
0.34005188941955566,
-0.5292797088623047,
-0.8517765998840332,
-0.9068211913108826,
-0.6122609376907349,
0.4838804304599762,
0.37424057722091675,
0.9870269894599915,
0.6117483973503113,
0.26445654034614563,
0.3344312310218811,
-0.21116076409816742,
0.009614492766559124,
-0.3950433135032654,
0.3737189471721649,
-0.23934373259544373,
-0.41563087701797485,
-0.46339377760887146,
0.192590594291687,
0.7004181742668152,
0.7921860218048096,
-0.4564618170261383,
0.1501474529504776,
0.00839011650532484,
0.5291619300842285,
-0.5207293629646301,
0.31362661719322205,
-0.861734926700592,
0.061002250760793686,
-0.13246870040893555,
-0.02218915894627571,
-0.5017808079719543,
-0.1584520787000656,
0.5631843209266663,
-0.3080972731113434,
0.10787796229124069,
0.5736863613128662,
0.7318586707115173,
-0.1463594138622284,
-0.23700504004955292,
-0.08555001765489578,
-0.6372557878494263,
0.8474828600883484,
-0.6503946185112,
0.6654091477394104,
0.5866844058036804,
0.606484055519104,
-0.3047184646129608,
-0.7327757477760315,
-0.35853391885757446,
-0.11944327503442764,
0.05507587641477585,
0.14558736979961395,
-0.12853281199932098,
-0.16252034902572632,
-0.17903755605220795,
-0.05412650853395462,
-0.5718625783920288,
0.17283087968826294,
-0.3562818765640259,
0.03528541699051857,
0.7623510956764221,
0.5118438005447388,
0.34155330061912537,
-0.1150297224521637,
-0.24068109691143036,
0.0404883436858654,
-0.6071211695671082,
-0.05616919696331024,
0.10996967554092407,
0.5639051198959351,
0.13834722340106964,
0.3087349534034729,
-0.30637821555137634,
0.7403104901313782,
-0.13030630350112915,
-0.03694296255707741,
-0.10615284740924835,
-0.0730423554778099,
-0.10361573845148087,
-0.02820230834186077,
0.628410279750824,
0.5436671376228333,
0.44481658935546875,
-0.42015084624290466,
-0.5208466053009033,
-0.14140591025352478,
0.09403907507658005,
-0.5555320382118225,
-0.17717227339744568,
0.17876316606998444,
-0.3465862572193146,
-0.4040932357311249,
-0.1740652322769165,
-1.016717553138733,
-0.6725108027458191,
-0.3550184369087219,
0.44747984409332275,
-0.011842072941362858,
-0.20696139335632324,
0.21273133158683777,
-0.1965072602033615,
-0.09401025623083115,
0.1847754269838333,
-0.9229647517204285,
0.4853758215904236,
0.5282618999481201,
0.675420343875885,
-0.12519925832748413,
-0.307395339012146,
-0.5524013042449951,
0.08664221316576004,
-0.5720359683036804,
0.9368374347686768,
-0.6093739867210388,
-0.5985127687454224,
0.21773692965507507,
-0.20559559762477875,
0.1107349693775177,
-0.8120599389076233,
0.3457757234573364,
-0.8277795910835266,
0.3412911593914032,
-0.09697936475276947,
-0.43003350496292114,
0.2082749456167221,
0.18167641758918762,
-0.6522234678268433,
0.7966328859329224,
-0.11986410617828369,
-0.34311822056770325,
0.5618349313735962,
-0.4545880854129791,
-0.3080926239490509,
0.22790083289146423,
-0.12786351144313812,
-0.19088837504386902,
-0.17007753252983093,
0.431780606508255,
0.5015695095062256,
-0.39601725339889526,
0.5483744740486145,
-0.31691300868988037,
-0.1584886759519577,
0.2818293869495392,
-0.3174799680709839,
0.22020137310028076,
0.26708900928497314,
0.004406458232551813,
0.014843965880572796,
-0.5129464864730835,
-0.026730548590421677,
0.11612767726182938,
-0.4340207874774933,
-0.19160833954811096,
0.7754613161087036,
0.016031086444854736,
0.40976858139038086,
0.4658261835575104,
-0.4275248944759369,
0.13867463171482086,
-0.49274709820747375,
0.26154428720474243,
0.9733271598815918,
-0.2331567108631134,
0.870359480381012,
-0.3910141885280609,
0.8129310011863708,
-0.17628701031208038,
0.2516837418079376,
-0.06860993802547455,
-0.6006008386611938,
-0.535986065864563,
0.29676327109336853,
0.19166482985019684,
0.5781070590019226,
-0.6841965913772583,
0.06971371173858643,
-0.32593995332717896,
-0.5477414131164551,
-0.21956923604011536,
-0.21357515454292297,
0.07265783101320267,
0.4254586398601532,
0.21610470116138458,
0.24402818083763123,
-0.8660976886749268,
-0.4699498414993286,
-0.7502201795578003,
-0.3373943567276001,
0.034532979130744934,
0.4224165976047516,
0.17386560142040253,
-0.1352708488702774,
1.1177276372909546,
-0.4789911210536957,
-0.1485872119665146,
-0.4200829863548279,
0.18781280517578125,
0.3376255929470062,
0.02192925661802292,
0.3311287462711334,
-0.8169296383857727,
-0.4103246331214905,
-0.08919360488653183,
-0.5267683267593384,
-0.05521950498223305,
0.15034355223178864,
0.043072547763586044,
0.2170032262802124,
0.30920860171318054,
-0.04166578873991966,
0.07882258296012878,
0.7384538650512695,
-0.6467524766921997,
0.5666722655296326,
-0.183478444814682,
-0.1781550794839859,
-0.9820733666419983,
-0.2124495655298233,
0.20783640444278717,
-0.42981863021850586,
-0.6582276225090027,
-0.245267853140831,
-0.13508297502994537,
-0.3201281726360321,
-0.24113918840885162,
1.152440071105957,
-0.4398204982280731,
-0.39402031898498535,
-0.18117016553878784,
0.3200010061264038,
-0.16900314390659332,
-0.13617464900016785,
0.4090435802936554,
0.9610264301300049,
0.37817999720573425,
-0.5187116861343384,
0.08705555647611618,
-0.13816794753074646,
-0.8439483642578125,
0.07669578492641449,
-0.5737894773483276,
-0.1516694873571396,
-0.06454197317361832,
0.1859622746706009,
-0.36553484201431274,
-0.3260815441608429,
-0.3344130516052246,
-0.6164824366569519,
0.02645258791744709,
0.08371121436357498,
-0.3973081409931183,
-0.6859229207038879,
0.21381209790706635,
0.11815329641103745,
0.6814326047897339,
-0.42588043212890625,
0.701654314994812,
0.9490500092506409,
-0.43641752004623413,
-0.7113773822784424,
-0.5055418610572815,
0.32593414187431335,
-0.10997200757265091,
-0.44215282797813416,
0.04818865656852722,
0.07484301179647446,
-0.5616825819015503,
-0.1961984783411026,
0.2802715301513672,
-0.10413625836372375,
0.2409956008195877,
0.08526196330785751,
0.5663331151008606,
-0.006430035922676325,
0.03537743538618088,
-0.4365882873535156,
0.007547407411038876,
0.1388729065656662,
-0.5590820908546448,
0.6176954507827759,
-0.07071597874164581,
-0.09659239649772644,
-0.1742013841867447,
0.15569481253623962,
0.40827691555023193,
-0.32971009612083435,
0.8521860837936401,
0.262140154838562,
-0.6909421682357788,
0.00031272723572328687,
-0.7505283355712891,
-0.14145076274871826,
-0.4824693202972412,
0.6280087828636169,
-0.25361213088035583,
-0.6787529587745667,
0.7307456731796265,
0.05888216197490692,
0.06391526013612747,
0.4680953323841095,
0.5653403401374817,
-0.17628365755081177,
1.65421724319458,
0.507355272769928,
-0.4626629054546356,
0.6690711975097656,
-0.18533076345920563,
0.03797195106744766,
-0.49998584389686584,
-0.5125676989555359,
-0.5723048448562622,
-0.2806234061717987,
-0.3025725185871124,
-0.46676039695739746,
0.4896746575832367,
0.11280003935098648,
-0.2977939546108246,
0.23769435286521912,
-0.14379726350307465,
0.6381040811538696,
0.5338656902313232,
-0.1454795002937317,
0.1943211406469345,
-0.07724727690219879,
-0.030130522325634956,
-0.00611990736797452,
-0.6817394495010376,
-0.6474401950836182,
0.8579554557800293,
0.298536092042923,
0.9515159726142883,
-0.14467138051986694,
0.6762022376060486,
0.36400076746940613,
0.6108132004737854,
-0.4425966739654541,
0.4344606399536133,
-0.15116702020168304,
-0.8406228423118591,
-0.6489631533622742,
-0.5537440180778503,
-1.0632359981536865,
0.32703182101249695,
-0.3149697184562683,
-0.9301817417144775,
0.5690354108810425,
0.022410986945033073,
-0.3822574019432068,
0.4531361162662506,
-0.42521628737449646,
0.510870099067688,
-0.22408512234687805,
-0.04800529405474663,
-0.35120636224746704,
-0.4858987331390381,
-0.07921119034290314,
-0.006374914664775133,
0.8682623505592346,
-0.4508221745491028,
-0.29046669602394104,
0.9632563591003418,
-0.06782945990562439,
0.6424315571784973,
-0.10589980334043503,
-0.024074098095297813,
0.21563725173473358,
0.19631607830524445,
0.4736792743206024,
-0.15228167176246643,
-0.7894662618637085,
-0.12517307698726654,
0.07480131834745407,
-0.3849676847457886,
-0.3826427757740021,
0.6716557741165161,
-0.9772704243659973,
-0.5355944633483887,
-0.35295963287353516,
-0.5132684707641602,
-0.25974041223526,
0.11730418354272842,
0.07996430993080139,
0.6555149555206299,
-0.45844516158103943,
-0.06382905691862106,
0.15244007110595703,
-0.06715478748083115,
0.4264070987701416,
0.8079923987388611,
-0.6133939027786255,
-0.33322325348854065,
1.1571455001831055,
0.3310539126396179,
0.1471925973892212,
0.4720345437526703,
0.3802788257598877,
-0.522059977054596,
-0.40173009037971497,
-0.42703524231910706,
-0.006715948693454266,
-0.5206870436668396,
-0.29024043679237366,
-0.37583738565444946,
-0.045447591692209244,
-0.564213216304779,
-0.16048209369182587,
-0.24500888586044312,
-0.21822860836982727,
-0.40342414379119873,
-0.014630178920924664,
-0.08585821092128754,
1.1333531141281128,
-0.021640656515955925,
0.048752788454294205,
-0.8282528519630432,
0.01929224282503128,
0.13236649334430695,
0.4847031831741333,
0.1947629153728485,
-0.5119926333427429,
-0.639274537563324,
0.11356057971715927,
-0.20598773658275604,
-0.8143821954727173,
1.0633636713027954,
0.2384442687034607,
0.6488814949989319,
0.30576232075691223,
0.05262291058897972,
0.5191091895103455,
-0.6664755940437317,
0.8805067539215088,
0.14967362582683563,
-0.7643498778343201,
0.5266668796539307,
-0.5104414820671082,
0.16036055982112885,
0.21228861808776855,
0.3289637863636017,
-0.9933429956436157,
-0.4125330150127411,
-0.45299819111824036,
-0.9216912388801575,
0.7836425304412842,
-0.29991787672042847,
0.17798283696174622,
-0.3660840094089508,
0.16123098134994507,
-0.12811394035816193,
0.08660809695720673,
-0.41692084074020386,
-0.18314872682094574,
0.18374216556549072,
0.02291700802743435,
-0.4452648460865021,
-0.32277530431747437,
0.3773995637893677,
-0.1779608428478241,
0.6745233535766602,
0.08127402514219284,
0.008652566000819206,
-0.09644892811775208,
0.2023007720708847,
-0.5740141272544861,
0.31051260232925415,
0.3268449008464813,
0.9638442397117615,
-0.36201292276382446,
-0.20584441721439362,
0.39553722739219666,
-0.040557652711868286,
0.05521286278963089,
0.18784916400909424,
0.07272904366254807,
0.04736649990081787,
0.23495906591415405,
0.5237305760383606,
0.26544809341430664,
-1.1070551872253418,
0.3243832290172577,
-0.1302482634782791,
-0.04411505535244942,
-0.5210235714912415,
-0.25340938568115234,
0.30527836084365845,
0.5054025053977966,
0.7949660420417786,
-0.13521191477775574,
0.1311037838459015,
-0.842131495475769,
0.05010615289211273,
0.3177856206893921,
-0.35518142580986023,
-0.2545900046825409,
1.0272715091705322,
0.3981471359729767,
-0.5246052145957947,
0.6042501330375671,
0.15117321908473969,
-0.7362391948699951,
0.6152929663658142,
0.5610253214836121,
0.4980500042438507,
-0.5090538859367371,
-0.08368503302335739,
0.2232971340417862,
0.004262229893356562,
-0.48051661252975464,
0.40308263897895813,
0.5300890207290649,
-0.8629501461982727,
-0.4843648076057434,
-0.9077909588813782,
-0.5969567894935608,
-0.09906849265098572,
-0.6512477397918701,
0.29894182085990906,
-0.034063395112752914,
-0.478292316198349,
-0.21444375813007355,
0.14162670075893402,
-0.7850511074066162,
0.41604188084602356,
0.5213126540184021,
1.1386315822601318,
-0.667896032333374,
0.6796776056289673,
0.7318091988563538,
-0.31690719723701477,
-0.673454225063324,
-0.2712833881378174,
-0.23343874514102936,
-0.8446998000144958,
0.7346062064170837,
-0.26003777980804443,
-0.08962161839008331,
-0.07910653948783875,
-0.23665715754032135,
-1.1172828674316406,
1.1712678670883179,
0.3374379873275757,
-0.7847790718078613,
-0.5983336567878723,
0.0024540764279663563,
0.49834755063056946,
-0.37434521317481995,
0.24461758136749268,
0.5070540308952332,
0.4003833830356598,
-0.1699700653553009,
-1.2051008939743042,
-0.4210509955883026,
-0.05032772943377495,
-0.08165563642978668,
0.34969285130500793,
-0.37255725264549255,
1.0653880834579468,
-0.2340860217809677,
-0.23312804102897644,
0.22416681051254272,
1.1190673112869263,
0.01650991477072239,
0.41971874237060547,
0.4897208511829376,
0.19569933414459229,
0.8518274426460266,
-0.09072040766477585,
1.3548117876052856,
-0.5639469027519226,
0.2569299340248108,
1.0812221765518188,
-0.40160295367240906,
1.2890846729278564,
0.08430542051792145,
-0.2772272527217865,
0.7386608719825745,
0.7686899900436401,
0.37949568033218384,
0.39261505007743835,
0.04961058869957924,
-0.32111096382141113,
-0.666725218296051,
-0.2447250336408615,
-0.3430514931678772,
0.3448149263858795,
0.5087995529174805,
-0.35101884603500366,
-0.07346992194652557,
-0.06178443878889084,
-0.243550643324852,
0.39063015580177307,
-0.5280064940452576,
0.9411699771881104,
0.08724240958690643,
-0.812383234500885,
0.38755661249160767,
0.08225346356630325,
0.5550994873046875,
-0.18211132287979126,
0.2547312378883362,
-0.1617588996887207,
0.3703918159008026,
0.22454559803009033,
-0.9486870169639587,
0.07260538637638092,
-0.14884406328201294,
-0.2114490270614624,
-0.3135327100753784,
0.7751473188400269,
-0.6504202485084534,
-0.5639775395393372,
0.5421489477157593,
0.9402763247489929,
0.14761067926883698,
-0.15945343673229218,
-0.5339856743812561,
-0.21281829476356506,
-0.33545470237731934,
-0.2656208574771881,
0.59437096118927,
0.14591221511363983,
-0.1915213167667389,
1.3325705528259277,
0.34748461842536926,
0.49621346592903137,
0.06512859463691711,
0.1706254631280899,
0.7692296504974365,
-0.6487046480178833,
-0.5907323360443115,
-0.7907154560089111,
0.05368655547499657,
-0.04678792133927345,
0.12357811629772186,
0.3176429569721222,
0.6247293949127197,
0.6286519765853882,
0.13415390253067017,
0.8915195465087891,
0.44957679510116577,
0.8905882835388184,
-0.1067170575261116,
0.677993655204773,
-0.687623143196106,
0.1946796327829361,
0.023100711405277252,
-0.5818397998809814,
0.05059231072664261,
0.20591974258422852,
-0.607896089553833,
-0.0032964053098112345,
0.0707211047410965,
0.5571921467781067,
0.24437758326530457,
0.06434480100870132,
0.5853706002235413,
0.009709054604172707,
0.33477073907852173,
0.1525675654411316,
0.9871509075164795,
-0.012875492684543133,
0.7434574365615845,
-0.13670606911182404,
0.08419641852378845,
-0.34718143939971924,
-0.7405616641044617,
-0.7143930196762085,
-0.6168082356452942,
0.32567542791366577,
-0.13797928392887115,
0.5839691162109375,
1.1657086610794067,
0.816633939743042,
-0.7881144285202026,
-0.8205961585044861,
0.2662239372730255,
0.05084572732448578,
0.059151791036129,
-0.2590259611606598,
0.24209247529506683,
-0.36172112822532654,
-0.8727293610572815,
0.441766619682312,
0.06039294973015785,
-0.010690620169043541,
-0.431471049785614,
-0.24142955243587494,
-0.1779170036315918,
0.2374337762594223,
0.6338474750518799,
0.14179657399654388,
-0.8692457675933838,
-0.18617713451385498,
0.11836118996143341,
-0.17246021330356598,
-0.3470570743083954,
0.6801226139068604,
-1.2178287506103516,
0.45290160179138184,
0.5118862390518188,
0.3384794592857361,
0.06888043135404587,
0.09847958385944366,
1.1323778629302979,
-0.6037410497665405,
-0.08342494815587997,
0.47494539618492126,
0.5190171599388123,
0.25618958473205566,
-0.23777399957180023,
0.40137091279029846,
-0.05623304098844528,
-0.8230774998664856,
-0.6754656434059143,
-0.12031371891498566,
-0.16630178689956665,
-0.19023802876472473,
0.9772902131080627,
0.09704488515853882,
-0.09407538175582886,
-0.1893693208694458,
0.01782459020614624,
0.16037635505199432,
-0.7494094371795654,
0.7906212210655212,
0.6980720162391663,
-0.015006042085587978,
-0.2707309424877167,
-0.6765692234039307,
0.46199068427085876,
0.11619734764099121,
-0.5031121373176575,
0.19661012291908264,
0.2915499210357666,
0.05890798941254616,
0.0005392230814322829,
0.6868338584899902,
0.12421050667762756,
0.19391997158527374,
-0.19115597009658813,
0.003501059953123331,
0.24343742430210114,
-0.39039480686187744,
0.023659884929656982,
-0.057993073016405106,
0.37593528628349304,
0.2800225615501404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18551v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18551v1
|
Implicit Bias of Next-Token Prediction
| 2024-02-28T18:34:53 | 2024-02-28T18:34:53 |
Christos Thrampoulidis
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Next-token prediction (NTP), the go-to training paradigm in training large
language models, involves predicting the next token in a sequence. Departing
from traditional one-hot classification, in NTP, multiple tokens with varying
frequencies follow each given context. This work frames NTP training as
cross-entropy minimization over distinct contexts, each associated with a
sparse empirical probability vector across a finite vocabulary. It then
addresses the following question: do gradient-based optimizers exhibit a bias
towards solutions with specific structure as the NTP training loss reaches its
lower bound (entropy)? Specifically, for linear NTP models trained using
gradient descent (GD), we make the following contributions: Firstly, we
determine NTP-separability conditions on the data, under which GD can attain
its lower bound. We also demonstrate that these conditions hold under
overparameterization. Secondly, we establish that the parameters of GD
projected onto an appropriate data subspace converge to the unique solution of
a system of linear equations, which requires the logits' difference of
in-support tokens to be equal to the log-ratio of their respective
probabilities. Meanwhile, on the orthogonal subspace, the parameters diverge
and converge in the direction of the solution of a max-margin quadratic
program, minimizing the Euclidean norm of parameters satisfying the
\NTP-separability conditions. Akin to prior research on implicit bias of
one-hot classification, our work opens exciting avenues for future research
that can lead to better understanding optimization, generalization and
robustness principles of models trained with NTP.
|
[
-0.41202253103256226,
-0.354245126247406,
0.3141777813434601,
-0.02703694999217987,
-0.15156249701976776,
-0.11489048600196838,
-0.14604200422763824,
-0.618289589881897,
0.11773426085710526,
0.056981999427080154,
-0.6192790269851685,
-0.4546465575695038,
-0.5793342590332031,
-0.08729672431945801,
-0.30214524269104004,
1.0812451839447021,
0.12856265902519226,
0.41627129912376404,
-0.09797755628824234,
-0.1808120310306549,
-0.5126681923866272,
-0.6938962936401367,
-0.5203583240509033,
-0.28459763526916504,
0.28263768553733826,
0.16710224747657776,
0.6082113981246948,
0.595521867275238,
0.06555674970149994,
0.2253120094537735,
-0.1445288062095642,
-0.3085750937461853,
-0.312235951423645,
0.14823992550373077,
0.05323689430952072,
-0.8425062894821167,
-0.014493281953036785,
0.18624790012836456,
0.6778982877731323,
0.730377197265625,
-0.0348445363342762,
0.20730186998844147,
0.10576554387807846,
0.553308367729187,
-0.7638123035430908,
-0.044092338532209396,
-0.8396348357200623,
0.48841622471809387,
-0.19018733501434326,
-0.3713773190975189,
-0.29943111538887024,
-0.40076175332069397,
0.3981187343597412,
-0.37750136852264404,
0.4823061227798462,
0.08868203312158585,
0.6409618854522705,
0.29631859064102173,
-0.3861037790775299,
0.18086104094982147,
-0.6415241360664368,
0.8865493535995483,
-0.5471336841583252,
0.5773412585258484,
0.36306270956993103,
0.2085433304309845,
0.22498776018619537,
-0.5348030924797058,
-0.3331475555896759,
-0.14796653389930725,
0.24031555652618408,
-0.25785115361213684,
0.015066105872392654,
0.13241617381572723,
0.3044000566005707,
0.11260611563920975,
-0.44416898488998413,
0.1781529039144516,
-0.5146471858024597,
-0.2956266403198242,
0.19000212848186493,
0.28531062602996826,
-0.028897562995553017,
0.1303442269563675,
-0.5868585109710693,
0.23158372938632965,
-0.5552886128425598,
0.009300651960074902,
0.41421207785606384,
0.28579217195510864,
-0.16041041910648346,
0.31927207112312317,
-0.015717780217528343,
0.3452718257904053,
0.30132603645324707,
0.18784241378307343,
0.38732773065567017,
-0.24024604260921478,
-0.10819738358259201,
0.25651389360427856,
0.36001303791999817,
0.4089391827583313,
0.3049778640270233,
-0.28771594166755676,
-0.12642474472522736,
0.05260251834988594,
0.013430099003016949,
-0.750930905342102,
-0.05286218598484993,
0.19927558302879333,
-0.5804809331893921,
-0.37858644127845764,
-0.2353716343641281,
-0.5557395219802856,
-0.2759099304676056,
-0.49016958475112915,
0.010305027477443218,
-0.19788691401481628,
-0.11621297150850296,
-0.008348692208528519,
-0.24522726237773895,
0.09858408570289612,
0.10789351165294647,
-0.9239886403083801,
0.3364488482475281,
0.6950103640556335,
1.2221579551696777,
-0.20665553212165833,
-0.3079076111316681,
-0.5236296057701111,
-0.033626534044742584,
-0.5277039408683777,
0.5086630582809448,
-0.7762024402618408,
-0.2355378419160843,
0.24705736339092255,
-0.3759608566761017,
-0.014794775284826756,
-0.27682191133499146,
0.38287198543548584,
-0.5616235733032227,
0.3090207278728485,
-0.5219134092330933,
-0.3604598343372345,
0.08323335647583008,
0.22555269300937653,
-0.48251232504844666,
0.9375895261764526,
-0.020132068544626236,
-1.2069923877716064,
0.8677315711975098,
-0.43686363101005554,
-0.09231962263584137,
-0.24456346035003662,
-0.2930142879486084,
-0.1491713523864746,
0.4066529870033264,
0.12176179885864258,
0.26565930247306824,
-0.41591745615005493,
0.06553208827972412,
-0.7522229552268982,
-0.09903916716575623,
0.056801751255989075,
-0.5342246294021606,
0.7448402643203735,
-0.004008898977190256,
-0.4483726918697357,
-0.055131252855062485,
-0.7754440307617188,
0.2121800035238266,
-0.22022052109241486,
-0.3474075198173523,
-0.418155312538147,
-0.11822356283664703,
0.19456785917282104,
0.5356124043464661,
0.12043380737304688,
-0.5822583436965942,
0.1575959175825119,
-0.2425103634595871,
0.32000482082366943,
1.2594804763793945,
-0.16557280719280243,
0.6065505146980286,
-0.07622043043375015,
0.5712755918502808,
0.025563353672623634,
0.27475446462631226,
0.1429358869791031,
-0.4962565004825592,
-0.4664697051048279,
0.16672435402870178,
0.3168117105960846,
0.3953556716442108,
-0.4402886927127838,
0.0645538717508316,
-0.08927926421165466,
-0.11667505651712418,
-0.07954858243465424,
-0.11975570023059845,
0.5324403643608093,
0.7124975919723511,
0.38316962122917175,
-0.47927966713905334,
-0.7253216505050659,
-0.7483639717102051,
-0.16925059258937836,
-0.4070507287979126,
0.20417587459087372,
0.17366716265678406,
0.3381752371788025,
-0.13422232866287231,
0.9539697766304016,
-0.4931332767009735,
-0.3463476002216339,
-0.051461879163980484,
0.1409788429737091,
0.20480787754058838,
0.6820046305656433,
0.6718560457229614,
-0.6212577819824219,
-0.5168450474739075,
0.06100006774067879,
-0.464895099401474,
-0.023742031306028366,
0.16096416115760803,
-0.15847693383693695,
0.5321666598320007,
0.7338637113571167,
-0.5113703608512878,
0.497651606798172,
0.2833709716796875,
-0.3117130696773529,
0.673312783241272,
0.0680323988199234,
-0.5210606455802917,
-0.883894681930542,
0.06235244870185852,
0.30629897117614746,
-0.055051952600479126,
-0.7837424278259277,
-0.21529045701026917,
-0.43379998207092285,
0.21946729719638824,
-0.35463210940361023,
0.6464410424232483,
-0.32733848690986633,
-0.30117571353912354,
-0.17633044719696045,
-0.41040992736816406,
-0.3216063380241394,
0.6562670469284058,
0.4749245047569275,
0.49515533447265625,
0.7267563939094543,
-0.6134180426597595,
0.04558320343494415,
0.0007557301432825625,
-0.12007168680429459,
0.48033642768859863,
-0.7748825550079346,
0.25246599316596985,
-0.3765580654144287,
0.4175068140029907,
-0.7993060350418091,
0.29973527789115906,
0.02950037084519863,
-0.5697633028030396,
0.4044300615787506,
-0.41131287813186646,
-0.09949729591608047,
-0.10573834180831909,
-0.5014091730117798,
0.7251826524734497,
0.40953755378723145,
-0.5557594299316406,
0.28381115198135376,
0.29297757148742676,
-0.022359803318977356,
-1.207567811012268,
-0.7759071588516235,
-0.1431325525045395,
-0.21136751770973206,
-0.36050668358802795,
0.21009962260723114,
0.048986900597810745,
-0.14380577206611633,
-0.062200434505939484,
-0.3375979959964752,
-0.1451994925737381,
-0.1293141394853592,
0.1990097612142563,
0.11500288546085358,
-0.3451976776123047,
0.159618079662323,
-0.16894599795341492,
-0.29300829768180847,
0.300961434841156,
-1.052581548690796,
0.8893592357635498,
-0.20081837475299835,
-0.1470065712928772,
-0.2733851373195648,
0.31636688113212585,
0.18799005448818207,
0.06073390319943428,
0.7537114024162292,
0.9322211146354675,
-0.4617695212364197,
-0.27008315920829773,
-0.5556313395500183,
-0.17387041449546814,
-0.4181562662124634,
0.5926099419593811,
-0.2714596390724182,
-0.5992975831031799,
0.7285029292106628,
0.35367411375045776,
0.2306075543165207,
0.5354582071304321,
0.6804011464118958,
0.20654599368572235,
1.0757482051849365,
0.7876269221305847,
-0.4468853771686554,
0.6953557133674622,
-0.5573521256446838,
-0.21082642674446106,
-0.8686801195144653,
-0.4195939898490906,
-0.7674455046653748,
-0.5467897653579712,
-0.6993970274925232,
-0.3627927303314209,
0.29011932015419006,
-0.20176562666893005,
-0.46600958704948425,
-0.14079560339450836,
-0.30167198181152344,
0.5858700275421143,
0.7799152135848999,
-0.0633964091539383,
-0.10181726515293121,
0.020269013941287994,
-0.44961363077163696,
-0.16533252596855164,
-0.8366430997848511,
0.13399937748908997,
1.4107625484466553,
0.4498038589954376,
0.6866448521614075,
-0.2614741027355194,
0.6060931086540222,
0.38530153036117554,
0.042088501155376434,
-0.39593642950057983,
0.31892332434654236,
0.17174048721790314,
-0.8542566895484924,
-0.35545143485069275,
-0.4213621914386749,
-0.7431961894035339,
0.34218695759773254,
-0.14575812220573425,
-1.0219190120697021,
0.6488328576087952,
0.21684721112251282,
-0.13688114285469055,
0.4302076995372772,
-0.4440148174762726,
0.5988732576370239,
-0.03382343798875809,
-0.4144251346588135,
-0.10122836381196976,
-0.9231188893318176,
0.4421260356903076,
0.11304092407226562,
-0.08020208030939102,
-0.05499880760908127,
-0.2528075575828552,
0.7243996858596802,
-0.6160789728164673,
0.8980563879013062,
-0.5417693257331848,
-0.009969152510166168,
0.05927056446671486,
-0.04004755616188049,
0.44903355836868286,
0.2629082202911377,
-0.058753348886966705,
0.2231944352388382,
-0.05923384055495262,
-0.5399190783500671,
-0.4168141186237335,
0.5472686290740967,
-0.8365736603736877,
-0.4353153705596924,
-0.5629472732543945,
-0.33035433292388916,
-0.42460179328918457,
0.11009084433317184,
0.5778337121009827,
0.6701104044914246,
0.05003252625465393,
0.0474734865128994,
0.5154313445091248,
-0.02485644817352295,
0.5207896828651428,
0.12193991243839264,
-0.0551549531519413,
-0.23040659725666046,
0.7518240809440613,
0.1494404524564743,
0.3509167730808258,
0.2886677086353302,
0.3270832598209381,
-0.5249935984611511,
-0.7491437196731567,
-0.18978555500507355,
-0.06535810232162476,
-0.9909262657165527,
-0.13071879744529724,
-0.47621408104896545,
-0.09876591712236404,
-0.3590167462825775,
-0.07208286225795746,
-0.22824786603450775,
-0.6526995301246643,
-0.19533100724220276,
-0.31263887882232666,
-0.0009553986019454896,
0.3435537815093994,
-0.3673017919063568,
0.038584884256124496,
-0.5334043502807617,
0.13585127890110016,
0.15396049618721008,
0.3717353641986847,
0.112007275223732,
-0.6025494337081909,
-0.38083532452583313,
-0.20428653061389923,
0.000796431559138,
-0.649631679058075,
0.24659599363803864,
0.3675661087036133,
0.5313757658004761,
0.6623238325119019,
-0.05528606101870537,
0.4475211501121521,
-0.635041356086731,
0.7693980932235718,
0.4438282251358032,
-0.9111954569816589,
0.23925231397151947,
-0.18321335315704346,
0.10330035537481308,
0.6028123497962952,
0.46513715386390686,
-0.6138801574707031,
-0.21553976833820343,
-0.6609540581703186,
-0.8045961260795593,
0.8394691944122314,
-0.13062159717082977,
0.24173134565353394,
0.027330365031957626,
0.34219804406166077,
0.20838312804698944,
0.32916024327278137,
-0.6902362108230591,
-0.47308558225631714,
-0.058205798268318176,
0.17342184484004974,
0.034684937447309494,
-0.28184837102890015,
0.02508406713604927,
-0.12096735090017319,
0.692907989025116,
-0.3600234091281891,
0.458072304725647,
0.0346241258084774,
0.15016457438468933,
-0.18348248302936554,
-0.11666818708181381,
0.5750598311424255,
0.6342742443084717,
-0.30883777141571045,
0.030483359470963478,
0.2910860478878021,
-0.5657142400741577,
0.11860227584838867,
-0.054640498012304306,
-0.2731446623802185,
0.29798999428749084,
0.4610294997692108,
0.9144560694694519,
-0.25392642617225647,
-0.14365845918655396,
0.5108852386474609,
-0.15100140869617462,
-0.13274319469928741,
-0.288891464471817,
-0.1403382122516632,
-0.5071566104888916,
0.3475798964500427,
0.6540437340736389,
0.4912053644657135,
0.2910035252571106,
-0.5102336406707764,
0.13727855682373047,
0.7623503804206848,
-0.5817586183547974,
-0.6771618127822876,
0.8857137560844421,
0.10093183815479279,
0.1522657573223114,
0.3471832871437073,
-0.021766221150755882,
-0.8308245539665222,
0.6328842639923096,
0.45726585388183594,
1.2048076391220093,
-0.18858255445957184,
0.17198193073272705,
0.23217682540416718,
0.31787505745887756,
-0.12283008545637131,
0.20812970399856567,
-0.24478158354759216,
-0.7374842762947083,
-0.505802571773529,
-0.39230138063430786,
-0.1682252138853073,
0.05968964844942093,
-0.5944452881813049,
0.27283623814582825,
-0.690334677696228,
-0.36234766244888306,
0.002790612867102027,
0.04183119162917137,
-0.7130572199821472,
0.30698150396347046,
0.43134379386901855,
0.840268611907959,
-0.8886489868164062,
0.7176903486251831,
0.43888014554977417,
-0.1909390389919281,
-0.5309473872184753,
0.2416418343782425,
0.07179858535528183,
-0.9765948057174683,
1.0094878673553467,
0.12244399636983871,
-0.03216565400362015,
-0.4548363983631134,
-0.628689169883728,
-1.0677231550216675,
0.707676351070404,
0.5593779683113098,
-0.21900694072246552,
-0.5183515548706055,
0.1516098529100418,
0.4494797885417938,
-0.1833367645740509,
0.3876834511756897,
0.5254477262496948,
0.20066992938518524,
0.02563438005745411,
-0.9222199320793152,
0.002202993258833885,
-0.34215712547302246,
0.22692875564098358,
0.25332239270210266,
-0.569666862487793,
0.9749780297279358,
-0.33950451016426086,
-0.003483631880953908,
-0.2687567174434662,
0.84136962890625,
0.07568060606718063,
0.46310877799987793,
0.4531627297401428,
0.48452669382095337,
0.6349614262580872,
0.06257341802120209,
1.0090501308441162,
-0.4462253153324127,
0.2761440873146057,
0.9605034589767456,
-0.03234320506453514,
0.4875451922416687,
0.5912215113639832,
-0.31650328636169434,
0.4425692856311798,
0.6887596249580383,
0.3846513330936432,
0.6685143709182739,
0.38090282678604126,
-0.052385907620191574,
0.03650198131799698,
-0.26461130380630493,
-0.7556728720664978,
0.14710906147956848,
0.11039280891418457,
-0.362292617559433,
-0.10794899612665176,
-0.22018153965473175,
-0.1703372746706009,
-0.33735910058021545,
-0.44290679693222046,
0.47218114137649536,
0.044210415333509445,
-0.3132430911064148,
0.7140110731124878,
0.10508173704147339,
0.7955542802810669,
-0.4042692184448242,
0.25760361552238464,
-0.3710136413574219,
0.10714396089315414,
-0.31125494837760925,
-0.2362654060125351,
0.16360850632190704,
-0.22802521288394928,
-0.1838313788175583,
0.07981802523136139,
0.5140151381492615,
-0.270268976688385,
-0.39795249700546265,
0.03326236829161644,
0.2425042986869812,
-0.12376092374324799,
0.07857242971658707,
-0.5859838128089905,
-0.17929355800151825,
-0.08598115295171738,
-0.40891748666763306,
0.4490787386894226,
0.49632522463798523,
-0.15721461176872253,
0.7143988609313965,
0.6411246061325073,
0.29111248254776,
0.6119327545166016,
-0.11725412309169769,
0.7979625463485718,
-0.3113496005535126,
-0.8920589685440063,
-1.0137540102005005,
0.12975022196769714,
0.13566415011882782,
-0.6328480839729309,
0.4563509225845337,
0.7069379091262817,
0.9736683964729309,
0.07749034464359283,
0.9098663330078125,
0.2581951916217804,
0.17955541610717773,
-0.8085167407989502,
0.001475396566092968,
-0.4483403265476227,
0.19317109882831573,
-0.3465254008769989,
-1.1526246070861816,
-0.2314390242099762,
0.3501673638820648,
-0.2873750329017639,
0.3706790506839752,
0.740860104560852,
0.4395366311073303,
0.07142441719770432,
-0.06123685836791992,
0.04667835310101509,
-0.15218378603458405,
0.12265586853027344,
0.6494945287704468,
0.7553700804710388,
-0.11141292005777359,
0.37552937865257263,
-0.17557139694690704,
0.2351260930299759,
-0.19951286911964417,
-0.748748242855072,
-1.0146592855453491,
-0.7700356841087341,
-0.21510319411754608,
-0.5603787302970886,
0.11198104172945023,
1.2635438442230225,
0.923721194267273,
-0.7707160115242004,
0.014077221043407917,
-0.2922545075416565,
0.149983748793602,
-0.12240041792392731,
-0.1842316836118698,
0.44385236501693726,
-0.5336153507232666,
-0.8007764220237732,
-0.07181932032108307,
0.11343132704496384,
0.03622543811798096,
-0.4294680058956146,
-0.1715652048587799,
0.1435888111591339,
-0.022748205810785294,
0.2138000726699829,
0.4732123017311096,
-0.43695196509361267,
-0.11935842782258987,
-0.1727423369884491,
0.10032664239406586,
0.13418929278850555,
1.0706284046173096,
-0.7756673693656921,
0.1242622509598732,
0.6483523845672607,
0.7511202096939087,
0.696973979473114,
-0.07627198100090027,
0.7284259796142578,
-1.0981756448745728,
0.4362926483154297,
0.32952752709388733,
0.3552982807159424,
-0.001362781273201108,
-0.3740483224391937,
0.4691082537174225,
0.37137889862060547,
-0.2600756287574768,
-1.068334937095642,
0.20172114670276642,
-0.41039109230041504,
-0.09889820963144302,
1.3351631164550781,
0.13917557895183563,
-0.13168737292289734,
-0.1969253271818161,
0.048714086413383484,
-0.006320194341242313,
-0.5860259532928467,
0.6963827013969421,
0.5805804133415222,
-0.044357527047395706,
-0.04517515376210213,
-0.5762481689453125,
0.8538187146186829,
0.587605893611908,
-0.4196959137916565,
0.08027754724025726,
0.41464146971702576,
0.1620854139328003,
0.16556775569915771,
0.7995666265487671,
0.15848205983638763,
0.3157816529273987,
0.06027878075838089,
-0.15495413541793823,
-0.0671219602227211,
-0.43530774116516113,
-0.5472151637077332,
0.234976127743721,
0.09580495208501816,
-0.4285343587398529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18540v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18540v1
|
Keeping LLMs Aligned After Fine-tuning: The Crucial Role of Prompt Templates
| 2024-02-28T18:23:49 | 2024-02-28T18:23:49 |
Kaifeng Lyu, Haoyu Zhao, Xinran Gu, Dingli Yu, Anirudh Goyal, Sanjeev Arora
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Public LLMs such as the Llama 2-Chat have driven huge activity in LLM
research. These models underwent alignment training and were considered safe.
Recently Qi et al. (2023) reported that even benign fine-tuning (e.g., on
seemingly safe datasets) can give rise to unsafe behaviors in the models. The
current paper is about methods and best practices to mitigate such loss of
alignment. Through extensive experiments on several chat models (Meta's Llama
2-Chat, Mistral AI's Mistral 7B Instruct v0.2, and OpenAI's GPT-3.5 Turbo),
this paper uncovers that the prompt templates used during fine-tuning and
inference play a crucial role in preserving safety alignment, and proposes the
"Pure Tuning, Safe Testing" (PTST) principle -- fine-tune models without a
safety prompt, but include it at test time. Fine-tuning experiments on GSM8K,
ChatDoctor, and OpenOrca show that PTST significantly reduces the rise of
unsafe behaviors, and even almost eliminates them in some cases.
|
[
-0.37235400080680847,
-0.5757179856300354,
0.497618168592453,
-0.011663890443742275,
-0.5077701807022095,
-0.19573424756526947,
0.025548972189426422,
-0.29413533210754395,
-0.4706338942050934,
0.3774959444999695,
-0.5732240080833435,
-0.39215970039367676,
-0.3924398422241211,
-0.07033273577690125,
-0.36138227581977844,
1.1941653490066528,
-0.19166114926338196,
0.03509221598505974,
-0.04162926971912384,
-0.11345558613538742,
-0.798287034034729,
-0.436404287815094,
-0.951644778251648,
-0.06019821763038635,
0.6194570064544678,
0.34393107891082764,
0.7062849998474121,
1.0588922500610352,
0.41258111596107483,
0.15890035033226013,
-0.37917011976242065,
0.3037738502025604,
-0.6308102607727051,
0.4327510595321655,
-0.1866069883108139,
-0.646814227104187,
-0.6969402432441711,
0.20805160701274872,
0.3467453122138977,
0.31784549355506897,
-0.3140740990638733,
-0.020579852163791656,
0.5789703726768494,
0.47837746143341064,
-0.6382178664207458,
-0.051943350583314896,
-0.568636417388916,
-0.14715878665447235,
-0.30222293734550476,
-0.38154107332229614,
-0.4311680495738983,
-0.6700453758239746,
-0.23374885320663452,
-0.6512821316719055,
-0.0148397795855999,
0.23775753378868103,
0.9186437726020813,
0.6516861319541931,
-0.7703682780265808,
0.03268785402178764,
-0.6660653352737427,
0.7309162020683289,
-0.5319560170173645,
0.14742359519004822,
0.47540101408958435,
0.2801864743232727,
-0.6501952409744263,
-0.4169835150241852,
-0.35943254828453064,
0.11208214610815048,
0.15371358394622803,
0.20518554747104645,
-0.15625400841236115,
0.45067107677459717,
0.3386576473712921,
0.12408643960952759,
-0.36468306183815,
0.629172146320343,
-0.29777172207832336,
-0.19983361661434174,
0.4091273546218872,
0.5029961466789246,
0.15413209795951843,
0.1594843715429306,
-0.40764620900154114,
-0.15631841123104095,
-1.3255764245986938,
0.20790636539459229,
0.30361396074295044,
0.30010655522346497,
-0.13487234711647034,
0.5690497756004333,
-0.1349705159664154,
0.6782841086387634,
0.301326721906662,
-0.3730875253677368,
-0.1930355429649353,
-0.405666708946228,
-0.2659093141555786,
0.24698922038078308,
0.545208752155304,
0.8701466917991638,
0.5266345143318176,
0.023592526093125343,
-0.3650449216365814,
0.32353129982948303,
0.22452005743980408,
-0.485482394695282,
0.03579731658101082,
0.14855296909809113,
-0.299698144197464,
-0.5904278755187988,
-0.008124366402626038,
-0.43882277607917786,
-0.5774373412132263,
-0.6401503086090088,
0.2843915820121765,
-0.4141082465648651,
-0.12782420217990875,
0.13737545907497406,
0.1194494217634201,
0.5747371315956116,
0.42942526936531067,
-0.8628766536712646,
0.21587838232517242,
1.3211346864700317,
0.6450715065002441,
-0.14639194309711456,
-0.27491238713264465,
-0.8915849924087524,
0.23739120364189148,
-0.6118276715278625,
0.7815144658088684,
-0.06239937245845795,
-0.4695269763469696,
0.02842370606958866,
0.03635347634553909,
-0.15613462030887604,
-0.3362603783607483,
0.7007015347480774,
-0.3761451542377472,
0.20172207057476044,
-0.4904661178588867,
-0.7184514403343201,
-0.025020064786076546,
0.3905391991138458,
-0.038125403225421906,
0.8239006996154785,
-0.3341372013092041,
-0.6618183255195618,
0.39625686407089233,
-0.28314468264579773,
-0.24982808530330658,
-0.5199541449546814,
-0.06614834070205688,
-0.32447290420532227,
0.1970733404159546,
0.28162509202957153,
0.31590551137924194,
-0.2224091738462448,
0.30239102244377136,
-0.4345792829990387,
-0.5317249298095703,
0.2688533663749695,
-0.3786064088344574,
0.6930990219116211,
0.3678078055381775,
-0.2807571291923523,
0.24290384352207184,
-0.40083712339401245,
-0.017494317144155502,
-0.1964367777109146,
-0.2514204978942871,
-0.2614131569862366,
0.07420486956834793,
-0.3079194724559784,
0.2519908845424652,
-0.1889997273683548,
-0.4267510771751404,
0.18425622582435608,
-0.3179992735385895,
0.42125368118286133,
1.1498241424560547,
0.18697038292884827,
0.4277961254119873,
-0.823184072971344,
0.44438841938972473,
0.2355390191078186,
0.4773644804954529,
-0.2456892430782318,
-0.5380794405937195,
-0.8939929008483887,
-0.22079943120479584,
0.16770216822624207,
0.7164098024368286,
-0.20912602543830872,
0.6326649188995361,
0.01659180037677288,
-0.5621834397315979,
-0.48453637957572937,
0.10563256591558456,
0.42607197165489197,
0.7328458428382874,
-0.010101904161274433,
-0.21085689961910248,
-0.39045289158821106,
-0.7464118003845215,
-0.2894096374511719,
-0.057722680270671844,
-0.05212860554456711,
-0.1479065865278244,
-0.06701453030109406,
-0.16751065850257874,
0.8652558326721191,
-0.18129564821720123,
0.10980690270662308,
0.1193084642291069,
-0.017523787915706635,
0.04550096020102501,
0.9251211881637573,
0.6312980055809021,
-0.40629279613494873,
-0.27569425106048584,
-0.27674591541290283,
-0.5853978395462036,
-0.2552049160003662,
-0.17957445979118347,
-0.40836867690086365,
0.09372500330209732,
0.6268242597579956,
-0.7608430981636047,
0.6194941401481628,
0.3017732501029968,
-0.35632574558258057,
0.26343899965286255,
0.0997122973203659,
0.022363843396306038,
-1.1415009498596191,
-0.21791474521160126,
-0.04800443351268768,
-0.4002973437309265,
-0.6561682224273682,
-0.08899011462926865,
0.27017608284950256,
0.0169905386865139,
-0.5658329129219055,
0.4788217544555664,
-0.1458256095647812,
0.1299692988395691,
-0.37018850445747375,
-0.03740688040852547,
0.03983323276042938,
0.16246336698532104,
-0.28989535570144653,
1.1368075609207153,
0.656184732913971,
-0.9444687962532043,
-0.09083548188209534,
0.44764405488967896,
-0.2260291427373886,
0.8318428993225098,
-0.7493700981140137,
0.4000517725944519,
-0.26129281520843506,
0.10931435227394104,
-1.0055501461029053,
-0.07519443333148956,
0.39101317524909973,
-0.184076726436615,
0.3550301790237427,
-0.2577422857284546,
-0.5088419914245605,
0.17037786543369293,
-0.4117841422557831,
0.17266976833343506,
0.7916316986083984,
-0.5147815942764282,
0.03738511726260185,
0.3111516237258911,
-0.11938482522964478,
-0.45301955938339233,
-0.28544706106185913,
-0.18114498257637024,
-0.6611440777778625,
-0.5012331604957581,
0.05796641856431961,
-0.09483320266008377,
-0.23849862813949585,
-0.5136225819587708,
-0.43776342272758484,
0.11323986947536469,
0.6626033782958984,
0.5312628746032715,
0.31695762276649475,
-0.16740724444389343,
0.005860896315425634,
0.2711433172225952,
-0.5176403522491455,
-0.0935053899884224,
-0.21386712789535522,
0.48278671503067017,
-0.15743236243724823,
-0.5532884001731873,
-0.8644100427627563,
0.161906436085701,
0.5708557367324829,
-0.19543707370758057,
0.5603922605514526,
0.40097513794898987,
-0.27971553802490234,
0.46614834666252136,
-0.6912730932235718,
-0.31241023540496826,
-0.5073948502540588,
-0.1565081924200058,
0.04633130505681038,
-0.9461306929588318,
0.45826655626296997,
-0.20524731278419495,
0.24133487045764923,
0.19114544987678528,
0.5008624196052551,
-0.5570178627967834,
1.1503537893295288,
0.7933884859085083,
-0.032078035175800323,
0.6908994317054749,
0.3160049617290497,
0.19327084720134735,
-0.8594973087310791,
-0.02636696770787239,
-0.5670334696769714,
-0.41423776745796204,
-0.679864764213562,
-0.12431634962558746,
0.6044209003448486,
0.357258141040802,
-0.8232668042182922,
0.007273340597748756,
-0.377268522977829,
0.6327093839645386,
0.6564273834228516,
0.0753801092505455,
0.16555559635162354,
-0.05495045706629753,
-0.13892871141433716,
-0.11308055371046066,
-0.5003767013549805,
-0.778546929359436,
0.9616934657096863,
0.36459264159202576,
0.9269682168960571,
-0.08334862440824509,
0.8353810906410217,
-0.3170127868652344,
0.13000205159187317,
-0.6882889270782471,
0.46103182435035706,
0.2894929051399231,
-0.5434392094612122,
-0.06481777876615524,
-0.11575502902269363,
-0.9620853662490845,
-0.05769746005535126,
-0.03914282098412514,
-0.7555454969406128,
0.24548691511154175,
0.5026971697807312,
-0.6213655471801758,
0.19076590240001678,
-0.498759001493454,
0.6182564496994019,
-0.3286859095096588,
-0.25174427032470703,
0.043404895812273026,
-0.7732216119766235,
0.4685612618923187,
0.03984322398900986,
-0.08804313838481903,
-0.38791486620903015,
-0.16056892275810242,
0.7431308031082153,
-0.21328918635845184,
1.0923051834106445,
-0.06485952436923981,
-0.16297206282615662,
0.2777347266674042,
0.36511608958244324,
0.7551936507225037,
0.041206296533346176,
0.08781266957521439,
-0.10763328522443771,
0.15610897541046143,
-0.31678369641304016,
-0.5093129277229309,
0.5110717415809631,
-0.8304386138916016,
-0.8349522948265076,
-0.39520102739334106,
-0.4449065327644348,
-0.37233275175094604,
0.19992265105247498,
0.3703857660293579,
0.17749859392642975,
0.013242246583104134,
0.13529595732688904,
0.9864014387130737,
-0.037599481642246246,
0.30179163813591003,
0.3803216814994812,
0.068967305123806,
-0.31277722120285034,
0.5180678963661194,
-0.17619232833385468,
0.34798845648765564,
-0.022428423166275024,
0.2985878586769104,
-0.10807278007268906,
-0.7256460189819336,
-0.13317334651947021,
0.08367735147476196,
-0.5814998149871826,
-0.6456004977226257,
-0.3170021176338196,
-0.02643546275794506,
-0.443389356136322,
-0.22461245954036713,
-0.4029073715209961,
-0.5547680854797363,
-0.43709439039230347,
-0.45360395312309265,
0.6031008958816528,
0.5646254420280457,
-0.22499796748161316,
0.6818183660507202,
-0.8929973840713501,
-0.0465833880007267,
0.19247764348983765,
0.320354700088501,
-0.21449023485183716,
-0.35297736525535583,
0.22196075320243835,
-0.019189506769180298,
-0.45865875482559204,
-0.6116136908531189,
0.1738501936197281,
-0.031926944851875305,
0.5300312638282776,
0.7023614645004272,
0.28431928157806396,
0.8811724781990051,
-0.43796369433403015,
0.7104251384735107,
0.13181693851947784,
-0.7299681901931763,
0.7160043716430664,
-0.7812342047691345,
0.057588543742895126,
0.7736647129058838,
0.21392284333705902,
-0.817135214805603,
-0.34201160073280334,
-0.3742222785949707,
-0.7246721386909485,
0.4647049307823181,
0.13483519852161407,
0.08260368555784225,
-0.06324665248394012,
0.6216626763343811,
0.19195494055747986,
0.3196675777435303,
-0.368612140417099,
0.03657529130578041,
-0.19408577680587769,
-0.41238394379615784,
0.051460593938827515,
-0.4378357231616974,
-0.7235763072967529,
-0.31448787450790405,
0.3577909469604492,
-0.10558740794658661,
0.23643897473812103,
-0.026616336777806282,
0.06715615838766098,
-0.29409581422805786,
0.2812742590904236,
0.8929288983345032,
0.4090717136859894,
-0.12067454308271408,
0.10229582339525223,
0.15874789655208588,
-0.33646759390830994,
0.4410984516143799,
-0.21770250797271729,
-0.27802735567092896,
-0.6997677683830261,
0.12595106661319733,
0.686086893081665,
0.3465719521045685,
-0.28965622186660767,
0.339977502822876,
-0.17804120481014252,
0.011786657385528088,
-0.06031240150332451,
0.5222668647766113,
-0.0216447152197361,
0.10110790282487869,
-0.03842475637793541,
0.34277722239494324,
-0.326282262802124,
-0.24899813532829285,
0.18679484724998474,
0.3510556221008301,
-0.44810980558395386,
-0.31650418043136597,
0.8584531545639038,
0.2556655704975128,
-0.2680325210094452,
0.7531663179397583,
0.022595390677452087,
-0.3270699679851532,
0.5329402089118958,
0.546297550201416,
0.8287891745567322,
-0.27589091658592224,
-0.26676446199417114,
0.13165035843849182,
0.4805639386177063,
-0.36049285531044006,
0.29415127635002136,
0.11027747392654419,
-0.629622220993042,
-0.09017132967710495,
-0.2486208826303482,
-0.41433411836624146,
-0.022552208974957466,
-0.825804591178894,
0.3467690050601959,
-0.729337751865387,
-0.12834139168262482,
-0.5033681392669678,
-0.20249375700950623,
-0.6376116275787354,
-0.004023423418402672,
0.13062620162963867,
1.044201135635376,
-0.7534602880477905,
0.718146562576294,
0.46045568585395813,
0.05632619932293892,
-0.9110032916069031,
0.08291003108024597,
0.565967857837677,
-0.960990309715271,
0.2575470209121704,
0.1599600911140442,
0.11927685141563416,
-0.021201923489570618,
-0.7206178307533264,
-1.018398404121399,
1.1999492645263672,
0.5829684734344482,
-0.7279907464981079,
-0.018339231610298157,
0.014031781814992428,
0.3087434470653534,
-0.0417475625872612,
-0.06431788206100464,
0.7018257975578308,
0.48251673579216003,
-0.04085126519203186,
-1.0499664545059204,
0.14831042289733887,
0.06055146083235741,
-0.05793745443224907,
0.15482376515865326,
-0.7120219469070435,
0.8140076398849487,
-0.07202412188053131,
-0.26687464118003845,
0.3532598316669464,
0.4879370331764221,
0.5773720741271973,
0.31666746735572815,
0.5150787234306335,
0.592570424079895,
1.0498723983764648,
-0.30158135294914246,
0.9498516321182251,
-0.39237359166145325,
0.03575648367404938,
0.9621476531028748,
-0.36643803119659424,
0.533068835735321,
0.6222860813140869,
0.23008736968040466,
-0.18632549047470093,
1.1233004331588745,
0.21100886166095734,
0.6874030232429504,
-0.030087074264883995,
0.05223969370126724,
-0.4784153997898102,
-0.08814815431833267,
-0.4965626895427704,
0.4839702248573303,
0.33873623609542847,
0.04869880527257919,
-0.2909465730190277,
-0.2335122674703598,
0.319620281457901,
-0.16341076791286469,
-0.25001898407936096,
0.9251077771186829,
0.23436512053012848,
-0.709680438041687,
0.5884219408035278,
-0.23533029854297638,
0.639232873916626,
-0.35616281628608704,
0.2927761375904083,
-0.5542957782745361,
0.11894182860851288,
-0.017220092937350273,
-0.6996773481369019,
0.2902812063694,
-0.03247775882482529,
0.10689420253038406,
-0.2809726893901825,
0.6742458939552307,
-0.0633462518453598,
-0.10975578427314758,
-0.08931326866149902,
0.43686965107917786,
-0.16142021119594574,
0.09137383103370667,
-0.5713875889778137,
0.040542759001255035,
-0.21757911145687103,
-0.34184008836746216,
0.6469687819480896,
0.5418766736984253,
-0.2698218524456024,
0.6717480421066284,
0.6094188094139099,
-0.11528799682855606,
0.025615382939577103,
-0.31591251492500305,
1.033622145652771,
-0.663180410861969,
-0.5894530415534973,
-0.8393123745918274,
0.607214093208313,
0.12082914263010025,
-0.4728931486606598,
0.7048643827438354,
0.2929861843585968,
0.5628671050071716,
0.20170487463474274,
0.5426763892173767,
0.44135257601737976,
0.3943163752555847,
-0.8136199116706848,
0.8099997043609619,
-0.3122725784778595,
0.206364244222641,
-0.07828308641910553,
-0.6912893056869507,
-0.3321942985057831,
0.47289028763771057,
-0.1691575050354004,
-0.2254890501499176,
0.47716087102890015,
1.0027143955230713,
-0.1278148740530014,
0.0683736577630043,
0.18292750418186188,
0.054127249866724014,
0.6769434809684753,
0.3457734286785126,
1.0746921300888062,
-0.40469589829444885,
0.5184769630432129,
-0.24283745884895325,
-0.11369604617357254,
-0.21558867394924164,
-1.2094756364822388,
-0.8231091499328613,
-0.3763887286186218,
-0.35228806734085083,
-0.44103044271469116,
0.17553384602069855,
0.984438955783844,
0.6206178665161133,
-0.7242863774299622,
-0.08554165810346603,
-0.03535936400294304,
0.20213615894317627,
-0.34006500244140625,
-0.06714320182800293,
0.15326987206935883,
-0.4950118660926819,
-0.48351091146469116,
0.5089120268821716,
0.2971973121166229,
0.650607168674469,
0.259981244802475,
-0.006283772177994251,
0.19122877717018127,
-0.0562855489552021,
0.20497310161590576,
0.3879813849925995,
-0.5797643065452576,
-0.5301482081413269,
0.032445065677165985,
-0.34199345111846924,
0.2660905718803406,
0.8730446696281433,
-0.5244402289390564,
0.0865386575460434,
0.39346781373023987,
0.49738559126853943,
-0.0272649135440588,
0.15572884678840637,
1.0440382957458496,
-0.6521872878074646,
0.3903801143169403,
0.22475847601890564,
0.418302983045578,
0.22027871012687683,
-0.5333062410354614,
0.5080069899559021,
-0.024249477311968803,
-0.7200663089752197,
-1.174698829650879,
0.32194241881370544,
-1.0325905084609985,
0.21115319430828094,
1.088761568069458,
-0.011247036047279835,
-0.2639401853084564,
-0.20995458960533142,
-0.4178328514099121,
0.5823685526847839,
-0.3608686923980713,
1.00645112991333,
0.3862197697162628,
-0.19083793461322784,
-0.21337783336639404,
-0.5084331035614014,
0.8882594704627991,
0.5074664354324341,
-0.6630843281745911,
0.15937954187393188,
0.18733511865139008,
0.415223628282547,
-0.29014021158218384,
0.4444532096385956,
-0.008321447297930717,
0.4516133964061737,
-0.3416769206523895,
-0.45021018385887146,
-0.25463226437568665,
-0.22298645973205566,
-0.6127009987831116,
-0.22527232766151428,
0.3346122205257416,
-0.40951529145240784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18510v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18510v3
|
RNNs are not Transformers (Yet): The Key Bottleneck on In-context Retrieval
| 2024-02-28T17:38:06 | 2024-05-10T08:55:21 |
Kaiyue Wen, Xingyu Dang, Kaifeng Lyu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
This paper investigates the gap in representation powers of Recurrent Neural
Networks (RNNs) and Transformers in the context of solving algorithmic
problems. We focus on understanding whether RNNs, known for their memory
efficiency in handling long sequences, can match the performance of
Transformers, particularly when enhanced with Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting.
Our theoretical analysis reveals that CoT improves RNNs but is insufficient to
close the gap with Transformers. A key bottleneck lies in the inability of RNNs
to perfectly retrieve information from the context, even with CoT: for several
tasks that explicitly or implicitly require this capability, such as
associative recall and determining if a graph is a tree, we prove that RNNs are
not expressive enough to solve the tasks while Transformers can solve them with
ease. Conversely, we prove that adopting techniques to enhance the in-context
retrieval capability of RNNs, including Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
and adding a single Transformer layer, can elevate RNNs to be capable of
solving all polynomial-time solvable problems with CoT, hence closing the
representation gap with Transformers.
|
[
-0.6370551586151123,
-0.36537647247314453,
0.5943675637245178,
0.2573367655277252,
-0.17769627273082733,
0.45359382033348083,
-0.3062726557254791,
-0.44433674216270447,
0.1679057478904724,
0.38266420364379883,
-0.5645052194595337,
0.20396029949188232,
-0.6794614791870117,
0.5152515769004822,
-0.6732880473136902,
0.7333635091781616,
0.0965489000082016,
-0.32644617557525635,
-0.25117480754852295,
-0.26681897044181824,
-0.6378676891326904,
-0.49359217286109924,
-0.6113806366920471,
-0.5968900322914124,
0.5904719233512878,
0.26037368178367615,
0.4510595202445984,
0.39354434609413147,
0.6257708668708801,
0.37720954418182373,
-0.2767197787761688,
0.29517754912376404,
-0.5685661435127258,
0.5173836350440979,
-0.22344981133937836,
-0.33072972297668457,
0.10470976680517197,
-0.34287673234939575,
0.5084980130195618,
0.6398345232009888,
-0.09682357311248779,
0.28512445092201233,
0.011145403608679771,
1.0979562997817993,
-0.5846021771430969,
-0.011223590932786465,
-0.8986210227012634,
0.36286741495132446,
-0.02070040814578533,
-0.5107707381248474,
-0.543509840965271,
-0.09098055213689804,
0.5446704626083374,
-0.43614932894706726,
0.4005180299282074,
0.03978634253144264,
0.6045886874198914,
0.6586624979972839,
-0.10030262917280197,
-0.264724463224411,
-0.9157225489616394,
0.777664065361023,
-0.36259040236473083,
0.05693882331252098,
0.018493056297302246,
0.3485400080680847,
-0.32922425866127014,
-0.9178726673126221,
-0.42849984765052795,
0.027479970827698708,
-0.135751411318779,
-0.05236263573169708,
-0.3460286259651184,
-0.0541633777320385,
0.7448079586029053,
0.395012766122818,
-0.1815912276506424,
-0.339619904756546,
-0.4622323513031006,
0.10616043210029602,
0.33405086398124695,
0.1239539384841919,
0.011839641258120537,
-0.35173892974853516,
-0.5369453430175781,
-0.063747338950634,
-0.5307304859161377,
-0.10776287317276001,
-0.13976435363292694,
0.2866455614566803,
0.1679304987192154,
0.35622021555900574,
0.2959337830543518,
0.8002035617828369,
0.012573065236210823,
0.3303622007369995,
0.16304321587085724,
-0.2389703243970871,
-0.031177004799246788,
0.1463182419538498,
0.5983807444572449,
-0.10505694150924683,
0.5200324058532715,
-0.4095712900161743,
-0.36008358001708984,
-0.1295747607946396,
0.8180883526802063,
-0.4746016561985016,
-0.14401210844516754,
-0.06780563294887543,
-0.39521652460098267,
-0.1261981576681137,
0.3012253940105438,
-0.7878265380859375,
-0.20158740878105164,
-0.27841636538505554,
0.42480188608169556,
-0.10987002402544022,
-0.17024041712284088,
-0.14608177542686462,
-0.46728214621543884,
0.18519911170005798,
-0.04162340238690376,
-0.6453703045845032,
0.3031970262527466,
0.7619722485542297,
1.0149598121643066,
-0.013714303262531757,
0.025081487372517586,
0.02529352717101574,
-0.17164446413516998,
-0.4511973261833191,
0.5533883571624756,
-0.4802819490432739,
-0.431406706571579,
-0.2642914354801178,
-0.2170218974351883,
-0.16925787925720215,
-0.7314589023590088,
0.020205164328217506,
-0.7146128416061401,
-0.08517259359359741,
-0.39847859740257263,
-0.36177822947502136,
0.03450457379221916,
-0.02613453008234501,
-1.0899934768676758,
1.0700230598449707,
0.3013055920600891,
-0.5834566950798035,
0.07571699470281601,
-0.469049870967865,
-0.4680735766887665,
-0.07687536627054214,
-0.4984891712665558,
-0.4217994511127472,
0.2574990689754486,
0.1144770011305809,
0.13691654801368713,
-0.3900538980960846,
0.21984729170799255,
0.1997484266757965,
-0.7459302544593811,
0.38984471559524536,
-0.516661524772644,
0.3891226649284363,
0.19971226155757904,
-0.6893153786659241,
-0.23203954100608826,
-0.3429657518863678,
0.21478864550590515,
0.06480783224105835,
-0.15839627385139465,
0.003047418314963579,
0.05228686332702637,
-0.27393588423728943,
0.3568156957626343,
0.04721473157405853,
-0.5173376202583313,
0.29509449005126953,
-0.34054234623908997,
0.8333542346954346,
0.8897594809532166,
-0.16400374472141266,
0.40053218603134155,
-0.3428819179534912,
0.4263891577720642,
-0.08537589758634567,
-0.2760830521583557,
-0.26284700632095337,
-0.6536266207695007,
-0.8260840773582458,
0.3616850972175598,
0.28551721572875977,
0.2936473488807678,
-0.9320581555366516,
0.22341391444206238,
-0.39595234394073486,
0.03632687032222748,
-0.45825397968292236,
-0.171255961060524,
0.6179163455963135,
0.6079477667808533,
0.47730952501296997,
-0.4383971393108368,
-0.9977526664733887,
-0.866837203502655,
-0.4501935839653015,
0.11482291668653488,
-0.0164051353931427,
0.5267840623855591,
0.5182631611824036,
0.07388922572135925,
1.0259039402008057,
-0.05912100896239281,
-0.20011579990386963,
-0.41359540820121765,
0.2796284556388855,
0.5233274698257446,
0.44107580184936523,
0.016008548438549042,
-1.0773344039916992,
-0.23454587161540985,
-0.04651299864053726,
-0.8055787682533264,
0.16162197291851044,
-0.2005113661289215,
0.2988934814929962,
0.25720298290252686,
0.5891788601875305,
-0.671249508857727,
0.7699739933013916,
0.19106316566467285,
0.0049122534692287445,
0.2147655338048935,
-0.2892221510410309,
-0.18835420906543732,
-0.6557202935218811,
0.2884984612464905,
-0.18193519115447998,
-0.22885434329509735,
-0.5455905199050903,
-0.11756032705307007,
-0.00890687108039856,
-0.2396419495344162,
-0.20484350621700287,
0.33106938004493713,
-0.39871644973754883,
-0.2992718815803528,
-0.3322645127773285,
0.28791558742523193,
-0.003730039345100522,
0.6598548293113708,
0.052293527871370316,
1.0075215101242065,
0.19942094385623932,
-0.7630907893180847,
0.0818786472082138,
0.07580704241991043,
-0.3230600357055664,
0.12129919975996017,
-0.6408517360687256,
0.4228261113166809,
-0.4327012896537781,
0.5538331270217896,
-0.6374516487121582,
0.022682059556245804,
0.011758655309677124,
-0.42932698130607605,
0.38189706206321716,
-0.027367131784558296,
-0.31005460023880005,
-0.680466890335083,
-0.038753025233745575,
1.0172208547592163,
0.5908414125442505,
-0.7086609601974487,
0.5191692113876343,
-0.007682133931666613,
0.5355356335639954,
-1.0156327486038208,
-0.873793363571167,
0.06472478806972504,
-0.04034774377942085,
-0.2960486114025116,
0.7612535953521729,
0.47955313324928284,
-0.000964619277510792,
0.16797755658626556,
-0.5680462121963501,
0.20699991285800934,
-0.1797848343849182,
0.08061216026544571,
-0.02643883228302002,
-0.21026085317134857,
0.3130326271057129,
-0.5779880285263062,
-0.5818197131156921,
0.05211016163229942,
-0.4128389060497284,
0.4613127112388611,
-0.4277589023113251,
-0.21645261347293854,
-0.20790566504001617,
0.3520330488681793,
0.4776836335659027,
-0.25215598940849304,
0.491739958524704,
0.287788450717926,
-0.2911665737628937,
-0.4253627359867096,
-0.5227522253990173,
-0.2755151093006134,
-0.49627983570098877,
0.2553883492946625,
-0.3077842593193054,
-0.8609950542449951,
0.41350680589675903,
-0.16317494213581085,
-0.21877235174179077,
0.30738088488578796,
0.15628834068775177,
-0.17700785398483276,
0.7493879199028015,
0.3868227005004883,
-0.14009808003902435,
0.4011407792568207,
-0.8210472464561462,
0.5945907235145569,
-1.3454879522323608,
-0.32430151104927063,
-0.31549081206321716,
-0.9692878127098083,
-0.7907896041870117,
-0.45583397150039673,
0.5098834037780762,
-0.02935974672436714,
-0.5321922302246094,
0.5833728313446045,
-1.0116229057312012,
0.6175641417503357,
0.5589433312416077,
0.18826232850551605,
0.14490492641925812,
-0.06671219319105148,
0.09686253219842911,
0.11077558249235153,
-1.1214553117752075,
-0.16430023312568665,
0.8869262337684631,
0.06861414760351181,
0.568773627281189,
-0.14009180665016174,
0.5798985362052917,
0.05942274630069733,
0.029515957459807396,
-0.5958905220031738,
0.5363659262657166,
-0.28133630752563477,
-0.6374972462654114,
-0.260859876871109,
-0.6563192009925842,
-1.260452389717102,
0.1409682184457779,
0.08656530827283859,
-0.8212703466415405,
0.49691200256347656,
0.13989388942718506,
-0.39831840991973877,
0.7499297261238098,
-0.2905697524547577,
0.6099987626075745,
-0.0647219642996788,
-0.19466175138950348,
-0.28658753633499146,
-0.9007818102836609,
0.05649003013968468,
0.3453454077243805,
-0.1690412014722824,
0.1630432903766632,
0.035599980503320694,
0.6455299854278564,
-0.48772960901260376,
0.35149988532066345,
0.034316033124923706,
0.40306222438812256,
0.6101911067962646,
0.08759132772684097,
0.43128105998039246,
-0.18066160380840302,
-0.10612288862466812,
0.03215210884809494,
-0.3270982801914215,
-0.3411010801792145,
-1.158228874206543,
0.6171603798866272,
-0.35354048013687134,
-0.7003477811813354,
-0.5837721228599548,
-0.4854913353919983,
0.04801999777555466,
-0.010838267393410206,
0.4011685848236084,
0.6945382952690125,
0.26865071058273315,
0.44340983033180237,
0.8435816168785095,
0.0574922114610672,
0.6825933456420898,
-0.3032427728176117,
-0.02313375100493431,
-0.1019744873046875,
1.0122324228286743,
0.22570376098155975,
0.36833903193473816,
0.4222997725009918,
0.0653192326426506,
-0.2260771542787552,
-0.09903358668088913,
-0.5058874487876892,
-0.06630919128656387,
-0.6847591400146484,
-0.496555358171463,
-0.30690303444862366,
-0.5753104090690613,
0.3762963116168976,
-0.042064499109983444,
-0.448439359664917,
-0.6161097288131714,
-0.14242912828922272,
0.09246626496315002,
0.6369348764419556,
0.9293635487556458,
0.032233577221632004,
0.0529792457818985,
-0.3342832028865814,
0.5249760150909424,
0.21636591851711273,
0.5430620312690735,
0.7532888650894165,
-0.23581577837467194,
-0.2365037202835083,
-0.1325141042470932,
-0.5951315760612488,
-0.5368195176124573,
0.06785089522600174,
-0.008239357732236385,
0.21518999338150024,
0.1319955289363861,
-0.16612443327903748,
0.9615674614906311,
-0.4533272981643677,
0.6556304097175598,
0.03915933892130852,
-0.6821436882019043,
0.20935042202472687,
0.10328695923089981,
0.3630993664264679,
0.5733022689819336,
0.2219216525554657,
-0.4378345310688019,
-0.02558872289955616,
-0.7509279847145081,
-1.0168873071670532,
0.7113017439842224,
0.570652186870575,
0.1926930993795395,
-0.19479437172412872,
0.6207204461097717,
-0.2307092845439911,
0.35219070315361023,
-0.5065103769302368,
-0.5422025322914124,
-0.25296691060066223,
-0.015944484621286392,
0.054160818457603455,
-0.012076850980520248,
0.2128629833459854,
-0.3719915747642517,
0.27189990878105164,
0.21773315966129303,
0.7660791277885437,
0.7583067417144775,
0.12685513496398926,
-0.16313238441944122,
0.18315529823303223,
0.3731129467487335,
0.711454451084137,
-0.1359252780675888,
0.1892099827528,
0.20829446613788605,
-0.3623333275318146,
0.22085273265838623,
-0.31815871596336365,
-0.0444536991417408,
0.14912313222885132,
0.4794234037399292,
0.7459995746612549,
0.6328219175338745,
-0.559934139251709,
0.36359477043151855,
0.007155026309192181,
0.08859273791313171,
-0.4538949728012085,
-0.006054408848285675,
-0.13380001485347748,
0.2819496989250183,
0.7572653293609619,
0.5346745848655701,
-0.04508131742477417,
-0.5755372047424316,
0.3957655429840088,
0.6039263010025024,
-0.48425424098968506,
0.12283223122358322,
0.34454432129859924,
-0.0950569286942482,
-0.8778228163719177,
1.0538475513458252,
0.021930303424596786,
-0.7304960489273071,
0.9791321158409119,
0.7574883699417114,
0.879281222820282,
0.07639122009277344,
-0.14848692715168,
0.4959830343723297,
0.10225614160299301,
-0.15540800988674164,
0.19520840048789978,
-0.3575381934642792,
-0.46789127588272095,
-0.5408161282539368,
-0.2352697104215622,
-0.07199843972921371,
0.0640595406293869,
-0.7679933309555054,
-0.12986621260643005,
-0.46893343329429626,
-0.40973910689353943,
-0.28072404861450195,
-0.23659828305244446,
-0.6956075429916382,
-0.08248338103294373,
-0.19123288989067078,
1.0912916660308838,
0.05826592445373535,
0.4127824604511261,
0.02573210932314396,
-0.18354201316833496,
-0.8274449706077576,
-0.10946117341518402,
-0.36933863162994385,
-0.45250216126441956,
0.6304236650466919,
0.550321102142334,
-0.31811031699180603,
0.0069884732365608215,
-0.30797237157821655,
-1.0152134895324707,
1.2070661783218384,
0.07148156315088272,
-0.563822329044342,
-0.3806166350841522,
0.023477844893932343,
0.7283333539962769,
-0.5274410843849182,
0.29310232400894165,
0.6376913785934448,
0.49488961696624756,
0.01949157379567623,
-0.9931387901306152,
-0.05654939264059067,
-0.355082243680954,
0.41915568709373474,
0.5909003019332886,
-0.4477422535419464,
0.9745767116546631,
-0.2837171256542206,
-0.4102586805820465,
0.34380900859832764,
0.5433931946754456,
0.2704005539417267,
0.4891890585422516,
0.3518860638141632,
0.611829936504364,
0.4484439492225647,
-0.20524044334888458,
1.4315109252929688,
-0.1000971645116806,
0.22083720564842224,
1.0182788372039795,
0.18134376406669617,
0.6583835482597351,
0.7109063267707825,
-0.15327391028404236,
0.9483479857444763,
0.1942639797925949,
0.1188434362411499,
0.4351039528846741,
0.47695934772491455,
-0.25711387395858765,
-0.12842167913913727,
0.07055483013391495,
-0.3863426148891449,
0.17355632781982422,
0.4135029911994934,
-0.6482954025268555,
-0.21462802588939667,
0.031140465289354324,
-0.49442169070243835,
0.3540550172328949,
-0.44231632351875305,
0.7417824864387512,
0.5106117725372314,
-0.8432243466377258,
0.7854215502738953,
-0.34675776958465576,
0.4952845871448517,
-0.35736191272735596,
-0.4206397831439972,
0.16676144301891327,
0.06235580891370773,
-0.32044580578804016,
-0.7655344009399414,
0.42454925179481506,
-0.20592264831066132,
-0.2484445720911026,
-0.27458226680755615,
0.6834337711334229,
-0.04395308718085289,
-0.34877246618270874,
0.4001806974411011,
0.4284180700778961,
0.07929259538650513,
0.10274963825941086,
-0.4976412355899811,
0.051423002034425735,
-0.23306958377361298,
-0.1295105665922165,
0.06619591265916824,
0.3089580237865448,
-0.1350613534450531,
1.0699106454849243,
0.25275659561157227,
-0.06952700763940811,
0.08388891071081161,
0.08229198306798935,
0.8319292664527893,
-0.8996396660804749,
-0.07404331862926483,
-0.8637717962265015,
0.3165249526500702,
0.010680917650461197,
-0.29194116592407227,
0.43374085426330566,
0.34283238649368286,
0.9309929609298706,
0.04314232990145683,
0.4985370337963104,
-0.2638072073459625,
0.2103031873703003,
-0.33958372473716736,
0.41698092222213745,
-0.3356008529663086,
0.38607266545295715,
-0.23736847937107086,
-0.9768614768981934,
-0.1404571384191513,
0.8650540709495544,
-0.2235381007194519,
0.37006887793540955,
0.7060220241546631,
0.7397951483726501,
-0.20784352719783783,
0.37596601247787476,
-0.09628581255674362,
0.020317871123552322,
0.012183990329504013,
0.9730215668678284,
0.8797075748443604,
-0.6541200280189514,
0.4794871509075165,
-0.369640588760376,
0.048187416046857834,
0.00678997440263629,
-0.8194782137870789,
-0.6112745404243469,
-0.8265897035598755,
0.21332687139511108,
-0.47808289527893066,
0.18175984919071198,
0.9113225340843201,
0.6617070436477661,
-0.560101330280304,
-0.26742249727249146,
-0.6344504356384277,
0.5775695443153381,
-0.4149525463581085,
-0.25169357657432556,
0.323207288980484,
-0.5798688530921936,
-0.266631543636322,
0.43203088641166687,
0.2627509534358978,
-0.21291528642177582,
-0.4259687066078186,
-0.008415703661739826,
-0.08566806465387344,
-0.20196916162967682,
0.5531495809555054,
0.5946024656295776,
-0.8256949186325073,
-0.2938823997974396,
0.1697787046432495,
0.10695642977952957,
0.3838297724723816,
1.3975749015808105,
-1.5753545761108398,
0.5614943504333496,
0.34763455390930176,
0.8487241864204407,
0.6615474224090576,
0.13768352568149567,
0.5866454839706421,
-0.8784788250923157,
0.165122389793396,
0.6002901196479797,
0.13760176301002502,
0.17296740412712097,
-0.33421701192855835,
0.5263678431510925,
-0.12322429567575455,
-0.7553976774215698,
-0.7311483025550842,
0.48340168595314026,
-0.7339433431625366,
-0.24781319499015808,
0.6748731732368469,
0.2172420769929886,
-0.3984197676181793,
-0.24160052835941315,
0.05859890952706337,
0.1661975383758545,
-0.21487796306610107,
0.8900359869003296,
0.4648687243461609,
-0.5869218111038208,
-0.08294686675071716,
-0.5141727924346924,
0.7231043577194214,
0.5873104333877563,
0.0033828015439212322,
-0.024035906419157982,
-0.15867866575717926,
-0.2253003865480423,
0.5946173667907715,
0.4308953583240509,
-0.24661126732826233,
0.5235046148300171,
-0.2561008930206299,
-0.4639592170715332,
-0.12931540608406067,
-0.6889669895172119,
-0.3990909457206726,
0.01860634796321392,
-0.2512044310569763,
0.15087978541851044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18502v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18502v1
|
Few-Shot Fairness: Unveiling LLM's Potential for Fairness-Aware Classification
| 2024-02-28T17:29:27 | 2024-02-28T17:29:27 |
Garima Chhikara, Anurag Sharma, Kripabandhu Ghosh, Abhijnan Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Employing Large Language Models (LLM) in various downstream applications such
as classification is crucial, especially for smaller companies lacking the
expertise and resources required for fine-tuning a model. Fairness in LLMs
helps ensure inclusivity, equal representation based on factors such as race,
gender and promotes responsible AI deployment. As the use of LLMs has become
increasingly prevalent, it is essential to assess whether LLMs can generate
fair outcomes when subjected to considerations of fairness. In this study, we
introduce a framework outlining fairness regulations aligned with various
fairness definitions, with each definition being modulated by varying degrees
of abstraction. We explore the configuration for in-context learning and the
procedure for selecting in-context demonstrations using RAG, while
incorporating fairness rules into the process. Experiments conducted with
different LLMs indicate that GPT-4 delivers superior results in terms of both
accuracy and fairness compared to other models. This work is one of the early
attempts to achieve fairness in prediction tasks by utilizing LLMs through
in-context learning.
|
[
-0.18580928444862366,
-0.4293760359287262,
0.6783961653709412,
0.016832556575536728,
-0.030819715932011604,
-0.09321387857198715,
-0.057605210691690445,
-0.536849856376648,
-0.4983008801937103,
0.35899221897125244,
-0.292042076587677,
-0.39720508456230164,
-0.752757728099823,
0.0836242139339447,
-0.40585821866989136,
1.2832539081573486,
0.17060041427612305,
0.35349833965301514,
-0.14071489870548248,
-0.18360893428325653,
-0.5196769833564758,
-0.5631355047225952,
-0.8229875564575195,
-0.6737770438194275,
0.43241339921951294,
0.47924497723579407,
0.3480052351951599,
0.5595134496688843,
0.4438278377056122,
0.39224469661712646,
-0.07817881554365158,
-0.34424158930778503,
-0.5342552661895752,
-0.169154554605484,
-0.2187131643295288,
-0.7963287234306335,
-0.4820999205112457,
0.4182020425796509,
0.7545731663703918,
0.6823551058769226,
-0.21375761926174164,
0.3082183301448822,
0.3677571415901184,
0.4917365610599518,
-0.8000553846359253,
0.08483869582414627,
-0.9198241233825684,
0.4718412160873413,
-0.46621617674827576,
-0.11098188906908035,
-0.3816753327846527,
-0.36224427819252014,
-0.11568701267242432,
-0.4608643054962158,
0.09691710025072098,
0.2725978493690491,
0.6610791087150574,
0.3574415445327759,
-0.48275041580200195,
-0.2005218118429184,
-0.43202129006385803,
1.085476279258728,
-0.7811896800994873,
0.17183002829551697,
0.2559756338596344,
0.8454721570014954,
-0.20643199980258942,
-0.8456892371177673,
-0.6948539614677429,
0.1545417159795761,
-0.178901806473732,
0.17749609053134918,
0.053691692650318146,
0.25648972392082214,
0.41095083951950073,
0.17962467670440674,
-0.23675110936164856,
0.5843452215194702,
-0.18046240508556366,
-0.2746455669403076,
0.3516729176044464,
0.29127976298332214,
-0.20196408033370972,
-0.2854028046131134,
-0.3173145651817322,
0.40043437480926514,
-0.7686411142349243,
0.17061330378055573,
0.47451427578926086,
0.47850242257118225,
-0.3245684504508972,
0.4264809489250183,
-0.3204950988292694,
0.5928550958633423,
-0.06114625930786133,
-0.48013627529144287,
0.24960586428642273,
0.06698548048734665,
-0.5510075092315674,
0.19860564172267914,
0.5015469193458557,
0.24808982014656067,
0.1419246643781662,
0.012922655791044235,
-0.5482364296913147,
-0.06898181885480881,
0.012129162438213825,
-0.8574281334877014,
0.2747521698474884,
-0.052528467029333115,
-0.7184581756591797,
-0.4044119715690613,
-0.06669045239686966,
-0.7379679083824158,
-0.56949383020401,
-0.36234909296035767,
0.5590710639953613,
0.24624428153038025,
-0.055769387632608414,
-0.063163623213768,
-0.1053396612405777,
0.5443744659423828,
0.462051123380661,
-0.8781709671020508,
0.3944220542907715,
1.0579607486724854,
0.722847580909729,
-0.08778490126132965,
-0.12789319455623627,
-0.9682230353355408,
0.2698468863964081,
-0.1685074120759964,
0.5411840677261353,
-0.500341534614563,
-0.09473667293787003,
-0.06182350963354111,
-0.24131497740745544,
0.2803727388381958,
-0.5113111138343811,
0.5667660236358643,
-0.5592398643493652,
0.2911140024662018,
-0.1576027125120163,
-0.6993242502212524,
-0.2749321162700653,
0.47887706756591797,
-0.3510921895503998,
0.29685720801353455,
0.24469219148159027,
-0.8249620795249939,
0.79638671875,
-0.9257475733757019,
-0.30760762095451355,
0.35262104868888855,
-0.7286487221717834,
-0.48830392956733704,
0.04421122372150421,
-0.2502362132072449,
0.6373810172080994,
-0.01974627748131752,
0.0010653197532519698,
-0.48335763812065125,
-0.7024831771850586,
0.15508143603801727,
-0.7231915593147278,
0.692017138004303,
0.35117852687835693,
-0.6049239635467529,
-0.016433874145150185,
-0.2473682165145874,
-0.14007386565208435,
-0.049929965287446976,
-0.46724164485931396,
0.08957754820585251,
-0.22015288472175598,
-0.06054932251572609,
0.3461090326309204,
-0.08032882213592529,
-0.3861398994922638,
-0.2645738124847412,
-0.5248168110847473,
0.24623173475265503,
1.3394256830215454,
-0.5504902601242065,
0.9476475119590759,
-0.405735045671463,
0.6345767974853516,
-0.05361229553818703,
0.40969133377075195,
0.15898677706718445,
-0.6206637024879456,
-0.4945727586746216,
-0.48225903511047363,
0.43786147236824036,
0.5225609540939331,
-0.536896824836731,
-0.041024550795555115,
-0.32393646240234375,
0.06993778795003891,
-0.4104599952697754,
0.19229869544506073,
0.37487322092056274,
0.7739505767822266,
-0.07384872436523438,
-0.21144422888755798,
-0.3102554380893707,
-0.8639155626296997,
-0.26081353425979614,
0.06408815830945969,
0.0038983640260994434,
0.5764291882514954,
0.3806304931640625,
-0.1551545262336731,
1.0526037216186523,
-0.10392755270004272,
-0.6362580060958862,
-0.2611320912837982,
-0.07361545413732529,
0.37207773327827454,
0.1750897914171219,
0.7237587571144104,
-0.8464750647544861,
-0.40352755784988403,
0.08232695609331131,
-0.8217015862464905,
-0.16182632744312286,
0.2991693317890167,
-0.16650477051734924,
0.4185008704662323,
0.537365198135376,
-0.13682831823825836,
0.6125304102897644,
0.4355827271938324,
-0.14770913124084473,
0.2662813365459442,
0.09944067895412445,
0.2500358819961548,
-0.6968563199043274,
-0.19108109176158905,
-0.06282342970371246,
-0.6366627216339111,
-0.3370722830295563,
-0.020769568160176277,
-0.1374243050813675,
0.1991168111562729,
-0.9776182174682617,
0.9127092957496643,
0.05722996965050697,
-0.5998740792274475,
-0.6083913445472717,
0.181095689535141,
-0.25709956884384155,
0.2813110947608948,
-0.30801886320114136,
0.5925747752189636,
0.4884573519229889,
-0.7211509943008423,
-0.047236040234565735,
-0.14012905955314636,
-0.23911048471927643,
0.7974453568458557,
-0.15835176408290863,
-0.020401248708367348,
-0.313770592212677,
0.39236828684806824,
-0.49296706914901733,
-0.3939965069293976,
0.2579064667224884,
-0.2833555042743683,
0.26098141074180603,
-0.5930092334747314,
-0.5039022564888,
-0.07833363860845566,
-0.2955678403377533,
0.6524267792701721,
0.7936458587646484,
-0.7085002660751343,
0.7339801788330078,
0.5351480841636658,
-0.12105780094861984,
-0.8078832626342773,
-0.8937865495681763,
-0.141621395945549,
-0.7477511167526245,
-0.32469990849494934,
0.3105924725532532,
-0.05103869363665581,
-0.36728426814079285,
-0.29967033863067627,
-0.0024779594969004393,
-0.06988457590341568,
0.4025171995162964,
0.38224300742149353,
0.019633319228887558,
0.14986665546894073,
0.016147518530488014,
0.11672503501176834,
-0.13114477694034576,
-0.1746620386838913,
-0.03859708830714226,
0.2740856409072876,
-0.21034395694732666,
-0.477102130651474,
-0.4465698301792145,
0.1271614283323288,
0.05661473423242569,
0.2848097085952759,
0.2355286329984665,
0.7649445533752441,
-0.588530421257019,
-0.3371562063694,
-0.39127618074417114,
-0.14723671972751617,
-0.5751162171363831,
0.19991430640220642,
-0.3835638165473938,
-1.262812614440918,
0.5123534798622131,
-0.09714041650295258,
0.24369987845420837,
0.10922632366418839,
0.6050800085067749,
-0.1967407912015915,
0.8963617086410522,
0.9183348417282104,
-0.10415139049291611,
0.5303048491477966,
-0.002022289903834462,
0.2109042853116989,
-0.4613155126571655,
-0.19301645457744598,
-0.5304391384124756,
-0.5285945534706116,
-0.8822131752967834,
-0.2775178551673889,
0.45495808124542236,
0.11479375511407852,
-0.6502519845962524,
-0.42890292406082153,
-0.1590687483549118,
0.944331169128418,
0.6202581524848938,
-0.07885967940092087,
0.4144991934299469,
0.044796381145715714,
-0.006878585088998079,
-0.09997545182704926,
-0.6734915375709534,
-0.8342677354812622,
1.133131742477417,
0.5687518119812012,
0.7087624073028564,
0.37783804535865784,
0.9111791849136353,
0.41868844628334045,
0.9064401388168335,
-0.9517870545387268,
0.48105424642562866,
-0.5119041800498962,
-0.5715140104293823,
-0.1530652642250061,
-0.6612533926963806,
-0.7446597218513489,
0.18352293968200684,
-0.19701603055000305,
-0.5231413841247559,
-0.05336190015077591,
0.26397037506103516,
-0.4326288104057312,
0.33299145102500916,
-0.8078782558441162,
0.7195125222206116,
-0.28235167264938354,
-0.3472774624824524,
-0.27752143144607544,
-0.5673170685768127,
0.6209420561790466,
-0.3327292799949646,
0.5953317880630493,
-0.43021106719970703,
-0.16406035423278809,
0.587573230266571,
-0.08684900403022766,
0.8515629172325134,
-0.4854714274406433,
0.0274492297321558,
0.04552086442708969,
0.10032442957162857,
0.1256888061761856,
0.0817761942744255,
-0.2727212905883789,
0.4444151520729065,
-0.44304633140563965,
-0.38285619020462036,
-0.4733969271183014,
0.7402324676513672,
-0.4259488582611084,
-0.4638141989707947,
-0.5725045800209045,
-0.30829572677612305,
-0.10208537429571152,
0.20179545879364014,
0.07964427769184113,
0.05761883035302162,
0.08040013164281845,
-0.05317484959959984,
0.45523378252983093,
-0.3682699501514435,
0.7880384922027588,
0.5268347859382629,
-0.3698144853115082,
0.0532558411359787,
0.6750239729881287,
-0.12624315917491913,
0.1872960329055786,
0.23465850949287415,
0.3075246512889862,
-0.48123475909233093,
-0.6450262069702148,
-0.14541779458522797,
-0.1610213965177536,
-0.9717159271240234,
-0.6791521906852722,
-0.3460516035556793,
-0.21963468194007874,
-0.2728373110294342,
-0.25450849533081055,
-0.1229470819234848,
-0.30420511960983276,
-0.20197030901908875,
-0.07711377739906311,
0.14386425912380219,
0.9230360388755798,
-0.1760743260383606,
0.44744089245796204,
-0.45869573950767517,
0.2955149710178375,
0.6494572162628174,
0.7616678476333618,
-0.13602674007415771,
-0.7949791550636292,
-0.056223709136247635,
-0.07017956674098969,
-0.46816059947013855,
-0.3340054154396057,
0.10890206694602966,
0.13802720606327057,
0.862188458442688,
0.30651557445526123,
-0.22755196690559387,
0.38770195841789246,
-0.7463301420211792,
0.6414562463760376,
0.302701860666275,
-1.0704762935638428,
0.3694719076156616,
-0.09029053151607513,
-0.11228366196155548,
0.4286489188671112,
0.19989357888698578,
-0.2027587592601776,
-0.391004353761673,
-0.2508176863193512,
-0.6747319102287292,
0.8586686849594116,
0.16876500844955444,
0.3615417778491974,
0.09299995005130768,
0.4930354654788971,
0.36824172735214233,
0.3122994005680084,
-1.1955931186676025,
-0.08961346000432968,
-0.1542036384344101,
-0.36313241720199585,
0.1806316375732422,
0.011608592234551907,
-0.14834097027778625,
-0.06940867751836777,
0.4081190526485443,
-0.31045687198638916,
0.19528555870056152,
-0.27005672454833984,
-0.21619202196598053,
0.08173946291208267,
0.5217915773391724,
0.49239256978034973,
0.6161224246025085,
-0.048200465738773346,
0.08540138602256775,
0.3658745586872101,
-0.10396996885538101,
0.09503044933080673,
-0.008451140485703945,
-0.14328157901763916,
-0.3691740334033966,
0.04491253197193146,
0.5517124533653259,
0.07721664011478424,
-0.5798489451408386,
0.8444001078605652,
-0.19727638363838196,
-0.11249058693647385,
-0.12063005566596985,
0.26184213161468506,
-0.2281770408153534,
0.6722524166107178,
0.32514524459838867,
-0.15082280337810516,
0.6221226453781128,
-0.4261418879032135,
0.19651682674884796,
0.5728643536567688,
-0.17125020921230316,
0.2415827214717865,
0.7166761159896851,
0.3336137533187866,
-0.10214555263519287,
0.4574110805988312,
-0.7486822009086609,
-0.49453800916671753,
0.42944425344467163,
0.2849212884902954,
0.8023493885993958,
0.13956104218959808,
-0.03777366504073143,
0.006392115727066994,
0.07082707434892654,
-0.09606008976697922,
-0.10250981152057648,
0.07975564897060394,
-0.8519615530967712,
-0.4227849543094635,
-0.861335277557373,
-0.38106152415275574,
-0.06809349358081818,
-0.2160717099905014,
0.4839344918727875,
-0.6937139630317688,
-0.3826783299446106,
-0.1603698432445526,
-0.12370609492063522,
-0.9668461084365845,
0.06403608620166779,
0.5192331671714783,
0.6452327370643616,
-0.7670651078224182,
0.5732983946800232,
0.4984070658683777,
-0.3570021986961365,
-0.5205931067466736,
0.08975905179977417,
0.2233051061630249,
-0.694382905960083,
0.9104373455047607,
0.4083150327205658,
-0.24795274436473846,
-0.09435109794139862,
-0.7716004252433777,
-0.19003614783287048,
1.247927188873291,
0.7366381883621216,
-0.6647180318832397,
0.20236089825630188,
0.18126867711544037,
0.18379759788513184,
-0.4353000521659851,
0.3952762484550476,
0.5834624171257019,
0.2784046530723572,
-0.08104986697435379,
-1.2542155981063843,
-0.18710435926914215,
0.3147258460521698,
0.10490520298480988,
-0.26292747259140015,
-0.5703099966049194,
0.7791348695755005,
-0.26694977283477783,
-0.1627172976732254,
-0.2201758176088333,
0.614595353603363,
0.6751767992973328,
0.692132294178009,
0.6684862375259399,
0.43289321660995483,
0.779932975769043,
-0.21097677946090698,
1.1330448389053345,
0.3559521734714508,
0.2693755328655243,
1.188186526298523,
-0.4583684802055359,
0.697874128818512,
0.3553473651409149,
-0.2263605296611786,
0.36521032452583313,
0.6139664649963379,
0.2687827944755554,
0.5525960922241211,
0.3671046793460846,
-0.5275562405586243,
-0.08830960839986801,
-0.19899174571037292,
-0.17529737949371338,
0.6364459991455078,
0.23765070736408234,
-0.08169935643672943,
-0.2592134475708008,
0.17284615337848663,
0.0034006652422249317,
0.17586055397987366,
-0.8588172793388367,
0.8413580060005188,
0.3731941282749176,
-0.14947332441806793,
0.010723496787250042,
0.2911347448825836,
1.4219073057174683,
-0.33659517765045166,
-0.21841126680374146,
-0.31764814257621765,
0.264698326587677,
-0.4165835380554199,
-1.08894681930542,
0.10087944567203522,
0.2205571085214615,
-0.2693786919116974,
-0.2787710726261139,
0.5651401281356812,
-0.13783273100852966,
-0.27538686990737915,
0.31104350090026855,
0.3249613344669342,
0.398486852645874,
0.05225714296102524,
-0.8063511848449707,
-0.08010391891002655,
-0.23179776966571808,
0.16921667754650116,
0.5831047892570496,
0.5691508650779724,
-0.17244254052639008,
0.6922731995582581,
0.258023202419281,
-0.10859271883964539,
0.322374165058136,
0.42074891924858093,
0.48992618918418884,
-0.6048315763473511,
-0.5781522989273071,
-0.8867590427398682,
0.5162935256958008,
-0.05060778930783272,
0.20452137291431427,
0.5553654432296753,
0.520577073097229,
1.1251075267791748,
0.15685699880123138,
0.8216562867164612,
0.1514054536819458,
0.3831687569618225,
-0.652071475982666,
0.8097683787345886,
-0.6363317370414734,
0.444387286901474,
-0.2918093502521515,
-0.7329623699188232,
-0.3665838837623596,
0.6848620772361755,
-0.2029982954263687,
0.6517310738563538,
0.3168931007385254,
0.6726001501083374,
-0.2549210488796234,
-0.18962004780769348,
0.4503434896469116,
-0.03019840642809868,
0.47126784920692444,
0.5682902932167053,
0.8368154168128967,
-0.31057652831077576,
0.5070140957832336,
0.09709037095308304,
-0.3562694489955902,
-0.2132646143436432,
-1.316056489944458,
-0.6417379379272461,
-0.009298483841121197,
-0.16400761902332306,
-0.2775653898715973,
0.039313673973083496,
0.9592840671539307,
0.8748231530189514,
-0.6454053521156311,
-0.34715622663497925,
0.05783920735120773,
0.40314754843711853,
0.3684141933917999,
-0.27477794885635376,
-0.16095393896102905,
-0.5613225698471069,
-0.8438984751701355,
0.04611585661768913,
0.37189772725105286,
0.2767132520675659,
0.04780713468790054,
-0.5470752716064453,
0.21649670600891113,
-0.17444047331809998,
0.9175281524658203,
0.01778334192931652,
-0.6089113354682922,
-0.15560701489448547,
-0.6549784541130066,
-0.14416764676570892,
-0.03732381388545036,
0.6870191693305969,
-0.993015706539154,
0.20831723511219025,
0.29578810930252075,
0.7278398275375366,
0.32306545972824097,
-0.2065706104040146,
0.3780369162559509,
-1.0673959255218506,
0.3799215853214264,
0.43496832251548767,
0.4169812500476837,
0.4851855933666229,
-0.2750338613986969,
0.46742647886276245,
0.19696453213691711,
-0.6668382883071899,
-0.8816030621528625,
0.34295743703842163,
-0.7418984174728394,
-0.24911105632781982,
1.1577728986740112,
0.04818650335073471,
-0.048721443861722946,
-0.12417949736118317,
0.02339593693614006,
0.12048269063234329,
-0.4885920286178589,
0.6426135301589966,
0.45355063676834106,
-0.2165955752134323,
-0.08675671368837357,
-0.7926129102706909,
0.7129709124565125,
0.13754306733608246,
-1.0477262735366821,
-0.23763082921504974,
0.5776236057281494,
0.4812145531177521,
-0.42774561047554016,
1.123619794845581,
-0.3861629068851471,
0.2713892459869385,
-0.6280309557914734,
-0.1668531894683838,
0.2759191393852234,
-0.13556568324565887,
-0.7604393362998962,
0.1139630600810051,
0.34121307730674744,
-0.06004813686013222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18496v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18496v3
|
Language Models Represent Beliefs of Self and Others
| 2024-02-28T17:25:59 | 2024-05-30T12:43:01 |
Wentao Zhu, Zhining Zhang, Yizhou Wang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Understanding and attributing mental states, known as Theory of Mind (ToM),
emerges as a fundamental capability for human social reasoning. While Large
Language Models (LLMs) appear to possess certain ToM abilities, the mechanisms
underlying these capabilities remain elusive. In this study, we discover that
it is possible to linearly decode the belief status from the perspectives of
various agents through neural activations of language models, indicating the
existence of internal representations of self and others' beliefs. By
manipulating these representations, we observe dramatic changes in the models'
ToM performance, underscoring their pivotal role in the social reasoning
process. Additionally, our findings extend to diverse social reasoning tasks
that involve different causal inference patterns, suggesting the potential
generalizability of these representations.
|
[
-0.3451708257198334,
-0.6445764303207397,
1.2105239629745483,
0.03383195772767067,
-0.1525093913078308,
0.03298362344503403,
-0.44119271636009216,
-0.46678370237350464,
0.41273513436317444,
0.2380315512418747,
-0.35046374797821045,
0.02576025389134884,
-0.6509900689125061,
0.03890610113739967,
-0.20487938821315765,
0.48813700675964355,
0.1338057518005371,
0.19214652478694916,
-0.03087620437145233,
-0.06491377204656601,
-0.22825126349925995,
-0.7627415060997009,
-0.7250179052352905,
-0.8802680373191833,
0.7044723629951477,
-0.2929438352584839,
0.7514260411262512,
0.3474369943141937,
0.24691979587078094,
0.24571870267391205,
0.13427843153476715,
0.08741354197263718,
-0.3754153251647949,
0.30995702743530273,
-0.6632256507873535,
-0.9135237336158752,
-0.27075013518333435,
0.207844540476799,
0.8479054570198059,
0.7069644927978516,
0.01083863154053688,
0.017121823504567146,
0.29838475584983826,
0.3614101707935333,
-0.32584717869758606,
0.4538780152797699,
-0.921798050403595,
-0.21361501514911652,
0.21887709200382233,
-0.2773604094982147,
-0.6261817812919617,
-0.3000084161758423,
0.213774174451828,
-0.2407190352678299,
0.16361616551876068,
-0.06487131118774414,
0.8110676407814026,
0.2007124125957489,
-0.5181077718734741,
-0.2271689623594284,
-0.8359918594360352,
0.6852568984031677,
-0.676892101764679,
0.2448129802942276,
0.5754826068878174,
0.24403312802314758,
-0.32051700353622437,
-0.23419484496116638,
-0.8229350447654724,
-0.2983992397785187,
-0.2337934523820877,
-0.24523410201072693,
-0.15679046511650085,
0.4030033051967621,
0.29432201385498047,
0.19880534708499908,
-0.19015038013458252,
-0.3825433850288391,
-0.0895504504442215,
-0.0855766236782074,
0.5832282900810242,
0.013042435050010681,
0.4847005605697632,
-0.1807829886674881,
0.00044647115282714367,
-0.14713279902935028,
-0.446033239364624,
-0.01720913127064705,
-0.01721574179828167,
0.36779022216796875,
-0.13002897799015045,
0.31873494386672974,
0.016145214438438416,
0.46389463543891907,
0.11411632597446442,
-0.03295551612973213,
0.004466463346034288,
0.1783636510372162,
-0.6510882377624512,
-0.23384711146354675,
0.49686628580093384,
0.1187576949596405,
0.5236189365386963,
-0.09277793765068054,
-0.2920207977294922,
0.5214220881462097,
0.40151870250701904,
-0.16962026059627533,
0.02936401404440403,
0.1120511144399643,
-0.6524363160133362,
-0.14514949917793274,
0.0357246920466423,
-0.28117963671684265,
-0.7084508538246155,
-0.3019789457321167,
0.47983649373054504,
-0.48999881744384766,
-0.7097817063331604,
0.2935292422771454,
-0.2709324359893799,
0.3224673569202423,
0.45199063420295715,
-0.9264329671859741,
0.43637922406196594,
0.5631775856018066,
0.5824678540229797,
0.29535508155822754,
-0.37901419401168823,
0.23754769563674927,
0.4013487696647644,
-0.7030231952667236,
0.6980195045471191,
-0.7256618738174438,
-0.25965067744255066,
0.0007774679106660187,
0.17258170247077942,
-0.17694944143295288,
-0.1608242690563202,
-0.026700999587774277,
-0.4755113422870636,
-0.02255905792117119,
-0.8948232531547546,
-0.5897332429885864,
-0.5155919194221497,
0.1901257187128067,
-0.46755290031433105,
0.5213759541511536,
-0.23423920571804047,
-0.2870657444000244,
0.12127580493688583,
-0.4655666649341583,
-0.2123057097196579,
0.061665136367082596,
-0.6337742209434509,
0.24843856692314148,
0.6454517245292664,
-0.03846675530076027,
0.800021767616272,
-0.6962769627571106,
0.5021235346794128,
-0.7256112098693848,
-0.31054580211639404,
0.6521399617195129,
-0.4685652554035187,
0.9513201117515564,
0.195515438914299,
-0.46030399203300476,
-0.04150169715285301,
-0.3378426730632782,
-0.05046489089727402,
0.49565041065216064,
-0.15328243374824524,
-0.6629316806793213,
0.23751509189605713,
-0.6214090585708618,
0.13642284274101257,
0.12043269723653793,
-0.4359420835971832,
0.25727152824401855,
-0.3378402292728424,
0.3843175768852234,
0.9720306396484375,
0.017631758004426956,
0.5687790513038635,
-0.32437461614608765,
0.3746657967567444,
0.0015854283701628447,
-0.165197491645813,
-0.07885266840457916,
-0.7722088098526001,
-0.9641215205192566,
0.018837623298168182,
-0.26651936769485474,
0.12943579256534576,
-0.5648672580718994,
0.16905008256435394,
-0.22851087152957916,
-0.13134537637233734,
-0.5631948113441467,
0.004609875846654177,
0.48488032817840576,
-0.007749990094453096,
0.09825516492128372,
0.057328637689352036,
-0.32664281129837036,
-1.1495214700698853,
-0.46671661734580994,
-0.5143018364906311,
0.00709629338234663,
0.13375189900398254,
0.5865772366523743,
-0.23247912526130676,
0.8269814252853394,
-0.43849480152130127,
0.07995425164699554,
-0.47947484254837036,
0.2048618346452713,
0.2477283775806427,
0.3698359727859497,
0.7061176300048828,
-0.42959147691726685,
0.011143342591822147,
0.0674155130982399,
-1.1398048400878906,
0.19514994323253632,
-0.4643810987472534,
-0.13994450867176056,
0.06822553277015686,
0.37563127279281616,
-0.611478328704834,
0.591077983379364,
0.3879190683364868,
-0.5705668926239014,
0.23171702027320862,
-0.383169561624527,
0.25369542837142944,
-0.9949874877929688,
-0.44359174370765686,
0.2288082242012024,
-0.1331733912229538,
-0.5949284434318542,
0.2480778843164444,
0.15131153166294098,
0.167464017868042,
0.07275579869747162,
0.5675206780433655,
-0.7147666811943054,
-0.11183807998895645,
-0.3097188174724579,
0.16079652309417725,
-0.03230007365345955,
0.700099527835846,
-0.004326401744037867,
0.5135184526443481,
0.6787718534469604,
-0.6499040722846985,
0.19274550676345825,
-0.2704533636569977,
-0.1981135904788971,
0.4176901876926422,
-0.6745174527168274,
0.2814795970916748,
-0.6657927632331848,
0.2003612518310547,
-1.24519681930542,
-0.4330965578556061,
0.24960851669311523,
-0.41790178418159485,
0.14399781823158264,
-0.09598052501678467,
-0.5375010967254639,
-0.34343189001083374,
0.18298374116420746,
0.16336938738822937,
0.5732640624046326,
-0.3203608989715576,
0.8732352256774902,
0.6010388731956482,
0.2909439206123352,
-0.05721321329474449,
-1.0087056159973145,
0.01846226677298546,
-0.16736644506454468,
-0.47926315665245056,
0.14755895733833313,
0.03806834667921066,
-0.8284433484077454,
0.02393976040184498,
0.09253064543008804,
-0.1361575573682785,
-0.027035513892769814,
0.33731764554977417,
0.115606389939785,
-0.19696371257305145,
0.5584242343902588,
0.23597989976406097,
0.06610240787267685,
0.4575399160385132,
-0.4201192855834961,
0.5007199645042419,
-0.18595349788665771,
-0.5050504803657532,
-0.46381452679634094,
0.3066103756427765,
0.7075498700141907,
-0.1873379647731781,
0.9004544615745544,
-0.06629294157028198,
-0.8181785345077515,
-0.47569435834884644,
-0.6036521792411804,
-0.375898540019989,
-0.44088736176490784,
0.2050369381904602,
-0.6384090781211853,
-0.7938464879989624,
0.7063905596733093,
0.13566915690898895,
-0.3333210051059723,
0.1932990550994873,
0.5496598482131958,
-0.1326986849308014,
1.1746656894683838,
0.487258642911911,
-0.0394878052175045,
0.35679149627685547,
-0.18357893824577332,
0.2769557237625122,
-0.7976606488227844,
-0.016670387238264084,
-0.20465898513793945,
-0.1978844702243805,
-0.2533872723579407,
-0.7016547322273254,
0.2448175996541977,
-0.020921269431710243,
-0.2700118124485016,
0.08832310140132904,
-0.45514899492263794,
0.523067057132721,
0.3688892424106598,
0.3975755572319031,
0.024145973846316338,
-0.08790882676839828,
-0.32580065727233887,
0.1038513332605362,
-0.3606017529964447,
-0.7801631093025208,
1.1323107481002808,
0.6090223789215088,
0.6241153478622437,
0.19843626022338867,
0.48944035172462463,
0.4111899435520172,
0.3441774249076843,
-0.4925817847251892,
0.7984972596168518,
0.2234126478433609,
-1.0827702283859253,
-0.292959600687027,
0.05735263600945473,
-0.7793093323707581,
0.5341200828552246,
-0.13926447927951813,
-1.1234872341156006,
0.4401269555091858,
0.1596640944480896,
-0.356844037771225,
0.497183233499527,
-0.6827629208564758,
0.5171297192573547,
-0.035470932722091675,
-0.17233097553253174,
-0.8750489950180054,
-0.36657074093818665,
0.44422003626823425,
0.1776408851146698,
0.09564846754074097,
-0.31865668296813965,
0.2866196632385254,
0.5261965394020081,
-0.08022741973400116,
1.105267882347107,
-0.3211289048194885,
-0.4430896043777466,
0.37339144945144653,
0.26749953627586365,
0.4733503758907318,
-0.05615932494401932,
-0.25131165981292725,
0.07638130336999893,
-0.11364194750785828,
-0.36203625798225403,
-1.0042935609817505,
0.5792360305786133,
-0.7690838575363159,
-1.088325023651123,
-0.3973739445209503,
-0.5664423108100891,
-0.23536564409732819,
0.11744097620248795,
-0.1572294980287552,
0.41240036487579346,
-0.21170726418495178,
0.20050771534442902,
0.7030991315841675,
-0.18153604865074158,
0.25256675481796265,
0.3158413767814636,
-0.5868549346923828,
-0.08262167125940323,
0.6449629664421082,
0.2127266675233841,
0.6045766472816467,
0.21961450576782227,
0.08254200965166092,
-0.13712775707244873,
-0.32556432485580444,
0.2573559582233429,
0.6073163151741028,
-1.0920807123184204,
0.2749895453453064,
-0.5901821851730347,
0.04417141154408455,
-0.37352949380874634,
-0.21220393478870392,
-0.2806408107280731,
-0.13614235818386078,
-0.14733721315860748,
-0.3690817654132843,
0.0724625214934349,
1.1986818313598633,
-0.13554216921329498,
0.37894055247306824,
-0.16472271084785461,
0.4786895513534546,
0.5933136940002441,
0.39639174938201904,
0.44232553243637085,
-0.26893851161003113,
-0.3276303708553314,
0.49264082312583923,
0.10457710176706314,
-1.3056561946868896,
0.20894062519073486,
-0.22192735970020294,
0.7629698514938354,
0.595236599445343,
-0.22084873914718628,
0.7495524883270264,
-0.30245912075042725,
0.62305748462677,
-0.0071325115859508514,
-1.0468714237213135,
0.6471049189567566,
-0.6541273593902588,
0.17830120027065277,
0.06435991078615189,
0.3128259778022766,
-0.4995250999927521,
-0.6454911231994629,
-0.5287555456161499,
-0.13026119768619537,
0.6233692765235901,
0.020726311951875687,
0.2843917906284332,
-0.4191555380821228,
0.41957929730415344,
-0.11693434417247772,
-0.12294556200504303,
-0.9344761371612549,
-0.32550331950187683,
-0.20576266944408417,
-0.03968071565032005,
-0.12757103145122528,
-0.43810126185417175,
-0.15142717957496643,
-0.49288204312324524,
0.3455229699611664,
-0.24879345297813416,
0.768075704574585,
0.4147445261478424,
0.002955768723040819,
-0.3270484209060669,
0.21250267326831818,
0.40798136591911316,
0.8099618554115295,
-0.13322760164737701,
0.31271132826805115,
0.12823113799095154,
-0.040625326335430145,
0.24092139303684235,
-0.341170996427536,
0.027873359620571136,
-0.2141013741493225,
0.38079196214675903,
0.6774694919586182,
0.36251071095466614,
-0.26019516587257385,
0.247212216258049,
-0.11035294085741043,
-0.0384054109454155,
-0.5389514565467834,
0.18830865621566772,
0.25853651762008667,
0.6497552394866943,
0.6579980254173279,
0.095493845641613,
-0.0689215362071991,
-1.0212494134902954,
-0.05128365382552147,
0.6305713653564453,
-0.30725833773612976,
-0.708392858505249,
0.8143038153648376,
-0.04803285375237465,
-0.3036576211452484,
0.13576143980026245,
-0.3093706965446472,
-0.3999830186367035,
0.5663184523582458,
0.7526870369911194,
1.215904712677002,
-0.29998570680618286,
0.36191365122795105,
0.2508644759654999,
0.5536965131759644,
-0.16685020923614502,
0.43275371193885803,
0.12933626770973206,
-1.575067400932312,
-0.30272287130355835,
-0.404406875371933,
0.013763843104243279,
0.14541828632354736,
-0.6733277440071106,
-0.15304554998874664,
-0.7105113863945007,
-0.42771580815315247,
0.09267614781856537,
-0.3850643038749695,
-0.7326473593711853,
0.2832556366920471,
0.5880564451217651,
0.44621041417121887,
-0.7363995313644409,
1.3609929084777832,
0.6340621113777161,
-0.6047821044921875,
-0.9026831984519958,
0.27232182025909424,
0.23025526106357574,
-0.9154426455497742,
0.839664101600647,
0.01326831802725792,
-0.49193572998046875,
-0.035627689212560654,
-0.718847930431366,
-1.0773457288742065,
0.7988857626914978,
0.6678240895271301,
-0.2821290194988251,
-0.4097355902194977,
0.03365140035748482,
0.7358173131942749,
-0.7845466732978821,
0.14145278930664062,
0.4836713671684265,
0.39347708225250244,
-0.3840462565422058,
-0.7222287058830261,
0.3974645733833313,
-0.2166377454996109,
0.22409138083457947,
-0.12171956151723862,
-0.5994511246681213,
1.0210016965866089,
-0.11124704778194427,
-0.36564403772354126,
-0.2357923984527588,
0.7419930696487427,
0.23872098326683044,
-0.07843341678380966,
0.4406639337539673,
0.2150883674621582,
0.8434274792671204,
0.04587110877037048,
1.359374761581421,
-0.4045795500278473,
0.2447551041841507,
0.8170316815376282,
-0.1957089751958847,
0.5254272818565369,
0.33174803853034973,
-0.272677481174469,
0.7051931023597717,
0.2593064308166504,
0.3896210789680481,
0.45245474576950073,
-0.06197251379489899,
-0.15662366151809692,
-0.7202188372612,
0.072788767516613,
-0.10139912366867065,
0.41976481676101685,
0.8456920981407166,
-0.6915073394775391,
0.09184908866882324,
-0.04848679155111313,
0.08905180543661118,
0.24474287033081055,
-0.3464677631855011,
0.458959698677063,
0.27607905864715576,
-0.7602089047431946,
0.6743639707565308,
-0.2527048885822296,
0.48597514629364014,
-0.5323599576950073,
-0.20258653163909912,
0.0979924127459526,
0.31971266865730286,
0.24134810268878937,
-0.8673397302627563,
0.20556209981441498,
-0.3954550325870514,
-0.21009798347949982,
-0.6163902878761292,
0.9610081315040588,
-0.20420032739639282,
-0.26448097825050354,
0.8224548697471619,
0.4663841426372528,
0.12631992995738983,
-0.1569288671016693,
-0.5467948913574219,
-0.004815211985260248,
0.2866118848323822,
-0.37737420201301575,
0.19982418417930603,
0.5738617777824402,
-0.07587160915136337,
0.929009735584259,
0.42929044365882874,
0.2775820195674896,
0.018562790006399155,
0.03134102374315262,
0.8520073890686035,
-1.0283379554748535,
-0.40821149945259094,
-1.1112444400787354,
0.3804931342601776,
-0.05056597292423248,
-0.07040035724639893,
0.7774984240531921,
-0.1818973571062088,
0.8174582719802856,
-0.14542487263679504,
0.9993550777435303,
0.07603345066308975,
0.4134570062160492,
-0.3284710943698883,
1.0654433965682983,
-0.6049622297286987,
0.18628811836242676,
-0.5233501195907593,
-0.5494417548179626,
-0.06190492585301399,
0.9247913360595703,
-0.6220893263816833,
-0.05391489341855049,
0.7845097184181213,
0.6004162430763245,
0.28704434633255005,
0.251995712518692,
0.6428418159484863,
0.5979095697402954,
0.4224635064601898,
0.39760103821754456,
0.8785348534584045,
-0.012722262181341648,
-0.028355754911899567,
-0.08218298107385635,
-0.2432263046503067,
0.03469722718000412,
-0.5393345952033997,
-1.3391414880752563,
-0.9680010080337524,
0.0021300402004271746,
-0.24581222236156464,
0.1408478021621704,
1.1627446413040161,
0.6521561741828918,
-0.5804213285446167,
-0.40936604142189026,
-0.11535917967557907,
0.2769356369972229,
-0.21852976083755493,
-0.2221382111310959,
-0.020054025575518608,
-0.39601799845695496,
-0.5520642399787903,
0.43533697724342346,
0.4723219573497772,
0.12289241701364517,
-0.7416476607322693,
0.0015479665016755462,
-0.35148677229881287,
0.6266770362854004,
0.6468989253044128,
0.08103091269731522,
-1.276676058769226,
-0.7052590250968933,
-0.2827986180782318,
-0.125425785779953,
0.016052529215812683,
0.859616219997406,
-0.8628973364830017,
0.4476735293865204,
0.4368548095226288,
0.302815705537796,
0.16244496405124664,
-0.303410142660141,
1.032991886138916,
-0.19512099027633667,
0.34611767530441284,
0.1169048473238945,
0.8171378970146179,
0.022994453087449074,
-0.436420202255249,
0.3589783310890198,
0.242117777466774,
-0.35685813426971436,
-0.8188672661781311,
0.47690653800964355,
-0.5550148487091064,
-0.5894168615341187,
1.0605632066726685,
-0.15683883428573608,
-0.49892958998680115,
-0.08370416611433029,
-0.06379377841949463,
0.29917216300964355,
-0.3435686230659485,
0.8673127889633179,
0.9473822116851807,
-0.16712287068367004,
-0.32388243079185486,
-0.5218729972839355,
0.45843011140823364,
0.38108471035957336,
-0.5509170889854431,
0.1597360223531723,
0.4655207395553589,
0.11063720285892487,
0.35940712690353394,
0.9668019413948059,
0.10147178173065186,
-0.03389628604054451,
0.13477106392383575,
0.1046772226691246,
0.47808271646499634,
-0.27700096368789673,
-0.25792744755744934,
0.22217299044132233,
0.16611896455287933,
0.09685994684696198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18479v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18479v2
|
NewsQs: Multi-Source Question Generation for the Inquiring Mind
| 2024-02-28T16:59:35 | 2024-06-15T15:30:53 |
Alyssa Hwang, Kalpit Dixit, Miguel Ballesteros, Yassine Benajiba, Vittorio Castelli, Markus Dreyer, Mohit Bansal, Kathleen McKeown
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present NewsQs (news-cues), a dataset that provides question-answer pairs
for multiple news documents. To create NewsQs, we augment a traditional
multi-document summarization dataset with questions automatically generated by
a T5-Large model fine-tuned on FAQ-style news articles from the News On the Web
corpus. We show that fine-tuning a model with control codes produces questions
that are judged acceptable more often than the same model without them as
measured through human evaluation. We use a QNLI model with high correlation
with human annotations to filter our data. We release our final dataset of
high-quality questions, answers, and document clusters as a resource for future
work in query-based multi-document summarization.
|
[
-0.6743749976158142,
-0.702000617980957,
0.48269394040107727,
-0.12716761231422424,
-0.34908488392829895,
-0.041902732104063034,
0.1050831750035286,
-0.1423838883638382,
0.2515066862106323,
0.6506385207176208,
-0.635261595249176,
-0.38429775834083557,
-0.1875387728214264,
0.26872679591178894,
-0.7470521330833435,
1.2565897703170776,
0.24234777688980103,
0.09694215655326843,
-0.49295198917388916,
-0.3134705722332001,
0.15939821302890778,
-0.39853984117507935,
-0.6667696237564087,
0.1648690104484558,
0.6758449077606201,
0.6105929613113403,
0.7813507318496704,
0.07505781203508377,
0.3577629625797272,
0.09631597995758057,
0.04475809633731842,
0.4646165072917938,
-0.31776759028434753,
0.201206773519516,
0.029767561703920364,
-0.6147263646125793,
-0.049290820956230164,
0.18624477088451385,
0.6082625389099121,
0.5860993266105652,
0.019511675462126732,
0.45683661103248596,
-0.25415465235710144,
0.7724424004554749,
-0.5372318625450134,
-0.4367934465408325,
-0.6354408860206604,
-0.022069284692406654,
-0.08322478830814362,
-0.32292476296424866,
-0.14673452079296112,
-0.8890036940574646,
-0.16952858865261078,
-0.5613003373146057,
0.5093068480491638,
0.08060626685619354,
0.8732046484947205,
0.21822986006736755,
-0.8914169073104858,
-0.3737272024154663,
-0.3507092297077179,
0.5710861682891846,
-0.5648834109306335,
0.41422736644744873,
0.3342876434326172,
0.32231801748275757,
0.050337716937065125,
-0.6254222989082336,
-0.6239621639251709,
0.14875000715255737,
-0.10682764649391174,
0.29275113344192505,
-0.021999768912792206,
-0.44564321637153625,
0.19358430802822113,
0.32321181893348694,
-0.779902458190918,
-0.4910338222980499,
-0.757561445236206,
0.020355992019176483,
0.716730535030365,
0.35405105352401733,
0.11037883907556534,
-0.394054114818573,
0.074860580265522,
0.04655645787715912,
-0.6580852270126343,
0.18809150159358978,
0.5166668891906738,
0.07100978493690491,
0.18035326898097992,
0.6075795292854309,
-0.469180703163147,
0.9359184503555298,
0.2387693077325821,
-0.006969641428440809,
-0.047573938965797424,
-0.8026289343833923,
0.22199082374572754,
-0.21277187764644623,
0.6345244646072388,
1.008653998374939,
0.08878190815448761,
-0.21399249136447906,
0.15433622896671295,
-0.22623376548290253,
0.3433437645435333,
-0.5619259476661682,
0.05293572321534157,
0.6873460412025452,
-0.23398305475711823,
-0.5797953009605408,
0.13194294273853302,
-0.6085423231124878,
-0.4839434325695038,
-0.28801319003105164,
0.2534945607185364,
-0.1265585869550705,
-0.22548891603946686,
0.06900675594806671,
-0.7616395354270935,
0.5200123190879822,
0.4566262364387512,
-0.6104733347892761,
0.00468018651008606,
0.2321254163980484,
0.44346877932548523,
-0.0338611863553524,
-0.15948623418807983,
-0.507826566696167,
0.2912411689758301,
-0.5037580132484436,
0.8974820971488953,
-0.26563337445259094,
-0.2999618947505951,
-0.0703188106417656,
-0.09673197567462921,
0.17271487414836884,
-0.2680944800376892,
0.45189329981803894,
-0.6834376454353333,
0.8295016884803772,
-0.7281121611595154,
-0.5595340728759766,
0.09812293201684952,
0.5206374526023865,
-0.6235098242759705,
0.9258172512054443,
0.2228958159685135,
-1.0712860822677612,
0.22245430946350098,
-0.5812554955482483,
-0.5376611948013306,
-0.08051474392414093,
-0.24558638036251068,
-0.1744847446680069,
-0.014820150099694729,
0.47025442123413086,
0.2915416657924652,
-0.41264107823371887,
0.28277888894081116,
-0.045634232461452484,
-0.054384730756282806,
0.514590859413147,
-0.22499312460422516,
0.7455455660820007,
0.3645407557487488,
0.31205716729164124,
0.13617762923240662,
-0.755405068397522,
0.26865342259407043,
-0.022844024002552032,
-0.5071677565574646,
-0.34505000710487366,
-0.09210095554590225,
-0.15876172482967377,
0.3345015347003937,
0.1832989603281021,
-0.5176143050193787,
-0.043737318366765976,
-0.009875934571027756,
0.6319920420646667,
0.06362173706293106,
0.6145365238189697,
0.4337087869644165,
-0.6757678985595703,
0.46164023876190186,
0.06171785667538643,
0.47037503123283386,
-0.30014199018478394,
-0.4481046497821808,
-0.6573654413223267,
0.4312884509563446,
0.07699006795883179,
0.42958399653434753,
-0.9624090790748596,
0.28250446915626526,
0.11165562272071838,
-0.7306886911392212,
-0.5876520276069641,
-0.015476041473448277,
0.11910242587327957,
0.6734740734100342,
0.4266422390937805,
0.14685100317001343,
-0.34408020973205566,
-0.8100950121879578,
-0.25995153188705444,
0.10095056891441345,
-0.1821337342262268,
0.2333521842956543,
0.17962557077407837,
0.6248737573623657,
1.0348644256591797,
-0.7157989144325256,
0.26744747161865234,
-0.25372374057769775,
0.44374990463256836,
0.09733545035123825,
0.40820029377937317,
0.6469675898551941,
-1.1298707723617554,
-0.09779428690671921,
-0.6093786358833313,
-0.7253881692886353,
0.010640502907335758,
-0.17688216269016266,
-0.42514732480049133,
-0.09809012711048126,
0.707166314125061,
-0.7556307315826416,
-0.04071080684661865,
0.2532370984554291,
-0.26194998621940613,
0.5943979620933533,
0.14257176220417023,
0.5108131170272827,
-1.609533429145813,
0.03790125623345375,
-0.08835098147392273,
-0.021639365702867508,
-0.4831599295139313,
0.23866556584835052,
0.2781210243701935,
-0.41823986172676086,
-0.6033810973167419,
0.45209014415740967,
-0.24016179144382477,
-0.11353540420532227,
-0.021398818120360374,
0.42103949189186096,
0.7067871689796448,
0.3337370455265045,
-0.27825143933296204,
0.7941135764122009,
0.2990441620349884,
-0.8825849890708923,
0.7225901484489441,
0.3070920407772064,
-0.24038895964622498,
0.6304157376289368,
-0.8168411254882812,
0.28242671489715576,
-0.5612082481384277,
0.30257242918014526,
-1.1477421522140503,
-0.47678038477897644,
-0.05485999956727028,
-0.6331062316894531,
-0.1979784071445465,
0.07252831757068634,
-0.5298637747764587,
-0.5016806721687317,
-0.6672391295433044,
0.2608334720134735,
0.11518185585737228,
-0.2687739133834839,
0.2602189779281616,
0.41427451372146606,
-0.2666144073009491,
-0.4843921959400177,
-0.6851951479911804,
-0.0593886598944664,
-0.005495788529515266,
-0.6189889907836914,
0.10373596847057343,
-0.35475704073905945,
-0.23501557111740112,
0.35339871048927307,
-0.03526405617594719,
-0.2680133581161499,
0.10270178318023682,
-0.07188025861978531,
0.08067101985216141,
-0.23564410209655762,
0.46454229950904846,
0.5914832949638367,
0.49930012226104736,
0.10645553469657898,
-0.24939127266407013,
0.30525603890419006,
0.0677122250199318,
-0.3296719789505005,
0.004874868784099817,
1.033877968788147,
0.8818511962890625,
-0.8403201699256897,
0.37141209840774536,
0.5687076449394226,
-0.33829331398010254,
0.08960115164518356,
-0.5496488809585571,
-0.19853879511356354,
-0.3538770377635956,
0.22994232177734375,
-0.27201297879219055,
-1.0772277116775513,
0.4009149670600891,
0.30571219325065613,
0.3569924235343933,
0.40276744961738586,
0.43449562788009644,
-0.21550963819026947,
1.1152846813201904,
0.09153768420219421,
-0.04345693811774254,
0.3314875364303589,
-0.038945745676755905,
-0.23547497391700745,
-0.500577986240387,
-0.12776845693588257,
-0.6353965401649475,
-0.18384627997875214,
-0.14945925772190094,
-0.2105308622121811,
0.5731713771820068,
0.19549089670181274,
-0.21147580444812775,
0.004489318002015352,
-0.4271295666694641,
0.653907835483551,
1.0359013080596924,
0.15351241827011108,
0.5415123105049133,
-0.3648826777935028,
0.10411269217729568,
0.32007816433906555,
-0.636122465133667,
-0.34399864077568054,
1.2532501220703125,
-0.16423892974853516,
0.7283721566200256,
0.1803995966911316,
0.5700938701629639,
0.1776629090309143,
-0.10107019543647766,
-0.4807024896144867,
0.31344497203826904,
0.09939195960760117,
-1.0307809114456177,
-0.5898911952972412,
-0.39759424328804016,
-0.8144340515136719,
0.16493944823741913,
-0.39679545164108276,
-0.27754247188568115,
0.12451257556676865,
-0.1489771455526352,
-1.045316457748413,
0.10288076847791672,
-0.8574529886245728,
0.5782145857810974,
-0.26656797528266907,
-0.22768917679786682,
-0.1283968687057495,
-0.7707407474517822,
0.6611824631690979,
0.07138406485319138,
0.12167680263519287,
-0.15744878351688385,
0.04248271510004997,
0.6174892783164978,
-0.023822491988539696,
0.4180697202682495,
-0.018211646005511284,
-0.052444301545619965,
0.686075747013092,
-0.3227745592594147,
0.0805988758802414,
0.5527377724647522,
-0.10188139230012894,
-0.3898506164550781,
0.17183555662631989,
-0.4098970592021942,
-0.814807116985321,
0.48305952548980713,
-0.6347169876098633,
-0.7196345925331116,
-0.05151192098855972,
-0.7457315921783447,
-0.4092235565185547,
0.2934441864490509,
0.39382287859916687,
0.7619156241416931,
-0.06692839413881302,
0.2541010081768036,
0.6833036541938782,
-0.31311702728271484,
0.3388247489929199,
0.7629967331886292,
-0.32399246096611023,
-0.34739330410957336,
0.5294454097747803,
0.12401251494884491,
0.20635981857776642,
0.5010076761245728,
-0.014670321717858315,
-0.3783692419528961,
-0.34849783778190613,
-0.7449650168418884,
0.1045948714017868,
-0.5367098450660706,
-0.4424150586128235,
-0.6382725238800049,
-0.3473927676677704,
-0.7265161871910095,
0.14855021238327026,
-0.144328773021698,
-0.6201803684234619,
-0.3664171099662781,
-0.2742794454097748,
0.4618948698043823,
0.5117048621177673,
0.27594196796417236,
-0.0019638484809547663,
-1.282273292541504,
0.6404879093170166,
0.7351594567298889,
0.14895525574684143,
-0.37260568141937256,
-0.25794851779937744,
-0.3252134621143341,
0.06343919783830643,
-0.5015318393707275,
-1.1213147640228271,
0.004194359760731459,
0.011736401356756687,
0.41539859771728516,
0.3336421549320221,
0.5957791209220886,
0.20198629796504974,
-0.30688560009002686,
0.9414681792259216,
0.03794483840465546,
-0.6717092990875244,
0.8602234125137329,
-0.7018886804580688,
0.5083340406417847,
0.7415710091590881,
0.5539589524269104,
-0.7223791480064392,
-0.9362615942955017,
-0.5533702373504639,
-0.5805165767669678,
0.5368314981460571,
-0.032000359147787094,
0.3150237798690796,
-0.19559969007968903,
0.6844325661659241,
0.034145474433898926,
0.42652589082717896,
-0.22799724340438843,
-0.08622857928276062,
-0.34862491488456726,
-0.18532618880271912,
0.30011051893234253,
-0.21806135773658752,
-0.434027761220932,
-0.2814771831035614,
0.3539925813674927,
-0.29130223393440247,
0.1458759605884552,
0.31372860074043274,
0.0657515749335289,
-0.46162259578704834,
0.5183056592941284,
0.6638603806495667,
0.7388971447944641,
-0.23898139595985413,
0.09936655312776566,
0.01342407800257206,
-0.17505775392055511,
-0.10109258443117142,
0.1769123524427414,
-0.4263116717338562,
0.08023050427436829,
-0.03256860002875328,
0.6339983940124512,
0.040875647217035294,
-0.582015872001648,
0.5659058094024658,
-0.48141223192214966,
-0.4985123872756958,
-0.20770367980003357,
0.23400220274925232,
0.3796379864215851,
0.29435795545578003,
0.646101176738739,
0.018140330910682678,
0.20848017930984497,
-0.506331205368042,
0.33974573016166687,
0.33225008845329285,
-0.032952386885881424,
-0.1378786712884903,
0.8206984996795654,
0.3414548635482788,
0.09672784805297852,
0.4993133842945099,
-0.34501945972442627,
-0.143625870347023,
0.577437162399292,
0.14314745366573334,
0.3160456418991089,
-0.012082654982805252,
0.5142281651496887,
0.47417542338371277,
0.25851139426231384,
-0.051299627870321274,
0.8318156599998474,
0.005965717602521181,
-0.8874410390853882,
-0.38364002108573914,
-0.2636370062828064,
-0.7563331723213196,
0.3490019142627716,
-0.8084970712661743,
0.28761613368988037,
-0.4250052273273468,
-0.1965428739786148,
0.07311289012432098,
0.06018802151083946,
-0.352785587310791,
0.5276041626930237,
-0.02851494401693344,
0.9246335625648499,
-0.8139051795005798,
0.7479620575904846,
0.8545809388160706,
-0.9702037572860718,
-0.7986204028129578,
0.15363535284996033,
-0.2996767461299896,
-0.3892940282821655,
-0.03138818219304085,
-0.15472154319286346,
0.27327287197113037,
0.2959096133708954,
-0.935580313205719,
-1.1119012832641602,
1.2132139205932617,
0.43546944856643677,
-0.09211066365242004,
-0.29424357414245605,
-0.0036636211443692446,
0.26487621665000916,
-0.0419602133333683,
0.2912188470363617,
0.4563736617565155,
0.3891741633415222,
0.03343092277646065,
-0.45920297503471375,
-0.1071765348315239,
-0.43948572874069214,
-0.4886159598827362,
0.2705025374889374,
-0.8617330193519592,
1.116432547569275,
-0.3911651372909546,
-0.07735105603933334,
-0.12286302447319031,
0.6841563582420349,
0.18478932976722717,
0.40227603912353516,
0.39238232374191284,
0.46099022030830383,
0.9852405786514282,
-0.025416065007448196,
1.1336373090744019,
-0.5613603591918945,
0.07555323094129562,
1.218923568725586,
-0.015901749953627586,
0.5875429511070251,
0.4045089781284332,
-0.10076658427715302,
0.1008635014295578,
0.6361169219017029,
0.042248621582984924,
0.40859290957450867,
0.16007256507873535,
-0.15022705495357513,
-0.24555855989456177,
-0.3227093517780304,
-0.5118868350982666,
0.34359198808670044,
0.29849255084991455,
-0.13221706449985504,
-0.5269424319267273,
-0.012255420908331871,
-0.13028836250305176,
0.06073707714676857,
-0.22769547998905182,
0.6708984375,
-0.18026162683963776,
-0.9144508242607117,
0.20104998350143433,
0.05168520286679268,
0.41341057419776917,
-0.599117636680603,
0.22633881866931915,
-0.7719434499740601,
-0.3670770823955536,
-0.18165098130702972,
-0.937741219997406,
0.30101412534713745,
0.05834116041660309,
-0.5260986089706421,
0.108245350420475,
0.6662798523902893,
-0.7005200982093811,
-0.554450511932373,
-0.40986302495002747,
1.0444755554199219,
0.15332259237766266,
-0.31762903928756714,
-0.589747965335846,
-0.4384763538837433,
-0.06978318840265274,
-0.3407173454761505,
0.22738386690616608,
0.6745109558105469,
-0.051170434802770615,
0.41657885909080505,
0.6210370659828186,
-0.21342502534389496,
0.26823070645332336,
0.45235908031463623,
0.9336900115013123,
-0.7351623773574829,
-0.5360332131385803,
-0.2641073167324066,
0.4364004135131836,
-0.2811320424079895,
-0.6284289360046387,
0.7619960308074951,
0.6640059351921082,
0.5645948052406311,
0.013666638173162937,
1.1228724718093872,
0.034627050161361694,
0.8502189517021179,
-0.5254231095314026,
0.8230600953102112,
-0.8091402649879456,
-0.20338349044322968,
-0.0931011214852333,
-0.41745471954345703,
-0.20337247848510742,
0.09906446188688278,
0.12972354888916016,
-0.11141268908977509,
0.7252041101455688,
0.8172719478607178,
0.3948376476764679,
0.3888367712497711,
0.19009055197238922,
-0.21881555020809174,
0.15638206899166107,
0.5362923741340637,
1.087155818939209,
-0.5060780048370361,
0.8394736647605896,
-0.20685015618801117,
0.08237320929765701,
0.06121613085269928,
-0.6119544506072998,
-0.8509874939918518,
-0.7321107983589172,
-0.2790484130382538,
-0.16847050189971924,
-0.10476786643266678,
0.813697874546051,
0.34512045979499817,
-0.8935552835464478,
0.11988513171672821,
-0.10754568129777908,
0.4737338721752167,
-0.08476972579956055,
-0.2584303915500641,
0.3238759934902191,
-0.6112599968910217,
-0.6678147315979004,
0.2664743661880493,
-0.04636949673295021,
0.07722901552915573,
-0.3841950595378876,
0.278872013092041,
-0.4240928888320923,
0.08602316677570343,
0.41202306747436523,
0.037212811410427094,
-0.1909860074520111,
-0.26554208993911743,
0.37840357422828674,
-0.31505200266838074,
-0.13688458502292633,
0.9150977730751038,
-0.45121335983276367,
0.08050660789012909,
0.5483829379081726,
0.6556448340415955,
0.2622782588005066,
0.27301329374313354,
0.48507794737815857,
-1.157987356185913,
-0.04868549481034279,
0.13815806806087494,
0.10314211994409561,
0.3905870318412781,
-0.5673090815544128,
0.3623534142971039,
0.09666801244020462,
-0.31769219040870667,
-0.4011525809764862,
0.16690057516098022,
-0.7932416796684265,
-0.4607715308666229,
1.1984584331512451,
0.2216678261756897,
-0.15833134949207306,
-0.3284309208393097,
-0.27381622791290283,
0.46134769916534424,
-0.5937734842300415,
0.6727209687232971,
0.844581663608551,
-0.21296176314353943,
-0.4634474813938141,
-0.5143818259239197,
0.4760896861553192,
0.2743823826313019,
-0.9976069927215576,
0.021734846755862236,
0.7481920123100281,
0.13606807589530945,
0.1988145411014557,
0.6813229918479919,
-0.23715457320213318,
0.49478504061698914,
-0.022321490570902824,
-0.008449404500424862,
-0.1871872842311859,
-0.10079240053892136,
0.04849564656615257,
0.6215177178382874,
-0.056064724922180176,
-0.3121494650840759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18458v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18458v1
|
Meta-Task Prompting Elicits Embedding from Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T16:35:52 | 2024-02-28T16:35:52 |
Yibin Lei, Di Wu, Tianyi Zhou, Tao Shen, Yu Cao, Chongyang Tao, Andrew Yates
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we introduce a new unsupervised embedding method, Meta-Task
Prompting with Explicit One-Word Limitation (MetaEOL), for generating
high-quality sentence embeddings from Large Language Models (LLMs) without the
need for model fine-tuning or task-specific engineering. Leveraging meta-task
prompting, MetaEOL guides LLMs to produce embeddings through a series of
carefully designed prompts that address multiple representational aspects. Our
comprehensive experiments demonstrate that embeddings averaged from various
meta-tasks yield competitive performance on Semantic Textual Similarity (STS)
benchmarks and excel in downstream tasks, surpassing contrastive-trained
models. Our findings suggest a new scaling law for embedding generation,
offering a versatile, resource-efficient approach for embedding extraction
across diverse sentence-centric scenarios.
|
[
-0.38362497091293335,
-0.7874588966369629,
0.7942194938659668,
0.34837496280670166,
-0.45825207233428955,
-0.3111596405506134,
-0.26271283626556396,
0.19653961062431335,
0.43631792068481445,
0.6347845792770386,
-0.8853588700294495,
-0.6086721420288086,
-0.5641393065452576,
0.18305328488349915,
-0.22460214793682098,
0.8317420482635498,
-0.017137916758656502,
-0.3494585454463959,
-0.7205494046211243,
0.011821204796433449,
-0.7240476608276367,
-0.04135973006486893,
-0.05233200266957283,
-0.027688149362802505,
0.5129362940788269,
0.5609110593795776,
0.5259769558906555,
0.5983785390853882,
-0.04743213579058647,
0.19742600619792938,
0.19462674856185913,
0.37195950746536255,
-0.13313941657543182,
0.4270036816596985,
-0.17875142395496368,
-0.11064557731151581,
-0.21748711168766022,
0.04769330844283104,
0.6715865135192871,
0.5806354880332947,
-0.11934838443994522,
0.46357786655426025,
0.5422792434692383,
0.3407966196537018,
-0.9693260788917542,
0.25461894273757935,
-0.569379448890686,
0.10249748080968857,
-0.06967764347791672,
-0.22858645021915436,
-0.7211155295372009,
-0.03829910233616829,
0.12842869758605957,
-0.5712860226631165,
0.03664737194776535,
-0.006539714056998491,
0.49460166692733765,
0.4111878275871277,
-0.4084565341472626,
-0.3691200017929077,
-0.1768007129430771,
0.6730898022651672,
-0.5050151348114014,
0.35485348105430603,
0.0676427111029625,
-0.13673135638237,
0.19940043985843658,
-0.7114442586898804,
-0.4888111650943756,
-0.33424732089042664,
-0.0856395959854126,
-0.0499831885099411,
-0.34635645151138306,
-0.13631610572338104,
0.2534407079219818,
-0.1689603477716446,
-0.47159555554389954,
-0.015355919487774372,
0.08205144852399826,
0.11021270602941513,
0.18157227337360382,
0.1992315948009491,
0.23124220967292786,
-0.4942237436771393,
-0.21991147100925446,
-0.16645045578479767,
-0.8278627991676331,
-0.23850120604038239,
0.09814637154340744,
0.5059278607368469,
0.14726267755031586,
0.7328289747238159,
0.01840030774474144,
0.4922875165939331,
0.11393111944198608,
0.3676503300666809,
0.2738720178604126,
-0.12355624884366989,
-0.1314445286989212,
-0.02931939624249935,
1.1293139457702637,
0.3289567232131958,
0.3775026500225067,
-0.16328519582748413,
-0.17984634637832642,
-0.11983216553926468,
0.38042381405830383,
-0.7606440186500549,
0.2004520297050476,
0.10197889059782028,
-0.39137792587280273,
-0.2944258749485016,
0.2806788384914398,
-0.8200128078460693,
-0.2218565195798874,
-0.06018826737999916,
0.6343672275543213,
-0.264743447303772,
-0.13865555822849274,
0.07718033343553543,
-0.2478155940771103,
0.028059253469109535,
-0.11949407309293747,
-0.8859877586364746,
0.01072302833199501,
0.5871180295944214,
0.7837865352630615,
0.05024120211601257,
-0.49158182740211487,
-0.8734506964683533,
0.28195884823799133,
-0.47629478573799133,
0.47810986638069153,
-0.7108190059661865,
-0.4538908898830414,
0.36451447010040283,
-0.023647688329219818,
0.03840097039937973,
-0.5078575015068054,
0.30626142024993896,
-0.2704105079174042,
0.10945169627666473,
-0.5664633512496948,
-0.45468267798423767,
0.10993435233831406,
0.26601338386535645,
-0.6275236010551453,
1.1174942255020142,
-0.07667000591754913,
-0.7016730904579163,
0.49885034561157227,
-0.8773012161254883,
-0.43176504969596863,
0.19740651547908783,
-0.30306559801101685,
-0.10498932003974915,
0.42752283811569214,
0.5782281160354614,
0.8953632116317749,
-0.27975383400917053,
0.2096906304359436,
-0.18409009277820587,
-0.00004240464841132052,
-0.015377599745988846,
-0.4360395073890686,
0.22371798753738403,
-0.005576907657086849,
-0.3702738881111145,
0.11618015915155411,
-0.2649877965450287,
0.106388159096241,
0.16460660099983215,
-0.27364975214004517,
-0.3765007555484772,
0.050073783844709396,
-0.03887462988495827,
0.21636928617954254,
0.48005253076553345,
-0.7106616497039795,
0.3800588846206665,
-0.18400783836841583,
0.6763047575950623,
0.6215460300445557,
-0.05841441452503204,
0.3503388464450836,
-0.05646917223930359,
0.5124009251594543,
-0.24942058324813843,
-0.21969398856163025,
-0.6632227301597595,
-0.188092902302742,
-0.42786192893981934,
-0.4830572307109833,
0.31613633036613464,
0.39006370306015015,
-0.6655502319335938,
0.5852043628692627,
-0.5193907022476196,
-0.1712368279695511,
-0.6806230545043945,
0.26926493644714355,
0.32867833971977234,
0.16038735210895538,
0.42888256907463074,
0.1994553655385971,
-0.4318481385707855,
-0.879789412021637,
-0.3097485303878784,
0.2649020552635193,
-0.15693609416484833,
0.38079163432121277,
0.5224624276161194,
-0.3308686316013336,
0.9940664172172546,
-0.6850224733352661,
-0.225677952170372,
-0.5029475688934326,
0.4920043647289276,
-0.019802836701273918,
0.3939632475376129,
0.4238680303096771,
-0.4461859166622162,
-0.6713160276412964,
-0.2635798156261444,
-0.7388021945953369,
-0.26635417342185974,
0.0016312611987814307,
0.044171012938022614,
-0.0005183020257391036,
1.0251529216766357,
-0.8577864766120911,
0.10439962893724442,
0.608782172203064,
-0.440985769033432,
0.32999175786972046,
-0.4575417935848236,
0.1035836711525917,
-1.376343846321106,
0.11748694628477097,
-0.28189435601234436,
-0.4398397207260132,
-0.196379616856575,
0.19952432811260223,
0.208933487534523,
-0.4013654291629791,
-0.45840984582901,
0.6017816066741943,
-0.5881049036979675,
0.05433676764369011,
-0.35467344522476196,
0.3017468750476837,
-0.018845850601792336,
0.17363767325878143,
0.036380328238010406,
0.7369847297668457,
0.5827454328536987,
-0.6169456243515015,
0.09417854249477386,
0.42020848393440247,
-0.17201583087444305,
0.26810401678085327,
-0.9384066462516785,
0.02635153941810131,
-0.21484056115150452,
0.35277605056762695,
-0.8998826146125793,
-0.12929996848106384,
-0.012068577110767365,
-0.18985114991664886,
0.08309344947338104,
-0.053572043776512146,
-0.740003228187561,
-0.45532017946243286,
-0.4091218113899231,
0.3715682029724121,
0.6176498532295227,
-0.6259472966194153,
0.593423068523407,
0.029524216428399086,
-0.2843738794326782,
-0.4571545720100403,
-0.8115692138671875,
0.10345692932605743,
0.008236126974225044,
-0.4634801745414734,
0.47944092750549316,
0.05108460783958435,
0.20155562460422516,
0.2588670253753662,
0.19594363868236542,
0.330872118473053,
-0.05467893183231354,
0.3626842498779297,
0.10479769110679626,
-0.16183027625083923,
0.39813894033432007,
0.3776593506336212,
-0.17111797630786896,
0.23077936470508575,
-0.6016796231269836,
0.6836631894111633,
0.08242084085941315,
-0.4953339397907257,
-0.37904614210128784,
0.7118380069732666,
0.7532224059104919,
-0.5299789905548096,
0.6547402739524841,
0.5598765015602112,
-0.3353303074836731,
-0.32356205582618713,
-0.43572214245796204,
-0.3194180727005005,
-0.504978358745575,
0.33633458614349365,
-0.37749576568603516,
-1.0894644260406494,
0.008794307708740234,
-0.25444817543029785,
0.2231980711221695,
0.43309640884399414,
0.6003879904747009,
-0.007038967218250036,
1.2641966342926025,
0.549238383769989,
0.10433108359575272,
0.4657847285270691,
-0.06881827116012573,
-0.06702379882335663,
-0.8980424404144287,
-0.07732478529214859,
-0.33753663301467896,
-0.2629089057445526,
-0.6091217398643494,
-0.6539549827575684,
0.35038959980010986,
-0.20611295104026794,
-0.20027634501457214,
0.44714871048927307,
-0.4240066409111023,
0.5465608835220337,
0.6116619110107422,
0.059826306998729706,
-0.17784811556339264,
-0.16994979977607727,
-0.49578315019607544,
-0.0981358215212822,
-0.7188920378684998,
-0.6008152961730957,
1.0242829322814941,
0.06232142448425293,
0.6128410696983337,
-0.051936499774456024,
0.939072847366333,
0.4097050428390503,
-0.020495619624853134,
-0.6368155479431152,
0.5662609934806824,
-0.35892415046691895,
-0.27413520216941833,
-0.3412279486656189,
-0.31019747257232666,
-1.0852197408676147,
0.23897026479244232,
-0.5196728110313416,
-0.586319625377655,
-0.07781583070755005,
0.10824350267648697,
-0.5828966498374939,
0.0966041311621666,
-0.3432828187942505,
0.9557276964187622,
0.2735458016395569,
-0.13318295776844025,
-0.21261678636074066,
-0.25967738032341003,
-0.08747981488704681,
0.23830156028270721,
0.14213040471076965,
0.0006602403591386974,
-0.3678121566772461,
0.6252843737602234,
-0.26265057921409607,
0.8705059289932251,
-0.2634798586368561,
-0.0952487587928772,
0.4170961081981659,
0.35317468643188477,
0.7792046070098877,
0.14958696067333221,
0.04729381203651428,
-0.41821548342704773,
-0.2930946946144104,
-0.3203893005847931,
-0.5734396576881409,
0.7105307579040527,
-0.24659229815006256,
-0.6307559013366699,
-0.03296343982219696,
-0.6223056316375732,
-0.29189062118530273,
0.1370372772216797,
0.5257793068885803,
0.5391666293144226,
-0.34216323494911194,
0.42495831847190857,
0.7962099313735962,
-0.3326207995414734,
0.7205386161804199,
0.26330122351646423,
-0.05116073414683342,
-0.372976690530777,
0.8524474501609802,
-0.08943887054920197,
0.100926972925663,
0.551615297794342,
0.2912229895591736,
-0.3581041991710663,
-0.12199085205793381,
-0.4460718035697937,
0.21396197378635406,
-0.49165284633636475,
-0.13968835771083832,
-0.9912827014923096,
0.12780974805355072,
-0.7041383385658264,
-0.3541628420352936,
-0.5193068981170654,
-0.17934493720531464,
-0.39345449209213257,
-0.23780310153961182,
0.05781630054116249,
0.9486819505691528,
0.005000092554837465,
0.1516890525817871,
-1.1269316673278809,
0.0699298083782196,
0.7127072811126709,
-0.08543454110622406,
0.06017341837286949,
-0.3320157825946808,
-0.098859503865242,
-0.14544206857681274,
-0.32756614685058594,
-0.7835028767585754,
0.2652714252471924,
0.2327139675617218,
0.58367919921875,
0.5713766813278198,
0.18016289174556732,
0.3575669825077057,
-0.971963107585907,
1.0298726558685303,
0.24674290418624878,
-1.332896113395691,
0.7744137644767761,
-0.41195937991142273,
0.48882296681404114,
0.42291003465652466,
0.4717097580432892,
-0.43462708592414856,
-0.30838721990585327,
-0.6340398788452148,
-0.8237369656562805,
0.28324535489082336,
-0.13149960339069366,
0.7825356721878052,
-0.5291888117790222,
0.21246078610420227,
0.13461437821388245,
0.3956505060195923,
-0.6259297728538513,
0.058553677052259445,
-0.18452540040016174,
-0.339913010597229,
0.026905758306384087,
-0.41789868474006653,
0.08509181439876556,
0.10459252446889877,
0.30031314492225647,
-0.3843095302581787,
0.3285844624042511,
0.2491995096206665,
-0.4446548521518707,
0.016791753470897675,
0.4232232868671417,
0.6324687600135803,
0.47612813115119934,
0.17117202281951904,
0.24819278717041016,
0.4018208682537079,
-0.1191757395863533,
0.0009677335037849844,
-0.08191300183534622,
-0.05692875385284424,
0.1333247870206833,
0.6466080546379089,
0.7263607978820801,
0.4657506048679352,
-0.6915483474731445,
0.8976905345916748,
0.2153843194246292,
-0.4512804448604584,
0.19995750486850739,
-0.13859553635120392,
0.20476120710372925,
0.3374883830547333,
0.33299610018730164,
-0.41459059715270996,
0.01711268536746502,
-0.5794636011123657,
0.4083876311779022,
0.6687569618225098,
-0.5059369206428528,
-0.19138666987419128,
0.6822113394737244,
0.3886812925338745,
-0.0675671175122261,
0.6800233721733093,
-0.3635629117488861,
-0.5465258955955505,
0.1629886031150818,
0.5777658224105835,
0.8857470750808716,
-0.15141655504703522,
0.6147668361663818,
0.44940653443336487,
0.3030073046684265,
-0.1659470498561859,
0.2614375352859497,
-0.09919650107622147,
-0.41621431708335876,
-0.580041766166687,
-0.41963431239128113,
-0.17232142388820648,
-0.16353677213191986,
-0.7708240151405334,
0.2134595513343811,
-0.387723833322525,
-0.0334237664937973,
-0.2807919383049011,
-0.4234721064567566,
-0.6216976046562195,
-0.020999524742364883,
0.29139038920402527,
0.8494495153427124,
-0.9174141883850098,
0.4015888273715973,
0.6766210198402405,
-0.19473114609718323,
-0.6668016910552979,
0.1430504471063614,
-0.10591688007116318,
-0.6540436744689941,
0.4738409221172333,
0.3683303892612457,
0.13644801080226898,
0.10394265502691269,
-0.5353538393974304,
-0.5380508899688721,
1.3046687841415405,
0.5851399302482605,
-0.5695740580558777,
-0.23793499171733856,
0.20510105788707733,
0.22147946059703827,
-0.8217378258705139,
0.12075874209403992,
0.15935415029525757,
0.5150660872459412,
-0.15695586800575256,
-0.6084150075912476,
0.5929426550865173,
0.0026077658403664827,
-0.05015947297215462,
0.2697981595993042,
-0.364991158246994,
0.9658301472663879,
-0.3747403621673584,
-0.23716552555561066,
-0.03934045881032944,
0.6067989468574524,
0.27101847529411316,
-0.04723203554749489,
0.7466751933097839,
0.6459388136863708,
0.7319175601005554,
0.03268775716423988,
1.0058883428573608,
-0.2739378809928894,
0.23011581599712372,
1.1533973217010498,
-0.2016998827457428,
1.0520985126495361,
0.4645017981529236,
0.25237101316452026,
0.7652564644813538,
0.29505395889282227,
-0.07128646224737167,
0.593904435634613,
0.05432528257369995,
-0.21483014523983002,
-0.6671103239059448,
-0.34288179874420166,
-0.2632726728916168,
0.3992833197116852,
0.21914814412593842,
-0.6095408797264099,
-0.35306811332702637,
0.4359827935695648,
-0.019652316346764565,
0.021710798144340515,
-0.07098297029733658,
0.8381116986274719,
0.10036826878786087,
-0.757256805896759,
0.18426966667175293,
-0.17439810931682587,
0.8019598722457886,
-0.5901328325271606,
-0.02205715700984001,
0.09803038835525513,
-0.3130073845386505,
0.15397579967975616,
-0.7468728423118591,
0.12221034616231918,
0.06586693227291107,
-0.33766406774520874,
-0.5652918219566345,
0.40608450770378113,
-0.6278770565986633,
-0.28130632638931274,
0.32249715924263,
0.7659309506416321,
-0.11781707406044006,
-0.36632564663887024,
-0.46229082345962524,
-0.12595084309577942,
-0.21203312277793884,
-0.377114862203598,
0.20980173349380493,
0.755156934261322,
0.15699346363544464,
0.5354752540588379,
0.5589830279350281,
-0.12146924436092377,
-0.1398388296365738,
0.08896250277757645,
0.7757510542869568,
-0.6541887521743774,
-0.5437173247337341,
-0.9480094909667969,
0.5717796087265015,
0.09440342336893082,
-0.23827442526817322,
0.527070164680481,
0.2289418876171112,
0.3723461627960205,
-0.33676785230636597,
0.7976957559585571,
-0.19219373166561127,
0.16491025686264038,
-0.5744895339012146,
0.4713957905769348,
-0.7927688956260681,
-0.011781171895563602,
-0.2920042872428894,
-0.9059023857116699,
0.07086140662431717,
0.3329463303089142,
-0.012142114341259003,
-0.08864793181419373,
0.8989811539649963,
0.7408736348152161,
-0.08347788453102112,
-0.21062734723091125,
0.42634159326553345,
-0.022068671882152557,
0.13970543444156647,
0.4751567244529724,
0.615616500377655,
-0.15815342962741852,
0.6901422739028931,
0.37086090445518494,
-0.03704150393605232,
-0.23701269924640656,
-1.1289846897125244,
-0.9227397441864014,
-0.7566115856170654,
-0.30875471234321594,
-0.28067976236343384,
-0.08381205797195435,
1.1962294578552246,
0.6828585863113403,
-0.4755652844905853,
0.2132391780614853,
-0.20422989130020142,
-0.0011536532547324896,
-0.2349637746810913,
-0.2025941163301468,
0.31056568026542664,
-0.5589547157287598,
-0.7742246985435486,
0.5198069214820862,
0.209916353225708,
-0.04720335826277733,
-0.26707723736763,
0.012155840173363686,
-0.10860413312911987,
0.37698954343795776,
0.650619626045227,
-0.09514354914426804,
-0.6442687511444092,
-0.3427862524986267,
0.01872374303638935,
-0.19505566358566284,
-0.3464219570159912,
1.0522884130477905,
-0.6404244303703308,
0.08520841598510742,
0.6918297410011292,
0.7557215094566345,
0.22816860675811768,
-0.2557936906814575,
0.651722252368927,
-1.2092405557632446,
-0.10711507499217987,
0.02356170304119587,
0.38427242636680603,
0.17295926809310913,
-0.237663134932518,
0.26688265800476074,
-0.050018031150102615,
-0.33102503418922424,
-0.624005913734436,
0.17456455528736115,
-0.6292325854301453,
-0.5043787360191345,
1.2303065061569214,
-0.234321728348732,
-0.13654360175132751,
0.35392582416534424,
-0.1457059681415558,
0.09254341572523117,
-0.47650355100631714,
0.35874396562576294,
0.7781250476837158,
0.2279258817434311,
-0.19085891544818878,
-0.37907296419143677,
0.3466739058494568,
0.6132524013519287,
-0.8136138319969177,
0.44635599851608276,
0.18431825935840607,
0.3339005410671234,
0.31385108828544617,
0.27841198444366455,
0.05710672587156296,
0.33004698157310486,
0.0960019901394844,
-0.02546529285609722,
-0.4037369191646576,
-0.4485355019569397,
-0.12128949910402298,
0.35171982645988464,
-0.19690820574760437,
-0.2655041813850403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18449v1
|
HOP to the Next Tasks and Domains for Continual Learning in NLP
| 2024-02-28T16:21:02 | 2024-02-28T16:21:02 |
Umberto Michieli, Mete Ozay
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Continual Learning (CL) aims to learn a sequence of problems (i.e., tasks and
domains) by transferring knowledge acquired on previous problems, whilst
avoiding forgetting of past ones. Different from previous approaches which
focused on CL for one NLP task or domain in a specific use-case, in this paper,
we address a more general CL setting to learn from a sequence of problems in a
unique framework. Our method, HOP, permits to hop across tasks and domains by
addressing the CL problem along three directions: (i) we employ a set of
adapters to generalize a large pre-trained model to unseen problems, (ii) we
compute high-order moments over the distribution of embedded representations to
distinguish independent and correlated statistics across different tasks and
domains, (iii) we process this enriched information with auxiliary heads
specialized for each end problem. Extensive experimental campaign on 4 NLP
applications, 5 benchmarks and 2 CL setups demonstrates the effectiveness of
our HOP.
|
[
-0.13206356763839722,
-0.4531586170196533,
0.6470658779144287,
0.5635895729064941,
-0.0931914672255516,
0.1332014799118042,
-0.21353508532047272,
-0.5474570393562317,
0.08025377243757248,
0.4917580485343933,
-0.7159004807472229,
-0.47125956416130066,
-0.7036945223808289,
0.13551118969917297,
-0.12579628825187683,
1.0455602407455444,
0.06962066888809204,
-0.2508736550807953,
-0.34974315762519836,
-0.2896422743797302,
-1.186919927597046,
-0.6145198941230774,
-1.0001180171966553,
-0.21295922994613647,
0.6073543429374695,
0.5286876559257507,
0.4358840882778168,
0.13607753813266754,
0.5049311518669128,
0.17375123500823975,
-0.01902911439538002,
0.2964078187942505,
-0.5387811064720154,
0.3674266040325165,
-0.597822368144989,
-0.4145013093948364,
-0.1363557130098343,
-0.14005360007286072,
0.5512146949768066,
1.1507970094680786,
0.2550390660762787,
0.18569092452526093,
0.36287131905555725,
0.740636944770813,
-0.6026010513305664,
0.08254586160182953,
-0.679273247718811,
0.09271736443042755,
-0.12307702749967575,
-0.49127396941185,
-0.5491597652435303,
-0.0550386980175972,
0.32303667068481445,
-0.6246029734611511,
-0.05292253568768501,
0.03843005374073982,
0.5459071397781372,
0.3331608772277832,
-0.2104148268699646,
-0.4894590377807617,
-0.8869245052337646,
0.8671107888221741,
-0.2409086376428604,
0.6349968314170837,
0.20267203450202942,
0.11707806587219238,
-0.12740306556224823,
-1.0416152477264404,
-0.18357518315315247,
-0.11415612697601318,
0.22831305861473083,
0.18742018938064575,
-0.05844668298959732,
-0.38632747530937195,
0.09114138036966324,
-0.2579324245452881,
-0.5571271181106567,
-0.09313711524009705,
-0.2156759351491928,
0.031050559133291245,
0.46727991104125977,
0.18352848291397095,
0.2502574622631073,
0.4844460189342499,
-0.48137766122817993,
-0.025262074545025826,
-0.699993908405304,
0.10560812056064606,
-0.2393294721841812,
0.38318902254104614,
0.12765541672706604,
0.3557373881340027,
0.12821348011493683,
0.8368250727653503,
0.09161270409822464,
-0.16169266402721405,
0.3554583489894867,
-0.09169285744428635,
0.07578621059656143,
-0.27597513794898987,
0.19775964319705963,
0.06221716105937958,
0.3408951163291931,
-0.5430901646614075,
-0.15943707525730133,
-0.3547903299331665,
0.5699516534805298,
0.026392528787255287,
-0.24581453204154968,
0.24176117777824402,
-0.2964209318161011,
0.08266615122556686,
-0.2792277932167053,
-0.6060085296630859,
-0.1345185786485672,
-0.6444611549377441,
0.5259456634521484,
-0.5837007761001587,
-0.1466778963804245,
0.11550222337245941,
-0.049106791615486145,
0.2053488790988922,
0.37354281544685364,
-0.5693441033363342,
0.49252837896347046,
0.7754914164543152,
1.284340739250183,
-0.7451152205467224,
-0.6311830282211304,
-0.890299916267395,
0.29300451278686523,
-0.29015809297561646,
0.7674168348312378,
-0.6172436475753784,
-0.5568333864212036,
0.16465674340724945,
0.13477405905723572,
-0.46677926182746887,
-0.613190233707428,
0.267249196767807,
-0.723183274269104,
-0.27168112993240356,
-0.17000629007816315,
-0.6548855304718018,
-0.21853238344192505,
0.20469048619270325,
-0.37669360637664795,
0.7406870722770691,
0.16503167152404785,
-0.7332577705383301,
0.35725685954093933,
-0.7114285230636597,
-0.39331358671188354,
0.276169091463089,
0.05576266720890999,
-0.2822893559932709,
-0.007096056826412678,
-0.20509988069534302,
0.4393547475337982,
0.17575202882289886,
0.1624429076910019,
-0.3305680453777313,
-0.16010892391204834,
-0.0538756400346756,
-0.008897213265299797,
0.9159032106399536,
0.08385572582483292,
-0.25525957345962524,
-0.05534454062581062,
-0.4982762932777405,
-0.08434855937957764,
0.18948273360729218,
-0.25043779611587524,
-0.650371789932251,
0.11155600845813751,
-0.030512334778904915,
0.23868060111999512,
0.2230653017759323,
-0.169644296169281,
0.32005277276039124,
-0.23284952342510223,
0.007282983511686325,
0.6577698588371277,
0.504223108291626,
0.33750760555267334,
-0.5273743271827698,
0.509807825088501,
0.226361483335495,
-0.021874086931347847,
-0.15463349223136902,
-0.8230381608009338,
-0.6688686609268188,
0.1107977032661438,
0.18068958818912506,
0.718944787979126,
-0.5052194595336914,
0.4148274064064026,
-0.33950144052505493,
-0.293649822473526,
0.20180276036262512,
0.273567795753479,
0.10726167261600494,
0.33710020780563354,
0.6146032214164734,
-0.36722591519355774,
-0.4321899116039276,
-0.01026358362287283,
-0.3182530999183655,
-0.023247674107551575,
-0.09358995407819748,
0.32499414682388306,
0.7697729468345642,
-0.49622827768325806,
1.0278644561767578,
-0.46443790197372437,
-0.3598552942276001,
-0.22695212066173553,
0.27471184730529785,
0.21005333960056305,
0.7075268626213074,
0.4731820523738861,
-0.9387498497962952,
-0.6959660053253174,
0.038652677088975906,
-0.6644834876060486,
0.11411852389574051,
-0.9400929808616638,
-0.3148113787174225,
-0.14783361554145813,
0.6167199015617371,
-0.4509730041027069,
0.20041906833648682,
0.279110848903656,
-0.23165613412857056,
0.8528265357017517,
-0.03215760365128517,
-0.4117785096168518,
-0.7330365180969238,
0.1580049991607666,
-0.17468003928661346,
-0.3860090672969818,
-0.7013267874717712,
-0.04276759922504425,
-0.2775115966796875,
-0.06836641579866409,
-0.267910361289978,
0.6623236536979675,
-0.41434407234191895,
-0.12591564655303955,
-0.2910797894001007,
0.17048774659633636,
-0.19752520322799683,
0.6036843657493591,
0.3410392701625824,
0.5943574905395508,
0.7892796993255615,
-1.1041842699050903,
0.20818345248699188,
0.3463664948940277,
0.08294589072465897,
0.4259577691555023,
-0.7265419363975525,
0.30687177181243896,
0.1135171502828598,
0.06856589019298553,
-0.6431746482849121,
0.23325872421264648,
0.25758376717567444,
-0.5777405500411987,
0.30584922432899475,
-0.14707104861736298,
-0.1954295039176941,
-0.34610316157341003,
0.16446155309677124,
0.41583189368247986,
0.4532429873943329,
-0.6418474912643433,
0.4259711503982544,
0.33533164858818054,
-0.24517814815044403,
-0.669107973575592,
-0.33940204977989197,
0.05138769745826721,
-0.3172866106033325,
-0.2456948161125183,
0.3576139807701111,
-0.25622209906578064,
-0.21238352358341217,
0.014297469519078732,
-0.2532951831817627,
-0.2071792036294937,
0.09384950250387192,
0.31857603788375854,
-0.0611879788339138,
-0.039206504821777344,
0.3169969916343689,
-0.18445663154125214,
-0.1850602775812149,
0.09491749852895737,
-0.9938974380493164,
0.6210116147994995,
-0.126729354262352,
-0.3791128993034363,
-0.12630847096443176,
0.5366294384002686,
0.26849421858787537,
-0.11314588040113449,
0.5649740099906921,
0.5396120548248291,
-0.3784232437610626,
-0.44563722610473633,
-0.2166016399860382,
0.18481603264808655,
-0.4156505763530731,
0.13118819892406464,
-0.443029522895813,
-0.8469103574752808,
0.3830288350582123,
-0.6040157675743103,
0.47263744473457336,
0.34845638275146484,
0.47445374727249146,
-0.3436959981918335,
0.349720299243927,
1.2800188064575195,
-0.18213462829589844,
0.30906549096107483,
-0.3513132333755493,
0.19325777888298035,
-0.7791219353675842,
-0.17484347522258759,
-0.38489046692848206,
-0.13852979242801666,
-0.12992316484451294,
-0.5498631596565247,
0.42820197343826294,
0.6037731766700745,
-0.29167988896369934,
0.6143486499786377,
-0.15835313498973846,
0.2618321478366852,
0.5820624828338623,
0.11136266589164734,
0.22709116339683533,
-0.17946739494800568,
-0.17773307859897614,
0.11609245836734772,
-0.7330762147903442,
-0.028157442808151245,
1.0299209356307983,
0.24246154725551605,
0.31524187326431274,
-0.03327146917581558,
0.9361901879310608,
0.5565750598907471,
0.1280401349067688,
-0.8705019354820251,
0.3287815749645233,
0.12072449922561646,
-0.22306756675243378,
-0.32225123047828674,
-0.2541447579860687,
-1.128512978553772,
-0.020828306674957275,
0.08046047389507294,
-0.8687360286712646,
0.3488115072250366,
0.25487345457077026,
-0.44220978021621704,
0.2583772838115692,
-0.19211040437221527,
0.7388249039649963,
-0.220968097448349,
-0.4352893531322479,
-0.2241533398628235,
-0.876448929309845,
0.18803943693637848,
-0.2691228687763214,
0.13389843702316284,
0.1669914275407791,
-0.05329849570989609,
0.7313160300254822,
-0.157293900847435,
0.9661683440208435,
-0.1468421071767807,
0.16599829494953156,
0.512181282043457,
0.15480577945709229,
0.46984952688217163,
0.255562961101532,
0.3625793159008026,
0.16868025064468384,
-0.16698220372200012,
-0.36819255352020264,
-0.4216519594192505,
0.31444746255874634,
-0.5080646872520447,
-0.40264424681663513,
-0.5291218161582947,
-0.5676831603050232,
-0.5666199922561646,
0.3532109558582306,
0.16776548326015472,
0.4691978394985199,
0.07142605632543564,
0.0996009111404419,
0.7237505912780762,
-0.2571452260017395,
0.5208326578140259,
0.16448135673999786,
-0.01217446755617857,
-0.08452703058719635,
0.853684663772583,
-0.11757045984268188,
0.3016219139099121,
0.5096059441566467,
0.032518673688173294,
-0.2664374113082886,
-0.555994987487793,
0.04357031360268593,
0.2155156284570694,
-0.8274107575416565,
-0.38288798928260803,
-0.8791455030441284,
-0.26823198795318604,
-0.5347716808319092,
-0.5322607159614563,
-0.305779367685318,
-0.05479172244668007,
-0.4117475748062134,
0.38644638657569885,
0.2934996485710144,
0.5173320770263672,
-0.38913241028785706,
0.3244997262954712,
-1.136193871498108,
0.3893490135669708,
0.3893353044986725,
0.3203146755695343,
0.04339498654007912,
-0.7362369894981384,
-0.4278097152709961,
-0.16747190058231354,
-0.371834397315979,
-0.8167040348052979,
0.6542715430259705,
0.5073275566101074,
0.6316967010498047,
0.29687365889549255,
0.03238322213292122,
0.7874972820281982,
-0.8913258910179138,
0.8307968974113464,
0.2070544809103012,
-0.8167365193367004,
0.6061024069786072,
-0.26374706625938416,
0.29524967074394226,
0.578810453414917,
1.050219178199768,
-0.7353584170341492,
-0.0990903377532959,
-0.6753326654434204,
-0.9424037337303162,
0.178995281457901,
0.04343688115477562,
0.007423234637826681,
-0.11090385168790817,
0.618799090385437,
0.14297635853290558,
-0.02989242784678936,
-0.7248930335044861,
-0.17771048843860626,
0.001174825825728476,
0.1889859139919281,
-0.04970082640647888,
-0.043312735855579376,
-0.10852105915546417,
-0.15148450434207916,
0.6489101052284241,
-0.25492680072784424,
0.473306804895401,
0.18452560901641846,
-0.5148832201957703,
0.2573819160461426,
-0.16481418907642365,
0.3107883036136627,
0.9952183365821838,
-0.04129747673869133,
-0.031050756573677063,
0.23712430894374847,
-0.5520618557929993,
-0.055641114711761475,
-0.5190971493721008,
0.06223256140947342,
0.25085434317588806,
0.601796567440033,
0.5709632635116577,
0.18058229982852936,
-0.6208097338676453,
0.4981686472892761,
0.3413333594799042,
-0.1371152549982071,
-0.5521112084388733,
0.015934687107801437,
0.003022476565092802,
0.46564072370529175,
0.27172189950942993,
0.5024133324623108,
0.19901522994041443,
-0.44843363761901855,
0.8423907160758972,
0.1833145022392273,
-0.31715017557144165,
-0.2700071930885315,
0.5029477477073669,
-0.03986116498708725,
-0.3235056698322296,
0.5708907842636108,
-0.29471996426582336,
-0.5050764083862305,
0.43294233083724976,
0.912312924861908,
0.8823224306106567,
-0.016408579424023628,
0.16772957146167755,
0.4643581807613373,
0.04700533673167229,
-0.26636120676994324,
0.18206581473350525,
-0.38371923565864563,
-0.780431866645813,
-0.5765810012817383,
-0.5661484003067017,
-0.6593255996704102,
-0.11075569689273834,
-0.765254557132721,
0.17145520448684692,
-0.30964282155036926,
0.03753525763750076,
-0.400197833776474,
-0.1998853236436844,
-0.7327516674995422,
0.3301149606704712,
0.09741050750017166,
0.8253734111785889,
-0.813558042049408,
0.8235177397727966,
0.5885940790176392,
-0.23499052226543427,
-0.32060354948043823,
0.35456788539886475,
-0.088395856320858,
-0.6539273262023926,
0.9192681908607483,
0.17586550116539001,
-0.3149097263813019,
0.06359254568815231,
-0.6129757165908813,
-1.028631329536438,
0.8339753746986389,
-0.33428314328193665,
-0.5294374227523804,
-0.14991125464439392,
-0.16685475409030914,
0.25612926483154297,
-0.5011489391326904,
-0.2391360104084015,
0.5398504137992859,
0.09254246950149536,
0.04346318542957306,
-0.5725773572921753,
-0.34068116545677185,
-0.14801561832427979,
0.05898427218198776,
-0.21275824308395386,
-0.3171056807041168,
0.523086667060852,
-0.3850879967212677,
-0.20929983258247375,
-0.12863850593566895,
1.0284444093704224,
0.4624606668949127,
0.439160019159317,
0.8469001650810242,
0.20073141157627106,
0.7888787984848022,
0.1606702357530594,
0.5935852527618408,
-0.39568623900413513,
0.4445893466472626,
1.4309674501419067,
-0.20902316272258759,
0.8746411204338074,
0.35914573073387146,
-0.20785707235336304,
0.46459200978279114,
0.6832771897315979,
0.1073518767952919,
0.636603057384491,
0.14961345493793488,
-0.24080254137516022,
-0.25753504037857056,
0.08909889310598373,
-0.2541007101535797,
0.3267505466938019,
0.7428242564201355,
0.1862538605928421,
-0.2004498988389969,
0.4461783766746521,
-0.04052264988422394,
-0.10249727964401245,
-0.4800061881542206,
0.643734872341156,
0.23288173973560333,
-0.502605140209198,
0.463344931602478,
-0.3730965852737427,
0.6318589448928833,
-0.6662806272506714,
-0.20434899628162384,
-0.0738193616271019,
0.07532469928264618,
-0.035376038402318954,
-0.7033414840698242,
0.7618924379348755,
-0.06549590080976486,
-0.11333955079317093,
-0.4043143093585968,
0.646010160446167,
-0.14483299851417542,
-0.19531798362731934,
0.41342276334762573,
0.4757333993911743,
0.3551364243030548,
-0.09137332439422607,
-0.7251845598220825,
-0.13282303512096405,
-0.15616577863693237,
-0.2650122046470642,
0.26769405603408813,
0.5619648098945618,
0.0321333222091198,
0.7944358587265015,
0.5266404151916504,
0.13407480716705322,
0.3540666997432709,
-0.056047022342681885,
0.7640587687492371,
-0.7012106776237488,
-0.6114005446434021,
-0.43734174966812134,
0.5168657302856445,
0.0339350551366806,
-0.6099081635475159,
0.5110673904418945,
0.2135433852672577,
1.0162888765335083,
-0.1553821861743927,
0.8156498670578003,
-0.11972107738256454,
0.549223005771637,
-0.6126344799995422,
0.11601796746253967,
-0.5089569091796875,
0.12640635669231415,
-0.1885925829410553,
-0.8731885552406311,
-0.6151097416877747,
0.6516591310501099,
-0.03460942581295967,
-0.13251812756061554,
0.9484333395957947,
0.05354991555213928,
-0.07277963310480118,
-0.1610541194677353,
0.3740612864494324,
0.024273257702589035,
0.17697685956954956,
0.7157400846481323,
0.5061883926391602,
-0.14900462329387665,
0.25668877363204956,
-0.3229876160621643,
-0.15742403268814087,
0.06196882948279381,
-0.7482438087463379,
-0.6644297242164612,
-0.8412879705429077,
-0.356325626373291,
-0.3502225875854492,
0.1306099146604538,
0.9081684947013855,
0.6295225620269775,
-0.8460715413093567,
-0.22724837064743042,
-0.30983150005340576,
0.1605803519487381,
-0.8112242221832275,
-0.20704244077205658,
0.32276222109794617,
-1.1826767921447754,
-0.5598334074020386,
0.5286552906036377,
0.3237456977367401,
-0.3460257053375244,
0.16220609843730927,
0.0018467403715476394,
-0.35060402750968933,
-0.16466160118579865,
0.7780649662017822,
0.6526621580123901,
-0.2154705971479416,
-0.5018221735954285,
0.0630631297826767,
0.31459471583366394,
0.11744333058595657,
1.0537822246551514,
-0.7774565815925598,
0.2506990134716034,
0.23932114243507385,
1.2360191345214844,
0.3923293948173523,
-0.19965508580207825,
0.4663652181625366,
-0.8041092753410339,
-0.033899351954460144,
0.5757963061332703,
0.23431694507598877,
-0.019006213173270226,
-0.503950297832489,
0.6522475481033325,
0.5730881094932556,
-0.832481324672699,
-0.547125518321991,
0.45834118127822876,
-1.1982829570770264,
-0.35593050718307495,
1.2050434350967407,
-0.504119336605072,
0.0717213973402977,
-0.6556757092475891,
0.3336951434612274,
0.10033396631479263,
0.26309600472450256,
0.46196913719177246,
0.3972615897655487,
-0.5218632221221924,
-0.018231196328997612,
-0.6247409582138062,
0.5172380805015564,
0.3871951103210449,
-0.6608432531356812,
0.013386699371039867,
0.1834629774093628,
0.3749280571937561,
0.39652323722839355,
0.7843883633613586,
0.0064249527640640736,
0.2411065250635147,
0.0406915619969368,
-0.156124085187912,
0.3843323588371277,
-1.236651062965393,
-0.2881307601928711,
0.17554667592048645,
-0.038986705243587494,
-0.27978986501693726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18439v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18439v3
|
Beyond Natural Language: LLMs Leveraging Alternative Formats for Enhanced Reasoning and Communication
| 2024-02-28T16:07:54 | 2024-06-19T01:42:22 |
Weize Chen, Chenfei Yuan, Jiarui Yuan, Yusheng Su, Chen Qian, Cheng Yang, Ruobing Xie, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Natural language (NL) has long been the predominant format for human
cognition and communication, and by extension, has been similarly pivotal in
the development and application of Large Language Models (LLMs). Yet, besides
NL, LLMs have seen various non-NL formats during pre-training, such as code and
logical expression. NL's status as the optimal format for LLMs, particularly in
single-LLM reasoning and multi-agent communication, has not been thoroughly
examined. In this work, we challenge the default use of NL by exploring the
utility of non-NL formats in these contexts. We show that allowing LLMs to
autonomously select the most suitable format before reasoning or communicating
leads to a 3.3 to 5.7\% improvement in reasoning efficiency for different LLMs,
and up to a 72.7\% reduction in token usage in multi-agent communication, all
while maintaining communicative effectiveness. Our comprehensive analysis
further reveals that LLMs can devise a format from limited task instructions
and that the devised format is effectively transferable across different LLMs.
Intriguingly, the structured communication format decided by LLMs exhibits
notable parallels with established agent communication languages, suggesting a
natural evolution towards efficient, structured communication in agent
communication. Our code is released at
\url{https://github.com/thunlp/AutoForm}.
|
[
-0.32881271839141846,
-0.8097538948059082,
0.7396191954612732,
0.27826303243637085,
-0.3208926320075989,
0.15315692126750946,
-0.6276936531066895,
-0.6456685662269592,
0.2432391196489334,
0.4427298903465271,
-0.3762059509754181,
-0.3982456624507904,
-0.31617307662963867,
0.44371452927589417,
-0.03192973881959915,
0.669244110584259,
-0.028497766703367233,
-0.13593962788581848,
-0.4115365445613861,
-0.290933221578598,
-0.540873110294342,
-0.8175237774848938,
-0.7833253145217896,
-0.6827065944671631,
0.4700058102607727,
0.15778321027755737,
0.7469250559806824,
0.7213225960731506,
0.4460158050060272,
0.40973585844039917,
0.1809035837650299,
0.5821236371994019,
-0.170676127076149,
0.1916380226612091,
-0.055456679314374924,
-0.5173738598823547,
-0.669688880443573,
0.1901182234287262,
0.6633611917495728,
0.8077369928359985,
-0.19122113287448883,
-0.014411060139536858,
-0.14433561265468597,
0.9570639133453369,
-0.5301729440689087,
0.41847866773605347,
-0.6098311543464661,
0.06078694388270378,
-0.1114925742149353,
-0.5412609577178955,
-0.6025890111923218,
-0.21343831717967987,
-0.024543145671486855,
-0.8268868923187256,
-0.4324614703655243,
0.16307327151298523,
0.5503960847854614,
0.41773489117622375,
-0.47014275193214417,
-0.4633130729198456,
-0.8515498638153076,
0.5207048654556274,
-0.6881853342056274,
0.6317158937454224,
0.3338985741138458,
0.42791128158569336,
-0.3130134642124176,
-0.7804608941078186,
-0.6996688842773438,
-0.472777396440506,
-0.16379493474960327,
0.02679380215704441,
-0.33690640330314636,
0.2314320206642151,
0.20095893740653992,
0.16600735485553741,
-0.5848837494850159,
0.3042466640472412,
-0.020507486537098885,
-0.242448091506958,
0.7262083888053894,
0.19879546761512756,
0.15533845126628876,
-0.08283480256795883,
-0.27270224690437317,
-0.09106779843568802,
-0.695432186126709,
0.009976211003959179,
0.3468765616416931,
0.34346699714660645,
-0.21288608014583588,
0.6290075182914734,
-0.18268315494060516,
0.9406903982162476,
0.021978992968797684,
-0.20704160630702972,
0.08345786482095718,
-0.4520525336265564,
-0.4490600526332855,
-0.011976958252489567,
0.747464120388031,
0.25675779581069946,
0.2805940508842468,
-0.1967206597328186,
-0.22250942885875702,
0.11771044880151749,
0.21493388712406158,
-0.4419056475162506,
-0.33156922459602356,
-0.058237478137016296,
-0.5079727172851562,
0.05233678221702576,
-0.1850820630788803,
-0.24279195070266724,
-0.37536710500717163,
-0.7102254033088684,
0.29251912236213684,
-0.37191563844680786,
-0.15960299968719482,
0.37004783749580383,
-0.06764313578605652,
0.38590025901794434,
0.675150454044342,
-0.7578169703483582,
0.25610843300819397,
0.501038134098053,
0.6155402064323425,
-0.08444608747959137,
-0.09166930615901947,
-0.5662634372711182,
0.2165481299161911,
-0.573366641998291,
1.0268300771713257,
-0.6441935300827026,
-0.18411456048488617,
-0.28548237681388855,
-0.1742127239704132,
-0.11924486607313156,
-0.44558456540107727,
0.3982820212841034,
-0.5155102610588074,
0.4535163342952728,
-0.10314937680959702,
-0.6313827633857727,
-0.07756481319665909,
0.3630527853965759,
-0.8302730321884155,
0.9806227087974548,
-0.063867948949337,
-0.32357078790664673,
0.2988109290599823,
-1.1413064002990723,
-0.531986653804779,
0.1192241981625557,
-0.33319440484046936,
-0.15115074813365936,
-0.06177955120801926,
0.09878738969564438,
0.28613537549972534,
-0.23984695971012115,
0.3097549080848694,
-0.34365853667259216,
-0.29874494671821594,
0.25562551617622375,
-0.5668226480484009,
0.5655206441879272,
0.2653901278972626,
-0.2633030414581299,
0.2808779776096344,
-0.7172330617904663,
0.09549606591463089,
0.3381601870059967,
-0.5388666391372681,
-0.2744275629520416,
-0.11064380407333374,
-0.4337065815925598,
0.4083145260810852,
0.23116444051265717,
-0.3479263186454773,
0.26490846276283264,
-0.467164546251297,
0.5596507787704468,
0.7334635257720947,
-0.2987845838069916,
0.9265686869621277,
-0.5128658413887024,
0.38906240463256836,
-0.34534844756126404,
0.2492251694202423,
-0.09604879468679428,
-0.38325226306915283,
-0.7501035928726196,
-0.3437832295894623,
0.015919934958219528,
0.5006722211837769,
-0.7229406833648682,
0.5063294172286987,
-0.016711153090000153,
-0.47269555926322937,
-0.5512254238128662,
0.20407702028751373,
0.19501657783985138,
0.4428088665008545,
0.37520456314086914,
-0.11151368916034698,
-0.8910038471221924,
-0.8646637201309204,
-0.217423677444458,
-0.37951260805130005,
0.3187066316604614,
0.2669185698032379,
0.23835937678813934,
-0.18280957639217377,
1.1581376791000366,
-0.1297684758901596,
0.09945753961801529,
-0.6955968737602234,
-0.14559951424598694,
0.1342904269695282,
0.3066600263118744,
0.4787873327732086,
-0.700604259967804,
-0.48862817883491516,
-0.23099008202552795,
-0.7791638970375061,
-0.21273460984230042,
-0.6632474660873413,
-0.30619627237319946,
0.7075394988059998,
0.6141446828842163,
-0.7602888345718384,
0.5377182960510254,
0.4825076758861542,
-0.28730034828186035,
0.5771691203117371,
-0.47352832555770874,
-0.12014192342758179,
-0.7250341773033142,
-0.017519088461995125,
-0.14363062381744385,
-0.539210319519043,
-0.6383653283119202,
-0.25156646966934204,
0.06232059374451637,
0.2210518717765808,
-0.27749350666999817,
0.8768023252487183,
-0.8792712092399597,
-0.20623993873596191,
-0.48149579763412476,
0.12664136290550232,
0.4413091540336609,
0.444031685590744,
0.39624151587486267,
0.8608315587043762,
0.382571816444397,
-0.5903583765029907,
0.4131418466567993,
0.27007049322128296,
-0.04558684304356575,
0.5393721461296082,
-0.6600677371025085,
0.3938230872154236,
-0.46821150183677673,
0.5757920742034912,
-0.6243174076080322,
0.12937413156032562,
0.29853612184524536,
-0.32154619693756104,
0.34927502274513245,
0.11588974297046661,
-0.8015512824058533,
-0.0686253011226654,
-0.36782070994377136,
0.06494908779859543,
0.3353513479232788,
-0.5330522060394287,
0.6937447190284729,
0.19911400973796844,
0.13806156814098358,
-0.33572694659233093,
-0.6870372295379639,
0.5924932956695557,
-0.33961769938468933,
-0.6717351675033569,
0.16831012070178986,
-0.4223679006099701,
-0.44241684675216675,
-0.2308880239725113,
-0.20797373354434967,
0.1440332680940628,
0.3001534044742584,
-0.08562573790550232,
0.40082961320877075,
-0.4029681384563446,
0.3481020927429199,
0.005838328506797552,
-0.16089411079883575,
0.03285190090537071,
-0.4181062579154968,
0.6087236404418945,
-0.430716335773468,
-0.48302844166755676,
-0.4240628182888031,
0.6270742416381836,
0.15300814807415009,
-0.330392450094223,
1.0279107093811035,
0.37676680088043213,
-0.2045232504606247,
-0.24971158802509308,
-0.5094667077064514,
-0.25962260365486145,
-0.546947181224823,
0.039709124714136124,
-0.31111082434654236,
-0.8459000587463379,
0.19188418984413147,
-0.08750439435243607,
0.0804709643125534,
0.269103467464447,
0.46987536549568176,
-0.07768679410219193,
0.6768540143966675,
0.7458720803260803,
0.4093033969402313,
0.5172638297080994,
0.010557928122580051,
0.4795924425125122,
-0.815811276435852,
-0.3455447554588318,
-0.2815401256084442,
-0.09108885377645493,
-0.5732609033584595,
-0.5985289216041565,
0.16095727682113647,
0.18534447252750397,
-0.2611961364746094,
0.4296596348285675,
-0.38381636142730713,
0.4318861663341522,
0.40403592586517334,
-0.2341582179069519,
0.646668016910553,
-0.2978152334690094,
-0.11527368426322937,
0.08437895774841309,
-0.8019380569458008,
-1.0574063062667847,
0.9198580384254456,
0.3660707175731659,
0.6607255339622498,
0.21021491289138794,
0.8312544226646423,
0.2162332981824875,
0.4680558443069458,
-0.8098931908607483,
0.6990115642547607,
0.09433205425739288,
-0.32836249470710754,
-0.39002546668052673,
-0.3402414321899414,
-0.966564416885376,
0.35329803824424744,
-0.2886938452720642,
-0.5795210599899292,
-0.011538398452103138,
0.04553721845149994,
-0.2974195182323456,
0.23481373488903046,
-0.9097659587860107,
0.7305383086204529,
-0.34056782722473145,
-0.05071287602186203,
0.2415565550327301,
-0.8371490836143494,
-0.009642967954277992,
-0.06162972375750542,
0.21955439448356628,
-0.1041530966758728,
-0.2718925476074219,
0.5271595120429993,
-0.3187893033027649,
0.9607217907905579,
0.26834315061569214,
-0.2651037275791168,
0.3740706145763397,
-0.08523542433977127,
0.6505627036094666,
0.2393973171710968,
-0.1608390212059021,
-0.08431912213563919,
-0.3060039281845093,
-0.21614471077919006,
-0.9362759590148926,
0.2989422380924225,
-0.65143883228302,
-0.710294783115387,
-0.40783825516700745,
-0.6244502663612366,
-0.247941255569458,
0.27579161524772644,
-0.04053344577550888,
0.5227780342102051,
0.023768149316310883,
0.12656468152999878,
0.6394588947296143,
-0.1752554178237915,
0.7302983403205872,
0.7374880313873291,
0.10034769773483276,
-0.047309670597314835,
0.5969530344009399,
-0.12615840137004852,
0.5071267485618591,
0.564517617225647,
0.3593849837779999,
-0.6845334768295288,
-0.6468647122383118,
-0.3561434745788574,
0.23538626730442047,
-1.042048692703247,
-0.24820716679096222,
-0.8205838203430176,
-0.15223708748817444,
-0.5982534885406494,
-0.21951262652873993,
-0.40587207674980164,
-0.5615960359573364,
-0.39105087518692017,
-0.22720937430858612,
0.2752293050289154,
0.6251768469810486,
-0.34188950061798096,
0.11465577036142349,
-0.784041166305542,
0.19109486043453217,
0.23221461474895477,
0.3136873245239258,
-0.17506659030914307,
-0.29195499420166016,
0.09304088354110718,
0.07216602563858032,
-0.04016728326678276,
-0.915172815322876,
0.2895081639289856,
0.3933982849121094,
1.0045676231384277,
0.13758741319179535,
0.06479839980602264,
0.6548038721084595,
-0.4536515474319458,
0.49720630049705505,
0.05778208002448082,
-0.8163753151893616,
0.365035742521286,
-0.2166302651166916,
0.2449195683002472,
0.44831138849258423,
0.024145344272255898,
-0.6591230034828186,
-0.39834368228912354,
-0.5599567890167236,
-0.737561821937561,
0.5929399728775024,
0.3338495194911957,
0.08574477583169937,
-0.19072547554969788,
0.29043203592300415,
0.23906689882278442,
0.24190782010555267,
-0.8607683181762695,
-0.43126434087753296,
-0.37197551131248474,
-0.07892870903015137,
-0.1652286797761917,
0.13502898812294006,
-0.19892318546772003,
-0.287221759557724,
0.17586268484592438,
-0.3564916253089905,
0.501239001750946,
0.363690584897995,
-0.27391353249549866,
0.17465487122535706,
0.47334393858909607,
0.7100159525871277,
0.5550378561019897,
0.15798723697662354,
0.32927629351615906,
0.007500813342630863,
-0.14410175383090973,
-0.04814866930246353,
0.1573682725429535,
0.290470689535141,
-0.07411506026983261,
0.48862510919570923,
0.9761020541191101,
-0.14374791085720062,
-0.6541604995727539,
0.1885109394788742,
-0.096090167760849,
-0.1742018610239029,
-0.3687719702720642,
0.02546088397502899,
0.30329492688179016,
0.36440539360046387,
0.19646106660366058,
0.061606861650943756,
0.037142109125852585,
-0.7163772583007812,
0.11937274038791656,
0.5242938995361328,
0.0779600441455841,
-0.19629979133605957,
0.33498987555503845,
0.237565279006958,
-0.43676841259002686,
0.24849148094654083,
-0.5776069760322571,
-0.2667120397090912,
0.4814628064632416,
0.7851446866989136,
0.7246501445770264,
0.2703497111797333,
0.38589712977409363,
-0.053127262741327286,
0.5356283187866211,
-0.011628820560872555,
0.21788811683654785,
-0.26104575395584106,
-0.8494057059288025,
-0.6683409214019775,
-0.521504282951355,
-0.3653578460216522,
0.04792740195989609,
-0.2419348955154419,
0.031774017959833145,
-0.46355512738227844,
-0.019689129665493965,
-0.06283848732709885,
0.16165898740291595,
-0.6856608986854553,
-0.019091928377747536,
0.5927797555923462,
1.0672760009765625,
-0.5980710387229919,
0.9338740706443787,
1.053146481513977,
-0.045314617455005646,
-0.9603476524353027,
-0.2660600543022156,
-0.029974380508065224,
-0.7216541171073914,
0.47044283151626587,
0.26505136489868164,
-0.31842344999313354,
-0.17340105772018433,
-0.5605872869491577,
-0.9034201502799988,
1.009469985961914,
0.5338184237480164,
-0.3726038336753845,
-0.006864494178444147,
0.3169844150543213,
0.6520373225212097,
-0.6065002679824829,
0.3467511832714081,
0.5837981700897217,
0.7222238779067993,
0.24344761669635773,
-1.0891313552856445,
0.2715578079223633,
-0.3686870336532593,
0.04695644974708557,
0.3755655586719513,
-0.586561381816864,
0.6836705803871155,
-0.2761024832725525,
-0.3161716163158417,
-0.13280926644802094,
0.8150531053543091,
0.38133758306503296,
0.2998140752315521,
0.4440864026546478,
0.12713980674743652,
0.9668116569519043,
0.13705383241176605,
0.9614626169204712,
0.13542640209197998,
-0.18038994073867798,
1.218363881111145,
-0.4535139203071594,
0.4976116716861725,
0.5995451807975769,
0.08784178644418716,
0.6830006241798401,
0.46900179982185364,
0.28118807077407837,
0.22002708911895752,
0.21841846406459808,
-0.11146698147058487,
-0.5436309576034546,
-0.13642479479312897,
-0.11467400193214417,
0.837555468082428,
0.32784709334373474,
0.14585630595684052,
-0.3990335464477539,
-0.09521181881427765,
0.12360002100467682,
0.4463711977005005,
-0.043121203780174255,
0.8724523782730103,
0.14576946198940277,
-0.4856303036212921,
0.5447357296943665,
0.0014506509760394692,
0.7956893444061279,
-0.5226783752441406,
-0.18686868250370026,
-0.18879956007003784,
-0.22645705938339233,
-0.2010485678911209,
-0.7291285395622253,
0.6271739602088928,
-0.21282106637954712,
0.062212955206632614,
-0.5879951119422913,
0.9996468424797058,
-0.42764022946357727,
-0.004486574791371822,
0.21809956431388855,
0.8176581859588623,
-0.006547785829752684,
-0.1110418438911438,
-0.7567616105079651,
0.01270313560962677,
-0.40884914994239807,
-0.3808043897151947,
0.2520824670791626,
0.6546182632446289,
-0.3503018021583557,
0.8168138861656189,
0.8844619989395142,
0.056531623005867004,
0.047752439975738525,
0.13142994046211243,
0.9804911017417908,
-0.668684720993042,
-0.595683753490448,
-0.9641299247741699,
0.33460086584091187,
-0.2998155355453491,
-0.07643233239650726,
0.7966575026512146,
0.46091175079345703,
0.6264474987983704,
0.2408861517906189,
0.6322199106216431,
0.04826539382338524,
0.052785102277994156,
-0.689997136592865,
0.5304876565933228,
-0.3987502157688141,
0.33344003558158875,
-0.10668984055519104,
-0.7354740500450134,
-0.2795184254646301,
0.6917042136192322,
-0.23436641693115234,
0.07713409513235092,
0.8211775422096252,
0.35683774948120117,
0.2935165464878082,
0.1993989199399948,
0.19379515945911407,
-0.2924502491950989,
0.5523064136505127,
0.7160610556602478,
0.9915238618850708,
0.11314184218645096,
0.5253309011459351,
-0.10005812346935272,
-0.14221180975437164,
0.06371767073869705,
-1.23481285572052,
-1.1603666543960571,
-0.39039409160614014,
-0.1693863868713379,
0.04641414433717728,
-0.12838363647460938,
1.3506370782852173,
0.636172354221344,
-0.2069244235754013,
-0.1561712771654129,
-0.10281629115343094,
0.17963536083698273,
-0.004097032360732555,
-0.17460259795188904,
0.054766230285167694,
-0.45530545711517334,
-0.4533891975879669,
0.6851274967193604,
0.6060764193534851,
0.3853150010108948,
-0.15312345325946808,
-0.24164943397045135,
-0.24137842655181885,
0.33707937598228455,
0.9127499461174011,
0.37814393639564514,
-0.5317456722259521,
-0.27188587188720703,
0.3797338306903839,
-0.3146283030509949,
0.33691102266311646,
0.8462273478507996,
-0.8527041673660278,
0.23377877473831177,
0.38106584548950195,
0.568589985370636,
0.10353507101535797,
-0.11530578136444092,
0.821959376335144,
-0.5878673195838928,
0.26862260699272156,
0.387999951839447,
0.22701671719551086,
0.5544905066490173,
-0.47064751386642456,
0.32926318049430847,
0.03656379505991936,
-0.2858377695083618,
-0.747681200504303,
0.32351377606391907,
-0.9678168892860413,
-0.3637290894985199,
1.352941632270813,
0.08837450295686722,
-0.15636250376701355,
-0.4013859033584595,
-0.25415143370628357,
0.2945297360420227,
-0.6451587080955505,
0.5351116061210632,
0.5663763284683228,
-0.49761441349983215,
-0.2753776013851166,
-0.5162504315376282,
0.7583240270614624,
0.3375488519668579,
-1.2230298519134521,
-0.10826367139816284,
0.3822174668312073,
0.037892792373895645,
-0.0254985261708498,
1.0667908191680908,
-0.06290548294782639,
0.15360930562019348,
-0.34647634625434875,
-0.24513883888721466,
-0.4544469714164734,
-0.3934614360332489,
-0.257232666015625,
-0.20413361489772797,
0.17556333541870117,
0.018205659464001656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18428v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18428v1
|
Leveraging Diverse Modeling Contexts with Collaborating Learning for Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-02-28T15:55:02 | 2024-02-28T15:55:02 |
Yusheng Liao, Yanfeng Wang, Yu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Autoregressive (AR) and Non-autoregressive (NAR) models are two types of
generative models for Neural Machine Translation (NMT). AR models predict
tokens in a word-by-word manner and can effectively capture the distribution of
real translations. NAR models predict tokens by extracting bidirectional
contextual information which can improve the inference speed but they suffer
from performance degradation. Previous works utilized AR models to enhance NAR
models by reducing the training data's complexity or incorporating the global
information into AR models by virtue of NAR models. However, those investigated
methods only take advantage of the contextual information of a single type of
model while neglecting the diversity in the contextual information that can be
provided by different types of models. In this paper, we propose a novel
generic collaborative learning method, DCMCL, where AR and NAR models are
treated as collaborators instead of teachers and students. To hierarchically
leverage the bilateral contextual information, token-level mutual learning and
sequence-level contrastive learning are adopted between AR and NAR models.
Extensive experiments on four widely used benchmarks show that the proposed
DCMCL method can simultaneously improve both AR and NAR models with up to 1.38
and 2.98 BLEU scores respectively, and can also outperform the current
best-unified model with up to 0.97 BLEU scores for both AR and NAR decoding.
|
[
-0.3506219685077667,
-0.5351986289024353,
0.26185911893844604,
0.016490602865815163,
-0.4337446689605713,
0.39488130807876587,
-0.26586729288101196,
-0.2553713023662567,
0.011363031342625618,
0.35342109203338623,
-0.4617147743701935,
-0.6098355054855347,
-0.6865519285202026,
0.08471942692995071,
-0.14525267481803894,
0.9876925945281982,
-0.11958930641412735,
0.3379601836204529,
-0.2578776478767395,
-0.5343876481056213,
-0.6535204648971558,
-0.7302104830741882,
-0.47770029306411743,
-0.36757218837738037,
0.6504744291305542,
0.20003212988376617,
0.6263418793678284,
0.6187219619750977,
0.48026666045188904,
0.3274039924144745,
-0.17558836936950684,
0.43446099758148193,
-0.1662158966064453,
0.3088800609111786,
-0.35788482427597046,
-0.4167274534702301,
-0.5099503993988037,
-0.009294874034821987,
0.304189532995224,
1.0329890251159668,
-0.2253614366054535,
-0.011287241242825985,
0.42301055788993835,
0.6008856892585754,
-0.546413004398346,
0.27388301491737366,
-0.6774609684944153,
0.254455029964447,
0.4807092845439911,
0.009996316395699978,
-0.34780922532081604,
-0.17501293122768402,
0.39677298069000244,
-0.33199113607406616,
0.3703446686267853,
-0.06585986912250519,
0.2867938280105591,
0.31422704458236694,
-0.7007836699485779,
-0.3205539584159851,
-0.4993637204170227,
0.8576220870018005,
-0.555343747138977,
0.31880614161491394,
0.02112755738198757,
0.40929895639419556,
0.06484425812959671,
-0.6064167618751526,
-0.4313669800758362,
-0.22820308804512024,
-0.1964033544063568,
0.3216848075389862,
-0.12686431407928467,
0.10199732333421707,
-0.2654968798160553,
0.46907860040664673,
-0.47889143228530884,
-0.04048338159918785,
-0.04152238368988037,
0.053443096578121185,
0.4876749515533447,
0.335319846868515,
0.2265041321516037,
-0.08210417628288269,
-0.6668620109558105,
-0.23455066978931427,
-0.16131827235221863,
-0.11929086595773697,
-0.2654815912246704,
0.45138946175575256,
-0.602549135684967,
0.2378673106431961,
0.0620669350028038,
0.6912539601325989,
0.2023838758468628,
0.2846839129924774,
0.2427964061498642,
-0.43607833981513977,
-0.3251602351665497,
-0.38350722193717957,
0.8900541663169861,
0.2459021359682083,
-0.2756652534008026,
-0.6945913434028625,
-0.2529676854610443,
-0.20019106566905975,
-0.011939776130020618,
-0.38578444719314575,
-0.392179936170578,
-0.2361946552991867,
-0.5064874887466431,
-0.2967506945133209,
0.023488031700253487,
-0.8281126022338867,
-0.0013980773510411382,
-0.6910656094551086,
0.47137650847435,
-0.09574302285909653,
-0.4003664255142212,
-0.49089181423187256,
0.13610617816448212,
-0.138876274228096,
0.38734421133995056,
-0.8237942457199097,
0.4193165600299835,
0.39753100275993347,
1.1597793102264404,
-0.6608760952949524,
-0.5461722612380981,
-0.6484899520874023,
0.0074213407933712006,
-0.42837831377983093,
0.2564998269081116,
-0.16265301406383514,
-0.531851589679718,
-0.2586659789085388,
-0.19296042621135712,
-0.5439881682395935,
-0.5766130089759827,
0.04123152047395706,
-0.7084705233573914,
0.07276608049869537,
-0.39571449160575867,
-0.2760501801967621,
-0.37726685404777527,
0.33997642993927,
-0.6608333587646484,
0.6130031943321228,
0.2971389889717102,
-0.6979390382766724,
0.39563190937042236,
-0.5469487309455872,
-0.3004316985607147,
-0.14083155989646912,
-0.2876373827457428,
-0.3903951942920685,
0.05246386677026749,
0.2899043560028076,
0.4840073585510254,
-0.17598427832126617,
0.7802033424377441,
-0.15393787622451782,
0.001451186602935195,
0.13770245015621185,
-0.4467332363128662,
0.6645040512084961,
0.3609347343444824,
-0.5141090750694275,
0.20475859940052032,
-0.48423629999160767,
-0.25687384605407715,
-0.17693482339382172,
-0.3680809736251831,
-0.2658487856388092,
-0.369213730096817,
0.18071198463439941,
0.6097975373268127,
0.12616799771785736,
-0.19523413479328156,
0.1611413061618805,
-0.13550648093223572,
0.26068252325057983,
0.5135711431503296,
0.11162584275007248,
0.7621036171913147,
-0.5402528047561646,
0.5955608487129211,
0.3677998185157776,
0.02472858875989914,
0.033892467617988586,
-0.3587559759616852,
-0.822622537612915,
-0.30221590399742126,
0.26250118017196655,
0.35570377111434937,
-0.9880732893943787,
0.3938799798488617,
-0.08873419463634491,
-0.27709245681762695,
-0.4809102714061737,
0.199834406375885,
0.5116201043128967,
0.8775339126586914,
0.8456425070762634,
-0.4705854654312134,
-0.6979209780693054,
-0.5439915060997009,
-0.08285840600728989,
0.0012514537665992975,
0.12862837314605713,
0.46580225229263306,
0.429371178150177,
-0.14851044118404388,
0.9566004872322083,
-0.0006988201639614999,
-0.19848518073558807,
-0.3272938132286072,
0.49902305006980896,
0.17886638641357422,
0.6653143763542175,
0.3387020230293274,
-0.9527515769004822,
-0.8537686467170715,
0.036304865032434464,
-0.8421669006347656,
0.009961096569895744,
-0.08020985871553421,
-0.1282995492219925,
0.2716558575630188,
0.50981605052948,
-0.21620452404022217,
0.3228709399700165,
0.9791818261146545,
-0.09557057917118073,
0.2817690372467041,
-0.28675535321235657,
0.2785758674144745,
-1.4370774030685425,
0.10505323857069016,
-0.2885604500770569,
-0.30609479546546936,
-0.40670302510261536,
0.19767408072948456,
0.028642825782299042,
0.06280454993247986,
-0.2778894305229187,
0.41765642166137695,
-0.7652884125709534,
-0.06929853558540344,
-0.3610478341579437,
0.01574546843767166,
0.09183906763792038,
0.49686935544013977,
0.3155224025249481,
0.714911162853241,
0.4236065745353699,
-0.5401366949081421,
0.11527363210916519,
0.1975250542163849,
0.00172522128559649,
0.2805299162864685,
-0.46698418259620667,
0.13274361193180084,
0.13405898213386536,
0.3473988175392151,
-1.0156776905059814,
0.1447150856256485,
0.20795144140720367,
-0.5373353958129883,
0.24766966700553894,
-0.3864685297012329,
-0.5635079741477966,
0.08080630749464035,
0.514285683631897,
0.4645584225654602,
0.37920746207237244,
-0.8707515001296997,
0.6962246894836426,
0.11696617305278778,
0.08711384236812592,
-0.5354419350624084,
-1.01387619972229,
0.15448260307312012,
-0.005110000725835562,
-0.3780730962753296,
0.43567559123039246,
-0.05555018410086632,
-0.0062178196385502815,
0.18470634520053864,
-0.033113520592451096,
-0.2523615062236786,
0.06239195540547371,
0.27857914566993713,
0.5233826637268066,
-0.24502113461494446,
-0.013535421341657639,
0.10971752554178238,
-0.17471010982990265,
-0.13846580684185028,
-0.34085798263549805,
0.5496906638145447,
-0.18080933392047882,
-0.3281593322753906,
-0.20140358805656433,
0.632928729057312,
0.5407918095588684,
-0.44087082147598267,
1.03995680809021,
0.7357715964317322,
-0.1220787987112999,
-0.25043973326683044,
-0.4356623888015747,
-0.14869612455368042,
-0.43840399384498596,
0.21459412574768066,
-0.3085203766822815,
-0.946647047996521,
0.599136471748352,
-0.03718942776322365,
-0.08785876631736755,
0.2818661034107208,
0.6202296018600464,
0.35915544629096985,
1.0148454904556274,
0.8219831585884094,
-0.24998900294303894,
0.3713483214378357,
-0.596842885017395,
-0.08923878520727158,
-1.0685055255889893,
-0.45553871989250183,
-0.0135548897087574,
-0.2777132987976074,
-0.4430430829524994,
-0.6806689500808716,
0.38305720686912537,
0.22864657640457153,
-0.022649317979812622,
0.5031855702400208,
-0.524584949016571,
0.238592728972435,
0.5197343826293945,
0.09552759677171707,
0.4630638659000397,
-0.022791272029280663,
-1.020917296409607,
-0.021350406110286713,
-0.946588933467865,
-0.09555324167013168,
0.88926762342453,
-0.08276519924402237,
0.42240631580352783,
0.2963828444480896,
0.8873199820518494,
0.007573473267257214,
0.472124844789505,
-0.5739232301712036,
0.30240339040756226,
-0.18249057233333588,
-0.38344934582710266,
0.12197668105363846,
-0.7335959076881409,
-0.8579632639884949,
0.6489744186401367,
-0.1667918860912323,
-0.38116326928138733,
0.49906662106513977,
-0.0028050504624843597,
-0.24276752769947052,
0.5553907752037048,
-0.5143693089485168,
0.7068934440612793,
-0.16062019765377045,
-0.49901315569877625,
-0.09198439866304398,
-0.8955970406532288,
0.23626738786697388,
0.061866119503974915,
0.25490888953208923,
0.28676819801330566,
-0.2468978464603424,
0.20487311482429504,
-0.3072364926338196,
0.9552357792854309,
-0.10203548520803452,
0.21566395461559296,
0.1885564923286438,
0.3439958989620209,
0.4225901663303375,
0.14725671708583832,
-0.23346629738807678,
0.24876107275485992,
-0.38670194149017334,
-0.27801117300987244,
-0.5121577978134155,
0.8498044013977051,
-0.9595723152160645,
-0.2633499205112457,
-0.40077707171440125,
-0.9754256010055542,
-0.27495473623275757,
0.08291497826576233,
0.35796424746513367,
0.30597802996635437,
-0.14080339670181274,
0.17881996929645538,
0.2771085798740387,
0.1275157928466797,
0.7265962362289429,
0.6379269957542419,
-0.015938105061650276,
-0.8971225023269653,
0.5205743908882141,
0.052717991173267365,
0.5611164569854736,
0.5597848296165466,
0.03903554007411003,
-0.20737697184085846,
-0.6573842167854309,
-0.3646964728832245,
-0.01410338468849659,
-0.6745901703834534,
-0.23365573585033417,
-1.0967727899551392,
-0.2798158824443817,
-0.40042316913604736,
-0.44823068380355835,
-0.3517937660217285,
-0.18000681698322296,
-0.5179467797279358,
0.11693645268678665,
0.10670438408851624,
0.58472740650177,
-0.5024855732917786,
0.13085845112800598,
-0.811610758304596,
0.1458931565284729,
0.4270896017551422,
0.032284170389175415,
0.5571009516716003,
-0.4689565896987915,
-0.36498594284057617,
0.10243343561887741,
-0.2978789210319519,
-0.6878393888473511,
0.8496081829071045,
0.013703126460313797,
0.7834707498550415,
-0.049973923712968826,
0.12842877209186554,
0.6760462522506714,
-0.40563729405403137,
0.590890109539032,
0.34683600068092346,
-0.8746508359909058,
0.22745533287525177,
-0.40884050726890564,
0.4402507245540619,
0.7956488728523254,
0.5466746091842651,
-0.5979653000831604,
-0.15322139859199524,
-0.5488395690917969,
-0.9034109115600586,
0.39010339975357056,
0.19961215555667877,
0.01572035439312458,
-0.11015725880861282,
0.24870991706848145,
0.27735063433647156,
0.33083051443099976,
-0.6476872563362122,
-0.3456595540046692,
-0.30487459897994995,
-0.317755788564682,
-0.3648222088813782,
0.23348219692707062,
0.06677373498678207,
-0.3140662610530853,
0.3345280587673187,
-0.04516296461224556,
-0.16132794320583344,
0.6340609788894653,
-0.3378874361515045,
-0.08699485659599304,
0.024031922221183777,
0.2221221625804901,
0.4597232937812805,
-0.1448948085308075,
0.10700828582048416,
0.2839796245098114,
-0.18217350542545319,
0.21044018864631653,
0.09345563501119614,
0.004842874128371477,
0.07864370197057724,
0.2794331908226013,
0.5308553576469421,
0.18479275703430176,
-0.09728832542896271,
0.6112238764762878,
-0.18346260488033295,
-0.38449037075042725,
-0.0816035196185112,
-0.0831163302063942,
0.237473726272583,
0.44976845383644104,
0.32482948899269104,
0.635557234287262,
0.2789769470691681,
-0.3666810393333435,
0.6090275049209595,
0.25926291942596436,
-0.7601318359375,
-0.3666345775127411,
0.8052054047584534,
0.2428344339132309,
-0.16487251222133636,
0.5591408014297485,
-0.2557322084903717,
-0.5435760617256165,
0.7083668112754822,
0.7128388285636902,
0.9756579995155334,
-0.26621413230895996,
0.18398191034793854,
0.4652097523212433,
0.03879528120160103,
-0.003120232140645385,
-0.256915420293808,
-0.5072758197784424,
-0.4326910972595215,
-0.3458474278450012,
-0.4568726122379303,
-0.6183275580406189,
-0.05338142439723015,
-0.8937764167785645,
-0.011151748709380627,
-0.33474820852279663,
0.018281208351254463,
-0.3222561776638031,
0.07257398217916489,
-0.6992270350456238,
0.20544151961803436,
-0.030006011947989464,
0.4879033863544464,
-0.7899494171142578,
1.0164456367492676,
0.5943582057952881,
-0.5606499314308167,
-0.7329525351524353,
0.16953438520431519,
0.09361912310123444,
-0.5050849914550781,
0.9147051572799683,
0.05748007819056511,
-0.10456916689872742,
0.24030382931232452,
-0.23678447306156158,
-0.914552628993988,
1.3342416286468506,
0.10563331842422485,
-0.720810055732727,
-0.0816480740904808,
0.05314543470740318,
0.5572451949119568,
-0.8139083981513977,
0.09645272046327591,
-0.14294756948947906,
-0.08526644855737686,
0.36070671677589417,
-0.7718833088874817,
0.10830123722553253,
-0.2431207001209259,
0.20689551532268524,
0.008184084668755531,
-0.7854952812194824,
1.1615831851959229,
-0.16655761003494263,
-0.031255435198545456,
0.25572890043258667,
0.5937249660491943,
0.3755452036857605,
0.2591860890388489,
0.5907601714134216,
0.42453643679618835,
0.5446465611457825,
0.38344481587409973,
0.7073283195495605,
-0.26103585958480835,
0.4866945743560791,
1.4541926383972168,
-0.07822643220424652,
0.8044224381446838,
0.4556684195995331,
0.17838260531425476,
0.566881000995636,
0.49308204650878906,
-0.19794458150863647,
0.8541180491447449,
0.07083454728126526,
-0.5421926975250244,
-0.33795371651649475,
-0.1086307093501091,
-0.3410617709159851,
0.24924816191196442,
0.13742680847644806,
-0.6623255014419556,
-0.3570619821548462,
0.13384424149990082,
-0.2362065464258194,
0.3173494040966034,
-0.06415249407291412,
0.8788701295852661,
0.4141930937767029,
-0.7908532023429871,
0.624718189239502,
-0.06107450649142265,
0.8095374703407288,
-0.12461383640766144,
-0.16274552047252655,
-0.3903906047344208,
0.20011112093925476,
0.1292896568775177,
-0.13037461042404175,
0.40033814311027527,
-0.1516961306333542,
-0.39827921986579895,
-0.07720989733934402,
0.35222747921943665,
-0.7061287760734558,
-0.34746795892715454,
0.6796250343322754,
0.6579978466033936,
-0.2657359540462494,
0.09337768703699112,
-0.958626389503479,
-0.3074987530708313,
-0.21213138103485107,
0.251486599445343,
0.41717764735221863,
0.3033645451068878,
0.2538031339645386,
0.4859876334667206,
0.6916959881782532,
0.03340471535921097,
0.03032778389751911,
-0.012682512402534485,
0.9343130588531494,
-0.427186518907547,
-0.4045845866203308,
-0.8500149846076965,
0.5636216402053833,
-0.045493267476558685,
-0.18540892004966736,
0.769614040851593,
0.5212733149528503,
0.8361677527427673,
0.04019259288907051,
0.8135886788368225,
0.1649530678987503,
0.5126718282699585,
-0.39723166823387146,
0.9112667441368103,
-0.5195332169532776,
0.2666040360927582,
-0.17028729617595673,
-0.7829009890556335,
-0.4389050304889679,
0.42221131920814514,
-0.266195148229599,
0.1406191736459732,
0.7247532606124878,
0.4457781910896301,
-0.29520949721336365,
-0.2153184562921524,
0.549088716506958,
-0.09884457290172577,
0.12160146236419678,
0.6020869612693787,
0.6954345107078552,
-0.5633904933929443,
0.688922643661499,
-0.5512481331825256,
-0.19500000774860382,
-0.18107536435127258,
-0.7668124437332153,
-1.2195907831192017,
-0.6235612034797668,
-0.33838748931884766,
-0.16878114640712738,
0.2714913487434387,
1.01285719871521,
1.035690188407898,
-0.7901396155357361,
-0.23847922682762146,
-0.589606523513794,
0.09906312823295593,
-0.20266501605510712,
-0.22073931992053986,
0.3440952003002167,
-0.6095669269561768,
-0.6354976296424866,
0.4706040918827057,
0.0032580967526882887,
0.1791408360004425,
-0.09565276652574539,
-0.2184954434633255,
-0.497219979763031,
-0.15926697850227356,
0.36057764291763306,
-0.09669987857341766,
-0.6227020025253296,
0.17851704359054565,
0.11524772644042969,
-0.27707192301750183,
0.2705163359642029,
0.5864225625991821,
-0.6759554743766785,
0.5443084836006165,
0.47842612862586975,
0.7044845223426819,
0.5194185972213745,
0.04963192716240883,
0.8400595188140869,
-0.7769160270690918,
0.10602609068155289,
0.24985568225383759,
0.2330499291419983,
0.5385698676109314,
-0.2699224054813385,
0.34178221225738525,
0.28869906067848206,
-0.7402098178863525,
-0.46506017446517944,
0.09287460893392563,
-0.7882034182548523,
-0.2982642352581024,
0.9219369888305664,
-0.49802452325820923,
-0.14310075342655182,
-0.2119717001914978,
0.11657482385635376,
0.7437878251075745,
-0.35242241621017456,
0.6835963129997253,
0.3786219656467438,
0.12256760150194168,
-0.33364155888557434,
-0.467337429523468,
0.1412125676870346,
0.5407906174659729,
-0.44056808948516846,
-0.22941379249095917,
0.27848944067955017,
0.3604781925678253,
-0.12527790665626526,
0.2213621437549591,
-0.24867646396160126,
0.19168366491794586,
0.14567837119102478,
0.05281953886151314,
-0.2638762891292572,
-0.20262958109378815,
-0.593891441822052,
0.006155478768050671,
0.03870493918657303,
-0.21460381150245667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18424v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18424v1
|
Emotion Classification in Low and Moderate Resource Languages
| 2024-02-28T15:46:09 | 2024-02-28T15:46:09 |
Shabnam Tafreshi, Shubham Vatsal, Mona Diab
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
It is important to be able to analyze the emotional state of people around
the globe. There are 7100+ active languages spoken around the world and
building emotion classification for each language is labor intensive.
Particularly for low-resource and endangered languages, building emotion
classification can be quite challenging. We present a cross-lingual emotion
classifier, where we train an emotion classifier with resource-rich languages
(i.e. \textit{English} in our work) and transfer the learning to low and
moderate resource languages. We compare and contrast two approaches of transfer
learning from a high-resource language to a low or moderate-resource language.
One approach projects the annotation from a high-resource language to low and
moderate-resource language in parallel corpora and the other one uses direct
transfer from high-resource language to the other languages. We show the
efficacy of our approaches on 6 languages: Farsi, Arabic, Spanish, Ilocano,
Odia, and Azerbaijani. Our results indicate that our approaches outperform
random baselines and transfer emotions across languages successfully. For all
languages, the direct cross-lingual transfer of emotion yields better results.
We also create annotated emotion-labeled resources for four languages: Farsi,
Azerbaijani, Ilocano and Odia.
|
[
-0.39215531945228577,
-0.20727378129959106,
0.012112833559513092,
0.36660143733024597,
-0.07831263542175293,
0.346767395734787,
-0.6435942649841309,
-0.8533514142036438,
0.10731146484613419,
0.06392891705036163,
-0.2228197455406189,
-0.2786552608013153,
-0.5112411975860596,
0.23842234909534454,
0.16408699750900269,
1.1050329208374023,
-0.4710639715194702,
0.08805108070373535,
0.3228292465209961,
-0.5770308971405029,
-0.22289660573005676,
-0.6607993841171265,
-0.6673073172569275,
-0.2643328309059143,
0.8166285157203674,
0.6513595581054688,
0.458892285823822,
0.0022015958093106747,
0.3412495255470276,
0.3497897982597351,
0.06071494519710541,
-0.06905537843704224,
-0.5322352647781372,
-0.17060686647891998,
-0.2682138979434967,
-0.37504148483276367,
-0.17470602691173553,
-0.017085427418351173,
0.2407483607530594,
0.5193086266517639,
0.08113217353820801,
0.2276623398065567,
-0.17156243324279785,
0.6749516725540161,
-0.9358832836151123,
0.3867371082305908,
-0.09821229428052902,
0.5470964312553406,
-0.27792054414749146,
0.005164389032870531,
-0.36444371938705444,
-0.23715251684188843,
0.20126985013484955,
-0.3168245553970337,
-0.11350926756858826,
0.34948375821113586,
0.6132198572158813,
0.12054365873336792,
-0.48250582814216614,
-0.33265578746795654,
-0.7269029021263123,
0.9283049702644348,
0.009984333999454975,
0.5046948194503784,
0.19145211577415466,
0.21645739674568176,
0.7887441515922546,
-0.2535547912120819,
-0.637416422367096,
-0.05729101598262787,
-0.07750051468610764,
0.2176099270582199,
-0.4221040606498718,
-0.004650491755455732,
0.2203751653432846,
0.45441117882728577,
-0.39525285363197327,
0.44236186146736145,
-0.4664323627948761,
-0.29948216676712036,
0.642661988735199,
0.03198116645216942,
0.5378662347793579,
-0.36234840750694275,
-0.43145427107810974,
-0.2976779341697693,
-0.5886948704719543,
0.20233841240406036,
0.3657313585281372,
0.45968085527420044,
-0.42816728353500366,
0.16959887742996216,
-0.09641687572002411,
0.3643524944782257,
-0.00393278943374753,
-0.06904803216457367,
0.4363817572593689,
-0.15197768807411194,
-0.09451477974653244,
0.2108798623085022,
0.8693501949310303,
0.27808794379234314,
0.23823609948158264,
-0.08685014396905899,
-0.18713490664958954,
0.170789435505867,
-0.16941486299037933,
-0.6861664652824402,
-0.05356086418032646,
-0.12158901244401932,
-0.469023734331131,
-0.08950990438461304,
-0.5043258666992188,
-1.2263610363006592,
-0.40541622042655945,
-0.10593029856681824,
0.245701864361763,
-0.28491896390914917,
-0.3072936534881592,
-0.018527774140238762,
0.5132269859313965,
-0.006888565607368946,
0.420763224363327,
-0.9201058745384216,
0.1718870997428894,
0.23159058392047882,
0.7480264902114868,
-0.24380375444889069,
-0.18173541128635406,
-0.31404969096183777,
-0.1996455192565918,
-0.263852059841156,
0.6962475180625916,
-0.5307009220123291,
-0.21150356531143188,
0.372828871011734,
0.1639767736196518,
-0.13195450603961945,
-0.4207622706890106,
0.6948410272598267,
-0.33703091740608215,
0.5022745728492737,
-0.3321990966796875,
0.039071906358003616,
-0.5198861360549927,
0.1680804193019867,
-0.7553146481513977,
0.940132737159729,
0.4664289057254791,
-0.7148900628089905,
-0.01685887575149536,
-0.6919205188751221,
-0.7414956092834473,
0.0867086872458458,
0.2552330493927002,
0.08575465530157089,
-0.006151562090963125,
-0.17223899066448212,
0.5302985310554504,
-0.5569463968276978,
-0.37129369378089905,
-0.20347997546195984,
-0.3091036379337311,
0.12968039512634277,
-0.18588843941688538,
0.558465301990509,
0.6571561098098755,
-0.3824906051158905,
-0.16020609438419342,
-0.6387100219726562,
-0.1437121331691742,
-0.08154942095279694,
-0.43918588757514954,
-0.4661838114261627,
-0.4445590674877167,
0.5078672766685486,
0.5322693586349487,
0.33359494805336,
-0.580115795135498,
-0.06785368174314499,
-0.003148122923448682,
0.040239252150058746,
0.6268503665924072,
-0.26486191153526306,
0.7489271759986877,
0.01619553565979004,
0.9098443388938904,
0.16873130202293396,
-0.06239726394414902,
0.3850843906402588,
-0.056386448442935944,
-0.8955989480018616,
-0.23782412707805634,
0.255295991897583,
0.9146500825881958,
-0.8043636083602905,
0.222032830119133,
-0.10185086727142334,
-0.3891235291957855,
-0.7650401592254639,
0.18071211874485016,
0.6516451835632324,
0.5779789090156555,
0.39622968435287476,
-0.2567799687385559,
-0.4206269383430481,
-0.5820816159248352,
0.0528937391936779,
-0.31825605034828186,
0.2912510931491852,
0.5533666014671326,
-0.11475980281829834,
-0.2677628993988037,
0.036785174161195755,
-0.20474770665168762,
-0.1810321807861328,
-0.4246351420879364,
0.354877233505249,
-0.1499054729938507,
0.3311372399330139,
0.860817551612854,
-0.7192215919494629,
-1.0038625001907349,
0.6686021089553833,
-0.5692694783210754,
-0.29217830300331116,
-0.05437465384602547,
-0.4346228539943695,
0.7477971315383911,
0.09780652821063995,
-0.345106840133667,
0.0836886465549469,
0.7362315654754639,
-0.09667174518108368,
0.09928514063358307,
0.15217188000679016,
0.4690111577510834,
-1.0581532716751099,
0.06514929980039597,
0.02958238683640957,
0.04400784149765968,
-0.4901884198188782,
-0.5050801634788513,
0.02552514150738716,
-0.2413848340511322,
-0.7817668914794922,
0.7880677580833435,
-0.5443634390830994,
0.04882434383034706,
-0.10147549211978912,
-0.1251358538866043,
-0.28493812680244446,
0.7081413865089417,
0.31337976455688477,
0.470855176448822,
0.6153639554977417,
-0.2953789532184601,
0.7190644145011902,
0.2775585949420929,
-0.2671905755996704,
0.8809635043144226,
0.0923067107796669,
0.06930311024188995,
-0.0775035172700882,
0.0581480972468853,
-0.5427033305168152,
-0.004674339201301336,
0.3783661425113678,
-0.008559295907616615,
0.596390426158905,
-0.2828582525253296,
-0.16563571989536285,
-0.04549819603562355,
-0.14416556060314178,
0.4905349314212799,
0.8745262026786804,
-0.5811412930488586,
0.5982708930969238,
0.167544424533844,
-0.5039305686950684,
-0.6120128035545349,
-0.7968283295631409,
-0.09052135050296783,
-0.5310477614402771,
-0.3209666907787323,
-0.04028112441301346,
-0.013023965992033482,
-0.2878202497959137,
0.2564282715320587,
0.09427941590547562,
-0.2970433235168457,
-0.16150347888469696,
0.29259172081947327,
0.18750354647636414,
-0.13146939873695374,
0.2673298716545105,
-0.03133795037865639,
-0.04084741324186325,
-0.13054370880126953,
0.22010593116283417,
0.2296440452337265,
-0.43554508686065674,
-0.2684780955314636,
-0.2565661370754242,
0.5718318223953247,
0.5003036260604858,
-0.28252536058425903,
0.6083364486694336,
1.0704700946807861,
-0.3861393630504608,
-0.37713736295700073,
-0.4729326665401459,
0.2747887074947357,
-0.3286493122577667,
0.4809739291667938,
-0.44835612177848816,
-0.8919264078140259,
0.6156730651855469,
-0.27767419815063477,
-0.2854703366756439,
0.4448927640914917,
0.6926370859146118,
0.047628261148929596,
0.8764722347259521,
0.9704554677009583,
-0.6502398252487183,
0.860504686832428,
-0.14551164209842682,
0.31456103920936584,
-0.5456857085227966,
-0.027626879513263702,
-0.6357129216194153,
-0.5511362552642822,
-0.8230283260345459,
-0.3188372552394867,
-0.015505741350352764,
-0.049105796962976456,
-0.0718880295753479,
0.3118627071380615,
-0.13744035363197327,
0.37367185950279236,
0.1434195637702942,
-0.06306784600019455,
-0.015934573486447334,
0.26105430722236633,
0.19986149668693542,
-0.2784341871738434,
-0.7520595192909241,
-0.38066616654396057,
0.4865344166755676,
0.23922137916088104,
1.0221023559570312,
0.2519335448741913,
0.8279944062232971,
0.21831955015659332,
0.7591125965118408,
-1.0198780298233032,
0.2759854197502136,
-0.443646639585495,
-0.33255159854888916,
-0.13967080414295197,
-0.5661600828170776,
-0.6955815553665161,
0.1121811494231224,
-0.2763146460056305,
-0.725666880607605,
0.48810631036758423,
-0.12883251905441284,
-0.26319995522499084,
0.42329835891723633,
-0.9800878167152405,
1.0914169549942017,
-0.5098651051521301,
-0.527649462223053,
-0.43118566274642944,
-0.5650593638420105,
0.3527154326438904,
-0.28825798630714417,
0.4838044047355652,
-0.24226762354373932,
0.09083151072263718,
0.6779574751853943,
-0.18782493472099304,
0.7819725871086121,
-0.1482863575220108,
-0.0006036228151060641,
0.25163140892982483,
0.30337175726890564,
0.2355962097644806,
-0.3255000114440918,
-0.17666807770729065,
0.13222937285900116,
-0.1948939859867096,
-0.35316717624664307,
-0.4531433582305908,
0.6425899863243103,
-0.9265581965446472,
-0.24301795661449432,
-0.5358942747116089,
-0.5240298509597778,
-0.18668465316295624,
-0.00964666623622179,
0.1373383104801178,
-0.12529969215393066,
-0.15953944623470306,
-0.11311732977628708,
0.4925304055213928,
-0.4738391637802124,
0.3030438721179962,
0.7073611617088318,
0.26282423734664917,
-0.21555495262145996,
1.2160125970840454,
0.17466843128204346,
0.1960119903087616,
0.40648728609085083,
0.22090618312358856,
-0.16567039489746094,
-0.16162773966789246,
-0.4013305604457855,
0.16673962771892548,
-0.9058505892753601,
-0.34322988986968994,
-0.3828521966934204,
-0.011385353282094002,
-0.13357341289520264,
-0.48118963837623596,
-0.44543328881263733,
-0.21300658583641052,
-0.14511065185070038,
-0.10309065133333206,
0.48620375990867615,
0.541772186756134,
-0.48318910598754883,
-0.09478141367435455,
-1.114970088005066,
-0.03479890525341034,
0.4054768681526184,
0.24491113424301147,
-0.026125064119696617,
-0.5235757827758789,
-0.40953025221824646,
-0.23188355565071106,
-0.01660466194152832,
-0.9383299350738525,
0.598200261592865,
0.4589311480522156,
0.2713760733604431,
0.4746183753013611,
0.5469000935554504,
0.6426814794540405,
-0.3237032890319824,
0.4235927164554596,
0.41854631900787354,
-1.1316043138504028,
0.25896888971328735,
0.18187518417835236,
-0.17454375326633453,
0.4951228201389313,
1.0278364419937134,
-1.0152024030685425,
0.09127476066350937,
-0.4160012900829315,
-0.7328243255615234,
1.1126024723052979,
-0.26414892077445984,
0.16367441415786743,
0.0032672006636857986,
-0.06107188016176224,
0.11776308715343475,
-0.09732013195753098,
-0.7257164716720581,
0.10249815136194229,
-0.015012357383966446,
-0.5083341002464294,
-0.1238074079155922,
-0.13402238488197327,
-0.11134879291057587,
-0.08517951518297195,
0.425714373588562,
-0.17419184744358063,
0.16148534417152405,
-0.012811833061277866,
-0.4801759123802185,
-0.6001524329185486,
0.3952716886997223,
0.08966931700706482,
-0.15655675530433655,
-0.2188575118780136,
0.40382689237594604,
0.6745356917381287,
-0.2492346167564392,
0.36851632595062256,
0.17478159070014954,
0.17800728976726532,
-0.09495449811220169,
0.3839300870895386,
1.145367980003357,
0.43667274713516235,
-0.6913779973983765,
0.5179353952407837,
-0.005018746946007013,
0.20711742341518402,
0.10529220849275589,
-0.41831234097480774,
0.04970850050449371,
0.5951512455940247,
-0.18790996074676514,
0.006586765870451927,
0.21566668152809143,
-0.8925037980079651,
-0.2839947044849396,
0.05398489162325859,
-0.4398164749145508,
-0.6807361841201782,
0.06198465824127197,
0.5689301490783691,
-0.03495003283023834,
0.512191891670227,
-0.5170625448226929,
-1.0047568082809448,
0.2724337577819824,
0.407161146402359,
0.9787049293518066,
-0.3969497084617615,
0.1830175518989563,
0.33920034766197205,
0.08579612523317337,
-0.09446576982736588,
0.5318816900253296,
-0.28989896178245544,
-0.7018760442733765,
-0.5462920665740967,
-0.7645633816719055,
-0.8009808659553528,
-0.3332204222679138,
-0.6753871440887451,
0.12550613284111023,
-0.27390289306640625,
0.20805078744888306,
-0.09529144316911697,
0.26961037516593933,
-0.9776996374130249,
0.03921932727098465,
0.7764958739280701,
0.6481186151504517,
-1.4631155729293823,
0.6936803460121155,
1.0891532897949219,
-0.5190319418907166,
-0.6301842331886292,
-0.3595767021179199,
-0.09785798192024231,
-0.7017238140106201,
1.1434110403060913,
0.1360575556755066,
-0.31325680017471313,
-0.3002133369445801,
-0.22759689390659332,
-0.6884028911590576,
0.7076735496520996,
0.3090774118900299,
-0.4052659273147583,
0.3482877016067505,
-0.09743610769510269,
0.9566260576248169,
-0.2955740988254547,
0.17622363567352295,
0.07973436266183853,
0.44891291856765747,
0.10016629844903946,
-1.00320565700531,
0.13313503563404083,
-0.24263975024223328,
-0.11985985934734344,
0.2213844358921051,
-0.9931031465530396,
0.7489197850227356,
-0.17065651714801788,
-0.5369086265563965,
-0.17598353326320648,
0.6392945647239685,
-0.20023103058338165,
0.31868627667427063,
0.6409797668457031,
0.4511696994304657,
0.7059040069580078,
-0.20043884217739105,
0.7164598703384399,
-0.5038192868232727,
0.29594191908836365,
0.36434000730514526,
-0.7640670537948608,
0.9711033701896667,
0.2444342076778412,
-0.43393567204475403,
0.525301456451416,
0.793287456035614,
0.23721829056739807,
0.4020072817802429,
0.313128799200058,
-0.5292615294456482,
-0.19918188452720642,
-0.6767126321792603,
-0.21579447388648987,
0.3840979337692261,
0.37328076362609863,
0.10834898799657822,
-0.13986732065677643,
0.3913111686706543,
0.3007769286632538,
-0.17940352857112885,
-0.37136420607566833,
0.5412880778312683,
0.001637486508116126,
-0.5120647549629211,
0.6817130446434021,
-0.18651175498962402,
0.8736275434494019,
-0.33551225066185,
0.10185695439577103,
-0.49031636118888855,
0.1816675215959549,
-0.4707137942314148,
-0.7038357257843018,
0.26723533868789673,
0.4757922887802124,
-0.030351653695106506,
-0.4762881100177765,
0.6585887670516968,
-0.8323667049407959,
-0.2594991624355316,
0.6152310371398926,
0.5528664588928223,
0.46190911531448364,
0.2857119143009186,
-0.5734007358551025,
0.0721699446439743,
-0.05174049735069275,
-0.30557581782341003,
0.599089503288269,
0.8788780570030212,
-0.36072272062301636,
0.3115343153476715,
0.39465776085853577,
0.16370746493339539,
-0.01389568205922842,
0.097002774477005,
0.6672786474227905,
-0.7036378979682922,
-0.32842379808425903,
-0.3197927474975586,
0.18594907224178314,
0.21893082559108734,
-0.3132493793964386,
0.4937761723995209,
0.20924757421016693,
0.9379916787147522,
-0.24506153166294098,
0.8145650029182434,
-0.4349905848503113,
0.26997655630111694,
-0.37020552158355713,
0.439957857131958,
-0.6556149125099182,
-0.3183063268661499,
-0.36389216780662537,
-0.8509348034858704,
-0.13553744554519653,
0.7317777872085571,
-0.25512436032295227,
-0.1667957901954651,
0.8415811657905579,
0.25121018290519714,
0.07113476097583771,
-0.31070616841316223,
0.31613871455192566,
0.10431404411792755,
-0.1645464152097702,
1.120752215385437,
1.0004342794418335,
-0.09523233771324158,
0.6798543930053711,
-0.774962842464447,
-0.42143750190734863,
-0.2767631411552429,
-0.8045375943183899,
-0.6307279467582703,
-0.3470325171947479,
-0.5302141308784485,
-0.4105653762817383,
-0.05591011792421341,
1.0882624387741089,
0.5667086839675903,
-0.8997596502304077,
-0.36718109250068665,
0.5200573801994324,
0.26462870836257935,
-0.05294819176197052,
-0.1936870813369751,
0.3228748142719269,
-0.3774423599243164,
-1.0499190092086792,
0.1703306883573532,
0.26830363273620605,
0.1450139880180359,
-0.24287870526313782,
-0.35384640097618103,
-0.06306696683168411,
-0.25659680366516113,
0.6724579930305481,
0.7541729807853699,
-0.3376905620098114,
-0.3762268126010895,
-0.050434477627277374,
-0.4261360168457031,
-0.06824769824743271,
0.47270387411117554,
-0.30028876662254333,
0.3647827208042145,
0.8257010579109192,
0.752473771572113,
0.5269442200660706,
-0.29669737815856934,
0.2514473795890808,
-0.7189834713935852,
0.4484086334705353,
0.17839089035987854,
0.5773475766181946,
0.5262205600738525,
-0.3581993877887726,
0.6814200282096863,
0.3568257689476013,
-0.4221513569355011,
-0.8109049201011658,
0.2447098195552826,
-1.0793428421020508,
0.10606911033391953,
1.0953809022903442,
-0.4419286549091339,
-0.2239386886358261,
0.22477544844150543,
-0.34412217140197754,
0.5548809766769409,
-0.3416929841041565,
0.8274741768836975,
0.7440469861030579,
-0.30683577060699463,
-0.3415379226207733,
-0.3218475580215454,
0.5055921077728271,
0.6173954010009766,
-0.9625406265258789,
0.030748965218663216,
0.5471018552780151,
0.00876590609550476,
0.6059990525245667,
0.3767843246459961,
0.003980141133069992,
0.228414848446846,
-0.022527119144797325,
0.7325361967086792,
0.3962237536907196,
-0.10215979069471359,
-0.6535027623176575,
-0.01234410796314478,
-0.012190707959234715,
-0.1027497798204422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18419v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18419v1
|
Can GPT Improve the State of Prior Authorization via Guideline Based Automated Question Answering?
| 2024-02-28T15:39:53 | 2024-02-28T15:39:53 |
Shubham Vatsal, Ayush Singh, Shabnam Tafreshi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Health insurance companies have a defined process called prior authorization
(PA) which is a health plan cost-control process that requires doctors and
other healthcare professionals to get clearance in advance from a health plan
before performing a particular procedure on a patient in order to be eligible
for payment coverage. For health insurance companies, approving PA requests for
patients in the medical domain is a time-consuming and challenging task. One of
those key challenges is validating if a request matches up to certain criteria
such as age, gender, etc. In this work, we evaluate whether GPT can validate
numerous key factors, in turn helping health plans reach a decision drastically
faster. We frame it as a question answering task, prompting GPT to answer a
question from patient electronic health record. We experiment with different
conventional prompting techniques as well as introduce our own novel prompting
technique. Moreover, we report qualitative assessment by humans on the natural
language generation outputs from our approach. Results show that our method
achieves superior performance with the mean weighted F1 score of 0.61 as
compared to its standard counterparts.
|
[
-0.2697431147098541,
-0.9809931516647339,
1.0819470882415771,
0.08512557297945023,
-0.3570381999015808,
-0.11946333944797516,
0.25015032291412354,
-0.508686363697052,
-0.1675652265548706,
0.3736947774887085,
-0.5474814772605896,
-0.09463410079479218,
-0.1964309811592102,
0.3201543390750885,
0.14957217872142792,
0.8772909045219421,
-0.2986113131046295,
0.08053244650363922,
-0.2837580442428589,
0.30042943358421326,
-0.6115706562995911,
-0.412000447511673,
-1.0662249326705933,
-0.39407533407211304,
0.22524061799049377,
0.13942605257034302,
0.4557510018348694,
0.12707915902137756,
0.5219020247459412,
0.30771178007125854,
-0.17396961152553558,
0.2621839940547943,
0.05415700376033783,
0.0010469454573467374,
-0.13709108531475067,
-0.36188411712646484,
-0.7914881110191345,
0.10104376822710037,
0.4462263584136963,
0.5364699959754944,
-0.3905906081199646,
0.169239804148674,
0.0559438019990921,
0.6978675127029419,
-0.5038294792175293,
-0.026224594563245773,
-0.5434868931770325,
-0.09024020284414291,
0.09908939152956009,
-0.45605072379112244,
-0.26489025354385376,
-0.5999279022216797,
0.6896017789840698,
-0.8358227610588074,
0.28421270847320557,
-0.005973764229565859,
0.9911664724349976,
0.4894827604293823,
-0.21575221419334412,
-0.2859225869178772,
-0.7801975607872009,
-0.04574573412537575,
-0.526088297367096,
0.35546231269836426,
0.5671488046646118,
0.47342631220817566,
-0.024859072640538216,
-0.8155981302261353,
-0.9305369853973389,
-0.31268519163131714,
-0.30972325801849365,
0.24354009330272675,
-0.2331467717885971,
0.21771323680877686,
0.5623049736022949,
0.34094101190567017,
-0.7540315389633179,
-0.2283196747303009,
-0.3872075378894806,
-0.31432297825813293,
0.5683635473251343,
-0.003102760063484311,
0.33283910155296326,
-0.21666644513607025,
-0.3614548146724701,
0.10003887116909027,
-0.565238356590271,
0.23309189081192017,
0.21946021914482117,
-0.21698740124702454,
-0.07864885777235031,
0.3743727207183838,
-0.5330278277397156,
0.4872182011604309,
0.49184414744377136,
0.1555653214454651,
0.3761715888977051,
-0.2132968157529831,
-0.6110839247703552,
0.09599537402391434,
0.360388845205307,
0.4407242238521576,
0.5185844302177429,
0.02294733375310898,
-0.01557885017246008,
-0.2521090805530548,
0.2556782364845276,
-0.7424386143684387,
-0.3103095293045044,
0.5424474477767944,
-0.46466657519340515,
0.21944476664066315,
0.39328533411026,
-0.55341637134552,
-0.4104766547679901,
-0.45602744817733765,
0.4027652144432068,
-0.4244011342525482,
-0.31429123878479004,
0.06498274207115173,
-0.03376658260822296,
0.6557043194770813,
0.6365180015563965,
-0.46153756976127625,
0.274270236492157,
0.5356089472770691,
0.6028792262077332,
0.16130831837654114,
0.016136499121785164,
-0.5664992928504944,
-0.06497276574373245,
-0.397879421710968,
0.7636718153953552,
-0.31104034185409546,
-0.5995435118675232,
-0.18057121336460114,
0.037442076951265335,
-0.4792816936969757,
-0.459555447101593,
0.4716663658618927,
-0.8716941475868225,
0.4724384844303131,
-0.42092612385749817,
-0.3514394760131836,
-0.09589467942714691,
0.44010016322135925,
-0.30776670575141907,
0.4306385815143585,
0.154261976480484,
-0.6225430369377136,
0.9170312285423279,
-0.7230685353279114,
-0.3280661702156067,
0.334645539522171,
-0.24853284657001495,
-0.5477209091186523,
-0.05596847087144852,
0.6227359175682068,
0.21894490718841553,
-0.1757768988609314,
0.2026136815547943,
0.08383215963840485,
-0.22303640842437744,
0.24333173036575317,
-0.4233759343624115,
0.6681056022644043,
0.4004158079624176,
-0.30313175916671753,
0.3426322340965271,
-0.5345873832702637,
0.45897796750068665,
0.12622947990894318,
-0.24995002150535583,
-0.3424127697944641,
-0.2372836023569107,
-0.43680617213249207,
0.11442412436008453,
-0.03279095143079758,
-0.17876176536083221,
0.3513728380203247,
-0.4125189483165741,
0.2412136048078537,
0.8436233997344971,
0.7285023927688599,
0.5567005276679993,
-0.35458019375801086,
0.7798553705215454,
-0.3953371047973633,
0.31925609707832336,
-0.21369536221027374,
-0.7409774661064148,
-0.11941763013601303,
-0.16707295179367065,
0.33700132369995117,
0.729791522026062,
-0.7824733853340149,
0.3596445322036743,
-0.14898040890693665,
-0.14807477593421936,
-0.4862203598022461,
-0.1339905709028244,
0.20446805655956268,
1.058772325515747,
0.35171693563461304,
-0.2645147144794464,
-0.06678622961044312,
-0.5013304948806763,
0.08265655487775803,
-0.6442192792892456,
-0.38521286845207214,
0.3023809492588043,
0.363583505153656,
-0.18085023760795593,
0.9764313101768494,
-0.618893027305603,
-0.33034271001815796,
-0.11209487169981003,
0.2570483684539795,
0.09546033293008804,
0.43089941143989563,
0.3415887951850891,
-1.0732831954956055,
-0.5432551503181458,
-0.041512083262205124,
-0.4860178530216217,
-0.2998582422733307,
-0.27147698402404785,
-0.024412773549556732,
0.0426919050514698,
0.38940373063087463,
-0.512243926525116,
0.46954405307769775,
0.11950882524251938,
-0.4478509724140167,
0.3950701057910919,
-0.6701664328575134,
0.5376741290092468,
-0.688266396522522,
0.4476550817489624,
-0.1652938574552536,
-0.11307264864444733,
-0.5933213829994202,
-0.07283959537744522,
0.20746779441833496,
-0.27847036719322205,
-0.42925238609313965,
0.46611833572387695,
-0.5038553476333618,
0.4900987148284912,
-0.26398664712905884,
-0.47264906764030457,
-0.14078284800052643,
0.2215496152639389,
-0.0035447515547275543,
0.9352515935897827,
0.5085599422454834,
-0.9265324473381042,
0.03059202805161476,
0.35488569736480713,
-0.1580216884613037,
0.9886398911476135,
-0.9788297414779663,
0.43233975768089294,
-0.536995530128479,
0.5014275908470154,
-0.9957232475280762,
-0.37493133544921875,
0.5838057994842529,
-0.3330467641353607,
0.14132726192474365,
-0.28692275285720825,
-0.00006741766992490739,
-0.5851828455924988,
0.07194698601961136,
0.13289391994476318,
0.562720000743866,
-0.007116978522390127,
0.653150737285614,
0.0053298696875572205,
-0.46624764800071716,
-0.307086318731308,
-0.3314542770385742,
-0.12392502278089523,
-0.10268225520849228,
-0.4805702269077301,
0.3239731788635254,
-0.05483994632959366,
-0.3270411491394043,
0.03197788819670677,
-0.25575417280197144,
-0.34525811672210693,
-0.07106913626194,
0.30710843205451965,
0.15180206298828125,
-0.10758671909570694,
0.21376022696495056,
0.1553468257188797,
-0.3964080810546875,
0.06911322474479675,
-0.4748157262802124,
0.4712907075881958,
0.08316140621900558,
-0.4157862961292267,
-0.899865448474884,
0.5875437259674072,
0.5368558764457703,
-0.5794888734817505,
0.08181699365377426,
0.41356784105300903,
-0.4792124629020691,
0.31472623348236084,
-0.7839984893798828,
-0.23351505398750305,
-0.47036629915237427,
-0.05108150094747543,
-0.39534226059913635,
-0.37435394525527954,
0.3683384656906128,
-0.002671499503776431,
0.1256047636270523,
0.4085112512111664,
0.44114845991134644,
0.034377288073301315,
0.9626905918121338,
0.5045531988143921,
0.10807113349437714,
0.3473547697067261,
-0.035247523337602615,
-0.18822383880615234,
-0.5930361747741699,
-0.17041389644145966,
-0.5372031927108765,
0.08167092502117157,
-0.40436211228370667,
-0.3509146273136139,
0.5596781373023987,
0.01081906445324421,
0.1500636339187622,
-0.1258915811777115,
-0.563670814037323,
0.31825903058052063,
0.4371267855167389,
0.5417634844779968,
0.3856033384799957,
-0.25381699204444885,
-0.11500110477209091,
0.11405157297849655,
-0.18759550154209137,
-0.4922822415828705,
1.0151287317276,
0.3072691261768341,
0.36781519651412964,
-0.048895709216594696,
0.6342540979385376,
0.40126991271972656,
0.6233677268028259,
-0.4501386880874634,
0.4769364893436432,
0.3584006130695343,
-0.7181900143623352,
-0.46460166573524475,
-0.4756150245666504,
-0.9752740263938904,
0.00616033747792244,
-0.17485974729061127,
-0.6079984903335571,
0.3045649528503418,
0.6539983153343201,
-0.8314992189407349,
-0.18811781704425812,
-1.093603491783142,
0.7948249578475952,
-0.32195088267326355,
-0.05275721102952957,
0.021473921835422516,
-0.6636283993721008,
-0.057711657136678696,
-0.08148213475942612,
-0.18431870639324188,
-0.07570723444223404,
-0.03557209670543671,
0.5391988754272461,
-0.6002589464187622,
0.4011841416358948,
-0.7224951386451721,
-0.04119041934609413,
0.48882198333740234,
-0.2699458599090576,
0.6554966568946838,
0.2514044940471649,
-0.056796249002218246,
-0.2773985266685486,
0.08349555730819702,
-0.30188632011413574,
-0.7486605644226074,
0.37360256910324097,
-0.30931130051612854,
-0.7715012431144714,
-0.39642053842544556,
-0.13715064525604248,
-0.6195796728134155,
0.463003545999527,
0.2685651183128357,
-0.020250052213668823,
-0.047433409839868546,
-0.3232998549938202,
0.5433666706085205,
-0.10367613285779953,
0.21939125657081604,
0.7393212914466858,
0.09651273488998413,
-0.2438684105873108,
0.33527180552482605,
0.24601644277572632,
0.21100790798664093,
0.4417884945869446,
0.6202556490898132,
-0.5570493936538696,
-0.8844432830810547,
-0.5986618399620056,
0.08356485515832901,
-0.41310587525367737,
0.0781220868229866,
-0.7585628032684326,
0.1631985753774643,
-0.5765768885612488,
0.10297215729951859,
0.4192889928817749,
0.08552561700344086,
0.21326616406440735,
-0.2373613715171814,
0.06517547369003296,
0.5125276446342468,
0.20202675461769104,
0.3602149784564972,
-0.4959007799625397,
0.5581099987030029,
0.7207772135734558,
0.2732335925102234,
-0.3200865089893341,
-0.01561832521110773,
0.41030532121658325,
-0.15900233387947083,
-0.12045903503894806,
-1.2458257675170898,
-0.09290170669555664,
-0.0033421649131923914,
0.869581937789917,
0.37878918647766113,
0.21982476115226746,
0.8561010360717773,
-0.8496001362800598,
0.6625069379806519,
-0.0028137925546616316,
-0.9405398964881897,
0.8242018818855286,
-0.1933484822511673,
0.40880241990089417,
0.9502562880516052,
0.6498094201087952,
-0.40388068556785583,
-0.2587360739707947,
-0.6783786416053772,
-0.9482814073562622,
0.17297276854515076,
0.05071599781513214,
0.13483397662639618,
0.12269856780767441,
0.5261709690093994,
-0.09185275435447693,
0.21788422763347626,
-0.31966501474380493,
-0.19788962602615356,
-0.0045218016020953655,
0.024170435965061188,
0.192472904920578,
-0.20558352768421173,
0.052806444466114044,
0.01072757225483656,
0.3246717154979706,
-0.16415035724639893,
0.26425161957740784,
0.9933382272720337,
0.0355125330388546,
-0.23490352928638458,
0.6385053992271423,
0.7881038188934326,
1.1948440074920654,
-0.20767050981521606,
-0.2285846471786499,
0.2768796980381012,
-0.7802779674530029,
0.15661616623401642,
0.45479780435562134,
-0.5106762051582336,
-0.04736718535423279,
-0.009650731459259987,
0.32336851954460144,
-0.281797856092453,
-0.30255866050720215,
0.4646883010864258,
-0.3060901463031769,
-0.5814826488494873,
-0.10792793333530426,
-0.013527565635740757,
-0.5768409967422485,
0.06580127030611038,
0.7089223265647888,
-0.1429063379764557,
0.16658172011375427,
-0.28995004296302795,
0.6797364354133606,
0.2742975652217865,
-0.523573100566864,
-0.07422025501728058,
0.728377103805542,
0.25473862886428833,
-0.257182240486145,
0.5415626168251038,
-0.1265278160572052,
-0.37392836809158325,
0.36738771200180054,
0.30049875378608704,
0.738211989402771,
-0.4602353870868683,
0.3101171851158142,
0.4075550138950348,
0.4524102509021759,
0.1276652067899704,
0.5266645550727844,
-0.19856566190719604,
-0.22173838317394257,
-0.7708987593650818,
-0.1978495568037033,
-0.6552106738090515,
0.145571768283844,
-0.4412042498588562,
-0.0805283859372139,
-0.6723699569702148,
-0.13552725315093994,
-0.05108385533094406,
-0.04569406062364578,
-0.9136540293693542,
0.5446476340293884,
-0.09441106766462326,
0.8225253224372864,
-0.7042003870010376,
0.4453621208667755,
0.9707470536231995,
-0.48815473914146423,
-1.3261229991912842,
0.40688639879226685,
0.12608563899993896,
-0.7472398281097412,
0.401623398065567,
0.014756949618458748,
0.08419346064329147,
-0.06407324969768524,
-0.32096806168556213,
-0.3037843406200409,
0.9828643202781677,
0.1630564033985138,
-0.3633269667625427,
-0.400327205657959,
-0.13987384736537933,
0.5076637268066406,
0.11443176865577698,
0.4103744328022003,
0.38466763496398926,
0.7456151247024536,
0.10830038040876389,
-1.1289334297180176,
0.329136461019516,
-0.22870565950870514,
-0.5228148698806763,
0.11696992069482803,
0.009206530638039112,
0.7012816667556763,
-0.3586518168449402,
-0.4461786150932312,
-0.07587210834026337,
0.6182629466056824,
0.04443936422467232,
0.7330746650695801,
0.9997493624687195,
0.17037822306156158,
1.2657177448272705,
-0.13743187487125397,
1.3931347131729126,
0.13763511180877686,
0.07858800143003464,
0.8828571438789368,
-0.5062394738197327,
0.5756885409355164,
0.5863310098648071,
-0.34205490350723267,
0.31598666310310364,
0.6313184499740601,
0.34873437881469727,
0.42106109857559204,
0.24338239431381226,
-0.23173779249191284,
-0.18159019947052002,
0.02784710004925728,
-0.7168360352516174,
0.1990930438041687,
0.008989013731479645,
-0.26630899310112,
-0.10830745846033096,
0.05776179954409599,
-0.023046523332595825,
0.05083019286394119,
-0.3455534279346466,
1.1258845329284668,
-0.03204916790127754,
-0.9463047385215759,
0.2085367888212204,
-0.3609263598918915,
0.3364887237548828,
-1.0021699666976929,
-0.18052710592746735,
0.10834751278162003,
0.057717520743608475,
-0.20564386248588562,
-0.4552026689052582,
0.2260378897190094,
0.028009073808789253,
-0.183182954788208,
-0.44930195808410645,
0.6227361559867859,
-0.1947248876094818,
-0.17247629165649414,
-0.31718266010284424,
0.6471969485282898,
-0.05968340113759041,
-0.4816678762435913,
-0.9094966650009155,
-0.46396079659461975,
-0.3060353994369507,
-0.14262019097805023,
-0.17300036549568176,
0.4002703130245209,
-0.20759062469005585,
0.4790095090866089,
1.066467523574829,
0.6277719140052795,
-0.09033230692148209,
0.11592786759138107,
0.43788912892341614,
-0.21831752359867096,
-1.0881153345108032,
-0.7853924632072449,
0.6910266876220703,
-0.31991511583328247,
-0.46092918515205383,
0.5077477693557739,
0.16375789046287537,
0.7752641439437866,
-0.003458860097452998,
0.6408582925796509,
-0.2206268310546875,
0.6899974942207336,
-0.8497783541679382,
0.6874626278877258,
-0.4009093940258026,
0.029833894222974777,
-0.5983927845954895,
-0.4376686215400696,
-0.4841421842575073,
0.5269799828529358,
-0.9668171405792236,
0.036636050790548325,
0.6030148267745972,
0.5475847125053406,
0.22018007934093475,
-0.0023805948439985514,
0.06332136690616608,
-0.27804577350616455,
0.7090919017791748,
0.39419665932655334,
0.8044118285179138,
-0.12029457837343216,
0.5675866603851318,
-0.13062401115894318,
-0.4636642038822174,
-0.0074109784327447414,
-0.9169724583625793,
-0.5630999803543091,
-0.29816150665283203,
-0.4193611443042755,
-0.36468541622161865,
0.243214413523674,
0.9711412191390991,
0.7145968079566956,
-0.6021115779876709,
0.43853193521499634,
-0.21787258982658386,
0.1242213249206543,
-0.665336549282074,
-0.2371399849653244,
0.4696422219276428,
-0.13021644949913025,
-0.5675640106201172,
0.08906549215316772,
0.1125149205327034,
0.38024306297302246,
0.21356140077114105,
-0.07844748347997665,
0.18805837631225586,
-0.22505758702754974,
0.2308867871761322,
0.4257960915565491,
-0.3693024218082428,
-0.25363877415657043,
0.2093115746974945,
-0.02693489007651806,
-0.01556510478258133,
1.3457204103469849,
-0.5964829325675964,
0.6382417678833008,
0.5864018797874451,
0.8524601459503174,
0.13097114861011505,
0.48729342222213745,
0.6552995443344116,
-0.27514225244522095,
-0.019253959879279137,
0.3762522339820862,
0.3430835008621216,
-0.04692171886563301,
-0.594824492931366,
0.19451197981834412,
-0.05953265726566315,
-0.6543183922767639,
-0.37479066848754883,
0.1802678108215332,
-0.9532907009124756,
0.027336644008755684,
0.8657476305961609,
-0.12234753370285034,
-0.0830502137541771,
-0.6036695241928101,
-0.7420482635498047,
-0.022592788562178612,
-0.5165789723396301,
0.6796286702156067,
0.4698476493358612,
-0.27943214774131775,
-0.17078888416290283,
-0.3857310116291046,
0.675315260887146,
0.39391881227493286,
-1.1189062595367432,
0.030700311064720154,
0.44794872403144836,
0.4202008843421936,
0.2348867505788803,
1.4634863138198853,
-0.18536944687366486,
0.7906470894813538,
-0.39789146184921265,
-0.5082993507385254,
-0.3551120460033417,
-0.25394079089164734,
-0.3352895975112915,
0.3407699763774872,
0.08958958089351654,
-0.45820340514183044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18409v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18409v3
|
A Cognitive Evaluation Benchmark of Image Reasoning and Description for Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-02-28T15:28:36 | 2024-06-14T09:35:57 |
Xiujie Song, Mengyue Wu, Kenny Q. Zhu, Chunhao Zhang, Yanyi Chen
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs), despite their recent success, are
hardly comprehensively tested for their cognitive abilities. Inspired by the
prevalent use of the "Cookie Theft" task in human cognition test, we propose a
novel evaluation benchmark to evaluate high-level cognitive ability of LVLMs
using images with rich semantics. It defines eight reasoning capabilities and
consists of an image description task and a visual question answering task. Our
evaluation on well-known LVLMs shows that there is still a large gap in
cognitive ability between LVLMs and humans.
|
[
-0.47725892066955566,
-0.7379179000854492,
0.6352201700210571,
-0.1843906193971634,
-0.2540538012981415,
0.10512032359838486,
-0.3184961676597595,
-0.8686239123344421,
-0.31153735518455505,
0.7124419212341309,
-0.43447473645210266,
-0.2719908058643341,
-0.49136218428611755,
-0.051905613392591476,
-0.527859091758728,
0.5078938007354736,
-0.10888826102018356,
0.1753641963005066,
-0.5823834538459778,
-0.07698366791009903,
-0.7530093193054199,
-0.09902074187994003,
-0.5256687998771667,
-0.04948221892118454,
0.4140373766422272,
0.04070993885397911,
0.6479635238647461,
0.4807753264904022,
0.8796399831771851,
0.2943020761013031,
0.06893216073513031,
0.047515615820884705,
-0.2985660433769226,
-0.11455941945314407,
-0.3657485842704773,
-0.3915238678455353,
-0.17456188797950745,
-0.16134987771511078,
0.6160772442817688,
0.6399590969085693,
-0.011670907028019428,
0.4706245958805084,
-0.22809568047523499,
0.6261261105537415,
-1.0644736289978027,
0.18227121233940125,
-0.8402602672576904,
-0.07999773323535919,
-0.095720574259758,
0.1890643835067749,
-0.4144246578216553,
-0.19344767928123474,
0.15708374977111816,
-0.7317983508110046,
0.17653274536132812,
0.3732722997665405,
1.0448005199432373,
0.21674540638923645,
-0.22952739894390106,
-0.16783715784549713,
-0.5342239737510681,
0.9535040259361267,
-0.40614554286003113,
0.3492097854614258,
0.6943793296813965,
0.8017110228538513,
0.04258446395397186,
-0.8160321712493896,
-0.6305466890335083,
-0.31726741790771484,
0.11098331958055496,
0.0926888957619667,
-0.21729034185409546,
-0.310944139957428,
0.37598085403442383,
0.2876527011394501,
-0.4788499176502228,
0.15789054334163666,
-0.5735583901405334,
-0.20814193785190582,
0.6309659481048584,
0.44364434480667114,
0.32704615592956543,
-0.126307874917984,
-0.5257506370544434,
-0.17182804644107819,
-0.2832435369491577,
0.36757180094718933,
-0.23237065970897675,
-0.18479621410369873,
0.2819361090660095,
0.6992651224136353,
-0.38458964228630066,
0.9040813446044922,
-0.49334150552749634,
-0.2427276223897934,
0.2713417410850525,
-0.21566657721996307,
-0.4804798662662506,
-0.2715955078601837,
0.4548996686935425,
0.8610722422599792,
0.37666580080986023,
-0.062554731965065,
-0.4093041718006134,
0.42003417015075684,
0.165988028049469,
-0.5191434025764465,
0.08193471282720566,
0.04390883445739746,
-0.7697049975395203,
-0.006142608821392059,
-0.04927947372198105,
-0.8037513494491577,
-0.44682565331459045,
-0.026629261672496796,
0.34861844778060913,
-0.39993607997894287,
-0.1971973478794098,
0.49617499113082886,
-0.47737228870391846,
0.7066235542297363,
0.5463317632675171,
-0.47479960322380066,
0.4944436550140381,
0.7429385781288147,
0.38857826590538025,
-0.327055424451828,
-0.4235266447067261,
-0.5173972845077515,
0.07720790803432465,
-0.38606974482536316,
0.8498700857162476,
-0.6685026288032532,
-0.2410106360912323,
-0.0290167648345232,
0.15632639825344086,
0.10764733701944351,
-0.7482576966285706,
0.6371856927871704,
-0.7607846856117249,
-0.1329757422208786,
-0.4576936662197113,
-0.5800883769989014,
-0.17040027678012848,
0.46764037013053894,
-0.6827664375305176,
0.9215132594108582,
0.12409520149230957,
-0.4569733440876007,
0.563223123550415,
-0.2297680526971817,
-0.4044950604438782,
0.6046870350837708,
-0.4450683891773224,
-0.3365343511104584,
0.018447326496243477,
0.24697275459766388,
0.46783530712127686,
-0.7905438542366028,
0.08624415844678879,
-0.45128753781318665,
-0.566547691822052,
0.5997815728187561,
-0.2827194929122925,
0.8204971551895142,
0.260404109954834,
-0.41901707649230957,
-0.011277547106146812,
-0.6336749792098999,
0.36906149983406067,
0.580191969871521,
-0.27697932720184326,
-0.4448826313018799,
0.013763693161308765,
-0.09842097759246826,
0.12263107299804688,
0.4644054174423218,
-0.5585121512413025,
0.040427058935165405,
0.10403488576412201,
0.34481409192085266,
0.6633222103118896,
-0.1298792064189911,
0.13582591712474823,
-0.20169389247894287,
0.3628564476966858,
-0.14396919310092926,
0.4687997102737427,
-0.1474761664867401,
-0.53639155626297,
-0.6944095492362976,
-0.5143123269081116,
0.005439183209091425,
0.6865414381027222,
-1.0036702156066895,
0.3797611594200134,
-0.3802028298377991,
-0.566314160823822,
-0.421029657125473,
0.17566756904125214,
0.8153740167617798,
0.19790689647197723,
0.34880873560905457,
-0.5764874815940857,
-0.006001582369208336,
-1.2702616453170776,
-0.41013583540916443,
0.024966400116682053,
0.003219225909560919,
0.4668413996696472,
0.8273951411247253,
0.03926624357700348,
0.37981823086738586,
-0.4583054780960083,
-0.2970648407936096,
0.006459505762904882,
-0.11256159096956253,
-0.05628151446580887,
0.23454701900482178,
0.4346598982810974,
-0.7662283778190613,
-0.15197788178920746,
-0.1306198239326477,
-0.8168588280677795,
0.3925884962081909,
0.017520582303404808,
-0.12126632034778595,
0.0990733951330185,
0.5965536832809448,
-0.7815831303596497,
0.9140714406967163,
0.17761926352977753,
-0.5637660026550293,
0.7265835404396057,
-0.16152195632457733,
0.4328534007072449,
-0.323746919631958,
-0.017838845029473305,
-0.014337893575429916,
-0.018268054351210594,
-0.08305013924837112,
0.2557600140571594,
0.19983932375907898,
-0.04067329317331314,
-0.6204003691673279,
0.6399818658828735,
-0.7281010746955872,
-0.625675618648529,
0.12890061736106873,
0.17650459706783295,
0.005769254639744759,
0.2830420136451721,
0.20711256563663483,
0.2986845076084137,
1.0137830972671509,
-0.3473552465438843,
0.7165322303771973,
0.1151827722787857,
-1.0931645631790161,
0.8433776497840881,
-0.49195772409439087,
0.0882815346121788,
-0.1704685389995575,
0.10420280694961548,
-0.9341611862182617,
-0.246720090508461,
-0.17441080510616302,
-0.2263438105583191,
-0.08897000551223755,
0.19788946211338043,
-0.5835299491882324,
-0.711356520652771,
-0.12408963590860367,
0.5465855598449707,
0.7928301095962524,
-0.4377068877220154,
0.5976228713989258,
0.15099529922008514,
0.32708269357681274,
-0.6019117832183838,
-0.7329029440879822,
0.278145968914032,
-0.1651594340801239,
-0.585024356842041,
0.009106197394430637,
0.015039559453725815,
-0.45739370584487915,
0.31843236088752747,
0.047470301389694214,
-0.10720556229352951,
0.07240425050258636,
0.10145071893930435,
0.3637268543243408,
-0.16806240379810333,
0.17365367710590363,
-0.739004373550415,
0.17751695215702057,
0.18659117817878723,
-0.11005543172359467,
0.332022100687027,
-0.5042165517807007,
-0.6060515642166138,
-0.2945156693458557,
0.3496231138706207,
0.711069643497467,
-0.6883955001831055,
0.4895941913127899,
0.5153326392173767,
-0.47220975160598755,
-0.14537841081619263,
-0.7206214070320129,
0.12427353858947754,
-0.39140310883522034,
0.5499160885810852,
-0.6701464056968689,
-0.6485342979431152,
0.34852609038352966,
0.19709478318691254,
-0.046204544603824615,
0.37848106026649475,
0.4751458466053009,
-0.11996175348758698,
0.886819064617157,
0.029759561643004417,
0.3598054349422455,
0.2751076817512512,
-0.15399779379367828,
-0.022395825013518333,
-0.828330934047699,
-0.5730763673782349,
-0.4196796715259552,
-0.20644058287143707,
-0.14682862162590027,
-0.6724299192428589,
0.07128199934959412,
0.11893415451049805,
-0.3998425006866455,
0.16113631427288055,
-0.6649880409240723,
0.6314378380775452,
0.6243466734886169,
0.16120019555091858,
0.1818140596151352,
-0.012578381225466728,
-0.018199732527136803,
-0.023830367252230644,
-0.24240238964557648,
-0.42993345856666565,
0.7673860192298889,
0.14250388741493225,
0.7547740340232849,
-0.0643215999007225,
0.20783570408821106,
0.2940661609172821,
0.02875661663711071,
-0.6930440068244934,
1.0223320722579956,
-0.2264658361673355,
-0.736158013343811,
-0.36041459441185,
-0.31254053115844727,
-1.082772135734558,
0.21761071681976318,
-0.4658413529396057,
-1.124100685119629,
-0.0788637325167656,
-0.08404916524887085,
-0.06083992123603821,
0.40935173630714417,
-0.545821487903595,
1.06088387966156,
-0.772557258605957,
-0.29142892360687256,
-0.5630757212638855,
-0.4646317958831787,
0.5274314880371094,
0.14112262427806854,
0.2994978427886963,
-0.3788486421108246,
-0.11558562517166138,
0.7610758543014526,
-0.0746927559375763,
0.5767273902893066,
-0.17502804100513458,
0.30000343918800354,
0.49472591280937195,
0.3338288366794586,
0.3998064696788788,
-0.34786441922187805,
0.25023528933525085,
0.04791995882987976,
0.3290027379989624,
-0.6811622977256775,
-0.7178213596343994,
0.41581496596336365,
-0.474738746881485,
-0.5625296235084534,
-0.2690882682800293,
-0.3226051330566406,
-0.2900329828262329,
0.2430306077003479,
0.17236080765724182,
0.37250030040740967,
-0.2480171173810959,
0.407456636428833,
0.4628942310810089,
-0.5517916083335876,
0.3651050925254822,
0.35116147994995117,
-0.4127112627029419,
-0.29011377692222595,
0.8715816140174866,
-0.23740622401237488,
0.393320232629776,
0.2669515609741211,
0.07116538286209106,
-0.05814743414521217,
-0.7296897768974304,
-0.3617764413356781,
0.021463409066200256,
-1.1896390914916992,
-0.023050133138895035,
-0.3181481957435608,
-0.061030492186546326,
-0.04223625734448433,
-0.2602355480194092,
-0.42722442746162415,
-0.29919198155403137,
0.19277361035346985,
0.26526662707328796,
0.03905201703310013,
0.6729890704154968,
0.5725206732749939,
-0.2359752655029297,
-0.5804267525672913,
0.5889970064163208,
0.6585519909858704,
0.4264066219329834,
0.23191241919994354,
-0.20660856366157532,
-0.24325326085090637,
-0.22023022174835205,
0.054569780826568604,
-0.5412850379943848,
-0.024875598028302193,
-0.24761168658733368,
0.8726646900177002,
0.22123639285564423,
-0.12405234575271606,
0.6827356219291687,
-0.276798278093338,
1.0082169771194458,
0.5791592597961426,
-0.8068428039550781,
0.444539338350296,
-0.040036387741565704,
0.5770161151885986,
0.31742867827415466,
-0.09154565632343292,
-0.19033008813858032,
-0.20996476709842682,
-0.68483567237854,
-0.6854767203330994,
0.12287867814302444,
0.17745792865753174,
-0.14309999346733093,
-0.12161928415298462,
0.2144780308008194,
-0.10942012071609497,
0.021510113030672073,
-0.6170597672462463,
0.08495108783245087,
-0.10123138129711151,
-0.02014840394258499,
-0.013821623288094997,
-0.09196936339139938,
-0.1860182136297226,
-0.43153777718544006,
0.36881405115127563,
-0.11733175069093704,
0.21362841129302979,
0.22202257812023163,
-0.178160160779953,
0.04909863695502281,
0.24425694346427917,
0.28487712144851685,
0.7539539933204651,
-0.0527770034968853,
0.3640662431716919,
0.3075271248817444,
-0.3196227252483368,
-0.17499040067195892,
-0.19675888121128082,
0.03135645017027855,
-0.5348146557807922,
0.8813130259513855,
0.8039695620536804,
0.046057119965553284,
-1.2443853616714478,
0.8086296319961548,
-0.38796648383140564,
-0.20291191339492798,
-0.4375011920928955,
0.07437773048877716,
0.25613853335380554,
0.32650065422058105,
0.2706451416015625,
0.1281588226556778,
0.16411924362182617,
-0.765580415725708,
0.11881563067436218,
0.7706651091575623,
-0.34142276644706726,
0.11825860291719437,
0.48183131217956543,
-0.15903057157993317,
-0.17438781261444092,
0.8102039694786072,
-0.23290033638477325,
-0.42179426550865173,
0.9471278190612793,
0.3424615263938904,
0.6720300912857056,
0.17751789093017578,
0.03786376491189003,
0.3378320038318634,
0.46874651312828064,
-0.10664298385381699,
0.3591856360435486,
-0.11707048118114471,
-0.7793212532997131,
-0.30742043256759644,
-0.4973903000354767,
-0.08067454397678375,
0.0118425153195858,
-0.9156730771064758,
0.15022526681423187,
-0.49952971935272217,
-0.17554111778736115,
0.37083396315574646,
-0.27287763357162476,
-1.170487403869629,
0.5855774879455566,
0.32479724287986755,
0.9467984437942505,
-0.3928074538707733,
0.6930078864097595,
0.5464467406272888,
-0.34589797258377075,
-0.5027029514312744,
-0.3596948981285095,
-0.3049365282058716,
-1.2585480213165283,
1.0947275161743164,
0.1373465359210968,
-0.2045966237783432,
-0.5523695349693298,
-0.835803747177124,
-0.6644958257675171,
1.160355806350708,
0.24052400887012482,
-0.48959413170814514,
0.044310569763183594,
-0.09707620739936829,
0.4757816195487976,
-0.6004763245582581,
0.07882105559110641,
0.7338786125183105,
0.5779076814651489,
0.18406666815280914,
-0.9992777705192566,
0.20491699874401093,
-0.23680633306503296,
0.1797429770231247,
-0.024815762415528297,
-0.5521791577339172,
0.8756162524223328,
-0.3868880569934845,
-0.36088666319847107,
0.3499543070793152,
0.2910851836204529,
0.2164871245622635,
0.18675653636455536,
0.8625282049179077,
0.722706139087677,
0.7028734683990479,
-0.1203749030828476,
1.4231972694396973,
0.23595911264419556,
0.189392551779747,
1.1595489978790283,
-0.42161861062049866,
1.172113060951233,
0.30027228593826294,
-0.05738040804862976,
0.42751264572143555,
0.3844452202320099,
-0.2956273555755615,
0.594703197479248,
0.49587956070899963,
-0.14049765467643738,
-0.7290856838226318,
-0.2082604020833969,
-0.12699249386787415,
0.674591600894928,
0.44879594445228577,
-0.36073043942451477,
0.016911355778574944,
-0.05646216496825218,
-0.333263099193573,
0.11890392005443573,
-0.638338029384613,
0.7028023600578308,
-0.026151807978749275,
-0.9946377873420715,
0.7904950380325317,
-0.2823706567287445,
0.1668338179588318,
-0.3021808862686157,
-0.024694330990314484,
0.3882804811000824,
0.4739358425140381,
-0.08649720251560211,
-1.2747563123703003,
0.014779426157474518,
-0.011726328171789646,
0.06235215812921524,
0.07424023747444153,
0.8644649982452393,
-0.06050393730401993,
-0.5570907592773438,
0.6724637746810913,
0.45898088812828064,
0.2731017768383026,
0.027512338012456894,
-0.8886402249336243,
0.23631799221038818,
-0.17566025257110596,
-0.27990636229515076,
0.16314518451690674,
0.12416516989469528,
-0.3902072608470917,
0.864726722240448,
0.5103216171264648,
0.038227640092372894,
0.15091311931610107,
0.13456791639328003,
0.6093841195106506,
-1.0163049697875977,
-0.28165721893310547,
-0.7442086935043335,
0.3763684034347534,
-0.3318398892879486,
-0.33376172184944153,
0.672148585319519,
0.6279182434082031,
0.8318504095077515,
-0.2145726978778839,
0.9414807558059692,
-0.1310596466064453,
0.2333221584558487,
-0.737144947052002,
0.12432384490966797,
-0.662530243396759,
0.07079653441905975,
-0.2897578477859497,
-0.8503286838531494,
-0.18750987946987152,
0.5047563314437866,
-0.32749029994010925,
0.03580029681324959,
0.9972875118255615,
0.5401067137718201,
-0.03339783474802971,
-0.010379715822637081,
0.72977215051651,
0.1157010868191719,
0.11274989694356918,
1.0391998291015625,
1.3588714599609375,
-0.27546218037605286,
0.6954018473625183,
-0.1643390953540802,
-0.31495797634124756,
0.05841037631034851,
-0.9187480807304382,
-1.1058893203735352,
-0.6280847787857056,
-0.3197445273399353,
-0.4762691557407379,
-0.062414757907390594,
0.42663392424583435,
0.7278048396110535,
-0.44094976782798767,
-0.10133621841669083,
0.16969190537929535,
-0.12002681195735931,
-0.603860080242157,
-0.18601462244987488,
0.41801536083221436,
0.09679067879915237,
-0.2913265526294708,
0.08075910806655884,
0.42860376834869385,
-0.03287793695926666,
-0.54305499792099,
-0.13014087080955505,
0.0424974299967289,
-0.062107667326927185,
0.5681928396224976,
0.1505710482597351,
-1.2296408414840698,
-0.39764609932899475,
-0.02739521488547325,
-0.11114126443862915,
-0.06746625155210495,
0.7928222417831421,
-0.6665433645248413,
0.6658202409744263,
0.36028945446014404,
0.6847271919250488,
0.8856814503669739,
-0.22636324167251587,
0.1299607753753662,
-0.14591296017169952,
0.18610775470733643,
0.21451567113399506,
0.7740113139152527,
0.49121689796447754,
-0.191901296377182,
0.4353073239326477,
0.1828560084104538,
-0.46940749883651733,
-0.6545100212097168,
0.4833960235118866,
-1.3262659311294556,
-0.6783388257026672,
1.0537251234054565,
-0.3189408779144287,
-0.5333434343338013,
-0.013467401266098022,
-0.1629546880722046,
-0.20768845081329346,
-0.07096272706985474,
0.48417967557907104,
0.8242058753967285,
0.019784657284617424,
-0.44848304986953735,
-0.8260841369628906,
0.24769137799739838,
0.18205320835113525,
-0.9010801911354065,
0.1545579582452774,
0.6486399173736572,
0.28218090534210205,
0.24215689301490784,
0.5006029605865479,
-0.3419434130191803,
0.6584333777427673,
0.2576609253883362,
0.27071869373321533,
0.036942530423402786,
-0.09686750173568726,
-0.020212478935718536,
0.08650907129049301,
0.24876508116722107,
-0.23086127638816833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18397v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18397v1
|
Decomposed Prompting: Unveiling Multilingual Linguistic Structure Knowledge in English-Centric Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T15:15:39 | 2024-02-28T15:15:39 |
Ercong Nie, Shuzhou Yuan, Bolei Ma, Helmut Schmid, Michael Färber, Frauke Kreuter, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the predominance of English in their training data, English-centric
Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-3 and LLaMA display a remarkable ability
to perform multilingual tasks, raising questions about the depth and nature of
their cross-lingual capabilities. This paper introduces the decomposed
prompting approach to probe the linguistic structure understanding of these
LLMs in sequence labeling tasks. Diverging from the single text-to-text prompt,
our method generates for each token of the input sentence an individual prompt
which asks for its linguistic label. We assess our method on the Universal
Dependencies part-of-speech tagging dataset for 38 languages, utilizing both
English-centric and multilingual LLMs. Our findings show that decomposed
prompting surpasses the iterative prompting baseline in efficacy and efficiency
under zero- and few-shot settings. Further analysis reveals the influence of
evaluation methods and the use of instructions in prompts. Our multilingual
investigation shows that English-centric language models perform better on
average than multilingual models. Our study offers insights into the
multilingual transferability of English-centric LLMs, contributing to the
understanding of their multilingual linguistic knowledge.
|
[
-0.2890360355377197,
-0.6753672957420349,
0.5161620378494263,
0.34219688177108765,
-0.18755093216896057,
-0.021523190662264824,
-0.37495049834251404,
-0.33772122859954834,
0.030941927805542946,
0.15125487744808197,
-0.6809917092323303,
-0.5800228118896484,
-0.4255427122116089,
0.5763428807258606,
-0.06640727818012238,
0.9103989601135254,
0.11321518570184708,
0.17070560157299042,
-0.2546878457069397,
-0.13675139844417572,
-0.7075321078300476,
-0.43498465418815613,
-0.6919035911560059,
-0.5646185278892517,
0.7875279188156128,
0.4594491124153137,
0.3371311128139496,
0.574821412563324,
-0.25043341517448425,
0.33145347237586975,
-0.5098267793655396,
0.03460753336548805,
-0.229121133685112,
0.2905171513557434,
-0.1784103661775589,
-0.6656615138053894,
-0.20699073374271393,
-0.16111339628696442,
0.6916075348854065,
0.9120405316352844,
0.039277974516153336,
0.0898934081196785,
0.24617375433444977,
0.4126123785972595,
-0.36595702171325684,
0.39740973711013794,
-0.6298324465751648,
-0.04109400138258934,
-0.0702567994594574,
-0.2682027816772461,
-0.7721543312072754,
0.08877933770418167,
0.0436992421746254,
-0.46981361508369446,
0.13922955095767975,
-0.16455262899398804,
0.4826648533344269,
0.20507413148880005,
-0.45054614543914795,
-0.22603997588157654,
-0.3579387068748474,
0.6908636093139648,
-0.43678101897239685,
0.5322083830833435,
0.4770345687866211,
-0.1480676829814911,
-0.0264133308082819,
-0.45919138193130493,
-0.33628126978874207,
-0.25034961104393005,
-0.17156288027763367,
-0.054479777812957764,
-0.1491183638572693,
-0.007949193939566612,
0.156119242310524,
0.15705476701259613,
-0.8800826072692871,
0.46007826924324036,
-0.4074714183807373,
-0.17301669716835022,
0.28770071268081665,
-0.025170709937810898,
0.6838458180427551,
-0.2781464457511902,
-0.39007437229156494,
0.00895777065306902,
-0.9624530076980591,
0.29315999150276184,
0.20270812511444092,
0.6923817992210388,
-0.33307990431785583,
0.540996789932251,
-0.035707712173461914,
0.6673407554626465,
-0.06561873108148575,
-0.3144714832305908,
0.2285294383764267,
-0.30489382147789,
-0.013074140064418316,
0.3338536024093628,
0.6717049479484558,
0.2757532000541687,
0.4258972108364105,
0.0030086610931903124,
0.0012477000709623098,
-0.01907476969063282,
-0.24821016192436218,
-0.6363506317138672,
-0.25123754143714905,
0.43669378757476807,
-0.20624426007270813,
0.1125035509467125,
-0.35844793915748596,
-0.45452120900154114,
-0.29046744108200073,
-0.21188966929912567,
0.3379501402378082,
-0.39816004037857056,
-0.26663121581077576,
0.22408458590507507,
0.03910176455974579,
0.35341671109199524,
0.17402514815330505,
-0.9998880624771118,
-0.37416183948516846,
0.751344621181488,
0.6511104106903076,
-0.09908868372440338,
-0.7875242829322815,
-0.5652933120727539,
0.13737501204013824,
-0.14179593324661255,
0.8990157246589661,
-0.6286682486534119,
-0.5036276578903198,
0.08911526948213577,
0.2875448167324066,
-0.1682799607515335,
-0.32771193981170654,
0.31515511870384216,
-0.47440773248672485,
0.46214839816093445,
-0.46910157799720764,
-0.38830816745758057,
-0.3206844627857208,
0.6682648062705994,
-0.743685245513916,
1.0203036069869995,
-0.29454854130744934,
-0.6554913520812988,
0.26801443099975586,
-0.5100297927856445,
-0.5656794309616089,
0.29465749859809875,
-0.14259018003940582,
0.16959898173809052,
-0.029225153848528862,
0.6849612593650818,
0.6171745657920837,
-0.1858995109796524,
0.33824169635772705,
0.0889696478843689,
-0.21560326218605042,
0.0741363987326622,
-0.5679459571838379,
0.9445553421974182,
-0.028376586735248566,
-0.14521469175815582,
0.24178779125213623,
-0.8040295243263245,
-0.0664888247847557,
0.22696098685264587,
-0.6302483677864075,
-0.31720882654190063,
-0.16074462234973907,
-0.4506368935108185,
-0.06186646968126297,
0.1552661657333374,
-0.3155270218849182,
0.3871877193450928,
-0.5093082785606384,
0.4466346204280853,
0.638724148273468,
0.08080600947141647,
0.5427955389022827,
0.09928076714277267,
0.7828772664070129,
-0.005901739466935396,
-0.12594202160835266,
-1.093307614326477,
-0.6325671076774597,
-0.46628719568252563,
-0.4114794135093689,
0.10283820331096649,
0.7534816861152649,
-0.8593345880508423,
0.023797299712896347,
-0.18041212856769562,
-0.1499675214290619,
-0.5370913743972778,
-0.008922507055103779,
0.5325139164924622,
0.6888508796691895,
0.4017614424228668,
0.29449573159217834,
-0.3578610420227051,
-0.7986234426498413,
-0.20466916263103485,
-0.4072358012199402,
-0.031175317242741585,
-0.2731959819793701,
0.248673215508461,
-0.14661888778209686,
0.4291379749774933,
-0.2411753237247467,
0.14181053638458252,
-0.527615487575531,
0.21682946383953094,
0.2916940152645111,
0.11964388936758041,
0.258994460105896,
-0.5454964637756348,
-0.33763277530670166,
0.0665769949555397,
-0.3666020929813385,
-0.30323880910873413,
0.040785498917102814,
0.1624552458524704,
0.3052527904510498,
0.4654275178909302,
-0.5763940215110779,
0.06000557169318199,
0.6313642859458923,
-0.21934159100055695,
0.7551443576812744,
-0.13682809472084045,
0.22434189915657043,
-1.2116576433181763,
0.13066717982292175,
-0.16608500480651855,
-0.029276583343744278,
-0.7509893774986267,
0.0412282794713974,
0.19542303681373596,
-0.13173510134220123,
-0.6112924814224243,
0.7037163972854614,
-0.8580029606819153,
-0.014587796293199062,
-0.07006785273551941,
0.08487721532583237,
0.3714521825313568,
0.4488086700439453,
0.04195011779665947,
0.8160220980644226,
0.6449180245399475,
-0.7278620600700378,
0.09913922846317291,
0.3550485372543335,
-0.34450674057006836,
0.5265238285064697,
-0.7431493401527405,
0.139417365193367,
-0.4702552855014801,
0.21259674429893494,
-1.3381282091140747,
-0.2783573269844055,
0.11694525182247162,
-0.4013003706932068,
0.43041250109672546,
-0.49075761437416077,
-0.3747573792934418,
-0.1582748293876648,
-0.39811134338378906,
0.6811439394950867,
0.2391831874847412,
-0.7141431570053101,
0.3341616988182068,
0.11257738620042801,
-0.47750309109687805,
-0.7428719401359558,
-0.7138413786888123,
0.04307709261775017,
-0.29222387075424194,
-0.4892769753932953,
0.30376026034355164,
-0.19510531425476074,
-0.20851676166057587,
-0.29520565271377563,
0.15322299301624298,
0.11076802760362625,
0.08217130601406097,
0.12504063546657562,
0.2993299067020416,
-0.29431265592575073,
0.16131699085235596,
0.09960698336362839,
-0.22116678953170776,
0.2952375113964081,
-0.09135337918996811,
0.7048113346099854,
0.031001150608062744,
-0.32476523518562317,
-0.323443204164505,
0.5534115433692932,
0.411969393491745,
-0.5488873720169067,
0.6252728700637817,
0.45003801584243774,
-0.1951984167098999,
-0.28481805324554443,
-0.3386082947254181,
-0.14149481058120728,
-0.47045403718948364,
0.2875196635723114,
-0.6735430359840393,
-1.0429245233535767,
0.6721276044845581,
0.1653788983821869,
0.14265413582324982,
0.2692255675792694,
0.7333201169967651,
0.2222411185503006,
1.103314757347107,
0.5703017711639404,
-0.07284712791442871,
0.2758614420890808,
-0.03133150935173035,
0.09353608638048172,
-0.4868631362915039,
-0.5612382888793945,
-0.690329909324646,
-0.1355278193950653,
-0.277660995721817,
-0.3777795433998108,
0.4150655269622803,
0.14765389263629913,
-0.07499641180038452,
0.08819818496704102,
-0.5568326115608215,
0.8134876489639282,
0.3573310077190399,
-0.2279329150915146,
0.3812257945537567,
0.0706854835152626,
-0.31010863184928894,
0.09439937025308609,
-0.6646263003349304,
-0.33075687289237976,
0.5094134211540222,
0.3156411051750183,
0.6231820583343506,
0.005265689920634031,
0.5700650811195374,
-0.08768349885940552,
-0.0021519851870834827,
-1.1660441160202026,
0.5047827363014221,
0.14528213441371918,
-0.3787704110145569,
-0.1114109456539154,
-0.2392580360174179,
-1.3541638851165771,
0.3275068700313568,
0.25225958228111267,
-0.8226289749145508,
0.07458257675170898,
0.0879032090306282,
-0.21429289877414703,
0.010074916295707226,
-0.8190183639526367,
0.6567010879516602,
-0.14229553937911987,
0.056312110275030136,
0.13344646990299225,
-0.6549951434135437,
0.33701494336128235,
0.2118707299232483,
0.3863179385662079,
-0.18501462042331696,
-0.15502338111400604,
0.6138043403625488,
-0.1036711111664772,
1.0287363529205322,
-0.11655343323945999,
-0.8080258369445801,
0.18063963949680328,
0.3238297700881958,
0.4872904419898987,
0.0725264772772789,
-0.0418950617313385,
0.13541528582572937,
-0.01381611917167902,
-0.22875149548053741,
-0.5208327174186707,
0.7417370080947876,
-0.47451531887054443,
-0.5754764676094055,
-0.05456317961215973,
-0.5877343416213989,
-0.3389001488685608,
0.22703339159488678,
0.5180922746658325,
0.6392824053764343,
0.10015193372964859,
-0.27697324752807617,
0.6856456398963928,
-0.3839770555496216,
0.6863608360290527,
0.6026811003684998,
-0.30193042755126953,
-0.4771495759487152,
0.5588894486427307,
-0.023563001304864883,
0.08933433145284653,
0.6017414927482605,
0.2626006007194519,
-0.6451308727264404,
-0.4030982255935669,
-0.6009122133255005,
0.5270525813102722,
-1.008887767791748,
-0.1740403175354004,
-0.6362186670303345,
0.260265976190567,
-0.44244733452796936,
-0.13711996376514435,
-0.21122333407402039,
-0.2843562662601471,
-0.26553139090538025,
-0.39411988854408264,
0.251615971326828,
0.9301369786262512,
0.10735662281513214,
0.11623292416334152,
-1.032729983329773,
0.06783979386091232,
0.2241087704896927,
0.13654114305973053,
0.08517394959926605,
-0.5167782306671143,
-0.178949773311615,
-0.06985388696193695,
0.2215546816587448,
-1.2224085330963135,
0.2325945794582367,
0.250978022813797,
0.6175640821456909,
0.15763114392757416,
-0.028892260044813156,
0.6352563500404358,
-0.7332490086555481,
1.1487879753112793,
0.03907220810651779,
-0.9495993256568909,
0.6029754281044006,
-0.3892286717891693,
0.7882088422775269,
0.3584314286708832,
0.6923149824142456,
-0.5911401510238647,
-0.1248917430639267,
-0.1609712541103363,
-1.1073856353759766,
0.7913772463798523,
-0.4887208640575409,
0.1732482761144638,
-0.2962294816970825,
0.26316431164741516,
0.2489003986120224,
-0.07447776198387146,
-0.8204516172409058,
-0.2782595455646515,
0.17533530294895172,
-0.04360977187752724,
-0.10694952309131622,
-0.577213704586029,
-0.1616070568561554,
-0.09543107450008392,
0.5085117816925049,
-0.309413343667984,
0.07034148275852203,
0.22679752111434937,
-0.3703615069389343,
0.30090564489364624,
0.6891956329345703,
0.7740271091461182,
0.757135808467865,
0.29879331588745117,
0.5523446798324585,
0.15370117127895355,
-0.26806533336639404,
0.47358331084251404,
0.03752094879746437,
0.014877337031066418,
0.012189442291855812,
0.5991431474685669,
0.7712813019752502,
0.2088867872953415,
-0.5145206451416016,
0.1524197906255722,
0.04502948001027107,
-0.1297914981842041,
0.25843074917793274,
-0.37044963240623474,
0.18346044421195984,
0.19034966826438904,
0.3415136933326721,
-0.5908234119415283,
0.07359570264816284,
-0.4680672585964203,
0.08297737687826157,
0.2353469431400299,
-0.10545142740011215,
-0.7380511164665222,
0.4482368230819702,
0.1266518086194992,
-0.1721705198287964,
0.407823771238327,
-0.23446273803710938,
-0.7513383030891418,
0.30187347531318665,
0.8102349638938904,
0.8292302489280701,
-0.6360154747962952,
0.3589373230934143,
0.5105762481689453,
0.4520960748195648,
-0.13035137951374054,
0.4397328495979309,
-0.2537204623222351,
-0.6674862504005432,
-1.0011430978775024,
-0.35724660754203796,
-0.2813943326473236,
0.28709107637405396,
-0.7079402804374695,
0.09902367740869522,
-0.15755662322044373,
0.2038271576166153,
0.024249043315649033,
-0.32190343737602234,
-0.42495444416999817,
-0.04146506264805794,
0.49094802141189575,
0.7493317127227783,
-0.8510891199111938,
0.6071491837501526,
1.136765480041504,
-0.09842658787965775,
-1.2748312950134277,
-0.17698639631271362,
0.25504356622695923,
-1.0061938762664795,
0.7294245958328247,
0.5575563907623291,
-0.2768988609313965,
0.13171367347240448,
-0.44794875383377075,
-0.6951894164085388,
0.6950734257698059,
0.6109589338302612,
-0.2443046271800995,
0.11455363035202026,
0.18474581837654114,
0.3515602946281433,
-0.14369195699691772,
0.30722272396087646,
0.5344123840332031,
0.5478479862213135,
0.15196463465690613,
-0.9746069312095642,
0.20837849378585815,
-0.41467368602752686,
-0.09538832306861877,
0.2659722864627838,
-0.2955964505672455,
0.7817781567573547,
-0.3573033809661865,
-0.4925476908683777,
-0.18483056128025055,
0.464586079120636,
0.37135449051856995,
0.12203449010848999,
0.4407024085521698,
0.3033405542373657,
0.9408490061759949,
0.040471151471138,
0.8522966504096985,
-0.27122360467910767,
0.04939410462975502,
1.0390534400939941,
-0.34210968017578125,
0.8692353963851929,
0.43747156858444214,
-0.1306810975074768,
0.5281004309654236,
0.659308135509491,
0.2429170310497284,
0.1598059982061386,
-0.04562533274292946,
-0.3701801896095276,
-0.008595340885221958,
-0.3050992488861084,
-0.4273378551006317,
0.53014075756073,
0.4051755964756012,
-0.09895782917737961,
-0.45421555638313293,
0.2797105312347412,
0.5150870680809021,
-0.20575502514839172,
-0.4365834891796112,
0.9029695987701416,
0.0024947102647274733,
-1.0065020322799683,
1.032945990562439,
-0.0631103664636612,
0.6337160468101501,
-0.7655303478240967,
-0.06369198113679886,
-0.46768221259117126,
-0.22574283182621002,
-0.31632402539253235,
-1.0205975770950317,
0.07017538696527481,
0.10814528912305832,
-0.3686855435371399,
-0.45718783140182495,
0.5019347071647644,
-0.8181973099708557,
-0.09127771854400635,
0.25508078932762146,
0.5542927384376526,
0.3108050525188446,
-0.16483977437019348,
-0.617103636264801,
0.19700093567371368,
0.21052286028862,
-0.35715794563293457,
0.19000022113323212,
0.567562460899353,
-0.07119379192590714,
0.6057235598564148,
0.503129780292511,
-0.11338985711336136,
-0.011767351068556309,
0.43188557028770447,
0.6938065886497498,
-0.6545286178588867,
-0.5400824546813965,
-1.1110972166061401,
0.8886715173721313,
0.49957719445228577,
-0.07951243966817856,
1.016329050064087,
0.4013625383377075,
0.8488688468933105,
-0.08917386829853058,
0.5563410520553589,
0.16286686062812805,
0.22642113268375397,
-0.7370009422302246,
0.4880015254020691,
-0.5023773312568665,
0.41741496324539185,
0.00549567025154829,
-0.8876341581344604,
-0.37966617941856384,
0.16215242445468903,
-0.12106364965438843,
-0.020162755623459816,
0.706988513469696,
0.9247762560844421,
0.30684271454811096,
-0.0018940557492896914,
0.3408064544200897,
0.10110484808683395,
0.3245973289012909,
0.4493885934352875,
0.9375124573707581,
-0.01453144010156393,
0.6261311769485474,
-0.1013137698173523,
-0.1432860940694809,
0.11805803328752518,
-0.9256329536437988,
-0.9625005722045898,
-0.6758891940116882,
-0.36663320660591125,
-0.23043116927146912,
-0.3224431574344635,
0.9832648038864136,
0.3300185799598694,
-0.6359206438064575,
-0.13648557662963867,
0.33888179063796997,
0.19991567730903625,
-0.050065841525793076,
-0.22065046429634094,
0.3502882719039917,
-0.5806734561920166,
-0.8307299017906189,
0.968421995639801,
0.32364621758461,
0.1443185657262802,
-0.2679887115955353,
0.18788015842437744,
-0.1325606256723404,
-0.20954422652721405,
0.8608691096305847,
0.32146620750427246,
-0.8109582662582397,
-0.06851907074451447,
0.10282652080059052,
0.15259437263011932,
0.06496952474117279,
0.7939416766166687,
-0.7749371528625488,
0.4197975695133209,
0.7370547652244568,
0.5765777826309204,
0.016728689894080162,
-0.011196866631507874,
0.6180588603019714,
-1.1962323188781738,
0.28872615098953247,
-0.003238197648897767,
0.3932063579559326,
0.5172741413116455,
-0.36815008521080017,
0.2858029007911682,
-0.008167521096765995,
-0.5306863188743591,
-0.8772069811820984,
0.3566453456878662,
-0.7807018160820007,
-0.4331490397453308,
1.4004942178726196,
-0.26687824726104736,
-0.3235876262187958,
-0.12191236764192581,
-0.40856608748435974,
0.09010613709688187,
-0.26937681436538696,
0.19396941363811493,
0.6779758334159851,
0.031047604978084564,
-0.5235159993171692,
-0.15894095599651337,
0.4235823452472687,
0.5814047455787659,
-0.6742380857467651,
0.2375648319721222,
0.568949282169342,
0.30925536155700684,
0.17666834592819214,
0.6090668439865112,
-0.054769448935985565,
0.062047701328992844,
-0.1989247351884842,
0.10053986310958862,
-0.20218825340270996,
-0.4767343997955322,
-0.9107694029808044,
0.17523808777332306,
0.18740782141685486,
-0.12608486413955688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18385v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18385v1
|
The First Place Solution of WSDM Cup 2024: Leveraging Large Language Models for Conversational Multi-Doc QA
| 2024-02-28T15:05:43 | 2024-02-28T15:05:43 |
Yiming Li, Zhao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Conversational multi-doc question answering aims to answer specific questions
based on the retrieved documents as well as the contextual conversations. In
this paper, we introduce our winning approach for the "Conversational Multi-Doc
QA" challenge in WSDM Cup 2024, which exploits the superior natural language
understanding and generation capability of Large Language Models (LLMs). We
first adapt LLMs to the task, then devise a hybrid training strategy to make
the most of in-domain unlabeled data. Moreover, an advanced text embedding
model is adopted to filter out potentially irrelevant documents and several
approaches are designed and compared for the model ensemble. Equipped with all
these techniques, our solution finally ranked 1st place in WSDM Cup 2024,
surpassing its rivals to a large extent. The source codes have been released at
https://github.com/zhangzhao219/WSDM-Cup-2024.
|
[
-0.5635019540786743,
-0.7229295372962952,
0.9699941277503967,
-0.13006797432899475,
-0.38650867342948914,
0.5925703048706055,
-0.04693920910358429,
-0.42952388525009155,
0.008747639134526253,
0.5980519652366638,
-0.7759835124015808,
-0.6569790840148926,
-0.6574526429176331,
0.24097593128681183,
-0.17390227317810059,
0.7194535732269287,
-0.11140802502632141,
0.2517908215522766,
-0.8170941472053528,
-0.18800577521324158,
-0.2616508901119232,
-0.5812215209007263,
-0.5831742882728577,
-0.28190404176712036,
0.3390735983848572,
0.36409634351730347,
0.3003651797771454,
0.22979141771793365,
0.5479692816734314,
0.42999884486198425,
-0.16058044135570526,
0.6434109807014465,
-0.4284939765930176,
0.10660304874181747,
-0.018666693940758705,
-0.5053292512893677,
-0.3515024483203888,
0.139118954539299,
0.5128862261772156,
0.5915756225585938,
-0.3183164894580841,
-0.02713041380047798,
-0.10014782845973969,
0.0555325411260128,
-0.05692179873585701,
0.266875296831131,
-0.9690786600112915,
-0.050598032772541046,
0.1548028439283371,
-0.5989104509353638,
-0.541353166103363,
-0.21245227754116058,
0.05868449807167053,
-0.700600802898407,
0.3056793808937073,
0.08169299364089966,
1.004362940788269,
0.13713622093200684,
-0.614822506904602,
-0.3296510577201843,
-0.6696237921714783,
0.7047403454780579,
-0.8528563976287842,
0.14536134898662567,
0.14032351970672607,
0.38634052872657776,
-0.20040540397167206,
-0.5753605365753174,
-0.8123477101325989,
0.19394758343696594,
0.24248237907886505,
0.45246264338493347,
0.18185678124427795,
0.14989466965198517,
0.000656774383969605,
-0.0014504909049719572,
-0.6007782220840454,
0.2665591537952423,
-0.34664323925971985,
-0.09161888808012009,
0.7083209156990051,
0.2934763729572296,
0.03295489400625229,
0.28493380546569824,
-0.42306700348854065,
-0.028707152232527733,
-0.2599034607410431,
0.0830787718296051,
0.028737377375364304,
0.1258781999349594,
-0.017568379640579224,
0.5410406589508057,
-0.16593123972415924,
0.50013667345047,
0.08729860186576843,
-0.487001895904541,
0.2347622662782669,
-0.4992871582508087,
-0.08071908354759216,
-0.09665406495332718,
0.7166049480438232,
0.32021763920783997,
0.1187642365694046,
-0.2867329716682434,
-0.08140509575605392,
-0.045447174459695816,
0.08784724026918411,
-0.6804254055023193,
0.08948612213134766,
0.6515579223632812,
-0.11772508919239044,
-0.4004143178462982,
-0.04890962690114975,
-0.790962278842926,
-0.3875827491283417,
-0.22580383718013763,
0.13965465128421783,
-0.24355801939964294,
-0.23931708931922913,
0.09390853345394135,
-0.26338720321655273,
0.6616551280021667,
0.4221368134021759,
-0.6765118837356567,
0.05296361818909645,
0.8125009536743164,
0.7036087512969971,
-0.16956141591072083,
-0.33509936928749084,
-0.6518468856811523,
0.34638166427612305,
-0.421153724193573,
1.0512851476669312,
-0.6259129047393799,
-0.5305861830711365,
0.19688521325588226,
-0.0038185054436326027,
-0.3456849157810211,
-0.46434515714645386,
0.6654861569404602,
-0.7292547225952148,
0.33923470973968506,
-0.1163196936249733,
-0.7628970742225647,
0.0968119204044342,
0.5243885517120361,
-0.3951480984687805,
0.8724218010902405,
0.0018678252818062901,
-0.7399870157241821,
0.06843098253011703,
-0.563469648361206,
-0.1614292562007904,
0.34887459874153137,
-0.022645654156804085,
-0.4656594395637512,
-0.128651961684227,
0.1991305649280548,
0.4192488491535187,
-0.22482307255268097,
0.3420453369617462,
-0.63150954246521,
-0.2783234119415283,
0.29139575362205505,
-0.14835700392723083,
0.5628491640090942,
0.06511442363262177,
0.17794832587242126,
0.29664990305900574,
-0.7589718103408813,
0.21692177653312683,
0.6211594939231873,
-0.39557570219039917,
-0.05373471975326538,
-0.2618241608142853,
-0.1351630836725235,
0.548465371131897,
0.12365163117647171,
-0.7545230388641357,
0.15985393524169922,
-0.209615096449852,
0.6448207497596741,
0.7349311709403992,
0.26711505651474,
0.5303477048873901,
-0.4046240448951721,
0.7601265907287598,
0.052866335958242416,
0.1614295095205307,
-0.11785881966352463,
-0.5762808918952942,
-0.4385206997394562,
-0.36026445031166077,
0.21440890431404114,
0.5876713991165161,
-1.0328056812286377,
0.2631683647632599,
-0.20048385858535767,
-0.7818734049797058,
-0.5674706101417542,
0.03057197295129299,
0.18476688861846924,
0.5277039408683777,
0.07807011157274246,
0.07170487195253372,
-0.41395333409309387,
-0.5692623257637024,
0.24538928270339966,
-0.315768837928772,
0.23057152330875397,
0.3498976230621338,
0.5084785223007202,
-0.18934378027915955,
0.8820851445198059,
-0.7002221941947937,
-0.3394361436367035,
-0.49757981300354004,
0.032977327704429626,
0.0694432184100151,
0.30926114320755005,
0.3326928913593292,
-0.9544755220413208,
-0.31883329153060913,
-0.24768640100955963,
-0.8428049683570862,
0.041307710111141205,
0.11699629575014114,
-0.21803000569343567,
0.2274244874715805,
0.6612748503684998,
-0.890884518623352,
-0.23245428502559662,
0.6747153997421265,
-0.2151951640844345,
0.724125325679779,
-0.4664672017097473,
0.25414174795150757,
-1.147683024406433,
-0.1119401827454567,
-0.018242238089442253,
-0.17210333049297333,
-0.6714483499526978,
0.2736414074897766,
-0.00683829328045249,
-0.49193239212036133,
-0.49876779317855835,
0.528850257396698,
-0.30552682280540466,
0.20979900658130646,
-0.14697328209877014,
0.5445737242698669,
0.2694215178489685,
0.7458323240280151,
0.2530408799648285,
0.6394480466842651,
0.300775945186615,
-0.4768489599227905,
0.4507392942905426,
0.589921772480011,
-0.19353921711444855,
0.5389867424964905,
-0.5948582291603088,
0.2965394854545593,
-0.30573511123657227,
0.5867899656295776,
-1.2495300769805908,
0.02896585874259472,
-0.11430167406797409,
-0.5755569934844971,
0.3379909098148346,
-0.07873685657978058,
-0.508930504322052,
-0.7018111944198608,
-0.26108676195144653,
0.1540536880493164,
0.23789407312870026,
-0.4423450827598572,
0.5611518621444702,
0.642122745513916,
-0.34381529688835144,
-0.12310003489255905,
-0.1896059364080429,
0.23348648846149445,
-0.3983049988746643,
-0.7956379055976868,
0.4125077724456787,
-0.553474485874176,
-0.05194118246436119,
-0.3918968439102173,
0.04077460616827011,
-0.2513946294784546,
0.23472943902015686,
-0.23449823260307312,
0.4528418779373169,
-0.208291158080101,
-0.015115524642169476,
-0.0696568712592125,
-0.31258881092071533,
0.06009231507778168,
-0.3695746660232544,
0.7163683772087097,
0.006921248976141214,
-0.29402223229408264,
-0.24303309619426727,
0.6401239633560181,
0.6442235112190247,
-0.6397340893745422,
0.7318387031555176,
0.6071502566337585,
-0.30553025007247925,
-0.22241143882274628,
-0.48562636971473694,
-0.17181994020938873,
-0.4665609896183014,
0.6275663375854492,
-0.588558554649353,
-0.9251182675361633,
0.3686390519142151,
-0.2663525342941284,
0.2587084174156189,
0.15816597640514374,
0.4916801452636719,
-0.440565288066864,
1.3757494688034058,
0.5420889258384705,
-0.0024024888407438993,
0.12809567153453827,
-0.18206095695495605,
0.3332386910915375,
-0.7791828513145447,
-0.5133519768714905,
-0.8160510063171387,
0.22914592921733856,
-0.42144420742988586,
-0.4832768440246582,
0.5754709243774414,
0.05354480817914009,
0.050164856016635895,
0.11048313230276108,
-0.3846689462661743,
0.2709040939807892,
0.43995410203933716,
0.026233114302158356,
0.4538581073284149,
-0.4847742021083832,
-0.2872065603733063,
0.04816572740674019,
-0.8223868608474731,
-0.547782838344574,
0.8422711491584778,
0.3086128234863281,
0.30403515696525574,
0.14226339757442474,
0.8209639191627502,
0.04044298827648163,
-0.0036706181708723307,
-0.5960544943809509,
0.6301575303077698,
0.15093235671520233,
-0.24380627274513245,
-0.6157268285751343,
-0.3770599067211151,
-0.9002352356910706,
0.7602185606956482,
-0.295244425535202,
-0.4355456531047821,
-0.2853057086467743,
-0.29206785559654236,
-0.21084195375442505,
0.21778680384159088,
-0.5905190110206604,
0.857826292514801,
-0.07655852288007736,
-0.11884482204914093,
0.1776593178510666,
-0.4448034167289734,
0.438099205493927,
-0.10255325585603714,
0.612883985042572,
-0.13087956607341766,
-0.04791427031159401,
0.7260252237319946,
-0.3935393989086151,
0.48207560181617737,
-0.24858058989048004,
-0.35775476694107056,
0.22630956768989563,
-0.15930220484733582,
0.7948065996170044,
0.17273256182670593,
-0.0543946847319603,
-0.22093689441680908,
0.43158289790153503,
-0.6135711669921875,
-0.49846184253692627,
0.514977216720581,
-0.6165673732757568,
-0.8639029264450073,
-0.5647276639938354,
-0.474580317735672,
-0.6998167634010315,
0.20383094251155853,
0.13173042237758636,
0.5182282328605652,
-0.4385855793952942,
-0.17780041694641113,
1.0722378492355347,
-0.23314118385314941,
0.5172829031944275,
0.7505361437797546,
-0.0017032980686053634,
-0.20830081403255463,
0.847037136554718,
-0.22209817171096802,
0.397147536277771,
0.4751780033111572,
0.19782587885856628,
-0.6276130676269531,
-1.0467579364776611,
-0.7277966737747192,
0.4377704858779907,
-0.7584701776504517,
-0.12983399629592896,
-1.0113590955734253,
-0.30291515588760376,
-0.7043846249580383,
-0.1278853714466095,
-0.24975557625293732,
0.029424652457237244,
-0.066621795296669,
-0.21935614943504333,
-0.005839161574840546,
0.5223271250724792,
0.31830281019210815,
0.022799814119935036,
-0.9480912089347839,
0.15919339656829834,
0.37087973952293396,
0.05068439990282059,
-0.146123468875885,
-0.4627741277217865,
0.02217104472219944,
-0.08797954767942429,
-0.21147671341896057,
-0.6950750350952148,
0.4249878227710724,
0.07464125007390976,
0.8645050525665283,
0.23005631566047668,
0.1877877563238144,
0.5038575530052185,
-0.5293976068496704,
0.8253648281097412,
0.21399593353271484,
-0.6253612637519836,
0.3505946099758148,
-0.548312246799469,
0.4706810712814331,
0.694691002368927,
0.22343361377716064,
-0.6773858070373535,
-0.7188189625740051,
-0.6134567260742188,
-0.709901750087738,
0.6791309118270874,
-0.09692983329296112,
0.11408426612615585,
0.060881104320287704,
0.023498989641666412,
-0.017922790721058846,
0.30228886008262634,
-0.3977756202220917,
-0.06959734857082367,
0.10761665552854538,
-0.26680469512939453,
-0.21219536662101746,
-0.14814749360084534,
-0.11513225734233856,
0.0016050143167376518,
0.9150445461273193,
-0.39326536655426025,
0.23261767625808716,
0.09584936499595642,
-0.11947588622570038,
0.2560475766658783,
0.24619388580322266,
0.6868383288383484,
0.7511430978775024,
-0.22007784247398376,
-0.013730950653553009,
0.2850642502307892,
-0.20528069138526917,
0.13080376386642456,
0.12065032869577408,
-0.10037592053413391,
0.026827460154891014,
0.42763811349868774,
0.48771458864212036,
0.31827813386917114,
-0.875201404094696,
0.5796727538108826,
-0.25059786438941956,
-0.42954128980636597,
-0.39272239804267883,
-0.1777794510126114,
0.4334253966808319,
0.12640535831451416,
0.4393369257450104,
-0.30704548954963684,
-0.03776151314377785,
-0.585054874420166,
0.21425683796405792,
0.6137266159057617,
-0.42158299684524536,
0.03636902943253517,
0.6830397248268127,
0.33138903975486755,
-0.13858745992183685,
0.1821863055229187,
-0.4800807237625122,
-1.0279827117919922,
0.7834277153015137,
0.7367231249809265,
0.22804144024848938,
-0.0670575499534607,
0.7184282541275024,
0.3099460303783417,
-0.012676028534770012,
0.12003247439861298,
0.18251298367977142,
0.12314049154520035,
-0.8610889911651611,
-0.19399550557136536,
-0.584969699382782,
-0.7221308350563049,
0.06687457859516144,
-0.3447296619415283,
0.2501104176044464,
-0.20103678107261658,
0.32020094990730286,
0.1785317361354828,
0.28986459970474243,
-0.6973604559898376,
0.1374841332435608,
0.16223709285259247,
0.927315890789032,
-0.6072823405265808,
0.9346866011619568,
0.6248871684074402,
-0.38152652978897095,
-0.5582126379013062,
-0.3003762662410736,
0.006738715805113316,
-0.8043662309646606,
-0.04567398875951767,
-0.0744529664516449,
-0.009673415683209896,
0.2633228302001953,
-0.5528264045715332,
-0.7811341881752014,
1.2364332675933838,
0.06109989807009697,
-0.33629900217056274,
-0.19690334796905518,
0.20795515179634094,
0.2779819965362549,
-0.3899570405483246,
0.4178119897842407,
0.5584423542022705,
0.39598938822746277,
0.583132803440094,
-0.8008057475090027,
-0.14652220904827118,
-0.19160346686840057,
-0.20361639559268951,
-0.014406025409698486,
-0.8824591040611267,
0.4791170358657837,
-0.38243040442466736,
-0.15355907380580902,
0.3126240670681,
0.6830568313598633,
0.613525927066803,
0.42871224880218506,
0.511674702167511,
0.4341701865196228,
1.131805658340454,
-0.1733124703168869,
0.9687491059303284,
0.0012269840808585286,
0.3204527199268341,
1.083618402481079,
-0.7198919057846069,
0.6141365766525269,
0.32435858249664307,
-0.24516932666301727,
0.10682960599660873,
0.7879474759101868,
0.06737115234136581,
0.6219711899757385,
0.23024290800094604,
-0.30039018392562866,
-0.4957696497440338,
-0.21393631398677826,
-0.38175973296165466,
0.7203819155693054,
0.05457684397697449,
0.20138362050056458,
-0.2514917850494385,
0.19050131738185883,
0.10696068406105042,
0.29867956042289734,
-0.17246375977993011,
1.192257046699524,
0.10528368502855301,
-0.8543180227279663,
0.396559476852417,
0.31895947456359863,
0.8088959455490112,
-0.8261118531227112,
0.07834567129611969,
-0.27428340911865234,
0.09408853948116302,
0.06716994941234589,
-0.7135542035102844,
0.05363302305340767,
-0.23545365035533905,
-0.13477823138237,
-0.12244096398353577,
0.5314909815788269,
-0.7644212245941162,
-0.510792076587677,
0.30929264426231384,
0.647607147693634,
0.02184923365712166,
-0.1827620267868042,
-0.5916394591331482,
-0.030974293127655983,
-0.20958733558654785,
0.1951577067375183,
0.5782955288887024,
0.5611318349838257,
-0.01105575542896986,
0.6785222291946411,
0.780087947845459,
-0.05806547775864601,
-0.002975656883791089,
0.30119195580482483,
0.6946569681167603,
-0.35130074620246887,
-0.7418506741523743,
-0.43388983607292175,
0.12205877155065536,
-0.27468401193618774,
-0.35887837409973145,
0.5167874693870544,
0.6876489520072937,
0.6601499915122986,
0.02183672972023487,
0.8395587801933289,
0.28073790669441223,
0.5220547318458557,
-0.46251437067985535,
0.6147697567939758,
-0.4515440762042999,
-0.023484010249376297,
-0.3703972101211548,
-0.5355512499809265,
0.0847954973578453,
0.1514727622270584,
0.13568784296512604,
-0.17284870147705078,
0.760175883769989,
0.652654767036438,
0.22764547169208527,
0.3574472963809967,
0.5120235085487366,
0.00100700743496418,
0.6491628289222717,
0.9882874488830566,
0.7447276711463928,
-0.34733647108078003,
0.8830100297927856,
-0.12597692012786865,
-0.37397775053977966,
-0.04794604703783989,
-0.6945654153823853,
-0.7953397631645203,
-0.9892212152481079,
-0.42085713148117065,
-0.46339789032936096,
-0.17452561855316162,
0.7920442223548889,
0.7234939336776733,
-0.734454333782196,
0.17575106024742126,
0.28356748819351196,
0.28277233242988586,
-0.2184387445449829,
-0.1842338591814041,
0.2569367587566376,
-0.40064409375190735,
-1.0403574705123901,
0.5155697464942932,
0.06843332946300507,
0.020779568701982498,
-0.14182952046394348,
-0.2869327962398529,
-0.5020992159843445,
0.367172509431839,
0.7707812190055847,
-0.042367175221443176,
-0.41353240609169006,
-0.2187221348285675,
0.09399095922708511,
-0.2536792457103729,
0.07461746037006378,
0.7029905915260315,
-0.49159660935401917,
0.1778666377067566,
0.34285613894462585,
0.8595969676971436,
0.6809975504875183,
0.008492959663271904,
0.4420221745967865,
-0.41904518008232117,
0.01305360160768032,
0.31837230920791626,
0.37866777181625366,
0.2039123922586441,
-0.3102516829967499,
0.46596649289131165,
0.4102003276348114,
-0.369925320148468,
-0.8056618571281433,
-0.0006733954069204628,
-1.316664218902588,
-0.4937423765659332,
1.2412244081497192,
-0.1267632693052292,
-0.07987399399280548,
-0.5551791191101074,
-0.2858261466026306,
0.23811596632003784,
-0.29884472489356995,
0.898276686668396,
0.9632689952850342,
0.09156926721334457,
-0.20713123679161072,
-0.4869624972343445,
0.345659077167511,
0.1613457351922989,
-1.2587957382202148,
-0.08932030200958252,
0.23180146515369415,
0.23284262418746948,
-0.031953729689121246,
0.9730151295661926,
-0.35670992732048035,
0.13738246262073517,
-0.15757326781749725,
-0.25323471426963806,
-0.338351845741272,
-0.1631626933813095,
-0.08149126172065735,
0.4991453289985657,
0.005369992461055517,
-0.243663027882576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18376v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18376v1
|
Tokenization Is More Than Compression
| 2024-02-28T14:52:15 | 2024-02-28T14:52:15 |
Craig W. Schmidt, Varshini Reddy, Haoran Zhang, Alec Alameddine, Omri Uzan, Yuval Pinter, Chris Tanner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Tokenization is a foundational step in Natural Language Processing (NLP)
tasks, bridging raw text and language models. Existing tokenization approaches
like Byte-Pair Encoding (BPE) originate from the field of data compression, and
it has been suggested that the effectiveness of BPE stems from its ability to
condense text into a relatively small number of tokens. We test the hypothesis
that fewer tokens lead to better downstream performance by introducing
PathPiece, a new tokenizer that segments a document's text into the minimum
number of tokens for a given vocabulary. Through extensive experimentation we
find this hypothesis not to be the case, casting doubt on the understanding of
the reasons for effective tokenization. To examine which other factors play a
role, we evaluate design decisions across all three phases of tokenization:
pre-tokenization, vocabulary construction, and segmentation, offering new
insights into the design of effective tokenizers. Specifically, we illustrate
the importance of pre-tokenization and the benefits of using BPE to initialize
vocabulary construction. We train 64 language models with varying tokenization,
ranging in size from 350M to 2.4B parameters, all of which are made publicly
available.
|
[
-0.5303146839141846,
-0.4255099594593048,
0.16687144339084625,
0.2618364989757538,
-0.8014240860939026,
-0.02545740082859993,
-0.06559902429580688,
-0.5721157789230347,
0.2561492919921875,
0.29053136706352234,
-0.07406355440616608,
-0.331938773393631,
-0.7328568696975708,
0.2085614800453186,
-0.4193629324436188,
1.111905574798584,
0.2094920426607132,
0.12986397743225098,
0.026623060926795006,
0.128750279545784,
-0.8750981092453003,
-0.7076772451400757,
-0.9122955799102783,
-0.2222243994474411,
0.5903361439704895,
-0.09524822980165482,
0.6138890981674194,
1.0038740634918213,
0.6037871241569519,
0.21691566705703735,
-0.31712719798088074,
-0.14541031420230865,
-0.21680478751659393,
0.02428712509572506,
-0.06338166445493698,
-0.5501714944839478,
-0.15418852865695953,
0.20966599881649017,
0.6226018667221069,
1.066064476966858,
0.2090628743171692,
0.2736595869064331,
0.023473622277379036,
0.6320267915725708,
-0.47565528750419617,
-0.0918479785323143,
-0.5414919853210449,
-0.006953896954655647,
-0.5466469526290894,
-0.15063543617725372,
-0.6163087487220764,
-0.029187824577093124,
0.026242705062031746,
-0.357893705368042,
0.1983933001756668,
0.3523155450820923,
0.8856731653213501,
0.23806633055210114,
-0.34123924374580383,
-0.316689670085907,
-0.5836566090583801,
0.4679766893386841,
-0.6566762328147888,
0.6102693676948547,
0.2824842035770416,
-0.1565791517496109,
-0.15792441368103027,
-0.8974401950836182,
-0.4633270800113678,
0.3259906470775604,
-0.24830812215805054,
-0.265847384929657,
-0.1264866590499878,
0.4499306380748749,
0.15620049834251404,
0.44904422760009766,
-0.4194609224796295,
0.2612728178501129,
-0.6292243003845215,
-0.45886433124542236,
0.1472741812467575,
-0.08649355173110962,
0.4372485280036926,
-0.6851693391799927,
-0.5256272554397583,
-0.03611491993069649,
-0.5291395783424377,
0.11742719262838364,
0.3773629069328308,
0.5819104313850403,
0.26562854647636414,
0.5699456334114075,
0.09079959243535995,
0.8472885489463806,
0.015479755587875843,
-0.049725256860256195,
-0.08200136572122574,
-0.7434403896331787,
-0.3089468777179718,
0.24605853855609894,
0.5594284534454346,
0.23699314892292023,
-0.09946933388710022,
-0.6007524132728577,
-0.2211601585149765,
0.26370319724082947,
0.5458752512931824,
-1.148112416267395,
-0.0076894317753612995,
0.5789677500724792,
-0.7370226383209229,
-0.39513036608695984,
0.18531134724617004,
-0.3492297828197479,
-0.30079030990600586,
-0.33324143290519714,
0.4075451195240021,
-0.6022728085517883,
0.019506733864545822,
0.41205525398254395,
-0.633209228515625,
0.4152657687664032,
-0.07376888394355774,
-1.1332663297653198,
0.4831037223339081,
1.1323539018630981,
1.2929556369781494,
-0.3988349139690399,
-0.1956651508808136,
-0.6988013982772827,
-0.026060396805405617,
-0.47245630621910095,
0.9357591271400452,
-0.5115285515785217,
-0.49306973814964294,
-0.1745353639125824,
-0.1878412663936615,
-0.017206478863954544,
-0.4102559983730316,
0.763499915599823,
-0.5989516377449036,
0.08560027182102203,
-0.2866649627685547,
-0.7739695310592651,
0.045140590518713,
0.01832098327577114,
-0.7023439407348633,
0.9089993834495544,
-0.11630995571613312,
-0.8905969262123108,
1.0370429754257202,
-0.8570011854171753,
-0.6178644299507141,
0.3465871810913086,
0.00530770281329751,
0.018459783867001534,
0.589604914188385,
0.18831509351730347,
0.45302334427833557,
0.010968860238790512,
0.023711970075964928,
0.2889993190765381,
-0.7166053056716919,
-0.10491536557674408,
-0.21767781674861908,
0.5118116140365601,
0.03879115357995033,
-0.24328768253326416,
0.0651865303516388,
-0.5690404772758484,
-0.1271679401397705,
-0.23469680547714233,
-0.6822887659072876,
-0.3728583753108978,
0.09234357625246048,
0.13143417239189148,
0.1351076364517212,
0.08552859723567963,
-0.6199141144752502,
0.13622160255908966,
-1.0321495532989502,
0.496049165725708,
0.8519005179405212,
0.04339658096432686,
0.7063573002815247,
-0.27967140078544617,
0.3273181915283203,
0.1196974664926529,
0.23843787610530853,
-0.23807407915592194,
-0.5011105537414551,
-0.8559755086898804,
-0.2758934795856476,
0.8127763867378235,
0.03790038451552391,
-0.45380881428718567,
0.3544560670852661,
-0.4743000566959381,
-0.25204095244407654,
-0.4437170624732971,
-0.08085175603628159,
0.12038172781467438,
0.18745411932468414,
0.18781232833862305,
-0.6760483384132385,
-0.7200877666473389,
-0.6771095395088196,
-0.3200899064540863,
-0.2954798638820648,
-0.1466684341430664,
-0.09207581728696823,
0.43440738320350647,
0.0844728872179985,
1.191009521484375,
-0.14029155671596527,
-0.21285349130630493,
-0.2572614252567291,
0.33758044242858887,
0.33323588967323303,
0.6683247089385986,
0.47800490260124207,
-0.7036505937576294,
-0.2792874574661255,
-0.27480170130729675,
-0.07255297154188156,
0.08081899583339691,
-0.09794845432043076,
-0.3265058100223541,
0.12937043607234955,
0.4312477707862854,
-0.5434245467185974,
0.4698466658592224,
0.5433401465415955,
-0.4543895423412323,
0.3812912404537201,
-0.04046091437339783,
-0.16623255610466003,
-1.0936121940612793,
0.21124623715877533,
-0.4168640673160553,
-0.06366527080535889,
-0.9883220195770264,
0.07127655297517776,
-0.18883268535137177,
-0.2931702733039856,
-0.48787689208984375,
0.5456236004829407,
-0.4501192271709442,
-0.08238769322633743,
-0.517107367515564,
0.185752272605896,
0.1063762754201889,
0.46766823530197144,
0.06579481810331345,
0.7881120443344116,
0.27271604537963867,
-0.7434437870979309,
-0.06384185701608658,
0.29468733072280884,
-0.3100905418395996,
0.4519069492816925,
-0.8983765244483948,
0.45729705691337585,
-0.3914269208908081,
0.2827706038951874,
-0.8221132755279541,
-0.08667462319135666,
0.10931642353534698,
-0.4761159121990204,
0.20885156095027924,
-0.44233056902885437,
-0.5792905688285828,
-0.2535192668437958,
-0.49566540122032166,
0.413469523191452,
0.3821372389793396,
-0.4491839110851288,
0.525166928768158,
0.36565256118774414,
0.17688119411468506,
-0.35101333260536194,
-0.7101339101791382,
0.41283881664276123,
-0.23380900919437408,
-0.7349158525466919,
0.741553008556366,
-0.15885093808174133,
0.032859548926353455,
-0.10556096583604813,
-0.34768980741500854,
-0.025370463728904724,
0.1837037056684494,
0.3014490604400635,
0.22261594235897064,
-0.007713084574788809,
0.46119144558906555,
-0.17595702409744263,
-0.2939890921115875,
0.017017275094985962,
-0.8330843448638916,
1.0606480836868286,
0.19999541342258453,
-0.17140042781829834,
-0.21003678441047668,
0.21571888029575348,
0.14824095368385315,
-0.350647509098053,
0.9248122572898865,
0.786888837814331,
-0.4864683151245117,
-0.04574041813611984,
-0.4643402099609375,
-0.1882108747959137,
-0.4770602583885193,
0.09740983694791794,
-0.4934885799884796,
-0.9063541889190674,
0.35590294003486633,
-0.0565413236618042,
0.26819711923599243,
0.24316054582595825,
0.19583582878112793,
0.21447351574897766,
0.7809922695159912,
0.6154067516326904,
-0.11132262647151947,
0.5568909645080566,
-0.047148630023002625,
0.4209803640842438,
-0.9670677781105042,
-0.10670652985572815,
-0.6249732375144958,
-0.33517971634864807,
-0.6219435930252075,
-0.6764854788780212,
0.1657637655735016,
0.3016491234302521,
0.19436730444431305,
0.40112733840942383,
-0.594532310962677,
0.7165069580078125,
0.6024156212806702,
-0.07801514118909836,
-0.005902978125959635,
-0.12448754161596298,
-0.14638899266719818,
0.12017126381397247,
-0.8090787529945374,
-0.7846317291259766,
0.9322664141654968,
0.30997881293296814,
0.03380854055285454,
0.11711382120847702,
1.0771484375,
0.1520167738199234,
-0.07032865285873413,
-1.1701430082321167,
0.3988375961780548,
-0.15105876326560974,
-0.7406067848205566,
-0.32129335403442383,
-0.10790403932332993,
-1.3414127826690674,
0.35132691264152527,
-0.32113245129585266,
-0.7540780305862427,
0.14652392268180847,
0.09226400405168533,
-0.5039244294166565,
0.29788246750831604,
-0.7269983291625977,
0.8933711051940918,
0.04508137330412865,
-0.17770586907863617,
-0.09882360696792603,
-0.6165501475334167,
-0.03910408169031143,
-0.08754866570234299,
0.28642264008522034,
0.11788424849510193,
-0.292109876871109,
1.1639444828033447,
-0.6072292327880859,
0.7665191292762756,
-0.2279621660709381,
0.1762775033712387,
0.20845051109790802,
0.040272608399391174,
0.5808354616165161,
-0.08960992097854614,
0.050584230571985245,
0.17620083689689636,
0.193773090839386,
-0.6838639378547668,
-0.6212310194969177,
0.13653479516506195,
-0.3954227566719055,
-0.5369332432746887,
-0.17003734409809113,
0.017649797722697258,
-0.1627064347267151,
0.5290626883506775,
0.2180253267288208,
0.8295213580131531,
-0.14631278812885284,
0.3040955364704132,
0.3915923535823822,
-0.03436526656150818,
0.6803439855575562,
0.01924070343375206,
-0.12072550505399704,
-0.36484408378601074,
0.8787463903427124,
0.03884321451187134,
0.1542067974805832,
0.4312954843044281,
0.45002374053001404,
-0.15419991314411163,
-1.0874814987182617,
-0.2922637164592743,
0.18701699376106262,
-0.7303358316421509,
-0.005371765233576298,
-0.5669563412666321,
-0.02648881822824478,
-0.4211374521255493,
-0.23005710542201996,
-0.3066768944263458,
-0.29838597774505615,
-0.14200864732265472,
-0.19386012852191925,
-0.06500034779310226,
0.9055061936378479,
-0.1259063184261322,
0.41625744104385376,
-0.8458444476127625,
-0.009930363856256008,
0.2709577977657318,
0.5129881501197815,
-0.044309597462415695,
-0.3665628433227539,
-0.4002862572669983,
-0.36269205808639526,
0.21190017461776733,
-0.6931856274604797,
0.03775207698345184,
0.04983360692858696,
0.29940593242645264,
0.2964862883090973,
-0.2179855853319168,
0.7061671614646912,
-0.7817890644073486,
1.1259695291519165,
0.16154302656650543,
-1.141727089881897,
0.41166120767593384,
-0.06952433288097382,
0.2772066593170166,
0.6658135056495667,
0.23111775517463684,
-1.017857313156128,
-0.023967372253537178,
-0.5373926758766174,
-1.0054107904434204,
0.5842013359069824,
0.42818450927734375,
0.39314037561416626,
-0.3488188683986664,
0.42558014392852783,
0.24254633486270905,
0.3484896421432495,
-0.6174047589302063,
-0.1470886617898941,
-0.16414478421211243,
-0.027209259569644928,
0.05827561393380165,
-0.4958902895450592,
0.15675769746303558,
-0.02528204582631588,
0.39122599363327026,
-0.058079708367586136,
0.45797744393348694,
0.047848980873823166,
-0.17767827212810516,
0.35381320118904114,
0.18093426525592804,
0.4717041850090027,
0.37782859802246094,
-0.13631431758403778,
0.38645556569099426,
0.023555969819426537,
-0.6410683393478394,
-0.0005031799082644284,
-0.21134592592716217,
-0.009210964664816856,
0.21458764374256134,
0.5640117526054382,
1.0360114574432373,
0.20684510469436646,
-0.30683133006095886,
0.6309608221054077,
-0.054111920297145844,
-0.05486874282360077,
0.16799665987491608,
-0.1387203484773636,
-0.07334141433238983,
-0.09951729327440262,
0.1784968078136444,
0.1476200670003891,
0.27365443110466003,
-0.3953014612197876,
0.21368485689163208,
0.4783457815647125,
-0.3114158809185028,
-0.4515722393989563,
0.5813526511192322,
0.4732816219329834,
-0.5007509589195251,
0.39992502331733704,
-0.2765783965587616,
-0.4571585953235626,
0.1844121366739273,
0.40055030584335327,
0.8084309697151184,
0.3003816306591034,
0.19688624143600464,
0.34210747480392456,
0.5047523379325867,
0.08797387033700943,
-0.2212708443403244,
-0.303440123796463,
-0.7340748310089111,
-0.7033110857009888,
-1.0135321617126465,
-0.1061573177576065,
-0.11188018321990967,
-0.3451603353023529,
0.32828789949417114,
-0.509022057056427,
-0.3886440396308899,
0.03536069393157959,
0.08044914156198502,
-0.679009199142456,
0.2529726028442383,
0.04659484326839447,
1.0484930276870728,
-0.6248388290405273,
0.46328479051589966,
0.4501118063926697,
-0.5405381321907043,
-0.8816353678703308,
0.10555510967969894,
-0.2710130214691162,
-0.6909421682357788,
0.8703578114509583,
0.35340094566345215,
0.1495351642370224,
0.07364588975906372,
-0.1749737560749054,
-0.9303857684135437,
0.7894462943077087,
-0.02146214433014393,
-0.19100365042686462,
-0.34173116087913513,
0.29040437936782837,
0.3689911365509033,
-0.022481953725218773,
0.0941360667347908,
0.6575456261634827,
0.500281035900116,
0.10897490382194519,
-0.8510839939117432,
0.06531334668397903,
-0.20185264945030212,
0.42102017998695374,
0.5963244438171387,
-0.4544748365879059,
0.6893123984336853,
0.2717438042163849,
-0.6779049634933472,
-0.14087434113025665,
0.4911137819290161,
-0.1606898456811905,
-0.27103668451309204,
0.7272887229919434,
0.268368124961853,
0.765432596206665,
-0.11091430485248566,
1.0570930242538452,
-0.5524457097053528,
-0.2800464928150177,
0.7968458533287048,
0.27318987250328064,
0.8533770442008972,
0.8593928813934326,
-0.19805927574634552,
0.46308574080467224,
0.6618243455886841,
0.21647754311561584,
0.18169240653514862,
0.3955003619194031,
-0.1522672176361084,
0.000053927244152873755,
-0.3445481061935425,
0.03330123424530029,
0.6419432163238525,
-0.1219322457909584,
-0.24844324588775635,
0.04902305081486702,
-0.04094194620847702,
0.18404142558574677,
-0.2022690623998642,
-0.20875100791454315,
0.8234002590179443,
-0.11177993565797806,
-0.5783215165138245,
0.3197418451309204,
0.24643296003341675,
0.9568812251091003,
-0.556061863899231,
0.30214929580688477,
-0.22176042199134827,
-0.38678181171417236,
-0.19792380928993225,
-0.27677109837532043,
0.4977625906467438,
-0.027239715680480003,
-0.06299520283937454,
-0.3426332175731659,
0.9129242300987244,
0.010773413814604282,
-0.26132896542549133,
-0.09021268784999847,
0.3255026936531067,
0.3786355257034302,
-0.12583012878894806,
-0.2843150198459625,
0.2994799017906189,
-0.3893340826034546,
-0.2171032577753067,
0.21164225041866302,
0.36342403292655945,
0.15993499755859375,
0.2586483955383301,
0.8782948851585388,
0.48889678716659546,
0.2689107656478882,
0.19332775473594666,
0.7843320965766907,
-0.6584104299545288,
-0.5621386766433716,
-1.0027439594268799,
0.6372166275978088,
-0.268569678068161,
-0.2811984419822693,
0.7257944345474243,
0.6442416310310364,
0.8223469257354736,
0.19297471642494202,
0.4964674115180969,
-0.1269024759531021,
0.07769009470939636,
-0.7025812864303589,
0.36630502343177795,
-0.33315789699554443,
0.07588212937116623,
-0.326880544424057,
-0.7044671773910522,
-0.40795639157295227,
0.4618179500102997,
-0.0782756581902504,
-0.0877932459115982,
0.8590850830078125,
0.5003310441970825,
0.2174188792705536,
-0.018946487456560135,
0.18850260972976685,
-0.43498101830482483,
0.47519591450691223,
0.19811509549617767,
0.5400865077972412,
-0.5885918736457825,
0.6325357556343079,
-0.22859330475330353,
-0.027990877628326416,
0.0718221589922905,
-0.95311039686203,
-1.1330528259277344,
-0.6240753531455994,
-0.08583156764507294,
-0.10331536084413528,
-0.15755769610404968,
1.0803700685501099,
1.0445014238357544,
-0.513064444065094,
-0.27298927307128906,
-0.48230600357055664,
-0.014761351980268955,
-0.05845080688595772,
-0.15562237799167633,
0.3224964439868927,
-0.8208150267601013,
-0.8433245420455933,
0.30753418803215027,
0.3979462683200836,
0.1846327781677246,
-0.27936825156211853,
0.06863920390605927,
-0.05966904014348984,
0.3920360207557678,
0.6813098192214966,
-0.2306288480758667,
-0.4273964464664459,
-0.5102699398994446,
-0.15248632431030273,
0.11813147366046906,
0.2293855845928192,
1.1125385761260986,
-0.6976087093353271,
0.5195062160491943,
0.6172485947608948,
0.7064921259880066,
0.451861709356308,
0.029891451820731163,
0.6948678493499756,
-1.0050733089447021,
0.4129160940647125,
0.13015101850032806,
0.28726157546043396,
0.2695910334587097,
-0.2562200725078583,
0.5320411920547485,
0.34943529963493347,
-0.29222220182418823,
-0.9739096760749817,
0.32309961318969727,
-0.6369116902351379,
-0.4488544762134552,
0.9214777946472168,
0.21658608317375183,
-0.3828611373901367,
-0.135736346244812,
-0.38800114393234253,
0.2609759569168091,
-0.24615740776062012,
0.4631250202655792,
0.9643873572349548,
-0.06396161764860153,
0.18464478850364685,
-0.20351044833660126,
0.7818130850791931,
0.4221726357936859,
-0.6295585036277771,
-0.07606620341539383,
0.2337309569120407,
0.02205524407327175,
0.37880465388298035,
0.7974511384963989,
0.04862327128648758,
-0.10719236731529236,
0.32680100202560425,
-0.07330623269081116,
0.014027082361280918,
-0.11795328557491302,
-0.2768324315547943,
0.4184335470199585,
0.42034316062927246,
-0.3749637305736542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18374v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18374v2
|
VerifiNER: Verification-augmented NER via Knowledge-grounded Reasoning with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T14:49:05 | 2024-06-08T13:01:36 |
Seoyeon Kim, Kwangwook Seo, Hyungjoo Chae, Jinyoung Yeo, Dongha Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent approaches in domain-specific named entity recognition (NER), such as
biomedical NER, have shown remarkable advances. However, they still lack of
faithfulness, producing erroneous predictions. We assume that knowledge of
entities can be useful in verifying the correctness of the predictions. Despite
the usefulness of knowledge, resolving such errors with knowledge is
nontrivial, since the knowledge itself does not directly indicate the
ground-truth label. To this end, we propose VerifiNER, a post-hoc verification
framework that identifies errors from existing NER methods using knowledge and
revises them into more faithful predictions. Our framework leverages the
reasoning abilities of large language models to adequately ground on knowledge
and the contextual information in the verification process. We validate
effectiveness of VerifiNER through extensive experiments on biomedical
datasets. The results suggest that VerifiNER can successfully verify errors
from existing models as a model-agnostic approach. Further analyses on
out-of-domain and low-resource settings show the usefulness of VerifiNER on
real-world applications.
|
[
-0.008603943511843681,
-0.8637580275535583,
0.8950371742248535,
-0.22863146662712097,
-0.014680987223982811,
0.019724469631910324,
-0.2310447096824646,
-0.49866610765457153,
0.12433291226625443,
0.5425540804862976,
-0.025175778195261955,
-0.47543925046920776,
-0.6476137638092041,
0.29478394985198975,
-0.5089188814163208,
0.9040288329124451,
-0.28655245900154114,
0.15371496975421906,
-0.6418206691741943,
-0.1852504312992096,
-0.3202834725379944,
-0.7394186854362488,
-0.4947444498538971,
-0.5968977808952332,
0.2772095203399658,
0.21705782413482666,
0.43642351031303406,
0.7733445167541504,
0.5947657823562622,
0.2660684883594513,
-0.16228169202804565,
0.4398728907108307,
-0.3858542740345001,
0.02716265432536602,
-0.5902852416038513,
-0.1888866275548935,
-0.5093923211097717,
-0.41207343339920044,
0.6684597134590149,
0.7039535045623779,
-0.10130659490823746,
0.017340827733278275,
-0.17400267720222473,
0.23813652992248535,
-0.739713728427887,
-0.1710730344057083,
-0.6917018890380859,
-0.1601732075214386,
-0.0940270721912384,
-0.072519451379776,
-0.3833067715167999,
-0.3814965486526489,
0.18763256072998047,
-0.6035855412483215,
0.34006401896476746,
0.04551771655678749,
1.3300197124481201,
0.4590967893600464,
-0.5016506910324097,
-0.05585291236639023,
-1.1169770956039429,
0.6201291680335999,
-0.5468067526817322,
0.6287838220596313,
0.5204647183418274,
0.7154363989830017,
-0.3252594769001007,
-1.010646104812622,
-0.669459342956543,
-0.2550884485244751,
-0.12581562995910645,
-0.13689014315605164,
-0.18217474222183228,
-0.06994438171386719,
0.5214686393737793,
0.3898370862007141,
-0.2590799331665039,
-0.26621583104133606,
-0.3441604673862457,
-0.48781099915504456,
0.352497935295105,
-0.1348673552274704,
0.39461323618888855,
0.22831948101520538,
-0.36176127195358276,
0.150169238448143,
-1.0278176069259644,
-0.0071404678747057915,
-0.15191256999969482,
-0.18802060186862946,
0.1599941849708557,
0.6850901246070862,
-0.34332314133644104,
0.8069319725036621,
0.40989261865615845,
-0.05187597870826721,
0.2670729160308838,
-0.2848305404186249,
-0.2656193673610687,
0.2809918224811554,
0.40266555547714233,
0.2762874960899353,
-0.17427505552768707,
-0.2535277009010315,
-0.2710355520248413,
0.19533179700374603,
0.16014167666435242,
-0.8304044604301453,
-0.3113993704319,
0.28830939531326294,
-0.2308788150548935,
-0.0296877883374691,
-0.35613617300987244,
-0.4877842366695404,
-0.6081069111824036,
-0.3375052213668823,
0.6692013144493103,
-0.6183556318283081,
-0.22308970987796783,
0.2755109667778015,
-0.06399977207183838,
0.32747307419776917,
0.6542912125587463,
-0.25736284255981445,
0.258232057094574,
0.7366252541542053,
0.4623531997203827,
0.31697577238082886,
-0.4191131889820099,
-0.6208621263504028,
0.20065897703170776,
-0.247487872838974,
0.8834406733512878,
-0.4923055171966553,
-0.17441533505916595,
-0.2915698289871216,
0.1468462496995926,
0.09841468185186386,
-0.4094417989253998,
0.639136791229248,
-0.5942977666854858,
-0.18373286724090576,
-0.6827303767204285,
-0.9002363681793213,
-0.22037333250045776,
0.6224672198295593,
-0.5025758743286133,
0.7940371036529541,
0.044560857117176056,
-0.8432982563972473,
0.7262101173400879,
-0.21701575815677643,
-0.34956324100494385,
0.2639828026294708,
-0.46213486790657043,
-0.3784339129924774,
0.06604916602373123,
0.05988186597824097,
0.2781337797641754,
-0.5015852451324463,
0.6470730900764465,
-0.34145963191986084,
-0.11360941082239151,
0.37563782930374146,
-0.0650825947523117,
0.3704707622528076,
-0.13234609365463257,
-0.3412508964538574,
0.06134195625782013,
-1.10079026222229,
0.16480876505374908,
0.021889623254537582,
-0.13725419342517853,
-0.5506830215454102,
0.15889796614646912,
-0.18958282470703125,
0.16223831474781036,
0.19619788229465485,
-0.8846582770347595,
-0.06939750164747238,
-0.3006892800331116,
0.5513412356376648,
0.34088021516799927,
-0.07705719023942947,
0.3089551329612732,
-0.4278063476085663,
0.0769147202372551,
0.0007743533933535218,
-0.12157969176769257,
0.09601858258247375,
-0.37280887365341187,
-0.7657078504562378,
-0.35316386818885803,
0.41374602913856506,
0.4403829574584961,
-0.631888210773468,
0.4900207221508026,
-0.5040816068649292,
-0.6387620568275452,
-0.24850384891033173,
-0.15588273108005524,
0.38326582312583923,
1.1189467906951904,
0.6650870442390442,
0.25702542066574097,
-0.8636893033981323,
-0.7545983791351318,
-0.2515617907047272,
-0.2132948786020279,
-0.08664609491825104,
0.40578386187553406,
0.8524782061576843,
-0.752723217010498,
1.1711552143096924,
-0.2051084041595459,
0.0047502582892775536,
0.07745175808668137,
-0.19913728535175323,
0.19580022990703583,
0.6426674127578735,
0.25349193811416626,
-0.7401198148727417,
-0.02857377380132675,
0.46453723311424255,
-0.9611862897872925,
-0.02277342975139618,
0.18025289475917816,
-0.1148858517408371,
-0.12713971734046936,
0.4937593936920166,
-0.39237549901008606,
0.4964037239551544,
0.4556373953819275,
-0.43187984824180603,
0.625903308391571,
-0.5822977423667908,
0.2822094261646271,
-0.7188895344734192,
0.3787979185581207,
-0.1115206629037857,
-0.5287010669708252,
-0.6208977103233337,
-0.28007379174232483,
0.19645754992961884,
-0.023630835115909576,
-0.07630892097949982,
0.8902305960655212,
-0.3108835518360138,
0.24090057611465454,
-0.38819554448127747,
-0.15610136091709137,
0.3633333742618561,
-0.1752142459154129,
0.48413223028182983,
0.6227765679359436,
0.5769810676574707,
-0.8075231909751892,
0.31822285056114197,
0.4524332582950592,
-0.1491595208644867,
1.0236210823059082,
-1.1380828619003296,
0.1017371118068695,
-0.3372018337249756,
0.2156580537557602,
-0.6657853722572327,
-0.6253410577774048,
0.26007574796676636,
-0.41816380620002747,
0.2349836677312851,
-0.3146374523639679,
-0.22583293914794922,
-0.3138557970523834,
0.28130173683166504,
0.5737870931625366,
0.41391631960868835,
-0.7424682378768921,
1.0354253053665161,
0.5052786469459534,
0.2681337893009186,
-0.6340259313583374,
-0.58266282081604,
-0.07429548352956772,
0.008392393589019775,
-0.7039996981620789,
0.5453221797943115,
0.14939194917678833,
-0.29417458176612854,
0.16488432884216309,
-0.337335467338562,
-0.4030715823173523,
-0.0016193368937820196,
0.4469258785247803,
0.18605875968933105,
-0.19974808394908905,
0.18246793746948242,
0.05804205685853958,
-0.36071881651878357,
-0.0060053858906030655,
-0.38375312089920044,
-0.011997057124972343,
-0.36955347657203674,
-0.5799676775932312,
-0.21118995547294617,
0.08806630969047546,
0.5758086442947388,
-0.31682702898979187,
0.6305229663848877,
0.36255547404289246,
-1.0205961465835571,
-0.006182046141475439,
-0.8032320737838745,
-0.2751559019088745,
-0.37662559747695923,
0.2542303800582886,
-0.5100885033607483,
-0.9490002393722534,
0.6964909434318542,
-0.4524741470813751,
-0.26093271374702454,
0.3621484637260437,
0.3302191197872162,
0.1942434310913086,
0.7707027792930603,
0.6001132726669312,
0.3184557855129242,
-0.2722454369068146,
0.04525476321578026,
0.32072070240974426,
-0.8699187636375427,
-0.30581995844841003,
-0.6473991274833679,
-0.022413957864046097,
-0.10374587774276733,
-0.5496430397033691,
0.315284788608551,
0.21380500495433807,
-0.3713790774345398,
0.4495677351951599,
-0.4198824465274811,
0.6246429085731506,
0.3993028700351715,
0.2830064296722412,
0.12285277992486954,
-0.2456503063440323,
-0.11553596705198288,
-0.019765038043260574,
-0.3939307928085327,
-0.8087493181228638,
0.8165058493614197,
0.2524796724319458,
0.4415619969367981,
-0.08195900917053223,
0.5030049085617065,
0.011524994857609272,
0.5493959188461304,
-0.6200886964797974,
0.3157757818698883,
0.1663162112236023,
-0.8740155100822449,
-0.15129108726978302,
-0.40372562408447266,
-0.5559735894203186,
0.06425569951534271,
-0.27518340945243835,
-0.8004598021507263,
0.5419036149978638,
0.5038298964500427,
-0.39639610052108765,
0.3158291280269623,
-0.13994301855564117,
0.9973704218864441,
-0.21022561192512512,
-0.43128544092178345,
0.11513326317071915,
-0.5873923301696777,
0.3451983630657196,
-0.23554836213588715,
0.15104882419109344,
-0.0895213857293129,
0.18315637111663818,
0.45949870347976685,
-0.9302539229393005,
0.5679725408554077,
-0.2306710034608841,
-0.07968223094940186,
0.09728628396987915,
0.05356920138001442,
0.8546845316886902,
0.29239770770072937,
-0.2436216026544571,
0.3794618248939514,
0.19279073178768158,
-0.18609113991260529,
-0.46318379044532776,
0.5820810794830322,
-0.6380122303962708,
-0.41892489790916443,
-0.3245760500431061,
0.009908155538141727,
-0.26873546838760376,
0.5953689217567444,
0.6341570019721985,
0.38291651010513306,
-0.24629554152488708,
0.23218615353107452,
0.9292662739753723,
-0.19062639772891998,
-0.33620917797088623,
0.4776290953159332,
-0.1952877640724182,
-0.8317839503288269,
0.7736334800720215,
0.01928316429257393,
-0.023619916290044785,
0.37344464659690857,
0.1852991282939911,
-0.23567292094230652,
-0.7026286125183105,
-0.5305011868476868,
0.28928133845329285,
-0.8030976057052612,
-0.3793400228023529,
-0.8897210955619812,
-0.15925392508506775,
-0.15578147768974304,
-0.2987978160381317,
-0.569646954536438,
-0.012189967557787895,
0.02432371862232685,
-0.13243135809898376,
0.5232876539230347,
0.30149003863334656,
-0.1655120551586151,
0.25092411041259766,
-0.8517597317695618,
0.2763288617134094,
0.17976169288158417,
0.29968518018722534,
-0.6143444180488586,
-0.5282233357429504,
-0.1172986850142479,
0.23854191601276398,
0.3723500072956085,
-0.8268265724182129,
0.02541535347700119,
0.24986162781715393,
0.6071690320968628,
0.3600931465625763,
0.017265433445572853,
0.6723712086677551,
-0.8395454287528992,
0.5205292701721191,
-0.005571303423494101,
-1.223315715789795,
0.6203497052192688,
-0.16860444843769073,
-0.19610154628753662,
0.7767990231513977,
0.12159518897533417,
-0.41133546829223633,
-0.17534346878528595,
-0.7313425540924072,
-0.8185944557189941,
0.291016548871994,
0.009346891194581985,
-0.1437331885099411,
-0.08003181219100952,
0.5663298964500427,
0.09252208471298218,
0.1139008179306984,
-0.35767194628715515,
-0.26543813943862915,
-0.3087427318096161,
0.07402291148900986,
0.12268313020467758,
-0.48519203066825867,
-0.20899200439453125,
-0.057277314364910126,
0.8784450888633728,
-0.15512850880622864,
0.09188662469387054,
0.6726998090744019,
-0.31143420934677124,
-0.04820391908288002,
0.14792297780513763,
0.5139579772949219,
0.7977487444877625,
-0.15050165355205536,
0.38897958397865295,
0.3924945294857025,
-0.35303136706352234,
0.37172049283981323,
0.22747555375099182,
-0.4337659776210785,
0.21648292243480682,
0.20188258588314056,
0.5639668703079224,
0.19018615782260895,
-0.6085278391838074,
0.748517632484436,
-0.1391272246837616,
-0.13188758492469788,
-0.43751275539398193,
-0.2693163752555847,
-0.0952390506863594,
0.143155038356781,
0.09944816678762436,
0.3969120383262634,
0.3213854134082794,
0.2682258188724518,
0.46178337931632996,
0.28524649143218994,
-0.5474382638931274,
-0.4485968351364136,
0.8875458240509033,
-0.03125826269388199,
0.08816278725862503,
0.3546648323535919,
-0.24627915024757385,
-0.36525967717170715,
0.5222065448760986,
0.6291514039039612,
0.6577361226081848,
-0.34713611006736755,
0.032478827983140945,
0.5960935354232788,
0.222526416182518,
-0.4103599190711975,
0.34152886271476746,
0.08549806475639343,
-1.0569370985031128,
-0.7165178656578064,
-0.5295819044113159,
-0.6090484261512756,
0.08596639335155487,
-0.49798154830932617,
0.43207505345344543,
-0.7675448656082153,
-0.48201870918273926,
0.27813461422920227,
-0.4896767735481262,
-0.637060821056366,
0.3091973066329956,
0.12202458083629608,
0.7692641615867615,
-0.7166356444358826,
0.6978386640548706,
1.2315126657485962,
-0.2433186024427414,
-0.866067111492157,
-0.3088217079639435,
0.11599524319171906,
-0.4384628236293793,
0.8713973760604858,
0.15416023135185242,
-0.2757086753845215,
0.06610939651727676,
-0.42087438702583313,
-1.0330957174301147,
0.9329118132591248,
0.5019723773002625,
-0.5350776314735413,
0.21667775511741638,
-0.1678447127342224,
0.45807573199272156,
0.00037337015965022147,
0.21690620481967926,
0.1886998564004898,
0.5021107196807861,
0.40588465332984924,
-0.9244433641433716,
0.31257471442222595,
-0.2766181528568268,
-0.02715303562581539,
0.1785804182291031,
0.048493627458810806,
0.8331131935119629,
-0.2379632294178009,
-0.27371612191200256,
-0.072531558573246,
0.8399901390075684,
0.5947756171226501,
0.4776105582714081,
0.24939095973968506,
0.6236066818237305,
1.3598358631134033,
-0.15047290921211243,
0.8770560622215271,
-0.35708221793174744,
0.4276849925518036,
1.1512855291366577,
-0.8960923552513123,
0.5192140340805054,
0.49161073565483093,
-0.05857662484049797,
0.4657817482948303,
0.14344064891338348,
0.04340792074799538,
0.2808762490749359,
0.3299762010574341,
-0.3858396112918854,
-0.5929120182991028,
-0.3168666958808899,
-0.6014276146888733,
0.32092031836509705,
0.45517498254776,
-0.26948311924934387,
-0.3640668988227844,
0.14009644091129303,
0.18828971683979034,
0.10225240886211395,
-0.2692224979400635,
0.5656300187110901,
-0.13521476089954376,
-0.29830262064933777,
0.6601760983467102,
0.07223398983478546,
0.41906607151031494,
-0.3833303153514862,
-0.2678411602973938,
0.19489547610282898,
0.6968221068382263,
-0.20625346899032593,
-0.32191625237464905,
0.49570587277412415,
-0.07707791030406952,
-0.42256826162338257,
-0.01375745888799429,
1.3332767486572266,
-0.28600385785102844,
-0.48410025238990784,
0.12953488528728485,
0.512226939201355,
0.022280734032392502,
-0.19297221302986145,
-0.2932802140712738,
-0.07545063644647598,
-0.36757510900497437,
0.09016638249158859,
-0.1710984855890274,
0.7655113339424133,
-0.06679227948188782,
0.574530303478241,
0.7347025275230408,
0.17641150951385498,
-0.31656163930892944,
-0.29363927245140076,
0.7352812886238098,
-0.5790508389472961,
-0.2339484691619873,
-0.9084486961364746,
0.4824697971343994,
-0.28315746784210205,
-0.10095331072807312,
0.7670271396636963,
0.5243157148361206,
0.8134768009185791,
-0.1198701560497284,
0.9378008842468262,
-0.16631166636943817,
0.7387991547584534,
-0.41015493869781494,
0.7046084403991699,
-0.29495927691459656,
0.20166073739528656,
-0.049150027334690094,
-0.43400049209594727,
-0.6392975449562073,
0.8188618421554565,
-0.6514771580696106,
-0.12510398030281067,
0.667680025100708,
0.7170789241790771,
-0.13408885896205902,
0.007609806023538113,
0.3698555827140808,
0.20799578726291656,
0.3260572552680969,
0.604703426361084,
1.1880091428756714,
-0.5519164204597473,
0.007250314112752676,
-0.12929311394691467,
-0.3127473294734955,
-0.30521684885025024,
-1.1458507776260376,
-0.8053138256072998,
-0.2969728708267212,
-0.7318702936172485,
-0.824645459651947,
0.30921757221221924,
0.8684989213943481,
0.7390551567077637,
-0.8983835577964783,
0.370716392993927,
-0.2995685935020447,
0.2090011090040207,
-0.3283842206001282,
-0.07284507155418396,
0.33717894554138184,
-0.09278975427150726,
-0.3038659393787384,
0.42945873737335205,
0.2192530333995819,
0.11336080729961395,
0.1710406243801117,
-0.13112285733222961,
0.1097322627902031,
-0.058638934046030045,
0.38167354464530945,
0.6461023688316345,
-0.6864372491836548,
-0.46367964148521423,
0.12137342244386673,
-0.22353777289390564,
-0.042721040546894073,
0.7493212819099426,
-0.9896305203437805,
0.2145693451166153,
0.590208888053894,
0.9578132033348083,
-0.018576281145215034,
-0.0010804524645209312,
0.6161946654319763,
-0.4108291268348694,
-0.2918740212917328,
0.22015975415706635,
0.750999927520752,
0.46459752321243286,
-0.5861647725105286,
0.34342247247695923,
0.3081216812133789,
-0.7579224109649658,
-0.9509921073913574,
0.13331392407417297,
-0.6952846646308899,
0.16396936774253845,
1.271230697631836,
-0.467012882232666,
-0.4479031264781952,
-0.25991547107696533,
-0.08902797102928162,
0.21098339557647705,
-0.012143013998866081,
0.40221545100212097,
0.5908052921295166,
0.15111012756824493,
0.08734986931085587,
-0.30411508679389954,
0.5967682600021362,
0.23578505218029022,
-0.889892578125,
0.13590729236602783,
0.8161406517028809,
0.571516752243042,
0.3524996042251587,
0.7676787376403809,
-0.17380142211914062,
0.3467964828014374,
-0.05780608206987381,
0.16178444027900696,
-0.21637146174907684,
-0.32799434661865234,
-0.27484825253486633,
-0.06396155059337616,
0.23997673392295837,
0.06572344899177551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18344v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18344v2
|
Focus on Your Question! Interpreting and Mitigating Toxic CoT Problems in Commonsense Reasoning
| 2024-02-28T14:09:02 | 2024-06-27T06:54:58 |
Jiachun Li, Pengfei Cao, Chenhao Wang, Zhuoran Jin, Yubo Chen, Daojian Zeng, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models exhibit high-level commonsense reasoning abilities,
especially with enhancement methods like Chain-of-Thought (CoT). However, we
find these CoT-like methods lead to a considerable number of originally correct
answers turning wrong, which we define as the Toxic CoT problem. To interpret
and mitigate this problem, we first utilize attribution tracing and causal
tracing methods to probe the internal working mechanism of the LLM during CoT
reasoning. Through comparisons, we prove that the model exhibits information
loss from the question over the shallow attention layers when generating
rationales or answers. Based on the probing findings, we design a novel method
called RIDERS (Residual decodIng and sERial-position Swap), which compensates
for the information deficit in the model from both decoding and serial-position
perspectives. Through extensive experiments on multiple commonsense reasoning
benchmarks, we validate that this method not only significantly eliminates
Toxic CoT problems (decreased by 23.6%), but also effectively improves the
model's overall commonsense reasoning performance (increased by 5.5%).
|
[
-0.22505776584148407,
-0.7924251556396484,
0.9166315197944641,
-0.0791812539100647,
-0.37287551164627075,
-0.015119829215109348,
0.011489839293062687,
-0.5189489722251892,
-0.14037473499774933,
0.9477484226226807,
-0.42707154154777527,
-0.42177674174308777,
-0.6198214888572693,
-0.006875811144709587,
-0.38569536805152893,
0.9903085231781006,
0.07530665397644043,
-0.21512094140052795,
-0.2171526998281479,
-0.16218781471252441,
-0.6554827094078064,
-0.6690772771835327,
-1.0117824077606201,
-0.10657976567745209,
0.9226856231689453,
0.47897690534591675,
0.7951268553733826,
0.3563210368156433,
0.37690529227256775,
0.28995341062545776,
-0.7310064435005188,
0.27602553367614746,
-0.9739319682121277,
-0.05384896695613861,
-0.4459910988807678,
-0.601304292678833,
-0.2956010401248932,
-0.3132193982601166,
0.39389917254447937,
0.4570835828781128,
-0.04454823210835457,
0.10315138846635818,
0.03276950120925903,
0.6709463596343994,
-1.0958930253982544,
-0.1612822413444519,
-0.7030526399612427,
-0.13883012533187866,
-0.1698732078075409,
-0.5415165424346924,
-0.9585773944854736,
-0.17067307233810425,
-0.22233447432518005,
-0.6328511238098145,
0.12018320709466934,
0.1072460487484932,
0.6006051301956177,
0.29148516058921814,
-0.9051269888877869,
-0.20628999173641205,
-0.6188150644302368,
1.0070732831954956,
-0.9023427367210388,
0.006748526357114315,
0.46436378359794617,
0.10248814523220062,
-0.12100468575954437,
-0.49007996916770935,
-0.6247084736824036,
-0.26576343178749084,
-0.260640412569046,
0.0831712856888771,
0.017710890620946884,
0.023217542096972466,
0.27098849415779114,
-0.14112836122512817,
-0.3659301698207855,
0.051726482808589935,
-0.5165886878967285,
-0.42546454071998596,
0.730888307094574,
0.49975472688674927,
0.37088364362716675,
-0.07814181596040726,
-0.7987685203552246,
0.011107548139989376,
-0.9170718193054199,
-0.12493812292814255,
0.2808283567428589,
0.16055245697498322,
-0.01132097840309143,
0.38951727747917175,
0.005079186055809259,
0.7651587128639221,
-0.32494688034057617,
0.20334312319755554,
-0.007038631942123175,
-0.35238608717918396,
-0.09248611330986023,
-0.024373430758714676,
0.4597482681274414,
0.5329144597053528,
0.23452121019363403,
-0.1632373183965683,
-0.2446189522743225,
0.016446996480226517,
0.29801464080810547,
-0.39927107095718384,
-0.10578615218400955,
0.3634691536426544,
-0.40446215867996216,
-0.726094126701355,
-0.3431299924850464,
-0.9210231304168701,
-0.5733550786972046,
-0.3775361478328705,
0.36808183789253235,
-0.23635932803153992,
-0.6270977854728699,
0.17802682518959045,
-0.33171626925468445,
0.2814251482486725,
0.3774515390396118,
-0.7190188765525818,
0.2607609033584595,
0.5887575149536133,
0.7562870383262634,
-0.24832378327846527,
-0.12018747627735138,
-0.6159524917602539,
0.5654005408287048,
-0.3975681662559509,
1.1815297603607178,
-0.5171457529067993,
-0.34727632999420166,
-0.18599599599838257,
-0.08976152539253235,
-0.10853911936283112,
-0.6420920491218567,
0.5556755661964417,
-0.5224613547325134,
-0.20564253628253937,
-0.8117368817329407,
-0.2659844160079956,
-0.06657075136899948,
0.3380380868911743,
-0.6608943343162537,
0.6912137866020203,
-0.2267286777496338,
-1.0363186597824097,
0.08271808177232742,
-0.5486363172531128,
-0.26865771412849426,
-0.28038904070854187,
0.3080151379108429,
-0.11474699527025223,
0.02761237323284149,
0.15669038891792297,
0.02490936405956745,
-0.2849271595478058,
0.2164086401462555,
-0.40481388568878174,
-0.45149773359298706,
0.5776907205581665,
-0.6750386953353882,
1.0513845682144165,
0.4393601715564728,
-0.16153274476528168,
0.18713529407978058,
-0.511432409286499,
-0.12131761014461517,
-0.06484626978635788,
0.1704406589269638,
-0.478867769241333,
0.11564744263887405,
0.10367231070995331,
0.2549839913845062,
-0.13526032865047455,
-0.4128158688545227,
-0.27598878741264343,
-0.24253220856189728,
0.5109767317771912,
1.1964911222457886,
0.4640858769416809,
0.32052457332611084,
-0.542931079864502,
0.3919637203216553,
0.3085585832595825,
0.47195470333099365,
0.3506219983100891,
-0.510456383228302,
-0.6310470104217529,
-0.038599833846092224,
-0.22282153367996216,
0.302961528301239,
-0.7767249941825867,
-0.06709971278905869,
0.0019444465870037675,
-0.24389374256134033,
-0.0775533989071846,
-0.20559988915920258,
0.5466554760932922,
0.8806377649307251,
0.5572416186332703,
-0.12095211446285248,
0.026166310533881187,
-0.6682639122009277,
-0.4854027330875397,
-0.14650936424732208,
0.2980843186378479,
0.1621243953704834,
0.38354963064193726,
-0.174431711435318,
0.7290319800376892,
-0.6939103603363037,
-0.10802716761827469,
-0.10268311202526093,
0.3070818781852722,
-0.11751970648765564,
0.513493001461029,
0.31566911935806274,
-0.7930710911750793,
-0.24110029637813568,
-0.11473250389099121,
-0.4462070167064667,
-0.26714056730270386,
-0.24225713312625885,
-0.6359438896179199,
0.21382740139961243,
0.660105288028717,
-0.45124149322509766,
0.4254136085510254,
0.1638941615819931,
-0.566329300403595,
0.7784667611122131,
-0.05934179201722145,
0.16597674787044525,
-0.502013087272644,
0.2768241763114929,
-0.3595926761627197,
-0.10784300416707993,
-0.5881826281547546,
0.13088037073612213,
-0.02879350632429123,
-0.02286328375339508,
-0.8284751772880554,
0.7027885317802429,
-0.4018920361995697,
0.1328117549419403,
-0.3571004271507263,
0.6055099964141846,
0.23711496591567993,
0.5830549597740173,
-0.17228963971138,
0.6689845323562622,
0.3028845191001892,
-0.6334808468818665,
0.2728460431098938,
0.29436585307121277,
0.11959241330623627,
0.4670625329017639,
-0.4204236567020416,
0.21047230064868927,
-0.42093488574028015,
0.259432852268219,
-1.2111554145812988,
0.09867462515830994,
0.22538456320762634,
-0.33622145652770996,
0.06788075715303421,
-0.16156332194805145,
-0.580603301525116,
-0.29988279938697815,
-0.2784089148044586,
0.5929058790206909,
0.3003479242324829,
-0.4954052269458771,
0.4440905749797821,
0.2552247643470764,
0.033476751297712326,
-0.7496843934059143,
-0.8777028322219849,
-0.11911441385746002,
-0.36249321699142456,
-0.5149469375610352,
-0.09055675566196442,
0.02775384671986103,
-0.38720011711120605,
0.23158790171146393,
-0.38446369767189026,
-0.2725223898887634,
0.10792557895183563,
-0.26251497864723206,
0.42421168088912964,
-0.029009826481342316,
0.43469786643981934,
0.2167825847864151,
-0.5811794400215149,
0.3217332661151886,
0.17909175157546997,
0.540330171585083,
0.0027955404948443174,
-0.3146516978740692,
-0.38005396723747253,
0.3856649696826935,
0.8146891593933105,
-0.3916659653186798,
0.8367615938186646,
0.3401091992855072,
-0.038739435374736786,
-0.2637506425380707,
-0.48169228434562683,
-0.26173433661460876,
-0.535539448261261,
0.20780397951602936,
-0.15913772583007812,
-0.39774289727211,
0.714739978313446,
0.011004332453012466,
-0.22032786905765533,
0.5453527569770813,
0.5306100845336914,
-0.05448070168495178,
0.8726591467857361,
0.2368181049823761,
0.01435557659715414,
0.22784365713596344,
-0.4094817042350769,
0.28168684244155884,
-1.0318714380264282,
-0.20962847769260406,
-0.32490840554237366,
-0.24434515833854675,
-0.349619597196579,
-0.5038831830024719,
0.5959842801094055,
-0.15538495779037476,
-0.6763591766357422,
0.1522449105978012,
-0.5942011475563049,
0.8605349659919739,
0.19132252037525177,
0.6732911467552185,
0.5158081650733948,
-0.4706675410270691,
-0.08455851674079895,
0.4339781105518341,
-0.6540564298629761,
-0.5598412752151489,
1.0658520460128784,
0.2196732759475708,
0.8224190473556519,
0.1998412311077118,
0.574182391166687,
0.09122017025947571,
0.6294180154800415,
-0.4030298888683319,
0.7027385830879211,
-0.20285741984844208,
-1.0214924812316895,
-0.26249754428863525,
-0.6240079998970032,
-0.6185667514801025,
0.37059932947158813,
-0.07248673588037491,
-0.735105574131012,
0.30110183358192444,
0.3551001250743866,
-0.3392832279205322,
0.60804682970047,
-0.9762731194496155,
0.9280464053153992,
-0.20933739840984344,
-0.8502016067504883,
-0.5456618666648865,
-0.7119894027709961,
0.7321898937225342,
0.05697740614414215,
0.4427627623081207,
-0.10249775648117065,
-0.11439144611358643,
0.680902898311615,
-0.4000585675239563,
1.061488389968872,
-0.23292194306850433,
-0.2997143864631653,
0.5946562886238098,
0.09370268136262894,
0.6138407588005066,
0.0003526849905028939,
-0.06849461048841476,
-0.07058669626712799,
0.25720274448394775,
-0.6839121580123901,
-0.5527223348617554,
0.7042230367660522,
-0.6671074628829956,
-0.6139971017837524,
-0.5101763010025024,
-0.654407799243927,
-0.3122031092643738,
0.07993848621845245,
0.2692326307296753,
0.6238262057304382,
0.2255582958459854,
-0.1324537694454193,
0.6391681432723999,
-0.568417489528656,
0.2828938663005829,
0.4429771304130554,
-0.04468029364943504,
-0.2627538740634918,
0.8263267278671265,
-0.08728738129138947,
1.0055335760116577,
0.26025599241256714,
0.3666333258152008,
-0.4239383339881897,
-0.5218230485916138,
-0.11354146897792816,
0.5152358412742615,
-1.1207863092422485,
-0.43322885036468506,
-0.5218672156333923,
-0.04724997282028198,
-0.0961323007941246,
-0.26137274503707886,
-0.3777654469013214,
-0.2529066801071167,
-0.2570910155773163,
-0.15257258713245392,
0.37872347235679626,
0.5909976959228516,
-0.009041770361363888,
0.2532646954059601,
-0.7463763952255249,
0.4948200285434723,
0.2446029633283615,
0.47799116373062134,
0.5037890076637268,
-0.5139226317405701,
-0.004086393862962723,
0.2572025656700134,
-0.5423608422279358,
-1.1083414554595947,
0.2926257848739624,
-0.5199177265167236,
0.5984503626823425,
0.3267154097557068,
0.4695587158203125,
0.8885980844497681,
-0.16271694004535675,
0.7433769106864929,
0.18210344016551971,
-1.0676023960113525,
0.43900391459465027,
-0.3243131935596466,
-0.05007830262184143,
0.38144394755363464,
0.25374868512153625,
-0.47159650921821594,
-0.8659170866012573,
-0.5728856921195984,
-0.9740963578224182,
0.5779155492782593,
0.3001227080821991,
0.07852188497781754,
-0.2923250198364258,
0.230681911110878,
-0.07175478339195251,
-0.22545315325260162,
-0.7292198538780212,
-0.022103723138570786,
0.12920409440994263,
-0.061230991035699844,
0.08605799823999405,
-0.45597949624061584,
-0.24485985934734344,
-0.09580352157354355,
0.6359258890151978,
0.12538233399391174,
0.24261246621608734,
0.42387399077415466,
-0.24236902594566345,
-0.33835867047309875,
0.2864249050617218,
0.7942599058151245,
0.7615499496459961,
-0.1341424435377121,
0.3835846781730652,
0.39134567975997925,
-0.2976568639278412,
0.13013942539691925,
-0.44915446639060974,
-0.025316184386610985,
-0.35646653175354004,
0.5828753709793091,
0.4734886586666107,
0.3193521797657013,
-0.8495151996612549,
0.5297156572341919,
0.30928516387939453,
0.09584804624319077,
-0.14782381057739258,
0.09622053802013397,
0.19741517305374146,
0.08617611974477768,
0.1515175998210907,
0.2911717891693115,
0.2505783140659332,
-0.6739590167999268,
0.22329512238502502,
0.3560250699520111,
-0.2545683979988098,
-0.03929715231060982,
0.7354579567909241,
0.42392435669898987,
0.03141484782099724,
0.6294163465499878,
0.10707256197929382,
-0.577652633190155,
0.9512527585029602,
0.6465753316879272,
0.7132251858711243,
0.037306156009435654,
0.2628001868724823,
0.41732457280158997,
0.31311583518981934,
0.003317294642329216,
0.09679938107728958,
-0.00010141945676878095,
-0.7245115637779236,
-0.6465534567832947,
-0.06286899745464325,
-0.5035348534584045,
-0.0616813525557518,
-0.838117778301239,
0.3409571945667267,
-0.26387226581573486,
-0.025047169998288155,
-0.2424936443567276,
-0.2900177240371704,
-0.2500540614128113,
0.09913002699613571,
0.16155952215194702,
0.8738948702812195,
-1.1541427373886108,
0.5748336911201477,
0.09709851443767548,
-0.7421379685401917,
-0.7164501547813416,
0.24580079317092896,
-0.05212930962443352,
-0.8469061851501465,
0.7389620542526245,
0.01711939089000225,
-0.45337632298469543,
0.00024210214905906469,
-0.8532429337501526,
-0.7827868461608887,
0.9431947469711304,
0.2784633934497833,
-0.45487895607948303,
0.20400400459766388,
0.09280996769666672,
0.5112900137901306,
0.1563446968793869,
0.32328683137893677,
0.5217344164848328,
0.4868360757827759,
0.24491249024868011,
-0.7836977243423462,
0.32997432351112366,
-0.0005790690192952752,
-0.05174189805984497,
0.30358001589775085,
-0.7754740715026855,
0.6764134764671326,
-0.4379645586013794,
-0.28451457619667053,
0.06270520389080048,
0.06303471326828003,
0.4253101646900177,
0.6482018232345581,
0.6319310665130615,
0.3806789517402649,
0.7512151002883911,
0.217877596616745,
1.0808191299438477,
0.0438772514462471,
0.46270090341567993,
1.0993026494979858,
-0.32747000455856323,
0.8382871747016907,
0.6183164119720459,
0.027067314833402634,
0.48458898067474365,
0.21472498774528503,
0.4036683440208435,
0.7453567981719971,
0.38425639271736145,
-0.4610777497291565,
-0.22041574120521545,
0.0999235138297081,
-0.3242844045162201,
0.13499656319618225,
0.2768373489379883,
-0.1613123118877411,
-0.2869696021080017,
0.241688534617424,
0.1252351552248001,
0.1797870695590973,
-0.3764854967594147,
0.6889162659645081,
0.020580295473337173,
-0.5768554210662842,
0.9515597224235535,
-0.35218364000320435,
0.39071106910705566,
-0.32038038969039917,
-0.020921265706419945,
-0.4384806752204895,
0.22444383800029755,
-0.08835673332214355,
-0.9700914025306702,
0.6910322308540344,
-0.09560912102460861,
0.202297180891037,
-0.3604757487773895,
0.7027496099472046,
-0.3065359890460968,
-0.3336189091205597,
0.35232409834861755,
0.1676168292760849,
0.1712408810853958,
-0.05107171833515167,
-0.4644237160682678,
0.23217958211898804,
-0.05375971272587776,
-0.028768541291356087,
0.01860189251601696,
0.7054949402809143,
-0.1715053766965866,
0.9223966598510742,
0.6752378940582275,
0.06258605420589447,
0.10104796290397644,
-0.029601579532027245,
1.2958124876022339,
-0.8709754347801208,
-0.39398884773254395,
-0.7368502616882324,
0.7952523231506348,
-0.20658765733242035,
-0.22884492576122284,
0.25473740696907043,
0.39179182052612305,
0.5543224215507507,
-0.24627351760864258,
0.4477171003818512,
0.2349361926317215,
0.5153840780258179,
-0.7611621618270874,
0.8563764691352844,
-0.37558045983314514,
0.6600652933120728,
-0.2517210841178894,
-0.48388585448265076,
-0.39344465732574463,
0.3960959315299988,
-0.6080749034881592,
-0.12087012082338333,
1.1193565130233765,
1.0195575952529907,
-0.0030293555464595556,
0.04651157185435295,
0.26326635479927063,
0.6495509147644043,
0.4837125539779663,
0.825173020362854,
1.0991140604019165,
-0.2637912929058075,
0.7506111860275269,
-0.2703890800476074,
-0.29017141461372375,
-0.04735441878437996,
-0.8457220792770386,
-0.7339170575141907,
-0.3296613395214081,
-0.2598651647567749,
-0.3469831049442291,
0.2792544960975647,
0.2819516360759735,
0.28407520055770874,
-0.7643945813179016,
0.04726778343319893,
-0.4960041046142578,
0.5169588327407837,
-0.36353495717048645,
-0.309325248003006,
0.48609280586242676,
-0.7019673585891724,
-0.25589412450790405,
-0.19143247604370117,
0.020936360582709312,
-0.2769431173801422,
0.09182055294513702,
0.03029518574476242,
-0.3243752419948578,
0.14052510261535645,
0.7509737610816956,
0.028484003618359566,
-0.7621830105781555,
-0.6631296277046204,
-0.07132600247859955,
-0.08497516065835953,
-0.11547522246837616,
0.9583351016044617,
-0.750633716583252,
0.43863505125045776,
0.44356420636177063,
0.09526637941598892,
0.5400790572166443,
0.09965141117572784,
0.46259066462516785,
-0.2865976095199585,
0.3175867795944214,
0.525049090385437,
0.09531918913125992,
0.016149505972862244,
-0.5728738307952881,
0.41856709122657776,
0.2947063744068146,
-0.5735474824905396,
-1.002745509147644,
0.36263635754585266,
-1.2625889778137207,
-0.5044587850570679,
1.4564846754074097,
0.08399147540330887,
-0.2436896413564682,
-0.39464715123176575,
-0.5675807595252991,
0.34944382309913635,
-0.043409451842308044,
0.8872339129447937,
0.5700053572654724,
-0.1681569218635559,
-0.2196238934993744,
-0.5780148506164551,
0.32975903153419495,
0.4246336817741394,
-0.8206166625022888,
0.6157373785972595,
0.5172280669212341,
0.4796435236930847,
0.044713664799928665,
0.8406692743301392,
-0.472179651260376,
0.2861592471599579,
0.14286930859088898,
-0.38611677289009094,
-0.005972458980977535,
-0.1341761350631714,
0.07471569627523422,
-0.08233333379030228,
0.04821818321943283,
-0.2362985908985138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18334v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18334v2
|
Learning to Generate Instruction Tuning Datasets for Zero-Shot Task Adaptation
| 2024-02-28T13:54:57 | 2024-06-06T13:50:26 |
Nihal V. Nayak, Yiyang Nan, Avi Trost, Stephen H. Bach
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We introduce Bonito, an open-source model for conditional task generation
that converts unannotated text into task-specific training datasets for
instruction tuning. We aim to enable zero-shot task adaptation of large
language models on users' specialized, private data. We train Bonito by
fine-tuning a pretrained large language model on a new large-scale dataset with
1.65M examples created by remixing existing instruction tuning datasets into
meta-templates. The meta-templates for a dataset produce training examples
where the input is the unannotated text and the task attribute and the output
consists of the instruction and the response. We use Bonito to generate
synthetic tasks for seven datasets from specialized domains with unannotated
text across three task types -- yes-no question answering, extractive question
answering, and natural language inference -- and adapt language models. We show
that Bonito significantly improves the average performance of pretrained and
instruction tuned models over the de facto self supervised baseline. For
example, adapting Mistral-Instruct-v2 and instruction tuned variants of Mistral
and Llama2 with Bonito improves the strong zero-shot performance by 22.1 F1
points whereas the next word prediction objective undoes some of the benefits
of instruction tuning and reduces the average performance by 0.8 F1 points. We
conduct additional experiments with Bonito to understand the effects of the
domain, the size of the training set, and the choice of alternative synthetic
task generators. Overall, we show that learning with synthetic instruction
tuning datasets is an effective way to adapt language models to new domains.
The model, dataset, and code are available at
https://github.com/BatsResearch/bonito.
|
[
-0.02470303140580654,
-0.6596550941467285,
0.33742013573646545,
0.026036271825432777,
-0.25498345494270325,
-0.20872826874256134,
-0.5745052695274353,
-0.3626898527145386,
-0.1776542067527771,
0.8005778789520264,
-0.6120367050170898,
-0.7612513303756714,
-0.5817103385925293,
0.1330866515636444,
-0.09823814034461975,
1.524222731590271,
0.10261261463165283,
-0.029336106032133102,
-0.07928582280874252,
0.11421561986207962,
-0.9089748859405518,
-0.15650880336761475,
-0.6951731443405151,
-0.09757433086633682,
0.3850262761116028,
0.6698116660118103,
0.23596613109111786,
0.6819350123405457,
0.046063609421253204,
0.2804618775844574,
0.7265738248825073,
0.29540368914604187,
-0.6878778338432312,
0.2459312379360199,
-0.4409671127796173,
-0.9266010522842407,
-0.47488391399383545,
-0.21426528692245483,
0.4031424820423126,
0.46441972255706787,
0.20237860083580017,
0.18235847353935242,
0.007225493434816599,
0.47334128618240356,
-0.8858788013458252,
0.3020226061344147,
-1.1833443641662598,
-0.13002261519432068,
-0.23372246325016022,
-0.7742092609405518,
-0.5559755563735962,
-0.09120111912488937,
-0.22360703349113464,
-0.8519607782363892,
0.7484520077705383,
-0.1366407424211502,
0.6741379499435425,
0.5955214500427246,
-0.3627360165119171,
-0.22057697176933289,
-0.7840627431869507,
0.9617457985877991,
-0.6835042238235474,
0.30922365188598633,
0.4669095575809479,
0.21955056488513947,
-0.36179500818252563,
-0.43719908595085144,
-0.354582279920578,
-0.13109509646892548,
0.1787315160036087,
0.33473876118659973,
0.025669263675808907,
0.18583229184150696,
0.14006619155406952,
0.16121338307857513,
-0.5299900770187378,
0.14108029007911682,
-0.41339072585105896,
0.024187013506889343,
0.6844660639762878,
0.10884536057710648,
0.27468061447143555,
0.1258397251367569,
-0.20239603519439697,
-0.12688656151294708,
-0.7926267385482788,
0.1761135458946228,
0.44674912095069885,
0.46252524852752686,
0.016241848468780518,
0.40635842084884644,
-0.31739485263824463,
1.1540206670761108,
0.15476055443286896,
-0.12966963648796082,
-0.0137755973264575,
-0.21152104437351227,
-0.36912187933921814,
0.37599143385887146,
0.6441007852554321,
0.3134520649909973,
0.44742655754089355,
-0.45876938104629517,
-0.15381886065006256,
0.12582437694072723,
0.6915248036384583,
-0.8133360147476196,
-0.4966602623462677,
0.04479905217885971,
0.2523234784603119,
-0.12990084290504456,
-0.14263604581356049,
-0.6406036019325256,
-0.13860125839710236,
-0.4366547167301178,
0.6401503086090088,
-0.47160932421684265,
0.24405452609062195,
0.5286338329315186,
-0.20734348893165588,
0.12130879610776901,
0.3026577830314636,
-1.1579859256744385,
0.35631030797958374,
0.6018573045730591,
0.6897159218788147,
-0.03902542218565941,
-0.3254844546318054,
-0.7683560252189636,
0.3574404716491699,
-0.5012643933296204,
0.95816570520401,
-0.6504504680633545,
-0.3506883978843689,
-0.08766555786132812,
0.48038652539253235,
-0.43125903606414795,
-0.38277941942214966,
0.5610201358795166,
-0.3034566342830658,
0.1661081165075302,
-0.021732114255428314,
-0.6240170001983643,
-0.1385679543018341,
-0.02517755888402462,
-0.3811761140823364,
0.6906083822250366,
0.15208514034748077,
-0.3508792221546173,
0.3962996304035187,
-0.8152798414230347,
-0.7801971435546875,
0.1859923154115677,
-0.19149059057235718,
-0.19224797189235687,
0.3155559003353119,
0.2187221199274063,
0.5666595697402954,
-0.3067670464515686,
-0.1031399741768837,
-0.05173986777663231,
-0.5542781949043274,
-0.034628190100193024,
-0.21908451616764069,
0.6494315266609192,
-0.16826468706130981,
-0.5572168231010437,
0.06105777248740196,
-0.6870843172073364,
0.16680896282196045,
0.12995274364948273,
-0.20283062756061554,
-0.3736284375190735,
-0.02374580316245556,
-0.4402979910373688,
-0.21110594272613525,
0.2646539509296417,
-0.64023357629776,
0.376382052898407,
-0.5685691237449646,
0.24825412034988403,
0.6223970651626587,
0.33811095356941223,
0.31725671887397766,
-0.2982015311717987,
0.6386467814445496,
-0.04253452271223068,
0.10827429592609406,
-0.4145865738391876,
-0.5275152921676636,
-0.8977276682853699,
-0.18949636816978455,
0.4418455958366394,
0.5855433344841003,
-0.9446024298667908,
0.39220234751701355,
-0.39547601342201233,
-0.34042832255363464,
-0.6902928352355957,
0.32639095187187195,
0.6268857717514038,
0.6976827383041382,
0.43488991260528564,
-0.27614665031433105,
-0.4976537525653839,
-0.7889360785484314,
-0.2840975224971771,
0.3171096742153168,
-0.15309105813503265,
0.20493055880069733,
0.31120654940605164,
0.12057903409004211,
0.621465265750885,
-0.5818778872489929,
-0.5072175860404968,
0.008337482810020447,
0.3194449841976166,
0.05686403438448906,
0.5047035813331604,
0.6721031069755554,
-0.45878154039382935,
-0.5825691223144531,
0.28605756163597107,
-0.43524861335754395,
0.00478755310177803,
-0.2833678126335144,
-0.28291645646095276,
0.26496151089668274,
0.17219635844230652,
-0.3371143043041229,
0.2659696936607361,
0.6334338784217834,
-0.11874736845493317,
0.37252330780029297,
-0.3708912134170532,
0.3458267152309418,
-1.1655735969543457,
0.006838349159806967,
0.049918998032808304,
-0.3386766016483307,
-0.7477803230285645,
-0.12292604893445969,
0.05264126509428024,
-0.23422913253307343,
-0.35306957364082336,
0.4950121343135834,
-0.36591532826423645,
-0.03895173594355583,
-0.5337933301925659,
0.04542750492691994,
0.11759885400533676,
0.8338043093681335,
0.12012200802564621,
1.0092079639434814,
0.7554178237915039,
-0.8300603032112122,
0.07160025835037231,
0.2850155532360077,
-0.5141895413398743,
0.25687381625175476,
-0.7595049142837524,
0.37284737825393677,
-0.0369303859770298,
0.030866678804159164,
-0.7464381456375122,
-0.32530477643013,
0.289619505405426,
-0.4822143614292145,
0.5296486020088196,
-0.45954158902168274,
-0.29801613092422485,
0.017065003514289856,
-0.13051769137382507,
0.07334683835506439,
0.5558556914329529,
-0.400892436504364,
-0.06351962685585022,
0.2882445454597473,
-0.11929351091384888,
-0.5642880201339722,
-0.489541620016098,
0.0010446623200550675,
0.13546127080917358,
-0.007840186357498169,
0.5672242641448975,
-0.18331921100616455,
0.4203442931175232,
0.06439097225666046,
-0.19664889574050903,
-0.2250254601240158,
0.241267591714859,
0.3561517000198364,
0.20101483166217804,
-0.2364322692155838,
0.07305176556110382,
0.5934727191925049,
0.004433836322277784,
-0.16101869940757751,
-0.4775928258895874,
0.37494587898254395,
0.21013034880161285,
-0.015551898628473282,
-0.4539811909198761,
-0.0015793116763234138,
0.32954809069633484,
-0.3950417637825012,
0.7077821493148804,
0.44920796155929565,
-0.3024154007434845,
-0.7319632172584534,
-0.043233804404735565,
-0.21002255380153656,
-0.46427857875823975,
0.32893797755241394,
-0.44960349798202515,
-0.7193514108657837,
-0.10203016549348831,
-0.01707148551940918,
0.5422256588935852,
0.17099058628082275,
0.6540291905403137,
0.06188679859042168,
0.8820605874061584,
0.7339646220207214,
0.16690276563167572,
0.5600587725639343,
-0.319527804851532,
0.2766827344894409,
-0.698418378829956,
-0.07860027253627777,
-0.48007145524024963,
-0.3584248125553131,
-0.6001691222190857,
-0.47947797179222107,
0.24822841584682465,
0.13450345396995544,
0.10334482043981552,
0.6919606328010559,
-0.5860450863838196,
0.6332647800445557,
0.5714635848999023,
0.18051813542842865,
0.11624818295240402,
-0.015138532966375351,
0.4137778878211975,
0.13431712985038757,
-0.8187419772148132,
-0.4495044946670532,
1.428341031074524,
-0.1814180463552475,
0.48165231943130493,
-0.19614434242248535,
0.7394044399261475,
0.36715802550315857,
0.2315467894077301,
-0.8854825496673584,
0.40612998604774475,
-0.5348684787750244,
-0.6802255511283875,
-0.2895778715610504,
-0.3929932415485382,
-1.0397672653198242,
-0.12688426673412323,
-0.21913966536521912,
-0.6518747210502625,
0.22301085293293,
0.44608375430107117,
-0.35599446296691895,
0.1459726244211197,
-0.8469761610031128,
1.0291156768798828,
-0.3088025748729706,
-0.4214262366294861,
-0.12164200097322464,
-0.22327058017253876,
0.43200138211250305,
-0.15339809656143188,
-0.254503458738327,
-0.2212364375591278,
-0.06857559084892273,
0.6296210885047913,
0.0643354281783104,
1.0780850648880005,
-0.28881144523620605,
-0.238824263215065,
0.22809383273124695,
0.17880533635616302,
0.3320995271205902,
0.14766836166381836,
-0.22772713005542755,
0.28925323486328125,
0.18643011152744293,
-0.5838770866394043,
-0.8832111358642578,
1.0224037170410156,
-0.7748716473579407,
-0.7023141384124756,
-0.019820040091872215,
-0.8033412098884583,
-0.5024386644363403,
0.24225379526615143,
0.500151515007019,
0.5179080963134766,
-0.07156728208065033,
0.28610682487487793,
0.4916188418865204,
0.00014324219955597073,
0.1894993633031845,
0.6959623098373413,
0.4251222312450409,
-0.2138468325138092,
1.1303045749664307,
0.03833552077412605,
0.04927463084459305,
0.6739901900291443,
-0.18767033517360687,
-0.10651565343141556,
-0.5149187445640564,
-0.7970998883247375,
0.01056861411780119,
-0.3775833547115326,
-0.40932339429855347,
-0.42228221893310547,
-0.03713316097855568,
-0.43985748291015625,
-0.1532004028558731,
-0.40187931060791016,
-0.39429327845573425,
-0.4357081651687622,
0.053228773176670074,
0.4439197778701782,
0.4218652844429016,
0.27867019176483154,
0.2681150734424591,
-0.6395183205604553,
0.3138977587223053,
0.10276305675506592,
0.2712308466434479,
-0.3361724615097046,
-0.7146930694580078,
-0.44148197770118713,
0.37923187017440796,
-0.36662569642066956,
-0.7970336675643921,
0.309937447309494,
0.7338406443595886,
0.3526874780654907,
0.2132693976163864,
0.29758599400520325,
0.7102607488632202,
-0.9190718531608582,
0.6149140000343323,
-0.03582938387989998,
-0.8986943364143372,
0.7370492815971375,
-0.37013837695121765,
0.32384946942329407,
0.6914733648300171,
0.8140344023704529,
-0.12520833313465118,
-0.3439979553222656,
-0.30711448192596436,
-0.3084581792354584,
0.9139530658721924,
0.13375988602638245,
0.46718883514404297,
-0.11358977854251862,
0.6294931769371033,
0.5611287951469421,
0.34038880467414856,
-0.49705490469932556,
-0.07299109548330307,
-0.5117471814155579,
-0.42225268483161926,
-0.4787191152572632,
0.16937460005283356,
-0.21370765566825867,
-0.20643097162246704,
0.9037066698074341,
-0.47360795736312866,
0.32214438915252686,
-0.0572706013917923,
-0.20556442439556122,
-0.32513946294784546,
0.28390249609947205,
0.6800136566162109,
0.5484413504600525,
-0.20274478197097778,
-0.08579898625612259,
-0.0003663991519715637,
-0.18996337056159973,
0.08331531286239624,
-0.01885518804192543,
-0.18297412991523743,
0.05776801332831383,
0.34312325716018677,
1.2668285369873047,
0.6227105259895325,
-0.7520796656608582,
0.37368476390838623,
-0.04799254611134529,
-0.5245638489723206,
-0.003208411391824484,
0.9595304727554321,
-0.2825959026813507,
-0.05855700746178627,
-0.036593418568372726,
0.04644189774990082,
0.08158519864082336,
-0.5540255904197693,
0.2068747729063034,
0.3470659852027893,
-0.3025524616241455,
-0.7157251238822937,
0.6563938856124878,
0.18524137139320374,
-0.44091418385505676,
0.19263337552547455,
-0.24062620103359222,
-0.009515210054814816,
0.5173599720001221,
0.9559264183044434,
0.8204098343849182,
-0.30509668588638306,
0.5436030626296997,
0.3922215402126312,
0.19970138370990753,
0.20980562269687653,
0.18708893656730652,
-0.438959538936615,
-0.5952942967414856,
-0.43313977122306824,
-0.6962515711784363,
-0.3036110997200012,
0.4066566824913025,
-0.7838276624679565,
0.270938903093338,
-0.6764492392539978,
0.017419563606381416,
0.12347414344549179,
0.05272287502884865,
-0.7552375197410583,
0.29502078890800476,
-0.14670336246490479,
0.5164369940757751,
-0.8957483172416687,
1.0729904174804688,
0.9910615086555481,
-0.2226295918226242,
-0.3106963336467743,
0.23567844927310944,
-0.48418667912483215,
-0.8420320749282837,
0.2971835434436798,
0.02025480940937996,
-0.08970765769481659,
0.4183517396450043,
-0.29968351125717163,
-0.5445829033851624,
0.9411982297897339,
0.7069140076637268,
-0.7170835733413696,
-0.0029787691310048103,
0.09368040412664413,
0.6570677757263184,
-0.288771390914917,
-0.13417011499404907,
0.4458514451980591,
0.11157997697591782,
-0.1811780035495758,
-0.5476927161216736,
-0.04448376223444939,
-0.07197057455778122,
-0.11176585406064987,
0.44478839635849,
-0.51384037733078,
0.628201961517334,
-0.06066613271832466,
-0.2893966734409332,
-0.025049831718206406,
0.47887539863586426,
-0.10131014883518219,
0.17846770584583282,
0.34087252616882324,
0.3767560124397278,
0.6007696986198425,
0.05649936944246292,
1.0358422994613647,
-0.6837322115898132,
0.1852419227361679,
1.4078096151351929,
-0.31360840797424316,
0.7348126769065857,
0.027897117659449577,
0.28650856018066406,
0.6856252551078796,
0.3869608938694,
-0.041715700179338455,
0.698315441608429,
-0.1431979537010193,
-0.3726782500743866,
-0.3285108208656311,
-0.22623690962791443,
-0.025660976767539978,
0.6566752195358276,
0.35613125562667847,
-0.22924910485744476,
-0.3600795567035675,
0.08441581577062607,
-0.12474676221609116,
0.11461891233921051,
-0.2989996075630188,
0.7108448147773743,
-0.11106657981872559,
-0.8786829113960266,
1.0180734395980835,
0.2313721776008606,
0.31252312660217285,
-0.7315191030502319,
-0.1872873455286026,
-0.1860969364643097,
0.16658222675323486,
-0.062112465500831604,
-0.48962703347206116,
0.10568133741617203,
0.29115384817123413,
-0.22750802338123322,
-0.14510446786880493,
0.6142523884773254,
-0.5261107087135315,
-0.5544842481613159,
-0.020742317661643028,
0.13933448493480682,
0.09783459454774857,
0.07004666328430176,
-0.7894116044044495,
-0.16919870674610138,
0.1584385335445404,
-0.09972545504570007,
0.4603000581264496,
0.4552553594112396,
-0.08957105129957199,
0.2846916913986206,
0.6683860421180725,
0.1281377077102661,
0.2176329344511032,
-0.049742694944143295,
0.5621322393417358,
-0.4332527816295624,
-0.27796828746795654,
-0.3888484239578247,
0.3277150094509125,
0.11274227499961853,
-0.5030898451805115,
0.8224232196807861,
0.4828639030456543,
1.2150294780731201,
-0.4988713264465332,
0.867214024066925,
0.04611166939139366,
0.1505669355392456,
-0.7166301012039185,
0.48249107599258423,
-0.7365109324455261,
-0.21406623721122742,
0.19338640570640564,
-0.8373602628707886,
-0.05661647021770477,
0.35881584882736206,
-0.5200037956237793,
-0.012864552438259125,
0.4882551431655884,
0.9601740837097168,
-0.38226500153541565,
-0.15147264301776886,
0.579138457775116,
0.09835700690746307,
0.11925365030765533,
0.7501319646835327,
0.18021324276924133,
-0.6069642901420593,
0.29490917921066284,
-0.5102943778038025,
-0.31302618980407715,
-0.146324023604393,
-0.7221704721450806,
-1.1396689414978027,
-0.7436602115631104,
-0.46893033385276794,
0.2798381447792053,
0.49918627738952637,
0.6306335926055908,
0.8514113426208496,
-1.0075194835662842,
-0.18374641239643097,
-0.36811819672584534,
-0.16719414293766022,
-0.2579492926597595,
-0.24085038900375366,
0.11510111391544342,
-0.8497709035873413,
-1.1715582609176636,
0.8809643983840942,
0.3551766574382782,
-0.07405341416597366,
0.17569230496883392,
0.1497228741645813,
-0.016044961288571358,
0.3232310712337494,
0.5252830386161804,
0.6196887493133545,
-0.41224855184555054,
-0.31702783703804016,
-0.07792405784130096,
0.25980764627456665,
0.022902220487594604,
0.9106390476226807,
-0.6909145712852478,
0.5979949831962585,
0.1785106211900711,
0.8467230796813965,
0.47499653697013855,
-0.036633871495723724,
0.569749116897583,
-1.0697005987167358,
0.30346134305000305,
0.10784068703651428,
0.058170136064291,
0.21806201338768005,
-0.5783640742301941,
0.2843773663043976,
0.0015683500096201897,
-0.44891244173049927,
-0.7778334617614746,
0.1800873577594757,
-0.7700564861297607,
-0.3355540335178375,
0.8420995473861694,
-0.24071073532104492,
-0.5253658294677734,
0.049940597265958786,
-0.10534796118736267,
0.4817645847797394,
-0.22326868772506714,
1.0753605365753174,
0.2515174448490143,
-0.14162443578243256,
-0.1146019995212555,
-0.7695826292037964,
0.6135240793228149,
0.49521830677986145,
-1.0358405113220215,
0.1402561217546463,
0.34896084666252136,
0.45851054787635803,
-0.17777614295482635,
0.3359675705432892,
0.20324867963790894,
0.4764600396156311,
-0.1317034661769867,
0.24627628922462463,
-0.3540782034397125,
-0.7325321435928345,
-0.19702517986297607,
-0.16256164014339447,
0.005580947268754244,
-0.6437016725540161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18312v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18312v2
|
How to think step-by-step: A mechanistic understanding of chain-of-thought reasoning
| 2024-02-28T13:14:20 | 2024-05-06T09:16:15 |
Subhabrata Dutta, Joykirat Singh, Soumen Chakrabarti, Tanmoy Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Despite superior reasoning prowess demonstrated by Large Language Models
(LLMs) with Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting, a lack of understanding prevails
around the internal mechanisms of the models that facilitate CoT generation.
This work investigates the neural sub-structures within LLMs that manifest CoT
reasoning from a mechanistic point of view. From an analysis of Llama-2 7B
applied to multistep reasoning over fictional ontologies, we demonstrate that
LLMs deploy multiple parallel pathways of answer generation for step-by-step
reasoning. These parallel pathways provide sequential answers from the input
question context as well as the generated CoT. We observe a functional rift in
the middle layers of the LLM. Token representations in the initial half remain
strongly biased towards the pretraining prior, with the in-context prior taking
over in the later half. This internal phase shift manifests in different
functional components: attention heads that write the answer token appear in
the later half, attention heads that move information along ontological
relationships appear in the initial half, and so on. To the best of our
knowledge, this is the first attempt towards mechanistic investigation of CoT
reasoning in LLMs.
|
[
-0.3710532784461975,
-0.9320424795150757,
0.9868859052658081,
-0.030701996758580208,
-0.13588786125183105,
0.38121265172958374,
0.20129530131816864,
-0.19437961280345917,
0.0679781436920166,
0.5762534737586975,
-1.0895380973815918,
-0.22036397457122803,
-0.327602356672287,
0.14099808037281036,
-0.2785101532936096,
0.9824069142341614,
-0.21705669164657593,
0.024160493165254593,
-0.13928359746932983,
0.08126639574766159,
-0.36618685722351074,
-0.6940338015556335,
-0.48267480731010437,
-0.6812984347343445,
0.7210354804992676,
0.3344216048717499,
0.5299023985862732,
0.3878224194049835,
0.27374267578125,
0.23673659563064575,
-0.25853267312049866,
0.038558658212423325,
-0.3825112581253052,
0.23573943972587585,
-0.4874998927116394,
-0.9882312417030334,
-0.39955195784568787,
-0.24560144543647766,
0.3793487250804901,
0.6716305017471313,
-0.08575253188610077,
0.34140318632125854,
0.04507288709282875,
0.7263606190681458,
-0.5661423206329346,
-0.003002856858074665,
-0.7857675552368164,
0.12360972166061401,
-0.08661289513111115,
-0.32839494943618774,
-0.3884468376636505,
0.16487208008766174,
0.10395562648773193,
-0.34830424189567566,
0.17775411903858185,
0.1571062058210373,
0.10653401911258698,
0.28809040784835815,
-0.34953585267066956,
-0.5716474652290344,
-0.46643149852752686,
0.5211833715438843,
-0.48993581533432007,
0.31613826751708984,
0.2273949533700943,
0.046992525458335876,
-0.4764024019241333,
-0.6200698018074036,
-0.796349287033081,
-0.20511408150196075,
-0.00014812700101174414,
-0.15195420384407043,
0.31512248516082764,
0.06024074926972389,
0.37418273091316223,
0.19218625128269196,
-0.4964873194694519,
-0.14203962683677673,
-0.4217849373817444,
-0.13152842223644257,
0.1717221587896347,
0.26873353123664856,
0.16283424198627472,
-0.20466458797454834,
-0.6469565033912659,
-0.09189211577177048,
-0.8330447673797607,
0.12286942452192307,
0.09299179911613464,
0.2699165344238281,
-0.01522467564791441,
0.5545534491539001,
-0.04203212261199951,
0.7535911798477173,
0.13361111283302307,
-0.32605329155921936,
0.11919897794723511,
-0.6443212628364563,
-0.3817535936832428,
0.2949684262275696,
0.5971261858940125,
-0.1197640523314476,
0.35372987389564514,
-0.06255201995372772,
-0.1182275265455246,
0.022580429911613464,
0.7285448312759399,
-0.22000189125537872,
0.14045734703540802,
0.44323503971099854,
-0.35217660665512085,
-0.3514529764652252,
-0.314123272895813,
-0.44177675247192383,
-0.37720975279808044,
-0.4092698395252228,
0.2859461307525635,
-0.2655121982097626,
-0.2764580547809601,
0.18839651346206665,
0.17847231030464172,
0.3429011106491089,
0.33788013458251953,
-0.74947589635849,
0.2839414179325104,
0.7899289131164551,
0.6596088409423828,
-0.008989819325506687,
-0.5825353264808655,
-0.07322166860103607,
0.22046655416488647,
-0.4925425052642822,
0.8751471042633057,
-0.4841699004173279,
-0.07267967611551285,
-0.004486212506890297,
-0.08894232660531998,
-0.21134638786315918,
-0.3544507920742035,
0.1965322494506836,
-0.642622172832489,
-0.15707927942276,
-0.7614659070968628,
-0.1939132660627365,
-0.25192365050315857,
0.5715528726577759,
-0.3693317174911499,
0.9251352548599243,
-0.29161521792411804,
-0.8919117450714111,
0.28426387906074524,
-0.5090575814247131,
-0.35912129282951355,
-0.357364296913147,
-0.5332421660423279,
0.363821804523468,
0.1492328643798828,
0.0422506257891655,
0.36900588870048523,
-0.6759204864501953,
0.059122391045093536,
-0.16435442864894867,
0.032290272414684296,
0.5392562747001648,
-0.33975645899772644,
0.6800095438957214,
0.05800889804959297,
-0.5250027775764465,
0.13488967716693878,
-0.7216887474060059,
-0.19766107201576233,
0.0014482205733656883,
-0.14768289029598236,
-0.30524319410324097,
0.005172655917704105,
-0.6295709013938904,
0.7863231897354126,
0.16291210055351257,
-0.3513835370540619,
0.3491612374782562,
-0.09579488635063171,
0.3864564895629883,
0.8933852314949036,
0.04778607562184334,
0.5151839852333069,
-0.22911886870861053,
0.4513997435569763,
0.39831534028053284,
0.24106621742248535,
-0.2601016163825989,
-0.4459603726863861,
-1.070801019668579,
0.3286448121070862,
-0.10990149527788162,
0.519941508769989,
-0.9491589665412903,
0.11121377348899841,
0.11469177901744843,
-0.25279897451400757,
-0.5267001986503601,
0.1826990842819214,
0.6139129996299744,
0.5945078730583191,
0.5206508040428162,
-0.3174412250518799,
-0.13038814067840576,
-0.6965309977531433,
-0.006852485705167055,
-0.38012877106666565,
0.1544451117515564,
0.016690755262970924,
0.5823394060134888,
-0.05971935763955116,
0.48358801007270813,
-0.4151298403739929,
-0.07666908949613571,
-0.28141388297080994,
0.2313598245382309,
0.06964392960071564,
0.3037734925746918,
0.07429073750972748,
-0.40312305092811584,
0.24799156188964844,
-0.06808929145336151,
-0.922067403793335,
-0.010064750909805298,
-0.6113569140434265,
-0.6045700907707214,
0.06825493276119232,
0.8042604327201843,
-0.7586866021156311,
0.45068594813346863,
0.08339960873126984,
-0.48181387782096863,
0.580796480178833,
-0.2358948439359665,
0.04939407855272293,
-1.0550907850265503,
-0.20407523214817047,
-0.45104971528053284,
-0.026163173839449883,
-0.4796617329120636,
0.2304949313402176,
-0.21904751658439636,
0.4720867872238159,
-0.39943575859069824,
0.2262909710407257,
-0.568513810634613,
-0.3748187720775604,
-0.3517063856124878,
0.2987843453884125,
-0.07656741142272949,
0.8128705024719238,
-0.26839175820350647,
0.6507888436317444,
0.5375300049781799,
-0.7442622780799866,
0.0963105633854866,
0.35911908745765686,
-0.24264483153820038,
0.31394410133361816,
-0.43321603536605835,
0.522127091884613,
-0.19491003453731537,
0.44323477149009705,
-1.0905665159225464,
0.12516038119792938,
0.3668057918548584,
-0.17595751583576202,
0.21891838312149048,
0.1364724040031433,
-0.6956238150596619,
-0.3803022503852844,
-0.1525551825761795,
0.70899498462677,
0.25366586446762085,
-0.3602038323879242,
0.7197431325912476,
0.302094966173172,
-0.11940852552652359,
-0.6626659035682678,
-0.8699965476989746,
-0.16147391498088837,
0.14020419120788574,
-0.5151078701019287,
0.013021843507885933,
0.11087017506361008,
-0.4085686504840851,
-0.2802621126174927,
-0.47040238976478577,
0.04850650206208229,
-0.21108020842075348,
0.05377817153930664,
0.15077067911624908,
-0.23685573041439056,
0.22917982935905457,
0.3117324411869049,
-0.061325717717409134,
0.4702061712741852,
-0.5366916060447693,
0.791458785533905,
-0.019885461777448654,
-0.4422302544116974,
-0.18561041355133057,
0.15581248700618744,
0.8238579034805298,
-0.06291420757770538,
0.6960496306419373,
0.06915200501680374,
-0.12259621918201447,
-0.4406985342502594,
-0.393490195274353,
-0.13584919273853302,
-0.4126804769039154,
0.11901555955410004,
-0.734270453453064,
-0.7071468830108643,
0.7260095477104187,
-0.02349896915256977,
0.019030451774597168,
0.3198952376842499,
0.8973402976989746,
-0.1039511114358902,
0.5379648804664612,
0.2924165725708008,
0.3695303797721863,
0.06578546017408371,
-0.4473811686038971,
0.23247385025024414,
-1.119234561920166,
-0.6724855899810791,
-0.19709812104701996,
-0.3650898039340973,
-0.5131856799125671,
-0.9989144206047058,
0.3849278390407562,
0.15157365798950195,
-0.4058995842933655,
0.262652724981308,
-0.21950678527355194,
0.4025106430053711,
0.3241017460823059,
0.19072173535823822,
0.24453485012054443,
-0.25782185792922974,
-0.8495847582817078,
0.4875444173812866,
-0.8259109258651733,
-0.5708072781562805,
0.9684132933616638,
0.3303319215774536,
1.004513144493103,
-0.09041623026132584,
0.5161986947059631,
0.06687801331281662,
0.02633756399154663,
-0.5493026375770569,
0.7742801904678345,
0.1298656016588211,
-0.6999379992485046,
-0.25033608078956604,
0.08108865469694138,
-0.6966900825500488,
0.41401368379592896,
-0.12072403728961945,
-0.7272366881370544,
0.16552330553531647,
0.1333431750535965,
-0.30587613582611084,
0.4039418399333954,
-0.3551207482814789,
0.5125020742416382,
-0.39925387501716614,
-0.5765863060951233,
-0.5843267440795898,
-1.0377354621887207,
0.4766649901866913,
-0.12930640578269958,
0.23345693945884705,
0.07608712464570999,
-0.02777469903230667,
0.5326424837112427,
-0.5208002924919128,
0.9576011300086975,
0.131173238158226,
-0.40213528275489807,
0.6905625462532043,
0.40140631794929504,
0.34968018531799316,
-0.1630055159330368,
0.18847213685512543,
0.17944371700286865,
-0.2525896728038788,
-0.292006254196167,
-0.6589116454124451,
0.662250816822052,
-0.5121618509292603,
-0.8366088271141052,
-0.5222821831703186,
-0.6642094850540161,
-0.3208470642566681,
-0.0256517231464386,
0.18472127616405487,
0.39448657631874084,
0.2413794845342636,
-0.22371569275856018,
0.6529237031936646,
-0.10563605278730392,
0.3480086624622345,
0.10741003602743149,
-0.3984866738319397,
-0.09141697734594345,
0.3990843892097473,
0.19203916192054749,
0.6106228828430176,
0.5373229384422302,
0.01657760888338089,
-0.4990714490413666,
-0.3378797769546509,
-0.4873489737510681,
0.3277844190597534,
-1.069863200187683,
0.06516051292419434,
-0.6242705583572388,
-0.18149688839912415,
-0.10981302708387375,
-0.11202292889356613,
-0.26639652252197266,
-0.5018563270568848,
-0.012438666075468063,
-0.38611850142478943,
0.00406373105943203,
1.2661230564117432,
0.21056418120861053,
0.005860540550202131,
-0.6074019074440002,
0.32683083415031433,
0.26787570118904114,
0.1722385436296463,
0.6917273998260498,
-0.4075261950492859,
-0.052322808653116226,
0.06485110521316528,
-0.5314611792564392,
-0.7719020843505859,
-0.21324995160102844,
-0.3463658392429352,
0.516019880771637,
0.26096829771995544,
-0.16807794570922852,
0.7649759650230408,
-0.8430245518684387,
0.7854832410812378,
0.28305500745773315,
-0.8709855079650879,
0.5088967680931091,
-0.14928822219371796,
0.3352266848087311,
0.43275904655456543,
0.5312227010726929,
-0.08991531282663345,
-0.5438348054885864,
-0.5504130721092224,
-0.7818844318389893,
0.532137393951416,
0.283460795879364,
-0.04555333033204079,
-0.1169646754860878,
0.49062225222587585,
0.390165239572525,
0.23351888358592987,
-0.7071757316589355,
-0.20570506155490875,
-0.06273914128541946,
0.22337573766708374,
0.0966985747218132,
-0.18235790729522705,
-0.08867208659648895,
-0.1984662413597107,
0.33528149127960205,
-0.1800682246685028,
0.2876286804676056,
0.516259491443634,
-0.24351589381694794,
-0.09659384191036224,
0.2740288972854614,
0.7576205730438232,
0.9828638434410095,
0.11161001026630402,
0.3750346302986145,
0.18467095494270325,
-0.15915749967098236,
0.25185611844062805,
-0.5719342231750488,
-0.07165249437093735,
-0.3520520329475403,
0.6797242164611816,
0.9140615463256836,
0.21476376056671143,
-0.3604283332824707,
0.06311086565256119,
0.15283408761024475,
-0.08024632185697556,
-0.166035458445549,
0.23279140889644623,
0.07335331290960312,
0.6048540472984314,
0.19147005677223206,
0.11292935162782669,
0.2414042204618454,
-0.9490809440612793,
0.05756270885467529,
0.2228444218635559,
-0.3001086115837097,
-0.5803322196006775,
0.682059645652771,
0.007030843757092953,
-0.37556320428848267,
0.43473801016807556,
0.03394003584980965,
-0.5688346028327942,
0.5083325505256653,
0.6020435094833374,
1.0924091339111328,
-0.05471447855234146,
0.22902382910251617,
0.20690038800239563,
0.41772398352622986,
0.017811132594943047,
0.46431928873062134,
-0.46134957671165466,
-0.7102280855178833,
-0.5646716356277466,
-0.7867674827575684,
-0.30056440830230713,
-0.03862246125936508,
-0.5267224907875061,
0.15352489054203033,
-0.5795901417732239,
-0.1616356521844864,
-0.03597235679626465,
-0.6454804539680481,
-0.5786465406417847,
0.36524030566215515,
0.5468207597732544,
0.989004373550415,
-0.6818392872810364,
0.7308661937713623,
0.596581220626831,
-0.6392304301261902,
-0.9014706611633301,
0.6786478757858276,
-0.11273784190416336,
-1.0199741125106812,
0.5915870666503906,
0.12824231386184692,
-0.5054807662963867,
-0.18060040473937988,
-0.5313844680786133,
-0.8578438758850098,
1.1388343572616577,
0.17651355266571045,
-0.4815932512283325,
-0.3111388385295868,
0.36063575744628906,
0.6075775623321533,
-0.5639836192131042,
0.19869427382946014,
0.6267592310905457,
0.04476582631468773,
0.4040258228778839,
-0.9494901895523071,
0.3746720552444458,
0.10916221141815186,
-0.025783291086554527,
0.28061795234680176,
-0.694419801235199,
1.1012401580810547,
-0.5018383264541626,
0.15415780246257782,
-0.20243225991725922,
0.3007625341415405,
0.5249334573745728,
0.18700218200683594,
0.4949778616428375,
0.48161473870277405,
0.6197766065597534,
0.22005067765712738,
1.193029761314392,
-0.2897323966026306,
0.06294886767864227,
1.0489662885665894,
-0.2840956747531891,
0.8922566175460815,
0.7860785722732544,
-0.1985665112733841,
1.0836037397384644,
0.587572455406189,
0.5925045609474182,
0.6107640862464905,
0.5613892674446106,
-0.12428901344537735,
-0.31148380041122437,
0.12011856585741043,
-0.2085505574941635,
0.4891539514064789,
0.3643939793109894,
-0.3340666890144348,
-0.11951302736997604,
-0.11635364592075348,
-0.02553693577647209,
-0.38138076663017273,
-0.6354408860206604,
0.8887004852294922,
0.3980933129787445,
-1.0449297428131104,
0.7264050245285034,
-0.5127415060997009,
0.14498697221279144,
-0.5457556247711182,
-0.09167955070734024,
-0.01837029680609703,
0.11488956958055496,
-0.06686842441558838,
-1.0671838521957397,
0.2793557345867157,
-0.021903786808252335,
-0.3039727807044983,
-0.2753307819366455,
0.630781888961792,
-0.2827509939670563,
-0.4324920177459717,
0.6656489968299866,
0.6731083989143372,
0.2537209093570709,
0.15901221334934235,
-0.7222210168838501,
-0.038812898099422455,
-0.061399612575769424,
-0.4223594665527344,
0.3626525104045868,
0.7493641972541809,
-0.41861099004745483,
0.7348526120185852,
0.6779803037643433,
-0.1382756531238556,
0.42660051584243774,
0.28572878241539,
0.9998200535774231,
-0.8780357837677002,
-0.5250895619392395,
-1.0444360971450806,
0.6635533571243286,
0.274090051651001,
-0.36649274826049805,
0.2099962830543518,
0.08807305991649628,
0.8625521063804626,
-0.0696408748626709,
0.7028834223747253,
-0.07935193181037903,
0.0709746852517128,
-0.9197604060173035,
0.49442237615585327,
-0.5336588025093079,
0.3902759253978729,
-0.2988686263561249,
-0.7518498301506042,
0.04828646779060364,
0.585136890411377,
-0.24741411209106445,
-0.15023832023143768,
1.3110480308532715,
0.6547171473503113,
0.19841814041137695,
0.07748297601938248,
0.24705053865909576,
0.5368357300758362,
0.08964590728282928,
0.6746364831924438,
0.8579823970794678,
-0.20876140892505646,
0.2675788998603821,
0.01204015500843525,
-0.19396109879016876,
0.26098477840423584,
-0.7469125390052795,
-1.00399649143219,
-0.6022962331771851,
0.009249494411051273,
-0.5356965661048889,
-0.09197254478931427,
1.03402841091156,
0.28938886523246765,
-0.8016572594642639,
-0.4950287342071533,
-0.6421137452125549,
0.2618424892425537,
0.06677521020174026,
-0.12312563508749008,
0.1655144989490509,
-0.7782487273216248,
-0.07065768539905548,
0.32989880442619324,
0.5294556617736816,
-0.1924433410167694,
-0.6201078295707703,
0.18235968053340912,
-0.7075693607330322,
0.39817777276039124,
0.7014918923377991,
-0.0981392040848732,
-1.0980573892593384,
-0.12084360420703888,
0.12213192135095596,
-0.013959065079689026,
0.10193894058465958,
1.1173923015594482,
-0.8296184539794922,
0.47565433382987976,
0.6159405708312988,
0.4648020267486572,
0.4391285479068756,
-0.14963340759277344,
0.7180492281913757,
-0.43134805560112,
0.17982877790927887,
0.03416932374238968,
0.39637789130210876,
0.16520991921424866,
-0.281527042388916,
0.49841630458831787,
0.16311216354370117,
-0.5595025420188904,
-0.5947821736335754,
0.44366100430488586,
-0.9350336790084839,
-0.2908846139907837,
1.2252769470214844,
0.014151626266539097,
-0.4944634735584259,
-0.2136591374874115,
-0.2777829170227051,
0.3266292214393616,
0.10617528110742569,
0.7939947247505188,
1.019569754600525,
-0.6927800178527832,
0.05373482033610344,
-0.34354063868522644,
0.43262186646461487,
0.3736149072647095,
-0.7368950247764587,
0.1469050496816635,
0.11450646817684174,
0.11411478370428085,
0.567268967628479,
0.8872069716453552,
-0.01887461170554161,
0.1012706458568573,
0.21569469571113586,
-0.15129518508911133,
0.35027503967285156,
-0.6485142707824707,
0.050451088696718216,
0.11610372364521027,
-0.007693683262914419,
-0.25456586480140686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18284v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18284v2
|
Is Crowdsourcing Breaking Your Bank? Cost-Effective Fine-Tuning of Pre-trained Language Models with Proximal Policy Optimization
| 2024-02-28T12:24:07 | 2024-03-02T23:19:27 |
Shuo Yang, Gjergji Kasneci
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Wide usage of ChatGPT has highlighted the potential of reinforcement learning
from human feedback. However, its training pipeline relies on manual ranking, a
resource-intensive process. To reduce labor costs, we propose a self-supervised
text ranking approach for applying Proximal-Policy-Optimization to fine-tune
language models while eliminating the need for human annotators. Our method
begins with probabilistic sampling to encourage a language model to generate
diverse responses for each input. We then employ TextRank and ISODATA
algorithms to rank and cluster these responses based on their semantics.
Subsequently, we construct a reward model to learn the rank and optimize our
generative policy. Our experimental results, conducted using two language
models on three tasks, demonstrate that the models trained by our method
considerably outperform baselines regarding BLEU, GLEU, and METEOR scores.
Furthermore, our manual evaluation shows that our ranking results exhibit a
remarkably high consistency with that of humans. This research significantly
reduces training costs of proximal policy-guided models and demonstrates the
potential for self-correction of language models.
|
[
-0.29189443588256836,
-0.3708057105541229,
0.33109429478645325,
0.19427739083766937,
-0.06808940321207047,
0.12036718428134918,
-0.550623893737793,
-0.20272739231586456,
-0.10696069151163101,
0.831379234790802,
-0.5870030522346497,
-0.33177119493484497,
-0.507661759853363,
0.08002153038978577,
-0.020780082792043686,
1.3795335292816162,
0.3798891305923462,
-0.17004705965518951,
-0.1754124015569687,
0.04799095168709755,
0.03447960689663887,
-0.5068935751914978,
-0.8979831337928772,
-0.1603543609380722,
0.5998955965042114,
0.6479846239089966,
0.9309624433517456,
0.7907540202140808,
0.3976825773715973,
0.45759743452072144,
0.14975523948669434,
0.32793450355529785,
-0.6522274017333984,
-0.07510940730571747,
-0.33828601241111755,
-0.35267728567123413,
-0.12777872383594513,
0.5150083303451538,
0.3748623728752136,
0.35186755657196045,
-0.28365546464920044,
0.198996439576149,
0.3070690631866455,
0.588609516620636,
-0.5795261859893799,
0.3040483593940735,
-0.6487525105476379,
-0.4371798038482666,
-0.3111518919467926,
-0.20540566742420197,
-0.3552195727825165,
-0.834022581577301,
0.010101161897182465,
-0.657992422580719,
0.3525182902812958,
0.03238486498594284,
0.8791807293891907,
0.521852970123291,
0.12616898119449615,
-0.16214677691459656,
-0.40649744868278503,
0.9070122838020325,
-0.5752242803573608,
-0.0007341713644564152,
0.8522208333015442,
0.06835750490427017,
-0.03578975051641464,
-0.5617228150367737,
-0.4396754205226898,
-0.6363757252693176,
-0.18296636641025543,
0.06108622997999191,
-0.16986867785453796,
0.2461603879928589,
-0.1468571126461029,
0.11227596551179886,
-0.6044432520866394,
0.39495372772216797,
-0.3865385353565216,
-0.3300769329071045,
0.8090916872024536,
-0.17328272759914398,
0.13190336525440216,
-0.23714536428451538,
-0.03260306268930435,
-0.4201565086841583,
-0.4353286027908325,
0.09673207253217697,
0.7784340977668762,
0.4889219105243683,
0.20676212012767792,
0.3466145396232605,
-0.5077021718025208,
0.5928101539611816,
0.11196500808000565,
0.03804933279752731,
0.07129327952861786,
-0.1436404436826706,
0.1079939529299736,
-0.16995210945606232,
1.0449069738388062,
0.14532838761806488,
0.5589897632598877,
-0.505597710609436,
-0.1688743680715561,
-0.152921661734581,
0.37823283672332764,
-0.7107303142547607,
-0.6322477459907532,
0.03193172439932823,
-0.3061610460281372,
-0.7136127948760986,
-0.21964380145072937,
-0.5509974956512451,
-0.25142624974250793,
-0.4754103422164917,
0.48518890142440796,
-0.17809262871742249,
-0.2559255361557007,
-0.11948610097169876,
0.16210044920444489,
-0.34194955229759216,
0.17221447825431824,
-1.191282033920288,
0.19909895956516266,
0.6519339680671692,
0.7366245985031128,
0.12726379930973053,
-0.4172174632549286,
-0.593095064163208,
-0.15323829650878906,
-0.36328181624412537,
0.9795857071876526,
-0.6607193350791931,
-0.44005340337753296,
-0.022957077249884605,
-0.11119499057531357,
0.023733871057629585,
-0.8327490091323853,
0.3677130341529846,
-0.3735117018222809,
0.40352290868759155,
0.028889834880828857,
-0.42353564500808716,
0.23270127177238464,
0.11810131371021271,
-0.6193630695343018,
1.0717161893844604,
0.13656771183013916,
-0.5269479751586914,
0.42139768600463867,
-0.68426114320755,
-0.22234217822551727,
0.16103899478912354,
-0.01275425124913454,
-0.5629924535751343,
-0.12814508378505707,
0.42008456587791443,
0.3449769914150238,
-0.11603984236717224,
0.627449095249176,
-0.18104344606399536,
-0.17017759382724762,
0.08803264796733856,
-0.3737838864326477,
0.4972493052482605,
0.3801429569721222,
-0.47068920731544495,
0.2621857821941376,
-0.7123544216156006,
0.14252811670303345,
-0.13576972484588623,
-0.5149757862091064,
-0.4496806561946869,
0.1949627846479416,
0.12994171679019928,
0.17792031168937683,
0.27970656752586365,
-0.37748247385025024,
0.47258877754211426,
-0.5252756476402283,
0.488648384809494,
1.0482820272445679,
-0.18573668599128723,
0.6873905658721924,
-0.14271333813667297,
0.4522549510002136,
-0.5049341917037964,
0.2982669174671173,
0.1135927215218544,
-0.1362650990486145,
-0.6707431674003601,
-0.1937621831893921,
0.5446438193321228,
0.3305662274360657,
-0.5058712363243103,
0.3922373056411743,
-0.1479274332523346,
-0.6855381727218628,
-0.9672157168388367,
0.2520231008529663,
0.5064486265182495,
0.406449556350708,
0.4079756438732147,
-0.0770493745803833,
-0.22749623656272888,
-0.887570321559906,
-0.5832236409187317,
-0.356589138507843,
-0.17076590657234192,
0.23893101513385773,
0.17480656504631042,
0.07176879048347473,
1.1226210594177246,
-0.4359279274940491,
-0.494636207818985,
0.013314568437635899,
0.5971494317054749,
0.06623554974794388,
0.6862328052520752,
0.23165865242481232,
-0.5993884801864624,
-0.27149203419685364,
-0.16631445288658142,
-0.2361207753419876,
-0.30454108119010925,
-0.04525916650891304,
-0.017138369381427765,
0.15503846108913422,
0.5231809020042419,
-0.2358904480934143,
0.037155427038669586,
0.7182764410972595,
-0.23928050696849823,
0.38267603516578674,
-0.6089013814926147,
0.10770925134420395,
-0.7519716620445251,
-0.022658653557300568,
0.10819624364376068,
-0.42707788944244385,
-0.09209868311882019,
-0.025541385635733604,
-0.08106967806816101,
-0.33844706416130066,
-0.005972412880510092,
0.5818473696708679,
-0.15774674713611603,
0.30620381236076355,
-0.36382997035980225,
0.10764767974615097,
-0.2657698094844818,
0.6734716892242432,
0.314334511756897,
1.0470764636993408,
0.143222376704216,
-0.5755576491355896,
0.0868130773305893,
-0.0056306407786905766,
-0.43932104110717773,
0.2735536992549896,
-0.7488821148872375,
0.15625931322574615,
-0.11689326912164688,
0.0635283961892128,
-0.8387855291366577,
-0.08445136249065399,
0.1760767251253128,
-0.32056668400764465,
0.08579155057668686,
-0.18828848004341125,
-0.49654144048690796,
-0.053866032510995865,
-0.04645256698131561,
0.15084847807884216,
0.49236536026000977,
-0.647821843624115,
-0.04520059749484062,
0.6844314336776733,
-0.46324118971824646,
-0.4090674817562103,
-0.23768697679042816,
-0.0057954443618655205,
-0.05159277468919754,
-0.134611114859581,
0.40626809000968933,
0.15311141312122345,
-0.10328252613544464,
0.03696022927761078,
0.08008705824613571,
-0.04940994083881378,
0.0482504740357399,
0.06623551994562149,
-0.10799658298492432,
0.23629195988178253,
0.37399470806121826,
-0.1212395504117012,
-0.4854540228843689,
-0.136837899684906,
-0.526261031627655,
0.48520582914352417,
-0.15947842597961426,
-0.1550106555223465,
-0.3580853343009949,
-0.09046028554439545,
0.19196173548698425,
-0.6674464344978333,
0.5728916525840759,
0.5709839463233948,
-0.0882151648402214,
-0.016420764848589897,
-0.6795632839202881,
-0.23838791251182556,
-0.5489431023597717,
0.4851646423339844,
-0.11740943789482117,
-1.1321310997009277,
0.009717271663248539,
-0.395176500082016,
0.13645614683628082,
0.32879382371902466,
0.6203438639640808,
-0.20016053318977356,
1.1546120643615723,
0.6575971841812134,
-0.5214530825614929,
0.5858067274093628,
-0.2466968446969986,
0.07734474539756775,
-0.0765819102525711,
-0.193894162774086,
-0.7978452444076538,
-0.1057298481464386,
-1.1216866970062256,
-0.4483892023563385,
0.3783881962299347,
0.15268366038799286,
-0.2744438648223877,
0.33355963230133057,
-0.781337559223175,
0.8229267001152039,
0.9286995530128479,
0.16151387989521027,
0.22782613337039948,
-0.058723434805870056,
0.20286250114440918,
-0.15631873905658722,
-0.7003774642944336,
-0.5825697183609009,
0.9760141968727112,
0.16986744105815887,
0.7921523451805115,
-0.1351781040430069,
1.0282278060913086,
0.47592440247535706,
0.4687023460865021,
-0.2674950063228607,
0.35451841354370117,
-0.10904638469219208,
-0.4778251349925995,
-0.9456403851509094,
-0.5980039834976196,
-1.1253830194473267,
0.2950100898742676,
-0.18700049817562103,
-0.7708978056907654,
0.08956841379404068,
0.4075373113155365,
-0.29991915822029114,
0.06088089197874069,
-0.6742826700210571,
1.1328628063201904,
-0.1902124583721161,
-0.4755862057209015,
-0.6897633671760559,
-0.30934908986091614,
0.10382287949323654,
0.12902547419071198,
0.4441240131855011,
-0.35983556509017944,
0.14675486087799072,
0.6800639033317566,
-0.7990142703056335,
0.7766407132148743,
-0.2893727421760559,
-0.01207346934825182,
0.20806439220905304,
0.019444532692432404,
0.648086667060852,
0.2806965112686157,
-0.03159106895327568,
0.029870692640542984,
-0.05636321380734444,
-0.7035925388336182,
-0.4608958959579468,
0.7698310613632202,
-0.9990596771240234,
-0.5192030668258667,
-0.2117137759923935,
-0.271996408700943,
-0.28753066062927246,
0.01668350212275982,
0.3120344877243042,
0.3041835427284241,
-0.2514823377132416,
0.027011267840862274,
0.4918632507324219,
-0.14506563544273376,
0.41629111766815186,
0.42216813564300537,
-0.017881715670228004,
-0.37129709124565125,
1.3374481201171875,
0.13911527395248413,
0.07605978846549988,
0.41039904952049255,
0.4097801744937897,
-0.5399067997932434,
-0.2349443882703781,
-0.19841399788856506,
0.11697813123464584,
-0.12321696430444717,
-0.1495833396911621,
-0.49984806776046753,
0.0495685450732708,
-0.5684729218482971,
-0.016178438439965248,
-0.6310540437698364,
-0.35990822315216064,
-0.11052467674016953,
-0.07534649968147278,
0.3713843822479248,
0.39396870136260986,
-0.3985031545162201,
0.45609408617019653,
-0.6350703239440918,
0.08202221989631653,
0.6159749031066895,
0.5142480134963989,
-0.18290138244628906,
-0.333517849445343,
-0.4108291268348694,
0.02851807326078415,
-0.23419445753097534,
-0.5331212282180786,
0.5046260356903076,
0.2312885820865631,
0.47490206360816956,
0.3907916843891144,
0.20728915929794312,
0.7097580432891846,
-0.49715983867645264,
0.383971244096756,
-0.04584866762161255,
-0.9111379981040955,
0.5981779098510742,
-0.41639894247055054,
0.3049911558628082,
0.9286380410194397,
0.2844945192337036,
-0.5185788869857788,
-0.6941949725151062,
-0.8055604100227356,
-0.7716401219367981,
0.8428426384925842,
0.26610177755355835,
0.30561748147010803,
-0.10639110207557678,
0.19084469974040985,
-0.0828716903924942,
0.16014118492603302,
-0.7061032056808472,
0.06083407625555992,
-0.24293185770511627,
-0.16042867302894592,
-0.3466724753379822,
-0.20951542258262634,
0.006346309091895819,
-0.24676217138767242,
0.7494514584541321,
-0.1818104386329651,
-0.30817610025405884,
0.06750717014074326,
-0.14181733131408691,
0.02897603064775467,
0.23737281560897827,
0.2884901762008667,
0.5053505897521973,
-0.1294243335723877,
-0.009963796474039555,
-0.04512021690607071,
-0.16101324558258057,
0.1429297775030136,
0.2710989713668823,
-0.21773786842823029,
0.02509767934679985,
0.05280656740069389,
0.5924128293991089,
0.5060132741928101,
-0.7784983515739441,
0.38952529430389404,
0.06223636865615845,
-0.23707342147827148,
-0.14544780552387238,
0.1789560765028,
0.08571214228868484,
0.3150129020214081,
0.15303047001361847,
0.02677883207798004,
0.270576536655426,
-0.11619201302528381,
0.15304745733737946,
0.39380308985710144,
-0.33574604988098145,
-0.019898632541298866,
0.7208303213119507,
0.4981828033924103,
-0.3901609480381012,
0.7067661285400391,
-0.27729079127311707,
-0.24940161406993866,
0.45119449496269226,
0.22602517902851105,
0.6067367196083069,
-0.3746829628944397,
0.7623187303543091,
0.4464874565601349,
0.4609450101852417,
-0.428153932094574,
-0.19601580500602722,
-0.2663327753543854,
-0.5483526587486267,
-0.5576449632644653,
-0.6085066199302673,
-0.5891550183296204,
0.1058267280459404,
-0.5272696018218994,
0.15048055350780487,
-0.3587963879108429,
-0.17709773778915405,
-0.09707240015268326,
0.1769670695066452,
-0.662658154964447,
0.300193190574646,
-0.04128674790263176,
0.43973252177238464,
-0.7289882302284241,
0.778312623500824,
0.42217621207237244,
-0.5987951159477234,
-0.8039243221282959,
0.021411465480923653,
-0.35346415638923645,
-0.7322285771369934,
0.6311766505241394,
0.051554542034864426,
-0.09091246873140335,
0.506851315498352,
-0.8014102578163147,
-0.8821259140968323,
0.5288795828819275,
0.5085107088088989,
-0.7279438376426697,
-0.10064464807510376,
0.03565286472439766,
0.4923582673072815,
0.13924260437488556,
0.5045058131217957,
0.5352074503898621,
0.5041586756706238,
-0.4570079445838928,
-1.0243782997131348,
-0.2692157030105591,
-0.0015424799639731646,
0.061569321900606155,
0.21573017537593842,
-0.8449904322624207,
0.5030650496482849,
-0.23280321061611176,
-0.07430419325828552,
-0.07575632631778717,
0.710407018661499,
0.27601733803749084,
0.020025357604026794,
0.5359495878219604,
0.41293802857398987,
0.8743072152137756,
-0.0381675623357296,
1.0578117370605469,
-0.37292811274528503,
0.5785323977470398,
0.9350923299789429,
0.10097682476043701,
0.7653017044067383,
0.31593582034111023,
-0.35578441619873047,
0.4826892614364624,
0.8275624513626099,
-0.0524071641266346,
0.7938947081565857,
0.5237517356872559,
-0.097479447722435,
-0.6158314347267151,
-0.1646813154220581,
-0.09578887373209,
0.5331093668937683,
-0.0889206975698471,
-0.12972240149974823,
-0.4520328640937805,
-0.012638121843338013,
0.2540014982223511,
0.5440409183502197,
-0.2780306935310364,
0.8722594380378723,
-0.18003582954406738,
-0.8691731691360474,
0.4856734871864319,
0.2135036140680313,
0.7313117384910583,
-0.5105358958244324,
0.06757203489542007,
-0.3338560461997986,
0.2348863184452057,
-0.02223959006369114,
-0.2588101029396057,
0.08282189816236496,
0.16479256749153137,
-0.0658213421702385,
-0.542391300201416,
0.4795151948928833,
-0.7090344429016113,
-0.6030113697052002,
-0.07092953473329544,
0.4606624245643616,
0.2873147130012512,
-0.5129068493843079,
-0.7730365991592407,
-0.43445831537246704,
-0.24827702343463898,
-0.41555389761924744,
0.587479829788208,
0.329071968793869,
-0.2421753853559494,
0.7581568956375122,
0.8524714708328247,
0.1211673766374588,
-0.31060510873794556,
0.22191105782985687,
0.7934718132019043,
-0.4090731143951416,
-0.7968710064888,
-0.8969147801399231,
0.32291582226753235,
-0.27140012383461,
-0.4629583954811096,
0.3614751696586609,
0.6151463985443115,
1.221144676208496,
-0.004099883604794741,
0.9081439971923828,
0.24155403673648834,
0.5955208539962769,
-0.41964709758758545,
0.9025324583053589,
-0.40659090876579285,
-0.050067950040102005,
-0.28605616092681885,
-0.7234875559806824,
-0.06658273190259933,
0.7400668263435364,
-0.5872324109077454,
-0.07873371988534927,
0.167022705078125,
1.0044350624084473,
0.25002995133399963,
-0.26263970136642456,
0.12530435621738434,
-0.21071243286132812,
0.1763986349105835,
0.12991729378700256,
0.705364465713501,
0.04161678999662399,
0.8802023530006409,
-0.3409125804901123,
-0.3804274797439575,
-0.18056800961494446,
-0.7396809458732605,
-0.7054175138473511,
-0.5507149696350098,
-0.4206230342388153,
-0.15419167280197144,
0.4049448072910309,
1.0530726909637451,
1.0481116771697998,
-0.7833921313285828,
-0.3597424626350403,
-0.21013624966144562,
0.12278769910335541,
-0.4106358587741852,
-0.2821710705757141,
0.45561760663986206,
-0.9884132146835327,
-1.0100383758544922,
0.28101927042007446,
0.21389392018318176,
-0.40245333313941956,
-0.36274173855781555,
-0.13684222102165222,
0.050865620374679565,
-0.1926877647638321,
0.2788684070110321,
0.3839980959892273,
-0.6350529193878174,
-0.12067034095525742,
-0.07627636194229126,
-0.3590499460697174,
-0.18978120386600494,
0.9959164261817932,
-0.98882657289505,
0.4687310457229614,
0.29890185594558716,
0.6258872151374817,
0.4120580852031708,
0.33047646284103394,
0.6143459677696228,
-0.7535890340805054,
0.17302976548671722,
0.34796142578125,
-0.17109115421772003,
0.20102179050445557,
-0.29441404342651367,
0.5480096340179443,
0.08243994414806366,
-0.8966349959373474,
-0.6736392974853516,
0.04593244194984436,
-0.3774082660675049,
-0.40211790800094604,
0.9959682822227478,
-0.027029428631067276,
-0.01251436397433281,
-0.04780382663011551,
-0.4268311560153961,
0.2104051262140274,
-0.5376485586166382,
1.2119154930114746,
0.5039064288139343,
-0.09099734574556351,
-0.3697259724140167,
-0.32285863161087036,
0.9602829813957214,
0.4361611306667328,
-0.7647925615310669,
0.2148239016532898,
0.3519057035446167,
0.18535339832305908,
-0.061769261956214905,
0.9794331192970276,
0.01747601293027401,
-0.008870181627571583,
-0.21051213145256042,
0.4544408321380615,
-0.12678083777427673,
-0.14572778344154358,
-0.15880227088928223,
0.0733456164598465,
0.40012162923812866,
-0.3699949383735657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18281v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18281v2
|
Towards Better Understanding of Contrastive Sentence Representation Learning: A Unified Paradigm for Gradient
| 2024-02-28T12:17:40 | 2024-06-05T14:07:50 |
Mingxin Li, Richong Zhang, Zhijie Nie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sentence Representation Learning (SRL) is a crucial task in Natural Language
Processing (NLP), where contrastive Self-Supervised Learning (SSL) is currently
a mainstream approach. However, the reasons behind its remarkable effectiveness
remain unclear. Specifically, many studies have investigated the similarities
between contrastive and non-contrastive SSL from a theoretical perspective.
Such similarities can be verified in classification tasks, where the two
approaches achieve comparable performance. But in ranking tasks (i.e., Semantic
Textual Similarity (STS) in SRL), contrastive SSL significantly outperforms
non-contrastive SSL. Therefore, two questions arise: First, *what commonalities
enable various contrastive losses to achieve superior performance in STS?*
Second, *how can we make non-contrastive SSL also effective in STS?* To address
these questions, we start from the perspective of gradients and discover that
four effective contrastive losses can be integrated into a unified paradigm,
which depends on three components: the **Gradient Dissipation**, the
**Weight**, and the **Ratio**. Then, we conduct an in-depth analysis of the
roles these components play in optimization and experimentally demonstrate
their significance for model performance. Finally, by adjusting these
components, we enable non-contrastive SSL to achieve outstanding performance in
STS.
|
[
-0.3477559983730316,
-0.3709413409233093,
0.4026074707508087,
0.2874382734298706,
-0.43634670972824097,
0.08061979711055756,
-0.22326375544071198,
-0.28090912103652954,
0.08366576582193375,
0.4150215983390808,
-0.4760432839393616,
-0.46383994817733765,
-0.6096662282943726,
0.13231536746025085,
-0.4622606039047241,
1.3422080278396606,
0.0811258852481842,
0.3106616735458374,
-0.36421021819114685,
-0.6211365461349487,
-0.2786043882369995,
-0.49045225977897644,
-0.531846284866333,
-0.674680769443512,
0.4821139872074127,
-0.07023108005523682,
0.5764885544776917,
0.6623560190200806,
0.7252947688102722,
0.35048604011535645,
-0.09728595614433289,
-0.19775183498859406,
-0.641972005367279,
0.19800561666488647,
-0.2302428036928177,
-0.6754469871520996,
0.19298231601715088,
0.09594617784023285,
0.741581916809082,
1.0355374813079834,
-0.25593891739845276,
-0.15332449972629547,
0.666765034198761,
1.1297391653060913,
-0.6324114203453064,
-0.08413661271333694,
-0.51324462890625,
0.47935938835144043,
-0.15562601387500763,
-0.2759447991847992,
-0.4074549674987793,
0.029674697667360306,
0.017731115221977234,
-0.6894371509552002,
0.5471199750900269,
0.20703125,
0.801651656627655,
0.4508310854434967,
-0.6854021549224854,
-0.17119364440441132,
-0.5760544538497925,
0.9284678101539612,
-0.4206065535545349,
0.34355229139328003,
-0.10196464508771896,
0.03314632549881935,
-0.03340610861778259,
-0.8350198268890381,
-0.3931695818901062,
-0.39440351724624634,
-0.2957172691822052,
0.5025759339332581,
-0.2850361764431,
0.3023879826068878,
0.059827130287885666,
0.5970903635025024,
-0.7482738494873047,
0.15112082660198212,
-0.30789005756378174,
-0.24627700448036194,
0.41609928011894226,
0.2276921570301056,
0.1972934752702713,
-0.2611549496650696,
-0.814030110836029,
0.0007512738229706883,
-0.578921914100647,
0.09761189669370651,
0.18325719237327576,
0.4018835127353668,
-0.08995882421731949,
0.2679036557674408,
-0.04183473438024521,
0.48020389676094055,
0.13923946022987366,
0.40888920426368713,
0.22919712960720062,
-0.49588650465011597,
-0.3058854043483734,
-0.2067120522260666,
0.8601734042167664,
0.4425767958164215,
0.11196450889110565,
-0.16689163446426392,
-0.21178674697875977,
0.13571719825267792,
0.5858815312385559,
-0.5996193289756775,
-0.3661918640136719,
-0.11195787042379379,
-0.8541395664215088,
-0.31726691126823425,
0.046522267162799835,
-0.665131151676178,
-0.30291488766670227,
-0.5959547758102417,
0.2991445064544678,
-0.4176742136478424,
-0.03940228745341301,
-0.018604712560772896,
-0.21848097443580627,
0.09509558975696564,
0.28343522548675537,
-1.044519066810608,
0.6450342535972595,
0.5501353740692139,
0.8711705207824707,
-0.264783650636673,
-0.3829622268676758,
-0.44513246417045593,
-0.024114614352583885,
-0.48893630504608154,
0.5783696174621582,
-0.39157217741012573,
-0.3566828668117523,
0.13281424343585968,
-0.36219945549964905,
-0.26538440585136414,
-0.5294999480247498,
0.5359157919883728,
-0.49251559376716614,
0.38084420561790466,
-0.3288535177707672,
-0.7171527147293091,
-0.13164100050926208,
0.027883850038051605,
-0.8319984674453735,
1.0079504251480103,
-0.0002760036149993539,
-0.9871065616607666,
0.18482272326946259,
-0.5550004839897156,
-0.39543572068214417,
0.01179127860814333,
-0.30364736914634705,
-0.2234744131565094,
0.44632527232170105,
-0.08069344609975815,
0.596304178237915,
-0.26227766275405884,
0.021124929189682007,
-0.0794646367430687,
-0.5213707089424133,
0.06951692700386047,
-0.12121372669935226,
0.7109521627426147,
0.3258379101753235,
-0.2298489511013031,
0.13817031681537628,
-0.6413767337799072,
-0.2469848245382309,
0.027686767280101776,
-0.22438639402389526,
-0.5478662848472595,
-0.1568749099969864,
0.1478753536939621,
0.14707492291927338,
0.11510574072599411,
-0.4650411009788513,
-0.1591784507036209,
-0.34502270817756653,
0.4599294364452362,
0.8616682291030884,
-0.19050459563732147,
0.8231980204582214,
-0.11250641942024231,
0.41413992643356323,
0.1882268488407135,
0.026196669787168503,
-0.025911638513207436,
-0.17476747930049896,
-0.9469829797744751,
-0.07702209055423737,
0.4946497678756714,
0.3076591491699219,
-0.7410284280776978,
0.16866818070411682,
0.0232161246240139,
-0.3755573332309723,
-0.5918577313423157,
0.25245121121406555,
0.711281418800354,
0.9120995402336121,
0.6602655053138733,
-0.3321186900138855,
-0.4857136011123657,
-1.100240707397461,
-0.4510473310947418,
-0.2138006091117859,
-0.04100856930017471,
-0.06399601697921753,
0.5298586487770081,
0.018952934071421623,
0.6482754349708557,
-0.4237807095050812,
-0.49873557686805725,
-0.38309359550476074,
0.4814837872982025,
0.037657689303159714,
0.6126633286476135,
0.6013990640640259,
-0.9928141832351685,
-0.544906735420227,
-0.09264625608921051,
-0.824163019657135,
-0.04246820881962776,
-0.24299316108226776,
0.10547305643558502,
0.2717403471469879,
0.8471008539199829,
-0.38883185386657715,
0.29007574915885925,
0.4955732524394989,
-0.1391756683588028,
0.35012826323509216,
-0.5471397042274475,
0.009525035507977009,
-0.8555065989494324,
0.02203184738755226,
0.5488946437835693,
-0.009459609165787697,
-0.7412665486335754,
0.20996561646461487,
0.2594946324825287,
0.06939883530139923,
-0.1414966583251953,
0.21940112113952637,
-0.29503026604652405,
-0.06134534254670143,
-0.13454397022724152,
0.3175415098667145,
0.17414961755275726,
0.6454973816871643,
-0.12215647101402283,
0.7996386885643005,
0.4728650450706482,
-0.6961578726768494,
0.08569584786891937,
-0.033816948533058167,
-0.10210369527339935,
0.8424352407455444,
-0.7187643647193909,
-0.3229210674762726,
-0.5639117360115051,
0.46641936898231506,
-1.1397223472595215,
0.32777395844459534,
0.12119126319885254,
-0.3255910277366638,
0.3630383312702179,
0.0975007489323616,
-0.1295308768749237,
-0.034400876611471176,
-0.48812413215637207,
0.36029109358787537,
0.5508713722229004,
-0.582314133644104,
0.4885745644569397,
0.11574596911668777,
0.06320979446172714,
-0.8719677925109863,
-0.9236255884170532,
-0.06768214702606201,
-0.3395157754421234,
-0.3307938873767853,
0.8255839347839355,
-0.019498953595757484,
-0.21359635889530182,
0.10817590355873108,
-0.1516241580247879,
0.01910766214132309,
0.11015603691339493,
0.07265257835388184,
0.25496888160705566,
-0.18642471730709076,
0.5622976422309875,
-0.1324682980775833,
-0.42564645409584045,
0.05421353876590729,
-0.24716559052467346,
0.3666072189807892,
-0.304975301027298,
-0.23493598401546478,
-0.6984727382659912,
0.4568009674549103,
0.0028420875314623117,
-0.19043917953968048,
0.6767734885215759,
0.700167715549469,
-0.04029400274157524,
-0.25129950046539307,
-0.39572179317474365,
-0.04492253065109253,
-0.4519803822040558,
0.3512532711029053,
-0.38494789600372314,
-0.9453957080841064,
0.6619508862495422,
-0.09278716892004013,
-0.05565965548157692,
0.8192784190177917,
0.3151097297668457,
-0.5566606521606445,
0.6209221482276917,
0.8369097113609314,
-0.0140135632827878,
0.5458964109420776,
-0.25248855352401733,
0.027501937001943588,
-1.0777089595794678,
-0.37358322739601135,
-0.7254208922386169,
-0.3155916631221771,
-0.9053913950920105,
-0.3269325792789459,
0.027599308639764786,
0.10252446681261063,
-0.21848417818546295,
0.19140972197055817,
-0.43200597167015076,
0.4333176910877228,
0.5818055868148804,
-0.0804741308093071,
0.21639852225780487,
-0.06195757910609245,
-0.3629498779773712,
-0.2848198413848877,
-0.6540899276733398,
-0.4707448482513428,
0.9101340770721436,
0.20527780055999756,
0.807289719581604,
-0.09842745214700699,
0.9986170530319214,
0.4838586747646332,
0.01006670668721199,
-0.4358981251716614,
0.4661119878292084,
-0.45794010162353516,
-0.22232620418071747,
-0.23737525939941406,
-0.531463086605072,
-1.1821297407150269,
0.7785651087760925,
-0.1881323605775833,
-0.36504343152046204,
0.01926812343299389,
0.3047795593738556,
-0.2545810043811798,
0.11525369435548782,
-0.5624929666519165,
0.9904202818870544,
0.02197519689798355,
-0.40732941031455994,
-0.3733662962913513,
-1.123091220855713,
0.06201489269733429,
0.34066227078437805,
0.19974741339683533,
0.30494773387908936,
-0.3009597659111023,
0.6709440350532532,
-0.09752356261014938,
0.7251086235046387,
-0.15773136913776398,
0.01120485458523035,
-0.006592209450900555,
-0.012862500734627247,
0.16386455297470093,
-0.3037329912185669,
-0.02139086090028286,
0.24501754343509674,
-0.21414399147033691,
-0.602066159248352,
-0.913909912109375,
0.7828973531723022,
-0.7216607928276062,
-0.49418696761131287,
-0.47204357385635376,
-0.27248626947402954,
-0.021228058263659477,
-0.02793535590171814,
0.3201502561569214,
0.5154290795326233,
-0.43584319949150085,
0.31872761249542236,
0.8619406819343567,
-0.03567114099860191,
0.5282599925994873,
0.2231498807668686,
-0.02433163858950138,
-0.14233621954917908,
0.8964318633079529,
0.1611010581254959,
0.23308506608009338,
0.7992298603057861,
0.12622442841529846,
-0.5048365592956543,
-0.8521826267242432,
-0.19529105722904205,
0.1780177354812622,
-1.023833155632019,
0.0542854480445385,
-0.5691072940826416,
-0.1845429390668869,
-0.22763729095458984,
-0.2705543339252472,
-0.1782347857952118,
-0.40011104941368103,
-0.620924711227417,
-0.2147788256406784,
-0.1858110874891281,
0.8854073286056519,
-0.1798923909664154,
0.16892755031585693,
-0.5640273690223694,
0.3307758569717407,
0.24507169425487518,
0.24978165328502655,
0.055773455649614334,
-0.5293455719947815,
-0.22374612092971802,
-0.2674519717693329,
-0.30536091327667236,
-0.6128389239311218,
0.23134715855121613,
0.2980140149593353,
0.7053207755088806,
0.29789966344833374,
0.11290187388658524,
0.6479707360267639,
-0.5762449502944946,
0.9111807942390442,
0.4406946897506714,
-0.9600260853767395,
0.4224663972854614,
-0.1811126321554184,
0.10089435428380966,
0.7958007454872131,
0.40064388513565063,
-0.6135883331298828,
-0.42119210958480835,
-0.6827138066291809,
-0.76594078540802,
0.5014961361885071,
0.4119364321231842,
0.3784109354019165,
0.10982708632946014,
0.35422950983047485,
0.15989762544631958,
0.19296738505363464,
-1.0614105463027954,
-0.43429139256477356,
-0.5545467734336853,
-0.4461103677749634,
-0.23281772434711456,
-0.19177456200122833,
-0.10942045599222183,
0.07558060437440872,
0.44884976744651794,
-0.15291044116020203,
0.17932645976543427,
0.314601331949234,
-0.21540120244026184,
0.07422598451375961,
0.29513564705848694,
0.47052228450775146,
0.3941495418548584,
-0.03657502308487892,
0.41647571325302124,
0.029369957745075226,
-0.1445881426334381,
-0.10370644181966782,
-0.03441822901368141,
0.0378759503364563,
-0.029888330027461052,
0.7628465890884399,
0.7307536602020264,
0.29796022176742554,
-0.397079199552536,
0.6207618117332458,
-0.20748162269592285,
-0.23873496055603027,
-0.016352960839867592,
0.037705954164266586,
-0.054958149790763855,
0.18410083651542664,
0.4264000952243805,
0.26337963342666626,
0.44672149419784546,
-0.49268975853919983,
0.18162445724010468,
0.5490263104438782,
-0.5816226601600647,
-0.03352031856775284,
0.4792538583278656,
0.5457826852798462,
-0.21023696660995483,
0.6726536154747009,
-0.10290934145450592,
-0.599289059638977,
0.6727486252784729,
0.5480865836143494,
0.6524622440338135,
-0.20511728525161743,
0.4307954013347626,
0.3892408013343811,
0.19258461892604828,
0.014335001818835735,
-0.027274811640381813,
-0.3196985423564911,
-0.6172184944152832,
-0.22487115859985352,
-0.4305277466773987,
-0.2252184897661209,
-0.2179890125989914,
-0.9713749289512634,
-0.19486120343208313,
-0.4161839485168457,
0.21569065749645233,
0.12524668872356415,
0.05740347504615784,
-0.5675032138824463,
0.30695340037345886,
-0.02461310662329197,
0.6007015705108643,
-1.0170729160308838,
0.5611804723739624,
0.5167655944824219,
-0.5916644334793091,
-0.4290178120136261,
0.2146935760974884,
-0.06492850929498672,
-0.8073359727859497,
0.9693989753723145,
0.3495384156703949,
-0.25626587867736816,
-0.09340288490056992,
-0.38974547386169434,
-0.5588572025299072,
1.138304591178894,
0.30039188265800476,
-0.5893736481666565,
0.08821304142475128,
0.08709049224853516,
0.9490928649902344,
-0.5457363724708557,
0.09812522679567337,
0.20508670806884766,
0.1415652334690094,
0.1033158227801323,
-0.632731020450592,
0.06952839344739914,
-0.31403881311416626,
0.5372820496559143,
0.23772621154785156,
-0.7592137455940247,
0.9145092964172363,
-0.06452307105064392,
-0.3840131163597107,
-0.0018752946052700281,
0.8640948534011841,
0.03015095926821232,
0.3678204119205475,
0.3197232186794281,
0.6463126540184021,
0.801486611366272,
-0.11341498047113419,
1.3804304599761963,
-0.2603467106819153,
0.5086760520935059,
0.9820063710212708,
-0.22619085013866425,
0.7303083539009094,
0.7490191459655762,
-0.1892610639333725,
0.7315088510513306,
0.5958639979362488,
-0.03201089799404144,
0.7084280252456665,
0.420272558927536,
-0.09379968047142029,
-0.32079237699508667,
-0.2166101187467575,
-0.36656180024147034,
0.31429415941238403,
0.04059530794620514,
-0.4776342511177063,
-0.2905218005180359,
-0.013471911661326885,
-0.3006907105445862,
0.6374346017837524,
-0.33932042121887207,
0.8335344195365906,
0.1438302844762802,
-0.6089328527450562,
0.41324663162231445,
-0.09633766114711761,
0.6816104054450989,
-0.6441959738731384,
-0.11061422526836395,
-0.25945737957954407,
0.09396648406982422,
-0.13789460062980652,
-0.7008095979690552,
0.2881513833999634,
-0.33885279297828674,
-0.26261502504348755,
-0.34004107117652893,
0.6776030659675598,
-0.41205886006355286,
-0.2406332641839981,
0.6189297437667847,
0.42616307735443115,
-0.06721271574497223,
0.21416516602039337,
-0.9591697454452515,
0.015150311402976513,
-0.03930537402629852,
-0.04588804021477699,
0.6021102666854858,
0.4205310642719269,
0.3845382332801819,
0.798791229724884,
0.4044729769229889,
-0.05652683973312378,
-0.18204456567764282,
0.28903844952583313,
0.8119720816612244,
-0.8298075795173645,
-0.593208372592926,
-0.9472609758377075,
0.5852737426757812,
-0.320997953414917,
-0.31889015436172485,
0.7719779014587402,
0.39346596598625183,
0.9781654477119446,
-0.0011846942361444235,
0.6072245240211487,
0.2367667704820633,
0.3107074201107025,
-0.8534219861030579,
0.406282514333725,
-0.7704742550849915,
0.19930604100227356,
-0.2531231641769409,
-0.7873961329460144,
-0.617514431476593,
0.8777162432670593,
0.01131664589047432,
0.1655077338218689,
1.121813178062439,
0.5895744562149048,
0.18955276906490326,
0.1718735545873642,
0.3238205909729004,
-0.043298184871673584,
0.16305942833423615,
0.43718573451042175,
0.9478352069854736,
-0.4508081376552582,
0.5976310968399048,
-0.1738838106393814,
-0.007178351748734713,
-0.11480233818292618,
-0.9466310143470764,
-0.9198092818260193,
-0.7728810906410217,
-0.3686748445034027,
-0.09911681711673737,
0.13077490031719208,
0.7814068794250488,
0.6130927205085754,
-0.5819982886314392,
-0.1551797240972519,
-0.5257554650306702,
0.1495293229818344,
-0.22465653717517853,
-0.2038118988275528,
0.463827520608902,
-0.7901935577392578,
-0.512940526008606,
0.1379997879266739,
0.48372361063957214,
0.015934651717543602,
-0.2772628962993622,
-0.15613995492458344,
-0.10381269454956055,
-0.032413382083177567,
0.5453320741653442,
0.051328785717487335,
-0.8663433790206909,
-0.08358436077833176,
-0.46235769987106323,
-0.4033554494380951,
0.22465746104717255,
1.0700531005859375,
-0.7899171113967896,
0.349895179271698,
0.40535086393356323,
0.7664923071861267,
0.4009700417518616,
0.007554394658654928,
0.4426822364330292,
-0.8634995222091675,
-0.09389768540859222,
0.3227880299091339,
0.5126901268959045,
0.4707117974758148,
-0.21432913839817047,
0.7353262901306152,
0.2791178822517395,
-0.5581535696983337,
-0.5634741187095642,
0.4480723738670349,
-1.0327174663543701,
-0.4434814453125,
0.8067219257354736,
-0.26583924889564514,
0.054788511246442795,
-0.09351779520511627,
-0.1809331774711609,
0.1732754111289978,
-0.5258637070655823,
0.8383923172950745,
0.7059481143951416,
-0.4379715919494629,
-0.22192968428134918,
-0.22272683680057526,
0.6254832744598389,
0.7642203569412231,
-0.5341634750366211,
0.09104055911302567,
0.4543869197368622,
0.14619489014148712,
0.3601818084716797,
0.6067299842834473,
-0.007830537855625153,
0.0777861699461937,
-0.07573607563972473,
-0.17748913168907166,
0.15103863179683685,
-0.26958996057510376,
-0.8364145755767822,
0.4668099284172058,
-0.10709145665168762,
-0.20477281510829926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18275v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18275v3
|
Exploration of Adapter for Noise Robust Automatic Speech Recognition
| 2024-02-28T12:06:08 | 2024-06-04T08:20:02 |
Hao Shi, Tatsuya Kawahara
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Adapting an automatic speech recognition (ASR) system to unseen noise
environments is crucial. Integrating adapters into neural networks has emerged
as a potent technique for transfer learning. This study thoroughly investigates
adapter-based ASR adaptation in noisy environments. We conducted experiments
using the CHiME--4 dataset. The results show that inserting the adapter in the
shallow layer yields superior effectiveness, and there is no significant
difference between adapting solely within the shallow layer and adapting across
all layers. The simulated data helps the system to improve its performance
under real noise conditions. Nonetheless, when the amount of data is the same,
the real data is more effective than the simulated data. Multi-condition
training is still useful for adapter training. Furthermore, integrating
adapters into speech enhancement-based ASR systems yields substantial
improvements.
|
[
-0.2143237143754959,
-0.3430320918560028,
0.2387377768754959,
0.2401748150587082,
-0.19838827848434448,
-0.06874828785657883,
-0.1913059651851654,
-0.8195719122886658,
-0.36455076932907104,
-0.0040316954255104065,
-0.09220177680253983,
0.06673162430524826,
-0.608003556728363,
0.07303021103143692,
-0.5356929302215576,
0.5024704337120056,
0.29275035858154297,
0.08888387680053711,
0.23936520516872406,
-0.29210203886032104,
-0.6380196809768677,
-0.3003218472003937,
-0.9447632431983948,
-0.22549110651016235,
0.026247525587677956,
0.07490971684455872,
0.42130813002586365,
0.5811839699745178,
0.49272528290748596,
0.4753973186016083,
-0.0675148218870163,
-0.19704674184322357,
-0.25001880526542664,
0.1998795121908188,
-0.15713448822498322,
-0.405013769865036,
-0.13125187158584595,
-0.3233562409877777,
0.8287573456764221,
0.42407143115997314,
-0.1361178606748581,
-0.09012837707996368,
0.3895268440246582,
0.4462701082229614,
-0.48225927352905273,
0.27310922741889954,
-0.8251153826713562,
0.11128885298967361,
-0.004374671261757612,
-0.08487915247678757,
0.05988582223653793,
-0.1745625138282776,
0.4625912010669708,
-0.5578130483627319,
0.22774825990200043,
-0.15375427901744843,
0.41982126235961914,
0.6497692465782166,
-0.07056989520788193,
-0.36860817670822144,
-1.0745422840118408,
0.6245355010032654,
-0.6779177784919739,
0.7846040725708008,
0.14085592329502106,
0.4676014184951782,
-0.042712461203336716,
-0.6085838079452515,
-0.31259119510650635,
0.16720014810562134,
0.2091435045003891,
0.2933591902256012,
-0.5070480704307556,
-0.1095372885465622,
0.12178437411785126,
0.4349042773246765,
-0.16238930821418762,
0.09842276573181152,
-0.636146605014801,
-0.46857503056526184,
0.44422027468681335,
-0.27821552753448486,
0.0616772286593914,
0.2564398944377899,
0.07597942650318146,
-0.2336837351322174,
0.040225379168987274,
0.3489053249359131,
0.0931384488940239,
0.46735307574272156,
-0.3542157709598541,
-0.16451217234134674,
0.0423254631459713,
0.808828592300415,
0.33409422636032104,
-0.1988101601600647,
0.4024401605129242,
-0.42601966857910156,
0.00012707168934866786,
0.5156412124633789,
0.531980574131012,
-0.04339843615889549,
0.2951755225658417,
-0.16599202156066895,
-0.5507186055183411,
0.059175100177526474,
0.4739830195903778,
-0.775946855545044,
-0.6800330281257629,
-0.21355460584163666,
-0.5215819478034973,
-0.4460712671279907,
-0.00225082621909678,
-0.623754620552063,
-0.37490513920783997,
-0.3065130114555359,
0.9108338952064514,
-0.44455021619796753,
-0.124310202896595,
0.08443569391965866,
-0.286114901304245,
0.34238171577453613,
0.4889093339443207,
-0.6184062361717224,
0.6261410117149353,
0.10704441368579865,
1.004000186920166,
-0.02193070761859417,
-0.1376175880432129,
-0.8440219759941101,
0.02495555207133293,
-0.35473522543907166,
1.0291815996170044,
-0.37819769978523254,
-0.3519298732280731,
-0.2949274778366089,
0.12391858547925949,
-0.3865189254283905,
-0.8788362741470337,
0.9069680571556091,
-0.2789117991924286,
-0.08825936168432236,
0.020128531381487846,
-0.04685386270284653,
-0.14250992238521576,
-0.07994133979082108,
-0.4581427276134491,
0.6345682740211487,
0.12669889628887177,
-0.29244884848594666,
0.2800147831439972,
-0.9980970621109009,
-0.5984419584274292,
-0.2567007839679718,
0.043117836117744446,
-0.6259202361106873,
0.22652257978916168,
0.2318134903907776,
0.07878473401069641,
0.1968700885772705,
-0.43297597765922546,
-0.15163195133209229,
-0.6141762137413025,
0.5868939161300659,
-0.4750339388847351,
0.6610435843467712,
0.39678332209587097,
-0.38823679089546204,
0.049097634851932526,
-1.0208369493484497,
-0.08284459263086319,
-0.09474977850914001,
-0.6753233671188354,
-0.3993333876132965,
-0.06085031107068062,
0.0810777023434639,
0.13827826082706451,
-0.41140806674957275,
-0.4878886044025421,
-0.3755602538585663,
-0.36475107073783875,
0.7021299600601196,
0.6640610098838806,
0.051466502249240875,
0.5620729923248291,
-0.5100534558296204,
0.32296058535575867,
0.3210804760456085,
0.04188204184174538,
0.08235370367765427,
-0.3603132963180542,
-0.8143598437309265,
-0.21668316423892975,
0.4617805778980255,
0.5380688309669495,
-0.35923731327056885,
0.4970964193344116,
-0.07521338015794754,
-0.14685724675655365,
-0.7686221599578857,
0.08761269599199295,
0.04371108487248421,
0.6606390476226807,
0.5185169577598572,
-0.27758246660232544,
-0.6215832829475403,
-0.5625312328338623,
-0.270216703414917,
-0.17325416207313538,
-0.2312328964471817,
0.43763983249664307,
0.06743714213371277,
-0.37555474042892456,
0.4081246554851532,
0.10657978802919388,
-0.47827470302581787,
0.06408857554197311,
-0.2966959774494171,
0.18791323900222778,
0.6779294610023499,
0.7458174228668213,
-0.45843592286109924,
-0.3629723787307739,
-0.023832397535443306,
-0.33917737007141113,
-0.16018499433994293,
-0.16844311356544495,
0.028382087126374245,
-0.13581803441047668,
0.37895429134368896,
0.15307524800300598,
0.6226559281349182,
0.730603039264679,
0.009790078736841679,
0.2244146764278412,
-0.036806318908929825,
0.003688293509185314,
-0.9528672695159912,
0.0020211555529385805,
-0.07343214750289917,
-0.3224252760410309,
-0.9491676092147827,
-0.4690704345703125,
-0.09462500363588333,
-0.2779897451400757,
0.03776383399963379,
0.09162978827953339,
-0.4117613732814789,
-0.2716499865055084,
-0.48114901781082153,
-0.0035400011111050844,
-0.10243798047304153,
-0.03479243442416191,
0.0059961299411952496,
0.9022953510284424,
1.1214966773986816,
-0.9182420372962952,
0.11268641799688339,
0.33539578318595886,
-0.2026306539773941,
0.4939592182636261,
-0.7395173907279968,
0.44100046157836914,
-0.03485998883843422,
0.09895951300859451,
-0.8893373608589172,
-0.10976314544677734,
0.3886755704879761,
-0.33605313301086426,
0.31098848581314087,
-0.28825053572654724,
0.24597367644309998,
-0.08982739597558975,
-0.3435221016407013,
0.5056746602058411,
0.6439480185508728,
-0.7720910906791687,
0.7042774558067322,
0.4662074148654938,
-0.12456690520048141,
-0.16072770953178406,
-0.9135675430297852,
0.08675392717123032,
-0.4269086718559265,
-0.19960489869117737,
0.2289600819349289,
-0.2414570301771164,
-0.12855853140354156,
-0.14224745333194733,
-0.42871350049972534,
-0.3225615322589874,
0.15520988404750824,
0.34662267565727234,
0.008349340409040451,
-0.48640745878219604,
-0.18821601569652557,
-0.1963108479976654,
0.026251090690493584,
0.08333329856395721,
-0.34730014204978943,
0.19486767053604126,
-0.3573075234889984,
-0.25027409195899963,
-0.892703115940094,
-0.07798518985509872,
0.3700202703475952,
0.18073679506778717,
0.1782243847846985,
0.8077003359794617,
-0.5179705023765564,
-0.3281329274177551,
-0.46878138184547424,
-0.44401034712791443,
-0.553398847579956,
0.4117366075515747,
-0.5673148036003113,
-0.42267102003097534,
0.5184553861618042,
-0.07915661484003067,
0.14990362524986267,
0.11461450904607773,
0.011188182048499584,
-0.17421841621398926,
0.47585150599479675,
0.5057100057601929,
-0.42459917068481445,
0.7432560324668884,
0.11289167404174805,
0.22347784042358398,
-1.0132485628128052,
0.010624557733535767,
-0.8219909071922302,
-0.6312192678451538,
-0.3529391884803772,
-0.39277103543281555,
0.3382190763950348,
0.01374155655503273,
-0.16464778780937195,
0.18329839408397675,
-0.5653610825538635,
0.19414068758487701,
0.45124512910842896,
0.3791218101978302,
0.1377524882555008,
0.2167312502861023,
0.3080770671367645,
-0.021650495007634163,
-0.8647768497467041,
0.14990557730197906,
0.7809959650039673,
0.4399275481700897,
0.9474918246269226,
0.29786476492881775,
0.5314763784408569,
0.14193876087665558,
-0.130544051527977,
-0.8908676505088806,
0.04795930162072182,
-0.21304287016391754,
-0.04681577533483505,
-0.46359366178512573,
-0.327666312456131,
-1.0006771087646484,
-0.024703437462449074,
-0.3329496681690216,
-0.5419248342514038,
0.977435290813446,
0.3948148488998413,
-0.6315726637840271,
-0.00008139556302921847,
-0.6565498113632202,
0.1496000736951828,
-0.2229991853237152,
-0.07368839532136917,
-0.10421302169561386,
-0.6997564435005188,
-0.0835014283657074,
-0.4143085479736328,
0.4698481261730194,
0.29899752140045166,
0.20717254281044006,
0.956791341304779,
0.07650764286518097,
0.6842505931854248,
-0.4138639271259308,
0.12267513573169708,
0.37550657987594604,
0.096871517598629,
0.5204222798347473,
-0.20110350847244263,
-0.4060326814651489,
0.20383714139461517,
-0.09865069389343262,
-0.1804845780134201,
-0.4747185707092285,
0.6223955154418945,
-1.2380307912826538,
-0.21708759665489197,
-0.32769885659217834,
-0.874575674533844,
-0.2962428629398346,
0.13453693687915802,
0.11529231816530228,
0.654293417930603,
0.03194083645939827,
0.5403961539268494,
0.649022102355957,
-0.14615756273269653,
0.45388638973236084,
0.5746017694473267,
0.06890029460191727,
-0.4811599850654602,
1.0738028287887573,
0.2154456079006195,
0.1484505534172058,
-0.2195271998643875,
0.6046620011329651,
-0.24127839505672455,
-0.8408117294311523,
-0.34220704436302185,
-0.18233834207057953,
-0.5874235033988953,
-0.21251505613327026,
-0.7315747737884521,
-1.0010020732879639,
-0.4500260055065155,
-0.12297189235687256,
-0.35510823130607605,
-0.36598119139671326,
-0.40940335392951965,
0.22670936584472656,
0.41041862964630127,
0.6650744676589966,
-0.5068619251251221,
0.3288786709308624,
-0.5573063492774963,
0.4059765636920929,
0.5804786086082458,
0.3719038665294647,
-0.1252339482307434,
-1.282822608947754,
-0.1515626609325409,
-0.07661009579896927,
-0.04607954993844032,
-0.5580787062644958,
0.08870560675859451,
1.0613354444503784,
0.7788999080657959,
0.6066204309463501,
0.27714359760284424,
0.9806550741195679,
-0.2137863039970398,
0.2658286392688751,
-0.23667842149734497,
-0.8564816117286682,
0.598214864730835,
-0.22569474577903748,
0.5982259511947632,
0.6520097851753235,
-0.09341245144605637,
-0.13007350265979767,
-0.195530503988266,
-0.35138383507728577,
-0.4233921766281128,
0.8471677303314209,
0.30371129512786865,
0.16654768586158752,
0.7352240085601807,
0.6665011048316956,
-0.03420163691043854,
-0.08883288502693176,
-0.6112383008003235,
-0.013669157400727272,
-0.7578237652778625,
-0.1820198893547058,
-0.03419032320380211,
0.1362581104040146,
-0.15490566194057465,
-0.5489292740821838,
0.5301382541656494,
-0.18301747739315033,
0.5147003531455994,
0.20641253888607025,
-0.1271030753850937,
-0.4102015793323517,
0.24311132729053497,
0.37275752425193787,
0.2785938084125519,
-0.24859757721424103,
0.3113665282726288,
0.6333411931991577,
-0.7292537093162537,
0.10107263922691345,
0.39253899455070496,
-0.07220911979675293,
-0.025246920064091682,
0.37205860018730164,
0.7652260065078735,
0.11743438243865967,
-0.25695517659187317,
0.41215676069259644,
-0.29013049602508545,
-0.44429925084114075,
-0.23047064244747162,
0.5838830471038818,
-0.08559077233076096,
0.40712985396385193,
0.2260454148054123,
0.8433857560157776,
0.5913102030754089,
-0.5591400861740112,
0.2871033847332001,
0.37041568756103516,
-0.7809607982635498,
-0.6273019909858704,
0.6117549538612366,
0.22275499999523163,
-0.6746079325675964,
0.46588677167892456,
0.30718114972114563,
-0.533930242061615,
0.24736250936985016,
1.0817806720733643,
0.7534115314483643,
-0.8546745181083679,
-0.4536263346672058,
0.3714568018913269,
0.3561461269855499,
0.04842844977974892,
0.2354859858751297,
-0.3684215843677521,
-0.9043274521827698,
-0.1291397660970688,
-0.6026143431663513,
-0.32867804169654846,
0.2914040684700012,
-0.7622722387313843,
0.30583155155181885,
-0.4689044654369354,
-0.007518609054386616,
-0.05904064327478409,
-0.5008784532546997,
-0.6680942177772522,
0.16456274688243866,
0.10222682356834412,
0.6281306743621826,
-0.953856885433197,
0.9052198529243469,
0.905459463596344,
0.30615732073783875,
-0.7208966016769409,
0.3158770799636841,
0.2523936927318573,
-0.9817146062850952,
-0.0170778539031744,
0.032396674156188965,
-0.539761483669281,
0.09044234454631805,
-0.13339971005916595,
-0.9163713455200195,
0.926266074180603,
0.37762272357940674,
-0.6671640276908875,
0.5191555023193359,
0.005817065946757793,
0.6340593695640564,
-0.19280654191970825,
-0.059647396206855774,
0.600925087928772,
0.3612227141857147,
0.19761881232261658,
-1.0714848041534424,
-0.020862475037574768,
-0.4225056767463684,
-0.026975875720381737,
-0.22405444085597992,
-0.5876666307449341,
0.4669475555419922,
-0.1334010511636734,
-0.010637101717293262,
-0.047286342829465866,
0.48324939608573914,
0.13886262476444244,
0.3435857594013214,
1.1822082996368408,
0.0867566168308258,
0.7434309124946594,
0.17795155942440033,
0.33002281188964844,
-0.30776041746139526,
-0.24174098670482635,
1.0576080083847046,
-0.07242649048566818,
0.6600804924964905,
0.2790409028530121,
-0.11584301292896271,
0.32757115364074707,
0.28087732195854187,
0.1207512617111206,
0.6702709794044495,
0.11449070274829865,
-0.37995749711990356,
-0.0597473606467247,
-0.0847058966755867,
-0.5943811535835266,
0.673414409160614,
0.3523862957954407,
-0.20071293413639069,
-0.030902894213795662,
0.16364286839962006,
-0.49311959743499756,
-0.18132013082504272,
-0.2164933830499649,
1.2734166383743286,
0.13675235211849213,
0.0314771942794323,
0.4429205060005188,
-0.4613952338695526,
0.6340606212615967,
-0.4329872131347656,
-0.02074316330254078,
0.02663712576031685,
0.37045392394065857,
-0.4282199740409851,
-0.4508498013019562,
0.6882086396217346,
-0.1882936954498291,
-0.07295292615890503,
0.11421551555395126,
1.250921368598938,
-0.19704701006412506,
-0.5317208766937256,
0.2849678695201874,
0.3216266334056854,
0.3380792438983917,
-0.008580290712416172,
-0.609646737575531,
0.2845667898654938,
0.04896590858697891,
0.0827961266040802,
0.4755997955799103,
0.6278577446937561,
0.2825622856616974,
0.4936898350715637,
0.8439412713050842,
0.2811296582221985,
0.23661619424819946,
0.15187643468379974,
1.1590930223464966,
-0.3723490536212921,
-0.6087175607681274,
-0.43143194913864136,
0.3646945655345917,
0.060059547424316406,
-0.017045671120285988,
0.6406489610671997,
0.5877758860588074,
0.34645482897758484,
0.13834531605243683,
0.9348893761634827,
0.2510785758495331,
0.5093693733215332,
-0.3300575017929077,
0.7587047815322876,
-0.21613912284374237,
0.47926566004753113,
-0.47319716215133667,
-0.8852372765541077,
-0.426581472158432,
1.156092643737793,
0.05454179272055626,
0.10010754317045212,
0.28272369503974915,
0.8709310293197632,
-0.5350878238677979,
0.19821394979953766,
0.4448389708995819,
0.4479323625564575,
0.2308337539434433,
0.08152132481336594,
0.9638795852661133,
-0.863036572933197,
0.8933444619178772,
-0.5276334285736084,
-0.37834998965263367,
0.09481284022331238,
-0.42136839032173157,
-0.7353748679161072,
-0.4407781660556793,
-0.4429025948047638,
-0.4557260572910309,
0.4083768129348755,
0.7098721265792847,
0.9250195026397705,
-1.197966456413269,
-0.3165627121925354,
-0.1782250553369522,
-0.4158610999584198,
-0.4913589358329773,
-0.1884336620569229,
0.21520543098449707,
-0.3102048933506012,
-0.5434495806694031,
0.9680845737457275,
0.05107226222753525,
0.30609285831451416,
0.3768042325973511,
-0.21261833608150482,
0.1828567087650299,
-0.027557844296097755,
0.26451030373573303,
0.34814122319221497,
-0.23419159650802612,
-0.6268681883811951,
-0.21958012878894806,
0.4926452934741974,
0.3153502345085144,
0.6223031878471375,
-0.8484892249107361,
0.6595830917358398,
0.17679180204868317,
0.7686290144920349,
0.33538147807121277,
0.1743668168783188,
0.5486350059509277,
-0.47548311948776245,
0.37462350726127625,
0.16799841821193695,
0.277872771024704,
0.25755465030670166,
-0.40686285495758057,
0.25976476073265076,
0.1094808503985405,
-0.9179467558860779,
-0.8464244604110718,
-0.36916473507881165,
-0.9822384119033813,
0.0014449249720200896,
1.0407096147537231,
0.06351905316114426,
0.11323544383049011,
-0.8039065003395081,
-0.21741724014282227,
0.26705121994018555,
-0.5952558517456055,
1.0812586545944214,
0.17643457651138306,
-0.5311241745948792,
-0.5132966041564941,
-0.3462815582752228,
0.5453342795372009,
0.12428192794322968,
-0.6601722836494446,
-0.24526847898960114,
0.2703196704387665,
0.6038584113121033,
0.25959399342536926,
0.4618615210056305,
0.00755354342982173,
0.35518646240234375,
0.25096940994262695,
-0.27298954129219055,
-0.047372475266456604,
-0.22789178788661957,
-1.0917177200317383,
-0.024550944566726685,
0.37892284989356995,
-0.5539326071739197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18272v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18272v1
|
Rethinking the Bounds of LLM Reasoning: Are Multi-Agent Discussions the Key?
| 2024-02-28T12:04:05 | 2024-02-28T12:04:05 |
Qineng Wang, Zihao Wang, Ying Su, Hanghang Tong, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent progress in LLMs discussion suggests that multi-agent discussion
improves the reasoning abilities of LLMs. In this work, we reevaluate this
claim through systematic experiments, where we propose a novel group discussion
framework to enrich the set of discussion mechanisms. Interestingly, our
results show that a single-agent LLM with strong prompts can achieve almost the
same performance as the best existing discussion approach on a wide range of
reasoning tasks and backbone LLMs. We observe that the multi-agent discussion
performs better than a single agent only when there is no demonstration in the
prompt. Further study reveals the common interaction mechanisms of LLMs during
the discussion.
|
[
-0.8273751735687256,
-0.6820105910301208,
1.0782626867294312,
-0.07790876179933548,
-0.25831106305122375,
0.1712803840637207,
-0.22374944388866425,
-0.5536723136901855,
0.3250586986541748,
0.4150833785533905,
-0.5837131142616272,
-0.3263128995895386,
-0.5498011112213135,
0.3229222893714905,
-0.05199559032917023,
0.5695140957832336,
0.14209140837192535,
0.2263915091753006,
-0.4975268840789795,
-0.516844630241394,
-0.4104638397693634,
-0.612756073474884,
-0.6945188045501709,
-0.6369339823722839,
1.001145362854004,
0.538564145565033,
0.7833308577537537,
0.41260287165641785,
0.44725140929222107,
0.4293825328350067,
-0.2506158947944641,
0.5730644464492798,
-0.29427650570869446,
0.6299924254417419,
-0.23722276091575623,
-0.5498061776161194,
-0.6150149703025818,
0.030967706814408302,
0.5742244124412537,
0.7476745843887329,
-0.07715218514204025,
-0.2315104603767395,
0.11178971827030182,
0.4436943829059601,
-0.3049814701080322,
-0.1870982050895691,
-0.6510556936264038,
0.0823642909526825,
0.040160056203603745,
-0.3761141896247864,
-0.592867910861969,
-0.03816641867160797,
0.11693765223026276,
-0.35788989067077637,
0.21634028851985931,
0.005359593313187361,
0.5285469889640808,
0.5452207922935486,
-0.7456348538398743,
-0.06527723371982574,
-0.5351821184158325,
0.6249960660934448,
-0.5233203768730164,
0.11353950202465057,
0.062091607600450516,
0.49791282415390015,
-0.4594317674636841,
-0.6299237608909607,
-0.4216080605983734,
-0.18913336098194122,
-0.057107534259557724,
-0.08854562789201736,
-0.1623728722333908,
0.3142165541648865,
0.2086992859840393,
0.270338237285614,
-0.14009235799312592,
-0.0033550020307302475,
-0.20947913825511932,
-0.34056708216667175,
0.9147180318832397,
0.4055229723453522,
-0.14552396535873413,
0.25937673449516296,
-0.35593971610069275,
0.3514561653137207,
-0.6965357661247253,
-0.09533561766147614,
0.15239356458187103,
0.24699608981609344,
0.2696666419506073,
0.4279221296310425,
-0.23359283804893494,
0.5116808414459229,
0.1386900395154953,
-0.09326062351465225,
0.0005627927021123469,
-0.6115766763687134,
0.08095574378967285,
-0.3744703531265259,
0.5640461444854736,
0.6927173733711243,
0.10686490684747696,
-0.29251959919929504,
0.06994295865297318,
0.05779432877898216,
0.17004024982452393,
-0.6642275452613831,
0.19668424129486084,
0.14321091771125793,
-0.437636137008667,
0.07584524154663086,
0.061034590005874634,
-0.7043748497962952,
-0.6532430648803711,
-0.2632141411304474,
0.032162584364414215,
0.192510724067688,
-0.2418714463710785,
0.16721780598163605,
-0.4268098771572113,
0.31235048174858093,
1.0709216594696045,
-0.34986746311187744,
0.5128021240234375,
0.6848741173744202,
0.569435715675354,
-0.06266635656356812,
-0.6195372939109802,
-0.5283897519111633,
0.23461346328258514,
-0.32590919733047485,
1.395499587059021,
-0.45570728182792664,
-0.5274152159690857,
-0.1881907433271408,
-0.16960906982421875,
0.006181566510349512,
-0.5197632312774658,
0.4511575996875763,
-0.3952864706516266,
0.14052362740039825,
-0.7242932915687561,
-0.6693830490112305,
0.07440654188394547,
0.6364754438400269,
-0.6592402458190918,
0.33365756273269653,
-0.4901066720485687,
-0.4643794596195221,
0.3752394914627075,
-0.7537853121757507,
-0.27714595198631287,
0.07447084039449692,
-0.4323076605796814,
0.011101811192929745,
0.019334688782691956,
0.15835604071617126,
0.28846442699432373,
-0.5992098450660706,
0.0520344041287899,
-0.5027599334716797,
-0.4674128592014313,
0.755902886390686,
-0.5110471844673157,
0.385688841342926,
0.2677159905433655,
-0.1266372799873352,
0.392047643661499,
-0.15691521763801575,
0.30164635181427,
-0.03110809251666069,
-0.275153785943985,
0.19370007514953613,
-0.03131231665611267,
-0.739578366279602,
0.11085104942321777,
0.10202747583389282,
-0.3403157591819763,
0.6579338312149048,
-0.1365683376789093,
0.49380457401275635,
0.9362050890922546,
0.20054256916046143,
0.6455017328262329,
-0.8502047657966614,
0.5215979218482971,
-0.31578195095062256,
0.45507627725601196,
-0.17475447058677673,
-0.6661064028739929,
-0.7926708459854126,
-0.11180659383535385,
-0.0969415083527565,
0.15599514544010162,
-0.6484043598175049,
-0.14238135516643524,
0.04468025267124176,
-0.3564641773700714,
-0.4793228507041931,
0.0451643280684948,
0.3123067319393158,
-0.019919121637940407,
0.29912683367729187,
-0.029466142877936363,
-0.314095675945282,
-0.8005669713020325,
-0.24091583490371704,
-0.4953654110431671,
0.18167154490947723,
0.30263301730155945,
0.14898784458637238,
-0.20910175144672394,
0.9593298435211182,
-0.25485020875930786,
0.10819746553897858,
-0.6134557127952576,
0.07106431573629379,
-0.06486476212739944,
0.07028637081384659,
0.3043369948863983,
-0.500355064868927,
-0.4321778118610382,
-0.39815375208854675,
-0.7394476532936096,
-0.10898371785879135,
-0.09729047864675522,
-0.21389344334602356,
0.3147904574871063,
0.5182573795318604,
-0.9759782552719116,
0.6116913557052612,
0.22673030197620392,
-0.5224073529243469,
0.5263726711273193,
-0.10444650799036026,
0.2888197600841522,
-0.8529558181762695,
-0.7053298354148865,
-0.2435755729675293,
-0.15636830031871796,
-0.6483588814735413,
0.09633214771747589,
-0.3586517870426178,
0.20507240295410156,
-0.36678314208984375,
0.6771343350410461,
-0.7285891175270081,
0.11958349496126175,
-0.877181887626648,
0.38656383752822876,
0.08158142864704132,
0.47120168805122375,
-0.13944011926651,
0.7261027097702026,
0.6939972043037415,
-0.8650995492935181,
0.4829442501068115,
0.24348367750644684,
0.21115276217460632,
0.6900839805603027,
-0.6807727217674255,
0.4923788905143738,
-0.14895549416542053,
0.7773411273956299,
-1.0270018577575684,
-0.03650174289941788,
0.2418917417526245,
-0.5112178921699524,
-0.05664416402578354,
-0.13516965508460999,
-0.39404723048210144,
-0.2828727662563324,
-0.5812263488769531,
0.4502044916152954,
0.17557935416698456,
-0.467779278755188,
0.8432437777519226,
0.31411513686180115,
0.00123744853772223,
-0.7186782360076904,
-0.47620415687561035,
0.48317572474479675,
-0.3425996005535126,
-1.130033254623413,
0.164097398519516,
-0.31115424633026123,
-0.8331376910209656,
-0.03210612013936043,
-0.10510861128568649,
0.07647348195314407,
0.05587827041745186,
0.2296149581670761,
-0.012395367957651615,
-0.038209397345781326,
0.666217029094696,
-0.1362297534942627,
-0.21138903498649597,
0.0742330327630043,
0.1640651524066925,
0.5188219547271729,
-0.4872482419013977,
-0.612955629825592,
-0.10732626169919968,
0.6254646182060242,
0.5008998513221741,
-0.09643067419528961,
0.6781699061393738,
-0.018579404801130295,
-0.1294778734445572,
-0.32988667488098145,
-0.8267872929573059,
-0.5436763167381287,
-0.5232630372047424,
0.024096161127090454,
-0.5826965570449829,
-1.2273184061050415,
0.7110856175422668,
-0.41665250062942505,
0.10451509803533554,
0.3906254768371582,
0.4336627721786499,
-0.052806269377470016,
0.8988662362098694,
0.643667459487915,
0.38011911511421204,
0.1075049415230751,
-0.08476436883211136,
0.07733548432588577,
-0.8870362043380737,
-0.1376916766166687,
-0.5436238050460815,
-0.33563491702079773,
-0.3135175406932831,
-0.7866285443305969,
0.4157259464263916,
0.04654257744550705,
-0.05785135552287102,
-0.1090812087059021,
-0.32930028438568115,
0.8099395036697388,
0.29003018140792847,
-0.016832776367664337,
0.44205284118652344,
-0.3639582097530365,
-0.17415326833724976,
0.24856019020080566,
-0.8022165298461914,
-0.8543109893798828,
0.9721224904060364,
0.25720641016960144,
0.639676034450531,
0.49797406792640686,
0.5310400128364563,
0.33916082978248596,
0.5565178990364075,
-0.6296032071113586,
1.036534070968628,
0.4761183559894562,
-0.7657202482223511,
-0.6561892032623291,
-0.49723222851753235,
-1.1868271827697754,
0.7334299683570862,
-0.0421881303191185,
-0.6210829019546509,
-0.03425518795847893,
-0.0616680271923542,
-0.1441085934638977,
0.4880931079387665,
-0.5375019907951355,
0.7102846503257751,
-0.19260013103485107,
-0.590510904788971,
-0.34590113162994385,
-0.759788453578949,
0.1964668482542038,
0.39630556106567383,
0.21969200670719147,
-0.24048158526420593,
-0.022782310843467712,
0.5148249864578247,
-0.8034655451774597,
0.7870761752128601,
-0.16778990626335144,
-0.44339263439178467,
0.7766544818878174,
-0.3939319849014282,
0.432474285364151,
0.14091910421848297,
0.06085047498345375,
-0.03976079449057579,
-0.5312879085540771,
-0.43114280700683594,
-0.9903139472007751,
0.3630879819393158,
-0.5773434042930603,
-1.3652604818344116,
-0.36173585057258606,
-0.5057560801506042,
-0.22361569106578827,
-0.18308159708976746,
0.09786923229694366,
0.17310985922813416,
-0.3240060806274414,
0.03062409721314907,
0.5793148875236511,
0.18609581887722015,
0.3781554102897644,
0.6762397885322571,
-0.28442296385765076,
-0.5149982571601868,
0.4596695601940155,
0.08360103517770767,
0.5869497656822205,
0.03175270929932594,
0.27099916338920593,
-0.2982100248336792,
-0.5030262470245361,
-0.29448795318603516,
0.3900533616542816,
-1.160681128501892,
-0.14842061698436737,
-0.6432974934577942,
0.06989697366952896,
-0.4668980538845062,
-0.13893936574459076,
-0.36844903230667114,
-0.6239607930183411,
0.015854835510253906,
-0.3122038245201111,
0.26767510175704956,
0.8923689126968384,
-0.15254966914653778,
0.22237533330917358,
-0.6735853552818298,
-0.03412220999598503,
0.8264060020446777,
0.05291607975959778,
0.1266314685344696,
-0.38059577345848083,
-0.1520557850599289,
-0.13165713846683502,
-0.5189291834831238,
-1.125401258468628,
-0.26037147641181946,
-0.2882869839668274,
1.0846657752990723,
0.456908643245697,
0.19659876823425293,
0.5318057537078857,
-0.3875199854373932,
0.9718168377876282,
0.14893674850463867,
-0.8116768002510071,
0.44959238171577454,
-0.1018974557518959,
0.18828783929347992,
0.39392369985580444,
-0.0650145635008812,
-0.4900539219379425,
-0.7867016792297363,
-0.6704540848731995,
-0.6300274729728699,
0.3877730667591095,
0.17144766449928284,
-0.16639353334903717,
0.0450456328690052,
0.43419572710990906,
0.06308916211128235,
0.14283312857151031,
-0.5328007936477661,
-0.41975197196006775,
0.17025749385356903,
0.39276382327079773,
-0.07911412417888641,
-0.323064386844635,
-0.513323187828064,
-0.20117716491222382,
0.3257034718990326,
-0.3393057584762573,
0.4638374149799347,
0.28957968950271606,
0.17376907169818878,
-0.32981598377227783,
0.7059199213981628,
0.8381175994873047,
0.9301382899284363,
0.23096837103366852,
0.7304637432098389,
0.5051549077033997,
0.08741064369678497,
0.5939611792564392,
0.09460102766752243,
0.22114363312721252,
-0.13423994183540344,
0.5704410672187805,
0.7469130158424377,
-0.30087247490882874,
-0.4465862512588501,
0.3961682915687561,
-0.5572868585586548,
-0.5523982048034668,
-0.04162243381142616,
0.28202584385871887,
0.2857208847999573,
0.8099156022071838,
0.43082618713378906,
0.026691723614931107,
0.025349460542201996,
-0.7164450287818909,
0.3304940164089203,
0.6237915754318237,
0.05380341410636902,
0.06908877938985825,
0.47620341181755066,
0.4556044042110443,
-0.5913392901420593,
0.1843959093093872,
-0.46232184767723083,
-0.7284054160118103,
0.8194475173950195,
0.2781572937965393,
0.7718763947486877,
-0.19877010583877563,
0.33611202239990234,
-0.11779133230447769,
0.6367032527923584,
-0.053922317922115326,
0.24230919778347015,
-0.20918728411197662,
-1.0148659944534302,
-0.5735493898391724,
0.19668762385845184,
-1.0246291160583496,
-0.3420056998729706,
-0.20996341109275818,
0.021337101235985756,
-0.29040229320526123,
-0.45288583636283875,
-0.19961632788181305,
0.277671217918396,
-0.22881753742694855,
-0.37235262989997864,
0.09446391463279724,
0.6720818281173706,
-0.45183733105659485,
0.5110335946083069,
0.744124174118042,
-0.31338322162628174,
-0.6347020864486694,
0.02506292797625065,
-0.0806104764342308,
-0.4736899137496948,
0.3046567738056183,
0.32439830899238586,
-0.6280795335769653,
-0.4940038323402405,
-0.9205453991889954,
-0.823086142539978,
1.1959526538848877,
0.657250702381134,
-0.2440308928489685,
0.2448284924030304,
0.09966100752353668,
0.5801522731781006,
-0.432324081659317,
0.33793097734451294,
0.03700406104326248,
0.752897322177887,
0.6000776886940002,
-1.1019353866577148,
0.1429109424352646,
-0.4962872266769409,
-0.5062349438667297,
0.06983073800802231,
-1.181291937828064,
0.9786781072616577,
-0.5854617953300476,
-0.25948482751846313,
0.046679314225912094,
0.931141197681427,
0.5800487995147705,
0.8453149795532227,
0.6660116314888,
0.38807615637779236,
1.1058740615844727,
-0.0713813453912735,
0.9511799812316895,
-0.04589587077498436,
0.22258716821670532,
1.1989741325378418,
-0.7497754096984863,
0.19625654816627502,
0.5587546229362488,
-0.16718141734600067,
0.31895890831947327,
0.4155455231666565,
0.3495536148548126,
-0.02484723925590515,
0.6083012223243713,
-0.5791881084442139,
-0.7272291779518127,
-0.33156365156173706,
-0.5518231391906738,
0.1167169064283371,
0.09426632523536682,
0.1460873782634735,
-0.11283441632986069,
-0.05073842778801918,
-0.0253323782235384,
0.14977926015853882,
-0.2802792489528656,
0.8097473382949829,
0.04898308590054512,
-0.7807875275611877,
0.36753156781196594,
0.036190614104270935,
0.5725600123405457,
-0.3097001016139984,
-0.19869378209114075,
-0.44224992394447327,
0.09686081856489182,
-0.08642209321260452,
-0.6316500306129456,
0.15920040011405945,
-0.1638432890176773,
-0.1193256750702858,
-0.4388968348503113,
1.1076979637145996,
-0.48391029238700867,
0.06360767036676407,
0.43473365902900696,
0.9801369309425354,
0.39785054326057434,
-0.0323147177696228,
-0.3680392801761627,
0.11481307446956635,
-0.26215678453445435,
-0.282866895198822,
0.28578895330429077,
1.0061225891113281,
0.056086987257003784,
0.9037353992462158,
0.4153844714164734,
-0.3005729913711548,
0.19267457723617554,
0.22495658695697784,
1.2391984462738037,
-0.6791229248046875,
-0.25429317355155945,
-0.8948756456375122,
0.38719800114631653,
-0.3468230366706848,
0.028400857001543045,
0.8987908363342285,
0.27954918146133423,
0.5200421810150146,
0.34828004240989685,
0.6416653394699097,
0.44681844115257263,
0.37899717688560486,
-0.47071534395217896,
0.3817759156227112,
-0.49851247668266296,
0.5024619698524475,
-0.11880400031805038,
-0.6626389622688293,
-0.2384931743144989,
0.6166856288909912,
-0.17999057471752167,
0.30430588126182556,
1.0400211811065674,
0.6546878218650818,
0.5149884223937988,
0.352183073759079,
0.40225300192832947,
0.02035021036863327,
0.6480010151863098,
0.7648899555206299,
1.6788543462753296,
-0.1198536604642868,
0.6036320328712463,
0.050380948930978775,
-0.18470872938632965,
-0.02092878520488739,
-0.7757230997085571,
-1.1889758110046387,
-0.13305160403251648,
-0.41253045201301575,
-0.3247905671596527,
0.04684625193476677,
0.9881320595741272,
0.48290902376174927,
-0.07959248870611191,
-0.3521847426891327,
-0.1446049064397812,
0.7807874083518982,
-0.21562717854976654,
-0.1973457932472229,
0.027171213179826736,
-0.31068575382232666,
-0.48586222529411316,
0.6399120092391968,
0.276903361082077,
-0.026458587497472763,
-0.3518611490726471,
-0.6698439717292786,
-0.1767430454492569,
0.43423497676849365,
0.4441204071044922,
0.16937734186649323,
-0.7413527965545654,
-0.4820624887943268,
0.014397123828530312,
-0.06502748280763626,
0.12984676659107208,
1.0775293111801147,
-0.6228861212730408,
0.12500743567943573,
0.23807872831821442,
0.6098291277885437,
0.29673871397972107,
-0.029670672491192818,
0.49933120608329773,
-0.45246103405952454,
0.09162990003824234,
0.1541648954153061,
0.3949216306209564,
-0.006331054959446192,
-0.21167081594467163,
0.6365560293197632,
0.4218105673789978,
-0.9418011903762817,
-0.8597431778907776,
0.5824438333511353,
-0.9305301308631897,
-0.36271771788597107,
1.2596783638000488,
0.00523850042372942,
0.041008953005075455,
-0.1985754668712616,
-0.493917316198349,
0.21801528334617615,
-0.5390110611915588,
0.5796117782592773,
0.9307237267494202,
-0.6461682319641113,
-0.4469482898712158,
-0.06581763178110123,
0.12339942157268524,
0.4748915135860443,
-1.048643946647644,
0.13481035828590393,
0.6632648706436157,
-0.22979435324668884,
0.3459585905075073,
1.1974613666534424,
0.24058684706687927,
0.26598024368286133,
0.09917739778757095,
-0.16757261753082275,
-0.2399481236934662,
-0.803942084312439,
-0.13052815198898315,
0.5882137417793274,
0.3815493881702423,
0.04229733347892761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18267v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18267v2
|
A Survey on Neural Question Generation: Methods, Applications, and Prospects
| 2024-02-28T11:57:12 | 2024-05-07T15:08:56 |
Shasha Guo, Lizi Liao, Cuiping Li, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this survey, we present a detailed examination of the advancements in
Neural Question Generation (NQG), a field leveraging neural network techniques
to generate relevant questions from diverse inputs like knowledge bases, texts,
and images. The survey begins with an overview of NQG's background,
encompassing the task's problem formulation, prevalent benchmark datasets,
established evaluation metrics, and notable applications. It then methodically
classifies NQG approaches into three predominant categories: structured NQG,
which utilizes organized data sources, unstructured NQG, focusing on more
loosely structured inputs like texts or visual content, and hybrid NQG, drawing
on diverse input modalities. This classification is followed by an in-depth
analysis of the distinct neural network models tailored for each category,
discussing their inherent strengths and potential limitations. The survey
culminates with a forward-looking perspective on the trajectory of NQG,
identifying emergent research trends and prospective developmental paths.
Accompanying this survey is a curated collection of related research papers,
datasets and codes, systematically organized on Github, providing an extensive
reference for those delving into NQG.
|
[
-0.6663665771484375,
-0.8428443074226379,
0.35399100184440613,
0.015529080294072628,
0.0306121576577425,
0.04038115590810776,
0.03840191289782524,
-0.18126821517944336,
0.08434359729290009,
0.31164684891700745,
-0.6545710563659668,
-0.36788660287857056,
-0.22237464785575867,
0.21181467175483704,
-0.6365981101989746,
0.8138830661773682,
0.30173662304878235,
0.2722488045692444,
-0.8477723002433777,
0.10184302181005478,
-0.19081048667430878,
-0.3192576766014099,
-0.8378821015357971,
-0.1938556432723999,
0.7277786135673523,
0.2500578761100769,
0.36851373314857483,
0.08482206612825394,
0.19731491804122925,
0.19820381700992584,
-0.29437077045440674,
0.3426699638366699,
0.03914111480116844,
0.40630659461021423,
0.21539326012134552,
-0.4302087128162384,
-0.11732762306928635,
0.06583193689584732,
0.6005939245223999,
0.8657718300819397,
0.029985763132572174,
0.4557352364063263,
-0.022948946803808212,
0.49699798226356506,
-0.6318923830986023,
-0.14016245305538177,
-0.5102924704551697,
0.30004721879959106,
0.12756209075450897,
-0.21124380826950073,
-0.007811294868588448,
-0.9229605197906494,
0.19953638315200806,
-0.44785016775131226,
0.4803028702735901,
-0.15517902374267578,
0.40432727336883545,
0.09746696799993515,
-0.691197395324707,
-0.2443021982908249,
-0.4227486252784729,
0.4600917100906372,
-0.7707697749137878,
0.18866285681724548,
0.3399491310119629,
0.5022494196891785,
-0.19559386372566223,
-1.1410490274429321,
-0.52327960729599,
-0.2670965790748596,
0.2597281038761139,
0.3803413212299347,
-0.17034542560577393,
-0.19676141440868378,
0.3185466229915619,
0.47468146681785583,
-0.6965468525886536,
0.04575279727578163,
-0.2881159782409668,
-0.07837514579296112,
0.7305780053138733,
0.3471013307571411,
0.29228782653808594,
-0.4940200746059418,
-0.3334737718105316,
0.13316959142684937,
-0.5832926034927368,
0.13496221601963043,
0.5285859107971191,
0.003856252646073699,
0.32028844952583313,
0.3391650915145874,
-0.6135822534561157,
1.0625813007354736,
0.10982485860586166,
0.38703539967536926,
-0.1563345491886139,
-0.8321534395217896,
0.17031626403331757,
-0.21511338651180267,
0.9627535939216614,
0.7411441206932068,
-0.16522137820720673,
-0.2165585309267044,
-0.10841057449579239,
-0.5398274064064026,
0.3687577247619629,
-0.6183553338050842,
-0.19906069338321686,
0.3059748709201813,
-0.47611096501350403,
-0.5818677544593811,
-0.3177298307418823,
-0.8845640420913696,
-0.6262736916542053,
-0.13115499913692474,
0.14217709004878998,
-0.2012895792722702,
-0.5520922541618347,
-0.0834926962852478,
-0.43190839886665344,
0.5292322635650635,
0.1955001950263977,
-0.763808012008667,
0.007298940792679787,
0.2657250761985779,
0.4275014102458954,
-0.03804602101445198,
0.03220612555742264,
0.055042363703250885,
-0.5174784660339355,
-0.1810133308172226,
0.8643034100532532,
-0.07951679825782776,
-0.10357723385095596,
0.22631733119487762,
-0.34655052423477173,
-0.015335172414779663,
-0.6963125467300415,
0.06758616119623184,
-0.8328404426574707,
0.5689017176628113,
-0.24584834277629852,
-0.43473103642463684,
-0.22509914636611938,
0.9426224827766418,
-0.7005947828292847,
0.9751474857330322,
0.20661164820194244,
-0.7467408180236816,
0.3193170428276062,
-0.5038442611694336,
-0.11048628389835358,
0.32426244020462036,
-0.32881617546081543,
-0.21424002945423126,
0.10411712527275085,
0.30793648958206177,
0.390937864780426,
-0.726000964641571,
0.3448694348335266,
0.007363927084952593,
-0.14727096259593964,
0.45827716588974,
-0.1426398605108261,
1.004472017288208,
0.24631625413894653,
-0.14157164096832275,
0.08175770193338394,
-0.7490805387496948,
0.5857193470001221,
0.22600151598453522,
-0.3730742931365967,
0.054481226950883865,
0.009957524947822094,
-0.12731559574604034,
0.20988577604293823,
0.3369438350200653,
-0.653951108455658,
0.08579865843057632,
-0.11154410243034363,
0.7732032537460327,
0.33123019337654114,
0.4865688979625702,
0.4444807767868042,
-0.29499998688697815,
1.0147082805633545,
-0.16649162769317627,
0.4090419113636017,
0.009396214969456196,
-0.6092319488525391,
-0.5352407693862915,
0.8655251264572144,
0.8371731042861938,
0.38939526677131653,
-1.252580165863037,
0.13728873431682587,
0.2526949644088745,
-0.6153149008750916,
-0.044939637184143066,
-0.10837537795305252,
0.158043771982193,
0.7865071892738342,
0.17098259925842285,
0.10407412797212601,
-0.516707181930542,
-0.8618389964103699,
-0.022259006276726723,
-0.4937766194343567,
-0.015383993275463581,
0.48354414105415344,
0.2644764184951782,
0.4392761290073395,
0.621605634689331,
-0.47504326701164246,
0.4666941165924072,
-0.2834082245826721,
0.27294114232063293,
0.08209627121686935,
0.41337019205093384,
0.5134981870651245,
-0.9728169441223145,
-0.06427456438541412,
-0.1970343142747879,
-0.8471235036849976,
0.14108507335186005,
-0.128659188747406,
-0.30441316962242126,
-0.2634648382663727,
0.6094407439231873,
-0.48260295391082764,
0.16300444304943085,
0.4499821662902832,
-0.05597774684429169,
0.7293956875801086,
0.31409209966659546,
0.09102005511522293,
-1.2770172357559204,
-0.025286678224802017,
-0.14553704857826233,
0.35447344183921814,
-0.7447904348373413,
0.3045779764652252,
0.21763627231121063,
-0.15416260063648224,
-0.5352903604507446,
0.26463639736175537,
-0.37768295407295227,
0.13475678861141205,
-0.10242871940135956,
0.02893468365073204,
0.2114333212375641,
0.3021237552165985,
-0.2924400269985199,
0.4871003031730652,
0.37502390146255493,
-0.77857506275177,
0.6899407505989075,
0.401951402425766,
-0.27626582980155945,
0.1540367156267166,
-0.8136168718338013,
0.44475409388542175,
-0.25835147500038147,
0.03725791350007057,
-1.0802960395812988,
-0.08177081495523453,
0.34020769596099854,
-0.8819665312767029,
0.048288509249687195,
-0.12338212132453918,
-0.5276734232902527,
-0.3671351373195648,
-0.02900337241590023,
0.7941076755523682,
0.5971302390098572,
-0.24082094430923462,
0.3497450351715088,
0.04316721111536026,
-0.15544788539409637,
-0.45129430294036865,
-0.6657975912094116,
0.1216377466917038,
-0.03646785020828247,
-0.7891314625740051,
0.3004254698753357,
0.004180082585662603,
-0.14369210600852966,
-0.057089757174253464,
-0.05381187051534653,
-0.30375123023986816,
0.028042148798704147,
-0.13826622068881989,
0.10780685395002365,
-0.5395877957344055,
0.3594072461128235,
-0.06162716820836067,
0.36606550216674805,
0.5507193803787231,
-0.4540172517299652,
0.438142329454422,
0.185987189412117,
-0.15035244822502136,
0.3025170862674713,
0.4818252921104431,
0.05494633689522743,
-0.5770900249481201,
0.1881525218486786,
0.4272410273551941,
-0.3814297914505005,
-0.4383949935436249,
-0.30259066820144653,
-0.2577662169933319,
-0.3736819922924042,
0.3427932858467102,
0.26826050877571106,
-0.8798759579658508,
0.5149332284927368,
-0.17777490615844727,
0.23637154698371887,
0.2801121175289154,
0.39358365535736084,
-0.258781760931015,
0.9097251296043396,
0.24163073301315308,
0.4438774883747101,
0.5499112606048584,
-0.5044846534729004,
0.05524782836437225,
-0.8554884195327759,
-0.6425472497940063,
-0.4345030188560486,
-0.7384387254714966,
-0.4029940664768219,
-0.372108519077301,
0.2814166843891144,
0.1667214184999466,
0.1212567612528801,
0.09844423085451126,
-0.57198566198349,
0.36708182096481323,
0.7270260453224182,
0.014957577921450138,
-0.09220568835735321,
-0.27315986156463623,
-0.14737990498542786,
0.22014226019382477,
-1.1307181119918823,
-0.1968718320131302,
1.355440616607666,
-0.07351259142160416,
0.11569546163082123,
-0.21701566874980927,
0.9058018922805786,
-0.14349745213985443,
0.08720215409994125,
-0.9008040428161621,
0.7213984727859497,
0.19406986236572266,
-0.977473795413971,
-0.3375746011734009,
-0.5450549125671387,
-1.1671620607376099,
0.043245892971754074,
-0.24930572509765625,
-0.12890362739562988,
0.2997952401638031,
0.03460689261555672,
-0.9759056568145752,
0.3714888393878937,
-0.47233155369758606,
0.6032309532165527,
-0.5185876488685608,
-0.3773580491542816,
0.525050699710846,
-0.5874971747398376,
0.6670405864715576,
0.3367888033390045,
-0.5178670883178711,
0.06875280290842056,
0.08647853136062622,
0.7560511827468872,
0.034284450113773346,
0.38079899549484253,
-0.41342219710350037,
0.1412513256072998,
0.8386602401733398,
-0.25901493430137634,
-0.2573728859424591,
0.3042367696762085,
-0.18474745750427246,
-0.01410703081637621,
-0.13839249312877655,
-0.30226200819015503,
-0.8026643395423889,
0.42128270864486694,
-0.4875817596912384,
-0.33722734451293945,
-0.21179106831550598,
-0.811427116394043,
-0.5569111704826355,
0.25733038783073425,
0.36610573530197144,
0.5094433426856995,
-0.16507317125797272,
0.27624982595443726,
0.7271064519882202,
-0.5440402626991272,
0.5468695163726807,
0.0446556881070137,
-0.29886361956596375,
-0.5869863033294678,
0.7613343000411987,
0.16087311506271362,
0.28531235456466675,
0.08505374193191528,
-0.00015051318041514605,
-0.5969479084014893,
-1.043106198310852,
-0.5690457820892334,
-0.16860146820545197,
-0.361582487821579,
-0.5947128534317017,
-0.3376501798629761,
-0.584524929523468,
-0.5430454611778259,
0.4991426169872284,
0.022199813276529312,
-0.6508612036705017,
-0.2201996147632599,
-0.07054948061704636,
0.24710991978645325,
0.7534387707710266,
0.47647935152053833,
0.1910848766565323,
-0.55021071434021,
0.49354490637779236,
0.7244696617126465,
0.2699110805988312,
0.05300350859761238,
0.05743525177240372,
-0.11052292585372925,
0.13451038300991058,
-0.5982503890991211,
-0.9248549938201904,
0.030854014679789543,
0.0030479226261377335,
0.6270477771759033,
0.18092088401317596,
0.10953760892152786,
0.3051561415195465,
-0.14493542909622192,
1.1613950729370117,
0.3494250774383545,
-0.1599164456129074,
0.6008577346801758,
-0.49444401264190674,
0.47409385442733765,
0.6764305233955383,
0.42928430438041687,
-0.5138506293296814,
0.012026367709040642,
-0.6268498301506042,
-0.9240623116493225,
0.3491957187652588,
0.14769937098026276,
0.24493971467018127,
-0.17041544616222382,
0.6795048713684082,
-0.04049674794077873,
0.4857122302055359,
-0.3477155566215515,
-0.15525656938552856,
-0.42143604159355164,
0.19066299498081207,
0.25489166378974915,
0.18670591711997986,
-0.1584710031747818,
-0.24694640934467316,
0.17766569554805756,
-0.29983460903167725,
0.472311407327652,
0.21110685169696808,
0.1719365417957306,
0.27443957328796387,
0.16189606487751007,
0.5207349061965942,
0.4929661750793457,
-0.007535060402005911,
0.029412882402539253,
-0.04865991324186325,
-0.1922006607055664,
0.1818869411945343,
0.11418818682432175,
-0.6695362329483032,
-0.09534202516078949,
0.06332094222307205,
0.4639246463775635,
-0.2118987888097763,
-0.36018437147140503,
0.30498167872428894,
-0.3720381557941437,
-1.0595263242721558,
-0.3785036504268646,
0.12532253563404083,
0.3594156503677368,
0.26805004477500916,
0.26776671409606934,
0.15493497252464294,
0.3860854506492615,
-0.3202836215496063,
0.06417972594499588,
0.3635452389717102,
-0.3440513014793396,
-0.1235959380865097,
0.6576863527297974,
-0.06036989390850067,
-0.4047910273075104,
1.053688406944275,
-0.3383021950721741,
-0.2626117765903473,
1.1035150289535522,
0.38972893357276917,
0.9282969832420349,
0.2546465992927551,
0.6149476766586304,
0.5474296808242798,
0.20964236557483673,
0.12847208976745605,
0.8140353560447693,
-0.23872293531894684,
-0.8671175241470337,
-0.2839709520339966,
-0.4188198149204254,
-0.25771811604499817,
0.5562072992324829,
-0.5908470749855042,
-0.2849745750427246,
-0.9303010702133179,
-0.6814144253730774,
-0.061531536281108856,
-0.3090062737464905,
-0.56171715259552,
0.3282882571220398,
0.37140101194381714,
0.9636178016662598,
-0.33913254737854004,
0.16261513531208038,
1.1260095834732056,
-0.5651577711105347,
-0.8152397274971008,
0.2255786508321762,
-0.3374477028846741,
-0.47619545459747314,
0.5142344236373901,
-0.10738673806190491,
0.2813008725643158,
0.11502109467983246,
-0.8612162470817566,
-0.7412427663803101,
1.295196771621704,
0.25112712383270264,
0.24794292449951172,
-0.45029789209365845,
0.28796231746673584,
0.5023590922355652,
-0.31098514795303345,
0.4085632264614105,
0.3903912901878357,
0.38687142729759216,
0.054142214357852936,
-0.1836944818496704,
-0.10429947823286057,
-0.9844968318939209,
-0.010772811248898506,
0.17317251861095428,
-0.7702351212501526,
0.8815539479255676,
0.07011537998914719,
-0.061748720705509186,
0.33399873971939087,
0.57346510887146,
0.33451545238494873,
0.47288620471954346,
0.4541527330875397,
0.3142220079898834,
0.3901873230934143,
-0.3256782293319702,
0.7843512892723083,
-0.28327304124832153,
-0.3075433373451233,
0.6965634226799011,
0.07235989719629288,
0.44152143597602844,
0.5775056481361389,
-0.01633601076900959,
0.3151857852935791,
0.8021204471588135,
-0.2730354368686676,
0.20474748313426971,
0.6880710124969482,
-0.1833864450454712,
-0.22377127408981323,
-0.38308507204055786,
-0.5134657025337219,
0.6215117573738098,
0.00590919004753232,
-0.4556316137313843,
-0.2831445336341858,
-0.2481861561536789,
-0.6681232452392578,
-0.036977142095565796,
-0.37870556116104126,
0.7693645358085632,
-0.07725529372692108,
-0.9080262780189514,
0.5604457259178162,
-0.13513566553592682,
0.506018340587616,
-0.5821491479873657,
-0.2816254496574402,
-0.5287477374076843,
-0.4942954182624817,
-0.24629047513008118,
-0.7171216607093811,
0.018297165632247925,
-0.26112380623817444,
-0.10696288198232651,
-0.6504194736480713,
0.8671334385871887,
-0.14599765837192535,
-0.3691495954990387,
-0.18882356584072113,
0.9667171239852905,
-0.08220961689949036,
-0.20641861855983734,
-0.5709752440452576,
-0.6921314001083374,
-0.017665687948465347,
-0.17089201509952545,
0.20806238055229187,
0.43881088495254517,
0.0746527910232544,
0.3602513372898102,
0.5547618865966797,
0.04035976156592369,
0.7441770434379578,
0.08921117335557938,
0.7361412048339844,
-0.7326149344444275,
-0.2316473126411438,
-0.20669522881507874,
0.8845527768135071,
-0.19774934649467468,
-0.978460431098938,
0.7373815774917603,
0.4933566153049469,
0.752264678478241,
-0.025006050243973732,
0.7635509967803955,
-0.18262657523155212,
0.1369880884885788,
-0.375705361366272,
0.9300563931465149,
-0.5348371267318726,
-0.1906936913728714,
-0.10361193120479584,
-0.8366783261299133,
-0.26453110575675964,
0.17885655164718628,
-0.20718595385551453,
0.20157580077648163,
0.5066596865653992,
0.5674206018447876,
0.35357508063316345,
0.47339996695518494,
0.2343723326921463,
-0.5896313786506653,
-0.04258989170193672,
0.5830569267272949,
1.684668779373169,
-0.6329107284545898,
0.5310398936271667,
-0.36141711473464966,
0.17530645430088043,
0.17798969149589539,
-0.5157659649848938,
-0.7538094520568848,
-0.550964891910553,
-0.34096357226371765,
-0.11626087129116058,
-0.4178527891635895,
0.4541887640953064,
0.6724650859832764,
-0.5364730954170227,
-0.14941424131393433,
-0.4195234775543213,
-0.011007685214281082,
-0.1001378744840622,
-0.24075324833393097,
-0.089162677526474,
-0.2947123944759369,
-0.34101858735084534,
0.3452611267566681,
-0.2779567539691925,
-0.027003072202205658,
-0.30705294013023376,
0.20292212069034576,
-0.4294915199279785,
-0.22005681693553925,
0.43520209193229675,
0.2729317545890808,
-0.21377743780612946,
0.13208654522895813,
0.7124648690223694,
0.17747566103935242,
-0.10765019804239273,
0.9741891622543335,
-0.7720314264297485,
0.17632798850536346,
1.0056252479553223,
0.9855413436889648,
0.26313820481300354,
0.01069002877920866,
0.5573674440383911,
-0.7576767206192017,
-0.4961090087890625,
0.8311756253242493,
0.004439037758857012,
0.12570393085479736,
-0.3690854609012604,
0.17043666541576385,
-0.00783522892743349,
-0.5324406623840332,
-0.6558904647827148,
0.39482569694519043,
-0.6688166260719299,
-0.13291168212890625,
0.9848060607910156,
0.13872414827346802,
-0.17015333473682404,
-0.02337048389017582,
0.025766389444470406,
0.3805854022502899,
0.024981144815683365,
0.609260082244873,
0.5897799730300903,
-0.5686091184616089,
-0.34395846724510193,
-0.7394596934318542,
0.3977281153202057,
0.618825376033783,
-0.9363717436790466,
-0.28393012285232544,
0.6351693868637085,
0.036085452884435654,
0.3004533648490906,
0.3377949297428131,
-0.38564157485961914,
0.5722591876983643,
0.10781834274530411,
0.3246541917324066,
-0.3605714738368988,
-0.17716233432292938,
-0.43334540724754333,
0.7190089821815491,
0.08877699077129364,
-0.31934136152267456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18264v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18264v1
|
Retrieval-based Full-length Wikipedia Generation for Emergent Events
| 2024-02-28T11:51:56 | 2024-02-28T11:51:56 |
Jiebin Zhang, Eugene J. Yu, Qinyu Chen, Chenhao Xiong, Dawei Zhu, Han Qian, Mingbo Song, Xiaoguang Li, Qun Liu, Sujian Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In today's fast-paced world, the growing demand to quickly generate
comprehensive and accurate Wikipedia documents for emerging events is both
crucial and challenging. However, previous efforts in Wikipedia generation have
often fallen short of meeting real-world requirements. Some approaches focus
solely on generating segments of a complete Wikipedia document, while others
overlook the importance of faithfulness in generation or fail to consider the
influence of the pre-training corpus. In this paper, we simulate a real-world
scenario where structured full-length Wikipedia documents are generated for
emergent events using input retrieved from web sources. To ensure that Large
Language Models (LLMs) are not trained on corpora related to recently occurred
events, we select events that have taken place recently and introduce a new
benchmark Wiki-GenBen, which consists of 309 events paired with their
corresponding retrieved web pages for generating evidence. Additionally, we
design a comprehensive set of systematic evaluation metrics and baseline
methods, to evaluate the capability of LLMs in generating factual full-length
Wikipedia documents. The data and code are open-sourced at WikiGenBench.
|
[
-0.47317132353782654,
-0.8543264269828796,
0.6351476907730103,
0.2088494747877121,
-0.5743630528450012,
-0.1583566814661026,
-0.5893834233283997,
-0.6747056841850281,
0.4315219223499298,
0.10836433619260788,
-0.6788051724433899,
-0.30317002534866333,
-0.06224486231803894,
0.2927561104297638,
-0.9836263656616211,
1.0658400058746338,
-0.06546170264482498,
-0.26377612352371216,
-0.22945375740528107,
0.4297090172767639,
0.27274763584136963,
-0.1457464098930359,
-0.56544429063797,
-0.17309506237506866,
0.6639046669006348,
0.5502885580062866,
0.33467403054237366,
0.4975309669971466,
0.2693970501422882,
0.09545496106147766,
-0.052568159997463226,
0.26633405685424805,
-0.7879957556724548,
0.3731729984283447,
-0.17298853397369385,
0.09872733801603317,
0.007240349426865578,
0.06636695563793182,
0.9227495789527893,
0.5109023451805115,
-0.17218056321144104,
0.5494974255561829,
-0.0629139095544815,
0.1932949423789978,
-0.7610502243041992,
-0.18771611154079437,
-0.86659836769104,
0.1575518399477005,
-0.5711443424224854,
-0.12776429951190948,
-0.41537415981292725,
-0.22729118168354034,
0.0593850202858448,
-0.5396376848220825,
0.6252403855323792,
-0.13846416771411896,
1.0688886642456055,
-0.2553695738315582,
-0.1525026112794876,
-0.22029797732830048,
-0.81829833984375,
0.2862757742404938,
-0.49766966700553894,
0.4223599433898926,
0.0022188974544405937,
0.08877982944250107,
-0.3793782889842987,
-1.0211856365203857,
-0.9413126707077026,
-0.4843486249446869,
0.36906421184539795,
0.1324198842048645,
-0.012001586146652699,
-0.2942182719707489,
0.38484320044517517,
0.17407210171222687,
-0.467823326587677,
0.26795557141304016,
-0.3410378694534302,
0.05105459690093994,
0.5341973304748535,
0.10428845882415771,
0.26830583810806274,
-0.709490180015564,
-0.2656514048576355,
-0.16128382086753845,
-0.9803460240364075,
-0.33956047892570496,
0.5358867049217224,
0.0946839228272438,
-0.051255494356155396,
0.7825997471809387,
-0.39423424005508423,
0.3708885610103607,
0.17226934432983398,
-0.09405815601348877,
0.1951378583908081,
-0.5338876843452454,
0.2353796511888504,
0.004152172710746527,
0.998951256275177,
0.37820130586624146,
0.524204671382904,
-0.5259775519371033,
0.07123108953237534,
-0.24045544862747192,
0.3424184024333954,
-0.9574569463729858,
-0.08826933056116104,
0.12432429194450378,
-0.1927141547203064,
-0.5317716002464294,
0.1354062259197235,
-0.9858992099761963,
-0.17906713485717773,
-0.09776266664266586,
0.24239255487918854,
-0.478564977645874,
-0.23683325946331024,
-0.5764926075935364,
-0.32219216227531433,
0.3165952265262604,
0.15250016748905182,
-0.5476329922676086,
-0.3301811218261719,
0.47247448563575745,
0.8214372992515564,
-0.35555005073547363,
-0.3878520131111145,
-0.662043571472168,
0.4393022656440735,
-0.5782940983772278,
0.8177322149276733,
-0.17874349653720856,
-0.4698657691478729,
0.19628849625587463,
-0.1582830250263214,
0.38963353633880615,
-0.4567093551158905,
0.7890891432762146,
-0.7315468192100525,
-0.14374510943889618,
-0.0876217857003212,
-0.520721971988678,
0.5705803632736206,
0.18593841791152954,
-0.6542671322822571,
0.9736937284469604,
-0.1837492436170578,
-1.0864797830581665,
0.6530206203460693,
-0.2734203040599823,
-0.7307502627372742,
0.1477580964565277,
-0.3417988121509552,
-0.4433348774909973,
0.11283852159976959,
-0.06151673570275307,
0.21821756660938263,
-0.19731326401233673,
0.5108728408813477,
-0.40875688195228577,
-0.23772796988487244,
0.2384355068206787,
-0.5945693850517273,
0.45519763231277466,
-0.0002937617537099868,
-0.5183352828025818,
-0.10451314598321915,
-1.1746013164520264,
-0.004010707605630159,
0.2517787516117096,
-0.5803704261779785,
-0.13620944321155548,
0.3575965166091919,
0.15036915242671967,
0.26700901985168457,
0.3380921185016632,
-0.9024165272712708,
-0.010140842758119106,
-0.35215726494789124,
-0.22198209166526794,
0.6971858143806458,
0.38868269324302673,
0.28836512565612793,
0.025717316195368767,
0.17471082508563995,
0.10019794851541519,
0.23114460706710815,
-0.12023215740919113,
-0.32687437534332275,
-0.8398038148880005,
-0.07714074850082397,
0.4151105582714081,
0.3102329969406128,
-0.9710602760314941,
0.4488620162010193,
-0.7753041386604309,
-0.6535683274269104,
-0.1162513867020607,
0.3253399431705475,
0.14695480465888977,
0.5558638572692871,
0.10435383021831512,
-0.135020449757576,
-0.8276292085647583,
-0.7584566473960876,
0.011815113946795464,
-0.2334374338388443,
-0.4466665983200073,
-0.021405044943094254,
0.4629572331905365,
-0.13771215081214905,
0.817577064037323,
-0.3907953202724457,
0.2768453061580658,
0.01095094345510006,
0.2618812024593353,
-0.06211511418223381,
0.0772528424859047,
0.3505622148513794,
-0.691426157951355,
-0.44420766830444336,
-0.15177011489868164,
-0.7247126698493958,
0.007718867622315884,
-0.022520091384649277,
-0.34631749987602234,
0.2139699012041092,
0.3595799207687378,
-0.7759073376655579,
0.43257877230644226,
0.19014236330986023,
-0.0611458420753479,
0.7866328954696655,
-0.14812855422496796,
-0.030032120645046234,
-1.1061015129089355,
0.33970218896865845,
-0.3173997700214386,
-0.010462176986038685,
-0.5123969912528992,
0.16287046670913696,
0.316270649433136,
-0.17752483487129211,
-0.3710128366947174,
0.5241267681121826,
-0.4167998433113098,
-0.06777358800172806,
-0.2579975426197052,
0.42241835594177246,
-0.16346560418605804,
0.05892803892493248,
0.11066041141748428,
0.5702429413795471,
0.13021966814994812,
-0.7045367360115051,
0.48217254877090454,
0.213566392660141,
-0.601869523525238,
0.25830116868019104,
-0.21121300756931305,
-0.11406897008419037,
-0.22330930829048157,
0.353219598531723,
-0.4471472203731537,
-0.5914404392242432,
0.032095473259687424,
-0.5029704570770264,
0.40909841656684875,
0.04266336187720299,
-0.8031527996063232,
-0.5702638030052185,
-0.4775638282299042,
-0.10664673149585724,
0.4778836667537689,
-0.6901476979255676,
0.30076074600219727,
0.09429802000522614,
-0.3364713191986084,
-0.5840144753456116,
-0.22653990983963013,
0.26130610704421997,
-0.00678894342854619,
-0.691392183303833,
0.3353164494037628,
-0.10326560586690903,
-0.1879333257675171,
0.1110968217253685,
-0.22655364871025085,
0.12019062787294388,
0.005674769636243582,
0.18755565583705902,
0.2807452082633972,
-0.1284666508436203,
-0.04728178679943085,
-0.019247092306613922,
0.25340521335601807,
0.057899463921785355,
-0.2804720997810364,
0.42898935079574585,
0.47111329436302185,
-0.38392844796180725,
-0.17417146265506744,
0.47403058409690857,
0.4338814616203308,
-0.22882241010665894,
0.8898982405662537,
0.8107173442840576,
-0.27629354596138,
-0.32223522663116455,
-0.8596614599227905,
-0.05557311326265335,
-0.3607286214828491,
0.3592342138290405,
-0.12770915031433105,
-0.5620443820953369,
0.42292729020118713,
0.017890650779008865,
0.3053657114505768,
0.5630351901054382,
0.6297988295555115,
-0.2735685110092163,
0.6701778173446655,
0.07327406108379364,
0.20270077884197235,
0.7050015330314636,
0.030251571908593178,
-0.004650691524147987,
-0.7348307967185974,
-0.41027218103408813,
-0.5567994713783264,
0.03975413367152214,
-0.3656335771083832,
-0.5083199739456177,
0.3695571720600128,
0.21619898080825806,
-0.1809605211019516,
0.09470199048519135,
0.07319410145282745,
0.3938688337802887,
0.610563337802887,
0.053589820861816406,
0.3147077262401581,
0.4755410850048065,
-0.3287815749645233,
0.11824819445610046,
-0.6162194609642029,
-0.36831796169281006,
1.2610820531845093,
-0.3611311912536621,
0.5271676778793335,
0.16867786645889282,
0.7305198311805725,
0.20181140303611755,
0.5829868912696838,
-0.26601555943489075,
0.499163419008255,
-0.057148873805999756,
-0.8020378351211548,
-0.5100249648094177,
-0.799235463142395,
-1.0958939790725708,
-0.01867428794503212,
-0.339228093624115,
-0.479244202375412,
-0.005431652534753084,
-0.242799311876297,
-0.009225032292306423,
0.36246684193611145,
-0.3123752176761627,
0.5187036991119385,
-0.2891594469547272,
-0.3644416034221649,
-0.22391603887081146,
-0.43820586800575256,
0.517289936542511,
-0.4879893660545349,
0.32961851358413696,
-0.23457367718219757,
0.08169228583574295,
0.6187467575073242,
-0.23794110119342804,
0.5848873257637024,
-0.023264335468411446,
-0.08890946954488754,
0.5544387698173523,
0.10527109354734421,
0.576819896697998,
0.263363778591156,
-0.15012052655220032,
-0.13616928458213806,
-0.28194645047187805,
-0.31354570388793945,
-0.21650487184524536,
0.8142040967941284,
-0.8278149366378784,
-0.44547656178474426,
0.08965087682008743,
0.00385886337608099,
-0.29716894030570984,
0.27566131949424744,
0.659600555896759,
0.4142170548439026,
-0.7498596906661987,
0.16542892158031464,
0.7850675582885742,
-0.19957441091537476,
0.5072247385978699,
0.6759346127510071,
-0.18613822758197784,
-0.4493879973888397,
0.8571271300315857,
0.2674243748188019,
0.09544897824525833,
0.38204336166381836,
-0.20693576335906982,
-0.2061222493648529,
-0.4846213757991791,
-0.7509468793869019,
0.21188461780548096,
-0.6680151224136353,
-0.36306527256965637,
-0.5201617479324341,
-0.3940770626068115,
-0.484464168548584,
0.02736963890492916,
-0.11448448896408081,
-0.4067606031894684,
-0.3170314133167267,
-0.36933016777038574,
0.10743776708841324,
0.5159699320793152,
-0.37113168835639954,
-0.11135350167751312,
-0.8997649550437927,
0.5820295810699463,
0.23944136500358582,
0.4481377601623535,
0.3352057635784149,
-0.33981403708457947,
-0.3173168897628784,
-0.11638208478689194,
-0.3922289311885834,
-0.9796883463859558,
-0.022644976153969765,
0.37439629435539246,
0.7387059926986694,
0.6340387463569641,
0.23533476889133453,
0.5716267228126526,
-0.9992378354072571,
0.6959370374679565,
0.3506850004196167,
-0.4184345602989197,
0.707869827747345,
-0.3371877670288086,
0.18588705360889435,
0.4464937746524811,
0.5006885528564453,
-0.3477137088775635,
-0.4710823595523834,
-0.8873501420021057,
-1.0404975414276123,
0.43083953857421875,
0.4157382845878601,
0.29120948910713196,
-0.48542919754981995,
0.5926535725593567,
0.041617751121520996,
0.10257137566804886,
-0.5135903358459473,
-0.035155653953552246,
0.020649004727602005,
-0.09625494480133057,
-0.03055446222424507,
-0.4137544631958008,
-0.05095063894987106,
0.03502621129155159,
0.7828368544578552,
0.08713485300540924,
-0.13213631510734558,
0.22548864781856537,
-0.25678178668022156,
-0.2825126349925995,
0.2258746325969696,
0.4014017581939697,
0.835797131061554,
-0.20195059478282928,
0.00963811855763197,
0.23327840864658356,
-0.5448333621025085,
0.12627996504306793,
0.4007568061351776,
-0.6209259629249573,
0.485365629196167,
0.4240025281906128,
0.5636338591575623,
0.47704970836639404,
-1.013680338859558,
0.6514605283737183,
0.0196148119866848,
0.03270503133535385,
-0.7238306403160095,
-0.007763322442770004,
0.2705989480018616,
0.15435214340686798,
0.7619413733482361,
-0.6927675008773804,
-0.05554085597395897,
-0.5044915676116943,
0.3654218316078186,
0.38659432530403137,
0.045847442001104355,
-0.24409234523773193,
0.5925947427749634,
0.38368791341781616,
0.033121298998594284,
0.9585608243942261,
-0.3605753481388092,
-0.09687308967113495,
0.5039514899253845,
0.3601403832435608,
0.45592936873435974,
0.019960667937994003,
0.17599621415138245,
0.5778762102127075,
0.3133485019207001,
0.22221648693084717,
0.045623138546943665,
-0.14323464035987854,
-0.6219112277030945,
-0.5865379571914673,
-1.2808763980865479,
-0.3760930001735687,
0.27719759941101074,
-0.554377019405365,
0.26338499784469604,
-0.12252704799175262,
-0.35236209630966187,
-0.041950520128011703,
0.04807078465819359,
-0.5683008432388306,
0.041205279529094696,
0.45662593841552734,
1.3217453956604004,
-0.6185881495475769,
0.6242769956588745,
0.4790954291820526,
-0.5641522407531738,
-0.46250420808792114,
0.25436636805534363,
-0.2688816785812378,
-0.2020796239376068,
0.35855427384376526,
-0.21767233312129974,
0.31091830134391785,
-0.11779584735631943,
-0.48044490814208984,
-0.757336437702179,
0.9050354957580566,
0.38238653540611267,
-0.5456230640411377,
-0.6360782980918884,
0.039406802505254745,
0.47474661469459534,
0.07747676223516464,
-0.11410009860992432,
0.16714736819267273,
0.4367870092391968,
0.25715434551239014,
-0.8576512932777405,
-0.17657361924648285,
-0.07719063013792038,
-0.05853543058037758,
0.24568594992160797,
-0.5229468941688538,
0.49139848351478577,
-0.07478992640972137,
-0.4634934961795807,
0.2990894913673401,
0.9865298271179199,
0.49987056851387024,
0.10043934732675552,
0.3828183114528656,
0.5072769522666931,
0.806637167930603,
0.07612870633602142,
1.004631519317627,
-0.25040286779403687,
0.14713966846466064,
1.107909917831421,
-0.3089534342288971,
1.0931130647659302,
0.38538506627082825,
-0.054556407034397125,
0.5298389792442322,
0.5517739653587341,
-0.11289017647504807,
0.392465204000473,
0.30189189314842224,
-0.6004841923713684,
-0.34064289927482605,
0.018466409295797348,
-0.41946956515312195,
0.348209947347641,
0.22515562176704407,
-0.3092620074748993,
-0.602729856967926,
-0.07619668543338776,
0.05463595688343048,
-0.21864967048168182,
-0.3211638629436493,
0.7685865759849548,
0.02132311277091503,
-0.815933883190155,
0.16695931553840637,
0.13806912302970886,
0.5868151783943176,
-0.7995346188545227,
0.13745030760765076,
-0.3092149496078491,
-0.06309094280004501,
-0.05139707028865814,
-0.6323386430740356,
0.015085235238075256,
0.6444391012191772,
-0.37468865513801575,
0.24342456459999084,
0.7026888132095337,
-0.2885628938674927,
-0.6359269618988037,
0.11925295740365982,
0.5723826289176941,
0.2450050562620163,
0.06207803264260292,
-0.05722321942448616,
0.04559096321463585,
-0.07075514644384384,
-0.562074601650238,
0.5088329315185547,
0.699015736579895,
-0.10775259882211685,
0.3014835715293884,
0.9087691903114319,
0.24179622530937195,
0.4263306260108948,
0.05986582860350609,
0.7698352336883545,
-0.4598897397518158,
-0.30676573514938354,
-0.7066648006439209,
0.14786866307258606,
-0.6054813861846924,
-0.16323603689670563,
0.7225834727287292,
0.8801864385604858,
0.8741567134857178,
-0.0023939181119203568,
0.786068320274353,
-0.2817343473434448,
0.3959295451641083,
-0.3557211756706238,
0.7656580805778503,
-0.41933050751686096,
-0.26450803875923157,
-0.09865133464336395,
-0.837303876876831,
0.1291647106409073,
0.12553013861179352,
0.2473316490650177,
-0.27134525775909424,
0.34027916193008423,
0.3019602596759796,
-0.11212693899869919,
0.016481807455420494,
0.18423178791999817,
0.26525354385375977,
0.26733511686325073,
0.21288417279720306,
0.9874030947685242,
0.14823946356773376,
1.0845352411270142,
-0.02887336164712906,
-0.0868554413318634,
-0.3760907053947449,
-0.8582310676574707,
-0.620388388633728,
-0.6334235072135925,
-0.01357755996286869,
-0.4399012327194214,
0.09038664400577545,
0.6468617916107178,
0.40617427229881287,
-0.6295695304870605,
0.0635562539100647,
0.1325581669807434,
-0.17898322641849518,
0.3914164900779724,
-0.23338238894939423,
0.3707323670387268,
-0.4579544961452484,
-0.5506322979927063,
0.5139959454536438,
-0.04099519923329353,
0.037717849016189575,
-0.33676502108573914,
0.10028502345085144,
-0.2798765003681183,
0.11574821919202805,
0.5328415036201477,
0.34295451641082764,
-0.41688695549964905,
-0.4378891885280609,
-0.17712658643722534,
-0.21913602948188782,
-0.2111920863389969,
0.5159899592399597,
-0.7000219821929932,
0.17066296935081482,
0.46234995126724243,
0.5844446420669556,
1.0279717445373535,
-0.2035195380449295,
0.5216774940490723,
-0.9824925065040588,
-0.06426563113927841,
0.017031516879796982,
0.3389960527420044,
0.3483425974845886,
-0.14427721500396729,
0.47747519612312317,
0.34740346670150757,
-0.20636944472789764,
-0.8680925369262695,
0.2901841402053833,
-0.5302451252937317,
-0.32221004366874695,
1.1595261096954346,
-0.06312358379364014,
-0.1635780781507492,
0.14338478446006775,
0.3728334903717041,
0.6846661567687988,
-0.017429200932383537,
0.8856257200241089,
0.7858765721321106,
-0.00876101478934288,
0.1796490103006363,
-0.5139447450637817,
0.26616594195365906,
-0.32147306203842163,
-0.6990659832954407,
0.0774521678686142,
0.8165176510810852,
0.6257246136665344,
0.4288100302219391,
0.4920181930065155,
0.029148638248443604,
0.5008000731468201,
0.25328338146209717,
0.20325949788093567,
0.029797660186886787,
-0.4378693699836731,
0.3052743375301361,
0.4264022707939148,
-0.004287294112145901,
0.31107714772224426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18262v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18262v1
|
Hierarchical Multimodal Pre-training for Visually Rich Webpage Understanding
| 2024-02-28T11:50:36 | 2024-02-28T11:50:36 |
Hongshen Xu, Lu Chen, Zihan Zhao, Da Ma, Ruisheng Cao, Zichen Zhu, Kai Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The growing prevalence of visually rich documents, such as webpages and
scanned/digital-born documents (images, PDFs, etc.), has led to increased
interest in automatic document understanding and information extraction across
academia and industry. Although various document modalities, including image,
text, layout, and structure, facilitate human information retrieval, the
interconnected nature of these modalities presents challenges for neural
networks. In this paper, we introduce WebLM, a multimodal pre-training network
designed to address the limitations of solely modeling text and structure
modalities of HTML in webpages. Instead of processing document images as
unified natural images, WebLM integrates the hierarchical structure of document
images to enhance the understanding of markup-language-based documents.
Additionally, we propose several pre-training tasks to model the interaction
among text, structure, and image modalities effectively. Empirical results
demonstrate that the pre-trained WebLM significantly surpasses previous
state-of-the-art pre-trained models across several webpage understanding tasks.
The pre-trained models and code are available at
https://github.com/X-LANCE/weblm.
|
[
-0.4517984390258789,
-0.5383062958717346,
0.325818806886673,
0.28525394201278687,
-0.5212808847427368,
-0.01004026923328638,
-0.05344928056001663,
-0.46262407302856445,
-0.16396628320217133,
0.15172451734542847,
-0.5864343047142029,
-0.45834681391716003,
-0.5794821977615356,
-0.10345420986413956,
-0.28900474309921265,
0.8294512629508972,
0.22168241441249847,
0.2656448781490326,
-0.5930197238922119,
0.05290650576353073,
0.13066042959690094,
-0.41734400391578674,
-0.3167981505393982,
-0.2384575754404068,
0.9909655451774597,
-0.06690788269042969,
0.6242364645004272,
0.39260855317115784,
0.597338080406189,
0.4008558988571167,
0.17777366936206818,
0.20209330320358276,
-0.30293241143226624,
-0.06557825207710266,
-0.0226576030254364,
-0.33903199434280396,
-0.5765519738197327,
0.04081696271896362,
0.5538603663444519,
0.8754715323448181,
0.0911005437374115,
0.055276185274124146,
0.2697891592979431,
0.41900280117988586,
-0.875606894493103,
0.3009045720100403,
-0.6266575455665588,
0.17482227087020874,
-0.23151056468486786,
-0.40645670890808105,
-0.48133525252342224,
0.11274291574954987,
0.15080568194389343,
-1.176969051361084,
0.4585391879081726,
0.01472639199346304,
1.1341667175292969,
0.13656139373779297,
-0.5912110209465027,
-0.03956546261906624,
-0.38327282667160034,
0.6447579264640808,
-0.327680766582489,
0.9387354850769043,
0.8555938005447388,
0.011150870472192764,
0.13547588884830475,
-0.9655439853668213,
-0.7719805836677551,
-0.014506238512694836,
-0.1672275960445404,
0.3845733106136322,
-0.17804408073425293,
0.12488803267478943,
-0.018407344818115234,
0.1231796145439148,
-0.8734179139137268,
0.23251795768737793,
-0.18501776456832886,
-0.25566530227661133,
0.17901046574115753,
-0.04720298945903778,
0.38853639364242554,
-0.33366265892982483,
-0.5366796255111694,
-0.2533681094646454,
-0.12447676062583923,
-0.18330629169940948,
0.12873360514640808,
0.09751718491315842,
-0.08023665100336075,
0.1275610625743866,
0.06289465725421906,
0.7988985180854797,
-0.17425663769245148,
-0.22706785798072815,
0.3099747896194458,
-0.5591999888420105,
-0.27820488810539246,
-0.3797696530818939,
0.649307906627655,
0.19313448667526245,
0.18031831085681915,
-0.19246135652065277,
-0.3047499656677246,
0.06082828342914581,
0.5294176340103149,
-0.7566489577293396,
-0.41319739818573,
-0.12254921346902847,
-0.8506336212158203,
-0.16230270266532898,
0.193860724568367,
-0.6859241127967834,
-0.3667035400867462,
-0.5988028645515442,
0.5668444037437439,
-0.4157997965812683,
-0.30469009280204773,
-0.1679438352584839,
-0.3258681297302246,
0.23040656745433807,
0.7641743421554565,
-0.7873319387435913,
0.20335356891155243,
0.1887754201889038,
0.541092574596405,
-0.0968148410320282,
-0.6365029811859131,
-0.5002521276473999,
0.3552927076816559,
-0.17987577617168427,
0.7787497639656067,
-0.4601347744464874,
-0.3084314167499542,
0.03908427059650421,
-0.2440454363822937,
-0.2322215735912323,
-0.3306747376918793,
0.3470920920372009,
-0.823978066444397,
0.29413852095603943,
0.2882501482963562,
-0.14542990922927856,
-0.1601972132921219,
0.6894060373306274,
-0.7024268507957458,
0.5196612477302551,
-0.07615990936756134,
-0.8549363017082214,
0.28008610010147095,
-0.5661184787750244,
-0.6784486770629883,
0.016318833455443382,
-0.13904736936092377,
-0.45231547951698303,
0.09344855695962906,
0.33999916911125183,
0.4308468699455261,
-0.026902571320533752,
-0.13692361116409302,
-0.36392074823379517,
-0.10470106452703476,
0.12849953770637512,
-0.6648533344268799,
0.5367839336395264,
0.25305989384651184,
0.0007704456802457571,
0.4962272644042969,
-1.022232174873352,
0.15535028278827667,
0.28437429666519165,
-0.6594040989875793,
-0.451452374458313,
-0.254583477973938,
0.7694412469863892,
0.3200758397579193,
0.3153717517852783,
-0.19206540286540985,
0.09364479035139084,
0.15362122654914856,
0.13690879940986633,
0.7135214805603027,
-0.26062703132629395,
0.5165595412254333,
-0.09567542374134064,
0.3935926854610443,
0.0755249634385109,
0.45403507351875305,
-0.472211092710495,
-0.15489181876182556,
-0.7260610461235046,
-0.38182583451271057,
0.24037747085094452,
0.3843042850494385,
-0.8888711333274841,
0.29565566778182983,
-0.2762787640094757,
-0.12885966897010803,
-0.09624879062175751,
0.32504957914352417,
0.6640921831130981,
0.6096277236938477,
0.5457192063331604,
-0.47349709272384644,
-0.5620612502098083,
-0.6970794200897217,
-0.059851307421922684,
0.008648449555039406,
0.010533212684094906,
0.18525183200836182,
0.47916871309280396,
-0.6172897219657898,
0.9042863845825195,
-0.3093281686306,
-0.4938473105430603,
-0.24046753346920013,
0.691167414188385,
-0.1634451001882553,
0.5949977040290833,
0.1618770956993103,
-1.4959745407104492,
-0.44534099102020264,
0.03843611478805542,
-0.7688876986503601,
0.1754864603281021,
-0.2659526467323303,
0.05707205459475517,
-0.20504242181777954,
0.3332769572734833,
-0.5969399213790894,
0.5046821236610413,
0.44171321392059326,
-0.15308114886283875,
0.463408887386322,
-0.4227292537689209,
-0.04965671896934509,
-1.0631177425384521,
0.058631911873817444,
0.371857225894928,
-0.3298579156398773,
-0.6339174509048462,
0.16400320827960968,
0.5630342364311218,
-0.32381436228752136,
-0.4597958028316498,
0.4983922839164734,
-0.8525691628456116,
-0.5017805695533752,
-0.010810798034071922,
0.13901080191135406,
0.5736066699028015,
0.6379116177558899,
0.047635238617658615,
0.517859160900116,
0.28391918540000916,
-0.574443519115448,
-0.013488177210092545,
0.4201485514640808,
-0.1255902200937271,
0.5856558680534363,
-0.2868768572807312,
0.08634598553180695,
-0.2644982635974884,
0.43471962213516235,
-0.9035958647727966,
-0.24987749755382538,
-0.08561600744724274,
-0.3791438341140747,
0.4813721776008606,
-0.11080951988697052,
-0.5076980590820312,
-0.38384783267974854,
-0.24720445275306702,
0.33753353357315063,
0.12667424976825714,
-0.4787256419658661,
0.9171801805496216,
0.05575183779001236,
-0.006077265832573175,
-0.5879727005958557,
-0.5266961455345154,
0.08578691631555557,
0.2736934423446655,
-0.6463913917541504,
0.5804048180580139,
-0.09205624461174011,
-0.14102359116077423,
0.09545537829399109,
-0.10119982808828354,
-0.6458091735839844,
0.41677114367485046,
0.33376508951187134,
0.3138487935066223,
-0.1725471466779709,
0.19909214973449707,
-0.1920793652534485,
-0.03377342224121094,
-0.2465551197528839,
-0.45674148201942444,
0.6822332143783569,
-0.2353370040655136,
-0.6309546828269958,
-0.8023348450660706,
0.28542953729629517,
0.6562635898590088,
-0.7998679280281067,
0.43924421072006226,
0.9768535494804382,
-0.4031326472759247,
0.10427083820104599,
-0.33805543184280396,
0.028263211250305176,
-0.45903483033180237,
0.5342555642127991,
-0.410864919424057,
-0.4100359082221985,
0.2764265239238739,
-0.12912815809249878,
-0.056258633732795715,
0.393171101808548,
0.25716352462768555,
-0.7205975651741028,
1.0340300798416138,
0.7540898323059082,
0.2338278591632843,
0.8123724460601807,
-0.3965342044830322,
-0.20600222051143646,
-0.7105342149734497,
-0.5627153515815735,
-0.34438493847846985,
-0.3585655689239502,
-0.004785510245710611,
-0.5808665752410889,
0.328725129365921,
0.4977853298187256,
0.04070939123630524,
-0.019251395016908646,
-0.07858525216579437,
0.31299102306365967,
0.5778160095214844,
0.28851959109306335,
0.3420110046863556,
0.06181596964597702,
-0.3343278467655182,
0.32462993264198303,
-0.622075080871582,
-0.1667856127023697,
0.759604275226593,
0.18559220433235168,
1.071403980255127,
0.01046000700443983,
0.561362624168396,
0.26944953203201294,
0.3113391697406769,
-0.6149068474769592,
0.37940454483032227,
-0.19399556517601013,
-0.34301865100860596,
-0.2953879237174988,
-0.34409603476524353,
-1.3257118463516235,
0.6161941885948181,
-0.6446720361709595,
-0.3409886658191681,
0.3007228672504425,
0.20834526419639587,
-0.11460436880588531,
0.122915118932724,
-0.7326236963272095,
1.0491018295288086,
-0.7396063208580017,
-0.48651283979415894,
-0.35509729385375977,
-0.7871600985527039,
-0.07741237431764603,
0.008869586512446404,
0.3628333508968353,
0.29207688570022583,
-0.05220383405685425,
0.45097747445106506,
-0.22493520379066467,
0.8826099038124084,
-0.025695370510220528,
0.050127070397138596,
-0.16934403777122498,
-0.03967541828751564,
0.31198179721832275,
-0.21754808723926544,
0.17913289368152618,
0.13214269280433655,
-0.2350972592830658,
-0.6141622066497803,
-0.689807653427124,
0.22029905021190643,
-0.9387905597686768,
-0.38448038697242737,
-0.32510337233543396,
-0.6006457805633545,
-0.290010541677475,
0.625835657119751,
0.34327274560928345,
0.993133008480072,
-0.20993447303771973,
0.36664676666259766,
0.6505563259124756,
-0.13166917860507965,
0.692107617855072,
0.2622271180152893,
-0.3744824528694153,
-0.36937302350997925,
0.8907192945480347,
-0.11900295317173004,
0.006394659634679556,
0.6485007405281067,
0.14113399386405945,
-0.48761889338493347,
-0.7761872410774231,
-0.5058152079582214,
-0.11570195853710175,
-0.9441478848457336,
-0.03681221604347229,
-0.810767412185669,
-0.21663032472133636,
-0.456127405166626,
-0.11177065223455429,
-0.021274443715810776,
-0.17166845500469208,
-0.7192712426185608,
0.153294175863266,
-0.25995275378227234,
0.9181204438209534,
0.14698538184165955,
0.25644198060035706,
-1.1648119688034058,
0.5830885171890259,
0.6343879103660583,
0.3347374498844147,
0.2695375680923462,
-0.24046911299228668,
-0.37930378317832947,
-0.15876466035842896,
-0.3335627317428589,
-0.7287564873695374,
0.39026883244514465,
0.3857284188270569,
0.9605998992919922,
0.6612383723258972,
-0.27364519238471985,
0.8201237320899963,
-0.39452028274536133,
0.48004990816116333,
0.7298039197921753,
-0.6744664907455444,
0.5153236389160156,
-0.6241142749786377,
0.591416597366333,
0.4283519685268402,
0.7975557446479797,
-0.2710913121700287,
0.25576484203338623,
-0.34341609477996826,
-0.5351433753967285,
0.4118409752845764,
0.11590009927749634,
0.1309197098016739,
0.22279168665409088,
-0.026099370792508125,
0.1108887642621994,
0.23115423321723938,
-0.9231410622596741,
0.17533358931541443,
-0.773679792881012,
-0.3627864420413971,
-0.024492964148521423,
-0.033538661897182465,
-0.05974151939153671,
-0.3202247619628906,
0.14396345615386963,
-0.4066433310508728,
-0.05063934624195099,
0.15786416828632355,
-1.0509109497070312,
0.1535222977399826,
0.22860397398471832,
0.6209936141967773,
0.9984856843948364,
-0.03864674270153046,
0.6259691119194031,
-0.2292775809764862,
-0.6431761980056763,
-0.027134330943226814,
0.27371662855148315,
0.18344680964946747,
-0.3012021780014038,
0.850203812122345,
0.8888352513313293,
0.3621283173561096,
-0.43476784229278564,
0.6078336834907532,
-0.38742098212242126,
-0.2793025076389313,
-0.08644825965166092,
-0.27366599440574646,
-0.06717730313539505,
0.18754234910011292,
0.6857540607452393,
0.19780471920967102,
0.09783373773097992,
-0.7408732771873474,
0.3900139629840851,
0.46956124901771545,
-0.42761266231536865,
-0.3588896691799164,
0.5402945876121521,
0.5083112716674805,
-0.4477720260620117,
0.7019104957580566,
-0.10540419816970825,
-0.764726459980011,
0.3811905086040497,
0.8293318748474121,
0.5175310373306274,
0.10510165989398956,
0.2483234703540802,
-0.04721928387880325,
0.025403983891010284,
0.40525129437446594,
0.13559748232364655,
-0.45512548089027405,
-0.7016794681549072,
-0.10294414311647415,
-0.826503336429596,
-0.1469348967075348,
-0.058584533631801605,
-0.46338438987731934,
-0.14155526459217072,
-0.5828855633735657,
-0.22098968923091888,
-0.03737004101276398,
-0.10360445082187653,
-0.8520883321762085,
0.5337971448898315,
0.42894431948661804,
0.7454560995101929,
-0.492533415555954,
1.0168081521987915,
0.7225743532180786,
-0.6467611193656921,
-0.4475368857383728,
0.30186671018600464,
0.04351189360022545,
-0.49135303497314453,
1.0221891403198242,
0.2856123745441437,
-0.15507154166698456,
0.22334988415241241,
-0.11280685663223267,
-0.7043691277503967,
0.9789215922355652,
0.08932516723871231,
-0.4329603910446167,
-0.30911874771118164,
-0.19933243095874786,
0.42023637890815735,
-0.06471434980630875,
0.35292303562164307,
-0.36789536476135254,
0.4866168200969696,
-0.1379353106021881,
-0.844646692276001,
-0.3729153871536255,
-0.645277738571167,
0.17463259398937225,
-0.10706128180027008,
-0.35382670164108276,
1.1953374147415161,
-0.0006547430530190468,
-0.08173565566539764,
-0.11619085818529129,
0.617194414138794,
-0.09069924801588058,
0.18052180111408234,
0.9635421633720398,
0.6175426244735718,
0.9181957840919495,
0.1922738254070282,
1.1582839488983154,
0.05337149649858475,
0.09520557522773743,
1.132603645324707,
-0.1140776202082634,
0.7883895039558411,
0.30460062623023987,
0.055652327835559845,
0.7164003252983093,
0.7136489748954773,
0.08659376949071884,
0.5076685547828674,
-0.04383397847414017,
-0.22308571636676788,
-0.5758246779441833,
-0.1731201708316803,
-0.355320543050766,
0.613423228263855,
0.31416308879852295,
-0.2781248986721039,
-0.4367852210998535,
0.2927306592464447,
-0.49651116132736206,
0.09304697811603546,
-0.5049038529396057,
0.8479713201522827,
-0.029736414551734924,
-0.28384339809417725,
0.4887109398841858,
-0.126859650015831,
0.6973081231117249,
-0.9010266065597534,
-0.015272610820829868,
0.00506783789023757,
0.0890234038233757,
-0.41764843463897705,
-0.6127137541770935,
-0.09165692329406738,
-0.20720161497592926,
-0.39723244309425354,
-0.4881572723388672,
1.1921230554580688,
-0.263249933719635,
-0.3060244023799896,
0.5586915612220764,
0.6506446599960327,
-0.21170668303966522,
-0.2043071836233139,
-0.825818657875061,
0.09213483333587646,
-0.3019293248653412,
-0.335269033908844,
0.6939204931259155,
0.32974082231521606,
-0.14482972025871277,
0.5448325276374817,
1.0475306510925293,
-0.3286018371582031,
0.39182835817337036,
0.5263315439224243,
0.9625835418701172,
-0.32087990641593933,
-0.6804433465003967,
-0.7368354201316833,
0.47369590401649475,
-0.30938124656677246,
-0.18060302734375,
0.6311734318733215,
0.5660417675971985,
0.7889516353607178,
-0.1273447424173355,
0.6376136541366577,
0.2999989986419678,
-0.34700968861579895,
-0.5484122037887573,
1.181451439857483,
-1.0286515951156616,
-0.4948585033416748,
-0.33424365520477295,
-1.0556644201278687,
-0.5060749053955078,
0.7877930998802185,
0.0007582202088087797,
-0.05595799535512924,
0.671661913394928,
0.4119184613227844,
-0.3319699168205261,
-0.11634009331464767,
0.5010964870452881,
-0.017436929047107697,
0.18095028400421143,
0.06505446135997772,
0.9170677661895752,
0.03972376883029938,
0.7838605046272278,
-0.1967187374830246,
-0.19630523025989532,
-0.24718362092971802,
-0.877937912940979,
-0.9062156677246094,
-0.8037944436073303,
0.18546675145626068,
-0.06438443809747696,
-0.06915362924337387,
0.7942547798156738,
1.2758296728134155,
-0.31222763657569885,
0.004331408999860287,
-0.023410411551594734,
0.10968954116106033,
-0.05620501562952995,
-0.09007512778043747,
0.22395937144756317,
-0.4346091151237488,
-0.4417356848716736,
0.38021203875541687,
0.43417367339134216,
0.32238176465034485,
-0.3403434455394745,
-0.05869264900684357,
-0.7469056248664856,
-0.16804489493370056,
0.7376290559768677,
0.06955613195896149,
-0.563721239566803,
-0.020520096644759178,
-0.10396289825439453,
-0.46122342348098755,
0.38112902641296387,
0.8024353981018066,
-0.5247971415519714,
0.5420800447463989,
0.569435179233551,
0.9351119995117188,
0.7156676054000854,
0.10208828002214432,
0.2518937587738037,
-0.9347171783447266,
0.33448168635368347,
0.19925355911254883,
0.6383998990058899,
0.39420953392982483,
-0.2157045304775238,
0.27823135256767273,
0.3792017102241516,
-0.05847000703215599,
-0.3745366930961609,
0.2513970136642456,
-1.112699031829834,
-0.7908002138137817,
0.6676385998725891,
-0.33782875537872314,
-0.23366419970989227,
-0.20152908563613892,
-0.1359241008758545,
0.47158896923065186,
0.0009480188600718975,
0.3485814034938812,
0.22850370407104492,
-0.029131626710295677,
-0.5616669058799744,
-0.16637980937957764,
0.1958790421485901,
0.30589932203292847,
-1.1400914192199707,
-0.36103734374046326,
0.559116542339325,
-0.13018544018268585,
0.5362904071807861,
0.732492983341217,
0.16298723220825195,
0.3284187912940979,
0.061584681272506714,
0.20639216899871826,
-0.34054675698280334,
-0.7232962846755981,
-0.18064679205417633,
0.3962993323802948,
-0.08670971542596817,
-0.21506106853485107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18258v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18258v1
|
A BiRGAT Model for Multi-intent Spoken Language Understanding with Hierarchical Semantic Frames
| 2024-02-28T11:39:26 | 2024-02-28T11:39:26 |
Hongshen Xu, Ruisheng Cao, Su Zhu, Sheng Jiang, Hanchong Zhang, Lu Chen, Kai Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Previous work on spoken language understanding (SLU) mainly focuses on
single-intent settings, where each input utterance merely contains one user
intent. This configuration significantly limits the surface form of user
utterances and the capacity of output semantics. In this work, we first propose
a Multi-Intent dataset which is collected from a realistic in-Vehicle dialogue
System, called MIVS. The target semantic frame is organized in a 3-layer
hierarchical structure to tackle the alignment and assignment problems in
multi-intent cases. Accordingly, we devise a BiRGAT model to encode the
hierarchy of ontology items, the backbone of which is a dual relational graph
attention network. Coupled with the 3-way pointer-generator decoder, our method
outperforms traditional sequence labeling and classification-based schemes by a
large margin.
|
[
-0.06811854988336563,
-0.6912641525268555,
0.5084059834480286,
0.2013319432735443,
-0.08731439709663391,
-0.20033034682273865,
-0.13081094622612,
-0.22938135266304016,
-0.17073789238929749,
0.6841681003570557,
-0.7402491569519043,
-0.4263366162776947,
-0.4116933345794678,
-0.21638274192810059,
-0.1213255301117897,
1.1582670211791992,
0.27584582567214966,
0.08324363827705383,
0.06691179424524307,
-0.2794386148452759,
-0.5519730448722839,
-0.24302515387535095,
-0.4464452862739563,
-0.2533856928348541,
0.5285278558731079,
0.6595791578292847,
0.8521007895469666,
0.3609505295753479,
0.5434244871139526,
0.21428140997886658,
-0.0019860626198351383,
0.20168758928775787,
-0.6299267411231995,
0.051735445857048035,
-0.3132932782173157,
-0.034086477011442184,
-0.6079740524291992,
-0.19209270179271698,
0.8979515433311462,
0.8474562168121338,
-0.2968567907810211,
0.03464068844914436,
0.04791253060102463,
0.30088528990745544,
-0.5542920827865601,
0.4620932936668396,
-0.4530838429927826,
-0.31490057706832886,
-0.020893435925245285,
-0.21095308661460876,
-0.763929545879364,
0.1114109680056572,
0.3872877061367035,
-0.875227153301239,
-0.08367842435836792,
0.18650655448436737,
0.9313152432441711,
0.43082180619239807,
-0.3632071316242218,
-0.3916020095348358,
-0.8924213647842407,
0.6117385029792786,
-0.5195780396461487,
0.6162182092666626,
0.4382787346839905,
0.21163126826286316,
-0.04181424155831337,
-0.7037060856819153,
-0.6205694079399109,
0.056109607219696045,
-0.3043537139892578,
0.2247270941734314,
-0.30116355419158936,
0.2595774233341217,
-0.03639296814799309,
0.13916249573230743,
-0.9397377967834473,
-0.09832436591386795,
-0.18440884351730347,
0.0927785336971283,
0.2472531646490097,
0.2632451355457306,
0.3868587613105774,
-0.377407044172287,
-0.8471139669418335,
-0.016860006377100945,
-0.6535724401473999,
0.09400584548711777,
-0.008665313944220543,
0.5260201096534729,
-0.05814199522137642,
0.7085834741592407,
-0.15222284197807312,
0.9550028443336487,
-0.02643890120089054,
-0.1656273901462555,
0.0879514217376709,
-0.8776537179946899,
-0.4470829367637634,
0.23412959277629852,
0.7650374174118042,
0.1986195296049118,
0.0531357116997242,
-0.25699737668037415,
0.14353838562965393,
-0.18265461921691895,
0.29004544019699097,
-0.5595320463180542,
0.008121776394546032,
0.11017344892024994,
-0.35421279072761536,
0.03213033825159073,
-0.04440269619226456,
-0.41716212034225464,
-0.018279612064361572,
-0.24985656142234802,
0.3776443898677826,
-0.6364825963973999,
-0.19260041415691376,
0.610436737537384,
0.1575879603624344,
0.597131073474884,
0.12302233278751373,
-1.125105857849121,
0.29279664158821106,
0.5296058654785156,
0.6061044931411743,
0.28969326615333557,
-0.4832513928413391,
-0.5551778078079224,
0.7372922897338867,
-0.08921777456998825,
0.8117324113845825,
-0.532157838344574,
-0.1829073280096054,
-0.29055798053741455,
-0.26137784123420715,
-0.3470381498336792,
0.1703614741563797,
0.48904627561569214,
-0.668580949306488,
0.30870088934898376,
0.10006590932607651,
-0.28889334201812744,
-0.518690824508667,
0.2598399817943573,
-0.18969516456127167,
0.8565600514411926,
0.2210593968629837,
-0.7902995347976685,
0.15950731933116913,
-0.867678701877594,
-0.45611923933029175,
0.3401529788970947,
-0.17280073463916779,
-0.18119874596595764,
-0.0277312770485878,
0.05819723382592201,
0.4140416979789734,
-0.2313772290945053,
0.395955353975296,
-0.20380094647407532,
-0.21085111796855927,
0.11162221431732178,
-0.45564907789230347,
0.7364048361778259,
-0.03735034912824631,
-0.15542063117027283,
0.27884650230407715,
-0.5318089723587036,
0.002190318889915943,
-0.056995656341314316,
-0.35376742482185364,
-0.5391831398010254,
-0.009637556038796902,
0.02760924957692623,
0.3628767728805542,
0.10936374217271805,
-0.6703502535820007,
0.15451446175575256,
-0.5592960119247437,
0.2322506159543991,
0.5337634682655334,
-0.04131927341222763,
0.4673480987548828,
0.0542876236140728,
0.23091882467269897,
0.030452579259872437,
0.22493566572666168,
-0.1443599909543991,
-0.6681731343269348,
-0.7216188907623291,
-0.11683783680200577,
-0.062344904989004135,
0.6711369156837463,
-0.6124308109283447,
0.364316463470459,
-0.7420477271080017,
-0.024257801473140717,
-0.5122396945953369,
-0.14538322389125824,
0.7116989493370056,
0.40296947956085205,
0.26112106442451477,
-0.17833757400512695,
-0.1991974413394928,
-1.0330594778060913,
-0.07399290800094604,
-0.4887935519218445,
0.13680478930473328,
0.4827762842178345,
0.26904383301734924,
-0.3977809250354767,
1.0025750398635864,
-0.48303160071372986,
-0.3866322338581085,
-0.39000725746154785,
0.06906525790691376,
0.048242464661598206,
0.09610392898321152,
0.22325216233730316,
-0.8545399904251099,
-0.39690065383911133,
0.48141372203826904,
-0.6793287396430969,
0.23389768600463867,
-0.0422062985599041,
-0.31294459104537964,
-0.28653833270072937,
0.19787029922008514,
-0.6784130930900574,
0.6115677952766418,
0.5132054686546326,
-0.4828384518623352,
0.2157919853925705,
-0.24314650893211365,
-0.030842630192637444,
-1.1008003950119019,
-0.13414746522903442,
-0.3025069832801819,
-0.2263146936893463,
-1.109521508216858,
-0.3910250663757324,
0.0666247084736824,
-0.07047891616821289,
-0.5091650485992432,
0.30502599477767944,
-0.41252952814102173,
-0.38392388820648193,
-0.13667701184749603,
0.4460987150669098,
0.3694925904273987,
0.8707271814346313,
0.16156521439552307,
0.6291326284408569,
0.47996270656585693,
-0.477273166179657,
0.1713460236787796,
0.817173182964325,
-0.4565807282924652,
0.4585449695587158,
-0.5550193190574646,
0.2379510998725891,
-0.36890408396720886,
0.2139115184545517,
-1.317466378211975,
-0.342765212059021,
0.39177456498146057,
-0.467134028673172,
0.3539317846298218,
-0.3467765748500824,
-0.26172614097595215,
0.07222913205623627,
0.12963397800922394,
0.3756125569343567,
-0.013016968965530396,
-0.4422125816345215,
0.7563331723213196,
0.6014719605445862,
-0.4228123724460602,
-0.7740123867988586,
-0.6416711807250977,
0.033013880252838135,
-0.022867616266012192,
-1.033424973487854,
0.2556992471218109,
0.18626147508621216,
-0.06512589752674103,
0.07974070310592651,
0.06395165622234344,
0.020571228116750717,
-0.1330578476190567,
0.317215234041214,
0.40735822916030884,
-0.45412686467170715,
0.28719696402549744,
0.055416397750377655,
-0.2938631474971771,
-0.14449916779994965,
-0.5492338538169861,
0.4900067150592804,
-0.4994661211967468,
-0.42613983154296875,
-0.7049757242202759,
0.7348239421844482,
0.6779043674468994,
-0.4229675531387329,
0.7637872099876404,
0.5038287043571472,
-0.20653089880943298,
0.042168378829956055,
-0.024005962535738945,
0.13913241028785706,
-0.3790619671344757,
0.4645789861679077,
-0.5724098682403564,
-0.8819431066513062,
0.08228205889463425,
0.14783161878585815,
0.28502601385116577,
0.1683482974767685,
0.9365100264549255,
-0.16727575659751892,
1.0801470279693604,
0.48419907689094543,
0.24525853991508484,
0.29251667857170105,
-0.26732319593429565,
0.7612799406051636,
-1.0199999809265137,
-0.4736761748790741,
-0.47537681460380554,
0.017540721222758293,
-0.23822550475597382,
-0.4437161087989807,
0.5146968960762024,
-0.029584703966975212,
-0.08430661261081696,
0.42111319303512573,
-0.3567497432231903,
0.27015477418899536,
0.2729750871658325,
-0.09719223529100418,
0.4384326934814453,
0.015315094962716103,
0.11072106659412384,
0.2902240455150604,
-0.9057935476303101,
-0.6010754108428955,
0.6039324998855591,
0.3408993184566498,
0.8752721548080444,
0.6625474691390991,
0.1564880609512329,
-0.11464216560125351,
0.24259129166603088,
-0.8355351090431213,
0.2604791820049286,
-0.11755600571632385,
-0.761085033416748,
-0.5827188491821289,
-0.38958001136779785,
-0.9843854308128357,
0.6834312677383423,
0.2649845778942108,
-0.9951815009117126,
0.44335564970970154,
0.034181106835603714,
-0.6587534546852112,
0.11086216568946838,
-0.9584927558898926,
1.1691738367080688,
-0.27278000116348267,
-0.29244065284729004,
-0.09853828698396683,
-1.0304452180862427,
0.4568718373775482,
0.3575579822063446,
0.45554405450820923,
-0.4157378673553467,
0.2019156813621521,
0.6493352055549622,
-0.043395575135946274,
0.7587687373161316,
-0.07797247171401978,
-0.027123579755425453,
0.14134283363819122,
-0.09018382430076599,
0.37025782465934753,
0.19639451801776886,
0.05431479960680008,
0.007434840314090252,
-0.056261807680130005,
-0.4125105142593384,
-0.5757768750190735,
0.5318629741668701,
-0.7277833819389343,
-0.2896476984024048,
-0.26654887199401855,
-0.8831826448440552,
-0.38997575640678406,
0.26912233233451843,
0.37031081318855286,
0.9410563707351685,
-0.3621998727321625,
0.13472889363765717,
0.6843696236610413,
-0.011652507819235325,
0.23893257975578308,
0.4249940514564514,
-0.18679644167423248,
0.03256139159202576,
0.9127151966094971,
-0.19852671027183533,
0.4979422688484192,
0.5528090000152588,
0.22766542434692383,
-0.5893312692642212,
-0.4956265985965729,
-0.7914886474609375,
0.18282337486743927,
-0.8670982122421265,
-0.12845923006534576,
-0.8721153140068054,
-0.16991998255252838,
-0.6302216053009033,
-0.005072401370853186,
-0.37664520740509033,
-0.4245181083679199,
-0.033081527799367905,
-0.04270847141742706,
0.21535387635231018,
1.1459559202194214,
0.0778065100312233,
0.723265528678894,
-0.7030422687530518,
0.4526957869529724,
0.30793705582618713,
0.40361160039901733,
-0.2808014750480652,
-0.6387318968772888,
-0.3587796688079834,
0.06814504414796829,
-0.07006938010454178,
-0.8080320358276367,
0.23438969254493713,
0.2813718914985657,
0.5950708985328674,
0.6290099024772644,
-0.044859372079372406,
0.6804033517837524,
-0.45254257321357727,
0.47408610582351685,
0.2616508901119232,
-0.7489519715309143,
0.4919735789299011,
-0.5376838445663452,
0.3689216673374176,
0.6951600909233093,
0.15925469994544983,
-0.8033717274665833,
-0.16953054070472717,
-0.4205699563026428,
-0.6388218998908997,
1.3147389888763428,
0.46515047550201416,
0.026424197480082512,
0.08650161325931549,
0.13082163035869598,
0.0017163401935249567,
-0.13932673633098602,
-0.593441367149353,
-0.3373689353466034,
-0.3287395238876343,
-0.22010259330272675,
-0.09321398288011551,
-0.23118889331817627,
-0.018321750685572624,
-0.06624538451433182,
0.6646389365196228,
0.04399881884455681,
0.28514716029167175,
0.15476569533348083,
-0.3403208553791046,
0.14966826140880585,
0.6080721616744995,
0.575300395488739,
0.515633761882782,
-0.26082679629325867,
0.403693825006485,
-0.15200740098953247,
-0.5934498906135559,
0.22143997251987457,
0.03564681485295296,
-0.13950717449188232,
-0.10876527428627014,
0.1459372490644455,
1.228358507156372,
0.4814370274543762,
-0.3735632598400116,
0.543996274471283,
-0.34743544459342957,
0.07514555752277374,
-0.07691207528114319,
-0.10082133114337921,
0.1607215255498886,
-0.13546234369277954,
-0.24698199331760406,
0.12716299295425415,
0.362644225358963,
-0.5030321478843689,
0.17806249856948853,
0.24373866617679596,
-0.7709217071533203,
-0.32376596331596375,
0.3209092319011688,
0.18180450797080994,
-0.36219996213912964,
0.6790524125099182,
-0.3285858631134033,
-0.4500059485435486,
0.0819396898150444,
0.42381787300109863,
0.6442998051643372,
-0.3310473561286926,
0.22667689621448517,
0.18921829760074615,
0.2734070122241974,
0.31460294127464294,
0.18068696558475494,
-0.20129665732383728,
-1.1377897262573242,
-0.46405428647994995,
-0.6884111762046814,
-0.37843602895736694,
-0.04176446422934532,
-0.7828779220581055,
-0.032786086201667786,
-0.12982282042503357,
-0.011319384910166264,
0.41571512818336487,
-0.4173440635204315,
-0.5049803256988525,
-0.1702556163072586,
0.05142718553543091,
0.36973458528518677,
-0.6386133432388306,
1.1791516542434692,
0.6236248016357422,
-0.24838288128376007,
-0.8707858324050903,
-0.16629496216773987,
0.10223038494586945,
-0.7186846137046814,
0.47313421964645386,
0.13727255165576935,
-0.8025847673416138,
0.28867238759994507,
-0.11682742834091187,
-0.9165841341018677,
0.7048476338386536,
-0.05606376752257347,
-0.267782062292099,
-0.2616060972213745,
0.029235245659947395,
0.1163182258605957,
-0.5845615267753601,
0.17382647097110748,
0.8972558379173279,
0.5745750665664673,
0.1225590705871582,
-0.7084168195724487,
-0.38475850224494934,
-0.3259830176830292,
0.024662675336003304,
0.2929719090461731,
-0.40817978978157043,
0.6326377987861633,
-0.3203426003456116,
-0.3588887155056,
-0.20854146778583527,
0.5130993723869324,
0.15379782021045685,
0.1799391806125641,
0.5658658742904663,
0.43836522102355957,
0.5287685394287109,
-0.016994534060359,
1.159947156906128,
0.009201083332300186,
0.5377713441848755,
1.388034462928772,
-0.46328482031822205,
0.6383856534957886,
0.4683431088924408,
0.0706617459654808,
0.6339802742004395,
0.41027265787124634,
0.5375633239746094,
0.7263060808181763,
-0.18894711136817932,
-0.3978355824947357,
-0.3684786260128021,
-0.2710685133934021,
-0.02083936706185341,
0.8539602160453796,
0.8949752449989319,
0.13678929209709167,
-0.4225437045097351,
0.2062925547361374,
-0.1294674426317215,
-0.291781485080719,
-0.054209765046834946,
1.1514766216278076,
-0.17558419704437256,
-0.6867862343788147,
0.41642898321151733,
-0.00019256143423262984,
0.07729874551296234,
-0.6577176451683044,
0.03691237419843674,
0.18586552143096924,
0.267583429813385,
-0.16086161136627197,
-1.053270697593689,
0.3380059003829956,
-0.19122794270515442,
-0.23700843751430511,
-0.34015607833862305,
0.7330936789512634,
-0.7070356011390686,
-0.2681172490119934,
0.42762163281440735,
0.39822861552238464,
0.4403100311756134,
0.13078628480434418,
-0.5365132689476013,
-0.04916328191757202,
0.02687685564160347,
-0.35165935754776,
-0.013970914296805859,
0.35629719495773315,
-0.041029468178749084,
0.5045562982559204,
0.51031893491745,
-0.3296259641647339,
0.3407573103904724,
0.35409146547317505,
0.7446244955062866,
-0.3818477690219879,
-0.5789543390274048,
-0.5892463326454163,
0.5721354484558105,
0.027186695486307144,
-0.3010351061820984,
0.6721505522727966,
0.5233675241470337,
0.6806769371032715,
0.33423179388046265,
0.842805802822113,
-0.06965374201536179,
0.32622030377388,
-0.40571823716163635,
0.41808244585990906,
-0.4320952594280243,
0.20281921327114105,
0.030162418261170387,
-0.46023058891296387,
-0.326419860124588,
0.828039288520813,
-0.34130826592445374,
-0.18524040281772614,
0.586547315120697,
0.9015300273895264,
-0.3615742325782776,
0.3647761940956116,
0.47300758957862854,
0.191132590174675,
0.18670079112052917,
0.7303656935691833,
1.0359445810317993,
-0.38809704780578613,
0.634285032749176,
-0.18141081929206848,
-0.4556853175163269,
-0.32214802503585815,
-0.22509916126728058,
-0.6547102928161621,
-0.6571143865585327,
0.051427602767944336,
-0.2456350028514862,
0.003382215043529868,
0.5854597687721252,
0.8705885410308838,
-0.5685639977455139,
-0.3167169392108917,
0.2155197411775589,
0.256247878074646,
-0.06811384111642838,
-0.1066012755036354,
0.5147733092308044,
-0.3279031217098236,
-0.4831664264202118,
0.6422401666641235,
1.0074175596237183,
-0.18223848938941956,
-0.23677027225494385,
-0.39097148180007935,
-0.5731390714645386,
0.04233790561556816,
0.7969847321510315,
-0.08033330738544464,
-0.9002171158790588,
-0.5262357592582703,
0.1444571167230606,
-0.2702735662460327,
0.27611488103866577,
1.039567232131958,
-0.3078654706478119,
0.5208016633987427,
0.5083524584770203,
0.4069026708602905,
0.671107292175293,
0.12558546662330627,
0.3665560483932495,
-0.7044999599456787,
0.18775536119937897,
0.21336381137371063,
0.358468234539032,
0.1910477876663208,
-0.3757748305797577,
0.23577772080898285,
-0.12017856538295746,
-0.49550074338912964,
-0.5081843733787537,
0.47573140263557434,
-1.4062775373458862,
-0.32878413796424866,
1.1422655582427979,
-0.21196673810482025,
-0.3598465621471405,
-0.9483105540275574,
-0.18315115571022034,
0.365051805973053,
-0.3141178786754608,
0.028183748945593834,
0.48799794912338257,
-0.487881600856781,
-0.17647244036197662,
-0.6325719356536865,
0.2211081087589264,
0.3328361213207245,
-0.747710108757019,
0.6179971694946289,
0.39305534958839417,
0.0675320252776146,
0.21513062715530396,
0.8420094847679138,
-0.1693345308303833,
0.4461301863193512,
-0.03990666940808296,
0.10730437934398651,
0.17824064195156097,
-0.699076771736145,
-0.2441718727350235,
0.08212705701589584,
-0.04154171049594879,
-0.3589673936367035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18252v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18252v1
|
Towards Generalist Prompting for Large Language Models by Mental Models
| 2024-02-28T11:29:09 | 2024-02-28T11:29:09 |
Haoxiang Guan, Jiyan He, Shuxin Zheng, En-Hong Chen, Weiming Zhang, Nenghai Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance on many
tasks. However, to achieve optimal performance, specially designed prompting
methods are still needed. These methods either rely on task-specific few-shot
examples that require a certain level of domain knowledge, or are designed to
be simple but only perform well on a few types of tasks. In this work, we
attempt to introduce the concept of generalist prompting, which operates on the
design principle of achieving optimal or near-optimal performance on a wide
range of tasks while eliminating the need for manual selection and
customization of prompts tailored to specific problems. Furthermore, we propose
MeMo (Mental Models), an innovative prompting method that is simple-designed
yet effectively fulfills the criteria of generalist prompting. MeMo distills
the cores of various prompting methods into individual mental models and allows
LLMs to autonomously select the most suitable mental models for the problem,
achieving or being near to the state-of-the-art results on diverse tasks such
as STEM, logical reasoning, and commonsense reasoning in zero-shot settings. We
hope that the insights presented herein will stimulate further exploration of
generalist prompting methods for LLMs.
|
[
-0.5628918409347534,
-1.0595669746398926,
1.017728328704834,
0.2097586989402771,
-0.4033045172691345,
-0.38058382272720337,
-0.44771403074264526,
0.16385343670845032,
0.14282530546188354,
0.3851245641708374,
-0.9393284916877747,
-0.5509145855903625,
-0.10398554801940918,
-0.00030424894066527486,
-0.4299660325050354,
0.9765384793281555,
0.06312653422355652,
-0.08500911295413971,
-0.18242521584033966,
0.20456553995609283,
-0.6961997747421265,
-0.4482359290122986,
-0.7886506915092468,
-0.34182634949684143,
0.7829415202140808,
0.35216575860977173,
0.30415329337120056,
0.5394399762153625,
-0.016545603051781654,
0.21363084018230438,
-0.13403554260730743,
0.14999033510684967,
-0.29668015241622925,
0.3306457996368408,
-0.26176953315734863,
-0.7251046299934387,
-0.3333367109298706,
-0.054519571363925934,
0.45538952946662903,
0.5218843817710876,
-0.33309659361839294,
0.2259475737810135,
0.14861999452114105,
0.6482805609703064,
-0.6338340640068054,
-0.014349138364195824,
-0.7555777430534363,
-0.03498261794447899,
0.02289845049381256,
-0.25457528233528137,
-0.5448647141456604,
-0.3226812779903412,
0.03754841163754463,
-0.7019473314285278,
0.39813852310180664,
0.17294935882091522,
0.5108041763305664,
0.12808792293071747,
-0.051240094006061554,
-0.4052908718585968,
-0.8244202733039856,
0.7265065312385559,
-0.5302085876464844,
0.09523096680641174,
0.4241257607936859,
0.3644137680530548,
-0.2014576494693756,
-0.2728542983531952,
-0.551455020904541,
-0.445101261138916,
0.15182112157344818,
0.022192589938640594,
-0.4546578824520111,
0.2554049491882324,
0.52774578332901,
0.054726455360651016,
-0.663104772567749,
0.07620415091514587,
-0.11949942260980606,
0.03523198887705803,
0.2837585508823395,
0.4218398630619049,
0.34599894285202026,
0.22211912274360657,
0.0543251633644104,
0.12747852504253387,
-0.8134488463401794,
0.11375223100185394,
0.38149699568748474,
0.3725460469722748,
-0.1066678836941719,
0.4651181697845459,
-0.346082866191864,
0.9198719263076782,
0.322642982006073,
0.10291975736618042,
-0.42616963386535645,
-0.2350032478570938,
-0.2400943636894226,
-0.36918574571609497,
0.7141770124435425,
0.2704658806324005,
0.9545401930809021,
-0.1466381698846817,
-0.46336305141448975,
0.25793179869651794,
0.11864278465509415,
-0.6790373921394348,
-0.4423755407333374,
0.1840563863515854,
-0.10528751462697983,
-0.022542167454957962,
-0.3336893320083618,
-0.8228757977485657,
-0.24206459522247314,
-0.676473081111908,
0.4845616817474365,
-0.35114914178848267,
-0.055630072951316833,
0.3325585126876831,
-0.14439955353736877,
-0.054567791521549225,
0.5429433584213257,
-1.5320590734481812,
0.2887793481349945,
0.5968515872955322,
0.7289800047874451,
0.05467389151453972,
-0.04853622242808342,
-0.6469318270683289,
0.6019864678382874,
-0.5019119381904602,
0.9961191415786743,
-0.7189489006996155,
-0.7449550032615662,
0.13760016858577728,
-0.5207170844078064,
-0.12835612893104553,
-0.5636675953865051,
0.3316997289657593,
-0.298541396856308,
0.4346862733364105,
-0.5844941735267639,
-0.42350542545318604,
-0.19280731678009033,
0.32660526037216187,
-0.3564939796924591,
0.6659972071647644,
-0.087459996342659,
-0.41590505838394165,
0.22107787430286407,
-0.8957772850990295,
-0.19259993731975555,
0.11893697082996368,
-0.37800508737564087,
0.25910988450050354,
0.5622411370277405,
0.6105944514274597,
0.5586557388305664,
-0.7382861971855164,
0.5013309717178345,
-0.23054823279380798,
-0.4402144253253937,
0.02867579087615013,
-0.4679868817329407,
0.5574737191200256,
0.17473651468753815,
-0.15312205255031586,
0.24812841415405273,
-0.3937165141105652,
0.2649688422679901,
0.3158133924007416,
-0.4482979476451874,
-0.41624245047569275,
-0.10301986336708069,
-0.3474825918674469,
0.03441784530878067,
0.015427879057824612,
-0.05326637625694275,
0.5513224601745605,
-0.27390411496162415,
0.3643719553947449,
0.9500908851623535,
0.033328067511320114,
0.5528914332389832,
-0.5484201908111572,
0.7113423943519592,
-0.13008004426956177,
0.19067654013633728,
-0.4132063388824463,
-0.38658764958381653,
-0.6737515926361084,
-0.5878292918205261,
-0.04700413718819618,
0.7294529676437378,
-0.2953321039676666,
0.21223421394824982,
-0.20992498099803925,
-0.07854265719652176,
-0.4496075510978699,
0.5557923913002014,
0.30529966950416565,
0.3934421241283417,
0.3256949186325073,
-0.10024182498455048,
-0.4075995981693268,
-0.9452572464942932,
-0.3470430076122284,
-0.2591229975223541,
-0.42587941884994507,
0.3808349072933197,
0.2496822476387024,
-0.1175839975476265,
1.1448606252670288,
-0.5409330725669861,
-0.1469527930021286,
-0.449457585811615,
0.13233274221420288,
0.4987630844116211,
0.14693006873130798,
0.4300936162471771,
-0.40700677037239075,
-0.45096322894096375,
-0.24421562254428864,
-0.6870916485786438,
-0.4483877122402191,
-0.05009119212627411,
-0.03476344421505928,
0.11229370534420013,
0.6290063858032227,
-0.9902607798576355,
0.10957613587379456,
0.14792773127555847,
0.027332881465554237,
0.782293438911438,
-0.2633432447910309,
-0.15143075585365295,
-0.9278049468994141,
0.328511506319046,
0.07573995739221573,
0.1520325094461441,
-0.8664520978927612,
-0.01053088903427124,
0.05534347519278526,
-0.08986534923315048,
-0.3844853639602661,
0.9510022401809692,
-0.47599607706069946,
0.44544562697410583,
-0.1824953258037567,
0.09765144437551498,
-0.010688798502087593,
0.5435678958892822,
-0.24959853291511536,
0.7284122109413147,
0.5237520933151245,
-1.0010956525802612,
0.34779036045074463,
-0.05181249603629112,
-0.18646308779716492,
0.8376151919364929,
-0.9033392667770386,
0.35539621114730835,
-0.5095774531364441,
0.2510804831981659,
-1.0239403247833252,
-0.39551278948783875,
0.3674040138721466,
-0.10898487269878387,
0.35288333892822266,
-0.14433884620666504,
-0.4111717939376831,
-0.7734498977661133,
-0.21482883393764496,
0.11768501996994019,
0.6063508987426758,
-0.3599008321762085,
0.533163845539093,
-0.09000717103481293,
-0.4183999300003052,
-0.38554471731185913,
-0.37633270025253296,
0.020140353590250015,
-0.3738611936569214,
-0.3765803873538971,
0.0638771504163742,
-0.6338911652565002,
-0.32416224479675293,
-0.1574525535106659,
-0.0029182485304772854,
0.0830618292093277,
0.13823828101158142,
0.22280937433242798,
0.6866070628166199,
-0.2790047824382782,
0.11581119894981384,
0.06086236238479614,
-0.17011475563049316,
0.1380118876695633,
-0.5161389708518982,
0.693979799747467,
-0.0032633936498314142,
-0.43656831979751587,
-0.5909965634346008,
0.5580799579620361,
0.3509976267814636,
-0.1520777940750122,
0.3142629563808441,
0.22683651745319366,
-0.28879597783088684,
-0.44359493255615234,
-0.9567314982414246,
-0.49034181237220764,
-0.49829399585723877,
0.09280268102884293,
-0.5366631150245667,
-0.9884976148605347,
0.3422394096851349,
-0.13106516003608704,
0.20675291121006012,
0.017572373151779175,
0.7443355321884155,
0.023094644770026207,
1.359073519706726,
0.6091436743736267,
-0.24107478559017181,
0.5833689570426941,
-0.15710143744945526,
0.14382028579711914,
-0.7235419750213623,
-0.03589499369263649,
-0.5711284875869751,
-0.17698419094085693,
0.2641479969024658,
-0.3189815580844879,
0.1148962527513504,
0.229952871799469,
-0.41912147402763367,
-0.1362069547176361,
-0.5885608196258545,
0.8472107648849487,
0.5941691398620605,
-0.2859165370464325,
0.11873720586299896,
0.2904032766819,
-0.7506985068321228,
0.11376192420721054,
-0.6622414588928223,
-0.5909956097602844,
0.8162261843681335,
0.12111477553844452,
0.981257438659668,
-0.011206913739442825,
0.8104133009910583,
0.032058387994766235,
0.30231693387031555,
-0.9792484045028687,
0.8874797224998474,
0.17358608543872833,
-0.8792930841445923,
-0.28205224871635437,
-0.2777905762195587,
-0.9532147645950317,
0.17525888979434967,
0.20586833357810974,
-1.1075090169906616,
0.02208016999065876,
0.4507065415382385,
-0.7014203667640686,
0.08282335847616196,
-0.6012573838233948,
0.6330856680870056,
-0.04950236156582832,
-0.07203850895166397,
-0.3169543445110321,
-0.3075035810470581,
0.4513252079486847,
0.0025188885629177094,
0.3270584046840668,
-0.21369503438472748,
-0.24375195801258087,
0.4497637450695038,
0.09470962733030319,
1.0424370765686035,
-0.40709787607192993,
-0.060118936002254486,
0.3104020357131958,
0.34594711661338806,
0.7704532742500305,
-0.3366864025592804,
0.05596097931265831,
-0.5187324285507202,
-0.2926468849182129,
-0.2118321806192398,
-0.7608476281166077,
0.6168525815010071,
-0.4096848964691162,
-1.166872262954712,
0.1330224722623825,
-0.8187127113342285,
-0.37550070881843567,
0.3079422116279602,
0.4060525894165039,
0.43710848689079285,
-0.2243354618549347,
-0.15618951618671417,
0.9797901511192322,
-0.045618146657943726,
0.558391273021698,
0.636324405670166,
-0.37846803665161133,
-0.4415348470211029,
0.8574156761169434,
0.1140754371881485,
0.30798643827438354,
0.32328367233276367,
0.4024156928062439,
-0.43295636773109436,
-0.6580261588096619,
-0.4901280701160431,
0.4995162785053253,
-0.8039889335632324,
0.047400038689374924,
-0.73635333776474,
0.16339431703090668,
-0.39215803146362305,
-0.38277801871299744,
0.10261295735836029,
-0.21890585124492645,
-0.4668181836605072,
0.06037040054798126,
0.16137689352035522,
0.802790105342865,
-0.02001168765127659,
0.24081067740917206,
-0.6710365414619446,
0.4259188175201416,
0.8016420602798462,
0.051893413066864014,
0.40159517526626587,
-0.6074827909469604,
-0.08251089602708817,
-0.021938931196928024,
-0.44431164860725403,
-0.6756529808044434,
0.23430848121643066,
0.14334805309772491,
0.9519754648208618,
0.6546380519866943,
0.11396650969982147,
0.6310393810272217,
-0.7230808138847351,
0.6014173626899719,
0.41582149267196655,
-0.9462165236473083,
0.8655611276626587,
-0.7434214353561401,
0.5690800547599792,
0.45284411311149597,
0.3899567127227783,
-0.8399467468261719,
-0.4626782536506653,
-0.42794743180274963,
-0.7955236434936523,
0.42899104952812195,
-0.47584986686706543,
0.47920531034469604,
-0.3065027892589569,
0.4291004538536072,
-0.06966942548751831,
0.3010793924331665,
-0.45706215500831604,
-0.04645320400595665,
0.12238360941410065,
-0.35340502858161926,
0.0767078697681427,
-0.22798363864421844,
-0.41017356514930725,
-0.10157064348459244,
0.5368072986602783,
-0.4646407663822174,
0.3754718005657196,
0.13018323481082916,
-0.05587349832057953,
-0.3319273591041565,
0.527889609336853,
0.9383598566055298,
0.7717258334159851,
-0.046159204095602036,
0.010732267051935196,
0.3622264564037323,
-0.1072346642613411,
0.48332709074020386,
-0.28922519087791443,
-0.4386521279811859,
-0.13777726888656616,
-0.0693303793668747,
0.8076411485671997,
0.12530994415283203,
-0.3829687237739563,
0.276923269033432,
-0.03679225966334343,
-0.3909735381603241,
0.0011534225195646286,
0.5029160380363464,
0.40965381264686584,
0.2506923973560333,
0.5305076837539673,
-0.30311498045921326,
-0.1448420137166977,
-0.38664934039115906,
-0.13891282677650452,
0.6580917835235596,
-0.21419450640678406,
-0.44932201504707336,
0.8160768151283264,
-0.011330093257129192,
-0.5508198738098145,
0.6012910604476929,
-0.13860216736793518,
-0.2495051920413971,
0.25064530968666077,
0.847545862197876,
1.0119653940200806,
-0.43326717615127563,
0.3948984146118164,
0.3404601216316223,
0.14090099930763245,
-0.4685957133769989,
0.23790724575519562,
-0.13073231279850006,
-0.46556881070137024,
-0.4574942886829376,
-0.4197064936161041,
-0.5629069805145264,
0.2944451570510864,
-0.6574898958206177,
0.12461695075035095,
-0.8842892050743103,
-0.1274072527885437,
-0.040844112634658813,
-0.09721272438764572,
-0.6656969785690308,
0.1037556454539299,
0.28622227907180786,
1.1686514616012573,
-0.685880184173584,
0.896564245223999,
0.6049994826316833,
-0.1876801699399948,
-0.894223153591156,
-0.12032793462276459,
0.30378782749176025,
-0.9638614654541016,
0.4705123007297516,
0.2341102510690689,
-0.021523788571357727,
0.14836344122886658,
-0.6785948276519775,
-0.4667604863643646,
0.8462258577346802,
0.7992584705352783,
-0.7210768461227417,
-0.4028034210205078,
-0.10858041793107986,
0.3880341053009033,
-0.46565771102905273,
0.11618442088365555,
0.36043575406074524,
0.6121224164962769,
0.2228153944015503,
-0.5432985424995422,
0.28412097692489624,
-0.25243526697158813,
0.2552509009838104,
0.1435621678829193,
-0.42172783613204956,
0.7642655968666077,
-0.47838911414146423,
-0.2828020751476288,
0.3031473457813263,
0.46281734108924866,
0.4208458364009857,
0.12123674154281616,
0.5322715044021606,
0.38789868354797363,
1.155012607574463,
0.1867665946483612,
1.158395528793335,
-0.14282739162445068,
-0.09606829285621643,
0.9625018835067749,
-0.28225570917129517,
0.7506721615791321,
0.51319420337677,
-0.10656628012657166,
0.34173962473869324,
0.430514931678772,
-0.012816302478313446,
0.5048696398735046,
0.42521417140960693,
-0.6396527886390686,
-0.42813625931739807,
-0.21896187961101532,
-0.1915145218372345,
-0.12988556921482086,
0.6159611940383911,
-0.13870881497859955,
-0.22907724976539612,
-0.07268816232681274,
0.10114916414022446,
-0.16410620510578156,
-0.35963836312294006,
0.7485180497169495,
0.2642905116081238,
-1.0276429653167725,
0.7539174556732178,
-0.23268942534923553,
0.6306635141372681,
-0.7399110794067383,
0.3441295325756073,
-0.3379785120487213,
0.031386177986860275,
0.21379493176937103,
-0.5751314759254456,
0.014268124476075172,
-0.05295496806502342,
-0.6084864139556885,
-0.2052076756954193,
0.5346991419792175,
-0.4368591010570526,
-0.1435575783252716,
0.1893213987350464,
0.6209768652915955,
0.04395754262804985,
-0.29658281803131104,
-0.718772828578949,
-0.11379972845315933,
-0.005119984969496727,
-0.28875038027763367,
0.4283090829849243,
0.5646014213562012,
-0.15901152789592743,
0.9108371138572693,
0.8882633447647095,
0.18710309267044067,
-0.27964407205581665,
0.2860431373119354,
0.8132423162460327,
-0.975886881351471,
-0.4856627583503723,
-1.2344659566879272,
0.40577930212020874,
0.1678871214389801,
-0.18789489567279816,
0.5676090717315674,
0.10519400238990784,
0.46142175793647766,
-0.25345245003700256,
0.9134363532066345,
0.40808746218681335,
0.4438016414642334,
-0.5025847554206848,
0.3992038369178772,
-0.34270790219306946,
0.21569159626960754,
-0.17827878892421722,
-0.9761860370635986,
-0.4427592158317566,
0.5063962340354919,
-0.4913577437400818,
0.052509475499391556,
0.5770085453987122,
1.1692036390304565,
0.035821426659822464,
0.15058301389217377,
0.5861932635307312,
-0.016470974311232567,
0.49523335695266724,
0.7017943263053894,
1.0574616193771362,
0.43490850925445557,
0.5455074310302734,
0.20518657565116882,
-0.16692572832107544,
-0.40451058745384216,
-0.8572971224784851,
-1.1845699548721313,
-0.3170214891433716,
0.005739687010645866,
0.03966108337044716,
0.16730943322181702,
1.1630213260650635,
0.5412707924842834,
-0.694808304309845,
-0.31776392459869385,
-0.13965488970279694,
0.0661078691482544,
0.02056894823908806,
-0.11954790353775024,
-0.0479888916015625,
-0.5142161846160889,
-0.7266843318939209,
0.45239338278770447,
0.40090394020080566,
0.44743192195892334,
-0.2248983532190323,
-0.0838732048869133,
0.022490134462714195,
0.5308066010475159,
0.33778470754623413,
0.4851374328136444,
-0.9562346339225769,
-0.10434150695800781,
0.034588947892189026,
-0.27531078457832336,
-0.11978218704462051,
1.0689218044281006,
-0.7556424140930176,
0.285183310508728,
0.4182022213935852,
0.3878481388092041,
0.2197129875421524,
-0.1459205150604248,
0.6609445810317993,
-0.5415776968002319,
0.020734107121825218,
0.29791900515556335,
0.1711772084236145,
0.2630413770675659,
-0.1471477895975113,
0.30161920189857483,
0.14075811207294464,
-0.4580278694629669,
-0.8180184960365295,
0.34576940536499023,
-0.607025146484375,
-0.21981921792030334,
1.1535269021987915,
-0.13312892615795135,
-0.320599228143692,
-0.12143900990486145,
-0.5008130669593811,
-0.09461386501789093,
-0.5844430923461914,
0.6962141394615173,
0.8487537503242493,
-0.005606491584330797,
-0.22341100871562958,
-0.8478596806526184,
0.3907594382762909,
0.6471688151359558,
-0.6131789088249207,
0.31995323300361633,
0.46506252884864807,
0.3495562970638275,
-0.004980379715561867,
0.8182327747344971,
0.2923862636089325,
0.3611706793308258,
-0.19659413397312164,
-0.1409376710653305,
-0.19199298322200775,
-0.5519147515296936,
-0.4797089695930481,
0.19578613340854645,
0.2030407339334488,
0.17723190784454346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18243v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18243v2
|
Learning or Self-aligning? Rethinking Instruction Fine-tuning
| 2024-02-28T11:16:00 | 2024-03-02T08:28:14 |
Mengjie Ren, Boxi Cao, Hongyu Lin, Cao Liu, Xianpei Han, Ke Zeng, Guanglu Wan, Xunliang Cai, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction Fine-tuning~(IFT) is a critical phase in building large language
models~(LLMs). Previous works mainly focus on the IFT's role in the transfer of
behavioral norms and the learning of additional world knowledge. However, the
understanding of the underlying mechanisms of IFT remains significantly
limited. In this paper, we design a knowledge intervention framework to
decouple the potential underlying factors of IFT, thereby enabling individual
analysis of different factors. Surprisingly, our experiments reveal that
attempting to learn additional world knowledge through IFT often struggles to
yield positive impacts and can even lead to markedly negative effects. Further,
we discover that maintaining internal knowledge consistency before and after
IFT is a critical factor for achieving successful IFT. Our findings reveal the
underlying mechanisms of IFT and provide robust support for some very recent
and potential future works.
|
[
-0.29618382453918457,
-0.7119712233543396,
0.4407206177711487,
-0.13817434012889862,
0.016428794711828232,
0.12232384830713272,
-0.2948766052722931,
-0.24581049382686615,
-0.37886810302734375,
0.3340103328227997,
-0.7016937732696533,
-0.2741827368736267,
-0.614829421043396,
-0.08855284005403519,
-0.37007075548171997,
1.11223304271698,
-0.24915356934070587,
-0.21044564247131348,
-0.04951855540275574,
0.09527209401130676,
-0.7999287247657776,
-0.14260882139205933,
-0.7985536456108093,
-0.49901679158210754,
0.34555235505104065,
0.9150893688201904,
0.36723077297210693,
0.7602059245109558,
0.4990313947200775,
0.2374563068151474,
0.2692788243293762,
0.22859837114810944,
-0.7489334344863892,
-0.08324309438467026,
-0.30375972390174866,
-0.4602372944355011,
-0.1432596892118454,
0.02894178405404091,
0.8781255483627319,
0.5758558511734009,
-0.10302449017763138,
0.17652881145477295,
0.6139429211616516,
0.6804468035697937,
-0.38786745071411133,
0.2819311320781708,
-0.4812529981136322,
-0.15139605104923248,
-0.06227691471576691,
-0.2274959236383438,
-0.0766194760799408,
-0.3016575574874878,
0.15742461383342743,
-0.4048894941806793,
0.1588641256093979,
-0.17234398424625397,
0.7059629559516907,
0.6125102639198303,
-0.42428383231163025,
-0.27955254912376404,
-0.6343528032302856,
0.6581227779388428,
-0.7836641073226929,
0.6567180156707764,
0.33024516701698303,
-0.1433131843805313,
-0.41054368019104004,
-0.3832985460758209,
-0.40714195370674133,
-0.19360357522964478,
-0.033267792314291,
-0.11633075773715973,
0.0706200897693634,
0.182437464594841,
0.10630083829164505,
0.4431300461292267,
0.05708694085478783,
0.34542644023895264,
-0.560237467288971,
-0.18576093018054962,
0.5020912289619446,
0.12764163315296173,
0.2207159698009491,
0.10741714388132095,
-0.4944547712802887,
0.1261158287525177,
-0.9776220917701721,
0.509649395942688,
0.3148893713951111,
0.45774081349372864,
-0.1482410877943039,
0.43336567282676697,
-0.2412220984697342,
0.677345871925354,
0.543851912021637,
-0.28062209486961365,
-0.29495465755462646,
-0.38238656520843506,
-0.06867692619562149,
0.19554835557937622,
0.4711812734603882,
0.4087558388710022,
0.18540522456169128,
-0.1254386156797409,
-0.48142144083976746,
-0.1789383441209793,
0.32790282368659973,
-0.8314761519432068,
-0.29934847354888916,
-0.11832533776760101,
-0.177682027220726,
-0.22618959844112396,
0.09784317761659622,
-0.3329014778137207,
-0.1321965754032135,
-0.8574888110160828,
0.5731687545776367,
-0.7138442993164062,
-0.2400592863559723,
0.20384475588798523,
0.20594578981399536,
0.46332815289497375,
0.17441745102405548,
-1.1199973821640015,
0.2728444039821625,
0.8743456602096558,
0.4483603537082672,
-0.10636597126722336,
-0.5159109234809875,
-0.23095446825027466,
0.13340330123901367,
-0.43174904584884644,
0.7982655763626099,
-0.49567461013793945,
-0.3369886577129364,
-0.0010649942560121417,
0.16577284038066864,
-0.012878138571977615,
-0.42181509733200073,
0.3093934655189514,
-0.4028683006763458,
0.2179107815027237,
-0.591426432132721,
-1.0631754398345947,
-0.14763085544109344,
0.35993990302085876,
-0.30295491218566895,
0.7550755739212036,
0.07565514743328094,
-0.5019764304161072,
0.5331841111183167,
-0.7253263592720032,
-0.5339733362197876,
-0.17186659574508667,
-0.32120072841644287,
-0.2076670527458191,
0.27510377764701843,
-0.0936669260263443,
0.4451051950454712,
-0.37373971939086914,
0.21641668677330017,
-0.10270624607801437,
-0.47386986017227173,
0.20270852744579315,
-0.44571274518966675,
0.5371686220169067,
0.014380690641701221,
-0.5842060446739197,
0.0500129796564579,
-0.6472316384315491,
0.12572915852069855,
-0.10788040608167648,
-0.5790812969207764,
-0.30531027913093567,
-0.03427889943122864,
-0.7866610288619995,
0.06035890430212021,
0.3211023509502411,
-0.4286491572856903,
0.4826946258544922,
-0.2705744504928589,
0.37482163310050964,
1.0356438159942627,
0.20821161568164825,
0.551565945148468,
-0.3085932433605194,
0.49680185317993164,
-0.01440284214913845,
0.06642749160528183,
-0.1815369427204132,
-0.18471385538578033,
-0.8422061204910278,
0.029076388105750084,
0.24389678239822388,
0.29864537715911865,
-0.6383169293403625,
0.0808660089969635,
-0.09611675888299942,
-0.1684693545103073,
-0.7105143666267395,
0.40489351749420166,
0.7741475105285645,
0.49923214316368103,
0.32238972187042236,
-0.037834662944078445,
-0.4122928977012634,
-1.0092997550964355,
-0.47512897849082947,
0.08981607109308243,
0.2336319386959076,
-0.2859305143356323,
0.26231101155281067,
-0.26872333884239197,
0.8769733905792236,
-0.32685691118240356,
-0.30928805470466614,
-0.048408105969429016,
0.08871041983366013,
-0.06827198714017868,
0.7463210225105286,
0.21024209260940552,
-0.27061495184898376,
-0.6213880181312561,
0.0447675995528698,
-0.5214182138442993,
0.006658769678324461,
-0.1509573757648468,
-0.041848476976156235,
0.007021774537861347,
1.047404408454895,
-0.04234470799565315,
0.47381970286369324,
0.3455134928226471,
-0.10145418345928192,
0.5303383469581604,
-0.3323059380054474,
0.31304654479026794,
-0.7949559092521667,
-0.4776513874530792,
0.06976643204689026,
0.096289724111557,
-0.5897600650787354,
0.12340401858091354,
0.41602540016174316,
0.20629160106182098,
-0.18281327188014984,
0.4860154688358307,
-0.5186981558799744,
0.31655848026275635,
-0.39125216007232666,
-0.021081868559122086,
-0.1129458025097847,
0.4261963665485382,
-0.4746008515357971,
1.0580368041992188,
0.30719271302223206,
-0.7190134525299072,
-0.304582417011261,
0.036114368587732315,
-0.4437989890575409,
0.6378362774848938,
-0.4235266149044037,
0.1185963898897171,
0.007954063825309277,
-0.2079121619462967,
-1.1050941944122314,
-0.2260797917842865,
0.04069308936595917,
-0.07158254832029343,
0.7390920519828796,
-0.18597730994224548,
-0.428676038980484,
-0.1587354838848114,
-0.1946195811033249,
0.16690382361412048,
0.32967087626457214,
-0.576783299446106,
0.3664477467536926,
0.3496740758419037,
0.17129181325435638,
-0.4259326159954071,
-0.388727605342865,
-0.18488916754722595,
-0.2262357920408249,
-0.7037889957427979,
0.44329237937927246,
-0.09964455664157867,
-0.32203009724617004,
0.009184971451759338,
-0.36337292194366455,
0.03201967105269432,
0.3167470097541809,
-0.032332129776477814,
-0.15017221868038177,
-0.45351922512054443,
0.36159366369247437,
0.49822455644607544,
-0.4243389964103699,
0.07703527808189392,
-0.5099946856498718,
0.19092056155204773,
-0.41156548261642456,
-0.46247684955596924,
-0.8534572124481201,
0.2656606137752533,
0.43228161334991455,
-0.24087344110012054,
0.6270920634269714,
0.486124724149704,
-0.09568312764167786,
-0.2687639594078064,
-0.58671635389328,
-0.5452841520309448,
-0.5234872102737427,
0.33859336376190186,
-0.425226628780365,
-1.0048240423202515,
0.29065003991127014,
-0.42675265669822693,
0.3084954023361206,
0.18122051656246185,
0.4335103929042816,
-0.2843712866306305,
0.8696284890174866,
1.113768458366394,
0.08675463497638702,
0.8727766871452332,
-0.3341958820819855,
0.5306174159049988,
-0.9862975478172302,
-0.028604935854673386,
-0.09566397219896317,
-0.4357874393463135,
-0.45634526014328003,
-0.2276974320411682,
0.2042180597782135,
0.2699100971221924,
-0.5190885066986084,
0.07637231796979904,
-0.4059647023677826,
0.7717025279998779,
0.5894747376441956,
0.14362995326519012,
0.3562546968460083,
-0.12770579755306244,
-0.0971595048904419,
-0.015399884432554245,
-0.8483027219772339,
-0.3388092815876007,
0.9017803072929382,
0.15988951921463013,
1.0433751344680786,
0.16351504623889923,
0.897075891494751,
0.09904934465885162,
0.45707565546035767,
-0.5907233357429504,
0.3237363398075104,
-0.23466329276561737,
-0.4719698429107666,
-0.37073180079460144,
-0.05882648751139641,
-0.9730793833732605,
-0.032305460423231125,
-0.04350170120596886,
-0.6837140917778015,
0.22472447156906128,
0.4374535381793976,
-0.5592705607414246,
0.24272748827934265,
-1.2236970663070679,
1.0156073570251465,
-0.3993195593357086,
-0.44116267561912537,
-0.24264051020145416,
-0.45975998044013977,
0.43563786149024963,
0.07096200436353683,
0.24535705149173737,
-0.058197010308504105,
0.0420856811106205,
0.36872193217277527,
-0.2108568698167801,
1.2428877353668213,
-0.05656205862760544,
-0.5102383494377136,
0.1589936465024948,
0.29707276821136475,
0.4724985361099243,
-0.020803626626729965,
0.006596146617084742,
0.022595945745706558,
0.06096698343753815,
-0.36911624670028687,
-0.6301273107528687,
0.8450474143028259,
-0.9286106824874878,
-1.1008481979370117,
0.10422913730144501,
-0.6761811375617981,
-0.3613548278808594,
0.2705373167991638,
0.13195912539958954,
0.4926382899284363,
-0.1273658573627472,
0.27918916940689087,
0.9703918695449829,
0.2129279226064682,
0.009438649751245975,
0.6688922047615051,
-0.18602168560028076,
-0.006958468351513147,
1.1087273359298706,
0.40044569969177246,
0.7184986472129822,
0.32357028126716614,
0.4999639689922333,
-0.0728774145245552,
-0.6015142202377319,
-0.13381928205490112,
0.16953974962234497,
-0.8296997547149658,
-0.32403936982154846,
-0.22148019075393677,
-0.16206525266170502,
-0.3739650845527649,
-0.24154582619667053,
-0.40551233291625977,
0.05484802648425102,
-0.40602922439575195,
-0.2231043577194214,
0.30722516775131226,
0.9019481539726257,
-0.2782233953475952,
0.39392685890197754,
-0.7402902245521545,
-0.10445568710565567,
0.43604835867881775,
0.5319477915763855,
0.20142480731010437,
-0.6816819310188293,
-0.6459172964096069,
0.2003822922706604,
-0.38101479411125183,
-0.5882911682128906,
-0.15723906457424164,
0.276307612657547,
0.6712034344673157,
0.48299452662467957,
-0.01672886312007904,
0.942172110080719,
-0.506354570388794,
0.4716016948223114,
-0.09886854141950607,
-0.9358256459236145,
0.3009556233882904,
-0.3136264979839325,
0.5387460589408875,
0.6403641104698181,
0.3197365403175354,
-0.5276235342025757,
-0.3917696177959442,
-0.638712465763092,
-0.7312453389167786,
0.6837005615234375,
-0.1550949662923813,
0.1775864064693451,
-0.07813221216201782,
0.7017038464546204,
0.23938266932964325,
0.11211300641298294,
-0.44653329253196716,
-0.03207765147089958,
-0.04619748890399933,
-0.36258697509765625,
0.1426662653684616,
-0.43759962916374207,
-0.33113807439804077,
-0.38718417286872864,
0.8188130855560303,
-0.329190731048584,
-0.0015176337910816073,
0.11015491187572479,
-0.22904476523399353,
-0.2768460810184479,
0.138824000954628,
0.5869284868240356,
0.5024211406707764,
0.17521677911281586,
-0.010076544247567654,
0.18338793516159058,
-0.08390966057777405,
0.010976264253258705,
-0.1990104764699936,
-0.17590881884098053,
-0.8910138607025146,
0.36631885170936584,
0.7532302141189575,
0.7943305969238281,
-0.2551431357860565,
0.16303282976150513,
-0.07015898823738098,
-0.1556677371263504,
-0.11194175481796265,
0.3949248492717743,
-0.04962524399161339,
0.4933665692806244,
-0.021818306297063828,
-0.05962750315666199,
-0.17863789200782776,
-0.6216768026351929,
0.4106507897377014,
0.44826316833496094,
-0.5439625382423401,
-0.34801816940307617,
0.3619880676269531,
0.19616706669330597,
-0.5428911447525024,
0.5580360889434814,
-0.26805028319358826,
-0.5726768970489502,
0.4223580062389374,
0.6799185872077942,
0.5663010478019714,
-0.4675821363925934,
0.04113290086388588,
0.3633194863796234,
0.5346817374229431,
-0.009983415715396404,
0.19828134775161743,
-0.10974779725074768,
-0.8911245465278625,
-0.4597141444683075,
-0.3484657406806946,
-0.13274350762367249,
-0.13695544004440308,
-0.605900764465332,
0.2824920117855072,
-0.5374797582626343,
0.2422144114971161,
-0.2498749941587448,
-0.011739621870219707,
-0.7038374543190002,
-0.10252436250448227,
0.033817604184150696,
0.566536545753479,
-0.6213492751121521,
0.9540504217147827,
0.4230145514011383,
-0.5011812448501587,
-1.2043447494506836,
0.4655795097351074,
0.25902432203292847,
-1.0751737356185913,
0.5633785724639893,
-0.021052351221442223,
-0.21992626786231995,
0.36133623123168945,
-0.5426182150840759,
-1.259451150894165,
0.9521244764328003,
0.31142792105674744,
-0.5987027883529663,
-0.06351202726364136,
-0.05406535044312477,
0.3345630466938019,
-0.30176591873168945,
-0.35094597935676575,
0.9110177159309387,
0.5830868482589722,
-0.19846931099891663,
-0.727747917175293,
0.16991521418094635,
0.16908931732177734,
-0.17601412534713745,
0.522842288017273,
-0.7913418412208557,
0.8052218556404114,
-0.47147494554519653,
-0.3372761309146881,
-0.09612712264060974,
0.67978435754776,
-0.23863449692726135,
-0.12258033454418182,
0.4160095751285553,
0.4785560965538025,
0.8720118999481201,
0.017305010929703712,
1.0187110900878906,
-0.5770188570022583,
0.2656647562980652,
1.2195391654968262,
0.13251814246177673,
0.4601137638092041,
0.48625051975250244,
-0.09755375236272812,
0.4283018708229065,
0.6297211050987244,
0.2945738732814789,
0.5096895098686218,
0.04637689143419266,
-0.14146959781646729,
-0.41689184308052063,
0.25036683678627014,
-0.3033117651939392,
0.43161433935165405,
0.6313366293907166,
-0.013130612671375275,
-0.324103981256485,
0.034150801599025726,
0.10016979277133942,
0.06456706672906876,
-0.26643526554107666,
0.9398307800292969,
0.09738244116306305,
-0.9042314291000366,
0.7013295888900757,
-0.2362031489610672,
0.5419522523880005,
-0.5672164559364319,
-0.18160930275917053,
-0.22693195939064026,
0.48764699697494507,
-0.26654255390167236,
-0.8942004442214966,
0.2757784128189087,
-0.3369307219982147,
-0.3588179647922516,
-0.25081729888916016,
0.6476268172264099,
-0.7778046131134033,
-0.22524048388004303,
0.227445587515831,
0.4597839117050171,
-0.19808487594127655,
0.19023166596889496,
-0.7587776184082031,
0.07786236703395844,
0.45299383997917175,
0.043239593505859375,
0.5932627320289612,
0.9802684187889099,
-0.04643338918685913,
0.5476530194282532,
0.6256763339042664,
-0.4693731367588043,
0.1106126457452774,
-0.14683747291564941,
0.8556604385375977,
-0.5550980567932129,
-0.2439889758825302,
-0.7275673151016235,
0.7103891372680664,
0.22715505957603455,
-0.39576855301856995,
0.9563587307929993,
0.08111998438835144,
1.016417145729065,
0.19627745449543,
0.5347146987915039,
0.06897317618131638,
0.2748510539531708,
-0.5610873699188232,
0.5281522274017334,
-0.7623998522758484,
0.4296231269836426,
-0.07330220192670822,
-0.4197314977645874,
-0.14274460077285767,
0.5558416843414307,
-0.5839462280273438,
-0.2233208864927292,
0.674919068813324,
0.7591633796691895,
-0.02281085215508938,
0.2073824107646942,
0.5123222470283508,
0.45164161920547485,
0.6641286611557007,
0.08534694463014603,
0.7762901782989502,
-0.18961621820926666,
0.2766793966293335,
-0.46327903866767883,
-0.32369446754455566,
-0.2145579308271408,
-0.9520748853683472,
-0.6945009231567383,
-0.7150781750679016,
-0.16383647918701172,
-0.09579670429229736,
0.1995691955089569,
1.075806975364685,
0.38698744773864746,
-0.5777429342269897,
-0.33448636531829834,
-0.2144523710012436,
0.42971888184547424,
-0.32432764768600464,
-0.15818344056606293,
0.35321998596191406,
-0.8628263473510742,
-0.4512479603290558,
0.40898895263671875,
0.295955091714859,
-0.02472086064517498,
-0.3457585871219635,
0.08740503340959549,
-0.13426204025745392,
0.017746025696396828,
0.6722300052642822,
0.47135236859321594,
-0.6391746401786804,
-0.6649429798126221,
-0.09220153838396072,
0.2398947924375534,
0.1585371494293213,
1.0361452102661133,
-0.5467938184738159,
0.4754592478275299,
0.10597444325685501,
0.8421328663825989,
0.059577032923698425,
-0.30936211347579956,
0.8064530491828918,
-0.6576991677284241,
-0.08914404362440109,
-0.017051557078957558,
0.3614340126514435,
0.24372510612010956,
-0.4869001805782318,
0.251288503408432,
-0.0026728687807917595,
-0.801856279373169,
-0.7297430634498596,
0.39986371994018555,
-0.3298356831073761,
-0.1676439791917801,
0.9651966691017151,
-0.009893841110169888,
-0.2092130482196808,
-0.1242174282670021,
-0.2482263445854187,
0.17024670541286469,
-0.35681581497192383,
1.1461344957351685,
0.7342444062232971,
-0.2568814754486084,
-0.15647916495800018,
-0.34829553961753845,
0.6568287014961243,
0.33803117275238037,
-0.628971517086029,
0.2569561302661896,
0.226279154419899,
0.6350100636482239,
-0.023737715557217598,
0.5767256617546082,
0.10170876979827881,
0.21864980459213257,
-0.19015978276729584,
0.006936564110219479,
0.0662197396159172,
-0.5458174347877502,
-0.21598289906978607,
-0.23853924870491028,
0.30368080735206604,
0.1427057683467865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18240v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18240v2
|
Prospect Personalized Recommendation on Large Language Model-based Agent Platform
| 2024-02-28T11:12:17 | 2024-03-05T12:14:52 |
Jizhi Zhang, Keqin Bao, Wenjie Wang, Yang Zhang, Wentao Shi, Wanhong Xu, Fuli Feng, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The new kind of Agent-oriented information system, exemplified by GPTs, urges
us to inspect the information system infrastructure to support Agent-level
information processing and to adapt to the characteristics of Large Language
Model (LLM)-based Agents, such as interactivity. In this work, we envisage the
prospect of the recommender system on LLM-based Agent platforms and introduce a
novel recommendation paradigm called Rec4Agentverse, comprised of Agent Items
and Agent Recommender. Rec4Agentverse emphasizes the collaboration between
Agent Items and Agent Recommender, thereby promoting personalized information
services and enhancing the exchange of information beyond the traditional
user-recommender feedback loop. Additionally, we prospect the evolution of
Rec4Agentverse and conceptualize it into three stages based on the enhancement
of the interaction and information exchange among Agent Items, Agent
Recommender, and the user. A preliminary study involving several cases of
Rec4Agentverse validates its significant potential for application. Lastly, we
discuss potential issues and promising directions for future research.
|
[
-0.5251141786575317,
-0.5693902373313904,
0.7010689973831177,
0.15377642214298248,
-0.0020357626490294933,
0.23938117921352386,
-0.01991150714457035,
-0.6109679937362671,
0.4651266038417816,
0.8968146443367004,
-0.6917831301689148,
-0.5534391403198242,
-0.1919097602367401,
0.1174076721072197,
-0.09816554933786392,
1.3292608261108398,
0.08618614822626114,
-0.06464780122041702,
-0.14351095259189606,
0.01146771851927042,
-0.9301131963729858,
-0.6658288836479187,
-0.9281326532363892,
-0.8311289548873901,
0.678348183631897,
0.3622749149799347,
0.6899158358573914,
0.3803233504295349,
0.46755915880203247,
0.46057963371276855,
0.3078537881374359,
-0.03987201675772667,
-0.4617502689361572,
0.526018500328064,
-0.5525928735733032,
-0.31510916352272034,
-0.8539767265319824,
-0.057402852922677994,
0.4530304968357086,
0.2558404803276062,
-0.24583855271339417,
-0.16678258776664734,
-0.08448613435029984,
0.6697202324867249,
-0.232047900557518,
0.34267228841781616,
-0.3570421636104584,
0.10381339490413666,
-0.1461833268404007,
-0.5458693504333496,
-0.2518337070941925,
-0.205795556306839,
0.430634081363678,
-0.7307924628257751,
0.20027686655521393,
0.116695336997509,
0.36671993136405945,
-0.23743411898612976,
-0.3750259280204773,
-0.0450262725353241,
-1.0969524383544922,
0.612270176410675,
-0.4004795253276825,
0.455249160528183,
0.40033379197120667,
0.718119740486145,
-0.38835281133651733,
-0.9162549376487732,
-0.5028036236763,
-0.3968465030193329,
0.25704139471054077,
-0.2201581448316574,
-0.3340309262275696,
-0.0016968920826911926,
-0.1182003989815712,
0.19154119491577148,
-0.4886758029460907,
0.018417175859212875,
0.16846130788326263,
-0.2096647024154663,
0.4431436359882355,
0.2449585646390915,
0.161908820271492,
0.4922400116920471,
-0.4779055416584015,
0.16923508048057556,
-0.6923389434814453,
-0.09604670852422714,
0.43538668751716614,
0.351104736328125,
0.04587142914533615,
0.4612273573875427,
-0.561701238155365,
0.5973576307296753,
0.32258039712905884,
0.11547807604074478,
0.610223650932312,
-0.5497955679893494,
0.04748789593577385,
-0.1571309119462967,
0.4319193661212921,
0.5488491654396057,
0.21060968935489655,
-0.3304995894432068,
-0.3330908417701721,
-0.27905163168907166,
0.20011529326438904,
-0.861047089099884,
-0.13250833749771118,
0.12570533156394958,
-0.4072270691394806,
-0.38807550072669983,
0.038222912698984146,
-0.6612582206726074,
-0.737221896648407,
-0.4034399092197418,
0.20669510960578918,
-0.25888708233833313,
-0.3761991560459137,
0.21000230312347412,
-0.07950479537248611,
0.009019343182444572,
0.6057395339012146,
-0.817657470703125,
0.3775528371334076,
0.7113208770751953,
0.7201464772224426,
-0.2823120653629303,
-0.4869442284107208,
-0.4452150762081146,
0.3115820586681366,
0.1462859958410263,
1.189309000968933,
-0.9082251787185669,
-0.25265607237815857,
0.08306380361318588,
0.3548677861690521,
0.44496726989746094,
-0.26774126291275024,
0.29912227392196655,
-0.7880210876464844,
0.06376415491104126,
-0.47296929359436035,
-0.3972719609737396,
-0.2970503270626068,
0.6973777413368225,
-0.6422456502914429,
0.3728044331073761,
0.21742327511310577,
-0.5729799866676331,
0.313717782497406,
-0.8788285255432129,
-0.10272414982318878,
0.4949931204319,
-0.12862439453601837,
-0.09638551622629166,
-0.46344685554504395,
-0.03568641096353531,
0.4303877353668213,
-0.39241334795951843,
0.34601137042045593,
-0.54591965675354,
-0.46408721804618835,
0.21037684381008148,
-0.17310966551303864,
0.07371474802494049,
0.25177720189094543,
-0.4620349705219269,
0.41207605600357056,
-0.455409973859787,
-0.17572878301143646,
0.1100563332438469,
-0.17372722923755646,
-0.28533560037612915,
-0.1121068149805069,
0.255097895860672,
0.0928308516740799,
0.8505386114120483,
-0.5975918769836426,
0.45152047276496887,
-0.43620947003364563,
0.4922334849834442,
0.9734209179878235,
0.0931537002325058,
0.5152630805969238,
-0.5253385305404663,
0.7103136777877808,
-0.08589588105678558,
0.09368512779474258,
-0.3047395348548889,
-0.47796663641929626,
-0.28864002227783203,
0.02470720186829567,
-0.03474307060241699,
0.3881639540195465,
-0.893865704536438,
0.39759406447410583,
-0.05845201760530472,
-0.25755664706230164,
-0.024399904534220695,
-0.07701051235198975,
0.19525180757045746,
0.05519646033644676,
0.1463342010974884,
-0.34284427762031555,
-0.6153523325920105,
-0.9378322958946228,
-0.09611061960458755,
-0.1434265822172165,
0.17073523998260498,
0.44048169255256653,
0.1833297163248062,
-0.8642797470092773,
1.101014494895935,
-0.39982858300209045,
-0.4057352840900421,
-0.34874892234802246,
-0.3990849554538727,
0.39942097663879395,
0.2323485165834427,
0.6008809208869934,
-0.787490725517273,
-0.4177679121494293,
0.3749813735485077,
-0.4252934455871582,
0.04226270318031311,
0.4453515112400055,
-0.1832674890756607,
-0.009539404883980751,
0.13401874899864197,
-0.47469592094421387,
0.15622685849666595,
0.4068693220615387,
-0.7332080602645874,
0.43111228942871094,
-0.5096179842948914,
0.1293071210384369,
-1.1589622497558594,
-0.029691828414797783,
-0.026328375563025475,
-0.5295767188072205,
-0.72980797290802,
-0.13247574865818024,
-0.5301699042320251,
-0.07992563396692276,
-0.08329175412654877,
0.93429034948349,
-0.22466067969799042,
-0.22047798335552216,
-0.7591261863708496,
0.30500608682632446,
-0.026547569781541824,
0.33066004514694214,
-0.049118928611278534,
0.5320963263511658,
0.3238084614276886,
-0.31096717715263367,
0.7367591857910156,
0.2915416359901428,
0.21906527876853943,
0.704720139503479,
-0.5457327961921692,
0.36790141463279724,
-0.06966452300548553,
0.662911593914032,
-0.8686121106147766,
0.10986793786287308,
0.3596009910106659,
-0.15419712662696838,
-0.010114088654518127,
0.11541562527418137,
-0.42643681168556213,
-0.3383316397666931,
-0.5227379202842712,
0.38724732398986816,
-0.04123399779200554,
-0.5263081192970276,
0.5685603022575378,
0.4926815330982208,
-0.42932015657424927,
-0.729756772518158,
-0.32498088479042053,
0.3710032105445862,
-0.07812684029340744,
-0.6730355620384216,
0.3604010045528412,
-0.4868481159210205,
-0.12702079117298126,
0.10234435647726059,
0.34947842359542847,
0.25041720271110535,
-0.1037551760673523,
0.38929858803749084,
0.1549561470746994,
-0.10706733167171478,
0.24032627046108246,
-0.22854198515415192,
-0.3619594871997833,
-0.22718307375907898,
-0.7556596398353577,
0.7313639521598816,
-0.6627019643783569,
-0.171169713139534,
-0.4000625014305115,
0.3195752799510956,
0.38849467039108276,
-0.23636947572231293,
0.51860511302948,
0.7781543731689453,
-0.27904003858566284,
-0.06238655373454094,
-0.7705422043800354,
-0.3213523328304291,
-0.567196786403656,
0.6371709704399109,
-0.4392926096916199,
-1.1891282796859741,
0.4081069529056549,
-0.13237908482551575,
0.025032225996255875,
0.19486473500728607,
0.8861873745918274,
0.27918943762779236,
1.105767846107483,
0.9942945837974548,
-0.28068313002586365,
0.7249268889427185,
-0.36754080653190613,
0.18805952370166779,
-0.6981011629104614,
-0.23471786081790924,
-0.2017233669757843,
-0.21104805171489716,
-0.8580757975578308,
-0.1811656653881073,
-0.0036131334491074085,
-0.520999014377594,
-0.583923876285553,
0.20745690166950226,
-0.5675894021987915,
0.41250818967819214,
0.4619922637939453,
0.029511289671063423,
0.5195081233978271,
0.024125656113028526,
-0.10220588743686676,
0.11136044561862946,
-0.2181231677532196,
-0.5632845163345337,
0.9198864698410034,
0.5766252875328064,
0.6731466054916382,
0.3731071352958679,
0.5060093402862549,
0.9192080497741699,
0.4217086136341095,
-0.6762189865112305,
0.5509761571884155,
0.004131567198783159,
-0.48525694012641907,
-0.33993297815322876,
-0.06989522278308868,
-1.340680480003357,
0.1554541289806366,
-0.1804163157939911,
-0.8645341992378235,
0.45773598551750183,
-0.05503499135375023,
-0.11865271627902985,
0.15361778438091278,
-0.4527265131473541,
0.6577109694480896,
-0.014321678318083286,
-0.4278385043144226,
-0.3118232786655426,
-0.4174201786518097,
0.08503539860248566,
-0.10469086468219757,
0.2096208781003952,
-0.046428382396698,
-0.1593179851770401,
0.5028607249259949,
-0.2977111041545868,
0.7754747271537781,
-0.38259363174438477,
-0.12999284267425537,
0.13094916939735413,
0.1184353157877922,
0.9336142539978027,
0.11208648234605789,
-0.22029152512550354,
0.08070544898509979,
0.07161469012498856,
-0.03030957095324993,
-0.4337218403816223,
1.0528818368911743,
-0.9488526582717896,
-0.721520721912384,
-0.396106094121933,
-0.5157764554023743,
-0.32734209299087524,
0.6325281262397766,
-0.06960796564817429,
0.21878209710121155,
-0.3030802309513092,
0.12188117206096649,
0.13632111251354218,
-0.15076251327991486,
0.25056394934654236,
1.0321372747421265,
-0.44165998697280884,
-0.6864904165267944,
1.1346772909164429,
-0.23812134563922882,
-0.27090170979499817,
0.47354868054389954,
0.2585617005825043,
-0.3517557680606842,
-0.6883696913719177,
-0.11367439478635788,
0.4656476378440857,
-0.6354870796203613,
-0.17075300216674805,
-0.6968945264816284,
0.03391192853450775,
-0.3993261456489563,
-0.11236274242401123,
-0.2680707573890686,
0.1261216551065445,
-0.01948453299701214,
-0.0708734542131424,
0.3881246745586395,
1.1408255100250244,
0.22880060970783234,
0.36571115255355835,
-0.5739054083824158,
0.04374891147017479,
0.16805598139762878,
0.7333000302314758,
-0.03804055228829384,
-0.25727298855781555,
-0.6023334264755249,
-0.018910687416791916,
-0.5119723677635193,
-0.5585340857505798,
0.36215516924858093,
-0.1351526826620102,
0.7663386464118958,
0.7377340197563171,
-0.06884662806987762,
0.010351583361625671,
-0.5829668045043945,
0.5420203804969788,
0.0516725592315197,
-0.5567848086357117,
0.19369281828403473,
-0.7615934610366821,
0.11276467889547348,
0.37205639481544495,
-0.016747508198022842,
-0.6151618361473083,
-0.2535143494606018,
-0.45949602127075195,
-0.6851686835289001,
0.7127403616905212,
0.14945420622825623,
0.04323973134160042,
0.20024745166301727,
0.5689166188240051,
0.33940768241882324,
0.5850874781608582,
-0.7580085396766663,
-0.11684198677539825,
-0.1690104454755783,
0.06145942956209183,
-0.5084906220436096,
-0.26979154348373413,
0.021410474553704262,
0.277346134185791,
0.6322017312049866,
-0.18128886818885803,
0.48928409814834595,
0.047794122248888016,
0.3782971203327179,
-0.238963320851326,
0.2845694422721863,
0.6464810967445374,
0.6247196793556213,
-0.4694201648235321,
-0.1769387423992157,
-0.14563927054405212,
-0.509789764881134,
0.41076067090034485,
0.29976895451545715,
-0.05540955439209938,
-0.3666711151599884,
-0.025320351123809814,
0.8651980757713318,
-0.1635662019252777,
-0.5226923227310181,
0.5878786444664001,
-0.3523392379283905,
-0.0061445278115570545,
-0.9368696212768555,
-0.09864771366119385,
0.11750300973653793,
0.7282751798629761,
0.18653364479541779,
0.09998517483472824,
0.47081926465034485,
-0.5770010352134705,
0.1333131641149521,
0.5556051135063171,
-0.4888685345649719,
-0.5888611674308777,
0.40063196420669556,
0.582333505153656,
-0.6296448707580566,
0.07184497267007828,
-0.05802106112241745,
-0.2754998803138733,
0.24970810115337372,
0.6513699293136597,
1.1677812337875366,
-0.40863364934921265,
0.2408769428730011,
-0.1296796351671219,
0.09940142929553986,
-0.1778322011232376,
0.08417246490716934,
-0.06033725291490555,
-1.0665544271469116,
-0.2079259157180786,
-0.34171250462532043,
-0.50453782081604,
0.16293561458587646,
-0.12309043109416962,
0.49711963534355164,
-0.5537529587745667,
-0.5439266562461853,
-0.005767908412963152,
0.16783085465431213,
-0.7056981325149536,
-0.07589516788721085,
0.046560466289520264,
0.562277615070343,
-0.3892424702644348,
0.924331545829773,
0.9675774574279785,
-0.2822818458080292,
-0.3909308612346649,
-0.04585713520646095,
-0.1541045755147934,
-0.5905061364173889,
0.6751297116279602,
0.15926548838615417,
-0.49983808398246765,
0.041273076087236404,
-0.1680617332458496,
-0.9265813231468201,
1.307065725326538,
0.44474032521247864,
-0.5903319716453552,
-0.12073981016874313,
-0.14299944043159485,
0.740044891834259,
-0.8625330328941345,
0.5693196058273315,
0.3531716763973236,
0.7008876204490662,
0.17158551514148712,
-0.7324710488319397,
0.17684221267700195,
-0.5380218625068665,
0.1526496708393097,
0.18139395117759705,
-0.766083836555481,
0.7875966429710388,
-0.22432224452495575,
0.19659043848514557,
0.27852335572242737,
0.43126949667930603,
0.23592422902584076,
0.6792688965797424,
0.6082428693771362,
0.1795501708984375,
0.5173495411872864,
0.36189618706703186,
1.1454105377197266,
-0.3243069350719452,
0.3021719455718994,
1.1532262563705444,
-0.7704887390136719,
0.6099321246147156,
0.16336944699287415,
-0.2624027729034424,
0.8382872343063354,
0.5972626805305481,
-0.11129050701856613,
0.44007205963134766,
0.0984726995229721,
-0.42898157238960266,
-0.0006417770637199283,
-0.28487926721572876,
-0.5327788591384888,
0.29483649134635925,
0.2115544080734253,
-0.24703611433506012,
-0.08088187873363495,
0.3656058609485626,
-0.20592620968818665,
-0.09369408339262009,
-0.09454027563333511,
0.9031201601028442,
-0.20659661293029785,
-0.48961585760116577,
0.23180259764194489,
0.2939958870410919,
0.6419166922569275,
-0.5604191422462463,
-0.3665972054004669,
-0.1438283920288086,
0.37990471720695496,
-0.1951628476381302,
-0.7065516710281372,
-0.2792465090751648,
-0.36810141801834106,
-0.3552097976207733,
-0.14389029145240784,
1.008117437362671,
-0.3529493808746338,
-0.07315488159656525,
0.536531388759613,
0.35785481333732605,
0.10830720514059067,
-0.1782010793685913,
-0.6457493901252747,
-0.19641654193401337,
0.008939063176512718,
-0.23527459800243378,
0.5269189476966858,
0.5378321409225464,
-0.09031514823436737,
0.9784371256828308,
0.7556408047676086,
0.17487452924251556,
-0.7134048342704773,
0.04374289885163307,
0.9317461848258972,
-0.9457300901412964,
-0.9134718179702759,
-0.7333603501319885,
0.07708712667226791,
0.03241325169801712,
0.12643733620643616,
0.7902875542640686,
0.3354770243167877,
0.5027887225151062,
0.003508158028125763,
1.000540018081665,
0.3111129701137543,
0.596468448638916,
-0.05569286271929741,
0.49198418855667114,
-0.2713859975337982,
0.7280762791633606,
-0.3814418315887451,
-1.282801628112793,
0.11511074006557465,
0.12709341943264008,
-0.4047372043132782,
0.6510235667228699,
0.5310797095298767,
0.7001555562019348,
0.1860789805650711,
0.07553307712078094,
0.4653626084327698,
0.29397091269493103,
0.6910314559936523,
0.37937092781066895,
0.7675411105155945,
0.05815805867314339,
0.271884948015213,
0.07057516276836395,
-0.3083784878253937,
-0.6951935887336731,
-0.7362727522850037,
-0.8247331976890564,
-0.7582187056541443,
-0.015908915549516678,
-0.4816646873950958,
0.26151546835899353,
1.1697791814804077,
0.5224949717521667,
-0.6045128703117371,
-0.3131505846977234,
-0.22145423293113708,
0.111224465072155,
-0.028941094875335693,
-0.241245836019516,
0.17798055708408356,
0.1010713055729866,
-0.633194088935852,
0.38042837381362915,
0.5040645003318787,
0.07800334692001343,
-0.6212641596794128,
-0.3097909986972809,
0.054130587726831436,
-0.09410105645656586,
0.6754218935966492,
0.1903984397649765,
-0.6552661061286926,
-0.26950111985206604,
-0.2261529266834259,
0.007013789843767881,
-0.1491694301366806,
1.0806981325149536,
-0.9356053471565247,
0.6427235007286072,
0.21497300267219543,
0.5108938217163086,
0.4595872461795807,
0.08207426965236664,
0.9748553037643433,
-0.28612062335014343,
0.22922565042972565,
0.13917085528373718,
0.3208976686000824,
0.37824052572250366,
-0.7392044067382812,
0.29770132899284363,
0.30487367510795593,
-0.8505982756614685,
-0.662868320941925,
0.22203178703784943,
-1.0144861936569214,
0.024328285828232765,
1.1835907697677612,
-0.16791604459285736,
0.006419423967599869,
-0.46376118063926697,
-0.5356472730636597,
-0.09354996681213379,
-0.9670856595039368,
0.4760311543941498,
0.5071143507957458,
-0.2450726330280304,
-0.07922981679439545,
-0.5041930079460144,
0.29627156257629395,
-0.027657439932227135,
-0.6599767804145813,
-0.0016570629086345434,
0.3528084456920624,
0.4910942614078522,
0.20101971924304962,
0.9277383089065552,
0.16865988075733185,
0.1815575212240219,
-0.37759262323379517,
0.43201446533203125,
-0.3742380440235138,
-0.10929925739765167,
-0.28337612748146057,
0.07789390534162521,
0.5024874806404114,
0.013169043697416782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18225v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18225v1
|
CogBench: a large language model walks into a psychology lab
| 2024-02-28T10:43:54 | 2024-02-28T10:43:54 |
Julian Coda-Forno, Marcel Binz, Jane X. Wang, Eric Schulz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced the field of
artificial intelligence. Yet, evaluating them comprehensively remains
challenging. We argue that this is partly due to the predominant focus on
performance metrics in most benchmarks. This paper introduces CogBench, a
benchmark that includes ten behavioral metrics derived from seven cognitive
psychology experiments. This novel approach offers a toolkit for phenotyping
LLMs' behavior. We apply CogBench to 35 LLMs, yielding a rich and diverse
dataset. We analyze this data using statistical multilevel modeling techniques,
accounting for the nested dependencies among fine-tuned versions of specific
LLMs. Our study highlights the crucial role of model size and reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF) in improving performance and aligning with
human behavior. Interestingly, we find that open-source models are less
risk-prone than proprietary models and that fine-tuning on code does not
necessarily enhance LLMs' behavior. Finally, we explore the effects of
prompt-engineering techniques. We discover that chain-of-thought prompting
improves probabilistic reasoning, while take-a-step-back prompting fosters
model-based behaviors.
|
[
-0.5373724699020386,
-1.0262104272842407,
0.5730376243591309,
0.4665321707725525,
0.1672917902469635,
0.027848176658153534,
-0.5208221673965454,
-0.49452537298202515,
-0.23004598915576935,
0.2534397840499878,
-0.835392951965332,
-0.45241618156433105,
-0.38948431611061096,
-0.16020017862319946,
-0.23979021608829498,
0.8393552899360657,
0.1951223760843277,
0.15540862083435059,
-0.30196061730384827,
0.018634716048836708,
-0.4157952666282654,
-0.5826948285102844,
-0.8076664209365845,
-0.6487176418304443,
0.5915732979774475,
0.25231483578681946,
0.6527063846588135,
0.2359766960144043,
0.5346124172210693,
0.22537833452224731,
0.02561120130121708,
-0.03279193490743637,
-0.6036213636398315,
0.02722882851958275,
-0.2574799954891205,
-0.3958629369735718,
-0.5936278700828552,
0.30441799759864807,
0.2675749361515045,
0.9742054343223572,
-0.569537341594696,
0.14601068198680878,
-0.08896367996931076,
0.41679495573043823,
-0.42622584104537964,
0.36932066082954407,
-0.3819181025028229,
-0.06209331750869751,
0.16089195013046265,
0.04755023121833801,
-0.6757377982139587,
-0.145262211561203,
0.07186860591173172,
-0.4023054242134094,
0.1692708134651184,
0.4001433551311493,
0.38093724846839905,
0.25205275416374207,
-0.13402344286441803,
-0.32110506296157837,
-0.5377683043479919,
1.013136863708496,
-0.7081182599067688,
0.4653153419494629,
0.3248598277568817,
0.1896638721227646,
-0.4370978772640228,
-0.30671489238739014,
-0.37498220801353455,
-0.8343667984008789,
-0.12994985282421112,
-0.03627445176243782,
-0.04508037865161896,
0.12037655711174011,
0.458966463804245,
0.20411530137062073,
-0.5395190715789795,
0.41320326924324036,
-0.2581859529018402,
-0.24389366805553436,
0.8140392899513245,
0.3652321994304657,
0.30450528860092163,
0.13335533440113068,
0.02637430466711521,
-0.33194276690483093,
-0.4885004460811615,
0.22171133756637573,
0.33346283435821533,
0.2766214609146118,
-0.15638762712478638,
0.3191855549812317,
-0.12499605119228363,
0.6001275181770325,
0.19899709522724152,
0.07504846155643463,
0.07180047780275345,
-0.12941935658454895,
0.09572339802980423,
-0.03166915476322174,
0.8577492833137512,
0.055204715579748154,
0.4697607755661011,
-0.4102610647678375,
-0.11341799050569534,
0.23294377326965332,
0.3451974093914032,
-0.7923731803894043,
-0.572080671787262,
0.33351680636405945,
-0.2680928111076355,
0.02745753712952137,
-0.10079063475131989,
-0.8271922469139099,
-0.529312789440155,
-0.40032339096069336,
0.1151769757270813,
-0.4009002149105072,
-0.1962975263595581,
0.1356901079416275,
-0.04046035557985306,
0.20535536110401154,
0.40205109119415283,
-0.9956836700439453,
0.5071302652359009,
1.0091155767440796,
0.7084686160087585,
-0.49350690841674805,
-0.48000890016555786,
-0.6497529745101929,
-0.03205197677016258,
-0.736630916595459,
0.5015416741371155,
-0.5818337202072144,
-0.29933735728263855,
-0.13502830266952515,
-0.19029688835144043,
0.2223021537065506,
-0.7899995446205139,
0.21821856498718262,
-0.45212438702583313,
0.08191806077957153,
-0.24972552061080933,
-0.6242840886116028,
-0.07926514744758606,
0.3286255896091461,
-0.6359925270080566,
1.0379220247268677,
0.13767877221107483,
-0.3139646053314209,
0.31349799036979675,
-0.7928330302238464,
-0.47278279066085815,
0.05420771986246109,
-0.20555520057678223,
-0.286730021238327,
0.34085986018180847,
0.16867254674434662,
0.4772619903087616,
-0.34204867482185364,
0.660246729850769,
-0.5796838998794556,
-0.349089115858078,
0.2689873278141022,
-0.18336644768714905,
0.7497900128364563,
-0.023152636364102364,
-0.14252716302871704,
0.24049216508865356,
-0.9753912091255188,
0.1998002827167511,
-0.008096407167613506,
-0.39778971672058105,
-0.13858312368392944,
0.048181161284446716,
-0.18828916549682617,
0.20767347514629364,
0.1678948849439621,
-0.46775034070014954,
-0.12329905480146408,
-0.19610531628131866,
0.49129796028137207,
0.6814501285552979,
-0.13500066101551056,
0.49589991569519043,
-0.20777741074562073,
0.37404918670654297,
-0.1735035628080368,
0.21678444743156433,
0.09173808991909027,
-0.21568097174167633,
-0.5262767672538757,
-0.6147850155830383,
-0.16903452575206757,
0.39281153678894043,
-0.1426561027765274,
0.5904696583747864,
0.038760654628276825,
-0.7116298675537109,
-0.3674464523792267,
0.2063523381948471,
0.24347099661827087,
0.2719756066799164,
0.3333246409893036,
-0.38834649324417114,
-0.3976154625415802,
-0.7326322197914124,
-0.5166372060775757,
-0.25981685519218445,
-0.085396409034729,
0.3037621080875397,
0.6201639175415039,
-0.11018334329128265,
0.6319581866264343,
-0.3423944413661957,
0.18700896203517914,
-0.24665620923042297,
0.47395771741867065,
0.33567237854003906,
0.429653137922287,
0.3713832497596741,
-0.24952161312103271,
-0.10039874166250229,
-0.32477912306785583,
-0.7321479916572571,
-0.19066311419010162,
0.020489167422056198,
-0.1451103240251541,
-0.0038707100320607424,
0.8029325008392334,
-0.6352856755256653,
0.08321982622146606,
0.6096744537353516,
-0.2975228428840637,
0.762416422367096,
-0.34586694836616516,
-0.12826216220855713,
-0.3382487893104553,
-0.0021670381538569927,
0.0325874388217926,
-0.03230079263448715,
-0.5508198142051697,
0.26386192440986633,
-0.1001964583992958,
-0.1705096960067749,
-0.20968815684318542,
0.67706698179245,
-0.26726964116096497,
-0.3014562427997589,
-0.07382702827453613,
-0.0995817631483078,
-0.22385013103485107,
0.8529719114303589,
0.07292661815881729,
0.7509324550628662,
0.26928994059562683,
-0.6906904578208923,
0.667447566986084,
0.2065453976392746,
-0.6848250031471252,
0.6522350311279297,
-0.7340584993362427,
0.2649584710597992,
-0.03274262323975563,
0.2988593280315399,
-0.9564919471740723,
-0.15935052931308746,
-0.06948468834161758,
-0.1654738336801529,
0.05003499984741211,
0.4393448233604431,
-0.6704493761062622,
-0.38463136553764343,
-0.20417946577072144,
0.14544053375720978,
0.5793797969818115,
-0.6160157918930054,
0.41785526275634766,
0.18528810143470764,
-0.3708246052265167,
0.09882183372974396,
-0.6067830920219421,
0.10872315615415573,
0.05432464927434921,
-0.5291226506233215,
0.1077030599117279,
-0.3902433216571808,
-0.4040564000606537,
-0.3414117395877838,
0.06264804303646088,
0.08871415257453918,
0.3458065092563629,
0.015737608075141907,
0.32349342107772827,
-0.1890377551317215,
0.2127884030342102,
-0.37104707956314087,
-0.0006507249781861901,
0.3591759502887726,
-0.10989746451377869,
0.8080267906188965,
-0.4237070083618164,
-0.30460014939308167,
-0.2693631052970886,
0.2181904911994934,
0.35662752389907837,
-0.29233846068382263,
0.8782899975776672,
0.5705410242080688,
-0.15814785659313202,
-0.37294650077819824,
-0.3144516944885254,
-0.49822136759757996,
-0.4321650564670563,
0.7724629044532776,
-0.17076000571250916,
-0.8656229972839355,
0.30563056468963623,
-0.10923207551240921,
-0.037496645003557205,
-0.06060142070055008,
0.729698657989502,
-0.27802324295043945,
1.2309510707855225,
0.6672934889793396,
0.060490772128105164,
0.7901543378829956,
-0.017321007326245308,
0.43076586723327637,
-0.7525416016578674,
-0.23531293869018555,
-0.359983891248703,
-0.3681773543357849,
-0.665203332901001,
-0.2536834180355072,
0.37557488679885864,
-0.00608086958527565,
-0.7594002485275269,
0.04030622914433479,
-0.11236004531383514,
0.2095031440258026,
0.5496094226837158,
0.10684821009635925,
0.25197869539260864,
-0.03245270252227783,
-0.11879374831914902,
0.09665344655513763,
-0.7989469766616821,
-0.37325188517570496,
0.7105005383491516,
0.32584118843078613,
1.0491501092910767,
0.016998622566461563,
0.48356494307518005,
0.11633738875389099,
0.497734010219574,
-0.7333277463912964,
0.8367027640342712,
-0.06223892793059349,
-0.6741472482681274,
-0.5623149871826172,
-0.431579053401947,
-0.8030917048454285,
0.24396869540214539,
-0.11111408472061157,
-1.0247869491577148,
-0.020379547029733658,
0.24236054718494415,
-0.35579103231430054,
-0.0755542516708374,
-0.6300603747367859,
0.8987866044044495,
-0.5517674684524536,
-0.5688883662223816,
-0.607994794845581,
-0.3348981440067291,
0.3849480450153351,
0.06016615033149719,
0.26261210441589355,
-0.2781088352203369,
-0.013638760894536972,
0.6558429002761841,
-0.23606400191783905,
0.8088520765304565,
-0.012845613062381744,
-0.2850055694580078,
0.10625351965427399,
0.2792915105819702,
0.7254752516746521,
-0.2109781950712204,
-0.07287000119686127,
0.13988333940505981,
0.037837475538253784,
-0.4880790710449219,
-0.6591760516166687,
0.5707361102104187,
-0.7784127593040466,
-0.6201438307762146,
-0.14245955646038055,
-0.8410084247589111,
-0.7032538056373596,
-0.02282719686627388,
-0.07982166856527328,
0.2508101761341095,
-0.47550535202026367,
0.24380435049533844,
0.7429684996604919,
-0.6152722239494324,
0.3010709583759308,
0.5437909364700317,
-0.3400254249572754,
-0.13064885139465332,
0.8174605369567871,
-0.15710507333278656,
0.29706719517707825,
0.2613101005554199,
0.3441857099533081,
-0.2650095522403717,
-0.3232387602329254,
-0.05784729868173599,
0.2843354046344757,
-0.6422403454780579,
0.3838474452495575,
-0.5159521102905273,
-0.025986842811107635,
-0.2746222913265228,
-0.09835092723369598,
-0.3290858268737793,
-0.0062625827267766,
0.061116769909858704,
-0.22734399139881134,
0.35384896397590637,
0.6749303936958313,
-0.05475227162241936,
0.40886086225509644,
-0.5315335392951965,
0.2801845073699951,
0.31975799798965454,
0.6029506921768188,
0.4927518367767334,
-0.1916317641735077,
-0.23479433357715607,
-0.1660243421792984,
-0.1663171499967575,
-0.5161916613578796,
0.22658954560756683,
0.04880635440349579,
0.6320165395736694,
0.0014462746912613511,
-0.20171049237251282,
0.46337613463401794,
-0.3908538222312927,
0.6951248049736023,
0.35911864042282104,
-0.7594846487045288,
0.42668265104293823,
-0.509763777256012,
0.34401050209999084,
0.3103537857532501,
0.21157331764698029,
-0.6887862682342529,
-0.3261304795742035,
-0.5659014582633972,
-0.6052634716033936,
0.6839166879653931,
-0.2988237738609314,
-0.07308366149663925,
-0.05611805617809296,
0.15932868421077728,
0.1359831541776657,
0.4234861433506012,
-0.48594555258750916,
0.16594593226909637,
0.04410551115870476,
-0.4534285366535187,
-0.45563554763793945,
0.02677147462964058,
-0.0980512723326683,
-0.33929935097694397,
0.6091505885124207,
-0.1499125063419342,
0.13090385496616364,
-0.11502858251333237,
-0.30646082758903503,
-0.04640519991517067,
0.3157585561275482,
0.3963710367679596,
0.6054794788360596,
-0.1728181391954422,
0.05340135097503662,
0.09260110557079315,
-0.2679864466190338,
0.2508869469165802,
-0.220955029129982,
0.015885844826698303,
-0.5188167691230774,
0.5202065110206604,
0.7950708270072937,
0.2641804814338684,
-0.9298384189605713,
0.1834641844034195,
0.007695900276303291,
-0.009074977599084377,
-0.05748586729168892,
0.4338979721069336,
0.24545781314373016,
0.32968881726264954,
-0.08336475491523743,
-0.05097578465938568,
-0.057874128222465515,
-0.9763315916061401,
0.08227179199457169,
0.4105072021484375,
-0.41723600029945374,
-0.40021514892578125,
0.41988345980644226,
0.24545934796333313,
-0.48332443833351135,
0.8723351359367371,
-0.1901310235261917,
-0.31559693813323975,
0.661399781703949,
0.3292418122291565,
0.5783995389938354,
-0.060241326689720154,
0.26305103302001953,
0.4205997586250305,
0.2993287444114685,
-0.45543402433395386,
0.23799654841423035,
0.039531607180833817,
-0.6695194244384766,
-0.4219949543476105,
-0.41330814361572266,
-0.42858976125717163,
0.24736210703849792,
-0.6519759297370911,
0.0204802006483078,
-0.7666952610015869,
-0.1060967743396759,
-0.12399281561374664,
0.13205622136592865,
-0.8800460696220398,
0.21454977989196777,
0.28701460361480713,
0.9333676099777222,
-0.6908336877822876,
0.4223676323890686,
0.5885690450668335,
-0.254530131816864,
-0.7123953700065613,
-0.1734064817428589,
-0.19584788382053375,
-0.9741068482398987,
0.5583012700080872,
0.0521608367562294,
0.033001091331243515,
-0.04267372563481331,
-0.8679603934288025,
-0.7229177951812744,
0.7319621443748474,
0.42713913321495056,
-0.8501569628715515,
0.05230420455336571,
0.01397777535021305,
0.8678085207939148,
-0.3221495449542999,
0.258648544549942,
1.0341020822525024,
0.4932275116443634,
-0.14378921687602997,
-0.7267013788223267,
0.09527478367090225,
-0.02483947016298771,
-0.06770606338977814,
0.1285007745027542,
-0.8312199115753174,
0.8538529872894287,
-0.4804849922657013,
0.08304155617952347,
0.1538386046886444,
0.6111857891082764,
0.5465522408485413,
0.06737750768661499,
0.3275565207004547,
0.47626549005508423,
1.0921005010604858,
0.004959486424922943,
1.1779308319091797,
-0.16141079366207123,
0.1892825961112976,
1.355134129524231,
-0.3816365897655487,
0.9560390114784241,
0.4632491171360016,
-0.3400729298591614,
0.6398600339889526,
0.6475399136543274,
-0.16696223616600037,
0.48334458470344543,
0.6187309622764587,
0.14659149944782257,
-0.5074726343154907,
-0.09689098596572876,
0.08543102443218231,
0.28646042943000793,
0.4968099594116211,
0.03679024055600166,
-0.12355320155620575,
-0.11500360816717148,
-0.061742495745420456,
0.07100814580917358,
-0.43595507740974426,
0.6281708478927612,
0.29378488659858704,
-1.0875310897827148,
0.3684036135673523,
-0.18682636320590973,
0.665054440498352,
-0.47543418407440186,
0.18464675545692444,
-0.23235240578651428,
0.5026094317436218,
0.05336562916636467,
-0.5738204121589661,
0.021049844101071358,
-0.08616248518228531,
-0.20402072370052338,
-0.1466800719499588,
0.36309802532196045,
-0.4507080018520355,
-0.47216495871543884,
0.5629259943962097,
0.6919757127761841,
0.15041831135749817,
-0.07007789611816406,
-0.708874523639679,
0.021192898973822594,
-0.5257401466369629,
-0.3013235926628113,
0.40552809834480286,
0.34799033403396606,
-0.25107118487358093,
0.8252966403961182,
0.5708917379379272,
0.2604905366897583,
0.14030729234218597,
0.30023160576820374,
0.3156028389930725,
-0.8784624338150024,
-0.586535632610321,
-1.0154061317443848,
-0.037112992256879807,
0.03178849816322327,
-0.13081513345241547,
0.5096147656440735,
0.18865342438220978,
0.828240156173706,
-0.05431455746293068,
0.9102413654327393,
0.13595111668109894,
0.4265362024307251,
-0.3626066744327545,
0.3963924050331116,
-0.33650898933410645,
0.0918455719947815,
-0.0567825511097908,
-0.6827163100242615,
-0.006400975864380598,
0.5979757905006409,
-0.7027397751808167,
0.266653835773468,
0.745458722114563,
0.9643175005912781,
0.18491287529468536,
0.07920464128255844,
0.5088415741920471,
0.5114033222198486,
0.5551603436470032,
0.7101334929466248,
1.1794770956039429,
-0.06545258313417435,
0.2882067859172821,
0.09721033275127411,
-0.20837825536727905,
-0.35252681374549866,
-0.9682635068893433,
-1.0820480585098267,
-0.13440975546836853,
-0.32559680938720703,
-0.16338761150836945,
-0.01420519407838583,
1.0011849403381348,
0.8167325854301453,
-0.8618869185447693,
-0.5661987066268921,
-0.29321521520614624,
-0.05570436269044876,
-0.43480581045150757,
-0.18022051453590393,
0.011871648952364922,
-0.4706439673900604,
-0.39130839705467224,
0.2520633339881897,
0.3390261232852936,
-0.08088833093643188,
-0.5932126045227051,
-0.32103753089904785,
-0.06967999786138535,
0.2550102472305298,
0.5996791124343872,
0.011190155521035194,
-0.7226177453994751,
-0.2538710832595825,
0.11111722141504288,
-0.1415182501077652,
0.06946016103029251,
0.8357601761817932,
-0.5783249735832214,
0.09201958775520325,
0.5638311505317688,
0.4714920222759247,
0.32916900515556335,
-0.257095068693161,
0.7727296352386475,
-0.555273711681366,
0.04305848479270935,
0.21093402802944183,
0.2901240587234497,
0.4034721553325653,
-0.23782044649124146,
0.48619547486305237,
0.03923076018691063,
-0.464251846075058,
-0.7506198287010193,
0.27316758036613464,
-0.6464303135871887,
-0.36329206824302673,
1.042626142501831,
-0.08159242570400238,
-0.40804609656333923,
0.011016640812158585,
-0.14370152354240417,
0.02701573446393013,
-0.5368819832801819,
0.9525524973869324,
1.2503938674926758,
-0.412211537361145,
-0.4062683880329132,
-0.6522892713546753,
0.36090728640556335,
0.4990251958370209,
-0.9383704662322998,
0.19981656968593597,
0.3764757215976715,
0.29228195548057556,
0.07938162982463837,
0.5713155269622803,
0.12031085789203644,
0.30454331636428833,
0.09419065713882446,
0.10858467221260071,
0.12287303805351257,
-0.36229100823402405,
-0.2485605925321579,
0.01713762804865837,
0.20970027148723602,
0.3154999315738678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18223v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18223v2
|
Improving Open-Ended Text Generation via Adaptive Decoding
| 2024-02-28T10:38:21 | 2024-06-03T03:02:44 |
Wenhong Zhu, Hongkun Hao, Zhiwei He, Yiming Ai, Rui Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current language models decode text token by token according to probabilistic
distribution, and determining the appropriate candidates for the next token is
crucial to ensure generation quality. This study introduces adaptive decoding,
a mechanism that dynamically empowers language models to ascertain a sensible
candidate set during generation. Specifically, we introduce an entropy-based
metric called confidence and conceptualize determining the optimal candidate
set as a confidence-increasing process. The rationality of including a token in
the candidate set is assessed by leveraging the increment of confidence.
Experimental results reveal that our method balances diversity and coherence
well. The human evaluation shows that our method can generate human-preferred
text. Additionally, our method can potentially improve the reasoning ability of
language models.
|
[
-0.09506929665803909,
-0.3352997303009033,
0.4184456467628479,
0.17891748249530792,
-0.4953449070453644,
0.19847451150417328,
-0.31996193528175354,
-0.3929941654205322,
-0.1773601770401001,
0.1749427318572998,
-0.229370579123497,
-0.48905324935913086,
-0.48660770058631897,
0.33483174443244934,
-0.3113953173160553,
0.8189437985420227,
-0.1479494273662567,
-0.17033448815345764,
-0.24388767778873444,
-0.02124118246138096,
-0.44712454080581665,
-0.2592996656894684,
-0.8082124590873718,
-0.35058438777923584,
0.18826109170913696,
0.4027186930179596,
0.8368704915046692,
0.7801364660263062,
0.3782147765159607,
0.2740207314491272,
-0.06521965563297272,
0.25856995582580566,
-0.45725613832473755,
0.5414683222770691,
-0.2784782648086548,
-0.5930947065353394,
-0.3446321189403534,
-0.1931128203868866,
0.7037574648857117,
0.5010115504264832,
-0.17989134788513184,
0.04346252977848053,
0.14785698056221008,
0.4499387741088867,
-0.8817147612571716,
-0.10265600681304932,
-1.096288800239563,
-0.11072379350662231,
-0.15848855674266815,
-0.8539886474609375,
-0.6883562207221985,
-0.5130353569984436,
0.07543903589248657,
-0.557027280330658,
0.42437508702278137,
0.12164734303951263,
0.5969860553741455,
0.06128900125622749,
-0.03659399598836899,
-0.7197396159172058,
-0.655849814414978,
0.7876778244972229,
-0.705453097820282,
0.4625590741634369,
0.39875733852386475,
-0.0632886067032814,
-0.3356371819972992,
-0.7770224213600159,
-0.553019642829895,
-0.06749197095632553,
0.3039567768573761,
0.3310201168060303,
-0.12050410360097885,
0.019453847780823708,
-0.32285624742507935,
0.5160478353500366,
-0.2588489055633545,
-0.029412781819701195,
-0.16902942955493927,
-0.19525562226772308,
0.38495194911956787,
0.041889309883117676,
0.4576319456100464,
0.031384434551000595,
0.03897252678871155,
-0.3941720128059387,
-0.15311293303966522,
0.06434550881385803,
0.7860329151153564,
0.48159822821617126,
0.09115539491176605,
0.4817332923412323,
-0.24842646718025208,
0.7422735691070557,
0.11094516515731812,
0.0034531448036432266,
0.25830453634262085,
-0.4763500690460205,
-0.16024266183376312,
0.314699649810791,
0.6740290522575378,
0.3337682783603668,
0.3351653218269348,
-0.1486785113811493,
-0.23513244092464447,
-0.03770378232002258,
0.32367441058158875,
-0.72255939245224,
-0.20822113752365112,
0.42252621054649353,
-0.6167318820953369,
-0.6427555084228516,
0.3189859092235565,
-0.6494954824447632,
-0.11890235543251038,
0.1419505476951599,
0.10237017273902893,
-0.7084557414054871,
-0.33644482493400574,
0.5634616017341614,
-0.598311722278595,
-0.05705712363123894,
0.14403487741947174,
-1.192986249923706,
-0.007123976480215788,
0.5441896915435791,
0.9374683499336243,
-0.04413731396198273,
-0.09377514570951462,
-0.4710063338279724,
0.10423475503921509,
-0.6569143533706665,
0.6977148056030273,
-0.6666262149810791,
-0.2590722143650055,
0.029785441234707832,
-0.4069044589996338,
0.07683827728033066,
-0.3734889328479767,
0.6786535382270813,
-0.5853870511054993,
0.41859206557273865,
-0.015999240800738335,
-0.3802259564399719,
0.21722674369812012,
-0.011666573584079742,
-0.5679952502250671,
0.9057899117469788,
0.2666850984096527,
-0.9517903327941895,
0.633688747882843,
-0.5710808634757996,
-0.3980271816253662,
0.0740150734782219,
-0.061627618968486786,
-0.5136749148368835,
0.5381260514259338,
0.25262251496315,
0.33178821206092834,
-0.2228671908378601,
0.11313015222549438,
-0.14712369441986084,
-0.2159951627254486,
0.4216074049472809,
-0.6482952833175659,
0.6718829870223999,
0.5651055574417114,
-0.05520463362336159,
0.10649456083774567,
-0.9955259561538696,
0.2872145175933838,
0.032677315175533295,
-0.6831328272819519,
-0.49102988839149475,
0.2557324469089508,
-0.20939849317073822,
-0.2460523098707199,
0.18784528970718384,
-0.5159364938735962,
-0.13130734860897064,
-0.795852541923523,
0.3088439404964447,
0.9318459033966064,
0.16321757435798645,
0.5981051921844482,
-0.26749303936958313,
0.3295916020870209,
0.15073911845684052,
-0.1996789276599884,
-0.5250508785247803,
-0.5533190369606018,
-0.6624865531921387,
-0.11048878729343414,
0.5172905921936035,
0.491668701171875,
-0.8553266525268555,
0.6974560618400574,
-0.2871907353401184,
-0.30521300435066223,
-0.792954683303833,
0.02566264010965824,
0.23278529942035675,
0.25858452916145325,
0.11735782772302628,
-0.5289890170097351,
-0.6222432255744934,
-0.36822307109832764,
-0.5888747572898865,
-0.47689592838287354,
-0.18890318274497986,
-0.0034752367064356804,
0.12960673868656158,
0.11005204916000366,
1.123962163925171,
-0.4474439024925232,
0.42197030782699585,
-0.09695056825876236,
0.3572070896625519,
0.08149581402540207,
0.594659149646759,
0.36513224244117737,
-0.7904514074325562,
-0.3629991114139557,
0.28525346517562866,
-0.8084848523139954,
-0.03464781120419502,
-0.3900580406188965,
-0.3162941038608551,
0.299131840467453,
0.4704648554325104,
-0.28591808676719666,
0.32874438166618347,
0.48928847908973694,
-0.5476871728897095,
0.4134976863861084,
-0.4770735800266266,
0.23251275718212128,
-1.3812189102172852,
0.02517394907772541,
-0.3169642388820648,
-0.20647917687892914,
-0.6839658617973328,
0.23796483874320984,
-0.11974440515041351,
0.057900320738554,
-0.13976556062698364,
0.4459610879421234,
-0.6165725588798523,
0.029599161818623543,
-0.5097227096557617,
0.028700748458504677,
-0.08948037028312683,
-0.026952484622597694,
0.0350656732916832,
0.7918740510940552,
0.455298513174057,
-0.6279350519180298,
0.33351442217826843,
0.14045150578022003,
-0.5758631825447083,
0.6150025725364685,
-0.36671462655067444,
0.1453120857477188,
-0.39673036336898804,
0.026353586465120316,
-0.8950186967849731,
-0.3923634886741638,
0.13866539299488068,
-0.8777197599411011,
0.16847963631153107,
0.2827167212963104,
-0.37467265129089355,
-0.2494814097881317,
-0.12378609925508499,
0.45795416831970215,
0.6894006729125977,
-0.5922828912734985,
0.26003360748291016,
-0.004520760849118233,
-0.2242719531059265,
-0.4817228317260742,
-0.6276555061340332,
0.20970577001571655,
-0.028898945078253746,
-0.5988896489143372,
0.29499638080596924,
-0.14999839663505554,
-0.3825184106826782,
0.03870752453804016,
-0.061250630766153336,
0.016440173611044884,
0.17482584714889526,
-0.20370474457740784,
-0.026077689602971077,
-0.24596141278743744,
0.2918770909309387,
0.2395269125699997,
-0.2188432812690735,
-0.2354501187801361,
-0.8352408409118652,
0.5411427021026611,
0.15265735983848572,
-0.11969666182994843,
-0.3206058740615845,
0.3544919192790985,
0.4888850152492523,
-0.35853350162506104,
1.0342763662338257,
0.5727450847625732,
-0.44537729024887085,
-0.30975577235221863,
-0.048311855643987656,
-0.08308245241641998,
-0.5449013710021973,
0.4339654743671417,
-0.5820124745368958,
-0.786490261554718,
0.48689591884613037,
0.1635311245918274,
0.3110639452934265,
0.2631976902484894,
0.8377792835235596,
0.1332836151123047,
1.0901360511779785,
0.8396886587142944,
0.2811771631240845,
0.6016209125518799,
0.412008136510849,
0.2115667462348938,
-0.4800542891025543,
-0.11369528621435165,
-0.656790554523468,
0.03836698457598686,
-0.563973605632782,
-0.4565517008304596,
0.09175755828619003,
0.4036562740802765,
-0.0712282657623291,
0.14288848638534546,
-0.8000288605690002,
0.3606621026992798,
0.7357357144355774,
0.20961764454841614,
0.3798556625843048,
0.30845969915390015,
-0.2538678050041199,
0.20223455131053925,
-0.8113849759101868,
-0.5507347583770752,
1.0900455713272095,
0.4454898536205292,
0.6853947639465332,
0.08683780580759048,
0.7729251980781555,
0.2755433917045593,
0.28602704405784607,
-0.4659646153450012,
0.2623957097530365,
-0.11120405793190002,
-0.41217491030693054,
-0.4115598797798157,
-0.6158751249313354,
-0.9966815114021301,
-0.012401197105646133,
-0.4366168677806854,
-0.6850734949111938,
0.3289566934108734,
0.3585018515586853,
-0.23506106436252594,
0.3858911991119385,
-0.45222657918930054,
0.46395450830459595,
0.09104398638010025,
-0.23656946420669556,
-0.09688693284988403,
-0.3568185865879059,
0.25183331966400146,
-0.34338822960853577,
0.04404306411743164,
0.06388172507286072,
-0.1758049875497818,
0.6292649507522583,
-0.19281509518623352,
0.4827328026294708,
-0.08567914366722107,
-0.372175931930542,
0.5706768035888672,
0.017802340909838676,
0.5693073272705078,
-0.08683602511882782,
-0.7382897734642029,
-0.30189093947410583,
-0.35569220781326294,
-0.6219726800918579,
-0.5011104345321655,
0.3969694972038269,
-0.6472187042236328,
-0.2968282997608185,
-0.18499882519245148,
-0.6845005750656128,
-0.10048704594373703,
0.3406001627445221,
0.8286183476448059,
0.2213280200958252,
-0.3296397924423218,
0.39371761679649353,
0.6090775728225708,
-0.466919869184494,
0.4808344542980194,
0.02024678885936737,
0.10201568156480789,
-0.616982638835907,
0.9760263562202454,
-0.13666380941867828,
0.5926472544670105,
0.4121409058570862,
0.30127352476119995,
-0.20678938925266266,
-0.8750074505805969,
-0.4228726625442505,
-0.2883546054363251,
-0.8076277375221252,
-0.3030812740325928,
-0.6671176552772522,
-0.12000968307256699,
-0.4658762812614441,
-0.43498694896698,
-0.14164982736110687,
-0.27027836441993713,
-0.5040127635002136,
-0.23298980295658112,
0.28113722801208496,
0.39741259813308716,
-0.02280249074101448,
0.4996226131916046,
-0.7061046361923218,
0.25443363189697266,
0.16728995740413666,
0.6799466013908386,
0.07092883437871933,
-0.5265883207321167,
-0.3448275923728943,
0.20436406135559082,
-0.23202811181545258,
-0.971071720123291,
0.2634579539299011,
0.41278591752052307,
0.49620845913887024,
0.27955543994903564,
0.3061020076274872,
0.32235607504844666,
-0.47213175892829895,
0.683447003364563,
0.44162023067474365,
-1.1071168184280396,
0.5836681723594666,
-0.4369349777698517,
0.4360133111476898,
0.5240152478218079,
0.022446105256676674,
-0.41583091020584106,
-0.7993527054786682,
-0.6584391593933105,
-0.7750614285469055,
0.5858902335166931,
0.5581488609313965,
0.3988249897956848,
-0.34464189410209656,
0.5532181262969971,
0.17631466686725616,
0.11565615236759186,
-0.6540641784667969,
0.2623315155506134,
-0.49839094281196594,
-0.8790990710258484,
0.0313526876270771,
-0.15194258093833923,
0.1114746481180191,
0.22762036323547363,
0.6654343605041504,
-0.39206042885780334,
0.4370613992214203,
0.24158219993114471,
0.20758718252182007,
-0.49165448546409607,
0.46754616498947144,
0.5658290982246399,
0.49433109164237976,
-0.26173481345176697,
0.2214817851781845,
0.14989031851291656,
-0.6180182099342346,
0.29410868883132935,
-0.2566084563732147,
-0.2926594018936157,
0.14169934391975403,
0.4663057327270508,
1.0024360418319702,
-0.2009909301996231,
-0.5846019387245178,
0.3233160078525543,
-0.1932656168937683,
-0.340196430683136,
0.14205175638198853,
0.35263800621032715,
0.01696784421801567,
0.01450340449810028,
0.4779212772846222,
0.29950517416000366,
-0.05063113942742348,
-0.7115190625190735,
0.4010922610759735,
0.4343556761741638,
-0.4075830280780792,
-0.26770392060279846,
0.6940402388572693,
0.29519563913345337,
-0.6497954726219177,
0.5891774892807007,
-0.23628154397010803,
-0.1252857744693756,
0.44637763500213623,
1.0842267274856567,
1.0635815858840942,
-0.3947881758213043,
0.14310625195503235,
0.47470176219940186,
0.4095337688922882,
-0.31286507844924927,
0.49123501777648926,
0.07070241123437881,
-1.1157352924346924,
-0.18940049409866333,
-0.9838290810585022,
-0.1895504742860794,
-0.2889123857021332,
-0.6643080711364746,
0.16451072692871094,
-0.3806099593639374,
-0.24877691268920898,
-0.2804970145225525,
-0.4125964045524597,
-0.33471766114234924,
0.44143879413604736,
-0.12699802219867706,
1.1000337600708008,
-0.6994227170944214,
0.7285535335540771,
0.4684082269668579,
-0.0769600197672844,
-0.4341128170490265,
0.4609664976596832,
-0.5044272541999817,
-0.6641085743904114,
0.05061587318778038,
0.07011883705854416,
-0.2376149445772171,
0.20131924748420715,
-0.5607961416244507,
-0.7850111722946167,
1.0227845907211304,
0.45458874106407166,
-0.2875773310661316,
-0.03824356943368912,
-0.05768650025129318,
0.5751879811286926,
-0.6135429739952087,
0.0296318419277668,
0.5075482726097107,
0.3678690791130066,
0.11391019076108932,
-0.6558586359024048,
0.11274015158414841,
-0.3247051239013672,
0.12523961067199707,
0.2687406539916992,
-0.24816416203975677,
0.778492271900177,
-0.35055866837501526,
-0.5828230977058411,
0.5162563323974609,
1.0783361196517944,
0.35404643416404724,
0.2859606444835663,
0.6354631781578064,
0.30981218814849854,
1.0000561475753784,
0.04036369547247887,
0.916079580783844,
-0.4220536947250366,
0.10673905909061432,
0.9964869022369385,
0.053842268884181976,
0.9976492524147034,
0.34774166345596313,
0.06641491502523422,
0.703148365020752,
0.5761693716049194,
0.29377707839012146,
0.579692542552948,
0.24536371231079102,
-0.5662604570388794,
-0.27752503752708435,
0.011601584032177925,
-0.21503987908363342,
0.41650390625,
0.34513458609580994,
-0.6556435823440552,
-0.027269311249256134,
0.08201179653406143,
-0.22970813512802124,
0.41427096724510193,
-0.24180662631988525,
0.8090623617172241,
-0.11945570260286331,
-1.0327842235565186,
0.537111222743988,
0.4816066324710846,
0.6325692534446716,
-0.4486296772956848,
0.1935088336467743,
0.03625858202576637,
0.20326046645641327,
-0.2321101278066635,
-0.8834189772605896,
0.25916358828544617,
0.12408381700515747,
-0.2932298481464386,
-0.13659709692001343,
0.8840917348861694,
-0.4890734553337097,
-0.5715300440788269,
-0.03355732187628746,
0.3334389626979828,
-0.027544928714632988,
0.19869714975357056,
-0.39284390211105347,
0.06992246955633163,
0.1683451533317566,
-0.12598101794719696,
0.04492427781224251,
0.6438606977462769,
0.04838177189230919,
0.4459633529186249,
0.8428875803947449,
0.212727352976799,
0.06556776911020279,
-0.08171903342008591,
0.5727118849754333,
-0.5031478404998779,
-0.8507573008537292,
-0.9078737497329712,
0.5280351042747498,
-0.14158853888511658,
-0.3304362893104553,
0.5389419794082642,
0.34394240379333496,
0.7534866333007812,
-0.004419208969920874,
1.143804669380188,
0.07285059243440628,
0.21888038516044617,
-0.7100739479064941,
0.5789427757263184,
-0.4264026880264282,
0.2009057253599167,
-0.30268973112106323,
-0.8541800379753113,
-0.3932151794433594,
0.6664846539497375,
0.09838021546602249,
0.04848857596516609,
0.5426029562950134,
0.6808714270591736,
-0.10416960716247559,
0.17394548654556274,
0.17150147259235382,
-0.09944899380207062,
0.3504651188850403,
0.5078025460243225,
0.6654199361801147,
-0.4386369287967682,
0.642396092414856,
0.3131382167339325,
-0.5842782855033875,
-0.0083101075142622,
-1.072879672050476,
-0.6992355585098267,
-0.5425986647605896,
-0.020366797223687172,
-0.5645885467529297,
0.26980048418045044,
0.805025041103363,
0.5185111165046692,
-0.6609504222869873,
-0.1704285889863968,
-0.6401597261428833,
0.05140572786331177,
-0.24452689290046692,
-0.19087624549865723,
0.1516520231962204,
-0.6654599905014038,
-0.7794623374938965,
0.2196340262889862,
0.3780217170715332,
0.15396593511104584,
-0.09850675612688065,
-0.3481898903846741,
0.03183510899543762,
0.6979747414588928,
0.4178389608860016,
0.10636372119188309,
-0.40580758452415466,
-0.4452930986881256,
-0.009685548022389412,
-0.1171124204993248,
0.1148606389760971,
0.9369732141494751,
-0.5218412280082703,
0.7645358443260193,
0.7984123826026917,
0.6750665307044983,
-0.1267349123954773,
0.12957355380058289,
1.0937612056732178,
-1.0351258516311646,
0.17125774919986725,
0.11691036075353622,
0.030929524451494217,
0.44753772020339966,
-0.5171304941177368,
0.177608922123909,
0.21775813400745392,
-0.29687532782554626,
-1.0722013711929321,
0.441290944814682,
-0.5921764969825745,
-0.5417935848236084,
0.9473267793655396,
-0.11575684696435928,
-0.18832488358020782,
-0.17910422384738922,
-0.08051745593547821,
0.4901072382926941,
-0.36841920018196106,
0.6782712936401367,
0.7243278622627258,
0.13763214647769928,
-0.2482329159975052,
-0.037801891565322876,
0.5587984323501587,
0.37820470333099365,
-0.8775445222854614,
0.24217242002487183,
0.1997775286436081,
0.08422762900590897,
0.31958237290382385,
0.9864479899406433,
-0.06094929203391075,
0.4419620931148529,
0.5171838998794556,
-0.04966088384389877,
0.18885616958141327,
-0.34909144043922424,
-0.22596773505210876,
0.4501585066318512,
0.3170969486236572,
-0.20081326365470886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18216v1
|
LLM Task Interference: An Initial Study on the Impact of Task-Switch in Conversational History
| 2024-02-28T10:19:05 | 2024-02-28T10:19:05 |
Akash Gupta, Ivaxi Sheth, Vyas Raina, Mark Gales, Mario Fritz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the recent emergence of powerful instruction-tuned large language models
(LLMs), various helpful conversational Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems
have been deployed across many applications. When prompted by users, these AI
systems successfully perform a wide range of tasks as part of a conversation.
To provide some sort of memory and context, such approaches typically condition
their output on the entire conversational history. Although this sensitivity to
the conversational history can often lead to improved performance on subsequent
tasks, we find that performance can in fact also be negatively impacted, if
there is a task-switch. To the best of our knowledge, our work makes the first
attempt to formalize the study of such vulnerabilities and interference of
tasks in conversational LLMs caused by task-switches in the conversational
history. Our experiments across 5 datasets with 15 task switches using popular
LLMs reveal that many of the task-switches can lead to significant performance
degradation.
|
[
-0.06516464054584503,
-1.2068265676498413,
0.4539177715778351,
-0.04579092934727669,
-0.056001197546720505,
0.009674661792814732,
-0.00017565855523571372,
-0.7737639546394348,
0.15097790956497192,
0.9660350680351257,
-0.5243098735809326,
-0.0894559770822525,
-0.8010874390602112,
-0.3602018356323242,
-0.7209463715553284,
0.9638361930847168,
0.08077402412891388,
-0.144192174077034,
-0.46869462728500366,
0.29524311423301697,
-0.6469652652740479,
-0.7073469161987305,
-0.7010334730148315,
-0.41029539704322815,
0.25553637742996216,
0.2523539066314697,
0.5757725834846497,
0.40125542879104614,
0.7032674551010132,
0.32797566056251526,
-0.06857910752296448,
0.08646870404481888,
-0.824580192565918,
0.3945193886756897,
-0.0727376863360405,
-0.8625743389129639,
-0.4821053445339203,
-0.13116440176963806,
0.35101771354675293,
0.7250158786773682,
0.08338239043951035,
-0.08259764313697815,
0.3389046788215637,
0.3465858995914459,
-0.5385234355926514,
0.18998079001903534,
-0.8253549933433533,
0.041011467576026917,
-0.5732244253158569,
-0.3469318449497223,
-0.553374171257019,
0.24203361570835114,
0.015173975378274918,
-0.2789613902568817,
0.008644736371934414,
-0.11373371630907059,
0.5501087307929993,
0.5549136996269226,
-0.508897602558136,
-0.030704261735081673,
-1.0659581422805786,
0.9012649059295654,
-0.6660728454589844,
0.2765321433544159,
0.48689696192741394,
-0.18176613748073578,
-0.26526933908462524,
-0.6190372109413147,
-0.2909367084503174,
-0.6005409359931946,
-0.08176862448453903,
0.04283944517374039,
-0.5376020073890686,
0.1871451437473297,
0.36525779962539673,
0.0819103941321373,
-0.08933168649673462,
0.25609806180000305,
-0.3044275641441345,
-0.12444508820772171,
0.5649722814559937,
0.6345164775848389,
0.3172725439071655,
0.035027679055929184,
-0.2122056782245636,
0.33197087049484253,
-0.8403621315956116,
0.05927304923534393,
0.4974571466445923,
0.2316366732120514,
0.1336488127708435,
0.6201209425926208,
-0.2674950659275055,
0.7074313759803772,
0.09738586097955704,
-0.016221817582845688,
-0.21051369607448578,
-0.5674033761024475,
-0.17184285819530487,
-0.36696699261665344,
0.7664704322814941,
0.2762453854084015,
0.11508584767580032,
-0.4964842200279236,
0.17869126796722412,
0.0483921617269516,
0.5867842435836792,
-0.4661557674407959,
-0.08840815722942352,
0.029190748929977417,
-0.22199873626232147,
-0.12266506254673004,
-0.20421312749385834,
-0.27376145124435425,
-0.32207217812538147,
-0.1877584457397461,
0.19037553668022156,
-0.2324666678905487,
0.10621209442615509,
-0.2082924097776413,
0.1956394910812378,
0.05762797221541405,
0.4668775200843811,
-0.6086916923522949,
0.6112996935844421,
0.7992919683456421,
0.6524264812469482,
-0.7118922472000122,
-0.557488739490509,
-0.4953918755054474,
0.04903235286474228,
-0.09712392836809158,
0.4218457043170929,
-0.5568227767944336,
-0.7958418726921082,
0.0943281427025795,
-0.09390215575695038,
-0.12747637927532196,
-0.6250474452972412,
0.39563238620758057,
-0.733086109161377,
-0.021187949925661087,
-0.11892221868038177,
-0.49332502484321594,
0.045794375240802765,
0.02230549231171608,
-0.6381723880767822,
0.8962246179580688,
-0.3974134624004364,
-0.4142357409000397,
0.1641494184732437,
-0.29955244064331055,
-1.061786413192749,
0.002941207494586706,
-0.03366069868206978,
-0.12984023988246918,
-0.20044240355491638,
-0.24826323986053467,
0.39509856700897217,
-0.18518352508544922,
0.06535525619983673,
0.01297114510089159,
-0.4496929943561554,
0.4056423008441925,
-0.5643380880355835,
0.6754071712493896,
-0.07048038393259048,
-0.6560693383216858,
-0.08207673579454422,
-0.2361990213394165,
-0.11737764626741409,
-0.24389010667800903,
-0.2381681650876999,
-0.31746649742126465,
0.29838138818740845,
0.02694268897175789,
0.13400232791900635,
0.4136965274810791,
-0.2769387364387512,
0.14305567741394043,
-0.14286823570728302,
0.24621930718421936,
0.5290582776069641,
0.09802412241697311,
0.13562923669815063,
-0.5568195581436157,
0.5331405997276306,
0.2802388370037079,
0.25856897234916687,
-0.2604263722896576,
-0.709540069103241,
-0.7662336826324463,
0.19778214395046234,
0.03274059668183327,
0.8457959890365601,
-0.3998181223869324,
0.20040658116340637,
0.13612842559814453,
-0.2422364354133606,
-0.1848810315132141,
0.36832067370414734,
0.6086801886558533,
0.23044438660144806,
0.10871097445487976,
-0.32730409502983093,
-0.4523142874240875,
-0.8929761052131653,
-0.46506467461586,
-0.2342616468667984,
0.27608799934387207,
0.8032325506210327,
0.40175339579582214,
-0.23779679834842682,
0.9598853588104248,
-0.4022517502307892,
-0.18796637654304504,
-0.10407453030347824,
0.06077342480421066,
0.08761303871870041,
0.5505586862564087,
0.12367210537195206,
-0.3921281099319458,
-0.2632554769515991,
-0.055778782814741135,
-0.36538514494895935,
-0.21861030161380768,
-0.44553810358047485,
-0.3724432587623596,
0.3129595220088959,
0.842570424079895,
-0.7659934759140015,
0.41425371170043945,
0.5068261623382568,
-0.2563292682170868,
0.5497511625289917,
0.004379183053970337,
0.35444554686546326,
-0.8514072299003601,
0.08601036667823792,
-0.08458603173494339,
-0.13982589542865753,
-0.9063647389411926,
-0.2960638999938965,
-0.12870192527770996,
0.2392004281282425,
-0.5741474032402039,
0.3664126694202423,
-0.2330823391675949,
0.07524699717760086,
-0.231391042470932,
0.06985124945640564,
-0.33549273014068604,
0.43972620368003845,
-0.14037594199180603,
0.63795006275177,
0.2034604251384735,
-0.6394849419593811,
0.11797219514846802,
0.35639965534210205,
-0.1837407946586609,
0.47496557235717773,
-0.43508443236351013,
0.4460518956184387,
0.4383041560649872,
0.037774648517370224,
-0.8999242782592773,
-0.035942330956459045,
0.377824604511261,
-0.21664533019065857,
0.3636835515499115,
-0.0990455374121666,
-0.21638250350952148,
0.07519136369228363,
-0.049679774791002274,
0.5295684337615967,
0.2714567184448242,
-0.19766339659690857,
0.20786872506141663,
0.6072720289230347,
-0.2259676605463028,
-0.48660242557525635,
-0.6742138862609863,
0.5536377429962158,
-0.01756219007074833,
-0.5376982688903809,
0.5527098774909973,
-0.21030931174755096,
-0.3638579249382019,
-0.06575584411621094,
-0.10033035278320312,
-0.18339397013187408,
0.287570595741272,
0.6592867374420166,
0.4338887333869934,
0.09155207127332687,
-0.11308497935533524,
-0.11016607284545898,
0.13542895019054413,
0.20847970247268677,
0.2675308883190155,
0.6241381764411926,
0.07086647301912308,
-0.7895713448524475,
-0.5525731444358826,
0.3486163020133972,
0.5700399279594421,
-0.02656557410955429,
0.49907925724983215,
-0.02987411990761757,
-0.22221408784389496,
0.03498532995581627,
-0.6525774002075195,
-0.1965196281671524,
-0.4258614480495453,
0.6795557141304016,
-0.177491694688797,
-1.0140460729599,
0.5042467713356018,
-0.21811896562576294,
0.15052832663059235,
0.15382976830005646,
0.630725085735321,
-0.3353338837623596,
0.7998761534690857,
0.45811665058135986,
-0.4177553057670593,
0.9778886437416077,
-0.006137470714747906,
0.2631746232509613,
-0.6304742097854614,
-0.2658938765525818,
-0.4312558174133301,
-0.4450444281101227,
-0.5822916626930237,
-0.47564631700515747,
0.1971920281648636,
-0.07198375463485718,
-0.08694051951169968,
0.11164996773004532,
-0.010080013424158096,
0.482356458902359,
0.6607148051261902,
0.3706524968147278,
0.37470194697380066,
-0.43081048130989075,
0.6686428189277649,
0.014658553525805473,
-0.55367112159729,
-0.34930843114852905,
1.1649764776229858,
0.017127566039562225,
0.9925296306610107,
-0.06085614487528801,
0.7849093079566956,
0.6840436458587646,
-0.2770029902458191,
-0.6597703695297241,
0.7825559377670288,
-0.1859799027442932,
-0.4877004623413086,
-0.4500879943370819,
-0.13270893692970276,
-1.4390963315963745,
0.03468022495508194,
-0.0740051120519638,
-1.0630929470062256,
-0.2731192409992218,
0.26047590374946594,
-0.14298692345619202,
0.10679873079061508,
-0.6768987774848938,
0.712781548500061,
-0.45163652300834656,
-0.6230437159538269,
-0.37371018528938293,
-0.6186120510101318,
0.6039896011352539,
0.12430518120527267,
-0.09012111276388168,
-0.04668028652667999,
-0.016103215515613556,
0.6435713171958923,
0.0470830574631691,
1.4720107316970825,
0.09889984875917435,
0.08715654909610748,
0.05510919168591499,
0.24155138432979584,
0.7322361469268799,
-0.21830210089683533,
0.29921063780784607,
0.4150941073894501,
-0.11214058101177216,
-0.17268694937229156,
-0.4042561650276184,
0.714749276638031,
-0.7485785484313965,
-1.2419326305389404,
-0.2058628499507904,
-0.9105355739593506,
-0.31815943121910095,
0.1760937124490738,
0.013833552598953247,
0.2554529309272766,
-0.55963534116745,
0.08647608757019043,
0.699130654335022,
0.26347616314888,
0.31790363788604736,
0.39083096385002136,
-0.04313282668590546,
0.30661115050315857,
0.6539897322654724,
0.07232595235109329,
0.4174877405166626,
0.2917786240577698,
-0.2419244647026062,
0.24514861404895782,
-0.6998375058174133,
-0.16980691254138947,
-0.06312975287437439,
-0.396115779876709,
-0.02646169811487198,
-0.5135179758071899,
-0.25476402044296265,
-0.13177981972694397,
-0.011797161772847176,
-0.33173486590385437,
-0.30914363265037537,
-0.6695957183837891,
0.24141979217529297,
0.14827416837215424,
0.966267466545105,
0.3038746118545532,
0.2281426042318344,
-0.7288675904273987,
0.1677442491054535,
0.28723809123039246,
0.15914592146873474,
-0.1760149598121643,
-0.3867177665233612,
-0.4028213918209076,
0.01034548133611679,
-0.39944928884506226,
-1.0468679666519165,
-0.05492854490876198,
0.12273754179477692,
0.9577112197875977,
0.44244152307510376,
-0.03597066551446915,
0.427316814661026,
-0.46089985966682434,
1.0016332864761353,
0.12882179021835327,
-0.9312170743942261,
0.43818166851997375,
-0.36366888880729675,
0.45952001214027405,
0.2932102084159851,
0.03237302228808403,
-0.8479946851730347,
-0.8042197823524475,
-0.5730093121528625,
-0.9900538921356201,
1.0148464441299438,
0.3249865770339966,
0.27953895926475525,
-0.032402705401182175,
0.1603173315525055,
0.2469804435968399,
0.1820906400680542,
-0.3713531494140625,
-0.5515176653862,
0.18380412459373474,
0.21360906958580017,
-0.09311480820178986,
-0.3021356761455536,
-0.42398375272750854,
-0.014200858771800995,
0.5271485447883606,
0.09855037182569504,
0.27737855911254883,
-0.3018076419830322,
-0.5228817462921143,
-0.11140470206737518,
0.2420516163110733,
0.7659762501716614,
0.6505568027496338,
0.24646417796611786,
0.1424846351146698,
0.4183657765388489,
-0.4849907457828522,
-0.08705249428749084,
-0.07069440186023712,
-0.19536440074443817,
-0.11858650296926498,
0.36051133275032043,
0.9540587663650513,
0.7511569857597351,
-0.6469537615776062,
0.1830647736787796,
0.09960855543613434,
0.03921063616871834,
-0.05070139840245247,
0.4583682417869568,
0.1462358981370926,
0.611136257648468,
0.14619770646095276,
0.1628475934267044,
0.11728722602128983,
-0.6344587206840515,
0.3207363784313202,
0.9047189354896545,
-0.08050429821014404,
-0.04606247693300247,
0.4002799391746521,
0.44798123836517334,
-0.7897406816482544,
0.5272282361984253,
0.24605368077754974,
-0.5337420105934143,
0.7622072696685791,
0.6067256331443787,
0.8989648818969727,
-0.3053475320339203,
-0.05641018971800804,
-0.1149372011423111,
0.43973374366760254,
0.14387379586696625,
-0.04256339743733406,
-0.1830127090215683,
-0.669954776763916,
-0.36680012941360474,
-0.008290917612612247,
-0.8417232632637024,
0.04900982603430748,
-0.7610803842544556,
-0.10470171272754669,
0.03926306217908859,
-0.45377957820892334,
-0.23941576480865479,
-0.1442929208278656,
-0.7308658957481384,
-0.10529912263154984,
0.35591617226600647,
0.42269569635391235,
-0.5556031465530396,
0.739101231098175,
0.4883328378200531,
0.18883274495601654,
0.016818653792142868,
0.2792339622974396,
0.000920082675293088,
-0.9214181303977966,
0.8184344172477722,
-0.27465197443962097,
-0.38377466797828674,
-0.2103184461593628,
-0.23043884336948395,
-0.890030562877655,
0.9443149566650391,
0.3703387677669525,
-0.7333838939666748,
0.10092464089393616,
0.6571190357208252,
0.3641217350959778,
-0.13447318971157074,
0.2963830530643463,
1.0012998580932617,
0.2456424981355667,
-0.09735142439603806,
-1.0770561695098877,
0.035259000957012177,
-0.2139202207326889,
-0.14470738172531128,
0.5064133405685425,
-0.7592174410820007,
0.6827654242515564,
-0.09814721345901489,
-0.14235331118106842,
0.0073473514057695866,
0.3943135142326355,
-0.06090488284826279,
0.3699948787689209,
0.48173829913139343,
0.31878072023391724,
0.6789283752441406,
-0.12633080780506134,
0.8548910617828369,
-0.5634121894836426,
0.03280982747673988,
1.1482945680618286,
-0.36732229590415955,
0.8733435273170471,
0.777707576751709,
-0.5360849499702454,
0.0240385290235281,
0.3847323954105377,
0.19067533314228058,
0.2775228023529053,
0.1185157522559166,
-0.26464739441871643,
-0.3109342157840729,
-0.01042864192277193,
-0.29838699102401733,
0.4756357669830322,
0.3340718150138855,
-0.1919369399547577,
0.05754764750599861,
-0.13042333722114563,
0.4315360486507416,
-0.4364717900753021,
-0.12165512889623642,
0.6977077126502991,
-0.054490674287080765,
-0.8460673689842224,
0.19021297991275787,
-0.34895431995391846,
0.8763946294784546,
-0.6185829639434814,
-0.0028924692887812853,
-0.2116779088973999,
-0.007737841457128525,
-0.21106019616127014,
-0.6518347263336182,
0.2058008313179016,
-0.1459944099187851,
-0.2804381847381592,
-0.33055639266967773,
0.8003461360931396,
-0.4311469495296478,
-0.16539783775806427,
0.26124030351638794,
0.7229551076889038,
0.08923069387674332,
0.02042977325618267,
-0.4484561085700989,
0.2884534001350403,
0.015447961166501045,
-0.48391252756118774,
0.755731463432312,
-0.187772735953331,
-0.09790967404842377,
0.4842720627784729,
0.5508080720901489,
-0.22354453802108765,
0.28694307804107666,
-0.2547031342983246,
0.768698513507843,
-0.7144488096237183,
-0.31174609065055847,
-0.9973726868629456,
0.3085639476776123,
0.0016098744235932827,
-0.3623879551887512,
0.751044750213623,
0.48645904660224915,
0.7668097019195557,
0.21134516596794128,
0.8454173803329468,
-0.023813609033823013,
0.15850947797298431,
-0.5331534147262573,
0.7293612360954285,
-0.3084813058376312,
0.4837431311607361,
-0.1529952883720398,
-0.4008311629295349,
0.09024509787559509,
-0.03145233169198036,
-0.3607517182826996,
0.11491778492927551,
0.7218260765075684,
0.7612800598144531,
0.23656558990478516,
0.022044867277145386,
0.5936232209205627,
0.2920747995376587,
0.36690807342529297,
0.5144965052604675,
0.9632828235626221,
-0.060320090502500534,
0.6664143800735474,
-0.2412768304347992,
-0.14455603063106537,
-0.5742276906967163,
-0.597930908203125,
-0.7395232915878296,
-0.6629219055175781,
-0.5079997181892395,
-0.23527996242046356,
0.538290798664093,
0.2655537724494934,
0.40580496191978455,
-0.5686795115470886,
-0.6779154539108276,
0.04484536498785019,
0.2580054998397827,
-0.3791551887989044,
-0.1954115629196167,
0.04943324252963066,
-0.4020695984363556,
-0.9370472431182861,
0.5213503837585449,
0.19866052269935608,
-0.31497323513031006,
-0.1928933709859848,
-0.09035356342792511,
-0.19549204409122467,
0.14861728250980377,
0.6392921805381775,
0.46905454993247986,
-0.8801239728927612,
-0.2188768982887268,
0.006883260328322649,
-0.30925676226615906,
0.062213364988565445,
1.1623573303222656,
-0.6480828523635864,
0.30440753698349,
0.28410911560058594,
0.7715003490447998,
0.7355336546897888,
-0.2031141221523285,
0.5145203471183777,
-0.5942314267158508,
-0.09534531086683273,
0.34727782011032104,
0.3461223840713501,
-0.24401651322841644,
-0.6224780082702637,
0.12232622504234314,
0.15612885355949402,
-0.7381650805473328,
-0.7370614409446716,
0.2305464744567871,
-1.1410551071166992,
-0.2440599501132965,
1.2034761905670166,
-0.0796266719698906,
0.1040763333439827,
-0.340602308511734,
-0.4133200943470001,
0.2363658994436264,
-0.360897421836853,
0.9177417755126953,
0.8579458594322205,
-0.8247751593589783,
-0.013016336597502232,
-0.8055748343467712,
0.3477066457271576,
0.7457308173179626,
-1.1710247993469238,
0.08400534838438034,
0.5566220879554749,
-0.05758048593997955,
-0.04497721046209335,
0.5145362019538879,
0.27881333231925964,
0.442399799823761,
-0.014634297229349613,
-0.05019558593630791,
-0.10299865156412125,
-0.12548299133777618,
-0.005625192541629076,
0.14983338117599487,
0.09107188135385513,
-0.4080355763435364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18209v1
|
DANSK and DaCy 2.6.0: Domain Generalization of Danish Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-02-28T10:01:00 | 2024-02-28T10:01:00 |
Kenneth Enevoldsen, Emil Trenckner Jessen, Rebekah Baglini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Named entity recognition is one of the cornerstones of Danish NLP, essential
for language technology applications within both industry and research.
However, Danish NER is inhibited by a lack of available datasets. As a
consequence, no current models are capable of fine-grained named entity
recognition, nor have they been evaluated for potential generalizability issues
across datasets and domains. To alleviate these limitations, this paper
introduces: 1) DANSK: a named entity dataset providing for high-granularity
tagging as well as within-domain evaluation of models across a diverse set of
domains; 2) DaCy 2.6.0 that includes three generalizable models with
fine-grained annotation; and 3) an evaluation of current state-of-the-art
models' ability to generalize across domains. The evaluation of existing and
new models revealed notable performance discrepancies across domains, which
should be addressed within the field. Shortcomings of the annotation quality of
the dataset and its impact on model training and evaluation are also discussed.
Despite these limitations, we advocate for the use of the new dataset DANSK
alongside further work on the generalizability within Danish NER.
|
[
-0.6729507446289062,
-0.5653969645500183,
0.4408692419528961,
0.13404305279254913,
-0.2922869622707367,
-0.15922033786773682,
-0.3644926846027374,
-0.9171885848045349,
0.16633446514606476,
0.4855023920536041,
-0.1514388918876648,
-0.658650279045105,
-0.780984103679657,
0.42306095361709595,
-0.38485682010650635,
0.8686579465866089,
-0.1596468836069107,
-0.008866248652338982,
-0.30231809616088867,
-0.14721328020095825,
-0.6975979804992676,
-0.6500974893569946,
-0.8641567230224609,
-0.295427143573761,
0.42730653285980225,
0.2492574155330658,
0.5134032964706421,
0.47862687706947327,
0.7600885033607483,
0.1824607402086258,
-0.3756747543811798,
0.12374262511730194,
-0.42173877358436584,
0.17707523703575134,
-0.4126569330692291,
-0.06441443413496017,
-0.8723985552787781,
-0.15887917578220367,
0.8944085240364075,
0.9560747146606445,
-0.06037113070487976,
0.021453820168972015,
0.061340585350990295,
0.7700522541999817,
-0.6860336065292358,
0.3739444315433502,
-0.638205885887146,
-0.19019715487957,
-0.10507717728614807,
0.34350186586380005,
-0.12902452051639557,
0.07005167007446289,
0.4004903733730316,
-1.1232733726501465,
0.4327653646469116,
-0.12368809431791306,
1.0120657682418823,
0.2992789149284363,
-0.43184763193130493,
-0.5194076299667358,
-0.936318576335907,
0.7983375191688538,
-0.5445529222488403,
0.6255966424942017,
0.5198764204978943,
0.5313648581504822,
-0.20609433948993683,
-0.7048572897911072,
-0.49394503235816956,
-0.20184530317783356,
-0.04335101321339607,
-0.11697379499673843,
-0.042016372084617615,
0.1932060271501541,
0.3236277401447296,
0.4635402262210846,
-0.26330265402793884,
0.19045211374759674,
-0.27784499526023865,
0.09776788204908371,
0.8326470255851746,
0.22363629937171936,
0.012855869717895985,
-0.11869310587644577,
-0.34978652000427246,
-0.003241205122321844,
-0.5110911130905151,
-0.11151284724473953,
0.46211761236190796,
0.3381378948688507,
-0.168691948056221,
0.2708100974559784,
-0.35796216130256653,
0.7043396830558777,
0.33480650186538696,
0.1392882764339447,
0.1850992739200592,
-0.0826367735862732,
-0.1967117041349411,
0.058591149747371674,
0.35084956884384155,
0.4044322967529297,
0.2772422432899475,
-0.20794454216957092,
-0.46299979090690613,
0.015304304659366608,
0.20796893537044525,
-0.4474647343158722,
-0.5386936068534851,
0.20144736766815186,
-0.4295513927936554,
-0.24666890501976013,
0.3141533434391022,
-0.654925525188446,
-0.4212533235549927,
-0.6279001832008362,
0.22389446198940277,
0.08303070068359375,
-0.7080416083335876,
0.28894373774528503,
-0.2177303284406662,
0.0585813969373703,
0.6177212595939636,
-1.049341082572937,
0.8407374024391174,
0.8569568395614624,
0.4769115447998047,
-0.47793692350387573,
0.03003811649978161,
-0.0525609627366066,
0.16251331567764282,
-0.5142149925231934,
0.6681427955627441,
-0.6800687909126282,
-0.555636465549469,
-0.19214138388633728,
0.21818289160728455,
-0.08047734946012497,
-0.8703352808952332,
0.46014174818992615,
-0.6249508261680603,
-0.316470205783844,
-0.4047226011753082,
-0.7501498460769653,
-0.22472047805786133,
0.26591503620147705,
-1.0524723529815674,
1.0659462213516235,
0.26915881037712097,
-1.024617075920105,
0.6280613541603088,
-0.5970732569694519,
-0.09699796885251999,
0.18246187269687653,
-0.4127831757068634,
-0.10419318079948425,
0.4128425717353821,
-0.017838049679994583,
0.7065904140472412,
-0.4035465121269226,
0.5385477542877197,
-0.4021521210670471,
-0.2629401385784149,
-0.03063715621829033,
-0.24695801734924316,
0.449140727519989,
0.05994970723986626,
-0.010599283501505852,
-0.49759647250175476,
-0.9717915058135986,
-0.23040683567523956,
0.18962986767292023,
-0.6388816237449646,
-0.768483579158783,
-0.08225349336862564,
0.32014626264572144,
0.23817966878414154,
0.13569410145282745,
-0.5526354908943176,
0.29242244362831116,
-0.4654874801635742,
0.03984709829092026,
0.6394142508506775,
0.08318018913269043,
0.5622865557670593,
0.0071775782853364944,
0.32122766971588135,
0.06338904052972794,
-0.009089745581150055,
0.3278430104255676,
-0.5273082852363586,
-0.7071818113327026,
-0.31507131457328796,
1.0515025854110718,
0.3470321297645569,
-0.7636746168136597,
0.1896481215953827,
-0.5986031889915466,
-0.2276025116443634,
-0.19156469404697418,
-0.2489747852087021,
0.19305652379989624,
0.32959315180778503,
0.3751700818538666,
-0.5002042651176453,
-0.7060733437538147,
-1.1679750680923462,
-0.2904982268810272,
-0.045285072177648544,
0.11912047863006592,
0.6338028907775879,
0.6056079864501953,
-0.34323424100875854,
0.9463381767272949,
-0.30193203687667847,
-0.04570138826966286,
-0.17715045809745789,
0.07125134766101837,
0.3527039587497711,
0.5077207684516907,
0.49132755398750305,
-1.2234169244766235,
-0.7058113813400269,
0.10672025382518768,
-0.5695971250534058,
-0.012829333543777466,
0.05550429970026016,
0.16397325694561005,
0.15523262321949005,
0.37498724460601807,
-0.5508407354354858,
0.6130648851394653,
0.3661435544490814,
-0.1754884570837021,
0.6953662633895874,
-0.00003492920222925022,
0.07341840863227844,
-0.9459495544433594,
0.12262005358934402,
-0.08097736537456512,
-0.4004482924938202,
-0.7625123858451843,
-0.21748892962932587,
0.06491798907518387,
0.0831030085682869,
-0.4297873079776764,
1.204714298248291,
-0.5567113161087036,
0.03140532970428467,
-0.3392103314399719,
-0.0745508149266243,
-0.04008225351572037,
0.056143444031476974,
0.20274409651756287,
0.5153442025184631,
0.6365362405776978,
-1.0723966360092163,
0.47855204343795776,
0.3650342524051666,
-0.24207600951194763,
0.87458336353302,
-0.5767033100128174,
-0.03528628125786781,
0.029230890795588493,
0.22809439897537231,
-0.44692179560661316,
-0.5256210565567017,
0.317266583442688,
-0.38733020424842834,
0.9156033992767334,
-0.4891095459461212,
-0.4871630370616913,
-0.3444215655326843,
-0.00259591918438673,
0.521582305431366,
0.3674449324607849,
-0.7483747005462646,
0.6390796303749084,
0.5736194849014282,
-0.23899495601654053,
-0.7291824817657471,
-0.5370966792106628,
0.3099771738052368,
-0.16559213399887085,
-0.4423072934150696,
0.49768736958503723,
0.1076858639717102,
-0.34303852915763855,
0.24343618750572205,
-0.5833710432052612,
-0.45515501499176025,
0.14637665450572968,
0.31671595573425293,
0.003642473602667451,
-0.09878028929233551,
0.361494243144989,
0.09665168076753616,
-0.39781737327575684,
0.055042289197444916,
-0.32931169867515564,
0.09274361282587051,
0.04487750679254532,
0.012263183481991291,
-0.39239683747291565,
0.4158496856689453,
-0.024953920394182205,
0.06807512789964676,
0.54644376039505,
0.34162887930870056,
-0.8200832605361938,
-0.337046355009079,
-0.5407045483589172,
0.11524584889411926,
-0.4267996549606323,
0.31880784034729004,
-0.7133774757385254,
-0.930579423904419,
0.3742613196372986,
-0.4785407483577728,
-0.17988836765289307,
0.9760249853134155,
0.5188069939613342,
-0.09118509292602539,
0.6283167600631714,
0.9747421145439148,
0.18978941440582275,
0.09028186649084091,
-0.42881670594215393,
0.25724756717681885,
-0.9735221266746521,
-0.12769684195518494,
-0.43780717253685,
-0.2307729423046112,
-0.7056183218955994,
-0.24091868102550507,
-0.10142391175031662,
0.282484233379364,
0.25077342987060547,
0.377135306596756,
-0.5132721066474915,
0.568198025226593,
0.2214113473892212,
-0.4824370741844177,
0.21693077683448792,
0.06466853618621826,
-0.38102883100509644,
0.09744744747877121,
-0.5398077368736267,
-0.8085474371910095,
1.0918121337890625,
0.30852633714675903,
0.8470557332038879,
-0.20055614411830902,
0.8399280905723572,
0.47821271419525146,
0.042152952402830124,
-0.5604627132415771,
0.458256334066391,
-0.4411904811859131,
-0.999484121799469,
-0.0718696117401123,
-0.3732143044471741,
-0.9853470325469971,
-0.048828642815351486,
-0.07653719931840897,
-0.7752242684364319,
0.8650733232498169,
0.23230910301208496,
-0.18767189979553223,
0.409872829914093,
-0.4379015266895294,
0.7006255388259888,
0.24816781282424927,
0.10184430330991745,
-0.08207051455974579,
-0.6290912628173828,
0.06770520657300949,
-0.32207050919532776,
0.04369817301630974,
-0.45854347944259644,
-0.04559767618775368,
0.9799609780311584,
0.05048203095793724,
0.7141590714454651,
-0.38746178150177,
-0.21472999453544617,
0.3520183265209198,
-0.05881394445896149,
0.4068377614021301,
0.33765915036201477,
0.06788798421621323,
0.674454927444458,
0.2286321520805359,
-0.18107832968235016,
-0.3619460165500641,
0.9625799059867859,
-0.4496699273586273,
-0.37310144305229187,
-0.48050737380981445,
-0.32088735699653625,
-0.1850452721118927,
0.12317847460508347,
0.1527945101261139,
0.32076796889305115,
-0.6066517233848572,
-0.028506698086857796,
0.7682735323905945,
-0.1037391871213913,
0.31415531039237976,
0.4567427337169647,
-0.02545081451535225,
-0.531217098236084,
0.8917289972305298,
0.35809147357940674,
0.02097916603088379,
0.2204185426235199,
-0.43895265460014343,
-0.16804388165473938,
-0.5326452851295471,
-0.2538433372974396,
0.29996317625045776,
-0.8665761351585388,
-0.25207799673080444,
-1.0069770812988281,
-0.1388804167509079,
-0.36365658044815063,
-0.08200656622648239,
-0.5341319441795349,
-1.0376818180084229,
-0.39876165986061096,
-0.10346432030200958,
0.04562714323401451,
1.2214998006820679,
-0.29606685042381287,
0.20276571810245514,
-0.539440393447876,
0.6553800702095032,
0.23474550247192383,
0.7247278690338135,
-0.05633199214935303,
-0.24921657145023346,
-0.5069734454154968,
-0.10634955018758774,
-0.12343981862068176,
-0.7429845929145813,
-0.08796529471874237,
0.21444225311279297,
0.4914015829563141,
0.1795499473810196,
-0.10847321897745132,
0.23187443614006042,
-0.6947580575942993,
0.6393178701400757,
0.021168271079659462,
-0.7829137444496155,
0.32785218954086304,
-0.3277796506881714,
-0.21984727680683136,
0.5306567549705505,
0.44642356038093567,
-0.7207773327827454,
0.17151778936386108,
-0.9575675129890442,
-0.9998295307159424,
0.6787212491035461,
0.23673760890960693,
0.16646471619606018,
-0.15769605338573456,
0.7596498131752014,
0.5363603830337524,
0.3212738633155823,
-0.26579341292381287,
-0.30685481429100037,
0.1765405833721161,
-0.10568566620349884,
0.011361788958311081,
-0.6037358641624451,
0.15875251591205597,
-0.2446644902229309,
0.9255094528198242,
0.1565033346414566,
0.36432352662086487,
0.2518661916255951,
-0.1551923006772995,
0.02405370958149433,
0.31800463795661926,
0.04473781958222389,
0.6931832432746887,
-0.21731294691562653,
0.06284472346305847,
0.29394590854644775,
-0.6353638172149658,
0.19486281275749207,
0.4200538694858551,
-0.1012042760848999,
0.42385339736938477,
0.16990672051906586,
0.6397351026535034,
0.021610967814922333,
-0.17045989632606506,
0.4214579463005066,
-0.1645098328590393,
-0.21395739912986755,
-0.26323944330215454,
0.15448282659053802,
-0.00446723960340023,
0.27134519815444946,
0.056879471987485886,
-0.09328041225671768,
0.36967533826828003,
0.24441201984882355,
0.13657410442829132,
0.18879374861717224,
-0.3474135398864746,
-0.5456400513648987,
0.6046541929244995,
0.2693658173084259,
0.0408603698015213,
0.49346765875816345,
-0.47370320558547974,
-0.24666890501976013,
0.7831929326057434,
0.290627121925354,
1.0378338098526,
-0.3103913366794586,
0.024331364780664444,
0.4745464324951172,
0.2495332807302475,
-0.19706712663173676,
0.5266162157058716,
0.014154510572552681,
-0.5766274333000183,
-0.1963319629430771,
-0.6684492826461792,
-0.3651721477508545,
0.15310704708099365,
-0.7601029872894287,
0.45113834738731384,
-0.4341430068016052,
-0.6380804777145386,
0.23193983733654022,
0.1590195596218109,
-1.1854256391525269,
0.5031831860542297,
0.35680466890335083,
0.9619436860084534,
-0.7471510171890259,
0.6797322034835815,
1.100748062133789,
-0.051344819366931915,
-0.3755815625190735,
-0.2075108289718628,
-0.17885811626911163,
-0.27090632915496826,
0.8710260391235352,
0.26862281560897827,
0.2912212312221527,
0.054603174328804016,
-0.6046501398086548,
-0.9899978041648865,
1.0275516510009766,
0.06639904528856277,
-0.5721785426139832,
-0.14535333216190338,
0.18809780478477478,
0.46145904064178467,
-0.5333155393600464,
-0.28817257285118103,
0.5914397835731506,
0.6714697480201721,
-0.3581680357456207,
-1.1745282411575317,
-0.19504790008068085,
-0.2061985284090042,
0.32055336236953735,
0.34863507747650146,
-0.23819707334041595,
0.7567871809005737,
0.04790349677205086,
-0.49740928411483765,
-0.002568811411038041,
0.5016737580299377,
-0.18083274364471436,
0.41362643241882324,
0.3641919195652008,
0.9876664876937866,
0.7189129590988159,
-0.16778196394443512,
1.1265590190887451,
0.03226831927895546,
0.6356886029243469,
1.3671092987060547,
-0.2663147449493408,
0.6179543733596802,
0.40018466114997864,
-0.18459811806678772,
0.2032480090856552,
0.7538105845451355,
-0.1690622717142105,
0.5277543663978577,
0.3459680378437042,
-0.24006210267543793,
-0.22195972502231598,
-0.3963344991207123,
-0.4557013213634491,
0.23012349009513855,
0.5978894829750061,
-0.11922625452280045,
-0.3242000639438629,
-0.12179434299468994,
-0.12207771837711334,
-0.3748684227466583,
-0.2594722807407379,
0.939540445804596,
0.32481878995895386,
0.12417785823345184,
0.6824581027030945,
0.3570609986782074,
0.4292369782924652,
-0.317987322807312,
-0.346640944480896,
0.06500543653964996,
-0.008794410154223442,
-0.1944480538368225,
-0.4177587032318115,
0.21594783663749695,
0.022127404808998108,
-0.43572911620140076,
0.22379037737846375,
1.0715160369873047,
-0.2590744197368622,
-0.3871455788612366,
0.42204025387763977,
0.4053901135921478,
0.3073559105396271,
-0.2115928679704666,
-0.787653923034668,
-0.2005194127559662,
-0.4732874929904938,
-0.3254478871822357,
0.11349290609359741,
0.6099070310592651,
-0.23759277164936066,
0.3192109763622284,
0.3474404811859131,
0.10194852203130722,
0.06533993035554886,
0.031286049634218216,
0.9975712299346924,
-0.5719914436340332,
-0.37013283371925354,
-0.5081350803375244,
0.4270147979259491,
-0.08746425807476044,
-0.23314419388771057,
0.5564391613006592,
0.5879600048065186,
1.2477208375930786,
-0.12392006069421768,
0.8166560530662537,
-0.14967046678066254,
0.5590206384658813,
-0.33093512058258057,
0.4526461660861969,
-0.5262779593467712,
0.21192629635334015,
-0.14293581247329712,
-1.2902514934539795,
-0.3901628255844116,
0.34172484278678894,
-0.4210778772830963,
0.26323002576828003,
0.6482968330383301,
0.34136685729026794,
-0.5024810433387756,
-0.06141526624560356,
0.43129074573516846,
0.4191424548625946,
0.13958658277988434,
0.27972766757011414,
0.8821015357971191,
-0.497542142868042,
-0.14267395436763763,
-0.2874528169631958,
-0.002422272926196456,
-0.309466153383255,
-0.8422785401344299,
-0.9742367267608643,
-0.5908716320991516,
-0.40172019600868225,
-0.10876204073429108,
0.34717732667922974,
0.8704439401626587,
0.6875850558280945,
-1.0689945220947266,
0.06241781637072563,
0.09174288064241409,
-0.10578599572181702,
-0.04239934682846069,
-0.1806989461183548,
0.5550677180290222,
-0.30168506503105164,
-0.6454519033432007,
0.20952869951725006,
0.3155355751514435,
0.24844929575920105,
0.20244504511356354,
-0.08755169063806534,
-0.13337893784046173,
0.1598581075668335,
0.2118706852197647,
0.15001024305820465,
-0.7177942395210266,
-0.06243792921304703,
-0.2665080428123474,
0.039943795651197433,
0.1774970442056656,
0.7679572701454163,
-0.7217153310775757,
0.6209081411361694,
0.3389117419719696,
0.7833760380744934,
0.23308998346328735,
-0.08187184482812881,
0.27750974893569946,
-0.7367039322853088,
-0.0853213220834732,
0.32210665941238403,
0.27184242010116577,
0.4772602319717407,
-0.4759806990623474,
0.7840870022773743,
0.23738747835159302,
-0.5061735510826111,
-0.6191574931144714,
0.15861892700195312,
-0.7902147769927979,
-0.03692679852247238,
1.176883339881897,
-0.14417608082294464,
-0.01700693555176258,
-0.38399532437324524,
-0.06507662683725357,
0.13555172085762024,
-0.38470178842544556,
0.44801968336105347,
1.1077828407287598,
0.0768054872751236,
0.48857104778289795,
-0.9478630423545837,
0.6859404444694519,
0.032182179391384125,
-0.5929809808731079,
0.2854243218898773,
0.46187177300453186,
0.3241725564002991,
-0.07166236639022827,
0.6283507347106934,
-0.13264621794223785,
0.31035080552101135,
0.07392285019159317,
0.2894662916660309,
-0.04044388234615326,
-0.7889846563339233,
-0.6966286897659302,
-0.30443891882896423,
0.09209317713975906,
0.06794602423906326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18191v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18191v1
|
Clustering and Ranking: Diversity-preserved Instruction Selection through Expert-aligned Quality Estimation
| 2024-02-28T09:27:29 | 2024-02-28T09:27:29 |
Yuan Ge, Yilun Liu, Chi Hu, Weibin Meng, Shimin Tao, Xiaofeng Zhao, Hongxia Ma, Li Zhang, Hao Yang, Tong Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With contributions from the open-source community, a vast amount of
instruction tuning (IT) data has emerged. Given the significant resource
allocation required by training and evaluating models, it is advantageous to
have an efficient method for selecting high-quality IT data. However, existing
methods for instruction data selection have limitations such as relying on
fragile external APIs, being affected by biases in GPT models, or reducing the
diversity of the selected instruction dataset. In this paper, we propose an
industrial-friendly, expert-aligned and diversity-preserved instruction data
selection method: Clustering and Ranking (CaR). CaR consists of two steps. The
first step involves ranking instruction pairs using a scoring model that is
well aligned with expert preferences (achieving an accuracy of 84.25%). The
second step involves preserving dataset diversity through a clustering
process.In our experiment, CaR selected a subset containing only 1.96% of
Alpaca's IT data, yet the underlying AlpaCaR model trained on this subset
outperforms Alpaca by an average of 32.1% in GPT-4 evaluations. Furthermore,
our method utilizes small models (355M parameters) and requires only 11.2% of
the monetary cost compared to existing methods, making it easily deployable in
industrial scenarios.
|
[
-0.5587067604064941,
-0.35327818989753723,
0.2811132073402405,
0.019712835550308228,
-0.36794939637184143,
0.19500723481178284,
-0.2990051209926605,
-0.396090030670166,
-0.1077207624912262,
0.06894727051258087,
-0.32410725951194763,
-0.9717187285423279,
-0.6533915996551514,
-0.4080444574356079,
-0.430626779794693,
1.0056568384170532,
0.26512056589126587,
0.14498254656791687,
-0.10787349939346313,
-0.2398984730243683,
-0.7654302716255188,
-0.09687357395887375,
-0.7127884030342102,
0.0358506478369236,
0.4135630130767822,
0.6970723867416382,
0.6629103422164917,
1.306679606437683,
0.5349521040916443,
0.2904895544052124,
-0.11919526755809784,
0.1523367017507553,
-0.4321994483470917,
-0.24237434566020966,
-0.2053297907114029,
-0.4113509953022003,
-0.38058438897132874,
0.14957210421562195,
0.438693106174469,
0.735041618347168,
-0.42540279030799866,
0.31765738129615784,
0.09333383291959763,
0.7136507630348206,
-0.7921608686447144,
0.034563131630420685,
-0.7814933061599731,
0.0748489573597908,
-0.09432430565357208,
-0.02027519978582859,
-0.26613903045654297,
-0.9432479739189148,
-0.08267899602651596,
-0.4055311679840088,
0.517795741558075,
0.1786862015724182,
0.5980063676834106,
0.4876362383365631,
-0.20026648044586182,
-0.23359540104866028,
-0.6401965022087097,
1.1641433238983154,
-0.5181260704994202,
0.24232210218906403,
0.5043835639953613,
0.5943648815155029,
-0.07978509366512299,
-0.1719626635313034,
-0.21320317685604095,
0.09704909473657608,
0.11600246280431747,
0.4231230914592743,
0.26759302616119385,
-0.11852762848138809,
-0.17312584817409515,
0.6115917563438416,
-0.5041574835777283,
0.6536035537719727,
-0.5764827132225037,
0.02787487581372261,
0.5237670540809631,
0.02684357762336731,
-0.009392098523676395,
0.42312169075012207,
-0.33583274483680725,
-0.3817613422870636,
-0.5804238319396973,
0.07239003479480743,
0.3226635456085205,
0.2882603108882904,
0.30170032382011414,
0.2935017943382263,
-0.17345304787158966,
0.8326372504234314,
0.010865657590329647,
-0.32401230931282043,
0.06569278240203857,
0.034241579473018646,
-0.0454900898039341,
0.0460236519575119,
0.49856847524642944,
0.5087215900421143,
-0.2623080313205719,
-0.26954758167266846,
-0.15448829531669617,
0.17319554090499878,
0.3793797791004181,
-0.5081033706665039,
-0.1080029234290123,
-0.18475954234600067,
-0.4802464544773102,
-0.12137509137392044,
0.3911893665790558,
-1.028123140335083,
0.037324853241443634,
-0.2032555788755417,
0.2773837745189667,
-0.2875160574913025,
0.08640212565660477,
-0.16335123777389526,
-0.13174092769622803,
0.3205612301826477,
0.19883085787296295,
-1.2780784368515015,
0.06877557188272476,
0.906737208366394,
0.6932912468910217,
-0.36210110783576965,
-0.3470994830131531,
-0.3554474115371704,
0.28799423575401306,
-0.4212222993373871,
1.0099704265594482,
-0.8993284702301025,
-0.7849660515785217,
-0.3194200098514557,
-0.015733497217297554,
-0.20116019248962402,
-0.7922120094299316,
0.5800748467445374,
-0.6195172667503357,
0.057028092443943024,
-0.25277653336524963,
-0.5381812453269958,
-0.3044957220554352,
-0.022573817521333694,
-0.5404323935508728,
1.0917688608169556,
0.30231523513793945,
-0.42311254143714905,
0.753637969493866,
-0.24710236489772797,
-0.4137801229953766,
-0.13321182131767273,
-0.36145591735839844,
-0.7772651314735413,
-0.059752993285655975,
0.3298068046569824,
0.013121865689754486,
-0.12565989792346954,
0.01994362473487854,
-0.3519013226032257,
-0.6359018683433533,
-0.3932364583015442,
-0.3437708616256714,
0.4217727780342102,
0.2313081920146942,
-0.6226074695587158,
-0.04558641463518143,
-0.6716508269309998,
0.1819697618484497,
-0.3111071288585663,
-0.566964864730835,
-0.3388659358024597,
0.11163588613271713,
-0.6346659660339355,
0.03504724055528641,
0.313395231962204,
-0.5853007435798645,
0.30665862560272217,
-0.1770380288362503,
0.017495116218924522,
1.0216560363769531,
-0.2233850210905075,
0.4920682907104492,
-0.4267790615558624,
0.5177434682846069,
-0.04633042961359024,
0.6067250370979309,
0.40083047747612,
-0.793361485004425,
-0.9170386791229248,
-0.31649845838546753,
0.39339113235473633,
0.5405527353286743,
-0.3753531277179718,
0.8488450050354004,
-0.07011116296052933,
-0.8485383987426758,
-0.7929994463920593,
-0.012869053520262241,
0.2862634062767029,
0.5106741786003113,
0.6404992341995239,
-0.3506491184234619,
-0.03138774260878563,
-0.8810484409332275,
0.006735858041793108,
0.05721404403448105,
-0.09556173533201218,
0.2286687046289444,
-0.023536793887615204,
-0.24402232468128204,
0.99142986536026,
-0.6105219721794128,
-0.17740514874458313,
0.25281667709350586,
0.378266841173172,
0.3048900067806244,
0.855724036693573,
0.6675366759300232,
-0.29398903250694275,
-0.5233607888221741,
0.22043126821517944,
-0.4947032630443573,
0.09553045779466629,
0.38867565989494324,
-0.6627578735351562,
-0.06290015578269958,
0.07879576086997986,
-0.18160508573055267,
0.6918507218360901,
0.5373466610908508,
0.07113301008939743,
0.18644948303699493,
-0.16058945655822754,
0.5014380216598511,
-0.8315886855125427,
-0.2214696705341339,
-0.060971830040216446,
-0.007833784446120262,
-0.03142203390598297,
-0.09706979990005493,
0.02391025610268116,
0.05446970462799072,
-0.03923449292778969,
0.12102693319320679,
-0.4169708490371704,
-0.3587343096733093,
-0.4319005012512207,
-0.3084510266780853,
-0.05540565773844719,
0.4299275577068329,
0.0497596450150013,
0.9772646427154541,
0.5993650555610657,
-0.5532510876655579,
-0.007274971343576908,
0.3860636353492737,
-0.5430427193641663,
0.48446476459503174,
-0.43536221981048584,
0.348525732755661,
0.016162822023034096,
-0.10481170564889908,
-0.498593807220459,
0.14007656276226044,
0.07694055885076523,
-0.10501036792993546,
0.356515109539032,
-0.35475680232048035,
-0.08970466256141663,
-0.27590882778167725,
-0.2489878535270691,
0.40130650997161865,
0.7353136539459229,
-0.9452211856842041,
0.24900414049625397,
0.41740891337394714,
-0.4131944179534912,
-0.7221676707267761,
-0.3094642460346222,
-0.3442005515098572,
-0.2461375594139099,
-0.36200302839279175,
0.38644805550575256,
-0.28297391533851624,
0.24092291295528412,
0.031852420419454575,
-0.46903690695762634,
-0.34392452239990234,
0.07969691604375839,
0.05561418458819389,
0.4918156862258911,
-0.19275937974452972,
0.02867981046438217,
0.7806648015975952,
-0.25991785526275635,
-0.40324896574020386,
-0.2741975486278534,
0.24189242720603943,
-0.10828810185194016,
-0.6492700576782227,
-0.2041855901479721,
0.5634727478027344,
0.3230399489402771,
-0.35099586844444275,
0.8754078149795532,
0.7713484764099121,
-0.0105041628703475,
-0.4246103763580322,
-0.6106190085411072,
-0.15749087929725647,
-0.5770158171653748,
0.1407308578491211,
0.11909749358892441,
-0.9052411913871765,
0.12387215346097946,
-0.032464854419231415,
0.4111362397670746,
0.4346735179424286,
0.27093157172203064,
-0.16432005167007446,
1.313711404800415,
0.6052590012550354,
-0.3733411133289337,
0.6327247023582458,
-0.2584318518638611,
0.3227677643299103,
-0.511136531829834,
-0.33853664994239807,
-0.818375825881958,
-0.4811086356639862,
-0.5329821109771729,
-0.2830599248409271,
0.8372759222984314,
-0.036922771483659744,
-0.2347954511642456,
0.13953061401844025,
-1.0309127569198608,
0.7794857025146484,
0.9680674076080322,
0.23948828876018524,
0.17285050451755524,
0.23628760874271393,
0.3583926558494568,
0.20736321806907654,
-0.7244690656661987,
-0.5149866938591003,
0.7765955328941345,
0.10675451904535294,
0.8290917873382568,
-0.036446310579776764,
0.7658143043518066,
0.3797050416469574,
0.4021969735622406,
-0.6892809271812439,
0.42069265246391296,
-0.6424712538719177,
-0.34512093663215637,
-0.3545739948749542,
-0.5535421967506409,
-1.0211901664733887,
0.010244744829833508,
-0.07429821044206619,
-0.5283141136169434,
0.4337184727191925,
0.1282317340373993,
-0.5274739861488342,
0.2665269076824188,
-0.7197413444519043,
0.734571635723114,
-0.2781650424003601,
-0.13145889341831207,
-0.5258743166923523,
-0.4481567144393921,
0.14118452370166779,
0.07020661979913712,
0.12917250394821167,
-0.19028790295124054,
0.1167542114853859,
0.8536435961723328,
-0.6731348037719727,
0.529785692691803,
-0.28738805651664734,
0.0876811295747757,
0.2114119529724121,
-0.2571124732494354,
0.15029844641685486,
-0.18965394794940948,
-0.4530588388442993,
0.30571115016937256,
-0.14845620095729828,
-0.5330129265785217,
-0.6611969470977783,
0.9387718439102173,
-1.0231024026870728,
-0.5356404185295105,
-0.07299096882343292,
-0.4191089868545532,
-0.28351345658302307,
0.08062852919101715,
0.40814802050590515,
0.44491803646087646,
0.10813895612955093,
0.2994263172149658,
0.6259274482727051,
-0.1374824494123459,
0.4794965088367462,
0.4720704257488251,
0.45720502734184265,
-0.49332305788993835,
1.3725180625915527,
0.3486027121543884,
0.11303359270095825,
0.1993873566389084,
0.26686620712280273,
-0.0764569342136383,
-0.7736807465553284,
-0.5909324288368225,
-0.08632584661245346,
-0.7734972834587097,
-0.4059908986091614,
-0.36392539739608765,
-0.24680867791175842,
-0.12322410196065903,
-0.35965678095817566,
-0.4701032340526581,
-0.5275750160217285,
-0.36115339398384094,
-0.19298139214515686,
0.2695974111557007,
0.7309552431106567,
0.04971862584352493,
0.5444491505622864,
-0.8401879668235779,
-0.017100302502512932,
0.6965510249137878,
0.7179074883460999,
-0.034145839512348175,
-0.30087921023368835,
-0.6594330072402954,
-0.11026237905025482,
-0.33426856994628906,
-0.6855236291885376,
0.1333545446395874,
0.30573195219039917,
0.8720474243164062,
0.5431416630744934,
-0.04224028438329697,
0.6918689608573914,
-0.3560452461242676,
0.5717594623565674,
-0.12384922802448273,
-0.7020615339279175,
0.5604487657546997,
-0.22262023389339447,
-0.040058378130197525,
1.0813981294631958,
0.36912721395492554,
0.11499953269958496,
-0.46151140332221985,
-0.42190566658973694,
-1.03046715259552,
0.6800680756568909,
-0.08773079514503479,
-0.3112833797931671,
-0.03578156232833862,
0.2405373901128769,
0.7525122165679932,
0.39392703771591187,
-0.3265765905380249,
-0.128805473446846,
-0.4512034058570862,
-0.5411189794540405,
0.300229549407959,
0.13840682804584503,
-0.11337421834468842,
-0.4892351031303406,
0.9533286094665527,
-0.0107811214402318,
0.22653275728225708,
-0.3781261444091797,
0.1275867223739624,
-0.04875592887401581,
0.19243250787258148,
0.301722913980484,
0.7144516110420227,
-0.19052480161190033,
-0.2620534598827362,
0.015542957000434399,
-0.512419581413269,
0.22752641141414642,
0.0689452514052391,
-0.34194934368133545,
-0.11005993187427521,
-0.14990033209323883,
0.6569311618804932,
0.08660919964313507,
-0.21857962012290955,
0.31212878227233887,
-0.06862598657608032,
0.1738511621952057,
-0.053582120686769485,
0.7212148904800415,
-0.2536362409591675,
0.16813066601753235,
0.3278958797454834,
0.18316242098808289,
0.372232049703598,
-0.24139763414859772,
0.014044037088751793,
0.4593012034893036,
-0.10342413187026978,
0.06927535682916641,
0.43079739809036255,
0.28658393025398254,
-0.16320839524269104,
0.7493127584457397,
-0.3221449851989746,
-0.21667110919952393,
1.0097891092300415,
0.3147621154785156,
0.7767043113708496,
-0.57085782289505,
0.2695651054382324,
0.5648697018623352,
0.31422141194343567,
-0.2946038544178009,
-0.04343612864613533,
-0.06053578853607178,
-0.4053671360015869,
-0.008482805453240871,
-0.6030135750770569,
-0.7011568546295166,
-0.18866440653800964,
-1.031506896018982,
0.17800071835517883,
-0.5945538878440857,
-0.18740957975387573,
-0.44481271505355835,
-0.23739178478717804,
-0.6175204515457153,
0.5235844254493713,
-0.10718347877264023,
0.8007634878158569,
-0.8538872599601746,
0.7665271759033203,
0.5323050022125244,
-0.1402323842048645,
-0.8782461285591125,
-0.09839425981044769,
-0.33913832902908325,
-0.7257228493690491,
0.01846453920006752,
0.274348646402359,
-0.17836065590381622,
0.18635956943035126,
-0.4587453007698059,
-0.9821368455886841,
1.2742472887039185,
0.32987457513809204,
-0.6706539392471313,
0.1022292971611023,
-0.02726581133902073,
0.17624536156654358,
-0.2782934010028839,
0.4345056414604187,
0.954153835773468,
0.4740158021450043,
0.13135139644145966,
-0.5123588442802429,
-0.36387941241264343,
-0.34703847765922546,
-0.04074455052614212,
0.22387877106666565,
-1.0399519205093384,
0.8089065551757812,
0.09336479753255844,
-0.09997105598449707,
0.05702124536037445,
0.7311280965805054,
0.3920034170150757,
0.43541911244392395,
0.7128643989562988,
0.6004983186721802,
0.9205178022384644,
-0.1420191377401352,
0.6615389585494995,
-0.3739885687828064,
0.19156993925571442,
0.8877632021903992,
-0.009691225364804268,
0.694374144077301,
0.0013702462892979383,
-0.19242163002490997,
0.750817060470581,
1.0011581182479858,
-0.3620564639568329,
0.7976349592208862,
-0.3254278302192688,
-0.37959131598472595,
-0.17014659941196442,
0.02892071194946766,
-0.7370527386665344,
0.5509966015815735,
0.2243523895740509,
-0.15399585664272308,
-0.11292725801467896,
-0.2857779264450073,
-0.22989845275878906,
-0.17588600516319275,
-0.41867199540138245,
0.9494917988777161,
-0.22779040038585663,
-0.854318380355835,
0.4288390576839447,
0.020273955538868904,
0.5369253158569336,
-0.4861338138580322,
-0.10916047543287277,
-0.4363931119441986,
-0.083816297352314,
-0.2759833037853241,
-0.44315123558044434,
0.1391463279724121,
-0.02969481237232685,
-0.41462433338165283,
0.19311358034610748,
0.33770543336868286,
-0.634469211101532,
-0.7151732444763184,
0.017822520807385445,
0.17660188674926758,
0.08031128346920013,
0.33223551511764526,
-0.39466729760169983,
0.011836708523333073,
-0.1271125227212906,
0.06234144791960716,
0.6053977012634277,
-0.018372299149632454,
-0.12245310097932816,
0.3509269058704376,
0.3062860667705536,
-0.05811222270131111,
0.1563808172941208,
0.027279730886220932,
0.9143756628036499,
-0.4757358431816101,
-0.7620368599891663,
-0.3756692409515381,
0.45151787996292114,
-0.18871955573558807,
-0.11338548362255096,
0.48880085349082947,
0.5306696891784668,
0.8599275350570679,
0.0056551615707576275,
0.9361146092414856,
0.23748113214969635,
0.5907860994338989,
-0.5325801968574524,
0.6478664875030518,
-0.2356245219707489,
0.37736213207244873,
-0.17298927903175354,
-1.0986367464065552,
0.22616879642009735,
0.7715146541595459,
-0.5314109325408936,
0.3882990777492523,
0.4066493511199951,
0.7817009687423706,
-0.30536365509033203,
0.3112422823905945,
0.11373233050107956,
-0.2117043137550354,
0.14354416728019714,
0.33950406312942505,
0.6968250870704651,
0.05903932824730873,
0.4222407042980194,
-0.5339742302894592,
-0.7563968896865845,
-0.1870878040790558,
-0.8284004926681519,
-0.6923683881759644,
-0.03431950509548187,
-0.3695307970046997,
0.27071690559387207,
-0.0032445306424051523,
0.8849500417709351,
0.955536961555481,
-0.8945013880729675,
-0.26741236448287964,
0.1758088320493698,
0.23747193813323975,
-0.6907949447631836,
-0.17889109253883362,
0.5378686189651489,
-0.23506660759449005,
-0.7297019362449646,
0.8738953471183777,
0.14075911045074463,
-0.08936426043510437,
0.014574768953025341,
0.11669525504112244,
0.27858710289001465,
-0.05854405090212822,
0.3093200623989105,
0.20719106495380402,
-0.20413874089717865,
-0.4033449590206146,
-0.24736899137496948,
0.14792972803115845,
0.25713348388671875,
0.5344304442405701,
-0.48846521973609924,
0.34681236743927,
0.18087662756443024,
0.800860583782196,
0.3070603311061859,
0.3510630428791046,
0.4628045856952667,
-0.6875631809234619,
0.05494733154773712,
0.24716903269290924,
0.22328773140907288,
0.3404698073863983,
-0.5290595889091492,
0.5195117592811584,
0.13294632732868195,
-0.9419443607330322,
-0.38277679681777954,
0.054191939532756805,
-0.859142005443573,
-0.0969209149479866,
0.5965163707733154,
-0.1752094179391861,
-0.2938924729824066,
0.05507165193557739,
-0.13780267536640167,
0.5062065720558167,
-0.5433269739151001,
1.4445749521255493,
0.24985593557357788,
-0.15514518320560455,
0.09590426087379456,
-0.3832952380180359,
0.22621670365333557,
0.45492786169052124,
-0.9626041054725647,
-0.4659270644187927,
0.5118874311447144,
0.13633351027965546,
-0.10469363629817963,
0.1010221466422081,
0.04911773279309273,
0.4188444912433624,
-0.13001243770122528,
0.15246707201004028,
-0.09630367904901505,
-0.5173054933547974,
-0.08063499629497528,
0.2974836826324463,
0.1926543265581131,
-0.6144915819168091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18179v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18179v1
|
Challenges in Pre-Training Graph Neural Networks for Context-Based Fake News Detection: An Evaluation of Current Strategies and Resource Limitations
| 2024-02-28T09:10:25 | 2024-02-28T09:10:25 |
Gregor Donabauer, Udo Kruschwitz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-training of neural networks has recently revolutionized the field of
Natural Language Processing (NLP) and has before demonstrated its effectiveness
in computer vision. At the same time, advances around the detection of fake
news were mainly driven by the context-based paradigm, where different types of
signals (e.g. from social media) form graph-like structures that hold
contextual information apart from the news article to classify. We propose to
merge these two developments by applying pre-training of Graph Neural Networks
(GNNs) in the domain of context-based fake news detection. Our experiments
provide an evaluation of different pre-training strategies for graph-based
misinformation detection and demonstrate that transfer learning does currently
not lead to significant improvements over training a model from scratch in the
domain. We argue that a major current issue is the lack of suitable large-scale
resources that can be used for pre-training.
|
[
-0.4341242015361786,
-0.9886109232902527,
0.48224887251853943,
0.04869266226887703,
-0.48928019404411316,
0.20805160701274872,
-0.004312839824706316,
-0.5892056822776794,
0.4508401155471802,
0.3538781702518463,
-0.5297468304634094,
-0.20947280526161194,
-0.9634020924568176,
0.11686569452285767,
-0.6029890179634094,
0.8798437118530273,
-0.1350802481174469,
-0.0002171229716623202,
-0.19851146638393402,
-0.09884791821241379,
-0.33198899030685425,
-0.7586097121238708,
-0.7962163090705872,
0.005087669473141432,
0.6619071364402771,
0.02508862130343914,
0.5461334586143494,
0.21627312898635864,
0.180824875831604,
0.2881418764591217,
0.16096407175064087,
0.3872191905975342,
-0.4430420398712158,
-0.48742610216140747,
-0.005513136740773916,
-0.04315023869276047,
-0.1306779384613037,
0.3856475055217743,
0.7283446788787842,
0.5740591287612915,
0.2746853530406952,
0.0904008224606514,
-0.002275887643918395,
0.4219001531600952,
-0.6781353950500488,
0.004587136674672365,
-0.7123251557350159,
0.15086333453655243,
-0.128874272108078,
-0.434234619140625,
-0.3625888228416443,
-0.3713047206401825,
0.3223734200000763,
-0.7544764280319214,
0.30371788144111633,
0.11564057320356369,
1.1260930299758911,
-0.14448362588882446,
-0.6795945763587952,
-0.37295863032341003,
-0.6457462310791016,
0.27419641613960266,
-0.6475158929824829,
0.3367685079574585,
0.23363736271858215,
0.28743231296539307,
-0.11386861652135849,
-1.0807456970214844,
-0.7310582995414734,
-0.11965487897396088,
-0.20948459208011627,
-0.08417042344808578,
-0.3832036256790161,
-0.08974526822566986,
0.19803600013256073,
-0.1239846795797348,
-0.6909669637680054,
0.13252319395542145,
-0.4449603259563446,
-0.6147376894950867,
0.32323673367500305,
-0.40419191122055054,
0.432839959859848,
-0.3362675607204437,
-0.34270721673965454,
0.058300428092479706,
-0.5378642678260803,
-0.13686272501945496,
0.550369143486023,
0.44748759269714355,
-0.011410501785576344,
0.08479031175374985,
-0.25082480907440186,
0.8741490840911865,
0.0032114312052726746,
0.013072682544589043,
0.4087681472301483,
-0.5082312226295471,
-0.3379519581794739,
0.1461334526538849,
0.8205469250679016,
0.17176178097724915,
0.34052643179893494,
-0.17782147228717804,
-0.008166659623384476,
0.21001605689525604,
0.5379056334495544,
-0.66611647605896,
-0.06461671739816666,
-0.316648930311203,
-0.501399040222168,
-0.48255544900894165,
0.01648998260498047,
-0.46869874000549316,
-0.19473958015441895,
-0.43489590287208557,
0.5516029000282288,
-0.20083864033222198,
-0.297112375497818,
-0.03568118438124657,
-0.22474056482315063,
-0.20106230676174164,
0.45822227001190186,
-0.44617927074432373,
0.15825708210468292,
0.26115837693214417,
0.911880612373352,
0.0431302934885025,
-0.2882680594921112,
-0.5593771934509277,
-0.1770755797624588,
-0.3775081932544708,
0.8866348266601562,
-0.39269423484802246,
-0.08717531710863113,
0.07173372805118561,
0.13418477773666382,
-0.19388175010681152,
-0.4771939814090729,
0.3328099548816681,
-0.7681839466094971,
0.24327139556407928,
-0.41574782133102417,
-0.2516120672225952,
-0.17568300664424896,
0.5013712644577026,
-0.7809193730354309,
0.6894146800041199,
0.5319539904594421,
-0.8874256014823914,
0.4212023913860321,
-0.5324265360832214,
-0.8719658255577087,
0.0025523228105157614,
-0.10085520893335342,
-0.35669365525245667,
0.0423019714653492,
0.3553178310394287,
0.26944589614868164,
0.294295996427536,
0.19421742856502533,
-0.3828859329223633,
-0.42806246876716614,
0.03885120153427124,
-0.5986119508743286,
0.9045764803886414,
0.2834305763244629,
-0.3854239284992218,
0.17585906386375427,
-0.576014518737793,
0.04614894837141037,
0.1143660768866539,
-0.2496049553155899,
-0.23579417169094086,
-0.23192395269870758,
-0.22611753642559052,
0.3983486294746399,
-0.08176928758621216,
-0.33069998025894165,
-0.02556350827217102,
-0.10328244417905807,
0.5602800846099854,
0.6709764003753662,
-0.12843716144561768,
0.49534058570861816,
-0.11158367246389389,
0.27415406703948975,
0.2909940481185913,
0.24347779154777527,
-0.01717674545943737,
-0.36609920859336853,
-0.5391499996185303,
0.19422779977321625,
0.4269106090068817,
0.6491815447807312,
-1.196645975112915,
0.46089091897010803,
-0.31957781314849854,
-0.08882718533277512,
-0.06783880293369293,
0.012304162606596947,
0.21156640350818634,
0.9513177871704102,
0.5289890170097351,
-0.3962740898132324,
-0.7883546948432922,
-0.8282687067985535,
-0.5817232131958008,
0.03938459977507591,
0.1472492516040802,
0.2334328293800354,
0.6272267699241638,
-0.15005967020988464,
1.034491777420044,
-0.08317723125219345,
-0.4050907790660858,
-0.2300613969564438,
0.11670557409524918,
-0.03717534616589546,
0.3352939486503601,
0.761820375919342,
-1.1333669424057007,
-0.5343198180198669,
-0.11498614400625229,
-0.7933773994445801,
0.14242692291736603,
0.022409791126847267,
0.1561967432498932,
0.41977179050445557,
0.7737804651260376,
-0.621204674243927,
0.8715398907661438,
0.5659096240997314,
-0.14484843611717224,
0.7839759588241577,
-0.02243262529373169,
0.28378984332084656,
-0.9274615049362183,
-0.08448442071676254,
0.12453611195087433,
-0.5917346477508545,
-0.9025894999504089,
-0.4846932888031006,
-0.10514921694993973,
-0.27560022473335266,
-0.6577886939048767,
0.5202770829200745,
-0.42532408237457275,
-0.3035115599632263,
-0.4562146067619324,
0.3067900240421295,
0.06962355226278305,
0.2562809884548187,
-0.05456124246120453,
0.5068802833557129,
0.2961430251598358,
-0.652320921421051,
0.5702515840530396,
-0.07590777426958084,
-0.488200843334198,
0.3937190771102905,
-0.28130054473876953,
0.18410846590995789,
-0.17800502479076385,
0.9188931584358215,
-0.6991985440254211,
-0.19907352328300476,
0.7471752166748047,
-0.6001800298690796,
0.35845285654067993,
-0.2600669860839844,
-0.5901773571968079,
-0.8908764719963074,
0.07295084744691849,
0.4021543264389038,
0.27572035789489746,
-0.504787027835846,
0.5924818515777588,
0.09210606664419174,
0.207784503698349,
-0.811352550983429,
-0.5736239552497864,
0.24263639748096466,
-0.06751489639282227,
-0.6501935720443726,
0.3602464199066162,
0.34754329919815063,
0.07322394102811813,
0.5632829070091248,
-0.3760971426963806,
-0.12419744580984116,
0.19453459978103638,
-0.08799867331981659,
0.10103727132081985,
-0.33385515213012695,
0.05837113410234451,
-0.27414825558662415,
-0.055760838091373444,
0.05958946421742439,
-0.7319074273109436,
0.5336490869522095,
-0.1819234937429428,
-0.28440847992897034,
-0.8014757633209229,
0.21305736899375916,
0.19746147096157074,
-0.058111853897571564,
0.8005553483963013,
0.6819182634353638,
-0.5543525218963623,
-0.259851336479187,
-0.5632195472717285,
-0.22531075775623322,
-0.41512981057167053,
0.6271141171455383,
0.2531081736087799,
-0.8609554767608643,
0.2969353199005127,
-0.3674815893173218,
-0.5918707847595215,
0.45418521761894226,
0.021907983347773552,
-0.11881262809038162,
0.7974578738212585,
0.5066888332366943,
-0.25664302706718445,
0.6962068676948547,
-0.2858661711215973,
0.5116074085235596,
-0.4191505014896393,
-0.008407793939113617,
-0.2395438253879547,
-0.47369372844696045,
-0.155155748128891,
-0.20579984784126282,
0.03737759217619896,
0.28545087575912476,
-0.25227758288383484,
0.1845010370016098,
-0.4433709681034088,
0.5533403158187866,
0.614812433719635,
0.17755459249019623,
0.1413234919309616,
0.38424035906791687,
0.185818612575531,
0.31931746006011963,
-1.0141164064407349,
-0.2753499746322632,
1.1074987649917603,
0.046673621982336044,
0.13743683695793152,
-0.4564215838909149,
0.23585698008537292,
0.5644408464431763,
0.7366463541984558,
-0.4507330656051636,
0.3885851800441742,
-0.27422666549682617,
-0.5363079905509949,
-0.3572758138179779,
-0.7621833682060242,
-0.785750687122345,
0.2938728630542755,
-0.37632569670677185,
-0.670870304107666,
-0.05295325070619583,
0.25052496790885925,
-0.2600776255130768,
0.7624830603599548,
-0.810962438583374,
1.042380452156067,
-0.36786016821861267,
0.19294393062591553,
0.027615226805210114,
-0.7109573483467102,
0.22109082341194153,
-0.14987479150295258,
0.3772868812084198,
0.10044866055250168,
0.5160984396934509,
0.6879605054855347,
-0.3764176368713379,
0.9663445353507996,
-0.571071982383728,
0.3811793327331543,
0.6176679134368896,
-0.28471019864082336,
0.6042241454124451,
-0.01026049442589283,
0.4040277302265167,
0.3172874450683594,
-0.38295531272888184,
-0.37614795565605164,
-0.5689969658851624,
0.4841545820236206,
-0.6158319115638733,
-0.6115090250968933,
-0.4217113256454468,
-0.4064931273460388,
-0.24507147073745728,
0.5804203748703003,
0.8209750652313232,
0.40757718682289124,
-0.26511964201927185,
0.24156837165355682,
0.31168121099472046,
-0.1282811313867569,
0.41937515139579773,
0.12759080529212952,
-0.258407324552536,
-0.2552991211414337,
0.8736140131950378,
0.6947418451309204,
-0.03344275802373886,
-0.19727016985416412,
0.08699847012758255,
-0.22651717066764832,
-0.8224983811378479,
-0.3529326021671295,
0.043089352548122406,
-0.6717842221260071,
-0.19054953753948212,
-0.42812830209732056,
-0.5943342447280884,
-0.6708252429962158,
-0.1690538376569748,
-0.22247639298439026,
-0.00308319553732872,
-0.5739391446113586,
-0.04376824572682381,
-0.17289520800113678,
0.625270664691925,
-0.07529804855585098,
0.638439416885376,
-0.7050354480743408,
0.44318288564682007,
0.2148127257823944,
0.34777048230171204,
-0.01574796438217163,
-0.4725586771965027,
-0.3555595278739929,
0.39368516206741333,
-0.26783350110054016,
-0.8580878376960754,
0.44797447323799133,
-0.12051685154438019,
0.5487494468688965,
0.46614739298820496,
0.04164542257785797,
0.4927053451538086,
-0.4053671360015869,
0.6136263608932495,
0.41374292969703674,
-0.8073210716247559,
0.5885561108589172,
-0.25609293580055237,
-0.09295149147510529,
0.4253062605857849,
0.8848844170570374,
-0.43536365032196045,
0.07355731725692749,
-0.7676364183425903,
-0.44719183444976807,
0.74693763256073,
0.17430129647254944,
0.2788207530975342,
0.08734458684921265,
0.5361834764480591,
-0.1615813672542572,
0.3678319752216339,
-1.0380173921585083,
-0.1375446319580078,
-0.6771668791770935,
0.12567412853240967,
-0.21200893819332123,
-0.06033536046743393,
-0.22050026059150696,
-0.4118717610836029,
0.5411636829376221,
-0.26545244455337524,
0.08707626163959503,
0.2672579884529114,
-0.36199653148651123,
0.17597761750221252,
-0.18246786296367645,
0.6660553812980652,
0.8630897402763367,
0.041348256170749664,
0.020211663097143173,
0.2245144248008728,
-0.5291738510131836,
0.13010115921497345,
0.13352210819721222,
-0.28587606549263,
0.23544831573963165,
0.5817270874977112,
1.1730166673660278,
0.08064652234315872,
-0.08035174757242203,
0.973352313041687,
0.0765652135014534,
-0.7160106897354126,
-0.4237493574619293,
-0.23384374380111694,
0.015237176790833473,
0.1685866415500641,
0.6333708763122559,
0.5461700558662415,
-0.14784306287765503,
-0.5934087634086609,
0.1671431064605713,
0.42298829555511475,
-0.47308337688446045,
-0.4952373206615448,
0.3419511616230011,
0.13566936552524567,
-0.3583788275718689,
0.8486778736114502,
-0.32484057545661926,
-0.7822115421295166,
0.7532387375831604,
0.7470360994338989,
0.527131199836731,
-0.10254266113042831,
0.5495415329933167,
0.040571022778749466,
0.45136576890945435,
-0.21393851935863495,
-0.1451476812362671,
0.21473143994808197,
-1.1739224195480347,
-0.39867693185806274,
-0.3225870430469513,
0.09026456624269485,
0.6670902967453003,
-0.15395286679267883,
0.18795911967754364,
-0.6462880969047546,
-0.4854862689971924,
-0.071330226957798,
-0.06178716570138931,
-0.7064196467399597,
0.370981365442276,
0.24051374197006226,
0.8387722969055176,
-0.849187433719635,
0.734980583190918,
0.3829171061515808,
-0.1587478518486023,
-0.6464548110961914,
-0.07153633236885071,
0.15689773857593536,
-0.49626535177230835,
0.9227620959281921,
0.524742841720581,
-0.015795698389410973,
0.016613200306892395,
-0.7789134979248047,
-0.8608232140541077,
0.8318263292312622,
0.7389599680900574,
-0.3698883652687073,
-0.5884458422660828,
0.09409692883491516,
0.39494454860687256,
-0.6194942593574524,
-0.2518845200538635,
0.11879183351993561,
0.5072540044784546,
0.03212490305304527,
-0.6751760840415955,
-0.03349720314145088,
-0.100758858025074,
-0.177254319190979,
-0.09514496475458145,
-0.4766707718372345,
1.0281157493591309,
0.08787047117948532,
-0.5664038062095642,
-0.5384860038757324,
0.7148715853691101,
-0.20473377406597137,
0.6220436692237854,
0.7355399131774902,
0.6134886741638184,
0.7674381732940674,
-0.1498667150735855,
1.1441118717193604,
-0.07447957247495651,
0.2943854331970215,
1.026039719581604,
-0.16809968650341034,
0.4920862019062042,
0.13731157779693604,
0.08315365016460419,
0.7761839628219604,
0.842353105545044,
-0.03468969836831093,
0.36532825231552124,
0.3708370327949524,
-0.20797006785869598,
-0.19840537011623383,
0.016990063712000847,
-0.5695066452026367,
0.28640589118003845,
0.33648911118507385,
-0.36047691106796265,
-0.3456387519836426,
0.25729578733444214,
0.06903623044490814,
-0.10618723928928375,
-0.6388519406318665,
0.28123795986175537,
0.08019278943538666,
-0.314730703830719,
0.37984296679496765,
-0.23759277164936066,
0.6893523335456848,
-0.7911863923072815,
0.2905629873275757,
0.09776604175567627,
-0.10667112469673157,
-0.3589167296886444,
-0.29176729917526245,
0.5240442156791687,
-0.3354291617870331,
-0.07350324094295502,
-0.13319635391235352,
1.3211625814437866,
-0.10151457786560059,
-0.2546021342277527,
0.5547096729278564,
0.5870590806007385,
-0.1599145382642746,
-0.5369191765785217,
-0.49225473403930664,
-0.11650563776493073,
-0.14210624992847443,
-0.39579254388809204,
0.4187513589859009,
0.3640894293785095,
-0.20908929407596588,
0.39070063829421997,
1.1380109786987305,
0.163069948554039,
0.1486779749393463,
0.0733301118016243,
1.075184941291809,
-0.35481610894203186,
-0.8006881475448608,
-0.7529007792472839,
0.0224316343665123,
-0.389414519071579,
-0.2222917079925537,
0.7641369700431824,
0.30234986543655396,
1.2216795682907104,
-0.09484772384166718,
0.9158480167388916,
0.22382621467113495,
0.24408921599388123,
-0.5852037668228149,
0.91096431016922,
-0.5480697751045227,
-0.15583425760269165,
-0.28298419713974,
-1.0544911623001099,
-0.40643030405044556,
0.521385908126831,
-0.3944990634918213,
0.3062889873981476,
0.866716206073761,
0.26287707686424255,
-0.21877726912498474,
0.04489856958389282,
0.17057745158672333,
0.06279749423265457,
0.14701315760612488,
0.4051250219345093,
0.844197690486908,
-0.3114260137081146,
0.6820763945579529,
0.06642910093069077,
-0.049155961722135544,
-0.44895052909851074,
-1.0402966737747192,
-0.7609432935714722,
-0.45824235677719116,
-0.12776465713977814,
-0.6159213781356812,
0.06412722915410995,
0.4141767919063568,
1.0980638265609741,
-0.5577815771102905,
0.3788639008998871,
-0.17903882265090942,
0.18742984533309937,
0.026787491515278816,
-0.1879129707813263,
0.3795625865459442,
-0.4089503288269043,
-0.20954996347427368,
0.4392339885234833,
0.0820326879620552,
0.3117115795612335,
-0.04382525756955147,
-0.008321138098835945,
-0.4221627712249756,
0.099875807762146,
0.6919612288475037,
0.6183220148086548,
-0.4071896970272064,
-0.7681815028190613,
-0.22386790812015533,
-0.07974507659673691,
0.16209104657173157,
0.9447584748268127,
-1.1260738372802734,
0.1990123987197876,
0.30144181847572327,
0.8146296143531799,
0.5799222588539124,
0.2211538702249527,
0.2653732895851135,
-0.9227688312530518,
0.33725759387016296,
0.12413009256124496,
0.2389623373746872,
0.3140799403190613,
-0.4744405746459961,
0.2898646593093872,
0.8604726791381836,
-0.2615197002887726,
-0.8708537220954895,
0.3113957345485687,
-0.6544356346130371,
-0.662230372428894,
0.8710473775863647,
-0.06939414143562317,
-0.3823446035385132,
-0.2966060936450958,
0.005601159296929836,
0.44526493549346924,
0.018266014754772186,
0.49594658613204956,
0.7940261960029602,
-0.004426382947713137,
0.16275030374526978,
-0.5870050191879272,
0.7922516465187073,
-0.04957983270287514,
-0.9118894338607788,
-0.44750839471817017,
0.4514475464820862,
0.32057633996009827,
0.5241906046867371,
1.0336440801620483,
0.10174565762281418,
0.26178884506225586,
0.14861242473125458,
-0.3154333233833313,
-0.4884258806705475,
-0.7825095057487488,
-0.17651647329330444,
0.2548297643661499,
-0.7340901494026184,
-0.02011592872440815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18169v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18169v2
|
MIKO: Multimodal Intention Knowledge Distillation from Large Language Models for Social-Media Commonsense Discovery
| 2024-02-28T08:57:42 | 2024-02-29T06:45:56 |
Feihong Lu, Weiqi Wang, Yangyifei Luo, Ziqin Zhu, Qingyun Sun, Baixuan Xu, Haochen Shi, Shiqi Gao, Qian Li, Yangqiu Song, Jianxin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social media has become a ubiquitous tool for connecting with others, staying
updated with news, expressing opinions, and finding entertainment. However,
understanding the intention behind social media posts remains challenging due
to the implicitness of intentions in social media posts, the need for
cross-modality understanding of both text and images, and the presence of noisy
information such as hashtags, misspelled words, and complicated abbreviations.
To address these challenges, we present MIKO, a Multimodal Intention Kowledge
DistillatiOn framework that collaboratively leverages a Large Language Model
(LLM) and a Multimodal Large Language Model (MLLM) to uncover users'
intentions. Specifically, we use an MLLM to interpret the image and an LLM to
extract key information from the text and finally instruct the LLM again to
generate intentions. By applying MIKO to publicly available social media
datasets, we construct an intention knowledge base featuring 1,372K intentions
rooted in 137,287 posts. We conduct a two-stage annotation to verify the
quality of the generated knowledge and benchmark the performance of widely used
LLMs for intention generation. We further apply MIKO to a sarcasm detection
dataset and distill a student model to demonstrate the downstream benefits of
applying intention knowledge.
|
[
-0.3396014869213104,
-0.735829770565033,
1.03200364112854,
0.4227902591228485,
-0.5717470645904541,
-0.16930118203163147,
-0.36161816120147705,
-0.22914035618305206,
0.3799564838409424,
0.3368851840496063,
-0.8273391723632812,
-0.6252785325050354,
-0.844836413860321,
-0.09064801037311554,
-0.2553428113460541,
0.9649458527565002,
-0.0336901918053627,
-0.0004706906038336456,
-0.12223763018846512,
-0.1105172261595726,
-0.3714026212692261,
-0.0862511396408081,
-0.5985410809516907,
-0.2916962504386902,
0.9661446213722229,
0.673015832901001,
0.5695276856422424,
-0.1822742521762848,
0.28999194502830505,
0.20203879475593567,
0.19567318260669708,
0.5952565670013428,
-0.8622111678123474,
0.11089115589857101,
-0.25453370809555054,
-0.21770328283309937,
-0.1596173793077469,
0.02243749424815178,
0.5878148078918457,
0.28229179978370667,
0.20774784684181213,
0.22131222486495972,
0.01001484040170908,
0.5923341512680054,
-0.7508214712142944,
0.053286854177713394,
-0.6287544965744019,
-0.24229420721530914,
0.043823979794979095,
-0.2896551191806793,
-0.4642234444618225,
-0.24721567332744598,
-0.2451307773590088,
-0.7253062129020691,
-0.020384231582283974,
-0.14887872338294983,
0.5564635992050171,
0.20732365548610687,
-0.5653902292251587,
-0.5916004180908203,
-0.47638222575187683,
0.983465313911438,
-0.5801226496696472,
0.6264375448226929,
0.6566619277000427,
0.46403977274894714,
-0.3121595084667206,
-0.6410450339317322,
-0.8025757074356079,
0.13413859903812408,
-0.21041662991046906,
0.014781519770622253,
-0.172069251537323,
0.09811940789222717,
0.22577433288097382,
0.02518049068748951,
-0.3979525566101074,
-0.43287238478660583,
-0.3977193236351013,
-0.19972530007362366,
0.9202357530593872,
-0.07151205837726593,
0.4640079736709595,
-0.3220185339450836,
-0.4319165349006653,
0.22913184762001038,
-0.49404847621917725,
-0.014256549999117851,
0.5043719410896301,
-0.040861133486032486,
-0.14096960425376892,
0.7254837155342102,
-0.3967409133911133,
0.3409474790096283,
-0.08716163039207458,
-0.2674570381641388,
0.18297447264194489,
-0.47578540444374084,
0.15597185492515564,
0.07568567991256714,
1.0374724864959717,
0.9372556209564209,
0.3637257218360901,
0.09448700398206711,
-0.14724348485469818,
0.12284614145755768,
0.1892818808555603,
-0.855555534362793,
-0.1947687417268753,
0.19743230938911438,
-0.6969377994537354,
-0.3003210425376892,
0.0302715040743351,
-0.6524739265441895,
-0.6211135983467102,
-0.3941456079483032,
0.49336567521095276,
-0.5511728525161743,
-0.6028822660446167,
0.13963355123996735,
-0.4904501736164093,
-0.0065519907511770725,
0.43982791900634766,
-0.682004451751709,
-0.33598268032073975,
0.7442038655281067,
0.7506579160690308,
0.4685767889022827,
-0.38704538345336914,
-0.5358922481536865,
0.17618651688098907,
-0.24802713096141815,
0.45598679780960083,
-0.6110689640045166,
-0.32829219102859497,
0.004286184441298246,
-0.051005877554416656,
0.19921061396598816,
0.07704129070043564,
0.6938700675964355,
-0.41658997535705566,
-0.32388487458229065,
-0.4554539620876312,
-0.26927196979522705,
-0.3620319962501526,
0.2575368285179138,
-0.6280977129936218,
0.7466264367103577,
-0.11999844014644623,
-0.4940645396709442,
0.5977147221565247,
-0.7318112254142761,
-0.456091046333313,
0.07974763959646225,
-0.14644315838813782,
-0.02864178456366062,
0.5510876774787903,
0.23369941115379333,
0.8461545705795288,
0.047532349824905396,
0.5676131248474121,
-0.6067330241203308,
-0.36781516671180725,
0.5951939225196838,
-0.6608185172080994,
0.5001883506774902,
0.44994261860847473,
0.11451087146997452,
-0.05693819746375084,
-0.5198670625686646,
-0.19544656574726105,
0.135661780834198,
-0.3207753598690033,
-0.8157102465629578,
0.12771524488925934,
0.07859717309474945,
0.433797687292099,
0.3067549765110016,
-0.5603312253952026,
0.10978557914495468,
0.292502760887146,
0.5726292729377747,
0.7110182642936707,
0.25105971097946167,
0.3834075927734375,
-0.09954012930393219,
0.20379264652729034,
0.014031734317541122,
0.6102083921432495,
-0.3265317678451538,
-0.7716549038887024,
-0.3530820608139038,
-0.13124310970306396,
-0.27008357644081116,
-0.3410769999027252,
-0.9638833403587341,
-0.000704997917637229,
-0.38332003355026245,
-0.3256877660751343,
-0.8214325308799744,
0.5529969930648804,
0.1654246598482132,
-0.0543803907930851,
0.20423655211925507,
0.02653278224170208,
-0.46824538707733154,
-0.9632354378700256,
-0.469512403011322,
-0.03677172586321831,
0.1525287628173828,
0.36270275712013245,
0.32204821705818176,
-0.6481249332427979,
0.8415126204490662,
-0.4874736964702606,
-0.03515249118208885,
-0.4673280715942383,
0.4693255126476288,
0.1012488454580307,
-0.007605831604450941,
0.5763573050498962,
-1.2075058221817017,
-0.838538646697998,
0.07063120603561401,
-0.730743944644928,
-0.03385643661022186,
-0.07915462553501129,
-0.25000306963920593,
0.007743297144770622,
0.34980490803718567,
-0.5500078797340393,
0.2967571020126343,
0.806009829044342,
-0.142754465341568,
0.38305148482322693,
0.1545838862657547,
0.598655104637146,
-1.3549869060516357,
-0.06543359160423279,
0.11650161445140839,
-0.06430214643478394,
-0.6809912919998169,
-0.2269744873046875,
0.19903792440891266,
0.09863781183958054,
-0.5212064981460571,
0.747761607170105,
-0.529167890548706,
0.13245150446891785,
-0.23259052634239197,
0.1267358660697937,
0.2466026395559311,
0.2797849476337433,
0.00744890421628952,
0.22724616527557373,
0.3535734713077545,
-0.5360254049301147,
0.15835246443748474,
-0.08102387189865112,
-0.4087100625038147,
0.5781378746032715,
-0.25291022658348083,
0.18382851779460907,
-0.34369558095932007,
-0.052495457231998444,
-1.3720358610153198,
-0.7519664168357849,
0.34801560640335083,
-0.804841935634613,
-0.024060221388936043,
-0.5395731925964355,
-0.5717910528182983,
-0.21930910646915436,
-0.3674558103084564,
0.5752177834510803,
0.1712501049041748,
-0.7198469638824463,
0.8346707820892334,
0.20941805839538574,
-0.2722039222717285,
-0.8323598504066467,
-0.6748650074005127,
0.07072179019451141,
-0.19998756051063538,
-0.7362402081489563,
-0.15019474923610687,
-0.03170610964298248,
-0.22511939704418182,
0.021923735737800598,
0.23172159492969513,
-0.07056139409542084,
-0.05891106277704239,
0.41653236746788025,
0.07179693877696991,
0.23205024003982544,
0.4201270043849945,
0.43015944957733154,
0.022208543494343758,
0.046488918364048004,
0.043467044830322266,
0.7529481649398804,
0.17868085205554962,
-0.357237845659256,
-0.5730606913566589,
0.49456652998924255,
0.8028582334518433,
0.1278112381696701,
0.6858223676681519,
1.015818476676941,
-0.4073655307292938,
-0.10119692981243134,
-0.669055700302124,
-0.32447725534439087,
-0.4812237620353699,
0.07298140972852707,
-0.34112611413002014,
-0.8238698840141296,
0.21125102043151855,
-0.20875805616378784,
0.13522790372371674,
0.10013223439455032,
0.24183838069438934,
-0.1987808793783188,
1.1814223527908325,
0.3378918766975403,
-0.10418294370174408,
0.5527688264846802,
-0.05136217549443245,
0.531196117401123,
-0.5853714942932129,
-0.0007346706697717309,
0.11048199236392975,
-0.6396804451942444,
-0.31935304403305054,
-0.4477855861186981,
0.3984015882015228,
0.2369227111339569,
0.5152217745780945,
0.18783822655677795,
-0.08808796852827072,
0.5428377985954285,
0.45664694905281067,
0.2417101413011551,
0.5820611119270325,
0.13177348673343658,
0.24058838188648224,
0.003781986655667424,
-0.4850972592830658,
-0.4967028796672821,
1.2088284492492676,
0.2921351492404938,
0.7571977972984314,
0.23462659120559692,
1.020207166671753,
0.3168922960758209,
0.5732906460762024,
-0.8883898854255676,
0.4964633584022522,
-0.008057049475610256,
-0.885683536529541,
-0.20300473272800446,
-0.5080670118331909,
-0.7780508995056152,
0.12710079550743103,
-0.5076109170913696,
-0.5910518765449524,
-0.013731630519032478,
0.4702693819999695,
-0.17655374109745026,
-0.0031244822312146425,
-0.9616574645042419,
0.7920529246330261,
-0.48635971546173096,
-0.5423604249954224,
-0.5602712035179138,
-0.5490631461143494,
0.804711103439331,
-0.09710873663425446,
0.6675149202346802,
-0.2816500663757324,
0.1859920173883438,
0.5000959038734436,
0.09564322233200073,
0.930042028427124,
-0.25771063566207886,
0.013972526416182518,
0.5021898150444031,
-0.04796268045902252,
0.5851693153381348,
0.1612522453069687,
0.23312194645404816,
0.4341678023338318,
-0.2556537389755249,
0.049585793167352676,
-0.5370398163795471,
0.8805974721908569,
-0.3983451724052429,
0.07363735884428024,
0.16230593621730804,
-0.7061797976493835,
0.07379326224327087,
0.3764203190803528,
0.17240440845489502,
0.3338298797607422,
-0.4188632071018219,
0.4509609043598175,
0.41965270042419434,
-0.10560573637485504,
0.35474810004234314,
0.304097443819046,
-0.5212166905403137,
-0.4312116205692291,
1.045400619506836,
0.12412579357624054,
0.2630770802497864,
0.1554637849330902,
0.4357181489467621,
-0.5629580020904541,
-0.3356137275695801,
-0.26026296615600586,
0.3829309940338135,
-0.896380603313446,
0.18206706643104553,
-0.7644088864326477,
0.24218963086605072,
-0.476876825094223,
-0.4413856267929077,
-0.26521188020706177,
-0.22051937878131866,
-0.024335911497473717,
0.026915958151221275,
0.4851442277431488,
0.7518512010574341,
-0.20058096945285797,
0.5152642130851746,
-0.9296249747276306,
0.4555838406085968,
0.11388030648231506,
0.3197547495365143,
-0.16468545794487,
0.0029766284860670567,
-0.20964844524860382,
0.5140224099159241,
0.044715333729982376,
-0.8622170090675354,
0.28275954723358154,
0.027515260502696037,
0.5249496698379517,
0.9684940576553345,
0.20854060351848602,
0.5115628838539124,
-0.06401754915714264,
0.37516462802886963,
0.5715529322624207,
-0.507098376750946,
0.6406002044677734,
-0.5237618088722229,
0.13220423460006714,
0.774943470954895,
0.8835721015930176,
-0.9584671854972839,
-0.17136481404304504,
-0.5678783059120178,
-0.7328968644142151,
0.4968996047973633,
0.14242394268512726,
0.3010958731174469,
-0.1609775573015213,
0.22575324773788452,
0.21528276801109314,
0.35356226563453674,
-0.8317834138870239,
0.025543836876749992,
-0.0437849685549736,
-0.5743570327758789,
-0.2907201945781708,
-0.4501645863056183,
-0.22554504871368408,
-0.08671768009662628,
0.6911110877990723,
-0.2044706642627716,
-0.006516439840197563,
-0.2349397838115692,
-0.4299347400665283,
-0.04026014730334282,
0.35589152574539185,
0.47072461247444153,
0.5274383425712585,
-0.08372936397790909,
0.3334203362464905,
-0.29739245772361755,
-0.523474931716919,
-0.08122168481349945,
-0.14234401285648346,
-0.2246018797159195,
0.16723836958408356,
0.0013633198104798794,
0.5222374796867371,
0.3970845639705658,
-0.736433744430542,
0.6019240021705627,
-0.28314363956451416,
-0.3842546045780182,
-0.20719069242477417,
-0.0000136471790028736,
0.5039358139038086,
0.2249707728624344,
0.15020541846752167,
-0.15422388911247253,
0.3889353573322296,
-0.6656053066253662,
-0.11240385472774506,
0.522953987121582,
-0.30441248416900635,
-0.3264639973640442,
0.1536792665719986,
0.2369910627603531,
-0.15476442873477936,
0.3205452263355255,
-0.4099400043487549,
-0.37374910712242126,
0.12721289694309235,
0.06462112814188004,
0.9021651148796082,
-0.2886444330215454,
0.33447450399398804,
0.5261290073394775,
0.3744926154613495,
0.00727291963994503,
0.4680689871311188,
-0.42536941170692444,
-0.9810670018196106,
-0.15257233381271362,
-0.6710742115974426,
0.09232021868228912,
0.24960486590862274,
-0.4040016829967499,
0.44508570432662964,
-0.30773892998695374,
-0.3374024033546448,
0.33263689279556274,
-0.43177708983421326,
-0.5797617435455322,
-0.17695048451423645,
-0.13871274888515472,
0.2584192454814911,
-1.1078784465789795,
0.6163291335105896,
0.7434190511703491,
-0.29057225584983826,
-0.7028213143348694,
-0.021795861423015594,
0.3108779191970825,
-0.7331564426422119,
0.524072527885437,
0.4241383969783783,
-0.20394529402256012,
-0.06569615006446838,
-0.7406845092773438,
-0.4988650977611542,
1.060661792755127,
0.06635934114456177,
-0.7169196605682373,
0.37997302412986755,
0.34770458936691284,
0.11624077707529068,
-0.2677607536315918,
0.06917686760425568,
0.28830429911613464,
0.5650181770324707,
0.4788830578327179,
-0.4127575159072876,
-0.1262924075126648,
-0.23259751498699188,
-0.22977745532989502,
0.4348335266113281,
-0.41716355085372925,
0.5582600831985474,
-0.33757802844047546,
-0.3879023492336273,
-0.5982398986816406,
0.24508316814899445,
0.3201277554035187,
0.8539400100708008,
0.49118366837501526,
0.48030659556388855,
0.5018229484558105,
-0.02325727604329586,
0.6585122346878052,
-0.26806843280792236,
0.2585007846355438,
1.0795319080352783,
-0.1778709441423416,
0.8153798580169678,
0.9133518934249878,
0.23617200553417206,
0.21962754428386688,
0.3650210499763489,
0.4388616979122162,
0.4724789261817932,
-0.31535422801971436,
-0.6846102476119995,
-0.41153019666671753,
-0.20236605405807495,
-0.11909149587154388,
0.40897396206855774,
0.7151677012443542,
-0.7888407707214355,
-0.30024170875549316,
0.047563694417476654,
0.15906819701194763,
-0.05517919734120369,
-0.5087878704071045,
0.81508868932724,
0.10246200114488602,
-0.7572545409202576,
0.10335762798786163,
-0.2276686578989029,
0.7023559808731079,
-0.5803283452987671,
-0.20281459391117096,
0.13726121187210083,
0.25444674491882324,
-0.39915668964385986,
-0.960869550704956,
0.15373657643795013,
-0.13645203411579132,
-0.2182883769273758,
-0.1997034102678299,
1.283239722251892,
-0.6997491121292114,
-0.5143930912017822,
0.362302303314209,
0.1279306411743164,
0.31204742193222046,
-0.4585282504558563,
-0.4443114399909973,
0.2562713623046875,
-0.1057434231042862,
-0.006900270003825426,
0.1375567764043808,
0.5980497598648071,
0.042234305292367935,
0.5382697582244873,
0.923051655292511,
-0.35752809047698975,
0.16782395541667938,
0.2464360147714615,
0.8512183427810669,
-0.1037287563085556,
-0.30125027894973755,
-0.9542459845542908,
0.6761723160743713,
-0.35448238253593445,
-0.1447732299566269,
0.7517704367637634,
0.3496868908405304,
0.8852154612541199,
-0.01339594554156065,
1.1487985849380493,
-0.08511526882648468,
0.13793905079364777,
-0.5486963987350464,
0.8610255122184753,
-0.8307530283927917,
-0.10282549262046814,
-0.44500887393951416,
-0.7983589768409729,
0.15798580646514893,
0.6465486884117126,
-0.40148600935935974,
0.026320969685912132,
0.3394662141799927,
0.8979697227478027,
-0.2161567360162735,
0.19229921698570251,
0.5546354055404663,
-0.011395733803510666,
0.1894422471523285,
0.4584052860736847,
1.245007038116455,
-0.24287638068199158,
0.37212780117988586,
-0.3701598644256592,
-0.43459972739219666,
-0.6424356698989868,
-0.8854572176933289,
-0.9600355625152588,
-0.7878548502922058,
-0.01867624558508396,
-0.10460461676120758,
-0.029194209724664688,
1.094125747680664,
0.47893908619880676,
-0.2965225577354431,
0.015146982856094837,
-0.0700690746307373,
0.2434876412153244,
0.009346257895231247,
-0.2514074742794037,
-0.18497513234615326,
-0.270467072725296,
-0.5911769270896912,
0.26169246435165405,
0.20615199208259583,
-0.0037230539601296186,
-0.17999927699565887,
-0.5306193828582764,
-0.525720477104187,
0.07417376339435577,
0.9000521898269653,
-0.08143173903226852,
-0.6634008288383484,
-0.28288695216178894,
0.01086272019892931,
0.07048314809799194,
-0.345281183719635,
0.8571975827217102,
0.024709319695830345,
0.859922468662262,
0.6544000506401062,
0.23819485306739807,
0.4844159781932831,
-0.09665302187204361,
0.3468053340911865,
-0.9885671734809875,
-0.19235001504421234,
0.05018750950694084,
0.6395682096481323,
0.18477949500083923,
-0.4707244336605072,
0.2344643920660019,
0.1631729006767273,
-0.4221830666065216,
-0.5959548354148865,
0.2712836265563965,
-0.9707801938056946,
-0.49693143367767334,
1.5105475187301636,
0.07889331877231598,
-0.10457044839859009,
-0.1988409161567688,
-0.4497356414794922,
0.16128788888454437,
-0.6917391419410706,
0.6943722367286682,
1.0099186897277832,
0.20697495341300964,
-0.4409770369529724,
-0.7527221441268921,
0.4822281301021576,
-0.2294410616159439,
-0.4252703785896301,
0.20157141983509064,
0.8928486108779907,
0.28315192461013794,
0.36579927802085876,
0.8888937830924988,
0.05467287823557854,
0.30148622393608093,
-0.1391655057668686,
0.4386879503726959,
-0.13412658870220184,
-0.6391748189926147,
-0.036312296986579895,
0.020776664838194847,
-0.02138642966747284,
-0.0951671227812767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18158v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18158v2
|
Evaluating Quantized Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T08:43:05 | 2024-06-06T07:30:44 |
Shiyao Li, Xuefei Ning, Luning Wang, Tengxuan Liu, Xiangsheng Shi, Shengen Yan, Guohao Dai, Huazhong Yang, Yu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Post-training quantization (PTQ) has emerged as a promising technique to
reduce the cost of large language models (LLMs). Specifically, PTQ can
effectively mitigate memory consumption and reduce computational overhead in
LLMs. To meet the requirements of both high efficiency and performance across
diverse scenarios, a comprehensive evaluation of quantized LLMs is essential to
guide the selection of quantization methods. This paper presents a thorough
evaluation of these factors by evaluating the effect of PTQ on Weight,
Activation, and KV Cache on 11 model families, including OPT, LLaMA2, Falcon,
Bloomz, Mistral, ChatGLM, Vicuna, LongChat, StableLM, Gemma, and Mamba, with
parameters ranging from 125M to 180B. The evaluation encompasses five types of
tasks: basic NLP, emergent ability, trustworthiness, dialogue, and long-context
tasks. Moreover, we also evaluate the state-of-the-art (SOTA) quantization
methods to demonstrate their applicability. Based on the extensive experiments,
we systematically summarize the effect of quantization, provide recommendations
to apply quantization techniques, and point out future directions. The code can
be found in https://github.com/thu-nics/qllm-eval.
|
[
-0.2249336987733841,
-0.5913196206092834,
0.6187848448753357,
0.4378409683704376,
-0.5142480134963989,
0.07709157466888428,
-0.40108105540275574,
0.09394555538892746,
-0.3358045816421509,
0.36698105931282043,
-0.07378874719142914,
-0.5410565137863159,
-0.5447695851325989,
0.04631507024168968,
-0.5601933002471924,
0.7966099977493286,
-0.059697914868593216,
0.12858574092388153,
-0.14873838424682617,
-0.08127402514219284,
-0.22878441214561462,
-0.7865192890167236,
-0.8491544127464294,
-0.23091690242290497,
0.20883582532405853,
-0.10356498509645462,
0.7685549855232239,
0.3508046269416809,
0.349463552236557,
0.2670700252056122,
-0.22471074759960175,
-0.18102632462978363,
-0.6761814951896667,
-0.03381374105811119,
0.2652531862258911,
-0.6285949349403381,
-0.6040666103363037,
-0.11513081192970276,
1.0587782859802246,
0.5152220726013184,
-0.1422048807144165,
0.2505839765071869,
-0.010421708226203918,
0.6203124523162842,
-0.990983784198761,
0.13186416029930115,
-0.41026008129119873,
0.16817016899585724,
-0.14562951028347015,
-0.18618400394916534,
-0.4627041220664978,
-0.48977866768836975,
0.3659863770008087,
-0.6425692439079285,
-0.5054165720939636,
-0.19264499843120575,
0.6435126662254333,
0.23556438088417053,
-0.6682896018028259,
0.09646638482809067,
-0.7988449335098267,
1.1213432550430298,
-0.8282821178436279,
0.5692527294158936,
0.42842525243759155,
0.1521240472793579,
0.016084732487797737,
-0.876584529876709,
-0.35932356119155884,
-0.26992329955101013,
0.17607057094573975,
0.15349511802196503,
-0.38465216755867004,
0.3201408088207245,
0.4093260169029236,
0.7034722566604614,
-0.6140221357345581,
0.014527969993650913,
-0.09095693379640579,
-0.04518389329314232,
0.2080601155757904,
0.1345011591911316,
0.14425227046012878,
0.06937816739082336,
-0.1953142285346985,
-0.2097305804491043,
-0.7143197059631348,
0.09617142379283905,
0.3430682122707367,
-0.1788390427827835,
0.04566724970936775,
0.5370975136756897,
-0.6156855821609497,
0.6564942002296448,
0.10046807676553726,
-0.1917382776737213,
0.12365175038576126,
-0.5825111269950867,
-0.5036749243736267,
-0.1732938587665558,
0.8993756771087646,
0.14645414054393768,
0.32249268889427185,
-0.2774750590324402,
-0.3413354158401489,
-0.142526313662529,
0.09146706014871597,
-1.0718506574630737,
-0.03042651154100895,
0.2220717817544937,
-0.5291046500205994,
-0.1614810824394226,
-0.2769271433353424,
-0.19963006675243378,
-0.1364274024963379,
-0.218306764960289,
0.7360802888870239,
-0.636191189289093,
-0.3073428273200989,
0.4034958779811859,
0.021750349551439285,
0.40391314029693604,
0.21396107971668243,
-0.5254525542259216,
0.24907183647155762,
0.722973108291626,
0.6793344616889954,
0.06933585554361343,
-0.00842892937362194,
-0.6396774649620056,
-0.06341564655303955,
-0.36380842328071594,
0.5174285769462585,
-0.4038679897785187,
-0.3041122257709503,
0.04614245146512985,
-0.24420680105686188,
-0.017046881839632988,
-0.4917503595352173,
0.6898385286331177,
-0.7741953730583191,
-0.007303936406970024,
-0.23651401698589325,
-0.26249566674232483,
-0.16150414943695068,
0.17420463263988495,
-0.8243570327758789,
1.126144528388977,
0.37382110953330994,
-0.6974490284919739,
0.43881091475486755,
-0.26804181933403015,
-0.3509162962436676,
0.1624796986579895,
0.425311416387558,
-0.49460315704345703,
0.3604544997215271,
0.15100719034671783,
0.4370591640472412,
-0.5279790759086609,
0.43744957447052,
-0.17364627122879028,
-0.7298559546470642,
0.44634810090065,
-0.308435320854187,
0.7753340601921082,
0.1705833524465561,
-0.3721637725830078,
0.27528247237205505,
-0.6839168071746826,
0.3088884651660919,
-0.17559567093849182,
-0.5366569757461548,
-0.45657840371131897,
-0.024163421243429184,
-0.21922551095485687,
0.1362190842628479,
0.17317037284374237,
-0.07647895812988281,
0.039979029446840286,
-0.6733221411705017,
0.7904981970787048,
0.3090636134147644,
0.005109213758260012,
0.37911608815193176,
-0.023895276710391045,
0.6876451373100281,
-0.2014814019203186,
0.4357241690158844,
-0.13912419974803925,
-0.08983758836984634,
-1.0306204557418823,
-0.414127379655838,
0.7137964963912964,
0.1626211404800415,
-1.0079022645950317,
0.27853453159332275,
-0.3205430805683136,
-0.35859477519989014,
-0.44697484374046326,
-0.23078647255897522,
0.7258254885673523,
-0.24681685864925385,
0.08404698967933655,
-0.33506685495376587,
-0.553280770778656,
-0.8301686644554138,
-0.19955594837665558,
-0.13635917007923126,
-0.22049105167388916,
-0.07887692749500275,
0.3876042366027832,
-0.05201653391122818,
0.8830380439758301,
0.048654355108737946,
0.26357409358024597,
-0.04192325100302696,
0.3344128131866455,
-0.10856470465660095,
0.23787768185138702,
0.3563147485256195,
-0.41669416427612305,
-0.4478354752063751,
-0.015397443436086178,
-0.29671651124954224,
-0.1606876254081726,
-0.01729579269886017,
-0.10573402047157288,
0.26318359375,
0.3836030960083008,
-0.8578974604606628,
0.37996819615364075,
0.6379730701446533,
-0.07043270766735077,
0.7164233326911926,
0.008678130805492401,
0.40622514486312866,
-0.6368446350097656,
0.3899960219860077,
-0.023221781477332115,
-0.3734816908836365,
-0.6221765279769897,
0.26238057017326355,
0.1769823133945465,
-0.1342109590768814,
-0.6569299101829529,
0.5245083570480347,
-0.45472127199172974,
-0.42004793882369995,
-0.16935692727565765,
0.025041311979293823,
0.05139988288283348,
0.4256313145160675,
-0.06641064584255219,
0.8507716655731201,
0.40099719166755676,
-0.4958902597427368,
0.21071213483810425,
-0.23906610906124115,
-0.5750630497932434,
0.2438255250453949,
-0.8798741102218628,
0.2170601636171341,
0.0887160450220108,
0.23163363337516785,
-0.8968251347541809,
0.3520927131175995,
0.05137201026082039,
-0.2653086185455322,
0.019120341166853905,
-0.10041408985853195,
-1.1468698978424072,
-0.21472090482711792,
-0.5206489562988281,
0.5610762238502502,
0.4216453731060028,
-0.1998211145401001,
0.420026034116745,
0.0804792121052742,
0.16387782990932465,
-0.2948382794857025,
-0.2591593563556671,
0.08973336964845657,
-0.5299488306045532,
-0.3231816291809082,
0.2298734337091446,
-0.03893463313579559,
-0.2705056071281433,
-0.20591948926448822,
-0.19549629092216492,
-0.14953351020812988,
0.3832145929336548,
0.11896951496601105,
-0.16528332233428955,
-0.17886163294315338,
0.24018096923828125,
0.20408959686756134,
-0.19971221685409546,
0.053484346717596054,
-0.4760904610157013,
0.9082658886909485,
-0.5149086117744446,
0.06510548293590546,
-0.4597611725330353,
-0.09708315879106522,
0.564441978931427,
-0.6124604940414429,
0.8266816139221191,
0.9148040413856506,
-0.29559165239334106,
0.0013561671366915107,
-0.48246878385543823,
-0.0002233195846201852,
-0.41203784942626953,
0.5310286283493042,
-0.30574339628219604,
-1.1418906450271606,
0.3603244721889496,
-0.27083706855773926,
-0.1820545643568039,
0.3877609968185425,
0.8407800197601318,
0.22908265888690948,
1.179139256477356,
0.41771647334098816,
0.10857032239437103,
0.5184323787689209,
-0.28401270508766174,
0.34910425543785095,
-0.8340355157852173,
0.1829821616411209,
-0.4344554841518402,
-0.10082308948040009,
-0.3218768239021301,
-0.7454935908317566,
0.36910197138786316,
0.49369266629219055,
-0.33294594287872314,
0.34947699308395386,
-0.15983572602272034,
0.2580556571483612,
0.45864245295524597,
-0.07013444602489471,
0.4521849751472473,
-0.09902874380350113,
0.057486120611429214,
0.1454663872718811,
-0.6077994704246521,
-0.6228011250495911,
1.4639098644256592,
0.46448537707328796,
0.4650014340877533,
-0.08271554112434387,
0.35522958636283875,
0.09658775478601456,
0.2133541852235794,
-1.1025071144104004,
0.6024032831192017,
-0.17109791934490204,
-0.2723985016345978,
-0.5281928181648254,
-0.4963105618953705,
-0.9744424223899841,
0.3338462710380554,
-0.27793827652931213,
-0.5554747581481934,
-0.2014819234609604,
-0.10604269802570343,
-0.7482583522796631,
-0.1953306794166565,
-0.6324900388717651,
0.8623688817024231,
-0.2889699339866638,
-0.13661044836044312,
-0.581387460231781,
-0.3479219079017639,
0.7333448529243469,
-0.49014753103256226,
-0.2463371902704239,
0.04820338636636734,
-0.185898095369339,
0.9811291098594666,
-0.3328208327293396,
0.5467619299888611,
0.036561187356710434,
-0.16491419076919556,
0.29989734292030334,
-0.09242837131023407,
0.4016357958316803,
0.0629773885011673,
-0.15470482409000397,
0.24644792079925537,
0.5225600600242615,
-0.1877593994140625,
-0.6942856907844543,
0.4960000813007355,
-0.6867794394493103,
-0.42132997512817383,
-0.18265467882156372,
-0.5366678833961487,
-0.419922411441803,
0.16110405325889587,
-0.08164366334676743,
0.3653377890586853,
-0.0957469791173935,
0.6112321615219116,
0.729861855506897,
-0.6327432990074158,
0.4118521809577942,
0.6088488698005676,
-0.2928522527217865,
-0.6219145059585571,
0.5967448353767395,
0.07081904262304306,
0.4614133834838867,
0.5232509970664978,
0.3550928235054016,
-0.19985714554786682,
-0.7242701649665833,
-0.15444380044937134,
0.2278246283531189,
-0.3436242938041687,
-0.3095313012599945,
-0.7079307436943054,
-0.1411237120628357,
-0.2809407413005829,
0.3151528537273407,
-0.4689790904521942,
-0.6543728709220886,
-0.3019498586654663,
0.05103551223874092,
0.17050592601299286,
0.05663113296031952,
0.498294860124588,
0.9707604646682739,
-0.7810563445091248,
0.15107762813568115,
0.4341503083705902,
0.2753340005874634,
0.14918853342533112,
-0.4627026617527008,
-0.6903067231178284,
0.03884485363960266,
-0.2907920777797699,
-0.5338706970214844,
0.39633551239967346,
0.23409117758274078,
0.3840896189212799,
0.6045859456062317,
0.13062112033367157,
0.8727176189422607,
-0.2745210528373718,
0.6476927399635315,
0.08734976500272751,
-1.379351019859314,
0.28969791531562805,
-0.24402548372745514,
0.4580119848251343,
0.45235562324523926,
0.47274574637413025,
-0.3616393804550171,
-0.33848705887794495,
-0.46764737367630005,
-0.800375759601593,
0.4869714379310608,
0.30989235639572144,
0.06016707420349121,
0.16291752457618713,
0.46196234226226807,
-0.14686352014541626,
0.5850409269332886,
-0.8223803639411926,
-0.07276369631290436,
0.10771585255861282,
0.0724826455116272,
0.22820928692817688,
-0.7223770618438721,
0.08852467685937881,
-0.08382324874401093,
0.499983012676239,
0.09109964221715927,
0.12737269699573517,
-0.26067230105400085,
-0.2262798398733139,
-0.14963595569133759,
0.36159002780914307,
0.49539491534233093,
0.7183965444564819,
-0.19483956694602966,
0.08187136054039001,
0.14018197357654572,
-0.18823610246181488,
-0.053905364125967026,
-0.06111888960003853,
-0.07392982393503189,
-0.18569809198379517,
0.3336254060268402,
0.9795436859130859,
0.48980262875556946,
-0.896138072013855,
0.6076279282569885,
-0.23091650009155273,
-0.10878899693489075,
-0.1375950276851654,
0.035158976912498474,
-0.11629917472600937,
0.41612425446510315,
0.14616820216178894,
-0.48324012756347656,
0.33552291989326477,
-0.6253376007080078,
-0.0004604057176038623,
0.62725430727005,
-0.1790490448474884,
-0.576555609703064,
0.35649415850639343,
0.0011812254087999463,
-0.05890674516558647,
0.47957220673561096,
-0.30645617842674255,
-0.6962254047393799,
0.36587387323379517,
0.38501638174057007,
0.8643782138824463,
-0.455740749835968,
0.18123596906661987,
0.3398735523223877,
0.3946339190006256,
-0.1848713606595993,
0.24340899288654327,
-0.21920475363731384,
-0.4186610281467438,
-1.0131345987319946,
-0.8677563071250916,
-0.08433549106121063,
0.2888789772987366,
-0.6171846389770508,
0.20805849134922028,
-0.3480924963951111,
-0.5240184664726257,
-0.47678765654563904,
0.3537358045578003,
-0.5721392631530762,
0.23040999472141266,
0.12940113246440887,
0.5062007904052734,
-0.6430705785751343,
1.0879899263381958,
0.5194305777549744,
0.013041160069406033,
-0.7258985638618469,
0.05970698595046997,
-0.468905508518219,
-0.7579774260520935,
0.9301131367683411,
-0.1081971675157547,
0.147352397441864,
0.37386196851730347,
-0.1911994218826294,
-1.0680317878723145,
1.0263667106628418,
0.4033243954181671,
-0.6106037497520447,
0.032341085374355316,
0.2724588215351105,
0.8071186542510986,
0.12286700308322906,
0.6559518575668335,
0.9291841983795166,
0.46534302830696106,
0.03776547685265541,
-1.2153643369674683,
0.023369569331407547,
-0.04277516156435013,
0.38188183307647705,
0.3439662456512451,
-0.615159273147583,
0.8636881709098816,
0.21043695509433746,
-0.4820443093776703,
0.3051186501979828,
0.459781289100647,
0.5164457559585571,
-0.04451313987374306,
0.524842381477356,
0.7571977376937866,
0.34059181809425354,
-0.04537779092788696,
0.9122779965400696,
-0.5083687901496887,
0.4254392385482788,
0.6906805634498596,
-0.2413378208875656,
0.8294109106063843,
0.4467565715312958,
-0.6382749080657959,
-0.03710445761680603,
0.6327579617500305,
0.21995283663272858,
0.5319375395774841,
0.7221393585205078,
-0.17727848887443542,
-0.20159514248371124,
-0.18673068284988403,
-0.32154399156570435,
0.452332079410553,
0.2253417670726776,
-0.10312862694263458,
0.033912476152181625,
0.14273279905319214,
0.20186513662338257,
-0.5282067060470581,
-0.4034794270992279,
0.5307617783546448,
0.2514136731624603,
-0.587024450302124,
0.9368608593940735,
0.2777971625328064,
0.38847285509109497,
-0.5708068013191223,
0.13132865726947784,
-0.10162217915058136,
-0.06295020133256912,
-0.033072639256715775,
-0.36164581775665283,
0.1571565866470337,
-0.0027311646845191717,
0.08072490245103836,
-0.402670681476593,
0.5154150724411011,
-0.28166064620018005,
-0.313339501619339,
0.10288459807634354,
0.4044862985610962,
0.07161407917737961,
-0.6601271629333496,
-0.45336490869522095,
0.3606753647327423,
-0.2018471658229828,
-0.430493026971817,
0.5261439085006714,
0.5794665813446045,
-0.17156006395816803,
0.6420964598655701,
0.5512486100196838,
0.03689093142747879,
0.05634153261780739,
0.13393083214759827,
0.7890671491622925,
-0.48553216457366943,
-0.295529842376709,
-0.7822726368904114,
0.5582910776138306,
0.4115898609161377,
-0.21096506714820862,
0.923795223236084,
0.6119627356529236,
0.6244257092475891,
-0.004091751761734486,
0.5200560092926025,
0.2872985899448395,
0.08376005291938782,
-0.7450109124183655,
0.6451090574264526,
-0.43510812520980835,
0.3357550799846649,
-0.332905113697052,
-1.180903434753418,
-0.32362329959869385,
0.5351362228393555,
-0.6160087585449219,
0.1300247311592102,
0.9211002588272095,
0.36907514929771423,
0.4137828052043915,
-0.26959022879600525,
0.5532112121582031,
0.10518067330121994,
0.0683693215250969,
0.7964096069335938,
1.2695025205612183,
-0.5713554620742798,
0.6770190596580505,
-0.2349260151386261,
-0.1468796730041504,
-0.25078219175338745,
-0.7880685329437256,
-0.9563525915145874,
-0.5476018190383911,
-0.6121488809585571,
-0.16815753281116486,
0.06596279889345169,
0.41058599948883057,
0.9102568030357361,
-0.49654415249824524,
-0.3119969964027405,
0.06684043258428574,
-0.1287163347005844,
-0.21000546216964722,
-0.23319533467292786,
0.5813166499137878,
-0.15641982853412628,
-0.8747112154960632,
0.15813706815242767,
0.5191730260848999,
-0.12876099348068237,
-0.40817132592201233,
-0.11641061305999756,
0.18111728131771088,
-0.0540100522339344,
1.0646008253097534,
-0.10818292945623398,
-0.8058266043663025,
-0.02447124384343624,
0.09078945219516754,
-0.1202109307050705,
-0.09809048473834991,
0.9514315724372864,
-0.9999158978462219,
0.2961563169956207,
0.45535266399383545,
0.5242180228233337,
0.5194084644317627,
0.07122847437858582,
0.5979537963867188,
-0.4222407639026642,
0.06319746375083923,
0.38177183270454407,
0.14771237969398499,
-0.012058679014444351,
-0.10059911012649536,
0.4632139205932617,
-0.10176442563533783,
-0.6160222291946411,
-1.0262302160263062,
-0.1562294065952301,
-0.9619845151901245,
-0.06815323233604431,
1.219486951828003,
-0.2684682607650757,
-0.10613556951284409,
0.17099276185035706,
-0.015176109969615936,
0.4493582248687744,
-0.2341759353876114,
0.6311580538749695,
0.76904296875,
0.24631009995937347,
-0.5478836894035339,
-0.6600542068481445,
0.4725090265274048,
0.6207162141799927,
-0.8400863409042358,
-0.11384136229753494,
0.3394712507724762,
-0.06562775373458862,
-0.25005704164505005,
0.575265645980835,
-0.20359453558921814,
0.19681641459465027,
-0.37158462405204773,
0.2658196985721588,
0.17548999190330505,
0.015872593969106674,
-0.5527910590171814,
-0.05173484981060028,
0.3445746898651123,
0.07038016617298126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18157v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18157v1
|
From Summary to Action: Enhancing Large Language Models for Complex Tasks with Open World APIs
| 2024-02-28T08:42:23 | 2024-02-28T08:42:23 |
Yulong Liu, Yunlong Yuan, Chunwei Wang, Jianhua Han, Yongqiang Ma, Li Zhang, Nanning Zheng, Hang Xu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The distinction between humans and animals lies in the unique ability of
humans to use and create tools. Tools empower humans to overcome physiological
limitations, fostering the creation of magnificent civilizations. Similarly,
enabling foundational models like Large Language Models (LLMs) with the
capacity to learn external tool usage may serve as a pivotal step toward
realizing artificial general intelligence. Previous studies in this field have
predominantly pursued two distinct approaches to augment the tool invocation
capabilities of LLMs. The first approach emphasizes the construction of
relevant datasets for model fine-tuning. The second approach, in contrast, aims
to fully exploit the inherent reasoning abilities of LLMs through in-context
learning strategies. In this work, we introduce a novel tool invocation
pipeline designed to control massive real-world APIs. This pipeline mirrors the
human task-solving process, addressing complicated real-life user queries. At
each step, we guide LLMs to summarize the achieved results and determine the
next course of action. We term this pipeline `from Summary to action', Sum2Act
for short. Empirical evaluations of our Sum2Act pipeline on the ToolBench
benchmark show significant performance improvements, outperforming established
methods like ReAct and DFSDT. This highlights Sum2Act's effectiveness in
enhancing LLMs for complex real-world tasks.
|
[
-0.21365191042423248,
-0.7162737250328064,
0.42971327900886536,
0.014865231700241566,
-0.1853417158126831,
0.29863977432250977,
-0.275499552488327,
-0.3738020658493042,
0.03559952229261398,
0.7258342504501343,
-0.5364636778831482,
-0.25482457876205444,
-0.49536433815956116,
-0.08123086392879486,
-0.5335517525672913,
0.8808179497718811,
0.045545876026153564,
-0.05556240677833557,
-0.35236766934394836,
-0.10499271750450134,
-0.5710184574127197,
-0.37009066343307495,
-0.6067984104156494,
-0.4916175901889801,
0.3854674994945526,
0.47595304250717163,
0.670773983001709,
0.42379406094551086,
0.38252606987953186,
0.361499547958374,
0.04447333887219429,
0.41948238015174866,
-0.6176835894584656,
0.0958411693572998,
-0.3446117341518402,
-0.6922162771224976,
-0.3886045813560486,
-0.07552911341190338,
0.43593505024909973,
0.8120251893997192,
-0.10702695697546005,
0.41207125782966614,
0.19868001341819763,
0.39998114109039307,
-0.5810215473175049,
0.14471694827079773,
-0.5364564657211304,
-0.19370980560779572,
0.11231847107410431,
0.017936361953616142,
-0.38897332549095154,
-0.046161867678165436,
0.13094910979270935,
-0.48995035886764526,
-0.06536346673965454,
-0.009239587932825089,
0.3405647873878479,
0.523492157459259,
-0.25827622413635254,
-0.4502115249633789,
-0.6790362000465393,
0.7996445298194885,
-0.9501020908355713,
0.1694192886352539,
0.28115540742874146,
0.23076196014881134,
-0.5346092581748962,
-1.0281974077224731,
-0.4476761817932129,
0.11081471294164658,
-0.3510802686214447,
0.05442626401782036,
-0.15304693579673767,
0.0072044748812913895,
0.5162734389305115,
0.15677273273468018,
-0.53141188621521,
0.21069663763046265,
-0.37863799929618835,
-0.2155618965625763,
0.5309288501739502,
0.27006882429122925,
0.3666450083255768,
0.12409175932407379,
-0.10524635761976242,
0.05816302075982094,
-0.785180926322937,
0.2463161051273346,
0.2595788240432739,
0.3742094039916992,
-0.2570836842060089,
0.6572816967964172,
-0.1094670295715332,
0.6799511909484863,
-0.34501540660858154,
-0.11794579029083252,
-0.11635928601026535,
-0.07793393731117249,
-0.40985846519470215,
-0.2091556042432785,
0.5177010297775269,
0.18115279078483582,
0.1384691745042801,
-0.32362353801727295,
-0.18568947911262512,
-0.08431844413280487,
0.3690697252750397,
-0.8919751644134521,
0.06578405946493149,
0.6368248462677002,
-0.20393253862857819,
-0.15378756821155548,
-0.10545335710048676,
-0.5234359502792358,
-0.5111294984817505,
-0.6385083198547363,
0.3944815397262573,
-0.17258353531360626,
-0.3640420436859131,
0.014700987376272678,
-0.24089916050434113,
0.2951659560203552,
0.3212544620037079,
-0.7530630826950073,
0.5609374046325684,
1.0077522993087769,
1.0072401762008667,
-0.0037160052452236414,
-0.22320057451725006,
-0.8106170892715454,
0.2499706894159317,
-0.48422345519065857,
0.7682985663414001,
-0.5105660557746887,
-0.4028000235557556,
0.044321078807115555,
-0.14052768051624298,
0.30337971448898315,
-0.8201617002487183,
0.3693876564502716,
-0.4990985095500946,
0.2628777325153351,
-0.3071853220462799,
-0.43789926171302795,
-0.32697609066963196,
0.2131175696849823,
-0.5082505345344543,
1.1246554851531982,
0.3282286822795868,
-0.4388664960861206,
0.22283178567886353,
-1.139818549156189,
-0.5346571803092957,
0.020344842225313187,
-0.04879816994071007,
-0.12439785897731781,
0.2119237333536148,
0.21674616634845734,
0.5187773704528809,
-0.4954381585121155,
0.15266203880310059,
-0.22735252976417542,
-0.4598219096660614,
0.02754395268857479,
-0.01987033151090145,
0.8663028478622437,
-0.02927011251449585,
-0.2692691385746002,
0.44538140296936035,
-0.4436853528022766,
-0.012295684777200222,
0.006283029913902283,
-0.1323641836643219,
-0.3678295612335205,
0.0812908262014389,
-0.28148606419563293,
0.33517321944236755,
-0.030679749324917793,
-0.4133763611316681,
0.18930405378341675,
-0.8231903910636902,
0.7412388920783997,
0.5929532647132874,
-0.005733489990234375,
0.633582592010498,
-0.07973656803369522,
0.3490479290485382,
-0.3573724031448364,
-0.03761811926960945,
-0.31207475066185,
-0.2910543382167816,
-0.5535807609558105,
-0.44366687536239624,
0.12439464777708054,
0.6715409755706787,
-0.5936437845230103,
0.47439417243003845,
-0.26541629433631897,
-0.564152717590332,
-0.3137519657611847,
0.2950878441333771,
0.43911105394363403,
0.550546407699585,
0.27518031001091003,
-0.3844933807849884,
-0.47085073590278625,
-0.6644991040229797,
-0.2843717932701111,
-0.12706516683101654,
-0.6243055462837219,
0.41793757677078247,
0.5367743372917175,
-0.16339854896068573,
1.0420631170272827,
-0.4531673491001129,
-0.1939094513654709,
-0.38704627752304077,
0.287334680557251,
0.22052480280399323,
0.27025219798088074,
0.5184720754623413,
-0.6384034752845764,
-0.14456841349601746,
-0.2077602595090866,
-0.9411047697067261,
-0.11555120348930359,
-0.031552210450172424,
-0.3878036439418793,
-0.07322502881288528,
0.7612806558609009,
-0.5953653454780579,
0.2493419647216797,
0.2621152102947235,
-0.39589181542396545,
0.48739171028137207,
-0.09130696952342987,
-0.23503144085407257,
-0.939972996711731,
0.1135464608669281,
-0.25331568717956543,
-0.2624451518058777,
-0.5071463584899902,
0.3679000437259674,
0.08756230771541595,
-0.320156067609787,
-0.6441185474395752,
0.8237789869308472,
-0.4601411521434784,
-0.37967973947525024,
-0.38929736614227295,
0.0769212618470192,
-0.17501066625118256,
0.6277891397476196,
-0.2956315875053406,
0.8257856369018555,
0.5975780487060547,
-0.7565725445747375,
0.43701836466789246,
0.2670310139656067,
-0.25147557258605957,
0.3485599458217621,
-0.7834765911102295,
0.0072412509471178055,
-0.10578097403049469,
0.3715014159679413,
-1.1377685070037842,
-0.5747396945953369,
0.07601490616798401,
-0.4046402871608734,
0.24051518738269806,
-0.10059598088264465,
-0.8472426533699036,
-0.20747654139995575,
-0.2703060209751129,
0.07815664261579514,
0.5134223103523254,
-0.5548685789108276,
1.0541625022888184,
0.4777696430683136,
-0.34304141998291016,
-0.35929349064826965,
-0.6876841187477112,
0.25432875752449036,
-0.26476016640663147,
-0.403106689453125,
0.09839439392089844,
-0.11311246454715729,
-0.48228058218955994,
-0.21116255223751068,
0.005661700386554003,
0.08988949656486511,
0.16497580707073212,
0.30580663681030273,
0.08997684717178345,
0.08436233550310135,
0.30828535556793213,
0.28857719898223877,
-0.08511967211961746,
0.3002161979675293,
-0.14793293178081512,
0.6362944841384888,
0.09223729372024536,
-0.41302433609962463,
-0.20713338255882263,
0.48389512300491333,
0.8070945143699646,
-0.5154992341995239,
0.2199111133813858,
0.43299394845962524,
-0.35456615686416626,
-0.2984901964664459,
-0.3487778306007385,
-0.5817862153053284,
-0.4901762306690216,
0.49725231528282166,
-0.11395666003227234,
-0.7263146042823792,
0.5780554413795471,
-0.7322852611541748,
0.6698046326637268,
0.1156487762928009,
0.7357904314994812,
-0.17081649601459503,
1.0419162511825562,
0.4805455803871155,
-0.10851182043552399,
0.5356050729751587,
-0.6611818075180054,
0.1858317106962204,
-1.05918288230896,
0.06881999969482422,
-0.2095847725868225,
-0.6284708976745605,
-0.06530775874853134,
-0.596748948097229,
0.4816162884235382,
0.17699967324733734,
-0.43627944588661194,
0.14883387088775635,
-0.30684998631477356,
0.6548330783843994,
0.43801406025886536,
0.013939491473138332,
0.07766630500555038,
0.06434386223554611,
-0.09999073296785355,
0.19319909811019897,
-0.5518280267715454,
-0.603410542011261,
1.249715805053711,
0.25198253989219666,
0.5157774686813354,
0.342788428068161,
0.38029566407203674,
0.35252776741981506,
0.47137853503227234,
-1.0132956504821777,
0.6211727261543274,
0.09236308187246323,
-0.46440356969833374,
-0.46983158588409424,
0.1136581227183342,
-0.6901954412460327,
0.4321715533733368,
-0.08859162777662277,
-0.7570803761482239,
-0.1478736698627472,
0.05031723529100418,
-0.34015393257141113,
0.22417570650577545,
-0.885383665561676,
0.6188606023788452,
-0.3056429624557495,
-0.5889654159545898,
-0.4872267544269562,
-0.7993239164352417,
0.32518965005874634,
0.23338013887405396,
0.4588944613933563,
-0.029083631932735443,
-0.39500901103019714,
0.3865446150302887,
-0.38863229751586914,
1.1702799797058105,
-0.24992801249027252,
-0.3451445400714874,
0.35123294591903687,
0.12645083665847778,
0.8847627639770508,
0.022877339273691177,
-0.13377676904201508,
0.03366049379110336,
-0.4632883071899414,
-0.4867708384990692,
-0.8600806593894958,
0.593475341796875,
-0.5022950768470764,
-0.37309157848358154,
-0.09519491344690323,
-0.7443098425865173,
-0.46715787053108215,
0.2887595295906067,
-0.04242207854986191,
0.7933372259140015,
-0.0789533481001854,
0.10863981395959854,
0.5321971774101257,
-0.0854949802160263,
0.7534908652305603,
0.5658068656921387,
-0.2395825833082199,
-0.36449646949768066,
0.709620475769043,
-0.01727794110774994,
0.4050326347351074,
0.29783156514167786,
0.1917763203382492,
-0.40279632806777954,
-0.442363440990448,
-0.7082346677780151,
0.2807292342185974,
-0.6603879928588867,
-0.1513509601354599,
-0.5712221264839172,
0.23003247380256653,
-0.30479589104652405,
-0.22410354018211365,
-0.17172956466674805,
-0.215348482131958,
-0.2595554292201996,
-0.12310069054365158,
0.19148017466068268,
0.6356610655784607,
0.10462082177400589,
0.3311545252799988,
-0.6896631717681885,
0.4292071759700775,
0.43894705176353455,
0.3527933955192566,
0.16753491759300232,
-0.4710634648799896,
-0.29625988006591797,
0.10859805345535278,
-0.23373734951019287,
-0.5850167870521545,
0.2476220279932022,
0.30860376358032227,
0.5411619544029236,
0.39341098070144653,
0.12428843230009079,
0.7516281008720398,
-0.42735373973846436,
0.8867795467376709,
-0.13694609701633453,
-0.8060307502746582,
0.4804311990737915,
-0.2771744430065155,
0.39350810647010803,
0.07259517163038254,
0.29295140504837036,
-0.30886968970298767,
-0.580992579460144,
-0.4033932089805603,
-1.1293209791183472,
0.608609676361084,
0.07156558334827423,
0.3138420581817627,
0.2964857220649719,
0.33243197202682495,
0.005703137256205082,
0.1311020702123642,
-0.14025352895259857,
0.022237194702029228,
0.01489625871181488,
-0.04518881440162659,
0.0858147069811821,
-0.10468532145023346,
-0.35608965158462524,
-0.3597680926322937,
0.5593929290771484,
-0.4929400384426117,
0.029316389933228493,
0.033115871250629425,
-0.33875182271003723,
-0.04245629906654358,
0.2884595990180969,
0.5113328695297241,
0.9336566925048828,
0.005772036034613848,
-0.04115169122815132,
0.3157632648944855,
-0.3306002914905548,
-0.17590245604515076,
-0.11567166447639465,
-0.03320534899830818,
-0.4152471423149109,
0.6357505917549133,
0.6554129123687744,
0.3950873017311096,
-1.2975819110870361,
0.26378440856933594,
-0.05549655854701996,
-0.08598310500383377,
-0.3153124153614044,
0.197305366396904,
0.29769381880760193,
0.49355942010879517,
0.3973675072193146,
-0.01331007108092308,
0.33179208636283875,
-0.7034650444984436,
0.046855710446834564,
0.3754188120365143,
-0.38240480422973633,
-0.25001540780067444,
0.477042555809021,
0.29434633255004883,
-0.28250986337661743,
0.5466457605361938,
-0.24900348484516144,
-0.3915640413761139,
0.4738643765449524,
0.6128215789794922,
0.7715103030204773,
0.1143849641084671,
-0.03935733437538147,
0.45363935828208923,
0.16995678842067719,
0.02504708617925644,
0.38355064392089844,
-0.16758885979652405,
-0.48424792289733887,
-0.7890679240226746,
-0.5063677430152893,
-0.48167893290519714,
-0.016773344948887825,
-0.4613829553127289,
0.23980464041233063,
-0.4501209855079651,
0.2779616117477417,
-0.06778014451265335,
-0.14257989823818207,
-0.34646520018577576,
0.08722512423992157,
-0.12213863432407379,
0.8048673272132874,
-0.788303554058075,
0.5855824947357178,
0.7667006850242615,
-0.36979734897613525,
-0.8538067936897278,
-0.04189344868063927,
0.24647757411003113,
-0.5539644956588745,
0.4993857443332672,
0.0016152998432517052,
-0.26610562205314636,
0.13174182176589966,
-0.8039464950561523,
-0.805599570274353,
1.0859066247940063,
0.532174825668335,
-0.34171512722969055,
0.061155062168836594,
-0.030379747971892357,
0.6188427805900574,
-0.3490188419818878,
0.3763390779495239,
0.7477922439575195,
0.3471599817276001,
0.30376678705215454,
-0.8951343297958374,
0.06562644243240356,
-0.24392463266849518,
-0.2177310585975647,
0.36899182200431824,
-0.41106483340263367,
0.6627839803695679,
-0.4946863055229187,
-0.22571109235286713,
-0.041837144643068314,
0.55898118019104,
0.2564625144004822,
0.10558371245861053,
0.5185519456863403,
0.6698609590530396,
0.6837479472160339,
-0.00448837922886014,
1.1055015325546265,
-0.03464793041348457,
0.05053588002920151,
1.2851704359054565,
-0.31337112188339233,
1.0452532768249512,
0.306343138217926,
-0.344401478767395,
0.5310248732566833,
0.48277896642684937,
0.25727665424346924,
0.36508357524871826,
0.24323254823684692,
-0.29504838585853577,
-0.13376744091510773,
-0.24731223285198212,
0.03618288040161133,
0.5779983997344971,
0.6860643625259399,
-0.10472196340560913,
-0.4187557101249695,
0.09379489719867706,
0.17857488989830017,
0.13924458622932434,
-0.42820850014686584,
1.199734091758728,
-0.10126844048500061,
-0.7450225353240967,
0.4573765993118286,
-0.13777445256710052,
0.5649566054344177,
-0.7147958874702454,
-0.34484967589378357,
-0.047948114573955536,
0.17381246387958527,
-0.2524130642414093,
-0.7777224183082581,
0.49919113516807556,
0.06926794350147247,
-0.14900299906730652,
-0.1967787742614746,
0.6358311772346497,
-0.27445554733276367,
-0.37615400552749634,
0.32845404744148254,
0.3582390248775482,
0.24248532950878143,
-0.35236242413520813,
-0.4805904030799866,
-0.16491539776325226,
-0.1775098294019699,
-0.0652843564748764,
0.39566826820373535,
0.40031862258911133,
-0.35886022448539734,
0.7524327039718628,
0.8772376775741577,
0.17910830676555634,
-0.1609303504228592,
0.09878962486982346,
1.0417125225067139,
-0.4610348641872406,
-0.5649611949920654,
-0.8027804493904114,
0.7621545791625977,
-0.23253659904003143,
-0.09409606456756592,
0.46412917971611023,
0.791975200176239,
0.8489112854003906,
-0.010953796096146107,
1.0233248472213745,
-0.21841871738433838,
0.9278654456138611,
-0.3053376376628876,
0.5514200925827026,
-0.587192714214325,
0.27864202857017517,
-0.1204514130949974,
-0.5895823836326599,
-0.44944024085998535,
0.2138492465019226,
-0.1601056307554245,
-0.34692278504371643,
0.412272185087204,
0.851456880569458,
-0.16812719404697418,
-0.1723497062921524,
0.20707900822162628,
0.26057735085487366,
0.728825032711029,
0.20395104587078094,
0.4742068946361542,
-0.21076220273971558,
0.5010948181152344,
-0.024165984243154526,
-0.4845808744430542,
-0.1328255981206894,
-0.8899136185646057,
-0.9016435146331787,
-0.28467872738838196,
0.12006458640098572,
-0.03365781158208847,
-0.2610761821269989,
1.1161832809448242,
0.6785377860069275,
-0.7666670083999634,
-0.4333280026912689,
-0.16903692483901978,
0.0920913964509964,
-0.5014328360557556,
-0.1615670621395111,
0.33721163868904114,
-0.49085676670074463,
-0.7759280204772949,
0.39711228013038635,
0.4842682480812073,
-0.19318275153636932,
-0.5233970880508423,
-0.13913123309612274,
-0.05759888514876366,
0.06392005831003189,
1.1008938550949097,
0.45672380924224854,
-0.9243841767311096,
-0.08548802137374878,
-0.1100907251238823,
0.2724602520465851,
-0.257725328207016,
1.1708041429519653,
-0.967837929725647,
0.5385450124740601,
0.6292656064033508,
0.6111026406288147,
0.2627080976963043,
0.04623144492506981,
0.6878117918968201,
-0.8928213119506836,
0.32598739862442017,
0.3565951883792877,
0.30386847257614136,
0.22185082733631134,
-0.19279679656028748,
0.7222486138343811,
-0.11047245562076569,
-0.361438125371933,
-0.8685013055801392,
0.4051669239997864,
-0.7798080444335938,
-0.43037235736846924,
0.98504638671875,
-0.11130733788013458,
-0.026750657707452774,
-0.23901969194412231,
-0.5646381974220276,
0.2656012773513794,
-0.38893619179725647,
0.6721540093421936,
0.5009679198265076,
-0.344387024641037,
-0.023145047947764397,
-0.7115057706832886,
0.2800065279006958,
0.03299583122134209,
-1.0454245805740356,
0.47670504450798035,
0.578281581401825,
0.22065488994121552,
0.14609506726264954,
0.3825121819972992,
-0.2103012353181839,
0.07676607370376587,
-0.21769511699676514,
-0.038147181272506714,
-0.22057189047336578,
-0.31830283999443054,
0.008684598840773106,
0.19756928086280823,
-0.007469245698302984,
0.022196631878614426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18154v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18154v1
|
Cutting Off the Head Ends the Conflict: A Mechanism for Interpreting and Mitigating Knowledge Conflicts in Language Models
| 2024-02-28T08:34:41 | 2024-02-28T08:34:41 |
Zhuoran Jin, Pengfei Cao, Hongbang Yuan, Yubo Chen, Jiexin Xu, Huaijun Li, Xiaojian Jiang, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Recently, retrieval augmentation and tool augmentation have demonstrated a
remarkable capability to expand the internal memory boundaries of language
models (LMs) by providing external context. However, internal memory and
external context inevitably clash, leading to knowledge conflicts within LMs.
In this paper, we aim to interpret the mechanism of knowledge conflicts through
the lens of information flow, and then mitigate conflicts by precise
interventions at the pivotal point. We find there are some attention heads with
opposite effects in the later layers, where memory heads can recall knowledge
from internal memory, and context heads can retrieve knowledge from external
context. Moreover, we reveal that the pivotal point at which knowledge
conflicts emerge in LMs is the integration of inconsistent information flows by
memory heads and context heads. Inspired by the insights, we propose a novel
method called Pruning Head via PatH PatcHing (PH3), which can efficiently
mitigate knowledge conflicts by pruning conflicting attention heads without
updating model parameters. PH3 can flexibly control eight LMs to use internal
memory ($\uparrow$ 44.0%) or external context ($\uparrow$ 38.5%). Moreover, PH3
can also improve the performance of LMs on open-domain QA tasks. We also
conduct extensive experiments to demonstrate the cross-model, cross-relation,
and cross-format generalization of our method.
|
[
-0.4554039239883423,
-0.923819899559021,
0.6994247436523438,
-0.0845504105091095,
-0.31788599491119385,
0.04548051580786705,
-0.2148442268371582,
-0.4778378903865814,
-0.018749592825770378,
0.7428184747695923,
-0.6885074973106384,
0.030744118615984917,
-0.6072791218757629,
-0.2982975244522095,
-0.19575224816799164,
0.9002419114112854,
-0.1704653948545456,
-0.27317705750465393,
-0.1776679903268814,
-0.21433600783348083,
-0.7828733325004578,
-0.4231013059616089,
-0.8127413392066956,
-0.3074548840522766,
0.6404987573623657,
0.2055922895669937,
0.6888394355773926,
1.0561829805374146,
0.8196878433227539,
0.24957582354545593,
-0.37824779748916626,
0.21319833397865295,
-0.6312034130096436,
0.37568795680999756,
-0.4989444315433502,
-0.40927067399024963,
-0.13796281814575195,
-0.16883881390094757,
0.620341956615448,
0.6436074376106262,
0.07805995643138885,
-0.11060788482427597,
0.2297162413597107,
0.9286743998527527,
-0.7834154963493347,
-0.029483545571565628,
-0.7820761799812317,
-0.10529185831546783,
-0.4504885673522949,
-0.43726545572280884,
-0.13201496005058289,
-0.22741614282131195,
0.40432387590408325,
-0.38909807801246643,
-0.2784860134124756,
-0.28594017028808594,
1.0303683280944824,
0.405181348323822,
-0.2624872028827667,
-0.12114822864532471,
-0.7609906196594238,
0.744624674320221,
-0.7969551086425781,
0.19953325390815735,
0.3258499205112457,
0.32977813482284546,
-0.07390651106834412,
-0.524296224117279,
-0.5183361172676086,
0.46019503474235535,
0.1147257462143898,
-0.08407405018806458,
-0.4314824938774109,
-0.0803091898560524,
0.3275281488895416,
0.10524255782365799,
-0.1539720892906189,
-0.2809988260269165,
-0.6944456100463867,
0.08368831872940063,
0.290523499250412,
-0.008956249803304672,
0.4242633879184723,
0.14833925664424896,
-0.3666573166847229,
-0.005798622965812683,
-1.0456184148788452,
0.14292258024215698,
0.27573084831237793,
0.22865159809589386,
0.2969050705432892,
0.4222298562526703,
-0.011323919519782066,
1.0516175031661987,
0.22674937546253204,
-0.370331346988678,
-0.07662589848041534,
-0.28213822841644287,
-0.3198075592517853,
-0.21537069976329803,
0.6537884473800659,
0.6479110717773438,
0.254470556974411,
-0.12277346849441528,
-0.09487579762935638,
-0.08931613713502884,
0.4682035744190216,
-0.6116414666175842,
-0.051681626588106155,
0.27385473251342773,
-0.10383357107639313,
-0.09019122272729874,
-0.16963467001914978,
-0.671116292476654,
-0.3844130039215088,
-0.25315335392951965,
0.5264820456504822,
-0.6440542936325073,
-0.5137366652488708,
-0.07968061417341232,
-0.10773599147796631,
0.12668149173259735,
0.3619112968444824,
-0.32758235931396484,
0.10872532427310944,
0.6692973375320435,
1.0235190391540527,
-0.20244340598583221,
-0.20588988065719604,
-0.26722848415374756,
0.5929053425788879,
-0.32209333777427673,
0.6188480854034424,
-0.472187340259552,
-0.18951955437660217,
-0.08876561373472214,
-0.10969280451536179,
-0.3096432685852051,
-0.8471014499664307,
0.2244158834218979,
-0.6210975646972656,
0.09216699749231339,
-0.5338080525398254,
-0.5160969495773315,
-0.5009530782699585,
0.3409585952758789,
-0.744675874710083,
0.6446210741996765,
0.1329685002565384,
-0.8465422987937927,
0.0923675149679184,
-0.421744167804718,
-0.3573445677757263,
-0.020662257447838783,
-0.2333858758211136,
-0.32846349477767944,
-0.24158573150634766,
0.01751689612865448,
0.10117747634649277,
-0.4433745741844177,
0.28908437490463257,
-0.1545267254114151,
-0.2372675985097885,
-0.033531539142131805,
0.1807674765586853,
0.8334693312644958,
0.13844828307628632,
-0.4234054684638977,
0.3000909686088562,
-0.396753191947937,
-0.17930938303470612,
0.2062830924987793,
-0.09761957824230194,
-0.7548932433128357,
-0.040197987109422684,
-0.45483750104904175,
0.6692795753479004,
0.006974173244088888,
-0.3733507990837097,
0.14011016488075256,
-0.28882884979248047,
0.46917030215263367,
0.7581841945648193,
0.5533474087715149,
0.4133097231388092,
-0.7777661681175232,
0.521781325340271,
0.512902557849884,
0.18051950633525848,
-0.14573146402835846,
-0.7011346817016602,
-0.7598513960838318,
0.09004605561494827,
-0.17131257057189941,
0.4495205879211426,
-0.7728942632675171,
0.2960554361343384,
-0.1085205078125,
-0.36018115282058716,
-0.5224913954734802,
0.10914742946624756,
0.4159199297428131,
0.7308611273765564,
0.20835794508457184,
-0.38495635986328125,
-0.5025122761726379,
-0.8346689939498901,
-0.6513473987579346,
-0.19850371778011322,
0.08852803707122803,
0.25923028588294983,
0.0009373180218972266,
0.00570673868060112,
1.340944528579712,
-0.33610275387763977,
-0.5407889485359192,
-0.23521758615970612,
0.025197559967637062,
-0.03366038203239441,
0.6938820481300354,
0.36620768904685974,
-0.7807022929191589,
-0.4137433171272278,
0.08213724195957184,
-0.5754533410072327,
-0.1378222554922104,
-0.2930371165275574,
-0.44869524240493774,
-0.037750933319330215,
0.430298388004303,
-0.7961143851280212,
0.46199139952659607,
0.20168669521808624,
-0.3601042926311493,
0.3838180899620056,
0.2946741580963135,
0.15600118041038513,
-0.549897313117981,
0.14130061864852905,
0.010115807875990868,
-0.1629151552915573,
-0.870893120765686,
0.32745400071144104,
0.15784642100334167,
0.21873724460601807,
-0.6654585599899292,
0.6204564571380615,
-0.48967546224594116,
0.23200280964374542,
-0.3957458436489105,
0.38413935899734497,
0.24195873737335205,
0.7307150959968567,
0.18938954174518585,
0.5036141872406006,
0.37080901861190796,
-0.8257167339324951,
0.0022484275978058577,
0.19083112478256226,
-0.10230141133069992,
0.7167274951934814,
-0.21196061372756958,
0.346288800239563,
-0.1997140794992447,
-0.14071226119995117,
-0.5753750205039978,
0.17910510301589966,
0.5513579845428467,
-0.1916203498840332,
0.2260512262582779,
-0.26485878229141235,
-0.08315572142601013,
-0.036413710564374924,
-0.45944178104400635,
0.6456306576728821,
0.47979316115379333,
-0.20576107501983643,
0.5390315055847168,
0.7692584991455078,
-0.2632896900177002,
-0.4575728476047516,
-0.6263781189918518,
-0.06964488327503204,
-0.46499624848365784,
-0.7019864916801453,
0.3219115734100342,
-0.19854265451431274,
-0.47359544038772583,
0.10565121471881866,
-0.36298203468322754,
-0.44300082325935364,
-0.17726196348667145,
-0.04430028423666954,
0.06329617649316788,
-0.13266688585281372,
0.016424857079982758,
0.0645802691578865,
0.22991693019866943,
0.1290893405675888,
-0.3135633170604706,
0.29791516065597534,
0.2326669692993164,
-0.410521924495697,
-0.11789915710687637,
0.2850985527038574,
0.7555007934570312,
-0.24709080159664154,
0.837458610534668,
0.29676687717437744,
-0.5742252469062805,
0.133829265832901,
-0.8724439144134521,
-0.2849739193916321,
-0.43595650792121887,
0.3297525942325592,
-0.4374487102031708,
-0.7355734705924988,
0.5090826749801636,
-0.17717769742012024,
0.2639741599559784,
0.3329882323741913,
0.43649861216545105,
0.25659483671188354,
0.7405644059181213,
0.5948249101638794,
0.05546657368540764,
0.5495279431343079,
-0.047081608325242996,
0.4710938036441803,
-1.2888457775115967,
-0.15346157550811768,
-0.17796695232391357,
-0.304483562707901,
0.034341584891080856,
-0.7049643993377686,
0.4384390413761139,
0.6693511605262756,
-0.028676612302660942,
0.5097912549972534,
-0.5195105075836182,
0.35987502336502075,
0.43698054552078247,
0.050929516553878784,
0.42177465558052063,
-0.307485967874527,
-0.2037190943956375,
-0.21070250868797302,
-0.8004583716392517,
-0.23771482706069946,
0.7960969805717468,
0.4823034107685089,
0.3895183503627777,
0.12121710926294327,
0.3009532392024994,
-0.14184819161891937,
0.11176930367946625,
-0.5988879203796387,
0.47844749689102173,
0.45936280488967896,
-0.3970161974430084,
-0.3369266092777252,
-0.5270431637763977,
-0.8127906322479248,
0.581649661064148,
0.2585654556751251,
-0.991278350353241,
0.4024541676044464,
0.1563950777053833,
-0.469439297914505,
0.8052944540977478,
-0.6248781085014343,
0.9761122465133667,
0.06579124182462692,
-0.5754160284996033,
-0.2548224627971649,
-0.5903739333152771,
0.6675142049789429,
-0.16552534699440002,
0.4931296408176422,
-0.010797579772770405,
0.08626418560743332,
1.1196398735046387,
-0.3962950110435486,
0.5359909534454346,
-0.16874919831752777,
-0.21952514350414276,
0.5623962879180908,
0.386675626039505,
0.6771673560142517,
-0.3015473783016205,
0.33472588658332825,
0.0729631781578064,
0.015017898753285408,
-0.24851249158382416,
-0.5369876027107239,
0.5477138757705688,
-0.4146442115306854,
-0.8271453380584717,
-0.22400325536727905,
-0.8794241547584534,
-0.4126876890659332,
0.2817838490009308,
0.037910085171461105,
0.1566668152809143,
0.2566598653793335,
-0.14606602489948273,
0.7077013254165649,
-0.15794765949249268,
0.4057888984680176,
0.5843362808227539,
-0.27655863761901855,
-0.06343366205692291,
1.0166455507278442,
0.2762148082256317,
0.569426417350769,
0.20385877788066864,
0.22807036340236664,
0.10318396985530853,
-0.4537302553653717,
-0.2135566622018814,
0.3227859139442444,
-0.7475964426994324,
-0.40681713819503784,
-0.7940138578414917,
-0.3746805787086487,
-0.3504383862018585,
0.1832156628370285,
-0.43934735655784607,
-0.2843921482563019,
0.12167882174253464,
0.20964355766773224,
0.34359070658683777,
0.8795180916786194,
-0.213224396109581,
0.4628927707672119,
-0.8695642948150635,
0.11202389001846313,
0.220345139503479,
0.145205557346344,
0.22157660126686096,
-0.48100894689559937,
-0.5434474349021912,
-0.05633342266082764,
-0.5656633973121643,
-1.3307554721832275,
0.5475446581840515,
-0.140203058719635,
0.2727642059326172,
0.670466423034668,
0.053203318268060684,
0.8655133247375488,
-0.4420420229434967,
0.43160000443458557,
0.1642690747976303,
-1.001766324043274,
0.44575235247612,
-0.4391707181930542,
0.6385927796363831,
0.19438470900058746,
0.16843996942043304,
-0.9660652279853821,
-0.8922532200813293,
-0.4872981905937195,
-1.156456708908081,
0.79271399974823,
0.2044437825679779,
-0.6211204528808594,
0.024943148717284203,
0.22341586649417877,
-0.1319935917854309,
0.30077609419822693,
-0.5017676949501038,
-0.12627819180488586,
0.234544575214386,
0.023766599595546722,
0.6530763506889343,
-0.26043614745140076,
-0.43747982382774353,
-0.13434387743473053,
0.80352383852005,
0.09617292135953903,
0.1855221688747406,
0.20799361169338226,
-0.3140975534915924,
-0.6210639476776123,
0.13144391775131226,
0.581113338470459,
1.1285851001739502,
-0.11620472371578217,
0.09034091979265213,
-0.10402683913707733,
-0.46617430448532104,
-0.1151161789894104,
-0.34495818614959717,
-0.5155017971992493,
-0.04792621731758118,
0.295614629983902,
0.8224559426307678,
0.23418374359607697,
-0.6796907782554626,
0.42191120982170105,
0.1556195169687271,
0.06650448590517044,
0.14885114133358002,
-0.26225778460502625,
0.20315517485141754,
0.2401968240737915,
0.4579515755176544,
0.3726520538330078,
0.011203909292817116,
-0.284936785697937,
0.4456052780151367,
0.5272390842437744,
-0.5496346354484558,
-0.08791850507259369,
0.18746891617774963,
0.027035631239414215,
-0.2769332528114319,
0.2348807454109192,
0.01589144952595234,
-0.7153233289718628,
0.35824140906333923,
0.2537862956523895,
0.6411406993865967,
-0.40025395154953003,
-0.125124990940094,
0.3005973994731903,
0.553505003452301,
0.048701703548431396,
0.06755395978689194,
0.04930070787668228,
-0.6792769432067871,
-0.6569757461547852,
-0.21509066224098206,
-0.42103952169418335,
0.4486621916294098,
-0.7792273759841919,
-0.0831696018576622,
-0.42315593361854553,
-0.11545063555240631,
-0.4935428202152252,
-0.23114119470119476,
-0.6230512857437134,
0.06384105235338211,
-0.054072584956884384,
0.821431040763855,
-0.5116605162620544,
0.9127427339553833,
0.5054494738578796,
-0.3817751407623291,
-0.6979423761367798,
0.33213943243026733,
0.16367295384407043,
-0.5791459083557129,
0.5025340914726257,
0.11671987175941467,
-0.10613338649272919,
-0.1531180739402771,
-0.030610600486397743,
-1.0639415979385376,
0.6739646792411804,
0.4778251647949219,
-0.6570603847503662,
-0.23797199130058289,
-0.12567609548568726,
0.006744203623384237,
-0.10410290956497192,
0.2578725218772888,
0.7125993371009827,
0.6710026264190674,
0.0196083877235651,
-1.0935717821121216,
0.2983550727367401,
-0.16077208518981934,
-0.12184273451566696,
0.3410389721393585,
-0.5216362476348877,
0.9582658410072327,
-0.07645166665315628,
-0.6220812797546387,
-0.3314104974269867,
0.4557844400405884,
0.20053119957447052,
-0.09299467504024506,
0.6605995297431946,
0.5082122087478638,
0.5022469162940979,
-0.10819896310567856,
0.7188875079154968,
-0.5938233137130737,
0.1348460167646408,
0.9151773452758789,
-0.237822487950325,
0.641608715057373,
0.9767466187477112,
-0.25873303413391113,
0.35749953985214233,
0.4740943908691406,
0.6121344566345215,
0.713262140750885,
0.12846966087818146,
-0.11160808801651001,
-0.03273795545101166,
-0.13571138679981232,
-0.41809865832328796,
0.10522697120904922,
0.29920297861099243,
0.04011576622724533,
-0.37528443336486816,
0.047709327191114426,
0.2771071493625641,
-0.07768564671278,
-0.21750898659229279,
0.8292850255966187,
0.19406381249427795,
-1.0206072330474854,
0.46882474422454834,
0.07739952951669693,
0.506367564201355,
-0.7477810382843018,
-0.16087086498737335,
0.010353869758546352,
0.3946797549724579,
-0.01919833943247795,
-0.7087984085083008,
0.7087365388870239,
-0.3785966634750366,
-0.14287081360816956,
-0.15087874233722687,
0.7356324791908264,
-0.8688522577285767,
-0.0059529757127165794,
0.6827095746994019,
0.7052270174026489,
-0.0016667131567373872,
-0.44860604405403137,
-0.6593388915061951,
0.3876825273036957,
0.0065879132598638535,
-0.3611326813697815,
0.5908837914466858,
0.48243218660354614,
-0.14591951668262482,
0.4967094957828522,
0.5496198534965515,
0.3785756528377533,
0.10519735515117645,
-0.10383289307355881,
1.0570473670959473,
-0.6305935978889465,
-0.7321270108222961,
-1.0466408729553223,
0.44739559292793274,
-0.14622710645198822,
-0.08045411854982376,
0.6852113604545593,
0.2110762745141983,
0.7824184894561768,
0.09904135018587112,
0.8100076913833618,
-0.019772805273532867,
0.7902559638023376,
-0.33899229764938354,
0.6766176819801331,
-0.3371713161468506,
0.30226922035217285,
-0.317426472902298,
-0.5704633593559265,
-0.07198689132928848,
0.6820694804191589,
-0.25004369020462036,
0.0016156852943822742,
0.9743670225143433,
0.5020760297775269,
0.09818892925977707,
-0.22989307343959808,
0.32158610224723816,
0.3105926215648651,
0.11846887320280075,
1.0217913389205933,
0.5139826536178589,
-0.3120591342449188,
0.7084178924560547,
-0.5763585567474365,
-0.37371504306793213,
0.11346229165792465,
-0.6942218542098999,
-0.7799676656723022,
-0.6376031041145325,
-0.4872252941131592,
-0.35351887345314026,
0.3207238018512726,
0.5944635272026062,
0.7857983112335205,
-0.64129638671875,
-0.4354325532913208,
-0.11818823963403702,
0.5088898539543152,
-0.6811755895614624,
-0.2983110249042511,
0.26990699768066406,
-0.32542046904563904,
-0.5035443902015686,
0.388632595539093,
0.4967782497406006,
-0.33597421646118164,
-0.4556484520435333,
-0.13651980459690094,
-0.46119874715805054,
0.17663267254829407,
0.3597579300403595,
0.4524403512477875,
-0.892701268196106,
-0.19633156061172485,
-0.3280945420265198,
0.020459746941924095,
0.27653080224990845,
1.1954118013381958,
-0.9539015293121338,
0.3214435875415802,
0.3105875849723816,
0.7970287799835205,
0.21680665016174316,
-0.07783292233943939,
1.1214330196380615,
-0.7585904598236084,
0.09643398225307465,
0.1356980800628662,
0.25310245156288147,
0.43764159083366394,
-0.5251510143280029,
0.4120291471481323,
0.29837295413017273,
-0.3248252868652344,
-0.9568055272102356,
0.3949132561683655,
-0.6553856134414673,
-0.45094946026802063,
1.079969048500061,
-0.39526811242103577,
-0.3122209310531616,
-0.14882172644138336,
-0.18971380591392517,
0.5036929845809937,
-0.16819173097610474,
0.7440906167030334,
0.680729329586029,
-0.05144025757908821,
-0.4409278631210327,
-0.5962279438972473,
0.8680413961410522,
0.4767838418483734,
-0.7012468576431274,
0.17389187216758728,
0.13415966928005219,
0.06659884750843048,
0.3402032256126404,
0.638703465461731,
-0.11568998545408249,
0.28209054470062256,
-0.37857505679130554,
0.024646786972880363,
-0.027790404856204987,
-0.37877988815307617,
-0.23295153677463531,
0.2522238790988922,
-0.04020751640200615,
-0.07335325330495834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00830v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00830v1
|
MedAide: Leveraging Large Language Models for On-Premise Medical Assistance on Edge Devices
| 2024-02-28T08:30:49 | 2024-02-28T08:30:49 |
Abdul Basit, Khizar Hussain, Muhammad Abdullah Hanif, Muhammad Shafique
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) are revolutionizing various domains with their
remarkable natural language processing (NLP) abilities. However, deploying LLMs
in resource-constrained edge computing and embedded systems presents
significant challenges. Another challenge lies in delivering medical assistance
in remote areas with limited healthcare facilities and infrastructure. To
address this, we introduce MedAide, an on-premise healthcare chatbot. It
leverages tiny-LLMs integrated with LangChain, providing efficient edge-based
preliminary medical diagnostics and support. MedAide employs model
optimizations for minimal memory footprint and latency on embedded edge devices
without server infrastructure. The training process is optimized using low-rank
adaptation (LoRA). Additionally, the model is trained on diverse medical
datasets, employing reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) to
enhance its domain-specific capabilities. The system is implemented on various
consumer GPUs and Nvidia Jetson development board. MedAide achieves 77\%
accuracy in medical consultations and scores 56 in USMLE benchmark, enabling an
energy-efficient healthcare assistance platform that alleviates privacy
concerns due to edge-based deployment, thereby empowering the community.
|
[
-0.19353577494621277,
-0.7471522688865662,
0.6948502063751221,
-0.038886263966560364,
-0.363153338432312,
0.18023507297039032,
-0.24642343819141388,
-0.5375423431396484,
0.43640953302383423,
0.5230481028556824,
-0.5488992929458618,
-0.5196691751480103,
-0.4877719581127167,
-0.09502293914556503,
0.16017790138721466,
1.0020743608474731,
0.1777784377336502,
0.24382100999355316,
-0.1890249103307724,
-0.23780664801597595,
-0.22295241057872772,
-0.22143800556659698,
-1.2808605432510376,
-0.4071609079837799,
0.30794230103492737,
0.41981565952301025,
1.042879343032837,
0.5757973194122314,
0.5908039212226868,
0.23050299286842346,
0.2133094221353531,
0.36033275723457336,
-0.3331921100616455,
-0.07741041481494904,
-0.07460133731365204,
-0.42369821667671204,
-0.8095077872276306,
-0.38654693961143494,
0.10717393457889557,
0.5963197946548462,
-0.476481556892395,
-0.007377303671091795,
-0.25685009360313416,
0.47890204191207886,
-0.3859877288341522,
-0.028233183547854424,
-0.6105989217758179,
-0.0919361412525177,
0.011892983689904213,
0.20200440287590027,
-0.2523643374443054,
-0.3166479170322418,
0.2584330141544342,
-0.5616574883460999,
-0.15554261207580566,
0.050816331058740616,
0.8192396759986877,
0.46257802844047546,
-0.21347984671592712,
-0.22470322251319885,
-0.5226598978042603,
0.6366869211196899,
-0.8844195604324341,
0.4280303120613098,
0.5164005160331726,
0.4730302691459656,
-0.35016578435897827,
-1.0856693983078003,
-0.28642985224723816,
-0.20195156335830688,
0.2718413472175598,
-0.011201359331607819,
-0.41394859552383423,
0.3694263696670532,
-0.029671842232346535,
0.24001160264015198,
-0.23771992325782776,
0.5975243449211121,
0.025250807404518127,
-0.09855055809020996,
0.38637447357177734,
0.09509286284446716,
0.5463781356811523,
-0.24121294915676117,
-0.3021000623703003,
0.17640350759029388,
-0.784950852394104,
-0.042249761521816254,
-0.5003764033317566,
0.34232309460639954,
-0.38147038221359253,
0.3893042802810669,
-0.0122760608792305,
0.5040841102600098,
-0.0995255559682846,
-0.6035120487213135,
0.14336785674095154,
0.060873351991176605,
-0.40468722581863403,
0.1757715344429016,
0.6672278046607971,
0.3716597557067871,
-0.13504962623119354,
-0.14289270341396332,
-0.34041306376457214,
-0.05465342849493027,
0.21004727482795715,
-0.7937324643135071,
-0.22367173433303833,
0.4917304217815399,
-0.6047554612159729,
-0.16863428056240082,
-0.7350878715515137,
-0.6128240823745728,
-0.885116696357727,
0.02514978125691414,
0.19025664031505585,
-0.3991067707538605,
-0.07566678524017334,
0.11224956065416336,
0.10702358931303024,
0.03558338060975075,
0.33580589294433594,
-0.8054819703102112,
0.7144311666488647,
0.5803019404411316,
1.1249561309814453,
-0.07803095132112503,
0.21681331098079681,
-0.6716017127037048,
-0.04084086790680885,
-0.06785168498754501,
0.7378741502761841,
-0.3046585023403168,
-0.48138660192489624,
0.028786133974790573,
0.06615579128265381,
-0.1770220547914505,
-0.6622310280799866,
0.6926032900810242,
-0.20944297313690186,
-0.06723710149526596,
0.3405478000640869,
-0.4437488317489624,
0.05453227832913399,
0.10486020147800446,
-0.4837602972984314,
0.6390190124511719,
0.17588543891906738,
-0.5160253047943115,
0.09141098707914352,
-0.9504123330116272,
-0.4588068425655365,
0.3798326253890991,
-0.3059558570384979,
-0.5976033806800842,
0.26277101039886475,
0.5071619749069214,
0.47657686471939087,
-0.6173239350318909,
0.1026737242937088,
-0.21649585664272308,
0.03851078450679779,
0.06164562329649925,
-0.26000142097473145,
0.5681778192520142,
0.21055229008197784,
-0.21916626393795013,
0.25106728076934814,
-0.6623131632804871,
0.11890153586864471,
0.29477009177207947,
-0.016631808131933212,
-0.46923941373825073,
0.2020256072282791,
0.3030989170074463,
0.05321352556347847,
0.2457856982946396,
-0.7019534707069397,
0.2659314274787903,
-0.7053369879722595,
0.5189409852027893,
0.5155551433563232,
0.030874941498041153,
0.26971325278282166,
-0.5151607394218445,
0.565636396408081,
-0.33772504329681396,
0.41177278757095337,
0.16993239521980286,
-0.6954582929611206,
-0.3253729045391083,
-0.7277252674102783,
0.34214797616004944,
0.8506143093109131,
-0.8740386366844177,
0.13587193191051483,
-0.5803297162055969,
-0.4355623424053192,
-0.9625392556190491,
0.06168874725699425,
0.06742902100086212,
0.4026661813259125,
0.26870501041412354,
0.08911795169115067,
-0.3397788107395172,
-0.9992989301681519,
0.1317225843667984,
0.011546212248504162,
-0.3816176652908325,
0.7035670876502991,
0.14848776161670685,
-0.725443959236145,
0.8710813522338867,
-0.4737458825111389,
-0.5310176610946655,
-0.43822288513183594,
-0.27560651302337646,
0.27531135082244873,
0.41761696338653564,
0.3472133278846741,
-0.6652989983558655,
-0.23834767937660217,
0.4915802776813507,
-0.5647004246711731,
-0.22065597772598267,
0.07696100324392319,
0.29982680082321167,
0.20125846564769745,
0.3381500840187073,
-0.5704517364501953,
0.21489430963993073,
0.9438443183898926,
-0.0036435320507735014,
-0.0017754660220816731,
-0.5530650019645691,
-0.058965932577848434,
-1.4556493759155273,
0.008076878264546394,
-0.11634892225265503,
-0.5654336214065552,
-0.5567567348480225,
-0.12226400524377823,
-0.17443333566188812,
-0.5870651602745056,
-0.37325456738471985,
0.6971973776817322,
-0.15028159320354462,
0.04928557574748993,
-0.5651765465736389,
0.31359514594078064,
-0.11578550189733505,
0.163161501288414,
0.09966106712818146,
0.6454448103904724,
0.39943212270736694,
-0.3796345293521881,
0.2529483735561371,
0.13282492756843567,
-0.07114063203334808,
0.6133435964584351,
-0.8580596446990967,
0.12887042760849,
0.17684586346149445,
0.18294782936573029,
-0.5575905442237854,
-0.28895142674446106,
0.028953664004802704,
-0.2127395123243332,
0.04953256621956825,
-0.29617851972579956,
-0.36716076731681824,
-0.2052297592163086,
-0.1480732560157776,
0.3128438889980316,
0.8888120651245117,
-0.5654413104057312,
0.7763742208480835,
0.7787156105041504,
-0.46867719292640686,
-0.21565672755241394,
-0.4213722348213196,
0.1395025998353958,
-0.05414680019021034,
-0.6769580245018005,
0.2842003405094147,
0.3006347119808197,
-0.3878519535064697,
-0.14239372313022614,
0.1295795440673828,
-0.13309283554553986,
0.21451713144779205,
0.7013797760009766,
0.33514639735221863,
-0.2099742591381073,
0.4301813542842865,
0.26808857917785645,
-0.10255349427461624,
-0.024138974025845528,
-0.47518959641456604,
0.4795820713043213,
-0.1531868875026703,
-0.388217955827713,
-0.5264732241630554,
0.288685142993927,
0.7127007842063904,
-0.02454499714076519,
0.7093681693077087,
0.30966654419898987,
-0.762569010257721,
-0.18844188749790192,
-0.4090394675731659,
-0.3526332676410675,
-0.49436765909194946,
0.48379164934158325,
-0.13625302910804749,
-0.7136048078536987,
0.5828714966773987,
-0.6425754427909851,
0.2723441421985626,
0.38010263442993164,
0.4812568426132202,
-0.07852187752723694,
1.0250508785247803,
0.6680516600608826,
-0.18778406083583832,
0.2808934152126312,
-0.018888365477323532,
0.21547788381576538,
-0.6549877524375916,
-0.1821308135986328,
-0.4028845727443695,
-0.13026563823223114,
-0.7510557770729065,
-0.4830181300640106,
0.8403589725494385,
-0.15539966523647308,
-0.059100192040205,
-0.06665991991758347,
-0.3554378151893616,
0.12087996304035187,
0.06875253468751907,
0.44918033480644226,
0.17072245478630066,
0.09568456560373306,
-0.13627642393112183,
-0.04146016016602516,
-0.9829486608505249,
-0.4166261553764343,
0.9020072817802429,
0.6600955128669739,
0.9672126770019531,
-0.017388593405485153,
0.5124551057815552,
0.4315353035926819,
0.5201016664505005,
-0.9340893626213074,
0.3134307265281677,
-0.4069484770298004,
-0.1727713942527771,
-0.10071913152933121,
-0.3351135551929474,
-1.1001911163330078,
0.039993464946746826,
-0.3124712407588959,
-0.715690016746521,
-0.12084095925092697,
0.03723428398370743,
-0.5839781761169434,
0.459823876619339,
-0.6759917140007019,
0.7189037203788757,
-0.11682864278554916,
-0.10331473499536514,
-0.43617796897888184,
-0.5206555724143982,
-0.05062873288989067,
0.046354278922080994,
0.4885518550872803,
-0.18280468881130219,
-0.16448812186717987,
0.6696683764457703,
-0.7753943204879761,
0.9287235736846924,
-0.24888350069522858,
-0.1570364236831665,
0.011251324787735939,
-0.06825564056634903,
0.5853244662284851,
0.26831385493278503,
0.14481103420257568,
0.17016753554344177,
-0.17582911252975464,
-0.6437278389930725,
-0.5763081312179565,
0.8604539036750793,
-0.8205997347831726,
-0.3887070119380951,
-0.23252791166305542,
-0.339885950088501,
-0.6146689653396606,
0.19194529950618744,
0.1413327306509018,
0.8361157178878784,
-0.22072471678256989,
-0.13391026854515076,
0.7170978784561157,
-0.4164065420627594,
0.2713852524757385,
0.4388628304004669,
-0.4911934733390808,
-0.4009120762348175,
0.7625954151153564,
-0.16363643109798431,
0.44368457794189453,
0.24737615883350372,
0.33597061038017273,
-0.22402368485927582,
-0.5534164905548096,
-0.8077459931373596,
0.37111854553222656,
-0.6902798414230347,
-0.42115047574043274,
-0.6436291933059692,
-0.3670704662799835,
0.02196257933974266,
-0.46766597032546997,
-0.7715721726417542,
-0.22973734140396118,
-0.08469098061323166,
-0.0013140662340447307,
0.858802080154419,
0.7397176027297974,
0.05509372428059578,
0.6937592029571533,
-0.8435314893722534,
0.2720630466938019,
0.20644105970859528,
0.3826274871826172,
-0.2085627019405365,
-0.28036126494407654,
-0.34087562561035156,
0.22175294160842896,
0.14670772850513458,
-0.4756264388561249,
0.08537670969963074,
0.2680223286151886,
0.39967361092567444,
0.37346503138542175,
0.09248825162649155,
0.35961127281188965,
-0.627223014831543,
0.7173143625259399,
0.27258867025375366,
-0.7783403992652893,
0.6082779169082642,
-0.2345242202281952,
0.3008749186992645,
0.5959240794181824,
0.2460947334766388,
-0.688957154750824,
-0.33184754848480225,
-0.5123750567436218,
-0.6575900316238403,
0.11492980271577835,
-0.17835751175880432,
0.10999792814254761,
-0.03853464126586914,
0.3203789293766022,
-0.0759793221950531,
-0.045174628496170044,
-0.32243412733078003,
-0.19858965277671814,
0.20813952386379242,
-0.3943568170070648,
0.27195173501968384,
0.10279739648103714,
-0.2973386347293854,
-0.05270784720778465,
0.5765446424484253,
-0.369136780500412,
0.3054870069026947,
0.3956946134567261,
0.00587835069745779,
-0.039569977670907974,
0.165108785033226,
0.5756706595420837,
0.5917823910713196,
-0.049169935286045074,
-0.07576557993888855,
0.5332625508308411,
-0.7578585147857666,
-0.13165602087974548,
0.2719123363494873,
0.16793842613697052,
0.22644548118114471,
0.2716602087020874,
0.8072416186332703,
0.283528208732605,
-0.9608009457588196,
0.6050158739089966,
-0.12150311470031738,
0.329319030046463,
-0.20108023285865784,
-0.15853069722652435,
0.11276791244745255,
0.12344029545783997,
0.28443580865859985,
0.15786488354206085,
0.03765944018959999,
-0.1760181039571762,
0.23856660723686218,
0.5391982197761536,
-0.7490310668945312,
-0.13549944758415222,
0.5796043872833252,
0.5011352896690369,
-0.46879488229751587,
0.6091010570526123,
0.02581922523677349,
-0.20742402970790863,
0.4707587659358978,
0.5925623774528503,
0.7787089347839355,
-0.3259766101837158,
0.11598514765501022,
-0.11578220874071121,
0.30801922082901,
0.13034525513648987,
0.39099159836769104,
0.366143137216568,
-0.5192592144012451,
-0.6218065619468689,
-0.36800822615623474,
-0.5315579771995544,
0.04753855988383293,
-0.23560871183872223,
0.24726736545562744,
-0.7227702736854553,
-0.447956919670105,
-0.11684136092662811,
-0.041640982031822205,
-0.5548920631408691,
0.12460885941982269,
0.2989778518676758,
0.9079629182815552,
-0.6499252319335938,
0.8820573687553406,
0.731596827507019,
0.09187807142734528,
-0.7787818312644958,
-0.25498828291893005,
-0.13619738817214966,
-1.142763614654541,
0.31581223011016846,
-0.1570167988538742,
-0.4073350131511688,
0.0005026860744692385,
-0.3947634696960449,
-0.4997910261154175,
1.012144684791565,
0.2145000398159027,
-0.460531622171402,
0.13164642453193665,
-0.09828866273164749,
0.615633487701416,
-0.46972575783729553,
0.38610318303108215,
0.24843843281269073,
0.091913141310215,
-0.20009572803974152,
-1.4750200510025024,
0.09315557777881622,
-0.05098762735724449,
0.05303287133574486,
0.33320850133895874,
-0.4191979169845581,
0.4081874489784241,
-0.38544711470603943,
-0.1091223955154419,
-0.006027826573699713,
0.32702717185020447,
0.10432232171297073,
0.3163919150829315,
0.4293122887611389,
0.422357439994812,
0.9394493103027344,
0.2923939526081085,
1.3252900838851929,
-0.35317927598953247,
0.08724431693553925,
0.6342403292655945,
-0.44786232709884644,
0.9259762167930603,
0.417961984872818,
-0.17993706464767456,
0.5744556784629822,
0.4234282374382019,
0.4927946627140045,
0.49285686016082764,
0.16474826633930206,
-0.6394970417022705,
-0.05223700776696205,
-0.6940670013427734,
-0.3979894816875458,
0.3692293167114258,
0.648147702217102,
-0.285043329000473,
-0.40496495366096497,
0.48350757360458374,
0.2887846827507019,
-0.0037382524460554123,
-0.6401833891868591,
0.8837108612060547,
0.45277139544487,
-0.18630622327327728,
0.7106488347053528,
0.22057582437992096,
0.5137504935264587,
-0.9365799427032471,
-0.0760616585612297,
-0.1252705603837967,
0.37321022152900696,
-0.25247877836227417,
-0.1357172429561615,
0.12720103561878204,
-0.20356310904026031,
-0.05290151759982109,
-0.05185261368751526,
0.9647918939590454,
-0.001579968142323196,
-0.41291576623916626,
0.26114964485168457,
0.6384615898132324,
0.17635779082775116,
0.12528079748153687,
-0.7222364544868469,
0.0609302893280983,
-0.10076988488435745,
0.07158651202917099,
0.5593964457511902,
0.2693478763103485,
-0.07884494215250015,
1.0320237874984741,
0.7106461524963379,
0.28780606389045715,
-0.18819962441921234,
0.047077424824237823,
0.8842778205871582,
-0.273163378238678,
-0.632038414478302,
-0.8309258818626404,
0.19022873044013977,
-0.15266107022762299,
-0.2974284589290619,
0.38407376408576965,
0.4772275984287262,
0.0341428704559803,
0.037201475352048874,
0.7242504954338074,
-0.01579194888472557,
0.5474114418029785,
-0.47373145818710327,
0.7700438499450684,
-0.5563220977783203,
0.2007407248020172,
0.11046366393566132,
-0.22384177148342133,
-0.3057442605495453,
0.4759690761566162,
-0.2927602529525757,
-0.28781312704086304,
0.533856213092804,
0.6486910581588745,
-0.08243869245052338,
0.03322703018784523,
0.2788941562175751,
0.019285034388303757,
0.3338671326637268,
0.5758281946182251,
0.3190968632698059,
-0.2817228436470032,
0.12199990451335907,
-0.0567176416516304,
-0.4151501953601837,
-0.36649519205093384,
-0.6977616548538208,
-0.7598084807395935,
-0.2378671020269394,
-0.28541603684425354,
-0.39352765679359436,
0.1613723337650299,
1.5321300029754639,
0.8229609727859497,
-0.7536817789077759,
-0.19619783759117126,
0.18609388172626495,
0.19984070956707,
-0.30511027574539185,
-0.12519681453704834,
0.5150680541992188,
-0.15908822417259216,
-0.5275470614433289,
0.6087393164634705,
0.4480361342430115,
-0.04701703414320946,
-0.19885827600955963,
0.043334897607564926,
0.02434491738677025,
-0.01872786320745945,
0.5710203051567078,
0.3854367733001709,
-0.6273715496063232,
-0.2251463681459427,
0.07283894717693329,
-0.4365784823894501,
0.1813034862279892,
0.7793782949447632,
-0.7646034955978394,
0.3279740512371063,
0.024624360725283623,
1.2359917163848877,
0.07631450891494751,
0.022023465484380722,
0.5481503009796143,
-0.468314528465271,
0.25835275650024414,
0.4882502555847168,
0.31361284852027893,
0.3237779140472412,
-0.3723113238811493,
0.19432081282138824,
0.1081795021891594,
-0.63243567943573,
-0.6693490743637085,
0.2473839819431305,
-0.8332454562187195,
-0.22661124169826508,
1.014931321144104,
-0.15416482090950012,
-0.3254939317703247,
-0.34471121430397034,
-0.30138328671455383,
-0.008846776559948921,
-0.39518648386001587,
0.5192083120346069,
0.12684103846549988,
-0.29604464769363403,
-0.07832293212413788,
-0.9125099182128906,
0.6645566821098328,
0.4560932219028473,
-1.0658049583435059,
-0.2614094913005829,
0.1605430692434311,
0.2862614095211029,
0.026256252080202103,
0.8866381645202637,
0.19060727953910828,
0.2367415577173233,
-0.049867283552885056,
0.26445040106773376,
0.08240050077438354,
0.10749545693397522,
-0.37193459272384644,
-0.03217402845621109,
0.3530733585357666,
-0.47873613238334656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18603v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18603v4
|
MMSR: Symbolic Regression is a Multimodal Task
| 2024-02-28T08:29:42 | 2024-03-14T12:10:43 |
Yanjie Li, Jingyi Liu, Weijun Li, Lina Yu, Min Wu, Wenqiang Li, Meilan Hao, Su Wei, Yusong Deng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Mathematical formulas are the crystallization of human wisdom in exploring
the laws of nature for thousands of years. Describing the complex laws of
nature with a concise mathematical formula is a constant pursuit of scientists
and a great challenge for artificial intelligence. This field is called
symbolic regression. Symbolic regression was originally formulated as a
combinatorial optimization problem, and GP and reinforcement learning
algorithms were used to solve it. However, GP is sensitive to hyperparameters,
and these two types of algorithms are inefficient. To solve this problem,
researchers treat the mapping from data to expressions as a translation
problem. And the corresponding large-scale pre-trained model is introduced.
However, the data and expression skeletons do not have very clear word
correspondences as the two languages do. Instead, they are more like two
modalities (e.g., image and text). Therefore, in this paper, we proposed MMSR.
The SR problem is solved as a pure multimodal problem, and contrastive learning
is also introduced in the training process for modal alignment to facilitate
later modal feature fusion. It is worth noting that in order to better promote
the modal feature fusion, we adopt the strategy of training contrastive
learning loss and other losses at the same time, which only needs one-step
training, instead of training contrastive learning loss first and then training
other losses. Because our experiments prove training together can make the
feature extraction module and feature fusion module running-in better.
Experimental results show that compared with multiple large-scale pre-training
baselines, MMSR achieves the most advanced results on multiple mainstream
datasets including SRBench.
|
[
-0.21178703010082245,
-0.6757174730300903,
0.46222177147865295,
0.11043421179056168,
-0.5055007338523865,
0.029393382370471954,
-0.10544286668300629,
-0.1292918473482132,
0.2311418652534485,
0.18776999413967133,
-0.8341241478919983,
0.0776335597038269,
-0.7594178915023804,
0.2047850787639618,
-0.09316521137952805,
0.9900878667831421,
-0.15477924048900604,
0.4937375783920288,
-0.12747450172901154,
-0.23897451162338257,
-0.4598155915737152,
-0.42166629433631897,
-0.464330792427063,
-0.16013625264167786,
0.541385293006897,
-0.1309756189584732,
0.5294028520584106,
0.5566034913063049,
0.9298888444900513,
0.409063458442688,
0.2985609769821167,
0.42863568663597107,
-0.473270446062088,
0.16417406499385834,
0.11416183412075043,
-0.36449095606803894,
-0.03467050939798355,
0.14108765125274658,
0.6358814239501953,
0.2330947369337082,
-0.13014845550060272,
0.19361236691474915,
0.037244345992803574,
0.8048345446586609,
-0.6952407956123352,
0.5163095593452454,
-0.4570055902004242,
0.0582750104367733,
-0.0840974822640419,
-0.2691202163696289,
-0.3168398439884186,
-0.3730940520763397,
-0.09511254727840424,
-0.6365554928779602,
0.07245845347642899,
-0.04702390357851982,
0.9919463396072388,
0.5777810215950012,
-0.5042327642440796,
0.016601834446191788,
-0.8308342099189758,
1.1267763376235962,
-0.3582470715045929,
0.5093280076980591,
0.1792364865541458,
0.8663442134857178,
-0.0529995895922184,
-0.5817679166793823,
-0.6335722208023071,
-0.5240516066551208,
-0.23901095986366272,
0.1901622712612152,
-0.19799678027629852,
-0.10477696359157562,
0.15328867733478546,
-0.06512495130300522,
-0.5604840517044067,
-0.33148321509361267,
-0.5453969240188599,
-0.4433774948120117,
0.47202828526496887,
0.39430490136146545,
0.02792229689657688,
-0.2668178081512451,
-0.4392908811569214,
-0.282085120677948,
-0.40021172165870667,
-0.021912788972258568,
-0.16286350786685944,
0.636512815952301,
-0.33026328682899475,
0.6209480166435242,
0.05226198956370354,
0.6661213636398315,
-0.2911086678504944,
-0.6720209121704102,
0.40750324726104736,
-0.5458908677101135,
-0.17591015994548798,
-0.050389740616083145,
0.7006098628044128,
-0.003223310923203826,
0.2503899037837982,
0.13582843542099,
-0.17901022732257843,
0.6061081886291504,
0.16224226355552673,
-0.7178325653076172,
0.035302989184856415,
-0.3179672956466675,
-0.44047489762306213,
-0.09740019589662552,
0.11756504327058792,
-0.45100995898246765,
-0.07114299386739731,
-0.978457510471344,
0.7195947766304016,
-0.6169115900993347,
-0.110273577272892,
-0.09166121482849121,
-0.09380335360765457,
-0.02513994090259075,
0.5688601732254028,
-0.4143354892730713,
0.07330965995788574,
0.6397954821586609,
0.92399001121521,
0.17088933289051056,
-0.37329861521720886,
-0.40452685952186584,
0.2985297739505768,
-0.17759709060192108,
0.34118980169296265,
-0.6038753986358643,
-0.21891477704048157,
-0.2993754744529724,
-0.19784219563007355,
-0.25105783343315125,
-0.1887098252773285,
0.10323598235845566,
-0.30120542645454407,
0.36138293147087097,
-0.21636873483657837,
0.10032497346401215,
-0.21783927083015442,
0.29659950733184814,
-0.5394315719604492,
0.859538733959198,
0.305379718542099,
-0.6249110102653503,
0.3469506800174713,
-0.6716820001602173,
-0.22017836570739746,
-0.17249204218387604,
-0.3751107156276703,
-0.3884294033050537,
0.07897307723760605,
0.04202260822057724,
0.331404447555542,
-0.5768954157829285,
0.43443650007247925,
-0.17042960226535797,
-0.16563889384269714,
0.3369576036930084,
-0.34676387906074524,
0.3621491491794586,
0.40352052450180054,
-0.30385535955429077,
0.20428749918937683,
-0.5501188039779663,
-0.08639081567525864,
0.04862794280052185,
-0.1855979859828949,
-0.47336533665657043,
-0.01829029992222786,
0.011651407927274704,
0.6226541996002197,
0.02413361147046089,
-0.4821527302265167,
0.04554589465260506,
0.0014748354442417622,
0.4510984420776367,
0.9805477857589722,
-0.33157724142074585,
0.2728971242904663,
-0.29964807629585266,
0.38987740874290466,
0.20012110471725464,
0.2883991003036499,
-0.0270847175270319,
-0.20025193691253662,
-0.6021658182144165,
-0.774555504322052,
0.29663321375846863,
0.3261287808418274,
-1.086270809173584,
0.12238188832998276,
-0.33779942989349365,
-0.4063361585140228,
-0.707915723323822,
-0.05261453986167908,
0.8194295763969421,
0.7202234268188477,
0.5728553533554077,
-0.13984960317611694,
-0.8303734660148621,
-1.1041309833526611,
0.14945490658283234,
-0.1486334502696991,
0.03669524937868118,
0.22870473563671112,
0.5954537987709045,
-0.37595123052597046,
0.8031771183013916,
-0.6390941739082336,
-0.7060062885284424,
-0.1802264302968979,
0.2140880525112152,
-0.10582974553108215,
0.5574341416358948,
0.42784735560417175,
-1.0372339487075806,
-0.34655144810676575,
-0.10095678269863129,
-0.83766770362854,
0.056035254150629044,
-0.086321622133255,
-0.11245467513799667,
0.318430632352829,
0.3495818078517914,
-0.6156951785087585,
0.12203605473041534,
0.5277212262153625,
0.01229183655232191,
0.589734673500061,
-0.10135620832443237,
0.26611581444740295,
-1.2015588283538818,
0.08820314705371857,
0.49378690123558044,
0.022015662863850594,
-0.43420663475990295,
0.10308782011270523,
0.05443941429257393,
-0.16150622069835663,
-0.44078293442726135,
0.40504223108291626,
-0.40100347995758057,
0.08735126256942749,
-0.046119384467601776,
-0.11633934080600739,
-0.3053840100765228,
0.5518431067466736,
-0.10794457793235779,
0.7900106310844421,
0.46994444727897644,
-0.5823202729225159,
0.2871755063533783,
0.17574766278266907,
0.1813250482082367,
0.5605875253677368,
-0.3559187948703766,
-0.30478617548942566,
-0.4302288293838501,
0.3078099489212036,
-0.9964351654052734,
0.04678789898753166,
0.3241030275821686,
-0.37378159165382385,
0.3369387686252594,
0.25986725091934204,
-0.3415082097053528,
-0.3621286153793335,
-0.26617518067359924,
0.3755875527858734,
0.6113475561141968,
-0.17562931776046753,
0.8966099619865417,
0.3006236255168915,
0.032265059649944305,
-0.6666339039802551,
-0.46039527654647827,
-0.17874346673488617,
-0.17317938804626465,
-0.5423694252967834,
0.19627311825752258,
0.03349413722753525,
-0.18713584542274475,
-0.07912647724151611,
-0.29199501872062683,
-0.03835626691579819,
-0.36610931158065796,
0.20584619045257568,
0.5283738970756531,
-0.39716461300849915,
0.12300282716751099,
-0.1855071485042572,
-0.5855016112327576,
-0.06829024851322174,
0.219220831990242,
0.630057156085968,
-0.12381087988615036,
-0.3417660892009735,
-0.7285397052764893,
0.20476281642913818,
0.6194074153900146,
-0.2733699083328247,
0.5281301736831665,
0.688366174697876,
-0.16988292336463928,
0.16554966568946838,
-0.6518668532371521,
-0.23853705823421478,
-0.4973117411136627,
0.555672824382782,
-0.6253573298454285,
-0.8436571955680847,
0.1207965761423111,
-0.13244746625423431,
-0.11866690963506699,
0.46947765350341797,
0.48241090774536133,
0.023824354633688927,
1.483247995376587,
0.8386463522911072,
-0.09772501140832901,
0.4308808445930481,
-0.1571994125843048,
0.06485799700021744,
-0.5894303321838379,
-0.6936576962471008,
-0.7190234065055847,
-0.5372889637947083,
-0.5165181756019592,
-0.425665944814682,
0.570247232913971,
-0.23482440412044525,
-0.5828468799591064,
0.3376122713088989,
-0.55812668800354,
0.16293616592884064,
0.4728733003139496,
0.42912814021110535,
0.024151308462023735,
0.11266159266233444,
-0.17894861102104187,
-0.6230328679084778,
-0.34553855657577515,
-0.20675869286060333,
0.6529494524002075,
0.0717599168419838,
1.0200352668762207,
0.27584460377693176,
0.5377545356750488,
0.098873071372509,
0.3249480724334717,
-0.8279262185096741,
0.7674183249473572,
-0.28473711013793945,
-0.22469347715377808,
-0.25746434926986694,
-0.8165075182914734,
-0.734675943851471,
0.5255144238471985,
-0.3967781066894531,
-0.20917725563049316,
-0.11980394273996353,
0.11932791769504547,
0.05585862323641777,
0.037962134927511215,
-0.5889388918876648,
0.6344762444496155,
-0.31851428747177124,
-0.10451902449131012,
-0.27111580967903137,
-1.044415831565857,
0.42869988083839417,
-0.3657607138156891,
0.3341549038887024,
0.017936551943421364,
-0.07300648838281631,
0.7454231381416321,
-0.4445386826992035,
0.8240119814872742,
-0.30404534935951233,
0.35407376289367676,
-0.11676595360040665,
0.24806970357894897,
0.4041444957256317,
-0.3955236077308655,
0.2728513777256012,
-0.21983300149440765,
-0.03366192430257797,
-0.3335333466529846,
-0.7856882810592651,
0.4558161199092865,
-0.8003708124160767,
-0.5334250330924988,
-0.6687681078910828,
-0.73113614320755,
-0.11880646646022797,
0.064870186150074,
-0.20290541648864746,
0.22016125917434692,
0.0036910625640302896,
0.1408916413784027,
0.42002972960472107,
0.19476936757564545,
0.4696599245071411,
0.626557469367981,
-0.03736589103937149,
-0.5692828893661499,
1.0387059450149536,
0.10428068041801453,
0.18327215313911438,
0.4121569097042084,
0.4873306453227997,
-0.2611091136932373,
-0.24481330811977386,
-0.3237621784210205,
0.6088309288024902,
-0.4235900938510895,
-0.41796770691871643,
-0.6362888216972351,
-0.22701485455036163,
-0.28280314803123474,
-0.30212700366973877,
-0.17250320315361023,
-0.34836679697036743,
-0.18867012858390808,
0.23093284666538239,
0.27318546175956726,
0.26144835352897644,
-0.1741463840007782,
0.3160685896873474,
-0.9426375031471252,
0.5083588361740112,
0.22295133769512177,
-0.12723542749881744,
-0.13598287105560303,
-0.3990514874458313,
-0.08763475716114044,
0.22244451940059662,
-0.2517675757408142,
-0.6261799931526184,
0.6257575750350952,
0.23603108525276184,
0.6179865002632141,
0.4082006812095642,
-0.14409080147743225,
1.2466039657592773,
-0.4802180826663971,
0.44358786940574646,
0.7420094609260559,
-0.8397494554519653,
0.46696120500564575,
-0.05064266547560692,
0.11669819802045822,
0.48751190304756165,
0.6667429208755493,
-0.4557245075702667,
-0.28570038080215454,
-0.4584501385688782,
-0.5070315003395081,
0.7526643872261047,
0.18554183840751648,
0.2695885896682739,
0.28785446286201477,
0.12982411682605743,
0.08438844978809357,
0.45114845037460327,
-0.6695869565010071,
-0.1913360059261322,
-0.32377076148986816,
-0.3591143786907196,
-0.34622424840927124,
-0.06026020273566246,
-0.26383736729621887,
-0.513451099395752,
0.6834694743156433,
-0.09334057569503784,
0.2256527841091156,
-0.10582207888364792,
-0.18489502370357513,
-0.20418405532836914,
0.06102224811911583,
0.7810531258583069,
0.5801411867141724,
-0.10326120257377625,
0.2183409035205841,
-0.12383167445659637,
-0.5721469521522522,
0.33742401003837585,
0.15830212831497192,
-0.0002751788997557014,
-0.01233034860342741,
0.14750789105892181,
0.5751866102218628,
0.18047073483467102,
-0.5636944770812988,
0.3765433430671692,
0.23715931177139282,
-0.33285123109817505,
-0.20506338775157928,
-0.08778771013021469,
-0.19097110629081726,
0.2868235409259796,
0.41889312863349915,
0.4231502413749695,
-0.07980310171842575,
-0.44383135437965393,
0.3280532956123352,
0.7012895345687866,
-0.6217308640480042,
-0.28930312395095825,
0.5850263237953186,
-0.09411277621984482,
-0.14168748259544373,
0.621490478515625,
0.13692158460617065,
-0.5982702374458313,
0.6005021333694458,
0.8285297751426697,
0.6174455285072327,
-0.42847099900245667,
0.4442935287952423,
0.36282429099082947,
0.3159107267856598,
-0.2327803671360016,
0.3809404969215393,
0.13510577380657196,
-0.4516814649105072,
-0.5866405367851257,
-0.7908317446708679,
-0.15409766137599945,
-0.17997589707374573,
-0.43948793411254883,
0.34509721398353577,
-0.23186595737934113,
-0.04929624870419502,
0.24426330626010895,
-0.16640838980674744,
-0.3199912905693054,
0.2595740854740143,
-0.06343059241771698,
0.6017065048217773,
-1.1452890634536743,
0.7294436693191528,
0.558729350566864,
-0.8545575141906738,
-0.8747495412826538,
-0.45207762718200684,
0.35251396894454956,
-1.0439599752426147,
1.2360050678253174,
0.13288907706737518,
-0.24307282269001007,
-0.07763277739286423,
-0.5157900452613831,
-1.0167591571807861,
1.0430282354354858,
0.4839015305042267,
-0.18399614095687866,
-0.09804067760705948,
0.2335362285375595,
0.5653029680252075,
-0.46289873123168945,
0.004824863281100988,
0.17525048553943634,
0.646510660648346,
0.5509107112884521,
-0.9284120798110962,
0.2539299726486206,
-0.14329217374324799,
0.20114684104919434,
0.8132120966911316,
-0.6329362988471985,
1.1954984664916992,
-0.11531965434551239,
-0.04781770706176758,
-0.04900582507252693,
0.5154144167900085,
0.4683397710323334,
0.2975882291793823,
0.2762325406074524,
0.5940840840339661,
0.10516653209924698,
-0.27137210965156555,
0.7759498357772827,
0.13620971143245697,
0.3643099367618561,
0.682373583316803,
-0.2402285635471344,
0.6763627529144287,
0.6987800002098083,
-0.3908786177635193,
0.41827699542045593,
0.416789710521698,
-0.11513188481330872,
0.7634307146072388,
0.2609653174877167,
-0.19827257096767426,
-0.2804443836212158,
-0.1636257767677307,
-0.55669766664505,
0.5171512961387634,
0.21028292179107666,
-0.41109687089920044,
-0.600310206413269,
0.2906917333602905,
0.05434636399149895,
-0.006801665294915438,
-0.38041213154792786,
0.7157511115074158,
0.08340030908584595,
-0.21395562589168549,
0.5343109369277954,
-0.05345230549573898,
0.6648568511009216,
-1.1672420501708984,
-0.3180725574493408,
-0.012892651371657848,
0.240425705909729,
-0.09729782491922379,
-0.19866818189620972,
0.2534002959728241,
-0.4313662648200989,
-0.11044283211231232,
-0.15049314498901367,
0.5516122579574585,
-0.33069077134132385,
-0.6605169773101807,
0.007138182409107685,
0.7849791049957275,
0.09532319009304047,
0.05472327768802643,
-0.9253849387168884,
-0.05709848552942276,
0.008066627196967602,
-0.055781956762075424,
0.6453120112419128,
0.38712140917778015,
-0.22595033049583435,
0.7725188136100769,
0.9116224050521851,
-0.017861755564808846,
-0.16544905304908752,
-0.1620560884475708,
1.1762133836746216,
-0.6850444078445435,
-0.5091530084609985,
-1.0052289962768555,
0.5607947111129761,
0.13735507428646088,
-0.024850938469171524,
0.7266419529914856,
0.6375572085380554,
0.5731986165046692,
-0.13676263391971588,
0.5272234082221985,
-0.06522788852453232,
0.30678778886795044,
-0.5086711645126343,
0.4270736575126648,
-0.6794319152832031,
-0.084516242146492,
-0.3783126473426819,
-1.0559700727462769,
-0.625142514705658,
0.5828768014907837,
-0.11015714704990387,
0.13961569964885712,
0.9041072130203247,
1.0017492771148682,
-0.15345346927642822,
-0.153846874833107,
0.30759197473526,
-0.10208297520875931,
0.23705008625984192,
0.34883230924606323,
0.7437791228294373,
-0.23129785060882568,
0.6279734373092651,
-0.2926155924797058,
-0.36760303378105164,
-0.21491995453834534,
-0.6564549207687378,
-0.4158514142036438,
-0.8524210453033447,
-0.18257205188274384,
-0.5511825680732727,
0.09183972328901291,
1.0325875282287598,
0.5814903378486633,
-0.5118970274925232,
-0.2532943785190582,
0.22429169714450836,
-0.18211346864700317,
-0.5715957283973694,
-0.2103477120399475,
0.5833384394645691,
-0.4943297803401947,
-0.4737169146537781,
0.03375296667218208,
0.22775648534297943,
0.2458290457725525,
-0.3606998026371002,
-0.27669334411621094,
-0.2316194325685501,
-0.09832031279802322,
0.7820661067962646,
0.21065878868103027,
-0.710909903049469,
-0.15479980409145355,
-0.0006370489718392491,
-0.4159024953842163,
0.09262340515851974,
1.0966721773147583,
-0.9717351794242859,
0.4566524624824524,
0.4105646014213562,
0.5805633664131165,
0.5589210391044617,
-0.012929155491292477,
0.4024582803249359,
-0.5320025086402893,
0.27334606647491455,
0.2681613266468048,
0.33769896626472473,
0.011255587451159954,
-0.05018113553524017,
0.6192194223403931,
0.34188613295555115,
-0.27025067806243896,
-0.9026488661766052,
0.3484077453613281,
-1.166953444480896,
-0.3684391975402832,
0.9174220561981201,
0.2535759210586548,
-0.23843252658843994,
-0.07645192742347717,
-0.4131045639514923,
0.37797558307647705,
-0.45633676648139954,
1.015899896621704,
0.2596330940723419,
-0.31158366799354553,
-0.27197492122650146,
-0.4327690303325653,
0.4241732060909271,
0.4475995600223541,
-0.6004043817520142,
-0.29037705063819885,
0.9007498025894165,
-0.07058824598789215,
0.4447915554046631,
0.5463777780532837,
-0.27148598432540894,
0.1709231734275818,
0.06245912238955498,
0.01645529456436634,
-0.4563950300216675,
-0.4120197594165802,
-0.20647987723350525,
0.3043288290500641,
-0.25297415256500244,
-0.2832164466381073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18150v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18150v2
|
Unsupervised Information Refinement Training of Large Language Models for Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-02-28T08:24:38 | 2024-06-12T03:21:15 |
Shicheng Xu, Liang Pang, Mo Yu, Fandong Meng, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng, Jie Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) enhances large language models (LLMs) by
incorporating additional information from retrieval. However, studies have
shown that LLMs still face challenges in effectively using the retrieved
information, even ignoring it or being misled by it. The key reason is that the
training of LLMs does not clearly make LLMs learn how to utilize input
retrieved texts with varied quality. In this paper, we propose a novel
perspective that considers the role of LLMs in RAG as ``Information Refiner'',
which means that regardless of correctness, completeness, or usefulness of
retrieved texts, LLMs can consistently integrate knowledge within the retrieved
texts and model parameters to generate the texts that are more concise,
accurate, and complete than the retrieved texts. To this end, we propose an
information refinement training method named InFO-RAG that optimizes LLMs for
RAG in an unsupervised manner. InFO-RAG is low-cost and general across various
tasks. Extensive experiments on zero-shot prediction of 11 datasets in diverse
tasks including Question Answering, Slot-Filling, Language Modeling, Dialogue,
and Code Generation show that InFO-RAG improves the performance of LLaMA2 by an
average of 9.39\% relative points. InFO-RAG also shows advantages in in-context
learning and robustness of RAG.
|
[
-0.3212100565433502,
-0.47650018334388733,
0.4130997359752655,
-0.2779791057109833,
-0.3516679108142853,
0.3896506428718567,
-0.38256847858428955,
-0.37533217668533325,
0.16974370181560516,
0.668960690498352,
-0.4333302676677704,
-0.16318759322166443,
-0.45322826504707336,
0.04419565573334694,
-0.3422972559928894,
1.2402691841125488,
0.05172618478536606,
0.014686224050819874,
-0.2937158942222595,
0.06661303341388702,
-0.23406492173671722,
-0.33449873328208923,
-0.6167625188827515,
-0.5071355700492859,
0.5448488593101501,
0.6892792582511902,
0.20924191176891327,
0.5718412399291992,
0.39962834119796753,
0.21668779850006104,
-0.059029366821050644,
0.5330865979194641,
-0.8939228653907776,
0.4680454730987549,
-0.37585893273353577,
-0.6816732287406921,
0.06322944164276123,
-0.12735018134117126,
0.6790395975112915,
0.6161647439002991,
-0.2495279759168625,
0.5183092355728149,
0.22763298451900482,
0.9507766962051392,
-0.8908318281173706,
-0.11101123690605164,
-1.0245829820632935,
-0.19452352821826935,
-0.40492162108421326,
-0.5373441576957703,
-0.5304821729660034,
-0.16342365741729736,
-0.048924434930086136,
-0.7026786804199219,
0.4816460907459259,
0.12700022757053375,
0.9243747591972351,
0.4922795593738556,
-0.3429925739765167,
-0.1688242405653,
-1.0022878646850586,
0.8619377017021179,
-0.5043702125549316,
0.367423951625824,
0.34014788269996643,
0.2615590989589691,
-0.4919975996017456,
-0.6912521123886108,
-0.6086956262588501,
0.014629348181188107,
-0.07183727622032166,
0.15773721039295197,
-0.04885232448577881,
-0.08059462904930115,
0.4378954768180847,
0.40076300501823425,
-0.35654598474502563,
0.027675718069076538,
-0.47052815556526184,
0.09642412513494492,
0.3920581638813019,
-0.13570763170719147,
-0.32665979862213135,
-0.1153186559677124,
-0.6257768869400024,
-0.032691653817892075,
-0.9116342067718506,
0.06345496326684952,
0.3562016785144806,
0.24157485365867615,
0.2760535478591919,
0.5918430685997009,
-0.3022327125072479,
0.6632813215255737,
0.26146069169044495,
-0.456161230802536,
0.28578469157218933,
-0.12614111602306366,
-0.08440539985895157,
-0.08903367817401886,
0.4547421336174011,
0.1461016982793808,
0.15824393928050995,
-0.1544668823480606,
-0.3445391058921814,
-0.2975581884384155,
0.5080726742744446,
-0.8719965219497681,
0.05604611709713936,
-0.008759002201259136,
-0.24121598899364471,
-0.4129738509654999,
0.15542611479759216,
-0.7657231688499451,
-0.612841784954071,
-0.5755066871643066,
0.21433405578136444,
-0.19572289288043976,
-0.4309478998184204,
-0.16084057092666626,
-0.13449057936668396,
0.17068208754062653,
0.3689328134059906,
-0.6869460344314575,
0.06516139209270477,
0.44048866629600525,
0.33407506346702576,
-0.1902017891407013,
-0.07481276988983154,
-0.6445683836936951,
0.41033145785331726,
-0.44629761576652527,
1.1190483570098877,
-0.6012022495269775,
-0.11146663874387741,
-0.14384591579437256,
-0.19551482796669006,
0.11686991155147552,
-0.6688767075538635,
0.4813362956047058,
-0.7760164737701416,
0.2132226526737213,
-0.10413587093353271,
-0.5252827405929565,
-0.3445616364479065,
0.32440313696861267,
-0.585907518863678,
1.2621926069259644,
0.17408806085586548,
-1.042036771774292,
0.4029443562030792,
-0.3426489531993866,
-0.21768778562545776,
0.025376219302415848,
-0.26344186067581177,
-0.38887572288513184,
0.37732869386672974,
0.08279085904359818,
0.23608851432800293,
-0.6429911255836487,
0.3353811204433441,
-0.10276251286268234,
-0.493314266204834,
0.289966344833374,
-0.3550509214401245,
0.1795230209827423,
0.34641551971435547,
-0.09323076158761978,
-0.1528497338294983,
-0.9760221242904663,
0.1873932182788849,
0.14896245300769806,
-0.7758302688598633,
-0.3033043444156647,
-0.264680415391922,
-0.1120135709643364,
-0.06901993602514267,
0.34960806369781494,
-0.6444446444511414,
0.2739773094654083,
-0.5229442119598389,
-0.14620144665241241,
0.6595088839530945,
0.10777539014816284,
0.5219153761863708,
-0.34984949231147766,
0.40715134143829346,
-0.08255381137132645,
-0.0009787549497559667,
-0.324543297290802,
-0.16284596920013428,
-1.015219807624817,
-0.20761829614639282,
0.6197795271873474,
0.4479933977127075,
-1.045114517211914,
0.12764956057071686,
-0.03536409139633179,
-0.47653281688690186,
-0.6584132313728333,
0.30253517627716064,
0.5590265393257141,
0.6436417102813721,
0.20204024016857147,
-0.2564563751220703,
-0.8303764462471008,
-0.7692739367485046,
-0.5099600553512573,
-0.12863679230213165,
0.02985009364783764,
0.11955562978982925,
0.19595956802368164,
-0.3115784227848053,
0.9127411842346191,
-0.3315311074256897,
-0.2667084038257599,
-0.2944377660751343,
0.33056721091270447,
0.24092836678028107,
0.27134788036346436,
0.03448089212179184,
-0.8519389033317566,
-0.4445262551307678,
0.008857343345880508,
-0.4421124756336212,
-0.2889995872974396,
0.0336429737508297,
0.004070077557116747,
0.3353833258152008,
0.5814089179039001,
-0.3487720489501953,
0.5923348665237427,
0.5083433985710144,
0.058833468705415726,
0.5532324314117432,
-0.41815048456192017,
0.05288063734769821,
-1.245417833328247,
0.3749745488166809,
-0.3128708302974701,
-0.29218873381614685,
-0.7657582759857178,
-0.02447914518415928,
-0.010745164938271046,
0.07035036385059357,
-0.18422837555408478,
0.8007023930549622,
-0.652515172958374,
-0.24981996417045593,
-0.7654146552085876,
0.26207634806632996,
0.20606502890586853,
0.49090245366096497,
-0.17072941362857819,
0.7735131978988647,
0.24661631882190704,
-0.6565612554550171,
0.24053414165973663,
0.0029318719170987606,
-0.5404813885688782,
0.5133083462715149,
-0.22881703078746796,
0.31669971346855164,
-0.5796896815299988,
0.1546269655227661,
-1.1165753602981567,
-0.3096765875816345,
-0.2603951692581177,
-0.6063941121101379,
0.7764215469360352,
-0.21026542782783508,
-0.564781904220581,
-0.04129523038864136,
-0.22456465661525726,
0.3721233308315277,
0.39664602279663086,
-0.7474038600921631,
0.5927959084510803,
0.4786773920059204,
-0.12974756956100464,
-0.968012809753418,
-0.5242621302604675,
-0.14551052451133728,
-0.09687628597021103,
-0.3394601345062256,
0.308293879032135,
-0.010503812693059444,
-0.1895270198583603,
-0.016116399317979813,
-0.1828683316707611,
-0.07718584686517715,
0.018486561253666878,
0.22738060355186462,
0.21585559844970703,
0.111260786652565,
0.5014451146125793,
-0.10249249637126923,
-0.30341386795043945,
-0.41045719385147095,
-0.11122908443212509,
0.5701143145561218,
0.13681329786777496,
-0.3352055251598358,
-0.05136222392320633,
0.204265296459198,
0.22459034621715546,
-0.4030260741710663,
0.7057079672813416,
0.6342698335647583,
-0.1802256852388382,
-0.3183830678462982,
-0.898165225982666,
-0.2897909879684448,
-0.4566150903701782,
0.3384988605976105,
-0.21284528076648712,
-0.8972994685173035,
0.17613454163074493,
-0.5171288251876831,
0.20485834777355194,
0.32893702387809753,
0.4371193051338196,
-0.24342387914657593,
0.8774970769882202,
0.8927431702613831,
0.1001904085278511,
0.5650460124015808,
-0.2547925114631653,
0.14525136351585388,
-1.1933389902114868,
-0.4073624908924103,
-0.5213800072669983,
-0.26511332392692566,
-0.4723661243915558,
-0.6011656522750854,
0.26996535062789917,
0.4797915518283844,
-0.4335869550704956,
-0.0873817726969719,
-0.383946031332016,
0.6224214434623718,
0.6074334979057312,
-0.10283425450325012,
0.44168195128440857,
0.4850141704082489,
-0.09193725138902664,
-0.04109540209174156,
-0.740743100643158,
-0.45607107877731323,
1.2246830463409424,
0.1417514979839325,
1.0689890384674072,
-0.0832575336098671,
0.632719874382019,
0.017925472930073738,
0.39607420563697815,
-0.6179949045181274,
0.2856779992580414,
-0.19385407865047455,
-0.5042083263397217,
0.03954416513442993,
-0.6066080331802368,
-1.0609792470932007,
0.09300663322210312,
-0.3915003836154938,
-0.4368346929550171,
0.10094377398490906,
0.0778040736913681,
-0.10873918235301971,
0.3837088346481323,
-0.5694390535354614,
0.24985525012016296,
-0.1807764619588852,
-0.22780877351760864,
-0.130857914686203,
-0.44926339387893677,
0.17377372086048126,
-0.4141991138458252,
0.3029811382293701,
0.018467755988240242,
-0.11377502232789993,
0.7237468361854553,
-0.16050003468990326,
0.7027285695075989,
-0.21855206787586212,
0.031965337693691254,
0.2873888909816742,
0.09889113157987595,
0.6675235033035278,
-0.16348271071910858,
-0.07675781846046448,
-0.09815645217895508,
-0.27866649627685547,
-0.23335877060890198,
-0.666057288646698,
0.622053325176239,
-0.6176785826683044,
-0.6456904411315918,
-0.35342130064964294,
-0.5730527639389038,
-0.4295436441898346,
0.31097936630249023,
0.4092193841934204,
0.3667074143886566,
0.07175252586603165,
0.31211885809898376,
0.9183291792869568,
-0.1629391312599182,
0.03906463086605072,
0.9080502390861511,
-0.4852004051208496,
-0.43492060899734497,
0.7588257789611816,
-0.046289652585983276,
0.3490845859050751,
0.49434053897857666,
0.09389586001634598,
-0.3142569661140442,
-0.40951409935951233,
-0.3008853793144226,
0.5208097696304321,
-0.7892605662345886,
-0.47409963607788086,
-0.35108065605163574,
-0.28201285004615784,
-0.1584925502538681,
0.21836306154727936,
-0.44525182247161865,
-0.458945095539093,
-0.22414034605026245,
-0.04175684228539467,
0.4623936712741852,
0.9747117757797241,
-0.04499242082238197,
0.3467627763748169,
-0.5767437815666199,
0.29920727014541626,
0.14841684699058533,
0.3928550183773041,
-0.08830618113279343,
-0.9638451337814331,
-0.3748488426208496,
0.13645164668560028,
-0.2743847072124481,
-0.5218743681907654,
0.1504679024219513,
0.14422325789928436,
0.5776232481002808,
0.34234896302223206,
-0.021691257134079933,
0.743698239326477,
-0.5594967603683472,
0.4682139456272125,
0.14122360944747925,
-0.39810702204704285,
0.49494990706443787,
0.024088149890303612,
0.35747748613357544,
0.7521389722824097,
0.17077350616455078,
-0.4427671730518341,
-0.37604793906211853,
-0.6394684910774231,
-0.790278434753418,
0.8299089670181274,
-0.06776443868875504,
-0.034805476665496826,
0.22496481239795685,
0.5989903807640076,
0.13046036660671234,
0.41363421082496643,
-0.4694061279296875,
-0.18653395771980286,
0.20508380234241486,
-0.13259346783161163,
0.0356956422328949,
-0.6870098114013672,
-0.025638442486524582,
0.08431147038936615,
0.9357923269271851,
-0.03625752031803131,
0.1383829414844513,
0.05683145672082901,
0.07870961725711823,
-0.36903953552246094,
0.3057157099246979,
0.3918175995349884,
0.5801398158073425,
-0.060212790966033936,
0.19172829389572144,
0.15450160205364227,
-0.4735225439071655,
0.13374614715576172,
-0.0403096005320549,
-0.2894362509250641,
0.05739583075046539,
0.23684006929397583,
0.8639160394668579,
0.03249984607100487,
-0.678026020526886,
0.4827963411808014,
-0.10892818868160248,
0.060582734644412994,
-0.40252619981765747,
0.052783116698265076,
-0.12829704582691193,
0.4578556418418884,
0.46072760224342346,
0.26126670837402344,
-0.03313198685646057,
-0.4681120812892914,
0.16086220741271973,
0.42482972145080566,
-0.2474052608013153,
-0.06132648512721062,
0.3275772035121918,
-0.07985913008451462,
-0.06814754754304886,
0.3768075108528137,
-0.2141716033220291,
-0.4073096811771393,
0.23899692296981812,
0.687505304813385,
0.659092366695404,
-0.4763445556163788,
-0.00867999903857708,
0.5522045493125916,
0.20423121750354767,
-0.19375433027744293,
0.3205364942550659,
-0.032769884914159775,
-0.6361292004585266,
-0.6394986510276794,
-0.8838987350463867,
-0.35538873076438904,
0.3239596486091614,
-0.6113469004631042,
0.274240106344223,
-0.3791274130344391,
-0.16670264303684235,
-0.34860286116600037,
0.08293042331933975,
-0.6098272800445557,
0.22813771665096283,
0.04322817549109459,
0.798509418964386,
-0.2692796587944031,
0.8755233287811279,
0.7794785499572754,
-0.23219691216945648,
-0.9201638698577881,
0.15120354294776917,
-0.24323925375938416,
-0.8056015968322754,
0.8111585378646851,
0.2228967547416687,
-0.3088230490684509,
-0.007706837262958288,
-0.5073127746582031,
-1.212533950805664,
1.0638580322265625,
0.5757086277008057,
-0.5860795378684998,
-0.09431609511375427,
0.13219167292118073,
0.5480189323425293,
-0.3770868480205536,
0.2541075646877289,
0.3734957277774811,
0.2752520740032196,
0.4906381070613861,
-0.8453331589698792,
-0.30548182129859924,
-0.29490163922309875,
0.2281622439622879,
0.32454830408096313,
-0.5095311999320984,
0.803752064704895,
-0.31359538435935974,
-0.4815634787082672,
0.15743312239646912,
0.43435603380203247,
0.33446863293647766,
0.1047525703907013,
0.46242791414260864,
0.7239049077033997,
1.0401064157485962,
-0.01332873571664095,
1.0427371263504028,
-0.19271086156368256,
0.20810560882091522,
1.377820372581482,
-0.15267661213874817,
0.9866407513618469,
0.45346471667289734,
0.13072046637535095,
0.6032013893127441,
0.3265921473503113,
0.19029611349105835,
0.62386554479599,
0.20874238014221191,
-0.32894790172576904,
-0.020060354843735695,
-0.36288824677467346,
-0.23768848180770874,
0.5003461241722107,
0.38002103567123413,
-0.3562489449977875,
-0.4193105697631836,
0.09919852018356323,
0.00433173356577754,
0.10749181360006332,
-0.37112969160079956,
1.093214511871338,
-0.06195565685629845,
-0.769862949848175,
0.9484189748764038,
-0.005794496275484562,
0.5192595720291138,
-0.6336290836334229,
-0.17697815597057343,
-0.2756449580192566,
0.36081454157829285,
-0.3799196183681488,
-0.7620927691459656,
0.17245154082775116,
0.4312119483947754,
-0.3787568211555481,
-0.07206819951534271,
0.9933260083198547,
-0.6875460147857666,
-0.37758415937423706,
0.17097324132919312,
0.2762892544269562,
0.37486565113067627,
-0.21726469695568085,
-0.5153500437736511,
0.05187150090932846,
0.2620936334133148,
-0.28536519408226013,
0.36928239464759827,
0.6932526230812073,
0.09992871433496475,
0.6017053723335266,
0.7347840666770935,
0.26677176356315613,
-0.035157620906829834,
0.09622561931610107,
1.0133370161056519,
-0.5621477365493774,
-0.16328513622283936,
-0.549587607383728,
0.4182283878326416,
-0.15505945682525635,
-0.034152910113334656,
0.7142391800880432,
0.6649149060249329,
1.0607640743255615,
0.14574210345745087,
0.8462251424789429,
0.22936835885047913,
1.3007193803787231,
-0.5407860279083252,
0.5436183214187622,
-0.7021551728248596,
0.470191091299057,
0.06074877083301544,
-1.1416568756103516,
-0.014562600292265415,
0.4283524453639984,
-0.14448483288288116,
0.04053425416350365,
0.428211510181427,
0.8463695645332336,
0.12257153540849686,
-0.1919766366481781,
0.18647335469722748,
0.14509348571300507,
0.20784682035446167,
0.38360148668289185,
0.9217923283576965,
-0.2867923080921173,
0.6716753840446472,
-0.21191267669200897,
-0.3807322382926941,
-0.19054843485355377,
-0.6930327415466309,
-0.8946832418441772,
-0.6317640542984009,
0.1348280906677246,
-0.2553524971008301,
-0.2749406099319458,
0.6826033592224121,
0.48900994658470154,
-0.4925806224346161,
-0.26411202549934387,
0.029775027185678482,
-0.10018551349639893,
0.33313092589378357,
-0.19962796568870544,
0.09935262054204941,
-0.6446803212165833,
-0.5581590533256531,
0.47479599714279175,
0.3018633723258972,
-0.05957901105284691,
-0.33028942346572876,
0.09762389212846756,
-0.2159872204065323,
0.1478346586227417,
0.4507659077644348,
0.2795526385307312,
-0.556199312210083,
0.04149366915225983,
-0.16228708624839783,
-0.12586233019828796,
0.16864727437496185,
0.8181737661361694,
-0.969610869884491,
0.8263845443725586,
0.3649972975254059,
0.8107848167419434,
0.866786777973175,
0.22864823043346405,
0.3644595146179199,
-1.2097153663635254,
0.36807000637054443,
0.11280766129493713,
0.18322348594665527,
0.6308977007865906,
-0.4166623651981354,
0.5536956787109375,
0.015836823731660843,
-0.7141074538230896,
-0.8529709577560425,
0.4242924451828003,
-0.5106977224349976,
-0.2542244791984558,
1.3407126665115356,
0.0025469709653407335,
-0.27877989411354065,
-0.10823468863964081,
-0.49601200222969055,
0.40474453568458557,
-0.28916236758232117,
0.7837826013565063,
0.39955568313598633,
0.1220630407333374,
-0.152523934841156,
-0.6313967704772949,
0.7289831638336182,
0.3043029308319092,
-0.7690505385398865,
0.3153184652328491,
0.29059866070747375,
0.30620643496513367,
0.4632987082004547,
0.6059219241142273,
-0.13376952707767487,
0.10670024156570435,
-0.3106459677219391,
0.2572176158428192,
-0.22360512614250183,
-0.46237802505493164,
-0.23099546134471893,
-0.13531924784183502,
0.4022950828075409,
0.14101098477840424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18145v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18145v1
|
Learning Intrinsic Dimension via Information Bottleneck for Explainable Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-02-28T08:11:05 | 2024-02-28T08:11:05 |
Zhenxiao Cheng, Jie Zhou, Wen Wu, Qin Chen, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Gradient-based explanation methods are increasingly used to interpret neural
models in natural language processing (NLP) due to their high fidelity. Such
methods determine word-level importance using dimension-level gradient values
through a norm function, often presuming equal significance for all gradient
dimensions. However, in the context of Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA),
our preliminary research suggests that only specific dimensions are pertinent.
To address this, we propose the Information Bottleneck-based Gradient
(\texttt{IBG}) explanation framework for ABSA. This framework leverages an
information bottleneck to refine word embeddings into a concise intrinsic
dimension, maintaining essential features and omitting unrelated information.
Comprehensive tests show that our \texttt{IBG} approach considerably improves
both the models' performance and interpretability by identifying
sentiment-aware features.
|
[
-0.7493896484375,
-0.8827427625656128,
0.35952019691467285,
0.4134896695613861,
-0.43289294838905334,
-0.04924049228429794,
-0.06519565731287003,
-0.5392739772796631,
0.14102812111377716,
0.28755849599838257,
-0.7424134016036987,
-0.46453750133514404,
-0.3297696113586426,
-0.22844460606575012,
-0.3026363253593445,
1.2001932859420776,
0.04456004872918129,
0.013599933125078678,
-0.5051677227020264,
-0.531219482421875,
-0.45938771963119507,
-0.4524778723716736,
-0.6461012959480286,
-0.5140862464904785,
0.5106588006019592,
0.35411202907562256,
0.31847625970840454,
0.8578059673309326,
0.5942855477333069,
0.13880406320095062,
-0.32633569836616516,
-0.2060329020023346,
-0.2957616150379181,
0.08254427462816238,
-0.4608946740627289,
-0.600020706653595,
-0.4461268186569214,
-0.07508210837841034,
0.42765137553215027,
0.9594946503639221,
-0.09515057504177094,
0.319296658039093,
0.3095543384552002,
1.0246689319610596,
-0.5538371205329895,
0.4588794708251953,
-0.637134313583374,
0.189944326877594,
0.06488455832004547,
-0.08279385417699814,
0.02104327827692032,
-0.22680877149105072,
0.277818500995636,
-0.38859936594963074,
0.5514551997184753,
0.10652288794517517,
0.9831845760345459,
0.3447517454624176,
0.06132790073752403,
-0.3596074879169464,
-0.6526910066604614,
0.6328524947166443,
-0.33530357480049133,
0.14554890990257263,
0.04188837110996246,
-0.1826641708612442,
0.4051661789417267,
-0.29718902707099915,
-0.6875803470611572,
0.07235702127218246,
0.09186436980962753,
0.08690530806779861,
-0.286287784576416,
0.2596174478530884,
0.21284574270248413,
0.8570097088813782,
-0.32489362359046936,
0.13384151458740234,
-0.14447537064552307,
-0.013786490075290203,
0.44609278440475464,
-0.048372406512498856,
-0.09576278924942017,
-0.3039882183074951,
-0.565824568271637,
0.15399383008480072,
-0.8559328317642212,
0.5396373867988586,
0.2687983214855194,
0.3536950647830963,
-0.12253213673830032,
0.4416031539440155,
-0.08336804807186127,
0.44522708654403687,
0.29991617798805237,
0.2342291921377182,
0.3264908492565155,
-0.13614310324192047,
-0.014867154881358147,
0.18753571808338165,
0.5103965401649475,
0.24158114194869995,
-0.1104145422577858,
-0.06723015755414963,
-0.21574951708316803,
-0.2713901996612549,
0.46371990442276,
-0.9124152660369873,
-0.017885593697428703,
0.5843738913536072,
-0.6270965933799744,
-0.2834239900112152,
0.07327240705490112,
-1.0073957443237305,
-0.5078098773956299,
-0.37937265634536743,
0.3218400478363037,
-0.5401208996772766,
-0.42371559143066406,
-0.17959009110927582,
-0.15642480552196503,
0.10212534666061401,
0.11415324360132217,
-0.6647323966026306,
-0.15986967086791992,
0.7640294432640076,
1.1341418027877808,
-0.014146649278700352,
0.13038349151611328,
-0.38491809368133545,
-0.25800013542175293,
-0.22201670706272125,
0.7280027270317078,
-0.7700955271720886,
-0.23480983078479767,
-0.05523717775940895,
-0.4092332124710083,
0.2684582471847534,
-0.681730329990387,
0.6399392485618591,
-0.2505980432033539,
-0.027436906471848488,
-0.6324469447135925,
-0.3346332609653473,
-0.6908293962478638,
0.1627635806798935,
-0.4609770178794861,
1.0331562757492065,
0.3209362030029297,
-0.8879019021987915,
0.46228089928627014,
-1.0282877683639526,
-0.45013949275016785,
0.011926734820008278,
0.082844078540802,
-0.47635212540626526,
0.6601386070251465,
0.4591180980205536,
0.5499221086502075,
-0.4338158667087555,
0.03033382259309292,
-0.28592973947525024,
-0.043391186743974686,
0.29825371503829956,
-0.2945386469364166,
0.4242730140686035,
0.09421328455209732,
-0.1597282588481903,
-0.023518549278378487,
-0.751356303691864,
-0.13856589794158936,
-0.1737065613269806,
-0.19281239807605743,
-0.42870694398880005,
0.03575141355395317,
-0.43341195583343506,
0.1302872747182846,
0.4609808623790741,
-0.6339684724807739,
0.027296394109725952,
-0.3038770854473114,
0.46508851647377014,
0.8141987323760986,
0.18327441811561584,
0.5009214282035828,
-0.15347501635551453,
0.742057740688324,
0.4757148325443268,
0.1954791396856308,
-0.21087265014648438,
-0.2626565992832184,
-0.831479549407959,
-0.45918968319892883,
0.2589039206504822,
0.47534433007240295,
-0.7707148790359497,
0.569581925868988,
-0.29739299416542053,
-0.3227531611919403,
-0.7244784235954285,
0.2017582356929779,
0.43845269083976746,
0.8872324824333191,
0.4369000196456909,
-0.6598489880561829,
-0.16015611588954926,
-1.0769693851470947,
-0.41246676445007324,
-0.4381207227706909,
-0.26863184571266174,
0.4398568570613861,
0.2333313375711441,
0.14964166283607483,
1.0781400203704834,
-0.3310505747795105,
-0.34496375918388367,
-0.4665822386741638,
0.7346104979515076,
0.46434178948402405,
0.29690560698509216,
0.5156658887863159,
-0.7476069927215576,
-0.26513636112213135,
0.060412026941776276,
-0.7195720076560974,
-0.49406492710113525,
-0.39911285042762756,
-0.021370284259319305,
-0.19295957684516907,
0.28312766551971436,
-0.47939905524253845,
0.42418137192726135,
0.18494409322738647,
-0.12991562485694885,
0.402988463640213,
-0.028640443459153175,
-0.34827977418899536,
-0.6246063113212585,
-0.030651332810521126,
0.5237479209899902,
-0.004023429937660694,
-0.5856704115867615,
0.03029967099428177,
-0.03705964237451553,
0.025593388825654984,
-0.03894789516925812,
0.4444168210029602,
-0.4793386459350586,
-0.11838525533676147,
-0.3725235164165497,
0.33591896295547485,
0.2059076875448227,
0.8508033752441406,
-0.1480877846479416,
0.44758567214012146,
0.6659424304962158,
-0.6862267255783081,
0.06333731859922409,
-0.0889921635389328,
-0.15159545838832855,
1.2364580631256104,
-0.6320616602897644,
-0.026728438213467598,
-0.5843567252159119,
-0.10185383260250092,
-0.7329745888710022,
0.17656488716602325,
0.13747407495975494,
-0.5808389186859131,
0.44540777802467346,
-0.25447002053260803,
-0.07082539796829224,
-0.2654058039188385,
-0.473702073097229,
0.20556944608688354,
0.31719279289245605,
-0.7617068886756897,
0.9121567606925964,
0.42056384682655334,
-0.32666704058647156,
-0.8694385886192322,
-0.511838972568512,
-0.16894181072711945,
-0.40050339698791504,
-0.32211020588874817,
0.33750638365745544,
0.19328057765960693,
-0.2972763180732727,
0.20297154784202576,
-0.3298570513725281,
-0.07604287564754486,
0.14254529774188995,
0.48281627893447876,
0.00751669704914093,
-0.30534034967422485,
0.5218153595924377,
0.06411553174257278,
-0.010511345230042934,
0.2584993541240692,
-0.3752339482307434,
0.5287250280380249,
-0.46844482421875,
0.023758426308631897,
-0.5822591185569763,
0.36637216806411743,
0.42842599749565125,
-0.2792094647884369,
0.9643526077270508,
0.8132355809211731,
-0.23976075649261475,
-0.49084627628326416,
-0.3298439383506775,
-0.10399460792541504,
-0.43353694677352905,
0.6516826152801514,
-0.30416595935821533,
-0.7225501537322998,
0.8079538345336914,
-0.04657551646232605,
-0.0044992463663220406,
0.6138032674789429,
0.31255990266799927,
-0.22397921979427338,
0.7369995713233948,
0.7917810678482056,
-0.2678245007991791,
0.7957097887992859,
-0.33367449045181274,
0.6636844873428345,
-1.3914223909378052,
-0.28587815165519714,
-0.5067510008811951,
-0.5366929769515991,
-0.2817668914794922,
-0.3541242480278015,
0.5411924123764038,
0.790608286857605,
-0.25096896290779114,
-0.1401509940624237,
-0.5264227390289307,
0.39682483673095703,
0.5449205040931702,
0.09175221621990204,
0.05784953758120537,
0.09983057528734207,
0.015354546718299389,
0.07673243433237076,
-0.7226752042770386,
-0.2374325692653656,
0.8719722032546997,
0.5661841630935669,
0.6170744299888611,
-0.06822299212217331,
0.12817026674747467,
0.16604433953762054,
0.577519953250885,
-0.9222046732902527,
0.2740555703639984,
-0.22997987270355225,
-0.3805263340473175,
-0.22872380912303925,
-0.6139552593231201,
-0.5403525233268738,
0.32664939761161804,
-0.17700199782848358,
-0.9055075645446777,
0.41278931498527527,
0.3643450140953064,
-0.2606912851333618,
0.3937092423439026,
-0.5673808455467224,
0.5060409903526306,
-0.05938403308391571,
-0.32181230187416077,
-0.299259215593338,
-0.32513004541397095,
0.3343851864337921,
0.04831462353467941,
0.28917011618614197,
-0.15158548951148987,
0.010608101263642311,
0.5357906222343445,
-0.485136479139328,
0.7571871280670166,
-0.46756863594055176,
0.022909732535481453,
0.3408716320991516,
0.11048698425292969,
0.3671744167804718,
0.2791690528392792,
-0.13923335075378418,
0.6869778037071228,
-0.5541604161262512,
-0.26423782110214233,
-0.875724732875824,
0.6570939421653748,
-0.6381651163101196,
-0.659652829170227,
-0.11377253383398056,
-0.5186821818351746,
-0.2215055376291275,
-0.30291280150413513,
0.33196818828582764,
0.5119462013244629,
0.07150811702013016,
0.41564521193504333,
0.7601350545883179,
-0.26434436440467834,
0.4796009659767151,
0.37008047103881836,
0.04714515060186386,
0.08412346988916397,
1.1366369724273682,
0.11275552213191986,
0.043347232043743134,
0.6728200912475586,
0.42944443225860596,
-0.3359401822090149,
-0.72523432970047,
-0.2603556513786316,
0.16448289155960083,
-0.5860574245452881,
-0.19213074445724487,
-0.6445131301879883,
-0.24654576182365417,
0.1677527129650116,
-0.11588795483112335,
-0.5227481126785278,
-0.4798334240913391,
-0.46725377440452576,
-0.23944604396820068,
0.33898600935935974,
0.6753666400909424,
-0.3375089466571808,
0.45493558049201965,
-0.6530823707580566,
0.21703079342842102,
0.06634032726287842,
0.42966219782829285,
0.39875179529190063,
-0.5894689559936523,
-0.46113353967666626,
0.08223946392536163,
-0.5648133754730225,
-0.648401141166687,
0.3900466561317444,
0.4152897596359253,
0.5237415432929993,
0.9584009051322937,
-0.10881474614143372,
0.32844600081443787,
-0.08071808516979218,
1.0300846099853516,
0.2866993248462677,
-1.3458812236785889,
0.5217260718345642,
-0.03879531845450401,
0.26941362023353577,
0.3920276165008545,
0.40985268354415894,
-0.5912520885467529,
-0.27197128534317017,
-0.5008076429367065,
-1.244401216506958,
0.5581079721450806,
0.0947302058339119,
0.0958133339881897,
0.11862209439277649,
0.8100748658180237,
0.3150634467601776,
0.4583671987056732,
-0.8832036852836609,
-0.2412443608045578,
-0.3702826201915741,
-0.3297274708747864,
0.28523802757263184,
-0.3738263249397278,
-0.06127259507775307,
-0.04681064561009407,
0.6697736382484436,
-0.33203479647636414,
0.5003314018249512,
0.27301445603370667,
-0.07857435196638107,
0.09306314587593079,
0.21542318165302277,
0.25268086791038513,
0.7422202825546265,
-0.1471906304359436,
0.12285888940095901,
-0.03217494487762451,
-0.4804099202156067,
-0.14984965324401855,
-0.1794571876525879,
-0.08654763549566269,
-0.050587184727191925,
0.629288375377655,
0.9778567552566528,
-0.44855111837387085,
-0.43441805243492126,
0.7543327212333679,
0.06653594225645065,
0.051402680575847626,
-0.11497143656015396,
0.04010938107967377,
-0.20907974243164062,
0.29718244075775146,
0.4952719211578369,
0.0156746506690979,
0.01091426145285368,
-0.5882736444473267,
-0.045442067086696625,
0.5689092874526978,
-0.9765228033065796,
-0.5260847806930542,
0.45988523960113525,
0.2343226671218872,
-0.10602233558893204,
0.551345705986023,
-0.2730954885482788,
-0.6874564290046692,
0.6817615032196045,
-0.09721443802118301,
1.0869876146316528,
-0.21770058572292328,
0.5420339107513428,
0.33880990743637085,
0.4080944061279297,
0.2005917876958847,
0.42257365584373474,
-0.17722204327583313,
-0.8536256551742554,
-0.3071698546409607,
-0.845744252204895,
-0.25509560108184814,
0.23842701315879822,
-1.008216142654419,
-0.276140034198761,
-0.7379692196846008,
0.09905911982059479,
0.04163045436143875,
-0.3495422601699829,
-0.7429478168487549,
0.16920039057731628,
-0.2458346039056778,
0.5399687886238098,
-0.6891998648643494,
0.40740302205085754,
0.36091601848602295,
-0.43902117013931274,
-0.45527368783950806,
0.2677755653858185,
-0.08747140318155289,
-0.8109856843948364,
0.672881543636322,
0.2528170347213745,
-0.15074492990970612,
-0.544342577457428,
-0.5443344116210938,
-0.6894809603691101,
0.7957991361618042,
0.09695177525281906,
-0.5380619168281555,
0.2359965443611145,
0.1202285960316658,
0.8278000354766846,
-0.6896609663963318,
0.15177740156650543,
0.4446665048599243,
0.25096607208251953,
0.09459594637155533,
-0.297519713640213,
0.06534934043884277,
-0.13788089156150818,
0.12056015431880951,
0.16020718216896057,
-0.5786462426185608,
0.920925498008728,
-0.13695603609085083,
-0.19235265254974365,
-0.4041280448436737,
0.8943231701850891,
-0.34666019678115845,
0.13220779597759247,
0.7101961970329285,
0.668840765953064,
0.9260692000389099,
-0.24735818803310394,
1.1241264343261719,
-0.5134930610656738,
0.44592973589897156,
1.00252366065979,
0.09749738872051239,
0.7566056251525879,
0.4331943988800049,
-0.08642768859863281,
0.7567499279975891,
0.617356538772583,
0.2034837156534195,
0.44787031412124634,
0.3165052831172943,
-0.3559199869632721,
-0.0548260398209095,
-0.4107470214366913,
-0.08918961882591248,
0.5458471179008484,
0.7807704210281372,
-0.5811731815338135,
-0.14971637725830078,
0.17545334994792938,
-0.052007853984832764,
-0.21693949401378632,
-0.7272244691848755,
0.7277538776397705,
0.04135672003030777,
-0.48384517431259155,
0.2700512409210205,
0.013856807723641396,
0.6443403363227844,
-0.46819716691970825,
0.0776585191488266,
-0.49115487933158875,
0.2459382563829422,
-0.14199015498161316,
-0.8326153755187988,
0.4204307198524475,
-0.07805352658033371,
-0.38564953207969666,
-0.18201503157615662,
0.2954784333705902,
-0.3585493564605713,
-0.4373217225074768,
0.04986290633678436,
0.28006234765052795,
-0.017289381474256516,
-0.5961028933525085,
-0.7157747149467468,
-0.32666197419166565,
0.07558717578649521,
-0.27178099751472473,
0.19889487326145172,
0.8818352222442627,
0.08817760646343231,
0.8523349761962891,
0.4023127555847168,
0.2250935435295105,
-0.41271623969078064,
-0.16734154522418976,
0.8612157106399536,
-0.7118726372718811,
-0.598545491695404,
-0.8724615573883057,
0.40614476799964905,
-0.2097516655921936,
-0.5426656007766724,
0.37644824385643005,
0.3674074411392212,
0.6047953367233276,
0.12051472812891006,
0.9097469449043274,
-0.04037103056907654,
0.5378883481025696,
-0.7230631709098816,
0.48440954089164734,
-0.6135872006416321,
0.6707525849342346,
-0.0121578648686409,
-1.0922397375106812,
-0.07037664204835892,
0.6685870289802551,
-0.06021520867943764,
-0.02325885370373726,
0.8663243651390076,
0.647821843624115,
0.10176273435354233,
0.2525903284549713,
-0.058914754539728165,
0.6575239896774292,
0.4071323275566101,
0.4822084605693817,
0.5852248668670654,
0.13483156263828278,
0.21091635525226593,
-0.4173687696456909,
-0.44020670652389526,
-0.13434119522571564,
-1.103630781173706,
-0.9288221001625061,
-0.6389941573143005,
-0.515251636505127,
-0.2648717761039734,
-0.43466103076934814,
0.6227566599845886,
0.6043954491615295,
-0.6518517732620239,
0.2306469976902008,
-0.13240857422351837,
0.4605632722377777,
-0.523209810256958,
-0.36232417821884155,
0.437679260969162,
-0.29746487736701965,
-0.47581732273101807,
0.032401155680418015,
0.6936003565788269,
-0.21668238937854767,
-0.6049744486808777,
0.49323296546936035,
0.16325931251049042,
0.3956547975540161,
0.5436835885047913,
0.30624279379844666,
-0.5916630625724792,
-0.6002939343452454,
-0.5436940789222717,
0.3520458936691284,
0.4653681516647339,
1.143874168395996,
-0.5712248086929321,
0.5137133598327637,
0.5187270045280457,
0.6254740357398987,
0.38975366950035095,
0.3343755602836609,
0.6485134959220886,
-1.2499003410339355,
0.1571589857339859,
0.26315128803253174,
0.29447638988494873,
0.5706524848937988,
-0.7098591327667236,
0.413245290517807,
0.20884548127651215,
-0.17923659086227417,
-0.6038123965263367,
0.26112082600593567,
-0.994488000869751,
-0.4524412155151367,
0.9692596793174744,
-0.5350385904312134,
-0.3192908465862274,
-0.17684614658355713,
0.1419377624988556,
-0.08365004509687424,
-0.428433358669281,
1.0254701375961304,
0.8488721251487732,
-0.32039323449134827,
-0.27506569027900696,
-0.2307349145412445,
0.5340670943260193,
0.17319519817829132,
-0.8276169300079346,
0.25540053844451904,
0.22744318842887878,
-0.054727375507354736,
0.37460389733314514,
0.1933189332485199,
-0.05732888728380203,
-0.17826060950756073,
-0.04175213724374771,
0.3011358678340912,
-0.12443037331104279,
-0.4489339590072632,
-0.5443823337554932,
0.5025525093078613,
-0.20898842811584473,
-0.15955579280853271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18139v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18139v2
|
Cause and Effect: Can Large Language Models Truly Understand Causality?
| 2024-02-28T08:02:14 | 2024-04-15T22:42:11 |
Swagata Ashwani, Kshiteesh Hegde, Nishith Reddy Mannuru, Mayank Jindal, Dushyant Singh Sengar, Krishna Chaitanya Rao Kathala, Dishant Banga, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the rise of Large Language Models(LLMs), it has become crucial to
understand their capabilities and limitations in deciphering and explaining the
complex web of causal relationships that language entails. Current methods use
either explicit or implicit causal reasoning, yet there is a strong need for a
unified approach combining both to tackle a wide array of causal relationships
more effectively. This research proposes a novel architecture called Context
Aware Reasoning Enhancement with Counterfactual Analysis(CARE CA) framework to
enhance causal reasoning and explainability. The proposed framework
incorporates an explicit causal detection module with ConceptNet and
counterfactual statements, as well as implicit causal detection through LLMs.
Our framework goes one step further with a layer of counterfactual explanations
to accentuate LLMs understanding of causality. The knowledge from ConceptNet
enhances the performance of multiple causal reasoning tasks such as causal
discovery, causal identification and counterfactual reasoning. The
counterfactual sentences add explicit knowledge of the not caused by scenarios.
By combining these powerful modules, our model aims to provide a deeper
understanding of causal relationships, enabling enhanced interpretability.
Evaluation of benchmark datasets shows improved performance across all metrics,
such as accuracy, precision, recall, and F1 scores. We also introduce
CausalNet, a new dataset accompanied by our code, to facilitate further
research in this domain.
|
[
-0.13798247277736664,
-1.1098889112472534,
0.8984725475311279,
0.3020477294921875,
-0.2071736454963684,
-0.4985978901386261,
0.05670967325568199,
-0.7082184553146362,
0.1009553000330925,
0.4251238703727722,
-0.61567223072052,
-0.12335403263568878,
-0.5622337460517883,
-0.14174407720565796,
-0.41222018003463745,
0.5952343940734863,
0.0952720195055008,
0.14227807521820068,
-0.28194355964660645,
-0.09115637838840485,
-0.6993644833564758,
-0.28218936920166016,
-1.1007041931152344,
-0.6023069024085999,
0.6592390537261963,
0.29292887449264526,
0.49926599860191345,
0.4309949278831482,
0.4227607548236847,
0.3581434190273285,
0.03575736656785011,
0.13435032963752747,
-0.5846248269081116,
-0.04999535158276558,
-0.6728406548500061,
-0.5020214319229126,
-0.5315393805503845,
-0.46816566586494446,
0.37845945358276367,
0.5580675601959229,
0.01324324682354927,
-0.19719363749027252,
-0.17511458694934845,
0.532593309879303,
-0.601862370967865,
0.2462121546268463,
-0.5824930667877197,
-0.1633767932653427,
0.09424299746751785,
-0.4914686381816864,
-0.2845134139060974,
0.04654580354690552,
0.15284040570259094,
-0.7756630778312683,
0.16568313539028168,
0.07674608379602432,
0.515935480594635,
0.46249890327453613,
-0.6708171367645264,
-0.15615826845169067,
-0.6147285103797913,
0.5483044981956482,
-0.8006118535995483,
0.33695295453071594,
0.08413495123386383,
0.14057657122612,
-0.4628838002681732,
-0.8146905899047852,
-0.8502109050750732,
-0.03442477807402611,
-0.22379447519779205,
0.2170763611793518,
-0.4372049868106842,
-0.0934128537774086,
0.30239444971084595,
0.11587792634963989,
-0.7014555335044861,
0.3884578347206116,
-0.15600545704364777,
-0.11294055730104446,
0.6227839589118958,
0.298289954662323,
0.7329127192497253,
-0.04776592552661896,
-0.42923977971076965,
0.24364033341407776,
-1.108870029449463,
-0.07308569550514221,
-0.0983741506934166,
0.23882782459259033,
-0.3294326066970825,
0.1974610537290573,
-0.17762331664562225,
0.5814063549041748,
-0.2432761788368225,
0.18930339813232422,
-0.24413500726222992,
-0.3041142523288727,
-0.5799185037612915,
0.3449006974697113,
0.4356801211833954,
0.30239710211753845,
0.22714383900165558,
-0.18066217005252838,
0.3311055302619934,
0.293915331363678,
0.30382803082466125,
-0.8972193598747253,
0.07346543669700623,
0.421761691570282,
-0.3716720938682556,
-0.1245778501033783,
-0.03785831108689308,
-0.3003425896167755,
-0.5508754253387451,
-0.734363317489624,
0.4217139184474945,
-0.08572608232498169,
-0.5730338096618652,
0.5580065846443176,
-0.09535222500562668,
0.22099731862545013,
0.4167361557483673,
-0.35580986738204956,
0.2012682408094406,
0.7743536233901978,
0.658037543296814,
-0.07086344808340073,
-0.19863276183605194,
-0.5682570934295654,
0.387291818857193,
-0.45881974697113037,
0.7929175496101379,
-0.32880130410194397,
-0.257485568523407,
-0.04379972070455551,
0.1857908070087433,
-0.18504148721694946,
-0.28599658608436584,
0.46534544229507446,
-0.6840819120407104,
0.031844403594732285,
-0.4861721098423004,
-0.503088116645813,
-0.3587229251861572,
0.04577268287539482,
-0.7049721479415894,
0.51652991771698,
-0.39041033387184143,
-0.7721726298332214,
0.46642976999282837,
-0.7747070789337158,
-0.7325854301452637,
-0.035280704498291016,
-0.1885843575000763,
-0.16343575716018677,
0.23336705565452576,
0.01695590279996395,
0.5575816035270691,
-0.5398141145706177,
1.1377702951431274,
-0.5006421208381653,
-0.34636035561561584,
0.22707876563072205,
-0.5818053483963013,
0.8769672513008118,
0.06249212101101875,
-0.6036115288734436,
0.39122286438941956,
-0.6808305978775024,
-0.35209232568740845,
0.07117905467748642,
0.16650144755840302,
-0.5439878106117249,
0.1513223797082901,
0.059546876698732376,
0.6869487166404724,
-0.026459168642759323,
-0.37482109665870667,
-0.16138441860675812,
-0.44613537192344666,
0.24445903301239014,
0.6852977275848389,
0.09285429865121841,
0.21216058731079102,
-0.06352093815803528,
0.2635729908943176,
0.39809441566467285,
0.19416865706443787,
-0.05933908000588417,
-0.2717417776584625,
-0.6069796085357666,
-0.17342235147953033,
-0.5243884325027466,
0.46769434213638306,
-0.8618558049201965,
0.1990041434764862,
-0.26353028416633606,
-0.17907597124576569,
0.18721744418144226,
-0.07223397493362427,
0.6120868921279907,
0.9841412305831909,
0.5919851064682007,
-0.024030674248933792,
-0.6947964429855347,
-0.8528826832771301,
-0.3605329096317291,
-0.30397453904151917,
0.1478462815284729,
0.34438440203666687,
0.6211910843849182,
-0.3429126441478729,
0.8877411484718323,
-0.6143386363983154,
-0.04424319043755531,
-0.19783030450344086,
0.017506927251815796,
0.24801981449127197,
0.5462981462478638,
0.330757737159729,
-1.0436958074569702,
0.17401552200317383,
-0.1686970293521881,
-0.9211663603782654,
-0.3452068865299225,
-0.2500810921192169,
-0.20946280658245087,
0.08687248826026917,
0.9560030698776245,
-0.4099917411804199,
0.5185345411300659,
0.29097238183021545,
-0.8236050009727478,
0.6320303678512573,
-0.24253496527671814,
0.07005568593740463,
-1.1006966829299927,
0.41539523005485535,
0.1220988780260086,
0.011837676167488098,
-0.7924059629440308,
-0.0753265768289566,
-0.10789842158555984,
0.08030834794044495,
-0.6017827987670898,
0.8793513178825378,
0.06742623448371887,
0.03827233240008354,
-0.3135799765586853,
0.19117164611816406,
0.2740616202354431,
0.3057865500450134,
0.27631044387817383,
0.484357088804245,
0.4442462921142578,
-0.710527241230011,
0.16102738678455353,
0.07615144550800323,
-0.30253300070762634,
0.7283541560173035,
-1.053467869758606,
-0.513178288936615,
-0.32250043749809265,
0.4560277462005615,
-1.039023756980896,
-0.24508036673069,
0.13555757701396942,
-0.2209516316652298,
0.17221294343471527,
0.2152346968650818,
-0.4057932496070862,
-0.10868361592292786,
0.13594280183315277,
0.2589893937110901,
-0.04672954976558685,
-0.7259039878845215,
0.5776300430297852,
0.08924232423305511,
0.14776611328125,
-0.6008538007736206,
-0.8138892650604248,
0.2072356641292572,
-0.3793048560619354,
-0.5648018717765808,
0.29723888635635376,
-0.19288532435894012,
-0.48730215430259705,
-0.05921110510826111,
-0.22195492684841156,
-0.21715551614761353,
0.46109849214553833,
0.4029911756515503,
0.29051363468170166,
-0.39274656772613525,
0.6707862019538879,
0.16322170197963715,
-0.2937436103820801,
0.4372487962245941,
-0.26759812235832214,
0.18101821839809418,
0.05392877757549286,
-0.22479002177715302,
-0.40301501750946045,
0.4168345332145691,
0.7165378332138062,
-0.1445915699005127,
1.0389324426651,
0.554311215877533,
-0.3540076017379761,
-0.15821008384227753,
-0.3842284679412842,
-0.31813347339630127,
-0.4187195301055908,
0.42535337805747986,
-0.4414205849170685,
-1.0644221305847168,
0.6150785088539124,
-0.23196294903755188,
-0.2949252724647522,
0.5757186412811279,
0.4539252817630768,
0.2814762592315674,
0.842864990234375,
0.4165894091129303,
-0.20117701590061188,
0.30232053995132446,
0.0140228271484375,
0.47186222672462463,
-0.7200334072113037,
-0.4575290381908417,
-0.3661206066608429,
0.26639991998672485,
-0.45563626289367676,
-0.22935260832309723,
0.27465465664863586,
0.17940586805343628,
-0.6864194273948669,
0.09883660078048706,
-0.0512210875749588,
0.22127258777618408,
0.06495894491672516,
0.28162288665771484,
0.4612048864364624,
-0.2291117161512375,
-0.06050616875290871,
0.26523277163505554,
-0.7526582479476929,
-0.37313294410705566,
0.5439196228981018,
0.24424521625041962,
0.5071448683738708,
0.5118519067764282,
0.08142291754484177,
0.17701035737991333,
0.3975282609462738,
-0.5130274891853333,
0.44151654839515686,
-0.11645205318927765,
-0.7831640243530273,
-0.3422079086303711,
-0.5057242512702942,
-0.8516674637794495,
0.41094717383384705,
-0.25572654604911804,
-0.8627141118049622,
0.40728288888931274,
0.310136616230011,
-0.15009500086307526,
0.04879584163427353,
-0.6719602346420288,
0.9059639573097229,
-0.15357749164104462,
-0.8581517934799194,
-0.4464987814426422,
-0.5324030518531799,
0.6626280546188354,
-0.0391877144575119,
0.39791396260261536,
0.10751808434724808,
0.25558096170425415,
0.5222775340080261,
-0.33942747116088867,
1.1638683080673218,
-0.12775574624538422,
-0.4766313433647156,
0.057970672845840454,
-0.0003420847642701119,
0.32528623938560486,
0.284249484539032,
-0.10059347748756409,
0.21148540079593658,
-0.2215302437543869,
-0.2971445620059967,
-0.8390748500823975,
1.0907806158065796,
-0.41432276368141174,
-0.7785378694534302,
0.02636721357703209,
-0.6142255067825317,
-0.22050584852695465,
0.2383291870355606,
-0.12557008862495422,
0.9136293530464172,
-0.30571070313453674,
0.07511211931705475,
0.7620245814323425,
-0.527019739151001,
0.46007752418518066,
0.8764556646347046,
-0.028823763132095337,
0.058129992336034775,
0.6431816220283508,
-0.1368054747581482,
0.1789211928844452,
0.6850704550743103,
0.5293022394180298,
-0.4381219148635864,
-0.134253591299057,
-0.21145763993263245,
0.15631848573684692,
-0.6838558316230774,
-0.00813688151538372,
-0.7756971120834351,
0.22355785965919495,
-0.40887248516082764,
-0.19412453472614288,
-0.1182502806186676,
-0.24141956865787506,
-0.3182494044303894,
-0.18879885971546173,
0.3140544295310974,
0.5566160082817078,
-0.1739584058523178,
0.39251774549484253,
-0.4080779552459717,
0.5176687836647034,
0.35838332772254944,
0.31512874364852905,
0.4748441278934479,
-0.3028974235057831,
-0.2349003404378891,
-0.1420021504163742,
0.21463744342327118,
-0.5981297492980957,
0.1890321671962738,
-0.12948982417583466,
0.4538598954677582,
0.7352362871170044,
0.026488836854696274,
0.9323533177375793,
-0.5331127047538757,
0.6021806597709656,
0.3562347888946533,
-1.0483847856521606,
0.5997011661529541,
-0.3413030803203583,
0.4190385937690735,
0.1295960545539856,
0.32733815908432007,
-0.4549422860145569,
-0.21136559545993805,
-0.6405162811279297,
-0.8508033752441406,
0.5978395938873291,
0.0043671997264027596,
-0.20607924461364746,
-0.059179581701755524,
0.440181702375412,
-0.14169204235076904,
-0.1549701690673828,
-0.5676606893539429,
-0.20124614238739014,
-0.0761314257979393,
-0.12419778853654861,
-0.4113546311855316,
-0.3333228826522827,
-0.10849405825138092,
-0.13298781216144562,
0.7252885699272156,
-0.16727851331233978,
0.02750144898891449,
0.5106402635574341,
-0.1890764832496643,
-0.1097148135304451,
0.39407625794410706,
0.8968147039413452,
0.9647291898727417,
0.09475008398294449,
0.3291695713996887,
0.05346749722957611,
-0.1456442028284073,
-0.13313543796539307,
0.1347295045852661,
0.08117235451936722,
-0.3434413969516754,
1.0462144613265991,
0.7379553318023682,
0.4850601553916931,
-0.6497693061828613,
0.3774925470352173,
-0.10840482264757156,
0.264698326587677,
-0.1452479362487793,
0.2923203408718109,
0.36683791875839233,
0.3630262613296509,
0.1961379051208496,
-0.22059032320976257,
0.3400379419326782,
-0.548607349395752,
0.27909934520721436,
0.3993784785270691,
-0.4899097681045532,
-0.2998565435409546,
0.6903923153877258,
0.025346161797642708,
0.11081349849700928,
0.23155981302261353,
0.36606961488723755,
-0.48348021507263184,
1.0381628274917603,
0.7754665613174438,
0.5237817764282227,
-0.29592496156692505,
0.20325441658496857,
0.48330003023147583,
0.3418625295162201,
-0.042286016047000885,
0.32208961248397827,
-0.018549200147390366,
-1.052912712097168,
-0.7369540929794312,
-0.2591365873813629,
-0.19381187856197357,
0.3260142207145691,
-0.5977994799613953,
-0.216553196310997,
-0.05434517189860344,
0.27298226952552795,
0.11044688522815704,
-0.09747926145792007,
-0.585584819316864,
0.6742308139801025,
-0.3235204219818115,
0.7275482416152954,
-1.2405030727386475,
0.6437661647796631,
0.48032525181770325,
-0.48231053352355957,
-0.9244943261146545,
-0.15499567985534668,
0.04079538583755493,
-0.7766475081443787,
1.1029688119888306,
0.21772588789463043,
-0.47940269112586975,
-0.27730393409729004,
-0.5143653154373169,
-0.5392540693283081,
1.023653268814087,
0.3585171699523926,
-0.7127543091773987,
0.4431367814540863,
0.08682779967784882,
0.6428872346878052,
-0.3981117904186249,
0.2819124162197113,
0.5600829124450684,
0.5431804656982422,
0.07747792452573776,
-0.5720312595367432,
0.5940281748771667,
-0.13800100982189178,
-0.09878625720739365,
-0.004006414208561182,
-0.3448573350906372,
0.3748503029346466,
-0.18703895807266235,
-0.041059643030166626,
-0.37585097551345825,
0.4310259521007538,
0.38215622305870056,
0.692363977432251,
0.3613945245742798,
0.5393959283828735,
0.5853032469749451,
0.09647233039140701,
1.3554953336715698,
-0.1808609813451767,
0.00712094409391284,
1.3075519800186157,
-0.3199923634529114,
0.48425182700157166,
0.6233490109443665,
0.15437838435173035,
0.6891112327575684,
0.27832043170928955,
0.6276136636734009,
0.27686455845832825,
0.28196436166763306,
-0.3626800775527954,
-0.5425375699996948,
-0.6241688132286072,
-0.19132433831691742,
0.4744035601615906,
0.4745750427246094,
-0.381087988615036,
-0.09941522777080536,
-0.14040276408195496,
0.2512003779411316,
0.015226385556161404,
-0.4431250989437103,
0.5797024965286255,
0.38022714853286743,
-0.5504236221313477,
0.13272912800312042,
-0.15666598081588745,
0.2015373408794403,
-0.5364123582839966,
-0.21399885416030884,
-0.22693660855293274,
0.320210337638855,
-0.2918890118598938,
-0.4232151210308075,
0.4598288834095001,
-0.34467756748199463,
-0.3833935260772705,
-0.001915200729854405,
0.9504465460777283,
-0.34963923692703247,
-0.3415180444717407,
0.6127122044563293,
0.6686821579933167,
-0.1191398873925209,
0.062348898500204086,
-0.47528505325317383,
0.03086337260901928,
-0.4130394458770752,
-0.13965126872062683,
0.09423040598630905,
0.5516893863677979,
-0.3859366178512573,
0.6312892436981201,
0.7946867346763611,
0.06338842213153839,
-0.5510638952255249,
0.4724653363227844,
0.8653252124786377,
-0.6243781447410583,
-0.5825769901275635,
-1.102872610092163,
0.5195215940475464,
-0.21696896851062775,
-0.19971194863319397,
0.5292328596115112,
0.18400973081588745,
0.4001975953578949,
0.006107216700911522,
0.435064435005188,
0.19049933552742004,
0.17371807992458344,
-0.6984279155731201,
0.6588409543037415,
-0.8545206189155579,
0.38605648279190063,
-0.35394299030303955,
-0.49113786220550537,
-0.6012541055679321,
0.31357771158218384,
-0.6360679268836975,
-0.14908568561077118,
0.7762597799301147,
0.8931716680526733,
-0.06044922396540642,
0.1708911806344986,
0.44194495677948,
0.5243675708770752,
0.5895472168922424,
0.5863914489746094,
0.6887202262878418,
-0.14479714632034302,
0.052422016859054565,
0.3756803870201111,
-0.2465382069349289,
-0.06125219911336899,
-1.0683841705322266,
-0.9086151719093323,
-0.41277170181274414,
-0.35901832580566406,
-0.01377644669264555,
0.18600836396217346,
0.4155306816101074,
0.621186375617981,
-0.7984324097633362,
0.14761440455913544,
-0.6124846935272217,
0.5196811556816101,
-0.08721296489238739,
-0.3469192385673523,
0.7117515802383423,
-0.21184898912906647,
-0.19804252684116364,
0.5441258549690247,
0.5137904286384583,
-0.42354047298431396,
-0.22465169429779053,
-0.0902407094836235,
-0.35256966948509216,
0.34115636348724365,
0.9507026076316833,
0.2678460478782654,
-0.7238360047340393,
-0.3453400731086731,
-0.35724931955337524,
0.20840492844581604,
-0.4878619313240051,
1.1644505262374878,
-0.6766207814216614,
0.4905714988708496,
0.4309000074863434,
0.5934125185012817,
0.13641826808452606,
-0.2703377604484558,
0.6857576966285706,
-0.33350905776023865,
0.1433408260345459,
-0.3125143051147461,
0.5790897011756897,
0.170088529586792,
-0.732404887676239,
0.5294255018234253,
0.21374332904815674,
-0.19320228695869446,
-0.45761436223983765,
0.5036223530769348,
-0.8328633308410645,
-0.7886236906051636,
1.02546226978302,
-0.22478355467319489,
-0.005367399659007788,
-0.4347832500934601,
-0.012625344097614288,
0.45253831148147583,
-0.11322510987520218,
0.7078678607940674,
0.3712539076805115,
-0.30390745401382446,
-0.05513491854071617,
-0.46706292033195496,
0.25202301144599915,
0.5913308262825012,
-1.174134373664856,
-0.06239122152328491,
0.7533579468727112,
0.16567866504192352,
-0.08674032986164093,
0.5295273661613464,
-0.1744728982448578,
0.3450816869735718,
-0.2818693220615387,
-0.1625610888004303,
-0.21624867618083954,
-0.400713711977005,
-0.4105253219604492,
0.0862634927034378,
-0.40403252840042114,
0.2784818112850189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18137v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18137v2
|
DecisionNCE: Embodied Multimodal Representations via Implicit Preference Learning
| 2024-02-28T07:58:24 | 2024-05-24T03:31:50 |
Jianxiong Li, Jinliang Zheng, Yinan Zheng, Liyuan Mao, Xiao Hu, Sijie Cheng, Haoyi Niu, Jihao Liu, Yu Liu, Jingjing Liu, Ya-Qin Zhang, Xianyuan Zhan
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Multimodal pretraining is an effective strategy for the trinity of goals of
representation learning in autonomous robots: 1) extracting both local and
global task progressions; 2) enforcing temporal consistency of visual
representation; 3) capturing trajectory-level language grounding. Most existing
methods approach these via separate objectives, which often reach sub-optimal
solutions. In this paper, we propose a universal unified objective that can
simultaneously extract meaningful task progression information from image
sequences and seamlessly align them with language instructions. We discover
that via implicit preferences, where a visual trajectory inherently aligns
better with its corresponding language instruction than mismatched pairs, the
popular Bradley-Terry model can transform into representation learning through
proper reward reparameterizations. The resulted framework, DecisionNCE, mirrors
an InfoNCE-style objective but is distinctively tailored for decision-making
tasks, providing an embodied representation learning framework that elegantly
extracts both local and global task progression features, with temporal
consistency enforced through implicit time contrastive learning, while ensuring
trajectory-level instruction grounding via multimodal joint encoding.
Evaluation on both simulated and real robots demonstrates that DecisionNCE
effectively facilitates diverse downstream policy learning tasks, offering a
versatile solution for unified representation and reward learning. Project
Page: https://2toinf.github.io/DecisionNCE/
|
[
-0.06023915112018585,
-0.17608602344989777,
0.9332799911499023,
0.04196548089385033,
0.014475868083536625,
0.1550525724887848,
-0.15043099224567413,
0.025858651846647263,
0.25140300393104553,
0.5323277711868286,
-0.765720784664154,
-0.569259524345398,
-0.7027680277824402,
-0.19930486381053925,
0.07943972200155258,
0.9823163747787476,
-0.29408136010169983,
0.05624014139175415,
-0.17202037572860718,
-0.34673643112182617,
-0.5870749354362488,
-0.4232448935508728,
-0.5795948505401611,
-0.44210636615753174,
0.8032981157302856,
0.4548441171646118,
0.6374519467353821,
0.4587220847606659,
0.34172841906547546,
0.41847097873687744,
0.6088704466819763,
0.22627794742584229,
-0.39262107014656067,
0.058338675647974014,
-0.1950560361146927,
-0.448354572057724,
-0.08441022783517838,
0.12179514020681381,
0.5622521042823792,
0.501782238483429,
-0.09406166523694992,
-0.10816577821969986,
0.04630154371261597,
0.8888147473335266,
-0.8478066921234131,
0.3743775486946106,
-0.10052792727947235,
0.3102198541164398,
0.25036191940307617,
-0.2869044542312622,
-0.406036376953125,
-0.36744314432144165,
-0.041167810559272766,
-0.9069013595581055,
-0.0827382355928421,
-0.17326505482196808,
0.7374511361122131,
0.5573678016662598,
-0.5559861660003662,
-0.2322952002286911,
-0.7322061657905579,
0.8398844599723816,
0.048629943281412125,
0.5544431209564209,
0.056250911206007004,
0.40990394353866577,
0.06644555181264877,
-0.5968753695487976,
-0.49147486686706543,
-0.5117366313934326,
-0.13710807263851166,
0.6354495882987976,
-0.0802721157670021,
0.4764179289340973,
0.2826908230781555,
-0.04001962020993233,
-0.5172839760780334,
-0.19650393724441528,
-0.21633055806159973,
-0.3631240725517273,
0.3617219924926758,
-0.05265054479241371,
0.2965839207172394,
-0.2344847023487091,
-0.7437165975570679,
-0.6830707788467407,
-0.34438708424568176,
0.5086783766746521,
0.45049145817756653,
0.28498348593711853,
-0.18776963651180267,
0.5700171589851379,
-0.2170088291168213,
0.4573839008808136,
0.12883588671684265,
-0.08353825658559799,
0.3881773054599762,
-0.05725037679076195,
0.12526662647724152,
0.004114879760891199,
0.6983253359794617,
0.28372636437416077,
0.11023245751857758,
-0.2668454051017761,
-0.08182545006275177,
0.21331548690795898,
0.5546914339065552,
-0.5806303024291992,
-0.32830676436424255,
0.05548574775457382,
-0.334989994764328,
0.009072874672710896,
0.45462843775749207,
-0.6140615344047546,
-0.21218417584896088,
-0.7990094423294067,
0.6206104159355164,
-0.37143707275390625,
-0.2701263129711151,
0.28861021995544434,
-0.17728573083877563,
0.13786356151103973,
0.514408528804779,
-0.806984007358551,
0.055625613778829575,
0.1351783126592636,
0.7030869722366333,
-0.2000177949666977,
-0.2320365309715271,
-0.431413471698761,
0.37175074219703674,
-0.41598671674728394,
0.6604714393615723,
-0.5875934362411499,
-0.33487749099731445,
-0.22730176150798798,
0.17537523806095123,
-0.0850096046924591,
-0.2006945013999939,
0.48107877373695374,
-0.3437114357948303,
0.07066696882247925,
-0.20952549576759338,
-0.0580429844558239,
-0.4858848452568054,
0.29896268248558044,
-0.7903103828430176,
0.7675879597663879,
0.20820949971675873,
-0.26780030131340027,
0.6820818781852722,
-0.8409279584884644,
-0.25441524386405945,
-0.26981642842292786,
-0.4430292546749115,
-0.12383559346199036,
-0.15845604240894318,
0.1283280998468399,
0.43620386719703674,
0.1169138103723526,
0.3596971035003662,
-0.1905800998210907,
-0.08702818304300308,
-0.37580838799476624,
-0.37359943985939026,
0.4190560579299927,
0.027848055586218834,
-0.4594930410385132,
0.5678571462631226,
-0.5010166168212891,
-0.018337957561016083,
0.17245016992092133,
-0.2559032738208771,
-0.2375389039516449,
0.1818702071905136,
-0.38188037276268005,
0.2877359390258789,
0.48174208402633667,
-0.3835049271583557,
0.22950077056884766,
-0.007157821208238602,
-0.08860130608081818,
1.2029540538787842,
-0.4650281071662903,
0.8611935973167419,
-0.3005804717540741,
0.4677993655204773,
0.0943835973739624,
0.30698060989379883,
-0.26501742005348206,
-0.08591912686824799,
-0.9936415553092957,
-0.25633808970451355,
-0.11472895741462708,
0.4968244731426239,
-0.7885808944702148,
0.28630948066711426,
-0.2076987326145172,
-0.19055308401584625,
-0.17558123171329498,
0.08912809938192368,
0.5477144718170166,
0.4051869213581085,
0.5379123091697693,
-0.2770920991897583,
-0.4600974917411804,
-0.9547489881515503,
0.18693388998508453,
-0.36782407760620117,
0.08963591605424881,
0.2968215048313141,
0.40256747603416443,
-0.3695400059223175,
0.8620125651359558,
-0.43874281644821167,
-0.2420397400856018,
-0.09395068138837814,
0.5730485916137695,
0.3175497055053711,
0.6003737449645996,
0.6179584860801697,
-1.120584487915039,
0.0171161200851202,
0.04480355605483055,
-0.8367471694946289,
0.288703590631485,
-0.21159550547599792,
-0.42897701263427734,
-0.044426921755075455,
0.37740233540534973,
-0.40041646361351013,
0.3248712122440338,
0.46606123447418213,
0.02589525282382965,
0.3674277067184448,
-0.46293553709983826,
0.6501461863517761,
-0.8706029057502747,
-0.07624845206737518,
-0.17035070061683655,
-0.30574217438697815,
-0.09373393654823303,
-0.08546645194292068,
0.07346214354038239,
0.009794789366424084,
-0.3876006007194519,
0.41952455043792725,
-0.3381020724773407,
-0.07696408778429031,
-0.09488725662231445,
-0.0687723383307457,
-0.028920238837599754,
0.8218202590942383,
0.4241173565387726,
0.6316149234771729,
0.6025386452674866,
-0.9055935740470886,
0.4915255904197693,
0.1541706770658493,
0.05911865085363388,
0.5543487071990967,
-0.5028314590454102,
0.2364567071199417,
-0.5060316920280457,
0.24887242913246155,
-1.0693120956420898,
-0.29655948281288147,
0.35173100233078003,
-0.4155518412590027,
0.1364864856004715,
-0.14594581723213196,
-0.11346052587032318,
-0.40343332290649414,
-0.2198963463306427,
0.3676012456417084,
0.37257707118988037,
-0.6719858646392822,
1.0038039684295654,
0.1593138873577118,
0.28728145360946655,
-0.9290105700492859,
-0.41610172390937805,
-0.3379272520542145,
0.019664624705910683,
-0.4538824260234833,
0.3508901298046112,
-0.250866174697876,
-0.006812218111008406,
-0.10842885076999664,
-0.3478502929210663,
0.2857198417186737,
-0.20987285673618317,
0.4099084436893463,
0.30843454599380493,
-0.004393455106765032,
0.1886357069015503,
0.11744676530361176,
-0.5790657997131348,
-0.10523571819067001,
-0.5411211848258972,
0.4570736885070801,
-0.0947646051645279,
-0.6224868297576904,
-0.054251398891210556,
0.33911943435668945,
0.44017350673675537,
-0.0923389419913292,
0.25853490829467773,
0.7471361756324768,
-0.12035830318927765,
-0.14763379096984863,
-0.246135875582695,
-0.2591639459133148,
-0.49249568581581116,
0.30529898405075073,
-0.2737917900085449,
-0.6965656280517578,
0.10840453952550888,
-0.5060278177261353,
0.09546094387769699,
0.24994231760501862,
0.27413931488990784,
-0.36520496010780334,
1.2646775245666504,
0.9505845308303833,
0.11365252733230591,
0.6082669496536255,
-0.4384983479976654,
-0.14387328922748566,
-0.5561122894287109,
-0.5540984869003296,
-0.1896984577178955,
-0.4538359045982361,
-0.35761988162994385,
-0.4820916950702667,
0.5445528626441956,
0.12282869964838028,
-0.6386075019836426,
0.3855993151664734,
-0.47423940896987915,
0.43301138281822205,
0.6529894471168518,
0.5446354746818542,
0.04216769337654114,
0.05928356200456619,
-0.3963606357574463,
-0.16292956471443176,
-0.3424172103404999,
-0.7401131987571716,
0.9683716893196106,
-0.42750996351242065,
0.8977848291397095,
0.02220502495765686,
0.7018910050392151,
0.6374098658561707,
-0.007879347540438175,
-0.6350981593132019,
0.6120903491973877,
-0.29566898941993713,
-0.27240830659866333,
-0.03351617604494095,
-0.30018582940101624,
-1.041524887084961,
0.08110502362251282,
-0.3675656318664551,
-0.6544986963272095,
0.2025502324104309,
0.3627568185329437,
-0.3212727904319763,
0.2878207564353943,
-0.5443272590637207,
1.1853511333465576,
-0.6657004356384277,
-0.5442380905151367,
-0.3503354787826538,
-1.0202972888946533,
0.07169868052005768,
0.34717226028442383,
0.0056902035139501095,
-0.29985401034355164,
-0.07498867809772491,
0.5726088285446167,
0.08334526419639587,
0.7062555551528931,
-0.24376481771469116,
0.14378312230110168,
-0.004724598024040461,
0.12475577741861343,
0.3275673985481262,
-0.01092529110610485,
0.12582086026668549,
0.023466898128390312,
-0.40006062388420105,
-0.4018431007862091,
-0.7092748880386353,
0.2948274314403534,
-0.8935412168502808,
-0.48010897636413574,
-0.4864531457424164,
-0.4916374087333679,
-0.1645325869321823,
0.20868991315364838,
0.10866831988096237,
0.45950302481651306,
-0.37318068742752075,
0.007966474629938602,
0.6048256754875183,
-0.10961195081472397,
0.4296865165233612,
0.3677275478839874,
-0.31113752722740173,
-0.18820834159851074,
0.9830881357192993,
-0.38967540860176086,
0.35619497299194336,
0.9132370352745056,
0.10273055732250214,
-0.5313348770141602,
-0.09911037236452103,
-0.41120994091033936,
-0.03302730619907379,
-0.9945144653320312,
0.06051189452409744,
-0.6975780129432678,
0.07360783964395523,
-0.05787757411599159,
-0.5630751252174377,
-0.5324110984802246,
-0.20889508724212646,
-0.2676919102668762,
-0.20866195857524872,
0.16347280144691467,
0.9413561224937439,
-0.5022127628326416,
0.2666008472442627,
-0.5647851824760437,
0.6992645859718323,
0.7541967630386353,
-0.11567314714193344,
-0.4620121419429779,
-0.14923371374607086,
0.10861577838659286,
0.31960877776145935,
-0.5388283133506775,
-0.5699084997177124,
0.08861686289310455,
0.0346229188144207,
0.7197660207748413,
0.4761418402194977,
0.009016447700560093,
0.735590934753418,
-0.3538462817668915,
0.6243365406990051,
0.5821331739425659,
-0.7905264496803284,
0.87762850522995,
-0.3686084747314453,
0.1307946890592575,
0.6600685119628906,
0.7156203389167786,
-0.40626540780067444,
-0.062268584966659546,
-0.48053058981895447,
-0.8033896088600159,
0.8381457924842834,
0.08423607051372528,
0.25416216254234314,
0.14253421127796173,
-0.016888536512851715,
0.22209446132183075,
0.20360393822193146,
-1.004630446434021,
-0.20961585640907288,
-0.4123248755931854,
-0.3005344271659851,
-0.17933343350887299,
0.21797063946723938,
-0.24670815467834473,
-0.22590868175029755,
0.2989952564239502,
-0.4754350483417511,
0.5200455188751221,
0.10378164052963257,
-0.31707072257995605,
0.14621031284332275,
0.06524193286895752,
0.4040481448173523,
0.48900386691093445,
-0.06516388803720474,
0.10967931896448135,
-0.18183772265911102,
-0.23651336133480072,
0.6042070984840393,
-0.06960541009902954,
0.02609183080494404,
-0.16342206299304962,
0.23319849371910095,
0.978240966796875,
0.2967125177383423,
-0.637006402015686,
0.5847817063331604,
0.023556619882583618,
-0.02147498168051243,
-0.31786680221557617,
0.2990729808807373,
-0.28996673226356506,
0.4775221645832062,
0.3449500501155853,
0.6189230680465698,
0.22545664012432098,
-0.5421108603477478,
0.28329670429229736,
0.4080912470817566,
-0.691510796546936,
-0.28082385659217834,
0.8132072687149048,
0.07890132814645767,
0.2237628847360611,
0.39914336800575256,
-0.25157395005226135,
-0.37451568245887756,
0.7494580745697021,
0.1983216106891632,
0.8561092615127563,
-0.3129681348800659,
0.704025149345398,
0.7369385957717896,
0.2767774760723114,
-0.33410149812698364,
0.2895020842552185,
-0.5321381092071533,
-0.951097309589386,
-0.2697727680206299,
-0.4783325791358948,
-0.43882039189338684,
-0.6338942646980286,
-0.5252951383590698,
0.33433452248573303,
-0.43028008937835693,
-0.07951899617910385,
-0.4964825212955475,
-0.6773195266723633,
-0.675193190574646,
0.29213032126426697,
0.2760065793991089,
-0.1534389704465866,
-0.6232158541679382,
0.467590868473053,
0.768353283405304,
-0.766871452331543,
-0.7845634818077087,
-0.19477955996990204,
0.147984579205513,
-1.009340524673462,
1.0829484462738037,
0.4923151731491089,
-0.8096071481704712,
-0.03654533624649048,
-0.7702630758285522,
-0.8551112413406372,
1.1256457567214966,
0.859908401966095,
-0.40942150354385376,
-0.07127553224563599,
-0.0849088504910469,
-0.05294765159487724,
-0.3433702290058136,
0.519318699836731,
0.25114941596984863,
0.7531754374504089,
0.36965230107307434,
-0.426683247089386,
-0.21355542540550232,
-0.2829005718231201,
-0.19759079813957214,
0.28803369402885437,
-0.7128472924232483,
0.889995276927948,
-0.47441962361335754,
-0.32501718401908875,
-0.0029654919635504484,
0.5414558053016663,
0.31520724296569824,
-0.09081678837537766,
0.6785873174667358,
0.5353545546531677,
0.71181321144104,
-0.4339650571346283,
1.0152597427368164,
0.03674325346946716,
0.15708184242248535,
0.7695167064666748,
-0.14484046399593353,
0.324920654296875,
0.17181195318698883,
-0.040703073143959045,
0.8574990034103394,
0.48437559604644775,
0.49549517035484314,
0.7850156426429749,
-0.15842978656291962,
-0.1713142693042755,
-0.708293616771698,
-0.09945732355117798,
-0.3156563639640808,
0.5791922807693481,
0.20085546374320984,
-0.08606348186731339,
-0.29893794655799866,
0.39706435799598694,
-0.01724126562476158,
0.17560070753097534,
-0.43165335059165955,
0.7467629313468933,
-0.29682981967926025,
-0.7210001349449158,
0.2235480397939682,
-0.5105071067810059,
0.7418788075447083,
-1.1283565759658813,
-0.5324838161468506,
0.08712594211101532,
0.30309367179870605,
-0.04629499465227127,
-0.7535521984100342,
-0.18423177301883698,
-0.468421071767807,
-0.1870456039905548,
-0.6407510638237,
0.42476004362106323,
-0.49335217475891113,
-0.427848219871521,
0.7463464736938477,
0.19116322696208954,
0.009156867861747742,
0.056900493800640106,
-0.8899713158607483,
-0.09991280734539032,
-0.00746264448389411,
-0.07427386194467545,
-0.06571241468191147,
0.2822427451610565,
0.0965690091252327,
0.6877701878547668,
0.5298139452934265,
-0.23630332946777344,
-0.07823480665683746,
0.03575652837753296,
0.7348661422729492,
-0.6013593673706055,
-0.43326711654663086,
-0.6840559840202332,
0.8141994476318359,
-0.06985768675804138,
-0.2655886709690094,
0.4567793309688568,
0.33193737268447876,
1.0065500736236572,
-0.10743393003940582,
0.6768878102302551,
-0.26565027236938477,
-0.12365765124559402,
-1.0365357398986816,
0.3012782037258148,
-0.8710639476776123,
-0.42639613151550293,
-0.44685685634613037,
-0.9458595514297485,
-0.10341484844684601,
0.8517510294914246,
-0.23303531110286713,
0.45959749817848206,
0.8515551090240479,
0.6906723976135254,
-0.0920180082321167,
-0.18947839736938477,
0.3421902358531952,
-0.30442091822624207,
0.11311917752027512,
0.7641397714614868,
0.9715152382850647,
-0.11211112886667252,
0.5085313320159912,
-0.20580120384693146,
-0.23993949592113495,
0.15112127363681793,
-0.8765917420387268,
-0.5967852473258972,
-0.8530909419059753,
-0.1712823361158371,
0.033650338649749756,
0.32102885842323303,
1.149670124053955,
1.1063499450683594,
-0.7032779455184937,
-0.3214503228664398,
-0.16400210559368134,
0.1577865332365036,
-0.2809184789657593,
-0.14410243928432465,
0.20737086236476898,
-0.6129530668258667,
-0.8860012888908386,
0.44245487451553345,
0.6169411540031433,
0.05480983853340149,
-0.11686591804027557,
-0.4920230805873871,
-0.1677629053592682,
-0.38750123977661133,
0.6994249820709229,
0.3855910003185272,
-0.5170628428459167,
-0.4430946409702301,
-0.038942717015743256,
-0.0835043340921402,
0.3496570289134979,
1.0648778676986694,
-0.8511731624603271,
0.824405312538147,
0.1642642319202423,
0.5016344785690308,
0.6373060941696167,
-0.07839908450841904,
0.6742885708808899,
-0.6114558577537537,
0.516440749168396,
0.23755773901939392,
0.5844868421554565,
0.2670726776123047,
-0.09655013680458069,
0.6463133096694946,
0.2596454918384552,
-0.3781711459159851,
0.032691292464733124,
0.4876246750354767,
-1.1864615678787231,
-0.16591796278953552,
0.9435848593711853,
0.006354344077408314,
-0.176603764295578,
-0.08026370406150818,
-0.6417656540870667,
0.37153446674346924,
-0.5468919277191162,
0.2965572476387024,
0.4547179341316223,
-0.13888655602931976,
-0.1415005624294281,
-0.4769475758075714,
0.2726662755012512,
0.2905551493167877,
-0.734818160533905,
-0.27676230669021606,
0.8776279091835022,
-0.2293807417154312,
0.4470100402832031,
0.7093257308006287,
-0.019842403009533882,
0.3651650846004486,
-0.2121635377407074,
0.6512333750724792,
0.10626815259456635,
-0.8423579335212708,
0.07595354318618774,
-0.03759219869971275,
-0.24795986711978912,
-0.47323766350746155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18121v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18121v1
|
Saving the legacy of Hero Ibash: Evaluating Four Language Models for Aminoacian
| 2024-02-28T07:22:13 | 2024-02-28T07:22:13 |
Yunze Xiao, Yiyang Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study assesses four cutting-edge language models in the underexplored
Aminoacian language. Through evaluation, it scrutinizes their adaptability,
effectiveness, and limitations in text generation, semantic coherence, and
contextual understanding. Uncovering insights into these models' performance in
a low-resourced language, this research pioneers pathways to bridge linguistic
gaps. By offering benchmarks and understanding challenges, it lays groundwork
for future advancements in natural language processing, aiming to elevate the
applicability of language models in similar linguistic landscapes, marking a
significant step toward inclusivity and progress in language technology.
|
[
-0.5164146423339844,
-0.39654219150543213,
0.42705008387565613,
-0.20845317840576172,
0.0684497058391571,
0.3237650990486145,
-0.1958828866481781,
-0.6037596464157104,
-0.14135295152664185,
0.746054470539093,
-0.40261316299438477,
-0.17582251131534576,
-0.38204824924468994,
0.47815433144569397,
-0.08757106959819794,
1.105765700340271,
-0.0865948423743248,
0.00472994102165103,
-0.24336518347263336,
-0.7005406022071838,
-0.8302791118621826,
-0.3511230945587158,
-0.8267446756362915,
-0.5513889789581299,
0.4799667298793793,
0.7158332467079163,
1.1062703132629395,
0.6742947101593018,
0.5788129568099976,
0.2144470363855362,
-0.038370005786418915,
-0.0955839678645134,
-0.43342509865760803,
0.16438810527324677,
-0.6513213515281677,
-0.41405320167541504,
-0.7478257417678833,
-0.1606103479862213,
0.7988852858543396,
0.7917155623435974,
0.2854158282279968,
0.03992524743080139,
-0.16814379394054413,
0.6590643525123596,
-0.6542645692825317,
0.08316183090209961,
-0.5484297871589661,
-0.379841685295105,
-0.5072706341743469,
0.0023932603653520346,
-0.34578055143356323,
-0.5285385251045227,
-0.01282457821071148,
-0.04499134048819542,
0.08608924597501755,
0.13401377201080322,
0.6384584307670593,
-0.28075456619262695,
-0.24865998327732086,
-0.26525643467903137,
-0.7094200849533081,
0.8376440405845642,
-1.0186904668807983,
0.18776430189609528,
0.6655413508415222,
0.585363507270813,
-0.12364000827074051,
-1.1681321859359741,
-0.8467096090316772,
-0.17544673383235931,
0.0217400211840868,
-0.03730687126517296,
-0.37848198413848877,
0.10353017598390579,
0.011303313076496124,
0.7057989835739136,
-0.40582913160324097,
0.34098950028419495,
-0.5731586217880249,
-0.016199445351958275,
0.7842863202095032,
0.29737189412117004,
0.6979542374610901,
-0.27624571323394775,
-0.2240362912416458,
-0.2854430079460144,
-0.9363589882850647,
0.3021136224269867,
0.44061607122421265,
0.5648740530014038,
-0.13307783007621765,
0.26055237650871277,
-0.16475088894367218,
0.46724560856819153,
-0.4726192355155945,
-0.2054888904094696,
-0.0013117109192535281,
-0.23708727955818176,
0.013153341598808765,
0.005130769219249487,
0.7445389628410339,
0.33977431058883667,
0.2334209829568863,
-0.053964342921972275,
-0.16590699553489685,
0.17998287081718445,
0.3878825008869171,
-0.7774305939674377,
-0.2999420762062073,
0.23459555208683014,
-0.46846961975097656,
-0.08749834448099136,
-0.49641531705856323,
-0.7842288613319397,
-0.33232569694519043,
0.08369357883930206,
0.3836507499217987,
-0.8593073487281799,
-0.14842922985553741,
-0.20905521512031555,
-0.1577075868844986,
0.029587119817733765,
0.37771111726760864,
-1.251284122467041,
0.3593713045120239,
0.5558893084526062,
0.9264890551567078,
0.024525552988052368,
-0.3085879385471344,
-0.15876804292201996,
0.0890277698636055,
-0.2535642981529236,
1.0595762729644775,
-0.8245598673820496,
-0.3027059733867645,
-0.1574403941631317,
-0.23657605051994324,
-0.12453959137201309,
-0.2896132171154022,
0.9491595029830933,
-0.33058661222457886,
-0.15248054265975952,
-0.3450250029563904,
-0.6214001774787903,
-0.6493869423866272,
0.2645832896232605,
-1.0611505508422852,
0.5899595618247986,
0.6462616920471191,
-0.536089301109314,
0.07562801241874695,
-0.8392599821090698,
-0.20637992024421692,
0.5066744089126587,
-0.19349388778209686,
-0.21192294359207153,
0.22880662977695465,
0.06886908411979675,
0.13945305347442627,
-0.724731981754303,
0.056312620639801025,
-0.17989516258239746,
-0.139537051320076,
0.17528283596038818,
-0.5415961146354675,
0.8021599650382996,
0.25579163432121277,
-0.24280200898647308,
-0.13957008719444275,
-0.6612908840179443,
0.07896681129932404,
-0.07005243748426437,
-0.09840963035821915,
-0.36123746633529663,
-0.02766573801636696,
0.3410433530807495,
0.15979091823101044,
0.11551729589700699,
-0.5247772932052612,
0.3432716429233551,
-0.3803189694881439,
0.5852746963500977,
0.6476244330406189,
-0.09320991486310959,
0.16508324444293976,
-0.3843995928764343,
0.7249155640602112,
-0.38111695647239685,
0.11718615144491196,
-0.4648371636867523,
-0.48160070180892944,
-0.685606062412262,
-0.153176411986351,
0.5482972860336304,
0.2808350622653961,
-0.8203151226043701,
-0.16872143745422363,
-0.3739253580570221,
-0.4640788435935974,
-0.7308205366134644,
0.02825252339243889,
0.3531397879123688,
0.493135929107666,
0.5022516250610352,
-0.6986371874809265,
-0.34967172145843506,
-1.3400459289550781,
-0.42528608441352844,
-0.398844838142395,
0.21483643352985382,
0.1470816284418106,
0.6243927478790283,
-0.6154474020004272,
1.0754262208938599,
0.17485223710536957,
0.18540307879447937,
-0.9721114039421082,
0.42042994499206543,
0.20342886447906494,
0.6739693284034729,
0.775753378868103,
-0.6335709095001221,
-0.5678753852844238,
0.3684522211551666,
-0.6289188861846924,
-0.12311559170484543,
0.03291599452495575,
0.10056343674659729,
-0.0615149587392807,
0.12178370356559753,
-0.41458797454833984,
0.7648743391036987,
0.5073263645172119,
-0.2472459226846695,
0.43980860710144043,
-0.007386968936771154,
0.40244510769844055,
-0.8918217420578003,
0.4515758752822876,
-0.5670856237411499,
-0.27659422159194946,
-1.008136510848999,
0.28299424052238464,
0.07095874845981598,
-0.1372608244419098,
-0.25557270646095276,
0.9780211448669434,
-0.49700066447257996,
-0.1103266254067421,
-0.5546558499336243,
0.07235116511583328,
0.08531075716018677,
0.24462124705314636,
0.03426745906472206,
0.7138881683349609,
0.3091765344142914,
-0.49137046933174133,
0.25012025237083435,
0.4146553575992584,
-0.3260464668273926,
0.8178739547729492,
-0.5853365659713745,
0.0664808601140976,
-0.0680866464972496,
-0.05968295782804489,
-0.9204363226890564,
-0.2146734893321991,
0.10634231567382812,
-0.543725311756134,
0.4602939188480377,
-0.25120553374290466,
-0.4149749279022217,
-0.300304651260376,
-0.25838610529899597,
0.7644398212432861,
0.4406636655330658,
-0.2764852046966553,
0.5562369227409363,
0.39630329608917236,
-0.5730926990509033,
-0.37343931198120117,
-0.5449255108833313,
0.3956027328968048,
-0.07647787779569626,
-0.49217817187309265,
0.036962151527404785,
-0.2584816515445709,
-0.5250422358512878,
-0.32988324761390686,
0.04693542420864105,
-0.17053762078285217,
0.27803835272789,
-0.15560536086559296,
0.15502233803272247,
-0.37734460830688477,
-0.1064399927854538,
0.2084159404039383,
-0.03744733706116676,
-0.3635990619659424,
0.18603910505771637,
0.6585169434547424,
-0.334624707698822,
-0.03406742215156555,
-0.39055490493774414,
0.4662412703037262,
0.6682252287864685,
-0.34968286752700806,
1.0095081329345703,
0.3623625338077545,
-0.5388637185096741,
-0.027914969250559807,
-0.3345598876476288,
0.01411112304776907,
-0.4611644148826599,
0.3224397599697113,
-0.29528433084487915,
-0.5318108201026917,
0.6205836534500122,
-0.11000874638557434,
0.16151073575019836,
0.6548230648040771,
0.4201706051826477,
0.02273331768810749,
0.6779415607452393,
0.6742242574691772,
-0.01614176109433174,
0.16301916539669037,
-0.3939298987388611,
0.35543856024742126,
-1.1681642532348633,
0.008791693486273289,
-0.49796828627586365,
-0.3561560809612274,
-0.5848252773284912,
-0.048000700771808624,
0.3753020763397217,
0.32270726561546326,
-0.04032536968588829,
0.7160300016403198,
0.14183178544044495,
0.2987750172615051,
0.24980568885803223,
-0.19408223032951355,
0.3127516806125641,
-0.15423738956451416,
-0.1131175309419632,
-0.12182357907295227,
-0.8523176312446594,
-0.9434210062026978,
1.1947077512741089,
0.4751405119895935,
0.5090529918670654,
0.30503571033477783,
0.34504300355911255,
0.706882894039154,
0.606147050857544,
-0.4396280348300934,
0.38615596294403076,
-0.09915097802877426,
-0.700718343257904,
-0.2856268882751465,
-0.3014223873615265,
-1.007577657699585,
0.30028170347213745,
-0.15176747739315033,
-1.1527007818222046,
0.42663511633872986,
0.14415575563907623,
-0.3478779196739197,
0.5488889217376709,
-0.3581359386444092,
1.251237154006958,
-0.15987813472747803,
-0.6124205589294434,
-0.38435786962509155,
-0.641208827495575,
0.4130623936653137,
0.20529401302337646,
0.4415822923183441,
-0.14303533732891083,
0.17259156703948975,
0.3612791895866394,
-0.3293299674987793,
0.4589669406414032,
0.4520106911659241,
0.11858364194631577,
0.31848689913749695,
0.3430079221725464,
0.17284327745437622,
0.05874677374958992,
-0.2610031068325043,
0.35916417837142944,
-0.18070350587368011,
-0.47088903188705444,
-0.5324490070343018,
0.6849954724311829,
-0.5720664262771606,
-0.2195955067873001,
-0.5025200247764587,
-0.7395108342170715,
-0.2543950378894806,
0.38308125734329224,
0.2502084970474243,
0.9959537386894226,
-0.5736000537872314,
0.22435995936393738,
0.4788849353790283,
-0.20298103988170624,
0.8024888634681702,
0.43189719319343567,
0.0074946703389286995,
-0.6565491557121277,
0.6970072388648987,
-0.013887320645153522,
0.44758614897727966,
0.3766208291053772,
0.019634800031781197,
-0.206742525100708,
-0.8188232183456421,
-0.691675066947937,
0.2423344850540161,
-0.7899858951568604,
-0.3839736878871918,
-0.6782164573669434,
-0.18666934967041016,
-0.4050290584564209,
-0.288100004196167,
-0.6743196845054626,
-0.6122313737869263,
-0.011046207509934902,
0.049675751477479935,
0.23386208713054657,
1.0567984580993652,
-0.10456639528274536,
0.5305182933807373,
-0.9407973289489746,
0.17606602609157562,
0.11093740165233612,
0.3935163617134094,
0.20038968324661255,
-0.46654006838798523,
-0.6523082256317139,
0.11690463870763779,
-0.4975728690624237,
-0.880638062953949,
0.5117759704589844,
0.3759428858757019,
0.7937990427017212,
0.31664398312568665,
0.1696593463420868,
0.36287444829940796,
-0.612955629825592,
0.7104490399360657,
0.18315310776233673,
-1.130213975906372,
0.5247912406921387,
-0.47194889187812805,
0.5377959609031677,
0.8712188601493835,
0.4041486084461212,
-0.7009352445602417,
-0.40568771958351135,
-0.7314996123313904,
-1.062892198562622,
0.7167366743087769,
0.6949360370635986,
-0.14765992760658264,
-0.09129992872476578,
0.08682402968406677,
0.48062974214553833,
0.285453200340271,
-0.8120743036270142,
-0.17481127381324768,
-0.25741708278656006,
-0.27529799938201904,
-0.11707571893930435,
-0.3064303398132324,
0.1005575880408287,
-0.22123059630393982,
0.5667347311973572,
-0.1558922678232193,
0.20335963368415833,
-0.07202611118555069,
-0.4555237293243408,
0.07804399728775024,
0.5096210837364197,
0.6358148455619812,
1.0351736545562744,
-0.12408340722322464,
-0.06821166723966599,
0.10892420262098312,
-0.7292691469192505,
-0.09799807518720627,
-0.07884235680103302,
-0.1374460607767105,
-0.10743896663188934,
0.8607566356658936,
1.060565710067749,
0.37088000774383545,
-0.7311262488365173,
0.15116538107395172,
-0.19947662949562073,
0.5920237302780151,
-0.1973256766796112,
0.11227961629629135,
-0.1395038515329361,
0.2581081688404083,
0.3974769711494446,
0.35110223293304443,
0.33118629455566406,
-1.1466537714004517,
0.05218386650085449,
0.23825174570083618,
-0.06946559995412827,
-0.5862852931022644,
0.5942421555519104,
0.1414507031440735,
-0.45560145378112793,
0.5933747291564941,
0.17324016988277435,
-0.6598109006881714,
0.4145820140838623,
0.6533377766609192,
1.0050112009048462,
-0.46030062437057495,
0.11585692316293716,
0.5289932489395142,
0.4626753330230713,
-0.09353653341531754,
-0.012297085486352444,
-0.10461338609457016,
-0.72797691822052,
0.22502800822257996,
-0.6899566054344177,
-0.5896484851837158,
0.1434761881828308,
-0.7709102034568787,
0.06986507773399353,
-0.5321630835533142,
-0.36776265501976013,
-0.012745382264256477,
-0.021650904789566994,
-0.6724793314933777,
0.22914206981658936,
0.1372770220041275,
0.8971105813980103,
-0.7614936232566833,
0.7370796203613281,
0.540086567401886,
-0.7027544975280762,
-0.35907480120658875,
0.011672155931591988,
-0.3533543050289154,
-0.5171764492988586,
0.47246894240379333,
0.17260265350341797,
-0.06946862488985062,
-0.10252748429775238,
-0.43443775177001953,
-0.9003217816352844,
1.1240688562393188,
0.4862510561943054,
-0.2961408495903015,
0.1053529754281044,
0.07475505024194717,
0.6743761301040649,
-0.4444045126438141,
0.8504584431648254,
0.920721173286438,
0.47940006852149963,
-0.2565045952796936,
-1.2092180252075195,
-0.26431986689567566,
-0.5310686230659485,
0.4324384033679962,
0.0002778559864964336,
-0.6986247301101685,
1.2364652156829834,
-0.10944513231515884,
-0.4830878674983978,
0.5177215337753296,
0.8389338850975037,
0.1776932030916214,
0.2474362701177597,
-0.08873146772384644,
0.5215458273887634,
0.4945533871650696,
0.126271590590477,
1.3956754207611084,
-0.2242223024368286,
0.13223126530647278,
0.9459400773048401,
-0.23508095741271973,
0.9361506104469299,
0.07474280893802643,
-0.1863861083984375,
1.011582374572754,
0.2743892967700958,
0.4830915033817291,
0.3895377218723297,
-0.2136339396238327,
-0.385966032743454,
-0.07814578711986542,
-0.15156790614128113,
-0.40010693669319153,
0.6825097799301147,
0.4719948172569275,
-0.2376432865858078,
-0.26125916838645935,
0.039996374398469925,
0.2792646586894989,
0.35432305932044983,
-0.791795551776886,
0.41022104024887085,
0.09998851269483566,
-0.5586927533149719,
0.6873175501823425,
0.17052708566188812,
0.24404028058052063,
-0.751958966255188,
-0.3293951153755188,
-0.630765974521637,
0.3596566915512085,
0.018472084775567055,
-0.6076264977455139,
0.21396182477474213,
0.1148999035358429,
-0.23648662865161896,
-0.1375584602355957,
0.6872612833976746,
-0.3051348328590393,
-0.48768356442451477,
0.2261495590209961,
0.10281267762184143,
0.17816880345344543,
0.47376343607902527,
-0.3420535922050476,
0.3184550702571869,
-0.15983988344669342,
0.1048918142914772,
0.2729850709438324,
0.23056849837303162,
-0.2955595850944519,
0.8958934545516968,
0.23548004031181335,
0.01986905001103878,
-0.2863052189350128,
-0.1851617842912674,
0.6281906366348267,
-0.7870779633522034,
-0.66017746925354,
-0.9087199568748474,
0.5727242231369019,
-0.08136557787656784,
-0.5427577495574951,
0.9913068413734436,
0.5168564915657043,
0.7124726176261902,
-0.19645167887210846,
0.8736289739608765,
-0.0851643979549408,
0.48800337314605713,
-0.5402222275733948,
1.177168607711792,
-0.3258529007434845,
0.258647084236145,
-0.4955670237541199,
-0.725893497467041,
-0.006489770021289587,
0.6398739218711853,
-0.13181783258914948,
0.06829115748405457,
0.8160243630409241,
0.18730776011943817,
-0.005750492215156555,
0.21153195202350616,
0.4349236488342285,
0.2356710433959961,
0.1597164422273636,
0.6043661236763,
0.6848229169845581,
-0.7320502400398254,
-0.06361201405525208,
0.10025478899478912,
-0.1856389045715332,
-0.23940809071063995,
-0.8238575458526611,
-1.052947998046875,
-0.5143881440162659,
-0.01007640641182661,
-0.057230886071920395,
0.2748040556907654,
0.7798999547958374,
0.2926923632621765,
-1.117507815361023,
-0.6182152628898621,
0.01730041764676571,
0.31896743178367615,
-0.15112817287445068,
-0.20368295907974243,
0.10527613759040833,
-0.11252471804618835,
-0.7927430272102356,
0.6632459163665771,
0.41193053126335144,
-0.062199916690588,
-0.3316081166267395,
-0.16858163475990295,
-0.3774961233139038,
0.34372973442077637,
0.6402785778045654,
0.8334171175956726,
-0.6053591966629028,
-0.3110845983028412,
-0.41473883390426636,
0.051429927349090576,
0.1944158524274826,
0.9003803730010986,
-0.8437472581863403,
0.5488617420196533,
0.5788792371749878,
0.5158711075782776,
0.2410695105791092,
-0.16648364067077637,
1.145211100578308,
-0.3771568238735199,
0.05708274245262146,
0.5406829714775085,
0.5919286608695984,
0.6552750468254089,
-0.04391923546791077,
0.47517120838165283,
0.30318957567214966,
-0.5396154522895813,
-1.1192145347595215,
0.44555914402008057,
-0.619916558265686,
-0.1844765841960907,
0.7163459062576294,
-0.17325067520141602,
-0.1066904067993164,
-0.32751181721687317,
0.07595986127853394,
0.09223975986242294,
-0.20098862051963806,
0.4890391528606415,
0.6228970289230347,
-0.17323924601078033,
-0.5776275396347046,
-0.6828760504722595,
0.5792199373245239,
-0.02491755597293377,
-0.7534429430961609,
-0.07111570239067078,
0.4407408833503723,
0.1214039996266365,
0.1077190414071083,
0.7556341290473938,
-0.09697306901216507,
0.5880442261695862,
0.23055022954940796,
0.3413446247577667,
0.12113415449857712,
-0.627979576587677,
-0.3734487295150757,
-0.061518557369709015,
0.25284475088119507,
0.36060672998428345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18120v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18120v2
|
Exploring Multilingual Concepts of Human Value in Large Language Models: Is Value Alignment Consistent, Transferable and Controllable across Languages?
| 2024-02-28T07:18:39 | 2024-04-16T07:29:36 |
Shaoyang Xu, Weilong Dong, Zishan Guo, Xinwei Wu, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prior research in representation engineering has revealed that LLMs encode
concepts within their representation spaces, predominantly centered around
English. In this study, we extend this philosophy to a multilingual scenario,
delving into multilingual human value concepts in LLMs. Through our
comprehensive exploration covering 7 types of human values, 16 languages and 3
LLM series with distinct multilinguality, we empirically substantiate the
existence of multilingual human values in LLMs. Further cross-lingual analysis
on these concepts discloses 3 traits arising from language resource
disparities: cross-lingual inconsistency, distorted linguistic relationships,
and unidirectional cross-lingual transfer between high- and low-resource
languages, all in terms of human value concepts. Additionally, we validate the
feasibility of cross-lingual control over value alignment capabilities of LLMs,
leveraging the dominant language as a source language. Drawing from our
findings on multilingual value alignment, we prudently provide suggestions on
the composition of multilingual data for LLMs pre-training: including a limited
number of dominant languages for cross-lingual alignment transfer while
avoiding their excessive prevalence, and keeping a balanced distribution of
non-dominant languages. We aspire that our findings would contribute to
enhancing the safety and utility of multilingual AI.
|
[
-0.28311657905578613,
-0.14450985193252563,
0.28797855973243713,
0.33437272906303406,
0.09543661028146744,
0.5255653858184814,
-0.14875754714012146,
-0.8851388096809387,
0.4276992380619049,
0.16243593394756317,
-0.2996641993522644,
-0.021713601425290108,
-0.6154313683509827,
0.029067283496260643,
0.16696102917194366,
0.51686030626297,
-0.4215985834598541,
0.4591614902019501,
-0.13226646184921265,
-0.634382963180542,
-0.4690361022949219,
-1.1212579011917114,
-0.22383883595466614,
-0.37892529368400574,
0.7150687575340271,
0.2630126178264618,
0.8635645508766174,
0.4470102787017822,
0.5127754807472229,
0.2052137702703476,
-0.1321265697479248,
0.03163791820406914,
-0.30165648460388184,
-0.17683950066566467,
-0.3750508427619934,
-0.32185617089271545,
-0.7469052672386169,
0.24584618210792542,
0.7596302032470703,
0.9117739796638489,
-0.05383698269724846,
0.09451744705438614,
0.09534141421318054,
0.6765700578689575,
-0.5720131397247314,
0.2051076740026474,
-0.3610343635082245,
0.13402000069618225,
-0.2878013551235199,
-0.10474209487438202,
-0.2444154918193817,
-0.3280544579029083,
-0.12470145523548126,
-0.5180930495262146,
-0.3104605972766876,
0.024206504225730896,
1.1080788373947144,
0.24079211056232452,
-0.6413323283195496,
-0.14042221009731293,
-0.40462222695350647,
0.9458912014961243,
-0.4308551251888275,
0.7251951694488525,
0.22291909158229828,
0.26104313135147095,
0.3031879961490631,
-0.05783155933022499,
-0.4639792740345001,
-0.06925678253173828,
-0.23715777695178986,
0.12813425064086914,
0.2927514612674713,
0.09169043600559235,
0.016037069261074066,
0.19955694675445557,
-0.3639915883541107,
0.4941721558570862,
-0.21034327149391174,
-0.40526896715164185,
0.9318425059318542,
0.14383819699287415,
0.44041144847869873,
0.06360575556755066,
-0.3151738941669464,
-0.3023277521133423,
-1.0109831094741821,
0.21588394045829773,
0.5316756963729858,
0.402103066444397,
-0.1435670405626297,
0.5886871218681335,
0.3129589855670929,
0.41873541474342346,
-0.33414193987846375,
-0.48497509956359863,
0.40626221895217896,
-0.5940807461738586,
0.1145891472697258,
0.18743088841438293,
0.5496054887771606,
0.2665264904499054,
0.6484928727149963,
-0.26112839579582214,
-0.0519966222345829,
-0.08078702539205551,
0.17150698602199554,
-0.671576201915741,
0.28474724292755127,
-0.16847504675388336,
-0.5829907059669495,
-0.08371800929307938,
-0.1341773271560669,
-0.47930893301963806,
-0.3443593680858612,
-0.5787926316261292,
0.035389065742492676,
-0.23972606658935547,
-0.5976481437683105,
0.15413494408130646,
0.11988849937915802,
0.39898037910461426,
0.21049442887306213,
-1.2232050895690918,
0.030349338427186012,
0.3619457185268402,
0.6044138073921204,
-0.5094448328018188,
-0.7961079478263855,
-0.016236748546361923,
0.2517077326774597,
-0.337891548871994,
0.5799241065979004,
-0.4795093834400177,
-0.4776518940925598,
-0.05232563987374306,
0.08886808156967163,
-0.029608581215143204,
-0.5126710534095764,
0.12435991317033768,
-0.6877928972244263,
0.06406859308481216,
-0.4421446919441223,
-0.30652838945388794,
-0.059175509959459305,
0.25160250067710876,
-0.7963522672653198,
0.8486186861991882,
0.12031329423189163,
-0.5320929884910583,
0.5231202244758606,
-0.6718497276306152,
-0.5744402408599854,
-0.10118787735700607,
-0.5300419330596924,
-0.10575241595506668,
0.01719542033970356,
-0.1915990114212036,
0.32230859994888306,
-0.3316866457462311,
0.29893219470977783,
-0.3106900453567505,
-0.07383476197719574,
0.40276801586151123,
-0.6161739230155945,
0.7737868428230286,
0.12693418562412262,
-0.23895177245140076,
0.004342988599091768,
-0.6022313237190247,
0.1560121774673462,
0.09556330740451813,
-0.47152552008628845,
-0.23795069754123688,
-0.1870577484369278,
0.2172323316335678,
0.5393407940864563,
0.4598526954650879,
-0.4533817172050476,
0.27585816383361816,
-0.09662323445081711,
0.18732622265815735,
0.8535759449005127,
-0.3023368716239929,
0.6940680146217346,
-0.2364204376935959,
0.7486879229545593,
0.11994404345750809,
-0.04262448474764824,
0.13674940168857574,
-0.32748082280158997,
-0.5026810765266418,
-0.28095120191574097,
0.0738307535648346,
0.7988998293876648,
-0.42835095524787903,
0.18439605832099915,
-0.22496740520000458,
-0.04720724746584892,
-0.8794938921928406,
0.2370395064353943,
0.3500441610813141,
0.21166583895683289,
0.37422680854797363,
0.08821608126163483,
-0.5445559024810791,
-1.2241829633712769,
-0.26547107100486755,
-0.24881736934185028,
0.09018459171056747,
0.09834745526313782,
0.2527771294116974,
-0.34081923961639404,
0.8007720708847046,
-0.2958287298679352,
-0.023209121078252792,
-0.12864616513252258,
0.12539657950401306,
0.06789353489875793,
0.3775720000267029,
0.546323835849762,
-0.9165396094322205,
-0.4841436445713043,
0.3979716897010803,
-0.8954036831855774,
-0.11822590976953506,
-0.14690501987934113,
-0.1785404533147812,
0.4490220546722412,
0.3723556697368622,
-0.28181546926498413,
0.19291816651821136,
0.6493346691131592,
-0.17533279955387115,
0.4115610420703888,
-0.21827180683612823,
0.3653307557106018,
-1.2435611486434937,
0.19795314967632294,
-0.10387424379587173,
-0.03201916813850403,
-0.3284679353237152,
0.07178420573472977,
0.3255250155925751,
0.10736864805221558,
-0.6631917953491211,
0.7974275946617126,
-0.6879315972328186,
-0.28756892681121826,
-0.22141750156879425,
-0.04562928155064583,
0.11362043023109436,
0.2645491659641266,
0.2864859104156494,
1.0001901388168335,
0.16905686259269714,
-0.4626798927783966,
0.4890042841434479,
0.1879713535308838,
-0.11663107573986053,
1.067971110343933,
-0.42746174335479736,
-0.046225663274526596,
-0.11602054536342621,
-0.24622023105621338,
-0.6683982014656067,
0.019947368651628494,
-0.04373084008693695,
-0.3960963487625122,
0.5604263544082642,
-0.11430218070745468,
-0.5119304656982422,
0.23714782297611237,
-0.04120824486017227,
0.6992033123970032,
0.2765331566333771,
-0.24676820635795593,
0.35175079107284546,
0.859032392501831,
-0.35850295424461365,
-0.8382124900817871,
-0.8497868180274963,
0.17840738594532013,
-0.37768685817718506,
-0.7343593835830688,
0.35343843698501587,
-0.17146123945713043,
-0.43522584438323975,
-0.048904284834861755,
0.15613025426864624,
-0.23615434765815735,
0.217460498213768,
-0.00913133006542921,
0.5166071057319641,
-0.1733192354440689,
0.34386706352233887,
-0.07444951683282852,
-0.3243766725063324,
0.009352663531899452,
-0.32618314027786255,
0.10207799077033997,
-0.26700714230537415,
-0.7320442199707031,
-0.10163893550634384,
0.4850986897945404,
0.7415232062339783,
-0.208192840218544,
0.6936011910438538,
0.5907185077667236,
-0.5073055624961853,
0.30097734928131104,
-0.49177587032318115,
0.08871377259492874,
-0.41426289081573486,
0.5148236751556396,
-0.5049641132354736,
-0.9724221229553223,
0.6836646199226379,
0.04497651755809784,
0.1274222433567047,
0.4261484146118164,
0.6244881749153137,
-0.24741266667842865,
1.0670709609985352,
0.7888829708099365,
-0.4437096118927002,
0.24999620020389557,
-0.04174661636352539,
0.1758238524198532,
-0.7216054797172546,
-0.3868120312690735,
-0.43388646841049194,
-0.5592486262321472,
-0.6637070178985596,
-0.3743513226509094,
0.4386552572250366,
0.22919294238090515,
-0.432172954082489,
0.07659098505973816,
-0.2809634208679199,
0.42491820454597473,
0.23473329842090607,
-0.413394570350647,
0.2946997880935669,
-0.12102967500686646,
-0.11775080859661102,
-0.4737357199192047,
-0.5936861634254456,
-0.7483490109443665,
0.7938054800033569,
0.49467676877975464,
1.0728175640106201,
0.33969852328300476,
0.5264608263969421,
0.08934027701616287,
0.3986891806125641,
-0.8823702335357666,
0.10623697191476822,
0.11600494384765625,
-0.6940184831619263,
-0.5228418707847595,
-0.3411211669445038,
-0.9093214273452759,
0.3797728717327118,
-0.09437812864780426,
-0.5954198241233826,
0.17563126981258392,
0.03981909155845642,
-0.16889946162700653,
0.5099790692329407,
-0.6450669765472412,
1.0137466192245483,
-1.010926604270935,
-0.31230872869491577,
-0.26883235573768616,
-0.7569483518600464,
0.20709119737148285,
-0.18836042284965515,
0.5109432339668274,
-0.16298511624336243,
-0.12257633358240128,
0.5131439566612244,
-0.05638136342167854,
0.7967166304588318,
0.047864265739917755,
-0.581115186214447,
0.00009787043381948024,
-0.025629036128520966,
0.1611970067024231,
0.06914059072732925,
-0.12871505320072174,
0.3900761306285858,
0.11847461014986038,
-0.6941502690315247,
-0.3475898504257202,
0.5852962136268616,
-1.1364929676055908,
-0.4708579480648041,
-0.48094141483306885,
-0.7498704195022583,
-0.28230395913124084,
0.3215634226799011,
0.13154037296772003,
-0.044359736144542694,
-0.3346174955368042,
-0.14382420480251312,
0.6997665166854858,
-0.34145835041999817,
0.3182261884212494,
0.2873973548412323,
-0.14308051764965057,
-0.4012362062931061,
1.0307424068450928,
0.23835624754428864,
0.6669269800186157,
0.7629899382591248,
0.017634591087698936,
-0.6061848402023315,
-0.27884751558303833,
-0.6834166049957275,
0.30247777700424194,
-0.8978438973426819,
-0.07073578983545303,
-0.326500803232193,
-0.21366608142852783,
-0.35972025990486145,
-0.480554461479187,
-0.5493999719619751,
-0.2994375228881836,
-0.3152585029602051,
-0.24537359178066254,
0.18963606655597687,
0.7325437068939209,
0.0201420858502388,
-0.09303930401802063,
-1.1339352130889893,
0.18273793160915375,
0.2206309586763382,
0.5041539669036865,
-0.3012647032737732,
-0.47117045521736145,
-0.5618218183517456,
0.42018333077430725,
-0.25066429376602173,
-0.696198046207428,
0.43401479721069336,
-0.07484982162714005,
1.0911917686462402,
0.20408011972904205,
-0.1911366879940033,
0.6709681749343872,
-0.39808687567710876,
0.6975157856941223,
0.34048232436180115,
-1.0046017169952393,
0.10303188115358353,
0.029235979542136192,
0.033538565039634705,
0.5462736487388611,
0.4935578405857086,
-0.9202099442481995,
0.08297952264547348,
-0.42941761016845703,
-0.5896522402763367,
0.5198013186454773,
-0.2103467434644699,
0.17877882719039917,
0.21164512634277344,
0.13840720057487488,
0.09088917076587677,
0.208923801779747,
-0.9251216053962708,
-0.1935960203409195,
-0.4094817638397217,
-0.20831668376922607,
-0.22387368977069855,
-0.09564027190208435,
-0.23223116993904114,
-0.10469700396060944,
0.376988023519516,
-0.29365038871765137,
0.027881821617484093,
-0.21128614246845245,
-0.5098319053649902,
-0.09807372093200684,
0.5597023367881775,
0.9382862448692322,
0.849622905254364,
-0.09872604161500931,
0.4116744101047516,
0.40359121561050415,
-0.1806151121854782,
0.7750535011291504,
-0.1558280885219574,
0.33994999527931213,
-0.2510073781013489,
0.35189759731292725,
0.7397571206092834,
0.14817525446414948,
-0.5698626637458801,
0.42707037925720215,
0.25029051303863525,
-0.02619076706469059,
-0.22747595608234406,
-0.4549417495727539,
0.4339081645011902,
0.07724503427743912,
0.16925184428691864,
-0.06423919647932053,
-0.2533729076385498,
-0.5650017261505127,
-0.06097585707902908,
0.3943027853965759,
-0.36850810050964355,
-0.6079022288322449,
0.5872089266777039,
0.32807108759880066,
-0.08243174105882645,
0.6107030510902405,
-0.2776825726032257,
-0.5311510562896729,
0.3977952301502228,
0.2794022560119629,
0.7309621572494507,
-0.2194080501794815,
-0.05237790569663048,
0.06685586273670197,
0.518938422203064,
0.02438121661543846,
0.3279644250869751,
0.36576154828071594,
-1.2404829263687134,
-0.6261202692985535,
-0.5157063007354736,
-0.4856151044368744,
-0.1983436942100525,
-0.5682703852653503,
0.30859053134918213,
-0.0033076966647058725,
0.03078388422727585,
-0.11823912709951401,
-0.2848431468009949,
-0.5865553617477417,
-0.07881487160921097,
0.4196152091026306,
0.6703784465789795,
-0.930773138999939,
1.005468726158142,
0.9482492804527283,
-0.5676631331443787,
-0.8522452712059021,
-0.3804839849472046,
0.17436420917510986,
-1.0704838037490845,
1.2415094375610352,
-0.06539786607027054,
-0.4037555456161499,
-0.22608131170272827,
-0.027124997228384018,
-0.8414474725723267,
1.2093182802200317,
0.7518909573554993,
-0.2722538411617279,
-0.2689345180988312,
0.6855047345161438,
0.4315319359302521,
-0.31207460165023804,
0.1892382651567459,
0.5017184615135193,
0.6312236785888672,
0.019117578864097595,
-1.2869952917099,
-0.22297599911689758,
-0.25216013193130493,
0.174801766872406,
0.31497251987457275,
-0.6937101483345032,
0.737308144569397,
-0.1588016152381897,
-0.17511340975761414,
-0.3785480558872223,
0.3819757103919983,
0.346599280834198,
0.044520147144794464,
0.1667027622461319,
0.5093965530395508,
0.8399124145507812,
0.18220317363739014,
0.8907673358917236,
-0.5992085933685303,
0.23083113133907318,
0.6370959281921387,
-0.5872367024421692,
0.47906818985939026,
0.7238889336585999,
-0.43206101655960083,
0.21224725246429443,
0.7461637854576111,
0.4612167179584503,
0.2535777688026428,
0.20381152629852295,
-0.12436328828334808,
-0.2673007845878601,
-0.31290403008461,
-0.5010106563568115,
0.44867557287216187,
0.2750251889228821,
-0.08895421773195267,
0.014187169261276722,
0.07366379350423813,
0.12267417460680008,
0.10634645074605942,
-0.11910801380872726,
0.6756194233894348,
0.20655901730060577,
-0.4398556351661682,
0.8959594964981079,
-0.11780992895364761,
0.8175073266029358,
-0.6228697896003723,
-0.029670963063836098,
-0.13304369151592255,
0.13091793656349182,
-0.12962359189987183,
-1.0438073873519897,
0.4559098482131958,
-0.349234014749527,
-0.2970716655254364,
-1.025225043296814,
0.40620240569114685,
-0.6041382551193237,
-0.3816293478012085,
0.4412616193294525,
0.7285398840904236,
0.14598213136196136,
0.04193156957626343,
-0.5327368378639221,
-0.06803727895021439,
-0.07068321108818054,
0.10108524560928345,
0.6698628067970276,
0.519624650478363,
-0.3901311755180359,
0.6613361835479736,
0.3107717037200928,
0.47281724214553833,
0.06597490608692169,
0.13689438998699188,
0.6217734217643738,
-0.7870872616767883,
-0.3980149030685425,
-0.8445223569869995,
0.5748387575149536,
0.08616161346435547,
-0.3863587975502014,
0.4977891445159912,
0.5097113847732544,
1.2101351022720337,
0.06591768562793732,
0.9777904748916626,
0.1882903277873993,
0.24091747403144836,
-0.6543444991111755,
0.7955729365348816,
-0.531482994556427,
0.13148640096187592,
-0.30609503388404846,
-0.7456242442131042,
-0.24795952439308167,
0.7311742901802063,
-0.0006546324584633112,
-0.09427259862422943,
0.6070292592048645,
0.5039690136909485,
0.09135058522224426,
-0.32424190640449524,
0.5081301331520081,
-0.38412657380104065,
0.5414196252822876,
0.49904710054397583,
1.1753066778182983,
-0.12454525381326675,
0.26985397934913635,
-0.010427520610392094,
-0.20482710003852844,
-0.245321586728096,
-0.9733093976974487,
-0.46649062633514404,
-0.5290700793266296,
-0.11894920468330383,
-0.18533720076084137,
-0.3320748805999756,
1.1383918523788452,
0.7490171194076538,
-0.7959194779396057,
-0.8672985434532166,
0.3797503113746643,
0.2422250360250473,
-0.09159260243177414,
-0.16379623115062714,
0.1671842485666275,
-0.3851757347583771,
-0.6892029643058777,
0.21398915350437164,
0.48828116059303284,
0.4334873557090759,
-0.5875069499015808,
-0.597538411617279,
-0.27305734157562256,
-0.22075490653514862,
0.7214263677597046,
0.384263813495636,
-0.7279576063156128,
-0.5416519045829773,
0.3726867735385895,
-0.5330279469490051,
0.2894430160522461,
0.9673562049865723,
-0.22973212599754333,
0.3662773072719574,
0.4574822187423706,
1.067887306213379,
0.21573808789253235,
-0.22624723613262177,
0.5941256880760193,
-0.7762354016304016,
0.42976677417755127,
0.39514896273612976,
0.6943920850753784,
0.4042201638221741,
-0.4401738941669464,
0.38436833024024963,
0.43588200211524963,
-0.43674522638320923,
-0.5980871915817261,
0.5384251475334167,
-0.8046945333480835,
-0.1587369292974472,
1.024193286895752,
-0.08529456704854965,
0.34570375084877014,
0.0021852480713278055,
-0.18633344769477844,
0.2581283152103424,
-0.10135753452777863,
0.6178404688835144,
0.9609922766685486,
-0.34195175766944885,
-0.34185105562210083,
-0.525138795375824,
0.31604352593421936,
0.43443357944488525,
-1.0629674196243286,
0.03213471174240112,
0.5090006589889526,
0.14225472509860992,
0.3757801055908203,
0.5332905650138855,
-0.3089277446269989,
0.038644202053546906,
-0.3333323299884796,
0.6998902559280396,
0.08515923470258713,
-0.18481341004371643,
-0.313351035118103,
-0.11656854301691055,
0.5586435198783875,
-0.21761755645275116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18115v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18115v2
|
UniVS: Unified and Universal Video Segmentation with Prompts as Queries
| 2024-02-28T07:05:27 | 2024-06-10T10:52:54 |
Minghan Li, Shuai Li, Xindong Zhang, Lei Zhang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Despite the recent advances in unified image segmentation (IS), developing a
unified video segmentation (VS) model remains a challenge. This is mainly
because generic category-specified VS tasks need to detect all objects and
track them across consecutive frames, while prompt-guided VS tasks require
re-identifying the target with visual/text prompts throughout the entire video,
making it hard to handle the different tasks with the same architecture. We
make an attempt to address these issues and present a novel unified VS
architecture, namely UniVS, by using prompts as queries. UniVS averages the
prompt features of the target from previous frames as its initial query to
explicitly decode masks, and introduces a target-wise prompt cross-attention
layer in the mask decoder to integrate prompt features in the memory pool. By
taking the predicted masks of entities from previous frames as their visual
prompts, UniVS converts different VS tasks into prompt-guided target
segmentation, eliminating the heuristic inter-frame matching process. Our
framework not only unifies the different VS tasks but also naturally achieves
universal training and testing, ensuring robust performance across different
scenarios. UniVS shows a commendable balance between performance and
universality on 10 challenging VS benchmarks, covering video instance,
semantic, panoptic, object, and referring segmentation tasks. Code can be found
at \url{https://github.com/MinghanLi/UniVS}.
|
[
-0.2938176691532135,
-0.41041821241378784,
0.4375641644001007,
0.26365840435028076,
-0.630255401134491,
0.13948509097099304,
0.08928846567869186,
-0.08978379517793655,
-0.05397665500640869,
0.5786668062210083,
-0.8286871910095215,
-0.5200850367546082,
-0.1150476261973381,
0.08898746222257614,
-0.248043030500412,
0.5784077644348145,
0.16048769652843475,
0.3001246154308319,
-0.4444212317466736,
-0.4647696316242218,
-0.7698931694030762,
-0.4437248706817627,
-0.39877617359161377,
-0.043764401227235794,
0.06892799586057663,
0.5018854737281799,
0.11058513820171356,
0.5372973084449768,
0.15809275209903717,
0.3636278808116913,
-0.0031065759249031544,
0.31480756402015686,
0.02724446915090084,
0.44528651237487793,
-0.07917337119579315,
-0.0716276690363884,
0.5710546374320984,
-0.3297497630119324,
0.7680104970932007,
0.6443139314651489,
0.12501049041748047,
0.2518673837184906,
0.16944319009780884,
0.6320644617080688,
-0.780400812625885,
-0.31085535883903503,
-0.452462375164032,
0.25613346695899963,
-0.09808216989040375,
-0.2225642204284668,
-0.2975248098373413,
0.3358210623264313,
0.09375721961259842,
-0.6629239320755005,
0.42841875553131104,
-0.05853898450732231,
0.6505629420280457,
0.4732076823711395,
-0.39402520656585693,
0.4744406044483185,
-0.6048370003700256,
0.5195033550262451,
0.25130006670951843,
0.6345281004905701,
-0.4433756470680237,
0.47017523646354675,
-0.17768125236034393,
-0.8605223298072815,
-0.021743785589933395,
-0.18606871366500854,
0.21175743639469147,
-0.11417287588119507,
-0.6220100522041321,
0.21493510901927948,
0.16988719999790192,
0.1495164930820465,
-0.7589965462684631,
0.21596917510032654,
-0.2512592673301697,
-0.35066109895706177,
0.3568028211593628,
0.378518670797348,
0.455748975276947,
-0.3374160826206207,
-0.9707347750663757,
-0.04082305356860161,
-0.3694055378437042,
0.7722004055976868,
0.023364368826150894,
-0.0002887918381020427,
0.3123752176761627,
0.35665974020957947,
-0.6550889015197754,
0.5843117237091064,
0.04677475988864899,
0.21961790323257446,
-0.10778295993804932,
-0.03653186559677124,
-0.45494863390922546,
-0.12608972191810608,
0.9391838312149048,
0.5782260298728943,
0.29668954014778137,
-0.2115386575460434,
-0.05109062418341637,
0.3046872317790985,
0.31160789728164673,
-0.8127720355987549,
-0.3097133934497833,
-0.038328319787979126,
-0.14158235490322113,
0.04706871882081032,
0.3026190400123596,
-0.8118735551834106,
-0.24142687022686005,
-0.3594275116920471,
0.23819759488105774,
-0.23906147480010986,
0.17385928332805634,
0.044759299606084824,
-0.263274610042572,
0.26711368560791016,
0.4976840317249298,
-0.6640251278877258,
0.2842349410057068,
0.2849423289299011,
0.44266921281814575,
-0.46404922008514404,
-0.09261926263570786,
-0.9566382765769958,
-0.09540567547082901,
-0.046537596732378006,
1.2724305391311646,
-0.6977177858352661,
-0.46576109528541565,
0.04770245403051376,
0.20508520305156708,
-0.18137307465076447,
-0.3260587155818939,
0.45215776562690735,
-0.33336547017097473,
0.16256755590438843,
-0.48629963397979736,
-0.3107609748840332,
-0.18740244209766388,
0.24430106580257416,
-0.33471348881721497,
1.1514897346496582,
-0.03834687918424606,
-0.4318425953388214,
0.19920583069324493,
-0.8064227104187012,
-0.04900587722659111,
0.4275590181350708,
-0.5466130375862122,
-0.058211781084537506,
0.17707549035549164,
0.6192413568496704,
0.3761415481567383,
-0.45374444127082825,
0.35685980319976807,
-0.08882822841405869,
-0.39322394132614136,
0.1769971400499344,
-0.7135098576545715,
0.7637287974357605,
0.2937542200088501,
-0.31488028168678284,
0.6969640254974365,
-0.8401926159858704,
0.1351531744003296,
-0.04000840336084366,
0.14939145743846893,
-0.17886047065258026,
-0.36131176352500916,
0.14227356016635895,
-0.20173385739326477,
-0.12061796337366104,
-0.72783362865448,
0.36369991302490234,
0.4977554678916931,
0.17788958549499512,
0.6956383585929871,
0.16650491952896118,
0.5639744997024536,
0.5191436409950256,
0.6500595808029175,
-0.06239396333694458,
0.4937608540058136,
-0.4673125445842743,
-0.6446062326431274,
-0.2578088641166687,
-0.390333890914917,
0.11510258167982101,
0.4890906512737274,
-0.5373131036758423,
0.15769943594932556,
0.15504485368728638,
-0.05322062224149704,
-0.14151819050312042,
0.11131462454795837,
0.47583696246147156,
0.6893934607505798,
0.27028074860572815,
-0.44548317790031433,
-0.8301764130592346,
-0.5922436714172363,
0.05496252700686455,
-0.11030862480401993,
-0.5184528827667236,
0.07927680015563965,
0.18049903213977814,
-0.23326580226421356,
0.9573870897293091,
-0.7229239344596863,
-0.36985984444618225,
-0.1814037561416626,
0.0273604579269886,
-0.30086711049079895,
0.41025376319885254,
0.33583366870880127,
-0.9353485703468323,
-0.3408345580101013,
-0.2530595064163208,
-1.0018901824951172,
-0.038113273680210114,
-0.16248071193695068,
-0.04209913685917854,
-0.18100222945213318,
0.8131763935089111,
-0.6063693165779114,
0.5608947277069092,
-0.18616725504398346,
-0.6375554203987122,
0.5475747585296631,
-0.3594384789466858,
0.36997443437576294,
-0.9145348072052002,
0.02273024059832096,
0.27292826771736145,
-0.056752730160951614,
-0.3823847472667694,
0.18318893015384674,
-0.11962616443634033,
-0.2903463542461395,
-0.5830307006835938,
0.3961779773235321,
-0.6802888512611389,
-0.3884011507034302,
0.07446737587451935,
-0.12204932421445847,
0.2964416444301605,
0.5400505661964417,
-0.16975970566272736,
0.675393283367157,
0.9739896655082703,
-0.699717104434967,
0.7250106930732727,
0.22539688646793365,
-0.24506355822086334,
1.0595654249191284,
-0.7363101243972778,
-0.049087319523096085,
-0.18624582886695862,
0.1447727084159851,
-1.283765435218811,
-0.38388481736183167,
0.258591890335083,
-0.5015069246292114,
0.11576087772846222,
-0.23320724070072174,
-0.16226254403591156,
-0.5244143605232239,
-0.32970160245895386,
0.43110397458076477,
0.5518019199371338,
-0.8689796328544617,
0.48424822092056274,
0.2841602861881256,
0.47138020396232605,
-0.5932589173316956,
-0.18770958483219147,
0.11971015483140945,
-0.3103232979774475,
-0.6939191222190857,
0.28205251693725586,
-0.30293142795562744,
-0.06574208289384842,
0.16834977269172668,
-0.36618274450302124,
-0.32591044902801514,
0.13412928581237793,
0.5841678977012634,
0.35835281014442444,
-0.30069220066070557,
-0.1975506693124771,
-0.029793117195367813,
-0.2275495082139969,
-0.0013090571155771613,
-0.522322416305542,
0.21745815873146057,
-0.08307969570159912,
-0.27863773703575134,
-0.6334832310676575,
0.7059013247489929,
0.602813184261322,
-0.5616341233253479,
-0.12826965749263763,
0.8166619539260864,
-0.3144104480743408,
-0.07747155427932739,
-0.5883861780166626,
0.049881141632795334,
-0.47826454043388367,
0.31755176186561584,
-0.3855307996273041,
-0.9600130915641785,
0.5589655637741089,
-0.1447346806526184,
-0.12886638939380646,
0.32246267795562744,
-0.006496885325759649,
-0.2614131271839142,
1.1884582042694092,
0.6380966305732727,
0.050877947360277176,
0.5617475509643555,
-0.3295242190361023,
-0.4297613799571991,
-1.067217469215393,
-0.7517906427383423,
-0.43520501255989075,
-0.17116214334964752,
-0.08259010314941406,
-0.41492152214050293,
0.4659782946109772,
0.29540860652923584,
-0.20255181193351746,
0.1810937523841858,
-0.9775218367576599,
0.9619513154029846,
0.5797745585441589,
-0.17967110872268677,
0.1399010270833969,
0.28294116258621216,
-0.25377357006073,
-0.052305739372968674,
-0.38295140862464905,
-0.2328287810087204,
0.809503972530365,
-0.12735886871814728,
0.7718947529792786,
-0.3633987307548523,
0.3955899178981781,
0.6065062284469604,
-0.14266903698444366,
-0.4067019820213318,
0.9088536500930786,
-0.13415496051311493,
-0.2915043830871582,
-0.4346781373023987,
-0.14642904698848724,
-1.3029489517211914,
0.46484678983688354,
0.024821287021040916,
-1.3673094511032104,
0.18058064579963684,
-0.008094476535916328,
-0.7635003924369812,
0.6067368388175964,
-0.46014222502708435,
1.2143338918685913,
-0.16741982102394104,
-0.13290096819400787,
0.3516528010368347,
-0.9553812742233276,
0.1357148289680481,
0.6007634401321411,
-0.3651087284088135,
-0.08648630231618881,
0.10578369349241257,
0.7660088539123535,
-0.14855585992336273,
0.6945430636405945,
-0.2248275876045227,
0.4318898320198059,
0.7403535842895508,
-0.1348421722650528,
0.006838830187916756,
0.335553914308548,
0.5582992434501648,
-0.03488802909851074,
0.001694828155450523,
-0.22861821949481964,
-0.5722910165786743,
0.42549076676368713,
-0.4880278706550598,
-0.582251787185669,
-0.37872636318206787,
-0.33534500002861023,
-0.03529275953769684,
0.163582906126976,
0.5321148633956909,
0.8117954134941101,
-0.6336272358894348,
0.14284704625606537,
1.033210039138794,
0.13091103732585907,
0.7673922181129456,
0.4293791949748993,
-0.054765913635492325,
-0.4703856408596039,
0.7218396067619324,
-0.3955606520175934,
-0.23620952665805817,
0.5414795279502869,
-0.09455816447734833,
-0.6837226152420044,
-0.4158708453178406,
-1.0366638898849487,
-0.3563738465309143,
-0.5833219289779663,
-0.4897882640361786,
-0.5915929675102234,
0.14711523056030273,
-0.5134862065315247,
-0.05992334708571434,
-0.3576648533344269,
0.046799901872873306,
-0.6640633940696716,
-0.13285711407661438,
0.26341480016708374,
0.6762286424636841,
-0.21369381248950958,
0.3228869140148163,
-0.8753671646118164,
0.6150826811790466,
0.7617326378822327,
0.20452019572257996,
-0.6260823011398315,
-0.5847998857498169,
0.2952626645565033,
-0.31264737248420715,
-0.4264242947101593,
-0.8675505518913269,
0.1171492412686348,
-0.09521114081144333,
0.6922022700309753,
0.6648942232131958,
0.1013665646314621,
0.7164462804794312,
-0.45520126819610596,
0.844047486782074,
0.5068783760070801,
-0.640653133392334,
0.3338938355445862,
-0.14420181512832642,
0.3524538278579712,
0.81704181432724,
0.29679590463638306,
-0.5388689637184143,
0.24437478184700012,
-0.42408329248428345,
-0.6494815349578857,
0.6790465116500854,
-0.07940446585416794,
0.07609080523252487,
0.18667711317539215,
0.09713481366634369,
-0.11019163578748703,
-0.12221980839967728,
-0.30421584844589233,
-0.44355013966560364,
-0.1015213206410408,
0.03843139111995697,
0.17394991219043732,
-0.3190195560455322,
-0.01600722409784794,
-0.3375721573829651,
0.10386843979358673,
-0.18933618068695068,
0.13914163410663605,
0.38556525111198425,
-0.2445295751094818,
-0.2954561710357666,
0.4228188395500183,
0.2366132289171219,
0.1607723832130432,
-0.2824627757072449,
0.02534247189760208,
-0.09688828885555267,
-0.3323339521884918,
0.5534436702728271,
0.31649336218833923,
-0.4323081076145172,
0.22899651527404785,
-0.1351480633020401,
0.895767092704773,
0.45766180753707886,
-0.6586125493049622,
0.5125734210014343,
-0.30374452471733093,
-0.16031108796596527,
-0.1168302670121193,
0.05819598212838173,
-0.40293195843696594,
0.49358561635017395,
0.6828369498252869,
0.3274039924144745,
0.40788909792900085,
-0.48065152764320374,
0.5438910126686096,
0.5379666686058044,
-0.5894321203231812,
-0.4072401225566864,
0.9175989031791687,
0.4668431878089905,
-0.44379672408103943,
0.6722703576087952,
-0.5193527936935425,
-0.6521028876304626,
0.5331627130508423,
0.30231884121894836,
1.1282317638397217,
-0.5128791332244873,
0.8134928345680237,
0.29142752289772034,
0.09138430655002594,
-0.09504248201847076,
0.30469581484794617,
-0.4509781301021576,
-0.32405441999435425,
-0.21356309950351715,
-0.4616451859474182,
-0.39513516426086426,
0.08887902647256851,
-0.8889765739440918,
-0.05071490630507469,
-0.20491856336593628,
0.22442317008972168,
-0.13391780853271484,
-0.31932732462882996,
-0.7506272196769714,
0.46185413002967834,
0.28939390182495117,
0.6432371139526367,
-0.699268639087677,
0.4456250071525574,
0.9612345099449158,
-0.415021151304245,
-0.6653937101364136,
-0.39420774579048157,
0.04025530815124512,
-0.6627075672149658,
0.35609129071235657,
0.640731692314148,
0.19440540671348572,
-0.12046633660793304,
-0.49948549270629883,
-0.7200257182121277,
0.8990692496299744,
0.423295795917511,
-0.24865636229515076,
-0.21376550197601318,
0.18128277361392975,
0.15713857114315033,
-0.5325283408164978,
0.19042785465717316,
0.5460371375083923,
0.15588903427124023,
0.4673517346382141,
-0.2844795286655426,
-0.029318878427147865,
-0.2587893605232239,
-0.11481405049562454,
0.21561646461486816,
-0.37002673745155334,
0.7888925075531006,
-0.5483587384223938,
-0.31299594044685364,
0.27397769689559937,
0.8876147270202637,
0.054905835539102554,
0.6780386567115784,
0.6936156153678894,
0.6491453647613525,
0.6754047870635986,
-0.061864424496889114,
0.7314826250076294,
0.15817469358444214,
-0.13674169778823853,
0.7907598614692688,
0.006927035748958588,
0.2396060675382614,
0.3394307494163513,
-0.1442735344171524,
0.525144636631012,
0.6728662252426147,
-0.22324781119823456,
0.5513959527015686,
0.13773228228092194,
-0.33558231592178345,
-0.6998817324638367,
-0.530789315700531,
-0.29998472332954407,
0.6383480429649353,
-0.05210484191775322,
0.19117407500743866,
-0.44538095593452454,
0.36147579550743103,
-0.40478211641311646,
0.0432644784450531,
-0.5369082689285278,
0.6622805595397949,
-0.1931895762681961,
-0.8344666957855225,
0.332175076007843,
-0.3064894676208496,
0.5192423462867737,
-0.6918173432350159,
-0.12972937524318695,
-0.4023692011833191,
-0.08622428774833679,
0.03814607113599777,
-0.7413632273674011,
-0.17280754446983337,
0.38774392008781433,
0.057177480310201645,
-0.014224915765225887,
0.5709877014160156,
-0.23834384977817535,
-0.33179691433906555,
0.0927031934261322,
0.24291472136974335,
0.2679479122161865,
-0.6593849062919617,
-0.6751894950866699,
0.16684645414352417,
0.44243499636650085,
-0.19783900678157806,
0.4430101215839386,
0.71446692943573,
-0.2889315187931061,
0.49374350905418396,
0.6161147356033325,
-0.5883031487464905,
-0.031046509742736816,
0.2027406245470047,
0.9324137568473816,
-0.713447630405426,
-0.4813805818557739,
-0.6276931166648865,
0.9092385768890381,
-0.1615971028804779,
-0.5685179233551025,
0.7015786170959473,
0.45423319935798645,
0.7454978227615356,
-0.060658667236566544,
0.2903681695461273,
0.26040416955947876,
-0.25028398633003235,
-0.3399078845977783,
0.021106751635670662,
-0.6060272455215454,
0.10385063290596008,
-0.37303534150123596,
-0.8913732171058655,
-0.3860029876232147,
0.18626810610294342,
0.35256484150886536,
-0.3776171803474426,
0.5523885488510132,
0.44355788826942444,
-0.039178621023893356,
-0.08790148049592972,
0.5721040964126587,
-0.48441082239151,
0.2558746933937073,
0.34922102093696594,
0.9342659115791321,
-0.21552442014217377,
0.8984976410865784,
-0.2538861334323883,
-0.16658399999141693,
-0.12130275368690491,
-0.5651928782463074,
-0.8433042764663696,
-0.5484361052513123,
-0.4172925353050232,
0.03883930295705795,
0.0758591741323471,
0.7853788137435913,
0.7009645104408264,
-0.6725716590881348,
-0.12022095173597336,
-0.12610429525375366,
0.19373688101768494,
-0.03266888111829758,
-0.16216568648815155,
0.316763699054718,
-0.2368466854095459,
-0.599650502204895,
0.7744065523147583,
0.630982518196106,
0.009745510295033455,
-0.22697003185749054,
0.06316221505403519,
0.14349478483200073,
-0.08873748779296875,
0.41573596000671387,
0.9211509823799133,
-0.5883532762527466,
-0.2072969377040863,
0.2642839550971985,
0.15813010931015015,
0.20247982442378998,
1.0967382192611694,
-1.0131113529205322,
0.5948648452758789,
0.29207679629325867,
0.7040800452232361,
0.30022236704826355,
0.23360122740268707,
0.1716899573802948,
-0.8737306594848633,
0.18321090936660767,
0.009671362116932869,
0.7264206409454346,
0.5745022892951965,
-0.334735244512558,
0.5675075054168701,
0.5219576358795166,
-0.41231217980384827,
-0.9831259846687317,
0.2949688136577606,
-1.2920973300933838,
-0.37107905745506287,
0.9241830706596375,
-0.022351641207933426,
-0.4131264090538025,
-0.10111932456493378,
-0.5272120237350464,
0.2044638693332672,
-0.5523219108581543,
0.32238122820854187,
-0.19418229162693024,
-0.3221328854560852,
-0.041362982243299484,
0.034924186766147614,
0.35331258177757263,
0.45534753799438477,
-0.6081596612930298,
-0.028672903776168823,
0.6394064426422119,
0.3677659332752228,
-0.03826284408569336,
0.7276202440261841,
0.1487729400396347,
0.5635167956352234,
-0.06971041113138199,
0.1364954262971878,
-0.31752869486808777,
-0.8076193332672119,
-0.4281821846961975,
0.3903532028198242,
-0.5071790218353271,
-1.07839035987854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18113v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18113v1
|
Small But Funny: A Feedback-Driven Approach to Humor Distillation
| 2024-02-28T07:02:38 | 2024-02-28T07:02:38 |
Sahithya Ravi, Patrick Huber, Akshat Shrivastava, Aditya Sagar, Ahmed Aly, Vered Shwartz, Arash Einolghozati
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) has brought to light promising
language generation capabilities, particularly in performing tasks like complex
reasoning and creative writing. Consequently, distillation through imitation of
teacher responses has emerged as a popular technique to transfer knowledge from
LLMs to more accessible, Small Language Models (SLMs). While this works well
for simpler tasks, there is a substantial performance gap on tasks requiring
intricate language comprehension and creativity, such as humor generation. We
hypothesize that this gap may stem from the fact that creative tasks might be
hard to learn by imitation alone and explore whether an approach, involving
supplementary guidance from the teacher, could yield higher performance. To
address this, we study the effect of assigning a dual role to the LLM - as a
"teacher" generating data, as well as a "critic" evaluating the student's
performance. Our experiments on humor generation reveal that the incorporation
of feedback significantly narrows the performance gap between SLMs and their
larger counterparts compared to merely relying on imitation. As a result, our
research highlights the potential of using feedback as an additional dimension
to data when transferring complex language abilities via distillation.
|
[
-0.19944332540035248,
-0.8516277074813843,
0.713866651058197,
0.3815593719482422,
-0.30284732580184937,
0.15323734283447266,
-0.43942952156066895,
-0.048575662076473236,
0.34100648760795593,
0.2774569094181061,
-0.3884657621383667,
0.08122707903385162,
-0.6029775142669678,
0.1647402048110962,
-0.3215760588645935,
1.3714543581008911,
0.4752877950668335,
0.3068850040435791,
-0.22700147330760956,
0.26287055015563965,
-0.5156773328781128,
-0.3142392039299011,
-0.8344827890396118,
-0.5836280584335327,
1.028238296508789,
0.7849862575531006,
0.44373518228530884,
0.34900760650634766,
0.21893192827701569,
0.35657960176467896,
-0.12341969460248947,
0.05522967875003815,
-0.5715574622154236,
0.07933706790208817,
-0.485533207654953,
-0.9445860981941223,
-0.0998038798570633,
0.08011488616466522,
0.6184042096138,
0.884011447429657,
-0.44023969769477844,
0.11212226748466492,
0.29909569025039673,
0.8308349847793579,
-0.2412882149219513,
0.044226016849279404,
-0.46604257822036743,
0.17190517485141754,
-0.2026987224817276,
-0.15712782740592957,
-0.5581334829330444,
-0.7057908177375793,
0.15386667847633362,
-0.13287091255187988,
0.04494421184062958,
-0.0926385372877121,
0.09521038830280304,
0.3088625371456146,
-0.2159889191389084,
-0.8390998840332031,
-1.030844807624817,
0.6569144129753113,
-0.8198246359825134,
-0.3895084857940674,
-0.17756474018096924,
0.5056196451187134,
-0.36727750301361084,
-0.8387454748153687,
-1.067969560623169,
-0.26856476068496704,
0.07810822129249573,
0.06840837001800537,
-0.043182771652936935,
-0.33428022265434265,
0.335833877325058,
0.36888688802719116,
0.04483357071876526,
-0.00844630878418684,
-0.5034152865409851,
0.33105751872062683,
0.6609790325164795,
0.19290442764759064,
0.18710820376873016,
-0.2632737159729004,
-0.09377487003803253,
-0.11176589876413345,
-0.5528772473335266,
0.3178086280822754,
0.7208868861198425,
0.36116012930870056,
0.20361356437206268,
0.49174827337265015,
-0.026108043268322945,
0.25725799798965454,
0.07598460465669632,
-0.39747387170791626,
-0.04145986959338188,
-0.06635677814483643,
0.08423098176717758,
0.2741171717643738,
0.7280547022819519,
0.19665852189064026,
0.3660193979740143,
0.051972683519124985,
-0.3020187020301819,
-0.009586482308804989,
0.191752627491951,
-0.7568274140357971,
-0.7228675484657288,
-0.34329932928085327,
-0.13746225833892822,
-0.7486818432807922,
0.2509096562862396,
-1.0745275020599365,
-0.6561087965965271,
-0.34532037377357483,
0.5900533199310303,
-0.11392991244792938,
-0.29521697759628296,
0.0014454302145168185,
-0.4299115240573883,
-0.40635034441947937,
0.3901057243347168,
-0.6557031869888306,
0.3287631571292877,
0.43525955080986023,
0.6918005347251892,
-0.06281442195177078,
-0.378182053565979,
-0.8843715190887451,
0.04308132827281952,
-0.22302626073360443,
0.496131032705307,
-0.549864649772644,
-0.3744645118713379,
-0.35845038294792175,
-0.01679248735308647,
0.17884071171283722,
-0.8139732480049133,
0.2561591863632202,
-0.12786412239074707,
0.2797393798828125,
-0.3520657420158386,
-0.18135876953601837,
-0.10633010417222977,
-0.03713320940732956,
-0.6695722341537476,
1.0129637718200684,
0.07828795164823532,
-0.8325085043907166,
0.16021770238876343,
-0.39325225353240967,
-0.576483964920044,
0.004076818004250526,
-0.31936556100845337,
-0.19336706399917603,
0.5883734822273254,
-0.05381384119391441,
0.17860828340053558,
-0.32735246419906616,
0.22518134117126465,
-0.4408060312271118,
-0.6200432777404785,
0.7008439898490906,
-0.5118464827537537,
0.5464053750038147,
0.21835997700691223,
-0.7416715025901794,
-0.2911123037338257,
-0.8309625387191772,
-0.01361463125795126,
0.34453028440475464,
-0.6180502772331238,
-0.40272822976112366,
0.07602628320455551,
-0.4024314284324646,
0.3465096652507782,
-0.10436972975730896,
-0.46625247597694397,
0.29357632994651794,
-0.4496006369590759,
0.4579622447490692,
0.8077808618545532,
0.025239454582333565,
0.21656478941440582,
-0.4782801866531372,
0.6077935695648193,
0.26996034383773804,
-0.08161840587854385,
-0.06159564480185509,
-0.4365521967411041,
-0.9185491800308228,
-0.06837501376867294,
0.20990103483200073,
0.3493801951408386,
-1.1459599733352661,
-0.16366609930992126,
-0.25168415904045105,
-0.49486494064331055,
-0.6825845241546631,
0.6043713092803955,
0.3473038673400879,
0.4824225902557373,
-0.09224552661180496,
-0.44988110661506653,
-0.5090844631195068,
-0.581190824508667,
-0.31085363030433655,
-0.21503737568855286,
0.04531267285346985,
0.3499690294265747,
0.25238439440727234,
0.18355105817317963,
0.8360243439674377,
-0.6133749485015869,
-0.10956050455570221,
-0.6314844489097595,
0.2771036624908447,
0.46333667635917664,
0.3223586678504944,
0.719125509262085,
-0.3811081647872925,
-0.6188777685165405,
-0.27573269605636597,
-0.3632682263851166,
-0.440713495016098,
0.10773316025733948,
0.09743165969848633,
-0.015094117261469364,
0.2266610711812973,
-0.45825275778770447,
0.34675925970077515,
0.28219494223594666,
-0.0596998892724514,
0.7709201574325562,
-0.18845665454864502,
0.06435719132423401,
-0.8648712038993835,
-0.06425374746322632,
-0.3907995820045471,
-0.1940339356660843,
-0.5117684602737427,
-0.205017551779747,
-0.5547279119491577,
-0.005751436110585928,
-0.5173091292381287,
0.2380954474210739,
-0.35300707817077637,
0.1314278393983841,
-0.5731723308563232,
0.2841174602508545,
0.0018136909930035472,
0.3280506730079651,
-0.3777708113193512,
0.3824325501918793,
0.5250579714775085,
-0.6018476486206055,
0.6473926305770874,
-0.4353002905845642,
-0.28111082315444946,
0.6412428617477417,
-0.6218084096908569,
0.39513564109802246,
-0.13371093571186066,
0.10121467709541321,
-1.2604049444198608,
-0.1905249059200287,
0.013798612169921398,
-0.26696622371673584,
0.37080925703048706,
-0.12585321068763733,
-0.8207288980484009,
-0.726918637752533,
-0.472943514585495,
0.07556665688753128,
0.7810771465301514,
-0.6154599189758301,
0.13692958652973175,
0.0991855189204216,
-0.5548210144042969,
-0.4079052805900574,
-0.9582852125167847,
-0.022333988919854164,
-0.4390762746334076,
-0.471935898065567,
-0.22469687461853027,
-0.18441490828990936,
-0.44554558396339417,
0.032019369304180145,
0.07279256731271744,
0.29734334349632263,
0.047625817358493805,
0.129758819937706,
-0.07278700917959213,
-0.2923162877559662,
0.05559023469686508,
0.08063241094350815,
0.30237385630607605,
0.20699749886989594,
-0.032052356749773026,
0.3720903694629669,
0.013458478264510632,
-0.23594148457050323,
-0.2975243031978607,
0.25091880559921265,
0.47613319754600525,
0.4806686341762543,
0.6724275946617126,
0.36298179626464844,
0.1268482655286789,
-0.7623282074928284,
-0.4854113757610321,
-0.5043914914131165,
-0.5423814654350281,
0.0780739113688469,
-0.25308841466903687,
-0.6908953189849854,
0.29095932841300964,
-0.2154947966337204,
-0.20931385457515717,
0.035734329372644424,
0.5982567667961121,
-0.2855711579322815,
1.0187042951583862,
0.6526924967765808,
0.1519262194633484,
0.4464791417121887,
-0.08490398526191711,
0.44964656233787537,
-0.49511051177978516,
-0.1720893830060959,
-0.4112470746040344,
-0.8008238077163696,
-0.3274379372596741,
-0.4065227210521698,
0.18142803013324738,
0.38673070073127747,
0.2024265080690384,
-0.1197451502084732,
-0.4108912944793701,
0.6389015913009644,
0.5978618264198303,
-0.1546289473772049,
0.44816291332244873,
-0.013734391890466213,
-0.3317767083644867,
-0.21511542797088623,
-0.8820682764053345,
-0.5500639081001282,
0.8382368087768555,
0.3281814754009247,
1.1726571321487427,
0.45568373799324036,
0.9354630708694458,
0.035485293716192245,
0.4949890971183777,
-0.7927060127258301,
0.6354707479476929,
-0.4531003534793854,
-0.08436167240142822,
-0.10632134228944778,
-0.5925766825675964,
-0.5582934617996216,
0.12525106966495514,
0.21963755786418915,
-0.5965142250061035,
-0.16628527641296387,
0.371791273355484,
-0.3606283962726593,
0.2623335123062134,
-1.1389062404632568,
0.4191495478153229,
-0.07234641909599304,
-0.5614579916000366,
-0.12942522764205933,
-0.5190504193305969,
0.4977351427078247,
0.027430595830082893,
0.4899420738220215,
0.19633853435516357,
0.37945452332496643,
0.5825091004371643,
-0.5623464584350586,
1.0963345766067505,
-0.5448347926139832,
-0.11745714396238327,
0.5629184246063232,
0.4717862010002136,
0.4717727601528168,
0.4114777147769928,
0.03308719024062157,
-0.5341848731040955,
0.014660024084150791,
-0.05458390340209007,
-1.013808012008667,
1.0143142938613892,
-0.5070968270301819,
-1.1318228244781494,
-0.2670980989933014,
-0.47098320722579956,
-0.07348420470952988,
0.008319028653204441,
0.06900855153799057,
-0.029608653858304024,
0.2634011507034302,
0.3488416075706482,
0.386660635471344,
-0.037098899483680725,
0.6958569288253784,
0.5440298318862915,
-0.32516559958457947,
-0.17015212774276733,
0.9459332823753357,
0.1298016458749771,
0.3971296548843384,
-0.08316908031702042,
0.6219054460525513,
-0.2328873723745346,
-0.16952964663505554,
-0.46333184838294983,
0.28983551263809204,
-0.7102126479148865,
-0.023599088191986084,
-0.5285674333572388,
-0.047665033489465714,
-0.41571733355522156,
0.07390905171632767,
-0.5089836120605469,
-0.636701226234436,
-0.4343491792678833,
0.004414324648678303,
0.1654851883649826,
1.2580562829971313,
-0.1971193104982376,
0.2560860216617584,
-0.5044460892677307,
-0.2509561777114868,
0.693189263343811,
0.21091973781585693,
0.5789262652397156,
-0.6017661094665527,
-0.15489564836025238,
0.04394763708114624,
-0.6645793318748474,
-0.9589627981185913,
0.1745956540107727,
0.3921726942062378,
0.38545024394989014,
0.3075028955936432,
0.0058453502133488655,
0.6622737646102905,
-0.6731188893318176,
1.0651389360427856,
0.32391470670700073,
-0.8011921048164368,
0.7186781764030457,
0.17304369807243347,
0.34221312403678894,
0.30804991722106934,
0.016353143379092216,
-0.37682798504829407,
-0.85847407579422,
-0.565449595451355,
-0.5755792856216431,
0.945580005645752,
0.10170967131853104,
0.5228923559188843,
-0.1566116362810135,
0.35112082958221436,
0.25304746627807617,
0.6552172303199768,
-0.8802661299705505,
-0.0913008600473404,
-0.22144804894924164,
-0.10449019074440002,
0.010793961584568024,
-0.17720535397529602,
-0.32105937600135803,
-0.2608071267604828,
0.4132971465587616,
-0.17381063103675842,
-0.0329422689974308,
0.17810027301311493,
0.10328413546085358,
-0.16636906564235687,
0.4995744824409485,
0.707055926322937,
0.4745337665081024,
0.1690940260887146,
0.8373452425003052,
0.09048143774271011,
-0.5335132479667664,
0.1991012692451477,
-0.40023496747016907,
0.09787546843290329,
0.2183791697025299,
0.2043045312166214,
0.6464024186134338,
0.1653355211019516,
-0.6937185525894165,
0.5225096344947815,
0.05297238752245903,
0.047951117157936096,
-0.03886980563402176,
0.607069730758667,
0.2813659608364105,
0.5909878611564636,
0.3878592848777771,
-0.11707398295402527,
0.10301560163497925,
-1.0596723556518555,
0.36914682388305664,
-0.05330437421798706,
-0.18864841759204865,
-0.7466251850128174,
0.5318366885185242,
0.026125531643629074,
-0.4002448618412018,
0.3892061114311218,
-0.3372112214565277,
-0.5097838640213013,
0.7322996854782104,
0.7873819470405579,
0.6019459366798401,
-0.26469364762306213,
0.3916334807872772,
0.2024402916431427,
0.05760301277041435,
-0.2463543564081192,
0.5170435905456543,
-0.06653273850679398,
-0.17891789972782135,
-0.31320613622665405,
-0.6627140641212463,
-0.11993582546710968,
0.06823396682739258,
-0.7006029486656189,
0.4280398190021515,
-0.5353075861930847,
-0.11145085841417313,
0.13457900285720825,
-0.13992179930210114,
-0.5322592258453369,
0.07011733204126358,
0.005857689771801233,
0.5799030065536499,
-0.6908349990844727,
1.0196751356124878,
0.8384705781936646,
-0.45390525460243225,
-1.08137047290802,
0.15781238675117493,
-0.024801641702651978,
-0.4942563474178314,
0.9242509007453918,
0.054573919624090195,
-0.17850206792354584,
-0.14896808564662933,
-0.389031320810318,
-0.30862781405448914,
0.8653784394264221,
0.533098042011261,
-0.8251566886901855,
-0.11695844680070877,
0.23620162904262543,
0.9695276618003845,
-0.6109232902526855,
0.18749812245368958,
0.5260610580444336,
0.11416444927453995,
0.540709912776947,
-0.8793878555297852,
0.13524816930294037,
-0.1880332976579666,
0.3147578835487366,
-0.11516325175762177,
-0.7980198264122009,
0.9891577363014221,
-0.6601146459579468,
-0.10411574691534042,
-0.07920888066291809,
0.3156234622001648,
0.39545878767967224,
0.5556843876838684,
0.7011528015136719,
0.5533953309059143,
0.5055658221244812,
0.03335516154766083,
0.916339635848999,
0.1374284327030182,
0.3179267644882202,
1.5092929601669312,
-0.29567620158195496,
0.8139618039131165,
1.0368059873580933,
-0.14836977422237396,
0.6768906712532043,
0.10893730074167252,
0.10122846812009811,
0.8493629097938538,
0.6365660429000854,
-0.13720357418060303,
0.23976576328277588,
-0.025148512795567513,
-0.13268278539180756,
0.12149196118116379,
0.14195264875888824,
-0.5064431428909302,
-0.1416274905204773,
0.25456222891807556,
0.05896180495619774,
0.24930031597614288,
-0.18390469253063202,
0.8377708792686462,
0.3671695590019226,
-0.9142789244651794,
0.2799489498138428,
-0.2126108705997467,
0.6383663415908813,
-0.21656787395477295,
-0.22327812016010284,
-0.3691798150539398,
0.23943187296390533,
-0.30965518951416016,
-1.0379602909088135,
0.389546275138855,
0.15187698602676392,
-0.14920379221439362,
0.0039117480628192425,
0.3065667748451233,
-0.6500414609909058,
-0.25486141443252563,
0.1995457261800766,
0.2449369579553604,
0.32157814502716064,
0.3793378174304962,
-0.2682550549507141,
-0.03322942927479744,
0.13506504893302917,
-0.30330145359039307,
0.25433605909347534,
0.957733154296875,
0.2508225739002228,
0.38445645570755005,
0.4567747414112091,
0.4678266942501068,
0.35824117064476013,
0.36360040307044983,
1.0446927547454834,
-0.5929394364356995,
-0.6264498829841614,
-1.0183119773864746,
0.6344552636146545,
-0.1341087967157364,
-0.19732722640037537,
0.7880724668502808,
0.2906658351421356,
0.7953489422798157,
-0.3440156579017639,
0.7044357657432556,
-0.2653580605983734,
0.5825130939483643,
-0.38668280839920044,
0.6454007029533386,
-0.8344506025314331,
0.6613040566444397,
-0.418668657541275,
-0.9746086597442627,
0.2953682243824005,
0.3171764016151428,
-0.1876240074634552,
0.06289591640233994,
0.8484882712364197,
0.7346599698066711,
-0.11283084005117416,
-0.00025795845431275666,
0.3276384770870209,
0.44564715027809143,
0.5318340063095093,
0.6277502179145813,
1.132196068763733,
0.007546474691480398,
0.625221848487854,
-0.5727970600128174,
-0.2687828242778778,
-0.3172178566455841,
-0.8315582275390625,
-0.9917953014373779,
-0.39412227272987366,
-0.301382839679718,
-0.44774773716926575,
-0.32451415061950684,
0.6147468090057373,
0.3602566719055176,
-0.5469036102294922,
-0.18485867977142334,
0.005179315339773893,
0.23426374793052673,
-0.13074305653572083,
-0.3575184941291809,
-0.003373918356373906,
-0.3489796817302704,
-1.0148402452468872,
0.2586044371128082,
0.2826278507709503,
0.04143369197845459,
-0.590793251991272,
0.01495211012661457,
0.1980147659778595,
0.4162134826183319,
0.5431436896324158,
0.04301949962973595,
-0.8008952736854553,
-0.3383679687976837,
-0.17880398035049438,
-0.11110254377126694,
-0.19773252308368683,
1.0177403688430786,
-0.5412431955337524,
0.6511908769607544,
0.5892190933227539,
0.42288899421691895,
0.3698495328426361,
-0.33933162689208984,
0.36493998765945435,
-1.1750754117965698,
0.38792139291763306,
0.3646949529647827,
-0.022794781252741814,
0.4066186845302582,
-0.5238443613052368,
0.2746468782424927,
0.5239824056625366,
-0.3813042640686035,
-1.361433744430542,
0.1417718380689621,
-0.7161076068878174,
-0.18976154923439026,
1.0459487438201904,
-0.324547678232193,
-0.343751460313797,
0.38535046577453613,
-0.40694233775138855,
0.18781043589115143,
-0.333678275346756,
1.1841564178466797,
0.9565470218658447,
-0.2525341510772705,
-0.330437570810318,
-0.5364339351654053,
0.4523542523384094,
0.6233145594596863,
-0.5597172379493713,
-0.14878764748573303,
0.17642658948898315,
0.6454404592514038,
0.33624696731567383,
0.5294830799102783,
-0.11950470507144928,
0.3794519901275635,
0.06050065532326698,
-0.23571999371051788,
0.04824839159846306,
-0.5187533497810364,
-0.2153683751821518,
0.3311436176300049,
0.40210288763046265,
0.07469330728054047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08822v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.08822v1
|
LoRA-SP: Streamlined Partial Parameter Adaptation for Resource-Efficient Fine-Tuning of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T06:50:10 | 2024-02-28T06:50:10 |
Yichao Wu, Yafei Xiang, Shuning Huo, Yulu Gong, Penghao Liang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
In addressing the computational and memory demands of fine-tuning Large
Language Models(LLMs), we propose LoRA-SP(Streamlined Partial Parameter
Adaptation), a novel approach utilizing randomized half-selective parameter
freezing within the Low-Rank Adaptation(LoRA)framework. This method efficiently
balances pre-trained knowledge retention and adaptability for task-specific
optimizations. Through a randomized mechanism, LoRA-SP determines which
parameters to update or freeze, significantly reducing computational and memory
requirements without compromising model performance. We evaluated LoRA-SP
across several benchmark NLP tasks, demonstrating its ability to achieve
competitive performance with substantially lower resource consumption compared
to traditional full-parameter fine-tuning and other parameter-efficient
techniques. LoRA-SP innovative approach not only facilitates the deployment of
advanced NLP models in resource-limited settings but also opens new research
avenues into effective and efficient model adaptation strategies.
|
[
-0.3371460735797882,
-0.9203747510910034,
0.36538732051849365,
0.12560689449310303,
-0.4795117676258087,
-0.07312306016683578,
-0.49632757902145386,
-0.22717496752738953,
0.364322692155838,
0.5765871405601501,
-0.6072106957435608,
-0.25836074352264404,
-0.3748403787612915,
-0.04995718225836754,
-0.37460196018218994,
1.091766595840454,
-0.018838807940483093,
-0.02189277485013008,
-0.02218453958630562,
-0.18327899277210236,
-0.22098955512046814,
-0.3813861608505249,
-1.1597721576690674,
-0.29495301842689514,
0.8956435918807983,
0.5271104574203491,
0.5898069143295288,
0.6555973887443542,
0.5315044522285461,
0.22348730266094208,
-0.09641025960445404,
0.12749303877353668,
-0.7842341065406799,
0.26707547903060913,
-0.32446274161338806,
-0.6340154409408569,
-0.6361240148544312,
-0.2906610369682312,
0.8084527254104614,
0.8250710368156433,
-0.4500768482685089,
0.45727241039276123,
0.11034102737903595,
0.9574936032295227,
-0.8796619772911072,
-0.016947412863373756,
-0.9826031923294067,
0.1659289449453354,
-0.1992366462945938,
-0.5599051713943481,
-0.47419190406799316,
-0.15703360736370087,
0.12975580990314484,
-0.8245499730110168,
0.06893584877252579,
0.18000920116901398,
0.7934609055519104,
0.7655232548713684,
0.1110687330365181,
-0.0399562269449234,
-0.8778324723243713,
0.8424978256225586,
-0.8579334616661072,
0.23571087419986725,
0.3360854983329773,
0.25100889801979065,
-0.23248164355754852,
-0.653759777545929,
-0.20083403587341309,
0.0008034758502617478,
0.47656360268592834,
-0.011479624547064304,
-0.17734549939632416,
0.07266730070114136,
0.3464214503765106,
0.11072439700365067,
-0.26633787155151367,
0.5016670227050781,
-0.45262807607650757,
0.0025779397692531347,
0.517401933670044,
-0.006545164156705141,
0.049741048365831375,
0.2988918721675873,
-0.14537787437438965,
0.15036234259605408,
-0.6900719404220581,
-0.1360320895910263,
0.25160691142082214,
0.8067197203636169,
-0.17729544639587402,
0.5195584297180176,
-0.37764719128608704,
0.8878322243690491,
0.13722777366638184,
-0.32141542434692383,
0.042452044785022736,
-0.006330681964755058,
-0.3985052704811096,
0.0646372064948082,
0.6244611740112305,
0.0341290645301342,
0.23349259793758392,
-0.12021320313215256,
-0.11586503684520721,
-0.2604736387729645,
-0.013711508363485336,
-0.641981303691864,
-0.19370508193969727,
0.005432325880974531,
-0.2725814878940582,
-0.021588237956166267,
-0.6299846172332764,
-0.8353020548820496,
-0.6085816621780396,
-0.23650451004505157,
0.5018677711486816,
-0.21254460513591766,
0.07540394365787506,
0.4911446273326874,
-0.08730537444353104,
0.1253904551267624,
0.5293439626693726,
-0.9139102101325989,
0.5523356199264526,
0.3977038562297821,
0.7809239029884338,
-0.4982280731201172,
-0.44986534118652344,
-0.7804412841796875,
0.3318704664707184,
-0.0845208391547203,
0.8352135419845581,
-0.503627359867096,
0.03277970105409622,
-0.1337032914161682,
-0.26028677821159363,
-0.21079784631729126,
-0.5359638333320618,
0.6162698864936829,
-0.5650213360786438,
0.1492844671010971,
-0.3341616988182068,
-0.24778684973716736,
0.05993949621915817,
-0.025690749287605286,
-0.7573816776275635,
1.261702537536621,
0.009553586132824421,
-0.8372913002967834,
0.27890443801879883,
-0.7658489942550659,
-0.30872997641563416,
-0.10560672730207443,
0.10441992431879044,
-0.34039363265037537,
0.36934277415275574,
0.14555995166301727,
0.3118512034416199,
-0.6957651972770691,
-0.18015819787979126,
-0.42370396852493286,
-0.36407405138015747,
0.07292914390563965,
-0.28358781337738037,
0.5161727070808411,
0.31803521513938904,
0.11372129619121552,
0.22657576203346252,
-0.7387494444847107,
0.02616376243531704,
0.3047357201576233,
-0.5278446078300476,
-0.4381764531135559,
0.31648120284080505,
-0.21397940814495087,
0.05580591410398483,
0.5774410367012024,
-0.1628601998090744,
0.34872809052467346,
-0.48399925231933594,
0.4664290249347687,
0.8056454658508301,
-0.0984601303935051,
0.5921397805213928,
-0.2770398259162903,
0.5356062650680542,
-0.0554642453789711,
0.2394607961177826,
0.11680256575345993,
-0.3704560697078705,
-1.3049659729003906,
-0.506376326084137,
0.5674707889556885,
0.4538158178329468,
-0.6817814707756042,
0.4202590882778168,
-0.19102656841278076,
-0.473245769739151,
-0.4565480351448059,
0.30481675267219543,
0.13705581426620483,
0.35327795147895813,
0.36310461163520813,
-0.2518767714500427,
-0.5644172430038452,
-0.8156004548072815,
-0.41233810782432556,
-0.09516318887472153,
-0.041904348880052567,
0.0778486579656601,
0.42843180894851685,
0.21845127642154694,
0.9385741353034973,
-0.6462710499763489,
-0.29926788806915283,
-0.3735821843147278,
-0.05881505459547043,
0.3902028799057007,
0.3171142637729645,
0.5727617144584656,
-0.4294421076774597,
-0.5726835131645203,
-0.11073323339223862,
-0.3394063115119934,
-0.1217353418469429,
0.03498731926083565,
-0.16682970523834229,
0.2331775575876236,
0.5455225706100464,
-0.5454524755477905,
0.15373878180980682,
0.7370550632476807,
-0.20609672367572784,
0.3693946897983551,
-0.5312886834144592,
-0.2827514111995697,
-1.0076655149459839,
0.17814530432224274,
-0.028757551684975624,
-0.27287665009498596,
-0.6430538892745972,
0.15103688836097717,
-0.23488155007362366,
-0.2101059854030609,
-0.4642873704433441,
0.6915684938430786,
-0.5387410521507263,
-0.1916637271642685,
-0.2594224214553833,
0.26695120334625244,
-0.18946529924869537,
0.5912951827049255,
0.03261156752705574,
0.6347094774246216,
0.6011727452278137,
-0.6778968572616577,
0.13618037104606628,
-0.1752314269542694,
-0.2580340504646301,
0.2805328071117401,
-0.4201772212982178,
0.3474099040031433,
-0.1024559885263443,
0.19526097178459167,
-0.531125009059906,
-0.158302903175354,
0.17321692407131195,
0.050362490117549896,
0.10147655010223389,
-0.42232269048690796,
-0.6081855297088623,
-0.03984230011701584,
-0.24820277094841003,
0.3947397768497467,
0.695664644241333,
-0.21429269015789032,
0.8339914679527283,
0.4361271858215332,
-0.4395222067832947,
-0.4031934142112732,
-0.48452028632164,
-0.13835029304027557,
-0.3604224622249603,
-0.24459892511367798,
0.21233248710632324,
-0.2610284686088562,
-0.05055610090494156,
-0.18067346513271332,
-0.20173801481723785,
-0.20156167447566986,
0.25173887610435486,
-0.1145029366016388,
0.011075888760387897,
-0.3707587718963623,
-0.24580247700214386,
0.27011439204216003,
-0.06979529559612274,
-0.29759538173675537,
-0.17913123965263367,
0.7218453288078308,
0.21195296943187714,
-0.3542906641960144,
-0.4135097861289978,
0.2364099770784378,
0.5338336825370789,
-0.07900792360305786,
0.9567579030990601,
0.3826109766960144,
-0.4216731786727905,
-0.7509424686431885,
-0.5547405481338501,
-0.13917891681194305,
-0.4956077039241791,
0.6240682005882263,
-0.41327258944511414,
-0.8665633201599121,
0.754147469997406,
-0.34970948100090027,
0.03238724172115326,
0.23891329765319824,
0.5982351303100586,
-0.043115537613630295,
0.7505614757537842,
0.978434145450592,
-0.33991512656211853,
0.6463659405708313,
0.0816667303442955,
0.28718090057373047,
-0.5453665256500244,
0.09611674398183823,
-0.8505446314811707,
-0.5615950226783752,
-0.3689526319503784,
-0.700045645236969,
0.29789480566978455,
0.4083833396434784,
-0.44694891571998596,
0.05330837517976761,
-0.4229796528816223,
0.6354999542236328,
0.3926197290420532,
0.057778261601924896,
0.37911757826805115,
0.21524827182292938,
0.09828327596187592,
0.027777429670095444,
-0.9703086018562317,
-0.14433200657367706,
0.8759905695915222,
0.4433681070804596,
0.9013775587081909,
0.008770301938056946,
0.5294473767280579,
0.3017822504043579,
-0.1715589314699173,
-0.9635371565818787,
0.7773289084434509,
-0.47493597865104675,
-0.4350563883781433,
-0.5778284072875977,
-0.3653808534145355,
-0.6787609457969666,
0.20010875165462494,
-0.16986894607543945,
-0.8742475509643555,
0.07357842475175858,
0.2943119406700134,
-0.6184675097465515,
0.42974138259887695,
-0.6979386210441589,
0.4703355133533478,
-0.02216009795665741,
-0.1897694319486618,
-0.3243318200111389,
-0.29572799801826477,
-0.0009062650497071445,
-0.5719073414802551,
0.041020043194293976,
-0.41622480750083923,
-0.4237341284751892,
1.0759437084197998,
-0.1568252146244049,
0.9279785752296448,
-0.5078660249710083,
-0.1644679754972458,
-0.01935170590877533,
0.10219605267047882,
0.8370010256767273,
-0.21981114149093628,
-0.43766212463378906,
0.021556947380304337,
0.04511851817369461,
-0.5542085766792297,
-0.7326372861862183,
0.742331326007843,
-0.8373702764511108,
-0.6013453006744385,
-0.38874003291130066,
-0.6739082932472229,
-0.5704948902130127,
0.3315754532814026,
0.002948748180642724,
-0.0725196897983551,
-0.027592133730649948,
0.14707031846046448,
0.8453344106674194,
-0.35260456800460815,
0.3701002895832062,
0.7809411287307739,
-0.3226504325866699,
-0.18325753509998322,
0.7604932188987732,
0.15474329888820648,
0.3682991564273834,
0.39848950505256653,
0.2839341461658478,
0.1305566430091858,
-0.9996103644371033,
-0.15225112438201904,
0.43477046489715576,
-0.6361876130104065,
-0.193827822804451,
-0.2402741014957428,
-0.430025577545166,
0.10550937801599503,
-0.2560896575450897,
-0.8105666637420654,
-0.5997232794761658,
-0.49902233481407166,
0.27158987522125244,
0.5522186160087585,
0.34588423371315,
0.18181654810905457,
0.4283052384853363,
-0.34823670983314514,
0.4262920022010803,
0.10604503005743027,
0.5035552978515625,
-0.20684020221233368,
-1.0898756980895996,
-0.36659184098243713,
-0.00851172860711813,
0.17100180685520172,
-0.44743111729621887,
0.3123415410518646,
0.5620970726013184,
0.4347798526287079,
0.16232597827911377,
0.26049166917800903,
0.8585600852966309,
-0.673772394657135,
0.6810449361801147,
0.1677069365978241,
-0.8629130125045776,
0.4715779423713684,
-0.47669023275375366,
0.5043578147888184,
0.5999199151992798,
0.16667808592319489,
-0.17899130284786224,
-0.2134142965078354,
-0.042713712900877,
-0.9396412968635559,
0.9320627450942993,
-0.04732527956366539,
0.1246703639626503,
0.6002336740493774,
0.5953731536865234,
0.17148031294345856,
-0.10748817771673203,
-0.5780560970306396,
-0.28716394305229187,
0.15537682175636292,
-0.19101275503635406,
-0.09846989810466766,
-0.47862622141838074,
-0.34528639912605286,
-0.3559117019176483,
0.8211939930915833,
-0.4810032844543457,
0.2703970968723297,
-0.17404744029045105,
0.03535991907119751,
-0.1937316358089447,
0.2845631241798401,
0.7315592169761658,
0.7614442110061646,
-0.33014965057373047,
-0.052232399582862854,
0.6574495434761047,
-0.4427039921283722,
-0.10280618071556091,
0.01934707723557949,
-0.21900413930416107,
-0.15508364140987396,
0.0682607889175415,
1.00631844997406,
0.41838163137435913,
-0.6128531694412231,
0.13229605555534363,
-0.018675168976187706,
-0.1945207417011261,
-0.2531990110874176,
0.21232254803180695,
0.13347424566745758,
0.15275439620018005,
0.5162977576255798,
0.15421730279922485,
-0.1334311068058014,
-0.42997920513153076,
-0.14443744719028473,
0.28058210015296936,
-0.30605629086494446,
-0.42465630173683167,
0.3990447223186493,
0.1424253284931183,
-0.20756053924560547,
0.1811784952878952,
0.1414366215467453,
0.10741861909627914,
0.18815846741199493,
0.6669906377792358,
0.7938768267631531,
-0.20492598414421082,
0.13917647302150726,
0.17323535680770874,
0.1579309105873108,
-0.45357197523117065,
0.5050033330917358,
0.1131095141172409,
-0.6984935998916626,
-0.6365668177604675,
-0.9877212047576904,
-0.42943426966667175,
0.14463646709918976,
-0.8603779077529907,
0.48237958550453186,
-0.8075433969497681,
-0.22859324514865875,
0.004817901644855738,
-0.02081472799181938,
-0.4753759503364563,
0.007223316468298435,
0.10583574324846268,
1.2504860162734985,
-0.7775284647941589,
1.2462260723114014,
0.5986196398735046,
-0.1417495310306549,
-0.5626513361930847,
0.011297451332211494,
-0.09006081521511078,
-0.844468355178833,
0.4301843047142029,
-0.6057864427566528,
-0.4292246997356415,
0.09024780988693237,
-0.5069525837898254,
-1.2779392004013062,
1.0173683166503906,
1.110895037651062,
-0.6347204446792603,
-0.38643118739128113,
0.2033100426197052,
0.6852718591690063,
-0.20392939448356628,
-0.11898981779813766,
0.6235790848731995,
0.28109729290008545,
0.11954984068870544,
-1.3089203834533691,
0.023933103308081627,
-0.019390147179365158,
0.04597150906920433,
0.18135076761245728,
-0.7921136617660522,
0.6320525407791138,
-0.0610850527882576,
-0.06971599161624908,
0.3414306044578552,
0.7451887130737305,
0.490741103887558,
0.045744042843580246,
0.5484014749526978,
0.41964802145957947,
0.7947751879692078,
0.07787667959928513,
0.642626941204071,
-0.41123688220977783,
0.32436832785606384,
1.378509521484375,
-0.5495661497116089,
1.3247681856155396,
0.7978029847145081,
-0.13713447749614716,
0.2969200909137726,
0.39784005284309387,
0.292353093624115,
0.6999886631965637,
0.3143596053123474,
-0.15436960756778717,
-0.1984328329563141,
-0.1918671727180481,
-0.28298282623291016,
0.5220262408256531,
0.28464797139167786,
-0.13538455963134766,
-0.12257352471351624,
-0.05298564210534096,
0.17215438187122345,
-0.16025175154209137,
-0.5120419859886169,
0.7742096185684204,
0.22093889117240906,
-0.5165829658508301,
0.8154954314231873,
0.07351911813020706,
0.6224488615989685,
-0.939389169216156,
0.285817950963974,
-0.21115824580192566,
0.30552059412002563,
-0.1664949506521225,
-0.25138428807258606,
0.016908371821045876,
0.16195295751094818,
-0.4280861020088196,
-0.24138642847537994,
0.6057285666465759,
-0.2682953178882599,
-0.48885467648506165,
0.39339256286621094,
0.4931616485118866,
0.07916591316461563,
0.07409811019897461,
-0.9150418639183044,
0.43516507744789124,
0.037147969007492065,
-0.38168472051620483,
0.7305294275283813,
0.436972975730896,
0.08524440973997116,
0.9897233247756958,
0.5447449684143066,
0.4890354871749878,
0.14722709357738495,
0.31041213870048523,
1.0298467874526978,
-0.6190597414970398,
-0.5152555108070374,
-0.5529764890670776,
0.3057449758052826,
0.07924284785985947,
-0.17405815422534943,
0.7241985201835632,
0.5811808705329895,
0.6228659152984619,
-0.08313833177089691,
0.7834696173667908,
0.023390477523207664,
0.6232916712760925,
-0.9186927676200867,
0.7555667757987976,
-0.6342545747756958,
0.4516632556915283,
-0.2422189712524414,
-1.0112661123275757,
-0.29522672295570374,
0.2820972204208374,
-0.2608174681663513,
0.13001301884651184,
0.8586335182189941,
0.6837775111198425,
-0.249677836894989,
-0.25572022795677185,
0.42912304401397705,
0.3968435227870941,
-0.07532601803541183,
0.4314308762550354,
0.527549147605896,
-0.2958212196826935,
0.387151837348938,
-0.10519999265670776,
-0.20962509512901306,
-0.14632266759872437,
-1.0134724378585815,
-0.8982669711112976,
-0.6646926403045654,
-0.5864196419715881,
-0.09423640370368958,
0.34815534949302673,
0.8121510744094849,
0.7992790341377258,
-0.8533355593681335,
-0.3750268220901489,
0.25294995307922363,
-0.17036041617393494,
-0.15954576432704926,
-0.1284864842891693,
0.44673293828964233,
-0.32938992977142334,
-0.5697158575057983,
0.5886629223823547,
0.37378811836242676,
-0.33357736468315125,
-0.3756501376628876,
-0.11574115604162216,
-0.2193070501089096,
0.4264996349811554,
0.5321011543273926,
0.5997389554977417,
-0.7971073985099792,
-0.1230287030339241,
-0.22532887756824493,
0.1370905637741089,
0.00494250888004899,
0.7258952856063843,
-0.5630165934562683,
0.22312815487384796,
0.5345338582992554,
0.5420922040939331,
0.6255002021789551,
-0.21745114028453827,
0.5384817123413086,
-0.6190574169158936,
0.5053674578666687,
0.1446465700864792,
0.3617269992828369,
0.10949008911848068,
-0.12982545793056488,
0.3404441773891449,
-0.02246139384806156,
-0.4628077745437622,
-1.1383461952209473,
0.18759344518184662,
-1.3209820985794067,
-0.3060498535633087,
1.2648710012435913,
0.017443189397454262,
-0.29840531945228577,
-0.02242821268737316,
-0.18633411824703217,
0.03448864445090294,
-0.5378468632698059,
0.726902961730957,
0.3956661820411682,
-0.12995029985904694,
-0.25883159041404724,
-0.6702954769134521,
0.6937925219535828,
0.48218461871147156,
-0.8116961717605591,
0.1701132357120514,
0.17805257439613342,
0.3838517963886261,
-0.12944969534873962,
0.7373112440109253,
0.2313879281282425,
-0.012536653317511082,
-0.1621575504541397,
-0.028143946081399918,
0.11154080182313919,
-0.31853753328323364,
-0.3792314827442169,
0.3415055572986603,
0.5016854405403137,
0.19436785578727722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18101v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18101v2
|
Assessing the Efficacy of Grammar Error Correction: A Human Evaluation Approach in the Japanese Context
| 2024-02-28T06:43:43 | 2024-02-29T10:53:40 |
Qiao Wang, Zheng Yuan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study, we evaluated the performance of the state-of-the-art sequence
tagging grammar error detection and correction model (SeqTagger) using Japanese
university students' writing samples. With an automatic annotation toolkit,
ERRANT, we first evaluated SeqTagger's performance on error correction with
human expert correction as the benchmark. Then a human-annotated approach was
adopted to evaluate Seqtagger's performance in error detection using a subset
of the writing dataset. Results indicated a precision of 63.66% and a recall of
20.19% for error correction in the full dataset. For the subset, after manual
exclusion of irrelevant errors such as semantic and mechanical ones, the model
shows an adjusted precision of 97.98% and an adjusted recall of 42.98% for
error detection, indicating the model's high accuracy but also its
conservativeness. Thematic analysis on errors undetected by the model revealed
that determiners and articles, especially the latter, were predominant.
Specifically, in terms of context-independent errors, the model occasionally
overlooked basic ones and faced challenges with overly erroneous or complex
structures. Meanwhile, context-dependent errors, notably those related to tense
and noun number, as well as those possibly influenced by the students' first
language (L1), remained particularly challenging.
|
[
0.05154985189437866,
-1.1023831367492676,
0.4265744090080261,
0.2050788849592209,
-0.010044555179774761,
0.055656980723142624,
-0.13372164964675903,
-0.1427648663520813,
-0.06450741738080978,
0.11264783889055252,
-0.38720396161079407,
-0.5497499704360962,
-0.31346768140792847,
0.632723867893219,
-0.1555168330669403,
0.47369468212127686,
-0.2315150648355484,
0.14883512258529663,
-0.2768532931804657,
0.07766088098287582,
-0.9370943903923035,
-0.5889559984207153,
-0.6706503033638,
-0.19488099217414856,
0.22686485946178436,
0.6890816688537598,
0.5617685914039612,
0.6359889507293701,
0.5298561453819275,
0.31088703870773315,
0.05233222246170044,
0.015272131189703941,
-0.24773195385932922,
-0.3538055121898651,
-0.26389360427856445,
-0.575078547000885,
-0.567141592502594,
-0.09709484130144119,
0.8684698343276978,
0.7961814403533936,
-0.32399481534957886,
0.12157265841960907,
-0.06493308395147324,
0.648248016834259,
-0.45281368494033813,
-0.0894218385219574,
-0.06455667316913605,
0.04062654823064804,
-0.47734689712524414,
0.14011362195014954,
-0.6455767750740051,
-0.2070128321647644,
-0.13329526782035828,
-0.6315634250640869,
0.16482746601104736,
-0.02862827107310295,
0.8178065419197083,
0.30895861983299255,
-0.2490546554327011,
-0.15682750940322876,
-0.46294552087783813,
0.35981184244155884,
-0.9639691710472107,
-0.04066689684987068,
0.5850672721862793,
0.2237573117017746,
-0.4759208559989929,
-0.5299416184425354,
-0.4496813714504242,
0.332377552986145,
-0.2541007101535797,
0.3784656226634979,
-0.19799146056175232,
0.13111428916454315,
0.6177228093147278,
0.04066656157374382,
-0.4859527349472046,
0.14003002643585205,
-0.25317007303237915,
-0.325212299823761,
0.6341689229011536,
0.21947015821933746,
0.7387484908103943,
-0.6774343252182007,
-0.15846583247184753,
-0.10443834215402603,
-0.15890823304653168,
0.28021538257598877,
0.6141631603240967,
0.35390329360961914,
0.22610153257846832,
0.32999715209007263,
-0.3891640901565552,
0.6292352080345154,
-0.1627129465341568,
-0.24339346587657928,
0.10565220564603806,
-0.26523303985595703,
-0.38234400749206543,
0.016034066677093506,
0.8215252161026001,
0.39857450127601624,
0.1803911030292511,
-0.0922844335436821,
-0.23886829614639282,
0.5121609568595886,
0.37008875608444214,
-0.367940217256546,
-0.2613162696361542,
-0.1365652084350586,
-0.20043215155601501,
-0.09038771688938141,
0.32214242219924927,
-0.8360952734947205,
-0.16140860319137573,
-0.03846307098865509,
0.7909058928489685,
-0.34793293476104736,
-0.08566159009933472,
0.2945091724395752,
-0.11168580502271652,
0.020237451419234276,
0.3015233874320984,
-0.638626754283905,
0.343299001455307,
0.5098505020141602,
0.6384252309799194,
0.055593203753232956,
-0.5163875818252563,
-0.06431429088115692,
-0.10400469601154327,
-0.2730271816253662,
0.8954762816429138,
-0.35822412371635437,
-0.7404847145080566,
-0.17307062447071075,
0.17116017639636993,
-0.5253260731697083,
-0.2785818874835968,
1.2375097274780273,
0.0475602000951767,
0.23476573824882507,
-0.39047303795814514,
-0.9366567730903625,
-0.17705310881137848,
-0.1354272961616516,
-0.6830084919929504,
1.2745351791381836,
0.37885698676109314,
-0.5939666628837585,
0.25836706161499023,
-0.4145866632461548,
-0.5095003247261047,
0.21373015642166138,
0.00013947731349617243,
-0.6987704038619995,
0.11432940512895584,
0.270908385515213,
0.4581013321876526,
0.12433986365795135,
0.6428342461585999,
0.12106187641620636,
-0.7635701298713684,
0.40957412123680115,
-0.21308603882789612,
0.7396484017372131,
-0.2674497961997986,
-0.47185784578323364,
-0.02403591200709343,
-1.0175477266311646,
0.0392669253051281,
0.39794522523880005,
-0.63530033826828,
-0.5513636469841003,
-0.24319958686828613,
-0.28639286756515503,
0.0072158644907176495,
-0.30008724331855774,
-0.4990979731082916,
0.37165582180023193,
-0.14897559583187103,
0.2805463969707489,
0.5691102147102356,
0.11056506633758545,
0.2780475616455078,
-0.4672899544239044,
0.7149302959442139,
-0.25224077701568604,
0.025433339178562164,
-0.7327585816383362,
-0.2984539568424225,
-1.0477787256240845,
0.1237693503499031,
0.6744478940963745,
0.48069053888320923,
-0.5451357960700989,
0.5012003183364868,
-0.18491584062576294,
-0.47176775336265564,
-0.7872382998466492,
-0.012864864431321621,
0.7488532066345215,
0.7675856351852417,
0.15720713138580322,
-0.45407161116600037,
-0.859592616558075,
-0.5495930910110474,
-0.6357526779174805,
-0.40831878781318665,
0.39323532581329346,
-0.07385200262069702,
0.6216186285018921,
-0.5355368852615356,
0.760154128074646,
-0.14893336594104767,
-0.06955207139253616,
-0.03157654032111168,
0.3468177914619446,
0.05534473434090614,
0.6807957887649536,
0.141438826918602,
-0.3632446825504303,
-0.3025400936603546,
-0.3288126587867737,
-0.5620596408843994,
-0.5014357566833496,
-0.20359672605991364,
-0.3828543722629547,
0.7132000923156738,
0.29434409737586975,
-0.21389032900333405,
0.6884868144989014,
0.11309955269098282,
-0.7061277031898499,
0.5742557048797607,
-0.11552854627370834,
0.2529882490634918,
-0.8740772008895874,
0.28052109479904175,
-0.037732843309640884,
-0.4618912637233734,
-0.7877030968666077,
0.04968547821044922,
0.48141610622406006,
0.1625116914510727,
-0.06419127434492111,
0.30318719148635864,
-0.1565447598695755,
0.0009161799680441618,
-0.11397238820791245,
-0.040276557207107544,
0.2955441176891327,
0.4256060719490051,
-0.3118607699871063,
0.547427773475647,
-0.11575369536876678,
-0.29160377383232117,
-0.05427142605185509,
0.0749686136841774,
-0.10555160790681839,
0.6470876932144165,
-0.5447332859039307,
0.3187277615070343,
-0.208401158452034,
-0.012388627976179123,
-1.527772068977356,
-0.6822341084480286,
0.39932766556739807,
-0.6818492412567139,
0.30660080909729004,
-0.05191197618842125,
-0.45718914270401,
-0.5139021277427673,
-0.08805020898580551,
0.024278946220874786,
0.37260138988494873,
-0.3593970835208893,
0.6839078068733215,
0.12962277233600616,
-0.2332698255777359,
-0.53353351354599,
-0.4154742956161499,
0.06970903277397156,
-0.08511710166931152,
-0.37295180559158325,
-0.04359230399131775,
0.20769278705120087,
-0.19129721820354462,
-0.04524118825793266,
-0.17037081718444824,
0.13234199583530426,
0.680412232875824,
0.4544486105442047,
0.4564933776855469,
-0.04639545455574989,
0.2911747694015503,
0.06325270980596542,
-0.08697912842035294,
0.25325119495391846,
0.2899985909461975,
0.3430178463459015,
-0.24840962886810303,
-0.3318108320236206,
-0.641264796257019,
-0.1541113406419754,
0.12452568858861923,
0.16540378332138062,
0.32485753297805786,
0.3947008550167084,
-0.555100679397583,
-0.14549098908901215,
-0.688298225402832,
0.11963721364736557,
-0.34411346912384033,
0.39166685938835144,
-0.2510634660720825,
-0.46982353925704956,
0.49246111512184143,
-0.011292285285890102,
-0.28776463866233826,
0.6261645555496216,
-0.028210287913680077,
-0.2841183543205261,
0.7476947903633118,
0.44679129123687744,
-0.04708854481577873,
0.10296355187892914,
-0.020319122821092606,
-0.03627792373299599,
-0.7412897348403931,
-0.21180970966815948,
-0.6932725310325623,
-0.28665149211883545,
-0.29023224115371704,
-0.30704620480537415,
0.07882848381996155,
0.5090987086296082,
-0.14784619212150574,
0.2061057686805725,
-0.07933655381202698,
0.6903327703475952,
0.5445200204849243,
0.04858335107564926,
0.46665626764297485,
-0.05257048457860947,
-0.16574761271476746,
-0.32355979084968567,
-0.8236814737319946,
-0.7906702160835266,
0.9380996227264404,
0.45512905716896057,
0.6762903332710266,
0.15048962831497192,
0.7294937372207642,
0.27323541045188904,
0.3901410698890686,
-0.8552553653717041,
0.4200406074523926,
-0.11019453406333923,
-0.4868190586566925,
-0.44946274161338806,
-0.2687249183654785,
-0.57875657081604,
0.323202908039093,
-0.18983258306980133,
-0.43607383966445923,
0.01317786518484354,
0.020520363003015518,
-0.5249689817428589,
0.016867993399500847,
-0.8521217703819275,
1.1922733783721924,
-0.2240539938211441,
-0.3830240070819855,
0.44156476855278015,
-0.883317232131958,
0.1827542930841446,
-0.12433704733848572,
0.3151324987411499,
-0.16647230088710785,
0.12329989671707153,
0.9957467317581177,
-0.2757115662097931,
1.0864460468292236,
-0.2649631202220917,
0.23471598327159882,
0.3223826587200165,
0.13686782121658325,
0.2791261672973633,
-0.12034441530704498,
-0.04096706956624985,
0.028627239167690277,
-0.03260641172528267,
-0.23491957783699036,
-0.4968293011188507,
0.01903081126511097,
-0.9592092633247375,
-0.4664232134819031,
-0.6351426839828491,
-0.3514505624771118,
-0.00728725316002965,
0.5257031321525574,
0.2617930471897125,
0.5277626514434814,
-0.49295517802238464,
-0.14773158729076385,
0.15155291557312012,
-0.09428150206804276,
0.47770044207572937,
0.8239631056785583,
-0.4089627265930176,
-0.4992329478263855,
0.5433842539787292,
0.17943713068962097,
0.1524285078048706,
-0.07109996676445007,
0.3632912337779999,
-0.20489992201328278,
-0.13718368113040924,
-0.7652812600135803,
0.367753267288208,
-0.9670263528823853,
-0.2699829339981079,
-0.7517902851104736,
0.16991595923900604,
-0.6156741976737976,
-0.10641661286354065,
-0.21503151953220367,
-0.4155205488204956,
-0.3945954740047455,
-0.12477017939090729,
-0.22584310173988342,
0.7375245690345764,
0.18800874054431915,
0.7030258178710938,
-0.7936949729919434,
-0.117141954600811,
-0.15578065812587738,
0.26162534952163696,
-0.09927954524755478,
-0.7104443907737732,
-0.09449615329504013,
-0.06614356487989426,
-0.17653587460517883,
-0.8398686647415161,
0.3277725875377655,
0.257736474275589,
0.5136935114860535,
-0.026678599417209625,
-0.1689414232969284,
1.073893427848816,
-0.1621282398700714,
0.4720737040042877,
-0.15502163767814636,
-1.3875185251235962,
0.798724353313446,
-0.3995576798915863,
0.6108302474021912,
0.8493037819862366,
0.2921331822872162,
-0.9350101351737976,
-0.3105860948562622,
-0.8452506065368652,
-0.6654788255691528,
0.9664480686187744,
-0.17902648448944092,
-0.16341358423233032,
-0.01897396519780159,
0.9565218091011047,
-0.05632144212722778,
-0.09468545764684677,
-0.7172560095787048,
0.003582391422241926,
-0.029492033645510674,
-0.42984533309936523,
-0.20785760879516602,
-0.5343456864356995,
0.23724646866321564,
-0.2166290432214737,
0.9189359545707703,
-0.20484331250190735,
-0.05651705712080002,
0.6126670837402344,
-0.3254553973674774,
-0.5439230799674988,
0.6388073563575745,
0.4416036307811737,
0.8575025200843811,
-0.14642679691314697,
0.0712222009897232,
0.13541282713413239,
-0.3972949981689453,
0.2883482575416565,
0.07888435572385788,
-0.4506571888923645,
0.30064383149147034,
0.46416372060775757,
0.5979315042495728,
0.5247887969017029,
-0.7724083662033081,
0.6649897694587708,
-0.31674352288246155,
0.23208025097846985,
-0.3673750162124634,
0.024296971037983894,
-0.014016122557222843,
-0.08114565908908844,
0.17337605357170105,
0.16833309829235077,
0.31540629267692566,
-0.49286773800849915,
-0.07840888202190399,
-0.14422054588794708,
-0.09093905240297318,
-0.3913397789001465,
0.4490164816379547,
0.18757444620132446,
-0.24498847126960754,
0.5177474021911621,
-0.37439411878585815,
-0.8388837575912476,
0.8332870006561279,
0.897720992565155,
0.503365695476532,
-0.7494738101959229,
0.3500312268733978,
0.8380840420722961,
0.3980047106742859,
-0.6214508414268494,
0.3671179413795471,
0.3645310699939728,
-0.8543844819068909,
-0.31917575001716614,
-0.5639703869819641,
-0.4037676453590393,
-0.38387638330459595,
-1.0075349807739258,
0.36252933740615845,
-0.563484251499176,
-0.372789204120636,
-0.07261686027050018,
0.0769963413476944,
-0.4302569329738617,
0.3109857738018036,
0.0443735308945179,
0.650618851184845,
-1.1027946472167969,
0.4901741147041321,
1.2845797538757324,
-0.2162822186946869,
-1.1863738298416138,
-0.23503448069095612,
0.21138857305049896,
-0.5163106918334961,
0.48255375027656555,
0.4689573645591736,
0.10194661468267441,
0.16121751070022583,
-0.1078934520483017,
-0.6328730583190918,
0.9830092191696167,
-0.11335770040750504,
-0.9107557535171509,
0.05971773341298103,
0.18664692342281342,
0.7176396250724792,
-0.02614404819905758,
0.3233444094657898,
0.9846173524856567,
0.1801597625017166,
-0.04835166782140732,
-0.9499596953392029,
0.007914085872471333,
-0.43009576201438904,
0.39729467034339905,
0.4432659447193146,
-0.5659219026565552,
0.8225153088569641,
-0.10416485369205475,
-0.6756705045700073,
0.203506737947464,
0.31472787261009216,
-0.09793722629547119,
0.4687577188014984,
0.19274401664733887,
0.9256265759468079,
1.1852871179580688,
-0.3956802487373352,
1.0128986835479736,
0.2825982868671417,
0.423615425825119,
1.2095022201538086,
-0.1363336443901062,
0.9226101040840149,
0.28191864490509033,
-0.4331554174423218,
0.4501032829284668,
0.44407033920288086,
0.0009897967102006078,
0.01656397059559822,
-0.0458662174642086,
0.10677185654640198,
-0.13130657374858856,
-0.11061102896928787,
-0.065128393471241,
0.47836825251579285,
0.33006760478019714,
-0.4212853014469147,
0.16507188975811005,
-0.0029665993060916662,
0.5466011166572571,
0.4623352587223053,
-0.5101398825645447,
0.9504523873329163,
-0.2756057679653168,
-1.020974040031433,
0.28387805819511414,
0.33788180351257324,
0.6006814241409302,
-0.06310364603996277,
0.0737072229385376,
-0.3729378283023834,
0.31191718578338623,
-0.3858543932437897,
-0.4839398264884949,
0.1919868141412735,
0.12843789160251617,
0.011786983348429203,
0.24108006060123444,
1.14985990524292,
-0.30892324447631836,
-0.7068042159080505,
-0.13673047721385956,
0.5258630514144897,
-0.07828355580568314,
0.3730176091194153,
-0.23941683769226074,
0.39230677485466003,
-0.04213550314307213,
0.21977129578590393,
-0.2085827738046646,
0.06279638409614563,
0.03519748896360397,
0.20840921998023987,
0.23731353878974915,
-0.12191940099000931,
0.16495251655578613,
0.27853137254714966,
0.4817161560058594,
-0.7895417213439941,
-0.5502457618713379,
-1.0471293926239014,
0.5910788178443909,
0.011056691408157349,
-0.40353038907051086,
1.0417277812957764,
0.310544490814209,
1.3464467525482178,
-0.028770824894309044,
0.9208347797393799,
0.0719374418258667,
0.7544549703598022,
-0.47637709975242615,
0.21490143239498138,
-0.07859013974666595,
0.1624513417482376,
-0.636911153793335,
-0.6863294243812561,
-0.7006791234016418,
0.9805783033370972,
-0.44126760959625244,
-0.05815957114100456,
0.6456154584884644,
0.48662081360816956,
0.38596048951148987,
0.41402584314346313,
0.28383108973503113,
0.2077825367450714,
0.11292169243097305,
0.6124114394187927,
1.2717232704162598,
-0.8677822351455688,
-0.2647809386253357,
-0.623080313205719,
-0.2622363269329071,
-0.38924577832221985,
-0.586584746837616,
-1.0424436330795288,
-0.27575817704200745,
-0.45044782757759094,
-0.3892971873283386,
0.33207955956459045,
1.1472276449203491,
0.02389650046825409,
-0.5963582396507263,
-0.20999129116535187,
0.04272071272134781,
-0.23421920835971832,
0.07164983451366425,
-0.22324883937835693,
0.13652600347995758,
-0.4156079590320587,
-0.6534677147865295,
0.021798472851514816,
0.046469464898109436,
0.19491733610630035,
0.16120822727680206,
0.03421390801668167,
-0.189331516623497,
-0.22035227715969086,
0.29023703932762146,
0.09118857979774475,
-0.7708859443664551,
-0.2116430401802063,
-0.025462912395596504,
-0.3573182225227356,
0.17784470319747925,
0.6870201230049133,
-0.5079149007797241,
0.9678040742874146,
0.5405247807502747,
0.735390841960907,
-0.2444637417793274,
0.7137944102287292,
0.24599586427211761,
-0.69687819480896,
-0.11058533936738968,
0.0851035937666893,
0.644780695438385,
0.6177561283111572,
-0.4002057909965515,
0.7984163761138916,
0.6350675821304321,
-0.7789457440376282,
-0.7420291304588318,
-0.4775966703891754,
-0.6546264886856079,
-0.24530847370624542,
1.024339199066162,
-0.5009454488754272,
-0.561227560043335,
-0.0666152760386467,
-0.6062694191932678,
0.49325066804885864,
-0.2192031741142273,
0.7775338292121887,
1.1317881345748901,
0.05214164778590202,
0.008915905840694904,
-0.4632730782032013,
0.2779310643672943,
0.6832570433616638,
-0.9840960502624512,
-0.1797155737876892,
0.788378894329071,
0.30700260400772095,
0.15566186606884003,
0.7100927829742432,
-0.21356511116027832,
0.6557577848434448,
-0.04120076820254326,
0.19932681322097778,
-0.037381429225206375,
-0.2736726999282837,
-0.9886295199394226,
-0.23740988969802856,
0.29818007349967957,
0.2734687626361847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18099v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18099v2
|
Editing Factual Knowledge and Explanatory Ability of Medical Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T06:40:57 | 2024-06-04T14:38:34 |
Derong Xu, Ziheng Zhang, Zhihong Zhu, Zhenxi Lin, Qidong Liu, Xian Wu, Tong Xu, Wanyu Wang, Yuyang Ye, Xiangyu Zhao, Yefeng Zheng, Enhong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Model editing aims to precisely alter the behaviors of large language models
(LLMs) in relation to specific knowledge, while leaving unrelated knowledge
intact. This approach has proven effective in addressing issues of
hallucination and outdated information in LLMs. However, the potential of using
model editing to modify knowledge in the medical field remains largely
unexplored, even though resolving hallucination is a pressing need in this
area. Our observations indicate that current methods face significant
challenges in dealing with specialized and complex knowledge in medical domain.
Therefore, we propose MedLaSA, a novel Layer-wise Scalable Adapter strategy for
medical model editing. MedLaSA harnesses the strengths of both adding extra
parameters and locate-then-edit methods for medical model editing. We utilize
causal tracing to identify the association of knowledge in neurons across
different layers, and generate a corresponding scale set from the association
value for each piece of knowledge. Subsequently, we incorporate scalable
adapters into the dense layers of LLMs. These adapters are assigned scaling
values based on the corresponding specific knowledge, which allows for the
adjustment of the adapter's weight and rank. The more similar the content, the
more consistent the scale between them. This ensures precise editing of
semantically identical knowledge while avoiding impact on unrelated knowledge.
To evaluate the editing impact on the behaviours of LLMs, we propose two model
editing studies for medical domain: (1) editing factual knowledge for medical
specialization and (2) editing the explanatory ability for complex knowledge.
We build two novel medical benchmarking datasets and introduce a series of
challenging and comprehensive metrics. Extensive experiments on medical LLMs
demonstrate the editing efficiency of MedLaSA, without affecting unrelated
knowledge.
|
[
0.10230288654565811,
-0.9639599323272705,
0.8696141242980957,
-0.04907714203000069,
0.018787411972880363,
-0.06223217770457268,
-0.21753811836242676,
-0.5934199690818787,
0.49172452092170715,
0.5625592470169067,
-0.14190484583377838,
-0.43697473406791687,
-0.5320543646812439,
-0.156005397439003,
0.022260325029492378,
1.0273197889328003,
-0.08037453889846802,
0.43466606736183167,
-0.23021329939365387,
-0.6080796122550964,
-0.673606276512146,
-0.4789636433124542,
-0.78077232837677,
-0.031135480850934982,
0.7108377814292908,
-0.046414539217948914,
0.8957031965255737,
0.9107588529586792,
0.5730987787246704,
0.3966558277606964,
-0.7018188834190369,
0.6034755110740662,
-0.2695535123348236,
0.19978424906730652,
-0.6038963794708252,
-0.7123072743415833,
-1.058274745941162,
-0.1594986468553543,
0.6169460415840149,
0.7759634852409363,
-0.133778378367424,
0.20193733274936676,
-0.294036865234375,
0.8428124189376831,
-0.37270277738571167,
0.14137503504753113,
-0.7772398591041565,
-0.030521219596266747,
-0.06339719146490097,
-0.4136417806148529,
-0.418016642332077,
-0.27442699670791626,
0.07172677665948868,
-0.6217827200889587,
0.1010923981666565,
-0.09338412433862686,
0.4988875687122345,
0.6642990708351135,
-0.17076356709003448,
-0.294727623462677,
-0.7934982180595398,
0.20627158880233765,
-0.9206014275550842,
0.07833222299814224,
0.04427940770983696,
0.24131141602993011,
-0.1703825742006302,
-0.7634287476539612,
-0.41183021664619446,
-0.013911906629800797,
-0.015044501051306725,
-0.12948040664196014,
-0.2093513011932373,
0.14974838495254517,
0.4408104717731476,
0.195726677775383,
-0.22735166549682617,
0.19470706582069397,
-0.616895854473114,
0.03169497475028038,
0.4270220100879669,
0.2667151987552643,
0.6435670852661133,
-0.059461478143930435,
0.1157316192984581,
0.17222216725349426,
-0.8206782937049866,
-0.011736389249563217,
-0.08655087649822235,
0.13441555202007294,
0.10028386861085892,
0.8681342005729675,
0.0486990250647068,
0.8704227209091187,
0.13892583549022675,
-0.29624712467193604,
0.3585662543773651,
0.010098861530423164,
-0.4784110486507416,
-0.067844457924366,
0.34069764614105225,
0.4453655779361725,
-0.15871275961399078,
-0.08089277148246765,
-0.11731062084436417,
-0.12301944941282272,
0.45410215854644775,
-0.719404399394989,
-0.21975760161876678,
0.26451990008354187,
-0.6427370309829712,
-0.4824005961418152,
-0.5535902380943298,
-0.5572722554206848,
-0.9009531140327454,
-0.4007467031478882,
0.6872913837432861,
-0.416181355714798,
0.05712136998772621,
0.4040199816226959,
0.040083516389131546,
-0.36319634318351746,
0.5910849571228027,
-0.8402586579322815,
0.16042663156986237,
0.4979112148284912,
0.9245429039001465,
0.09540759772062302,
-0.22257986664772034,
-0.3690126836299896,
0.31463176012039185,
-0.45897066593170166,
0.7317461371421814,
-0.6852909326553345,
0.062106020748615265,
-0.29117351770401,
0.013114995323121548,
-0.257708340883255,
-0.6957930326461792,
0.499787837266922,
-0.6895151138305664,
0.0362473800778389,
-0.3246768116950989,
-0.8459997177124023,
-0.4804249405860901,
-0.006086427718400955,
-0.6346326470375061,
0.4325617551803589,
0.08999283611774445,
-0.6980769634246826,
0.2126849740743637,
-0.8213751316070557,
-0.2751030921936035,
-0.22161196172237396,
-0.11994735151529312,
-0.3672153353691101,
0.4602532982826233,
0.23828625679016113,
0.4939956068992615,
-0.13007041811943054,
0.6333868503570557,
-0.2693536877632141,
0.0403449647128582,
0.3883097767829895,
-0.10525962710380554,
0.5418161153793335,
-0.07167782634496689,
-0.035032644867897034,
0.48279887437820435,
-0.998673677444458,
-0.1406111866235733,
0.020032888278365135,
-0.21718689799308777,
-0.5120980143547058,
0.0887056216597557,
-0.0847378671169281,
0.46429190039634705,
0.06748554855585098,
-0.4477531909942627,
0.5500749349594116,
-0.4831044375896454,
0.6293137669563293,
0.8251619935035706,
0.20275980234146118,
0.266571968793869,
-0.5156541466712952,
0.3893556296825409,
-0.051087286323308945,
0.2582238018512726,
-0.02754947543144226,
-0.5575113892555237,
-0.5918607115745544,
-0.44338905811309814,
0.38565781712532043,
0.3437593877315521,
-0.7035363912582397,
0.11849294602870941,
-0.14591288566589355,
-0.6688585877418518,
-0.9340213537216187,
0.03245513513684273,
0.27637335658073425,
0.8377280235290527,
0.6361055374145508,
0.09549760073423386,
-0.4576314389705658,
-0.9476653933525085,
-0.5512064695358276,
-0.0015553560806438327,
0.06532666832208633,
0.3305482566356659,
0.43391039967536926,
-0.3220723569393158,
0.4968615174293518,
-0.7094796299934387,
-0.44080471992492676,
0.01210104301571846,
-0.21368417143821716,
0.24172961711883545,
0.59809809923172,
0.6662548780441284,
-0.5534821152687073,
-0.21807657182216644,
0.19032691419124603,
-0.8410789966583252,
-0.18858951330184937,
-0.3615964651107788,
-0.0033463144209235907,
-0.00949867069721222,
0.6044394969940186,
-0.6710591316223145,
0.24557924270629883,
0.5294736623764038,
-0.5140575170516968,
0.5279568433761597,
-0.7883809208869934,
0.19616009294986725,
-1.0569326877593994,
0.10201122611761093,
-0.32257214188575745,
-0.06746476888656616,
-0.9329323768615723,
0.24706053733825684,
0.33713510632514954,
0.18601195514202118,
-0.2544044256210327,
0.5637491941452026,
-0.26771268248558044,
0.14491067826747894,
-0.2829207181930542,
0.021102571859955788,
0.004602442961186171,
0.41672420501708984,
-0.12166034430265427,
0.483258455991745,
0.4103931486606598,
-0.3090883493423462,
0.06715895980596542,
0.31278562545776367,
-0.40986931324005127,
0.459931343793869,
-0.7919306755065918,
0.07507237046957016,
-0.18684765696525574,
0.16652053594589233,
-0.6330350041389465,
-0.0848846510052681,
0.0555732436478138,
-0.14124973118305206,
0.2581360638141632,
-0.1381763368844986,
-0.4499584436416626,
0.015331344678997993,
-0.10888136178255081,
0.44435107707977295,
0.219223752617836,
-0.4591705799102783,
0.7711089253425598,
0.5817759037017822,
-0.3972432017326355,
-0.3277125954627991,
-0.5782892107963562,
0.27419549226760864,
-0.19050049781799316,
-0.7279666662216187,
0.5186319351196289,
-0.3612200915813446,
-0.2498369663953781,
-0.053547345101833344,
-0.008219296112656593,
-0.09320531040430069,
-0.11235706508159637,
0.22955092787742615,
0.6719988584518433,
-0.2677818238735199,
0.36980876326560974,
0.6441887617111206,
-0.0931052416563034,
0.05709642916917801,
0.06754492223262787,
0.10605903714895248,
0.2151067703962326,
-0.3327307105064392,
-0.4745696187019348,
0.05085807293653488,
1.1010286808013916,
-0.24045635759830475,
0.7556961178779602,
0.14913396537303925,
-0.6154231429100037,
-0.024387197569012642,
-0.782244861125946,
-0.01628488302230835,
-0.39272475242614746,
0.7044299244880676,
-0.4703367054462433,
-0.7860924005508423,
0.66836017370224,
-0.2846512496471405,
0.08365482091903687,
0.4633997082710266,
0.6084160208702087,
0.12289103865623474,
1.0741267204284668,
0.5552321672439575,
0.17697101831436157,
-0.010290654376149178,
-0.0014594580279663205,
0.18091438710689545,
-1.1445926427841187,
-0.20336152613162994,
-0.4198235273361206,
-0.45534202456474304,
-0.42363592982292175,
-0.7907570004463196,
0.566826343536377,
-0.1431732028722763,
0.11409646272659302,
-0.05611615628004074,
-0.47061923146247864,
0.5214512348175049,
-0.028074854984879494,
0.4915950894355774,
0.4245028793811798,
-0.29192185401916504,
-0.08709985017776489,
-0.21886563301086426,
-0.7707598805427551,
-0.3135600984096527,
1.2627943754196167,
0.45920947194099426,
0.5998899340629578,
0.06090034544467926,
0.11480467766523361,
0.13859854638576508,
0.3419162631034851,
-0.6034892201423645,
0.2523956298828125,
-0.2736522853374481,
-0.5805400013923645,
-0.20531561970710754,
-0.2100875824689865,
-0.34675300121307373,
0.4425414502620697,
-0.3855837881565094,
-0.4814656674861908,
0.4295656085014343,
0.321247398853302,
-0.6012426018714905,
0.8745784759521484,
-0.6635638475418091,
0.5871323347091675,
0.09591513872146606,
-0.2866300046443939,
-0.380881667137146,
-0.6117246150970459,
0.23690354824066162,
-0.4313409626483917,
0.4935428500175476,
0.2630070447921753,
-0.27485817670822144,
0.7591978907585144,
-0.5018065571784973,
0.8590630888938904,
-0.23485428094863892,
-0.1340089589357376,
-0.2806048095226288,
0.2939797043800354,
0.6992895603179932,
0.021788403391838074,
-0.18723122775554657,
-0.04379720240831375,
0.1221768707036972,
-0.25727784633636475,
-0.8002662062644958,
0.7399150133132935,
-0.574752151966095,
-0.5574527382850647,
-0.11101759225130081,
-1.1193759441375732,
-0.4112553894519806,
0.03302957862615585,
-0.08016619086265564,
0.4956119954586029,
-0.1162167564034462,
0.07539542019367218,
0.8038386702537537,
-0.4975311756134033,
-0.07448223978281021,
0.6800947189331055,
-0.3972943127155304,
-0.28571271896362305,
0.8260190486907959,
0.4760458171367645,
0.3867347538471222,
0.25801873207092285,
0.3138997256755829,
0.1641935259103775,
-0.8268970847129822,
-0.5688934922218323,
0.4541873037815094,
-0.7519441843032837,
-0.09871724247932434,
-1.0343108177185059,
-0.3322187662124634,
-0.09874138981103897,
-0.4380555748939514,
-0.5534301400184631,
-0.6173702478408813,
-0.03959087282419205,
-0.06378161907196045,
0.3563689887523651,
0.9609795212745667,
-0.12319035083055496,
-0.008035951294004917,
-0.5687553286552429,
0.5271017551422119,
0.22642968595027924,
0.2952405512332916,
0.06632955372333527,
-0.7676712870597839,
-0.2512490153312683,
-0.09525076299905777,
0.21744200587272644,
-0.7263619303703308,
0.3029235005378723,
-0.05628593638539314,
0.2694288492202759,
0.4130810499191284,
-0.3864763379096985,
0.9344556331634521,
-0.697145402431488,
0.46130597591400146,
-0.05944425240159035,
-0.9049386978149414,
0.4598447382450104,
-0.17535915970802307,
0.2228359878063202,
0.35089221596717834,
0.055357325822114944,
-0.5893245339393616,
-0.45566338300704956,
-0.47859373688697815,
-0.4811239540576935,
0.5413375496864319,
-0.09232953190803528,
0.0314406156539917,
0.32272836565971375,
0.7386247515678406,
0.2857707440853119,
0.08847884833812714,
-0.38849419355392456,
-0.2413119524717331,
0.3183336555957794,
0.0737844705581665,
0.04425410181283951,
-0.4901115596294403,
-0.2753748893737793,
-0.7719230651855469,
0.7059016227722168,
0.053844571113586426,
-0.2769971787929535,
0.32738277316093445,
-0.13882873952388763,
-0.23199211061000824,
0.19324392080307007,
0.9736012816429138,
1.0560729503631592,
-0.2803593873977661,
0.04098927602171898,
0.3799440860748291,
-0.6091156005859375,
0.008062170818448067,
-0.2483445405960083,
-0.4702746570110321,
0.05824447050690651,
0.41505464911460876,
0.8164905905723572,
0.28390932083129883,
-0.6430788636207581,
0.2364296019077301,
0.03269730880856514,
-0.15855923295021057,
0.25328394770622253,
0.017069658264517784,
0.3170528709888458,
0.42301809787750244,
-0.08109331876039505,
0.813767671585083,
0.08775106072425842,
-0.29315197467803955,
-0.052628930658102036,
0.1376674771308899,
-0.34387513995170593,
-0.3813017010688782,
0.7896113395690918,
-0.11587568372488022,
-0.23991568386554718,
0.05158117040991783,
0.2777045965194702,
-0.18092483282089233,
0.5612347722053528,
0.6325427889823914,
0.5705621242523193,
-0.5406630039215088,
0.1464495211839676,
0.3626978397369385,
0.39820486307144165,
0.0514780730009079,
0.10114726424217224,
0.46445921063423157,
-0.586146891117096,
-0.5133528113365173,
-0.2955436706542969,
-0.28101253509521484,
0.25927457213401794,
-0.5783156156539917,
0.20192179083824158,
-0.5723679065704346,
-0.04765888303518295,
0.5960242748260498,
-0.517073929309845,
-0.4543015658855438,
0.2702600061893463,
-0.29574069380760193,
0.800213634967804,
-0.7556750178337097,
0.9561316967010498,
0.7352135181427002,
-0.20521923899650574,
-0.6776013970375061,
-0.42186281085014343,
0.18795602023601532,
-0.8045825958251953,
0.3375357985496521,
-0.21462592482566833,
0.03851712495088577,
-0.25115659832954407,
-0.4644777178764343,
-0.6898204684257507,
1.0153268575668335,
0.43520650267601013,
-0.6193570494651794,
-0.31681933999061584,
-0.14260981976985931,
0.7961429357528687,
-0.5005568861961365,
0.05772250145673752,
0.4970709979534149,
0.3691686689853668,
0.018495749682188034,
-0.7242564558982849,
0.3110522925853729,
-0.3730567991733551,
-0.03369497135281563,
-0.10206697881221771,
-0.46241965889930725,
0.8715969324111938,
-0.5306992530822754,
0.28174614906311035,
0.13713349401950836,
0.27198973298072815,
0.047197211533784866,
0.16705356538295746,
0.3651646673679352,
0.5893608331680298,
1.0359152555465698,
0.39286425709724426,
0.8186242580413818,
-0.3576803207397461,
0.1086876392364502,
1.4088025093078613,
-0.2876091003417969,
0.713860809803009,
0.5927487015724182,
-0.02386663481593132,
0.38165879249572754,
0.22106340527534485,
0.05435685068368912,
0.19632291793823242,
0.1235802173614502,
-0.2500185966491699,
-0.07175789773464203,
0.0263195987790823,
-0.6127262115478516,
0.3880159556865692,
0.38471534848213196,
-0.7607040405273438,
0.059255827218294144,
0.20869551599025726,
0.5523313283920288,
0.07311780005693436,
-0.30797773599624634,
0.7429043054580688,
-0.19094255566596985,
-0.4551251232624054,
0.3999484181404114,
0.15749481320381165,
0.27053821086883545,
-0.5790572166442871,
-0.18705186247825623,
-0.03499497100710869,
0.1575300395488739,
-0.3355511426925659,
-0.5497553944587708,
0.38860079646110535,
0.06562966108322144,
-0.5178690552711487,
0.08311913162469864,
0.6572718024253845,
-0.3175666332244873,
-0.6525962352752686,
0.250997394323349,
0.583989143371582,
0.058786649256944656,
-0.15165862441062927,
-0.5863111019134521,
0.1342328041791916,
0.10405165702104568,
-0.19348467886447906,
0.3814927339553833,
0.5662674903869629,
0.10001732409000397,
0.7414555549621582,
0.7640764117240906,
0.7295547127723694,
-0.11764183640480042,
0.1293971836566925,
1.0867863893508911,
-0.587014377117157,
-0.26846709847450256,
-0.779478907585144,
0.41819754242897034,
-0.089097760617733,
-0.27172449231147766,
0.38017117977142334,
0.4983057379722595,
0.4288649559020996,
-0.2969571053981781,
0.5911607146263123,
-0.010715433396399021,
0.45285966992378235,
-0.6349900364875793,
1.118010401725769,
-0.5098719596862793,
0.3653009235858917,
-0.4185730516910553,
-0.7123820185661316,
-0.581657886505127,
0.25749722123146057,
-0.3281242847442627,
-0.21590711176395416,
0.889209508895874,
0.974583625793457,
-0.011138977482914925,
-0.02353936992585659,
0.5115402936935425,
0.9808058738708496,
0.35198649764060974,
0.3887283205986023,
0.3479517102241516,
-0.33188512921333313,
-0.06670355051755905,
-0.3525262176990509,
-0.4717831015586853,
-0.04006655514240265,
-0.5609170198440552,
-0.9976472854614258,
-0.5389854907989502,
-0.33313092589378357,
-0.23550459742546082,
0.252411812543869,
0.8959867358207703,
0.5703469514846802,
-0.693387508392334,
0.10952553153038025,
0.28126052021980286,
0.15908615291118622,
-0.4468776285648346,
-0.10686392337083817,
0.9056887626647949,
-0.23365522921085358,
-0.5564702749252319,
0.5458047986030579,
0.6954849362373352,
-0.27081793546676636,
-0.07713782787322998,
0.12099489569664001,
-0.35449790954589844,
0.3139581084251404,
0.7929462194442749,
0.1286538690328598,
-0.6948211789131165,
-0.26552271842956543,
-0.2026139348745346,
-0.010395837016403675,
0.11833777278661728,
0.8807845711708069,
-0.5711765885353088,
0.9907599687576294,
0.37015607953071594,
0.7451915144920349,
0.13766074180603027,
-0.31861135363578796,
0.3267168700695038,
-0.06877502799034119,
0.004340087529271841,
0.08540128916501999,
0.4595464766025543,
0.22247084975242615,
-0.4408803880214691,
0.3720256984233856,
0.1806558519601822,
-0.7014272809028625,
-0.8235823512077332,
-0.24394777417182922,
-1.0432484149932861,
-0.4242938756942749,
0.8473863005638123,
-0.1470121443271637,
-0.14798200130462646,
-0.047817084938287735,
-0.7166962623596191,
0.22269584238529205,
0.18543395400047302,
1.1320297718048096,
0.5393033623695374,
-0.15094995498657227,
0.21507631242275238,
-0.852013349533081,
0.5829604864120483,
0.5506622195243835,
-0.9841229319572449,
0.12274457514286041,
0.5627022385597229,
0.3649205267429352,
-0.02827369049191475,
0.4380588233470917,
-0.4172515869140625,
0.34974759817123413,
-0.1912076771259308,
0.04366367682814598,
-0.23766766488552094,
-0.3228701949119568,
-0.44986534118652344,
0.28363436460494995,
-0.011576607823371887,
0.18803443014621735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18091v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18091v1
|
Polos: Multimodal Metric Learning from Human Feedback for Image Captioning
| 2024-02-28T06:24:39 | 2024-02-28T06:24:39 |
Yuiga Wada, Kanta Kaneda, Daichi Saito, Komei Sugiura
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Establishing an automatic evaluation metric that closely aligns with human
judgments is essential for effectively developing image captioning models.
Recent data-driven metrics have demonstrated a stronger correlation with human
judgments than classic metrics such as CIDEr; however they lack sufficient
capabilities to handle hallucinations and generalize across diverse images and
texts partially because they compute scalar similarities merely using
embeddings learned from tasks unrelated to image captioning evaluation. In this
study, we propose Polos, a supervised automatic evaluation metric for image
captioning models. Polos computes scores from multimodal inputs, using a
parallel feature extraction mechanism that leverages embeddings trained through
large-scale contrastive learning. To train Polos, we introduce Multimodal
Metric Learning from Human Feedback (M$^2$LHF), a framework for developing
metrics based on human feedback. We constructed the Polaris dataset, which
comprises 131K human judgments from 550 evaluators, which is approximately ten
times larger than standard datasets. Our approach achieved state-of-the-art
performance on Composite, Flickr8K-Expert, Flickr8K-CF, PASCAL-50S, FOIL, and
the Polaris dataset, thereby demonstrating its effectiveness and robustness.
|
[
-0.49033334851264954,
-0.12041439116001129,
0.330089807510376,
0.41006922721862793,
-0.5569215416908264,
0.3084995448589325,
-0.3835147023200989,
-0.17511115968227386,
0.20595519244670868,
0.336887001991272,
-0.4860103130340576,
-0.6077521443367004,
-0.5066608786582947,
0.2945801615715027,
-0.05382828786969185,
1.1981697082519531,
0.022457657381892204,
0.6593815684318542,
-0.6203764081001282,
-0.3815155029296875,
-0.3581293821334839,
-0.13661806285381317,
-0.3828914165496826,
0.11588512361049652,
0.7560045719146729,
0.4885360598564148,
0.510759711265564,
0.21310599148273468,
0.7328401207923889,
0.28730741143226624,
0.46737006306648254,
0.7190762162208557,
-0.12971140444278717,
-0.09725558757781982,
-0.11954100430011749,
-0.32991066575050354,
-0.20795394480228424,
0.3187887370586395,
0.5157750844955444,
0.3953802287578583,
0.018424581736326218,
0.22871597111225128,
-0.09113624691963196,
0.7960793375968933,
-0.8005679249763489,
0.5885866284370422,
-0.3712851405143738,
0.4905594289302826,
0.14237596094608307,
-0.3756149709224701,
-0.5983452796936035,
-0.09466011822223663,
0.23123697936534882,
-0.826618492603302,
0.36043861508369446,
0.5966190099716187,
0.8488926291465759,
0.10189839452505112,
-0.3034082353115082,
-0.20854488015174866,
-0.4910842776298523,
1.1579376459121704,
-0.20989681780338287,
0.40361469984054565,
0.29786738753318787,
0.45791178941726685,
0.3324808180332184,
-0.34244590997695923,
-0.7014455795288086,
-0.5688909292221069,
-0.4528147876262665,
0.3914390802383423,
0.12702032923698425,
-0.2378396987915039,
0.15792866051197052,
0.2250794619321823,
-0.4265317916870117,
-0.03116953745484352,
-0.6698594093322754,
-0.3842228353023529,
0.6672554016113281,
0.33084848523139954,
-0.05688787251710892,
-0.5643420219421387,
-0.7530069351196289,
-0.37698233127593994,
-0.2881181538105011,
0.21399489045143127,
0.18237879872322083,
0.029294416308403015,
-0.26369810104370117,
0.2463984340429306,
-0.27487534284591675,
0.4424804747104645,
-0.1160859540104866,
-0.23528917133808136,
0.5945555567741394,
-0.18515947461128235,
0.1721632331609726,
-0.6403642892837524,
1.1738388538360596,
0.8470785021781921,
0.07675308734178543,
-0.3853330910205841,
-0.3481115996837616,
-0.027417944744229317,
0.34754428267478943,
-0.5174762010574341,
-0.3575749397277832,
-0.08863476663827896,
-0.42858508229255676,
-0.543140709400177,
0.8201366662979126,
-1.0269838571548462,
-0.6056735515594482,
-0.5836580395698547,
0.6241001486778259,
-0.43786510825157166,
0.2770371735095978,
-0.19824369251728058,
-0.3046378493309021,
0.38609033823013306,
0.39517471194267273,
-0.4989190101623535,
0.4412696659564972,
0.3879888951778412,
0.9217153191566467,
-0.44456279277801514,
-0.5886847972869873,
-0.9258176684379578,
0.020679881796240807,
-0.35038167238235474,
0.8250342011451721,
-0.36842265725135803,
-0.07908522337675095,
-0.1607801765203476,
0.2470265030860901,
0.14811426401138306,
-0.5332558751106262,
0.3143397867679596,
-0.516815721988678,
0.39698225259780884,
0.0018010607454925776,
-0.08306268602609634,
-0.19086363911628723,
0.21512086689472198,
-0.7694574594497681,
0.39954501390457153,
-0.024420306086540222,
-0.7571659684181213,
0.5491964221000671,
-0.8189897537231445,
-0.5247666239738464,
-0.07891755551099777,
-0.09576267749071121,
-0.9790439009666443,
0.04716680571436882,
0.6656762361526489,
0.5554502606391907,
-0.43551522493362427,
0.06035361811518669,
-0.47722986340522766,
-0.3275541365146637,
0.6039139032363892,
-0.1621505320072174,
0.41893234848976135,
0.20607328414916992,
-0.18148411810398102,
0.5248515605926514,
-0.5688816905021667,
-0.08000639826059341,
0.03147554397583008,
0.03207772225141525,
-0.0401063933968544,
0.015738792717456818,
0.08458694815635681,
0.0973137766122818,
-0.13936492800712585,
-0.6512700319290161,
-0.277296245098114,
0.1665772944688797,
0.6144004464149475,
0.6853494644165039,
-0.09841329604387283,
0.44317618012428284,
-0.4410686790943146,
0.5033860206604004,
0.22636005282402039,
0.4233447313308716,
-0.4706272780895233,
-0.1993039846420288,
-0.7582113146781921,
-0.7413694858551025,
0.25206243991851807,
0.46935349702835083,
-0.6801436543464661,
0.5206959843635559,
-0.38975411653518677,
-0.4271862506866455,
-0.6306948661804199,
0.45405980944633484,
0.5413188934326172,
0.32175183296203613,
0.40578794479370117,
-0.7564665675163269,
-0.26237520575523376,
-1.2206761837005615,
0.20878061652183533,
0.07555633038282394,
-0.28363147377967834,
0.4851484000682831,
0.46788275241851807,
0.012078292667865753,
0.7230806350708008,
-0.6481447219848633,
-0.8715535402297974,
0.05895327776670456,
0.6157596111297607,
-0.3191295862197876,
0.39261218905448914,
0.35018789768218994,
-0.6852068901062012,
-0.5126102566719055,
-0.21115019917488098,
-0.6872631311416626,
0.041867438703775406,
-0.2599806785583496,
-0.11800550669431686,
0.055292319506406784,
0.48912686109542847,
-0.4251161813735962,
-0.06445874273777008,
0.421032190322876,
0.05197255313396454,
0.6623459458351135,
-0.29205676913261414,
0.35414430499076843,
-0.7510935068130493,
-0.025125950574874878,
0.19489668309688568,
-0.247899129986763,
0.2014712393283844,
-0.014239192940294743,
0.17569874227046967,
-0.09599930047988892,
-0.4227019250392914,
0.2060406655073166,
-0.6508093476295471,
-0.2748604714870453,
0.08217765390872955,
0.5055915713310242,
0.4646318256855011,
0.7026599049568176,
0.07898323237895966,
0.5112134218215942,
0.6707148551940918,
-0.10219109803438187,
0.963956892490387,
0.11011814326047897,
-0.4801650047302246,
0.9564569592475891,
-0.415740042924881,
0.23837688565254211,
-0.37472888827323914,
0.2971065938472748,
-1.1958136558532715,
-0.25642314553260803,
0.1866769641637802,
-0.4567391872406006,
0.22140635550022125,
0.24868130683898926,
-0.4726555347442627,
-0.5781880617141724,
-0.7773320078849792,
0.14776396751403809,
0.302352637052536,
-0.600234866142273,
0.4965013861656189,
0.27484601736068726,
-0.0627351775765419,
-0.6354841589927673,
-0.40125614404678345,
-0.0044575962238013744,
-0.2114972025156021,
-0.36022862792015076,
0.060695987194776535,
-0.00012977633741684258,
0.08009767532348633,
-0.07560578733682632,
0.42040935158729553,
-0.011043199338018894,
-0.2212476283311844,
0.45742613077163696,
0.5410991311073303,
0.07069509476423264,
0.3613451421260834,
-0.15371733903884888,
-0.1488254815340042,
0.14788296818733215,
-0.0664370134472847,
0.2350965440273285,
-0.5755471587181091,
-0.3950292766094208,
-0.8045811653137207,
0.2214406281709671,
0.8266353011131287,
-0.6005957722663879,
0.4084397852420807,
1.1037230491638184,
0.06921686977148056,
-0.029817894101142883,
-0.5189408659934998,
-0.3480970859527588,
-0.35632410645484924,
0.6511366963386536,
-0.24000532925128937,
-0.5743367075920105,
0.4022303819656372,
0.09892095625400543,
-0.16276076436042786,
0.31047767400741577,
0.24990656971931458,
-0.5214865803718567,
1.111559510231018,
0.42926502227783203,
-0.1071905791759491,
0.4546557664871216,
-0.36020180583000183,
-0.10577765107154846,
-0.9208564758300781,
-0.3389938771724701,
-0.11631429940462112,
-0.513003408908844,
-0.5120953917503357,
-0.6087517142295837,
0.43801575899124146,
-0.26105737686157227,
0.004870278760790825,
0.07815013825893402,
-0.3078729212284088,
0.6566365361213684,
0.574360728263855,
0.6056507229804993,
0.21974600851535797,
0.10030948370695114,
0.0754038393497467,
-0.26694706082344055,
-0.42784592509269714,
-0.30583301186561584,
1.1068322658538818,
0.22429315745830536,
0.8184614777565002,
-0.14619596302509308,
0.3891751170158386,
0.51164311170578,
0.8275924921035767,
-0.8047009706497192,
0.3876228332519531,
-0.32212990522384644,
-0.367840051651001,
-0.2612638771533966,
-0.47178366780281067,
-0.7261690497398376,
0.3904222846031189,
-0.6645650863647461,
-0.1779049038887024,
-0.196254700422287,
0.09872536361217499,
-0.5065104365348816,
0.19627153873443604,
-0.6902750134468079,
0.8726069927215576,
-0.5429820418357849,
-0.508507251739502,
-0.45786651968955994,
-0.9879044890403748,
0.28957802057266235,
0.1343175321817398,
0.4961346685886383,
0.011167582124471664,
-0.17337949573993683,
0.8641536235809326,
0.024568870663642883,
0.9845002293586731,
-0.16282808780670166,
0.4084703028202057,
0.19986990094184875,
0.040388837456703186,
0.027012160047888756,
0.16688036918640137,
0.48170170187950134,
0.22732901573181152,
-0.08312176167964935,
-0.41111570596694946,
-0.7295249700546265,
0.5902113318443298,
-1.0064972639083862,
-0.3401247560977936,
-0.23798048496246338,
-0.5647010803222656,
-0.27934154868125916,
-0.09559407085180283,
0.11108442395925522,
0.43824294209480286,
-0.10045088082551956,
0.23292946815490723,
0.263244092464447,
-0.35630926489830017,
0.2670179009437561,
0.5017583966255188,
-0.09928063303232193,
-1.189386248588562,
1.1683918237686157,
-0.32136616110801697,
0.05535471439361572,
0.4576491117477417,
0.2667577862739563,
-0.17992590367794037,
-0.11178479343652725,
-0.6638882160186768,
0.5597041845321655,
-0.6254005432128906,
-0.5345320701599121,
-0.3005319833755493,
0.13078127801418304,
-0.12141354382038116,
-0.31210896372795105,
-0.3438204228878021,
-0.22552433609962463,
-0.17636767029762268,
-0.026481319218873978,
0.009988024830818176,
0.772750735282898,
-0.060948774218559265,
0.2076924592256546,
-0.901216983795166,
0.25728246569633484,
0.4758330285549164,
0.46068844199180603,
-0.020912108942866325,
-0.3717561960220337,
-0.33512455224990845,
-0.31470733880996704,
-0.568899393081665,
-0.8502261638641357,
0.4337245523929596,
0.3669115900993347,
0.36929675936698914,
0.7232736349105835,
0.03787185624241829,
0.5175968408584595,
-0.3008284568786621,
0.7351939082145691,
0.510053813457489,
-0.9412845969200134,
0.44593656063079834,
-0.08338387310504913,
0.0034871220123022795,
0.42011183500289917,
0.4648774266242981,
-0.39117273688316345,
-0.393538236618042,
-0.39221006631851196,
-0.42908287048339844,
0.6375795602798462,
-0.2537885904312134,
0.20286621153354645,
0.20250321924686432,
0.13183996081352234,
0.37720659375190735,
0.44776439666748047,
-0.9563960433006287,
0.30964162945747375,
-0.21593137085437775,
-0.26157140731811523,
-0.29988718032836914,
0.12217569351196289,
-0.3715567886829376,
-0.4490019381046295,
0.3163134753704071,
-0.3358169198036194,
0.10222222656011581,
0.09794449061155319,
-0.3893035054206848,
-0.16805201768875122,
0.12228503823280334,
0.5952157974243164,
0.4440705180168152,
-0.15441226959228516,
0.2749113142490387,
0.1695612519979477,
-0.11316978186368942,
-0.06457695364952087,
-0.1530962735414505,
0.08207369595766068,
-0.13854765892028809,
0.519878089427948,
0.8660805821418762,
0.06305290758609772,
-0.7771105170249939,
0.9994980096817017,
-0.028280191123485565,
-0.1405504047870636,
-0.32997775077819824,
-0.3011094629764557,
-0.3365599811077118,
0.13541215658187866,
0.07673592120409012,
0.34589916467666626,
0.09394558519124985,
-0.4412960112094879,
0.2828800082206726,
0.646243155002594,
-0.7557994723320007,
-0.49940603971481323,
0.5117864012718201,
0.42629072070121765,
0.028564026579260826,
0.6258007287979126,
-0.4601091742515564,
-0.6666478514671326,
0.4108608365058899,
0.07436662167310715,
0.9348716735839844,
0.13029852509498596,
0.5031360983848572,
0.614170253276825,
0.3226265609264374,
0.29166558384895325,
-0.09543289989233017,
-0.3421911895275116,
-0.4871681332588196,
-0.30210351943969727,
-0.5858267545700073,
-0.557103157043457,
-0.18874430656433105,
-0.746715784072876,
0.5033888816833496,
-0.5787191390991211,
-0.14078682661056519,
0.027293173596262932,
-0.24772845208644867,
-0.6544144749641418,
0.07069286704063416,
0.35523802042007446,
0.22541449964046478,
-1.1573008298873901,
0.26750871539115906,
0.8448200821876526,
-0.7700902223587036,
-0.2472287267446518,
-0.18363526463508606,
-0.048148296773433685,
-0.45165374875068665,
0.8969876766204834,
0.36510515213012695,
-0.20036527514457703,
-0.5431075692176819,
-0.7756315469741821,
-0.4753708839416504,
1.1497480869293213,
0.09253647178411484,
-0.29311877489089966,
0.3242557942867279,
-0.0664406567811966,
0.5859083533287048,
-0.7614965438842773,
0.3989526927471161,
0.10740473121404648,
0.29783791303634644,
-0.10768807679414749,
-0.6743019819259644,
-0.058420706540346146,
-0.20502018928527832,
-0.08129638433456421,
-0.1981864720582962,
-1.0256390571594238,
0.6550168395042419,
-0.7313668131828308,
0.06256909668445587,
0.09572844952344894,
0.7090118527412415,
0.04576174542307854,
0.28567108511924744,
0.8486460447311401,
0.44929230213165283,
0.40571698546409607,
-0.10376810282468796,
0.8737943172454834,
0.0012777285883203149,
0.3649347722530365,
0.8544101715087891,
-0.04184979572892189,
0.9905043244361877,
0.4905713200569153,
-0.33737483620643616,
0.8642106652259827,
0.4112929701805115,
-0.40075331926345825,
0.6917977929115295,
0.26925352215766907,
0.019984310492873192,
-0.4819520115852356,
0.16239556670188904,
0.255955308675766,
0.6041744351387024,
0.2185581475496292,
-0.5523383617401123,
0.1313171684741974,
0.36399126052856445,
-0.30234643816947937,
0.06483189761638641,
0.04891955852508545,
0.9095315933227539,
-0.09365414828062057,
-0.7212048172950745,
0.19514332711696625,
-0.06311888247728348,
0.7399343848228455,
-0.29686084389686584,
-0.10392185300588608,
-0.08637403696775436,
0.2265927791595459,
-0.2015819400548935,
-0.7642888426780701,
0.09931079298257828,
-0.20090754330158234,
-0.33797961473464966,
0.024698300287127495,
0.07508912682533264,
-0.4910115897655487,
-0.45471397042274475,
0.20624315738677979,
0.17487381398677826,
0.09879812598228455,
0.11797039955854416,
-0.5282098650932312,
-0.09352511912584305,
-0.19196422398090363,
0.08546555042266846,
0.08393070846796036,
0.245194673538208,
-0.16651634871959686,
0.5676438212394714,
0.5533240437507629,
0.04177597910165787,
-0.09700606018304825,
0.2400532364845276,
0.7009947896003723,
-0.5657274127006531,
-0.5432122945785522,
-0.5299449563026428,
0.458762526512146,
-0.3489362895488739,
-0.20014910399913788,
0.49412885308265686,
0.5867666006088257,
0.770882248878479,
-0.5605126023292542,
0.672672688961029,
0.18824997544288635,
0.4948435127735138,
-0.32217422127723694,
0.6631494164466858,
-0.6173254251480103,
0.07609609514474869,
-0.328400582075119,
-0.9368141293525696,
-0.5277273058891296,
0.6576616168022156,
-0.389364093542099,
-0.19054462015628815,
0.7634690999984741,
0.9071004986763,
0.0812673568725586,
-0.10195821523666382,
0.17965486645698547,
-0.03554873540997505,
0.18789701163768768,
0.3306162655353546,
1.0630451440811157,
-0.34168168902397156,
0.7712346315383911,
-0.5342121720314026,
-0.5004751682281494,
-0.09401809424161911,
-0.6887139678001404,
-0.8189122080802917,
-0.7288889288902283,
-0.49468567967414856,
-0.025716155767440796,
-0.08179687708616257,
0.817652702331543,
0.8367742300033569,
-1.068899393081665,
-0.26699867844581604,
0.47459733486175537,
-0.01216359343379736,
-0.43857693672180176,
-0.25875329971313477,
0.44900718331336975,
-0.6865097880363464,
-0.8260543942451477,
-0.2218480408191681,
0.4497063457965851,
-0.2774182856082916,
-0.648012638092041,
-0.25613081455230713,
0.20697417855262756,
-0.13584867119789124,
0.6982064247131348,
-0.08440978825092316,
-0.7931913733482361,
-0.21881206333637238,
0.06380999088287354,
-0.19799618422985077,
0.11324332654476166,
0.8148342370986938,
-0.5796680450439453,
0.8643818497657776,
0.3968898355960846,
0.2811950147151947,
0.3557783365249634,
0.07373020797967911,
0.3691287636756897,
-0.8269961476325989,
0.19935059547424316,
-0.01776755228638649,
0.4641576409339905,
0.8072602152824402,
0.12368462234735489,
0.2450958490371704,
0.6065858602523804,
-0.3979282081127167,
-0.44679245352745056,
-0.048343148082494736,
-1.144020676612854,
-0.0072463927790522575,
0.8493269085884094,
-0.32676222920417786,
-0.25122347474098206,
0.3246823847293854,
-0.5947656631469727,
-0.028870820999145508,
-0.34237179160118103,
1.1642098426818848,
0.6694439053535461,
-0.12519043684005737,
-0.36835068464279175,
-0.1045927032828331,
0.2459193617105484,
0.5535824298858643,
-0.6828749179840088,
-0.05429951101541519,
0.7995157241821289,
0.3422242999076843,
0.5432271957397461,
0.1463954895734787,
-0.4855586588382721,
0.43253186345100403,
-0.05814746394753456,
0.31458649039268494,
-0.08714759349822998,
-0.459585964679718,
-0.26471027731895447,
0.29313963651657104,
-0.04516855254769325,
-0.5191501379013062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18061v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18061v2
|
On the use of Silver Standard Data for Zero-shot Classification Tasks in Information Extraction
| 2024-02-28T05:45:37 | 2024-03-06T08:42:24 |
Jianwei Wang, Tianyin Wang, Ziqian Zeng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The superior performance of supervised classification methods in the
information extraction (IE) area heavily relies on a large amount of gold
standard data. Recent zero-shot classification methods converted the task to
other NLP tasks (e.g., textual entailment) and used off-the-shelf models of
these NLP tasks to directly perform inference on the test data without using a
large amount of IE annotation data. A potentially valuable by-product of these
methods is the large-scale silver standard data, i.e., pseudo-labeled data by
the off-the-shelf models of other NLP tasks. However, there is no further
investigation into the use of these data. In this paper, we propose a new
framework, Clean-LaVe, which aims to utilize silver standard data to enhance
the zero-shot performance. Clean-LaVe includes four phases: (1) Obtaining
silver data; (2) Identifying relatively clean data from silver data; (3)
Finetuning the off-the-shelf model using clean data; (4) Inference on the test
data. The experimental results show that Clean-LaVe can outperform the baseline
by 5% and 6% on TACRED and Wiki80 dataset in the zero-shot relation
classification task, and by 3%-7% on Smile (Korean and Polish) in the zero-shot
cross-lingual relation classification task, and by 8% on ACE05-E+ in the
zero-shot event argument classification task. The code is share in
https://github.com/wjw136/Clean_LaVe.git.
|
[
-0.10752363502979279,
-0.5841169357299805,
0.26342254877090454,
-0.7194003462791443,
-0.13705947995185852,
-0.26922017335891724,
0.07838884741067886,
-0.49617111682891846,
-0.03795275092124939,
0.5233197212219238,
-0.16478762030601501,
-0.8280474543571472,
-0.4339916706085205,
-0.02796120196580887,
-0.44538840651512146,
1.3113856315612793,
-0.03349412605166435,
-0.32898110151290894,
-0.021248389035463333,
-0.07993116229772568,
-0.38410714268684387,
-0.3885650634765625,
-0.3904210329055786,
-0.20145678520202637,
0.39304909110069275,
0.6015579700469971,
0.5183601975440979,
0.7752964496612549,
0.2794990539550781,
0.1874813586473465,
0.019934620708227158,
0.20427754521369934,
-0.7511094212532043,
0.045170221477746964,
-0.35624873638153076,
-0.7259727716445923,
-0.47836992144584656,
0.35939785838127136,
0.40709418058395386,
0.599408745765686,
-0.08550183475017548,
0.5265597701072693,
-0.1856750100851059,
0.36332547664642334,
-1.3287553787231445,
0.369579017162323,
-0.6691043972969055,
0.2975108325481415,
-0.4548932611942291,
-0.2912014424800873,
-0.5220935940742493,
0.01385270431637764,
-0.27461016178131104,
-0.7399741411209106,
0.1926271617412567,
-0.3010297119617462,
1.3952573537826538,
0.1612730175256729,
-0.2083909511566162,
0.051460735499858856,
-0.8436803221702576,
0.9296183586120605,
-0.8072803020477295,
0.30626174807548523,
0.5233011245727539,
0.22471095621585846,
0.07305005192756653,
-0.8948966860771179,
-0.5507009029388428,
0.10874493420124054,
0.05066894739866257,
0.38743436336517334,
-0.44585394859313965,
-0.1325986385345459,
0.41988036036491394,
0.17294098436832428,
-0.6144363284111023,
0.10797084867954254,
-0.7899587750434875,
0.012778030708432198,
0.6846631765365601,
-0.15633507072925568,
0.052890531718730927,
-0.034491948783397675,
-0.27209800481796265,
-0.07293783128261566,
-0.6064876914024353,
0.16780468821525574,
0.13147221505641937,
0.5136813521385193,
0.17573319375514984,
0.5660821199417114,
-0.5873207449913025,
0.7973901033401489,
0.18161314725875854,
-0.4385411739349365,
0.6816478967666626,
-0.16618892550468445,
-0.6534104943275452,
0.19785012304782867,
0.6556462049484253,
0.40267905592918396,
0.40519288182258606,
-0.45795413851737976,
-0.15931007266044617,
0.12234162539243698,
0.03330641984939575,
-0.7749131321907043,
-0.08171699196100235,
0.11766881495714188,
-0.35269930958747864,
-0.15237334370613098,
0.24977947771549225,
-0.5821120142936707,
-0.273863285779953,
-0.33954471349716187,
0.582817792892456,
-0.14613842964172363,
-0.1606423705816269,
0.4229879379272461,
-0.2900906801223755,
0.28090164065361023,
0.6077833771705627,
-0.4996452331542969,
0.29164090752601624,
0.5936117768287659,
0.800862193107605,
0.004981081001460552,
0.20109982788562775,
-0.9220918416976929,
0.24857842922210693,
-0.4209080934524536,
0.7991902232170105,
-0.33105751872062683,
-0.24298514425754547,
-0.25098368525505066,
0.008404122665524483,
-0.08855832368135452,
-0.6803305149078369,
0.7226468324661255,
-0.39275234937667847,
0.3122412860393524,
-0.008781214244663715,
-0.5183873772621155,
-0.3338378071784973,
0.4169764518737793,
-0.5592340230941772,
0.8647980093955994,
0.1552441567182541,
-0.9182004332542419,
0.44802147150039673,
-0.6014617085456848,
-0.1096494123339653,
0.4352121651172638,
-0.16237513720989227,
-0.16671429574489594,
0.02924066223204136,
-0.014466224238276482,
0.4796277582645416,
0.025088010355830193,
0.008781583048403263,
-0.4475193917751312,
-0.7447716593742371,
-0.18157969415187836,
-0.21736441552639008,
0.8730071187019348,
0.4398058354854584,
-0.4295531213283539,
-0.4344114065170288,
-0.9022900462150574,
0.11739785224199295,
0.04230881109833717,
-0.06459838896989822,
-0.5246070623397827,
-0.3187776803970337,
-0.270088791847229,
0.3376920819282532,
0.20667123794555664,
-0.7637160420417786,
0.0628119483590126,
-0.45273444056510925,
-0.21851009130477905,
0.4802093803882599,
0.04113032668828964,
0.6319262385368347,
-0.21636514365673065,
0.5578765273094177,
0.023702872917056084,
0.12014083564281464,
-0.2707947790622711,
-0.29256051778793335,
-0.7613700032234192,
-0.4886195957660675,
0.7574709057807922,
1.0181792974472046,
-0.6122463941574097,
0.4938209056854248,
-0.16761574149131775,
-0.5974875688552856,
-0.902394711971283,
0.22379997372627258,
0.3413991630077362,
0.9039676189422607,
0.3776276409626007,
-0.3162980377674103,
-0.286343514919281,
-0.9888452887535095,
-0.04391054809093475,
-0.04773852601647377,
-0.07002506405115128,
0.013448204845190048,
0.515304684638977,
0.012125116772949696,
1.090640902519226,
-0.597846508026123,
-0.4443848431110382,
0.060812365263700485,
0.4755578637123108,
0.21715742349624634,
0.17876556515693665,
0.3422834277153015,
-0.6870970129966736,
-0.42336180806159973,
0.2675812542438507,
-1.086974024772644,
-0.32278865575790405,
-0.13193422555923462,
-0.01471716072410345,
0.024439984932541847,
0.5069116950035095,
-0.38917481899261475,
0.7782392501831055,
0.05668255314230919,
-0.18279793858528137,
0.3219025433063507,
-0.04355781525373459,
0.15498386323451996,
-0.6966853141784668,
0.490214079618454,
0.2836957275867462,
-0.47103583812713623,
-1.085258960723877,
0.22376537322998047,
0.09495231509208679,
0.13151998817920685,
-0.9629524946212769,
0.7212337255477905,
-0.2680138349533081,
0.09045779705047607,
-0.23746855556964874,
0.24804016947746277,
0.28006574511528015,
0.12041406333446503,
-0.009666846133768559,
0.5189148187637329,
0.29216432571411133,
-0.3205461800098419,
0.03228157386183739,
0.1294567584991455,
-0.05122850835323334,
0.5901375412940979,
-0.49604666233062744,
0.08006353676319122,
-0.43103864789009094,
0.027463972568511963,
-0.5437144041061401,
0.087737075984478,
0.22928845882415771,
-0.434128999710083,
0.588372528553009,
-0.13653351366519928,
-0.8062960505485535,
0.14124208688735962,
-0.49223512411117554,
0.006961036939173937,
0.6647996306419373,
-0.2019907683134079,
0.23419155180454254,
0.4653797745704651,
-0.11506494879722595,
-0.7346485257148743,
-0.5548668503761292,
0.11270628869533539,
-0.36742740869522095,
-0.48813584446907043,
0.19171197712421417,
0.21802504360675812,
-0.41672760248184204,
-0.0033244492951780558,
-0.2874767482280731,
-0.07747942954301834,
0.21919512748718262,
0.26482295989990234,
0.4285160005092621,
0.14728344976902008,
0.02939804457128048,
-0.23145565390586853,
-0.27677208185195923,
-0.466799259185791,
0.22498451173305511,
0.29099807143211365,
-0.14269094169139862,
-0.18217772245407104,
-0.7025419473648071,
0.19650322198867798,
0.1390206515789032,
-0.3167415261268616,
0.6586909890174866,
0.7075409293174744,
-0.4166405200958252,
-0.21145454049110413,
-0.3182186186313629,
0.07561188191175461,
-0.38733983039855957,
0.14129962027072906,
-0.1693735122680664,
-0.6523193717002869,
0.4366132915019989,
-0.13034303486347198,
0.5100403428077698,
0.6140012741088867,
0.12464471906423569,
-0.37251073122024536,
0.9928554892539978,
0.45477721095085144,
0.06446634232997894,
0.3009966015815735,
-0.5640524625778198,
0.25298789143562317,
-0.5185168385505676,
-0.2657092213630676,
-0.6506341695785522,
-0.23254747688770294,
-0.26897168159484863,
-0.09994900971651077,
0.07642907649278641,
0.5576332807540894,
-0.2054114192724228,
0.13273143768310547,
-0.32242435216903687,
0.39649704098701477,
0.520706832408905,
-0.21808290481567383,
0.27967581152915955,
-0.01882294751703739,
0.33491116762161255,
0.03164156898856163,
-0.48135098814964294,
-0.6683260798454285,
1.070686936378479,
0.20489579439163208,
0.6819203495979309,
-0.2832779586315155,
1.2747602462768555,
0.29545512795448303,
0.05708206072449684,
-0.7750527262687683,
0.5494738817214966,
-0.594914436340332,
-0.5682370662689209,
0.15096573531627655,
-0.35155627131462097,
-1.0718843936920166,
0.12061520665884018,
-0.39750033617019653,
-0.9432971477508545,
0.17121893167495728,
-0.07109326124191284,
-0.47185981273651123,
0.18894736468791962,
-0.9027569890022278,
0.6743152737617493,
-0.08832642436027527,
-0.24803012609481812,
0.4771452844142914,
-0.6509583592414856,
0.40921974182128906,
-0.31262868642807007,
0.5233675837516785,
-0.10268894582986832,
0.044569190591573715,
0.9411717653274536,
-0.06355390697717667,
0.7099810242652893,
-0.41182616353034973,
0.026976725086569786,
0.3524962365627289,
0.06601948291063309,
0.4639461636543274,
-0.2856483459472656,
-0.13088642060756683,
0.2502955198287964,
0.2792101204395294,
-0.1725473552942276,
-0.5765756964683533,
0.5160024166107178,
-0.631436288356781,
-0.26404350996017456,
-0.6771336197853088,
-0.6626590490341187,
0.013697156682610512,
0.4178335666656494,
0.06238478049635887,
0.18302258849143982,
0.24295148253440857,
0.3957832455635071,
0.5956578254699707,
0.09266544878482819,
0.47954902052879333,
0.5567111372947693,
0.038566555827856064,
-0.1542021781206131,
0.8970208764076233,
0.5618319511413574,
0.23797321319580078,
0.10795614868402481,
-0.07814434915781021,
-0.22585533559322357,
-0.6955004930496216,
-0.09285768121480942,
0.242822527885437,
-0.8219799399375916,
-0.4586106538772583,
-0.4961288273334503,
-0.3556712865829468,
-0.409355103969574,
-0.21984679996967316,
-0.29293185472488403,
-0.6861334443092346,
-0.756833553314209,
-0.1687910407781601,
-0.06138215586543083,
0.3616635501384735,
-0.1451607048511505,
0.3031560182571411,
-1.0828689336776733,
0.4693700969219208,
-0.2167833000421524,
-0.024414006620645523,
-0.46780386567115784,
-0.4798782765865326,
-0.2393755167722702,
0.04769159108400345,
-0.3244040906429291,
-0.7765333652496338,
0.443222314119339,
0.2911597788333893,
0.767246425151825,
0.6956825256347656,
0.3870076537132263,
0.9223292469978333,
-0.2582665979862213,
0.8748632073402405,
0.24659813940525055,
-0.6130104660987854,
0.46923255920410156,
-0.24747894704341888,
0.41780954599380493,
0.9970045685768127,
0.37980207800865173,
-0.4142323434352875,
-0.4051465392112732,
-1.0626565217971802,
-0.8684857487678528,
0.7322555184364319,
0.18451222777366638,
-0.259988009929657,
0.03657504543662071,
0.6104102730751038,
0.26681092381477356,
0.2622365355491638,
-0.6442300081253052,
-0.19680769741535187,
0.05033012107014656,
-0.28889909386634827,
-0.09721022099256516,
0.17779043316841125,
-0.2108353227376938,
0.05633564293384552,
0.7024717330932617,
-0.08548039942979813,
-0.16666185855865479,
0.0777263194322586,
-0.19595485925674438,
0.06836424767971039,
0.3922046422958374,
0.181364506483078,
0.6382055878639221,
-0.46889281272888184,
0.17329442501068115,
0.1565527617931366,
-0.3604741394519806,
-0.11705939471721649,
0.23821456730365753,
-0.8460833430290222,
0.08115454018115997,
0.33920758962631226,
0.4351891577243805,
-0.12738536298274994,
-0.7214330434799194,
0.5251145958900452,
0.03516574203968048,
-0.5344811081886292,
0.008496306836605072,
0.4620133936405182,
-0.23403963446617126,
0.21320182085037231,
0.24650654196739197,
0.013223719783127308,
0.4550095200538635,
-0.6221659779548645,
0.361223965883255,
0.519852340221405,
-0.37928110361099243,
-0.26086747646331787,
0.35068169236183167,
-0.17660905420780182,
-0.04667545109987259,
0.45280829071998596,
-0.6190481185913086,
0.06693223118782043,
0.29151806235313416,
0.5392325520515442,
0.5351922512054443,
0.03796515241265297,
0.46765217185020447,
0.41692304611206055,
-0.06544578075408936,
-0.2374219000339508,
0.49517983198165894,
0.00017291157564613968,
-0.4467874765396118,
-0.6191021800041199,
-0.788665235042572,
-0.04849500581622124,
0.4210830330848694,
-0.8376335501670837,
0.5156140327453613,
-0.354043573141098,
-0.31550708413124084,
0.19548943638801575,
0.25240233540534973,
-0.5974816679954529,
0.4190232753753662,
0.4616971015930176,
1.0447969436645508,
-0.9262703061103821,
0.6081546545028687,
0.45207756757736206,
-0.3322998881340027,
-0.6035276651382446,
-0.5538820028305054,
0.2831040024757385,
-0.5843589305877686,
0.8221390843391418,
0.201027512550354,
-0.04511411488056183,
-0.1495818793773651,
-0.5369933843612671,
-0.6655958890914917,
1.2212402820587158,
0.4214727580547333,
-0.44679906964302063,
-0.2853820025920868,
-0.11889283359050751,
0.3818638026714325,
-0.30397912859916687,
0.09726078063249588,
0.6137320399284363,
0.3321157693862915,
0.5308976173400879,
-1.0972919464111328,
-0.28459253907203674,
-0.4094868302345276,
-0.42355069518089294,
0.4013776183128357,
-0.2274806797504425,
0.7384984493255615,
-0.006375609431415796,
-0.5492755770683289,
-0.1946055144071579,
0.27972185611724854,
0.3348008394241333,
0.5308799147605896,
0.48439285159111023,
0.9734743237495422,
0.9524937272071838,
-0.020370909944176674,
0.5723176598548889,
0.1965724676847458,
0.4644816517829895,
1.2799705266952515,
-0.638864278793335,
1.1211493015289307,
0.3401433825492859,
0.022628234699368477,
0.3169300854206085,
0.47380343079566956,
-0.31722646951675415,
0.7514991164207458,
-0.0007413094863295555,
-0.22978688776493073,
0.002422702731564641,
-0.31608131527900696,
-0.17953988909721375,
1.025278925895691,
0.2606459856033325,
-0.12210115045309067,
-0.82549649477005,
-0.12203044444322586,
0.46848064661026,
-0.24247018992900848,
-0.7043694257736206,
0.9238818883895874,
-0.21692493557929993,
-0.43960312008857727,
0.48194628953933716,
0.001218843157403171,
0.6441341042518616,
-0.61668860912323,
-0.2764582335948944,
0.11434052884578705,
0.292315274477005,
-0.5318880081176758,
-0.7239686846733093,
0.3149298429489136,
0.22118225693702698,
0.14501997828483582,
-0.23981155455112457,
1.0086956024169922,
-0.31572309136390686,
-0.37721773982048035,
-0.05874048173427582,
0.5202845335006714,
0.49596136808395386,
0.10569220036268234,
-0.6595933437347412,
-0.3677721619606018,
0.07216254621744156,
-0.10634266585111618,
0.5673630833625793,
0.17011652886867523,
-0.15014423429965973,
0.2060091197490692,
0.8104501366615295,
0.4956442713737488,
0.07807382196187973,
0.01768353208899498,
0.5583409070968628,
-0.5212411880493164,
-0.38335198163986206,
-0.6352275609970093,
0.863974928855896,
-0.34969955682754517,
0.10288158059120178,
0.8363178968429565,
0.7251137495040894,
0.8737093806266785,
0.3620128929615021,
0.7691298127174377,
-0.012966372072696686,
0.5580627918243408,
-0.2685076594352722,
0.5880663990974426,
-0.6315757632255554,
-0.15507112443447113,
0.056288283318281174,
-0.7345055937767029,
-0.558402419090271,
0.618962287902832,
-0.1752738356590271,
-0.022802457213401794,
0.4492225646972656,
0.5485966801643372,
-0.11502370238304138,
0.025759978219866753,
0.3961750864982605,
-0.056105051189661026,
0.5495352149009705,
0.3108883202075958,
0.26486217975616455,
-0.5229721069335938,
0.4241318106651306,
-0.26249146461486816,
-0.5271245837211609,
-0.018602410331368446,
-0.9189435839653015,
-0.5797104239463806,
-0.3262260854244232,
-0.43735626339912415,
-0.23619908094406128,
-0.13746188580989838,
0.557112455368042,
0.7136682868003845,
-0.6262720823287964,
0.01042687613517046,
0.2423783838748932,
-0.5059729218482971,
-0.05567380040884018,
-0.25739532709121704,
0.35182031989097595,
-0.4676862955093384,
-0.619784414768219,
0.28849124908447266,
0.4101254642009735,
0.0871354192495346,
0.2560274004936218,
0.19420751929283142,
-0.5139399766921997,
-0.08447083085775375,
0.45766618847846985,
0.6064708232879639,
-0.4146239459514618,
-0.2603401243686676,
0.2174219787120819,
0.20113366842269897,
0.0592360720038414,
0.2196502536535263,
-0.9556780457496643,
0.7507491111755371,
0.45179128646850586,
0.32894983887672424,
0.8285863399505615,
0.13744968175888062,
0.23371854424476624,
-0.8456153273582458,
0.09998863190412521,
0.2858133018016815,
0.3672683537006378,
0.148565873503685,
-0.2476191371679306,
0.5859824419021606,
-0.007621813099831343,
-0.463406503200531,
-0.9720066785812378,
-0.05952005833387375,
-1.1610609292984009,
-0.3122081458568573,
1.30687415599823,
-0.3798668682575226,
-0.32684123516082764,
-0.24886207282543182,
-0.15905733406543732,
0.45698773860931396,
-0.34390851855278015,
0.5088891386985779,
0.4729662537574768,
-0.3775099217891693,
-0.272824227809906,
-0.9647389650344849,
0.22932182252407074,
-0.2315433770418167,
-1.0200525522232056,
-0.008254497312009335,
0.4639728367328644,
0.3189263343811035,
0.5787351727485657,
0.7611968517303467,
-0.31190288066864014,
0.2838796079158783,
-0.15750230848789215,
0.0676809698343277,
-0.4214690327644348,
-0.4020231068134308,
-0.2962142527103424,
0.5635964274406433,
-0.24600191414356232,
-0.31615111231803894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18060v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18060v4
|
Benchmarking Large Language Models on Answering and Explaining Challenging Medical Questions
| 2024-02-28T05:44:41 | 2024-06-25T21:17:09 |
Hanjie Chen, Zhouxiang Fang, Yash Singla, Mark Dredze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
LLMs have demonstrated impressive performance in answering medical questions,
such as achieving passing scores on medical licensing examinations. However,
medical board exam or general clinical questions do not capture the complexity
of realistic clinical cases. Moreover, the lack of reference explanations means
we cannot easily evaluate the reasoning of model decisions, a crucial component
of supporting doctors in making complex medical decisions. To address these
challenges, we construct two new datasets: JAMA Clinical Challenge and
Medbullets. JAMA Clinical Challenge consists of questions based on challenging
clinical cases, while Medbullets comprises simulated clinical questions. Both
datasets are structured as multiple-choice question-answering tasks,
accompanied by expert-written explanations. We evaluate seven LLMs on the two
datasets using various prompts. Experiments demonstrate that our datasets are
harder than previous benchmarks. Human and automatic evaluations of
model-generated explanations provide insights into the promise and deficiency
of LLMs for explainable medical QA.
|
[
-0.09109125286340714,
-0.7473164796829224,
1.1320862770080566,
-0.08804688602685928,
-0.09736797958612442,
0.018938422203063965,
-0.21377959847450256,
-0.2860439419746399,
-0.21001170575618744,
0.5326471328735352,
-0.803011953830719,
-0.4636598229408264,
-0.579177737236023,
0.44379013776779175,
0.08010029792785645,
0.8819461464881897,
-0.2909863293170929,
0.5218343734741211,
-0.7188554406166077,
-0.2800355553627014,
-0.7913394570350647,
-0.3960692286491394,
-0.6192270517349243,
-0.4840886890888214,
0.5992839932441711,
0.18654952943325043,
0.7808087468147278,
0.5462161898612976,
0.8444860577583313,
0.28093039989471436,
-0.09977679699659348,
0.20059490203857422,
-0.4080788791179657,
0.20119892060756683,
-0.3171887993812561,
-0.7357348203659058,
-0.07813066244125366,
-0.1480848640203476,
0.33892378211021423,
1.1788369417190552,
-0.1598661094903946,
0.15575046837329865,
-0.42868533730506897,
0.5630538463592529,
-0.3804498612880707,
0.0511336512863636,
-0.5986390113830566,
-0.06270661950111389,
-0.023399224504828453,
-0.24999728798866272,
-0.3816806972026825,
-0.4877438247203827,
-0.011668580584228039,
-0.5156847834587097,
0.2273479700088501,
0.011387920007109642,
0.8979577422142029,
0.2927575707435608,
-0.7157646417617798,
-0.5481355786323547,
-0.6175983548164368,
0.5768606066703796,
-0.49107223749160767,
0.25532931089401245,
0.21237264573574066,
0.6657155752182007,
-0.34668034315109253,
-0.6782209277153015,
-0.24223828315734863,
-0.21972528100013733,
-0.09669515490531921,
0.13003520667552948,
-0.20350468158721924,
0.04287979006767273,
0.37018483877182007,
0.281765878200531,
-0.8666898012161255,
0.2438330054283142,
-0.6064206957817078,
-0.07755039632320404,
0.5954487323760986,
0.6750692129135132,
0.16025201976299286,
-0.06636448949575424,
-0.19218476116657257,
-0.06323740631341934,
-0.9515279531478882,
0.16066773235797882,
-0.279488205909729,
-0.06035645306110382,
0.024951105937361717,
0.5442115664482117,
0.0004219500406179577,
0.7631021738052368,
-0.22382457554340363,
-0.22634607553482056,
0.20146825909614563,
-0.17002534866333008,
-0.2669375538825989,
-0.3371736407279968,
0.7247778177261353,
0.5820898413658142,
0.1968390792608261,
-0.08063209056854248,
0.06678114831447601,
0.09708132594823837,
0.26608312129974365,
-0.6882646679878235,
-0.010660581290721893,
0.6528224945068359,
-0.5879396796226501,
-0.14635446667671204,
-0.25508326292037964,
-0.6497205495834351,
-0.6203216910362244,
-0.059846632182598114,
0.49434375762939453,
-0.14085230231285095,
0.1615225374698639,
0.4137328863143921,
-0.11866050958633423,
0.1986486315727234,
0.5091670155525208,
-0.5186434388160706,
0.40580376982688904,
0.5182790756225586,
0.5117457509040833,
-0.21145741641521454,
0.11033540219068527,
-0.2662203311920166,
-0.04507637023925781,
-0.48332804441452026,
0.95010906457901,
-0.5671850442886353,
-0.38223713636398315,
-0.08756769448518753,
0.16904930770397186,
-0.09476234763860703,
-1.15445876121521,
0.4617201089859009,
-0.21568278968334198,
0.3071900010108948,
-0.5047568082809448,
-0.7149925827980042,
-0.286030113697052,
0.269284188747406,
-0.2751309871673584,
0.7076842784881592,
0.16061799228191376,
-0.32381561398506165,
0.2147943526506424,
-0.4249664545059204,
-0.1284792721271515,
0.09919428080320358,
-0.5825109481811523,
-0.39035460352897644,
0.3327179551124573,
0.4454081356525421,
0.6219573616981506,
-0.8850297331809998,
0.5533367395401001,
-0.42625531554222107,
-0.2373354732990265,
0.5634742379188538,
-0.3105487525463104,
0.716990053653717,
0.34246572852134705,
0.09672512114048004,
-0.11730057746171951,
-0.6756099462509155,
0.049140121787786484,
0.5037994384765625,
-0.17516827583312988,
-0.06355753540992737,
0.04107533022761345,
-0.40930742025375366,
0.19465214014053345,
-0.03756155073642731,
-0.3418920338153839,
0.19996270537376404,
0.002760722069069743,
0.3420555591583252,
0.4657842218875885,
0.2216869741678238,
-0.3544892370700836,
-0.763632595539093,
0.8909549117088318,
0.014655997976660728,
0.24530744552612305,
-0.42219242453575134,
-0.62656170129776,
-0.33865049481391907,
-0.14804713428020477,
0.10630769282579422,
0.5099765658378601,
-0.4721207320690155,
-0.2448137104511261,
-0.3457769453525543,
-0.5056383013725281,
-0.8400130271911621,
0.06010281667113304,
0.4489166736602783,
0.761300265789032,
0.4315807819366455,
-0.2223118394613266,
-0.3246619999408722,
-1.050031065940857,
-0.4234393835067749,
-0.19880211353302002,
-0.37408411502838135,
0.7079463005065918,
0.5472656488418579,
-0.10083116590976715,
0.4940219521522522,
-0.4972037672996521,
0.08350342512130737,
-0.12774431705474854,
-0.001838132506236434,
0.4337124526500702,
0.12655755877494812,
0.38277047872543335,
-0.6496323943138123,
-0.09058557450771332,
-0.14460822939872742,
-0.9437323212623596,
-0.5137028098106384,
-0.29902544617652893,
0.2709110677242279,
-0.39304304122924805,
0.6065517067909241,
-0.5155654549598694,
0.15390326082706451,
0.4470064640045166,
-0.2817162573337555,
0.7402384281158447,
-0.2319563329219818,
0.19349850714206696,
-0.7102048397064209,
0.04141698032617569,
-0.2675776779651642,
-0.3478940725326538,
-0.5270496606826782,
0.13703466951847076,
0.015964267775416374,
-0.20221498608589172,
-0.48481476306915283,
0.5675786733627319,
-0.44823259115219116,
-0.06757466495037079,
-0.01722077466547489,
0.19170226156711578,
0.2277790606021881,
0.1710738092660904,
-0.2461494505405426,
0.6788766384124756,
0.3833428919315338,
-0.40321457386016846,
0.47705405950546265,
0.2828752100467682,
-0.3437286913394928,
0.5327403545379639,
-0.9254819750785828,
0.03304820507764816,
-0.28960898518562317,
0.27239155769348145,
-1.0947498083114624,
-0.2964966297149658,
-0.10223585367202759,
-0.33095139265060425,
0.09289614111185074,
-0.1382862627506256,
-0.35560867190361023,
-0.7314475774765015,
-0.021517587825655937,
0.38052815198898315,
0.6172410845756531,
-0.2700657546520233,
0.42056477069854736,
0.19556975364685059,
-0.3522239029407501,
-0.291273832321167,
-0.483975887298584,
0.03377813100814819,
-0.2123139202594757,
-0.3631860911846161,
0.20575329661369324,
-0.2912580370903015,
-0.4473680257797241,
-0.09403020143508911,
-0.1337246149778366,
-0.1244286447763443,
0.18552842736244202,
0.48701736330986023,
0.3148617744445801,
-0.3446718454360962,
0.3779851794242859,
-0.09304025024175644,
-0.04764654114842415,
0.4573378264904022,
0.3790597915649414,
0.25149795413017273,
0.0032741338945925236,
-0.6167725920677185,
-0.4205786883831024,
0.4317854046821594,
0.6457312107086182,
0.04795928671956062,
0.5184601545333862,
0.0693025141954422,
-0.3848719894886017,
0.09897278249263763,
-0.801628053188324,
-0.19406965374946594,
-0.3941447138786316,
0.37200742959976196,
-0.5245649218559265,
-0.7852942943572998,
0.6290261745452881,
-0.2055637240409851,
0.16322295367717743,
0.4004278779029846,
1.052559733390808,
-0.20029176771640778,
1.2874513864517212,
-0.1533835232257843,
0.3112187385559082,
-0.3734634220600128,
0.18857719004154205,
-0.10863164812326431,
-0.42600521445274353,
-0.3885596692562103,
-0.591251015663147,
-0.12203187495470047,
-0.3878607451915741,
-0.6543394923210144,
0.6544041037559509,
0.015561937354505062,
-0.03588539734482765,
-0.17832912504673004,
-0.32308924198150635,
0.6458699703216553,
0.20574799180030823,
0.22602634131908417,
0.36136966943740845,
-0.3940502107143402,
-0.33020541071891785,
-0.026516925543546677,
-0.7647939920425415,
-0.5383362770080566,
1.3123493194580078,
0.5708193778991699,
0.7914468050003052,
-0.01307462528347969,
0.442333847284317,
-0.0768616646528244,
0.42909178137779236,
-0.5406893491744995,
0.4075912535190582,
-0.1216617226600647,
-1.0041234493255615,
0.05277498438954353,
-0.462431401014328,
-1.0569067001342773,
0.42409849166870117,
-0.2875271141529083,
-0.48003578186035156,
-0.19547972083091736,
0.091965451836586,
-0.6243628263473511,
-0.02865292876958847,
-0.6510342359542847,
0.7848342061042786,
-0.17059120535850525,
-0.22846250236034393,
0.023824555799365044,
-0.749862790107727,
0.436308354139328,
-0.018334221094846725,
0.4974190592765808,
-0.3368360698223114,
-0.0841364711523056,
0.5924315452575684,
-0.5058149695396423,
0.6585047841072083,
0.011817624792456627,
0.03202094882726669,
0.124000184237957,
0.1679057478904724,
0.21568749845027924,
0.20993702113628387,
-0.1483151912689209,
-0.09272147715091705,
0.3345048129558563,
-0.5665462613105774,
-0.7743314504623413,
0.48194828629493713,
-0.5059925317764282,
-0.7988556623458862,
-0.17419926822185516,
-0.6857588887214661,
-0.5920286774635315,
-0.06892178952693939,
0.06765910983085632,
0.5433221459388733,
-0.05326724797487259,
0.16172897815704346,
0.5619916915893555,
-0.520500659942627,
-0.17454706132411957,
0.7397929430007935,
-0.3208049535751343,
-0.17578758299350739,
0.3900868892669678,
-0.04151461645960808,
0.32508477568626404,
0.29306095838546753,
0.3614351153373718,
-0.29671671986579895,
-0.9266924262046814,
-0.5240868330001831,
0.5673447847366333,
-0.8472375869750977,
-0.13233906030654907,
-0.5257479548454285,
-0.0036183870397508144,
-0.1405116319656372,
-0.1295081079006195,
-0.13481660187244415,
-0.10577752441167831,
-0.06811244785785675,
-0.019985919818282127,
0.1766487956047058,
0.9049774408340454,
0.27097904682159424,
-0.028081616386771202,
-0.8470320701599121,
0.5464951395988464,
0.3987971246242523,
0.24559475481510162,
-0.23394417762756348,
-0.5109657645225525,
0.01646948978304863,
-0.12752966582775116,
-0.20814400911331177,
-1.1261632442474365,
0.036443885415792465,
0.021628079935908318,
0.5185015797615051,
0.36068451404571533,
-0.1155569776892662,
0.947243869304657,
-0.6841634511947632,
0.7504422068595886,
-0.038719408214092255,
-0.5412678718566895,
0.5349957942962646,
-0.24670450389385223,
0.41825953125953674,
0.6393218040466309,
0.7135770320892334,
-0.4964277148246765,
-0.48293960094451904,
-0.4329284131526947,
-0.43687063455581665,
0.3345630466938019,
0.06031316891312599,
-0.0900302305817604,
-0.09693930298089981,
0.8220222592353821,
0.4171493351459503,
-0.022349944338202477,
-0.5261461734771729,
-0.21952319145202637,
0.44997361302375793,
-0.3732522130012512,
-0.23798152804374695,
-0.27016329765319824,
-0.41238296031951904,
-0.19201993942260742,
0.3190501034259796,
-0.013406574726104736,
0.20201408863067627,
0.3340754508972168,
-0.1703176200389862,
-0.08637888729572296,
0.2886379063129425,
0.7634074687957764,
0.9095026254653931,
-0.3044556677341461,
0.22212840616703033,
0.3677780032157898,
-0.2761180102825165,
0.20892252027988434,
-0.013449073769152164,
0.253795325756073,
0.13421694934368134,
0.7381431460380554,
0.6904487013816833,
0.06881554424762726,
-1.2272160053253174,
0.5482729077339172,
-0.21246202290058136,
-0.5808485150337219,
-0.04935663193464279,
0.04535294324159622,
0.3096526563167572,
0.248769611120224,
0.20505361258983612,
-0.48238271474838257,
0.09093202650547028,
-0.5808852314949036,
0.14237430691719055,
0.40550994873046875,
-0.3867906332015991,
-0.19938820600509644,
0.7276764512062073,
-0.0719992145895958,
-0.13134971261024475,
0.37333282828330994,
0.1963610053062439,
-0.2608320116996765,
0.7856184840202332,
0.6202430725097656,
0.21221116185188293,
-0.09389736503362656,
0.11623487621545792,
0.3151720464229584,
0.23296643793582916,
0.11058878898620605,
0.49944934248924255,
0.32173746824264526,
-0.4062891900539398,
-0.5149943828582764,
-0.20619450509548187,
-0.9311743378639221,
0.5082483291625977,
-0.8496915102005005,
0.19167856872081757,
-0.49108004570007324,
-0.07431768625974655,
0.4371657073497772,
-0.12151582539081573,
-0.8220016956329346,
0.4651755392551422,
0.024548964574933052,
0.864962637424469,
-0.9180098176002502,
0.39368247985839844,
0.7642713785171509,
-0.2476063221693039,
-0.7470564246177673,
-0.4357447624206543,
0.15730689465999603,
-1.24229896068573,
0.42091104388237,
0.15678881108760834,
0.44922971725463867,
-0.3945258557796478,
-0.4785486161708832,
-0.4370640814304352,
0.8274617791175842,
0.3477625548839569,
-0.6355802416801453,
-0.031509432941675186,
0.18245382606983185,
0.6816816926002502,
-0.46965134143829346,
0.6502225399017334,
0.5280618667602539,
0.36954063177108765,
-0.059840377420186996,
-0.9306498765945435,
0.27993279695510864,
-0.1463100165128708,
-0.15916644036769867,
-0.0046354858204722404,
-0.36719948053359985,
0.7648376226425171,
-0.578164279460907,
0.03302407264709473,
0.007826555520296097,
0.07000482082366943,
0.4797295033931732,
0.5029512643814087,
0.4779001772403717,
0.42825108766555786,
0.7691477537155151,
-0.25417518615722656,
1.2521350383758545,
0.10923018306493759,
0.2283695936203003,
0.9954219460487366,
-0.4607929289340973,
0.7563154697418213,
0.5501607656478882,
-0.6123566627502441,
0.6528550982475281,
0.7593398690223694,
-0.07417959719896317,
0.15028820931911469,
0.6243587136268616,
-0.16950923204421997,
-0.6373758912086487,
-0.1420404464006424,
-0.43594932556152344,
0.4202052354812622,
0.5160999894142151,
-0.3241051733493805,
-0.36748066544532776,
0.27916109561920166,
0.017045222222805023,
0.09235834330320358,
-0.22327762842178345,
0.8384672999382019,
0.11026908457279205,
-0.6943216919898987,
0.9469066262245178,
-0.20639151334762573,
0.04210136830806732,
-0.5640663504600525,
0.016203448176383972,
-0.31028813123703003,
0.20400941371917725,
0.03599516302347183,
-0.7638899087905884,
0.17265348136425018,
0.09577719867229462,
-0.17966723442077637,
-0.031550753861665726,
0.33258965611457825,
-0.33346402645111084,
-0.4408338665962219,
0.005250414367765188,
0.6041378974914551,
0.6275461316108704,
0.1552448570728302,
-0.909156084060669,
0.1608775407075882,
-0.21386568248271942,
-0.2325959950685501,
0.2192075401544571,
0.3994247019290924,
-0.08964603394269943,
1.1445307731628418,
0.509646475315094,
0.1940273493528366,
-0.04537292197346687,
0.10141278803348541,
0.7491317391395569,
-0.7084988355636597,
-0.03913889825344086,
-0.8116052150726318,
0.14259043335914612,
0.10912088304758072,
-0.23238104581832886,
0.36525747179985046,
0.41222673654556274,
0.38715851306915283,
-0.11392729729413986,
0.5541026592254639,
0.41314199566841125,
1.042864441871643,
-0.6871506571769714,
0.42108696699142456,
-0.8347350358963013,
0.3036442995071411,
0.0933031290769577,
-0.3551251292228699,
-0.5093290209770203,
0.303894579410553,
-0.15529562532901764,
0.13979169726371765,
0.9385656714439392,
0.8085482120513916,
0.125130295753479,
-0.13247758150100708,
0.43967753648757935,
0.5511719584465027,
0.3576667010784149,
1.084085464477539,
0.6979503035545349,
-0.4929904639720917,
0.576515793800354,
-0.12493292987346649,
-0.08564142882823944,
-0.38722512125968933,
-0.8811590075492859,
-1.108122706413269,
-0.3066430985927582,
-0.34694910049438477,
-0.3477898836135864,
0.2233027219772339,
0.9361521601676941,
0.6296287775039673,
-0.962020218372345,
-0.0626937597990036,
0.2215677946805954,
0.1757812350988388,
-0.2566979229450226,
-0.16311116516590118,
0.3956027925014496,
-0.24728044867515564,
-0.5025687217712402,
0.5764168500900269,
0.2445344179868698,
0.09547390043735504,
-0.09756172448396683,
0.15117259323596954,
0.10245323926210403,
0.2198537141084671,
0.29435962438583374,
0.15374383330345154,
-0.8891812562942505,
-0.09134598821401596,
0.04526457563042641,
-0.15979325771331787,
0.16065995395183563,
0.8788806796073914,
-0.8962087035179138,
0.5511437058448792,
0.2181967943906784,
0.8332569003105164,
0.2301565557718277,
-0.00918649323284626,
0.5783729553222656,
-0.2985438108444214,
-0.26997220516204834,
0.33176180720329285,
0.3650166988372803,
0.21164630353450775,
-0.10383609682321548,
0.41798871755599976,
0.14135539531707764,
-0.5836358070373535,
-1.095091462135315,
0.03141697496175766,
-0.9632155895233154,
-0.5383819341659546,
0.9840942621231079,
-0.26441001892089844,
-0.11417899280786514,
-0.3920033872127533,
-0.21527303755283356,
-0.09508246183395386,
0.07701082527637482,
0.7279480695724487,
0.8379132747650146,
-0.2841432988643646,
-0.2221727967262268,
-1.1117372512817383,
0.46059438586235046,
0.8911399841308594,
-1.0394296646118164,
0.15424132347106934,
0.5068400502204895,
0.5457594990730286,
-0.29782411456108093,
0.7339156270027161,
-0.38859477639198303,
0.63934725522995,
-0.1828342229127884,
-0.22743333876132965,
-0.2102760225534439,
-0.13177615404129028,
-0.5352387428283691,
0.25640445947647095,
0.09412414580583572,
-0.00422902125865221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18059v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18059v3
|
Token-Specific Watermarking with Enhanced Detectability and Semantic Coherence for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T05:43:22 | 2024-06-06T04:49:37 |
Mingjia Huo, Sai Ashish Somayajula, Youwei Liang, Ruisi Zhang, Farinaz Koushanfar, Pengtao Xie
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Large language models generate high-quality responses with potential
misinformation, underscoring the need for regulation by distinguishing
AI-generated and human-written texts. Watermarking is pivotal in this context,
which involves embedding hidden markers in texts during the LLM inference
phase, which is imperceptible to humans. Achieving both the detectability of
inserted watermarks and the semantic quality of generated texts is challenging.
While current watermarking algorithms have made promising progress in this
direction, there remains significant scope for improvement. To address these
challenges, we introduce a novel multi-objective optimization (MOO) approach
for watermarking that utilizes lightweight networks to generate token-specific
watermarking logits and splitting ratios. By leveraging MOO to optimize for
both detection and semantic objective functions, our method simultaneously
achieves detectability and semantic integrity. Experimental results show that
our method outperforms current watermarking techniques in enhancing the
detectability of texts generated by LLMs while maintaining their semantic
coherence. Our code is available at https://github.com/mignonjia/TS_watermark.
|
[
-0.2040656954050064,
-0.6735129952430725,
0.418963760137558,
-0.01835397444665432,
-0.7181218266487122,
0.1623571217060089,
-0.05476169288158417,
-0.5874337553977966,
0.2552414536476135,
0.6423933506011963,
-0.420099139213562,
-0.5634200572967529,
-0.7943632006645203,
0.027583448216319084,
-0.4309115707874298,
0.8173936605453491,
0.06764589250087738,
-0.21675345301628113,
-0.1883726269006729,
-0.4807552993297577,
-0.38015127182006836,
-0.5155079960823059,
-0.7030353546142578,
-0.24981442093849182,
0.36263442039489746,
0.25958478450775146,
0.4390629827976227,
0.9629978537559509,
0.5092158913612366,
0.31412819027900696,
-0.3319479525089264,
0.41869068145751953,
-0.3466958999633789,
0.2803124785423279,
0.02898915484547615,
-0.3554301857948303,
-0.3175075650215149,
-0.1537887454032898,
0.5560686588287354,
0.23306050896644592,
0.24253970384597778,
0.10356716066598892,
0.053619131445884705,
0.32177403569221497,
-1.0654163360595703,
0.1673782616853714,
-0.8965376019477844,
0.04031037166714668,
-0.3347395360469818,
-0.21687765419483185,
-0.3545120358467102,
0.07166723161935806,
-0.07791037857532501,
-0.8215924501419067,
0.049777157604694366,
0.3501141667366028,
1.1265116930007935,
0.16379110515117645,
-0.24165256321430206,
-0.3475683629512787,
-0.23604242503643036,
1.1669586896896362,
-0.8288092017173767,
0.36642754077911377,
0.3633316159248352,
-0.09414347261190414,
-0.015652822330594063,
-0.6194725632667542,
-0.4858413338661194,
-0.05712798610329628,
0.16741284728050232,
0.17115969955921173,
-0.12068632245063782,
0.014838038012385368,
-0.011675124987959862,
0.1803087294101715,
-0.2804619073867798,
-0.06634726375341415,
0.14719057083129883,
-0.6699778437614441,
0.4006824493408203,
0.01160790678113699,
0.5652138590812683,
-0.12203390896320343,
-0.5459869503974915,
0.07642017304897308,
-0.4899931848049164,
-0.06084121763706207,
0.5650190114974976,
0.4824881851673126,
0.051798705011606216,
0.4399964511394501,
-0.2476293295621872,
0.3848212957382202,
-0.2584937810897827,
-0.5496731996536255,
0.13841629028320312,
-0.5701006650924683,
0.11124063283205032,
0.0968504548072815,
0.7600373029708862,
0.10345134884119034,
0.06179926171898842,
-0.263037770986557,
-0.4666426181793213,
0.08157443255186081,
-0.11465658247470856,
-0.8923966288566589,
0.24434182047843933,
0.0743241012096405,
-0.463148295879364,
-0.46821051836013794,
0.07350152730941772,
-0.4353453516960144,
-0.37701132893562317,
-0.3687613606452942,
0.6029241681098938,
-0.33047398924827576,
-0.2983904778957367,
0.31088998913764954,
-0.45223259925842285,
-0.036283861845731735,
0.13651280105113983,
-0.7375989556312561,
0.0920209065079689,
0.9056891798973083,
0.8924039602279663,
-0.31269675493240356,
-0.04692448675632477,
-0.8459135890007019,
0.6474688649177551,
-0.19275091588497162,
0.6454546451568604,
-0.5915613174438477,
-0.22711187601089478,
-0.20238132774829865,
-0.38238534331321716,
0.06000737100839615,
-0.5920644998550415,
0.7014625668525696,
-0.6179394721984863,
-0.07837067544460297,
-0.10806481540203094,
-0.6452882289886475,
0.0717318058013916,
0.3763013482093811,
-0.7175660133361816,
0.9387274384498596,
-0.19880720973014832,
-0.8160960674285889,
0.5455161929130554,
-0.7251850962638855,
-0.42629578709602356,
0.12351808696985245,
0.06877564638853073,
-0.7022718191146851,
0.13174216449260712,
0.21860270202159882,
0.453922837972641,
-0.33528363704681396,
0.48928335309028625,
-0.31222477555274963,
-0.22173085808753967,
0.16602882742881775,
-0.5246537923812866,
0.5311017632484436,
0.07947677373886108,
-0.43358945846557617,
0.3938656449317932,
-0.9001433253288269,
0.14559152722358704,
0.15736991167068481,
-0.42590487003326416,
-0.65244460105896,
0.0698573887348175,
0.055729858577251434,
-0.12260743230581284,
0.5296497344970703,
-0.7073456048965454,
-0.23158036172389984,
-0.1340780109167099,
0.6267103552818298,
0.8606789708137512,
-0.04260551184415817,
0.3282923996448517,
-0.0767330452799797,
0.2492859959602356,
0.22168518602848053,
0.42827197909355164,
-0.11154857277870178,
-0.49394410848617554,
-0.8593334555625916,
-0.7292883992195129,
0.2307301014661789,
0.2917921841144562,
-0.7757980227470398,
0.6548750400543213,
-0.33298811316490173,
-0.3021987974643707,
-0.2793433368206024,
0.3486799895763397,
0.48378801345825195,
0.49317696690559387,
0.4567919373512268,
-0.25365403294563293,
-0.22985191643238068,
-0.9764556288719177,
-0.5492739677429199,
-0.2296331524848938,
0.2860812544822693,
0.3416454792022705,
0.6655648350715637,
-0.28044483065605164,
0.9014026522636414,
-0.4060556888580322,
-0.23021724820137024,
-0.35411518812179565,
0.08644506335258484,
-0.20604276657104492,
0.5856645107269287,
0.409920334815979,
-0.9659486413002014,
-0.3078010082244873,
-0.033633116632699966,
-0.46933355927467346,
-0.3892922103404999,
0.06986279785633087,
-0.2754347324371338,
-0.03124794363975525,
0.5607830882072449,
-0.37644803524017334,
0.41396746039390564,
0.6953036189079285,
-0.4335675835609436,
0.33566686511039734,
-0.06053875386714935,
-0.02858060412108898,
-1.0772144794464111,
0.09456154704093933,
-0.2858583927154541,
-0.39259251952171326,
-0.4074176847934723,
0.23639068007469177,
0.05655357614159584,
-0.16948142647743225,
-0.2277839481830597,
0.7767531275749207,
-0.38719359040260315,
0.18958090245723724,
-0.39229175448417664,
0.05524345114827156,
0.35042622685432434,
0.325204998254776,
-0.21989218890666962,
0.6655949950218201,
0.44868144392967224,
-0.3644709289073944,
0.11445016413927078,
-0.04184647276997566,
-0.32591497898101807,
0.5831088423728943,
-0.7861902713775635,
0.16648633778095245,
-0.07223503291606903,
0.005041325464844704,
-0.9050901532173157,
0.0333515964448452,
0.26359015703201294,
-0.14271703362464905,
0.17634348571300507,
-0.15596012771129608,
-0.6255872845649719,
0.26604562997817993,
-0.44478586316108704,
0.542466938495636,
0.03638038411736488,
-0.4673161208629608,
0.8256617784500122,
0.32335278391838074,
0.10327903181314468,
-0.5891740322113037,
-0.6700429916381836,
0.36570900678634644,
-0.15401889383792877,
-0.6192715764045715,
0.5072113275527954,
0.022697649896144867,
-0.045080628246068954,
0.156829833984375,
-0.314418762922287,
-0.27003365755081177,
0.3268429636955261,
0.27717816829681396,
0.15178807079792023,
-0.19083264470100403,
-0.09526465088129044,
0.26227033138275146,
-0.6132749319076538,
-0.40483665466308594,
-0.4126318395137787,
0.5888367891311646,
0.09089462459087372,
-0.5554293990135193,
-0.9238482117652893,
0.44412174820899963,
0.6051400899887085,
-0.5057715177536011,
0.7967358231544495,
0.7775697708129883,
-0.38343775272369385,
-0.20782023668289185,
-0.5220491886138916,
-0.06552864611148834,
-0.5112945437431335,
0.3453487753868103,
-0.3345493674278259,
-1.0930826663970947,
0.4953292906284332,
0.00921347364783287,
-0.07270557433366776,
0.3990785479545593,
0.20586416125297546,
0.326735258102417,
0.7416316270828247,
0.3932892382144928,
-0.31783196330070496,
0.8603909015655518,
-0.14892832934856415,
0.35513803362846375,
-0.7326789498329163,
-0.0980347990989685,
-0.6023503541946411,
-0.12922737002372742,
-0.2068665623664856,
-0.47112685441970825,
0.007709957659244537,
0.2715032994747162,
-0.25146377086639404,
0.3137018084526062,
-0.4169168770313263,
0.6388599276542664,
0.7726763486862183,
0.08572044968605042,
0.5346092581748962,
0.01636362634599209,
-0.23667000234127045,
0.03292004019021988,
-0.5606923699378967,
-0.5705025792121887,
0.8063703775405884,
0.07242221385240555,
0.5104905366897583,
-0.040076497942209244,
0.9904646277427673,
0.23281297087669373,
0.28942495584487915,
-0.6178209781646729,
0.7110841274261475,
-0.1372288465499878,
-0.6721444129943848,
-0.3484553396701813,
-0.6129483580589294,
-0.8754430413246155,
0.44628408551216125,
-0.19832637906074524,
-0.6893613338470459,
-0.05967874079942703,
-0.13538627326488495,
0.15889988839626312,
0.36382871866226196,
-0.6557599306106567,
0.8671376705169678,
-0.25726041197776794,
-0.4685858190059662,
-0.2712404131889343,
-0.38061073422431946,
-0.04289499297738075,
-0.1982090175151825,
0.338893324136734,
-0.6948975920677185,
-0.6043164730072021,
0.6813464164733887,
-0.6130864024162292,
0.7058592438697815,
-0.27027633786201477,
-0.07550543546676636,
0.3983844518661499,
-0.10635490715503693,
0.6652714610099792,
0.15871645510196686,
-0.19587382674217224,
0.20917494595050812,
-0.10289055854082108,
-0.5011081099510193,
-0.28974512219429016,
0.5339709520339966,
-0.5999845266342163,
-0.4437888562679291,
-0.21933022141456604,
-0.5118603706359863,
-0.09939172118902206,
0.5903295874595642,
0.14499598741531372,
0.5093388557434082,
0.10756833106279373,
0.41126158833503723,
0.290119469165802,
-0.22689789533615112,
0.7022490501403809,
0.27532628178596497,
0.19590222835540771,
-0.6909544467926025,
1.0934944152832031,
0.0017002890817821026,
0.3025231957435608,
0.588135838508606,
0.5227853059768677,
-0.2969812750816345,
-0.9644976854324341,
-0.28300270438194275,
0.07149504125118256,
-0.7480278611183167,
-0.2981418967247009,
-0.4512855112552643,
0.07613526284694672,
-0.0010500849457457662,
-0.06486223638057709,
-0.5433761477470398,
-0.20006991922855377,
-0.4581674039363861,
0.10444803535938263,
0.12655194103717804,
0.32173973321914673,
0.14959768950939178,
0.2897373139858246,
-0.8169153332710266,
0.47388729453086853,
0.1970803588628769,
0.4107743203639984,
0.07935485988855362,
-0.27847015857696533,
-0.20129995048046112,
0.14969086647033691,
-0.12541931867599487,
-0.25644659996032715,
0.08415329456329346,
0.3470274806022644,
0.414029061794281,
0.5606808066368103,
0.25182273983955383,
0.8499861359596252,
-0.42264044284820557,
0.5737346410751343,
0.39495334029197693,
-1.4578871726989746,
0.366464227437973,
-0.18894988298416138,
0.1391267329454422,
0.5710079073905945,
-0.26978978514671326,
-0.3050042390823364,
-0.6480435729026794,
-0.32980120182037354,
-1.192291498184204,
0.4188169240951538,
0.38693273067474365,
0.5232670307159424,
0.06110939010977745,
0.4560404419898987,
0.12332569807767868,
0.2049863040447235,
-0.758894145488739,
-0.042242005467414856,
-0.038836583495140076,
-0.41808298230171204,
0.2790248990058899,
-0.39985716342926025,
-0.22843538224697113,
0.054991088807582855,
0.6386914253234863,
-0.34199896454811096,
-0.01501911785453558,
0.0981055423617363,
-0.18354615569114685,
0.1912781447172165,
0.1485464870929718,
0.49587497115135193,
0.5189279317855835,
0.24790245294570923,
0.25763949751853943,
-0.036613695323467255,
-0.6252216696739197,
0.2788034975528717,
-0.21790798008441925,
-0.3683360815048218,
0.05914364755153656,
0.7553461790084839,
0.7924772500991821,
0.10645116120576859,
-0.7651245594024658,
0.6738976240158081,
-0.043453045189380646,
0.011192884296178818,
0.12273427844047546,
0.34197065234184265,
0.1521243453025818,
0.3514573574066162,
0.5087496042251587,
0.027701791375875473,
-0.04565570130944252,
-0.2718617022037506,
-0.004522518254816532,
0.6838506460189819,
-0.13127020001411438,
-0.30306658148765564,
0.833961009979248,
0.30949634313583374,
-0.2576535940170288,
0.15427134931087494,
-0.080760657787323,
-0.5820835828781128,
0.5752244591712952,
0.49611058831214905,
1.0612300634384155,
0.28609272837638855,
-0.062126725912094116,
0.08311185240745544,
0.23459994792938232,
-0.11683111637830734,
0.1855020374059677,
-0.2620839476585388,
-1.0639630556106567,
-0.27512919902801514,
-0.6769242882728577,
-0.45591244101524353,
-0.05247717350721359,
-0.5831449627876282,
0.199492409825325,
-0.4643309414386749,
-0.40278446674346924,
0.09627004712820053,
-0.09753603488206863,
-0.3304281532764435,
0.2613249719142914,
0.01403551921248436,
0.5209134817123413,
-0.5646651983261108,
0.598972737789154,
0.30665549635887146,
-0.07533332705497742,
-0.5375542640686035,
0.1472645252943039,
-0.19305935502052307,
-0.9733380675315857,
0.4906725287437439,
0.39198631048202515,
-0.388916552066803,
0.003937719389796257,
-0.5813153982162476,
-0.8813387155532837,
1.080079436302185,
0.8198368549346924,
-0.40497079491615295,
0.4312410056591034,
0.3141222894191742,
0.3801695704460144,
-0.20464931428432465,
-0.16625827550888062,
0.06887564063072205,
0.4841107130050659,
-0.055667269974946976,
-0.5854360461235046,
0.26573437452316284,
-0.12267459183931351,
0.2056407779455185,
0.27329081296920776,
-0.8405062556266785,
0.5110279321670532,
0.06021494045853615,
-0.22896906733512878,
0.20255307853221893,
0.43522465229034424,
0.3699721693992615,
0.341172456741333,
0.5734739303588867,
0.7106613516807556,
0.7191066741943359,
-0.18847344815731049,
0.9892991185188293,
-0.5798853635787964,
0.4183965027332306,
0.7131483554840088,
-0.21582013368606567,
0.8698369264602661,
0.7402771711349487,
0.17914630472660065,
0.24027961492538452,
0.448874294757843,
0.0820189118385315,
0.527298092842102,
0.18945260345935822,
-0.5330526828765869,
-0.42350903153419495,
-0.6171615719795227,
-0.1701056957244873,
0.3715037703514099,
0.016466913744807243,
-0.37461766600608826,
0.11637168377637863,
-0.16170714795589447,
0.0350809246301651,
-0.2228003889322281,
-0.21983292698860168,
0.7106740474700928,
-0.02564188465476036,
-0.21235692501068115,
0.22320032119750977,
0.2664615511894226,
0.9243578910827637,
-0.6604618430137634,
0.30620408058166504,
-0.16719728708267212,
0.3079041540622711,
-0.17779846489429474,
-0.34959638118743896,
0.21405963599681854,
0.00034384167520329356,
-0.13191379606723785,
-0.414549320936203,
0.9898059368133545,
-0.4007854461669922,
-0.41649022698402405,
0.5506607294082642,
0.44401076436042786,
-0.1060500219464302,
-0.1291268914937973,
-0.6331043839454651,
0.34177231788635254,
-0.19259415566921234,
-0.4416232407093048,
0.22968754172325134,
0.5723510980606079,
-0.062332190573215485,
0.867327094078064,
0.9200146794319153,
0.09395187348127365,
0.0860561951994896,
0.26459553837776184,
0.7065761089324951,
-0.43655720353126526,
-0.5756489038467407,
-1.2066935300827026,
0.30185285210609436,
-0.23346145451068878,
-0.43017658591270447,
0.5545884966850281,
0.750403881072998,
0.5861788988113403,
0.0397585853934288,
0.7790936231613159,
0.1771046370267868,
-0.12263128906488419,
-0.44461536407470703,
0.6936818957328796,
-0.8644110560417175,
0.12928789854049683,
-0.4748465418815613,
-0.8300890922546387,
-0.5650351047515869,
0.36560526490211487,
0.0890590026974678,
-0.058677200227975845,
0.45247682929039,
0.7745077610015869,
-0.09434893727302551,
-0.04901465028524399,
0.36035093665122986,
-0.4378858804702759,
0.5889917612075806,
0.39789140224456787,
0.7500150799751282,
-0.42365291714668274,
0.8492682576179504,
-0.0702395811676979,
0.08169198781251907,
-0.1281372308731079,
-1.0994410514831543,
-0.8548041582107544,
-0.48052912950515747,
-0.5487551689147949,
-0.19579347968101501,
0.029490619897842407,
0.7024783492088318,
0.8642350435256958,
-0.9726570844650269,
0.06963703036308289,
-0.32620978355407715,
0.35204222798347473,
-0.011442213319242,
-0.22115619480609894,
0.4912106394767761,
-0.201368510723114,
-0.8336370587348938,
0.06341054290533066,
0.8132959008216858,
0.3293209373950958,
0.02294684201478958,
-0.17314699292182922,
-0.008664444088935852,
0.24980725347995758,
0.5192182064056396,
-0.16552895307540894,
-0.6689436435699463,
-0.5017980337142944,
-0.18912948668003082,
-0.3413851857185364,
-0.03527631610631943,
0.8214938640594482,
-0.1392950862646103,
0.47042274475097656,
0.6536853313446045,
0.9673612117767334,
0.34594592452049255,
-0.10567386448383331,
0.20242726802825928,
-0.8239523768424988,
0.4000801146030426,
0.33006322383880615,
0.5759852528572083,
0.41663452982902527,
-0.060967106372117996,
0.4425792694091797,
0.72566819190979,
-0.09710974246263504,
-0.9807013273239136,
0.06700003892183304,
-0.8472270369529724,
-0.217087984085083,
1.1374496221542358,
-0.3673131465911865,
-0.1399475783109665,
-0.2043241411447525,
-0.2513609826564789,
0.21379928290843964,
-0.5048997402191162,
0.6024155616760254,
0.9684270024299622,
0.1450972557067871,
0.024961834773421288,
-0.2677192986011505,
0.1482539027929306,
0.5048307776451111,
-0.9045628905296326,
-0.07076750695705414,
0.08327556401491165,
0.2933647632598877,
0.1949933022260666,
0.41337668895721436,
-0.14364968240261078,
-0.11422698944807053,
0.08317101001739502,
-0.04232223704457283,
-0.26322686672210693,
-0.1357167512178421,
0.15343384444713593,
0.26867151260375977,
-0.04013559967279434,
-0.4598499536514282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18054v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18054v1
|
Contextualizing Generated Citation Texts
| 2024-02-28T05:24:21 | 2024-02-28T05:24:21 |
Biswadip Mandal, Xiangci Li, Jessica Ouyang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Abstractive citation text generation is usually framed as an infilling task,
where a sequence-to-sequence model is trained to generate a citation given a
reference paper and the context window around the target; the generated
citation should be a brief discussion of the reference paper as it relates to
the citing context. However, examining a recent LED-based citation generation
system, we find that many of the generated citations are generic summaries of
the reference papers main contribution, ignoring the citation contexts focus on
a different topic. To address this problem, we propose a simple modification to
the citation text generation task: the generation target is not only the
citation itself, but the entire context window, including the target citation.
This approach can be easily applied to any abstractive citation generation
system, and our experimental results show that training in this way is
preferred by human readers and allows the generation model to make use of
contextual clues about what topic to discuss and what stance to take.
|
[
-0.31258103251457214,
-0.41611984372138977,
0.8068940043449402,
0.029261959716677666,
-0.5455887317657471,
-0.2292422652244568,
-0.1418588012456894,
-0.4160609841346741,
0.14368103444576263,
0.26593339443206787,
-0.4168431758880615,
-0.24737447500228882,
-0.3252410590648651,
0.5077919960021973,
-0.5295085906982422,
1.3660598993301392,
0.09981154650449753,
-0.23790748417377472,
-0.4189336895942688,
0.0863322988152504,
-0.4657468795776367,
-0.4540005624294281,
-0.2934132516384125,
-0.5035788416862488,
0.8368659615516663,
0.4652825593948364,
0.2632036805152893,
0.6130335927009583,
0.3930497169494629,
0.11589135229587555,
-0.2025187462568283,
0.08413893729448318,
-0.41064125299453735,
0.46723318099975586,
-0.6117504835128784,
-0.03995038568973541,
-0.0721762403845787,
-0.0003964729839935899,
0.6630237698554993,
0.8663102984428406,
0.5297170877456665,
0.3736422657966614,
0.23740723729133606,
0.710661768913269,
-0.7168759703636169,
-0.05332813784480095,
-0.9202142953872681,
-0.18238669633865356,
-0.3360079526901245,
-0.6813051700592041,
-0.7270601391792297,
-0.2729208469390869,
0.19936399161815643,
-0.3191315531730652,
0.5409421920776367,
0.05047529935836792,
0.6173236966133118,
-0.044103845953941345,
-0.7800641059875488,
-0.41656675934791565,
-0.769720196723938,
0.6913862228393555,
-0.31813982129096985,
-0.347202330827713,
0.037821006029844284,
0.0513516366481781,
0.036326777189970016,
-0.7859985828399658,
-0.23363079130649567,
0.17413592338562012,
-0.2739185690879822,
0.026826895773410797,
-0.03967193886637688,
-0.18023209273815155,
0.36235615611076355,
0.04865487292408943,
-0.5134534239768982,
-0.6206623315811157,
-0.3415493965148926,
0.13329601287841797,
0.6449134945869446,
-0.12787364423274994,
-0.048071932047605515,
-0.48735281825065613,
-0.2638820707798004,
-0.007477967534214258,
-1.0049747228622437,
-0.2566072344779968,
0.1073288843035698,
0.650507390499115,
0.35898223519325256,
0.5451020002365112,
-0.07564752548933029,
0.7689672708511353,
0.3104950785636902,
0.11648336797952652,
0.1287299394607544,
-0.48425552248954773,
-0.21752658486366272,
0.2544422745704651,
0.2782624363899231,
0.3481842577457428,
0.3378829061985016,
-0.40970301628112793,
-0.07498320192098618,
-0.4231680631637573,
0.45545488595962524,
-0.9571408033370972,
-0.029585720971226692,
0.14955654740333557,
-0.4495772421360016,
-0.32068532705307007,
0.34263259172439575,
-0.32207903265953064,
0.03247475624084473,
-0.49164411425590515,
0.05787339061498642,
-0.23937340080738068,
-0.031640052795410156,
-0.692233681678772,
-0.28867197036743164,
0.03975357860326767,
0.35216960310935974,
-0.8012229800224304,
-0.36694127321243286,
0.4246196150779724,
0.9074425101280212,
-0.16770900785923004,
-0.13684441149234772,
-0.6842077374458313,
0.7686317563056946,
-0.12915904819965363,
1.0285552740097046,
-0.6505441069602966,
-0.7135247588157654,
0.29677435755729675,
-0.170694962143898,
-0.10018452256917953,
-0.478303462266922,
0.31474122405052185,
-0.7549178600311279,
0.11230743676424026,
-0.5921306014060974,
-0.5418606996536255,
0.012705044820904732,
0.04562830179929733,
-0.39322859048843384,
0.7574920058250427,
-0.0004423018835950643,
-0.9847555756568909,
0.6440296173095703,
-0.7617360949516296,
-0.7002716064453125,
0.12407120317220688,
-0.3265177011489868,
-0.3188226521015167,
0.11536990106105804,
-0.013613613322377205,
0.26761242747306824,
-0.10968723148107529,
0.5777376890182495,
0.20549285411834717,
-0.3610878884792328,
0.1343400478363037,
0.08707554638385773,
0.6481797695159912,
0.608439028263092,
-0.42727360129356384,
0.3374517858028412,
-0.8748189210891724,
0.06251697242259979,
-0.07323896884918213,
-0.5752840638160706,
-0.5475494265556335,
0.010312558151781559,
0.571685254573822,
0.04089966043829918,
0.17641250789165497,
-0.5226613283157349,
0.06002068147063255,
-0.2410546839237213,
0.2713049054145813,
0.5938382148742676,
0.46614623069763184,
0.5425792932510376,
-0.2938135266304016,
0.27872195839881897,
-0.06419248133897781,
-0.4341011941432953,
-0.6994057893753052,
-0.5515674352645874,
-0.3172996938228607,
-0.08267760276794434,
0.18676576018333435,
0.20932763814926147,
-0.5760747194290161,
0.3267611861228943,
-0.31992900371551514,
-0.034298431128263474,
0.3113791346549988,
0.11685951799154282,
0.3991311192512512,
0.6595266461372375,
0.2748660147190094,
0.22933261096477509,
-0.7667273283004761,
-0.6672032475471497,
-0.5198732614517212,
-0.3585754334926605,
-0.15741650760173798,
0.2088569849729538,
0.7110081315040588,
-0.011761000379920006,
1.440824270248413,
-0.6042499542236328,
0.14015159010887146,
-0.16535963118076324,
0.4503583610057831,
-0.03951354697346687,
0.8008421063423157,
0.7078619003295898,
-1.0712196826934814,
-0.8042687177658081,
-0.11748853325843811,
-0.9400359988212585,
-0.14770318567752838,
-0.43181174993515015,
-0.30071115493774414,
-0.17631641030311584,
0.8860311508178711,
-0.29504793882369995,
0.3048892319202423,
-0.1979476660490036,
-0.4895682632923126,
0.3674088418483734,
-0.05924472212791443,
-0.01771494373679161,
-1.3513422012329102,
0.7147239446640015,
-0.21530425548553467,
-0.1922977715730667,
-0.5818754434585571,
0.18212009966373444,
0.13481183350086212,
-0.48303577303886414,
-0.2072804570198059,
0.4756263494491577,
-0.5571222305297852,
0.003627892816439271,
-0.7481281757354736,
-0.026957573369145393,
0.08841744065284729,
0.09196843206882477,
0.22227510809898376,
0.706843912601471,
0.013821815140545368,
-0.5932589769363403,
-0.19969235360622406,
0.3191663920879364,
-0.1027597114443779,
0.7037490010261536,
-0.6226713061332703,
0.2287643551826477,
-0.458656907081604,
0.4254605174064636,
-0.898384153842926,
-0.3354493975639343,
-0.07567806541919708,
-0.33652350306510925,
0.31714120507240295,
-0.13671451807022095,
-0.32821914553642273,
-0.02294611744582653,
-0.3097570538520813,
0.7043511271476746,
0.2535061836242676,
-0.6999203562736511,
0.2291068434715271,
-0.06222698464989662,
-0.25236374139785767,
-0.380135715007782,
-0.479423850774765,
0.24111823737621307,
-0.31628069281578064,
-0.6752440929412842,
0.8370755910873413,
-0.2889940142631531,
-0.40010252594947815,
-0.052644215524196625,
0.18708808720111847,
0.10179883986711502,
-0.08194687217473984,
0.4446651041507721,
0.06864112615585327,
-0.19102779030799866,
0.4873182475566864,
0.22102093696594238,
-0.10097882896661758,
-0.09666911512613297,
-0.31340551376342773,
0.11060117930173874,
0.19424641132354736,
-0.17083197832107544,
0.018130531534552574,
1.0636205673217773,
0.32870203256607056,
-0.0616246797144413,
0.5374078154563904,
0.2032475769519806,
-0.11254469305276871,
-0.06714357435703278,
-0.11325225234031677,
-0.23268218338489532,
-0.4108971059322357,
0.1880854368209839,
-0.4771789014339447,
-0.5811352729797363,
0.2127409428358078,
-0.15118591487407684,
0.4494536519050598,
0.419657826423645,
0.5602787137031555,
-0.1350366771221161,
0.7218493223190308,
0.6513728499412537,
0.2630428671836853,
0.7853567004203796,
0.0009240679210051894,
0.05747571960091591,
-0.8497602939605713,
-0.16058361530303955,
-0.6711329817771912,
-0.28005194664001465,
-0.18611454963684082,
-0.1660645604133606,
0.272434264421463,
0.14018255472183228,
-0.3710653781890869,
0.22985902428627014,
-0.7409458756446838,
0.40154406428337097,
0.7085910439491272,
-0.11980652809143066,
0.477187842130661,
0.31243279576301575,
0.07878661155700684,
-0.00408877432346344,
-0.3844018280506134,
-0.8847752809524536,
1.3101565837860107,
-0.17689041793346405,
0.2967841923236847,
0.010099277831614017,
1.0990407466888428,
0.41288480162620544,
0.660216748714447,
-0.4074609577655792,
0.3869388699531555,
0.34570735692977905,
-0.8145502805709839,
-0.13250845670700073,
-0.2013915479183197,
-1.120678186416626,
0.4381619393825531,
0.041706230491399765,
-0.4647290110588074,
0.391542911529541,
0.3131108283996582,
-0.25838589668273926,
0.0005699454923160374,
-0.6509780287742615,
0.5007078051567078,
0.3445875644683838,
-0.29566308856010437,
-0.11701256036758423,
-0.5947519540786743,
0.15099884569644928,
-0.002975208917632699,
0.07545405626296997,
0.26194658875465393,
0.23220974206924438,
0.7107707262039185,
-0.5425236225128174,
0.7166309952735901,
-0.2200709879398346,
0.030163569375872612,
0.6320651769638062,
-0.24656084179878235,
0.6800209879875183,
0.269194096326828,
-0.06346429884433746,
-0.43908265233039856,
-0.5566579699516296,
-0.556655764579773,
-0.3235798478126526,
0.6190817952156067,
-0.3226030170917511,
-0.7546623349189758,
-0.5630283951759338,
-0.7099696397781372,
-0.1469605416059494,
0.0866614580154419,
0.655047595500946,
0.3913775086402893,
-0.45480287075042725,
0.08066970854997635,
0.6218441128730774,
0.14480158686637878,
0.7300288081169128,
0.252035528421402,
0.0462513342499733,
-0.31170129776000977,
0.6376977562904358,
-0.148287832736969,
0.14249703288078308,
0.4434877634048462,
-0.14977842569351196,
-0.0776214599609375,
-0.650498628616333,
-0.46754932403564453,
0.18245691061019897,
-0.8558511137962341,
-0.20283570885658264,
-0.5467803478240967,
-0.07683119177818298,
-0.5979230403900146,
-0.574653148651123,
0.05999092012643814,
-0.4335304796695709,
-0.7059987783432007,
-0.19120663404464722,
0.34733104705810547,
0.670541524887085,
-0.07469289749860764,
0.25754207372665405,
-0.5608065724372864,
-0.06998033821582794,
0.5316003561019897,
-0.26616063714027405,
0.18664245307445526,
-0.46442708373069763,
-0.41595011949539185,
-0.22694911062717438,
-0.6491159796714783,
-0.9181919693946838,
0.16825158894062042,
0.43089595437049866,
0.3224411904811859,
0.43867236375808716,
0.13810065388679504,
0.49522170424461365,
-0.8850478529930115,
0.8230752944946289,
0.34069764614105225,
-0.7294445037841797,
1.0781302452087402,
-0.5675377249717712,
0.5061438679695129,
0.6642554402351379,
0.15117071568965912,
-0.09691368788480759,
-0.4003954827785492,
-0.5253630876541138,
-0.9464337229728699,
0.451522558927536,
0.4152716398239136,
0.29310181736946106,
-0.21611681580543518,
0.5436748266220093,
0.12980099022388458,
0.19580934941768646,
-0.9355947375297546,
-0.2687881886959076,
-0.3543780744075775,
-0.10439635813236237,
0.013430670835077763,
-0.37825751304626465,
-0.33530205488204956,
0.048883408308029175,
0.5131356120109558,
-0.24783076345920563,
0.2370040863752365,
0.47862952947616577,
-0.24468062818050385,
-0.25794124603271484,
0.3712819516658783,
0.9245142340660095,
0.9925905466079712,
-0.5875186920166016,
0.20162150263786316,
-0.4864886403083801,
-0.42743176221847534,
0.16995283961296082,
-0.09303018450737,
-0.8988106846809387,
0.5030501484870911,
0.4165789783000946,
0.42947980761528015,
0.23557570576667786,
-0.5207544565200806,
0.2619030773639679,
0.3567526936531067,
-0.3078494369983673,
-0.24390272796154022,
-0.0929371640086174,
0.04156447574496269,
0.21686692535877228,
0.9133388996124268,
0.2328026294708252,
0.1711047887802124,
-0.7184906005859375,
0.3111521601676941,
0.4115240275859833,
-0.30132168531417847,
-0.3656519651412964,
0.8353924751281738,
0.5727559924125671,
-0.08536228537559509,
0.12752075493335724,
-0.17508965730667114,
-0.25688669085502625,
0.36041781306266785,
0.8752838969230652,
1.0572834014892578,
0.2759245038032532,
0.13684037327766418,
0.7554629445075989,
-0.03523145616054535,
0.25680023431777954,
0.08367947489023209,
-0.47247514128685,
-0.3213960528373718,
-0.3141089081764221,
-0.4214918315410614,
-0.2184906154870987,
-0.08372840285301208,
-0.7509363889694214,
-0.011694930493831635,
-0.25645893812179565,
-0.3135641813278198,
0.08262909948825836,
-0.23185700178146362,
-0.15115344524383545,
0.2533077597618103,
0.11868633329868317,
0.7982867360115051,
-0.7810912132263184,
0.9367548823356628,
0.9142233729362488,
-0.6283974051475525,
-0.11629825085401535,
0.3840373158454895,
-0.31781306862831116,
-0.1965983808040619,
1.1127594709396362,
-0.018679875880479813,
-0.10302380472421646,
-0.03211932256817818,
-0.563304603099823,
-0.8507122993469238,
1.1212431192398071,
0.23742759227752686,
-0.2752087116241455,
-0.15063977241516113,
-0.17658257484436035,
0.18695564568042755,
-0.8907536268234253,
-0.06653057038784027,
0.12223269790410995,
0.40880173444747925,
0.3378588855266571,
-0.4609193801879883,
0.34310460090637207,
-0.4880388379096985,
0.4045325517654419,
-0.004146122373640537,
-0.3556101620197296,
0.9843611121177673,
-0.3195871412754059,
-0.3199818432331085,
0.21856912970542908,
1.021707534790039,
0.5714232921600342,
0.5294036865234375,
0.2228144258260727,
0.020007260143756866,
0.735594630241394,
0.1633170247077942,
1.0290894508361816,
-0.08543006330728531,
0.0845133364200592,
1.2958265542984009,
-0.21476741135120392,
0.7103601694107056,
0.9923794269561768,
0.09920774400234222,
0.6805898547172546,
0.5333646535873413,
0.02708856388926506,
0.9798069596290588,
0.06262393295764923,
-0.370748907327652,
-0.1369926482439041,
0.023340793326497078,
-0.7799658179283142,
-0.16472037136554718,
0.06283815950155258,
-0.87285977602005,
-0.42792096734046936,
0.14473432302474976,
-0.08513525873422623,
0.5197428464889526,
-0.3183141350746155,
0.516524076461792,
0.06166262552142143,
-0.8492027521133423,
0.5909263491630554,
-0.008332301862537861,
0.6390596628189087,
-0.2873561978340149,
-0.020613791421055794,
-0.04621341452002525,
-0.09201782196760178,
-0.27580350637435913,
-0.29607224464416504,
0.371143102645874,
0.4174668788909912,
-0.9434529542922974,
-0.480202853679657,
0.5999224185943604,
-0.3129490911960602,
-0.3200804889202118,
-0.145521342754364,
0.41105586290359497,
0.1434440016746521,
-0.21523410081863403,
-0.19260689616203308,
-0.35988837480545044,
0.3970699906349182,
-0.32901960611343384,
0.5545514225959778,
0.29277756810188293,
0.0535757802426815,
0.027364561334252357,
0.6202296018600464,
-0.20027770102024078,
-0.016803786158561707,
0.02366291731595993,
0.7842980623245239,
-0.8937004208564758,
-0.6435523629188538,
-0.7145198583602905,
0.5125263929367065,
-0.39085498452186584,
-0.5894114971160889,
0.890869140625,
0.6241458654403687,
0.4552159905433655,
-0.2307124137878418,
1.0143250226974487,
-0.17928582429885864,
0.6664761900901794,
-0.31485679745674133,
0.5860374569892883,
-0.4660009741783142,
0.2764970660209656,
-0.4036288559436798,
-1.0646910667419434,
-0.14586429297924042,
0.5970138907432556,
-0.19931483268737793,
0.07386481761932373,
0.7097491025924683,
0.3331919312477112,
0.05182535946369171,
0.08199960738420486,
0.1127389594912529,
-0.2712450623512268,
0.392290323972702,
0.3837823271751404,
0.7353783249855042,
-0.363797664642334,
0.7158629894256592,
0.15487362444400787,
-0.10229966789484024,
-0.421647846698761,
-0.9734576940536499,
-0.8505598306655884,
-0.6436159014701843,
-0.47195538878440857,
-0.42891591787338257,
-0.02548426389694214,
0.6511896252632141,
0.6117339134216309,
-0.8955385088920593,
-0.25075340270996094,
-0.38876381516456604,
0.10514044016599655,
-0.052738167345523834,
-0.23946498334407806,
0.5352767109870911,
-0.6423580050468445,
-0.8782603740692139,
0.47787702083587646,
0.06615129113197327,
0.06412814557552338,
0.06230812892317772,
0.02035083808004856,
-0.38966742157936096,
0.09095407277345657,
0.6754438877105713,
0.3419402241706848,
-0.49196699261665344,
-0.4006381034851074,
-0.15022914111614227,
-0.254159152507782,
0.19697831571102142,
1.4122394323349,
-0.8775151968002319,
0.2699345052242279,
0.40121740102767944,
0.2848002314567566,
0.7481414675712585,
0.23725466430187225,
0.8745622634887695,
-1.0316084623336792,
0.21040917932987213,
0.14864802360534668,
0.29284411668777466,
0.41199180483818054,
-0.40064185857772827,
0.5277997851371765,
0.30206412076950073,
-0.48977479338645935,
-0.9811453223228455,
0.3276608884334564,
-0.8292540907859802,
-0.7533699870109558,
0.9963266849517822,
-0.11116005480289459,
0.04523087665438652,
-0.33958277106285095,
-0.21711015701293945,
0.19414478540420532,
-0.3734065592288971,
0.6466304659843445,
0.47670048475265503,
-0.2554413378238678,
0.4106985926628113,
-0.06985814869403839,
0.5433650612831116,
0.38773313164711,
-0.6177471280097961,
0.11118151992559433,
0.5580598711967468,
0.1831209510564804,
0.6198413372039795,
0.5205535292625427,
0.016842303797602654,
0.4811745882034302,
0.1003095880150795,
-0.08633427321910858,
-0.05448766425251961,
-0.18096546828746796,
0.03163617104291916,
0.5624160170555115,
0.0891810953617096,
0.0010881131747737527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18050v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18050v1
|
MEGAnno+: A Human-LLM Collaborative Annotation System
| 2024-02-28T04:58:07 | 2024-02-28T04:58:07 |
Hannah Kim, Kushan Mitra, Rafael Li Chen, Sajjadur Rahman, Dan Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Large language models (LLMs) can label data faster and cheaper than humans
for various NLP tasks. Despite their prowess, LLMs may fall short in
understanding of complex, sociocultural, or domain-specific context,
potentially leading to incorrect annotations. Therefore, we advocate a
collaborative approach where humans and LLMs work together to produce reliable
and high-quality labels. We present MEGAnno+, a human-LLM collaborative
annotation system that offers effective LLM agent and annotation management,
convenient and robust LLM annotation, and exploratory verification of LLM
labels by humans.
|
[
-0.3499631881713867,
-0.5622321963310242,
0.6852278113365173,
0.3475593328475952,
-0.2770412862300873,
0.6269469261169434,
-0.34842127561569214,
-1.0097533464431763,
0.48610708117485046,
0.6747234463691711,
-0.5824909210205078,
-0.8599661588668823,
-0.532145619392395,
0.5533526539802551,
-0.12830626964569092,
0.703387439250946,
0.22405780851840973,
0.13208723068237305,
-0.4256814420223236,
-0.08780312538146973,
-0.4519291818141937,
-1.0335863828659058,
-1.1289137601852417,
-0.8029215931892395,
1.1099357604980469,
0.19173160195350647,
0.8400657176971436,
0.8511404395103455,
0.4394984543323517,
0.4354020059108734,
-0.41312000155448914,
0.5960537791252136,
-0.2385798990726471,
0.18100515007972717,
-0.23515313863754272,
-0.49294543266296387,
-0.9487916231155396,
0.09898772090673447,
0.41623032093048096,
0.8813601732254028,
0.12825627624988556,
0.1857910007238388,
-0.07517409324645996,
0.38532283902168274,
-0.3095722794532776,
-0.06274203211069107,
-0.4982222318649292,
-0.012949489057064056,
-0.14360356330871582,
0.008609463460743427,
-0.4486202299594879,
-0.6500813364982605,
0.16084563732147217,
-0.978133499622345,
-0.0982423797249794,
0.2127651423215866,
0.6517869830131531,
0.41416677832603455,
-0.2957268953323364,
-0.05119285359978676,
-0.7762028574943542,
0.7499408721923828,
-0.2991585433483124,
0.29457923769950867,
0.47373634576797485,
0.29858624935150146,
-0.29312318563461304,
-0.49730822443962097,
-0.5742793679237366,
-0.4333942234516144,
-0.24412652850151062,
-0.000520711240824312,
0.32001543045043945,
0.003411891171708703,
0.08979226648807526,
-0.10782947391271591,
-0.3592877686023712,
0.39993396401405334,
-0.26174232363700867,
-0.518684446811676,
1.018438696861267,
0.3226642906665802,
0.37198635935783386,
-0.10417652130126953,
-0.6346234083175659,
0.01962166465818882,
-0.7613447904586792,
-0.562353789806366,
0.4896942973136902,
0.556495726108551,
-0.05989016965031624,
0.4680994153022766,
-0.2544028162956238,
0.7549359202384949,
-0.4549082815647125,
-0.04113297536969185,
0.3504940867424011,
-0.4307602643966675,
-0.03809593617916107,
0.2607593834400177,
1.0784815549850464,
0.3912977874279022,
0.4246552884578705,
-0.4186345636844635,
0.10209819674491882,
0.0596085786819458,
-0.11634649336338043,
-0.40831783413887024,
-0.217710480093956,
0.37344732880592346,
-0.014854014851152897,
-0.48230087757110596,
-0.05372314155101776,
-0.6598175168037415,
-0.8241382241249084,
-0.6259898543357849,
0.6521492600440979,
-0.009446904063224792,
-0.31396880745887756,
0.01477473508566618,
-0.23160120844841003,
-0.267575204372406,
0.7769091725349426,
-0.6198265552520752,
0.30901676416397095,
0.7994346618652344,
0.8989299535751343,
-0.43119996786117554,
-0.6280034780502319,
-0.250708669424057,
0.2623908221721649,
-0.35229629278182983,
0.9939566850662231,
-0.21656788885593414,
-0.40485090017318726,
-0.20326243340969086,
0.04817802831530571,
0.06380783766508102,
-0.7494667172431946,
0.5138739943504333,
-0.3152622878551483,
0.12042112648487091,
-0.23793676495552063,
-0.5639101266860962,
-0.24042287468910217,
0.4755743741989136,
-0.8364601731300354,
1.192596197128296,
0.34362396597862244,
-0.6684624552726746,
0.3576435446739197,
-0.5409348011016846,
-0.01382200326770544,
0.5195822715759277,
-0.0705084353685379,
-0.24153080582618713,
-0.517342746257782,
-0.18307973444461823,
0.6974467039108276,
-0.3852449655532837,
0.5033267140388489,
-0.3299570083618164,
-0.5878095626831055,
0.6859378218650818,
-0.07096266746520996,
0.9466168880462646,
0.07410883903503418,
-0.043551333248615265,
0.507090151309967,
-0.9014956951141357,
-0.2429981529712677,
0.32008007168769836,
-0.7600758671760559,
-0.38397231698036194,
0.013781769201159477,
0.06648673117160797,
0.2371217906475067,
0.6634870171546936,
-0.5666436553001404,
0.3703901171684265,
-0.19432926177978516,
0.3437812030315399,
0.7376483678817749,
-0.36790016293525696,
0.31275495886802673,
-0.5220765471458435,
0.28525301814079285,
-0.3660619854927063,
0.10164573043584824,
-0.049967385828495026,
-0.6494422554969788,
-0.7574869394302368,
-0.5775713324546814,
0.460652619600296,
0.8884884119033813,
-0.6731904745101929,
0.7558187246322632,
-0.2992062270641327,
-0.5122448801994324,
-0.48566001653671265,
0.3776632845401764,
0.37202998995780945,
0.3797249495983124,
0.273159921169281,
-0.10794324427843094,
-0.7661944627761841,
-0.9526786208152771,
0.11645369231700897,
-0.29630911350250244,
-0.24257399141788483,
0.1817510426044464,
0.4532095789909363,
-0.4993782639503479,
0.881219744682312,
-0.3079718351364136,
-0.3462051749229431,
-0.47574248909950256,
0.02509770728647709,
0.2151820808649063,
0.33845633268356323,
0.2819983661174774,
-0.6904814839363098,
-0.4489440321922302,
0.3527907133102417,
-0.5826098918914795,
-0.35416242480278015,
0.016167722642421722,
-0.21501778066158295,
0.31417450308799744,
0.4138217866420746,
-0.47310879826545715,
0.1444193720817566,
0.7247763872146606,
-0.5168994665145874,
0.3873656690120697,
-0.3254513144493103,
0.03212101384997368,
-1.3077569007873535,
-0.06724368035793304,
-0.15419994294643402,
-0.7136169672012329,
-0.43391600251197815,
-0.20855116844177246,
-0.237476646900177,
0.17967164516448975,
-0.539691686630249,
0.6041517853736877,
-0.014934292994439602,
0.11491894721984863,
-0.11179915070533752,
0.31795158982276917,
0.14568856358528137,
0.41559478640556335,
0.39028382301330566,
0.6990764141082764,
0.1818767488002777,
-0.45553281903266907,
0.8699778914451599,
0.2353677600622177,
0.13470003008842468,
0.7466314435005188,
-0.6770263314247131,
0.2805003225803375,
0.184154212474823,
0.20286382734775543,
-0.9209117889404297,
-0.6133821606636047,
0.47568854689598083,
-0.4564878046512604,
-0.020968008786439896,
-0.22355620563030243,
-0.9993529915809631,
-0.225708469748497,
-0.4306949973106384,
0.2065473198890686,
0.0993466004729271,
-0.691007137298584,
0.575041651725769,
0.3621870279312134,
-0.1564103662967682,
-0.117967888712883,
-0.6592444181442261,
0.3720305562019348,
-0.38410836458206177,
-0.710318386554718,
0.23920638859272003,
0.03793761506676674,
-0.4607706069946289,
-0.09472507238388062,
0.654312014579773,
-0.27096590399742126,
0.2840893566608429,
0.45344671607017517,
0.3905927836894989,
0.0912865698337555,
0.21800263226032257,
-0.29994675517082214,
-0.43174365162849426,
-0.04422755166888237,
-0.033504050225019455,
0.6170410513877869,
0.05337825044989586,
-0.12069863080978394,
-0.7176964282989502,
0.39511722326278687,
0.4058290123939514,
0.17164145410060883,
0.8519060611724854,
0.5372236967086792,
-0.5712607502937317,
0.02209017239511013,
-0.6670910120010376,
0.06971020996570587,
-0.47232288122177124,
0.24510839581489563,
0.038306824862957,
-1.1046967506408691,
0.6598541140556335,
-0.3498079478740692,
-0.30035194754600525,
0.4765230715274811,
0.6228835582733154,
-0.3113526701927185,
0.7206111550331116,
0.6476800441741943,
-0.059783950448036194,
0.2471657544374466,
-0.033350978046655655,
-0.35329678654670715,
-0.8114402890205383,
-0.6765932440757751,
-0.5972074866294861,
-0.3206480145454407,
-0.5433762073516846,
-0.45789068937301636,
0.1664363145828247,
-0.07796834409236908,
-0.2727643847465515,
0.7115625143051147,
-0.8611957430839539,
0.629460871219635,
0.7700315117835999,
0.22307799756526947,
0.6666207909584045,
-0.33128663897514343,
0.013569463975727558,
0.011478167027235031,
-0.5183199048042297,
-0.7784619331359863,
0.9248723983764648,
0.23022979497909546,
0.5179106593132019,
0.09529394656419754,
0.8351091146469116,
0.44113829731941223,
0.5678940415382385,
-0.7620295286178589,
0.6395808458328247,
-0.04090254008769989,
-0.8528695702552795,
-0.331076979637146,
-0.4083282947540283,
-0.9978448748588562,
0.1971132457256317,
-0.6425994038581848,
-1.1603739261627197,
-0.043961744755506516,
0.1200619786977768,
-0.5716375708580017,
0.27216944098472595,
-0.8610413670539856,
0.8557344675064087,
-0.2896142899990082,
-0.37604352831840515,
-0.01596524380147457,
-0.5903555154800415,
0.1621597707271576,
-0.4599224030971527,
0.3601197302341461,
-0.554082453250885,
-0.30915868282318115,
0.8716700673103333,
-0.5007625222206116,
1.0581310987472534,
0.2006516307592392,
-0.09142854064702988,
0.4386712908744812,
0.16411295533180237,
0.3867867588996887,
-0.006925977300852537,
-0.11262354999780655,
0.36281222105026245,
-0.02646198682487011,
-0.02385062351822853,
-0.26240119338035583,
0.5942132472991943,
-0.8888385891914368,
-0.2213377207517624,
-0.31120607256889343,
-0.5615319609642029,
0.07162933796644211,
0.01721094734966755,
0.05675312504172325,
0.02818329818546772,
0.07484480738639832,
-0.07976359128952026,
0.49167370796203613,
-0.27255168557167053,
0.3446103632450104,
0.11641164869070053,
-0.5227643251419067,
-0.9803605675697327,
1.0120364427566528,
0.2277890294790268,
0.1940833032131195,
0.31099703907966614,
0.3416321873664856,
-0.19110949337482452,
-0.4904719591140747,
-0.4461207687854767,
0.34697088599205017,
-0.6069326400756836,
-0.17478011548519135,
-0.5148336291313171,
-0.04892349988222122,
0.04424469918012619,
-0.3825400173664093,
-0.48288512229919434,
-0.5812860131263733,
-0.2937781512737274,
-0.029852144420146942,
0.8303394317626953,
1.094352126121521,
-0.059088557958602905,
0.6175762414932251,
-0.8507025241851807,
0.10551278293132782,
0.47398778796195984,
0.17064283788204193,
-0.36908745765686035,
-0.0883224681019783,
-0.2455071657896042,
-0.04223308339715004,
-0.09895472228527069,
-0.8532211184501648,
0.2001422643661499,
-0.19443506002426147,
0.2951202392578125,
0.11005952954292297,
-0.2500755488872528,
0.41463980078697205,
-0.26606935262680054,
0.7202825546264648,
0.11996676027774811,
-0.9488847851753235,
0.4354360103607178,
-0.8414117693901062,
0.007676339708268642,
0.6097985506057739,
0.38124749064445496,
-0.6938028931617737,
-0.34513458609580994,
-0.3997170627117157,
-0.9645110368728638,
0.6872864365577698,
0.27069661021232605,
0.061340413987636566,
0.036725662648677826,
0.5192044377326965,
0.15477950870990753,
-0.004170029889792204,
-0.7572072744369507,
-0.14887133240699768,
0.3604086935520172,
-0.24752087891101837,
-0.0776045098900795,
-0.2719804346561432,
-0.0751131922006607,
-0.3828672468662262,
0.5956025123596191,
-0.038037367165088654,
0.1343643069267273,
0.32937222719192505,
0.0018218348268419504,
0.04942106083035469,
0.031289007514715195,
0.6689950227737427,
0.5723661780357361,
-0.37156710028648376,
0.2154821753501892,
0.5515604615211487,
-0.31995490193367004,
0.22041846811771393,
0.044068593531847,
-0.10481961816549301,
-0.025945795699954033,
0.6580544710159302,
0.40403881669044495,
-0.01646246388554573,
-0.6097360253334045,
0.3475334942340851,
-0.14066840708255768,
-0.31210434436798096,
-0.5584957599639893,
0.16461244225502014,
0.7496472001075745,
0.3348366320133209,
0.2679675221443176,
-0.09007979184389114,
-0.05887778475880623,
-0.22727374732494354,
0.05258828029036522,
0.20644016563892365,
-0.38149362802505493,
-0.44051092863082886,
0.724786639213562,
0.5167220830917358,
-0.8005200028419495,
0.2937457263469696,
-0.2816154360771179,
-0.7223032712936401,
0.7555899024009705,
0.33213934302330017,
0.7530977725982666,
-0.21959935128688812,
0.2847122251987457,
0.3599565923213959,
0.34344249963760376,
-0.2019956409931183,
0.22345787286758423,
0.010844098404049873,
-0.8292925357818604,
-0.8250941038131714,
-0.4920338988304138,
-0.9829320907592773,
-0.16219216585159302,
-0.3413819968700409,
0.39137473702430725,
-0.5478678345680237,
-0.4258020222187042,
0.04657954350113869,
0.09140052646398544,
-0.5695158839225769,
0.2946709096431732,
0.37600424885749817,
0.5928015112876892,
-0.7712050080299377,
0.8500126004219055,
0.732019305229187,
-0.35704463720321655,
-0.6453233957290649,
-0.6950768232345581,
0.05342607945203781,
-0.6694681644439697,
0.949246346950531,
0.2969096004962921,
-0.37303808331489563,
-0.019732562825083733,
-0.6434083580970764,
-0.7664439678192139,
1.2838051319122314,
0.4626460671424866,
-0.664894700050354,
0.33974558115005493,
0.523589551448822,
0.7433241605758667,
-0.41026702523231506,
-0.06395353376865387,
0.44396376609802246,
0.6638883948326111,
0.1902218759059906,
-1.0504777431488037,
0.1305083930492401,
0.1855674833059311,
-0.15226535499095917,
0.1845816671848297,
-0.7147697806358337,
0.6673222780227661,
-0.07814285159111023,
0.03197680413722992,
0.3252156674861908,
0.3644661605358124,
0.18591977655887604,
0.3724641799926758,
0.45822376012802124,
0.5649705529212952,
0.9777585864067078,
-0.23617272078990936,
1.037199854850769,
0.13267499208450317,
0.23304085433483124,
1.3368955850601196,
-0.30498257279396057,
0.9062995314598083,
0.37201350927352905,
-0.3637961149215698,
0.25102734565734863,
0.8359038829803467,
0.10410009324550629,
-0.19568420946598053,
0.3678399324417114,
-0.5612008571624756,
-0.7025655508041382,
-0.6848160624504089,
-0.07282266765832901,
0.2937116026878357,
0.3770538866519928,
-0.1939937174320221,
0.06858629733324051,
-0.41932064294815063,
0.24945403635501862,
0.25693991780281067,
-0.19605235755443573,
0.9675402641296387,
0.027919966727495193,
-0.2564378082752228,
0.3057432472705841,
-0.10446961969137192,
0.940013587474823,
-0.31934061646461487,
-0.020637553185224533,
-0.005581973120570183,
0.025036059319972992,
-0.4879606068134308,
-0.7661074995994568,
0.47356274724006653,
-0.07296847552061081,
0.05760321021080017,
-0.08355005085468292,
0.7306679487228394,
-0.5437115430831909,
-0.6709646582603455,
0.7155330181121826,
0.588988184928894,
0.24364495277404785,
-0.16709941625595093,
-0.3720663785934448,
0.3628707826137543,
-0.2186761349439621,
-0.0568719245493412,
0.01696283370256424,
0.20514915883541107,
-0.2887110412120819,
0.9271265864372253,
0.8373445868492126,
0.2752787470817566,
-0.05121471360325813,
0.1699027717113495,
0.7363771200180054,
-0.7481688261032104,
0.09148766845464706,
-1.301144003868103,
0.4987774193286896,
-0.36433297395706177,
-0.23128187656402588,
0.5995948314666748,
0.4226878583431244,
0.9399577379226685,
0.25390174984931946,
0.7215254306793213,
0.4067705571651459,
0.6131354570388794,
-0.2603827118873596,
1.0182939767837524,
-0.3763444125652313,
0.08831658959388733,
-0.22320254147052765,
-1.2009360790252686,
-0.9938010573387146,
0.6054869890213013,
0.008970954455435276,
-0.11228226870298386,
0.4593278467655182,
0.5776739120483398,
0.4708065092563629,
-0.28931090235710144,
0.5030261874198914,
-0.18784961104393005,
0.17394153773784637,
0.5684383511543274,
1.3524614572525024,
-0.06869932264089584,
0.4898476004600525,
-0.4486464560031891,
0.05905730277299881,
-0.1133502870798111,
-1.0262641906738281,
-1.2836352586746216,
-0.4038461744785309,
-0.578380823135376,
-0.20396386086940765,
-0.04063219577074051,
1.4617197513580322,
0.8454903364181519,
-0.5575999021530151,
-0.21962763369083405,
0.23396658897399902,
0.5220319628715515,
0.22280094027519226,
-0.18342551589012146,
0.2415129691362381,
0.16889551281929016,
-0.8488014936447144,
0.21507026255130768,
0.39235761761665344,
0.2616364061832428,
-0.4608009159564972,
-0.2683175206184387,
-0.15573136508464813,
0.036693353205919266,
0.5773555040359497,
-0.09141054004430771,
-0.6001815795898438,
-0.4426570534706116,
-0.2656939625740051,
-0.20270591974258423,
0.20521695911884308,
0.45114389061927795,
-0.8104419708251953,
0.411081463098526,
0.5447684526443481,
0.6224513649940491,
0.07224638015031815,
0.051302626729011536,
0.47773483395576477,
-0.6333683133125305,
0.2588934600353241,
0.16783291101455688,
0.32103079557418823,
0.6641412973403931,
-0.5590970516204834,
0.7114456295967102,
0.4332575798034668,
-0.6373612284660339,
-0.5814229846000671,
0.09488020837306976,
-1.1614376306533813,
-0.047773707658052444,
1.1726917028427124,
-0.20673112571239471,
-0.386161208152771,
-0.3750854730606079,
-0.6861454844474792,
0.18233606219291687,
-0.40492793917655945,
0.6177482008934021,
0.8157855272293091,
-0.035141829401254654,
0.19236016273498535,
-0.41171935200691223,
0.22116592526435852,
-0.0647001639008522,
-1.0558029413223267,
-0.10691053420305252,
0.3880749046802521,
0.24078962206840515,
0.5518254041671753,
0.6242640614509583,
0.17835110425949097,
0.03468751162290573,
-0.20871712267398834,
0.5108525156974792,
-0.3910664916038513,
-0.34825044870376587,
-0.10573571175336838,
-0.06250564008951187,
0.35999733209609985,
-0.12905900180339813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18048v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18048v1
|
Characterizing Truthfulness in Large Language Model Generations with Local Intrinsic Dimension
| 2024-02-28T04:56:21 | 2024-02-28T04:56:21 |
Fan Yin, Jayanth Srinivasa, Kai-Wei Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We study how to characterize and predict the truthfulness of texts generated
from large language models (LLMs), which serves as a crucial step in building
trust between humans and LLMs. Although several approaches based on entropy or
verbalized uncertainty have been proposed to calibrate model predictions, these
methods are often intractable, sensitive to hyperparameters, and less reliable
when applied in generative tasks with LLMs. In this paper, we suggest
investigating internal activations and quantifying LLM's truthfulness using the
local intrinsic dimension (LID) of model activations. Through experiments on
four question answering (QA) datasets, we demonstrate the effectiveness
ohttps://info.arxiv.org/help/prep#abstractsf our proposed method. Additionally,
we study intrinsic dimensions in LLMs and their relations with model layers,
autoregressive language modeling, and the training of LLMs, revealing that
intrinsic dimensions can be a powerful approach to understanding LLMs.
|
[
-0.11781258881092072,
-0.8588173985481262,
0.933786153793335,
-0.046138931065797806,
-0.083875872194767,
0.13025158643722534,
-0.29764723777770996,
-0.6483503580093384,
-0.1984764039516449,
0.30540940165519714,
-0.27458906173706055,
-0.39276957511901855,
-0.40682855248451233,
0.0853792279958725,
-0.21101975440979004,
0.6128120422363281,
-0.15943023562431335,
0.135872021317482,
-0.752506673336029,
-0.25557389855384827,
-0.03125393018126488,
-0.8110439777374268,
-0.49096471071243286,
-0.5796234011650085,
0.4053993821144104,
0.19931404292583466,
0.5413758158683777,
0.5803148150444031,
0.5431305170059204,
0.27298882603645325,
-0.30085909366607666,
0.04528168961405754,
-0.3590978980064392,
0.3279111385345459,
-0.07118148356676102,
-0.7587219476699829,
-0.31342613697052,
0.18918845057487488,
1.0410335063934326,
0.680305004119873,
-0.011668577790260315,
0.5010176301002502,
0.16894344985485077,
0.4434335231781006,
-0.4631196856498718,
0.31259408593177795,
-0.8888433575630188,
-0.009241361171007156,
0.06818055361509323,
-0.1440206915140152,
-0.3304016590118408,
-0.6758854389190674,
0.22716526687145233,
-0.28996631503105164,
0.2289225310087204,
-0.033749960362911224,
0.8008326292037964,
0.29300785064697266,
-0.6396698355674744,
-0.2703976035118103,
-1.0047035217285156,
0.9495431184768677,
-1.059382677078247,
0.31823623180389404,
0.6152308583259583,
0.02520243637263775,
0.21788421273231506,
-0.48947346210479736,
-0.746118426322937,
-0.5283928513526917,
-0.04495205730199814,
-0.1212102547287941,
0.050065990537405014,
-0.09721289575099945,
0.2892467677593231,
0.7720004916191101,
-0.5201441645622253,
0.3007969260215759,
0.10226244479417801,
-0.25174129009246826,
0.36986905336380005,
0.2088128626346588,
0.0967608317732811,
-0.09865108132362366,
-0.46094563603401184,
-0.004120748955756426,
-0.8431636691093445,
0.27238646149635315,
0.5871964693069458,
0.06006608530879021,
-0.12751267850399017,
0.6237584948539734,
-0.28506457805633545,
0.38558998703956604,
0.15206731855869293,
-0.4977883994579315,
0.34828314185142517,
-0.41285115480422974,
-0.04311225935816765,
-0.02471708506345749,
0.618977963924408,
0.0010187550215050578,
-0.06382717192173004,
-0.21155032515525818,
-0.23290309309959412,
-0.12680122256278992,
0.12592007219791412,
-1.0447028875350952,
0.4147387742996216,
0.34038302302360535,
-0.4682179391384125,
-0.51789391040802,
-0.04928429052233696,
-0.13058693706989288,
-0.3725832998752594,
-0.46474671363830566,
0.5288294553756714,
-0.629572868347168,
-0.4008398652076721,
-0.0024025931488722563,
0.18684376776218414,
0.4817119538784027,
0.10691379755735397,
-0.6160922050476074,
0.05526464059948921,
0.648879885673523,
0.6027240753173828,
0.03146299347281456,
-0.3531719446182251,
-0.3894343972206116,
0.053936950862407684,
-0.4328223168849945,
0.4965912401676178,
-0.5379748344421387,
-0.03161194920539856,
0.032333869487047195,
-0.37100037932395935,
0.027602901682257652,
-0.7014480233192444,
0.7990292906761169,
-0.6612539887428284,
0.13509172201156616,
-0.5407678484916687,
-0.7572060227394104,
-0.27816125750541687,
0.5396068096160889,
-0.35711780190467834,
1.0654230117797852,
0.028814466670155525,
-0.8714054822921753,
0.2735218405723572,
-0.4192778766155243,
-0.148807093501091,
0.1337772011756897,
-0.16572199761867523,
-0.32711243629455566,
0.5791143774986267,
0.03379158303141594,
0.5360650420188904,
-0.33094659447669983,
0.47221335768699646,
-0.39801979064941406,
0.021694360300898552,
0.761660635471344,
-0.8568887710571289,
0.7094161510467529,
0.011282337829470634,
-0.20439930260181427,
-0.045882225036621094,
-0.7521181702613831,
0.22443148493766785,
0.114977166056633,
-0.27329596877098083,
-0.3149043023586273,
-0.029714301228523254,
-0.5505420565605164,
0.18494266271591187,
0.6327279806137085,
-0.8179256319999695,
-0.012692381627857685,
-0.5216719508171082,
0.34044405817985535,
0.7658525109291077,
0.2916001081466675,
0.26981133222579956,
-0.20781248807907104,
0.4517391324043274,
0.2249133586883545,
0.1639549434185028,
-0.03352523595094681,
-0.33824726939201355,
-0.7472835183143616,
-0.12183212488889694,
0.3471217751502991,
0.21487577259540558,
-0.7812245488166809,
0.8009930849075317,
-0.551099956035614,
-0.560746431350708,
-0.354352742433548,
0.14890708029270172,
0.3364220857620239,
0.7156851291656494,
0.05535797029733658,
-0.30886340141296387,
0.08743208646774292,
-1.1406261920928955,
-0.12646183371543884,
-0.6732072234153748,
-0.2768598198890686,
0.3274369537830353,
0.633338451385498,
-0.08833343535661697,
1.151593565940857,
-0.24528267979621887,
0.07592551410198212,
0.10371590405702591,
0.612194299697876,
0.08647497743368149,
0.28131046891212463,
0.4216688573360443,
-0.6867784857749939,
-0.4721374213695526,
-0.05159694701433182,
-0.9750377535820007,
-0.07527614384889603,
-0.09560205787420273,
0.21510033309459686,
0.13325777649879456,
0.11357678472995758,
-0.547417402267456,
0.3386736214160919,
0.6849176287651062,
-0.1858021765947342,
0.7074857950210571,
-0.23406048119068146,
0.10066806524991989,
-0.8365429043769836,
0.025451770052313805,
0.04123139753937721,
-0.17452925443649292,
-0.5896680951118469,
0.2330397367477417,
0.09756100922822952,
0.22459577023983002,
-0.30798646807670593,
0.5335134863853455,
-0.6051754355430603,
-0.20407597720623016,
-0.20831765234470367,
-0.038195475935935974,
0.05369187146425247,
0.43728703260421753,
0.09802359342575073,
0.8434473276138306,
0.6782011985778809,
-0.5053988695144653,
0.5371096134185791,
0.04172982648015022,
-0.6545265913009644,
0.7660510540008545,
-0.799642026424408,
0.3588177561759949,
-0.21580305695533752,
0.11144060641527176,
-0.7392852306365967,
-0.12916803359985352,
-0.23216314613819122,
-0.7580336332321167,
0.24722586572170258,
-0.009185811504721642,
-0.9381783604621887,
-0.10836444050073624,
-0.3467912971973419,
0.4935680329799652,
0.4008050858974457,
-0.5206992030143738,
0.7955086827278137,
0.22193877398967743,
-0.1906624734401703,
-0.26235726475715637,
-0.6391514539718628,
0.09519010037183762,
-0.3013763427734375,
-0.8199207186698914,
0.08208316564559937,
-0.2790532410144806,
-0.4944702386856079,
-0.15230770409107208,
-0.126592218875885,
-0.042756062000989914,
0.12781064212322235,
0.3607984185218811,
0.12053632736206055,
-0.37877610325813293,
0.2077026218175888,
-0.1089242547750473,
0.03949804604053497,
0.3665216267108917,
-0.220160111784935,
0.5068183541297913,
-0.6364190578460693,
-0.38931646943092346,
-0.4735228717327118,
0.06564745306968689,
0.6443661451339722,
-0.41560661792755127,
1.2051469087600708,
0.6413551568984985,
-0.3926701247692108,
-0.05441903695464134,
-0.7391953468322754,
-0.394203245639801,
-0.5048010945320129,
0.17909197509288788,
-0.3634839951992035,
-0.9271705746650696,
0.8284815549850464,
0.1233021691441536,
-0.17455843091011047,
0.3376244306564331,
0.8123002648353577,
-0.03801647201180458,
1.001020908355713,
0.5234821438789368,
-0.012569520622491837,
0.16632221639156342,
-0.0936216413974762,
0.3346233367919922,
-1.122503399848938,
-0.1702992171049118,
-0.6570350527763367,
-0.11837353557348251,
-0.4826829731464386,
-0.5468150973320007,
0.7559351921081543,
0.21660034358501434,
-0.37708333134651184,
-0.21093904972076416,
-0.09012424945831299,
0.37892115116119385,
0.7053597569465637,
0.16860489547252655,
0.4282570779323578,
-0.002804386429488659,
-0.13504265248775482,
-0.14150969684123993,
-0.3690037727355957,
-0.7440832257270813,
0.9831734895706177,
0.8367300033569336,
0.7715429663658142,
0.1063513457775116,
0.43312153220176697,
-0.1612158864736557,
0.303531289100647,
-0.8018917441368103,
0.5308780670166016,
0.27185124158859253,
-0.7544689774513245,
-0.5003775954246521,
-0.8269903063774109,
-0.5823812484741211,
-0.056531354784965515,
-0.1414797604084015,
-0.8902435898780823,
0.212751105427742,
0.010319738648831844,
-0.2902737557888031,
0.5235345363616943,
-0.6021614074707031,
0.5086091756820679,
-0.3494839072227478,
-0.2881847620010376,
-0.17351780831813812,
-0.6719485521316528,
0.3483503460884094,
-0.15238121151924133,
-0.09728007763624191,
-0.16823086142539978,
-0.08536721765995026,
0.5415369272232056,
-0.11324416100978851,
1.057579755783081,
0.09838566184043884,
-0.6320520043373108,
0.31284797191619873,
0.24751485884189606,
0.6988201141357422,
0.09966069459915161,
-0.3597091734409332,
0.45301491022109985,
-0.11593196541070938,
-0.2644199728965759,
-0.6440309286117554,
0.8705406785011292,
-0.8944186568260193,
-0.49416765570640564,
-0.3954203128814697,
-0.6752597093582153,
-0.6718043684959412,
0.07491271942853928,
0.265389621257782,
0.5205691456794739,
-0.15800079703330994,
0.6931893229484558,
1.0644192695617676,
-0.27127382159233093,
0.29501429200172424,
0.6365551352500916,
-0.06372226774692535,
-0.056288257241249084,
0.9015822410583496,
0.21137042343616486,
0.5816642642021179,
0.720268726348877,
0.49007683992385864,
-0.5293222069740295,
-0.5901942849159241,
0.028870923444628716,
0.2683377265930176,
-0.6808184385299683,
-0.22680287063121796,
-0.4691575765609741,
-0.46801841259002686,
-0.42684677243232727,
0.21444617211818695,
-0.3665052354335785,
-0.2976817488670349,
-0.30125147104263306,
-0.4187520444393158,
0.1362653225660324,
0.5622171759605408,
-0.08298172801733017,
0.0003582686767913401,
-0.9009199142456055,
0.3171059489250183,
0.6646179556846619,
0.3872818648815155,
0.09357665479183197,
-0.8832983374595642,
-0.3064914345741272,
0.3487250804901123,
-0.2317933887243271,
-0.6654441356658936,
0.22300775349140167,
0.13115550577640533,
0.6945701241493225,
0.651276171207428,
0.2920856475830078,
0.05023779720067978,
-0.1634911298751831,
0.9894396662712097,
-0.023153753951191902,
-1.1184909343719482,
0.3905549645423889,
-0.39405903220176697,
0.28832778334617615,
0.4528180956840515,
0.43619999289512634,
-0.36423105001449585,
-0.6773947477340698,
-0.7070319652557373,
-0.4542643427848816,
0.264844685792923,
0.29228323698043823,
0.42835018038749695,
0.27396059036254883,
0.5969420075416565,
0.20943649113178253,
0.4005127251148224,
-0.9138807654380798,
-0.35379353165626526,
0.03378301113843918,
-0.14168056845664978,
0.011542361229658127,
-0.6391143202781677,
-0.06698683649301529,
-0.10153879970312119,
0.7242640256881714,
-0.359605997800827,
0.2165990173816681,
0.131846621632576,
0.08510356396436691,
-0.3256186544895172,
0.3395608365535736,
0.3820793628692627,
0.9216732978820801,
-0.32679545879364014,
0.48244863748550415,
0.16495107114315033,
-0.39007335901260376,
0.1742846518754959,
-0.38623282313346863,
-0.34780171513557434,
-0.2639424800872803,
0.5894556045532227,
0.8734849095344543,
-0.40244725346565247,
-0.37567442655563354,
0.5023861527442932,
-0.037934817373752594,
-0.026477470993995667,
-0.27613455057144165,
0.03691381216049194,
-0.05044803395867348,
0.09471480548381805,
0.3332003355026245,
-0.06634959578514099,
-0.14890986680984497,
-0.808728039264679,
-0.16477257013320923,
0.5733276009559631,
-0.4853571951389313,
-0.6039512753486633,
0.3720293343067169,
0.16561703383922577,
-0.007371637038886547,
0.6683551073074341,
-0.3088047206401825,
-0.7560121417045593,
0.40993717312812805,
0.31444427371025085,
1.0735846757888794,
-0.2855553925037384,
0.3503274917602539,
0.38994351029396057,
0.6217741370201111,
0.19385790824890137,
-0.013280792161822319,
0.06179365515708923,
-1.25612211227417,
-0.622745156288147,
-0.7477204203605652,
-0.4774247109889984,
0.3429252803325653,
-0.8611854910850525,
-0.4275093376636505,
-0.20496298372745514,
-0.0964721143245697,
-0.34641674160957336,
0.19211335480213165,
-0.5237502455711365,
0.31275638937950134,
0.27454227209091187,
0.6453748941421509,
-0.7949246168136597,
0.9871475696563721,
0.46973326802253723,
-0.24552936851978302,
-0.7335493564605713,
0.407748818397522,
0.013695879839360714,
-0.972272515296936,
0.8763402104377747,
0.018233733251690865,
-0.23204880952835083,
-0.15906481444835663,
-0.8664121031761169,
-0.8025278449058533,
1.0208673477172852,
0.4922284185886383,
-0.26650726795196533,
-0.011368156410753727,
0.4561730921268463,
0.7990904450416565,
-0.2510780692100525,
0.11164824664592743,
0.42406165599823,
0.4687485992908478,
0.14139309525489807,
-0.8573533892631531,
0.03132513538002968,
0.012241923250257969,
0.2147400826215744,
-0.10264607518911362,
-0.5951534509658813,
0.7688190340995789,
-0.18771079182624817,
-0.2410976141691208,
0.14826932549476624,
0.9639765620231628,
0.1518077701330185,
-0.0828123539686203,
0.49223822355270386,
0.7312867641448975,
0.9199087619781494,
-0.03774959594011307,
1.1470102071762085,
-0.4798057973384857,
0.5014623403549194,
1.1060386896133423,
-0.4017893671989441,
0.9081580638885498,
0.3914634883403778,
-0.07661779969930649,
0.3982650339603424,
0.3079412877559662,
0.2248414307832718,
0.16341230273246765,
0.16047120094299316,
-0.5153526663780212,
-0.42698800563812256,
-0.39823460578918457,
-0.24685688316822052,
0.3519628643989563,
0.31089648604393005,
-0.15672001242637634,
0.03198004886507988,
0.024662723764777184,
-0.12581178545951843,
-0.03636637702584267,
-0.20835945010185242,
0.7397412061691284,
0.06839784979820251,
-0.341389924287796,
0.4246982932090759,
0.04404141753911972,
0.5895137786865234,
-0.6299161314964294,
0.14331530034542084,
-0.34268108010292053,
0.048862703144550323,
0.10102523118257523,
-1.1130143404006958,
0.06294866651296616,
-0.024072295054793358,
-0.2929590940475464,
-0.2014022022485733,
0.5451884269714355,
-0.34359198808670044,
-0.5892868638038635,
0.016969168558716774,
0.485542893409729,
-0.12661686539649963,
-0.4263013005256653,
-0.44303494691848755,
0.027490602806210518,
-0.034573495388031006,
-0.31939733028411865,
0.33347707986831665,
0.8307830691337585,
0.33203399181365967,
0.9851436018943787,
0.5976735949516296,
0.2586306631565094,
0.10754834860563278,
-0.16659872233867645,
0.5067449808120728,
-0.4986075460910797,
-0.20081274211406708,
-0.622612476348877,
0.2722513973712921,
0.02417117729783058,
-0.3719910979270935,
1.0249807834625244,
0.5354686975479126,
0.8117514848709106,
0.14799998700618744,
0.5922669768333435,
0.19805483520030975,
0.6904213428497314,
-0.7321373224258423,
0.45149630308151245,
-0.4126649796962738,
0.4308781623840332,
0.1899898201227188,
-1.0281682014465332,
0.08196433633565903,
0.4519617557525635,
-0.4694115221500397,
0.03879879042506218,
0.7633575797080994,
0.8074641823768616,
0.22338543832302094,
-0.047126393765211105,
0.5065406560897827,
0.7669293284416199,
0.30715838074684143,
0.28077876567840576,
1.213738203048706,
-0.1859784871339798,
0.11804497987031937,
-0.47697702050209045,
-0.2546468675136566,
-0.03684910014271736,
-0.9632221460342407,
-0.7913157343864441,
-0.7129086256027222,
-0.4861881136894226,
-0.37199485301971436,
-0.609255850315094,
0.6235013008117676,
0.6381996870040894,
-0.6142764091491699,
-0.04593160003423691,
0.14039616286754608,
0.14621737599372864,
-0.07970055937767029,
-0.2871791124343872,
0.2813401222229004,
-0.3123006224632263,
-0.621669352054596,
0.24515503644943237,
0.2776460349559784,
0.19146117568016052,
-0.7237629890441895,
0.04586980119347572,
0.16846300661563873,
0.37528830766677856,
0.6595848202705383,
0.0020260687451809645,
-0.6749297976493835,
-0.5627071261405945,
-0.019459325820207596,
-0.38350602984428406,
0.19666966795921326,
0.7628092169761658,
-0.5792928338050842,
0.2603408992290497,
0.6652518510818481,
0.36981287598609924,
0.3489345610141754,
0.12367671728134155,
0.5743445754051208,
-1.0051817893981934,
-0.1914290487766266,
0.47592103481292725,
0.306917667388916,
0.4541568458080292,
-0.3755395710468292,
0.30792036652565,
-0.004565199371427298,
-0.7076630592346191,
-0.9281685948371887,
0.2889137864112854,
-0.8229007124900818,
-0.14329840242862701,
1.3215347528457642,
-0.18262499570846558,
-0.09744392335414886,
0.05329664424061775,
0.18942207098007202,
-0.20143036544322968,
-0.18568646907806396,
0.7720551490783691,
0.9268420934677124,
0.024113759398460388,
-0.060569800436496735,
-0.44599494338035583,
0.30271217226982117,
0.20212411880493164,
-0.9498457312583923,
0.2718144655227661,
0.5020480751991272,
0.16061070561408997,
0.5090446472167969,
0.2911486327648163,
-0.15312722325325012,
-0.2506629526615143,
0.01740887016057968,
0.025819972157478333,
0.07020509243011475,
-0.2649116516113281,
-0.31177496910095215,
0.1557203233242035,
0.44422048330307007,
0.14081579446792603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18045v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18045v2
|
Multi-FAct: Assessing Multilingual LLMs' Multi-Regional Knowledge using FActScore
| 2024-02-28T04:43:46 | 2024-03-01T12:35:55 |
Sheikh Shafayat, Eunsu Kim, Juhyun Oh, Alice Oh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are prone to factuality hallucination,
generating text that contradicts established knowledge. While extensive
research has addressed this in English, little is known about multilingual
LLMs. This paper systematically evaluates multilingual LLMs' factual accuracy
across languages and geographic regions. We introduce a novel pipeline for
multilingual factuality evaluation, adapting FActScore(Min et al., 2023) for
diverse languages. Our analysis across nine languages reveals that English
consistently outperforms others in factual accuracy and quantity of generated
facts. Furthermore, multilingual models demonstrate a bias towards factual
information from Western continents. These findings highlight the need for
improved multilingual factuality assessment and underscore geographical biases
in LLMs' fact generation.
|
[
-0.28385862708091736,
-0.6870519518852234,
0.8194876909255981,
0.25841671228408813,
-0.07509532570838928,
0.2160084992647171,
-0.5208444595336914,
-0.4667727053165436,
0.21843288838863373,
0.38363879919052124,
-0.4698983430862427,
-0.7885227799415588,
-0.7625988125801086,
0.3124086260795593,
-0.10807572305202484,
0.9185892343521118,
0.174503892660141,
0.19517569243907928,
-0.43621861934661865,
-0.6937905550003052,
-0.29439905285835266,
-0.8391202688217163,
-0.05194738507270813,
-0.2744133770465851,
0.4949409067630768,
0.6052249073982239,
0.6392147541046143,
0.3492809534072876,
0.6004201173782349,
0.37371113896369934,
0.05121731385588646,
0.7071415781974792,
-0.41704273223876953,
0.04134059324860573,
-0.2239840179681778,
-0.6770234704017639,
-0.37882956862449646,
-0.011977318674325943,
0.6972619295120239,
0.6291150450706482,
-0.1933271288871765,
0.3469316363334656,
-0.15563297271728516,
0.500213623046875,
-0.5593807101249695,
0.23256824910640717,
-0.824440598487854,
0.00004328368595452048,
-0.20263226330280304,
-0.22151091694831848,
-0.45762011408805847,
-0.69813072681427,
0.19501280784606934,
-0.21258802711963654,
0.6172289252281189,
0.21943724155426025,
0.6520667672157288,
0.23840154707431793,
-0.9197756052017212,
-0.6087909936904907,
-0.6902467012405396,
0.795232355594635,
-0.5384543538093567,
0.753887414932251,
0.05857785791158676,
0.20700538158416748,
0.10907518118619919,
-0.48780784010887146,
-0.48933520913124084,
-0.24506273865699768,
-0.24551372230052948,
0.18249033391475677,
0.03562935069203377,
-0.38573163747787476,
0.23327504098415375,
0.20938096940517426,
-0.5349504947662354,
0.0060839164070785046,
-0.4376208782196045,
-0.4539029896259308,
0.6920116543769836,
0.055642273277044296,
0.2825259268283844,
-0.3395536243915558,
-0.576489269733429,
0.3047950267791748,
-0.90642249584198,
-0.03722907602787018,
0.39850401878356934,
0.5968843698501587,
-0.35985425114631653,
0.6638144850730896,
0.01510907057672739,
0.4204489588737488,
-0.30570322275161743,
-0.8964169025421143,
0.33906590938568115,
-0.6256216168403625,
0.10876234620809555,
0.29451191425323486,
0.610869288444519,
0.5950105786323547,
-0.02473314106464386,
-0.16094788908958435,
0.09557594358921051,
0.05214885622262955,
-0.1851729303598404,
-0.5923077464103699,
-0.08570341765880585,
0.2708548903465271,
-0.05201534181833267,
0.22579452395439148,
-0.017550254240632057,
-0.7857517600059509,
-0.49351540207862854,
-0.30053412914276123,
-0.007134355138987303,
-0.3972567021846771,
-0.22340127825737,
0.11758396029472351,
-0.04046749323606491,
0.018273046240210533,
0.37125203013420105,
-0.3991408944129944,
-0.019890611991286278,
0.4966904819011688,
0.8155961036682129,
-0.19222435355186462,
-0.8101451992988586,
-0.3700065314769745,
0.0198797769844532,
-0.3193477690219879,
1.268020749092102,
-0.3113066256046295,
-0.01603829115629196,
0.04965395852923393,
0.128202423453331,
-0.08837389945983887,
-0.4252627193927765,
0.6683092713356018,
-0.4700506925582886,
0.344756543636322,
-0.7847867608070374,
-0.24567994475364685,
-0.5825982689857483,
0.6157307624816895,
-0.6911577582359314,
1.0466893911361694,
-0.31949475407600403,
-0.7455561757087708,
0.7422034740447998,
-0.4292827546596527,
-0.5087607502937317,
-0.20371246337890625,
-0.0905468761920929,
-0.19134145975112915,
0.06401478499174118,
0.264271080493927,
0.2647058367729187,
-0.4140698313713074,
0.6784505248069763,
-0.24974295496940613,
-0.049044106155633926,
0.3568246066570282,
-0.7280504703521729,
0.611008882522583,
0.08256921917200089,
-0.20184364914894104,
-0.04470593482255936,
-0.8722894191741943,
-0.3134233355522156,
-0.02166903018951416,
-0.5145521759986877,
-0.2160414755344391,
0.13411369919776917,
-0.2892381548881531,
0.4035637676715851,
0.22200891375541687,
-0.6963796019554138,
-0.06925297528505325,
-0.018215220421552658,
0.030625130981206894,
0.4104093611240387,
-0.015626192092895508,
0.10436967015266418,
-0.4088442921638489,
0.2241763174533844,
0.19176840782165527,
-0.1056285947561264,
0.029048383235931396,
-0.5376113653182983,
-0.6695829033851624,
-0.457241028547287,
0.2566104829311371,
0.7190020084381104,
-0.734435498714447,
0.18636088073253632,
-0.5051025152206421,
-0.6154924631118774,
-0.39257168769836426,
0.12829312682151794,
0.09712675958871841,
0.49454909563064575,
0.15688148140907288,
-0.14805833995342255,
-0.5818494558334351,
-0.8591377139091492,
-0.3812360465526581,
-0.15274953842163086,
0.43453481793403625,
0.17956118285655975,
0.5124834179878235,
-0.15733778476715088,
0.6667865514755249,
-0.35478636622428894,
-0.011176802217960358,
-0.18828801810741425,
0.09305618703365326,
0.10583342611789703,
-0.06816425919532776,
0.6591241955757141,
-0.6476448774337769,
-0.23699022829532623,
-0.0937005877494812,
-0.9305092692375183,
0.19665610790252686,
-0.0460672527551651,
0.0993315801024437,
0.4508597254753113,
0.010746828280389309,
-0.6838885545730591,
0.052500270307064056,
0.8042086362838745,
-0.3498212695121765,
0.7209841012954712,
-0.2962234914302826,
0.6498070955276489,
-0.8389702439308167,
-0.11225669085979462,
0.06192992627620697,
-0.2668286859989166,
-0.3689117431640625,
0.16267168521881104,
0.11195795983076096,
0.04572780057787895,
-0.6543256044387817,
0.34856295585632324,
-0.6191069483757019,
-0.2921302616596222,
0.12357807159423828,
0.5080536007881165,
0.0843367725610733,
0.1491255909204483,
-0.037628497928380966,
0.7703274488449097,
0.3765951991081238,
-0.6970929503440857,
0.7122533321380615,
0.12854835391044617,
-0.7634249329566956,
0.5431802868843079,
-0.14027804136276245,
-0.07026004046201706,
-0.292265385389328,
0.11295560747385025,
-0.9781237840652466,
-0.15293878316879272,
-0.3330223262310028,
-0.2609177827835083,
0.037074360996484756,
-0.16946859657764435,
-0.4857267737388611,
-0.2878701984882355,
-0.3365701735019684,
0.2248150110244751,
0.15616701543331146,
-0.6882554292678833,
0.5902846455574036,
0.5314977169036865,
-0.30946943163871765,
-0.849692165851593,
-0.7473457455635071,
0.3090091347694397,
-0.2894018888473511,
-0.8480713367462158,
-0.22968311607837677,
-0.2039719969034195,
-0.5611516833305359,
0.01553039625287056,
0.049080368131399155,
-0.10292820632457733,
0.11725394427776337,
-0.17667992413043976,
0.16044199466705322,
-0.3738197088241577,
0.07645463198423386,
-0.11902650445699692,
0.20249424874782562,
0.27068811655044556,
-0.08234242349863052,
0.34762758016586304,
-0.0804624855518341,
-0.6086177825927734,
-0.00009184070950141177,
0.23324614763259888,
0.7351431846618652,
-0.23125232756137848,
0.82878577709198,
0.5651025772094727,
-0.396269291639328,
-0.23431073129177094,
-0.7885264754295349,
-0.05614960193634033,
-0.3400057852268219,
0.6418006420135498,
-0.44126686453819275,
-0.7697350978851318,
0.7142501473426819,
-0.13654856383800507,
0.23709851503372192,
0.6175690293312073,
0.786846399307251,
0.16979803144931793,
0.6023843288421631,
0.39790549874305725,
0.16190502047538757,
-0.3517394959926605,
-0.009876525960862637,
0.5069955587387085,
-0.31759244203567505,
-0.5026993155479431,
-0.5846123099327087,
-0.018049290403723717,
-0.787706196308136,
-0.6018118858337402,
0.6194939017295837,
-0.28181731700897217,
0.011886406689882278,
-0.07276833057403564,
0.23368528485298157,
0.5242337584495544,
0.37448176741600037,
-0.0029696919955313206,
0.5350269079208374,
0.23962520062923431,
-0.35511088371276855,
-0.3204054832458496,
-0.9926085472106934,
-0.6555068492889404,
1.1446058750152588,
0.3125753700733185,
0.5505144000053406,
0.6231722235679626,
0.25627636909484863,
0.4026431441307068,
0.4607381820678711,
-0.7966549396514893,
0.21332807838916779,
-0.3078613877296448,
-0.8804556131362915,
-0.12209250777959824,
-0.3931563198566437,
-0.39065641164779663,
0.41035500168800354,
-0.4552369713783264,
-0.3589981496334076,
-0.04788810759782791,
0.020996809005737305,
-0.4880100190639496,
0.6228222250938416,
-0.7016277313232422,
0.348300576210022,
-0.4981634020805359,
-0.3431920111179352,
-0.20396173000335693,
-0.3887622356414795,
0.8447032570838928,
-0.20934051275253296,
0.9543297290802002,
-0.3756738603115082,
0.05649588629603386,
0.4550603926181793,
-0.02582976222038269,
0.9104886651039124,
-0.012760528363287449,
-0.47857263684272766,
0.3656172454357147,
0.17961038649082184,
0.2816731333732605,
0.3310370147228241,
-0.26690393686294556,
0.538261353969574,
-0.054988469928503036,
-0.4702492654323578,
-0.5518354177474976,
0.8277083039283752,
-0.8238738179206848,
-0.6299403309822083,
-0.6965708136558533,
-0.7214023470878601,
-0.35743775963783264,
0.0478871650993824,
0.20427928864955902,
0.8350144028663635,
-0.4365094304084778,
-0.1260761022567749,
0.6360033750534058,
-0.3278433382511139,
0.2705989181995392,
0.839862585067749,
-0.14499959349632263,
-0.39784669876098633,
0.9486772418022156,
0.4058218002319336,
0.1348520964384079,
0.290956050157547,
0.24517251551151276,
-0.7033815979957581,
-0.5205098986625671,
-0.5785557627677917,
0.38610517978668213,
-1.0563981533050537,
-0.10886625200510025,
-0.6428171992301941,
-0.07094576954841614,
-0.5096318125724792,
0.144586443901062,
-0.5155037045478821,
-0.3643724322319031,
0.3734789192676544,
-0.3700198531150818,
0.20426872372627258,
1.0665332078933716,
-0.3507559299468994,
-0.053095728158950806,
-1.0573081970214844,
0.23723851144313812,
0.3584640920162201,
0.12260071933269501,
-0.2686731815338135,
-0.66105717420578,
-0.2858985960483551,
0.06849963217973709,
-0.05614547058939934,
-0.7192389965057373,
0.13820597529411316,
0.22241972386837006,
0.6983820796012878,
0.2377166897058487,
0.0626821219921112,
0.5263773202896118,
-0.7383339405059814,
1.04335618019104,
0.16221880912780762,
-0.7218688130378723,
0.10362783819437027,
0.07788258045911789,
0.1482778787612915,
0.31651169061660767,
0.7057201266288757,
-0.6400788426399231,
-0.31259506940841675,
-0.4559006094932556,
-0.5273665189743042,
0.36511853337287903,
-0.2888299226760864,
0.10468793660402298,
-0.021218787878751755,
0.1269751787185669,
0.46804988384246826,
0.2582610249519348,
-0.7368156313896179,
-0.5324089527130127,
0.025245722383260727,
-0.0679394081234932,
-0.3927248418331146,
-0.6614304184913635,
-0.5279406309127808,
-0.0944230929017067,
0.6559322476387024,
-0.3065401613712311,
0.15969961881637573,
0.36599379777908325,
-0.4198337197303772,
0.038119830191135406,
0.5293432474136353,
0.987860918045044,
1.2350895404815674,
-0.19517816603183746,
0.628021240234375,
0.6618842482566833,
-0.4049950838088989,
0.24962517619132996,
-0.07321690768003464,
-0.1971459835767746,
0.2856464982032776,
0.8481056094169617,
0.7361839413642883,
0.26035845279693604,
-0.4556065797805786,
0.40910547971725464,
-0.2816595435142517,
-0.1764460951089859,
-0.18128271400928497,
-0.2721821069717407,
0.22092671692371368,
0.12766434252262115,
0.2771117091178894,
0.38786324858665466,
-0.0017248318763449788,
-0.7524744868278503,
0.25819551944732666,
0.28127384185791016,
-0.1796192228794098,
-0.556028425693512,
0.2869235575199127,
0.4085146486759186,
0.20762231945991516,
0.32066813111305237,
-0.3737436830997467,
-0.9461797475814819,
0.41662833094596863,
0.6190164685249329,
0.42554405331611633,
-0.15966728329658508,
0.21248537302017212,
0.6096967458724976,
0.8077320456504822,
0.12192773073911667,
0.552370548248291,
0.42384740710258484,
-1.0831514596939087,
-0.7622999548912048,
-0.47528016567230225,
-0.4045555889606476,
-0.023385440930724144,
-0.3101893365383148,
0.29946017265319824,
-0.22978998720645905,
-0.09285283088684082,
-0.22508707642555237,
0.14061430096626282,
-0.8175422549247742,
0.3088892698287964,
0.27789008617401123,
0.8961718082427979,
-1.1611915826797485,
0.5543506741523743,
0.8991451263427734,
0.08485706895589828,
-0.5976085662841797,
-0.0495610274374485,
0.4022855758666992,
-0.9429295659065247,
0.5681352019309998,
-0.036211684346199036,
-0.39827167987823486,
-0.3665367364883423,
-0.3980063199996948,
-1.0120097398757935,
0.9176506400108337,
0.5658621788024902,
-0.5019760727882385,
0.31294354796409607,
0.32188984751701355,
0.24295084178447723,
-0.3767947554588318,
0.4162904620170593,
0.7361968159675598,
0.5569670796394348,
-0.07287278771400452,
-0.8535357713699341,
-0.08931130170822144,
0.20030634105205536,
-0.44660213589668274,
-0.11423712223768234,
-0.9708834290504456,
0.7640592455863953,
-0.5554194450378418,
-0.28301045298576355,
-0.46532291173934937,
0.6770807504653931,
0.4785037636756897,
0.30844026803970337,
0.46317213773727417,
0.5410441756248474,
1.3320934772491455,
-0.2423800826072693,
1.0580737590789795,
-0.6319929957389832,
0.4074065685272217,
1.1294660568237305,
-0.6022717952728271,
0.4976223409175873,
0.15869620442390442,
-0.35683196783065796,
0.6772810816764832,
0.5229477882385254,
0.21773216128349304,
0.28121837973594666,
-0.21596287190914154,
-0.34939929842948914,
-0.3044378459453583,
-0.34182223677635193,
-0.22447502613067627,
0.7942733764648438,
0.2630363702774048,
0.2620540261268616,
-0.4160724878311157,
-0.25997990369796753,
0.39341795444488525,
0.2166033536195755,
-0.13405992090702057,
0.47037890553474426,
-0.09568160772323608,
-0.7114185690879822,
0.42445656657218933,
0.23599207401275635,
0.681647002696991,
-0.540193498134613,
0.11811961233615875,
-0.4349510967731476,
-0.01650146394968033,
-0.3549194037914276,
-0.8077337145805359,
0.3834170997142792,
0.28532344102859497,
-0.3902849853038788,
0.3070482611656189,
0.4986307919025421,
-0.6130090951919556,
-0.7486742734909058,
0.2962251901626587,
0.9087282419204712,
0.15750792622566223,
0.17333658039569855,
-0.5817043781280518,
0.03496094048023224,
0.14786872267723083,
0.07628641277551651,
0.01078119222074747,
0.8093337416648865,
0.09910691529512405,
0.5997501015663147,
0.6237886548042297,
0.36513644456863403,
0.3545375466346741,
0.2034330666065216,
0.36657676100730896,
-0.6256958842277527,
-0.23392707109451294,
-0.9424453973770142,
0.4327865242958069,
-0.020601315423846245,
-0.3507472574710846,
1.2190004587173462,
0.7397801876068115,
0.8705618977546692,
-0.021359017118811607,
0.9839308857917786,
-0.012356972321867943,
0.5631128549575806,
-0.808452844619751,
0.6093248724937439,
-0.40853196382522583,
0.1326921284198761,
0.09119176119565964,
-0.8669866323471069,
-0.24448511004447937,
0.07724904268980026,
-0.34621965885162354,
-0.15067501366138458,
1.1609272956848145,
0.6601142883300781,
-0.14208447933197021,
0.14587056636810303,
0.45564574003219604,
0.4059561491012573,
0.1090833991765976,
0.19489091634750366,
1.0703914165496826,
-0.3795860707759857,
0.24328739941120148,
-0.4530971944332123,
-0.185900017619133,
0.21457931399345398,
-1.1747193336486816,
-0.7941681146621704,
-0.42285028100013733,
-0.4011407196521759,
-0.2862308919429779,
-0.19265082478523254,
0.9242477416992188,
0.7442910671234131,
-0.9659752249717712,
-0.4146765470504761,
0.7499004602432251,
0.520721971988678,
0.11842625588178635,
-0.19342942535877228,
0.3424747884273529,
-0.4278649687767029,
-0.6169309020042419,
0.6432735919952393,
0.2921925187110901,
-0.20601403713226318,
-0.3523980975151062,
-0.02984822727739811,
-0.47976750135421753,
0.10016560554504395,
0.9772982001304626,
-0.21139036118984222,
-0.6879889369010925,
-0.4949091672897339,
-0.005975044332444668,
-0.15144643187522888,
0.2126307338476181,
0.8755657076835632,
-0.28873324394226074,
0.3139709532260895,
0.34377801418304443,
0.452406644821167,
0.038286689668893814,
0.03007306158542633,
0.3487073481082916,
-0.9128754138946533,
0.31146863102912903,
-0.13283486664295197,
0.6442172527313232,
0.8559836745262146,
-0.32369211316108704,
0.33717501163482666,
0.7074735164642334,
-0.48319706320762634,
-0.6466299891471863,
0.14362433552742004,
-0.4621681869029999,
-0.2533004581928253,
1.1728700399398804,
-0.27163252234458923,
-0.277165949344635,
-0.26314234733581543,
0.09969832748174667,
0.06220242753624916,
-0.09776850789785385,
0.6581523418426514,
1.0339300632476807,
0.07678279280662537,
0.062195390462875366,
-0.709053635597229,
0.40546727180480957,
0.15907858312129974,
-0.7392504215240479,
0.06546288728713989,
0.7200213074684143,
0.5658103823661804,
0.38831639289855957,
0.4303542673587799,
0.0010821514297276735,
0.053289879113435745,
0.01484955195337534,
0.20138868689537048,
0.1959604024887085,
-0.7636916637420654,
-0.16414129734039307,
0.2354915291070938,
0.3575407862663269,
0.27020469307899475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18043v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18043v1
|
Crisis talk: analysis of the public debate around the energy crisis and cost of living
| 2024-02-28T04:42:59 | 2024-02-28T04:42:59 |
Rrubaa Panchendrarajan, Geri Popova, Tony Russell-Rose
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A prominent media topic in the UK in the early 2020s is the energy crisis
affecting the UK and most of Europe. It brings into a single public debate
issues of energy dependency and sustainability, fair distribution of economic
burdens and cost of living, as well as climate change, risk, and
sustainability. In this paper, we investigate the public discourse around the
energy crisis and cost of living to identify how these pivotal and
contradictory issues are reconciled in this debate and to identify which social
actors are involved and the role they play. We analyse a document corpus
retrieved from UK newspapers from January 2014 to March 2023. We apply a
variety of natural language processing and data visualisation techniques to
identify key topics, novel trends, critical social actors, and the role they
play in the debate, along with the sentiment associated with those actors and
topics. We combine automated techniques with manual discourse analysis to
explore and validate the insights revealed in this study. The findings verify
the utility of these techniques by providing a flexible and scalable pipeline
for discourse analysis and providing critical insights for cost of living -
energy crisis nexus research.
|
[
-0.47450798749923706,
-0.4003332853317261,
0.33960846066474915,
-0.1205054298043251,
0.11752676218748093,
0.4910384714603424,
-0.06388555467128754,
-0.28776323795318604,
0.6288811564445496,
0.46068835258483887,
-0.3861510753631592,
-0.08253554254770279,
-0.44630488753318787,
0.06530614197254181,
-0.3344714343547821,
0.47181713581085205,
0.19306375086307526,
-0.061572566628456116,
-0.13383625447750092,
0.00798803847283125,
-0.4898100793361664,
0.018179070204496384,
-0.6442047953605652,
0.20001082122325897,
0.5626720786094666,
0.514847457408905,
0.9234525561332703,
0.056476980447769165,
0.39409539103507996,
0.3995566964149475,
-0.30186086893081665,
-0.021727316081523895,
-0.8271755576133728,
0.10257258266210556,
-0.18475031852722168,
-0.16483701765537262,
-0.31664595007896423,
0.16795381903648376,
0.603147029876709,
0.5373556613922119,
-0.030611373484134674,
0.2610972821712494,
0.2594037652015686,
0.6200643181800842,
-0.6668859124183655,
0.07328374683856964,
-0.9507530331611633,
-0.03059183619916439,
-0.13131672143936157,
-0.19758613407611847,
-0.05666743218898773,
-0.2731894850730896,
-0.14415626227855682,
-0.16268639266490936,
0.2291988730430603,
0.1699191927909851,
1.0347659587860107,
0.5100930333137512,
-0.43149641156196594,
-0.29169830679893494,
-0.833433985710144,
0.5577734112739563,
-0.3135471045970917,
0.06964826583862305,
-0.21205905079841614,
0.3154432475566864,
-0.012671933509409428,
-0.5919618010520935,
-0.7672469019889832,
0.3005374073982239,
-0.5381535291671753,
0.25026535987854004,
-0.44864535331726074,
-0.03649192303419113,
-0.05547142028808594,
0.31691884994506836,
-0.2274414300918579,
-0.2114507555961609,
-0.7269667387008667,
-0.1438601016998291,
0.5829605460166931,
-0.007467914372682571,
0.05519716441631317,
-1.003365397453308,
-0.5035390257835388,
0.03645695745944977,
-0.5571591854095459,
-0.14850886166095734,
0.8113410472869873,
0.32603687047958374,
-0.26797738671302795,
0.12456496804952621,
0.1353788673877716,
0.015002713538706303,
-0.3330872654914856,
0.022861560806632042,
-0.18918952345848083,
-0.21637196838855743,
0.1531093716621399,
0.5652340650558472,
0.5674605369567871,
0.927890419960022,
-0.1671903282403946,
0.31722065806388855,
0.27717989683151245,
-0.4576655328273773,
0.3788564205169678,
-0.523642897605896,
-0.03835716471076012,
0.387325644493103,
-0.31070613861083984,
-0.3509214222431183,
-0.03193819895386696,
-1.2274723052978516,
-0.6248842477798462,
0.23321157693862915,
0.1266135424375534,
0.5173866152763367,
-0.496736079454422,
0.2500036358833313,
-0.21451953053474426,
-0.0543687529861927,
0.18509352207183838,
-0.20618385076522827,
0.0455508679151535,
0.4354400336742401,
0.6925514340400696,
0.45097512006759644,
0.24022276699543,
-0.14786048233509064,
0.3169252276420593,
-0.10264316946268082,
1.1855698823928833,
-0.5768330097198486,
-0.7647333145141602,
0.053612396121025085,
0.2808930575847626,
0.04210735857486725,
-0.31448453664779663,
0.7751149535179138,
-0.015556692145764828,
0.43063947558403015,
-0.7289370894432068,
-0.19741162657737732,
0.04424172639846802,
-0.02657519094645977,
-0.6991703510284424,
0.7065459489822388,
-0.18685056269168854,
-1.074061393737793,
0.17445367574691772,
-1.140143632888794,
-0.1535622775554657,
0.3499448597431183,
-0.31975823640823364,
-0.21625614166259766,
-0.036212049424648285,
-0.06687016040086746,
0.40989336371421814,
-0.604197084903717,
0.2563456594944,
-0.1335386484861374,
0.18089929223060608,
0.10019826889038086,
-0.7112891674041748,
0.48707011342048645,
0.271241694688797,
-0.11015832424163818,
-0.13591843843460083,
-0.7864225506782532,
-0.4768085181713104,
-0.04104393348097801,
0.11635993421077728,
0.03803638368844986,
0.5823487043380737,
-0.03402248024940491,
0.28713586926460266,
0.01873648166656494,
-0.5568341016769409,
0.08912355452775955,
0.022094765678048134,
0.7625929117202759,
0.39272597432136536,
0.44226622581481934,
-0.036875758320093155,
-0.29754701256752014,
0.5011418461799622,
-0.07316239178180695,
0.21889053285121918,
-0.13323350250720978,
-0.435983270406723,
-0.6438811421394348,
0.005959013011306524,
-0.011512729339301586,
0.7012924551963806,
-0.22918502986431122,
-0.0607994869351387,
0.05197596922516823,
-0.30430182814598083,
-0.7156252861022949,
-0.535475492477417,
0.061941519379615784,
0.7721259593963623,
0.23781751096248627,
0.2487766146659851,
-0.5694829821586609,
-0.897792398929596,
-0.5844630599021912,
-0.2590019702911377,
-0.024041205644607544,
0.5065656304359436,
0.10703317821025848,
0.3756496012210846,
0.8274641633033752,
-0.7543594837188721,
0.2237926423549652,
0.028667544946074486,
0.8740012645721436,
0.037674982100725174,
0.4382125437259674,
0.19167539477348328,
-0.8897626399993896,
-0.4425525665283203,
-0.10014547407627106,
-0.15093271434307098,
-0.2584431767463684,
-0.4239310622215271,
-0.053375791758298874,
-0.028041105717420578,
0.6515763401985168,
-0.09727902710437775,
0.131218820810318,
0.24314764142036438,
-0.30673831701278687,
0.4043588638305664,
-0.027678189799189568,
0.5470869541168213,
-1.0306267738342285,
0.31853601336479187,
0.04584365338087082,
0.08933178335428238,
-0.7210807800292969,
-0.43580707907676697,
-0.4170001447200775,
-0.6572226285934448,
-0.7193219661712646,
0.32404565811157227,
-0.5055856704711914,
0.10330222547054291,
-0.005898479837924242,
0.1141582578420639,
0.25765740871429443,
-0.10153868794441223,
0.043058913201093674,
0.6062929034233093,
0.3366348445415497,
0.14517197012901306,
0.07624927908182144,
0.21077075600624084,
-0.28625866770744324,
0.45766356587409973,
-0.2748798727989197,
0.2798893451690674,
-0.16732768714427948,
0.3563317656517029,
-1.4361813068389893,
-0.3522000312805176,
-0.09571480005979538,
-0.19599752128124237,
0.16804499924182892,
-0.21564561128616333,
-0.2219143658876419,
-0.62920743227005,
-0.13950030505657196,
-0.21984928846359253,
0.3479490578174591,
0.17604365944862366,
0.7485598921775818,
0.728325366973877,
-0.5668046474456787,
-0.44562163949012756,
-0.12182918190956116,
0.3624996542930603,
-0.42512837052345276,
-0.712955117225647,
0.29363638162612915,
0.1826784908771515,
-0.615057647228241,
0.0072256033308804035,
-0.18315596878528595,
0.06084582582116127,
0.1295613795518875,
0.5153485536575317,
0.18091648817062378,
-0.011354736052453518,
0.3005233407020569,
-0.13556623458862305,
-0.5283040404319763,
0.33236077427864075,
0.1819891333580017,
0.2772451937198639,
-0.16670304536819458,
0.0666939839720726,
-0.3442317545413971,
0.8453660011291504,
0.8555557131767273,
0.07316113263368607,
0.7049230337142944,
0.09791319817304611,
-0.33557283878326416,
0.4903472661972046,
-0.6107249855995178,
0.27667665481567383,
-0.432908833026886,
-0.034435391426086426,
0.1401786357164383,
-0.6019548177719116,
0.35136762261390686,
-0.47686928510665894,
0.28047463297843933,
0.6928286552429199,
0.410160094499588,
-0.30930033326148987,
0.6171990633010864,
0.37650346755981445,
-0.06617414206266403,
0.028594160452485085,
-0.15496084094047546,
0.5705715417861938,
-0.2892362177371979,
-0.3418595790863037,
-0.9472752213478088,
-0.5902133584022522,
-0.4009518027305603,
-0.450300008058548,
0.6045575141906738,
-0.18992310762405396,
0.006483164615929127,
0.13642044365406036,
-0.5392974615097046,
0.8622875213623047,
-0.2456485480070114,
-0.2390064001083374,
0.12948934733867645,
-0.44370144605636597,
0.4143441915512085,
0.14577768743038177,
-0.32902318239212036,
-0.8682270050048828,
0.12846942245960236,
0.37015971541404724,
0.4098062515258789,
0.014398550614714622,
0.3072409927845001,
0.3014145791530609,
0.27781662344932556,
-0.6655471324920654,
0.6361198425292969,
0.1709318310022354,
-0.7861085534095764,
-0.40186312794685364,
-0.3142751455307007,
-1.0544495582580566,
0.18553917109966278,
-0.46145251393318176,
-0.6164834499359131,
0.652388870716095,
-0.1685231775045395,
-0.819699227809906,
0.6400029063224792,
-0.5254788994789124,
0.8353334069252014,
0.025096509605646133,
-0.37409189343452454,
-0.560899019241333,
-0.5549505949020386,
0.1568593978881836,
0.25670379400253296,
0.6503109931945801,
-0.469470739364624,
0.3001682460308075,
0.815899133682251,
-0.3616093099117279,
0.7161514759063721,
-0.15299825370311737,
-0.35831597447395325,
0.4495249092578888,
-0.39784976840019226,
0.3346627950668335,
-0.023489072918891907,
0.08404233306646347,
-0.11020122468471527,
0.167089581489563,
-0.63969486951828,
-0.26072192192077637,
0.5825183987617493,
-0.6418477296829224,
-0.8919946551322937,
-0.22393174469470978,
-0.15768550336360931,
-0.22601747512817383,
-0.32573235034942627,
0.23226450383663177,
0.5487031936645508,
-0.4591294527053833,
-0.1163189709186554,
0.40299901366233826,
-0.012258695438504219,
0.754078209400177,
0.4507611095905304,
0.03622829541563988,
-0.4991666376590729,
0.8533046245574951,
0.5632010102272034,
0.2786826193332672,
0.37658536434173584,
0.6431822776794434,
-0.059666577726602554,
-0.15053772926330566,
0.22242611646652222,
0.11937710642814636,
-0.5318976640701294,
-0.34727776050567627,
-0.715259850025177,
-0.02348141558468342,
-0.38225653767585754,
-0.5167398452758789,
-0.648719847202301,
-0.07618305832147598,
-0.24309314787387848,
-0.3254481554031372,
0.2302093207836151,
0.5993971824645996,
-0.5722846388816833,
0.03361578285694122,
-0.7636811137199402,
0.047651257365942,
0.599124014377594,
-0.19838711619377136,
-0.1558457762002945,
0.18089407682418823,
-0.31355205178260803,
-0.4056159257888794,
-0.7805919051170349,
-1.314411997795105,
0.3736893832683563,
0.02076643332839012,
0.15018391609191895,
0.7100543975830078,
0.48718199133872986,
0.5371837615966797,
-0.5104425549507141,
1.2236590385437012,
0.569957971572876,
-0.8741111755371094,
0.36895519495010376,
-0.2604254484176636,
-0.10383149236440659,
0.6590373516082764,
0.9160431623458862,
-0.632176399230957,
-0.0829673781991005,
-1.1042544841766357,
-1.0893422365188599,
0.34148404002189636,
0.18317946791648865,
0.07794438302516937,
-0.1961272805929184,
-0.054212536662817,
-0.03534609079360962,
0.2316228300333023,
-0.053100116550922394,
-0.48550498485565186,
-0.2502649128437042,
0.7194843888282776,
0.1414414793252945,
-0.34295687079429626,
-0.5794782638549805,
-0.4195766746997833,
0.37126874923706055,
-0.013309908099472523,
0.15627551078796387,
0.05488709360361099,
0.5701699256896973,
-0.48536741733551025,
0.6294602155685425,
0.48058030009269714,
0.3518407642841339,
-0.3341296911239624,
-0.005006950814276934,
0.23468248546123505,
-0.33678746223449707,
0.23273755609989166,
-0.08972332626581192,
0.11587591469287872,
0.311320036649704,
0.14520110189914703,
0.7600781917572021,
0.764615535736084,
-0.4744228422641754,
0.31846070289611816,
-0.2185981720685959,
-0.6052671670913696,
-0.11923462152481079,
-0.15647438168525696,
0.3382830321788788,
0.41968271136283875,
0.5166218876838684,
-0.006211114581674337,
0.36219993233680725,
-0.9959865212440491,
-0.17487119138240814,
0.11837509274482727,
-0.500674843788147,
-0.36651989817619324,
0.43908756971359253,
0.9873980283737183,
-0.40766575932502747,
0.05917626991868019,
0.07074280083179474,
-0.6072441339492798,
0.3982199728488922,
0.13059735298156738,
0.9425867199897766,
-0.17325960099697113,
0.46657514572143555,
0.1712920069694519,
0.03572843596339226,
0.3649098873138428,
0.6070128679275513,
0.14730587601661682,
-0.3989836871623993,
-0.36562567949295044,
-0.33227699995040894,
-0.5993722677230835,
0.30170807242393494,
-0.8186700940132141,
0.21915015578269958,
-0.18284010887145996,
-0.10507579892873764,
0.11388124525547028,
0.48536205291748047,
-0.3454151451587677,
-0.1716485470533371,
0.6257832050323486,
1.0289002656936646,
-0.9819002151489258,
0.2646358907222748,
0.29500812292099,
0.06710448861122131,
-0.866835355758667,
0.3157923221588135,
0.31827348470687866,
-0.2391546070575714,
0.3785569369792938,
0.027918556705117226,
-0.2570945918560028,
-0.13924987614154816,
-0.7704081535339355,
-0.9091740250587463,
1.0152289867401123,
0.8332388997077942,
-0.7256508469581604,
0.018694080412387848,
0.041975319385528564,
0.13428758084774017,
-0.18650098145008087,
0.4002588093280792,
0.6815677881240845,
1.0462918281555176,
0.6178387403488159,
-0.8752346634864807,
-0.10003487765789032,
-0.25561344623565674,
-0.4379799962043762,
0.5330503582954407,
-1.2124483585357666,
0.5056300163269043,
0.1181376725435257,
-0.8440355062484741,
-0.5584690570831299,
0.6352394819259644,
-0.6275144815444946,
0.4785670340061188,
0.5186764597892761,
0.17923203110694885,
1.1868926286697388,
0.059884991496801376,
0.8521234393119812,
-0.638416588306427,
0.5695914030075073,
0.6474663019180298,
-0.5534641742706299,
0.90309077501297,
0.1591772586107254,
-0.5589588284492493,
0.43168988823890686,
0.3348720371723175,
0.39271271228790283,
0.42821359634399414,
0.425853967666626,
-0.47614118456840515,
-0.2835384011268616,
-0.2983120381832123,
-0.41286933422088623,
0.5027575492858887,
0.6054537296295166,
0.16219373047351837,
-0.708039402961731,
-0.1690201312303543,
0.29974672198295593,
0.0528070405125618,
-0.10890249907970428,
0.7633728384971619,
-0.03538310155272484,
-0.2400142401456833,
0.25843897461891174,
-0.405586302280426,
-0.0020652494858950377,
-0.3160271942615509,
0.24733217060565948,
-0.20023755729198456,
-0.5751012563705444,
-0.24300433695316315,
-0.5890941619873047,
0.7689864039421082,
0.037147048860788345,
-0.04980531707406044,
-0.44625774025917053,
0.6584222316741943,
-0.1953408420085907,
-0.3434091806411743,
-0.014921859838068485,
0.2713399827480316,
0.4030041992664337,
0.08959612250328064,
-0.953779399394989,
0.20551049709320068,
-0.09130711853504181,
0.08444729447364807,
0.4112071394920349,
0.517386794090271,
0.6767586469650269,
0.1093723252415657,
0.1451713889837265,
-0.09775399416685104,
-0.29226019978523254,
-0.16302664577960968,
1.0340218544006348,
-0.7758128046989441,
-0.23667769134044647,
-0.4452020525932312,
0.6251463294029236,
-0.4994114935398102,
-0.6985177993774414,
0.37420785427093506,
0.29942989349365234,
0.2339152991771698,
0.21004988253116608,
0.578795850276947,
-0.1960349828004837,
0.622445285320282,
-0.45469188690185547,
1.0036778450012207,
-0.3625966012477875,
0.135112464427948,
-0.1908944696187973,
-0.3923081159591675,
0.15298551321029663,
0.36487653851509094,
-0.6792183518409729,
-0.5651639699935913,
0.8300220966339111,
0.8501855731010437,
0.31214606761932373,
0.36635538935661316,
0.4824845492839813,
0.4159313142299652,
0.3110760450363159,
0.17629167437553406,
0.853321373462677,
-0.08568359911441803,
0.430743932723999,
0.09958883374929428,
0.04585396125912666,
-0.3963104486465454,
-1.2263647317886353,
-0.2559012770652771,
-0.7709718346595764,
-0.7302880883216858,
-0.40252017974853516,
0.1529139280319214,
0.8838945627212524,
0.5587446689605713,
-0.6186071634292603,
-0.1727532595396042,
0.075008325278759,
0.4061328172683716,
0.01628830097615719,
-0.21014583110809326,
0.5008999705314636,
-0.09647556394338608,
-0.6904643177986145,
0.3518955707550049,
0.5883556604385376,
-0.2446448653936386,
-0.5833390355110168,
0.480683833360672,
-0.29429498314857483,
0.8307404518127441,
0.4016989767551422,
0.5498271584510803,
-0.39680925011634827,
-0.41927146911621094,
-0.7180242538452148,
0.06824520230293274,
0.3436179459095001,
1.0612331628799438,
-0.6877561211585999,
-0.06961952894926071,
0.2950056493282318,
0.38942843675613403,
-0.013345062732696533,
-0.2635507881641388,
0.32009926438331604,
-0.6371463537216187,
-0.03308197483420372,
0.14848555624485016,
0.4642767608165741,
0.4747208058834076,
-0.6577267050743103,
0.284333735704422,
0.3905166685581207,
-0.7593502402305603,
-1.0010147094726562,
0.06633762270212173,
-0.8475223183631897,
-0.4487016499042511,
0.8244153261184692,
-0.09419605880975723,
-0.2760263979434967,
-0.26035431027412415,
-0.2958487272262573,
0.027660245075821877,
-0.645298421382904,
1.0192950963974,
0.7974883913993835,
0.05091771483421326,
-0.28213101625442505,
-0.3719817101955414,
0.3727862238883972,
-0.01687832921743393,
-0.7694399952888489,
0.3693757653236389,
0.3195798099040985,
-0.3553231358528137,
0.6584058403968811,
0.41386136412620544,
0.24829436838626862,
-0.46121305227279663,
0.39383840560913086,
-0.1876252442598343,
0.4360046982765198,
-0.5998137593269348,
0.07858849316835403,
0.6940986514091492,
-0.6059004664421082,
-0.06059827655553818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18041v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18041v1
|
Datasets for Large Language Models: A Comprehensive Survey
| 2024-02-28T04:35:51 | 2024-02-28T04:35:51 |
Yang Liu, Jiahuan Cao, Chongyu Liu, Kai Ding, Lianwen Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper embarks on an exploration into the Large Language Model (LLM)
datasets, which play a crucial role in the remarkable advancements of LLMs. The
datasets serve as the foundational infrastructure analogous to a root system
that sustains and nurtures the development of LLMs. Consequently, examination
of these datasets emerges as a critical topic in research. In order to address
the current lack of a comprehensive overview and thorough analysis of LLM
datasets, and to gain insights into their current status and future trends,
this survey consolidates and categorizes the fundamental aspects of LLM
datasets from five perspectives: (1) Pre-training Corpora; (2) Instruction
Fine-tuning Datasets; (3) Preference Datasets; (4) Evaluation Datasets; (5)
Traditional Natural Language Processing (NLP) Datasets. The survey sheds light
on the prevailing challenges and points out potential avenues for future
investigation. Additionally, a comprehensive review of the existing available
dataset resources is also provided, including statistics from 444 datasets,
covering 8 language categories and spanning 32 domains. Information from 20
dimensions is incorporated into the dataset statistics. The total data size
surveyed surpasses 774.5 TB for pre-training corpora and 700M instances for
other datasets. We aim to present the entire landscape of LLM text datasets,
serving as a comprehensive reference for researchers in this field and
contributing to future studies. Related resources are available at:
https://github.com/lmmlzn/Awesome-LLMs-Datasets.
|
[
-0.4116533100605011,
-0.6503838300704956,
0.4733387529850006,
0.028041809797286987,
0.0743553638458252,
0.227524071931839,
-0.5739193558692932,
-0.13881035149097443,
0.04773373901844025,
0.8163193464279175,
-0.44630104303359985,
-0.750507652759552,
-0.6741960644721985,
0.1094769611954689,
-0.5933048129081726,
0.9304847121238708,
-0.022448008880019188,
0.20895537734031677,
-0.22578375041484833,
-0.11345084011554718,
-0.3640293776988983,
-0.6307171583175659,
-0.281127005815506,
-0.21656838059425354,
0.4761764407157898,
0.3720315098762512,
0.38635265827178955,
0.640322208404541,
0.5756353139877319,
0.199338898062706,
-0.17014797031879425,
0.13811571896076202,
-0.728868842124939,
0.2827594578266144,
-0.008114746771752834,
-0.3348832130432129,
-0.3084108531475067,
-0.018525633960962296,
1.0603680610656738,
1.1562978029251099,
-0.0814923346042633,
0.3997681438922882,
0.007435064297169447,
0.638297438621521,
-0.42628711462020874,
0.17990422248840332,
-0.5322901010513306,
-0.0508175753057003,
-0.6284013390541077,
-0.08642721176147461,
-0.2700459361076355,
-0.44063571095466614,
0.09679561108350754,
-0.05508952587842941,
0.11149691045284271,
0.12911802530288696,
0.33849745988845825,
0.05944034084677696,
-0.6791191101074219,
-0.39733320474624634,
-0.8442683815956116,
0.9263179898262024,
-0.6428650617599487,
0.468127578496933,
0.13671229779720306,
0.11586346477270126,
-0.16767756640911102,
-0.5815226435661316,
-0.2906236946582794,
-0.10689528286457062,
0.2344692051410675,
-0.09029752761125565,
-0.1333504319190979,
-0.04101359844207764,
0.25843116641044617,
0.6930445432662964,
-0.7654194831848145,
0.444679856300354,
-0.2640959918498993,
0.0054284557700157166,
0.6398382782936096,
0.5044886469841003,
0.2159094512462616,
0.11894635856151581,
-0.0467102937400341,
-0.0000939069504966028,
-1.092903733253479,
-0.24637463688850403,
0.39620912075042725,
0.28421056270599365,
-0.16103094816207886,
0.5656802654266357,
-0.18454526364803314,
1.023153305053711,
-0.4426232874393463,
-0.10804089903831482,
0.26454630494117737,
-0.5439471006393433,
-0.20074562728405,
-0.10082791745662689,
0.8738342523574829,
0.15814334154129028,
0.4329264760017395,
-0.09112036228179932,
-0.2344076931476593,
-0.2061118483543396,
-0.04683029279112816,
-0.5951279401779175,
0.010902768932282925,
0.28444740176200867,
-0.26795563101768494,
-0.20216825604438782,
-0.03830349072813988,
-0.658608615398407,
-0.40192893147468567,
-0.6689083576202393,
-0.2532235085964203,
-0.09964439272880554,
-0.2653562128543854,
0.271293580532074,
0.35435035824775696,
0.48854944109916687,
0.13503071665763855,
-0.8493037819862366,
0.4894338548183441,
0.8263322114944458,
0.708946943283081,
-0.3402419686317444,
-0.29527726769447327,
0.009649505838751793,
0.0028591605369001627,
-0.5748252868652344,
0.7639750242233276,
-0.5807064175605774,
-0.3969712555408478,
0.40377354621887207,
-0.00791250728070736,
0.11330738663673401,
-0.6859482526779175,
0.5361746549606323,
-0.6559295058250427,
0.2322605401277542,
-0.33350276947021484,
-0.7567470073699951,
-0.014899400994181633,
0.6109196543693542,
-0.8671319484710693,
0.9903072714805603,
-0.11031883209943771,
-0.7435219287872314,
0.1254783570766449,
-0.4725223183631897,
-0.40755322575569153,
-0.03913678973913193,
-0.34063974022865295,
-0.17524532973766327,
0.16306717693805695,
0.12460991740226746,
0.7146623134613037,
-0.7840778231620789,
0.5598694682121277,
-0.3918694257736206,
-0.1847546547651291,
0.35271328687667847,
-0.4406137466430664,
0.7884655594825745,
0.07065726071596146,
0.06839460879564285,
0.0837087631225586,
-0.87112957239151,
0.021047858521342278,
0.14871282875537872,
-0.1406625360250473,
-0.2147195190191269,
-0.04791603609919548,
0.1869429498910904,
0.13476064801216125,
0.4920889139175415,
-0.45602932572364807,
0.42161691188812256,
-0.2067856639623642,
0.2578088939189911,
0.6442012786865234,
-0.02793416753411293,
0.4344615042209625,
0.004993713926523924,
0.6310661435127258,
-0.1256081461906433,
0.16751790046691895,
-0.26784074306488037,
-0.13698852062225342,
-0.6989074349403381,
-0.01617087423801422,
0.4658922553062439,
0.3905450105667114,
-0.3960534632205963,
0.5565194487571716,
-0.49677184224128723,
-0.42523929476737976,
-0.2613683044910431,
0.16227340698242188,
0.2370026558637619,
0.16583873331546783,
0.050521258264780045,
-0.07486319541931152,
-0.6762653589248657,
-0.989654541015625,
0.11014234274625778,
-0.019789472222328186,
-0.027845734730362892,
0.3468063771724701,
0.4950464367866516,
-0.15165641903877258,
0.9281482100486755,
-0.6491703391075134,
-0.1563190370798111,
-0.504658579826355,
-0.275837242603302,
0.5129013657569885,
0.1797625720500946,
0.45357203483581543,
-0.520949125289917,
-0.33122608065605164,
-0.17109841108322144,
-0.6685760021209717,
-0.1923588365316391,
0.16215780377388,
0.040598295629024506,
0.01189418788999319,
0.4385158121585846,
-0.3911459445953369,
-0.15395760536193848,
0.8040527105331421,
-0.07715670764446259,
0.6309968829154968,
-0.05897124856710434,
-0.12551598250865936,
-1.1198010444641113,
0.2570638358592987,
0.0027133969124406576,
0.009286733344197273,
-0.7095823287963867,
0.049341410398483276,
-0.13451692461967468,
0.12497016042470932,
-0.18041859567165375,
0.5834541320800781,
-0.5470907688140869,
-0.3817596435546875,
-0.1159418523311615,
-0.016975874081254005,
-0.262703001499176,
0.0786643698811531,
0.020316703245043755,
0.6722248792648315,
0.7380235195159912,
-0.4072084128856659,
0.5162415504455566,
0.36711788177490234,
-0.5210880637168884,
0.2575283944606781,
-0.5761805772781372,
0.1866653859615326,
-0.10410504043102264,
0.4058835804462433,
-0.707667887210846,
-0.2296607345342636,
0.06855428963899612,
-0.1584046185016632,
0.26364409923553467,
-0.02339559607207775,
-0.7022228240966797,
-0.18283085525035858,
-0.2710857391357422,
0.22070345282554626,
0.2989269196987152,
-0.21280509233474731,
0.1181938573718071,
0.7335504293441772,
-0.40173280239105225,
-0.6915780901908875,
-0.3890855312347412,
0.3650051951408386,
-0.2009531557559967,
-0.29741281270980835,
0.008460398763418198,
-0.16061383485794067,
-0.4458106458187103,
-0.22492362558841705,
0.2279774248600006,
-0.013487210497260094,
-0.07545352727174759,
0.0037351716309785843,
0.35258549451828003,
-0.2582376003265381,
0.14707419276237488,
-0.34189823269844055,
-0.025603272020816803,
0.16652178764343262,
-0.30145347118377686,
0.875190258026123,
-0.21154473721981049,
-0.2976956367492676,
-0.014851178973913193,
0.2244916409254074,
0.3938215374946594,
-0.18602719902992249,
0.5891757011413574,
0.2677149176597595,
-0.28979140520095825,
-0.2307896912097931,
-0.5071104168891907,
0.044779881834983826,
-0.3625091016292572,
0.4151609241962433,
-0.17454612255096436,
-1.1480629444122314,
0.5166193246841431,
-0.053577814251184464,
0.34503868222236633,
0.33591264486312866,
0.8183006048202515,
0.07201480865478516,
0.6799105405807495,
0.7324501276016235,
-0.618805468082428,
0.3016873002052307,
-0.4371357858181,
0.13780197501182556,
-0.8308653831481934,
-0.17790529131889343,
-0.7044727206230164,
-0.1289590448141098,
-0.6398459076881409,
-0.40278416872024536,
0.07825959473848343,
-0.32146286964416504,
-0.3216928243637085,
-0.011961753480136395,
-0.03204334154725075,
0.43830403685569763,
0.1696089655160904,
-0.35842445492744446,
0.3428375720977783,
0.026630043983459473,
-0.030246403068304062,
-0.016365334391593933,
-0.63497394323349,
-0.8449771404266357,
1.3983635902404785,
0.47796812653541565,
0.757780909538269,
0.03364689648151398,
0.505155086517334,
-0.04349661245942116,
0.1777150183916092,
-0.8412250876426697,
0.5616157054901123,
-0.3025989830493927,
-0.8493505120277405,
-0.4277268648147583,
-0.43667593598365784,
-0.9159830212593079,
0.04350825026631355,
0.08431421220302582,
-0.35619285702705383,
0.10334845632314682,
-0.008463723585009575,
-0.19673316180706024,
0.2888481020927429,
-0.282306969165802,
0.6410296559333801,
-0.4121887981891632,
-0.22917790710926056,
-0.056557267904281616,
-0.7037725448608398,
0.5361611843109131,
-0.2977930009365082,
0.27000632882118225,
-0.13942426443099976,
-0.10039996355772018,
0.8202607035636902,
0.03403836488723755,
0.8146049976348877,
0.037391453981399536,
-0.5309634208679199,
0.2581324875354767,
-0.25979843735694885,
0.3040522634983063,
-0.12375860661268234,
-0.12403730303049088,
0.25136226415634155,
0.007622359320521355,
-0.25136497616767883,
-0.4153249263763428,
0.6842513680458069,
-0.6655178666114807,
-0.2683740556240082,
-0.4544990658760071,
-0.5140893459320068,
-0.6076288819313049,
0.17043592035770416,
-0.05596653372049332,
0.5823203921318054,
-0.5115612745285034,
0.5232527852058411,
0.9630102515220642,
-0.4702502489089966,
0.1459002047777176,
0.5727158188819885,
-0.5026841759681702,
-0.2527022361755371,
0.9098178744316101,
0.2804427742958069,
0.22292634844779968,
0.44442400336265564,
-0.043395522981882095,
-0.4432433247566223,
-0.8793454170227051,
-0.1505645513534546,
0.3469768464565277,
-0.5540333986282349,
-0.07635441422462463,
-0.49704885482788086,
-0.2487560212612152,
-0.4206465780735016,
0.2798800766468048,
-0.40068212151527405,
-0.1537725180387497,
-0.30024561285972595,
-0.09517679363489151,
0.28548574447631836,
1.048994541168213,
0.22188079357147217,
0.39073634147644043,
-0.6647425889968872,
0.16727401316165924,
0.05777979642152786,
0.5600136518478394,
-0.007583084050565958,
-0.3931090533733368,
-0.2586974799633026,
-0.012899775058031082,
-0.02134554646909237,
-0.44854867458343506,
0.36248382925987244,
0.11736627668142319,
0.567897379398346,
0.5996288657188416,
-0.1458018720149994,
0.424144446849823,
-0.6333417296409607,
0.857787549495697,
0.032790739089250565,
-0.4723564386367798,
0.15610314905643463,
-0.6044492125511169,
0.23936569690704346,
0.5390828847885132,
0.5714439153671265,
-0.9156816601753235,
-0.06787377595901489,
-0.5330890417098999,
-0.8839738368988037,
0.6311926245689392,
0.034251004457473755,
0.27080613374710083,
0.22351425886154175,
0.20320509374141693,
0.23031136393547058,
0.36324480175971985,
-0.36215993762016296,
-0.33951273560523987,
0.2686781883239746,
-0.3790695071220398,
-0.44751614332199097,
-0.32891833782196045,
-0.03039637953042984,
-0.01703302562236786,
0.5252131223678589,
-0.06891892850399017,
0.034148428589105606,
-0.4821712374687195,
-0.15549884736537933,
0.3414321541786194,
0.44371703267097473,
0.4738820195198059,
0.9010831713676453,
-0.24659763276576996,
0.16853882372379303,
0.20301871001720428,
-0.6125573515892029,
0.17823126912117004,
-0.08325501531362534,
-0.051977839320898056,
-0.06450723856687546,
0.468782901763916,
0.7243788838386536,
0.15752257406711578,
-0.7716884016990662,
0.3714509904384613,
-0.05148095265030861,
-0.09619949012994766,
-0.4858913719654083,
-0.2387843132019043,
0.26051756739616394,
-0.09783504158258438,
0.3006165325641632,
-0.4958312511444092,
0.02093822881579399,
-0.5512024760246277,
0.07105474919080734,
0.3456556797027588,
-0.3519923985004425,
-0.4252637028694153,
0.11572248488664627,
0.03566792234778404,
0.10301137715578079,
0.7270777821540833,
0.22809448838233948,
-0.2870665490627289,
0.5254560708999634,
0.2723841369152069,
0.6373106241226196,
-0.07702690362930298,
0.09299656748771667,
0.16962361335754395,
0.2991868257522583,
-0.1902737021446228,
0.20323722064495087,
0.23032721877098083,
-0.9052321314811707,
-0.567258894443512,
-0.8394492864608765,
-0.6404038667678833,
0.6861562132835388,
-0.5044963955879211,
0.30352526903152466,
-0.3969472050666809,
0.1390150487422943,
-0.241676464676857,
0.2571437358856201,
-0.6463387608528137,
0.2951594293117523,
0.28188735246658325,
0.9186201095581055,
-0.8777955174446106,
0.8298214077949524,
0.6527616381645203,
-0.18712960183620453,
-0.40460410714149475,
-0.10980233550071716,
0.05616450682282448,
-0.8132897019386292,
0.5637585520744324,
-0.1052551344037056,
0.007099499925971031,
0.08017028868198395,
-0.7566167116165161,
-0.8876574635505676,
0.7310647964477539,
0.31029725074768066,
-0.8387614488601685,
-0.08839955925941467,
0.5766822695732117,
0.5680260062217712,
-0.40400075912475586,
0.24967455863952637,
1.0001945495605469,
0.42013636231422424,
-0.06557552516460419,
-0.6273077130317688,
-0.29619354009628296,
-0.21734566986560822,
0.10673224180936813,
0.06834974884986877,
-0.5839529633522034,
0.5813387036323547,
0.22133074700832367,
0.08750283718109131,
0.0664675384759903,
0.46870800852775574,
0.3605714738368988,
-0.1118437871336937,
0.3226011097431183,
0.40843504667282104,
0.5246441960334778,
-0.11554165184497833,
0.8733175992965698,
-0.467168927192688,
0.3500061333179474,
1.1238319873809814,
-0.5241902470588684,
0.7506693601608276,
0.3532087802886963,
-0.4556860327720642,
-0.0014795222086831927,
0.8059296607971191,
-0.10959964990615845,
0.12096948176622391,
0.5106375813484192,
-0.2265838235616684,
-0.23457801342010498,
-0.2880339026451111,
-0.47326087951660156,
0.5445109605789185,
0.5159885883331299,
-0.2400735318660736,
-0.3796818256378174,
-0.12204037606716156,
-0.0021949822548776865,
-0.15280359983444214,
-0.24822834134101868,
0.7016275525093079,
0.1627478003501892,
-0.1654600352048874,
0.2298501580953598,
-0.0170644111931324,
0.668279230594635,
-0.8285737633705139,
0.11192987859249115,
-0.39081045985221863,
0.03682352975010872,
-0.12457789480686188,
-1.0877735614776611,
0.08202847838401794,
0.21540185809135437,
-0.16585873067378998,
-0.5740146636962891,
0.5860865116119385,
-0.37963953614234924,
-0.5026389956474304,
0.09149348735809326,
0.624543309211731,
0.402492493391037,
0.11051966995000839,
-0.43350163102149963,
0.3835797905921936,
-0.16755172610282898,
-0.3939649164676666,
0.33920982480049133,
0.47502559423446655,
-0.06245071813464165,
0.5781263113021851,
0.44780731201171875,
0.36363935470581055,
0.08663590252399445,
0.3916808068752289,
0.9195315837860107,
-0.8570016026496887,
-0.0824701115489006,
-0.6708149313926697,
0.30629515647888184,
-0.0223227646201849,
-0.3982792794704437,
0.8236187100410461,
0.9455457329750061,
0.8579659461975098,
-0.031186800450086594,
1.0605908632278442,
0.00313200824894011,
0.7989550828933716,
-0.5135783553123474,
0.6652715802192688,
-0.22138968110084534,
0.30215829610824585,
-0.20077919960021973,
-1.0421401262283325,
-0.42436331510543823,
0.2821909189224243,
-0.4907805621623993,
0.1263778656721115,
0.4253976047039032,
0.6090208888053894,
-0.0014284882927313447,
0.045143771916627884,
0.33437979221343994,
0.35182732343673706,
0.34453269839286804,
0.2190122753381729,
1.0516055822372437,
-0.19551679491996765,
0.18744376301765442,
0.0009644835372455418,
-0.02089260146021843,
-0.1422058790922165,
-0.7629980444908142,
-0.6990286707878113,
-0.6232991218566895,
-0.1227862760424614,
0.1248602494597435,
-0.09941617399454117,
0.8383339047431946,
0.3248353898525238,
-0.9305369257926941,
-0.6531659960746765,
0.10568684339523315,
-0.04940145090222359,
0.3015226423740387,
-0.14043056964874268,
0.3281749188899994,
-0.3729933798313141,
-0.7828101515769958,
0.3321114182472229,
0.16010509431362152,
-0.07215566188097,
-0.775208055973053,
0.11431397497653961,
-0.19183745980262756,
-0.08580774813890457,
0.8141418695449829,
0.19286511838436127,
-0.4544801414012909,
0.019887935370206833,
0.2565574049949646,
-0.1423349827528,
0.01571253314614296,
0.8456475138664246,
-0.458497017621994,
0.1287539154291153,
0.47144815325737,
0.6964908838272095,
0.29767751693725586,
-0.5012456178665161,
0.6295868158340454,
-0.6329922080039978,
-0.05071570724248886,
0.24219255149364471,
0.36554116010665894,
0.4411117136478424,
-0.0054590823128819466,
0.49471840262413025,
0.007687792181968689,
-0.4962114691734314,
-0.9586748480796814,
0.16111011803150177,
-0.9076149463653564,
-0.14987686276435852,
1.2409793138504028,
0.013229102827608585,
-0.0618479922413826,
-0.17385004460811615,
-0.16257381439208984,
0.0814674124121666,
-0.12527041137218475,
0.4942067265510559,
1.0283452272415161,
0.028005540370941162,
-0.2281801551580429,
-0.7600147128105164,
0.26824572682380676,
0.0486978255212307,
-0.9822378158569336,
0.4575439989566803,
0.8276526927947998,
0.3512663245201111,
-0.14458999037742615,
0.4992758631706238,
-0.21067240834236145,
-0.3987092673778534,
-0.3175828456878662,
0.18509218096733093,
0.19289445877075195,
-0.4419899582862854,
-0.7182354927062988,
0.2507691979408264,
0.12963485717773438,
0.21516917645931244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18039v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18039v1
|
ResLoRA: Identity Residual Mapping in Low-Rank Adaption
| 2024-02-28T04:33:20 | 2024-02-28T04:33:20 |
Shuhua Shi, Shaohan Huang, Minghui Song, Zhoujun Li, Zihan Zhang, Haizhen Huang, Furu Wei, Weiwei Deng, Feng Sun, Qi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As one of the most popular parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods,
low-rank adaptation (LoRA) is commonly applied to fine-tune large language
models (LLMs). However, updating the weights of LoRA blocks effectively and
expeditiously is challenging due to the long calculation path in the original
model. To address this, we propose ResLoRA, an improved framework of LoRA. By
adding residual paths during training and using merging approaches to eliminate
these extra paths during inference, our method can achieve better results in
fewer training steps without any extra trainable parameters or inference cost
compared to LoRA. The experiments on NLG, NLU, and text-to-image tasks
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method. To the best of our knowledge,
ResLoRA is the first work that combines the residual path with LoRA. The code
of our method is available at
https://github.com/microsoft/LMOps/tree/main/reslora .
|
[
-0.2958008050918579,
-0.5860074758529663,
0.4592788815498352,
-0.1433716118335724,
-0.31454727053642273,
0.0986759290099144,
-0.4075973629951477,
-0.5688128471374512,
0.2880559265613556,
0.6014962792396545,
-0.5296597480773926,
-0.45292168855667114,
-0.4872919023036957,
-0.08003021776676178,
-0.23898619413375854,
0.8706852793693542,
0.0893857479095459,
-0.22528265416622162,
0.21558105945587158,
-0.6460453867912292,
-0.7172254323959351,
-0.1978883147239685,
-0.8602937459945679,
-0.31393009424209595,
1.294730305671692,
0.6371243596076965,
0.6948928236961365,
0.392649382352829,
0.3566555380821228,
0.24413053691387177,
-0.12341700494289398,
0.41070666909217834,
-0.9067854881286621,
0.20966434478759766,
-0.5933820009231567,
-0.5011245608329773,
-0.6454416513442993,
-0.04994651675224304,
0.9350836873054504,
0.7371065020561218,
0.007902897894382477,
0.5779696106910706,
0.04348693788051605,
1.0335317850112915,
-0.7800931930541992,
-0.3910183012485504,
-0.8734971284866333,
-0.16751985251903534,
-0.137386754155159,
-0.4432888925075531,
-0.46481767296791077,
-0.4426482021808624,
-0.12686501443386078,
-0.43358680605888367,
-0.13673409819602966,
-0.07263005524873734,
0.9570091366767883,
0.5373563766479492,
-0.2799117863178253,
0.29110053181648254,
-0.8998196721076965,
0.7460267543792725,
-0.8188644647598267,
0.42887213826179504,
0.014965664595365524,
0.5176320672035217,
-0.2741847336292267,
-0.6360827684402466,
-0.18542061746120453,
0.00818675383925438,
0.1631963551044464,
-0.12332995980978012,
-0.32600557804107666,
-0.06305184960365295,
-0.007082452066242695,
0.18122266232967377,
-0.17290228605270386,
0.5448355674743652,
-0.5865643620491028,
0.15356361865997314,
0.5197016596794128,
-0.24579265713691711,
0.0974205806851387,
0.5315598845481873,
-0.169929638504982,
-0.01724112592637539,
-1.2173902988433838,
-0.302640438079834,
0.30002015829086304,
0.7489119172096252,
-0.049187321215867996,
0.3668535649776459,
-0.14567531645298004,
1.2017744779586792,
0.06108683720231056,
-0.3461703360080719,
0.19993098080158234,
-0.10238493233919144,
-0.2808784246444702,
0.21952718496322632,
0.1785377413034439,
0.22118979692459106,
0.22518157958984375,
-0.2656051814556122,
0.04869726300239563,
-0.0950046181678772,
0.0223274827003479,
-0.7445160746574402,
-0.11804763972759247,
0.09192598611116409,
-0.44354742765426636,
-0.17144186794757843,
-0.19097280502319336,
-0.8189346790313721,
-0.586826741695404,
-0.5327815413475037,
0.27446436882019043,
-0.306035578250885,
0.022997012361884117,
-0.018347179517149925,
0.28788819909095764,
0.5057892799377441,
0.7871858477592468,
-0.5421584248542786,
0.200099915266037,
0.6804689168930054,
0.664196252822876,
-0.41991254687309265,
-0.42557576298713684,
-0.9417181611061096,
0.08219818770885468,
-0.35662609338760376,
1.0375239849090576,
-0.4200725555419922,
0.19560450315475464,
-0.1693635731935501,
0.142557293176651,
-0.1351523995399475,
-0.5811642408370972,
0.4908764660358429,
-0.6493406295776367,
0.24277082085609436,
-0.1931312531232834,
-0.2749521732330322,
-0.4627637267112732,
0.07219355553388596,
-0.6250013113021851,
1.061547875404358,
0.5982472896575928,
-0.4269850552082062,
0.10625764727592468,
-0.620076596736908,
-0.13098272681236267,
-0.13312985002994537,
0.1522327959537506,
-0.359915554523468,
0.18937371671199799,
-0.024383608251810074,
-0.026146480813622475,
-0.37126320600509644,
0.05517714098095894,
-0.3407558798789978,
-0.6880771517753601,
-0.04761767014861107,
-0.5053911805152893,
0.5970593094825745,
0.11596237123012543,
-0.2916965186595917,
0.2594304382801056,
-0.8542271256446838,
0.07528616487979889,
-0.07582499086856842,
-0.6104577779769897,
-0.4018399715423584,
-0.07887516170740128,
0.0789806991815567,
0.24256311357021332,
0.34286215901374817,
-0.27263113856315613,
0.4732547700405121,
-0.46290478110313416,
0.1179179921746254,
0.9684887528419495,
0.06395239382982254,
0.46655264496803284,
-0.313127726316452,
0.5441938042640686,
-0.15028013288974762,
-0.06576938927173615,
0.11803451180458069,
-0.6222848296165466,
-1.077668309211731,
-0.2521984577178955,
0.6776160597801208,
0.46955108642578125,
-0.5936278104782104,
0.5310080647468567,
-0.624843180179596,
-0.8186632990837097,
-0.6045922636985779,
0.3757769465446472,
0.31644511222839355,
0.505691647529602,
0.42782893776893616,
-0.18250469863414764,
-0.5369369983673096,
-0.7870622873306274,
-0.4616518020629883,
-0.015546222217381,
0.05419720336794853,
0.21313762664794922,
0.23647910356521606,
-0.33375638723373413,
1.192800521850586,
-0.44761303067207336,
-0.6655778288841248,
-0.08694133907556534,
-0.18828141689300537,
0.4435773491859436,
0.5289571285247803,
0.8363073468208313,
-0.41794678568840027,
-0.7114055156707764,
0.24302692711353302,
-0.3122099041938782,
-0.3355075418949127,
-0.1881043165922165,
-0.24537870287895203,
0.24331264197826385,
0.45883500576019287,
-0.009626587852835655,
0.40996479988098145,
0.8835261464118958,
-0.608844518661499,
0.11029723286628723,
-0.38810545206069946,
0.08772207051515579,
-0.9331185817718506,
0.2712881863117218,
-0.19090037047863007,
-0.6321530342102051,
-0.5880035161972046,
0.14686034619808197,
-0.27654212713241577,
-0.1512369066476822,
-0.5680583119392395,
0.623910129070282,
-0.5267271399497986,
-0.45469045639038086,
-0.43631666898727417,
0.37878385186195374,
-0.10599226504564285,
0.7217139601707458,
-0.3117460012435913,
0.9046226739883423,
0.22305411100387573,
-0.3997691869735718,
0.23137271404266357,
-0.16512475907802582,
0.03780900314450264,
0.6128339767456055,
-0.3211556077003479,
0.3144074082374573,
-0.0791996493935585,
0.2467770278453827,
-0.9396183490753174,
0.23090070486068726,
0.3417014181613922,
-0.06342608481645584,
0.13146106898784637,
-0.3334145247936249,
-0.263171523809433,
0.10892262309789658,
-0.27283284068107605,
0.46598127484321594,
0.807650089263916,
-0.8149328827857971,
0.9171982407569885,
0.16791245341300964,
0.020245099440217018,
-0.3065301477909088,
-0.44349464774131775,
0.2581939101219177,
-0.6055823564529419,
-0.2900707423686981,
0.6356096267700195,
-0.06970325112342834,
-0.11156688630580902,
-0.12941612303256989,
0.16046766936779022,
-0.09970492124557495,
0.4084128141403198,
0.23824968934059143,
0.028905900195240974,
-0.4193651080131531,
0.00606463523581624,
0.10356266796588898,
-0.2643485367298126,
-0.5891757011413574,
0.05125490203499794,
0.5104245543479919,
-0.09820179641246796,
-0.4875018894672394,
-0.6160125136375427,
0.1717979907989502,
0.6927282810211182,
-0.030555058270692825,
0.9094606637954712,
0.6149189472198486,
-0.42192569375038147,
-0.177414208650589,
-0.5001240372657776,
-0.05342438071966171,
-0.488435834646225,
0.2659434378147125,
-0.20708006620407104,
-0.7328886985778809,
0.685455322265625,
-0.5129637718200684,
0.16071496903896332,
0.3862442672252655,
0.28240475058555603,
0.07570863515138626,
0.38528335094451904,
0.8106682896614075,
-0.32781511545181274,
0.6447354555130005,
-0.11894867569208145,
0.2975865304470062,
-0.9598264098167419,
0.22334595024585724,
-0.5465145111083984,
-0.7430163621902466,
-0.39825159311294556,
-0.6061878800392151,
0.31043773889541626,
0.3400317430496216,
-0.2889552116394043,
0.3919563591480255,
-0.5677452087402344,
0.4096418023109436,
0.4646085500717163,
0.1604549139738083,
0.6329760551452637,
0.18323932588100433,
0.5499079823493958,
-0.20214153826236725,
-0.7925650477409363,
-0.3336482644081116,
0.8663574457168579,
0.5110552310943604,
0.7509435415267944,
0.3935011327266693,
0.8579740524291992,
0.35506901144981384,
0.7676001191139221,
-0.7401978969573975,
0.4820265769958496,
-0.37568986415863037,
-0.047845665365457535,
-0.36633801460266113,
-0.08228267729282379,
-1.0337189435958862,
0.43899837136268616,
-0.21762065589427948,
-0.8958637118339539,
0.5980157256126404,
0.3671324849128723,
-0.5642234683036804,
0.36417272686958313,
-0.6476227045059204,
0.641532838344574,
-0.11366861313581467,
-0.4313648045063019,
-0.16988660395145416,
-0.23849590122699738,
0.32818296551704407,
-0.4438988268375397,
0.027790432795882225,
-0.12295535951852798,
-0.1548285186290741,
0.9366337656974792,
-0.38732102513313293,
1.0759649276733398,
-0.24603985249996185,
-0.5990478992462158,
0.22358888387680054,
-0.023295581340789795,
0.7937871217727661,
-0.2847425639629364,
-0.12602786719799042,
0.02113775536417961,
0.01665259711444378,
-0.277901291847229,
-0.735404908657074,
0.9630663394927979,
-0.6124264597892761,
-0.43233099579811096,
-0.4216661751270294,
-0.43194496631622314,
-0.45699480175971985,
0.19373390078544617,
-0.09337197989225388,
0.0740061104297638,
-0.05115005746483803,
0.29996559023857117,
0.4907510280609131,
-0.27336227893829346,
0.22734089195728302,
0.6448235511779785,
-0.34828469157218933,
-0.4089106619358063,
0.9635288715362549,
0.12868107855319977,
0.2228907197713852,
0.15736936032772064,
0.15196572244167328,
0.011718155816197395,
-0.644791305065155,
-0.10118194669485092,
0.5004969835281372,
-0.7261228561401367,
-0.4170648157596588,
-0.011878677643835545,
-0.17961522936820984,
-0.24776065349578857,
-0.27923789620399475,
-0.688523530960083,
-0.383559912443161,
-0.5634918808937073,
0.2513723075389862,
0.6163801550865173,
0.4422387182712555,
0.09525367617607117,
0.5519722700119019,
-0.6260721683502197,
0.39850273728370667,
0.23051078617572784,
0.2892474830150604,
0.07991527020931244,
-0.9894523024559021,
-0.23599638044834137,
0.0058816419914364815,
-0.09846386313438416,
-0.8180767893791199,
0.3896770179271698,
0.6122505068778992,
0.3128851354122162,
0.28748559951782227,
0.0515226349234581,
1.136339783668518,
-0.5947491526603699,
0.5989400148391724,
0.04021286591887474,
-0.601835310459137,
0.37875857949256897,
-0.2317519187927246,
0.16914793848991394,
0.8863600492477417,
-0.28189414739608765,
-0.48431718349456787,
-0.008989043533802032,
-0.3930773437023163,
-0.716762125492096,
0.42011499404907227,
-0.051643166691064835,
-0.1343511939048767,
0.5796485543251038,
0.5517358779907227,
-0.07878205180168152,
-0.12736152112483978,
-0.7217237949371338,
-0.3637528717517853,
0.3159881830215454,
-0.19668106734752655,
-0.15651988983154297,
-0.4363597631454468,
-0.42899709939956665,
-0.44532668590545654,
0.7942347526550293,
-0.46849924325942993,
-0.049707163125276566,
0.16365228593349457,
-0.11330725252628326,
-0.07533860206604004,
0.13669483363628387,
0.728432297706604,
0.9010495543479919,
-0.3848596215248108,
0.04804500564932823,
0.42241573333740234,
-0.21966132521629333,
0.2266518622636795,
-0.12344133108854294,
-0.08783987164497375,
0.03779345378279686,
0.5541372895240784,
0.6826518177986145,
0.4913400113582611,
-0.6096545457839966,
0.2142980992794037,
0.2212323099374771,
-0.046671561896800995,
-0.3802746832370758,
0.06324521452188492,
0.08179205656051636,
0.2539483606815338,
0.4038260877132416,
0.13996416330337524,
-0.24264194071292877,
-0.5081797242164612,
0.15975461900234222,
0.18405231833457947,
-0.590336263179779,
-0.21936939656734467,
0.2373892068862915,
0.15064586699008942,
-0.4644371569156647,
0.29384684562683105,
0.06578733772039413,
-0.3000113368034363,
0.3458231985569,
0.5760811567306519,
0.8949192762374878,
-0.256879597902298,
0.08776883035898209,
0.13439761102199554,
0.3248182535171509,
0.019857270643115044,
0.2309388518333435,
0.30240514874458313,
-0.5669135451316833,
-0.36007583141326904,
-0.5555753111839294,
-0.1395481824874878,
0.056576378643512726,
-0.4149855971336365,
0.37798672914505005,
-0.3441411852836609,
-0.056289348751306534,
-0.35814422369003296,
-0.12873756885528564,
-0.36112868785858154,
-0.21409453451633453,
0.034238774329423904,
1.1049281358718872,
-1.0282522439956665,
1.0519465208053589,
0.38478273153305054,
-0.13937847316265106,
-0.6231868863105774,
-0.132362499833107,
-0.3194226324558258,
-0.6071166396141052,
0.7623022794723511,
-0.2419995367527008,
-0.41525566577911377,
0.18459546566009521,
-0.2944895029067993,
-1.2609131336212158,
1.3369858264923096,
0.8490738868713379,
-0.49344760179519653,
-0.10146552324295044,
-0.11469350010156631,
0.6749880909919739,
-0.5775758624076843,
-0.2885205149650574,
0.7511781454086304,
0.7121789455413818,
0.06098923459649086,
-0.8330032229423523,
0.12074936926364899,
0.2265542596578598,
0.13673193752765656,
-0.12097393721342087,
-0.662611186504364,
0.7699295282363892,
-0.03077482059597969,
-0.24948085844516754,
0.44563961029052734,
0.7240350246429443,
0.5186408162117004,
0.10566020011901855,
0.5776427984237671,
0.6725366711616516,
0.8108311295509338,
-0.04242425039410591,
0.6979243755340576,
-0.3564818501472473,
0.5288368463516235,
1.6506956815719604,
-0.39936962723731995,
0.9973132610321045,
0.7508504986763,
-0.2530854642391205,
0.7855045795440674,
0.7454827427864075,
0.06733288615942001,
0.5544705390930176,
0.20839045941829681,
-0.008264333009719849,
-0.2538699805736542,
-0.1380332112312317,
-0.5059402585029602,
0.4215024709701538,
0.1400974988937378,
-0.4184204339981079,
-0.5472322702407837,
-0.02542300894856453,
0.07098353654146194,
0.24287879467010498,
-0.3379646837711334,
0.5249220132827759,
-0.013721385039389133,
-0.586083173751831,
1.047194242477417,
0.10207900404930115,
0.6497440338134766,
-0.47710806131362915,
-0.41518163681030273,
-0.43224960565567017,
0.30547192692756653,
-0.3115229606628418,
-0.239238440990448,
0.17006762325763702,
-0.18799997866153717,
0.04910824075341225,
0.007643954828381538,
0.7032008171081543,
-0.49161261320114136,
-0.5188539624214172,
0.40172430872917175,
0.4192516505718231,
0.04273441061377525,
-0.10871461778879166,
-0.6964429020881653,
0.2501680552959442,
0.048357266932725906,
-0.11620592325925827,
0.47477149963378906,
0.14182455837726593,
-0.18955284357070923,
0.7426168918609619,
0.6982407569885254,
0.2893974483013153,
0.06986735761165619,
0.12462466210126877,
0.9847016334533691,
-0.6000428199768066,
-0.4462163746356964,
-0.6031120419502258,
0.30408769845962524,
0.04429277405142784,
-0.06906698644161224,
0.5936194062232971,
0.5922734141349792,
0.15934184193611145,
-0.06454330682754517,
0.346131831407547,
0.20386706292629242,
0.5501942038536072,
-0.6868548393249512,
0.7482315301895142,
-0.6542258262634277,
0.46340054273605347,
-0.18769536912441254,
-1.416690468788147,
-0.3217935264110565,
0.3979628384113312,
-0.09655633568763733,
-0.019823698326945305,
0.7025331854820251,
0.8121858835220337,
-0.27863019704818726,
-0.8006645441055298,
0.4099612832069397,
0.15199555456638336,
0.3735552430152893,
0.7849659323692322,
0.26352712512016296,
-0.8257883787155151,
0.22622311115264893,
0.02579416334629059,
-0.2735361158847809,
-0.4173436164855957,
-1.1301476955413818,
-0.6076132655143738,
-0.4073410928249359,
-0.4791397154331207,
-0.4711311161518097,
0.14284974336624146,
0.6033772230148315,
0.7353342771530151,
-0.7815098762512207,
-0.09654365479946136,
0.0642089769244194,
0.4479840099811554,
-0.48069801926612854,
-0.20458269119262695,
0.5983046889305115,
-0.015517023392021656,
-0.8451365232467651,
0.5428746938705444,
0.31952551007270813,
-0.002254428341984749,
-0.5181933641433716,
-0.19612133502960205,
-0.43709224462509155,
-0.016582123935222626,
0.5109691619873047,
0.7730286717414856,
-0.8036067485809326,
-0.6119535565376282,
-0.5354143977165222,
0.15324154496192932,
0.2049243152141571,
0.6326839923858643,
-1.0594375133514404,
0.15587395429611206,
0.5425488352775574,
0.7271963953971863,
0.1598966270685196,
0.3061695992946625,
0.598458468914032,
-0.5482703447341919,
0.32581204175949097,
-0.055850569158792496,
0.43370679020881653,
0.30453187227249146,
-0.3405507206916809,
0.7346935868263245,
0.20751364529132843,
-0.3005610704421997,
-1.148475170135498,
0.24028700590133667,
-1.343334674835205,
-0.27880123257637024,
1.2619646787643433,
-0.16756947338581085,
-0.5603722333908081,
-0.01475130207836628,
-0.3908393681049347,
0.11142498254776001,
-0.18967807292938232,
0.605714738368988,
0.11852110177278519,
-0.03820362687110901,
-0.32066914439201355,
-0.19007675349712372,
0.5735049247741699,
0.2885197103023529,
-0.9102492332458496,
0.25488948822021484,
0.291439026594162,
0.3473384380340576,
0.34671977162361145,
0.6469165086746216,
0.04202943667769432,
0.1933021992444992,
-0.5133571624755859,
-0.1351439207792282,
-0.09368716925382614,
-0.3873458802700043,
-0.688165545463562,
0.16109612584114075,
0.5111081600189209,
-0.0865408331155777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18031v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18031v1
|
Corpus-Steered Query Expansion with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-28T03:58:58 | 2024-02-28T03:58:58 |
Yibin Lei, Yu Cao, Tianyi Zhou, Tao Shen, Andrew Yates
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Recent studies demonstrate that query expansions generated by large language
models (LLMs) can considerably enhance information retrieval systems by
generating hypothetical documents that answer the queries as expansions.
However, challenges arise from misalignments between the expansions and the
retrieval corpus, resulting in issues like hallucinations and outdated
information due to the limited intrinsic knowledge of LLMs. Inspired by Pseudo
Relevance Feedback (PRF), we introduce Corpus-Steered Query Expansion (CSQE) to
promote the incorporation of knowledge embedded within the corpus. CSQE
utilizes the relevance assessing capability of LLMs to systematically identify
pivotal sentences in the initially-retrieved documents. These corpus-originated
texts are subsequently used to expand the query together with LLM-knowledge
empowered expansions, improving the relevance prediction between the query and
the target documents. Extensive experiments reveal that CSQE exhibits strong
performance without necessitating any training, especially with queries for
which LLMs lack knowledge.
|
[
-0.2389264851808548,
-0.7828766703605652,
0.969150185585022,
0.0494849719107151,
-0.27366751432418823,
0.16394460201263428,
-0.3390854001045227,
-0.28601089119911194,
0.37683144211769104,
0.7577552199363708,
-0.7022046446800232,
-0.6006017923355103,
-0.5756885409355164,
-0.08078397810459137,
-0.7884661555290222,
0.7345802783966064,
0.42816561460494995,
0.16182537376880646,
-0.19755230844020844,
0.050313662737607956,
-0.38354408740997314,
-0.7777913808822632,
-0.2788054943084717,
0.252032607793808,
0.4873356819152832,
0.25378498435020447,
0.8714524507522583,
0.3632025420665741,
0.4207894206047058,
0.18699763715267181,
-0.16484765708446503,
0.46268823742866516,
-0.8004167079925537,
0.2695252299308777,
-0.29528459906578064,
-0.7213402390480042,
-0.18238946795463562,
-0.31061890721321106,
0.9517036080360413,
0.7158156633377075,
-0.22605040669441223,
-0.1727527678012848,
0.05280158668756485,
0.6813032627105713,
-0.8207895755767822,
-0.11567112803459167,
-0.6622651815414429,
-0.20862457156181335,
-0.25392335653305054,
-0.48916614055633545,
-0.42625048756599426,
-0.6388427019119263,
0.3653368651866913,
-0.5374351143836975,
0.05215809866786003,
0.3041035532951355,
0.6216458678245544,
0.07831225544214249,
-0.46609553694725037,
-0.5167807936668396,
-0.679435670375824,
0.8023262023925781,
-0.5465022325515747,
0.6576754450798035,
0.18080781400203705,
0.23984187841415405,
-0.500379204750061,
-0.805286705493927,
-0.4630545377731323,
-0.42768311500549316,
-0.1252610832452774,
0.08962879329919815,
-0.0007884649094194174,
0.1557808369398117,
0.1891627013683319,
0.2568855583667755,
-0.5535746812820435,
-0.07053959369659424,
-0.3060738742351532,
-0.24779854714870453,
0.3996583819389343,
0.08934704214334488,
0.2765980660915375,
-0.10930775105953217,
-0.18535304069519043,
-0.05328597128391266,
-0.922757625579834,
-0.18907494843006134,
0.2613320052623749,
0.2672375738620758,
0.38019344210624695,
0.688554048538208,
-0.19700153172016144,
0.9531210660934448,
0.37443313002586365,
0.056425951421260834,
0.051794856786727905,
-0.37871354818344116,
0.08432932198047638,
0.05768579989671707,
0.607654869556427,
0.12318427860736847,
-0.11719603836536407,
-0.39855995774269104,
-0.1484328806400299,
-0.44466131925582886,
0.47038987278938293,
-0.8233679533004761,
0.10752160102128983,
0.1454431116580963,
-0.3657119870185852,
-0.05035385861992836,
0.27287501096725464,
-0.7026252746582031,
-0.48248612880706787,
-0.2983953058719635,
0.3254740238189697,
-0.6609771251678467,
-0.36830565333366394,
-0.10904794931411743,
-0.1790081262588501,
0.45643311738967896,
0.21355032920837402,
-0.6020748615264893,
0.13405069708824158,
0.7382663488388062,
0.45131784677505493,
-0.22496254742145538,
0.07801665365695953,
-0.8966191411018372,
0.07847482711076736,
-0.5388050079345703,
0.8155995011329651,
-0.8962929248809814,
-0.801860511302948,
0.31837621331214905,
0.07323484122753143,
-0.012902759946882725,
-0.6230481863021851,
0.7648747563362122,
-1.260213017463684,
0.16331610083580017,
-0.5106552839279175,
-0.7506377100944519,
-0.09339587390422821,
0.2117997407913208,
-0.442207008600235,
1.310863971710205,
0.16203996539115906,
-0.6945418119430542,
0.14249619841575623,
-0.5300361514091492,
-0.35369354486465454,
0.1248844712972641,
-0.24239958822727203,
0.02371101640164852,
0.18091239035129547,
0.09343064576387405,
0.18057683110237122,
-0.4943775236606598,
0.512607991695404,
-0.3360806405544281,
-0.40524202585220337,
0.12749551236629486,
-0.12986958026885986,
0.6212062835693359,
0.09948182851076126,
0.015633122995495796,
0.27881231904029846,
-0.6297945380210876,
0.20481202006340027,
-0.14415402710437775,
-0.18950457870960236,
-0.5783888697624207,
0.07105396687984467,
-0.25109732151031494,
-0.05320023000240326,
0.5330212116241455,
-0.24351906776428223,
0.24210292100906372,
-0.7349620461463928,
0.11486431956291199,
0.3111307919025421,
0.23479725420475006,
0.8359971046447754,
-0.17844249308109283,
0.7999863028526306,
-0.018287619575858116,
-0.00469554215669632,
-0.15378759801387787,
-0.3449207842350006,
-0.5602658987045288,
-0.10903739184141159,
0.5046315789222717,
0.5915367603302002,
-0.8871884942054749,
0.4301123321056366,
-0.38428473472595215,
-0.5099332928657532,
-0.44211652874946594,
0.22628188133239746,
0.09930255264043808,
0.44859930872917175,
0.4462375342845917,
0.005234583280980587,
-0.5024736523628235,
-0.8497496247291565,
-0.30835554003715515,
-0.34281402826309204,
-0.16451546549797058,
0.47487616539001465,
0.13894179463386536,
0.021719617769122124,
1.0706140995025635,
-0.6056522130966187,
-0.08557599782943726,
-0.19329023361206055,
0.07576913386583328,
0.3376634418964386,
0.1428283303976059,
0.3932931125164032,
-1.107279658317566,
-0.3308461010456085,
-0.2336011677980423,
-0.5845056772232056,
-0.30047088861465454,
-0.049002524465322495,
-0.46127620339393616,
-0.13554777204990387,
0.725028932094574,
-0.5498165488243103,
0.15574972331523895,
0.20353847742080688,
-0.0719805359840393,
0.7808788418769836,
-0.24515412747859955,
0.25879278779029846,
-1.030882716178894,
-0.03446284309029579,
-0.11212076246738434,
-0.15221157670021057,
-0.3726797103881836,
0.21737097203731537,
0.5715665221214294,
0.024464262649416924,
-0.34011462330818176,
0.5113769769668579,
-0.6562258005142212,
-0.17733162641525269,
-0.5130661725997925,
0.465120404958725,
-0.19470927119255066,
0.10685919970273972,
0.32508307695388794,
0.8900995254516602,
0.6484342217445374,
-0.8964752554893494,
0.08828580379486084,
0.08235158026218414,
-0.09695529192686081,
0.4419942796230316,
-0.3053915202617645,
0.011258440092206001,
-0.2465869039297104,
0.12808862328529358,
-1.0232362747192383,
-0.007291428744792938,
-0.20808453857898712,
-0.44051888585090637,
0.3782268166542053,
-0.18518663942813873,
-0.6844704151153564,
-0.5237574577331543,
-0.3478243350982666,
0.21073481440544128,
0.42293107509613037,
-0.7204040884971619,
0.8259957432746887,
0.34820878505706787,
-0.1805771291255951,
-0.8090141415596008,
-0.16930030286312103,
0.12853549420833588,
-0.1943591833114624,
-0.691338837146759,
0.667687714099884,
-0.05763382092118263,
-0.24807380139827728,
0.09274645894765854,
0.10079006105661392,
-0.11723645031452179,
-0.09779977798461914,
0.10776109993457794,
0.3293077349662781,
-0.38227614760398865,
0.33157938718795776,
0.47298526763916016,
0.37402838468551636,
0.009309292770922184,
-0.5308746695518494,
0.6287031769752502,
0.056472718715667725,
-0.20410558581352234,
0.011666581965982914,
0.3104945421218872,
0.5443448424339294,
-0.36095964908599854,
0.7730469107627869,
0.47883549332618713,
-0.1495693027973175,
-0.10443130880594254,
-0.7777295112609863,
-0.5325626730918884,
-0.4683677852153778,
0.5354549288749695,
-0.4857368767261505,
-1.1728205680847168,
0.40535399317741394,
-0.4261125326156616,
-0.12065189331769943,
0.5565270781517029,
0.4738471508026123,
-0.1597411036491394,
0.8905213475227356,
0.7797071933746338,
0.0453205406665802,
0.5213795900344849,
-0.04262671619653702,
0.10963914543390274,
-0.9637847542762756,
-0.0374787412583828,
-0.47878146171569824,
-0.0469096414744854,
-0.7333565950393677,
-0.5856447815895081,
0.41243085265159607,
0.49641984701156616,
0.09322451800107956,
0.40321585536003113,
-0.37668704986572266,
0.43134212493896484,
0.52885901927948,
0.0477139987051487,
0.27441152930259705,
-0.26889339089393616,
-0.46730881929397583,
-0.11303224414587021,
-0.8611594438552856,
-0.26915448904037476,
1.4037222862243652,
-0.11162444204092026,
0.47933056950569153,
0.30942150950431824,
0.7115308046340942,
0.3660591244697571,
0.4029388725757599,
-0.8407120704650879,
0.6020357012748718,
-0.00027358238003216684,
-0.6380177140235901,
-0.16030968725681305,
-0.35306334495544434,
-0.9176984429359436,
0.3252059519290924,
-0.3420223891735077,
-0.5746687054634094,
0.29716747999191284,
-0.12592671811580658,
-0.6028233170509338,
-0.07585306465625763,
-0.6268253326416016,
0.4276857078075409,
-0.422288179397583,
-0.7341415286064148,
-0.4603722393512726,
-0.605869710445404,
0.36153846979141235,
-0.30562901496887207,
0.17304956912994385,
0.3418925702571869,
-0.17085804045200348,
0.7796475291252136,
-0.49198606610298157,
0.6703791618347168,
-0.18768534064292908,
-0.06693154573440552,
0.62094646692276,
0.14349442720413208,
0.6837904453277588,
0.22369599342346191,
-0.3025416433811188,
-0.14025726914405823,
0.15282133221626282,
-0.2879941463470459,
-0.7289015054702759,
0.926874041557312,
-0.41836562752723694,
-1.181779384613037,
-0.2896597385406494,
-0.3863527774810791,
-0.5583718419075012,
0.4469437599182129,
-0.06993557512760162,
0.18919797241687775,
-0.3117961585521698,
0.37619292736053467,
0.7433707118034363,
-0.35473349690437317,
0.3047395944595337,
1.1382982730865479,
-0.49007996916770935,
-0.16836009919643402,
0.49838030338287354,
0.22760321199893951,
0.10577922314405441,
0.6442847847938538,
0.09703873097896576,
-0.799003541469574,
-0.685299813747406,
-0.4088808000087738,
0.44695019721984863,
-0.4208028018474579,
-0.1816660314798355,
-0.6991243958473206,
-0.16872817277908325,
-0.5678917169570923,
0.017488135024905205,
-0.22184593975543976,
-0.32145076990127563,
-0.3781682252883911,
-0.09259485453367233,
0.34286853671073914,
0.42911043763160706,
-0.03278582915663719,
0.48976269364356995,
-0.9791808724403381,
0.04998552054166794,
0.06892681121826172,
0.12590108811855316,
-0.12237454205751419,
-0.7666295170783997,
-0.14752048254013062,
-0.17795716226100922,
-0.4488247334957123,
-1.2027451992034912,
0.5660440921783447,
-0.10238603502511978,
0.6088759899139404,
0.4625875949859619,
0.238106831908226,
0.6318652629852295,
-0.4784287214279175,
0.7438136339187622,
0.10560653358697891,
-0.572157621383667,
0.5780069231987,
-0.5454967021942139,
0.29737958312034607,
0.5874815583229065,
0.6233512759208679,
-0.19147101044654846,
-0.4453025162220001,
-0.5518712401390076,
-0.8143379092216492,
0.523772656917572,
0.0673329308629036,
0.1846349537372589,
-0.299930214881897,
0.7768182158470154,
-0.17910435795783997,
0.20753200352191925,
-0.2172500193119049,
-0.0510052926838398,
0.19444876909255981,
-0.04595812410116196,
0.33021730184555054,
-0.5518020391464233,
0.2344759702682495,
-0.1271411031484604,
0.8044987320899963,
-0.14391864836215973,
0.26401540637016296,
0.4404032528400421,
-0.26253852248191833,
0.015134802088141441,
0.28648918867111206,
0.35959210991859436,
0.6651551723480225,
-0.33212751150131226,
-0.16991350054740906,
0.16981922090053558,
-0.26726406812667847,
-0.20754167437553406,
0.1283373087644577,
-0.03895234316587448,
-0.09668184071779251,
0.02708112634718418,
0.38564756512641907,
0.3365176022052765,
-0.8691068887710571,
0.5476193428039551,
0.0066456180065870285,
-0.07062433660030365,
-0.4732419550418854,
0.08544670790433884,
0.37328341603279114,
0.27605974674224854,
0.7841957211494446,
-0.24365687370300293,
0.43392717838287354,
-0.5598918795585632,
0.43000075221061707,
0.6264529824256897,
-0.5567453503608704,
-0.0900781974196434,
0.6731369495391846,
0.1561296433210373,
-0.16340412199497223,
0.5804683566093445,
-0.1820223331451416,
-0.6186560988426208,
0.45718705654144287,
0.5716791152954102,
0.5128679871559143,
-0.15023449063301086,
-0.025635572150349617,
0.6030105948448181,
0.32766175270080566,
-0.1917959451675415,
0.22695563733577728,
-0.2149004489183426,
-0.712921142578125,
-0.7705203890800476,
-0.6416836977005005,
-0.33466458320617676,
0.09489455819129944,
-0.6733965277671814,
0.5694130659103394,
-0.3642215430736542,
-0.39768674969673157,
-0.29620063304901123,
0.03603370487689972,
-0.3538350462913513,
0.2145269811153412,
-0.0019437925657257438,
1.0079712867736816,
-0.29647359251976013,
1.1728862524032593,
0.5102010369300842,
-0.3862702548503876,
-0.6019415855407715,
0.2459726184606552,
-0.1771859973669052,
-0.760353147983551,
0.7608543634414673,
-0.1551818996667862,
-0.29644840955734253,
0.1818305402994156,
-0.28984513878822327,
-1.0809035301208496,
1.0326136350631714,
0.21943604946136475,
-0.8397222757339478,
-0.15036797523498535,
-0.004696907475590706,
0.6544923186302185,
-0.40442806482315063,
0.5704807043075562,
0.45675331354141235,
0.4692087173461914,
0.15871679782867432,
-0.8571369647979736,
-0.038348279893398285,
0.020397977903485298,
-0.07101602852344513,
0.3287960886955261,
-0.5642110705375671,
0.2688373029232025,
-0.1754474937915802,
-0.12651851773262024,
0.21464166045188904,
1.1436607837677002,
0.10257868468761444,
0.022447966039180756,
0.46930232644081116,
0.2154003232717514,
0.9993299841880798,
0.06638865172863007,
1.2688499689102173,
-0.6667455434799194,
0.005072667729109526,
1.3495311737060547,
-0.4229593276977539,
1.1452488899230957,
0.4833041727542877,
-0.05515247955918312,
0.5360050797462463,
0.5758354067802429,
0.28295597434043884,
0.4947545826435089,
0.2152484655380249,
-0.20630769431591034,
-0.45284533500671387,
-0.21493127942085266,
-0.4173984229564667,
0.3250545263290405,
0.686069667339325,
-0.6517926454544067,
-0.1318100541830063,
-0.16035905480384827,
-0.15711207687854767,
0.2953922152519226,
-0.3166678547859192,
0.7471579313278198,
-0.03920994699001312,
-0.8542739152908325,
0.5383134484291077,
0.10499190539121628,
0.760263204574585,
-0.7048461437225342,
0.04941156879067421,
-0.19879688322544098,
-0.13323138654232025,
-0.07443941384553909,
-0.706340491771698,
0.45783811807632446,
-0.12991295754909515,
-0.28326669335365295,
0.045807547867298126,
1.0337018966674805,
-0.39184805750846863,
-0.39652782678604126,
0.5998912453651428,
0.6896529793739319,
-0.05111547186970711,
-0.33021101355552673,
-0.5210439562797546,
-0.2104431539773941,
0.16197200119495392,
-0.15774016082286835,
0.5712239742279053,
0.4653550386428833,
-0.2350999116897583,
0.5228613018989563,
0.755316436290741,
-0.028830543160438538,
0.20590907335281372,
-0.029054051265120506,
0.9851751327514648,
-0.6865653991699219,
-0.46948179602622986,
-0.6865920424461365,
0.05315045267343521,
-0.3317882716655731,
0.0855344757437706,
0.7330055236816406,
0.7909229397773743,
0.35735461115837097,
0.07340854406356812,
0.8050247430801392,
0.062473706901073456,
0.8105347752571106,
-0.4988732933998108,
0.6298636198043823,
-0.666774332523346,
0.5078164935112,
-0.02895011380314827,
-1.1471619606018066,
-0.2514551281929016,
0.29019519686698914,
-0.8816211819648743,
-0.038628410547971725,
0.770451009273529,
1.087509036064148,
0.08819061517715454,
0.12922297418117523,
0.44341811537742615,
0.41117599606513977,
0.023244550451636314,
0.3125319480895996,
0.9262929558753967,
-0.14145633578300476,
0.7012129426002502,
0.13504919409751892,
-0.28471362590789795,
-0.31173720955848694,
-0.760667622089386,
-0.6753127574920654,
-0.5095744132995605,
-0.2863104045391083,
-0.3758115768432617,
0.10858456790447235,
0.682745635509491,
0.7636745572090149,
-0.693715512752533,
-0.11090117692947388,
-0.06109655275940895,
0.1461324840784073,
0.07943593710660934,
-0.33802303671836853,
0.4930189251899719,
-0.4800001382827759,
-0.7678948640823364,
0.7465633749961853,
0.254802942276001,
-0.37719693779945374,
-0.24623635411262512,
0.01718393713235855,
-0.3823379874229431,
0.2821561098098755,
0.5751152634620667,
0.24499283730983734,
-0.4918535649776459,
0.11736349016427994,
0.29516658186912537,
0.02343330904841423,
-0.08610127121210098,
0.8751611113548279,
-0.9982441663742065,
0.34988343715667725,
0.4551021456718445,
0.8003647327423096,
0.6682950258255005,
0.12569496035575867,
0.7283292412757874,
-0.6488987803459167,
-0.06110682711005211,
0.32931023836135864,
0.2365589737892151,
0.11342056840658188,
-0.6529607176780701,
0.3965512812137604,
0.1143617033958435,
-0.293895423412323,
-0.6362562775611877,
0.07345275580883026,
-0.918616533279419,
-0.3503047525882721,
1.3033791780471802,
0.10405365377664566,
-0.4106389582157135,
0.04093838855624199,
-0.3052297830581665,
0.060297511518001556,
-0.509181559085846,
0.5840073823928833,
0.6936650276184082,
-0.1627071350812912,
-0.04825340211391449,
-0.4436662793159485,
0.325687050819397,
0.7606046199798584,
-0.40359142422676086,
-0.016453776508569717,
0.6514990329742432,
0.21914450824260712,
0.2112308144569397,
0.6087515950202942,
-0.5255898237228394,
0.2967507541179657,
-0.32813841104507446,
-0.2580818831920624,
0.26466307044029236,
-0.10735813528299332,
0.03514179214835167,
0.6621940732002258,
0.33266618847846985,
0.1874610036611557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18025v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18025v1
|
Hire a Linguist!: Learning Endangered Languages with In-Context Linguistic Descriptions
| 2024-02-28T03:44:01 | 2024-02-28T03:44:01 |
Kexun Zhang, Yee Man Choi, Zhenqiao Song, Taiqi He, William Yang Wang, Lei Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
How can large language models (LLMs) process and translate endangered
languages? Many languages lack a large corpus to train a decent LLM; therefore
existing LLMs rarely perform well in unseen, endangered languages. On the
contrary, we observe that 2000 endangered languages, though without a large
corpus, have a grammar book or a dictionary. We propose LINGOLLM, a
training-free approach to enable an LLM to process unseen languages that hardly
occur in its pre-training. Our key insight is to demonstrate linguistic
knowledge of an unseen language in an LLM's prompt, including a dictionary, a
grammar book, and morphologically analyzed input text. We implement LINGOLLM on
top of two models, GPT-4 and Mixtral, and evaluate their performance on 5 tasks
across 8 endangered or low-resource languages. Our results show that LINGOLLM
elevates translation capability from GPT-4's 0 to 10.5 BLEU for 10 language
directions. Our findings demonstrate the tremendous value of linguistic
knowledge in the age of LLMs for endangered languages. Our data, code, and
model generations can be found at https://github.com/LLiLab/llm4endangeredlang.
|
[
-0.14675401151180267,
-0.3752983808517456,
0.26583918929100037,
0.31692808866500854,
-0.2943776547908783,
0.0758155956864357,
-0.5110816955566406,
-0.6274866461753845,
0.10880454629659653,
0.8151609301567078,
-0.5507543683052063,
-0.35019874572753906,
-0.5484665632247925,
0.28612834215164185,
-0.4608593285083771,
0.6520798802375793,
0.1819794774055481,
-0.14020204544067383,
-0.10834114998579025,
-0.14695855975151062,
-0.29495322704315186,
-0.46637803316116333,
-0.4311694800853729,
-0.039433058351278305,
0.3708714544773102,
0.6513522267341614,
0.7789047360420227,
0.9128673076629639,
0.18299028277397156,
0.3337010443210602,
-0.4237079322338104,
0.13389888405799866,
-0.8358831405639648,
0.188642218708992,
-0.18257711827754974,
-0.6430116891860962,
-0.24778342247009277,
-0.07448924332857132,
0.7108173966407776,
0.9020722508430481,
0.19385921955108643,
-0.041721802204847336,
-0.1030062735080719,
0.4487389922142029,
-0.4913391172885895,
0.126936137676239,
-0.995096743106842,
0.11567559838294983,
-0.3433992266654968,
-0.2613062560558319,
-0.5298840999603271,
-0.3573116958141327,
0.21896909177303314,
-0.7508218884468079,
-0.13574762642383575,
-0.09934771806001663,
0.5974687933921814,
0.33927327394485474,
-0.38017627596855164,
-0.29801997542381287,
-0.4239438772201538,
0.9587143659591675,
-0.5588856935501099,
0.2290167361497879,
0.6894874572753906,
-0.11169778555631638,
-0.25461745262145996,
-0.48375874757766724,
-0.29770222306251526,
-0.10196870565414429,
-0.1184169128537178,
0.11732630431652069,
-0.1288653314113617,
0.035055484622716904,
0.15045325458049774,
0.27705854177474976,
-0.5004914999008179,
0.43476176261901855,
-0.3057197630405426,
-0.0821661651134491,
0.35118988156318665,
-0.0452788844704628,
0.36361175775527954,
-0.16140177845954895,
-0.4136312007904053,
0.024768611416220665,
-0.827421247959137,
-0.2534879446029663,
0.2935319244861603,
0.4118509590625763,
-0.029687413945794106,
0.3921731412410736,
-0.16387970745563507,
0.6919409036636353,
-0.16550765931606293,
0.10046751797199249,
0.275251567363739,
0.24748419225215912,
0.04758712649345398,
0.0008147057378664613,
0.38644102215766907,
0.23577170073986053,
0.26871931552886963,
-0.2633761167526245,
-0.26326805353164673,
-0.39075222611427307,
0.21171921491622925,
-0.8018214106559753,
-0.040790386497974396,
-0.12287890166044235,
-0.2951282858848572,
-0.32974618673324585,
-0.7270169258117676,
-0.7574037909507751,
-0.34883150458335876,
0.04822569712996483,
0.2527545392513275,
-0.5798198580741882,
-0.36808767914772034,
-0.023066744208335876,
0.11020106077194214,
0.22752493619918823,
0.2060965597629547,
-1.096145749092102,
0.02402815967798233,
0.5132006406784058,
0.8892808556556702,
-0.11050663888454437,
-0.4097514748573303,
-0.715566098690033,
0.1819162666797638,
-0.5422798991203308,
0.5072516202926636,
-0.6878030300140381,
-0.4300273060798645,
0.3289009928703308,
0.20623964071273804,
-0.18592265248298645,
-0.6155806183815002,
0.7185713648796082,
-0.7290752530097961,
0.0014972847420722246,
0.09022364765405655,
-0.44010111689567566,
-0.5838170647621155,
0.08697434514760971,
-0.5277131199836731,
0.9381884336471558,
0.24909384548664093,
-0.5542986989021301,
0.1950053870677948,
-0.5885514616966248,
-0.35122713446617126,
0.7515276670455933,
0.23985013365745544,
-0.08174793422222137,
0.24866734445095062,
0.11479971557855606,
0.37511271238327026,
0.050799135118722916,
0.1520819365978241,
-0.18578821420669556,
-0.21010933816432953,
0.3706255555152893,
-0.3658294081687927,
1.0931750535964966,
0.29255756735801697,
-0.27566346526145935,
0.017942922189831734,
-0.3606174886226654,
0.13835924863815308,
-0.07783130556344986,
-0.7153443694114685,
-0.4629971385002136,
-0.05561258643865585,
0.21950548887252808,
0.1781916469335556,
0.22463089227676392,
-0.30994951725006104,
0.032163385301828384,
-0.804576575756073,
0.3623999059200287,
0.6609435677528381,
-0.35848352313041687,
0.4915958344936371,
-0.12405264377593994,
0.7134225964546204,
-0.3244746923446655,
-0.06404885649681091,
0.02190096490085125,
-0.22695006430149078,
-1.0865848064422607,
-0.21303564310073853,
0.13272880017757416,
0.6369190812110901,
-0.7755028605461121,
0.173807293176651,
-0.35729560256004333,
-0.27170562744140625,
-0.5179339647293091,
0.37720179557800293,
0.30203351378440857,
0.2685626149177551,
0.33665379881858826,
-0.23654113709926605,
-0.5714008212089539,
-0.7063806056976318,
-0.41729381680488586,
-0.3536478877067566,
0.09713276475667953,
0.26449504494667053,
0.22262273728847504,
-0.5983878970146179,
0.6383492350578308,
-0.015160181559622288,
-0.22093388438224792,
-0.3610202372074127,
-0.04974151775240898,
0.15591318905353546,
0.3961189389228821,
0.422023206949234,
-0.7948213219642639,
-0.43712297081947327,
0.14349354803562164,
-0.8083602786064148,
-0.22586479783058167,
0.16223843395709991,
-0.2602858245372772,
0.4969783127307892,
0.684113621711731,
-0.5116694569587708,
-0.0037179370410740376,
0.6771675944328308,
0.07779757678508759,
0.1976408064365387,
-0.18915989995002747,
-0.31463730335235596,
-0.825739860534668,
0.2253289371728897,
-0.38739654421806335,
-0.3359523117542267,
-0.8259310722351074,
0.2759605050086975,
0.16966378688812256,
-0.2941878139972687,
-0.7044702172279358,
0.8564703464508057,
-0.6451565623283386,
0.012057003565132618,
-0.22589704394340515,
0.15235495567321777,
-0.7461451292037964,
0.371721476316452,
0.43970680236816406,
0.4687092900276184,
0.7109199166297913,
-0.51145339012146,
0.043711382895708084,
0.5293068289756775,
-0.4494611322879791,
0.19374719262123108,
-0.017913537099957466,
0.07015566527843475,
0.005918821319937706,
-0.2750283479690552,
-0.5091318488121033,
-0.47862374782562256,
0.15610051155090332,
-0.23282159864902496,
0.6080717444419861,
-0.46197202801704407,
-0.10924579203128815,
-0.2753641903400421,
-0.04720475152134895,
0.44461590051651,
0.4885609447956085,
-0.619022011756897,
0.3738016188144684,
0.7442901134490967,
-0.647358238697052,
-0.6996640563011169,
-0.6762421131134033,
0.4548538327217102,
-0.48236924409866333,
-0.3482014536857605,
-0.09979952126741409,
-0.28687408566474915,
-0.06259498745203018,
0.13913236558437347,
-0.050464238971471786,
-0.31498220562934875,
0.5292524099349976,
0.3012829124927521,
0.1384914368391037,
-0.12578538060188293,
0.18502512574195862,
-0.14998038113117218,
-0.11236690729856491,
-0.01627998985350132,
-0.47932350635528564,
0.3501545488834381,
-0.32547155022621155,
0.04921003058552742,
0.2063654661178589,
0.2176365852355957,
0.4496784508228302,
-0.2007320672273636,
0.517250120639801,
0.4212578237056732,
-0.3415440320968628,
-0.31792885065078735,
-0.4024690091609955,
0.27765345573425293,
-0.4771551787853241,
0.6265444755554199,
-0.18278853595256805,
-1.0291531085968018,
0.2354281097650528,
-0.36092206835746765,
0.14138242602348328,
0.39277222752571106,
0.5892690420150757,
0.2967577874660492,
0.6280592679977417,
0.9283732175827026,
-0.28348487615585327,
0.6002580523490906,
-0.14135903120040894,
0.10548926144838333,
-0.4527270197868347,
-0.13015641272068024,
-0.1834000051021576,
0.0017833602614700794,
-0.5018131732940674,
-0.6148117184638977,
0.4164201319217682,
0.37902596592903137,
0.07441452145576477,
0.48696911334991455,
-0.31532999873161316,
0.7985575199127197,
0.5242376923561096,
-0.076130710542202,
0.26018401980400085,
0.1873323917388916,
-0.19831687211990356,
0.03251734748482704,
-0.9400454163551331,
-0.7461215257644653,
0.9757416248321533,
0.2253076285123825,
0.5773064494132996,
0.09238319098949432,
0.706922173500061,
0.10393465310335159,
0.5522802472114563,
-1.0768818855285645,
0.690674364566803,
-0.25328144431114197,
-0.6548821330070496,
-0.7120590806007385,
-0.5236076712608337,
-0.7919236421585083,
0.41765251755714417,
0.025537988170981407,
-0.43406227231025696,
0.13033229112625122,
0.01936274766921997,
-0.08729200065135956,
0.2174833118915558,
-0.4390886723995209,
0.9648918509483337,
-0.847151517868042,
-0.3938017785549164,
-0.35716572403907776,
-0.6978762745857239,
0.29216268658638,
-0.4862123429775238,
0.610256016254425,
-0.24709463119506836,
-0.24023842811584473,
0.6279319524765015,
-0.21255838871002197,
0.9468204975128174,
-0.09995537996292114,
0.04511837661266327,
0.04834943637251854,
0.5430305004119873,
0.28976118564605713,
-0.10214053094387054,
-0.3214797377586365,
0.15817813575267792,
-0.2286389172077179,
-0.3513432741165161,
0.12373284995555878,
0.713144838809967,
-0.626578688621521,
-0.6188833117485046,
-0.41998395323753357,
-1.0446773767471313,
-0.24870562553405762,
0.6252277493476868,
0.2381410151720047,
0.08113179355859756,
-0.4598798155784607,
0.057381097227334976,
0.5115000009536743,
-0.5869726538658142,
0.5518117547035217,
0.7094665169715881,
0.08260396122932434,
-0.19728001952171326,
0.8827173709869385,
0.10993638634681702,
0.3039112687110901,
0.4800032675266266,
0.11865310370922089,
-0.3558214008808136,
-0.6514266133308411,
-0.6038159728050232,
0.2259095460176468,
-0.9764765501022339,
-0.12671300768852234,
-0.8500372171401978,
-0.09437880665063858,
-0.095745749771595,
-0.3263603448867798,
-0.12067922204732895,
-0.44797593355178833,
-0.3489803671836853,
-0.14654946327209473,
0.37746667861938477,
0.8007071614265442,
-0.4508129954338074,
0.19750170409679413,
-0.662321150302887,
-0.10945599526166916,
0.27047988772392273,
0.20643839240074158,
-0.0871259793639183,
-0.787759006023407,
-0.44745638966560364,
0.2068796157836914,
-0.16141054034233093,
-0.4183706045150757,
0.9033954739570618,
0.6340562701225281,
0.7457482218742371,
0.3189689517021179,
0.2037741094827652,
0.651799201965332,
-0.5318092107772827,
0.40382295846939087,
-0.009917945601046085,
-0.8814353346824646,
0.26124829053878784,
-0.4365374445915222,
0.16446875035762787,
0.3012508451938629,
0.7604928612709045,
-0.8595476746559143,
-0.7307323217391968,
-0.3296268880367279,
-1.0999795198440552,
1.0333524942398071,
-0.02473551593720913,
0.43057891726493835,
-0.2842899560928345,
-0.021999599412083626,
0.07096073031425476,
0.15647175908088684,
-1.089518666267395,
0.28832101821899414,
-0.17771705985069275,
-0.00423777662217617,
-0.3105084002017975,
-0.679409384727478,
-0.13947060704231262,
-0.03535483032464981,
0.6996279358863831,
-0.14722402393817902,
-0.05149872228503227,
-0.12959234416484833,
-0.8273981809616089,
-0.3548240065574646,
0.3448989689350128,
0.44673794507980347,
0.5124279260635376,
-0.2240348905324936,
0.3966672122478485,
0.37057697772979736,
-0.1062505766749382,
0.00697660818696022,
-0.025915687903761864,
-0.18009549379348755,
0.03127804398536682,
0.5340015292167664,
0.7129437923431396,
0.6658156514167786,
-0.9447664618492126,
0.46455028653144836,
0.2248528003692627,
-0.194980651140213,
-0.47324681282043457,
-0.15100927650928497,
0.4604695737361908,
0.13355150818824768,
0.12231148034334183,
-0.09631547331809998,
-0.058394502848386765,
-0.5079123973846436,
0.04147305339574814,
0.3482477068901062,
-0.31423506140708923,
-0.10403851419687271,
0.7647771835327148,
0.31370872259140015,
-0.12566761672496796,
0.7415459156036377,
-0.28929364681243896,
-0.823112428188324,
0.2946467697620392,
0.6476751565933228,
0.8000583052635193,
-0.29528629779815674,
0.28889697790145874,
0.17982439696788788,
0.44287946820259094,
-0.28224626183509827,
-0.014241456054151058,
0.10916011035442352,
-0.7013047933578491,
-0.29694026708602905,
-0.8677190542221069,
-0.46770262718200684,
0.1819574236869812,
-0.4128480553627014,
0.14246955513954163,
-0.08111688494682312,
0.2340044528245926,
-0.22667792439460754,
-0.30808064341545105,
-0.5734606385231018,
-0.2665279805660248,
0.10188576579093933,
0.8550141453742981,
-0.8927059769630432,
0.6372358202934265,
0.5696794986724854,
-0.25442588329315186,
-0.6059197187423706,
-0.14704659581184387,
0.050569549202919006,
-1.0258705615997314,
0.8810819983482361,
0.11882791668176651,
0.00549670122563839,
0.2613256573677063,
-0.3101125657558441,
-0.883878767490387,
0.5022794008255005,
0.7650777697563171,
-0.3787045478820801,
0.1698588728904724,
0.06265538185834885,
0.5227867960929871,
-0.18616324663162231,
0.1794322282075882,
0.3945716917514801,
0.28954365849494934,
0.04389461502432823,
-0.8800702691078186,
-0.1453891396522522,
-0.19508416950702667,
0.02675624005496502,
0.1214517280459404,
-0.422517329454422,
0.6531626582145691,
-0.24944807589054108,
-0.4837939143180847,
0.4514153003692627,
0.16734734177589417,
-0.2184586524963379,
-0.21162588894367218,
0.49845942854881287,
0.263445109128952,
0.8650104999542236,
0.20025520026683807,
1.0063960552215576,
-0.3627780079841614,
0.15980345010757446,
0.9292442798614502,
-0.2255224585533142,
0.9662644863128662,
0.3256676495075226,
0.25725841522216797,
0.16059204936027527,
0.7787468433380127,
0.2971707582473755,
0.49426406621932983,
0.27055662870407104,
-0.5394515991210938,
-0.5884628891944885,
-0.3801344037055969,
-0.13964146375656128,
0.3708423674106598,
0.5698121786117554,
-0.17557035386562347,
-0.3509771227836609,
0.12733297049999237,
-0.08959095180034637,
0.14551280438899994,
-0.5212469696998596,
0.601212203502655,
0.2505871057510376,
-0.4258321225643158,
1.2025483846664429,
-0.13355907797813416,
0.5923389196395874,
-0.4494367837905884,
0.10777460038661957,
-0.47219985723495483,
0.3223760426044464,
-0.3317582905292511,
-0.5845240354537964,
0.24905267357826233,
0.12259968370199203,
-0.02415079064667225,
-0.5903863906860352,
0.6642310619354248,
-0.8592064380645752,
-0.5283308029174805,
0.5819133520126343,
0.5818558931350708,
0.8463691473007202,
0.09153144061565399,
-0.3791714310646057,
-0.1430111974477768,
0.0798964872956276,
-0.07829907536506653,
0.3044016659259796,
0.7433680891990662,
-0.4237869083881378,
1.0237634181976318,
0.408422589302063,
0.43932655453681946,
0.4167165160179138,
-0.1258777379989624,
0.8652298450469971,
-0.3272482454776764,
-0.38214248418807983,
-0.5904256701469421,
0.2153090089559555,
0.09469759464263916,
-0.1233995109796524,
0.7861188650131226,
0.6790755391120911,
1.1817361116409302,
-0.4710034132003784,
0.6966312527656555,
0.006745478603988886,
0.6972169876098633,
-0.38605865836143494,
0.8300853967666626,
-0.5556308627128601,
0.12154536694288254,
-0.2797394096851349,
-0.7136808633804321,
-0.4728167951107025,
0.7507691979408264,
-0.3730049133300781,
-0.3614482283592224,
0.5309067964553833,
0.9930253028869629,
-0.1730032116174698,
-0.35381895303726196,
0.6506381630897522,
0.4372981786727905,
-0.10347792506217957,
0.579800546169281,
1.211416244506836,
0.1134449914097786,
0.8868116736412048,
-0.026154087856411934,
-0.3058232367038727,
-0.3209463357925415,
-0.9128908514976501,
-0.8822782039642334,
-0.3122265338897705,
-0.05672618746757507,
0.19017435610294342,
0.09193973243236542,
0.7168855667114258,
0.747718334197998,
-0.7429593801498413,
-0.7890163660049438,
-0.0008213528781197965,
0.07286949455738068,
-0.02233068458735943,
-0.1325492411851883,
0.10334153473377228,
-0.5743290185928345,
-0.7968490123748779,
0.8442777991294861,
0.2815558910369873,
0.026183491572737694,
0.17453277111053467,
-0.3610890209674835,
-0.21481585502624512,
-0.3432355225086212,
0.6705639362335205,
0.45202261209487915,
-0.7570685744285583,
-0.21938134729862213,
-0.08715037256479263,
0.015621337108314037,
-0.3171781897544861,
0.5853500962257385,
-0.502342700958252,
0.6193874478340149,
0.1288904994726181,
0.9204245209693909,
0.5928348302841187,
-0.32508671283721924,
0.6396392583847046,
-0.6523609161376953,
0.6109024286270142,
0.5070754885673523,
0.2941383123397827,
0.3860474228858948,
-0.26158392429351807,
0.7059112787246704,
0.22593122720718384,
-0.5722697973251343,
-0.9359021782875061,
0.21245068311691284,
-0.6831316351890564,
-0.2345084398984909,
1.1969085931777954,
-0.28769010305404663,
-0.08290819078683853,
-0.23406019806861877,
-0.10196033865213394,
0.16690272092819214,
-0.1557416468858719,
0.565602719783783,
0.5798845887184143,
0.24251890182495117,
-0.29361066222190857,
-0.7951126098632812,
0.6396897435188293,
0.5834974050521851,
-0.5258310437202454,
0.43085408210754395,
0.5736282467842102,
0.37806180119514465,
-0.07133413851261139,
0.6439530253410339,
-0.09601514041423798,
0.17763401567935944,
-0.16268156468868256,
0.17567721009254456,
0.025689059868454933,
-0.16553175449371338,
-0.6035893559455872,
-0.1601666510105133,
0.6473211050033569,
-0.008473432622849941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00829v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00829v1
|
TroubleLLM: Align to Red Team Expert
| 2024-02-28T03:40:46 | 2024-02-28T03:40:46 |
Zhuoer Xu, Jianping Zhang, Shiwen Cui, Changhua Meng, Weiqiang Wang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) become the start-of-the-art solutions for a
variety of natural language tasks and are integrated into real-world
applications. However, LLMs can be potentially harmful in manifesting
undesirable safety issues like social biases and toxic content. It is
imperative to assess its safety issues before deployment. However, the quality
and diversity of test prompts generated by existing methods are still far from
satisfactory. Not only are these methods labor-intensive and require large
budget costs, but the controllability of test prompt generation is lacking for
the specific testing domain of LLM applications. With the idea of LLM for LLM
testing, we propose the first LLM, called TroubleLLM, to generate controllable
test prompts on LLM safety issues. Extensive experiments and human evaluation
illustrate the superiority of TroubleLLM on generation quality and generation
controllability.
|
[
-0.2354109138250351,
-0.834354817867279,
0.3122767508029938,
0.5553160309791565,
-0.04746301844716072,
0.1751987636089325,
-0.11628570407629013,
-0.3721473515033722,
-0.13996590673923492,
0.4813772439956665,
-0.7189281582832336,
-0.42275458574295044,
-0.4993186891078949,
0.31609663367271423,
-0.37612804770469666,
0.8408325910568237,
-0.2944466471672058,
-0.29108190536499023,
-0.06753817200660706,
0.034613028168678284,
-0.7549523711204529,
-0.4685691297054291,
-0.8560688495635986,
-0.11937598884105682,
0.5396794080734253,
0.6636527180671692,
0.7734482884407043,
0.43600258231163025,
0.6858178973197937,
0.31179171800613403,
-0.11686450242996216,
0.321947306394577,
-0.4825146198272705,
0.3754713833332062,
-0.07708919793367386,
-0.3666771650314331,
-0.3627570569515228,
-0.04559672623872757,
0.39822155237197876,
0.46534597873687744,
-0.2528051733970642,
-0.08725737780332565,
0.039007075130939484,
0.43725866079330444,
-0.35503536462783813,
0.020209571346640587,
-0.68910151720047,
0.0006861030706204474,
0.05535006895661354,
-0.22341229021549225,
-0.592782199382782,
-0.7476878762245178,
-0.18785376846790314,
-0.4320686459541321,
-0.08334580808877945,
0.6255474090576172,
0.8687596321105957,
0.594861626625061,
-0.3038596212863922,
-0.23153544962406158,
-0.581795334815979,
1.0928370952606201,
-0.6992818117141724,
0.14532384276390076,
0.18238726258277893,
0.5198143124580383,
-0.5548921823501587,
-0.1890813559293747,
-0.6903846263885498,
-0.25511330366134644,
0.0027701305225491524,
-0.03703375905752182,
-0.35821065306663513,
-0.05949924886226654,
0.1088264212012291,
-0.08914148807525635,
-0.8516156077384949,
0.518621563911438,
-0.08179190754890442,
-0.3081851899623871,
0.9588032960891724,
0.6261062026023865,
0.5899773240089417,
-0.008288073353469372,
-0.6376840472221375,
-0.003220881335437298,
-0.892102837562561,
-0.4344216585159302,
0.23896998167037964,
0.4403103291988373,
-0.22113758325576782,
0.6483701467514038,
0.017791103571653366,
0.8227450847625732,
-0.1525878757238388,
-0.22648245096206665,
-0.0870976522564888,
-0.36897143721580505,
-0.37514039874076843,
0.14470945298671722,
0.8219457268714905,
0.615917980670929,
0.5145466327667236,
-0.032177843153476715,
-0.2186182737350464,
0.002016953658312559,
0.3353957235813141,
-0.5934418439865112,
-0.17232495546340942,
0.38379451632499695,
-0.019423378631472588,
-0.45600125193595886,
-0.19786842167377472,
-0.8092248439788818,
-0.5712164044380188,
-0.1724809855222702,
0.3042362928390503,
-0.4792942702770233,
-0.43032020330429077,
0.047233860939741135,
0.31595665216445923,
0.2798357903957367,
0.21501252055168152,
-0.612437903881073,
-0.07501797378063202,
0.5396860837936401,
0.47358086705207825,
-0.7273073196411133,
-0.30536696314811707,
-0.4494152367115021,
0.11261808127164841,
-0.38350242376327515,
0.5787748098373413,
0.03114333748817444,
-0.501606822013855,
0.1285206824541092,
-0.028537288308143616,
-0.1056530624628067,
-0.6615411043167114,
0.28978288173675537,
-0.6430159211158752,
0.2990739047527313,
0.034359466284513474,
-0.5002068281173706,
0.19157779216766357,
0.5590282678604126,
-0.28541648387908936,
0.8962492942810059,
0.03157250955700874,
-0.7486673593521118,
0.20133860409259796,
-0.5677000284194946,
-0.30706846714019775,
0.2942604720592499,
-0.22404713928699493,
-0.4377070665359497,
-0.3515884578227997,
-0.2928674519062042,
0.41215407848358154,
-0.2730451226234436,
0.4608016312122345,
0.08495859801769257,
-0.16266149282455444,
0.43124330043792725,
-0.2851351797580719,
0.8164160847663879,
0.3545895516872406,
-0.4366869628429413,
0.37583667039871216,
-0.4128217399120331,
0.25532466173171997,
0.2959229648113251,
-0.5554210543632507,
-0.29573333263397217,
-0.17871317267417908,
-0.07929883897304535,
0.17643094062805176,
0.19255144894123077,
-0.3301348388195038,
-0.14284713566303253,
-0.24702201783657074,
0.04186234623193741,
0.8633893728256226,
0.00798961240798235,
0.1615094393491745,
-0.5674726963043213,
0.854171097278595,
-0.04240419343113899,
0.2685292959213257,
0.04316967725753784,
-0.42625439167022705,
-0.8498244881629944,
-0.11643363535404205,
0.18644855916500092,
0.845085620880127,
-0.4119821786880493,
0.6148411631584167,
0.08910305052995682,
-0.45213624835014343,
-0.14254112541675568,
0.2815913259983063,
0.6405982375144958,
0.35714539885520935,
0.2414524406194687,
0.4174354374408722,
-0.47197970747947693,
-0.9347895979881287,
-0.08455505222082138,
-0.3559551537036896,
0.09277347475290298,
0.2554371654987335,
0.17013265192508698,
-0.5440365076065063,
1.0671329498291016,
-0.5890640020370483,
-0.004316605627536774,
-0.47397321462631226,
0.10597012937068939,
-0.04181508347392082,
0.4819420576095581,
0.32334643602371216,
-0.6679832935333252,
-0.4688917398452759,
-0.2593839466571808,
-0.5494988560676575,
-0.5352128148078918,
0.022879399359226227,
-0.24849571287631989,
0.6226568222045898,
0.6196390986442566,
-0.6403865814208984,
-0.20188023149967194,
0.8041605353355408,
-0.5359659194946289,
0.7318078875541687,
-0.1431828886270523,
-0.043260302394628525,
-1.1979695558547974,
-0.029863497242331505,
0.028827857226133347,
-0.2395448237657547,
-0.4540615379810333,
0.11820772290229797,
0.14240337908267975,
-0.2978900969028473,
-0.8052518963813782,
0.6626259088516235,
-0.3503272831439972,
0.4329352378845215,
-0.22872833907604218,
0.22194482386112213,
-0.05122973769903183,
0.10881894826889038,
-0.3356129229068756,
1.0575885772705078,
0.2478686422109604,
-0.9018020033836365,
0.23352967202663422,
0.2518004775047302,
-0.09690993279218674,
0.5146679878234863,
-0.6040824055671692,
-0.027972472831606865,
-0.10750826448202133,
-0.34535151720046997,
-1.0672874450683594,
-0.4416513442993164,
0.11709871888160706,
-0.13063634932041168,
0.5198311805725098,
0.46345701813697815,
-0.5702453851699829,
-0.41958287358283997,
-0.010822415351867676,
0.32237985730171204,
0.907410740852356,
-0.4274141788482666,
0.13164855539798737,
0.5580660104751587,
-0.4615856111049652,
-0.39490967988967896,
-0.5453599095344543,
0.048687975853681564,
-0.601901113986969,
-0.7320809364318848,
0.02967357449233532,
-0.43816909193992615,
-0.5618466138839722,
-0.4271044433116913,
0.07024276256561279,
-0.1602490395307541,
0.3911968171596527,
0.42213574051856995,
0.3505019247531891,
-0.030413243919610977,
0.31514355540275574,
-0.04554532840847969,
-0.281647652387619,
0.2101515531539917,
0.3243222236633301,
0.40794461965560913,
0.008371591567993164,
-0.2553999423980713,
-0.34082499146461487,
0.5155286192893982,
0.496921181678772,
-0.1487123817205429,
0.39142531156539917,
0.07035528868436813,
-0.28760647773742676,
-0.5713214874267578,
-0.5950095057487488,
-0.10143009573221207,
-0.520002007484436,
0.32079723477363586,
0.18985970318317413,
-0.9535987973213196,
0.11379260569810867,
-0.26844802498817444,
0.14552634954452515,
0.20410366356372833,
0.5178645849227905,
-0.2762250602245331,
0.9643256068229675,
0.7309368252754211,
0.007784651126712561,
0.08123626559972763,
0.2578801214694977,
0.20313626527786255,
-0.16920599341392517,
-0.2950111925601959,
-0.6589294672012329,
-0.11619265377521515,
-0.2816780209541321,
-0.29528579115867615,
0.3631838262081146,
0.15340062975883484,
-0.6514747738838196,
0.20590150356292725,
-0.4749578535556793,
0.5766372084617615,
0.23503388464450836,
-0.1883334070444107,
0.39457404613494873,
-0.12013614922761917,
-0.25552329421043396,
-0.3011931777000427,
-0.7411454916000366,
-0.8014439940452576,
0.510615885257721,
0.48546111583709717,
1.124861717224121,
0.3182205557823181,
0.7046496272087097,
0.18157479166984558,
0.5316486358642578,
-0.6531111598014832,
0.7802466750144958,
0.0771905928850174,
-0.5425944924354553,
-0.3408525884151459,
-0.30606186389923096,
-1.01991605758667,
-0.2289697527885437,
-0.10269350558519363,
-0.41250157356262207,
-0.43610551953315735,
0.2808665633201599,
-0.5524453520774841,
0.025126444175839424,
-0.8378992676734924,
0.8250366449356079,
-0.45568493008613586,
-0.11787983030080795,
0.29154035449028015,
-0.5138643383979797,
0.7561488747596741,
-0.42061835527420044,
0.3003154695034027,
-0.20821429789066315,
-0.05326180160045624,
0.7367709279060364,
-0.4403238892555237,
0.9803471565246582,
-0.02412480115890503,
-0.554497480392456,
0.33175674080848694,
0.49348101019859314,
0.6593868136405945,
-0.05211912840604782,
-0.09500842541456223,
-0.06541759520769119,
-0.4703804850578308,
-0.037004612386226654,
-0.23950748145580292,
0.8411973714828491,
-0.5086877346038818,
-0.866206705570221,
-0.3158280551433563,
-0.7438633441925049,
-0.29374247789382935,
0.3302795886993408,
0.09671014547348022,
-0.023402076214551926,
0.02721887268126011,
-0.280804306268692,
0.9388852715492249,
-0.6037508249282837,
0.6169911623001099,
0.6914690136909485,
-0.3336734473705292,
-0.07915086299180984,
0.8154634237289429,
-0.3819875121116638,
0.52762770652771,
0.022574903443455696,
0.1746487319469452,
-0.33487704396247864,
-0.7677053809165955,
-0.28789952397346497,
0.29065969586372375,
-0.40141457319259644,
-0.5874977707862854,
-0.5835866928100586,
-0.24459020793437958,
0.017111733555793762,
-0.26689890027046204,
-0.3918541669845581,
-0.05275215953588486,
-0.4700709879398346,
-0.2079622894525528,
0.5549585223197937,
0.5513198971748352,
0.12820211052894592,
0.3979722261428833,
-0.9540397524833679,
0.17483188211917877,
0.3995620608329773,
0.1375630795955658,
-0.46708184480667114,
-0.24434509873390198,
0.05590207874774933,
-0.1909448653459549,
-0.3863619863986969,
-0.8033494353294373,
0.3676236867904663,
-0.17005403339862823,
0.5086069107055664,
0.22410880029201508,
0.4919942617416382,
0.26463401317596436,
-0.42878755927085876,
0.9140334725379944,
0.4198627769947052,
-0.7156808376312256,
0.6801686882972717,
-0.4135105013847351,
0.033478450030088425,
0.5477523803710938,
0.4726436734199524,
-0.34394100308418274,
-0.7006388902664185,
-0.3732994794845581,
-0.7183600068092346,
0.5044683814048767,
0.14833027124404907,
0.22371108829975128,
-0.3048372268676758,
0.07719825208187103,
0.183408722281456,
0.010469827800989151,
-0.5365474224090576,
-0.3740583658218384,
0.13744905591011047,
-0.38526976108551025,
0.006829041987657547,
-0.49615564942359924,
-0.43728306889533997,
0.2654551565647125,
0.469182550907135,
-0.06181500479578972,
0.17453007400035858,
0.06459520012140274,
-0.014433438889682293,
-0.4910546541213989,
0.5903745889663696,
0.9021213054656982,
0.584019660949707,
-0.09679234027862549,
0.3407491445541382,
0.2243068963289261,
-0.16310253739356995,
0.477655827999115,
-0.051816415041685104,
-0.2186281830072403,
-0.04109229892492294,
0.182612806558609,
0.5119479298591614,
0.18103884160518646,
-0.9541082382202148,
0.43198162317276,
-0.03234061971306801,
-0.31563088297843933,
-0.29046234488487244,
0.6247854232788086,
0.221695214509964,
0.21356983482837677,
0.2242293357849121,
-0.2782120108604431,
-0.49921783804893494,
-0.19889535009860992,
0.3382200002670288,
0.533050000667572,
-0.34135839343070984,
0.07286766916513443,
0.8579133749008179,
0.5335189700126648,
-0.6692744493484497,
0.4510994851589203,
-0.44522130489349365,
-0.5328977704048157,
0.8030489683151245,
0.8299907445907593,
0.684380829334259,
-0.4783470034599304,
0.29443639516830444,
0.3050781488418579,
0.48932164907455444,
-0.047887858003377914,
0.615606963634491,
0.6819101572036743,
-0.7912113070487976,
-0.49699515104293823,
-0.570402979850769,
-0.5490816831588745,
0.22308102250099182,
-0.27167809009552,
0.2615664005279541,
-0.36605024337768555,
-0.08263633400201797,
-0.5092124938964844,
-0.2579115033149719,
-0.33750271797180176,
0.3007444441318512,
0.029504604637622833,
1.1603351831436157,
-0.681908130645752,
0.5524195432662964,
0.6156545281410217,
-0.007437005639076233,
-1.17282235622406,
-0.05915806069970131,
-0.019028808921575546,
-0.7450628876686096,
0.9266706705093384,
0.2169501781463623,
0.1770334094762802,
0.2207850068807602,
-0.48236167430877686,
-0.5478167533874512,
1.199724555015564,
0.5250584483146667,
-0.9142269492149353,
0.08820711821317673,
0.2829190790653229,
0.20352739095687866,
-0.24249817430973053,
-0.08722338825464249,
0.4552215039730072,
0.8922805786132812,
-0.06273674964904785,
-0.9466193914413452,
0.46118655800819397,
0.02201301045715809,
-0.0550851970911026,
0.4033583104610443,
-0.6386474370956421,
0.7799480557441711,
-0.6004166603088379,
-0.501706600189209,
-0.030739229172468185,
0.276151180267334,
0.8447805047035217,
0.18463779985904694,
0.5466716289520264,
0.34113162755966187,
0.8124276995658875,
-0.18416927754878998,
1.1431196928024292,
-0.17250025272369385,
0.16829152405261993,
1.0447016954421997,
-0.4516031742095947,
0.4700418710708618,
0.6248183846473694,
-0.3061731159687042,
0.14041456580162048,
0.6277358531951904,
0.14393511414527893,
0.3642972707748413,
0.5822784304618835,
-0.27264147996902466,
-0.4042552709579468,
-0.21608085930347443,
-0.4361996352672577,
0.17117156088352203,
0.12696093320846558,
-0.2801770567893982,
-0.378976970911026,
-0.18972328305244446,
0.16893041133880615,
0.1361992359161377,
-0.154160737991333,
0.6344690322875977,
0.1333349198102951,
-0.6041139960289001,
0.7711412310600281,
-0.09161841124296188,
0.9114952683448792,
-0.646293580532074,
0.0954766795039177,
-0.4538175165653229,
0.013921903446316719,
-0.09474661201238632,
-0.7525379657745361,
0.531071662902832,
0.06069520115852356,
-0.051684677600860596,
-0.23307079076766968,
0.6720225811004639,
-0.5248823761940002,
-0.32141709327697754,
0.34661468863487244,
0.5947868227958679,
0.12739042937755585,
0.05648180842399597,
-0.6096792817115784,
0.1244899183511734,
-0.035132162272930145,
-0.11760459840297699,
0.2508145868778229,
0.19502633810043335,
-0.12858682870864868,
0.8129176497459412,
0.3267727792263031,
0.055210500955581665,
0.3344237804412842,
-0.16072586178779602,
0.641658365726471,
-0.794736385345459,
-0.30247512459754944,
-0.9056829810142517,
0.7060542702674866,
0.15639592707157135,
-0.2379472404718399,
0.7765945792198181,
0.19823379814624786,
0.44764402508735657,
-0.17210088670253754,
0.8329366445541382,
0.17779994010925293,
0.398514986038208,
-0.6323015689849854,
1.0153199434280396,
-0.5113920569419861,
0.26652708649635315,
-0.16388241946697235,
-0.7443704605102539,
-0.5833621621131897,
0.23946794867515564,
0.1911712884902954,
-0.062425147742033005,
0.8710339069366455,
1.1159498691558838,
0.1990722119808197,
-0.07210113853216171,
0.3852572441101074,
0.1975589394569397,
0.44181862473487854,
0.7425297498703003,
1.08698308467865,
-0.15339086949825287,
0.7073565721511841,
0.029077766463160515,
-0.2756832540035248,
-0.29563724994659424,
-1.2768675088882446,
-0.8776580691337585,
-0.040297601372003555,
-0.6282718181610107,
-0.331419438123703,
-0.03710741922259331,
0.8524814248085022,
0.4499644339084625,
-0.8172025680541992,
-0.009894297458231449,
-0.4243934154510498,
0.3864133656024933,
0.18909808993339539,
-0.2994086742401123,
0.0938074067234993,
-0.46714314818382263,
-0.680753231048584,
0.5646621584892273,
0.0976555123925209,
0.583182156085968,
-0.3889363408088684,
-0.49305495619773865,
0.06190715730190277,
-0.0711015909910202,
0.37556639313697815,
0.28465691208839417,
-0.519659161567688,
-0.3851359188556671,
0.03149992972612381,
-0.46450525522232056,
-0.19536471366882324,
0.6216309666633606,
-0.18404075503349304,
0.07375393062829971,
0.33570051193237305,
0.8447583913803101,
-0.3908010721206665,
0.04676606506109238,
0.8099668025970459,
-0.7874236702919006,
-0.07757450640201569,
0.23737962543964386,
0.23044729232788086,
0.30333927273750305,
-0.5222487449645996,
0.4469103217124939,
-0.14264148473739624,
-0.7569936513900757,
-1.0142111778259277,
0.3418503701686859,
-1.0409294366836548,
-0.10227519273757935,
1.6245441436767578,
-0.1892726719379425,
-0.026370804756879807,
-0.3589072823524475,
-0.33593010902404785,
0.2692726254463196,
-0.26199042797088623,
0.7894338369369507,
0.5011309385299683,
-0.19669441878795624,
-0.11273510009050369,
-0.36780646443367004,
0.5743438005447388,
0.6868780255317688,
-1.2803152799606323,
0.24335186183452606,
0.43025726079940796,
0.4054861068725586,
0.20063666999340057,
0.4717627465724945,
-0.0489501915872097,
0.11120001971721649,
-0.45461806654930115,
0.20660878717899323,
-0.4443909525871277,
-0.34853658080101013,
-0.36236289143562317,
0.2071719467639923,
0.38828563690185547,
-0.1594814658164978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18023v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18023v2
|
Do Large Language Models Mirror Cognitive Language Processing?
| 2024-02-28T03:38:20 | 2024-05-28T05:51:15 |
Yuqi Ren, Renren Jin, Tongxuan Zhang, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable abilities in text
comprehension and logical reasoning, indicating that the text representations
learned by LLMs can facilitate their language processing capabilities. In
cognitive science, brain cognitive processing signals are typically utilized to
study human language processing. Therefore, it is natural to ask how well the
text embeddings from LLMs align with the brain cognitive processing signals,
and how training strategies affect the LLM-brain alignment? In this paper, we
employ Representational Similarity Analysis (RSA) to measure the alignment
between 23 mainstream LLMs and fMRI signals of the brain to evaluate how
effectively LLMs simulate cognitive language processing. We empirically
investigate the impact of various factors (e.g., pre-training data size, model
scaling, alignment training, and prompts) on such LLM-brain alignment.
Experimental results indicate that pre-training data size and model scaling are
positively correlated with LLM-brain similarity, and alignment training can
significantly improve LLM-brain similarity. Explicit prompts contribute to the
consistency of LLMs with brain cognitive language processing, while nonsensical
noisy prompts may attenuate such alignment. Additionally, the performance of a
wide range of LLM evaluations (e.g., MMLU, Chatbot Arena) is highly correlated
with the LLM-brain similarity.
|
[
-0.24412240087985992,
-0.7481625080108643,
0.9232709407806396,
0.16367094218730927,
-0.24360522627830505,
-0.07096882164478302,
-0.7188674807548523,
-0.41492778062820435,
0.2483673095703125,
0.4272964298725128,
-0.6357915997505188,
-0.3948739469051361,
-0.6340104341506958,
0.11212654411792755,
-0.1920727789402008,
0.49183493852615356,
0.10276846587657928,
0.5829708576202393,
-0.5728799104690552,
-0.11591070890426636,
-0.6527179479598999,
-0.6069809794425964,
-0.6225079298019409,
-0.537863552570343,
0.45544034242630005,
-0.1353345662355423,
0.7956417202949524,
0.6731192469596863,
0.4712557792663574,
0.32754555344581604,
0.08128999918699265,
-0.045195408165454865,
-0.3327930271625519,
0.20456475019454956,
-0.23623311519622803,
-0.6733407974243164,
-0.4362403452396393,
-0.000006269229288591305,
0.8527083396911621,
0.7497565746307373,
-0.16213245689868927,
0.09382911771535873,
0.291410893201828,
0.5183327198028564,
-0.38190922141075134,
0.17821185290813446,
-0.8408730030059814,
-0.2279336303472519,
-0.11840417236089706,
-0.19266192615032196,
-0.4842665195465088,
-0.2860032618045807,
0.02393067255616188,
-0.4574887454509735,
-0.13014185428619385,
0.2168523073196411,
0.7767997980117798,
0.30301201343536377,
-0.3069808781147003,
-0.26445627212524414,
-0.34863540530204773,
0.9015317559242249,
-0.822268009185791,
0.5831778645515442,
0.23932413756847382,
0.06538104265928268,
-0.3167443573474884,
-0.1897367537021637,
-0.8881765604019165,
-0.13280576467514038,
-0.169123113155365,
-0.09094157069921494,
0.05571127310395241,
0.023764384910464287,
0.4677349328994751,
-0.0615234300494194,
-0.7866323590278625,
0.3761376738548279,
-0.10013952106237411,
-0.19168812036514282,
0.4751327633857727,
0.3964429199695587,
0.4562753140926361,
0.014473671093583107,
-0.16675980389118195,
-0.5934574007987976,
-0.6116840839385986,
-0.05226846784353256,
0.29961079359054565,
0.2842232584953308,
-0.08841683715581894,
0.63315349817276,
0.1813407838344574,
0.9209522604942322,
0.021206052973866463,
-0.2551417350769043,
0.37452176213264465,
-0.10424460470676422,
-0.3128899335861206,
0.10622241348028183,
1.0454107522964478,
0.4225325584411621,
0.6243680119514465,
-0.15658004581928253,
-0.2381114959716797,
0.2904396057128906,
0.34851983189582825,
-0.5327200293540955,
0.060630299150943756,
0.046867381781339645,
-0.5093860030174255,
-0.03116154670715332,
-0.10473671555519104,
-0.2943221628665924,
-0.487060010433197,
-0.7409260272979736,
0.4040398597717285,
-0.6139459609985352,
-0.16344034671783447,
0.19117645919322968,
0.12454989552497864,
0.6172842979431152,
0.2064339518547058,
-1.0816688537597656,
0.32054945826530457,
1.010279655456543,
0.5808647274971008,
-0.3317281901836395,
-0.31621167063713074,
-0.12267407029867172,
0.10443731397390366,
-0.3006131649017334,
0.7452206611633301,
-0.7919660210609436,
0.10826170444488525,
0.0946420431137085,
-0.029109330847859383,
-0.342373788356781,
-0.5109320282936096,
0.3006221652030945,
-0.9217720031738281,
0.06388187408447266,
-0.4522527754306793,
-0.5236756205558777,
-0.13560190796852112,
0.3546948730945587,
-0.6888871192932129,
0.6493682265281677,
-0.37238937616348267,
-0.7071732878684998,
0.255128413438797,
-0.09562481194734573,
-0.38224196434020996,
-0.28406766057014465,
-0.6896748542785645,
-0.3260236382484436,
0.043033018708229065,
0.3415261507034302,
0.6664398908615112,
-0.4181080162525177,
0.15318216383457184,
-0.49647462368011475,
-0.4348958134651184,
0.7445195913314819,
-0.4020509123802185,
0.7387308478355408,
-0.11954648047685623,
-0.1637226790189743,
0.09421145915985107,
-0.32614362239837646,
0.2182905524969101,
0.059897810220718384,
0.024160902947187424,
-0.49655166268348694,
0.05104533210396767,
-0.09758413583040237,
0.3172960579395294,
0.4290879964828491,
-0.4526078701019287,
0.2903059124946594,
-0.4016914367675781,
0.49653738737106323,
0.5221944451332092,
-0.1432899832725525,
0.4687390625476837,
-0.31287941336631775,
0.32669731974601746,
0.0009385355515405536,
-0.1794355809688568,
-0.17941629886627197,
-0.3925480246543884,
-0.368738055229187,
-0.36487725377082825,
0.25888845324516296,
0.41118597984313965,
-0.24590492248535156,
0.43103745579719543,
-0.7467219233512878,
-0.3022366166114807,
-0.5448315143585205,
0.07540833950042725,
0.31959548592567444,
0.21429945528507233,
0.204228013753891,
-0.2839403748512268,
-0.6267995238304138,
-1.0352368354797363,
-0.33577457070350647,
0.042056530714035034,
-0.13037359714508057,
-0.06387492269277573,
0.20310179889202118,
-0.13091790676116943,
0.7528938055038452,
-0.3331764042377472,
-0.37550482153892517,
0.10200248658657074,
-0.0022169481962919235,
0.2427521049976349,
0.2714082896709442,
0.40652701258659363,
-0.34476399421691895,
-0.2795336842536926,
-0.0662335455417633,
-0.9104227423667908,
-0.054399773478507996,
-0.14414969086647034,
0.07078386843204498,
0.3301735520362854,
0.7375621199607849,
-0.7597669363021851,
0.0673385038971901,
0.7117252349853516,
-0.09065978229045868,
0.06856530904769897,
-0.21343281865119934,
0.3251881003379822,
-0.9752050638198853,
-0.047319818288087845,
-0.11959317326545715,
-0.11604355275630951,
-0.19940997660160065,
-0.12944406270980835,
0.2580764591693878,
0.07058250904083252,
0.08931004256010056,
0.27563244104385376,
-0.720142662525177,
-0.4202169179916382,
-0.40464407205581665,
0.5933247208595276,
-0.2072487771511078,
0.4678236246109009,
0.352033406496048,
0.8209977149963379,
0.548965573310852,
-0.30108654499053955,
-0.11742960661649704,
0.05710218846797943,
-0.40824854373931885,
0.5390986204147339,
-0.5685675740242004,
0.3052213191986084,
-0.12862417101860046,
0.2717683017253876,
-1.3292542695999146,
0.16213011741638184,
-0.07976415008306503,
-0.47482991218566895,
0.3915109634399414,
0.3397122025489807,
-0.5869239568710327,
0.006743405479937792,
-0.2254621386528015,
0.4410129487514496,
0.6404735445976257,
-0.2806859016418457,
0.8240545392036438,
0.3382154107093811,
0.049861643463373184,
-0.728841245174408,
-0.8033462166786194,
-0.03131406754255295,
-0.05944246053695679,
-0.5454200506210327,
0.3879709243774414,
0.16856084764003754,
-0.09389226883649826,
-0.06796041131019592,
0.08634801208972931,
0.3236827850341797,
-0.12423497438430786,
0.5862910747528076,
0.35800936818122864,
-0.37041983008384705,
0.021498098969459534,
-0.17477014660835266,
0.08634734153747559,
0.41720151901245117,
-0.09443555772304535,
0.8668237924575806,
-0.024148063734173775,
-0.43301039934158325,
-0.5250623226165771,
-0.1211680993437767,
0.5933698415756226,
-0.2461426556110382,
1.0706168413162231,
0.3630843460559845,
-0.44022050499916077,
0.04332094267010689,
-0.6713051199913025,
-0.41966769099235535,
-0.4308229684829712,
0.4680159091949463,
-0.40754371881484985,
-0.9077336192131042,
0.430039644241333,
0.1394856572151184,
-0.05042452737689018,
0.19859416782855988,
0.8054923415184021,
-0.3799361288547516,
1.0727148056030273,
0.35505351424217224,
-0.2783394753932953,
0.49889230728149414,
0.15441791713237762,
0.1747109442949295,
-1.1371405124664307,
-0.21982164680957794,
-0.39503079652786255,
-0.4847034811973572,
-0.2811751365661621,
-0.4821355640888214,
-0.0576215423643589,
0.03260596841573715,
-0.3664582669734955,
0.4368702173233032,
-0.3322716951370239,
0.5228486657142639,
0.052810586988925934,
0.07956380397081375,
0.29261332750320435,
0.2126552313566208,
-0.274413138628006,
-0.31860607862472534,
-0.4654262661933899,
-0.7299039363861084,
1.1166539192199707,
0.36105582118034363,
0.8105132579803467,
-0.1671038717031479,
0.3895004093647003,
-0.03295397385954857,
0.46791523694992065,
-0.5648214817047119,
0.7229315042495728,
0.007179266773164272,
-0.3578217029571533,
-0.3471599817276001,
-0.16359978914260864,
-0.9413406848907471,
0.3202078342437744,
-0.6896106600761414,
-0.7068297863006592,
-0.15696917474269867,
-0.0997145026922226,
-0.13716177642345428,
0.15131667256355286,
-0.4353114664554596,
0.6023111343383789,
-0.17751745879650116,
-0.12115828692913055,
-0.7162214517593384,
-0.4026969075202942,
0.40807241201400757,
-0.21262845396995544,
0.27502891421318054,
0.05231127515435219,
-0.20019209384918213,
0.7426859736442566,
0.12219344824552536,
0.9004735350608826,
0.12279167771339417,
-0.32298362255096436,
0.015548119321465492,
0.09757015109062195,
0.2021481692790985,
-0.07649935036897659,
-0.026448354125022888,
0.40108951926231384,
0.1359383463859558,
-0.2468104064464569,
-0.8636242747306824,
1.0431216955184937,
-1.0267735719680786,
-0.6818661093711853,
-0.479338139295578,
-0.5806143879890442,
-0.34651392698287964,
0.022652646526694298,
0.06711866706609726,
0.08012203127145767,
-0.25715887546539307,
0.08153533935546875,
0.7638347148895264,
-0.11618389934301376,
0.25870782136917114,
0.47470247745513916,
-0.34766247868537903,
-0.48651981353759766,
0.47139009833335876,
0.1337725967168808,
0.24270214140415192,
0.6518048644065857,
-0.25834915041923523,
-0.29984766244888306,
-0.6218819618225098,
-0.25217437744140625,
0.5114543437957764,
-0.6109073758125305,
-0.20710785686969757,
-0.576162576675415,
-0.13323509693145752,
-0.3698543906211853,
0.02149733528494835,
-0.23281240463256836,
-0.05611693486571312,
0.033344339579343796,
0.03034447506070137,
0.1835070699453354,
0.5737640857696533,
0.384300172328949,
0.4451078474521637,
-0.5703679323196411,
0.10593679547309875,
0.21698273718357086,
0.3037850260734558,
0.2875669002532959,
-0.558594286441803,
-0.22591838240623474,
0.3289865553379059,
-0.13822844624519348,
-0.7793091535568237,
0.019416924566030502,
-0.06133555993437767,
0.5231618881225586,
0.42165982723236084,
-0.3215166926383972,
0.6796189546585083,
-0.6464824676513672,
0.7361068725585938,
0.31834158301353455,
-0.8041703104972839,
0.025737546384334564,
-0.275768518447876,
0.31800946593284607,
0.4252910912036896,
0.49002888798713684,
-0.44136857986450195,
-0.289782851934433,
-0.21455766260623932,
-0.19870281219482422,
0.5951187610626221,
0.07133617252111435,
0.2527151107788086,
-0.18637371063232422,
0.5080117583274841,
-0.2226240038871765,
-0.10493939369916916,
-0.6517884731292725,
-0.07027100026607513,
0.14795617759227753,
-0.5410274267196655,
-0.06387139111757278,
-0.050554364919662476,
-0.1606169492006302,
-0.06429318338632584,
0.492184042930603,
-0.12129756063222885,
0.4285620152950287,
-0.04694613441824913,
-0.08967621624469757,
-0.21050317585468292,
-0.008461927063763142,
0.6372888684272766,
0.5661728382110596,
-0.03658730909228325,
0.10452323406934738,
0.34608280658721924,
-0.49375730752944946,
0.025775359943509102,
-0.38627469539642334,
0.19656959176063538,
-0.35398560762405396,
0.6465106010437012,
0.5824602842330933,
0.3035404682159424,
-0.8493844270706177,
0.638335108757019,
-0.31604814529418945,
-0.13310390710830688,
-0.41904962062835693,
0.16084177792072296,
0.6154085397720337,
0.46821680665016174,
0.1908445656299591,
-0.08506546169519424,
-0.2823227047920227,
-0.4939059317111969,
-0.09245678782463074,
0.9452908039093018,
-0.17895470559597015,
-0.33742454648017883,
0.5231558084487915,
-0.3506484627723694,
-0.38998943567276,
0.9402567148208618,
0.36856913566589355,
-0.40855541825294495,
0.44985100626945496,
0.7385928630828857,
0.649341344833374,
-0.17002981901168823,
-0.30627021193504333,
0.4834974706172943,
0.33686894178390503,
-0.18716977536678314,
0.15801678597927094,
0.128762349486351,
-1.098386287689209,
-0.7487186789512634,
-0.522064745426178,
-0.12379810214042664,
0.1369909942150116,
-0.6021183133125305,
0.5109559893608093,
-0.5276166796684265,
-0.338259220123291,
0.05492512509226799,
-0.06879052519798279,
-0.7596901059150696,
0.29469674825668335,
0.608974039554596,
0.6716530323028564,
-0.8576558232307434,
1.2260457277297974,
0.8137101531028748,
-0.27645522356033325,
-0.8339361548423767,
0.005436140578240156,
-0.20016850531101227,
-0.9575929641723633,
0.6926038861274719,
0.1251860111951828,
-0.25642064213752747,
-0.27427899837493896,
-0.5910590887069702,
-1.0429750680923462,
1.124882698059082,
0.6764519214630127,
-0.9438432455062866,
0.0475485622882843,
0.4057231545448303,
0.7916871309280396,
-0.5920655131340027,
0.5004660487174988,
0.4798872470855713,
0.26662883162498474,
-0.19327537715435028,
-0.8727273941040039,
0.42838212847709656,
0.0035489979200065136,
0.19109661877155304,
0.2322772890329361,
-0.6194902062416077,
0.5449578166007996,
-0.011719922535121441,
-0.15414857864379883,
-0.07719919830560684,
0.8544231653213501,
0.6099392771720886,
-0.07861189544200897,
0.5191831588745117,
0.6503092050552368,
0.6617571115493774,
-0.0007654536166228354,
0.7204986810684204,
-0.5178181529045105,
0.09789559245109558,
1.0703226327896118,
-0.47405704855918884,
1.2309000492095947,
0.7726841568946838,
-0.18028703331947327,
0.6773657202720642,
0.4138149619102478,
0.09875333309173584,
0.393604040145874,
0.20960184931755066,
0.27185991406440735,
-0.4040468633174896,
0.3406241536140442,
-0.23293285071849823,
0.2223808467388153,
0.4547857344150543,
-0.47617030143737793,
0.0832463949918747,
0.165348619222641,
-0.06045442074537277,
0.5173284411430359,
-0.11272399872541428,
0.7362726926803589,
0.3355964720249176,
-0.7135612964630127,
0.6849240064620972,
-0.003995582927018404,
0.8491540551185608,
-0.6375013589859009,
0.15229041874408722,
0.04682140052318573,
0.07839885354042053,
-0.2597178816795349,
-0.8880311250686646,
0.35931888222694397,
-0.25351589918136597,
-0.35269150137901306,
-0.22937074303627014,
0.43092572689056396,
-0.40422388911247253,
0.04721653088927269,
0.49176025390625,
0.25882989168167114,
0.14684656262397766,
-0.13049165904521942,
-0.605469286441803,
0.5080382823944092,
-0.17019535601139069,
-0.31923800706863403,
0.751623272895813,
0.37166160345077515,
-0.3158583641052246,
0.5074878334999084,
0.541525661945343,
0.02843971736729145,
0.07582122832536697,
0.0710836723446846,
0.6821170449256897,
-0.8307967185974121,
-0.19501431286334991,
-1.0761798620224,
-0.0549943745136261,
-0.05313197895884514,
-0.09999320656061172,
0.5955965518951416,
0.4483085572719574,
0.7584372162818909,
-0.20461958646774292,
0.37565121054649353,
0.12844182550907135,
0.08692147582769394,
-0.7324866652488708,
0.6009788513183594,
-0.18363310396671295,
0.2574145495891571,
-0.1138310506939888,
-1.397757887840271,
-0.2080240100622177,
0.802138090133667,
-0.7290222644805908,
0.03310510888695717,
0.785424530506134,
0.9910544753074646,
-0.10579408705234528,
0.2750459611415863,
0.3569013476371765,
0.19458773732185364,
0.09059622138738632,
0.66522616147995,
0.7948652505874634,
-0.4455243945121765,
0.26055335998535156,
0.15339191257953644,
-0.052966680377721786,
0.14764976501464844,
-0.8729802370071411,
-1.135713815689087,
-0.6920544505119324,
-0.29925867915153503,
-0.3146946132183075,
-0.007885516621172428,
1.14631187915802,
0.6075948476791382,
-0.6755260825157166,
-0.41002368927001953,
0.11130523681640625,
-0.1983186900615692,
-0.36139580607414246,
-0.16977383196353912,
0.47074076533317566,
-0.4966336190700531,
-0.6987375617027283,
0.15282559394836426,
0.1207234114408493,
-0.2460923194885254,
-0.49889010190963745,
-0.09905509650707245,
-0.10163046419620514,
0.146480530500412,
0.46343761682510376,
-0.1391400843858719,
-0.8636299967765808,
-0.3907002806663513,
0.20996037125587463,
-0.6847679615020752,
0.0341569259762764,
0.8141301274299622,
-0.9553852677345276,
0.07473801076412201,
0.5326920747756958,
0.849635660648346,
0.37816664576530457,
-0.17890115082263947,
0.6479833126068115,
-0.3839855194091797,
0.10894452035427094,
0.018261373043060303,
0.38524481654167175,
0.37911608815193176,
-0.3639245629310608,
0.16003549098968506,
-0.30545976758003235,
-0.6436317563056946,
-0.600571870803833,
-0.021372485905885696,
-1.219175100326538,
-0.27032390236854553,
1.1454133987426758,
0.16669267416000366,
-0.5652918815612793,
0.2295864373445511,
-0.2695654332637787,
0.3219814896583557,
-0.15040229260921478,
0.7030353546142578,
1.0387892723083496,
-0.17447245121002197,
-0.1930711269378662,
-0.4773693382740021,
0.3481363356113434,
0.6604170203208923,
-0.3090720474720001,
0.1630849689245224,
0.25526654720306396,
0.5548607707023621,
0.21910594403743744,
0.5001023411750793,
-0.3207486867904663,
-0.05741823837161064,
-0.26179173588752747,
0.2317265421152115,
0.14149661362171173,
0.13058215379714966,
-0.5725818276405334,
0.023814095184206963,
0.15199996531009674,
-0.010596477426588535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07921v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07921v1
|
Merino: Entropy-driven Design for Generative Language Models on IoT Devices
| 2024-02-28T03:20:27 | 2024-02-28T03:20:27 |
Youpeng Zhao, Ming Lin, Huadong Tang, Qiang Wu, Jun Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Generative Large Language Models (LLMs) stand as a revolutionary advancement
in the modern era of artificial intelligence (AI). However, directly deploying
LLMs in resource-constrained hardware, such as Internet-of-Things (IoT)
devices, is difficult due to their high computational cost. In this paper, we
propose a novel information-entropy framework for designing mobile-friendly
generative language models. Our key design paradigm is to maximize the entropy
of transformer decoders within the given computational budgets. The whole
design procedure involves solving a mathematical programming (MP) problem,
which can be done on the CPU within minutes, making it nearly zero-cost. We
evaluate our designed models, termed MeRino, across nine NLP downstream tasks,
showing their competitive performance against the state-of-the-art
autoregressive transformer models under the mobile setting. Notably, MeRino
achieves similar or better zero performance compared to the 350M parameter OPT
while being 4.9x faster on NVIDIA Jetson Nano with 5.5x reduction in model
size. Code will be made available soon.
|
[
-0.23327261209487915,
-0.1603952795267105,
0.32943984866142273,
0.34615737199783325,
-0.2955273389816284,
-0.21235822141170502,
-0.17130015790462494,
-0.5143129825592041,
0.14390382170677185,
0.4206671714782715,
-0.5159597992897034,
-0.4001275599002838,
-0.5345012545585632,
0.0714876800775528,
-0.31230536103248596,
0.6069275140762329,
0.10924756526947021,
-0.3579655885696411,
-0.20380644500255585,
0.20755521953105927,
-0.09342986345291138,
-0.10445903986692429,
-0.4370708465576172,
-0.2728274166584015,
0.3845287561416626,
0.34624725580215454,
0.5662307143211365,
0.6300539374351501,
0.6130779981613159,
0.28656309843063354,
-0.016297589987516403,
0.08902157843112946,
-0.12716026604175568,
0.37713325023651123,
0.15058453381061554,
-0.6400303840637207,
-0.3215961158275604,
-0.2518930435180664,
0.04640219360589981,
0.09436210989952087,
-0.4321383833885193,
0.31125858426094055,
-0.08664973080158234,
0.8217298984527588,
-0.837045431137085,
0.19309179484844208,
-0.9941482543945312,
0.08824630081653595,
-0.09914969652891159,
-0.22848919034004211,
-0.5088149905204773,
-0.1375892162322998,
-0.20304426550865173,
-0.4415791928768158,
0.19856205582618713,
-0.0103085245937109,
0.6020810008049011,
0.7668051719665527,
-0.12385936826467514,
-0.34381648898124695,
-1.0903899669647217,
0.6707067489624023,
-0.8113343119621277,
0.6687859296798706,
0.5942623019218445,
-0.04919784516096115,
0.09441549330949783,
-0.4311852753162384,
-0.5591439604759216,
-0.3572492003440857,
0.2795760929584503,
0.18578244745731354,
-0.5214857459068298,
-0.2793320119380951,
-0.047751814126968384,
0.389614075422287,
-0.7665796875953674,
0.22665251791477203,
-0.1883402317762375,
0.12221460044384003,
0.6345905661582947,
0.2554081380367279,
0.012104988098144531,
-0.03152481094002724,
-0.2973708510398865,
0.04011821746826172,
-0.8024740219116211,
-0.28688251972198486,
0.2080005705356598,
0.2281147688627243,
-0.3945308029651642,
0.32720619440078735,
-0.4032854735851288,
0.8998339772224426,
0.008985554799437523,
-0.4657784402370453,
0.053561024367809296,
0.11512208729982376,
-0.2824591398239136,
-0.010456321761012077,
1.0161221027374268,
0.21196424961090088,
-0.22398637235164642,
-0.406175434589386,
-0.3340872824192047,
-0.2745477557182312,
0.48569753766059875,
-0.8111488819122314,
-0.10183490812778473,
0.39168602228164673,
-0.5409325957298279,
-0.5576135516166687,
-0.2603771984577179,
-0.7049307823181152,
-0.45713067054748535,
-0.07466679066419601,
0.17447295784950256,
-0.0722866803407669,
-0.1578877568244934,
0.16219733655452728,
-0.04391780123114586,
0.07927792519330978,
0.05069134384393692,
-1.2491401433944702,
-0.24029898643493652,
0.5071170330047607,
0.898746132850647,
-0.025905603542923927,
-0.029590090736746788,
0.06990932673215866,
0.35483554005622864,
-0.08290007710456848,
0.5118027329444885,
-0.23577843606472015,
-0.5082111954689026,
-0.2576250731945038,
-0.41182518005371094,
-0.16715997457504272,
-0.5791866779327393,
0.8360041975975037,
-0.8212169408798218,
-0.02517622336745262,
0.4513392448425293,
-0.22884535789489746,
-0.04586757346987724,
0.1468666046857834,
-0.7731565237045288,
0.5460588932037354,
0.04129016771912575,
-0.8149218559265137,
-0.05257773399353027,
-0.8672354221343994,
-0.7211888432502747,
0.174615278840065,
0.22100335359573364,
-0.494916707277298,
0.3841644525527954,
-0.06563369929790497,
0.49947550892829895,
-1.030300259590149,
0.3374047875404358,
-0.23329085111618042,
-0.07261116802692413,
0.24384990334510803,
-0.9357317686080933,
0.7656181454658508,
0.8735725283622742,
-0.5645752549171448,
0.06491264700889587,
-1.030290961265564,
0.11066417396068573,
0.08093006163835526,
-0.4954976737499237,
-0.26943743228912354,
0.2846100330352783,
0.053844913840293884,
0.17032389342784882,
0.31407788395881653,
-0.6497012972831726,
-0.01201558392494917,
-0.1309814304113388,
0.7921423316001892,
0.6248642206192017,
-0.6396228671073914,
0.5128616690635681,
-0.10656619817018509,
0.48557576537132263,
-0.45097965002059937,
0.4135904014110565,
-0.019440283998847008,
-0.5254676938056946,
-0.8000020980834961,
-0.4821101129055023,
0.12383123487234116,
0.8594769239425659,
-0.6702189445495605,
0.7248380780220032,
-0.4545019865036011,
-0.7416974902153015,
-0.5248205661773682,
0.22005106508731842,
-0.006632841657847166,
0.339153528213501,
0.12169910222291946,
0.323208749294281,
-0.48111826181411743,
-0.8070818781852722,
0.04739557206630707,
-0.2672634720802307,
-0.49204203486442566,
0.3778297007083893,
0.2682039141654968,
-0.6893393993377686,
0.9407181739807129,
-0.53522127866745,
-0.03411484137177467,
-0.16528111696243286,
0.32932060956954956,
0.23757769167423248,
0.5136577486991882,
0.25225913524627686,
-0.9006999135017395,
-0.2272156924009323,
0.4260784387588501,
-0.7573848366737366,
-0.29941633343696594,
-0.07239766418933868,
0.05554567277431488,
0.24549661576747894,
0.29119086265563965,
-0.9304641485214233,
0.5284009575843811,
0.8630344867706299,
-0.017023591324687004,
0.36159247159957886,
-0.11566167324781418,
-0.2476077377796173,
-1.3808289766311646,
0.134514719247818,
-0.038377150893211365,
-0.05434480682015419,
-0.5384856462478638,
0.11776591837406158,
0.025613537058234215,
-0.42926594614982605,
-0.37577757239341736,
0.4154498875141144,
-0.061374232172966,
0.4936526417732239,
-0.49481022357940674,
-0.6021031737327576,
-0.03520556911826134,
0.4577995538711548,
0.10141577571630478,
0.802625834941864,
0.5624456405639648,
-0.7573139667510986,
0.3949839174747467,
-0.4214078187942505,
-0.30981409549713135,
0.35794705152511597,
-0.8543601036071777,
-0.05056994408369064,
-0.131810262799263,
0.05432433262467384,
-0.510847806930542,
-0.216902494430542,
0.034037042409181595,
-0.37102997303009033,
0.03092014417052269,
-0.06652019172906876,
-0.589413583278656,
-0.5413597226142883,
-0.09880033135414124,
0.6419764757156372,
0.4850534498691559,
-0.614642858505249,
0.8705049753189087,
0.45292672514915466,
0.05288539081811905,
-0.1327725201845169,
-0.5880116820335388,
0.24479377269744873,
-0.6194272637367249,
-0.6322070956230164,
0.6565071940422058,
-0.057883430272340775,
-0.16224995255470276,
-0.11055750399827957,
0.005592133849859238,
-0.17074963450431824,
0.24409475922584534,
0.3828406035900116,
0.0636574998497963,
-0.06478963792324066,
0.16063159704208374,
-0.24913890659809113,
-0.3578183352947235,
-0.054902516305446625,
-0.7979552745819092,
0.7562318444252014,
-0.2652013599872589,
-0.23923198878765106,
-0.9463105797767639,
0.4842544198036194,
0.9663597345352173,
-0.24507486820220947,
0.6868650317192078,
0.7316197752952576,
-0.3056713044643402,
-0.21111682057380676,
-0.5020501613616943,
0.07876899838447571,
-0.5653796792030334,
0.11244094371795654,
-0.5679925680160522,
-0.997645914554596,
0.5886082053184509,
-0.14660871028900146,
-0.11642105132341385,
0.5712772011756897,
0.8074102401733398,
-0.3971877992153168,
0.7963131666183472,
0.9401364922523499,
-0.37776321172714233,
0.6184278130531311,
-0.2625657916069031,
0.6015390753746033,
-0.7032620310783386,
-0.2645862400531769,
-0.5518953204154968,
-0.16000375151634216,
-0.8469011187553406,
-0.44145143032073975,
0.6707807779312134,
0.06440316140651703,
-0.3448794186115265,
0.4162565767765045,
-0.5107195973396301,
0.35464608669281006,
0.9178237318992615,
0.10072969645261765,
0.11813263595104218,
0.16536997258663177,
0.21873155236244202,
0.45333293080329895,
-0.9943937063217163,
-0.3498566448688507,
0.9505857825279236,
0.22627665102481842,
1.2644840478897095,
0.301238477230072,
0.5297200679779053,
0.25525298714637756,
0.3202921450138092,
-0.6988450884819031,
0.3099183142185211,
-0.22721201181411743,
-0.45871517062187195,
-0.2744690179824829,
-0.6721264123916626,
-0.8644435405731201,
0.12726888060569763,
0.2064535766839981,
-0.6409065127372742,
0.296436071395874,
0.07774781435728073,
-0.32319700717926025,
0.5477471947669983,
-0.6678065061569214,
0.6047822833061218,
-0.41965654492378235,
-0.2927771508693695,
-0.22054055333137512,
-0.4858722984790802,
0.30106422305107117,
-0.030689051374793053,
0.0881267711520195,
-0.025902576744556427,
0.1201297789812088,
0.5332360863685608,
-0.7776369452476501,
0.7862183451652527,
0.20858420431613922,
-0.42081084847450256,
0.6193105578422546,
0.06954805552959442,
0.49167683720588684,
-0.004756989888846874,
-0.24996627867221832,
0.22363963723182678,
-0.43619588017463684,
-0.21404924988746643,
-0.5362014174461365,
0.6059086918830872,
-0.549462616443634,
-0.4713487923145294,
0.000842955254483968,
-0.6887578368186951,
0.011082625947892666,
0.10178733617067337,
0.693341076374054,
0.2461674064397812,
0.07752875238656998,
0.3561331629753113,
0.7175959944725037,
-0.13885298371315002,
0.7822619676589966,
0.3523937463760376,
0.3238745927810669,
-0.4603358805179596,
1.1220173835754395,
-0.31631943583488464,
0.1491958647966385,
0.7274338006973267,
0.2370378077030182,
-0.11822878569364548,
-0.19902770221233368,
-0.683788001537323,
-0.16781221330165863,
-0.16714254021644592,
-0.660207986831665,
-0.512275218963623,
-0.2747632563114166,
-0.35924041271209717,
-0.18726740777492523,
-0.7027339339256287,
-0.30144429206848145,
-0.48511263728141785,
0.19909361004829407,
0.6011085510253906,
0.4510524570941925,
-0.2613670825958252,
0.5680230855941772,
-0.699134349822998,
0.2972024381160736,
0.48509806394577026,
0.4949662983417511,
0.27908554673194885,
-0.4658852815628052,
-0.39398613572120667,
0.04889776185154915,
-0.44557109475135803,
-0.5667617917060852,
0.46000561118125916,
0.023979967460036278,
0.1831139177083969,
0.698577344417572,
0.12954506278038025,
0.5124008655548096,
-0.4685992896556854,
0.3741789758205414,
0.4787176549434662,
-0.9131627678871155,
0.5716660022735596,
-0.3402767479419708,
0.44903647899627686,
0.22593098878860474,
0.18065916001796722,
-0.3818116784095764,
-0.1793418526649475,
-0.41901764273643494,
-0.8735023736953735,
0.35629090666770935,
0.2964518070220947,
0.39758816361427307,
0.15952709317207336,
0.03921074792742729,
-0.0522150918841362,
0.24971410632133484,
-0.6841101050376892,
-0.10954014211893082,
-0.183344304561615,
-0.3358360528945923,
0.28880107402801514,
-0.381246417760849,
0.03650027513504028,
-0.3019525110721588,
0.5406335592269897,
0.11603790521621704,
0.5810795426368713,
0.009383170865476131,
-0.03689870238304138,
0.162257120013237,
0.33291980624198914,
0.9863659143447876,
0.18921886384487152,
-0.15152403712272644,
0.35003140568733215,
-0.21049764752388,
-0.46752700209617615,
0.11339578777551651,
-0.006256444379687309,
-0.4219331443309784,
0.04123568907380104,
0.2700274586677551,
1.0517421960830688,
-0.2715112566947937,
-0.6186178922653198,
0.09170867502689362,
-0.0441681407392025,
0.12309857457876205,
-0.10297734290361404,
0.054338760673999786,
-0.022096607834100723,
0.3399866819381714,
0.47005560994148254,
0.13848234713077545,
0.15244925022125244,
-0.2841712534427643,
0.044036801904439926,
0.5208742618560791,
-0.06228795647621155,
-0.388964980840683,
0.9347996711730957,
0.28973981738090515,
-0.5630071759223938,
0.5294345021247864,
-0.4781705439090729,
-0.6420341730117798,
0.5754984021186829,
0.8862440586090088,
1.2306311130523682,
-0.3304470181465149,
0.257735013961792,
0.1837068349123001,
0.5533378720283508,
0.2163621187210083,
0.2381630837917328,
-0.5785738825798035,
-0.6674463152885437,
-0.0732002854347229,
-0.8401060104370117,
-0.02531488798558712,
0.045491158962249756,
-0.45202016830444336,
-0.08998566120862961,
-0.19297060370445251,
-0.3254210352897644,
-0.40288031101226807,
-0.586297869682312,
-0.5731212496757507,
0.3252653479576111,
0.3240727484226227,
0.5574632287025452,
-0.5894958972930908,
0.7595422267913818,
0.24574215710163116,
0.041335154324769974,
-0.5776864290237427,
-0.003688193392008543,
-0.28377580642700195,
-0.7712278962135315,
0.7294424176216125,
-0.16254454851150513,
-0.5424550175666809,
0.0395527221262455,
-0.4605768918991089,
-0.9795128703117371,
0.9819383025169373,
0.28154927492141724,
-0.4394955337047577,
0.2296864241361618,
0.44997552037239075,
0.4511249363422394,
-0.2833717167377472,
0.07356633245944977,
0.15649141371250153,
0.26401302218437195,
0.14658145606517792,
-0.9966700077056885,
-0.31758543848991394,
-0.48226112127304077,
0.26132532954216003,
0.098802350461483,
-0.7142664790153503,
0.62856525182724,
-0.4101423919200897,
-0.09546947479248047,
0.12984931468963623,
0.5656048655509949,
0.09754563122987747,
0.3158419728279114,
0.25334542989730835,
0.8914909958839417,
0.8500528931617737,
0.18689417839050293,
1.093407392501831,
-0.7112605571746826,
0.3631087839603424,
0.8926138281822205,
-0.0874776691198349,
0.9274724721908569,
0.4136289656162262,
-0.15007935464382172,
0.29950758814811707,
0.43575525283813477,
0.20919278264045715,
0.9138673543930054,
0.298978328704834,
-0.6807540059089661,
-0.0916278213262558,
-0.27269262075424194,
-0.3153153657913208,
0.581313967704773,
0.3083363473415375,
-0.35910743474960327,
-0.11344492435455322,
0.3257976472377777,
0.04724139720201492,
-0.48246148228645325,
-0.37014180421829224,
0.6507805585861206,
0.0746978148818016,
-0.21219483017921448,
0.925978422164917,
0.5323733687400818,
0.8168082237243652,
-0.15854555368423462,
0.446768194437027,
-0.3312089741230011,
0.11067500710487366,
-0.22970673441886902,
-0.31794601678848267,
0.4416467249393463,
0.42103877663612366,
-0.6106771230697632,
-0.36606112122535706,
0.5822020769119263,
-0.19242343306541443,
-0.8634273409843445,
-0.18981602787971497,
0.05821961164474487,
-0.07570440322160721,
-0.21200130879878998,
-0.44430413842201233,
0.45343029499053955,
-0.024562522768974304,
0.014089311473071575,
-0.10120172053575516,
0.45822951197624207,
0.055285681039094925,
1.059355616569519,
0.5969670414924622,
-0.22405315935611725,
0.31849461793899536,
-0.045470621436834335,
0.7216667532920837,
-0.5131736993789673,
-0.4756726324558258,
-1.059509038925171,
0.4675545394420624,
0.17494484782218933,
-0.2334827184677124,
0.5403177738189697,
0.6714025139808655,
0.5828636288642883,
-0.29929518699645996,
0.7551273703575134,
-0.3299248516559601,
-0.05173908919095993,
-0.5614004135131836,
0.8296136260032654,
-0.6037333607673645,
0.4254443347454071,
0.12065141648054123,
-0.7941548228263855,
-0.4607989192008972,
0.6271346211433411,
-0.0569457933306694,
-0.1425822228193283,
0.30217429995536804,
0.7983841300010681,
-0.05209523066878319,
0.16497647762298584,
0.18021085858345032,
-0.03766801208257675,
0.24291111528873444,
0.7882051467895508,
0.6239386200904846,
-0.5403759479522705,
0.2475387006998062,
-0.40771132707595825,
-0.15314538776874542,
-0.37645426392555237,
-0.828042209148407,
-0.521148145198822,
-0.7504080533981323,
-0.1468818038702011,
-0.01769074611365795,
-0.11047761142253876,
0.7252753376960754,
0.9767330288887024,
-0.5594249367713928,
-0.3892374634742737,
-0.437154084444046,
0.43630194664001465,
0.10667630285024643,
-0.1634867787361145,
0.2585732936859131,
-0.19904449582099915,
-0.5317566394805908,
0.38250595331192017,
0.47903263568878174,
-0.059994250535964966,
-0.06689871102571487,
-0.04898984357714653,
0.2754639685153961,
-0.003580051939934492,
0.9790118336677551,
0.2719537615776062,
-0.6896241903305054,
0.24654047191143036,
0.04527115449309349,
-0.1473945677280426,
0.08368729799985886,
0.9318503141403198,
-0.6492726802825928,
0.3503420352935791,
0.5529849529266357,
0.7007184624671936,
0.30691373348236084,
-0.03893137350678444,
0.41180264949798584,
-0.2855337858200073,
0.27698972821235657,
0.27662062644958496,
0.0073370845057070255,
0.08678744733333588,
-0.33273762464523315,
0.35740023851394653,
0.2335960865020752,
-0.39753851294517517,
-0.8294665813446045,
0.3098975718021393,
-0.7312790155410767,
-0.12360048294067383,
1.0652848482131958,
0.26237934827804565,
-0.28345730900764465,
0.32994166016578674,
0.3486006557941437,
-0.04423356428742409,
-0.10556991398334503,
1.1162848472595215,
0.31767475605010986,
-0.09224449098110199,
-0.2269197553396225,
-0.3936831057071686,
0.18123875558376312,
0.2838737666606903,
-0.8075568675994873,
0.12264946103096008,
0.0741899386048317,
-0.13851968944072723,
0.3049317002296448,
0.3456609547138214,
0.119429811835289,
0.029977766796946526,
-0.02638799138367176,
0.4029122292995453,
0.09623558074235916,
-0.5908752679824829,
-0.1912887692451477,
0.09402099996805191,
-0.10136598348617554,
-0.32619208097457886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18013v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18013v1
|
A Survey on Recent Advances in LLM-Based Multi-turn Dialogue Systems
| 2024-02-28T03:16:44 | 2024-02-28T03:16:44 |
Zihao Yi, Jiarui Ouyang, Yuwen Liu, Tianhao Liao, Zhe Xu, Ying Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This survey provides a comprehensive review of research on multi-turn
dialogue systems, with a particular focus on multi-turn dialogue systems based
on large language models (LLMs). This paper aims to (a) give a summary of
existing LLMs and approaches for adapting LLMs to downstream tasks; (b)
elaborate recent advances in multi-turn dialogue systems, covering both
LLM-based open-domain dialogue (ODD) and task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems,
along with datasets and evaluation metrics; (c) discuss some future emphasis
and recent research problems arising from the development of LLMs and the
increasing demands on multi-turn dialogue systems.
|
[
-0.5843203067779541,
-0.6840929985046387,
0.9442102313041687,
0.28317704796791077,
0.0836227759718895,
0.4862183928489685,
-0.276172399520874,
-0.4488786458969116,
0.34868407249450684,
0.9165167808532715,
-0.7547087073326111,
-0.2863417863845825,
-0.6133742332458496,
0.1453487128019333,
-0.3001207113265991,
0.6435007452964783,
0.13128364086151123,
0.5445134043693542,
0.013961161486804485,
-0.33091357350349426,
-0.3621648848056793,
-0.6529590487480164,
-0.6997420787811279,
-0.16509366035461426,
0.43418607115745544,
0.41698113083839417,
0.4553152024745941,
-0.478983074426651,
0.389872670173645,
0.4126506745815277,
-0.06478861719369888,
0.3580824136734009,
-0.335966557264328,
0.46181371808052063,
0.002759665949270129,
-0.39298102259635925,
-0.7746790647506714,
-0.1868268847465515,
0.9196422696113586,
0.7149965167045593,
-0.10922989249229431,
-0.09608083963394165,
-0.008473196998238564,
0.4173295795917511,
-0.5752686858177185,
0.1530025452375412,
-0.4622885584831238,
-0.17652089893817902,
-0.167586088180542,
-0.15802188217639923,
-0.5672103762626648,
-0.35280367732048035,
0.3165011703968048,
-0.20007582008838654,
-0.21846309304237366,
0.15011613070964813,
0.044601038098335266,
-0.11169710755348206,
-0.3410758972167969,
-0.5058999061584473,
-1.0611554384231567,
1.1961344480514526,
-1.0875043869018555,
0.40553292632102966,
-0.17958728969097137,
0.4294999837875366,
-0.4382523000240326,
-0.5037601590156555,
-0.4829958379268646,
-0.24726180732250214,
0.29382359981536865,
0.16748403012752533,
-0.017063084989786148,
0.07791323214769363,
-0.07640005648136139,
0.4775826334953308,
-0.17000441253185272,
0.2858063876628876,
-0.05053649842739105,
0.061955150216817856,
0.5592193007469177,
0.6314195990562439,
0.11793983727693558,
0.07896903157234192,
-0.24054700136184692,
0.20748068392276764,
-0.8772013783454895,
-0.14234143495559692,
0.15540382266044617,
0.3587739169597626,
-0.04756176099181175,
0.6542413234710693,
-0.39162397384643555,
1.0144283771514893,
-0.008307709358632565,
-0.41802847385406494,
-0.14365102350711823,
-0.6708123683929443,
-0.32367464900016785,
-0.20937852561473846,
0.9375723004341125,
0.5905959010124207,
0.12033355981111526,
-0.0049797650426626205,
-0.18269117176532745,
-0.4115947484970093,
0.07039456069469452,
-0.37049219012260437,
0.16908276081085205,
0.299371600151062,
-0.5286562442779541,
0.006521002855151892,
-0.21910534799098969,
-0.8484451174736023,
-0.5791923403739929,
-0.4506678283214569,
0.19243215024471283,
-0.1251465082168579,
-0.4530985951423645,
0.1522039771080017,
-0.08540104329586029,
0.42474818229675293,
0.793554961681366,
-0.5616855621337891,
0.40147876739501953,
0.8058158755302429,
1.0995982885360718,
-0.5197659134864807,
-0.20580412447452545,
-0.48287802934646606,
-0.040460966527462006,
-0.13403868675231934,
0.8763731122016907,
-0.5938518643379211,
-0.5269217491149902,
0.46090227365493774,
0.3194010853767395,
-0.1525087207555771,
-0.5927063226699829,
0.30866095423698425,
-0.6003520488739014,
0.21760350465774536,
-0.028983138501644135,
-0.1864355355501175,
0.014501876197755337,
0.4267193078994751,
-0.41594162583351135,
0.6184473633766174,
-0.0014581703580915928,
-0.611997663974762,
-0.09518871456384659,
-0.6708813309669495,
-0.32652950286865234,
-0.29333576560020447,
0.04115048050880432,
-0.16834519803524017,
0.2186853289604187,
0.12513458728790283,
0.45916250348091125,
-0.6069628596305847,
0.34262436628341675,
-0.48213231563568115,
-0.1835082471370697,
0.5679911375045776,
-0.5190654993057251,
0.7860038876533508,
0.28999680280685425,
-0.04559902846813202,
0.40623918175697327,
-0.664954662322998,
0.010584060102701187,
-0.15270662307739258,
-0.29634562134742737,
0.008997712284326553,
0.3469122350215912,
-0.0104734618216753,
0.26125407218933105,
0.2584804594516754,
-0.7382049560546875,
0.6106936931610107,
-0.024190325289964676,
0.48120754957199097,
0.5124161839485168,
-0.05134405568242073,
0.48370376229286194,
-0.3672283887863159,
0.5470075011253357,
-0.0355306975543499,
0.25782811641693115,
-0.3154235780239105,
-0.6431275606155396,
-1.1393932104110718,
-0.1077902689576149,
-0.011900762096047401,
0.6065607666969299,
-0.8970756530761719,
0.08359839767217636,
-0.1782168298959732,
-0.29186543822288513,
-0.20055462419986725,
-0.06855328381061554,
0.05376305803656578,
-0.31243622303009033,
0.24018819630146027,
-0.5038044452667236,
-0.4155239760875702,
-0.7216265201568604,
-0.1482217013835907,
-0.21198563277721405,
-0.1650724560022354,
0.32496437430381775,
0.0010703272419050336,
-0.21084216237068176,
0.7113444209098816,
-0.4941035807132721,
-0.040233343839645386,
-0.5505529046058655,
0.06911367177963257,
0.13543659448623657,
0.09168343991041183,
0.29661616683006287,
-0.3106786906719208,
-0.4722883701324463,
-0.000581951520871371,
-0.3133486807346344,
-0.1017155796289444,
-0.07944594323635101,
0.09525630623102188,
0.2963239252567291,
0.44678154587745667,
-0.7728316187858582,
0.26830917596817017,
0.6957544684410095,
-0.026691129431128502,
0.5514851808547974,
0.1149214431643486,
0.1621357947587967,
-0.9629220366477966,
-0.3299906849861145,
-0.01450740359723568,
-0.27293768525123596,
-0.8771460652351379,
-0.4117782413959503,
-0.2887950837612152,
0.18238258361816406,
-0.4394948482513428,
0.4777959883213043,
-0.655758261680603,
-0.5537460446357727,
-0.4941473603248596,
0.1521894931793213,
-0.27609506249427795,
0.4809243679046631,
0.2875974476337433,
0.4836748540401459,
0.5343092083930969,
-0.7770260572433472,
0.6761898994445801,
0.17154674232006073,
-0.41433361172676086,
0.7559299468994141,
-0.15785367786884308,
0.18966875970363617,
0.21037423610687256,
0.4842984676361084,
-1.0381380319595337,
-0.07956576347351074,
0.3573143780231476,
-0.25509873032569885,
0.2143063098192215,
-0.29610171914100647,
-0.2567152976989746,
-0.4720262289047241,
-0.31664928793907166,
0.3110211491584778,
0.2900508940219879,
-0.3342321217060089,
0.7012041211128235,
0.47532331943511963,
-0.9673715829849243,
-0.34769028425216675,
-0.4217728078365326,
0.3218393623828888,
-0.11703295260667801,
-0.5329003930091858,
0.06825283169746399,
-0.07265125960111618,
-0.5220305919647217,
-0.4592244625091553,
0.20068979263305664,
-0.10306385159492493,
-0.29753825068473816,
0.026295166462659836,
0.14172132313251495,
-0.21225853264331818,
-0.2272517830133438,
-0.11133014410734177,
0.13610674440860748,
0.20434841513633728,
-0.5207982659339905,
0.6723023056983948,
-0.009359076619148254,
-0.603912889957428,
-0.24319593608379364,
0.5793207883834839,
0.9045079946517944,
0.009552277624607086,
0.41519585251808167,
0.4008374512195587,
0.103258416056633,
-0.11831536889076233,
-0.788522481918335,
-0.15589241683483124,
-0.44577303528785706,
0.4301137328147888,
-0.16394004225730896,
-1.1038321256637573,
0.2781006097793579,
-0.4938846826553345,
0.45102646946907043,
0.3013986647129059,
1.026351809501648,
-0.15639722347259521,
1.0950144529342651,
0.7675485014915466,
-0.03234151750802994,
0.6289184093475342,
0.037160128355026245,
0.4354398548603058,
-1.1594593524932861,
-0.32422348856925964,
-0.7105640769004822,
-0.12320687621831894,
-0.6562926769256592,
-0.5972849130630493,
0.26485198736190796,
-0.20213423669338226,
-0.11447479575872421,
0.1581941843032837,
-0.22638584673404694,
-0.2451372593641281,
0.5318136215209961,
-0.44585278630256653,
0.6946074962615967,
-0.23990483582019806,
-0.020059682428836823,
0.2910614311695099,
-0.8035569787025452,
-0.5774714946746826,
1.0339539051055908,
0.4767020344734192,
1.0593761205673218,
0.34797030687332153,
0.2532757818698883,
0.1452174037694931,
0.5150562524795532,
-0.9180024862289429,
0.5504156947135925,
-0.003463102038949728,
-0.5596757531166077,
-0.649311363697052,
-0.20650438964366913,
-0.7355141639709473,
0.23825562000274658,
0.205335333943367,
-0.8204029202461243,
0.06372849643230438,
-0.2135140299797058,
-0.18614882230758667,
0.5807737708091736,
-0.4572676718235016,
0.17878863215446472,
-0.48034432530403137,
0.0027748383581638336,
-0.13865838944911957,
-0.4770330488681793,
0.44762808084487915,
0.079571932554245,
0.31375160813331604,
-0.1255633383989334,
0.25968655943870544,
0.6978351473808289,
-0.4816827178001404,
0.869642972946167,
-0.49174556136131287,
-0.6045096516609192,
0.6327123641967773,
-0.28702762722969055,
0.4785947799682617,
0.06768717616796494,
0.045950718224048615,
-0.03840342164039612,
0.20139847695827484,
-0.13499756157398224,
-0.5073202848434448,
0.8314348459243774,
-0.48004376888275146,
-0.7286587357521057,
-0.46823620796203613,
-0.5787379741668701,
-0.8284805417060852,
-0.008380165323615074,
-0.09788483381271362,
0.3559480905532837,
-0.2551921010017395,
0.026988552883267403,
0.5522019863128662,
-0.3361443281173706,
0.6628109812736511,
0.6374316215515137,
-0.7035064697265625,
-0.529059112071991,
0.6833741068840027,
0.08904948085546494,
0.6064653992652893,
0.34849491715431213,
-0.1940210908651352,
-0.4859584867954254,
-0.8833146095275879,
-0.5913362503051758,
0.1185833290219307,
-0.4423561096191406,
-0.19066451489925385,
-0.5960425138473511,
-0.19053563475608826,
-0.48564279079437256,
0.15454986691474915,
-0.4394320547580719,
-0.5396755933761597,
0.03915003687143326,
0.2802887558937073,
0.387150377035141,
1.389033555984497,
0.2524595260620117,
0.41897085309028625,
-0.81378173828125,
0.33915743231773376,
0.3600057363510132,
0.5503843426704407,
0.10123711079359055,
-0.4552280604839325,
-0.2208680808544159,
0.1511240005493164,
-0.5120683908462524,
-0.5838854312896729,
0.20981915295124054,
-0.22908376157283783,
0.629047155380249,
0.3201662302017212,
0.0768314003944397,
0.27718180418014526,
-0.5951263904571533,
1.1497392654418945,
0.43648961186408997,
-0.5989195108413696,
0.11739002913236618,
-0.40330618619918823,
0.5844791531562805,
0.19207441806793213,
0.22658908367156982,
-0.7632816433906555,
-0.4072519540786743,
-0.15531806647777557,
-0.4727559983730316,
0.8783382773399353,
-0.16323992609977722,
0.08032400161027908,
0.30219340324401855,
-0.07587376981973648,
0.07453558593988419,
0.21456365287303925,
-0.41693124175071716,
-0.2276587188243866,
0.01463501900434494,
-0.15616725385189056,
-0.17977523803710938,
-0.2416244000196457,
-0.041823118925094604,
0.024358022958040237,
0.5347567796707153,
-0.3268699645996094,
0.6379112601280212,
0.045522768050432205,
-0.03877408057451248,
0.2405179738998413,
0.7445976138114929,
0.8446370959281921,
0.5828372240066528,
-0.17767004668712616,
-0.1953512281179428,
0.39330604672431946,
-0.34144070744514465,
0.2949751019477844,
-0.1267002373933792,
-0.05224031209945679,
0.14088183641433716,
0.08984457701444626,
0.9127110838890076,
0.2135944813489914,
-0.5078283548355103,
0.31846463680267334,
-0.07278360426425934,
-0.11016359180212021,
-0.31058359146118164,
-0.15313692390918732,
0.25773149728775024,
0.3821072280406952,
0.45271608233451843,
-0.06640265136957169,
0.07917239516973495,
-0.7280091643333435,
-0.4401799142360687,
0.7423907518386841,
-0.5660685896873474,
-0.36781197786331177,
-0.03904073312878609,
0.5060606598854065,
-0.4523963928222656,
0.33649933338165283,
0.11812172085046768,
-0.41865861415863037,
0.17660166323184967,
0.3245292603969574,
1.042659878730774,
-0.2809447646141052,
0.05514408275485039,
0.0033587852958589792,
0.06198464706540108,
0.012420850805938244,
0.37881729006767273,
-0.12237713485956192,
-0.6071154475212097,
-0.7807848453521729,
-0.625093936920166,
-0.9859833121299744,
0.3747662603855133,
-0.45421168208122253,
0.2049245834350586,
-0.36291322112083435,
-0.5099788904190063,
-0.16940969228744507,
-0.24356728792190552,
-0.4259948134422302,
-0.01539381593465805,
0.18689031898975372,
0.7645912766456604,
-0.3503890633583069,
0.6849734783172607,
0.7531085014343262,
0.2600841522216797,
-0.0902521163225174,
-0.06278304010629654,
0.009368877857923508,
-0.5439357161521912,
0.32950595021247864,
-0.3641109764575958,
-0.6735561490058899,
-0.24343636631965637,
-0.3968735635280609,
-0.8645938038825989,
0.8900902271270752,
-0.15544936060905457,
-0.8582351803779602,
-0.2586779296398163,
0.5127412676811218,
0.3884885609149933,
-0.5393452048301697,
0.4706726670265198,
0.6903249025344849,
0.609390377998352,
-0.029279494658112526,
-1.2684211730957031,
-0.4453524053096771,
0.04312117397785187,
0.0365973524749279,
0.29535427689552307,
-1.0484142303466797,
0.6285789608955383,
0.03887007758021355,
0.07619786262512207,
0.6140605807304382,
0.41955098509788513,
0.3033657968044281,
0.4510813355445862,
0.4154190719127655,
0.1881483495235443,
0.2288728505373001,
-0.34349021315574646,
0.8756552338600159,
-0.06721685826778412,
0.25857600569725037,
1.2024825811386108,
-0.5524150133132935,
0.8086351156234741,
0.6270588636398315,
-0.5447747707366943,
0.44639357924461365,
0.2594188451766968,
0.27670541405677795,
0.35679861903190613,
0.39279136061668396,
-0.44424790143966675,
-0.2455109804868698,
-0.17630863189697266,
-0.2647300660610199,
0.33149829506874084,
0.7905879020690918,
-0.06457816809415817,
-0.19093790650367737,
0.07835087180137634,
-0.3001059293746948,
-0.45926088094711304,
-0.36510035395622253,
1.154444694519043,
0.29451432824134827,
-0.9671454429626465,
0.29814139008522034,
0.16889862716197968,
0.9774473309516907,
-0.6507216691970825,
0.1183815598487854,
-0.016102265566587448,
0.08219527453184128,
-0.12406178563833237,
-0.8838088512420654,
0.1401972472667694,
0.11636363714933395,
-0.14367912709712982,
-0.31075093150138855,
0.7576878070831299,
-0.35718879103660583,
-0.3916088342666626,
0.3070243299007416,
0.8051103353500366,
0.023579547181725502,
0.00029267772333696485,
-0.4990881383419037,
0.5034350156784058,
0.12169115245342255,
-0.16081319749355316,
0.2464926838874817,
0.43804681301116943,
-0.17376096546649933,
0.7438153624534607,
0.3476657569408417,
0.09740031510591507,
0.4229222238063812,
0.3554176688194275,
0.7837175130844116,
-0.987255871295929,
-0.07885652780532837,
-0.3125394880771637,
0.4311366379261017,
-0.0452348068356514,
-0.09536246955394745,
0.7363479733467102,
0.3389699459075928,
0.6693454384803772,
-0.09547170251607895,
1.177772879600525,
0.08158399164676666,
0.9628667235374451,
-0.690816342830658,
0.36491188406944275,
-0.2675012946128845,
0.20849791169166565,
-0.40755900740623474,
-1.162590742111206,
0.10801777988672256,
0.14711949229240417,
-0.42714014649391174,
0.2620401680469513,
0.5842725038528442,
0.642235279083252,
0.07602450996637344,
0.3028726577758789,
0.283501535654068,
0.2520454525947571,
0.5086153149604797,
0.4712245464324951,
1.619031548500061,
-0.12841549515724182,
0.3936325013637543,
0.16168376803398132,
-0.09843151271343231,
-0.5700619220733643,
-0.7122527956962585,
-0.6692185997962952,
-0.5927745699882507,
-0.3406083583831787,
-0.020384326577186584,
-0.09610766172409058,
0.4444566071033478,
0.7158360481262207,
-1.0668281316757202,
-0.5615890026092529,
0.1296701729297638,
0.052489567548036575,
0.11475816369056702,
-0.1608508825302124,
-0.1345229595899582,
-0.3802279531955719,
-1.1813488006591797,
0.6164267659187317,
0.7127559185028076,
0.014436122961342335,
-0.6228829622268677,
-0.3681226670742035,
-0.32329562306404114,
0.2046695500612259,
0.9476526379585266,
0.24822378158569336,
-1.063321590423584,
-0.14114749431610107,
0.14553768932819366,
0.056649621576070786,
0.18268613517284393,
1.204123854637146,
-0.42497578263282776,
0.28106680512428284,
0.465084433555603,
0.42419514060020447,
0.6613028645515442,
-0.1685989499092102,
0.8314638733863831,
-0.22151874005794525,
-0.12106937915086746,
0.34156736731529236,
0.36464813351631165,
0.5040135979652405,
0.16018398106098175,
0.13549254834651947,
-0.10879743844270706,
-0.5452536940574646,
-0.5937697291374207,
0.4466744363307953,
-1.059963583946228,
-0.14952440559864044,
1.0857160091400146,
-0.07370788604021072,
0.21276462078094482,
-0.6056065559387207,
-0.39988723397254944,
0.11255009472370148,
-0.2450045347213745,
0.1822211891412735,
1.1167651414871216,
-0.5949051380157471,
-0.20576271414756775,
-0.40595734119415283,
0.40701189637184143,
0.3550977110862732,
-0.8236380815505981,
0.07356924563646317,
0.6004142761230469,
0.09842182695865631,
0.3525434732437134,
0.6899968981742859,
-0.3780065178871155,
-0.09820961207151413,
-0.460267573595047,
-0.21280725300312042,
0.45756539702415466,
-0.5020837783813477,
-0.32293930649757385,
0.02164742536842823,
0.477332204580307,
0.182265043258667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18005v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18005v2
|
A Sentiment Consolidation Framework for Meta-Review Generation
| 2024-02-28T02:40:09 | 2024-06-04T16:10:13 |
Miao Li, Jey Han Lau, Eduard Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Modern natural language generation systems with Large Language Models (LLMs)
exhibit the capability to generate a plausible summary of multiple documents;
however, it is uncertain if they truly possess the capability of information
consolidation to generate summaries, especially on documents with opinionated
information. We focus on meta-review generation, a form of sentiment
summarisation for the scientific domain. To make scientific sentiment
summarization more grounded, we hypothesize that human meta-reviewers follow a
three-layer framework of sentiment consolidation to write meta-reviews. Based
on the framework, we propose novel prompting methods for LLMs to generate
meta-reviews and evaluation metrics to assess the quality of generated
meta-reviews. Our framework is validated empirically as we find that prompting
LLMs based on the framework -- compared with prompting them with simple
instructions -- generates better meta-reviews.
|
[
-0.7839890122413635,
-0.2541744112968445,
0.5843566060066223,
0.36378008127212524,
-0.4444241225719452,
0.041195228695869446,
-0.1258058100938797,
-0.019957607612013817,
0.5264078378677368,
0.4329591393470764,
-0.672366738319397,
-0.6758705973625183,
-0.3719751834869385,
0.7374227643013,
-0.27773991227149963,
1.3394438028335571,
0.16380639374256134,
0.1969689577817917,
-0.5400171279907227,
0.14911656081676483,
-0.05031365156173706,
-0.11917019635438919,
-0.257024884223938,
-0.549955427646637,
0.7569813132286072,
0.3832707405090332,
0.41013067960739136,
0.03440625220537186,
0.6096928119659424,
0.19646354019641876,
-0.1820121705532074,
0.6304202079772949,
-0.31349360942840576,
0.2551596760749817,
-0.11623858660459518,
-0.1847192347049713,
-0.8014335632324219,
0.07329323142766953,
0.5298387408256531,
0.7768090963363647,
-0.12090904265642166,
0.4012693464756012,
0.4621835947036743,
0.8099027872085571,
-0.5800090432167053,
-0.0008386734989471734,
-0.19621339440345764,
0.28301677107810974,
0.36996886134147644,
-0.45492640137672424,
-0.3884906470775604,
-0.7248674035072327,
0.04359662905335426,
-0.2712036967277527,
0.48307332396507263,
-0.10051047801971436,
0.3863251507282257,
0.12028130143880844,
-0.42550045251846313,
-0.31096646189689636,
-0.5705364942550659,
0.6479625105857849,
-0.8811150193214417,
-0.19371631741523743,
-0.018771762028336525,
0.04075917974114418,
0.020824439823627472,
-0.49000316858291626,
-0.7595746517181396,
-0.010432041250169277,
-0.3003416955471039,
0.5041239857673645,
0.10141200572252274,
0.10525427758693695,
-0.012105397880077362,
0.4160728454589844,
-0.3228047490119934,
-0.3990926444530487,
-0.5416083335876465,
0.014651723206043243,
0.5292237997055054,
0.2460000067949295,
-0.06350906938314438,
-0.6017469763755798,
-0.2388513833284378,
-0.22115817666053772,
-0.8998294472694397,
-0.08694643527269363,
0.24418750405311584,
0.2526014447212219,
0.21871857345104218,
0.6967416405677795,
-0.19107982516288757,
0.6008615493774414,
0.23947523534297943,
-0.24799129366874695,
0.29425048828125,
-0.5195186138153076,
-0.42903196811676025,
0.09435872733592987,
1.0916950702667236,
1.0873703956604004,
-0.0795510932803154,
0.1862381249666214,
-0.23964948952198029,
0.19244609773159027,
0.3738526701927185,
-0.8584680557250977,
0.1437148004770279,
0.47010672092437744,
-0.6537832021713257,
-1.0501395463943481,
0.33016952872276306,
-0.900261402130127,
-0.2988361716270447,
-0.22437913715839386,
0.14447320997714996,
-0.03407459333539009,
-0.42424529790878296,
0.2851457893848419,
-0.33684247732162476,
0.12974411249160767,
0.13448244333267212,
-0.7233579158782959,
0.17141571640968323,
0.6151517629623413,
0.7157830595970154,
-0.024787353351712227,
-0.25711145997047424,
-0.2520935833454132,
0.25283804535865784,
-0.41121289134025574,
0.9143030047416687,
-0.26048144698143005,
-0.9329298138618469,
0.07136999815702438,
-0.2581004798412323,
0.3049705922603607,
-0.42358309030532837,
0.3837859332561493,
-0.25637713074684143,
0.7953733205795288,
-0.5789977312088013,
-0.06476066261529922,
-0.32806074619293213,
0.6273413896560669,
-0.6092718243598938,
1.0486435890197754,
0.09220506995916367,
-0.9073289632797241,
0.5663378238677979,
-0.7731621861457825,
-0.4807320535182953,
0.028541777282953262,
0.11847976595163345,
-0.34635040163993835,
0.4847134053707123,
0.46133217215538025,
0.7345360517501831,
-0.4086110591888428,
0.5762326717376709,
-0.2754391133785248,
-0.008245225995779037,
0.12052914500236511,
-0.08048919588327408,
0.29962286353111267,
0.3642703890800476,
-0.394431471824646,
-0.0839696004986763,
-0.3653504252433777,
0.05312284454703331,
-0.34745168685913086,
-0.3988752067089081,
-0.0986957773566246,
-0.06818795949220657,
-0.24981319904327393,
0.24965211749076843,
0.005065933335572481,
-0.38176289200782776,
0.3674841523170471,
-0.3964621424674988,
0.4994906187057495,
0.3700992166996002,
0.5662116408348083,
0.6562513113021851,
-0.4340629577636719,
0.6460626125335693,
0.1528269201517105,
0.08820783346891403,
-0.5115323662757874,
-0.2794768214225769,
-0.5366307497024536,
0.00434771878644824,
0.3282663822174072,
0.21737824380397797,
-0.4815826714038849,
0.6677141785621643,
-0.47576597332954407,
-0.3647092580795288,
-0.5152735114097595,
0.3343530297279358,
0.3541939854621887,
0.6246950626373291,
0.33818796277046204,
-0.05663702264428139,
-0.5243518352508545,
-0.7308419942855835,
-0.23477347195148468,
-0.38049212098121643,
-0.10107467323541641,
0.21520419418811798,
0.46287694573402405,
-0.6431968212127686,
1.0407418012619019,
-0.2275780588388443,
-0.13534635305404663,
-0.2933967411518097,
0.5445554852485657,
0.19427256286144257,
0.1124647706747055,
0.21819809079170227,
-0.487575501203537,
-0.3647977113723755,
-0.1384490430355072,
-0.9300848245620728,
-0.2993007302284241,
0.09153043478727341,
0.05123180150985718,
0.07927297800779343,
0.5092686414718628,
-0.8170766830444336,
-0.09411006420850754,
0.5250490307807922,
-0.01873582974076271,
0.5247120261192322,
0.07355739921331406,
0.46001848578453064,
-1.3757691383361816,
0.3481791615486145,
-0.29779908061027527,
-0.16960476338863373,
-0.3587786555290222,
-0.07212810963392258,
-0.11743349581956863,
-0.15182438492774963,
-0.28994742035865784,
0.30321282148361206,
-0.5151351690292358,
0.05220853164792061,
-0.38000911474227905,
0.3134912848472595,
0.4164823889732361,
0.012747421860694885,
-0.013100413605570793,
0.28963005542755127,
0.4399430751800537,
-0.8091976642608643,
0.19187545776367188,
0.14694984257221222,
-0.11550838500261307,
0.6140092015266418,
-0.6968601942062378,
-0.33331575989723206,
-0.4691362679004669,
0.6969485282897949,
-0.9975090622901917,
-0.6511513590812683,
0.022632787004113197,
-0.4675098657608032,
0.1322985142469406,
0.27519282698631287,
-0.3541678488254547,
-0.7062742114067078,
-0.7258893847465515,
0.061084210872650146,
0.5113559365272522,
-0.5255112648010254,
0.837786078453064,
-0.049785371869802475,
-0.5281552672386169,
-0.7475556135177612,
-0.6653845310211182,
0.2574719488620758,
-0.20850494503974915,
-0.6665436029434204,
0.36487990617752075,
0.004831983707845211,
-0.3809903860092163,
0.29721537232398987,
0.10588090866804123,
0.7157425284385681,
-0.2360982447862625,
0.1919931322336197,
0.08903896063566208,
-0.17265751957893372,
0.07313099503517151,
0.38830745220184326,
0.03460303694009781,
0.3584257960319519,
-0.3797348141670227,
0.3228098452091217,
-0.13954153656959534,
-0.11245354264974594,
-0.1388024538755417,
0.5303252339363098,
0.8547020554542542,
0.030353320762515068,
0.3199712336063385,
0.5054833292961121,
-0.13234299421310425,
-0.3562057912349701,
-0.5976752638816833,
-0.5128138065338135,
-0.3914765417575836,
-0.1034846231341362,
0.022817037999629974,
-0.7834811806678772,
0.24456340074539185,
-0.2351134866476059,
0.3196844458580017,
0.6278888583183289,
0.717965304851532,
-0.4570457339286804,
1.2826056480407715,
0.4134976863861084,
-0.10036617517471313,
0.009069966152310371,
-0.40008148550987244,
0.1286773830652237,
-0.8438979387283325,
-0.3404057025909424,
-0.33416253328323364,
-0.41215232014656067,
-0.2855954170227051,
-0.34602612257003784,
0.5737586617469788,
0.15180493891239166,
0.2264900952577591,
-0.16948100924491882,
-0.691794753074646,
0.5997334718704224,
0.3341241180896759,
0.012850976549088955,
0.07186521589756012,
0.058483436703681946,
-0.24488650262355804,
0.3289894461631775,
-0.6554881930351257,
-0.8393065929412842,
0.9079618453979492,
0.0685618594288826,
0.5046453475952148,
-0.10910643637180328,
1.1643069982528687,
0.357572078704834,
0.6368203163146973,
-0.6089836955070496,
0.6169870495796204,
0.14252768456935883,
-0.3701132833957672,
-0.05190185829997063,
-0.5109683275222778,
-0.5818812847137451,
0.21338267624378204,
-0.4032125174999237,
0.2653059959411621,
0.05489173159003258,
0.2790837287902832,
-0.6328751444816589,
0.010705137625336647,
-0.4195840358734131,
0.3211061358451843,
0.04094348102807999,
-0.2848219871520996,
-0.2929523289203644,
-0.6586893200874329,
0.8649186491966248,
0.0948457419872284,
0.3926716148853302,
0.21596786379814148,
0.004320298321545124,
0.4605269432067871,
-0.4878644645214081,
1.0833574533462524,
-0.38798823952674866,
-0.2136007845401764,
0.5512133836746216,
0.35890230536460876,
0.31057316064834595,
0.3259914815425873,
0.02324904315173626,
-0.34609106183052063,
-0.29147082567214966,
-0.09595733135938644,
-0.6495909690856934,
0.6195822954177856,
-0.44779476523399353,
-0.49069449305534363,
-0.20657354593276978,
-0.09887167066335678,
-0.18867924809455872,
0.14445239305496216,
0.6842700839042664,
0.2705695927143097,
-0.27342602610588074,
0.23756948113441467,
0.7554317116737366,
-0.016918275505304337,
0.35716333985328674,
0.20817746222019196,
-0.4495246112346649,
-0.9552239775657654,
0.6617517471313477,
-0.26959097385406494,
0.11599206924438477,
0.15723924338817596,
0.4132246971130371,
-0.2153167873620987,
-0.17235100269317627,
-0.2913419306278229,
0.27489855885505676,
-0.6388890147209167,
-0.6486762762069702,
-0.7468344569206238,
0.03640110790729523,
-0.6018789410591125,
-0.31309774518013,
0.07931437343358994,
-0.38839641213417053,
-0.37167197465896606,
-0.46468496322631836,
0.0747312679886818,
1.2156102657318115,
-0.1678658276796341,
0.3663902282714844,
-1.1209863424301147,
0.24996192753314972,
0.546275794506073,
0.04251331090927124,
-0.020211201161146164,
-0.12298586964607239,
-0.06077764555811882,
-0.06086484342813492,
-0.4896518290042877,
-0.8784250020980835,
0.4195673167705536,
0.29281651973724365,
0.2610320448875427,
0.6168822646141052,
-0.19629822671413422,
0.39011529088020325,
-0.3724026083946228,
1.3831509351730347,
0.5046020150184631,
-0.9186134934425354,
0.6547970175743103,
-0.5641753673553467,
0.38974529504776,
0.6953686475753784,
0.35520583391189575,
-0.3569859564304352,
-0.6072121262550354,
-0.763729989528656,
-0.7773425579071045,
0.32684335112571716,
-0.19496893882751465,
0.15726621448993683,
-0.259669691324234,
0.4234920144081116,
0.154497891664505,
0.48175179958343506,
-0.8111587762832642,
0.2953430712223053,
-0.5509961843490601,
-0.3031149208545685,
-0.19341906905174255,
-0.4831193685531616,
-0.5423271656036377,
0.27558356523513794,
0.6152776479721069,
-0.38843539357185364,
0.17829200625419617,
0.2973160147666931,
-0.037920691072940826,
-0.3975343406200409,
0.3470040261745453,
0.86463862657547,
0.19314435124397278,
-0.09756506234407425,
0.3035944402217865,
0.13456787168979645,
-0.1469743549823761,
0.06746477633714676,
-0.5632463097572327,
-0.2966693341732025,
0.08002258837223053,
0.4316510856151581,
0.39933452010154724,
0.22208023071289062,
-0.12951426208019257,
0.596244215965271,
-0.06896013021469116,
-0.9004833698272705,
0.17881326377391815,
0.051483143121004105,
0.19517414271831512,
-0.04462986811995506,
0.3349429965019226,
0.23560017347335815,
0.3286420702934265,
-0.395751953125,
-0.005605233367532492,
0.6226580142974854,
-0.051577500998973846,
-0.5036798715591431,
0.3411116898059845,
0.6131792664527893,
-0.026563888415694237,
0.24734371900558472,
-0.19215127825737,
-0.7218304872512817,
0.24964511394500732,
0.33387163281440735,
1.0798498392105103,
-0.07550545781850815,
0.5665498971939087,
0.7004753947257996,
0.2593572437763214,
-0.4483087956905365,
0.460806667804718,
-0.3978675305843353,
-0.4053899347782135,
-0.6113606095314026,
-0.8021771311759949,
-0.658331036567688,
-0.27367526292800903,
-0.7198269367218018,
0.4035685956478119,
-0.3174813389778137,
-0.5633907318115234,
-0.3213929235935211,
-0.20977282524108887,
-0.28364577889442444,
0.2654711604118347,
0.20104911923408508,
0.8071268796920776,
-0.9417639374732971,
0.05962957814335823,
0.5692393779754639,
-0.35021549463272095,
-0.6833011507987976,
-0.0948028564453125,
-0.07639457285404205,
-0.1843796968460083,
0.6033952832221985,
0.2819696068763733,
-0.5906335115432739,
-0.17814500629901886,
-0.6883060932159424,
-0.46061772108078003,
1.26869797706604,
0.05388732999563217,
-0.3162062466144562,
-0.13341613113880157,
0.035265129059553146,
0.7646793723106384,
-0.6526542901992798,
0.18129220604896545,
0.3443681299686432,
0.7337931990623474,
0.043016232550144196,
-0.36125215888023376,
-0.01744743436574936,
-0.41153261065483093,
-0.21243730187416077,
0.013816735707223415,
-0.5898002982139587,
0.67704176902771,
-0.3165413439273834,
-0.18370191752910614,
-0.23820681869983673,
0.5181897878646851,
0.43017300963401794,
0.342183381319046,
0.45164754986763,
0.4530414938926697,
0.7448124885559082,
-0.08307354152202606,
0.9370445609092712,
-0.6287359595298767,
0.138410747051239,
0.745149552822113,
-0.3516084849834442,
0.6933438181877136,
0.6391910314559937,
0.11970488727092743,
0.9103375673294067,
0.5174244046211243,
-0.07680796086788177,
0.375881552696228,
-0.01820952631533146,
-0.33334729075431824,
-0.15121087431907654,
0.04921630024909973,
-0.4556190073490143,
0.059440918266773224,
0.36787545680999756,
-0.6361331939697266,
-0.13058699667453766,
-0.05435049906373024,
-0.1388079971075058,
-0.07526988536119461,
-0.4148821234703064,
1.1307011842727661,
0.18228451907634735,
-1.286769986152649,
0.36419954895973206,
-0.08610956370830536,
0.5821718573570251,
-0.5681073665618896,
0.15585970878601074,
-0.32765352725982666,
-0.23540489375591278,
-0.7207037806510925,
-0.7718580365180969,
0.17285554111003876,
0.21913191676139832,
-0.560910165309906,
-0.6448361873626709,
0.406311571598053,
-0.4556228816509247,
-0.44294798374176025,
0.07127021998167038,
0.459568589925766,
-0.018642419949173927,
0.3765665292739868,
-0.2886495292186737,
-0.2602052688598633,
-0.08181476593017578,
-0.46707284450531006,
0.12063351273536682,
0.4496678411960602,
0.1425214260816574,
0.32033684849739075,
0.8457071781158447,
0.35362669825553894,
-0.17228244245052338,
0.30510687828063965,
0.791322648525238,
-0.6298909783363342,
-0.4719386100769043,
-0.9498934745788574,
0.7031928300857544,
-0.10921596735715866,
-0.08618783950805664,
0.7551186084747314,
0.479276567697525,
0.1823311597108841,
-0.3039209246635437,
1.1280794143676758,
0.02823236957192421,
0.4784451723098755,
-0.506153404712677,
0.6644220352172852,
-0.5909222364425659,
0.18024738132953644,
-0.36495423316955566,
-1.1525086164474487,
-0.5613630414009094,
0.2912788689136505,
0.06009401008486748,
0.13690370321273804,
0.75082927942276,
0.8182075023651123,
0.11298944801092148,
0.08469527214765549,
0.02448657900094986,
-0.05843789502978325,
0.276074081659317,
0.1634099781513214,
0.9578653573989868,
-0.08737137913703918,
0.49144676327705383,
0.21947802603244781,
-0.16213124990463257,
-0.4253576099872589,
-1.367334246635437,
-0.8675493001937866,
-0.2593957483768463,
-0.005761335603892803,
-0.6024681925773621,
-0.48015737533569336,
0.8864433765411377,
0.4814645051956177,
-0.6807542443275452,
-0.04087687283754349,
-0.3430635929107666,
-0.087613545358181,
-0.10157706588506699,
-0.24520675837993622,
0.028434865176677704,
-0.7129520773887634,
-0.5486500263214111,
0.3979808986186981,
0.3638533651828766,
0.07801131904125214,
-0.7734794616699219,
-0.23243623971939087,
0.5445433259010315,
0.2916184067726135,
0.6983140707015991,
-0.03862922638654709,
-0.6562080979347229,
0.13530398905277252,
0.22391632199287415,
-0.2061934769153595,
-0.2125476896762848,
1.2281183004379272,
-0.7253993153572083,
0.36573028564453125,
0.7858858108520508,
0.19371230900287628,
0.18677443265914917,
0.3222236931324005,
0.8263742327690125,
-0.7949956655502319,
-0.48835426568984985,
0.34181955456733704,
0.29071637988090515,
0.5359472632408142,
-0.21428684890270233,
0.38246604800224304,
0.030993113294243813,
-0.5048186779022217,
-1.1291835308074951,
0.12997938692569733,
-0.7924194931983948,
0.04266888648271561,
1.2508028745651245,
0.2964244782924652,
-0.25209304690361023,
0.38261717557907104,
-0.27289730310440063,
-0.08233396708965302,
-0.26742348074913025,
0.8160873651504517,
0.6838430762290955,
-0.1430394947528839,
0.14484894275665283,
0.10334671288728714,
0.6821380257606506,
0.36595842242240906,
-0.8814053535461426,
0.38045546412467957,
0.5456311106681824,
0.24821625649929047,
0.5891978144645691,
0.5364914536476135,
-0.3546142280101776,
0.5323765277862549,
-0.23531432449817657,
0.23609821498394012,
-0.13269507884979248,
-0.47559836506843567,
-0.5709125399589539,
0.4242400825023651,
-0.10207678377628326,
0.6219486594200134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17985v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17985v1
|
FlattenQuant: Breaking Through the Inference Compute-bound for Large Language Models with Per-tensor Quantization
| 2024-02-28T02:00:34 | 2024-02-28T02:00:34 |
Yi Zhang, Fei Yang, Shuang Peng, Fangyu Wang, Aimin Pan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated state-of-the-art performance
across various tasks. However, the latency of inference and the large GPU
memory consumption of LLMs restrict their deployment performance. Recently,
there have been some efficient attempts to quantize LLMs, yet inference with
large batch size or long sequence still has the issue of being compute-bound.
Fine-grained quantization methods have showcased their proficiency in achieving
low-bit quantization for LLMs, while requiring FP16 data type for linear layer
computations, which is time-consuming when dealing with large batch size or
long sequence. In this paper, we introduce a method called FlattenQuant, which
significantly reduces the maximum value of the tensor by flattening the large
channels in the tensor, to achieve low bit per-tensor quantization with minimal
accuracy loss. Our experiments show that FlattenQuant can directly use 4 bits
to achieve 48.29% of the linear layer calculation in LLMs, with the remaining
layers using 8 bits. The 4-bit matrix multiplication introduced in the
FlattenQuant method can effectively address the compute-bound caused by large
matrix calculation. Our work achieves up to 2$\times$ speedup and 2.3$\times$
memory reduction for LLMs with negligible loss in accuracy.
|
[
-0.3863967955112457,
-0.8998445272445679,
0.6989636421203613,
0.20383399724960327,
-0.27026525139808655,
0.14652958512306213,
-0.6058534383773804,
-0.09269564598798752,
-0.04999321326613426,
0.5748308897018433,
-0.3876360058784485,
-0.6409052014350891,
-0.33929508924484253,
-0.3086012899875641,
-0.3179290294647217,
0.7048566341400146,
-0.012051406316459179,
-0.09877186268568039,
-0.20315593481063843,
0.1630687713623047,
-0.002451931592077017,
-0.6013966798782349,
-0.5939100980758667,
-0.40388190746307373,
0.28638145327568054,
0.4691830277442932,
0.7790806889533997,
0.6789254546165466,
0.4375929832458496,
0.3395411968231201,
-0.24486759305000305,
-0.05167881026864052,
-0.569344699382782,
0.08312331885099411,
0.19451786577701569,
-0.8151302933692932,
-0.6309751868247986,
-0.14813919365406036,
0.8668502569198608,
0.7805474996566772,
-0.32755810022354126,
0.22879914939403534,
-0.08777280151844025,
0.5851080417633057,
-0.9636609554290771,
0.03676411882042885,
-0.43726423382759094,
0.37923675775527954,
-0.3419492840766907,
-0.10066737234592438,
-0.34166431427001953,
-0.1801203042268753,
-0.2772093713283539,
-0.49530529975891113,
0.44195231795310974,
-0.312051385641098,
0.7065824866294861,
0.4147467613220215,
-0.11572679132223129,
0.4234989583492279,
-0.765415370464325,
0.9872157573699951,
-0.9901144504547119,
0.49042809009552,
0.2978922128677368,
0.07237547636032104,
-0.1017363891005516,
-0.8503097295761108,
-0.5056414604187012,
0.004827790893614292,
0.1917271912097931,
-0.2155849188566208,
-0.2302251160144806,
0.4286689758300781,
0.39037811756134033,
0.7510926723480225,
-0.4144124388694763,
0.10300951451063156,
-0.21322591602802277,
-0.16283255815505981,
0.4397019147872925,
0.05790694057941437,
-0.10682845860719681,
-0.17228220403194427,
-0.34839704632759094,
-0.020948586985468864,
-0.8072308897972107,
-0.10027292370796204,
0.18067963421344757,
0.07269559800624847,
-0.06658772379159927,
0.5325749516487122,
-0.24406132102012634,
0.40773752331733704,
0.006443087011575699,
-0.19991466403007507,
0.028906583786010742,
0.07418154180049896,
-0.6268647909164429,
0.06556382775306702,
0.8718783855438232,
0.04352554678916931,
0.229696124792099,
-0.18344050645828247,
-0.3857917785644531,
0.07239101827144623,
0.04554435983300209,
-1.181130290031433,
-0.3262593746185303,
0.36465832591056824,
-0.20944051444530487,
-0.014736929908394814,
-0.32695499062538147,
-0.5593948364257812,
-0.3161737620830536,
-0.2151528298854828,
0.31700897216796875,
-0.47998300194740295,
0.06110072880983353,
0.20038801431655884,
0.2805781662464142,
0.0438925139605999,
0.4080781042575836,
-0.7502833008766174,
0.4253897964954376,
0.8995051980018616,
0.9080309867858887,
0.007082286290824413,
-0.04985193535685539,
-0.6400795578956604,
0.13370539247989655,
-0.21752521395683289,
0.503490686416626,
-0.25040289759635925,
-0.08382488787174225,
-0.18414539098739624,
-0.39089325070381165,
0.2815975248813629,
-0.40389901399612427,
0.5042282342910767,
-0.5782700777053833,
-0.0776299387216568,
0.14265410602092743,
-0.5515885949134827,
-0.08065515011548996,
0.24384941160678864,
-0.6959041953086853,
0.7028935551643372,
-0.19976550340652466,
-0.5395601987838745,
-0.09309499710798264,
-0.4504251480102539,
-0.4348295032978058,
0.16771095991134644,
-0.1391659677028656,
-0.5561417937278748,
0.36029624938964844,
0.41653233766555786,
0.7082783579826355,
-0.5038681030273438,
0.0766262412071228,
-0.5616256594657898,
-0.6114763617515564,
0.12729451060295105,
-0.7967614531517029,
0.7007887959480286,
0.3722369074821472,
-0.38808995485305786,
-0.08463048189878464,
-0.6531488299369812,
0.24378471076488495,
0.01664264313876629,
-0.4339247941970825,
-0.3483103811740875,
-0.2820446491241455,
0.1548132300376892,
-0.18025609850883484,
0.20416536927223206,
-0.627041757106781,
0.3400382995605469,
-0.19012810289859772,
0.6734898090362549,
0.8393141627311707,
-0.47100916504859924,
0.45106855034828186,
0.06028885766863823,
0.6682632565498352,
-0.17229042947292328,
0.24106235802173615,
0.020464126020669937,
-0.13648657500743866,
-0.7981681823730469,
-0.7751734256744385,
0.5339257717132568,
0.3362639248371124,
-0.6715182662010193,
0.19242289662361145,
-0.439593642950058,
-0.3885468542575836,
-0.5612893104553223,
0.04636991396546364,
0.6022211313247681,
0.10060720890760422,
0.45332133769989014,
-0.2408723086118698,
-0.37490925192832947,
-0.725352942943573,
-0.13935957849025726,
0.14701181650161743,
-0.33055824041366577,
-0.10616768896579742,
0.1930534541606903,
-0.1389571875333786,
0.5753486752510071,
-0.7627139687538147,
-0.20477920770645142,
0.15705756843090057,
0.08358035981655121,
0.22042927145957947,
0.6159982085227966,
0.05315577611327171,
-0.6585512161254883,
-0.11776814609766006,
-0.19082331657409668,
-0.4568440914154053,
-0.024876868352293968,
0.12168274819850922,
0.06652011722326279,
0.46558499336242676,
0.5451611280441284,
-0.7659774422645569,
0.6009288430213928,
0.940845787525177,
-0.34508854150772095,
0.3499249815940857,
-0.22790972888469696,
0.038934364914894104,
-0.8780778050422668,
-0.03675169497728348,
0.0692724734544754,
-0.6050348281860352,
-0.4480678141117096,
0.08341208100318909,
0.17190326750278473,
0.04879697784781456,
-0.32241198420524597,
0.33744555711746216,
-0.5232521891593933,
-0.1541445106267929,
0.132110133767128,
-0.10221794992685318,
0.33259618282318115,
0.401523619890213,
-0.09550641477108002,
0.7378995418548584,
0.20131973922252655,
-0.4384489953517914,
0.35197341442108154,
0.1171642541885376,
-0.4237785041332245,
0.5401440858840942,
-0.5057805776596069,
0.22571350634098053,
0.1253620833158493,
0.502284586429596,
-0.8364967107772827,
0.1355287879705429,
-0.27615582942962646,
-0.15881700813770294,
0.4203064739704132,
-0.3294292986392975,
-0.5227896571159363,
0.04761257395148277,
-0.4857116937637329,
0.7133209109306335,
0.4610897898674011,
-0.6391177773475647,
0.6449747085571289,
0.2028808891773224,
-0.06973889470100403,
-0.7880486845970154,
-1.1398831605911255,
0.19242820143699646,
-0.19880154728889465,
-0.732921838760376,
0.6606118083000183,
-0.11310391128063202,
-0.12469426542520523,
-0.060622021555900574,
-0.2579573690891266,
-0.07025019824504852,
-0.027338782325387,
0.17227938771247864,
0.17704245448112488,
-0.46124207973480225,
-0.10297730565071106,
0.07659325748682022,
-0.021398721262812614,
0.04265281930565834,
-0.3653680682182312,
0.8107708692550659,
-0.6119692921638489,
-0.2792814075946808,
-0.440350204706192,
0.2785751223564148,
0.5244797468185425,
-0.23808154463768005,
0.6721582412719727,
0.7042309045791626,
-0.28127044439315796,
-0.34312987327575684,
-0.8427389860153198,
-0.17590606212615967,
-0.4604615867137909,
0.37174010276794434,
-0.7529289126396179,
-1.216396689414978,
0.5408652424812317,
-0.000295023201033473,
-0.226566880941391,
0.18114985525608063,
0.5755774974822998,
0.1252315193414688,
0.8023296594619751,
0.4480334222316742,
-0.02581319771707058,
0.3678441643714905,
-0.6258100867271423,
0.17874528467655182,
-0.9066095948219299,
-0.11596012860536575,
-0.4326830804347992,
-0.3123714327812195,
-0.6960000991821289,
-0.7393559813499451,
0.3542053699493408,
0.2504688799381256,
-0.5085874795913696,
-0.02264220453798771,
-0.3513266146183014,
0.5057018995285034,
0.49600300192832947,
0.15979665517807007,
0.6456946730613708,
0.2000064253807068,
-0.05781017988920212,
0.23103661835193634,
-0.7210559844970703,
-0.2311791479587555,
0.9367005825042725,
0.4694201648235321,
1.1323429346084595,
0.35563531517982483,
0.6902264356613159,
0.07962813973426819,
0.19804641604423523,
-0.8806411623954773,
0.6270961165428162,
-0.4654160737991333,
-0.3139989972114563,
-0.3899711072444916,
-0.9336420893669128,
-0.8367171883583069,
0.24670633673667908,
-0.008570496924221516,
-0.632927656173706,
-0.017911115661263466,
0.10391059517860413,
-0.4492732882499695,
0.665928304195404,
-0.7139000296592712,
0.6523541212081909,
0.12067216634750366,
-0.42513832449913025,
-0.22241590917110443,
-0.4186207056045532,
0.5493046045303345,
0.01093471609055996,
0.13069215416908264,
-0.160279780626297,
-0.1755674034357071,
0.5836592316627502,
-0.8178316354751587,
0.6640679836273193,
-0.002113850088790059,
-0.3588056266307831,
-0.15950579941272736,
0.17963680624961853,
0.3612182140350342,
0.2866332232952118,
0.003847968066111207,
0.5308282971382141,
0.3180815279483795,
-0.7452748417854309,
-0.5463154911994934,
0.9222827553749084,
-0.768437922000885,
-0.45066848397254944,
-0.2625030279159546,
-0.7571247816085815,
-0.2701411247253418,
0.11631085723638535,
0.17094220221042633,
0.40527278184890747,
0.014911097474396229,
0.22181709110736847,
0.8353413343429565,
-0.09734296798706055,
0.5297043919563293,
0.14015650749206543,
-0.1841944456100464,
-0.5351064205169678,
0.6150875687599182,
-0.020663000643253326,
0.4608273506164551,
0.5560433268547058,
0.30906006693840027,
-0.27137458324432373,
-0.5912100672721863,
-0.19730551540851593,
0.2751978635787964,
-0.5906944274902344,
-0.450243204832077,
-0.27841928601264954,
-0.23188167810440063,
-0.43559372425079346,
-0.17798006534576416,
-0.7623051404953003,
-0.6872348785400391,
-0.09454317390918732,
0.24678416550159454,
0.43458735942840576,
0.26753827929496765,
-0.0846993550658226,
0.40696558356285095,
-0.7538074851036072,
0.3434801399707794,
0.24260932207107544,
0.6469479203224182,
-0.012333485297858715,
-0.490766316652298,
-0.22614364326000214,
-0.11604408174753189,
-0.09124097973108292,
-0.25885578989982605,
0.3038715422153473,
0.09631075710058212,
-0.019905023276805878,
0.41593486070632935,
0.08697690069675446,
0.9802529215812683,
-0.39507317543029785,
0.5442530512809753,
0.23042666912078857,
-1.3313746452331543,
-0.08525041490793228,
-0.13750514388084412,
0.5529381036758423,
0.40342381596565247,
0.17555542290210724,
-0.39518073201179504,
-0.30377697944641113,
-0.6417034864425659,
-0.9637224078178406,
0.48514533042907715,
0.22553057968616486,
0.1124054566025734,
0.37138062715530396,
0.40321218967437744,
-0.28505679965019226,
0.24175454676151276,
-0.37301480770111084,
-0.3392985761165619,
0.05825383588671684,
-0.150198295712471,
-0.127093106508255,
-0.35248395800590515,
0.010134597308933735,
-0.36500468850135803,
0.6381726264953613,
-0.18709032237529755,
0.2791476547718048,
0.132746160030365,
-0.019933799281716347,
-0.09148509800434113,
0.4283064603805542,
0.4986063838005066,
0.6261313557624817,
-0.4346592426300049,
0.592277467250824,
0.1574186533689499,
-0.8387576937675476,
0.08635169267654419,
0.4507693648338318,
-0.22273214161396027,
-0.20154911279678345,
0.19886301457881927,
0.7639675140380859,
0.09341128915548325,
-0.46314114332199097,
0.3907672166824341,
-0.21352523565292358,
0.012137776240706444,
-0.33951324224472046,
-0.13398069143295288,
0.08497612178325653,
0.4742186665534973,
0.2732005715370178,
-0.18121132254600525,
-0.04310564324259758,
-0.3043019771575928,
0.13851425051689148,
0.5211327075958252,
-0.1693563610315323,
-0.13329288363456726,
0.5779158473014832,
0.04625491052865982,
-0.04049515724182129,
0.6816651821136475,
0.10629689693450928,
-0.43865352869033813,
0.2491111159324646,
0.3773382008075714,
0.815055787563324,
-0.3885323107242584,
-0.15518604218959808,
-0.03349241614341736,
0.06440342962741852,
-0.07823485136032104,
0.20628100633621216,
-0.001599281677044928,
-0.732006847858429,
-1.2392942905426025,
-0.7685863375663757,
-0.4232039749622345,
0.5635110139846802,
-0.6713664531707764,
0.06275108456611633,
-0.6456140875816345,
-0.23840083181858063,
0.14958137273788452,
0.2839829921722412,
-0.5358264446258545,
0.23834948241710663,
0.4360470771789551,
0.7525454759597778,
-0.3506369888782501,
0.9396885633468628,
0.5503779053688049,
-0.24855761229991913,
-0.8951933979988098,
-0.056413259357213974,
-0.13861045241355896,
-0.6573315262794495,
0.44879722595214844,
-0.009273272007703781,
-0.21698355674743652,
0.20673485100269318,
-0.6218454241752625,
-0.639171302318573,
0.949471116065979,
0.8844758868217468,
-0.6379798054695129,
-0.08213938027620316,
0.25727519392967224,
0.12267900258302689,
0.020181311294436455,
0.3435894548892975,
0.7907684445381165,
0.43522578477859497,
0.2801268994808197,
-0.865058958530426,
0.31482765078544617,
0.026183372363448143,
0.19982598721981049,
0.5150460004806519,
-0.6027317047119141,
1.0978124141693115,
-0.16432778537273407,
0.0690879300236702,
0.09350382536649704,
0.7082968354225159,
0.37640100717544556,
0.014311673119664192,
0.5278090238571167,
0.8467110395431519,
0.7543751001358032,
-0.03745304048061371,
1.0982086658477783,
-0.0470338799059391,
0.7169082760810852,
0.8639287352561951,
0.0046814559027552605,
0.9223164319992065,
0.7636333703994751,
-0.34874752163887024,
0.44118407368659973,
0.31962916254997253,
0.21350271999835968,
0.14998264610767365,
0.6137701869010925,
-0.5184702277183533,
-0.40267401933670044,
0.08183540403842926,
-0.04788244515657425,
0.40090152621269226,
0.25121957063674927,
0.020258544012904167,
-0.10572657734155655,
-0.22249674797058105,
0.6546462774276733,
-0.07652618736028671,
-0.4866025745868683,
0.22031594812870026,
0.30243980884552,
-0.5112496018409729,
1.205963134765625,
0.2461249828338623,
0.8479961156845093,
-0.3862324059009552,
-0.0716586783528328,
-0.40154969692230225,
0.6591820120811462,
-0.45501410961151123,
-0.5770392417907715,
0.0859060287475586,
0.051518335938453674,
-0.09551474452018738,
-0.2049933224916458,
0.4341678023338318,
-0.4954075515270233,
-0.4988483488559723,
0.01590781658887863,
0.13416366279125214,
0.11720430850982666,
-0.5501882433891296,
-0.44814181327819824,
0.2899326980113983,
0.038814254105091095,
-0.6570195555686951,
0.45853346586227417,
0.5353179574012756,
-0.10450754314661026,
0.5905168056488037,
0.735905110836029,
0.332033634185791,
0.10831701010465622,
0.0552482083439827,
0.8278291821479797,
-0.6915695667266846,
-0.16518448293209076,
-0.8584040999412537,
0.3665657937526703,
0.11501095443964005,
-0.0726277306675911,
0.5197319388389587,
0.658058762550354,
0.7368411421775818,
0.032339487224817276,
0.5289222598075867,
0.14392350614070892,
0.018696501851081848,
-0.8266904950141907,
0.7117819786071777,
-0.5277637243270874,
0.5662455558776855,
-0.10154150426387787,
-0.9637702703475952,
-0.5509623885154724,
0.64127516746521,
-0.3810681700706482,
0.046599823981523514,
0.8059973120689392,
0.6272987723350525,
-0.23798193037509918,
-0.13711725175380707,
0.48579543828964233,
0.4336265027523041,
0.4664878845214844,
0.6958053708076477,
0.5771614909172058,
-0.4178606867790222,
0.5826776027679443,
-0.6338878870010376,
-0.22149156033992767,
-0.12409330904483795,
-1.0251628160476685,
-0.7835515737533569,
-0.2887822687625885,
-0.39562076330184937,
-0.5717694759368896,
-0.06440183520317078,
0.7087900042533875,
0.8415769934654236,
-0.6260252594947815,
-0.2770894467830658,
-0.13014677166938782,
0.14837801456451416,
-0.015259752050042152,
-0.2621053457260132,
0.6917020678520203,
-0.27400562167167664,
-0.8863307237625122,
0.24130631983280182,
0.1504790037870407,
-0.2546434700489044,
-0.5776888132095337,
-0.013525313697755337,
-0.15249255299568176,
0.06521160155534744,
0.675449788570404,
0.18089470267295837,
-0.6205752491950989,
-0.2014356553554535,
-0.29940134286880493,
-0.11530324071645737,
0.1475498229265213,
0.7746555209159851,
-0.853905975818634,
0.1235935315489769,
0.43587633967399597,
0.7144317030906677,
1.146066427230835,
0.018021468073129654,
0.459549218416214,
-0.9306716918945312,
0.3578205406665802,
0.4079514145851135,
0.26527851819992065,
0.4821655750274658,
-0.3642338216304779,
0.4825775921344757,
0.1783391535282135,
-0.532621443271637,
-0.9254702925682068,
0.12193526327610016,
-1.038597583770752,
-0.2605622410774231,
1.3307435512542725,
-0.21949154138565063,
-0.5618826746940613,
0.25355467200279236,
0.23508287966251373,
0.25644633173942566,
-0.47877076268196106,
0.5609497427940369,
0.229545459151268,
-0.04210121929645538,
-0.3778817355632782,
-0.6264693140983582,
0.4030889868736267,
0.6570584774017334,
-0.6564611196517944,
0.08670834451913834,
0.4431108236312866,
0.34901416301727295,
0.16190944612026215,
0.3464028239250183,
-0.04092353209853172,
-0.11898981034755707,
-0.23812457919120789,
0.6201995611190796,
-0.1887548267841339,
-0.014088665135204792,
-0.4411228597164154,
0.26773831248283386,
0.14398455619812012,
-0.1029835194349289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17983v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17983v2
|
M3-VRD: Multimodal Multi-task Multi-teacher Visually-Rich Form Document Understanding
| 2024-02-28T01:56:00 | 2024-05-20T01:49:47 |
Yihao Ding, Lorenzo Vaiani, Caren Han, Jean Lee, Paolo Garza, Josiah Poon, Luca Cagliero
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
This paper presents a groundbreaking multimodal, multi-task, multi-teacher
joint-grained knowledge distillation model for visually-rich form document
understanding. The model is designed to leverage insights from both
fine-grained and coarse-grained levels by facilitating a nuanced correlation
between token and entity representations, addressing the complexities inherent
in form documents. Additionally, we introduce new inter-grained and
cross-grained loss functions to further refine diverse multi-teacher knowledge
distillation transfer process, presenting distribution gaps and a harmonised
understanding of form documents. Through a comprehensive evaluation across
publicly available form document understanding datasets, our proposed model
consistently outperforms existing baselines, showcasing its efficacy in
handling the intricate structures and content of visually complex form
documents.
|
[
-0.4179859459400177,
-0.8216091394424438,
0.6872330904006958,
0.16346155107021332,
-0.2682017385959625,
0.0651809498667717,
0.0299697108566761,
-0.22407852113246918,
-0.3748733699321747,
0.32309862971305847,
-0.6180828809738159,
-0.4497694969177246,
-1.143308162689209,
-0.21488057076931,
-0.41017407178878784,
0.7658823132514954,
-0.349282443523407,
0.3760843575000763,
-0.7004364728927612,
0.07971954345703125,
-0.5353915691375732,
-0.4249867796897888,
-0.30692094564437866,
-0.34350308775901794,
0.5032016038894653,
0.45405814051628113,
0.38276898860931396,
0.2835603654384613,
0.6502411365509033,
0.28427550196647644,
-0.21822011470794678,
0.23865525424480438,
-0.5725250840187073,
0.14027023315429688,
-0.2498141974210739,
-0.6353541016578674,
-0.4868120551109314,
-0.06539507955312729,
0.5367833375930786,
0.7155244946479797,
-0.09356618672609329,
0.22835485637187958,
0.3545263409614563,
0.5621489882469177,
-0.90068119764328,
0.5905646085739136,
-0.42382997274398804,
0.25524213910102844,
-0.17101554572582245,
-0.18199796974658966,
-0.46571290493011475,
0.3306211829185486,
0.12391243129968643,
-0.9704770445823669,
0.44243624806404114,
-0.3937469720840454,
0.7622836828231812,
0.2522542476654053,
-0.6538090705871582,
-0.06046319007873535,
-0.7920119762420654,
0.32575884461402893,
-0.16149240732192993,
0.5647504925727844,
0.5023646354675293,
0.6447249054908752,
0.1363038420677185,
-1.0236924886703491,
-0.9769986867904663,
0.20716094970703125,
0.3230680227279663,
0.48280006647109985,
-0.09296220541000366,
0.17859157919883728,
0.01745566911995411,
0.6274646520614624,
-0.35352063179016113,
-0.014059239067137241,
-0.6717761754989624,
-0.10890801250934601,
0.16972069442272186,
0.1410062611103058,
0.3315434753894806,
-0.2513126730918884,
-0.7891151309013367,
-0.3914341926574707,
0.031627215445041656,
0.07875319570302963,
0.05250975117087364,
0.07663104683160782,
-0.37174782156944275,
0.7675240635871887,
-0.10698391497135162,
0.8615753650665283,
-0.10246828198432922,
-0.4855843782424927,
-0.08931870013475418,
-0.47613608837127686,
-0.5363652110099792,
-0.14576119184494019,
0.44684460759162903,
0.5466490387916565,
0.0100953234359622,
0.01750313676893711,
-0.09455230832099915,
-0.007223065476864576,
0.2306443154811859,
-0.8842431902885437,
-0.22552859783172607,
-0.1386510282754898,
-0.5866844654083252,
-0.42098182439804077,
0.24980475008487701,
-0.6518405079841614,
-0.6251278519630432,
-0.8351994156837463,
0.8106591105461121,
-0.6896317005157471,
-0.24874337017536163,
0.3077850639820099,
-0.8389391899108887,
-0.08163532614707947,
1.0126579999923706,
-0.9545176029205322,
0.1993119865655899,
0.5440393090248108,
0.9235336780548096,
-0.028834179043769836,
-0.5057733058929443,
-0.36628368496894836,
0.6148639917373657,
0.08752543479204178,
0.8087140321731567,
-0.6161342859268188,
-0.5799359083175659,
-0.3887898623943329,
0.029917875304818153,
-0.0323110930621624,
-0.3626541495323181,
0.3586091995239258,
-0.19762811064720154,
0.26794466376304626,
-0.12173276394605637,
-0.30881720781326294,
-0.6037619709968567,
0.3300246000289917,
-0.8561267256736755,
0.8489245772361755,
0.4488772451877594,
-0.7412160038948059,
0.681926965713501,
-0.19999800622463226,
-0.11967155337333679,
-0.05267374590039253,
-0.3013593852519989,
-0.33153727650642395,
0.27497032284736633,
0.2589053809642792,
0.701816976070404,
-0.273722767829895,
0.31140175461769104,
-0.509232223033905,
0.03389012813568115,
-0.14344936609268188,
-0.9804858565330505,
0.6172816753387451,
0.24770966172218323,
-0.036538008600473404,
0.21994461119174957,
-1.1335629224777222,
-0.47801822423934937,
-0.14642269909381866,
-0.31274667382240295,
-0.3678146302700043,
-0.5059219002723694,
0.42100635170936584,
0.44465067982673645,
0.15655437111854553,
-0.2229640781879425,
0.2892692983150482,
0.40487754344940186,
0.37732598185539246,
0.7548624873161316,
-0.059352535754442215,
0.5598388910293579,
-0.3732617497444153,
0.6699908971786499,
0.5415316224098206,
0.2952935993671417,
-0.3822084367275238,
-0.4727790057659149,
-0.43948039412498474,
-0.6573101282119751,
0.012988256290555,
0.208443284034729,
-0.7564312815666199,
-0.06023142859339714,
-0.19538193941116333,
-0.5129482746124268,
-0.5895929932594299,
0.17472434043884277,
0.24655839800834656,
0.7435176372528076,
0.2827215790748596,
-0.46772968769073486,
-0.22828969359397888,
-0.7775187492370605,
0.3424243927001953,
-0.025313744321465492,
0.21737806499004364,
0.1252518743276596,
0.41792500019073486,
-0.4432711899280548,
0.8097981810569763,
-0.5572234392166138,
-0.6270707249641418,
-0.27167031168937683,
0.5159072279930115,
-0.3602197468280792,
0.382157564163208,
0.6085289120674133,
-1.0190176963806152,
-0.31389713287353516,
-0.005389086436480284,
-0.6741375923156738,
0.12591956555843353,
-0.24912481009960175,
-0.25791001319885254,
-0.19152480363845825,
0.5907543897628784,
-0.6738461852073669,
0.6322868466377258,
0.5618940591812134,
-0.5954561829566956,
0.42075875401496887,
-0.5071943402290344,
0.2567988932132721,
-1.2608215808868408,
-0.11675353348255157,
-0.014215790666639805,
-0.17787255346775055,
-0.2444794774055481,
0.004226048476994038,
0.3167971968650818,
-0.39162009954452515,
-0.4952174127101898,
0.4747990667819977,
-0.6871049404144287,
-0.11777066439390182,
0.04443204030394554,
0.14684192836284637,
0.7119584679603577,
0.3440287113189697,
0.03192877769470215,
0.5600807070732117,
0.7337099313735962,
-0.455509752035141,
0.41094276309013367,
0.22539663314819336,
-0.3215451240539551,
0.9852734804153442,
-0.3261222839355469,
-0.4277651011943817,
-0.7514898777008057,
0.23737619817256927,
-1.2730779647827148,
-0.1303141862154007,
-0.07278195768594742,
-0.3275294601917267,
0.5543569326400757,
-0.31000959873199463,
-0.3929842412471771,
-0.23465321958065033,
-0.33251047134399414,
0.26061102747917175,
-0.035844217985868454,
-0.3370162546634674,
0.9968947172164917,
0.27417245507240295,
-0.06529609113931656,
-0.4345342814922333,
-0.6835479140281677,
0.018871843814849854,
-0.03925300016999245,
-0.923454761505127,
0.6217826008796692,
0.03131485357880592,
-0.2278018742799759,
0.2130233347415924,
-0.2681747078895569,
-0.4158836901187897,
0.24380865693092346,
0.4838481545448303,
0.23360304534435272,
-0.27861136198043823,
0.13551950454711914,
0.23933526873588562,
-0.015146009624004364,
-0.1426635980606079,
0.01954040490090847,
0.3444989323616028,
0.24866987764835358,
-0.5640987157821655,
-0.6772627234458923,
0.3972248136997223,
1.2267191410064697,
-0.3059067130088806,
0.9092305302619934,
1.2236723899841309,
-0.4194290339946747,
-0.17962804436683655,
-0.44755083322525024,
0.056353859603405,
-0.38506367802619934,
0.4476372301578522,
-0.8895854353904724,
-0.6609036922454834,
0.5569235682487488,
-0.13749545812606812,
-0.193095862865448,
0.7114493250846863,
0.5969656705856323,
-0.1357170194387436,
0.5724170804023743,
0.9623496532440186,
0.36386850476264954,
0.6055862903594971,
-0.6045327186584473,
-0.19665299355983734,
-0.8202978372573853,
-0.9309887290000916,
-0.2800080180168152,
-0.20767498016357422,
0.0889480859041214,
-0.8899405598640442,
0.3439381420612335,
0.6807365417480469,
0.2886449694633484,
-0.10459859669208527,
-0.5223118662834167,
0.20591920614242554,
0.5898876786231995,
0.1710231602191925,
0.4627038836479187,
-0.10027872771024704,
-0.19705407321453094,
0.14869378507137299,
-0.4792255461215973,
-0.45408591628074646,
0.9875496029853821,
0.2466665655374527,
0.9560052752494812,
0.3683446943759918,
0.5426926016807556,
0.2988872528076172,
0.001330749480985105,
-0.7430803775787354,
0.22532965242862701,
-0.1342674344778061,
-0.3783332109451294,
-0.28223228454589844,
-0.07510998845100403,
-0.8134737014770508,
0.676506519317627,
-0.45191988348960876,
-0.4016886353492737,
0.2535562813282013,
-0.07073742151260376,
-0.352217435836792,
0.38472655415534973,
-1.4049171209335327,
1.301774263381958,
-0.03392493352293968,
-0.3301602602005005,
-0.23250997066497803,
-0.40142372250556946,
0.6760711073875427,
-0.02277987077832222,
0.352416455745697,
-0.1512448638677597,
0.13387487828731537,
0.6315259337425232,
-0.6021854281425476,
0.6613113880157471,
-0.2769377529621124,
-0.1856263279914856,
0.30049726366996765,
0.09186055511236191,
0.12200220674276352,
0.11987276375293732,
0.11997832357883453,
-0.19921092689037323,
0.24159109592437744,
-0.31122100353240967,
-0.8226334452629089,
0.5484163165092468,
-0.8349550366401672,
-0.45756468176841736,
-0.24107666313648224,
-0.4692709147930145,
0.11659523099660873,
0.2952643036842346,
0.07452097535133362,
0.8135417103767395,
-0.2548264265060425,
0.2629719376564026,
0.7327886819839478,
-0.03897102177143097,
0.3293588161468506,
0.39525747299194336,
-0.14450302720069885,
-0.10550118237733841,
0.8353763222694397,
0.2477152943611145,
0.35746073722839355,
0.5564284324645996,
0.0880565270781517,
-0.43248024582862854,
-0.5363624691963196,
-0.7013217806816101,
-0.1361585408449173,
-0.9775252342224121,
-0.12498916685581207,
-0.9056320786476135,
-0.05992013216018677,
-0.7430119514465332,
-0.18342113494873047,
-0.20758284628391266,
-0.5280153751373291,
-0.8148835897445679,
-0.3069734275341034,
0.3658369779586792,
1.0517910718917847,
-0.14411132037639618,
0.28925737738609314,
-0.8727805614471436,
0.9281622171401978,
0.6291334629058838,
0.47568279504776,
0.2453089952468872,
-0.6164258122444153,
-0.0869215726852417,
-0.14756911993026733,
-0.6513682007789612,
-0.8389778137207031,
0.3586280345916748,
0.2702154219150543,
0.6891254186630249,
0.5807980298995972,
-0.15639229118824005,
1.0700008869171143,
-0.3567946255207062,
0.691171407699585,
0.34467440843582153,
-0.802921712398529,
0.5094472169876099,
-0.24736502766609192,
0.39988353848457336,
0.5565283894538879,
0.4714539349079132,
-0.5103604793548584,
-0.11667586863040924,
-0.5523888468742371,
-0.9572203159332275,
0.8272103071212769,
-0.10306461900472641,
-0.07766739279031754,
0.3387987017631531,
-0.025215182453393936,
0.5789901614189148,
0.032888755202293396,
-0.4558054804801941,
-0.14911721646785736,
-0.510187566280365,
-0.40344053506851196,
-0.04502187296748161,
-0.42446961998939514,
-0.059411801397800446,
-0.39824461936950684,
0.2898704707622528,
0.1365744173526764,
0.04952172562479973,
0.16970115900039673,
-0.4188530147075653,
0.28838714957237244,
0.26043546199798584,
0.8257119059562683,
0.8166285753250122,
-0.3633224666118622,
0.7400544881820679,
-0.21791726350784302,
-0.8721612095832825,
0.09684491902589798,
0.3755802512168884,
0.34040960669517517,
-0.022182326763868332,
0.4117124080657959,
1.0402249097824097,
0.262521356344223,
-0.4138008654117584,
0.7776302099227905,
-0.3424285352230072,
-0.37916022539138794,
-0.04575179144740105,
-0.008505253121256828,
0.18062356114387512,
0.21927669644355774,
0.32067230343818665,
0.3542029559612274,
0.21755757927894592,
-0.7845514416694641,
0.32079383730888367,
0.14584980905056,
-0.4934430718421936,
-0.28019899129867554,
0.9621552228927612,
0.2858090400695801,
0.12251221388578415,
0.2950054705142975,
-0.08071985840797424,
-0.14753495156764984,
0.5215836763381958,
0.43165352940559387,
0.6705209016799927,
0.13707979023456573,
0.48374518752098083,
0.12311916798353195,
0.011755362153053284,
-0.0696382224559784,
0.31009575724601746,
-0.576741099357605,
-0.4171265661716461,
-0.12099435925483704,
-0.7008299231529236,
-0.2685236632823944,
0.054558612406253815,
-0.7603360414505005,
0.3829025626182556,
-0.4253459572792053,
-0.16424861550331116,
0.4844210147857666,
-0.3362743854522705,
-0.8325459957122803,
0.3284319341182709,
0.46662139892578125,
0.6301479935646057,
-0.7856610417366028,
0.720984697341919,
0.45392879843711853,
-0.882371187210083,
-0.7459825277328491,
-0.3920462131500244,
0.29018741846084595,
-0.8401302099227905,
0.9951882362365723,
0.09520461410284042,
-0.18341203033924103,
-0.06615828722715378,
-0.08333980292081833,
-0.8188196420669556,
1.444980502128601,
0.4284043610095978,
-0.5042371153831482,
-0.18224109709262848,
-0.0164338368922472,
0.15859511494636536,
0.05576108396053314,
0.5504626035690308,
0.0021028320770710707,
0.4451081454753876,
0.39539095759391785,
-0.8991170525550842,
-0.26360657811164856,
-0.23333881795406342,
0.13900326192378998,
-0.051366742700338364,
-0.5697752237319946,
1.0077275037765503,
-0.12153410166501999,
-0.30981042981147766,
-0.5394765734672546,
0.6237649917602539,
0.010088265873491764,
0.41711923480033875,
0.21297703683376312,
0.9015229940414429,
0.7810590267181396,
-0.004057889338582754,
0.9311311841011047,
-0.1299109011888504,
0.19562016427516937,
1.184645652770996,
0.029265666380524635,
0.599006175994873,
0.602850615978241,
-0.12603481113910675,
0.3649367094039917,
0.38108184933662415,
0.15342232584953308,
0.5400303602218628,
0.12166176736354828,
-0.4356471002101898,
-0.2353491336107254,
-0.12535852193832397,
-0.4319765269756317,
0.7013972997665405,
0.3013575077056885,
-0.287356436252594,
-0.6287470459938049,
0.528667151927948,
-0.2892601191997528,
0.08771679550409317,
-0.44418537616729736,
0.8517355918884277,
0.02324685826897621,
-0.42533165216445923,
0.3726119101047516,
0.19649164378643036,
0.5998934507369995,
-0.4799129366874695,
-0.2028113156557083,
0.0925239622592926,
0.11332863569259644,
-0.29680588841438293,
-1.2230077981948853,
0.1676875650882721,
-0.26961684226989746,
-0.524300754070282,
-0.5800434947013855,
0.7167749404907227,
-0.6103707551956177,
-0.526871919631958,
0.18226999044418335,
0.5022581219673157,
0.04995761439204216,
-0.2714061439037323,
-0.48584043979644775,
0.24094976484775543,
-0.16969287395477295,
-0.023966984823346138,
0.2946300208568573,
1.2519595623016357,
-0.04945136979222298,
0.6755539178848267,
0.47288602590560913,
-0.1640542596578598,
0.3535206913948059,
0.5955509543418884,
0.8919699788093567,
-0.4353397488594055,
-0.42809122800827026,
-0.8374019265174866,
0.7622517943382263,
0.026780802756547928,
-0.43036550283432007,
0.6058402061462402,
0.6776789426803589,
1.0326652526855469,
-0.3673621714115143,
0.6935224533081055,
0.26112693548202515,
-0.14314192533493042,
-0.6295384168624878,
0.9560390710830688,
-0.6261085867881775,
-0.2763969898223877,
-0.46050941944122314,
-0.769065797328949,
-0.2201630175113678,
0.45433083176612854,
0.09464919567108154,
-0.2811764180660248,
0.4319220185279846,
0.46579283475875854,
-0.3533305525779724,
-0.21434897184371948,
0.5018517971038818,
-0.13458314538002014,
0.4445401728153229,
0.330443412065506,
0.7757384777069092,
-0.4162675738334656,
0.5238974690437317,
-0.24919907748699188,
-0.17690247297286987,
-0.2618046998977661,
-0.47807830572128296,
-0.9095298647880554,
-1.0885545015335083,
-0.2678905427455902,
0.08130057156085968,
-0.28654977679252625,
0.46475473046302795,
0.8561105728149414,
-0.09102075546979904,
0.13330353796482086,
-0.024075813591480255,
0.1384500116109848,
0.005904254503548145,
-0.30180421471595764,
0.38165849447250366,
-0.11775293946266174,
-0.6399246454238892,
-0.0293072871863842,
0.573703944683075,
0.6551451683044434,
-0.40823444724082947,
0.12572592496871948,
-0.19190776348114014,
-0.18634511530399323,
1.1018667221069336,
-0.2844846546649933,
-0.6532890200614929,
0.15248221158981323,
-0.3606550097465515,
-0.3690283000469208,
0.03777698799967766,
0.5554444193840027,
-0.7147213220596313,
0.9652465581893921,
0.6866936087608337,
0.5179040431976318,
1.001866340637207,
-0.03060009516775608,
0.4016849994659424,
-0.5143454670906067,
0.3861869275569916,
-0.06451182812452316,
0.43795111775398254,
0.23020145297050476,
-0.2973245680332184,
0.15059931576251984,
0.5216308236122131,
-0.023273315280675888,
-0.6728480458259583,
-0.05072144418954849,
-1.6405036449432373,
-0.6165875196456909,
0.8957114815711975,
-0.049272969365119934,
-0.3707349896430969,
-0.04706718772649765,
-0.6828765273094177,
0.5149354934692383,
-0.32649609446525574,
0.6267805695533752,
0.888363242149353,
0.15893088281154633,
-0.46388429403305054,
-0.4756283462047577,
0.32722166180610657,
-0.025615831837058067,
-0.8466440439224243,
0.10204634815454483,
0.6936475038528442,
0.09454991668462753,
-0.07680566608905792,
0.8458841443061829,
-0.23706848919391632,
0.20075710117816925,
0.36869579553604126,
0.15839256346225739,
-0.5701006650924683,
-0.5622279047966003,
-0.0579511784017086,
0.5094654560089111,
0.022896844893693924,
-0.27984148263931274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17982v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17982v1
|
Collaborative decoding of critical tokens for boosting factuality of large language models
| 2024-02-28T01:53:37 | 2024-02-28T01:53:37 |
Lifeng Jin, Baolin Peng, Linfeng Song, Haitao Mi, Ye Tian, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The most common training pipeline for large language models includes
pretraining, finetuning and aligning phases, with their respective resulting
models, such as the pretrained model and the finetuned model. Finetuned and
aligned models show improved abilities of instruction following and safe
generation, however their abilities to stay factual about the world are
impacted by the finetuning process. Furthermore, the common practice of using
sampling during generation also increases chances of hallucination. In this
work, we introduce a collaborative decoding framework to harness the high
factuality within pretrained models through the concept of critical tokens. We
first design a critical token classifier to decide which model to use for the
next token, and subsequently generates the next token using different decoding
strategies. Experiments with different models and datasets show that our
decoding framework is able to reduce model hallucination significantly,
showcasing the importance of the collaborative decoding framework.
|
[
-0.33113428950309753,
-0.5425447225570679,
0.449346125125885,
-0.039071086794137955,
-0.3348211646080017,
0.20542007684707642,
-0.3381965756416321,
-0.34235718846321106,
0.08100594580173492,
0.728268563747406,
-0.27824217081069946,
-0.49720171093940735,
-0.49327293038368225,
0.07557180523872375,
-0.44249942898750305,
1.2387274503707886,
0.1231389194726944,
0.32844072580337524,
-0.2227691262960434,
-0.18438830971717834,
-0.5863910913467407,
-0.9563246965408325,
-0.5057741403579712,
-0.29915016889572144,
0.2843814790248871,
0.5541201829910278,
0.6458438038825989,
0.5323169231414795,
0.5092419385910034,
0.30108630657196045,
0.013110191561281681,
0.3253331780433655,
-0.9111246466636658,
0.0676102414727211,
-0.2561299800872803,
-0.6569470763206482,
-0.3599753677845001,
0.029670335352420807,
0.39114129543304443,
1.045005202293396,
-0.15451163053512573,
0.30471253395080566,
0.23626917600631714,
0.42805320024490356,
-0.6332966089248657,
0.46098268032073975,
-0.773548424243927,
0.0182651299983263,
0.02488524094223976,
-0.2144613116979599,
-0.7308495044708252,
-0.6254565715789795,
0.11787622421979904,
-0.602004885673523,
0.7400550246238708,
0.24078692495822906,
0.596909761428833,
0.19364206492900848,
-0.07593223452568054,
-0.2618245482444763,
-0.7710233330726624,
0.6269489526748657,
-0.6388238668441772,
0.47765299677848816,
0.3743734657764435,
0.03577530011534691,
-0.08352705091238022,
-0.8873475790023804,
-0.7308295965194702,
-0.1993047147989273,
-0.16608861088752747,
-0.08032887428998947,
0.24303199350833893,
0.3276013731956482,
0.0826338678598404,
0.5480959415435791,
-0.34180623292922974,
0.01054164208471775,
-0.2780090272426605,
-0.6472753882408142,
0.38522985577583313,
0.190855011343956,
0.2380494475364685,
-0.12202564626932144,
-0.3061731159687042,
-0.26893264055252075,
-0.5442952513694763,
-0.21023136377334595,
0.08756637573242188,
0.5634145140647888,
-0.03377903252840042,
0.4515140950679779,
-0.1939251571893692,
0.3763178586959839,
0.24478775262832642,
-0.01054944284260273,
0.36482441425323486,
-0.69256591796875,
-0.13147293031215668,
0.23224535584449768,
0.5771523118019104,
0.5200180411338806,
0.17161448299884796,
-0.4905254542827606,
-0.32119226455688477,
0.2334088683128357,
0.06307513266801834,
-0.9004908204078674,
-0.30855080485343933,
0.1298726499080658,
-0.578066349029541,
-0.5634768605232239,
0.14594371616840363,
-0.4764156639575958,
-0.3526068329811096,
-0.5484834313392639,
0.5237042903900146,
-0.3034619688987732,
-0.5417450070381165,
0.4656500816345215,
-0.10360432416200638,
-0.022415773943066597,
0.07120362669229507,
-1.0954301357269287,
0.3846985101699829,
0.9065548777580261,
0.7554190754890442,
-0.02156870812177658,
-0.39671725034713745,
-0.9696871638298035,
0.11239106953144073,
-0.4614271819591522,
0.633361279964447,
-0.3776426613330841,
-0.24535638093948364,
0.19210287928581238,
0.03535659983754158,
0.02920377068221569,
-0.5688384771347046,
0.5140203237533569,
-0.6128190755844116,
0.09382402151823044,
-0.6093077063560486,
-0.6866171360015869,
-0.30936020612716675,
0.40880468487739563,
-0.7937005162239075,
0.6722039580345154,
-0.05479879677295685,
-0.8981825709342957,
0.5297484397888184,
-0.38448160886764526,
-0.27904316782951355,
0.238210991024971,
-0.3301165699958801,
-0.23563522100448608,
0.2805574834346771,
0.21961548924446106,
0.7360115051269531,
-0.35429465770721436,
0.6846096515655518,
-0.25554192066192627,
-0.44276711344718933,
0.14541040360927582,
-0.47998377680778503,
0.6816088557243347,
0.2263025939464569,
-0.5366621613502502,
0.20505458116531372,
-0.8688221573829651,
-0.1353544443845749,
-0.0916200801730156,
-0.26067954301834106,
-0.22625623643398285,
-0.19572320580482483,
0.22033174335956573,
0.08943663537502289,
0.1389942765235901,
-0.27532875537872314,
-0.08449753373861313,
-0.37432992458343506,
0.2789924740791321,
0.6913217902183533,
0.16567176580429077,
0.34012576937675476,
-0.312518447637558,
0.34407946467399597,
0.1777978241443634,
-0.06867974251508713,
-0.19421854615211487,
-0.1612330973148346,
-1.042168140411377,
-0.2647760808467865,
0.4983600974082947,
0.39192259311676025,
-0.7497829794883728,
0.7327016592025757,
-0.3038097321987152,
-0.2124791145324707,
-0.607327401638031,
0.08666525781154633,
0.47900253534317017,
0.5066436529159546,
0.1765030175447464,
-0.4359426200389862,
-0.6324872970581055,
-0.6303364038467407,
0.05621079355478287,
-0.2651216387748718,
0.11224166303873062,
0.01488830242305994,
0.3746194541454315,
-0.3244814872741699,
0.9032186269760132,
-0.3698504567146301,
-0.13564863801002502,
-0.3590865433216095,
0.3821105659008026,
0.1287699043750763,
0.751118540763855,
0.4427887201309204,
-0.6308415532112122,
-0.2104075849056244,
-0.11288891732692719,
-0.7875362634658813,
0.2158794403076172,
-0.3594726026058197,
-0.2146325409412384,
0.09612873941659927,
0.739374577999115,
-0.5112704634666443,
0.05404255539178848,
0.5360465049743652,
-0.41846901178359985,
0.6362186074256897,
-0.16761383414268494,
0.18970423936843872,
-1.237766981124878,
0.15043967962265015,
-0.6034947037696838,
-0.4693237543106079,
-0.4395531415939331,
0.3640410006046295,
-0.4253308176994324,
-0.08958750218153,
-0.2172001302242279,
0.05582646653056145,
-0.44889095425605774,
0.16972555220127106,
-0.13220182061195374,
0.07547155767679214,
-0.0018413960933685303,
0.38900095224380493,
0.17835357785224915,
0.7353166341781616,
0.5596931576728821,
-0.4048474133014679,
0.3293466866016388,
0.2420760989189148,
-0.5121301412582397,
0.2231285572052002,
-0.5466525554656982,
0.4178897440433502,
-0.09533179551362991,
0.276700884103775,
-0.785670280456543,
-0.3011470437049866,
0.11323681473731995,
-0.22373339533805847,
0.18308962881565094,
-0.07254128903150558,
-0.7661336064338684,
-0.2175181657075882,
-0.10449504852294922,
0.6365675330162048,
0.3723292946815491,
-0.7844332456588745,
0.4887661933898926,
0.5574632883071899,
0.16755889356136322,
-0.5266211628913879,
-0.5564627647399902,
0.08605121076107025,
-0.019299209117889404,
-0.6608315110206604,
0.09779812395572662,
-0.11201996356248856,
-0.07880886644124985,
0.011839428916573524,
0.10153986513614655,
0.021334480494260788,
0.1120573952794075,
0.31975772976875305,
0.38077419996261597,
-0.3736514449119568,
-0.03064967505633831,
-0.23833401501178741,
-0.33599817752838135,
0.1599377989768982,
-0.5631335377693176,
0.9326956868171692,
-0.2942757308483124,
-0.24869641661643982,
-0.5707827210426331,
0.3826451897621155,
0.7946022748947144,
-0.5003775358200073,
1.2005317211151123,
0.8897166848182678,
-0.5712047815322876,
-0.09622111916542053,
-0.8037284016609192,
-0.4416235685348511,
-0.49450841546058655,
0.39892423152923584,
-0.29897642135620117,
-1.0202280282974243,
0.7405574321746826,
-0.11136531084775925,
-0.14375446736812592,
0.14610598981380463,
0.7877187728881836,
0.4111114740371704,
1.072016954421997,
0.927963376045227,
-0.2921035587787628,
0.2508453130722046,
-0.4420569837093353,
0.3160358965396881,
-0.4354569613933563,
-0.28756123781204224,
-0.4339260756969452,
0.12721720337867737,
-0.4058483839035034,
-0.5304083228111267,
0.12152307480573654,
0.3084356188774109,
0.028655080124735832,
0.03781532123684883,
-0.49882176518440247,
0.7971524000167847,
0.52534019947052,
0.24302755296230316,
0.22019068896770477,
0.20579415559768677,
-0.5270404815673828,
0.08937709778547287,
-0.7891373038291931,
-0.5286858677864075,
1.067071795463562,
0.24786540865898132,
0.5028618574142456,
-0.1596040427684784,
0.8287506699562073,
0.05112148076295853,
0.1740567684173584,
-0.7833472490310669,
0.48336347937583923,
0.025176318362355232,
-0.8816058039665222,
-0.1820373386144638,
-0.477760374546051,
-0.6113752126693726,
-0.04432295262813568,
-0.6459885239601135,
-0.5058779120445251,
0.19874192774295807,
0.2983642816543579,
-0.6394461989402771,
0.25709253549575806,
-0.7725043892860413,
0.9758275747299194,
0.19548159837722778,
-0.312210351228714,
-0.6036692261695862,
-0.6145378351211548,
0.41774022579193115,
-0.18198464810848236,
0.33866769075393677,
0.2541138827800751,
0.6014277935028076,
0.7400403618812561,
-0.48866429924964905,
1.0894125699996948,
-0.16318175196647644,
0.07744179666042328,
0.3579498827457428,
0.2119665890932083,
0.523078203201294,
0.18909846246242523,
-0.2257281243801117,
0.04804175719618797,
0.06464157998561859,
-0.3578869700431824,
-0.3380599021911621,
0.4494817554950714,
-0.7762284874916077,
-0.4566354751586914,
-0.22347775101661682,
-0.5222722291946411,
-0.22834905982017517,
0.45672842860221863,
0.4263695180416107,
0.8065375089645386,
-0.4287262558937073,
0.3466186225414276,
0.6030094027519226,
0.13474085927009583,
0.18157707154750824,
0.2157624065876007,
-0.13967262208461761,
-0.5413300395011902,
1.234542965888977,
-0.017695888876914978,
0.2698253393173218,
0.17109990119934082,
0.19119027256965637,
-0.21462894976139069,
-0.9275623559951782,
-0.05957135930657387,
0.2590262293815613,
-0.8742879629135132,
-0.19111214578151703,
-0.5861513614654541,
-0.26835325360298157,
-0.5831092596054077,
-0.2783818542957306,
-0.4783977270126343,
-0.28524869680404663,
-0.2806699872016907,
-0.3608537018299103,
0.034019891172647476,
0.8536186218261719,
-0.37035512924194336,
0.17130662500858307,
-1.2436389923095703,
0.30812934041023254,
0.3134440779685974,
0.3145589232444763,
0.20258834958076477,
-0.24808631837368011,
-0.4924599826335907,
0.0050967540591955185,
0.15951919555664062,
-0.5429909229278564,
0.10163675248622894,
-0.12983089685440063,
0.5426314473152161,
0.5553863048553467,
0.3721467852592468,
0.7572926878929138,
-0.6079938411712646,
0.8100296854972839,
0.315620094537735,
-1.2314101457595825,
0.04395703226327896,
-0.15026606619358063,
-0.03979978337883949,
1.076088547706604,
0.2093525528907776,
-0.6372794508934021,
-0.4160764813423157,
-0.5726681351661682,
-0.7230532765388489,
0.777531087398529,
0.17540515959262848,
0.26362794637680054,
-0.17001639306545258,
0.39668095111846924,
0.4593810439109802,
0.22201786935329437,
-0.6692939400672913,
0.05021802335977554,
-0.298812597990036,
-0.5216542482376099,
-0.05905517563223839,
-0.4321529269218445,
-0.41668304800987244,
-0.32823675870895386,
0.4789237976074219,
-0.18788902461528778,
0.02710655704140663,
0.03145261108875275,
-0.24276003241539001,
-0.11418485641479492,
-0.13104340434074402,
0.2859300374984741,
0.43266281485557556,
-0.18522688746452332,
0.29129791259765625,
0.16287115216255188,
-0.5868434309959412,
0.05976786091923714,
-0.09764622151851654,
-0.09114304929971695,
-0.01773669943213463,
0.6315203309059143,
0.8598976731300354,
0.09704310446977615,
-0.4671742618083954,
0.6623001098632812,
-0.2815585434436798,
-0.1506681889295578,
-0.18109361827373505,
0.13594967126846313,
-0.05333196371793747,
0.3187767267227173,
0.07394092530012131,
0.4819062352180481,
0.20054449141025543,
-0.5089527368545532,
0.3653102517127991,
0.31108367443084717,
-0.16845270991325378,
-0.5660343766212463,
0.5203527808189392,
0.6359665989875793,
-0.2131257802248001,
0.6777681708335876,
-0.4280112087726593,
-0.8715496063232422,
0.396933913230896,
0.8118405938148499,
0.9335677027702332,
0.10804961621761322,
0.33095815777778625,
0.4488019645214081,
0.24235917627811432,
-0.47881177067756653,
-0.022663185372948647,
-0.3106386065483093,
-0.9856036901473999,
-0.5016129612922668,
-0.6158870458602905,
-0.39013972878456116,
0.24547386169433594,
-0.8653781414031982,
0.364446759223938,
-0.5694705247879028,
-0.06923425197601318,
-0.33594226837158203,
-0.026051141321659088,
-0.7611004710197449,
0.32003945112228394,
0.41643226146698,
0.529207706451416,
-0.947938859462738,
0.7021790742874146,
0.37205785512924194,
-0.41071492433547974,
-1.2399839162826538,
0.2875620424747467,
-0.1166258230805397,
-0.5382048487663269,
0.6433715224266052,
0.5000907778739929,
-0.37321963906288147,
0.16858282685279846,
-0.5651097893714905,
-0.8762394785881042,
0.7508513927459717,
0.5155572891235352,
-0.7271760702133179,
-0.28158509731292725,
0.2335626482963562,
0.4332507848739624,
-0.4946450889110565,
-0.0843106061220169,
0.5950326323509216,
0.14521588385105133,
0.14543236792087555,
-0.7891644239425659,
0.4102042019367218,
-0.06907998025417328,
-0.2517625689506531,
-0.2716072201728821,
-0.4969603419303894,
0.7724555134773254,
-0.2050686627626419,
-0.316715270280838,
0.054680150002241135,
0.7163347005844116,
0.23433725535869598,
0.13559986650943756,
0.737856924533844,
0.48034417629241943,
1.1500139236450195,
0.23829348385334015,
0.7226467728614807,
-0.6222254037857056,
0.4545159637928009,
0.9960644245147705,
-0.06687373667955399,
0.7834870219230652,
0.2588839828968048,
0.26630711555480957,
0.34431156516075134,
0.3940282166004181,
0.12551386654376984,
0.5769190192222595,
-0.06735975295305252,
-0.2839917242527008,
-0.6611390709877014,
-0.16628199815750122,
-0.5552307367324829,
0.41852661967277527,
0.33716514706611633,
-0.24640609323978424,
-0.10870958119630814,
0.038518987596035004,
0.07447867840528488,
0.10748226195573807,
-0.08108953386545181,
0.6661608815193176,
-0.03234303370118141,
-0.6638305187225342,
0.9276856780052185,
-0.22037073969841003,
0.5396804809570312,
-0.11523943394422531,
0.014804134145379066,
-0.17395161092281342,
0.3807533085346222,
-0.28595277667045593,
-0.3533732295036316,
0.20767667889595032,
-0.11713074147701263,
-0.3398190140724182,
-0.15060296654701233,
0.3547801971435547,
-0.5253838300704956,
-0.45160043239593506,
0.15116474032402039,
0.2852928638458252,
0.036559611558914185,
0.07903143763542175,
-0.41949746012687683,
0.3518022894859314,
0.06120028346776962,
0.15711964666843414,
-0.14856991171836853,
0.5971721410751343,
0.19604839384555817,
0.25516554713249207,
0.9258999228477478,
0.12768712639808655,
0.03990984335541725,
0.4275367558002472,
1.1000194549560547,
-0.477064311504364,
-0.6482155919075012,
-0.7932602763175964,
0.4939671754837036,
-0.07343854010105133,
-0.23012232780456543,
0.6425638198852539,
0.5400118827819824,
0.9988592863082886,
-0.11036662012338638,
0.6589230895042419,
0.3316843807697296,
0.3009324073791504,
-0.7546116709709167,
1.0876473188400269,
-0.15667849779129028,
0.22921374440193176,
-0.2679165005683899,
-0.9369598627090454,
-0.49557575583457947,
0.7218002676963806,
0.028229456394910812,
-0.3552430272102356,
0.7437734603881836,
0.8520718216896057,
-0.08228881657123566,
0.15596327185630798,
0.15786391496658325,
0.3575955629348755,
0.550967276096344,
0.2545938789844513,
0.7949649095535278,
-0.23077532649040222,
0.5066279172897339,
-0.19626286625862122,
-0.32739531993865967,
-0.31438735127449036,
-0.7325659990310669,
-1.3424979448318481,
-0.6765629053115845,
-0.22279693186283112,
-0.5754976868629456,
-0.037049274891614914,
1.3116556406021118,
0.9306535124778748,
-1.0411337614059448,
-0.11400695890188217,
-0.5256880521774292,
0.012867891229689121,
0.055234454572200775,
-0.20169581472873688,
0.23865753412246704,
-0.7200955748558044,
-0.5867806673049927,
0.16923706233501434,
0.013986566103994846,
0.05151446536183357,
-0.33839982748031616,
-0.023591207340359688,
0.16472068428993225,
0.11306092143058777,
0.5375036597251892,
-0.03416755050420761,
-0.3858814239501953,
-0.5376848578453064,
0.04124566540122032,
-0.2107773721218109,
-0.135219544172287,
1.0209453105926514,
-0.8376083970069885,
0.4660114645957947,
0.6519709825515747,
0.8938384652137756,
0.430905818939209,
-0.15512987971305847,
0.8721141815185547,
-0.5841533541679382,
0.4831691384315491,
0.3232511281967163,
0.29860809445381165,
0.5447498559951782,
-0.3807351291179657,
0.2087707668542862,
0.5845476388931274,
-0.5520195960998535,
-1.2801674604415894,
0.10318926721811295,
-0.8096619248390198,
-0.13068200647830963,
0.9602428078651428,
-0.1973067671060562,
-0.29674863815307617,
-0.18922759592533112,
-0.3648751974105835,
0.5689414739608765,
-0.16999493539333344,
0.9635275602340698,
0.92666095495224,
0.37337276339530945,
0.2949555218219757,
-0.026920149102807045,
0.6355369091033936,
0.5886369347572327,
-0.562565267086029,
0.3645164370536804,
0.5249196290969849,
0.2598162293434143,
0.4165564179420471,
0.5317984223365784,
0.03252767026424408,
0.19135305285453796,
0.3169495761394501,
-0.04049847647547722,
-0.03692351281642914,
-0.5231164693832397,
-0.21469801664352417,
0.20463994145393372,
0.23905619978904724,
-0.30472803115844727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17971v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17971v2
|
All in an Aggregated Image for In-Image Learning
| 2024-02-28T01:32:59 | 2024-04-02T09:32:51 |
Lei Wang, Wanyu Xu, Zhiqiang Hu, Yihuai Lan, Shan Dong, Hao Wang, Roy Ka-Wei Lee, Ee-Peng Lim
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper introduces a new in-context learning (ICL) mechanism called
In-Image Learning (I$^2$L) that combines demonstration examples, visual cues,
and chain-of-thought reasoning into an aggregated image to enhance the
capabilities of Large Multimodal Models (e.g., GPT-4V) in multimodal reasoning
tasks. Unlike previous approaches that rely on converting images to text or
incorporating visual input into language models, I$^2$L consolidates all
information into an aggregated image and leverages image processing,
understanding, and reasoning abilities. This has several advantages: it reduces
inaccurate textual descriptions of complex images, provides flexibility in
positioning demonstration examples, and avoids multiple input images and
lengthy prompts. We also introduce I$^2$L-Hybrid, a method that combines the
strengths of I$^2$L with other ICL methods. Specifically, it uses an automatic
strategy to select the most suitable method (I$^2$L or another certain ICL
method) for a specific task instance. We conduct extensive experiments to
assess the effectiveness of I$^2$L and I$^2$L-Hybrid on MathVista, which covers
a variety of complex multimodal reasoning tasks. Additionally, we investigate
the influence of image resolution, the number of demonstration examples in a
single image, and the positions of these demonstrations in the aggregated image
on the effectiveness of I$^2$L. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/AGI-Edgerunners/IIL.
|
[
-0.4941495358943939,
-0.9182282090187073,
0.4652181565761566,
0.09776200354099274,
-0.606651782989502,
0.364750474691391,
-0.02219310961663723,
-0.46023207902908325,
-0.12586882710456848,
-0.02549830824136734,
-0.22464504837989807,
-0.2827468514442444,
-0.4292653501033783,
-0.12456587702035904,
-0.299355685710907,
0.8805072903633118,
-0.12950631976127625,
0.3723709285259247,
-0.8295754194259644,
-0.37674424052238464,
-0.35424256324768066,
-0.27183160185813904,
-0.5150890946388245,
-0.5241930484771729,
0.26004767417907715,
0.608968198299408,
0.48632335662841797,
0.4929579198360443,
0.47552385926246643,
0.26798489689826965,
0.2456238716840744,
0.5554978251457214,
-0.2597105801105499,
-0.15614399313926697,
-0.22541743516921997,
-0.342699259519577,
-0.1378103792667389,
0.031163854524493217,
0.8034934401512146,
0.4440191984176636,
0.14941075444221497,
0.09290604293346405,
0.09186039865016937,
0.38731810450553894,
-0.7815231084823608,
0.24799898266792297,
-0.6914071440696716,
0.057180602103471756,
-0.1855139136314392,
-0.1752161979675293,
-0.37831249833106995,
-0.23879748582839966,
-0.03962770104408264,
-0.5917476415634155,
-0.21703410148620605,
-0.11002912372350693,
0.5367651581764221,
0.1715794950723648,
-0.8467128276824951,
-0.32665735483169556,
-0.5183144807815552,
0.7133549451828003,
-0.30935412645339966,
0.31361567974090576,
0.19428178668022156,
0.3883698880672455,
0.19301116466522217,
-0.8354740738868713,
-0.8870373368263245,
-0.19025735557079315,
-0.1301615685224533,
0.4292895495891571,
-0.18972913920879364,
-0.0426887683570385,
0.24300839006900787,
0.3706173896789551,
-0.3946782052516937,
0.1515953540802002,
-0.46434497833251953,
-0.06542551517486572,
0.35795870423316956,
-0.0036976344417780638,
0.35875725746154785,
0.2938603460788727,
-0.722308337688446,
-0.2606206238269806,
-0.7443395256996155,
0.3085792064666748,
-0.07698986679315567,
-0.30628979206085205,
-0.2216365933418274,
0.5205844640731812,
0.24099400639533997,
0.660347044467926,
0.12978321313858032,
-0.3402644097805023,
0.19184191524982452,
-0.28436797857284546,
-0.041196029633283615,
-0.1286611109972,
0.6011825203895569,
0.5332397818565369,
-0.14772537350654602,
0.02583245187997818,
-0.2864711284637451,
0.40631040930747986,
-0.09538937360048294,
-0.6719706058502197,
-0.01806778274476528,
-0.14243565499782562,
-0.4952733814716339,
-0.16368505358695984,
-0.04048044607043266,
-0.7422799468040466,
0.03389051929116249,
-0.48164254426956177,
0.8751301765441895,
-0.8421645164489746,
-0.20897144079208374,
-0.2755868136882782,
-0.17981746792793274,
0.35175222158432007,
0.5120723247528076,
-0.5970211625099182,
0.6250200867652893,
0.32839077711105347,
0.8916345238685608,
-0.18093842267990112,
-0.3862577974796295,
-0.8449079394340515,
0.18504519760608673,
-0.42117977142333984,
0.9963406920433044,
-0.5662679076194763,
-0.3276745676994324,
-0.04057394340634346,
-0.3550562858581543,
-0.19898955523967743,
-0.6586342453956604,
0.26828962564468384,
-0.46984386444091797,
0.4263935685157776,
0.12223222106695175,
-0.6467044949531555,
-0.5636703968048096,
0.44719478487968445,
-0.4350254535675049,
0.87110435962677,
0.0990595892071724,
-0.5213444828987122,
0.3380813002586365,
-0.899008572101593,
-0.5682475566864014,
0.28929993510246277,
-0.5735788345336914,
-0.49474337697029114,
-0.23511700332164764,
0.1876678317785263,
0.43767446279525757,
-0.16315492987632751,
0.16814880073070526,
-0.3776441514492035,
-0.4201012849807739,
0.46778497099876404,
-0.4181024432182312,
0.6313155889511108,
0.3043028712272644,
-0.5476645231246948,
0.15053771436214447,
-0.35467052459716797,
0.023680616170167923,
0.19456976652145386,
-0.22251348197460175,
-0.34126707911491394,
-0.1336534321308136,
0.12380033731460571,
0.35974621772766113,
0.18880432844161987,
-0.4357597231864929,
0.34593665599823,
-0.001148764044046402,
0.2647796869277954,
0.6812243461608887,
-0.09683029353618622,
0.6213664412498474,
-0.2470368891954422,
0.343453049659729,
0.2959825098514557,
0.34470853209495544,
-0.5381403565406799,
-0.5321794748306274,
-0.6247029304504395,
-0.48595497012138367,
0.04624197259545326,
0.49132248759269714,
-1.2506788969039917,
0.10627655684947968,
-0.07123439759016037,
-0.27849557995796204,
-0.09686466306447983,
0.07188674062490463,
0.8024622201919556,
0.6766279339790344,
0.5276973843574524,
-0.24854537844657898,
-0.13181233406066895,
-0.9650072455406189,
0.06877094507217407,
-0.014907769858837128,
0.27958422899246216,
0.36469531059265137,
0.8024094104766846,
-0.2725028991699219,
0.7967392206192017,
-0.16752365231513977,
-0.2538106143474579,
-0.26076778769493103,
0.2162402719259262,
0.020119020715355873,
0.5143402814865112,
0.7705680131912231,
-1.0899107456207275,
-0.6542083621025085,
0.11627563834190369,
-1.0144176483154297,
0.25204914808273315,
-0.14578953385353088,
-0.05657819285988808,
-0.006158197298645973,
0.49824753403663635,
-0.552207350730896,
0.47507259249687195,
0.3031017482280731,
-0.4395391345024109,
0.44284769892692566,
-0.47722309827804565,
0.3104003071784973,
-0.990734338760376,
-0.5504169464111328,
0.5033985376358032,
-0.14687156677246094,
-0.5245630145072937,
0.42736831307411194,
0.5945441126823425,
-0.06525696069002151,
-0.4449990391731262,
0.4662669897079468,
-0.425669401884079,
-0.22337937355041504,
-0.1966896802186966,
-0.11352820694446564,
-0.09851100295782089,
0.5259975790977478,
-0.2508546710014343,
0.9661998748779297,
0.9450815916061401,
-0.6612760424613953,
0.31214210391044617,
0.14798520505428314,
-0.45278894901275635,
0.7548508644104004,
-0.2652330994606018,
0.22825674712657928,
-0.3750647008419037,
0.5481943488121033,
-1.061493158340454,
-0.24829600751399994,
0.1461203247308731,
-0.2923855781555176,
0.46860271692276,
0.11343841999769211,
-0.47140949964523315,
-0.13718554377555847,
-0.14920784533023834,
0.7882182002067566,
0.5707469582557678,
-1.0493559837341309,
0.8399686217308044,
0.36713704466819763,
0.25886961817741394,
-0.3022402822971344,
-0.5843966007232666,
0.15638242661952972,
-0.42073890566825867,
-0.6609189510345459,
0.5452192425727844,
-0.2835592031478882,
-0.5361171960830688,
0.11009981483221054,
0.268622487783432,
-0.15745395421981812,
-0.1001744195818901,
0.11386304348707199,
0.5091794729232788,
-0.1311565488576889,
0.3226858973503113,
0.27720287442207336,
-0.044009167701005936,
-0.14822977781295776,
-0.48789310455322266,
0.2819092571735382,
-0.5124027132987976,
-0.6004666686058044,
-0.4883880019187927,
0.6292542815208435,
0.6392288208007812,
-0.4186195731163025,
0.23301775753498077,
0.5450658202171326,
-0.3550701439380646,
-0.0766596645116806,
-0.4475257098674774,
-0.16675034165382385,
-0.4219050705432892,
0.27013134956359863,
-0.38007140159606934,
-0.678425669670105,
0.2733810245990753,
-0.45011141896247864,
0.11494545638561249,
0.31941232085227966,
0.4743930995464325,
-0.5227875709533691,
1.138268232345581,
0.3915369212627411,
0.11683725565671921,
0.5340179800987244,
-0.7318592071533203,
-0.01653994247317314,
-0.8013304471969604,
-0.45048874616622925,
0.0862739086151123,
-0.6216856837272644,
-0.10305570065975189,
-0.726511538028717,
0.9786000847816467,
0.020616663619875908,
-0.21042189002037048,
-0.23869243264198303,
-0.22404295206069946,
0.8340940475463867,
0.6256892085075378,
0.6812652349472046,
0.1767934113740921,
0.24467773735523224,
-0.249137744307518,
0.055361852049827576,
-0.6305601596832275,
-0.13476456701755524,
0.8921198844909668,
0.07820110023021698,
0.812005877494812,
0.2931586503982544,
0.3439449965953827,
0.33206814527511597,
0.38057950139045715,
-0.7757732272148132,
0.6324138641357422,
-0.3472234606742859,
-0.2222256064414978,
-0.043221812695264816,
-0.18858814239501953,
-0.5747619271278381,
0.6322382688522339,
-0.4427924156188965,
-0.5059142112731934,
0.13050876557826996,
0.32416918873786926,
-0.15650568902492523,
0.5813383460044861,
-0.8486387729644775,
0.6604475975036621,
-0.6718783974647522,
-0.6198844313621521,
-0.7112230658531189,
-0.638866126537323,
0.5528030395507812,
0.15600897371768951,
0.4066692888736725,
0.34242841601371765,
-0.023388629779219627,
0.3349597156047821,
-0.2217690497636795,
0.841644823551178,
-0.23010919988155365,
0.2685045897960663,
0.28697943687438965,
0.06598441302776337,
0.6024537682533264,
-0.12005778402090073,
0.29024913907051086,
0.044630736112594604,
-0.40884512662887573,
-0.33765625953674316,
-0.767979085445404,
0.6143531203269958,
-0.6928380131721497,
-0.20358403027057648,
-0.26642516255378723,
-0.5429224967956543,
-0.1741163581609726,
-0.09490323066711426,
0.3504354953765869,
1.0946743488311768,
0.1818104386329651,
0.434901624917984,
0.8759884238243103,
-0.018326908349990845,
0.620557963848114,
0.06698159128427505,
-0.13504523038864136,
-0.6006627082824707,
0.9554990530014038,
0.08796031028032303,
0.4574732184410095,
0.4171851873397827,
0.32722049951553345,
-0.41506752371788025,
-0.3668912947177887,
-0.6597044467926025,
0.008667129091918468,
-1.226778507232666,
-0.1979799121618271,
-0.6559881567955017,
0.021168723702430725,
-0.009108680300414562,
-0.29986444115638733,
-0.1273426115512848,
-0.3091089427471161,
-0.21370330452919006,
-0.055336449295282364,
0.09648575633764267,
0.6420879364013672,
0.007009890396147966,
0.2523474395275116,
-0.4106263518333435,
0.28519922494888306,
0.696303129196167,
0.1717153638601303,
0.13577495515346527,
-0.40517377853393555,
-0.40139663219451904,
0.07980497181415558,
-0.5196878910064697,
-0.6873704791069031,
0.0724344402551651,
0.5061277747154236,
0.7980743646621704,
0.5749290585517883,
-0.3661656379699707,
0.8433820009231567,
-0.22743374109268188,
0.6730445623397827,
0.6525475978851318,
-0.9199191927909851,
0.41605740785598755,
-0.23231898248195648,
0.2117546945810318,
0.1924344003200531,
0.3772372901439667,
-0.10916469991207123,
-0.18755988776683807,
-0.6860266327857971,
-0.6655507683753967,
0.30480560660362244,
0.09807595610618591,
-0.09322062134742737,
0.08281497657299042,
0.23534750938415527,
0.21022404730319977,
-0.21836823225021362,
-0.8944143056869507,
-0.2604548931121826,
-0.25526466965675354,
-0.2727530002593994,
0.16230729222297668,
-0.229024276137352,
-0.3568110764026642,
-0.7114312052726746,
0.6703985929489136,
-0.6546751856803894,
0.17260754108428955,
0.06212998181581497,
-0.38585537672042847,
-0.014272954314947128,
-0.08797477930784225,
0.5550315380096436,
0.7580753564834595,
0.248971626162529,
0.4395222067832947,
0.35331612825393677,
-0.21451634168624878,
0.23834584653377533,
-0.12951739132404327,
-0.20654216408729553,
-0.21586543321609497,
0.485785573720932,
0.8377888202667236,
0.23008745908737183,
-0.5845996141433716,
0.7557175159454346,
-0.19512484967708588,
-0.678747296333313,
-0.4074987769126892,
-0.18257901072502136,
-0.3335898518562317,
0.6492424011230469,
0.4801125228404999,
0.3674299418926239,
0.2289741039276123,
-0.686210036277771,
0.3937230408191681,
0.6733350157737732,
-0.3178860545158386,
-0.2186838537454605,
0.6636515259742737,
-0.0142830116674304,
-0.04791231453418732,
0.6449460983276367,
-0.32503169775009155,
-0.4595731198787689,
0.6943432092666626,
0.9548995494842529,
0.6803004145622253,
0.134138286113739,
0.3139713406562805,
0.32722267508506775,
0.11767805367708206,
0.11413829773664474,
0.18230068683624268,
-0.3208707869052887,
-0.8669460415840149,
-0.5553914308547974,
0.056794095784425735,
-0.3944138288497925,
-0.11663438379764557,
-0.3009364902973175,
0.1680649220943451,
-0.37759628891944885,
0.10014984756708145,
-0.09921785444021225,
-0.5644423961639404,
-0.6121132969856262,
0.22978593409061432,
0.3782496154308319,
0.6423487663269043,
-0.9251834154129028,
0.9334486126899719,
0.9540731906890869,
-0.48422256112098694,
-0.6606318950653076,
0.04078124463558197,
-0.034048132598400116,
-0.9100432991981506,
0.8948495984077454,
0.25708040595054626,
-0.23163697123527527,
-0.1045016422867775,
-1.0595883131027222,
-0.719356119632721,
1.3002769947052002,
0.29589250683784485,
-0.1215909868478775,
0.3502838909626007,
-0.2334381639957428,
0.12704846262931824,
-0.6789554357528687,
0.4586004316806793,
0.09077282249927521,
0.31080347299575806,
0.44589173793792725,
-0.6699271202087402,
-0.173464834690094,
-0.5030273795127869,
-0.030602581799030304,
0.06921006739139557,
-0.8594630360603333,
1.0840736627578735,
-0.42339178919792175,
-0.07404004782438278,
-0.23082681000232697,
0.6398313045501709,
0.41376304626464844,
0.6361812949180603,
1.0501291751861572,
0.6975223422050476,
0.5901445150375366,
-0.06256061047315598,
1.0454320907592773,
0.10885968059301376,
0.16534467041492462,
0.9303666353225708,
-0.1999712735414505,
0.43645453453063965,
0.5628862977027893,
-0.018848074600100517,
0.6713125109672546,
0.630693256855011,
0.14575785398483276,
0.8216193318367004,
-0.2735728621482849,
-0.592736005783081,
-0.48325809836387634,
-0.12079395353794098,
-0.18171414732933044,
0.4616040289402008,
0.6895659565925598,
-0.0982615128159523,
-0.45479708909988403,
0.5399940013885498,
-0.3666921555995941,
0.11306271702051163,
-0.44582095742225647,
0.9229115843772888,
-0.0433514341711998,
-0.5636027455329895,
0.3687771260738373,
-0.4306201636791229,
0.6697685718536377,
-0.48794716596603394,
-0.49545127153396606,
-0.1381484419107437,
0.47860583662986755,
-0.1392582207918167,
-0.8996679186820984,
-0.028545835986733437,
-0.2231443077325821,
0.023742197081446648,
-0.22343669831752777,
0.7445635795593262,
-0.49973762035369873,
-0.506632924079895,
0.22344441711902618,
0.2878167927265167,
0.12235226482152939,
0.017773693427443504,
-0.6629349589347839,
-0.3283514678478241,
-0.085030697286129,
0.14880134165287018,
0.5948591828346252,
0.474261611700058,
-0.49822476506233215,
0.7233823537826538,
0.711196780204773,
-0.36929959058761597,
-0.03908854350447655,
0.011353051289916039,
1.1121071577072144,
-0.2904941737651825,
-0.5680671334266663,
-0.8574407696723938,
0.7002394199371338,
-0.23532810807228088,
-0.1409521847963333,
0.5480452179908752,
0.8064857721328735,
0.9843877553939819,
-0.0133870430290699,
0.9679940938949585,
-0.07757940888404846,
0.0931030735373497,
-0.7513533234596252,
0.13995419442653656,
-0.9427832961082458,
-0.15218470990657806,
-0.07561586052179337,
-0.5931516289710999,
-0.3129686117172241,
0.6116905808448792,
-0.10075175017118454,
-0.17867106199264526,
0.8160879015922546,
0.4993029534816742,
-0.452414870262146,
-0.04214567691087723,
0.36898165941238403,
-0.159344881772995,
0.4870430827140808,
0.444124698638916,
1.1274868249893188,
-0.19499792158603668,
0.4894627034664154,
-0.4840809106826782,
-0.5275139212608337,
-0.004260901361703873,
-0.713111937046051,
-0.68808913230896,
-0.7931860685348511,
-0.30424678325653076,
-0.20598240196704865,
-0.22232815623283386,
1.0584697723388672,
0.8535361289978027,
-0.4120873510837555,
-0.3456641137599945,
0.04878106713294983,
0.05448753386735916,
-0.5748533606529236,
-0.18816447257995605,
0.23696269094944,
-0.2430546134710312,
-0.5371161103248596,
0.4968216121196747,
0.5593479871749878,
0.11803733557462692,
-0.1978462189435959,
-0.24254021048545837,
-0.3574308753013611,
-0.3565061092376709,
0.858932375907898,
0.0038922149688005447,
-0.6456303596496582,
0.011586176231503487,
-0.22937224805355072,
0.10983481258153915,
0.17582064867019653,
0.8552654981613159,
-0.7533593773841858,
0.635970950126648,
0.2520875632762909,
0.5112500190734863,
0.7991161346435547,
-0.09674668312072754,
0.24201516807079315,
-0.5774150490760803,
0.4682699143886566,
0.20729634165763855,
0.6879570484161377,
0.18420234322547913,
-0.3659866154193878,
0.5038026571273804,
0.3378881812095642,
-0.46363088488578796,
-0.3519762456417084,
0.21310879290103912,
-0.9105066061019897,
-0.38945820927619934,
0.9913182258605957,
0.030024902895092964,
-0.2105276733636856,
0.12970875203609467,
-0.33903124928474426,
0.0658930167555809,
-0.30969470739364624,
0.6351888179779053,
0.3090040981769562,
-0.3668312728404999,
-0.473474383354187,
-0.4226241707801819,
-0.025715133175253868,
0.08465246111154556,
-0.9019178748130798,
-0.6038098931312561,
0.7054441571235657,
-0.012405572459101677,
0.07956883311271667,
0.6310067772865295,
-0.22172708809375763,
0.5092147588729858,
-0.13141286373138428,
0.1091720312833786,
-0.07060786336660385,
-0.3625604212284088,
-0.2325058877468109,
0.12284134328365326,
-0.20942066609859467,
-0.36579352617263794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07920v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07920v1
|
ProtLLM: An Interleaved Protein-Language LLM with Protein-as-Word Pre-Training
| 2024-02-28T01:29:55 | 2024-02-28T01:29:55 |
Le Zhuo, Zewen Chi, Minghao Xu, Heyan Huang, Heqi Zheng, Conghui He, Xian-Ling Mao, Wentao Zhang
|
q-bio.BM
|
q-bio.BM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We propose ProtLLM, a versatile cross-modal large language model (LLM) for
both protein-centric and protein-language tasks. ProtLLM features a unique
dynamic protein mounting mechanism, enabling it to handle complex inputs where
the natural language text is interspersed with an arbitrary number of proteins.
Besides, we propose the protein-as-word language modeling approach to train
ProtLLM. By developing a specialized protein vocabulary, we equip the model
with the capability to predict not just natural language but also proteins from
a vast pool of candidates. Additionally, we construct a large-scale interleaved
protein-text dataset, named InterPT, for pre-training. This dataset
comprehensively encompasses both (1) structured data sources like protein
annotations and (2) unstructured data sources like biological research papers,
thereby endowing ProtLLM with crucial knowledge for understanding proteins. We
evaluate ProtLLM on classic supervised protein-centric tasks and explore its
novel protein-language applications. Experimental results demonstrate that
ProtLLM not only achieves superior performance against protein-specialized
baselines on protein-centric tasks but also induces zero-shot and in-context
learning capabilities on protein-language tasks.
|
[
-0.24802900850772858,
-0.922584593296051,
0.2400892823934555,
0.05064302310347557,
-0.5622513890266418,
0.3045303225517273,
-0.04236689209938049,
-0.47144243121147156,
0.22960403561592102,
0.33895623683929443,
-0.5891572833061218,
-0.404261976480484,
-0.7831411361694336,
0.23312310874462128,
-0.5717446208000183,
1.0650804042816162,
0.16530859470367432,
0.5803103446960449,
-0.36303097009658813,
-0.0681154727935791,
0.017769016325473785,
-0.713813841342926,
-0.1332835555076599,
-0.7105505466461182,
0.8000639081001282,
0.22596332430839539,
0.47401607036590576,
0.26028579473495483,
0.5704766511917114,
0.150822252035141,
0.12341813743114471,
0.19572365283966064,
-0.5047165155410767,
0.06193256005644798,
-0.2473447471857071,
-0.3556285798549652,
-0.629084587097168,
0.1816481351852417,
0.5535077452659607,
0.8595483899116516,
0.34329932928085327,
0.1576322317123413,
0.14895114302635193,
0.6356269121170044,
-0.5098640322685242,
0.20214278995990753,
-0.6342172026634216,
0.0593908466398716,
-0.6932393312454224,
-0.3548935353755951,
-0.47833335399627686,
0.024956688284873962,
0.30949336290359497,
-0.2756739556789398,
-0.11605054140090942,
0.26780951023101807,
0.47561973333358765,
-0.04804190620779991,
-0.5696513056755066,
-0.33528026938438416,
-0.31381189823150635,
0.6188734769821167,
-0.789940357208252,
0.7199028134346008,
0.6313802599906921,
0.17186212539672852,
-0.5285511016845703,
-1.1238186359405518,
-0.6325989961624146,
-0.512162446975708,
-0.10701538622379303,
0.1312829852104187,
0.1580471694469452,
0.2860099971294403,
-0.08685305714607239,
0.2800642251968384,
-0.9584591388702393,
0.014504451304674149,
-0.171568363904953,
0.023930052295327187,
0.523719310760498,
-0.0916733518242836,
0.4380393922328949,
0.34506043791770935,
-0.04040412977337837,
0.1511673927307129,
-0.9253121018409729,
-0.012939845211803913,
0.25507184863090515,
0.5607606172561646,
0.2741282284259796,
0.7248520851135254,
-0.20466865599155426,
0.9027592539787292,
-0.2737748324871063,
0.17239393293857574,
0.16615654528141022,
-0.09746234863996506,
-0.4413466453552246,
0.24810977280139923,
0.7357121706008911,
-0.0686514675617218,
0.17790737748146057,
-0.47103753685951233,
-0.04287923499941826,
-0.3287193179130554,
0.22410021722316742,
-0.9222615361213684,
-0.4054073691368103,
0.5548813343048096,
-0.3284328877925873,
-0.10654494166374207,
-0.0037743602879345417,
-0.16910883784294128,
-0.09026985615491867,
-0.1583670675754547,
0.8642200827598572,
-0.7458653450012207,
-0.0481395460665226,
0.2231975644826889,
0.07872956991195679,
0.1451382040977478,
0.041244953870773315,
-0.6215978264808655,
0.17390908300876617,
0.5249932408332825,
0.732090175151825,
-0.23582860827445984,
-0.5301545262336731,
-1.0867807865142822,
0.40241503715515137,
0.0423637256026268,
0.7155826687812805,
-0.7836406826972961,
-0.1686556190252304,
-0.036642350256443024,
0.24262423813343048,
0.049210842698812485,
-0.5077126026153564,
0.2993953227996826,
-0.835936427116394,
0.26155638694763184,
-0.24585308134555817,
-0.9283463954925537,
-0.29577943682670593,
0.24787509441375732,
-0.39467573165893555,
0.4378090500831604,
0.09822258353233337,
-1.0254591703414917,
0.23320220410823822,
-0.7635399699211121,
-0.7075411677360535,
0.5618389844894409,
-0.16554641723632812,
-0.24117620289325714,
0.23858365416526794,
-0.20436511933803558,
0.3560839891433716,
-0.4726499915122986,
0.3936763107776642,
-0.2838723659515381,
-0.2690548598766327,
0.5248790979385376,
0.059152860194444656,
0.6185467839241028,
0.08957532048225403,
-0.02780824713408947,
0.2638126313686371,
-0.4515550136566162,
0.3846810460090637,
-0.1343308985233307,
-0.543593168258667,
-0.2304365634918213,
0.13095723092556,
0.08705686032772064,
0.04079660773277283,
0.2806135416030884,
-0.7749582529067993,
0.3297829031944275,
-0.3171284794807434,
0.44571274518966675,
0.2657940685749054,
-0.2924736440181732,
0.2009730339050293,
-0.11858757585287094,
0.20598702132701874,
0.05872722342610359,
0.24977846443653107,
0.01625978574156761,
-0.3052537143230438,
-0.60524582862854,
-0.37190574407577515,
0.43830570578575134,
0.24662069976329803,
-0.736450731754303,
0.37486082315444946,
0.030260398983955383,
-0.3085708022117615,
-0.5079852342605591,
-0.04164278134703636,
0.4298505187034607,
0.5444425344467163,
0.7936273813247681,
-0.2371269315481186,
-0.5101639032363892,
-0.881123423576355,
-0.4707185626029968,
-0.048612624406814575,
-0.08802279084920883,
-0.11560391634702682,
0.44496965408325195,
-0.3467150926589966,
0.9010794758796692,
-0.24577540159225464,
-0.4923129081726074,
-0.5489969253540039,
0.28106820583343506,
0.3135063648223877,
0.47776666283607483,
0.17883531749248505,
-0.85613614320755,
-0.6608626246452332,
0.038748614490032196,
-0.7874631285667419,
-0.3275359272956848,
0.19289088249206543,
0.18941901624202728,
-0.1843423843383789,
0.5527588725090027,
-0.5460453033447266,
0.2608470618724823,
0.7395794987678528,
-0.5271864533424377,
0.7581055760383606,
-0.47564154863357544,
-0.15461474657058716,
-0.5607229471206665,
0.22963100671768188,
-0.3477676808834076,
-0.3938984274864197,
-1.0094887018203735,
0.06719310581684113,
0.15283744037151337,
0.11778759956359863,
-0.7922055721282959,
0.7012313604354858,
-0.5700273513793945,
-0.26872822642326355,
-0.6195198893547058,
-0.26454871892929077,
0.12166982144117355,
0.20477046072483063,
0.15914534032344818,
0.7378584742546082,
0.573079526424408,
-0.5077722072601318,
0.0789189413189888,
0.2212556153535843,
-0.34272903203964233,
0.010744422674179077,
-0.7358850240707397,
0.024955833330750465,
-0.16354461014270782,
0.22319193184375763,
-0.4460805356502533,
-0.1949087530374527,
0.19586171209812164,
-0.23531411588191986,
0.3039029538631439,
0.34260767698287964,
-0.6424099802970886,
-0.3504611849784851,
-0.2663506269454956,
0.4223468601703644,
0.2617843747138977,
-0.13464701175689697,
0.6274392604827881,
0.26617392897605896,
-0.07795684039592743,
-0.3183145523071289,
-0.7705178260803223,
0.029458895325660706,
0.1625213772058487,
-0.12495903670787811,
0.5186284780502319,
-0.24478526413440704,
-0.04558033496141434,
0.05123281851410866,
-0.02402932569384575,
-0.029968824237585068,
-0.1390996277332306,
0.14359818398952484,
-0.21064139902591705,
0.07039725035429001,
0.31146928668022156,
-0.05577947944402695,
-0.11128456145524979,
-0.39119651913642883,
-0.7062910795211792,
0.9123355150222778,
-0.2360621988773346,
-0.5006549954414368,
-0.15187019109725952,
0.5500674843788147,
0.5408027768135071,
-0.4745071828365326,
0.8906217217445374,
0.7606256604194641,
-0.12186509370803833,
0.03574570268392563,
-0.1975104808807373,
-0.3975585997104645,
-0.4232965409755707,
0.7327585816383362,
-0.3847356140613556,
-0.7984890937805176,
0.20776526629924774,
-0.11267264932394028,
0.09433624893426895,
-0.07971584796905518,
0.597378671169281,
-0.4489276707172394,
0.8034927248954773,
0.8157468438148499,
0.48800915479660034,
0.4002753496170044,
-0.17403262853622437,
0.44119980931282043,
-0.8548057079315186,
-0.4165858030319214,
-0.12041626125574112,
-0.6730785369873047,
-0.072406105697155,
-0.7077580094337463,
0.317187637090683,
0.5035990476608276,
-0.43777546286582947,
0.33774760365486145,
-0.019184624776244164,
0.26328444480895996,
0.7159883379936218,
0.17477940022945404,
0.36678147315979004,
-0.06953845173120499,
-0.252450168132782,
-0.10050348937511444,
-0.8768816590309143,
-0.3124420642852783,
0.7890645265579224,
0.1921699196100235,
0.6849086880683899,
-0.008402115665376186,
0.45728611946105957,
0.38418760895729065,
0.4520152509212494,
-0.7751638889312744,
0.5638675093650818,
-0.7455030679702759,
-0.33238863945007324,
-0.1987280398607254,
-0.0248162429779768,
-0.7262594103813171,
0.16841697692871094,
-0.12728461623191833,
-0.5602877736091614,
-0.017765676602721214,
0.045293040573596954,
-0.010309098288416862,
0.10722271353006363,
-0.45210808515548706,
0.7726945877075195,
-0.641914963722229,
-0.37594637274742126,
-0.05560069903731346,
-0.7179538607597351,
0.12775211036205292,
-0.47869178652763367,
0.1508282721042633,
-0.22886459529399872,
-0.13782203197479248,
0.5542433261871338,
-0.7483782768249512,
0.7325957417488098,
-0.07967618107795715,
0.01962449587881565,
0.21827326714992523,
0.31868577003479004,
0.4704672396183014,
0.0074937292374670506,
-0.19930429756641388,
0.08852007240056992,
-0.1276274472475052,
-0.4709162414073944,
-0.34866082668304443,
0.436338871717453,
-0.6076478362083435,
-0.5530545115470886,
-0.3506813645362854,
-0.8114681839942932,
-0.3605697751045227,
0.32605496048927307,
0.5639885067939758,
0.5384697914123535,
0.2401730865240097,
0.4629415273666382,
0.4973355233669281,
-0.4323618710041046,
0.37108495831489563,
0.9072974920272827,
-0.49270325899124146,
-0.2630371153354645,
0.7941787242889404,
0.32274287939071655,
0.21425935626029968,
0.7296674251556396,
0.0866042897105217,
-0.5378188490867615,
-0.8865686655044556,
0.05713137239217758,
0.3099258542060852,
-0.4023115932941437,
-0.32031551003456116,
-1.0766898393630981,
-0.3719770014286041,
-0.2648388147354126,
-0.2763238549232483,
-0.33005353808403015,
-0.022857090458273888,
-0.17442569136619568,
0.07247921079397202,
0.2881026864051819,
0.3500092923641205,
0.05304844304919243,
0.3730475604534149,
-1.0146267414093018,
0.24875427782535553,
0.36807122826576233,
0.3047626316547394,
-0.32028651237487793,
-0.6503058075904846,
-0.28506240248680115,
0.14350228011608124,
0.06824000179767609,
-0.879862904548645,
0.713028609752655,
0.900591254234314,
0.6984813213348389,
0.026820233091711998,
0.23748885095119476,
0.31199824810028076,
-0.43426820635795593,
0.7082083225250244,
0.2261989265680313,
-0.7557314038276672,
0.5737147331237793,
-0.18537846207618713,
0.7822065949440002,
0.4378727078437805,
0.7609853744506836,
-0.3746005892753601,
-0.6603879332542419,
-0.26400110125541687,
-0.8526583909988403,
0.571053683757782,
0.000010339563232264481,
-0.11231125891208649,
-0.2425321787595749,
0.052278608083724976,
0.4496062695980072,
0.37767574191093445,
-0.990966260433197,
0.19585494697093964,
-0.030622052028775215,
-0.2656099200248718,
-0.009193798527121544,
-0.43273240327835083,
-0.2090931534767151,
-0.30549144744873047,
0.6753849387168884,
-0.47927573323249817,
0.1260218769311905,
0.15733113884925842,
-0.5646092295646667,
0.09785860776901245,
0.12906217575073242,
0.3578454256057739,
0.4780874252319336,
-0.3724134862422943,
0.5309967994689941,
-0.0013545382535085082,
-0.6249306201934814,
0.07622601836919785,
-0.01394171454012394,
-0.1722053736448288,
-0.15299057960510254,
0.8220869302749634,
0.6713888645172119,
-0.04285787045955658,
-1.0819448232650757,
0.41336143016815186,
-0.020739158615469933,
-0.3380117118358612,
0.22697880864143372,
-0.27707698941230774,
0.38539189100265503,
0.5610639452934265,
0.5873479247093201,
-0.40528208017349243,
0.07651866972446442,
-0.7637784481048584,
0.5301569700241089,
0.4044599235057831,
-0.5070315599441528,
-0.6404961347579956,
0.686504602432251,
0.005969500169157982,
-0.3545108437538147,
0.5169655680656433,
-0.17856721580028534,
-0.5750873684883118,
0.22160987555980682,
0.9414893984794617,
0.8492289781570435,
-0.049588706344366074,
0.3536359965801239,
-0.03583776205778122,
-0.11494672298431396,
0.08983426541090012,
0.5433443188667297,
0.1431627869606018,
-0.5805517435073853,
-0.45175978541374207,
-1.3369088172912598,
0.03737296536564827,
0.24070189893245697,
-0.1414438635110855,
0.29596954584121704,
-0.37215355038642883,
-0.1720142364501953,
-0.12342393398284912,
0.17967893183231354,
-0.5539617538452148,
0.10161278396844864,
0.056302353739738464,
1.151586651802063,
-0.7478169798851013,
1.6044344902038574,
0.9987319111824036,
-0.4020494818687439,
-0.37497377395629883,
0.15272457897663116,
-0.2456323206424713,
-0.5736446976661682,
1.4187349081039429,
0.21263886988162994,
-0.04384876415133476,
0.34075963497161865,
-0.28376880288124084,
-0.667559802532196,
0.9307998418807983,
0.477754682302475,
-0.8044499158859253,
0.013079925440251827,
0.32311591506004333,
0.6807695627212524,
-0.5679575800895691,
0.14032897353172302,
0.40868809819221497,
0.4046134948730469,
-0.047575343400239944,
-0.8659586906433105,
-0.23820392787456512,
-0.1545202136039734,
-0.2662090063095093,
-0.08889950811862946,
-0.7562184929847717,
1.2001842260360718,
0.018096456304192543,
0.07646631449460983,
-0.2558937966823578,
0.647916316986084,
0.26064735651016235,
0.02009960077702999,
0.17881664633750916,
0.1594999134540558,
0.5567963719367981,
0.19183413684368134,
0.8279753923416138,
-0.3177446722984314,
0.14580830931663513,
1.2938482761383057,
-0.5748279094696045,
0.8929275870323181,
0.6264042854309082,
-0.23832149803638458,
0.16107672452926636,
0.43065622448921204,
0.4216269552707672,
0.8661266565322876,
0.3009180426597595,
-0.5322062373161316,
-0.339489221572876,
-0.5110971331596375,
-0.4433455467224121,
0.6755045652389526,
0.412735253572464,
-0.18704795837402344,
-0.3714750111103058,
0.5728153586387634,
-0.3044772148132324,
-0.019699281081557274,
-0.19691970944404602,
0.6367916464805603,
0.25501006841659546,
-0.1256610006093979,
0.5395777821540833,
-0.23299990594387054,
0.5655087232589722,
-0.9569382667541504,
0.2072208970785141,
-0.3257546126842499,
0.2686280310153961,
-0.05460270866751671,
-0.7903441786766052,
0.38750678300857544,
-0.06424758583307266,
-0.19373591244220734,
-0.19939126074314117,
0.7792103886604309,
-0.9344725608825684,
-0.41313230991363525,
0.5925420522689819,
0.5437219142913818,
0.08904097229242325,
-0.18965955078601837,
-0.709896981716156,
0.2568335235118866,
-0.10265182703733444,
-0.3947318494319916,
0.7477856278419495,
0.28025662899017334,
-0.04287238046526909,
0.7657555937767029,
0.45009714365005493,
0.2649674117565155,
-0.09129387885332108,
0.127714604139328,
1.0432202816009521,
-0.5123370885848999,
-0.34673088788986206,
-0.9398680329322815,
0.3887379765510559,
0.01823410391807556,
0.23247979581356049,
0.5422223210334778,
0.573239803314209,
0.6863083839416504,
-0.3511078953742981,
0.7267243266105652,
-0.24264059960842133,
0.38025495409965515,
-0.44269895553588867,
0.7502108812332153,
-0.693932831287384,
-0.07825396209955215,
0.24672257900238037,
-0.8781974911689758,
-0.6724597811698914,
0.3792927861213684,
-0.325980007648468,
-0.3268163502216339,
0.8176587820053101,
0.7433358430862427,
0.015671683475375175,
-0.01398328598588705,
0.5032368302345276,
0.32106345891952515,
0.6727339625358582,
0.5288875102996826,
0.723968505859375,
-0.3813861608505249,
0.2685661017894745,
0.22314947843551636,
-0.20101279020309448,
-0.5516960024833679,
-1.1376744508743286,
-0.8008410930633545,
-0.6637136340141296,
-0.20983244478702545,
0.03929070755839348,
0.3525836169719696,
1.1015541553497314,
0.7672836184501648,
-0.899246096611023,
-0.2636420726776123,
-0.2617763578891754,
-0.4600737690925598,
-0.12794949114322662,
-0.13365410268306732,
0.21397021412849426,
-0.564362645149231,
-0.6728543043136597,
0.7161154747009277,
0.6456830501556396,
0.22374750673770905,
-0.11095414310693741,
-0.23205821216106415,
-0.8311776518821716,
-0.09968353062868118,
1.0096650123596191,
0.42457348108291626,
-0.6007379293441772,
-0.2912304103374481,
-0.06538598239421844,
0.011438444256782532,
-0.28859591484069824,
0.8892115354537964,
-0.8401012420654297,
0.47439831495285034,
0.7226991653442383,
0.6988553404808044,
0.3369687795639038,
-0.21314774453639984,
0.9616404175758362,
-0.8274588584899902,
0.4539111852645874,
0.369306355714798,
0.13857004046440125,
0.16212797164916992,
-0.2543107569217682,
0.36530837416648865,
0.19348733127117157,
-0.4063202738761902,
-0.8451948761940002,
0.2870328724384308,
-0.7483444213867188,
-0.7088474631309509,
0.9103357791900635,
-0.34755635261535645,
-0.10807379335165024,
-0.26191020011901855,
-0.09970124810934067,
0.42878609895706177,
0.17335526645183563,
0.5326760411262512,
0.4732518494129181,
-0.290693461894989,
-0.13171501457691193,
-0.5943590998649597,
0.7390124797821045,
0.4063253104686737,
-0.723810613155365,
0.2985536754131317,
0.13240109384059906,
-0.01773960515856743,
-0.2518426477909088,
0.9366398453712463,
-0.1990349143743515,
-0.03568591922521591,
-0.13624829053878784,
-0.07712309807538986,
-0.4388057291507721,
-0.5820534229278564,
0.13646665215492249,
0.31975775957107544,
0.21711768209934235,
0.05143715441226959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17959v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17959v2
|
An Iterative Associative Memory Model for Empathetic Response Generation
| 2024-02-28T00:49:06 | 2024-06-02T10:46:13 |
Zhou Yang, Zhaochun Ren, Yufeng Wang, Chao Chen, Haizhou Sun, Xiaofei Zhu, Xiangwen Liao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Empathetic response generation aims to comprehend the cognitive and emotional
states in dialogue utterances and generate proper responses. Psychological
theories posit that comprehending emotional and cognitive states necessitates
iteratively capturing and understanding associated words across dialogue
utterances. However, existing approaches regard dialogue utterances as either a
long sequence or independent utterances for comprehension, which are prone to
overlook the associated words between them. To address this issue, we propose
an Iterative Associative Memory Model (IAMM) for empathetic response
generation. Specifically, we employ a novel second-order interaction attention
mechanism to iteratively capture vital associated words between dialogue
utterances and situations, dialogue history, and a memory module (for storing
associated words), thereby accurately and nuancedly comprehending the
utterances. We conduct experiments on the Empathetic-Dialogue dataset. Both
automatic and human evaluations validate the efficacy of the model. Variant
experiments on LLMs also demonstrate that attending to associated words
improves empathetic comprehension and expression.
|
[
-0.31837597489356995,
-0.8494024276733398,
0.6439442038536072,
0.256570965051651,
-0.26640960574150085,
-0.16988889873027802,
-0.04284864664077759,
-0.07695774734020233,
0.26288118958473206,
0.4358673095703125,
-0.66897052526474,
-0.1325959414243698,
-0.4498923718929291,
0.09357229620218277,
-0.3430706858634949,
0.7928385734558105,
-0.21672163903713226,
0.028874846175312996,
-0.2549203336238861,
-0.41086384654045105,
-0.2910003364086151,
-0.568106472492218,
-0.997486412525177,
-0.4854782521724701,
0.43357259035110474,
0.27255314588546753,
-0.008567151613533497,
0.4529784321784973,
0.4575170874595642,
0.32434386014938354,
0.011408276855945587,
0.1788560301065445,
-0.361206591129303,
0.3375551998615265,
0.08580265939235687,
-0.2626045048236847,
-0.36615902185440063,
-0.003549144836142659,
0.29018697142601013,
0.2882051467895508,
-0.5100739002227783,
0.11001580208539963,
-0.0894642248749733,
0.3945278525352478,
-0.567138671875,
0.14242716133594513,
-0.7148357033729553,
0.23838426172733307,
0.5030196309089661,
-0.6896624565124512,
-0.5914170145988464,
-0.2217932939529419,
0.32703712582588196,
-0.326214998960495,
0.07904361933469772,
0.20148564875125885,
0.07845177501440048,
0.2744353413581848,
-0.195172980427742,
-0.6169716715812683,
-0.5821531414985657,
0.5054855942726135,
-0.6738250851631165,
-0.02629903331398964,
0.5598511099815369,
0.016095798462629318,
0.14848138391971588,
-0.3848537802696228,
-0.5802654027938843,
-0.4269159734249115,
0.05346968397498131,
0.49400025606155396,
-0.24805454909801483,
0.22799845039844513,
0.17791645228862762,
0.3257346749305725,
-0.2964000105857849,
-0.2814577519893646,
-0.17935194075107574,
-0.02399463579058647,
0.38072875142097473,
0.7887623906135559,
0.18293505907058716,
-0.13006505370140076,
-0.28431087732315063,
0.10698994994163513,
-0.19333331286907196,
0.02919401228427887,
0.01808467134833336,
0.21367594599723816,
-0.14196117222309113,
0.6706889867782593,
0.23399518430233002,
0.4702090919017792,
0.45644253492355347,
-0.23515498638153076,
-0.16425105929374695,
-0.2752475440502167,
-0.0365213043987751,
0.28307095170021057,
0.6616588830947876,
0.5845754742622375,
0.2676497995853424,
-0.18548345565795898,
0.15593482553958893,
0.4470890760421753,
0.527096688747406,
-0.8378177881240845,
-0.3672086000442505,
0.5470055341720581,
-0.3694226145744324,
-0.09614536911249161,
-0.46055421233177185,
-0.716793954372406,
-0.08600552380084991,
-0.1182224377989769,
0.45311424136161804,
-0.7280170321464539,
-0.14483019709587097,
-0.1833726018667221,
-0.09967029839754105,
0.1903923898935318,
0.18244919180870056,
-0.7860730886459351,
0.42006027698516846,
0.2734537422657013,
0.8966981768608093,
0.03830213472247124,
-0.20347966253757477,
-0.6544815301895142,
0.35221996903419495,
0.10599708557128906,
0.8108205199241638,
-0.7765066027641296,
-0.6061531901359558,
-0.08364389836788177,
-0.23777638375759125,
-0.16765862703323364,
-0.31057044863700867,
0.06780527532100677,
-0.2721601724624634,
0.08446187525987625,
-0.046939872205257416,
-0.6884007453918457,
-0.3235373795032501,
0.4770410656929016,
-0.5485012531280518,
0.5758639574050903,
0.149513840675354,
-0.7562677264213562,
-0.16664735972881317,
-0.4060228765010834,
-0.38046059012413025,
-0.3716845214366913,
-0.14669299125671387,
-0.4356287717819214,
0.4150410294532776,
0.009866452775895596,
0.24182190001010895,
-0.44942402839660645,
0.012800457887351513,
-0.34814387559890747,
-0.07927870005369186,
0.4551599323749542,
-0.2798357903957367,
0.31758353114128113,
0.09507501870393753,
-0.1188591718673706,
-0.19120517373085022,
-0.7152659893035889,
0.1129407286643982,
0.12097350507974625,
-0.3297960162162781,
-0.23456865549087524,
-0.26639461517333984,
-0.23634406924247742,
0.34279319643974304,
-0.037851482629776,
-0.683542788028717,
-0.14479674398899078,
-0.25645801424980164,
0.5670689940452576,
0.6887169480323792,
0.473640114068985,
0.6530466079711914,
-0.38708963990211487,
0.49328741431236267,
0.5379055142402649,
-0.035151880234479904,
-0.8536098003387451,
-0.09529761970043182,
-0.7914771437644958,
-0.042583636939525604,
-0.20314182341098785,
0.43608662486076355,
-0.3894638419151306,
0.1596398949623108,
0.21129971742630005,
-0.2795358896255493,
-0.9001997709274292,
-0.11127705127000809,
0.7896550297737122,
0.7507185935974121,
0.41503819823265076,
-0.7386391758918762,
-0.40853333473205566,
-0.5511105060577393,
-0.037126198410987854,
-0.4306912422180176,
0.20537620782852173,
0.6662573218345642,
0.22452561557292938,
-0.20268598198890686,
0.5684225559234619,
-0.35254383087158203,
-0.24876655638217926,
0.013046039268374443,
0.535396158695221,
-0.45437273383140564,
0.13641567528247833,
0.07756875455379486,
-0.4480695426464081,
-0.1280890256166458,
-0.13588328659534454,
-0.5066474080085754,
-0.018097184598445892,
-0.18274249136447906,
-0.1405487209558487,
0.21069563925266266,
0.27111122012138367,
-0.6340000033378601,
0.46178725361824036,
0.300478458404541,
-0.29175877571105957,
-0.05393536761403084,
-0.18825705349445343,
0.30225658416748047,
-1.2064757347106934,
0.2173164188861847,
-0.06865426898002625,
0.11391191929578781,
-0.5085200667381287,
-0.16252948343753815,
-0.09725220501422882,
-0.03133608028292656,
-0.2838543653488159,
0.7841950058937073,
-0.4830627143383026,
-0.18910691142082214,
-0.3167194128036499,
0.27294084429740906,
-0.05472567304968834,
0.6421900391578674,
0.053716015070676804,
0.4080354869365692,
0.37927520275115967,
-0.7736958265304565,
0.34842222929000854,
0.7297248244285583,
0.1630033403635025,
0.8999140858650208,
-0.40562790632247925,
0.40692728757858276,
-0.39743921160697937,
0.2990309000015259,
-1.1189393997192383,
-0.14135979115962982,
0.28879138827323914,
-0.5704305768013,
0.25807255506515503,
0.31781455874443054,
-0.27863943576812744,
-0.47594672441482544,
-0.14792115986347198,
0.5715159773826599,
0.4664965271949768,
-0.468009352684021,
1.000732660293579,
0.2619147300720215,
-0.31169870495796204,
-0.04517793282866478,
-0.5764405727386475,
-0.21128065884113312,
-0.2681460380554199,
-0.47566288709640503,
-0.04498683288693428,
-0.3579184412956238,
-0.42370572686195374,
-0.1476489007472992,
0.0844794511795044,
0.04318065568804741,
-0.10527439415454865,
0.2547984719276428,
-0.1267322152853012,
0.08945303410291672,
0.15866252779960632,
-0.03736564889550209,
-0.21461349725723267,
0.1773415058851242,
0.48014184832572937,
0.7544106245040894,
0.2534462809562683,
-0.25896090269088745,
-0.5778831839561462,
0.8230831027030945,
0.569930911064148,
-0.3072375953197479,
0.44059252738952637,
0.507745623588562,
-0.22092975676059723,
0.1504380702972412,
-0.4879818558692932,
-0.4755087196826935,
-0.39561939239501953,
0.18300917744636536,
-0.49734577536582947,
-0.5311465859413147,
0.8797743916511536,
-0.14970438182353973,
0.13499398529529572,
-0.006929299328476191,
0.79087895154953,
-0.1413394659757614,
1.4092692136764526,
0.3313949704170227,
-0.19281627237796783,
0.41550979018211365,
-0.04465659707784653,
0.4980437755584717,
-1.2808784246444702,
-0.0827186331152916,
-0.1521962583065033,
-0.23214593529701233,
-0.14780645072460175,
-0.21502980589866638,
0.4046877920627594,
-0.3504800498485565,
-0.4993159770965576,
-0.08435219526290894,
-0.19769316911697388,
0.00906077865511179,
0.3394376337528229,
0.416152685880661,
0.4977055788040161,
-0.06240670010447502,
-0.05426056310534477,
-0.09247481822967529,
-0.4798887073993683,
-0.24768218398094177,
0.783147394657135,
0.29874318838119507,
1.0007977485656738,
0.06566347926855087,
0.874233067035675,
-0.05274808034300804,
0.4338770806789398,
-0.9546718001365662,
0.48139578104019165,
0.02548358030617237,
-0.25705787539482117,
0.14151020348072052,
-0.15088210999965668,
-0.6560102701187134,
-0.04890216886997223,
0.3013085424900055,
-1.1679767370224,
-0.14875754714012146,
0.37188029289245605,
-0.7424981594085693,
-0.042407650500535965,
-0.5453416109085083,
0.06120011955499649,
-0.1185288205742836,
-0.47294002771377563,
-0.3320475220680237,
-0.8449096083641052,
0.40503770112991333,
-0.026971202343702316,
-0.17265933752059937,
0.11703237891197205,
0.19817934930324554,
0.5478783845901489,
-0.39286813139915466,
0.7566767930984497,
-0.056827764958143234,
-0.15258856117725372,
0.3997046947479248,
0.3591598570346832,
0.539679765701294,
-0.08522041141986847,
-0.3152007758617401,
-0.33314189314842224,
-0.3563026785850525,
-0.11068081855773926,
-0.4935818612575531,
0.6744059920310974,
-0.5269616842269897,
-0.5692679286003113,
-0.23145027458667755,
-0.7482293844223022,
-0.2509997487068176,
-0.37037229537963867,
0.35960912704467773,
0.43676304817199707,
-0.430722713470459,
-0.20210178196430206,
0.686145544052124,
-0.1463746279478073,
0.43686971068382263,
0.7387498617172241,
0.030660036951303482,
-0.3569094240665436,
0.5569883584976196,
-0.1955089271068573,
0.47603869438171387,
0.14069022238254547,
-0.07019247859716415,
0.01893606409430504,
0.09896331280469894,
-0.2088233232498169,
0.2318696528673172,
-0.4873030185699463,
-0.41553837060928345,
-1.2340712547302246,
-0.2197883129119873,
-0.17104527354240417,
-0.19077962636947632,
-0.39464566111564636,
-0.12104219198226929,
-0.2972264289855957,
-0.17772316932678223,
0.8940310478210449,
0.5145999193191528,
-0.20938338339328766,
0.36834990978240967,
-0.8264166116714478,
0.6066297292709351,
0.2449311912059784,
0.08342117071151733,
0.5229540467262268,
-0.6534301042556763,
0.022511949762701988,
0.08298934996128082,
-0.5915685892105103,
-0.8281363248825073,
0.6867048144340515,
0.20588503777980804,
0.264384388923645,
0.37727752327919006,
-0.11552742123603821,
0.8203937411308289,
-0.5704445838928223,
0.610080897808075,
0.370350182056427,
-0.7982010841369629,
0.6269095540046692,
-0.16287541389465332,
0.500880777835846,
0.5717280507087708,
0.19719670712947845,
-0.5958595871925354,
-0.6290801763534546,
-0.7561153173446655,
-1.0878334045410156,
0.7427744269371033,
0.1881636381149292,
0.331935316324234,
-0.36893826723098755,
0.4545351266860962,
0.04632902145385742,
0.1988767385482788,
-0.304056316614151,
-0.2459104210138321,
0.14995384216308594,
-0.4083141088485718,
-0.09582854062318802,
-0.2697641849517822,
-0.5521197319030762,
-0.001863974379375577,
0.39416739344596863,
-0.1662251502275467,
1.048588752746582,
0.22626963257789612,
-0.02765585668385029,
-0.7484902143478394,
-0.07561954855918884,
0.2838709354400635,
-0.020505251362919807,
-0.23607632517814636,
0.04231297969818115,
0.14839795231819153,
-0.16938069462776184,
0.18035323917865753,
-0.03842362016439438,
0.2764391005039215,
-0.21638868749141693,
0.08406928926706314,
0.7058592438697815,
0.28459832072257996,
-0.6722680330276489,
0.33021196722984314,
-0.34758979082107544,
0.13234694302082062,
-0.3756554126739502,
0.0656203031539917,
0.3322611153125763,
0.5339390635490417,
0.009680763818323612,
-0.2192857563495636,
0.3850371241569519,
-0.9400650858879089,
0.46189361810684204,
0.30393046140670776,
-0.26352837681770325,
-0.22546716034412384,
0.5983118414878845,
0.09377249330282211,
-0.6108061671257019,
0.5952795743942261,
0.22332186996936798,
-0.6803233027458191,
0.6937159299850464,
0.8974383473396301,
1.006820559501648,
-0.6546128988265991,
0.1709628850221634,
0.7101195454597473,
-0.278979629278183,
-0.014437968842685223,
0.5602272748947144,
-0.49200472235679626,
-0.6411066055297852,
0.34291642904281616,
-0.5766543745994568,
-0.6460745930671692,
-0.2389352172613144,
-1.1197717189788818,
-0.27715352177619934,
-0.5810605883598328,
-0.12637540698051453,
-0.20878520607948303,
-0.2493961751461029,
-0.7606905102729797,
0.37550070881843567,
0.10577273368835449,
0.7068516612052917,
-0.7586023807525635,
0.3692174553871155,
0.3255489766597748,
-0.451772004365921,
-0.7996717691421509,
0.22827978432178497,
0.08067730814218521,
-1.1629186868667603,
0.2658464014530182,
0.38271209597587585,
-0.22340598702430725,
0.3009263575077057,
-0.3359559178352356,
-0.7366805672645569,
1.3289533853530884,
-0.2509627342224121,
-0.5504366159439087,
-0.014946969226002693,
-0.11935209482908249,
0.705864667892456,
-0.8744969367980957,
0.6056427359580994,
0.8842280507087708,
0.23906077444553375,
0.3082587718963623,
-0.6203898787498474,
0.15112364292144775,
-0.384013295173645,
0.18943668901920319,
0.1481771022081375,
-1.1691908836364746,
0.7006363272666931,
-0.5931940078735352,
-0.07772292196750641,
0.7071376442909241,
0.26998379826545715,
0.6089239716529846,
0.5748997926712036,
0.13410161435604095,
0.7899450659751892,
0.4233407974243164,
0.10305275022983551,
1.075892448425293,
-0.4145751893520355,
0.05740618333220482,
1.3469854593276978,
-0.3951098620891571,
0.9324884414672852,
0.7228054404258728,
0.2970225214958191,
0.2503253221511841,
0.5596809387207031,
0.2701690196990967,
0.8196853995323181,
0.06751411408185959,
-0.5834555625915527,
-0.07626224309206009,
-0.4093002676963806,
-0.10349003970623016,
0.6496703624725342,
0.4925056993961334,
-0.8365684151649475,
-0.1095491573214531,
0.14746002852916718,
-0.03841955587267876,
-0.09113210439682007,
-0.41715627908706665,
1.3235853910446167,
0.48822706937789917,
-0.9418270587921143,
0.21880292892456055,
-0.28909698128700256,
0.1981063336133957,
-0.3256371319293976,
-0.20504330098628998,
-0.4591979682445526,
0.22043423354625702,
0.1852532923221588,
-0.7227660417556763,
0.16281628608703613,
0.11975812166929245,
-0.15886972844600677,
0.035306863486766815,
0.5864614844322205,
-0.753036379814148,
-0.15856656432151794,
0.6688278913497925,
0.3195353150367737,
-0.15022307634353638,
0.3407537043094635,
-0.5835893750190735,
0.07588265091180801,
-0.060617949813604355,
-0.5481870174407959,
0.18444079160690308,
0.47500666975975037,
0.41983702778816223,
0.7551113367080688,
0.14983682334423065,
-0.3174295127391815,
-0.04836485907435417,
-0.0012202081270515919,
0.9397250413894653,
-0.8831838965415955,
-0.5495997667312622,
-0.7510799765586853,
0.6842341423034668,
0.06880651414394379,
-0.21295422315597534,
0.28478261828422546,
-0.028686363250017166,
0.2993146479129791,
0.06643096357584,
0.7816363573074341,
0.05538724362850189,
0.41443580389022827,
-0.566611111164093,
0.165598526597023,
-0.5229272842407227,
-0.025200188159942627,
-0.19136352837085724,
-0.7722113132476807,
-0.03230816125869751,
0.841704785823822,
-0.24357454478740692,
0.15553367137908936,
0.6675287485122681,
0.7994527816772461,
0.08197635412216187,
0.2729124128818512,
0.275089830160141,
0.6042814254760742,
-0.013710829429328442,
1.0651122331619263,
0.7442576289176941,
-0.4777524173259735,
0.15841931104660034,
-0.0031761149875819683,
-0.08497391641139984,
-0.28275108337402344,
-0.5078394412994385,
-0.850100576877594,
-0.4973810911178589,
-0.10913671553134918,
-0.5657253265380859,
0.014430096372961998,
0.9983682036399841,
0.07650669664144516,
-0.4824933111667633,
-0.026839716359972954,
-0.303192138671875,
-0.5065314769744873,
0.16909410059452057,
-0.2669473886489868,
-0.10388989746570587,
-0.09719943255186081,
-0.6437596678733826,
-0.09924681484699249,
0.7207974195480347,
0.11002832651138306,
-0.20812149345874786,
-0.3056126832962036,
-0.12128863483667374,
0.5444130897521973,
0.4304378032684326,
0.38665980100631714,
-0.5960972309112549,
-0.21518607437610626,
-0.14098137617111206,
-0.10089288651943207,
0.2763609290122986,
0.9850233793258667,
-0.5422080159187317,
0.7724349498748779,
0.07331066578626633,
0.5118153095245361,
0.46439075469970703,
0.1403399258852005,
0.9008418321609497,
-0.4878811538219452,
0.03487163409590721,
0.3241094946861267,
0.3496440649032593,
0.46568334102630615,
-0.5210076570510864,
0.3723074793815613,
-0.31067246198654175,
-0.49579522013664246,
-0.5707193613052368,
0.47509536147117615,
-1.1988799571990967,
0.17652691900730133,
1.2888885736465454,
-0.3247910141944885,
-0.26181840896606445,
0.2516379952430725,
-0.519565999507904,
0.6067759394645691,
-0.6065638661384583,
1.1141650676727295,
0.598151683807373,
-0.57887864112854,
-0.48233768343925476,
0.019911568611860275,
0.21833597123622894,
0.5500515699386597,
-0.780860185623169,
0.2523304522037506,
0.4788624048233032,
-0.03495950996875763,
0.19853278994560242,
1.0007773637771606,
-0.03119240142405033,
0.5649007558822632,
0.10269962251186371,
-0.146864116191864,
0.5357003211975098,
-0.19093604385852814,
-0.39784878492355347,
-0.04841209948062897,
-0.1224776953458786,
-0.041243430227041245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17954v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17954v2
|
Twists, Humps, and Pebbles: Multilingual Speech Recognition Models Exhibit Gender Performance Gaps
| 2024-02-28T00:24:29 | 2024-06-19T13:42:48 |
Giuseppe Attanasio, Beatrice Savoldi, Dennis Fucci, Dirk Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current automatic speech recognition (ASR) models are designed to be used
across many languages and tasks without substantial changes. However, this
broad language coverage hides performance gaps within languages, for example,
across genders. Our study systematically evaluates the performance of two
widely used multilingual ASR models on three datasets, encompassing 19
languages from eight language families and two speaking conditions. Our
findings reveal clear gender disparities, with the advantaged group varying
across languages and models. Surprisingly, those gaps are not explained by
acoustic or lexical properties. However, probing internal model states reveals
a correlation with gendered performance gap. I.e., the easier it is to
distinguish speaker gender in a language using probes, the more the gap
reduces, favoring female speakers. Our results show that gender disparities
persist even in state-of-the-art models. Our findings have implications for the
improvement of multilingual ASR systems, underscoring the importance of
accessibility to training data and nuanced evaluation to predict and mitigate
gender gaps. We release all code and artifacts at
https://github.com/g8a9/multilingual-asr-gender-gap.
|
[
-0.21239595115184784,
-0.2515503764152527,
0.14233170449733734,
0.2088836282491684,
0.2352396696805954,
0.5134170055389404,
-0.0755055695772171,
-0.7176035642623901,
-0.49785083532333374,
0.07496420294046402,
-0.5343111157417297,
-0.007265259511768818,
-0.9884262084960938,
0.28762051463127136,
-0.5541378259658813,
0.5200649499893188,
0.20325757563114166,
0.5599333047866821,
-0.13040897250175476,
-0.1289626508951187,
-0.7212184071540833,
-0.4942733645439148,
-0.31621965765953064,
-0.5925493240356445,
0.23884837329387665,
0.1895490437746048,
0.740667998790741,
0.6914455890655518,
0.43181753158569336,
0.31258663535118103,
-0.4842120409011841,
0.11547304689884186,
-0.06282181292772293,
0.08546613901853561,
0.21481594443321228,
-0.0675911158323288,
-0.2711865305900574,
-0.047579217702150345,
0.9981721043586731,
1.0485197305679321,
-0.24530509114265442,
0.0336373895406723,
0.4078192114830017,
0.6665778756141663,
-0.5000972747802734,
0.13901810348033905,
-0.473037451505661,
0.1311856210231781,
-0.5102266073226929,
-0.03295101225376129,
-0.09164626896381378,
-0.17799681425094604,
0.3432455360889435,
-0.21298764646053314,
0.5318713784217834,
-0.13492628931999207,
0.718890905380249,
0.21111707389354706,
-0.5389581322669983,
-0.54713374376297,
-0.9398394227027893,
0.6157935857772827,
-0.5050126910209656,
1.0926589965820312,
0.4669623374938965,
0.46882906556129456,
-0.08795217424631119,
-0.13694797456264496,
-0.3163979649543762,
-0.2642472982406616,
0.1090344488620758,
-0.41297489404678345,
-0.2920653522014618,
-0.31373971700668335,
0.40057045221328735,
0.442025750875473,
-0.7663360238075256,
0.15960118174552917,
-0.7041543126106262,
-0.08157508820295334,
0.5700235366821289,
-0.09433342516422272,
0.37926793098449707,
0.20985759794712067,
-0.03863781690597534,
-0.09610191732645035,
-0.7158010005950928,
0.4795929193496704,
0.7609531879425049,
0.9960457682609558,
-0.4040144085884094,
0.5473951697349548,
0.18195860087871552,
0.6190811395645142,
0.05700407922267914,
-0.32821762561798096,
0.45571866631507874,
-0.02551043964922428,
0.19218872487545013,
0.32465431094169617,
0.6271538138389587,
-0.21352729201316833,
0.28880006074905396,
-0.1755242496728897,
-0.16980862617492676,
0.03566790372133255,
-0.05559780076146126,
-0.45857924222946167,
-0.3055116534233093,
-0.2193843573331833,
-0.18841791152954102,
0.2979467809200287,
-0.04173334687948227,
-0.5238355994224548,
-0.7292757630348206,
-0.2775418758392334,
0.1900644302368164,
-0.24700544774532318,
-0.4505075216293335,
0.21281813085079193,
-0.4011867046356201,
0.05441960692405701,
0.10066012293100357,
-0.9738667607307434,
0.6415392756462097,
0.5869681239128113,
0.7553381323814392,
0.36193427443504333,
-0.5326059460639954,
-0.45002174377441406,
0.08566472679376602,
-0.2105979323387146,
0.6438111662864685,
-0.7663892507553101,
-0.7173823118209839,
-0.13510967791080475,
-0.12140060216188431,
-0.38302892446517944,
-0.6576994061470032,
0.10235656797885895,
-0.05440064147114754,
0.14240263402462006,
-0.432025283575058,
-0.31972891092300415,
-0.08854791522026062,
-0.09492788463830948,
-0.7142195701599121,
0.9491072297096252,
-0.47784316539764404,
-0.5773748159408569,
0.4826548993587494,
-0.5401800274848938,
-0.31040337681770325,
-0.04725297540426254,
-0.5466373562812805,
-0.4761769473552704,
0.030202846974134445,
0.1354784220457077,
-0.028281105682253838,
-0.34383946657180786,
0.23377375304698944,
-0.06252428144216537,
-0.3710286617279053,
0.38369879126548767,
-0.591812252998352,
0.6622974276542664,
0.02427106723189354,
-0.43134716153144836,
0.05574025213718414,
-0.5892986059188843,
-0.3503471314907074,
-0.07056419551372528,
-0.43059685826301575,
-0.12507984042167664,
0.2896243631839752,
0.17553755640983582,
0.32333019375801086,
-0.14192302525043488,
-0.48333707451820374,
-0.11429953575134277,
-0.20391546189785004,
0.46669259667396545,
0.4878825843334198,
-0.795383870601654,
0.34854191541671753,
-0.19088710844516754,
0.40235742926597595,
0.035165440291166306,
-0.06904149800539017,
-0.14482544362545013,
-0.7246886491775513,
-0.5572981238365173,
-0.3688247501850128,
0.5793730020523071,
0.3250999450683594,
-0.36368438601493835,
0.014975365251302719,
-0.3242794871330261,
-0.2681332528591156,
-0.7043499946594238,
0.01189437322318554,
0.8024896383285522,
0.32363295555114746,
0.1711830198764801,
-0.2786640226840973,
-0.34197577834129333,
-0.8837059736251831,
-0.6434849500656128,
-0.23974600434303284,
-0.10376658290624619,
0.35760995745658875,
0.3827313482761383,
-0.12453906238079071,
0.6590980887413025,
-0.12063364684581757,
-0.20578281581401825,
-0.3565604090690613,
0.3430900275707245,
0.130899578332901,
0.5377801656723022,
0.38120147585868835,
-0.9723129272460938,
-0.181613489985466,
-0.12335015088319778,
-0.4059254825115204,
0.04429266229271889,
0.2802688181400299,
0.3615378737449646,
0.3482910394668579,
0.2382059544324875,
-0.25673189759254456,
0.4760780334472656,
0.683661699295044,
-0.7021085023880005,
0.4689479172229767,
-0.1948673278093338,
0.34574398398399353,
-0.3383846580982208,
0.006337163969874382,
0.03825851529836655,
-0.32330402731895447,
-0.8130745887756348,
-0.07185296714305878,
0.19927556812763214,
-0.2642156779766083,
-0.2128552794456482,
0.5023117065429688,
-0.7451017498970032,
-0.589283287525177,
-0.1290438175201416,
-0.08772952854633331,
-0.18986167013645172,
-0.043562181293964386,
0.04058409482240677,
0.992957353591919,
0.5312511920928955,
-0.8369710445404053,
-0.2927965223789215,
0.47024771571159363,
-0.12132026255130768,
0.22757206857204437,
-0.5765755772590637,
0.2158752679824829,
-0.08445190638303757,
0.0011419386137276888,
-1.1253615617752075,
-0.24633198976516724,
0.11799412220716476,
-0.7497317790985107,
0.846302330493927,
-0.2973198890686035,
-0.23919090628623962,
-0.5144200921058655,
-0.1427968144416809,
0.7036322951316833,
0.292230486869812,
-0.46742427349090576,
0.6420264840126038,
0.719652533531189,
-0.2845954895019531,
-0.6936296224594116,
-0.7865350842475891,
0.138639435172081,
-0.15671364963054657,
-0.6006336212158203,
0.08358585089445114,
-0.05688255652785301,
-0.16714780032634735,
-0.4933919906616211,
-0.21154168248176575,
-0.372854620218277,
0.20250338315963745,
0.4134880006313324,
-0.14363983273506165,
-0.11194918304681778,
0.2818860113620758,
-0.25758978724479675,
-0.13511216640472412,
-0.16451767086982727,
0.16092894971370697,
0.7362379431724548,
-0.3944076597690582,
-0.5335835814476013,
-0.37333324551582336,
0.4566301107406616,
0.5136914849281311,
-0.34530311822891235,
0.47104495763778687,
0.5584753751754761,
-0.6278539299964905,
0.1998523771762848,
-0.5992952585220337,
-0.11733617633581161,
-0.4527544677257538,
0.15968947112560272,
-0.7864516377449036,
-0.916410505771637,
0.6976581811904907,
0.2777208387851715,
-0.09551021456718445,
0.32340434193611145,
0.2347181737422943,
-0.1609567403793335,
1.0960450172424316,
0.7688180208206177,
-0.08661900460720062,
0.32960668206214905,
0.03070138581097126,
0.23528172075748444,
-0.7331761121749878,
-0.418376624584198,
-1.0311834812164307,
-0.16982661187648773,
-0.902582585811615,
-0.3312295079231262,
0.3455581068992615,
-0.016154006123542786,
-0.31424519419670105,
-0.06445800513029099,
-0.22909590601921082,
0.30467489361763,
0.557722270488739,
-0.21622295677661896,
0.3245353400707245,
-0.0397857129573822,
0.23600812256336212,
-0.3603164553642273,
-0.7345088124275208,
-0.5289599299430847,
0.7934627532958984,
0.6408697962760925,
0.5821096897125244,
0.3699053227901459,
0.3080194592475891,
0.47416242957115173,
-0.39033591747283936,
-0.3994483947753906,
0.11907486617565155,
-0.5246319770812988,
-0.7476682662963867,
-0.3711175322532654,
-0.5636944770812988,
-1.048578143119812,
0.3247951865196228,
0.04728708043694496,
-0.6010478734970093,
0.4435712993144989,
0.2788059115409851,
-0.16592609882354736,
0.32964086532592773,
-0.3196788728237152,
0.6180946826934814,
-0.24065326154232025,
-0.1263149082660675,
0.027468325570225716,
-0.6861771941184998,
0.31526893377304077,
0.043282490223646164,
0.4441734254360199,
-0.4282647967338562,
0.3479319214820862,
0.7204656600952148,
-0.03454574942588806,
0.5122534036636353,
-0.30156949162483215,
-0.11139203608036041,
-0.26404616236686707,
0.04494025185704231,
-0.023805100470781326,
-0.2311663180589676,
0.008786888793110847,
0.7677314281463623,
-0.21242986619472504,
-0.2933819591999054,
-0.0024680374190211296,
0.4541379511356354,
-0.786765992641449,
-0.300191193819046,
-0.6646650433540344,
-0.5707769989967346,
-0.23366297781467438,
0.043488115072250366,
0.23245282471179962,
0.7953217625617981,
-0.020606735721230507,
-0.07137774676084518,
0.6387633085250854,
-0.46759384870529175,
0.46793505549430847,
0.5647218227386475,
-0.18087832629680634,
-0.07319054007530212,
0.6852883696556091,
0.3502381145954132,
0.11974456906318665,
0.12384700775146484,
0.22138389945030212,
-0.658228874206543,
-0.48395347595214844,
-0.8679938316345215,
0.23795883357524872,
-0.3984638452529907,
-0.0036646947264671326,
-0.7592461705207825,
-0.21834081411361694,
-0.6584995985031128,
0.08977073431015015,
-0.623806357383728,
-0.5624858736991882,
-0.04152613878250122,
0.18342308700084686,
0.3116125464439392,
0.9037079811096191,
-0.08478211611509323,
0.20252463221549988,
-0.6778440475463867,
0.5252532958984375,
0.23410886526107788,
0.4021557867527008,
-0.03568238019943237,
-0.7336081862449646,
0.022678392007946968,
0.2857676148414612,
-0.24800600111484528,
-0.7916622161865234,
0.5390980839729309,
0.6200263500213623,
0.481609970331192,
0.0932326540350914,
-0.3270668387413025,
0.983816921710968,
-0.8542784452438354,
0.7463681101799011,
0.22393375635147095,
-1.2309285402297974,
0.3239818811416626,
-0.589039146900177,
0.4150402247905731,
0.31956732273101807,
0.18196024000644684,
-0.6520386338233948,
-0.4363645017147064,
-0.21889165043830872,
-1.0420260429382324,
0.9223187565803528,
0.3542220890522003,
-0.0007414427818730474,
0.31858015060424805,
0.06489147245883942,
0.35017600655555725,
0.6038292050361633,
-0.673406720161438,
-0.3866744339466095,
-0.11604111641645432,
0.024778444319963455,
-0.15773329138755798,
-0.30497294664382935,
-0.0003501872706692666,
-0.23930679261684418,
0.6057019829750061,
0.04831259697675705,
0.472990483045578,
-0.19763991236686707,
-0.34821584820747375,
-0.1945076733827591,
0.3710538446903229,
0.7286731004714966,
0.7436190247535706,
-0.1264258325099945,
0.2004031538963318,
0.0950923040509224,
-0.5185801982879639,
0.2732417583465576,
0.4220879375934601,
0.14297164976596832,
0.2597346305847168,
0.37062811851501465,
0.7520059943199158,
0.4497646689414978,
-0.6179201602935791,
0.23137931525707245,
-0.38282328844070435,
0.00025339730200357735,
-0.3588886857032776,
-0.1786160171031952,
0.0016810439992696047,
0.4546041786670685,
0.4463067352771759,
0.17014485597610474,
0.6121595501899719,
-0.5513033270835876,
0.04526572301983833,
0.3391069173812866,
-0.4703129231929779,
-0.2436172068119049,
0.72922283411026,
0.17142876982688904,
-0.46504470705986023,
0.7377939820289612,
-0.025386236608028412,
-0.639444887638092,
0.5137621760368347,
0.4570544362068176,
0.7721872925758362,
-0.8580797910690308,
0.0975911095738411,
0.2833746075630188,
0.44527578353881836,
-0.21549072861671448,
0.4564276337623596,
0.08058015257120132,
-0.5224249362945557,
-0.057426776736974716,
-0.48013582825660706,
-0.2938227951526642,
-0.08638174831867218,
-0.7859464287757874,
0.30706140398979187,
-0.15814761817455292,
-0.1869276762008667,
0.17109434306621552,
-0.20966504514217377,
-0.6360728740692139,
0.0692562535405159,
0.6732180118560791,
0.633193850517273,
-0.9160417318344116,
0.4467933177947998,
0.639712393283844,
-0.06772199273109436,
-0.620137631893158,
0.061746399849653244,
0.3606233596801758,
-0.45455509424209595,
0.5634033679962158,
0.5389544367790222,
-0.6254895329475403,
-0.46586179733276367,
0.15779832005500793,
-1.0071115493774414,
0.6862409710884094,
0.5562695860862732,
-0.7625451683998108,
0.034664593636989594,
0.6767483353614807,
0.4075845777988434,
-0.13265575468540192,
0.3374773859977722,
0.48781436681747437,
0.3903980553150177,
-0.05535999312996864,
-1.5920155048370361,
-0.4432141184806824,
-0.36328449845314026,
0.20248940587043762,
0.3056296706199646,
-0.39653560519218445,
1.1482203006744385,
-0.20006531476974487,
-0.30677807331085205,
0.08285938203334808,
0.30672910809516907,
0.5954143404960632,
0.6011401414871216,
0.5642504692077637,
0.17457449436187744,
0.8941245675086975,
-0.46380433440208435,
1.146657943725586,
-0.04438721761107445,
0.05718471482396126,
1.1297920942306519,
-0.3876175582408905,
0.7728225588798523,
0.12613122165203094,
-0.3923284709453583,
0.11771232634782791,
0.5774617791175842,
0.2786683738231659,
0.3507798910140991,
0.03494853898882866,
-0.12051882594823837,
-0.31151753664016724,
-0.16194795072078705,
-0.7263585925102234,
0.750906229019165,
0.33125028014183044,
-0.23078903555870056,
-0.08960138261318207,
0.1355707049369812,
0.03543468192219734,
0.11301440000534058,
-0.2794450521469116,
0.6432438492774963,
0.08724088221788406,
-0.030292389914393425,
0.544799268245697,
0.03542757034301758,
0.6097767353057861,
-0.681412935256958,
-0.019379466772079468,
0.0895673930644989,
0.30676084756851196,
-0.19022014737129211,
-0.5401321649551392,
0.23553018271923065,
0.3296845555305481,
-0.48524147272109985,
-0.17746895551681519,
0.6679211258888245,
-0.6715997457504272,
-0.6925462484359741,
0.5331194996833801,
0.5959491729736328,
0.2719745635986328,
0.04795011878013611,
-0.6952429413795471,
0.11696460843086243,
-0.13151828944683075,
0.15828514099121094,
0.31610533595085144,
0.15623196959495544,
-0.25407660007476807,
0.8601168990135193,
0.48099130392074585,
0.0802474319934845,
0.4855896830558777,
0.41397300362586975,
0.6149148941040039,
-0.5436315536499023,
-0.6323457956314087,
-0.840366005897522,
0.6116892099380493,
0.18495793640613556,
-0.3426356911659241,
0.7820498943328857,
0.78145432472229,
0.8548463582992554,
0.04722598195075989,
0.4993629455566406,
0.29925140738487244,
0.8559168577194214,
-0.3833441138267517,
0.9034579992294312,
-0.5531080365180969,
0.39324355125427246,
-0.5694546699523926,
-0.6458749175071716,
-0.3801185190677643,
0.7702372074127197,
-0.25552016496658325,
0.4270712435245514,
0.19173496961593628,
0.5453550219535828,
-0.2738999128341675,
0.14019672572612762,
0.306160569190979,
0.050632212311029434,
0.3649666905403137,
0.1297444999217987,
1.2255322933197021,
-0.5840627551078796,
0.17429479956626892,
-0.025487150996923447,
0.03227059170603752,
-0.12576203048229218,
-0.6636459827423096,
-0.6420361399650574,
-0.6093913316726685,
-0.42069244384765625,
0.07798724621534348,
0.4129837155342102,
0.724250853061676,
0.8261913657188416,
-0.7243067622184753,
-0.8191542029380798,
0.1445930153131485,
0.051734182983636856,
-0.20518487691879272,
-0.09160258620977402,
0.10490106046199799,
-0.11258924007415771,
-0.7359423041343689,
0.5231937766075134,
0.01939178630709648,
0.07584425061941147,
0.05026105046272278,
-0.3782159984111786,
-0.15484356880187988,
-0.1998898833990097,
0.19524189829826355,
0.3496675491333008,
-0.8865659832954407,
0.050604723393917084,
-0.19350947439670563,
0.2811749279499054,
0.15627296268939972,
0.8683516383171082,
-0.5962392091751099,
0.4906582832336426,
0.24973073601722717,
0.3762100040912628,
0.2898005247116089,
-0.18999554216861725,
0.7241623401641846,
-0.9764294028282166,
0.19076943397521973,
0.17817701399326324,
0.40961548686027527,
0.8253017663955688,
-0.1681215614080429,
0.31017524003982544,
0.006007444579154253,
-0.4084634780883789,
-1.2320202589035034,
0.1543305367231369,
-0.4867563247680664,
-0.33116772770881653,
0.9983600974082947,
0.011373651213943958,
0.28458037972450256,
-0.3083299398422241,
0.045833464711904526,
0.2926534414291382,
-0.5632506012916565,
0.7528913021087646,
0.6101913452148438,
-0.23907774686813354,
-0.16519218683242798,
-0.691772997379303,
0.595502495765686,
0.16697220504283905,
-0.3421047627925873,
0.2567538917064667,
0.6093146800994873,
0.31868088245391846,
0.22250230610370636,
0.44765105843544006,
-0.24650822579860687,
0.4463309049606323,
0.017240485176444054,
0.25151750445365906,
-0.07869493216276169,
-0.846612274646759,
-1.0565218925476074,
-0.06295564025640488,
0.3048345744609833,
-0.22585272789001465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14659v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14659v1
|
Social Intelligence Data Infrastructure: Structuring the Present and Navigating the Future
| 2024-02-28T00:22:42 | 2024-02-28T00:22:42 |
Minzhi Li, Weiyan Shi, Caleb Ziems, Diyi Yang
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
As Natural Language Processing (NLP) systems become increasingly integrated
into human social life, these technologies will need to increasingly rely on
social intelligence. Although there are many valuable datasets that benchmark
isolated dimensions of social intelligence, there does not yet exist any body
of work to join these threads into a cohesive subfield in which researchers can
quickly identify research gaps and future directions. Towards this goal, we
build a Social AI Data Infrastructure, which consists of a comprehensive social
AI taxonomy and a data library of 480 NLP datasets. Our infrastructure allows
us to analyze existing dataset efforts, and also evaluate language models'
performance in different social intelligence aspects. Our analyses demonstrate
its utility in enabling a thorough understanding of current data landscape and
providing a holistic perspective on potential directions for future dataset
development. We show there is a need for multifaceted datasets, increased
diversity in language and culture, more long-tailed social situations, and more
interactive data in future social intelligence data efforts.
|
[
-0.3448362350463867,
-0.6964108347892761,
0.17229916155338287,
0.22669728100299835,
0.11294727772474289,
0.5765062570571899,
-0.030561087653040886,
-0.8062532544136047,
0.4128318428993225,
0.3961056172847748,
-0.688458263874054,
-0.5453433990478516,
-0.5440321564674377,
-0.0679447203874588,
-0.5569964647293091,
0.8599839806556702,
0.5753193497657776,
-0.10818290710449219,
-0.6991176605224609,
-0.36697617173194885,
-0.40814757347106934,
-0.6426651477813721,
-0.7418568730354309,
-0.41922736167907715,
0.6451514363288879,
0.6654276251792908,
1.0178046226501465,
0.6573807597160339,
0.5076181888580322,
0.3076190650463104,
-0.10203816741704941,
0.18918928503990173,
-0.5408920049667358,
0.06273964047431946,
-0.17873187363147736,
-0.12214238941669464,
-0.6921294927597046,
-0.15128518640995026,
0.5232511758804321,
1.0333012342453003,
0.09574970602989197,
0.6098074913024902,
0.12716186046600342,
0.992516279220581,
-0.3929852247238159,
0.45242348313331604,
-0.4273163974285126,
-0.13804326951503754,
-0.554931640625,
0.05872054770588875,
0.010412873700261116,
-0.29533082246780396,
0.21440373361110687,
-0.3225645422935486,
-0.2297564297914505,
0.21033087372779846,
0.5249519348144531,
0.20408442616462708,
-0.3143955171108246,
-0.05164621025323868,
-0.851487934589386,
0.6505494713783264,
-0.35746124386787415,
0.35216134786605835,
0.33395785093307495,
0.38011497259140015,
-0.0985739529132843,
-0.8243582844734192,
-0.31914305686950684,
0.12392591685056686,
0.13970786333084106,
-0.1714305728673935,
0.00693317549303174,
-0.3316331207752228,
-0.1250757873058319,
0.15396972000598907,
-0.5159257650375366,
0.11708204448223114,
-0.6764333844184875,
0.05815865844488144,
1.056412696838379,
0.3869800269603729,
0.40584230422973633,
-0.10372549295425415,
-0.023646827787160873,
0.10201387107372284,
-0.6903601288795471,
0.0026356291491538286,
0.3375553488731384,
0.46115079522132874,
-0.30099719762802124,
0.5591978430747986,
-0.4375361502170563,
0.23342519998550415,
-0.3922659754753113,
0.3373923599720001,
0.5445998907089233,
-0.5955171585083008,
0.04592636972665787,
0.03431455045938492,
0.693642795085907,
0.4711465835571289,
0.5142968893051147,
-0.4521324932575226,
-0.01569259539246559,
0.20179101824760437,
0.30806323885917664,
-0.31808534264564514,
-0.2361198216676712,
0.45040401816368103,
-0.4757245182991028,
-0.2619505822658539,
-0.30748260021209717,
-0.8578161597251892,
-0.658873975276947,
-0.6230342388153076,
-0.15871648490428925,
-0.40176692605018616,
-0.40442410111427307,
-0.019788872450590134,
-0.394431471824646,
0.3030376136302948,
-0.032876309007406235,
-0.7058327198028564,
0.5294961333274841,
1.0612685680389404,
0.9822496175765991,
-0.06332762539386749,
-0.49694156646728516,
-0.26506802439689636,
0.16222825646400452,
-0.24134157598018646,
0.8963815569877625,
-0.6408956050872803,
-0.19704146683216095,
0.31813186407089233,
0.008713198825716972,
0.22695015370845795,
-0.23450501263141632,
0.2677002549171448,
-0.4342441260814667,
-0.23235246539115906,
-0.3473110496997833,
-0.42216432094573975,
0.0843653753399849,
0.2730907201766968,
-0.9111084938049316,
0.9702349901199341,
0.011788547039031982,
-0.806210994720459,
0.41302984952926636,
-1.0350804328918457,
-0.6791052222251892,
0.45361098647117615,
-0.169137105345726,
-0.17716780304908752,
-0.029111826792359352,
0.11370736360549927,
0.48295021057128906,
-0.38008609414100647,
0.577926516532898,
-0.8859995007514954,
-0.3835920989513397,
0.08933323621749878,
-0.26920878887176514,
1.165594220161438,
0.002805044176056981,
-0.15025639533996582,
-0.009125526063144207,
-0.8138295412063599,
-0.2911446690559387,
0.15418201684951782,
0.06351038813591003,
-0.33632713556289673,
0.596343457698822,
0.0728909820318222,
0.0436842180788517,
0.5343225002288818,
-0.4908906817436218,
0.00342194945551455,
-0.4030218720436096,
0.6132726669311523,
0.9895926117897034,
-0.24802179634571075,
0.6318076252937317,
-0.4336121678352356,
0.3371487855911255,
-0.27538296580314636,
0.4955540597438812,
0.42984718084335327,
-0.8274436593055725,
-0.5639573335647583,
0.30144912004470825,
0.07517414540052414,
0.694524347782135,
-0.7891172170639038,
0.404331773519516,
-0.8134743571281433,
-0.744320273399353,
-0.41718655824661255,
0.036637723445892334,
-0.13742801547050476,
0.11051174253225327,
0.21132971346378326,
-0.05644931644201279,
-0.624592661857605,
-0.8964092135429382,
-0.1910364180803299,
-0.368763267993927,
0.034056127071380615,
0.21600505709648132,
0.5771914720535278,
-0.26667657494544983,
1.100818157196045,
-0.10994138568639755,
-0.046413522213697433,
-0.575029194355011,
0.011437924578785896,
0.1394721120595932,
0.3154333233833313,
0.33146193623542786,
-1.0098017454147339,
-0.18899184465408325,
0.07550760358572006,
-0.9452844858169556,
0.14067669212818146,
0.20400981605052948,
-0.28729796409606934,
-0.16245350241661072,
0.43528321385383606,
-0.5229449272155762,
0.4582626223564148,
0.3918691575527191,
-0.4488828778266907,
0.15980488061904907,
0.14804789423942566,
-0.09565059840679169,
-1.0177581310272217,
0.28923770785331726,
-0.12575963139533997,
0.10658030956983566,
-0.8867842555046082,
-0.15265758335590363,
-0.2610836327075958,
-0.2704797387123108,
-0.251519113779068,
0.8015220761299133,
-0.23449838161468506,
-0.34817740321159363,
0.30611535906791687,
0.11537208408117294,
-0.21643728017807007,
0.3221261501312256,
-0.2890835404396057,
0.4725188612937927,
0.5911436676979065,
-0.4924306571483612,
0.5896921157836914,
0.4261435866355896,
-0.4265076518058777,
0.5255105495452881,
-0.8866798281669617,
0.26709315180778503,
-0.3003952205181122,
0.06164546310901642,
-0.5856720805168152,
-0.4546160101890564,
0.17837943136692047,
-0.5921140909194946,
-0.06012120470404625,
0.17134998738765717,
-0.6207761764526367,
-0.3584887981414795,
-0.42099446058273315,
0.31833764910697937,
0.16241063177585602,
-0.27917739748954773,
0.8232119083404541,
1.1435590982437134,
-0.5150718688964844,
-0.63322514295578,
-0.6599611043930054,
0.5060240030288696,
-0.17008762061595917,
-0.8605712056159973,
0.34537339210510254,
-0.05937638878822327,
-0.6104434132575989,
0.19884037971496582,
0.38891083002090454,
-0.04455804079771042,
0.3908895254135132,
0.46612924337387085,
0.31959423422813416,
-0.04385661333799362,
0.3025425672531128,
-0.031057847663760185,
-0.204918771982193,
0.33848002552986145,
-0.056681424379348755,
0.5898345112800598,
-0.13389360904693604,
-0.3133314847946167,
-0.07452648133039474,
0.6803433895111084,
0.7361136674880981,
-0.5034742951393127,
0.7717108130455017,
0.5349932312965393,
-0.6782000064849854,
0.041499052196741104,
-0.2885501980781555,
0.22450610995292664,
-0.44523686170578003,
0.38610410690307617,
0.10759802162647247,
-0.8403193354606628,
0.7406995892524719,
0.09575491398572922,
0.5264924764633179,
0.25209611654281616,
0.3844333589076996,
-0.15968403220176697,
1.0794355869293213,
0.664404034614563,
-0.6502436995506287,
0.4284152686595917,
-0.151792973279953,
0.5740023851394653,
-0.4822346270084381,
-0.3291257619857788,
-0.5732066631317139,
-0.4990306496620178,
-0.5722276568412781,
0.0813189372420311,
0.07086721062660217,
-0.5503043532371521,
-0.3181041181087494,
-0.024493582546710968,
-0.4287905991077423,
0.27167266607284546,
0.6086173057556152,
-0.009179577231407166,
0.009972148574888706,
-0.12292356789112091,
0.6099250316619873,
0.3143778443336487,
-0.6167108416557312,
-0.633092999458313,
1.109582543373108,
0.3512100875377655,
0.40443092584609985,
0.14265254139900208,
0.49437791109085083,
0.6900101900100708,
0.39310160279273987,
-0.4667985439300537,
0.7640495896339417,
-0.29604586958885193,
-0.6021214723587036,
-0.47012776136398315,
-0.16842669248580933,
-0.9652503728866577,
-0.4446328282356262,
-0.3599163293838501,
-0.5272355675697327,
0.2793450653553009,
-0.1690009981393814,
-0.2368025779724121,
0.10445594787597656,
-0.7041866779327393,
0.7911599278450012,
-0.09817466884851456,
-0.2818882465362549,
-0.15025967359542847,
-0.7846960425376892,
0.09287387132644653,
0.23356306552886963,
0.4958105981349945,
-0.4219193160533905,
0.1692662388086319,
0.6264991760253906,
-0.12956172227859497,
0.962207555770874,
-0.1170625239610672,
0.2961582839488983,
0.0953068658709526,
-0.5077323913574219,
0.2078114151954651,
0.15693695843219757,
-0.3673548698425293,
0.4394630491733551,
0.009385357610881329,
-0.5548751950263977,
-0.38167715072631836,
0.6236224174499512,
-0.7663772702217102,
-0.25814566016197205,
-0.21917098760604858,
-0.456794410943985,
-0.2597430944442749,
-0.05057608336210251,
-0.09004093706607819,
0.5785695910453796,
-0.38016000390052795,
0.6040739417076111,
0.4040418863296509,
0.034857649356126785,
0.32007962465286255,
-0.0919857993721962,
0.0768057256937027,
-0.2587585151195526,
0.8536028861999512,
0.5792576670646667,
-0.06280604749917984,
0.16309754550457,
-0.17856332659721375,
-0.2894796133041382,
-0.58228999376297,
-0.1805328130722046,
-0.02579747885465622,
-0.7076192498207092,
-0.14037011563777924,
-0.49907195568084717,
-0.3646005690097809,
-0.7121710181236267,
-0.24149024486541748,
-0.20679114758968353,
-0.15334121882915497,
-0.1009160503745079,
-0.0737128034234047,
0.6250503659248352,
0.9770230054855347,
-0.08655103296041489,
-0.09837553650140762,
-0.7856963872909546,
0.21620094776153564,
0.19968757033348083,
0.6416345834732056,
0.16062892973423004,
0.24712106585502625,
-0.5013073682785034,
0.12926222383975983,
0.2733900845050812,
-0.8206759691238403,
0.2684597969055176,
0.38452523946762085,
0.5202596783638,
0.00790435541421175,
0.12864510715007782,
0.6047714352607727,
-0.5454697012901306,
0.8666983246803284,
-0.41892698407173157,
-0.6325156688690186,
0.6415318846702576,
-0.3151598572731018,
0.26745864748954773,
0.760065495967865,
0.22409231960773468,
-0.8186488151550293,
-0.45286768674850464,
-0.6555666327476501,
-1.071494221687317,
0.37269797921180725,
0.11484735459089279,
0.2508431077003479,
-0.12406282126903534,
0.40183570981025696,
-0.08725182712078094,
0.03866538405418396,
-0.5198528170585632,
-0.36241814494132996,
-0.13089394569396973,
-0.3853829801082611,
-0.10706817358732224,
-0.027872009202837944,
0.024478450417518616,
-0.25606054067611694,
0.5257705450057983,
-0.21786943078041077,
0.24081914126873016,
-0.3013574481010437,
0.18605001270771027,
0.27736929059028625,
-0.0059417420998215675,
-0.15777450799942017,
0.8580106496810913,
-0.12983331084251404,
-0.10827379673719406,
0.13608630001544952,
-0.3931771516799927,
-0.14187321066856384,
0.07034148275852203,
-0.10196437686681747,
-0.13304980099201202,
0.397698312997818,
0.39688241481781006,
0.10542558878660202,
-0.6491376161575317,
0.41761720180511475,
-0.33092454075813293,
-0.18853211402893066,
-0.7776306867599487,
0.19196867942810059,
0.4248866140842438,
0.41307878494262695,
0.4172915816307068,
-0.06260669976472855,
0.19465896487236023,
-0.6805946826934814,
0.2210315763950348,
0.4359593093395233,
-0.3774667978286743,
-0.20589092373847961,
0.45259368419647217,
0.21561762690544128,
-0.6983428597450256,
0.9208048582077026,
-0.19905833899974823,
-0.20493045449256897,
0.5984717011451721,
0.013894498348236084,
0.7940834164619446,
0.006911397445946932,
0.2803148031234741,
0.0848391130566597,
0.3605557084083557,
0.2283838391304016,
0.3636663854122162,
0.06836879998445511,
-0.7995206117630005,
-0.4755708575248718,
-0.48226356506347656,
-0.439245343208313,
0.02723035216331482,
-0.5619562864303589,
0.26312604546546936,
-0.4342746436595917,
-0.1154109388589859,
0.1793988049030304,
0.16916294395923615,
-0.9575425982475281,
0.21234922111034393,
0.2603965699672699,
0.9054375290870667,
-1.0835009813308716,
0.7824363112449646,
0.6994541883468628,
-0.18427462875843048,
-0.27881476283073425,
-0.38132110238075256,
0.1339031308889389,
-0.7375463843345642,
0.36233359575271606,
0.2316865473985672,
-0.2788751423358917,
-0.16531890630722046,
-0.9180406332015991,
-0.9497166275978088,
1.184123158454895,
0.08952218294143677,
-0.05992823466658592,
-0.2844472825527191,
0.3648102879524231,
0.6142764091491699,
-0.48573440313339233,
-0.15113535523414612,
0.6326099038124084,
0.47273218631744385,
-0.1909150630235672,
-0.2617991268634796,
-0.1825578361749649,
-1.0041358470916748,
0.08141017705202103,
0.13797277212142944,
-0.49222108721733093,
0.6030904650688171,
0.3253733217716217,
-0.5453908443450928,
-0.14779211580753326,
0.9162992238998413,
0.05742191895842552,
0.5772422552108765,
0.4025016129016876,
0.21683122217655182,
0.7754690051078796,
-0.08729533106088638,
0.7745380401611328,
-0.4987472891807556,
-0.0791223868727684,
1.02802574634552,
-0.41928449273109436,
0.8804192543029785,
0.32152873277664185,
-0.1559063047170639,
0.5549020767211914,
0.7925167083740234,
0.05072253569960594,
0.2268848717212677,
-0.14544254541397095,
-0.09889183938503265,
-0.08353821188211441,
-0.5271465182304382,
-0.13683940470218658,
0.6425018906593323,
0.6977869272232056,
0.0720505639910698,
0.11946481466293335,
-0.18103966116905212,
-0.3105006515979767,
0.025928737595677376,
-0.21353408694267273,
0.7370715141296387,
-0.19874295592308044,
-0.4634564220905304,
-0.12141214311122894,
-0.43790191411972046,
0.5026209950447083,
-0.48520201444625854,
-0.07951167225837708,
-0.3413691520690918,
-0.1694321185350418,
-0.13432952761650085,
-1.0112500190734863,
0.7695461511611938,
-0.12539872527122498,
0.022133370861411095,
-0.21935750544071198,
0.9372286200523376,
-0.058372147381305695,
-0.45895904302597046,
0.5388526916503906,
0.6730321645736694,
0.034963008016347885,
0.14611223340034485,
-0.7872944474220276,
-0.10487428307533264,
-0.2061072289943695,
0.029943976551294327,
0.35171350836753845,
0.6694892048835754,
0.02341097593307495,
1.0224941968917847,
0.7883932590484619,
0.10303212702274323,
-0.1460191011428833,
0.29676553606987,
0.9503464102745056,
-0.6194272041320801,
-0.3887884318828583,
-0.9108675122261047,
0.6794511079788208,
-0.6372445821762085,
-0.5651706457138062,
0.4963986575603485,
0.30817586183547974,
0.5290384888648987,
0.5072754621505737,
0.7878574132919312,
-0.27444028854370117,
0.539662778377533,
-0.15194888412952423,
0.7605995535850525,
-0.5571703910827637,
0.261326402425766,
-0.10520510375499725,
-0.5792586207389832,
-0.34501567482948303,
0.20188957452774048,
-0.22689689695835114,
-0.17692841589450836,
0.11818879097700119,
0.7449859976768494,
0.24168655276298523,
0.3897216022014618,
-0.08412802964448929,
-0.11859897524118423,
0.43444275856018066,
0.25579702854156494,
0.7930971384048462,
-0.11953803896903992,
0.37114763259887695,
-0.1699477732181549,
-0.22249528765678406,
-0.1196119636297226,
-0.6661236882209778,
-0.8048585057258606,
-0.8165007829666138,
-0.12980173528194427,
-0.09681712836027145,
0.23937340080738068,
0.7641051411628723,
0.5794833302497864,
-0.5505576729774475,
-0.25949445366859436,
-0.007416451815515757,
0.4225611686706543,
-0.20656956732273102,
-0.2443988174200058,
0.1307557076215744,
-0.2917461097240448,
-0.514762282371521,
0.23566624522209167,
0.759750485420227,
-0.298561155796051,
-0.6971558928489685,
0.004506085067987442,
-0.46945154666900635,
0.047966595739126205,
0.6520671844482422,
0.2122032791376114,
-0.31673964858055115,
-0.5121542811393738,
0.3724225163459778,
0.06207654997706413,
0.011458642780780792,
0.2689771354198456,
-0.6316760778427124,
0.17806962132453918,
0.5592042207717896,
0.9298554062843323,
-0.07923711836338043,
-0.36115938425064087,
0.8086163997650146,
-0.621412992477417,
-0.12781395018100739,
0.2624216079711914,
0.2836495339870453,
0.4503139555454254,
-0.3942693769931793,
0.7039193511009216,
0.07797854393720627,
-0.758817195892334,
-0.6993325352668762,
0.11855711787939072,
-0.5506882071495056,
-0.23833808302879333,
0.8622528314590454,
0.2238631695508957,
-0.6003172993659973,
-0.8389897346496582,
0.22058115899562836,
0.19715988636016846,
-0.44619354605674744,
0.874059796333313,
0.9075889587402344,
0.005011031404137611,
-0.19222334027290344,
-0.6477587223052979,
0.4210394620895386,
0.10426811128854752,
-1.0513856410980225,
0.3263123035430908,
0.4304865300655365,
-0.3763437867164612,
0.46504560112953186,
0.8839535713195801,
0.037094973027706146,
0.09200374782085419,
0.10896111279726028,
-0.17670562863349915,
0.3956752419471741,
-0.4821391999721527,
-0.025134069845080376,
0.27072983980178833,
-0.155080646276474,
0.011759762652218342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17946v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17946v3
|
SparseLLM: Towards Global Pruning for Pre-trained Language Models
| 2024-02-28T00:09:07 | 2024-05-23T20:19:07 |
Guangji Bai, Yijiang Li, Chen Ling, Kibaek Kim, Liang Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The transformative impact of large language models (LLMs) like LLaMA and GPT
on natural language processing is countered by their prohibitive computational
demands. Pruning has emerged as a pivotal compression strategy, introducing
sparsity to enhance both memory and computational efficiency. Yet, traditional
global pruning is impractical for LLMs due to scalability issues, while local
pruning, despite its efficiency, leads to suboptimal solutions. Addressing
these challenges, we propose SparseLLM, a novel framework that redefines the
global pruning process into manageable, coordinated subproblems, allowing for
resource-efficient optimization with global optimality. SparseLLM's approach,
which conceptualizes LLMs as a chain of modular functions and leverages
auxiliary variables for problem decomposition, not only facilitates a pragmatic
application on LLMs but also demonstrates significant performance improvements,
particularly in high-sparsity regimes where it surpasses current
state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.4018630087375641,
-0.9910579323768616,
0.4608703553676605,
0.4528260827064514,
-0.3970493972301483,
0.1855061948299408,
-0.6769558191299438,
-0.22327859699726105,
0.390464186668396,
0.37090787291526794,
-0.8977319002151489,
-0.422725647687912,
-0.5953519940376282,
0.1659838855266571,
-0.45822593569755554,
0.9477508068084717,
-0.0036338206846266985,
-0.2004413902759552,
-0.367754727602005,
-0.2356310486793518,
-0.5078018307685852,
-0.8059635162353516,
-0.46617192029953003,
-0.11246491968631744,
0.5444424748420715,
0.2726746201515198,
0.9102360010147095,
0.6057190895080566,
0.2001110166311264,
0.3891535997390747,
-0.2728647291660309,
0.3675414025783539,
-0.8144435286521912,
0.23326657712459564,
0.13194042444229126,
-0.29145798087120056,
-0.3596339225769043,
-0.1763349026441574,
1.065698504447937,
0.9881171584129333,
-0.2692161500453949,
0.04666953533887863,
0.35060542821884155,
0.39333876967430115,
-0.4307864010334015,
0.09411294758319855,
-0.8165819048881531,
-0.12522605061531067,
-0.022941002622246742,
-0.1969195455312729,
-0.07637710124254227,
-0.43615156412124634,
-0.060240935534238815,
-0.5438816547393799,
0.4045257270336151,
-0.024227911606431007,
0.8285828828811646,
0.44313791394233704,
0.0019660883117467165,
0.11541856825351715,
-0.7664284110069275,
0.946326732635498,
-0.4238205552101135,
0.3220883011817932,
0.19337613880634308,
-0.12013553828001022,
-0.3401641249656677,
-0.5206950902938843,
-0.2559814751148224,
-0.1690603345632553,
-0.0720093846321106,
-0.2776227295398712,
-0.09860143810510635,
0.25837093591690063,
-0.06699362397193909,
0.48613449931144714,
-0.7345288395881653,
0.1280512511730194,
-0.2988063395023346,
-0.18067418038845062,
0.4180828332901001,
0.12636522948741913,
0.37313783168792725,
0.3559774160385132,
-0.1979864090681076,
0.37143176794052124,
-1.0644080638885498,
-0.4673847556114197,
0.3075283169746399,
0.40286120772361755,
0.22400958836078644,
0.277847558259964,
0.08500296622514725,
0.7673323750495911,
-0.4212833344936371,
-0.3144620358943939,
-0.06684885919094086,
-0.4176868796348572,
-0.3546086549758911,
-0.19976016879081726,
0.6622022986412048,
-0.1046874076128006,
0.451864629983902,
-0.424039363861084,
-0.1465202122926712,
-0.05188002809882164,
0.141031414270401,
-0.8422380089759827,
-0.23492003977298737,
0.12207654863595963,
-0.24104122817516327,
-0.16911233961582184,
-0.11119909584522247,
-0.5463256239891052,
-0.017403777688741684,
-0.44976410269737244,
0.18790970742702484,
-0.19259217381477356,
-0.4213617146015167,
0.14989373087882996,
0.4933341443538666,
-0.0999947115778923,
0.25845929980278015,
-1.0154178142547607,
0.6886774301528931,
1.004482388496399,
1.094500184059143,
-0.19350279867649078,
-0.27207326889038086,
-0.49355390667915344,
0.22350189089775085,
-0.23681312799453735,
0.6547725200653076,
-0.487734317779541,
-0.481686532497406,
-0.019333869218826294,
0.05881907790899277,
-0.34513115882873535,
-0.7848830223083496,
0.49331218004226685,
-0.2504275441169739,
-0.1880364567041397,
-0.007509799674153328,
-0.23885060846805573,
-0.06480760127305984,
0.3907390832901001,
-0.7211084365844727,
1.1217758655548096,
0.1204245463013649,
-0.4317292273044586,
0.1476922184228897,
-0.1636366993188858,
-0.5830821394920349,
0.1910666525363922,
-0.12145767360925674,
-0.5152671337127686,
0.43139782547950745,
0.2887227237224579,
0.6262917518615723,
-0.5488592386245728,
0.7285099625587463,
-0.23915502429008484,
-0.559222936630249,
-0.015680084004998207,
-0.3882567882537842,
0.48660773038864136,
0.09688009321689606,
0.16372352838516235,
0.3470557630062103,
-0.6059772968292236,
0.03894457221031189,
0.1976356953382492,
-0.44668078422546387,
-0.26857149600982666,
0.10110810399055481,
0.07751061767339706,
-0.026144787669181824,
0.1598387509584427,
-0.29821014404296875,
0.45021140575408936,
-0.7142720222473145,
0.7552310228347778,
0.852502703666687,
-0.1435198038816452,
0.5752748250961304,
-0.44638773798942566,
0.48649176955223083,
-0.47525185346603394,
0.21144597232341766,
-0.12033374607563019,
-0.21750667691230774,
-0.9125562906265259,
-0.6109912395477295,
0.15209384262561798,
0.45115283131599426,
-0.21037296950817108,
0.4862104058265686,
-0.38679876923561096,
-0.23797975480556488,
-0.3027817904949188,
0.49526530504226685,
0.13632389903068542,
0.038968414068222046,
0.37091538310050964,
-0.17692698538303375,
-0.6852205991744995,
-0.8154237270355225,
-0.10661209374666214,
-0.06810323894023895,
-0.00012148178211646155,
0.08312612771987915,
0.21206869184970856,
-0.2934718728065491,
1.0385403633117676,
-0.44819721579551697,
-0.5338261127471924,
-0.6404548287391663,
0.15866035223007202,
0.3340902626514435,
0.6479089856147766,
0.12488769739866257,
-0.769956111907959,
-0.28880730271339417,
-0.1665698140859604,
-0.2848173677921295,
-0.22021572291851044,
-0.2694195508956909,
0.12608332931995392,
0.09191490709781647,
0.4436999559402466,
-0.9952862858772278,
0.12234745919704437,
0.443274587392807,
0.16155193746089935,
0.6378986835479736,
-0.25293388962745667,
-0.2789580225944519,
-0.8233642578125,
-0.04817035049200058,
-0.028719764202833176,
-0.29179850220680237,
-0.5554272532463074,
0.09755218029022217,
-0.2443103939294815,
-0.24647367000579834,
-0.26571619510650635,
0.5061914324760437,
-0.8835484385490417,
-0.14236599206924438,
-0.1635439693927765,
-0.0656333640217781,
-0.13157589733600616,
0.5956063270568848,
0.17570653557777405,
0.8217669129371643,
0.4579654335975647,
-0.556122899055481,
0.1692943572998047,
-0.04779423400759697,
-0.27521294355392456,
-0.0322839617729187,
-0.6522772908210754,
-0.0446319654583931,
-0.21826930344104767,
0.10182126611471176,
-0.8367324471473694,
-0.07553113251924515,
0.12505123019218445,
-0.11756490916013718,
0.629939615726471,
-0.2626691460609436,
-0.7013959884643555,
-0.11522774398326874,
-0.33160585165023804,
0.5132855772972107,
0.5695542097091675,
-0.3740941286087036,
0.544119119644165,
0.5036911964416504,
-0.5499706864356995,
-0.4509042501449585,
-0.4338948130607605,
0.20835372805595398,
-0.35447511076927185,
-0.7688956260681152,
0.49861279129981995,
-0.12172558903694153,
-0.2289033681154251,
-0.09308908879756927,
-0.3085823953151703,
-0.23204191029071808,
0.3670443594455719,
0.10828296840190887,
0.26917344331741333,
-0.14357194304466248,
0.05742727220058441,
-0.22473463416099548,
-0.22143933176994324,
-0.04540028050541878,
-0.4287624955177307,
0.6913141012191772,
-0.11457254737615585,
-0.2834776043891907,
-0.03374041989445686,
0.42981958389282227,
0.2432706654071808,
-0.18082565069198608,
0.6887759566307068,
0.5750268697738647,
-0.431136816740036,
-0.5848245620727539,
-0.7105265855789185,
-0.09941858053207397,
-0.5018647909164429,
0.6227166652679443,
-0.14612920582294464,
-1.3958624601364136,
0.13857802748680115,
-0.4367309808731079,
0.0565376952290535,
-0.022946089506149292,
0.6559150218963623,
0.3206660747528076,
1.0174739360809326,
0.9206733107566833,
-0.35555776953697205,
0.3811747133731842,
-0.2957651913166046,
0.374826043844223,
-0.5228527188301086,
-0.015263705514371395,
-0.5733705759048462,
-0.0791269913315773,
-0.11307172477245331,
-0.8502268195152283,
0.11152105778455734,
0.402931272983551,
0.023990249261260033,
0.20158004760742188,
-0.5611171722412109,
0.8223838210105896,
0.17567840218544006,
-0.36244142055511475,
0.19462913274765015,
0.1850201040506363,
-0.15395285189151764,
-0.22005431354045868,
-1.035636305809021,
-0.45368948578834534,
0.6074463725090027,
0.2955773174762726,
0.789029598236084,
-0.12878477573394775,
0.6428293585777283,
-0.06484522670507431,
0.6378782987594604,
-0.8694553971290588,
0.836107075214386,
0.01957012340426445,
-0.2250525951385498,
-0.2790997624397278,
-0.540522575378418,
-1.109365463256836,
0.5092585682868958,
-0.09617461264133453,
-0.9342800378799438,
-0.1940988451242447,
0.12808926403522491,
-0.2910313904285431,
0.40560537576675415,
-0.605701208114624,
0.7605353593826294,
-0.18552131950855255,
-0.5259439945220947,
-0.3540615439414978,
-0.3317664861679077,
0.5349054932594299,
-0.2615630030632019,
0.5066225528717041,
-0.4182354211807251,
-0.20304791629314423,
0.6643359661102295,
-0.7555490732192993,
0.9582985043525696,
-0.001203925465233624,
-0.021278010681271553,
0.2906011939048767,
0.2958514988422394,
0.4942176342010498,
0.2496020644903183,
0.26936179399490356,
0.25615444779396057,
-0.11877930909395218,
-0.2772880494594574,
-0.40742719173431396,
0.971510112285614,
-0.5627594590187073,
-0.8048166632652283,
-0.45717546343803406,
-0.7559828758239746,
-0.43970736861228943,
0.0700632706284523,
-0.10691596567630768,
0.40947574377059937,
-0.43630486726760864,
0.034697532653808594,
0.7028319835662842,
-0.24801558256149292,
0.3412054181098938,
0.36344167590141296,
-0.07043870538473129,
-0.433141827583313,
1.2434028387069702,
0.30147257447242737,
-0.0020607071928679943,
0.357305645942688,
0.058992382138967514,
-0.2079579085111618,
-0.9593994617462158,
0.0004181239055469632,
0.45893993973731995,
-0.5403463244438171,
-0.29384249448776245,
-0.45168885588645935,
-0.29685118794441223,
-0.3554424047470093,
-0.24068689346313477,
-0.15029317140579224,
-0.3743934631347656,
-0.3614029288291931,
-0.13140040636062622,
0.04405461996793747,
0.7355139255523682,
-0.15306009352207184,
0.3575407564640045,
-0.9398061633110046,
0.24481166899204254,
0.23323898017406464,
0.29007452726364136,
-0.06578191369771957,
-0.2189999520778656,
-0.3449726700782776,
-0.3106541335582733,
-0.10641679912805557,
-0.520896852016449,
0.7584035992622375,
0.5047808885574341,
0.6162316203117371,
0.05696257948875427,
-0.17016328871250153,
0.9617345929145813,
-0.6539335250854492,
0.4766426384449005,
0.19916602969169617,
-0.7060889601707458,
0.22317743301391602,
-0.20819801092147827,
0.3615815043449402,
0.4189532995223999,
0.44867125153541565,
-0.5890257954597473,
-0.5009573101997375,
-0.4758298695087433,
-1.2101105451583862,
0.6298153400421143,
0.08935904502868652,
0.28946927189826965,
-0.17993339896202087,
0.29336026310920715,
0.055839668959379196,
0.09260829538106918,
-0.8122224807739258,
0.0805758684873581,
0.22037626802921295,
-0.2649655342102051,
-0.11663621664047241,
-0.6683276891708374,
-0.11782960593700409,
-0.24778223037719727,
0.7001445293426514,
-0.17882031202316284,
0.07546956092119217,
0.119198739528656,
-0.5149794816970825,
-0.049208659678697586,
0.3564383387565613,
0.30155131220817566,
0.6429869532585144,
-0.02519276738166809,
0.17683084309101105,
0.2920289933681488,
-0.4381699562072754,
0.27995336055755615,
-0.012675969861447811,
-0.22628511488437653,
-0.098504438996315,
0.5541551113128662,
0.4105148911476135,
0.5682162046432495,
-0.7473878860473633,
0.3497982919216156,
-0.21762461960315704,
-0.3121153712272644,
-0.18732306361198425,
0.030570389702916145,
0.1993524730205536,
-0.05806145444512367,
0.4938882291316986,
0.08525075018405914,
-0.22103218734264374,
-0.16343271732330322,
0.09088852256536484,
0.5369732975959778,
-0.17705905437469482,
-0.42304322123527527,
0.5335138440132141,
0.10904745757579803,
-0.1893547624349594,
0.3709907829761505,
0.0736464336514473,
-0.5696167945861816,
0.45957469940185547,
0.6444781422615051,
0.8597924113273621,
-0.15011799335479736,
0.06315142661333084,
0.4281502068042755,
0.5986915230751038,
-0.3296695053577423,
-0.011915711686015129,
-0.36212366819381714,
-0.6584601998329163,
-1.0153496265411377,
-0.9812820553779602,
-0.16047880053520203,
0.3124850392341614,
-0.22015154361724854,
0.08384983241558075,
-0.7889325022697449,
0.10401524603366852,
-0.47168827056884766,
0.05611114576458931,
-0.37611690163612366,
-0.008314329199492931,
0.10563678294420242,
0.7856448292732239,
-0.6906129121780396,
1.1079035997390747,
0.4861510396003723,
-0.12498394399881363,
-0.6868255734443665,
-0.03862089663743973,
0.014130044728517532,
-0.700639545917511,
0.5391544103622437,
0.45125848054885864,
-0.1577414721250534,
0.05541029945015907,
-0.4735223948955536,
-1.0802332162857056,
0.757071852684021,
0.7752649784088135,
-0.64253830909729,
-0.00034909392707049847,
0.21290992200374603,
0.22641563415527344,
-0.07949277013540268,
-0.10689061135053635,
0.6676838397979736,
0.3697017431259155,
0.1548687070608139,
-0.8750183582305908,
0.05344529077410698,
-0.2549116313457489,
0.18397977948188782,
0.5116050243377686,
-0.5891549587249756,
0.8704418540000916,
-0.05779430642724037,
-0.6351158022880554,
0.297664999961853,
0.7369434833526611,
0.20902839303016663,
-0.4077328145503998,
0.49802136421203613,
0.6291478276252747,
0.7803560495376587,
-0.264281690120697,
0.7603312134742737,
-0.35437825322151184,
0.26296937465667725,
0.8790892362594604,
-0.35545143485069275,
0.5674533247947693,
0.5905255675315857,
-0.3050115704536438,
0.0347730778157711,
0.5854260325431824,
0.2867967486381531,
0.3124878704547882,
0.5445380210876465,
-0.5638413429260254,
-0.43266117572784424,
-0.20090696215629578,
-0.18943235278129578,
-0.09972511231899261,
0.63187575340271,
0.2840172052383423,
-0.4144054353237152,
-0.07347170263528824,
0.18412911891937256,
0.24322213232517242,
-0.4755191206932068,
0.671816349029541,
0.22540773451328278,
-0.5647149085998535,
0.9037467241287231,
0.23518194258213043,
0.9040315747261047,
-0.8496312499046326,
0.10127869248390198,
-0.34366852045059204,
0.23328696191310883,
-0.28741687536239624,
-0.24469093978405,
0.7361780405044556,
-0.028351638466119766,
0.014015967026352882,
-0.6926923394203186,
1.099870204925537,
-0.5795166492462158,
-0.43928712606430054,
0.3815837800502777,
0.5272620320320129,
0.020003346726298332,
-0.11282378435134888,
-0.7218812108039856,
0.39298656582832336,
-0.20990976691246033,
-0.2726241648197174,
0.6629429459571838,
0.3875117897987366,
-0.20851750671863556,
0.8793519139289856,
0.7702896595001221,
0.4071328938007355,
0.07419922202825546,
0.05789852514863014,
1.1676620244979858,
-0.41768887639045715,
-0.3908180594444275,
-0.9749261140823364,
0.18068259954452515,
0.11466928571462631,
-0.10004992038011551,
0.7846145033836365,
0.5343822240829468,
0.7903878092765808,
0.20490390062332153,
0.5937364101409912,
0.1305040568113327,
0.3841504156589508,
-0.514622151851654,
0.42084449529647827,
-0.34851375222206116,
0.4576501250267029,
-0.03617119416594505,
-1.1129226684570312,
-0.7182072997093201,
0.8030067086219788,
-0.2639772593975067,
-0.11891422420740128,
0.5627283453941345,
1.0226320028305054,
-0.07198544591665268,
-0.14896360039710999,
0.4094260036945343,
0.2821354269981384,
0.1166863739490509,
0.5304612517356873,
0.8696309924125671,
0.2030908167362213,
0.7559124231338501,
-0.10245562344789505,
-0.053448084741830826,
0.06429020315408707,
-0.8050829768180847,
-0.8570308089256287,
-0.3970044255256653,
-0.2031075805425644,
0.14173057675361633,
0.0420747846364975,
1.038373351097107,
0.9629082679748535,
-0.7002609968185425,
-0.5130621194839478,
-0.3493923842906952,
0.28789809346199036,
-0.03685443103313446,
-0.18139152228832245,
0.15362893044948578,
-0.6077284812927246,
-0.6616270542144775,
0.7470535635948181,
0.6018574237823486,
-0.08081149309873581,
-0.48524758219718933,
-0.23394575715065002,
-0.24299675226211548,
-0.07536141574382782,
0.506443202495575,
0.4108234643936157,
-0.6371608376502991,
0.037275511771440506,
-0.33575278520584106,
0.1348312944173813,
0.05814589187502861,
1.1435238122940063,
-0.9118139147758484,
-0.08895695954561234,
0.3394312560558319,
0.7439610958099365,
0.516288161277771,
-0.023198967799544334,
0.7836830019950867,
-1.2210088968276978,
0.666505753993988,
0.5122888684272766,
0.5170704126358032,
0.344455748796463,
-0.14423511922359467,
0.47956401109695435,
0.49846214056015015,
-0.5734355449676514,
-1.143784761428833,
0.18358691036701202,
-0.6434070467948914,
-0.561582624912262,
1.1709959506988525,
-0.1723771095275879,
-0.46050286293029785,
-0.26302000880241394,
-0.27793461084365845,
0.002062504878267646,
-0.08547040820121765,
0.36443328857421875,
0.6293705701828003,
0.27088865637779236,
-0.2652997672557831,
-0.40993237495422363,
0.559386670589447,
0.6597595810890198,
-0.7046411037445068,
0.3941850960254669,
0.5819693207740784,
0.24927657842636108,
-0.21424521505832672,
1.0320255756378174,
0.03597260266542435,
-0.19328434765338898,
-0.2810368537902832,
-0.11032252013683319,
-0.2282043695449829,
-0.6224552392959595,
-0.5252928733825684,
0.4467557370662689,
0.28623515367507935,
0.37153360247612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17944v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17944v4
|
Large Language Models(LLMs) on Tabular Data: Prediction, Generation, and Understanding -- A Survey
| 2024-02-27T23:59:01 | 2024-06-21T19:59:54 |
Xi Fang, Weijie Xu, Fiona Anting Tan, Jiani Zhang, Ziqing Hu, Yanjun Qi, Scott Nickleach, Diego Socolinsky, Srinivasan Sengamedu, Christos Faloutsos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Recent breakthroughs in large language modeling have facilitated rigorous
exploration of their application in diverse tasks related to tabular data
modeling, such as prediction, tabular data synthesis, question answering, and
table understanding. Each task presents unique challenges and opportunities.
However, there is currently a lack of comprehensive review that summarizes and
compares the key techniques, metrics, datasets, models, and optimization
approaches in this research domain. This survey aims to address this gap by
consolidating recent progress in these areas, offering a thorough survey and
taxonomy of the datasets, metrics, and methodologies utilized. It identifies
strengths, limitations, unexplored territories, and gaps in the existing
literature, while providing some insights for future research directions in
this vital and rapidly evolving field. It also provides relevant code and
datasets references. Through this comprehensive review, we hope to provide
interested readers with pertinent references and insightful perspectives,
empowering them with the necessary tools and knowledge to effectively navigate
and address the prevailing challenges in the field.
|
[
-0.35353928804397583,
-0.961116373538971,
0.6579421162605286,
0.022370584309101105,
0.1751510053873062,
0.329094797372818,
-0.32717031240463257,
-0.1390436887741089,
-0.07728837430477142,
0.7581092119216919,
-0.5933012962341309,
-0.8072174191474915,
-0.3840470612049103,
-0.007617933209985495,
-0.6641799211502075,
0.9277687668800354,
-0.21560177206993103,
0.16135050356388092,
-0.36950141191482544,
0.2550160884857178,
-0.43491628766059875,
-0.5119643211364746,
-0.25250235199928284,
-0.22512906789779663,
0.6449342370033264,
0.5851552486419678,
0.559514045715332,
0.7321512699127197,
0.720535159111023,
0.2882990837097168,
-0.19413873553276062,
0.19442404806613922,
-0.6777306795120239,
0.4628146290779114,
0.14507678151130676,
-0.39278072118759155,
-0.6231726408004761,
-0.1651291400194168,
1.0560702085494995,
1.085423231124878,
-0.44060707092285156,
0.3623625636100769,
-0.04633747413754463,
0.6200851202011108,
-0.22696013748645782,
0.28567203879356384,
-0.9788250923156738,
0.3072398900985718,
-0.4689553380012512,
-0.16821672022342682,
-0.36371031403541565,
-0.33617594838142395,
0.09752237796783447,
-0.23373663425445557,
0.22297462821006775,
0.27567359805107117,
0.44391292333602905,
-0.05204877257347107,
-0.6163330674171448,
-0.33772730827331543,
-1.0235041379928589,
0.9297363758087158,
-0.7447180151939392,
0.5209260582923889,
0.21391865611076355,
0.5936892032623291,
-0.4623604118824005,
-0.8087173104286194,
-0.3741113245487213,
-0.4000929892063141,
0.2430306077003479,
-0.08754677325487137,
-0.08546421676874161,
-0.12616030871868134,
0.23139573633670807,
0.4302099645137787,
-0.7382066249847412,
0.45812830328941345,
-0.42005226016044617,
0.0007282071164809167,
0.6721305251121521,
0.7303449511528015,
0.26643359661102295,
-0.07671129703521729,
-0.044063273817300797,
0.19902221858501434,
-1.0433070659637451,
-0.11085319519042969,
0.22632499039173126,
0.41667401790618896,
-0.20681653916835785,
0.6726921200752258,
-0.29155537486076355,
0.9585599303245544,
-0.5945702195167542,
-0.30597952008247375,
0.21595437824726105,
-0.5162297487258911,
-0.3390408158302307,
-0.34018296003341675,
0.772104799747467,
0.22767388820648193,
0.05634795501828194,
-0.17655785381793976,
-0.2765336334705353,
-0.13497231900691986,
0.050360605120658875,
-0.5609049797058105,
0.026097822934389114,
0.267280638217926,
-0.31417807936668396,
-0.2659633457660675,
-0.0075514474883675575,
-1.1061856746673584,
-0.5349465608596802,
-0.5600348711013794,
-0.29919368028640747,
0.14769743382930756,
-0.18335017561912537,
-0.04256128892302513,
0.44485804438591003,
0.272316575050354,
0.38072580099105835,
-0.8124793767929077,
0.3325413763523102,
0.8102999925613403,
0.7890602946281433,
-0.5026606321334839,
-0.19009879231452942,
-0.23462072014808655,
0.13315585255622864,
-0.6469566226005554,
0.8325319290161133,
-0.48901090025901794,
-0.4911222755908966,
0.43121954798698425,
-0.1113876923918724,
0.13387835025787354,
-0.7491071820259094,
0.588695764541626,
-0.44530877470970154,
-0.1052510067820549,
-0.35164281725883484,
-0.522010862827301,
-0.054823704063892365,
0.4342027008533478,
-0.7727982401847839,
0.9089471697807312,
0.1523672640323639,
-0.6019933819770813,
0.3170299232006073,
-0.3766704797744751,
-0.15547119081020355,
0.08384303003549576,
-0.3115818500518799,
-0.5466858148574829,
0.12534987926483154,
0.144590362906456,
0.8023462891578674,
-0.7552765011787415,
0.5914877653121948,
-0.3248947262763977,
0.011283623985946178,
0.4497480094432831,
-0.15677422285079956,
0.36752790212631226,
0.4188113212585449,
0.10602564364671707,
0.2168469876050949,
-0.6794149875640869,
0.04659826308488846,
0.17525804042816162,
-0.352336585521698,
0.23253825306892395,
0.3255477547645569,
0.27269360423088074,
0.18383313715457916,
0.15093691647052765,
-0.316201776266098,
0.3500630855560303,
-0.0881132036447525,
0.4117030203342438,
0.42656999826431274,
0.010876253247261047,
0.3804146647453308,
-0.1552082598209381,
0.8265127539634705,
-0.016505930572748184,
0.11119533330202103,
-0.07042337954044342,
-0.1710084229707718,
-0.4771527945995331,
0.12399832904338837,
0.3140901029109955,
0.5846290588378906,
-0.6384677290916443,
0.2234807312488556,
-0.46663209795951843,
-0.8696889877319336,
-0.2415052205324173,
0.36736029386520386,
0.2871275842189789,
0.42736661434173584,
0.11053749918937683,
0.016061905771493912,
-0.7456215023994446,
-1.0052495002746582,
-0.03599901124835014,
0.04750913754105568,
0.17376708984375,
0.47545892000198364,
0.5132257342338562,
-0.3605738580226898,
0.8543078303337097,
-0.5424531698226929,
-0.19571436941623688,
-0.8753119707107544,
-0.104559026658535,
0.45587992668151855,
0.24245625734329224,
0.36571651697158813,
-0.7026880979537964,
-0.5726184248924255,
0.29149967432022095,
-0.734094500541687,
-0.06659010052680969,
0.06326989084482193,
0.1480053812265396,
0.1784260869026184,
0.5721322298049927,
-0.4145694077014923,
0.15713849663734436,
0.6811381578445435,
-0.11016988009214401,
0.6664844155311584,
0.17732472717761993,
0.09068011492490768,
-1.0741463899612427,
0.07718715071678162,
0.0744236633181572,
-0.02228972502052784,
-1.035940170288086,
-0.04717180132865906,
-0.08860953152179718,
-0.04534855857491493,
-0.35366132855415344,
0.5133347511291504,
-0.7780787944793701,
-0.42748895287513733,
-0.0928850919008255,
0.2787415385246277,
-0.35408177971839905,
0.02427561767399311,
-0.13705940544605255,
0.7886273860931396,
0.6987244486808777,
-0.45259132981300354,
0.5631299018859863,
0.413425087928772,
-0.8754791021347046,
0.1837385892868042,
-0.5291531085968018,
-0.11392942816019058,
-0.14149698615074158,
0.26699382066726685,
-0.9998247623443604,
-0.3048701882362366,
0.07083170861005783,
-0.4557149410247803,
0.45969897508621216,
-0.14618661999702454,
-0.6638043522834778,
-0.5814814567565918,
-0.15856055915355682,
0.2571052014827728,
0.3965301811695099,
-0.10675352066755295,
0.34636035561561584,
0.7995224595069885,
-0.5691817998886108,
-0.7006887197494507,
-0.8334437012672424,
0.28526803851127625,
-0.3624584376811981,
-0.3786236345767975,
0.07692346721887589,
0.0366273932158947,
-0.5987560749053955,
-0.2908865511417389,
0.027062397450208664,
-0.04824436828494072,
-0.07309402525424957,
-0.002853242913261056,
0.31734588742256165,
-0.17023684084415436,
0.11987008154392242,
-0.3074442446231842,
0.1336146593093872,
0.14890056848526,
0.11915838718414307,
0.7638872265815735,
-0.0002931517956312746,
-0.14162564277648926,
-0.08262283354997635,
0.24780292809009552,
0.41941285133361816,
-0.21943441033363342,
0.7420202493667603,
0.414277583360672,
-0.3066994845867157,
-0.4007357954978943,
-0.6631385684013367,
0.08916370570659637,
-0.41947057843208313,
0.8164097666740417,
-0.29795944690704346,
-0.9689317345619202,
0.7651333808898926,
-0.09242566674947739,
0.15970855951309204,
0.21047478914260864,
0.9434967041015625,
0.048486560583114624,
0.753057062625885,
0.5170145034790039,
-0.3243981599807739,
0.38049399852752686,
-0.31813523173332214,
0.2413897067308426,
-0.8860502243041992,
-0.43857622146606445,
-0.9468928575515747,
-0.09952132403850555,
-0.709965705871582,
-0.4495933949947357,
0.39293113350868225,
-0.40332385897636414,
-0.120086669921875,
-0.056192103773355484,
-0.20805485546588898,
0.19894109666347504,
0.0789988562464714,
-0.24120250344276428,
0.28067970275878906,
0.2210533320903778,
0.09045877307653427,
-0.07522650808095932,
-0.5905331373214722,
-0.5496999025344849,
1.3253190517425537,
0.4070368707180023,
1.038374900817871,
0.06678541749715805,
0.4689042270183563,
0.1289128065109253,
0.299948126077652,
-0.6949781775474548,
0.6629376411437988,
-0.03105001524090767,
-0.7540023922920227,
-0.4878270924091339,
-0.826383113861084,
-1.1600465774536133,
0.23138751089572906,
-0.14584726095199585,
-0.8996426463127136,
-0.28156203031539917,
0.14384201169013977,
0.08135154098272324,
0.4812774062156677,
-0.37320244312286377,
0.8037723898887634,
-0.2685577869415283,
-0.36043581366539,
-0.019066208973526955,
-0.47485777735710144,
0.5305768847465515,
-0.21800220012664795,
0.47394782304763794,
-0.2235082983970642,
-0.12319701910018921,
0.840864360332489,
-0.06814630329608917,
0.5408666729927063,
-0.1636648178100586,
-0.40430477261543274,
0.520768404006958,
0.16924777626991272,
0.4566892385482788,
-0.1182638481259346,
-0.10965564846992493,
-0.010711445473134518,
0.03841548040509224,
-0.1100315973162651,
-0.3823757469654083,
0.7974444627761841,
-0.5083069801330566,
-0.4936823844909668,
-0.29938849806785583,
-0.8422462344169617,
-0.6319409012794495,
0.045358069241046906,
-0.046757638454437256,
0.49561285972595215,
-0.21389275789260864,
0.4383528530597687,
0.5846583843231201,
-0.312250554561615,
0.4037247598171234,
0.3869626820087433,
-0.6713858842849731,
-0.44980388879776,
0.7888543009757996,
0.3492300808429718,
0.08248437941074371,
0.47296956181526184,
-0.04938954859972,
-0.4486039876937866,
-0.9864592552185059,
-0.2528744637966156,
0.3922456204891205,
-0.5184265971183777,
-0.31933289766311646,
-0.39310991764068604,
-0.15632185339927673,
-0.474974662065506,
0.1573617160320282,
-0.22359877824783325,
-0.16369417309761047,
-0.23630701005458832,
-0.20054291188716888,
0.2710786759853363,
1.1232502460479736,
0.44494715332984924,
0.4672917425632477,
-0.7909950017929077,
0.21004071831703186,
-0.004533058498054743,
0.3745894432067871,
0.25295916199684143,
-0.4476662278175354,
-0.47051146626472473,
-0.16520899534225464,
-0.1634817123413086,
-0.942432701587677,
0.599578857421875,
-0.11050007492303848,
0.7864921689033508,
0.15889284014701843,
-0.34920206665992737,
0.568382740020752,
-0.5970898270606995,
0.8280622959136963,
0.11655739694833755,
-0.6615520119667053,
0.29731976985931396,
-0.6736290454864502,
0.24164257943630219,
0.5450909733772278,
0.4291090965270996,
-0.6550371646881104,
-0.05301033332943916,
-0.15939392149448395,
-0.9906571507453918,
0.5032163858413696,
-0.062172070145606995,
0.03030223771929741,
0.44813740253448486,
0.2692441940307617,
0.1931062787771225,
0.5590471029281616,
-0.8842363953590393,
-0.23998849093914032,
0.5509818196296692,
-0.2837437391281128,
-0.26357540488243103,
-0.34079623222351074,
0.08389267325401306,
-0.2867218255996704,
0.63437420129776,
0.02794966846704483,
0.13667480647563934,
-0.320000559091568,
-0.12264183163642883,
-0.14479368925094604,
0.4988660216331482,
0.5369518995285034,
1.1316171884536743,
-0.057926978915929794,
-0.2340339571237564,
0.24026907980442047,
-0.5028420090675354,
0.05395684018731117,
0.08317682147026062,
-0.19125646352767944,
-0.1637224406003952,
0.20802263915538788,
0.80000901222229,
-0.06899119168519974,
-0.81477952003479,
0.2091187983751297,
0.06888440996408463,
-0.2842175364494324,
-0.38801923394203186,
-0.252954363822937,
0.25442612171173096,
0.13026970624923706,
0.3385425806045532,
-0.6518701910972595,
0.23144415020942688,
-0.6533995270729065,
-0.03175320848822594,
0.6143388748168945,
-0.12007040530443192,
-0.13807833194732666,
0.32326608896255493,
-0.15513886511325836,
-0.012598617933690548,
0.5406636595726013,
0.16761618852615356,
-0.2670077681541443,
0.6059262156486511,
0.49526819586753845,
0.53779137134552,
-0.2813655436038971,
0.15327171981334686,
0.1447673738002777,
0.18757431209087372,
0.016414836049079895,
0.4584225118160248,
0.11050612479448318,
-0.6335288882255554,
-0.4143108129501343,
-0.8204283118247986,
-0.5601921677589417,
0.4838818907737732,
-0.5493708252906799,
0.1262364387512207,
-0.17498956620693207,
-0.25797703862190247,
-0.07688320428133011,
0.1970091164112091,
-0.6962022185325623,
0.16330714523792267,
0.2688905596733093,
0.8566368222236633,
-0.8240284323692322,
0.6669237017631531,
0.7029739618301392,
-0.17311079800128937,
-0.7420404553413391,
-0.2263471484184265,
0.013213301077485085,
-0.5501847267150879,
0.3918475806713104,
-0.2210286259651184,
0.12419673800468445,
-0.12143544852733612,
-0.47713503241539,
-1.0470471382141113,
0.9984146952629089,
0.12948836386203766,
-0.7777354121208191,
-0.16449801623821259,
0.49742022156715393,
0.5361381769180298,
-0.38923242688179016,
0.12136537581682205,
0.9194539785385132,
0.6159709095954895,
0.000793976301793009,
-0.8948488831520081,
-0.21155895292758942,
-0.1362483650445938,
0.24779191613197327,
0.21561260521411896,
-0.5243399739265442,
0.8119083046913147,
-0.0429953895509243,
-0.057346004992723465,
0.2551072835922241,
0.696049153804779,
0.2932250499725342,
0.32144486904144287,
0.1577567756175995,
0.5097987651824951,
0.45149481296539307,
-0.2620043158531189,
0.7418708205223083,
-0.10165975987911224,
0.419772744178772,
1.016605019569397,
-0.5748637318611145,
0.8901494145393372,
0.44550254940986633,
-0.7309542298316956,
0.2117030918598175,
0.7313598990440369,
-0.3252565562725067,
0.11684885621070862,
0.6212634444236755,
-0.07595875859260559,
-0.09277866780757904,
-0.18174687027931213,
-0.4301671087741852,
0.5412857532501221,
0.8033480048179626,
-0.454346239566803,
-0.33000460267066956,
-0.23356413841247559,
0.0009753946796990931,
0.09886694699525833,
-0.5735006332397461,
0.8586285710334778,
0.10179796069860458,
-0.6398234963417053,
0.4141058623790741,
-0.0710117444396019,
0.3659655451774597,
-0.6189818978309631,
0.037098947912454605,
-0.26122644543647766,
-0.004232851788401604,
-0.2567822337150574,
-1.0417767763137817,
0.030818428844213486,
0.15110531449317932,
-0.054041311144828796,
-0.33324116468429565,
0.538141667842865,
-0.4867476224899292,
-0.5371894240379333,
0.027235612273216248,
0.9696680307388306,
0.21542683243751526,
0.33048051595687866,
-0.5805978775024414,
0.4688244163990021,
0.09328024089336395,
-0.40697142481803894,
0.23505118489265442,
0.3453708589076996,
0.04938063025474548,
0.9754160046577454,
0.3035723865032196,
0.4408639371395111,
0.2686639428138733,
0.2474600225687027,
0.8889090418815613,
-0.8106997013092041,
-0.31088340282440186,
-0.8152666687965393,
0.4278562068939209,
0.08703650534152985,
-0.1678917557001114,
0.7803109288215637,
0.9092386364936829,
0.6140652894973755,
-0.32460254430770874,
0.9743751883506775,
0.04084911569952965,
0.951055645942688,
-0.6739104986190796,
0.7473326325416565,
-0.534168541431427,
0.22616569697856903,
-0.4260213077068329,
-1.1136103868484497,
-0.4611523151397705,
0.11682049185037613,
-0.42960119247436523,
0.21212992072105408,
0.5644979476928711,
0.8507302403450012,
0.19092999398708344,
-0.16279776394367218,
0.36208149790763855,
0.40596264600753784,
0.3262086510658264,
0.40266478061676025,
0.9914959669113159,
-0.013796612620353699,
0.48717406392097473,
0.13503701984882355,
0.05343016982078552,
-0.19471034407615662,
-0.6827315092086792,
-0.745494544506073,
-0.7848728895187378,
-0.04448864981532097,
-0.033918049186468124,
-0.12690812349319458,
0.7020293474197388,
0.5241619944572449,
-0.8556898832321167,
-0.7381836771965027,
-0.08417034894227982,
0.10011142492294312,
0.35360124707221985,
-0.19075915217399597,
0.36639204621315,
-0.26568666100502014,
-0.7197956442832947,
0.2206287533044815,
0.06287873536348343,
0.05938010290265083,
-0.5338671803474426,
0.10766741633415222,
-0.13266177475452423,
-0.10733149945735931,
0.6316857933998108,
0.2978443205356598,
-0.6937596797943115,
0.283563494682312,
-0.039459019899368286,
-0.14567513763904572,
0.05634690448641777,
0.8774504661560059,
-0.4641624093055725,
0.09461569041013718,
0.5512822866439819,
0.7536509037017822,
0.5688863396644592,
-0.12851770222187042,
0.401944637298584,
-0.4952128529548645,
-0.17764617502689362,
0.2899134159088135,
0.5472412705421448,
0.572770893573761,
-0.1732046902179718,
0.5160555243492126,
-0.10574368387460709,
-0.8026314377784729,
-1.177107572555542,
0.34190115332603455,
-1.1722056865692139,
-0.06069722771644592,
1.3404053449630737,
0.10765329003334045,
-0.22260895371437073,
0.16790102422237396,
-0.12250172346830368,
0.1457405537366867,
-0.2691168785095215,
0.6301642656326294,
0.65267014503479,
-0.12401119619607925,
-0.2772751748561859,
-0.9670162796974182,
0.375060111284256,
0.07258004695177078,
-1.322484016418457,
0.37007126212120056,
0.8047387003898621,
0.11439508944749832,
-0.16974692046642303,
0.32000306248664856,
-0.2991080582141876,
-0.08148136734962463,
-0.2595386207103729,
-0.021308263763785362,
0.1516328752040863,
-0.5319892764091492,
-0.2907123565673828,
0.23092548549175262,
0.4090672433376312,
0.3199581205844879
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17938v1
|
EmMark: Robust Watermarks for IP Protection of Embedded Quantized Large Language Models
| 2024-02-27T23:30:17 | 2024-02-27T23:30:17 |
Ruisi Zhang, Farinaz Koushanfar
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
This paper introduces EmMark,a novel watermarking framework for protecting
the intellectual property (IP) of embedded large language models deployed on
resource-constrained edge devices. To address the IP theft risks posed by
malicious end-users, EmMark enables proprietors to authenticate ownership by
querying the watermarked model weights and matching the inserted signatures.
EmMark's novelty lies in its strategic watermark weight parameters selection,
nsuring robustness and maintaining model quality. Extensive proof-of-concept
evaluations of models from OPT and LLaMA-2 families demonstrate EmMark's
fidelity, achieving 100% success in watermark extraction with model performance
preservation. EmMark also showcased its resilience against watermark removal
and forging attacks.
|
[
0.022610370069742203,
-1.102107048034668,
0.4470178484916687,
-0.013249889947474003,
-0.5573676824569702,
0.4666649103164673,
0.20608088374137878,
-0.5479230880737305,
0.11044524610042572,
0.6318603157997131,
-0.176796555519104,
-0.5026583671569824,
-0.7827793955802917,
-0.44086864590644836,
-0.6535384058952332,
0.6430856585502625,
-0.012572146952152252,
-0.15559546649456024,
-0.11433003842830658,
-0.3359200358390808,
-0.0661097913980484,
-0.4232516884803772,
-0.8138140439987183,
-0.03224597126245499,
0.2685616910457611,
0.036527521908283234,
0.8972182273864746,
0.8001236915588379,
0.5086715817451477,
0.22465503215789795,
-0.3566015064716339,
-0.06798046827316284,
-0.12753039598464966,
0.5290514826774597,
-0.1251254826784134,
-0.41551825404167175,
-0.7243592143058777,
-0.1826670914888382,
0.7475184202194214,
0.16073937714099884,
-0.030224187299609184,
0.1848461776971817,
0.20122766494750977,
0.4828123450279236,
-1.0254201889038086,
-0.039969876408576965,
-0.8697358965873718,
0.04816567897796631,
-0.7237590551376343,
-0.058816224336624146,
-0.5999661684036255,
-0.057649534195661545,
-0.2838248610496521,
-0.6838177442550659,
-0.3397201895713806,
0.4674634337425232,
1.2340350151062012,
0.3050805628299713,
-0.4176981449127197,
0.04376997426152229,
-0.9312673211097717,
1.011802077293396,
-0.803155243396759,
0.24361787736415863,
0.8399301171302795,
0.4705007076263428,
0.2202572375535965,
-0.8417248725891113,
-0.5172133445739746,
0.12767989933490753,
0.38910606503486633,
0.06234157830476761,
-0.5364164113998413,
-0.24347180128097534,
0.3599337935447693,
0.41375479102134705,
-0.4201764464378357,
0.14813844859600067,
-0.05731147155165672,
-0.13761915266513824,
0.6587018966674805,
0.13801175355911255,
0.34892651438713074,
0.08851169049739838,
-0.5145035982131958,
-0.052479200065135956,
-1.3716986179351807,
-0.011151918210089207,
0.7056273818016052,
0.3110767900943756,
-0.17565682530403137,
0.4556690752506256,
-0.11305820196866989,
0.5200191736221313,
-0.26976123452186584,
-0.26595377922058105,
-0.17240586876869202,
0.3458622395992279,
-0.13088473677635193,
0.06485568732023239,
0.8643333911895752,
-0.07341338694095612,
0.21291567385196686,
0.19833916425704956,
-0.39936375617980957,
-0.3766704797744751,
-0.0012701014056801796,
-0.8512125611305237,
-0.12860029935836792,
0.42221006751060486,
-0.5021790266036987,
-0.26350006461143494,
-0.177743598818779,
-0.7413438558578491,
-0.48122793436050415,
0.04816344752907753,
0.7617267370223999,
-0.4549042880535126,
-0.6564419269561768,
-0.02750101499259472,
0.18349401652812958,
0.25189271569252014,
0.23964722454547882,
-0.853396475315094,
0.31058406829833984,
0.9143887758255005,
0.6471087336540222,
-0.02521366812288761,
0.19348452985286713,
-0.49807220697402954,
0.4434947073459625,
-0.2912661135196686,
0.9161456823348999,
-0.57060706615448,
-0.38958922028541565,
0.04534263163805008,
-0.04959362372756004,
0.03772718459367752,
-0.5960161685943604,
0.37383922934532166,
-1.0784910917282104,
-0.11478070914745331,
-0.09790614992380142,
-0.685269832611084,
-0.008882198482751846,
0.27872994542121887,
-1.0428396463394165,
1.0367512702941895,
0.2518567144870758,
-1.0101608037948608,
0.19523489475250244,
-0.44899436831474304,
-0.47147732973098755,
0.5199244618415833,
0.19031231105327606,
-0.8284445405006409,
-0.2123013734817505,
0.1247711032629013,
0.45356661081314087,
-0.37746042013168335,
-0.05943736061453819,
-0.5409936308860779,
0.027262074872851372,
0.3520846664905548,
-0.37713176012039185,
1.039239525794983,
0.42310357093811035,
-0.2875851094722748,
0.021718908101320267,
-0.9545658826828003,
0.16923224925994873,
0.47471147775650024,
-0.1890808492898941,
-0.9405646324157715,
0.09467318654060364,
0.21752257645130157,
-0.2579062283039093,
0.34848713874816895,
-0.6978220343589783,
-0.13979753851890564,
0.23555000126361847,
0.6483791470527649,
0.8536567687988281,
-0.03466477990150452,
0.1751849353313446,
-0.19395515322685242,
0.8352052569389343,
-0.17312222719192505,
0.19828446209430695,
-0.3347311317920685,
-0.6705965399742126,
-0.532095730304718,
-0.7717283368110657,
0.9001046419143677,
0.49222010374069214,
-0.7362679243087769,
0.2851978838443756,
-0.39087536931037903,
-0.3905533254146576,
-0.7266018986701965,
0.1434921771287918,
0.4778066873550415,
0.31361842155456543,
0.2856445908546448,
-0.0482744500041008,
-0.0558098740875721,
-1.163226842880249,
-0.14818914234638214,
-0.258362352848053,
-0.10540322959423065,
0.20003899931907654,
0.45099204778671265,
0.03447157144546509,
0.8995418548583984,
-0.2804996073246002,
-0.12238717079162598,
-0.3415076732635498,
0.11282214522361755,
-0.07502201199531555,
0.676053524017334,
0.46324601769447327,
-0.9510343670845032,
-0.8490683436393738,
0.2635612487792969,
-0.6816771626472473,
-0.1116650328040123,
0.03099929168820381,
-0.0037956039886921644,
0.049167945981025696,
0.4528914988040924,
-0.7118673920631409,
0.4437759816646576,
0.792491614818573,
-0.3259723484516144,
0.5498597025871277,
0.2343711107969284,
-0.06433790922164917,
-1.2344427108764648,
0.19541935622692108,
-0.2721794545650482,
-0.6283034682273865,
-0.24496303498744965,
0.5253416895866394,
0.1493641883134842,
-0.041672877967357635,
-0.5327550172805786,
0.8649681806564331,
-0.191104918718338,
0.08359768241643906,
-0.18353965878486633,
-0.35075753927230835,
0.2772785723209381,
-0.04587951675057411,
-0.16321659088134766,
0.8332520723342896,
0.5289074778556824,
-0.23730148375034332,
0.27142250537872314,
0.17179274559020996,
-0.4471871554851532,
1.22475266456604,
-1.0150525569915771,
0.23283420503139496,
0.36272722482681274,
-0.21512803435325623,
-0.7610710859298706,
-0.038983043283224106,
-0.17635494470596313,
-0.20566034317016602,
0.5883783102035522,
-0.6247796416282654,
-0.5950220823287964,
-0.022401301190257072,
-0.28311896324157715,
0.2976795434951782,
0.6822026371955872,
-0.5433877110481262,
0.9700555205345154,
0.5393293499946594,
-0.3888227045536041,
-0.4611450731754303,
-0.630302906036377,
0.15232108533382416,
-0.6370989084243774,
-0.7267633676528931,
0.6230414509773254,
-0.03726982697844505,
-0.47933369874954224,
0.2370452880859375,
0.18601657450199127,
-0.4530186355113983,
0.423941433429718,
0.3344508707523346,
-0.05316642299294472,
-0.3293924629688263,
-0.3143600821495056,
0.4438198506832123,
-0.3959029018878937,
-0.12998169660568237,
-0.0403289720416069,
0.41668859124183655,
-0.055521488189697266,
-0.5576515197753906,
-0.5185989737510681,
0.6583834290504456,
0.5239754915237427,
-0.27095845341682434,
0.7739802002906799,
0.4881322383880615,
-0.7035833597183228,
-0.3852115273475647,
-0.36533626914024353,
-0.09705465286970139,
-0.5452181100845337,
0.11615573614835739,
-0.46109527349472046,
-1.1539947986602783,
0.7337082028388977,
-0.03419148549437523,
0.07317648828029633,
0.5694052577018738,
0.25910305976867676,
-0.3735305368900299,
0.741783618927002,
0.7150801420211792,
-0.05805644392967224,
0.41428661346435547,
-0.11607883870601654,
0.3771752715110779,
-1.1106914281845093,
0.16084648668766022,
-0.417671799659729,
-0.2194175273180008,
-0.2368966042995453,
0.0635877400636673,
0.08253322541713715,
0.2829359769821167,
-0.2997737526893616,
0.6048689484596252,
-0.4160177707672119,
0.501630425453186,
0.9425016045570374,
-0.026549413800239563,
0.30381932854652405,
-0.028607433661818504,
-0.43162432312965393,
-0.2398456335067749,
-0.34186291694641113,
-0.6951102018356323,
1.148236632347107,
0.46879395842552185,
0.8813146948814392,
0.12136021256446838,
0.4221709668636322,
0.6647108793258667,
0.22046305239200592,
-0.3746664524078369,
0.5876649022102356,
0.22161410748958588,
-0.9804685711860657,
-0.2190663069486618,
-0.31163325905799866,
-1.039196252822876,
-0.014796112664043903,
-0.11399216949939728,
-1.028179407119751,
0.059831056743860245,
0.12610875070095062,
-0.700229823589325,
0.662883996963501,
-0.35568317770957947,
0.6325613856315613,
-0.11562930792570114,
-0.9764512181282043,
-0.38737407326698303,
-0.3262285590171814,
0.2826266586780548,
-0.5025356411933899,
0.21588566899299622,
-0.36859381198883057,
0.3160136044025421,
0.7890112996101379,
-0.37931081652641296,
0.7087445259094238,
-0.19926539063453674,
-0.2232629507780075,
0.4948802590370178,
0.6586934328079224,
0.7313550114631653,
0.08905075490474701,
-0.08465909957885742,
0.23308897018432617,
0.08897235989570618,
-0.3407197594642639,
-0.23757587373256683,
0.4141639471054077,
-0.3246902823448181,
-0.6707156300544739,
-0.20339784026145935,
-0.3149609863758087,
0.07362865656614304,
0.3531438410282135,
0.2058434784412384,
0.25110259652137756,
-0.03337773680686951,
0.53758305311203,
0.72111976146698,
-0.5076781511306763,
0.7496074438095093,
0.4783836901187897,
-0.0356704480946064,
-0.6518662571907043,
0.8809850811958313,
0.09560652077198029,
0.36763718724250793,
0.5172798037528992,
0.1344253271818161,
-0.04154755547642708,
-0.666942834854126,
-0.39372512698173523,
-0.1563158631324768,
-0.7280930280685425,
-0.4993879795074463,
-0.7185105085372925,
-0.5536929368972778,
0.01217721588909626,
-0.2369598001241684,
-1.1059541702270508,
-0.8231253623962402,
0.020667031407356262,
-0.09189827740192413,
0.6886950731277466,
0.5775002837181091,
-0.10246743261814117,
0.811663031578064,
-0.738436758518219,
0.05851440131664276,
0.6619014739990234,
0.3406936228275299,
-0.12296269088983536,
-0.5115166902542114,
-0.44303062558174133,
-0.06602417677640915,
-0.5684880018234253,
-0.5056881904602051,
0.4190366268157959,
0.21430496871471405,
0.3610849976539612,
0.8827469348907471,
0.3523625135421753,
0.26690879464149475,
-0.4966498911380768,
0.7544711828231812,
-0.13658945262432098,
-1.1889432668685913,
0.4536208510398865,
-0.6614585518836975,
0.07049082219600677,
0.2306799441576004,
0.2057935893535614,
-0.07981567829847336,
-0.257291316986084,
-0.6886456608772278,
-1.269662618637085,
0.07420629262924194,
0.3814493715763092,
0.3286215364933014,
0.3870212137699127,
0.005134314298629761,
-0.06392698734998703,
0.22730571031570435,
-0.9593580365180969,
0.1316000074148178,
0.03283928707242012,
-0.19921568036079407,
0.812528133392334,
-0.6726439595222473,
-0.3461759090423584,
-0.1398388296365738,
0.8000797033309937,
-0.053911272436380386,
0.4871180057525635,
-0.22534383833408356,
-0.1282922625541687,
-0.1871330887079239,
0.13504180312156677,
0.37503090500831604,
0.4029392898082733,
-0.09542029350996017,
0.36838728189468384,
0.03536611050367355,
-0.48324811458587646,
0.07079178839921951,
0.19395707547664642,
-0.29330259561538696,
-0.2699902355670929,
0.8431146740913391,
0.4589281976222992,
0.04647858813405037,
-0.4245256781578064,
0.4413304626941681,
-0.04539823159575462,
0.11254189163446426,
-0.3675883710384369,
-0.013863880187273026,
0.2631087899208069,
0.26991987228393555,
0.5946565866470337,
-0.5024672150611877,
-0.08184253424406052,
-0.028196724131703377,
0.17943459749221802,
0.769917368888855,
-0.3047395944595337,
-0.707381546497345,
1.1010217666625977,
-0.013482603244483471,
-0.26924121379852295,
0.463085800409317,
-0.014515714719891548,
-0.5778146982192993,
0.5850986242294312,
0.5661182403564453,
1.1795164346694946,
-0.6948956847190857,
-0.18122155964374542,
0.2743460237979889,
0.5787831544876099,
0.1549571305513382,
0.3322668969631195,
-0.12418291717767715,
-0.8220698237419128,
-0.11815829575061798,
-0.6650397181510925,
-0.7307219505310059,
0.08932697027921677,
-0.6385321617126465,
0.17466598749160767,
-0.8844594359397888,
-0.43052276968955994,
0.02678055129945278,
-0.41148635745048523,
-0.22462281584739685,
-0.046126846224069595,
0.18986113369464874,
0.5291913747787476,
-0.7350869178771973,
1.0294979810714722,
0.3613957166671753,
0.04673972353339195,
-0.4808356761932373,
-0.2736496031284332,
0.15988077223300934,
-0.804188072681427,
0.37404170632362366,
-0.013068275526165962,
0.06895417720079422,
0.12214101105928421,
-0.7457991242408752,
-1.097176194190979,
0.9903351664543152,
0.4207516610622406,
-0.37620803713798523,
0.5181108117103577,
0.2845558524131775,
0.29825541377067566,
-0.2644127905368805,
-0.0813356339931488,
0.14882390201091766,
0.3576156198978424,
-0.13323572278022766,
-0.6786620616912842,
0.2036212533712387,
-0.5650222897529602,
-0.08022332191467285,
0.0381084606051445,
-0.8243669867515564,
0.9264434576034546,
0.07345334440469742,
-0.3154609203338623,
0.1490020453929901,
0.39416182041168213,
0.3633997440338135,
0.047486208379268646,
0.295525461435318,
0.7894940972328186,
0.6031756401062012,
-0.25355392694473267,
1.1965153217315674,
-0.3846263885498047,
0.21677406132221222,
0.9908159375190735,
-0.7019139528274536,
1.30729079246521,
0.38257157802581787,
-0.3710603713989258,
0.5155486464500427,
0.5407492518424988,
-0.07678862661123276,
0.7364420890808105,
-0.09061489999294281,
-0.5456260442733765,
-0.30840736627578735,
-0.1693037748336792,
-0.4309261441230774,
0.3412106931209564,
0.6072518825531006,
-0.3361925482749939,
0.23741266131401062,
-0.16630616784095764,
0.42398104071617126,
0.02094506286084652,
0.08657535165548325,
0.5110942721366882,
0.41507479548454285,
0.09980852156877518,
0.5210855603218079,
0.14895230531692505,
0.46587127447128296,
-0.7051602602005005,
0.14406196773052216,
-0.2196822166442871,
0.3649798333644867,
-0.00954106729477644,
-0.6982619166374207,
0.39920148253440857,
-0.0619991235435009,
0.12404294312000275,
-0.3360767364501953,
0.6922543048858643,
-0.07397560775279999,
-0.4969192147254944,
0.4932059645652771,
0.15870818495750427,
-0.31464865803718567,
-0.18346157670021057,
-0.69451504945755,
0.34103965759277344,
-0.2406519651412964,
-0.5791760683059692,
0.3171262741088867,
0.33626869320869446,
-0.1506231725215912,
0.9405878186225891,
0.7400531768798828,
-0.016097405925393105,
0.0022058237809687853,
-0.43024972081184387,
0.6259323954582214,
-0.4850786328315735,
-0.515150785446167,
-1.0558043718338013,
0.6925426721572876,
-0.2637096345424652,
-0.0815856084227562,
0.9823710322380066,
0.5164759755134583,
0.3973160684108734,
0.11485780775547028,
0.6819577813148499,
0.006380015984177589,
0.3499095141887665,
-0.5698505640029907,
1.2375719547271729,
-0.50799161195755,
0.41137373447418213,
-0.5867324471473694,
-1.1521742343902588,
-0.5005037784576416,
0.5253555774688721,
0.050097834318876266,
-0.07221084833145142,
0.623214066028595,
0.710281491279602,
-0.254499226808548,
-0.02934933640062809,
0.5916963815689087,
0.013134011067450047,
0.5244303345680237,
0.353060781955719,
0.9864264726638794,
-0.546444296836853,
0.20616397261619568,
-0.1538647711277008,
-0.18034876883029938,
0.04055672138929367,
-1.158374547958374,
-0.8237450122833252,
-0.6090227961540222,
-0.811373233795166,
-0.4225042760372162,
0.18906962871551514,
0.5486567616462708,
1.1224350929260254,
-1.1226991415023804,
0.08178170025348663,
0.3092077672481537,
0.29972895979881287,
-0.17097730934619904,
-0.2258545160293579,
0.6585213541984558,
0.37676090002059937,
-0.7223833203315735,
0.3464468717575073,
0.49636512994766235,
0.46505826711654663,
-0.18955668807029724,
0.16828720271587372,
-0.007081576623022556,
0.33274489641189575,
0.46499761939048767,
0.3280264139175415,
-0.25482821464538574,
-0.001966044306755066,
-0.30724117159843445,
-0.0989864319562912,
-0.05512707680463791,
0.3953540325164795,
-0.3119319677352905,
0.14410832524299622,
0.20330731570720673,
0.8018155097961426,
0.5405596494674683,
-0.2688053250312805,
0.4926837682723999,
-0.761602520942688,
0.48616504669189453,
0.2326103150844574,
0.7156765460968018,
0.640450119972229,
-0.3614042401313782,
0.49288785457611084,
0.2959076464176178,
-0.33707571029663086,
-1.1005895137786865,
0.04737163335084915,
-0.8441365361213684,
-0.10264340043067932,
1.229109764099121,
-0.5325502753257751,
-0.3368147611618042,
-0.10052148252725601,
0.22737562656402588,
-0.36056819558143616,
-0.24102531373500824,
0.7376871705055237,
0.7481153011322021,
0.6908940672874451,
-0.4132968783378601,
-0.8387616276741028,
0.2952318787574768,
0.28105512261390686,
-0.8363416790962219,
0.04507790133357048,
-0.016242174431681633,
0.30983710289001465,
0.13521011173725128,
0.3018844425678253,
-0.5570336580276489,
-0.05608266964554787,
0.22957485914230347,
0.39730754494667053,
0.015410373918712139,
-0.2690998613834381,
0.05750630050897598,
0.2304615080356598,
0.30171939730644226,
-0.056872736662626266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17936v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17936v1
|
Acquiring Linguistic Knowledge from Multimodal Input
| 2024-02-27T23:29:10 | 2024-02-27T23:29:10 |
Theodor Amariucai, Alex Warstadt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In contrast to children, language models (LMs) exhibit considerably inferior
data efficiency when acquiring language. In this submission to the BabyLM
Challenge (Warstadt et al., 2023), we test the hypothesis that this data
efficiency gap is partly caused by a lack of multimodal input and grounding in
the learning environment of typical language models. Although previous work
looking into this question found that multimodal training can even harm
language-only performance, we speculate that these findings can be attributed
to catastrophic forgetting of complex language due to fine-tuning on captions
data. To test our hypothesis, we perform an ablation study on FLAVA (Singh et
al., 2022), a multimodal vision-and-language model, independently varying the
volume of text and vision input to quantify how much text data (if any) can be
offset by vision at different data scales. We aim to limit catastrophic
forgetting through a multitask pretraining regime that includes unimodal
text-only tasks and data sampled from WiT, the relatively diverse
Wikipedia-based dataset (Srinivasan et al., 2021). Our results are largely
negative: Multimodal pretraining does not harm our models' language performance
but does not consistently help either. That said, our conclusions are limited
by our having been able to conduct only a small number of runs. While we must
leave open the possibility that multimodal input explains some of the gap in
data efficiency between LMs and humans, positive evidence for this hypothesis
will require better architectures and techniques for multimodal training.
|
[
-0.3744029402732849,
-0.6969546675682068,
0.2806169390678406,
-0.15406781435012817,
-0.32548585534095764,
0.13880248367786407,
-0.2582511901855469,
-0.4072900116443634,
-0.296998530626297,
0.32157570123672485,
-0.5477308034896851,
-0.07691533118486404,
-0.7015345096588135,
-0.10333281755447388,
-0.199332594871521,
0.964679479598999,
-0.021427640691399574,
0.08230741322040558,
-0.6467207074165344,
-0.2720237076282501,
-0.5810908079147339,
-0.5354884266853333,
-0.47610172629356384,
-0.3321138620376587,
0.8926662802696228,
0.5360803604125977,
0.48091959953308105,
0.526155412197113,
0.38270828127861023,
0.2957550287246704,
0.1829717457294464,
0.385555624961853,
-0.5365657806396484,
0.1965676099061966,
-0.18056872487068176,
-0.6854308843612671,
-0.17777082324028015,
-0.049153298139572144,
0.7078392505645752,
0.8240658044815063,
-0.12660358846187592,
0.030052809044718742,
-0.07130403071641922,
0.9364884495735168,
-0.8394349217414856,
0.21708424389362335,
-0.6660400032997131,
-0.04008205607533455,
-0.34300681948661804,
-0.3173905909061432,
-0.5667781233787537,
0.04825877398252487,
0.13945652544498444,
-0.42608290910720825,
0.3476203978061676,
0.10044285655021667,
0.8835098743438721,
0.35808444023132324,
-0.44909700751304626,
-0.42561444640159607,
-0.8622295260429382,
0.9216632843017578,
-0.42626067996025085,
0.7350968718528748,
0.5786912441253662,
-0.013478009030222893,
0.11628936976194382,
-0.2246248871088028,
-0.8279609084129333,
-0.2584991455078125,
-0.10373623669147491,
0.06056084856390953,
-0.07721059024333954,
0.23046524822711945,
0.5669659376144409,
0.17997156083583832,
-0.6786274909973145,
-0.12638507783412933,
-0.6520660519599915,
-0.27256670594215393,
0.3891187012195587,
0.06292136013507843,
0.438117653131485,
-0.08977081626653671,
-0.22248436510562897,
-0.31421926617622375,
-0.6564894914627075,
0.1303151547908783,
0.32311519980430603,
0.31128862500190735,
-0.18596890568733215,
0.6690105199813843,
-0.11969032883644104,
0.784433126449585,
-0.27110588550567627,
-0.423813134431839,
0.4979190528392792,
-0.39499977231025696,
0.010463469661772251,
-0.24272385239601135,
0.683928370475769,
0.22719888389110565,
0.4964452087879181,
-0.16707225143909454,
-0.22846351563930511,
0.40672871470451355,
0.39347079396247864,
-0.5388655066490173,
-0.40182140469551086,
0.1301686018705368,
-0.15096627175807953,
0.19883736968040466,
-0.024014068767428398,
-0.7325036525726318,
-0.4064040780067444,
-0.2624605894088745,
0.548049807548523,
-0.7434278130531311,
-0.2816929221153259,
-0.13559158146381378,
-0.10668311268091202,
-0.006289226468652487,
0.15113750100135803,
-1.0775032043457031,
-0.14213375747203827,
0.3104775846004486,
0.7230828404426575,
-0.013467452488839626,
-0.6225847601890564,
-0.3340079188346863,
-0.09841054677963257,
-0.38897478580474854,
0.8530762791633606,
-0.4537353515625,
-0.12364381551742554,
-0.018317393958568573,
-0.09471292048692703,
-0.5829045176506042,
-0.5875722169876099,
0.0639968067407608,
-0.6078559756278992,
0.02851076051592827,
-0.25713232159614563,
-0.3237094581127167,
-0.2891727685928345,
0.16573554277420044,
-0.7426125407218933,
0.5986481308937073,
-0.016046077013015747,
-0.5961538553237915,
0.7578600645065308,
-0.635580837726593,
-0.6198477149009705,
-0.27903270721435547,
-0.0413532480597496,
-0.4943121671676636,
0.2861770987510681,
0.031605202704668045,
0.3896350562572479,
-0.03733690455555916,
0.31020206212997437,
-0.2734876573085785,
-0.19902943074703217,
0.3994289040565491,
-0.7099454402923584,
0.4751785099506378,
0.3079061806201935,
-0.26487091183662415,
-0.08008318394422531,
-0.9640434384346008,
-0.3014678955078125,
0.1346544325351715,
-0.5663788318634033,
-0.44748789072036743,
0.10794181376695633,
-0.14404502511024475,
0.43711721897125244,
0.017471788451075554,
-0.6711708903312683,
0.04627334699034691,
-0.20961950719356537,
0.1329379826784134,
0.6416822075843811,
-0.2945582866668701,
0.48482948541641235,
-0.5940809845924377,
0.5186695456504822,
0.35839831829071045,
0.10503451526165009,
-0.6619667410850525,
-0.1426975131034851,
-1.1657558679580688,
-0.14226363599300385,
0.16502949595451355,
0.27215680480003357,
-1.2043137550354004,
-0.2765151858329773,
-0.2421809881925583,
-0.33958736062049866,
-0.5376649498939514,
0.42917826771736145,
0.654481053352356,
0.42630961537361145,
0.31051185727119446,
-0.5445507168769836,
-0.5456735491752625,
-0.9841358065605164,
-0.12571823596954346,
-0.20020633935928345,
0.17526929080486298,
0.27120789885520935,
0.4673002362251282,
-0.18883192539215088,
0.7196313738822937,
-0.17937959730625153,
-0.26364293694496155,
-0.32691237330436707,
0.22557838261127472,
-0.1167338490486145,
0.6090436577796936,
0.4410332143306732,
-0.8333293795585632,
-0.2657845914363861,
-0.20709410309791565,
-0.8579065203666687,
0.11829757690429688,
-0.18538914620876312,
0.19916869699954987,
0.5399519801139832,
0.21224834024906158,
-0.8313905000686646,
0.2876109480857849,
0.768227756023407,
-0.38481441140174866,
0.42052948474884033,
-0.35839954018592834,
0.1948740929365158,
-0.5514546632766724,
0.09504152834415436,
-0.20148959755897522,
0.004954329691827297,
-0.8636990189552307,
-0.05509961396455765,
0.3002859652042389,
0.054765734821558,
-0.5842400193214417,
0.5072342157363892,
-0.4982047379016876,
0.10766027867794037,
-0.22254569828510284,
-0.07772304117679596,
0.08859094977378845,
0.6759809255599976,
0.022369833663105965,
0.768246054649353,
0.41118499636650085,
-0.7707726955413818,
0.17185664176940918,
0.06947943568229675,
-0.4222603738307953,
0.5574565529823303,
-0.28251373767852783,
0.16699373722076416,
-0.566464364528656,
-0.032683003693819046,
-1.207810878753662,
-0.40395307540893555,
0.0359184592962265,
-0.5637801289558411,
0.5720763802528381,
0.29869818687438965,
-0.4973106384277344,
-0.1924595683813095,
-0.12071342021226883,
0.5424918532371521,
0.4108903706073761,
-0.4191935658454895,
0.6608263850212097,
0.25614261627197266,
-0.07961346209049225,
-0.7217031717300415,
-0.7547442317008972,
-0.0295772273093462,
-0.12638847529888153,
-0.4455293118953705,
-0.16876725852489471,
-0.1703774333000183,
-0.18904751539230347,
-0.14072275161743164,
-0.055980194360017776,
-0.1316036432981491,
0.13041572272777557,
0.2886909544467926,
0.19931891560554504,
-0.17645034193992615,
0.5564625263214111,
-0.11935126781463623,
-0.20050737261772156,
-0.02294679544866085,
-0.036010514944791794,
0.6649952530860901,
0.045643873512744904,
-0.45290741324424744,
-0.3678721785545349,
0.28702259063720703,
0.8137589693069458,
-0.2625148892402649,
0.9450960755348206,
0.590997576713562,
-0.28955507278442383,
-0.01660383678972721,
-0.7835445404052734,
-0.09848097711801529,
-0.42762866616249084,
0.4803668260574341,
-0.32496359944343567,
-0.6063505411148071,
0.2733207643032074,
0.06374689191579819,
0.1505822092294693,
0.40025630593299866,
0.460646390914917,
-0.4766210615634918,
0.8587865233421326,
0.8175617456436157,
0.3084396421909332,
0.6376241445541382,
-0.40887776017189026,
-0.028803732246160507,
-0.774285078048706,
-0.5050783157348633,
-0.3070664703845978,
-0.22931784391403198,
-0.18014666438102722,
-0.2730916738510132,
0.15109921991825104,
0.04189306125044823,
-0.1607690453529358,
0.08672145009040833,
-0.030512334778904915,
0.348121702671051,
0.6189367771148682,
0.28381091356277466,
0.3496074676513672,
0.08465811610221863,
-0.21818865835666656,
-0.17655406892299652,
-1.1022169589996338,
-0.27688032388687134,
1.218008041381836,
0.17908930778503418,
0.7925006747245789,
0.07611099630594254,
0.33797287940979004,
0.13244310021400452,
0.3966250717639923,
-0.48489105701446533,
0.2315971702337265,
-0.19068805873394012,
-0.9269499182701111,
-0.1628553867340088,
-0.409269243478775,
-1.0142172574996948,
0.3288251459598541,
-0.22319768369197845,
-0.4935866594314575,
0.20360176265239716,
0.5392602682113647,
-0.41035252809524536,
0.3105781078338623,
-0.9633840322494507,
0.9184318780899048,
-0.3953917622566223,
-0.558350682258606,
-0.19737127423286438,
-0.6462674736976624,
0.3899531662464142,
-0.3821313977241516,
0.6578445434570312,
-0.03002537041902542,
0.09314259886741638,
0.9134952425956726,
-0.1514674425125122,
0.9828432202339172,
-0.41027384996414185,
0.024467667564749718,
0.2803954482078552,
-0.05952465161681175,
0.09021712839603424,
-0.2784627079963684,
0.23098595440387726,
0.10642317682504654,
-0.17512404918670654,
-0.6242111921310425,
-0.4589715898036957,
0.4313660264015198,
-0.8593096137046814,
-0.27560141682624817,
-0.49008479714393616,
-0.732276976108551,
-0.33803635835647583,
0.13476401567459106,
0.32500723004341125,
0.6094808578491211,
0.16481652855873108,
0.3595466911792755,
0.830572783946991,
-0.2448446899652481,
0.5597344636917114,
0.4575783908367157,
-0.11209245026111603,
-0.22807690501213074,
1.1292412281036377,
0.3723643720149994,
0.7557846903800964,
0.27815473079681396,
0.051406484097242355,
-0.36660587787628174,
-0.661036491394043,
-0.5307491421699524,
0.30699095129966736,
-0.8050244450569153,
-0.0764981135725975,
-0.761076033115387,
0.12435348331928253,
-0.098496213555336,
-0.04166945442557335,
-0.6869913935661316,
-0.09693898260593414,
-0.23380769789218903,
0.05712084844708443,
0.12106480449438095,
0.7346846461296082,
-0.17563921213150024,
0.3976273834705353,
-0.9001975059509277,
0.3898436725139618,
0.34420713782310486,
0.3045980930328369,
0.23588424921035767,
-0.48655372858047485,
-0.4762178659439087,
0.31177255511283875,
-0.22794173657894135,
-0.5023764371871948,
0.26412442326545715,
0.47268566489219666,
0.5342090725898743,
0.4820491075515747,
-0.103354312479496,
0.8729419112205505,
-0.37730512022972107,
0.8104854822158813,
0.4335680603981018,
-0.5884106159210205,
0.3848685622215271,
-0.23828943073749542,
0.7670510411262512,
0.6894556879997253,
0.3987143933773041,
-0.5680931806564331,
-0.3114665448665619,
-0.5536142587661743,
-0.800201416015625,
0.80527663230896,
-0.143293097615242,
0.25817108154296875,
0.10541316121816635,
0.1918947398662567,
0.31759539246559143,
0.42004361748695374,
-0.8071638941764832,
-0.19144569337368011,
-0.13003070652484894,
-0.11063285917043686,
-0.5485618710517883,
-0.4649125337600708,
0.08746993541717529,
-0.37363818287849426,
0.4891161024570465,
-0.07630093395709991,
0.2180858552455902,
0.09229614585638046,
-0.6542126536369324,
-0.29676511883735657,
0.1349773108959198,
0.8501381278038025,
0.8173691630363464,
0.060954391956329346,
0.35151347517967224,
0.1861260086297989,
-0.5207395553588867,
0.2207927405834198,
-0.23723135888576508,
-0.11148273199796677,
-0.042248018085956573,
0.8914691805839539,
1.0607671737670898,
0.3963301479816437,
-0.9397344589233398,
0.4089203476905823,
-0.08878450840711594,
-0.2572334408760071,
-0.2717215418815613,
0.12097331881523132,
0.16733916103839874,
0.11707167327404022,
0.4253956377506256,
0.4988262951374054,
-0.3938615024089813,
-0.6705375909805298,
0.3244454562664032,
0.39940840005874634,
-0.39846786856651306,
-0.4016139805316925,
0.7220689654350281,
-0.01822763867676258,
-0.35277873277664185,
0.720771312713623,
0.016662495210766792,
-0.4321465790271759,
0.5047250390052795,
0.30973127484321594,
0.48798665404319763,
-0.34415990114212036,
-0.0019616142380982637,
0.40229424834251404,
0.4469866454601288,
0.021885694935917854,
0.18715055286884308,
-0.13738836348056793,
-0.8424541354179382,
-0.4213348925113678,
-0.7210685610771179,
-0.027713952586054802,
0.19922490417957306,
-0.40737783908843994,
0.09031326323747635,
-0.3012055456638336,
0.049230944365262985,
-0.009365967474877834,
-0.28928887844085693,
-0.8932934403419495,
0.26411983370780945,
0.2710998058319092,
0.4187278747558594,
-0.9070241451263428,
0.8392991423606873,
0.5972999930381775,
-0.48483896255493164,
-0.6223025918006897,
-0.2727850079536438,
0.021008307114243507,
-0.7294687032699585,
0.6748502254486084,
0.24705573916435242,
-0.09392879903316498,
-0.12836839258670807,
-0.3914329409599304,
-0.8307624459266663,
0.8046165108680725,
0.30336233973503113,
-0.6132416725158691,
-0.15219612419605255,
0.32847562432289124,
0.44994860887527466,
-0.22239680588245392,
0.32072558999061584,
0.49893051385879517,
0.37681761384010315,
0.14480909705162048,
-1.0613347291946411,
-0.3109252154827118,
-0.19800697267055511,
-0.05610951781272888,
0.08904751390218735,
-0.6263089776039124,
1.1457579135894775,
-0.4410247206687927,
-0.37579840421676636,
-0.17239990830421448,
0.3388670086860657,
-0.042031582444906235,
0.46203896403312683,
0.6549153327941895,
0.5336569547653198,
0.44265201687812805,
-0.03616256266832352,
1.1384553909301758,
-0.07253758609294891,
0.36797404289245605,
0.8561797738075256,
0.12974758446216583,
0.7347699999809265,
0.6823320984840393,
-0.16221708059310913,
0.2361001968383789,
0.4630826711654663,
0.3483521044254303,
0.6996248364448547,
-0.12645018100738525,
-0.11277174204587936,
-0.34283602237701416,
-0.08442285656929016,
-0.1600538045167923,
0.6464618444442749,
0.41531455516815186,
-0.25319331884384155,
-0.24728502333164215,
0.6081714034080505,
0.06891412287950516,
0.08464931696653366,
-0.0462249256670475,
0.8291658759117126,
0.06466123461723328,
-0.8006617426872253,
0.9709485173225403,
-0.35257139801979065,
0.8893815279006958,
-0.7568410634994507,
0.0056909238919615746,
-0.20668064057826996,
0.2411532998085022,
-0.10573656111955643,
-0.2857964038848877,
0.3879650831222534,
-0.15085966885089874,
-0.18874144554138184,
-0.19004413485527039,
0.5898379683494568,
-0.7621057033538818,
-0.36201974749565125,
0.23416413366794586,
0.7136247754096985,
0.09811745584011078,
0.0572456456720829,
-0.5251644849777222,
0.3085974156856537,
0.0657166987657547,
-0.38455647230148315,
0.4496632218360901,
0.1255471259355545,
0.18713559210300446,
0.8145543336868286,
0.75156170129776,
0.06106556951999664,
0.40982383489608765,
-0.06476190686225891,
0.8188059329986572,
-0.5870252847671509,
-0.18015310168266296,
-1.0156800746917725,
0.6628914475440979,
0.1815778762102127,
-0.35487088561058044,
0.5629866123199463,
0.515998899936676,
1.1027828454971313,
-0.18737520277500153,
0.7720123529434204,
-0.16341491043567657,
0.3738485872745514,
-0.646872878074646,
0.7912229895591736,
-0.9269387125968933,
0.03380758315324783,
-0.32461971044540405,
-0.7660945057868958,
-0.3590746521949768,
0.5944147109985352,
-0.20900584757328033,
0.06337834894657135,
1.0033308267593384,
0.6692981123924255,
0.024064812809228897,
-0.17154157161712646,
0.5948050022125244,
0.12249090522527695,
0.28139036893844604,
0.7448391318321228,
1.009429693222046,
-0.2594417631626129,
0.5147870182991028,
-0.5897024273872375,
-0.25029051303863525,
-0.13814860582351685,
-0.5077359080314636,
-1.040715217590332,
-0.8888858556747437,
-0.14990483224391937,
-0.07652635127305984,
0.20130416750907898,
0.7741133570671082,
0.59983891248703,
-0.6822888255119324,
-0.14848610758781433,
0.0880712941288948,
-0.0037227573338896036,
-0.08584213256835938,
-0.13868293166160583,
0.17552216351032257,
-0.520264744758606,
-0.7225995659828186,
0.30247560143470764,
0.14254127442836761,
-0.00939108058810234,
-0.3824707567691803,
-0.05964849516749382,
-0.5458118319511414,
-0.1881081461906433,
0.7779291272163391,
0.3370828628540039,
-0.7285492420196533,
-0.4289413094520569,
-0.022118525579571724,
-0.03249223530292511,
0.18363630771636963,
0.8206131458282471,
-0.6897093653678894,
0.8987733721733093,
0.274808794260025,
0.5721285939216614,
0.4122985303401947,
-0.20291604101657867,
0.3633083403110504,
-0.6862523555755615,
0.4318685829639435,
0.11353243142366409,
0.3049246668815613,
0.43526986241340637,
-0.07473462074995041,
0.1410706341266632,
0.48905256390571594,
-0.3420584499835968,
-0.8023319244384766,
0.12404249608516693,
-0.6293857097625732,
-0.31658226251602173,
1.0851349830627441,
-0.12372791022062302,
-0.38522255420684814,
-0.33456048369407654,
-0.20902463793754578,
0.37690529227256775,
-0.34739580750465393,
0.8498757481575012,
0.9014880657196045,
-0.2005586475133896,
-0.39376944303512573,
-0.7418164014816284,
0.3834097683429718,
0.5513403415679932,
-0.4699065685272217,
0.13657613098621368,
0.5066595077514648,
0.25512030720710754,
0.4346550405025482,
0.7044166922569275,
0.032762665301561356,
0.38218793272972107,
0.3349779546260834,
0.2457592636346817,
-0.2467537671327591,
-0.701336145401001,
-0.40325695276260376,
0.36666586995124817,
0.21290501952171326,
-0.22011414170265198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17934v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17934v1
|
Multitask Multilingual Model Adaptation with Featurized Low-Rank Mixtures
| 2024-02-27T23:12:45 | 2024-02-27T23:12:45 |
Chu-Cheng Lin, Xinyi Wang, Jonathan H. Clark, Han Lu, Yun Zhu, Chenxi Whitehouse, Hongkun Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Adapting pretrained large language models (LLMs) to various downstream tasks
in tens or hundreds of human languages is computationally expensive.
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) significantly reduces the adaptation
cost, by tuning only a small amount of parameters. However, directly applying
PEFT methods such as LoRA (Hu et al., 2022) on diverse dataset mixtures could
lead to suboptimal performance due to limited parameter capacity and negative
interference among different datasets. In this work, we propose Featurized
Low-rank Mixtures (FLix), a novel PEFT method designed for effective multitask
multilingual tuning. FLix associates each unique dataset feature, such as the
dataset's language or task, with its own low-rank weight update parameters. By
composing feature-specific parameters for each dataset, FLix can accommodate
diverse dataset mixtures and generalize better to unseen datasets. Our
experiments show that FLix leads to significant improvements over a variety of
tasks for both supervised learning and zero-shot settings using different
training data mixtures.
|
[
-0.30927616357803345,
-0.5308271050453186,
0.413223534822464,
0.34071388840675354,
-0.17487680912017822,
0.34237921237945557,
-0.48871949315071106,
-0.28660109639167786,
0.11598309874534607,
0.5535430312156677,
-0.5177837014198303,
-0.29332879185676575,
-0.4873182773590088,
0.12087111175060272,
-0.13924816250801086,
1.036536693572998,
-0.18288801610469818,
-0.17258544266223907,
-0.24010984599590302,
-0.26816415786743164,
-0.4033719599246979,
-0.5022950768470764,
-0.4506877064704895,
-0.14752741158008575,
0.721248984336853,
0.8430298566818237,
0.3100247383117676,
0.17031633853912354,
0.02104305289685726,
0.2923974394798279,
0.3189656734466553,
0.4907620847225189,
-0.8391392827033997,
0.17434437572956085,
-0.19758674502372742,
-0.6066721677780151,
-0.44911330938339233,
-0.16761250793933868,
0.6033818125724792,
0.9362921118736267,
-0.02553061954677105,
0.09051625430583954,
0.3963891863822937,
0.6034305095672607,
-0.8133518695831299,
-0.08297491073608398,
-0.7179451584815979,
-0.08863485604524612,
-0.29920536279678345,
-0.16014990210533142,
-0.14591124653816223,
0.1908433884382248,
-0.24699510633945465,
-0.7460218667984009,
0.17410200834274292,
0.26305556297302246,
0.4087725579738617,
0.4079459309577942,
-0.10530281811952591,
0.24662378430366516,
-0.7455512881278992,
1.0685824155807495,
-0.7450093030929565,
0.590742826461792,
0.4825035035610199,
0.1180921122431755,
-0.12033148109912872,
-0.20426243543624878,
-0.36342889070510864,
-0.2093428671360016,
0.12324130535125732,
0.09258093684911728,
0.1244492456316948,
-0.07295379042625427,
0.14540739357471466,
0.15692301094532013,
-0.5959395170211792,
0.2519994080066681,
-0.19422726333141327,
-0.2131270319223404,
0.5681803822517395,
-0.06536957621574402,
0.10342390090227127,
0.12351018190383911,
-0.2889811098575592,
-0.22078311443328857,
-0.5625751614570618,
0.21648436784744263,
0.4517393708229065,
0.626896321773529,
-0.36472421884536743,
0.2546407878398895,
-0.49362877011299133,
0.7583915591239929,
0.20384718477725983,
-0.5566090941429138,
0.49448075890541077,
-0.3339516818523407,
-0.2607719898223877,
0.05263831838965416,
0.5077358484268188,
-0.018960464745759964,
0.20857523381710052,
-0.41798675060272217,
-0.25666311383247375,
-0.32344141602516174,
0.19015003740787506,
-0.67647385597229,
-0.3674989938735962,
0.462138295173645,
-0.23595067858695984,
-0.20584511756896973,
-0.16037818789482117,
-0.7139605283737183,
-0.4138311445713043,
-0.42312267422676086,
0.6177909970283508,
-0.5256631374359131,
-0.22732989490032196,
0.044557131826877594,
0.07003089785575867,
-0.15018457174301147,
0.5628277659416199,
-0.8646143078804016,
0.2991520166397095,
0.49512821435928345,
0.75726717710495,
-0.35232311487197876,
-0.8015250563621521,
-1.0626543760299683,
0.04651036486029625,
-0.2700504958629608,
0.9385880827903748,
-0.46577954292297363,
-0.22270160913467407,
-0.3835493326187134,
0.12523077428340912,
-0.5846746563911438,
-0.6378300786018372,
0.46248629689216614,
-0.07629334926605225,
-0.11755036562681198,
-0.18577037751674652,
-0.2063317447900772,
-0.10900579392910004,
0.14370094239711761,
-0.541659951210022,
1.4205377101898193,
0.4454461336135864,
-0.5401571393013,
0.49371206760406494,
-0.661899745464325,
-0.8471402525901794,
0.05066419020295143,
0.030879100784659386,
-0.21584920585155487,
0.37497058510780334,
0.38556522130966187,
0.6406791806221008,
-0.04229588434100151,
0.08568810671567917,
-0.6118350625038147,
-0.499359667301178,
0.13263364136219025,
-0.28826916217803955,
0.3662859797477722,
0.15748122334480286,
-0.2606728672981262,
0.2902672290802002,
-0.8259966969490051,
-0.09368337690830231,
0.014102025888860226,
-0.34699487686157227,
-0.43291351199150085,
0.08284765481948853,
0.25303953886032104,
0.26136255264282227,
0.23089848458766937,
-0.3897354304790497,
0.09706659615039825,
-0.4267217516899109,
0.3637080788612366,
0.5479439496994019,
-0.13962720334529877,
0.4207640290260315,
-0.555179238319397,
0.47705763578414917,
0.28564906120300293,
-0.09261033684015274,
0.006244187243282795,
-0.2233731746673584,
-0.8321940898895264,
-0.46665653586387634,
0.440884530544281,
0.7364597916603088,
-1.1055986881256104,
0.25168031454086304,
-0.5272070169448853,
-0.5720105767250061,
-0.435569703578949,
0.727985680103302,
0.0564141720533371,
0.443745493888855,
0.3330783247947693,
-0.04719950631260872,
-0.11560548841953278,
-0.8537582755088806,
-0.27580296993255615,
0.1898452639579773,
-0.2030826210975647,
0.3565331697463989,
0.4103342294692993,
0.09044717252254486,
0.6193400025367737,
-0.25686734914779663,
-0.1956193447113037,
-0.4448806941509247,
0.2590964734554291,
0.18882882595062256,
0.47193846106529236,
0.8350741267204285,
-0.6702465415000916,
-0.5734061002731323,
0.05092690885066986,
-0.19239871203899384,
-0.062287136912345886,
-0.22902224957942963,
-0.2543492317199707,
0.04047219455242157,
0.2009236216545105,
-0.030747847631573677,
-0.04228641837835312,
0.7258399128913879,
-0.0851789265871048,
0.32153791189193726,
-0.40885281562805176,
0.4907599091529846,
-1.0523619651794434,
0.05249195918440819,
0.05815339833498001,
-0.5151126980781555,
-0.8499487042427063,
-0.02901652827858925,
0.20472411811351776,
-0.21714960038661957,
-0.8727807402610779,
0.5385406613349915,
-0.1479102373123169,
0.16859374940395355,
-0.3024354875087738,
-0.21320103108882904,
0.011022265069186687,
0.7090208530426025,
0.1833452582359314,
0.9007833003997803,
0.7752299308776855,
-0.7377674579620361,
-0.00486895814538002,
0.05242959409952164,
-0.21120797097682953,
0.8275496959686279,
-0.2710014581680298,
0.22994741797447205,
-0.139942929148674,
-0.0779358372092247,
-0.9417687654495239,
-0.332876980304718,
0.11904636025428772,
0.0375215969979763,
0.23712144792079926,
-0.21962031722068787,
-0.6906887292861938,
-0.035952698439359665,
-0.49214208126068115,
0.4584331214427948,
0.14767447113990784,
-0.49034520983695984,
0.51688551902771,
0.2593179941177368,
-0.3767630457878113,
-0.242265984416008,
-0.655815601348877,
-0.011691320687532425,
-0.3795512914657593,
-0.5195263028144836,
0.5440620183944702,
-0.20414528250694275,
0.10849076509475708,
-0.46096858382225037,
-0.21289053559303284,
-0.1159149780869484,
0.33880525827407837,
0.11847218871116638,
-0.018506452441215515,
-0.2564438581466675,
-0.007266903296113014,
0.4499862790107727,
0.07197455316781998,
-0.6071939468383789,
-0.11147162318229675,
0.4114362597465515,
0.013079836033284664,
-0.2056342363357544,
-0.07291895896196365,
0.5237399935722351,
0.6278324723243713,
-0.22957128286361694,
0.8097245097160339,
1.0142964124679565,
-0.4706043004989624,
-0.4558587968349457,
-0.47123491764068604,
-0.2711116075515747,
-0.47096797823905945,
0.5161572694778442,
-0.5667785406112671,
-1.0735913515090942,
0.4276178181171417,
-0.24894531071186066,
-0.00478515075519681,
0.17464224994182587,
0.5515387058258057,
-0.22381676733493805,
0.7743254899978638,
0.5897376537322998,
-0.2356669306755066,
0.3985366225242615,
0.18113471567630768,
0.26474836468696594,
-0.6769525408744812,
0.27662983536720276,
-0.5194145441055298,
-0.722690224647522,
-0.4492098391056061,
-0.4721480906009674,
0.6215531229972839,
0.29764026403427124,
-0.0889962688088417,
0.37582725286483765,
-0.1540941298007965,
0.26868948340415955,
0.7080292105674744,
0.25178003311157227,
0.14161834120750427,
0.3474860191345215,
-0.05295277386903763,
-0.16770364344120026,
-0.975404679775238,
-0.048582419753074646,
1.1053472757339478,
0.10180824995040894,
0.703895092010498,
0.10115637630224228,
0.854274332523346,
0.23292861878871918,
0.12559156119823456,
-0.4503919184207916,
0.25639888644218445,
-0.6606276035308838,
-0.2384336143732071,
-0.19983115792274475,
-0.37793877720832825,
-0.7204205393791199,
0.44500070810317993,
-0.475923627614975,
-1.0360485315322876,
0.3287145793437958,
0.2561764121055603,
-0.7541977167129517,
0.12212837487459183,
-0.8944364190101624,
1.0299646854400635,
-0.5664550065994263,
-0.5613595247268677,
-0.11300458759069443,
-0.34535446763038635,
0.24575309455394745,
-0.4733467698097229,
0.5612083077430725,
-0.28889206051826477,
-0.09703166782855988,
0.812315821647644,
-0.14244110882282257,
0.9497820734977722,
-0.28678205609321594,
-0.14021913707256317,
-0.10025196522474289,
0.04840489476919174,
0.5265607833862305,
0.06017962843179703,
-0.18118223547935486,
0.28237202763557434,
0.42651087045669556,
-0.5122444033622742,
-0.46667051315307617,
0.8877584934234619,
-0.7324576377868652,
-0.2604818642139435,
-0.24309295415878296,
-0.8176036477088928,
-0.7625569105148315,
0.13113033771514893,
0.10887866467237473,
0.37037888169288635,
0.10045406967401505,
0.1866208016872406,
0.4157623052597046,
-0.27032703161239624,
0.3804429769515991,
0.4557715356349945,
0.07836643606424332,
-0.42591592669487,
1.4288352727890015,
0.02711617201566696,
0.18667398393154144,
0.5374289155006409,
0.1294749677181244,
-0.18466468155384064,
-0.739595890045166,
-0.5772249698638916,
0.1354210078716278,
-0.43513625860214233,
-0.0959918200969696,
-0.5396510362625122,
0.19332259893417358,
-0.489094078540802,
-0.11719752103090286,
-0.4652159810066223,
-0.34158089756965637,
-0.4708080291748047,
0.35787898302078247,
0.3830047845840454,
0.1554855853319168,
0.14731702208518982,
0.447726845741272,
-0.9195788502693176,
0.627662718296051,
0.10534672439098358,
0.3975267708301544,
-0.21316125988960266,
-0.6030046939849854,
-0.4378493130207062,
0.08748287707567215,
-0.17075222730636597,
-0.727961540222168,
0.2762570381164551,
0.754667341709137,
0.6964120864868164,
0.1776190549135208,
0.1333315670490265,
0.9187928438186646,
-0.4353419244289398,
0.6502544283866882,
0.010307029820978642,
-0.8172630071640015,
0.42347604036331177,
-0.4053407609462738,
0.4046631455421448,
0.8835428953170776,
0.20946143567562103,
-0.45229828357696533,
-0.2666415870189667,
-0.22416803240776062,
-0.8009536862373352,
0.8932070136070251,
0.09910199791193008,
0.10302548855543137,
0.45750293135643005,
0.2827572524547577,
0.5245479345321655,
0.42521369457244873,
-0.5425258278846741,
-0.20033492147922516,
-0.2909733057022095,
-0.4968716502189636,
-0.4232120215892792,
-0.0029849703423678875,
-0.14217284321784973,
-0.509624183177948,
0.6015287637710571,
-0.5766221284866333,
0.07673461735248566,
-0.12295062094926834,
-0.5247277617454529,
-0.10035166144371033,
0.5113809704780579,
0.8861128091812134,
0.5448193550109863,
-0.013520674780011177,
0.1913367509841919,
0.350838303565979,
-0.33272799849510193,
0.1345888078212738,
0.49339357018470764,
0.13174684345722198,
-0.4747806489467621,
0.33522894978523254,
0.932242214679718,
0.8885471224784851,
-0.8317655920982361,
0.21692493557929993,
0.26114535331726074,
-0.533572793006897,
0.187033012509346,
0.5015349984169006,
0.12263857573270798,
0.25617706775665283,
0.5482955574989319,
0.300626277923584,
-0.0424376018345356,
-0.2117057591676712,
0.13738597929477692,
0.19347725808620453,
-0.10225246846675873,
-0.295211523771286,
0.6736149787902832,
0.20340196788311005,
0.03367367014288902,
0.06294500082731247,
-0.21291972696781158,
-0.2786307632923126,
0.27921655774116516,
0.36385029554367065,
0.5580375790596008,
-0.22162966430187225,
0.36249977350234985,
0.06574399024248123,
0.25813379883766174,
-0.13593895733356476,
0.35652339458465576,
-0.12348385900259018,
-0.7568818926811218,
-0.5339171886444092,
-0.9330083727836609,
-0.27448147535324097,
0.4474911689758301,
-0.24830418825149536,
0.1120620146393776,
-0.22632873058319092,
0.22053587436676025,
0.05035490542650223,
0.015467558987438679,
-0.7831958532333374,
0.06644026935100555,
0.20967571437358856,
0.6601349115371704,
-0.9310526251792908,
1.0248321294784546,
0.8838025331497192,
-0.014143905602395535,
-0.448259562253952,
0.03022017329931259,
-0.14290504157543182,
-0.5874035358428955,
0.17013925313949585,
-0.05550510436296463,
0.034678295254707336,
0.20288130640983582,
-0.2016654908657074,
-0.8818711042404175,
0.8477678298950195,
0.7418150305747986,
-0.641357421875,
0.27434584498405457,
0.4526086151599884,
0.355604887008667,
-0.3876611888408661,
-0.09350354224443436,
0.5454821586608887,
0.6153219938278198,
-0.11263847351074219,
-1.1466726064682007,
-0.09453880041837692,
-0.11285827308893204,
-0.06360212713479996,
0.07606925815343857,
-0.5430980324745178,
0.8114898800849915,
-0.0038250875659286976,
0.14425337314605713,
-0.05578579008579254,
0.4357556104660034,
0.2763645052909851,
0.20849575102329254,
0.8481153845787048,
0.41256535053253174,
0.7590307593345642,
0.05750836431980133,
0.76817786693573,
-0.4511428773403168,
0.2040344625711441,
1.1529431343078613,
-0.5751441717147827,
0.9310086369514465,
0.5141861438751221,
-0.32012346386909485,
0.24839907884597778,
0.815320611000061,
0.05781135335564613,
0.641277551651001,
-0.2490430474281311,
-0.09346456825733185,
-0.686259388923645,
0.19364920258522034,
-0.14153440296649933,
0.507289469242096,
0.4053327739238739,
0.016738560050725937,
-0.4304238259792328,
0.4730682373046875,
-0.2768327295780182,
-0.08203751593828201,
-0.38125675916671753,
0.5631034970283508,
-0.038443904370069504,
-0.6468934416770935,
0.8555707335472107,
0.16027462482452393,
0.9287867546081543,
-0.4844101369380951,
0.12715838849544525,
-0.03623530641198158,
0.08110565692186356,
-0.22429637610912323,
-0.32214024662971497,
0.059636279940605164,
-0.17494317889213562,
-0.1322266012430191,
-0.18479126691818237,
0.8303022980690002,
-0.749209463596344,
-0.8703711032867432,
0.04398627579212189,
0.6880612373352051,
-0.1269245594739914,
-0.554151177406311,
-0.9564862251281738,
0.13698209822177887,
-0.0627269595861435,
-0.011886068619787693,
0.7622054815292358,
-0.05878911912441254,
-0.024652043357491493,
0.46090269088745117,
0.6764541864395142,
0.1495039314031601,
0.027240287512540817,
0.1549598127603531,
0.6925992369651794,
-0.3762751817703247,
-0.7194722890853882,
-0.40991416573524475,
0.5436276197433472,
0.2364429533481598,
-0.17483752965927124,
0.48588064312934875,
0.552381694316864,
0.750666618347168,
-0.31400054693222046,
1.000883936882019,
0.13213296234607697,
0.5753647089004517,
-0.6134467124938965,
0.7232625484466553,
-1.0452370643615723,
-0.016424475237727165,
-0.22090457379817963,
-0.919847309589386,
-0.14249677956104279,
0.4233096241950989,
-0.3046320080757141,
0.2218967080116272,
0.614439070224762,
0.7093355655670166,
-0.6588164567947388,
-0.07443565130233765,
0.5831321477890015,
0.08355763554573059,
-0.032612208276987076,
0.569161593914032,
0.30595117807388306,
-0.20012640953063965,
0.2714570462703705,
-0.6961557865142822,
-0.2972623109817505,
-0.35126882791519165,
-0.8148089647293091,
-0.8933495879173279,
-0.6032277941703796,
-0.5018820762634277,
0.1336597204208374,
0.06413087993860245,
0.8602193593978882,
1.0857561826705933,
-1.1676920652389526,
-0.19252422451972961,
0.17588941752910614,
0.008524577133357525,
-0.6815445423126221,
-0.22600549459457397,
0.20693711936473846,
-0.4596574902534485,
-0.889957845211029,
0.8296244144439697,
0.3285687267780304,
-0.2001345008611679,
-0.13767001032829285,
-0.05323018506169319,
-0.1334874927997589,
-0.2686176002025604,
0.6952577233314514,
0.18311364948749542,
-0.5997509360313416,
-0.4320782721042633,
-0.04385094717144966,
0.3656683564186096,
0.23066972196102142,
0.8458587527275085,
-0.6695563793182373,
0.22743941843509674,
0.3157965838909149,
0.5820997357368469,
0.5018792152404785,
-0.04378660395741463,
0.4121737778186798,
-1.1046040058135986,
0.41283145546913147,
-0.00046476622810587287,
0.33951520919799805,
0.363450288772583,
-0.3782504200935364,
0.12421618402004242,
0.3676058351993561,
-0.20705687999725342,
-0.8490539193153381,
-0.06919935345649719,
-1.1863535642623901,
-0.3423781991004944,
1.0418550968170166,
0.1313914805650711,
-0.24108359217643738,
-0.25713789463043213,
-0.1827334463596344,
-0.12103629857301712,
-0.4709877669811249,
0.5034313797950745,
0.6110407114028931,
-0.3679756820201874,
-0.4641731381416321,
-0.6329012513160706,
0.3890141248703003,
0.407219797372818,
-0.971879243850708,
-0.017414050176739693,
0.15071959793567657,
0.5753307938575745,
-0.0687720850110054,
0.41111013293266296,
0.3863064646720886,
0.16735988855361938,
-0.2151426523923874,
-0.19054622948169708,
-0.16071192920207977,
-0.3639703691005707,
-0.12050262093544006,
0.3772883117198944,
0.18472209572792053,
-0.07987011224031448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17930v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17930v1
|
Pragmatic Instruction Following and Goal Assistance via Cooperative Language-Guided Inverse Planning
| 2024-02-27T23:06:53 | 2024-02-27T23:06:53 |
Tan Zhi-Xuan, Lance Ying, Vikash Mansinghka, Joshua B. Tenenbaum
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
People often give instructions whose meaning is ambiguous without further
context, expecting that their actions or goals will disambiguate their
intentions. How can we build assistive agents that follow such instructions in
a flexible, context-sensitive manner? This paper introduces cooperative
language-guided inverse plan search (CLIPS), a Bayesian agent architecture for
pragmatic instruction following and goal assistance. Our agent assists a human
by modeling them as a cooperative planner who communicates joint plans to the
assistant, then performs multimodal Bayesian inference over the human's goal
from actions and language, using large language models (LLMs) to evaluate the
likelihood of an instruction given a hypothesized plan. Given this posterior,
our assistant acts to minimize expected goal achievement cost, enabling it to
pragmatically follow ambiguous instructions and provide effective assistance
even when uncertain about the goal. We evaluate these capabilities in two
cooperative planning domains (Doors, Keys & Gems and VirtualHome), finding that
CLIPS significantly outperforms GPT-4V, LLM-based literal instruction following
and unimodal inverse planning in both accuracy and helpfulness, while closely
matching the inferences and assistive judgments provided by human raters.
|
[
-0.2020169496536255,
-0.8527576923370361,
0.7550249695777893,
0.3624063730239868,
0.11216525733470917,
0.20874477922916412,
-0.2276691347360611,
0.11796098947525024,
0.19704945385456085,
0.3865475356578827,
-1.0818010568618774,
-0.6947530508041382,
-0.45983946323394775,
-0.1665552705526352,
0.3275362551212311,
0.5263825058937073,
-0.3044325113296509,
0.08307795226573944,
0.09416134655475616,
0.2143331915140152,
-0.7347163558006287,
-0.32414478063583374,
-0.5674414038658142,
-0.2857655882835388,
0.36545443534851074,
0.7668535709381104,
1.1064304113388062,
0.3826847970485687,
0.2743090093135834,
0.34554851055145264,
0.30213844776153564,
0.2875303328037262,
-0.26181405782699585,
0.07963637262582779,
-0.32905712723731995,
-0.3207338750362396,
-0.7067442536354065,
-0.04614732787013054,
0.48411643505096436,
0.6668208241462708,
-0.3838706910610199,
-0.22631686925888062,
0.03191164508461952,
0.5137344598770142,
-0.6703284382820129,
0.4826315641403198,
-0.3681389093399048,
-0.04609355702996254,
0.5137203931808472,
-0.008065331727266312,
-0.06044917181134224,
-0.2595382034778595,
0.2387564480304718,
-0.8267815113067627,
0.21534422039985657,
-0.13399751484394073,
0.42164963483810425,
0.12953175604343414,
0.04416453465819359,
-0.37460005283355713,
-0.5247258543968201,
0.6642333269119263,
-0.39269858598709106,
0.28095999360084534,
0.7711188197135925,
0.36001139879226685,
-0.67939293384552,
-0.45619311928749084,
-0.5664269924163818,
-0.2001400589942932,
-0.10663206875324249,
0.2542327046394348,
-0.34913352131843567,
0.5334686040878296,
0.1442689746618271,
-0.3471630811691284,
-0.6911650896072388,
-0.13683746755123138,
-0.08920948952436447,
-0.22938869893550873,
0.6212821006774902,
0.0082451356574893,
0.22088047862052917,
0.0995042473077774,
-0.5259495973587036,
-0.32963332533836365,
-0.46915799379348755,
0.20781350135803223,
0.3348653018474579,
0.16038252413272858,
0.03878100961446762,
0.6139256954193115,
-0.48744282126426697,
0.8571549654006958,
-0.018513811752200127,
-0.018572654575109482,
-0.08748582750558853,
-0.30698761343955994,
-0.11223607510328293,
0.06011918932199478,
0.3231922388076782,
0.4475254416465759,
0.20317083597183228,
-0.41688698530197144,
-0.26974937319755554,
0.11646202951669693,
0.23972652852535248,
-0.39169415831565857,
-0.41997164487838745,
0.01736464537680149,
-0.1930752843618393,
0.4162483215332031,
0.12597160041332245,
-0.5438429117202759,
-0.05911482498049736,
-0.5828147530555725,
0.7869991064071655,
-0.6362096071243286,
0.005895362701267004,
0.4013005495071411,
-0.3263276517391205,
0.3956853449344635,
0.4173644781112671,
-0.5646058917045593,
0.4765127897262573,
0.8766441941261292,
0.714156985282898,
0.29013603925704956,
-0.5870834589004517,
-0.887764036655426,
0.4724833369255066,
-0.1261834353208542,
0.8403264880180359,
-0.835593581199646,
-0.5668507814407349,
-0.02973164990544319,
0.11204990744590759,
-0.23759713768959045,
-0.09340295195579529,
0.4911496639251709,
-0.3017892837524414,
0.12687645852565765,
-0.4022398293018341,
-0.2959391176700592,
-0.5646324157714844,
0.2877604365348816,
-0.28912249207496643,
0.406825989484787,
0.13805952668190002,
-0.25896334648132324,
0.20597894489765167,
-0.31769561767578125,
-0.3066183924674988,
0.1250365525484085,
-0.4143296778202057,
-0.3078804910182953,
-0.18641935288906097,
0.3075177073478699,
0.46771055459976196,
-0.1449848711490631,
0.31504368782043457,
-0.21733227372169495,
-0.629992663860321,
-0.05149638652801514,
-0.4238068759441376,
0.4820496439933777,
-0.3946799635887146,
-0.5068123936653137,
0.41566529870033264,
-0.5994676351547241,
0.04322340339422226,
-0.004482686519622803,
0.017748938873410225,
-0.5147526264190674,
0.22747160494327545,
-0.4699324369430542,
0.062420494854450226,
0.3915756344795227,
-0.3144650459289551,
0.4119482636451721,
-0.13039027154445648,
-0.05963928997516632,
0.8443460464477539,
0.11131346970796585,
0.7372564077377319,
-0.537181556224823,
0.8185207843780518,
-0.4578840732574463,
0.2951802909374237,
-0.07717255502939224,
-0.8651517629623413,
-0.12276676297187805,
-0.4590654969215393,
-0.3020267188549042,
0.569817066192627,
-0.6578026413917542,
0.4807543158531189,
0.08991220593452454,
-0.3522469997406006,
-0.5232729315757751,
0.024366501718759537,
0.6238936185836792,
0.5882811546325684,
0.34529051184654236,
-0.23517584800720215,
-0.3318323493003845,
-0.9411223530769348,
-0.22478899359703064,
-0.2904855012893677,
-0.18558882176876068,
0.10459195077419281,
0.22581683099269867,
-0.15853562951087952,
1.0199151039123535,
-0.708259105682373,
-0.40894582867622375,
-0.11630039662122726,
0.2966185212135315,
0.15450070798397064,
0.37703120708465576,
0.28331291675567627,
-1.07658851146698,
-0.5670543313026428,
-0.07954572886228561,
-0.1857222467660904,
-0.2782633900642395,
-0.2023215889930725,
-0.2936449944972992,
-0.23810814321041107,
-0.07556045800447464,
-0.5415902733802795,
0.7087695002555847,
0.43196573853492737,
-0.3560000956058502,
0.7216570973396301,
-0.5236183404922485,
0.1239129975438118,
-0.7392532825469971,
-0.0557926669716835,
-0.13134163618087769,
-0.1475275456905365,
-0.5306875109672546,
-0.13833928108215332,
-0.05160454660654068,
0.10126853734254837,
-0.02872643619775772,
0.4550500214099884,
-0.7326821088790894,
-0.2741040289402008,
-0.41644588112831116,
0.33721354603767395,
0.023915711790323257,
0.8879885077476501,
0.6060434579849243,
1.0214881896972656,
0.6568496823310852,
-0.45029592514038086,
0.3115634322166443,
0.4848266839981079,
0.12803199887275696,
0.5302438139915466,
-0.5940797924995422,
0.05696405842900276,
-0.26055610179901123,
0.31220224499702454,
-0.9775477647781372,
-0.26298248767852783,
0.7112088203430176,
-0.4718398451805115,
0.18562397360801697,
-0.3353038430213928,
-0.2088436633348465,
-0.15412792563438416,
-0.45492973923683167,
0.012211645022034645,
0.3765365779399872,
-0.40647315979003906,
0.5622466802597046,
0.2889118194580078,
-0.20088186860084534,
-0.8584545254707336,
-0.4909800887107849,
-0.30390453338623047,
0.09642276912927628,
-0.5450854897499084,
0.6555759310722351,
-0.04625073820352554,
-0.2402777373790741,
0.16898825764656067,
-0.27878326177597046,
-0.20980051159858704,
-0.023422447964549065,
0.5734383463859558,
0.34281125664711,
-0.0006018129060976207,
-0.03309403359889984,
0.24096786975860596,
0.06314271688461304,
0.12888363003730774,
-0.12765859067440033,
0.43981969356536865,
-0.11471075564622879,
-0.526521623134613,
-0.2898770570755005,
0.6261252760887146,
0.013363434001803398,
-0.13765501976013184,
0.673235297203064,
0.4488849937915802,
-0.07617471367120743,
-0.2119467705488205,
-0.3522416651248932,
-0.1346254050731659,
-0.4711860716342926,
0.23066680133342743,
-0.48639750480651855,
-0.54371577501297,
0.4911353886127472,
-0.0362989641726017,
0.08875377476215363,
-0.284732848405838,
0.308065265417099,
0.04503316059708595,
1.1981867551803589,
0.6738566756248474,
0.21603262424468994,
0.640359103679657,
-0.32131072878837585,
0.019381916150450706,
-0.8240401148796082,
-0.32517480850219727,
-0.29966071248054504,
-0.3523893654346466,
-0.4169182777404785,
-0.6485022902488708,
0.4882020056247711,
0.3711322844028473,
-0.020406944677233696,
0.8414708375930786,
-0.6621193885803223,
0.28192007541656494,
0.6727628707885742,
0.3107210099697113,
0.1271832436323166,
-0.19581696391105652,
-0.09333562105894089,
0.17752373218536377,
-0.9263619780540466,
-0.6528158783912659,
0.6446020007133484,
0.15263931453227997,
0.8668427467346191,
0.16236217319965363,
0.6800069808959961,
0.04118992015719414,
0.29825904965400696,
-0.9617134928703308,
0.6469402313232422,
0.2908923029899597,
-0.2463250756263733,
-0.2923138439655304,
-0.20840077102184296,
-0.9533188939094543,
0.4174146056175232,
-0.05268670246005058,
-0.8527342081069946,
0.4162460267543793,
0.2759081721305847,
-0.2610272765159607,
0.007336195092648268,
-0.941239595413208,
0.9320166707038879,
-0.23712831735610962,
-0.7070027589797974,
-0.4231698513031006,
-0.82391756772995,
0.006523014511913061,
0.15485677123069763,
0.13454793393611908,
-0.20279131829738617,
-0.4939790368080139,
0.406218558549881,
-0.22500820457935333,
0.9201489686965942,
-0.42056846618652344,
0.1330213099718094,
0.42723461985588074,
0.2669841945171356,
0.7218957543373108,
0.043891359120607376,
-0.013730055652558804,
-0.2790352404117584,
-0.15386806428432465,
-0.4850548207759857,
-0.8080539107322693,
0.6771984100341797,
-0.5196861624717712,
-1.0283323526382446,
-0.20169097185134888,
-0.6075833439826965,
-0.35480934381484985,
0.19401687383651733,
-0.05519331619143486,
0.3193766176700592,
-0.3072185218334198,
-0.34077468514442444,
0.34338894486427307,
-0.11417106539011002,
0.47736817598342896,
0.8254476189613342,
0.13005325198173523,
-0.15137726068496704,
0.713001549243927,
-0.11742012202739716,
0.11333765834569931,
0.6799021363258362,
0.2813061475753784,
-0.41299596428871155,
-0.40346434712409973,
-0.2484147995710373,
0.2687202990055084,
-0.5539027452468872,
-0.2337808758020401,
-0.3550545573234558,
0.08389505743980408,
-0.4223441183567047,
-0.5820968747138977,
-0.023807257413864136,
-0.32032522559165955,
-0.17847000062465668,
0.07373213768005371,
0.0656813234090805,
0.3963412344455719,
-0.3349341154098511,
0.5828761458396912,
-0.8700041174888611,
0.2189716249704361,
0.45046165585517883,
0.059502750635147095,
-0.19742073118686676,
-0.14914678037166595,
0.19618858397006989,
0.38158854842185974,
-0.44324129819869995,
-1.2539992332458496,
0.371600478887558,
0.06222133710980415,
0.8930258750915527,
0.2557535767555237,
0.2896486818790436,
0.8277838230133057,
-0.5007094144821167,
0.4709075391292572,
0.14976701140403748,
-0.6116698384284973,
0.5628257989883423,
-0.2435375303030014,
0.3161677122116089,
0.402535617351532,
0.6940829157829285,
-0.18333514034748077,
-0.1841091811656952,
-0.5487819910049438,
-0.5214142799377441,
0.7976232171058655,
0.22975914180278778,
-0.12890742719173431,
0.007919262163341045,
0.1797911524772644,
0.12845247983932495,
0.2310747355222702,
-0.346398264169693,
0.15096957981586456,
-0.047072235494852066,
-0.16866691410541534,
0.17666250467300415,
0.08097828924655914,
-0.23028700053691864,
0.07195800542831421,
0.48345860838890076,
-0.3342728316783905,
0.48340678215026855,
0.5158745050430298,
0.07666486501693726,
-0.08498218655586243,
0.28491541743278503,
0.7090170979499817,
0.7194024920463562,
-0.2490377426147461,
0.024152178317308426,
-0.005669290665537119,
-0.3393266201019287,
-0.002225486095994711,
0.36672186851501465,
0.13420304656028748,
-0.03947427496314049,
0.3084242343902588,
0.6627582907676697,
0.4642731249332428,
-0.9903424978256226,
0.7325685620307922,
-0.10438237339258194,
0.035506751388311386,
-0.5230363011360168,
0.2986004054546356,
-0.05538685992360115,
0.45117831230163574,
0.28429651260375977,
0.14746136963367462,
0.22090189158916473,
-0.6523290276527405,
0.3207327723503113,
0.7106695771217346,
-0.3304072618484497,
-0.6040025353431702,
0.2857710123062134,
-0.03746059536933899,
-0.7071924805641174,
0.2693924605846405,
-0.36690977215766907,
-0.7360450625419617,
0.5208858847618103,
0.514728844165802,
0.8008751273155212,
-0.2824399471282959,
0.6844030618667603,
0.11132931709289551,
0.17010074853897095,
-0.14693494141101837,
0.4209129512310028,
-0.7193928360939026,
-0.5940572023391724,
-0.37190815806388855,
-0.1671254187822342,
-0.6150115132331848,
-0.6183463335037231,
-0.470363974571228,
0.28763213753700256,
-0.22936978936195374,
-0.009448339231312275,
-0.21664002537727356,
-0.0332067646086216,
-0.59577476978302,
-0.14582455158233643,
-0.27222010493278503,
0.7778933048248291,
-0.5001371502876282,
0.8976230621337891,
1.064133644104004,
-0.4559200704097748,
-0.8994662761688232,
0.22360184788703918,
0.04517805948853493,
-1.0862125158309937,
0.4999999403953552,
-0.005303879734128714,
-0.6539195775985718,
-0.09092260897159576,
-0.5256134867668152,
-0.5293368697166443,
1.2078168392181396,
0.23717190325260162,
-0.6476644277572632,
-0.6895172595977783,
-0.31314367055892944,
0.42460235953330994,
-0.2851748764514923,
0.18234725296497345,
0.3447939157485962,
0.4694640338420868,
0.4560607671737671,
-0.6687446236610413,
0.0015799123793840408,
0.32805630564689636,
-0.2890629768371582,
0.3083667755126953,
-0.6557210087776184,
0.49187907576560974,
-0.4250076413154602,
-0.24794907867908478,
0.24568629264831543,
0.4321981370449066,
0.37681829929351807,
0.5526993870735168,
0.3311408460140228,
0.00444515235722065,
0.4472943842411041,
0.31641384959220886,
0.8952348232269287,
-0.1322983354330063,
-0.02693207748234272,
1.3566362857818604,
-0.21881066262722015,
0.8124234080314636,
0.4552387297153473,
0.07306118309497833,
0.5557720065116882,
0.147200345993042,
0.2297353893518448,
0.7150605320930481,
-0.06036851927638054,
-0.37134209275245667,
-0.1286735087633133,
-0.03395034372806549,
0.11670071631669998,
0.3464198112487793,
0.636894702911377,
-0.13887180387973785,
-0.32461318373680115,
-0.13767942786216736,
-0.12086817622184753,
0.4700755774974823,
-0.3123226463794708,
0.70392906665802,
-0.0886089876294136,
-1.0262908935546875,
0.2439410388469696,
0.10409075021743774,
0.36529698967933655,
-0.8211566805839539,
-0.5123212337493896,
0.030403582379221916,
0.12644802033901215,
-0.07799692451953888,
-1.0012656450271606,
0.3143910765647888,
-0.20820391178131104,
0.14851926267147064,
-0.22282937169075012,
0.8603004217147827,
-0.5588729381561279,
0.12215771526098251,
0.3530365526676178,
0.3688316345214844,
-0.0584319606423378,
-0.18495550751686096,
-0.8803809285163879,
-0.10110367834568024,
-0.13204708695411682,
-0.07951260358095169,
0.24719621241092682,
0.32138994336128235,
-0.20108608901500702,
0.6528981328010559,
0.36182892322540283,
0.17792661488056183,
-0.005121967755258083,
-0.3916543126106262,
0.9368282556533813,
-0.42274248600006104,
-0.43179479241371155,
-0.4361784756183624,
0.3555910587310791,
-0.12627030909061432,
-0.08613096177577972,
0.6093993782997131,
0.24380026757717133,
0.8982309699058533,
-0.04831494763493538,
0.3478848934173584,
-0.05746690183877945,
0.22040970623493195,
-0.43889424204826355,
0.18869127333164215,
-0.2137630581855774,
0.29526782035827637,
-0.1651231050491333,
-1.070425033569336,
-0.17248426377773285,
1.0418211221694946,
-0.7362738251686096,
-0.13820905983448029,
0.3249916136264801,
1.05518639087677,
-0.14703811705112457,
-0.05153028666973114,
0.4403224587440491,
-0.2942450940608978,
0.23609089851379395,
0.8457013964653015,
0.8417263031005859,
0.00625935522839427,
0.4880303740501404,
-0.3826333284378052,
-0.6115221381187439,
-0.017553463578224182,
-0.49806642532348633,
-0.8251122236251831,
-0.6395154595375061,
-0.25616011023521423,
0.08764408528804779,
0.3039291799068451,
1.2775018215179443,
0.6786959767341614,
-0.3931947350502014,
-0.34745174646377563,
-0.5150496363639832,
0.44331255555152893,
-0.6389139294624329,
-0.23324017226696014,
0.3693418502807617,
-0.1630367487668991,
-0.6356103420257568,
0.7077537775039673,
0.22538921236991882,
-0.07574323564767838,
-0.2268981784582138,
-0.29644060134887695,
-0.33973491191864014,
-0.003010343760251999,
0.31178033351898193,
0.522211492061615,
-0.7465589642524719,
-0.3814365863800049,
0.06119868904352188,
-0.07082825154066086,
-0.07647599279880524,
0.930088222026825,
-0.8109581470489502,
0.6971039175987244,
0.49984294176101685,
0.5189208984375,
0.2543705403804779,
0.3174716830253601,
0.9108527302742004,
-0.7331739664077759,
0.16512295603752136,
0.45262864232063293,
-0.014825144782662392,
0.10845544189214706,
-0.3895713686943054,
0.4302557110786438,
-0.04084707051515579,
-0.5905681252479553,
-0.38893064856529236,
0.3245541453361511,
-0.984230637550354,
-0.4450110197067261,
1.0616925954818726,
-0.5837711691856384,
-0.39412349462509155,
-0.09151926636695862,
-0.9294823408126831,
0.31738317012786865,
-0.6649819016456604,
0.6121091246604919,
0.3658234477043152,
-0.6351290941238403,
-0.3037901520729065,
-0.1416219025850296,
0.5016571283340454,
0.37857455015182495,
-0.36262616515159607,
-0.017233017832040787,
0.7885057926177979,
-0.037027567625045776,
0.0479353666305542,
0.6490358114242554,
0.26146644353866577,
0.514825165271759,
0.06605273485183716,
-0.19576020538806915,
-0.19224952161312103,
-0.4221612513065338,
-0.2577245831489563,
0.09066446125507355,
0.007937951944768429,
-0.6063495874404907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.17916v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.17916v3
|
Adversarial Math Word Problem Generation
| 2024-02-27T22:07:52 | 2024-06-15T22:36:20 |
Roy Xie, Chengxuan Huang, Junlin Wang, Bhuwan Dhingra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have significantly transformed the educational
landscape. As current plagiarism detection tools struggle to keep pace with
LLMs' rapid advancements, the educational community faces the challenge of
assessing students' true problem-solving abilities in the presence of LLMs. In
this work, we explore a new paradigm for ensuring fair evaluation -- generating
adversarial examples which preserve the structure and difficulty of the
original questions aimed for assessment, but are unsolvable by LLMs. Focusing
on the domain of math word problems, we leverage abstract syntax trees to
structurally generate adversarial examples that cause LLMs to produce incorrect
answers by simply editing the numeric values in the problems. We conduct
experiments on various open- and closed-source LLMs, quantitatively and
qualitatively demonstrating that our method significantly degrades their math
problem-solving ability. We identify shared vulnerabilities among LLMs and
propose a cost-effective approach to attack high-cost models. Additionally, we
conduct automatic analysis to investigate the cause of failure, providing
further insights into the limitations of LLMs.
|
[
-0.13478150963783264,
-1.226406455039978,
0.6808790564537048,
0.13300172984600067,
0.060793302953243256,
0.258919358253479,
-0.06563887745141983,
-0.011031299829483032,
-0.23137907683849335,
0.5889261960983276,
-0.49237751960754395,
-0.28829485177993774,
-0.8171921372413635,
0.01662624627351761,
-0.6144402623176575,
1.0085957050323486,
-0.2891058027744293,
0.09224225580692291,
-0.6211679577827454,
-0.19226354360580444,
-0.333317369222641,
-0.7585979104042053,
-0.663040280342102,
-0.2952733337879181,
0.2047271728515625,
0.14640940725803375,
1.1015844345092773,
0.4683707058429718,
0.7586280703544617,
0.4004894495010376,
-0.21059545874595642,
0.007570481859147549,
-0.6340911984443665,
0.19051456451416016,
-0.03167208284139633,
-0.6207892298698425,
-0.3381265699863434,
0.17857658863067627,
0.4383772611618042,
0.8673056364059448,
-0.3147641122341156,
0.14958852529525757,
-0.03871629014611244,
0.6483413577079773,
-0.598569929599762,
0.07189442962408066,
-1.1623926162719727,
0.22721774876117706,
-0.2735671103000641,
-0.0888204276561737,
-0.39430397748947144,
-0.5684193968772888,
-0.1039731502532959,
-0.5763911008834839,
0.20457935333251953,
-0.41417959332466125,
0.6961686015129089,
0.2909505069255829,
-0.0679030641913414,
-0.6945511698722839,
-0.4288097321987152,
0.6924911141395569,
-0.458661288022995,
-0.20367127656936646,
0.15532442927360535,
0.43856412172317505,
-0.6403974890708923,
-0.5298710465431213,
-0.6158050298690796,
-0.12542487680912018,
0.2800934910774231,
0.02862233854830265,
-0.5569776892662048,
-0.18623603880405426,
0.29100924730300903,
0.3787134289741516,
-0.5487670302391052,
0.0312538743019104,
-0.40831995010375977,
-0.11324210464954376,
0.6242457032203674,
0.43333661556243896,
0.4953935742378235,
-0.148912712931633,
-0.08672960847616196,
-0.18198561668395996,
-0.9261687397956848,
-0.1965152770280838,
0.6739317774772644,
0.09547310322523117,
0.27298709750175476,
0.7865330576896667,
0.4050275385379791,
0.4441353678703308,
-0.40225663781166077,
0.08825396746397018,
0.0501924566924572,
0.06482294946908951,
-0.30461061000823975,
-0.1846168488264084,
0.7399159073829651,
0.13282592594623566,
0.4716809093952179,
-0.15594133734703064,
-0.42992615699768066,
0.5245857834815979,
0.14535392820835114,
-0.6382744312286377,
-0.17338012158870697,
0.0842820256948471,
-0.10389097779989243,
-0.7644989490509033,
-0.3010963499546051,
-0.7083385586738586,
-0.6348565220832825,
-0.12213163822889328,
0.7977783679962158,
-0.2975691258907318,
-0.03789225593209267,
0.2273111492395401,
-0.1650051325559616,
-0.25890272855758667,
0.2779856324195862,
-0.2588755190372467,
0.2802864611148834,
0.6944998502731323,
0.6028851866722107,
0.025890694931149483,
-0.3211597800254822,
-0.5865492820739746,
-0.24488160014152527,
-0.40242552757263184,
0.2800997197628021,
-0.3806298077106476,
-0.6038195490837097,
-0.05194087326526642,
-0.29415565729141235,
0.18535949289798737,
-0.7475860118865967,
0.35187438130378723,
-0.6091693639755249,
0.4000350534915924,
-0.05913916975259781,
-0.4334721267223358,
0.04473840817809105,
0.44993042945861816,
-0.5607584118843079,
0.7059144377708435,
0.23602189123630524,
-0.7615718841552734,
-0.2676451802253723,
-0.6953809857368469,
-0.21970097720623016,
0.20392689108848572,
-0.32404956221580505,
-0.7438302040100098,
0.24923305213451385,
0.16672222316265106,
0.173256516456604,
-0.3284633755683899,
0.47213441133499146,
-0.3840652108192444,
-0.23348018527030945,
0.5140732526779175,
-0.804698646068573,
1.1042877435684204,
0.16761063039302826,
-0.36677953600883484,
0.06730885803699493,
-0.6692708134651184,
0.044608622789382935,
0.9995225071907043,
-0.22261685132980347,
-0.36941778659820557,
-0.045134346932172775,
-0.38997864723205566,
0.13168072700500488,
0.2666682004928589,
-0.37861260771751404,
-0.02180800959467888,
-0.5282260179519653,
0.33010584115982056,
1.1443085670471191,
-0.14208830893039703,
0.010236100293695927,
-0.44765371084213257,
0.8476974964141846,
-0.08651494234800339,
0.19926300644874573,
-0.029847946017980576,
-0.4023512601852417,
-0.6585904359817505,
-0.002550813602283597,
0.22354629635810852,
0.5177148580551147,
-1.0228323936462402,
0.05897103622555733,
-0.29905709624290466,
-0.4971069097518921,
-0.5718477368354797,
0.36840006709098816,
0.6884808540344238,
0.4625079929828644,
0.27511066198349,
-0.003054582281038165,
-0.19557346403598785,
-0.7196228504180908,
-0.49553701281547546,
0.01587849296629429,
-0.11166378855705261,
0.46073266863822937,
0.7044072151184082,
-0.06778531521558762,
0.7331950664520264,
-0.7111941576004028,
-0.2265857309103012,
-0.11000241339206696,
0.13590268790721893,
-0.058953821659088135,
0.17252132296562195,
0.49483373761177063,
-0.7070043683052063,
-0.1779627799987793,
-0.546687126159668,
-0.7676990628242493,
-0.3472137749195099,
0.04933910816907883,
-0.031277112662792206,
0.11986648291349411,
0.379676878452301,
-0.48723623156547546,
0.40681350231170654,
0.5523873567581177,
-0.4127492904663086,
0.6535622477531433,
-0.15735644102096558,
-0.19939671456813812,
-0.9445525407791138,
-0.1784653514623642,
-0.07638236880302429,
0.06502402573823929,
-0.16708028316497803,
0.6944563984870911,
-0.18841633200645447,
-0.571897029876709,
-0.47814416885375977,
0.3216034770011902,
-0.28071731328964233,
-0.06335166096687317,
-0.17129044234752655,
0.4605121612548828,
0.12582366168498993,
0.37100210785865784,
-0.6214715242385864,
0.7495406270027161,
0.34725522994995117,
-0.2754272520542145,
0.6364558935165405,
0.12372305989265442,
-0.16664470732212067,
0.4740079641342163,
-0.8012370467185974,
0.20698019862174988,
-0.28831905126571655,
0.13518734276294708,
-0.7317960262298584,
0.10283099114894867,
0.07766199111938477,
-0.6271626949310303,
0.06477236747741699,
-0.051944632083177567,
-0.6137189865112305,
-0.34309816360473633,
-0.559988796710968,
0.3919491767883301,
0.5235682725906372,
-0.7309901714324951,
0.37956544756889343,
0.40606433153152466,
-0.20859120786190033,
-0.5799838900566101,
-0.625939667224884,
0.2615392208099365,
-0.19016803801059723,
-0.7594496011734009,
0.11322633922100067,
-0.23073942959308624,
-0.6339293122291565,
0.30432796478271484,
-0.029519611969590187,
0.04830067977309227,
0.591283917427063,
0.13046270608901978,
0.42532575130462646,
-0.1313236653804779,
0.02084738202393055,
-0.2344159185886383,
0.116621233522892,
0.48439040780067444,
-0.05741391330957413,
0.41810542345046997,
-0.26813897490501404,
-0.6431607604026794,
0.16115246713161469,
0.4353786110877991,
0.8245102763175964,
-0.39211148023605347,
0.4378426671028137,
0.11213178187608719,
-0.6681596636772156,
-0.508899986743927,
-0.2823985517024994,
0.06791975349187851,
-0.5399070978164673,
0.6667439341545105,
-0.3487146198749542,
-0.7114157676696777,
0.35474681854248047,
0.020780058577656746,
0.18432961404323578,
0.3686620891094208,
0.5340316891670227,
0.3206489086151123,
1.0294005870819092,
0.13875994086265564,
0.15208211541175842,
0.0050282469019293785,
-0.35990479588508606,
0.16901405155658722,
-0.5358471870422363,
-0.29953205585479736,
-0.5016048550605774,
-0.18069685995578766,
-0.3151736557483673,
-0.5919986367225647,
0.6036128997802734,
0.16773344576358795,
-0.15430207550525665,
0.17672885954380035,
-0.5312408208847046,
0.7375056743621826,
0.3698785901069641,
0.011033532209694386,
0.2296077013015747,
0.222940593957901,
-0.2958493232727051,
-0.11688809841871262,
-0.48498106002807617,
-0.5239331126213074,
1.3172281980514526,
0.3526095747947693,
0.6984267234802246,
0.35561904311180115,
0.5735859274864197,
0.20451222360134125,
0.5810105204582214,
-0.7628748416900635,
0.7405454516410828,
-0.3460500240325928,
-0.636853039264679,
-0.34241652488708496,
-0.8864173293113708,
-1.0311143398284912,
0.44777849316596985,
-0.16368211805820465,
-0.3868616819381714,
-0.4651913642883301,
-0.06772690266370773,
-0.06962040811777115,
0.47862112522125244,
-0.5999243259429932,
0.811712384223938,
-0.39202597737312317,
-0.3302120864391327,
-0.06443838775157928,
-0.08327537775039673,
0.5293139219284058,
-0.3420690596103668,
0.48321497440338135,
-0.003733275691047311,
0.26046454906463623,
0.6939352750778198,
-0.636857807636261,
0.6200791597366333,
-0.19218549132347107,
-0.3294784128665924,
0.49228590726852417,
0.6493625640869141,
0.566326379776001,
0.04930737987160683,
-0.06947846710681915,
0.01015052106231451,
-0.2127048224210739,
-0.4388962984085083,
-0.8618599772453308,
0.9289102554321289,
-0.7707710266113281,
-0.9613417983055115,
-0.5171315670013428,
-0.6766761541366577,
-0.2880175709724426,
0.03958970308303833,
0.001908151083625853,
0.5092611908912659,
-0.1654554307460785,
0.04922828823328018,
0.5717971920967102,
-0.4288164973258972,
0.2793041467666626,
0.48135411739349365,
-0.301503449678421,
-0.45069965720176697,
1.2294578552246094,
0.1287742257118225,
0.32614701986312866,
-0.19388814270496368,
0.4175606966018677,
-0.19769227504730225,
-0.6952734589576721,
-0.3109998404979706,
0.027883261442184448,
-0.9090394377708435,
-0.3619701862335205,
-0.29433563351631165,
-0.3616749942302704,
-0.26470157504081726,
-0.24260011315345764,
-0.22757212817668915,
-0.5035009384155273,
-0.28988319635391235,
0.001125067356042564,
0.17521071434020996,
0.7722510695457458,
0.11401084810495377,
0.12477701157331467,
-0.6192529797554016,
0.3051375448703766,
0.5900624990463257,
0.1384735405445099,
0.034659288823604584,
-0.46035128831863403,
0.24723878502845764,
0.07755041867494583,
-0.7451731562614441,
-0.7324743270874023,
0.30053389072418213,
-0.17559511959552765,
0.3354254961013794,
-0.023328673094511032,
0.0014789672568440437,
0.5240391492843628,
-0.5721440315246582,
0.6843720078468323,
0.35940811038017273,
-1.0991497039794922,
0.42191386222839355,
-0.16911464929580688,
0.10166547447443008,
0.234029158949852,
0.21879567205905914,
-0.26517581939697266,
-0.7100991606712341,
-0.8102993369102478,
-0.8292067050933838,
0.41515928506851196,
0.4734179973602295,
0.28695496916770935,
-0.12130165845155716,
0.42667824029922485,
-0.1594410538673401,
0.09730464220046997,
-0.8064941763877869,
-0.2479444295167923,
-0.15803074836730957,
-0.39735472202301025,
0.02170371264219284,
-0.18173334002494812,
-0.4364408254623413,
-0.007486800663173199,
0.5572945475578308,
0.009164506569504738,
-0.21260589361190796,
0.06552901118993759,
-0.13477203249931335,
-0.26703208684921265,
0.4616880416870117,
0.5038548111915588,
0.6289172768592834,
0.14728133380413055,
0.270982950925827,
0.23421883583068848,
-0.24637524783611298,
0.19143657386302948,
0.17545649409294128,
-0.21259158849716187,
-0.08313212543725967,
0.347459077835083,
0.4556829631328583,
-0.08139870315790176,
-0.8873452544212341,
0.8795815706253052,
-0.1656835973262787,
-0.44274234771728516,
-0.5692053437232971,
0.030818304046988487,
0.10750662535429001,
-0.007220964413136244,
0.3300515115261078,
0.08819858729839325,
-0.04226766154170036,
-0.5524946451187134,
0.1748814880847931,
0.8481576442718506,
-0.08722883462905884,
-0.20741166174411774,
0.5699430704116821,
0.14553013443946838,
-0.611160397529602,
0.5399690866470337,
-0.2752281427383423,
-0.9753600358963013,
0.8532446026802063,
0.6657695770263672,
0.6840527057647705,
-0.1803990602493286,
0.15821225941181183,
-0.02663823403418064,
0.4119865596294403,
0.12313421815633774,
0.2264728844165802,
0.427421510219574,
-0.6126144528388977,
-0.1918504685163498,
-0.5393173694610596,
-0.48336344957351685,
0.5688512325286865,
-0.3985801935195923,
0.2149437963962555,
-0.6766986846923828,
0.022750912234187126,
0.06652409583330154,
-0.03035775013267994,
-0.3347216248512268,
0.19585120677947998,
0.23747920989990234,
0.5614644289016724,
-0.6645225882530212,
0.25965678691864014,
0.6422014236450195,
-0.1984676867723465,
-0.6382015943527222,
-0.2035185694694519,
0.12071847170591354,
-1.0080633163452148,
0.6911414861679077,
-0.07456512749195099,
-0.11920955777168274,
-0.18659141659736633,
-0.5675410032272339,
-0.4395780563354492,
0.8363014459609985,
0.756088376045227,
-0.4473463296890259,
-0.2397381216287613,
0.35958877205848694,
0.44573843479156494,
0.07052873075008392,
0.000060588754422497004,
0.346269428730011,
0.27876609563827515,
0.08229411393404007,
-0.7100686430931091,
0.19578668475151062,
-0.2527589201927185,
-0.09525531530380249,
0.3653176724910736,
-0.35322365164756775,
1.1114381551742554,
-0.2995772957801819,
-0.21136625111103058,
-0.025147434324026108,
0.2251850962638855,
0.4746602475643158,
0.3100244402885437,
0.5414025783538818,
0.9323165416717529,
0.6854672431945801,
-0.09551773965358734,
0.9648042917251587,
-0.03153381124138832,
0.299848735332489,
1.063531517982483,
-0.08091839402914047,
0.5599541664123535,
0.4453396201133728,
-0.31422773003578186,
0.15122051537036896,
0.1563381552696228,
-0.26810142397880554,
0.08140429854393005,
1.0991193056106567,
-0.3388153910636902,
-0.2808123230934143,
0.03624093905091286,
-0.4532693922519684,
0.5001180171966553,
0.46564245223999023,
-0.19817696511745453,
-0.5383861064910889,
-0.05530186742544174,
0.29683780670166016,
0.5915982723236084,
-0.3669550120830536,
0.33314406871795654,
0.1734323352575302,
-0.4765109717845917,
0.604541540145874,
0.3302582800388336,
0.5338461995124817,
-0.5297581553459167,
-0.10650646686553955,
-0.15461315214633942,
0.3874809443950653,
-0.08160330355167389,
-0.6591291427612305,
0.36814606189727783,
0.3046993911266327,
0.14390157163143158,
-0.00497766537591815,
0.43278035521507263,
-0.31463146209716797,
-0.8593205809593201,
0.26136401295661926,
0.5380589962005615,
0.05151740089058876,
-0.07257308065891266,
-0.8431665897369385,
0.1516970843076706,
-0.2513137757778168,
-0.14999595284461975,
0.4786963164806366,
0.5886340737342834,
-0.0011076825903728604,
0.800536572933197,
0.7717808485031128,
0.19739484786987305,
0.041611447930336,
-0.039878442883491516,
0.890938401222229,
-0.3584127128124237,
-0.2626367211341858,
-1.0980637073516846,
0.05647309869527817,
-0.020874639973044395,
-0.29046568274497986,
0.8349580764770508,
0.4143751859664917,
0.8225328326225281,
0.23997803032398224,
0.7397686243057251,
0.4503149092197418,
0.20561829209327698,
-0.36643677949905396,
0.8050856590270996,
-0.6837342381477356,
0.580863893032074,
-0.42457982897758484,
-0.5658124685287476,
-0.365135133266449,
0.3192165493965149,
-0.18775993585586548,
-0.1270822137594223,
0.6915361285209656,
0.5714457631111145,
0.2061629444360733,
-0.047478318214416504,
0.39027464389801025,
0.21946054697036743,
0.5806934833526611,
0.955868124961853,
0.9955114722251892,
-0.5154785513877869,
1.0778908729553223,
-0.1598353534936905,
-0.26847270131111145,
0.061959296464920044,
-0.6706384420394897,
-0.9955848455429077,
-0.16265077888965607,
-0.4946417212486267,
-0.7567790746688843,
0.1305658519268036,
0.6232519149780273,
-0.06980274617671967,
-0.5932145118713379,
-0.0364583358168602,
-0.21755672991275787,
0.4209565818309784,
0.31420692801475525,
-0.305654913187027,
0.4926438629627228,
-0.29735279083251953,
-0.6199514269828796,
0.43599483370780945,
0.04465553164482117,
0.2797163724899292,
-0.5431769490242004,
0.19618521630764008,
0.43289339542388916,
0.3649143576622009,
0.4275164306163788,
-0.09350183606147766,
-0.6313662528991699,
-0.184604674577713,
-0.0927969440817833,
-0.22832612693309784,
-0.25623831152915955,
0.8174293041229248,
-0.5693901777267456,
0.34129995107650757,
0.24462877213954926,
0.9965143799781799,
-0.17071446776390076,
-0.10428574681282043,
0.4382069408893585,
-0.5737454295158386,
-0.1820024847984314,
0.46208715438842773,
0.45474064350128174,
0.4092068374156952,
-0.27852243185043335,
0.2235085815191269,
0.5372617840766907,
-0.2676423192024231,
-1.1896464824676514,
0.3039819598197937,
-0.3734932541847229,
-0.6504435539245605,
1.0487797260284424,
-0.38591668009757996,
-0.27197569608688354,
0.07892278581857681,
-0.03356460854411125,
-0.028371255844831467,
0.07782389223575592,
1.0012931823730469,
0.8709520697593689,
0.36863988637924194,
0.4332069456577301,
-0.28563904762268066,
0.25058382749557495,
0.644287645816803,
-0.7643762826919556,
0.19966340065002441,
0.4341593384742737,
0.389960378408432,
0.30212998390197754,
0.26719725131988525,
-0.5590012669563293,
0.24800850450992584,
0.07324530184268951,
-0.1946491152048111,
-0.5406586527824402,
-0.1805717647075653,
-0.5707482695579529,
0.6677888631820679,
0.17918454110622406,
-0.016439635306596756
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.