id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01616v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01616v2
|
Towards Comprehensive Vietnamese Retrieval-Augmented Generation and Large Language Models
| 2024-03-03T21:24:35 | 2024-03-05T18:15:49 |
Nguyen Quang Duc, Le Hai Son, Nguyen Duc Nhan, Nguyen Dich Nhat Minh, Le Thanh Huong, Dinh Viet Sang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents our contributions towards advancing the state of
Vietnamese language understanding and generation through the development and
dissemination of open datasets and pre-trained models for Vietnamese
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) and Large Language Models (LLMs).
|
[
-0.09120077639818192,
-0.6558935642242432,
0.8116167187690735,
-0.03363288193941116,
-0.1336727738380432,
0.056504540145397186,
-0.3218514323234558,
-0.029607800766825676,
0.09594804048538208,
1.150123119354248,
-0.16984723508358002,
-0.49316051602363586,
-0.5884170532226562,
0.17646583914756775,
-0.28221893310546875,
0.5985912084579468,
-0.19934697449207306,
0.046820297837257385,
-0.09789035469293594,
-0.1397714465856552,
-0.422157883644104,
-0.7302449345588684,
-0.6520895957946777,
-0.3358817994594574,
0.5296115279197693,
0.4576868414878845,
0.4062725305557251,
0.4855280816555023,
0.5768707990646362,
0.2744637727737427,
-0.11282520741224289,
0.3115750551223755,
-0.9050285220146179,
0.2924075722694397,
-0.43021160364151,
-0.532825231552124,
-0.6032163500785828,
-0.23849014937877655,
0.8975771069526672,
0.563484251499176,
-0.18055368959903717,
0.31350624561309814,
-0.12112221121788025,
0.8093822598457336,
-0.8983854055404663,
0.04912056401371956,
-0.6550971865653992,
-0.3222382068634033,
-0.2650834619998932,
-0.422621488571167,
-0.5507460236549377,
-0.2822197377681732,
0.059519801288843155,
-0.5338174700737,
0.22098226845264435,
-0.46914181113243103,
0.5821709632873535,
0.09468691051006317,
-0.8944122195243835,
-0.2610158622264862,
-0.8320730924606323,
0.8720850944519043,
-0.377719521522522,
0.5815064311027527,
0.6075345873832703,
0.418282151222229,
-0.25560465455055237,
-0.8849301338195801,
-0.37325453758239746,
-0.33782029151916504,
0.039904285222291946,
0.3260037899017334,
0.04413910582661629,
0.23937922716140747,
0.05200909078121185,
0.6664587259292603,
-0.5803058743476868,
0.12023197114467621,
-0.40064817667007446,
-0.0063950978219509125,
0.7846954464912415,
0.1162680834531784,
-0.00006193307490320876,
-0.17457202076911926,
-0.33307045698165894,
0.2774578332901001,
-0.9382696747779846,
-0.49750974774360657,
0.0007065573008731008,
0.4347118139266968,
-0.1786527782678604,
0.9258018732070923,
-0.2734849452972412,
1.0966296195983887,
-0.4943911135196686,
-0.30170467495918274,
0.4160599112510681,
-0.7117979526519775,
-0.4219277799129486,
-0.15063630044460297,
0.35720351338386536,
-0.1438104659318924,
0.4052625000476837,
0.0662795826792717,
-0.47607919573783875,
-0.07355289906263351,
0.23998813331127167,
-0.33868199586868286,
0.3091937303543091,
0.19568772614002228,
-0.5483565926551819,
-0.11352971196174622,
0.5002845525741577,
-0.5460216403007507,
-0.40516841411590576,
-0.6658571362495422,
0.6247132420539856,
-0.0692841038107872,
-0.6432644128799438,
0.2957702875137329,
-0.2603786885738373,
0.3287017047405243,
0.34430453181266785,
-0.30948272347450256,
0.014154468663036823,
0.8102118372917175,
0.8659290075302124,
-0.22593720257282257,
-0.3730469346046448,
-0.6508209705352783,
0.5793591141700745,
-0.2724950611591339,
0.6632413268089294,
-0.625659704208374,
-0.7333184480667114,
0.4285249710083008,
0.04170945659279823,
0.11635687947273254,
-0.8706257343292236,
0.5779120922088623,
-0.6846553683280945,
0.09360069036483765,
0.07612528651952744,
-0.5914856195449829,
-0.1329740434885025,
0.16756990551948547,
-0.6597592830657959,
0.8801772594451904,
0.5833456516265869,
-0.714421808719635,
-0.10784148424863815,
-0.6513851881027222,
-0.17949098348617554,
0.1398312896490097,
0.10144516080617905,
-0.06088165193796158,
0.4172413647174835,
0.07839853316545486,
0.521552562713623,
-0.37055841088294983,
0.3988777697086334,
-0.01732211746275425,
-0.35970696806907654,
0.17574702203273773,
-0.26630279421806335,
0.8371819257736206,
0.6129396557807922,
0.034900955855846405,
0.2738341689109802,
-0.9132981300354004,
-0.15077415108680725,
0.30777981877326965,
-0.5851729512214661,
-0.522266149520874,
-0.31351351737976074,
0.1765558272600174,
0.0936473160982132,
0.5738816857337952,
-0.2749786972999573,
0.34540650248527527,
0.03787439689040184,
0.03111746348440647,
0.6662232875823975,
0.10294687002897263,
0.49302777647972107,
-0.028992149978876114,
0.7331786751747131,
0.3212316930294037,
-0.11677926033735275,
-0.8126225471496582,
-0.10795340687036514,
-0.8547000288963318,
-0.3610435128211975,
0.2649444341659546,
0.4907306134700775,
-1.1485304832458496,
0.40548470616340637,
-0.34050843119621277,
-0.4613506495952606,
-0.791870653629303,
0.40517657995224,
0.43975645303726196,
0.5151047110557556,
0.26642879843711853,
-0.18154826760292053,
-0.9942320585250854,
-0.7047675848007202,
-0.13104669749736786,
-0.24616454541683197,
-0.38112953305244446,
0.3140186369419098,
0.4501492381095886,
-0.7392368912696838,
0.8054332137107849,
-0.5918135046958923,
-0.11478628218173981,
-0.4633886218070984,
-0.08810041844844818,
0.21929116547107697,
0.24625004827976227,
0.45111268758773804,
-0.9434857368469238,
-0.5612722635269165,
0.1837417483329773,
-0.7485735416412354,
-0.30972379446029663,
0.42259371280670166,
-0.2281126081943512,
0.3327785134315491,
0.6505592465400696,
-0.4522570073604584,
0.43631625175476074,
0.5282667875289917,
-0.3880595266819,
0.6134490966796875,
-0.22077591717243195,
0.06692102551460266,
-1.3110986948013306,
-0.03253134712576866,
-0.10556881874799728,
-0.3995233178138733,
-0.8553466796875,
0.2745426893234253,
-0.20801933109760284,
0.026649249717593193,
-0.5136072039604187,
0.8732427954673767,
-0.5651947855949402,
-0.1598329395055771,
-0.5633809566497803,
0.18120810389518738,
-0.07268429547548294,
-0.28722864389419556,
0.34358134865760803,
0.9979074597358704,
0.6557229161262512,
-0.8267070651054382,
0.2883792817592621,
0.02789447456598282,
-0.14502693712711334,
0.6299664974212646,
-0.6693263649940491,
0.06479206681251526,
-0.3132808804512024,
0.1888526827096939,
-0.5820416808128357,
-0.3153536915779114,
-0.1691233366727829,
-0.40596941113471985,
0.3004452586174011,
-0.2216591238975525,
-0.3602138161659241,
-0.38164496421813965,
-0.0774102658033371,
0.32381612062454224,
0.4770793616771698,
-0.6015597581863403,
0.3674013018608093,
0.6735807657241821,
-0.029415782541036606,
-0.5608171224594116,
-0.3184027373790741,
-0.04959552362561226,
-0.2606513202190399,
-0.4460809826850891,
-0.0825100839138031,
0.25029072165489197,
-0.7541210055351257,
-0.18619947135448456,
0.3316240906715393,
-0.2717033326625824,
-0.25713667273521423,
-0.23712415993213654,
0.2032458633184433,
-0.7092291116714478,
0.4003406763076782,
-0.373222291469574,
-0.07581021636724472,
-0.12076251953840256,
-0.5644717216491699,
0.7020672559738159,
0.12314693629741669,
-0.07662404328584671,
-0.06751025468111038,
0.2592707574367523,
0.33136922121047974,
-0.5338900685310364,
0.8208096027374268,
0.6391938328742981,
-0.1565479189157486,
0.04567846655845642,
-0.7410668730735779,
0.13023333251476288,
-0.4714648127555847,
0.4316576421260834,
-0.47752314805984497,
-1.3575888872146606,
0.24551504850387573,
-0.2681112289428711,
-0.15568214654922485,
0.5146974325180054,
0.9688740372657776,
0.14963361620903015,
0.7397308945655823,
1.1185661554336548,
-0.09424088895320892,
0.504371166229248,
-0.17704197764396667,
-0.2812899947166443,
-0.8239463567733765,
0.09449039399623871,
-0.6663488149642944,
0.2960331439971924,
-1.0251697301864624,
-0.9243342876434326,
0.19978846609592438,
0.12744994461536407,
-0.615989089012146,
-0.00047928959247656167,
-0.3468058407306671,
0.24311420321464539,
0.6472513675689697,
0.08367735147476196,
0.5637813806533813,
0.03278592973947525,
0.16484487056732178,
0.13027504086494446,
-0.525627613067627,
-0.6169927716255188,
1.3719762563705444,
0.285972535610199,
0.7806674242019653,
0.05879543349146843,
0.8248220682144165,
0.09361205250024796,
0.13462381064891815,
-0.6169183254241943,
0.3640647530555725,
-0.19213233888149261,
-0.5417221784591675,
-0.25564590096473694,
-0.6963515281677246,
-1.1998215913772583,
0.11961746960878372,
0.12032513320446014,
-0.4328473210334778,
-0.09208875894546509,
-0.16380956768989563,
0.41577938199043274,
0.2119448333978653,
-0.726274847984314,
0.5197716951370239,
-0.22915461659431458,
-0.04432888329029083,
-0.368860125541687,
-0.46475136280059814,
0.5568285584449768,
-0.15662367641925812,
0.04713072627782822,
0.12900875508785248,
-0.45622438192367554,
0.6075994372367859,
-0.17628516256809235,
0.42892494797706604,
-0.2522779405117035,
-0.3127823770046234,
0.8367435336112976,
-0.033366017043590546,
0.20740438997745514,
0.25711461901664734,
-0.2672623097896576,
0.03814096748828888,
-0.4202997386455536,
-0.645512044429779,
-0.3018740117549896,
0.5660952925682068,
-0.7867472767829895,
-0.6828218698501587,
-0.2930300831794739,
-0.5112310647964478,
-0.10135626792907715,
0.3911902606487274,
0.08509588241577148,
-0.007243007887154818,
-0.37488099932670593,
0.20365341007709503,
0.8924331068992615,
-0.502866268157959,
-0.010461045429110527,
0.7643077969551086,
-0.6096293330192566,
-0.5342248678207397,
1.0552641153335571,
0.16584958136081696,
0.34554627537727356,
0.4810411334037781,
0.06807641685009003,
-0.24088725447654724,
-0.40326979756355286,
0.19145552814006805,
0.7226392030715942,
-0.5421754121780396,
-0.21296952664852142,
-0.5459087491035461,
-0.42511025071144104,
-0.6118139624595642,
0.03075413592159748,
-0.3294554054737091,
-0.45686236023902893,
-0.3453814685344696,
-0.3204748332500458,
0.6275520920753479,
1.4332494735717773,
-0.3876573443412781,
0.6489183902740479,
-1.0495291948318481,
0.6286103129386902,
0.11151918023824692,
0.4354229271411896,
-0.1224532276391983,
-0.7259712815284729,
-0.43101766705513,
0.020974906161427498,
-0.3094198405742645,
-0.619937539100647,
0.1836697906255722,
0.07344526052474976,
0.4147476553916931,
0.21930082142353058,
-0.25480493903160095,
0.5515220165252686,
-0.47306686639785767,
0.7536543607711792,
0.014116485603153706,
-0.7935633659362793,
1.0331746339797974,
-0.5945568084716797,
0.5318298935890198,
0.2997436821460724,
0.5458415746688843,
-0.5724978446960449,
0.012414386495947838,
-0.5415424108505249,
-0.7906547784805298,
0.5565336346626282,
0.15565328299999237,
0.011577140539884567,
0.1125652864575386,
0.452191025018692,
0.17371921241283417,
0.38979408144950867,
-0.4385697841644287,
-0.18138137459754944,
-0.05662402883172035,
-0.021732272580266,
-0.5599051713943481,
-0.6325503587722778,
0.1692681610584259,
-0.2319764792919159,
0.6105421781539917,
-0.10733716189861298,
0.2843097448348999,
0.03146958723664284,
0.014391870237886906,
0.03279229998588562,
0.3743434250354767,
0.5631177425384521,
1.0662635564804077,
-0.09922709316015244,
0.003843532409518957,
-0.03971729055047035,
-0.7845279574394226,
0.3661474585533142,
-0.10049792379140854,
-0.07988528907299042,
0.2320173978805542,
0.6034170389175415,
0.6641179919242859,
-0.3581230044364929,
-0.7136391401290894,
0.3131231665611267,
-0.036284755915403366,
0.05882284790277481,
-0.4592737853527069,
0.008562499657273293,
0.060673557221889496,
-0.02050670236349106,
0.5137935280799866,
-0.7187321186065674,
-0.09837411344051361,
-0.6071970462799072,
0.41135910153388977,
0.2270657867193222,
-0.4866914749145508,
-0.3277265131473541,
0.38825342059135437,
0.08445187658071518,
-0.221577450633049,
0.8459250330924988,
0.1950453817844391,
-0.566074788570404,
0.3978941738605499,
0.6465520262718201,
0.9254118204116821,
-0.5635382533073425,
0.3982084393501282,
0.5131242871284485,
0.21549706161022186,
-0.12706047296524048,
0.7979733943939209,
0.012038922868669033,
-0.4259883761405945,
-0.6793232560157776,
-0.8463826775550842,
-0.3107573390007019,
0.2418186068534851,
-0.8119120597839355,
0.5065200328826904,
0.1536267101764679,
-0.13409249484539032,
-0.5933375954627991,
0.06341787427663803,
-0.6235803365707397,
0.27635329961776733,
0.16910451650619507,
1.2281761169433594,
-0.44772154092788696,
1.060287356376648,
0.7691081762313843,
-0.4505481421947479,
-0.5318679809570312,
0.06728958338499069,
-0.22920677065849304,
-0.7678846716880798,
0.8807815909385681,
-0.023151356726884842,
0.09823492914438248,
0.12352191656827927,
-0.6984166502952576,
-1.014245629310608,
0.95844966173172,
0.4959271252155304,
-0.36596205830574036,
-0.056518394500017166,
0.4293665587902069,
0.6267528533935547,
-0.5163107514381409,
0.2644914388656616,
0.7976478934288025,
0.5013986825942993,
0.04064195230603218,
-1.1271696090698242,
-0.45264163613319397,
-0.016077907755970955,
0.28644415736198425,
0.14330057799816132,
-0.6114651560783386,
0.8269194960594177,
-0.102419413626194,
0.029747532680630684,
0.208301842212677,
1.0238021612167358,
0.5345233678817749,
0.29149898886680603,
0.1415245234966278,
0.6793344616889954,
0.5900630354881287,
-0.14690379798412323,
1.0655733346939087,
0.07934039831161499,
0.17342615127563477,
1.1490070819854736,
-0.1497616171836853,
1.0259112119674683,
0.4185048043727875,
-0.1420448273420334,
0.13814935088157654,
0.5322958827018738,
0.41116297245025635,
0.23346419632434845,
0.2693251967430115,
-0.5134504437446594,
0.0044577461667358875,
-0.6514483094215393,
-0.6330820322036743,
0.7253317832946777,
0.6288475394248962,
-0.36387956142425537,
-0.042982716113328934,
0.19950184226036072,
-0.15605494379997253,
0.3108135163784027,
-0.7096980810165405,
0.8619970679283142,
0.40275925397872925,
-0.5407693982124329,
0.715119481086731,
-0.24519377946853638,
0.6109389066696167,
-0.6396484375,
-0.25298672914505005,
-0.06920920312404633,
0.17058949172496796,
-0.18766182661056519,
-1.1033655405044556,
0.2884019911289215,
0.10234036296606064,
-0.11653868108987808,
-0.07146351784467697,
0.9350724220275879,
-0.5988240838050842,
-0.5048829913139343,
0.5099422931671143,
0.8430856466293335,
0.12851783633232117,
0.033442769199609756,
-0.5214428901672363,
0.37869852781295776,
-0.2213708758354187,
-0.2910833954811096,
0.19823351502418518,
0.7056476473808289,
0.040087539702653885,
0.519324004650116,
0.37904641032218933,
0.25272002816200256,
0.23161645233631134,
0.11440814286470413,
0.8863636255264282,
-0.7661284804344177,
-0.3410954177379608,
-0.5676906704902649,
0.5311799049377441,
0.2429186999797821,
-0.030154017731547356,
0.8412344455718994,
0.6563087701797485,
1.2814048528671265,
-0.22852982580661774,
1.0054388046264648,
-0.007676785811781883,
0.8809911012649536,
-0.5232435464859009,
0.6621590852737427,
-0.678578794002533,
-0.01801333576440811,
-0.13630540668964386,
-1.197765827178955,
-0.2523905634880066,
0.2672779858112335,
-0.11697889119386673,
0.20526544749736786,
0.17494623363018036,
0.6035782098770142,
-0.009365596808493137,
-0.4837079346179962,
0.3434458076953888,
0.6447257995605469,
0.3698030114173889,
0.26434001326560974,
0.924131453037262,
-0.22410418093204498,
0.18229392170906067,
-0.17783600091934204,
-0.21547798812389374,
-0.10905447602272034,
-0.4604097306728363,
-0.7991377115249634,
-0.8292375206947327,
0.17287656664848328,
-0.3900049328804016,
0.18066450953483582,
0.7653853297233582,
0.26564276218414307,
-0.7040615081787109,
-0.8095815777778625,
-0.00243377685546875,
0.27210763096809387,
0.33645373582839966,
-0.2425421178340912,
0.4677981436252594,
-0.43787992000579834,
-0.8408203125,
0.4190070927143097,
0.27993035316467285,
0.09429164975881577,
-0.5892025232315063,
-0.35490113496780396,
-0.5892776846885681,
-0.04684379696846008,
1.2399932146072388,
0.2733164131641388,
-0.5441049337387085,
0.05691992864012718,
0.08015080541372299,
-0.17320118844509125,
0.13434277474880219,
0.9721768498420715,
-1.0579068660736084,
0.6817325353622437,
0.7046340703964233,
0.7466904520988464,
0.2331731766462326,
0.04038647189736366,
1.0362515449523926,
-0.5611246228218079,
0.48234719038009644,
0.12894010543823242,
0.24867427349090576,
0.4328734874725342,
-0.3530307710170746,
0.9062870740890503,
0.0437103696167469,
-0.7111608386039734,
-1.0917032957077026,
0.45199093222618103,
-0.684958279132843,
-0.12739640474319458,
1.2056647539138794,
-0.0451958104968071,
-0.41162317991256714,
-0.1398170292377472,
-0.33555540442466736,
0.5219742059707642,
0.008303774520754814,
0.23077426850795746,
0.294900119304657,
0.03756391257047653,
-0.07832508534193039,
-0.7725681662559509,
0.3667973279953003,
-0.05892067030072212,
-0.7884700298309326,
0.05421018227934837,
0.48595771193504333,
-0.296069860458374,
0.0526692196726799,
0.840484082698822,
-0.16358882188796997,
0.35328221321105957,
-0.18697185814380646,
-0.18291833996772766,
0.3504209816455841,
-0.5605403184890747,
-0.6047154664993286,
-0.1378268599510193,
0.37757325172424316,
0.19198301434516907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01599v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01599v1
|
SCHEMA: State CHangEs MAtter for Procedure Planning in Instructional Videos
| 2024-03-03T19:53:06 | 2024-03-03T19:53:06 |
Yulei Niu, Wenliang Guo, Long Chen, Xudong Lin, Shih-Fu Chang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We study the problem of procedure planning in instructional videos, which
aims to make a goal-oriented sequence of action steps given partial visual
state observations. The motivation of this problem is to learn a structured and
plannable state and action space. Recent works succeeded in sequence modeling
of steps with only sequence-level annotations accessible during training, which
overlooked the roles of states in the procedures. In this work, we point out
that State CHangEs MAtter (SCHEMA) for procedure planning in instructional
videos. We aim to establish a more structured state space by investigating the
causal relations between steps and states in procedures. Specifically, we
explicitly represent each step as state changes and track the state changes in
procedures. For step representation, we leveraged the commonsense knowledge in
large language models (LLMs) to describe the state changes of steps via our
designed chain-of-thought prompting. For state change tracking, we align visual
state observations with language state descriptions via cross-modal contrastive
learning, and explicitly model the intermediate states of the procedure using
LLM-generated state descriptions. Experiments on CrossTask, COIN, and NIV
benchmark datasets demonstrate that our proposed SCHEMA model achieves
state-of-the-art performance and obtains explainable visualizations.
|
[
0.07487401366233826,
-0.731532871723175,
0.6144660711288452,
-0.09756069630384445,
-0.2498895674943924,
-0.46509572863578796,
-0.07373421639204025,
0.09850819408893585,
0.46458423137664795,
0.6097335815429688,
-0.6398949027061462,
-0.4312942922115326,
-0.4960027039051056,
-0.08418934047222137,
-0.6058042049407959,
0.9274430871009827,
-0.49129581451416016,
0.21235747635364532,
-0.05681949108839035,
0.16096462309360504,
-0.3832198679447174,
0.09620554745197296,
-0.24384330213069916,
-0.3336383104324341,
0.2750530242919922,
0.4549434185028076,
0.3897574543952942,
1.0221482515335083,
0.42986053228378296,
0.3449479937553406,
-0.06102297827601433,
-0.04805479571223259,
-0.40490102767944336,
0.40290188789367676,
-0.3463899493217468,
-0.5175672173500061,
-0.30056774616241455,
-0.33044302463531494,
0.7989681363105774,
0.6867315769195557,
-0.424874871969223,
0.12501509487628937,
-0.27402395009994507,
0.581805944442749,
-0.5900918245315552,
0.6620052456855774,
-0.6456412672996521,
0.21523743867874146,
-0.02603137493133545,
-0.4474802017211914,
-0.2341575026512146,
-0.13089057803153992,
0.15451045334339142,
-0.8485992550849915,
0.3591892421245575,
-0.2554241418838501,
0.43405619263648987,
0.38615548610687256,
-0.21890948712825775,
-0.30237922072410583,
-1.0825008153915405,
0.22989974915981293,
-0.4184177815914154,
0.5956590175628662,
0.10969321429729462,
0.3266298174858093,
-0.3276277184486389,
-0.7149391174316406,
-0.6764964461326599,
-0.07690420001745224,
0.22700822353363037,
0.01787622831761837,
0.006185163278132677,
0.24976566433906555,
0.785709798336029,
0.3178262412548065,
-0.2980130612850189,
0.011504407972097397,
-0.7017125487327576,
-0.30907922983169556,
0.5049669146537781,
0.6183521151542664,
0.20830705761909485,
-0.2560916244983673,
-0.5198849439620972,
-0.1869623214006424,
-0.8204636573791504,
0.12468018382787704,
0.07686889171600342,
0.3191032111644745,
-0.095447838306427,
0.7166761755943298,
-0.45051804184913635,
0.8252505660057068,
0.10452497005462646,
-0.4751312732696533,
-0.23638270795345306,
-0.38206085562705994,
-0.6168381571769714,
0.059712041169404984,
0.3758528530597687,
0.40890973806381226,
0.016577383503317833,
0.29351887106895447,
-0.011961637996137142,
0.18941394984722137,
0.31761637330055237,
-0.9493979215621948,
-0.28746581077575684,
0.0042349244467914104,
-0.2961658835411072,
0.0638892874121666,
-0.025156762450933456,
-0.36133337020874023,
-0.6184930205345154,
-0.8284496665000916,
0.3178442418575287,
-0.5679064393043518,
-0.0646924301981926,
0.1393919140100479,
0.04420804977416992,
0.15935637056827545,
0.7863039970397949,
-1.0743399858474731,
0.45357245206832886,
0.7035916447639465,
0.4037923514842987,
-0.059978604316711426,
-0.44047030806541443,
-0.47613999247550964,
0.38756269216537476,
-0.4889477789402008,
0.7464079856872559,
-0.6184763312339783,
-0.3860795795917511,
0.529992401599884,
0.053880613297224045,
-0.01825699955224991,
-0.37650105357170105,
-0.13371415436267853,
-0.2740272283554077,
-0.19510473310947418,
-0.4496753513813019,
-0.8688427209854126,
-0.06822577863931656,
0.05280343070626259,
-0.4971271753311157,
0.7136353850364685,
-0.04096598923206329,
-0.574521005153656,
0.7505468130111694,
-0.7523934245109558,
-0.6356992721557617,
-0.08026361465454102,
-0.5766441822052002,
-0.033837758004665375,
0.004712904803454876,
-0.24857723712921143,
0.5778225064277649,
0.1652095764875412,
0.29030194878578186,
0.10449138283729553,
-0.38159969449043274,
0.27758586406707764,
0.08148125559091568,
0.25797516107559204,
0.06623739004135132,
-0.09711726009845734,
0.560437023639679,
-0.7337061762809753,
-0.45252200961112976,
-0.3559006452560425,
-0.3426741063594818,
-0.19242976605892181,
0.20437924563884735,
-0.44788670539855957,
0.4120035767555237,
-0.1015164852142334,
-0.263656884431839,
0.4125460982322693,
0.02407008968293667,
0.4887872636318207,
0.6566160321235657,
0.2781427204608917,
0.9707885980606079,
0.21612587571144104,
0.4453999698162079,
0.19848676025867462,
0.27275514602661133,
-0.6161961555480957,
-0.25568899512290955,
-0.8871327638626099,
0.12065562605857849,
-0.21347874402999878,
0.4295583963394165,
-0.7217000126838684,
-0.31563594937324524,
-0.09023896604776382,
-0.37368467450141907,
-0.1494535356760025,
-0.10696414858102798,
0.1924540102481842,
0.8810646533966064,
0.5401979088783264,
-0.20339623093605042,
-0.2626383900642395,
-0.8510039448738098,
-0.16707348823547363,
-0.24648836255073547,
0.05548826977610588,
-0.02251356653869152,
0.817547082901001,
0.3100288212299347,
0.5587385296821594,
-0.7834206223487854,
-0.379161536693573,
-0.24395903944969177,
0.1276431679725647,
-0.04800967499613762,
0.21466805040836334,
-0.15349812805652618,
-0.5430631041526794,
-0.1849285215139389,
-0.3503649830818176,
-0.5061657428741455,
0.1942523866891861,
-0.5685831904411316,
-0.13238109648227692,
0.24734459817409515,
0.8701618909835815,
-0.4728724956512451,
0.8825970888137817,
0.04678959771990776,
-0.12099934369325638,
0.538714587688446,
-0.3181338906288147,
0.26145491003990173,
-0.9186403155326843,
-0.3232589066028595,
0.15669375658035278,
0.47077280282974243,
-0.6895286440849304,
-0.020349962636828423,
0.3144534230232239,
-0.27457642555236816,
-0.7940734624862671,
0.32823464274406433,
-0.33785077929496765,
-0.5047546625137329,
-0.0005019748932681978,
0.061995331197977066,
-0.31505146622657776,
0.5518006086349487,
0.4770059585571289,
0.6110386848449707,
0.757177472114563,
-0.779957115650177,
0.05977029353380203,
0.30663275718688965,
-0.27336493134498596,
0.8304873108863831,
-0.2096574902534485,
-0.3875540494918823,
0.1104518324136734,
0.47705671191215515,
-0.7539045214653015,
-0.34244728088378906,
0.49569350481033325,
-0.04679596424102783,
0.3886915445327759,
-0.373110294342041,
-0.3847725987434387,
0.040200915187597275,
-0.01142702903598547,
-0.10662569105625153,
0.03168495371937752,
0.07189559191465378,
0.5981404781341553,
0.31915953755378723,
-0.032622918486595154,
-0.5526314377784729,
-0.5802415013313293,
-0.17984279990196228,
-0.062300845980644226,
-0.44667693972587585,
0.4878409504890442,
0.21440234780311584,
-0.2752675712108612,
-0.020804092288017273,
-0.5716733932495117,
-0.18770627677440643,
-0.21138940751552582,
0.5671104788780212,
0.2426629215478897,
0.006563612259924412,
0.3807576894760132,
0.42431190609931946,
0.08345025777816772,
0.40677306056022644,
-0.23085857927799225,
0.3813976049423218,
0.19040459394454956,
-0.3334517180919647,
-0.7500953674316406,
0.43463680148124695,
0.3620225191116333,
-0.11265397816896439,
0.37008756399154663,
0.1969665139913559,
-0.48409518599510193,
-0.1818860024213791,
-0.1112067848443985,
-0.4319514036178589,
-0.40625685453414917,
0.5207352042198181,
-0.20611561834812164,
-0.6125338673591614,
0.37245824933052063,
-0.07337281852960587,
0.3116822838783264,
-0.007769982796162367,
0.3975195288658142,
-0.4521627426147461,
0.5239985585212708,
0.5600585341453552,
0.48670145869255066,
0.7551103234291077,
-0.5253047943115234,
-0.022085098549723625,
-0.8622742891311646,
-0.4003826379776001,
-0.22091300785541534,
-0.2929210066795349,
-0.6181783676147461,
-0.9226784110069275,
0.4369121491909027,
-0.04767373576760292,
-0.42403945326805115,
0.4653983414173126,
-0.007972187362611294,
0.3010328710079193,
0.2032770812511444,
0.03366702422499657,
0.24551451206207275,
0.3261473476886749,
-0.0739857479929924,
-0.3613184094429016,
-0.7084386348724365,
-0.2488134652376175,
1.032099962234497,
0.012008115649223328,
1.0807042121887207,
-0.1994745433330536,
0.9285524487495422,
0.028453774750232697,
0.10174188762903214,
-0.8523907661437988,
1.1004669666290283,
-0.02950773946940899,
-0.2500509023666382,
-0.6387204527854919,
-0.013920139521360397,
-0.8555999994277954,
0.1851462423801422,
-0.42476174235343933,
-0.5395953059196472,
0.043786026537418365,
0.4668693244457245,
-0.04353533685207367,
0.4560922682285309,
-0.22498638927936554,
0.5526201128959656,
0.055946219712495804,
-0.616385281085968,
-0.5769173502922058,
-0.6423072814941406,
0.20005136728286743,
0.475334107875824,
-0.04084518551826477,
0.2708696126937866,
0.055252037942409515,
0.7754157781600952,
-0.686621904373169,
0.9065605401992798,
-0.025071458891034126,
-0.1621318906545639,
0.29370224475860596,
0.5280228853225708,
0.4601934850215912,
-0.21246151626110077,
0.3036248981952667,
-0.06939399987459183,
-0.35049185156822205,
-0.07374993711709976,
-0.7534900307655334,
0.5314126014709473,
-0.17197807133197784,
-0.737680971622467,
-0.52887362241745,
-0.6859502196311951,
-0.016308458521962166,
0.1514851152896881,
0.00023005626280792058,
0.4416385591030121,
-0.13552546501159668,
-0.12088479101657867,
0.8495291471481323,
-0.03539770841598511,
0.3039729595184326,
0.7169656753540039,
-0.12438543885946274,
-0.04555915668606758,
0.7222850918769836,
0.5056592226028442,
0.4896833002567291,
0.529790997505188,
-0.007388961501419544,
-0.21944276988506317,
-0.4796912372112274,
-0.4845578372478485,
0.4315159320831299,
-1.0141370296478271,
0.09762495756149292,
-0.10506186634302139,
-0.016557106748223305,
-0.37268275022506714,
-0.19708038866519928,
-0.2129787653684616,
-0.48914557695388794,
-0.2960546314716339,
-0.2007026970386505,
0.11008305847644806,
0.7993581295013428,
-0.05648842453956604,
0.04862355813384056,
-0.3373523950576782,
0.20629990100860596,
0.2741096615791321,
0.22781601548194885,
-0.2789192795753479,
-0.4040459096431732,
-0.33038514852523804,
-0.21932268142700195,
-0.3502512574195862,
-1.1509041786193848,
0.04569186642765999,
-0.004767338279634714,
0.4505815804004669,
0.594601035118103,
-0.2209612876176834,
1.0779047012329102,
-0.720311164855957,
0.7497273683547974,
0.32968589663505554,
-0.7348964214324951,
1.010574460029602,
-0.2710445821285248,
0.21306106448173523,
0.15544015169143677,
0.4366873800754547,
-0.8215033411979675,
-0.3731575310230255,
-0.6553409099578857,
-0.6975395679473877,
0.6778397560119629,
-0.05688103660941124,
0.056913822889328,
-0.03727848455309868,
0.2912503778934479,
0.09943414479494095,
0.32176247239112854,
-0.3320122957229614,
-0.21834109723567963,
-0.17388708889484406,
0.29076018929481506,
0.38093823194503784,
0.026622239500284195,
-0.496957004070282,
-0.006695951335132122,
0.274118572473526,
-0.17011308670043945,
0.08957186341285706,
0.1610765904188156,
-0.19536751508712769,
-0.26080191135406494,
0.4310145080089569,
0.8855269551277161,
0.8855520486831665,
0.2613029479980469,
-0.006942334119230509,
-0.004657006356865168,
-0.46798989176750183,
-0.07306661456823349,
0.028060993179678917,
-0.47257837653160095,
-0.09004515409469604,
0.49131572246551514,
0.9814208149909973,
0.7790589928627014,
-0.22848567366600037,
0.3310330808162689,
0.3440530002117157,
-0.34775426983833313,
-0.17248377203941345,
0.46747636795043945,
0.0017564190784469247,
0.3335261046886444,
-0.019795482978224754,
0.07441743463277817,
0.3679187297821045,
-0.6295051574707031,
0.046447668224573135,
-0.03821868076920509,
-0.33295774459838867,
-0.32200050354003906,
0.5726885199546814,
0.154276043176651,
-0.5886098146438599,
0.4578264355659485,
0.047968897968530655,
-0.23617011308670044,
0.5488418340682983,
0.5433452725410461,
0.31071892380714417,
-0.47510743141174316,
0.7726570963859558,
0.48854148387908936,
0.15113519132137299,
-0.22433410584926605,
0.5637327432632446,
-0.4476848840713501,
-0.3022075593471527,
-0.2881132960319519,
-0.18994757533073425,
-0.5366906523704529,
0.13202068209648132,
-0.8884773254394531,
0.4625094532966614,
-0.4022633731365204,
0.2253817319869995,
-0.30626147985458374,
-0.26484546065330505,
-0.6726085543632507,
0.3474334478378296,
0.062021154910326004,
1.0541068315505981,
-1.2431762218475342,
0.5736819505691528,
0.6030614972114563,
-0.684485137462616,
-1.1099225282669067,
-0.0585448257625103,
0.1382247656583786,
-0.6542233228683472,
0.7271420359611511,
-0.33665159344673157,
0.028217339888215065,
-0.5149633288383484,
-0.44151437282562256,
-0.8291318416595459,
1.3298866748809814,
0.0847269669175148,
-0.638256847858429,
-0.12773115932941437,
0.30715474486351013,
0.6636772751808167,
-0.36733588576316833,
-0.27462953329086304,
0.43916577100753784,
0.09739913791418076,
0.24696305394172668,
-0.5287010073661804,
0.0518467091023922,
0.22944264113903046,
-0.02858586609363556,
0.4322940409183502,
-0.21895423531532288,
0.9222592711448669,
-0.5739547610282898,
-0.37994909286499023,
-0.29771915078163147,
0.785576581954956,
0.5181065797805786,
0.5939290523529053,
0.5875151753425598,
0.4813407063484192,
0.6168665289878845,
-0.12544409930706024,
0.7565435171127319,
-0.11547839641571045,
-0.017944997176527977,
1.4683729410171509,
-0.38480842113494873,
0.946690559387207,
0.8449252247810364,
-0.20231832563877106,
0.6905370950698853,
0.6222124695777893,
0.1292257457971573,
0.335795521736145,
0.42586788535118103,
0.12202384322881699,
-0.2919253706932068,
0.12232239544391632,
-0.32189950346946716,
0.4040979743003845,
0.677250325679779,
-0.5535820722579956,
-0.293445885181427,
-0.1426236480474472,
0.36144012212753296,
0.06063994765281677,
-0.5105181932449341,
0.5616064071655273,
-0.24170345067977905,
-0.9363546371459961,
-0.04630323871970177,
-0.5493311882019043,
-0.234505757689476,
-0.7273358702659607,
-0.5562943816184998,
-0.3463442623615265,
-0.16581572592258453,
-0.26264628767967224,
-1.0967880487442017,
-0.031083162873983383,
-0.1668975055217743,
-0.036782242357730865,
-0.3153316378593445,
0.4873834252357483,
-0.7115669250488281,
-0.23685243725776672,
-0.04343080893158913,
0.15011104941368103,
0.2955624461174011,
0.35625889897346497,
-0.5739266872406006,
0.0870530977845192,
-0.20638668537139893,
-0.04972811043262482,
0.3855884075164795,
0.3212810754776001,
-0.5158177018165588,
0.6536350846290588,
0.51177579164505,
0.3320831060409546,
-0.015443159267306328,
0.20399484038352966,
0.7927578091621399,
-0.45560422539711,
-0.7239962816238403,
-0.3489382266998291,
0.6952605843544006,
-0.14932450652122498,
-0.36704084277153015,
0.2377268224954605,
0.40098291635513306,
1.0878698825836182,
-0.22142788767814636,
0.4173896014690399,
0.019571024924516678,
0.1161247119307518,
-0.8728734254837036,
0.29243215918540955,
-0.3950502872467041,
0.36222097277641296,
-0.40611323714256287,
-0.7766826152801514,
-0.1041390597820282,
0.5468123555183411,
-0.44336748123168945,
-0.3883463144302368,
0.8438159227371216,
0.9001460075378418,
0.10183940082788467,
0.053843528032302856,
0.1659056693315506,
0.2537287473678589,
0.24573339521884918,
0.32163500785827637,
0.6414505839347839,
-0.2081865817308426,
0.4269883930683136,
-0.33029937744140625,
0.008728507906198502,
-0.3788388967514038,
-0.9075180888175964,
-0.4223380982875824,
-1.0387605428695679,
-0.5514328479766846,
-0.24093778431415558,
-0.05764682590961456,
0.7370849847793579,
0.5781911015510559,
-0.35611000657081604,
-0.6299837827682495,
-0.15717202425003052,
0.07660981267690659,
-0.23833626508712769,
-0.18775425851345062,
0.3795076906681061,
-0.12164131551980972,
-0.4573688507080078,
0.3575211763381958,
0.5784220099449158,
-0.13558559119701385,
-0.4567115008831024,
-0.09343928843736649,
-0.1339637190103531,
0.08634977042675018,
0.5382021069526672,
0.5149781107902527,
-1.118336796760559,
-0.30064085125923157,
0.2336680144071579,
0.07494276016950607,
-0.10569664090871811,
1.3746329545974731,
-0.47320863604545593,
0.8038552403450012,
0.5309318900108337,
-0.020024854689836502,
0.9002076387405396,
-0.3195159435272217,
0.28170910477638245,
-0.3747497498989105,
-0.06512834131717682,
-0.15134404599666595,
0.5194810032844543,
0.14449158310890198,
-0.1490650475025177,
0.5265460014343262,
0.06511685252189636,
-0.3733707368373871,
-0.5833845138549805,
0.6784104108810425,
-1.0175179243087769,
-0.08924679458141327,
1.0803731679916382,
-0.1162579134106636,
-0.15919232368469238,
0.2586507797241211,
-0.19826476275920868,
0.4985825717449188,
-0.3672083616256714,
0.8666024804115295,
0.6369156837463379,
-0.8021681308746338,
0.08941098302602768,
-0.3876115679740906,
0.6419491171836853,
0.060050152242183685,
-0.7955813407897949,
0.10745526105165482,
0.8160776495933533,
0.43589773774147034,
0.18767204880714417,
0.824117124080658,
-0.0018572922563180327,
0.48946306109428406,
0.11920307576656342,
-0.2769201397895813,
-0.09163577854633331,
-0.7567122578620911,
-0.22645246982574463,
-0.06870800256729126,
-0.5580821633338928,
-0.27301087975502014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01580v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01580v1
|
Enhancing Neural Machine Translation of Low-Resource Languages: Corpus Development, Human Evaluation and Explainable AI Architectures
| 2024-03-03T18:08:30 | 2024-03-03T18:08:30 |
Séamus Lankford
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the current machine translation (MT) landscape, the Transformer
architecture stands out as the gold standard, especially for high-resource
language pairs. This research delves into its efficacy for low-resource
language pairs including both the English$\leftrightarrow$Irish and
English$\leftrightarrow$Marathi language pairs. Notably, the study identifies
the optimal hyperparameters and subword model type to significantly improve the
translation quality of Transformer models for low-resource language pairs.
The scarcity of parallel datasets for low-resource languages can hinder MT
development. To address this, gaHealth was developed, the first bilingual
corpus of health data for the Irish language. Focusing on the health domain,
models developed using this in-domain dataset exhibited very significant
improvements in BLEU score when compared with models from the LoResMT2021
Shared Task. A subsequent human evaluation using the multidimensional quality
metrics error taxonomy showcased the superior performance of the Transformer
system in reducing both accuracy and fluency errors compared to an RNN-based
counterpart.
Furthermore, this thesis introduces adaptNMT and adaptMLLM, two open-source
applications streamlined for the development, fine-tuning, and deployment of
neural machine translation models. These tools considerably simplify the setup
and evaluation process, making MT more accessible to both developers and
translators. Notably, adaptNMT, grounded in the OpenNMT ecosystem, promotes
eco-friendly natural language processing research by highlighting the
environmental footprint of model development. Fine-tuning of MLLMs by adaptMLLM
demonstrated advancements in translation performance for two low-resource
language pairs: English$\leftrightarrow$Irish and
English$\leftrightarrow$Marathi, compared to baselines from the LoResMT2021
Shared Task.
|
[
-0.11654522269964218,
-0.38622474670410156,
0.23982790112495422,
0.22214774787425995,
-0.050194598734378815,
0.0677456259727478,
-0.5079400539398193,
-0.47881779074668884,
0.1866876482963562,
0.5493646860122681,
-0.11549167335033417,
-0.3140401244163513,
-0.7112709283828735,
0.3746151924133301,
-0.1443282812833786,
0.9421379566192627,
-0.03716196492314339,
0.23573452234268188,
0.09601905196905136,
-0.6730515956878662,
-0.5600275993347168,
-0.3007875382900238,
-0.6526709198951721,
-0.4841057062149048,
0.6017698645591736,
0.3262435793876648,
1.03352689743042,
0.7217583060264587,
0.7911644577980042,
0.2807307541370392,
-0.24053692817687988,
0.2714186906814575,
-0.3125803768634796,
0.021044306457042694,
-0.25476062297821045,
-0.4691004157066345,
-0.6195316314697266,
-0.3343210220336914,
0.32901376485824585,
0.7489314079284668,
0.05483580380678177,
0.4949166178703308,
0.24985483288764954,
0.7387080788612366,
-0.4640979468822479,
0.23704521358013153,
-0.586063802242279,
0.007299868389964104,
-0.25300681591033936,
-0.2559181749820709,
-0.4241252541542053,
-0.13587947189807892,
-0.03696175292134285,
-0.43378469347953796,
-0.047068458050489426,
0.24945847690105438,
0.7056477069854736,
0.5740997195243835,
-0.2737814486026764,
-0.1664419323205948,
-0.71824049949646,
0.8767789602279663,
-0.7984066605567932,
0.5431252717971802,
0.33442747592926025,
0.2339344471693039,
-0.009310365654528141,
-0.6833929419517517,
-0.4166775345802307,
-0.1625678390264511,
-0.3877885043621063,
0.3323862850666046,
-0.49875956773757935,
-0.028574561700224876,
-0.11184713244438171,
0.4386877715587616,
-0.6532782912254333,
0.3079512119293213,
-0.5581211447715759,
-0.1711476445198059,
0.3336886167526245,
0.418675035238266,
0.4890364706516266,
-0.4483431279659271,
-0.13566944003105164,
-0.06254284828901291,
-0.5024011731147766,
-0.1328202486038208,
0.16484487056732178,
0.5784434080123901,
-0.24228501319885254,
0.6858935356140137,
-0.008473644033074379,
0.5897066593170166,
-0.15943177044391632,
0.023093217983841896,
0.35780036449432373,
-0.7073038816452026,
-0.28943654894828796,
-0.03266480565071106,
0.6942256689071655,
0.2911682426929474,
-0.04575159028172493,
-0.3331955373287201,
-0.3111395239830017,
-0.015571767464280128,
0.3508254587650299,
-0.6924762725830078,
-0.09661857038736343,
0.002602207940071821,
-0.8558047413825989,
-0.11236009001731873,
-0.6027284264564514,
-0.9292542934417725,
-0.298001766204834,
-0.41535261273384094,
0.41393613815307617,
-0.43199360370635986,
-0.41512274742126465,
0.20360064506530762,
0.15601447224617004,
0.12435872107744217,
0.04846571758389473,
-0.9302408695220947,
0.3828853368759155,
0.4640258252620697,
0.9221488237380981,
-0.30076339840888977,
-0.27270886301994324,
-0.26257845759391785,
-0.07486601918935776,
-0.17936398088932037,
0.36162230372428894,
-0.34955522418022156,
-0.1909429430961609,
-0.1626429259777069,
0.05092393979430199,
-0.3135205805301666,
-0.6974388957023621,
0.7454314231872559,
-0.5197970271110535,
0.21727705001831055,
0.15119196474552155,
-0.014300455339252949,
-0.18004846572875977,
0.22616076469421387,
-0.6726141571998596,
0.9223025441169739,
0.3012828826904297,
-0.6597704887390137,
-0.023184364661574364,
-1.1905138492584229,
-0.5109630227088928,
0.19153982400894165,
0.34292861819267273,
-0.30507245659828186,
0.27533474564552307,
0.23731036484241486,
0.1338731050491333,
-0.5129622220993042,
0.0056547122076153755,
0.2183610200881958,
-0.242271289229393,
-0.04842932149767876,
-0.6163010597229004,
0.8643008470535278,
0.39704298973083496,
-0.23723652958869934,
0.2942214012145996,
-0.5553038716316223,
0.06977927684783936,
0.039014142006635666,
-0.48209166526794434,
-0.3796727955341339,
-0.21866080164909363,
0.48207277059555054,
0.24863608181476593,
0.15890662372112274,
-0.35990846157073975,
-0.1992494761943817,
-0.5170337557792664,
0.769470751285553,
0.33754855394363403,
-0.2344721257686615,
0.639898419380188,
-0.18084987998008728,
0.5470359325408936,
0.194527730345726,
0.2795579433441162,
-0.029600191861391068,
-0.7046082615852356,
-0.6399720907211304,
-0.0840054377913475,
0.4601830840110779,
0.7674447894096375,
-0.788760244846344,
0.2916061282157898,
-0.5699623227119446,
-0.3301178812980652,
-1.4035707712173462,
0.39814281463623047,
0.39856135845184326,
0.7414140701293945,
0.8493581414222717,
-0.11998380720615387,
-0.4720894694328308,
-1.0191075801849365,
-0.24904371798038483,
-0.0909787118434906,
0.037147801369428635,
0.20831085741519928,
0.21543748676776886,
-0.6345676779747009,
0.49346908926963806,
-0.16517069935798645,
-0.1806371510028839,
-0.3554215729236603,
-0.024018732830882072,
0.37880420684814453,
0.5132214426994324,
0.4845821261405945,
-0.9463939666748047,
-0.3991391658782959,
0.4375549256801605,
-0.5674923658370972,
0.0026232083328068256,
0.16374580562114716,
-0.2424643486738205,
0.2994396388530731,
0.17832478880882263,
-0.5355914831161499,
0.3556402623653412,
0.9183748960494995,
-0.16396015882492065,
0.3489093482494354,
-0.4564613103866577,
0.07102449238300323,
-1.217785358428955,
0.20829109847545624,
-0.15232054889202118,
-0.12240956723690033,
-0.5993892550468445,
0.2011922150850296,
0.0477210208773613,
-0.23071643710136414,
-0.6353499293327332,
0.5756237506866455,
-0.3025989234447479,
0.1339292973279953,
-0.24108518660068512,
-0.13277071714401245,
-0.005655029322952032,
0.3005518317222595,
-0.27711451053619385,
0.824881374835968,
0.1241072341799736,
-0.2344660460948944,
0.1965322196483612,
0.3850490152835846,
-0.20629215240478516,
0.37663534283638,
-0.6893708109855652,
0.11319075524806976,
-0.009920092299580574,
-0.05241069197654724,
-0.4796659052371979,
-0.10863178968429565,
0.25354817509651184,
-0.47461336851119995,
0.06193704903125763,
-0.022061621770262718,
-0.4607942998409271,
-0.24435429275035858,
0.1688900887966156,
0.4434606432914734,
0.708989143371582,
-0.44141659140586853,
0.4924919307231903,
0.2792428731918335,
-0.09976993501186371,
-0.36022624373435974,
-1.1556295156478882,
0.4149424135684967,
-0.236588254570961,
-0.67714923620224,
0.33789923787117004,
0.058275800198316574,
-0.34083670377731323,
0.31928911805152893,
0.06028863042593002,
-0.21628302335739136,
0.04366735368967056,
0.02148646116256714,
0.3550456762313843,
-0.6389150023460388,
0.13624213635921478,
0.02581389993429184,
-0.41880202293395996,
-0.19288985431194305,
-0.6690195202827454,
0.3378443717956543,
-0.28535622358322144,
-0.14269356429576874,
-0.3690783381462097,
0.3577534258365631,
0.674936056137085,
-0.4882238805294037,
0.819349467754364,
0.9018106460571289,
-0.49646860361099243,
0.10454525798559189,
-0.29082658886909485,
-0.0701122060418129,
-0.39587676525115967,
0.4433562755584717,
-0.24833229184150696,
-0.8401132225990295,
0.3206082582473755,
-0.003480940591543913,
-0.034956496208906174,
0.5920644402503967,
0.9098207354545593,
0.06582745164632797,
0.7319936156272888,
0.5779809355735779,
-0.1330782026052475,
0.20511552691459656,
-0.12895740568637848,
0.42797818779945374,
-0.9845595359802246,
0.07893641293048859,
-0.45474421977996826,
-0.5807730555534363,
-0.907216489315033,
-0.4985664188861847,
0.44375744462013245,
0.0027952806558459997,
0.07184156030416489,
0.6938971877098083,
-0.6714898347854614,
0.23611731827259064,
0.6029713749885559,
0.2837890386581421,
0.3312782347202301,
-0.20215915143489838,
-0.22396408021450043,
-0.2390827238559723,
-0.8347527980804443,
-0.6384880542755127,
0.9654509425163269,
0.2408774346113205,
0.4816623032093048,
0.11200422793626785,
0.4689350128173828,
0.3012428879737854,
0.3725748062133789,
-0.7727184295654297,
0.16533668339252472,
-0.433061420917511,
-0.46568021178245544,
-0.2846711277961731,
-0.44257745146751404,
-1.1095868349075317,
0.26763927936553955,
-0.2016555368900299,
-0.3208963871002197,
0.03369179740548134,
0.1308419406414032,
-0.4334661662578583,
0.367679238319397,
-0.9517892599105835,
0.9362965226173401,
-0.4328254163265228,
-0.40077537298202515,
-0.35494542121887207,
-0.6361612677574158,
0.11967507749795914,
-0.12324238568544388,
0.18388886749744415,
0.07706606388092041,
-0.02719349041581154,
0.40344199538230896,
-0.15465015172958374,
0.5277823209762573,
0.04013253375887871,
0.15383142232894897,
0.05683393403887749,
-0.028923464938998222,
0.19127729535102844,
-0.037216588854789734,
-0.45601868629455566,
0.33975622057914734,
-0.20646648108959198,
-0.5633935332298279,
-0.47806695103645325,
0.7630764842033386,
-0.6718059182167053,
-0.4750140607357025,
0.07456189393997192,
-0.8845905065536499,
-0.10515424609184265,
0.37986427545547485,
0.24610644578933716,
0.18457023799419403,
0.050610437989234924,
0.2876013219356537,
0.4445462226867676,
-0.44484174251556396,
0.38467469811439514,
0.35061779618263245,
0.09702162444591522,
-0.49343010783195496,
0.9175137877464294,
0.04842555522918701,
0.23895151913166046,
0.4843800961971283,
0.38585057854652405,
-0.17550882697105408,
-0.7462545037269592,
-0.7433859705924988,
-0.0431818887591362,
-0.3951142430305481,
-0.3825623095035553,
-0.7279980182647705,
-0.2973136007785797,
-0.2732299864292145,
-0.04767106473445892,
-0.27845051884651184,
-0.47597649693489075,
-0.05855083465576172,
-0.02145344391465187,
0.34191757440567017,
0.614880383014679,
0.005998511333018541,
0.26364442706108093,
-0.9538298845291138,
0.18403087556362152,
0.06826598197221756,
0.18734033405780792,
0.03168627992272377,
-0.44478973746299744,
-0.6762167811393738,
0.11506961286067963,
-0.3196105659008026,
-0.566616952419281,
0.5028181672096252,
-0.04867915064096451,
0.38748711347579956,
-0.09159057587385178,
-0.1622876524925232,
0.5533860921859741,
-0.6943718791007996,
0.611735463142395,
0.08697706460952759,
-0.742473840713501,
0.47592803835868835,
-0.18670259416103363,
0.368887722492218,
0.6470880508422852,
0.10480684041976929,
-0.6381603479385376,
-0.15433479845523834,
-0.35063406825065613,
-0.8179026246070862,
0.4175795614719391,
0.46138250827789307,
0.2533368170261383,
0.10297953337430954,
0.1528671681880951,
0.1548081487417221,
-0.03577771410346031,
-0.36259499192237854,
-0.16424855589866638,
-0.19233998656272888,
-0.4800049364566803,
-0.1483820229768753,
0.14809614419937134,
0.0036393837071955204,
-0.3396015167236328,
0.4734758734703064,
-0.11082883179187775,
0.24386738240718842,
0.11576062440872192,
-0.3427126407623291,
-0.11318784207105637,
0.4042823314666748,
0.6726406216621399,
0.4625226855278015,
-0.0328686460852623,
0.17185258865356445,
0.41913938522338867,
-0.532148003578186,
0.19365674257278442,
0.09874443709850311,
-0.2771342396736145,
0.16056744754314423,
0.4294222295284271,
0.8733100891113281,
0.29805365204811096,
-0.33403265476226807,
0.22653315961360931,
-0.06683552265167236,
0.20961381494998932,
0.10931122303009033,
-0.06235165894031525,
0.3868965208530426,
0.11579644680023193,
0.056372981518507004,
0.6471801996231079,
0.05459420010447502,
-0.21197709441184998,
0.010894712060689926,
0.05325033888220787,
-0.47858843207359314,
-0.6599015593528748,
0.8272077441215515,
0.38947418332099915,
-0.7407174706459045,
0.6660202145576477,
0.013721020892262459,
-0.3685745894908905,
0.39538782835006714,
0.6773571968078613,
0.9037327170372009,
-0.2886902391910553,
-0.06237917020916939,
0.2027779370546341,
0.6831108927726746,
0.08733634650707245,
0.08957374840974808,
0.08787274360656738,
-0.5443634390830994,
-0.5307523608207703,
-0.7631374001502991,
-0.37947946786880493,
0.0627669095993042,
-0.65708988904953,
0.2321062535047531,
0.06325539201498032,
-0.3113047778606415,
-0.049686186015605927,
-0.17935432493686676,
-1.042699933052063,
0.003078930079936981,
-0.09139183908700943,
1.0775998830795288,
-0.698085606098175,
0.9349164962768555,
0.8959256410598755,
-0.5030485987663269,
-0.5126597285270691,
-0.04995632544159889,
-0.11939940601587296,
-0.9012889862060547,
0.6861487030982971,
-0.1576371043920517,
0.009655601345002651,
0.14522522687911987,
0.054742999374866486,
-0.5551031231880188,
1.1004878282546997,
0.5248665809631348,
-0.4695908725261688,
-0.2674768567085266,
0.47636696696281433,
0.8718476891517639,
-0.12841250002384186,
0.24260661005973816,
0.5206663608551025,
0.785548746585846,
-0.4477241635322571,
-1.0505588054656982,
-0.04559921473264694,
-0.31734758615493774,
0.18787801265716553,
0.3444053828716278,
-0.6442661285400391,
0.47188204526901245,
-0.1292944699525833,
0.07332244515419006,
0.13783568143844604,
0.5141637325286865,
-0.21117174625396729,
0.22919735312461853,
0.3467032313346863,
0.598742663860321,
0.6210576891899109,
-0.01705060712993145,
1.1038440465927124,
-0.5405480265617371,
0.16142968833446503,
0.9944432973861694,
-0.0816316306591034,
0.9119813442230225,
0.6676414012908936,
-0.1172289252281189,
0.2050018310546875,
0.2541309893131256,
0.24678808450698853,
0.3366609215736389,
0.24327193200588226,
-0.23633787035942078,
-0.010789606720209122,
-0.3609124720096588,
-0.19604472815990448,
0.6318856477737427,
0.3796725869178772,
-0.5820336937904358,
-0.251254141330719,
0.23889735341072083,
-0.012806699611246586,
0.25375431776046753,
-0.2097829133272171,
0.6048011779785156,
0.21218058466911316,
-0.4624426066875458,
0.5612302422523499,
0.2120189517736435,
0.762241780757904,
-0.3727140724658966,
0.06449351459741592,
-0.3915167450904846,
0.32974371314048767,
-0.26832315325737,
-0.584362268447876,
0.8124138712882996,
0.0690644159913063,
-0.32975873351097107,
-0.5281001329421997,
0.7378422617912292,
-0.4750586450099945,
-0.5672099590301514,
0.6176435947418213,
0.7651435136795044,
-0.049076277762651443,
0.2999365031719208,
-0.661199688911438,
-0.04550167918205261,
-0.25973907113075256,
0.046014703810214996,
0.20920579135417938,
0.4737006425857544,
-0.13853305578231812,
0.39684033393859863,
0.6415345072746277,
0.45006871223449707,
0.07033314555883408,
-0.06867261230945587,
0.5463257431983948,
-0.508368730545044,
-0.12378355860710144,
-0.8117009997367859,
0.41510072350502014,
0.23050256073474884,
-0.427338182926178,
0.6370784640312195,
0.6219226717948914,
0.6407197117805481,
-0.18669496476650238,
0.6165890693664551,
0.05888970196247101,
0.3331853747367859,
-0.36444005370140076,
1.1264958381652832,
-0.46510928869247437,
-0.13782109320163727,
0.16074754297733307,
-0.784489095211029,
-0.48190295696258545,
0.13883395493030548,
-0.13512057065963745,
-0.35167115926742554,
0.670670747756958,
0.8591774702072144,
-0.30194297432899475,
-0.15850916504859924,
0.48182302713394165,
0.1941475123167038,
0.12799078226089478,
0.6345577836036682,
0.5658050775527954,
-0.6593432426452637,
0.6846147775650024,
-0.14060845971107483,
-0.15101192891597748,
-0.17014768719673157,
-0.6567782759666443,
-0.49888235330581665,
-0.44717517495155334,
-0.10432133823633194,
-0.5104808211326599,
0.2241591215133667,
1.029377818107605,
0.7146288156509399,
-0.8506682515144348,
-0.21859417855739594,
0.0748622938990593,
0.11185618489980698,
-0.4380008280277252,
-0.22482694685459137,
0.2919207215309143,
-0.4369801878929138,
-0.7591795921325684,
0.5757479667663574,
0.5544425845146179,
-0.1449524313211441,
-0.2613079845905304,
-0.3221453130245209,
-0.02701166644692421,
-0.07083088904619217,
0.6362408995628357,
0.12121464312076569,
-0.6497635841369629,
-0.14394396543502808,
0.24924024939537048,
-0.3924805521965027,
0.2919519543647766,
0.5855149626731873,
-0.5757007598876953,
0.42439544200897217,
0.5122894048690796,
1.2105467319488525,
0.09986745566129684,
-0.3046436309814453,
0.4818677008152008,
-0.3600534200668335,
0.19793225824832916,
0.36914411187171936,
0.37004753947257996,
0.5481085181236267,
-0.42225217819213867,
0.6361997127532959,
0.12060391157865524,
-0.5410823822021484,
-0.6384368538856506,
-0.011767411604523659,
-0.6966351866722107,
0.2780326008796692,
0.9011639952659607,
-0.04719729349017143,
-0.4516332447528839,
-0.14938585460186005,
-0.14866513013839722,
0.4169880747795105,
-0.06760210543870926,
0.7246946692466736,
0.5873245596885681,
-0.03977944701910019,
-0.03259123116731644,
-0.8565515875816345,
0.1901923418045044,
0.7379617691040039,
-0.8135446310043335,
-0.15125517547130585,
-0.017243893817067146,
0.09948446601629257,
0.311349481344223,
0.309426486492157,
-0.32776519656181335,
0.1700427532196045,
-0.24216605722904205,
0.02993728034198284,
-0.11076574772596359,
0.08502310514450073,
-0.5347974300384521,
-0.1313243955373764,
-0.09662597626447678,
-0.38902607560157776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01570v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01570v2
|
SERVAL: Synergy Learning between Vertical Models and LLMs towards Oracle-Level Zero-shot Medical Prediction
| 2024-03-03T17:35:52 | 2024-03-16T04:07:01 |
Jiahuan Yan, Jintai Chen, Chaowen Hu, Bo Zheng, Yaojun Hu, Jimeng Sun, Jian Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent development of large language models (LLMs) has exhibited impressive
zero-shot proficiency on generic and common sense questions. However, LLMs'
application on domain-specific vertical questions still lags behind, primarily
due to the humiliation problems and deficiencies in vertical knowledge.
Furthermore, the vertical data annotation process often requires
labor-intensive expert involvement, thereby presenting an additional challenge
in enhancing the model's vertical capabilities. In this paper, we propose
SERVAL, a synergy learning pipeline designed for unsupervised development of
vertical capabilities in both LLMs and small models by mutual enhancement.
Specifically, SERVAL utilizes the LLM's zero-shot outputs as annotations,
leveraging its confidence to teach a robust vertical model from scratch.
Reversely, the trained vertical model guides the LLM fine-tuning to enhance its
zero-shot capability, progressively improving both models through an iterative
process. In medical domain, known for complex vertical knowledge and costly
annotations, comprehensive experiments show that, without access to any gold
labels, SERVAL with the synergy learning of OpenAI GPT-3.5 and a simple model
attains fully-supervised competitive performance across ten widely used medical
datasets. These datasets represent vertically specialized medical diagnostic
scenarios (e.g., diabetes, heart diseases, COVID-19), highlighting the
potential of SERVAL in refining the vertical capabilities of LLMs and training
vertical models from scratch, all achieved without the need for annotations.
|
[
-0.06457418203353882,
-0.32309114933013916,
0.45564353466033936,
-0.5219311714172363,
-0.3812713623046875,
0.06503506004810333,
-0.03737156093120575,
-0.6658560633659363,
0.3071850538253784,
0.7875451445579529,
-0.747122585773468,
-0.8208937048912048,
-0.5938133597373962,
-0.08235375583171844,
0.13231733441352844,
1.4240155220031738,
0.15368732810020447,
0.28878992795944214,
-0.44689321517944336,
-0.4595648944377899,
-0.5915970206260681,
-0.541366457939148,
-0.4068832993507385,
-0.42567089200019836,
0.563215970993042,
0.6155824065208435,
0.3549671471118927,
0.33319222927093506,
0.4277304410934448,
0.19357915222644806,
0.10252071917057037,
0.11358128488063812,
-0.49557459354400635,
0.5457586050033569,
-0.11905837804079056,
-0.5971423387527466,
-0.43042615056037903,
-0.13362297415733337,
0.5358108282089233,
0.9040431976318359,
0.03310522064566612,
0.34346336126327515,
-0.19225607812404633,
0.5434300899505615,
-0.5099363327026367,
0.30245518684387207,
-0.6785656213760376,
0.3151475489139557,
-0.18320900201797485,
-0.13080960512161255,
0.008104052394628525,
0.10375385731458664,
0.4122893214225769,
-0.6119897365570068,
-0.04251425340771675,
-0.006446360144764185,
0.5673553347587585,
0.5832080245018005,
-0.46020960807800293,
0.31553375720977783,
-0.48748210072517395,
0.7384836077690125,
-0.4483104348182678,
0.1329747587442398,
0.014219366014003754,
0.7708262205123901,
-0.04319026321172714,
-0.8168330192565918,
-0.2814651131629944,
-0.11257360875606537,
0.09925184398889542,
0.37555184960365295,
0.10434924066066742,
0.2803956866264343,
0.14000049233436584,
0.43016722798347473,
-0.42405006289482117,
0.45429089665412903,
-0.5216770768165588,
-0.25563177466392517,
0.4734441041946411,
0.4473878741264343,
0.19673314690589905,
-0.14044752717018127,
-0.5186550617218018,
0.09334217011928558,
-0.6351043581962585,
0.21494640409946442,
-0.3384552001953125,
0.4652940332889557,
-0.06833941489458084,
0.5972973108291626,
-0.17090916633605957,
0.7306624054908752,
-0.07143937051296234,
-0.47294169664382935,
0.3901787996292114,
-0.2765067219734192,
-0.6570065021514893,
0.1716589778661728,
0.48715007305145264,
0.09907055646181107,
-0.22463476657867432,
-0.16751421988010406,
-0.0517306812107563,
0.30605247616767883,
0.15198203921318054,
-0.6513180136680603,
0.03822494298219681,
0.12732738256454468,
-0.2957434058189392,
-0.5165947675704956,
-0.3096143305301666,
-0.5301867127418518,
-0.8116171360015869,
-0.26592034101486206,
0.6729982495307922,
-0.11189871281385422,
0.06606640666723251,
0.24630111455917358,
0.031510692089796066,
0.07977350801229477,
0.34612712264060974,
-0.6470385789871216,
0.3630578815937042,
0.6397660970687866,
0.4682350754737854,
-0.05909603461623192,
-0.19237898290157318,
-1.0947635173797607,
0.163307785987854,
-0.13145796954631805,
0.628960132598877,
-0.5136012434959412,
-0.10873718559741974,
-0.20860600471496582,
0.07730821520090103,
0.19388073682785034,
-0.3807905316352844,
0.498405396938324,
-0.23270918428897858,
0.401122123003006,
-0.06901083141565323,
-0.4995397925376892,
-0.31807470321655273,
0.18949337303638458,
-0.4158208668231964,
0.5879573822021484,
0.23410458862781525,
-0.9262980222702026,
0.7347184419631958,
-0.3445325791835785,
-0.36567065119743347,
0.4440689980983734,
-0.7366740107536316,
-0.6501713991165161,
-0.017549607902765274,
0.3194330036640167,
0.5112937092781067,
-0.6408544182777405,
0.15864446759223938,
-0.463406503200531,
-0.15719670057296753,
-0.31295397877693176,
-0.03827165439724922,
0.7096078991889954,
-0.29649481177330017,
-0.261636346578598,
0.2565469741821289,
-0.9586191177368164,
-0.24141612648963928,
-0.015468964353203773,
0.35105961561203003,
-0.4518742859363556,
-0.4734191298484802,
-0.5780705809593201,
0.35647866129875183,
0.19912396371364594,
-0.4283067286014557,
0.34095656871795654,
-0.7814142107963562,
-0.15883417427539825,
0.5180261731147766,
0.35839009284973145,
0.4932258427143097,
-0.46228671073913574,
0.7821136713027954,
0.11719470471143723,
0.3150731921195984,
-0.13807904720306396,
-0.582319974899292,
-0.46232184767723083,
-0.4402102530002594,
0.2713130712509155,
0.480502188205719,
-1.0164101123809814,
0.15393491089344025,
0.14043402671813965,
-0.5534834265708923,
-0.8116994500160217,
0.20130294561386108,
0.4222712516784668,
1.1892666816711426,
0.43312397599220276,
-0.5981840491294861,
-0.7243186831474304,
-0.8070741891860962,
-0.07669520378112793,
-0.14116381108760834,
0.10504691302776337,
0.4821954071521759,
0.35817980766296387,
-0.2719395160675049,
0.3940635323524475,
-0.2621868848800659,
-0.7031263709068298,
-0.2180059552192688,
0.36427032947540283,
0.4145826995372772,
0.16762720048427582,
0.461990088224411,
-0.4805428385734558,
-0.2800772190093994,
0.12021534889936447,
-1.0025913715362549,
-0.21896743774414062,
0.1143212765455246,
-0.05886460468173027,
0.19102412462234497,
0.17443004250526428,
-0.035240523517131805,
0.6689011454582214,
0.707649827003479,
-0.19498023390769958,
0.6054470539093018,
-0.4338259994983673,
-0.12234251946210861,
-1.2672754526138306,
0.012891625054180622,
0.12915927171707153,
-0.09154589474201202,
-0.5772464275360107,
-0.19185414910316467,
-0.31502434611320496,
-0.1901806890964508,
-0.4612107574939728,
0.5522375106811523,
-0.3882862329483032,
-0.3897116780281067,
-0.17156383395195007,
-0.09248314797878265,
-0.07867860794067383,
0.28728604316711426,
0.1346556544303894,
0.5760875940322876,
0.9623560905456543,
-0.33947429060935974,
0.4342712461948395,
0.130130797624588,
-0.08698830753564835,
0.5072042942047119,
-0.6217828989028931,
-0.34707406163215637,
-0.07033690065145493,
0.19056947529315948,
-0.7428974509239197,
-0.2566894590854645,
0.17793580889701843,
-0.48111599683761597,
0.15786013007164001,
-0.2782890200614929,
-0.3565320372581482,
-0.36732590198516846,
-0.1216508150100708,
0.25474080443382263,
0.7286299467086792,
-0.4882582128047943,
0.47853800654411316,
0.691611647605896,
0.015338657423853874,
-0.8555205464363098,
-0.6929361820220947,
-0.17884255945682526,
-0.03699149191379547,
-0.6761733293533325,
0.22837921977043152,
0.3533552587032318,
0.012120412662625313,
0.04443098232150078,
-0.2773367762565613,
-0.05069069191813469,
0.03688307851552963,
0.6634458303451538,
0.6777412295341492,
-0.15662813186645508,
0.47071269154548645,
-0.002762913005426526,
-0.40237629413604736,
-0.192449152469635,
-0.7580877542495728,
-0.042405325919389725,
-0.24483522772789001,
-0.413192480802536,
-0.40287137031555176,
-0.08654283732175827,
0.7127302885055542,
-0.26565754413604736,
0.8687303066253662,
0.607464075088501,
-0.47543713450431824,
-0.18346887826919556,
-0.42642742395401,
-0.39435893297195435,
-0.33391690254211426,
0.07537446171045303,
-0.18215784430503845,
-1.121848702430725,
0.5994465947151184,
-0.15728573501110077,
-0.14572933316230774,
0.5684617757797241,
0.6606932878494263,
0.017761602997779846,
0.876783549785614,
0.8573157787322998,
-0.07678361237049103,
0.05808059126138687,
-0.34180331230163574,
-0.014824585057795048,
-0.6593620181083679,
-0.49108344316482544,
-0.15787827968597412,
-0.23438334465026855,
-0.7117904424667358,
-0.4524739980697632,
1.1116498708724976,
-0.183155819773674,
-0.27395397424697876,
0.026439504697918892,
-0.5185855031013489,
0.15826579928398132,
0.45045116543769836,
0.13363997638225555,
0.3813159465789795,
0.10660577565431595,
-0.6409593820571899,
-0.25933048129081726,
-0.8441373109817505,
0.13511526584625244,
1.1696248054504395,
0.2595520615577698,
0.7169605493545532,
-0.33825790882110596,
0.9430291652679443,
-0.04672202467918396,
0.07114619016647339,
-0.6647894382476807,
0.3494461476802826,
-0.3755485415458679,
-0.3687806725502014,
-0.25690507888793945,
-0.3690667748451233,
-0.9611304998397827,
0.07075891643762589,
-0.6507620811462402,
-0.6099359393119812,
0.08623471856117249,
-0.03771001473069191,
-0.7725399732589722,
0.37374985218048096,
-0.364820271730423,
0.9929724335670471,
-0.36131229996681213,
-0.8126038312911987,
-0.04029406979680061,
-0.9785069227218628,
0.40064606070518494,
-0.01827199198305607,
-0.04631498083472252,
-0.017946504056453705,
-0.2374781221151352,
0.34873318672180176,
-0.6839349865913391,
1.109103798866272,
-0.24925513565540314,
0.06637950986623764,
0.18552638590335846,
-0.047016389667987823,
0.14447836577892303,
0.32933369278907776,
0.12009444832801819,
0.07385971397161484,
-0.05799908563494682,
-0.5154240727424622,
-0.6026753783226013,
0.5167735815048218,
-0.828917920589447,
-0.43211039900779724,
-0.6761433482170105,
-0.522116482257843,
-0.5034473538398743,
0.17111580073833466,
0.037810202687978745,
0.417167603969574,
0.17365847527980804,
0.15337851643562317,
0.4783976674079895,
-0.32825374603271484,
-0.10941870510578156,
0.5185297727584839,
-0.16751855611801147,
-0.5046262145042419,
0.7435444593429565,
0.1168496310710907,
0.06716931611299515,
0.2390216737985611,
0.148928701877594,
-0.22502723336219788,
-0.2658284604549408,
-0.28258541226387024,
0.2716662585735321,
-0.43129250407218933,
-0.46495649218559265,
-0.405890554189682,
-0.5154246091842651,
-0.24091258645057678,
-0.1697157621383667,
-0.30860504508018494,
-0.40138235688209534,
-0.15412287414073944,
0.043282438069581985,
0.4459654688835144,
0.5259436368942261,
-0.16067427396774292,
-0.06744470447301865,
-0.7731044888496399,
0.28060123324394226,
0.49628710746765137,
0.3736605644226074,
-0.18988776206970215,
-0.5885313749313354,
-0.18745584785938263,
-0.11962375044822693,
0.025853179395198822,
-0.5685427784919739,
0.46696582436561584,
-0.10206432640552521,
0.5519707202911377,
0.3025585412979126,
-0.0025612055324018,
0.7324577569961548,
-0.11361681669950485,
0.7238357067108154,
0.48068860173225403,
-0.5804129242897034,
0.6874088048934937,
-0.2555505335330963,
0.12290187925100327,
0.640920102596283,
0.42358726263046265,
-0.4243091940879822,
-0.11761368066072464,
-0.7453641295433044,
-0.5894060134887695,
0.5771710276603699,
-0.17173726856708527,
-0.6483420133590698,
0.4320255517959595,
0.33349284529685974,
0.6202965974807739,
0.29966500401496887,
-0.4639461040496826,
-0.028879133984446526,
0.17753133177757263,
-0.04637249931693077,
-0.0573371946811676,
0.19718202948570251,
-0.20695070922374725,
-0.6396217346191406,
0.6456962823867798,
-0.26067879796028137,
-0.07465588301420212,
0.09528005868196487,
0.0714697614312172,
-0.2913218140602112,
0.049934159964323044,
0.18673714995384216,
0.3077284097671509,
-0.18222063779830933,
-0.06842847168445587,
0.41206493973731995,
-0.10499822348356247,
0.09830493479967117,
0.21516188979148865,
-0.009639215655624866,
-0.166105717420578,
0.3423270881175995,
0.9539236426353455,
0.3264204263687134,
-0.7103270292282104,
0.6966201066970825,
-0.1097279042005539,
-0.30940064787864685,
-0.2783266603946686,
0.0032856501638889313,
-0.2095233052968979,
0.5515610575675964,
0.061542291194200516,
0.18448421359062195,
0.0789896547794342,
-0.5134114623069763,
0.40543800592422485,
0.36642152070999146,
-0.6637964248657227,
-0.2610544264316559,
0.7376177906990051,
0.21571512520313263,
0.40490153431892395,
0.3327823579311371,
-0.17720383405685425,
-0.30789685249328613,
0.6322385668754578,
0.3105599284172058,
0.6663038730621338,
0.06997878104448318,
0.2181960642337799,
0.30362629890441895,
-0.029702480882406235,
0.09546329826116562,
0.21046413481235504,
-0.11511372774839401,
-0.39378148317337036,
-0.7495567798614502,
-0.5116297602653503,
-0.532776951789856,
0.25949010252952576,
-0.575465738773346,
0.6322904229164124,
-0.40499502420425415,
0.020708026364445686,
0.10615336149930954,
0.510987401008606,
-0.7205121517181396,
0.2836022675037384,
0.44357049465179443,
0.6760392785072327,
-1.001009464263916,
0.9780515432357788,
0.9240526556968689,
-0.8976680636405945,
-0.6660224199295044,
-0.06850431859493256,
0.15741868317127228,
-1.077728509902954,
0.8042401671409607,
0.08476049453020096,
0.04662320017814636,
-0.32503607869148254,
-0.4646516740322113,
-0.508009135723114,
1.4155529737472534,
0.3349997103214264,
-0.5608208179473877,
-0.14393733441829681,
0.002328562783077359,
0.9652203321456909,
-0.5908905267715454,
0.24969814717769623,
0.28236672282218933,
-0.007971661165356636,
0.4526740312576294,
-1.050471305847168,
0.007820132188498974,
0.0007737535634078085,
-0.04930698499083519,
0.028666291385889053,
-0.6792383193969727,
0.7355983853340149,
-0.5250369906425476,
0.06337190419435501,
0.07987425476312637,
0.5175882577896118,
0.3537558615207672,
0.6037928462028503,
0.3053480088710785,
0.8145818710327148,
0.7984996438026428,
0.19633848965168,
0.876066267490387,
-0.4741554856300354,
0.08846387267112732,
1.05219566822052,
-0.6341370940208435,
0.5760216116905212,
0.30893316864967346,
0.24781548976898193,
0.6293532848358154,
0.40980544686317444,
-0.050615426152944565,
0.5306740999221802,
0.027538541704416275,
-0.49377021193504333,
-0.40858227014541626,
-0.4412840008735657,
-0.5345637202262878,
0.5674453377723694,
0.5509611368179321,
-0.31514817476272583,
-0.41594696044921875,
0.2523520886898041,
-0.37402334809303284,
-0.010675846599042416,
-0.4913076162338257,
0.982591450214386,
0.18484380841255188,
-0.5802087187767029,
0.713989794254303,
-0.3830012083053589,
0.451795369386673,
-0.434180349111557,
-0.10490790754556656,
-0.17807190120220184,
0.2012212574481964,
-0.2253183126449585,
-0.544470489025116,
0.05867981165647507,
-0.2019730806350708,
-0.040570877492427826,
0.2063397467136383,
1.253395915031433,
-0.5332289934158325,
-0.30132216215133667,
0.5223410725593567,
0.7876502871513367,
-0.035942766815423965,
0.37871935963630676,
-0.6135534048080444,
-0.14298997819423676,
-0.24327430129051208,
0.45797815918922424,
0.4415651857852936,
0.6663472652435303,
-0.02558131143450737,
0.5540446639060974,
0.455126017332077,
0.5660932660102844,
-0.29234156012535095,
0.18387213349342346,
0.9913823008537292,
-0.42329466342926025,
-0.39246898889541626,
-0.5073426961898804,
0.43392282724380493,
-0.09856509417295456,
-0.018266798928380013,
0.4026559591293335,
0.24702301621437073,
0.8348689079284668,
0.12864802777767181,
1.0262593030929565,
0.3820362687110901,
0.6810089349746704,
-0.1580866277217865,
0.49282512068748474,
-0.8830477595329285,
0.36122775077819824,
0.025347081944346428,
-0.35698625445365906,
-0.6021305918693542,
0.2521086633205414,
-0.6379364728927612,
-0.14732731878757477,
0.5811907052993774,
0.5094227194786072,
-0.04109850898385048,
-0.055159423500299454,
0.6409538984298706,
0.2680750787258148,
-0.08103000372648239,
0.9651556015014648,
0.510604977607727,
-0.4177916646003723,
0.4137268662452698,
-0.3762041926383972,
-0.4810408055782318,
-0.36747121810913086,
-0.7313045859336853,
-1.1532927751541138,
-0.42635297775268555,
-0.17132322490215302,
-0.369987815618515,
0.44229042530059814,
1.0133637189865112,
0.8387852311134338,
-0.6264373064041138,
-0.030355947092175484,
-0.22671358287334442,
-0.10227972269058228,
-0.13352376222610474,
-0.06504450738430023,
0.1998528242111206,
-0.5898326635360718,
-0.20011523365974426,
0.20177945494651794,
0.7528283596038818,
-0.021738983690738678,
-0.3206443786621094,
-0.06917326897382736,
0.0391417071223259,
-0.317128449678421,
0.44968733191490173,
0.6204800605773926,
-0.49694445729255676,
-0.04624456912279129,
-0.15448449552059174,
-0.06996569782495499,
0.006997744087129831,
0.5222060680389404,
-1.3896510601043701,
0.8369212746620178,
0.4702165126800537,
1.0719417333602905,
0.48823612928390503,
-0.15641982853412628,
0.46512866020202637,
-0.8072397112846375,
0.4226556420326233,
0.4509999454021454,
0.18913404643535614,
0.17247451841831207,
-0.2982749044895172,
0.47985780239105225,
0.5696778893470764,
-0.6185606122016907,
-0.7161615490913391,
0.041164837777614594,
-0.7308759093284607,
-0.0963037982583046,
0.7972992658615112,
0.043796394020318985,
-0.44064614176750183,
0.12855875492095947,
-0.168526753783226,
0.5428422689437866,
-0.19229236245155334,
0.821679413318634,
0.16701631247997284,
-0.33230674266815186,
-0.110477976500988,
-0.6668446660041809,
0.5967856645584106,
0.8771016597747803,
-0.783061146736145,
-0.36666494607925415,
0.35440680384635925,
0.03452577441930771,
-0.10454297065734863,
0.40101557970046997,
-0.2722058892250061,
0.511523962020874,
-0.04766582325100899,
0.12457136809825897,
-0.1901245415210724,
-0.567023515701294,
-0.5259034633636475,
0.09236650168895721,
0.03273550793528557,
-0.29809898138046265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01548v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01548v3
|
In-Context Sharpness as Alerts: An Inner Representation Perspective for Hallucination Mitigation
| 2024-03-03T15:53:41 | 2024-03-12T09:49:28 |
Shiqi Chen, Miao Xiong, Junteng Liu, Zhengxuan Wu, Teng Xiao, Siyang Gao, Junxian He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) frequently hallucinate and produce factual
errors, yet our understanding of why they make these errors remains limited. In
this study, we delve into the underlying mechanisms of LLM hallucinations from
the perspective of inner representations, and discover a salient pattern
associated with hallucinations: correct generations tend to have sharper
context activations in the hidden states of the in-context tokens, compared to
the incorrect ones. Leveraging this insight, we propose an entropy-based metric
to quantify the ``sharpness'' among the in-context hidden states and
incorporate it into the decoding process to formulate a constrained decoding
approach. Experiments on various knowledge-seeking and hallucination benchmarks
demonstrate our approach's consistent effectiveness, for example, achieving up
to an 8.6 point improvement on TruthfulQA. We believe this study can improve
our understanding of hallucinations and serve as a practical solution for
hallucination mitigation.
|
[
-0.14240652322769165,
-0.5652201175689697,
0.7870283722877502,
0.07733792811632156,
-0.4191363453865051,
-0.20707201957702637,
-0.3654162883758545,
-0.5020050406455994,
0.3235383629798889,
0.34095534682273865,
-0.5523156523704529,
-0.4758218824863434,
-0.5090135335922241,
0.2319236695766449,
-0.26381903886795044,
0.4871406853199005,
0.14184632897377014,
0.22475770115852356,
-0.294018417596817,
0.05114724487066269,
-0.7954631447792053,
-0.7380664944648743,
-0.3433593809604645,
-0.27569299936294556,
0.2024277299642563,
0.409007728099823,
0.5488461852073669,
0.3162674605846405,
0.6944679021835327,
0.13986395299434662,
-0.0482478030025959,
0.24853934347629547,
-0.7241018414497375,
0.4422798454761505,
0.06131188943982124,
-0.4252455532550812,
-0.013210773468017578,
-0.2556248605251312,
0.60242760181427,
0.7864303588867188,
0.10459310561418533,
-0.18439292907714844,
0.30365487933158875,
0.6863016486167908,
-0.7647484540939331,
0.06951674073934555,
-0.9831077456474304,
0.36282095313072205,
0.06936769932508469,
-0.6642235517501831,
-0.44980528950691223,
-0.2581199109554291,
0.05810146778821945,
-0.25694769620895386,
0.21906675398349762,
0.06500595808029175,
0.6210748553276062,
0.7794720530509949,
-0.13924409449100494,
-0.4957582354545593,
-0.5509155988693237,
0.6499496102333069,
-0.6216853857040405,
0.6227416396141052,
0.5680680871009827,
-0.02064328081905842,
-0.15289127826690674,
-0.43235334753990173,
-0.2512987554073334,
-0.25192418694496155,
-0.1548275649547577,
-0.19172696769237518,
-0.10004357248544693,
0.1800728291273117,
0.347411572933197,
0.40108516812324524,
-0.33093008399009705,
-0.0664171352982521,
-0.2994725704193115,
-0.4869917333126068,
0.44413068890571594,
0.2664622962474823,
0.13347935676574707,
-0.13520336151123047,
-0.28466302156448364,
-0.06269397586584091,
-0.6155401468276978,
-0.25561174750328064,
0.1294529289007187,
0.3241713345050812,
0.1751960963010788,
0.43157726526260376,
-0.10251586139202118,
0.22598490118980408,
0.10310430824756622,
-0.15393199026584625,
0.13398829102516174,
-0.22504115104675293,
-0.2805388271808624,
0.49474242329597473,
0.230229452252388,
0.5841303467750549,
0.10482680797576904,
-0.5365062952041626,
-0.5320721864700317,
0.02162593975663185,
0.48694896697998047,
-0.806717574596405,
-0.2297625094652176,
0.19611836969852448,
-0.5304029583930969,
-0.1581074297428131,
0.21263869106769562,
-0.6925637125968933,
-0.8438453078269958,
-0.31315454840660095,
0.5851098299026489,
-0.6104534864425659,
-0.12089452892541885,
0.2454753965139389,
-0.21966275572776794,
0.45838722586631775,
0.054275836795568466,
-0.8778368830680847,
0.20080173015594482,
0.5605039596557617,
0.8925614356994629,
-0.07412716001272202,
-0.1300024688243866,
-0.22844363749027252,
0.05171918869018555,
-0.5547008514404297,
0.6849408745765686,
-0.4580537676811218,
-0.30380484461784363,
0.1338167041540146,
-0.19649843871593475,
-0.012394333258271217,
-0.7803028225898743,
0.6005645990371704,
-0.29736068844795227,
-0.2483709305524826,
-0.5438024997711182,
-0.5691364407539368,
-0.45903006196022034,
-0.002180123934522271,
-0.5066795945167542,
0.9338242411613464,
0.019661562517285347,
-0.5546091794967651,
0.6679922938346863,
-0.4197525382041931,
-0.2616526186466217,
0.29574093222618103,
-0.24754968285560608,
-0.2154717892408371,
0.7789539098739624,
0.2411353439092636,
0.5144094228744507,
-0.048083432018756866,
0.2901689410209656,
-0.13348843157291412,
-0.7959478497505188,
0.4333183765411377,
-0.5789780616760254,
0.46352240443229675,
0.17632879316806793,
-0.5906981229782104,
0.19921009242534637,
-0.6222681999206543,
-0.11617051064968109,
0.03536442294716835,
-0.1348372846841812,
-0.4763403832912445,
0.002090663183480501,
-0.2188234180212021,
-0.08196906000375748,
0.05474420264363289,
-0.11785273253917694,
0.0901656225323677,
-0.5252255797386169,
0.26290959119796753,
0.7969107627868652,
0.25086477398872375,
0.37927570939064026,
-0.31122535467147827,
-0.024936586618423462,
0.2649381756782532,
0.3211715519428253,
0.06982015818357468,
-0.24981875717639923,
-0.8830285668373108,
-0.1364269256591797,
-0.2623295783996582,
0.38032588362693787,
-0.42366644740104675,
0.5972596406936646,
-0.2942964434623718,
0.051405370235443115,
-0.5944531559944153,
-0.0905902162194252,
0.3167911171913147,
0.3803625702857971,
0.3048330247402191,
-0.30514198541641235,
-0.7032099962234497,
-0.7886390686035156,
-0.22995635867118835,
0.03845062851905823,
0.06771167367696762,
-0.024905411526560783,
0.5764537453651428,
-0.6211193799972534,
0.6497688293457031,
-0.17059208452701569,
-0.3445439040660858,
-0.03197214752435684,
-0.14184202253818512,
-0.03281058371067047,
0.4408438205718994,
0.13841645419597626,
-0.7292661666870117,
0.039005618542432785,
-0.17163750529289246,
-1.0030323266983032,
0.007803119253367186,
-0.31055155396461487,
-0.004044090863317251,
0.3564223349094391,
0.931681215763092,
-0.2832256853580475,
0.6186533570289612,
0.04978417232632637,
-0.5121640563011169,
0.5403904318809509,
-0.06908504664897919,
0.077201247215271,
-0.7246628999710083,
-0.06373400241136551,
-0.27656182646751404,
0.16016997396945953,
-0.6717572808265686,
0.17717204988002777,
0.0744670107960701,
0.13024133443832397,
-0.24994774162769318,
0.3789164423942566,
-0.46711525321006775,
0.015535210259258747,
-0.1599765568971634,
0.12895949184894562,
-0.08403609693050385,
0.5650517344474792,
-0.28936007618904114,
0.9084648489952087,
0.5197628140449524,
-0.6127723455429077,
0.08303175866603851,
-0.11614347249269485,
-0.5667631030082703,
0.5403056740760803,
-0.20912818610668182,
0.22599445283412933,
-0.453946590423584,
-0.13444304466247559,
-0.7359805703163147,
-0.4876217246055603,
0.2948775291442871,
-0.31164976954460144,
0.28178367018699646,
0.1619398146867752,
-0.575430691242218,
-0.07180070877075195,
-0.4466588795185089,
0.5614829659461975,
0.48745959997177124,
-0.6574662923812866,
0.4064618647098541,
0.2481638491153717,
0.42194169759750366,
-0.535321831703186,
-0.7592659592628479,
0.3444348871707916,
-0.46172189712524414,
-0.5406044125556946,
0.4611262381076813,
-0.3509308993816376,
-0.7405090928077698,
-0.19643689692020416,
-0.32789352536201477,
0.18055394291877747,
0.19754765927791595,
0.3961794674396515,
-0.10744534432888031,
-0.0188312828540802,
0.3581114113330841,
-0.12025412172079086,
0.10758937150239944,
0.420219749212265,
-0.387129545211792,
0.7557744383811951,
-0.15839649736881256,
-0.27297699451446533,
-0.6826880574226379,
0.40569445490837097,
0.6436282396316528,
0.22169843316078186,
0.7182237505912781,
0.2306642234325409,
-0.7164525985717773,
-0.34537968039512634,
-0.6765828132629395,
-0.7264311909675598,
-0.4528093636035919,
0.22659598290920258,
-0.6413372755050659,
-0.6444459557533264,
0.8675644993782043,
0.0032274785917252302,
-0.3392852246761322,
0.3227722644805908,
0.4460943043231964,
0.05820838734507561,
0.9719444513320923,
0.7773979902267456,
0.16540062427520752,
0.3886672854423523,
-0.27113261818885803,
0.49114617705345154,
-0.8842411041259766,
-0.7527223229408264,
-0.3166497051715851,
-0.06454314291477203,
-0.3244498670101166,
-0.26721814274787903,
0.4393016993999481,
0.2419406920671463,
-0.18310534954071045,
-0.2278861105442047,
-0.7693651914596558,
0.7029841542243958,
0.5173121690750122,
0.3790796399116516,
0.09796910732984543,
0.20045889914035797,
-0.22185422480106354,
-0.19629833102226257,
-0.6604470014572144,
-0.47089532017707825,
0.7469052672386169,
0.33752748370170593,
0.6732727289199829,
0.014853747561573982,
0.7545937299728394,
0.2418687343597412,
-0.19002284109592438,
-1.0700693130493164,
0.5386909246444702,
0.256309449672699,
-0.36030131578445435,
-0.34279078245162964,
-0.35020941495895386,
-0.6203809976577759,
0.20243939757347107,
-0.1305500715970993,
-0.8752471208572388,
0.4612734615802765,
-0.14125342667102814,
-0.4192066788673401,
0.38885498046875,
-0.5227252840995789,
0.5607189536094666,
-0.015796512365341187,
-0.26478150486946106,
-0.08248887956142426,
-0.6539303064346313,
0.36299386620521545,
-0.0076209488324820995,
0.1272161453962326,
-0.14487607777118683,
0.1500852406024933,
0.686812698841095,
-0.17037861049175262,
1.0298728942871094,
-0.057516712695360184,
-0.3761029541492462,
0.11304416507482529,
0.15087173879146576,
0.5351368188858032,
0.06291279941797256,
-0.11762476712465286,
0.2238488644361496,
-0.266488641500473,
-0.2628755569458008,
-0.545674741268158,
0.5723569989204407,
-0.6707747578620911,
-0.681834876537323,
-0.3556446135044098,
-0.7598608732223511,
-0.11910779029130936,
-0.0003318307572044432,
0.6072067618370056,
0.5254647731781006,
-0.1271345317363739,
0.15799881517887115,
1.0661218166351318,
0.022519517689943314,
0.4543920159339905,
-0.18567965924739838,
-0.0012351529439911246,
-0.3368986248970032,
0.7468777894973755,
0.1205706000328064,
0.0024793504271656275,
0.31287050247192383,
0.07875185459852219,
-0.2795822322368622,
-0.7998654246330261,
0.0017542669083923101,
0.21772482991218567,
-1.3922960758209229,
-0.28669241070747375,
-0.5477400422096252,
-0.30244970321655273,
-0.546352744102478,
-0.37919482588768005,
0.0035032087471336126,
-0.011770287528634071,
-0.571221649646759,
-0.12735848128795624,
0.27467411756515503,
0.7484492659568787,
-0.14071045815944672,
0.14337782561779022,
-0.28574448823928833,
0.15694215893745422,
0.2965773642063141,
0.461271196603775,
0.15247370302677155,
-0.6459563970565796,
-0.37319085001945496,
-0.054428521543741226,
0.08494756370782852,
-0.8586120009422302,
0.4137161374092102,
0.02765338495373726,
0.5276814699172974,
0.7001385688781738,
0.33722907304763794,
0.8347798585891724,
-0.14761222898960114,
0.8234816789627075,
0.07107920944690704,
-1.130668044090271,
0.48304128646850586,
0.14856071770191193,
0.3490915596485138,
0.7585505247116089,
0.1062166839838028,
-0.5279101729393005,
-0.6002646088600159,
-0.2909933030605316,
-0.771719753742218,
0.3602718710899353,
0.045465726405382156,
0.2134486883878708,
-0.04622162505984306,
0.5035943388938904,
0.282624214887619,
-0.02512405253946781,
-0.8874863386154175,
0.0032276499550789595,
-0.2594345510005951,
-0.12236004322767258,
0.11273542791604996,
-0.7253586053848267,
-0.3632180392742157,
-0.41188517212867737,
0.4683329463005066,
-0.16404083371162415,
0.4806777536869049,
0.4779610335826874,
-0.39661917090415955,
-0.24093087017536163,
0.015501168556511402,
0.8746647834777832,
0.6683811545372009,
-0.4507017135620117,
0.6990991234779358,
0.31565436720848083,
-0.6621795296669006,
-0.0927199050784111,
-0.36989206075668335,
-0.08619064837694168,
0.008760708384215832,
0.5111659169197083,
0.9023173451423645,
0.20471183955669403,
-0.5638247728347778,
0.3445633351802826,
-0.0034928619861602783,
-0.04230862110853195,
-0.36482495069503784,
0.06733886152505875,
-0.590103805065155,
0.4348173141479492,
0.7539191246032715,
0.06481597572565079,
0.3607223927974701,
-0.7134848833084106,
0.13962428271770477,
0.6133204102516174,
-0.6242107152938843,
-0.2037862241268158,
0.5417195558547974,
-0.09824200719594955,
-0.20435605943202972,
0.8268475532531738,
-0.34718218445777893,
-0.6906852126121521,
0.3838192820549011,
0.6511059403419495,
1.3162786960601807,
-0.001499525154940784,
-0.20408271253108978,
0.32058319449424744,
0.5859885215759277,
-0.02891811542212963,
0.36256715655326843,
-0.055728234350681305,
-0.7288507223129272,
-0.14314678311347961,
-0.6735566258430481,
0.02207368239760399,
0.1643848568201065,
-0.555354118347168,
0.1425998955965042,
-0.2958572804927826,
-0.05988691374659538,
-0.37024450302124023,
-0.08922932296991348,
-0.485806941986084,
0.05911258980631828,
0.34841030836105347,
0.6423003077507019,
-0.5304251909255981,
0.7057040333747864,
0.08910276740789413,
-0.320080041885376,
-0.6026736497879028,
0.6750574707984924,
-0.053345926105976105,
-0.7916337251663208,
0.49058786034584045,
0.5478426814079285,
-0.45954641699790955,
-0.13312144577503204,
-0.716863214969635,
-0.8460012674331665,
0.9024168848991394,
0.2766972482204437,
-0.41468700766563416,
-0.005455183330923319,
0.0743575245141983,
0.2745327353477478,
-0.36826109886169434,
-0.256281316280365,
0.7541379928588867,
0.4961535930633545,
0.08983181416988373,
-0.5524206161499023,
0.48293212056159973,
-0.12669222056865692,
0.0614476203918457,
0.1605406552553177,
-0.26902085542678833,
0.5969210267066956,
-0.44730299711227417,
-0.6763613820075989,
-0.18690502643585205,
0.5028278231620789,
0.07550935447216034,
0.42541101574897766,
0.22711777687072754,
0.4111478626728058,
1.0268328189849854,
-0.07317503541707993,
0.9316837191581726,
-0.4784103035926819,
0.03809588775038719,
0.6831125020980835,
-0.048478271812200546,
0.4292975068092346,
0.8863241076469421,
0.3695368766784668,
0.2880100905895233,
0.603206217288971,
0.045238494873046875,
0.948844850063324,
0.28382381796836853,
-0.37772172689437866,
-0.11568086594343185,
-0.2656551003456116,
-0.3709556460380554,
0.21890166401863098,
0.6581164598464966,
-0.29520708322525024,
0.24602606892585754,
0.34017857909202576,
0.12890906631946564,
-0.03773591294884682,
-0.46251294016838074,
0.9973534345626831,
0.21990080177783966,
-0.6076033711433411,
1.0678023099899292,
-0.21529032289981842,
0.8062129020690918,
-0.18880631029605865,
-0.05435489863157272,
-0.5271180272102356,
0.051285333931446075,
-0.23400337994098663,
-0.5418742895126343,
0.4790455400943756,
-0.3433084487915039,
-0.2840202748775482,
-0.12246166914701462,
0.6712139248847961,
-0.19731388986110687,
-0.2999488413333893,
0.3871608078479767,
0.15915369987487793,
0.4555825889110565,
-0.34189173579216003,
-0.1587039977312088,
0.5368310213088989,
0.007876568473875523,
0.13358502089977264,
-0.0013450373662635684,
0.728033185005188,
-0.10074679553508759,
0.47858351469039917,
0.25391045212745667,
-0.10821904987096786,
0.235245481133461,
0.2469182312488556,
0.8414905667304993,
-0.7664970755577087,
-0.2534889876842499,
-1.0541974306106567,
0.24845562875270844,
0.03724333271384239,
-0.30151239037513733,
0.7288565039634705,
0.3762281537055969,
0.906356692314148,
-0.12074272334575653,
0.5025591850280762,
0.2566688060760498,
-0.16063937544822693,
-0.7778380513191223,
0.8212235569953918,
-0.6817011833190918,
0.4073304831981659,
-0.11224991083145142,
-1.0001051425933838,
-0.7852463722229004,
0.7252592444419861,
-0.107020802795887,
-0.23135904967784882,
0.8650218844413757,
1.0782334804534912,
0.19869683682918549,
-0.010669117793440819,
0.6637099981307983,
0.23682942986488342,
-0.07011417299509048,
0.5315884351730347,
1.0375573635101318,
-0.2315441220998764,
0.2881385385990143,
-0.35445573925971985,
-0.03247418254613876,
-0.7073870301246643,
-0.5898756980895996,
-0.9905926585197449,
-1.0113446712493896,
-0.13193300366401672,
-0.35194557905197144,
0.19826006889343262,
0.9621639847755432,
0.6190515160560608,
-0.6717233657836914,
-0.09813952445983887,
-0.24302689731121063,
0.12133803218603134,
-0.3544631004333496,
-0.20936237275600433,
0.4676477015018463,
-0.7581464052200317,
-0.35091784596443176,
0.5170828104019165,
0.42641445994377136,
0.33329126238822937,
-0.3704489767551422,
-0.11419221013784409,
0.33970025181770325,
0.3867982029914856,
0.8042170405387878,
-0.21098914742469788,
-1.036936640739441,
-0.47680121660232544,
0.060017477720975876,
-0.24518656730651855,
0.30116134881973267,
0.932654082775116,
-0.6868544816970825,
0.47542956471443176,
0.3299976885318756,
0.26941797137260437,
0.08919308334589005,
-0.44990846514701843,
0.24018064141273499,
-0.765791118144989,
0.3132020831108093,
0.494686096906662,
0.27150386571884155,
0.4751463234424591,
-0.7601056098937988,
0.39902618527412415,
0.1533624678850174,
-0.3960040509700775,
-1.1711593866348267,
0.16010507941246033,
-0.7365023493766785,
-0.6629606485366821,
1.0948987007141113,
0.4371020495891571,
-0.21996621787548065,
-0.23001380264759064,
-0.20946314930915833,
0.31586089730262756,
-0.2708280086517334,
1.2523250579833984,
0.6238408088684082,
-0.009578036144375801,
-0.15774448215961456,
-0.4929850697517395,
0.9296125173568726,
0.40480634570121765,
-0.5943175554275513,
0.2936866283416748,
0.5643860101699829,
-0.24986013770103455,
0.19526073336601257,
0.3254478871822357,
0.04124340042471886,
0.01641983352601528,
0.25075027346611023,
0.13823118805885315,
0.3070339262485504,
-0.7913060188293457,
-0.6889835596084595,
0.33444347977638245,
0.06778658181428909,
0.08330750465393066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01528v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01528v2
|
Leveraging Biomolecule and Natural Language through Multi-Modal Learning: A Survey
| 2024-03-03T14:59:47 | 2024-03-05T11:12:47 |
Qizhi Pei, Lijun Wu, Kaiyuan Gao, Jinhua Zhu, Yue Wang, Zun Wang, Tao Qin, Rui Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.BM
|
The integration of biomolecular modeling with natural language (BL) has
emerged as a promising interdisciplinary area at the intersection of artificial
intelligence, chemistry and biology. This approach leverages the rich,
multifaceted descriptions of biomolecules contained within textual data sources
to enhance our fundamental understanding and enable downstream computational
tasks such as biomolecule property prediction. The fusion of the nuanced
narratives expressed through natural language with the structural and
functional specifics of biomolecules described via various molecular modeling
techniques opens new avenues for comprehensively representing and analyzing
biomolecules. By incorporating the contextual language data that surrounds
biomolecules into their modeling, BL aims to capture a holistic view
encompassing both the symbolic qualities conveyed through language as well as
quantitative structural characteristics. In this review, we provide an
extensive analysis of recent advancements achieved through cross modeling of
biomolecules and natural language. (1) We begin by outlining the technical
representations of biomolecules employed, including sequences, 2D graphs, and
3D structures. (2) We then examine in depth the rationale and key objectives
underlying effective multi-modal integration of language and molecular data
sources. (3) We subsequently survey the practical applications enabled to date
in this developing research area. (4) We also compile and summarize the
available resources and datasets to facilitate future work. (5) Looking ahead,
we identify several promising research directions worthy of further exploration
and investment to continue advancing the field. The related resources and
contents are updating in
\url{https://github.com/QizhiPei/Awesome-Biomolecule-Language-Cross-Modeling}.
|
[
-0.2009100615978241,
-1.0760966539382935,
0.3977701663970947,
-0.0879446417093277,
0.021008852869272232,
0.5060365200042725,
-0.24001608788967133,
-0.9192418456077576,
0.09168827533721924,
0.13616998493671417,
-0.2667973041534424,
-0.23770023882389069,
-0.49631282687187195,
0.29296445846557617,
-0.07154112309217453,
0.9390594363212585,
0.20474565029144287,
0.4617786109447479,
-0.36346736550331116,
-0.2640472948551178,
-0.2503991425037384,
-0.508704662322998,
-0.11013396084308624,
-0.30101677775382996,
0.6132375001907349,
-0.11239919811487198,
0.6258246898651123,
0.6418304443359375,
0.4716412425041199,
0.39444035291671753,
-0.21566955745220184,
0.09636320173740387,
-0.04830282926559448,
0.030264468863606453,
-0.35551154613494873,
-0.3776649534702301,
-0.5138020515441895,
0.19590012729167938,
0.7304030060768127,
1.3096694946289062,
0.2334388941526413,
0.02158404141664505,
0.1045568659901619,
0.7275794744491577,
-0.5187414884567261,
0.2728336453437805,
-0.20609155297279358,
0.0949031263589859,
-0.19865551590919495,
-0.08108260482549667,
-0.20461006462574005,
-0.20317116379737854,
0.4666459262371063,
-0.30157896876335144,
0.10527343302965164,
0.02609254978597164,
0.6281324028968811,
-0.016479898244142532,
-0.9340758323669434,
-0.48107731342315674,
-0.7403799295425415,
0.9056564569473267,
-0.6631381511688232,
0.9498664140701294,
0.23135539889335632,
0.48520365357398987,
-0.23000198602676392,
-0.5920533537864685,
-0.36716651916503906,
-0.8687018752098083,
-0.08714985102415085,
0.20207014679908752,
-0.022601459175348282,
0.30699360370635986,
-0.10997562110424042,
0.47637099027633667,
-0.7584540843963623,
-0.2775530219078064,
-0.654017984867096,
-0.20880545675754547,
0.47437795996665955,
-0.035585857927799225,
0.5478042364120483,
-0.35245150327682495,
-0.5198109745979309,
-0.0999424085021019,
-0.23698526620864868,
0.12111429125070572,
0.1565243899822235,
0.5248456597328186,
-0.22678999602794647,
0.761829137802124,
-0.08088626712560654,
0.8394178748130798,
-0.3395431339740753,
0.009048604406416416,
0.3027598559856415,
-1.0715124607086182,
-0.37336766719818115,
0.3275960683822632,
0.7516826391220093,
-0.02781197801232338,
-0.015098236501216888,
-0.08175361156463623,
0.059377625584602356,
-0.18476353585720062,
0.2003917247056961,
-0.4585338830947876,
-0.011017522774636745,
0.42871591448783875,
-0.577164351940155,
-0.15490278601646423,
0.14008478820323944,
-1.0882967710494995,
-0.24247333407402039,
-0.47331318259239197,
0.2733345925807953,
-0.6373441219329834,
-0.07355278730392456,
0.004820880480110645,
-0.19377560913562775,
0.06058499589562416,
0.17543677985668182,
-0.7975953221321106,
0.27407166361808777,
0.2731457054615021,
0.9198552370071411,
-0.11100472509860992,
-0.1177702322602272,
-0.3107041120529175,
0.5686804056167603,
-0.023162102326750755,
0.5114808082580566,
-0.6763268709182739,
-0.4182516932487488,
-0.21570071578025818,
-0.008215057663619518,
-0.010596265085041523,
-0.3751988112926483,
0.234966441988945,
-0.2592780292034149,
0.1396913230419159,
-0.23037026822566986,
-0.3455922305583954,
-0.5580759048461914,
0.16362576186656952,
-0.9475117921829224,
0.5939434766769409,
0.09609836339950562,
-0.3752508759498596,
0.23925550282001495,
-0.7585367560386658,
-0.611640214920044,
0.14532051980495453,
-0.21730811893939972,
-0.1761152744293213,
0.12357501685619354,
-0.13245823979377747,
0.3080350458621979,
-0.5377489924430847,
0.3981841504573822,
-0.4374517798423767,
0.29488030076026917,
0.6743968725204468,
-0.3316044807434082,
0.6041761040687561,
0.17743101716041565,
-0.016821863129734993,
0.09311366081237793,
-0.7556596398353577,
-0.12201327830553055,
-0.3984542787075043,
-0.4977022111415863,
-0.1056855171918869,
-0.2522980272769928,
0.25633177161216736,
0.30143529176712036,
0.43564480543136597,
-0.5296924710273743,
0.35839933156967163,
-0.3696315288543701,
0.5619210004806519,
0.5952630043029785,
0.0033992219250649214,
0.6871804594993591,
-0.3000277280807495,
0.26113733649253845,
0.018542716279625893,
0.07814390957355499,
-0.04350614175200462,
-0.5350094437599182,
-0.07860204577445984,
-0.3238454759120941,
0.3417319357395172,
0.4517744779586792,
-0.5103923678398132,
0.10715755075216293,
0.0834360271692276,
-0.48888099193573,
-0.4507438838481903,
0.34876272082328796,
0.31882888078689575,
0.5624376535415649,
0.8441256880760193,
-0.30572858452796936,
-0.5738086104393005,
-0.847993016242981,
-0.4022895395755768,
-0.3064664900302887,
0.09290189296007156,
0.3122704029083252,
0.5073809623718262,
-0.30140313506126404,
0.7984240651130676,
-0.2939811050891876,
-0.33371174335479736,
-0.581965982913971,
0.2630385756492615,
0.20372627675533295,
0.49598023295402527,
0.4658397436141968,
-0.9420491456985474,
-0.40922561287879944,
0.6004894971847534,
-0.8402329683303833,
0.17286993563175201,
0.0022830809466540813,
-0.004383189138025045,
0.19697189331054688,
0.14964041113853455,
-0.5820315480232239,
0.2247300148010254,
0.389199823141098,
-0.39270949363708496,
0.47928881645202637,
-0.29024064540863037,
0.25837185978889465,
-0.9586158990859985,
0.35409578680992126,
0.38871830701828003,
-0.09493730962276459,
-0.9001685976982117,
-0.21909479796886444,
0.010145985521376133,
-0.028532879427075386,
-0.5466151833534241,
0.621166467666626,
-0.7342109084129333,
-0.05977503955364227,
-0.03241467475891113,
-0.36712002754211426,
0.007963573560118675,
0.42110925912857056,
-0.09334456920623779,
0.4628627300262451,
0.5709806680679321,
-0.4648807942867279,
0.45377790927886963,
0.19093570113182068,
0.07159217447042465,
0.40145882964134216,
-0.6613381505012512,
-0.3887782096862793,
-0.15403419733047485,
0.19102147221565247,
-0.8831855654716492,
-0.30518221855163574,
0.6827656030654907,
-0.4054231345653534,
0.451193630695343,
-0.006297041196376085,
-0.22424504160881042,
-0.1775292605161667,
-0.37851482629776,
0.45918163657188416,
0.1679663360118866,
0.06479636579751968,
0.88392573595047,
0.48609459400177,
-0.09852144867181778,
-0.05637452378869057,
-0.9284645318984985,
0.05912400782108307,
0.07050946354866028,
-0.4135302007198334,
0.302264541387558,
-0.3153877556324005,
-0.02266407012939453,
0.03316301479935646,
-0.3556132912635803,
-0.3858011066913605,
-0.27665114402770996,
0.058514028787612915,
0.4148406982421875,
-0.18823468685150146,
0.3270905315876007,
0.0691189244389534,
0.08448224514722824,
0.021062538027763367,
-0.31110551953315735,
0.20276686549186707,
-0.34348905086517334,
-0.0928088128566742,
-0.3049269914627075,
0.459172785282135,
0.5954269170761108,
-0.4509613811969757,
0.6443648338317871,
0.44748470187187195,
-0.3363497853279114,
0.17234137654304504,
-0.09037509560585022,
-0.2387729436159134,
-0.4556165039539337,
0.4060407876968384,
-0.17378632724285126,
-0.5008676052093506,
0.12848205864429474,
-0.01903802715241909,
-0.3976599872112274,
0.006811090745031834,
0.4942823648452759,
-0.1857271045446396,
0.7586809396743774,
0.8877598643302917,
0.0837293490767479,
0.45548781752586365,
-0.1950557976961136,
0.43485647439956665,
-0.6794679760932922,
-0.6345329284667969,
-0.4852500855922699,
-0.347802072763443,
-0.5396920442581177,
-0.6727422475814819,
0.5666388273239136,
0.022131381556391716,
0.1595699042081833,
0.24945998191833496,
-0.2458493709564209,
0.13174259662628174,
0.23677116632461548,
0.17050296068191528,
0.2036713808774948,
-0.0692354068160057,
-0.4396120309829712,
0.16430145502090454,
-0.7228630185127258,
-0.4691088795661926,
0.9339260458946228,
0.3090313673019409,
0.6854979991912842,
0.13571828603744507,
0.17655690014362335,
0.19837413728237152,
0.07842408865690231,
-0.6395179033279419,
0.4053970277309418,
0.11029218137264252,
-0.5255865454673767,
-0.20066389441490173,
-0.5530507564544678,
-0.9075655341148376,
0.12407539784908295,
-0.3857239782810211,
-0.4502795934677124,
0.4404619038105011,
0.22665095329284668,
-0.10311052948236465,
0.32941919565200806,
-0.5596147179603577,
0.9954276084899902,
-0.7646468877792358,
-0.5634101629257202,
-0.26993265748023987,
-1.0393036603927612,
0.35679253935813904,
-0.023133616894483566,
0.4405282437801361,
0.02779635228216648,
-0.20401649177074432,
0.4438924491405487,
-0.1329185664653778,
0.8022480607032776,
0.20252725481987,
-0.07008951157331467,
0.21696969866752625,
0.062303368002176285,
-0.1687246561050415,
-0.06704672425985336,
-0.02100343257188797,
0.4144008457660675,
0.22394004464149475,
-0.5343488454818726,
-0.4190985858440399,
0.4421921968460083,
-0.4828452467918396,
-0.05346372723579407,
-0.6505928635597229,
-0.6296483278274536,
-0.2326006144285202,
0.3066188395023346,
-0.15489867329597473,
0.5865451693534851,
-0.0825575590133667,
0.17379562556743622,
0.4427095353603363,
-0.3971189260482788,
0.5290616154670715,
0.35908472537994385,
-0.15906386077404022,
-0.44077762961387634,
1.1539785861968994,
0.27468085289001465,
0.3662168085575104,
0.8328191637992859,
0.30177122354507446,
-0.3879333436489105,
-0.40640294551849365,
-0.17137692868709564,
0.36333993077278137,
-0.37982121109962463,
-0.21477515995502472,
-0.6659506559371948,
-0.07611081749200821,
-0.5416562557220459,
-0.19212539494037628,
-0.33653998374938965,
-0.4164023697376251,
0.026928892359137535,
-0.13025382161140442,
0.3277132511138916,
0.6452690958976746,
-0.2695932984352112,
-0.31056520342826843,
-1.1780409812927246,
0.6290870904922485,
0.10256009548902512,
0.31470078229904175,
0.07115675508975983,
0.18984372913837433,
-0.6331966519355774,
0.40710926055908203,
-0.30824172496795654,
-1.2219352722167969,
0.5055497288703918,
0.43578431010246277,
0.9048990607261658,
0.06680116057395935,
-0.5163549184799194,
0.25867143273353577,
-0.27283787727355957,
0.7013060450553894,
0.05237894505262375,
-0.7322307825088501,
0.713878870010376,
-0.25794515013694763,
0.5123096108436584,
0.364641934633255,
0.8250429034233093,
-0.5501870512962341,
-0.4482109844684601,
-0.2653783857822418,
-0.9243436455726624,
0.23687727749347687,
0.12474453449249268,
-0.2938973605632782,
0.07004414498806,
-0.07217081636190414,
0.3872348666191101,
0.44396474957466125,
-0.6732087135314941,
-0.2016410082578659,
-0.33537834882736206,
-0.3870655298233032,
0.055879853665828705,
0.04653344303369522,
-0.06350127607584,
-0.41502845287323,
0.4890316128730774,
-0.3118179738521576,
0.21559271216392517,
0.04759961739182472,
-0.5117290616035461,
0.12517333030700684,
0.31123483180999756,
0.5740988850593567,
0.4336964786052704,
-0.3399755358695984,
0.2233208268880844,
-0.14887015521526337,
-0.5433582663536072,
0.018870342522859573,
0.2681630551815033,
0.14663980901241302,
-0.13049177825450897,
0.5733617544174194,
0.4485052227973938,
0.3187721073627472,
-0.9061657786369324,
0.0173203032463789,
0.23227615654468536,
0.07398411631584167,
0.381590336561203,
-0.1787528246641159,
0.025084558874368668,
0.3853318393230438,
0.34199729561805725,
0.24455195665359497,
0.3498342037200928,
-0.8984642028808594,
0.1634995937347412,
0.5540388226509094,
-0.5331461429595947,
-0.7247896194458008,
0.7024786472320557,
0.3109678030014038,
0.15547147393226624,
0.31190311908721924,
0.19330719113349915,
-0.351286917924881,
0.35802924633026123,
0.47519680857658386,
0.7900605201721191,
-0.36992424726486206,
0.2160118669271469,
0.34449875354766846,
0.14724425971508026,
0.41375160217285156,
0.21559248864650726,
-0.3981667459011078,
-0.5592377781867981,
-0.009992722421884537,
-0.8563050627708435,
-0.1893388330936432,
-0.26022204756736755,
-0.19282488524913788,
0.11878323554992676,
-0.5293663740158081,
0.03237810358405113,
0.2512649595737457,
0.01849163882434368,
-0.4285050630569458,
-0.06206776201725006,
0.31868016719818115,
0.8013513088226318,
-0.9118901491165161,
0.8676737546920776,
1.0098141431808472,
-1.025541067123413,
-0.241171732544899,
-0.30073654651641846,
0.3673414885997772,
-0.20230767130851746,
0.9818335771560669,
0.09455720335245132,
0.00698721082881093,
-0.2946651577949524,
-0.4029882848262787,
-0.9403337240219116,
0.9826986789703369,
-0.005717453546822071,
-0.2859121859073639,
-0.14018630981445312,
0.5966590046882629,
0.741996705532074,
-0.29793259501457214,
0.237936332821846,
0.48672714829444885,
0.7146300673484802,
0.03227648884057999,
-0.9381722807884216,
0.03884890303015709,
-0.44825121760368347,
-0.027367427945137024,
0.16230244934558868,
-0.5593054294586182,
0.7414632439613342,
-0.021399199962615967,
-0.1829553097486496,
-0.0006307458970695734,
0.723858654499054,
0.2218528538942337,
0.23906217515468597,
-0.12194016575813293,
0.1263226568698883,
0.6635715365409851,
0.06643135845661163,
1.1175090074539185,
-0.37445104122161865,
0.1086331307888031,
0.600349485874176,
-0.22831586003303528,
0.5476996302604675,
0.743556559085846,
-0.2441265732049942,
0.3270221948623657,
0.37441128492355347,
-0.2538575232028961,
0.4216175079345703,
0.09306639432907104,
-0.3543804883956909,
-0.07815462350845337,
-0.43848201632499695,
-0.3874177932739258,
0.3297792673110962,
0.4380391538143158,
-0.2480909824371338,
-0.39172592759132385,
0.37801170349121094,
-0.4556143879890442,
0.08321503549814224,
-0.2286180704832077,
0.466606467962265,
0.2201281040906906,
-0.07740390300750732,
0.19093367457389832,
-0.05916869267821312,
0.4627018868923187,
-0.8611078858375549,
-0.44937166571617126,
-0.0062718684785068035,
-0.13348664343357086,
0.03677981346845627,
-0.7170389890670776,
0.2709916830062866,
-0.41930243372917175,
-0.266327440738678,
-0.4151257276535034,
0.7738642692565918,
-0.8372038006782532,
-0.5455840229988098,
0.42241141200065613,
0.5604379773139954,
-0.11902009695768356,
0.3816402554512024,
-0.6759471297264099,
0.08533164113759995,
-0.25559282302856445,
-0.034964669495821,
0.1848721206188202,
0.35010918974876404,
0.037574753165245056,
0.8643643260002136,
0.7537282109260559,
0.1021089181303978,
0.0767817273736,
-0.30064505338668823,
0.8810878396034241,
-1.1115469932556152,
-0.27536651492118835,
-0.6141788363456726,
0.7815548777580261,
0.17546187341213226,
-0.23611919581890106,
0.7079847455024719,
0.8015813827514648,
0.9782809615135193,
-0.3193080723285675,
0.9433391094207764,
-0.14487233757972717,
0.2948336601257324,
-0.5784720182418823,
0.5896790623664856,
-0.59294193983078,
-0.00692931329831481,
-0.27075913548469543,
-0.6976192593574524,
-0.39040714502334595,
0.4259086549282074,
-0.0053352671675384045,
0.29556816816329956,
0.944150984287262,
0.8373312950134277,
-0.1463954746723175,
0.05777523294091225,
0.02334718219935894,
0.4095737934112549,
0.4290647804737091,
0.5891071557998657,
0.7412502765655518,
-0.32557132840156555,
0.16481894254684448,
-0.2725432217121124,
-0.0011126369936391711,
-0.3543776273727417,
-0.8124703764915466,
-0.792909562587738,
-0.5820664167404175,
-0.262452632188797,
-0.145537868142128,
0.08192861825227737,
1.0503416061401367,
0.4535524547100067,
-0.8176407217979431,
-0.7492923736572266,
-0.1349870264530182,
0.14353905618190765,
-0.159758523106575,
-0.1978878676891327,
0.0675443783402443,
-0.18759186565876007,
-0.6510308384895325,
0.6803541779518127,
0.7625053524971008,
0.43182384967803955,
-0.29519781470298767,
-0.09394366294145584,
-0.9605634808540344,
-0.027824794873595238,
0.8015201091766357,
0.7583397030830383,
-0.6177288889884949,
0.10972481966018677,
0.11894414573907852,
-0.381911039352417,
0.08265780657529831,
0.7376294732093811,
-0.897172749042511,
0.520524799823761,
0.7285946011543274,
0.8707120418548584,
0.15004760026931763,
-0.29825857281684875,
1.1370658874511719,
-0.45749643445014954,
-0.09045979380607605,
0.20862193405628204,
0.18168766796588898,
0.4087933599948883,
-0.3251972198486328,
0.45389658212661743,
0.4206322729587555,
-0.200717493891716,
-0.6261163949966431,
0.16224943101406097,
-1.3854272365570068,
-0.6501403450965881,
0.7463067770004272,
0.5840763449668884,
-0.4528595507144928,
-0.14090140163898468,
-0.2520614564418793,
0.46497392654418945,
-0.3924430310726166,
0.5851994752883911,
0.6424458026885986,
-0.2800229787826538,
-0.09570625424385071,
-0.747873067855835,
0.5332066416740417,
0.4593951404094696,
-1.0307124853134155,
0.004761533811688423,
0.6506938338279724,
-0.14638644456863403,
0.10585147142410278,
0.07883002609014511,
-0.20765557885169983,
0.3145827353000641,
-0.34539198875427246,
0.0571989081799984,
-0.15144650638103485,
-0.5412221550941467,
-0.5765610933303833,
0.17511919140815735,
-0.233013316988945,
0.16580255329608917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01518v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01518v1
|
Revisiting Dynamic Evaluation: Online Adaptation for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-03T14:03:48 | 2024-03-03T14:03:48 |
Amal Rannen-Triki, Jorg Bornschein, Razvan Pascanu, Marcus Hutter, Andras György, Alexandre Galashov, Yee Whye Teh, Michalis K. Titsias
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We consider the problem of online fine tuning the parameters of a language
model at test time, also known as dynamic evaluation. While it is generally
known that this approach improves the overall predictive performance,
especially when considering distributional shift between training and
evaluation data, we here emphasize the perspective that online adaptation turns
parameters into temporally changing states and provides a form of
context-length extension with memory in weights, more in line with the concept
of memory in neuroscience. We pay particular attention to the speed of
adaptation (in terms of sample efficiency),sensitivity to the overall
distributional drift, and the computational overhead for performing gradient
computations and parameter updates. Our empirical study provides insights on
when online adaptation is particularly interesting. We highlight that with
online adaptation the conceptual distinction between in-context learning and
fine tuning blurs: both are methods to condition the model on previously
observed tokens.
|
[
-0.3876391649246216,
-0.9152369499206543,
0.4948715269565582,
0.2183515578508377,
-0.1084110364317894,
0.24044817686080933,
-0.6735210418701172,
-0.7068250775337219,
-0.052039988338947296,
-0.06062927097082138,
-0.45844966173171997,
0.2357155680656433,
-0.3190814256668091,
-0.15108777582645416,
-0.4536948502063751,
1.0614888668060303,
-0.3322264552116394,
0.06572436541318893,
-0.06576671451330185,
-0.250942200422287,
-0.42337462306022644,
-0.10874569416046143,
-1.0362533330917358,
-0.2794521152973175,
0.3652587831020355,
-0.15944424271583557,
0.49558964371681213,
0.7811184525489807,
0.3763473629951477,
0.3349650204181671,
-0.1709689050912857,
-0.096890889108181,
-0.7897664904594421,
0.2825092375278473,
-0.172988623380661,
-0.7225612998008728,
-0.27425363659858704,
-0.27677497267723083,
0.9164621233940125,
0.8734652996063232,
-0.3265073895454407,
0.15504875779151917,
-0.04994454234838486,
0.6000391244888306,
-0.9962912201881409,
-0.04466193914413452,
-0.7363076210021973,
0.16720186173915863,
0.13806457817554474,
-0.46680310368537903,
-0.31439149379730225,
-0.4990903437137604,
0.46128129959106445,
-0.8450922966003418,
0.15659333765506744,
-0.25091156363487244,
0.7777495384216309,
0.30080562829971313,
-0.24444298446178436,
-0.32749396562576294,
-1.1748366355895996,
0.6839809417724609,
-0.4829665422439575,
0.6684913039207458,
0.26812291145324707,
0.6195070147514343,
-0.14172828197479248,
-0.8852678537368774,
-0.24360477924346924,
-0.5543182492256165,
0.5011361241340637,
0.20326705276966095,
0.0390625037252903,
0.03715018182992935,
0.3271416127681732,
0.4082298278808594,
0.16904900968074799,
0.1001213863492012,
-0.36382851004600525,
-0.0871090218424797,
0.5826079845428467,
0.16801267862319946,
0.10618357360363007,
0.4372760057449341,
-0.08288692682981491,
-0.04522261023521423,
-0.33530163764953613,
0.11862365156412125,
0.35619935393333435,
0.2009718269109726,
-0.2520369589328766,
-0.1527540534734726,
-0.21737872064113617,
0.7597797513008118,
0.4112682640552521,
-0.06961224973201752,
0.2571861743927002,
-0.3417322635650635,
0.1043761596083641,
0.04729902744293213,
0.12241031229496002,
0.3763143718242645,
0.2757072150707245,
-0.24850456416606903,
-0.23475202918052673,
-0.15652737021446228,
0.3110558092594147,
-0.8726147413253784,
-0.24597172439098358,
-0.032859209924936295,
-0.4997277557849884,
-0.137197345495224,
-0.09594987332820892,
-1.0449000597000122,
-0.5694553852081299,
-0.425517201423645,
0.7349216938018799,
-0.27468448877334595,
-0.1680404096841812,
0.2807188034057617,
-0.20457486808300018,
0.010612732730805874,
0.5692814588546753,
-0.983386218547821,
0.574888288974762,
0.45020097494125366,
0.8665570020675659,
-0.3772836923599243,
-0.3132779896259308,
-0.726517915725708,
-0.1690550595521927,
-0.28060030937194824,
0.7055238485336304,
-0.6096214056015015,
-0.10275492072105408,
0.10350186377763748,
-0.03609037771821022,
-0.23376280069351196,
-0.5280892848968506,
0.1619238555431366,
-0.6602275967597961,
0.14367015659809113,
-0.17223139107227325,
-0.5254678130149841,
0.013521512970328331,
0.027042482048273087,
-0.6595652103424072,
1.1278204917907715,
0.3027457892894745,
-0.5147302150726318,
0.638196587562561,
-0.9369456768035889,
-0.3354828953742981,
-0.19621871411800385,
0.3886329233646393,
-0.2299557775259018,
0.5028901696205139,
0.06339357048273087,
0.13283558189868927,
0.0010330852819606662,
0.08946854621171951,
-0.5490763783454895,
-0.6387490630149841,
0.5583142042160034,
-0.2764571011066437,
0.5090046525001526,
0.31310245394706726,
-0.46308135986328125,
0.1343069076538086,
-1.0658321380615234,
0.13690103590488434,
-0.14640502631664276,
-0.8760891556739807,
-0.34298476576805115,
0.5371209979057312,
-0.05937494337558746,
-0.0409776046872139,
-0.00018636553431861103,
-0.2925477921962738,
0.14798565208911896,
-0.817238986492157,
0.7119020223617554,
0.8809565305709839,
0.057278823107481,
0.5002541542053223,
-0.12518474459648132,
0.4405924379825592,
-0.2801969349384308,
0.2847225069999695,
-0.18169844150543213,
-0.09764980524778366,
-1.0808485746383667,
-0.08557066321372986,
0.8098593354225159,
0.3571571707725525,
-0.4307991564273834,
0.17648163437843323,
-0.33622607588768005,
-0.3902054727077484,
-0.4107573628425598,
-0.13006404042243958,
0.08269479870796204,
-0.054833848029375076,
0.1611814945936203,
-0.5518170595169067,
-0.47010549902915955,
-0.5272547006607056,
-0.4806616008281708,
0.042864859104156494,
-0.16235840320587158,
0.3746013343334198,
0.3904661536216736,
-0.254734069108963,
0.6928182244300842,
-0.3891870081424713,
0.15000203251838684,
-0.15052805840969086,
0.15183693170547485,
-0.16726523637771606,
0.2521643340587616,
0.6697710752487183,
-0.39240574836730957,
-0.36262014508247375,
-0.09518728405237198,
-0.24967984855175018,
-0.1256195306777954,
-0.4780389964580536,
0.18485699594020844,
0.11737847328186035,
0.4668605625629425,
-0.18001532554626465,
-0.0015561730833724141,
0.5727821588516235,
-0.3135147988796234,
0.20518150925636292,
-0.6192895174026489,
0.19670920073986053,
-0.9161612391471863,
-0.14561481773853302,
-0.16129067540168762,
-0.2754898965358734,
-0.5122044086456299,
0.4022899866104126,
0.03715123236179352,
-0.05582257732748985,
-0.595770001411438,
0.7368516325950623,
-0.6500281691551208,
-0.3023868501186371,
-0.2841791808605194,
0.25056833028793335,
-0.13531272113323212,
0.14859770238399506,
-0.47921282052993774,
0.7194207310676575,
0.6254068613052368,
-0.827793538570404,
0.3594653904438019,
-0.1956275999546051,
-0.667676568031311,
0.29757606983184814,
-0.16760565340518951,
0.26154083013534546,
-0.11164484173059464,
0.3674243986606598,
-0.6491208672523499,
-0.13508188724517822,
-0.024362407624721527,
-0.00837424211204052,
0.3502766191959381,
0.23967435956001282,
-0.2827008366584778,
-0.03574361279606819,
-0.40385332703590393,
0.5940476059913635,
0.3687165379524231,
-0.4598682224750519,
0.4604223966598511,
0.30579888820648193,
0.2692718207836151,
-0.11703471839427948,
-0.5099540948867798,
-0.13592514395713806,
-0.3716999590396881,
-0.14931820333003998,
0.5429273247718811,
-0.2352091521024704,
-0.4533044397830963,
-0.04952484369277954,
-0.02069716341793537,
-0.31988370418548584,
0.7097702622413635,
-0.023231500759720802,
-0.22141693532466888,
-0.31205204129219055,
0.3407760262489319,
0.0335056371986866,
0.16699494421482086,
0.04036364704370499,
-0.116121806204319,
0.4480375647544861,
-0.07258825749158859,
-0.11578063666820526,
-0.3577403426170349,
0.11596367508172989,
0.4471684396266937,
-0.010855155065655708,
0.7722875475883484,
0.6280003786087036,
-0.5373881459236145,
-0.42970436811447144,
-0.3893715441226959,
-0.3803195059299469,
-0.47726577520370483,
0.634876012802124,
-0.39057978987693787,
-0.8249946236610413,
0.7954781651496887,
-0.5114322304725647,
-0.31159454584121704,
0.4748149812221527,
0.6704282164573669,
-0.01828913204371929,
0.8930099606513977,
0.8915581107139587,
0.2948685586452484,
0.885344922542572,
0.08246789127588272,
0.19651824235916138,
-0.752666175365448,
0.002174219349399209,
-0.2854786217212677,
-0.5828728675842285,
-0.8426687717437744,
-0.32889214158058167,
0.21416422724723816,
0.40317365527153015,
-0.11848221719264984,
0.03312965855002403,
-0.14169786870479584,
0.6055827736854553,
0.009881893172860146,
0.35129013657569885,
-0.015180312097072601,
-0.07711615413427353,
-0.056481678038835526,
-0.1611921191215515,
-0.6556164622306824,
0.17078885436058044,
0.9666855931282043,
0.478702187538147,
0.5336464047431946,
-0.04367624968290329,
-0.08571714162826538,
0.3598489463329315,
0.23470351099967957,
-0.8523799180984497,
0.36292195320129395,
0.08731835335493088,
-0.6503592133522034,
-0.13162924349308014,
-0.1975952386856079,
-1.029215931892395,
0.030960634350776672,
-0.3395657241344452,
-0.8182408213615417,
0.15289060771465302,
0.2950764000415802,
-0.6393068432807922,
0.22655336558818817,
-0.6668118238449097,
0.6746392250061035,
-0.5313175320625305,
-0.5226364731788635,
-0.7983277440071106,
-0.4372158348560333,
0.13834688067436218,
-0.5750666856765747,
0.13374553620815277,
-0.026096966117620468,
-0.19894056022167206,
0.8764212131500244,
-0.052268002182245255,
0.7771236300468445,
-0.20217080414295197,
0.1941918432712555,
0.03228320926427841,
0.15426555275917053,
0.49984583258628845,
-0.16882790625095367,
-0.3207576274871826,
0.017180083319544792,
0.3261251747608185,
-0.22036558389663696,
-0.8570374846458435,
0.7774887681007385,
-0.7021031975746155,
-0.38771864771842957,
-0.362455278635025,
-0.6333164572715759,
-0.41581493616104126,
0.019861513748764992,
-0.18250128626823425,
0.44927605986595154,
-0.2108604609966278,
0.2966919541358948,
0.49502670764923096,
-0.5574160814285278,
0.4535087049007416,
0.5008388757705688,
-0.2605338394641876,
-0.23294185101985931,
0.8621370196342468,
0.303791344165802,
0.643405556678772,
0.3544256389141083,
0.602590024471283,
-0.24767403304576874,
-0.7167576551437378,
-0.45243605971336365,
0.15860387682914734,
-0.9621314406394958,
0.33894073963165283,
-0.24176737666130066,
-0.05034993216395378,
0.08845531195402145,
-0.22297869622707367,
-0.4611707925796509,
-0.5713862776756287,
-0.3459020256996155,
-0.07097353786230087,
0.5320484638214111,
0.7179268002510071,
0.07171269506216049,
0.3355501592159271,
-0.5708015561103821,
0.003751461859792471,
0.10601359605789185,
0.7896333336830139,
0.10193854570388794,
-0.7900483012199402,
-0.6178240180015564,
-0.027239801362156868,
-0.4209052324295044,
-0.7679495811462402,
0.09761350601911545,
0.84394371509552,
0.7034761309623718,
0.44325605034828186,
-0.055715881288051605,
1.081011414527893,
-0.6426168084144592,
0.7430130243301392,
-0.19046036899089813,
-1.0484083890914917,
0.37102019786834717,
-0.32101866602897644,
0.448498010635376,
0.6069900989532471,
0.4155844449996948,
-0.4789091944694519,
-0.10610965639352798,
-0.3881995677947998,
-0.8358924388885498,
0.5188910365104675,
-0.2117607146501541,
0.574974775314331,
0.28567489981651306,
0.813875675201416,
0.35927635431289673,
0.28074705600738525,
-0.4122893512248993,
-0.015581821091473103,
-0.034635163843631744,
0.09244481474161148,
-0.10121827572584152,
-0.3308318853378296,
-0.0013959313509985805,
-0.6952998638153076,
0.1768004298210144,
-0.2913323640823364,
0.5672195553779602,
-0.11636094748973846,
-0.12250373512506485,
-0.3343530297279358,
0.1933361291885376,
0.8180311322212219,
1.2270679473876953,
-0.21353623270988464,
-0.05093635618686676,
0.8230782747268677,
-0.2090281844139099,
-0.027142584323883057,
-0.15426334738731384,
-0.035639774054288864,
-0.3271048367023468,
0.45934927463531494,
1.317141056060791,
0.7542107105255127,
-0.7417857050895691,
0.3574654757976532,
0.006297629792243242,
-0.002845081267878413,
-0.36774736642837524,
0.24847780168056488,
-0.13911692798137665,
0.25322529673576355,
0.2245747447013855,
0.08926238864660263,
0.13624171912670135,
-0.9181250333786011,
0.28694114089012146,
0.20064783096313477,
-0.4892607033252716,
-0.658389151096344,
0.6757203936576843,
0.24836158752441406,
-0.4630516469478607,
0.3667430281639099,
-0.03737332299351692,
-0.4922727942466736,
0.38259515166282654,
0.7960106134414673,
0.9944051504135132,
-0.3282328248023987,
-0.1567547619342804,
0.32571882009506226,
-0.11764775216579437,
-0.23056583106517792,
0.15520796179771423,
-0.10776545852422714,
-0.524661660194397,
-0.49361076951026917,
-0.9346288442611694,
-0.30032649636268616,
0.16315051913261414,
-0.5451499819755554,
0.2755260467529297,
-0.6700231432914734,
-0.19852082431316376,
-0.07881736010313034,
-0.2186891883611679,
-0.3672877550125122,
0.33142295479774475,
0.20117631554603577,
0.9570459723472595,
-0.6998180150985718,
0.8128125071525574,
0.451471745967865,
0.08190227299928665,
-0.4821810722351074,
0.3802710175514221,
-0.2247338891029358,
-0.46305224299430847,
0.5429974794387817,
0.12458112835884094,
-0.002155182184651494,
0.06732537597417831,
-0.028240153566002846,
-1.1563721895217896,
0.8451928496360779,
0.7350216507911682,
-0.48036277294158936,
0.16995128989219666,
-0.2029208093881607,
1.029613733291626,
-0.2931845784187317,
0.5365527272224426,
0.6248484253883362,
0.3400968313217163,
-0.2509206533432007,
-1.205115556716919,
0.00757228210568428,
-0.024272548034787178,
0.007251621689647436,
0.3552665412425995,
-0.6319097280502319,
0.7582297325134277,
-0.10957390815019608,
-0.37786227464675903,
-0.1524760127067566,
0.43404316902160645,
-0.38465723395347595,
0.07541428506374359,
0.5801917910575867,
0.31063446402549744,
0.8045738339424133,
-0.12310350686311722,
1.3665993213653564,
-0.36271461844444275,
0.4062183201313019,
0.8784436583518982,
-0.2922048568725586,
1.0847527980804443,
0.4539012610912323,
-0.3933762013912201,
0.6178463697433472,
0.9591237902641296,
-0.019299674779176712,
0.6756134033203125,
0.47023504972457886,
-0.08315400034189224,
-0.2662523686885834,
-0.05650170147418976,
-0.4173724949359894,
0.36946579813957214,
0.1818782389163971,
-0.30859532952308655,
-0.28968513011932373,
0.18161322176456451,
-0.24308793246746063,
0.08842504769563675,
-0.5222508907318115,
0.6406999826431274,
-0.04534221068024635,
-0.7497294545173645,
0.8329934477806091,
0.19707593321800232,
0.32350829243659973,
-0.5579502582550049,
0.21824142336845398,
0.06264989823102951,
0.6806982755661011,
-0.045372311025857925,
-0.4177384078502655,
0.5363126397132874,
-0.3487756550312042,
-0.05524389445781708,
-0.14342878758907318,
0.5199606418609619,
0.01187181193381548,
-0.4808475971221924,
0.6295283436775208,
0.27918070554733276,
0.11192699521780014,
0.16292844712734222,
-0.8410189151763916,
0.30237236618995667,
-0.2257043719291687,
-0.3904680013656616,
0.6922188997268677,
0.14665964245796204,
-0.29497838020324707,
0.8910109400749207,
0.6088066697120667,
0.2864329516887665,
0.501494288444519,
0.21403363347053528,
0.8231365084648132,
-0.47871941328048706,
-0.5821064114570618,
-0.8479790687561035,
0.39018386602401733,
0.1835167557001114,
-0.5114014744758606,
0.5476052165031433,
0.4238635003566742,
1.1223772764205933,
-0.1372847706079483,
0.5193894505500793,
0.11577094346284866,
0.28003302216529846,
-0.6943643093109131,
0.74867182970047,
-0.8271970152854919,
0.01670931838452816,
-0.032335251569747925,
-0.9571824073791504,
-0.31068918108940125,
0.5176588296890259,
-0.43744856119155884,
0.1274752914905548,
1.0501940250396729,
0.5072952508926392,
-0.25149744749069214,
-0.12363165616989136,
0.22271591424942017,
0.30516451597213745,
0.04115196689963341,
0.40964198112487793,
0.8620597720146179,
-0.5468519926071167,
0.16837961971759796,
-0.07760577648878098,
-0.12699992954730988,
-0.30424198508262634,
-1.1138489246368408,
-0.7693800330162048,
-0.5884050726890564,
-0.47923964262008667,
-0.2440895140171051,
0.4594394862651825,
1.030024528503418,
0.5979359745979309,
-0.9841845035552979,
-0.3570918142795563,
-0.07254672050476074,
-0.4247089624404907,
-0.5426808595657349,
-0.17842501401901245,
0.21731047332286835,
-0.33734825253486633,
-0.768648087978363,
0.5687488913536072,
0.2088138908147812,
-0.23689378798007965,
-0.4584518373012543,
-0.0876552015542984,
-0.1919899433851242,
0.26841050386428833,
0.5715126991271973,
0.1494840830564499,
-0.6697707772254944,
-0.5954285264015198,
-0.3358839452266693,
0.23714452981948853,
0.33603614568710327,
0.8600813150405884,
-0.6876604557037354,
0.8447778820991516,
0.7200232148170471,
1.0325580835342407,
0.6790603399276733,
-0.05491049960255623,
0.803209662437439,
-0.24552159011363983,
0.19170095026493073,
-0.059939004480838776,
0.11624541878700256,
0.3105944097042084,
-0.1644221991300583,
0.0550009086728096,
0.41197919845581055,
-0.5558974146842957,
-1.1244125366210938,
0.20921938121318817,
-0.7412344813346863,
-0.2543427646160126,
1.1249268054962158,
-0.07117482274770737,
-0.20033693313598633,
-0.03670244291424751,
0.06412092596292496,
0.37977609038352966,
-0.11104852706193924,
1.206291675567627,
0.8200056552886963,
-0.11679669469594955,
-0.1284393072128296,
-1.0113577842712402,
0.6919971704483032,
0.32956358790397644,
-0.8069412112236023,
-0.03734468296170235,
0.18718133866786957,
0.4663812220096588,
-0.08374181389808655,
0.25377723574638367,
0.2936113178730011,
0.2585201561450958,
-0.024553224444389343,
-0.2579507529735565,
0.19810977578163147,
-0.3602065145969391,
-0.8394976854324341,
0.14797434210777283,
0.37831905484199524,
-0.056581005454063416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01509v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01509v2
|
Fantastic Semantics and Where to Find Them: Investigating Which Layers of Generative LLMs Reflect Lexical Semantics
| 2024-03-03T13:14:47 | 2024-06-09T13:07:50 |
Zhu Liu, Cunliang Kong, Ying Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models have achieved remarkable success in general language
understanding tasks. However, as a family of generative methods with the
objective of next token prediction, the semantic evolution with the depth of
these models are not fully explored, unlike their predecessors, such as
BERT-like architectures. In this paper, we specifically investigate the
bottom-up evolution of lexical semantics for a popular LLM, namely Llama2, by
probing its hidden states at the end of each layer using a contextualized word
identification task. Our experiments show that the representations in lower
layers encode lexical semantics, while the higher layers, with weaker semantic
induction, are responsible for prediction. This is in contrast to models with
discriminative objectives, such as mask language modeling, where the higher
layers obtain better lexical semantics. The conclusion is further supported by
the monotonic increase in performance via the hidden states for the last
meaningless symbols, such as punctuation, in the prompting strategy. Our codes
are available at https://github.com/RyanLiut/LLM_LexSem.
|
[
-0.3984166979789734,
-0.6334599256515503,
0.8847746849060059,
0.03521352261304855,
-0.29417625069618225,
0.3672008514404297,
-0.05652061477303505,
-0.37758392095565796,
0.21883054077625275,
0.5708269476890564,
-0.71419358253479,
-0.7856848239898682,
-0.644394040107727,
0.0654163807630539,
-0.370140016078949,
0.7881594896316528,
0.09219993650913239,
-0.20140831172466278,
-0.18169139325618744,
0.06793922185897827,
-0.2474532425403595,
-0.6969351768493652,
-0.35184189677238464,
-0.632537841796875,
0.4505099356174469,
0.258206307888031,
0.8647864460945129,
0.7325445413589478,
0.20052330195903778,
0.20264913141727448,
-0.7632567882537842,
0.28147947788238525,
-0.5121643543243408,
0.17750424146652222,
-0.17212516069412231,
-0.7730755805969238,
-0.18232619762420654,
-0.22200222313404083,
0.5940101146697998,
0.7338780760765076,
-0.12841229140758514,
-0.037843283265829086,
-0.10121607035398483,
0.3409843146800995,
-0.738472580909729,
0.29714590311050415,
-0.8290886878967285,
0.25971686840057373,
-0.41409826278686523,
-0.42358317971229553,
-0.2577474117279053,
-0.09529004245996475,
0.07789602875709534,
-0.45966988801956177,
0.15825045108795166,
0.11215081065893173,
0.8380118012428284,
0.2884126305580139,
-0.20792576670646667,
-0.5521664023399353,
-0.44376370310783386,
0.7061159014701843,
-0.5122467279434204,
0.28359222412109375,
0.43240800499916077,
0.07855258882045746,
-0.32128530740737915,
-0.5626972913742065,
-0.6075097918510437,
-0.6475792527198792,
-0.020441094413399696,
0.2086809128522873,
-0.46070581674575806,
0.14034558832645416,
0.1256849616765976,
0.5296489000320435,
-0.13754938542842865,
0.519844651222229,
0.07196158915758133,
-0.4320184290409088,
0.12581202387809753,
0.18645812571048737,
0.40215766429901123,
-0.3351195454597473,
-0.6379868388175964,
0.09597859531641006,
-1.0570883750915527,
-0.25915834307670593,
0.3346540331840515,
0.09205705672502518,
-0.3287668526172638,
0.7355809211730957,
-0.052399203181266785,
0.4213095009326935,
-0.4400143623352051,
-0.06255219876766205,
0.3835703730583191,
-0.42301246523857117,
0.07856013625860214,
0.17610055208206177,
0.2665298283100128,
-0.05810561403632164,
0.22130772471427917,
-0.3269227147102356,
-0.4420911371707916,
0.3418714702129364,
0.02888520434498787,
-0.47410285472869873,
-0.15377356112003326,
-0.11512482166290283,
-0.21555261313915253,
-0.37624379992485046,
-0.12332471460103989,
-0.1507466584444046,
-0.515575647354126,
-0.2844487428665161,
0.19958554208278656,
-0.4930512309074402,
-0.27918723225593567,
0.24668745696544647,
-0.15087667107582092,
0.6143205165863037,
0.268881231546402,
-0.8955885171890259,
0.28800415992736816,
1.0539124011993408,
0.895093560218811,
-0.16915786266326904,
-0.18795663118362427,
-0.3836748003959656,
0.14320795238018036,
-0.7989933490753174,
0.9433631300926208,
-0.7952897548675537,
-0.3014819025993347,
0.13116170465946198,
0.0048299930058419704,
0.19491367042064667,
-0.7712080478668213,
0.6942235231399536,
-0.7226415872573853,
0.08258850872516632,
-0.4888879060745239,
-0.47465795278549194,
-0.2607412338256836,
0.1983775943517685,
-0.4672694802284241,
1.1335020065307617,
-0.01741386577486992,
-0.7715937495231628,
0.32923415303230286,
-0.6062374711036682,
-0.26013126969337463,
0.2292252480983734,
-0.17708948254585266,
-0.14998404681682587,
0.6648902893066406,
0.19256135821342468,
0.568050742149353,
-0.3671068251132965,
-0.013781663961708546,
-0.17984354496002197,
-0.4591433107852936,
0.4281782805919647,
-0.2930760979652405,
0.7131298780441284,
0.11922026425600052,
-0.4652247428894043,
-0.03063841350376606,
-0.6979660391807556,
-0.23577624559402466,
0.30078789591789246,
-0.34716174006462097,
-0.4476163387298584,
0.13049201667308807,
-0.243935689330101,
0.051437728106975555,
0.37701207399368286,
-0.43918174505233765,
-0.06609530746936798,
-0.4664822220802307,
0.5201285481452942,
0.8264399766921997,
-0.03757661208510399,
0.3521665632724762,
-0.13663075864315033,
0.5124189257621765,
0.1644454151391983,
-0.23128001391887665,
-0.2175462543964386,
-0.5720219016075134,
-0.9401324987411499,
-0.2278990000486374,
0.12712261080741882,
0.4224257469177246,
-0.5786095857620239,
0.3895920515060425,
-0.1249045878648758,
-0.1946636587381363,
-0.40003708004951477,
0.25824734568595886,
0.6272960305213928,
0.2802024185657501,
0.23562879860401154,
-0.2955147624015808,
-0.22928358614444733,
-1.1631910800933838,
0.10850851237773895,
-0.36937904357910156,
-0.03695381060242653,
0.20486608147621155,
0.3585009276866913,
-0.5442746877670288,
0.6314586400985718,
-0.33536750078201294,
-0.007919849827885628,
-0.47759881615638733,
-0.04675361514091492,
0.10239897668361664,
0.08753567934036255,
0.4166164994239807,
-0.34281590580940247,
0.2462553083896637,
0.013816495425999165,
-0.6804814338684082,
-0.44101035594940186,
0.05837076157331467,
-0.3465782105922699,
0.0766667053103447,
0.39146292209625244,
-0.6134956479072571,
0.031159447506070137,
0.4633103907108307,
-0.126528799533844,
0.5317869782447815,
-0.13737289607524872,
-0.44831666350364685,
-0.952232837677002,
-0.17029842734336853,
-0.2747216820716858,
-0.15299850702285767,
-0.6455602645874023,
0.38457825779914856,
0.15744921565055847,
0.21402615308761597,
-0.26409733295440674,
0.3680037260055542,
-0.7712944149971008,
-0.4472983479499817,
-0.2955766022205353,
0.33138272166252136,
-0.08492550998926163,
0.3199714720249176,
0.12086635082960129,
0.9424036741256714,
0.8514503240585327,
-0.4973442554473877,
0.012689106166362762,
0.14771217107772827,
-0.5344418883323669,
0.10453689843416214,
-0.36580100655555725,
0.19488100707530975,
-0.249650239944458,
0.2005956768989563,
-0.9767097234725952,
-0.23676292598247528,
0.018471362069249153,
-0.40887582302093506,
0.25629398226737976,
0.06925685703754425,
-0.7734849452972412,
-0.35360223054885864,
-0.4563963711261749,
0.21680942177772522,
0.5588276982307434,
-0.6444007158279419,
0.1908612847328186,
0.5035775899887085,
-0.005340716801583767,
-0.5011283159255981,
-0.8213528990745544,
0.38141903281211853,
-0.12792323529720306,
-0.21312500536441803,
0.4224530756473541,
0.13192443549633026,
-0.3334222733974457,
-0.09966091811656952,
-0.10674358159303665,
0.4132999777793884,
0.3762407600879669,
0.2082909643650055,
0.24235594272613525,
-0.38328754901885986,
0.1301640421152115,
0.2685840427875519,
-0.24999256432056427,
0.3415025770664215,
-0.4384605884552002,
0.8792376518249512,
-0.31146255135536194,
-0.20605047047138214,
-0.5010871291160583,
0.027631042525172234,
0.4721837639808655,
-0.21038740873336792,
0.7165334224700928,
0.536395788192749,
-0.5158655643463135,
-0.4057152569293976,
-0.5434376001358032,
-0.04132159799337387,
-0.44489428400993347,
0.4601443111896515,
-0.5295525193214417,
-1.0343270301818848,
0.729795515537262,
-0.01320724468678236,
-0.22301051020622253,
0.3263288736343384,
0.9054742455482483,
0.09150026738643646,
0.8154364824295044,
0.633050799369812,
0.10128938406705856,
0.18275107443332672,
-0.33567047119140625,
0.002073079813271761,
-0.857642650604248,
-0.4800928235054016,
-0.2900054156780243,
0.011335093528032303,
-0.658812940120697,
-0.4833790063858032,
0.24437303841114044,
0.45017126202583313,
0.0029225365724414587,
0.3740406632423401,
-0.27769213914871216,
0.5991854667663574,
0.49480047821998596,
0.04825441166758537,
0.2767736315727234,
0.26122766733169556,
-0.5638911724090576,
0.18121972680091858,
-0.6288096904754639,
-0.5775289535522461,
0.7513565421104431,
0.5756924748420715,
0.6547255516052246,
0.23115257918834686,
0.8173933625221252,
0.1183205246925354,
0.062965027987957,
-0.8726473450660706,
0.7420582175254822,
-0.07431197911500931,
-0.3600553870201111,
0.13229359686374664,
-0.16222693026065826,
-0.7942144274711609,
0.18596139550209045,
-0.07896868139505386,
-0.732405424118042,
-0.027680855244398117,
-0.028336811810731888,
-0.2449408918619156,
0.22556106746196747,
-0.4671466052532196,
0.4657202661037445,
-0.11604717373847961,
-0.23325279355049133,
-0.28302767872810364,
-0.5262590646743774,
0.35336464643478394,
-0.0073541137389838696,
0.09338191896677017,
-0.35288846492767334,
-0.5287432670593262,
0.5674267411231995,
-0.3849889934062958,
0.7676227688789368,
0.048395369201898575,
-0.510695219039917,
0.3033025562763214,
0.380271315574646,
0.4613807499408722,
-0.049268078058958054,
0.03781731799244881,
0.26278162002563477,
-0.32647979259490967,
-0.462738037109375,
-0.3869081735610962,
0.8588773608207703,
-0.7875681519508362,
-0.7623076438903809,
-0.19869963824748993,
-0.39389753341674805,
-0.25681328773498535,
-0.008776330389082432,
0.2842375934123993,
0.5673732161521912,
0.2531892657279968,
0.017265044152736664,
0.7167587280273438,
-0.36882123351097107,
0.3429567813873291,
0.21546833217144012,
-0.11718413233757019,
0.0021690858993679285,
0.8698665499687195,
-0.1691998541355133,
0.33562690019607544,
0.685447633266449,
0.3662409484386444,
-0.5478091239929199,
-0.8172401189804077,
-0.2899894118309021,
0.43180808424949646,
-0.9328687787055969,
-0.15961450338363647,
-0.4683067798614502,
-0.30266886949539185,
-0.0967612937092781,
-0.11030924320220947,
-0.19923236966133118,
-0.39061275124549866,
-0.5969741940498352,
-0.47483885288238525,
0.22653979063034058,
0.9646188616752625,
-0.12460179626941681,
0.23530344665050507,
-0.35686805844306946,
0.08853717148303986,
0.16711296141147614,
0.24514271318912506,
0.07517483830451965,
-0.5783281326293945,
0.15239045023918152,
-0.391964852809906,
-0.04844067618250847,
-0.7894478440284729,
0.10130403190851212,
0.22307293117046356,
0.5372289419174194,
0.5522825717926025,
-0.26173195242881775,
0.4943608045578003,
-0.44844046235084534,
0.8122837543487549,
0.19717468321323395,
-0.7996383905410767,
0.4403243660926819,
-0.25514233112335205,
0.4253614544868469,
0.2880125641822815,
0.32392042875289917,
-0.389171302318573,
-0.5328474044799805,
-0.28448352217674255,
-0.7184486985206604,
0.6017579436302185,
0.26753008365631104,
0.6580095291137695,
-0.3359866142272949,
0.4475833773612976,
0.41082116961479187,
0.14592264592647552,
-0.7100937366485596,
-0.26092666387557983,
-0.017048968002200127,
-0.005515743512660265,
0.10505848377943039,
-0.7043377757072449,
-0.04759472608566284,
0.08684723824262619,
0.270999938249588,
-0.03246062621474266,
0.4272840619087219,
-0.0575922466814518,
-0.1769765019416809,
0.23297595977783203,
0.42726215720176697,
0.5511804223060608,
0.6205658912658691,
0.09878160059452057,
0.6879317760467529,
0.21298068761825562,
-0.4263072609901428,
-0.14426612854003906,
-0.08047150820493698,
-0.10845191776752472,
-0.06672732532024384,
0.8134927153587341,
1.0301822423934937,
0.539825975894928,
-0.695303738117218,
0.45101988315582275,
0.44216471910476685,
-0.15938718616962433,
-0.5033124089241028,
0.32645663619041443,
0.19675065577030182,
0.3057670295238495,
0.42417481541633606,
-0.3424903452396393,
0.14706897735595703,
-0.7143303751945496,
0.0725448802113533,
0.5898957848548889,
-0.29581761360168457,
-0.4738612174987793,
0.6924278736114502,
-0.23594419658184052,
-0.0643240362405777,
0.346004843711853,
-0.49590739607810974,
-0.7754133343696594,
0.3454745411872864,
0.751733660697937,
0.7629803419113159,
0.3050019145011902,
0.3720364570617676,
0.01915094628930092,
0.23653633892536163,
0.211584210395813,
0.251497745513916,
-0.4355038106441498,
-0.8592569828033447,
-0.27384087443351746,
-0.9211103320121765,
-0.23279711604118347,
0.14648878574371338,
-0.4148835837841034,
0.12442538887262344,
-0.4089781939983368,
0.033345289528369904,
0.03199229761958122,
-0.17049136757850647,
-0.5727699398994446,
-0.13643576204776764,
0.8017321228981018,
0.8849778771400452,
-0.4552455246448517,
0.7504124641418457,
0.631012499332428,
-0.25741273164749146,
-0.47004953026771545,
0.07435797154903412,
0.059461332857608795,
-1.493375301361084,
0.7451549172401428,
0.28380918502807617,
-0.47597581148147583,
0.1930997222661972,
-0.624359130859375,
-0.9844627976417542,
1.0049054622650146,
0.4741053581237793,
-0.42564108967781067,
-0.23282960057258606,
0.3441629707813263,
0.6351141333580017,
-0.2581915855407715,
0.31834664940834045,
0.665531575679779,
0.14934813976287842,
0.2656542658805847,
-0.4749370217323303,
0.13863427937030792,
-0.09976043552160263,
0.5718254446983337,
0.07073910534381866,
-0.35363492369651794,
0.6447560787200928,
-0.4575744569301605,
-0.6532734036445618,
0.3491380512714386,
0.7090211510658264,
0.37424802780151367,
-0.0016368725337088108,
0.23616565763950348,
0.7345265746116638,
0.6217289566993713,
-0.1783616989850998,
1.1823315620422363,
-0.29178401827812195,
0.2952486276626587,
0.6134907007217407,
-0.13645586371421814,
0.8025195002555847,
0.32669317722320557,
-0.06966345757246017,
0.8421550393104553,
0.8635963797569275,
0.1665537804365158,
0.6137126088142395,
0.4497838020324707,
-0.44541871547698975,
-0.40073370933532715,
-0.36148136854171753,
-0.35748982429504395,
0.4569619297981262,
0.6709766983985901,
-0.30537766218185425,
-0.3539718985557556,
-0.07823678106069565,
0.2083212435245514,
-0.07179223001003265,
-0.4740039110183716,
0.9081236124038696,
0.07370592653751373,
-0.3823983073234558,
0.8713094592094421,
-0.046773746609687805,
0.6578596830368042,
-0.44983503222465515,
0.045914746820926666,
-0.5296526551246643,
-0.04309511557221413,
-0.1852881759405136,
-0.9127172231674194,
-0.09906405210494995,
-0.12783779203891754,
0.12400364130735397,
0.006275918800383806,
0.6857646703720093,
-0.17891880869865417,
-0.3935806453227997,
0.6765289306640625,
0.5566048622131348,
0.2453141063451767,
0.3009301722049713,
-0.5695245265960693,
0.23501332104206085,
-0.3568072021007538,
-0.19730877876281738,
0.08071666955947876,
0.45938795804977417,
-0.08344598114490509,
0.5453945398330688,
0.5263171792030334,
0.07060777395963669,
0.3525680601596832,
0.35227149724960327,
0.8971052169799805,
-0.5919699668884277,
-0.42110446095466614,
-0.932663083076477,
0.13045525550842285,
0.13471706211566925,
-0.41657519340515137,
0.5116748213768005,
0.42896345257759094,
0.9441943764686584,
0.051026348024606705,
0.4766116440296173,
0.21574082970619202,
0.17969386279582977,
-0.8678389191627502,
0.4441834092140198,
-0.6410395503044128,
0.421857625246048,
-0.05212264880537987,
-1.1934291124343872,
-0.3921970725059509,
0.27291926741600037,
-0.2107820063829422,
-0.1997404396533966,
0.6389553546905518,
1.002604365348816,
-0.0016685010632500052,
0.09184262156486511,
0.337443470954895,
0.5094365477561951,
0.010022005997598171,
0.5145887732505798,
1.3508039712905884,
0.16017404198646545,
0.08309431374073029,
-0.23682205379009247,
-0.34180906414985657,
-0.08874160796403885,
-0.6141255497932434,
-0.7707954049110413,
-0.6279200315475464,
-0.13633441925048828,
-0.15305350720882416,
0.23621582984924316,
0.7350560426712036,
0.40650200843811035,
-0.7917447686195374,
-0.07974842190742493,
-0.5415306091308594,
0.07377922534942627,
0.1918361335992813,
-0.21658208966255188,
0.35347771644592285,
-0.6418783664703369,
-0.4685060977935791,
0.4810863733291626,
0.4442507028579712,
-0.04231114685535431,
-0.5282905101776123,
-0.016720551997423172,
0.13076160848140717,
0.043452031910419464,
0.8401587605476379,
0.05254535377025604,
-1.213649868965149,
-0.38408827781677246,
0.03084798902273178,
-0.15664948523044586,
-0.051191430538892746,
0.6746072769165039,
-0.7328788042068481,
0.2695205509662628,
0.26621028780937195,
0.7932384014129639,
0.446219801902771,
-0.2489733099937439,
0.1899953931570053,
-0.5639588832855225,
0.0013610413298010826,
0.07526267319917679,
0.4448782801628113,
0.4127095341682434,
-0.10583477467298508,
0.3961421847343445,
0.38320139050483704,
-0.0743991881608963,
-0.817246675491333,
0.3454575538635254,
-0.8620738387107849,
-0.21664372086524963,
1.3565690517425537,
0.1602398157119751,
-0.22570939362049103,
0.0958206057548523,
-0.04987126961350441,
0.018511099740862846,
-0.14209258556365967,
0.6613377332687378,
0.6523869037628174,
-0.2768605947494507,
-0.25449469685554504,
-0.6210160255432129,
0.4129696786403656,
0.4780050814151764,
-0.6274124383926392,
0.028307201340794563,
0.4998263716697693,
0.06648517400026321,
0.3273136019706726,
0.2829331159591675,
-0.2355073243379593,
0.09936172515153885,
-0.08128050714731216,
-0.3064403235912323,
0.012318329885601997,
-0.4373193085193634,
-0.26008373498916626,
0.17639599740505219,
0.3003069758415222,
-0.15699125826358795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01481v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01481v1
|
Infusing Knowledge into Large Language Models with Contextual Prompts
| 2024-03-03T11:19:26 | 2024-03-03T11:19:26 |
Kinshuk Vasisht, Balaji Ganesan, Vikas Kumar, Vasudha Bhatnagar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge infusion is a promising method for enhancing Large Language Models
for domain-specific NLP tasks rather than pre-training models over large data
from scratch. These augmented LLMs typically depend on additional pre-training
or knowledge prompts from an existing knowledge graph, which is impractical in
many applications. In contrast, knowledge infusion directly from relevant
documents is more generalisable and alleviates the need for structured
knowledge graphs while also being useful for entities that are usually not
found in any knowledge graph. With this motivation, we propose a simple yet
generalisable approach for knowledge infusion by generating prompts from the
context in the input text. Our experiments show the effectiveness of our
approach which we evaluate by probing the fine-tuned LLMs.
|
[
-0.21352607011795044,
-0.8316349983215332,
0.8524048328399658,
0.00021857238607481122,
-0.23523126542568207,
0.09192358702421188,
-0.21261434257030487,
-0.490499347448349,
0.27349168062210083,
0.7533973455429077,
-0.6285027861595154,
-0.2825855016708374,
-0.37272047996520996,
0.21939128637313843,
-0.34663137793540955,
0.9905471801757812,
-0.008108340203762054,
-0.02148725651204586,
-0.8752862215042114,
0.1955498605966568,
-0.5641237497329712,
-0.6776972413063049,
-0.7772334218025208,
-0.6728007793426514,
0.503978431224823,
0.4535596966743469,
0.3027394413948059,
0.19488437473773956,
0.1466597318649292,
0.19116008281707764,
-0.16283003985881805,
0.5962823629379272,
-0.24964511394500732,
0.370606005191803,
-0.34812596440315247,
-0.3621438443660736,
-0.23425734043121338,
-0.22228273749351501,
0.6510143876075745,
1.0391215085983276,
0.14114922285079956,
-0.1502537727355957,
0.5198719501495361,
0.4171237647533417,
-0.5176393985748291,
-0.09333021938800812,
-0.6292157173156738,
-0.06626208126544952,
-0.22440990805625916,
-0.5585298538208008,
-0.4177128076553345,
-0.3305208384990692,
0.6768596172332764,
-0.6151314973831177,
-0.01673959568142891,
0.20256996154785156,
0.6622158885002136,
0.20168817043304443,
-0.4279312193393707,
-0.5125502347946167,
-0.5905998945236206,
0.5933017730712891,
-0.7470657825469971,
0.2053295522928238,
0.309271901845932,
0.26342296600341797,
-0.34673553705215454,
-0.986699640750885,
-0.7716348767280579,
-0.21318985521793365,
-0.3887222409248352,
-0.18319258093833923,
0.043808095157146454,
0.13807690143585205,
0.32740136981010437,
0.14367206394672394,
-0.31900715827941895,
0.04078259691596031,
0.15789227187633514,
-0.07733061164617538,
0.13064377009868622,
0.269001305103302,
0.5035735368728638,
-0.08089321106672287,
-0.5034124255180359,
0.1350879967212677,
-1.0802645683288574,
0.006117478013038635,
0.03880513459444046,
0.44321927428245544,
0.09771332889795303,
0.5602554678916931,
-0.25533100962638855,
1.2933359146118164,
0.10387635231018066,
-0.4216584265232086,
0.018673298880457878,
-0.5206229090690613,
-0.30032050609588623,
0.12366948276758194,
0.5636101961135864,
0.2631780207157135,
0.21403460204601288,
-0.36466988921165466,
-0.13648740947246552,
-0.37263205647468567,
-0.031115999445319176,
-1.0183509588241577,
0.10696551203727722,
0.2944521903991699,
0.13167154788970947,
-0.19660300016403198,
-0.2097187340259552,
-0.5830063223838806,
-0.700514018535614,
-0.37065449357032776,
0.3258365988731384,
-0.549701988697052,
0.07346569746732712,
0.15018002688884735,
-0.4458805322647095,
0.26033708453178406,
0.5183967351913452,
-1.1169439554214478,
-0.09270323067903519,
0.4528461992740631,
0.7172057628631592,
-0.2914573550224304,
-0.23868310451507568,
-0.49000605940818787,
0.6592915058135986,
-0.09163842350244522,
1.101925015449524,
-0.7127368450164795,
-0.33623525500297546,
0.43907591700553894,
-0.005215117707848549,
0.10738328844308853,
-0.5559589266777039,
0.33852681517601013,
-0.6996608972549438,
0.40089601278305054,
-0.44203686714172363,
-1.006581425666809,
-0.1237422451376915,
0.4984269142150879,
-0.20236201584339142,
1.0784927606582642,
0.4151110351085663,
-0.7213987112045288,
0.4972922205924988,
-0.7980703115463257,
-0.43101435899734497,
0.334628701210022,
-0.1995096355676651,
0.2452557533979416,
-0.21674294769763947,
0.5732596516609192,
0.7306215167045593,
-0.4154989421367645,
0.5209453701972961,
-0.30919545888900757,
-0.037579406052827835,
0.2701382637023926,
-0.20604397356510162,
0.8736009001731873,
0.02003907971084118,
-0.06020501255989075,
0.04006708785891533,
-0.6118469834327698,
-0.09214535355567932,
-0.03869503736495972,
-0.40139201283454895,
-0.5953003764152527,
-0.2757510840892792,
-0.303581178188324,
0.044613614678382874,
0.28507673740386963,
-0.37731409072875977,
0.6185166835784912,
-0.903215229511261,
0.48178908228874207,
0.5006200671195984,
0.5468299984931946,
0.8762971758842468,
-0.12783512473106384,
0.4480559229850769,
0.03064570389688015,
-0.12812724709510803,
-0.3557877242565155,
-0.4507808983325958,
-0.6355041861534119,
-0.4485413432121277,
0.19483371078968048,
0.5609580278396606,
-1.2036645412445068,
0.5205737948417664,
-0.22595202922821045,
-0.3459397256374359,
-0.16119295358657837,
0.36461201310157776,
0.006439410150051117,
1.3074167966842651,
0.39355504512786865,
0.10506683588027954,
-0.4508114457130432,
-0.6732968091964722,
-0.12581217288970947,
0.16137506067752838,
-0.3937261700630188,
0.4086868464946747,
0.28162652254104614,
-0.4613635838031769,
1.3510279655456543,
-0.5541788339614868,
-0.27004820108413696,
-0.4292096197605133,
-0.2630929946899414,
0.33347275853157043,
0.46439284086227417,
0.6219437122344971,
-0.3571045994758606,
-0.5889676809310913,
0.024484341964125633,
-1.1121858358383179,
-0.15547852218151093,
-0.11887162178754807,
-0.22537867724895477,
-0.11454480141401291,
0.8603934645652771,
-0.6220589280128479,
-0.015674792230129242,
0.39885213971138,
-0.5139016509056091,
0.32740917801856995,
-0.1568491905927658,
0.06488587707281113,
-1.3424116373062134,
0.04051145166158676,
-0.3176349699497223,
-0.3816046416759491,
-0.9936031699180603,
-0.05666508898139,
0.08859728276729584,
-0.20682910084724426,
-0.6067971587181091,
1.1410298347473145,
-0.31734731793403625,
0.2095210999250412,
-0.22445334494113922,
0.5344718098640442,
0.3364310562610626,
0.3554474115371704,
0.10445889830589294,
0.6594719290733337,
0.7414240837097168,
-0.8385041952133179,
0.4536234438419342,
0.4606190323829651,
-0.6217217445373535,
0.692184567451477,
-0.6405549049377441,
0.2136823982000351,
-0.13929995894432068,
0.49072012305259705,
-1.0540522336959839,
-0.5081268548965454,
0.37710514664649963,
-0.24194097518920898,
0.4774393141269684,
-0.06023259460926056,
-0.48125794529914856,
-0.05479447916150093,
0.04350550100207329,
0.4383666217327118,
0.3885866701602936,
-0.9245030283927917,
0.8705042004585266,
0.23505252599716187,
-0.26192745566368103,
-0.5349917411804199,
-0.692463219165802,
0.17198391258716583,
-0.4261094629764557,
-0.804558515548706,
0.47336873412132263,
-0.08984760195016861,
-0.24751871824264526,
-0.07155632227659225,
0.46071118116378784,
0.04670313000679016,
0.14496538043022156,
0.0069974446669220924,
0.20052507519721985,
-0.06970050185918808,
0.38826990127563477,
0.36486172676086426,
0.0866272822022438,
0.024727968499064445,
-0.7542881369590759,
0.550513744354248,
0.24417644739151,
-0.401317834854126,
-0.4134807884693146,
0.464536190032959,
0.30395522713661194,
-0.0912090614438057,
0.9029812216758728,
0.2522585690021515,
-0.5059173107147217,
-0.44237491488456726,
-0.60043865442276,
-0.3762578070163727,
-0.49570006132125854,
0.06586345285177231,
-0.19487448036670685,
-1.0498689413070679,
0.45372265577316284,
-0.49559691548347473,
-0.058578021824359894,
0.35934919118881226,
0.557345449924469,
-0.27236005663871765,
0.8698561191558838,
0.6273197531700134,
0.0242994986474514,
0.6410686373710632,
-0.12926208972930908,
0.15709486603736877,
-0.7629626989364624,
-0.24940593540668488,
-0.44384318590164185,
-0.006061920430511236,
0.08545785397291183,
-0.4574529230594635,
0.39757248759269714,
0.26642823219299316,
-0.16096340119838715,
-0.10694003105163574,
-0.34877607226371765,
0.6107500791549683,
0.5308738350868225,
0.1829274594783783,
0.275422602891922,
-0.069990374147892,
-0.30671975016593933,
0.08709497004747391,
-0.9625259041786194,
-0.47529637813568115,
1.037766456604004,
0.05826739966869354,
0.4300474524497986,
-0.09799524396657944,
0.6573079824447632,
0.009679148904979229,
0.42680680751800537,
-0.7639574408531189,
0.37079042196273804,
0.18803754448890686,
-0.38703933358192444,
-0.4951031804084778,
-0.09662266075611115,
-0.9414755702018738,
-0.19450658559799194,
-0.4324227273464203,
-0.6867893934249878,
0.19035327434539795,
0.39593300223350525,
-0.7423912882804871,
0.08964098244905472,
-0.7543724775314331,
0.696553647518158,
0.032425425946712494,
-0.0794830173254013,
0.16396339237689972,
-0.5120525360107422,
0.2936323285102844,
-0.15981751680374146,
0.12380119413137436,
0.29022130370140076,
-0.12536700069904327,
0.7082511186599731,
-0.7601529955863953,
0.9323912262916565,
-0.38820984959602356,
-0.3356774151325226,
0.2953397333621979,
-0.25793230533599854,
0.8986296057701111,
0.09837019443511963,
0.02136358432471752,
-0.21298103034496307,
-0.2702766954898834,
-0.3125355839729309,
-1.1174037456512451,
0.688993513584137,
-0.4814758896827698,
-0.7528280019760132,
-0.06656453013420105,
-0.6967385411262512,
-0.8238574266433716,
0.17803677916526794,
0.2255736142396927,
0.6788643002510071,
-0.03394315764307976,
0.12501180171966553,
1.1081875562667847,
-0.3424017131328583,
0.36574554443359375,
0.37469494342803955,
-0.24209289252758026,
-0.28739604353904724,
0.6633641123771667,
-0.07458484917879105,
0.40531787276268005,
0.6415744423866272,
0.2915506958961487,
-0.5036543011665344,
-0.47100743651390076,
-0.6622772216796875,
0.19191357493400574,
-0.9888983368873596,
-0.3517352342605591,
-0.8420852422714233,
0.017207663506269455,
-0.5058644413948059,
-0.6084190607070923,
0.13817232847213745,
-0.2978505492210388,
-0.5417997241020203,
-0.14308778941631317,
0.6019811034202576,
0.6448457837104797,
0.24116919934749603,
0.4437902569770813,
-0.8837621212005615,
0.03360772505402565,
0.7345832586288452,
0.08664355427026749,
0.09105263650417328,
-0.6727884411811829,
-0.34520283341407776,
-0.006989433895796537,
0.12918764352798462,
-0.9764490723609924,
0.3226031959056854,
0.2446105182170868,
0.6133163571357727,
0.65402752161026,
-0.017970282584428787,
0.7858088612556458,
-0.6457148790359497,
1.1160328388214111,
0.17455071210861206,
-0.9733317494392395,
0.7151897549629211,
-0.470075398683548,
0.39951926469802856,
0.584952175617218,
0.4821133017539978,
-0.5478358864784241,
-0.450700968503952,
-0.5070936679840088,
-0.861210823059082,
0.4305266737937927,
-0.38521793484687805,
0.41182824969291687,
-0.14438943564891815,
0.5987803339958191,
0.03899110481142998,
0.1773661971092224,
-0.4048537611961365,
-0.12452305853366852,
0.03125453367829323,
-0.2189665585756302,
-0.07180533558130264,
-0.5147690176963806,
-0.36353081464767456,
-0.3368420898914337,
0.5945225954055786,
-0.29868075251579285,
0.114156574010849,
0.3663318455219269,
-0.2993142306804657,
0.19661322236061096,
0.05043541267514229,
0.533735990524292,
0.7180304527282715,
-0.01573086902499199,
0.258323609828949,
0.4416012167930603,
-0.10759446769952774,
-0.016830405220389366,
-0.07865357398986816,
-0.2540244460105896,
-0.08616282790899277,
0.4417707920074463,
0.7250891923904419,
0.4331755042076111,
-0.7151123285293579,
0.5530737638473511,
0.10667864978313446,
-0.1560562551021576,
-0.18660786747932434,
0.04978078976273537,
0.38442397117614746,
0.38589978218078613,
0.314948171377182,
-0.1699339598417282,
-0.029719781130552292,
-0.5863544344902039,
0.10164924710988998,
0.5642948150634766,
-0.31864452362060547,
0.10751575231552124,
0.4277934432029724,
0.3384323716163635,
-0.1605449616909027,
0.6525777578353882,
-0.11462514847517014,
-0.46070486307144165,
0.07807725667953491,
0.8111119866371155,
0.6887405514717102,
-0.03286055102944374,
0.03611653298139572,
0.37476539611816406,
-0.07688339799642563,
0.06211264804005623,
-0.016711421310901642,
-0.11693695932626724,
-0.9677639007568359,
-0.5837391018867493,
-0.6675918102264404,
-0.47979143261909485,
-0.05381017550826073,
-0.27489516139030457,
0.2819640040397644,
-0.2758941352367401,
0.08147081732749939,
-0.10398182272911072,
-0.18124952912330627,
-0.8045205473899841,
0.16821226477622986,
-0.06725049018859863,
1.1060267686843872,
-0.7495377063751221,
1.0890954732894897,
0.6226055026054382,
-0.3214017152786255,
-0.8750149011611938,
-0.11229540407657623,
-0.4548042118549347,
-0.9423213005065918,
0.7286162972450256,
-0.16647280752658844,
0.08768241107463837,
0.20994745194911957,
-0.782566487789154,
-0.9299681186676025,
1.1553996801376343,
0.6204210519790649,
-0.16490960121154785,
-0.1477753221988678,
0.19728177785873413,
0.370321661233902,
-0.5615819692611694,
0.13919419050216675,
0.545454204082489,
0.574836015701294,
0.18702584505081177,
-0.5016058683395386,
0.2641887962818146,
-0.02463226392865181,
0.022845396772027016,
-0.04433135688304901,
0.03325371444225311,
0.6351307034492493,
-0.10839826613664627,
-0.20647947490215302,
-0.21443350613117218,
0.9091864228248596,
0.17217795550823212,
-0.07021782547235489,
0.5705590844154358,
0.3948889672756195,
1.2564270496368408,
0.10792172700166702,
1.2705421447753906,
-0.34358909726142883,
-0.1124778762459755,
1.0658977031707764,
-0.16490072011947632,
0.5747519135475159,
0.7771415114402771,
0.08647159487009048,
0.6741942167282104,
0.6019077301025391,
0.2793247401714325,
0.6288596391677856,
0.07545941323041916,
-0.5284118056297302,
-0.31981393694877625,
-0.6045398116111755,
-0.422919899225235,
0.08241483569145203,
0.4937744736671448,
-0.2752310037612915,
-0.15053239464759827,
0.2512744665145874,
0.2183195799589157,
-0.10807840526103973,
-0.39699798822402954,
1.0304125547409058,
0.06723255664110184,
-0.9186736941337585,
0.6200526356697083,
-0.30108842253685,
0.6138386726379395,
-0.9792574048042297,
-0.13726593554019928,
-0.28675079345703125,
-0.17422187328338623,
-0.2448674440383911,
-0.744552493095398,
0.22394214570522308,
-0.03473958373069763,
-0.3187611401081085,
-0.6106049418449402,
0.9250411987304688,
-0.7863566279411316,
-0.15008306503295898,
0.09357348084449768,
0.7013036012649536,
0.04990150406956673,
-0.22769944369792938,
-0.23830825090408325,
-0.46547454595565796,
0.01031550019979477,
-0.30180349946022034,
0.5789453983306885,
0.6085677742958069,
0.11933379620313644,
0.5607969760894775,
0.7918126583099365,
0.08558499813079834,
-0.3314831852912903,
0.2605099678039551,
1.070974588394165,
-0.36202263832092285,
-0.48368752002716064,
-0.9798004031181335,
0.6915796399116516,
-0.16500557959079742,
-0.2166435569524765,
0.8979560136795044,
0.08746438473463058,
0.6070995330810547,
-0.1988183856010437,
0.9475933909416199,
0.07072626799345016,
0.4670388102531433,
-0.7252316474914551,
0.706646203994751,
-0.7253032326698303,
0.12586848437786102,
-0.3156183660030365,
-0.6664674878120422,
-0.45300668478012085,
0.3802966773509979,
-0.16822317242622375,
-0.27977073192596436,
0.690992534160614,
0.8499690890312195,
0.329962819814682,
-0.14173226058483124,
0.32518354058265686,
0.06423051655292511,
0.2860306203365326,
0.5070980787277222,
1.0017967224121094,
0.10865525156259537,
0.22652684152126312,
-0.012834721244871616,
-0.3901641070842743,
-0.1517879217863083,
-1.21738862991333,
-1.1168451309204102,
-0.6331008672714233,
-0.03922432288527489,
-0.36359885334968567,
-0.14981572329998016,
1.045118808746338,
0.4214451313018799,
-0.6810123920440674,
0.05110030621290207,
0.05345902219414711,
0.3693166673183441,
-0.08144181966781616,
-0.18315942585468292,
0.3610887825489044,
-0.7138177156448364,
-0.7952189445495605,
0.7802323698997498,
0.20584014058113098,
0.2206326276063919,
-0.36194175481796265,
0.021497737616300583,
-0.11643315851688385,
0.19900570809841156,
0.8073357939720154,
0.07881283760070801,
-0.36806562542915344,
-0.4256461262702942,
0.019787348806858063,
0.01243169791996479,
-0.16382735967636108,
0.9350038170814514,
-1.0539093017578125,
0.48367825150489807,
0.638581395149231,
0.9981358647346497,
0.24944397807121277,
-0.1674703061580658,
0.9411838054656982,
-1.082519769668579,
0.23153568804264069,
0.23359714448451996,
0.5762003660202026,
0.47305452823638916,
-0.526217520236969,
0.2958778142929077,
0.2206033170223236,
-0.43133682012557983,
-0.9047648310661316,
0.28786876797676086,
-0.9055078625679016,
-0.22700457274913788,
1.5049501657485962,
-0.15666180849075317,
-0.033443957567214966,
-0.26575925946235657,
-0.21729131042957306,
0.17852705717086792,
-0.2669287919998169,
0.39136937260627747,
0.7184614539146423,
-0.11218153685331345,
0.34223124384880066,
-0.37641096115112305,
1.005778431892395,
0.257797509431839,
-1.1167869567871094,
0.02608882077038288,
0.3519098162651062,
0.152782142162323,
0.1644149273633957,
0.7529149651527405,
0.25403669476509094,
-0.10698992013931274,
-0.22172263264656067,
-0.1505752056837082,
-0.07557767629623413,
-0.366691529750824,
-0.2316054105758667,
0.327353835105896,
0.14351986348628998,
0.39598289132118225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01479v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01479v3
|
Align-to-Distill: Trainable Attention Alignment for Knowledge Distillation in Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-03-03T11:13:44 | 2024-03-25T08:46:15 |
Heegon Jin, Seonil Son, Jemin Park, Youngseok Kim, Hyungjong Noh, Yeonsoo Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7
|
The advent of scalable deep models and large datasets has improved the
performance of Neural Machine Translation. Knowledge Distillation (KD) enhances
efficiency by transferring knowledge from a teacher model to a more compact
student model. However, KD approaches to Transformer architecture often rely on
heuristics, particularly when deciding which teacher layers to distill from. In
this paper, we introduce the 'Align-to-Distill' (A2D) strategy, designed to
address the feature mapping problem by adaptively aligning student attention
heads with their teacher counterparts during training. The Attention Alignment
Module in A2D performs a dense head-by-head comparison between student and
teacher attention heads across layers, turning the combinatorial mapping
heuristics into a learning problem. Our experiments show the efficacy of A2D,
demonstrating gains of up to +3.61 and +0.63 BLEU points for WMT-2022 De->Dsb
and WMT-2014 En->De, respectively, compared to Transformer baselines.
|
[
-0.36039677262306213,
-0.4019060730934143,
0.5976284742355347,
0.20945951342582703,
-0.19724175333976746,
0.21689607203006744,
-0.5490791201591492,
0.09093374758958817,
-0.22247911989688873,
0.17244365811347961,
-0.39766058325767517,
-0.26475009322166443,
-1.1395537853240967,
-0.15092791616916656,
-0.421896755695343,
0.9320637583732605,
-0.18371637165546417,
0.022219305858016014,
-0.5268136262893677,
-0.29856061935424805,
-0.8421207666397095,
-0.09669849276542664,
-0.6021943688392639,
-0.5605055093765259,
0.6273404955863953,
0.5725769400596619,
0.6349288821220398,
0.8959161639213562,
0.8672226071357727,
0.4112735092639923,
-0.1587711125612259,
0.16268248856067657,
-0.3851487934589386,
0.3669348955154419,
-0.48427721858024597,
-0.5161176919937134,
-0.2998569905757904,
-0.08607472479343414,
0.33263614773750305,
0.8020954132080078,
-0.25456708669662476,
0.3579469621181488,
0.6575790643692017,
1.127229928970337,
-0.6400402784347534,
0.07918862253427505,
-0.7908526062965393,
0.057917218655347824,
0.059575144201517105,
-0.009084578603506088,
-0.3460988402366638,
-0.221753790974617,
0.6093376874923706,
-0.49228325486183167,
0.1356915980577469,
-0.13558417558670044,
0.642526388168335,
1.1448029279708862,
-0.3063792884349823,
-0.22766245901584625,
-0.7292417287826538,
0.6675850749015808,
-0.4414495825767517,
0.262904554605484,
0.09647320210933685,
0.7635714411735535,
0.016605982556939125,
-0.7884909510612488,
-0.561612069606781,
0.42342761158943176,
-0.2537723481655121,
0.29699021577835083,
-0.05655061453580856,
-0.30473554134368896,
0.2954199016094208,
0.3702786862850189,
-0.2982361912727356,
-0.011797658167779446,
-0.39075279235839844,
0.1516420543193817,
0.42715179920196533,
-0.07093846052885056,
-0.11127228289842606,
0.36211326718330383,
-0.6495428681373596,
-0.28776848316192627,
-0.08239102363586426,
-0.06764834374189377,
0.1381952464580536,
0.2619033753871918,
0.09648962318897247,
0.3684264123439789,
-0.05629700794816017,
0.7118449807167053,
0.7256605625152588,
-0.26490190625190735,
0.0863429605960846,
-0.030976252630352974,
-0.15674032270908356,
0.6734511852264404,
0.587148129940033,
0.4814888834953308,
0.3654535412788391,
-0.29330113530158997,
-0.12862595915794373,
-0.05217054858803749,
0.6200236678123474,
-0.8492291569709778,
-0.5358920693397522,
0.20312100648880005,
-0.12708966434001923,
-0.3519779443740845,
-0.2864985764026642,
-0.7478596568107605,
-0.39443543553352356,
-0.6059147715568542,
0.7806283831596375,
-0.3148162066936493,
-0.2120959758758545,
0.005859235767275095,
-0.3503546118736267,
0.07513853162527084,
0.048718713223934174,
-1.028254508972168,
0.07750243693590164,
0.4507350027561188,
0.7550690770149231,
-0.44146934151649475,
-0.46989190578460693,
-0.062275614589452744,
0.2983521819114685,
-0.14344482123851776,
0.4039241373538971,
-0.11945454031229019,
-0.0049076201394200325,
-0.3018589913845062,
-0.19872058928012848,
-0.2844727635383606,
-0.7359672784805298,
0.33837467432022095,
-0.5276303291320801,
0.2650430500507355,
-0.40298977494239807,
-0.47611674666404724,
-0.2789808213710785,
0.3199773132801056,
-0.443011611700058,
1.006270170211792,
0.3650549352169037,
-0.6675284504890442,
0.33489423990249634,
-0.685202419757843,
-0.38229337334632874,
-0.21562542021274567,
0.04950779303908348,
-0.7064400315284729,
0.14684844017028809,
0.2880140244960785,
0.22493579983711243,
-0.15794803202152252,
0.4189508855342865,
-0.008954977616667747,
-0.06523033231496811,
0.22086122632026672,
-0.46096500754356384,
0.8204108476638794,
0.22079750895500183,
-0.5928499102592468,
-0.05180937051773071,
-0.5382525324821472,
-0.2133866846561432,
0.10857666283845901,
-0.18427063524723053,
-0.44366270303726196,
-0.0929194837808609,
-0.35862645506858826,
0.23703575134277344,
0.3201996684074402,
-0.08637310564517975,
0.36209842562675476,
-0.10250868648290634,
0.5170738101005554,
0.6393185257911682,
-0.2021198868751526,
0.7782838344573975,
-0.13173314929008484,
0.29925623536109924,
0.6442005038261414,
-0.05846149101853371,
-0.1088142842054367,
-0.2871469259262085,
-0.7977926135063171,
-0.2562594711780548,
0.57979416847229,
0.4960491955280304,
-0.7052012085914612,
0.6150944828987122,
-0.5402314066886902,
-0.47532981634140015,
-1.0649991035461426,
0.30846551060676575,
0.31410694122314453,
1.2069547176361084,
0.6757687926292419,
-0.10004305839538574,
-0.3630799353122711,
-0.7836991548538208,
-0.15334612131118774,
0.27413275837898254,
0.08593787997961044,
-0.162478506565094,
0.09251318126916885,
-0.03407447412610054,
1.0010017156600952,
-0.8209630846977234,
-0.6730669736862183,
0.0792907252907753,
-0.07065616548061371,
-0.019056880846619606,
0.5013682842254639,
0.6394606828689575,
-0.7012139558792114,
-0.9027568101882935,
0.09252557903528214,
-0.6415191888809204,
-0.05849806219339371,
-0.04852026328444481,
-0.5386070609092712,
-0.08117282390594482,
0.4407457411289215,
-0.41618528962135315,
0.20056012272834778,
0.45070257782936096,
-0.1255248337984085,
-0.16379669308662415,
-0.04900383576750755,
0.12025447934865952,
-1.4229964017868042,
0.06705949455499649,
-0.026936322450637817,
-0.21458931267261505,
-0.46290189027786255,
-0.11047561466693878,
0.2521129250526428,
0.018348319455981255,
-0.286397248506546,
0.18486346304416656,
-0.49371635913848877,
-0.020594514906406403,
-0.509790301322937,
0.38742730021476746,
0.24510560929775238,
0.5681984424591064,
-0.06538938730955124,
0.6801188588142395,
0.6144923567771912,
-0.42760589718818665,
0.4608752429485321,
0.477406769990921,
-0.30904415249824524,
0.9058725237846375,
-0.3815021812915802,
0.23783864080905914,
-0.07594095170497894,
-0.039320316165685654,
-1.2579708099365234,
0.15594612061977386,
0.05672575533390045,
-0.4446538984775543,
0.582974374294281,
-0.1609676331281662,
-0.027105063199996948,
-0.4742642343044281,
0.015085374936461449,
0.5887405276298523,
0.702272355556488,
-0.7539427280426025,
0.6783131957054138,
0.12309468537569046,
-0.06069732457399368,
-0.7932450771331787,
-0.7584008574485779,
0.04074201360344887,
-0.586151123046875,
-0.41561782360076904,
0.6003864407539368,
0.1518651694059372,
0.028430389240384102,
0.2763741910457611,
-0.45519953966140747,
-0.16629308462142944,
0.3349537253379822,
-0.09211262315511703,
0.2839125990867615,
-0.4034651219844818,
-0.17116865515708923,
0.20826296508312225,
-0.2769626975059509,
0.061783600598573685,
-0.6545711755752563,
0.40782877802848816,
0.37456899881362915,
-0.2221851646900177,
-0.4776943624019623,
0.060659606009721756,
0.7539963126182556,
-0.25923922657966614,
0.717578649520874,
0.7637082934379578,
-0.3119928240776062,
-0.10032579302787781,
-0.4429532289505005,
-0.34085750579833984,
-0.5079419612884521,
0.4333476424217224,
-0.2874755263328552,
-0.35074475407600403,
0.4055519104003906,
-0.22259022295475006,
0.1298818737268448,
0.35185903310775757,
0.500698447227478,
-0.33692166209220886,
0.9471349120140076,
0.5238764882087708,
-0.32892903685569763,
0.4209689497947693,
-0.3528828024864197,
0.32504504919052124,
-1.026048183441162,
-0.2722530663013458,
-0.4566252529621124,
-1.379769206047058,
-0.2557688355445862,
-0.2794165313243866,
0.35787472128868103,
0.3200780749320984,
-0.06752113252878189,
0.5905477404594421,
-0.9478223323822021,
0.5411348938941956,
0.5715826749801636,
0.10168101638555527,
0.22845889627933502,
-0.029212431982159615,
-0.0196720901876688,
-0.2629927694797516,
-0.6090710759162903,
-0.13474230468273163,
1.1372802257537842,
0.06049848347902298,
0.5195838212966919,
0.1138177365064621,
0.7422300577163696,
-0.15695331990718842,
0.20727333426475525,
-1.0603035688400269,
0.2591286301612854,
-0.19638682901859283,
-0.33885031938552856,
-0.4015358090400696,
-0.15365219116210938,
-0.7134589552879333,
0.2656193971633911,
0.09736195206642151,
-0.3167612850666046,
0.18189637362957,
0.32727810740470886,
-0.4471391439437866,
0.10436617583036423,
-0.9579629898071289,
1.0494285821914673,
-0.4132656753063202,
-0.263515830039978,
0.01497227419167757,
-0.8208585381507874,
0.13955846428871155,
-0.19593507051467896,
-0.16187873482704163,
0.1487257331609726,
0.08172819018363953,
0.4109936058521271,
-0.20400163531303406,
0.46230071783065796,
-0.47808894515037537,
-0.18325014412403107,
0.13518056273460388,
-0.19998860359191895,
0.3939911723136902,
-0.22320784628391266,
0.13849948346614838,
0.08247444778680801,
-0.32718217372894287,
-0.3046543002128601,
-0.9430944323539734,
0.6941860914230347,
-0.8423555493354797,
-0.9242441654205322,
-0.2511250674724579,
-0.9255340099334717,
-0.13280950486660004,
0.15103942155838013,
0.260717511177063,
0.013556022197008133,
0.22115929424762726,
0.3038213849067688,
0.9342408776283264,
0.36537423729896545,
0.5634893774986267,
0.42739155888557434,
-0.056502338498830795,
-0.5526153445243835,
0.9616584181785583,
0.31671544909477234,
0.4397599399089813,
0.43190181255340576,
0.2679980993270874,
-0.4509899318218231,
-0.5832817554473877,
-0.674010694026947,
-0.3168594241142273,
-0.5595434904098511,
-0.4603782594203949,
-0.5478223562240601,
-0.43791013956069946,
-0.48574158549308777,
-0.127561554312706,
-0.48390427231788635,
-0.45596253871917725,
-0.20385143160820007,
0.0228387750685215,
0.3520326316356659,
0.11120239645242691,
0.18997512757778168,
0.5345973372459412,
-0.5453396439552307,
0.3591774106025696,
0.46552181243896484,
0.08110342174768448,
0.006770503707230091,
-0.9516381621360779,
-0.38153982162475586,
0.11801274120807648,
-0.8218247294425964,
-0.7106449007987976,
0.12243843823671341,
0.3499690592288971,
0.42462486028671265,
0.4700588285923004,
0.20209918916225433,
1.0257627964019775,
-0.720772385597229,
0.3009582459926605,
0.20216268301010132,
-0.8349170088768005,
0.49452152848243713,
0.16468258202075958,
0.4931148886680603,
0.8145846128463745,
0.6029962301254272,
-0.4268077313899994,
-0.31002798676490784,
-0.38172972202301025,
-0.9250671863555908,
0.6789482235908508,
0.068075992166996,
-0.028997207060456276,
0.4059402048587799,
0.3269955515861511,
0.08213324099779129,
0.3200593888759613,
-0.3079150319099426,
-0.4629479944705963,
-0.276073157787323,
-0.9387310147285461,
-0.029928814619779587,
0.14673438668251038,
-0.33142203092575073,
-0.46045583486557007,
0.6350176334381104,
-0.2560582160949707,
-0.0546998530626297,
0.035423800349235535,
-0.2443399429321289,
0.05888686329126358,
-0.07462218403816223,
0.47522541880607605,
0.5478583574295044,
-0.031132083386182785,
0.36946699023246765,
0.07661805301904678,
-0.5768231749534607,
0.3066675364971161,
0.30193522572517395,
-0.1897619366645813,
-0.2103409469127655,
-0.023457089439034462,
0.8529850244522095,
0.19677628576755524,
-0.05552617460489273,
0.4369255006313324,
0.0751110389828682,
-0.37462884187698364,
0.09022185206413269,
0.22551338374614716,
0.4603401720523834,
0.5847423076629639,
0.33387330174446106,
0.3271348178386688,
0.13437218964099884,
-0.19500334560871124,
0.20190787315368652,
0.2507927417755127,
-0.5434614419937134,
-0.13033992052078247,
0.838661253452301,
0.1895362287759781,
-0.3659648001194,
0.7558152079582214,
0.04807236045598984,
-0.5849667191505432,
0.6232686638832092,
0.599491536617279,
1.0571271181106567,
-0.607998788356781,
-0.09657907485961914,
0.3705940246582031,
0.1843634694814682,
-0.18355830013751984,
-0.07579236477613449,
-0.204837366938591,
-0.6798582077026367,
-0.15755635499954224,
-0.5303174257278442,
-0.06602835655212402,
-0.0801595151424408,
-0.9588001370429993,
0.3897750973701477,
-0.07135172933340073,
-0.13972577452659607,
0.4189906716346741,
-0.22899934649467468,
-0.5764684677124023,
0.08385507017374039,
0.06953156739473343,
0.5517152547836304,
-0.776843249797821,
1.0015161037445068,
0.7266673445701599,
-0.22221040725708008,
-0.6761457324028015,
0.20995666086673737,
-0.003370195161551237,
-0.7477273344993591,
0.5671905875205994,
0.1464642882347107,
0.23444156348705292,
0.5083091259002686,
-0.09963105618953705,
-0.7857574224472046,
1.6225368976593018,
0.5950148105621338,
-0.9846429228782654,
-0.16780254244804382,
0.3806021511554718,
0.3571477234363556,
-0.2968798279762268,
0.02194962091743946,
0.7981771230697632,
0.4715608060359955,
0.36896631121635437,
-0.727902352809906,
-0.08669919520616531,
0.17971374094486237,
0.1003929004073143,
0.4193556606769562,
-0.6346194744110107,
0.45466697216033936,
-0.21998904645442963,
-0.09007123857736588,
-0.4958812892436981,
0.7319538593292236,
-0.08021760731935501,
0.2581421732902527,
0.600831151008606,
1.080469012260437,
0.7319349050521851,
-0.38977670669555664,
0.35713472962379456,
-0.4784596860408783,
0.3313654065132141,
1.3383327722549438,
-0.2753261625766754,
0.5692746639251709,
0.9885047078132629,
-0.17993491888046265,
0.2237953543663025,
0.3831266462802887,
-0.08668377995491028,
1.054746389389038,
0.09047496318817139,
-0.09512656182050705,
0.0025518848560750484,
0.16494032740592957,
-0.32414767146110535,
0.3935275375843048,
0.1229235976934433,
-0.42948994040489197,
-0.2429155558347702,
0.17980895936489105,
-0.2505173087120056,
0.39409691095352173,
-0.104182668030262,
1.2273904085159302,
0.12777066230773926,
-1.0365298986434937,
0.6766875982284546,
-0.28668493032455444,
0.417388379573822,
-0.2411501705646515,
0.05439053475856781,
-0.27858173847198486,
0.6345599889755249,
-0.1604212075471878,
-0.7071087956428528,
0.5609531402587891,
-0.18619082868099213,
-0.5716236233711243,
-0.38377031683921814,
0.34989458322525024,
-1.1494691371917725,
-0.37932702898979187,
0.1210528090596199,
0.1517062485218048,
-0.2775641977787018,
-0.14409871399402618,
-0.7050591111183167,
-0.117879718542099,
0.024262573570013046,
-0.0934167355298996,
0.4890029728412628,
0.7331942319869995,
0.1628877967596054,
0.36578261852264404,
0.18169890344142914,
-0.23772898316383362,
0.1300109326839447,
-0.03877002000808716,
0.8693647384643555,
-0.21447214484214783,
-0.2365935742855072,
-1.118876338005066,
0.8219241499900818,
-0.1016354113817215,
-0.23867063224315643,
0.4713364243507385,
0.6056420803070068,
0.8523532152175903,
-0.0651022270321846,
0.5575761198997498,
0.01615484617650509,
0.1924663484096527,
-0.36973732709884644,
0.8769971132278442,
-0.40294548869132996,
0.15553122758865356,
0.047172050923109055,
-1.2781014442443848,
0.2248937487602234,
0.5556539297103882,
-0.06534125655889511,
-0.23355336487293243,
0.8228709697723389,
0.535791277885437,
-0.34714317321777344,
-0.2576697766780853,
0.220272958278656,
0.12339679151773453,
0.24077348411083221,
0.6389877796173096,
0.48774081468582153,
-0.7339828014373779,
0.6003918051719666,
-0.4709359407424927,
-0.1915464997291565,
-0.08575626462697983,
-0.7922354936599731,
-0.7507062554359436,
-0.7372256517410278,
-0.7561101913452148,
-0.32861706614494324,
0.001958906650543213,
0.669600784778595,
0.42668119072914124,
-0.6964759826660156,
0.02719290927052498,
-0.03863164037466049,
0.17108801007270813,
-0.68136066198349,
-0.19691987335681915,
0.49192509055137634,
-0.7205359935760498,
-0.9774309396743774,
0.11901520192623138,
0.1895284503698349,
0.07929722219705582,
-0.19240784645080566,
-0.011797373183071613,
-0.10108140856027603,
-0.16847743093967438,
0.29822614789009094,
-0.22818733751773834,
-0.5168529748916626,
-0.13076813519001007,
0.09150350093841553,
-0.304608553647995,
0.23072919249534607,
0.5816648602485657,
-0.5595263838768005,
0.4879131317138672,
0.290287047624588,
1.230830430984497,
0.4458356201648712,
0.1560491919517517,
0.47364145517349243,
-0.9698891043663025,
0.1974506974220276,
-0.0125620998442173,
0.10344617813825607,
0.35091158747673035,
-0.4013439118862152,
0.38725608587265015,
0.12819892168045044,
-0.6082687377929688,
-0.7117659449577332,
-0.14315135776996613,
-1.0349290370941162,
0.05815717950463295,
0.7756214141845703,
-0.3219541609287262,
-0.29247328639030457,
0.17848752439022064,
-0.32638195157051086,
0.5310133099555969,
-0.0728980302810669,
1.2063143253326416,
0.8898725509643555,
0.3212328553199768,
0.0027547727804630995,
-0.4081006646156311,
0.5543922781944275,
0.5324683785438538,
-0.5373600721359253,
0.07768520712852478,
0.07736342400312424,
0.3504732847213745,
0.35346415638923645,
0.09153743088245392,
-0.04634736105799675,
0.10348200052976608,
-0.2560766637325287,
-0.0014769156696274877,
-0.22856833040714264,
-0.5503751039505005,
-0.1456226408481598,
-0.03148435801267624,
-0.0027209322433918715,
-0.7079805731773376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12984v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12984v2
|
When SMILES have Language: Drug Classification using Text Classification Methods on Drug SMILES Strings
| 2024-03-03T11:09:32 | 2024-03-27T21:51:03 |
Azmine Toushik Wasi, Šerbetar Karlo, Raima Islam, Taki Hasan Rafi, Dong-Kyu Chae
|
q-bio.BM
|
q-bio.BM, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
Complex chemical structures, like drugs, are usually defined by SMILES
strings as a sequence of molecules and bonds. These SMILES strings are used in
different complex machine learning-based drug-related research and
representation works. Escaping from complex representation, in this work, we
pose a single question: What if we treat drug SMILES as conventional sentences
and engage in text classification for drug classification? Our experiments
affirm the possibility with very competitive scores. The study explores the
notion of viewing each atom and bond as sentence components, employing basic
NLP methods to categorize drug types, proving that complex problems can also be
solved with simpler perspectives. The data and code are available here:
https://github.com/azminewasi/Drug-Classification-NLP.
|
[
-0.04214334860444069,
-0.8136467933654785,
0.7977501749992371,
-0.03882373124361038,
0.025152841582894325,
0.41866645216941833,
-0.5375985503196716,
-0.8270723223686218,
0.247170552611351,
0.325094610452652,
-0.5798065066337585,
-0.7220503687858582,
-0.6325746774673462,
0.3348087966442108,
-0.14550845324993134,
1.2559281587600708,
0.07254042476415634,
0.37094077467918396,
-0.42823880910873413,
-0.18326878547668457,
0.0348474383354187,
-0.29037898778915405,
-0.5426348447799683,
-0.6085944175720215,
0.8263944387435913,
0.42923682928085327,
0.6528118848800659,
0.4928972125053406,
0.752318799495697,
0.4394739270210266,
-0.11537211388349533,
-0.06522242724895477,
0.11945828795433044,
0.04549384117126465,
-0.13023003935813904,
-1.1660956144332886,
-0.381007581949234,
0.00601838156580925,
-0.015066538006067276,
0.8829009532928467,
-0.09936012327671051,
-0.09276681393384933,
-0.2993907332420349,
0.6888440847396851,
-0.43928366899490356,
0.34956061840057373,
-0.32855910062789917,
0.39411216974258423,
-0.4138219654560089,
-0.22379183769226074,
-0.41042983531951904,
-0.4647084176540375,
0.2978978157043457,
-0.45801517367362976,
-0.001808107946999371,
0.22400452196598053,
1.07282555103302,
-0.14462149143218994,
-0.8252387046813965,
-0.8096979856491089,
-0.5768870115280151,
0.6938085556030273,
-0.6830335855484009,
-0.013798657804727554,
-0.009934176690876484,
0.5776135325431824,
-0.598888635635376,
-0.8846215605735779,
-0.7559894919395447,
-0.3984455168247223,
-0.13374389708042145,
-0.0757012739777565,
0.09929493814706802,
0.5251961350440979,
0.118585966527462,
0.7303947806358337,
-0.7923961877822876,
-0.12232159823179245,
-0.3620215654373169,
-0.19505079090595245,
0.4294337034225464,
-0.08136354386806488,
0.9876981973648071,
-0.40610894560813904,
-0.6121636629104614,
0.03939986974000931,
-0.5773651003837585,
0.08157725632190704,
0.030746448785066605,
0.6819325089454651,
0.18196143209934235,
1.0398037433624268,
0.06958958506584167,
0.5907840728759766,
-0.21726000308990479,
-0.2813047468662262,
0.4673959016799927,
-0.014865154400467873,
-0.3541676104068756,
0.5399098992347717,
0.8271833658218384,
0.4066573679447174,
0.5917725563049316,
-0.06740240752696991,
-0.1995386779308319,
0.4506596326828003,
0.2314741611480713,
-0.6498876214027405,
-0.19904303550720215,
0.5117320418357849,
-0.43941786885261536,
-0.19776062667369843,
0.02799307182431221,
-0.6812065243721008,
-0.41477665305137634,
-0.2819126844406128,
0.5915221571922302,
-0.39990872144699097,
0.14831778407096863,
0.2984827160835266,
-0.43585243821144104,
0.2104131579399109,
0.08965644240379333,
-0.8764980435371399,
0.8769431710243225,
0.622433066368103,
0.7933669090270996,
-0.2643052339553833,
0.007403717376291752,
-0.33542728424072266,
-0.17499129474163055,
-0.10335838794708252,
1.0513219833374023,
-0.39281344413757324,
-0.315260648727417,
0.07559335976839066,
0.10495980083942413,
-0.1111004427075386,
-0.7544143795967102,
0.4333818256855011,
-0.21802835166454315,
0.5181881785392761,
-0.19387368857860565,
-0.7347835898399353,
-0.16259707510471344,
0.0914304107427597,
-0.46972647309303284,
0.29050910472869873,
0.2902117967605591,
-0.7644400596618652,
0.30002930760383606,
-0.7223527431488037,
-0.7648137211799622,
0.11437858641147614,
-0.305607408285141,
-0.4604261517524719,
0.10124307125806808,
-0.3322548568248749,
0.13210603594779968,
0.030187727883458138,
0.12322314083576202,
-0.37813976407051086,
-0.27200934290885925,
0.7600575685501099,
0.0450790636241436,
0.7579131126403809,
0.6696038246154785,
-0.5417804718017578,
0.18438202142715454,
-0.7122766971588135,
0.005708983633667231,
-0.1842312216758728,
-0.5999829173088074,
-0.2840774357318878,
-0.13179044425487518,
0.5131775736808777,
0.29380378127098083,
0.2273796945810318,
-0.7239126563072205,
0.585793673992157,
-0.6175501346588135,
0.4093429148197174,
0.5334277749061584,
0.08441085368394852,
0.41776329278945923,
-0.14527298510074615,
0.3954547047615051,
0.01574692688882351,
-0.008233957923948765,
0.0034407542552798986,
-0.7219669222831726,
-0.8299418687820435,
-0.16384252905845642,
0.4481780529022217,
0.7947197556495667,
-0.5294185280799866,
0.41555193066596985,
-0.07902424037456512,
-0.11346344649791718,
-0.3145867586135864,
0.11715026199817657,
0.3874869644641876,
0.2577194273471832,
0.3711460828781128,
-0.15665888786315918,
-0.46273037791252136,
-0.8886228799819946,
-0.623614490032196,
-0.15994642674922943,
-0.03612035512924194,
0.3279404938220978,
0.5557069778442383,
-0.251007080078125,
0.7073325514793396,
-0.9168659448623657,
-0.4867037832736969,
-0.28633928298950195,
0.4033735394477844,
0.05065516382455826,
0.2160664051771164,
0.4695937931537628,
-0.9776275753974915,
-0.3880409002304077,
0.2139434665441513,
-0.7891044020652771,
0.09467826038599014,
-0.1907588094472885,
0.04545092210173607,
0.10604320466518402,
0.5301898717880249,
-0.8337754607200623,
0.0674806609749794,
0.014487816952168941,
-0.5496487617492676,
0.03647572174668312,
-0.12132798880338669,
0.44338616728782654,
-0.9317651987075806,
-0.1512955278158188,
0.3538443446159363,
-0.44948217272758484,
-0.6809257864952087,
-0.11419244110584259,
-0.24446983635425568,
-0.26059094071388245,
-0.4080096483230591,
0.23758162558078766,
-0.26834478974342346,
-0.04943137988448143,
-0.33249157667160034,
0.02468111924827099,
-0.008231193758547306,
0.364076167345047,
0.009469816461205482,
0.40811586380004883,
0.6067935228347778,
-0.4487278461456299,
0.36615505814552307,
-0.03848402202129364,
-0.3679422438144684,
0.7241695523262024,
-0.30882054567337036,
-0.3198639452457428,
-0.0740441158413887,
0.24575255811214447,
-1.0347423553466797,
-0.7143555283546448,
0.23977051675319672,
-0.4828176200389862,
0.6587395071983337,
0.2236562967300415,
-0.5245452523231506,
-0.5394061803817749,
-0.29502084851264954,
-0.1667129397392273,
0.4828265905380249,
-0.1767180860042572,
0.32029175758361816,
0.4432761073112488,
-0.04594546556472778,
-0.4249410033226013,
-0.9991039633750916,
0.03216836228966713,
-0.36931830644607544,
-0.34498804807662964,
0.4684828519821167,
0.0019380786688998342,
-0.3865792155265808,
0.09147246181964874,
-0.29570895433425903,
-0.327976256608963,
0.10416381061077118,
0.3504514992237091,
0.06057485193014145,
-0.2036549299955368,
0.43012094497680664,
0.33895793557167053,
0.18614241480827332,
0.10146953910589218,
-0.005759809631854296,
0.4580932855606079,
-0.3555777668952942,
0.10560616850852966,
-0.37070176005363464,
0.5103617906570435,
0.7630900144577026,
0.03056504763662815,
0.6239114999771118,
0.35452020168304443,
-0.42626234889030457,
-0.29519543051719666,
0.24395348131656647,
-0.08382720500230789,
-0.5078840851783752,
0.1281331181526184,
-0.3172377645969391,
-0.8342966437339783,
0.33343058824539185,
-0.3384872376918793,
-0.46025994420051575,
0.22517332434654236,
0.4527865946292877,
-0.501848042011261,
0.8154259324073792,
0.5508255958557129,
0.3742057979106903,
0.30048009753227234,
0.041946616023778915,
0.3152877986431122,
-0.31023097038269043,
-0.6359250545501709,
-0.34186580777168274,
-0.30365273356437683,
-0.680314838886261,
-0.12246666103601456,
0.26697656512260437,
0.10422302782535553,
-0.22016111016273499,
0.40564900636672974,
-0.5144482254981995,
0.5388806462287903,
0.2171618491411209,
0.28364554047584534,
0.08749977499246597,
-0.01368949469178915,
0.15932738780975342,
0.050118863582611084,
-0.22399380803108215,
-0.4628753960132599,
0.8040297627449036,
0.30450817942619324,
0.5412811636924744,
0.05304211750626564,
0.8967501521110535,
0.5465192198753357,
0.2979160249233246,
-1.117887258529663,
0.7072440385818481,
-0.32540246844291687,
-0.6868459582328796,
0.1461426168680191,
-0.5868420600891113,
-1.109096646308899,
-0.13086676597595215,
-0.3659364581108093,
-0.8571907877922058,
0.19722424447536469,
-0.2056804746389389,
-0.3052535057067871,
0.04354209080338478,
-0.9509950876235962,
0.885211169719696,
-0.18237194418907166,
0.38437387347221375,
-0.05094684660434723,
-1.0323817729949951,
0.35165342688560486,
0.2244187295436859,
0.323405921459198,
-0.11317019909620285,
0.18613660335540771,
0.648460865020752,
-0.5476239919662476,
0.5407615303993225,
0.09313356131315231,
-0.00661158561706543,
0.5342859625816345,
-0.07714240252971649,
-0.21966911852359772,
-0.4198816418647766,
0.4763125479221344,
-0.35380440950393677,
0.003543308237567544,
-0.37086260318756104,
-0.9485729932785034,
0.9254835247993469,
-0.5440096259117126,
-0.20915929973125458,
-0.6959725022315979,
-0.0841895267367363,
-0.1816592961549759,
0.2755413353443146,
0.3067936897277832,
0.4563349485397339,
0.12301231175661087,
-0.15621308982372284,
0.7334794402122498,
-0.2963436245918274,
0.35953229665756226,
0.16790470480918884,
-0.5212938189506531,
-0.3077019453048706,
0.9895795583724976,
0.22836574912071228,
0.34364578127861023,
0.7233696579933167,
0.21874478459358215,
-0.2839623987674713,
-0.16281424462795258,
-0.03486327826976776,
0.272478312253952,
-0.8294123411178589,
-0.23578594624996185,
-0.5088375210762024,
0.023138325661420822,
-0.470133900642395,
0.028853299096226692,
-0.26666074991226196,
-0.5801631808280945,
-0.10516770929098129,
-0.2738879919052124,
0.6465581655502319,
0.7675508856773376,
0.07064196467399597,
0.23913191258907318,
-0.7874791622161865,
0.5330054759979248,
0.3601306080818176,
0.5628066658973694,
-0.42648524045944214,
0.35414063930511475,
-0.06394457072019577,
-0.12657023966312408,
-0.17523601651191711,
-1.092805027961731,
0.1482429802417755,
0.4981272518634796,
0.41451728343963623,
0.25759604573249817,
0.04499940946698189,
0.29599621891975403,
-0.565184473991394,
0.7239588499069214,
0.23352113366127014,
-0.975043535232544,
0.9317912459373474,
-0.42019423842430115,
0.14379601180553436,
0.6147297620773315,
0.7030366659164429,
-0.5737851858139038,
-0.46291303634643555,
-0.3850161135196686,
-0.8650190830230713,
0.39886853098869324,
0.4549065828323364,
0.015247264876961708,
-0.3410003185272217,
0.5054500102996826,
-0.21159593760967255,
0.36268457770347595,
-0.7499847412109375,
-0.8056229948997498,
-0.08856434375047684,
-0.8069044351577759,
0.20463129878044128,
0.03210630640387535,
-0.1024494469165802,
0.04473656415939331,
0.029803814366459846,
0.07286204397678375,
0.4006609320640564,
0.3866613507270813,
-0.2719790041446686,
-0.025327472016215324,
0.7327449321746826,
0.41337457299232483,
0.19271837174892426,
-0.5432408452033997,
0.44134777784347534,
-0.38395166397094727,
-0.7210458517074585,
0.31503456830978394,
-0.1828615963459015,
0.1448487639427185,
-0.10304714739322662,
0.3194207549095154,
0.32036569714546204,
0.1162688359618187,
-1.0353294610977173,
0.33731159567832947,
-0.042577795684337616,
0.09106387197971344,
0.032941851764917374,
0.43678510189056396,
0.046537160873413086,
0.3695127069950104,
0.09679028391838074,
0.4188908338546753,
0.7976077795028687,
-1.406220555305481,
0.6367388367652893,
0.043040044605731964,
-0.7135756015777588,
-0.1583484411239624,
0.2661792039871216,
-0.09842029958963394,
-0.5966368913650513,
0.48558562994003296,
-0.10688004642724991,
-0.6876410841941833,
0.4665461778640747,
0.6252608895301819,
0.7935650944709778,
-0.32017892599105835,
0.5393020510673523,
0.15480941534042358,
-0.35765865445137024,
-0.0794767215847969,
0.32224929332733154,
0.08607962727546692,
-0.46050316095352173,
-0.1316586285829544,
-0.6063791513442993,
-0.09692355245351791,
-0.20056019723415375,
-0.6741880774497986,
0.2959699332714081,
-0.5812593698501587,
-0.2870030403137207,
0.5374049544334412,
0.11227942258119583,
-0.05473843961954117,
0.5028162002563477,
0.6145117878913879,
0.5648894906044006,
-1.0806196928024292,
0.6871654391288757,
0.883923351764679,
-0.5073781609535217,
-0.3680376708507538,
-0.11105252057313919,
0.18776807188987732,
-0.08135659247636795,
0.5346022248268127,
0.5473716259002686,
-0.27325135469436646,
-0.34918978810310364,
-0.9342644214630127,
-0.4065474569797516,
0.6918404698371887,
-0.1191156730055809,
-0.291716068983078,
-0.051448382437229156,
0.16199041903018951,
0.8962344527244568,
-0.4354248046875,
-0.020098764449357986,
0.44275999069213867,
0.3964616656303406,
0.18492962419986725,
-0.7734438180923462,
-0.005198861472308636,
-0.6438997387886047,
-0.18730922043323517,
0.12947197258472443,
-0.23535247147083282,
1.1243245601654053,
-0.24991026520729065,
-0.476560115814209,
-0.001802067388780415,
0.6875549554824829,
0.25928810238838196,
0.5286930203437805,
0.4416240453720093,
0.3968908488750458,
1.0148403644561768,
-0.2949555218219757,
1.2115072011947632,
0.2415817677974701,
0.5841767191886902,
0.7940492033958435,
-0.12259625643491745,
0.8932331800460815,
0.4798007309436798,
-0.4647824168205261,
1.104451298713684,
0.8630325198173523,
-0.15718010067939758,
0.6891194581985474,
0.6842770576477051,
-0.38211262226104736,
-0.12082601338624954,
-0.037343788892030716,
-0.001236440846696496,
0.3984374701976776,
0.6659608483314514,
-0.013011985458433628,
-0.22022300958633423,
0.7583514451980591,
0.22665531933307648,
0.3352457880973816,
-0.3007572889328003,
0.6850683093070984,
0.5137243270874023,
-0.47480595111846924,
0.10449682176113129,
-0.06469401717185974,
0.5232346057891846,
-0.4984004497528076,
-0.19656547904014587,
0.03623361513018608,
0.5116378664970398,
-0.3967963457107544,
-1.0722852945327759,
0.21287918090820312,
-0.26901838183403015,
-0.08924274891614914,
0.267345130443573,
0.6329341530799866,
-0.6812304854393005,
-0.25439706444740295,
0.06793186813592911,
-0.11273860931396484,
0.15078620612621307,
0.07821688801050186,
-0.737293004989624,
-0.3096539378166199,
0.023442717269062996,
-0.2125624269247055,
0.45433932542800903,
0.5556356310844421,
0.050857581198215485,
0.9512268900871277,
0.39411282539367676,
0.0000027889429929928156,
0.06819182634353638,
0.0023661928717046976,
0.6432577967643738,
-0.9586296677589417,
-0.18150198459625244,
-0.7823513150215149,
0.4524386525154114,
-0.14446762204170227,
-0.33069199323654175,
0.9034613966941833,
0.6618228554725647,
0.44142675399780273,
-0.25353172421455383,
0.37200242280960083,
0.06335621327161789,
0.3354818522930145,
-0.5172658562660217,
0.723075270652771,
-0.7512245178222656,
0.12551163136959076,
-0.453113853931427,
-0.6976438164710999,
-0.9164670705795288,
0.7096896767616272,
0.1614343672990799,
-0.16850681602954865,
0.9063823819160461,
0.4178156852722168,
0.221884086728096,
0.0005043772980570793,
-0.25923624634742737,
0.11614708602428436,
0.33729591965675354,
0.5817503929138184,
0.6255343556404114,
-0.5851801633834839,
0.1364084780216217,
0.000005738679647038225,
0.04417307674884796,
-0.2794569432735443,
-0.3010645806789398,
-0.8499728441238403,
-0.49048712849617004,
-0.5187698602676392,
-0.8992239236831665,
-0.1539871096611023,
1.241182804107666,
0.14531424641609192,
-0.9634012579917908,
-0.4194530248641968,
-0.3804740905761719,
0.5131433010101318,
0.10655912011861801,
-0.2976876497268677,
0.40912166237831116,
-0.5621314644813538,
-0.6830967664718628,
0.19898609817028046,
0.4670453667640686,
0.39678001403808594,
-0.2330782264471054,
0.16660736501216888,
-0.364846795797348,
0.2204485833644867,
0.6172652840614319,
0.34241822361946106,
-0.5003947019577026,
-0.0013213061029091477,
0.30194729566574097,
-0.5553228259086609,
0.4480590522289276,
0.9838974475860596,
-0.5912076830863953,
0.7129342555999756,
0.5954039692878723,
-0.012882212176918983,
0.4864722788333893,
-0.2687135636806488,
0.7052065134048462,
-0.48158472776412964,
-0.09258481860160828,
0.3105672299861908,
0.25200286507606506,
0.3202904462814331,
-0.2637590765953064,
0.1401834934949875,
0.11613057553768158,
-0.44356146454811096,
-0.9133802056312561,
0.3479403853416443,
-1.701666235923767,
-0.8711917996406555,
0.9952766299247742,
-0.2867021858692169,
-0.978401243686676,
-0.19647102057933807,
-0.32019925117492676,
0.2667096257209778,
-0.3321225047111511,
0.5731117129325867,
0.5744662284851074,
-0.2827463150024414,
-0.13825297355651855,
-0.32399097084999084,
0.8600088357925415,
-0.24907530844211578,
-1.0379329919815063,
-0.306497722864151,
0.1993754655122757,
0.19556139409542084,
0.7176423072814941,
0.4575663208961487,
-0.2803720533847809,
-0.02902042679488659,
0.05841096490621567,
0.05595861375331879,
0.6648922562599182,
-0.42759621143341064,
-0.057639267295598984,
0.1533782035112381,
-0.03739585727453232,
-0.09313420206308365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01472v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01472v2
|
WARDEN: Multi-Directional Backdoor Watermarks for Embedding-as-a-Service Copyright Protection
| 2024-03-03T10:39:27 | 2024-06-09T04:34:55 |
Anudeex Shetty, Yue Teng, Ke He, Qiongkai Xu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Embedding as a Service (EaaS) has become a widely adopted solution, which
offers feature extraction capabilities for addressing various downstream tasks
in Natural Language Processing (NLP). Prior studies have shown that EaaS can be
prone to model extraction attacks; nevertheless, this concern could be
mitigated by adding backdoor watermarks to the text embeddings and subsequently
verifying the attack models post-publication. Through the analysis of the
recent watermarking strategy for EaaS, EmbMarker, we design a novel CSE
(Clustering, Selection, Elimination) attack that removes the backdoor watermark
while maintaining the high utility of embeddings, indicating that the previous
watermarking approach can be breached. In response to this new threat, we
propose a new protocol to make the removal of watermarks more challenging by
incorporating multiple possible watermark directions. Our defense approach,
WARDEN, notably increases the stealthiness of watermarks and has been
empirically shown to be effective against CSE attack.
|
[
-0.5651654005050659,
-0.6026475429534912,
0.41009965538978577,
0.5919274091720581,
-0.2675792872905731,
0.40253034234046936,
0.10114762932062149,
-0.4801962375640869,
0.4148877263069153,
0.721356213092804,
-0.4819124639034271,
-0.6869968175888062,
-1.0825151205062866,
0.1301879733800888,
-0.6463002562522888,
0.5340823531150818,
0.11443246155977249,
0.1639251708984375,
0.22752618789672852,
-0.2658076584339142,
-0.7413532733917236,
-0.4362180829048157,
-0.9649698138237,
0.21303001046180725,
0.6149162650108337,
0.12248503416776657,
0.5627154111862183,
0.6794739961624146,
0.3605808913707733,
0.22986021637916565,
-0.008792050182819366,
-0.19932740926742554,
-0.08122091740369797,
0.4822220206260681,
-0.2622571885585785,
-0.21328380703926086,
-0.22528615593910217,
0.09609410166740417,
0.5340206623077393,
0.038990605622529984,
-0.015391881577670574,
-0.1157803013920784,
-0.035804398357868195,
0.750485360622406,
-1.1153862476348877,
-0.2056538313627243,
-0.6381180882453918,
0.23359237611293793,
-0.20781941711902618,
-0.045361705124378204,
-0.5411316752433777,
-0.1674448400735855,
0.15313228964805603,
-0.6042052507400513,
-0.16857412457466125,
0.270271897315979,
0.89506596326828,
0.14855404198169708,
-0.04514043778181076,
-0.22233536839485168,
-0.4278792440891266,
0.85419100522995,
-0.3303242623806,
0.3784916400909424,
0.34778955578804016,
0.547926127910614,
0.10696671158075333,
-0.6059783697128296,
-0.23998789489269257,
0.3204476237297058,
0.16748814284801483,
0.24983097612857819,
-0.6285189390182495,
-0.5681180357933044,
0.15179336071014404,
0.026006076484918594,
-0.24626174569129944,
0.17638564109802246,
0.014242785051465034,
-0.23330193758010864,
0.7326430678367615,
-0.06808102130889893,
0.47000619769096375,
0.045900557190179825,
-0.6460165977478027,
-0.14786279201507568,
-0.9535080790519714,
0.17932073771953583,
0.6082074046134949,
0.03626466542482376,
0.08515137434005737,
0.3422054052352905,
0.1727566123008728,
0.01664031483232975,
0.18182383477687836,
0.41710013151168823,
-0.0032997652888298035,
0.29184889793395996,
0.10283143818378448,
0.3108861744403839,
0.6047734022140503,
0.38557273149490356,
-0.14356881380081177,
-0.6220205426216125,
-0.41947802901268005,
-0.06769196689128876,
0.4994516372680664,
-0.9286735653877258,
-0.009310162626206875,
0.46296426653862,
-0.5585001111030579,
-0.5455363392829895,
0.5169044733047485,
-0.9669578075408936,
-0.4785563051700592,
0.11715005338191986,
0.43110716342926025,
-0.4374008774757385,
-0.20960791409015656,
-0.07843982428312302,
-0.642232358455658,
0.7355380058288574,
0.08144156634807587,
-0.5706387162208557,
0.4199609160423279,
0.8374367356300354,
0.8306359648704529,
-0.36358609795570374,
-0.22530339658260345,
-1.0256459712982178,
0.8933587074279785,
-0.20687389373779297,
0.9307752251625061,
-0.8802944421768188,
-0.6683990359306335,
-0.03032381646335125,
0.29337480664253235,
0.18253980576992035,
-0.32953116297721863,
0.04088558256626129,
-1.0119237899780273,
-0.16019879281520844,
-0.42566806077957153,
-0.526831328868866,
-0.19508430361747742,
0.2563672363758087,
-0.8821168541908264,
0.5443630814552307,
-0.3572475016117096,
-0.5636090040206909,
0.258285790681839,
-0.657241702079773,
-0.3108537495136261,
0.07938654720783234,
-0.39600902795791626,
-0.6562989354133606,
-0.05338975042104721,
0.6168370842933655,
0.3234499394893646,
-0.030584288761019707,
-0.06711395829916,
-0.41084024310112,
-0.2464042454957962,
0.3346173167228699,
-0.37400728464126587,
0.890006959438324,
0.07252732664346695,
-0.5927788615226746,
0.0286448672413826,
-0.6886683106422424,
0.07734827697277069,
0.0703597292304039,
-0.04926776513457298,
-0.5628837943077087,
0.14605477452278137,
-0.08158423006534576,
0.21400363743305206,
0.2493066042661667,
-0.8699082732200623,
0.05789140611886978,
-0.1374807208776474,
0.4216843545436859,
1.134379506111145,
0.2831057012081146,
0.5833125114440918,
-0.10697343945503235,
0.6961520910263062,
0.04277335852384567,
0.5660685300827026,
0.04253067076206207,
-0.8907446265220642,
-0.1621125191450119,
-0.9864040613174438,
0.22974003851413727,
0.5053838491439819,
-0.6078644394874573,
0.5157783627510071,
0.13861802220344543,
-0.5938416719436646,
-0.46545469760894775,
0.10149705410003662,
0.6262997388839722,
-0.17925140261650085,
0.6650499105453491,
-0.3924911320209503,
-0.20088453590869904,
-0.8525272607803345,
-0.7014748454093933,
0.4967672824859619,
0.03713536635041237,
0.19251161813735962,
0.2941296398639679,
-0.5164602994918823,
1.1076014041900635,
-0.6332494020462036,
-0.4040708839893341,
0.15379007160663605,
0.06440530717372894,
-0.2747146189212799,
0.5617971420288086,
0.6632090210914612,
-0.9877645969390869,
-0.6824156045913696,
-0.22716903686523438,
-0.7361591458320618,
-0.2716389000415802,
0.27999547123908997,
-0.18975642323493958,
0.01203853264451027,
0.6977448463439941,
-0.3645131587982178,
0.8063740134239197,
0.6598785519599915,
-0.4715791940689087,
0.5104129314422607,
0.05036378279328346,
0.0061087110079824924,
-0.7416940927505493,
0.007126137614250183,
-0.30267250537872314,
-0.006527558900415897,
-0.285404235124588,
0.35216477513313293,
0.21106618642807007,
-0.6228994131088257,
-0.24970705807209015,
0.512583315372467,
-0.5267384648323059,
-0.18729856610298157,
-0.3415224850177765,
0.03478829562664032,
0.1060999184846878,
0.2928468883037567,
-0.10522796958684921,
0.5871957540512085,
0.9024832248687744,
-0.5161240696907043,
0.2002921849489212,
0.4125423729419708,
0.34469741582870483,
0.8186308145523071,
-0.7450376152992249,
0.421124130487442,
-0.1575150340795517,
0.24961715936660767,
-0.7521945238113403,
0.5394417643547058,
0.2922176420688629,
-0.23396697640419006,
0.39552056789398193,
-0.379019558429718,
-0.22568616271018982,
0.07328012585639954,
-0.8522138595581055,
0.15596073865890503,
0.11382690817117691,
-0.7813733816146851,
1.0427148342132568,
0.3311600983142853,
-0.11349379271268845,
-0.7587863802909851,
-0.6980851292610168,
0.32437700033187866,
-0.19708971679210663,
-0.6321130394935608,
0.8654113411903381,
-0.0937131717801094,
-0.10043106973171234,
0.20906901359558105,
-0.09964067488908768,
-0.24764281511306763,
0.27065134048461914,
0.5016714334487915,
-0.06357161700725555,
-0.12088067084550858,
-0.40410536527633667,
0.27537569403648376,
-0.6761385798454285,
0.13446414470672607,
-0.1691826581954956,
0.4099034368991852,
-0.03556283935904503,
-0.6528844833374023,
-0.4116980731487274,
1.0807253122329712,
0.3709101974964142,
-0.6411730647087097,
0.7578573226928711,
0.6677883863449097,
-0.40977218747138977,
-0.2119123935699463,
-0.49087995290756226,
-0.35832875967025757,
-0.5504404306411743,
-0.04274237900972366,
-0.22556649148464203,
-0.5619570016860962,
0.7497879862785339,
0.1196247860789299,
0.40634873509407043,
0.16610927879810333,
-0.1675838679075241,
0.022986026480793953,
1.1600942611694336,
0.6629865169525146,
-0.153957337141037,
0.6521543860435486,
-0.41012042760849,
0.539936900138855,
-1.0436122417449951,
-0.2633987069129944,
-0.6903716325759888,
-0.2934536635875702,
-0.551758885383606,
0.08015952259302139,
0.03053056262433529,
0.25812476873397827,
-0.13001276552677155,
0.642789900302887,
-0.49160677194595337,
0.310477614402771,
0.4137710928916931,
0.21527279913425446,
0.28858035802841187,
0.06537381559610367,
-0.1415402889251709,
-0.1413981169462204,
-0.28731784224510193,
-0.6273403763771057,
0.9558539986610413,
0.332855761051178,
0.5559096336364746,
0.47162261605262756,
1.0999425649642944,
0.3947239816188812,
0.43844467401504517,
-0.5738130211830139,
0.5462428331375122,
-0.13665229082107544,
-0.5513677000999451,
-0.3702058792114258,
-0.019632380455732346,
-0.9512328505516052,
0.3493603765964508,
-0.16854248940944672,
-0.6638550162315369,
0.3869543671607971,
-0.08141427487134933,
-0.3514600992202759,
0.3132316470146179,
-0.6202613711357117,
0.7026926875114441,
-0.061241619288921356,
-0.5958576202392578,
-0.3680226802825928,
-0.4155241549015045,
-0.394546240568161,
-0.14780203998088837,
0.4152359962463379,
0.10779698938131332,
-0.39081496000289917,
0.7440286874771118,
-0.5631875991821289,
0.672253429889679,
-0.6041319966316223,
-0.23869410157203674,
0.10758588463068008,
0.26084399223327637,
0.7929185628890991,
0.4100900888442993,
0.17913411557674408,
0.2331709861755371,
0.016768498346209526,
-0.5274180173873901,
-0.6501421928405762,
0.6018701791763306,
-0.5309247970581055,
-0.7093058824539185,
-0.5745810270309448,
0.03631197661161423,
-0.19916440546512604,
0.19860363006591797,
0.17594659328460693,
0.5756306648254395,
0.026036620140075684,
0.29613181948661804,
0.6202171444892883,
-0.5071553587913513,
0.882151186466217,
0.7817056179046631,
-0.0205558892339468,
-0.6854076981544495,
0.8777345418930054,
0.02076096460223198,
0.05232521519064903,
0.2247968167066574,
0.3453369736671448,
-0.2336471825838089,
-0.6239097118377686,
-0.25629445910453796,
-0.011780180037021637,
-0.6161733865737915,
-0.19891200959682465,
-0.7464818954467773,
-0.4096052646636963,
-0.20476123690605164,
-0.6716418266296387,
-0.5071573853492737,
-0.08093063533306122,
-0.0124308867380023,
0.2067824751138687,
0.45730119943618774,
0.7344969511032104,
0.011427554301917553,
0.4206022620201111,
-0.8126198649406433,
0.34926557540893555,
0.5925287008285522,
0.39425310492515564,
0.051583752036094666,
-0.24828864634037018,
0.11068105697631836,
-0.185029536485672,
-0.6302297711372375,
-1.053371548652649,
0.3504900634288788,
-0.10764621198177338,
0.7509300112724304,
0.6464544534683228,
-0.20379261672496796,
0.42651090025901794,
-0.7701570987701416,
0.7458217740058899,
0.33638623356819153,
-0.9563043713569641,
0.4717831015586853,
-0.17809079587459564,
-0.041630689054727554,
0.3216173052787781,
0.17802095413208008,
-0.27011147141456604,
-0.625356137752533,
-0.7449816465377808,
-1.041597604751587,
0.16233772039413452,
0.21579137444496155,
0.07498869299888611,
-0.032272566109895706,
0.033616144210100174,
0.09769447892904282,
0.342338502407074,
-0.557043194770813,
-0.28761425614356995,
-0.4395228624343872,
0.19797374308109283,
0.230152428150177,
-0.21205466985702515,
-0.11529474705457687,
-0.05266449600458145,
0.9425367116928101,
0.06445429474115372,
0.5175953507423401,
0.24140602350234985,
-0.20390544831752777,
0.20734184980392456,
0.4154812693595886,
0.14139863848686218,
0.3426492214202881,
-0.01806741952896118,
0.07844074815511703,
-0.09344787150621414,
-0.6926461458206177,
0.017349034547805786,
-0.11492795497179031,
-0.31888777017593384,
-0.07773896306753159,
0.27259448170661926,
0.07488307356834412,
0.4892687201499939,
-0.11023862659931183,
1.0109347105026245,
-0.10801362246274948,
0.15424808859825134,
-0.42957305908203125,
-0.21869027614593506,
-0.08317716419696808,
0.21290509402751923,
0.6799745559692383,
0.27010345458984375,
0.0751751959323883,
-0.2700987458229065,
0.35158228874206543,
0.6375635862350464,
-0.653315544128418,
-0.2008701115846634,
0.3385944962501526,
0.22587840259075165,
-0.3301701247692108,
0.06434646248817444,
-0.2746279239654541,
-0.6661916971206665,
0.5880020260810852,
0.5655479431152344,
1.3893835544586182,
-0.3185603618621826,
0.1364867389202118,
-0.06003677845001221,
0.5635656714439392,
0.11842534691095352,
0.41096609830856323,
0.09198106080293655,
-0.6238943338394165,
-0.10937713086605072,
-0.39191174507141113,
-0.31299105286598206,
-0.08935202658176422,
-0.963057816028595,
0.19451117515563965,
-0.9669775366783142,
0.012975235469639301,
0.08033596724271774,
-0.2376786768436432,
-0.5129926800727844,
-0.19984199106693268,
-0.14673586189746857,
0.8676374554634094,
-0.6477368474006653,
0.5368391275405884,
0.4148887097835541,
-0.35437050461769104,
-0.581329345703125,
0.05501418933272362,
-0.04851256683468819,
-0.6256341338157654,
0.3302151560783386,
0.44105708599090576,
-0.4482405185699463,
0.21572574973106384,
-0.7460128664970398,
-0.6921132802963257,
1.0906782150268555,
0.28237321972846985,
-0.5043601989746094,
0.3380250334739685,
-0.3911197781562805,
0.18482717871665955,
-0.37195268273353577,
-0.23561938107013702,
0.32490530610084534,
0.6728494167327881,
-0.5047137141227722,
-0.09187880158424377,
0.45160046219825745,
-0.13536976277828217,
0.08925577253103256,
-0.08070506155490875,
-0.5361364483833313,
0.5503416657447815,
0.18752644956111908,
-0.23247382044792175,
-0.005292649380862713,
0.3510156571865082,
0.35018670558929443,
0.2623157501220703,
0.4223557710647583,
0.5889859795570374,
0.29906439781188965,
-0.002233202336356044,
0.9008852243423462,
-0.24835245311260223,
-0.04332940652966499,
0.7035306692123413,
-0.49913841485977173,
0.9897923469543457,
0.907636821269989,
0.1466193050146103,
0.8286799192428589,
-0.040887873619794846,
-0.4478597939014435,
0.9382346868515015,
-0.07586146891117096,
-0.23647630214691162,
-0.07826238870620728,
0.06166178360581398,
-0.5448734164237976,
0.3962516486644745,
0.211419478058815,
-0.30822885036468506,
-0.08409386873245239,
0.1461142599582672,
-0.03774716332554817,
0.3919983208179474,
-0.35263553261756897,
0.792486310005188,
0.24057266116142273,
-0.18854835629463196,
-0.09217897802591324,
0.40632328391075134,
0.816867470741272,
-0.7385430335998535,
0.027640260756015778,
0.05696902796626091,
-0.008435922674834728,
-0.3684302270412445,
-0.6072646379470825,
0.4251851439476013,
0.0019842025358229876,
-0.18687613308429718,
-0.3795931041240692,
0.6239469051361084,
-0.06129320338368416,
0.00700624193996191,
0.8755559921264648,
0.20449097454547882,
-0.10970129072666168,
-0.4239962697029114,
-0.9585615396499634,
0.17737942934036255,
-0.47885841131210327,
-0.20796412229537964,
0.2550280690193176,
0.16019867360591888,
-0.11954743415117264,
0.7111803293228149,
0.8315765261650085,
0.24763670563697815,
0.33803829550743103,
0.3378903567790985,
0.8560320734977722,
-0.6524521708488464,
-1.096370816230774,
-0.9247173070907593,
0.182639479637146,
-0.5532857179641724,
-0.07941839843988419,
1.1346317529678345,
0.5348721146583557,
0.34906911849975586,
-0.07980610430240631,
0.8292330503463745,
-0.012809526175260544,
0.09980709850788116,
-0.4330303370952606,
0.9404727816581726,
-0.2646007835865021,
0.2682156264781952,
-0.6970425248146057,
-0.7843675017356873,
-0.11691156029701233,
0.4540571868419647,
-0.26210519671440125,
-0.18146559596061707,
0.9364613890647888,
1.0266326665878296,
-0.004315090831369162,
0.4911668598651886,
0.19967173039913177,
-0.23482926189899445,
0.684092104434967,
0.32804277539253235,
0.9285683035850525,
-0.8030586242675781,
0.5358622074127197,
-0.2182379513978958,
-0.3099587559700012,
0.08555144816637039,
-1.1697028875350952,
-0.9151994585990906,
-0.31988978385925293,
-0.41097015142440796,
-0.3526367247104645,
0.07504944503307343,
0.5316434502601624,
0.6446139812469482,
-1.178084135055542,
0.24194452166557312,
0.021585898473858833,
0.1359606385231018,
-0.7859314680099487,
-0.2019452452659607,
0.3657476007938385,
-0.0011598009150475264,
-0.23026065528392792,
0.44817420840263367,
0.6448309421539307,
0.08335058391094208,
-0.350128173828125,
-0.1767592579126358,
-0.24046948552131653,
0.03517921268939972,
0.44392260909080505,
0.21450449526309967,
-0.541576623916626,
-0.4196907579898834,
-0.16391287744045258,
-0.2630045413970947,
-0.2592432498931885,
0.970417857170105,
-0.28826260566711426,
0.16987541317939758,
0.13997647166252136,
0.9745496511459351,
0.3770638108253479,
-0.28414756059646606,
0.657049834728241,
-0.9158776998519897,
0.3074553906917572,
0.1290271282196045,
0.35716918110847473,
0.2564146816730499,
-0.5253894329071045,
0.09627475589513779,
0.4447295367717743,
-0.04375256970524788,
-0.73105388879776,
0.2936759889125824,
-0.7335602641105652,
-0.4741511046886444,
0.9311760067939758,
-0.3953652083873749,
-0.3848625421524048,
-0.4831240177154541,
-0.18314996361732483,
-0.20075201988220215,
-0.6242300271987915,
0.7973796725273132,
0.7087937593460083,
0.5038350820541382,
0.08925870805978775,
-0.3757389187812805,
0.45832279324531555,
0.3614324927330017,
-0.6217561960220337,
0.0676112174987793,
0.00824076496064663,
0.4805712401866913,
0.38752099871635437,
0.21269598603248596,
-0.7067029476165771,
0.5478951930999756,
-0.07962648570537567,
-0.06391426920890808,
-0.3532067537307739,
-0.5512614846229553,
-0.5194947719573975,
0.3630436360836029,
-0.2219386100769043,
-0.39805665612220764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01469v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01469v2
|
KorMedMCQA: Multi-Choice Question Answering Benchmark for Korean Healthcare Professional Licensing Examinations
| 2024-03-03T10:31:49 | 2024-03-05T09:58:08 |
Sunjun Kweon, Byungjin Choi, Minkyu Kim, Rae Woong Park, Edward Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce KorMedMCQA, the first Korean multiple-choice question answering
(MCQA) benchmark derived from Korean healthcare professional licensing
examinations, covering from the year 2012 to year 2023. This dataset consists
of a selection of questions from the license examinations for doctors, nurses,
and pharmacists, featuring a diverse array of subjects. We conduct baseline
experiments on various large language models, including
proprietary/open-source, multilingual/Korean-additional pretrained, and
clinical context pretrained models, highlighting the potential for further
enhancements. We make our data publicly available on HuggingFace
(https://huggingface.co/datasets/sean0042/KorMedMCQA) and provide a evaluation
script via LM-Harness, inviting further exploration and advancement in Korean
healthcare environments.
|
[
-0.6127197742462158,
-0.43029189109802246,
0.722865879535675,
0.20609568059444427,
-0.13756923377513885,
0.12923337519168854,
0.1578138768672943,
-0.1999748945236206,
0.094840407371521,
0.8018458485603333,
-0.6339057087898254,
-0.5153130292892456,
-0.31273481249809265,
0.08233547955751419,
0.4521014988422394,
0.7573110461235046,
-0.2336292713880539,
0.42379963397979736,
-0.6091075539588928,
-0.5566274523735046,
-0.12255068123340607,
-0.5924428701400757,
-0.43986454606056213,
-0.4158836603164673,
0.8901644945144653,
0.5000512003898621,
0.6482282876968384,
0.2969287037849426,
0.287722647190094,
0.12613065540790558,
0.056285228580236435,
-0.004876250866800547,
-0.010606518015265465,
0.08396516740322113,
-0.02767355926334858,
-0.13380323350429535,
-0.596243679523468,
0.2585830092430115,
0.48712462186813354,
0.7314935922622681,
-0.06964189559221268,
0.6206991076469421,
-0.34211742877960205,
0.8671672344207764,
-0.7687144875526428,
-0.2237471342086792,
-0.13597546517848969,
0.10098841041326523,
0.1643647402524948,
-0.10548675060272217,
-0.18940027058124542,
-0.8180005550384521,
0.13233298063278198,
-0.40670856833457947,
-0.22641395032405853,
-0.3025124669075012,
0.9209495782852173,
0.2049904316663742,
-1.0753273963928223,
-0.3752463757991791,
0.013233574107289314,
0.4693986177444458,
-0.45399150252342224,
0.9091299176216125,
0.3396143317222595,
0.8058891296386719,
0.010891040787100792,
-1.1122390031814575,
-0.4147818684577942,
-0.5899152755737305,
0.3400242030620575,
0.5364284515380859,
0.22261112928390503,
0.13758142292499542,
-0.0752764642238617,
0.2961224913597107,
-0.5050303339958191,
-0.07500803470611572,
-0.4533475637435913,
-0.5343821048736572,
0.6974289417266846,
0.11565274745225906,
0.3565707802772522,
-0.18507535755634308,
-0.5313458442687988,
-0.09162689745426178,
-0.6553954482078552,
0.15992315113544464,
0.29988348484039307,
0.0017555882222950459,
-0.03591504320502281,
0.7706727385520935,
-0.5627280473709106,
0.49197736382484436,
-0.13467755913734436,
-0.18719448149204254,
0.5455552935600281,
-0.5213376879692078,
-0.29385051131248474,
0.25641071796417236,
0.7414852976799011,
0.7397528290748596,
0.014963971450924873,
-0.011164584197103977,
0.3097954988479614,
0.06169627606868744,
0.32805854082107544,
-0.6565066576004028,
-0.8014458417892456,
0.7422404289245605,
-0.5492838025093079,
-0.2923862338066101,
-0.1907907873392105,
-0.9845399260520935,
-0.5344786643981934,
-0.41998153924942017,
0.4240500330924988,
0.1415272206068039,
-0.46733349561691284,
0.24888615310192108,
0.133820042014122,
0.3374868929386139,
-0.03963668271899223,
-0.12317159026861191,
0.408221036195755,
0.44599103927612305,
0.5150082111358643,
-0.39268630743026733,
-0.1565372347831726,
-0.5630547404289246,
-0.4647083282470703,
-0.5027735233306885,
0.6161780953407288,
-0.15995058417320251,
-0.4810461401939392,
-0.19473041594028473,
0.2789776921272278,
-0.18233293294906616,
-0.8443081378936768,
0.848700761795044,
-0.6462624073028564,
0.10832596570253372,
-0.5605509877204895,
-0.42402881383895874,
0.10165359824895859,
0.41365358233451843,
-0.5780125260353088,
1.1112010478973389,
0.4828471839427948,
-0.7222887277603149,
0.45395585894584656,
-0.5294075012207031,
0.10702599585056305,
0.06330743432044983,
-0.23945893347263336,
-0.5387706160545349,
-0.23343101143836975,
0.4278249442577362,
0.4732130467891693,
0.039450034499168396,
0.2640417814254761,
-0.5090420246124268,
0.1671242117881775,
0.48780307173728943,
-0.24562931060791016,
1.1153422594070435,
0.3235650062561035,
0.3851833641529083,
0.044349879026412964,
-0.9849671721458435,
0.6030269265174866,
0.012958015315234661,
-0.5162538290023804,
-0.10977143794298172,
-0.5375298261642456,
-0.1324281096458435,
0.9749893546104431,
0.07918369770050049,
-0.7523036599159241,
0.06285473704338074,
0.048230089247226715,
-0.0002615426492411643,
0.3846246302127838,
0.5476461052894592,
0.2097969651222229,
-0.41435712575912476,
1.1941118240356445,
0.1304815411567688,
0.3222839832305908,
-0.029696190729737282,
-0.6942571997642517,
-0.27186155319213867,
-0.5445349216461182,
0.6306343674659729,
0.6958597302436829,
-0.994996964931488,
-0.1626615971326828,
-0.00396939180791378,
-0.8294399976730347,
-1.1625888347625732,
-0.18997317552566528,
0.5759506225585938,
0.7969114184379578,
0.4149337112903595,
-0.013993584550917149,
-0.4143116772174835,
-0.9302543997764587,
-0.38363444805145264,
-0.113718681037426,
-0.0926232635974884,
0.5781493782997131,
0.422414094209671,
-0.20397241413593292,
0.5221302509307861,
-0.6090750694274902,
0.13853146135807037,
-0.01825270801782608,
-0.25009456276893616,
0.13277770578861237,
0.27947402000427246,
0.5280434489250183,
-0.8551618456840515,
-0.7167763113975525,
-0.013567128218710423,
-0.4078773856163025,
-0.45758894085884094,
0.009864923544228077,
-0.3770869970321655,
-0.20334385335445404,
0.6802101731300354,
-0.41997990012168884,
0.0706423819065094,
0.8363613486289978,
-0.4325418174266815,
1.299095630645752,
-0.05942799523472786,
0.45583757758140564,
-1.1424793004989624,
0.11819011718034744,
-0.3112940788269043,
-0.32247063517570496,
-0.810347855091095,
0.3173489272594452,
0.4561094641685486,
-0.04617682471871376,
-0.7752014994621277,
0.7002457976341248,
-0.38221919536590576,
-0.04299004375934601,
0.04494093358516693,
0.3139232099056244,
-0.00037851231172680855,
0.2138403356075287,
-0.21629834175109863,
0.8147352337837219,
0.5270035862922668,
-0.8457143902778625,
0.3148135542869568,
0.3508884012699127,
-0.423037588596344,
0.9387363791465759,
-0.6984540820121765,
0.06414773315191269,
0.024407759308815002,
0.1290910542011261,
-1.0180153846740723,
-0.4620888829231262,
0.4293571710586548,
-0.6853675842285156,
-0.125130757689476,
-0.3483024835586548,
-0.2983724772930145,
-0.5000149607658386,
0.031730230897665024,
0.3510734736919403,
0.3187919855117798,
-0.4784267246723175,
0.309032678604126,
0.5169334411621094,
-0.30280598998069763,
-0.6718056797981262,
-0.455942839384079,
-0.28532809019088745,
-0.15025104582309723,
-0.20250089466571808,
-0.06727517396211624,
-0.26995471119880676,
-0.04540680721402168,
-0.19498756527900696,
-0.31288886070251465,
-0.41331392526626587,
0.019370852038264275,
0.10138189047574997,
0.5111371874809265,
-0.4669549763202667,
0.06189111992716789,
0.27737295627593994,
-0.07802370935678482,
0.562420129776001,
-0.1085539162158966,
0.39421775937080383,
-0.053489867597818375,
-0.4823639690876007,
-0.3404599130153656,
0.19734685122966766,
0.7546086311340332,
-0.23267048597335815,
0.4711587727069855,
0.567795991897583,
-0.15500551462173462,
0.3430054485797882,
-0.39273756742477417,
0.22405682504177094,
-0.5097758173942566,
0.5018588304519653,
-0.5411959290504456,
-1.0308098793029785,
0.5300946235656738,
-0.23770107328891754,
-0.06488879024982452,
0.3619396984577179,
0.8602358102798462,
0.1000853106379509,
1.1442885398864746,
-0.13081708550453186,
0.37080293893814087,
-0.3918812572956085,
0.40883907675743103,
-0.01988977938890457,
-1.042097806930542,
-0.49851560592651367,
-0.3951265811920166,
-0.0144925182685256,
-0.8457066416740417,
-0.548627495765686,
0.5640839338302612,
0.10142941027879715,
-0.39761990308761597,
0.0537518635392189,
-0.4699234366416931,
0.4389687478542328,
0.4251379072666168,
0.35682231187820435,
0.2517990469932556,
-0.6322250366210938,
-0.8889358043670654,
-0.1415684074163437,
-0.5442051887512207,
-0.42642346024513245,
1.4350310564041138,
0.4406205713748932,
0.22387385368347168,
0.006142726633697748,
0.6727351546287537,
-0.1270979642868042,
0.40988364815711975,
-0.7203770875930786,
0.5390891432762146,
0.34789833426475525,
-0.7492128610610962,
0.08393347263336182,
-0.5482422709465027,
-0.7819238901138306,
0.47639453411102295,
0.010634424164891243,
-0.6196544766426086,
0.2724214494228363,
0.15289676189422607,
-0.3933952748775482,
0.09304849058389664,
-0.547766923904419,
1.101549744606018,
-0.07601172477006912,
-0.016331462189555168,
0.6290287971496582,
-0.7962734699249268,
0.6118210554122925,
-0.15983155369758606,
-0.09301813691854477,
-0.4667847752571106,
-0.49769288301467896,
0.5437261462211609,
-0.1205999106168747,
0.10413505882024765,
-0.42832067608833313,
0.026589591056108475,
0.248845174908638,
-0.08021248877048492,
-0.10685949772596359,
0.5986897945404053,
-0.1047876849770546,
-0.08597937226295471,
0.7674591541290283,
-0.6327314972877502,
-0.4529002904891968,
0.5240196585655212,
-0.6402645111083984,
0.037382178008556366,
-0.3747483491897583,
-0.387342244386673,
-0.8272231221199036,
0.3802361488342285,
0.2845304012298584,
0.3838962912559509,
-0.2411782145500183,
0.007344791200011969,
0.8049794435501099,
-0.5632890462875366,
-0.22705696523189545,
0.5514680743217468,
-0.7523930072784424,
-0.7135194540023804,
0.6512329578399658,
0.10170692950487137,
0.6153202056884766,
-0.12596283853054047,
0.1657361537218094,
-0.7156810164451599,
-0.30093199014663696,
-0.6028931140899658,
0.29386305809020996,
-0.892312228679657,
-0.02120525948703289,
-1.1374098062515259,
-0.46824318170547485,
-0.23779472708702087,
-0.01113340724259615,
-0.5713568329811096,
-0.3368772566318512,
-0.05999772995710373,
-0.05461147055029869,
0.005981967784464359,
0.3356570303440094,
0.20626670122146606,
0.18722645938396454,
-0.8435471057891846,
0.6491351127624512,
0.34190332889556885,
0.7617971301078796,
-0.21844004094600677,
-0.30378514528274536,
-0.011207821778953075,
0.01407162006944418,
-0.2992287874221802,
-0.9141883850097656,
0.08812934905290604,
-0.12742511928081512,
0.7557945847511292,
0.26244163513183594,
0.2965525686740875,
0.45804521441459656,
-0.6054666638374329,
0.9538940787315369,
0.13382169604301453,
-0.47466424107551575,
0.09890412539243698,
-0.315811425447464,
0.8498522043228149,
1.070786952972412,
0.9091924428939819,
-0.8277341723442078,
-0.15173976123332977,
-0.5259584188461304,
-0.6354847550392151,
0.1843784749507904,
0.012803067453205585,
-0.09329944849014282,
-0.018153786659240723,
0.3296593129634857,
0.18862572312355042,
0.40764203667640686,
-0.35951492190361023,
-0.48561447858810425,
-0.07777108252048492,
-0.14712165296077728,
-0.011201927438378334,
-0.2727496325969696,
-0.07435911148786545,
-0.4306589961051941,
0.5702764391899109,
-0.06060856953263283,
0.4890477657318115,
0.391681969165802,
0.14678597450256348,
0.2121293842792511,
0.5196353197097778,
0.5380229949951172,
1.0471787452697754,
-0.09844353795051575,
0.03828402981162071,
0.14708846807479858,
-0.946543276309967,
0.3211475908756256,
0.2284824550151825,
0.15311725437641144,
0.19561061263084412,
-0.24821725487709045,
0.3074326515197754,
0.11294794827699661,
-0.9518284201622009,
0.2912463843822479,
-0.1336820125579834,
-0.8522804975509644,
-0.18697944283485413,
-0.18824301660060883,
0.39021456241607666,
0.18847858905792236,
-0.004754308611154556,
-0.23825694620609283,
0.1634664684534073,
-0.2241973727941513,
0.7067947387695312,
-0.023697787895798683,
-0.7962990403175354,
-0.03152809664607048,
0.8624557852745056,
-0.38185232877731323,
0.059820495545864105,
0.5360254049301147,
-0.07698099315166473,
-0.6604880690574646,
0.6239181160926819,
0.30908018350601196,
0.5406054854393005,
-0.47275209426879883,
0.6360163688659668,
0.608672022819519,
0.1230592355132103,
-0.07623384147882462,
0.995339035987854,
0.21513035893440247,
-0.45450326800346375,
-0.22692130506038666,
-0.38969287276268005,
-0.7135491967201233,
0.18113484978675842,
-1.1638036966323853,
0.02592051774263382,
-0.35172662138938904,
-0.31821319460868835,
0.06038330867886543,
0.2452845424413681,
-0.5893116593360901,
0.4780718684196472,
0.0039000757969915867,
1.2818968296051025,
-0.6002993583679199,
0.6248921155929565,
0.8907684087753296,
-0.16436976194381714,
-0.6821774244308472,
-0.18869754672050476,
0.08574739098548889,
-0.6297382712364197,
0.03612149506807327,
0.07957858592271805,
0.1484520435333252,
-0.10234592109918594,
-0.555570662021637,
-0.6189630627632141,
1.0338258743286133,
0.034498028457164764,
-0.14160864055156708,
0.3741557002067566,
0.3821907937526703,
0.514920175075531,
-0.40065309405326843,
-0.09557940810918808,
0.9297103881835938,
0.2347620278596878,
-0.09840895980596542,
-0.9255110621452332,
-0.07663578540086746,
-0.39600372314453125,
-0.3266347348690033,
0.22949886322021484,
-0.4175546169281006,
0.7521862983703613,
-0.062166471034288406,
0.15275061130523682,
0.1761505901813507,
0.25940218567848206,
0.8735193014144897,
0.8935365676879883,
0.3425769805908203,
0.427744060754776,
0.916370153427124,
-0.07001793384552002,
0.9916663765907288,
-0.05887074023485184,
0.16732296347618103,
1.5666513442993164,
-0.38482600450515747,
0.7754754424095154,
0.430850625038147,
-0.3833690285682678,
0.2519647181034088,
0.9725914001464844,
0.1827266365289688,
0.4726253151893616,
0.17031477391719818,
-0.32206976413726807,
-0.2931705713272095,
-0.15165375173091888,
-0.651487410068512,
0.34064024686813354,
0.15036705136299133,
-0.24316205084323883,
0.0378112867474556,
0.2605307698249817,
0.12524138391017914,
-0.036859236657619476,
-0.5630021095275879,
0.5920620560646057,
0.1831480860710144,
-0.7304041981697083,
0.39559656381607056,
-0.34377211332321167,
0.028083782643079758,
-0.543867826461792,
0.20335069298744202,
-0.0007050538551993668,
0.047965217381715775,
-0.0010693402728065848,
-0.9587429165840149,
0.03568058833479881,
-0.31846126914024353,
0.1953062117099762,
0.009180308319628239,
0.7538113594055176,
-0.590162456035614,
-0.421351820230484,
0.025246519595384598,
0.7092913389205933,
0.29981476068496704,
-0.16058306396007538,
-1.0582668781280518,
-0.22434623539447784,
-0.29628267884254456,
-0.08270512521266937,
0.4967308044433594,
0.3079266846179962,
0.15024840831756592,
0.8481326699256897,
0.5662684440612793,
0.22063110768795013,
0.40908199548721313,
0.04757218807935715,
1.0372270345687866,
-0.20633390545845032,
-0.8040545582771301,
-0.3073788583278656,
0.6508558392524719,
-0.12788215279579163,
-0.7179562449455261,
0.7286811470985413,
0.6292409300804138,
0.770261824131012,
-0.212092325091362,
0.630775511264801,
0.21066749095916748,
0.8376038074493408,
-0.42438799142837524,
1.078859806060791,
-0.707074761390686,
-0.327156662940979,
-0.3593229353427887,
-0.5607216954231262,
-0.12931154668331146,
-0.1440868228673935,
-0.10070331394672394,
0.2032194286584854,
0.4917896091938019,
0.6865406632423401,
-0.14675433933734894,
-0.041583649814128876,
0.5324774384498596,
-0.18763123452663422,
-0.09030196070671082,
0.42030179500579834,
0.7971647381782532,
-0.5877346396446228,
0.4635060429573059,
-0.5411444902420044,
0.003409476950764656,
-0.0857483297586441,
-0.7340998649597168,
-0.9196817874908447,
-0.5605776309967041,
-0.5488398671150208,
-0.7933841347694397,
-0.040509164333343506,
1.1873120069503784,
0.38605648279190063,
-1.0285564661026,
0.14417527616024017,
0.46412456035614014,
-0.07190977782011032,
-0.46769437193870544,
-0.24544598162174225,
0.46913015842437744,
0.04838407784700394,
-0.16192403435707092,
0.222733274102211,
0.11107002198696136,
-0.011837895959615707,
-0.15312707424163818,
-0.30515092611312866,
-0.4047059416770935,
0.26403161883354187,
0.5175067186355591,
0.5080193281173706,
-0.3201407492160797,
0.09992989897727966,
0.39577391743659973,
-0.3618043065071106,
0.36978599429130554,
0.6393042802810669,
-0.5766912698745728,
0.9340286254882812,
0.25226151943206787,
0.9008482098579407,
-0.015060474164783955,
0.17893949151039124,
0.313387006521225,
-0.42105841636657715,
-0.2593696713447571,
0.4779915511608124,
-0.1375436633825302,
0.029540350660681725,
-0.19847378134727478,
0.3280795216560364,
-0.07714203745126724,
-0.9475010633468628,
-0.886879563331604,
0.20037707686424255,
-1.0717347860336304,
-0.1363394558429718,
0.9380273818969727,
-0.2698429226875305,
-0.047089483588933945,
-0.6223772168159485,
-0.29679733514785767,
0.2817569971084595,
0.08740147203207016,
0.4653920531272888,
0.7510696649551392,
-0.1815679669380188,
-0.5137181282043457,
-1.4827220439910889,
0.766589879989624,
0.2052709311246872,
-1.0275192260742188,
-0.13370366394519806,
0.4503302574157715,
0.4572175145149231,
-0.3305153250694275,
1.0337060689926147,
-0.5468098521232605,
0.8926222920417786,
0.07753731310367584,
-0.1446876972913742,
-0.009077075868844986,
-0.32984277606010437,
-0.492342472076416,
0.21291227638721466,
-0.20202624797821045,
-0.5382299423217773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01461v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01461v1
|
Answerability in Retrieval-Augmented Open-Domain Question Answering
| 2024-03-03T09:55:35 | 2024-03-03T09:55:35 |
Rustam Abdumalikov, Pasquale Minervini, Yova Kementchedjhieva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The performance of Open-Domain Question Answering (ODQA) retrieval systems
can exhibit sub-optimal behavior, providing text excerpts with varying degrees
of irrelevance. Unfortunately, many existing ODQA datasets lack examples
specifically targeting the identification of irrelevant text excerpts. Previous
attempts to address this gap have relied on a simplistic approach of pairing
questions with random text excerpts. This paper aims to investigate the
effectiveness of models trained using this randomized strategy, uncovering an
important limitation in their ability to generalize to irrelevant text excerpts
with high semantic overlap. As a result, we observed a substantial decrease in
predictive accuracy, from 98% to 1%. To address this limitation, we discovered
an efficient approach for training models to recognize such excerpts. By
leveraging unanswerable pairs from the SQuAD 2.0 dataset, our models achieve a
nearly perfect (~100%) accuracy when confronted with these challenging text
excerpts.
|
[
-0.4626163840293884,
-0.8289245963096619,
0.5822804570198059,
-0.15282906591892242,
-0.022303907200694084,
0.09875272214412689,
0.026169776916503906,
-0.5607239007949829,
0.009306814521551132,
0.3609241843223572,
-0.68767249584198,
-0.175804004073143,
-0.31813740730285645,
0.11459106206893921,
-0.3804469406604767,
1.0721931457519531,
-0.3349417746067047,
0.037168215960264206,
-0.40867379307746887,
-0.5384780168533325,
-0.36649274826049805,
-0.576992928981781,
-0.33596840500831604,
-0.24246199429035187,
0.21591149270534515,
0.3091399669647217,
0.5317971110343933,
0.43881770968437195,
0.5653045773506165,
0.17275087535381317,
-0.1218324601650238,
0.2474069595336914,
-0.8112571239471436,
0.17425574362277985,
-0.22432774305343628,
-0.2517995834350586,
-0.15264034271240234,
0.19784697890281677,
0.44202062487602234,
0.7599332928657532,
-0.13242949545383453,
0.1491011679172516,
-0.15060263872146606,
0.5191307663917542,
-0.7238602042198181,
-0.12598726153373718,
-0.9545087218284607,
-0.019953088834881783,
0.17534573376178741,
-0.2277575582265854,
-0.4610437750816345,
-0.2786455750465393,
0.42549726366996765,
-0.7940961122512817,
0.47798317670822144,
0.07758542895317078,
0.6960189938545227,
0.19380222260951996,
-0.17437595129013062,
-0.48226913809776306,
-0.708853006362915,
0.8244243264198303,
-0.3691542446613312,
0.04596951976418495,
0.6986559629440308,
0.19250555336475372,
-0.05382073298096657,
-0.5134088397026062,
-0.4933822751045227,
0.06981399655342102,
-0.010874235071241856,
0.25368112325668335,
-0.08001558482646942,
-0.016150787472724915,
0.02775547467172146,
0.2807641923427582,
-0.5962824821472168,
0.06572084128856659,
-0.4123477041721344,
0.06731197237968445,
0.5138444304466248,
0.10413956642150879,
0.3868703842163086,
0.0013875867007300258,
-0.5370093584060669,
0.051124729216098785,
-0.33919769525527954,
0.25878003239631653,
0.34236952662467957,
0.30286705493927,
0.29429125785827637,
0.8400718569755554,
-0.4785856008529663,
0.5930777192115784,
0.14474745094776154,
0.4011737108230591,
0.05494461581110954,
-0.5050597786903381,
-0.1311040222644806,
-0.1833106428384781,
0.48310309648513794,
0.19876913726329803,
0.2595301866531372,
-0.517235279083252,
-0.19140613079071045,
-0.3985154926776886,
0.4123679995536804,
-0.5894465446472168,
-0.2277505248785019,
0.626430332660675,
-0.3024210035800934,
-0.17428503930568695,
0.3148036599159241,
-0.5510802268981934,
-0.10285928100347519,
0.03430401161313057,
0.8043233752250671,
-0.5320665240287781,
-0.13436056673526764,
0.10206874459981918,
-0.4951779246330261,
0.319649338722229,
0.32892870903015137,
-0.7269061803817749,
0.3943505585193634,
0.4759601950645447,
0.6014208197593689,
-0.4116159677505493,
-0.16509996354579926,
-0.7902331352233887,
0.04897813871502876,
-0.2475462108850479,
0.7551562786102295,
-0.4174692630767822,
-0.293518990278244,
0.01794995740056038,
-0.05029122531414032,
-0.4286535084247589,
-0.5979982018470764,
0.5296705961227417,
-1.1308457851409912,
0.17218825221061707,
-0.2662574052810669,
-0.7221055626869202,
-0.0454423762857914,
0.159798726439476,
-0.6930202841758728,
0.9908616542816162,
0.3735697567462921,
-0.6957476139068604,
0.2689369022846222,
-0.38719049096107483,
-0.05623301491141319,
-0.15025198459625244,
-0.07764846086502075,
-0.30147260427474976,
0.09238304197788239,
0.26899752020835876,
0.3237497806549072,
-0.16902919113636017,
-0.07651872932910919,
-0.41841429471969604,
-0.5855236053466797,
0.27059441804885864,
-0.15041609108448029,
0.6141015291213989,
0.060202378779649734,
0.03662009537220001,
-0.1901283860206604,
-0.7143772840499878,
0.401640385389328,
0.16057704389095306,
-0.22821249067783356,
-0.8002585172653198,
-0.11957038938999176,
-0.10719400644302368,
0.16970472037792206,
0.11413383483886719,
-0.7704302668571472,
0.12984056770801544,
-0.4533541798591614,
0.36360788345336914,
0.6830706000328064,
0.16050326824188232,
0.6802521347999573,
-0.5278231501579285,
0.5523605346679688,
0.037954121828079224,
-0.20094181597232819,
0.0706353560090065,
-0.5205286145210266,
-0.35898134112358093,
-0.35594621300697327,
0.3133580982685089,
0.5400511026382446,
-1.1314202547073364,
0.1668311059474945,
-0.24464790523052216,
-0.43963706493377686,
-0.5057655572891235,
0.0764111876487732,
0.7484666705131531,
0.5756844878196716,
0.6694220900535583,
-0.2612329125404358,
-0.3590124845504761,
-0.6705061197280884,
-0.48349982500076294,
-0.21711136400699615,
0.014059128239750862,
0.339213490486145,
0.7370097637176514,
0.40306994318962097,
1.15891432762146,
-0.5902788639068604,
0.028288986533880234,
-0.22261004149913788,
0.055930767208337784,
-0.09948950260877609,
0.591783344745636,
0.4638978838920593,
-1.2033593654632568,
-0.3626041114330292,
-0.2863888740539551,
-0.9097626209259033,
0.23484617471694946,
0.26513659954071045,
-0.25977081060409546,
0.057829584926366806,
0.6816912889480591,
-0.6059940457344055,
0.7406906485557556,
0.17241264879703522,
-0.15589363873004913,
0.4015631079673767,
-0.20023758709430695,
0.2040015012025833,
-0.709941029548645,
0.13131102919578552,
-0.2510795593261719,
-0.006518073379993439,
-0.7893195748329163,
0.20415566861629486,
0.15170247852802277,
0.046270228922367096,
-0.5078006386756897,
0.8167336583137512,
-0.3282928466796875,
0.00874264445155859,
-0.003726172260940075,
0.14727868139743805,
-0.09311452507972717,
0.6006782650947571,
0.1548682153224945,
1.0351331233978271,
-0.07599886506795883,
-0.6816026568412781,
-0.04627453163266182,
0.8040379285812378,
-0.5267690420150757,
0.558901309967041,
-0.9780340790748596,
0.3316129446029663,
-0.4111623466014862,
0.16472448408603668,
-1.2936066389083862,
-0.5780193209648132,
0.1467721164226532,
-0.5807478427886963,
0.07224425673484802,
-0.16354228556156158,
-0.19747905433177948,
-0.24223744869232178,
-0.3699255585670471,
1.0382908582687378,
0.45034313201904297,
-0.7546112537384033,
0.2504953145980835,
0.17848782241344452,
-0.3049777150154114,
-0.7993208169937134,
-0.42773130536079407,
-0.7162638902664185,
0.16462449729442596,
-0.37234368920326233,
0.3316599130630493,
-0.15838120877742767,
-0.18901345133781433,
0.1740896850824356,
-0.3650820851325989,
-0.6800280809402466,
0.09642870724201202,
0.18102768063545227,
0.3769048750400543,
-0.18058273196220398,
0.3188974857330322,
0.06538094580173492,
0.3424879312515259,
-0.13542723655700684,
-0.20013758540153503,
0.35637199878692627,
0.201027050614357,
-0.37436413764953613,
-0.12776589393615723,
0.571907639503479,
0.1835874617099762,
-0.3627743721008301,
1.0834271907806396,
0.3494220972061157,
-0.2613202631473541,
-0.1278364658355713,
-0.29917746782302856,
-0.05227290838956833,
-0.4103059768676758,
0.5999313592910767,
-0.40453124046325684,
-0.8639394640922546,
0.5503424406051636,
0.5255211591720581,
0.0004629900795407593,
0.46867799758911133,
0.19216229021549225,
-0.24152028560638428,
0.8963737487792969,
0.34561026096343994,
0.23697015643119812,
0.20384123921394348,
-0.1965956836938858,
-0.10896581411361694,
-0.8869695067405701,
-0.4398217499256134,
-0.7081056833267212,
0.026256941258907318,
-0.41996270418167114,
-0.4731336832046509,
0.3770139813423157,
0.325174480676651,
-0.24179726839065552,
0.31872648000717163,
-0.34261637926101685,
0.646175742149353,
0.7658075094223022,
0.5468583703041077,
0.33133217692375183,
0.160613015294075,
-0.04878946766257286,
0.12781277298927307,
-0.8171987533569336,
-0.23458881676197052,
1.2201770544052124,
0.0899341031908989,
0.5633249282836914,
0.22261373698711395,
0.47519466280937195,
0.28150346875190735,
0.048868823796510696,
-0.5887528657913208,
0.45507916808128357,
0.03855426609516144,
-0.8919621109962463,
-0.5266892313957214,
-0.5726643204689026,
-0.8214370608329773,
0.06559869647026062,
-0.20829962193965912,
-0.7103455066680908,
0.2781551480293274,
-0.13828186690807343,
-0.5232093334197998,
0.3045286536216736,
-0.6196724772453308,
0.5352803468704224,
0.3689984083175659,
-0.20737434923648834,
0.1849091798067093,
-0.8399791121482849,
0.3162456154823303,
-0.32242727279663086,
0.01301179826259613,
0.07681608200073242,
-0.290863573551178,
0.8617116212844849,
-0.37225672602653503,
0.4027554988861084,
-0.011447343975305557,
-0.032579366117715836,
0.5605453848838806,
-0.19511500000953674,
0.33118289709091187,
-0.07637582719326019,
-0.4709665775299072,
-0.1724216789007187,
0.1986067146062851,
-0.9906659126281738,
-0.7774391174316406,
0.41601964831352234,
-0.8292227387428284,
-0.32546311616897583,
-0.441080242395401,
-0.6072309017181396,
-0.6363891363143921,
-0.01722213253378868,
0.3880109488964081,
0.6508805751800537,
-0.5018937587738037,
0.10437554866075516,
0.9641675353050232,
-0.20794661343097687,
0.5119013786315918,
0.5533410310745239,
0.12198715656995773,
-0.6017105579376221,
0.7974188327789307,
0.16282810270786285,
0.6246418952941895,
0.4935004711151123,
-0.34412312507629395,
-0.41017165780067444,
-0.6296001076698303,
-0.5219593644142151,
0.16880106925964355,
-0.6737326383590698,
-0.08690795302391052,
-0.719052255153656,
-0.459560751914978,
-0.30920252203941345,
0.0640958696603775,
-0.06511075049638748,
-0.7318077087402344,
-0.3927123248577118,
-0.053617097437381744,
0.26019763946533203,
0.8212475776672363,
0.3575178384780884,
0.16912120580673218,
-0.7824739217758179,
0.45498979091644287,
0.49262353777885437,
0.35160988569259644,
0.016580266878008842,
-0.8419212698936462,
-0.20169125497341156,
0.15240271389484406,
-0.1629692167043686,
-0.6857902407646179,
0.009446498937904835,
0.3150233328342438,
0.5497540831565857,
-0.13285936415195465,
0.6280805468559265,
0.466465026140213,
-0.40784740447998047,
0.659132182598114,
-0.09422814100980759,
-0.5727010369300842,
0.5635667443275452,
-0.4328027069568634,
0.21869398653507233,
0.8598585724830627,
0.7736634612083435,
0.3087446391582489,
-0.22856175899505615,
-0.6576541066169739,
-0.6977288722991943,
1.0125863552093506,
0.6463995575904846,
0.003969365730881691,
-0.09755989909172058,
0.5861008167266846,
0.18202221393585205,
0.3642023503780365,
-0.27490517497062683,
-0.2735006511211395,
0.14931604266166687,
-0.2678731083869934,
-0.18235591053962708,
-0.2022828310728073,
-0.0605897419154644,
-0.012069021351635456,
0.6339579820632935,
0.004007729236036539,
0.3887385129928589,
0.5720854997634888,
-0.11645837873220444,
-0.003934566397219896,
0.18352194130420685,
0.5186387896537781,
0.44728925824165344,
-0.6656030416488647,
-0.18787753582000732,
0.05038244649767876,
-0.6771978139877319,
0.3968503177165985,
0.1956997513771057,
-0.3537622094154358,
0.012485673651099205,
0.279293030500412,
0.3530117869377136,
-0.09600768983364105,
-0.9422671794891357,
0.6982729434967041,
-0.09811607003211975,
-0.28311994671821594,
-0.16935855150222778,
0.07782742381095886,
-0.3522196412086487,
0.1456252485513687,
0.5518954992294312,
0.33405187726020813,
0.10809001326560974,
-0.6832621097564697,
0.23574483394622803,
0.558647632598877,
-0.8352289795875549,
-0.16723713278770447,
0.6344075202941895,
0.07056433707475662,
-0.2079734057188034,
0.5549453496932983,
-0.16641409695148468,
-0.430421382188797,
0.8131916522979736,
0.1870155930519104,
0.5680155754089355,
-0.05188800394535065,
0.28536078333854675,
0.2592656910419464,
0.10202375799417496,
-0.21559229493141174,
0.311358779668808,
0.0010861105984076858,
-0.67341548204422,
-0.12521763145923615,
-0.40160515904426575,
-0.5048961043357849,
0.03124730847775936,
-1.1187779903411865,
-0.1101817786693573,
-0.3109225928783417,
0.07975248247385025,
-0.06653176248073578,
-0.11798671633005142,
-0.4763447046279907,
0.4097048342227936,
-0.7725560069084167,
0.9552076458930969,
-0.530125081539154,
0.608940601348877,
0.848548948764801,
-0.7620455026626587,
-0.7229123711585999,
0.20010675489902496,
-0.4590247869491577,
-0.9751431345939636,
0.6197032332420349,
0.053443510085344315,
0.09221778810024261,
0.1451559215784073,
-0.5957774519920349,
-0.39466047286987305,
0.9437304735183716,
0.10467003285884857,
0.21442976593971252,
-0.22050413489341736,
0.12555380165576935,
0.41684210300445557,
-0.26195961236953735,
0.6073958873748779,
0.4747494161128998,
-0.010971221141517162,
0.2518208920955658,
-0.9592306017875671,
-0.004554043989628553,
-0.314363569021225,
-0.09260120242834091,
0.12070222944021225,
-0.6048250794410706,
0.7358888387680054,
-0.38339200615882874,
0.08935736864805222,
0.8110994696617126,
0.5614203810691833,
0.0647527351975441,
0.6189302206039429,
0.3749597370624542,
0.39938464760780334,
0.709632933139801,
0.03283616527915001,
1.0570472478866577,
0.19541548192501068,
0.3546941876411438,
1.3359736204147339,
-0.1842079609632492,
1.2075861692428589,
0.4326251447200775,
-0.061919450759887695,
0.21872147917747498,
0.4265775978565216,
0.3804403841495514,
0.7572100162506104,
0.02826899290084839,
-0.47381824254989624,
-0.40041619539260864,
-0.20029565691947937,
-0.45149192214012146,
0.3888434171676636,
0.017886735498905182,
-0.4139423370361328,
-0.09952934086322784,
0.037783313542604446,
-0.28857603669166565,
0.37888380885124207,
-0.3571220338344574,
0.9322184324264526,
-0.20854748785495758,
-0.9202406406402588,
0.6668505072593689,
-0.22559025883674622,
0.32800883054733276,
-0.4558534324169159,
-0.1433439999818802,
-0.2660501301288605,
0.04854962229728699,
-0.07572346925735474,
-0.7432073354721069,
0.0024228901602327824,
-0.10625043511390686,
-0.6302404403686523,
0.026371270418167114,
0.5897062420845032,
-0.5446887612342834,
-0.23838385939598083,
0.018784653395414352,
0.8810051083564758,
0.03664182871580124,
-0.22952055931091309,
-0.25899702310562134,
-0.33411434292793274,
-0.026201633736491203,
0.0736025869846344,
0.5538953542709351,
0.4764895439147949,
0.204717755317688,
0.6786454916000366,
0.4105483591556549,
-0.154307559132576,
-0.027210701256990433,
-0.4925021827220917,
0.8289098143577576,
-0.36379027366638184,
-0.2263466715812683,
-0.46837225556373596,
0.3206826150417328,
-0.13853512704372406,
-0.3932885527610779,
0.7581713199615479,
0.519593358039856,
0.885372519493103,
-0.27392837405204773,
0.9097827672958374,
-0.028120458126068115,
0.9941104054450989,
-0.6660826802253723,
0.5363553762435913,
-0.6728284358978271,
0.41694700717926025,
-0.3392387330532074,
-0.5982332825660706,
0.17968310415744781,
0.3109934329986572,
-0.27475258708000183,
0.20184136927127838,
0.6427837014198303,
0.6703504920005798,
-0.21949177980422974,
0.35939913988113403,
0.23623882234096527,
-0.10411382466554642,
-0.08268816024065018,
0.6300495862960815,
0.9630808234214783,
-0.8792390823364258,
0.9147093296051025,
-0.21505878865718842,
-0.19892308115959167,
-0.17959754168987274,
-0.4224393367767334,
-1.166540265083313,
-0.6290978193283081,
-0.25494736433029175,
-0.6599262356758118,
0.4376944303512573,
0.8434454798698425,
0.6540742516517639,
-0.8840214014053345,
0.13780444860458374,
-0.20781414210796356,
0.1443692445755005,
-0.10212984681129456,
-0.1733471155166626,
0.3989405632019043,
-0.33817464113235474,
-0.6097362041473389,
0.1993156373500824,
-0.16593679785728455,
0.2554590106010437,
0.1497807502746582,
0.06336234509944916,
-0.4379248321056366,
0.20788806676864624,
0.38068893551826477,
0.6717957854270935,
-0.42391708493232727,
-0.36092934012413025,
0.3650946021080017,
-0.13843759894371033,
-0.006274644751101732,
0.6248181462287903,
-0.8294250965118408,
0.34819692373275757,
0.4383202791213989,
0.9134883880615234,
0.1751508116722107,
0.5304529070854187,
0.6534784436225891,
-0.8516713380813599,
0.026395423337817192,
0.38509976863861084,
-0.1248905211687088,
0.04018596559762955,
-0.10851118713617325,
0.7541812062263489,
0.3026965856552124,
-0.5488019585609436,
-0.8402139544487,
0.11250908672809601,
-1.057565450668335,
-0.3095392882823944,
1.241341233253479,
-0.5257478952407837,
0.010632294230163097,
-0.4944334626197815,
-0.27894777059555054,
-0.014488903805613518,
-0.4379023611545563,
0.49695268273353577,
0.7258948683738708,
-0.10287084430456161,
0.27574029564857483,
-0.6145895719528198,
0.5036306381225586,
0.6714149117469788,
-0.683820366859436,
-0.23994417488574982,
0.255102276802063,
0.12608377635478973,
0.052037376910448074,
0.7656570076942444,
0.11254595965147018,
0.442888081073761,
-0.06196391209959984,
-0.5294310450553894,
-0.08871910721063614,
-0.14364606142044067,
-0.2437925487756729,
0.517356812953949,
-0.07499386370182037,
-0.39984649419784546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01457v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01457v1
|
Logic Rules as Explanations for Legal Case Retrieval
| 2024-03-03T09:22:21 | 2024-03-03T09:22:21 |
Zhongxiang Sun, Kepu Zhang, Weijie Yu, Haoyu Wang, Jun Xu
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we address the issue of using logic rules to explain the
results from legal case retrieval. The task is critical to legal case retrieval
because the users (e.g., lawyers or judges) are highly specialized and require
the system to provide logical, faithful, and interpretable explanations before
making legal decisions. Recently, research efforts have been made to learn
explainable legal case retrieval models. However, these methods usually select
rationales (key sentences) from the legal cases as explanations, failing to
provide faithful and logically correct explanations. In this paper, we propose
Neural-Symbolic enhanced Legal Case Retrieval (NS-LCR), a framework that
explicitly conducts reasoning on the matching of legal cases through learning
case-level and law-level logic rules. The learned rules are then integrated
into the retrieval process in a neuro-symbolic manner. Benefiting from the
logic and interpretable nature of the logic rules, NS-LCR is equipped with
built-in faithful explainability. We also show that NS-LCR is a model-agnostic
framework that can be plugged in for multiple legal retrieval models. To
showcase NS-LCR's superiority, we enhance existing benchmarks by adding
manually annotated logic rules and introducing a novel explainability metric
using Large Language Models (LLMs). Our comprehensive experiments reveal
NS-LCR's effectiveness for ranking, alongside its proficiency in delivering
reliable explanations for legal case retrieval.
|
[
-0.02048918977379799,
-0.6887414455413818,
1.0827009677886963,
-0.07521617412567139,
-0.6124505996704102,
-0.2605149745941162,
-0.19341515004634857,
-0.27659979462623596,
0.12988993525505066,
0.6843620538711548,
-0.439815491437912,
-0.4189836382865906,
-0.32427164912223816,
0.10168404132127762,
-0.6120952367782593,
1.007608413696289,
0.3196660578250885,
0.3412953019142151,
-0.2493865191936493,
-0.24399910867214203,
-0.6782407164573669,
-0.7463226318359375,
-0.48984432220458984,
-0.3897394835948944,
0.4805871248245239,
-0.044961776584386826,
0.665203869342804,
0.7832115292549133,
0.5185244679450989,
0.28634560108184814,
-0.22505506873130798,
-0.16945713758468628,
-0.22176113724708557,
0.05689038708806038,
-0.2966116964817047,
-0.6648809313774109,
-0.4922002851963043,
-0.20344075560569763,
0.07602739334106445,
0.33706191182136536,
-0.5461025834083557,
-0.13504289090633392,
-0.5769246220588684,
0.8223781585693359,
-0.4847610294818878,
0.1916031688451767,
-0.6957709789276123,
0.4371897280216217,
0.04353079944849014,
-0.4697604179382324,
-0.5130869746208191,
-0.693243682384491,
-0.08147941529750824,
-1.0428111553192139,
0.20395860075950623,
0.21448814868927002,
0.7117843627929688,
0.29740259051322937,
-0.5267743468284607,
-0.38094061613082886,
-0.4370425343513489,
0.4463578760623932,
-0.8261998891830444,
0.48180845379829407,
0.17202994227409363,
0.8577841520309448,
0.0909334123134613,
-0.6829181909561157,
-0.7510501742362976,
-0.5114789605140686,
-0.3182260990142822,
0.28251543641090393,
-0.2706356346607208,
0.19797182083129883,
0.5689870119094849,
-0.08590130507946014,
-0.513215959072113,
-0.33414000272750854,
-0.28109368681907654,
-0.4256226122379303,
0.6564048528671265,
0.014285207726061344,
0.41038739681243896,
-0.0616849921643734,
-0.017720205709338188,
0.22444283962249756,
-0.6961126327514648,
-0.1568981260061264,
0.35719242691993713,
0.439628005027771,
0.3196404278278351,
0.7523822784423828,
-0.1261129379272461,
0.6683531403541565,
0.2358734905719757,
0.06050944700837135,
0.19006352126598358,
-0.5400066375732422,
-0.09024465084075928,
0.5292471647262573,
0.517019510269165,
0.4321717619895935,
0.5241608023643494,
-0.33173081278800964,
-0.32796674966812134,
-0.2056659758090973,
0.3383466303348541,
-0.7297961115837097,
0.16566304862499237,
-0.0025534993037581444,
-0.9405200481414795,
-0.044811442494392395,
0.19690725207328796,
-0.5513024926185608,
-0.5000433921813965,
-0.667572557926178,
0.4530404210090637,
-0.46551695466041565,
-0.3221217691898346,
0.4292911887168884,
-0.46935978531837463,
0.3954295516014099,
0.4921585023403168,
-0.500799834728241,
0.5065518617630005,
0.9414829611778259,
0.4370327889919281,
0.3691859245300293,
0.36597898602485657,
-0.7136309742927551,
0.05308670550584793,
-0.3034749925136566,
0.4460498094558716,
-0.577903687953949,
0.14346089959144592,
-0.06234480440616608,
-0.04356982186436653,
0.14511051774024963,
-0.562885582447052,
0.8257842659950256,
-0.8661452531814575,
-0.15655438601970673,
-0.5808528661727905,
-0.4598689675331116,
-0.5199937224388123,
0.11791957169771194,
-0.465731143951416,
0.3842097520828247,
-0.3835306167602539,
-0.5050837993621826,
0.6906989812850952,
-0.701762855052948,
-0.7676172256469727,
0.2596902847290039,
-0.3332597315311432,
-0.24747608602046967,
0.31763869524002075,
0.1013941615819931,
0.21538859605789185,
-0.1816893070936203,
0.5718565583229065,
-0.22298532724380493,
-0.5186626315116882,
0.13454757630825043,
-0.133148655295372,
1.1578696966171265,
0.4048127830028534,
-0.3943216800689697,
0.07553279399871826,
-0.3411368131637573,
-0.12320725619792938,
0.25616610050201416,
-0.18603171408176422,
-0.38278457522392273,
0.20913264155387878,
-0.3749012351036072,
0.467680960893631,
0.04483731836080551,
-0.5289556980133057,
-0.2990959882736206,
-0.31472161412239075,
0.4724728465080261,
0.5645769238471985,
-0.16974042356014252,
0.37817126512527466,
-0.24090637266635895,
0.532574474811554,
0.15073832869529724,
0.1771426796913147,
0.04947568103671074,
-0.22712907195091248,
-0.47491514682769775,
0.023216161876916885,
0.1193370446562767,
0.48937785625457764,
-0.5063228011131287,
0.3103846311569214,
-0.3768989145755768,
0.08350441604852676,
-0.6417978405952454,
-0.0405331589281559,
0.3855721950531006,
0.6528316140174866,
0.48730599880218506,
0.05607135221362114,
-0.6769535541534424,
-1.1517635583877563,
-0.6780068278312683,
-0.2011566460132599,
0.13815869390964508,
0.6457880735397339,
0.6674869656562805,
0.22757285833358765,
0.9265684485435486,
0.09946054220199585,
-0.11382278800010681,
-0.475466787815094,
-0.18478065729141235,
0.633194088935852,
-0.0878661721944809,
0.4056091606616974,
-1.0308542251586914,
-0.1711743175983429,
0.10948983579874039,
-0.9822714328765869,
-0.3107304871082306,
-0.4269503057003021,
-0.17623035609722137,
-0.0019429471576586366,
0.7864869236946106,
-0.6052496433258057,
0.6005842685699463,
-0.5538882613182068,
-0.6541644930839539,
0.6598021388053894,
-0.2844295799732208,
0.015476131811738014,
-0.48856428265571594,
-0.1888531744480133,
0.10612025111913681,
-0.4014185070991516,
-0.450935423374176,
0.37446755170822144,
0.16404904425144196,
0.3165000081062317,
-0.5477860569953918,
0.32714033126831055,
-0.4087236821651459,
-0.3220396339893341,
-0.35756149888038635,
0.456975519657135,
0.17590764164924622,
0.21359434723854065,
-0.1452200710773468,
0.4175853729248047,
0.39154690504074097,
-0.583650529384613,
0.40803414583206177,
0.05680659040808678,
0.09727967530488968,
0.7703092694282532,
-0.8124164342880249,
-0.2695631682872772,
-0.4862912893295288,
0.2797353267669678,
-0.3792100250720978,
0.16277192533016205,
0.21348343789577484,
-0.1691550612449646,
0.10354325920343399,
-0.5225552916526794,
-0.7477782964706421,
-0.33546319603919983,
0.018957359716296196,
0.16885507106781006,
0.5577911734580994,
-0.6346651911735535,
1.1207034587860107,
0.22304430603981018,
0.15766552090644836,
-0.5026417374610901,
-0.4229719042778015,
0.0701846033334732,
-0.4137820303440094,
-0.20846576988697052,
0.30176660418510437,
-0.07198767364025116,
-0.5234208703041077,
0.2686369717121124,
-0.3499462306499481,
-0.11207487434148788,
0.284443736076355,
0.3391953110694885,
0.14373742043972015,
-0.4538733959197998,
0.22060778737068176,
0.18686456978321075,
0.01814328134059906,
0.7370328307151794,
-0.06570503860712051,
0.21031661331653595,
-0.3709682822227478,
-0.5567081570625305,
-0.5034183859825134,
0.26055213809013367,
0.36926427483558655,
-0.2181471586227417,
0.4565081000328064,
0.12885203957557678,
-0.3695792257785797,
-0.051368508487939835,
-0.646324634552002,
-0.3795314133167267,
-0.4240071773529053,
0.171559140086174,
-0.6173921227455139,
-0.6320732831954956,
0.4151695966720581,
-0.026427024975419044,
-0.05707200616598129,
0.544096052646637,
0.36420202255249023,
-0.03675659000873566,
1.1107807159423828,
0.35453563928604126,
0.17292910814285278,
0.2464946210384369,
0.29212942719459534,
0.4539203643798828,
-0.5507984757423401,
-0.6517625451087952,
-0.5417144894599915,
-0.08915888518095016,
-0.2561025023460388,
0.10832171142101288,
0.03409099578857422,
0.15187345445156097,
-0.4942455291748047,
0.3338030278682709,
-0.4111683964729309,
0.9134368896484375,
0.5370468497276306,
0.32385650277137756,
0.5126641392707825,
0.02724272757768631,
-0.6626196503639221,
0.08587359637022018,
-0.597740650177002,
-0.20706631243228912,
0.8086897730827332,
-0.06627172231674194,
0.39502885937690735,
0.3750782907009125,
0.6027097105979919,
0.1877710074186325,
-0.016352280974388123,
-0.874505877494812,
0.8309105634689331,
-0.2941347360610962,
-0.6776092648506165,
0.023599551990628242,
-0.5991371870040894,
-0.6284932494163513,
0.361593097448349,
-0.3857603669166565,
-0.5992645621299744,
0.03058493509888649,
-0.10133760422468185,
-0.5784828066825867,
-0.044071223586797714,
-0.334831565618515,
0.5862759947776794,
-0.6319199800491333,
-0.41360190510749817,
-0.5084799528121948,
-0.6554661989212036,
0.41258636116981506,
-0.1485474407672882,
0.31049782037734985,
-0.14461711049079895,
0.18665048480033875,
0.6008545756340027,
-0.7475153207778931,
0.4315914511680603,
-0.2940395474433899,
0.416228711605072,
0.00370308430865407,
0.287114679813385,
0.2199351042509079,
0.035038288682699203,
-0.44069504737854004,
-0.21490056812763214,
0.008956429548561573,
0.04980561137199402,
-1.0413521528244019,
0.6095576286315918,
-0.29437699913978577,
-0.877036988735199,
-0.43121081590652466,
-0.5284079313278198,
0.4374488294124603,
0.3097565770149231,
-0.38708239793777466,
0.17851488292217255,
0.40128812193870544,
0.37335148453712463,
0.533460795879364,
-0.3369216322898865,
0.20799267292022705,
0.8463488221168518,
-0.06764306128025055,
-0.011227828450500965,
0.8705098628997803,
0.013258231803774834,
-0.33569198846817017,
0.34317123889923096,
0.4462655186653137,
-0.6931769847869873,
-0.642982006072998,
-0.198751762509346,
0.4032262861728668,
-0.8935953378677368,
-0.09248511493206024,
-0.6004568934440613,
-0.24677246809005737,
-0.0859711542725563,
-0.1575358361005783,
0.12982796132564545,
-0.6190560460090637,
-0.15211139619350433,
-0.28349655866622925,
0.461225688457489,
0.46435967087745667,
-0.07724542915821075,
-0.11084354668855667,
-0.4014089107513428,
0.6634787321090698,
0.06606321781873703,
0.35019394755363464,
-0.10933293402194977,
-0.8334799408912659,
0.1801028549671173,
0.026003094390034676,
0.12335444986820221,
-0.8717997074127197,
0.28988438844680786,
0.1577436625957489,
0.9378839731216431,
0.390733540058136,
0.13991205394268036,
0.8942645788192749,
-0.6674678921699524,
0.22400327026844025,
0.07841125875711441,
-0.9442759156227112,
0.89736008644104,
-0.12457700818777084,
-0.2116958349943161,
0.6589871048927307,
0.21840715408325195,
-0.22370339930057526,
-0.16393543779850006,
-0.47301018238067627,
-0.8547362089157104,
0.7653230428695679,
0.23115883767604828,
0.2222193479537964,
-0.037057895213365555,
1.0983026027679443,
-0.01430714875459671,
0.14907418191432953,
-0.7742652893066406,
-0.06410040706396103,
-0.4430645704269409,
-0.313535213470459,
0.4481945037841797,
0.0743650272488594,
-0.13041675090789795,
-0.5265963673591614,
0.7231631875038147,
-0.17056365311145782,
0.24152664840221405,
0.18592290580272675,
-0.3971613645553589,
0.34231099486351013,
0.2554127275943756,
0.4407840371131897,
0.6086665987968445,
-0.1728757619857788,
0.09864827245473862,
-0.032503802329301834,
-0.14641182124614716,
0.0030892968643456697,
0.2272852510213852,
-0.27271050214767456,
0.05205726996064186,
0.1400887668132782,
0.5368481278419495,
-0.030836554244160652,
-0.8241491317749023,
0.6145266890525818,
-0.3764202296733856,
-0.5011852979660034,
-0.5018012523651123,
0.07280386239290237,
0.08859089761972427,
0.4880193769931793,
0.3819162845611572,
-0.090090811252594,
0.47229114174842834,
-0.6184930801391602,
0.44061118364334106,
0.6272830963134766,
-0.43290120363235474,
0.03281247243285179,
0.9603407979011536,
-0.16380633413791656,
-0.15943127870559692,
0.8584190607070923,
-0.07786881178617477,
-0.585637629032135,
0.9725149869918823,
0.606113076210022,
0.5193804502487183,
0.6313917636871338,
0.215432271361351,
0.2820082902908325,
0.362746000289917,
-0.40140363574028015,
0.47586822509765625,
-0.1968269795179367,
-0.5239437818527222,
-0.38443583250045776,
-0.4392663836479187,
-0.10751757025718689,
-0.23251484334468842,
-0.832516610622406,
0.015720486640930176,
-0.44826093316078186,
-0.004276453983038664,
0.1659841388463974,
-0.28700265288352966,
-0.5062284469604492,
0.03184138983488083,
-0.08353365957736969,
1.0489031076431274,
-0.5829367637634277,
0.560083270072937,
0.4375165104866028,
-0.7762811183929443,
-0.7409416437149048,
-0.2650126814842224,
0.27056461572647095,
-0.803278923034668,
1.0283869504928589,
0.20405255258083344,
-0.0024115147534757853,
-0.2956382930278778,
-0.399400532245636,
-0.47291332483291626,
1.107954502105713,
0.6351678371429443,
-0.6147170662879944,
0.08086522668600082,
0.18471109867095947,
0.7832761406898499,
-0.3038018047809601,
0.5678187608718872,
0.49577832221984863,
0.5917749404907227,
0.34207451343536377,
-0.41664695739746094,
0.6122563481330872,
-0.48089584708213806,
-0.07374612987041473,
0.009641492739319801,
-0.15053384006023407,
0.3399546146392822,
-0.5741187930107117,
-0.029849087819457054,
-0.02822043001651764,
0.45824992656707764,
0.5890120267868042,
0.4104575216770172,
0.4944351315498352,
0.5348637104034424,
0.6982377171516418,
-0.49146604537963867,
1.3644100427627563,
-0.33937790989875793,
-0.007521101739257574,
1.0889724493026733,
-0.34198832511901855,
0.6750642657279968,
0.6309766173362732,
0.28200092911720276,
0.621446967124939,
0.36723655462265015,
-0.17048561573028564,
0.4785385727882385,
0.462914377450943,
-0.07637813687324524,
-0.7241547703742981,
-0.4121133089065552,
-0.011592155322432518,
0.17766694724559784,
0.19786794483661652,
-0.8026626110076904,
-0.2586061954498291,
-0.17562374472618103,
-0.18744859099388123,
0.15065425634384155,
-0.3938785493373871,
0.7387847304344177,
0.06587350368499756,
-0.45310401916503906,
0.11320511996746063,
-0.07223950326442719,
0.2626872658729553,
-0.32428544759750366,
-0.35015761852264404,
-0.32869982719421387,
0.23456330597400665,
-0.3437066078186035,
-0.8095323443412781,
0.3424130380153656,
-0.006185960955917835,
-0.1926427185535431,
-0.4015101492404938,
0.7616556286811829,
-0.00011235041165491566,
-0.5011789202690125,
0.5305414199829102,
0.4305843412876129,
0.3061673045158386,
-0.16547489166259766,
-1.1178319454193115,
-0.20858995616436005,
-0.3185567259788513,
-0.09931767731904984,
0.21259525418281555,
0.667999804019928,
-0.2580004930496216,
0.8984997272491455,
0.770829975605011,
-0.03140980005264282,
0.0912679061293602,
0.6015647053718567,
0.7667202949523926,
-0.7029081583023071,
-0.17495733499526978,
-0.9479460120201111,
0.38550207018852234,
-0.19155718386173248,
0.29073193669319153,
0.42797553539276123,
0.6036273241043091,
0.4643368721008301,
0.15325632691383362,
0.5439051985740662,
0.02306675910949707,
0.06057584658265114,
-0.6472933292388916,
0.7940614819526672,
-0.6696178317070007,
0.5185545086860657,
0.011505910195410252,
-0.6959827542304993,
-0.42075058817863464,
0.91991126537323,
-0.17828890681266785,
0.23645934462547302,
0.6601743698120117,
0.8291839957237244,
-0.37908661365509033,
0.10912059992551804,
0.27903732657432556,
0.27848461270332336,
0.08270663768053055,
0.44298750162124634,
0.6788272261619568,
-0.29429835081100464,
0.8056566119194031,
-0.025388723239302635,
0.1365712583065033,
-0.28910720348358154,
-1.040523648262024,
-0.713753342628479,
-0.04105374589562416,
-0.27358299493789673,
-0.3589251637458801,
0.45631060004234314,
0.6906969547271729,
0.7712503671646118,
-0.5868675112724304,
-0.05234179273247719,
-0.4940531253814697,
0.3937786817550659,
-0.35167810320854187,
-0.29691967368125916,
0.04297736659646034,
-0.24482367932796478,
-0.051588669419288635,
0.5858619809150696,
0.10566643625497818,
-0.18903371691703796,
0.42496752738952637,
-0.37454646825790405,
-0.22478242218494415,
0.187347874045372,
0.49066153168678284,
0.31920677423477173,
-0.9277481436729431,
-0.12870967388153076,
0.0944024920463562,
0.0869237408041954,
0.024106338620185852,
0.9018728733062744,
-0.9190735220909119,
0.35557758808135986,
0.438640832901001,
0.6175975799560547,
0.4092351794242859,
-0.03313935175538063,
0.664592981338501,
-0.3509206175804138,
-0.31393346190452576,
0.2770134210586548,
0.7879688143730164,
-0.12766459584236145,
-0.3515201508998871,
0.5807017087936401,
0.17291510105133057,
-0.1680285930633545,
-0.5593453645706177,
0.13077278435230255,
-1.0823994874954224,
-0.4147186577320099,
0.9438620805740356,
-0.1417102813720703,
-0.21807214617729187,
-0.34796950221061707,
0.07410694658756256,
0.26434165239334106,
-0.542758047580719,
0.7783580422401428,
0.528311550617218,
-0.1669338494539261,
-0.42582470178604126,
-0.8527095317840576,
0.13680234551429749,
0.4220699071884155,
-0.7859818339347839,
-0.03221900388598442,
0.7216417193412781,
0.4443015158176422,
0.061987098306417465,
0.3654254376888275,
-0.5819490551948547,
0.6642484068870544,
-0.32237985730171204,
-0.18556979298591614,
-0.41903170943260193,
-0.22172604501247406,
-0.5360807180404663,
0.08429165184497833,
-0.3692687451839447,
0.46537482738494873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01456v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01456v1
|
Controlling Cloze-test Question Item Difficulty with PLM-based Surrogate Models for IRT Assessment
| 2024-03-03T09:18:05 | 2024-03-03T09:18:05 |
Jingshen Zhang, Jiajun Xie, Xinying Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Item difficulty plays a crucial role in adaptive testing. However, few works
have focused on generating questions of varying difficulty levels, especially
for multiple-choice (MC) cloze tests. We propose training pre-trained language
models (PLMs) as surrogate models to enable item response theory (IRT)
assessment, avoiding the need for human test subjects. We also propose two
strategies to control the difficulty levels of both the gaps and the
distractors using ranking rules to reduce invalid distractors. Experimentation
on a benchmark dataset demonstrates that our proposed framework and methods can
effectively control and evaluate the difficulty levels of MC cloze tests.
|
[
-0.8280911445617676,
-0.9178398251533508,
0.23302192986011505,
-0.05400022864341736,
-0.20727455615997314,
-0.10414985567331314,
-0.13623224198818207,
-0.19597266614437103,
-0.2513030767440796,
0.815077006816864,
-0.7248389720916748,
-0.07768891006708145,
-0.5800725817680359,
0.39658042788505554,
0.02187909185886383,
1.129077672958374,
-0.329812228679657,
-0.11071786284446716,
-0.3351600766181946,
-0.23895421624183655,
-0.9321921467781067,
-0.4666265547275543,
-0.6057544946670532,
0.0012209682026878,
0.49635395407676697,
0.6875885128974915,
0.5125412344932556,
0.03849839046597481,
0.7908498048782349,
0.22390322387218475,
0.020636292174458504,
0.2729239761829376,
-0.3166232109069824,
0.2420944720506668,
-0.32933732867240906,
-0.3076000213623047,
-0.27226337790489197,
0.1735221892595291,
0.25058799982070923,
0.6331495642662048,
-0.3137158453464508,
0.22715730965137482,
0.1656653732061386,
0.5195267200469971,
-0.6753015518188477,
-0.16247615218162537,
-0.606009304523468,
-0.17037534713745117,
-0.03892424702644348,
-0.24418103694915771,
-0.6198166012763977,
-0.4081404209136963,
0.4277186691761017,
-0.42148128151893616,
0.3321351408958435,
0.10015463083982468,
0.6512980461120605,
0.340772420167923,
-0.48580029606819153,
-0.5109241604804993,
-0.6803194880485535,
0.6246631741523743,
-0.42737212777137756,
0.3357570767402649,
0.46108919382095337,
0.05842777341604233,
-0.16508285701274872,
-0.6755073070526123,
-0.26013830304145813,
-0.7865214943885803,
-0.1482391357421875,
0.3352454900741577,
0.3723900616168976,
0.23405860364437103,
0.2610073387622833,
0.13851115107536316,
-0.7545015215873718,
-0.16863895952701569,
-0.7110298871994019,
0.01305528823286295,
0.5535357594490051,
0.07911606878042221,
0.38855111598968506,
0.13642941415309906,
-0.6773574948310852,
0.07906590402126312,
-0.6502688527107239,
0.08386022597551346,
-0.11410168558359146,
0.11844077706336975,
0.5541108846664429,
0.6880004405975342,
-0.09948916733264923,
0.800948977470398,
-0.010767162777483463,
0.09224803745746613,
0.03839660808444023,
-0.25886642932891846,
0.05673227831721306,
-0.13829779624938965,
0.3473035991191864,
0.15252785384655,
0.32135483622550964,
0.19745658338069916,
-0.07160903513431549,
0.04962935671210289,
0.42391785979270935,
-0.8483136892318726,
-0.21549959480762482,
0.2887653112411499,
-0.18800020217895508,
0.17577624320983887,
-0.05488499253988266,
-0.7366843223571777,
-0.4291253387928009,
-0.13376939296722412,
0.7362894415855408,
-0.6215623021125793,
0.00782388262450695,
0.24962417781352997,
0.01576925441622734,
0.11401572823524475,
0.041394542902708054,
-0.5179550051689148,
0.6109325289726257,
0.13859137892723083,
0.6284898519515991,
-0.14782318472862244,
-0.5659641623497009,
-0.6790817975997925,
-0.02022833190858364,
-0.23380203545093536,
0.8635968565940857,
-0.7310675978660583,
-0.43305206298828125,
-0.23110708594322205,
-0.16626325249671936,
-0.6923981308937073,
-0.6352051496505737,
0.19580353796482086,
-0.4510762691497803,
0.4032684564590454,
-0.27159038186073303,
-0.7384078502655029,
-0.22223834693431854,
0.3679637908935547,
-0.44283220171928406,
0.9679512977600098,
0.475094199180603,
-0.5584040284156799,
0.2796553373336792,
-0.9557295441627502,
-0.44990766048431396,
0.07918088883161545,
0.2141517549753189,
-0.32097381353378296,
0.182064488530159,
0.1781478375196457,
0.25409722328186035,
-0.17963984608650208,
-0.08340862393379211,
-0.2593725919723511,
-0.3287714421749115,
0.47572025656700134,
-0.22423741221427917,
0.22029799222946167,
0.09254597127437592,
-0.2385648488998413,
-0.004219801630824804,
-0.6105583906173706,
0.1964334100484848,
-0.15101471543312073,
-0.38479822874069214,
-0.34515485167503357,
0.15738317370414734,
-0.3297353684902191,
0.26681220531463623,
0.06252181529998779,
-0.28426289558410645,
0.21209397912025452,
-0.00447456119582057,
0.29310208559036255,
0.7060017585754395,
0.2525959014892578,
-0.016359135508537292,
-0.6340788006782532,
0.7818651795387268,
-0.08126392960548401,
0.30807924270629883,
-0.022921456024050713,
-0.441415935754776,
-0.7914972901344299,
-0.09089213609695435,
0.4325851500034332,
0.9474456310272217,
-0.7015339136123657,
0.15052060782909393,
0.2921505570411682,
-0.4182322025299072,
-0.6425799131393433,
0.32296493649482727,
0.40612342953681946,
0.5064298510551453,
0.5736739039421082,
-0.5856729745864868,
-0.26045161485671997,
-0.5713906288146973,
-0.045854758471250534,
-0.04721638187766075,
-0.04812098294496536,
0.3448643088340759,
0.5845324993133545,
0.07544249296188354,
0.7793550491333008,
-0.5407919883728027,
-0.4347496032714844,
-0.5238304734230042,
0.41373375058174133,
-0.11744678765535355,
0.6709492802619934,
0.36208558082580566,
-1.1545382738113403,
-0.5736372470855713,
-0.20425616204738617,
-0.06346012651920319,
-0.4724854826927185,
-0.045893002301454544,
0.13007712364196777,
0.02952677384018898,
0.5740020871162415,
-0.5878802537918091,
0.44736599922180176,
0.06850428134202957,
-0.26289427280426025,
0.7569035291671753,
-0.19617119431495667,
0.15842069685459137,
-0.8267016410827637,
0.005959829781204462,
-0.25565046072006226,
-0.0879158154129982,
-0.9390614032745361,
0.1659362018108368,
0.0502001978456974,
-0.1076851412653923,
-0.690237283706665,
0.39280810952186584,
-0.294721782207489,
0.2708127796649933,
-0.37489548325538635,
0.10022913664579391,
0.06640893220901489,
0.5019320249557495,
0.3429427444934845,
0.9533829092979431,
0.2658761739730835,
-0.9862551689147949,
0.11610545963048935,
0.34295403957366943,
-0.1626775562763214,
0.7441720962524414,
-0.6109129786491394,
0.279194176197052,
-0.2301803082227707,
-0.003847143379971385,
-1.175813913345337,
-0.15567755699157715,
0.16925306618213654,
-0.28559690713882446,
0.17203092575073242,
0.10804829001426697,
-0.10557030141353607,
-0.4594475030899048,
-0.26986658573150635,
0.39313262701034546,
0.600172221660614,
-0.11014311015605927,
0.6702008843421936,
-0.11900661140680313,
-0.6609181761741638,
-0.4908142685890198,
-0.4876670837402344,
-0.44262489676475525,
-0.4926413595676422,
-0.2880634069442749,
0.14738373458385468,
-0.8517800569534302,
-0.019478311762213707,
-0.30003613233566284,
-0.13356411457061768,
-0.33200183510780334,
0.31523028016090393,
0.014238488860428333,
0.19325433671474457,
-0.03583909943699837,
0.16005514562129974,
-0.3265211880207062,
-0.12708011269569397,
-0.10766460746526718,
0.042978301644325256,
0.6911608576774597,
-0.1743132621049881,
-0.5153053402900696,
-0.1971057802438736,
0.39067450165748596,
0.36323562264442444,
-0.5113717913627625,
0.4443139433860779,
0.4554452896118164,
-0.25809842348098755,
-0.13841448724269867,
-0.7920234203338623,
-0.26317504048347473,
-0.47534090280532837,
0.39804399013519287,
-0.49985113739967346,
-0.7753284573554993,
0.691659152507782,
-0.10751909017562866,
-0.05150808021426201,
0.060764163732528687,
0.4973641335964203,
-0.13086755573749542,
1.0727601051330566,
0.3968432545661926,
0.1701751947402954,
0.34331652522087097,
-0.05812850594520569,
0.01854878105223179,
-1.0199050903320312,
0.08172798901796341,
-0.3892771005630493,
-0.30209654569625854,
-0.3942280411720276,
-0.20497632026672363,
0.5034303069114685,
0.17591314017772675,
-0.3586192727088928,
0.20560653507709503,
-0.401488333940506,
0.6265381574630737,
0.5999359488487244,
0.2924247980117798,
0.02512611821293831,
-0.3711041212081909,
-0.10999749600887299,
0.16128937900066376,
-0.6482589244842529,
-0.18690909445285797,
1.0196771621704102,
0.1051756888628006,
0.6552087664604187,
-0.08664868026971817,
0.580943763256073,
0.05262192338705063,
0.4992034435272217,
-0.5280057191848755,
0.6153877973556519,
-0.13343487679958344,
-0.944688081741333,
-0.35978835821151733,
-0.34994906187057495,
-0.8309220671653748,
0.5008435249328613,
0.2444271594285965,
-0.9433642029762268,
0.34283673763275146,
0.05607172101736069,
-0.8863312602043152,
-0.010122700594365597,
-0.9153155088424683,
0.8039425015449524,
-0.2344033271074295,
-0.3780401647090912,
0.23543091118335724,
-0.7791261076927185,
0.18709149956703186,
0.028721129521727562,
0.14746186137199402,
-0.13985496759414673,
0.030750218778848648,
0.6870372891426086,
-0.41452041268348694,
0.7895156741142273,
-0.0697096586227417,
0.4194222092628479,
0.7280723452568054,
0.6039547920227051,
0.5438394546508789,
0.15285281836986542,
-0.03009732998907566,
-0.4534893035888672,
0.01125016063451767,
-0.5375078320503235,
-0.4595155119895935,
0.21884430944919586,
-0.4874294698238373,
-0.933449387550354,
-0.4656449258327484,
-0.984931230545044,
-0.4016087055206299,
0.2996746003627777,
0.3782057464122772,
0.41099944710731506,
0.01928023062646389,
0.3241422474384308,
0.9776579141616821,
-0.01431170105934143,
0.33324891328811646,
0.8470304608345032,
0.08612832427024841,
-0.45437490940093994,
0.9111973643302917,
0.49038365483283997,
0.73183274269104,
0.1850796639919281,
0.37229615449905396,
-0.31066909432411194,
-0.8099930882453918,
-0.017501698806881905,
-0.13227221369743347,
-0.5641463994979858,
-0.23260106146335602,
-0.1363259106874466,
-0.30809712409973145,
-0.1971251517534256,
-0.2530864477157593,
-0.2881503701210022,
0.0003599665651563555,
-0.3459654450416565,
-0.320463091135025,
0.31785669922828674,
0.6207455396652222,
-0.06353370100259781,
0.3827923834323883,
-0.5879631638526917,
0.3123685121536255,
0.5030791759490967,
0.29957371950149536,
-0.5135061144828796,
-0.5862839221954346,
0.16584981977939606,
-0.15403001010417938,
-0.48632827401161194,
-0.9634199738502502,
0.3845979869365692,
0.19513623416423798,
0.210164874792099,
0.20468828082084656,
0.2632790803909302,
0.8829044699668884,
-0.37560874223709106,
0.9240574240684509,
-0.05840341001749039,
-0.9268473386764526,
0.5069313049316406,
-0.09335211664438248,
0.07531306892633438,
0.8150795698165894,
0.44323113560676575,
-0.3675816059112549,
-0.40916261076927185,
-0.6419076919555664,
-0.7561651468276978,
0.6853393316268921,
0.3124622404575348,
0.0004366495122667402,
-0.08415354043245316,
0.38347485661506653,
0.26262956857681274,
0.3673950731754303,
-0.9509384632110596,
0.06805790960788727,
-0.13714808225631714,
-0.20010779798030853,
0.044838204979896545,
-0.37874919176101685,
-0.09041613340377808,
-0.06171951815485954,
0.45730966329574585,
-0.010268562473356724,
-0.13873504102230072,
0.6250925660133362,
-0.2879495918750763,
0.0069696963764727116,
0.529575765132904,
0.8340864181518555,
0.7372242212295532,
-0.5436503291130066,
0.21080636978149414,
0.6750733256340027,
-0.564276397228241,
0.21788883209228516,
0.31874504685401917,
-0.21494773030281067,
-0.40159276127815247,
0.08434576541185379,
0.643915057182312,
-0.07288430631160736,
-0.741174042224884,
0.24931570887565613,
0.108283631503582,
-0.35075244307518005,
-0.182036891579628,
0.21625347435474396,
-0.23324239253997803,
-0.05861460044980049,
0.19633172452449799,
0.0033692042343318462,
-0.0025330076459795237,
-0.2527662217617035,
0.44379815459251404,
0.2834160327911377,
-0.5233709216117859,
-0.06417806446552277,
0.5459999442100525,
-0.006430300883948803,
-0.3823276460170746,
0.567947268486023,
-0.25002726912498474,
-0.6241923570632935,
0.818193256855011,
0.783589243888855,
0.4041289687156677,
-0.7948651909828186,
0.3058772683143616,
-0.03318608179688454,
0.7513342499732971,
-0.1899632215499878,
0.7470706105232239,
0.3034527897834778,
-0.531199038028717,
-0.11425375938415527,
-0.19796042144298553,
-0.5237066149711609,
0.5126695036888123,
-0.694497287273407,
0.0838969275355339,
-0.3964289724826813,
0.03048710711300373,
-0.4742472767829895,
0.07472139596939087,
-0.7233133912086487,
0.5308524966239929,
-0.05856141448020935,
0.9060796499252319,
-0.6369026303291321,
0.3451223075389862,
0.6060172915458679,
-0.7119495272636414,
-0.7409544587135315,
-0.2446836233139038,
-0.5289093852043152,
-0.5831396579742432,
0.2488209754228592,
0.2739591896533966,
0.25310879945755005,
0.16520409286022186,
-0.40195971727371216,
-0.8118280172348022,
0.9203264117240906,
0.16095823049545288,
-0.2757543921470642,
0.236311137676239,
0.4178369343280792,
0.4415280818939209,
-0.4173923432826996,
0.6713836789131165,
0.6670008301734924,
0.5709673762321472,
-0.0650080218911171,
-0.9208310842514038,
0.0016814203700050712,
-0.13442137837409973,
0.0569736585021019,
0.2004963457584381,
-0.8034500479698181,
0.990986168384552,
-0.16308754682540894,
-0.021292027086019516,
0.17493557929992676,
0.37445271015167236,
0.5949082970619202,
0.5412818789482117,
0.6552643775939941,
0.3313663601875305,
0.7212440967559814,
0.037764642387628555,
0.9171544313430786,
-0.1591576337814331,
0.2673957347869873,
1.1951621770858765,
-0.7931376695632935,
0.8967840075492859,
0.4519317150115967,
0.043829891830682755,
0.47772106528282166,
0.8267826437950134,
0.06308663636445999,
0.44221583008766174,
0.6371178030967712,
-0.07963170856237411,
-0.4287133514881134,
-0.202948197722435,
-0.436383992433548,
0.2826613187789917,
0.5217008590698242,
-0.1000601276755333,
-0.09265246242284775,
0.44922471046447754,
-0.24677877128124237,
0.030179111286997795,
-0.27996739745140076,
0.6189528107643127,
-0.04427110776305199,
-0.8411041498184204,
0.5499514937400818,
-0.46140310168266296,
0.18202286958694458,
-0.8871593475341797,
0.009777341969311237,
-0.3876635730266571,
-0.00542355515062809,
0.1845853477716446,
-0.4977279007434845,
0.047086358070373535,
-0.2293284833431244,
-0.08392607420682907,
0.035567380487918854,
0.9722608327865601,
-0.5997711420059204,
-0.6096774935722351,
0.08150807023048401,
0.49345749616622925,
0.11962874233722687,
-0.09276223182678223,
-0.7170203328132629,
-0.2169359177350998,
-0.2269383668899536,
-0.7520027756690979,
0.287474125623703,
0.11276011914014816,
-0.10043393075466156,
1.0660152435302734,
0.4763742685317993,
-0.16321226954460144,
0.2920656204223633,
-0.1416894644498825,
0.6531144976615906,
-0.6457901000976562,
-0.39331525564193726,
-0.8070855140686035,
0.7012766599655151,
0.16203933954238892,
-0.3518068790435791,
0.28457871079444885,
0.32691529393196106,
0.7346298694610596,
-0.28903526067733765,
0.8719507455825806,
-0.11276250332593918,
0.6980687975883484,
-0.4906730055809021,
0.3975074291229248,
-0.47511202096939087,
0.1998390555381775,
-0.03892724588513374,
-0.6065719127655029,
-0.3068636953830719,
0.3478113114833832,
-0.3252195417881012,
0.23532749712467194,
1.029478907585144,
0.8534691333770752,
-0.11451812833547592,
-0.14997552335262299,
0.26179713010787964,
0.19860431551933289,
0.19036996364593506,
1.0179311037063599,
1.0681127309799194,
-0.23792897164821625,
0.8357154130935669,
-0.40414130687713623,
-0.13689647614955902,
-0.10224512219429016,
-0.7306122183799744,
-1.1612380743026733,
-0.5491008758544922,
-0.4490610957145691,
-0.28681570291519165,
0.054899297654628754,
1.026498556137085,
0.5356775522232056,
-0.9050967693328857,
-0.19982512295246124,
-0.21743030846118927,
0.37024885416030884,
-0.6350252628326416,
-0.2510712742805481,
0.5225797295570374,
-0.483141154050827,
-0.5738778114318848,
0.42571163177490234,
-0.027176903560757637,
0.21354582905769348,
-0.023337021470069885,
0.1503731906414032,
-0.30182668566703796,
0.38188716769218445,
0.3748045563697815,
0.2053496092557907,
-0.6054404973983765,
-0.4594687521457672,
0.1448115110397339,
0.22519998252391815,
0.07148484140634537,
0.9037342071533203,
-0.6359307765960693,
0.5081541538238525,
0.4319997727870941,
0.34107735753059387,
0.008368098177015781,
0.4210151433944702,
0.4767889082431793,
-0.7616546750068665,
0.010099961422383785,
0.3623654842376709,
0.26380565762519836,
0.11031033843755722,
-0.4358566105365753,
0.5609034895896912,
0.2142753303050995,
-0.6875175833702087,
-1.0477526187896729,
0.36989834904670715,
-0.8042424917221069,
-0.41952502727508545,
1.1224411725997925,
-0.2647351324558258,
-0.04342198371887207,
-0.3549517095088959,
-0.5292152762413025,
0.030571497976779938,
0.04104996100068092,
0.9725519418716431,
0.8931171894073486,
-0.3725651800632477,
-0.34793752431869507,
-0.7407806515693665,
0.5584871768951416,
0.8358421921730042,
-0.712735116481781,
0.07953090965747833,
0.14756780862808228,
0.5011580586433411,
0.3496803343296051,
0.7099934220314026,
0.2190147489309311,
0.4602876901626587,
-0.40977343916893005,
0.055806342512369156,
-0.11183595657348633,
-0.48401808738708496,
0.024066196754574776,
0.5235487818717957,
0.03310480713844299,
-0.31211382150650024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04787v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04787v2
|
Ever-Evolving Memory by Blending and Refining the Past
| 2024-03-03T08:12:59 | 2024-04-07T04:31:30 |
Seo Hyun Kim, Keummin Ka, Yohan Jo, Seung-won Hwang, Dongha Lee, Jinyoung Yeo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
For a human-like chatbot, constructing a long-term memory is crucial.
However, current large language models often lack this capability, leading to
instances of missing important user information or redundantly asking for the
same information, thereby diminishing conversation quality. To effectively
construct memory, it is crucial to seamlessly connect past and present
information, while also possessing the ability to forget obstructive
information. To address these challenges, we propose CREEM, a novel memory
system for long-term conversation. Improving upon existing approaches that
construct memory based solely on current sessions, CREEM blends past memories
during memory formation. Additionally, we introduce a refining process to
handle redundant or outdated information. Unlike traditional paradigms, we view
responding and memory construction as inseparable tasks. The blending process,
which creates new memories, also serves as a reasoning step for response
generation by informing the connection between past and present. Through
evaluation, we demonstrate that CREEM enhances both memory and response
qualities in multi-session personalized dialogues.
|
[
-0.294088214635849,
-1.1671687364578247,
0.5484974980354309,
0.1002996414899826,
0.01858121156692505,
0.6423237323760986,
-0.3773691952228546,
-0.5048888325691223,
0.4003148078918457,
0.748871386051178,
-0.5698961615562439,
-0.3276069462299347,
0.03763286769390106,
-0.445133775472641,
-0.2730751633644104,
0.896578311920166,
0.20162516832351685,
-0.3088267147541046,
-0.10904153436422348,
-0.3715583086013794,
-1.0901919603347778,
-0.777930498123169,
-0.9805372357368469,
-0.36656761169433594,
0.37160611152648926,
0.3627740144729614,
0.7768831253051758,
0.20577087998390198,
-0.09142181277275085,
0.3190513253211975,
-0.0319812074303627,
0.37284141778945923,
-0.6984671950340271,
0.5974190831184387,
-0.2920236885547638,
-0.5395174026489258,
-0.7488017082214355,
-0.2831309735774994,
0.4268525242805481,
0.6842560768127441,
-0.27684256434440613,
-0.17285044491291046,
0.029799077659845352,
0.49966326355934143,
-0.5755473971366882,
-0.1784493774175644,
-1.1043834686279297,
0.10535698384046555,
0.04471173509955406,
-0.3196631669998169,
-0.5553745031356812,
-0.26765620708465576,
0.2318010777235031,
-0.26870372891426086,
0.2086491584777832,
0.05857604742050171,
0.7476860880851746,
-0.2691362202167511,
-0.10505059361457825,
-0.28403860330581665,
-1.1488125324249268,
0.8946128487586975,
-0.5580083727836609,
0.0994199886918068,
0.3002854585647583,
0.389450341463089,
-0.3001653850078583,
-0.6673310399055481,
-0.53236323595047,
-0.05139175429940224,
0.21324779093265533,
0.31565162539482117,
-0.12929505109786987,
-0.005741811823099852,
-0.19059620797634125,
0.24901331961154938,
-0.33875831961631775,
-0.26153624057769775,
-0.6211481094360352,
-0.33132973313331604,
0.33021560311317444,
0.5164914131164551,
0.5005576610565186,
0.057071659713983536,
-0.7627493143081665,
0.1492602527141571,
-0.49859997630119324,
-0.23222044110298157,
0.2117777019739151,
0.30998966097831726,
0.2251717746257782,
0.10249084234237671,
0.008052199147641659,
0.5723472833633423,
0.03347257524728775,
-0.16348762810230255,
0.19144612550735474,
-0.06364161521196365,
-0.21432949602603912,
0.11492181569337845,
0.7565641403198242,
0.49703559279441833,
0.008283061906695366,
-0.3411352336406708,
0.0467437319457531,
-0.15164195001125336,
0.46039730310440063,
-0.5441253185272217,
-0.43560001254081726,
0.28207021951675415,
-0.5187138319015503,
0.0725972056388855,
0.041256800293922424,
-0.7138305306434631,
-0.06234767287969589,
-0.008406085893511772,
0.5935750007629395,
-0.7616169452667236,
-0.40943193435668945,
0.2083543986082077,
-0.19456668198108673,
0.24051007628440857,
0.4454044699668884,
-0.8632757663726807,
0.4305764436721802,
0.32526177167892456,
0.8232777714729309,
-0.39927390217781067,
-0.18488271534442902,
-0.49391311407089233,
0.5086396336555481,
-0.16594171524047852,
0.7189171314239502,
-0.6013779044151306,
-0.650558590888977,
0.02570563368499279,
-0.1768055260181427,
0.23511391878128052,
-0.9777831435203552,
0.22149908542633057,
-0.4447205662727356,
0.6653770804405212,
0.3647647202014923,
-0.5305564403533936,
-0.14230309426784515,
0.19649165868759155,
-0.33596184849739075,
1.0151216983795166,
0.5301102995872498,
-0.10908744484186172,
0.17855358123779297,
-0.4794738292694092,
-0.5402950644493103,
0.37161892652511597,
-0.14639951288700104,
-0.333848774433136,
0.0891394391655922,
-0.022493859753012657,
0.27172234654426575,
-0.04302484169602394,
0.3816182613372803,
-0.1277519166469574,
-0.23469577729701996,
0.4164060056209564,
-0.38876304030418396,
0.4174700975418091,
0.21370437741279602,
0.06730933487415314,
0.07189349830150604,
-0.4312674403190613,
0.4485054910182953,
-0.10795319080352783,
-0.3215204179286957,
-0.04633304476737976,
-0.006456371396780014,
-0.1217297688126564,
0.10961976647377014,
0.3152856230735779,
-0.5888487100601196,
0.011189636774361134,
-0.4177529811859131,
0.8263612985610962,
0.7918964624404907,
0.04243898764252663,
0.38517093658447266,
-0.6521669626235962,
0.2740175127983093,
0.2934797406196594,
0.40842628479003906,
-0.9752180576324463,
-0.3221172094345093,
-1.1570173501968384,
0.17813047766685486,
-0.17242790758609772,
0.48107969760894775,
-0.30818095803260803,
0.5808972120285034,
-0.15359453856945038,
-0.05879708379507065,
-0.17723581194877625,
0.2745640277862549,
0.002894732402637601,
0.5000924468040466,
0.5747062563896179,
-0.6204429268836975,
-0.7807853817939758,
-0.8535674810409546,
-0.04375813528895378,
-0.4500042498111725,
-0.33809521794319153,
0.4574742317199707,
-0.09309082478284836,
-0.2731161415576935,
1.2308610677719116,
-0.6336273550987244,
-0.13120241463184357,
-0.2823403477668762,
-0.02541070245206356,
-0.061080243438482285,
0.4262585937976837,
0.25204503536224365,
-0.5053108334541321,
-0.3719230890274048,
-0.20140527188777924,
-0.48685359954833984,
0.34926342964172363,
-0.5910385847091675,
-0.3753223121166229,
0.21260450780391693,
0.5986586809158325,
-0.7222090363502502,
0.22508354485034943,
0.30174148082733154,
-0.222939595580101,
0.19985902309417725,
-0.23829299211502075,
0.11783929169178009,
-1.1916462182998657,
-0.370654821395874,
-0.6635593771934509,
-0.3634095788002014,
-0.4888486862182617,
-0.5323891639709473,
0.08324328809976578,
-0.27685025334358215,
-0.6085764765739441,
1.0083824396133423,
-0.6449998617172241,
0.40768420696258545,
-0.48660579323768616,
0.269687682390213,
-0.013071575202047825,
0.7037334442138672,
-0.16852353513240814,
0.469461053609848,
0.5485497713088989,
-0.7239274382591248,
0.40809366106987,
0.1368916630744934,
-0.0392288975417614,
0.7987415194511414,
-0.31049981713294983,
0.4320380985736847,
-0.06773681938648224,
0.14680229127407074,
-1.1441549062728882,
-0.17870061099529266,
0.23734253644943237,
-0.5237684845924377,
0.45027104020118713,
0.05778256431221962,
-0.13412368297576904,
-0.3151102066040039,
-0.19380232691764832,
0.3494000732898712,
1.002550721168518,
-0.46409872174263,
1.0834200382232666,
0.3955109715461731,
-0.4052412509918213,
0.0000388703920179978,
-0.5223822593688965,
0.6392190456390381,
-0.2847503125667572,
-0.7760847210884094,
0.5201492309570312,
-0.3104422688484192,
-0.07470754534006119,
-0.13836689293384552,
-0.24169044196605682,
-0.13925792276859283,
-0.2164023220539093,
0.387498676776886,
0.46026891469955444,
-0.35416659712791443,
0.4074971377849579,
-0.04259030520915985,
-0.005165836773812771,
-0.10855308175086975,
-0.28058886528015137,
1.1225228309631348,
0.005265834741294384,
-0.2068975567817688,
-0.45715227723121643,
0.48700034618377686,
0.48889219760894775,
0.04838268458843231,
0.6593325138092041,
0.46167275309562683,
-0.13623517751693726,
-0.3653098940849304,
-1.0266613960266113,
-0.30365893244743347,
-0.5231357216835022,
0.3632022440433502,
-0.13569815456867218,
-0.9904915690422058,
0.5454398989677429,
-0.20763374865055084,
0.06958906352519989,
0.2023162841796875,
0.5168755650520325,
-0.367297887802124,
0.6636916995048523,
0.4019492566585541,
-0.08220718055963516,
0.7705997228622437,
0.26600971817970276,
0.28024086356163025,
-0.9297794699668884,
-0.3418624699115753,
0.05719119682908058,
-0.43165841698646545,
-0.09684210270643234,
-0.40290123224258423,
-0.022851234301924706,
0.2995131015777588,
-0.4859975278377533,
0.17249292135238647,
-0.42554324865341187,
0.6020873188972473,
0.41493818163871765,
0.37896788120269775,
0.2808895409107208,
-0.17428581416606903,
0.36720651388168335,
0.07013003528118134,
-0.5233948230743408,
-0.6501218676567078,
0.9195975661277771,
0.1303751915693283,
1.0482345819473267,
0.0013426188379526138,
0.7272700071334839,
0.3140994608402252,
0.2889285981655121,
-0.5579238533973694,
0.7436193227767944,
0.24949419498443604,
-0.3729898929595947,
-0.1320628970861435,
-0.2794223725795746,
-1.211410403251648,
0.038623321801424026,
-0.11534257978200912,
-0.9236053824424744,
-0.44165119528770447,
0.31502240896224976,
-0.6378098130226135,
0.4069051444530487,
-0.8877130746841431,
0.42728087306022644,
-0.43615373969078064,
-0.3772740960121155,
-0.23141784965991974,
-0.8456827998161316,
0.32602500915527344,
0.2321460098028183,
-0.2382127046585083,
-0.3296993374824524,
-0.08763913065195084,
0.4243304133415222,
-0.21418026089668274,
0.9257100224494934,
0.145758256316185,
0.18801002204418182,
0.5941265225410461,
0.25501549243927,
0.06794850528240204,
0.18974246084690094,
0.25253307819366455,
-0.0814843475818634,
-0.22464005649089813,
-0.4496989846229553,
-0.7670100927352905,
0.7731167078018188,
-0.5254101753234863,
-0.9414616227149963,
-0.11632625758647919,
-0.5061779618263245,
-0.3234368562698364,
0.03387370705604553,
-0.1104828417301178,
0.2138517051935196,
-0.6354790925979614,
0.13277676701545715,
0.8000775575637817,
-0.5184522867202759,
0.4936635494232178,
0.3816864788532257,
-0.47424155473709106,
-0.4524082541465759,
0.586440920829773,
-0.4313257038593292,
0.6627593040466309,
0.3516624867916107,
0.12173611670732498,
0.09680397808551788,
-0.30367404222488403,
-0.2675049901008606,
0.03276573121547699,
-0.4278086721897125,
-0.44015932083129883,
-0.8994026184082031,
-0.5391889214515686,
-0.07094260305166245,
-0.16387338936328888,
-0.38222673535346985,
-0.2921905219554901,
-0.16635160148143768,
0.11343464255332947,
0.4266425669193268,
0.337458074092865,
0.2143387645483017,
0.29352235794067383,
-1.0127111673355103,
0.3724586069583893,
0.5448766350746155,
0.26334428787231445,
0.1929573118686676,
-0.3838425278663635,
-0.10597708076238632,
0.2887267768383026,
-0.7072286605834961,
-0.5957786440849304,
0.29849404096603394,
0.38063371181488037,
0.6094237565994263,
0.22892598807811737,
-0.21298004686832428,
0.7709968686103821,
-0.5538544654846191,
1.0362130403518677,
0.5894380211830139,
-0.7615947127342224,
0.7047972679138184,
-0.24465666711330414,
0.663162112236023,
0.38196003437042236,
-0.21848182380199432,
-0.8526903986930847,
-0.6065916419029236,
-0.7344064116477966,
-1.052043080329895,
0.4309321641921997,
0.10455066710710526,
0.9071289300918579,
-0.48261648416519165,
0.4859106242656708,
0.27393853664398193,
0.03126738965511322,
-0.34989574551582336,
-0.09954264760017395,
-0.04189525544643402,
-0.08491943776607513,
0.22791308164596558,
-0.2519180476665497,
-0.11470090597867966,
-0.056070875376462936,
0.29241639375686646,
0.15195180475711823,
0.3800925612449646,
-0.20705318450927734,
-0.06564438343048096,
0.04188083857297897,
0.39519909024238586,
0.41608527302742004,
0.7111492156982422,
-0.17732807993888855,
0.07090172916650772,
0.34317824244499207,
-0.40804752707481384,
-0.02523234486579895,
-0.6034445762634277,
0.08114009350538254,
-0.03727716952562332,
-0.011438990011811256,
0.6293428540229797,
0.24418291449546814,
-0.8946264982223511,
0.26747018098831177,
-0.10402725636959076,
0.03632671758532524,
-0.5255899429321289,
0.648668110370636,
0.5284156203269958,
0.24654577672481537,
0.6714039444923401,
0.20588502287864685,
-0.3200019598007202,
-1.1849457025527954,
0.262421578168869,
0.5040910840034485,
-0.44521188735961914,
-0.2608889639377594,
0.5695413947105408,
0.42527294158935547,
-0.6908895969390869,
0.9199004173278809,
0.1611037403345108,
-0.35720208287239075,
0.17030678689479828,
0.7272294163703918,
0.8342676162719727,
-0.48429563641548157,
0.17263323068618774,
0.417283833026886,
-0.30049359798431396,
-0.22791787981987,
0.2104603499174118,
-0.28738194704055786,
-0.7889391779899597,
-0.03592054545879364,
-0.4941028356552124,
-0.32812395691871643,
0.17169877886772156,
-0.5293591022491455,
0.10401935875415802,
-0.5499699711799622,
-0.5023674964904785,
-0.4676770865917206,
-0.40609970688819885,
-0.5471217036247253,
0.12200651317834854,
-0.0461219847202301,
0.4086760878562927,
-0.2519054412841797,
0.5840625166893005,
0.08752422034740448,
-0.22096920013427734,
-0.17144747078418732,
-0.08036544919013977,
-0.29669398069381714,
-0.9027455449104309,
0.39564454555511475,
0.1095614954829216,
-0.4010952413082123,
-0.3136422038078308,
-0.4796627163887024,
-0.7435867786407471,
1.0760102272033691,
0.2891548275947571,
-0.4860036373138428,
-0.21165436506271362,
-0.17461559176445007,
0.4968012571334839,
-0.35842570662498474,
0.09957093745470047,
0.3770219683647156,
-0.06562820076942444,
0.4491504430770874,
-0.7658154964447021,
-0.13434231281280518,
-0.12042990326881409,
0.11659692227840424,
0.6970920562744141,
-0.8810417056083679,
0.898654043674469,
-0.3488314151763916,
-0.8304235935211182,
0.43169769644737244,
0.9849056601524353,
-0.02894383668899536,
0.017908789217472076,
0.2090902477502823,
0.21336965262889862,
0.8825621008872986,
-0.043031707406044006,
0.39216935634613037,
-0.2881048321723938,
-0.12769478559494019,
1.5991442203521729,
-0.3539142310619354,
0.8475795984268188,
0.5027249455451965,
-0.10546597093343735,
0.6719921827316284,
0.15946923196315765,
0.18696071207523346,
0.26753342151641846,
0.22903335094451904,
-0.5053650140762329,
-0.2741725742816925,
0.19897179305553436,
-0.23529866337776184,
0.34152504801750183,
0.4173368215560913,
-0.32895350456237793,
-0.14111843705177307,
0.1694742888212204,
0.1267491728067398,
0.1931414157152176,
-0.11200990527868271,
0.8079566359519958,
0.018159979954361916,
-0.7722565531730652,
0.45439478754997253,
-0.35729658603668213,
0.9159652590751648,
-0.7121491432189941,
-0.03329816088080406,
-0.4675278961658478,
0.26617884635925293,
-0.09912751615047455,
-0.9407629370689392,
0.3700251877307892,
-0.3149486780166626,
-0.055550720542669296,
-0.3543781042098999,
0.6445440649986267,
-0.7493478655815125,
-0.1732420027256012,
0.17009897530078888,
0.8221864700317383,
0.04254717752337456,
0.08710907399654388,
-0.4136797785758972,
0.12216386944055557,
-0.027793219313025475,
0.019214190542697906,
0.37960878014564514,
0.44004279375076294,
0.053511980921030045,
0.8845343589782715,
0.3838372826576233,
0.013913242146372795,
-0.005045074503868818,
0.035667531192302704,
0.7106118202209473,
-1.096339225769043,
-0.34722259640693665,
-1.0184593200683594,
0.38306689262390137,
-0.2657725214958191,
-0.4889947175979614,
0.6726711988449097,
0.833626925945282,
0.7182820439338684,
0.13266994059085846,
0.8503506183624268,
0.1389515995979309,
0.5688454508781433,
-0.6150788068771362,
0.5956665873527527,
-0.1412619650363922,
0.03059018962085247,
0.067811019718647,
-0.766758382320404,
-0.1707502007484436,
0.5276370644569397,
0.23787279427051544,
0.25392523407936096,
0.5767406821250916,
0.6950128078460693,
-0.061691977083683014,
0.11910320073366165,
0.5161219835281372,
0.13699553906917572,
0.5037134289741516,
0.9756746888160706,
1.1655082702636719,
-0.23888099193572998,
0.7819052934646606,
0.37081024050712585,
0.05547739565372467,
-0.04405326023697853,
-0.5399278998374939,
-0.9733933210372925,
-0.7573444843292236,
-0.19843779504299164,
-0.30396729707717896,
0.09466040879487991,
0.7532733678817749,
0.7436690926551819,
-0.4161640703678131,
-0.41008836030960083,
0.2312067151069641,
-0.17736771702766418,
0.015965554863214493,
-0.2525409460067749,
0.1307661384344101,
-0.5815213918685913,
-0.5828993320465088,
0.3102256655693054,
0.9549388885498047,
0.27125105261802673,
-0.4527752101421356,
-0.045352041721343994,
0.02279549650847912,
0.27391695976257324,
0.8208658695220947,
0.5056322813034058,
-0.7518508434295654,
-0.4256177842617035,
0.15286089479923248,
-0.11777424067258835,
0.8772395849227905,
0.900576114654541,
-1.0319206714630127,
0.8016537427902222,
0.1543695628643036,
0.3978178799152374,
0.8364856243133545,
-0.04986632242798805,
0.9546616077423096,
-0.3940792977809906,
0.06228015571832657,
0.5862843990325928,
0.12939460575580597,
0.4934799373149872,
-0.1698465347290039,
0.1814197152853012,
-0.2226366251707077,
-0.4292961359024048,
-0.5340992212295532,
0.4887675940990448,
-1.0705156326293945,
-0.4708029627799988,
0.83781898021698,
0.24351376295089722,
-0.21006391942501068,
-0.4463769495487213,
-0.6381019353866577,
-0.012917013838887215,
-0.5890601873397827,
0.9921234846115112,
0.8872359395027161,
-0.7044914364814758,
-0.1891021579504013,
-0.32016491889953613,
0.37787139415740967,
0.2504456341266632,
-0.7966047525405884,
0.04439288750290871,
0.502042293548584,
0.36041292548179626,
0.16133156418800354,
1.019505262374878,
-0.10939767956733704,
0.22815032303333282,
0.08111733943223953,
-0.1387149542570114,
0.20692956447601318,
-0.17492002248764038,
0.42861706018447876,
0.18056155741214752,
-0.09931352734565735,
-0.12550362944602966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01432v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01432v2
|
Fine Tuning vs. Retrieval Augmented Generation for Less Popular Knowledge
| 2024-03-03T08:07:55 | 2024-03-07T11:24:09 |
Heydar Soudani, Evangelos Kanoulas, Faegheh Hasibi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) memorize a vast amount of factual knowledge,
exhibiting strong performance across diverse tasks and domains. However, it has
been observed that the performance diminishes when dealing with less-popular or
low-frequency concepts and entities, for example in domain specific
applications. The two prominent approaches to enhance the performance of LLMs
on low-frequent topics are: Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) and
fine-tuning (FT) over synthetic data. This paper explores and evaluates the
impact of RAG and FT on customizing LLMs in handling low-frequency entities on
question answering task. Our findings indicate that FT significantly boosts the
performance across entities of varying popularity, especially in the most and
least popular groups, while RAG surpasses other methods. Additionally, the
success of both RAG and FT approaches is amplified by advancements in retrieval
and data augmentation techniques. We release our data and code at
https://github.com/informagi/RAGvsFT.
|
[
-0.9747629761695862,
-1.1961870193481445,
0.5276534557342529,
-0.21303793787956238,
-0.15544165670871735,
0.360024094581604,
-0.4372881054878235,
-0.6797916889190674,
0.2974180281162262,
0.6424892544746399,
-0.39648178219795227,
-0.2796521782875061,
-0.32546645402908325,
0.1958041936159134,
-0.2558956444263458,
1.0565035343170166,
0.1404494345188141,
-0.1810985654592514,
-0.39667457342147827,
-0.271104097366333,
-0.5822921395301819,
-0.435932457447052,
-0.7514547109603882,
-0.3523339331150055,
0.6015805602073669,
0.6574252843856812,
0.6589705944061279,
0.7249473333358765,
0.5002234578132629,
0.28533273935317993,
-0.3275723457336426,
0.8273712992668152,
-0.9349780082702637,
0.22967040538787842,
-0.33863288164138794,
-0.3911534249782562,
-0.4517277181148529,
-0.2232125848531723,
0.4113314151763916,
0.8792340755462646,
-0.13817304372787476,
0.4259033501148224,
-0.00964425876736641,
0.7999556064605713,
-0.7041580080986023,
-0.2086111158132553,
-1.1477066278457642,
-0.3969900906085968,
-0.2725391983985901,
-0.477958083152771,
-0.17270731925964355,
-0.2968565821647644,
0.01597028784453869,
-0.8736175894737244,
0.49603042006492615,
0.3303830921649933,
0.8821430802345276,
0.5156559944152832,
-0.12682481110095978,
-0.2825964689254761,
-1.0246065855026245,
0.8860519528388977,
-0.411420613527298,
0.48630139231681824,
0.3686423599720001,
0.23004846274852753,
-0.17781631648540497,
-0.5961064100265503,
-0.5631979703903198,
-0.08339516818523407,
-0.054075926542282104,
-0.0816025361418724,
-0.10693936049938202,
-0.0023069584276527166,
0.43924084305763245,
0.5946637988090515,
-0.2736620008945465,
0.10321807861328125,
-0.39845553040504456,
0.004483667202293873,
0.5909040570259094,
0.2610792815685272,
0.02742699719965458,
-0.24536238610744476,
-0.18487843871116638,
0.11978980153799057,
-0.8939082622528076,
-0.08941273391246796,
0.15971675515174866,
0.4652138948440552,
0.17824026942253113,
0.6925747990608215,
-0.5996906757354736,
0.8809430599212646,
0.4043833315372467,
-0.12487965822219849,
0.13916294276714325,
-0.36734911799430847,
-0.28357723355293274,
-0.20119072496891022,
0.24004259705543518,
0.3240526020526886,
0.3248104453086853,
-0.24719491600990295,
-0.41844287514686584,
-0.34651240706443787,
0.17774932086467743,
-0.6848117709159851,
0.03641902282834053,
-0.21013669669628143,
-0.30494067072868347,
0.018932338804006577,
-0.233400359749794,
-0.7165294885635376,
-0.5270507335662842,
-0.8462216258049011,
0.4613049030303955,
-0.3954337239265442,
0.09698864072561264,
-0.030727852135896683,
-0.1466592252254486,
0.12813490629196167,
0.6359269022941589,
-0.9019733667373657,
0.3353765606880188,
1.0537599325180054,
0.6816570162773132,
-0.32814228534698486,
0.12397781014442444,
-0.7404108047485352,
0.11164376884698868,
-0.3661976158618927,
0.9857009053230286,
-0.7397476434707642,
-0.35816821455955505,
-0.24146682024002075,
-0.20832495391368866,
-0.07358808815479279,
-0.8941709995269775,
0.38032644987106323,
-0.9843697547912598,
0.007735301740467548,
-0.45206594467163086,
-0.7158868312835693,
0.08771239966154099,
0.20139886438846588,
-0.6519941091537476,
1.1753278970718384,
0.2305295616388321,
-0.5775095820426941,
0.46597814559936523,
-0.38885393738746643,
-0.47257745265960693,
0.08991371840238571,
-0.04640309885144234,
-0.22146502137184143,
0.3003902733325958,
0.15782447159290314,
0.3734985589981079,
-0.5903098583221436,
-0.10368906706571579,
-0.3460981249809265,
-0.7052688002586365,
0.1929626315832138,
-0.28429681062698364,
0.07206013053655624,
0.5804523825645447,
0.12816032767295837,
-0.28805282711982727,
-0.9112101197242737,
0.08865917474031448,
-0.14414989948272705,
-0.6113268733024597,
-0.6754494309425354,
-0.01041316892951727,
-0.11935073882341385,
-0.0848698765039444,
0.2789396643638611,
-0.42636561393737793,
0.18691731989383698,
-0.8002381324768066,
0.18991009891033173,
0.5418139696121216,
0.5325816869735718,
0.6595157980918884,
-0.7855419516563416,
0.42236602306365967,
-0.13145418465137482,
-0.19217288494110107,
0.22081279754638672,
-0.3716796040534973,
-0.7169135212898254,
-0.0637914389371872,
0.4149148762226105,
0.45840656757354736,
-1.118947982788086,
-0.16428041458129883,
-0.3452117145061493,
-0.5236629843711853,
-0.7666431665420532,
0.5569649934768677,
0.32643499970436096,
0.7347447276115417,
0.5922145843505859,
-0.001105639268644154,
-0.6440590023994446,
-0.9157968163490295,
-0.5393759608268738,
0.07903388142585754,
-0.08743734657764435,
0.8230946660041809,
0.13259351253509521,
-0.20033998787403107,
0.900242269039154,
-0.6695401072502136,
-0.18872956931591034,
-0.31402647495269775,
-0.0646907314658165,
0.2503439784049988,
0.4082460403442383,
0.5842838287353516,
-0.7777189016342163,
-0.6737264394760132,
0.07798267155885696,
-0.015398099087178707,
-0.03430955111980438,
0.10558723658323288,
-0.14701558649539948,
0.5685024261474609,
0.47576940059661865,
-0.5648590922355652,
0.12464779615402222,
0.2819264531135559,
0.09300665557384491,
0.1667226105928421,
-0.08036116510629654,
0.42554450035095215,
-1.0380398035049438,
0.017348019406199455,
-0.05771157518029213,
-0.2276354730129242,
-0.8675355911254883,
0.024830637499690056,
-0.14396370947360992,
0.1934405416250229,
-0.44509223103523254,
0.7248978018760681,
-0.31343457102775574,
0.06318800151348114,
-0.3028578758239746,
0.24449670314788818,
0.09050120413303375,
0.2986879348754883,
-0.15838399529457092,
1.1729176044464111,
0.07580042630434036,
-0.9886665940284729,
0.0481269396841526,
0.2236384153366089,
-0.48908132314682007,
0.3316662013530731,
-0.6770626306533813,
0.2581714987754822,
-0.29844990372657776,
-0.3300839960575104,
-0.8095924854278564,
-0.4170432388782501,
-0.15948468446731567,
-0.42657849192619324,
0.4685126841068268,
-0.36934059858322144,
-0.6029971241950989,
-0.02381068281829357,
-0.2871110141277313,
0.20021872222423553,
0.6726912260055542,
-0.432131290435791,
0.38389313220977783,
0.4426042437553406,
-0.04212265461683273,
-0.4225509464740753,
-0.5917244553565979,
-0.31895706057548523,
-0.44906166195869446,
-0.6020025610923767,
0.36732056736946106,
-0.08365342766046524,
-0.4539948105812073,
-0.19787411391735077,
-0.2401258647441864,
-0.11022673547267914,
0.26291507482528687,
-0.0359419584274292,
0.19896000623703003,
-0.47157174348831177,
0.4432016909122467,
0.07575817406177521,
0.030875438824295998,
-0.4521251618862152,
0.03146881237626076,
0.6119487285614014,
-0.09148550778627396,
-0.19801098108291626,
0.16106966137886047,
0.16652485728263855,
0.28078946471214294,
-0.25139349699020386,
0.8736637830734253,
0.5555673241615295,
-0.29143086075782776,
-0.42086243629455566,
-0.8813093304634094,
-0.24162089824676514,
-0.5319653153419495,
0.11880321055650711,
-0.45235031843185425,
-1.1883630752563477,
0.41198235750198364,
-0.2502307891845703,
-0.0007543679093942046,
0.48201531171798706,
0.6534863114356995,
-0.29991772770881653,
0.946182906627655,
0.575312614440918,
0.02506173774600029,
0.5890985727310181,
-0.10884691774845123,
0.013598337769508362,
-0.9176047444343567,
0.1458425372838974,
-0.5953719615936279,
-0.3539092540740967,
-0.865032434463501,
-0.5515194535255432,
0.4575338661670685,
0.41458460688591003,
-0.18896888196468353,
0.09310643374919891,
-0.5578627586364746,
0.5898870825767517,
0.6138206720352173,
0.10082130879163742,
0.6148160099983215,
0.31779277324676514,
0.2695430815219879,
-0.07619389146566391,
-0.7577682733535767,
-0.4605103135108948,
1.1116352081298828,
0.06804131716489792,
0.896767258644104,
0.14872485399246216,
0.7142288088798523,
0.08257387578487396,
0.23342809081077576,
-0.6815931797027588,
0.46931299567222595,
-0.5973406434059143,
-0.6999121904373169,
-0.3728632628917694,
-0.5295262336730957,
-1.0193192958831787,
0.03600708022713661,
-0.4026281237602234,
-0.44567304849624634,
0.2641535997390747,
0.42723631858825684,
-0.47448480129241943,
0.1807272732257843,
-0.8015283942222595,
0.3277466595172882,
0.16315703094005585,
-0.2880057394504547,
-0.2819647490978241,
-0.229268878698349,
0.3311758041381836,
-0.24148067831993103,
0.11773493885993958,
-0.0644950196146965,
-0.15989021956920624,
0.5578997135162354,
-0.258743017911911,
0.5299385190010071,
-0.15935350954532623,
0.1297028362751007,
0.4084245562553406,
-0.027151692658662796,
0.7340906262397766,
0.30192598700523376,
-0.3511607348918915,
-0.2716056704521179,
0.05728921666741371,
-0.22857767343521118,
-0.7412028312683105,
0.964594841003418,
-0.7070606350898743,
-0.885392963886261,
0.09084797650575638,
-0.625274658203125,
-0.6730162501335144,
0.1299741268157959,
0.19122712314128876,
0.32126230001449585,
-0.010220522060990334,
0.46906712651252747,
1.1407232284545898,
-0.22199702262878418,
0.09211856126785278,
0.7040553689002991,
-0.07755176723003387,
-0.3787953555583954,
1.1128151416778564,
0.3652580976486206,
0.501984715461731,
0.4361844062805176,
-0.01736120507121086,
-0.04464391991496086,
-0.7454113960266113,
-0.3917422890663147,
0.36976760625839233,
-0.6333810687065125,
-0.3638390302658081,
-0.6853765249252319,
-0.15508180856704712,
-0.36699554324150085,
-0.0728391781449318,
-0.3563031256198883,
-0.7627449035644531,
-0.5108064413070679,
0.08100958168506622,
0.9019582271575928,
0.5709704756736755,
0.06845158338546753,
0.09473828971385956,
-0.7503760457038879,
0.6650710701942444,
0.26356229186058044,
0.5148242115974426,
-0.13038088381290436,
-0.606317400932312,
-0.34997203946113586,
0.1221332922577858,
-0.10698682069778442,
-0.4398459792137146,
0.11244126409292221,
0.3494974970817566,
0.47285014390945435,
0.006010557524859905,
0.1610672026872635,
1.0104402303695679,
-0.4973165690898895,
0.5377407670021057,
-0.37819358706474304,
-0.5296596884727478,
0.3447456955909729,
-0.4208317995071411,
0.1732373684644699,
0.9221048951148987,
0.22832469642162323,
-0.4905286729335785,
-0.44964489340782166,
-0.5047938823699951,
-0.8446240425109863,
0.7147549986839294,
0.035728082060813904,
0.26401790976524353,
0.00922344345599413,
0.7421941161155701,
0.157314732670784,
0.4894104599952698,
-0.04965422302484512,
-0.49658697843551636,
0.1702568680047989,
-0.08043655008077621,
-0.17444072663784027,
-0.22067517042160034,
-0.08188926428556442,
-0.3139122724533081,
0.6885758638381958,
-0.13568681478500366,
0.19104629755020142,
0.16675089299678802,
-0.2166011780500412,
-0.3786425292491913,
0.40386512875556946,
0.7203070521354675,
0.5891860723495483,
-0.19676199555397034,
-0.07847926765680313,
0.6020894646644592,
-0.39352577924728394,
-0.16922400891780853,
0.16679301857948303,
-0.6569622159004211,
-0.009849323891103268,
0.1993931382894516,
0.8594714999198914,
0.07803873717784882,
-0.5351017713546753,
-0.07027272135019302,
0.19463221728801727,
-0.11501658707857132,
-0.13889554142951965,
0.5118769407272339,
0.11982607841491699,
0.25305402278900146,
0.37494078278541565,
0.20667900145053864,
0.13492488861083984,
-0.5405697822570801,
0.13904327154159546,
0.6041421294212341,
-0.03811214864253998,
-0.08124713599681854,
0.518047034740448,
-0.025821402668952942,
-0.13730573654174805,
0.20486919581890106,
-0.18203306198120117,
-0.15718646347522736,
0.5383100509643555,
0.32569625973701477,
0.38448527455329895,
0.06018095090985298,
0.06531684100627899,
0.2749386727809906,
0.24454611539840698,
0.025901146233081818,
0.38015246391296387,
-0.06819956004619598,
-0.6523734331130981,
-0.6235886812210083,
-0.9018223285675049,
-0.37455490231513977,
0.32138410210609436,
-0.5452235341072083,
0.28275492787361145,
-0.42165863513946533,
-0.1307910680770874,
0.0988176092505455,
0.3451176583766937,
-0.7835886478424072,
0.24542178213596344,
-0.10100630670785904,
0.8842917680740356,
-0.3475394546985626,
0.7350785136222839,
1.010994553565979,
-0.34539347887039185,
-0.8476293683052063,
-0.019360987469553947,
-0.24461697041988373,
-0.764107882976532,
0.5979331731796265,
-0.41014567017555237,
-0.022837374359369278,
0.2964542806148529,
-0.38506147265434265,
-1.2756999731063843,
1.101418375968933,
0.3139338791370392,
-0.53728848695755,
0.00453608762472868,
0.29188981652259827,
0.8758590817451477,
-0.2417295277118683,
-0.05831551179289818,
0.776560366153717,
0.4703241288661957,
0.24048416316509247,
-0.9506033062934875,
-0.11670776456594467,
0.07424765080213547,
0.15164273977279663,
0.4240795373916626,
-0.735152542591095,
0.7827199101448059,
-0.048542771488428116,
-0.36053621768951416,
0.12611357867717743,
0.5828030705451965,
0.42689159512519836,
0.5259265899658203,
0.4602817893028259,
0.4534277617931366,
0.903828501701355,
-0.2123813033103943,
1.1007370948791504,
-0.3680330514907837,
0.2328425496816635,
1.1134880781173706,
-0.0968133956193924,
0.8245717287063599,
0.5021580457687378,
-0.09682845324277878,
0.05111764371395111,
0.5204975605010986,
0.04174135625362396,
0.5160695314407349,
0.07159648835659027,
-0.04500708729028702,
-0.38097140192985535,
-0.23756659030914307,
-0.3418334126472473,
0.23048752546310425,
0.5120511651039124,
-0.14432866871356964,
-0.18423306941986084,
0.16451862454414368,
-0.050436779856681824,
0.24396497011184692,
-0.5966984629631042,
1.1453758478164673,
0.12370618432760239,
-0.8290073275566101,
1.0187407732009888,
0.05958033353090286,
0.6322160959243774,
-0.1793821007013321,
-0.05301377549767494,
-0.4390489161014557,
0.0750073716044426,
-0.28762078285217285,
-0.6695365905761719,
0.5169604420661926,
0.14345033466815948,
-0.49466168880462646,
-0.15783433616161346,
1.0161726474761963,
-0.39199069142341614,
-0.25947389006614685,
-0.030235351994633675,
0.6812688708305359,
-0.17280316352844238,
0.05528140440583229,
-0.5333941578865051,
-0.009050024673342705,
-0.03256439045071602,
-0.41339173913002014,
0.45438113808631897,
0.5643518567085266,
-0.15728743374347687,
0.7012400031089783,
0.7717968821525574,
0.19222751259803772,
0.20873302221298218,
0.15210585296154022,
1.0911650657653809,
-0.43989256024360657,
-0.00041363260243088007,
-0.5060498118400574,
0.2603256404399872,
0.03017428144812584,
-0.18132305145263672,
0.9217232465744019,
0.6080937385559082,
0.9058377146720886,
-0.09290493279695511,
0.5352923274040222,
0.016762500628829002,
1.263031005859375,
-0.6730024218559265,
0.5943644046783447,
-0.8192037343978882,
0.5731635093688965,
-0.23615385591983795,
-0.9971701502799988,
-0.10385613143444061,
0.0872039943933487,
-0.47448253631591797,
0.14145468175411224,
0.24587026238441467,
1.0052013397216797,
-0.14519165456295013,
-0.13214470446109772,
0.3118113875389099,
0.33300942182540894,
0.07395655661821365,
0.297095388174057,
0.9041564464569092,
-0.19268356263637543,
0.5501798391342163,
-0.361441045999527,
0.17908403277397156,
-0.27368852496147156,
-0.3992636799812317,
-0.8630326986312866,
-0.45480096340179443,
-0.16818681359291077,
-0.1651025414466858,
0.045543454587459564,
0.9246265292167664,
0.4626111090183258,
-0.8735218644142151,
0.2107909470796585,
-0.035629358142614365,
0.29711487889289856,
0.09765072911977768,
-0.287520170211792,
0.12310806661844254,
-0.5310257077217102,
-0.8268951773643494,
0.4107495844364166,
0.021448330953717232,
0.036201559007167816,
0.05159289762377739,
0.014068666845560074,
-0.17136308550834656,
0.42252519726753235,
0.710809051990509,
0.3033360540866852,
-0.63679039478302,
-0.2830088138580322,
0.3482435941696167,
-0.1360858976840973,
0.07867665588855743,
0.6777258515357971,
-0.9753926396369934,
0.15472450852394104,
0.7499310970306396,
0.8490768671035767,
0.594239354133606,
0.572618305683136,
0.2872394025325775,
-0.9439771175384521,
-0.1424904316663742,
0.21608835458755493,
0.03864240273833275,
0.3268720805644989,
-0.4988626539707184,
0.4869075417518616,
0.11454378813505173,
-0.6963415145874023,
-1.0499563217163086,
0.21038918197155,
-0.8050497770309448,
-0.32825759053230286,
1.1811492443084717,
0.4031623601913452,
-0.11382509768009186,
-0.31474077701568604,
-0.11434309929609299,
0.12373314052820206,
-0.4388802945613861,
0.7029427886009216,
0.5893667340278625,
-0.2793739140033722,
-0.053070761263370514,
-0.8511708974838257,
0.936823844909668,
0.4818093776702881,
-0.6119595170021057,
-0.07435629516839981,
0.5328832268714905,
0.47064539790153503,
0.24447819590568542,
0.46051526069641113,
0.2322763204574585,
0.33200404047966003,
-0.47126245498657227,
-0.405218243598938,
-0.22852514684200287,
-0.18322312831878662,
-0.18100620806217194,
0.21184757351875305,
0.37468284368515015,
0.29504185914993286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01411v1
|
OVEL: Large Language Model as Memory Manager for Online Video Entity Linking
| 2024-03-03T06:47:51 | 2024-03-03T06:47:51 |
Haiquan Zhao, Xuwu Wang, Shisong Chen, Zhixu Li, Xin Zheng, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, multi-modal entity linking (MEL) has garnered increasing
attention in the research community due to its significance in numerous
multi-modal applications. Video, as a popular means of information
transmission, has become prevalent in people's daily lives. However, most
existing MEL methods primarily focus on linking textual and visual mentions or
offline videos's mentions to entities in multi-modal knowledge bases, with
limited efforts devoted to linking mentions within online video content. In
this paper, we propose a task called Online Video Entity Linking OVEL, aiming
to establish connections between mentions in online videos and a knowledge base
with high accuracy and timeliness. To facilitate the research works of OVEL, we
specifically concentrate on live delivery scenarios and construct a live
delivery entity linking dataset called LIVE. Besides, we propose an evaluation
metric that considers timelessness, robustness, and accuracy. Furthermore, to
effectively handle OVEL task, we leverage a memory block managed by a Large
Language Model and retrieve entity candidates from the knowledge base to
augment LLM performance on memory management. The experimental results prove
the effectiveness and efficiency of our method.
|
[
-0.6477996706962585,
-1.0395046472549438,
0.3543459177017212,
0.09021789580583572,
-0.31165817379951477,
-0.07605137676000595,
-0.5214584469795227,
-0.5981069207191467,
0.2750377357006073,
0.29002290964126587,
-0.2939623296260834,
-0.36218735575675964,
-0.2911019027233124,
-0.348526269197464,
-0.4443854093551636,
0.7057215571403503,
-0.37099942564964294,
0.05914144963026047,
-0.09738525003194809,
-0.41162043809890747,
-0.31338828802108765,
-0.16550703346729279,
-0.7638027667999268,
0.2515694797039032,
0.4745117425918579,
0.0011218669824302197,
0.5865854620933533,
0.9166971445083618,
0.5903355479240417,
0.29422855377197266,
0.1672806590795517,
0.4577234983444214,
-0.5073555111885071,
0.5333656072616577,
-0.3329470455646515,
-0.2064957469701767,
-0.8215875029563904,
-0.7324861884117126,
0.8694579601287842,
0.30304232239723206,
-0.24954766035079956,
0.3417077660560608,
-0.4083397686481476,
0.3255852460861206,
-0.9281217455863953,
0.18739797174930573,
-0.8735659122467041,
0.11041698604822159,
-0.2845230996608734,
-0.14199689030647278,
-0.1850779503583908,
-0.38744357228279114,
-0.03120017610490322,
-0.6759199500083923,
0.12289291620254517,
0.41262906789779663,
0.6774877309799194,
0.3403400480747223,
-0.24474428594112396,
-0.1750490367412567,
-0.9527514576911926,
0.5216391682624817,
-0.5400876402854919,
0.6576662659645081,
0.44614705443382263,
0.7397557497024536,
0.12990988790988922,
-0.3946858048439026,
-0.6791532039642334,
-0.15423548221588135,
0.5108845829963684,
-0.26846376061439514,
0.23990517854690552,
0.0729607567191124,
0.32630226016044617,
0.3704478144645691,
-0.1764470487833023,
-0.210079625248909,
-0.3140570819377899,
-0.12734240293502808,
0.33695051074028015,
0.1353929489850998,
0.5194255113601685,
-0.01391750480979681,
-0.5532586574554443,
0.33313482999801636,
-0.7466254830360413,
-0.5601536631584167,
0.21739229559898376,
0.17623306810855865,
-0.06435076892375946,
0.8917691111564636,
0.013101238757371902,
0.8706151843070984,
-0.21040034294128418,
-0.5248382687568665,
0.09234850853681564,
-0.32418403029441833,
-0.35775673389434814,
0.2626042068004608,
0.6979132294654846,
0.5491299033164978,
0.3221515119075775,
-0.1637718677520752,
-0.13664259016513824,
0.1450260877609253,
0.29342204332351685,
-0.7870610952377319,
-0.14689821004867554,
-0.15133152902126312,
-0.3347170054912567,
0.2788013815879822,
0.10388490557670593,
-0.8896798491477966,
-0.3716758191585541,
-0.008678067475557327,
0.627494215965271,
-0.653431236743927,
-0.4000276029109955,
-0.0999072715640068,
0.3519878387451172,
-0.1325901448726654,
0.549504816532135,
-0.7354518175125122,
0.2921789288520813,
0.3847620487213135,
0.8289249539375305,
-0.23335562646389008,
-0.3647337555885315,
-1.0413761138916016,
0.8519842028617859,
0.18689146637916565,
0.5647487044334412,
-0.44104883074760437,
0.06783653050661087,
0.5247383117675781,
-0.08494678139686584,
-0.11947769671678543,
-0.47913408279418945,
0.19052104651927948,
-0.9318944811820984,
-0.1536197066307068,
-0.23155273497104645,
-0.5850813984870911,
-0.1804056167602539,
0.5784120559692383,
-0.9322735071182251,
0.9705070853233337,
-0.17333859205245972,
-0.6252665519714355,
0.47336387634277344,
-0.48854580521583557,
-0.41707348823547363,
-0.08963271975517273,
-0.2670069932937622,
-0.33857443928718567,
-0.2244938313961029,
0.10026169568300247,
0.559283435344696,
-0.32460224628448486,
0.5781980752944946,
-0.4901610016822815,
-0.09497503936290741,
0.09794825315475464,
-0.2640324532985687,
0.19630180299282074,
0.2354905605316162,
-0.2786233425140381,
-0.04165547341108322,
-0.9637562036514282,
-0.5064594745635986,
-0.020883405581116676,
-0.5347728729248047,
-0.44012632966041565,
0.03548141196370125,
-0.01832052692770958,
0.3300226926803589,
-0.12400040030479431,
-0.4766700267791748,
0.30096712708473206,
-0.030765490606427193,
0.48233962059020996,
0.4778347313404083,
0.13195210695266724,
0.5658482909202576,
0.03210664540529251,
0.403931200504303,
0.08213992416858673,
0.26370078325271606,
-0.53655606508255,
-0.4851762652397156,
-0.8577072024345398,
-0.21105195581912994,
0.008743365295231342,
0.25335946679115295,
-0.7725258469581604,
-0.22344672679901123,
-0.49181056022644043,
-0.04667603597044945,
-0.450624942779541,
0.447238028049469,
0.3140152394771576,
0.5406822562217712,
0.5605570077896118,
-0.1610143929719925,
-0.48287418484687805,
-0.519988477230072,
0.03284694626927376,
-0.2029644250869751,
0.006145547144114971,
0.510736882686615,
0.3396173119544983,
-0.14188869297504425,
0.8894947171211243,
-0.6682742238044739,
-0.7364399433135986,
0.12225233018398285,
-0.05529652535915375,
-0.27887752652168274,
0.030051153153181076,
0.5407446026802063,
-0.9177740812301636,
-0.41928547620773315,
-0.10795453190803528,
-0.8424837589263916,
0.4621832072734833,
0.06524855643510818,
-0.15741465985774994,
0.2560579478740692,
0.45694878697395325,
-0.7111963629722595,
0.2131866216659546,
0.40239229798316956,
0.022520799189805984,
0.13626013696193695,
-0.36276161670684814,
0.395506352186203,
-1.0542020797729492,
-0.040643494576215744,
0.07052402198314667,
-0.32782265543937683,
-0.09206234663724899,
0.051206573843955994,
-0.05897361785173416,
-0.10067588090896606,
-0.922066330909729,
0.6931041479110718,
-0.685819149017334,
-0.471231609582901,
0.13725192844867706,
0.5754299759864807,
-0.23631632328033447,
0.5255991220474243,
0.0482901968061924,
0.5422595143318176,
0.6819192171096802,
-0.9702773690223694,
0.8459754586219788,
0.2316294014453888,
-0.447109580039978,
0.8406366109848022,
-0.09302671253681183,
-0.22746632993221283,
-0.232335165143013,
-0.07167552411556244,
-0.8847265839576721,
-0.3948293924331665,
0.30242612957954407,
-0.2539985477924347,
0.3538713753223419,
-0.24648068845272064,
-0.5083592534065247,
-0.05865487456321716,
-0.05976741760969162,
0.5338911414146423,
0.23506209254264832,
-0.38819772005081177,
0.963715136051178,
0.6365935802459717,
-0.059218909591436386,
-0.3545689880847931,
-0.5667932629585266,
-0.05019359290599823,
-0.32979536056518555,
-0.666328489780426,
0.4575768709182739,
-0.07791868597269058,
-0.3125859200954437,
0.3670506179332733,
-0.12298880517482758,
-0.28958606719970703,
-0.2822120189666748,
0.3132880628108978,
0.3123672306537628,
-0.418979287147522,
0.3765033781528473,
-0.24068160355091095,
0.11159973591566086,
0.08790943026542664,
-0.17262625694274902,
0.37766849994659424,
0.40726438164711,
-0.4877692461013794,
0.12125843018293381,
0.4111156165599823,
0.5556525588035583,
-0.36042317748069763,
1.2082120180130005,
0.7843390703201294,
-0.7022126317024231,
-0.045837804675102234,
-1.0228524208068848,
0.02143765240907669,
-0.3837480843067169,
0.34831365942955017,
-0.1711416095495224,
-0.851137638092041,
0.6716448068618774,
-0.20139771699905396,
-0.09535636007785797,
0.17001700401306152,
0.4198607802391052,
-0.05194473639130592,
0.6707983613014221,
0.44927531480789185,
-0.16897785663604736,
0.5933043956756592,
-0.17407067120075226,
0.11782938241958618,
-0.8523610830307007,
-0.6046356558799744,
-0.20969246327877045,
0.05331450328230858,
0.047604531049728394,
-0.8726481199264526,
0.4708729088306427,
0.3143225908279419,
-0.5762342214584351,
0.5103474259376526,
0.09318926930427551,
0.13950300216674805,
0.1790858656167984,
0.0195558313280344,
0.5730677843093872,
0.23421509563922882,
-0.251294881105423,
0.03962039574980736,
-0.6964360475540161,
-0.1545201987028122,
0.7349011301994324,
0.3923361897468567,
1.0343354940414429,
0.4315618574619293,
0.07600974291563034,
0.40629422664642334,
0.11773492395877838,
-0.4937240779399872,
0.7708953619003296,
0.4057265818119049,
-0.7083489298820496,
-0.32089763879776,
-0.20321108400821686,
-0.5764796733856201,
-0.14265696704387665,
-0.461439847946167,
-0.7858867645263672,
-0.47341907024383545,
0.4578620493412018,
-0.38397303223609924,
0.8152594566345215,
-0.22531627118587494,
0.8048762679100037,
-0.4460298717021942,
-0.7444524168968201,
-0.3627428412437439,
-0.7596384286880493,
0.37107837200164795,
0.05798603594303131,
0.48862209916114807,
0.03190405294299126,
-0.23561058938503265,
0.5326676964759827,
-0.41106560826301575,
0.5381735563278198,
0.011177093721926212,
-0.13121023774147034,
0.606971025466919,
0.16364358365535736,
0.7187715768814087,
0.18655292689800262,
0.09319699555635452,
-0.08840613067150116,
-0.47913822531700134,
-0.03909149765968323,
-0.45930635929107666,
1.1705436706542969,
-0.5797570943832397,
-0.2288026511669159,
-0.19515171647071838,
-0.15405555069446564,
-0.24166113138198853,
0.13195550441741943,
-0.14833614230155945,
0.5699939727783203,
-0.27727022767066956,
0.12182538211345673,
1.2168811559677124,
-0.4216175973415375,
0.7090245485305786,
0.5004904866218567,
-0.504368782043457,
-0.6671083569526672,
0.9564542770385742,
0.05444788560271263,
0.3575358986854553,
0.8153854608535767,
-0.36001887917518616,
-0.30154749751091003,
-0.36482858657836914,
-0.9093118906021118,
0.31524625420570374,
-0.7810256481170654,
-0.36527255177497864,
-0.976967990398407,
-0.07179218530654907,
-0.30452269315719604,
-0.03832881152629852,
-0.6175915598869324,
0.16890370845794678,
-0.16369770467281342,
-0.18248116970062256,
0.6951851844787598,
0.3064451217651367,
0.38741034269332886,
0.14111411571502686,
-0.990094006061554,
0.6847970485687256,
0.493124395608902,
0.786781907081604,
0.39478224515914917,
-0.2147814929485321,
-0.5314928889274597,
-0.18181520700454712,
-0.07220780849456787,
-1.0601555109024048,
0.22114260494709015,
0.44320178031921387,
0.6260338425636292,
0.8192405700683594,
-0.10618425905704498,
0.8126296401023865,
-0.7371025681495667,
0.7347278594970703,
0.26845550537109375,
-0.6800220012664795,
0.5408837795257568,
-0.6420215368270874,
-0.10812810808420181,
0.33533456921577454,
0.5923416614532471,
-0.337531715631485,
-0.08562848716974258,
-0.3202366232872009,
-0.9863332509994507,
0.37650641798973083,
0.045312635600566864,
-0.026746928691864014,
-0.27806514501571655,
0.10148411989212036,
-0.03311009705066681,
0.553617537021637,
-0.4890470504760742,
-0.46868497133255005,
0.08803025633096695,
0.34561818838119507,
0.10391682386398315,
-0.1900087147951126,
0.03813163936138153,
0.01132154930382967,
0.6219161748886108,
0.030239921063184738,
0.41859889030456543,
-0.08898923546075821,
-0.502325177192688,
-0.4452645778656006,
0.17673325538635254,
0.5911193490028381,
0.7671838998794556,
-0.32631680369377136,
0.17838850617408752,
0.45401039719581604,
-0.38446044921875,
0.08947663754224777,
-0.12005570530891418,
-0.18077263236045837,
0.07915988564491272,
0.17694556713104248,
0.9151619076728821,
0.6989007592201233,
-0.8444696664810181,
0.5117965340614319,
0.36848047375679016,
0.31206071376800537,
-0.7801194190979004,
0.03407646343111992,
0.17175425589084625,
0.3148648142814636,
0.32793939113616943,
0.12653891742229462,
-0.0871587023139,
-0.9348109364509583,
0.06295499950647354,
0.3161613941192627,
-0.4427332580089569,
-0.21670527756214142,
1.135872721672058,
0.3516005575656891,
-0.4812101721763611,
0.5460585951805115,
-0.15132082998752594,
-0.3661613166332245,
0.1885177344083786,
0.44693684577941895,
0.5910012722015381,
-0.3138764798641205,
0.07850860059261322,
0.5042227506637573,
-0.06638681888580322,
-0.5037617087364197,
0.1661883294582367,
-0.10339386761188507,
-0.5456180572509766,
-0.6881833076477051,
-0.6566608548164368,
-0.10339154303073883,
0.0724559873342514,
-0.7058393359184265,
0.5579618215560913,
-0.2391929030418396,
-0.24556481838226318,
-0.2471873164176941,
-0.42731544375419617,
-0.7811153531074524,
0.40198808908462524,
0.31019821763038635,
1.00270414352417,
-0.7192648649215698,
1.036784291267395,
0.8703213930130005,
-0.7802940607070923,
-0.772354006767273,
-0.40015530586242676,
-0.08835739642381668,
-0.6015851497650146,
0.5846889615058899,
-0.239645317196846,
-0.1350223273038864,
-0.008902915753424168,
0.09436098486185074,
-0.7932655215263367,
1.2378851175308228,
0.44531893730163574,
-0.6209284067153931,
-0.2761783301830292,
-0.1075412780046463,
0.3454086184501648,
-0.3943195641040802,
0.4538983106613159,
-0.12897557020187378,
0.4292242228984833,
0.4003438353538513,
-0.9077754020690918,
0.04855545610189438,
0.06585992872714996,
-0.11108347773551941,
0.6618722677230835,
-0.7098662853240967,
0.7258781790733337,
-0.29899704456329346,
-0.036921706050634384,
-0.254067987203598,
0.913809061050415,
0.1891712099313736,
0.41144052147865295,
0.41390854120254517,
0.5822510123252869,
0.3382112979888916,
0.38778698444366455,
0.6933426260948181,
-0.19551870226860046,
0.2900402545928955,
1.3428561687469482,
-0.41864728927612305,
1.0482813119888306,
0.5680432319641113,
-0.17108173668384552,
0.29779624938964844,
0.15277139842510223,
-0.08793886750936508,
0.5556412935256958,
0.1012536883354187,
-0.530058741569519,
-0.4197930693626404,
-0.25066640973091125,
-0.5576795935630798,
0.04112715274095535,
0.26858264207839966,
-0.6434186697006226,
-0.3391924202442169,
0.2934921085834503,
0.019576752558350563,
0.16724339127540588,
-0.770636260509491,
0.5221250653266907,
-0.037582170218229294,
-0.7393990159034729,
0.11434467881917953,
0.031041793525218964,
0.5246424674987793,
-0.6061381697654724,
-0.1826317459344864,
0.008606739342212677,
0.29849326610565186,
-0.1394757181406021,
-0.5015695095062256,
0.3220931589603424,
0.20989900827407837,
-0.13997963070869446,
0.018385034054517746,
0.7200621962547302,
-0.7893290519714355,
-0.2192845195531845,
0.4641592502593994,
0.3556264638900757,
0.10443872213363647,
-0.14834466576576233,
-0.37397119402885437,
0.4856024980545044,
-0.35642802715301514,
-0.11920429766178131,
0.6484862565994263,
0.4115171730518341,
-0.26248443126678467,
0.971442699432373,
0.2620673179626465,
0.25938481092453003,
0.29550400376319885,
-0.008296327665448189,
0.9958605170249939,
-0.7135136723518372,
-0.36562883853912354,
-0.9687590599060059,
0.4111281633377075,
-0.07224643230438232,
-0.0710393413901329,
0.9789866805076599,
0.9349898099899292,
1.006729245185852,
-0.34150806069374084,
0.662788987159729,
-0.21427205204963684,
0.26904064416885376,
-0.5665675401687622,
0.3889458179473877,
-0.3770580589771271,
0.2633328139781952,
-0.5647433400154114,
-1.3250815868377686,
-0.21067775785923004,
0.46215391159057617,
-0.05876479670405388,
-0.04784660041332245,
0.6681405901908875,
0.7366926670074463,
-0.5006006360054016,
-0.19455401599407196,
0.4194318354129791,
0.2180391401052475,
-0.021642720326781273,
0.579794704914093,
0.714400053024292,
-0.4550604820251465,
0.8941888213157654,
0.07741888612508774,
0.27711278200149536,
-0.5309790372848511,
-1.3405946493148804,
-1.2492507696151733,
-0.566209614276886,
-0.6071111559867859,
-0.3707849979400635,
0.22023388743400574,
1.1308258771896362,
0.699988842010498,
-0.557969868183136,
0.02367747575044632,
0.25528794527053833,
-0.13162584602832794,
-0.10093342512845993,
-0.11426923424005508,
0.2994782030582428,
0.39554616808891296,
-0.5636487603187561,
0.16377927362918854,
0.6735839247703552,
-0.203232079744339,
-0.7461238503456116,
-0.16021811962127686,
-0.43741586804389954,
-0.1902826726436615,
0.5488129258155823,
0.3838501572608948,
-0.7021209597587585,
-0.33581802248954773,
0.09621263295412064,
-0.010019107721745968,
-0.010615051724016666,
0.9359762668609619,
-0.62596195936203,
0.5936875939369202,
0.6181828379631042,
0.6321975588798523,
0.9067097306251526,
0.011563816107809544,
0.5116807222366333,
-0.5069652199745178,
0.020827898755669594,
0.022780850529670715,
0.43794530630111694,
0.44876039028167725,
-0.14832372963428497,
0.2958473861217499,
0.18814247846603394,
-0.3209390640258789,
-0.7222461104393005,
0.16733497381210327,
-1.179365634918213,
0.16544751822948456,
1.2743419408798218,
-0.4743335247039795,
-0.26236504316329956,
-0.06359423696994781,
-0.2493642419576645,
0.5857968330383301,
-0.5615059733390808,
0.6965799331665039,
0.4576428532600403,
0.31293994188308716,
-0.5094221234321594,
-1.1071815490722656,
0.3842584788799286,
-0.17039696872234344,
-0.7037279009819031,
-0.3602750301361084,
0.6224642992019653,
0.38390490412712097,
0.11205390095710754,
0.6523693799972534,
0.14875295758247375,
-0.018405653536319733,
-0.1025758758187294,
0.010110567323863506,
-0.5239182114601135,
-0.585792064666748,
0.23355282843112946,
0.621379017829895,
-0.04782338812947273,
-0.320609986782074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01404v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01404v1
|
What Is Missing in Multilingual Visual Reasoning and How to Fix It
| 2024-03-03T05:45:27 | 2024-03-03T05:45:27 |
Yueqi Song, Simran Khanuja, Graham Neubig
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
NLP models today strive for supporting multiple languages and modalities,
improving accessibility for diverse users. In this paper, we evaluate their
multilingual, multimodal capabilities by testing on a visual reasoning task. We
observe that proprietary systems like GPT-4V obtain the best performance on
this task now, but open models lag in comparison. Surprisingly, GPT-4V exhibits
similar performance between English and other languages, indicating the
potential for equitable system development across languages. Our analysis on
model failures reveals three key aspects that make this task challenging:
multilinguality, complex reasoning, and multimodality. To address these
challenges, we propose three targeted interventions including a translate-test
approach to tackle multilinguality, a visual programming approach to break down
complex reasoning, and a novel method that leverages image captioning to
address multimodality. Our interventions achieve the best open performance on
this task in a zero-shot setting, boosting open model LLaVA by 13.4%, while
also minorly improving GPT-4V's performance.
|
[
-0.21755412220954895,
-0.6105257272720337,
0.6104320287704468,
0.3607519865036011,
-0.08454125374555588,
0.022959597408771515,
-0.2009323686361313,
-0.5794762969017029,
-0.24886451661586761,
0.24407827854156494,
-0.4587602913379669,
-0.29977187514305115,
-0.5575595498085022,
0.25843092799186707,
-0.023279903456568718,
0.6687130331993103,
-0.4977659285068512,
0.16370949149131775,
-0.3197895586490631,
-0.43421733379364014,
-0.8481034636497498,
-0.3723192512989044,
-0.49264243245124817,
-0.08765941113233566,
0.4973111152648926,
0.3837687075138092,
0.9256787896156311,
0.14153537154197693,
0.6927285194396973,
0.3018423914909363,
0.21632139384746552,
0.3833889663219452,
-0.1023719310760498,
0.04912065714597702,
-0.26785483956336975,
-0.623210608959198,
-0.34090471267700195,
-0.13827931880950928,
0.4906632602214813,
0.5645251870155334,
0.04405907914042473,
-0.09542029350996017,
-0.06985201686620712,
0.3179422616958618,
-0.6309306025505066,
0.4721754789352417,
-0.42662060260772705,
0.1980913132429123,
-0.09599202126264572,
-0.07249755412340164,
-0.4042603075504303,
-0.07271483540534973,
0.011431990191340446,
-0.7271071076393127,
0.07892712950706482,
0.13366039097309113,
1.0043935775756836,
0.36840584874153137,
-0.5739782452583313,
-0.02825075387954712,
-0.7186761498451233,
0.9014344215393066,
-0.6306769251823425,
0.6120333075523376,
0.23484252393245697,
0.38576239347457886,
0.016188176348805428,
-0.4539361894130707,
-0.5958545207977295,
-0.25980305671691895,
0.1026446744799614,
0.2561907470226288,
-0.3595608174800873,
-0.1214243471622467,
0.5031008720397949,
0.06124725565314293,
-0.8169149160385132,
-0.14630061388015747,
-0.2660517692565918,
-0.25445878505706787,
0.3559757173061371,
-0.10834309458732605,
0.724729061126709,
-0.27016109228134155,
-0.23350413143634796,
-0.02782934345304966,
-0.5487934350967407,
0.07893162965774536,
0.33110135793685913,
0.4118473529815674,
-0.17946988344192505,
0.8656920194625854,
-0.09370154142379761,
0.8275250792503357,
-0.6154659390449524,
-0.3282800316810608,
0.37945693731307983,
-0.702176034450531,
-0.28835228085517883,
-0.3935348689556122,
0.5160800218582153,
0.4921606779098511,
0.5143622159957886,
0.07833372801542282,
-0.3018650710582733,
0.24568414688110352,
-0.02176050655543804,
-0.325674444437027,
-0.1689147800207138,
0.0805252194404602,
-0.31159594655036926,
0.19807609915733337,
-0.3389304578304291,
-0.47687020897865295,
-0.0845738872885704,
-0.3828464150428772,
0.5147747993469238,
-0.6040098667144775,
-0.4932546019554138,
0.347601056098938,
-0.2684062719345093,
0.17160633206367493,
0.6434234380722046,
-0.9631643891334534,
-0.033422406762838364,
0.39151713252067566,
0.869647741317749,
-0.06775040179491043,
-0.471978098154068,
-0.4405289590358734,
0.10947304964065552,
-0.3962273895740509,
0.8076146841049194,
-0.47540339827537537,
0.04798852279782295,
-0.06179889664053917,
0.03073449805378914,
-0.3608523905277252,
-0.32474061846733093,
0.31205055117607117,
-0.1032349094748497,
0.2567395865917206,
-0.503119707107544,
-0.08372058719396591,
-0.2367480993270874,
0.6697131395339966,
-0.6233326196670532,
0.6817765831947327,
-0.0422731377184391,
-0.8239759206771851,
0.431196391582489,
-0.8857686519622803,
-0.16586826741695404,
0.13274702429771423,
-0.31556236743927,
-0.15758675336837769,
-0.039680689573287964,
0.571624219417572,
0.3118550777435303,
0.047313205897808075,
0.15208828449249268,
-0.3033718764781952,
-0.34894174337387085,
-0.16511550545692444,
-0.45978668332099915,
0.756586492061615,
0.032314203679561615,
-0.45858460664749146,
0.3775515854358673,
-0.5837371945381165,
0.04228635132312775,
0.41928791999816895,
-0.2584458887577057,
-0.3197450637817383,
-0.06156183406710625,
0.17154715955257416,
0.30814072489738464,
-0.04694264754652977,
-0.43970754742622375,
0.24097754061222076,
-0.4265579879283905,
0.4141223132610321,
0.7528606653213501,
-0.368956983089447,
0.36658501625061035,
0.09624674171209335,
0.8371356129646301,
0.0791151225566864,
0.32047611474990845,
-0.4322744309902191,
-0.9426122903823853,
-0.8148535490036011,
-0.22130577266216278,
0.17306260764598846,
0.7570964694023132,
-1.452478289604187,
-0.47587162256240845,
-0.14386093616485596,
-0.058797769248485565,
-0.379705548286438,
0.07721414417028427,
0.44767701625823975,
0.27631711959838867,
0.3618207275867462,
-0.2881491482257843,
-0.25598639249801636,
-1.125253677368164,
-0.3502066433429718,
-0.2925559878349304,
0.05204305797815323,
0.16846883296966553,
0.8453760147094727,
-0.22317247092723846,
0.3804604411125183,
-0.24542036652565002,
-0.20846545696258545,
-0.3346274793148041,
0.0033110531512647867,
0.10625673830509186,
0.33370867371559143,
0.610818088054657,
-0.9506905674934387,
-0.2899450361728668,
0.2869321405887604,
-0.9715985655784607,
0.09000478684902191,
-0.20509488880634308,
0.06287053972482681,
0.3106427788734436,
0.3266207277774811,
-0.547549307346344,
0.6255455613136292,
0.7152734398841858,
-0.4902067184448242,
0.7779841423034668,
-0.41125553846359253,
0.27101948857307434,
-0.5700021982192993,
-0.2526399493217468,
0.1280989646911621,
-0.24312737584114075,
-0.3848353326320648,
0.44993096590042114,
0.1969621777534485,
-0.2223414182662964,
-0.5060511827468872,
0.47362998127937317,
-0.5669196844100952,
-0.18534719944000244,
0.07695630937814713,
0.16291238367557526,
0.07330531626939774,
0.4624458849430084,
-0.10271697491407394,
0.7441960573196411,
0.6158071756362915,
-0.1537773609161377,
0.4697571098804474,
0.30544593930244446,
-0.2937651574611664,
0.6250386238098145,
-0.6220131516456604,
-0.2505229413509369,
-0.268001914024353,
0.018749168142676353,
-0.9217606782913208,
-0.3429607152938843,
0.2999681830406189,
-0.2799913287162781,
0.12037051469087601,
-0.16285420954227448,
-0.5964146852493286,
-0.3683086633682251,
-0.01833704300224781,
0.42365148663520813,
-0.03375590220093727,
-0.5487805604934692,
0.7578230500221252,
0.08122298866510391,
-0.16121375560760498,
-0.7846810221672058,
-0.7294303178787231,
0.3286445736885071,
-0.023775501176714897,
-1.0732746124267578,
0.016165394335985184,
-0.09562651813030243,
-0.34109950065612793,
-0.07986821979284286,
-0.005278009921312332,
-0.08092024177312851,
0.0705123245716095,
0.035661011934280396,
0.2879166901111603,
-0.20224235951900482,
0.31768137216567993,
-0.07531601935625076,
-0.05819883197546005,
-0.14186719059944153,
-0.16286703944206238,
0.21078826487064362,
-0.7476962208747864,
-0.8418508172035217,
-0.15030571818351746,
0.563538670539856,
0.4752434194087982,
-0.6890850067138672,
0.3700106143951416,
0.8295974135398865,
-0.28925982117652893,
-0.2049940824508667,
-0.3976920247077942,
0.08867674320936203,
-0.36328864097595215,
0.43318504095077515,
-0.7217893004417419,
-0.8606699109077454,
0.4113026261329651,
0.14713162183761597,
0.037429582327604294,
0.19267266988754272,
0.6299030184745789,
-0.01712031103670597,
1.2035263776779175,
0.7953664064407349,
0.5616437792778015,
0.1742352694272995,
-0.16700443625450134,
0.5856142640113831,
-0.4822293817996979,
-0.3822859227657318,
-0.14440865814685822,
-0.19452962279319763,
-0.5703684687614441,
-0.6466771364212036,
0.5386714935302734,
0.12116441130638123,
-0.009085474535822868,
0.23724836111068726,
-0.3650364875793457,
0.4533575177192688,
0.7245562672615051,
-0.07444548606872559,
0.4708497226238251,
-0.09585294127464294,
-0.6412865519523621,
-0.35294613242149353,
-0.7857529520988464,
-0.47468534111976624,
0.8586081862449646,
0.2821255624294281,
0.5028440356254578,
0.4812304377555847,
0.2394121140241623,
-0.15428611636161804,
0.20769040286540985,
-0.6897345781326294,
0.4418615400791168,
-0.0221998393535614,
-0.5363743305206299,
-0.23436520993709564,
-0.2256729155778885,
-0.7521896958351135,
0.673894464969635,
-0.27417701482772827,
-0.580115795135498,
0.07938055694103241,
0.2574414908885956,
-0.07515453547239304,
0.4033055305480957,
-1.0626641511917114,
1.2801989316940308,
-0.37832212448120117,
-0.40697240829467773,
0.05627091974020004,
-0.5702609419822693,
0.6077089905738831,
0.044395238161087036,
0.4453761875629425,
-0.19573190808296204,
0.14437466859817505,
0.1826632171869278,
-0.10947500169277191,
0.651627779006958,
-0.14312981069087982,
-0.14381422102451324,
-0.06679315865039825,
0.09060376137495041,
0.1559934765100479,
-0.0029634693637490273,
0.3264160752296448,
0.29920873045921326,
-0.05623393505811691,
-0.5051674842834473,
-0.7067885994911194,
0.555587649345398,
-0.43135231733322144,
-0.5794474482536316,
-0.46985214948654175,
-0.7708984017372131,
-0.2909986078739166,
0.19792278110980988,
-0.09583638608455658,
0.2640548646450043,
0.07050685584545135,
0.046282026916742325,
0.5070595145225525,
-0.6155138611793518,
0.638263463973999,
0.3457648456096649,
-0.5190609693527222,
-0.09117866307497025,
0.7822717428207397,
0.04781718924641609,
0.44347137212753296,
0.09001492708921432,
0.09605705738067627,
-0.2849602997303009,
-0.6256958246231079,
-0.8213638663291931,
0.22401975095272064,
-0.9516228437423706,
0.07739568501710892,
-0.6020101308822632,
0.14928676187992096,
-0.3605423867702484,
-0.015346248634159565,
-0.39136672019958496,
-0.38909196853637695,
0.013683394528925419,
-0.11755628883838654,
-0.07234352082014084,
0.48628440499305725,
-0.21926331520080566,
-0.17083555459976196,
-0.6482798457145691,
0.469270795583725,
0.32064908742904663,
0.45791155099868774,
-0.0560116320848465,
-0.2086944580078125,
0.04334848374128342,
-0.09502145648002625,
-0.4225664436817169,
-0.796482264995575,
0.36166054010391235,
0.013219528831541538,
0.5390368700027466,
0.0647868812084198,
-0.3814226984977722,
0.6733796000480652,
-0.8360439538955688,
0.9177138209342957,
0.3836829960346222,
-0.8589363694190979,
0.7024877071380615,
-0.5036686658859253,
0.5208917260169983,
-0.008861917071044445,
0.40980657935142517,
-0.5131841897964478,
-0.41865184903144836,
-0.251716673374176,
-0.8354446887969971,
0.3057937026023865,
0.3845764398574829,
-0.020585430786013603,
-0.07108839601278305,
-0.018196672201156616,
-0.013124180026352406,
-0.01567748934030533,
-1.1717280149459839,
0.04257352650165558,
-0.4758174419403076,
0.06757247447967529,
-0.0441674068570137,
0.01772003062069416,
-0.18025623261928558,
-0.3466431796550751,
0.40400180220603943,
-0.4469022750854492,
0.10843400657176971,
0.2415829449892044,
-0.12843595445156097,
0.1444053053855896,
0.32317960262298584,
0.8842322826385498,
1.0762150287628174,
-0.0344352088868618,
0.03045595809817314,
-0.066880002617836,
-0.049187593162059784,
0.05620082840323448,
0.034409891813993454,
-0.16209706664085388,
0.08317290246486664,
0.6560924053192139,
1.0187902450561523,
0.21496166288852692,
-0.8498546481132507,
0.7689913511276245,
-0.26349493861198425,
-0.1667165458202362,
-0.24068427085876465,
-0.16926537454128265,
0.22220294177532196,
0.37006115913391113,
0.08606687933206558,
0.43962642550468445,
-0.0066780103370547295,
-0.551485002040863,
0.07464815676212311,
0.484165221452713,
-0.33173587918281555,
-0.22355981171131134,
1.0155872106552124,
0.06796858459711075,
-0.08572208136320114,
0.518216073513031,
-0.23873044550418854,
-0.5130452513694763,
0.46087566018104553,
0.5135491490364075,
0.47018900513648987,
-0.18094339966773987,
0.4969969093799591,
0.3690216839313507,
0.8577854633331299,
-0.23044390976428986,
0.5993226170539856,
0.22108837962150574,
-0.8707528710365295,
-0.9409159421920776,
-0.3345016539096832,
-0.4274534583091736,
-0.22259582579135895,
-0.3790920376777649,
0.1746591329574585,
-0.11832401901483536,
-0.0006411205977201462,
0.017977941781282425,
-0.5167242884635925,
-0.8614456057548523,
0.20183202624320984,
0.2579864263534546,
0.6993080973625183,
-1.0973314046859741,
0.5763555765151978,
0.6534196138381958,
-0.7988854050636292,
-0.6912479996681213,
-0.42103198170661926,
0.13236477971076965,
-0.7836331129074097,
0.9810591340065002,
0.22838614881038666,
-0.0010622033150866628,
-0.3556082844734192,
-0.5408974885940552,
-0.7802414894104004,
0.6933535933494568,
0.6153500080108643,
-0.44086262583732605,
-0.01607309654355049,
0.0851798951625824,
0.5024533867835999,
-0.22380739450454712,
0.3652752935886383,
0.3330536484718323,
0.7714803814888,
-0.07280713319778442,
-1.328226923942566,
-0.12165907025337219,
-0.3340938091278076,
0.11501109600067139,
-0.00209256773814559,
-0.3636828064918518,
0.9067989587783813,
-0.6016959547996521,
-0.06344012171030045,
-0.1353878378868103,
0.44230976700782776,
0.3112751245498657,
0.2413543313741684,
0.5543592572212219,
0.7658785581588745,
0.6985100507736206,
-0.28627848625183105,
1.5092904567718506,
0.31096765398979187,
0.16731460392475128,
1.0620338916778564,
-0.3404565155506134,
0.9194784164428711,
0.6840103268623352,
-0.0030722888186573982,
0.3120913505554199,
0.4477616548538208,
-0.11404313147068024,
0.39414411783218384,
0.13988804817199707,
-0.10286306589841843,
-0.3866293132305145,
-0.1436888873577118,
-0.2101372629404068,
0.7120884656906128,
0.18611270189285278,
-0.035349611192941666,
-0.38789719343185425,
0.45595717430114746,
-0.13296033442020416,
0.21293818950653076,
-0.23977945744991302,
0.3038143813610077,
0.07819395512342453,
-0.6364133954048157,
0.591251015663147,
0.11604802310466766,
0.529464602470398,
-0.46406880021095276,
-0.36536747217178345,
-0.11528901010751724,
0.20900246500968933,
-0.11699998378753662,
-0.6968672275543213,
0.4105876088142395,
-0.1604955494403839,
-0.12503692507743835,
-0.47305113077163696,
0.6023883819580078,
-0.47600871324539185,
-0.605109691619873,
0.5725601315498352,
0.7543977499008179,
0.14259248971939087,
-0.25126194953918457,
-0.847204327583313,
0.21259386837482452,
0.24133425951004028,
-0.017180120572447777,
0.1844366043806076,
0.4414483606815338,
-0.36927294731140137,
0.9569370150566101,
0.7539106011390686,
-0.004391226917505264,
0.23287814855575562,
0.435142457485199,
0.5449742674827576,
-0.5974016189575195,
-0.19897769391536713,
-0.7592193484306335,
0.6253724694252014,
0.02851008251309395,
-0.3724326193332672,
0.9106699824333191,
0.3889148235321045,
1.1755743026733398,
-0.2608008086681366,
0.7398580312728882,
0.15336266160011292,
0.0918632298707962,
-0.5880651473999023,
0.4590171277523041,
-0.8708867430686951,
0.11598715931177139,
-0.3183651268482208,
-0.8765982985496521,
-0.8367723226547241,
0.6913367509841919,
-0.23964723944664001,
-0.130594864487648,
1.0005353689193726,
0.6617532968521118,
-0.13054099678993225,
-0.09802312403917313,
0.590344250202179,
0.11199028789997101,
0.5903732180595398,
0.7692856788635254,
0.9133656620979309,
-0.44703570008277893,
0.682508647441864,
-0.14186738431453705,
-0.3653494119644165,
0.2251145839691162,
-1.0351886749267578,
-0.8896414041519165,
-0.4268198013305664,
-0.3723526895046234,
-0.2353612780570984,
0.034766342490911484,
0.4426834285259247,
0.5699442028999329,
-0.5616274476051331,
0.019895413890480995,
0.22053830325603485,
0.2534569203853607,
-0.29696908593177795,
-0.2003871351480484,
0.21019916236400604,
-0.31276676058769226,
-0.7608776688575745,
0.4263395667076111,
0.6985329389572144,
-0.011560337617993355,
-0.33014369010925293,
0.004315644968301058,
-0.27678948640823364,
-0.1891510784626007,
0.8428769111633301,
0.16944003105163574,
-1.1046751737594604,
-0.4383740723133087,
0.08034373819828033,
0.1544879972934723,
0.14164170622825623,
0.6230421662330627,
-0.37560221552848816,
0.9207391142845154,
0.3937007486820221,
0.6195971965789795,
0.4961808919906616,
-0.246760293841362,
0.7106619477272034,
-0.6159090995788574,
0.24783413112163544,
0.36168643832206726,
0.7623404264450073,
0.5986157655715942,
0.06571219116449356,
0.6012654900550842,
0.4088279902935028,
-0.4109322428703308,
-0.7670308351516724,
0.4814067780971527,
-1.0456562042236328,
-0.4081745743751526,
0.9601803421974182,
-0.29608622193336487,
-0.16159622371196747,
-0.17318107187747955,
-0.22565707564353943,
-0.1567331701517105,
0.018826279789209366,
0.3491111993789673,
0.9527642130851746,
-0.20714853703975677,
-0.51010662317276,
-1.1349691152572632,
0.2065163403749466,
0.3884134888648987,
-0.7335799336433411,
-0.2584036886692047,
0.5995396971702576,
0.20701153576374054,
0.3261367082595825,
0.728500485420227,
-0.23985713720321655,
0.35786885023117065,
0.08036342263221741,
0.3401724100112915,
-0.032842881977558136,
-0.4650161564350128,
-0.22322076559066772,
0.2268691211938858,
-0.15113089978694916,
-0.06886379420757294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01395v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01395v1
|
CR-LT-KGQA: A Knowledge Graph Question Answering Dataset Requiring Commonsense Reasoning and Long-Tail Knowledge
| 2024-03-03T04:47:01 | 2024-03-03T04:47:01 |
Willis Guo, Armin Toroghi, Scott Sanner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.4, I.2.7
|
Knowledge graph question answering (KGQA) is a well-established field that
seeks to provide factual answers to natural language (NL) questions by
leveraging knowledge graphs (KGs). However, existing KGQA datasets suffer from
two significant limitations: (1) no existing KGQA dataset requires commonsense
reasoning to arrive at an answer and (2) existing KGQA datasets focus on
popular entities for which large language models (LLMs) can directly answer
without hallucinating and without leveraging the KG. In this work, we seek a
novel KGQA dataset that supports commonsense reasoning and focuses on long-tail
entities (e.g., non-mainstream and recent entities) where LLMs frequently
hallucinate, and thus create the need for novel methodologies that leverage the
KG for factual and attributable commonsense inference. We create a novel
Commonsense Reasoning (CR) and Long-Tail (LT) KGQA dataset with two subtasks --
question answering and claim verification -- that address both limitations (1)
and (2). We construct CR-LT-KGQA by building extensions to existing reasoning
datasets StrategyQA and CREAK over Wikidata. While existing KGQA methods are
not applicable due to their lack of commonsense inference support, baseline
evaluation of LLMs on CR-LT KGQA demonstrate a high rate of hallucination.
Thus, CR-LT KGQA poses significant challenges for hallucination-prone LLMs,
hence paving the way for future commonsense KGQA research to provide accurate
and factual answers for long-tail entities in the era of LLMs.
|
[
-0.5366600155830383,
-0.9238842725753784,
0.6518535017967224,
-0.04240309074521065,
-0.2276187688112259,
0.0031691163312643766,
-0.12289843708276749,
-0.23508524894714355,
0.08463786542415619,
0.8271999359130859,
-0.6762722134590149,
-0.6494708061218262,
-0.5367095470428467,
0.2439415454864502,
-0.13841687142848969,
0.8334375023841858,
0.05336283519864082,
-0.2627154588699341,
-0.4627135992050171,
-0.4566766619682312,
-0.5547280311584473,
-0.3844504952430725,
-0.4692569971084595,
-0.3295955955982208,
0.8973473906517029,
0.46356436610221863,
0.906265914440155,
0.2755727469921112,
-0.04241667687892914,
0.1700354963541031,
0.03401061147451401,
0.3194982707500458,
-0.6407012343406677,
-0.03974144905805588,
-0.1792144924402237,
0.017929593101143837,
-0.29374322295188904,
-0.37849998474121094,
0.568350613117218,
0.8142083287239075,
-0.10624583065509796,
0.12592864036560059,
-0.10486508160829544,
0.8352617025375366,
-0.6729404330253601,
0.2299458235502243,
-0.8806719779968262,
-0.011142261326313019,
-0.11068644374608994,
0.06660809367895126,
-0.5210691094398499,
-0.4335123896598816,
-0.01830672100186348,
-0.7860368490219116,
-0.06182079389691353,
0.0907406136393547,
0.8084320425987244,
0.3335718810558319,
-0.8000631332397461,
-0.5121465921401978,
-0.1444198191165924,
0.7339029312133789,
-0.6272822022438049,
0.7970806360244751,
0.5151206254959106,
0.48083528876304626,
-0.15356822311878204,
-0.8488380312919617,
-0.9572409987449646,
-0.2631690502166748,
-0.25420576333999634,
0.027653714641928673,
-0.12624265253543854,
-0.1081843301653862,
0.08118540793657303,
0.0426492877304554,
-0.9249587655067444,
0.12466689944267273,
-0.36035266518592834,
-0.448325514793396,
0.5122430324554443,
0.17010630667209625,
0.21044297516345978,
-0.5010480284690857,
-0.5065850615501404,
0.09783800691366196,
-0.6235285997390747,
-0.1328638345003128,
0.3808355927467346,
0.32459351420402527,
0.04195619374513626,
0.7036804556846619,
-0.6322187781333923,
0.8012910485267639,
-0.43452680110931396,
-0.12900088727474213,
0.2219245433807373,
0.1297425478696823,
-0.20996634662151337,
0.21295228600502014,
0.7529887557029724,
0.43587344884872437,
0.3432990312576294,
-0.3985014855861664,
-0.13300417363643646,
-0.19619527459144592,
-0.04336154833436012,
-0.7228731513023376,
-0.3822180926799774,
0.4604423940181732,
-0.2786959111690521,
-0.3553731143474579,
-0.4625559449195862,
-1.0163451433181763,
-0.5262590050697327,
-0.2289804220199585,
0.6468760371208191,
-0.2892032861709595,
-0.44373971223831177,
0.21542079746723175,
-0.13972608745098114,
0.31294915080070496,
0.20868411660194397,
-0.4637148380279541,
0.2460058033466339,
0.7008787393569946,
0.5412103533744812,
-0.20094740390777588,
-0.1455080509185791,
-0.4109545052051544,
0.08986888080835342,
-0.2818901836872101,
0.6329056620597839,
-0.5430576205253601,
-0.2540956437587738,
-0.09320192784070969,
0.10503636300563812,
-0.02000289410352707,
-0.5316412448883057,
0.8426713347434998,
-0.9595755338668823,
0.1954701691865921,
-0.6592844128608704,
-0.4842487573623657,
-0.3502642810344696,
0.5886609554290771,
-0.8191216588020325,
1.041163444519043,
0.2184210866689682,
-0.8622488975524902,
0.20607498288154602,
-0.6493229866027832,
-0.4332611858844757,
0.10881874710321426,
-0.08065100759267807,
-0.2999572455883026,
-0.5024215579032898,
0.5459634065628052,
0.4592967927455902,
-0.3635566532611847,
0.5212939977645874,
-0.45922884345054626,
-0.09771807491779327,
0.4161187410354614,
-0.5520055890083313,
0.899774968624115,
0.28149768710136414,
0.10281725972890854,
-0.32314398884773254,
-0.8236215710639954,
0.2060016542673111,
0.3393453359603882,
-0.021895263344049454,
-0.2340518683195114,
-0.23098094761371613,
-0.2985984981060028,
0.048330456018447876,
0.2766556441783905,
-0.5511126518249512,
0.11558828502893448,
0.05253848060965538,
0.46954700350761414,
0.6810587048530579,
0.145634263753891,
0.15994592010974884,
-0.2857017517089844,
0.31644511222839355,
-0.0011827211128547788,
-0.09008659422397614,
0.40620341897010803,
-0.5505897998809814,
-0.4027850031852722,
-0.3546951413154602,
0.33258572220802307,
0.5187870264053345,
-1.2505775690078735,
0.14697209000587463,
-0.6704561710357666,
-0.43510815501213074,
-0.10013581067323685,
-0.044778186827898026,
0.3850146234035492,
1.036189079284668,
0.5257435441017151,
0.008570215664803982,
-0.2781282663345337,
-1.0621381998062134,
-0.17579804360866547,
-0.07189130038022995,
0.05589102581143379,
0.5988405346870422,
0.6662285923957825,
0.06875688582658768,
1.0453516244888306,
-0.7984775304794312,
-0.0067436364479362965,
-0.3645274043083191,
0.0769389420747757,
0.30957210063934326,
0.1057937815785408,
0.16806478798389435,
-1.0537420511245728,
-0.2118758112192154,
-0.13392522931098938,
-0.7607818841934204,
-0.056026868522167206,
-0.0326111875474453,
-0.16056807339191437,
0.10873408615589142,
0.22416768968105316,
-0.9322444796562195,
0.19727090001106262,
0.510094404220581,
-0.32261279225349426,
0.7325337529182434,
0.24468258023262024,
0.21954232454299927,
-0.9038118124008179,
0.12809498608112335,
-0.2715637981891632,
-0.03075898066163063,
-0.6499024033546448,
-0.08406775444746017,
0.047948796302080154,
-0.16629208624362946,
-0.4337841868400574,
0.8856806755065918,
-0.043980374932289124,
-0.10122383385896683,
0.005142877344042063,
0.37103742361068726,
0.19729745388031006,
0.7711865901947021,
0.16380715370178223,
0.7118149995803833,
0.27669665217399597,
-0.6151275038719177,
0.40483731031417847,
0.514264702796936,
-0.29349637031555176,
0.44604063034057617,
-0.6398847103118896,
0.1662789285182953,
-0.2570290267467499,
0.4011886417865753,
-0.9298429489135742,
-0.5225846171379089,
0.4143548905849457,
-0.6329196095466614,
-0.010590922087430954,
-0.36163923144340515,
-0.5790697932243347,
-0.5488442182540894,
0.04124501347541809,
0.6137346029281616,
0.41693198680877686,
-0.6875877380371094,
0.8359096646308899,
0.1023179143667221,
-0.16730569303035736,
-1.131981611251831,
-0.5527582764625549,
0.24436643719673157,
-0.30424052476882935,
-0.7159218192100525,
0.021793849766254425,
0.18379482626914978,
-0.0956568717956543,
0.3666231036186218,
-0.15864181518554688,
-0.3918789327144623,
-0.05728759616613388,
-0.07441125810146332,
0.26413315534591675,
-0.2502315044403076,
0.29636475443840027,
0.10099240392446518,
-0.017361490055918694,
0.19089676439762115,
-0.26181480288505554,
0.5219478011131287,
0.07138829678297043,
-0.23789657652378082,
-0.27883923053741455,
0.13213475048542023,
0.5679474472999573,
-0.16981473565101624,
0.7143090963363647,
0.5245828032493591,
-0.38344672322273254,
-0.37861746549606323,
-0.5818151235580444,
-0.16413280367851257,
-0.4725373685359955,
0.6979376673698425,
-0.5544233322143555,
-1.0109100341796875,
0.4585237503051758,
0.0910283699631691,
-0.11112061142921448,
0.4063694477081299,
0.5721748471260071,
0.09800650924444199,
0.4767201542854309,
-0.2391529381275177,
0.06367993354797363,
-0.46467825770378113,
-0.011431757360696793,
0.32815051078796387,
-0.6829454302787781,
-0.33989182114601135,
-0.4081740975379944,
-0.06971018016338348,
-0.4279072880744934,
-0.41581135988235474,
0.33955878019332886,
-0.01598823443055153,
-0.5205179452896118,
0.16136181354522705,
-0.4687694013118744,
0.5584772229194641,
0.3863579332828522,
0.21885152161121368,
0.3735038936138153,
-0.21924829483032227,
-0.10293986648321152,
0.1869463473558426,
-0.669527530670166,
-0.3843832314014435,
1.121315836906433,
0.22614054381847382,
0.538847804069519,
0.28843995928764343,
0.4686717987060547,
0.46859487891197205,
0.16241738200187683,
-0.639332115650177,
0.8401560187339783,
-0.02437633089721203,
-0.7727627158164978,
-0.658727765083313,
-0.8883569836616516,
-0.8201049566268921,
0.1821153610944748,
-0.1491135209798813,
-0.7341687679290771,
-0.11443153768777847,
0.11989101022481918,
-0.11657899618148804,
0.4622744619846344,
-0.5644969344139099,
1.102831244468689,
-0.04285271838307381,
-0.2632337808609009,
0.06443871557712555,
-0.7763516902923584,
0.756843626499176,
-0.02348714880645275,
0.19077683985233307,
-0.20337900519371033,
0.1428200900554657,
0.8105682730674744,
-0.37953367829322815,
0.8113560676574707,
-0.45093610882759094,
-0.3710230588912964,
0.6829336881637573,
0.17424163222312927,
0.8605259656906128,
0.24430741369724274,
0.02056647092103958,
0.002860580338165164,
0.1322939395904541,
-0.5378237962722778,
-0.898608386516571,
0.6922756433486938,
-0.6380211710929871,
-0.4984193742275238,
-0.26998740434646606,
-0.7368928790092468,
-0.6422566175460815,
0.34065473079681396,
-0.09568852186203003,
0.5604777336120605,
0.035656776279211044,
0.23633407056331635,
0.7792097926139832,
-0.39258861541748047,
0.03641290217638016,
0.1880238950252533,
-0.1617928445339203,
-0.743026077747345,
1.053739070892334,
0.1364678293466568,
0.4120604395866394,
0.36260372400283813,
0.21539737284183502,
-0.7659104466438293,
-0.5178331136703491,
-0.6161897778511047,
0.28743112087249756,
-1.0028408765792847,
-0.2614652216434479,
-0.9048414826393127,
-0.2883891761302948,
-0.41185739636421204,
-0.060282181948423386,
-0.19247031211853027,
-0.7376053929328918,
0.1524205207824707,
-0.01987103372812271,
0.5466663837432861,
0.47968026995658875,
0.1065308153629303,
-0.13317541778087616,
-0.7917596697807312,
0.8539953231811523,
0.8222475647926331,
0.28140494227409363,
0.26889482140541077,
-0.3391256630420685,
0.1363024115562439,
0.18023298680782318,
-0.04931885749101639,
-0.8343774080276489,
0.046194422990083694,
-0.167310431599617,
0.5220780968666077,
0.042290136218070984,
0.5994395017623901,
0.5135473012924194,
-0.2731405198574066,
0.8703295588493347,
0.1376396268606186,
-0.6237959265708923,
0.017877953127026558,
-0.4595155715942383,
0.09949161112308502,
0.5003579258918762,
0.5687996745109558,
-0.6507384777069092,
-0.13319581747055054,
-0.45646414160728455,
-0.6765219569206238,
0.3193289339542389,
0.45007088780403137,
0.07063227891921997,
-0.1308535635471344,
0.21233311295509338,
0.26473554968833923,
0.26715847849845886,
-0.883874773979187,
-0.22007928788661957,
-0.4477614462375641,
-0.36988139152526855,
0.3623507618904114,
-0.1513337790966034,
-0.2804837226867676,
-0.11659887433052063,
0.8068862557411194,
-0.22839142382144928,
0.20940546691417694,
0.21732047200202942,
-0.006590627133846283,
0.2978689670562744,
0.5186695456504822,
0.28435516357421875,
0.5926475524902344,
-0.1685114949941635,
0.2975064814090729,
0.6416274309158325,
-0.3835759460926056,
-0.12318243086338043,
0.12164197862148285,
-0.14549098908901215,
-0.15333154797554016,
0.2813734710216522,
0.5287222862243652,
-0.07513578236103058,
-0.8348835706710815,
0.5133438110351562,
0.21097543835639954,
-0.5941112041473389,
-0.29268643260002136,
-0.09213297814130783,
0.46791699528694153,
0.2407432496547699,
0.4862600862979889,
-0.29137998819351196,
-0.00498256366699934,
-0.3159339725971222,
0.25980979204177856,
0.4907653033733368,
-0.2130776047706604,
0.1269124448299408,
0.5600239038467407,
0.03805585578083992,
0.07092959433794022,
0.8356322646141052,
-0.4306134879589081,
-0.6356019377708435,
0.7209776043891907,
0.3762229084968567,
0.4167574346065521,
0.418295681476593,
0.38613343238830566,
0.5127824544906616,
0.1142353042960167,
0.15217085182666779,
0.2617637813091278,
-0.16692966222763062,
-0.8946988582611084,
-0.5459150671958923,
-0.5333606004714966,
-0.29692599177360535,
0.3603532612323761,
-0.5949981808662415,
0.21028411388397217,
-0.030897511169314384,
0.10855036973953247,
-0.18965882062911987,
0.012333364225924015,
-0.38082075119018555,
0.4859991669654846,
0.1311941146850586,
0.9435299038887024,
-0.6261524558067322,
0.6778162717819214,
0.032697997987270355,
-0.19769445061683655,
-0.7501254677772522,
-0.08166032284498215,
-0.11030901223421097,
-1.0769245624542236,
0.7872714996337891,
0.04404063522815704,
-0.09712537378072739,
0.0881064236164093,
-0.6465873718261719,
-0.6651307344436646,
1.3574020862579346,
0.08063123375177383,
-0.24599970877170563,
-0.1770159900188446,
0.6383444666862488,
0.042516060173511505,
0.00016528334526810795,
-0.2435774803161621,
0.4042985737323761,
0.7104284763336182,
0.5762884616851807,
-0.6361318230628967,
0.4239533543586731,
0.12421950697898865,
-0.44589775800704956,
0.3055095672607422,
-0.6868286728858948,
0.4347388744354248,
-0.2028607577085495,
-0.15500052273273468,
0.2086731642484665,
0.7827838063240051,
0.6921268105506897,
0.7105143070220947,
0.6568913459777832,
0.9995976090431213,
0.8848047256469727,
-0.03939540684223175,
0.7029736042022705,
-0.06683479994535446,
0.3812236785888672,
1.3882306814193726,
-0.35697782039642334,
0.6729903817176819,
0.33890092372894287,
-0.2115117758512497,
0.37229716777801514,
0.3570597171783447,
-0.039295002818107605,
0.4875873625278473,
0.24544066190719604,
-0.38660281896591187,
-0.5263049006462097,
-0.12498726695775986,
-0.4329524636268616,
0.29388460516929626,
0.30818644165992737,
0.004677502438426018,
-0.3726860284805298,
-0.03645610809326172,
0.21377065777778625,
-0.01365683227777481,
-0.21226048469543457,
0.36777395009994507,
0.010408054105937481,
-0.6352683901786804,
0.7473528981208801,
-0.2809487581253052,
0.2195160835981369,
-0.5434143543243408,
-0.09408733993768692,
-0.17086312174797058,
-0.41044554114341736,
-0.14614015817642212,
-1.0821424722671509,
0.0686890184879303,
-0.06144242733716965,
0.1622217893600464,
0.11753349006175995,
0.7006098031997681,
-0.3144276440143585,
-0.4034551680088043,
-0.029079589992761612,
0.5562896132469177,
0.049723245203495026,
0.03978665545582771,
-0.6165386438369751,
-0.22715047001838684,
-0.04186658188700676,
-0.2717946171760559,
0.18102101981639862,
0.877941906452179,
-0.053129892796278,
0.9731380343437195,
0.6597355604171753,
-0.2495305985212326,
-0.06628435105085373,
-0.02188437059521675,
1.0817041397094727,
-0.5351231098175049,
-0.30423396825790405,
-0.47623491287231445,
0.41750141978263855,
-0.2042165994644165,
-0.2751155197620392,
0.5646849870681763,
0.6564545035362244,
0.4890212118625641,
-0.005657336208969355,
0.7809261083602905,
-0.3874426484107971,
0.5274633765220642,
-0.8729901313781738,
0.7852937579154968,
-0.5972251296043396,
-0.0211531650274992,
-0.12515509128570557,
-0.5925512313842773,
-0.27924296259880066,
0.09898769855499268,
-0.4404415786266327,
0.1023520827293396,
0.6848570108413696,
1.156628131866455,
-0.07989650219678879,
0.24505716562271118,
0.34830573201179504,
0.3461437225341797,
0.08501141518354416,
0.7796785235404968,
0.8785756826400757,
-0.2697610557079315,
0.9904864430427551,
-0.25952911376953125,
0.25143370032310486,
0.06618347764015198,
-0.9121848344802856,
-0.9351904392242432,
-0.6196707487106323,
-0.31131964921951294,
-0.736348032951355,
0.29068124294281006,
0.6886687874794006,
0.2841942310333252,
-0.6930648684501648,
0.3904276490211487,
-0.1078752651810646,
0.21664394438266754,
0.04840940237045288,
-0.33283618092536926,
0.7423132658004761,
-0.12812042236328125,
-0.33725082874298096,
0.19762088358402252,
-0.16646236181259155,
-0.17897222936153412,
-0.05131342262029648,
-0.2931077778339386,
-0.10417407006025314,
0.013015324249863625,
0.5253743529319763,
0.46877968311309814,
-0.7214595079421997,
-0.49881431460380554,
0.07170049846172333,
0.12005703896284103,
0.06529781967401505,
0.6259085536003113,
-0.8600396513938904,
0.1890999972820282,
0.3145112097263336,
0.8961851000785828,
0.39683929085731506,
-0.0759751945734024,
0.1403426229953766,
-0.6617717146873474,
-0.06644117832183838,
0.5003125667572021,
0.12400586158037186,
0.2245025485754013,
-0.34001970291137695,
0.45385944843292236,
0.2875669300556183,
-0.5965738296508789,
-0.8886830806732178,
0.5177333950996399,
-1.2540217638015747,
-0.4959295392036438,
1.3418201208114624,
0.10501085966825485,
-0.1927456557750702,
-0.4113996624946594,
-0.07401014119386673,
0.17619091272354126,
-0.33141177892684937,
0.6788008213043213,
0.8301118612289429,
0.0001258481206605211,
-0.23421305418014526,
-0.7341948747634888,
0.38767245411872864,
0.190533846616745,
-0.6766210198402405,
0.4506484270095825,
0.5614781379699707,
0.30531540513038635,
-0.11516852676868439,
0.5898812413215637,
-0.14917415380477905,
0.2799278199672699,
0.16006973385810852,
-0.28640612959861755,
-0.4056496024131775,
-0.18116222321987152,
0.3564419448375702,
0.5314381718635559,
-0.05130787938833237,
0.02544506825506687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04786v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04786v2
|
Breaking Down the Defenses: A Comparative Survey of Attacks on Large Language Models
| 2024-03-03T04:46:21 | 2024-03-23T05:21:49 |
Arijit Ghosh Chowdhury, Md Mofijul Islam, Vaibhav Kumar, Faysal Hossain Shezan, Vaibhav Kumar, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become a cornerstone in the field of
Natural Language Processing (NLP), offering transformative capabilities in
understanding and generating human-like text. However, with their rising
prominence, the security and vulnerability aspects of these models have
garnered significant attention. This paper presents a comprehensive survey of
the various forms of attacks targeting LLMs, discussing the nature and
mechanisms of these attacks, their potential impacts, and current defense
strategies. We delve into topics such as adversarial attacks that aim to
manipulate model outputs, data poisoning that affects model training, and
privacy concerns related to training data exploitation. The paper also explores
the effectiveness of different attack methodologies, the resilience of LLMs
against these attacks, and the implications for model integrity and user trust.
By examining the latest research, we provide insights into the current
landscape of LLM vulnerabilities and defense mechanisms. Our objective is to
offer a nuanced understanding of LLM attacks, foster awareness within the AI
community, and inspire robust solutions to mitigate these risks in future
developments.
|
[
-0.44242769479751587,
-1.0901139974594116,
0.4665793180465698,
-0.31069448590278625,
0.22244109213352203,
0.25507256388664246,
-0.07477308064699173,
-0.5822952389717102,
-0.172450989484787,
0.8161383271217346,
-0.44171270728111267,
-0.30137747526168823,
-0.8102418184280396,
0.08181443065404892,
-0.7144191265106201,
0.8746858835220337,
0.34858840703964233,
0.10281136631965637,
-0.3757437765598297,
0.05760364979505539,
-0.2631717026233673,
-1.0347729921340942,
-0.6574127078056335,
-0.16993771493434906,
0.5952030420303345,
-0.21420583128929138,
0.6440960764884949,
0.29169508814811707,
0.9190166592597961,
0.3996797800064087,
-0.35077956318855286,
-0.32536017894744873,
-0.5203731060028076,
0.48288920521736145,
-0.17381198704242706,
-0.6188737154006958,
-0.4538514018058777,
-0.16316939890384674,
0.6039003729820251,
0.592167854309082,
0.04239371791481972,
0.07283402979373932,
-0.00463878596201539,
0.6591470241546631,
-0.6737276315689087,
-0.308458149433136,
-1.036167860031128,
0.045770540833473206,
-0.5637157559394836,
0.05881489813327789,
-0.6295664310455322,
-0.08876179158687592,
0.1488431841135025,
0.12387049943208694,
-0.013760341331362724,
0.006773130502551794,
0.6214981079101562,
0.20530544221401215,
-0.5000969767570496,
-0.24841058254241943,
-0.5042046308517456,
1.051931619644165,
-0.8617434501647949,
0.2614043653011322,
0.2956276834011078,
0.31272685527801514,
-0.42274147272109985,
-0.5234123468399048,
-0.2553047835826874,
-0.47397756576538086,
-0.010007064789533615,
-0.24523089826107025,
-0.8104174733161926,
0.2651241719722748,
0.34546592831611633,
0.4830012321472168,
-0.7082186937332153,
0.49436697363853455,
-0.29379284381866455,
-0.0648888424038887,
0.7828140258789062,
0.3097383677959442,
0.765509843826294,
-0.07797802239656448,
-0.4472826421260834,
-0.10098433494567871,
-0.9769182801246643,
-0.200867161154747,
0.5070370435714722,
0.13387548923492432,
-0.15757502615451813,
0.669490396976471,
0.20905564725399017,
0.7472748160362244,
-0.35633981227874756,
-0.20353418588638306,
-0.38880985975265503,
-0.12553641200065613,
-0.4757946729660034,
-0.1607368141412735,
1.0237979888916016,
0.20727381110191345,
0.18017056584358215,
-0.43064773082733154,
-0.313637912273407,
-0.18202190101146698,
0.5430822968482971,
-0.5329362154006958,
-0.007688408717513084,
0.1779857575893402,
-0.39632588624954224,
-0.6441048979759216,
-0.02376457303762436,
-0.8127918839454651,
-0.8121113181114197,
0.07898694276809692,
0.033041778951883316,
-0.28261229395866394,
-0.13709639012813568,
-0.02111571468412876,
0.017530526965856552,
0.3441739082336426,
0.005927626043558121,
-0.8833144903182983,
0.48376476764678955,
0.9448658227920532,
0.7927416563034058,
-0.18529585003852844,
-0.02608378976583481,
-0.33293747901916504,
0.11586950719356537,
-0.22851677238941193,
0.4252772629261017,
-0.23904892802238464,
-0.6167676448822021,
0.045969389379024506,
-0.36582303047180176,
-0.018714619800448418,
-0.5678994655609131,
0.5355432033538818,
-0.8488309383392334,
-0.0824679285287857,
-0.16994982957839966,
-0.5580131411552429,
-0.21853488683700562,
0.8642377853393555,
-0.9714529514312744,
0.656053900718689,
-0.2066827416419983,
-1.1138778924942017,
-0.3208141028881073,
-0.5298856496810913,
-0.45648473501205444,
-0.07429189234972,
-0.19994747638702393,
-0.20438681542873383,
0.23638619482517242,
0.10876639932394028,
0.6390607357025146,
-0.6909062266349792,
-0.10090371966362,
-0.5509334206581116,
0.09934062510728836,
0.45323219895362854,
-0.5426034331321716,
0.9568649530410767,
0.2811782658100128,
-0.14896754920482635,
0.25064384937286377,
-0.7035321593284607,
-0.09642879664897919,
0.6386051774024963,
-0.18876104056835175,
-0.3034769594669342,
0.052439168095588684,
-0.33385398983955383,
-0.040952179580926895,
0.3402741849422455,
-0.3149819076061249,
0.2754250466823578,
-0.6458342671394348,
0.7215732932090759,
0.7272524833679199,
0.2142459601163864,
0.41412702202796936,
-0.13659800589084625,
0.7359471917152405,
-0.3828420341014862,
0.38982415199279785,
-0.03919300436973572,
-0.30925121903419495,
-0.45783883333206177,
-0.11925283074378967,
0.1462392359972,
0.538817286491394,
-0.46914035081863403,
0.25552234053611755,
-0.10738323628902435,
-0.7486141920089722,
-0.3223414719104767,
0.29189613461494446,
0.4117077887058258,
0.2719202935695648,
0.25385504961013794,
0.051353707909584045,
-0.5247859358787537,
-0.858787477016449,
-0.45149320363998413,
-0.2797619104385376,
-0.10283838212490082,
0.0061715152114629745,
0.48982346057891846,
-0.2760031819343567,
0.6586533784866333,
-0.5104908347129822,
-0.15266931056976318,
-0.5821991562843323,
-0.2328113317489624,
-0.07656152546405792,
0.26921555399894714,
0.78257817029953,
-0.6350547075271606,
-0.21408100426197052,
-0.14164909720420837,
-0.7206265330314636,
0.11354254931211472,
0.04604705423116684,
0.17768137156963348,
0.22247155010700226,
0.6792066693305969,
-0.8550602197647095,
0.23006121814250946,
0.6185510754585266,
-0.14242307841777802,
0.5017674565315247,
0.1787165254354477,
-0.14637315273284912,
-1.0699371099472046,
-0.13001807034015656,
-0.06474346667528152,
-0.10036272555589676,
-0.8950926065444946,
0.6024038791656494,
-0.3279837667942047,
0.022477366030216217,
-0.5425884127616882,
0.5026354789733887,
-0.3607131540775299,
-0.1278090476989746,
-0.21146352589130402,
-0.10226564854383469,
0.08309964090585709,
-0.026632191613316536,
-0.20006705820560455,
0.45587676763534546,
0.5466627478599548,
-0.35888364911079407,
0.6564947366714478,
-0.01607404090464115,
-0.35075703263282776,
0.24449770152568817,
-0.8865056037902832,
0.5145941972732544,
0.13360165059566498,
0.22659966349601746,
-0.7553665041923523,
-0.10057339817285538,
0.3065941631793976,
-0.485139936208725,
0.7009763717651367,
-0.16684189438819885,
-0.5618981719017029,
-0.10839777439832687,
-0.6224571466445923,
0.2562066316604614,
0.3007897734642029,
-0.46389269828796387,
0.6365413069725037,
0.5770173072814941,
-0.18248580396175385,
-0.9177829027175903,
-0.8549126982688904,
0.6545920372009277,
-0.5360842943191528,
-0.8032634854316711,
0.14580748975276947,
0.015800438821315765,
-0.9511073231697083,
-0.2853861153125763,
0.2205706387758255,
0.09814153611660004,
0.6844237446784973,
0.23657485842704773,
0.26633429527282715,
-0.09422656148672104,
-0.25033634901046753,
-0.5563603043556213,
0.11345848441123962,
0.5183713436126709,
0.05776600539684296,
0.7960628867149353,
-0.07943461835384369,
-0.5604161024093628,
-0.29345375299453735,
0.4403325617313385,
0.6173160076141357,
-0.24709069728851318,
0.9470508098602295,
0.29814910888671875,
-0.37819039821624756,
-0.16331519186496735,
-0.527167797088623,
-0.29137465357780457,
-0.4407588243484497,
0.7481056451797485,
-0.2147439867258072,
-0.9528738260269165,
0.3200249969959259,
0.21106970310211182,
0.2479693442583084,
0.5343422293663025,
0.6675891280174255,
-0.06697411835193634,
0.9889951348304749,
0.503326952457428,
-0.5889902114868164,
0.2874866724014282,
-0.11127880215644836,
0.41560113430023193,
-0.6819981336593628,
-0.26902034878730774,
-0.6705441474914551,
-0.06557999551296234,
-0.36920541524887085,
-0.22673940658569336,
-0.04778999090194702,
0.04675627872347832,
-0.252310186624527,
0.222095787525177,
-0.2796461582183838,
0.4016568660736084,
0.29742494225502014,
-0.28877466917037964,
0.2754151225090027,
-0.22971567511558533,
0.27634692192077637,
0.013356179930269718,
-0.5371214151382446,
-0.6936026215553284,
1.2036129236221313,
0.7403250932693481,
0.9162208437919617,
0.5400055050849915,
0.5014164447784424,
0.5310168862342834,
0.21538978815078735,
-0.7217137813568115,
0.7197170853614807,
-0.06549638509750366,
-0.7622752785682678,
-0.15550991892814636,
-0.5060825347900391,
-0.8406654596328735,
0.1702868789434433,
-0.22830109298229218,
-0.854698121547699,
-0.3821471333503723,
-0.10701064765453339,
-0.13551810383796692,
0.803368091583252,
-0.5503957867622375,
0.702629804611206,
-0.6475192308425903,
-0.13959594070911407,
-0.10482364147901535,
-0.6418925523757935,
0.6634891033172607,
-0.13944080471992493,
0.15567968785762787,
0.04997850954532623,
0.08896961063146591,
0.6486813426017761,
-0.21530622243881226,
1.0208066701889038,
0.15549421310424805,
-0.44830432534217834,
0.1736704409122467,
0.18153569102287292,
0.44850054383277893,
0.009726058691740036,
0.018314972519874573,
0.3361857533454895,
-0.03160998970270157,
-0.3232102692127228,
-0.29744279384613037,
0.7275897860527039,
-0.6142973899841309,
-0.9481604099273682,
-0.4307106137275696,
-0.48314011096954346,
-0.09177237749099731,
0.10332239419221878,
0.2442401945590973,
0.1731867492198944,
-0.5038143396377563,
0.26823708415031433,
0.8731759786605835,
-0.44420403242111206,
0.44747522473335266,
0.27199801802635193,
-0.12702827155590057,
-0.36455875635147095,
0.6887139081954956,
-0.018519779667258263,
0.5763576030731201,
0.5476778745651245,
-0.06124664470553398,
-0.20705784857273102,
-0.872338056564331,
-0.11096843332052231,
0.09399204701185226,
-0.6988679766654968,
-0.3935580551624298,
-0.58619624376297,
-0.39958706498146057,
-0.7409960031509399,
-0.08391626179218292,
-0.41060444712638855,
-0.17160922288894653,
-0.14966103434562683,
-0.322609007358551,
0.3930455446243286,
0.9680632948875427,
0.3560422360897064,
0.2549680471420288,
-0.7845369577407837,
0.06612510979175568,
0.33814552426338196,
-0.15636934340000153,
0.17332223057746887,
-0.4656756818294525,
0.02075488679111004,
-0.22643552720546722,
-0.4321667551994324,
-0.9126346111297607,
0.42058542370796204,
-0.09987842291593552,
0.4304387867450714,
0.49113988876342773,
0.10847042500972748,
0.04107414186000824,
-0.40025100111961365,
0.964594304561615,
0.3220495879650116,
-0.7100111246109009,
0.3520202040672302,
-0.22670745849609375,
0.12362975627183914,
0.3599989712238312,
0.3992767632007599,
-0.3178667426109314,
-0.34234631061553955,
-0.5708451867103577,
-0.756080687046051,
0.38131022453308105,
0.045213326811790466,
0.31446030735969543,
0.10406355559825897,
0.18493196368217468,
-0.225006103515625,
0.010779079981148243,
-0.8107785582542419,
-0.2918732464313507,
0.21106120944023132,
-0.09313064068555832,
0.07970452308654785,
-0.48057645559310913,
-0.5011876821517944,
0.1159181073307991,
0.6815580129623413,
0.18230164051055908,
-0.23954741656780243,
-0.11071239411830902,
-0.22661340236663818,
0.37390005588531494,
0.45385777950286865,
0.46948567032814026,
0.2266930788755417,
-0.0598006397485733,
0.3824162185192108,
0.471418559551239,
-0.542136549949646,
0.14397738873958588,
-0.09918663650751114,
-0.18113583326339722,
-0.28741028904914856,
0.8301861882209778,
0.5986426472663879,
0.23682665824890137,
-0.890291690826416,
0.43860360980033875,
-0.17687715590000153,
-0.11666601151227951,
-0.3795150816440582,
0.04049583151936531,
0.22965095937252045,
0.25815433263778687,
0.07719048112630844,
-0.16422340273857117,
-0.03744891285896301,
-0.5657426118850708,
-0.03432520106434822,
0.8302621245384216,
-0.28439685702323914,
-0.281258761882782,
0.45725375413894653,
-0.04995938763022423,
-0.4087505638599396,
0.4735129177570343,
0.27465054392814636,
-0.6509421467781067,
0.5629231929779053,
0.549534261226654,
0.8142377138137817,
-0.220617413520813,
-0.30314770340919495,
-0.07618100196123123,
0.6589423418045044,
0.12912391126155853,
-0.2598589360713959,
0.12609001994132996,
-0.7693669199943542,
-0.18571510910987854,
-0.47368791699409485,
-0.5361009240150452,
0.5309512615203857,
-0.6311994791030884,
-0.02771545760333538,
-0.8946152925491333,
-0.3741932511329651,
-0.1232989951968193,
0.004842680878937244,
-0.24760426580905914,
-0.047874487936496735,
0.5862958431243896,
0.9585111141204834,
-0.3923991322517395,
0.6112444400787354,
0.6344807147979736,
-0.3328988254070282,
-0.31556257605552673,
-0.023877020925283432,
0.430480033159256,
-0.4702821373939514,
0.6314834952354431,
-0.03285455331206322,
-0.19829308986663818,
-0.3552611172199249,
-0.5236137509346008,
-0.6973446607589722,
0.7206678986549377,
0.5590662956237793,
-0.5508172512054443,
-0.07205571979284286,
0.4716264009475708,
0.33374008536338806,
-0.06787333637475967,
0.07170295715332031,
0.853888988494873,
0.4131021797657013,
-0.3179834485054016,
-0.4984540343284607,
-0.0777270644903183,
-0.07997176796197891,
-0.1209060549736023,
0.16173991560935974,
-0.709577202796936,
0.6810311675071716,
-0.050131481140851974,
-0.10959947854280472,
0.0825410708785057,
0.590076208114624,
0.31681180000305176,
0.12008371949195862,
0.41173475980758667,
0.7624666094779968,
0.5346407294273376,
0.07642757147550583,
1.262755036354065,
-0.1717081367969513,
-0.02849331870675087,
1.0610426664352417,
-0.35912561416625977,
0.8969194889068604,
0.45352116227149963,
-0.3352491557598114,
0.11608074605464935,
0.4400467872619629,
-0.20860779285430908,
0.10527604073286057,
0.5649983286857605,
-0.29093876481056213,
0.0208661500364542,
0.06514272838830948,
-0.32414257526397705,
0.4500616490840912,
0.3081110119819641,
-0.32713189721107483,
-0.26328957080841064,
-0.10617084801197052,
0.5092738270759583,
0.15079374611377716,
-0.3303080201148987,
0.89923495054245,
0.42876875400543213,
-0.2712954580783844,
0.3512747585773468,
0.3038486838340759,
0.759352445602417,
-0.8519273996353149,
0.3615191876888275,
-0.0660947635769844,
0.2101757675409317,
-0.23757225275039673,
-0.6593966484069824,
0.3043088912963867,
0.4434426426887512,
-0.3139420449733734,
-0.1265178918838501,
0.8356270790100098,
-0.03568335622549057,
-0.23506172001361847,
0.569202184677124,
0.23562946915626526,
-0.13238665461540222,
-0.21696841716766357,
-0.8813226222991943,
0.4828985631465912,
-0.09069671481847763,
-0.5064595341682434,
0.7929527163505554,
-0.05488177388906479,
0.0966227799654007,
0.9182501435279846,
0.5476905703544617,
0.17944419384002686,
0.16632451117038727,
0.21063488721847534,
0.7432563900947571,
-0.5753013491630554,
0.05774794518947601,
-1.460336446762085,
0.0734749510884285,
-0.31870755553245544,
-0.00965008046478033,
1.0384182929992676,
0.4094415605068207,
0.7206007838249207,
0.18821386992931366,
0.7445722818374634,
0.3044350743293762,
0.4145602881908417,
-0.6855943202972412,
1.0406862497329712,
-0.24886488914489746,
0.7327505946159363,
-0.21486328542232513,
-0.7723727226257324,
-0.41326120495796204,
0.15887311100959778,
-0.3675302267074585,
-0.04664734750986099,
0.26668232679367065,
0.6992300748825073,
0.3561497628688812,
-0.1316043585538864,
0.25534385442733765,
0.4197271764278412,
0.7975614070892334,
0.45502611994743347,
1.1451215744018555,
-0.24085795879364014,
0.5308624505996704,
-0.1691545695066452,
0.1219969168305397,
0.00667903758585453,
-0.8230288624763489,
-1.204206943511963,
-0.2569950222969055,
-0.15696991980075836,
-0.28572192788124084,
0.07196028530597687,
0.6129871010780334,
0.4286080002784729,
-0.7685952186584473,
-0.15598124265670776,
0.169088214635849,
0.270896315574646,
0.29286742210388184,
-0.2167944759130478,
0.3862098753452301,
-0.27863359451293945,
-0.5287842154502869,
0.6710087060928345,
0.284292072057724,
0.023091895505785942,
-0.7058109641075134,
0.04139983654022217,
-0.23678477108478546,
0.2545419931411743,
0.49085569381713867,
0.4284247159957886,
-0.7841678261756897,
-0.0813206136226654,
-0.13244207203388214,
-0.3309921622276306,
-0.27387091517448425,
0.642708957195282,
-0.3283471465110779,
0.09997916966676712,
0.5296618938446045,
1.1320685148239136,
-0.18039575219154358,
-0.17589107155799866,
0.6709210872650146,
-0.6203600764274597,
0.04334529489278793,
0.3544885218143463,
0.5129201412200928,
0.5245736241340637,
-0.4256502687931061,
0.4526319205760956,
0.0695527195930481,
-0.4004265367984772,
-1.3514606952667236,
0.43102404475212097,
-0.8272038102149963,
-0.49029624462127686,
1.0333384275436401,
-0.1353169083595276,
-0.3341560661792755,
0.02233411930501461,
-0.03216300904750824,
-0.15491840243339539,
0.0631299838423729,
0.7329006195068359,
0.7843676805496216,
0.28148069977760315,
0.06826836615800858,
-0.7423558235168457,
0.5405430793762207,
0.28835558891296387,
-0.8445642590522766,
0.2694782018661499,
0.23693151772022247,
0.10244308412075043,
0.033784184604883194,
0.1392815262079239,
-0.36332690715789795,
-0.1895621418952942,
-0.20745575428009033,
-0.041135676205158234,
0.017701830714941025,
-0.1753576397895813,
-0.5156357884407043,
0.4835786521434784,
0.2752094566822052,
0.09995374083518982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01390v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01390v1
|
Right for Right Reasons: Large Language Models for Verifiable Commonsense Knowledge Graph Question Answering
| 2024-03-03T04:22:13 | 2024-03-03T04:22:13 |
Armin Toroghi, Willis Guo, Mohammad Mahdi Abdollah Pour, Scott Sanner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Knowledge Graph Question Answering (KGQA) methods seek to answer Natural
Language questions using the relational information stored in Knowledge Graphs
(KGs). With the recent advancements of Large Language Models (LLMs) and their
remarkable reasoning abilities, there is a growing trend to leverage them for
KGQA. However, existing methodologies have only focused on answering factual
questions, e.g., "In which city was Silvio Berlusconi's first wife born?",
leaving questions involving commonsense reasoning that real-world users may
pose more often, e.g., "Do I need separate visas to see the Venus of Willendorf
and attend the Olympics this summer?" unaddressed. In this work, we first
observe that existing LLM-based methods for KGQA struggle with hallucination on
such questions, especially on queries targeting long-tail entities (e.g.,
non-mainstream and recent entities), thus hindering their applicability in
real-world applications especially since their reasoning processes are not
easily verifiable. In response, we propose Right for Right Reasons (R3), a
commonsense KGQA methodology that allows for a verifiable reasoning procedure
by axiomatically surfacing intrinsic commonsense knowledge of LLMs and
grounding every factual reasoning step on KG triples. Through experimental
evaluations across three different tasks--question answering, claim
verification, and preference matching--our findings showcase R3 as a superior
approach, outperforming existing methodologies and notably reducing instances
of hallucination and reasoning errors.
|
[
-0.5711284875869751,
-0.919958770275116,
1.0639762878417969,
-0.09436062723398209,
-0.18116436898708344,
-0.2112765610218048,
-0.10351823270320892,
-0.31596583127975464,
-0.10412528365850449,
0.7998424768447876,
-0.3886536657810211,
-0.5123350024223328,
-0.37310880422592163,
0.19196972250938416,
-0.08983364701271057,
0.5802597403526306,
-0.19615717232227325,
-0.14254865050315857,
-0.5287011861801147,
-0.3846326172351837,
-0.40767526626586914,
-0.4554917812347412,
-0.5298708081245422,
-0.47593122720718384,
0.7599968314170837,
0.7160350680351257,
1.0598200559616089,
0.5981939435005188,
0.1731661707162857,
0.21347081661224365,
0.035207267850637436,
0.2699648439884186,
-0.3905288875102997,
0.042482659220695496,
-0.35125744342803955,
-0.373524010181427,
-0.10991296917200089,
0.1092621311545372,
0.24362200498580933,
0.523395836353302,
-0.09834904223680496,
0.12048903852701187,
-0.3714120090007782,
0.8129630088806152,
-0.6696556806564331,
-0.13488700985908508,
-0.400118350982666,
0.16446158289909363,
0.009138049557805061,
-0.31532222032546997,
-0.4673393666744232,
-0.6888355016708374,
-0.024443408474326134,
-0.6001281142234802,
0.07973877340555191,
0.3650013208389282,
0.9437232613563538,
0.22796274721622467,
-0.5925445556640625,
-0.46110299229621887,
-0.4067797362804413,
0.8981003761291504,
-0.8605929613113403,
0.8251457810401917,
0.7399986982345581,
0.5611250996589661,
-0.3507283329963684,
-0.715723991394043,
-0.9494335055351257,
-0.3512139916419983,
-0.19077818095684052,
0.05676841363310814,
-0.14278650283813477,
-0.0024326518177986145,
0.556390643119812,
0.09169954806566238,
-0.7278218865394592,
0.10233578830957413,
-0.21898335218429565,
-0.37310367822647095,
0.6958154439926147,
-0.028436604887247086,
0.43074098229408264,
-0.32351770997047424,
-0.14283227920532227,
0.23465226590633392,
-0.9080327749252319,
-0.09280109405517578,
0.5443439483642578,
0.13783112168312073,
0.05741243064403534,
0.6315613389015198,
-0.43199241161346436,
1.0497218370437622,
-0.1409449428319931,
-0.24868252873420715,
-0.11927712708711624,
-0.07249133288860321,
-0.1562681794166565,
0.003589597065001726,
0.6215699911117554,
0.4282917380332947,
0.5662515759468079,
-0.47757139801979065,
0.01002069003880024,
-0.4767974317073822,
0.13761556148529053,
-0.6784157752990723,
0.004656043369323015,
0.6507383584976196,
-0.44388484954833984,
-0.23327545821666718,
-0.4748387038707733,
-0.5793159604072571,
-0.39316004514694214,
-0.6215027570724487,
0.4213881194591522,
-0.33974921703338623,
-0.3533998131752014,
0.10020540654659271,
-0.1328963190317154,
0.26724693179130554,
0.2543093264102936,
-0.7994666695594788,
0.05610912665724754,
0.9259229302406311,
0.47830358147621155,
0.0273189265280962,
-0.22506055235862732,
-0.5616635084152222,
0.14606663584709167,
-0.5220305323600769,
0.5164499282836914,
-0.5544043183326721,
-0.17964118719100952,
0.06603971868753433,
-0.10700935870409012,
-0.02564367838203907,
-0.6237956881523132,
0.6992126107215881,
-1.0423282384872437,
0.37612277269363403,
-0.6999781727790833,
-0.4608774483203888,
-0.341322124004364,
0.6599751114845276,
-0.4973411560058594,
0.8842382431030273,
-0.06988732516765594,
-0.8954737782478333,
0.31751227378845215,
-0.6003697514533997,
-0.34329190850257874,
-0.009986991994082928,
-0.1359507292509079,
-0.17695370316505432,
-0.2321162074804306,
0.3553607761859894,
0.5931342840194702,
-0.4259679317474365,
0.5396765470504761,
-0.4221736192703247,
-0.021848125383257866,
0.4318709969520569,
-0.3729425072669983,
0.9117828011512756,
0.5124359726905823,
-0.07183997333049774,
-0.17084205150604248,
-0.8255643248558044,
0.18949292600154877,
0.09188792109489441,
-0.15243005752563477,
-0.2892487645149231,
0.07982231676578522,
-0.5491328239440918,
0.19873246550559998,
0.04632429778575897,
-0.5541811585426331,
-0.24177488684654236,
-0.36159375309944153,
0.4126714766025543,
0.5511137247085571,
0.11017172783613205,
0.17866921424865723,
-0.2764190435409546,
0.4671071469783783,
-0.1877797693014145,
0.14457263052463531,
0.5785278081893921,
-0.6863037943840027,
-0.37347084283828735,
-0.28167521953582764,
0.18469463288784027,
0.4882367253303528,
-0.8274962306022644,
-0.03464057296514511,
-0.41910338401794434,
-0.34501853585243225,
-0.15526685118675232,
-0.05441693961620331,
0.3531941771507263,
0.9892023205757141,
0.2711678445339203,
0.2907448709011078,
-0.3730834424495697,
-0.992702305316925,
-0.37277552485466003,
-0.4365851879119873,
0.20445530116558075,
0.5174251198768616,
0.7443203926086426,
0.07834246009588242,
1.206594705581665,
-0.5394297242164612,
0.39491161704063416,
-0.3805793225765228,
-0.01487037818878889,
0.3162098228931427,
0.15311181545257568,
0.24464812874794006,
-1.2603760957717896,
-0.30131950974464417,
0.05923600122332573,
-0.8394140005111694,
-0.0675404816865921,
0.21218660473823547,
-0.33985456824302673,
0.1767720729112625,
0.4004523754119873,
-0.7297725081443787,
0.30973052978515625,
0.49839818477630615,
-0.23376737534999847,
0.5909844636917114,
0.021842246875166893,
0.278786838054657,
-1.0449579954147339,
0.18448370695114136,
-0.12093435972929001,
-0.39165252447128296,
-0.7041424512863159,
0.18413393199443817,
-0.05948686599731445,
-0.12760645151138306,
-0.47341015934944153,
0.6608605980873108,
0.010524970479309559,
-0.18849095702171326,
-0.07592123746871948,
0.39683306217193604,
0.10563928633928299,
0.401105672121048,
0.1351589411497116,
0.5780488848686218,
0.3557218313217163,
-0.7591826319694519,
0.6745649576187134,
0.17398805916309357,
-0.3124818801879883,
0.6508213877677917,
-0.4361428916454315,
0.17421720921993256,
-0.2794400751590729,
0.18872976303100586,
-0.9665601849555969,
-0.4804709255695343,
0.6546517610549927,
-0.7133254408836365,
-0.06874433904886246,
-0.2769509553909302,
-0.5321434736251831,
-0.6678622364997864,
0.05946602299809456,
0.3562348783016205,
0.32323580980300903,
-0.9035043120384216,
0.9708621501922607,
0.368209570646286,
0.01731664128601551,
-0.9051879644393921,
-0.6325576901435852,
0.1512826681137085,
-0.42138299345970154,
-0.9255721569061279,
-0.1266346573829651,
0.06848205626010895,
-0.38727399706840515,
0.12677299976348877,
-0.15325027704238892,
-0.37418150901794434,
0.21851499378681183,
0.12122206389904022,
0.18372038006782532,
-0.10276513546705246,
0.0877738669514656,
-0.129342719912529,
-0.28348708152770996,
0.15972045063972473,
-0.2573711574077606,
0.2346905767917633,
0.06856690347194672,
-0.33791637420654297,
-0.38813331723213196,
0.3101293444633484,
0.6093119978904724,
-0.1592692881822586,
0.4562365412712097,
0.40114688873291016,
-0.494245707988739,
-0.21819652616977692,
-0.770466685295105,
-0.14354491233825684,
-0.4236694872379303,
0.28242263197898865,
-0.4721606373786926,
-1.185525894165039,
0.6142117977142334,
0.20212948322296143,
-0.03349177539348602,
0.09376230835914612,
0.7496575117111206,
-0.03539822995662689,
1.0019099712371826,
0.09555817395448685,
0.09391385316848755,
-0.36567196249961853,
0.1839032620191574,
0.8206048607826233,
-0.5416676998138428,
-0.27518483996391296,
-0.6565292477607727,
0.11944390833377838,
-0.35970813035964966,
-0.3363841474056244,
0.2145475298166275,
-0.0024638341274112463,
-0.24438722431659698,
-0.011220904067158699,
-0.34617653489112854,
0.8290858864784241,
0.3973334729671478,
-0.018599292263388634,
0.3276837468147278,
-0.2628666162490845,
-0.1785290390253067,
0.06958586722612381,
-0.8670240044593811,
-0.6314294934272766,
0.817343533039093,
0.3746013343334198,
0.45822298526763916,
0.30031928420066833,
0.6190602779388428,
0.1863960176706314,
0.4112469255924225,
-0.7125136852264404,
0.86512690782547,
0.281437486410141,
-1.0461630821228027,
-0.5706188082695007,
-0.6501284241676331,
-0.8510186672210693,
0.27860018610954285,
0.1863478124141693,
-0.8389549255371094,
0.025032905861735344,
0.373857319355011,
-0.41511279344558716,
0.29185977578163147,
-0.4523491859436035,
1.0275225639343262,
-0.06955132633447647,
-0.37827569246292114,
-0.17852970957756042,
-0.8267975449562073,
0.5533491373062134,
0.0630277693271637,
0.5144627094268799,
-0.07928847521543503,
0.28464624285697937,
0.854313313961029,
-0.5493154525756836,
0.5696510672569275,
-0.38594332337379456,
-0.30874568223953247,
0.5037437677383423,
0.051407068967819214,
0.7548763751983643,
0.27952906489372253,
0.009034003131091595,
-0.23177039623260498,
0.12790866196155548,
-0.28116321563720703,
-0.9442694187164307,
0.8106004595756531,
-0.6199562549591064,
-0.9066340923309326,
-0.2969266474246979,
-0.5228626728057861,
-0.5554442405700684,
0.19588488340377808,
0.021665772423148155,
0.4764426350593567,
0.26133015751838684,
0.0675533190369606,
0.8960346579551697,
-0.15417951345443726,
0.16910606622695923,
0.37265533208847046,
-0.380180299282074,
-0.49827539920806885,
0.8963356018066406,
0.25388482213020325,
0.3596324920654297,
0.2921993136405945,
0.49119019508361816,
-0.7354730367660522,
-0.6213539838790894,
-0.540683388710022,
0.4550674259662628,
-1.0893608331680298,
-0.10058249533176422,
-0.7983523011207581,
0.14896897971630096,
-0.6071929335594177,
-0.23434865474700928,
-0.12729057669639587,
-0.5041523575782776,
0.06263403594493866,
-0.23159489035606384,
0.22751225531101227,
0.2637072503566742,
-0.24956727027893066,
-0.23814034461975098,
-0.699143648147583,
0.7638311982154846,
0.7653821706771851,
0.2522298991680145,
0.07722203433513641,
-0.40788131952285767,
-0.12133044004440308,
-0.017497925087809563,
-0.04160834476351738,
-0.9039496183395386,
0.07134290784597397,
-0.38843706250190735,
0.6991573572158813,
0.11476708203554153,
0.21987275779247284,
0.6175371408462524,
-0.08854403346776962,
0.7933183312416077,
-0.016391189768910408,
-0.7378278374671936,
0.33217471837997437,
-0.37231892347335815,
-0.11262606084346771,
0.4822596311569214,
0.739079475402832,
-0.6821873784065247,
-0.3455919325351715,
-0.5627143979072571,
-0.541954755783081,
0.6236574649810791,
0.11066918075084686,
-0.07702372223138809,
-0.02656451240181923,
0.3657848834991455,
0.027004573494195938,
0.05528697744011879,
-0.762826144695282,
0.09756988286972046,
-0.34333518147468567,
-0.2523999512195587,
0.409130722284317,
-0.3118492066860199,
-0.511133074760437,
0.021073903888463974,
1.0682295560836792,
-0.23117628693580627,
0.027058802545070648,
0.36545857787132263,
0.11992378532886505,
-0.006583807989954948,
0.422244131565094,
0.38089704513549805,
0.9315054416656494,
-0.10078994184732437,
0.18093962967395782,
0.4146454632282257,
-0.031776003539562225,
0.0911654680967331,
-0.03670312464237213,
-0.3118419051170349,
-0.14551576972007751,
0.1276530772447586,
0.5518772006034851,
-0.17207488417625427,
-0.7169572114944458,
0.574383020401001,
0.0127350352704525,
-0.44404399394989014,
-0.22828800976276398,
-0.036482300609350204,
0.2629513442516327,
0.25016486644744873,
0.11544087529182434,
-0.3197024464607239,
0.06366703659296036,
-0.5054405331611633,
-0.01429738849401474,
0.3337985575199127,
-0.3183063566684723,
0.050789155066013336,
0.40651413798332214,
-0.029445355758070946,
-0.09764500707387924,
0.7611760497093201,
-0.1563999056816101,
-0.6502571702003479,
0.4757532477378845,
0.5914741158485413,
0.5277232527732849,
0.2660556435585022,
0.47714370489120483,
0.48576873540878296,
0.07302670925855637,
-0.24721142649650574,
0.4080084264278412,
-0.229047030210495,
-1.1164309978485107,
-0.6691045165061951,
-0.3436005711555481,
-0.49411842226982117,
0.012481349520385265,
-0.40829789638519287,
0.0792449340224266,
-0.22463670372962952,
-0.0749061331152916,
-0.18686985969543457,
-0.17088757455348969,
-0.2461913675069809,
0.5749990344047546,
0.23969492316246033,
0.9613669514656067,
-0.730224609375,
0.4942172169685364,
0.43043947219848633,
-0.3182345926761627,
-1.1408734321594238,
-0.19904126226902008,
-0.1555669605731964,
-0.8382904529571533,
0.8760534524917603,
-0.07444662600755692,
-0.17400489747524261,
0.17686888575553894,
-0.8659660816192627,
-0.7910364866256714,
0.8807187080383301,
0.13369254767894745,
-0.24219514429569244,
-0.0194618608802557,
0.46627917885780334,
0.04166272655129433,
0.014798670075833797,
-0.08199986815452576,
0.498568058013916,
0.8276205062866211,
0.45833951234817505,
-0.5481768846511841,
0.30785098671913147,
0.19789986312389374,
-0.16108588874340057,
0.19273798167705536,
-0.5874541401863098,
0.12431064248085022,
-0.3822581470012665,
-0.18688872456550598,
0.05491945520043373,
0.7290089130401611,
0.7599246501922607,
0.7403656244277954,
0.4661484360694885,
1.0693018436431885,
1.146520972251892,
-0.21656525135040283,
1.1943578720092773,
-0.11444868892431259,
0.3285447359085083,
0.7493026256561279,
-0.31723329424858093,
0.4456452429294586,
0.6098576188087463,
-0.03548198193311691,
0.2362910807132721,
0.5757484436035156,
0.2688502073287964,
0.47926291823387146,
0.4522702097892761,
-0.16230149567127228,
-0.5936456322669983,
-0.06147952005267143,
-0.32015305757522583,
0.23956458270549774,
0.10896146297454834,
0.036901842802762985,
-0.3169126510620117,
0.04967906326055527,
0.5505701899528503,
0.11584897339344025,
-0.2949031889438629,
0.2986224293708801,
0.012609855271875858,
-1.113213300704956,
0.5966766476631165,
-0.05293142423033714,
0.03993593901395798,
-0.59440016746521,
0.13587412238121033,
-0.19279621541500092,
-0.23500487208366394,
-0.3615141808986664,
-0.9510793685913086,
0.25882357358932495,
0.05267471820116043,
0.028673607856035233,
-0.22146354615688324,
0.7744705080986023,
0.013228921219706535,
-0.27445533871650696,
-0.20208288729190826,
0.46880874037742615,
0.26811903715133667,
0.19230209290981293,
-0.6356346011161804,
-0.16178862750530243,
0.07116291671991348,
-0.3643854558467865,
0.04418627917766571,
0.8145505785942078,
-0.11933861672878265,
0.9197446703910828,
0.8090581297874451,
-0.07837935537099838,
0.028933661058545113,
0.1766800433397293,
0.6380927562713623,
-0.6312781572341919,
-0.33401936292648315,
-0.8457160592079163,
0.39139723777770996,
-0.16368038952350616,
-0.27638959884643555,
0.8730430006980896,
0.6345639228820801,
0.5812001824378967,
0.14217537641525269,
0.8329694271087646,
-0.18078221380710602,
0.651640772819519,
-0.9084532856941223,
0.47450074553489685,
-0.5217932462692261,
-0.05558374524116516,
-0.0920550525188446,
-0.7496147751808167,
-0.7558445930480957,
0.4762404263019562,
-0.6453914642333984,
-0.006722698919475079,
0.5988408327102661,
1.1749531030654907,
0.17837445437908173,
0.4248998761177063,
0.4358028173446655,
0.1497451514005661,
0.4984258711338043,
0.39172282814979553,
1.1628187894821167,
-0.02699124999344349,
0.40546339750289917,
-0.0032777676824480295,
-0.03146804869174957,
-0.08904644846916199,
-0.9986246824264526,
-0.7168979644775391,
-0.369875967502594,
-0.440519243478775,
-0.7235748767852783,
0.355398565530777,
0.897681474685669,
0.5588409900665283,
-0.5546493530273438,
0.1126626506447792,
-0.23544780910015106,
0.46486762166023254,
0.07201710343360901,
-0.2141144722700119,
0.3856508135795593,
-0.3474356532096863,
-0.32775288820266724,
0.1796765774488449,
0.1530844271183014,
-0.15010231733322144,
-0.040396858006715775,
-0.3596426844596863,
-0.10002116113901138,
0.18220774829387665,
0.36600980162620544,
0.6682060956954956,
-0.6723496317863464,
-0.6366913318634033,
-0.06956057250499725,
-0.01913660578429699,
0.024483516812324524,
0.6798686981201172,
-0.7684212327003479,
0.23040908575057983,
0.6853244304656982,
0.72768235206604,
0.2210419774055481,
0.0755598172545433,
0.3126518726348877,
-0.20114104449748993,
-0.3406291902065277,
0.47660309076309204,
0.14788396656513214,
0.3287379741668701,
-0.1794198751449585,
0.582291841506958,
0.31250521540641785,
-0.8709242939949036,
-0.9888978600502014,
0.4984965920448303,
-0.994417667388916,
-0.1762249916791916,
1.3542605638504028,
0.07947488874197006,
-0.35948607325553894,
-0.5274738073348999,
-0.10193359851837158,
0.13728295266628265,
-0.014656568877398968,
0.6941908001899719,
1.0589649677276611,
-0.09905443340539932,
0.030143439769744873,
-0.6412935853004456,
0.485103577375412,
0.40935903787612915,
-0.6306158304214478,
0.3614048957824707,
0.6856765747070312,
0.17643630504608154,
0.1460617184638977,
0.8797323703765869,
-0.30506953597068787,
0.41190406680107117,
-0.3863109350204468,
-0.4051724076271057,
-0.18310673534870148,
-0.2652542293071747,
0.32996928691864014,
0.45919135212898254,
0.27622827887535095,
0.09045728296041489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01384v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01384v2
|
On the Compressibility of Quantized Large Language Models
| 2024-03-03T03:27:07 | 2024-05-06T02:29:14 |
Yu Mao, Weilan Wang, Hongchao Du, Nan Guan, Chun Jason Xue
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Deploying Large Language Models (LLMs) on edge or mobile devices offers
significant benefits, such as enhanced data privacy and real-time processing
capabilities. However, it also faces critical challenges due to the substantial
memory requirement of LLMs. Quantization is an effective way of reducing the
model size while maintaining good performance. However, even after
quantization, LLMs may still be too big to fit entirely into the limited memory
of edge or mobile devices and have to be partially loaded from the storage to
complete the inference. In this case, the I/O latency of model loading becomes
the bottleneck of the LLM inference latency. In this work, we take a
preliminary step of studying applying data compression techniques to reduce
data movement and thus speed up the inference of quantized LLM on
memory-constrained devices. In particular, we discussed the compressibility of
quantized LLMs, the trade-off between the compressibility and performance of
quantized LLMs, and opportunities to optimize both of them jointly.
|
[
-0.2847762107849121,
-0.7949156761169434,
0.6171389222145081,
0.10007792711257935,
-0.2942655682563782,
0.20193330943584442,
-0.24411043524742126,
-0.42055052518844604,
0.01185152493417263,
0.4630039632320404,
-0.2817392945289612,
-0.3402327001094818,
-0.5265330076217651,
-0.17698289453983307,
-0.4175984263420105,
0.4132447838783264,
0.023496849462389946,
-0.26372674107551575,
-0.38826507329940796,
-0.024377048015594482,
-0.06965232640504837,
-0.9907974600791931,
-0.6897069811820984,
-0.0672745630145073,
-0.0499156229197979,
0.07416734844446182,
1.1296225786209106,
0.933318555355072,
0.3898424506187439,
0.3019360303878784,
-0.27297091484069824,
-0.2720548212528229,
-0.4253869950771332,
0.30103230476379395,
0.20084667205810547,
-0.697258710861206,
-0.4402611553668976,
-0.2619941532611847,
0.6305019855499268,
0.8515864610671997,
-0.3390722870826721,
0.15369491279125214,
-0.06208578869700432,
0.6410082578659058,
-0.7908194065093994,
-0.1137356236577034,
-0.40482696890830994,
0.1478279083967209,
-0.18135182559490204,
0.0007440434419550002,
-0.41858965158462524,
-0.44277793169021606,
-0.009264066815376282,
-0.45535507798194885,
0.11721574515104294,
0.13696539402008057,
0.6957231163978577,
0.6757253408432007,
-0.5774591565132141,
0.010187963955104351,
-0.9928446412086487,
0.9262279868125916,
-0.671517014503479,
0.5890064835548401,
0.44043678045272827,
0.15746572613716125,
-0.07600948214530945,
-0.676288366317749,
-0.5563158988952637,
0.14859043061733246,
0.21513457596302032,
-0.34254834055900574,
-0.24020501971244812,
0.23978380858898163,
0.589888334274292,
0.6126548647880554,
-0.6418026089668274,
0.20784564316272736,
-0.12112032622098923,
-0.19943086802959442,
0.6514505743980408,
0.060909539461135864,
0.21112878620624542,
0.1410224586725235,
-0.17591145634651184,
0.018788350746035576,
-0.9577348828315735,
0.03337423875927925,
0.2240203619003296,
-0.0728822648525238,
-0.11332455277442932,
0.4178319573402405,
-0.32167521119117737,
0.8836754560470581,
-0.25711092352867126,
-0.4513084590435028,
-0.06633476912975311,
-0.285220205783844,
-0.351718008518219,
-0.07398054003715515,
0.7546460628509521,
0.3067203760147095,
0.19956181943416595,
-0.06044009327888489,
-0.20899470150470734,
-0.003495933022350073,
-0.16690756380558014,
-1.163240671157837,
-0.1741323620080948,
0.5360479354858398,
-0.6862943768501282,
0.1348648965358734,
-0.3647581934928894,
-0.46507883071899414,
-0.20087571442127228,
-0.07936783134937286,
0.47526851296424866,
-0.2242816835641861,
-0.06532604992389679,
0.430896133184433,
0.16633595526218414,
-0.2104378193616867,
0.22439423203468323,
-0.9120426774024963,
0.45685139298439026,
0.6270155906677246,
1.1155586242675781,
-0.003982034511864185,
0.37146061658859253,
-0.6341609358787537,
0.23904137313365936,
-0.026665760204195976,
0.45111551880836487,
-0.36397483944892883,
-0.523669421672821,
-0.03317245468497276,
-0.3274851143360138,
-0.025737982243299484,
-0.5966790914535522,
0.7453629970550537,
-0.6271311044692993,
-0.39310774207115173,
0.08752308785915375,
-0.696990430355072,
-0.2147749364376068,
-0.03559667617082596,
-0.8701801300048828,
0.7918728590011597,
0.11639408767223358,
-0.4527839124202728,
-0.1078319326043129,
0.056744638830423355,
-0.49688151478767395,
-0.12162674218416214,
0.006880606058984995,
-0.54194575548172,
0.40061941742897034,
0.24606870114803314,
0.6307854056358337,
-0.48056167364120483,
0.13679011166095734,
-0.47872862219810486,
-0.6611628532409668,
0.460633248090744,
-0.37174996733665466,
0.766401469707489,
0.3748382031917572,
0.023479286581277847,
-0.4598064124584198,
-0.7229858040809631,
0.2736726999282837,
-0.09646118432283401,
-0.508256733417511,
-0.5015855431556702,
0.2638140320777893,
-0.3593730628490448,
0.03761326149106026,
0.16464917361736298,
-0.33751657605171204,
0.5523204803466797,
-0.1712302714586258,
0.7627212405204773,
0.36582618951797485,
-0.22511857748031616,
0.43005141615867615,
-0.1246483102440834,
0.6142063736915588,
-0.17381854355335236,
0.29857268929481506,
-0.09644897282123566,
-0.054852135479450226,
-0.7773354053497314,
-0.5170144438743591,
0.5648715496063232,
0.6661363244056702,
-0.9301772713661194,
0.17854200303554535,
-0.550544261932373,
-0.34766197204589844,
-0.5145323872566223,
0.03631032258272171,
0.25180789828300476,
0.017907988280057907,
-0.032390471547842026,
0.17516157031059265,
-0.3605755865573883,
-0.6782817840576172,
-0.10031517595052719,
-0.048796892166137695,
-0.06894543766975403,
0.17004413902759552,
0.22135257720947266,
0.07461416721343994,
0.7548815608024597,
-0.533674955368042,
0.20669971406459808,
0.046155549585819244,
0.1790831983089447,
0.29774847626686096,
0.574602484703064,
0.15499770641326904,
-0.9572032690048218,
-0.44619297981262207,
-0.24321304261684418,
-0.6046631336212158,
-0.4522705674171448,
-0.06029825285077095,
0.37017589807510376,
0.29227980971336365,
0.7200109958648682,
-0.9808961153030396,
0.6010733842849731,
1.065304160118103,
-0.1275889277458191,
0.38352975249290466,
-0.20606663823127747,
0.08479267358779907,
-0.8068844676017761,
-0.33496516942977905,
-0.14536559581756592,
-0.5202713012695312,
-0.652301013469696,
0.08732610940933228,
0.01351527776569128,
-0.373588889837265,
-0.5323633551597595,
0.4441429376602173,
-0.7052634358406067,
-0.23906166851520538,
-0.1533026546239853,
0.026889493688941002,
0.10205377638339996,
0.22513744235038757,
0.14071489870548248,
0.985844075679779,
0.6802647113800049,
-1.0322706699371338,
0.030986957252025604,
0.015015127137303352,
-0.3173624575138092,
0.4535936415195465,
-0.7486127614974976,
0.11259955912828445,
0.1420830637216568,
0.3070898652076721,
-0.5232263803482056,
0.19064943492412567,
-0.06713157892227173,
-0.1463022232055664,
0.21906138956546783,
-0.33919110894203186,
-0.9487683773040771,
-0.21328723430633545,
-0.3655056059360504,
0.7111032009124756,
0.7399219274520874,
-0.6060205698013306,
0.602482259273529,
0.4070502519607544,
-0.1297057569026947,
-0.2293330878019333,
-0.8095378279685974,
0.0794665515422821,
-0.47601333260536194,
-0.7437976598739624,
0.6392790675163269,
-0.21948185563087463,
-0.5450246930122375,
-0.07415136694908142,
-0.02228309027850628,
-0.09953666478395462,
0.2468622624874115,
0.47712966799736023,
-0.02420426346361637,
-0.06893058866262436,
0.39762747287750244,
0.22599279880523682,
-0.14177873730659485,
-0.1141049861907959,
-0.3084987699985504,
0.6098386645317078,
-0.04303884133696556,
-0.20180918276309967,
-0.4552556574344635,
0.3224108815193176,
0.31429365277290344,
0.037204548716545105,
0.8334064483642578,
0.34573113918304443,
-0.2194996327161789,
-0.1328185349702835,
-0.4549902081489563,
-0.019977791234850883,
-0.5212833881378174,
0.1498742699623108,
-0.557785153388977,
-1.0809658765792847,
0.4920850694179535,
-0.45093539357185364,
-0.3859204351902008,
0.09329450130462646,
0.44677841663360596,
0.014938038773834705,
0.9579772353172302,
0.4986651539802551,
0.018146978691220284,
0.3850123882293701,
-0.36770302057266235,
0.36293482780456543,
-0.9043040871620178,
0.21479275822639465,
-0.6533392667770386,
-0.27171358466148376,
-0.7231862545013428,
-0.6203923225402832,
0.5246157050132751,
0.5008751749992371,
-0.09165603667497635,
0.19019456207752228,
-0.3467302918434143,
0.3981248438358307,
0.35366305708885193,
0.12762589752674103,
0.5548950433731079,
0.06479170173406601,
0.2853197455406189,
0.0876820906996727,
-0.8323419094085693,
-0.29848313331604004,
0.9609305262565613,
0.4184497892856598,
0.9793556928634644,
0.34197089076042175,
0.5006906390190125,
0.08645099401473999,
-0.22977596521377563,
-0.7397374510765076,
0.7713730931282043,
-0.33943450450897217,
-0.2852173149585724,
-0.30344799160957336,
-0.6883981227874756,
-0.8881285190582275,
0.2957264482975006,
-0.10113746672868729,
-1.0658382177352905,
0.13098102807998657,
0.05147106572985649,
-0.7092078924179077,
0.2983829975128174,
-0.704960286617279,
0.4026278257369995,
-0.03091646544635296,
-0.554935872554779,
-0.2682320773601532,
-0.4627560079097748,
0.2901689112186432,
-0.06068386510014534,
0.42489463090896606,
-0.127431720495224,
-0.28469619154930115,
0.6428394913673401,
-0.9052677154541016,
0.7284565567970276,
-0.10709304362535477,
-0.3429933786392212,
0.3810221552848816,
0.24884635210037231,
0.5291475653648376,
0.07720153778791428,
-0.17034515738487244,
0.2941986620426178,
0.20909346640110016,
-0.4290875196456909,
-0.795380711555481,
0.6169331073760986,
-0.3972777724266052,
-0.5322772264480591,
-0.1420001983642578,
-0.7799253463745117,
-0.17939512431621552,
-0.12526579201221466,
0.33365240693092346,
0.49187883734703064,
0.17145541310310364,
0.15840208530426025,
0.9970969557762146,
-0.3907146155834198,
0.8915448784828186,
0.29288989305496216,
-0.2860593795776367,
-0.35497915744781494,
0.966424286365509,
0.4066784083843231,
0.43739235401153564,
0.5458132028579712,
0.14228349924087524,
-0.19706088304519653,
-0.7550899982452393,
-0.312007874250412,
0.10465070605278015,
-0.43341928720474243,
-0.2301815301179886,
-0.5705627202987671,
-0.1588554084300995,
-0.2625501751899719,
-0.16280697286128998,
-0.5329911708831787,
-0.7640231847763062,
-0.31758663058280945,
0.23756065964698792,
0.40579867362976074,
0.24765028059482574,
-0.14271321892738342,
1.051426649093628,
-1.0166707038879395,
0.1920660436153412,
0.12201963365077972,
0.10290106385946274,
-0.004377348814159632,
-0.45945048332214355,
-0.6135382056236267,
0.01110992580652237,
-0.1365836262702942,
-0.45035168528556824,
0.3641866445541382,
0.3128972351551056,
-0.03317269682884216,
0.32006463408470154,
0.19547176361083984,
0.7392821907997131,
-0.1255965679883957,
0.684335470199585,
-0.1119217723608017,
-1.2248111963272095,
0.19813793897628784,
-0.11013497412204742,
0.2671743929386139,
0.2988565266132355,
0.529996395111084,
-0.18242229521274567,
-0.1067211776971817,
-0.5110491514205933,
-0.8318963646888733,
0.10483645647764206,
0.0922946184873581,
0.21532180905342102,
0.2500499188899994,
0.49981486797332764,
0.019307225942611694,
0.33143121004104614,
-0.714387059211731,
-0.05266883969306946,
0.4110244810581207,
-0.12677639722824097,
0.1345204859972,
-0.4748622179031372,
0.3009469211101532,
-0.22021076083183289,
0.5283955335617065,
-0.026245279237627983,
0.316588431596756,
0.11632255464792252,
-0.2622308135032654,
0.17662283778190613,
0.1537734419107437,
0.5010735988616943,
0.21153174340724945,
-0.07658696919679642,
0.36282193660736084,
-0.05157042667269707,
-0.46455201506614685,
0.43318891525268555,
0.05787713825702667,
-0.3915305435657501,
0.004927164874970913,
0.3347224295139313,
0.9398008584976196,
0.07146798074245453,
-0.6667222380638123,
0.29873740673065186,
-0.16850106418132782,
0.09877178072929382,
-0.14919449388980865,
-0.009549629874527454,
0.051781997084617615,
0.4345550835132599,
0.2704969644546509,
-0.5005646347999573,
0.2285604327917099,
-0.4579051733016968,
-0.014591054990887642,
0.6129570603370667,
0.08255238085985184,
-0.22857773303985596,
0.4952559769153595,
0.12334853410720825,
-0.3260642886161804,
0.6391652226448059,
-0.2904368042945862,
-0.4327085018157959,
0.3426145911216736,
0.48174989223480225,
0.5959153175354004,
-0.3249051868915558,
-0.09986812621355057,
0.1810106337070465,
0.05066203698515892,
-0.29253682494163513,
0.2693365514278412,
-0.25771716237068176,
-0.5459219813346863,
-0.9090909957885742,
-0.36159077286720276,
-0.27446675300598145,
-0.03618165850639343,
-0.5724058151245117,
0.10039059817790985,
-0.22010476887226105,
-0.508380651473999,
-0.4656344950199127,
0.03817462548613548,
-0.2883332371711731,
0.23706474900245667,
0.12889546155929565,
0.8329549431800842,
-0.5767236948013306,
0.9285333156585693,
-0.011777730658650398,
0.11633319407701492,
-0.778710663318634,
0.13364790380001068,
-0.16970354318618774,
-0.6454826593399048,
0.7668748497962952,
-0.047387056052684784,
0.026486920192837715,
0.2908468544483185,
-0.5368880033493042,
-0.9173178672790527,
0.995585560798645,
0.5777380466461182,
-0.8927276730537415,
-0.001271093962714076,
0.2697339951992035,
0.37817952036857605,
0.12829072773456573,
0.30739572644233704,
0.505713701248169,
0.2857353091239929,
0.06614658236503601,
-0.949802577495575,
0.2550053298473358,
0.10100295394659042,
0.1021643653512001,
0.4667750597000122,
-0.8327205181121826,
1.032339334487915,
-0.1215406134724617,
-0.34543654322624207,
0.14794744551181793,
0.5492455959320068,
0.25974416732788086,
0.2652661204338074,
0.39278924465179443,
0.9568502902984619,
0.7780072689056396,
-0.014750687405467033,
1.241024136543274,
-0.3703337609767914,
0.42444366216659546,
0.8704084157943726,
-0.28544339537620544,
1.013080358505249,
0.6256437301635742,
-0.43036168813705444,
0.23718605935573578,
0.782721757888794,
0.23505744338035583,
0.3434760272502899,
0.6146247982978821,
-0.6122951507568359,
-0.16746361553668976,
-0.32075029611587524,
-0.3069891929626465,
0.2591577470302582,
0.29424718022346497,
-0.05957626923918724,
0.018926842138171196,
0.18130449950695038,
0.224291130900383,
-0.15450309216976166,
-0.40432220697402954,
0.40242627263069153,
0.3292790949344635,
-0.343852162361145,
1.0140457153320312,
-0.05097472667694092,
0.6252345442771912,
-0.044028520584106445,
0.16737453639507294,
-0.21287158131599426,
-0.12605151534080505,
-0.17061543464660645,
-0.4575289785861969,
0.42927926778793335,
-0.22392378747463226,
-0.12691326439380646,
-0.40598294138908386,
0.5501661896705627,
-0.30961915850639343,
-0.3655722439289093,
0.14715562760829926,
0.5561686158180237,
0.3158167004585266,
-0.49871331453323364,
-0.2809080183506012,
0.6415334343910217,
-0.14938417077064514,
-0.5108619332313538,
0.4761320650577545,
0.5335584282875061,
-0.09397325664758682,
1.2421233654022217,
0.5528469085693359,
0.2449231743812561,
0.0059035178273916245,
-0.29160547256469727,
0.7755837440490723,
-0.6363293528556824,
-0.3518357574939728,
-1.1848015785217285,
0.22345317900180817,
0.19246578216552734,
0.21530459821224213,
0.5301591753959656,
0.6810078024864197,
0.4698125422000885,
0.05117679014801979,
0.6596680879592896,
-0.06851338595151901,
0.3754636347293854,
-1.0928587913513184,
0.5336920022964478,
-0.4828961193561554,
0.5818095803260803,
0.07196896523237228,
-0.7315341234207153,
-0.26308882236480713,
0.4774051010608673,
-0.1450890302658081,
-0.062044207006692886,
0.8573797345161438,
0.7545741200447083,
0.20554065704345703,
-0.28087592124938965,
0.49060124158859253,
0.14828655123710632,
0.09279295057058334,
0.9598362445831299,
0.6409626007080078,
-0.580766499042511,
0.5686188340187073,
-0.4417584240436554,
-0.016360566020011902,
-0.2092088907957077,
-1.1623258590698242,
-0.7622310519218445,
-0.6251392960548401,
-0.7671462297439575,
-0.32222700119018555,
-0.044068679213523865,
0.5075954794883728,
1.1093631982803345,
-0.26479673385620117,
-0.33900120854377747,
-0.1332809031009674,
0.333091676235199,
0.014774620532989502,
-0.206869974732399,
0.3396284580230713,
0.3076046109199524,
-0.8447358012199402,
0.2413983941078186,
0.24812036752700806,
0.4418852627277374,
-0.16986116766929626,
-0.009747873060405254,
0.040832437574863434,
0.05782647803425789,
0.6480845212936401,
0.30231329798698425,
-0.28897377848625183,
0.04662255942821503,
-0.14598879218101501,
-0.11612223088741302,
-0.01124608051031828,
0.9105678796768188,
-1.0448983907699585,
0.02245323173701763,
0.4556008577346802,
0.5558280944824219,
0.6577604413032532,
0.07381822168827057,
0.6437297463417053,
-0.6264110207557678,
0.4541071355342865,
-0.026813965290784836,
0.17589028179645538,
0.1660042107105255,
-0.514926016330719,
0.7024555206298828,
0.17448145151138306,
-0.7280327081680298,
-1.111665964126587,
0.2018306851387024,
-0.9806649684906006,
-0.3002294898033142,
1.213950276374817,
-0.1738349348306656,
-0.3762149214744568,
0.01898672804236412,
-0.04575658217072487,
0.24019742012023926,
-0.2129056602716446,
0.5982523560523987,
0.6215572357177734,
-0.21585004031658173,
-0.4907861649990082,
-0.9063822627067566,
0.4026375114917755,
0.4088635742664337,
-0.8058180212974548,
0.11296794563531876,
0.17163905501365662,
-0.19605857133865356,
0.01417192816734314,
0.5401841402053833,
0.23845840990543365,
-0.12008459120988846,
0.12350966036319733,
0.23197130858898163,
-0.019142523407936096,
0.0964634045958519,
-0.6375587582588196,
0.10878752171993256,
0.05568521097302437,
-0.22329087555408478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01382v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01382v1
|
Automatic Question-Answer Generation for Long-Tail Knowledge
| 2024-03-03T03:06:31 | 2024-03-03T03:06:31 |
Rohan Kumar, Youngmin Kim, Sunitha Ravi, Haitian Sun, Christos Faloutsos, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, Minji Yoon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pretrained Large Language Models (LLMs) have gained significant attention for
addressing open-domain Question Answering (QA). While they exhibit high
accuracy in answering questions related to common knowledge, LLMs encounter
difficulties in learning about uncommon long-tail knowledge (tail entities).
Since manually constructing QA datasets demands substantial human resources,
the types of existing QA datasets are limited, leaving us with a scarcity of
datasets to study the performance of LLMs on tail entities. In this paper, we
propose an automatic approach to generate specialized QA datasets for tail
entities and present the associated research challenges. We conduct extensive
experiments by employing pretrained LLMs on our newly generated long-tail QA
datasets, comparing their performance with and without external resources
including Wikipedia and Wikidata knowledge graphs.
|
[
-0.6590688824653625,
-0.8817685842514038,
0.7029945254325867,
-0.041377753019332886,
-0.2225891351699829,
0.10610402375459671,
-0.150605246424675,
-0.3837512135505676,
0.32460564374923706,
0.8657852411270142,
-0.8090790510177612,
-0.5531174540519714,
-0.20056065917015076,
0.43095311522483826,
-0.24570512771606445,
1.0435904264450073,
-0.11491076648235321,
-0.33380770683288574,
-0.179956316947937,
-0.14355017244815826,
-0.4423358738422394,
-0.4515284299850464,
-0.6757723093032837,
0.17001821100711823,
0.46249306201934814,
0.44909289479255676,
0.6043911576271057,
0.3045468032360077,
0.2496868222951889,
0.158954918384552,
0.30952951312065125,
0.4601920545101166,
-0.558047890663147,
0.14290034770965576,
-0.1943904012441635,
-0.27328577637672424,
-0.42341557145118713,
-0.31185004115104675,
0.7400349974632263,
0.8185662031173706,
-0.05478900298476219,
0.4650329053401947,
-0.20850378274917603,
0.6972602605819702,
-0.5517618060112,
0.0891832485795021,
-0.9616948962211609,
-0.24522022902965546,
-0.3872098922729492,
-0.16198061406612396,
-0.1250169426202774,
-0.5623753666877747,
0.19239182770252228,
-0.9582653641700745,
0.25884824991226196,
0.09908991307020187,
0.9104188084602356,
0.34583091735839844,
-0.5566532015800476,
-0.5218909978866577,
-0.6372703313827515,
0.5954788327217102,
-0.767795979976654,
0.3008238673210144,
0.13109147548675537,
0.23940381407737732,
-0.284379780292511,
-0.6792919635772705,
-0.6437272429466248,
0.12347028404474258,
-0.021405253559350967,
-0.09606295078992844,
-0.1628613919019699,
-0.1884203404188156,
0.30975261330604553,
0.10351376980543137,
-0.7304204702377319,
0.2611943781375885,
-0.4211731255054474,
0.21148638427257538,
0.824924647808075,
0.390918493270874,
0.10521256178617477,
-0.21195924282073975,
0.12171073257923126,
-0.1161399632692337,
-1.0457135438919067,
0.08143804967403412,
0.5054079294204712,
0.12934695184230804,
0.45975133776664734,
0.6864163279533386,
-0.45577993988990784,
0.8307272791862488,
0.1776355504989624,
0.14609304070472717,
0.3300015330314636,
-0.08327433466911316,
-0.040725816041231155,
-0.21429148316383362,
0.8566210269927979,
0.2840290367603302,
0.6310757994651794,
-0.35522353649139404,
-0.39072078466415405,
-0.6437070369720459,
0.15341471135616302,
-0.7858818769454956,
-0.1443641036748886,
0.37386226654052734,
0.025524988770484924,
-0.027923595160245895,
-0.16573761403560638,
-0.7779198288917542,
-0.09442687034606934,
-0.27601101994514465,
0.7094517350196838,
-0.2407274842262268,
-0.48387688398361206,
0.13123871386051178,
0.09340556710958481,
0.3317357301712036,
0.05504125729203224,
-0.5166600346565247,
0.4521620273590088,
0.28338876366615295,
0.2937259078025818,
-0.5706222653388977,
-0.22102488577365875,
-0.71345055103302,
0.24083958566188812,
-0.5341079831123352,
0.7603948712348938,
-0.3362543284893036,
-0.25582894682884216,
0.12598444521427155,
0.12922510504722595,
-0.09269227832555771,
-0.698098361492157,
0.08831021189689636,
-1.1074763536453247,
-0.028699902817606926,
-0.3043188154697418,
-0.7513189911842346,
-0.051886625587940216,
0.06145185977220535,
-0.8842786550521851,
0.868380606174469,
0.25001099705696106,
-1.0744904279708862,
0.2530154287815094,
-0.6894670724868774,
-0.3642978370189667,
0.1491333693265915,
-0.2524675726890564,
-0.3510476350784302,
-0.1329658478498459,
0.6289241909980774,
0.6084327697753906,
-0.33334681391716003,
0.3785554766654968,
-0.05076651647686958,
-0.15120653808116913,
0.34086349606513977,
0.06466779857873917,
0.6826819181442261,
0.07459842413663864,
-0.12302311509847641,
-0.024076877161860466,
-0.965045690536499,
0.34791356325149536,
0.4556266963481903,
-0.029222767800092697,
-0.5601193308830261,
0.01549150887876749,
-0.388123095035553,
-0.07348541915416718,
0.327444463968277,
-0.4401989281177521,
0.22346751391887665,
-0.29364725947380066,
0.2578991949558258,
0.6938018202781677,
0.42190021276474,
0.17790846526622772,
-0.1306019425392151,
0.6899679899215698,
0.1488649994134903,
-0.10633353888988495,
0.005271621514111757,
-0.2370031625032425,
-0.759604811668396,
0.08244120329618454,
0.3046048879623413,
0.5148671865463257,
-0.9894370436668396,
0.46922722458839417,
-0.4945007860660553,
-0.3928981423377991,
-0.390251487493515,
0.3218238651752472,
0.14961346983909607,
0.5209352374076843,
0.4299221336841583,
-0.13339895009994507,
-0.4237443804740906,
-0.9170538783073425,
0.03927748277783394,
-0.02157018519937992,
-0.154388889670372,
0.5890796184539795,
0.5833513140678406,
-0.0011138183763250709,
1.2273129224777222,
-1.0504626035690308,
0.006486702244728804,
0.08951108157634735,
0.1289617121219635,
0.1347663253545761,
0.20901308953762054,
0.4328140914440155,
-0.5748275518417358,
-0.3293650150299072,
-0.4104301333427429,
-0.7604631185531616,
-0.04738909378647804,
0.020733749493956566,
-0.28715088963508606,
0.14137977361679077,
0.4275190234184265,
-0.888662576675415,
-0.06259920448064804,
0.30550825595855713,
-0.013803932815790176,
0.8532934784889221,
-0.0033553086686879396,
0.09822534769773483,
-1.0653408765792847,
0.2073465883731842,
-0.09270484745502472,
0.03170940652489662,
-0.4516963064670563,
0.09704095125198364,
-0.023397129029035568,
-0.22649982571601868,
-0.4119114577770233,
0.6182536482810974,
-0.5256328582763672,
-0.1723717749118805,
0.11248888820409775,
0.22976627945899963,
-0.15555530786514282,
0.5196223855018616,
0.3966974914073944,
0.8856173157691956,
0.4303978681564331,
-0.9818761348724365,
0.347943514585495,
0.2935373783111572,
-0.12640440464019775,
0.2737540304660797,
-0.8745695948600769,
0.3968372046947479,
-0.1237250491976738,
0.12946344912052155,
-0.5461788773536682,
-0.43249133229255676,
0.13094842433929443,
-0.1964869499206543,
0.2138890027999878,
-0.1561232954263687,
-0.6556060910224915,
-0.5491747856140137,
-0.02551073022186756,
0.43026286363601685,
0.7662255764007568,
-0.43767422437667847,
0.3601560890674591,
0.45084643363952637,
-0.48400360345840454,
-0.6608728766441345,
-0.02142995223402977,
-0.07852537930011749,
-0.22538088262081146,
-0.8963595032691956,
0.10595507174730301,
-0.1692589670419693,
-0.1813526153564453,
0.005009409971535206,
0.16411715745925903,
-0.3272109031677246,
0.057362500578165054,
0.05313032492995262,
0.06310617178678513,
-0.47983717918395996,
0.5663365721702576,
0.20221197605133057,
0.24419598281383514,
0.45841366052627563,
-0.3919389247894287,
0.3432057499885559,
-0.1588568240404129,
-0.36102792620658875,
0.09928806871175766,
0.4068150818347931,
0.1444048136472702,
-0.6173232793807983,
0.4860968291759491,
0.3133818805217743,
-0.26798105239868164,
-0.5320460796356201,
-0.6360462307929993,
-0.22629521787166595,
-0.44534334540367126,
0.432438462972641,
-0.3521865904331207,
-0.7936855554580688,
0.46789678931236267,
0.12742939591407776,
0.3716978132724762,
0.500619649887085,
0.4759475588798523,
0.010046491399407387,
0.8349337577819824,
0.45561400055885315,
0.2343515157699585,
-0.0669114738702774,
-0.22283749282360077,
0.009313465096056461,
-0.43563804030418396,
0.015303635969758034,
-0.4548361897468567,
0.2747304439544678,
-0.5318853855133057,
-0.30832189321517944,
0.4780404567718506,
0.1443966180086136,
-0.3642168343067169,
0.06214219704270363,
-0.4707503914833069,
0.44750097393989563,
0.5969750285148621,
-0.015111058950424194,
0.5380519032478333,
-0.0909886285662651,
0.23713603615760803,
0.33634212613105774,
-0.5642367601394653,
-0.5958127379417419,
1.4861770868301392,
0.12037321925163269,
0.8311890959739685,
-0.13546223938465118,
0.943141520023346,
-0.09386659413576126,
0.15085740387439728,
-0.4766824245452881,
0.49519073963165283,
-0.010598999448120594,
-0.523949146270752,
-0.7495278120040894,
-0.5677960515022278,
-1.1007094383239746,
-0.24895301461219788,
-0.12980017066001892,
-0.16555696725845337,
-0.17284204065799713,
0.11102898418903351,
-0.5192316770553589,
0.219931498169899,
-0.48953700065612793,
0.6463837027549744,
-0.30600735545158386,
-0.053194884210824966,
0.11639409512281418,
-0.6237660050392151,
0.6486703157424927,
-0.6181792616844177,
0.015219154767692089,
-0.03994976356625557,
0.08144804835319519,
1.218259334564209,
-0.29745498299598694,
0.5720070600509644,
-0.34869006276130676,
-0.416464239358902,
0.6710079312324524,
-0.0585334450006485,
0.6568353772163391,
0.22736839950084686,
0.02919737622141838,
-0.1860286295413971,
0.25454026460647583,
-0.35797005891799927,
-0.5266318321228027,
0.35730597376823425,
-0.8341965079307556,
-0.7934741377830505,
-0.08461064845323563,
-0.5350103974342346,
-0.7542623281478882,
0.21884453296661377,
0.19691431522369385,
0.14412562549114227,
-0.2789410948753357,
-0.16132168471813202,
1.1068097352981567,
-0.4276562035083771,
0.13286255300045013,
0.8692768216133118,
-0.2906952202320099,
-0.22174420952796936,
0.9177373647689819,
0.3479585349559784,
0.0639333724975586,
0.19559374451637268,
-0.12287919223308563,
-0.43587008118629456,
-0.7056463360786438,
-0.7182579040527344,
0.3591131269931793,
-0.5588694214820862,
-0.3135494589805603,
-0.765849232673645,
-0.48097437620162964,
-0.28002455830574036,
0.270248144865036,
-0.2025989443063736,
-0.36815229058265686,
-0.3833537697792053,
0.00829553697258234,
0.6568716764450073,
0.7858930826187134,
0.14350701868534088,
0.14552870392799377,
-1.0871466398239136,
0.6213614344596863,
0.7532532811164856,
0.18728415668010712,
0.06991706043481827,
-0.14279699325561523,
-0.2968422770500183,
0.17988194525241852,
-0.1387924700975418,
-0.8230773210525513,
0.28597530722618103,
0.2345171570777893,
0.5207962989807129,
0.08665686845779419,
0.4790230095386505,
0.5108388662338257,
-0.6703952550888062,
0.7766374349594116,
-0.017457803711295128,
-0.5762287378311157,
0.566716730594635,
-0.41922762989997864,
0.026942001655697823,
0.4014627933502197,
0.9303277134895325,
-0.11027916520833969,
-0.6030628085136414,
-0.6634398102760315,
-0.8899877071380615,
0.2589394152164459,
0.2407715618610382,
0.1971951425075531,
-0.19348357617855072,
0.4987097680568695,
0.5204216241836548,
0.3261243999004364,
-0.4768434166908264,
-0.09654861688613892,
-0.14059630036354065,
-0.24389342963695526,
-0.026046330109238625,
0.002728984458371997,
-0.08622536063194275,
0.15625068545341492,
0.657986044883728,
-0.2990069091320038,
-0.16496853530406952,
0.10366148501634598,
-0.4026525020599365,
-0.2510141432285309,
0.2880786061286926,
0.0918254554271698,
1.1756658554077148,
-0.268097460269928,
-0.1033405289053917,
0.23466670513153076,
-0.2720321714878082,
0.20433948934078217,
0.17738984525203705,
-0.3290891647338867,
0.013596457429230213,
0.07979042828083038,
0.4691306948661804,
-0.2977718710899353,
-1.0020009279251099,
0.43150565028190613,
-0.041014429181814194,
-0.21272803843021393,
-0.7195383906364441,
0.1488596647977829,
0.34003737568855286,
0.020464392378926277,
0.7880897521972656,
-0.7061961889266968,
-0.17253880202770233,
-0.19219589233398438,
0.35369616746902466,
0.4923305809497833,
0.1790134459733963,
-0.21396218240261078,
0.3769153654575348,
0.3498287498950958,
0.05607214197516441,
1.017849326133728,
-0.16586172580718994,
-0.3082183599472046,
0.64699786901474,
0.2558426558971405,
0.5137397646903992,
0.021634424105286598,
0.14655305445194244,
0.4142289459705353,
0.13437315821647644,
0.09588170796632767,
0.2972521185874939,
0.21385589241981506,
-0.6210314631462097,
-0.7312905788421631,
-0.7289192080497742,
-0.4550512433052063,
0.5124843120574951,
-0.7644020318984985,
0.13226871192455292,
-0.13724787533283234,
-0.06012865900993347,
-0.20446057617664337,
0.07266362011432648,
-0.9820905923843384,
0.4351083040237427,
-0.11500298231840134,
0.8975139260292053,
-0.6729814410209656,
0.5818028450012207,
0.6290802359580994,
-0.7416312098503113,
-0.9103512763977051,
0.07557663321495056,
-0.8248205780982971,
-0.7829269170761108,
1.019656777381897,
-0.20680932700634003,
0.016386941075325012,
0.42340752482414246,
-0.73102867603302,
-0.8051906824111938,
0.9567974805831909,
0.30700379610061646,
-0.6347705721855164,
-0.754274845123291,
0.40980446338653564,
0.4116045832633972,
-0.2942695915699005,
0.0953742042183876,
0.5213027596473694,
0.38134822249412537,
-0.2406480461359024,
-0.961834728717804,
0.18308119475841522,
-0.07901684939861298,
-0.3924582600593567,
0.1408131867647171,
-0.5786365866661072,
0.8253585696220398,
-0.3436393439769745,
-0.11556482315063477,
-0.059183161705732346,
0.9138190150260925,
0.452763170003891,
0.06953845173120499,
0.6349841952323914,
0.49833887815475464,
0.792468786239624,
0.2986985146999359,
0.4806165397167206,
-0.3564407527446747,
0.12476589530706406,
1.1334127187728882,
-0.3875308632850647,
0.937721848487854,
0.3458203375339508,
-0.19212250411510468,
0.4259898066520691,
0.7969611883163452,
-0.11920146644115448,
0.2232343852519989,
0.5638957619667053,
-0.10480069369077682,
-0.5684623718261719,
0.2300994098186493,
-0.5228090882301331,
0.253266304731369,
0.2603283226490021,
-0.08458627760410309,
-0.3296898305416107,
-0.09849312901496887,
-0.2514179050922394,
-0.11676111072301865,
-0.3595620095729828,
0.8600122928619385,
0.17486752569675446,
-0.8943358659744263,
0.8229165077209473,
-0.13670118153095245,
0.6849755048751831,
-0.7697587013244629,
-0.07504090666770935,
-0.24345926940441132,
-0.36532941460609436,
-0.20748424530029297,
-1.0820046663284302,
0.21251578629016876,
0.2844443917274475,
-0.04983973503112793,
0.2432837039232254,
0.5074204802513123,
-0.31420525908470154,
-0.3808256685733795,
-0.007241913583129644,
0.9964041709899902,
0.30508604645729065,
-0.26799362897872925,
-0.407684862613678,
-0.4930058419704437,
-0.2335614711046219,
-0.4714357852935791,
0.34228482842445374,
0.6943790912628174,
-0.21773432195186615,
0.8639610409736633,
0.5491506457328796,
0.026941867545247078,
0.41999009251594543,
-0.2630325257778168,
0.9200533032417297,
-0.626990795135498,
-0.427776575088501,
-0.23939771950244904,
0.31546321511268616,
0.01704622618854046,
-0.27045029401779175,
0.43911051750183105,
0.5216872096061707,
0.8176227807998657,
-0.34616997838020325,
0.9295403957366943,
-0.04603565111756325,
0.8868230581283569,
-0.8149879574775696,
0.9485177397727966,
-0.6112618446350098,
0.06560324877500534,
-0.022073309868574142,
-0.7470681667327881,
0.21915048360824585,
0.10131322592496872,
-0.12036821991205215,
-0.053727149963378906,
0.5537348389625549,
0.7988622784614563,
-0.007629129104316235,
-0.26053473353385925,
0.10783203691244125,
0.100811667740345,
0.22263839840888977,
0.8824827075004578,
0.8838393092155457,
-0.20039556920528412,
0.8326362371444702,
-0.30903398990631104,
0.22061200439929962,
0.044669270515441895,
-0.846958577632904,
-0.996930718421936,
-0.7558797001838684,
-0.33969610929489136,
-0.23630109429359436,
0.20269885659217834,
0.7677807211875916,
0.46895632147789,
-0.7678928971290588,
-0.11475163698196411,
0.010924247093498707,
0.1465313732624054,
0.1323687732219696,
-0.30583086609840393,
0.862968921661377,
-0.4849657416343689,
-0.5627700686454773,
0.17512769997119904,
-0.4736900329589844,
0.028313331305980682,
-0.45676133036613464,
0.022161588072776794,
0.08805213123559952,
0.08000733703374863,
0.34224262833595276,
0.42986029386520386,
-0.3936150074005127,
-0.23088426887989044,
0.227648064494133,
0.005820618476718664,
0.08316620439291,
0.6711899042129517,
-0.8967829942703247,
-0.15882864594459534,
0.3127819299697876,
0.8596242070198059,
0.42308905720710754,
0.01753663457930088,
0.707956075668335,
-0.7448413968086243,
-0.4546881914138794,
0.535897433757782,
0.004339501727372408,
0.15218624472618103,
-0.2979865074157715,
0.4510357081890106,
0.01143106259405613,
-0.48980212211608887,
-0.8906097412109375,
0.21250736713409424,
-0.7690345048904419,
-0.21825897693634033,
1.2359906435012817,
-0.20438534021377563,
-0.26467594504356384,
-0.19255812466144562,
0.05338845029473305,
0.30228590965270996,
-0.22193431854248047,
0.5389607548713684,
0.3801122009754181,
-0.16025367379188538,
0.0313190259039402,
-0.5372459292411804,
0.6533928513526917,
0.04782741144299507,
-1.1108603477478027,
0.23646226525306702,
0.5347931385040283,
0.9033787846565247,
-0.06722123920917511,
0.6990119814872742,
0.09996872395277023,
0.2450539618730545,
-0.197191521525383,
0.1858077496290207,
-0.3175034523010254,
-0.05814778804779053,
0.17528794705867767,
0.37648361921310425,
0.3125212490558624,
0.09179673343896866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14666v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14666v1
|
SyllabusQA: A Course Logistics Question Answering Dataset
| 2024-03-03T03:01:14 | 2024-03-03T03:01:14 |
Nigel Fernandez, Alexander Scarlatos, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Automated teaching assistants and chatbots have significant potential to
reduce the workload of human instructors, especially for logistics-related
question answering, which is important to students yet repetitive for
instructors. However, due to privacy concerns, there is a lack of publicly
available datasets. We introduce SyllabusQA, an open-source dataset with 63
real course syllabi covering 36 majors, containing 5,078 open-ended course
logistics-related question-answer pairs that are diverse in both question types
and answer formats. Since many logistics-related questions contain critical
information like the date of an exam, it is important to evaluate the
factuality of answers. We benchmark several strong baselines on this task, from
large language model prompting to retrieval-augmented generation. We find that
despite performing close to humans on traditional metrics of textual
similarity, there remains a significant gap between automated approaches and
humans in terms of fact precision.
|
[
-0.1575801819562912,
-0.8190144896507263,
0.42270079255104065,
-0.27464014291763306,
0.11507080495357513,
0.0563836470246315,
0.1813943088054657,
-0.4963727295398712,
0.12469396740198135,
0.4798506796360016,
-0.8720389604568481,
-0.445886492729187,
0.09107603132724762,
-0.007993718609213829,
-0.7323241233825684,
1.251338005065918,
0.107884481549263,
-0.2663068175315857,
-0.569502592086792,
-0.3673285245895386,
-0.6065046191215515,
-0.6811554431915283,
-0.6492645740509033,
-0.04591028392314911,
0.5745857357978821,
0.3017652928829193,
0.8984286189079285,
0.5211998224258423,
0.5322457551956177,
0.18997475504875183,
0.021126730367541313,
-0.11616002768278122,
-0.3013589382171631,
0.08272511512041092,
-0.3166739046573639,
-0.6280086636543274,
-0.5908064246177673,
-0.12703785300254822,
0.6278345584869385,
0.8824437856674194,
-0.6850309371948242,
0.8588054180145264,
0.040949661284685135,
0.5278282165527344,
-0.8792802691459656,
0.024392200633883476,
-0.3582734763622284,
-0.11443480849266052,
-0.29147565364837646,
0.1714572310447693,
-0.39583534002304077,
-0.5892990231513977,
0.41675540804862976,
-0.9606354832649231,
0.3817547559738159,
0.09882643073797226,
1.070919394493103,
0.4715009331703186,
-0.43689534068107605,
-0.43736520409584045,
-0.6392419338226318,
0.7098566889762878,
-0.3813006281852722,
0.3448107838630676,
0.7452658414840698,
0.4705122113227844,
0.05027283728122711,
-0.7151917219161987,
-0.4681974947452545,
0.16825929284095764,
-0.21167142689228058,
0.2547956705093384,
-0.14483051002025604,
0.18909168243408203,
0.10377620905637741,
0.36834874749183655,
-1.0035794973373413,
0.004178497474640608,
-0.6753630638122559,
-0.17240552604198456,
0.8144016265869141,
0.6035864353179932,
0.25383198261260986,
-0.2717995345592499,
-0.2978154718875885,
-0.2999503016471863,
-0.4057317078113556,
0.21885839104652405,
0.4458474814891815,
-0.12005260586738586,
-0.16488714516162872,
0.3660355806350708,
-0.5197629332542419,
0.9156380891799927,
-0.48382624983787537,
0.1485217809677124,
-0.06683901697397232,
-0.32632580399513245,
-0.4330652356147766,
0.044110316783189774,
0.4704122841358185,
0.41300228238105774,
-0.13461890816688538,
0.010400994680821896,
0.05494608357548714,
-0.1512438952922821,
0.372933030128479,
-0.21440955996513367,
-0.540241003036499,
0.5322461724281311,
-0.15609392523765564,
-0.02715042419731617,
0.019212400540709496,
-0.822192370891571,
-0.22507566213607788,
-0.3168462812900543,
0.595814049243927,
0.020098082721233368,
0.15172117948532104,
0.14415086805820465,
-0.09944936633110046,
0.4374871850013733,
0.7200950980186462,
-0.5129801630973816,
0.2916702628135681,
0.540103554725647,
0.7630948424339294,
-0.0495794303715229,
-0.08051987737417221,
-0.5810693502426147,
0.20925572514533997,
-0.33150339126586914,
0.7158327698707581,
-0.22418522834777832,
0.005959019530564547,
-0.03203234821557999,
0.11515630036592484,
0.18724225461483002,
-0.5487949252128601,
0.48205825686454773,
-0.6594463586807251,
0.6017653942108154,
-0.24119353294372559,
-0.5854840874671936,
-0.517990231513977,
0.27663058042526245,
-0.8616381883621216,
1.3055845499038696,
0.10894200205802917,
-0.3231724202632904,
0.22949188947677612,
-0.542068600654602,
-0.1463238000869751,
0.33943039178848267,
-0.2601935863494873,
-0.29656463861465454,
-0.3877146244049072,
-0.05099206045269966,
0.525994062423706,
-0.4812726378440857,
0.580756664276123,
-0.11223887652158737,
-0.2272588014602661,
0.2416342943906784,
-0.42317959666252136,
1.2627290487289429,
0.13096266984939575,
-0.08387771248817444,
-0.19380556046962738,
-0.7300794720649719,
0.10232901573181152,
-0.21717697381973267,
-0.40030673146247864,
-0.2961685359477997,
-0.1446632295846939,
-0.0035396465100347996,
0.08613389730453491,
0.2884221374988556,
-0.40274757146835327,
0.10638582706451416,
-0.28125694394111633,
-0.006645592395216227,
1.0465905666351318,
-0.18347333371639252,
0.10822262614965439,
-0.7272605895996094,
0.8393125534057617,
-0.10940171033143997,
0.2897745370864868,
0.09752301126718521,
-0.7553209662437439,
-0.867743194103241,
-0.04384755343198776,
0.12510959804058075,
0.672986626625061,
-0.6493344902992249,
0.287065714597702,
-0.17835506796836853,
-0.7060979604721069,
-0.6787828207015991,
0.19588539004325867,
0.2865539789199829,
0.5063488483428955,
0.41456231474876404,
-0.38324621319770813,
-0.39973726868629456,
-0.7071716785430908,
-0.05358909070491791,
-0.6410384178161621,
-0.15357984602451324,
0.06821010261774063,
0.38305437564849854,
0.2928428649902344,
1.0874147415161133,
-0.9866452813148499,
-0.028958918526768684,
0.09812275320291519,
-0.08675100654363632,
0.22575102746486664,
0.20179638266563416,
0.37037545442581177,
-0.5510261058807373,
-0.0007223039283417165,
-0.24810029566287994,
-1.07732355594635,
0.20547227561473846,
-0.2679382860660553,
-0.4754622280597687,
0.2798461616039276,
0.11595515161752701,
-0.8086672425270081,
0.6577358841896057,
0.256587415933609,
-0.42155709862709045,
0.4682523012161255,
-0.12457761913537979,
-0.10347941517829895,
-0.9643530249595642,
0.2759554386138916,
-0.14016975462436676,
0.02949683368206024,
-0.5315762758255005,
0.06830646097660065,
-0.1041482463479042,
-0.2725452184677124,
-0.28112897276878357,
0.5952191352844238,
0.06807634234428406,
-0.27260175347328186,
0.28114598989486694,
0.19280202686786652,
0.11442437022924423,
0.3971762955188751,
-0.1094842329621315,
0.7551411390304565,
0.2881065607070923,
-0.6247103810310364,
0.8012731671333313,
0.657444953918457,
-0.2965145409107208,
0.603917121887207,
-0.575774610042572,
-0.04924245923757553,
-0.405322402715683,
0.5439421534538269,
-1.0248123407363892,
-0.30568253993988037,
0.3283379077911377,
-0.17126168310642242,
-0.4831539988517761,
0.0018520259764045477,
-0.5282010436058044,
-0.2685967981815338,
-0.02593117393553257,
0.344065397977829,
0.4786972105503082,
-0.3912596106529236,
0.3413355350494385,
0.1529206931591034,
-0.35937532782554626,
-0.8115559816360474,
-0.367178350687027,
-0.13093648850917816,
-0.13250625133514404,
-0.290802001953125,
-0.3188684284687042,
-0.25049886107444763,
-0.27731552720069885,
-0.07544360309839249,
-0.43894240260124207,
-0.5109087228775024,
0.44140657782554626,
0.25078892707824707,
0.702381432056427,
-0.2523258626461029,
0.6978278756141663,
0.052750617265701294,
0.14641983807086945,
0.4605698883533478,
-0.5146788954734802,
0.2518131136894226,
0.09831994026899338,
-0.33417731523513794,
-0.4478033781051636,
0.173170268535614,
0.24345022439956665,
-0.08431707322597504,
0.7503018975257874,
0.38106346130371094,
-0.5288295745849609,
0.04717770963907242,
-0.35700520873069763,
-0.31534871459007263,
-0.5013650059700012,
0.2769321799278259,
0.057903554290533066,
-0.5524818301200867,
0.09445087611675262,
0.5094388723373413,
0.5661991834640503,
0.2855340838432312,
0.3652523159980774,
-0.41124072670936584,
0.20251958072185516,
0.3891630470752716,
-0.042752593755722046,
-0.04834023118019104,
-0.2472572922706604,
0.07782544195652008,
0.0810396820306778,
-0.6984986066818237,
-0.5643270611763,
-0.20628486573696136,
-0.28895971179008484,
-0.35034501552581787,
0.3039882481098175,
-0.05129637196660042,
-0.3493129312992096,
0.3397452235221863,
-0.4294475317001343,
0.5300238728523254,
0.7539383769035339,
0.2528749406337738,
0.49285265803337097,
-0.0002064859145320952,
0.29738306999206543,
0.33973029255867004,
-0.8228923082351685,
-0.6702369451522827,
1.1465883255004883,
0.07507068663835526,
0.6582815647125244,
0.3898589611053467,
0.22422005236148834,
0.5933325290679932,
0.07936245948076248,
-0.4969103932380676,
0.7957226037979126,
-0.06058642640709877,
-1.0293960571289062,
-0.563886284828186,
-0.35855141282081604,
-0.9534477591514587,
-0.28385165333747864,
-0.180938258767128,
-0.4261980950832367,
-0.06523596495389938,
0.2269987165927887,
-0.4517533779144287,
0.25188082456588745,
-0.684599757194519,
0.8435280919075012,
-0.09335808455944061,
-0.06949203461408615,
-0.1444506198167801,
-1.023134469985962,
0.0695931687951088,
-0.347170889377594,
0.18409915268421173,
-0.2809438705444336,
-0.027433618903160095,
1.1262179613113403,
-0.5577542185783386,
0.8383961319923401,
0.17239278554916382,
-0.510541558265686,
0.4228494465351105,
-0.017507709562778473,
-0.033793289214372635,
0.10523252934217453,
-0.11689407378435135,
0.07724460959434509,
0.4209491014480591,
-0.8918519020080566,
-0.7778328657150269,
0.28260770440101624,
-0.8429413437843323,
-0.49769312143325806,
-0.4223788380622864,
-0.5672984719276428,
-0.09182306379079819,
-0.03308304399251938,
0.1470542848110199,
0.7447043061256409,
0.15260149538516998,
-0.10513430088758469,
0.6538012027740479,
-0.2576325237751007,
0.32279348373413086,
0.3452698290348053,
0.04426968842744827,
-0.04928181320428848,
0.9263854622840881,
0.23036742210388184,
0.39511677622795105,
0.5774025321006775,
-0.11570271104574203,
-0.36323752999305725,
0.1628492921590805,
-0.7180408835411072,
0.12358777225017548,
-0.9852742552757263,
-0.2803359925746918,
-0.6540754437446594,
-0.36764779686927795,
-0.20730148255825043,
-0.1424742043018341,
-0.05815005302429199,
-0.8045835494995117,
-0.20580358803272247,
-0.20904096961021423,
0.7054353952407837,
0.9270759224891663,
0.2719919681549072,
0.3439217209815979,
-0.7366475462913513,
0.06112142652273178,
0.5640562176704407,
0.3453739285469055,
0.03037363290786743,
-0.3422180116176605,
-0.47907617688179016,
0.11801629513502121,
-0.5400986671447754,
-0.7687286734580994,
-0.09025383740663528,
0.18743963539600372,
0.38047218322753906,
0.24352972209453583,
0.4362459182739258,
0.5732861161231995,
-0.07111288607120514,
1.0386719703674316,
-0.037768132984638214,
-0.7833097577095032,
0.6420810222625732,
-0.10122361779212952,
0.18548353016376495,
0.2440507411956787,
1.088314414024353,
-0.43016883730888367,
-0.5344278812408447,
-0.8301752805709839,
-0.6195406913757324,
0.8521134257316589,
0.6398496627807617,
0.01468295231461525,
0.46536725759506226,
0.31684383749961853,
0.12216228991746902,
0.36305955052375793,
-0.36465221643447876,
-0.7148928046226501,
-0.171404629945755,
-0.622327983379364,
-0.33399438858032227,
0.18216781318187714,
-0.12744054198265076,
-0.14966653287410736,
0.5683169364929199,
0.10944528132677078,
-0.05939483270049095,
-0.04927632957696915,
0.12263375520706177,
0.1507057398557663,
0.48051267862319946,
0.4477800130844116,
0.8074670433998108,
-0.4367738366127014,
0.0036205118522047997,
0.5124965906143188,
-1.007057785987854,
0.46178656816482544,
0.03162924572825432,
-0.1262204796075821,
0.3139733374118805,
0.2534991204738617,
0.30457863211631775,
-0.21851064264774323,
-1.2622746229171753,
0.24699930846691132,
0.09376300871372223,
-0.04398791119456291,
-0.45993900299072266,
0.2152542620897293,
-0.22413836419582367,
0.06426332145929337,
0.6811959743499756,
-0.2184852659702301,
0.32932206988334656,
-0.30838292837142944,
0.3234178423881531,
-0.04909803345799446,
-0.3351345658302307,
-0.29450249671936035,
0.6850827932357788,
0.08844473958015442,
-0.11507973074913025,
0.5942111015319824,
0.21563884615898132,
-0.1126820370554924,
0.7342671155929565,
0.012640782631933689,
0.4090109169483185,
-0.2183796465396881,
0.5465192794799805,
0.4622475206851959,
0.33518943190574646,
0.04861424118280411,
0.3392726480960846,
-0.09520552307367325,
-0.2927895784378052,
-0.2662627100944519,
-0.47486063838005066,
-0.7469985485076904,
0.05814805626869202,
-0.9738522171974182,
0.3991537094116211,
-0.48334577679634094,
-0.17153874039649963,
-0.1434936821460724,
-0.013599102385342121,
-0.5561957359313965,
0.6328787207603455,
-0.14565333724021912,
0.6387856602668762,
-0.8502385020256042,
0.552030622959137,
1.259218454360962,
-0.46394142508506775,
-0.8054093718528748,
-0.0678044855594635,
0.031932320445775986,
-0.33835989236831665,
0.7370744943618774,
-0.09712375700473785,
0.19472214579582214,
0.10773783177137375,
-0.4584106504917145,
-0.7366178631782532,
1.2819907665252686,
0.39007651805877686,
-0.3390105664730072,
-0.6454207897186279,
0.441476047039032,
0.3870604932308197,
0.3906509280204773,
0.35857754945755005,
0.42246708273887634,
-0.09168580919504166,
-0.2578386664390564,
-0.907478392124176,
0.035380102694034576,
-0.131761834025383,
-0.41689297556877136,
0.29375219345092773,
-0.6541077494621277,
0.753462016582489,
0.2250286191701889,
-0.24326741695404053,
0.07814668864011765,
0.5520336031913757,
0.3803127408027649,
0.632182240486145,
0.3940546214580536,
0.5744995474815369,
1.1564775705337524,
0.03883875161409378,
0.6271181106567383,
0.12489770352840424,
0.3939826190471649,
1.0894930362701416,
-0.06410682946443558,
0.9126076698303223,
0.24241000413894653,
-0.35570335388183594,
0.7039983868598938,
0.5851873755455017,
0.23433421552181244,
0.08356770128011703,
0.16695134341716766,
-0.335754930973053,
-0.5432628393173218,
-0.26548415422439575,
-0.3698188066482544,
0.4591917395591736,
0.2585541307926178,
0.24795430898666382,
-0.5254992842674255,
0.015757134184241295,
-0.10296023637056351,
-0.029239393770694733,
-0.1351858675479889,
0.6887220740318298,
-0.16096755862236023,
-0.4144294261932373,
0.7094392776489258,
-0.17527000606060028,
0.018880294635891914,
-0.3619368076324463,
-0.12701337039470673,
-0.4621674120426178,
-0.25558584928512573,
-0.21235249936580658,
-1.1488195657730103,
0.26563575863838196,
0.19397467374801636,
-0.061589568853378296,
0.0200358796864748,
0.22722090780735016,
-0.31241574883461,
-0.2511417269706726,
-0.33223095536231995,
0.4375552237033844,
0.16422681510448456,
0.363898366689682,
-0.5165091753005981,
-0.32896700501441956,
-0.3165300786495209,
0.31525325775146484,
0.01860545016825199,
0.43024545907974243,
-0.23709611594676971,
1.2473028898239136,
0.4855383038520813,
-0.3117639720439911,
0.2358650118112564,
-0.5865892767906189,
0.6162624359130859,
-0.5883139967918396,
-0.6374298334121704,
-0.4366071820259094,
0.4946051836013794,
-0.09435231238603592,
-0.5487745404243469,
0.7100389003753662,
0.7215210795402527,
1.2054357528686523,
-0.1688469499349594,
0.5295277833938599,
0.10692843794822693,
0.5223451256752014,
-0.6792116165161133,
0.6884523630142212,
-0.681763231754303,
0.37331098318099976,
-0.33649390935897827,
-0.6647843718528748,
0.03475549817085266,
0.31790560483932495,
0.03133325278759003,
-0.3540098965167999,
0.5278468132019043,
0.7076082229614258,
-0.026705533266067505,
0.395863801240921,
0.13212545216083527,
-0.2415424883365631,
0.02522544004023075,
0.7138431072235107,
1.104390025138855,
-0.7865736484527588,
0.8909018039703369,
-0.3052504360675812,
0.14258171617984772,
-0.2632977366447449,
-0.3997853100299835,
-0.9158505797386169,
-0.871214747428894,
-0.6492650508880615,
-0.5851760506629944,
0.567030668258667,
1.0241823196411133,
0.638077437877655,
-0.7711950540542603,
-0.7485157251358032,
0.14736208319664001,
0.2038515955209732,
-0.18685117363929749,
-0.24388454854488373,
0.45609864592552185,
-0.02997259795665741,
-0.23087486624717712,
-0.23601193726062775,
-0.00016580158262513578,
0.21017493307590485,
-0.11319174617528915,
0.11300799250602722,
-0.32283076643943787,
0.03797033801674843,
0.4228956699371338,
0.19192586839199066,
-0.6463251709938049,
-0.14249862730503082,
0.24577440321445465,
-0.22898359596729279,
-0.10060730576515198,
0.46551358699798584,
-0.864555299282074,
0.16973310708999634,
0.41077688336372375,
1.0696316957473755,
0.007073393557220697,
0.14066974818706512,
0.529796302318573,
-0.8810930252075195,
0.06373979896306992,
0.118041031062603,
-0.18730080127716064,
0.028982141986489296,
-0.43995553255081177,
0.6231127977371216,
0.4290929138660431,
-0.4765714108943939,
-0.9169435501098633,
0.15063528716564178,
-0.9902907609939575,
-0.14498864114284515,
0.5187987089157104,
-0.13541767001152039,
0.037472520023584366,
-0.6088480353355408,
-0.15323951840400696,
0.1681859791278839,
-0.2840000092983246,
0.7516451478004456,
0.6790394186973572,
0.2565409243106842,
-0.08087632060050964,
-0.8944207429885864,
0.5340856909751892,
0.6773365139961243,
-1.2542403936386108,
-0.010138832032680511,
0.6564801931381226,
0.022552289068698883,
-0.038111090660095215,
0.6129488945007324,
0.534713089466095,
0.6638625264167786,
-0.29606306552886963,
-0.17417046427726746,
0.49495047330856323,
-0.5093761682510376,
-0.10621152818202972,
0.06912529468536377,
-0.05369862914085388,
-0.2456149011850357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01373v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01373v4
|
Quantity Matters: Towards Assessing and Mitigating Number Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-03-03T02:31:11 | 2024-05-06T13:39:12 |
Huixuan Zhang, Junzhe Zhang, Xiaojun Wan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large-scale vision-language models have demonstrated impressive skill in
handling tasks that involve both areas. Nevertheless, these models frequently
experience significant issues with generating inaccurate information, which is
hallucination. In this study, we concentrate on a specific type of
hallucination-number hallucination, referring to models incorrectly identifying
the number of certain objects in pictures. We perform quantitative evaluations
regarding number hallucination, showing it to be critical in major open-source
large vision-language models. Furthermore, we utilizes two related tasks to
conduct an in-depth analysis of number hallucination, revealing the severe
inner and outer inconsistency among all tasks. Based on this examination, we
devise a training approach aimed at improving consistency to reduce number
hallucinations, which leads to an 8% enhancement in performance over direct
finetuning methods. Our code and dataset will be released to the community.
|
[
-0.43998900055885315,
-0.6641643047332764,
0.38679736852645874,
0.6377307176589966,
-0.15709413588047028,
-0.3070436418056488,
-0.0821312665939331,
-0.5900009870529175,
0.0053406464867293835,
0.5323894023895264,
-0.1788763701915741,
-0.041360437870025635,
-0.6885889768600464,
0.17565429210662842,
-0.538383424282074,
0.5291680097579956,
-0.028743961825966835,
0.6002063155174255,
-0.4690493047237396,
-0.3300287127494812,
-0.7642276287078857,
-0.5988188982009888,
-0.8681881427764893,
-0.051731474697589874,
0.48623067140579224,
0.07459712773561478,
0.8013501763343811,
0.4708018898963928,
1.0671372413635254,
0.3503960371017456,
0.11305662989616394,
0.15694281458854675,
-0.6967697143554688,
-0.1893080770969391,
-0.1530592143535614,
-0.2540554404258728,
-0.5322774648666382,
-0.34266722202301025,
0.5181794762611389,
0.8488631844520569,
-0.059485066682100296,
0.24836528301239014,
0.08223860710859299,
0.9168996810913086,
-0.7980830073356628,
0.2488311380147934,
-0.6096258163452148,
0.23421964049339294,
0.007865204475820065,
-0.12427626550197601,
-0.505522608757019,
-0.18400683999061584,
-0.04675397276878357,
-0.5113669633865356,
0.4170236885547638,
-0.13469304144382477,
0.6281428337097168,
0.6391674280166626,
-0.04429628327488899,
-0.19618086516857147,
-0.6374247670173645,
0.7903233766555786,
-0.6835376620292664,
0.5770228505134583,
0.7162766456604004,
-0.02417679876089096,
0.12339327484369278,
-0.2617700397968292,
-0.49418553709983826,
-0.2784601151943207,
0.08554406464099884,
-0.11497306823730469,
0.035875603556632996,
0.056552477180957794,
0.5075618028640747,
0.4049525856971741,
-0.5789046883583069,
-0.08617368340492249,
-0.6882708072662354,
-0.1375674307346344,
0.8184057474136353,
0.2721141278743744,
0.2571543753147125,
0.22661326825618744,
0.11729515343904495,
-0.34386250376701355,
-0.43505796790122986,
-0.27879199385643005,
0.2605837285518646,
0.04804007709026337,
-0.013468398712575436,
0.8126721978187561,
-0.3253026604652405,
0.9288442730903625,
0.16582158207893372,
0.04580167308449745,
0.2558611333370209,
-0.2768085300922394,
-0.4848388135433197,
0.1408839076757431,
0.4217715561389923,
0.43832826614379883,
0.42400607466697693,
-0.28274208307266235,
-0.17841315269470215,
0.3118925988674164,
0.5720991492271423,
-1.0009212493896484,
-0.2071550041437149,
0.42045581340789795,
-0.27819767594337463,
-0.45313334465026855,
0.3004794120788574,
-0.5282135009765625,
-0.6883955001831055,
-0.5308433175086975,
0.8838403224945068,
-0.36917075514793396,
-0.1844293773174286,
0.6115719676017761,
-0.00356708443723619,
0.068189337849617,
0.4340597689151764,
-1.13962721824646,
0.3991204500198364,
0.703555166721344,
0.9136346578598022,
-0.06698641180992126,
-0.4496804475784302,
-0.5843286514282227,
-0.12257363647222519,
-0.829180121421814,
0.36062857508659363,
-0.2514960765838623,
-0.07205227017402649,
-0.3747682273387909,
0.051251281052827835,
0.15289825201034546,
-0.9537171125411987,
-0.02724253013730049,
-0.28208398818969727,
-0.26944464445114136,
-0.30051857233047485,
-0.4895777702331543,
-0.18792732059955597,
0.0893387719988823,
-0.9658116102218628,
0.802483856678009,
0.11522587388753891,
-0.4976896345615387,
0.5532030463218689,
-0.4217832088470459,
-0.25450146198272705,
0.26722994446754456,
-0.37202200293540955,
-0.5121942162513733,
0.6755418181419373,
-0.1265905648469925,
0.4244740903377533,
0.02289358526468277,
0.5246153473854065,
-0.17645493149757385,
-0.7021538019180298,
0.49982890486717224,
-0.3853904604911804,
0.5875564813613892,
0.038800936192274094,
-0.4986875057220459,
0.058584872633218765,
-0.6785858273506165,
-0.16538546979427338,
0.03477753326296806,
0.11079570651054382,
-0.2716940641403198,
-0.06598348170518875,
-0.07019243389368057,
0.03398699685931206,
0.15324847400188446,
-0.32510414719581604,
0.1265479475259781,
-0.3902084529399872,
0.05680818110704422,
0.6736734509468079,
-0.019965779036283493,
0.5938418507575989,
-0.3326765298843384,
0.16621443629264832,
0.07316173613071442,
0.36590179800987244,
0.20691144466400146,
-0.46526265144348145,
-0.9933577179908752,
0.1482006162405014,
0.1121574267745018,
0.37096038460731506,
-0.7604625225067139,
0.4624882638454437,
-0.1585094928741455,
-0.4386124014854431,
-0.40210214257240295,
0.06888450682163239,
0.24856102466583252,
0.2225242704153061,
0.21227578818798065,
-0.48947229981422424,
-0.42069292068481445,
-0.6085218787193298,
0.05966280400753021,
0.037764836102724075,
0.020298665389418602,
-0.02758442796766758,
0.6605937480926514,
-0.1824326366186142,
0.646478533744812,
-0.4336642920970917,
-0.37571242451667786,
0.14355139434337616,
0.2025199979543686,
-0.15677478909492493,
0.5993909239768982,
0.4398964047431946,
-0.880409836769104,
-0.15314503014087677,
0.07103656977415085,
-1.013375997543335,
-0.004503181204199791,
-0.3457047939300537,
0.019552892073988914,
0.6650959253311157,
0.41435492038726807,
-0.48438891768455505,
0.777753472328186,
0.6290030479431152,
-0.40857651829719543,
0.21944794058799744,
-0.2624497413635254,
0.22583171725273132,
-0.5240389108657837,
-0.14994341135025024,
0.06782324612140656,
0.23127833008766174,
-0.6108306050300598,
0.11362100392580032,
0.1073533147573471,
-0.19835048913955688,
-0.40674856305122375,
0.5017874240875244,
-0.20958316326141357,
-0.30395641922950745,
-0.24778389930725098,
-0.2536272704601288,
0.11440292000770569,
0.40298524498939514,
0.16732576489448547,
0.7686836123466492,
0.5406747460365295,
-0.5156750082969666,
0.3782755434513092,
-0.03570359945297241,
-0.5757375359535217,
0.33378955721855164,
-0.6018430590629578,
0.12124109268188477,
-0.27373212575912476,
-0.22315235435962677,
-0.8595572710037231,
-0.3707939088344574,
0.4259586036205292,
-0.314420610666275,
0.06407403945922852,
0.0016711166827008128,
-0.5657304525375366,
-0.06544707715511322,
-0.08515390008687973,
0.6182100772857666,
0.29153570532798767,
-0.24826224148273468,
0.31383660435676575,
0.28758248686790466,
-0.08714106678962708,
-0.4574643075466156,
-0.6178656220436096,
-0.06784772127866745,
-0.11535938829183578,
-0.6549862623214722,
0.0018266334664076567,
-0.22428660094738007,
-0.7284046411514282,
-0.33305472135543823,
-0.3769861161708832,
-0.23495936393737793,
0.131919726729393,
0.29163989424705505,
0.16100244224071503,
0.12254894524812698,
0.5262194871902466,
-0.40587714314460754,
-0.0816100686788559,
0.18037135899066925,
-0.19266808032989502,
0.8483395576477051,
-0.23991498351097107,
-0.48807817697525024,
-0.43460023403167725,
0.2578440010547638,
0.57486492395401,
-0.07124662399291992,
0.698976457118988,
0.6977925300598145,
-0.6800117492675781,
0.10108499974012375,
-0.6435312032699585,
-0.48001188039779663,
-0.4662870168685913,
0.6851908564567566,
-0.5044496059417725,
-0.47658705711364746,
0.4121525287628174,
0.4889141619205475,
-0.23038792610168457,
0.3617425858974457,
0.43803152441978455,
0.1382380723953247,
1.037753701210022,
0.585245668888092,
0.20001435279846191,
0.30853304266929626,
-0.4106419086456299,
0.23171985149383545,
-0.2793219983577728,
-0.4415161907672882,
-0.2640368640422821,
-0.19637440145015717,
-0.14065997302532196,
-0.5060272216796875,
0.1262875497341156,
0.051705487072467804,
-0.3797963857650757,
0.20032796263694763,
-0.6714630722999573,
0.7800617814064026,
0.2360256463289261,
0.383956640958786,
0.33572712540626526,
0.40623244643211365,
0.773034393787384,
-0.33904051780700684,
-0.4894203543663025,
-0.2961830198764801,
0.8024758696556091,
0.23715123534202576,
0.9100444912910461,
0.13391955196857452,
0.3859326243400574,
0.3106657564640045,
0.02788403071463108,
-1.0060948133468628,
0.5798282623291016,
-0.29035940766334534,
-0.3206855058670044,
-0.7874473929405212,
-0.740638256072998,
-0.7056646943092346,
0.17381809651851654,
-0.2209712415933609,
-0.6604699492454529,
0.5042968988418579,
0.2265663594007492,
-0.2547188103199005,
0.3411974012851715,
-0.6097363829612732,
1.0421411991119385,
-0.49338775873184204,
-0.3768692910671234,
-0.476254403591156,
-0.311684250831604,
0.22420085966587067,
-0.4393655061721802,
0.013551299460232258,
-0.08896438032388687,
0.023845957592129707,
0.6861531734466553,
-0.3949074447154999,
0.9944117665290833,
0.016989700496196747,
-0.5238555669784546,
0.04134280979633331,
0.24586696922779083,
0.4551692605018616,
-0.03552247956395149,
0.03696903586387634,
0.5266042351722717,
-0.12967826426029205,
-0.553174614906311,
-0.6925401091575623,
0.4579758048057556,
-0.8472598195075989,
-0.3557320833206177,
-0.30647075176239014,
-0.6942286491394043,
-0.016743753105401993,
-0.12044279277324677,
0.6540327668190002,
0.7334542274475098,
0.000922622624784708,
0.27928078174591064,
0.9648022651672363,
-0.22633032500743866,
0.21604371070861816,
0.06428859382867813,
-0.3721897304058075,
-0.3389550745487213,
1.2736669778823853,
0.6105092167854309,
0.519906222820282,
0.3048623502254486,
-0.05407794937491417,
-0.046262990683317184,
-0.5279322862625122,
-0.3136242628097534,
0.0856599435210228,
-0.6942574977874756,
-0.15382426977157593,
-0.5103863477706909,
-0.3014320731163025,
-0.614644467830658,
-0.209457665681839,
-0.4215916395187378,
-0.3118373155593872,
-0.31938204169273376,
0.049391042441129684,
0.5109722018241882,
0.758948802947998,
-0.019404998049139977,
0.1626419723033905,
-0.5364667177200317,
0.5885015726089478,
0.5309046506881714,
0.45664921402931213,
0.2433425933122635,
-0.6845566034317017,
-0.48233452439308167,
0.027497991919517517,
0.06350184231996536,
-0.6652964949607849,
0.41752636432647705,
-0.15605667233467102,
0.060476481914520264,
0.5229629278182983,
0.06557490676641464,
0.9211630821228027,
-0.1745622456073761,
0.4293566048145294,
0.37556153535842896,
-1.2545106410980225,
0.21313704550266266,
0.003969328012317419,
0.28539249300956726,
0.4672953188419342,
0.16526684165000916,
-0.5986298322677612,
-0.40422970056533813,
-0.7133132219314575,
-0.8215625882148743,
0.5850017666816711,
0.3113200068473816,
0.1260751336812973,
0.08698879182338715,
-0.0032377690076828003,
0.02815617248415947,
0.17799951136112213,
-0.7137609124183655,
0.15695564448833466,
-0.29539498686790466,
-0.13162483274936676,
-0.0016075395978987217,
-0.2980571687221527,
-0.10578913986682892,
-0.41511714458465576,
0.556172788143158,
-0.004813670180737972,
-0.0961560383439064,
0.09285873174667358,
-0.1666589379310608,
-0.13366179168224335,
-0.08743041753768921,
0.8800110816955566,
1.113530158996582,
-0.30755606293678284,
0.12258438020944595,
0.39620769023895264,
-0.7803447246551514,
0.16115759313106537,
-0.38456404209136963,
-0.00765298493206501,
0.05806499719619751,
0.1688893586397171,
0.7555667757987976,
-0.01644587703049183,
-0.7551663517951965,
0.5416330099105835,
0.1180633082985878,
-0.27883854508399963,
-0.5425798892974854,
-0.05791112780570984,
-0.2749796509742737,
0.07394947111606598,
0.4320974051952362,
0.2932440936565399,
0.26891154050827026,
-0.38423508405685425,
0.07504431158304214,
0.11357957124710083,
-0.4959263801574707,
0.05248942971229553,
0.3654665946960449,
0.03666200861334801,
-0.21683920919895172,
0.8401665687561035,
-0.19813723862171173,
-0.018475374206900597,
1.1271573305130005,
0.2829626202583313,
0.6841972470283508,
0.042122870683670044,
0.3054528534412384,
0.32006898522377014,
0.5434818267822266,
-0.5722593665122986,
0.33151715993881226,
0.21379828453063965,
-0.889991283416748,
-0.7474855184555054,
-0.32365405559539795,
-0.39769408106803894,
0.30115631222724915,
-0.7842027544975281,
0.10272803902626038,
-0.3768696188926697,
-0.2356245517730713,
0.04726193845272064,
-0.1458306461572647,
-0.32528719305992126,
0.18646609783172607,
0.30222684144973755,
0.570754885673523,
-0.9108149409294128,
0.5385960340499878,
0.4545402526855469,
-0.6825162768363953,
-0.5084823369979858,
-0.23261527717113495,
-0.233888179063797,
-0.5366039872169495,
0.9182710647583008,
0.21429772675037384,
-0.1264464408159256,
-0.07786594331264496,
-0.805978536605835,
-0.6944825649261475,
0.7796477675437927,
0.4130047559738159,
-0.6852745413780212,
0.2680877149105072,
0.30875036120414734,
0.3488524854183197,
-0.06946342438459396,
-0.286907821893692,
0.32287946343421936,
0.5306758284568787,
0.23075060546398163,
-0.8268817663192749,
0.07729621231555939,
-0.1345318853855133,
0.11698367446660995,
0.40131500363349915,
-0.5369350910186768,
0.8792475461959839,
-0.32844337821006775,
-0.17361100018024445,
0.28540855646133423,
0.30142900347709656,
0.3357376456260681,
0.4315188229084015,
0.3765426576137543,
0.6906448006629944,
0.7863303422927856,
-0.18645770847797394,
0.7573750019073486,
-0.07345680147409439,
0.36232760548591614,
0.9854883551597595,
-0.36513304710388184,
0.7089658975601196,
0.6302080154418945,
-0.12582755088806152,
-0.3765721917152405,
0.4318278729915619,
-0.43881720304489136,
0.2672789990901947,
0.5704063773155212,
-0.2974405586719513,
-0.28887939453125,
0.0011588499182835221,
-0.4857735335826874,
0.2963162362575531,
0.2705019414424896,
-0.17527490854263306,
0.2509489357471466,
0.306720107793808,
-0.16502715647220612,
-0.24435777962207794,
-0.515674352645874,
0.8699702024459839,
-0.10755068808794022,
-0.3308619260787964,
0.7136404514312744,
-0.2769942581653595,
0.32651451230049133,
-0.2285403311252594,
-0.2709386944770813,
-0.5604735612869263,
0.2731538414955139,
-0.3713330030441284,
-0.6786759495735168,
0.5039777755737305,
-0.17459678649902344,
-0.29062792658805847,
-0.10613401234149933,
0.4369666874408722,
-0.3775586187839508,
-0.7566143274307251,
-0.04735298082232475,
0.3205280303955078,
0.5910828709602356,
-0.6616244316101074,
-0.18468622863292694,
0.4865576922893524,
0.04326419159770012,
0.4060898721218109,
0.24686682224273682,
0.6603915095329285,
-0.22839604318141937,
0.544665515422821,
0.38282737135887146,
0.12033554166555405,
-0.023440036922693253,
0.42965227365493774,
0.40461671352386475,
-0.787128746509552,
-0.024958539754152298,
-1.0579911470413208,
0.342081755399704,
-0.2793196737766266,
-0.3075922429561615,
0.5629220008850098,
0.6876457333564758,
1.0543290376663208,
-0.6285408139228821,
0.4011334478855133,
0.11655458807945251,
-0.34272629022598267,
-0.6238030791282654,
0.7312378287315369,
-0.45847204327583313,
0.20306141674518585,
-0.306370347738266,
-1.116951584815979,
-0.5942324995994568,
0.8911007046699524,
-0.2031461000442505,
-0.2522165775299072,
0.5093201398849487,
0.8049802780151367,
0.09899881482124329,
-0.11348801106214523,
0.7883763909339905,
0.1476220041513443,
-0.3364846706390381,
0.46452173590660095,
0.989494800567627,
-0.5393738746643066,
0.5713889598846436,
-0.3900448977947235,
-0.03763430193066597,
-0.30180230736732483,
-0.4478684365749359,
-0.660600483417511,
-0.6896745562553406,
-0.622545599937439,
-0.32824015617370605,
-0.007384157739579678,
0.5366857647895813,
0.8480585217475891,
-0.832879900932312,
-0.5472494959831238,
-0.34023818373680115,
-0.04851353541016579,
-0.2554056942462921,
-0.2599862217903137,
0.21567761898040771,
-0.4462946653366089,
-0.6589382886886597,
-0.1740875244140625,
0.5385711193084717,
0.6008456945419312,
-0.5101270079612732,
-0.014549682848155499,
0.5095192193984985,
-0.11962277442216873,
0.7893738150596619,
0.029961923137307167,
-0.7790905237197876,
-0.025986390188336372,
0.1792454868555069,
-0.15282438695430756,
0.10662927478551865,
0.7457519769668579,
-0.6034033894538879,
0.42022156715393066,
0.5643588900566101,
0.5796300172805786,
0.33451348543167114,
-0.00782800279557705,
0.43780916929244995,
-0.48873022198677063,
0.42653366923332214,
0.05814041197299957,
0.2999120354652405,
0.4075031578540802,
-0.41686439514160156,
0.972621738910675,
0.17555275559425354,
-0.3674997091293335,
-0.8012784123420715,
0.14430341124534607,
-1.113553762435913,
-0.4977666139602661,
1.021691083908081,
0.28732582926750183,
-0.03438486158847809,
-0.09141267836093903,
-0.37658482789993286,
-0.07690045982599258,
-0.1803654432296753,
1.1551308631896973,
0.8137046098709106,
0.14648763835430145,
-0.24185018241405487,
-0.4884461760520935,
0.4572807252407074,
0.4085707664489746,
-0.821816623210907,
0.1752203404903412,
0.6807740926742554,
-0.28073379397392273,
0.4937954843044281,
0.49259963631629944,
-0.13751119375228882,
0.24611233174800873,
0.28776273131370544,
0.3581453561782837,
0.3919314444065094,
-0.628592312335968,
-0.5180898904800415,
0.09620386362075806,
0.047034852206707,
-0.05675402656197548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01364v1
|
Improving Cross-lingual Representation for Semantic Retrieval with Code-switching
| 2024-03-03T01:47:52 | 2024-03-03T01:47:52 |
Mieradilijiang Maimaiti, Yuanhang Zheng, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Yue Zhang, Wenpei Luo, Kaiyu Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Semantic Retrieval (SR) has become an indispensable part of the FAQ system in
the task-oriented question-answering (QA) dialogue scenario. The demands for a
cross-lingual smart-customer-service system for an e-commerce platform or some
particular business conditions have been increasing recently. Most previous
studies exploit cross-lingual pre-trained models (PTMs) for multi-lingual
knowledge retrieval directly, while some others also leverage the continual
pre-training before fine-tuning PTMs on the downstream tasks. However, no
matter which schema is used, the previous work ignores to inform PTMs of some
features of the downstream task, i.e. train their PTMs without providing any
signals related to SR. To this end, in this work, we propose an Alternative
Cross-lingual PTM for SR via code-switching. We are the first to utilize the
code-switching approach for cross-lingual SR. Besides, we introduce the novel
code-switched continual pre-training instead of directly using the PTMs on the
SR tasks. The experimental results show that our proposed approach consistently
outperforms the previous SOTA methods on SR and semantic textual similarity
(STS) tasks with three business corpora and four open datasets in 20+
languages.
|
[
-0.4447990357875824,
-0.4551115334033966,
0.15039843320846558,
0.2815937101840973,
-0.4075046479701996,
0.13231520354747772,
-0.18788596987724304,
-0.5002061128616333,
0.3924335539340973,
0.7613162398338318,
-0.7186736464500427,
-0.5876766443252563,
-0.30064618587493896,
0.27764177322387695,
-0.3591591715812683,
1.030805230140686,
-0.2042444944381714,
0.3820655941963196,
-0.05118563771247864,
-0.12292291224002838,
-0.2773955464363098,
-0.6893501281738281,
-0.34897565841674805,
-0.21324127912521362,
0.49615731835365295,
0.42661240696907043,
0.649189829826355,
-0.005218943115323782,
0.10108556598424911,
0.1390482783317566,
0.40655457973480225,
0.03220750391483307,
-0.49510258436203003,
-0.24139752984046936,
-0.4311487376689911,
-0.5719118118286133,
-0.06242768466472626,
-0.2456205040216446,
0.40489691495895386,
0.6916301250457764,
0.0865701213479042,
0.08260796964168549,
-0.21738678216934204,
0.6534198522567749,
-0.6250792145729065,
0.24405692517757416,
-0.8661816120147705,
0.26694613695144653,
-0.09838764369487762,
-0.43571558594703674,
-0.6694157719612122,
-0.11450125277042389,
0.39505884051322937,
-0.8120091557502747,
0.06255672872066498,
0.10850504040718079,
1.1830271482467651,
-0.005655583925545216,
-0.41829198598861694,
-0.15231290459632874,
-0.606162965297699,
0.7546438574790955,
-0.34250378608703613,
1.0172110795974731,
0.28432831168174744,
0.17068041861057281,
0.2929501235485077,
-0.7440065741539001,
-0.3982832729816437,
-0.10010944306850433,
-0.1315823644399643,
0.2685583531856537,
-0.2250562161207199,
-0.39925408363342285,
-0.01931692101061344,
-0.05717041715979576,
-0.6229133009910583,
-0.22279641032218933,
-0.0940568670630455,
-0.3291228115558624,
0.30926838517189026,
0.04729849100112915,
0.38651376962661743,
-0.007558653596788645,
-0.8153635859489441,
-0.03652561828494072,
-0.8469786047935486,
-0.058256689459085464,
0.17699940502643585,
0.39422208070755005,
0.3089185953140259,
0.30640536546707153,
-0.34104183316230774,
0.620161771774292,
0.2942485809326172,
0.14627990126609802,
0.36771172285079956,
-0.5979666709899902,
-0.1692754626274109,
0.14671678841114044,
0.46986475586891174,
0.21022264659404755,
0.3300219178199768,
-0.5604249835014343,
-0.05115242674946785,
0.12430870532989502,
0.3492532968521118,
-0.5357421636581421,
-0.17094270884990692,
-0.2550942599773407,
-0.48259246349334717,
0.22826828062534332,
0.02785751037299633,
-0.6871119141578674,
0.3263451159000397,
-0.33376678824424744,
0.47159889340400696,
-0.44934484362602234,
-0.46376195549964905,
0.26528504490852356,
0.170094832777977,
0.5182478427886963,
0.0965372622013092,
-0.6162326335906982,
0.43661096692085266,
0.4770491421222687,
0.3475590944290161,
-0.25513705611228943,
-0.47453439235687256,
-0.6000916957855225,
0.2657671272754669,
-0.3882969617843628,
0.7343097925186157,
-0.7356335520744324,
-0.3829309344291687,
0.07271843403577805,
0.2157667726278305,
-0.3781098425388336,
-0.7350066900253296,
0.12362875044345856,
-1.22396981716156,
0.40464305877685547,
-0.2399233877658844,
-0.22783292829990387,
-0.08471640944480896,
0.4116186797618866,
-0.5545041561126709,
1.0100423097610474,
0.06875607371330261,
-0.7428399920463562,
0.42562153935432434,
-0.20638960599899292,
-0.5648266673088074,
-0.03344201296567917,
-0.22798167169094086,
-0.4267120063304901,
-0.33530187606811523,
0.1503794938325882,
0.13880887627601624,
-0.11673419922590256,
-0.12697578966617584,
-0.018257593736052513,
-0.469383180141449,
0.01879894733428955,
0.010818909853696823,
0.5942263007164001,
0.3097696304321289,
-0.44383707642555237,
-0.06480719149112701,
-0.38565927743911743,
0.41395729780197144,
-0.04535838961601257,
-0.3022586405277252,
-0.7890048623085022,
-0.3992733657360077,
0.17786502838134766,
0.7290349006652832,
0.46746838092803955,
-0.4030594229698181,
0.01815856248140335,
-0.26712512969970703,
-0.08399728685617447,
0.27474647760391235,
-0.18868516385555267,
0.4088633954524994,
-0.15808044373989105,
0.7855507135391235,
0.3107370436191559,
0.20712359249591827,
0.197713702917099,
-0.418635755777359,
-0.7212725877761841,
-0.10217427462339401,
0.5136464238166809,
0.7755235433578491,
-1.4490638971328735,
0.15345005691051483,
-0.5094645023345947,
-0.3946816027164459,
-0.4482234716415405,
0.19009147584438324,
0.8143118619918823,
0.14965811371803284,
0.582957923412323,
-0.5749958753585815,
-0.5215150117874146,
-0.6239621043205261,
-0.6807929277420044,
-0.18367476761341095,
0.21507206559181213,
0.2935841381549835,
0.29913896322250366,
-0.40473994612693787,
1.215051531791687,
-0.4355728328227997,
-0.2742350697517395,
-0.5529614090919495,
0.17461897432804108,
-0.050478316843509674,
0.33442988991737366,
0.37636780738830566,
-1.179565668106079,
-0.7837144136428833,
0.0350029282271862,
-0.22519192099571228,
-0.2889748811721802,
-0.22812892496585846,
-0.5199664831161499,
0.6923326849937439,
0.6643235683441162,
-0.6486459970474243,
0.36605730652809143,
0.37941688299179077,
-0.44310781359672546,
0.68907630443573,
-0.009032857604324818,
0.4151099622249603,
-0.7569590210914612,
0.19153828918933868,
-0.29051098227500916,
-0.21975064277648926,
-0.5863239169120789,
-0.11091288924217224,
0.40487411618232727,
-0.09826973080635071,
-0.7339279055595398,
0.5604437589645386,
-0.5243656635284424,
-0.4615436792373657,
0.04985305666923523,
0.145284503698349,
0.2582356929779053,
0.7957656383514404,
0.413307249546051,
0.6860329508781433,
0.19443289935588837,
-0.7213150262832642,
-0.07047322392463684,
0.41113296151161194,
-0.19261130690574646,
0.5476632714271545,
-0.2843310236930847,
0.0633716732263565,
-0.01796334981918335,
0.27933579683303833,
-0.6391292214393616,
0.49714112281799316,
0.47064971923828125,
-0.4000711143016815,
0.17821577191352844,
-0.42870065569877625,
-0.6627567410469055,
0.041464995592832565,
0.11574283987283707,
0.5344657897949219,
0.18745367228984833,
-0.5372036695480347,
0.6960539221763611,
0.182399183511734,
-0.2516355812549591,
-0.5103159546852112,
-0.7688314914703369,
0.16242456436157227,
-0.024211252108216286,
-0.5948771238327026,
0.6605349779129028,
-0.03035779669880867,
0.1420622318983078,
0.18819668889045715,
-0.48187991976737976,
-0.2020266205072403,
-0.2673834264278412,
-0.3314315378665924,
0.5621613264083862,
-0.2194257229566574,
0.2532377541065216,
0.04468105360865593,
-0.43071383237838745,
-0.07126322388648987,
-0.7074452638626099,
0.7768142223358154,
-0.20513002574443817,
-0.43940219283103943,
-0.085770383477211,
0.47420892119407654,
0.12270094454288483,
-0.6346552968025208,
0.4104626178741455,
0.47914403676986694,
-0.1042705625295639,
-0.10436604171991348,
-0.38663992285728455,
-0.01854652911424637,
-0.40483880043029785,
0.5286805033683777,
-0.5776245594024658,
-0.9402583241462708,
0.39398959279060364,
-0.2056027203798294,
-0.13618029654026031,
0.15894442796707153,
0.4720616042613983,
0.2872519791126251,
0.9362735748291016,
0.6299022436141968,
0.21849200129508972,
0.6098095774650574,
-0.04499014839529991,
0.5579519271850586,
-0.2785550355911255,
-0.3906363844871521,
-0.6075443625450134,
0.15413761138916016,
-0.3719625174999237,
-0.6791148781776428,
0.3363349735736847,
0.07884419709444046,
-0.2003902643918991,
0.5653757452964783,
-0.028508298099040985,
0.1866661161184311,
0.24435880780220032,
0.06544719636440277,
0.5892350673675537,
0.026237456128001213,
-0.28057706356048584,
-0.09545737504959106,
-0.8804081678390503,
-0.07469044625759125,
0.7255534529685974,
-0.020343756303191185,
1.000890851020813,
-0.008028694428503513,
0.7929820418357849,
0.03320835903286934,
0.11166711896657944,
-0.5147252082824707,
0.7656710743904114,
-0.4556214511394501,
-0.46526017785072327,
-0.21552921831607819,
-0.720927894115448,
-1.0585929155349731,
0.5300709009170532,
0.06648137420415878,
-0.23203779757022858,
0.30643895268440247,
-0.04037459194660187,
-0.20309050381183624,
0.1560743898153305,
-0.8803703784942627,
1.109858512878418,
-0.47103068232536316,
-0.21191884577274323,
-0.21033425629138947,
-0.7668269276618958,
-0.044838763773441315,
0.028600789606571198,
0.1608804166316986,
0.15926146507263184,
-0.20063401758670807,
0.6665910482406616,
-0.3353487253189087,
0.8502079248428345,
-0.17447547614574432,
-0.22410044074058533,
0.10285752266645432,
0.1368609070777893,
0.39404213428497314,
0.003669807454571128,
0.19967728853225708,
0.21872325241565704,
0.29010525345802307,
-0.42732349038124084,
-0.7076138257980347,
0.5682144165039062,
-0.5848193764686584,
-0.5026885867118835,
-0.451526015996933,
-0.4480738937854767,
-0.7060492634773254,
0.44285255670547485,
0.22283118963241577,
0.3419029116630554,
-0.10447277873754501,
-0.07658935338258743,
0.9097915887832642,
-0.31820550560951233,
0.0033661341294646263,
0.8726544976234436,
-0.48387086391448975,
-0.08933009952306747,
1.0083255767822266,
0.15234160423278809,
0.5177450776100159,
0.7872436046600342,
-0.2141251415014267,
-0.5109222531318665,
0.00673946738243103,
-0.5233134627342224,
0.2074904441833496,
-0.7324411869049072,
-0.12303073704242706,
-0.9195001125335693,
-0.0032628437038511038,
-0.6062417030334473,
-0.06074228137731552,
-0.43684646487236023,
-0.2575841248035431,
-0.2719048857688904,
0.21004442870616913,
0.29010021686553955,
0.1462140530347824,
0.20420725643634796,
-0.34344327449798584,
-1.1097973585128784,
0.5447734594345093,
0.2695184051990509,
0.6149430274963379,
-0.15060733258724213,
-0.3375084102153778,
-0.5080313086509705,
-0.09938502311706543,
0.22423410415649414,
-0.7290888428688049,
0.4026639759540558,
0.12554609775543213,
0.7087564468383789,
0.0978570431470871,
0.30020663142204285,
0.7857856750488281,
-0.45437145233154297,
0.5093649625778198,
0.33595010638237,
-1.0188833475112915,
0.21493873000144958,
-0.017046188935637474,
0.48637789487838745,
0.7217979431152344,
0.7316870093345642,
-0.8553962111473083,
-0.1953429877758026,
-0.4243001341819763,
-0.936926007270813,
0.7152041792869568,
-0.00961571279913187,
0.14511904120445251,
-0.12156187742948532,
-0.16466957330703735,
0.43613526225090027,
0.21700745820999146,
-0.6393634676933289,
-0.2521134316921234,
-0.5987226366996765,
-0.09017691761255264,
0.21697819232940674,
0.1304493397474289,
0.17941007018089294,
-0.09120945632457733,
0.7406547665596008,
-0.28539973497390747,
0.33014512062072754,
0.29489865899086,
-0.5049422979354858,
0.032673899084329605,
0.4977291226387024,
0.08450482040643692,
0.6436867713928223,
0.19995300471782684,
0.07201320677995682,
0.14593316614627838,
-0.3357827663421631,
-0.1607179194688797,
0.12867121398448944,
-0.1683698445558548,
0.33389565348625183,
-0.14326989650726318,
0.6801103949546814,
0.7854343056678772,
-0.9689225554466248,
0.3905276954174042,
-0.0589340478181839,
-0.10921761393547058,
-0.23140420019626617,
-0.18320468068122864,
0.10353990644216537,
0.160689577460289,
0.32964932918548584,
0.10003583878278732,
0.041697658598423004,
-0.7178922295570374,
0.4658833146095276,
0.24472643435001373,
-0.4412248730659485,
-0.015293524600565434,
0.2689599394798279,
0.17785701155662537,
-0.11146055907011032,
0.5262816548347473,
-0.17560969293117523,
-0.7437251806259155,
0.3793223798274994,
0.6694326400756836,
0.7084155678749084,
0.04777013882994652,
0.3987855017185211,
-0.15253853797912598,
0.1327512562274933,
0.06508751958608627,
0.5152952671051025,
-0.13747812807559967,
-0.816261351108551,
-0.33722853660583496,
-0.25294703245162964,
-0.3738626539707184,
-0.4453505575656891,
-0.8845020532608032,
0.32288724184036255,
-0.18250301480293274,
0.04694114997982979,
-0.6239600777626038,
0.004964972380548716,
-0.7973213791847229,
0.3025481104850769,
-0.022195324301719666,
1.1107161045074463,
-0.4428839385509491,
1.1223726272583008,
0.801328718662262,
-0.36040619015693665,
-0.5980093479156494,
0.29872390627861023,
-0.4989691972732544,
-0.7659255862236023,
0.8853105306625366,
-0.12255383282899857,
-0.4800972044467926,
0.14719080924987793,
-0.16270379722118378,
-0.734343409538269,
0.9353936314582825,
0.21772980690002441,
-0.38477736711502075,
-0.06459570676088333,
0.42735904455184937,
0.5525006651878357,
-0.44552093744277954,
0.04194903373718262,
0.5201592445373535,
0.26968851685523987,
-0.09953702241182327,
-0.9169133901596069,
-0.0671006515622139,
-0.4972899854183197,
0.15647199749946594,
0.14588864147663116,
-0.7446209192276001,
0.7096087336540222,
-0.05823446810245514,
-0.2926204204559326,
-0.013324095867574215,
0.5587259531021118,
0.3426605463027954,
0.3304930329322815,
0.8433780670166016,
0.42702990770339966,
0.2723890244960785,
0.01891331374645233,
0.8211354613304138,
-0.48060283064842224,
0.37413203716278076,
1.0320864915847778,
-0.6781619191169739,
0.890436053276062,
0.7029175162315369,
0.08646943420171738,
0.6470295190811157,
0.424148827791214,
0.22574792802333832,
0.7607381939888,
0.0009218068444170058,
0.08057953417301178,
-0.716799795627594,
-0.016269799321889877,
-0.6197522878646851,
0.3355634808540344,
0.1707666963338852,
0.004889282397925854,
-0.3831334412097931,
0.05586183816194534,
0.07717090100049973,
0.018467355519533157,
-0.24622289836406708,
0.6395397186279297,
0.03195346146821976,
-0.7338772416114807,
0.7207953929901123,
0.0031897034496068954,
0.8821088671684265,
-1.071305751800537,
-0.06858713924884796,
-0.2603902816772461,
-0.059954073280096054,
-0.12298823893070221,
-0.3984696865081787,
0.3611566424369812,
0.01288587599992752,
-0.05622686445713043,
-0.7081839442253113,
0.7175163626670837,
-0.6584092974662781,
-0.2522243559360504,
0.7466782331466675,
0.5650519132614136,
-0.0313870944082737,
0.037570297718048096,
-0.8154491782188416,
0.032266706228256226,
0.014011251740157604,
-0.0766596570611,
0.622077465057373,
0.5982871651649475,
-0.3235042095184326,
0.5129939317703247,
0.5487779974937439,
-0.2967015504837036,
0.4506506025791168,
0.2768278419971466,
0.992730438709259,
-0.7747727632522583,
-1.0031790733337402,
-0.09618989378213882,
0.07428433001041412,
0.2311033308506012,
-0.4496610760688782,
0.7510327100753784,
0.5817493200302124,
1.4009933471679688,
-0.3232925236225128,
0.7997176051139832,
-0.0872686356306076,
0.5493956804275513,
-0.7349040508270264,
0.6732181906700134,
-0.7026675939559937,
0.2729516327381134,
-0.42262163758277893,
-0.6092271208763123,
-0.17520588636398315,
0.35745909810066223,
-0.4844033718109131,
0.16609756648540497,
0.7997890710830688,
0.890476644039154,
-0.04519033804535866,
0.07228298485279083,
0.3955019414424896,
0.12653717398643494,
0.02342541143298149,
0.699105441570282,
0.8382145762443542,
-0.4154340922832489,
1.29127836227417,
-0.007493473589420319,
0.03171847015619278,
-0.3633243143558502,
-0.5279489159584045,
-0.6050621271133423,
-0.5536366701126099,
-0.4404154121875763,
-0.3157069981098175,
0.34626254439353943,
0.7749000191688538,
0.6039562821388245,
-0.8896113038063049,
-0.15550290048122406,
0.24560673534870148,
0.05204346403479576,
-0.587518036365509,
-0.23196333646774292,
0.11352964490652084,
-0.5151312351226807,
-0.6531432271003723,
0.17373204231262207,
0.2813754677772522,
-0.3555821478366852,
-0.2320486158132553,
-0.30032235383987427,
-0.4925917983055115,
-0.02952103689312935,
0.5755120515823364,
0.41370829939842224,
-0.4778623580932617,
-0.21535950899124146,
0.4583340585231781,
-0.3888718783855438,
-0.003921628929674625,
1.1271302700042725,
-1.0462396144866943,
0.15110495686531067,
0.6676383018493652,
0.9541727900505066,
0.5135572552680969,
-0.3985881805419922,
0.4921741187572479,
-0.5309727191925049,
-0.05667940527200699,
0.3872668147087097,
0.2100527286529541,
0.12412695586681366,
-0.25286412239074707,
0.2895274758338928,
0.39954882860183716,
-0.12845860421657562,
-0.31828054785728455,
0.475806325674057,
-0.8866344690322876,
-0.4892604351043701,
1.1201294660568237,
-0.3860832750797272,
-0.10169896483421326,
-0.8612087965011597,
-0.14270444214344025,
0.1671077013015747,
-0.2162182331085205,
0.7202471494674683,
0.4225020706653595,
-0.17591175436973572,
-0.20110739767551422,
-0.14435799419879913,
0.27208051085472107,
0.9439662098884583,
-0.8081079721450806,
-0.054685771465301514,
0.22868113219738007,
0.3762204647064209,
0.13830265402793884,
0.8757789731025696,
-0.5004297494888306,
0.5347582697868347,
-0.24174939095973969,
0.13314661383628845,
0.15242217481136322,
-0.45387759804725647,
-0.016687985509634018,
0.05280335247516632,
-0.26863738894462585,
-0.06134685128927231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01342v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01342v1
|
LM4OPT: Unveiling the Potential of Large Language Models in Formulating Mathematical Optimization Problems
| 2024-03-02T23:32:33 | 2024-03-02T23:32:33 |
Tasnim Ahmed, Salimur Choudhury
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
In the rapidly evolving field of natural language processing, the translation
of linguistic descriptions into mathematical formulation of optimization
problems presents a formidable challenge, demanding intricate understanding and
processing capabilities from Large Language Models (LLMs). This study compares
prominent LLMs, including GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and Llama-2-7b, in zero-shot and
one-shot settings for this task. Our findings show GPT-4's superior
performance, particularly in the one-shot scenario. A central part of this
research is the introduction of `LM4OPT,' a progressive fine-tuning framework
for Llama-2-7b that utilizes noisy embeddings and specialized datasets.
However, this research highlights a notable gap in the contextual understanding
capabilities of smaller models such as Llama-2-7b compared to larger
counterparts, especially in processing lengthy and complex input contexts. Our
empirical investigation, utilizing the NL4Opt dataset, unveils that GPT-4
surpasses the baseline performance established by previous research, achieving
an F1-score of 0.63, solely based on the problem description in natural
language, and without relying on any additional named entity information.
GPT-3.5 follows closely, both outperforming the fine-tuned Llama-2-7b. These
findings not only benchmark the current capabilities of LLMs in a novel
application area but also lay the groundwork for future improvements in
mathematical formulation of optimization problems from natural language input.
|
[
-0.4345468580722809,
-0.9686689376831055,
0.960051417350769,
0.40728551149368286,
-0.3121449649333954,
0.03882093355059624,
-0.47745048999786377,
-0.5173389911651611,
-0.2093936949968338,
0.34200412034988403,
-0.5485329031944275,
-0.2801646292209625,
-0.5575321316719055,
0.5279672145843506,
-0.059131547808647156,
1.0048166513442993,
-0.3990696370601654,
-0.0597592368721962,
-0.14318665862083435,
0.15434587001800537,
-0.30241870880126953,
-0.41708049178123474,
-0.7517440319061279,
-0.48890990018844604,
0.37352293729782104,
-0.041929010301828384,
0.819121778011322,
0.7181518077850342,
0.8133075833320618,
0.2644619345664978,
0.030803674831986427,
-0.03226820006966591,
-0.650726318359375,
-0.10793764889240265,
0.0054156165570020676,
-0.36487486958503723,
-0.34480395913124084,
-0.10781065374612808,
0.7574889659881592,
0.577653169631958,
-0.20541827380657196,
0.06757733225822449,
-0.03587616607546806,
0.6594580411911011,
-0.4535917341709137,
0.42208048701286316,
-0.8181411623954773,
0.34651556611061096,
-0.20828311145305634,
-0.24811646342277527,
0.0023307318333536386,
-0.37114983797073364,
0.14247660338878632,
-0.8611830472946167,
0.06769529730081558,
-0.16438305377960205,
0.8475627899169922,
0.7416893243789673,
0.020149586722254753,
-0.34288647770881653,
-0.5904245972633362,
0.9556961059570312,
-0.9724839329719543,
0.1444375067949295,
0.3354075253009796,
0.25709444284439087,
-0.17809517681598663,
-0.5989634990692139,
-0.4034782350063324,
-0.1318032294511795,
0.3041536509990692,
0.09349431097507477,
-0.4675291180610657,
0.2663177251815796,
0.36944475769996643,
0.24605198204517365,
-0.47315701842308044,
0.27990421652793884,
-0.3571566343307495,
-0.2101108282804489,
0.46037736535072327,
0.02096918784081936,
-0.17848500609397888,
-0.0022325755562633276,
-0.27455049753189087,
0.24872048199176788,
-0.7306054830551147,
-0.2468322366476059,
0.2553557753562927,
0.2526070773601532,
0.04975481331348419,
0.5094091892242432,
-0.2109554260969162,
0.7929814457893372,
-0.22033897042274475,
-0.3946351110935211,
0.1935408115386963,
-0.4668605923652649,
-0.23039761185646057,
-0.1435905545949936,
0.5513095259666443,
0.293684720993042,
0.39460137486457825,
-0.05706333369016647,
-0.39201030135154724,
0.13919290900230408,
0.0018066412303596735,
-0.8272700309753418,
-0.03742612898349762,
-0.056788504123687744,
-0.10899427533149719,
-0.2664889097213745,
-0.2998480796813965,
-0.6751148700714111,
0.11906707286834717,
-0.5438699722290039,
0.5184515118598938,
-0.2582593858242035,
0.05633939802646637,
0.3637099862098694,
0.24274413287639618,
0.29674047231674194,
0.3083899915218353,
-0.7757890820503235,
0.33650103211402893,
0.8817565441131592,
1.034887433052063,
-0.3054714798927307,
-0.03341641649603844,
-0.32578447461128235,
0.1301717460155487,
-0.5224375128746033,
0.6203126311302185,
-0.5358357429504395,
-0.15336140990257263,
-0.13347218930721283,
-0.6335002779960632,
-0.06843461841344833,
-0.5650970935821533,
0.7297030687332153,
-0.38989073038101196,
0.11179295182228088,
-0.21925301849842072,
-0.4677667021751404,
-0.35567715764045715,
0.43087753653526306,
-0.5754228830337524,
1.102765679359436,
0.24011284112930298,
-0.5043337941169739,
0.1104762852191925,
-0.9315283298492432,
-0.17390449345111847,
0.043894167989492416,
-0.20821519196033478,
-0.6302843689918518,
0.295392781496048,
0.2242271602153778,
0.3279363811016083,
-0.5448856353759766,
0.12294507026672363,
-0.30972906947135925,
-0.30085909366607666,
-0.15215785801410675,
-0.5333727598190308,
0.24510784447193146,
0.24015973508358002,
-0.4103242754936218,
-0.05635785683989525,
-0.4799824655056,
0.18568366765975952,
0.4952828288078308,
-0.42955586314201355,
0.0026451083831489086,
-0.04508214816451073,
-0.4978981018066406,
0.16076481342315674,
0.5048732161521912,
-0.2280610352754593,
0.2663586139678955,
-0.5873203873634338,
0.7055906057357788,
0.7784509658813477,
0.00873852614313364,
0.245550274848938,
-0.0538846030831337,
0.9138435125350952,
-0.49467933177948,
0.1075810045003891,
-0.10586750507354736,
-0.6415726542472839,
-0.5454288721084595,
-0.12031836062669754,
0.2527309060096741,
0.5281354188919067,
-0.6499263644218445,
-0.010531757026910782,
-0.13435953855514526,
-0.10568501055240631,
-0.29793116450309753,
0.2870634198188782,
0.37705162167549133,
0.5761313438415527,
0.38120028376579285,
0.08214954286813736,
-0.4509487450122833,
-1.1255098581314087,
-0.2759968936443329,
0.14593231678009033,
0.06781613826751709,
0.3118878901004791,
0.4632987678050995,
-0.15903545916080475,
0.8030058741569519,
-0.5971619486808777,
-0.38125401735305786,
-0.2848929464817047,
-0.05502113699913025,
0.4421597719192505,
0.18072985112667084,
0.5646899342536926,
-0.5639455318450928,
-0.535574197769165,
0.2337506115436554,
-0.6997779011726379,
-0.30274564027786255,
0.18872661888599396,
-0.01676282472908497,
0.08653246611356735,
0.16527976095676422,
-0.5686896443367004,
0.2327718287706375,
0.6555378437042236,
0.2801564037799835,
0.5130456686019897,
-0.14569351077079773,
-0.3157398998737335,
-0.7348734736442566,
-0.18999968469142914,
-0.07804574817419052,
-0.1148916631937027,
-0.5078621506690979,
0.11936181038618088,
-0.10707234591245651,
-0.1300692856311798,
-0.35063639283180237,
0.333242803812027,
-0.5419776439666748,
-0.3393493890762329,
-0.056973736733198166,
0.2697053551673889,
-0.1897399127483368,
0.6497076153755188,
-0.12550033628940582,
0.8683643937110901,
0.4817286729812622,
-0.38003218173980713,
0.21256093680858612,
0.049092330038547516,
-0.15023410320281982,
-0.0004255792882759124,
-0.7346621751785278,
0.33466750383377075,
0.060682233422994614,
0.20983067154884338,
-0.698440432548523,
-0.18358716368675232,
0.15954168140888214,
-0.15068930387496948,
0.050727177411317825,
0.018803829327225685,
-0.6313450932502747,
-0.39639022946357727,
-0.5377528667449951,
0.6173964142799377,
0.3320997953414917,
-0.2016540914773941,
0.36508870124816895,
0.08599178493022919,
-0.3129325807094574,
-0.5175395011901855,
-0.3539201021194458,
0.015929101034998894,
-0.4120194613933563,
-0.49989765882492065,
0.4310762286186218,
-0.10818098485469818,
-0.13338863849639893,
-0.14863908290863037,
-0.30662021040916443,
0.048026833683252335,
0.07609038800001144,
-0.30247238278388977,
0.08173025399446487,
-0.37769070267677307,
-0.0026720277965068817,
-0.05005154386162758,
-0.33245763182640076,
0.022179940715432167,
-0.24820014834403992,
0.6204056143760681,
-0.2451065182685852,
-0.184774249792099,
-0.2983277142047882,
0.23465502262115479,
0.16508062183856964,
-0.3906324803829193,
0.29620569944381714,
0.4102787673473358,
-0.4932728707790375,
-0.14436019957065582,
-0.35445958375930786,
-0.11688975989818573,
-0.4906885027885437,
0.4518112540245056,
-0.6414859890937805,
-0.8576890826225281,
0.33112913370132446,
-0.14339296519756317,
0.10698748379945755,
0.5009170770645142,
0.715941309928894,
0.29968899488449097,
1.2024831771850586,
0.6429421901702881,
-0.1368737667798996,
0.38992300629615784,
-0.3125670254230499,
0.46498221158981323,
-0.7601536512374878,
0.04666239395737648,
-0.4432637095451355,
-0.32105863094329834,
-0.570576548576355,
-0.557669997215271,
0.6219128966331482,
0.21420659124851227,
-0.23991547524929047,
0.22342275083065033,
-0.4908360242843628,
0.7350603342056274,
0.244820699095726,
-0.25334230065345764,
0.43546101450920105,
0.0942441076040268,
-0.25425559282302856,
-0.1461663693189621,
-0.7044810056686401,
-0.5366665124893188,
1.1219614744186401,
0.42153626680374146,
0.5493050217628479,
0.2615383565425873,
0.5485054850578308,
-0.0592300184071064,
0.2808631956577301,
-0.8411376476287842,
0.4138640761375427,
0.05057139694690704,
-0.5416107773780823,
-0.33103853464126587,
-0.5802907347679138,
-0.9780690670013428,
0.4321560859680176,
0.11947090923786163,
-0.7134037613868713,
-0.3406580686569214,
0.22201615571975708,
-0.3981405794620514,
0.1869843304157257,
-0.5812238454818726,
0.9666957259178162,
-0.5260217785835266,
-0.39886292815208435,
-0.06340618431568146,
-0.4215746819972992,
0.3422345221042633,
-0.5492569804191589,
0.39748284220695496,
-0.5157003998756409,
-0.4724210798740387,
0.4547393023967743,
-0.24505457282066345,
0.459333598613739,
0.035994525998830795,
-0.4314788579940796,
0.04695536196231842,
0.10905466973781586,
0.5392810106277466,
0.16308873891830444,
-0.3466932475566864,
0.337506502866745,
-0.10105767101049423,
-0.3927532136440277,
-0.5507540702819824,
0.7971823215484619,
-0.7973381280899048,
-0.5832139849662781,
-0.2557832896709442,
-0.4812732934951782,
-0.3248664140701294,
0.35128211975097656,
0.3788459300994873,
0.2389838993549347,
0.11389683187007904,
0.11367401480674744,
0.29240715503692627,
-0.13747747242450714,
0.54380202293396,
0.2338225543498993,
-0.23789528012275696,
-0.24944321811199188,
0.855354905128479,
0.09930522739887238,
0.3960218131542206,
0.498953253030777,
0.4437219500541687,
-0.4560774266719818,
-0.8086287975311279,
-0.31657886505126953,
0.39714163541793823,
-0.6677442193031311,
-0.5074678659439087,
-0.34093934297561646,
0.027486180886626244,
-0.0666380375623703,
-0.23580294847488403,
-0.5757461786270142,
-0.39041200280189514,
-0.1962881088256836,
-0.10436104238033295,
0.17661811411380768,
0.7760166525840759,
-0.11347824335098267,
0.3714136779308319,
-0.32460179924964905,
0.3108152747154236,
0.02542434073984623,
0.44421881437301636,
-0.16684579849243164,
-0.29654496908187866,
-0.1957206130027771,
0.002665118547156453,
-0.6016204953193665,
-0.8092859387397766,
0.44925788044929504,
0.41509076952934265,
0.586529016494751,
0.412639856338501,
-0.2394447922706604,
0.7488385438919067,
-0.5809869170188904,
0.6143821477890015,
0.05698226019740105,
-0.9147288799285889,
0.553954541683197,
-0.5725976228713989,
0.2792559564113617,
0.3863675594329834,
0.43574628233909607,
0.07203057408332825,
0.0009104094933718443,
-0.3503190279006958,
-0.8236623406410217,
0.5233281254768372,
0.5979204773902893,
-0.0008052548510022461,
0.10705376416444778,
0.7133628129959106,
0.18111562728881836,
0.49161580204963684,
-0.9479194283485413,
0.11216415464878082,
-0.0215251874178648,
-0.1544814109802246,
-0.2652122974395752,
-0.10978217422962189,
-0.004345653112977743,
-0.23773789405822754,
0.4764559268951416,
-0.2701842188835144,
0.3662344515323639,
-0.0690143033862114,
0.09417452663183212,
-0.23916970193386078,
-0.045482516288757324,
0.8714484572410583,
0.8881717920303345,
-0.11000215262174606,
-0.008577072992920876,
0.3259035646915436,
-0.2979564070701599,
-0.1575048416852951,
0.1502414047718048,
-0.10107389837503433,
-0.12155245244503021,
0.5547960996627808,
0.780724048614502,
0.3960570693016052,
-0.5099128484725952,
0.27429404854774475,
0.20611105859279633,
-0.32069337368011475,
-0.2912459671497345,
-0.1172327995300293,
-0.0991421565413475,
0.0024011849891394377,
0.2740207314491272,
-0.1800907850265503,
0.3930405080318451,
-0.3301791846752167,
-0.1391085833311081,
0.5866420865058899,
0.14526022970676422,
-0.4062362015247345,
0.6566845178604126,
0.054995473474264145,
-0.264708936214447,
0.25345683097839355,
-0.13713133335113525,
-0.8294846415519714,
0.5211060047149658,
0.7262917757034302,
0.6268415451049805,
-0.06784497201442719,
-0.10100872069597244,
0.40519392490386963,
0.4006000757217407,
-0.1336500644683838,
0.05974561348557472,
-0.07619234919548035,
-0.7912414073944092,
-0.7182605266571045,
-0.9170182943344116,
-0.48306509852409363,
0.25459349155426025,
-0.46199095249176025,
0.17231707274913788,
-0.5516479015350342,
-0.21082699298858643,
0.14273150265216827,
0.2581949532032013,
-0.7482532858848572,
-0.09364612400531769,
-0.06370475143194199,
0.3933211863040924,
-0.3632248640060425,
0.5259854197502136,
0.5762989521026611,
-0.2588426172733307,
-0.9435731172561646,
-0.13110537827014923,
0.13106778264045715,
-1.0157866477966309,
0.3329167366027832,
0.18866334855556488,
-0.29132044315338135,
0.270565927028656,
-0.36734893918037415,
-1.1395236253738403,
0.9614890813827515,
0.7177987098693848,
-0.6194684505462646,
-0.1830262988805771,
0.2577672302722931,
0.46259161829948425,
-0.3529013693332672,
0.0185936838388443,
0.8498852252960205,
0.6554417014122009,
-0.05264629051089287,
-1.2284835577011108,
-0.19360129535198212,
0.08238300681114197,
0.23863904178142548,
0.44700881838798523,
-0.620212733745575,
0.920971155166626,
-0.2580813765525818,
0.09710456430912018,
0.24576067924499512,
0.27496352791786194,
0.3931957185268402,
0.20923654735088348,
0.26093369722366333,
0.606911838054657,
0.48585206270217896,
-0.23022189736366272,
1.266076683998108,
-0.20382805168628693,
0.6414381861686707,
0.8020190596580505,
-0.2753136456012726,
0.8872967958450317,
0.4676215350627899,
-0.5376684665679932,
0.16117644309997559,
0.8329665064811707,
0.13192737102508545,
0.5732765793800354,
0.44234582781791687,
-0.29504960775375366,
-0.06882429122924805,
0.30270636081695557,
-0.5414661169052124,
0.5447827577590942,
0.42846062779426575,
-0.048337653279304504,
-0.3960839807987213,
-0.12874802947044373,
0.12091927975416183,
-0.0256758164614439,
-0.3361262083053589,
0.7945776581764221,
0.22389736771583557,
-0.6393523812294006,
0.8279670476913452,
0.17320649325847626,
0.5523526668548584,
-0.7031885981559753,
-0.10791308432817459,
-0.21237924695014954,
0.3488035202026367,
-0.10961873084306717,
-0.5994122624397278,
0.24332158267498016,
0.04794928431510925,
0.09695152938365936,
-0.08065982908010483,
0.5084336996078491,
-0.13432076573371887,
-0.5892900824546814,
0.24213024973869324,
0.3643372356891632,
0.4034084677696228,
-0.20401401817798615,
-0.8577877879142761,
0.4236910343170166,
0.13968884944915771,
-0.20282262563705444,
0.08975159376859665,
0.5228695869445801,
-0.09399425238370895,
0.6864151358604431,
0.7398468852043152,
0.060954391956329346,
0.1065579205751419,
0.02700333669781685,
0.7009921073913574,
-0.5769860148429871,
-0.3992305397987366,
-1.0422011613845825,
-0.10452347248792648,
0.12089169770479202,
-0.4222705364227295,
0.6189627051353455,
0.693369448184967,
0.805632472038269,
-0.031785376369953156,
0.6740488409996033,
0.32235413789749146,
0.38423463702201843,
-0.7013520002365112,
0.11745531111955643,
-0.477279931306839,
0.4698912799358368,
-0.4760676622390747,
-1.4413671493530273,
-0.5237534642219543,
0.9876881837844849,
-0.4279121458530426,
0.3185819983482361,
0.5423681139945984,
0.515645444393158,
-0.03165680915117264,
-0.03617999702692032,
0.41159841418266296,
0.23681266605854034,
0.4805617034435272,
0.7292979955673218,
0.6957513093948364,
-0.07499498873949051,
0.5995333790779114,
-0.26533108949661255,
-0.26964113116264343,
-0.25538143515586853,
-1.1030653715133667,
-0.6409164071083069,
-0.161096453666687,
-0.07200030237436295,
0.3069940507411957,
-0.006123760715126991,
0.7640426158905029,
0.5472623109817505,
-0.5071130394935608,
-0.12300539016723633,
-0.2593038082122803,
-0.05510413274168968,
-0.07130896300077438,
-0.2111392319202423,
0.23095139861106873,
-0.4217444956302643,
-0.7702944874763489,
0.4888767600059509,
0.590960681438446,
-0.015681300312280655,
-0.35227447748184204,
-0.23601134121418,
0.045335687696933746,
0.16608880460262299,
0.8496859073638916,
0.17436471581459045,
-1.0285770893096924,
-0.17114828526973724,
-0.024732884019613266,
0.2917097508907318,
0.19302821159362793,
0.6940246224403381,
-0.574539303779602,
0.2498043030500412,
0.010159932076931,
0.7737851738929749,
0.7716305255889893,
0.08123379945755005,
0.6708862781524658,
-0.6250079870223999,
0.09893223643302917,
0.4434153437614441,
0.33062297105789185,
0.36297687888145447,
-0.2690204381942749,
0.9254488945007324,
0.09674979746341705,
-0.6446084976196289,
-0.8339785933494568,
0.2838977873325348,
-1.0486631393432617,
-0.06983736157417297,
1.1184394359588623,
0.13348570466041565,
0.06601469218730927,
0.17110376060009003,
-0.35693490505218506,
-0.09864455461502075,
-0.4178769290447235,
0.5419803857803345,
0.7304184436798096,
-0.5645134449005127,
-0.1372848004102707,
-1.1533235311508179,
0.6123907566070557,
0.5764055848121643,
-0.8680974841117859,
-0.2031836062669754,
0.3886197507381439,
0.2643536329269409,
0.06471063196659088,
0.5922355055809021,
-0.1337994933128357,
0.12443987280130386,
-0.3474258482456207,
-0.33517491817474365,
-0.08269617706537247,
-0.07279204577207565,
-0.256740927696228,
0.207116961479187,
0.12242402881383896,
0.04584028571844101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04785v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04785v1
|
Large Language Multimodal Models for 5-Year Chronic Disease Cohort Prediction Using EHR Data
| 2024-03-02T22:33:17 | 2024-03-02T22:33:17 |
Jun-En Ding, Phan Nguyen Minh Thao, Wen-Chih Peng, Jian-Zhe Wang, Chun-Cheng Chug, Min-Chen Hsieh, Yun-Chien Tseng, Ling Chen, Dongsheng Luo, Chi-Te Wang, Pei-fu Chen, Feng Liu, Fang-Ming Hung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Chronic diseases such as diabetes are the leading causes of morbidity and
mortality worldwide. Numerous research studies have been attempted with various
deep learning models in diagnosis. However, most previous studies had certain
limitations, including using publicly available datasets (e.g. MIMIC), and
imbalanced data. In this study, we collected five-year electronic health
records (EHRs) from the Taiwan hospital database, including 1,420,596 clinical
notes, 387,392 laboratory test results, and more than 1,505 laboratory test
items, focusing on research pre-training large language models. We proposed a
novel Large Language Multimodal Models (LLMMs) framework incorporating
multimodal data from clinical notes and laboratory test results for the
prediction of chronic disease risk. Our method combined a text embedding
encoder and multi-head attention layer to learn laboratory test values,
utilizing a deep neural network (DNN) module to merge blood features with
chronic disease semantics into a latent space. In our experiments, we observe
that clinicalBERT and PubMed-BERT, when combined with attention fusion, can
achieve an accuracy of 73% in multiclass chronic diseases and diabetes
prediction. By transforming laboratory test values into textual descriptions
and employing the Flan T-5 model, we achieved a 76% Area Under the ROC Curve
(AUROC), demonstrating the effectiveness of leveraging numerical text data for
training and inference in language models. This approach significantly improves
the accuracy of early-stage diabetes prediction.
|
[
-0.07415556907653809,
-0.8952650427818298,
0.7621444463729858,
-0.20710700750350952,
-0.3236522674560547,
0.03118518553674221,
-0.2720944285392761,
-0.5868952870368958,
0.35469818115234375,
0.6915920972824097,
-0.17112144827842712,
-0.6347848773002625,
-0.5886890888214111,
0.16700425744056702,
-0.12196368724107742,
1.069117546081543,
-0.023280100896954536,
0.41609954833984375,
-0.27399665117263794,
-0.013990079052746296,
-0.47765225172042847,
-0.6487801671028137,
-0.49352672696113586,
-0.4191673696041107,
0.8815001249313354,
0.3688231110572815,
0.3126384913921356,
0.3741425573825836,
0.6554617285728455,
0.19145961105823517,
0.1254921853542328,
0.14508451521396637,
-0.18207669258117676,
0.10148555785417557,
0.3746374547481537,
-0.22788602113723755,
-0.591126024723053,
-0.37031176686286926,
0.2286134511232376,
0.6510542631149292,
-0.06360834091901779,
-0.0204201377928257,
-0.13532784581184387,
0.4513230323791504,
-0.23970790207386017,
0.3708638548851013,
-0.2531978487968445,
0.32407402992248535,
-0.21963433921337128,
-0.28583574295043945,
-0.4508320987224579,
-0.190163254737854,
0.3554072082042694,
-0.4144958257675171,
0.17524917423725128,
-0.09716475009918213,
0.6101095676422119,
0.2380584180355072,
-0.6609125137329102,
-0.20070520043373108,
-0.5805703997612,
0.6187451481819153,
-0.7497483491897583,
0.49053290486335754,
0.4884682595729828,
0.36629244685173035,
-0.040056973695755005,
-0.6538085341453552,
-0.39427655935287476,
-0.5963016748428345,
-0.13808408379554749,
0.3713590204715729,
0.2174014300107956,
0.20196221768856049,
0.06876960396766663,
0.348490446805954,
-0.7331960797309875,
0.005733042024075985,
-0.5322993397712708,
0.004113732371479273,
0.5358283519744873,
0.26205164194107056,
0.2898130416870117,
-0.12056176364421844,
-0.5552676320075989,
-0.0071046496741473675,
-0.37383267283439636,
-0.1761055290699005,
-0.44903549551963806,
0.27272409200668335,
-0.20955094695091248,
0.5622647404670715,
0.08834584802389145,
0.3489062488079071,
0.15082235634326935,
-0.4006597101688385,
0.4678114354610443,
-0.5547034740447998,
-0.2647895812988281,
0.37325558066368103,
0.5913873910903931,
0.40942564606666565,
0.13166117668151855,
-0.17775073647499084,
-0.08037949353456497,
0.14759720861911774,
0.2331855297088623,
-0.7743296027183533,
-0.4973861873149872,
0.5833596587181091,
-0.5927252769470215,
0.004949485417455435,
-0.18783551454544067,
-0.9040651917457581,
-0.46030253171920776,
-0.2786928713321686,
0.02676667831838131,
-0.5702805519104004,
-0.13022911548614502,
0.3416973054409027,
0.12914720177650452,
-0.27356573939323425,
0.37572309374809265,
-0.6756913065910339,
0.24629426002502441,
0.44705289602279663,
0.6271870136260986,
-0.18153472244739532,
-0.08172786235809326,
-0.5453284978866577,
0.19982217252254486,
0.039164524525403976,
0.6185593008995056,
-0.37657907605171204,
-0.2057993859052658,
-0.06388238817453384,
0.013003407046198845,
-0.18783845007419586,
-0.5217114686965942,
0.3500858545303345,
-0.36535781621932983,
-0.12291928380727768,
0.2367333620786667,
-0.5565904974937439,
0.10979731380939484,
0.2432609647512436,
-0.9658889770507812,
0.9499902725219727,
0.10157819837331772,
-0.7035490870475769,
0.46690136194229126,
-0.33086153864860535,
-0.6058552265167236,
0.21833141148090363,
-0.08643114566802979,
-0.9620606303215027,
0.06744104623794556,
0.2697978615760803,
0.6928762197494507,
-0.28993070125579834,
0.9996485114097595,
-0.5896967649459839,
0.10437577217817307,
0.4069053828716278,
-0.438850462436676,
0.29000183939933777,
0.07985246181488037,
-0.19084236025810242,
0.23464488983154297,
-0.7201183438301086,
-0.21835999190807343,
-0.027109436690807343,
-0.2507929801940918,
-0.5992304682731628,
-0.14595787227153778,
0.39841121435165405,
0.3596940040588379,
0.09998170286417007,
-0.5451165437698364,
0.13752961158752441,
-0.3440222442150116,
0.39631178975105286,
0.4646632969379425,
0.03897792845964432,
-0.03303409367799759,
-0.4929526746273041,
0.3927753269672394,
0.41056209802627563,
0.3559136986732483,
-0.39866605401039124,
-0.7160757780075073,
-0.2236257940530777,
-0.2455955147743225,
0.24584820866584778,
0.5413978099822998,
-0.44567298889160156,
0.6096252202987671,
-0.6267290115356445,
-0.35562974214553833,
-0.292521595954895,
-0.03793688490986824,
0.2696183919906616,
0.5133580565452576,
0.538037896156311,
-0.40439754724502563,
-0.35293594002723694,
-0.7759165167808533,
0.2984374761581421,
-0.04222182556986809,
0.10925180464982986,
0.45345714688301086,
0.7264751195907593,
-0.4390777051448822,
0.3765759766101837,
-0.6593109965324402,
-0.4681985378265381,
-0.2919140160083771,
0.02067871205508709,
-0.031244464218616486,
0.5228453278541565,
0.2732844650745392,
-0.9644310474395752,
-0.5152662992477417,
0.24130681157112122,
-0.5358065366744995,
0.20952895283699036,
-0.031930793076753616,
0.19354897737503052,
-0.10508781671524048,
0.38133612275123596,
-0.40386563539505005,
0.39644259214401245,
0.7661340236663818,
-0.41814985871315,
0.382321834564209,
-0.39392369985580444,
-0.07339273393154144,
-1.2265125513076782,
0.18235744535923004,
0.28195375204086304,
-0.2833153009414673,
-0.7368595600128174,
-0.2035451978445053,
0.11273141950368881,
-0.17102733254432678,
-0.14020761847496033,
0.7276524305343628,
-0.27238258719444275,
0.4133296012878418,
0.046199943870306015,
-0.07554417103528976,
0.02956990711390972,
0.16782121360301971,
0.05086423084139824,
0.14554205536842346,
0.22111211717128754,
-0.48342347145080566,
0.3247803747653961,
0.39359283447265625,
-0.5676189661026001,
0.24596334993839264,
-0.5461962819099426,
-0.21807894110679626,
-0.16366709768772125,
0.49482569098472595,
-0.9333170652389526,
-0.35006770491600037,
-0.0020493892952799797,
-0.43391454219818115,
0.3937379717826843,
0.27672794461250305,
-0.5089930891990662,
-0.565755307674408,
-0.15206791460514069,
0.4935857355594635,
0.07716985791921616,
-0.13677363097667694,
0.5945088863372803,
0.5523747801780701,
-0.3440130352973938,
-0.37164103984832764,
-0.9714779853820801,
0.00709457928314805,
-0.21615037322044373,
-0.4769216477870941,
0.5773269534111023,
-0.18254192173480988,
0.10277542471885681,
0.13546940684318542,
0.13724353909492493,
-0.4406137764453888,
0.12196315079927444,
0.24963811039924622,
0.4032254219055176,
-0.22329893708229065,
0.4626663029193878,
-0.20081470906734467,
-0.1758253276348114,
-0.17465007305145264,
-0.09356602281332016,
0.519399106502533,
0.29333728551864624,
-0.3015182614326477,
-0.4013514220714569,
0.5349307060241699,
0.8018800616264343,
-0.37466391921043396,
0.702980637550354,
0.5156937837600708,
-0.5273115634918213,
0.31939056515693665,
-0.5978506207466125,
-0.2944391667842865,
-0.3162930905818939,
0.5578426122665405,
-0.0960150957107544,
-0.9259859323501587,
0.4454825222492218,
0.05804213508963585,
-0.13540324568748474,
0.16228513419628143,
0.6635897755622864,
0.19378462433815002,
0.9711397886276245,
0.6141539812088013,
-0.08912718296051025,
0.3670922815799713,
-0.05242132022976875,
0.1419091671705246,
-0.7651677131652832,
-0.4697146415710449,
-0.22876271605491638,
0.024626467376947403,
-0.5704832673072815,
-0.6120360493659973,
0.8294731974601746,
-0.38635486364364624,
-0.35134363174438477,
-0.0774536058306694,
-0.2500006854534149,
-0.062326159328222275,
0.21487414836883545,
0.6665428876876831,
0.29752117395401,
-0.03931912034749985,
-0.38215169310569763,
-0.030777085572481155,
-0.6304553747177124,
-0.23431305587291718,
1.3361064195632935,
0.49959835410118103,
0.7000324726104736,
-0.012088111601769924,
0.5861262679100037,
0.21035389602184296,
0.7169658541679382,
-0.7083887457847595,
-0.12127260118722916,
-0.5655173063278198,
-0.6275665760040283,
-0.3001030683517456,
-0.4216117858886719,
-1.0428656339645386,
-0.06093493849039078,
-0.16694606840610504,
-0.47277677059173584,
0.03260141611099243,
0.2065407633781433,
-0.7411422729492188,
0.23152439296245575,
-0.6621823906898499,
0.9680750966072083,
-0.7654311656951904,
-0.28899863362312317,
0.0035119259264320135,
-0.7420828342437744,
0.439767986536026,
-0.33388546109199524,
0.30477556586265564,
-0.060743000358343124,
0.18005840480327606,
0.38344016671180725,
-0.15071481466293335,
1.0721086263656616,
0.0709976777434349,
-0.10375626385211945,
-0.21170832216739655,
-0.40303096175193787,
0.3799241781234741,
0.26122862100601196,
0.03323862701654434,
-0.030658317729830742,
0.041465625166893005,
-0.31138476729393005,
-0.2576448917388916,
0.6259652376174927,
-0.6372283101081848,
-0.23747216165065765,
-0.44157126545906067,
-0.35585981607437134,
-0.2551541328430176,
0.31913331151008606,
-0.17479245364665985,
0.6307373642921448,
-0.3024403750896454,
0.20250408351421356,
0.7777804732322693,
-0.48710036277770996,
0.0693075880408287,
0.3004612922668457,
-0.02709946781396866,
-0.6938608884811401,
0.688650369644165,
-0.1357066035270691,
0.24768196046352386,
0.6315383911132812,
0.5332086086273193,
-0.22656291723251343,
-0.3435184061527252,
-0.4262421429157257,
0.2512185573577881,
-0.4193210005760193,
-0.25867530703544617,
-0.8225988745689392,
-0.10919635742902756,
-0.517749547958374,
-0.01550385169684887,
-0.20589837431907654,
0.21016764640808105,
-0.34317806363105774,
-0.04959764704108238,
0.4514460265636444,
0.5624945163726807,
0.26168036460876465,
0.043362174183130264,
-1.1303589344024658,
0.4689923822879791,
0.03292373940348625,
0.44272613525390625,
0.28130629658699036,
-0.25456520915031433,
-0.475957453250885,
-0.08245185017585754,
-0.16788724064826965,
-0.7825145125389099,
0.7655007243156433,
0.22988593578338623,
0.5046261548995972,
0.44536182284355164,
-0.03973979502916336,
0.6905243396759033,
-0.6146992444992065,
0.5712417960166931,
0.5111910104751587,
-0.4594101309776306,
0.40014150738716125,
-0.22951321303844452,
0.4153817296028137,
0.4984210729598999,
0.390117883682251,
-0.7089542746543884,
-0.15801893174648285,
-0.5263863801956177,
-0.9251738786697388,
0.27082204818725586,
-0.19632039964199066,
-0.06964351236820221,
-0.007147831842303276,
0.2718653976917267,
0.29341045022010803,
0.14068272709846497,
-0.6739415526390076,
-0.3562862277030945,
-0.15897327661514282,
-0.6524381637573242,
-0.5423685312271118,
-0.189060777425766,
-0.07782235741615295,
-0.41199371218681335,
0.27614250779151917,
-0.30766186118125916,
0.3947461247444153,
0.4025091826915741,
-0.05740536004304886,
-0.1424713283777237,
0.3446354866027832,
0.759651243686676,
0.42759138345718384,
-0.2774653136730194,
0.18360501527786255,
0.0254694651812315,
-0.7297750115394592,
0.031687259674072266,
0.458936870098114,
0.031091980636119843,
-0.07121266424655914,
0.40363559126853943,
0.7834042906761169,
0.5264192819595337,
-0.9202920794487,
0.5036085247993469,
-0.011561321094632149,
-0.08114255219697952,
-0.7628099918365479,
-0.39575502276420593,
0.1891791820526123,
-0.033406924456357956,
0.19589221477508545,
-0.07075052708387375,
0.05006026476621628,
-0.4111223816871643,
0.573347806930542,
0.16406415402889252,
-0.6006250977516174,
-0.35851964354515076,
0.7910729646682739,
0.27042660117149353,
0.4045543670654297,
0.4666770398616791,
0.26200437545776367,
-0.3969346582889557,
0.8306460380554199,
0.5114448070526123,
0.574761152267456,
-0.33013859391212463,
0.20061716437339783,
0.38448548316955566,
0.14280658960342407,
-0.2550928592681885,
0.1818385124206543,
0.40305906534194946,
-0.5952271223068237,
-0.6287698745727539,
-0.6624485850334167,
-0.19876068830490112,
0.5404653549194336,
-0.46091219782829285,
0.29616472125053406,
-0.2702557146549225,
-0.22358699142932892,
0.3027721345424652,
-0.042869195342063904,
-0.6393968462944031,
0.44970008730888367,
0.5126695036888123,
0.5599890947341919,
-0.866516649723053,
1.0602283477783203,
0.6025399565696716,
-0.44193241000175476,
-0.6010860204696655,
-0.011136743240058422,
-0.027013959363102913,
-0.5615267753601074,
0.7228182554244995,
0.4031081795692444,
0.41549426317214966,
-0.1572744995355606,
-0.19916288554668427,
-0.88857102394104,
0.9722278714179993,
0.16545580327510834,
-0.835599958896637,
-0.17408744990825653,
0.136514812707901,
0.5919479727745056,
-0.47488561272621155,
0.11095798015594482,
0.3141001760959625,
0.6022196412086487,
-0.06261808425188065,
-1.1567704677581787,
0.03157191723585129,
-0.18834656476974487,
-0.1862214207649231,
0.31575238704681396,
-0.6243351697921753,
1.012495517730713,
-0.2999250888824463,
0.051489558070898056,
-0.00013961733202449977,
0.29896312952041626,
0.28435268998146057,
0.6914491653442383,
0.20178675651550293,
0.7149949669837952,
0.7992412447929382,
0.09995188564062119,
1.2016282081604004,
-0.40751197934150696,
0.3125525116920471,
1.0133403539657593,
-0.579063355922699,
0.7390273213386536,
0.2900710105895996,
0.008269185200333595,
0.35614916682243347,
0.6249148845672607,
-0.10866973549127579,
0.5717687606811523,
0.23263156414031982,
-0.3574479818344116,
-0.2947361171245575,
-0.1230718195438385,
-0.30745431780815125,
0.25568369030952454,
0.59816575050354,
-0.6799545288085938,
0.009252510033547878,
0.4244421124458313,
-0.0856945738196373,
-0.13250106573104858,
-0.17626750469207764,
0.620586633682251,
0.21640682220458984,
-0.4533238410949707,
0.4394814968109131,
-0.12263020873069763,
0.6834938526153564,
-0.4388362467288971,
-0.20805877447128296,
-0.04599902406334877,
0.5420731902122498,
0.0022259659599512815,
-0.5079488158226013,
0.15974144637584686,
-0.35729125142097473,
-0.2062920331954956,
-0.0679367408156395,
0.6682477593421936,
-0.7604093551635742,
-0.7443617582321167,
0.4192344844341278,
0.49782055616378784,
-0.0579056516289711,
0.06680256873369217,
-0.7013543248176575,
-0.14052288234233856,
-0.2876908481121063,
0.021353712305426598,
0.3981264531612396,
0.5565832257270813,
-0.22588422894477844,
0.6940833926200867,
0.5400680899620056,
0.27464503049850464,
-0.11366453766822815,
0.06057535856962204,
0.9395776987075806,
-0.7910926342010498,
-0.2784518301486969,
-0.6953391432762146,
0.4245428740978241,
0.1796390265226364,
-0.36979469656944275,
0.290192574262619,
0.5948268175125122,
0.5933752059936523,
-0.3147854804992676,
0.9743627905845642,
0.17918598651885986,
0.5345739126205444,
-0.6305058002471924,
0.686995804309845,
-0.6589046716690063,
-0.17687655985355377,
-0.20317687094211578,
-0.06916558742523193,
-0.6191133260726929,
0.24454626441001892,
-0.22284266352653503,
0.11140090972185135,
0.9156039357185364,
0.43656301498413086,
-0.07889010012149811,
-0.3311971127986908,
0.4186922013759613,
0.37509819865226746,
0.33539852499961853,
0.919649064540863,
0.3020566701889038,
-0.30365926027297974,
0.212558776140213,
-0.3221476674079895,
-0.03251876309514046,
-0.6247349381446838,
-0.5569674968719482,
-0.8775434494018555,
-0.6265227794647217,
-0.2691155970096588,
-0.3209133446216583,
0.1706114113330841,
0.8508973717689514,
0.5401838421821594,
-0.952122688293457,
0.11565668880939484,
0.126125305891037,
-0.2400546669960022,
-0.2956632375717163,
-0.16375358402729034,
0.6495379209518433,
0.18405693769454956,
-0.474571168422699,
0.1209835410118103,
0.2390776127576828,
0.2244136929512024,
-0.40203672647476196,
0.08030765503644943,
-0.3463461697101593,
-0.46929341554641724,
0.7795538306236267,
0.004721777979284525,
-0.8435912728309631,
-0.2080869972705841,
0.290580153465271,
-0.43278735876083374,
0.14937084913253784,
0.8225376605987549,
-0.6401597261428833,
0.4892985224723816,
0.1570759117603302,
0.631629467010498,
0.3612731695175171,
-0.08059154450893402,
0.535516619682312,
-0.3136715292930603,
0.022384556010365486,
0.5357043743133545,
0.297414094209671,
0.4721551835536957,
-0.579214870929718,
0.1693667620420456,
0.2864097058773041,
-0.5079505443572998,
-0.48154720664024353,
-0.06792274117469788,
-1.1429482698440552,
-0.31448158621788025,
1.0610332489013672,
-0.16695059835910797,
-0.36352595686912537,
-0.6219336986541748,
-0.06501450389623642,
0.4438769519329071,
-0.4823139011859894,
1.0412111282348633,
0.35942965745925903,
-0.27610382437705994,
-0.23378455638885498,
-1.023056149482727,
0.33269596099853516,
0.40788939595222473,
-0.9921984076499939,
0.14094845950603485,
0.6411490440368652,
0.2950798273086548,
0.07071569561958313,
0.6510090231895447,
-0.1517234891653061,
0.32448646426200867,
-0.26215115189552307,
0.21163783967494965,
0.07089678943157196,
-0.36403873562812805,
-0.19407065212726593,
0.042606670409440994,
-0.2559052109718323,
0.206827774643898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01309v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01309v1
|
VNLP: Turkish NLP Package
| 2024-03-02T20:46:56 | 2024-03-02T20:46:56 |
Meliksah Turker, Mehmet Erdi Ari, Aydin Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this work, we present VNLP: the first dedicated, complete, open-source,
well-documented, lightweight, production-ready, state-of-the-art Natural
Language Processing (NLP) package for the Turkish language. It contains a wide
variety of tools, ranging from the simplest tasks, such as sentence splitting
and text normalization, to the more advanced ones, such as text and token
classification models. Its token classification models are based on "Context
Model", a novel architecture that is both an encoder and an auto-regressive
model. NLP tasks solved by VNLP models include but are not limited to Sentiment
Analysis, Named Entity Recognition, Morphological Analysis \& Disambiguation
and Part-of-Speech Tagging. Moreover, it comes with pre-trained word embeddings
and corresponding SentencePiece Unigram tokenizers. VNLP has an open-source
GitHub repository, ReadtheDocs documentation, PyPi package for convenient
installation, Python and command-line API and a demo page to test all the
functionality. Consequently, our main contribution is a complete, compact,
easy-to-install and easy-to-use NLP package for Turkish.
|
[
-0.5115420818328857,
-0.5949487090110779,
-0.008258071728050709,
0.43838071823120117,
-0.6152769923210144,
-0.3803092837333679,
-0.4681394696235657,
-0.6575173139572144,
0.34631478786468506,
0.6298190355300903,
-0.3080916702747345,
-0.6590510606765747,
-0.4911841154098511,
0.19755719602108002,
-0.21143992245197296,
1.1598546504974365,
0.22642764449119568,
0.12738196551799774,
0.21396076679229736,
-0.17017970979213715,
-0.41114234924316406,
-0.47171488404273987,
-0.6498804688453674,
-0.12913574278354645,
0.5606545805931091,
0.18530502915382385,
0.43005964159965515,
0.43758031725883484,
0.4227936863899231,
0.20719648897647858,
-0.45428088307380676,
-0.13787996768951416,
0.1863190084695816,
0.2625463306903839,
-0.24289488792419434,
-0.17874692380428314,
-0.4143472909927368,
-0.3997170329093933,
0.6042008399963379,
0.47858211398124695,
-0.2181369662284851,
0.6433544158935547,
0.09701337665319443,
0.7608972787857056,
-0.6953009366989136,
0.069008968770504,
-0.5916306972503662,
0.2688126564025879,
-0.421294629573822,
-0.24981209635734558,
-0.2691875100135803,
0.015535683371126652,
0.029829464852809906,
-0.3335975706577301,
-0.06605270504951477,
-0.09124339371919632,
0.6686680316925049,
0.3278166949748993,
-0.39168816804885864,
-0.4465171992778778,
-0.5138831734657288,
0.6844371557235718,
-1.109692931175232,
0.24537725746631622,
0.09770404547452927,
0.5027155876159668,
-0.28560709953308105,
-1.0510730743408203,
-0.6723644733428955,
-0.14773499965667725,
-0.08936966955661774,
-0.13946427404880524,
0.0062883649952709675,
0.2281097024679184,
0.02893085964024067,
0.7545466423034668,
-0.6528457999229431,
0.06991497427225113,
-0.3332342505455017,
-0.020244602113962173,
0.325214684009552,
-0.01841617375612259,
0.3107275068759918,
-0.2465984970331192,
-0.39279791712760925,
0.22021840512752533,
-0.36559560894966125,
0.2705915868282318,
0.15093408524990082,
0.576397180557251,
0.12505586445331573,
1.0610207319259644,
-0.7643924355506897,
1.1609034538269043,
-0.3953312337398529,
-0.0014941024128347635,
0.041690949350595474,
-0.3386665880680084,
-0.7125838398933411,
0.5062875747680664,
0.7565891146659851,
0.07212202250957489,
-0.1198010966181755,
0.10792666673660278,
-0.014641632325947285,
0.00027752097230404615,
0.12422438710927963,
-0.4587063193321228,
0.05653201416134834,
0.5222670435905457,
-0.5269386768341064,
-0.5393299460411072,
-0.1644422709941864,
-0.6925649046897888,
-0.20788007974624634,
-0.3383805751800537,
0.29673051834106445,
-0.14351649582386017,
-0.514814019203186,
0.5661407709121704,
0.11478547006845474,
0.501166820526123,
0.30285894870758057,
-0.9735105037689209,
0.5390294194221497,
1.0576348304748535,
0.9925228357315063,
-0.21793514490127563,
-0.09475439041852951,
-0.7465916275978088,
-0.16085298359394073,
0.037545714527368546,
0.7051880359649658,
-0.21980024874210358,
0.02657964453101158,
0.35277360677719116,
0.038154538720846176,
0.2145557552576065,
-0.3427654206752777,
1.2269015312194824,
-0.2758122384548187,
0.4998385012149811,
-0.2391824573278427,
-0.6261811256408691,
-0.1739407479763031,
0.38022592663764954,
-0.7529059052467346,
1.0055900812149048,
0.00868403259664774,
-1.4952929019927979,
0.5226573348045349,
-0.756767749786377,
-0.12061437219381332,
0.479194700717926,
-0.09631434082984924,
-0.09609636664390564,
0.3002711832523346,
0.22575761377811432,
0.41953322291374207,
-0.02528567425906658,
0.05591157451272011,
0.00580031331628561,
-0.2105126976966858,
-0.21023103594779968,
-0.11199469119310379,
1.2123552560806274,
0.36564695835113525,
-0.31778424978256226,
0.4205819070339203,
-0.7802648544311523,
0.10999519377946854,
-0.0675731748342514,
-0.9339141249656677,
-0.27901360392570496,
-0.09080744534730911,
0.7685778141021729,
0.484475702047348,
0.5045502781867981,
-0.589989423751831,
0.5470767021179199,
-0.6881661415100098,
0.06337519735097885,
0.6294989585876465,
-0.46345335245132446,
0.28783518075942993,
0.13375070691108704,
0.4052536189556122,
-0.06901099532842636,
0.05084148794412613,
-0.1852106899023056,
-0.7735278606414795,
-0.8718393445014954,
-0.2968652546405792,
0.37815630435943604,
0.736495852470398,
-0.5294434428215027,
0.5822174549102783,
-0.156532883644104,
-0.2656010687351227,
-0.5719829201698303,
0.03590009734034538,
0.09708289057016373,
0.550699770450592,
0.42353034019470215,
-0.0353248305618763,
-0.8244609236717224,
-0.780684232711792,
-0.3731954097747803,
-0.252925843000412,
-0.07874485850334167,
-0.15983285009860992,
0.36553701758384705,
-0.07946087419986725,
0.8323591351509094,
-0.17722496390342712,
-0.6687347888946533,
-0.6448989510536194,
-0.15732528269290924,
0.5137439966201782,
0.4979345202445984,
0.27661949396133423,
-0.6686077117919922,
-0.48202791810035706,
0.2750602960586548,
-0.5718731880187988,
-0.1663682609796524,
0.25674334168434143,
0.14855439960956573,
0.7356064915657043,
0.38911518454551697,
-0.9155318140983582,
0.3940812647342682,
0.5612749457359314,
-0.6750378608703613,
0.897509753704071,
-0.0828445628285408,
-0.3084894120693207,
-1.3180787563323975,
0.32008105516433716,
-0.14389388263225555,
-0.47361794114112854,
-0.6072034239768982,
0.4165702760219574,
-0.5572766661643982,
0.0534321628510952,
-0.8037163615226746,
0.7108426094055176,
-0.049157992005348206,
-0.10481391102075577,
-0.3792460262775421,
-0.37041449546813965,
-0.2796597480773926,
0.2856380343437195,
0.45222488045692444,
0.5098586082458496,
0.467532753944397,
-0.585168182849884,
0.47578391432762146,
0.05960763618350029,
-0.4489230811595917,
0.3441345989704132,
-0.6296065449714661,
-0.05221680924296379,
0.06321702897548676,
-0.04957066476345062,
-0.6780408620834351,
-0.0464358776807785,
0.6446810364723206,
-0.4742128849029541,
0.29645836353302,
-0.24058875441551208,
-0.44780126214027405,
-0.1355314701795578,
-0.3440517485141754,
-0.009152458049356937,
0.381041944026947,
-0.41451382637023926,
0.38416287302970886,
0.2410563975572586,
-0.2994292080402374,
-1.0854101181030273,
-0.6518340706825256,
0.2717176079750061,
-0.25414058566093445,
-0.5001206994056702,
0.3538592457771301,
0.1148688793182373,
-0.31874731183052063,
0.2791522741317749,
0.006332315970212221,
-0.31651249527931213,
-0.0036109620705246925,
-0.0005449462914839387,
-0.14355872571468353,
-0.6320011019706726,
0.09220992773771286,
-0.004883987363427877,
-0.3889754116535187,
-0.3313809335231781,
-0.5837981104850769,
0.7892854809761047,
-0.6197506189346313,
-0.04927944019436836,
-0.5255903601646423,
0.4815959334373474,
0.25710752606391907,
-0.2090771347284317,
0.8562085628509521,
1.0702615976333618,
-0.4696008861064911,
-0.1277579367160797,
-0.34689876437187195,
0.20630210638046265,
-0.4185998737812042,
0.3633841872215271,
-0.2571505904197693,
-0.9839465022087097,
0.09793177992105484,
-0.09023916721343994,
0.5756333470344543,
0.5465072393417358,
0.5501016974449158,
-0.05985436215996742,
0.7085972428321838,
1.0356231927871704,
-0.32483750581741333,
0.19054165482521057,
0.1801355481147766,
0.14501149952411652,
-0.6190885901451111,
-0.047069303691387177,
-0.7263088226318359,
-0.05271380394697189,
-0.594490647315979,
-0.1617293804883957,
-0.1876409500837326,
0.3163997232913971,
0.090789794921875,
0.3616938889026642,
-0.870146632194519,
0.4232454299926758,
0.6298691630363464,
-0.5435696840286255,
0.357730507850647,
0.2252732515335083,
0.013596930541098118,
-0.08344756811857224,
-0.5433312058448792,
-0.8349853754043579,
0.8940080404281616,
0.4564420282840729,
0.18638214468955994,
0.1087956503033638,
0.8586345911026001,
0.4404236376285553,
-0.15510642528533936,
-1.026721477508545,
0.700984537601471,
-0.21340100467205048,
-0.38124799728393555,
-0.38471654057502747,
-0.013616472482681274,
-1.0588505268096924,
0.29893189668655396,
-0.376941978931427,
-1.1499537229537964,
-0.24868986010551453,
0.005940408445894718,
-0.23175212740898132,
0.3844517767429352,
-0.3101862668991089,
1.1109035015106201,
0.18626388907432556,
0.050536490976810455,
-0.1247442290186882,
-0.5448063015937805,
0.5961112380027771,
0.37340888381004333,
-0.05936210975050926,
-0.02594045177102089,
-0.05642472580075264,
0.7500028610229492,
-0.5916374325752258,
0.28760576248168945,
-0.246741384267807,
0.2065063714981079,
0.20200811326503754,
-0.01454146672040224,
0.08567341417074203,
0.27784907817840576,
0.11594048142433167,
0.2806832194328308,
0.4311676025390625,
-0.42307358980178833,
-0.32368573546409607,
0.6842186450958252,
-0.5119388699531555,
-0.40785348415374756,
-0.7760908007621765,
-0.1620795875787735,
0.32820597290992737,
0.3016500473022461,
0.15044260025024414,
0.21441054344177246,
-0.2550452649593353,
0.2745547592639923,
0.5523195862770081,
-0.546991229057312,
0.7700268626213074,
0.31965237855911255,
-0.9032911062240601,
-0.3799351453781128,
0.6551233530044556,
-0.18211178481578827,
-0.16775819659233093,
0.44062137603759766,
0.31571072340011597,
-0.38198646903038025,
-0.6728142499923706,
-0.4506962299346924,
0.07185476273298264,
-0.8195116519927979,
0.10194911062717438,
-0.797446072101593,
-0.36588525772094727,
-0.3714020550251007,
-0.07239363342523575,
-0.5243737101554871,
-0.7753582000732422,
-0.07250943034887314,
-0.06491482257843018,
-0.022073596715927124,
0.658890962600708,
-0.10428866744041443,
0.33084774017333984,
-0.5467150211334229,
0.4018923342227936,
0.4592134952545166,
0.018512282520532608,
-0.45731160044670105,
-0.16308525204658508,
-0.3629402816295624,
-0.37657448649406433,
-0.04200742393732071,
-0.7504602074623108,
0.5867965817451477,
0.21735034883022308,
0.40933895111083984,
0.34840700030326843,
0.02683003805577755,
0.022616071626544,
-0.3496483266353607,
1.1675217151641846,
0.02845657989382744,
-0.8383985757827759,
0.5560941696166992,
-0.2820894122123718,
0.6225224733352661,
0.5885276794433594,
0.03334921970963478,
-0.793154239654541,
-0.0720931813120842,
-0.3809551000595093,
-1.0638900995254517,
0.7013785243034363,
0.3081616461277008,
-0.08554156124591827,
0.18233722448349,
0.19551551342010498,
0.06664969027042389,
0.43030616641044617,
-1.0332292318344116,
-0.3106265962123871,
-0.3494090139865875,
-0.2742961645126343,
0.005063813645392656,
-0.5921559929847717,
0.02137644961476326,
-0.29709166288375854,
0.7030872106552124,
0.026591943576931953,
0.3481288254261017,
0.32557687163352966,
-0.23900456726551056,
0.17613530158996582,
0.5053014159202576,
0.9922946691513062,
0.5151936411857605,
-0.5627040863037109,
0.27117401361465454,
0.0572037436068058,
-0.6978002190589905,
-0.08767592906951904,
0.08130919188261032,
-0.05458791181445122,
0.5635964870452881,
0.48043766617774963,
0.651206374168396,
-0.3620702028274536,
-0.5831925868988037,
0.6538640856742859,
-0.40675681829452515,
0.17284515500068665,
-0.6970745325088501,
-0.11498530954122543,
0.15840160846710205,
0.15275880694389343,
0.5288265943527222,
-0.1185019239783287,
0.39302414655685425,
-0.34332671761512756,
0.3768393397331238,
0.16876454651355743,
-0.6120628118515015,
-0.2424086183309555,
0.5347979664802551,
-0.029844526201486588,
-0.7012115120887756,
0.4294266402721405,
-0.29830607771873474,
-0.36194103956222534,
0.33262237906455994,
0.42018964886665344,
1.0971530675888062,
-0.10992554575204849,
0.567166268825531,
0.4352435767650604,
0.476528525352478,
0.07914114743471146,
0.4991303086280823,
-0.2633153796195984,
-0.5880321860313416,
-0.7593826651573181,
-1.0002920627593994,
-0.14577370882034302,
0.5479854941368103,
-0.5829817652702332,
0.5966722965240479,
-0.6614949703216553,
-0.04882887750864029,
-0.0017472758190706372,
0.1289728283882141,
-0.6358015537261963,
0.2183692902326584,
0.41619154810905457,
1.1853221654891968,
-0.7197785973548889,
1.1169970035552979,
0.8879938125610352,
-0.21558696031570435,
-0.42413994669914246,
-0.13963936269283295,
-0.06055080518126488,
-0.33553117513656616,
0.8664224743843079,
0.5369262099266052,
0.14427299797534943,
0.05485491082072258,
-0.4756345748901367,
-0.47217249870300293,
0.6217989325523376,
0.15182554721832275,
-0.38212162256240845,
0.08185636252164841,
0.43506765365600586,
0.5542150139808655,
-0.2135765254497528,
0.1589958667755127,
0.481383740901947,
0.3181677460670471,
-0.2127007097005844,
-1.127629280090332,
0.044038236141204834,
-0.3826073408126831,
-0.1477237045764923,
-0.015340707264840603,
-0.08672609180212021,
0.775875449180603,
0.29189643263816833,
-0.11687151342630386,
-0.0739651620388031,
0.8899370431900024,
0.2769739031791687,
0.28785523772239685,
0.5203864574432373,
0.7654588222503662,
0.33969324827194214,
0.058466847985982895,
0.7953728437423706,
-0.2624220848083496,
0.14838404953479767,
1.2477530241012573,
0.29177331924438477,
1.053823709487915,
0.7530102729797363,
-0.15181748569011688,
0.3052197992801666,
0.5811405181884766,
0.46572375297546387,
0.5306334495544434,
0.15473581850528717,
-0.5840305685997009,
-0.04759645089507103,
-0.38452813029289246,
-0.575573205947876,
0.5211167335510254,
0.22954443097114563,
-0.09637286514043808,
-0.43956801295280457,
-0.27647072076797485,
0.15011022984981537,
-0.2704103887081146,
-0.2899269759654999,
0.6519694328308105,
0.2377091348171234,
-0.2580116391181946,
0.3542711138725281,
0.2785925567150116,
0.9193193912506104,
-0.7754127383232117,
-0.100833959877491,
0.10906359553337097,
0.011907483451068401,
-0.3568377196788788,
-0.7944286465644836,
0.7055239677429199,
-0.15304267406463623,
0.14304907619953156,
0.0020922364201396704,
1.0417311191558838,
-0.29012975096702576,
-0.4419044256210327,
0.05902225524187088,
0.3287937343120575,
0.18347373604774475,
-0.2333613932132721,
-0.904849648475647,
-0.05315970256924629,
-0.06694979220628738,
-0.7265638113021851,
0.2958700358867645,
0.1882469654083252,
0.16088034212589264,
0.4748661518096924,
0.7478440403938293,
0.40427273511886597,
0.34186291694641113,
-0.07628072798252106,
0.6765767931938171,
-0.7478537559509277,
-0.5832223296165466,
-0.9282970428466797,
0.9588772058486938,
-0.22571156919002533,
-0.5241641998291016,
0.5708003044128418,
0.5266616940498352,
0.8140476942062378,
-0.27573341131210327,
0.6536514759063721,
-0.18838554620742798,
0.350460410118103,
-0.5196248888969421,
0.6697911024093628,
-0.49025774002075195,
0.08407357335090637,
-0.3960188031196594,
-1.1164089441299438,
-0.5743077397346497,
0.620195209980011,
0.20341382920742035,
-0.6207472085952759,
0.6481589078903198,
0.2815288305282593,
0.008020066656172276,
-0.27989959716796875,
0.39043989777565,
-0.10721336305141449,
0.3461102843284607,
0.2846981883049011,
0.640390157699585,
-0.28205549716949463,
0.2039586752653122,
-0.2273605316877365,
0.03127902373671532,
-0.19953136146068573,
-0.933802604675293,
-0.9828295707702637,
-0.6853559017181396,
-0.25878703594207764,
-0.22527199983596802,
-0.16571985185146332,
1.317893624305725,
0.4396042823791504,
-0.917324960231781,
-0.23154519498348236,
-0.38165196776390076,
0.20128817856311798,
-0.3115288019180298,
-0.2654232382774353,
0.4423050880432129,
-0.5814245343208313,
-0.6071536540985107,
0.30536848306655884,
0.5171632766723633,
-0.09886660426855087,
-0.4459957778453827,
0.01940010115504265,
-0.38713690638542175,
-0.05708220601081848,
0.5899114012718201,
0.5064176321029663,
-0.8560081124305725,
0.06351618468761444,
-0.2401507943868637,
-0.030241983011364937,
0.10432781279087067,
0.5758492946624756,
-0.770672619342804,
0.6552789807319641,
0.911101222038269,
0.6025474071502686,
0.33958086371421814,
-0.44253501296043396,
0.5460801124572754,
-0.5607203841209412,
0.6827380657196045,
0.3083690106868744,
0.46104827523231506,
0.30620989203453064,
-0.2864437997341156,
0.4721307158470154,
0.09881235659122467,
-0.4441583752632141,
-1.138587236404419,
0.3631064295768738,
-1.2254118919372559,
-0.2475367784500122,
0.9656864404678345,
-0.18986788392066956,
-0.35777223110198975,
-0.4060506522655487,
-0.687926709651947,
0.3630092442035675,
-0.08287674188613892,
0.8095480799674988,
0.7024158239364624,
0.29270103573799133,
-0.3884343206882477,
-0.831024706363678,
0.940321147441864,
0.2988651394844055,
-0.6690212488174438,
-0.23497751355171204,
0.11220008879899979,
0.09377586841583252,
0.09353967756032944,
0.8557294607162476,
0.11371535062789917,
0.011166484095156193,
-0.04686315730214119,
0.35593336820602417,
-0.24567918479442596,
-0.2245471328496933,
-0.610905110836029,
0.36279869079589844,
0.19501455128192902,
-0.37608885765075684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01308v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01308v2
|
VBART: The Turkish LLM
| 2024-03-02T20:40:11 | 2024-03-14T16:37:37 |
Meliksah Turker, Mehmet Erdi Ari, Aydin Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We present VBART, the first Turkish sequence-to-sequence Large Language
Models (LLMs) pre-trained on a large corpus from scratch. VBART are compact
LLMs based on good ideas leveraged from BART and mBART models and come in two
sizes, Large and XLarge. Fine-tuned VBART models surpass the prior
state-of-the-art results in abstractive text summarization, title generation,
text paraphrasing, question answering and question generation tasks. They allow
fine-tuning for future text generation tasks and datasets, carving a new path
for Turkish Natural Language Processing (NLP) research. Our work shows that
having a pre-trained LLM for Turkish outperforms up to 3x multilingual models,
improving existing results and providing efficient models for training and
inference. Moreover, we show that our monolingual tokenizer is up to 11x more
efficient than multilingual tokenizers. Last but not least, we introduce a
method to enlarge an existing pre-trained LLM and question the relevancy of
Chinchilla Scaling Law to sequence-to-sequence masked language models. Our
fine-tuned models, tokenizer and cleaned vngrs-web-corpus of 135 GB are
publicly available at huggingface.co/vngrs-ai.
|
[
-0.5895131230354309,
-0.6083734035491943,
0.23012958467006683,
0.25521811842918396,
-0.8084036707878113,
0.11772306263446808,
-0.31406712532043457,
-0.4139693081378937,
0.3546673357486725,
0.8679487109184265,
-0.4526498317718506,
-0.3858304023742676,
-0.6564859747886658,
0.21460673213005066,
-0.4219408929347992,
1.2873250246047974,
0.06366300582885742,
0.18132954835891724,
0.1822085827589035,
-0.14518016576766968,
-0.4035170078277588,
-0.6633034944534302,
-0.5949084162712097,
-0.038420114666223526,
0.6112733483314514,
0.020800573751330376,
0.3159462809562683,
0.7303246855735779,
0.37236788868904114,
0.24679507315158844,
-0.22641494870185852,
0.10766278952360153,
-0.2637923061847687,
0.07551394402980804,
-0.15010040998458862,
-0.24976517260074615,
-0.4973228871822357,
-0.4070361256599426,
0.5284830331802368,
0.6403836011886597,
-0.04390277713537216,
0.5833590030670166,
0.040900953114032745,
0.7733296155929565,
-0.33146587014198303,
0.10645169019699097,
-0.6691334247589111,
-0.10126778483390808,
-0.4433128237724304,
-0.12248627096414566,
-0.30697494745254517,
-0.3085058033466339,
-0.00977151095867157,
-0.2441159188747406,
0.14655309915542603,
0.21103835105895996,
0.6000723838806152,
0.3062251806259155,
-0.711722731590271,
-0.22478047013282776,
-0.6283185482025146,
0.5556061267852783,
-0.8603895902633667,
0.394843727350235,
0.2597461938858032,
0.3018999397754669,
-0.31953415274620056,
-1.1646085977554321,
-0.5202059745788574,
-0.34970083832740784,
0.1471288651227951,
-0.037382639944553375,
-0.007273707538843155,
0.08786360174417496,
0.06496718525886536,
0.5429636240005493,
-0.7902740240097046,
0.031794462352991104,
-0.5649599432945251,
0.1039724051952362,
0.36218681931495667,
0.21340897679328918,
-0.07866127043962479,
0.026393910869956017,
-0.2118828147649765,
0.17385487258434296,
-0.8709725141525269,
0.029028508812189102,
0.21344241499900818,
0.535091757774353,
0.24983488023281097,
0.9049872756004333,
-0.27900055050849915,
0.9454765319824219,
0.1967872679233551,
-0.03988206014037132,
-0.058549653738737106,
-0.4314110577106476,
-0.3823312819004059,
0.32037875056266785,
0.7300447821617126,
-0.13429072499275208,
0.233024463057518,
0.06878360360860825,
0.038911912590265274,
-0.264399915933609,
0.40084096789360046,
-1.0203121900558472,
0.06004222109913826,
0.12790261209011078,
-0.3314167261123657,
-0.36089298129081726,
-0.04792269319295883,
-0.30691367387771606,
-0.3817872405052185,
-0.37536707520484924,
0.4424561858177185,
-0.30134376883506775,
-0.20268350839614868,
0.5127426981925964,
0.3289867341518402,
0.43358922004699707,
0.42986634373664856,
-0.9316714406013489,
0.36930596828460693,
0.8866095542907715,
0.6532843708992004,
0.12421923875808716,
-0.11452659219503403,
-0.517250657081604,
-0.13888299465179443,
-0.5480408668518066,
0.6280140280723572,
-0.05125374346971512,
-0.05843602865934372,
0.24812465906143188,
0.16181601583957672,
0.30602380633354187,
-0.40209540724754333,
0.6785339713096619,
-0.6310093402862549,
0.11845968663692474,
-0.29314589500427246,
-0.660333514213562,
-0.2331019639968872,
0.3413628041744232,
-0.724528431892395,
0.9126927256584167,
-0.010933666490018368,
-1.017884612083435,
0.5179546475410461,
-0.26990604400634766,
-0.6415601372718811,
0.22576506435871124,
-0.0035142782144248486,
-0.4319989085197449,
0.3783229887485504,
0.30951303243637085,
0.6252419948577881,
-0.45789146423339844,
0.12810993194580078,
-0.09526408463716507,
-0.23666638135910034,
-0.06151248514652252,
-0.2526737153530121,
0.8095110654830933,
0.21626581251621246,
-0.16885870695114136,
0.16631385684013367,
-0.7301293015480042,
-0.09954311698675156,
0.0849388912320137,
-0.7462763786315918,
-0.27128922939300537,
-0.0667334571480751,
0.08562944084405899,
0.16152991354465485,
0.42921575903892517,
-0.41659435629844666,
0.323078989982605,
-0.38587573170661926,
0.39235496520996094,
0.6092323064804077,
-0.15572547912597656,
-0.02086613141000271,
-0.32447075843811035,
0.5537829399108887,
-0.22761252522468567,
-0.26661577820777893,
-0.383295476436615,
-0.23970183730125427,
-0.9045042991638184,
-0.6465951204299927,
0.4217306971549988,
0.5891258716583252,
-0.5105991363525391,
0.5232539772987366,
-0.4162929952144623,
-0.5515377521514893,
-0.5053693056106567,
0.1744917333126068,
0.1037447452545166,
0.2694171965122223,
0.19886888563632965,
-0.38514795899391174,
-0.8349595665931702,
-0.6258558034896851,
-0.2300780564546585,
-0.17004044353961945,
-0.04155435413122177,
-0.0687544122338295,
0.3458901643753052,
-0.06345367431640625,
0.8555920720100403,
0.16209471225738525,
-0.27222543954849243,
-0.7169344425201416,
0.0480181910097599,
0.5533113479614258,
0.2823925018310547,
0.3800932765007019,
-0.595207691192627,
-0.6215757131576538,
0.1398135870695114,
-0.43528419733047485,
-0.13813059031963348,
0.08131535351276398,
0.18899419903755188,
0.33294951915740967,
0.8353211879730225,
-0.6755709648132324,
0.23912477493286133,
0.5214418172836304,
-0.3256458640098572,
0.8858436346054077,
-0.25309473276138306,
0.05042363703250885,
-1.6248958110809326,
-0.021201306954026222,
-0.22851316630840302,
-0.6791039109230042,
-0.6253646612167358,
0.05393197014927864,
0.03491498529911041,
0.05647794529795647,
-0.629334568977356,
0.7747107744216919,
-0.47705698013305664,
-0.04827796295285225,
-0.34670862555503845,
-0.21660368144512177,
-0.3721987307071686,
0.28198057413101196,
0.11006385087966919,
0.8687227964401245,
0.30790913105010986,
-0.6627155542373657,
0.4048387408256531,
0.24682751297950745,
-0.7290191054344177,
0.3469781279563904,
-0.6117294430732727,
-0.05217919498682022,
-0.10425067692995071,
0.30517148971557617,
-0.864160418510437,
-0.17524810135364532,
0.020220398902893066,
-0.450744092464447,
0.4891694486141205,
-0.3061586916446686,
-0.5456058382987976,
-0.5620306730270386,
-0.3513016104698181,
0.5342501401901245,
0.5796237587928772,
-0.6287241578102112,
0.3970208466053009,
0.09022645652294159,
-0.47346875071525574,
-0.8645501136779785,
-0.5707483887672424,
0.13348005712032318,
-0.35039329528808594,
-0.4274377226829529,
0.04809749126434326,
0.052238911390304565,
-0.07425450533628464,
-0.1966615617275238,
-0.11845087260007858,
-0.04989507421851158,
0.010735545307397842,
0.026966048404574394,
0.03178105503320694,
-0.7043138742446899,
0.12752942740917206,
0.06922838091850281,
0.04478399455547333,
-0.15477152168750763,
-0.7240240573883057,
0.9562478065490723,
-0.4174672067165375,
-0.24133209884166718,
-0.22164148092269897,
0.08913759142160416,
0.37524569034576416,
-0.543055534362793,
0.9047185778617859,
0.738575279712677,
-0.3081852197647095,
0.20667874813079834,
-0.6419603228569031,
0.14808371663093567,
-0.4575027823448181,
0.7085865139961243,
-0.4908081889152527,
-1.3036352396011353,
0.3198893368244171,
-0.3009311556816101,
0.3939037024974823,
0.404686838388443,
1.0062273740768433,
0.004404209554195404,
0.7804694175720215,
0.8382576107978821,
-0.21605244278907776,
0.5251367688179016,
0.14403411746025085,
0.31544122099876404,
-0.6229910850524902,
0.2169329971075058,
-0.46652162075042725,
0.23274289071559906,
-0.712737500667572,
-0.4331601560115814,
0.02279721386730671,
0.28728780150413513,
-0.34592750668525696,
0.48465579748153687,
-0.04203367605805397,
0.5177393555641174,
0.5526843070983887,
-0.19033361971378326,
0.22825385630130768,
0.05428009480237961,
0.031060118228197098,
0.07379259169101715,
-0.4886159300804138,
-0.740399956703186,
1.3964909315109253,
0.15315189957618713,
0.5219554305076599,
0.15217426419258118,
0.8921536803245544,
0.3292674720287323,
0.2470920830965042,
-0.756295919418335,
0.46464282274246216,
-0.2815834879875183,
-0.7700079679489136,
-0.39643594622612,
-0.14347107708454132,
-1.13858163356781,
0.40885940194129944,
-0.2175533026456833,
-0.7158969044685364,
-0.4871935546398163,
0.1687033623456955,
-0.41083309054374695,
0.32430389523506165,
-0.16925790905952454,
0.837528645992279,
-0.11493933945894241,
-0.3299248516559601,
-0.13937148451805115,
-0.6483548879623413,
0.7045170664787292,
-0.3875294327735901,
0.1687687188386917,
-0.03494083881378174,
0.01059898640960455,
0.6913788318634033,
-0.6940188407897949,
0.4890916645526886,
0.19790922105312347,
0.061099711805582047,
0.25417596101760864,
0.15594890713691711,
0.38259947299957275,
0.08392324298620224,
0.10472862422466278,
0.1155242919921875,
0.19116483628749847,
-0.6444283723831177,
-0.17936263978481293,
0.29408755898475647,
-0.5352704524993896,
-0.7447733879089355,
-0.47340595722198486,
-0.14711754024028778,
-0.07963240891695023,
0.4298519194126129,
0.2590794563293457,
0.4058566987514496,
-0.490989089012146,
0.3672808110713959,
0.72845458984375,
-0.46976402401924133,
0.26269155740737915,
0.4663997292518616,
-0.5964184999465942,
-0.416214257478714,
0.6636816263198853,
-0.1201188936829567,
0.1426747590303421,
0.4678305387496948,
0.08767634630203247,
-0.1904049813747406,
-0.66440749168396,
-0.6127366423606873,
0.3662962019443512,
-0.42562445998191833,
-0.14556743204593658,
-0.759757399559021,
-0.37859687209129333,
-0.6531564593315125,
-0.17493005096912384,
-0.6936102509498596,
-0.49566489458084106,
-0.030675465241074562,
-0.2882251739501953,
0.2566298842430115,
0.8245618343353271,
-0.34996476769447327,
0.5626465678215027,
-0.6870454549789429,
0.22930759191513062,
0.3598136305809021,
-0.09337585419416428,
-0.3772546052932739,
-0.7202284336090088,
-0.4579504132270813,
-0.24058938026428223,
-0.08300188183784485,
-0.4976964592933655,
0.7411661148071289,
0.09492059051990509,
0.26030245423316956,
0.37263059616088867,
-0.03640715777873993,
0.42522570490837097,
-0.7763636112213135,
0.8239692449569702,
0.10043565928936005,
-0.7609494924545288,
0.12420758605003357,
-0.38297244906425476,
0.3425832986831665,
0.542169451713562,
0.3003951609134674,
-0.7123550176620483,
-0.39084139466285706,
-0.25550222396850586,
-1.0432931184768677,
0.5330426096916199,
-0.004361087456345558,
0.3140416145324707,
-0.0043946229852736,
0.3397991955280304,
0.4262792766094208,
0.45574966073036194,
-0.8069902658462524,
-0.20975716412067413,
-0.21367080509662628,
-0.39752697944641113,
-0.44572848081588745,
-0.6411585807800293,
0.2893427014350891,
-0.27999696135520935,
0.7334390878677368,
0.013371884822845459,
0.2014014571905136,
-0.034745730459690094,
-0.3485921025276184,
0.1527302861213684,
0.33921921253204346,
0.9285836219787598,
0.5357176661491394,
-0.4245375692844391,
0.20006747543811798,
0.3368358016014099,
-0.6433164477348328,
0.2501026690006256,
0.19867663085460663,
0.22548720240592957,
-0.025040147826075554,
0.5491651296615601,
0.8130877614021301,
-0.18377724289894104,
-0.6992809176445007,
0.5892528295516968,
-0.41026097536087036,
-0.29172876477241516,
-0.5977346897125244,
-0.4562438726425171,
0.14640340209007263,
0.41815346479415894,
0.30838292837142944,
-0.3772977888584137,
-0.011890891939401627,
-0.3660467565059662,
0.38507968187332153,
0.23455779254436493,
-0.30345138907432556,
-0.2434026598930359,
0.7379735708236694,
-0.05735211819410324,
-0.3046129643917084,
0.4073193073272705,
-0.08965850621461868,
-0.6852586269378662,
0.40454328060150146,
0.505096971988678,
0.7439075708389282,
-0.22848166525363922,
0.1718958467245102,
0.5147412419319153,
0.6008099913597107,
-0.23102451860904694,
0.07556111365556717,
-0.18136413395404816,
-0.511620819568634,
-0.5948437452316284,
-0.9671260714530945,
-0.24950921535491943,
0.5170230865478516,
-0.5290407538414001,
0.5046219229698181,
-0.5964307188987732,
-0.01348844449967146,
-0.30838266015052795,
0.32246965169906616,
-0.7337862253189087,
0.18901249766349792,
0.09720919281244278,
0.9736037850379944,
-0.6760730147361755,
1.0959852933883667,
0.6627153754234314,
-0.31690242886543274,
-0.6112698912620544,
-0.18257750570774078,
-0.20649215579032898,
-0.8464849591255188,
0.5626714825630188,
0.3284919559955597,
0.13538150489330292,
0.18504022061824799,
-0.43453386425971985,
-0.9437255859375,
0.8328514099121094,
0.30005159974098206,
-0.5644870400428772,
0.10368666797876358,
0.28567278385162354,
0.5737444758415222,
-0.18003585934638977,
0.15327945351600647,
0.550068199634552,
0.21015220880508423,
0.022083990275859833,
-0.9979804754257202,
0.008500155992805958,
-0.04725399985909462,
-0.09642983973026276,
0.22939351201057434,
-0.46646833419799805,
0.9625500440597534,
-0.15181292593479156,
0.1358191817998886,
0.41992124915122986,
0.8723155856132507,
0.29075297713279724,
-0.17145103216171265,
0.2921604514122009,
0.5818846225738525,
0.5397427082061768,
0.2551896870136261,
1.0094385147094727,
-0.25173455476760864,
-0.02957097627222538,
1.3017559051513672,
-0.11926960200071335,
0.8727511763572693,
0.5316495895385742,
-0.05298791453242302,
0.0938776433467865,
0.9609651565551758,
0.35280919075012207,
0.6746898889541626,
0.4798848628997803,
-0.4387110471725464,
-0.27021512389183044,
0.15569962561130524,
-0.44504255056381226,
0.37783148884773254,
0.21470139920711517,
-0.15408238768577576,
-0.203184574842453,
0.1150876134634018,
0.1449347883462906,
-0.24469639360904694,
-0.38683977723121643,
0.7448455095291138,
0.1950552612543106,
-0.379220187664032,
0.5204904675483704,
0.2484225630760193,
0.6925209164619446,
-0.5975173115730286,
0.3533560037612915,
-0.47557803988456726,
0.29771557450294495,
0.23844042420387268,
-0.29004427790641785,
0.11505437642335892,
0.1501220017671585,
0.16683566570281982,
-0.08964814990758896,
0.5609172582626343,
-0.3744726777076721,
-0.6887463927268982,
-0.056089360266923904,
0.5354401469230652,
0.328921914100647,
-0.2245257943868637,
-0.34015893936157227,
-0.18622218072414398,
-0.08600624650716782,
-0.7156466245651245,
0.3473658263683319,
0.6429858207702637,
-0.25797009468078613,
0.5424781441688538,
0.5661755800247192,
0.23150324821472168,
0.5329779386520386,
-0.11883813142776489,
0.6343655586242676,
-0.7779399156570435,
-0.334825336933136,
-0.9406937956809998,
0.4419739246368408,
0.23803812265396118,
-0.20619353652000427,
0.45333370566368103,
0.686782956123352,
1.0093812942504883,
-0.2132156640291214,
0.895141065120697,
-0.00012223537487443537,
0.6686884760856628,
-0.5070756673812866,
0.7561958432197571,
-0.7814171314239502,
-0.09347760677337646,
-0.0999760702252388,
-1.0087569952011108,
-0.381712406873703,
0.5177618265151978,
-0.004982926417142153,
-0.1269911229610443,
0.5453465580940247,
0.5570736527442932,
-0.06338469684123993,
-0.3612491488456726,
0.5553394556045532,
0.26573383808135986,
0.40471893548965454,
0.4273979067802429,
0.8437017798423767,
-0.3867279887199402,
0.42995697259902954,
0.06796909868717194,
-0.055999550968408585,
-0.413967102766037,
-0.8385085463523865,
-1.2552354335784912,
-0.7433876395225525,
0.030947532504796982,
-0.16627855598926544,
0.10521231591701508,
1.2762089967727661,
0.593021035194397,
-0.7875269055366516,
-0.3979897201061249,
-0.1868273913860321,
-0.13869698345661163,
-0.023231621831655502,
-0.08409814536571503,
0.26676318049430847,
-0.39459314942359924,
-0.4624093472957611,
0.30291125178337097,
0.10722722858190536,
0.18109913170337677,
-0.10192384570837021,
-0.10600587725639343,
-0.032574232667684555,
0.440120667219162,
0.7873096466064453,
0.5122542381286621,
-0.7540996074676514,
-0.09723743051290512,
-0.24013036489486694,
-0.24381984770298004,
0.060233090072870255,
0.7428316473960876,
-0.7334136366844177,
0.2346656322479248,
0.3894927203655243,
0.9302310347557068,
0.9532896280288696,
-0.2871153950691223,
0.7088198065757751,
-0.5346036553382874,
0.36963582038879395,
0.06770750135183334,
0.4477514922618866,
0.24585369229316711,
0.17817479372024536,
0.4808952510356903,
-0.12853550910949707,
-0.3857104778289795,
-1.0129574537277222,
0.18682537972927094,
-1.0401767492294312,
-0.23586267232894897,
0.9080219268798828,
-0.1077776849269867,
-0.23275689780712128,
0.0022348095662891865,
-0.5670773386955261,
0.5608692169189453,
-0.00260248058475554,
0.8686410784721375,
0.6740913987159729,
0.3152638077735901,
-0.3493793308734894,
-0.7153683304786682,
0.572243869304657,
0.41681182384490967,
-0.8325621485710144,
0.08956955373287201,
0.21610799431800842,
0.32385149598121643,
-0.38072487711906433,
0.8234062194824219,
0.03620578721165657,
0.1295298933982849,
-0.11796485632658005,
0.2740899324417114,
-0.20834752917289734,
-0.23349609971046448,
-0.3838902711868286,
0.018410788848996162,
0.4904302954673767,
-0.14758281409740448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01304v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01304v1
|
Improving the Validity of Automatically Generated Feedback via Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-03-02T20:25:50 | 2024-03-02T20:25:50 |
Alexander Scarlatos, Digory Smith, Simon Woodhead, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatically generating feedback via large language models (LLMs) in
intelligent tutoring systems and online learning platforms has the potential to
improve the learning outcomes of many students. However, both feedback
generation and evaluation are challenging: feedback content has to be valid
especially in subjects like math, which requires models to understand the
problem, the solution, and where the student's error lies. Feedback also has to
be pedagogically valid to reflect effective tutoring strategies, such as
explaining possible misconceptions and encouraging the student, among other
desirable features. In this work, we address both problems of automatically
generating and evaluating feedback while considering both correctness and
alignment. First, we propose a rubric for evaluating math feedback and show
that GPT-4 is able to effectively use it to annotate human-written and
LLM-generated feedback. Second, we propose a framework for feedback generation
that optimizes both correctness and alignment using reinforcement learning
(RL). Specifically, we use GPT-4's annotations to create preferences over
feedback pairs in an augmented dataset for training via direct preference
optimization (DPO). We show that our methods significantly increase the
correctness and alignment of generated feedback with Llama 2, an open-source
LLM, qualitatively analyze our generation and evaluation systems using case
studies, and outline several areas for future work.
|
[
-0.18782399594783783,
-0.7432757616043091,
0.5803852677345276,
0.4478684663772583,
-0.08345481008291245,
0.20028258860111237,
-0.4941544234752655,
-0.15302632749080658,
-0.06565514951944351,
0.18197524547576904,
-0.5749807357788086,
-0.4029605984687805,
-0.37099647521972656,
0.3271563649177551,
-0.07211744785308838,
1.3976356983184814,
-0.428722620010376,
0.3165985643863678,
-0.516549825668335,
0.018022501841187477,
-0.5830442309379578,
-0.44045886397361755,
-0.6770215630531311,
-0.5181785821914673,
0.41698336601257324,
0.4511426091194153,
0.47474727034568787,
0.6195375323295593,
0.5028871893882751,
0.3450673520565033,
0.41370120644569397,
0.5251004695892334,
-0.45925819873809814,
0.2515299916267395,
-0.0951187014579773,
-0.28798219561576843,
-0.42852383852005005,
0.003113451413810253,
0.650140643119812,
0.3205043077468872,
-0.3384397625923157,
0.1523990035057068,
0.18963949382305145,
0.6961292028427124,
-0.2714352309703827,
0.24200090765953064,
-0.3983099162578583,
0.23562221229076385,
0.049148786813020706,
-0.26988282799720764,
-0.3222660720348358,
-0.9552134275436401,
0.12419071048498154,
-0.9671512246131897,
-0.10014098137617111,
-0.05262814462184906,
0.8403874635696411,
0.5466702580451965,
-0.0905766561627388,
-0.6449337601661682,
-0.7504849433898926,
0.7966300249099731,
-0.6731986999511719,
0.21311615407466888,
0.3956032693386078,
0.4980630576610565,
-0.3730314373970032,
-0.4059331715106964,
-0.568679690361023,
-0.45186418294906616,
0.0915556401014328,
0.221802219748497,
0.13545800745487213,
-0.10839385539293289,
0.35824891924858093,
0.2031056433916092,
-0.21049392223358154,
0.18945319950580597,
-0.08220503479242325,
-0.3916338384151459,
0.8647919297218323,
0.15380677580833435,
0.1884060502052307,
-0.1423293650150299,
-0.17738986015319824,
-0.164007768034935,
-0.8278874754905701,
0.18425540626049042,
0.9922464489936829,
0.2536543905735016,
0.11829101294279099,
0.6713041663169861,
0.0007586348801851273,
0.6469206809997559,
0.435577392578125,
-0.46402689814567566,
0.24159274995326996,
-0.2902398407459259,
0.10994426161050797,
-0.010714228264987469,
0.8244949579238892,
0.3931136429309845,
0.22492103278636932,
-0.1814347207546234,
-0.47977414727211,
0.2779017686843872,
0.2927182614803314,
-0.5984506607055664,
-0.1988992989063263,
0.15199331939220428,
-0.048004064708948135,
-0.5457385182380676,
0.15273955464363098,
-0.678499162197113,
-0.2048371136188507,
-0.8078343272209167,
0.42245882749557495,
-0.36656975746154785,
-0.1651262491941452,
0.03628556802868843,
0.28654730319976807,
0.06909237056970596,
0.6643089056015015,
-1.0226585865020752,
0.42987895011901855,
0.7389464974403381,
0.48993754386901855,
-0.4145315885543823,
-0.2699987292289734,
-0.7590945959091187,
-0.0012053768150508404,
-0.3379800021648407,
0.7682325839996338,
-0.37890926003456116,
-0.25280988216400146,
0.08381299674510956,
-0.28299379348754883,
0.14488953351974487,
-0.5996374487876892,
0.23970039188861847,
-0.5004875063896179,
0.5474159717559814,
-0.1664399355649948,
-0.8038281202316284,
0.05895187705755234,
0.4424198865890503,
-0.5881349444389343,
1.1116081476211548,
0.18625149130821228,
-0.45317983627319336,
0.38672763109207153,
-0.8225266337394714,
-0.2521241009235382,
0.011151688173413277,
-0.3838246464729309,
-0.802130401134491,
-0.11081436276435852,
0.3444100022315979,
0.017285626381635666,
0.04743634909391403,
0.5845216512680054,
-0.16281627118587494,
-0.2513638734817505,
0.439650297164917,
-0.24746616184711456,
0.2597961127758026,
0.07562185823917389,
-0.7271351218223572,
0.39151227474212646,
-0.7050259709358215,
0.16233496367931366,
0.08791492879390717,
-0.6416044235229492,
0.11785221844911575,
-0.009311513043940067,
-0.27962133288383484,
0.09306994825601578,
0.315573513507843,
-0.5165902376174927,
0.370257169008255,
-0.3273070156574249,
0.3342006802558899,
1.0696372985839844,
0.03226698935031891,
0.32156866788864136,
-0.28252777457237244,
0.6883525252342224,
0.009205708280205727,
0.10538646578788757,
0.02387249656021595,
-0.14535966515541077,
-0.7503465414047241,
0.08412172645330429,
0.5273095965385437,
0.4824495315551758,
-0.9407013058662415,
0.4063681662082672,
-0.07309433817863464,
-0.20324362814426422,
-0.43374142050743103,
0.5534090399742126,
0.5972217321395874,
0.5027554631233215,
0.21643273532390594,
-0.2863369286060333,
-0.6867074370384216,
-0.5756659507751465,
-0.06776505708694458,
-0.349308580160141,
0.11477109044790268,
0.29436179995536804,
0.3495383560657501,
-0.27241504192352295,
1.008040189743042,
-0.29815587401390076,
-0.031071171164512634,
-0.02800009585916996,
0.06069368124008179,
-0.11617453396320343,
0.5156722068786621,
0.3417719900608063,
-0.34616684913635254,
-0.3454216718673706,
-0.1643001139163971,
-0.5784035921096802,
-0.3078634440898895,
-0.06048082187771797,
-0.36614832282066345,
0.3965810537338257,
-0.03021320328116417,
-0.24019016325473785,
0.3076869547367096,
0.3801107108592987,
-0.08153178542852402,
0.6395687460899353,
-0.12271028012037277,
0.09559635818004608,
-0.8135152459144592,
-0.06957773119211197,
0.11459735780954361,
-0.3669280409812927,
-0.1162097230553627,
-0.28205519914627075,
-0.08097700774669647,
-0.013328511267900467,
-0.10432873666286469,
0.4106554687023163,
-0.16970761120319366,
-0.18346606194972992,
-0.25169065594673157,
0.35711386799812317,
-0.0016552726738154888,
0.5985257029533386,
0.036745864897966385,
0.7980495095252991,
0.030094081535935402,
-0.3706440329551697,
0.7319564819335938,
0.23933514952659607,
-0.27319440245628357,
0.654103696346283,
-0.5253510475158691,
0.3006989359855652,
0.21152184903621674,
0.4049660861492157,
-0.8217324614524841,
-0.3028041124343872,
0.5052467584609985,
-0.5114255547523499,
0.26589706540107727,
-0.03305131196975708,
-0.48876944184303284,
-0.3171128034591675,
-0.4042906165122986,
0.2968604564666748,
0.36349329352378845,
-0.6741870045661926,
0.23812079429626465,
0.27208808064460754,
-0.11986280232667923,
-0.7328402996063232,
-0.07905982434749603,
-0.1778496503829956,
-0.05436813831329346,
-0.3691224157810211,
0.11163517832756042,
-0.19227802753448486,
-0.24693618714809418,
0.091103196144104,
-0.0899932011961937,
0.21945302188396454,
0.1004457101225853,
0.1958186775445938,
0.4136103689670563,
-0.002600323176011443,
0.1927313357591629,
0.06035265699028969,
-0.2993503510951996,
0.1558409184217453,
-0.3716700077056885,
0.372732013463974,
-0.27917808294296265,
-0.5770323276519775,
-0.3486271798610687,
-0.04540227726101875,
0.18866172432899475,
-0.035433486104011536,
0.052408281713724136,
0.443026065826416,
-0.2030572146177292,
-0.3792116343975067,
-0.5245080590248108,
-0.257595032453537,
-0.41309213638305664,
0.25434762239456177,
-0.14638912677764893,
-0.942790687084198,
0.31945571303367615,
-0.08845995366573334,
0.4066985845565796,
0.29787519574165344,
0.7586420178413391,
-0.03430837765336037,
1.2681831121444702,
0.5110991597175598,
0.13340923190116882,
0.4045044779777527,
-0.24023377895355225,
0.11846241354942322,
-0.8403671383857727,
-0.3721124827861786,
-0.23791274428367615,
-0.184997096657753,
-0.43999457359313965,
-0.11169842630624771,
0.17908699810504913,
0.1326383799314499,
-0.25335749983787537,
0.12909859418869019,
-0.5488977432250977,
0.4992069602012634,
0.5890880227088928,
0.17354951798915863,
0.28284701704978943,
0.14462226629257202,
-0.34187257289886475,
-0.2916138470172882,
-0.512359619140625,
-0.7032602429389954,
1.1798726320266724,
0.4072730541229248,
0.7385379076004028,
0.26233887672424316,
0.8660170435905457,
0.14681962132453918,
0.6734077334403992,
-0.8391015529632568,
0.3979514241218567,
0.2920379042625427,
-0.2177489697933197,
-0.32296115159988403,
-0.6510400772094727,
-0.788166880607605,
0.08041730523109436,
-0.23524686694145203,
-0.3804771304130554,
-0.4802597165107727,
0.41601675748825073,
-0.4882199466228485,
0.14311601221561432,
-0.4601670205593109,
0.690485417842865,
-0.6567716002464294,
-0.7111433744430542,
-0.06148480251431465,
-0.4300994277000427,
0.32178547978401184,
-0.04569406434893608,
0.04896339401602745,
0.006808186415582895,
0.019796721637248993,
0.744644820690155,
-0.8721043467521667,
0.80290687084198,
-0.2346978783607483,
-0.5023022294044495,
0.36326196789741516,
0.15475505590438843,
0.3150886595249176,
0.28599298000335693,
0.08945861458778381,
-0.2830617129802704,
-0.12334830313920975,
-0.1643606424331665,
-0.9943276643753052,
0.7341079115867615,
-1.170939564704895,
-0.6088777184486389,
-0.43144044280052185,
-0.5941240191459656,
-0.2870146334171295,
-0.14687393605709076,
-0.09186992049217224,
0.4862425625324249,
0.12403542548418045,
-0.3915461003780365,
0.5002128481864929,
-0.16364063322544098,
0.15895234048366547,
0.5011972784996033,
-0.5655748844146729,
-0.8954696655273438,
1.272782325744629,
-0.010651569813489914,
-0.04334573447704315,
0.018209144473075867,
0.1997024267911911,
-0.5829545259475708,
-0.3863248825073242,
-0.9416332840919495,
0.3582631051540375,
-0.7618430256843567,
-0.36381134390830994,
-0.005662455223500729,
-0.13782554864883423,
-0.33401575684547424,
-0.02879403717815876,
-0.21724019944667816,
-0.5761175155639648,
-0.19619373977184296,
-0.2091326117515564,
0.33319342136383057,
1.129372239112854,
-0.2629120349884033,
0.05384155735373497,
-0.6026844382286072,
-0.1075790673494339,
0.357404887676239,
0.4892022907733917,
0.030034638941287994,
-0.41976198554039,
-0.18817207217216492,
-0.018718166276812553,
-0.7652779817581177,
-0.6594133377075195,
0.15706610679626465,
-0.07669738680124283,
0.40035170316696167,
0.20255786180496216,
-0.31025829911231995,
0.6664801836013794,
-0.6398303508758545,
0.767367422580719,
0.24077051877975464,
-1.0526471138000488,
0.7065062522888184,
-0.28931355476379395,
0.025955678895115852,
0.49699145555496216,
0.1555822640657425,
-0.3559902310371399,
-0.3537617325782776,
-0.7050893902778625,
-0.683603048324585,
0.6498109698295593,
0.12438898533582687,
-0.042908091098070145,
0.03619278594851494,
0.6127607226371765,
0.3498847186565399,
0.4540630280971527,
-0.9006803035736084,
0.09314771741628647,
-0.4346221685409546,
-0.6438257694244385,
0.2231752872467041,
-0.09022313356399536,
-0.3493267893791199,
-0.19827255606651306,
0.934252142906189,
-0.2563267946243286,
0.09793383628129959,
-0.03130876645445824,
-0.12132750451564789,
-0.41777896881103516,
0.1047244518995285,
0.8739044666290283,
0.8449082374572754,
0.05416719987988472,
-0.12471969425678253,
0.09080386906862259,
-0.32851096987724304,
0.4536660313606262,
0.06061205640435219,
-0.2831004858016968,
-0.0379176028072834,
0.27757328748703003,
0.8287501335144043,
0.22407719492912292,
-0.6363893151283264,
0.6072188019752502,
-0.15788839757442474,
-0.2920878231525421,
-0.4356039762496948,
0.12116004526615143,
-0.32552051544189453,
0.09220211952924728,
0.06300908327102661,
-0.21746227145195007,
-0.16730263829231262,
-0.07567186653614044,
0.2050749957561493,
0.392316073179245,
-0.23939521610736847,
-0.40576091408729553,
0.3397778570652008,
0.530148983001709,
-0.2959514856338501,
0.5274869799613953,
-0.18860316276550293,
-0.7900579571723938,
0.481949120759964,
0.7335003614425659,
0.687711238861084,
-0.06101106479763985,
0.38396134972572327,
0.6182661652565002,
-0.10590095818042755,
-0.03625136613845825,
0.09712939709424973,
-0.4079701900482178,
-0.6043674349784851,
-0.7347007989883423,
-0.5671315789222717,
-0.9427942037582397,
-0.05002298578619957,
-0.6089009642601013,
0.3296774923801422,
-0.5872856378555298,
-0.2569274306297302,
-0.4013613164424896,
0.3788129389286041,
-0.35771307349205017,
0.06462502479553223,
0.08011900633573532,
0.29142439365386963,
-0.6547555923461914,
0.5010889172554016,
0.9983130693435669,
-0.5823898315429688,
-1.2104305028915405,
-0.26001089811325073,
-0.038998816162347794,
-0.8997260928153992,
0.9956270456314087,
0.09856174886226654,
-0.14269782602787018,
-0.0465715155005455,
-0.6138815879821777,
-0.8135815262794495,
0.9026691317558289,
0.31949692964553833,
-0.6753230690956116,
0.06329629570245743,
0.22718508541584015,
0.6330263018608093,
-0.27302107214927673,
0.49501553177833557,
0.26245319843292236,
0.4592387080192566,
0.013723458163440228,
-0.9143319725990295,
-0.08851773291826248,
-0.2778002917766571,
0.1326935887336731,
0.2775941491127014,
-0.5816683769226074,
0.47000882029533386,
-0.15203498303890228,
-0.07116278260946274,
0.13371394574642181,
0.6979127526283264,
0.6088330745697021,
0.1914544552564621,
0.5514334440231323,
1.0401442050933838,
0.786131739616394,
-0.3233881890773773,
0.9746363759040833,
-0.21774594485759735,
0.4211362898349762,
1.1283742189407349,
-0.254650741815567,
0.6143743395805359,
0.5530520677566528,
-0.29853469133377075,
0.7910782694816589,
0.8053013682365417,
-0.077957384288311,
0.3297322988510132,
0.6818770170211792,
-0.10967399179935455,
-0.1790400892496109,
0.11008115857839584,
-0.21253150701522827,
0.075054831802845,
0.1068708598613739,
-0.043309494853019714,
-0.2360331118106842,
-0.1701827347278595,
0.02162150666117668,
0.36707842350006104,
-0.26448124647140503,
1.007607340812683,
-0.10810791701078415,
-1.0525792837142944,
0.3197915256023407,
-0.0729028657078743,
0.5583811402320862,
-0.4823620915412903,
-0.3891308903694153,
-0.2498139590024948,
0.22235190868377686,
-0.47939109802246094,
-0.6999425292015076,
0.021287228912115097,
0.3222801685333252,
-0.10186527669429779,
-0.0917753130197525,
0.34293583035469055,
-0.6105943322181702,
-0.433098703622818,
-0.0014171828515827656,
0.3797115683555603,
-0.04388607665896416,
0.6481978297233582,
-0.7741367220878601,
0.28604719042778015,
0.0895804613828659,
-0.17402882874011993,
0.29668086767196655,
0.37315380573272705,
-0.0636543557047844,
0.5423504114151001,
0.8855780363082886,
0.2805901765823364,
-0.07073964178562164,
0.1933995634317398,
0.7672027349472046,
-0.2703184187412262,
-0.3120192289352417,
-0.8961350321769714,
0.3337950110435486,
-0.09774087369441986,
-0.3710603713989258,
0.8545682430267334,
0.4402609169483185,
1.0415349006652832,
0.09438983350992203,
0.8823197484016418,
0.13896553218364716,
0.5695158243179321,
-0.6360607743263245,
0.15952356159687042,
-0.24149388074874878,
0.3803962767124176,
-0.3454684615135193,
-1.2155673503875732,
-0.40032172203063965,
0.8924015760421753,
-0.6139715909957886,
0.07117011398077011,
0.5689401030540466,
0.5358197093009949,
0.2308482676744461,
0.015713948756456375,
-0.1695641726255417,
-0.21779178082942963,
0.6463930010795593,
0.6789345145225525,
1.2886991500854492,
-0.40830591320991516,
0.5359829068183899,
-0.35922330617904663,
-0.14267279207706451,
-0.17554067075252533,
-0.9862954020500183,
-0.7065404653549194,
-0.3324929177761078,
-0.5321411490440369,
-0.7116195559501648,
0.05897257849574089,
1.2477978467941284,
0.37825915217399597,
-0.8646894097328186,
-0.37617599964141846,
-0.24963496625423431,
0.2516653835773468,
0.08328240364789963,
-0.2545040249824524,
0.38345664739608765,
-0.7416372299194336,
-0.7221398949623108,
0.1265724152326584,
0.225364550948143,
0.18234755098819733,
-0.5356459617614746,
-0.515242338180542,
0.3485647737979889,
-0.168175607919693,
0.3876717686653137,
0.3617990016937256,
-0.8908025026321411,
-0.5631703734397888,
-0.08123094588518143,
-0.2002738118171692,
0.11685536056756973,
0.8132928609848022,
-0.6697317957878113,
0.36331892013549805,
0.2916748523712158,
1.0065425634384155,
0.16643723845481873,
0.27960583567619324,
0.7983726859092712,
-0.5819574594497681,
-0.1781606376171112,
0.36092665791511536,
0.22446678578853607,
0.660849928855896,
-0.2918623387813568,
0.5966472029685974,
0.21608664095401764,
-0.8606688380241394,
-0.8847833275794983,
0.20774182677268982,
-0.6376926302909851,
0.2623017728328705,
1.1379292011260986,
-0.2927497923374176,
-0.1631966084241867,
0.2909998893737793,
-0.4952259361743927,
0.24841730296611786,
-0.48357152938842773,
0.9979245066642761,
0.8392118811607361,
-0.4068252146244049,
0.13234633207321167,
-0.19990357756614685,
0.7057710289955139,
0.6743130087852478,
-0.8645662665367126,
-0.21927736699581146,
0.7874613404273987,
0.37434121966362,
0.21159885823726654,
0.4143058955669403,
-0.16799362003803253,
0.4771583676338196,
-0.4530608355998993,
0.09294632077217102,
-0.20224633812904358,
-0.3205074369907379,
-0.40882065892219543,
-0.09256111830472946,
0.320529043674469,
-0.019408920779824257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01289v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01289v2
|
Greed is All You Need: An Evaluation of Tokenizer Inference Methods
| 2024-03-02T19:01:40 | 2024-05-31T08:07:45 |
Omri Uzan, Craig W. Schmidt, Chris Tanner, Yuval Pinter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While subword tokenizers such as BPE and WordPiece are typically used to
build vocabularies for NLP models, the method of decoding text into a sequence
of tokens from these vocabularies is often left unspecified, or ill-suited to
the method in which they were constructed. We provide a controlled analysis of
seven tokenizer inference methods across four different algorithms and three
vocabulary sizes, performed on a novel intrinsic evaluation suite we curated
for English, combining measures rooted in morphology, cognition, and
information theory. We show that for the most commonly used tokenizers, greedy
inference performs surprisingly well; and that SaGe, a recently-introduced
contextually-informed tokenizer, outperforms all others on morphological
alignment.
|
[
-0.09576759487390518,
-0.5857521295547485,
0.3454490303993225,
0.10025493800640106,
-0.5546323657035828,
-0.24667149782180786,
-0.07370542734861374,
-0.3234737515449524,
0.6406618356704712,
0.1915503293275833,
-0.47701939940452576,
-0.14606589078903198,
-0.7529522180557251,
0.08209789544343948,
-0.38879722356796265,
1.039986252784729,
0.38671809434890747,
0.4352555572986603,
-0.09496843069791794,
0.06534884124994278,
-0.6171758770942688,
-0.4337306022644043,
-0.5512416958808899,
-0.2344287484884262,
0.5772219300270081,
-0.03953259065747261,
0.6135675311088562,
0.8559876680374146,
0.22322697937488556,
0.32961219549179077,
-0.20788586139678955,
0.06675564497709274,
-0.32911214232444763,
-0.247965469956398,
-0.489984929561615,
-0.5427830815315247,
0.06030866503715515,
0.04748311638832092,
0.16180790960788727,
0.5851251482963562,
-0.052538491785526276,
0.4299074709415436,
-0.14489780366420746,
0.36907759308815,
-1.233275294303894,
-0.18833595514297485,
-1.0479296445846558,
0.14228393137454987,
-0.4365193545818329,
-0.2675229012966156,
-0.5498847365379333,
-0.08063361793756485,
0.24858620762825012,
-0.5715662837028503,
0.11962287127971649,
0.05893905088305473,
1.1603022813796997,
0.3845032751560211,
-0.21284322440624237,
-0.6957488059997559,
-0.24463491141796112,
1.1684849262237549,
-0.5795485973358154,
0.31269943714141846,
0.3479492962360382,
0.04575353115797043,
-0.0009429064812138677,
-1.2319663763046265,
-0.45409542322158813,
0.005096748936921358,
-0.3042459785938263,
0.4303530156612396,
-0.19509762525558472,
0.4198470115661621,
-0.043267007917165756,
0.43227243423461914,
-0.20185768604278564,
0.15781402587890625,
-0.4544287621974945,
-0.5345183610916138,
0.26553887128829956,
-0.12148396670818329,
0.3762420117855072,
-0.6720077991485596,
-0.66324782371521,
-0.0472554974257946,
-0.38824427127838135,
-0.12025724351406097,
0.3179638385772705,
0.25601276755332947,
0.43768852949142456,
0.9157781600952148,
0.5341624617576599,
0.8948047757148743,
-0.14865584671497345,
-0.08688409626483917,
-0.30788373947143555,
-0.5238147377967834,
-0.40091168880462646,
0.15956853330135345,
0.552402138710022,
0.482704222202301,
0.1324286013841629,
-0.4551093876361847,
-0.20365001261234283,
0.3688511252403259,
0.5142572522163391,
-0.5098711252212524,
0.0903637632727623,
0.6085087060928345,
-0.6462071537971497,
-0.18459463119506836,
0.08915792405605316,
-0.9052437543869019,
-0.41542378067970276,
-0.19442619383335114,
0.5139226913452148,
-0.4547663927078247,
0.0954228863120079,
0.31510844826698303,
-1.0611153841018677,
0.7245961427688599,
-0.09329457581043243,
-1.105348825454712,
0.19245168566703796,
1.0644609928131104,
1.093521237373352,
-0.2993563413619995,
-0.4890884459018707,
-0.8932859301567078,
-0.008010385558009148,
-0.585093080997467,
1.0756717920303345,
-0.5039775967597961,
-0.35279926657676697,
0.0923900455236435,
-0.20749877393245697,
-0.19829247891902924,
-0.31499361991882324,
1.1372921466827393,
-0.5836262702941895,
0.10441591590642929,
-0.393795907497406,
-0.8732103705406189,
-0.2235560268163681,
0.16465498507022858,
-0.648438036441803,
0.7115386724472046,
0.07859067618846893,
-0.9924485683441162,
0.9810936450958252,
-0.4722059369087219,
-0.3971327245235443,
0.3848929703235626,
-0.06380700320005417,
-0.088558629155159,
0.6015049815177917,
0.20348608493804932,
0.41852709650993347,
-0.25100335478782654,
0.36451736092567444,
-0.05821867287158966,
-0.5848115682601929,
0.07491306215524673,
-0.3637021481990814,
0.9436145424842834,
0.10183165222406387,
-0.49635425209999084,
0.11114858835935593,
-0.22822846472263336,
-0.0012517777504399419,
-0.07076934725046158,
-0.23096942901611328,
-0.47396647930145264,
0.346450537443161,
0.14627757668495178,
-0.21238334476947784,
0.3857506811618805,
-0.5602045059204102,
0.35130032896995544,
-0.5891819596290588,
0.5485012531280518,
1.1330106258392334,
-0.04403034597635269,
0.3161029517650604,
-0.1942155361175537,
0.5919548273086548,
-0.18231746554374695,
0.07730039209127426,
0.09614696353673935,
-0.2925531566143036,
-0.8202774524688721,
-0.6137226819992065,
0.7916889786720276,
0.48342469334602356,
-0.5332295298576355,
0.42983606457710266,
-0.33005356788635254,
-0.5341342091560364,
-0.46443411707878113,
-0.08525901287794113,
0.3129713237285614,
0.18470259010791779,
0.06812041252851486,
-0.296419233083725,
-0.6924304366111755,
-1.0254749059677124,
-0.7710548043251038,
-0.21116062998771667,
-0.11380335688591003,
0.2938597798347473,
0.4266776442527771,
-0.20904210209846497,
1.0247876644134521,
-0.44673028588294983,
-0.3732142448425293,
-0.38060250878334045,
0.08220888674259186,
0.1997302621603012,
0.2126612514257431,
0.8376672863960266,
-0.48687872290611267,
-0.09231536090373993,
0.03820296749472618,
-0.1070718914270401,
-0.10352868586778641,
-0.3408968448638916,
-0.5491036772727966,
-0.03693332523107529,
0.3700643479824066,
-0.49057361483573914,
0.2439812570810318,
0.41147011518478394,
-0.5827206969261169,
0.6004260778427124,
0.13477984070777893,
-0.23987364768981934,
-0.914660632610321,
0.24145320057868958,
0.022443072870373726,
-0.024107206612825394,
-0.4564379155635834,
0.37688276171684265,
-0.025474481284618378,
0.1309143602848053,
-0.4331955909729004,
0.8380628228187561,
-0.38113895058631897,
-0.17054075002670288,
-0.023480940610170364,
0.39727890491485596,
-0.011440585367381573,
0.1887223720550537,
0.07882799953222275,
0.9734025597572327,
0.5096139907836914,
-0.5410988330841064,
0.3159179389476776,
0.10392770171165466,
-0.4572162628173828,
0.2374156415462494,
-0.6783106327056885,
-0.07051727920770645,
-0.2803489565849304,
-0.08760228008031845,
-0.8276679515838623,
-0.23954471945762634,
-0.08409246802330017,
-0.4441172778606415,
0.2348901480436325,
-0.4002404510974884,
-0.2618728280067444,
-0.3628014922142029,
-0.474006712436676,
-0.0013881943887099624,
0.31794998049736023,
-0.661098301410675,
0.9360288381576538,
0.44434648752212524,
0.14304602146148682,
-1.016446590423584,
-0.6407008171081543,
0.262928307056427,
-0.48252567648887634,
-0.1779528707265854,
0.3318629562854767,
0.14611561596393585,
-0.2971210181713104,
-0.03520404174923897,
-0.21015389263629913,
0.11356640607118607,
0.26867103576660156,
-0.15594661235809326,
0.3216639757156372,
0.06576236337423325,
-0.013300123624503613,
0.13411572575569153,
-0.10098012536764145,
0.037149809300899506,
-0.7748799920082092,
0.8175206184387207,
0.19780156016349792,
-0.36590269207954407,
-0.0998997911810875,
0.18209390342235565,
0.6526809334754944,
-0.2585449814796448,
0.4996398389339447,
0.502777636051178,
-0.31425976753234863,
-0.13975051045417786,
-0.7132173776626587,
0.011792217381298542,
-0.4825449585914612,
0.44227996468544006,
-0.3393580913543701,
-0.5720412731170654,
0.5712260603904724,
-0.011680019088089466,
0.34147709608078003,
0.5365899205207825,
0.5677545070648193,
0.6199531555175781,
0.9996835589408875,
0.35086530447006226,
-0.23317092657089233,
0.29700639843940735,
-0.22690080106258392,
0.5179857611656189,
-0.6153150796890259,
-0.043390024453401566,
-0.5874496698379517,
-0.3517656624317169,
-0.5756836533546448,
-0.4074588119983673,
0.18406108021736145,
0.1262947916984558,
0.05593404918909073,
0.30732765793800354,
-0.5711872577667236,
0.9157530069351196,
0.7117800116539001,
-0.1989280879497528,
-0.0904512107372284,
0.03924400359392166,
-0.22778509557247162,
-0.1912432461977005,
-0.7090344429016113,
-0.5819137096405029,
0.8796222805976868,
0.06011294573545456,
0.33434370160102844,
0.05452008545398712,
0.5278342366218567,
0.3365755081176758,
0.31049320101737976,
-1.6322060823440552,
0.32397979497909546,
-0.342763215303421,
-0.7724191546440125,
-0.06819259375333786,
-0.2091233730316162,
-1.0721722841262817,
0.4423225522041321,
0.006093794014304876,
-0.8432392477989197,
0.2906050384044647,
0.013092542067170143,
-0.4091738760471344,
0.3400888442993164,
-1.0660507678985596,
0.9783539772033691,
-0.2988489270210266,
-0.22832001745700836,
-0.018424319103360176,
-0.35228633880615234,
0.4063015580177307,
0.017663493752479553,
0.03210321068763733,
0.25896820425987244,
-0.4717980921268463,
0.8005704879760742,
-0.4941428005695343,
0.7657340168952942,
-0.3346844017505646,
-0.009035969153046608,
0.44364893436431885,
0.21946746110916138,
0.3368835747241974,
-0.03720215708017349,
-0.2917608618736267,
0.2592875063419342,
0.33554211258888245,
-0.7749748229980469,
-0.6159013509750366,
0.43599456548690796,
-0.5667644739151001,
-0.4746566712856293,
-0.5439572930335999,
0.11986443400382996,
-0.16013523936271667,
0.4431575536727905,
0.6140244007110596,
0.4601863920688629,
-0.20156210660934448,
-0.057268235832452774,
0.018905743956565857,
-0.09983595460653305,
0.547703206539154,
0.06515086442232132,
0.12294874340295792,
-0.5447028875350952,
1.084261178970337,
0.07981757074594498,
0.06744743138551712,
0.3322395384311676,
0.6275753974914551,
-0.46601665019989014,
-0.4608066976070404,
-0.6894270181655884,
0.22806665301322937,
-0.7519198656082153,
-0.3060409426689148,
-0.5937482714653015,
0.010542036965489388,
-0.4216248393058777,
-0.5575792789459229,
-0.44149360060691833,
-0.22190910577774048,
-0.2427864968776703,
-0.31129923462867737,
0.15696723759174347,
0.8113914728164673,
-0.11381220072507858,
0.26111000776290894,
-0.7543054819107056,
-0.04050332307815552,
0.4119317829608917,
0.2951216399669647,
0.1962704211473465,
-0.31515222787857056,
-0.10210806876420975,
-0.2331291139125824,
-0.01322869211435318,
-0.8848650455474854,
0.40519389510154724,
0.21580077707767487,
0.3585991859436035,
0.8426964282989502,
-0.058879073709249496,
0.987311601638794,
-0.6033785343170166,
1.2874916791915894,
0.10434894263744354,
-1.4046207666397095,
0.2758120596408844,
-0.08105433732271194,
-0.34975332021713257,
0.6281974911689758,
0.2510118782520294,
-0.7168691158294678,
0.10142001509666443,
-0.5589219331741333,
-1.095158576965332,
0.4964759647846222,
-0.05773145332932472,
0.3162994384765625,
-0.6049423813819885,
0.5073410868644714,
0.19900478422641754,
0.247160866856575,
-0.7489325404167175,
-0.20759378373622894,
-0.3094606399536133,
0.005451017525047064,
-0.013836346566677094,
-0.5029798746109009,
0.026295511052012444,
0.041060127317905426,
0.5979779958724976,
-0.2890263795852661,
0.2193181812763214,
0.19914835691452026,
-0.03776716813445091,
0.31981706619262695,
0.20053789019584656,
0.3751530945301056,
0.6977552175521851,
-0.026637040078639984,
0.10740987956523895,
0.13698427379131317,
-0.6040511131286621,
-0.045646678656339645,
-0.19330890476703644,
-0.1143350899219513,
0.22944849729537964,
0.5288562774658203,
0.6782830357551575,
0.10328838229179382,
-1.0978374481201172,
0.8867665529251099,
-0.13518959283828735,
-0.06154532730579376,
-0.3493514060974121,
-0.12935331463813782,
-0.16002695262432098,
-0.13311153650283813,
0.16683675348758698,
-0.19641779363155365,
0.43085339665412903,
-0.45924270153045654,
-0.02446599118411541,
0.8139336109161377,
-0.4745705723762512,
-0.15378542244434357,
0.5616636872291565,
-0.11741751432418823,
-0.05208239704370499,
0.47872424125671387,
-0.4598129391670227,
-0.7396138310432434,
0.284481018781662,
0.5990999341011047,
1.0727825164794922,
0.21189603209495544,
0.20452208817005157,
0.40694350004196167,
0.42809420824050903,
-0.01029048953205347,
0.23506039381027222,
-0.2689153850078583,
-0.7188012003898621,
-1.0621581077575684,
-1.011013150215149,
-0.3730855882167816,
0.012105987407267094,
-0.6527696251869202,
0.4486868977546692,
-0.24742445349693298,
-0.14994244277477264,
-0.00800585001707077,
-0.05094531551003456,
-0.3975159227848053,
-0.03710656613111496,
-0.3438437879085541,
1.0279209613800049,
-0.7907013893127441,
0.015687121078372,
0.7420222163200378,
-0.26153308153152466,
-0.7169829607009888,
0.1532299667596817,
-0.02842177264392376,
-1.1636912822723389,
0.7934414744377136,
0.05622245743870735,
-0.1455731838941574,
-0.04028923809528351,
-0.638399064540863,
-0.8899980783462524,
0.7573418617248535,
0.22109293937683105,
-0.13435597717761993,
-0.29882365465164185,
-0.17651188373565674,
0.27446481585502625,
0.2712123394012451,
0.3219870924949646,
0.879276692867279,
0.5949753522872925,
0.11993198841810226,
-0.5999338030815125,
-0.1658790409564972,
-0.3017590343952179,
0.13051407039165497,
0.37757498025894165,
-0.5870872139930725,
0.5000045895576477,
0.134037047624588,
-0.6025741100311279,
0.24732723832130432,
0.48572197556495667,
0.08822648972272873,
-0.10427145659923553,
0.6223055124282837,
0.723794162273407,
0.6694345474243164,
-0.14342547953128815,
1.1977990865707397,
-0.37176713347435,
0.2041945904493332,
0.6536285877227783,
-0.03236743062734604,
0.5991463661193848,
0.5326113700866699,
-0.16791263222694397,
0.20343010127544403,
0.8375459909439087,
-0.1019131988286972,
0.3306349217891693,
0.5462605953216553,
-0.09017998725175858,
-0.14443369209766388,
-0.35657936334609985,
0.20796941220760345,
0.8245704174041748,
0.6083208322525024,
-0.2038409411907196,
-0.1802903711795807,
-0.18897311389446259,
0.1609811633825302,
-0.3233315348625183,
-0.3745558261871338,
1.0442895889282227,
-0.22769857943058014,
-1.01177179813385,
0.4494268298149109,
0.17826835811138153,
0.9962875843048096,
-0.6676895022392273,
0.25049397349357605,
-0.1491212546825409,
0.010139531455934048,
-0.1829776018857956,
-0.24235890805721283,
0.3411622643470764,
0.12225949764251709,
0.27945294976234436,
0.04848859831690788,
0.6639232635498047,
0.11668723076581955,
-0.38016754388809204,
0.15413840115070343,
0.363727867603302,
0.26824912428855896,
-0.043703023344278336,
-0.4421766400337219,
-0.17833562195301056,
0.008722676895558834,
-0.2180161476135254,
0.11385500431060791,
0.5029172301292419,
0.3109559416770935,
0.2705577611923218,
0.667297899723053,
0.507919430732727,
0.2886185944080353,
0.18974529206752777,
0.7132142782211304,
-0.6352296471595764,
-0.30043113231658936,
-1.0821934938430786,
0.49272534251213074,
-0.15285761654376984,
-0.5141451954841614,
0.873551070690155,
0.7664415836334229,
0.8058508634567261,
-0.07859457284212112,
0.7179127931594849,
-0.15211114287376404,
0.26350027322769165,
-0.716578483581543,
0.39241740107536316,
-0.6941068172454834,
-0.22235819697380066,
-0.4498452842235565,
-0.81842041015625,
-0.3227771818637848,
0.7168764472007751,
-0.08142080903053284,
-0.1195489689707756,
0.7154553532600403,
0.35325706005096436,
-0.019002385437488556,
-0.045941583812236786,
0.1282372921705246,
-0.04857836663722992,
0.19177137315273285,
-0.0642957016825676,
0.7702674269676208,
-0.19726571440696716,
0.37789636850357056,
-0.10408299416303635,
-0.30221840739250183,
-0.06372887641191483,
-1.0111595392227173,
-0.7724961638450623,
-0.593103289604187,
0.11858625710010529,
-0.6105506420135498,
-0.2899077534675598,
0.9765705466270447,
0.6019294261932373,
-0.5548434853553772,
-0.21390190720558167,
-0.3558574914932251,
0.2158871293067932,
-0.3218686282634735,
-0.28574758768081665,
0.5573663115501404,
-0.755479633808136,
-1.1553587913513184,
0.2125406265258789,
0.2916252613067627,
-0.0707363560795784,
-0.3603629171848297,
0.40364277362823486,
0.08092273026704788,
0.4687352478504181,
0.7415809631347656,
-0.012846284545958042,
-0.8753693699836731,
-0.19343769550323486,
0.2062927484512329,
0.3651878237724304,
-0.16043949127197266,
1.2433773279190063,
-0.470870703458786,
0.5828083157539368,
0.6388814449310303,
0.8821729421615601,
0.1552276909351349,
0.146140456199646,
0.5581777095794678,
-0.6527776718139648,
0.21608227491378784,
0.4360352158546448,
0.7026479840278625,
0.036540400236845016,
-0.2842848598957062,
0.49360814690589905,
0.14885590970516205,
-0.5449903011322021,
-0.8075995445251465,
0.4447374641895294,
-0.655255138874054,
-0.5620699524879456,
1.020323395729065,
0.06006014347076416,
-0.604522705078125,
0.07241019606590271,
-0.3791521489620209,
0.06510434299707413,
-0.08903079479932785,
0.7818716168403625,
0.9040636420249939,
0.012457341887056828,
0.31777000427246094,
-0.23076152801513672,
0.5077258348464966,
0.6044249534606934,
-0.4948168694972992,
0.20114895701408386,
0.5463828444480896,
-0.11886816471815109,
0.5087546110153198,
0.48705410957336426,
-0.1933916062116623,
-0.05316583067178726,
0.11601827293634415,
-0.00036299662315286696,
0.5623248219490051,
-0.002251529833301902,
-0.21536757051944733,
-0.06410552561283112,
0.28470802307128906,
-0.10070876032114029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01273v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01273v1
|
NoMAD-Attention: Efficient LLM Inference on CPUs Through Multiply-add-free Attention
| 2024-03-02T17:29:22 | 2024-03-02T17:29:22 |
Tianyi Zhang, Jonah Wonkyu Yi, Bowen Yao, Zhaozhuo Xu, Anshumali Shrivastava
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language model inference on Central Processing Units (CPU) is
challenging due to the vast quantities of expensive Multiply-Add (MAD) matrix
operations in the attention computations. In this paper, we argue that there is
a rare gem in modern CPUs, Single-Instruction-Multiple-Data (SIMD) registers,
which allow for ultra-low-latency lookups in batch. We leverage this unique
capability of CPUs to propose NoMAD-Attention, an efficient attention algorithm
that replaces MAD operations with in-register lookups. Through hardware-aware
algorithmic designs, NoMAD-Attention achieves the computation of attention
scores using repeated fast accesses to SIMD registers despite their highly
limited sizes. Moreover, NoMAD-Attention works with pre-trained attention-based
LLMs without model finetuning. Empirical evaluations demonstrate that
NoMAD-Attention maintains the quality of the original LLMs well, and speeds up
the 4-bit quantized LLaMA-7B-based model by up to 2$\times$ at 16k context
length. Our results are reproducible at
https://github.com/tonyzhang617/nomad-dist.
|
[
-0.2949186861515045,
-0.6645587086677551,
0.6446981430053711,
0.3048902451992035,
-0.2974449396133423,
0.024340294301509857,
-0.18120598793029785,
-0.30078381299972534,
0.21664580702781677,
0.5121369957923889,
-0.6628203988075256,
-0.4775596261024475,
-0.2716016173362732,
-0.22521352767944336,
-0.15685498714447021,
0.7611624598503113,
0.057718273252248764,
-0.27802103757858276,
-0.36747631430625916,
-0.30684220790863037,
-0.17900560796260834,
-0.718043327331543,
-0.46637535095214844,
0.10403387248516083,
0.5924035906791687,
0.4821201264858246,
0.5354989171028137,
0.7304012775421143,
0.5715916156768799,
0.15203547477722168,
0.008123954758048058,
0.3683452606201172,
-0.6308139562606812,
0.11851926147937775,
0.38860979676246643,
-0.4895106256008148,
-0.9562079310417175,
0.015476933680474758,
0.7115252614021301,
0.5279738903045654,
-0.09345147758722305,
0.6343756318092346,
-0.22448010742664337,
0.5751864910125732,
-1.1345839500427246,
-0.04960756003856659,
-0.5158673524856567,
0.14701911807060242,
-0.43223223090171814,
-0.2558218538761139,
-0.7456289529800415,
-0.1702485978603363,
-0.29165002703666687,
-0.6938635110855103,
0.3037686347961426,
0.2173982709646225,
0.4185604155063629,
0.8836954236030579,
-0.2857820987701416,
0.2926800847053528,
-0.6885548233985901,
1.1542654037475586,
-0.6117696762084961,
0.6351150274276733,
0.1893455684185028,
0.2538345456123352,
-0.28520044684410095,
-0.5378715991973877,
-0.4760124683380127,
-0.06542696803808212,
0.32275131344795227,
0.02720087766647339,
-0.27561336755752563,
0.11565958708524704,
0.4083085060119629,
0.47477349638938904,
-0.31681761145591736,
-0.1357090026140213,
0.13374865055084229,
0.05148407071828842,
0.2693471908569336,
0.25373488664627075,
0.11857157945632935,
0.45893165469169617,
-0.5782141089439392,
0.19898395240306854,
-0.8911491632461548,
0.10316816717386246,
0.10939808189868927,
0.2420911192893982,
-0.22088900208473206,
0.40677472949028015,
-0.38446953892707825,
0.9944374561309814,
0.27567538619041443,
-0.1904943287372589,
0.07379816472530365,
-0.2603270411491394,
-0.6697574853897095,
0.23355737328529358,
0.6642308235168457,
0.13798631727695465,
0.05523047596216202,
-0.4408457577228546,
-0.02311227284371853,
0.24121613800525665,
0.3932495415210724,
-0.7328489422798157,
-0.17370542883872986,
0.29736146330833435,
-0.38701868057250977,
-0.10300090909004211,
-0.4069017171859741,
-0.5435662269592285,
-0.2136610895395279,
0.013247057795524597,
0.06293278187513351,
-0.09397527575492859,
-0.11237162351608276,
0.2513869106769562,
0.15635986626148224,
0.41347548365592957,
0.38644862174987793,
-0.7791340351104736,
0.4310399293899536,
0.5157559514045715,
0.8897161483764648,
-0.14563076198101044,
-0.10424827039241791,
-0.9527393579483032,
0.30884313583374023,
-0.3547310531139374,
0.984037458896637,
-0.6407540440559387,
-0.16215065121650696,
-0.640147864818573,
-0.26548436284065247,
-0.30543163418769836,
-0.5559751391410828,
0.31321391463279724,
-0.8053454756736755,
-0.3867267668247223,
-0.07684703171253204,
-0.2361670732498169,
-0.17983266711235046,
0.2042982131242752,
-0.6650025844573975,
1.1523839235305786,
-0.05290521681308746,
-0.8299362659454346,
-0.20586784183979034,
-0.7646743655204773,
-0.5622152090072632,
-0.13780762255191803,
0.06528764218091965,
-0.364971786737442,
0.39611130952835083,
0.23532503843307495,
0.2908499240875244,
-0.49973922967910767,
-0.1079525277018547,
-0.6817476749420166,
-0.45315152406692505,
0.31485888361930847,
-0.5395098924636841,
0.8101959824562073,
0.16554327309131622,
-0.2797608971595764,
0.2320283204317093,
-0.7235804796218872,
0.08588758111000061,
-0.044225528836250305,
-0.4069575369358063,
-0.14761804044246674,
-0.1347006857395172,
-0.007442060858011246,
0.19985148310661316,
0.44167429208755493,
-0.6281862258911133,
0.27986785769462585,
-0.23425163328647614,
0.12102174013853073,
0.6713228821754456,
-0.22981341183185577,
0.47321051359176636,
-0.09693961590528488,
0.6461564898490906,
-0.1044192835688591,
0.36974796652793884,
-0.2278018295764923,
-0.3171001672744751,
-0.9295960664749146,
-0.8145846724510193,
0.2432778775691986,
0.45966511964797974,
-0.5493048429489136,
-0.1354537308216095,
-0.10615070164203644,
-0.4009990394115448,
-0.9140760898590088,
0.23074060678482056,
0.5531044006347656,
0.4766930639743805,
0.3200402855873108,
-0.2677636742591858,
-0.4091125428676605,
-0.7900093793869019,
-0.31548967957496643,
0.21034936606884003,
-0.04025586321949959,
0.4560309052467346,
-0.22145406901836395,
-0.31309816241264343,
0.5466575026512146,
-0.5659644603729248,
-0.14306890964508057,
-0.1396467536687851,
-0.2711820900440216,
0.10126543045043945,
0.15647657215595245,
0.25952938199043274,
-0.21050333976745605,
-0.4154050350189209,
0.09700184315443039,
-0.7569692730903625,
-0.215637668967247,
-0.06894973665475845,
-0.37060239911079407,
0.11096527427434921,
0.5349934697151184,
-0.7387647032737732,
0.304065078496933,
0.5261640548706055,
0.07600796967744827,
0.3872935175895691,
-0.21828050911426544,
-0.14161528646945953,
-0.6654561758041382,
0.09059552103281021,
-0.23909498751163483,
-0.4441145062446594,
-0.7652830481529236,
0.12111342698335648,
0.2885032296180725,
0.12557587027549744,
-0.6051597595214844,
0.698111891746521,
-0.6511666178703308,
-0.39891278743743896,
-0.27913475036621094,
0.05836810916662216,
-0.008558749221265316,
0.7652860283851624,
-0.33974653482437134,
0.8852570652961731,
0.5892966985702515,
-0.711954653263092,
0.2688364088535309,
0.029916858300566673,
-0.09724677354097366,
0.5828957557678223,
-0.3386038541793823,
0.559562087059021,
-0.10004090517759323,
0.11244423687458038,
-1.2396600246429443,
-0.09436162561178207,
0.10709840804338455,
-0.27014926075935364,
0.33933770656585693,
0.06964606046676636,
-0.4412415325641632,
-0.19109803438186646,
-0.4359220564365387,
0.7851796746253967,
0.23910337686538696,
-0.587317168712616,
0.5713342428207397,
0.5829179883003235,
0.07800697535276413,
-0.6849318146705627,
-0.48806238174438477,
-0.01408341620117426,
0.050111230462789536,
-0.24458546936511993,
-0.045041028410196304,
-0.22608572244644165,
-0.21914339065551758,
-0.03575679287314415,
-0.4812186658382416,
-0.21757660806179047,
0.30792319774627686,
0.4089457094669342,
0.4346877634525299,
-0.4729628264904022,
0.10664013773202896,
-0.02363269217312336,
-0.1973472535610199,
-0.2352178692817688,
-0.3322741687297821,
0.5505608320236206,
-0.05691229924559593,
-0.3030003607273102,
-0.7353602051734924,
0.23836325109004974,
1.0035126209259033,
-0.4235892593860626,
0.4185401499271393,
0.31000348925590515,
-0.2051991969347,
-0.25820133090019226,
-0.7085403203964233,
-0.03393623232841492,
-0.4091110825538635,
0.06819887459278107,
-0.24059878289699554,
-0.8978567719459534,
0.3058587908744812,
-0.1543954461812973,
0.08522851765155792,
0.3407881259918213,
0.6967905163764954,
-0.10304124653339386,
0.8541218042373657,
0.6875240206718445,
-0.21018503606319427,
0.6030970811843872,
0.008422997780144215,
0.30340930819511414,
-1.3324048519134521,
-0.04583052918314934,
-0.264592707157135,
-0.6000083088874817,
-0.26787906885147095,
-0.8831800222396851,
0.29090458154678345,
-0.250419944524765,
-0.15939687192440033,
-0.017318356782197952,
-0.4161849617958069,
0.553019106388092,
0.5659365653991699,
0.08356721699237823,
0.332418292760849,
-0.05555824562907219,
0.06602554768323898,
0.20340682566165924,
-0.860177218914032,
-0.2909093499183655,
1.2397269010543823,
-0.05508020892739296,
0.9115176200866699,
-0.1677793711423874,
0.4635474383831024,
0.08462662994861603,
0.5643250942230225,
-0.7609236836433411,
0.5766834020614624,
-0.08827854692935944,
-0.4956609010696411,
-0.08576493710279465,
-0.3113952577114105,
-0.7398433685302734,
0.3334549367427826,
0.3082367181777954,
-0.5671075582504272,
0.14241907000541687,
0.3089750111103058,
-0.936069130897522,
0.4555204510688782,
-0.6460144519805908,
0.7994100451469421,
-0.08439988642930984,
-0.4440757632255554,
-0.21732938289642334,
-0.6051891446113586,
0.5821294784545898,
-0.11812537908554077,
0.12991701066493988,
-0.4374966323375702,
-0.2977638244628906,
0.5619363188743591,
-0.264423131942749,
0.8895492553710938,
-0.044359397143125534,
-0.025432642549276352,
0.27643755078315735,
-0.01708844304084778,
0.43015384674072266,
-0.17172493040561676,
-0.0764160230755806,
0.18007397651672363,
-0.27272269129753113,
-0.5558145046234131,
-0.3452359437942505,
1.0606834888458252,
-0.7085762023925781,
-0.37300270795822144,
-0.14038921892642975,
-0.9018310904502869,
-0.15997588634490967,
0.2706184387207031,
-0.18642283976078033,
0.33588460087776184,
-0.17676745355129242,
-0.09611574560403824,
0.946648120880127,
-0.12743942439556122,
0.44152918457984924,
0.5033997297286987,
0.09560304135084152,
-0.2819158136844635,
0.8781956434249878,
0.14787892997264862,
0.38419920206069946,
0.43256914615631104,
-0.22745680809020996,
-0.14848171174526215,
-0.19493593275547028,
-0.6929244995117188,
0.34633737802505493,
-0.31915968656539917,
-0.3321753442287445,
-1.0309242010116577,
0.13238142430782318,
-0.1443871408700943,
-0.09976569563150406,
-0.7564951181411743,
-0.560289204120636,
-0.35942351818084717,
0.13715016841888428,
0.3773249387741089,
0.4995241165161133,
0.197951540350914,
0.7257711291313171,
-0.4815719425678253,
0.8391007781028748,
0.35691821575164795,
0.5026754140853882,
0.341263085603714,
-0.4542207717895508,
-0.3951856195926666,
-0.11228490620851517,
-0.4667302072048187,
-0.6372833847999573,
0.2528761923313141,
0.11197613924741745,
0.5453105568885803,
0.5905237793922424,
0.2969094216823578,
0.8747929930686951,
-0.5910440683364868,
0.30203697085380554,
-0.04999561235308647,
-0.9395105838775635,
0.15551786124706268,
-0.1464252471923828,
0.5725889801979065,
0.49007996916770935,
-0.03360879048705101,
-0.5444192886352539,
-0.5038849711418152,
-0.6145181655883789,
-0.8031856417655945,
0.969875156879425,
-0.06641373038291931,
-0.06689126044511795,
-0.032938580960035324,
0.39966055750846863,
-0.09129147976636887,
0.610719621181488,
-0.2241307497024536,
-0.5058581829071045,
0.2302207052707672,
-0.09572307020425797,
0.02150922641158104,
-0.36527517437934875,
0.07082202285528183,
-0.12293389439582825,
0.5194838643074036,
-0.021341996267437935,
0.5719619989395142,
0.20191816985607147,
-0.19589969515800476,
-0.24349907040596008,
0.1394294947385788,
0.6529222726821899,
0.21264077723026276,
-0.30116966366767883,
0.6058885455131531,
0.33538007736206055,
-0.4768347442150116,
0.22669002413749695,
-0.1981026530265808,
0.0015797766391187906,
-0.09618493169546127,
0.08497481048107147,
0.8597404956817627,
0.4390845000743866,
-0.5095711350440979,
0.280466765165329,
-0.33835652470588684,
0.25992947816848755,
0.08627846091985703,
0.11325325816869736,
0.346452921628952,
0.33179140090942383,
0.09556131064891815,
0.284625381231308,
0.2026260644197464,
-0.13518960773944855,
0.020517369732260704,
0.7082666158676147,
-0.4453715682029724,
-0.4534737467765808,
0.9292933344841003,
-0.01909801736474037,
-0.29675260186195374,
0.568703830242157,
-0.17895540595054626,
-0.10453570634126663,
0.7592045068740845,
0.6217774748802185,
1.118303894996643,
-0.5941743850708008,
-0.1988971084356308,
0.012231046333909035,
0.43111681938171387,
-0.03540831431746483,
0.4971855878829956,
-0.3857680559158325,
-0.42975762486457825,
-0.6967724561691284,
-0.5336271524429321,
-0.5825807452201843,
-0.01576206460595131,
-0.6369844675064087,
0.010239260271191597,
-0.8527781367301941,
-0.2137414664030075,
0.02242504432797432,
-0.16162297129631042,
-0.7240029573440552,
-0.026278097182512283,
0.34379813075065613,
0.7260569334030151,
-0.5049248933792114,
1.068769931793213,
0.4930395781993866,
0.2790582478046417,
-0.4271238446235657,
-0.03739245608448982,
-0.10966911166906357,
-0.7950916290283203,
0.27448800206184387,
0.402451753616333,
-0.6352688670158386,
0.3601202666759491,
-0.5121938586235046,
-0.855894923210144,
0.8528895378112793,
0.8852839469909668,
-0.6564244031906128,
0.28903767466545105,
-0.2970913052558899,
0.2628405690193176,
-0.33700600266456604,
0.29524627327919006,
0.5683969855308533,
0.3182826042175293,
0.031675923615694046,
-0.7271319627761841,
-0.0608193539083004,
-0.1918717622756958,
-0.28774183988571167,
0.46786051988601685,
-1.0256729125976562,
1.0284361839294434,
-0.6867337226867676,
-0.350681871175766,
-0.22377125918865204,
0.514772355556488,
0.2048921436071396,
0.4862942397594452,
0.1600184142589569,
0.7567289471626282,
0.9935970306396484,
0.22690938413143158,
1.3659727573394775,
-0.4023341238498688,
0.3585813343524933,
1.2248892784118652,
-0.48802807927131653,
0.9564011693000793,
0.6941110491752625,
-0.16358885169029236,
0.3276442289352417,
0.5461518168449402,
0.4790477454662323,
0.6835455298423767,
0.1475832313299179,
-0.5952020287513733,
-0.6020930409431458,
-0.29034262895584106,
-0.186152383685112,
0.18681791424751282,
0.17698819935321808,
-0.0030728636775165796,
-0.2952919006347656,
-0.273761123418808,
0.021046137437224388,
-0.5315878391265869,
-0.39743664860725403,
0.7838055491447449,
0.09759411215782166,
-0.2579495310783386,
0.9090076088905334,
-0.0901196226477623,
0.42241373658180237,
-0.3461109697818756,
0.09556029736995697,
-0.3399272561073303,
0.411342978477478,
-0.014247729443013668,
0.021175822243094444,
0.15624931454658508,
-0.04143216088414192,
-0.7032685875892639,
-0.03129809722304344,
0.4697628915309906,
-0.28143981099128723,
-0.6490383744239807,
0.22070348262786865,
0.48353976011276245,
0.32861173152923584,
-0.41024452447891235,
-0.22532542049884796,
0.30380770564079285,
-0.030371101573109627,
-0.3850521445274353,
0.5800657868385315,
0.45823073387145996,
-0.2709353268146515,
0.7283545732498169,
0.8939354419708252,
-0.053839828819036484,
0.3301553428173065,
-0.26996585726737976,
1.023572325706482,
-0.6572194695472717,
-0.4444085657596588,
-1.1546032428741455,
0.10618733614683151,
0.22903673350811005,
-0.05826650932431221,
0.8022176027297974,
0.634194552898407,
0.5640645027160645,
-0.1855238825082779,
0.7925088405609131,
0.4601795971393585,
0.13432414829730988,
-0.10633394122123718,
0.4895038306713104,
-0.591228187084198,
0.06618782877922058,
0.0484115406870842,
-0.6703722476959229,
-0.6309258341789246,
0.62078458070755,
-0.46497291326522827,
-0.31189778447151184,
0.5596033334732056,
0.7632699012756348,
-0.42793747782707214,
-0.3076556324958801,
0.5066268444061279,
0.29240089654922485,
0.004377939738333225,
0.8777815699577332,
0.5902314782142639,
-0.3765071928501129,
0.33055269718170166,
0.025414155796170235,
-0.28257858753204346,
-0.538353443145752,
-0.7811960577964783,
-0.8568152189254761,
0.1571298986673355,
-0.239898681640625,
0.04733080044388771,
-0.006295624189078808,
0.757325291633606,
0.6134059429168701,
-0.7241721153259277,
-0.3511785566806793,
0.3269445300102234,
0.42413026094436646,
-0.4004404842853546,
-0.09780756384134293,
0.46253642439842224,
-0.4846629798412323,
-0.6776527166366577,
0.5878399610519409,
0.9265661239624023,
-0.16256962716579437,
-0.11786802858114243,
0.021098608151078224,
-0.2243465632200241,
0.35278668999671936,
0.7154805660247803,
0.23575763404369354,
-0.6212815046310425,
0.21561744809150696,
0.31000906229019165,
-0.2786549925804138,
0.3139709234237671,
0.7823750972747803,
-0.7782591581344604,
0.5356904864311218,
0.24616438150405884,
0.8602470755577087,
0.5781050324440002,
-0.0018955643754452467,
0.21721015870571136,
-0.7286378741264343,
0.4724731743335724,
-0.07029399275779724,
0.05766856670379639,
0.3425411880016327,
-0.4597378373146057,
0.1450868397951126,
0.15011410415172577,
-0.5019215941429138,
-0.9195213913917542,
0.20715530216693878,
-1.1207484006881714,
0.1463802456855774,
0.9879499077796936,
-0.14297521114349365,
-0.8402051329612732,
-0.1895635426044464,
-0.3956417441368103,
0.30527469515800476,
-0.5363534688949585,
0.6753153800964355,
0.34197214245796204,
-0.3904024362564087,
-0.17767934501171112,
-1.015292763710022,
0.3063872158527374,
0.4836772084236145,
-0.7157866358757019,
0.662346363067627,
0.3416004180908203,
0.14446742832660675,
0.013590623624622822,
1.0064061880111694,
0.13517552614212036,
0.3518409729003906,
-0.07271284610033035,
0.515720009803772,
-0.1922270953655243,
-0.5081356763839722,
-0.34804534912109375,
0.348421186208725,
0.13069021701812744,
-0.721822202205658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01270v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01270v1
|
A comprehensive cross-language framework for harmful content detection with the aid of sentiment analysis
| 2024-03-02T17:13:47 | 2024-03-02T17:13:47 |
Mohammad Dehghani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In today's digital world, social media plays a significant role in
facilitating communication and content sharing. However, the exponential rise
in user-generated content has led to challenges in maintaining a respectful
online environment. In some cases, users have taken advantage of anonymity in
order to use harmful language, which can negatively affect the user experience
and pose serious social problems. Recognizing the limitations of manual
moderation, automatic detection systems have been developed to tackle this
problem. Nevertheless, several obstacles persist, including the absence of a
universal definition for harmful language, inadequate datasets across
languages, the need for detailed annotation guideline, and most importantly, a
comprehensive framework. This study aims to address these challenges by
introducing, for the first time, a detailed framework adaptable to any
language. This framework encompasses various aspects of harmful language
detection. A key component of the framework is the development of a general and
detailed annotation guideline. Additionally, the integration of sentiment
analysis represents a novel approach to enhancing harmful language detection.
Also, a definition of harmful language based on the review of different related
concepts is presented. To demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed
framework, its implementation in a challenging low-resource language is
conducted. We collected a Persian dataset and applied the annotation guideline
for harmful detection and sentiment analysis. Next, we present baseline
experiments utilizing machine and deep learning methods to set benchmarks.
Results prove the framework's high performance, achieving an accuracy of 99.4%
in offensive language detection and 66.2% in sentiment analysis.
|
[
-0.3315402865409851,
-1.008275032043457,
0.1422485113143921,
0.3494083285331726,
-0.47420674562454224,
0.11064544320106506,
-0.32727673649787903,
-0.5048028826713562,
0.0445021390914917,
0.5526553392410278,
-0.4071827232837677,
-0.9808691740036011,
-0.7885120511054993,
0.07373803108930588,
-0.5207217335700989,
1.0751560926437378,
0.10166509449481964,
-0.03416093811392784,
0.1151401698589325,
-0.2758892774581909,
-0.252591997385025,
-0.42677754163742065,
-0.7814128994941711,
0.2524343430995941,
0.38791510462760925,
0.2934219539165497,
0.6328590512275696,
0.342369943857193,
0.6224246025085449,
0.31044963002204895,
-0.06848432868719101,
0.02427503652870655,
-0.3149307668209076,
0.3052361309528351,
-0.46974411606788635,
-0.1401200145483017,
-0.28981491923332214,
-0.38709935545921326,
0.3630160391330719,
0.3653869926929474,
0.07737265527248383,
0.11766564846038818,
0.10514865815639496,
0.5635210275650024,
-0.8115710020065308,
0.05974695831537247,
-0.4343945384025574,
0.22426608204841614,
-0.4744180738925934,
-0.20986175537109375,
-0.11261456459760666,
-0.3870469629764557,
-0.2968071401119232,
-0.44284915924072266,
-0.3250865042209625,
-0.21140263974666595,
0.5196035504341125,
0.2403341382741928,
-0.4319351613521576,
-0.5373636484146118,
-0.631332278251648,
0.9568629860877991,
-0.7426689863204956,
0.3107968270778656,
0.4151180386543274,
0.32715529203414917,
0.025461765006184578,
-0.3488060235977173,
-0.6471889019012451,
0.03381230682134628,
-0.036836136132478714,
-0.1366158127784729,
-0.49633896350860596,
-0.17401324212551117,
0.05734045058488846,
0.2190409153699875,
-0.6758309006690979,
-0.012260505929589272,
-0.10935523360967636,
-0.4235744774341583,
0.8113022446632385,
0.02712678723037243,
0.7491010427474976,
-0.4929267466068268,
-0.4042970538139343,
0.11773698776960373,
-0.3962826132774353,
-0.15404365956783295,
0.6876506209373474,
0.4321480393409729,
-0.24497775733470917,
0.19029363989830017,
-0.3295193016529083,
0.15021604299545288,
-0.10854671150445938,
0.030741048976778984,
0.4421553611755371,
-0.31040841341018677,
-0.0025965296663343906,
-0.06828726828098297,
1.1796926259994507,
0.5418329834938049,
0.48304641246795654,
-0.0011086795711889863,
-0.1969260573387146,
0.38800376653671265,
0.1774430125951767,
-0.7364704608917236,
-0.12673352658748627,
0.024613654240965843,
-0.41963404417037964,
-0.7121484279632568,
-0.04614706709980965,
-0.9282116889953613,
-0.9565554261207581,
0.12309946119785309,
0.20907457172870636,
-0.2859059274196625,
-0.6984431147575378,
0.14816272258758545,
0.144696444272995,
0.15350431203842163,
0.09308779984712601,
-0.4772884249687195,
0.29705607891082764,
0.535490095615387,
0.6176731586456299,
-0.34922924637794495,
0.2613290846347809,
-0.4427589774131775,
0.06698871403932571,
-0.14983688294887543,
0.7931216955184937,
-0.6609909534454346,
-0.3506043553352356,
0.27534061670303345,
0.06630043685436249,
0.3444576561450958,
-0.4770902395248413,
1.1167445182800293,
-0.39367711544036865,
0.22056327760219574,
-0.3464670181274414,
-0.14217203855514526,
-0.5837453007698059,
0.3981572091579437,
-0.5767318606376648,
0.9015764594078064,
0.012430351227521896,
-1.1539970636367798,
0.21314656734466553,
-0.5305165648460388,
-0.8912535309791565,
0.2691115736961365,
-0.020454570651054382,
-0.5269220471382141,
-0.20775306224822998,
0.03208884596824646,
0.542499303817749,
-0.19365054368972778,
0.3496541976928711,
-0.48846158385276794,
-0.34340783953666687,
0.23501743376255035,
-0.49650633335113525,
1.0798618793487549,
0.48513758182525635,
-0.6647792458534241,
0.2997049391269684,
-0.46122294664382935,
-0.08191809058189392,
0.1769534945487976,
-0.1555551439523697,
-0.5728919506072998,
0.055710747838020325,
0.40136295557022095,
0.4037831425666809,
0.09800256788730621,
-0.6379061341285706,
-0.5459834337234497,
-0.29838690161705017,
0.13053560256958008,
0.6765538454055786,
0.32453420758247375,
0.28761276602745056,
-0.09843013435602188,
0.7201838493347168,
0.16270166635513306,
0.44343674182891846,
0.006649293936789036,
-0.19164976477622986,
-0.5423704981803894,
-0.07572561502456665,
-0.16374507546424866,
0.7941555976867676,
-0.689627468585968,
0.7024760842323303,
-0.14856210350990295,
-0.3168749511241913,
-0.21211892366409302,
0.4899194836616516,
0.5124654769897461,
0.27148663997650146,
0.28589197993278503,
-0.5609360337257385,
-0.7744941115379333,
-0.8227885961532593,
-0.49061405658721924,
-0.3263511657714844,
0.1685076206922531,
0.19212554395198822,
0.22341522574424744,
-0.4245731830596924,
0.3993896245956421,
-0.14023657143115997,
-0.6972491145133972,
-0.30285948514938354,
-0.02867480367422104,
-0.029660018160939217,
0.40955355763435364,
0.6604534983634949,
-1.0234992504119873,
-0.8707440495491028,
0.017054853960871696,
-0.9905340075492859,
-0.44738271832466125,
0.1647685170173645,
-0.3178892433643341,
0.12109585106372833,
0.3461476266384125,
0.045977722853422165,
0.35840585827827454,
0.5494420528411865,
-0.43105918169021606,
0.2869417071342468,
0.4197324514389038,
0.2763507068157196,
-0.9760118722915649,
0.08673936128616333,
0.4359041452407837,
-0.31627100706100464,
-0.7665866017341614,
0.10137536376714706,
-0.17505310475826263,
0.10769295692443848,
-0.6975266337394714,
0.4726048409938812,
0.04075608029961586,
0.6311706304550171,
-0.37755286693573,
0.05378395691514015,
-0.09845761209726334,
0.36288732290267944,
0.06581547856330872,
0.492427259683609,
0.5578266382217407,
-0.38624709844589233,
0.2906908690929413,
0.06540071219205856,
-0.08372803032398224,
0.7286165356636047,
-0.36174264550209045,
-0.11904502660036087,
-0.201541468501091,
-0.0962359756231308,
-0.6956444382667542,
-0.008446458727121353,
0.8689196109771729,
-0.594799280166626,
0.0676368772983551,
-0.11100275814533234,
-0.591284453868866,
0.01141267828643322,
-0.7082132697105408,
0.3349766731262207,
0.26230937242507935,
-0.21098299324512482,
0.6050312519073486,
0.8320258259773254,
-0.2466331571340561,
-0.6451682448387146,
-0.6494774222373962,
0.2194095104932785,
-0.490060955286026,
-0.538762092590332,
-0.08174429833889008,
-0.07843846827745438,
-0.42251071333885193,
0.12803031504154205,
0.007864316925406456,
-0.19149279594421387,
0.3882625102996826,
0.3981216847896576,
-0.10599610209465027,
0.04287608712911606,
0.003029600717127323,
0.24077898263931274,
-0.1445271074771881,
0.4075109362602234,
0.10877969115972519,
0.4728294909000397,
-0.24605631828308105,
-0.18051740527153015,
-0.5122530460357666,
0.583278477191925,
0.39107459783554077,
-0.34514570236206055,
0.3932744860649109,
1.0090810060501099,
-0.5075094699859619,
-0.2536759376525879,
-0.3712257146835327,
0.12716494500637054,
-0.5224128365516663,
0.39041364192962646,
0.09148672223091125,
-0.753879964351654,
0.40148839354515076,
0.02977670356631279,
-0.11708300560712814,
0.3374433219432831,
0.5068104267120361,
0.0537477545440197,
1.129574179649353,
0.6776344180107117,
-0.4191451966762543,
0.5430671572685242,
0.020356126129627228,
0.39057502150535583,
-0.4499591588973999,
-0.02934104949235916,
-0.4501652419567108,
0.09408663213253021,
-0.7147667407989502,
-0.3471372723579407,
0.25088587403297424,
-0.05818754807114601,
-0.34206244349479675,
0.20002534985542297,
-0.3052108585834503,
0.4119258522987366,
0.17697884142398834,
0.06139873340725899,
0.31284213066101074,
0.07039796561002731,
-0.05791624262928963,
-0.03555778041481972,
-0.2580040693283081,
-0.8991218209266663,
0.7642267942428589,
0.4219834804534912,
0.7287189960479736,
0.3897022008895874,
0.5517856478691101,
0.858112096786499,
0.36840924620628357,
-0.7251430153846741,
0.613586962223053,
-0.40747687220573425,
-0.8653820753097534,
-0.08762646466493607,
-0.32380226254463196,
-0.4568924009799957,
0.1838299185037613,
-0.3381950557231903,
-0.6422263979911804,
0.12934117019176483,
0.08181269466876984,
-0.13624784350395203,
0.48394209146499634,
-0.44036442041397095,
0.849125325679779,
-0.3978413939476013,
-0.7002843022346497,
-0.2579251229763031,
-0.5424383282661438,
0.4961302578449249,
-0.15463261306285858,
0.8216598033905029,
-0.34122756123542786,
-0.036622002720832825,
0.565612256526947,
0.08893194049596786,
1.1750082969665527,
-0.44222939014434814,
-0.2749132812023163,
0.37747353315353394,
0.35628870129585266,
0.10761071741580963,
0.10084525495767593,
-0.18827319145202637,
0.30392396450042725,
-0.14905372262001038,
-0.2120850384235382,
-0.11440883576869965,
0.7036470174789429,
-0.3622394800186157,
-0.2710527181625366,
-0.3863282799720764,
-0.20566537976264954,
-0.13756370544433594,
0.4671187400817871,
-0.08430401235818863,
0.05780038982629776,
-0.41431593894958496,
0.06284661591053009,
0.7036095261573792,
-0.6657766103744507,
0.22853733599185944,
0.34834060072898865,
-0.25729674100875854,
-0.3159894645214081,
1.1881189346313477,
-0.27359312772750854,
-0.05720771104097366,
0.1116802990436554,
0.2928294539451599,
-0.28051576018333435,
-0.5728760957717896,
-0.4708195626735687,
0.012825481593608856,
-0.8300431966781616,
-0.3417075574398041,
-0.724600076675415,
0.004415517672896385,
-0.4100037217140198,
0.035812389105558395,
-0.10359648615121841,
-0.05337700620293617,
-0.01558500062674284,
-0.03207078203558922,
-0.00405430281534791,
0.5616956949234009,
-0.2742254436016083,
0.16116349399089813,
-0.9463170766830444,
0.2851008474826813,
-0.006456845439970493,
0.43979352712631226,
-0.004483907017856836,
-0.216142937541008,
-0.1502717286348343,
0.08340255916118622,
-0.24047686159610748,
-0.9459724426269531,
0.34647461771965027,
0.14124764502048492,
0.550685703754425,
0.7844520211219788,
0.4982641041278839,
0.17479410767555237,
-0.1061684787273407,
0.5475706458091736,
0.052882418036460876,
-0.8759011626243591,
0.58917236328125,
-0.4698083996772766,
-0.11092448234558105,
0.6512216925621033,
0.6612430810928345,
-0.8897804617881775,
-0.6851984858512878,
-0.2624926269054413,
-0.8567361235618591,
0.3941490948200226,
0.1490146666765213,
0.6065019965171814,
-0.33673006296157837,
0.01814045011997223,
0.15154977142810822,
0.19575659930706024,
-0.8618563413619995,
-0.17106015980243683,
-0.29138150811195374,
-0.3953346312046051,
0.21075616776943207,
-0.20807543396949768,
-0.030620211735367775,
-0.1135859414935112,
0.9482259750366211,
-0.03031853958964348,
-0.02401214838027954,
-0.13442225754261017,
-0.5375286340713501,
-0.4118865728378296,
0.3880576491355896,
0.056599631905555725,
0.22091692686080933,
0.09166879206895828,
0.2211710512638092,
0.05632534623146057,
-0.5574970245361328,
-0.06313833594322205,
0.014301390387117863,
-0.44459500908851624,
-0.15382413566112518,
0.38606077432632446,
0.4071913957595825,
0.10277089476585388,
-0.8532387614250183,
0.9160861372947693,
-0.1672474890947342,
0.14290179312229156,
-0.4455626308917999,
0.15564373135566711,
-0.1337500810623169,
0.1384495198726654,
0.2792207598686218,
-0.16692374646663666,
0.5348725318908691,
-0.46966710686683655,
0.3809894621372223,
0.525952160358429,
-0.774444043636322,
-0.36795344948768616,
0.4547045826911926,
0.3926030695438385,
0.013918254524469376,
0.025735866278409958,
-0.521271288394928,
-0.9646892547607422,
0.31986406445503235,
0.23837867379188538,
0.9225292205810547,
-0.21221493184566498,
0.4750835597515106,
0.4381621778011322,
0.3839327394962311,
0.3891996145248413,
0.552736222743988,
-0.1713077276945114,
-0.8529280424118042,
-0.29247766733169556,
-0.8630342483520508,
-0.09282603114843369,
-0.011345049366354942,
-0.6540849208831787,
0.1660764366388321,
-0.8299855589866638,
-0.058250270783901215,
-0.011198586784303188,
0.2035355567932129,
-0.3366868793964386,
0.3687661290168762,
0.4384157657623291,
0.5665411353111267,
-1.27028489112854,
0.5138272643089294,
0.8256955742835999,
-0.5216187834739685,
-0.4281446635723114,
0.10779593139886856,
0.43779271841049194,
-0.610842764377594,
0.34868887066841125,
0.2174868881702423,
-0.4359424114227295,
-0.19888541102409363,
-0.4455222189426422,
-0.25818395614624023,
0.4987344443798065,
0.0488729327917099,
-0.2540608048439026,
0.4379890263080597,
0.3404349386692047,
0.7367251515388489,
-0.10001382231712341,
-0.08543559908866882,
0.37688106298446655,
0.5447982549667358,
-0.07811014354228973,
-0.518386721611023,
0.5177677869796753,
-0.556965708732605,
-0.14659810066223145,
0.2596464157104492,
-0.48029625415802,
0.511099100112915,
0.1532704085111618,
-0.5842342972755432,
-0.04558754712343216,
0.3239850401878357,
-0.19945645332336426,
0.2722605764865875,
0.7364070415496826,
0.467406302690506,
0.32043027877807617,
0.08087038993835449,
0.6244708895683289,
-0.3148103952407837,
0.24593698978424072,
0.8003380298614502,
-0.1806066930294037,
0.7071685194969177,
0.1854424774646759,
-0.03088138811290264,
0.6622903943061829,
0.2761642634868622,
-0.015074487775564194,
0.5118659138679504,
0.24745765328407288,
-0.6342555284500122,
-0.4013083577156067,
-0.6930001974105835,
-0.18850532174110413,
0.469136506319046,
0.5401639342308044,
-0.5361292362213135,
-0.3369850218296051,
0.13721635937690735,
0.29572075605392456,
0.5903335213661194,
-0.33904722332954407,
0.8941320180892944,
0.06526614725589752,
-0.10451669245958328,
0.15506665408611298,
0.28326594829559326,
1.0220777988433838,
-0.4077731668949127,
0.06451188027858734,
-0.19245469570159912,
0.19363006949424744,
-0.4515581727027893,
-0.8134039044380188,
0.6017837524414062,
0.2700394093990326,
0.22338134050369263,
-0.10248131304979324,
1.2032126188278198,
-0.2584022879600525,
-0.4852712154388428,
0.6284328103065491,
0.6273684501647949,
-0.007177275139838457,
-0.17989017069339752,
-0.8636936545372009,
0.3091298043727875,
-0.07087112218141556,
-0.009811450727283955,
0.2163032740354538,
0.5025761723518372,
-0.3984452486038208,
0.4510176181793213,
0.638733983039856,
-0.0037568011321127415,
0.03848522901535034,
0.28092047572135925,
1.0000312328338623,
-0.5605452060699463,
-0.5975245237350464,
-0.7218057513237,
0.5280683636665344,
-0.29904842376708984,
0.04530605301260948,
0.8545724749565125,
0.4774481952190399,
1.0570952892303467,
0.35190433263778687,
1.104690432548523,
-0.3305666744709015,
0.4887266457080841,
0.017709219828248024,
0.8929693102836609,
-0.5965043902397156,
0.3154577910900116,
-0.6452252864837646,
-0.7784995436668396,
-0.7292492985725403,
0.7566193342208862,
-0.16091188788414001,
-0.04726007208228111,
0.4454171359539032,
0.9109855890274048,
0.012618576176464558,
0.1668769121170044,
0.20580941438674927,
0.20977914333343506,
0.35052335262298584,
0.3822319209575653,
0.8413313031196594,
-0.3242485821247101,
0.7752178311347961,
-0.6698036789894104,
-0.20205819606781006,
0.03345924988389015,
-0.8957067728042603,
-1.1379501819610596,
-0.3145020306110382,
-0.3988291025161743,
-0.4204044044017792,
0.29750508069992065,
0.8212592005729675,
0.4215606153011322,
-1.1746697425842285,
-0.1491084098815918,
0.1931818425655365,
0.15391872823238373,
-0.021837903186678886,
-0.23438666760921478,
0.18788830935955048,
-0.09514155983924866,
-0.6495181322097778,
0.027611158788204193,
0.32129526138305664,
-0.22477373480796814,
-0.45720651745796204,
-0.11575264483690262,
-0.2766338586807251,
-0.055416304618120193,
0.727645993232727,
0.3413398563861847,
-0.3730558156967163,
-0.4658779501914978,
-0.050548940896987915,
-0.15659427642822266,
-0.17050236463546753,
0.5360572338104248,
-0.33700209856033325,
0.46048444509506226,
0.5281476378440857,
0.659183144569397,
0.007804313208907843,
-0.11002065241336823,
0.24513746798038483,
-0.8659493923187256,
0.05633403733372688,
0.43769776821136475,
0.1967826634645462,
0.617506206035614,
-0.514200747013092,
0.42048510909080505,
0.19051414728164673,
-0.035956405103206635,
-0.7174121737480164,
0.32936975359916687,
-0.836107075214386,
-0.3214656114578247,
1.3046646118164062,
-0.2034597247838974,
-0.22902911901474,
-0.5171369314193726,
-0.3369261622428894,
0.4755740463733673,
-0.557188868522644,
0.9155772924423218,
0.4938468933105469,
0.21929991245269775,
0.0333411879837513,
-0.4476672410964966,
0.4068692922592163,
0.23423375189304352,
-0.8217834234237671,
0.10722538828849792,
0.5990294218063354,
0.43094417452812195,
0.06024938449263573,
0.5469202399253845,
-0.4633806049823761,
0.3437586724758148,
-0.3982490003108978,
0.04305928200483322,
-0.05640426278114319,
-0.06620146334171295,
-0.43999141454696655,
0.24178680777549744,
-0.13269482553005219,
-0.021729741245508194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01267v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01267v1
|
Dissecting Language Models: Machine Unlearning via Selective Pruning
| 2024-03-02T17:10:44 | 2024-03-02T17:10:44 |
Nicholas Pochinkov, Nandi Schoots
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Understanding and shaping the behaviour of Large Language Models (LLMs) is
increasingly important as applications become more powerful and more frequently
adopted. This paper introduces a machine unlearning method specifically
designed for LLMs. We introduce a selective pruning method for LLMs that
removes neurons based on their relative importance on a targeted capability
compared to overall network performance. This approach is a compute- and
data-efficient method for identifying and removing neurons that enable specific
behaviours. Our findings reveal that both feed-forward and attention neurons in
LLMs are specialized; that is, for specific tasks, certain neurons are more
crucial than others.
|
[
-0.34132206439971924,
-0.9198459982872009,
0.31646373867988586,
-0.06216873601078987,
-0.3858836889266968,
0.36080896854400635,
-0.5195518136024475,
-0.010194976814091206,
0.08676189929246902,
0.6660182476043701,
-0.8410897254943848,
-0.13561555743217468,
-0.5166028141975403,
-0.13026954233646393,
-0.6809722781181335,
0.8481045365333557,
0.21970608830451965,
-0.012297233566641808,
-0.294262558221817,
-0.054974596947431564,
-0.43398317694664,
-0.5478219985961914,
-0.735856294631958,
-0.813421905040741,
0.8284966349601746,
0.26602494716644287,
0.5244678854942322,
0.7209430932998657,
0.33640626072883606,
0.44927963614463806,
-0.6799112558364868,
0.2368548959493637,
-0.8229398131370544,
0.2167542427778244,
-0.2533166706562042,
-0.5513331294059753,
-0.2727922201156616,
-0.04930571839213371,
0.8563036322593689,
0.990641713142395,
-0.09938064217567444,
0.04118536040186882,
0.4481239318847656,
0.676666259765625,
-0.432464599609375,
-0.010082479566335678,
-0.953301191329956,
0.10427281260490417,
-0.21406620740890503,
-0.13056355714797974,
-0.6502386927604675,
0.07658681273460388,
-0.12731993198394775,
-0.24285422265529633,
0.4014846980571747,
-0.37952178716659546,
0.6598852872848511,
0.3154066801071167,
-0.3460920453071594,
0.08353740721940994,
-0.7706372737884521,
1.0128229856491089,
-0.2471376210451126,
0.16345816850662231,
0.38859981298446655,
0.11708901822566986,
-0.2121559977531433,
-0.7718189358711243,
-0.19078831374645233,
-0.013976175338029861,
-0.24186880886554718,
-0.13151587545871735,
-0.26329997181892395,
0.20978668332099915,
0.28234729170799255,
0.38288986682891846,
-0.5473787784576416,
0.3567441999912262,
-0.67205810546875,
-0.20902341604232788,
0.5039768218994141,
0.08406005799770355,
0.4463791251182556,
0.06587239354848862,
0.016378723084926605,
0.22047053277492523,
-0.9438253045082092,
-0.1530466228723526,
0.5730497241020203,
0.0877087414264679,
0.5200167894363403,
0.7079116702079773,
-0.062381334602832794,
0.8831288814544678,
-0.2266356199979782,
-0.092229925096035,
0.1275324821472168,
0.2017289400100708,
-0.40332698822021484,
-0.15284627676010132,
0.7284308671951294,
-0.009239324368536472,
0.691199779510498,
-0.49866071343421936,
-0.5553653240203857,
0.022332515567541122,
0.503460705280304,
-0.47979477047920227,
-0.2882004380226135,
0.20929493010044098,
-0.6091887950897217,
-0.44335925579071045,
-0.4206849932670593,
-0.43271303176879883,
-0.2544477880001068,
-0.4443938434123993,
0.1966119110584259,
-0.4605693817138672,
-0.528256893157959,
-0.1530863642692566,
-0.3331426978111267,
-0.020544100552797318,
0.10868620872497559,
-0.9779589176177979,
0.29074010252952576,
0.7498748302459717,
0.6616036891937256,
-0.3566195070743561,
-0.3906534016132355,
-0.4286007285118103,
0.12198334187269211,
-0.29559481143951416,
0.37809672951698303,
-0.8110565543174744,
-0.41319653391838074,
-0.27739417552948,
0.36110249161720276,
-0.08323001861572266,
-1.0112898349761963,
0.2758665084838867,
-0.7174900770187378,
-0.19644612073898315,
-0.06696546077728271,
-0.4190109968185425,
-0.5454535484313965,
0.027489105239510536,
-0.6998670697212219,
0.6430373787879944,
0.08973154425621033,
-0.5077107548713684,
0.015100536867976189,
-0.48044353723526,
-0.7710597515106201,
-0.01180582121014595,
-0.06917909532785416,
-0.3450394868850708,
0.43764007091522217,
0.06170998141169548,
0.5724866390228271,
-0.16769559681415558,
0.6205801367759705,
-0.2992464005947113,
-0.26342156529426575,
0.1814800500869751,
-0.6065316200256348,
0.9862335920333862,
0.5025803446769714,
-0.05934686213731766,
0.4530205726623535,
-0.7521985769271851,
-0.010722469538450241,
0.3316560685634613,
-0.2638987898826599,
-0.2650792598724365,
0.29520383477211,
-0.32317668199539185,
0.08146410435438156,
0.15210680663585663,
-0.35694944858551025,
0.2036622315645218,
-0.610576331615448,
1.2707669734954834,
0.7805310487747192,
-0.07531169056892395,
0.6190990805625916,
-0.3533600866794586,
0.40211254358291626,
0.1417255997657776,
0.1258772611618042,
-0.11136242002248764,
-0.41929155588150024,
-0.8320539593696594,
-0.48260900378227234,
0.22532092034816742,
0.18891160190105438,
-0.5255365371704102,
0.3197678327560425,
0.10297774523496628,
-0.46677330136299133,
-0.6195405125617981,
0.4709837734699249,
0.3587090075016022,
0.3280755281448364,
0.2452334761619568,
-0.2120169848203659,
-0.6142310500144958,
-1.0938007831573486,
-0.4221853017807007,
-0.048877689987421036,
-0.1984289437532425,
0.0029990358743816614,
0.29795101284980774,
-0.2228909283876419,
0.8735855221748352,
-0.36926135420799255,
-0.01164272055029869,
-0.5429951548576355,
-0.0909302830696106,
0.20596230030059814,
0.3100311756134033,
0.17122238874435425,
-0.8423014283180237,
-0.20506539940834045,
0.044768694788217545,
-0.7024364471435547,
0.15466320514678955,
-0.18507684767246246,
0.22427593171596527,
-0.2590712308883667,
0.5765942931175232,
-0.6905840039253235,
0.48748743534088135,
0.4777570962905884,
0.1936621069908142,
0.3346599340438843,
-0.1431465446949005,
-0.3901476263999939,
-0.5520541667938232,
0.12494000047445297,
-0.04099218547344208,
-0.23775511980056763,
-0.7382212281227112,
-0.014272080734372139,
0.09796933829784393,
-0.0915917232632637,
-0.5090253949165344,
0.5240094065666199,
-0.8301506638526917,
-0.34905102849006653,
-0.4581087827682495,
0.07341297715902328,
0.024779530242085457,
0.633148729801178,
0.1967046856880188,
0.5646946430206299,
0.6068031787872314,
-0.7827767729759216,
0.2930992841720581,
0.0038784858770668507,
-0.41554149985313416,
-0.45952993631362915,
-0.6450222134590149,
0.12861067056655884,
-0.2207220047712326,
-0.33403053879737854,
-1.0177196264266968,
0.18112291395664215,
0.07179602235555649,
-0.3558137118816376,
0.4938002824783325,
-0.2893557846546173,
-0.35731828212738037,
-0.2700880467891693,
0.10413707792758942,
0.3666163682937622,
0.7454332113265991,
-0.5249772667884827,
0.4851386845111847,
0.747840404510498,
-0.24762561917304993,
-0.41429048776626587,
-0.6297121047973633,
-0.11634618788957596,
-0.3290901780128479,
-0.3455272912979126,
0.5498957633972168,
0.09730108827352524,
-0.4580840468406677,
-0.0625617504119873,
-0.0417557954788208,
-0.2734432816505432,
0.40409114956855774,
0.403919517993927,
-0.01588662900030613,
-0.006777364294975996,
0.2244303971529007,
0.008825741708278656,
-0.1457703709602356,
0.0734405592083931,
0.07671412080526352,
0.7926356792449951,
0.3165179491043091,
-0.46974828839302063,
-0.4202704131603241,
0.23712976276874542,
0.7358974814414978,
-0.628900408744812,
0.5805703401565552,
0.4916146695613861,
-0.24761587381362915,
-0.5608824491500854,
-0.23422938585281372,
-0.5849577188491821,
-0.5963939428329468,
0.6315674781799316,
-0.3149533271789551,
-0.8312391638755798,
0.3883526623249054,
-0.2639175057411194,
0.28432682156562805,
0.15538328886032104,
0.647326648235321,
0.09153212606906891,
1.2834227085113525,
0.7361159324645996,
-0.3709005117416382,
0.6515260338783264,
-0.2091640830039978,
0.3730242848396301,
-0.9342779517173767,
-0.26335203647613525,
-0.46830928325653076,
-0.4936455488204956,
-0.3186599910259247,
-0.20718131959438324,
-0.09101931005716324,
0.20766466856002808,
-0.01979474164545536,
0.21002909541130066,
-0.875584602355957,
0.6581907272338867,
0.46383020281791687,
0.18945367634296417,
0.17917753756046295,
0.19366203248500824,
-0.16123275458812714,
0.14208893477916718,
-0.7069032192230225,
-0.6612610816955566,
1.020379662513733,
0.4656040370464325,
0.4960799217224121,
-0.09756229817867279,
0.41798385977745056,
-0.14643636345863342,
0.48771366477012634,
-0.989109992980957,
0.7712830305099487,
-0.25133076310157776,
-0.7140130400657654,
-0.42703118920326233,
-0.5632151365280151,
-1.1268709897994995,
0.451069712638855,
0.21258383989334106,
-0.8717958331108093,
-0.28517240285873413,
0.04609701409935951,
-0.20485177636146545,
0.7078208923339844,
-0.8709461688995361,
0.5573484301567078,
-0.2537728548049927,
-0.2784007787704468,
-0.5095608234405518,
-0.22183941304683685,
0.4497610330581665,
-0.0012456277618184686,
0.11879117041826248,
-0.18811966478824615,
-0.033523011952638626,
0.806970477104187,
-0.2688431441783905,
1.1736388206481934,
-0.05162502080202103,
0.10530732572078705,
0.433170348405838,
0.4305374324321747,
0.4519566297531128,
-0.1637635976076126,
-0.19461041688919067,
0.1205865815281868,
-0.3129729926586151,
-0.21253341436386108,
-0.3488253057003021,
0.770320475101471,
-0.8436957001686096,
-0.896941065788269,
0.037731993943452835,
-0.5470017790794373,
-0.2411566823720932,
0.19256864488124847,
-0.06088227033615112,
0.3014029264450073,
-0.24051135778427124,
0.17335595190525055,
0.7468112111091614,
-0.251102089881897,
0.8995246887207031,
0.4831711947917938,
-0.2669176459312439,
-0.10407902300357819,
1.0770472288131714,
0.2960304617881775,
0.09579295665025711,
0.39671117067337036,
-0.029674462974071503,
-0.0836469829082489,
-0.9104381203651428,
0.005463885143399239,
0.36696553230285645,
-0.621796727180481,
0.09501855820417404,
-0.5972608923912048,
-0.49428707361221313,
-0.11614379286766052,
0.08922760933637619,
-0.3154848515987396,
-0.2925125062465668,
-0.6986430287361145,
-0.23186999559402466,
0.22117629647254944,
0.9125196933746338,
0.17133410274982452,
0.646746039390564,
-0.8534250855445862,
0.28863853216171265,
0.36535048484802246,
0.22037968039512634,
0.17104476690292358,
-0.6384636163711548,
0.1483796238899231,
-0.00009212725854013115,
-0.39715495705604553,
-0.8179976940155029,
0.8880069851875305,
0.2204495072364807,
0.8919844031333923,
0.7131607532501221,
-0.19489158689975739,
0.5770344734191895,
-0.5810877680778503,
0.39604443311691284,
0.39430129528045654,
-0.7562889456748962,
0.5312313437461853,
-0.2268187403678894,
0.26683309674263,
0.19856415688991547,
0.44270265102386475,
-0.5188324451446533,
-0.18159426748752594,
-0.7498161792755127,
-0.8903003334999084,
0.8124157190322876,
0.06390226632356644,
0.08987753838300705,
-0.018797079101204872,
0.6043815612792969,
0.05270111933350563,
0.367133229970932,
-0.5317341089248657,
-0.26732000708580017,
0.3267555832862854,
-0.11567861586809158,
-0.5272676944732666,
-0.42862558364868164,
-0.2476433962583542,
-0.41593337059020996,
0.4715489149093628,
0.14579766988754272,
-0.011062055826187134,
-0.2480114847421646,
-0.45048558712005615,
-0.06598979979753494,
0.001589526771567762,
0.25198790431022644,
0.7934024333953857,
0.10973584651947021,
0.16057389974594116,
0.16476038098335266,
-0.46077626943588257,
0.15804551541805267,
-0.6999796628952026,
-0.20962898433208466,
-0.026867160573601723,
0.3687364161014557,
0.560430645942688,
0.00574873061850667,
-0.64072585105896,
0.17525462806224823,
0.009550290182232857,
-0.25139057636260986,
-0.047874510288238525,
0.3631938695907593,
0.3035680949687958,
-0.025092989206314087,
0.06611302495002747,
0.20893092453479767,
-0.09527423977851868,
-0.6044871211051941,
0.3728434145450592,
0.3590985834598541,
-0.7077246904373169,
-0.5162057876586914,
0.05953821912407875,
0.3351902365684509,
-0.6406812071800232,
0.8622844219207764,
-0.007383190095424652,
-0.3690686821937561,
0.8490040302276611,
0.5477063059806824,
0.9344912767410278,
-0.3513289988040924,
0.25218039751052856,
0.13674630224704742,
0.548725426197052,
-0.05736612528562546,
0.0571051687002182,
0.0454668328166008,
-0.8155202865600586,
-0.755367636680603,
-0.6224672794342041,
0.01994163542985916,
0.5797264575958252,
-0.6649162173271179,
0.04086301848292351,
-0.7279832363128662,
-0.24833416938781738,
0.34322062134742737,
-0.10956373810768127,
-0.4059748649597168,
0.14745394885540009,
-0.0178376454859972,
0.7355353236198425,
-0.7146642208099365,
1.2818728685379028,
0.763413667678833,
-0.055032879114151,
-0.6238945722579956,
-0.3171517848968506,
0.09893729537725449,
-0.9393748044967651,
0.6652529239654541,
0.09624714404344559,
0.0063528683967888355,
0.12133506685495377,
-0.4574500620365143,
-0.6382099986076355,
0.5995147228240967,
0.6242995262145996,
-1.0524064302444458,
0.1400335431098938,
-0.10529135912656784,
0.12450843304395676,
-0.11457347869873047,
0.4271775186061859,
0.5707172155380249,
0.3755590617656708,
-0.16693048179149628,
-0.6488752365112305,
-0.1552838534116745,
-0.1851748377084732,
-0.19951023161411285,
0.4001820385456085,
-0.7138839364051819,
0.9594282507896423,
-0.15807107090950012,
-0.19364260137081146,
-0.20277859270572662,
0.43636590242385864,
0.07607918977737427,
-0.0830204039812088,
0.625227689743042,
0.35286808013916016,
1.0516092777252197,
-0.08080070465803146,
0.48978662490844727,
-0.24061737954616547,
0.033549435436725616,
0.9223921298980713,
-0.38619714975357056,
0.7088232040405273,
0.8183443546295166,
-0.08512195944786072,
-0.04934083670377731,
0.7450928092002869,
0.20492149889469147,
0.6346479058265686,
0.6109976172447205,
-0.15033024549484253,
-0.5431836843490601,
0.15075846016407013,
0.1399613320827484,
0.5288786292076111,
0.5575130581855774,
-0.48404401540756226,
-0.21166366338729858,
0.04987727105617523,
0.00006579028558917344,
0.03183355554938316,
-0.4841881990432739,
0.9230743050575256,
0.22721563279628754,
-0.8237454295158386,
0.632131814956665,
0.1649782508611679,
0.4076809883117676,
-0.57492995262146,
0.04404781013727188,
-0.1950969398021698,
0.44237780570983887,
-0.3114696145057678,
-0.6017158031463623,
0.5459245443344116,
0.021071380004286766,
-0.40317824482917786,
-0.4984779953956604,
0.8076775670051575,
-0.24076621234416962,
-0.1946486234664917,
0.6786715984344482,
0.5475146770477295,
0.3239511251449585,
-0.2704682946205139,
-0.8190813660621643,
0.22976845502853394,
0.5245306491851807,
-0.6555331945419312,
0.7906692028045654,
0.46145930886268616,
-0.06633776426315308,
1.0897243022918701,
0.7361249327659607,
0.18768222630023956,
-0.2381892204284668,
0.18157409131526947,
1.2337472438812256,
-0.7193928360939026,
-0.12018712610006332,
-1.1587047576904297,
0.4759639501571655,
-0.053117536008358,
-0.24250173568725586,
0.565509557723999,
0.4185682535171509,
0.6129258275032043,
0.16288697719573975,
0.8052160739898682,
0.30021920800209045,
0.3774290978908539,
-0.348228394985199,
0.9459888935089111,
-0.5364587903022766,
0.5598751902580261,
0.3004058599472046,
-0.79195237159729,
-0.1299596130847931,
0.5837237238883972,
-0.4805201292037964,
0.14107787609100342,
0.5988099575042725,
1.094849944114685,
-0.1040806770324707,
0.09261825680732727,
0.675903856754303,
0.2838864028453827,
0.21009384095668793,
0.2849924862384796,
1.0751510858535767,
0.18618887662887573,
0.6605328917503357,
-0.29625198245048523,
-0.24449729919433594,
-0.08114014565944672,
-0.6105495095252991,
-1.1089544296264648,
-0.3956531882286072,
-0.37197577953338623,
0.11929243057966232,
0.12539809942245483,
0.3051517605781555,
0.8748573064804077,
-0.7698222994804382,
-0.37107327580451965,
-0.253070205450058,
0.5452753901481628,
-0.30633923411369324,
-0.12799467146396637,
0.20693561434745789,
-0.5480849742889404,
-0.5862483382225037,
0.8116295337677002,
0.37526416778564453,
-0.27114802598953247,
-0.436015784740448,
0.08209049701690674,
-0.09601065516471863,
-0.13938504457473755,
0.5093864798545837,
0.2920673191547394,
-0.6517833471298218,
0.06346389651298523,
-0.0833483412861824,
0.05367324873805046,
-0.04424124211072922,
0.9849459528923035,
-0.7208859920501709,
0.12158727645874023,
0.5559316277503967,
0.35237014293670654,
0.4179672300815582,
-0.2980320155620575,
0.7322695851325989,
-0.9779425859451294,
0.4617331922054291,
0.4913441836833954,
0.4809076488018036,
0.12127695977687836,
-0.14466170966625214,
0.2057931274175644,
0.16497302055358887,
-0.5216333866119385,
-1.1180998086929321,
0.27858424186706543,
-0.48651593923568726,
-0.8802868723869324,
1.2933992147445679,
-0.23459458351135254,
-0.8449413776397705,
-0.21564722061157227,
-0.18280190229415894,
0.280188649892807,
-0.12578052282333374,
0.3610554039478302,
0.47528213262557983,
0.19951176643371582,
-0.33578184247016907,
-0.5884199142456055,
0.3727697730064392,
0.6849380135536194,
-0.2908165156841278,
0.3904353678226471,
0.18673156201839447,
0.40394899249076843,
-0.12261389195919037,
0.425235390663147,
-0.1557736098766327,
-0.20304632186889648,
-0.15525609254837036,
0.2648509740829468,
-0.16192106902599335,
-0.6913855075836182,
-0.535491943359375,
0.5377137660980225,
0.2281600683927536,
-0.2617071866989136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04783v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04783v1
|
AutoDefense: Multi-Agent LLM Defense against Jailbreak Attacks
| 2024-03-02T16:52:22 | 2024-03-02T16:52:22 |
Yifan Zeng, Yiran Wu, Xiao Zhang, Huazheng Wang, Qingyun Wu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Despite extensive pre-training and fine-tuning in moral alignment to prevent
generating harmful information at user request, large language models (LLMs)
remain vulnerable to jailbreak attacks. In this paper, we propose AutoDefense,
a response-filtering based multi-agent defense framework that filters harmful
responses from LLMs. This framework assigns different roles to LLM agents and
employs them to complete the defense task collaboratively. The division in
tasks enhances the overall instruction-following of LLMs and enables the
integration of other defense components as tools. AutoDefense can adapt to
various sizes and kinds of open-source LLMs that serve as agents. Through
conducting extensive experiments on a large scale of harmful and safe prompts,
we validate the effectiveness of the proposed AutoDefense in improving the
robustness against jailbreak attacks, while maintaining the performance at
normal user request. Our code and data are publicly available at
https://github.com/XHMY/AutoDefense.
|
[
-0.5810081958770752,
-0.9083224534988403,
0.39854520559310913,
0.11815355718135834,
-0.00664886087179184,
0.4881044924259186,
0.03739066421985626,
-0.5607850551605225,
0.24271927773952484,
0.7095584869384766,
-0.5641090273857117,
-0.50983065366745,
-0.5593271851539612,
0.1897612363100052,
-0.38427063822746277,
0.8826703429222107,
0.12899865210056305,
-0.1133812889456749,
0.0715281069278717,
0.04585538059473038,
-0.6489608287811279,
-0.5408729910850525,
-0.6871114373207092,
-0.014581273309886456,
0.4008873403072357,
0.34306058287620544,
0.5955946445465088,
0.446850061416626,
0.6105144619941711,
0.395922988653183,
0.3204020857810974,
-0.06289932131767273,
-0.036938972771167755,
0.7911633253097534,
-0.25895044207572937,
-0.2258668839931488,
-0.6841837763786316,
0.040397047996520996,
0.0077676246874034405,
-0.19270826876163483,
-0.26500630378723145,
-0.14543786644935608,
-0.13728328049182892,
0.47118136286735535,
-0.7855223417282104,
-0.3841557502746582,
-0.6833796501159668,
-0.06407009810209274,
0.057029157876968384,
0.2872922122478485,
-0.5467158555984497,
-0.23239828646183014,
-0.08902963250875473,
-0.137939915060997,
-0.249439999461174,
0.17794987559318542,
0.3829376697540283,
0.2889541983604431,
-0.26831820607185364,
-0.16677021980285645,
-0.18947364389896393,
0.3691156208515167,
-0.743033766746521,
0.060335658490657806,
0.42385610938072205,
0.23541001975536346,
-0.5608496069908142,
-0.2724635899066925,
-0.4647673964500427,
-0.4711993336677551,
0.08875305950641632,
0.010017179884016514,
-0.5486268997192383,
0.36348336935043335,
0.02092243731021881,
0.06807807087898254,
-0.8041313886642456,
0.3080395758152008,
0.02344255894422531,
-0.39931720495224,
0.726386308670044,
0.2622027099132538,
0.6994513869285583,
-0.08435045182704926,
-0.599217414855957,
-0.12386809289455414,
-0.6557934880256653,
0.10793706774711609,
0.5252615213394165,
0.035806119441986084,
-0.14758647978305817,
0.4207330048084259,
-0.14756223559379578,
0.6556307077407837,
0.2339693158864975,
-0.09206615388393402,
-0.062105245888233185,
-0.25528985261917114,
-0.19448640942573547,
0.057054243981838226,
0.9571927785873413,
0.42203861474990845,
0.18629415333271027,
-0.289861798286438,
-0.29184895753860474,
-0.02319357544183731,
0.46525368094444275,
-1.0502878427505493,
-0.10070033371448517,
0.3088512122631073,
-0.2977573573589325,
-0.7046253681182861,
0.2656340003013611,
-0.9321606755256653,
-0.8995205760002136,
0.2567451298236847,
0.16611585021018982,
-0.3531126379966736,
-0.26039865612983704,
0.34946775436401367,
0.0735228881239891,
0.16731837391853333,
0.020581398159265518,
-0.6166865229606628,
0.5085315108299255,
0.4680369198322296,
0.73039710521698,
-0.2865717113018036,
-0.42139336466789246,
-0.9654757976531982,
0.20884296298027039,
-0.10377590358257294,
1.0045336484909058,
-0.23757095634937286,
-0.5534508228302002,
-0.4090292155742645,
0.04055115208029747,
-0.2566002607345581,
-0.5059398412704468,
0.2378605306148529,
-0.7933282256126404,
-0.31395527720451355,
0.20134970545768738,
-0.40733802318573,
-0.03608269616961479,
0.472847580909729,
-0.7562628984451294,
0.5203972458839417,
0.018970279023051262,
-0.602918803691864,
-0.022147946059703827,
-0.6157255172729492,
-0.6033437848091125,
-0.057541560381650925,
0.05454001575708389,
-0.38040679693222046,
-0.09078894555568695,
0.3383387625217438,
0.30836221575737,
-0.3631124198436737,
0.20683389902114868,
-0.7614104151725769,
0.05903562158346176,
0.25824329257011414,
-0.28945431113243103,
0.7496665120124817,
0.5946044325828552,
-0.49768802523612976,
0.4340285360813141,
-0.5036704540252686,
0.009901745244860649,
0.2948716878890991,
-0.17199945449829102,
-0.3811517357826233,
0.11049102991819382,
-0.2827070355415344,
0.24627986550331116,
0.24448160827159882,
-0.8327281475067139,
0.2802355885505676,
-0.5567780137062073,
0.35223397612571716,
0.7509644031524658,
0.15434971451759338,
0.4263528287410736,
-0.3539346158504486,
0.809940755367279,
-0.009747766889631748,
0.5462793111801147,
-0.2344713658094406,
-0.3079683184623718,
-0.07271271198987961,
-0.5303099155426025,
-0.31145811080932617,
0.9123949408531189,
-0.6507085561752319,
0.5763168931007385,
0.36603471636772156,
-0.37619340419769287,
-0.37604066729545593,
0.447674959897995,
0.3179652690887451,
0.32312601804733276,
0.40316420793533325,
-0.44470906257629395,
-0.5718696713447571,
-0.7196208238601685,
-0.3094853162765503,
-0.4373752474784851,
0.26149171590805054,
-0.026403142139315605,
0.30202028155326843,
-0.48286211490631104,
0.8933351635932922,
-0.5347394943237305,
-0.12471991032361984,
-0.28550583124160767,
-0.21950632333755493,
-0.009967186488211155,
0.34958574175834656,
0.9719131588935852,
-0.2924792766571045,
-0.559689462184906,
-0.4362032413482666,
-0.6891497373580933,
-0.554853618144989,
0.08380887657403946,
-0.10486303269863129,
0.12769542634487152,
0.7502766251564026,
-0.6423588395118713,
0.39728298783302307,
0.34630611538887024,
-0.8116359114646912,
0.6846386194229126,
-0.12027589976787567,
0.07048286497592926,
-1.1549016237258911,
-0.43736574053764343,
-0.12329846620559692,
-0.4592353105545044,
-0.6641582250595093,
0.2676001489162445,
-0.04584631696343422,
0.014491740614175797,
-0.4021395444869995,
0.6205733418464661,
-0.20817342400550842,
0.16623122990131378,
-0.7760761976242065,
0.20585225522518158,
0.16244959831237793,
-0.05045328661799431,
-0.3526356816291809,
1.0040464401245117,
0.6165279746055603,
-0.3373895585536957,
0.9021850228309631,
0.1478486955165863,
-0.16607765853405,
0.6994463205337524,
-0.7171255350112915,
0.2583298683166504,
-0.05664890259504318,
0.3800569474697113,
-0.9561554789543152,
-0.09933637827634811,
0.4596617519855499,
-0.35448792576789856,
0.07038765400648117,
-0.24991977214813232,
-0.5313829183578491,
-0.5156668424606323,
-0.6720200181007385,
0.12011686712503433,
0.11099743843078613,
-0.5690951347351074,
0.5974990129470825,
0.5337039828300476,
-0.3312343657016754,
-0.5848209857940674,
-0.39176395535469055,
0.5497827529907227,
-0.5328974723815918,
-0.7833861112594604,
0.0011184279574081302,
-0.5272694826126099,
-0.5364835262298584,
-0.17547565698623657,
0.06624404340982437,
-0.1473167985677719,
0.6524868011474609,
0.41150423884391785,
0.49027299880981445,
-0.012838704511523247,
-0.16662372648715973,
-0.14049680531024933,
0.015350968576967716,
0.5155825018882751,
-0.30458566546440125,
0.5671306848526001,
-0.19981813430786133,
-0.42673295736312866,
-0.23786108195781708,
0.5401121973991394,
0.9609560370445251,
-0.42575204372406006,
0.7392857670783997,
0.49566367268562317,
0.04437282308936119,
-0.273422509431839,
-0.5707252025604248,
-0.40499818325042725,
-0.5604792833328247,
0.3552166819572449,
-0.31460997462272644,
-0.988010048866272,
0.4191131889820099,
0.14991098642349243,
0.05127432569861412,
0.03902488574385643,
0.5849397778511047,
0.013142166659235954,
0.8697015047073364,
0.3686198592185974,
-0.7794865965843201,
0.6294684410095215,
0.050550393760204315,
0.09078144282102585,
-0.562465250492096,
-0.04142165556550026,
-0.4554968476295471,
0.13941602408885956,
-0.3700736463069916,
0.11131109297275543,
0.17986755073070526,
-0.15147794783115387,
-0.4768178164958954,
0.6413678526878357,
-0.41684654355049133,
0.5466505885124207,
0.31935447454452515,
0.06421671062707901,
0.15150032937526703,
-0.19485560059547424,
-0.19204430282115936,
0.5277424454689026,
-0.3538456857204437,
-0.48234936594963074,
0.9848031997680664,
0.45308300852775574,
1.2226406335830688,
0.4986282289028168,
0.9060972332954407,
0.6901558041572571,
0.28196215629577637,
-0.666820228099823,
0.6962187886238098,
-0.04013554006814957,
-0.7862163186073303,
-0.18425388634204865,
-0.21737068891525269,
-0.8363848328590393,
0.5369430184364319,
0.025538288056850433,
-0.8417143225669861,
-0.001369303441606462,
0.0003369735204614699,
-0.6289412975311279,
0.4195635914802551,
-0.7278831005096436,
0.7223256230354309,
-0.5314651727676392,
-0.3578377366065979,
-0.3645004332065582,
-0.6043667197227478,
0.3582926094532013,
-0.2774120271205902,
0.44044065475463867,
-0.34673237800598145,
0.24619373679161072,
0.5030308365821838,
-0.6987819075584412,
1.031718134880066,
-0.47645679116249084,
-0.23126880824565887,
0.6001064777374268,
0.3313443958759308,
0.6730729937553406,
0.4306344985961914,
-0.011103744618594646,
-0.4074312448501587,
0.048672281205654144,
-0.16374455392360687,
-0.3214896619319916,
0.7047567367553711,
-0.685359001159668,
-1.0079965591430664,
-0.3498811721801758,
-0.6353079080581665,
0.06772147119045258,
0.2383478730916977,
-0.062347520142793655,
0.04911324754357338,
-0.19182142615318298,
-0.09609542042016983,
0.7540039420127869,
-0.3247961699962616,
0.8570753335952759,
0.928130030632019,
-0.2643844783306122,
-0.7264521718025208,
0.49939149618148804,
-0.3023967146873474,
0.2031998336315155,
-0.07447715103626251,
0.1407192349433899,
-0.2087770253419876,
-0.591222882270813,
-0.4490644037723541,
-0.13417837023735046,
-0.4408552348613739,
-0.6833879351615906,
-0.5848222970962524,
-0.21101826429367065,
-0.6764134764671326,
0.02502431534230709,
-0.2776337265968323,
-0.11163116246461868,
0.11054275929927826,
-0.17910034954547882,
0.6307513117790222,
0.6267709136009216,
-0.2920081913471222,
0.48748719692230225,
-0.8418467044830322,
0.549984335899353,
0.3045959174633026,
0.22203119099140167,
-0.1502424031496048,
-0.5219234824180603,
-0.1994168907403946,
-0.14582248032093048,
-0.45519348978996277,
-1.1104151010513306,
0.3375842869281769,
0.018942946568131447,
0.7103615403175354,
0.34867221117019653,
0.6300584077835083,
0.19704324007034302,
-0.4884657561779022,
0.35533633828163147,
0.15465228259563446,
-0.8133916258811951,
0.6069756150245667,
-0.13199461996555328,
0.16469542682170868,
0.721193253993988,
-0.19978827238082886,
-0.1453734189271927,
-0.7729882001876831,
-0.1671338975429535,
-0.8061258792877197,
0.5616036653518677,
-0.011534232646226883,
0.18334724009037018,
-0.16818830370903015,
0.23656058311462402,
-0.25372838973999023,
0.13520652055740356,
-0.7722612619400024,
-0.18071873486042023,
-0.3537156879901886,
-0.17149576544761658,
0.2635539472103119,
-0.1886489987373352,
-0.14363741874694824,
-0.07509321719408035,
0.6607184410095215,
0.1049744039773941,
-0.025944681838154793,
0.2077196091413498,
-0.47020062804222107,
0.05514642223715782,
0.6021333932876587,
0.5959489345550537,
-0.12646737694740295,
-0.08840660005807877,
0.28488457202911377,
0.1584913283586502,
-0.9260455369949341,
0.8268508315086365,
0.2697018086910248,
-0.05306955426931381,
-0.5060985088348389,
0.28021109104156494,
0.5544593334197998,
-0.2814536690711975,
-0.7141693234443665,
0.5829159021377563,
-0.2152874618768692,
0.14102081954479218,
-0.30841776728630066,
0.5543263554573059,
-0.24151937663555145,
0.44327598810195923,
0.23516219854354858,
-0.08779627084732056,
0.11089758574962616,
-0.31379011273384094,
0.4678196310997009,
0.4777756333351135,
-0.21650096774101257,
-0.23548604547977448,
0.732977569103241,
0.162937730550766,
-0.1485191434621811,
0.36806774139404297,
-0.15366418659687042,
-0.5850242376327515,
0.9649455547332764,
0.6976712942123413,
1.1568516492843628,
-0.7768990397453308,
-0.008552178740501404,
0.029038524255156517,
0.7445533275604248,
0.1530131846666336,
0.2363671511411667,
0.05689900740981102,
-0.834162175655365,
-0.3621608316898346,
-0.43597662448883057,
-0.26948821544647217,
0.2894801199436188,
-0.3813871443271637,
-0.1467038094997406,
-0.6731299161911011,
-0.45447269082069397,
-0.2548903822898865,
-0.24628694355487823,
-0.10170929878950119,
0.06995042413473129,
0.1889677345752716,
0.9921988844871521,
-0.5357033014297485,
0.988267183303833,
0.8298390507698059,
-0.3106251060962677,
-0.5161429643630981,
-0.0026018493808805943,
0.37173402309417725,
-0.5755665898323059,
0.45397230982780457,
0.24056115746498108,
-0.6035206317901611,
-0.19849750399589539,
-0.5239861011505127,
-0.7532690167427063,
0.7491173148155212,
0.42845964431762695,
-0.4466310739517212,
0.22121362388134003,
0.0414142943918705,
0.1716851145029068,
-0.6175603270530701,
0.1499183624982834,
0.558227002620697,
0.5297103524208069,
-0.3925206959247589,
-0.6713916063308716,
0.17576757073402405,
-0.27132168412208557,
-0.2991146445274353,
0.19203132390975952,
-0.5477380752563477,
0.46836763620376587,
-0.37094226479530334,
0.2375754565000534,
0.13833209872245789,
0.3710646629333496,
0.3560383915901184,
0.36928942799568176,
0.7242133617401123,
0.607370138168335,
0.22589707374572754,
0.17115727066993713,
0.7882765531539917,
-0.5566604137420654,
-0.02053874172270298,
1.3032876253128052,
-0.5589806437492371,
0.4492621421813965,
0.1829911470413208,
0.07455971837043762,
0.5375192761421204,
0.43197786808013916,
-0.30981364846229553,
0.6926982402801514,
0.41264432668685913,
-0.5826783776283264,
-0.08378484845161438,
0.04593877121806145,
-0.1716490387916565,
0.4573896825313568,
0.26201131939888,
-0.1830262839794159,
-0.4197874665260315,
0.720732569694519,
0.2941073179244995,
0.09414359927177429,
-0.22930417954921722,
1.0078126192092896,
0.07979908585548401,
-0.49435335397720337,
0.36189964413642883,
0.2585388123989105,
0.6203517913818359,
-0.6018074154853821,
0.45662447810173035,
-0.24456088244915009,
0.21007299423217773,
-0.19466863572597504,
-0.7583295106887817,
0.3785763680934906,
0.37927693128585815,
-0.361313134431839,
-0.06932778656482697,
0.9942542314529419,
-0.0762413963675499,
0.22174333035945892,
0.9473755359649658,
0.3303585648536682,
-0.10088852047920227,
-0.2145141065120697,
-0.864037036895752,
0.11656790971755981,
-0.13024723529815674,
-0.47831088304519653,
0.43136927485466003,
-0.027609150856733322,
-0.061721544712781906,
0.7962551116943359,
0.5695631504058838,
0.05935144051909447,
0.2611585259437561,
0.07134605199098587,
1.0312774181365967,
-0.4651855528354645,
-0.4818097949028015,
-1.3363471031188965,
0.1367083042860031,
-0.19225287437438965,
0.35636675357818604,
0.7311083674430847,
0.49266317486763,
0.5375217199325562,
0.08710988610982895,
0.9748163223266602,
-0.2559843957424164,
0.27076849341392517,
-0.2805408835411072,
1.030027151107788,
-0.014133591204881668,
0.5814785361289978,
-0.3554050028324127,
-0.5754387378692627,
-0.11439947038888931,
0.4504300355911255,
-0.1961960643529892,
-0.041414421051740646,
0.5152572393417358,
0.8436958193778992,
0.19415998458862305,
-0.20994877815246582,
0.3552338778972626,
0.19566287100315094,
0.6577522158622742,
0.5059860348701477,
0.8494598865509033,
-0.15492412447929382,
0.6364582777023315,
-0.010920887812972069,
-0.29685094952583313,
0.033820852637290955,
-0.7372420430183411,
-1.1468425989151,
-0.07187879085540771,
-0.10799134522676468,
-0.4935010075569153,
0.24057412147521973,
1.1371029615402222,
0.7645353674888611,
-0.9121675491333008,
-0.37156781554222107,
0.04243917390704155,
0.14610843360424042,
0.12155241519212723,
-0.20080861449241638,
-0.06337396800518036,
-0.5339063405990601,
-0.10415884107351303,
0.9605147242546082,
0.3173149824142456,
0.11658403277397156,
-0.1409073919057846,
-0.1301521211862564,
-0.2014211118221283,
0.31975889205932617,
0.510733962059021,
0.3517514765262604,
-0.565571665763855,
-0.20027588307857513,
-0.07335496693849564,
-0.4582957923412323,
-0.1324143260717392,
0.5810458064079285,
-0.6849870681762695,
0.35993605852127075,
0.245747372508049,
0.7942678332328796,
-0.06986550241708755,
-0.1312282681465149,
0.5288895964622498,
-0.46878165006637573,
0.22966477274894714,
-0.11477211117744446,
0.4577593207359314,
0.08207585662603378,
-0.5390986204147339,
0.3909543454647064,
0.103134386241436,
-0.4993906319141388,
-0.6159808039665222,
0.6156366467475891,
-0.5433555245399475,
-0.5974360108375549,
0.9226958155632019,
-0.4029783308506012,
-0.2430954873561859,
-0.49465411901474,
-0.3207641839981079,
-0.028164833784103394,
-0.7202343344688416,
0.7652502655982971,
0.6909474730491638,
0.06859707087278366,
-0.2446795552968979,
-0.5216803550720215,
0.4111693203449249,
0.15063627064228058,
-1.1534476280212402,
0.18647190928459167,
0.5013094544410706,
0.4891531765460968,
-0.07286681979894638,
0.3808390498161316,
-0.2033509910106659,
0.38253527879714966,
-0.46954429149627686,
0.10229760408401489,
-0.3681301772594452,
-0.5105025768280029,
-0.2861948013305664,
0.2978995144367218,
0.21161894500255585,
-0.25561732053756714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01251v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01251v2
|
Accelerating Greedy Coordinate Gradient via Probe Sampling
| 2024-03-02T16:23:44 | 2024-05-27T07:02:28 |
Yiran Zhao, Wenyue Zheng, Tianle Cai, Xuan Long Do, Kenji Kawaguchi, Anirudh Goyal, Michael Shieh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Safety of Large Language Models (LLMs) has become a critical issue given
their rapid progresses. Greedy Coordinate Gradient (GCG) is shown to be
effective in constructing adversarial prompts to break the aligned LLMs, but
optimization of GCG is time-consuming. To reduce the time cost of GCG and
enable more comprehensive studies of LLM safety, in this work, we study a new
algorithm called $\texttt{Probe sampling}$. At the core of the algorithm is a
mechanism that dynamically determines how similar a smaller draft model's
predictions are to the target model's predictions for prompt candidates. When
the target model is similar to the draft model, we rely heavily on the draft
model to filter out a large number of potential prompt candidates. Probe
sampling achieves up to $5.6$ times speedup using Llama2-7b-chat and leads to
equal or improved attack success rate (ASR) on the AdvBench. Furthermore, probe
sampling is also able to accelerate other prompt optimization techniques and
adversarial methods, leading to acceleration of $1.8\times$ for AutoPrompt,
$2.4\times$ for APE and $2.4\times$ for AutoDAN.
|
[
-0.42959606647491455,
-0.7476964592933655,
0.4824085235595703,
0.25990912318229675,
-0.3613656759262085,
0.17266888916492462,
-0.10996674001216888,
-0.3020778298377991,
0.024800831452012062,
0.3147895038127899,
-0.5451292991638184,
-0.5216881036758423,
-0.699364185333252,
-0.14795245230197906,
-0.20070502161979675,
0.6614179015159607,
0.228366881608963,
0.1960921585559845,
0.24833284318447113,
0.22432024776935577,
-0.2744165062904358,
-0.2815418243408203,
-1.1757142543792725,
-0.17456328868865967,
0.6298073530197144,
0.2999787926673889,
0.4239073097705841,
1.0728026628494263,
0.43846234679222107,
0.27566736936569214,
-0.3639254570007324,
0.13973809778690338,
-0.7385172247886658,
0.4320371448993683,
0.14343881607055664,
-0.604292094707489,
-0.44708579778671265,
0.21535097062587738,
0.5399217009544373,
0.3985477387905121,
-0.3557981848716736,
-0.10335079580545425,
-0.006055857520550489,
0.58470618724823,
-0.6995803713798523,
-0.08912216871976852,
-0.7518566846847534,
-0.2568250596523285,
-0.4501350522041321,
-0.5182050466537476,
-0.42251408100128174,
-0.30316564440727234,
0.08787615597248077,
-0.8311158418655396,
0.4502900242805481,
0.2300977259874344,
0.6548078656196594,
0.26623350381851196,
-0.28163668513298035,
-0.07981882244348526,
-0.31921064853668213,
0.7410120368003845,
-0.4686968922615051,
0.12824074923992157,
0.23302794992923737,
0.5351954102516174,
-0.6444129943847656,
-0.8100482225418091,
-0.33685097098350525,
-0.3030194640159607,
0.34220460057258606,
0.14510950446128845,
-0.061835289001464844,
0.20126959681510925,
0.5877245664596558,
0.08553561568260193,
-0.540803074836731,
0.5149258971214294,
-0.3859802782535553,
-0.42917492985725403,
0.7053728103637695,
0.45215436816215515,
0.10036638379096985,
-0.04522207751870155,
-0.6785475015640259,
-0.4738638699054718,
-0.8986964821815491,
0.28314998745918274,
0.6413151621818542,
0.3605559170246124,
-0.12201377004384995,
0.1867009997367859,
-0.46277815103530884,
0.8370267152786255,
0.22717073559761047,
0.18765562772750854,
0.09128373861312866,
-0.29145705699920654,
-0.04092275723814964,
-0.015379736199975014,
0.915772020816803,
0.5289308428764343,
0.23450814187526703,
0.12381491810083389,
-0.18389388918876648,
0.27885034680366516,
0.28746476769447327,
-1.045411229133606,
-0.38902390003204346,
0.20786453783512115,
-0.15729504823684692,
-0.3396061062812805,
-0.3173519968986511,
-1.0272618532180786,
-0.6822174787521362,
0.08604889363050461,
-0.047869667410850525,
-0.2687482535839081,
-0.018880710005760193,
0.18974971771240234,
-0.10702469944953918,
0.44215887784957886,
0.44574013352394104,
-0.6553776264190674,
0.016799435019493103,
0.7304139137268066,
0.7831740975379944,
-0.3626183867454529,
-0.21054337918758392,
-1.1716587543487549,
-0.1631307154893875,
-0.5059412717819214,
0.9149330258369446,
-0.490371435880661,
-0.8006611466407776,
-0.07617054879665375,
-0.16859003901481628,
-0.04363140091300011,
-0.38814833760261536,
0.75506991147995,
-0.8594393730163574,
0.17516286671161652,
-0.5182488560676575,
-0.5037908554077148,
-0.08506245166063309,
0.4745112657546997,
-0.7994404435157776,
1.0242862701416016,
-0.040662650018930435,
-0.6781495809555054,
0.4719703495502472,
-0.422966331243515,
-0.3169552981853485,
0.20641914010047913,
-0.2405097931623459,
-0.3809692859649658,
-0.27489253878593445,
0.6428645849227905,
0.6260828971862793,
-0.6569381356239319,
0.04244038090109825,
-0.31581568717956543,
-0.6509569883346558,
-0.06724825501441956,
-0.23092786967754364,
0.9696076512336731,
0.18772083520889282,
-0.322855144739151,
0.1357252597808838,
-0.4512442946434021,
-0.040240705013275146,
0.23692673444747925,
-0.5570606589317322,
-0.22684572637081146,
-0.0779154896736145,
-0.40251338481903076,
0.029173193499445915,
0.03910006210207939,
-0.5103713274002075,
0.4243380129337311,
-0.46802929043769836,
0.048611387610435486,
0.8945403695106506,
0.18864946067333221,
0.7158759236335754,
-0.3738585412502289,
0.8950716257095337,
-0.09395309537649155,
0.03700757026672363,
-0.22314544022083282,
-0.5998027324676514,
-0.47398829460144043,
-0.5262323021888733,
0.37681275606155396,
0.5969210863113403,
-0.8950056433677673,
0.20825882256031036,
-0.1426362842321396,
-0.7427453398704529,
-0.39208588004112244,
-0.12268799543380737,
0.5044668316841125,
0.6117643117904663,
0.3037194311618805,
-0.05315309390425682,
-0.1880255788564682,
-0.5711026191711426,
-0.3351321518421173,
-0.3061280846595764,
-0.24431703984737396,
0.508979856967926,
0.02004123665392399,
-0.05747486650943756,
0.38444966077804565,
-0.7155078649520874,
-0.10388536751270294,
-0.10330929607152939,
0.23980218172073364,
0.2972923517227173,
0.40382301807403564,
0.8036532998085022,
-0.4939507842063904,
-0.4880019724369049,
-0.35852065682411194,
-0.3394882380962372,
-0.44202572107315063,
-0.09253670275211334,
-0.49057307839393616,
0.05319801717996597,
0.8187687993049622,
-0.6139135956764221,
0.16539396345615387,
0.39830857515335083,
-0.21918438374996185,
0.49998435378074646,
0.05758305639028549,
0.11352690309286118,
-0.9973116517066956,
0.01806328073143959,
0.08689875900745392,
0.009826532565057278,
-0.6370179057121277,
0.15805085003376007,
0.3325434923171997,
0.11519686132669449,
-0.6343299150466919,
0.8396285176277161,
-0.6660326719284058,
0.3813374936580658,
-0.40523967146873474,
0.4147389829158783,
-0.058098312467336655,
0.34149450063705444,
-0.2934783399105072,
0.8821512460708618,
0.9200420379638672,
-0.8410851359367371,
0.4367729425430298,
0.025271091610193253,
-0.16203293204307556,
0.40634602308273315,
-0.6196808815002441,
0.34300515055656433,
-0.0930708721280098,
0.3145727813243866,
-1.0340607166290283,
0.11998919397592545,
0.48510390520095825,
-0.696099579334259,
0.5076039433479309,
-0.26991790533065796,
-0.06243402510881424,
-0.23493169248104095,
-0.5652037858963013,
0.5903617143630981,
0.5720478892326355,
-0.6691774725914001,
0.631615161895752,
0.3655848205089569,
-0.019050240516662598,
-0.9601610898971558,
-0.17750097811222076,
-0.08439213037490845,
-0.2698443531990051,
-0.4487195909023285,
0.21579007804393768,
0.040661003440618515,
-0.16646550595760345,
-0.32424888014793396,
0.11834339797496796,
0.4738772213459015,
0.3074606955051422,
0.04448484629392624,
0.3624190092086792,
0.1274089366197586,
-0.18076331913471222,
0.026877643540501595,
-0.3093765676021576,
0.36783626675605774,
-0.3810955882072449,
0.782845675945282,
0.36541175842285156,
-0.29058143496513367,
-0.12221746146678925,
0.20631153881549835,
0.3700510263442993,
-0.0790349692106247,
0.43637675046920776,
0.6574138402938843,
-0.20731420814990997,
-0.6000373363494873,
-0.5073001384735107,
-0.44159388542175293,
-0.567527711391449,
0.49097126722335815,
-0.25031164288520813,
-0.7535537481307983,
0.7821575403213501,
-0.03889230638742447,
0.07451491057872772,
0.3141341507434845,
0.6530078053474426,
0.2426716834306717,
0.8262085914611816,
0.2973038852214813,
-0.5027104020118713,
0.5822991728782654,
-0.3035440444946289,
-0.08586887270212173,
-1.0278631448745728,
-0.2699754536151886,
-0.7000135779380798,
-0.37945157289505005,
-0.5846987962722778,
-0.7245102524757385,
0.6031190156936646,
-0.020495912060141563,
-0.0589020773768425,
0.09223967045545578,
-0.3344587981700897,
0.34305137395858765,
0.8749806880950928,
0.06105215102434158,
-0.09781796485185623,
-0.015558101236820221,
-0.5057656764984131,
0.1223621517419815,
-0.7394731640815735,
-0.0687207505106926,
1.2920176982879639,
0.19622944295406342,
1.0582056045532227,
-0.25029730796813965,
0.4893779158592224,
0.18441051244735718,
0.23029941320419312,
-0.8002614378929138,
0.9516480565071106,
0.01855139620602131,
-0.41001254320144653,
-0.21086657047271729,
-0.5444650650024414,
-1.1261065006256104,
0.31965214014053345,
-0.06471617519855499,
-0.535095751285553,
0.13421304523944855,
0.35930439829826355,
-0.3977653980255127,
0.17175652086734772,
-0.4608016610145569,
0.26704612374305725,
-0.029470451176166534,
-0.46081769466400146,
-0.07865127921104431,
-0.6844879388809204,
0.3364589810371399,
-0.016396407037973404,
-0.3881775736808777,
-0.2475125640630722,
-0.08891251683235168,
0.9117013812065125,
-0.03465694561600685,
0.5677484273910522,
-0.6562378406524658,
-0.18466372787952423,
0.34673190116882324,
0.36224278807640076,
0.9878582954406738,
0.17412781715393066,
-0.26757606863975525,
0.17194469273090363,
-0.5712862610816956,
-0.4691709578037262,
-0.5095319151878357,
0.6339303851127625,
-0.5062993168830872,
-0.8549909591674805,
-0.4990895092487335,
-0.6113098859786987,
-0.2744872570037842,
0.08370954543352127,
0.4143795371055603,
0.23464353382587433,
-0.06808386743068695,
-0.03903496265411377,
0.5402233600616455,
-0.2537080645561218,
0.4209243953227997,
0.6288902163505554,
0.09766054153442383,
-0.3409489691257477,
0.5703837871551514,
-0.1468677818775177,
0.4253946542739868,
0.17525814473628998,
0.16735361516475677,
-0.4846346378326416,
-0.8415301442146301,
-0.5431866645812988,
0.3430282175540924,
-0.40719538927078247,
-0.5269648432731628,
-0.6493451595306396,
-0.20297874510288239,
-0.30498337745666504,
-0.18457575142383575,
-0.22147423028945923,
-0.21382588148117065,
-0.3688717782497406,
-0.04616163671016693,
0.31880906224250793,
0.09271678328514099,
-0.09443654865026474,
0.566581666469574,
-0.6677948236465454,
0.30941304564476013,
0.2028590887784958,
0.02581820636987686,
-0.11949019134044647,
-0.6869922876358032,
-0.035814110189676285,
0.0613245852291584,
-0.21673047542572021,
-0.7664006352424622,
0.35980361700057983,
-0.14719614386558533,
0.7206806540489197,
0.5742281079292297,
0.2719181776046753,
0.5711984038352966,
-0.5028142333030701,
0.6715259552001953,
-0.09868942201137543,
-0.6092737317085266,
0.3051969110965729,
-0.7886416912078857,
0.34499800205230713,
0.3073433041572571,
0.33422064781188965,
-0.4837206304073334,
-0.42447152733802795,
-0.3106538653373718,
-1.098968505859375,
0.7656556963920593,
-0.03711869940161705,
-0.10438507795333862,
0.026655729860067368,
0.5532995462417603,
-0.32145529985427856,
-0.016113460063934326,
-0.17783746123313904,
-0.22626431286334991,
0.2722659111022949,
0.11757049709558487,
-0.07935980707406998,
-0.3871404826641083,
-0.3684128522872925,
0.1650085151195526,
0.636430025100708,
-0.3695923686027527,
0.4630137085914612,
0.0655817985534668,
0.22492121160030365,
-0.21330228447914124,
-0.033466845750808716,
0.5865919589996338,
0.1388479322195053,
-0.09064286202192307,
-0.005495622754096985,
0.20299437642097473,
-0.7696552872657776,
0.2359752207994461,
0.5188176035881042,
-0.2628076374530792,
-0.45138952136039734,
0.17519409954547882,
0.6173090934753418,
-0.3265298008918762,
-0.5921412706375122,
0.5438376665115356,
-0.42209744453430176,
-0.28963661193847656,
0.037159211933612823,
0.42066046595573425,
-0.08625989407300949,
0.3609077036380768,
0.5101169347763062,
-0.11538155376911163,
0.1415509134531021,
0.16610205173492432,
0.13409768044948578,
0.8350508809089661,
-0.013674509711563587,
-0.10178704559803009,
0.8774212002754211,
0.2916054427623749,
-0.21717427670955658,
0.7026357650756836,
-0.3684488832950592,
-0.6314818263053894,
0.8041285872459412,
0.43999379873275757,
0.9384731650352478,
-0.5495687127113342,
-0.017470063641667366,
0.4263319969177246,
0.3797873854637146,
-0.17438772320747375,
0.4244706332683563,
0.1300070434808731,
-0.7696150541305542,
-0.3707382082939148,
-0.429343044757843,
-0.5357683300971985,
0.15798354148864746,
-0.5734767317771912,
0.2076379358768463,
-0.4302300810813904,
-0.1106724813580513,
-0.4230020046234131,
0.11549755930900574,
-0.4814753830432892,
0.18806897103786469,
0.1327109932899475,
1.1177371740341187,
-0.6446331143379211,
0.6475771069526672,
0.4805174767971039,
0.5026460289955139,
-0.9912910461425781,
0.16425934433937073,
0.09640512615442276,
-1.063023328781128,
0.5503705143928528,
0.17427921295166016,
-0.4407942593097687,
0.04820462688803673,
-0.5100623965263367,
-0.8744834065437317,
1.073589563369751,
0.4602110981941223,
-0.6874593496322632,
0.0007052112487144768,
-0.16749835014343262,
0.3903985619544983,
-0.06350218504667282,
0.234442338347435,
0.510762631893158,
0.2671602666378021,
0.14456084370613098,
-0.5408161282539368,
0.3575109839439392,
-0.3718668520450592,
0.03316478431224823,
0.3403623402118683,
-0.7123664617538452,
0.877443790435791,
-0.3152410387992859,
-0.40778273344039917,
0.014507540501654148,
0.6397209167480469,
0.6990965604782104,
0.08486099541187286,
0.8081958889961243,
0.5840898156166077,
0.8754113912582397,
-0.3084803521633148,
1.0258581638336182,
-0.5466861128807068,
0.12133034318685532,
0.802595317363739,
-0.4728521704673767,
0.38953256607055664,
0.38481512665748596,
0.001775395474396646,
0.05219650641083717,
0.8208262324333191,
-0.03561995550990105,
0.5194153189659119,
0.48524391651153564,
-0.3550209403038025,
-0.13834162056446075,
-0.11294771730899811,
-0.3736339211463928,
0.3512311577796936,
0.4049372673034668,
-0.217750683426857,
-0.17471599578857422,
-0.1586722582578659,
0.3118067979812622,
-0.21225503087043762,
-0.292643278837204,
0.47313904762268066,
-0.06753721833229065,
-0.9382569193840027,
0.7864504456520081,
0.092183418571949,
0.6277713179588318,
-0.5785501599311829,
0.12304449081420898,
-0.36021050810813904,
0.1748126745223999,
0.30246326327323914,
-0.5224639177322388,
-0.3128722310066223,
-0.19629321992397308,
0.26473507285118103,
-0.09719910472631454,
0.7175313830375671,
-0.33042001724243164,
-0.25281187891960144,
0.5759952664375305,
0.49700188636779785,
-0.16290774941444397,
-0.1385260373353958,
-0.49434882402420044,
0.014485055580735207,
-0.1613718569278717,
-0.7206318378448486,
0.16806671023368835,
0.31106269359588623,
0.018360428512096405,
0.9296072721481323,
0.8807288408279419,
0.4547256827354431,
0.3449469804763794,
-0.07725085318088531,
1.3365848064422607,
-0.5773831605911255,
-0.6997316479682922,
-0.9650785326957703,
0.34211522340774536,
-0.027257202193140984,
-0.3331708312034607,
0.7750696539878845,
0.3799620568752289,
0.7490518689155579,
0.19549864530563354,
0.5492267608642578,
0.11280348151922226,
0.618431806564331,
-0.8424001336097717,
0.7464634776115417,
-0.36330410838127136,
0.40540263056755066,
-0.14478638768196106,
-0.7835081219673157,
-0.3298076391220093,
0.30100375413894653,
-0.2997448444366455,
0.20129160583019257,
0.6072044372558594,
1.169173240661621,
0.15478703379631042,
-0.26958760619163513,
0.12079949676990509,
0.08810752630233765,
0.6633219122886658,
0.6930605173110962,
0.8758953809738159,
-0.2977226674556732,
0.5488208532333374,
-0.21867726743221283,
-0.27133920788764954,
-0.24824896454811096,
-0.999158501625061,
-1.129469633102417,
-0.239210844039917,
-0.07614731788635254,
-0.5943183898925781,
0.1145467683672905,
0.7703565359115601,
0.7718492150306702,
-0.4785378873348236,
-0.03749136999249458,
-0.07644032686948776,
-0.15699893236160278,
-0.03540465608239174,
-0.20123903453350067,
0.4073544442653656,
-0.3491392135620117,
-1.0524678230285645,
0.7097799181938171,
-0.001566752907820046,
0.07003209739923477,
-0.17816439270973206,
-0.0883418396115303,
-0.1543651968240738,
0.039245106279850006,
-0.02848873846232891,
0.32567229866981506,
-0.30362170934677124,
0.03363708406686783,
0.2247314453125,
-0.2666456997394562,
-0.06089361757040024,
0.9302592873573303,
-0.8635141253471375,
0.4897087812423706,
0.6215524673461914,
0.9142789840698242,
0.4747256934642792,
0.4290589988231659,
0.7285341024398804,
-0.6897293329238892,
0.41709452867507935,
0.40908199548721313,
0.36592867970466614,
0.12853838503360748,
-0.7152285575866699,
0.34787824749946594,
0.25853511691093445,
-0.7161003947257996,
-0.8233041763305664,
0.3522877097129822,
-0.9940710067749023,
0.03146270662546158,
1.4353114366531372,
-0.28021878004074097,
-0.263275146484375,
0.1499643176794052,
-0.29085245728492737,
0.4359053075313568,
-0.7471494674682617,
0.9219238758087158,
0.3246895372867584,
-0.03928545489907265,
0.008649980649352074,
-0.28355538845062256,
0.7863529920578003,
0.669922411441803,
-0.745316207408905,
0.057413067668676376,
0.5138195753097534,
0.05705752968788147,
-0.08294948935508728,
0.6892956495285034,
-0.00009981857147067785,
0.4178287088871002,
0.04686181992292404,
-0.18881845474243164,
-0.3519076406955719,
-0.36912035942077637,
-0.5237841010093689,
0.20203861594200134,
-0.07464519143104553,
-0.4965571165084839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04782v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04782v1
|
A Survey on Temporal Knowledge Graph: Representation Learning and Applications
| 2024-03-02T16:21:45 | 2024-03-02T16:21:45 |
Li Cai, Xin Mao, Yuhao Zhou, Zhaoguang Long, Changxu Wu, Man Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge graphs have garnered significant research attention and are widely
used to enhance downstream applications. However, most current studies mainly
focus on static knowledge graphs, whose facts do not change with time, and
disregard their dynamic evolution over time. As a result, temporal knowledge
graphs have attracted more attention because a large amount of structured
knowledge exists only within a specific period. Knowledge graph representation
learning aims to learn low-dimensional vector embeddings for entities and
relations in a knowledge graph. The representation learning of temporal
knowledge graphs incorporates time information into the standard knowledge
graph framework and can model the dynamics of entities and relations over time.
In this paper, we conduct a comprehensive survey of temporal knowledge graph
representation learning and its applications. We begin with an introduction to
the definitions, datasets, and evaluation metrics for temporal knowledge graph
representation learning. Next, we propose a taxonomy based on the core
technologies of temporal knowledge graph representation learning methods, and
provide an in-depth analysis of different methods in each category. Finally, we
present various downstream applications related to the temporal knowledge
graphs. In the end, we conclude the paper and have an outlook on the future
research directions in this area.
|
[
-0.2892840504646301,
-0.5736985802650452,
0.7104625105857849,
0.07720538973808289,
-0.2157747447490692,
0.7178246974945068,
0.17455391585826874,
-0.576042115688324,
0.27008089423179626,
0.06621907651424408,
-0.4458591639995575,
-0.7021540999412537,
-0.5431966781616211,
-0.26675912737846375,
-0.19982263445854187,
0.3645414710044861,
-0.22975094616413116,
-0.08666667342185974,
-0.2207852154970169,
-0.3154681324958801,
-0.5000982284545898,
-0.516160249710083,
-0.7487345933914185,
-0.7647219300270081,
0.8122565150260925,
0.023520508781075478,
0.03096492402255535,
0.6735039949417114,
-0.17844416201114655,
0.27811095118522644,
0.017430931329727173,
0.10829036682844162,
-0.3156639337539673,
0.22653165459632874,
-0.1354568749666214,
-0.15970808267593384,
-0.21607661247253418,
0.07639185339212418,
0.9091722965240479,
1.1545435190200806,
-0.06132791191339493,
0.31754788756370544,
0.012961168773472309,
0.3860788941383362,
-0.6669310331344604,
0.8587656021118164,
-0.23287734389305115,
0.4102593958377838,
-0.5042899250984192,
-0.4228629469871521,
-0.36614087224006653,
-0.6870007514953613,
0.1661282181739807,
-0.5465379357337952,
-0.10915683954954147,
0.2902989089488983,
0.48074203729629517,
0.041762951761484146,
-1.1616885662078857,
-0.08561685681343079,
-0.8286121487617493,
0.705420970916748,
-0.2920216917991638,
0.7248020768165588,
-0.190090149641037,
0.9414878487586975,
0.05997205153107643,
-1.0530200004577637,
-0.2454337775707245,
-0.026661761105060577,
0.004830359946936369,
0.24856992065906525,
-0.2484988421201706,
-0.0991826131939888,
0.20351706445217133,
0.12583579123020172,
-0.5429965257644653,
0.15950897336006165,
-0.0020965319126844406,
-0.20642635226249695,
0.21223212778568268,
0.5238862037658691,
0.036353059113025665,
-0.01922541856765747,
-0.5240572094917297,
-0.03363240510225296,
-0.46079567074775696,
0.09781000763177872,
0.2301066517829895,
-0.10596973448991776,
0.06105616316199303,
0.5333422422409058,
-0.27112144231796265,
0.8564124703407288,
-0.2525850236415863,
-0.03254508227109909,
0.21092699468135834,
0.007796482183039188,
0.00016708829207345843,
0.02907172031700611,
0.5291430950164795,
0.35173675417900085,
0.10682564973831177,
-0.5666667819023132,
0.0762491449713707,
-0.16678495705127716,
0.006869731470942497,
-0.5654558539390564,
-0.03464579954743385,
-0.055804040282964706,
-0.5997685790061951,
-0.18604886531829834,
-0.13941675424575806,
-0.582422137260437,
-0.3652391731739044,
-0.36053672432899475,
-0.05833456665277481,
-0.5569212436676025,
-0.3639772832393646,
-0.2089638113975525,
-0.44415974617004395,
0.1634155809879303,
0.3136759102344513,
-0.5503079295158386,
0.37773045897483826,
0.4857810437679291,
0.7638956904411316,
-0.06254243850708008,
-0.1552382856607437,
-0.06888484954833984,
0.6398424506187439,
-0.32253673672676086,
0.64711594581604,
-0.5117794275283813,
-0.44402679800987244,
0.003768101567402482,
-0.04317628592252731,
-0.2430400848388672,
-0.3522845506668091,
-0.061980877071619034,
-1.164931058883667,
-0.16287031769752502,
-0.23854410648345947,
-0.835785448551178,
-0.5485394597053528,
0.3455735445022583,
-0.6050719618797302,
0.6373704075813293,
0.361061155796051,
-0.7582725882530212,
0.6534222364425659,
-0.5724022388458252,
-0.2689037621021271,
0.13064275681972504,
-0.16638408601284027,
-0.17171572148799896,
-0.2582550346851349,
0.05149875208735466,
0.5753574967384338,
0.028377896174788475,
-0.07250944525003433,
-0.30245548486709595,
-0.09326425939798355,
0.08087226003408432,
0.09251987189054489,
0.6737492084503174,
0.4067723751068115,
-0.04584259167313576,
-0.16347476840019226,
-0.3924066126346588,
-0.125570610165596,
0.3649900257587433,
-0.1607062965631485,
-0.4107680916786194,
0.2776421904563904,
-0.3080919086933136,
-0.0022423677146434784,
0.307850182056427,
-0.5425626039505005,
0.3867964744567871,
0.1122356727719307,
0.7218288779258728,
0.6345409750938416,
0.7372692823410034,
0.48599040508270264,
-0.06606559455394745,
0.461515873670578,
0.449074387550354,
0.18157373368740082,
0.23228813707828522,
-0.342240571975708,
-0.21826788783073425,
0.41002294421195984,
0.6719251275062561,
0.3830018639564514,
-1.0005738735198975,
0.05904167518019676,
-0.6605076789855957,
-0.6751956939697266,
0.42898479104042053,
-0.12800709903240204,
-0.09653566777706146,
0.7119928598403931,
0.29741498827934265,
-0.13139647245407104,
-0.577468991279602,
-0.4732311964035034,
-0.18190371990203857,
-0.6257769465446472,
0.1838587373495102,
0.4585009515285492,
0.33796241879463196,
-0.31136032938957214,
1.1254642009735107,
-0.8021794557571411,
-0.07833036035299301,
-0.09251906722784042,
0.40817251801490784,
-0.045694347470998764,
0.06528957188129425,
1.0352119207382202,
-0.6614497303962708,
-0.06887990236282349,
-0.005963482428342104,
-0.7374142408370972,
0.3231414556503296,
0.0738816186785698,
-0.0872785747051239,
0.10307655483484268,
0.5380715727806091,
-0.15979258716106415,
0.1432304084300995,
0.3392804265022278,
-0.2435341477394104,
0.20538629591464996,
0.14599573612213135,
0.032333724200725555,
-0.7701386213302612,
-0.04147585481405258,
-0.00816219300031662,
-0.5535617470741272,
-0.05915851145982742,
-0.3620282709598541,
-0.009832752868533134,
-0.40863704681396484,
-0.32867980003356934,
0.6670563817024231,
-0.3844367563724518,
-0.07461930066347122,
0.274077445268631,
0.1913498491048813,
-0.3266757130622864,
0.45727893710136414,
0.10878404974937439,
0.1539732813835144,
0.3422447443008423,
-0.825333833694458,
0.5031479001045227,
-0.006982254795730114,
-0.2264019101858139,
0.09910953789949417,
-0.41367676854133606,
0.08060946315526962,
-0.09596984088420868,
0.08571875095367432,
-0.5427454113960266,
-0.0846150740981102,
0.4111713767051697,
-0.5034626722335815,
0.5559304356575012,
-0.5714046359062195,
-0.5044484734535217,
-0.4055466651916504,
0.09074606001377106,
0.28374388813972473,
0.5065440535545349,
-0.37366926670074463,
0.688664972782135,
0.6277766823768616,
0.27645790576934814,
-0.5195913910865784,
-0.45662975311279297,
-0.32035011053085327,
-0.012583614327013493,
-0.33625251054763794,
0.3243049085140228,
0.6001490950584412,
-0.14241957664489746,
0.5970441699028015,
-0.4679601788520813,
0.14849045872688293,
-0.12400170415639877,
0.035275720059871674,
-0.1427517533302307,
-0.1255449503660202,
0.4882027506828308,
-0.04270927980542183,
-0.2609863579273224,
0.0551660917699337,
-0.7448625564575195,
0.5072811245918274,
0.15324074029922485,
-0.46491482853889465,
0.30895623564720154,
0.02126341499388218,
0.24905754625797272,
-0.1093774065375328,
0.8909658789634705,
0.7465900182723999,
-0.48187655210494995,
-0.011485472321510315,
-0.16963206231594086,
0.1396179348230362,
-0.3866881728172302,
0.2449522167444229,
0.10094071179628372,
-0.8038039207458496,
0.4992533028125763,
-0.6495910286903381,
0.10829932987689972,
0.6203373670578003,
0.20590081810951233,
-0.25487983226776123,
0.7656136155128479,
0.5567525625228882,
-0.21254833042621613,
0.8983300924301147,
-0.7394405007362366,
0.11459892243146896,
-0.693205714225769,
-0.6125515103340149,
-0.39792725443840027,
-0.46140486001968384,
-0.6311971545219421,
-0.07770068943500519,
0.4255337119102478,
0.16212984919548035,
-0.6493211984634399,
0.07595868408679962,
-0.22908379137516022,
-0.014696120284497738,
0.13915084302425385,
0.14154240489006042,
0.19121119379997253,
0.03933917358517647,
-0.20674671232700348,
0.012788130901753902,
-0.6794766187667847,
-0.3072395324707031,
0.7663490772247314,
0.34563735127449036,
0.6411301493644714,
0.04718253016471863,
0.7397839426994324,
0.6213537454605103,
0.03163696452975273,
-0.8172585964202881,
0.42812493443489075,
-0.11228900402784348,
-0.27770906686782837,
-0.3289865255355835,
-0.895217776298523,
-0.8648873567581177,
-0.4658248722553253,
0.07882088422775269,
-0.6092668175697327,
0.45474758744239807,
0.03684158995747566,
0.02122265100479126,
0.6932398676872253,
-0.899458646774292,
0.7807064056396484,
-0.23227733373641968,
0.01523909904062748,
-0.21942728757858276,
-0.43570560216903687,
-0.012088585644960403,
0.41618290543556213,
-0.03576295077800751,
-0.07384402304887772,
-0.11893247812986374,
1.0490922927856445,
-0.36554327607154846,
0.9208272695541382,
-0.8201248049736023,
0.40940186381340027,
0.5363672375679016,
-0.056194815784692764,
0.3394903838634491,
0.21030524373054504,
0.1971893310546875,
0.21837347745895386,
0.2137162685394287,
-0.4366968870162964,
-0.8147650361061096,
0.31275632977485657,
-0.7686397433280945,
-0.3190804719924927,
-0.6562502980232239,
-0.13835927844047546,
-0.45101287961006165,
0.32055068016052246,
-0.08196766674518585,
0.5507091879844666,
-0.14880599081516266,
-0.003974615130573511,
0.5221925377845764,
0.06527213752269745,
0.4417724907398224,
0.16356119513511658,
-0.41299083828926086,
-0.22901076078414917,
0.9974009990692139,
0.5414102077484131,
-0.113838329911232,
0.7409749031066895,
0.0908493772149086,
-0.5199942588806152,
-0.6049256324768066,
-0.035308048129081726,
0.15947288274765015,
-0.7993165254592896,
-0.18459732830524445,
-0.7714858651161194,
-0.25309062004089355,
-0.5184800624847412,
0.28172236680984497,
0.08045858144760132,
-0.8348746299743652,
-0.22170329093933105,
-0.05314195528626442,
0.73765629529953,
0.9866631031036377,
0.056977529078722,
0.1767372488975525,
-0.7495676279067993,
0.18462982773780823,
0.6667634844779968,
0.4507100284099579,
0.4955073893070221,
0.28544560074806213,
-0.3627774119377136,
-0.10301502794027328,
-0.5326298475265503,
-0.9350412487983704,
-0.07696196436882019,
0.12014363706111908,
0.9267873167991638,
0.47006791830062866,
0.04565957933664322,
0.557806134223938,
-0.1820322424173355,
0.846044659614563,
-0.053086429834365845,
-0.6346450448036194,
0.3621123135089874,
-0.3200743496417999,
0.026403140276670456,
-0.03917313739657402,
0.6760366559028625,
-0.8812002539634705,
0.13077469170093536,
-0.4794832766056061,
-0.7582270503044128,
0.23681536316871643,
-0.09308674186468124,
-0.08659524470567703,
0.21698376536369324,
0.5678284764289856,
-0.19444003701210022,
0.18848489224910736,
-0.04677063971757889,
-0.3850291967391968,
-0.5462189316749573,
-0.010119323618710041,
0.049703095108270645,
-0.08878856152296066,
0.0968218669295311,
-0.11344210058450699,
0.4462970495223999,
-0.23728016018867493,
0.7730920910835266,
-0.15350548923015594,
-0.12751036882400513,
0.2220546305179596,
0.30880817770957947,
0.04448403790593147,
0.7664828896522522,
-0.2319592833518982,
-0.024739408865571022,
0.12552088499069214,
-0.6197383403778076,
0.13432595133781433,
0.11802303791046143,
-0.03632179647684097,
0.06863314658403397,
0.6322729587554932,
0.527689516544342,
0.11977869272232056,
0.02773234248161316,
0.2880651354789734,
0.04711269959807396,
0.18621514737606049,
-0.5810148119926453,
-0.06433141976594925,
0.42364439368247986,
0.43083715438842773,
0.5383440852165222,
0.1320059448480606,
-0.052872542291879654,
-0.8025937676429749,
-0.18672487139701843,
0.09076692909002304,
-0.6272104382514954,
-0.11802875995635986,
0.6084573268890381,
-0.09227246791124344,
0.24183952808380127,
0.7682695388793945,
-0.5039295554161072,
-0.5221549272537231,
0.4824793040752411,
0.21238166093826294,
0.5220080018043518,
0.09038525074720383,
0.17197120189666748,
0.2147769182920456,
-0.11911524087190628,
0.44538819789886475,
0.4156752824783325,
-0.2873283922672272,
-0.6503327488899231,
-0.22928471863269806,
-0.44119638204574585,
-0.5168209075927734,
-0.34848812222480774,
-0.4379264712333679,
0.14197739958763123,
-0.5114911198616028,
-0.6430646181106567,
-0.14526045322418213,
0.33382752537727356,
-0.8907155394554138,
-0.11861363798379898,
-0.06774485111236572,
1.2178672552108765,
-0.7823858857154846,
0.6536563634872437,
1.0639796257019043,
-0.4664309322834015,
-0.5810507535934448,
-0.13862237334251404,
0.016601940616965294,
-0.5990884900093079,
0.9311215877532959,
-0.41945192217826843,
-0.14377781748771667,
0.12895892560482025,
-0.5701091289520264,
-0.5182639956474304,
1.5137139558792114,
0.25894924998283386,
-0.2777463495731354,
-0.4292122721672058,
0.030335301533341408,
0.3985341489315033,
-0.5042348504066467,
-0.015949323773384094,
0.3899361789226532,
0.3334345519542694,
0.1528433859348297,
-0.18845981359481812,
-0.07389054447412491,
-0.22377727925777435,
0.2875310480594635,
0.1651151180267334,
-0.712449848651886,
0.5599596500396729,
0.11797719448804855,
-0.5166700482368469,
-0.3073674142360687,
0.846832811832428,
0.15177856385707855,
0.419586718082428,
0.4767484962940216,
0.32388490438461304,
0.6482219696044922,
-0.5961626172065735,
0.8930419683456421,
-0.19792436063289642,
0.2695585787296295,
0.7614132165908813,
-0.197194904088974,
0.25444096326828003,
0.22565996646881104,
-0.35310035943984985,
0.871546745300293,
1.0434719324111938,
0.07844720035791397,
0.6390472054481506,
0.06583654135465622,
-0.07082000374794006,
-0.26482391357421875,
-0.318129301071167,
-0.5581946969032288,
0.008944296278059483,
0.7089323997497559,
-0.24966974556446075,
-0.5430482029914856,
0.012529115192592144,
-0.2539507746696472,
-0.3833593428134918,
-0.5040943026542664,
0.6910122036933899,
0.12140911817550659,
0.08870647102594376,
-0.042214151471853256,
-0.14423057436943054,
0.026680178940296173,
-0.696931779384613,
-0.45447495579719543,
0.09219234436750412,
-0.11525634676218033,
-0.3139364421367645,
-0.9935098886489868,
0.24323192238807678,
-0.5118088722229004,
-0.08705850690603256,
-0.4730646312236786,
0.8243764042854309,
0.17853014171123505,
-0.029589682817459106,
0.6122300028800964,
0.5216624736785889,
-0.11258522421121597,
0.2835090458393097,
-0.353319376707077,
-0.277382493019104,
-0.5034939050674438,
-0.15285004675388336,
-0.16531743109226227,
0.6763591766357422,
-0.22818152606487274,
0.7049044966697693,
0.04828562214970589,
0.2679942548274994,
0.380033940076828,
0.2041466385126114,
0.9210744500160217,
-0.7518040537834167,
-0.42713066935539246,
-0.3530213236808777,
0.34447234869003296,
-0.06106250360608101,
-0.022856147959828377,
0.6103230714797974,
0.5385254621505737,
0.8613450527191162,
0.06710600852966309,
0.8212332725524902,
-0.3743947744369507,
0.5741305947303772,
-0.8956295847892761,
0.7714595198631287,
-0.3131674826145172,
-0.04574636369943619,
-0.047394994646310806,
-0.829852283000946,
-0.10261820256710052,
-0.18528495728969574,
-0.6646520495414734,
0.2864680886268616,
0.5708191394805908,
-0.04463926702737808,
-0.04965673014521599,
0.21216018497943878,
0.019781164824962616,
0.06582333892583847,
0.17986738681793213,
0.47361254692077637,
1.1210826635360718,
-0.23533332347869873,
0.4604912996292114,
-0.4098982810974121,
-0.06493725627660751,
-0.2543882429599762,
-0.8845673203468323,
-0.708155632019043,
-0.9380353689193726,
-0.3013712167739868,
-0.2081676572561264,
-0.02182249166071415,
0.7195124626159668,
0.7146462202072144,
-0.5604797601699829,
-0.026804884895682335,
0.2992735505104065,
0.4455459713935852,
-0.6207125782966614,
-0.20821626484394073,
0.5466464161872864,
-0.2862548530101776,
-0.3028823137283325,
0.13837401568889618,
0.023778297007083893,
0.29567235708236694,
-0.25807642936706543,
0.1575869917869568,
-0.025802388787269592,
-0.6747803688049316,
0.6500123739242554,
0.6010096669197083,
0.09267707169055939,
-0.4989751875400543,
0.29281169176101685,
0.281179815530777,
0.008472592569887638,
1.3859386444091797,
-0.8919233083724976,
0.34106820821762085,
0.9371628165245056,
0.3686479926109314,
1.0684800148010254,
-0.33229124546051025,
0.318342000246048,
-0.9007518291473389,
-0.03997534513473511,
0.2845056354999542,
0.6999027729034424,
0.13619929552078247,
-0.31687837839126587,
0.5571615695953369,
0.5603387355804443,
-0.3358345925807953,
-0.2284037172794342,
0.42442554235458374,
-0.9968381524085999,
-0.08268706500530243,
0.5534045696258545,
-0.08289909362792969,
-0.45390620827674866,
-0.5776276588439941,
0.484551340341568,
0.9315686821937561,
-0.466766357421875,
0.49625688791275024,
0.5292798280715942,
-0.5188443064689636,
-0.15307217836380005,
-0.4980720281600952,
0.09963817149400711,
-0.6106424331665039,
-0.45631587505340576,
-0.17663003504276276,
0.16643396019935608,
0.3012530207633972,
0.39034128189086914,
0.4964978098869324,
-0.5336896181106567,
-0.11625546962022781,
0.004517003428190947,
-0.20947377383708954,
-0.3886180520057678,
-0.19150201976299286,
0.033814672380685806,
0.19589215517044067,
0.1779126524925232,
-0.22783192992210388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01248v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01248v1
|
SceneCraft: An LLM Agent for Synthesizing 3D Scene as Blender Code
| 2024-03-02T16:16:26 | 2024-03-02T16:16:26 |
Ziniu Hu, Ahmet Iscen, Aashi Jain, Thomas Kipf, Yisong Yue, David A. Ross, Cordelia Schmid, Alireza Fathi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces SceneCraft, a Large Language Model (LLM) Agent
converting text descriptions into Blender-executable Python scripts which
render complex scenes with up to a hundred 3D assets. This process requires
complex spatial planning and arrangement. We tackle these challenges through a
combination of advanced abstraction, strategic planning, and library learning.
SceneCraft first models a scene graph as a blueprint, detailing the spatial
relationships among assets in the scene. SceneCraft then writes Python scripts
based on this graph, translating relationships into numerical constraints for
asset layout. Next, SceneCraft leverages the perceptual strengths of
vision-language foundation models like GPT-V to analyze rendered images and
iteratively refine the scene. On top of this process, SceneCraft features a
library learning mechanism that compiles common script functions into a
reusable library, facilitating continuous self-improvement without expensive
LLM parameter tuning. Our evaluation demonstrates that SceneCraft surpasses
existing LLM-based agents in rendering complex scenes, as shown by its
adherence to constraints and favorable human assessments. We also showcase the
broader application potential of SceneCraft by reconstructing detailed 3D
scenes from the Sintel movie and guiding a video generative model with
generated scenes as intermediary control signal.
|
[
-0.34215661883354187,
-0.7588000893592834,
0.6425555944442749,
0.3749978840351105,
0.1759517937898636,
0.21852447092533112,
0.31605568528175354,
-0.28349438309669495,
-0.111164890229702,
0.7407017350196838,
-0.5695978999137878,
-0.6124376058578491,
-0.03906871750950813,
0.061743393540382385,
-0.532404899597168,
0.40481123328208923,
0.007873747497797012,
-0.10645683109760284,
-0.35211631655693054,
0.2319682091474533,
-0.17059090733528137,
-0.3569727838039398,
-0.6517123579978943,
-0.3794286847114563,
0.3339272141456604,
0.1276800036430359,
0.6848095655441284,
0.853248119354248,
0.2911764085292816,
0.5212424397468567,
0.10220880061388016,
0.22032509744167328,
-0.46119800209999084,
0.09041009843349457,
-0.4064546227455139,
-0.07575400918722153,
-0.5540580749511719,
-0.11204126477241516,
0.4194455146789551,
0.5264917016029358,
0.027031773701310158,
0.272419273853302,
0.003139110980555415,
0.6550738215446472,
-0.4208782911300659,
0.38265588879585266,
-0.3558182120323181,
0.35554617643356323,
0.2302212119102478,
-0.36330413818359375,
-0.11934161931276321,
-0.033587295562028885,
0.2855364680290222,
-0.9385982751846313,
0.6247150897979736,
0.28932127356529236,
0.5099033117294312,
0.3191000521183014,
-0.04538387060165405,
0.14995674788951874,
-0.6584920287132263,
0.6807486414909363,
-0.456124484539032,
0.02356838807463646,
-0.01789739727973938,
0.5903635621070862,
-0.4487953186035156,
-0.8686265349388123,
-0.4056418240070343,
-0.10137646645307541,
0.1864691823720932,
0.1941017359495163,
0.02232549525797367,
0.22562868893146515,
0.38332903385162354,
0.48257824778556824,
-0.41098180413246155,
-0.15631432831287384,
-0.47234535217285156,
-0.48093298077583313,
0.557000994682312,
0.5190487504005432,
0.6665549874305725,
-0.25244346261024475,
-0.6321560144424438,
-0.33424144983291626,
-0.646026611328125,
-0.03627796471118927,
0.4140949249267578,
0.10223615914583206,
0.09054972231388092,
0.776267409324646,
-0.2831602394580841,
0.6424455642700195,
-0.20810642838478088,
-0.21818940341472626,
0.025079568848013878,
-0.016505232080817223,
-0.37440919876098633,
0.2542213797569275,
0.5660417675971985,
0.7732704877853394,
0.010072452016174793,
0.17688967287540436,
-0.3134298026561737,
-0.22737431526184082,
0.5406152009963989,
-0.885391354560852,
-0.44614464044570923,
0.4609498083591461,
-0.2793481945991516,
-0.5149999260902405,
-0.16666145622730255,
-0.5643858909606934,
-0.6449296474456787,
-0.4382840692996979,
0.27438583970069885,
-0.3403904139995575,
-0.25496363639831543,
-0.030332738533616066,
-0.35734251141548157,
0.3762720823287964,
0.7600627541542053,
-0.47779110074043274,
0.1417285054922104,
0.5106426477432251,
0.7725784778594971,
-0.2338382750749588,
-0.5948060750961304,
-0.34404176473617554,
0.4580720365047455,
-0.6068183183670044,
0.9947782754898071,
-0.19280828535556793,
-0.5133932828903198,
0.046221017837524414,
-0.0367991104722023,
0.48444122076034546,
-0.6921887397766113,
-0.221884086728096,
-0.28877896070480347,
-0.08475888520479202,
0.07932444661855698,
-0.1913052350282669,
-0.25025489926338196,
0.7361215949058533,
-1.06504225730896,
0.7216534614562988,
0.36576664447784424,
-0.4836992025375366,
0.030835624784231186,
-0.35446661710739136,
-0.1396016776561737,
0.04980161786079407,
-0.16842271387577057,
-0.09973138570785522,
0.17132292687892914,
0.31794047355651855,
0.3378589153289795,
-0.2577894926071167,
0.24728474020957947,
-0.17088119685649872,
-0.21779105067253113,
0.38767123222351074,
-0.41593432426452637,
0.17667174339294434,
0.5334797501564026,
0.11397303640842438,
0.2786339819431305,
-0.8561517000198364,
0.01579536497592926,
-0.014518020674586296,
-0.4330444931983948,
0.18939213454723358,
0.036738019436597824,
0.22030429542064667,
0.24975961446762085,
0.38173437118530273,
-0.372387170791626,
-0.07865989208221436,
-0.6346571445465088,
0.16292575001716614,
0.7065659761428833,
-0.08055096864700317,
0.6247265934944153,
-0.41412192583084106,
0.6037626266479492,
-0.020493824034929276,
-0.11211453378200531,
-0.6303758025169373,
-0.25758495926856995,
-0.4991053640842438,
-0.1522555947303772,
-0.49171754717826843,
0.5076166987419128,
-0.9848676323890686,
-0.1779848337173462,
-0.0006334644858725369,
-0.2396722435951233,
-0.07895255833864212,
0.08460254967212677,
0.38166725635528564,
0.277452677488327,
0.1664053499698639,
-0.19251784682273865,
-0.6420713663101196,
-0.9166894555091858,
-0.1898372918367386,
-0.08538514375686646,
-0.20722010731697083,
0.05301286652684212,
-0.062249328941106796,
-0.1884859949350357,
0.9895243644714355,
-0.4487556517124176,
-0.28755903244018555,
-0.7212433218955994,
-0.22906376421451569,
0.374697208404541,
0.5355640053749084,
0.30267155170440674,
-0.4300093650817871,
-0.2822035849094391,
0.3348988890647888,
-0.856813907623291,
-0.1436031311750412,
0.0035184877924621105,
-0.17232480645179749,
0.027805853635072708,
0.8381465077400208,
-0.2988909184932709,
0.4721386730670929,
0.575923502445221,
-0.19798021018505096,
0.6252862811088562,
-0.47382181882858276,
0.12333005666732788,
-1.0398622751235962,
-0.20643256604671478,
0.015025243163108826,
-0.3821943402290344,
-0.5508735179901123,
0.11329857259988785,
-0.49740299582481384,
-0.7098588943481445,
-0.9409198760986328,
0.827748715877533,
-0.39061951637268066,
-0.27084025740623474,
-0.3241594135761261,
-0.03005490079522133,
0.15596309304237366,
0.7250955700874329,
0.1862695962190628,
0.6319934725761414,
0.6047688126564026,
-0.579154908657074,
0.7285218834877014,
0.030007947236299515,
-0.49954691529273987,
0.54336017370224,
-0.614815890789032,
-0.09946992993354797,
-0.11271258443593979,
0.1559232473373413,
-1.031603455543518,
-0.6349350810050964,
0.17284195125102997,
0.09551848471164703,
0.012618417851626873,
-0.34964558482170105,
-0.5035977363586426,
-0.08931780606508255,
-0.13026069104671478,
0.5335697531700134,
0.3514899015426636,
-0.5231922268867493,
1.0597331523895264,
0.4813605546951294,
-0.08336389809846878,
-0.27760758996009827,
-0.6103202700614929,
-0.03832507133483887,
-0.07431554794311523,
-0.47413700819015503,
0.31161195039749146,
-0.048306237906217575,
-0.3449930250644684,
0.032563094049692154,
-0.3109660744667053,
-0.26775890588760376,
-0.3456871211528778,
0.5511040091514587,
0.2139635980129242,
0.03721625357866287,
-0.4614351987838745,
0.00023108154709916562,
-0.27437421679496765,
0.24730883538722992,
-0.3664870262145996,
0.5170332193374634,
-0.17159004509449005,
-0.4413412809371948,
-0.19658058881759644,
0.062061380594968796,
0.6674652695655823,
0.2327388972043991,
-0.07865700125694275,
0.5638023614883423,
-0.09360166639089584,
-0.6313816905021667,
-0.4676017463207245,
0.28506338596343994,
-0.5601449608802795,
0.5886873602867126,
-0.6345411539077759,
-0.7437654733657837,
0.5838498473167419,
-0.6124150156974792,
0.17806579172611237,
0.2851285934448242,
0.41648533940315247,
-0.08746084570884705,
0.8563668727874756,
0.36788347363471985,
0.30581164360046387,
0.5469653010368347,
-0.5901477932929993,
-0.024046365171670914,
-0.8092670440673828,
-0.2550325393676758,
0.10228519141674042,
-0.34778258204460144,
-0.3072807192802429,
-0.849450945854187,
0.4980413615703583,
-0.24126896262168884,
-0.4088583290576935,
0.25475889444351196,
-0.5780786871910095,
1.029258370399475,
0.3019583225250244,
0.12270273268222809,
0.18483060598373413,
0.36937496066093445,
-0.09473040699958801,
0.217242032289505,
-0.551811933517456,
-0.5327893495559692,
0.7065010070800781,
0.30943408608436584,
1.0095781087875366,
-0.09235566854476929,
0.6233272552490234,
0.392870157957077,
0.01093220617622137,
-0.5303374528884888,
0.8490388989448547,
0.06984208524227142,
-0.47759485244750977,
-0.33288365602493286,
-0.10743260383605957,
-0.7320480346679688,
0.5044742822647095,
-0.012747470289468765,
-0.53558748960495,
-0.006574958097189665,
0.2137695699930191,
-0.3160627484321594,
0.43634048104286194,
-0.4802171587944031,
0.9777233004570007,
-0.13607221841812134,
-0.6493405103683472,
-0.29924866557121277,
-0.16395506262779236,
0.3090789020061493,
0.0949636846780777,
0.2029210776090622,
-0.36938345432281494,
0.12499668449163437,
0.08385653048753738,
-0.5339334011077881,
0.9763866066932678,
0.0379599966108799,
-0.2529795467853546,
0.6491233110427856,
0.8496459126472473,
0.3271466791629791,
0.1691412478685379,
0.05361327901482582,
0.12517017126083374,
0.34490305185317993,
-0.29239535331726074,
-0.49307045340538025,
0.8154709339141846,
-0.9572058916091919,
-0.8300756216049194,
-0.44479233026504517,
-0.7569428086280823,
0.1904892921447754,
0.23429489135742188,
0.07330527156591415,
0.8105353713035583,
-0.8441280722618103,
-0.2054099291563034,
0.5916159749031067,
-0.8969278335571289,
0.38333022594451904,
0.1439436823129654,
-0.8734037280082703,
-0.5591732859611511,
1.0904754400253296,
-0.3191623091697693,
0.23063860833644867,
0.5220323204994202,
-0.04175911843776703,
0.026396652683615685,
-0.3496795892715454,
-0.5987146496772766,
-0.21880951523780823,
-0.8560894131660461,
-0.24885809421539307,
-0.33072954416275024,
-0.6334736943244934,
0.08068761974573135,
-0.656944751739502,
-0.6399467587471008,
-0.27536827325820923,
-0.16123728454113007,
-0.11822083592414856,
0.09174918383359909,
0.960941731929779,
0.09919638186693192,
0.23656262457370758,
-0.602291464805603,
0.48581305146217346,
0.5180327892303467,
0.2496495246887207,
-0.07845596969127655,
-0.14227551221847534,
-0.21360576152801514,
-0.23605884611606598,
-0.20862802863121033,
-0.24301473796367645,
0.7094773054122925,
-0.08482176065444946,
0.43848809599876404,
0.13772931694984436,
-0.27764958143234253,
0.8229254484176636,
-0.5995193719863892,
0.9508211612701416,
0.25314590334892273,
-0.6665390133857727,
0.4466303884983063,
-0.4048508405685425,
0.6669449806213379,
0.18881066143512726,
-0.4115367829799652,
-0.2044261246919632,
-0.5951535701751709,
-0.5446563363075256,
-0.8686313033103943,
0.8941534757614136,
0.14745761454105377,
0.28230518102645874,
-0.0012909048236906528,
0.06903120130300522,
-0.17168918251991272,
0.10219189524650574,
-0.5172644853591919,
0.09530315548181534,
-0.5995497703552246,
0.008135136216878891,
0.12365440279245377,
-0.2574702799320221,
-0.19933992624282837,
-0.09562870860099792,
0.2553882598876953,
-0.15393999218940735,
0.2027183473110199,
0.4354814291000366,
-0.1829422265291214,
0.027906198054552078,
-0.004068421665579081,
0.26864445209503174,
0.6393178701400757,
-0.11953254789113998,
0.22222761809825897,
0.18666493892669678,
-0.29849037528038025,
0.14553113281726837,
-0.14403758943080902,
0.04959504306316376,
-0.1430472880601883,
0.4306062161922455,
0.5578212738037109,
0.33434388041496277,
-0.8466242551803589,
0.43969061970710754,
0.11156032234430313,
-0.37982845306396484,
-0.6644402146339417,
0.3026348650455475,
0.04035470634698868,
0.4972679018974304,
-0.0033689276315271854,
0.1842382699251175,
0.256579726934433,
-0.4706261157989502,
0.021193213760852814,
0.17502900958061218,
-0.29944032430648804,
-0.2815730571746826,
0.8468924760818481,
0.2935088574886322,
-0.16161641478538513,
0.7075726985931396,
-0.04868922382593155,
-0.20968683063983917,
0.9008572697639465,
0.6629219651222229,
1.0471092462539673,
-0.04693466052412987,
0.39272406697273254,
0.5165172815322876,
0.10490100085735321,
-0.17497029900550842,
0.08044720441102982,
-0.021915895864367485,
-0.7684526443481445,
-0.4453004002571106,
-1.0199841260910034,
-0.2930270731449127,
-0.1605157107114792,
-0.06677085906267166,
0.1391083151102066,
-1.0421098470687866,
0.14687593281269073,
-0.42748743295669556,
-0.2974148094654083,
-0.7584134340286255,
0.03299564868211746,
0.1819024682044983,
0.8695866465568542,
-0.3894656300544739,
0.8074899911880493,
0.8231786489486694,
-0.4774671196937561,
-0.7314177751541138,
-0.40157759189605713,
0.22906725108623505,
-0.783650279045105,
0.7473270893096924,
0.2134365290403366,
-0.3509770333766937,
0.15724243223667145,
-0.5845041871070862,
-0.9121397733688354,
1.199636697769165,
0.3270874619483948,
-0.46839576959609985,
-0.01823314279317856,
0.36965233087539673,
0.5521319508552551,
-0.6252067685127258,
-0.011967875994741917,
0.34189191460609436,
0.21657291054725647,
0.700916588306427,
-0.4258553981781006,
-0.059118904173374176,
-0.418245404958725,
0.5597938895225525,
-0.21219903230667114,
-0.2752958834171295,
0.65473872423172,
-0.1657690703868866,
-0.2911923825740814,
0.28134602308273315,
0.5649394392967224,
0.4676693081855774,
0.3544671833515167,
0.3184990882873535,
0.5688387751579285,
0.09995143115520477,
0.042688749730587006,
1.0856761932373047,
-0.26834964752197266,
-0.16974376142024994,
0.9901340007781982,
-0.25673139095306396,
0.3704286813735962,
0.23093222081661224,
-0.0705961063504219,
0.4958413541316986,
0.4850146472454071,
-0.03420945629477501,
0.5396487712860107,
0.3041340410709381,
-0.3303285241127014,
-0.21490100026130676,
0.08632083237171173,
0.10405231267213821,
0.17881476879119873,
0.3728918731212616,
-0.14869746565818787,
-0.36799073219299316,
-0.03606037423014641,
-0.3065054714679718,
0.043393515050411224,
-0.5404329895973206,
0.9323816299438477,
0.1403263658285141,
-0.4970172345638275,
0.21005980670452118,
-0.1605507731437683,
-0.07654781639575958,
-0.45573151111602783,
-0.40292152762413025,
-0.3542534112930298,
0.307471364736557,
-0.32030946016311646,
-0.9137566685676575,
0.24955865740776062,
-0.2796696424484253,
-0.09962541610002518,
-0.4721109867095947,
0.6157001852989197,
-0.5158728957176208,
-0.46412310004234314,
-0.11001750826835632,
0.3921746611595154,
0.3804989755153656,
-0.20888037979602814,
-0.7104277610778809,
0.2740935683250427,
0.02037745527923107,
-0.21953465044498444,
0.40468505024909973,
0.7662432193756104,
-0.07339192926883698,
0.7696800231933594,
0.8543946146965027,
0.1509123295545578,
-0.09510798007249832,
0.20920494198799133,
0.954395592212677,
-0.7021141052246094,
-0.414678156375885,
-0.6750014424324036,
0.662783682346344,
-0.0275651216506958,
0.15380075573921204,
0.6237177848815918,
0.7108994722366333,
0.947655200958252,
-0.41787421703338623,
0.8105964064598083,
0.05537515506148338,
-0.16724960505962372,
-0.5598511099815369,
0.47016650438308716,
-0.3305128216743469,
0.5553297996520996,
-0.31600216031074524,
-1.438985824584961,
-0.4638429880142212,
0.6460981369018555,
0.0403054840862751,
-0.41039031744003296,
0.5901840329170227,
1.033705711364746,
-0.2399332970380783,
-0.4792734980583191,
0.6891245245933533,
-0.11165379732847214,
0.5347180962562561,
0.375172883272171,
1.1828749179840088,
-0.10639496892690659,
0.6378057599067688,
-0.14633086323738098,
0.0004511445004027337,
0.07075132429599762,
-0.8704490065574646,
-1.0106279850006104,
-0.3565734028816223,
-0.315782368183136,
-0.3888154923915863,
-0.24903538823127747,
0.8055493235588074,
0.5934572815895081,
-0.5237259864807129,
-0.6891830563545227,
-0.2581949234008789,
0.2768999934196472,
-0.32753118872642517,
-0.21878917515277863,
0.1484367847442627,
-0.4136773347854614,
-0.8947784900665283,
0.5047039985656738,
0.7486594915390015,
0.129524827003479,
-0.7528818845748901,
-0.14910708367824554,
0.32298460602760315,
0.007507051806896925,
0.829928994178772,
0.31384119391441345,
-0.7340890169143677,
0.06774180382490158,
-0.36442679166793823,
-0.13115376234054565,
-0.08985573798418045,
0.7942296862602234,
-0.7963895201683044,
0.8323734998703003,
0.7035768628120422,
0.3842395544052124,
0.6504434943199158,
0.18437059223651886,
1.0543735027313232,
-0.7062914967536926,
0.4470134973526001,
-0.24499815702438354,
0.361992210149765,
0.28982919454574585,
-0.2103111743927002,
0.5059617757797241,
-0.06664970517158508,
-0.4621354639530182,
-0.456817626953125,
0.42635577917099,
-1.0525708198547363,
-0.4646148383617401,
1.0269511938095093,
0.04587420076131821,
-0.7673377990722656,
0.015352313406765461,
-0.6413863897323608,
-0.15417101979255676,
-0.2577036917209625,
0.5310124158859253,
0.40375804901123047,
0.047559287399053574,
-0.31245917081832886,
-0.5313794016838074,
0.6297417879104614,
-0.4918871819972992,
-0.5627124309539795,
0.10024967789649963,
0.96821129322052,
0.30809980630874634,
0.20967456698417664,
0.6466485857963562,
-0.3396841585636139,
0.1262928694486618,
0.257797509431839,
0.37503913044929504,
-0.43850165605545044,
-0.44493043422698975,
0.011391174979507923,
0.27670130133628845,
0.03653253614902496,
0.09415224194526672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01244v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01244v2
|
Mitigating Catastrophic Forgetting in Large Language Models with Self-Synthesized Rehearsal
| 2024-03-02T16:11:23 | 2024-05-25T12:17:29 |
Jianheng Huang, Leyang Cui, Ante Wang, Chengyi Yang, Xinting Liao, Linfeng Song, Junfeng Yao, Jinsong Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) suffer from catastrophic forgetting during
continual learning. Conventional rehearsal-based methods rely on previous
training data to retain the model's ability, which may not be feasible in
real-world applications. When conducting continual learning based on a
publicly-released LLM checkpoint, the availability of the original training
data may be non-existent. To address this challenge, we propose a framework
called Self-Synthesized Rehearsal (SSR) that uses the LLM to generate synthetic
instances for rehearsal. Concretely, we first employ the base LLM for
in-context learning to generate synthetic instances. Subsequently, we utilize
the latest LLM to refine the instance outputs based on the synthetic inputs,
preserving its acquired ability. Finally, we select diverse high-quality
synthetic instances for rehearsal in future stages. Experimental results
demonstrate that SSR achieves superior or comparable performance compared to
conventional rehearsal-based approaches while being more data-efficient.
Besides, SSR effectively preserves the generalization capabilities of LLMs in
general domains.
|
[
-0.1475479155778885,
-0.5527231097221375,
0.4573616087436676,
0.5332428216934204,
-0.10683854669332504,
0.36320745944976807,
-0.3844083547592163,
0.014021651819348335,
0.21057374775409698,
0.7133919596672058,
-0.7708081603050232,
-0.3395287096500397,
0.061225973069667816,
0.06474845856428146,
-0.44050082564353943,
0.8684632182121277,
-0.10614901036024094,
0.06547312438488007,
-0.27505165338516235,
-0.07866813987493515,
-0.5739792585372925,
-0.6013228297233582,
-0.8533333539962769,
-0.46363648772239685,
0.3983195722103119,
0.5876394510269165,
-0.05788589268922806,
0.4439831078052521,
-0.06884507834911346,
0.29747477173805237,
0.1732177883386612,
0.15804345905780792,
-0.9957011938095093,
0.4885033965110779,
-0.312263548374176,
-0.2299860715866089,
-0.35143834352493286,
-0.049440354108810425,
1.282164216041565,
0.53028804063797,
-0.4456924796104431,
0.05895029008388519,
0.1682298630475998,
0.8478491902351379,
-0.607623279094696,
0.07166043668985367,
-1.1727932691574097,
0.3035753071308136,
-0.04315847158432007,
-0.18877486884593964,
-0.641545832157135,
-0.03508031368255615,
-0.197177454829216,
-0.45450475811958313,
0.415289044380188,
-0.17461322247982025,
0.2632414996623993,
0.07825667411088943,
0.024229593575000763,
0.07371242344379425,
-0.9524493217468262,
0.8215004801750183,
-0.6330432891845703,
0.4563924968242645,
0.3568253517150879,
0.5212925672531128,
-0.48743578791618347,
-0.5779854655265808,
-0.5819776058197021,
-0.3249818980693817,
0.4187929928302765,
0.425239622592926,
0.30156707763671875,
-0.05454552173614502,
0.04132872074842453,
0.35974279046058655,
-0.5954751968383789,
0.24161985516548157,
-0.2903860807418823,
-0.45833802223205566,
0.46470460295677185,
0.3200947344303131,
0.2165837436914444,
0.049646344035863876,
-0.35573580861091614,
0.005850968882441521,
-1.2647558450698853,
-0.5387605428695679,
0.07454442977905273,
0.2969242036342621,
0.06279538571834564,
0.28498610854148865,
-0.09423387795686722,
0.42782238125801086,
0.13643160462379456,
-0.09095300734043121,
-0.004915867932140827,
-0.17079627513885498,
-0.14574956893920898,
-0.02649860270321369,
0.5765300393104553,
0.012356494553387165,
0.26076847314834595,
-0.47576045989990234,
-0.4057765007019043,
-0.07053254544734955,
0.38550373911857605,
-0.511218249797821,
-0.33440539240837097,
0.08766339719295502,
0.12481788545846939,
-0.03139791637659073,
-0.4499719440937042,
-0.6590440273284912,
-0.06756819039583206,
-0.6023764610290527,
0.5217077136039734,
-0.47306719422340393,
-0.1586911976337433,
-0.22386017441749573,
0.13712042570114136,
-0.07378452271223068,
0.1762048751115799,
-1.0685858726501465,
0.2863025367259979,
0.3392318785190582,
0.8823573589324951,
-0.11912208050489426,
-0.7393242716789246,
-0.6396675109863281,
0.6884627938270569,
-0.7334896922111511,
0.5697223544120789,
-0.008780709467828274,
-0.2839447259902954,
-0.011266290210187435,
-0.13562028110027313,
-0.24977174401283264,
-0.850665271282196,
-0.009743320755660534,
-0.34698036313056946,
-0.052485834807157516,
-0.01673632673919201,
-0.6278049945831299,
0.2570075988769531,
0.2140757441520691,
-0.5304646492004395,
0.9168453812599182,
0.12307441234588623,
-0.1600225567817688,
0.2153792679309845,
-0.08949322253465652,
-0.35830631852149963,
0.05521984025835991,
-0.3559972643852234,
-0.5760383605957031,
0.3294640779495239,
0.12824973464012146,
0.49130743741989136,
-0.23657594621181488,
0.20748475193977356,
-0.30539947748184204,
-0.48380038142204285,
0.2513977587223053,
-0.21144308149814606,
-0.004621011670678854,
0.17661572992801666,
-0.2513236105442047,
-0.02541855350136757,
-0.8856185078620911,
0.07609319686889648,
0.16695857048034668,
-0.5047935843467712,
-0.07739829272031784,
0.14605280756950378,
0.06077837944030762,
0.36669978499412537,
-0.11666881293058395,
-0.36199304461479187,
0.01156003400683403,
-0.4546300172805786,
0.6200823783874512,
1.0571770668029785,
0.12944462895393372,
0.5509722232818604,
-0.4818102717399597,
0.6027196645736694,
0.030566785484552383,
-0.1217716708779335,
-0.4135591387748718,
0.20698854327201843,
-1.031248688697815,
-0.2387513518333435,
0.0798826515674591,
0.22291728854179382,
-0.617434561252594,
0.29838719964027405,
-0.28842654824256897,
-0.4343448579311371,
-0.2802395522594452,
0.34617361426353455,
0.44145551323890686,
0.36391276121139526,
0.3635556399822235,
-0.25307178497314453,
-0.7705610394477844,
-0.7597323656082153,
-0.17431548237800598,
0.0027502335142344236,
-0.04632747918367386,
0.05230458453297615,
0.3524004817008972,
-0.2833103835582733,
1.0613293647766113,
-0.06376819312572479,
-0.6967246532440186,
-0.43835410475730896,
0.06228350102901459,
-0.02460912987589836,
0.8458477258682251,
0.37086984515190125,
-0.2849677801132202,
-0.39645853638648987,
-0.14112365245819092,
-0.7720309495925903,
0.0947587862610817,
-0.6354373097419739,
-0.044075071811676025,
0.5990369915962219,
0.706787645816803,
-0.4504440128803253,
-0.02101203426718712,
0.711338460445404,
0.20939645171165466,
0.7984676361083984,
-0.31500035524368286,
-0.1993868201971054,
-0.9628206491470337,
-0.009652776643633842,
-0.2727827727794647,
-0.23624560236930847,
-0.5995965003967285,
-0.02424832433462143,
0.31521013379096985,
-0.4055936634540558,
-0.39531204104423523,
0.7315876483917236,
-0.7158175110816956,
-0.041776012629270554,
-0.29442355036735535,
0.18930238485336304,
-0.2773701846599579,
0.5134492516517639,
-0.06537123024463654,
0.8473849892616272,
0.6442751288414001,
-0.8159993290901184,
-0.10645278543233871,
0.05328712239861488,
-0.3731365501880646,
0.34444570541381836,
-0.4144032895565033,
0.507321834564209,
-0.14878639578819275,
0.5759497284889221,
-0.8137220740318298,
-0.4285438358783722,
0.026171350851655006,
-0.16369998455047607,
0.7049649953842163,
-0.5746384263038635,
-0.4428914487361908,
-0.33849623799324036,
-0.012565008364617825,
0.27690935134887695,
0.6443254947662354,
-0.5907266736030579,
0.6362910270690918,
0.38618138432502747,
-0.23437832295894623,
-0.21712791919708252,
-0.7175905704498291,
0.33532819151878357,
-0.30984586477279663,
-0.3527452051639557,
0.37362295389175415,
-0.2920915484428406,
0.22223739326000214,
-0.3963817358016968,
-0.39435404539108276,
0.13738393783569336,
-0.1010185107588768,
0.2300581932067871,
-0.0034210095182061195,
-0.008795103058218956,
0.3540598154067993,
0.150383859872818,
-0.23339729011058807,
0.001170605537481606,
-0.6204264163970947,
0.7513840198516846,
0.09425805509090424,
-0.3420618176460266,
-0.24699853360652924,
0.43153101205825806,
0.8108721971511841,
0.05886060744524002,
0.7584378719329834,
0.28533780574798584,
-0.32792186737060547,
-0.8208758234977722,
-0.887734591960907,
-0.3478614389896393,
-0.5148003697395325,
0.3441682457923889,
-0.22854232788085938,
-0.8858704566955566,
0.8148996233940125,
-0.23094943165779114,
-0.14900025725364685,
0.1485358625650406,
0.5505509972572327,
-0.258415162563324,
0.6914146542549133,
0.3159213960170746,
-0.2553892731666565,
0.537173330783844,
-0.3538477420806885,
-0.03785434737801552,
-1.0587294101715088,
0.01319457869976759,
-0.13427947461605072,
-0.04999854415655136,
-0.29737356305122375,
-0.4416314959526062,
0.5886773467063904,
0.04577611759305,
-0.3162718415260315,
0.21268028020858765,
-0.06497396528720856,
0.6458590626716614,
0.34022483229637146,
0.136140376329422,
-0.01662404276430607,
0.22146688401699066,
-0.3350551426410675,
-0.27897030115127563,
-0.8528915047645569,
-0.24789482355117798,
1.1424918174743652,
0.2139727771282196,
0.8068378567695618,
-0.15188787877559662,
1.043562412261963,
0.035163696855306625,
0.281944215297699,
-0.3723219633102417,
0.6976491808891296,
0.04209200665354729,
-0.6057721376419067,
-0.40717434883117676,
-0.7335197925567627,
-0.7491046786308289,
0.33836299180984497,
-0.0591309517621994,
-0.6516539454460144,
-0.2451525330543518,
0.5921874642372131,
-0.037258461117744446,
0.13711312413215637,
-0.5507239103317261,
0.6383518576622009,
0.018319295719265938,
-0.5365365147590637,
-0.5504664182662964,
-0.24530552327632904,
0.32858213782310486,
-0.5519043803215027,
0.28904470801353455,
-0.023614132776856422,
0.4779994487762451,
0.6747689247131348,
-0.2535506784915924,
1.129747748374939,
0.0000018142674207410892,
-0.06183173507452011,
0.39820730686187744,
0.42461490631103516,
0.9110643267631531,
0.048728618770837784,
-0.033868033438920975,
-0.011003962717950344,
-0.353590726852417,
-0.44707757234573364,
-0.5786016583442688,
1.0373713970184326,
-0.5343073010444641,
-0.597489058971405,
-0.271824449300766,
-0.4568808674812317,
-0.5390264987945557,
0.10851031541824341,
0.299393892288208,
0.5615978240966797,
-0.2839062213897705,
0.14952212572097778,
0.49355852603912354,
-0.14893276989459991,
0.5095570087432861,
0.6269868016242981,
-0.19528940320014954,
-0.8391813635826111,
1.1870588064193726,
0.45045286417007446,
0.6811847686767578,
0.021937191486358643,
0.24082233011722565,
-0.21386180818080902,
-0.8527873754501343,
-0.3874441981315613,
0.4056898355484009,
-0.8904966115951538,
-0.17345550656318665,
-0.5196830630302429,
-0.3891238272190094,
-0.4045315384864807,
-0.22269180417060852,
-0.6830405592918396,
-0.42874184250831604,
-0.1690058708190918,
-0.126372292637825,
0.08511720597743988,
0.5460814833641052,
-0.35260799527168274,
0.009347907267510891,
-0.8141416311264038,
0.20143209397792816,
0.3700306713581085,
0.45015576481819153,
0.35445210337638855,
-0.7206217646598816,
-0.5230351686477661,
-0.017032643780112267,
-0.388473242521286,
-0.4272289574146271,
0.5993872284889221,
0.4852021336555481,
0.6235090494155884,
0.018083179369568825,
0.06643687933683395,
0.9715456366539001,
-0.8720548152923584,
0.6862083077430725,
0.2999930679798126,
-0.8825002908706665,
0.6766843795776367,
-0.6419144868850708,
0.5057734847068787,
0.5882383584976196,
0.08802231401205063,
-0.7023297548294067,
-0.7944726347923279,
-0.42378857731819153,
-1.1693360805511475,
0.6205419301986694,
0.2631656229496002,
0.3056538999080658,
-0.2860008180141449,
0.4381212592124939,
0.13484376668930054,
0.13219186663627625,
-0.9273070693016052,
-0.0011458004591986537,
-0.20909929275512695,
0.020068159326910973,
-0.31750112771987915,
-0.38971003890037537,
-0.07646705955266953,
-0.13898152112960815,
0.7738445997238159,
-0.2592175304889679,
0.19912682473659515,
0.13913729786872864,
-0.28494465351104736,
-0.4217735230922699,
0.08779429644346237,
0.5854994654655457,
0.8580052852630615,
0.01413862593472004,
0.12982165813446045,
0.5046964883804321,
-0.3855248689651489,
0.33250105381011963,
-0.496377557516098,
-0.1665959507226944,
-0.2923247516155243,
0.39318951964378357,
0.48354941606521606,
0.7551030516624451,
-0.6965733766555786,
-0.0642041265964508,
0.28635314106941223,
-0.07943437993526459,
-0.9629111886024475,
0.24511770904064178,
0.23296678066253662,
0.014170167967677116,
0.47963812947273254,
-0.10842125862836838,
-0.22032053768634796,
-0.8016598224639893,
0.48089858889579773,
0.1980617195367813,
-0.20052364468574524,
-0.2965804636478424,
0.4590926170349121,
0.00421897554770112,
-0.2483542263507843,
0.8777564764022827,
0.09663263708353043,
-0.5078949332237244,
0.39863091707229614,
1.1569560766220093,
0.997947633266449,
-0.5517804026603699,
0.14109662175178528,
0.521037220954895,
0.08930669724941254,
-0.36613017320632935,
0.05714966356754303,
-0.019330916926264763,
-0.5264115333557129,
-0.4808048605918884,
-0.7011969089508057,
-0.3178626596927643,
0.41709789633750916,
-0.5349324345588684,
-0.01306719146668911,
-0.7745607495307922,
0.19743147492408752,
-0.4503314793109894,
-0.4348810911178589,
-0.32597655057907104,
0.3109414875507355,
-0.040478840470314026,
0.6273685693740845,
-0.7869687080383301,
0.9500514268875122,
0.2871597707271576,
-0.3716718554496765,
-0.684689462184906,
0.2222772240638733,
0.03502265363931656,
-0.7015117406845093,
0.43304646015167236,
0.1264287531375885,
-0.09985968470573425,
0.1525896042585373,
-0.46556276082992554,
-1.1060025691986084,
1.0559132099151611,
0.5711005330085754,
-0.8975037932395935,
0.16112899780273438,
0.15239697694778442,
0.6576352715492249,
-0.27632278203964233,
-0.174092099070549,
0.491996169090271,
0.19162437319755554,
0.4206068813800812,
-0.7602649927139282,
-0.10523360967636108,
-0.016565708443522453,
0.05947711318731308,
0.043942030519247055,
-0.7372788190841675,
0.5972667932510376,
-0.0033336267806589603,
-0.37948134541511536,
0.09618598222732544,
0.5497096180915833,
0.5985866189002991,
0.1611088216304779,
0.33179447054862976,
0.5930686593055725,
0.5740882158279419,
0.059621553868055344,
0.8727065920829773,
-0.02059072256088257,
0.3710920810699463,
1.403725028038025,
-0.4186626374721527,
0.8395566940307617,
0.42362454533576965,
-0.04778814688324928,
0.28386619687080383,
0.4149671196937561,
0.22170570492744446,
0.6920519471168518,
0.4783204197883606,
-0.41948655247688293,
-0.6310170292854309,
0.38501861691474915,
-0.2646236717700958,
0.38116273283958435,
0.3417017459869385,
-0.13439612090587616,
-0.18435660004615784,
0.10528906434774399,
-0.04639328271150589,
0.17534898221492767,
-0.3486187756061554,
0.8281687498092651,
0.3278759717941284,
-0.9139496684074402,
1.0819668769836426,
-0.3883547782897949,
0.04775742441415787,
-0.7242431044578552,
0.10019243508577347,
-0.5782017707824707,
0.42315444350242615,
0.1425255835056305,
-0.3529471158981323,
0.4107603430747986,
-0.21644575893878937,
-0.20515723526477814,
-0.29612234234809875,
0.3814130127429962,
-0.71860271692276,
-0.40972501039505005,
0.27093571424484253,
-0.001260405289940536,
-0.015951143577694893,
-0.11800651252269745,
-0.3995322287082672,
0.24216945469379425,
-0.31142133474349976,
-0.1470654308795929,
0.8635081648826599,
0.4310886263847351,
-0.013893954455852509,
1.0859071016311646,
0.6343477368354797,
0.11362967640161514,
0.09738894551992416,
0.2244877964258194,
1.0061872005462646,
-0.8964022397994995,
-0.6870505809783936,
-0.6660337448120117,
0.4270879328250885,
0.1355733424425125,
-0.11879123747348785,
0.7494012117385864,
0.4368998110294342,
0.8241209983825684,
-0.42286479473114014,
0.7631050944328308,
0.502309262752533,
0.41942349076271057,
-1.0818058252334595,
1.0125844478607178,
-0.42840149998664856,
0.32699188590049744,
-0.2720559239387512,
-0.9637854695320129,
-0.2933892011642456,
0.6286445260047913,
0.027817945927381516,
0.12259948998689651,
0.7126911878585815,
0.7448257803916931,
-0.06391165405511856,
-0.26888081431388855,
0.5571189522743225,
0.47241315245628357,
0.3615357577800751,
0.6581797003746033,
1.0178292989730835,
-0.2457188069820404,
0.3484733998775482,
-0.015869049355387688,
-0.09819445013999939,
-0.12712179124355316,
-0.8900625705718994,
-0.9930042028427124,
-0.8056619167327881,
-0.2945862114429474,
-0.2663930654525757,
0.2369270920753479,
0.8294335007667542,
0.87828528881073,
-0.8567361831665039,
-0.37669262290000916,
-0.5098399519920349,
-0.1253669410943985,
-0.17745527625083923,
-0.1473006159067154,
0.2413681000471115,
-0.7933306694030762,
-0.4812747836112976,
1.061624526977539,
0.37263378500938416,
0.3197077512741089,
-0.45670416951179504,
-0.13337096571922302,
0.038529880344867706,
0.16761747002601624,
0.5633702278137207,
0.49025002121925354,
-0.6187715530395508,
-0.42679446935653687,
-0.3847917318344116,
0.21315768361091614,
-0.09739107638597488,
0.8503298759460449,
-0.9163921475410461,
0.4962767958641052,
0.05598190426826477,
0.4739973247051239,
0.8242200016975403,
-0.3509303033351898,
0.8913019895553589,
-1.0012215375900269,
0.14443592727184296,
0.28396177291870117,
0.3637614846229553,
0.44971609115600586,
-0.17979691922664642,
0.3678841292858124,
0.2285308986902237,
-0.684831440448761,
-0.8418453931808472,
0.34631288051605225,
-0.8346869945526123,
-0.10049185901880264,
1.1317931413650513,
-0.17450879514217377,
-0.06673625856637955,
-0.007927554659545422,
0.11936470121145248,
-0.03775281831622124,
-0.15621064603328705,
1.1727774143218994,
0.5848026275634766,
0.24701449275016785,
-0.18740060925483704,
-0.20253874361515045,
0.5282597541809082,
0.4627794921398163,
-0.5181476473808289,
0.4452788531780243,
0.6115790009498596,
0.6715466976165771,
-0.169866681098938,
0.765292227268219,
-0.21005503833293915,
0.2715245187282562,
-0.11150442063808441,
-0.05089332163333893,
-0.018462855368852615,
-0.9195894002914429,
-0.3690047562122345,
0.05207272619009018,
-0.02110017091035843,
0.14245587587356567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01242v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01242v1
|
Augmenting Automation: Intent-Based User Instruction Classification with Machine Learning
| 2024-03-02T16:06:03 | 2024-03-02T16:06:03 |
Lochan Basyal, Bijay Gaudel
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Electric automation systems offer convenience and efficiency in controlling
electrical circuits and devices. Traditionally, these systems rely on
predefined commands for control, limiting flexibility and adaptability. In this
paper, we propose a novel approach to augment automation by introducing
intent-based user instruction classification using machine learning techniques.
Our system represents user instructions as intents, allowing for dynamic
control of electrical circuits without relying on predefined commands. Through
a machine learning model trained on a labeled dataset of user instructions, our
system classifies intents from user input, enabling a more intuitive and
adaptable control scheme. We present the design and implementation of our
intent-based electric automation system, detailing the development of the
machine learning model for intent classification. Experimental results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in enhancing user experience and
expanding the capabilities of electric automation systems. Our work contributes
to the advancement of smart technologies by providing a more seamless
interaction between users and their environments.
|
[
-0.29541876912117004,
-0.5222517848014832,
0.6884005069732666,
-0.006480957381427288,
0.29740235209465027,
-0.1923108696937561,
-0.005020331125706434,
-0.19294598698616028,
-0.04141518101096153,
0.6479734182357788,
-0.5776452422142029,
-0.3027324676513672,
-0.42458391189575195,
0.08382514119148254,
-0.2807771563529968,
0.58851557970047,
-0.3928269147872925,
-0.3073796331882477,
-0.18519334495067596,
0.09844101220369339,
-0.6342888474464417,
-0.1827475130558014,
-0.13176773488521576,
-0.5282899141311646,
0.4113999009132385,
0.8582897186279297,
0.3379562795162201,
0.1876482367515564,
0.4571734070777893,
0.41416826844215393,
0.6513776779174805,
0.5065426826477051,
-0.012759934179484844,
0.23848801851272583,
-0.024468326941132545,
-0.48851901292800903,
-0.3522290289402008,
0.1063854768872261,
0.14163251221179962,
0.6064630746841431,
-0.09734881669282913,
-0.016124602407217026,
-0.17084595561027527,
0.5662723779678345,
-0.6576257348060608,
0.3660430312156677,
-0.3955114185810089,
0.19579628109931946,
0.3336668014526367,
-0.8740113377571106,
-0.9231299757957458,
-0.24503475427627563,
0.12336878478527069,
-0.6559694409370422,
-0.21637681126594543,
0.15993927419185638,
0.6570116281509399,
0.2879945933818817,
-0.6633327603340149,
-0.3479235768318176,
-1.1493059396743774,
0.8065277934074402,
-0.1189122200012207,
0.5462968349456787,
0.21753886342048645,
0.5786567330360413,
-0.08171956241130829,
-0.8707528710365295,
-0.5096157789230347,
-0.32260453701019287,
-0.27515530586242676,
0.07613516598939896,
0.2210628241300583,
0.3331563472747803,
0.37390604615211487,
-0.061258070170879364,
-0.3728668689727783,
0.21893249452114105,
-0.23681016266345978,
-0.047035977244377136,
0.7967233061790466,
0.32055753469467163,
0.5065183639526367,
0.10641322284936905,
-0.49258339405059814,
-0.01835637167096138,
-0.4332238435745239,
0.4512021839618683,
0.5905388593673706,
0.2435847669839859,
0.3272680640220642,
0.6789430379867554,
-0.26393210887908936,
0.4978893995285034,
0.3594760000705719,
0.05412272736430168,
0.3471558392047882,
0.2528627812862396,
-0.5099791288375854,
0.4612739682197571,
0.5775425434112549,
0.31493234634399414,
0.11121722310781479,
-0.11667544394731522,
-0.4573129713535309,
-0.2792986035346985,
0.7364129424095154,
-0.5675267577171326,
-0.386147677898407,
0.11357629299163818,
-0.4970250427722931,
-0.2872168719768524,
0.6163766384124756,
-0.14873768389225006,
-0.33249199390411377,
-0.8302580118179321,
0.6448426842689514,
-0.1857408583164215,
0.27790915966033936,
0.24920348823070526,
-0.22331556677818298,
0.2798524796962738,
0.8149545192718506,
-1.2635478973388672,
0.3825840353965759,
0.6859003901481628,
0.3026392459869385,
-0.029415789991617203,
-0.30495113134384155,
-0.4203069508075714,
0.2998833656311035,
0.0026258432772010565,
0.6101410984992981,
-0.5469191670417786,
-0.519429087638855,
-0.1277170330286026,
0.347258061170578,
-0.23413904011249542,
-0.2583494782447815,
0.26840323209762573,
-1.0954413414001465,
0.42200127243995667,
0.4449922740459442,
-0.5595537424087524,
-0.7261962294578552,
-0.11406461894512177,
-0.553851306438446,
0.591115415096283,
0.2903701961040497,
-0.4490445554256439,
0.4304666519165039,
-1.1253955364227295,
-0.7525937557220459,
0.21464580297470093,
-0.10615277290344238,
-0.45333346724510193,
-0.07359235733747482,
-0.30807560682296753,
0.5555480122566223,
0.4747072756290436,
0.015588727779686451,
-0.270658940076828,
-0.2207375317811966,
0.37097397446632385,
-0.6785418391227722,
0.7072259783744812,
0.09829847514629364,
-0.41433265805244446,
0.4710671305656433,
-0.702560305595398,
0.028419053182005882,
-0.20348788797855377,
-0.15216030180454254,
-0.17746783792972565,
0.026725010946393013,
-0.07739467918872833,
0.1420498788356781,
0.5009328722953796,
-0.4208716154098511,
0.2573642134666443,
-0.2582134008407593,
-0.06045392528176308,
0.788692831993103,
-0.1410927176475525,
0.6496115326881409,
-0.25613856315612793,
0.399673730134964,
-0.3033560514450073,
0.3260101079940796,
-0.20092682540416718,
-0.4727652072906494,
-0.7026088833808899,
0.02782547101378441,
0.21089240908622742,
1.1498565673828125,
-0.41862571239471436,
1.08210027217865,
-0.06893987953662872,
-0.22216857969760895,
-0.1560634821653366,
0.24590151011943817,
-0.2373337745666504,
0.5731438398361206,
0.4687773585319519,
-0.29490038752555847,
-0.47418996691703796,
-0.6991259455680847,
0.02650868520140648,
0.053859151899814606,
-0.3718726336956024,
0.6844694018363953,
0.16890999674797058,
-0.472354531288147,
0.9340869784355164,
-0.5750164985656738,
-0.309169739484787,
-0.40912023186683655,
0.2532574534416199,
0.0441887266933918,
0.36064445972442627,
0.08738255500793457,
-0.9993830919265747,
-0.5970779657363892,
0.5934110879898071,
-0.7533671259880066,
-0.06120753288269043,
-0.2513653635978699,
0.14266249537467957,
0.009539133869111538,
0.4782496988773346,
-0.2439340204000473,
0.8134378790855408,
0.13581374287605286,
-0.16166739165782928,
0.5830524563789368,
-0.4443647265434265,
0.40670308470726013,
-0.5616183876991272,
-0.11017650365829468,
-0.2391001135110855,
-0.3400769531726837,
-0.7348379492759705,
-0.5861382484436035,
0.17324213683605194,
0.12895561754703522,
-0.7188262939453125,
0.24680016934871674,
-0.1796720027923584,
-0.03367353230714798,
-0.5838677883148193,
-0.45918330550193787,
0.1224253922700882,
0.5286975502967834,
-0.03394694626331329,
0.7275655269622803,
0.6228031516075134,
-1.032523512840271,
0.6488279700279236,
0.2286866456270218,
-0.19630561769008636,
0.19586873054504395,
-0.2795425057411194,
0.020350534468889236,
-0.02039584517478943,
0.011839963495731354,
-0.6591348052024841,
-0.6433216333389282,
0.2559835910797119,
-0.3134496212005615,
0.5141846537590027,
0.0746326670050621,
-0.23033127188682556,
-0.48031753301620483,
-0.10122454911470413,
0.07502269744873047,
0.8870351314544678,
-0.7340688109397888,
1.0908901691436768,
0.2252584844827652,
-0.15165011584758759,
-0.20402684807777405,
-0.39343395829200745,
-0.25001758337020874,
-0.30396997928619385,
-0.4156421422958374,
0.2325156331062317,
0.15982918441295624,
-0.19066587090492249,
-0.13558988273143768,
0.07311063259840012,
-0.09055786579847336,
0.324741929769516,
0.4841310381889343,
0.27105873823165894,
0.10847408324480057,
0.35913345217704773,
0.37023335695266724,
-0.20133619010448456,
0.31421974301338196,
-0.6243206262588501,
0.5004234910011292,
0.04767647013068199,
-0.6356006860733032,
-1.3558108806610107,
0.32009807229042053,
0.6221871972084045,
-0.09424104541540146,
0.23591992259025574,
0.22027818858623505,
-0.056133393198251724,
-0.5038104057312012,
-0.0959116593003273,
-0.3999176323413849,
-0.6679750680923462,
0.0604952834546566,
-0.26242733001708984,
-0.64732426404953,
0.010086233727633953,
-0.5575674176216125,
0.22083038091659546,
0.38468682765960693,
0.40792179107666016,
-0.6357924342155457,
1.2425435781478882,
0.9932684302330017,
0.3102714419364929,
1.013089656829834,
-0.26370513439178467,
0.26454025506973267,
-0.5224546194076538,
-0.4137726128101349,
-0.1397300362586975,
-0.736674427986145,
-0.46610328555107117,
-0.04036083444952965,
0.07843773812055588,
-0.40833625197410583,
-0.24520926177501678,
0.43661603331565857,
-0.6499565243721008,
0.22976809740066528,
0.5465903282165527,
0.49979180097579956,
0.09668976813554764,
0.0184866264462471,
0.24514518678188324,
0.33717969059944153,
-0.499904066324234,
-0.9034984111785889,
1.2092517614364624,
0.3848629295825958,
1.0825947523117065,
-0.048585548996925354,
0.5621852874755859,
0.7876228094100952,
0.36781764030456543,
-0.9622387886047363,
0.36254897713661194,
0.04821472242474556,
-0.06164054572582245,
-0.6589905619621277,
-0.3880695104598999,
-1.146864891052246,
-0.28004568815231323,
0.2596180737018585,
-0.9007729887962341,
0.3001292645931244,
0.4061182737350464,
-0.5077099800109863,
0.2297905683517456,
-1.1658722162246704,
0.7906404137611389,
-0.9028165340423584,
-0.08945325762033463,
-0.07157330214977264,
-0.5781920552253723,
0.2632131576538086,
0.23434266448020935,
-0.14183855056762695,
0.122197724878788,
-0.19924882054328918,
0.5798344612121582,
-0.5272508263587952,
0.5850018262863159,
-0.20409554243087769,
-0.16501662135124207,
0.4397563934326172,
-0.2616606652736664,
0.4785640239715576,
0.09876322001218796,
-0.10336373746395111,
-0.35723888874053955,
-0.6940634846687317,
-0.20520803332328796,
-0.826688289642334,
0.618162989616394,
-0.5424482822418213,
-0.4202814996242523,
-0.10810536891222,
-0.6357589960098267,
-0.08084694296121597,
0.4927660822868347,
-0.024987105280160904,
0.4444403648376465,
-0.01903880387544632,
0.1310439258813858,
1.1408867835998535,
0.1501391977071762,
0.4542172849178314,
0.18498195707798004,
-0.28417620062828064,
-0.031103095039725304,
0.9390310645103455,
-0.1589440405368805,
0.1242319867014885,
0.7935887575149536,
-0.007855581119656563,
-0.5582993626594543,
-0.26900357007980347,
-0.37729412317276,
-0.45880362391471863,
-0.551584005355835,
0.11833762377500534,
-1.0269100666046143,
0.024199066683650017,
-0.4498134255409241,
-0.5994523167610168,
0.14132964611053467,
-0.3953199088573456,
-0.6890897154808044,
-0.11750197410583496,
0.4632411599159241,
0.5498618483543396,
0.44290536642074585,
0.7702343463897705,
-0.6436108350753784,
0.3810032904148102,
0.8154733180999756,
0.4804750978946686,
-0.4653101861476898,
-0.32357528805732727,
0.022473182529211044,
-0.21756772696971893,
-0.7549238801002502,
-0.7892319560050964,
0.37124747037887573,
0.12069154530763626,
0.6346442699432373,
0.7481324672698975,
0.26088249683380127,
-0.15292511880397797,
-0.591385543346405,
0.38430270552635193,
0.45856890082359314,
-0.6469859480857849,
0.6652383804321289,
0.04007522016763687,
0.13872869312763214,
0.7350236773490906,
0.3971652686595917,
-0.10965219885110855,
0.1194552630186081,
-0.7318165898323059,
-0.6915299296379089,
0.8092767000198364,
-0.30083125829696655,
0.14790977537631989,
0.454743355512619,
-0.024090318009257317,
0.3008842170238495,
0.18920095264911652,
-0.2601683735847473,
-0.3073095977306366,
-0.30569425225257874,
-0.5854396820068359,
0.05414070188999176,
0.3225092589855194,
-0.05941963195800781,
-0.12745454907417297,
0.7283205986022949,
-0.1587245613336563,
0.3936460316181183,
-0.10512476414442062,
-0.351889431476593,
-0.02511696144938469,
0.382922887802124,
0.6240692734718323,
0.37624338269233704,
-0.11599551141262054,
0.07365670055150986,
0.3335822522640228,
-0.5172230005264282,
0.4244391620159149,
0.18514281511306763,
-0.4675045609474182,
-0.04292493686079979,
-0.29973122477531433,
0.9872084259986877,
0.01375768706202507,
-0.6275015473365784,
0.29075953364372253,
-0.38718321919441223,
-0.32880157232284546,
-0.4918154180049896,
0.8818129301071167,
-0.29178592562675476,
0.001452979282476008,
0.13363578915596008,
0.4270398020744324,
0.6671715974807739,
-0.32173582911491394,
0.5285617113113403,
0.1376321166753769,
-0.749101996421814,
-0.12763795256614685,
0.44271790981292725,
0.48911020159721375,
-0.7897818088531494,
0.323430597782135,
-0.38298413157463074,
-0.5742955803871155,
0.799648642539978,
0.29302236437797546,
0.9918036460876465,
-0.33283746242523193,
0.04792314022779465,
-0.0040357946418225765,
0.22583423554897308,
0.3323155343532562,
0.438233345746994,
-0.3232180178165436,
-0.299797385931015,
-0.1696452647447586,
-0.27066850662231445,
-0.472396582365036,
-0.02745763771235943,
-0.26242223381996155,
0.7582257986068726,
-0.5507470965385437,
0.17564892768859863,
-0.15356644988059998,
-0.11853279173374176,
-0.7801977396011353,
0.2537325620651245,
-0.029552383348345757,
1.0166122913360596,
-0.8085838556289673,
0.6732804179191589,
0.8949514031410217,
0.014558391645550728,
-0.8103182911872864,
0.0065444414503872395,
-0.24784453213214874,
-0.31051912903785706,
0.6684936881065369,
0.7251486778259277,
-0.19564981758594513,
0.3472505509853363,
-0.3000790476799011,
-0.29722946882247925,
1.2745128870010376,
-0.44022881984710693,
-0.29016515612602234,
0.26956018805503845,
-0.18473805487155914,
0.22639814019203186,
-0.3122941255569458,
0.47813090682029724,
0.20669320225715637,
0.870795488357544,
-0.034368619322776794,
-0.6183282732963562,
-0.23860003054141998,
-0.08367704600095749,
-0.37837934494018555,
0.41391485929489136,
-0.20003335177898407,
0.31722190976142883,
-0.3185175657272339,
-0.2551300823688507,
-0.18143253028392792,
1.058722734451294,
-0.1646658331155777,
0.7075877785682678,
0.7175287008285522,
0.11733844876289368,
0.7392317652702332,
0.019029734656214714,
0.7566573023796082,
-0.19639331102371216,
0.28790518641471863,
0.8325635194778442,
-0.48228397965431213,
0.35630232095718384,
0.3213096261024475,
-0.2725474536418915,
0.7529045343399048,
0.33186060190200806,
0.0795770138502121,
0.6126883029937744,
-0.11405719816684723,
-0.6488621830940247,
-0.21688580513000488,
0.13192526996135712,
0.08813772350549698,
0.30421340465545654,
0.6926714181900024,
-0.36732950806617737,
-0.11379215866327286,
0.47986721992492676,
-0.5789873600006104,
-0.10373416543006897,
-0.5092906951904297,
0.9547001719474792,
-0.2033635377883911,
-0.44926705956459045,
-0.015033728443086147,
0.008290065452456474,
0.5801887512207031,
-0.45080506801605225,
-0.1966087967157364,
0.6142160892486572,
0.24974288046360016,
-0.5925225019454956,
-0.8311729431152344,
0.0720343366265297,
-0.09448622167110443,
-0.24349866807460785,
-0.601674497127533,
0.9947699308395386,
-0.2627470791339874,
-0.3175193667411804,
-0.1757100373506546,
-0.0044591790065169334,
0.1869433969259262,
0.4433692395687103,
-0.383029967546463,
-0.4071004092693329,
0.034219078719615936,
-0.22154398262500763,
0.05384233593940735,
0.5959576368331909,
-0.2182178795337677,
0.8535826206207275,
0.5643054842948914,
-0.3140298128128052,
0.2107633650302887,
-0.08116427809000015,
0.5057218074798584,
-0.4222200810909271,
-0.6177762746810913,
-0.37196648120880127,
0.6764687299728394,
-0.22591517865657806,
-0.039716076105833054,
0.7125198245048523,
0.4547826647758484,
0.9165894985198975,
-0.19250182807445526,
1.2086411714553833,
-0.26361724734306335,
0.227238729596138,
-0.33394354581832886,
0.37332937121391296,
-0.4036112129688263,
0.3287392854690552,
0.20321282744407654,
-0.4166475832462311,
-0.23292796313762665,
0.29620301723480225,
-0.7008355855941772,
0.2779140770435333,
0.516690731048584,
0.549288272857666,
-0.64867103099823,
0.0962730273604393,
0.5416174530982971,
-0.37776806950569153,
0.28114646673202515,
0.2582606375217438,
0.9906426072120667,
-0.07552268356084824,
0.15766601264476776,
-0.42677706480026245,
-0.6085157990455627,
-0.913366436958313,
-0.5516294836997986,
-0.5448058843612671,
-0.30972689390182495,
-0.06972713023424149,
0.15765587985515594,
-0.3001512289047241,
1.0527514219284058,
0.5215836763381958,
-0.927783191204071,
-0.1279587745666504,
-0.5660324096679688,
0.4488944709300995,
-0.4730471968650818,
-0.29533547163009644,
0.10359615832567215,
-0.7377045750617981,
-0.6406881809234619,
0.35317450761795044,
0.5853970050811768,
0.17143794894218445,
-0.15540751814842224,
-0.4319884181022644,
-0.05527156963944435,
0.17228052020072937,
0.8123140931129456,
0.5067470669746399,
-0.5457732081413269,
-0.24551433324813843,
0.20370528101921082,
-0.23942448198795319,
-0.006115541327744722,
0.8561934232711792,
-0.7621610164642334,
0.41572821140289307,
0.6846727132797241,
0.6647176742553711,
-0.18338629603385925,
0.3003539741039276,
0.4630657732486725,
-0.3752458989620209,
-0.21397468447685242,
0.27213799953460693,
0.3532811999320984,
0.03195309638977051,
-0.8500056862831116,
-0.21038982272148132,
-0.12937144935131073,
-0.7773560881614685,
-0.36609044671058655,
0.43970024585723877,
-1.2424296140670776,
-0.313199907541275,
0.74434894323349,
-0.12095311284065247,
-0.42048195004463196,
-0.5294755101203918,
-0.6247866153717041,
0.28005072474479675,
-0.4841237962245941,
0.9327816963195801,
-0.04948113113641739,
-0.9234687685966492,
-0.08044662326574326,
-0.42421576380729675,
0.1616819202899933,
0.1954786479473114,
-1.2490720748901367,
0.0023849839344620705,
0.37457722425460815,
-0.15461032092571259,
0.2766742706298828,
0.21370314061641693,
0.229736328125,
0.6974042654037476,
-0.5516484379768372,
0.2757198214530945,
-0.32087475061416626,
-0.9446081519126892,
-0.2922167181968689,
0.37396252155303955,
-0.18494616448879242,
-0.47512245178222656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01241v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01241v2
|
IntactKV: Improving Large Language Model Quantization by Keeping Pivot Tokens Intact
| 2024-03-02T16:05:26 | 2024-05-25T10:33:03 |
Ruikang Liu, Haoli Bai, Haokun Lin, Yuening Li, Han Gao, Zhengzhuo Xu, Lu Hou, Jun Yao, Chun Yuan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) excel in natural language processing but demand
intensive computation. To mitigate this, various quantization methods have been
explored, yet they compromise LLM performance. This paper unveils a previously
overlooked type of outliers in LLMs. Such outliers are found to allocate most
of the attention scores on initial tokens of input, termed as pivot tokens,
which are crucial to the performance of quantized LLMs. Given that, we propose
IntactKV to generate the KV cache of pivot tokens losslessly from the
full-precision model. The approach is simple and easy to combine with existing
quantization solutions with no extra inference overhead. Besides, IntactKV can
be calibrated as additional LLM parameters to boost the quantized LLMs further
with minimal training costs. Mathematical analysis also proves that IntactKV
effectively reduces the upper bound of quantization error. Empirical results
show that IntactKV brings consistent improvement over various quantization
methods across different LLMs and downstream tasks, leading to the new
state-of-the-art for LLM quantization. The codes are available at
https://github.com/ruikangliu/IntactKV.
|
[
0.16627532243728638,
-0.6727228760719299,
0.5616714954376221,
0.15427321195602417,
-0.6920168399810791,
0.06767391413450241,
-0.5115676522254944,
0.004611867014318705,
0.09343738853931427,
0.68211829662323,
-0.23131632804870605,
-0.5366033315658569,
-0.5622559785842896,
-0.2399718165397644,
-0.28087979555130005,
0.8385694622993469,
0.10968366265296936,
0.2111649364233017,
-0.25495803356170654,
-0.21599991619586945,
-0.38886553049087524,
-0.3937041461467743,
-0.3730606436729431,
-0.2456737458705902,
0.14065082371234894,
0.3351801633834839,
0.6450057625770569,
0.839777946472168,
0.544863224029541,
0.28871703147888184,
-0.2629909813404083,
0.18661433458328247,
-0.4982755780220032,
0.5288787484169006,
0.1643933802843094,
-0.6538297533988953,
-0.43766385316848755,
-0.42522358894348145,
0.9991233348846436,
0.6293947696685791,
-0.35837432742118835,
0.030466539785265923,
-0.04997626692056656,
0.9589121341705322,
-0.9662647843360901,
0.31313028931617737,
-0.8040230870246887,
-0.07914738357067108,
-0.43319055438041687,
0.2451530545949936,
-0.6966946721076965,
-0.33373579382896423,
-0.193693608045578,
-0.5064696669578552,
-0.22556695342063904,
-0.27147310972213745,
0.6979542970657349,
0.5544871687889099,
-0.34064534306526184,
0.2138906568288803,
-0.6267019510269165,
0.6556991934776306,
-0.7857372760772705,
0.46199190616607666,
0.28045254945755005,
0.1511920839548111,
-0.3545989394187927,
-0.9207326769828796,
-0.2572875916957855,
-0.002376670017838478,
0.19424684345722198,
0.18555457890033722,
-0.08570614457130432,
0.20707818865776062,
0.030567605048418045,
0.44985711574554443,
-0.33229151368141174,
0.01978074572980404,
-0.3938208520412445,
-0.19680999219417572,
0.35883140563964844,
0.294528990983963,
0.2603883147239685,
-0.20956958830356598,
-0.11073216795921326,
-0.015265244990587234,
-0.9772547483444214,
0.25749361515045166,
0.3172888159751892,
0.28954118490219116,
0.13137201964855194,
0.8815305233001709,
-0.2880246341228485,
0.44819509983062744,
-0.006519170943647623,
-0.14959219098091125,
0.14270684123039246,
-0.4239956736564636,
-0.35943618416786194,
0.3157745599746704,
0.7556101083755493,
0.10616813600063324,
0.25362926721572876,
-0.052916597574949265,
-0.02369282953441143,
-0.04222843796014786,
0.4274819791316986,
-0.8973073959350586,
-0.5661547780036926,
0.17355242371559143,
-0.39311277866363525,
-0.253943532705307,
0.183568075299263,
-0.3104960024356842,
-0.11283475905656815,
-0.39258265495300293,
0.30809226632118225,
-0.5659706592559814,
-0.2894408702850342,
0.01977493055164814,
0.29648151993751526,
0.19615969061851501,
0.3512020409107208,
-0.7516515851020813,
-0.054314885288476944,
1.1140532493591309,
0.8744603991508484,
-0.2247348576784134,
0.10036683827638626,
-0.9154785871505737,
0.16000553965568542,
-0.5669649243354797,
0.5392531156539917,
-0.4983959197998047,
-0.17591610550880432,
-0.018751291558146477,
0.013761366717517376,
0.3891753852367401,
-0.4469429552555084,
0.6269089579582214,
-0.40212753415107727,
-0.12791214883327484,
-0.23151026666164398,
-0.5575444102287292,
0.028639420866966248,
0.13521908223628998,
-0.5919516682624817,
1.3128529787063599,
0.07452274858951569,
-0.7982187867164612,
0.5283523201942444,
-0.35794374346733093,
-0.31321775913238525,
0.37597498297691345,
0.08068279922008514,
-0.7282817959785461,
0.5598582625389099,
0.24825626611709595,
0.381317675113678,
0.01832389086484909,
0.4898969233036041,
-0.35168877243995667,
-0.3764590620994568,
0.27354615926742554,
-0.507493257522583,
0.7945636510848999,
-0.07581789046525955,
-0.08462779223918915,
0.24611707031726837,
-0.6426568627357483,
0.3096931576728821,
-0.16549772024154663,
-0.6671141386032104,
-0.5267273187637329,
0.03388003259897232,
-0.15264858305454254,
-0.2230159193277359,
-0.04104427993297577,
-0.5732879042625427,
0.4621724784374237,
-0.9875553250312805,
0.5749912858009338,
0.8567460179328918,
-0.08775883167982101,
0.560462236404419,
0.25781768560409546,
0.3379078209400177,
0.16838285326957703,
0.13574711978435516,
-0.6039183735847473,
-0.3914828300476074,
-0.833652138710022,
-0.8184009194374084,
0.5680986046791077,
0.028617898002266884,
-0.7733474969863892,
0.44056418538093567,
-0.7129993438720703,
-0.46556776762008667,
-0.7133209705352783,
0.0005222233012318611,
0.23799824714660645,
0.4551662504673004,
-0.053469277918338776,
-0.14086931943893433,
-0.45868781208992004,
-0.9705207943916321,
-0.37156084179878235,
-0.13991130888462067,
-0.24852706491947174,
-0.2853665351867676,
0.24467788636684418,
-0.04873104393482208,
1.0864533185958862,
-0.3544533848762512,
-0.21205773949623108,
0.03997838869690895,
-0.07294318825006485,
0.24500441551208496,
0.3396426737308502,
-0.03729734569787979,
-0.6685324311256409,
-0.8456916213035583,
0.21331407129764557,
-0.30170848965644836,
0.003641332732513547,
0.2762543261051178,
-0.35191959142684937,
0.39909976720809937,
0.5243644714355469,
-0.679573118686676,
0.5596614480018616,
0.3418142795562744,
-0.2836858630180359,
0.371182382106781,
-0.24519142508506775,
-0.004113995004445314,
-1.129225730895996,
0.0723118931055069,
-0.3617638647556305,
-0.7504031658172607,
-0.5925800800323486,
-0.14691492915153503,
0.6264523267745972,
0.2040531486272812,
-0.7296818494796753,
0.2741953432559967,
-0.4392669200897217,
-0.08182595670223236,
-0.38988685607910156,
0.07873791456222534,
0.05793486908078194,
0.45443472266197205,
-0.2935796082019806,
0.6429638266563416,
0.49284088611602783,
-0.30928027629852295,
0.48967820405960083,
0.15731962025165558,
-0.5105724334716797,
0.3263970613479614,
-0.6146183609962463,
0.04402444511651993,
-0.31241118907928467,
0.16183914244174957,
-0.752997875213623,
-0.21467477083206177,
0.2574267089366913,
-0.45254185795783997,
0.5027568936347961,
-0.46252045035362244,
-0.7125937938690186,
0.24713104963302612,
-0.5296516418457031,
0.49927130341529846,
0.6708287596702576,
-0.3371899724006653,
0.622735321521759,
0.46018198132514954,
-0.12151705473661423,
-0.5115417242050171,
-0.7017579674720764,
-0.017247503623366356,
-0.16860319674015045,
-0.48650574684143066,
0.17429398000240326,
0.1133028194308281,
-0.14271420240402222,
-0.0027606890071183443,
-0.25126439332962036,
-0.0019136341288685799,
-0.030539920553565025,
0.32605868577957153,
0.22593167424201965,
-0.3392030596733093,
0.37105798721313477,
0.19312676787376404,
-0.27059605717658997,
-0.0875050276517868,
-0.4802246689796448,
0.4858861267566681,
-0.34188970923423767,
-0.4185052812099457,
-0.40604960918426514,
0.09546691179275513,
0.9103518724441528,
-0.3427745997905731,
0.851033091545105,
0.43250325322151184,
-0.45114102959632874,
0.049838919192552567,
-0.45616310834884644,
0.05732259899377823,
-0.483891099691391,
0.7437507510185242,
-0.16126658022403717,
-0.8837954998016357,
0.39830127358436584,
-0.13391371071338654,
0.003966362681239843,
0.289659708738327,
0.9536539912223816,
0.09656527638435364,
1.017259120941162,
0.520453155040741,
0.0057793776504695415,
0.5052466988563538,
0.02634137123823166,
0.3483552634716034,
-1.0416067838668823,
-0.33523017168045044,
-0.36708348989486694,
-0.11342678219079971,
-0.40343260765075684,
-0.4917652904987335,
0.5014784932136536,
0.3340834379196167,
-0.2925513684749603,
-0.06603899598121643,
-0.5399190783500671,
0.670839250087738,
0.34181320667266846,
0.07498328387737274,
0.3038414716720581,
0.10231556743383408,
-0.18693256378173828,
-0.35888174176216125,
-0.6976070404052734,
-0.40264225006103516,
1.178756833076477,
0.2867625057697296,
0.6864879727363586,
0.00019916956080123782,
0.22997871041297913,
0.030875951051712036,
0.47608959674835205,
-0.8816874623298645,
0.09181378781795502,
-0.2573672831058502,
-0.39221352338790894,
-0.4858063757419586,
-0.42384982109069824,
-0.8452721238136292,
0.4035494327545166,
-0.008444203063845634,
-0.8363142609596252,
-0.07510848343372345,
0.1618947833776474,
-0.30426090955734253,
0.32135114073753357,
-0.6415530443191528,
0.8299712538719177,
-0.13179196417331696,
-0.2618957757949829,
0.19898538291454315,
-0.5437330007553101,
0.5468698740005493,
-0.2447023242712021,
0.027702370658516884,
-0.3460284173488617,
-0.1979765146970749,
0.5759772658348083,
-0.7504810094833374,
0.7445381283760071,
-0.09571731835603714,
-0.06823956221342087,
0.20028181374073029,
0.013611896894872189,
0.9214047193527222,
0.3358851969242096,
0.09076778590679169,
0.17563632130622864,
0.0195209588855505,
-0.47025254368782043,
-0.666010856628418,
0.6001022458076477,
-0.5643596649169922,
-0.35428866744041443,
-0.06565485894680023,
-0.3737996518611908,
-0.042099498212337494,
0.3309216797351837,
0.2380460500717163,
0.3694303035736084,
0.22631077468395233,
0.8447698950767517,
0.8009201288223267,
-0.03139106556773186,
0.5060662031173706,
0.3551613688468933,
-0.048850011080503464,
-0.8232161402702332,
0.6986345648765564,
0.026706332340836525,
0.3361380994319916,
0.4120120108127594,
0.34596097469329834,
-0.2105366587638855,
-0.4630676805973053,
-0.29723772406578064,
0.11062805354595184,
-0.7798022627830505,
-0.7811819314956665,
-0.685827910900116,
-0.07586131989955902,
-0.3113182783126831,
0.014212492853403091,
-1.3343048095703125,
-0.4938865602016449,
-0.19871151447296143,
-0.07660943269729614,
0.48937252163887024,
0.3338080942630768,
0.18912436068058014,
0.41983696818351746,
-1.0184733867645264,
0.1644994467496872,
0.03418423607945442,
0.46689391136169434,
-0.0032236117403954268,
-0.4968322217464447,
-0.4732811450958252,
0.3212173879146576,
-0.16624082624912262,
-0.48805588483810425,
0.5178113579750061,
0.33465421199798584,
0.30480262637138367,
0.5367365479469299,
0.30280420184135437,
0.9146648645401001,
-0.6277023553848267,
0.6294777393341064,
0.2760874032974243,
-1.1854418516159058,
0.4224637746810913,
-0.12957412004470825,
0.5799355506896973,
0.7280110120773315,
-0.07039966434240341,
-0.7115499377250671,
-0.48278364539146423,
-0.25427699089050293,
-1.262163758277893,
0.8667587041854858,
0.3038153350353241,
0.19000384211540222,
0.1378912776708603,
0.6517054438591003,
0.30466949939727783,
0.2277398556470871,
-0.9624518752098083,
-0.227722629904747,
-0.04895931854844093,
-0.515344500541687,
0.34510353207588196,
-0.4511909782886505,
0.18930086493492126,
-0.34821051359176636,
0.6433239579200745,
-0.1717757284641266,
0.05210539326071739,
0.09820639342069626,
-0.21669282019138336,
-0.34304100275039673,
-0.07685161381959915,
0.6236433982849121,
0.7603849768638611,
0.15546876192092896,
0.25031688809394836,
0.16064025461673737,
-0.7220717072486877,
0.11062369495630264,
-0.4380418062210083,
-0.1479615420103073,
-0.08600207418203354,
0.3637796938419342,
0.7094465494155884,
0.4840061068534851,
-0.8058962225914001,
0.6977066993713379,
-0.2717110216617584,
-0.054884977638721466,
-0.34004437923431396,
-0.15407724678516388,
0.1939450204372406,
0.35382553935050964,
0.3763277530670166,
-0.18682536482810974,
-0.28026217222213745,
-0.37991392612457275,
0.08209703862667084,
0.49003541469573975,
-0.4121488332748413,
-0.3528176546096802,
0.6212034821510315,
0.0021889887284487486,
-0.40110158920288086,
0.9511804580688477,
0.06713099032640457,
-0.8247211575508118,
0.2547365128993988,
0.20378780364990234,
0.9899618029594421,
-0.1398385614156723,
-0.07470880448818207,
0.04828859865665436,
0.560954213142395,
-0.21991850435733795,
0.011309402994811535,
-0.15519410371780396,
-0.4257476329803467,
-0.907163679599762,
-0.6464477181434631,
-0.17575794458389282,
-0.08434510976076126,
-0.4629688262939453,
0.46389836072921753,
-0.11835954338312149,
0.1655264049768448,
-0.3869968056678772,
-0.14475204050540924,
-0.32766345143318176,
-0.17216530442237854,
-0.049275029450654984,
0.4511512517929077,
-0.6017915606498718,
1.1581456661224365,
0.6359872221946716,
-0.02332152985036373,
-0.5926845669746399,
-0.09547120332717896,
-0.4993806481361389,
-0.6405051946640015,
0.702461302280426,
0.12963634729385376,
0.3350547254085541,
-0.19318930804729462,
-0.5844523906707764,
-1.117697834968567,
0.9192413687705994,
0.8115860819816589,
-0.578815758228302,
0.16241000592708588,
0.3389844298362732,
0.3264411687850952,
0.014416063204407692,
0.17160950601100922,
0.43956613540649414,
0.406026154756546,
0.10974381864070892,
-0.7432417273521423,
-0.025595160201191902,
-0.023375216871500015,
0.026254769414663315,
0.7811974287033081,
-0.6471220850944519,
0.581010103225708,
0.2333202213048935,
-0.16562196612358093,
-0.13026008009910583,
0.6811811923980713,
0.3439389765262604,
0.01720525324344635,
0.19483502209186554,
0.641010046005249,
0.6265406608581543,
-0.31850099563598633,
0.688603937625885,
-0.20549356937408447,
0.43446892499923706,
0.8763378858566284,
-0.07772853225469589,
0.8653905391693115,
0.7622819542884827,
-0.3119303286075592,
-0.16621790826320648,
0.5140278935432434,
0.20662765204906464,
0.6300853490829468,
0.17668339610099792,
-0.20307672023773193,
-0.4350760579109192,
0.3296841084957123,
-0.1564134806394577,
0.6044375896453857,
0.20395374298095703,
-0.12377116084098816,
-0.089925117790699,
0.1040562316775322,
0.17383794486522675,
-0.2861294746398926,
-0.3348429203033447,
0.7647097110748291,
0.15336082875728607,
-0.5974664688110352,
0.48474133014678955,
0.19952796399593353,
0.5179356336593628,
-0.641275942325592,
0.03996387496590614,
-0.29734566807746887,
0.3867148458957672,
-0.05319121852517128,
-0.3571661412715912,
0.5617155432701111,
-0.11273376643657684,
-0.2003767490386963,
-0.295386403799057,
0.6631585955619812,
-0.5327446460723877,
-0.8110311627388,
-0.3106265962123871,
0.016195019707083702,
0.13380655646324158,
-0.43758395314216614,
-0.2231328934431076,
0.3296746015548706,
0.09863128513097763,
-0.4326878786087036,
0.3862871527671814,
0.8818922638893127,
-0.060911718755960464,
0.7279323935508728,
0.6444684267044067,
0.1480352282524109,
0.36936503648757935,
-0.40424296259880066,
0.9757966995239258,
-0.52158123254776,
-0.5102236866950989,
-1.254153847694397,
0.9530399441719055,
0.07245150208473206,
-0.24223020672798157,
0.5932310819625854,
0.6856080889701843,
0.5806405544281006,
0.04586179926991463,
0.32061153650283813,
0.40856602787971497,
0.08264342695474625,
-0.618349552154541,
0.9282240867614746,
-0.4774906039237976,
0.24756111204624176,
-0.17075753211975098,
-1.0943247079849243,
-0.5105006694793701,
0.43063288927078247,
0.10027822107076645,
-0.27838134765625,
0.592917263507843,
0.3955480456352234,
-0.014502068981528282,
-0.21558550000190735,
0.5455560684204102,
0.31320005655288696,
0.4702378511428833,
0.37460872530937195,
0.7297921776771545,
-0.46069368720054626,
0.7269926071166992,
-0.2614111006259918,
-0.030726440250873566,
-0.29870831966400146,
-1.0783851146697998,
-0.6652825474739075,
-0.39794090390205383,
-0.5903593301773071,
-0.04218880832195282,
0.069699726998806,
0.7586711645126343,
0.7447068691253662,
-0.5508514046669006,
0.19270873069763184,
-0.28806525468826294,
0.26559028029441833,
0.25545191764831543,
-0.25622785091400146,
0.5694370269775391,
-0.3828866183757782,
-0.7828464508056641,
0.1624118983745575,
0.8294634819030762,
-0.24447692930698395,
-0.21308280527591705,
-0.12220583111047745,
0.11247227340936661,
-0.19342397153377533,
0.6737605333328247,
-0.1521841436624527,
-0.7964640259742737,
-0.1477295607328415,
-0.07241562008857727,
0.07653647661209106,
0.40116649866104126,
0.8944332003593445,
-0.7533843517303467,
0.7364305853843689,
0.4521997570991516,
0.8605448007583618,
0.6156731843948364,
0.015426810830831528,
0.6697065234184265,
-0.9517337083816528,
0.2600201964378357,
0.36825236678123474,
0.3251930773258209,
0.3325772285461426,
-0.3901427984237671,
0.21370051801204681,
0.16953516006469727,
-0.6136863827705383,
-1.3494219779968262,
0.0019583820831030607,
-0.7603402733802795,
-0.18667034804821014,
1.0054669380187988,
-0.21208547055721283,
-0.5015775561332703,
0.0706995353102684,
-0.09127678722143173,
0.39353910088539124,
-0.3599691390991211,
0.5526365637779236,
0.8145503401756287,
0.15541572868824005,
-0.1821039915084839,
-0.4060136675834656,
0.33991649746894836,
0.4127900004386902,
-0.5668196678161621,
0.4117702543735504,
0.2385721504688263,
0.24143032729625702,
-0.23364834487438202,
0.3570648729801178,
-0.45670101046562195,
0.13457566499710083,
-0.1833663284778595,
0.1772616058588028,
-0.08497432619333267,
0.014231325127184391,
-0.37021201848983765,
0.1164889857172966,
0.056806255131959915,
-0.22539211809635162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01222v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01222v2
|
Emotion Analysis in NLP: Trends, Gaps and Roadmap for Future Directions
| 2024-03-02T14:38:03 | 2024-03-18T10:51:14 |
Flor Miriam Plaza-del-Arco, Alba Curry, Amanda Cercas Curry, Dirk Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Emotions are a central aspect of communication. Consequently, emotion
analysis (EA) is a rapidly growing field in natural language processing (NLP).
However, there is no consensus on scope, direction, or methods. In this paper,
we conduct a thorough review of 154 relevant NLP publications from the last
decade. Based on this review, we address four different questions: (1) How are
EA tasks defined in NLP? (2) What are the most prominent emotion frameworks and
which emotions are modeled? (3) Is the subjectivity of emotions considered in
terms of demographics and cultural factors? and (4) What are the primary NLP
applications for EA? We take stock of trends in EA and tasks, emotion
frameworks used, existing datasets, methods, and applications. We then discuss
four lacunae: (1) the absence of demographic and cultural aspects does not
account for the variation in how emotions are perceived, but instead assumes
they are universally experienced in the same manner; (2) the poor fit of
emotion categories from the two main emotion theories to the task; (3) the lack
of standardized EA terminology hinders gap identification, comparison, and
future goals; and (4) the absence of interdisciplinary research isolates EA
from insights in other fields. Our work will enable more focused research into
EA and a more holistic approach to modeling emotions in NLP.
|
[
-0.713360071182251,
-0.5338205695152283,
0.26904770731925964,
0.5982182621955872,
0.1287132054567337,
0.16622968018054962,
-0.252407044172287,
-0.9838529229164124,
0.33757925033569336,
0.2665282189846039,
-0.6127813458442688,
-0.5931934714317322,
-0.8107197284698486,
0.4221826195716858,
-0.3690967857837677,
0.7091310024261475,
-0.1454300880432129,
-0.292456716299057,
-0.14257557690143585,
-0.5590759515762329,
-0.4388527572154999,
-0.8586744070053101,
-0.6216961145401001,
-0.26576587557792664,
0.5104944109916687,
0.28121182322502136,
0.3098878860473633,
0.12242734432220459,
0.5679867267608643,
0.3669013977050781,
-0.4234234094619751,
-0.17974461615085602,
-0.292885959148407,
0.23467499017715454,
0.14141714572906494,
-0.394492506980896,
-0.6185563206672668,
0.12234923988580704,
0.22683006525039673,
0.8059194087982178,
0.026629792526364326,
0.1477481573820114,
0.004443655256181955,
1.2482794523239136,
-0.6356555223464966,
0.24541865289211273,
-0.2463904619216919,
0.47477540373802185,
-0.24641741812229156,
-0.23655268549919128,
-0.164564311504364,
0.055240727961063385,
0.42869454622268677,
-0.03662775829434395,
0.24021047353744507,
0.0009997546439990401,
0.6148871183395386,
0.16129277646541595,
-0.7438721060752869,
-0.54477858543396,
-0.5697812438011169,
0.8914623856544495,
-0.6341392993927002,
0.3927902281284332,
0.17916882038116455,
-0.23916082084178925,
0.18147291243076324,
-0.5069214105606079,
-0.33557936549186707,
0.10634072870016098,
0.11482719331979752,
0.3373226821422577,
-0.6846883893013,
0.18567217886447906,
0.25016260147094727,
0.32489678263664246,
-0.47498154640197754,
0.11574482172727585,
-0.12186551094055176,
0.2604450583457947,
0.7817577123641968,
0.3050529360771179,
0.42627817392349243,
-0.037717875093221664,
-0.38264816999435425,
0.2376701682806015,
-0.4210548996925354,
0.08638066798448563,
0.44757750630378723,
-0.13472868502140045,
-0.020934851840138435,
0.39724013209342957,
-0.2850452661514282,
0.4677805006504059,
0.055437736213207245,
0.45205917954444885,
0.1997596174478531,
0.006056301295757294,
-0.1552637666463852,
-0.2035762518644333,
0.7663587927818298,
0.5762036442756653,
0.03883729130029678,
-0.20035724341869354,
-0.050385940819978714,
0.14858311414718628,
0.5016060471534729,
-0.3782561719417572,
0.12452181428670883,
0.7492153644561768,
-0.5574691891670227,
-0.06199266389012337,
-0.18916843831539154,
-1.303438663482666,
-0.2371244877576828,
-0.32011178135871887,
-0.299575537443161,
-0.022766748443245888,
-0.44563090801239014,
0.01749058999121189,
0.06044068560004234,
0.22656498849391937,
0.14248649775981903,
-0.9152063131332397,
0.4696063697338104,
0.8518438935279846,
0.7203109264373779,
-0.3382902145385742,
-0.1644209772348404,
0.1719379723072052,
-0.565325140953064,
-0.31889113783836365,
0.7593744397163391,
-0.4633885622024536,
-0.27597400546073914,
0.515943169593811,
0.07036138325929642,
-0.038119398057460785,
-0.33919307589530945,
0.6081064343452454,
-0.3593556582927704,
0.3331061005592346,
-0.5589670538902283,
-0.42266732454299927,
-0.4061579406261444,
0.30980151891708374,
-0.7058123350143433,
1.0639159679412842,
-0.14686910808086395,
-0.7451549172401428,
0.16244196891784668,
-0.8428502082824707,
-0.3089100420475006,
0.04819771274924278,
0.19975027441978455,
0.06490662693977356,
0.32916000485420227,
-0.131681427359581,
0.43105459213256836,
-0.3858041763305664,
0.1440175324678421,
-0.23029132187366486,
-0.1870967149734497,
0.03413183242082596,
0.12989281117916107,
0.7155373692512512,
0.1613699197769165,
-0.672398567199707,
-0.06427893042564392,
-0.5257465839385986,
-0.07546457648277283,
-0.1810818612575531,
-0.0145451370626688,
-0.24855685234069824,
0.3607005476951599,
0.292336642742157,
0.35915300250053406,
0.21030935645103455,
-0.45270559191703796,
-0.044240403920412064,
-0.4604097604751587,
0.24229009449481964,
0.48642227053642273,
-0.1487034112215042,
0.574704110622406,
0.223018616437912,
0.8414377570152283,
-0.2532958984375,
0.040425319224596024,
0.022691911086440086,
-0.7010038495063782,
-0.8299767971038818,
0.4198446571826935,
0.06999365240335464,
0.5846711993217468,
-0.09211165457963943,
0.6765645146369934,
0.32213011384010315,
-0.5011241436004639,
-0.5370150804519653,
-0.14366495609283447,
0.1372414380311966,
0.3524290919303894,
0.40798071026802063,
-0.34900686144828796,
-0.5165268182754517,
-0.6129942536354065,
-0.49551787972450256,
-0.3179711699485779,
0.161470428109169,
-0.06558653712272644,
0.25428521633148193,
-0.23899538815021515,
0.8829498291015625,
-0.40699344873428345,
-0.3814704120159149,
-0.37723204493522644,
0.6804662942886353,
-0.13258236646652222,
0.27959534525871277,
0.6769891381263733,
-0.8907752633094788,
-0.3928226828575134,
0.025038646534085274,
-0.8538455963134766,
-0.45390623807907104,
0.014027220197021961,
0.08393365144729614,
0.3883954882621765,
0.421954482793808,
-0.6189760565757751,
0.3926013112068176,
0.7350844740867615,
-0.3468107581138611,
0.33131861686706543,
0.1844104677438736,
0.07502610236406326,
-0.6458619236946106,
0.294942170381546,
0.44128096103668213,
0.3785593807697296,
-1.0037764310836792,
0.0788385197520256,
-0.23610712587833405,
-0.10199273377656937,
-0.24585428833961487,
0.5615606904029846,
-0.658469021320343,
0.10536764562129974,
-0.46030980348587036,
0.10938772559165955,
-0.03672483190894127,
0.5018004775047302,
0.20667028427124023,
0.06542792916297913,
0.46078571677207947,
-0.45161065459251404,
0.4573175013065338,
0.28368523716926575,
0.028036419302225113,
0.6957612037658691,
-0.4894031286239624,
0.30136239528656006,
-0.3395325541496277,
0.15705208480358124,
-0.6958872675895691,
0.06590570509433746,
0.18909326195716858,
-0.3499475121498108,
0.17733199894428253,
0.132257342338562,
-0.0183865986764431,
-0.31637513637542725,
-0.21029670536518097,
0.2337929755449295,
0.5185407996177673,
-0.013494965620338917,
0.7749074697494507,
0.4908815920352936,
-0.5700520277023315,
-0.7539743185043335,
-0.6127446293830872,
0.2859896719455719,
-0.43854644894599915,
-0.44716349244117737,
0.15014582872390747,
-0.11063625663518906,
-0.6647101044654846,
0.025906076654791832,
-0.29368820786476135,
-0.3713243901729584,
0.1764874905347824,
0.3958200216293335,
-0.15977707505226135,
-0.0855475515127182,
0.2087571769952774,
-0.13863931596279144,
-0.12843798100948334,
0.4367692172527313,
0.14276061952114105,
0.262382835149765,
-0.5359989404678345,
-0.07666212320327759,
-0.1613178551197052,
0.8857741355895996,
0.23612858355045319,
-0.35261571407318115,
0.4234567880630493,
0.7739630937576294,
-0.444492906332016,
-0.05417438596487045,
-0.5994358062744141,
0.21387776732444763,
-0.31914442777633667,
0.516129732131958,
0.015909621492028236,
-0.8478696942329407,
0.5832949280738831,
-0.11874754726886749,
0.22576111555099487,
0.6417297124862671,
0.5580741167068481,
-0.35093384981155396,
0.9295095801353455,
1.079008936882019,
-0.058976687490940094,
0.5516355633735657,
-0.22631976008415222,
0.4310763478279114,
-0.8390927910804749,
-0.11368807405233383,
-0.7852903604507446,
-0.6467576026916504,
-0.5976493954658508,
0.1212681457400322,
-0.06876040995121002,
-0.027084369212388992,
0.32045063376426697,
0.08956123143434525,
-0.2366422563791275,
0.2046595811843872,
0.18374982476234436,
-0.48872610926628113,
-0.000310937175527215,
-0.4010286331176758,
0.5605675578117371,
-0.2530374526977539,
-0.5938919186592102,
-0.6236504912376404,
0.632646918296814,
0.5529485940933228,
0.2579842209815979,
0.047548890113830566,
0.6506635546684265,
0.24125789105892181,
0.5598440766334534,
-0.9451128244400024,
0.49589213728904724,
-0.0762903243303299,
-0.7224319577217102,
-0.23178377747535706,
-0.15321049094200134,
-1.1273746490478516,
0.3498219847679138,
-0.3422282040119171,
-1.1882418394088745,
0.4350254237651825,
0.025287533178925514,
-0.061165980994701385,
0.1534702479839325,
-0.6565129160881042,
1.053098201751709,
-0.13509635627269745,
-0.15573428571224213,
0.040728211402893066,
-0.8360769748687744,
0.5631490349769592,
-0.10570060461759567,
0.3586534559726715,
-0.4994437098503113,
0.1436055302619934,
0.8491777777671814,
-0.14439773559570312,
0.7193837761878967,
-0.17963877320289612,
-0.20791855454444885,
0.3659707009792328,
-0.09332851320505142,
0.06951789557933807,
-0.2965922951698303,
-0.07188041508197784,
0.28014349937438965,
0.2827529013156891,
-0.22359611093997955,
-0.575724184513092,
0.4159270226955414,
-0.3561488687992096,
-0.5202066898345947,
-0.5834352374076843,
-0.38293927907943726,
-0.435537725687027,
0.016437459737062454,
0.24386057257652283,
0.09924408048391342,
-0.39218997955322266,
0.05561034008860588,
0.42027518153190613,
-0.1683627963066101,
0.4783598780632019,
0.2150481641292572,
0.12248892337083817,
0.0794181302189827,
0.6423567533493042,
0.026571480557322502,
0.02363230660557747,
0.2459525763988495,
0.009223386645317078,
-0.09464932233095169,
-0.4359184801578522,
0.028914613649249077,
-0.01827932894229889,
-0.6661503314971924,
-0.054368313401937485,
-0.8469255566596985,
0.21436159312725067,
-0.3825765550136566,
-0.12998813390731812,
-0.3656643033027649,
0.056731414049863815,
-0.3919655680656433,
-0.06769637763500214,
0.2946249544620514,
0.8032345771789551,
0.031108208000659943,
0.27701297402381897,
-0.9082136750221252,
0.2765049636363983,
0.049983374774456024,
0.39256155490875244,
0.2226509153842926,
0.028979994356632233,
-0.25597551465034485,
-0.21756358444690704,
-0.2405785173177719,
-1.231799602508545,
0.7195636630058289,
0.14440320432186127,
0.18190786242485046,
0.3954954147338867,
0.224608913064003,
0.4667130410671234,
-0.40315282344818115,
0.9727624654769897,
0.18141400814056396,
-1.1408404111862183,
0.25970032811164856,
-0.037629228085279465,
0.21830138564109802,
0.4925558567047119,
0.5454418063163757,
-1.042768120765686,
-0.36126595735549927,
-0.7889133095741272,
-1.3433265686035156,
0.6620838642120361,
0.008129507303237915,
0.2263767272233963,
-0.11065242439508438,
0.17518611252307892,
-0.08306097239255905,
0.22960467636585236,
-0.52461177110672,
-0.3534071743488312,
0.24181599915027618,
-0.4469485878944397,
-0.010655922815203667,
-0.24508188664913177,
-0.19522880017757416,
0.1775401085615158,
0.22653140127658844,
-0.10891695320606232,
0.5135977268218994,
0.11850740760564804,
0.08760297298431396,
-0.33114415407180786,
0.31464773416519165,
0.33329981565475464,
0.4840599596500397,
-0.349457710981369,
-0.04945552349090576,
0.26048097014427185,
-0.3923247158527374,
0.04263584688305855,
0.00525645911693573,
0.16068896651268005,
0.21705757081508636,
0.5627491474151611,
0.7184486985206604,
0.30316925048828125,
-0.602924644947052,
0.6160039901733398,
-0.013026133179664612,
-0.2726215422153473,
-0.2598026394844055,
-0.42558518052101135,
0.061814334243535995,
0.4422330856323242,
0.42137640714645386,
0.01582981087267399,
0.406421959400177,
-0.7388472557067871,
-0.07936319708824158,
0.33865147829055786,
-0.5837715864181519,
-0.549760103225708,
0.46965017914772034,
0.44835081696510315,
-0.2509198784828186,
0.2939518094062805,
-0.11673058569431305,
-0.6399009227752686,
0.7867627143859863,
0.08965425938367844,
1.200845718383789,
-0.0979565680027008,
0.10646570473909378,
-0.024649959057569504,
0.3707117736339569,
-0.025860803201794624,
0.3996712267398834,
0.1455351710319519,
-0.5826753973960876,
-0.4785703420639038,
-0.5131223201751709,
-0.6766538023948669,
-0.06744225323200226,
-0.8736715912818909,
-0.016212377697229385,
-0.1388353407382965,
-0.3753044307231903,
-0.07305815815925598,
0.12957993149757385,
-0.9947338700294495,
0.41232115030288696,
0.20352999866008759,
0.9797854423522949,
-0.9514608979225159,
0.32166588306427,
0.7630495429039001,
-0.20095977187156677,
-0.3552643954753876,
0.16623833775520325,
0.34271860122680664,
-0.09936656802892685,
0.6665228009223938,
0.1539618968963623,
0.050648048520088196,
-0.1727752387523651,
-0.46067437529563904,
-0.7122902274131775,
0.7205000519752502,
-0.15084326267242432,
-0.18182672560214996,
-0.308531254529953,
-0.1700257807970047,
0.9034234881401062,
-0.4042690396308899,
0.2652750611305237,
0.5816209316253662,
0.46630874276161194,
-0.30817562341690063,
-0.47079792618751526,
-0.4012547731399536,
-0.488189697265625,
-0.128323495388031,
0.2747459411621094,
-0.6814203262329102,
0.5292120575904846,
0.23385994136333466,
-0.4230913817882538,
-0.05901366472244263,
0.7945159077644348,
-0.05235033109784126,
0.5561501979827881,
0.3761906325817108,
0.30588066577911377,
0.5070647597312927,
-0.4668067395687103,
0.9553185105323792,
-0.3325997292995453,
0.3460193872451782,
0.5496309399604797,
-0.5904967188835144,
0.8610799312591553,
0.4190730154514313,
-0.42305004596710205,
0.34093382954597473,
0.7180721759796143,
0.10130685567855835,
-0.07278136909008026,
0.19419118762016296,
-0.09748753160238266,
0.17344947159290314,
-0.1711903065443039,
-0.295568585395813,
0.5968708992004395,
0.5119578838348389,
-0.01772185228765011,
-0.1037687286734581,
-0.034582290798425674,
-0.0663938969373703,
-0.11906339228153229,
-0.21984893083572388,
0.7005295157432556,
0.18597352504730225,
-0.4123893082141876,
0.03375716879963875,
0.07487494498491287,
0.6922342777252197,
-0.6349676847457886,
0.05594806745648384,
-0.3713313937187195,
-0.3245982825756073,
-0.43079859018325806,
-0.7794784307479858,
0.5871996283531189,
0.4198113977909088,
-0.0010146411368623376,
-0.4755287766456604,
0.6949973106384277,
-0.48670125007629395,
0.06051813066005707,
0.4813089966773987,
0.6009432673454285,
0.3268726170063019,
-0.1297774314880371,
-0.6081916093826294,
0.2018500119447708,
-0.22810162603855133,
-0.7122108936309814,
0.2678225636482239,
0.8078830242156982,
0.23397362232208252,
0.3918147385120392,
0.27347230911254883,
0.1634976714849472,
-0.0042469073086977005,
-0.13475199043750763,
0.36769673228263855,
-0.952130913734436,
-0.24074508249759674,
-0.6157911419868469,
0.7464655041694641,
0.08676867932081223,
-0.6396916508674622,
0.5277583599090576,
0.005214354954659939,
0.39937400817871094,
-0.014676307328045368,
0.6236007809638977,
-0.33805304765701294,
0.13110841810703278,
-0.43450912833213806,
0.322472482919693,
-0.5818802118301392,
-0.15354342758655548,
-0.7362588047981262,
-1.1576594114303589,
-0.44492974877357483,
0.4769548177719116,
-0.11982113867998123,
0.05875849351286888,
0.7381309866905212,
0.08689984679222107,
0.4206043779850006,
0.256066232919693,
0.16003970801830292,
0.0799127146601677,
0.08773180842399597,
0.5135633945465088,
0.9031565189361572,
-0.2798745334148407,
-0.001634560409002006,
-0.3194828927516937,
-0.2197878509759903,
-0.3589300811290741,
-1.0623201131820679,
-0.31612229347229004,
-0.777093768119812,
-0.45935729146003723,
-0.03388477489352226,
-0.32713982462882996,
0.7996148467063904,
0.4071226119995117,
-0.7303947806358337,
-0.28758126497268677,
0.10620849579572678,
0.20974715054035187,
-0.36358562111854553,
-0.2518378496170044,
0.19113744795322418,
-0.4404006898403168,
-0.9630523920059204,
0.1959099918603897,
0.49039819836616516,
-0.17966166138648987,
-0.13741539418697357,
0.1036757081747055,
-0.275675505399704,
0.010434764437377453,
0.7342655062675476,
0.7045978903770447,
-0.7925581932067871,
-0.17364171147346497,
0.07699739187955856,
0.14118175208568573,
-0.02834238111972809,
0.6831507682800293,
-0.16107572615146637,
0.4126088619232178,
0.4713573753833771,
0.6812171339988708,
0.04587347060441971,
-0.08511828631162643,
0.6456531882286072,
-0.7725011110305786,
-0.059622809290885925,
0.4445219337940216,
0.4696331322193146,
0.2105422019958496,
-0.3291255831718445,
0.7285894155502319,
0.1298520714044571,
-0.6414105892181396,
-0.7983118295669556,
0.339615136384964,
-1.1569483280181885,
-0.050196584314107895,
0.9639054536819458,
-0.09144391119480133,
-0.09751510620117188,
-0.02205340377986431,
-0.13659916818141937,
0.15334396064281464,
-0.1931707262992859,
0.7764407992362976,
1.1984747648239136,
-0.482749342918396,
-0.2070329338312149,
-0.7017342448234558,
0.6486658453941345,
0.6635323762893677,
-1.0504696369171143,
0.2801975905895233,
0.4602791965007782,
-0.33803442120552063,
0.48226186633110046,
0.5957866311073303,
0.056327056139707565,
0.008915437385439873,
-0.17919400334358215,
0.5346609354019165,
0.674049973487854,
-0.2694958448410034,
-0.7228226661682129,
0.326861709356308,
-0.020179204642772675,
0.308197945356369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01216v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01216v2
|
API Is Enough: Conformal Prediction for Large Language Models Without Logit-Access
| 2024-03-02T14:14:45 | 2024-04-04T02:15:39 |
Jiayuan Su, Jing Luo, Hongwei Wang, Lu Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This study aims to address the pervasive challenge of quantifying uncertainty
in large language models (LLMs) without logit-access. Conformal Prediction
(CP), known for its model-agnostic and distribution-free features, is a desired
approach for various LLMs and data distributions. However, existing CP methods
for LLMs typically assume access to the logits, which are unavailable for some
API-only LLMs. In addition, logits are known to be miscalibrated, potentially
leading to degraded CP performance. To tackle these challenges, we introduce a
novel CP method that (1) is tailored for API-only LLMs without logit-access;
(2) minimizes the size of prediction sets; and (3) ensures a statistical
guarantee of the user-defined coverage. The core idea of this approach is to
formulate nonconformity measures using both coarse-grained (i.e., sample
frequency) and fine-grained uncertainty notions (e.g., semantic similarity).
Experimental results on both close-ended and open-ended Question Answering
tasks show our approach can mostly outperform the logit-based CP baselines.
|
[
-0.30689945816993713,
-0.4774731397628784,
0.7894220948219299,
0.31418555974960327,
-0.2976945638656616,
-0.10659817606210709,
-0.3867143392562866,
-0.5560834407806396,
0.08458884805440903,
0.48993539810180664,
-0.6535084843635559,
-0.5425440073013306,
-0.6889554858207703,
0.08418121933937073,
-0.2657339572906494,
0.6915223002433777,
-0.06304388493299484,
0.017459554597735405,
-0.37386882305145264,
-0.08974209427833557,
-0.46236637234687805,
-0.2700828015804291,
-0.28954675793647766,
-0.012938817963004112,
0.30920690298080444,
0.17670509219169617,
0.5670745968818665,
0.7252463102340698,
0.25664612650871277,
0.12697869539260864,
-0.18734996020793915,
0.10488273948431015,
-0.18776634335517883,
0.1266816258430481,
0.16857601702213287,
-0.7774407863616943,
-0.40795236825942993,
-0.22321991622447968,
0.7425236105918884,
0.9178375005722046,
-0.029672835022211075,
0.3981640040874481,
0.12414441257715225,
0.728628396987915,
-0.7462261319160461,
0.4904188811779022,
-0.9595034122467041,
-0.19720342755317688,
-0.07264258712530136,
0.25677794218063354,
-0.39511629939079285,
-0.36481866240501404,
0.34883153438568115,
-0.7780497074127197,
-0.024456478655338287,
0.25585082173347473,
0.4190186858177185,
0.42937177419662476,
-0.29988497495651245,
-0.2866588234901428,
-0.6995696425437927,
1.1027436256408691,
-0.84300696849823,
0.7318775057792664,
0.7746788859367371,
0.17604942619800568,
-0.2173713892698288,
-0.3240055739879608,
-0.5054817199707031,
-0.18760059773921967,
0.06098358705639839,
-0.0729295015335083,
-0.16981972754001617,
0.1410776823759079,
-0.09048627316951752,
0.11019053310155869,
-0.4864104390144348,
-0.10351818799972534,
-0.49377167224884033,
-0.3256170451641083,
0.45301952958106995,
0.003788415575399995,
-0.08464620262384415,
0.1405935287475586,
-0.20752248167991638,
0.15367701649665833,
-0.6435867547988892,
0.25383955240249634,
0.2318907380104065,
0.5397323966026306,
-0.24546340107917786,
0.5666110515594482,
-0.024023301899433136,
0.5711937546730042,
-0.04749520868062973,
0.042030368000268936,
0.1131962388753891,
-0.219298854470253,
-0.34721842408180237,
-0.23058123886585236,
0.8000169992446899,
-0.011574411764740944,
0.2776694595813751,
-0.15299180150032043,
-0.25769394636154175,
-0.12054572254419327,
-0.052345890551805496,
-0.5216248631477356,
-0.30602025985717773,
0.6367524862289429,
-0.1639942079782486,
-0.0722937136888504,
-0.12204582244157791,
-0.8019454479217529,
-0.25789186358451843,
-0.4047050178050995,
0.07849261909723282,
-0.603859007358551,
-0.4330568015575409,
-0.09141433984041214,
0.07391922175884247,
0.06782391667366028,
0.35404807329177856,
-0.8835871815681458,
0.30370402336120605,
0.7680987119674683,
0.9946750998497009,
-0.13625985383987427,
-0.24975121021270752,
-0.3589312434196472,
0.1715410351753235,
-0.6332618594169617,
0.7848544716835022,
-0.6649495363235474,
-0.47828084230422974,
0.05746202543377876,
-0.10921493917703629,
-0.029247071593999863,
-0.3836609721183777,
0.5897481441497803,
-0.38965433835983276,
-0.32968464493751526,
-0.08258724212646484,
-0.9544957876205444,
0.027201801538467407,
0.1763768047094345,
-0.8065470457077026,
0.733344554901123,
0.18783268332481384,
-0.493671178817749,
0.21005775034427643,
-0.41110578179359436,
-0.15621317923069,
-0.07045508921146393,
-0.15478171408176422,
-0.542999804019928,
0.2662279009819031,
0.12168882042169571,
0.24642977118492126,
-0.10984063893556595,
0.0866672545671463,
-0.7145722508430481,
-0.20624825358390808,
0.4235740303993225,
-0.4425201714038849,
0.4720008075237274,
0.172109454870224,
-0.10093190521001816,
-0.03337906301021576,
-0.7399415969848633,
0.5750854015350342,
-0.328265517950058,
-0.25269222259521484,
-0.3572240471839905,
-0.006032786797732115,
0.08521019667387009,
-0.19283992052078247,
0.41720014810562134,
-0.5969662666320801,
0.001901120413094759,
-0.7079545259475708,
0.45843541622161865,
1.101442813873291,
-0.3159680962562561,
0.7049674391746521,
-0.36338111758232117,
0.4314761459827423,
-0.3490375280380249,
0.22919456660747528,
0.07578697055578232,
-0.4479463994503021,
-0.387307345867157,
-0.4072752892971039,
0.3489464223384857,
0.5499598979949951,
-0.1955021172761917,
0.42225217819213867,
-0.3014928102493286,
-0.6729462146759033,
-0.3803962469100952,
0.4617626965045929,
0.6206613779067993,
0.11209377646446228,
0.2716712951660156,
0.116450235247612,
-0.7085524797439575,
-0.678238034248352,
-0.12000597268342972,
-0.6078518629074097,
-0.3723590672016144,
0.3637336194515228,
0.15285804867744446,
-0.27633970975875854,
0.8318226337432861,
-0.5558153390884399,
-0.30504122376441956,
-0.08338344842195511,
-0.15009544789791107,
0.30990251898765564,
0.3018805980682373,
0.3852783441543579,
-0.7280884981155396,
-0.6654815077781677,
-0.12882748246192932,
-0.45457085967063904,
-0.12003534287214279,
0.1619020700454712,
-0.02237427793443203,
0.408158540725708,
0.4925328493118286,
-0.5940693020820618,
0.21294492483139038,
1.0746595859527588,
-0.14997951686382294,
0.6841840744018555,
-0.07321352511644363,
-0.256491094827652,
-0.7312384843826294,
0.1279577910900116,
-0.04331890121102333,
-0.34945082664489746,
-0.5927948951721191,
-0.10093709826469421,
0.28630590438842773,
-0.07306212931871414,
-0.37580475211143494,
0.7139166593551636,
-0.24075105786323547,
0.1848381608724594,
-0.2440844476222992,
-0.08724901080131531,
0.019464218989014626,
0.42723581194877625,
0.17961128056049347,
0.9043798446655273,
0.7204437851905823,
-0.6725972294807434,
-0.136646568775177,
0.30538055300712585,
-0.21391472220420837,
0.3468325138092041,
-0.6856406927108765,
-0.04026152938604355,
-0.10042231529951096,
0.25455257296562195,
-1.2023049592971802,
-0.1622241586446762,
-0.08997344970703125,
-0.5795636773109436,
0.15450921654701233,
-0.1573905646800995,
-0.1884145438671112,
-0.15579332411289215,
-0.39339226484298706,
0.5785508751869202,
0.5383065342903137,
-0.18275758624076843,
0.6179214119911194,
0.396915078163147,
-0.24402981996536255,
-0.41143161058425903,
-0.7184047698974609,
-0.23062829673290253,
-0.061969269067049026,
-0.4095532298088074,
-0.12516653537750244,
-0.5987638831138611,
-0.11600231379270554,
-0.17584073543548584,
-0.48702913522720337,
-0.4702345132827759,
0.029743902385234833,
0.39434102177619934,
0.4815933406352997,
-0.22722510993480682,
0.255657434463501,
-0.036409810185432434,
0.06843231618404388,
0.026303287595510483,
-0.572047770023346,
0.4051355719566345,
-0.532779335975647,
-0.4241543412208557,
-0.35870909690856934,
0.18622703850269318,
0.7596578598022461,
-0.10975126922130585,
0.5579237341880798,
0.1260475218296051,
-0.4141405522823334,
-0.24295246601104736,
-0.557529628276825,
0.0014665772905573249,
-0.4590851068496704,
0.11667124181985855,
-0.2090742290019989,
-0.8889281153678894,
0.6042273044586182,
0.022900577634572983,
0.2880694568157196,
0.181453675031662,
0.4369014501571655,
-0.11277810484170914,
0.6481908559799194,
0.7490725517272949,
-0.08965108543634415,
0.33971282839775085,
0.07608126103878021,
0.18759381771087646,
-0.7980647087097168,
-0.07888507843017578,
-0.42377376556396484,
0.0452362485229969,
-0.49079105257987976,
-0.3610335886478424,
0.3890606164932251,
0.14178438484668732,
-0.31153398752212524,
0.35938864946365356,
-0.307559996843338,
0.44342291355133057,
0.4448642432689667,
0.02193306013941765,
0.3245392143726349,
-0.23152263462543488,
0.030317949131131172,
0.09080404043197632,
-0.09353788197040558,
-0.45748522877693176,
1.6377867460250854,
0.3799484372138977,
0.8219093084335327,
0.17074747383594513,
0.483237624168396,
0.17386817932128906,
0.30919477343559265,
-0.719394326210022,
0.32621628046035767,
-0.12149740010499954,
-0.5670439600944519,
-0.7653672099113464,
-0.3884814977645874,
-0.8494285941123962,
-0.045927125960588455,
0.01179580669850111,
-0.9030752182006836,
0.24997690320014954,
0.45124199986457825,
-0.3609847128391266,
0.23448726534843445,
-0.6454919576644897,
0.38418030738830566,
0.0818781852722168,
0.14258238673210144,
0.3136746883392334,
-0.5768415927886963,
0.24315951764583588,
-0.5953489542007446,
0.5775750279426575,
-0.39446648955345154,
-0.2983628213405609,
0.3022215664386749,
-0.3388088643550873,
0.9926756620407104,
-0.10116149485111237,
-0.2267070710659027,
0.475096195936203,
0.4018577039241791,
0.5948465466499329,
0.3524071276187897,
-0.26503893733024597,
0.5502178072929382,
0.6223623156547546,
-0.45309698581695557,
-0.5692636966705322,
0.5757767558097839,
-0.6793093681335449,
-0.385231077671051,
-0.13853967189788818,
-0.6149452328681946,
-0.5203369855880737,
0.33313220739364624,
0.2290172278881073,
-0.00672963447868824,
-0.08087470382452011,
0.11479240655899048,
0.7953667044639587,
0.08216234296560287,
0.3254915177822113,
0.4708986282348633,
-0.16381783783435822,
-0.38517865538597107,
0.7690877318382263,
0.014058255590498447,
0.5728513598442078,
0.32330355048179626,
0.45523786544799805,
-0.5923007130622864,
-0.6252923607826233,
-0.36266231536865234,
0.18388012051582336,
-0.4780842959880829,
-0.35109105706214905,
-0.4146678149700165,
-0.08921962976455688,
-0.6737956404685974,
-0.055625271052122116,
-0.5868733525276184,
-0.35570845007896423,
-0.11788348853588104,
-0.010724121704697609,
0.2896909713745117,
0.4134773910045624,
-0.02868015132844448,
0.36284205317497253,
-0.7634069323539734,
0.09577363729476929,
0.14328444004058838,
0.8582963347434998,
-0.051329970359802246,
-0.4413405656814575,
-0.03929721564054489,
0.2545466721057892,
-0.19552795588970184,
-0.5921680927276611,
0.34542208909988403,
0.5973567962646484,
0.4338279664516449,
0.19167257845401764,
0.3587609827518463,
0.516608476638794,
-0.6442779302597046,
0.6723207235336304,
0.22664715349674225,
-1.092785120010376,
0.5116395354270935,
-0.3094746172428131,
0.1689819097518921,
0.6377525925636292,
0.27731651067733765,
-0.4122779667377472,
-0.9179306030273438,
-0.46654102206230164,
-0.8797761797904968,
0.2868773639202118,
0.33970049023628235,
0.2620047330856323,
0.019890140742063522,
0.3134193420410156,
0.20257847011089325,
0.47917792201042175,
-0.8829159736633301,
-0.15138162672519684,
-0.23994767665863037,
-0.3599644899368286,
0.0023930862080305815,
-0.16624431312084198,
-0.03996383771300316,
-0.08326711505651474,
0.6148777008056641,
-0.3571596145629883,
0.25011876225471497,
0.26499611139297485,
0.20670318603515625,
-0.4735632538795471,
0.3964453637599945,
0.39780136942863464,
0.9841856956481934,
-0.4623919725418091,
0.09749636054039001,
0.3393942713737488,
-0.5847402215003967,
-0.02985699661076069,
-0.1372544765472412,
-0.1404867023229599,
0.04926653951406479,
0.38044989109039307,
0.5443741083145142,
0.0012524346821010113,
-1.3072972297668457,
0.6221193075180054,
-0.032306574285030365,
-0.23117870092391968,
-0.9369338750839233,
-0.22977736592292786,
0.12681087851524353,
0.37770411372184753,
0.2778297960758209,
0.003453795798122883,
-0.07112547010183334,
-0.20860734581947327,
0.4244672954082489,
0.49443140625953674,
-0.6534435153007507,
-0.3567923307418823,
0.6591402888298035,
-0.2393719106912613,
-0.04365222901105881,
0.3300483822822571,
0.10121138393878937,
-0.029887594282627106,
0.5816799402236938,
0.6397114396095276,
0.7488637566566467,
-0.3442500829696655,
-0.01130311656743288,
0.18710751831531525,
0.2343471497297287,
-0.2786721885204315,
0.26226261258125305,
0.28947263956069946,
-0.6342407464981079,
-0.49710825085639954,
-0.9555010795593262,
-0.4791293740272522,
0.421616792678833,
-0.5727077126502991,
0.3216298818588257,
-0.7925005555152893,
0.03287153318524361,
-0.07159040868282318,
-0.2653982937335968,
-0.5243733525276184,
0.029577240347862244,
0.14194504916667938,
1.1504460573196411,
-0.7547828555107117,
0.7704721093177795,
0.3912244439125061,
-0.10457833111286163,
-0.9540137648582458,
0.19093278050422668,
0.030978119000792503,
-0.8561153411865234,
0.3579658567905426,
0.058206114917993546,
0.09475424140691757,
-0.20283880829811096,
-0.6530501246452332,
-1.0432244539260864,
0.9100419878959656,
0.5932571291923523,
-0.7115790247917175,
-0.05660067871212959,
0.27133554220199585,
0.4314095079898834,
-0.12514422833919525,
-0.035043150186538696,
0.5364819765090942,
0.5347182750701904,
0.28143686056137085,
-1.2387933731079102,
-0.010692877694964409,
0.07311798632144928,
0.031172240152955055,
0.3217501640319824,
-0.45714834332466125,
0.9236609935760498,
-0.09957444667816162,
-0.1283321976661682,
0.3822023868560791,
0.7239985466003418,
0.47251832485198975,
0.2983916699886322,
0.6713272929191589,
0.3086666762828827,
0.9938850402832031,
0.19992226362228394,
1.073061466217041,
-0.4772690534591675,
0.5146781802177429,
1.0517425537109375,
-0.10331013053655624,
1.1219637393951416,
0.603843629360199,
-0.43160781264305115,
0.12247885018587112,
0.7069429159164429,
0.12289608269929886,
0.602161169052124,
0.27097979187965393,
-0.5097901821136475,
-0.3446500301361084,
0.1216602697968483,
-0.11894402652978897,
0.19680741429328918,
0.456486314535141,
-0.009325595572590828,
-0.16606222093105316,
-0.06450393795967102,
-0.06703796237707138,
0.24646130204200745,
-0.4213440418243408,
0.7168672680854797,
0.28634166717529297,
-0.46374422311782837,
0.9120883345603943,
-0.2174243927001953,
0.6401187181472778,
-0.8181527256965637,
0.15701180696487427,
-0.020472463220357895,
0.04678774252533913,
-0.06267087906599045,
-0.7644027471542358,
0.583318829536438,
-0.2829188108444214,
-0.21264682710170746,
0.11631370335817337,
0.3480057716369629,
-0.4680718779563904,
-0.8669823408126831,
0.24650540947914124,
0.4535178244113922,
0.045484092086553574,
-0.29672449827194214,
-0.38917601108551025,
-0.0319465734064579,
-0.10611818730831146,
-0.1208743155002594,
0.2937780022621155,
0.6859485507011414,
-0.16681164503097534,
0.8951818943023682,
0.5980518460273743,
0.3867024779319763,
0.19063670933246613,
-0.3166034519672394,
0.8410629034042358,
-0.3012514114379883,
-0.47829535603523254,
-0.9104812741279602,
0.1776767075061798,
0.4172402620315552,
-0.1859159767627716,
0.32329991459846497,
0.6027467846870422,
0.7682844996452332,
-0.1751539260149002,
1.1521565914154053,
0.038346219807863235,
0.5731500387191772,
-0.503281831741333,
0.36098724603652954,
-0.5024585127830505,
0.3387129008769989,
-0.209395632147789,
-0.8848276138305664,
-0.47972995042800903,
0.33228814601898193,
-0.1763477325439453,
-0.43494245409965515,
0.6112080812454224,
0.6760818362236023,
-0.15307608246803284,
0.013623043894767761,
0.49596700072288513,
0.08344805985689163,
0.40124696493148804,
0.6531152129173279,
0.3430079519748688,
-0.16623090207576752,
0.8811550140380859,
-0.03387460857629776,
-0.4008362591266632,
0.14722317457199097,
-0.9150850176811218,
-0.8538546562194824,
-0.6884851455688477,
0.12316028028726578,
-0.3467470109462738,
-0.002782772993668914,
0.9120346307754517,
0.6007415652275085,
-1.0826925039291382,
-0.25920790433883667,
-0.3145767152309418,
0.11335555464029312,
-0.18206192553043365,
-0.13072645664215088,
0.4936327636241913,
-0.6416053175926208,
-0.9528698921203613,
0.18902002274990082,
0.024042658507823944,
0.23837654292583466,
-0.21249504387378693,
-0.058422572910785675,
0.15318997204303741,
0.38322678208351135,
0.4048331677913666,
0.4079805612564087,
-0.7999670505523682,
-0.5097253322601318,
0.11474960297346115,
0.12190734595060349,
0.044220395386219025,
0.6690068244934082,
-0.43949705362319946,
0.21682895720005035,
0.25543084740638733,
0.9497924447059631,
0.12023553252220154,
-0.041643235832452774,
0.720068633556366,
-1.0882993936538696,
0.2514513432979584,
0.3588947653770447,
0.35317444801330566,
-0.0632932037115097,
-0.5596012473106384,
0.29314088821411133,
0.04243782162666321,
-0.5727587938308716,
-0.7682156562805176,
0.5907293558120728,
-1.1070507764816284,
-0.40308505296707153,
1.342079520225525,
-0.3514932692050934,
-0.41650494933128357,
-0.34120890498161316,
0.011815439909696579,
-0.12437811493873596,
-0.6348333954811096,
0.7378997802734375,
0.8045759797096252,
-0.19397062063217163,
-0.13331370055675507,
-0.7481626272201538,
0.4521530866622925,
0.22276344895362854,
-0.5538819432258606,
0.66241055727005,
0.4672534167766571,
0.5308611392974854,
0.3379630744457245,
0.7126871347427368,
-0.09250322729349136,
0.0424409843981266,
-0.3409830331802368,
-0.08074523508548737,
-0.07518178969621658,
-0.2744489312171936,
-0.024357199668884277,
-0.008836858905851841,
0.5013759732246399,
-0.03889288008213043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01203v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01203v1
|
Pseudo-Label Calibration Semi-supervised Multi-Modal Entity Alignment
| 2024-03-02T12:44:59 | 2024-03-02T12:44:59 |
Luyao Wang, Pengnian Qi, Xigang Bao, Chunlai Zhou, Biao Qin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DB
|
Multi-modal entity alignment (MMEA) aims to identify equivalent entities
between two multi-modal knowledge graphs for integration. Unfortunately, prior
arts have attempted to improve the interaction and fusion of multi-modal
information, which have overlooked the influence of modal-specific noise and
the usage of labeled and unlabeled data in semi-supervised settings. In this
work, we introduce a Pseudo-label Calibration Multi-modal Entity Alignment
(PCMEA) in a semi-supervised way. Specifically, in order to generate holistic
entity representations, we first devise various embedding modules and attention
mechanisms to extract visual, structural, relational, and attribute features.
Different from the prior direct fusion methods, we next propose to exploit
mutual information maximization to filter the modal-specific noise and to
augment modal-invariant commonality. Then, we combine pseudo-label calibration
with momentum-based contrastive learning to make full use of the labeled and
unlabeled data, which improves the quality of pseudo-label and pulls aligned
entities closer. Finally, extensive experiments on two MMEA datasets
demonstrate the effectiveness of our PCMEA, which yields state-of-the-art
performance.
|
[
-0.41597118973731995,
-0.646558403968811,
0.6803046464920044,
-0.24377566576004028,
-0.41557401418685913,
0.08474806696176529,
0.0029305547941476107,
-0.44049134850502014,
0.5558004975318909,
0.032608889043331146,
-0.5617258548736572,
-0.44698768854141235,
-0.04377355799078941,
-0.050290659070014954,
0.280501127243042,
0.8557036519050598,
0.03911450132727623,
0.20288391411304474,
-0.34703364968299866,
-0.15120887756347656,
-0.5613657832145691,
-0.2572328746318817,
-0.12693187594413757,
-0.14984826743602753,
0.4792732894420624,
0.19967955350875854,
0.6442145705223083,
0.2353370636701584,
0.2195824384689331,
0.29623034596443176,
0.325116902589798,
0.6957628130912781,
-0.6367854475975037,
-0.3079845607280731,
-0.3343014419078827,
-0.28859421610832214,
-0.6930171847343445,
0.26443180441856384,
0.5621604919433594,
0.6067343950271606,
-0.054163508117198944,
0.2999809980392456,
-0.09306038916110992,
0.22151648998260498,
-0.6505774259567261,
0.3460552394390106,
-0.4507979452610016,
-0.09114734828472137,
-0.31640341877937317,
-0.4127088785171509,
-0.4007641077041626,
-0.11052048951387405,
0.2280196249485016,
-1.1223251819610596,
-0.3537178039550781,
0.21214818954467773,
1.0363022089004517,
0.4872731566429138,
-0.899242639541626,
-0.031162941828370094,
-0.669780969619751,
1.0950394868850708,
-0.4144456684589386,
0.7089501619338989,
0.3361770808696747,
0.3124462068080902,
-0.056397996842861176,
-0.6049732565879822,
-0.6834256649017334,
0.2098976969718933,
-0.09190302342176437,
0.4859349727630615,
-0.10565607249736786,
0.007063697092235088,
-0.10030387341976166,
0.23054718971252441,
-0.5908606052398682,
-0.0528869666159153,
-0.2966194152832031,
-0.7037307024002075,
0.19374245405197144,
-0.060658492147922516,
0.3030844032764435,
0.003026649123057723,
-0.8855346441268921,
-0.32789146900177,
-0.6287419199943542,
-0.09650859981775284,
0.2946351170539856,
0.19416749477386475,
-0.0514262393116951,
0.626352846622467,
0.12471405416727066,
0.8555858731269836,
0.38861003518104553,
-0.5402913093566895,
0.666649341583252,
-0.7442208528518677,
-0.3913063406944275,
0.2392563670873642,
0.7843927145004272,
0.501681923866272,
-0.37410733103752136,
-0.21675586700439453,
-0.20709244906902313,
0.2780596911907196,
0.2709139883518219,
-0.7889555096626282,
-0.329841285943985,
-0.14881782233715057,
-0.5010584592819214,
-0.20810270309448242,
0.09814759343862534,
-0.9436959624290466,
0.034337375313043594,
-0.894585132598877,
0.7864348292350769,
-0.257164865732193,
-0.1883947104215622,
-0.15079715847969055,
0.2179238200187683,
0.21579313278198242,
0.14170756936073303,
-0.31685635447502136,
-0.32660821080207825,
0.2524363100528717,
0.5872469544410706,
0.1536785066127777,
-0.12765102088451385,
-0.41994336247444153,
0.6715360283851624,
-0.16018612682819366,
0.6594148278236389,
-0.7422540187835693,
-0.23106805980205536,
-0.24944402277469635,
0.08215745538473129,
-0.3008413016796112,
-0.35433658957481384,
0.18014270067214966,
-0.7600882053375244,
0.42736107110977173,
-0.4042525887489319,
-0.41445279121398926,
-0.46702632308006287,
0.28413647413253784,
-0.6766316294670105,
0.8058251142501831,
0.08899284899234772,
-0.6619745492935181,
0.44642600417137146,
-0.1983029544353485,
-0.2958701550960541,
-0.18828624486923218,
-0.4224518835544586,
-0.6656013131141663,
-0.017301050946116447,
0.14139311015605927,
0.21894940733909607,
-0.3834318518638611,
0.5587698221206665,
-0.5229480862617493,
-0.15135017037391663,
0.14470995962619781,
-0.42276430130004883,
0.46146658062934875,
0.2288363128900528,
-0.29933077096939087,
0.24650976061820984,
-1.0363832712173462,
-0.07810550928115845,
-0.2501857280731201,
-0.08942229300737381,
-0.5172623991966248,
-0.15084807574748993,
-0.08988436311483383,
0.6518082022666931,
0.5756885409355164,
-0.3039822280406952,
0.02564302645623684,
-0.20080046355724335,
0.16125057637691498,
0.7245396971702576,
0.15460117161273956,
0.6478550434112549,
-0.18933004140853882,
0.23933200538158417,
0.554653525352478,
0.008331401273608208,
0.0955357775092125,
-0.3140455484390259,
-0.2496710866689682,
-0.7448107004165649,
0.3161517381668091,
0.46597981452941895,
-1.2400506734848022,
0.5856518149375916,
-0.2613809108734131,
-0.459255188703537,
-0.47093483805656433,
0.3584374785423279,
0.41371533274650574,
1.102228045463562,
0.6193984746932983,
-0.5939194560050964,
-0.45002058148384094,
-1.1028499603271484,
0.32961830496788025,
-0.2509158253669739,
-0.058403003960847855,
0.3634779155254364,
-0.013973950408399105,
-0.4071009159088135,
0.9204786419868469,
-0.24479345977306366,
-0.6907378435134888,
0.43661069869995117,
0.6650192141532898,
-0.08129525184631348,
0.3654136657714844,
0.6624947786331177,
-0.9664771556854248,
-0.22587044537067413,
-0.11273451894521713,
-0.6505913138389587,
-0.21396884322166443,
-0.41464000940322876,
-0.4859013259410858,
-0.410038560628891,
0.13834248483181,
-0.3901277780532837,
0.1422790288925171,
0.43160736560821533,
-0.1939285546541214,
0.1961296945810318,
-0.17367039620876312,
0.332183837890625,
-1.4108304977416992,
0.1690841019153595,
0.4423324167728424,
-0.4789188802242279,
-0.40462154150009155,
-0.4260590970516205,
0.3318093419075012,
0.012051008641719818,
-0.4968346357345581,
-0.03702123835682869,
-0.8553431034088135,
-0.0018772002076730132,
-0.29983559250831604,
0.2572943866252899,
0.010317983105778694,
0.5744251012802124,
0.2284277379512787,
0.9764779806137085,
0.5740208029747009,
-0.6037649512290955,
0.13084915280342102,
0.10782063752412796,
0.0553334541618824,
1.0790557861328125,
-0.18771465122699738,
0.08688212931156158,
-0.06042395532131195,
0.41026008129119873,
-0.7677746415138245,
0.12754186987876892,
0.2507031261920929,
0.07639580965042114,
0.5820621252059937,
0.03225089982151985,
-0.40236541628837585,
-0.07778055220842361,
-0.42135635018348694,
0.7327221035957336,
0.017998570576310158,
-0.3708091974258423,
0.9262048602104187,
0.6970090270042419,
0.466619074344635,
-0.49686360359191895,
-0.49258366227149963,
-0.1750388741493225,
-0.06056433171033859,
-0.45614245533943176,
0.7682092785835266,
-0.226687490940094,
0.1201799064874649,
0.11722505837678909,
-0.31456291675567627,
-0.09105516970157623,
-0.30666378140449524,
0.3632439970970154,
0.6346843838691711,
-0.4409070909023285,
0.020113855600357056,
0.340872198343277,
-0.13274464011192322,
-0.12400073558092117,
-0.2676433026790619,
0.2944340407848358,
-0.19650521874427795,
-0.3704351484775543,
-0.8128052353858948,
-0.005033220164477825,
0.47982993721961975,
-0.3047570586204529,
0.9129475355148315,
0.7108666300773621,
-0.4428352117538452,
0.2686901390552521,
-0.4881068766117096,
-0.37562745809555054,
-0.42314907908439636,
0.26619523763656616,
-0.5148352980613708,
-0.559632420539856,
0.2764126658439636,
-0.5784037709236145,
-0.040988482534885406,
0.39787551760673523,
0.5445880889892578,
-0.21150723099708557,
0.9409422278404236,
0.7040364146232605,
-0.1920042484998703,
0.33660101890563965,
-0.09287411719560623,
0.5137799382209778,
-0.7980514764785767,
-0.47252747416496277,
-0.15649867057800293,
-0.5905947089195251,
-0.46433037519454956,
-0.7004160284996033,
0.44871482253074646,
0.0370115265250206,
0.2319561094045639,
0.4340601861476898,
-0.32264643907546997,
0.32687613368034363,
0.5183601975440979,
0.46340319514274597,
0.1578056514263153,
-0.23972006142139435,
-0.03442294895648956,
-0.2704756557941437,
-0.34008723497390747,
-0.5032126903533936,
1.0525126457214355,
0.02604397013783455,
0.6168201565742493,
0.1832321435213089,
0.4213482737541199,
0.10860364139080048,
0.25151917338371277,
-0.5085830688476562,
0.3843468129634857,
0.22868624329566956,
-0.6548168063163757,
0.09750420600175858,
-0.6763609647750854,
-0.5531995892524719,
0.30935972929000854,
-0.4173787236213684,
-0.549946129322052,
0.7376930117607117,
0.3196272552013397,
-0.24463114142417908,
0.16543929278850555,
-0.8357715010643005,
0.9548357725143433,
-0.1718629151582718,
-0.40515655279159546,
-0.1554424911737442,
-0.8813552260398865,
0.4434943199157715,
-0.4173040986061096,
0.33986231684684753,
0.13612858951091766,
-0.20627683401107788,
0.6808172464370728,
-0.30264636874198914,
1.0175246000289917,
-0.18875378370285034,
-0.13176047801971436,
0.3303021788597107,
-0.06945279985666275,
0.4557494521141052,
-0.0509236678481102,
0.2711852192878723,
0.03062635287642479,
0.18386122584342957,
-0.36902326345443726,
-0.3743453323841095,
0.8186904788017273,
-0.7798135280609131,
-0.22255510091781616,
-0.2620418667793274,
-0.6548794507980347,
-0.536249577999115,
0.30719438195228577,
-0.17152589559555054,
0.413082093000412,
-0.1615898609161377,
0.12953931093215942,
0.8288678526878357,
0.11241613328456879,
0.28997835516929626,
0.6092140674591064,
0.1817142367362976,
-0.5323184728622437,
1.3746891021728516,
0.11448666453361511,
0.013734519481658936,
0.5566552877426147,
-0.18144038319587708,
-0.4713771641254425,
-0.053525812923908234,
-0.5051292181015015,
0.44127407670021057,
-0.4630655348300934,
-0.48814767599105835,
-0.4521978199481964,
0.34133005142211914,
-0.3656541705131531,
-0.04210874065756798,
-0.45799770951271057,
-0.2729874551296234,
-0.7868441939353943,
-0.01429418008774519,
-0.2755288779735565,
0.19171768426895142,
-0.1814376711845398,
0.2994498014450073,
-0.639582097530365,
0.405244380235672,
0.41368094086647034,
-0.14938820898532867,
-0.2995101809501648,
-0.43063971400260925,
0.07588160783052444,
0.1742471307516098,
-0.4080362915992737,
-1.3841253519058228,
0.05172577500343323,
0.20998577773571014,
0.5329132080078125,
0.7499938607215881,
0.11651521176099777,
0.9792478084564209,
-0.2815926671028137,
0.5543175935745239,
0.5723398923873901,
-0.7974576950073242,
0.4486674666404724,
0.10832852870225906,
0.026797063648700714,
0.8156365752220154,
0.5792191624641418,
0.14065654575824738,
-0.03897249326109886,
-0.39563047885894775,
-0.6921520829200745,
0.4927307367324829,
-0.008431046269834042,
-0.08309635519981384,
0.11505034565925598,
0.06846274435520172,
0.025655923411250114,
0.3525848984718323,
-0.78497314453125,
-0.5278922319412231,
-0.2978553771972656,
-0.5658627152442932,
0.03383306786417961,
-0.25412699580192566,
-0.2780841588973999,
-0.034111976623535156,
1.0754928588867188,
-0.3244669735431671,
0.012259010225534439,
0.10960251837968826,
-0.6463422179222107,
-0.24934838712215424,
0.11798965930938721,
0.6124674677848816,
0.9754824638366699,
-0.1660975068807602,
0.5144162178039551,
-0.09179390966892242,
-0.22133667767047882,
0.18706749379634857,
0.44496798515319824,
-0.25242719054222107,
-0.16936081647872925,
-0.15196065604686737,
0.6474227905273438,
0.5157787203788757,
-0.45968881249427795,
0.7071144580841064,
0.02827221341431141,
0.001049955259077251,
0.31985896825790405,
-0.423945814371109,
0.06831689924001694,
0.30872154235839844,
0.13917240500450134,
0.16667310893535614,
0.2783818244934082,
-0.5927150845527649,
0.4652521014213562,
0.5985289216041565,
-0.5293567776679993,
-0.7380528450012207,
0.7616443634033203,
0.0978582575917244,
0.346335232257843,
0.20993177592754364,
-0.25830772519111633,
-0.4146921634674072,
0.055107876658439636,
0.6422391533851624,
0.2862449288368225,
-0.3165040910243988,
0.36272576451301575,
0.29837125539779663,
0.44396069645881653,
0.36846187710762024,
0.17695054411888123,
-0.3386955261230469,
-0.5336369276046753,
-0.4614895284175873,
-0.5575427412986755,
-0.22140082716941833,
0.001999177038669586,
-0.5638203024864197,
0.29371312260627747,
-0.16360552608966827,
-0.3574567139148712,
0.11706484854221344,
-0.034824829548597336,
-0.7364429831504822,
0.41508549451828003,
0.14646849036216736,
0.29782620072364807,
-1.2043145895004272,
0.8657739758491516,
1.10752534866333,
-0.7581278681755066,
-1.0221325159072876,
-0.24061241745948792,
0.3285315930843353,
-0.5403708219528198,
0.27880409359931946,
0.18252675235271454,
-0.26563072204589844,
0.0398232527077198,
-0.0911736860871315,
-0.7255673408508301,
1.3499693870544434,
0.5135626196861267,
-0.8133361339569092,
-0.06489966064691544,
0.13447895646095276,
0.33095428347587585,
-0.19951343536376953,
0.3595995008945465,
0.19129498302936554,
0.5713147521018982,
0.2986486852169037,
-0.7629557251930237,
0.022433660924434662,
-0.10108795017004013,
-0.14170309901237488,
0.2909030318260193,
-0.7765048742294312,
0.1460772305727005,
0.23473744094371796,
-0.1453712284564972,
-0.555736780166626,
1.1298102140426636,
0.29378774762153625,
0.6381279230117798,
0.7549281120300293,
0.8088430166244507,
0.8895899653434753,
0.03499845042824745,
0.47029104828834534,
-0.27662283182144165,
0.26272469758987427,
1.1888248920440674,
-0.33975088596343994,
0.436582088470459,
0.8741199374198914,
0.005285934079438448,
0.3193863034248352,
0.7945059537887573,
0.16366785764694214,
0.7947233319282532,
-0.3121437430381775,
-0.20205019414424896,
-0.45984119176864624,
-0.31118375062942505,
-0.337545245885849,
0.39659884572029114,
0.0355713814496994,
-0.411845326423645,
-0.2938687801361084,
0.10163836181163788,
-0.16080981492996216,
-0.1278931051492691,
-0.13164715468883514,
0.8381637334823608,
0.036201149225234985,
-0.25953707098960876,
0.10207976400852203,
-0.03528926149010658,
0.4986705482006073,
-0.26105937361717224,
-0.025406183674931526,
0.14238616824150085,
-0.2256503403186798,
-0.09528065472841263,
-0.2960290014743805,
0.04655162990093231,
-0.4499327540397644,
-0.3837023079395294,
-0.16600830852985382,
0.7857472896575928,
-0.6779695749282837,
-0.2663629949092865,
0.14370734989643097,
0.5473077297210693,
0.030379535630345345,
0.08650100976228714,
-0.7306160926818848,
-0.09731324762105942,
0.07334966212511063,
-0.24753297865390778,
0.4553425908088684,
0.48788928985595703,
-0.019331946969032288,
0.09124499559402466,
0.6778377294540405,
-0.0924396812915802,
0.23452481627464294,
0.049274567514657974,
0.9822081327438354,
-0.27867627143859863,
-0.4096066355705261,
-0.5483344197273254,
0.3758421838283539,
-0.0656839907169342,
-0.11682752519845963,
0.43520501255989075,
0.8732258677482605,
0.8863672614097595,
0.13326396048069,
-0.07767476886510849,
0.04212480038404465,
0.0911872386932373,
-0.4937734007835388,
0.5103635787963867,
-0.7983737587928772,
0.158583402633667,
-0.1945423036813736,
-1.3565839529037476,
-0.2226458191871643,
0.43590760231018066,
-0.2688696086406708,
0.0026856036856770515,
0.620926558971405,
0.9659942388534546,
-0.60222989320755,
-0.06414522975683212,
0.44991186261177063,
0.06691675633192062,
0.3039000928401947,
0.6536638736724854,
0.45172119140625,
-0.42074355483055115,
0.49167874455451965,
-0.681420624256134,
-0.4599304795265198,
0.061173733323812485,
-0.8075249195098877,
-0.7221755981445312,
-0.7813975214958191,
-0.6071606874465942,
-0.008096055127680302,
-0.27258116006851196,
0.6494563817977905,
0.9956125020980835,
-0.7343486547470093,
0.2971593141555786,
0.35582292079925537,
-0.20612236857414246,
-0.16852673888206482,
-0.2500114142894745,
0.5309486389160156,
0.020157502964138985,
-0.8666306138038635,
0.7801073789596558,
0.4891994893550873,
0.11737104505300522,
-0.04087128862738609,
0.020562145859003067,
-0.4496774971485138,
0.077614426612854,
0.3622618019580841,
0.13962672650814056,
-0.4974019229412079,
-0.0741661861538887,
-0.33173760771751404,
-0.16179372370243073,
0.09587499499320984,
0.6224803924560547,
-0.7362074255943298,
0.7660441398620605,
0.3033755421638489,
0.7059525847434998,
0.421135812997818,
0.1630685180425644,
0.39350518584251404,
-0.7502707839012146,
0.0884769931435585,
0.11637101322412491,
0.45848095417022705,
0.10514072328805923,
-0.31146880984306335,
0.16105596721172333,
0.39524292945861816,
-0.4146108627319336,
-0.7996583580970764,
-0.09465332329273224,
-1.3574354648590088,
0.013511402532458305,
0.5571733713150024,
-0.019879382103681564,
-0.4431972801685333,
0.09940920025110245,
-0.2435671091079712,
0.6656132340431213,
-0.33517250418663025,
0.592634916305542,
0.483536958694458,
0.11471505463123322,
-0.13516566157341003,
-0.15355589985847473,
0.13765554130077362,
0.5505995154380798,
-0.9273567795753479,
-0.58846116065979,
1.0077518224716187,
0.06365698575973511,
0.41455936431884766,
0.2868991494178772,
-0.11944141983985901,
0.3345782160758972,
-0.46856406331062317,
-0.015086566098034382,
-0.13539260625839233,
-0.47498002648353577,
0.044163234531879425,
0.24139177799224854,
-0.33474647998809814,
-0.37914684414863586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01197v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01197v2
|
DMoERM: Recipes of Mixture-of-Experts for Effective Reward Modeling
| 2024-03-02T12:31:22 | 2024-04-28T03:24:41 |
Shanghaoran Quan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The performance of the reward model (RM) is a critical factor in improving
the effectiveness of the large language model (LLM) during alignment
fine-tuning. There remain two challenges in RM training: 1) training the same
RM using various categories of data may cause its generalization performance to
suffer from multi-task disturbance, and 2) the human annotation consistency
rate is generally only $60\%$ to $75\%$, causing training data to contain a lot
of noise. To tackle these two challenges, we introduced the idea of
Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) into the field of RM for the first time. We propose
the Double-Layer MoE RM (DMoERM). The outer layer MoE is a sparse model. After
classifying an input into task categories, we route it to the corresponding
inner layer task-specific model. The inner layer MoE is a dense model. We
decompose the specific task into multiple capability dimensions and
individually fine-tune a LoRA expert on each one. Their outputs are then
synthesized by an MLP to compute the final rewards. To minimize costs, we call
a public LLM API to obtain the capability preference labels. The validation on
manually labeled datasets confirms that our model attains superior consistency
with human preference and outstrips advanced generative approaches. Meanwhile,
through BoN sampling and RL experiments, we demonstrate that our model
outperforms state-of-the-art ensemble methods of RM and mitigates the
overoptimization problem. Our code and dataset are available at:
https://github.com/quanshr/DMoERM-v1.
|
[
-0.4004560708999634,
-0.5249395370483398,
0.3870067894458771,
0.05649035796523094,
-0.12887343764305115,
0.18006032705307007,
-0.3128094971179962,
-0.3543073534965515,
0.1743268221616745,
0.6881268620491028,
-0.5331631302833557,
-0.2327882945537567,
-0.8243274092674255,
-0.13753430545330048,
0.004653801675885916,
0.8187083601951599,
-0.13384948670864105,
-0.13147135078907013,
-0.5136126279830933,
-0.16034035384655,
-0.6923438906669617,
-0.579217255115509,
-0.45555734634399414,
-0.5938520431518555,
0.770754337310791,
0.6217015385627747,
0.33719658851623535,
0.8437305092811584,
0.5454133152961731,
0.3118637204170227,
-0.06654545664787292,
0.5536491274833679,
-0.6048638820648193,
0.19741971790790558,
-0.14247870445251465,
-0.5065089464187622,
-0.6103777289390564,
0.2992572784423828,
0.2990018129348755,
0.39388105273246765,
-0.4112757742404938,
-0.2069401890039444,
0.029507437720894814,
0.7268680334091187,
-0.7219069600105286,
0.14778351783752441,
-0.7749501466751099,
-0.16478510200977325,
-0.08838856220245361,
-0.4271949231624603,
-0.31437015533447266,
-0.05454757437109947,
-0.033698420971632004,
-0.578071653842926,
-0.10438763350248337,
0.08012028783559799,
0.5386430621147156,
0.7429547905921936,
-0.5345840454101562,
-0.1448563188314438,
-0.7315816283226013,
1.1155403852462769,
-0.6154454350471497,
0.08329309523105621,
0.5116323828697205,
0.309826523065567,
-0.31496378779411316,
-0.11996419727802277,
-0.5721498727798462,
-0.15867342054843903,
0.19143089652061462,
0.2057589590549469,
0.09563606232404709,
0.02338389866054058,
-0.1449946016073227,
0.6827548742294312,
-0.20555491745471954,
0.5108072757720947,
-0.15481498837471008,
0.04069354385137558,
0.9258078932762146,
0.34815916419029236,
0.14801493287086487,
0.10380259901285172,
-0.6810011267662048,
-0.31340500712394714,
-0.47734859585762024,
0.10899453610181808,
0.43387696146965027,
0.019053172320127487,
-0.011443538591265678,
0.5438998937606812,
-0.3324379622936249,
0.7174758911132812,
0.14763665199279785,
-0.4896596372127533,
0.1546521633863449,
-0.0990523248910904,
-0.006184201687574387,
0.02277860976755619,
0.7629033327102661,
0.4086885154247284,
-0.01651580072939396,
-0.240303173661232,
-0.5234043598175049,
-0.02114533632993698,
0.26474156975746155,
-0.6111422777175903,
-0.43054085969924927,
0.36424756050109863,
-0.10021988302469254,
-0.6051450967788696,
0.1872117817401886,
-0.4054521918296814,
-0.5325735211372375,
-0.6335389018058777,
0.6388235688209534,
-0.4021068215370178,
-0.6108645796775818,
0.4021603763103485,
-0.19296474754810333,
-0.2731606364250183,
0.33161023259162903,
-1.081718921661377,
0.24716313183307648,
0.9647186398506165,
0.5506682991981506,
-0.37773606181144714,
-0.28538817167282104,
-0.6242722868919373,
0.24675250053405762,
0.0183600801974535,
0.7534376978874207,
-0.4488738477230072,
-0.3022862672805786,
-0.33161109685897827,
-0.5066689848899841,
-0.20190811157226562,
-0.7333909869194031,
0.4933818280696869,
-0.46041953563690186,
0.1955610066652298,
-0.3366718590259552,
-0.7470123171806335,
-0.25441840291023254,
0.4292995035648346,
-0.5842199325561523,
1.1159749031066895,
0.22601166367530823,
-0.6148670315742493,
0.47524240612983704,
-0.7518690228462219,
-0.21740368008613586,
0.09283085912466049,
-0.2488221675157547,
-0.13438007235527039,
0.17139199376106262,
0.20694543421268463,
0.4977574646472931,
-0.31380173563957214,
0.4315422773361206,
-0.11869004368782043,
-0.2840175926685333,
0.48939886689186096,
-0.21244266629219055,
0.4854470193386078,
0.20161543786525726,
-0.26731449365615845,
0.19052547216415405,
-0.7074765563011169,
-0.052398327738046646,
0.08383038640022278,
-0.6015724539756775,
-0.5726514458656311,
0.10425137728452682,
0.019712137058377266,
0.4016720950603485,
0.28920021653175354,
-0.5008023381233215,
0.4420187175273895,
-0.21454916894435883,
0.6062096357345581,
1.0289281606674194,
-0.239167720079422,
0.5377586483955383,
-0.5235217809677124,
0.4617513418197632,
0.3026496469974518,
-0.007921812124550343,
-0.05128331854939461,
-0.3586540222167969,
-0.6380812525749207,
-0.7739155888557434,
0.6202526688575745,
0.569899320602417,
-0.5236133933067322,
0.9626284241676331,
-0.37253010272979736,
-0.4856719970703125,
-0.7621399164199829,
0.3302869498729706,
0.3476591408252716,
0.4808175265789032,
0.3123844563961029,
-0.46485990285873413,
-0.29496848583221436,
-0.9383946657180786,
0.054293833673000336,
-0.03189137205481529,
0.008016800507903099,
0.26151302456855774,
0.4766564667224884,
-0.2337597906589508,
1.0868595838546753,
-0.5202515721321106,
-0.4246171712875366,
-0.25996291637420654,
0.320464551448822,
0.06574829667806625,
0.8538782000541687,
0.2694964110851288,
-0.783987283706665,
-0.33868396282196045,
0.08655910938978195,
-0.6075499057769775,
-0.04712875187397003,
0.15590505301952362,
-0.35417476296424866,
0.06991741061210632,
0.031765520572662354,
-0.480153352022171,
-0.13286927342414856,
0.6121081709861755,
-0.0031741857528686523,
0.1822177916765213,
-0.14261972904205322,
0.22970741987228394,
-1.1545954942703247,
0.10731224715709686,
0.08755479007959366,
-0.21914151310920715,
-0.4170883893966675,
0.20289573073387146,
-0.032911524176597595,
0.23756268620491028,
-0.12944559752941132,
0.5884886980056763,
-0.192643404006958,
0.3671703338623047,
-0.5973660945892334,
-0.13296781480312347,
-0.08685711026191711,
0.7411721348762512,
0.08166662603616714,
0.4741007089614868,
0.4448956847190857,
-0.5871055722236633,
0.44757598638534546,
0.07213662564754486,
-0.46227264404296875,
0.6567216515541077,
-0.657288134098053,
0.28872424364089966,
0.012602175585925579,
0.2271772176027298,
-0.9601683020591736,
-0.5178399085998535,
0.34297990798950195,
-0.26183944940567017,
0.5162745714187622,
-0.14329472184181213,
-0.6403379440307617,
-0.1825694441795349,
-0.20100903511047363,
0.4715891182422638,
0.7725089192390442,
-0.35574886202812195,
0.6698983311653137,
0.6092714071273804,
-0.18625164031982422,
-0.6745542287826538,
-0.6502081751823425,
-0.025769811123609543,
-0.25284644961357117,
-0.8178026676177979,
0.6201627254486084,
-0.2458396553993225,
-0.2102491557598114,
-0.08011431992053986,
-0.23895259201526642,
-0.11960694938898087,
0.36413270235061646,
0.30213966965675354,
0.15612556040287018,
0.08554872870445251,
-0.10890614986419678,
0.15723982453346252,
-0.3660593330860138,
-0.09912754595279694,
-0.26684558391571045,
0.49432018399238586,
0.1876092106103897,
-0.4806760549545288,
-0.5631712675094604,
0.3360503613948822,
0.5532494187355042,
-0.3052983582019806,
0.7562103867530823,
0.5965911746025085,
-0.196781724691391,
-0.029507748782634735,
-0.9549915790557861,
-0.275522917509079,
-0.4249686002731323,
0.3065440356731415,
-0.29690465331077576,
-0.8639950156211853,
0.45418456196784973,
0.042672209441661835,
0.2238636016845703,
0.3538112938404083,
0.6617909073829651,
0.0440470390021801,
1.160651683807373,
0.6011183261871338,
-0.4029039144515991,
0.48587098717689514,
-0.30666595697402954,
-0.09154738485813141,
-0.747587263584137,
-0.4703132212162018,
-0.25207436084747314,
-0.6882982850074768,
-0.1022772490978241,
-0.4180554747581482,
0.5399996638298035,
0.22547607123851776,
0.09459151327610016,
0.020612649619579315,
-0.585713267326355,
0.48432379961013794,
0.7972065210342407,
0.38200339674949646,
0.2749675214290619,
0.10840928554534912,
-0.004993152804672718,
0.11060547083616257,
-0.9664217829704285,
-0.38497042655944824,
0.9572451114654541,
0.4891149699687958,
0.8861153721809387,
-0.14277873933315277,
0.8938920497894287,
0.2155788242816925,
0.06733506917953491,
-0.7802888751029968,
0.4345373809337616,
-0.02744772657752037,
-0.5984581708908081,
-0.22146949172019958,
-0.6298370361328125,
-0.5924968123435974,
0.35548022389411926,
-0.24933598935604095,
-0.3113430142402649,
0.12024921923875809,
0.4523617923259735,
-0.44700920581817627,
0.32823559641838074,
-0.5393820405006409,
0.78937166929245,
-0.41686898469924927,
-0.4139978289604187,
-0.39755240082740784,
-0.6604583859443665,
0.4718002378940582,
-0.012841208837926388,
0.12688133120536804,
-0.2838757336139679,
0.007806404493749142,
0.7313073873519897,
-0.4151262044906616,
0.7444116473197937,
-0.16245605051517487,
-0.2030715048313141,
0.10184868425130844,
0.0017733679851517081,
0.6138371229171753,
-0.08830755203962326,
-0.09415076673030853,
0.06621913611888885,
-0.3931835889816284,
-0.5348361134529114,
-0.5035141706466675,
0.8496025800704956,
-0.9635282158851624,
-0.555022120475769,
-0.2281322032213211,
-0.990696907043457,
-0.0584985613822937,
-0.06530731171369553,
0.17879952490329742,
0.3750629723072052,
0.20156267285346985,
0.28422245383262634,
0.8928353190422058,
0.08847465366125107,
-0.05806303024291992,
0.40407389402389526,
0.15187470614910126,
-0.4955761730670929,
1.0319163799285889,
0.04124909266829491,
0.20324257016181946,
0.5355337858200073,
0.23212683200836182,
-0.21976572275161743,
-0.573144257068634,
-0.5194140076637268,
-0.17532934248447418,
-0.46521610021591187,
-0.2282170206308365,
-0.808431088924408,
-0.02465081959962845,
-0.10791568458080292,
-0.05179625004529953,
-0.5113397836685181,
-0.49944886565208435,
-0.22566573321819305,
0.09102798998355865,
0.43922707438468933,
0.7198387384414673,
-0.05890009552240372,
0.295004665851593,
-0.7031481266021729,
0.10900069028139114,
0.48529040813446045,
0.25505557656288147,
0.0515606515109539,
-0.4960809350013733,
-0.42777109146118164,
0.3640497326850891,
-0.40263035893440247,
-0.3323388695716858,
0.20058949291706085,
-0.16157716512680054,
0.8615731000900269,
0.33312278985977173,
0.04960170388221741,
0.5214172601699829,
-0.04342612251639366,
0.6484944820404053,
0.33139848709106445,
-0.6286448240280151,
0.31955742835998535,
-0.4409800171852112,
-0.06882362812757492,
0.6083968877792358,
0.28342926502227783,
-0.26533061265945435,
-0.41566115617752075,
-0.3895024061203003,
-1.0225706100463867,
0.8288915157318115,
0.09977647662162781,
-0.13273590803146362,
0.14296337962150574,
0.1952628195285797,
0.5522708296775818,
0.3830117881298065,
-0.6340141892433167,
-0.11910320073366165,
-0.14962467551231384,
-0.503186821937561,
-0.16960717737674713,
-0.4039028584957123,
-0.3903903663158417,
-0.23228880763053894,
0.6237654089927673,
0.13300849497318268,
0.017361260950565338,
-0.1008577048778534,
-0.15030686557292938,
-0.3958509564399719,
0.31840765476226807,
0.7235394716262817,
0.70033198595047,
-0.42181694507598877,
0.14119714498519897,
-0.10364589840173721,
-0.04628036171197891,
0.17094089090824127,
0.1410549432039261,
0.06669656187295914,
-0.4245159924030304,
0.1614413559436798,
0.8284942507743835,
0.343838632106781,
-0.6558775305747986,
0.40866440534591675,
0.29708489775657654,
-0.5163586735725403,
-0.18578478693962097,
0.5430195927619934,
0.1020968109369278,
0.18473535776138306,
0.5447217226028442,
0.22559195756912231,
-0.11017812043428421,
-0.3951351046562195,
-0.08763626217842102,
0.4672173857688904,
-0.19506222009658813,
-0.2173728048801422,
0.7452430725097656,
0.40841934084892273,
-0.0397968664765358,
0.5907725691795349,
-0.12277060747146606,
-0.630497932434082,
0.5156009197235107,
0.1758410632610321,
0.6570436358451843,
-0.19099171459674835,
-0.06346582621335983,
0.07158422470092773,
0.09429304301738739,
-0.5775688886642456,
0.18649883568286896,
0.044301193207502365,
-0.6863507628440857,
-0.5074604749679565,
-0.49142152070999146,
-0.3942369818687439,
0.038097985088825226,
-0.6687867045402527,
0.16142722964286804,
-0.1155628189444542,
0.025665489956736565,
-0.08014892786741257,
-0.11694522202014923,
-0.5812207460403442,
0.06036113202571869,
0.1028575599193573,
0.7284921407699585,
-0.8285856246948242,
0.8668326735496521,
0.8518694639205933,
-0.3648786246776581,
-0.6229106783866882,
-0.3966827392578125,
-0.05699784308671951,
-0.829092264175415,
0.7322916388511658,
0.12294812500476837,
0.07084830850362778,
0.036550372838974,
-0.5029512047767639,
-0.5435197353363037,
1.225883960723877,
0.1860228031873703,
-0.6717866659164429,
0.1774314045906067,
0.011993280611932278,
0.2510134279727936,
-0.5715184807777405,
0.1902952790260315,
0.32502514123916626,
0.5770779252052307,
0.2072523683309555,
-0.8936118483543396,
-0.15981709957122803,
-0.20619544386863708,
-0.09172128885984421,
0.3058292269706726,
-0.5843853950500488,
1.0617932081222534,
0.01757742092013359,
0.21707308292388916,
0.1212373748421669,
0.5077137351036072,
0.5994822978973389,
0.36808785796165466,
0.7679618000984192,
0.8713136315345764,
0.6587842106819153,
-0.026621919125318527,
1.0640701055526733,
-0.341950386762619,
0.2354755848646164,
0.7712484002113342,
-0.33302852511405945,
0.7483553290367126,
0.5929728746414185,
-0.021423783153295517,
0.42357516288757324,
0.6059519052505493,
0.028285879641771317,
0.6800369620323181,
0.16525927186012268,
-0.1280863732099533,
-0.63572758436203,
-0.11932927370071411,
-0.44689151644706726,
0.3385297656059265,
0.0635925680398941,
-0.2792985141277313,
0.09053310751914978,
0.044279035180807114,
-0.2703682482242584,
0.16203045845031738,
-0.3768608868122101,
0.8141494989395142,
-0.029513109475374222,
-0.756779134273529,
0.5807887315750122,
0.1494351029396057,
1.0461121797561646,
-0.6225612759590149,
0.029602276161313057,
-0.13662567734718323,
0.25225207209587097,
-0.22141006588935852,
-0.6864303946495056,
-0.2314101904630661,
-0.27788686752319336,
-0.43994107842445374,
-0.22975561022758484,
0.540955126285553,
-0.794838011264801,
-0.47228965163230896,
-0.08788196742534637,
0.43524619936943054,
0.0036082041915506124,
-0.36287498474121094,
-0.5219377279281616,
-0.015389347448945045,
-0.09340953826904297,
-0.23416854441165924,
0.598711371421814,
0.33146926760673523,
0.12049456685781479,
0.8095797896385193,
0.5047856569290161,
-0.166608989238739,
-0.03838090971112251,
-0.14003197848796844,
1.0391653776168823,
-0.5193207263946533,
-0.5558406114578247,
-0.8837251663208008,
0.8966584801673889,
-0.006433424539864063,
-0.26758873462677,
0.5488334894180298,
0.5646184682846069,
0.814099133014679,
-0.1662071943283081,
0.7588850259780884,
0.014460147358477116,
0.3943459391593933,
-0.6753523349761963,
0.514593243598938,
-0.9246174097061157,
0.18780286610126495,
-0.11797986924648285,
-0.7922348976135254,
0.04829620197415352,
0.49097996950149536,
-0.14157049357891083,
0.13253158330917358,
0.3121296465396881,
0.7223225831985474,
-0.37963321805000305,
-0.13909541070461273,
0.21666772663593292,
-0.06475879997015,
0.12636379897594452,
0.7515764236450195,
1.0901830196380615,
-0.15630283951759338,
0.4085357189178467,
-0.5823784470558167,
-0.32885247468948364,
-0.6205818057060242,
-0.8638800978660583,
-0.8236489295959473,
-0.49633878469467163,
-0.4531307518482208,
-0.02931942418217659,
-0.13015614449977875,
1.3215560913085938,
0.931196928024292,
-0.6378077268600464,
-0.2403361201286316,
0.00966047216206789,
0.10350058972835541,
-0.578755795955658,
-0.18633690476417542,
0.04561662673950195,
-0.24404871463775635,
-0.7373422384262085,
0.388685941696167,
0.2628409266471863,
-0.00021327336435206234,
-0.4049631655216217,
-0.34373927116394043,
0.022751426324248314,
-0.21392621099948883,
0.4663957953453064,
-0.0940379872918129,
-0.8548278212547302,
0.01333680935204029,
-0.026055028662085533,
-0.23384255170822144,
0.043159253895282745,
0.8567662835121155,
-0.5172424912452698,
0.3959413170814514,
0.4678105115890503,
0.6862698197364807,
0.2220730185508728,
0.22816616296768188,
0.6883173584938049,
-0.7355250716209412,
0.15840822458267212,
0.2196994423866272,
0.3555153012275696,
0.22642838954925537,
-0.45415806770324707,
0.542454719543457,
0.1522982120513916,
-0.7620681524276733,
-0.9540516138076782,
0.1812342256307602,
-1.4479073286056519,
-0.22397300601005554,
1.1502772569656372,
-0.10023893415927887,
-0.011914798989892006,
0.04450061172246933,
-0.3488054573535919,
0.1078537181019783,
-0.6787244081497192,
1.1349451541900635,
0.8369339108467102,
0.0030172665137797594,
-0.048580482602119446,
-0.4310082197189331,
0.16869881749153137,
0.5844805836677551,
-0.4822571575641632,
-0.022228945046663284,
0.4107803404331207,
0.41022488474845886,
0.05558187514543533,
0.46501925587654114,
0.03571595996618271,
0.193664088845253,
-0.18547885119915009,
0.34474679827690125,
-0.7888222336769104,
-0.2794400155544281,
-0.16706068813800812,
0.1208055391907692,
0.38299429416656494,
-0.2852841317653656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01196v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01196v1
|
Machine Translation in the Covid domain: an English-Irish case study for LoResMT 2021
| 2024-03-02T12:29:28 | 2024-03-02T12:29:28 |
Séamus Lankford, Haithem Afli, Andy Way
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Translation models for the specific domain of translating Covid data from
English to Irish were developed for the LoResMT 2021 shared task. Domain
adaptation techniques, using a Covid-adapted generic 55k corpus from the
Directorate General of Translation, were applied. Fine-tuning, mixed
fine-tuning and combined dataset approaches were compared with models trained
on an extended in-domain dataset. As part of this study, an English-Irish
dataset of Covid related data, from the Health and Education domains, was
developed. The highest-performing model used a Transformer architecture trained
with an extended in-domain Covid dataset. In the context of this study, we have
demonstrated that extending an 8k in-domain baseline dataset by just 5k lines
improved the BLEU score by 27 points.
|
[
0.12977315485477448,
-0.5070263743400574,
0.07184574753046036,
0.1493464857339859,
0.03380421921610832,
0.12838174402713776,
0.04537967965006828,
-0.7980166673660278,
0.10032671689987183,
0.6406188011169434,
-0.47512945532798767,
-0.3707144558429718,
-0.62298184633255,
0.17861148715019226,
-0.4044049382209778,
1.2077783346176147,
-0.22335074841976166,
0.13003167510032654,
-0.35776016116142273,
-0.011467279866337776,
-0.6071490049362183,
-0.7017775177955627,
-0.687109112739563,
-0.40679147839546204,
0.2343665510416031,
0.7277277112007141,
0.5751330256462097,
0.1593366414308548,
1.2472679615020752,
0.08006332814693451,
0.27177947759628296,
0.3384656608104706,
-0.6738072037696838,
-0.0022943534422665834,
-0.48194101452827454,
-0.38048428297042847,
-0.8481550216674805,
0.08638238161802292,
0.13575305044651031,
0.6826573610305786,
0.07898864895105362,
0.5423631072044373,
0.05217369645833969,
0.5074983835220337,
-0.3570452034473419,
0.09679167717695236,
-0.5507436990737915,
0.06529221683740616,
-0.02460409142076969,
-0.33038198947906494,
-0.7212601900100708,
0.1547328382730484,
0.5593937635421753,
-0.7232844829559326,
0.24837246537208557,
0.38500845432281494,
0.8945663571357727,
0.387373685836792,
-0.5075516700744629,
-0.3242557942867279,
-0.7500348091125488,
0.9123965501785278,
-0.3559553027153015,
0.4733369052410126,
0.38704004883766174,
0.19329719245433807,
-0.30573737621307373,
-0.7260931134223938,
0.0074896072037518024,
-0.05909192934632301,
0.015334699302911758,
0.555950403213501,
-0.8012270331382751,
-0.21398991346359253,
0.027308009564876556,
0.24481984972953796,
-0.9519215226173401,
0.014693760313093662,
-0.9942960143089294,
-0.20918579399585724,
0.8856706023216248,
0.23655059933662415,
0.3128328323364258,
0.056649986654520035,
-0.633662760257721,
-0.08723033219575882,
-0.5161027908325195,
0.008150875568389893,
-0.12305225431919098,
0.27610817551612854,
-0.33136528730392456,
0.6886589527130127,
0.03665313869714737,
0.6181066036224365,
0.2308865338563919,
-0.11784286797046661,
0.2998031973838806,
-0.30221351981163025,
-0.6082656979560852,
0.266887903213501,
0.1554110199213028,
0.5497664213180542,
0.0396614633500576,
-0.36162039637565613,
-0.004469199571758509,
0.17140862345695496,
0.46296024322509766,
-0.6843076944351196,
-0.26314103603363037,
0.15329548716545105,
-0.3220148980617523,
0.07970480620861053,
-0.13781191408634186,
-0.5467228889465332,
-0.05478942021727562,
-0.3509020507335663,
0.5861139893531799,
-0.4121885597705841,
0.022720912471413612,
0.5236528515815735,
-0.43035632371902466,
0.2775227725505829,
0.5517958402633667,
-0.5121132135391235,
0.5686023235321045,
0.42434728145599365,
0.5805871486663818,
-0.7720134854316711,
-0.1283707171678543,
-0.6229018568992615,
0.2867223024368286,
-0.34863755106925964,
0.45952415466308594,
-0.48918524384498596,
-0.22059409320354462,
-0.14673858880996704,
0.15097078680992126,
-0.5021392703056335,
-0.6732528805732727,
0.7991979718208313,
-0.5271657705307007,
0.27782145142555237,
0.14175020158290863,
-0.4980633854866028,
-0.34016355872154236,
0.2447950392961502,
-0.5776821374893188,
0.8793631196022034,
0.33148086071014404,
-0.6137557625770569,
0.24901774525642395,
-0.7296756505966187,
-0.5525830388069153,
0.17630144953727722,
0.4208812713623047,
-0.5144767761230469,
0.13108617067337036,
0.30287420749664307,
0.740423858165741,
-0.4105425775051117,
0.24016205966472626,
-0.10779953747987747,
-0.10324114561080933,
0.07460537552833557,
-0.23093317449092865,
0.7192648649215698,
0.3415276110172272,
0.015377219766378403,
-0.23511697351932526,
-0.7115102410316467,
-0.2574536204338074,
-0.1693669855594635,
-0.11967845261096954,
-0.46374568343162537,
-0.28996244072914124,
0.19131867587566376,
0.17424236238002777,
0.3913781940937042,
-0.45350730419158936,
0.16072171926498413,
-0.15424545109272003,
0.29737207293510437,
-0.036238815635442734,
0.08467257767915726,
0.5980780720710754,
-0.5375106930732727,
0.6159825325012207,
0.19034677743911743,
0.26800039410591125,
0.09997481107711792,
-0.761478066444397,
-0.440279483795166,
-0.43371397256851196,
-0.04082190617918968,
1.1161315441131592,
-0.6776552796363831,
0.21520587801933289,
-0.3650727868080139,
-0.6009209752082825,
-0.8060691356658936,
-0.23284342885017395,
0.16083505749702454,
0.6022032499313354,
0.846348762512207,
-0.175713449716568,
-0.7185906767845154,
-0.7011946439743042,
-0.10289197415113449,
-0.011296235024929047,
0.2925529181957245,
0.2247295081615448,
0.8074710965156555,
-0.5486409068107605,
0.576587438583374,
-0.38517823815345764,
-0.30662307143211365,
-0.09321931004524231,
0.0810261070728302,
0.13185285031795502,
0.5858004093170166,
0.31276172399520874,
-1.0467689037322998,
-0.4267863929271698,
0.5417241454124451,
-0.8480648398399353,
0.028289487585425377,
-0.04766323044896126,
-0.06007194146513939,
-0.0374646857380867,
0.40005308389663696,
-0.16023142635822296,
0.7490083575248718,
0.986479640007019,
-0.5375084280967712,
0.49451062083244324,
-0.25500786304473877,
0.36785888671875,
-1.4261516332626343,
-0.08332376927137375,
-0.08085420727729797,
-0.5029194355010986,
-0.7856345772743225,
0.28285375237464905,
0.000063823361415416,
-0.4571285843849182,
-0.4999082088470459,
0.6255506277084351,
-0.0965559333562851,
0.2515180706977844,
0.012521643191576004,
-0.26772913336753845,
0.46919238567352295,
-0.038604363799095154,
-0.004892648197710514,
0.9605311155319214,
0.5196200609207153,
-0.4752156734466553,
0.5259214639663696,
0.5181499719619751,
-0.10738132894039154,
0.7554041147232056,
-0.5246390700340271,
0.022095391526818275,
0.310507208108902,
0.10228952765464783,
-0.6609393358230591,
-0.37341341376304626,
0.12694822251796722,
-0.4283399283885956,
0.04408750683069229,
-0.078969307243824,
0.10864612460136414,
-0.33034372329711914,
0.18122896552085876,
0.30783623456954956,
0.41659319400787354,
-0.593230128288269,
0.23839892446994781,
0.2613331079483032,
-0.18178673088550568,
-0.32618147134780884,
-1.0664973258972168,
0.33805328607559204,
-0.4780476689338684,
-0.8587740659713745,
0.7596703767776489,
-0.291292279958725,
-0.33179613947868347,
0.13971233367919922,
0.007713454309850931,
-0.42117998003959656,
0.06934835761785507,
0.08364441245794296,
0.304426372051239,
-0.42639943957328796,
-0.08755235373973846,
0.14362406730651855,
0.21613988280296326,
-0.13428258895874023,
-0.596624493598938,
0.15733295679092407,
0.09166129678487778,
-0.05281658098101616,
-0.5038239359855652,
0.6127199530601501,
0.6251065731048584,
-0.1375420242547989,
0.6897295713424683,
0.4422188699245453,
-0.5026504397392273,
-0.08665990829467773,
-0.291260689496994,
0.16661807894706726,
-0.35209840536117554,
0.24988093972206116,
-0.5879017114639282,
-1.0026981830596924,
0.4189872443675995,
-0.18703606724739075,
-0.2734454572200775,
0.6389511823654175,
0.5075187683105469,
-0.201009139418602,
0.43940800428390503,
0.9419591426849365,
-0.044564008712768555,
0.1341707855463028,
-0.22378680109977722,
0.1603129655122757,
-0.6739434003829956,
-0.20582802593708038,
-0.4894210398197174,
0.06418409198522568,
-0.5534847974777222,
-0.5381245613098145,
0.4066494107246399,
0.09651864320039749,
0.10906928777694702,
0.6941981315612793,
-0.43687039613723755,
-0.09781801700592041,
0.22498434782028198,
0.37451422214508057,
0.22793449461460114,
0.2166370153427124,
0.03842879459261894,
0.03754338622093201,
-0.8692296743392944,
-0.3507918417453766,
0.9222394227981567,
0.21751636266708374,
0.6931902766227722,
0.09143348783254623,
0.7299123406410217,
0.7209857106208801,
-0.15876778960227966,
-0.5756639242172241,
-0.0007683676667511463,
-0.6484845876693726,
-0.4645926356315613,
-0.4239204525947571,
-0.2150256335735321,
-1.1137093305587769,
-0.3496270775794983,
-0.004474333953112364,
-0.41500383615493774,
0.5563104152679443,
0.010822994634509087,
-0.3091653287410736,
-0.034115467220544815,
-0.9515436887741089,
0.7378832101821899,
-0.03721289336681366,
-0.3799213171005249,
-0.29520976543426514,
-0.3304857313632965,
-0.012170805595815182,
-0.4157662093639374,
0.2576158344745636,
-0.011385634541511536,
0.31840524077415466,
0.840851902961731,
-0.21582390367984772,
0.7351769804954529,
0.16248802840709686,
-0.11340183764696121,
0.12208785116672516,
-0.1520928293466568,
0.45145052671432495,
-0.059270747005939484,
-0.5299607515335083,
0.22841982543468475,
0.2398841679096222,
-0.746405839920044,
-0.2994401156902313,
0.27991783618927,
-1.0269972085952759,
-0.5654629468917847,
-0.33256104588508606,
-0.7672479748725891,
0.005482872016727924,
-0.14728333055973053,
0.3590690791606903,
0.5296376943588257,
-0.5999984741210938,
0.20742125809192657,
0.5875131487846375,
-0.2797608971595764,
0.13478685915470123,
0.43842196464538574,
-0.004470129497349262,
-0.32882165908813477,
0.800057590007782,
0.10045731067657471,
0.34120112657546997,
0.809615433216095,
0.20285066962242126,
0.2090267837047577,
-0.584151566028595,
-0.5741324424743652,
-0.1816430240869522,
-0.4529287815093994,
-0.41031956672668457,
-0.42676419019699097,
-0.5563262104988098,
-0.6761485934257507,
-0.4554899334907532,
0.0011703517520800233,
-0.33904221653938293,
-0.3434535562992096,
-0.027930166572332382,
0.8448027968406677,
0.943780243396759,
0.1410750448703766,
0.4626867473125458,
-0.7188237905502319,
0.28299862146377563,
0.1687457263469696,
-0.11514962464570999,
-0.6308256983757019,
-0.9708836078643799,
-0.7856587767601013,
-0.007424894720315933,
-0.051084261387586594,
-0.5290108919143677,
0.8762073516845703,
0.3909587562084198,
0.21431964635849,
-0.14281335473060608,
-0.0345134511590004,
1.07111656665802,
-0.8134783506393433,
0.9577697515487671,
0.23824171721935272,
-0.7573481202125549,
0.5573647022247314,
-0.21715271472930908,
0.26636803150177,
0.3205049932003021,
0.5659263134002686,
-0.6215510368347168,
-0.21871399879455566,
-0.4794420301914215,
-0.5492828488349915,
0.256351113319397,
0.16212071478366852,
0.004611110780388117,
0.1934085190296173,
0.4179284870624542,
0.5793471336364746,
-0.21689373254776,
-0.12611904740333557,
-0.029972627758979797,
-0.029638953506946564,
-0.27031636238098145,
-0.32246288657188416,
0.03630705177783966,
-0.0640125423669815,
-0.5549401640892029,
0.628400444984436,
0.006694061681628227,
0.32845938205718994,
0.46283724904060364,
-0.48711535334587097,
-0.20660974085330963,
0.2630440890789032,
0.5966371893882751,
0.7274612188339233,
-0.2365569919347763,
-0.03449948877096176,
0.32013946771621704,
-0.920801043510437,
0.13389451801776886,
0.2072196900844574,
-0.14966034889221191,
-0.017307491973042488,
0.5971789360046387,
0.9709792733192444,
-0.0014298399910330772,
-0.26492536067962646,
0.47577452659606934,
-0.0776943638920784,
-0.20703427493572235,
-0.2638965845108032,
0.11791449040174484,
-0.2515588104724884,
0.42022705078125,
0.5898537039756775,
0.48386433720588684,
0.3503202795982361,
-0.3408929705619812,
0.5646069049835205,
0.06982389092445374,
-0.46050652861595154,
-0.6028624176979065,
0.5391041040420532,
0.20239412784576416,
-0.3933415710926056,
0.24510332942008972,
0.10870449244976044,
-0.1612536460161209,
0.4814961552619934,
0.9504267573356628,
0.6786678433418274,
-0.5069528818130493,
0.23530535399913788,
0.1508316546678543,
0.2987087666988373,
-0.23629708588123322,
0.4128262996673584,
0.49874889850616455,
-0.6001242399215698,
-0.6053606867790222,
-0.5975843071937561,
-0.6264673471450806,
0.04806096851825714,
-1.1442126035690308,
0.3595430552959442,
0.24449892342090607,
-0.006094608921557665,
-0.10954896360635757,
0.2851058840751648,
-1.1806374788284302,
0.6590909361839294,
0.06393551081418991,
1.2381483316421509,
-1.073918104171753,
1.0522124767303467,
0.9183481335639954,
-0.21928228437900543,
-0.538154661655426,
-0.019951246678829193,
-0.4517766237258911,
-0.9208105206489563,
0.6969937086105347,
-0.1902008056640625,
-0.0700412318110466,
0.19484969973564148,
-0.5605948567390442,
-1.0487936735153198,
1.1902347803115845,
0.42415884137153625,
-0.6842987537384033,
0.07947288453578949,
0.46073415875434875,
0.5695993900299072,
-0.600439190864563,
-0.26779240369796753,
0.5221125483512878,
0.276233047246933,
-0.038231343030929565,
-1.172143816947937,
-0.34652459621429443,
-0.20306138694286346,
-0.4845307171344757,
-0.14917144179344177,
-0.6015669107437134,
0.45422008633613586,
0.00997931882739067,
0.20224317908287048,
0.016293209046125412,
0.6941401958465576,
-0.09066124260425568,
0.7520266771316528,
-0.08267199248075485,
0.66202312707901,
1.1471341848373413,
0.06538496166467667,
0.9354508519172668,
-0.05978579819202423,
0.12686467170715332,
1.0550644397735596,
-0.38938409090042114,
0.8735272288322449,
0.3998081386089325,
0.0014205281622707844,
0.39706799387931824,
0.5548827052116394,
0.059072427451610565,
0.508612334728241,
-0.0023234367836266756,
-0.24467088282108307,
-0.1405368447303772,
-0.4153200387954712,
-0.2937944233417511,
0.6431077122688293,
0.6258236169815063,
-0.21885645389556885,
0.04796906188130379,
0.5421159267425537,
-0.07121029496192932,
0.026410870254039764,
-0.6020325422286987,
0.7208721041679382,
0.19871945679187775,
-0.5256875157356262,
0.5619052648544312,
0.07730064541101456,
0.3947829008102417,
-0.3208766579627991,
-0.06717722117900848,
-0.22986842691898346,
0.10425231605768204,
-0.33255335688591003,
-0.577129602432251,
0.6049799919128418,
0.09038500487804413,
-0.5784736275672913,
-0.44351017475128174,
0.8733431696891785,
-0.49852609634399414,
-0.7743699550628662,
0.5063430666923523,
0.7374099493026733,
0.44083553552627563,
0.2813321053981781,
-0.6155900359153748,
0.09427613765001297,
-0.12128200381994247,
0.10308244079351425,
0.14679114520549774,
0.7122361660003662,
-0.5358538031578064,
0.46638980507850647,
0.38390782475471497,
0.29731231927871704,
0.2999067008495331,
-0.20016178488731384,
0.5641648173332214,
-0.45282959938049316,
-0.11976905912160873,
-0.6478268504142761,
0.29397785663604736,
0.0887257307767868,
-0.3641188442707062,
0.7422506213188171,
0.8236836791038513,
0.9556323885917664,
-0.26925915479660034,
0.9808936715126038,
0.11852313578128815,
0.38969242572784424,
-0.4112410545349121,
0.4645116329193115,
-0.4626022279262543,
-0.28598514199256897,
0.048595283180475235,
-0.33071795105934143,
-0.6006340384483337,
0.2990792691707611,
-0.476529598236084,
-0.7337096333503723,
0.7463131546974182,
0.6387902498245239,
-0.2452850490808487,
-0.14076083898544312,
0.7994157671928406,
0.15319737792015076,
0.12298583984375,
0.4892917573451996,
0.5510014891624451,
-0.8699334263801575,
0.30341836810112,
0.060535822063684464,
-0.1891927570104599,
-0.29010695219039917,
-0.7987653017044067,
-0.8760867714881897,
-0.6902741193771362,
-0.501133918762207,
-0.4057692587375641,
0.741712749004364,
0.9547821879386902,
0.7735539674758911,
-1.1247544288635254,
-0.3653424382209778,
0.4039272964000702,
-0.2669351100921631,
-0.6081082224845886,
-0.15095148980617523,
0.48138779401779175,
-0.23835906386375427,
-0.5612871050834656,
0.6414527893066406,
0.47640731930732727,
-0.10501261800527573,
0.08922313898801804,
-0.1468726545572281,
-0.23852373659610748,
0.12517531216144562,
0.8636547923088074,
-0.11764929443597794,
-0.34762853384017944,
-0.46474626660346985,
0.47993266582489014,
-0.14182303845882416,
0.13070261478424072,
0.5626761317253113,
-0.6736910939216614,
0.37069442868232727,
0.2590002417564392,
0.8489231467247009,
0.47556033730506897,
-0.26366549730300903,
0.7671449184417725,
-0.7056598663330078,
0.12319480627775192,
0.17331527173519135,
0.2750929892063141,
0.4296610951423645,
-0.7494747638702393,
0.5964412689208984,
0.28524959087371826,
-0.6566920876502991,
-0.539085328578949,
-0.007781231310218573,
-1.1686220169067383,
0.03413354232907295,
1.0482929944992065,
-0.2672573924064636,
-0.3061395287513733,
-0.5704821348190308,
-0.16146092116832733,
0.4989554286003113,
-0.36859914660453796,
0.5160620808601379,
0.6294394135475159,
-0.06626449525356293,
0.1355048269033432,
-0.7479512095451355,
0.4006904065608978,
0.19379346072673798,
-0.7843294739723206,
-0.1930970847606659,
-0.017718113958835602,
0.11187687516212463,
-0.04108348861336708,
0.19192637503147125,
0.1361331045627594,
0.42484787106513977,
-0.2846536636352539,
0.17049750685691833,
0.3518691658973694,
-0.44547703862190247,
-0.4089237451553345,
0.10226184874773026,
-0.13242554664611816,
-0.0699172168970108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01193v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01193v3
|
RAGged Edges: The Double-Edged Sword of Retrieval-Augmented Chatbots
| 2024-03-02T12:19:04 | 2024-06-12T12:00:52 |
Philip Feldman, James R. Foulds, Shimei Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, H.3.3; I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT demonstrate the remarkable progress
of artificial intelligence. However, their tendency to hallucinate -- generate
plausible but false information -- poses a significant challenge. This issue is
critical, as seen in recent court cases where ChatGPT's use led to citations of
non-existent legal rulings. This paper explores how Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG) can counter hallucinations by integrating external knowledge
with prompts. We empirically evaluate RAG against standard LLMs using prompts
designed to induce hallucinations. Our results show that RAG increases accuracy
in some cases, but can still be misled when prompts directly contradict the
model's pre-trained understanding. These findings highlight the complex nature
of hallucinations and the need for more robust solutions to ensure LLM
reliability in real-world applications. We offer practical recommendations for
RAG deployment and discuss implications for the development of more trustworthy
LLMs.
|
[
-0.5043911933898926,
-0.9318007230758667,
0.8137356638908386,
0.11591329425573349,
-0.07438075542449951,
0.2985493540763855,
-0.2451656013727188,
-0.6384775042533875,
0.31040140986442566,
0.8276164531707764,
-0.5612581968307495,
-0.16680897772312164,
-0.631675124168396,
-0.02509123459458351,
-0.6639693379402161,
1.0317305326461792,
0.366254597902298,
-0.13095033168792725,
-0.22517649829387665,
0.06812906265258789,
-0.7027538418769836,
-0.7354859709739685,
-0.7427619695663452,
-0.3857886791229248,
0.4224306046962738,
0.14173024892807007,
1.1108611822128296,
0.12310005724430084,
0.5423676371574402,
0.28763121366500854,
-0.08187933266162872,
0.6473581194877625,
-0.742805540561676,
0.590160071849823,
-0.050456319004297256,
-0.4200590252876282,
-0.08197638392448425,
-0.1766725331544876,
0.2692975103855133,
0.49903732538223267,
-0.3235979378223419,
-0.20639029145240784,
0.06075871363282204,
0.8275900483131409,
-0.38860321044921875,
-0.35683122277259827,
-1.0398461818695068,
0.2092560976743698,
0.039468295872211456,
-0.3470506966114044,
-0.7140913605690002,
-0.3499404191970825,
-0.0005673092673532665,
-0.4887792766094208,
0.19114743173122406,
0.31514692306518555,
1.0183101892471313,
0.726936399936676,
-0.06131231039762497,
-0.7216270565986633,
-0.9328678846359253,
0.5135388970375061,
-0.2961968779563904,
0.4878139793872833,
0.6222547888755798,
0.5088304281234741,
-0.700104832649231,
-0.8621062636375427,
-0.4854414463043213,
-0.5891496539115906,
-0.0357971154153347,
0.0638657882809639,
-0.22011762857437134,
0.010810664854943752,
0.3219131529331207,
0.11699710786342621,
-0.49097976088523865,
-0.0014205218758434057,
-0.5094456076622009,
-0.21321086585521698,
0.564854621887207,
0.12865683436393738,
0.3912522792816162,
-0.24166043102741241,
-0.34918129444122314,
0.02424686960875988,
-0.5820147395133972,
-0.5225980281829834,
0.48763108253479004,
0.3862170875072479,
0.3491310179233551,
0.7284883856773376,
0.20300225913524628,
0.4192753732204437,
0.1706657111644745,
-0.03313187509775162,
0.08050679415464401,
0.2029358297586441,
0.025312423706054688,
0.1443745195865631,
0.7095475196838379,
0.321688711643219,
0.45463860034942627,
-0.5118431448936462,
-0.4111473560333252,
0.06347262859344482,
0.9289640784263611,
-0.46606743335723877,
-0.39684242010116577,
0.28663158416748047,
-0.23583410680294037,
-0.18526609241962433,
-0.10790324211120605,
-1.0452251434326172,
-1.080471158027649,
-0.2192799150943756,
0.7230542898178101,
-0.6821043491363525,
-0.049407776445150375,
-0.10397735238075256,
-0.28653407096862793,
0.18947072327136993,
0.2604827582836151,
-0.5594595074653625,
0.3768105208873749,
0.810178279876709,
0.9444889426231384,
-0.274163156747818,
-0.09472858160734177,
-0.5128770470619202,
-0.20333126187324524,
-0.45975640416145325,
1.0105549097061157,
-0.5286350250244141,
-0.6266462802886963,
0.0570504292845726,
-0.14770272374153137,
0.1732041835784912,
-0.8508275151252747,
0.7521063685417175,
-0.5170009136199951,
0.3018427789211273,
-0.08987434953451157,
-0.1915845274925232,
-0.15731368958950043,
0.2831275463104248,
-0.49421846866607666,
1.2535059452056885,
-0.03685688599944115,
-0.6541566252708435,
0.08059541881084442,
-0.29179468750953674,
-0.42547687888145447,
0.1269071251153946,
-0.31582653522491455,
-0.46236252784729004,
0.29030704498291016,
0.1954175978899002,
0.1816188395023346,
-0.0865955650806427,
0.19255174696445465,
-0.07075422257184982,
-0.6069145798683167,
0.34884393215179443,
-0.6574895977973938,
0.5588127374649048,
0.32000914216041565,
-0.3417242467403412,
-0.04557791352272034,
-0.5829009413719177,
-0.02165856398642063,
0.2598119378089905,
0.06052397936582565,
-0.3894861936569214,
0.05372248589992523,
-0.1885530948638916,
0.04463908448815346,
0.1047591045498848,
-0.23826438188552856,
-0.010969899594783783,
-0.3872246742248535,
0.01949526183307171,
0.9771601557731628,
0.030161026865243912,
0.10701809823513031,
-0.7429699897766113,
0.41061314940452576,
-0.17609725892543793,
-0.003969717305153608,
0.06742404401302338,
-0.5235885381698608,
-0.8475949168205261,
-0.13110212981700897,
-0.08931177854537964,
0.6245832443237305,
-1.1182416677474976,
0.2784622311592102,
-0.08054787665605545,
-0.6083238124847412,
-0.6691958904266357,
-0.11785396933555603,
0.1703232228755951,
0.4891069233417511,
0.5639913082122803,
-0.009070799686014652,
-0.6689907312393188,
-0.6719068884849548,
-0.4889465272426605,
-0.07846177369356155,
-0.11677046865224838,
0.6775815486907959,
0.3212713599205017,
-0.6177086234092712,
0.6930474638938904,
-0.2988485097885132,
-0.32836711406707764,
-0.05501050874590874,
-0.045011039823293686,
0.0926862359046936,
0.29405033588409424,
0.11978374421596527,
-0.9975069761276245,
-0.2896744906902313,
-0.17470133304595947,
-0.7678908705711365,
-0.18388491868972778,
-0.419979065656662,
-0.2427241951227188,
0.42665448784828186,
0.3193567097187042,
-0.8028292059898376,
0.431087464094162,
0.40965259075164795,
-0.33248165249824524,
0.8187000751495361,
-0.3151612877845764,
0.20513705909252167,
-0.8911546468734741,
-0.06903806328773499,
-0.31279391050338745,
-0.2061939239501953,
-0.6223210692405701,
0.025355372577905655,
-0.3629215657711029,
-0.13418233394622803,
-0.1487657129764557,
0.6507554650306702,
-0.2899881899356842,
-0.09096118062734604,
-0.41183194518089294,
0.5779213905334473,
0.05310230702161789,
0.3266187310218811,
-0.038902461528778076,
0.9278964996337891,
0.1636705845594406,
-0.6649361252784729,
0.41566202044487,
0.29608747363090515,
-0.09299040585756302,
0.6939644813537598,
-0.5679660439491272,
0.5938841104507446,
-0.2727382481098175,
0.07440654933452606,
-0.8103142976760864,
-0.3312453031539917,
0.256368488073349,
-0.7098812460899353,
0.34376057982444763,
0.03553374856710434,
-0.5106818675994873,
-0.35829007625579834,
-0.3851926028728485,
-0.020812738686800003,
0.8412664532661438,
-0.8213969469070435,
0.7495823502540588,
0.5908756256103516,
0.037551410496234894,
-0.6700859665870667,
-0.5908302664756775,
0.3924137353897095,
-0.28743523359298706,
-0.45988014340400696,
0.19483418762683868,
-0.08382958173751831,
-0.5351381301879883,
-0.19184449315071106,
-0.12395519763231277,
0.12980733811855316,
-0.004760671406984329,
0.5707658529281616,
0.1650603711605072,
0.0774972066283226,
0.2728605270385742,
-0.11534798890352249,
0.1313229650259018,
0.1885872483253479,
-0.14560763537883759,
0.9102656245231628,
0.13064129650592804,
-0.42837610840797424,
-0.10893091559410095,
0.24759919941425323,
0.41934606432914734,
0.16522125899791718,
0.651948094367981,
0.509760856628418,
-0.48066624999046326,
-0.4188952147960663,
-1.0254063606262207,
-0.36311715841293335,
-0.5561788082122803,
0.32535356283187866,
-0.45254814624786377,
-0.6433691382408142,
0.5809239745140076,
-0.10451485961675644,
-0.028713537380099297,
0.3682304322719574,
0.5178952813148499,
-0.17162905633449554,
1.0145819187164307,
0.4899069666862488,
0.2763829529285431,
0.3931463360786438,
-0.02766989730298519,
0.2645990252494812,
-0.864984393119812,
-0.5003513097763062,
-0.5466728806495667,
-0.09239545464515686,
-0.7726716995239258,
-0.39413318037986755,
0.4767802655696869,
0.019547030329704285,
-0.19536393880844116,
0.06725171953439713,
-0.9391979575157166,
0.46072277426719666,
0.5949357748031616,
0.3698495626449585,
0.19853171706199646,
0.12330039590597153,
0.05774487182497978,
0.03491673991084099,
-0.6049460768699646,
-0.6254948377609253,
0.7356852293014526,
0.354087233543396,
0.9007980823516846,
-0.049892764538526535,
0.7119638919830322,
0.4020863473415375,
-0.013742093928158283,
-0.8305368423461914,
0.5792214870452881,
0.03595548868179321,
-0.6042627096176147,
-0.2500157952308655,
-0.5458546876907349,
-0.9793810248374939,
0.2899880111217499,
-0.23871032893657684,
-0.844262957572937,
0.09167516976594925,
-0.06697526574134827,
-0.3212919235229492,
0.4093327820301056,
-0.614539384841919,
0.30418509244918823,
-0.26065558195114136,
-0.41173118352890015,
-0.04258441552519798,
-0.46317070722579956,
0.36718645691871643,
-0.1800745278596878,
0.2521844506263733,
0.055521100759506226,
0.039128270000219345,
0.7631992697715759,
-0.2725938558578491,
0.7825457453727722,
-0.1694258600473404,
-0.159917414188385,
0.5629889965057373,
0.4298301637172699,
0.7284405827522278,
-0.05454039201140404,
0.015391861088573933,
0.03702710196375847,
-0.06700532138347626,
-0.14980226755142212,
-0.7102551460266113,
0.6746904850006104,
-0.7566318511962891,
-0.9057344794273376,
-0.47173890471458435,
-0.682037889957428,
-0.2949112057685852,
0.06101274862885475,
0.4426862895488739,
0.1966521143913269,
-0.055497847497463226,
-0.08053995668888092,
0.892284631729126,
-0.5050286650657654,
0.05817902088165283,
0.026128970086574554,
-0.4202132225036621,
-0.32988765835762024,
1.084384560585022,
0.25567391514778137,
0.27823325991630554,
-0.22852873802185059,
0.12326299399137497,
-0.2430408000946045,
-0.42301151156425476,
-0.37286901473999023,
0.21238170564174652,
-0.8226750493049622,
-0.2936462461948395,
-0.8728151321411133,
-0.5742480158805847,
-0.32721391320228577,
-0.1347890943288803,
-0.41056162118911743,
-0.31080061197280884,
-0.22926698625087738,
0.02479156292974949,
0.6786627173423767,
0.9563478231430054,
-0.19164887070655823,
0.0658508688211441,
-0.7587647438049316,
0.5132569074630737,
0.19169771671295166,
0.26198476552963257,
0.05977838113903999,
-0.8414667844772339,
0.07998819649219513,
0.19615212082862854,
-0.28132739663124084,
-0.7787542343139648,
0.4649744927883148,
-0.16189932823181152,
0.39425399899482727,
0.10109452158212662,
0.28515005111694336,
0.784519374370575,
-0.8229503035545349,
0.8152706623077393,
-0.10338453203439713,
-0.5600598454475403,
0.31478404998779297,
-0.1454630196094513,
0.05644068866968155,
0.4262830317020416,
0.5244928598403931,
-0.7195077538490295,
-0.6530632376670837,
-0.6690723299980164,
-0.7879352569580078,
0.30889612436294556,
0.03691130131483078,
0.5140308141708374,
-0.13291899859905243,
0.40387675166130066,
0.2866029143333435,
-0.0024777196813374758,
-0.6030285358428955,
-0.06636992841959,
-0.14218030869960785,
-0.14134332537651062,
0.43717095255851746,
-0.4666101038455963,
-0.03877287358045578,
0.19983342289924622,
0.7179139852523804,
0.18980920314788818,
0.4297442138195038,
0.3394506871700287,
-0.07370331883430481,
-0.05967194214463234,
0.048130426555871964,
0.6696199774742126,
0.4933019280433655,
0.008594240993261337,
0.32228466868400574,
0.34281861782073975,
-0.6930478811264038,
-0.0007429452380165458,
-0.02781454101204872,
-0.16639059782028198,
0.059431497007608414,
0.3076498508453369,
0.6665804386138916,
-0.16069874167442322,
-0.8621184825897217,
0.18980608880519867,
-0.009962355718016624,
-0.016954446211457253,
-0.6325415372848511,
0.10873030126094818,
-0.2918913960456848,
0.4705047905445099,
0.6078231930732727,
0.11412441730499268,
0.2550927698612213,
-0.5748780965805054,
0.4303227961063385,
0.6424073576927185,
-0.5875115990638733,
-0.05140703171491623,
0.4936407208442688,
-0.17324863374233246,
-0.8673696517944336,
0.7386298179626465,
-0.27692216634750366,
-0.8676104545593262,
0.2937330901622772,
0.6257969737052917,
0.8339376449584961,
-0.20151939988136292,
0.08873928338289261,
0.07868333905935287,
0.47264546155929565,
-0.17312434315681458,
0.09792974591255188,
0.0625365823507309,
-0.5533872842788696,
-0.2290339320898056,
-0.5322079658508301,
-0.5297263860702515,
0.07819545269012451,
-0.3476421535015106,
0.22471649944782257,
-0.33914700150489807,
-0.23405230045318604,
-0.4976080060005188,
-0.07242943346500397,
-0.38605427742004395,
-0.05479692667722702,
0.1654043048620224,
0.5866202712059021,
-0.25655022263526917,
0.4807584881782532,
0.09206517785787582,
-0.3232559561729431,
-0.4596607983112335,
0.16553565859794617,
-0.04401946812868118,
-0.9254776239395142,
0.47068291902542114,
0.2232033610343933,
-0.38493630290031433,
-0.16969525814056396,
-0.5913352370262146,
-0.6687526702880859,
0.6641404032707214,
0.07761089503765106,
-0.443264365196228,
-0.30449622869491577,
-0.02856678143143654,
0.5757692456245422,
0.06020226329565048,
0.19105921685695648,
0.5988344550132751,
0.39077430963516235,
0.3690018653869629,
-0.9844569563865662,
0.15116244554519653,
-0.012964599765837193,
-0.14681409299373627,
0.2614881098270416,
-0.4517301619052887,
0.6363053917884827,
-0.5129734873771667,
-0.5200477838516235,
0.14275814592838287,
0.5245542526245117,
0.44312208890914917,
0.31840643286705017,
0.31091493368148804,
0.42032143473625183,
1.0027010440826416,
-0.03024130128324032,
1.0208837985992432,
-0.11367424577474594,
-0.03854725882411003,
1.1807249784469604,
-0.2726340889930725,
0.734549880027771,
0.5512732267379761,
0.040424637496471405,
0.4147043228149414,
0.34058529138565063,
-0.163897305727005,
0.43424439430236816,
0.27724817395210266,
-0.06799071282148361,
-0.044267430901527405,
-0.3713388442993164,
-0.34257206320762634,
0.32016876339912415,
0.6227552890777588,
-0.11057940870523453,
0.031317565590143204,
0.2558211088180542,
0.1267402172088623,
0.37286871671676636,
-0.10023093223571777,
1.062197208404541,
0.30832594633102417,
-0.6872657537460327,
0.7395977973937988,
-0.40455806255340576,
0.7628591060638428,
-0.25391706824302673,
-0.3336654305458069,
-0.23750297725200653,
0.13572363555431366,
-0.2590485215187073,
-0.7161476612091064,
0.4261731207370758,
-0.004007664509117603,
0.21173438429832458,
0.14746356010437012,
0.9754638671875,
-0.23958609998226166,
-0.3537881374359131,
0.391872376203537,
0.4854975640773773,
0.4487387537956238,
-0.2025243639945984,
-0.4842343330383301,
0.2942110002040863,
-0.07288913428783417,
-0.2763400077819824,
0.13614320755004883,
0.7677206993103027,
0.0160953551530838,
0.976728081703186,
0.5641351342201233,
0.26743561029434204,
0.07590972632169724,
-0.0241316519677639,
0.9376704096794128,
-0.6141123175621033,
-0.09981419146060944,
-0.9723963141441345,
0.3600391447544098,
-0.22220323979854584,
0.03311670571565628,
0.7906157970428467,
0.3444552421569824,
0.6434873342514038,
0.24320214986801147,
0.5913415551185608,
0.09989599138498306,
0.7327059507369995,
-0.5624366402626038,
0.9779374003410339,
-0.4228888154029846,
0.3276972770690918,
-0.12018244713544846,
-0.8366467952728271,
-0.3412192165851593,
0.698698878288269,
-0.31683555245399475,
0.3247181475162506,
0.5225173830986023,
0.9876644611358643,
0.1559959352016449,
0.007153122685849667,
0.5946000814437866,
0.21352852880954742,
0.3484627902507782,
0.3710426390171051,
1.239175796508789,
-0.379116415977478,
0.7074804902076721,
-0.2366020232439041,
0.02248302474617958,
-0.27799445390701294,
-0.4559529721736908,
-1.1932064294815063,
-0.6870587468147278,
0.13096778094768524,
-0.8121881484985352,
0.37878236174583435,
0.9834444522857666,
0.4331013560295105,
-0.5005895495414734,
0.051711391657590866,
0.11845556646585464,
0.291302889585495,
0.2062910497188568,
-0.2746923863887787,
0.3932577669620514,
-0.7587986588478088,
-0.5464022159576416,
0.4381449520587921,
0.1436169147491455,
0.17639991641044617,
-0.3990503251552582,
-0.11567531526088715,
-0.09953849762678146,
0.3486505448818207,
0.6086663603782654,
0.06754349172115326,
-0.90177321434021,
-0.5862585306167603,
0.13190332055091858,
-0.2249642163515091,
0.12035412341356277,
0.5324873328208923,
-1.1150696277618408,
0.40765905380249023,
0.2524532079696655,
0.7782065272331238,
0.22768534719944,
0.0837615504860878,
0.46807530522346497,
-0.6144154071807861,
0.18488538265228271,
0.6115483641624451,
0.09445048123598099,
0.502108097076416,
-0.6820029020309448,
0.6133336424827576,
-0.0009494957630522549,
-0.7572212815284729,
-1.3172675371170044,
0.11420349776744843,
-0.4610426425933838,
-0.41603901982307434,
1.1171923875808716,
0.1973363757133484,
-0.19281212985515594,
-0.13029950857162476,
-0.6331718564033508,
0.17943306267261505,
-0.2715834975242615,
1.2863906621932983,
0.6291386485099792,
-0.08618158847093582,
-0.11070425063371658,
-0.7520642280578613,
0.8106188774108887,
0.31303659081459045,
-0.6820719838142395,
0.2721768617630005,
0.46732616424560547,
-0.3196253776550293,
0.56448894739151,
0.37590867280960083,
-0.05160190910100937,
0.12751375138759613,
0.3306339383125305,
-0.006531912833452225,
-0.03474016860127449,
-0.5990571975708008,
-0.3073647916316986,
0.09178776293992996,
0.19846415519714355,
0.07611034065485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01187v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01187v1
|
A Compositional Typed Semantics for Universal Dependencies
| 2024-03-02T11:58:24 | 2024-03-02T11:58:24 |
Laurestine Bradford, Timothy John O'Donnell, Siva Reddy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Languages may encode similar meanings using different sentence structures.
This makes it a challenge to provide a single set of formal rules that can
derive meanings from sentences in many languages at once. To overcome the
challenge, we can take advantage of language-general connections between
meaning and syntax, and build on cross-linguistically parallel syntactic
structures. We introduce UD Type Calculus, a compositional, principled, and
language-independent system of semantic types and logical forms for lexical
items which builds on a widely-used language-general dependency syntax
framework. We explain the essential features of UD Type Calculus, which all
involve giving dependency relations denotations just like those of words. These
allow UD-TC to derive correct meanings for sentences with a wide range of
syntactic structures by making use of dependency labels. Finally, we present
evaluation results on a large existing corpus of sentences and their logical
forms, showing that UD-TC can produce meanings comparable with our baseline.
|
[
-0.018416523933410645,
-0.524454653263092,
0.8686401844024658,
0.46279412508010864,
-0.08142241835594177,
0.11849423497915268,
0.0500783734023571,
-0.4574854075908661,
0.39763835072517395,
0.5443329215049744,
-0.3255797326564789,
-0.3773674964904785,
-0.4508275091648102,
0.15980786085128784,
-0.37533533573150635,
0.973576545715332,
-0.2842792868614197,
-0.0850796177983284,
-0.3160723149776459,
-0.37888744473457336,
-0.4804025888442993,
-0.5317699313163757,
0.10651008039712906,
-0.05119757354259491,
0.6682267189025879,
0.16856010258197784,
0.6887035965919495,
0.46752145886421204,
0.7898640036582947,
0.2813624441623688,
0.17334315180778503,
-0.45485296845436096,
-0.115786612033844,
0.2800382971763611,
-0.2929724454879761,
-0.5142215490341187,
-0.12852853536605835,
-0.09417761862277985,
0.7295310497283936,
1.0055118799209595,
-0.18289965391159058,
-0.1014033704996109,
-0.22156022489070892,
0.6853976845741272,
-0.8449712991714478,
0.6739664077758789,
-0.44389042258262634,
0.015745284035801888,
-0.3936207890510559,
0.03661563992500305,
-0.4310525357723236,
-0.28409260511398315,
0.5425429940223694,
-0.5789252519607544,
-0.29012545943260193,
-0.3586406111717224,
0.6237437725067139,
0.13356132805347443,
-0.7407809495925903,
-0.21568235754966736,
-0.7224938273429871,
0.5209179520606995,
-0.17875318229198456,
0.5163595676422119,
-0.006828032899647951,
0.24785484373569489,
-0.10099417716264725,
-0.7661033272743225,
-0.39389532804489136,
-0.48599186539649963,
-0.42394301295280457,
0.38677605986595154,
0.20052942633628845,
0.3538983464241028,
-0.004902247805148363,
0.38473138213157654,
-0.32084158062934875,
-0.10412421822547913,
-0.1837783306837082,
-0.21691744029521942,
0.24493934214115143,
0.3074655532836914,
0.8778042793273926,
-0.2485930472612381,
-0.4046822488307953,
0.3880714476108551,
-0.8813880085945129,
0.043134208768606186,
0.1896810084581375,
0.4783255159854889,
-0.45728161931037903,
0.7452648878097534,
-0.24302686750888824,
0.7205274105072021,
-0.43077030777931213,
-0.197187140583992,
-0.1199939101934433,
-0.2185942530632019,
-0.33112362027168274,
-0.11038994789123535,
0.5188999772071838,
-0.12386664748191833,
0.5030985474586487,
-0.6525370478630066,
0.1362086534500122,
0.348595529794693,
0.16620099544525146,
-0.6259235739707947,
-0.08580165356397629,
-0.05343957617878914,
-0.04960326850414276,
-0.16342328488826752,
0.3701480031013489,
-0.3427443206310272,
0.09424007683992386,
-0.7669540047645569,
0.405407190322876,
-0.27188095450401306,
-0.14697447419166565,
0.41340410709381104,
-0.09933296591043472,
0.19123241305351257,
0.3065711557865143,
-1.0563820600509644,
0.4594067335128784,
0.44630366563796997,
0.5918381214141846,
-0.21933427453041077,
-0.165441632270813,
-0.6659180521965027,
0.7409875392913818,
0.1376998871564865,
0.9460936188697815,
-0.7047044038772583,
-0.3757716119289398,
0.11785988509654999,
-0.29450422525405884,
-0.17370480298995972,
-0.2659943699836731,
0.4794233441352844,
-0.37688982486724854,
0.3881378769874573,
-0.274437814950943,
-0.7140478491783142,
-0.2505796253681183,
-0.18963518738746643,
-0.6746721267700195,
0.536587655544281,
0.568571150302887,
-0.8424298763275146,
0.3866428732872009,
-0.6056720018386841,
-1.0238916873931885,
0.5669941306114197,
-0.5903507471084595,
0.3302254378795624,
0.1380319595336914,
-0.5880380272865295,
0.2710793912410736,
-0.39988264441490173,
0.30231553316116333,
-0.3514019548892975,
0.1355980485677719,
-0.035348791629076004,
0.06846334040164948,
1.1937397718429565,
0.029972760006785393,
-0.5625020265579224,
-0.11981802433729172,
-1.082458257675171,
-0.1386786848306656,
-0.2524624466896057,
-0.6625229120254517,
-0.458121657371521,
0.226448193192482,
-0.020648499950766563,
0.07679102569818497,
0.19674474000930786,
-0.6304144859313965,
0.1591392308473587,
-0.34864383935928345,
0.5386607646942139,
0.784367561340332,
-0.07242071628570557,
0.4827755093574524,
-0.0493062324821949,
0.4355640411376953,
0.17279992997646332,
-0.047035571187734604,
0.1294596791267395,
-0.5018185377120972,
-0.7906790375709534,
-0.510391116142273,
0.014518560841679573,
0.6742894649505615,
-0.38594529032707214,
0.6726959347724915,
-0.048240430653095245,
0.031275954097509384,
-0.01485957857221365,
0.01585054025053978,
0.26739558577537537,
0.6541679501533508,
0.2494862675666809,
-0.24130459129810333,
-0.6197333931922913,
-0.7973335981369019,
0.10239177942276001,
-0.3712795376777649,
0.25605878233909607,
-0.06972721219062805,
0.35253259539604187,
-0.19185076653957367,
1.1515333652496338,
-0.781977117061615,
-0.4946337342262268,
-0.30031275749206543,
-0.13858996331691742,
-0.2636517286300659,
0.12610147893428802,
0.6195125579833984,
-0.6681893467903137,
-0.5268869400024414,
0.14845961332321167,
-0.8537436723709106,
-0.2127373367547989,
0.05429532006382942,
-0.36327096819877625,
0.16806255280971527,
0.207195445895195,
-0.6643406748771667,
0.5081859230995178,
0.14449933171272278,
-0.41574621200561523,
0.8306076526641846,
-0.08938560634851456,
-0.1488174945116043,
-0.8588320016860962,
0.10629519820213318,
-0.1295808106660843,
-0.1455804705619812,
-0.38984784483909607,
0.4057907164096832,
-0.2721182703971863,
0.23307238519191742,
-0.5503088235855103,
0.525029182434082,
-0.11019425839185715,
0.012670022435486317,
0.06866177171468735,
0.030675871297717094,
0.22820177674293518,
0.14661768078804016,
0.14627356827259064,
0.3757413923740387,
0.8593107461929321,
-0.7358291149139404,
0.8274275064468384,
0.3569243252277374,
-0.07132092118263245,
0.8607752323150635,
-0.5989124774932861,
-0.39277616143226624,
-0.12165863811969757,
0.2576198875904083,
-0.8004475831985474,
-0.16949431598186493,
0.11073672771453857,
-0.07811711728572845,
-0.06971864402294159,
-0.06958268582820892,
-0.672185480594635,
-0.2659705579280853,
0.06895583868026733,
0.26541292667388916,
0.0775376632809639,
-0.1878892481327057,
0.8146080374717712,
0.25898516178131104,
0.1407231241464615,
-0.3808976411819458,
-0.777108907699585,
-0.10802329331636429,
-0.18032312393188477,
-0.7703585028648376,
0.13317447900772095,
-0.0538865327835083,
-0.7225131392478943,
0.2858724892139435,
-0.20946502685546875,
-0.2766009271144867,
0.23784995079040527,
0.18713276088237762,
0.38920143246650696,
-0.2670154571533203,
0.38343098759651184,
0.00020112954371143132,
-0.1878402829170227,
0.16193807125091553,
-0.5901485681533813,
0.35092613101005554,
-0.14739277958869934,
-0.33767613768577576,
-0.29877084493637085,
0.6692121028900146,
0.4668513238430023,
-0.20334458351135254,
0.46332889795303345,
0.24646058678627014,
-0.2716444134712219,
-0.16175664961338043,
-0.35126781463623047,
0.066215880215168,
-0.42311570048332214,
0.007866475731134415,
-0.7945216298103333,
-1.1091982126235962,
0.6495831608772278,
0.5512362122535706,
0.04549037665128708,
0.6000773906707764,
0.6503626108169556,
0.04973088204860687,
0.4094527065753937,
0.7022199630737305,
-0.040571536868810654,
0.14986863732337952,
0.02780650556087494,
0.13707181811332703,
-0.3026959002017975,
-0.3201044499874115,
-0.6159576177597046,
0.004524167161434889,
-0.6411789059638977,
0.09787654131650925,
0.1778973639011383,
-0.014152668416500092,
-0.3594444692134857,
0.6836509108543396,
-0.31916823983192444,
0.3734833896160126,
0.6754381656646729,
-0.23597143590450287,
0.42183685302734375,
-0.06940604746341705,
-0.6636514067649841,
0.09166387468576431,
0.10244278609752655,
-0.17755688726902008,
0.9593396186828613,
-0.2577528655529022,
0.8770312070846558,
0.5157175660133362,
0.6563978791236877,
0.3376922309398651,
0.04722163453698158,
-0.9140435457229614,
0.5621734261512756,
-0.6153716444969177,
-0.5885884165763855,
0.2067711502313614,
-0.5643025636672974,
-0.7473374009132385,
0.051237739622592926,
0.05415847525000572,
-1.061943769454956,
-0.15974454581737518,
-0.3060514032840729,
-0.20270058512687683,
0.23142097890377045,
-0.9596593976020813,
0.7143343091011047,
-0.15680640935897827,
0.19219030439853668,
-0.09489960223436356,
-0.6802873611450195,
0.34685102105140686,
0.11023398488759995,
-0.2926461696624756,
-0.12060811370611191,
0.15587162971496582,
0.42040157318115234,
-0.48012301325798035,
0.8445437550544739,
0.2179594784975052,
-0.23255963623523712,
0.549307644367218,
0.5754647850990295,
-0.004222123418003321,
0.2379048764705658,
0.3118759095668793,
-0.289570689201355,
0.33455684781074524,
-0.3369215726852417,
-0.6915435194969177,
0.5840678811073303,
-0.7394412159919739,
-0.5469464063644409,
-0.2422427237033844,
-0.7117435336112976,
-0.3496125042438507,
0.5056677460670471,
0.0935811921954155,
0.8480135798454285,
-0.1452023684978485,
-0.1281842291355133,
0.30977821350097656,
0.17704689502716064,
0.5363930463790894,
0.6007601022720337,
-0.23685340583324432,
-0.3060327470302582,
0.7328665852546692,
-0.06284037232398987,
0.5756153464317322,
1.1246777772903442,
0.19431710243225098,
-0.48878273367881775,
0.03532090410590172,
-0.29647505283355713,
0.23323532938957214,
-0.8598008155822754,
-0.09844046831130981,
-0.8135204911231995,
-0.34173154830932617,
-0.6433598399162292,
-0.43372324109077454,
-0.02684013545513153,
-0.8296859860420227,
-0.2763933837413788,
-0.30071839690208435,
0.54402756690979,
0.9692412614822388,
-0.181627094745636,
0.14179635047912598,
-0.8535968065261841,
0.452160507440567,
0.6825745105743408,
0.4869559705257416,
-0.3530677258968353,
-0.03623126074671745,
0.005715603474527597,
-0.17575834691524506,
-0.35951197147369385,
-0.5600869655609131,
-0.14862747490406036,
0.22327877581119537,
0.6611505746841431,
0.5393179059028625,
-0.09063557535409927,
0.3547065854072571,
-0.4300033152103424,
0.45106247067451477,
0.4114033877849579,
-1.1506257057189941,
0.5666438937187195,
-0.511902391910553,
-0.014008235186338425,
0.5331264138221741,
0.26564744114875793,
-0.6377816796302795,
-0.6732205748558044,
-0.6629194021224976,
-0.40492895245552063,
0.3533386290073395,
0.0890253409743309,
-0.039027921855449677,
-0.26795706152915955,
0.4596402049064636,
0.10378962010145187,
0.012930790893733501,
-0.937361478805542,
-0.39305686950683594,
-0.01184081844985485,
-0.4312533438205719,
0.33772069215774536,
-0.10300377756357193,
-0.23695607483386993,
-0.1713363081216812,
0.06027167662978172,
-0.0008386048139072955,
0.18485397100448608,
0.0015432067448273301,
-0.42889609932899475,
0.17091259360313416,
0.43995726108551025,
0.6638147830963135,
0.6703981161117554,
-0.29056188464164734,
0.6045728325843811,
-0.6220709681510925,
-0.5899431705474854,
0.4143694341182709,
0.13060151040554047,
-0.4203297197818756,
-0.20111070573329926,
0.15748895704746246,
0.4202476739883423,
0.24870750308036804,
-0.5335253477096558,
0.27457305788993835,
0.35190311074256897,
-0.055928099900484085,
0.08072049170732498,
-0.0234054122120142,
0.4140253961086273,
-0.2375209778547287,
-0.09869116544723511,
-0.0826987475156784,
0.37800729274749756,
-0.8283978700637817,
0.6699914932250977,
0.19152776896953583,
-0.5505625605583191,
-0.5967734456062317,
0.6172098517417908,
0.2961186170578003,
0.3171703517436981,
0.4241846203804016,
-0.22921714186668396,
-0.4257069230079651,
0.46803197264671326,
0.6872240304946899,
1.0500202178955078,
0.009104156866669655,
0.751911461353302,
-0.02982383966445923,
-0.05855207517743111,
0.0489593967795372,
0.37772613763809204,
0.027117975056171417,
-0.8540703058242798,
-0.6058301329612732,
-0.7575280070304871,
-0.3817474842071533,
-0.37330135703086853,
-0.5448930859565735,
0.29839080572128296,
-0.49544793367385864,
0.4205334186553955,
0.2227390557527542,
-0.4261598587036133,
-0.5760098695755005,
0.20153307914733887,
0.06053262576460838,
0.35417863726615906,
-0.7040244340896606,
0.693328857421875,
0.9355785250663757,
-1.0659019947052002,
-0.980021059513092,
-0.2970154583454132,
0.11888505518436432,
-0.8922427296638489,
1.3010262250900269,
0.14598152041435242,
-0.20530429482460022,
0.06234334781765938,
-0.07032406330108643,
-0.7961326241493225,
0.5899885892868042,
0.5633890628814697,
-0.12730075418949127,
-0.21856315433979034,
0.7767282128334045,
0.5225911736488342,
-0.6496006846427917,
0.23961849510669708,
0.7054257392883301,
0.5581568479537964,
0.062225304543972015,
-0.8101933002471924,
0.30364277958869934,
0.20675675570964813,
0.054982732981443405,
0.5013834834098816,
-0.36198690533638,
0.6332862377166748,
-0.21727459132671356,
-0.45166003704071045,
-0.0003097749431617558,
0.4865233600139618,
-0.11383650451898575,
-0.4270809292793274,
0.24919791519641876,
1.1494327783584595,
0.21930643916130066,
-0.12835587561130524,
0.7285852432250977,
-0.061250872910022736,
0.34761515259742737,
1.0491310358047485,
-0.2610678970813751,
0.5202500224113464,
0.13817204535007477,
-0.44191601872444153,
0.9186350107192993,
0.11627822369337082,
0.19629542529582977,
0.42124053835868835,
0.5401416420936584,
-0.7733760476112366,
-0.20954079926013947,
-0.26576465368270874,
-0.19669954478740692,
0.6365169882774353,
0.31045329570770264,
-0.032265886664390564,
-0.8094703555107117,
0.03931349888443947,
-0.012682614848017693,
0.1421738564968109,
-0.062249526381492615,
0.7431634068489075,
0.25743117928504944,
-0.38028010725975037,
0.1563226580619812,
-0.47605931758880615,
0.29478245973587036,
-0.5024279952049255,
0.1339794397354126,
-0.14045089483261108,
0.04933224990963936,
-0.241375133395195,
-1.0227110385894775,
0.46435391902923584,
-0.2628246247768402,
-0.13287325203418732,
-0.06524593383073807,
0.34537720680236816,
-0.28917041420936584,
-0.5256456136703491,
0.5364131927490234,
0.5759519934654236,
-0.1563798040151596,
0.0767807587981224,
-0.30208706855773926,
-0.39463165402412415,
-0.15696090459823608,
0.27812790870666504,
0.23330147564411163,
0.7217231392860413,
0.08569557964801788,
0.6396275758743286,
0.13544747233390808,
0.14054663479328156,
0.2445373833179474,
0.5419696569442749,
0.5830727815628052,
-0.7868334650993347,
-0.5216614007949829,
-0.6227976083755493,
0.6522244215011597,
0.4853207767009735,
-0.3347896635532379,
0.2127184271812439,
0.43552717566490173,
0.6863389015197754,
0.012546034529805183,
0.8574534058570862,
-0.5685353875160217,
0.14376163482666016,
-0.38629451394081116,
0.2629368007183075,
-0.3160421550273895,
-0.15521836280822754,
-0.23949015140533447,
-1.101859211921692,
-0.823201596736908,
0.1790173202753067,
-0.14255200326442719,
-0.40372586250305176,
1.1765055656433105,
0.122212253510952,
-0.03183476999402046,
0.06914345175027847,
0.34523865580558777,
0.05355001613497734,
0.590712308883667,
0.6018251776695251,
0.7776467800140381,
0.09221738576889038,
0.6402842998504639,
-0.12559892237186432,
-0.17947545647621155,
0.10211364924907684,
-0.6121782064437866,
-0.5124484300613403,
-0.8980064392089844,
-0.4011800289154053,
-0.32867002487182617,
-0.26184898614883423,
0.5201981067657471,
0.3487979471683502,
-0.8679726123809814,
-0.3814338743686676,
-0.6559938192367554,
0.2360534816980362,
0.18471898138523102,
-0.39085087180137634,
0.3542782664299011,
-0.7880300283432007,
-0.3733575940132141,
0.039461009204387665,
0.9125264286994934,
0.2254934161901474,
-0.21337468922138214,
0.28839945793151855,
-0.16290158033370972,
-0.06386909633874893,
0.932296872138977,
0.4227087199687958,
-0.7546447515487671,
-0.9313511252403259,
-0.17713898420333862,
-0.3425807058811188,
0.15748724341392517,
1.0763771533966064,
-0.6278154850006104,
0.3782523572444916,
0.7045719027519226,
0.6052348017692566,
0.0181284099817276,
-0.45179483294487,
0.6801390051841736,
-0.4115687608718872,
0.31009894609451294,
0.14287671446800232,
0.7044993042945862,
0.03689193353056908,
-0.1853095442056656,
0.5413235425949097,
0.7250986099243164,
-0.33972233533859253,
-0.18245084583759308,
0.9507123231887817,
-1.640803337097168,
0.026370162144303322,
1.1647049188613892,
-0.37450239062309265,
0.15273213386535645,
-0.33305391669273376,
0.10991527885198593,
-0.027075836434960365,
-0.22434906661510468,
0.5713699460029602,
0.6031537652015686,
-0.15359295904636383,
0.12577776610851288,
-0.053989753127098083,
0.2433897852897644,
0.14207521080970764,
-1.1252721548080444,
-0.1206875666975975,
0.7016819715499878,
0.5223211646080017,
0.23306170105934143,
0.6427172422409058,
-0.2516443133354187,
0.10206304490566254,
-0.18884935975074768,
0.20640210807323456,
0.46640685200691223,
-0.33326882123947144,
0.4488615095615387,
0.024868881329894066,
-0.21701420843601227,
-0.07354816049337387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01185v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01185v1
|
Balancing Exploration and Exploitation in LLM using Soft RLLF for Enhanced Negation Understanding
| 2024-03-02T11:54:55 | 2024-03-02T11:54:55 |
Ha-Thanh Nguyen, Ken Satoh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Finetuning approaches in NLP often focus on exploitation rather than
exploration, which may lead to suboptimal models. Given the vast search space
of natural language, this limited exploration can restrict their performance in
complex, high-stakes domains, where accurate negation understanding and logical
reasoning abilities are crucial. To address this issue, we leverage
Reinforcement Learning from Logical Feedback (RLLF) to create an effective
balance between exploration and exploitation in LLMs. Our approach employs an
appropriate benchmark dataset for training and evaluation, highlighting the
importance of exploration in enhancing negation understanding capabilities. We
compare the performance of our RLLF-enhanced LLMs with baseline models trained
without RLLF, demonstrating the value of this balanced approach. Furthermore,
we showcase the potential of our method in legal AI applications by employing
transfer learning and evaluating its impact on negation understanding. Our
experimental results exhibit the effectiveness of balancing exploration and
exploitation with RLLF in improving LLMs' negation capabilities. This has
implications for the development of more accurate, reliable, and logically
consistent language models in high-stakes domains.
|
[
-0.24760685861110687,
-0.9434923529624939,
0.3978224992752075,
0.27057087421417236,
-0.18221428990364075,
-0.010252585634589195,
-0.35632675886154175,
-0.4919089376926422,
0.12279430031776428,
0.846377432346344,
-0.7697039842605591,
-0.5284207463264465,
-0.7140105962753296,
0.11579461395740509,
-0.2038939744234085,
1.2731519937515259,
0.13880254328250885,
-0.002404743805527687,
-0.4348796606063843,
-0.5400973558425903,
-1.0359385013580322,
-0.4090847373008728,
-0.7159230709075928,
-0.8576246500015259,
0.45346716046333313,
0.38129115104675293,
0.7773932218551636,
0.3788316547870636,
0.3983357846736908,
0.3167016804218292,
-0.13080601394176483,
0.2636120021343231,
-0.7473819851875305,
0.17845748364925385,
-0.6367530822753906,
-0.5063841938972473,
-0.3286227881908417,
0.011432361789047718,
0.47076666355133057,
0.6737561821937561,
-0.596662163734436,
-0.06812281906604767,
-0.05711253732442856,
0.7756088972091675,
-0.607126772403717,
0.06296109408140182,
-0.6121534705162048,
0.4068651497364044,
0.20193195343017578,
-0.2957276403903961,
-0.3838242292404175,
-0.20676541328430176,
0.4961007833480835,
-0.7924687266349792,
-0.169329434633255,
0.007162468042224646,
0.7554930448532104,
0.45764487981796265,
-0.48111194372177124,
-0.19571344554424286,
-0.5964016318321228,
0.762152373790741,
-0.7119462490081787,
0.3068993389606476,
0.157334566116333,
0.22014202177524567,
-0.3063414394855499,
-0.6388393044471741,
-0.4253630042076111,
-0.5335574150085449,
-0.1648855060338974,
0.19396184384822845,
-0.16979867219924927,
0.24912936985492706,
0.3717719316482544,
-0.047162603586912155,
-0.2631448209285736,
0.4181886315345764,
-0.41310638189315796,
-0.31499457359313965,
0.7840489149093628,
0.15894879400730133,
0.1754995435476303,
0.05369313806295395,
-0.5944235920906067,
-0.06723188608884811,
-0.7113006114959717,
0.18435849249362946,
0.4293294847011566,
0.3364203870296478,
0.050794146955013275,
0.6650170087814331,
-0.10905255377292633,
0.7660134434700012,
0.05264656990766525,
-0.1100815087556839,
0.34664925932884216,
-0.20006859302520752,
-0.3058326542377472,
0.09817968308925629,
0.5046610236167908,
0.44945353269577026,
0.3271048665046692,
-0.19413356482982635,
-0.6734694838523865,
-0.05917884409427643,
0.509712815284729,
-0.6188564300537109,
0.13030685484409332,
0.02213890478014946,
-0.39777329564094543,
-0.4467601180076599,
-0.03681502118706703,
-0.7815598845481873,
-0.7435846328735352,
-0.4706399440765381,
0.547563910484314,
-0.4696844518184662,
-0.3803432285785675,
0.39679211378097534,
-0.15753667056560516,
0.5191183686256409,
0.4522497355937958,
-0.7895358204841614,
0.5902956128120422,
0.9049620628356934,
0.4120517373085022,
-0.27236056327819824,
-0.2374277114868164,
-1.0899866819381714,
-0.13925974071025848,
-0.26993057131767273,
0.4952245354652405,
-0.42002546787261963,
-0.28927186131477356,
0.1225910484790802,
-0.2737310528755188,
-0.08129659295082092,
-0.8538979291915894,
0.7818363904953003,
-0.5530096888542175,
0.1407831460237503,
0.2370438277721405,
-0.4533637762069702,
-0.6222381591796875,
0.5115634799003601,
-0.6521309018135071,
0.9097738265991211,
0.09330878406763077,
-0.4096359610557556,
0.5357276797294617,
-0.6005698442459106,
-0.6873088479042053,
0.08262782543897629,
-0.3015557825565338,
-0.4140605628490448,
0.11382085084915161,
0.26250219345092773,
0.197704017162323,
-0.12370046973228455,
0.5079318881034851,
-0.2190316915512085,
-0.34434202313423157,
0.3689912259578705,
-0.34978005290031433,
0.6249120831489563,
-0.015816526487469673,
-0.6383838653564453,
0.49889883399009705,
-0.5073510408401489,
-0.03137707710266113,
0.11106663942337036,
-0.40841391682624817,
-0.22796094417572021,
0.19550858438014984,
-0.052342887967824936,
0.2662564814090729,
0.03685227036476135,
-0.299330472946167,
-0.09919141978025436,
-0.7136580348014832,
0.2688477337360382,
0.815257728099823,
0.01557321846485138,
0.44792458415031433,
-0.34413525462150574,
0.8835161924362183,
-0.1575191766023636,
-0.07786078006029129,
0.26098617911338806,
-0.2582642436027527,
-0.8380776643753052,
-0.013730335049331188,
0.369462251663208,
0.7882941961288452,
-0.6088317036628723,
0.34871238470077515,
-0.18234625458717346,
-0.0012231660075485706,
-0.636724054813385,
0.4527148902416229,
0.39754518866539,
0.8190602660179138,
0.5993814468383789,
-0.3032868802547455,
-0.5433091521263123,
-0.8787088394165039,
-0.4540601968765259,
-0.0023390487767755985,
0.2860015034675598,
0.6366394758224487,
0.35452982783317566,
-0.40148940682411194,
0.9671165943145752,
-0.13617900013923645,
-0.5732883810997009,
-0.6744535565376282,
0.2689049541950226,
0.4867226779460907,
0.48851627111434937,
0.36650869250297546,
-0.8782050013542175,
-0.14492382109165192,
-0.04032266139984131,
-0.6792559027671814,
-0.2863399088382721,
-0.5028600692749023,
-0.1657656878232956,
0.1636722981929779,
0.6524955630302429,
-0.5547559857368469,
0.38823920488357544,
0.18859398365020752,
-0.4622471332550049,
0.3343029022216797,
-0.21947228908538818,
-0.1786564290523529,
-0.24234192073345184,
-0.027454758062958717,
0.0807216688990593,
-0.6212670207023621,
-0.5071063041687012,
0.26942574977874756,
0.0025292541831731796,
0.13413527607917786,
-0.7428554892539978,
0.4219551682472229,
-0.2677856683731079,
-0.12407491356134415,
-0.40881848335266113,
0.6407995223999023,
-0.05179973691701889,
0.5488293170928955,
0.032573554664850235,
0.539756178855896,
0.373023122549057,
-0.6534734964370728,
0.3235006630420685,
-0.010100006125867367,
-0.09180033951997757,
0.5303571820259094,
-0.7039135694503784,
0.0073466310277581215,
-0.19281046092510223,
0.1700981855392456,
-0.4549730718135834,
0.2604716420173645,
0.2604067921638489,
-0.3506785035133362,
0.466543585062027,
-0.313874214887619,
-0.2814735770225525,
-0.05783430114388466,
-0.3653051555156708,
0.14956548810005188,
0.572597324848175,
-0.5556800365447998,
0.8616548776626587,
0.3764421045780182,
-0.02163304202258587,
-0.9666322469711304,
-0.6532336473464966,
0.059939268976449966,
-0.5072126984596252,
-0.6083795428276062,
0.31161898374557495,
0.27066564559936523,
-0.3903961479663849,
0.2356756031513214,
-0.21768076717853546,
0.2567427158355713,
0.4309424161911011,
0.19035714864730835,
0.3651309907436371,
-0.17072921991348267,
-0.06515147536993027,
-0.18515869975090027,
-0.23295986652374268,
0.4203658699989319,
-0.4053140878677368,
0.4428180158138275,
-0.2760842442512512,
-0.24095556139945984,
-0.23123973608016968,
0.010716987773776054,
0.1467462033033371,
-0.3237057030200958,
0.5828464031219482,
0.52434241771698,
-0.3339359164237976,
-0.5543296337127686,
-0.4609138071537018,
-0.23987625539302826,
-0.44727927446365356,
0.40870290994644165,
-0.13548725843429565,
-1.1251431703567505,
0.3430755138397217,
-0.22772526741027832,
0.08737531304359436,
0.6421079635620117,
0.323788046836853,
0.00031707933521829545,
0.8347197771072388,
0.8549322485923767,
-0.11363834887742996,
0.3298355042934418,
-0.22297583520412445,
0.06880764663219452,
-0.7002398371696472,
-0.363459050655365,
-0.19709797203540802,
-0.4505573511123657,
-0.5993568897247314,
-0.2597532868385315,
0.10068484395742416,
0.16484171152114868,
-0.0568147711455822,
0.10711166262626648,
-0.21160005033016205,
0.5458000898361206,
0.4895617961883545,
0.2031014859676361,
0.2550621032714844,
0.006904556881636381,
-0.34485137462615967,
-0.15869951248168945,
-0.8184503316879272,
-0.2605878412723541,
1.10207998752594,
0.44084489345550537,
0.9136643409729004,
0.20032550394535065,
0.7131267786026001,
0.337502121925354,
0.30013594031333923,
-0.9617228507995605,
0.5866332650184631,
0.05166523903608322,
-0.2417493313550949,
-0.3861236870288849,
-0.5313229560852051,
-0.8607550263404846,
0.5313192009925842,
-0.6281131505966187,
-0.4730733633041382,
0.11786621063947678,
0.14151506125926971,
-0.5341506600379944,
0.09646511822938919,
-0.617084801197052,
0.8567565083503723,
-0.46747905015945435,
-0.831079363822937,
-0.6667576432228088,
-0.5894800424575806,
0.49112430214881897,
0.3145357072353363,
0.3017505407333374,
0.0412626639008522,
-0.1884516030550003,
0.7377601265907288,
-0.2948233187198639,
0.8569865822792053,
-0.3310285806655884,
-0.14499060809612274,
0.3252231478691101,
0.15603981912136078,
0.5757986903190613,
0.3718547523021698,
-0.007409039419144392,
-0.20327261090278625,
-0.5152367353439331,
-0.19425587356090546,
-0.7399519085884094,
0.6589353084564209,
-0.6641451716423035,
-0.8804716467857361,
-0.7282055020332336,
-0.4350045621395111,
-0.11339040100574493,
0.25453516840934753,
-0.2842249274253845,
0.04697928950190544,
-0.05738374590873718,
0.2206604778766632,
0.929897129535675,
-0.32466503977775574,
0.19774997234344482,
0.5591461062431335,
-0.30142930150032043,
-0.4489588141441345,
0.8057289123535156,
-0.09922129660844803,
0.19778257608413696,
0.307380735874176,
0.3034231960773468,
-0.5001344680786133,
-0.7466755509376526,
-0.25168585777282715,
0.16686567664146423,
-0.7501903176307678,
-0.32717713713645935,
-0.5960263609886169,
-0.24148274958133698,
-0.2908211052417755,
-0.06933881342411041,
-0.1009717807173729,
-0.32796600461006165,
-0.2037358582019806,
-0.38625386357307434,
0.41645243763923645,
0.6514753103256226,
-0.29222577810287476,
0.09216108918190002,
-0.5394649505615234,
0.4019586741924286,
0.3683982193470001,
0.28885185718536377,
-0.16812483966350555,
-0.6496192812919617,
-0.08089045435190201,
-0.1017385795712471,
-0.23493757843971252,
-0.807266354560852,
0.41835999488830566,
0.1525842249393463,
0.8387117981910706,
0.08853448927402496,
-0.007375148590654135,
0.5941995978355408,
-0.2207152545452118,
0.38359251618385315,
0.08821167796850204,
-0.9131293892860413,
0.571473240852356,
-0.19355903565883636,
0.05314906686544418,
0.7856022119522095,
0.029368184506893158,
-0.5584682822227478,
-0.1398680955171585,
-0.7372074127197266,
-1.1253252029418945,
0.8941999673843384,
-0.028006521984934807,
0.05043568089604378,
0.4173343777656555,
0.391584187746048,
0.11400143802165985,
0.2725151777267456,
-1.2219284772872925,
-0.027351200580596924,
-0.0009002505103126168,
0.019904853776097298,
0.0810745432972908,
-0.07363767176866531,
-0.4324618875980377,
-0.1824202537536621,
0.8275811076164246,
-0.2034856230020523,
-0.06288126856088638,
0.28148093819618225,
-0.6037142872810364,
0.04532209038734436,
0.24897080659866333,
0.5259563326835632,
0.6196098327636719,
-0.11013705283403397,
0.153671532869339,
0.5300493836402893,
-0.2998979687690735,
-0.08331990242004395,
0.16482405364513397,
-0.14567767083644867,
-0.3443979322910309,
0.6129540205001831,
0.8305925130844116,
0.1351105123758316,
-1.077639102935791,
0.5679296255111694,
0.036373402923345566,
-0.5807124972343445,
-0.24785307049751282,
0.4306963086128235,
0.06823418289422989,
0.4557647407054901,
0.08548296242952347,
0.07290871441364288,
0.1467936784029007,
-0.4092269539833069,
0.3621980547904968,
0.4449980556964874,
-0.5413548350334167,
0.29209601879119873,
0.33277708292007446,
0.15418775379657745,
-0.31519025564193726,
0.8932476043701172,
-0.3137299120426178,
-0.7125821709632874,
0.8679636120796204,
0.5732216835021973,
0.8185125589370728,
0.4486480951309204,
0.15054984390735626,
0.12367668002843857,
0.6209266781806946,
0.18531154096126556,
0.32903552055358887,
-0.08301234990358353,
-0.7232798933982849,
-0.6975154876708984,
-0.24762709438800812,
-0.4488217234611511,
0.22292618453502655,
-0.48918893933296204,
0.3557109236717224,
-0.745647132396698,
0.0995432659983635,
-0.42736852169036865,
0.1302335113286972,
-0.6121336221694946,
0.13977091014385223,
0.10305535048246384,
0.8962273001670837,
-0.5842316746711731,
0.5977124571800232,
0.6091501712799072,
-0.46087661385536194,
-0.6369208097457886,
-0.08057348430156708,
-0.030548453330993652,
-0.8388071060180664,
0.7907634377479553,
0.3680821359157562,
-0.321291446685791,
-0.21786093711853027,
-0.6298876404762268,
-0.6369117498397827,
1.191189169883728,
0.32865092158317566,
-0.4309893548488617,
0.45153695344924927,
0.044659506529569626,
0.5887930989265442,
-0.387676477432251,
0.178569495677948,
0.697670578956604,
0.504814624786377,
-0.09146390855312347,
-0.47565391659736633,
0.10522858798503876,
-0.2386888712644577,
-0.20276346802711487,
0.04956544190645218,
-0.3871460258960724,
0.46086809039115906,
-0.31331127882003784,
-0.1458437740802765,
-0.3844274878501892,
0.919413149356842,
0.39447346329689026,
0.3276287019252777,
0.8691222667694092,
0.7439271211624146,
0.6281085014343262,
0.07164762169122696,
0.7337774038314819,
0.05016179755330086,
0.17690205574035645,
1.38286554813385,
-0.3520738184452057,
0.7027080059051514,
0.602828323841095,
0.0387381836771965,
0.41808459162712097,
0.5177009701728821,
0.08030975610017776,
0.4569809138774872,
0.7242866158485413,
-0.16004279255867004,
-0.19811829924583435,
-0.3134804368019104,
-0.12138712406158447,
0.20286233723163605,
0.5869871377944946,
-0.04713653773069382,
-0.33097654581069946,
-0.02571789175271988,
0.0318499393761158,
0.520548403263092,
-0.34456369280815125,
0.9860053658485413,
0.0036997455172240734,
-0.8345102667808533,
0.43895861506462097,
0.2717714011669159,
0.975595235824585,
-0.5078418850898743,
-0.3260309398174286,
-0.37549278140068054,
0.14148035645484924,
-0.409846693277359,
-0.8573411703109741,
0.28286752104759216,
0.05490424111485481,
0.2578107416629791,
-0.5788593888282776,
0.9531264901161194,
-0.3297300338745117,
-0.20159798860549927,
0.7700117826461792,
0.41042599081993103,
-0.20758818089962006,
0.3466067910194397,
-0.8823872804641724,
-0.2998236417770386,
0.036634135991334915,
-0.10746875405311584,
0.18287083506584167,
0.5340920090675354,
-0.02921062335371971,
0.7021599411964417,
0.6495913863182068,
0.11647329479455948,
0.1559927761554718,
0.24400001764297485,
0.9025732278823853,
-0.7378383874893188,
-0.43358665704727173,
-0.9654967188835144,
0.3992885649204254,
-0.10131014883518219,
-0.34816834330558777,
0.3871866762638092,
0.3750019371509552,
0.8854027986526489,
0.17284350097179413,
0.6303406953811646,
0.04611564055085182,
0.18076196312904358,
-0.8813872337341309,
0.41325825452804565,
-0.4951149821281433,
0.4067588448524475,
-0.032861821353435516,
-0.7461407780647278,
-0.29493728280067444,
0.8205080628395081,
-0.3017216920852661,
-0.057248011231422424,
0.49303433299064636,
0.7905436754226685,
-0.17580750584602356,
-0.08176187425851822,
0.15118837356567383,
0.2893657684326172,
0.3369700610637665,
0.643710196018219,
0.9587429165840149,
-0.04785916581749916,
0.4673425853252411,
-0.25297993421554565,
-0.26170116662979126,
-0.3527456223964691,
-1.1592260599136353,
-0.772127091884613,
0.1759236454963684,
-0.217494398355484,
-0.47321152687072754,
0.1710377335548401,
1.1359187364578247,
0.5528464913368225,
-0.6123470664024353,
-0.4840277433395386,
-0.4256998300552368,
0.4490101933479309,
-0.39344748854637146,
-0.2669580578804016,
0.048483557999134064,
-0.7238958477973938,
-0.41231080889701843,
0.7023782134056091,
0.274630069732666,
-0.15967467427253723,
-0.35678794980049133,
-0.4161159098148346,
-0.6152209043502808,
-0.00868732389062643,
0.4677242636680603,
0.4129995107650757,
-0.3833194077014923,
-0.09111437201499939,
-0.06160903722047806,
0.009819290600717068,
-0.05614852160215378,
0.8096153140068054,
-1.1090517044067383,
0.2140112668275833,
0.5556597709655762,
1.2472310066223145,
0.6281003952026367,
-0.2650907039642334,
0.8426346182823181,
-0.5013411641120911,
0.21851062774658203,
0.43261900544166565,
0.3098011612892151,
0.14645177125930786,
-0.4641709327697754,
0.7350373864173889,
0.22186492383480072,
-0.2417098879814148,
-0.5605248212814331,
0.14135514199733734,
-0.7331967353820801,
-0.21488645672798157,
1.0513056516647339,
-0.049640435725450516,
-0.08593824505805969,
0.10788266360759735,
-0.18505331873893738,
0.08057040721178055,
-0.4391603469848633,
0.4846096634864807,
0.7177994251251221,
-0.3154951333999634,
-0.09038321673870087,
-0.8741797804832458,
0.44067540764808655,
1.1301485300064087,
-0.7774983048439026,
-0.1363794505596161,
0.4450557827949524,
0.056600332260131836,
-0.03705328702926636,
0.48775532841682434,
-0.04411879554390907,
0.2824491858482361,
-0.4755368232727051,
-0.21988119184970856,
-0.04033585637807846,
-0.3652658760547638,
-0.8059206008911133,
0.07284201681613922,
0.06748565286397934,
0.08446019142866135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01166v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01166v2
|
DINER: Debiasing Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis with Multi-variable Causal Inference
| 2024-03-02T10:38:31 | 2024-06-06T07:27:33 |
Jialong Wu, Linhai Zhang, Deyu Zhou, Guoqiang Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Though notable progress has been made, neural-based aspect-based sentiment
analysis (ABSA) models are prone to learn spurious correlations from annotation
biases, resulting in poor robustness on adversarial data transformations. Among
the debiasing solutions, causal inference-based methods have attracted much
research attention, which can be mainly categorized into causal intervention
methods and counterfactual reasoning methods. However, most of the present
debiasing methods focus on single-variable causal inference, which is not
suitable for ABSA with two input variables (the target aspect and the review).
In this paper, we propose a novel framework based on multi-variable causal
inference for debiasing ABSA. In this framework, different types of biases are
tackled based on different causal intervention methods. For the review branch,
the bias is modeled as indirect confounding from context, where backdoor
adjustment intervention is employed for debiasing. For the aspect branch, the
bias is described as a direct correlation with labels, where counterfactual
reasoning is adopted for debiasing. Extensive experiments demonstrate the
effectiveness of the proposed method compared to various baselines on the two
widely used real-world aspect robustness test set datasets.
|
[
-0.4858507812023163,
-1.3282591104507446,
0.8120768070220947,
0.4519040584564209,
-0.33384808897972107,
-0.4857269525527954,
0.19486567378044128,
-0.09276200830936432,
0.39912542700767517,
0.5247406363487244,
-0.7141437530517578,
-0.6033011078834534,
-0.31589075922966003,
0.09811840951442719,
-0.033682651817798615,
0.7666525840759277,
0.2106928527355194,
0.5006090402603149,
-0.2330273687839508,
-0.35322362184524536,
-0.6927191615104675,
-0.5020820498466492,
-0.5787134170532227,
-0.2735603153705597,
0.7008140683174133,
0.3618660867214203,
0.5122291445732117,
-0.04409278184175491,
0.3805181086063385,
0.19505000114440918,
0.004217730835080147,
0.13508741557598114,
-0.07856369018554688,
0.31108880043029785,
-0.4406535029411316,
-0.33475935459136963,
-0.4050518870353699,
0.17044739425182343,
0.1113051101565361,
0.6257058382034302,
0.3108260929584503,
-0.09279326349496841,
0.105907142162323,
0.7813494801521301,
-0.7754795551300049,
0.4343680739402771,
-0.3892362713813782,
-0.0645231083035469,
0.31102216243743896,
0.25854820013046265,
-0.32956284284591675,
-0.42463165521621704,
-0.1557605266571045,
-0.46956121921539307,
-0.024534665048122406,
-0.126676544547081,
0.6442726850509644,
0.3546815812587738,
-0.4503740668296814,
0.02702285908162594,
-0.8415381908416748,
0.8997288942337036,
-0.9364596605300903,
0.17752589285373688,
0.5434004068374634,
0.029241893440485,
0.10013996064662933,
-0.19125838577747345,
-0.7969573140144348,
0.012261061929166317,
0.0036687019746750593,
0.27825796604156494,
-0.03722270950675011,
-0.06991657614707947,
-0.06738920509815216,
0.15388765931129456,
0.023452676832675934,
0.09098263829946518,
0.1935364007949829,
0.32169052958488464,
0.4322638213634491,
-0.02018054760992527,
0.007179123815149069,
-0.6494471430778503,
-0.6138941049575806,
-0.15528322756290436,
-0.889048159122467,
0.0982784628868103,
0.3929702937602997,
0.5633351802825928,
-0.17794202268123627,
0.4010450839996338,
-0.2598002552986145,
0.4478524327278137,
0.17201456427574158,
0.22597113251686096,
0.3723203241825104,
-0.45068004727363586,
-0.3078114688396454,
-0.11667169630527496,
0.8956320285797119,
0.7871944904327393,
-0.24892400205135345,
0.05145794898271561,
0.045640729367733,
0.18796341121196747,
0.41523125767707825,
-0.47422468662261963,
-0.02072473242878914,
0.6179687976837158,
-0.43415477871894836,
-0.5563582181930542,
0.2313176542520523,
-1.1661722660064697,
-0.7235344052314758,
-0.2677862346172333,
0.3958666920661926,
-0.33666476607322693,
-0.31466156244277954,
-0.2612440586090088,
-0.09303926676511765,
0.263830304145813,
0.23395605385303497,
-0.4896056056022644,
-0.23751476407051086,
0.8379952907562256,
0.7388393878936768,
0.1799365133047104,
-0.2877120077610016,
-0.3445512652397156,
-0.01421510148793459,
-0.4840320944786072,
0.8881112933158875,
-0.5842232704162598,
-0.2467721700668335,
0.02618045173585415,
-0.024521375074982643,
0.016718288883566856,
0.04347316548228264,
0.6066362261772156,
-0.3833684027194977,
0.01981603354215622,
-0.7906572818756104,
-0.059329692274332047,
-0.6492578983306885,
0.6789796352386475,
-0.8313213586807251,
0.5881378054618835,
0.09949548542499542,
-1.0308113098144531,
0.6867719292640686,
-0.2842476963996887,
-0.49570372700691223,
-0.6566267013549805,
-0.20831115543842316,
-0.8220380544662476,
0.3217555284500122,
0.7729184031486511,
0.3228873014450073,
-0.5538747310638428,
0.715408205986023,
-1.0285190343856812,
-0.03233112394809723,
0.36441776156425476,
-0.6712347865104675,
0.5706928372383118,
-0.02263561263680458,
-0.5132081508636475,
0.4220602810382843,
-0.5144795179367065,
-0.3174300491809845,
-0.2700694501399994,
0.1945262849330902,
-0.8598646521568298,
0.19215568900108337,
-0.16018325090408325,
0.4350002408027649,
-0.12896724045276642,
-0.6723912358283997,
0.060842182487249374,
-0.3329804837703705,
0.06569548696279526,
0.6680139303207397,
0.5663931369781494,
0.2836347222328186,
-0.197357177734375,
0.30845603346824646,
0.6372092962265015,
0.4878731966018677,
0.06019630283117294,
-0.22696155309677124,
-0.6681457757949829,
-0.4412364661693573,
0.05886523798108101,
0.3134302496910095,
-1.0465587377548218,
0.6471167206764221,
-0.0010070009157061577,
-0.3293287754058838,
-0.38827094435691833,
-0.25646960735321045,
0.6217135190963745,
0.6506931781768799,
0.5304659605026245,
-0.40366342663764954,
-0.3580608069896698,
-1.0563292503356934,
-0.274177223443985,
-0.3734327256679535,
0.29951807856559753,
0.1758028268814087,
0.16934612393379211,
-0.11044874787330627,
0.8338921666145325,
-0.5598438382148743,
-0.5195245146751404,
-0.3047780394554138,
0.3734786808490753,
0.3246240019798279,
0.5780892372131348,
0.7303563356399536,
-0.7308105230331421,
-0.08377373963594437,
-0.4884614944458008,
-0.9114252924919128,
0.001424413756467402,
-0.4019639492034912,
-0.22267617285251617,
-0.01896188221871853,
0.275703489780426,
-0.36901840567588806,
0.5521522164344788,
0.13188184797763824,
-0.4916395843029022,
0.5452057719230652,
0.17400804162025452,
0.3753872811794281,
-1.0803974866867065,
-0.14400029182434082,
0.433775931596756,
0.19253212213516235,
-0.30038225650787354,
-0.06866870075464249,
-0.20752011239528656,
0.15173852443695068,
-0.2586415112018585,
0.2975129187107086,
-0.12463388592004776,
0.17075224220752716,
-0.38103020191192627,
-0.21949715912342072,
0.3733717203140259,
0.860594630241394,
-0.028812523931264877,
0.22465229034423828,
0.6048070788383484,
-0.19752661883831024,
0.19918912649154663,
0.17602849006652832,
-0.03745937719941139,
1.0976605415344238,
-0.4820307195186615,
-0.09733272343873978,
-0.38507306575775146,
0.3150530457496643,
-1.1418795585632324,
0.1628597229719162,
0.6679115295410156,
-0.13358630239963531,
0.14293600618839264,
-0.13386954367160797,
-0.0930926725268364,
-0.1573815941810608,
-0.8586348295211792,
0.18880867958068848,
-0.2974385917186737,
-0.562371015548706,
0.7118455171585083,
0.26181235909461975,
-0.16733470559120178,
-0.7500977516174316,
-0.6426702737808228,
-0.03642432764172554,
-0.37164396047592163,
-0.15560367703437805,
0.03214365616440773,
0.23052796721458435,
-0.48602575063705444,
0.1714739203453064,
-0.3432497978210449,
-0.17387056350708008,
0.02778528444468975,
0.5286827087402344,
0.12086863815784454,
-0.11234518885612488,
-0.08278138190507889,
0.437763512134552,
-0.20001888275146484,
0.3085647225379944,
-0.08788260817527771,
0.32596898078918457,
-0.16282066702842712,
-0.4417487680912018,
-0.5211679339408875,
0.5951317548751831,
0.6328999996185303,
-0.028441259637475014,
0.7350033521652222,
0.40195170044898987,
-0.0747743621468544,
-0.005794737953692675,
-0.47314363718032837,
-0.29842597246170044,
-0.31328272819519043,
0.5000511407852173,
-0.3581145107746124,
-0.12469854205846786,
0.5657966732978821,
0.24794237315654755,
-0.13699543476104736,
0.4555799961090088,
0.31887805461883545,
0.10177445411682129,
0.6892436146736145,
0.22760406136512756,
-0.49302154779434204,
0.5590584874153137,
-0.21432913839817047,
0.2662610113620758,
-1.0283303260803223,
-0.22340445220470428,
-0.5721992254257202,
-0.2585998475551605,
-0.4174845218658447,
-0.3578965961933136,
0.36027172207832336,
0.12105704098939896,
-0.48668092489242554,
-0.04872770980000496,
-0.1102803573012352,
0.18550942838191986,
0.7801381945610046,
0.4891889989376068,
0.2547183930873871,
-0.24125857651233673,
-0.07486360520124435,
0.1709233820438385,
-0.26972508430480957,
-0.21302226185798645,
0.839777410030365,
0.24711133539676666,
1.0406242609024048,
0.18027669191360474,
0.39711707830429077,
0.32861024141311646,
0.49925661087036133,
-0.7783762812614441,
0.13533490896224976,
-0.11602166295051575,
-0.5944548845291138,
-0.2822481095790863,
-0.3851155638694763,
-0.33818283677101135,
0.554267168045044,
-0.17379754781723022,
-0.5559064745903015,
0.8292078971862793,
0.02735702320933342,
-0.293356716632843,
0.3185211718082428,
-0.5278053879737854,
0.8525422215461731,
-0.2102123647928238,
-0.8295808434486389,
-0.25045859813690186,
-0.6203238368034363,
0.44219958782196045,
0.05717070773243904,
0.519359827041626,
-0.18517963588237762,
0.46429958939552307,
0.41732558608055115,
-0.49311551451683044,
1.3559232950210571,
-0.7004625797271729,
-0.14745892584323883,
0.22457949817180634,
0.16403815150260925,
0.27941542863845825,
0.7411163449287415,
-0.2102721929550171,
0.6011705994606018,
-0.22906337678432465,
-0.0886436402797699,
-0.6633880138397217,
0.9991013407707214,
-0.7927922606468201,
-0.6601018309593201,
-0.5013658404350281,
-0.4649360179901123,
-0.6090759634971619,
0.22735081613063812,
-0.07467225193977356,
0.4975607395172119,
-0.28971314430236816,
0.026483360677957535,
0.04691256210207939,
-0.2639043927192688,
0.5123488903045654,
0.5203548669815063,
-0.004972396418452263,
-0.7749496102333069,
0.66445392370224,
-0.2435040920972824,
-0.17593663930892944,
0.6472802758216858,
0.4835219085216522,
-0.26818081736564636,
-0.27660632133483887,
-0.4321688115596771,
0.08231490850448608,
-0.5542182326316833,
-0.4414210319519043,
-0.4399421513080597,
0.34992164373397827,
-0.46930140256881714,
-0.1096506416797638,
-0.6392977833747864,
-0.3448422849178314,
-0.13978613913059235,
-0.18041765689849854,
0.1507023721933365,
0.5771816968917847,
-0.2863311469554901,
0.41340261697769165,
-0.37020143866539,
0.44794636964797974,
0.24504531919956207,
0.1877726912498474,
0.24574175477027893,
-0.08985815197229385,
-0.07945814728736877,
0.1476019024848938,
-0.5040498971939087,
-1.1027634143829346,
0.41978442668914795,
-0.11686738580465317,
0.20053207874298096,
0.7133554816246033,
0.3188174068927765,
0.43889319896698,
-0.04155542701482773,
0.8435948491096497,
0.3791164755821228,
-0.9703317284584045,
0.4324758052825928,
-0.24050889909267426,
0.00939367525279522,
0.7821496725082397,
0.2853911817073822,
-0.355132132768631,
-0.6095827221870422,
-0.3147544860839844,
-1.320335030555725,
0.6097813844680786,
-0.10197921842336655,
0.02153276838362217,
-0.3051190674304962,
0.3215438425540924,
0.3572790026664734,
0.34017643332481384,
-0.7885556817054749,
-0.3059871196746826,
-0.6292098760604858,
-0.204378142952919,
0.06538043916225433,
-0.32182130217552185,
-0.10485164821147919,
-0.20793527364730835,
0.9881328344345093,
-0.2765979468822479,
0.11629825085401535,
0.3795313835144043,
0.15183179080486298,
-0.04520593583583832,
0.3860100209712982,
0.2692226767539978,
0.672041118144989,
-0.33261048793792725,
0.2771257758140564,
-0.1331726461648941,
-0.16599300503730774,
0.17191673815250397,
0.13759271800518036,
-0.3754000663757324,
-0.1916431486606598,
0.4404771625995636,
0.7633323073387146,
0.20978742837905884,
0.031024960801005363,
0.7538890838623047,
-0.27590516209602356,
0.35984787344932556,
-0.32615968585014343,
-0.19865302741527557,
-0.12187722325325012,
0.38988998532295227,
0.1931641399860382,
0.12629111111164093,
0.17093002796173096,
-0.4498772919178009,
0.18378515541553497,
0.5674713253974915,
-0.9775735139846802,
-0.6194112300872803,
0.7203649878501892,
0.3416251838207245,
0.3926214277744293,
0.49782419204711914,
-0.12326717376708984,
-0.35719597339630127,
0.6187794804573059,
0.264438271522522,
1.2537559270858765,
-0.24099509418010712,
0.4548287093639374,
0.36749541759490967,
0.28710776567459106,
0.11726097762584686,
0.49335190653800964,
0.175540030002594,
-0.7986667156219482,
-0.4975508153438568,
-0.619021475315094,
-0.3111211657524109,
0.23421019315719604,
-0.9943671822547913,
-0.03234442323446274,
-0.40067699551582336,
-0.31281232833862305,
0.000023271764803212136,
-0.29724177718162537,
-0.4208672046661377,
0.34964099526405334,
-0.1347275823354721,
0.442361056804657,
-1.2896630764007568,
0.5760284662246704,
0.6215261816978455,
-0.8575026988983154,
-0.5686441659927368,
0.4348788559436798,
0.18729133903980255,
-0.4676670730113983,
0.38184502720832825,
0.1684173047542572,
-0.22228683531284332,
-0.630242645740509,
-0.32783231139183044,
-0.4851611256599426,
0.5765548348426819,
0.035309042781591415,
-0.3545614182949066,
0.128910094499588,
-0.06588105112314224,
0.3396514356136322,
-0.32665398716926575,
0.269827276468277,
0.474896639585495,
0.5061814188957214,
-0.10256494581699371,
-0.4107373058795929,
0.31834352016448975,
-0.011167852208018303,
-0.06694704294204712,
-0.055696893483400345,
-0.8586385250091553,
0.9541722536087036,
-0.06252649426460266,
0.5309503078460693,
-0.2573278248310089,
0.7715594172477722,
0.0029729476664215326,
0.5211695432662964,
0.5935161113739014,
0.5785794854164124,
0.29482582211494446,
-0.06729542464017868,
1.0103367567062378,
-0.19189700484275818,
0.5683376789093018,
1.4170639514923096,
-0.4166727066040039,
0.4939447343349457,
0.7373466491699219,
-0.043411001563072205,
0.824951171875,
0.5233755707740784,
0.19567374885082245,
1.0092073678970337,
-0.17585182189941406,
0.023922018706798553,
-0.18599137663841248,
-0.12599122524261475,
-0.1901693344116211,
0.5555469393730164,
0.33852776885032654,
-0.44599032402038574,
-0.22208154201507568,
0.057759471237659454,
0.2860918939113617,
-0.12696686387062073,
-0.26719793677330017,
0.8801297545433044,
0.26475465297698975,
-0.7741521596908569,
-0.07019619643688202,
0.15983512997627258,
0.4822898805141449,
-0.37832924723625183,
0.09751120954751968,
-0.5874943733215332,
0.3873385190963745,
0.034435924142599106,
-0.5178729295730591,
0.45944440364837646,
-0.20777124166488647,
-0.3881584107875824,
0.04318637773394585,
0.4322411119937897,
-0.14960364997386932,
-0.676037073135376,
0.2738552987575531,
0.5927159190177917,
-0.4772395193576813,
-0.4577021896839142,
-0.5662299394607544,
-0.00909743458032608,
-0.05838955193758011,
-0.411844938993454,
-0.008360512554645538,
0.4905335307121277,
-0.12967713177204132,
0.02876364439725876,
0.3035909831523895,
-0.009982225485146046,
-0.6700537204742432,
0.39171919226646423,
0.9451186060905457,
-0.9883930683135986,
-0.9213531017303467,
-1.1020525693893433,
0.20529212057590485,
-0.09535066783428192,
-0.3156683146953583,
0.8710706830024719,
0.33304697275161743,
0.4621908664703369,
-0.1387030929327011,
0.8516583442687988,
-0.18158797919750214,
0.3462086617946625,
-0.5366179347038269,
0.6285748481750488,
-0.4280187785625458,
0.32435476779937744,
-0.7209591269493103,
-0.6591910719871521,
-0.3790535032749176,
0.5527355670928955,
-0.6399391293525696,
0.13083310425281525,
0.8237438201904297,
0.6674603819847107,
0.05653106048703194,
0.3051391541957855,
0.024246370419859886,
0.3973456621170044,
0.5662870407104492,
0.30021172761917114,
0.8002363443374634,
-0.15963536500930786,
-0.1636531800031662,
-0.5321175456047058,
-0.32720378041267395,
-0.2059984803199768,
-0.9466813802719116,
-0.8845790028572083,
-0.5190256834030151,
-0.3672732710838318,
-0.5712281465530396,
-0.019165214151144028,
0.690640926361084,
0.6236206889152527,
-0.9955227971076965,
0.27708935737609863,
-0.06013115867972374,
0.5327388048171997,
-0.9212501645088196,
-0.30151763558387756,
0.7307562232017517,
-0.38970962166786194,
-0.6408624053001404,
0.3369496464729309,
0.25347262620925903,
-0.5079202651977539,
-0.4955386221408844,
0.5034313201904297,
-0.36057308316230774,
0.270037442445755,
0.6013221740722656,
-0.10853341221809387,
-0.6089696884155273,
-0.5633028745651245,
-0.4788694977760315,
0.1657724678516388,
0.20070038735866547,
0.8531132340431213,
-0.6589004993438721,
0.5533154010772705,
0.4324168562889099,
0.32188746333122253,
0.30221429467201233,
0.4931928217411041,
0.5500530004501343,
-1.0664750337600708,
0.324970543384552,
-0.009617687202990055,
0.5325297117233276,
0.39375221729278564,
-0.4950827360153198,
0.14991900324821472,
0.3398345708847046,
-0.15589436888694763,
-0.4772050678730011,
0.3812805414199829,
-0.9063287973403931,
-0.6828504204750061,
1.1743499040603638,
-0.30869176983833313,
-0.5147827863693237,
-0.22938598692417145,
-0.03255370631814003,
0.3449534773826599,
-0.5583759546279907,
1.1201756000518799,
0.41479700803756714,
-0.34981250762939453,
0.38852018117904663,
-0.02624010294675827,
0.18995487689971924,
0.4016042649745941,
-1.0856484174728394,
0.29257166385650635,
0.9300857782363892,
0.1962721198797226,
0.1795409619808197,
0.4315911829471588,
-0.13990437984466553,
0.02043532207608223,
0.24288256466388702,
0.03384515643119812,
-0.2910056412220001,
-0.6712380647659302,
-0.3971570134162903,
0.3899308741092682,
-0.053998567163944244,
-0.5080352425575256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01165v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01165v2
|
STAR: Constraint LoRA with Dynamic Active Learning for Data-Efficient Fine-Tuning of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-02T10:38:10 | 2024-06-06T07:31:39 |
Linhai Zhang, Jialong Wu, Deyu Zhou, Guoqiang Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Though Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated the powerful
capabilities of few-shot learning through prompting methods, supervised
training is still necessary for complex reasoning tasks. Because of their
extensive parameters and memory consumption, both Parameter-Efficient
Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods and Memory-Efficient Fine-Tuning methods have been
proposed for LLMs. Nevertheless, the issue of large annotated data consumption,
the aim of Data-Efficient Fine-Tuning, remains unexplored. One obvious way is
to combine the PEFT method with active learning. However, the experimental
results show that such a combination is not trivial and yields inferior
results. Through probe experiments, such observation might be explained by two
main reasons: uncertainty gap and poor model calibration. Therefore, in this
paper, we propose a novel approach to effectively integrate uncertainty-based
active learning and LoRA. Specifically, for the uncertainty gap, we introduce a
dynamic uncertainty measurement that combines the uncertainty of the base model
and the uncertainty of the full model during the iteration of active learning.
For poor model calibration, we incorporate the regularization method during
LoRA training to keep the model from being over-confident, and the Monte-Carlo
dropout mechanism is employed to enhance the uncertainty estimation.
Experimental results show that the proposed approach outperforms existing
baseline models on three complex reasoning tasks.
|
[
-0.221071258187294,
-1.3788495063781738,
0.54329514503479,
-0.33262869715690613,
-0.09466482698917389,
0.1465878188610077,
-0.44674354791641235,
-0.444625586271286,
-0.048307061195373535,
0.44831743836402893,
-0.5697717666625977,
-0.3782161474227905,
-0.3151252269744873,
-0.27688390016555786,
0.011654980480670929,
0.49805521965026855,
-0.5660735368728638,
-0.2503480315208435,
0.2759757936000824,
-0.11651473492383957,
-0.3521856367588043,
-0.14375902712345123,
-0.4328133761882782,
-0.29614633321762085,
0.6914946436882019,
0.6002606749534607,
0.7816675901412964,
0.7841012477874756,
0.33282068371772766,
0.24210575222969055,
-0.37323665618896484,
0.8217183351516724,
-0.25981515645980835,
0.23307614028453827,
-0.15416181087493896,
-0.5730167031288147,
-0.42958882451057434,
-0.008512076921761036,
0.8020158410072327,
0.9755582213401794,
-0.19080479443073273,
0.11378081887960434,
-0.1772482991218567,
0.43774139881134033,
-1.0247422456741333,
0.15773068368434906,
-0.8490222096443176,
0.087348572909832,
-0.09217224270105362,
0.17892320454120636,
-0.03437516465783119,
-0.1671357899904251,
-0.055651672184467316,
-0.8232620358467102,
-0.2237084060907364,
-0.07436110824346542,
1.0735446214675903,
0.9291089177131653,
-0.46317020058631897,
-0.04420917481184006,
-1.1543840169906616,
0.8982617855072021,
-0.7431451678276062,
0.3021625280380249,
0.46948492527008057,
0.2500772178173065,
-0.0842442661523819,
-0.31797951459884644,
-0.6534425616264343,
0.02183481864631176,
0.36643925309181213,
-0.05784239247441292,
-0.023619266226887703,
0.12151452153921127,
0.2040441334247589,
0.2841023802757263,
-0.02341333217918873,
0.38897597789764404,
-0.212571382522583,
-0.21845805644989014,
0.439911812543869,
0.0027929346542805433,
-0.2175246924161911,
0.15394864976406097,
-0.1799202561378479,
0.009836828336119652,
-0.80723637342453,
-0.004342925734817982,
0.5948922634124756,
0.6815577149391174,
0.053036753088235855,
0.5281888842582703,
-0.2523646056652069,
0.8648358583450317,
0.17044620215892792,
-0.18437273800373077,
0.26177874207496643,
-0.06623439490795135,
-0.17150625586509705,
-0.07144961506128311,
0.6150711178779602,
-0.32987889647483826,
-0.006234598811715841,
0.12068583816289902,
-0.3077477812767029,
0.15483711659908295,
-0.06409990042448044,
-0.3886606991291046,
-0.01582365296781063,
0.18342356383800507,
0.14247862994670868,
-0.2757822275161743,
-0.0047791460528969765,
-0.5029972791671753,
-0.21600964665412903,
-0.34405189752578735,
0.7457345724105835,
-0.2615363895893097,
-0.0975482240319252,
0.40696072578430176,
0.6677170991897583,
-0.028958236798644066,
0.5838788747787476,
-0.6326877474784851,
0.1936841756105423,
0.4257009029388428,
0.37629929184913635,
-0.18527837097644806,
-0.1676338165998459,
-0.9706129431724548,
0.38109472393989563,
-0.2271343171596527,
0.6801366209983826,
-0.5488287210464478,
0.11333268135786057,
-0.022597644478082657,
-0.2193899154663086,
-0.1413944810628891,
-0.5534807443618774,
0.7463770508766174,
-0.4985217750072479,
0.0023973670322448015,
-0.015084100887179375,
-0.3721986413002014,
-0.29645904898643494,
0.30427753925323486,
-0.7583720088005066,
1.2430834770202637,
0.11080312728881836,
-0.469843327999115,
0.25503990054130554,
-0.4575941562652588,
-0.29858148097991943,
-0.08482242375612259,
-0.2692379951477051,
-0.754459023475647,
0.018277287483215332,
0.22441920638084412,
0.3659152686595917,
-0.18699872493743896,
0.37685030698776245,
-0.25256243348121643,
-0.4907708764076233,
0.3198261260986328,
-0.46305495500564575,
0.2873498499393463,
0.32265302538871765,
-0.4554833769798279,
0.10222382843494415,
-0.8504218459129333,
0.08860555291175842,
0.09053760766983032,
-0.6520691514015198,
-0.19407927989959717,
0.18782939016819,
-0.31563207507133484,
-0.05642836540937424,
0.5115796327590942,
-0.3490154445171356,
0.4094444215297699,
-0.49499085545539856,
0.4028640389442444,
0.5593412518501282,
0.039782531559467316,
0.41540685296058655,
-0.014941195957362652,
0.4325556755065918,
0.025612397119402885,
0.15271905064582825,
0.010562666691839695,
-0.140589639544487,
-1.070705533027649,
-0.11054075509309769,
0.6557121872901917,
0.6884135007858276,
-0.5290613174438477,
0.6409767866134644,
0.1831582486629486,
-0.2953755557537079,
-0.32588812708854675,
0.44898882508277893,
0.3252660632133484,
0.3410613238811493,
0.27588823437690735,
0.21060286462306976,
-0.25514572858810425,
-0.6896046996116638,
-0.1363879144191742,
-0.2151366025209427,
0.2950105369091034,
0.3770815134048462,
0.38392508029937744,
-0.19040046632289886,
0.7202048897743225,
-0.5939720273017883,
-0.3752991557121277,
-0.14495660364627838,
0.10955262929201126,
0.3337974548339844,
0.5518830418586731,
0.24746006727218628,
-0.7612563371658325,
-0.4255737364292145,
-0.04441806301474571,
-0.25843510031700134,
-0.16173280775547028,
-0.08373037725687027,
-0.14006908237934113,
0.11477161943912506,
0.49597349762916565,
-0.6501780152320862,
0.3678123950958252,
0.5969943404197693,
-0.25435125827789307,
0.29526087641716003,
-0.20129747688770294,
-0.20841388404369354,
-0.7444658875465393,
0.04398265480995178,
-0.17939238250255585,
-0.1883898675441742,
-0.38095352053642273,
-0.01691310666501522,
0.19839851558208466,
-0.096196249127388,
-0.38169869780540466,
0.530085563659668,
-0.6839936971664429,
0.3163664638996124,
-0.2891368567943573,
0.15061840415000916,
-0.0676848515868187,
0.53420090675354,
0.0654483214020729,
0.40349680185317993,
0.6588596701622009,
-0.5535991191864014,
0.35176193714141846,
0.07789373397827148,
-0.605078399181366,
-0.040815822780132294,
-0.421833336353302,
0.0038448579143732786,
0.24828936159610748,
0.02897537685930729,
-0.7903866171836853,
-0.4464989900588989,
0.30931708216667175,
-0.1102997362613678,
0.4416812062263489,
-0.12980623543262482,
-0.5412949323654175,
-0.13195130228996277,
0.08428891748189926,
0.3833156228065491,
0.45294180512428284,
-0.3273867070674896,
0.7463822364807129,
0.31044235825538635,
0.1441464126110077,
-0.737878680229187,
-0.6932248473167419,
-0.24644221365451813,
-0.26722827553749084,
-0.28225812315940857,
0.3085998594760895,
0.08796221017837524,
-0.297542929649353,
-0.04635275900363922,
-0.45285454392433167,
-0.12299493700265884,
0.39198166131973267,
0.11513040214776993,
0.08367736637592316,
-0.09428094327449799,
0.2140876203775406,
0.408462792634964,
-0.1245734691619873,
-0.2456713765859604,
0.000604184519033879,
0.4187430441379547,
-0.04745509847998619,
-0.8355683088302612,
-0.5783190131187439,
0.08317951112985611,
0.4773463010787964,
-0.4177020192146301,
0.8639875054359436,
0.46416738629341125,
-0.6159328818321228,
-0.512002170085907,
-0.7526371479034424,
-0.14905676245689392,
-0.4858770966529846,
0.1849755495786667,
-0.3154129683971405,
-0.8025942444801331,
0.7124683260917664,
-0.35906916856765747,
0.13422547280788422,
0.33531519770622253,
0.4324100911617279,
0.01131368800997734,
0.9803820848464966,
0.5339722633361816,
0.2588345408439636,
0.7730071544647217,
-0.338837593793869,
0.3023239076137543,
-0.5309810042381287,
-0.10221114009618759,
-0.39966440200805664,
-0.4458070695400238,
-0.16807810962200165,
-0.6770278811454773,
0.29432231187820435,
0.45969805121421814,
-0.4557077884674072,
-0.11648428440093994,
-0.1944972425699234,
0.4632313549518585,
0.4710816740989685,
0.23504625260829926,
0.3984740078449249,
-0.023608040064573288,
-0.1526944488286972,
0.12958793342113495,
-0.7932507991790771,
-0.4043653905391693,
0.7251677513122559,
0.34838876128196716,
1.120231032371521,
0.12341807037591934,
0.4333339333534241,
-0.12257164716720581,
-0.29676496982574463,
-1.0052783489227295,
0.5144586563110352,
0.022206055000424385,
-0.561495304107666,
-0.5073014497756958,
-0.5970296263694763,
-0.9924939274787903,
-0.06572385877370834,
-0.3489821255207062,
-0.5895236730575562,
0.2978404462337494,
0.4450450539588928,
-0.8335726261138916,
0.5004543662071228,
-0.5699850916862488,
0.6586679816246033,
-0.36322787404060364,
-0.647339403629303,
-0.08441594243049622,
-0.6380468606948853,
0.16693292558193207,
-0.39803776144981384,
0.16157099604606628,
-0.36170506477355957,
-0.34293505549430847,
0.6236935257911682,
-0.4058421552181244,
1.1032822132110596,
-0.24180175364017487,
-0.3801194429397583,
0.5249011516571045,
0.22005416452884674,
1.0024961233139038,
0.11838272213935852,
-0.24967971444129944,
-0.21966490149497986,
-0.3306494355201721,
-0.3541405200958252,
-0.558473527431488,
0.716644287109375,
-0.8353540301322937,
-0.5228065252304077,
-0.4095751941204071,
-0.7475262880325317,
-0.6530385613441467,
0.18285585939884186,
-0.12366265058517456,
0.08619461208581924,
0.1286289244890213,
0.1469230055809021,
0.9732739925384521,
-0.2338941991329193,
0.1326085925102234,
0.717721700668335,
0.03213457763195038,
-0.17389804124832153,
0.5700621604919434,
0.3064662218093872,
0.40900421142578125,
0.38375619053840637,
0.31472617387771606,
0.00810981448739767,
-0.8015062212944031,
-0.23650702834129333,
0.43580999970436096,
-0.4528498351573944,
-0.39849621057510376,
-0.4032287001609802,
-0.21174228191375732,
-0.09914375841617584,
-0.16076110303401947,
-0.8482279777526855,
-0.5535986423492432,
-0.422315776348114,
-0.020211046561598778,
0.4729507863521576,
0.39371994137763977,
-0.03311518579721451,
0.47876858711242676,
-0.5399895310401917,
0.18816958367824554,
0.4353471100330353,
0.40393897891044617,
-0.17388463020324707,
-0.5940724015235901,
-0.3986518085002899,
0.20485369861125946,
-0.19231337308883667,
-0.6200968623161316,
0.15814858675003052,
0.44495952129364014,
0.7419769763946533,
0.6460788249969482,
0.33756837248802185,
0.6903828382492065,
-0.20060467720031738,
0.5822626948356628,
-0.08022943139076233,
-0.9217109084129333,
0.8352347016334534,
-0.5098013281822205,
0.3954651355743408,
0.6871997117996216,
0.11468178778886795,
0.05100421980023384,
-0.31440672278404236,
-0.556470513343811,
-0.9618545770645142,
0.5724103450775146,
0.1419224739074707,
-0.08178049325942993,
0.25944626331329346,
0.6866285800933838,
0.027545347809791565,
-0.01902271807193756,
-0.5113246440887451,
-0.1752234548330307,
0.3071572184562683,
-0.17040227353572845,
0.059700895100831985,
-0.1276269555091858,
-0.17987556755542755,
-0.31735026836395264,
0.8018581867218018,
-0.33721572160720825,
0.015542810782790184,
-0.18440242111682892,
-0.02500370889902115,
-0.5628367066383362,
0.16233602166175842,
0.2652769386768341,
0.5951590538024902,
-0.29668620228767395,
0.15350064635276794,
0.4597652852535248,
-0.37664347887039185,
0.023955851793289185,
0.1800217181444168,
-0.2266385853290558,
-0.13487014174461365,
0.1887858361005783,
0.9943402409553528,
0.24430720508098602,
-1.0018922090530396,
0.2921244204044342,
0.14959542453289032,
-0.3378431499004364,
-0.358964741230011,
0.43375203013420105,
0.0017997873947024345,
0.41387638449668884,
0.3972022235393524,
0.11704878509044647,
-0.3437301814556122,
-0.5187618732452393,
-0.06810974329710007,
0.3454659581184387,
-0.4640863239765167,
-0.19866757094860077,
0.6835463643074036,
0.2045225352048874,
-0.06132571026682854,
0.4200671315193176,
-0.031748801469802856,
-0.5176453590393066,
0.5157395005226135,
0.32899945974349976,
0.4260607659816742,
-0.3740883469581604,
-0.05969260260462761,
0.3331826329231262,
0.1546764373779297,
-0.37702131271362305,
0.6460761427879333,
0.008404065854847431,
-0.8171220421791077,
-0.7848731875419617,
-0.6383078694343567,
-0.6507291197776794,
0.3009803295135498,
-0.6301159262657166,
0.5333991050720215,
-0.4456115961074829,
-0.1253284215927124,
-0.18793252110481262,
0.4186756908893585,
-0.2782684564590454,
0.17067627608776093,
0.14910146594047546,
0.7056176662445068,
-0.9574253559112549,
1.035523533821106,
0.7671660780906677,
-0.16695018112659454,
-1.061447024345398,
-0.018658330664038658,
-0.186314195394516,
-0.6526062488555908,
0.3955777883529663,
-0.10214352607727051,
-0.23721355199813843,
-0.051830001175403595,
-0.5744996070861816,
-1.1104660034179688,
0.8839482665061951,
0.6459420919418335,
-0.7449977993965149,
-0.026497654616832733,
-0.14899711310863495,
0.31853431463241577,
-0.09003308415412903,
-0.42142874002456665,
0.44324612617492676,
0.6396538615226746,
0.37529537081718445,
-0.9018214344978333,
-0.07319866865873337,
-0.09831271320581436,
-0.4967495799064636,
0.6686559319496155,
-0.8820786476135254,
0.9128062129020691,
-0.24212677776813507,
-0.1591775268316269,
0.12033670395612717,
0.6798503994941711,
0.2886423170566559,
0.07869106531143188,
0.8211238384246826,
0.4791509807109833,
0.9839736223220825,
-0.22058361768722534,
0.4600312113761902,
-0.2615651786327362,
0.39173027873039246,
1.1790539026260376,
-0.43451201915740967,
0.9002425074577332,
0.5249544382095337,
-0.052113886922597885,
0.24327024817466736,
0.775415301322937,
0.022332336753606796,
0.4088364243507385,
0.18397676944732666,
-0.36048656702041626,
-0.7658320069313049,
-0.07592509686946869,
-0.10032684355974197,
0.6159199476242065,
0.7773320078849792,
-0.14857327938079834,
-0.052181243896484375,
-0.00222631823271513,
0.06804651767015457,
0.1125500351190567,
-0.2415386140346527,
0.5065296292304993,
-0.05100402608513832,
-0.7102735638618469,
0.7636523842811584,
-0.012991395778954029,
0.47962602972984314,
-0.780726969242096,
0.12546277046203613,
-0.08584050834178925,
0.42054668068885803,
-0.1286524087190628,
-0.4943735599517822,
0.15045571327209473,
-0.039651792496442795,
0.12359834462404251,
-0.06569237262010574,
0.5100095272064209,
-0.5312375426292419,
-0.5312595367431641,
0.07140424847602844,
0.7722886204719543,
0.0590052492916584,
-0.04127687215805054,
-0.6691855192184448,
0.2542702555656433,
0.04685187339782715,
-0.49851927161216736,
0.143990620970726,
0.66811203956604,
-0.1578012853860855,
0.6903738379478455,
0.3898875415325165,
0.2945657968521118,
-0.05153583735227585,
0.03836517408490181,
0.9863609075546265,
-0.46833059191703796,
-0.3189536929130554,
-0.5976733565330505,
0.2603646516799927,
0.2389535754919052,
-0.2669469714164734,
0.5924873352050781,
0.5828230381011963,
0.4745005965232849,
0.30514591932296753,
0.663871169090271,
0.00654166005551815,
0.6996176242828369,
-0.678946852684021,
0.45218008756637573,
-0.793921172618866,
0.5698268413543701,
-0.12976549565792084,
-1.0436710119247437,
-0.5779959559440613,
0.8420997262001038,
-0.3279446065425873,
-0.07062108814716339,
0.6481662392616272,
0.6942955851554871,
-0.3992238938808441,
-0.42233291268348694,
0.24696147441864014,
0.2957443594932556,
0.011155043728649616,
0.6793380975723267,
0.7376628518104553,
-0.3602461814880371,
0.6789741516113281,
-0.3025693893432617,
-0.19586440920829773,
-0.21852052211761475,
-0.8312700390815735,
-0.8968601226806641,
-0.4375121593475342,
-0.6671379208564758,
-0.25169092416763306,
-0.00325232301838696,
0.7574886083602905,
0.6400917172431946,
-0.7817315459251404,
0.026794640347361565,
-0.04221367835998535,
0.057632725685834885,
-0.3988141417503357,
-0.10874146223068237,
0.5608253479003906,
-0.15188701450824738,
-1.0247753858566284,
0.5057985186576843,
0.012468422763049603,
0.3255479633808136,
-0.44523733854293823,
0.06499257683753967,
-0.49171411991119385,
0.2798973619937897,
0.18664446473121643,
0.40088966488838196,
-0.7101370692253113,
-0.23940952122211456,
-0.10420238971710205,
0.10912604629993439,
0.0019097133772447705,
0.5103793740272522,
-0.8527053594589233,
0.22299730777740479,
0.40537580847740173,
0.55063396692276,
0.7443721294403076,
-0.02790149673819542,
0.5145193934440613,
-0.6127517819404602,
0.3531406819820404,
0.34191760420799255,
0.2585033178329468,
0.08437395840883255,
-0.3099348545074463,
0.5525388717651367,
0.06879362463951111,
-0.4930107593536377,
-1.1612204313278198,
0.41105660796165466,
-1.2044527530670166,
-0.44467994570732117,
1.2860044240951538,
-0.1522735357284546,
-0.25401878356933594,
-0.1444845348596573,
-0.2157895416021347,
0.43437284231185913,
-0.46703389286994934,
0.7731614708900452,
0.4573320746421814,
-0.1123126968741417,
-0.14164923131465912,
-0.6143215894699097,
0.264602929353714,
0.5493194460868835,
-0.6801766753196716,
0.13417598605155945,
0.4810115396976471,
0.047769829630851746,
0.07441999018192291,
-0.19753456115722656,
0.24749350547790527,
0.10477113723754883,
-0.0940864235162735,
-0.10446802526712418,
-0.2750204801559448,
-0.31715601682662964,
-0.2219351977109909,
0.21433383226394653,
0.21253341436386108,
0.015586982481181622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01163v1
|
BootTOD: Bootstrap Task-oriented Dialogue Representations by Aligning Diverse Responses
| 2024-03-02T10:34:11 | 2024-03-02T10:34:11 |
Weihao Zeng, Keqing He, Yejie Wang, Dayuan Fu, Weiran Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models have been successful in many scenarios. However,
their usefulness in task-oriented dialogues is limited due to the intrinsic
linguistic differences between general text and task-oriented dialogues.
Current task-oriented dialogue pre-training methods rely on a contrastive
framework, which faces challenges such as selecting true positives and hard
negatives, as well as lacking diversity. In this paper, we propose a novel
dialogue pre-training model called BootTOD. It learns task-oriented dialogue
representations via a self-bootstrapping framework. Unlike contrastive
counterparts, BootTOD aligns context and context+response representations and
dismisses the requirements of contrastive pairs. BootTOD also uses multiple
appropriate response targets to model the intrinsic one-to-many diversity of
human conversations. Experimental results show that BootTOD outperforms strong
TOD baselines on diverse downstream dialogue tasks.
|
[
-0.5169201493263245,
-0.2922889292240143,
0.2296581119298935,
0.44669732451438904,
-0.47633427381515503,
0.44247275590896606,
-0.12354148179292679,
-0.30640625953674316,
0.34096816182136536,
0.3994849622249603,
-0.8698469996452332,
-0.5230533480644226,
-0.5333725810050964,
0.03771621361374855,
-0.25149354338645935,
1.232815146446228,
0.208016499876976,
0.4086962640285492,
-0.010642373003065586,
-0.5506563186645508,
-0.6441811323165894,
-0.4863531291484833,
-0.46507829427719116,
-0.30186447501182556,
0.3118741512298584,
0.3338979482650757,
0.26811590790748596,
0.2960219085216522,
0.20251362025737762,
0.33303216099739075,
0.3758789300918579,
-0.37735310196876526,
-0.4408746659755707,
0.6014842987060547,
-0.21974438428878784,
-0.3348531126976013,
0.0009586852975189686,
-0.005790929775685072,
0.45427191257476807,
0.7514298558235168,
-0.19682720303535461,
-0.04948083311319351,
0.39389896392822266,
0.2915048599243164,
-0.6014000773429871,
-0.08018855005502701,
-0.57065749168396,
0.019542407244443893,
0.14354807138442993,
0.04560372233390808,
-0.14864079654216766,
0.05512402579188347,
0.1767486035823822,
-0.48229387402534485,
0.24868686497211456,
-0.03415164723992348,
0.4540266692638397,
0.24389930069446564,
-0.372588187456131,
-0.10746157914400101,
-0.6661353707313538,
0.7790595889091492,
-0.6474562287330627,
0.3146911859512329,
0.0938432589173317,
0.3162554204463959,
0.11323490738868713,
-0.3489273190498352,
-0.4959632456302643,
0.09237174689769745,
-0.10695680230855942,
0.15784870088100433,
0.2088703066110611,
0.0690707117319107,
-0.08687444031238556,
0.48962831497192383,
-0.4177350103855133,
0.23255451023578644,
-0.0061399671249091625,
-0.15879076719284058,
0.15485472977161407,
0.3631312847137451,
0.05198662728071213,
-0.0355135053396225,
-0.7030342817306519,
-0.140051931142807,
-0.4874957799911499,
0.007402126211673021,
0.29615122079849243,
0.6299108862876892,
-0.33256518840789795,
0.07105854153633118,
-0.32219263911247253,
0.6799994707107544,
0.36470913887023926,
-0.1907244175672531,
0.2548554837703705,
-0.3930034339427948,
-0.31665119528770447,
-0.11762481182813644,
0.9943701028823853,
0.343109130859375,
-0.1537981927394867,
-0.16409409046173096,
-0.3507712483406067,
-0.07526645064353943,
0.4041678011417389,
-0.9223688840866089,
-0.05963559448719025,
0.21142181754112244,
-0.4764844477176666,
-0.31017619371414185,
-0.3368786871433258,
-0.8376114964485168,
-0.39289233088493347,
-0.14701803028583527,
0.40491563081741333,
-0.30066534876823425,
-0.34382641315460205,
-0.04568511247634888,
0.14742229878902435,
0.22534909844398499,
0.5345097780227661,
-1.0447036027908325,
0.7825517058372498,
0.2784559726715088,
0.5830788612365723,
-0.4875423014163971,
-0.17280004918575287,
-0.7205797433853149,
-0.07202023267745972,
-0.07404198497533798,
0.519523024559021,
-0.801077127456665,
-0.4186452627182007,
0.06331877410411835,
-0.14370989799499512,
0.028403451666235924,
-0.45121580362319946,
0.1718454509973526,
-0.34094592928886414,
0.506583034992218,
-0.22621534764766693,
-0.2395721971988678,
-0.007320832926779985,
0.5530275702476501,
-0.44809240102767944,
0.7459579706192017,
0.40599358081817627,
-0.8641683459281921,
0.3460867404937744,
-0.620616614818573,
-0.5809676647186279,
0.05582636594772339,
-0.5893139243125916,
-0.39106878638267517,
-0.08689974993467331,
0.217409148812294,
0.4387437105178833,
-0.5595387816429138,
0.4215056300163269,
-0.15617287158966064,
-0.13421942293643951,
-0.08351562917232513,
-0.23859159648418427,
0.7401055097579956,
0.3867485821247101,
-0.684353232383728,
0.4080691933631897,
-0.5924606323242188,
-0.1353851705789566,
0.0838911160826683,
-0.034653034061193466,
-0.3985409140586853,
-0.2721542716026306,
0.24310944974422455,
0.40822967886924744,
0.009460052475333214,
-0.797321617603302,
0.09060511738061905,
-0.3346184492111206,
-0.01592407561838627,
0.7487037777900696,
-0.2532399296760559,
0.43545278906822205,
-0.3521939218044281,
0.7886309623718262,
0.44785967469215393,
-0.2665380835533142,
-0.5048676133155823,
-0.37564364075660706,
-0.7270265221595764,
-0.3589131236076355,
0.29825299978256226,
0.4893639385700226,
-0.6513897776603699,
0.41239097714424133,
0.02378683350980282,
-0.33711060881614685,
-0.6811266541481018,
0.18238013982772827,
0.6996855139732361,
0.551161527633667,
0.4008837342262268,
-0.6779819130897522,
-0.4033068120479584,
-0.9264765381813049,
-0.2940652370452881,
-0.30401092767715454,
-0.11627165228128433,
0.18287041783332825,
0.2874194085597992,
-0.10090827196836472,
1.02519690990448,
-0.23374994099140167,
-0.28500309586524963,
-0.4498564302921295,
0.3930132985115051,
-0.12489046156406403,
0.8886253833770752,
0.5065209269523621,
-0.8013100028038025,
-0.5198035836219788,
-0.165222629904747,
-0.39334145188331604,
-0.14645051956176758,
-0.3946576714515686,
-0.039163511246442795,
-0.1757766455411911,
0.2782193124294281,
-0.4960730969905853,
0.2819259464740753,
0.4902857840061188,
-0.2158593088388443,
0.5164405107498169,
0.1651662141084671,
0.4843362867832184,
-1.5783082246780396,
-0.07171492278575897,
0.028628187254071236,
-0.6213399767875671,
-0.6294001340866089,
-0.16317658126354218,
-0.1575656533241272,
-0.324017733335495,
-0.3866082727909088,
0.5607733130455017,
-0.40008363127708435,
-0.1852860152721405,
-0.17989994585514069,
-0.07392102479934692,
-0.18752571940422058,
0.706089198589325,
0.33311280608177185,
0.8197542428970337,
0.5743901133537292,
-0.6626150608062744,
0.28269651532173157,
0.4187297224998474,
-0.3378610610961914,
0.8403740525245667,
-0.5113263726234436,
0.048658519983291626,
-0.030323853716254234,
0.3278113603591919,
-1.3419543504714966,
-0.020767560228705406,
0.4213148057460785,
-0.10985943675041199,
0.5083495378494263,
-0.29044201970100403,
-0.17698292434215546,
-0.15010742843151093,
-0.1446727216243744,
0.9552897214889526,
0.5126741528511047,
-0.6247559785842896,
0.6638429164886475,
0.2927986681461334,
-0.5967573523521423,
-0.6086888313293457,
-0.28681981563568115,
-0.2225329428911209,
-0.2427286058664322,
-0.2959621548652649,
0.3836359679698944,
-0.27217361330986023,
0.006023316644132137,
-0.3934643566608429,
-0.33068764209747314,
-0.1796293705701828,
-0.04515695199370384,
0.28909820318222046,
0.05240383371710777,
-0.2877654433250427,
0.2831510007381439,
-0.10560935735702515,
-0.05416291207075119,
-0.048897791653871536,
-0.49378731846809387,
0.9513971209526062,
-0.12361584603786469,
-0.6146040558815002,
-0.3855646550655365,
0.6364728808403015,
0.5772384405136108,
-0.25955331325531006,
0.5621570348739624,
0.6679458022117615,
-0.09053203463554382,
0.14809688925743103,
-0.8373237252235413,
-0.35321927070617676,
-0.4645719826221466,
0.4947037994861603,
-0.29496827721595764,
-1.0945546627044678,
0.6075285077095032,
-0.1982155740261078,
0.1521664559841156,
0.20238885283470154,
0.5624033808708191,
-0.23503121733665466,
0.7754359245300293,
0.6599608063697815,
-0.05155065283179283,
0.7042416930198669,
0.1342802494764328,
0.07022249698638916,
-0.8380876183509827,
-0.23455160856246948,
-0.5789642930030823,
-0.4492388963699341,
-0.4887678027153015,
-0.35529935359954834,
-0.010299070738255978,
-0.17223824560642242,
-0.4278572201728821,
0.39431411027908325,
-0.4017404019832611,
0.3869284689426422,
0.4120998680591583,
-0.07947231829166412,
0.14433099329471588,
-0.11220863461494446,
-0.16267625987529755,
-0.20615175366401672,
-0.6503607034683228,
-0.3586650490760803,
0.9612376093864441,
0.3023582100868225,
0.9433618187904358,
-0.23723174631595612,
1.0552524328231812,
0.09329450130462646,
0.464008629322052,
-0.5254053473472595,
0.4940339922904968,
0.04473339766263962,
-0.6221336126327515,
-0.3168904483318329,
-0.35307827591896057,
-0.8703511357307434,
0.44248855113983154,
-0.12135335057973862,
-0.9883948564529419,
0.20715750753879547,
0.11491633951663971,
-0.41300034523010254,
0.24640841782093048,
-0.5996930003166199,
1.1380784511566162,
-0.1771671622991562,
-0.2604226768016815,
-0.2234916239976883,
-1.0405123233795166,
0.17711815237998962,
0.10379918664693832,
0.12172678858041763,
-0.04127462953329086,
0.23442243039608002,
0.9217812418937683,
-0.4275640547275543,
1.175277829170227,
-0.2636580169200897,
-0.03980860486626625,
0.20960313081741333,
0.2508660554885864,
0.32741308212280273,
0.05171510949730873,
0.19689080119132996,
-0.2164577692747116,
0.0037339474074542522,
-0.68265300989151,
-0.6322686076164246,
0.5262365937232971,
-0.6215448379516602,
-1.0011484622955322,
-0.37746715545654297,
-0.5585811734199524,
-0.542169451713562,
0.15927517414093018,
0.3789883553981781,
0.5804126858711243,
-0.6138284206390381,
0.0433390736579895,
0.41803044080734253,
-0.0420529730618,
0.5312862396240234,
0.5888404846191406,
-0.2953365445137024,
-0.3274722993373871,
0.8318846225738525,
-0.47878384590148926,
0.7208529114723206,
0.3443031311035156,
-0.08945360034704208,
-0.17286032438278198,
-0.5011416077613831,
-0.42211073637008667,
0.01781199872493744,
-0.6927687525749207,
-0.24010401964187622,
-0.6600230932235718,
0.007747664116322994,
-0.21945521235466003,
-0.1145402193069458,
-0.5964648127555847,
-0.3910163342952728,
-0.1732269823551178,
-0.042159225791692734,
-0.11854612827301025,
0.7262254357337952,
0.11760438233613968,
0.46559178829193115,
-0.6073826551437378,
0.5960121750831604,
0.5820814371109009,
0.4327433109283447,
-0.20578162372112274,
-0.3617781400680542,
-0.17441421747207642,
0.14573189616203308,
-0.505142867565155,
-0.8635172247886658,
0.3128425180912018,
0.03005984053015709,
0.49786534905433655,
0.4705979824066162,
0.4053370952606201,
0.4221239984035492,
-0.45096954703330994,
0.8388234376907349,
0.9168515205383301,
-0.7782634496688843,
0.4503766894340515,
-0.3883957266807556,
0.6005774736404419,
0.8341251015663147,
0.5181819796562195,
-0.4664005637168884,
-0.645545482635498,
-0.4833827018737793,
-0.4478825330734253,
0.7338669896125793,
0.27602145075798035,
0.3362066149711609,
-0.18645446002483368,
-0.25733742117881775,
0.6510177850723267,
0.5168803334236145,
-0.8833639621734619,
-0.24423086643218994,
-0.6392534971237183,
-0.30242225527763367,
0.06612826883792877,
0.009377454407513142,
-0.3759104013442993,
-0.13395309448242188,
0.40504178404808044,
-0.23047396540641785,
0.417598694562912,
0.10348013043403625,
-0.23088981211185455,
0.14015300571918488,
0.6662043333053589,
0.4044535160064697,
0.31040918827056885,
-0.035008594393730164,
0.02597568742930889,
0.08978413045406342,
-0.3107599914073944,
0.5766147971153259,
0.08240067958831787,
0.3311358392238617,
-0.04828259348869324,
0.08583732694387436,
0.8036951422691345,
0.29562848806381226,
-0.5171658396720886,
0.6869571805000305,
-0.18794682621955872,
0.09615431725978851,
0.1947353035211563,
-0.016006281599402428,
0.021345259621739388,
0.3725001811981201,
0.4956147074699402,
0.3772381842136383,
0.1891545057296753,
-0.7015915513038635,
0.13201341032981873,
0.5467151403427124,
-0.5741181373596191,
-0.20694653689861298,
0.48515501618385315,
0.8228057622909546,
-0.5710844993591309,
0.5738856196403503,
-0.35920605063438416,
-0.7245248556137085,
0.48032304644584656,
0.8160824179649353,
1.1097744703292847,
-0.541718065738678,
0.36476606130599976,
0.24844974279403687,
-0.06446705758571625,
0.29834744334220886,
0.07514837384223938,
-0.5788121819496155,
-0.8506262898445129,
-0.29261791706085205,
-0.573189914226532,
-0.37585607171058655,
0.25405004620552063,
-0.8255764842033386,
0.028525544330477715,
-0.5343983769416809,
-0.1355312317609787,
-0.36975860595703125,
-0.39810681343078613,
-0.8842763304710388,
0.5832961201667786,
-0.10652084648609161,
0.46021944284439087,
-0.7869654893875122,
0.7191464900970459,
0.5165123343467712,
-0.2929816246032715,
-0.4175250232219696,
0.37827038764953613,
-0.12837032973766327,
-0.6920163631439209,
0.7400336861610413,
0.43948474526405334,
-0.33293676376342773,
-0.02712390385568142,
-0.4534436762332916,
-0.4225064814090729,
0.681755781173706,
0.5290961265563965,
-0.6599243879318237,
-0.010126017965376377,
-0.012986398302018642,
0.2543003261089325,
-1.0714032649993896,
0.31961363554000854,
0.2847091257572174,
-0.005031623411923647,
0.23750483989715576,
-0.9749664068222046,
0.24022939801216125,
-0.534169614315033,
-0.07433385401964188,
0.10093025118112564,
-0.5055682063102722,
0.5895440578460693,
-0.20783595740795135,
-0.1891496181488037,
0.2212810516357422,
0.5561331510543823,
0.1151738241314888,
0.04915015399456024,
0.8253839612007141,
0.29357826709747314,
0.4202221930027008,
-0.1128380224108696,
0.8569770455360413,
-0.38392820954322815,
-0.03861619904637337,
1.3568246364593506,
-0.2621147930622101,
0.5960404276847839,
0.48623010516166687,
-0.1296999305486679,
0.7712846994400024,
0.5470191240310669,
0.28809812664985657,
0.7816513776779175,
0.031570810824632645,
-0.5163981318473816,
-0.7511736154556274,
0.10434499382972717,
-0.4495711028575897,
0.2860379219055176,
0.2976336181163788,
-0.13070982694625854,
-0.24805696308612823,
0.14595434069633484,
-0.455059289932251,
0.18537642061710358,
0.016400672495365143,
0.9217329621315002,
-0.03869865462183952,
-0.7959132194519043,
0.6620420813560486,
-0.2361021488904953,
0.7832460999488831,
-0.6818830966949463,
-0.08700397610664368,
-0.11649756133556366,
-0.10518458485603333,
-0.06319406628608704,
-0.5883778929710388,
-0.05587754771113396,
-0.18876728415489197,
-0.13166046142578125,
-0.4176179766654968,
0.44262611865997314,
-0.7452874183654785,
-0.17093078792095184,
0.3500692844390869,
0.3755219578742981,
-0.112953782081604,
0.03436782956123352,
-0.5893887877464294,
-0.0961947962641716,
0.062195584177970886,
-0.05553309619426727,
0.7021127343177795,
0.25594058632850647,
0.1892189085483551,
0.7444724440574646,
0.2382606863975525,
-0.42116832733154297,
-0.24496671557426453,
0.1945953518152237,
1.1439018249511719,
-0.6578733921051025,
-0.9565995335578918,
-0.5399148464202881,
0.8582718968391418,
-0.18672797083854675,
-0.4309057891368866,
0.3770633935928345,
0.48006829619407654,
0.7030712962150574,
-0.3044144809246063,
0.8490092754364014,
0.1129491999745369,
0.5237893462181091,
-0.401380330324173,
0.33497366309165955,
-0.38741910457611084,
0.32063382863998413,
-0.5119218230247498,
-1.1500247716903687,
0.07698304951190948,
0.896364152431488,
-0.14580635726451874,
0.39677852392196655,
0.8461077809333801,
0.5617653131484985,
-0.2953855097293854,
0.18402256071567535,
0.3471728563308716,
0.1772564947605133,
0.2141416370868683,
0.41810131072998047,
0.957489013671875,
-0.23011837899684906,
0.6088243126869202,
0.03994150459766388,
-0.11330042034387589,
-0.22366926074028015,
-0.7364861965179443,
-1.113203763961792,
-0.8729462027549744,
-0.4094897210597992,
-0.30162617564201355,
0.17658521234989166,
1.1139180660247803,
1.0225980281829834,
-1.0045000314712524,
-0.4689100682735443,
-0.12763608992099762,
0.02257474511861801,
-0.10686121135950089,
-0.15955683588981628,
-0.21662817895412445,
-0.8205438256263733,
-0.5635877251625061,
0.4357573390007019,
0.39325425028800964,
0.19502033293247223,
-0.20350664854049683,
-0.3660396337509155,
-0.10317723453044891,
-0.11573083698749542,
0.24281376600265503,
0.36217740178108215,
-0.6687151789665222,
-0.21367745101451874,
-0.3103107213973999,
-0.11026063561439514,
0.4814182221889496,
1.1169397830963135,
-1.071581482887268,
0.6124497056007385,
0.08921675384044647,
0.6937856078147888,
0.853782594203949,
0.11556509882211685,
1.232229232788086,
-0.9072499871253967,
0.370452344417572,
0.4435490369796753,
0.23052537441253662,
0.5702580213546753,
-0.007292989641427994,
0.20184864103794098,
0.18901866674423218,
-0.2713984549045563,
-0.489719957113266,
0.6797463893890381,
-0.95545494556427,
-0.23541054129600525,
0.9414736032485962,
-0.32685500383377075,
0.26382508873939514,
-0.3436552882194519,
-0.47831764817237854,
0.07079969346523285,
-0.4952125549316406,
0.6217470169067383,
0.6027751564979553,
0.09444970637559891,
-0.22819514572620392,
0.06612394005060196,
0.5356689095497131,
0.7952988743782043,
-0.8492318391799927,
0.13465416431427002,
0.3548831045627594,
0.4264664947986603,
0.23409801721572876,
0.9524569511413574,
0.09604180604219437,
0.3591081202030182,
-0.005328695755451918,
-0.09116767346858978,
0.2500500977039337,
-0.36899760365486145,
-0.11141723394393921,
0.2078181952238083,
-0.017116520553827286,
-0.33042430877685547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01152v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01152v1
|
A Survey of AI-generated Text Forensic Systems: Detection, Attribution, and Characterization
| 2024-03-02T09:39:13 | 2024-03-02T09:39:13 |
Tharindu Kumarage, Garima Agrawal, Paras Sheth, Raha Moraffah, Aman Chadha, Joshua Garland, Huan Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We have witnessed lately a rapid proliferation of advanced Large Language
Models (LLMs) capable of generating high-quality text. While these LLMs have
revolutionized text generation across various domains, they also pose
significant risks to the information ecosystem, such as the potential for
generating convincing propaganda, misinformation, and disinformation at scale.
This paper offers a review of AI-generated text forensic systems, an emerging
field addressing the challenges of LLM misuses. We present an overview of the
existing efforts in AI-generated text forensics by introducing a detailed
taxonomy, focusing on three primary pillars: detection, attribution, and
characterization. These pillars enable a practical understanding of
AI-generated text, from identifying AI-generated content (detection),
determining the specific AI model involved (attribution), and grouping the
underlying intents of the text (characterization). Furthermore, we explore
available resources for AI-generated text forensics research and discuss the
evolving challenges and future directions of forensic systems in an AI era.
|
[
-0.18523016571998596,
-0.91282719373703,
0.70986008644104,
-0.2062366008758545,
-0.04858241230249405,
0.14003773033618927,
0.10195274651050568,
-0.81546550989151,
0.17457088828086853,
0.7748963236808777,
-0.42594045400619507,
-0.2680565118789673,
-0.7253962159156799,
0.34332624077796936,
-1.048124074935913,
1.3239132165908813,
0.019045034423470497,
-0.24208912253379822,
-0.4302326738834381,
-0.0033353625331074,
-0.25024983286857605,
-0.780868411064148,
-0.6625645160675049,
-0.26232635974884033,
0.2757664918899536,
0.19216248393058777,
0.4072412848472595,
0.9684529900550842,
0.7676078677177429,
0.31308498978614807,
0.09062914550304413,
0.18957222998142242,
-0.1531587839126587,
0.33776065707206726,
0.04156000539660454,
-0.43261194229125977,
-0.2497294545173645,
0.18294242024421692,
0.5051032900810242,
0.07361495494842529,
0.06912325322628021,
0.21285566687583923,
-0.20351272821426392,
0.2760052978992462,
-0.7696330547332764,
-0.3889275789260864,
-0.8360845446586609,
-0.07434746623039246,
-0.5958636999130249,
-0.24812965095043182,
-0.5534666180610657,
-0.4008050262928009,
0.13703800737857819,
-0.42247307300567627,
0.2941288650035858,
0.155579075217247,
0.5559006929397583,
0.3668718934059143,
-0.5226264595985413,
-0.8375115394592285,
-0.9376049637794495,
0.6212661266326904,
-0.41344964504241943,
-0.11107020080089569,
0.3380829393863678,
0.36739811301231384,
0.18712832033634186,
-0.863703191280365,
-0.6119456887245178,
-0.13300743699073792,
-0.06910225749015808,
-0.12380706518888474,
-0.3255356550216675,
-0.04714619368314743,
-0.16631077229976654,
0.5820857882499695,
-0.2723093330860138,
0.24852389097213745,
-0.05232599005103111,
-0.6270999312400818,
0.7701424956321716,
0.5105074644088745,
0.6999982595443726,
-0.228451669216156,
-0.21165962517261505,
0.018677424639463425,
-0.9796274304389954,
-0.3671497106552124,
0.6390008330345154,
-0.03870179504156113,
0.15590500831604004,
0.5404837131500244,
0.1764206737279892,
0.37018755078315735,
-0.23036319017410278,
-0.44159752130508423,
-0.05801374837756157,
-0.7004315853118896,
-0.06997901201248169,
0.27949705719947815,
1.2072241306304932,
0.020179951563477516,
0.16031518578529358,
0.09175192564725876,
-0.3939785659313202,
-0.10542786866426468,
0.4114331901073456,
-0.5649473667144775,
-0.16612812876701355,
0.07918007671833038,
-0.8037035465240479,
-0.8323820233345032,
-0.11136416345834732,
-0.4631906747817993,
-0.7891438007354736,
-0.03396311774849892,
0.2633747160434723,
-0.5642445087432861,
-0.16991138458251953,
-0.07521378993988037,
-0.2914314568042755,
0.12369540333747864,
0.35140204429626465,
-0.6843438148498535,
0.22690285742282867,
0.49069276452064514,
0.6824791431427002,
-0.28527307510375977,
-0.12259012460708618,
-0.2571379244327545,
0.37698766589164734,
-0.1771215945482254,
0.922214686870575,
-0.23309294879436493,
-0.25541621446609497,
0.08251457661390305,
-0.3077763020992279,
0.5569848418235779,
-0.6641572117805481,
0.467526912689209,
-0.5366184115409851,
0.17869295179843903,
0.10894542187452316,
-0.3675675392150879,
-0.11418180167675018,
0.5486898422241211,
-0.7118311524391174,
0.8581060171127319,
-0.24385803937911987,
-0.8063803315162659,
0.42388811707496643,
-0.6361889839172363,
-0.6913979053497314,
0.4257444739341736,
-0.26355862617492676,
-0.4096749722957611,
-0.06678404659032822,
0.14579471945762634,
0.5278959274291992,
-0.5364983081817627,
0.4626738131046295,
0.16385075449943542,
-0.089775949716568,
0.3319834768772125,
-0.8086013197898865,
0.8764445185661316,
0.39956584572792053,
-0.1656816601753235,
0.07062403112649918,
-0.9782031774520874,
-0.4263727068901062,
0.292985737323761,
-0.4262043833732605,
-0.29516735672950745,
0.37143415212631226,
0.17766499519348145,
-0.4194450080394745,
0.4633219540119171,
-0.601814866065979,
-0.07352720201015472,
-0.3038052022457123,
0.4877568483352661,
0.5611428618431091,
0.21552030742168427,
0.2510196566581726,
-0.17005056142807007,
0.40394043922424316,
0.08089324831962585,
-0.06006262078881264,
-0.5784139037132263,
-0.32043981552124023,
-0.5143704414367676,
-0.3503638803958893,
0.08280818164348602,
0.8794190883636475,
-0.6927522420883179,
0.514703631401062,
-0.1497161090373993,
-0.5885707139968872,
-0.2899665832519531,
-0.27687305212020874,
0.4033301770687103,
0.2886776924133301,
0.2282768040895462,
0.0572703592479229,
-0.41696447134017944,
-1.0922771692276,
-0.48205748200416565,
-0.5347818732261658,
-0.3462599515914917,
0.23645949363708496,
0.708304226398468,
-0.285121351480484,
0.8847925066947937,
-0.29737353324890137,
-0.31279313564300537,
-0.14144998788833618,
0.4696354568004608,
-0.18381354212760925,
0.3702775835990906,
0.6573560833930969,
-0.5927891731262207,
-0.24706321954727173,
-0.06376194208860397,
-0.8810935020446777,
-0.11522386968135834,
-0.15731771290302277,
0.5366417765617371,
0.11358648538589478,
0.7558896541595459,
-0.4082881808280945,
0.3700518310070038,
0.06629274040460587,
-0.24524541199207306,
0.7801157236099243,
0.04343505576252937,
0.33507880568504333,
-0.9525117874145508,
0.22253720462322235,
-0.21359799802303314,
-0.45439431071281433,
-0.7168723940849304,
0.4001416563987732,
-0.14909936487674713,
-0.0926644429564476,
-0.4106687307357788,
0.28442877531051636,
-0.4332200288772583,
-0.04172183573246002,
-0.3939521312713623,
0.024661315605044365,
-0.15255138278007507,
-0.1782679408788681,
-0.1907578855752945,
0.7662099003791809,
0.2857844829559326,
-0.4241749942302704,
0.5902973413467407,
0.261380136013031,
-0.49481576681137085,
0.4798906445503235,
-0.43031206727027893,
0.08430028706789017,
-0.08145207911729813,
0.19205980002880096,
-0.7450466752052307,
-0.3811490535736084,
0.44535955786705017,
-0.7615983486175537,
0.20118142664432526,
0.026141859591007233,
-0.8596261143684387,
-0.016365543007850647,
-0.3618859350681305,
0.7832913994789124,
0.260989248752594,
-0.18227776885032654,
0.6993750929832458,
0.5004056096076965,
-0.3335941731929779,
-0.7132171392440796,
-0.7326271533966064,
0.5830573439598083,
-0.40525615215301514,
-0.5301547646522522,
0.420702189207077,
0.3271773159503937,
-0.7377004623413086,
-0.08536780625581741,
0.5649085640907288,
0.086029551923275,
0.44749948382377625,
0.15324421226978302,
0.11952077597379684,
-0.166503444314003,
0.1065637469291687,
0.0046432106755673885,
0.0017576729878783226,
0.3460606336593628,
0.07376029342412949,
0.4387993812561035,
0.1910516619682312,
-0.3970653712749481,
-0.4768390357494354,
0.5466935634613037,
0.6289203763008118,
-0.2450251281261444,
0.568861186504364,
0.4895825684070587,
-0.5010221600532532,
0.08798348903656006,
-0.4718784987926483,
-0.22753772139549255,
-0.41173410415649414,
0.37805262207984924,
-0.1066993698477745,
-0.8031084537506104,
0.6678721904754639,
0.11074519902467728,
0.18884672224521637,
0.8293185830116272,
0.7606011033058167,
0.021169280633330345,
0.9556477665901184,
0.6640801429748535,
-0.38580945134162903,
0.3209410011768341,
0.24173913896083832,
0.42857638001441956,
-0.4118466377258301,
-0.24441736936569214,
-0.8023715019226074,
0.03826334327459335,
-0.5011726021766663,
0.14134366810321808,
0.5348412990570068,
-0.24502290785312653,
-0.44857141375541687,
-0.07002953439950943,
-0.4843495488166809,
0.5248607397079468,
0.6355922222137451,
-0.2056313455104828,
0.5270471572875977,
0.07447272539138794,
0.46612539887428284,
0.3721258044242859,
-0.12190298736095428,
-0.9245864748954773,
1.293015480041504,
0.5605807304382324,
0.3999723792076111,
0.11625706404447556,
0.7211253643035889,
0.7976292967796326,
0.29456791281700134,
-0.9127954840660095,
0.45617789030075073,
-0.22050227224826813,
-0.9383925199508667,
-0.30606380105018616,
-0.08477503061294556,
-0.6823064684867859,
-0.3039216101169586,
-0.3947858214378357,
-0.8200342655181885,
-0.30640822649002075,
-0.07058294117450714,
-0.3055744469165802,
0.37091007828712463,
0.015800900757312775,
0.1291951984167099,
-0.14149148762226105,
-0.013870513066649437,
-0.33727601170539856,
-0.6711522936820984,
0.48392727971076965,
-0.19394582509994507,
0.2428659200668335,
0.05227337405085564,
-0.05134088546037674,
0.9877279996871948,
-0.39952194690704346,
0.6462081074714661,
-0.01336049847304821,
-0.5643271207809448,
0.8365556597709656,
0.4959835708141327,
0.5200665593147278,
0.13934718072414398,
0.09050959348678589,
0.08573727309703827,
-0.03776709362864494,
0.19655846059322357,
-0.1227225661277771,
0.2830626964569092,
-0.5713127255439758,
-0.5036627054214478,
-0.2659110426902771,
-0.6672027707099915,
0.12788332998752594,
0.5635987520217896,
0.6744502782821655,
0.48753437399864197,
-0.4718707799911499,
-0.07731498032808304,
0.8203549981117249,
-0.43224141001701355,
0.5381381511688232,
0.16011856496334076,
0.016279269009828568,
-0.3933424949645996,
1.3258625268936157,
-0.49366089701652527,
-0.05417320132255554,
0.2757182717323303,
-0.05527913197875023,
-0.05693621560931206,
-1.1517261266708374,
-0.6015931367874146,
-0.05621285364031792,
-0.7691332101821899,
-0.5618629455566406,
-0.6773098111152649,
-0.29737547039985657,
-0.4834378659725189,
-0.15471026301383972,
-0.33107414841651917,
-0.2180938571691513,
-0.8123285174369812,
0.04022228345274925,
0.3831329047679901,
1.0144461393356323,
0.1631065011024475,
0.48625993728637695,
-0.993614912033081,
0.3410814106464386,
-0.08951938897371292,
0.002750720363110304,
-0.11807296425104141,
-0.31204167008399963,
-0.08810198307037354,
-0.05202978849411011,
-0.3613838851451874,
-0.7175472378730774,
0.37430644035339355,
0.009929708205163479,
0.2137734591960907,
0.597955048084259,
-0.07729402929544449,
-0.19741134345531464,
-0.5681543350219727,
1.2808724641799927,
0.06066408380866051,
-0.7450123429298401,
0.519697368144989,
-0.6314617395401001,
-0.30841946601867676,
0.4063754379749298,
0.29462161660194397,
-0.30822107195854187,
-0.5677529573440552,
-0.34703028202056885,
-0.7564867734909058,
0.5235223770141602,
0.1938047707080841,
0.3494853079319,
0.10319043695926666,
0.4438651204109192,
0.28138887882232666,
0.21339166164398193,
-0.8397054076194763,
-0.38504743576049805,
-0.08993823081254959,
-0.5265703201293945,
0.16393128037452698,
-0.2098073810338974,
-0.3171866238117218,
0.29918473958969116,
0.4916098117828369,
-0.10966602712869644,
0.44586172699928284,
-0.061441484838724136,
-0.1580209583044052,
0.17305110394954681,
-0.005337780807167292,
0.5264280438423157,
0.11516116559505463,
0.06237124651670456,
0.03427090868353844,
-0.25760993361473083,
-0.6871034502983093,
0.418152779340744,
-0.18905216455459595,
-0.3702029883861542,
-0.28142136335372925,
0.8885858654975891,
0.3873358368873596,
-0.74215167760849,
-0.7593321800231934,
0.6694210171699524,
0.02382199652493,
-0.4442388713359833,
-0.65496426820755,
0.05088745802640915,
-0.3614504635334015,
0.08988812565803528,
0.7470180988311768,
0.034779902547597885,
0.5930618643760681,
-0.6675595641136169,
0.02415418066084385,
0.6294692158699036,
-0.08107306808233261,
-0.20338767766952515,
0.49802568554878235,
0.2562958300113678,
-0.42713338136672974,
0.7969261407852173,
0.10891301929950714,
-0.49796152114868164,
0.5858960151672363,
0.4608256220817566,
0.9717984795570374,
0.08079495280981064,
0.057180095463991165,
-0.05279654636979103,
0.4800645112991333,
0.12800471484661102,
-0.10100382566452026,
-0.012181983329355717,
-1.0373488664627075,
0.03584590181708336,
-0.5198193192481995,
-0.10535302013158798,
0.3936960995197296,
-0.37888139486312866,
0.22970622777938843,
-0.5306310057640076,
-0.08228355646133423,
0.12159842252731323,
-0.3899189829826355,
-0.18339993059635162,
0.22622190415859222,
0.2809954285621643,
0.6902006268501282,
-0.8023068904876709,
0.30401018261909485,
0.4795065224170685,
-0.2563372850418091,
-0.2941068112850189,
0.07698585838079453,
0.4546530544757843,
-0.8482863306999207,
0.47260138392448425,
0.028526317328214645,
-0.31524658203125,
0.15040837228298187,
-1.0234804153442383,
-0.7272583842277527,
0.9471001029014587,
0.21404443681240082,
0.12614329159259796,
-0.21998032927513123,
0.43786686658859253,
0.5036014318466187,
-0.38799309730529785,
0.04642066732048988,
0.8159151673316956,
0.33373433351516724,
-0.32170572876930237,
-0.586591899394989,
0.07918480783700943,
-0.3050388991832733,
-0.3123210668563843,
0.25517308712005615,
-0.2580704391002655,
0.8315961956977844,
0.0832316055893898,
-0.4584731161594391,
0.3054807484149933,
0.5843621492385864,
0.15243814885616302,
0.24997709691524506,
0.17000290751457214,
0.42894846200942993,
0.4718917906284332,
0.02655569091439247,
0.9380873441696167,
-0.0627085268497467,
-0.12744122743606567,
0.6132916212081909,
-0.11146362125873566,
0.42982587218284607,
0.40478086471557617,
-0.15281197428703308,
0.5613287687301636,
0.6128620505332947,
-0.29842638969421387,
0.24443741142749786,
0.20769014954566956,
-0.2923617660999298,
-0.041045982390642166,
-0.31047117710113525,
-0.02354038506746292,
0.7910219430923462,
0.6927394270896912,
-0.729677140712738,
-0.05215607210993767,
0.19986112415790558,
-0.15943150222301483,
0.0910138338804245,
-0.34155893325805664,
1.1993932723999023,
-0.4198412001132965,
-0.5179126262664795,
0.14107894897460938,
0.34813299775123596,
0.8119277954101562,
-0.17843809723854065,
0.013537231832742691,
0.07715311646461487,
0.001137354876846075,
-0.10693953186273575,
-0.9337911009788513,
0.3465516269207001,
0.0991264283657074,
-0.44425058364868164,
-0.3019999861717224,
1.1613456010818481,
-0.03829800337553024,
-0.27435624599456787,
-0.1557009071111679,
0.4026235044002533,
0.2677991986274719,
-0.247235968708992,
-0.19474796950817108,
0.012428343296051025,
-0.049972351640462875,
-0.16614745557308197,
0.21717122197151184,
0.4090573787689209,
-0.08471386879682541,
0.8293683528900146,
0.365785151720047,
-0.03595472127199173,
-0.011498075909912586,
-0.31919774413108826,
0.5719522833824158,
-0.5254531502723694,
-0.3028794527053833,
-1.0189110040664673,
0.25270727276802063,
0.08145950734615326,
-0.0939834862947464,
0.38277363777160645,
0.3434234857559204,
0.6387559771537781,
0.0488126203417778,
1.1956512928009033,
-0.2980900704860687,
0.5994022488594055,
-0.5642070174217224,
1.1918411254882812,
-0.6309389472007751,
0.20110207796096802,
-0.2541341185569763,
-0.6233531832695007,
-0.2529851794242859,
0.03465377539396286,
0.18354086577892303,
-0.21774065494537354,
0.48112013936042786,
0.4035785496234894,
0.08966492116451263,
0.13860532641410828,
-0.08661135286092758,
-0.24421773850917816,
0.5826612114906311,
0.3499253988265991,
0.9737817645072937,
-0.4770151376724243,
0.5597503781318665,
0.37716493010520935,
-0.06754973530769348,
-0.22459080815315247,
-0.8861516714096069,
-0.6746410131454468,
-0.8377059102058411,
-0.0891248881816864,
0.003101994516327977,
-0.28791967034339905,
0.2812453508377075,
0.2069031447172165,
-0.634009599685669,
-0.06949129700660706,
-0.21974582970142365,
-0.05323294922709465,
0.3602357804775238,
-0.18501392006874084,
0.20177844166755676,
-0.06887716799974442,
-0.621187150478363,
0.19611532986164093,
0.19048115611076355,
0.38752031326293945,
-0.455886572599411,
0.351176917552948,
-0.1870609074831009,
0.20526233315467834,
0.6724374294281006,
-0.012112435884773731,
-0.7404826879501343,
-0.4233314096927643,
-0.1906689703464508,
-0.2895703911781311,
-0.11950420588254929,
1.1595499515533447,
-0.5771413445472717,
-0.00287529150955379,
0.5592688918113708,
0.9486249685287476,
0.018531832844018936,
-0.0925283133983612,
0.7852795720100403,
-0.6693345904350281,
-0.10294249653816223,
0.5112695097923279,
0.1350899189710617,
0.22106632590293884,
-0.7320813536643982,
0.24403339624404907,
0.29614388942718506,
-0.5587252974510193,
-1.0121504068374634,
0.513014554977417,
-0.31685811281204224,
-0.5022886991500854,
0.7680715322494507,
-0.004952343180775642,
0.06735321134328842,
-0.31733110547065735,
-0.022861631587147713,
0.38742417097091675,
-0.08588796108961105,
0.6343317031860352,
0.789040207862854,
-0.09689852595329285,
0.06874606758356094,
-0.10653446614742279,
0.6928776502609253,
0.06903373450040817,
-0.8992446660995483,
0.4271409213542938,
0.9028738141059875,
0.08655965328216553,
0.5922125577926636,
0.6012190580368042,
-0.38088393211364746,
0.05059921368956566,
0.025330593809485435,
0.09120461344718933,
-0.042766354978084564,
-0.5858047008514404,
-0.0858762338757515,
0.29616326093673706,
-0.017524002119898796,
0.03541882336139679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04780v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04780v2
|
MuseGraph: Graph-oriented Instruction Tuning of Large Language Models for Generic Graph Mining
| 2024-03-02T09:27:32 | 2024-03-13T15:52:33 |
Yanchao Tan, Hang Lv, Xinyi Huang, Jiawei Zhang, Shiping Wang, Carl Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Graphs with abundant attributes are essential in modeling interconnected
entities and improving predictions in various real-world applications.
Traditional Graph Neural Networks (GNNs), which are commonly used for modeling
attributed graphs, need to be re-trained every time when applied to different
graph tasks and datasets. Although the emergence of Large Language Models
(LLMs) has introduced a new paradigm in natural language processing, the
generative potential of LLMs in graph mining remains largely under-explored. To
this end, we propose a novel framework MuseGraph, which seamlessly integrates
the strengths of GNNs and LLMs and facilitates a more effective and generic
approach for graph mining across different tasks and datasets. Specifically, we
first introduce a compact graph description via the proposed adaptive input
generation to encapsulate key information from the graph under the constraints
of language token limitations. Then, we propose a diverse instruction
generation mechanism, which distills the reasoning capabilities from LLMs
(e.g., GPT-4) to create task-specific Chain-of-Thought-based instruction
packages for different graph tasks. Finally, we propose a graph-aware
instruction tuning with a dynamic instruction package allocation strategy
across tasks and datasets, ensuring the effectiveness and generalization of the
training process. Our experimental results demonstrate significant improvements
in different graph tasks, showcasing the potential of our MuseGraph in
enhancing the accuracy of graph-oriented downstream tasks while keeping the
generation powers of LLMs.
|
[
0.009652109816670418,
-0.6742882132530212,
0.5314858555793762,
-0.09579450637102127,
-0.16617465019226074,
0.4841928780078888,
-0.2100842148065567,
-0.22409626841545105,
0.17383235692977905,
0.46302762627601624,
-0.8116868734359741,
-1.0156937837600708,
-0.5999283790588379,
-0.12269994616508484,
-0.17049601674079895,
0.7721790075302124,
-0.05229847505688667,
-0.012148904614150524,
-0.3599330484867096,
-0.12620310485363007,
-0.5509417057037354,
-0.21217156946659088,
-0.7471392750740051,
-0.3814106583595276,
0.594586968421936,
0.29569897055625916,
0.42837971448898315,
0.781360924243927,
0.14323478937149048,
0.36155444383621216,
0.20126372575759888,
0.719569206237793,
-0.6810895204544067,
0.02238333597779274,
-0.2701936662197113,
-0.5900532603263855,
-0.6686239838600159,
-0.10750465840101242,
0.6843135356903076,
0.7158448100090027,
0.12984944880008698,
0.2780832350254059,
0.24564959108829498,
0.23143582046031952,
-0.33361130952835083,
0.7268635034561157,
-0.7697535157203674,
-0.03630666434764862,
-0.3765953779220581,
-0.2219604253768921,
-0.6095740795135498,
-0.16930320858955383,
-0.19455699622631073,
-0.6817196607589722,
0.45122307538986206,
0.25333428382873535,
0.7575077414512634,
0.17489106953144073,
-0.244125634431839,
-0.2032732516527176,
-0.23162822425365448,
0.43956851959228516,
-0.4868134558200836,
0.1624710112810135,
0.17437362670898438,
0.284770131111145,
-0.3354409337043762,
-1.0984386205673218,
-0.2910636365413666,
0.07551763951778412,
-0.12269425392150879,
0.03556632250547409,
-0.2963084578514099,
0.1963646113872528,
0.11004431545734406,
0.30411291122436523,
-0.4889014959335327,
0.5308097004890442,
0.03885488212108612,
-0.334113746881485,
0.1852022111415863,
0.38832521438598633,
0.3900738060474396,
-0.144429013133049,
-0.025498008355498314,
0.10007213056087494,
-0.8454052209854126,
-0.1529160737991333,
0.5690970420837402,
0.6387141346931458,
0.1854018121957779,
0.4638477563858032,
-0.2584063708782196,
1.0000783205032349,
0.045665305107831955,
0.013865616172552109,
0.32956352829933167,
0.05601311847567558,
-0.15873095393180847,
-0.10977154970169067,
0.6764763593673706,
0.1887206733226776,
0.15862077474594116,
-0.5279190540313721,
-0.03213998302817345,
0.09957912564277649,
0.25144413113594055,
-0.8443301320075989,
-0.47999510169029236,
-0.24100753664970398,
-0.10640131682157516,
-0.37421050667762756,
-0.23859208822250366,
-0.6360845565795898,
-0.3996526002883911,
-0.22621934115886688,
0.15854576230049133,
-0.4791705310344696,
0.07857772707939148,
-0.012047491036355495,
-0.04650231823325157,
-0.0699344202876091,
0.1774487942457199,
-0.9293146729469299,
0.23674209415912628,
0.7694866061210632,
0.8431743383407593,
-0.23292483389377594,
-0.3649293780326843,
-0.7660373449325562,
0.3844871520996094,
-0.10669239610433578,
0.8101226091384888,
-0.863539457321167,
-0.27714234590530396,
-0.08559224754571915,
0.13529899716377258,
-0.5795246362686157,
-0.39736753702163696,
0.43554213643074036,
-0.6141321063041687,
0.007572160568088293,
-0.11683841049671173,
-0.5996706485748291,
-0.261522114276886,
0.4139822721481323,
-0.5689049959182739,
1.0317277908325195,
0.5046968460083008,
-0.7452251315116882,
0.32406434416770935,
-0.7548558115959167,
-0.7447917461395264,
0.22095388174057007,
-0.024324316531419754,
-0.47813084721565247,
-0.17639215290546417,
0.49770593643188477,
0.4413778781890869,
-0.4267512857913971,
0.07149998843669891,
-0.3985004127025604,
-0.3338596224784851,
0.008306743577122688,
-0.37369200587272644,
0.7132938504219055,
-0.03911822661757469,
-0.42748045921325684,
0.3842192590236664,
-0.6271637082099915,
0.2886432707309723,
0.13136540353298187,
-0.34535419940948486,
0.11019843816757202,
0.107718825340271,
-0.37195226550102234,
0.009782509878277779,
0.16189144551753998,
-0.4754015803337097,
0.35039302706718445,
-0.2095281183719635,
0.9094370007514954,
0.9736504554748535,
-0.061601851135492325,
0.18218746781349182,
-0.03622281551361084,
0.4486672580242157,
-0.29400813579559326,
-0.017562104389071465,
-0.13229058682918549,
-0.4383438229560852,
-0.9003983736038208,
-0.4746440649032593,
0.34485384821891785,
0.6268576979637146,
-0.6568836569786072,
0.3853963613510132,
-0.6208515763282776,
-0.26441505551338196,
-0.34375232458114624,
0.27183154225349426,
0.26863670349121094,
0.7523179054260254,
0.25582632422447205,
-0.2515890300273895,
-0.4349583685398102,
-0.5797967910766602,
-0.04154504835605621,
-0.014264512807130814,
0.07347386330366135,
0.8166683912277222,
-0.03054370917379856,
-0.32534292340278625,
0.856155514717102,
-0.9179926514625549,
-0.2684327960014343,
-0.4636553227901459,
0.062735415995121,
0.24589364230632782,
0.2857019007205963,
0.5062865018844604,
-0.3087491989135742,
-0.40049394965171814,
-0.052679333835840225,
-0.5830152034759521,
-0.27290594577789307,
0.09152717143297195,
-0.42858052253723145,
-0.08289521187543869,
0.5494588017463684,
-0.744879961013794,
0.1398514062166214,
0.4301878809928894,
0.040679335594177246,
0.3417009711265564,
-0.15541890263557434,
-0.1239328533411026,
-0.9516021013259888,
-0.19466577470302582,
-0.2194601446390152,
-0.5751276016235352,
-0.16840513050556183,
0.20633310079574585,
-0.1537705659866333,
-0.5254181623458862,
-0.013158069923520088,
0.2674684524536133,
-0.5346834063529968,
-0.016674773767590523,
-0.35024574398994446,
0.2856101095676422,
0.1937238723039627,
0.622207760810852,
-0.30276015400886536,
0.6502124667167664,
0.8988999128341675,
-0.4396494925022125,
0.7282720804214478,
0.12514622509479523,
-0.27499812841415405,
0.5791867971420288,
-0.3141001760959625,
0.4672170579433441,
-0.07877197116613388,
0.4214685261249542,
-0.9978561997413635,
-0.3299546241760254,
0.3874609172344208,
-0.29650822281837463,
0.6945887207984924,
-0.4281585216522217,
-0.5340189337730408,
-0.7370538115501404,
0.11443394422531128,
-0.049332790076732635,
0.29341211915016174,
-0.7052252888679504,
0.8464294672012329,
0.3495714068412781,
-0.07276340574026108,
-0.41370365023612976,
-0.4419623017311096,
0.22192750871181488,
-0.11745991557836533,
-0.7391287684440613,
0.4186965227127075,
0.17535383999347687,
0.42278820276260376,
0.4158448576927185,
-0.13128457963466644,
0.11759807169437408,
0.09720193594694138,
0.22831682860851288,
0.2547948658466339,
-0.21321438252925873,
0.21857595443725586,
0.044370464980602264,
-0.31106436252593994,
-0.1482105404138565,
-0.9715293049812317,
0.9214325547218323,
-0.010922199115157127,
-0.4818473756313324,
-0.19109277427196503,
0.012300338596105576,
0.3125377595424652,
-0.4513443112373352,
0.5075746774673462,
0.773517906665802,
-0.18433412909507751,
-0.5004171133041382,
-0.05253630131483078,
0.11498785763978958,
-0.5086624622344971,
0.6469095945358276,
-0.3604876697063446,
-0.9135472774505615,
0.439859002828598,
-0.6142898201942444,
-0.023374691605567932,
0.3148943781852722,
0.5454900860786438,
-0.03207375109195709,
1.0063481330871582,
0.4032405912876129,
-0.38055914640426636,
0.4461731016635895,
-0.5795740485191345,
0.3162895739078522,
-1.028261423110962,
-0.156375914812088,
-0.2897033095359802,
-0.6297236084938049,
-0.4104963541030884,
-0.5397217869758606,
0.12536339461803436,
-0.1513921171426773,
-0.3362218737602234,
0.2808091938495636,
-0.5674023628234863,
0.55088871717453,
0.6242218613624573,
0.3056727349758148,
-0.14051783084869385,
0.01845932938158512,
-0.19825051724910736,
0.2937449514865875,
-0.915183424949646,
-0.291989803314209,
1.1369612216949463,
-0.1513405442237854,
0.7069196105003357,
-0.13471978902816772,
0.5464791655540466,
0.23860172927379608,
0.4341264069080353,
-0.6491183638572693,
0.7587981820106506,
-0.43764063715934753,
-0.19195829331874847,
-0.3228915333747864,
-0.6172440052032471,
-1.0258874893188477,
-0.04806068539619446,
-0.05208558589220047,
-0.9451462626457214,
-0.3173270523548126,
0.43254390358924866,
0.04961321875452995,
0.5578298568725586,
-0.753415048122406,
1.0400100946426392,
-0.24633429944515228,
-0.253104567527771,
-0.13107147812843323,
-0.2605677545070648,
0.07696808874607086,
0.2822202146053314,
-0.06880635023117065,
-0.2111644744873047,
0.19245906174182892,
0.2952175438404083,
-0.4153846502304077,
1.1482594013214111,
-0.30747660994529724,
0.23839716613292694,
0.44422951340675354,
0.03521343320608139,
0.9757037162780762,
-0.044146277010440826,
-0.06470012664794922,
0.07244133204221725,
-0.7818859219551086,
-0.33876895904541016,
-0.7347713708877563,
1.0058746337890625,
-0.6797780394554138,
-0.9355524778366089,
0.11012522131204605,
-0.9922972917556763,
-0.3801308870315552,
0.4722811281681061,
0.37826868891716003,
0.6537740230560303,
-0.11918136477470398,
-0.0018620491027832031,
0.4416555166244507,
-0.01833084598183632,
0.0655367448925972,
0.05135386064648628,
0.034863412380218506,
-0.32284003496170044,
1.2880066633224487,
0.1423613578081131,
0.24988099932670593,
0.5359102487564087,
0.0646623969078064,
-0.15571695566177368,
-0.7491672039031982,
-0.6917572617530823,
0.04404381662607193,
-0.7565500140190125,
-0.2899787127971649,
-0.705753743648529,
-0.07845563441514969,
-0.5397329330444336,
-0.10520441085100174,
-0.03080095909535885,
-0.3581170439720154,
-0.5439938306808472,
-0.28610408306121826,
0.5327214598655701,
0.2908410131931305,
0.291989803314209,
0.32674989104270935,
-0.4365087151527405,
0.05502219498157501,
0.566318690776825,
0.5477005839347839,
0.06724805384874344,
-0.18924491107463837,
-0.2034822702407837,
-0.02851467952132225,
-0.4191155433654785,
-0.6145598888397217,
0.09287860244512558,
0.3873947560787201,
0.7305839657783508,
0.2772817611694336,
-0.08490590006113052,
0.7010031938552856,
-0.7294957041740417,
0.43535494804382324,
-0.09054305404424667,
-0.8825139999389648,
0.24021267890930176,
-0.4514530599117279,
0.10003439337015152,
0.10385625809431076,
0.08176722377538681,
-0.4311196506023407,
-0.40135306119918823,
-0.5496824383735657,
-1.025016188621521,
0.7799403667449951,
-0.11879124492406845,
0.2897855341434479,
-0.048361122608184814,
0.3079570531845093,
-0.1470441073179245,
0.17178653180599213,
-0.5880899429321289,
-0.06284410506486893,
-0.5792633891105652,
-0.592951774597168,
0.036375947296619415,
0.15233658254146576,
-0.32080182433128357,
-0.12039877474308014,
0.6115718483924866,
-0.5058510303497314,
0.3246791660785675,
-0.41793182492256165,
-0.32913780212402344,
0.12423618882894516,
0.0038984541315585375,
0.046710845082998276,
0.5963647961616516,
-0.01637379266321659,
0.31115859746932983,
0.2806583642959595,
-0.4245053231716156,
-0.039763495326042175,
0.355398029088974,
-0.32197991013526917,
-0.2680899500846863,
0.33582592010498047,
1.2407341003417969,
0.33544138073921204,
-0.4797099828720093,
0.20795397460460663,
0.37358558177948,
0.13741733133792877,
0.09962999075651169,
0.5456581115722656,
0.536992609500885,
0.0982188731431961,
0.034635040909051895,
0.07238812744617462,
-0.06143336743116379,
-0.4298807382583618,
0.10799399763345718,
0.5479716062545776,
-0.41267287731170654,
-0.25451990962028503,
0.7104051113128662,
0.2316901981830597,
-0.4963722229003906,
0.9966046810150146,
-0.4593997001647949,
-0.5665022730827332,
0.4862859845161438,
1.0079792737960815,
0.8318086862564087,
0.07695942372083664,
0.3884844481945038,
0.18789081275463104,
0.23796305060386658,
0.5339167714118958,
-0.16939204931259155,
0.11237727850675583,
-0.8049631118774414,
-0.41422128677368164,
-0.39523082971572876,
-0.2278527468442917,
-0.0165175162255764,
-0.3446672856807709,
0.09793440252542496,
-0.48333144187927246,
-0.13547278940677643,
0.058209288865327835,
-0.11501038819551468,
-0.609285831451416,
0.046777017414569855,
-0.08561607450246811,
0.644078254699707,
-0.5893113613128662,
0.6904768943786621,
0.6065159440040588,
-0.07448939234018326,
-0.8523162603378296,
-0.20556025207042694,
0.054660264402627945,
-1.0975102186203003,
0.4594796299934387,
0.2713724970817566,
-0.1139955073595047,
0.3937419652938843,
-0.39128515124320984,
-0.8544124364852905,
1.262312412261963,
0.6531065106391907,
-0.2910972535610199,
-0.03924443945288658,
0.20762348175048828,
0.3139266073703766,
-0.6248493790626526,
-0.2713419198989868,
0.5085884928703308,
0.23796166479587555,
0.2946363091468811,
-0.30016839504241943,
0.12601447105407715,
-0.29120463132858276,
-0.07341990619897842,
0.44737663865089417,
-0.6841496229171753,
0.8913421034812927,
-0.18952171504497528,
-0.31169962882995605,
-0.1151471808552742,
0.5522505044937134,
0.17695385217666626,
0.11803639680147171,
0.5325507521629333,
0.7714198231697083,
1.2294518947601318,
-0.3121695816516876,
1.1676609516143799,
-0.4501463770866394,
0.1891564577817917,
1.1491352319717407,
-0.3223368525505066,
0.13195517659187317,
-0.2874790132045746,
-0.022574961185455322,
0.765122652053833,
0.6974725127220154,
-0.1431286782026291,
0.28780797123908997,
0.3943566679954529,
-0.2469238042831421,
-0.467536598443985,
0.0035431513097137213,
-0.009974384680390358,
0.3517175316810608,
0.4538378417491913,
-0.39605090022087097,
-0.38540151715278625,
-0.06463782489299774,
0.1647014319896698,
-0.09094850718975067,
-0.5319363474845886,
0.393701434135437,
-0.22862650454044342,
-0.4258866608142853,
0.35397565364837646,
0.055736202746629715,
0.2293422818183899,
-0.6455042958259583,
0.01978074386715889,
0.08937278389930725,
0.2006807178258896,
-0.13457274436950684,
-0.5915493369102478,
-0.11308375746011734,
0.07189825922250748,
-0.3474861681461334,
-0.06750500202178955,
0.8158870339393616,
-0.1731937825679779,
-0.6488997340202332,
0.06518026441335678,
0.10707099735736847,
-0.10891654342412949,
0.21224157512187958,
-0.6110073924064636,
-0.17963244020938873,
0.050489019602537155,
-0.03432224690914154,
0.39618223905563354,
0.598842442035675,
-0.22481191158294678,
0.7544554471969604,
0.8430603742599487,
0.1575217992067337,
0.21642132103443146,
0.32933568954467773,
1.2501858472824097,
-0.26714545488357544,
-0.5315181612968445,
-0.5973262190818787,
0.28960514068603516,
-0.31551381945610046,
-0.19282056391239166,
0.835102379322052,
0.6889323592185974,
0.5833790898323059,
0.15907151997089386,
0.7945778369903564,
-0.03537142649292946,
0.27513980865478516,
-0.6240989565849304,
0.4056476652622223,
-0.0537673719227314,
0.1140168085694313,
-0.30471229553222656,
-0.9685729742050171,
-0.3030926287174225,
0.4504888653755188,
-0.4185445010662079,
0.034122224897146225,
0.46879640221595764,
0.8768954873085022,
-0.2194085270166397,
-0.10231953114271164,
-0.21385246515274048,
0.23513227701187134,
0.4918712377548218,
0.5906133055686951,
0.4138437509536743,
0.11859910935163498,
0.7113131880760193,
0.24162869155406952,
-0.23489069938659668,
-0.02478042058646679,
-0.8323785662651062,
-0.8605622053146362,
-0.23836974799633026,
-0.24882511794567108,
-0.2736643850803375,
-0.04344955459237099,
0.5578264594078064,
0.6710295081138611,
-0.48341044783592224,
0.07692856341600418,
-0.3734700679779053,
0.3191337287425995,
-0.3949746787548065,
-0.2150643914937973,
0.768904447555542,
-0.6005915403366089,
-0.860004723072052,
0.47788429260253906,
0.5464083552360535,
-0.13427680730819702,
-0.1099853515625,
0.07873090356588364,
0.0362267829477787,
0.0024705221876502037,
0.4896514415740967,
0.24288471043109894,
-0.24196983873844147,
-0.619500458240509,
0.14541468024253845,
0.11037927120923996,
0.11573923379182816,
0.9774662256240845,
-0.6157000660896301,
0.5436844229698181,
0.32689541578292847,
0.6261622905731201,
0.8176335692405701,
-0.1483781933784485,
0.3926478326320648,
-0.9907909631729126,
0.2517527639865875,
0.08355219662189484,
0.5366663932800293,
0.4672614336013794,
-0.44521474838256836,
0.3753412067890167,
0.4813324809074402,
-0.35074976086616516,
-0.8107435703277588,
0.6158139705657959,
-0.8285189270973206,
-0.21066991984844208,
0.7903759479522705,
-0.48038697242736816,
-0.29460081458091736,
-0.025961782783269882,
-0.15199579298496246,
0.4040736258029938,
-0.04550414904952049,
0.6654162406921387,
0.5151670575141907,
-0.31691282987594604,
0.04773474857211113,
-0.06111926585435867,
0.10433996468782425,
-0.22121982276439667,
-0.8180937170982361,
0.2527769207954407,
0.627528965473175,
0.37121665477752686,
0.01099956315010786,
0.49466344714164734,
0.09558019787073135,
0.0061393603682518005,
0.1554238349199295,
-0.06778611987829208,
-0.6353739500045776,
-0.21228386461734772,
0.4262276887893677,
0.33425650000572205,
-0.03812149167060852,
-0.33848756551742554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01139v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01139v4
|
ParallelPARC: A Scalable Pipeline for Generating Natural-Language Analogies
| 2024-03-02T08:53:40 | 2024-05-14T16:41:24 |
Oren Sultan, Yonatan Bitton, Ron Yosef, Dafna Shahaf
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Analogy-making is central to human cognition, allowing us to adapt to novel
situations -- an ability that current AI systems still lack. Most analogy
datasets today focus on simple analogies (e.g., word analogies); datasets
including complex types of analogies are typically manually curated and very
small. We believe that this holds back progress in computational analogy. In
this work, we design a data generation pipeline, ParallelPARC (Parallel
Paragraph Creator) leveraging state-of-the-art Large Language Models (LLMs) to
create complex, paragraph-based analogies, as well as distractors, both simple
and challenging. We demonstrate our pipeline and create ProPara-Logy, a dataset
of analogies between scientific processes. We publish a gold-set, validated by
humans, and a silver-set, generated automatically. We test LLMs' and humans'
analogy recognition in binary and multiple-choice settings, and found that
humans outperform the best models (~13% gap) after a light supervision. We
demonstrate that our silver-set is useful for training models. Lastly, we show
challenging distractors confuse LLMs, but not humans. We hope our pipeline will
encourage research in this emerging field.
|
[
-0.40309110283851624,
-0.5319116711616516,
0.7419441938400269,
0.1969386339187622,
-0.29483795166015625,
0.014142674393951893,
-0.31531015038490295,
-0.19659295678138733,
0.2607031464576721,
0.14019432663917542,
-0.5907249450683594,
-0.23348385095596313,
-0.44053134322166443,
0.27825412154197693,
-0.5048384666442871,
0.9163466095924377,
-0.044270094484090805,
0.052114807069301605,
-0.5188507437705994,
-0.07130704075098038,
-0.4191642701625824,
-0.3571273386478424,
-0.6917813420295715,
-0.35732874274253845,
0.47860991954803467,
0.3035491406917572,
0.7672284245491028,
0.9901067018508911,
0.40160393714904785,
0.42562609910964966,
0.011587142944335938,
-0.0200948566198349,
-0.4456542730331421,
0.048520248383283615,
-0.4366036653518677,
-0.39607474207878113,
-0.15781404078006744,
0.07422278076410294,
0.5969071984291077,
0.9927480220794678,
-0.05389922857284546,
0.20744052529335022,
0.10773014277219772,
0.5573254823684692,
-0.6265653967857361,
0.3958098292350769,
-0.8475059270858765,
0.1727191060781479,
-0.2490377128124237,
0.021691346541047096,
0.061102885752916336,
-0.3464469015598297,
0.08604948222637177,
-0.8286506533622742,
0.40470966696739197,
0.5052566528320312,
0.7616758346557617,
0.15851537883281708,
0.17394928634166718,
-0.4583594501018524,
-0.6772743463516235,
0.8346021771430969,
-0.5698596835136414,
0.07187847793102264,
-0.013615484349429607,
0.4064902365207672,
-0.2681845426559448,
-1.142571210861206,
-0.977027952671051,
-0.1875002235174179,
0.08913509547710419,
0.23469604551792145,
-0.07058418542146683,
-0.1434093415737152,
0.22905047237873077,
0.4063767194747925,
-0.49337175488471985,
0.16858775913715363,
-0.37536031007766724,
-0.10754777491092682,
0.2864106297492981,
0.6762872338294983,
0.46730801463127136,
-0.02521275170147419,
-0.28330016136169434,
-0.11238440126180649,
-0.7938597202301025,
-0.223593607544899,
0.30944451689720154,
0.07204156368970871,
0.20527687668800354,
0.4584818184375763,
-0.23061497509479523,
0.7192503809928894,
-0.07969183474779129,
-0.05649430304765701,
0.1132063940167427,
-0.3318844437599182,
-0.014768147841095924,
0.2102615386247635,
0.9328601956367493,
0.5724949836730957,
0.32850709557533264,
-0.42121028900146484,
0.017742685973644257,
0.5820746421813965,
0.2163226455450058,
-0.7950584292411804,
-0.3622525632381439,
0.07892496138811111,
-0.2671225368976593,
-0.2865409851074219,
0.021338175982236862,
-0.7617231011390686,
-0.4982478618621826,
-0.6968600153923035,
0.30594226717948914,
-0.3015429973602295,
0.12583282589912415,
0.21011044085025787,
-0.3684600293636322,
0.06457705050706863,
0.08514424413442612,
-0.8858286738395691,
0.7846918106079102,
0.8436993360519409,
0.8223840594291687,
-0.3751346468925476,
-0.9515873789787292,
-0.5029410123825073,
0.3408711850643158,
-0.3145979046821594,
1.0148301124572754,
-0.4836156368255615,
-0.2228049486875534,
-0.25493377447128296,
-0.19147907197475433,
0.0038704758044332266,
-0.9091410636901855,
0.851088285446167,
0.07739275693893433,
0.3519994020462036,
-0.1495380997657776,
-0.7593369483947754,
0.22130680084228516,
0.009444734081625938,
-0.5455828905105591,
0.5984470248222351,
-0.1694958209991455,
-1.034749150276184,
0.06518010795116425,
-0.4913576543331146,
-0.15586444735527039,
0.1276228278875351,
-0.34398308396339417,
-0.15895143151283264,
0.1491568386554718,
0.2984600067138672,
0.21411076188087463,
-0.8847463726997375,
0.33426761627197266,
-0.48008644580841064,
-0.5092516541481018,
0.4098663926124573,
-0.2579469084739685,
0.5711467862129211,
0.33049267530441284,
0.14122872054576874,
0.25989869236946106,
-0.6011954545974731,
-0.1440996676683426,
0.17086531221866608,
0.15115785598754883,
-0.35407888889312744,
0.1067420095205307,
-0.14966826140880585,
0.4446130394935608,
0.09217973798513412,
-0.7785962820053101,
-0.2718927264213562,
-0.3263643980026245,
0.85988849401474,
0.6288059949874878,
-0.047222837805747986,
0.3956378102302551,
-0.7408936619758606,
0.3798162043094635,
0.17239783704280853,
-0.15500400960445404,
-0.3645772635936737,
-0.34519678354263306,
-0.998753011226654,
-0.5678653717041016,
0.27674978971481323,
0.5182090997695923,
-0.5117630362510681,
0.47009792923927307,
-0.6606348752975464,
-0.506513774394989,
-0.6469331979751587,
-0.10088704526424408,
0.20951063930988312,
1.0012359619140625,
0.1717500388622284,
-0.3194868564605713,
-0.6071010231971741,
-1.0020197629928589,
-0.4699110686779022,
-0.0437970794737339,
-0.7388783097267151,
0.12146645784378052,
0.28496304154396057,
0.037801578640937805,
1.142129898071289,
-0.6640100479125977,
-0.3454520106315613,
0.027940455824136734,
0.24124793708324432,
0.19620709121227264,
0.24462878704071045,
0.22483839094638824,
-0.4008887708187103,
-0.32679495215415955,
-0.22375281155109406,
-0.9449954628944397,
-0.3380178213119507,
-0.3198436200618744,
-0.171861931681633,
-0.523262083530426,
0.6831890344619751,
-0.7589010000228882,
0.015357146970927715,
0.18671563267707825,
-0.08691497147083282,
0.6726177334785461,
-0.2116905152797699,
-0.16473257541656494,
-1.1095764636993408,
0.2305649220943451,
0.027937036007642746,
-0.07688558846712112,
-0.5716375112533569,
-0.09266035258769989,
-0.21454927325248718,
-0.49707236886024475,
-0.6492515206336975,
0.6810210943222046,
-0.18293985724449158,
-0.050993725657463074,
-0.20369689166545868,
0.284186989068985,
0.13975360989570618,
0.38496267795562744,
0.18159587681293488,
0.9315658211708069,
0.6636784672737122,
-0.2674616575241089,
0.3904436230659485,
0.25910645723342896,
-0.44308754801750183,
0.589024543762207,
-0.8413270115852356,
-0.054022166877985,
-0.25596025586128235,
0.4615135192871094,
-0.5376626253128052,
-0.42592328786849976,
0.15902045369148254,
0.06685484945774078,
-0.2525351941585541,
0.36618584394454956,
-0.7083404660224915,
-0.35411539673805237,
-0.43287670612335205,
0.3845134675502777,
0.8214024901390076,
-0.598082423210144,
0.3166847229003906,
0.40100759267807007,
-0.6375171542167664,
-0.14753557741641998,
-0.581226646900177,
0.34557732939720154,
-0.6033306121826172,
-0.28832536935806274,
0.5082593560218811,
-0.12432816624641418,
-0.33121588826179504,
0.0017867175629362464,
0.07121141999959946,
-0.1732378453016281,
-0.24874137341976166,
0.33775827288627625,
0.3081073462963104,
0.04824182391166687,
-0.07093629986047745,
0.06951110064983368,
-0.11704690009355545,
0.284136563539505,
-0.1870518922805786,
0.3041130602359772,
-0.3618256747722626,
-0.3717505633831024,
-0.4351710081100464,
0.44694647192955017,
0.6473475098609924,
0.1582087129354477,
0.5989312529563904,
0.3007233142852783,
-0.33261892199516296,
-0.10276772081851959,
-0.36013227701187134,
-0.23712413012981415,
-0.47928565740585327,
0.19994790852069855,
-0.40392664074897766,
-0.7236786484718323,
0.5216195583343506,
-0.46672943234443665,
-0.11955588310956955,
0.11363190412521362,
0.649179220199585,
-0.15791237354278564,
0.5550892353057861,
-0.06153770536184311,
0.10800869017839432,
0.07494556903839111,
0.1555521935224533,
0.3129226267337799,
-0.7851598858833313,
0.12829868495464325,
-0.273904025554657,
-0.2570377588272095,
-0.33523520827293396,
-0.5126624703407288,
0.24595916271209717,
0.357735276222229,
-0.27824869751930237,
0.329434335231781,
-0.40878406167030334,
0.6835815906524658,
0.5560328364372253,
-0.12825195491313934,
0.2683529257774353,
0.017220407724380493,
-0.19553236663341522,
-0.3277074098587036,
-0.9425957798957825,
-0.6308032870292664,
0.9655152559280396,
0.2731391191482544,
0.6270179748535156,
-0.39872297644615173,
0.7017885446548462,
-0.06114251911640167,
0.35423970222473145,
-0.6287745833396912,
0.7699457406997681,
-0.2142047882080078,
-0.2114381641149521,
0.00024242103972937912,
-0.2737800180912018,
-0.944600522518158,
0.24249663949012756,
-0.311810165643692,
-0.6727083921432495,
-0.0211490448564291,
0.17438997328281403,
-0.11081171035766602,
0.24144093692302704,
-0.8455349802970886,
0.8497480750083923,
0.1615099012851715,
-0.3565347194671631,
-0.08745010197162628,
-0.6759156584739685,
0.3689330220222473,
-0.3334208130836487,
0.23633690178394318,
-0.22579416632652283,
-0.04223332554101944,
0.4849383533000946,
-0.5475497841835022,
0.670631468296051,
0.37244299054145813,
0.40677642822265625,
0.56059330701828,
0.15125887095928192,
0.34360042214393616,
-0.12942510843276978,
-0.1661517471075058,
0.23961728811264038,
-0.15468229353427887,
-0.44633427262306213,
-0.7132703065872192,
0.9116904735565186,
-0.4373720586299896,
-0.6047492623329163,
-0.3570076525211334,
-1.0392680168151855,
-0.050503209233284,
0.08503561466932297,
0.09617818892002106,
0.19841904938220978,
-0.35331326723098755,
0.03411628305912018,
0.1829763948917389,
-0.06480544060468674,
0.5166924595832825,
0.07659211754798889,
0.09025705605745316,
-0.4103541374206543,
1.2941627502441406,
-0.2628779113292694,
0.06893711537122726,
0.21493154764175415,
0.40862298011779785,
-0.25186532735824585,
-0.42240482568740845,
-0.456636905670166,
0.21285010874271393,
-0.5064687132835388,
-0.16245827078819275,
-0.4790330231189728,
-0.23578496277332306,
-0.14383304119110107,
-0.30334922671318054,
-0.27659842371940613,
-0.6306040287017822,
-0.3680172860622406,
0.10099630057811737,
0.1613665223121643,
0.33834198117256165,
0.002170003717765212,
0.13039326667785645,
-0.5968614220619202,
0.5042527914047241,
0.7265624403953552,
0.12568284571170807,
-0.05534115061163902,
-0.20129214227199554,
-0.03087667003273964,
-0.056007467210292816,
-0.42429831624031067,
-0.47844403982162476,
0.5305072069168091,
0.4075797498226166,
0.29861965775489807,
0.29964688420295715,
0.07710948586463928,
0.696228563785553,
-1.0823464393615723,
0.7731821537017822,
0.446168452501297,
-1.0617283582687378,
0.1127801164984703,
-0.39371389150619507,
0.46677255630493164,
0.5355288982391357,
0.3231540024280548,
-0.4367828369140625,
-0.5460747480392456,
-0.5313193798065186,
-0.6972109079360962,
0.4231778383255005,
0.6236338019371033,
-0.13133642077445984,
-0.19702205061912537,
0.129903644323349,
0.25823670625686646,
0.4705818295478821,
-0.4247896075248718,
0.023915737867355347,
-0.32926228642463684,
-0.5047298073768616,
0.050351597368717194,
0.1466454416513443,
-0.2213636338710785,
-0.15937276184558868,
0.14675450325012207,
-0.1585233211517334,
0.2636702358722687,
-0.09880897402763367,
0.06715533137321472,
0.12967345118522644,
0.30057546496391296,
0.29375967383384705,
0.7421243190765381,
-0.05041242018342018,
0.5444051623344421,
0.390249639749527,
-0.22576825320720673,
0.02232208475470543,
0.28276321291923523,
0.0015528658404946327,
0.002480813767760992,
0.3336341381072998,
0.7844470739364624,
0.04474165663123131,
-1.1963201761245728,
0.35193702578544617,
-0.008210337720811367,
-0.0844811201095581,
-0.3001227080821991,
0.1329127997159958,
0.5527636408805847,
0.03404771536588669,
0.04064972326159477,
0.15042957663536072,
0.27657026052474976,
-0.5169093608856201,
0.15358835458755493,
0.29135626554489136,
-0.08137820661067963,
-0.3153999447822571,
0.8629971742630005,
0.10992114245891571,
-0.5746893882751465,
0.5943698287010193,
-0.07005955278873444,
-0.15666444599628448,
0.5642372369766235,
0.6546644568443298,
0.8970934748649597,
0.17103269696235657,
-0.026973245665431023,
0.2643285393714905,
-0.12270596623420715,
-0.2589084804058075,
-0.031205089762806892,
0.016067296266555786,
-0.5993711352348328,
-0.3173700273036957,
-0.8354119658470154,
-0.4559435248374939,
0.1422371119260788,
-0.5857411026954651,
0.35551872849464417,
-0.4499639570713043,
0.0786798745393753,
0.27379563450813293,
-0.5279075503349304,
-0.6968579888343811,
0.030709078535437584,
0.1548396348953247,
0.6923131346702576,
-1.1234469413757324,
0.9484725594520569,
0.683033287525177,
-0.21453863382339478,
-0.5056198835372925,
0.1413346230983734,
-0.20833055675029755,
-0.41517722606658936,
0.5850807428359985,
0.1968420147895813,
-0.09224843978881836,
-0.10165591537952423,
-0.2992579936981201,
-0.5231432318687439,
1.1798810958862305,
0.6511719226837158,
-0.5228106379508972,
-0.15951736271381378,
0.4034965932369232,
0.9221316576004028,
-0.7487471699714661,
0.19342640042304993,
0.6975100636482239,
0.0878995805978775,
0.09264062345027924,
-0.7595900297164917,
0.019829299300909042,
-0.09038694947957993,
0.30580511689186096,
-0.08080916106700897,
-0.4584195613861084,
0.9791345000267029,
0.011337265372276306,
-0.3123045265674591,
0.15408512949943542,
0.6299657821655273,
0.7307203412055969,
0.2750944197177887,
0.5697224736213684,
0.8952756524085999,
0.2876291573047638,
0.14215371012687683,
0.8980118632316589,
-0.18855835497379303,
0.18557101488113403,
1.5857630968093872,
-0.47500085830688477,
0.700764536857605,
0.7961611747741699,
-0.24171029031276703,
0.43412530422210693,
0.4385165870189667,
0.0009092243271879852,
0.4747956693172455,
0.47215455770492554,
-0.47035831212997437,
-0.17333576083183289,
-0.46589425206184387,
0.05207197368144989,
0.0553455650806427,
0.5432071089744568,
-0.30249345302581787,
-0.41606298089027405,
-0.26517152786254883,
-0.08163820207118988,
0.49553078413009644,
-0.13628508150577545,
0.631198525428772,
0.29015210270881653,
-0.7609022855758667,
0.537519097328186,
-0.23414237797260284,
0.3311578333377838,
-0.48215508460998535,
-0.10745221376419067,
-0.15636231005191803,
0.15852674841880798,
0.1957988739013672,
-0.832991361618042,
0.32305365800857544,
-0.018155109137296677,
-0.1514347940683365,
-0.1678081899881363,
0.4862081706523895,
-0.5452702045440674,
-0.5893582105636597,
-0.005316695664077997,
0.4136864244937897,
0.3552594780921936,
0.09886166453361511,
-0.7820279002189636,
0.1602063775062561,
-0.25200527906417847,
0.13860274851322174,
0.48338592052459717,
0.3792978525161743,
-0.09223014861345291,
0.8760794401168823,
0.5447573661804199,
0.34849971532821655,
0.12451567500829697,
-0.10962449014186859,
1.0377092361450195,
-0.4435740113258362,
-0.4188113212585449,
-0.6027354001998901,
0.16217847168445587,
-0.249972864985466,
-0.2267366647720337,
0.5682113170623779,
0.6438185572624207,
0.7861090302467346,
-0.4101027846336365,
0.661977231502533,
0.03615950793027878,
0.5770024657249451,
-0.24625885486602783,
0.44859936833381653,
-0.15162916481494904,
0.16938947141170502,
-0.2733843922615051,
-1.1547939777374268,
-0.2704736888408661,
0.4072078466415405,
-0.11009938269853592,
-0.48840460181236267,
1.0443307161331177,
0.8836316466331482,
-0.4936125576496124,
0.0738692507147789,
0.10535429418087006,
0.14222300052642822,
0.2605400085449219,
0.7414690852165222,
0.9019435048103333,
-0.40595221519470215,
0.6441535353660583,
-0.14386707544326782,
0.05369587615132332,
0.2670532763004303,
-1.139992594718933,
-1.005593180656433,
-0.4768937826156616,
-0.30152833461761475,
-0.0733875036239624,
0.08825848996639252,
0.9154047966003418,
0.41358599066734314,
-0.7547720670700073,
-0.4744076430797577,
-0.7750117182731628,
-0.08312398940324783,
-0.25186917185783386,
-0.14896172285079956,
0.40799015760421753,
-0.36166495084762573,
-1.0334635972976685,
0.35026684403419495,
0.2477874457836151,
-0.008752353489398956,
-0.2883144021034241,
0.05648574233055115,
-0.01686503179371357,
0.2000180184841156,
0.3905302882194519,
0.35731151700019836,
-0.9022452235221863,
-0.17888833582401276,
-0.42004701495170593,
0.008025097660720348,
0.017117202281951904,
0.95550537109375,
-1.0415606498718262,
0.6004864573478699,
0.5987906455993652,
0.6332051753997803,
0.3629296123981476,
0.12038667500019073,
0.6993697285652161,
-0.5988609790802002,
0.6627906560897827,
0.302996426820755,
0.3077377378940582,
0.4604915678501129,
0.12492208182811737,
0.2938312292098999,
0.26849567890167236,
-0.5820212960243225,
-0.7447654008865356,
0.4152075946331024,
-0.8815905451774597,
-0.3496018350124359,
0.875427782535553,
-0.36621683835983276,
-0.33857834339141846,
0.040658462792634964,
-0.26661577820777893,
0.03920159116387367,
-0.3241381347179413,
0.9821367263793945,
0.6180465221405029,
-0.1789444237947464,
0.10507077723741531,
-0.2608165442943573,
0.4776902496814728,
0.5327184796333313,
-0.9655788540840149,
0.13945256173610687,
0.5455463528633118,
0.32618826627731323,
0.11909554898738861,
0.254454642534256,
-0.04494931176304817,
-0.032040439546108246,
0.3176637291908264,
-0.07330645620822906,
-0.07247315347194672,
-0.1769069880247116,
-0.24091507494449615,
0.24115817248821259,
-0.06237567961215973,
-0.318387895822525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01131v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01131v2
|
LLaMoCo: Instruction Tuning of Large Language Models for Optimization Code Generation
| 2024-03-02T08:21:59 | 2024-03-05T11:11:41 |
Zeyuan Ma, Hongshu Guo, Jiacheng Chen, Guojun Peng, Zhiguang Cao, Yining Ma, Yue-Jiao Gong
|
math.OC
|
math.OC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.NE, cs.SE
|
Recent research explores optimization using large language models (LLMs) by
either iteratively seeking next-step solutions from LLMs or directly prompting
LLMs for an optimizer. However, these approaches exhibit inherent limitations,
including low operational efficiency, high sensitivity to prompt design, and a
lack of domain-specific knowledge. We introduce LLaMoCo, the first
instruction-tuning framework designed to adapt LLMs for solving optimization
problems in a code-to-code manner. Specifically, we establish a comprehensive
instruction set containing well-described problem prompts and effective
optimization codes. We then develop a novel two-phase learning strategy that
incorporates a contrastive learning-based warm-up procedure before the
instruction-tuning phase to enhance the convergence behavior during model
fine-tuning. The experiment results demonstrate that a CodeGen (350M) model
fine-tuned by our LLaMoCo achieves superior optimization performance compared
to GPT-4 Turbo and the other competitors across both synthetic and realistic
problem sets. The fine-tuned model and the usage instructions are available at
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/LLaMoCo-722A.
|
[
-0.17537935078144073,
-0.571766197681427,
0.5081471800804138,
0.3931141495704651,
-0.37677720189094543,
0.021299494430422783,
-0.5097264051437378,
-0.1913156807422638,
-0.09742648899555206,
0.5558897852897644,
-0.7043229937553406,
-0.6153720021247864,
-0.3529934585094452,
0.23794826865196228,
-0.06678297370672226,
0.9118160009384155,
0.022861575707793236,
0.13857614994049072,
-0.3208561837673187,
0.34464800357818604,
-0.1470998227596283,
-0.18154770135879517,
-0.7608913779258728,
-0.16470946371555328,
0.4073742628097534,
0.6484665274620056,
0.1620626300573349,
0.952943742275238,
0.30059128999710083,
0.291760116815567,
-0.12499332427978516,
0.5315344929695129,
-0.7872635126113892,
0.12837208807468414,
0.06666150689125061,
-0.6295284628868103,
-0.405027836561203,
-0.47696179151535034,
0.5106806755065918,
0.4273119866847992,
-0.2798353135585785,
0.030839236453175545,
0.13099700212478638,
0.7005198001861572,
-0.6869377493858337,
0.2005251944065094,
-0.9888484477996826,
-0.022296013310551643,
0.0017615080578252673,
-0.7080814242362976,
-0.3550301790237427,
-0.42873895168304443,
-0.36700743436813354,
-0.6054785847663879,
0.37115466594696045,
0.09346157312393188,
0.36646461486816406,
0.5811768174171448,
-0.227994903922081,
-0.5411779284477234,
-0.4925401508808136,
0.9403166770935059,
-0.7113978862762451,
0.16817110776901245,
0.05019905045628548,
0.015591784380376339,
-0.24153897166252136,
-0.5516587495803833,
-0.12398702651262283,
-0.3014785349369049,
0.5106531381607056,
0.1376577764749527,
-0.03405461460351944,
0.15511037409305573,
0.1961393803358078,
0.3494609296321869,
-0.37300917506217957,
0.5089935064315796,
-0.4088149666786194,
-0.10765515267848969,
0.5798569917678833,
0.3337252736091614,
-0.10828939080238342,
0.26741188764572144,
-0.15889324247837067,
0.14362862706184387,
-0.8923901319503784,
-0.20392382144927979,
0.5101401209831238,
0.31499287486076355,
-0.0888935774564743,
0.3556599020957947,
-0.16566798090934753,
0.5542190074920654,
0.09184058010578156,
-0.03320860490202904,
-0.063125841319561,
-0.07926943898200989,
-0.07139372080564499,
0.10875540971755981,
0.40044131875038147,
0.2879911959171295,
0.33457857370376587,
-0.02265029028058052,
-0.43749040365219116,
-0.04444205015897751,
0.44329169392585754,
-1.0384924411773682,
-0.08528736978769302,
0.017304863780736923,
-0.12264949083328247,
-0.672466516494751,
-0.2453293800354004,
-0.860723614692688,
-0.18889160454273224,
-0.4087928235530853,
0.16706471145153046,
0.06149863451719284,
0.004471105989068747,
0.2628731429576874,
0.3129245340824127,
0.47078877687454224,
0.16767452657222748,
-1.1193227767944336,
0.2907367944717407,
0.8467108607292175,
0.761834979057312,
-0.17739731073379517,
-0.1020229235291481,
-0.6689007878303528,
0.041106805205345154,
-0.5406798720359802,
0.6382697820663452,
-0.6853909492492676,
-0.6129176616668701,
0.35882705450057983,
-0.04461011663079262,
0.15656960010528564,
-0.7316407561302185,
0.3311299681663513,
-0.6364567279815674,
-0.2272549569606781,
-0.11628491431474686,
-0.5544361472129822,
0.08858168870210648,
0.0005782842636108398,
-0.3966487944126129,
0.9178681373596191,
0.12630385160446167,
-0.33061203360557556,
-0.18760176002979279,
-0.5352362394332886,
-0.6653062701225281,
-0.001252750284038484,
-0.18662694096565247,
-0.501991331577301,
0.5666592717170715,
-0.04062385857105255,
0.21003314852714539,
-0.7204472422599792,
-0.1251285970211029,
-0.13230973482131958,
-0.4287218153476715,
0.055716656148433685,
-0.15992313623428345,
0.4889289438724518,
0.38921234011650085,
-0.24243158102035522,
0.2723751664161682,
-0.6389297842979431,
0.26088947057724,
0.34276363253593445,
-0.3692706227302551,
0.008793897926807404,
0.043952688574790955,
-0.4390428066253662,
-0.17890994250774384,
0.5265577435493469,
-0.009398083202540874,
0.37711307406425476,
-0.33988356590270996,
0.6622107028961182,
0.8577271699905396,
-0.009866459295153618,
0.1900249868631363,
-0.21427562832832336,
0.8577550649642944,
-0.23100437223911285,
0.15555088222026825,
-0.376155287027359,
-0.23329442739486694,
-1.0018478631973267,
0.04246371239423752,
0.1854911893606186,
0.6275038123130798,
-0.5995209217071533,
0.25608354806900024,
0.1315842717885971,
-0.18777017295360565,
-0.34571710228919983,
0.4883166253566742,
0.5852949023246765,
0.4433581531047821,
0.20572148263454437,
-0.07371474802494049,
-0.5151408314704895,
-0.7768588066101074,
0.02236977405846119,
0.28643545508384705,
0.19003017246723175,
0.5200583934783936,
0.5776364207267761,
-0.1766936480998993,
0.2208346426486969,
-0.8515870571136475,
0.010937144048511982,
-0.2183619737625122,
-0.05029050633311272,
0.16868485510349274,
0.48091259598731995,
0.36724475026130676,
-0.4575008153915405,
-0.40732893347740173,
0.20127266645431519,
-0.40048304200172424,
-0.42902541160583496,
0.15506726503372192,
-0.32452070713043213,
0.16924913227558136,
0.7867923378944397,
-0.0313437320291996,
-0.047819677740335464,
0.7542658448219299,
0.28139957785606384,
0.6146325469017029,
-0.40985509753227234,
-0.05434499680995941,
-1.148288607597351,
-0.14164505898952484,
0.0041175042279064655,
-0.10948775708675385,
-0.42945465445518494,
0.16842392086982727,
0.038231879472732544,
-0.2445870339870453,
-0.4493817389011383,
0.293678343296051,
-0.47178977727890015,
-0.09898333251476288,
-0.48480066657066345,
-0.025455331429839134,
-0.019521107897162437,
0.6054314374923706,
-0.09621480107307434,
1.1894619464874268,
0.6114036440849304,
-0.8064398765563965,
0.27484387159347534,
-0.11454712599515915,
-0.3494624197483063,
0.2064610868692398,
-0.8470724821090698,
0.6804729104042053,
-0.011186976917088032,
-0.1555991917848587,
-0.6043277382850647,
-0.3471792936325073,
-0.024197757244110107,
-0.08059433847665787,
0.3988267481327057,
-0.19540826976299286,
-0.42247289419174194,
-0.21924945712089539,
-0.21121785044670105,
0.6363310217857361,
0.6344616413116455,
-0.5740700364112854,
0.22776544094085693,
0.15733851492404938,
-0.18285338580608368,
-0.26122477650642395,
-0.33320531249046326,
-0.328277587890625,
-0.21226979792118073,
-0.3171321153640747,
0.30203789472579956,
-0.22142377495765686,
0.026475071907043457,
-0.4329424500465393,
-0.224629208445549,
-0.18445928394794464,
0.24056854844093323,
-0.11127551645040512,
0.20700673758983612,
-0.2153293788433075,
0.13575540482997894,
0.37050193548202515,
-0.13142453134059906,
0.09253638237714767,
-0.630641758441925,
0.7359310388565063,
-0.13006170094013214,
0.02304314635694027,
-0.3162192702293396,
0.4010462164878845,
0.23619061708450317,
-0.33112919330596924,
0.5498694777488708,
0.1946643441915512,
-0.2170628011226654,
-0.6348314881324768,
-0.34097859263420105,
-0.13519006967544556,
-0.5225393772125244,
0.6747149229049683,
-0.4701301157474518,
-0.8124178647994995,
0.2601659297943115,
-0.5733206272125244,
0.022007999941706657,
0.10598386824131012,
0.8825190663337708,
0.05107112228870392,
1.0594419240951538,
0.8888042569160461,
0.08480770140886307,
0.6181990504264832,
-0.31907811760902405,
-0.07929643243551254,
-0.8876612186431885,
-0.1975504457950592,
-0.8261426091194153,
-0.17970411479473114,
-0.7062771916389465,
-0.5428498387336731,
0.4315093159675598,
0.24456992745399475,
-0.2608422636985779,
0.11944684386253357,
-0.5604416131973267,
1.069322943687439,
0.36355242133140564,
0.24819576740264893,
0.22453323006629944,
-0.014159789308905602,
-0.0153751689940691,
0.09024718403816223,
-0.8187044262886047,
-0.26386475563049316,
1.057300329208374,
0.0028183143585920334,
0.8955487608909607,
-0.06662990152835846,
0.7823277115821838,
0.21030057966709137,
0.10615644603967667,
-0.7874817252159119,
0.3795253336429596,
-0.33730676770210266,
-0.3359096944332123,
0.17336155474185944,
-0.7260861992835999,
-0.8037494421005249,
-0.017911672592163086,
0.07105784863233566,
-0.49995070695877075,
-0.09096866101026535,
0.4917706549167633,
-0.350578635931015,
-0.023849645629525185,
-0.5954862833023071,
0.7666552662849426,
-0.6332662105560303,
-0.5911454558372498,
-0.42312583327293396,
-0.2706587314605713,
0.3275291919708252,
-0.23983080685138702,
0.1968095749616623,
-0.02206517942249775,
-0.4256967306137085,
0.3055615723133087,
-0.32192471623420715,
0.7902947068214417,
0.061486583203077316,
-0.4496675133705139,
0.12243334203958511,
0.25090649724006653,
0.5844498872756958,
0.02994379587471485,
-0.18589253723621368,
-0.041662637144327164,
-0.2767319977283478,
-0.4750220775604248,
-0.6165686249732971,
0.9325317740440369,
-0.6179618835449219,
-0.6350311040878296,
0.06227226182818413,
-0.5711385011672974,
-0.24308565258979797,
0.3365565836429596,
0.36511892080307007,
0.5473224520683289,
0.0042360033839941025,
0.24933485686779022,
0.9043182134628296,
-0.27831894159317017,
0.06245098263025284,
0.36159756779670715,
-0.12991169095039368,
-0.44094040989875793,
0.9863926768302917,
-0.49350133538246155,
0.4412704408168793,
0.5040842890739441,
0.35082152485847473,
-0.1369452327489853,
-0.6815822720527649,
-0.22122013568878174,
0.2542616128921509,
-0.5369170308113098,
-0.3635385036468506,
0.047803379595279694,
-0.14062348008155823,
-0.2269192636013031,
-0.3579137921333313,
-0.5879061222076416,
-0.005804124288260937,
-0.5119744539260864,
0.23484870791435242,
0.15695004165172577,
0.6464840769767761,
0.12351679056882858,
0.36208072304725647,
-0.5064260959625244,
0.15010157227516174,
0.1885863095521927,
0.37644997239112854,
-0.15328353643417358,
-0.5700257420539856,
-0.4999729096889496,
-0.000534461869392544,
-0.37742695212364197,
-0.5577592253684998,
0.22328345477581024,
0.37429434061050415,
0.26223599910736084,
0.3682973384857178,
0.01116822101175785,
0.5614458322525024,
-0.6119232773780823,
0.27159446477890015,
0.034018225967884064,
-0.8683118224143982,
0.7707164883613586,
-0.2570600211620331,
0.3842512369155884,
0.43604278564453125,
0.4068435728549957,
-0.004937736317515373,
0.012345432303845882,
-0.2596885561943054,
-0.6791303157806396,
0.46542420983314514,
-0.010476159863173962,
0.44521182775497437,
0.01948637142777443,
0.7846832871437073,
0.14250825345516205,
0.47560349106788635,
-0.42698386311531067,
-0.13167420029640198,
0.046078912913799286,
-0.3264656662940979,
-0.06618445366621017,
-0.3498475253582001,
-0.31236574053764343,
-0.17925164103507996,
0.6808714270591736,
-0.5102931261062622,
0.2556297183036804,
-0.15409432351589203,
-0.09191685169935226,
-0.2468797117471695,
0.09420913457870483,
1.0768530368804932,
0.5061757564544678,
0.04324294626712799,
-0.14312662184238434,
0.19402532279491425,
-0.26605167984962463,
-0.03918636962771416,
-0.12384353578090668,
-0.13864508271217346,
-0.5198917984962463,
0.21198755502700806,
0.9866133332252502,
0.4631893038749695,
-0.6753786206245422,
0.15261420607566833,
-0.028711901977658272,
-0.28576111793518066,
-0.15993407368659973,
0.53790682554245,
-0.1074354276061058,
0.32675036787986755,
0.024759676307439804,
-0.269501268863678,
0.033319126814603806,
-0.427316278219223,
-0.059217244386672974,
0.5313899517059326,
-0.023883523419499397,
-0.09843230247497559,
0.7470739483833313,
0.5656155943870544,
-0.4400216042995453,
0.4695882201194763,
-0.24407872557640076,
-0.6732092499732971,
0.8038840293884277,
0.9089431762695312,
0.991486132144928,
-0.0967220887541771,
-0.07508500665426254,
0.38070324063301086,
0.25222083926200867,
0.050545644015073776,
0.20283670723438263,
-0.25771525502204895,
-0.5881245732307434,
-0.35502105951309204,
-0.713420569896698,
-0.522030770778656,
-0.039215538650751114,
-0.7797629237174988,
0.29307860136032104,
-0.7436596751213074,
0.07879839837551117,
-0.326328843832016,
0.25969135761260986,
-0.5058936476707458,
-0.04066917300224304,
0.12269358336925507,
0.8346232771873474,
-0.5546231865882874,
0.8314133882522583,
0.5216361284255981,
-0.020237402990460396,
-0.6116067171096802,
0.04903418943285942,
-0.029814407229423523,
-1.1188007593154907,
0.26408007740974426,
0.15427549183368683,
-0.5118778347969055,
0.597432553768158,
-0.7889087796211243,
-0.5200549364089966,
1.0318245887756348,
0.4886907637119293,
-1.0329127311706543,
0.024538157507777214,
0.027576277032494545,
0.3904712498188019,
-0.724036693572998,
-0.09625151008367538,
0.6879805326461792,
0.08752015233039856,
0.2802427411079407,
-0.56330806016922,
-0.20095935463905334,
-0.08851505815982819,
0.3697338402271271,
0.31570953130722046,
-0.9762408137321472,
0.654137909412384,
-0.5352572202682495,
0.10262259840965271,
0.36337050795555115,
0.5796002745628357,
0.2747439742088318,
0.03847135603427887,
0.31999659538269043,
0.3972164988517761,
0.7746683955192566,
-0.011952491477131844,
1.1689066886901855,
-0.5980207324028015,
0.41479256749153137,
1.0550602674484253,
-0.27085253596305847,
0.5761076211929321,
0.2622893452644348,
0.02540430799126625,
0.3098078966140747,
0.5302153825759888,
0.0037665420677512884,
0.625530481338501,
0.4730316698551178,
-0.3377656936645508,
-0.3845458924770355,
-0.07356875389814377,
-0.40116772055625916,
0.3574255406856537,
0.37261900305747986,
-0.2762666642665863,
0.04052804410457611,
-0.4066102206707001,
0.07041385769844055,
0.15418830513954163,
-0.5292319059371948,
0.7883574366569519,
0.15440404415130615,
-0.6625834703445435,
0.8643069267272949,
0.005754201672971249,
0.3534071445465088,
-0.5875422954559326,
-0.06381826102733612,
-0.46860066056251526,
0.2542349398136139,
-0.13217991590499878,
-0.3129480183124542,
-0.05389782786369324,
0.2811746299266815,
-0.2418912649154663,
0.09696073830127716,
0.2666841447353363,
-0.4149174988269806,
-0.5833627581596375,
0.020231125876307487,
0.08822205662727356,
0.04642491415143013,
0.14817439019680023,
-0.6937451362609863,
0.5248161554336548,
0.3014427423477173,
0.03540881350636482,
0.2346353530883789,
0.38487857580184937,
0.15157081186771393,
0.6950981616973877,
0.5457647442817688,
0.12897144258022308,
0.1182817593216896,
0.24062082171440125,
0.8121331334114075,
-0.5834248065948486,
-0.30079513788223267,
-0.6389007568359375,
0.16983060538768768,
0.18395940959453583,
-0.4623531699180603,
0.3051309287548065,
0.5907377004623413,
0.8575466871261597,
-0.1631082147359848,
0.6442019939422607,
0.24297228455543518,
0.005769805517047644,
-1.0804507732391357,
0.19372832775115967,
-0.8346377015113831,
0.5420053601264954,
0.11865641921758652,
-1.0893782377243042,
-0.17310750484466553,
0.6014730334281921,
-0.1784452646970749,
0.2928207218647003,
0.6505725383758545,
1.1112974882125854,
0.08699310570955276,
-0.1482110321521759,
0.20207761228084564,
0.3020806610584259,
0.23134343326091766,
0.8777535557746887,
0.7075703144073486,
-0.14206211268901825,
0.5561284422874451,
-0.37688758969306946,
-0.3415296673774719,
-0.38490018248558044,
-0.9895004034042358,
-0.8164985179901123,
-0.25448527932167053,
-0.3142307698726654,
-0.1795133650302887,
0.20729917287826538,
0.9516372084617615,
0.5872125029563904,
-0.6516500115394592,
-0.47207286953926086,
-0.34348157048225403,
0.02322658710181713,
-0.06681510806083679,
-0.13459712266921997,
-0.06139390915632248,
-0.7861928343772888,
-0.964496910572052,
0.4365319609642029,
0.22313594818115234,
-0.09356962144374847,
-0.20252282917499542,
-0.3588292896747589,
0.3395087718963623,
0.21427220106124878,
0.39924004673957825,
0.43111106753349304,
-0.4054033160209656,
0.1332310289144516,
0.05657001957297325,
-0.13052710890769958,
0.14362139999866486,
1.160847544670105,
-0.23054586350917816,
0.38863492012023926,
0.11202861368656158,
0.6355319023132324,
0.6419647932052612,
0.07735053449869156,
0.5821018218994141,
-0.8079109191894531,
0.336826890707016,
0.25668343901634216,
0.15909914672374725,
0.0660800039768219,
-0.3562180995941162,
0.3221418261528015,
0.04705455154180527,
-0.6930849552154541,
-0.7406888008117676,
0.44607847929000854,
-0.8424638509750366,
-0.1999431699514389,
1.1767257452011108,
0.21250754594802856,
-0.35625195503234863,
0.544942319393158,
-0.22417442500591278,
0.1927768439054489,
-0.3354499042034149,
0.911281168460846,
0.31344151496887207,
-0.18754695355892181,
-0.28100746870040894,
-0.6286423206329346,
0.4255245625972748,
0.43058282136917114,
-0.9462383985519409,
0.02017897553741932,
0.4171697795391083,
0.28898534178733826,
-0.31814536452293396,
0.16372567415237427,
0.0690634548664093,
0.41468679904937744,
0.05205800011754036,
-0.07792141288518906,
-0.3285464644432068,
-0.5665587782859802,
-0.3640281856060028,
-0.11605725437402725,
0.3380415737628937,
-0.18085381388664246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01116v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01116v1
|
MulCogBench: A Multi-modal Cognitive Benchmark Dataset for Evaluating Chinese and English Computational Language Models
| 2024-03-02T07:49:57 | 2024-03-02T07:49:57 |
Yunhao Zhang, Xiaohan Zhang, Chong Li, Shaonan Wang, Chengqing Zong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained computational language models have recently made remarkable
progress in harnessing the language abilities which were considered unique to
humans. Their success has raised interest in whether these models represent and
process language like humans. To answer this question, this paper proposes
MulCogBench, a multi-modal cognitive benchmark dataset collected from native
Chinese and English participants. It encompasses a variety of cognitive data,
including subjective semantic ratings, eye-tracking, functional magnetic
resonance imaging (fMRI), and magnetoencephalography (MEG). To assess the
relationship between language models and cognitive data, we conducted a
similarity-encoding analysis which decodes cognitive data based on its pattern
similarity with textual embeddings. Results show that language models share
significant similarities with human cognitive data and the similarity patterns
are modulated by the data modality and stimuli complexity. Specifically,
context-aware models outperform context-independent models as language stimulus
complexity increases. The shallow layers of context-aware models are better
aligned with the high-temporal-resolution MEG signals whereas the deeper layers
show more similarity with the high-spatial-resolution fMRI. These results
indicate that language models have a delicate relationship with brain language
representations. Moreover, the results between Chinese and English are highly
consistent, suggesting the generalizability of these findings across languages.
|
[
-0.4314643144607544,
-0.7487226128578186,
0.49460098147392273,
0.3682249188423157,
-0.10331311821937561,
-0.13008467853069305,
-0.6304070949554443,
-0.5515128374099731,
-0.08708734810352325,
0.23147530853748322,
-0.4852169454097748,
-0.3003852069377899,
-0.2733459174633026,
-0.05304399132728577,
0.042436227202415466,
0.570647656917572,
0.158254474401474,
0.4509693384170532,
-0.2484961748123169,
-0.31345105171203613,
-0.4936651587486267,
-0.5678108930587769,
-0.5347239971160889,
-0.375264436006546,
0.2846512794494629,
-0.16324153542518616,
0.9068486094474792,
0.5627936124801636,
0.32525426149368286,
0.34350499510765076,
0.12845101952552795,
0.11055213958024979,
-0.3581041693687439,
-0.08333880454301834,
-0.18663401901721954,
-0.229165717959404,
-0.43566417694091797,
0.14832022786140442,
0.6777880191802979,
0.9310413002967834,
-0.3496529757976532,
-0.13326065242290497,
0.34019261598587036,
0.231998011469841,
-0.4773634672164917,
0.449237197637558,
-0.8172454833984375,
-0.21245531737804413,
-0.20651432871818542,
0.02070303075015545,
-0.3312297761440277,
-0.05196258798241615,
-0.1918196827173233,
-0.49846312403678894,
0.2531525492668152,
0.13966001570224762,
0.7222530245780945,
-0.052664149552583694,
-0.4311593472957611,
-0.29383566975593567,
-0.1356906294822693,
0.9914731979370117,
-0.7051931023597717,
0.6978428363800049,
0.45646125078201294,
0.377340167760849,
-0.14176934957504272,
-0.3034512400627136,
-0.6558116674423218,
-0.7393301725387573,
-0.4307839274406433,
0.26753300428390503,
0.18785923719406128,
-0.03406956046819687,
0.28707894682884216,
0.17897343635559082,
-0.9375808238983154,
-0.0760391354560852,
-0.3053685426712036,
-0.40217897295951843,
0.5656920075416565,
0.37146487832069397,
0.3121444582939148,
-0.23586072027683258,
-0.3944070339202881,
-0.2919795513153076,
-0.30222058296203613,
0.13509707152843475,
0.2235172837972641,
0.47154700756073,
-0.2594456970691681,
0.15004700422286987,
-0.0031435254495590925,
0.8206676244735718,
-0.2903828024864197,
-0.1268889605998993,
0.5403979420661926,
-0.39986875653266907,
-0.042693495750427246,
-0.100129134953022,
0.981708824634552,
0.3336195647716522,
0.32543158531188965,
-0.2989104986190796,
-0.05877910926938057,
0.35306283831596375,
0.09895665943622589,
-0.6011744737625122,
-0.18844519555568695,
-0.02169281803071499,
-0.5477807521820068,
0.0833987221121788,
0.19105784595012665,
-0.6699625253677368,
-0.4603344798088074,
-0.4874495565891266,
-0.051507603377103806,
-0.6082975268363953,
-0.4944304823875427,
0.19021163880825043,
0.13367561995983124,
0.21255065500736237,
0.04960251227021217,
-0.9908040761947632,
0.2986426055431366,
0.8244805335998535,
0.5033898949623108,
-0.3016776442527771,
-0.9299124479293823,
-0.1433172971010208,
0.14053352177143097,
-0.332112580537796,
0.7964917421340942,
-0.7230460047721863,
-0.2098817080259323,
-0.2416429966688156,
0.1933484822511673,
-0.3341243863105774,
-0.47816285490989685,
0.4668061435222626,
-0.24027639627456665,
0.017932800576090813,
-0.20006494224071503,
-0.27798038721084595,
-0.15748034417629242,
0.43086129426956177,
-0.9224669933319092,
1.046465516090393,
0.062081918120384216,
-0.6504042148590088,
0.2931804358959198,
-0.47525426745414734,
-0.45919644832611084,
0.03195912018418312,
-0.567123532295227,
-0.0662028044462204,
0.22377456724643707,
0.119088314473629,
0.595196008682251,
-0.7851843237876892,
0.4286736249923706,
-0.5882694125175476,
-0.25560706853866577,
0.5089627504348755,
-0.6278161406517029,
0.7302237153053284,
0.30145204067230225,
-0.08613762259483337,
-0.23176205158233643,
-0.8664610385894775,
0.3534608781337738,
0.14280492067337036,
-0.41943031549453735,
-0.5487045049667358,
0.11096372455358505,
0.36627131700515747,
0.5945389866828918,
0.22285279631614685,
-0.7099217176437378,
-0.0018326666904613376,
-0.08201514929533005,
0.5868375897407532,
0.5029919147491455,
-0.45334237813949585,
0.09769833832979202,
-0.35399129986763,
0.11384747922420502,
0.22809894382953644,
0.021177608519792557,
-0.4646106958389282,
-0.3573547601699829,
-0.2076636701822281,
-0.4367476999759674,
0.11979478597640991,
0.36419400572776794,
-0.4831768870353699,
0.1570710837841034,
-0.6825695633888245,
-0.5292150378227234,
-0.8364081978797913,
-0.037234917283058167,
0.24501992762088776,
0.4028637409210205,
0.3967168629169464,
-0.2869209051132202,
-0.10842578113079071,
-1.1314018964767456,
-0.432425320148468,
0.002584122121334076,
-0.32103946805000305,
0.5360531806945801,
0.1379980593919754,
-0.32721948623657227,
0.4909481406211853,
-0.34827083349227905,
-0.04519205912947655,
0.08821641653776169,
0.30693063139915466,
0.1826184093952179,
0.47429215908050537,
0.6371616125106812,
-0.708480715751648,
-0.4016648232936859,
0.2720252573490143,
-0.7536107897758484,
0.06117141246795654,
-0.10817573964595795,
-0.031321585178375244,
0.09225182235240936,
0.5880293250083923,
-0.2494131326675415,
0.09367790818214417,
0.764865517616272,
-0.22175097465515137,
0.36594298481941223,
-0.23034441471099854,
0.7260348200798035,
-0.8522908687591553,
0.27264603972435,
-0.31946590542793274,
-0.03018900565803051,
-0.5546384453773499,
0.021678738296031952,
0.35887837409973145,
-0.2679171562194824,
-0.2740704417228699,
0.4877963066101074,
-0.5106675028800964,
0.1540471315383911,
-0.13118861615657806,
0.24367572367191315,
-0.10774387419223785,
0.862706184387207,
0.2674431800842285,
0.611784815788269,
0.757685661315918,
-0.48358237743377686,
0.3327884376049042,
-0.15887042880058289,
-0.5955208539962769,
0.7124112248420715,
-0.587398111820221,
0.1685396283864975,
-0.10590196400880814,
-0.24516382813453674,
-1.1635854244232178,
0.013656148687005043,
-0.24844993650913239,
-0.3151033818721771,
0.22202160954475403,
0.40695324540138245,
-0.4508150517940521,
-0.14730055630207062,
-0.41637122631073,
0.6231920123100281,
-0.010753992944955826,
-0.280449777841568,
0.9394388794898987,
0.4123583137989044,
-0.16280768811702728,
-0.33501550555229187,
-1.1067570447921753,
-0.15880608558654785,
0.15730589628219604,
-0.7642080783843994,
0.5231322646141052,
-0.27016520500183105,
0.14417840540409088,
-0.053894054144620895,
0.23640777170658112,
-0.2702694535255432,
0.03493490815162659,
0.21813614666461945,
0.20599693059921265,
-0.4334110617637634,
0.15315359830856323,
-0.13316762447357178,
-0.11233224719762802,
0.02373046986758709,
0.25563403964042664,
0.6103029847145081,
-0.33824700117111206,
-0.4029686748981476,
0.0810793787240982,
0.5194542407989502,
0.7269059419631958,
-0.3760334849357605,
0.7635483145713806,
0.5078238844871521,
-0.49834585189819336,
0.1388193666934967,
-0.5793919563293457,
-0.283092737197876,
-0.44526126980781555,
0.6254419088363647,
-0.8112686276435852,
-0.7263883948326111,
0.5020294785499573,
-0.012345190159976482,
-0.08429869264364243,
0.1421843320131302,
0.6839736104011536,
-0.022054094821214676,
1.039612889289856,
0.4195941984653473,
-0.35404762625694275,
0.4036409854888916,
0.17716765403747559,
-0.021465672180056572,
-0.874927282333374,
-0.09228719770908356,
-0.42753612995147705,
-0.03144684061408043,
-0.5723953247070312,
-0.26495984196662903,
0.00012240433716215193,
-0.14336366951465607,
-0.26978757977485657,
0.5274602770805359,
-0.2784152626991272,
0.4286471903324127,
0.3373982012271881,
0.07831691205501556,
0.17929911613464355,
0.09981925040483475,
-0.5618245601654053,
-0.2622244656085968,
-0.6749698519706726,
-0.3478270173072815,
0.8206496238708496,
-0.10396284610033035,
0.8613340854644775,
-0.0478798933327198,
-0.12018973380327225,
0.19717904925346375,
0.18998382985591888,
-0.4114818871021271,
0.5101675987243652,
-0.15821972489356995,
-0.5984622836112976,
-0.1386985182762146,
-0.4805452525615692,
-1.298244595527649,
0.6224039196968079,
-0.34684374928474426,
-0.6825332045555115,
-0.06094461306929588,
-0.2181800752878189,
-0.04631837457418442,
0.09658857434988022,
-0.5144177079200745,
1.084080457687378,
-0.44683927297592163,
-0.36700332164764404,
-0.5762798190116882,
-0.544367790222168,
0.3844180405139923,
-0.18755897879600525,
0.5177001357078552,
-0.30640289187431335,
-0.049383100122213364,
0.46816110610961914,
0.09476576745510101,
0.4619186520576477,
0.24191206693649292,
0.021941881626844406,
0.1351122260093689,
0.2513441741466522,
0.03563009202480316,
-0.16882096230983734,
-0.39247652888298035,
0.6190885305404663,
0.2030324935913086,
-0.5221951603889465,
-0.5188851356506348,
1.0539199113845825,
-0.7676156163215637,
-0.40031394362449646,
-0.41302844882011414,
-0.621543288230896,
-0.2654186189174652,
0.2565341591835022,
0.03351856768131256,
0.35951489210128784,
-0.5441639423370361,
0.14990153908729553,
0.05452301725745201,
-0.05407319217920303,
0.488127738237381,
0.8202947378158569,
-0.152180477976799,
-0.3928244709968567,
0.8375510573387146,
0.11560361832380295,
0.1756405532360077,
0.4091776907444,
-0.005394109524786472,
-0.2448779195547104,
-0.11021724343299866,
-0.3823143243789673,
0.45279160141944885,
-0.6122426390647888,
0.17395329475402832,
-0.4336467981338501,
-0.09651271253824234,
-0.3885960876941681,
-0.042257100343704224,
-0.39593350887298584,
0.046831659972667694,
0.27418437600135803,
0.14686881005764008,
-0.09240306913852692,
0.4708680510520935,
0.0715089738368988,
-0.01273393351584673,
-0.8550860285758972,
0.39616885781288147,
0.3070182800292969,
0.4978767931461334,
0.1859542280435562,
-0.10853894054889679,
-0.44187214970588684,
0.36100301146507263,
-0.217426598072052,
-0.9063966274261475,
0.018043087795376778,
0.15775224566459656,
0.9286521673202515,
0.4224589169025421,
-0.34797561168670654,
0.6805533170700073,
-0.5119564533233643,
0.7389892935752869,
0.14618048071861267,
-0.9906442165374756,
0.21688829362392426,
-0.2962968349456787,
0.5208985805511475,
0.6193864345550537,
0.3052254617214203,
-0.9509284496307373,
-0.217770054936409,
-0.32967305183410645,
-0.30495646595954895,
0.8400104641914368,
0.09167584031820297,
0.13141708076000214,
-0.15343746542930603,
-0.02954879216849804,
0.03718607872724533,
0.24927963316440582,
-0.6857789158821106,
-0.12557324767112732,
-0.290607750415802,
-0.17779187858104706,
-0.224348783493042,
0.07812982052564621,
0.13158060610294342,
-0.027677444741129875,
0.3008965253829956,
-0.20074163377285004,
0.29649055004119873,
-0.19251926243305206,
-0.26391154527664185,
0.20229880511760712,
0.27040213346481323,
0.46639978885650635,
0.5063749551773071,
0.1487790048122406,
0.2960297167301178,
0.4338732361793518,
-0.6133169531822205,
0.01686052978038788,
0.07727054506540298,
0.29449695348739624,
-0.2539558410644531,
0.5524686574935913,
0.5646613240242004,
0.3513377904891968,
-0.8586996793746948,
0.5770893096923828,
-0.2453431338071823,
0.29635995626449585,
0.2252374142408371,
-0.1073845773935318,
0.2746005356311798,
-0.10420975834131241,
0.03166183829307556,
0.1245475709438324,
0.18083585798740387,
-0.6105304956436157,
0.024556651711463928,
0.4750979244709015,
-0.37189701199531555,
-0.51301509141922,
0.5258426666259766,
0.021112913265824318,
0.020870596170425415,
0.8674628734588623,
-0.05174408480525017,
-0.44019508361816406,
0.48529312014579773,
0.47658514976501465,
0.5949388146400452,
-0.5595645308494568,
-0.2266952395439148,
0.5456139445304871,
0.5007649064064026,
0.040128014981746674,
0.3459257185459137,
-0.10428617149591446,
-0.9376404881477356,
-0.2058507651090622,
-0.343627393245697,
-0.021680131554603577,
0.17068639397621155,
-0.6949883699417114,
0.4848209023475647,
-0.232146754860878,
-0.222647026181221,
0.10166741162538528,
-0.21685858070850372,
-0.8629875183105469,
0.23198916018009186,
0.3395351767539978,
0.5437999367713928,
-0.8353387117385864,
1.168924331665039,
0.705092191696167,
-0.21973109245300293,
-0.6399158835411072,
-0.23169074952602386,
-0.09071303904056549,
-0.6736195683479309,
0.1823820024728775,
0.3558083474636078,
-0.42626723647117615,
-0.37339580059051514,
-0.3270476460456848,
-0.7476335167884827,
1.0303318500518799,
0.6413612961769104,
-0.40573543310165405,
0.34870943427085876,
0.4405785799026489,
0.6025583148002625,
-0.44323429465293884,
0.5674362182617188,
0.7036778330802917,
0.5181959867477417,
-0.2972323000431061,
-0.869257390499115,
0.15667323768138885,
-0.5056400299072266,
0.17508454620838165,
0.2208726853132248,
-0.8167223930358887,
1.2016122341156006,
0.17348475754261017,
-0.49218347668647766,
-0.19978290796279907,
0.5685335397720337,
0.29106780886650085,
0.010717406868934631,
0.4485931992530823,
0.3382664620876312,
0.8076198697090149,
-0.02613869681954384,
0.9754231572151184,
-0.6343667507171631,
0.3409847617149353,
1.1897006034851074,
-0.3594430983066559,
0.8253724575042725,
0.31430166959762573,
-0.24016079306602478,
0.5623233318328857,
0.4288966655731201,
-0.03153223544359207,
0.5034927725791931,
0.08592365682125092,
0.16686150431632996,
-0.37796321511268616,
-0.06886876374483109,
-0.42161715030670166,
0.36506229639053345,
0.3815116584300995,
-0.11252292990684509,
-0.3344993591308594,
0.13932502269744873,
0.19327542185783386,
0.24086816608905792,
-0.1847829520702362,
0.6336378455162048,
-0.06871464848518372,
-0.7908393144607544,
0.7474969029426575,
0.06866691261529922,
0.7886940240859985,
-0.8937453031539917,
0.1453857421875,
-0.15573766827583313,
0.16355231404304504,
0.033088091760873795,
-0.6592735052108765,
0.2579725980758667,
-0.2687138319015503,
-0.3154415488243103,
0.2592921257019043,
0.36507850885391235,
-0.7481335401535034,
-0.41849854588508606,
0.6685618162155151,
0.4576525390148163,
0.1952442079782486,
-0.24151137471199036,
-1.0551235675811768,
0.14720222353935242,
-0.14633214473724365,
-0.16841842234134674,
0.2568138539791107,
0.37069904804229736,
-0.27801787853240967,
0.525290846824646,
0.5966506004333496,
-0.033375728875398636,
0.256013423204422,
0.05791207775473595,
0.7775856852531433,
-0.8273457288742065,
-0.4940122961997986,
-0.955988347530365,
0.22289049625396729,
-0.06005604937672615,
-0.3138449490070343,
0.7101361751556396,
0.677287757396698,
0.8896622657775879,
-0.28836315870285034,
0.7107178568840027,
0.060132816433906555,
0.3364288806915283,
-0.3889305889606476,
0.7650070786476135,
-0.6070104837417603,
-0.11143876612186432,
-0.22524233162403107,
-0.9323111772537231,
-0.14709165692329407,
0.5911867022514343,
-0.16883988678455353,
0.33125099539756775,
1.0172762870788574,
1.2415611743927002,
-0.4620603919029236,
0.14306573569774628,
0.6582687497138977,
0.2830274999141693,
0.15757347643375397,
1.0041382312774658,
0.8551589846611023,
-0.3434777855873108,
0.3885001242160797,
-0.05472559481859207,
-0.2773762345314026,
0.09179817885160446,
-0.9544287919998169,
-0.929562509059906,
-0.7764939665794373,
-0.10212395340204239,
0.054504405707120895,
-0.39930593967437744,
0.9043959379196167,
0.7409509420394897,
-0.9393126964569092,
-0.49674150347709656,
0.25329822301864624,
-0.21327674388885498,
-0.6787627339363098,
-0.18683816492557526,
0.4644063413143158,
-0.28438273072242737,
-0.782290518283844,
0.4394291043281555,
0.3078722357749939,
-0.010522914119064808,
-0.3959589898586273,
-0.08984582126140594,
-0.21483463048934937,
0.31040680408477783,
0.5484668016433716,
-0.11477110534906387,
-0.8027375936508179,
-0.07436072826385498,
0.14090244472026825,
-0.6882572770118713,
0.11780330538749695,
1.0226157903671265,
-0.7009984850883484,
0.5750247240066528,
0.6157723665237427,
0.48577970266342163,
0.43961992859840393,
-0.31748080253601074,
0.42637571692466736,
-0.35524851083755493,
0.3929634392261505,
-0.04275057837367058,
0.6524125933647156,
0.48091939091682434,
-0.07422415167093277,
0.5026213526725769,
-0.08099113404750824,
-0.42178162932395935,
-0.4059702157974243,
0.12156789004802704,
-1.0313440561294556,
-0.5080984830856323,
0.8117668628692627,
-0.2827610373497009,
-0.3231140971183777,
-0.2007206231355667,
-0.38781487941741943,
-0.08679039776325226,
-0.2675987482070923,
0.8068344593048096,
1.113593339920044,
0.09360481798648834,
-0.023781636729836464,
-0.3767338693141937,
0.23300595581531525,
0.38052257895469666,
-0.68718421459198,
0.30649158358573914,
0.34680646657943726,
0.16399753093719482,
0.239132821559906,
0.4691217243671417,
-0.1942862570285797,
0.3306747376918793,
0.20720194280147552,
0.11687720566987991,
-0.17478494346141815,
-0.20989470183849335,
-0.3329634666442871,
0.2276570200920105,
-0.19882787764072418,
0.037505269050598145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01106v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01106v2
|
Distilling Text Style Transfer With Self-Explanation From LLMs
| 2024-03-02T06:38:15 | 2024-05-04T17:23:21 |
Chiyu Zhang, Honglong Cai, Yuezhang, Li, Yuexin Wu, Le Hou, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text Style Transfer (TST) seeks to alter the style of text while retaining
its core content. Given the constraints of limited parallel datasets for TST,
we propose CoTeX, a framework that leverages large language models (LLMs)
alongside chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting to facilitate TST. CoTeX distills
the complex rewriting and reasoning capabilities of LLMs into more streamlined
models capable of working with both non-parallel and parallel data. Through
experimentation across four TST datasets, CoTeX is shown to surpass traditional
supervised fine-tuning and knowledge distillation methods, particularly in
low-resource settings. We conduct a comprehensive evaluation, comparing CoTeX
against current unsupervised, supervised, in-context learning (ICL) techniques,
and instruction-tuned LLMs. Furthermore, CoTeX distinguishes itself by offering
transparent explanations for its style transfer process.
|
[
-0.18568916618824005,
-0.6932685971260071,
0.7892151474952698,
0.3672192096710205,
-0.42170947790145874,
0.46121785044670105,
-0.4303320646286011,
-0.20660953223705292,
0.13185252249240875,
0.697059154510498,
-0.9397256374359131,
-0.5452582836151123,
-0.45523226261138916,
0.2725332975387573,
-0.7668137550354004,
1.0777409076690674,
-0.4139496088027954,
-0.43254512548446655,
-0.03967152163386345,
0.14687830209732056,
-0.45718279480934143,
-0.49977362155914307,
-0.7402510046958923,
-0.48188701272010803,
0.5109596252441406,
0.6385486125946045,
0.3741035461425781,
0.678200364112854,
0.1541818082332611,
0.2674861550331116,
0.09883342683315277,
0.28072425723075867,
-0.6376792788505554,
0.11247055977582932,
-0.5557613372802734,
-0.4281632900238037,
-0.4200836420059204,
-0.020737485960125923,
0.43344539403915405,
0.34322965145111084,
0.0485137514770031,
0.11240921914577484,
0.3594350516796112,
1.0706754922866821,
-0.4236951470375061,
-0.11623378843069077,
-0.6923949718475342,
-0.028053004294633865,
-0.16801594197750092,
-0.2313331663608551,
-0.4460381269454956,
-0.24178867042064667,
0.34162604808807373,
-0.3459869623184204,
0.24469730257987976,
0.22040021419525146,
0.5163969993591309,
0.25051701068878174,
-0.4936273992061615,
-0.1629730463027954,
-0.736537754535675,
0.8628178238868713,
-0.43997722864151,
0.14315691590309143,
0.260151207447052,
0.33246955275535583,
0.1942821443080902,
-1.0772777795791626,
-0.6371439695358276,
0.11418605595827103,
-0.20062921941280365,
0.22591426968574524,
-0.06638464331626892,
-0.13171504437923431,
0.12788309156894684,
0.39462554454803467,
-0.4547675848007202,
0.03206143155694008,
-0.21612346172332764,
-0.08165447413921356,
0.6425682306289673,
0.018250176683068275,
0.2665189504623413,
-0.046008650213479996,
-0.7879940867424011,
0.09680993109941483,
-0.7011098265647888,
-0.3092111051082611,
-0.05023949593305588,
0.21221135556697845,
-0.1804770529270172,
0.0703577995300293,
-0.18790669739246368,
0.6823055744171143,
0.20043808221817017,
-0.12434312701225281,
-0.21261091530323029,
-0.47722771763801575,
-0.21971264481544495,
0.3787493109703064,
0.8358072638511658,
0.5460495948791504,
0.3514576256275177,
-0.2860351502895355,
-0.4227556586265564,
-0.29228007793426514,
0.06999551504850388,
-0.7876226305961609,
-0.23044054210186005,
0.0970691666007042,
-0.44349735975265503,
-0.31587257981300354,
-0.23996856808662415,
-0.9063999056816101,
-0.44053953886032104,
-0.9744959473609924,
0.23612290620803833,
-0.26998138427734375,
-0.2569001019001007,
0.08822077512741089,
-0.25241807103157043,
0.2285357266664505,
0.5569303035736084,
-0.8198724389076233,
0.4580538868904114,
0.5876492857933044,
1.1795299053192139,
-0.6325174570083618,
-0.08089185506105423,
-0.22306208312511444,
0.14351598918437958,
-0.2502237558364868,
0.9023428559303284,
-0.3373379111289978,
-0.33790260553359985,
-0.15107929706573486,
-0.03755372390151024,
0.07666755467653275,
-0.27549639344215393,
0.37041226029396057,
-0.1425754576921463,
-0.2086108773946762,
-0.5349234938621521,
-0.41154396533966064,
0.19141225516796112,
0.03853493183851242,
-0.5683748722076416,
0.9855507612228394,
0.1360039860010147,
-0.6960378289222717,
0.07895850390195847,
-0.42874160408973694,
-0.6296601295471191,
-0.1547156274318695,
0.0390666238963604,
-0.297865629196167,
0.18106040358543396,
0.43228474259376526,
0.47064414620399475,
-0.4563969671726227,
0.23145435750484467,
-0.3042196035385132,
-0.20002824068069458,
0.46216365694999695,
-0.44428032636642456,
0.6505756974220276,
0.41059672832489014,
-0.35997530817985535,
0.031209543347358704,
-0.6859398484230042,
-0.055932510644197464,
-0.03728620707988739,
0.21364544332027435,
-0.45401448011398315,
-0.2771390974521637,
0.14725777506828308,
0.42494919896125793,
0.2211516946554184,
-0.5090618133544922,
0.23717929422855377,
0.11908342689275742,
0.9437651038169861,
0.9872907400131226,
-0.0533611997961998,
0.5633828639984131,
-0.5086748600006104,
0.34309127926826477,
-0.2512625455856323,
0.0945933535695076,
-0.050522055476903915,
0.039214860647916794,
-0.8385284543037415,
-0.046849727630615234,
0.14566314220428467,
0.29635363817214966,
-1.0170693397521973,
-0.09871372580528259,
-0.008778532966971397,
-0.3471764028072357,
-0.34975090622901917,
0.16470928490161896,
0.34846076369285583,
0.6354252099990845,
0.5483769774436951,
0.04891709238290787,
-0.5059301853179932,
-0.9564974308013916,
-0.38148176670074463,
0.2522242069244385,
0.1928166002035141,
0.11585886031389236,
0.3101517856121063,
0.05417603999376297,
0.9328673481941223,
-0.49481070041656494,
-0.19243955612182617,
-0.630614697933197,
0.5223539471626282,
-0.037867482751607895,
0.4835255444049835,
0.6664847731590271,
-0.6613565683364868,
-0.8342583179473877,
0.04411126300692558,
-0.4901253879070282,
-0.4088585376739502,
-0.38530975580215454,
-0.30541345477104187,
0.10348333418369293,
0.8567055463790894,
0.2482919543981552,
0.5361559987068176,
0.47263556718826294,
-0.09962724894285202,
0.7808197736740112,
-0.1461065113544464,
0.19029980897903442,
-1.41086745262146,
-0.17746353149414062,
0.21828781068325043,
-0.45301780104637146,
-0.5604870319366455,
-0.36620020866394043,
0.2629912197589874,
0.022403283044695854,
-0.3939405083656311,
0.6401942372322083,
-0.6045413613319397,
0.04874454438686371,
-0.5142598748207092,
0.3162635862827301,
0.36204826831817627,
0.4671550393104553,
0.3117462992668152,
0.972678542137146,
0.4759594798088074,
-0.5582448840141296,
0.3841305673122406,
0.036184221506118774,
-0.3198319673538208,
0.9793199896812439,
-0.708819568157196,
0.39830371737480164,
-0.11798473447561264,
0.3464944064617157,
-1.0164318084716797,
0.15404239296913147,
-0.28578540682792664,
0.2750943899154663,
0.3432115912437439,
-0.4387369453907013,
-0.4531426727771759,
-0.28650981187820435,
-0.13504597544670105,
0.3977689743041992,
0.44613510370254517,
-0.8550407886505127,
0.4769269526004791,
0.04134788364171982,
-0.18701207637786865,
-0.5807427763938904,
-0.760384738445282,
0.2744918167591095,
-0.38913819193840027,
-0.3933718800544739,
0.6224550604820251,
-0.233782559633255,
-0.33101943135261536,
-0.2774522304534912,
-0.3385275900363922,
-0.30514001846313477,
0.11319252103567123,
-0.12190328538417816,
0.35310080647468567,
-0.13796672224998474,
0.31581491231918335,
0.3160722851753235,
0.017135094851255417,
-0.028854889795184135,
-0.6085798740386963,
0.44512325525283813,
-0.2506186366081238,
0.10932721942663193,
-0.7471258044242859,
0.2956047058105469,
0.6104564070701599,
-0.24664360284805298,
0.5991412401199341,
0.5082857608795166,
0.03937092423439026,
-0.8349510431289673,
-0.5458539128303528,
-0.27368980646133423,
-0.48823073506355286,
0.04820956662297249,
-0.5113373398780823,
-0.8323087096214294,
0.44127628207206726,
-0.45505455136299133,
-0.0023041199892759323,
0.339629203081131,
0.28775203227996826,
-0.17275342345237732,
0.49763792753219604,
0.6710211038589478,
0.04939386248588562,
0.6893699169158936,
-0.23558096587657928,
0.09708387404680252,
-0.9751244187355042,
0.04666096717119217,
-0.4449843466281891,
-0.6227705478668213,
-0.5624573230743408,
-0.18212074041366577,
0.2553848326206207,
-0.1515929400920868,
-0.0775383859872818,
0.4942309558391571,
-0.5672136545181274,
0.8704590797424316,
0.5526391863822937,
0.34649839997291565,
0.4843331277370453,
0.06803669035434723,
-0.014474546536803246,
0.10987960547208786,
-0.547802746295929,
-0.34343892335891724,
1.0905860662460327,
0.06877250969409943,
1.1768383979797363,
0.025497961789369583,
0.893389880657196,
0.4090663194656372,
0.3228852450847626,
-0.6910167932510376,
0.3896087408065796,
-0.6074143052101135,
-0.25988730788230896,
-0.15832273662090302,
-0.28792014718055725,
-0.6491276025772095,
-0.056416746228933334,
-0.22750867903232574,
-0.813434898853302,
0.2598596215248108,
0.16368673741817474,
-0.2855139672756195,
0.3753613233566284,
-0.6081506013870239,
0.6528031229972839,
-0.23954105377197266,
-0.7607119679450989,
-0.05704503506422043,
-0.47689923644065857,
0.4701355993747711,
-0.21213899552822113,
0.18245211243629456,
-0.12063878774642944,
0.02204592153429985,
0.6868089437484741,
-0.6549564599990845,
0.9774806499481201,
0.47610533237457275,
-0.34610164165496826,
0.49865004420280457,
0.5115455389022827,
0.48718518018722534,
-0.04638088867068291,
-0.14905746281147003,
0.0745207741856575,
0.10376401990652084,
-0.10169435292482376,
-0.9465599060058594,
1.010425329208374,
-0.7054069638252258,
-0.5616063475608826,
-0.21978311240673065,
-0.6295889616012573,
-0.2167978137731552,
0.17874914407730103,
0.2779988944530487,
0.9394789338111877,
-0.00039772631134837866,
0.1805313676595688,
0.7069548964500427,
0.04447996988892555,
0.5535055994987488,
0.3939557373523712,
-0.23582987487316132,
-0.2277889847755432,
0.8820031881332397,
0.12607793509960175,
0.6702245473861694,
0.5033880472183228,
0.5617488622665405,
-0.6245591640472412,
-0.47335633635520935,
-0.4437827169895172,
0.19932405650615692,
-0.7407845854759216,
-0.13268747925758362,
-0.4759213328361511,
-0.2917057275772095,
-0.31665512919425964,
-0.4310559034347534,
-0.4267020523548126,
-0.6404068470001221,
-0.26881301403045654,
-0.04912291467189789,
0.5860583782196045,
1.047844648361206,
0.03952844440937042,
0.5640730261802673,
-0.5684632658958435,
0.2554316222667694,
0.45001116394996643,
0.39952751994132996,
-0.1361856609582901,
-0.6525951623916626,
-0.027275435626506805,
-0.03788788244128227,
-0.17889855802059174,
-0.8989089131355286,
0.3838951587677002,
0.18971723318099976,
0.15551838278770447,
0.08193187415599823,
0.366581529378891,
0.727154552936554,
-0.5089471340179443,
0.5664731860160828,
0.2638832926750183,
-1.213228464126587,
0.6624804735183716,
-0.22079496085643768,
0.33826348185539246,
0.6385560035705566,
0.26147422194480896,
-0.806084394454956,
-0.08779117465019226,
-0.5217585563659668,
-0.6718180179595947,
0.7296004295349121,
0.2250920832157135,
-0.2539612650871277,
0.08884231746196747,
0.6704810857772827,
0.3157488703727722,
0.1268940418958664,
-0.5897654891014099,
-0.208907812833786,
-0.4169720709323883,
-0.42085087299346924,
-0.05732567235827446,
-0.1573585569858551,
-0.11602336168289185,
-0.054970934987068176,
0.5367141962051392,
-0.2333468198776245,
-0.06895480304956436,
0.39583584666252136,
-0.3474142551422119,
0.27445366978645325,
0.5018689036369324,
0.6251401901245117,
0.7822070121765137,
0.06323873996734619,
0.5938894748687744,
0.09864670783281326,
-0.23851355910301208,
0.1164235770702362,
-0.2797940969467163,
-0.13075782358646393,
-0.10140082240104675,
0.24298717081546783,
0.8070199489593506,
0.13979756832122803,
-0.14496725797653198,
0.3582959771156311,
-0.31516119837760925,
-0.242386594414711,
0.1344633251428604,
-0.045298490673303604,
-0.10034500062465668,
0.022818677127361298,
0.039117757230997086,
-0.08954842388629913,
0.22785334289073944,
-0.5716366171836853,
0.3158513903617859,
0.19128724932670593,
-0.5284097194671631,
-0.224624365568161,
0.4640549123287201,
0.4031795561313629,
-0.022830991074442863,
0.35443100333213806,
0.17363542318344116,
-0.3851568102836609,
0.6205601692199707,
0.7791054248809814,
1.0298477411270142,
-0.11692705005407333,
0.423941045999527,
0.43160438537597656,
0.30188748240470886,
-0.3442278802394867,
-0.06188918277621269,
-0.3850643038749695,
-0.451315313577652,
-0.44007638096809387,
-0.7099815607070923,
-0.38270145654678345,
0.08913261443376541,
-0.6261798143386841,
0.306290864944458,
-0.5683778524398804,
0.06108127161860466,
0.010858768597245216,
-0.329975962638855,
-0.6260020136833191,
0.015490739606320858,
0.05091356858611107,
0.9158883690834045,
-0.8959836363792419,
0.849448025226593,
0.37252721190452576,
-0.17158883810043335,
-0.7979975938796997,
0.2329854965209961,
0.09800072014331818,
-0.8812615871429443,
0.7532681226730347,
0.02755877748131752,
-0.556426465511322,
0.24476678669452667,
-0.6446965932846069,
-0.8455550670623779,
1.116878628730774,
0.36284464597702026,
-0.9699472188949585,
0.21067892014980316,
0.10006464272737503,
0.4443185031414032,
-0.289040744304657,
0.12937118113040924,
0.8824386596679688,
0.3459150791168213,
0.39157524704933167,
-1.0952975749969482,
0.229331374168396,
0.21703854203224182,
0.20875553786754608,
0.06212715059518814,
-0.6519972085952759,
0.7475782036781311,
-0.06864825636148453,
-0.38041478395462036,
0.01604403182864189,
0.7051121592521667,
-0.23082607984542847,
0.21871238946914673,
0.3146570920944214,
0.2460181564092636,
0.7641457915306091,
-0.27030321955680847,
1.0004040002822876,
-0.27515631914138794,
0.320099800825119,
1.4781631231307983,
-0.22258260846138,
0.5412169694900513,
0.4389217495918274,
-0.0957251489162445,
0.9200804829597473,
0.5576939582824707,
0.5705796480178833,
0.46110546588897705,
0.2197994589805603,
-0.20623812079429626,
-0.38883480429649353,
-0.2740851640701294,
-0.17367663979530334,
0.3264598548412323,
0.2354149967432022,
-0.31949251890182495,
-0.36549174785614014,
0.04903078079223633,
0.16930370032787323,
0.47099143266677856,
-0.5195215940475464,
1.0089902877807617,
0.34241345524787903,
-0.8228714466094971,
0.6291297674179077,
-0.326875776052475,
0.5364983677864075,
-0.5482960343360901,
-0.06698565930128098,
-0.3480987250804901,
0.2858957350254059,
-0.13518840074539185,
-1.187251091003418,
0.21162870526313782,
-0.16736890375614166,
-0.07824878394603729,
-0.798703670501709,
0.9316892027854919,
-0.6941196322441101,
-0.5295127034187317,
0.09140294790267944,
0.5260193347930908,
-0.020401347428560257,
-0.12199971824884415,
-0.6786025762557983,
0.10962308943271637,
-0.06616707891225815,
0.1269504576921463,
0.2829088270664215,
0.8939765095710754,
-0.0604085773229599,
0.6156165599822998,
0.4003729522228241,
-0.12092482298612595,
-0.29691165685653687,
0.1821395456790924,
0.7963550686836243,
-0.47731372714042664,
-0.5075529217720032,
-1.176619052886963,
0.258188933134079,
-0.3714366853237152,
-0.12315139174461365,
0.7355718016624451,
0.23007608950138092,
0.5165477395057678,
-0.07822134345769882,
1.0300413370132446,
0.17999623715877533,
0.25256359577178955,
-0.7674787640571594,
0.7215161323547363,
-0.5162761211395264,
0.1688922494649887,
-0.371173620223999,
-0.7437435984611511,
-0.03932896628975868,
0.47896453738212585,
-0.3190056383609772,
-0.08296874165534973,
1.0400196313858032,
0.48068124055862427,
-0.08844180405139923,
0.2493608295917511,
0.1900557577610016,
0.3270375728607178,
0.23807626962661743,
0.4383598566055298,
0.7224491834640503,
-0.008718863129615784,
0.2798178195953369,
-0.544670581817627,
-0.5081003308296204,
-0.040132295340299606,
-1.2950984239578247,
-1.220306158065796,
-0.7289305329322815,
-0.5019490122795105,
-0.46809983253479004,
0.13862377405166626,
0.9719030857086182,
0.6520764231681824,
-0.5460731983184814,
-0.3977402448654175,
-0.2606692314147949,
0.3261129856109619,
-0.47214359045028687,
-0.19490589201450348,
0.4418114423751831,
-0.42129915952682495,
-0.7643420696258545,
0.33377987146377563,
0.4007972776889801,
0.18772073090076447,
-0.21268056333065033,
0.2847500741481781,
-0.010766268707811832,
0.16336770355701447,
0.8171152472496033,
0.10671158879995346,
-0.5308318734169006,
-0.2517406642436981,
-0.07598313689231873,
-0.05138874426484108,
0.03813116252422333,
1.2015348672866821,
-0.6913238763809204,
0.5461674928665161,
0.44681426882743835,
0.42874428629875183,
0.5862477421760559,
0.06292811036109924,
0.7047162652015686,
-0.9451200366020203,
-0.1596985012292862,
-0.15645018219947815,
0.3668576180934906,
0.24577221274375916,
-0.40351584553718567,
0.3939087688922882,
0.298872709274292,
-0.4576248824596405,
-0.43871447443962097,
0.3881257176399231,
-1.1821362972259521,
-0.5453621745109558,
1.3750238418579102,
0.03704727813601494,
-0.5322638154029846,
-0.2509077787399292,
-0.5851521492004395,
0.0608234740793705,
-0.3809269368648529,
0.7234981060028076,
0.5235810279846191,
-0.09594711661338806,
-0.3149768114089966,
-0.1679326295852661,
0.8180636763572693,
0.02000868320465088,
-0.9616668820381165,
0.49316275119781494,
0.22923436760902405,
0.4830053448677063,
-0.27807506918907166,
0.5565513372421265,
0.0200802069157362,
0.04232937842607498,
-0.4151722192764282,
-0.06225346401333809,
-0.15916770696640015,
-0.44233426451683044,
0.021944036707282066,
-0.1333867907524109,
-0.25016993284225464,
0.1536152958869934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01081v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01081v3
|
LAB: Large-Scale Alignment for ChatBots
| 2024-03-02T03:48:37 | 2024-04-29T18:55:34 |
Shivchander Sudalairaj, Abhishek Bhandwaldar, Aldo Pareja, Kai Xu, David D. Cox, Akash Srivastava
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This work introduces LAB (Large-scale Alignment for chatBots), a novel
methodology designed to overcome the scalability challenges in the
instruction-tuning phase of large language model (LLM) training. Leveraging a
taxonomy-guided synthetic data generation process and a multi-phase tuning
framework, LAB significantly reduces reliance on expensive human annotations
and proprietary models like GPT-4. We demonstrate that LAB-trained models can
achieve competitive performance across several benchmarks compared to models
trained with traditional human-annotated or GPT-4 generated synthetic data.
Thus offering a scalable, cost-effective solution for enhancing LLM
capabilities and instruction-following behaviors without the drawbacks of
catastrophic forgetting, marking a step forward in the efficient training of
LLMs for a wide range of applications.
|
[
-0.03697746619582176,
-0.9662113785743713,
0.38593602180480957,
-0.05554358661174774,
0.14310412108898163,
0.7189635038375854,
-0.19211836159229279,
-0.13561555743217468,
-0.0626213327050209,
0.5375670790672302,
-0.6664792895317078,
-0.4074424207210541,
-0.347199410200119,
0.0032880064100027084,
-0.5664819478988647,
1.0069894790649414,
0.1823706477880478,
0.0970936045050621,
-0.1621927171945572,
-0.05834273248910904,
-0.602523148059845,
-0.5049264430999756,
-0.9801511764526367,
-0.3092394769191742,
0.6254994869232178,
0.5637650489807129,
0.732471764087677,
0.8613790273666382,
0.5410605669021606,
0.39228272438049316,
0.07994162291288376,
0.321972519159317,
-0.8026599884033203,
0.06786894798278809,
0.0352540947496891,
-0.6073789596557617,
-0.6984274983406067,
-0.044497739523649216,
0.8016999959945679,
0.487048864364624,
-0.2655341625213623,
0.0989597886800766,
-0.1998678296804428,
0.8325207233428955,
-0.2775842547416687,
0.17829541862010956,
-0.9326157569885254,
0.015152220614254475,
-0.03675755858421326,
-0.22050826251506805,
-0.7308341264724731,
-0.3009456396102905,
-0.02826976217329502,
-0.5906253457069397,
0.44235071539878845,
0.36746248602867126,
0.7762913703918457,
0.4525027573108673,
-0.3566848337650299,
0.04363313689827919,
-0.701017439365387,
0.7495359182357788,
-0.6016290783882141,
0.36033204197883606,
0.06187693029642105,
0.5934738516807556,
-0.4435618817806244,
-0.5715401768684387,
-0.7861964702606201,
0.002083642641082406,
0.15839867293834686,
0.05926665663719177,
0.1771547794342041,
0.18059022724628448,
0.3066062331199646,
0.1783725917339325,
-0.6108505129814148,
0.39707696437835693,
-0.39682626724243164,
-0.3057195246219635,
0.668749213218689,
0.268221378326416,
0.2196100503206253,
0.3704445958137512,
-0.042464498430490494,
-0.28824448585510254,
-0.7927893996238708,
-0.2554861307144165,
0.29925206303596497,
0.5254994034767151,
-0.13633330166339874,
0.6982947587966919,
-0.09206291288137436,
0.6657482981681824,
0.24312330782413483,
-0.2117486149072647,
0.41954025626182556,
-0.3191315233707428,
-0.19064725935459137,
0.25454336404800415,
0.9708830118179321,
0.21727968752384186,
0.1972929835319519,
-0.19870643317699432,
-0.03422055393457413,
-0.1745585799217224,
0.46430501341819763,
-0.7302075624465942,
-0.3301819860935211,
0.36649090051651,
0.11197090148925781,
-0.3597809672355652,
-0.43343210220336914,
-0.7596921324729919,
-0.5916341543197632,
-0.6065109372138977,
0.5035157799720764,
-0.5158671140670776,
0.029086295515298843,
-0.18032598495483398,
-0.06572820991277695,
0.45382726192474365,
0.4484901428222656,
-1.2305201292037964,
0.10101631283760071,
0.8721075654029846,
0.9423801898956299,
-0.18372809886932373,
-0.23478703200817108,
-0.6637656688690186,
0.2147708237171173,
-0.5520028471946716,
0.47004249691963196,
-0.5131990909576416,
-0.23292036354541779,
0.027246974408626556,
0.06917042285203934,
0.007690972648561001,
-0.4779687821865082,
0.1145147979259491,
-0.5104764699935913,
0.05666130408644676,
0.21701613068580627,
-0.7639063000679016,
0.11858851462602615,
0.3279639780521393,
-0.47239693999290466,
1.0891426801681519,
0.13780753314495087,
-0.4287187457084656,
0.1575905978679657,
-0.5437402725219727,
-0.4428650736808777,
0.19772885739803314,
-0.1601824313402176,
-0.5718041658401489,
-0.24966369569301605,
0.2250346690416336,
0.5049519538879395,
-0.3453088402748108,
0.26233482360839844,
-0.11016982793807983,
-0.20815427601337433,
0.3341352343559265,
-0.15901745855808258,
0.3446728587150574,
-0.06940200179815292,
-0.27226436138153076,
0.7108342051506042,
-1.0071089267730713,
-0.0859551727771759,
-0.044600408524274826,
-0.2587669789791107,
0.08091755211353302,
0.14416588842868805,
-0.19240009784698486,
0.1253041923046112,
0.4019947648048401,
-0.6449102759361267,
0.28702598810195923,
-0.41701799631118774,
0.7677888870239258,
0.9105375409126282,
-0.3891790509223938,
0.6410496234893799,
-0.2260623276233673,
0.5706980228424072,
-0.20626972615718842,
0.20070892572402954,
-0.22124499082565308,
-0.45770955085754395,
-0.8488982915878296,
-0.4824214279651642,
0.28827476501464844,
0.6393502354621887,
-0.6352469325065613,
0.6345840692520142,
-0.43026500940322876,
-0.7877328395843506,
-0.6000033617019653,
0.34392061829566956,
0.42678019404411316,
0.6461571455001831,
0.3228365480899811,
-0.006317202001810074,
-0.4926305413246155,
-1.009206771850586,
0.18048007786273956,
0.20063476264476776,
-0.17216168344020844,
0.15329168736934662,
0.4763074517250061,
-0.4151357412338257,
0.913414716720581,
-0.4673152565956116,
-0.19939343631267548,
-0.23820370435714722,
0.1979590505361557,
0.10719716548919678,
0.6175951361656189,
0.10808448493480682,
-0.5831494331359863,
-0.5593023896217346,
0.2652834355831146,
-0.3414447009563446,
0.030050819739699364,
-0.1314277946949005,
-0.5016669034957886,
0.35055556893348694,
0.8969199657440186,
-0.6283547878265381,
-0.00590964499861002,
0.8662588596343994,
0.07291862368583679,
0.4824458360671997,
-0.2966810166835785,
-0.004667321220040321,
-1.252256989479065,
-0.02160567045211792,
-0.09567517787218094,
-0.4694982171058655,
-0.625444233417511,
-0.1719195395708084,
0.33389294147491455,
-0.1909642219543457,
-0.29560384154319763,
0.5735917687416077,
-0.2065483033657074,
0.12033573538064957,
-0.25259503722190857,
0.40550899505615234,
-0.12687234580516815,
0.5073226690292358,
-0.10780342668294907,
1.0194059610366821,
0.4579177498817444,
-0.4434352219104767,
0.5161073803901672,
0.3209736943244934,
-0.08039864152669907,
0.5593927502632141,
-0.6133161187171936,
0.3328237533569336,
0.01337572280317545,
0.5582064390182495,
-1.1320608854293823,
-0.633776068687439,
-0.011526696383953094,
-0.4483024477958679,
0.552924394607544,
-0.03749614208936691,
-0.84699547290802,
-0.369766503572464,
-0.21535634994506836,
0.28283199667930603,
0.7507067322731018,
-0.5853683352470398,
0.7470665574073792,
0.4205125570297241,
0.014231981709599495,
-0.5663309693336487,
-0.3089386224746704,
-0.08071854710578918,
-0.27813953161239624,
-0.44342663884162903,
0.156157448887825,
-0.04528624936938286,
0.21707606315612793,
-0.5792267918586731,
0.0032458726782351732,
0.07560551166534424,
-0.006853438913822174,
0.2640708386898041,
0.4714691638946533,
-0.13817669451236725,
0.3516426682472229,
-0.08962737023830414,
0.0551178939640522,
-0.12702465057373047,
-0.1290946751832962,
0.8833447694778442,
0.07112699747085571,
-0.20325106382369995,
-0.5552964806556702,
0.017488138750195503,
0.650560736656189,
-0.05453987047076225,
0.9040940403938293,
0.6462200880050659,
-0.06001026928424835,
-0.20752675831317902,
-0.5732373595237732,
-0.12543673813343048,
-0.5602461695671082,
0.5604243874549866,
-0.011399224400520325,
-1.121755838394165,
0.4067915081977844,
-0.18886211514472961,
0.3808267116546631,
0.3621796667575836,
0.7110610008239746,
-0.23497359454631805,
1.4151734113693237,
0.5202765464782715,
-0.11606898903846741,
0.5773681998252869,
0.16055625677108765,
0.38055768609046936,
-0.9609180092811584,
-0.12019594758749008,
-0.572547435760498,
-0.5047775506973267,
-0.7323930859565735,
-0.6200745701789856,
0.4369816482067108,
-0.20023147761821747,
-0.8485565185546875,
0.3136758804321289,
-0.7475566267967224,
0.582800567150116,
0.6797301173210144,
0.09484485536813736,
0.05890404060482979,
-0.25987115502357483,
0.2256924957036972,
0.23389409482479095,
-0.6765555143356323,
-0.4161062240600586,
1.2766731977462769,
0.2424456924200058,
0.5876410603523254,
0.15060636401176453,
0.4620005786418915,
-0.14717300236225128,
0.37626394629478455,
-0.8740317821502686,
0.586174488067627,
-0.02281380072236061,
-0.7907527089118958,
-0.7235090136528015,
-0.48988884687423706,
-1.1544674634933472,
0.11891679465770721,
-0.2931896150112152,
-1.055140733718872,
-0.6163927316665649,
0.3685203492641449,
-0.19254042208194733,
0.15607884526252747,
-0.8190355896949768,
0.9026393890380859,
-0.2781740725040436,
-0.31507596373558044,
-0.28896066546440125,
-0.8348864316940308,
0.4404335021972656,
-0.5450202226638794,
0.29655352234840393,
-0.20024485886096954,
0.10927090048789978,
0.6796336770057678,
-0.43232107162475586,
1.0255517959594727,
0.12398511171340942,
-0.2672208547592163,
0.00495742354542017,
-0.08889351785182953,
0.5671982765197754,
-0.08108960092067719,
0.15890491008758545,
-0.11496872454881668,
0.008886481635272503,
-0.4846275746822357,
-0.5096490979194641,
0.6566866040229797,
-0.9555565118789673,
-0.690414547920227,
-0.2351996749639511,
-1.026547908782959,
-0.6268792152404785,
0.16237309575080872,
-0.051463283598423004,
0.2557631731033325,
-0.15207383036613464,
0.39971548318862915,
0.8086066842079163,
-0.5818260908126831,
0.18505868315696716,
0.3654094636440277,
-0.3554845154285431,
-0.37411394715309143,
0.9191461205482483,
-0.3135547637939453,
0.7392230033874512,
0.6606488227844238,
0.18716134130954742,
-0.22075870633125305,
-0.3535248935222626,
-0.5247811675071716,
0.21087849140167236,
-0.471103310585022,
-0.267490953207016,
-0.5824635028839111,
-0.44148024916648865,
-0.5161133408546448,
-0.48080068826675415,
-0.6516144275665283,
-0.32026830315589905,
-0.21031548082828522,
0.1041109636425972,
0.6520103812217712,
0.33228230476379395,
0.3379959166049957,
0.7392774820327759,
-0.9547995924949646,
0.27366381883621216,
0.32851630449295044,
0.2144930213689804,
-0.14266403019428253,
-0.610596776008606,
-0.2743288278579712,
0.12037429958581924,
-0.5682728886604309,
-0.34828072786331177,
0.3497159481048584,
0.30613502860069275,
0.2617279887199402,
0.16538803279399872,
-0.30259281396865845,
0.7972638010978699,
-0.8767300844192505,
0.7600509524345398,
0.36069971323013306,
-0.9168908596038818,
0.6439188718795776,
-0.5729672312736511,
0.6027606129646301,
0.43385937809944153,
0.2852955460548401,
-0.4877735674381256,
-0.5005345344543457,
-0.48330238461494446,
-0.991638720035553,
0.7805001735687256,
0.09132184833288193,
0.34487101435661316,
0.1679939329624176,
0.38008683919906616,
0.10752832889556885,
0.3035624325275421,
-0.4913496971130371,
-0.14551813900470734,
0.0303786788135767,
-0.6444492340087891,
-0.4373825192451477,
0.12191878259181976,
-0.402017205953598,
-0.3906267583370209,
0.8152539134025574,
-0.4215448796749115,
0.0782034769654274,
-0.3682318925857544,
0.10565534234046936,
-0.045548416674137115,
0.1244187206029892,
0.5406873226165771,
0.5193771123886108,
-0.20883949100971222,
-0.19931823015213013,
0.15294025838375092,
-0.4742271304130554,
0.2165699005126953,
-0.07527802884578705,
0.08112996816635132,
-0.39765655994415283,
0.20017848908901215,
0.7148107290267944,
0.43651387095451355,
-0.9395932555198669,
0.25364989042282104,
0.014790629036724567,
-0.27390915155410767,
-0.23683317005634308,
0.427694708108902,
0.38158920407295227,
0.31611937284469604,
0.09020687639713287,
-0.343639612197876,
-0.2596719264984131,
-0.668292224407196,
0.02559981867671013,
0.5949828028678894,
-0.21414387226104736,
-0.15715081989765167,
0.7521012425422668,
0.21321803331375122,
-0.6044428944587708,
0.8761369585990906,
-0.08061368018388748,
-0.4013964533805847,
0.7333329916000366,
0.6301933526992798,
0.6453579664230347,
-0.21017691493034363,
0.23480285704135895,
0.5864547491073608,
0.02092207409441471,
-0.26882535219192505,
-0.027707116678357124,
0.20784804224967957,
-0.7619531750679016,
-0.5406763553619385,
-0.7376826405525208,
-0.8079758882522583,
0.06664036959409714,
-0.3429235517978668,
0.4891577661037445,
-0.6085146069526672,
-0.01474260725080967,
0.3060210049152374,
-0.311885267496109,
-0.5543814897537231,
0.06995473802089691,
0.10434846580028534,
0.5379594564437866,
-0.5269513130187988,
1.0278048515319824,
0.4077674448490143,
-0.0711308941245079,
-0.957745373249054,
-0.4159901738166809,
0.3216603100299835,
-0.9376135468482971,
0.5527785420417786,
0.21616116166114807,
-0.0138099892064929,
0.2221986949443817,
-0.7768492698669434,
-1.0521677732467651,
1.2166961431503296,
0.14636150002479553,
-1.133198857307434,
-0.06565201282501221,
0.1921582669019699,
0.8121833205223083,
-0.3739517331123352,
-0.00045901467092335224,
0.7913869619369507,
0.1436166614294052,
0.555344820022583,
-1.1433357000350952,
-0.035522062331438065,
0.022358516231179237,
-0.1457403600215912,
0.5388230085372925,
-0.8399791717529297,
0.7228636145591736,
0.040883488953113556,
0.003983307164162397,
0.06933917850255966,
0.421768456697464,
0.40267428755760193,
-0.03747262433171272,
0.33364731073379517,
0.37700584530830383,
1.025651454925537,
-0.1269174963235855,
0.7307204604148865,
-0.3765662610530853,
0.10874197632074356,
1.4228143692016602,
-0.4592686891555786,
0.8716638088226318,
0.2711750268936157,
-0.225789412856102,
0.29226455092430115,
0.5456067323684692,
-0.16748762130737305,
0.2501600682735443,
0.42295971512794495,
-0.037921931594610214,
-0.1488698571920395,
0.2908466160297394,
-0.09349878877401352,
0.4809817671775818,
0.5790928602218628,
-0.14887453615665436,
0.1995667666196823,
-0.1954856663942337,
-0.03955078125,
-0.13647694885730743,
-0.2728731632232666,
0.8043764233589172,
-0.13168960809707642,
-0.7099347710609436,
0.6515565514564514,
-0.4218003749847412,
0.6232824921607971,
-0.5831926465034485,
0.12984715402126312,
0.014293098822236061,
0.29923686385154724,
-0.08892074227333069,
-0.6351406574249268,
0.032265737652778625,
-0.06549718976020813,
0.1534910351037979,
-0.1421431452035904,
0.1921277493238449,
-0.36182519793510437,
-0.5365694165229797,
-0.10142863541841507,
0.2632999122142792,
0.0737769678235054,
0.15530942380428314,
-0.608349084854126,
-0.06769159436225891,
-0.09623482823371887,
-0.12017026543617249,
0.5808328986167908,
0.5443692207336426,
-0.10921850800514221,
0.8775913715362549,
0.5851662755012512,
-0.12080798298120499,
0.15264146029949188,
0.21636411547660828,
0.6987181901931763,
-0.6651995778083801,
-0.03984561190009117,
-0.8600447773933411,
0.37333670258522034,
-0.215103417634964,
-0.22320809960365295,
0.6012502312660217,
0.618788480758667,
0.6870375275611877,
0.11200867593288422,
0.7213436961174011,
0.0778806209564209,
0.4807509481906891,
-0.5064795017242432,
0.43678489327430725,
-0.39833271503448486,
0.10685840249061584,
-0.1425655484199524,
-0.973560094833374,
-0.3747715353965759,
0.3626345098018646,
-0.08595433831214905,
-0.12601009011268616,
0.6555652618408203,
0.9731811285018921,
0.12626391649246216,
0.02514995075762272,
0.2997456192970276,
0.31007176637649536,
0.598863959312439,
0.464199960231781,
0.7420486807823181,
-0.1607450395822525,
0.4464353322982788,
-0.04671843349933624,
-0.2864643335342407,
-0.23393042385578156,
-0.6693708300590515,
-1.1596484184265137,
-0.620503306388855,
-0.4820221960544586,
-0.275458425283432,
-0.2138807475566864,
0.9799738526344299,
0.7171000242233276,
-0.7099353075027466,
-0.13301250338554382,
-0.1974048912525177,
-0.17210935056209564,
-0.04345191270112991,
-0.18731072545051575,
0.26877889037132263,
-0.770859956741333,
-0.9618992805480957,
0.2946852445602417,
0.281754732131958,
0.13916631042957306,
-0.27034762501716614,
0.11745016276836395,
-0.25008636713027954,
0.20681187510490417,
0.6855101585388184,
0.3085530996322632,
-0.6299249529838562,
-0.4584239721298218,
0.010444984771311283,
-0.246726855635643,
0.40329647064208984,
0.4630292057991028,
-0.49130818247795105,
0.504474937915802,
0.24469837546348572,
0.7529598474502563,
0.5667744874954224,
0.043436143547296524,
0.8840847015380859,
-0.9406622648239136,
0.17512431740760803,
0.12271095812320709,
0.19898676872253418,
0.4055290222167969,
-0.2819370925426483,
0.5759289860725403,
-0.298086017370224,
-1.0316247940063477,
-0.775812566280365,
0.1065603494644165,
-1.2535779476165771,
-0.1000940352678299,
1.2808630466461182,
0.1897212117910385,
-0.3538703918457031,
0.035654060542583466,
-0.47122812271118164,
0.4690443277359009,
-0.3498423099517822,
1.0452358722686768,
0.7821218967437744,
-0.25181102752685547,
-0.0947662815451622,
-0.7660797238349915,
0.4772008955478668,
0.3074190020561218,
-0.9312971234321594,
0.21853980422019958,
0.6798191070556641,
0.19898897409439087,
0.18993307650089264,
0.3585682213306427,
-0.00841918122023344,
0.029492642730474472,
-0.02434021793305874,
0.28186649084091187,
0.3244214653968811,
-0.04709652066230774,
-0.08512292802333832,
-0.059849683195352554,
0.11626125872135162,
-0.17683108150959015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01069v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01069v2
|
LLMCRIT: Teaching Large Language Models to Use Criteria
| 2024-03-02T02:25:55 | 2024-06-04T15:30:20 |
Weizhe Yuan, Pengfei Liu, Matthias Gallé
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Humans follow criteria when they execute tasks, and these criteria are
directly used to assess the quality of task completion. Therefore, having
models learn to use criteria to provide feedback can help humans or models to
perform tasks better. However, existing research in this field tends to
consider only a limited set of criteria or quality assessment aspects. To fill
this gap, we propose a general framework that enables large language models
(LLMs) to use comprehensive criteria for a task in delivering natural language
feedback on task execution. In particular, we present a model-in-the-loop
framework that semi-automatically derives criteria from collected guidelines
for different writing tasks and constructs in-context demonstrations for each
criterion. We choose three tasks from real-world scenarios to operationalize
this idea: paper introduction writing, Python code writing, and Reddit post
writing, and evaluate our feedback generation framework using different LLMs.
The results reveal the fine-grained effects of incorporating criteria and
demonstrations and provide valuable insights on how to teach LLMs to use
criteria more effectively.
|
[
-0.1793825477361679,
-0.8507622480392456,
0.7877264022827148,
0.22264479100704193,
-0.3741696774959564,
-0.1700473427772522,
-0.5121175050735474,
-0.35012876987457275,
-0.12085609138011932,
0.7947545647621155,
-0.37984028458595276,
-0.5866755247116089,
-0.2583514153957367,
0.11683519929647446,
-0.6794751286506653,
1.1533889770507812,
-0.36082661151885986,
0.007008175831288099,
-0.41711896657943726,
0.23792964220046997,
-0.5455772280693054,
-0.6081933975219727,
-0.6451885104179382,
-0.5193040370941162,
0.5784268975257874,
0.600740373134613,
0.2639155983924866,
0.1915009617805481,
0.5723486542701721,
0.26108571887016296,
0.20164112746715546,
0.4430692493915558,
-0.2811490297317505,
0.09852518886327744,
-0.31202757358551025,
-0.50020831823349,
-0.33528950810432434,
0.11375193297863007,
0.7011280059814453,
0.7380070090293884,
-0.27609875798225403,
0.31798702478408813,
0.3438349962234497,
0.3458097279071808,
-0.3266521692276001,
0.13997428119182587,
-0.4455450475215912,
0.017740866169333458,
0.014429383911192417,
-0.35063937306404114,
-0.5416978001594543,
-0.6708104014396667,
-0.012113004922866821,
-0.482128381729126,
0.01892699860036373,
-0.02189263515174389,
0.6741148829460144,
-0.008143588900566101,
-0.3624926805496216,
-0.7488071918487549,
-0.709164559841156,
0.7753016948699951,
-0.8957322835922241,
-0.08341803401708603,
0.5151786208152771,
0.3164660632610321,
-0.08624088019132614,
-0.6473629474639893,
-0.608668863773346,
-0.8974623680114746,
-0.09051143378019333,
-0.16445720195770264,
0.23848964273929596,
0.09189538657665253,
0.41755685210227966,
0.3423537313938141,
-0.21359342336654663,
0.17803822457790375,
-0.36437904834747314,
-0.1573815494775772,
0.5583981871604919,
0.25259929895401,
0.16882741451263428,
-0.19096697866916656,
-0.02045377902686596,
0.22073449194431305,
-0.7779273986816406,
0.09432791918516159,
0.3869840204715729,
0.5102701783180237,
-0.2741905450820923,
0.7920053601264954,
-0.2799072265625,
0.9892019033432007,
0.01075976062566042,
-0.2557302713394165,
-0.2815065383911133,
-0.42996281385421753,
-0.15114596486091614,
-0.36452487111091614,
0.6937926411628723,
0.4157702624797821,
0.2955239415168762,
-0.20410017669200897,
-0.5311924815177917,
0.25902923941612244,
0.4626087546348572,
-0.7904278635978699,
0.062427815049886703,
-0.0890585407614708,
-0.4110049307346344,
-0.31156396865844727,
0.06454066187143326,
-0.7290043234825134,
-0.452479749917984,
-0.9108119606971741,
0.5065010786056519,
-0.10779837518930435,
-0.10059316456317902,
0.025244221091270447,
0.08126084506511688,
0.2060043066740036,
0.4948662221431732,
-0.7270984053611755,
0.4017852544784546,
0.7088492512702942,
0.8046287894248962,
-0.3025995194911957,
-0.3497503399848938,
-0.915177583694458,
0.00016561892698518932,
-0.3771917521953583,
0.7552124857902527,
-0.8323097825050354,
-0.27775195240974426,
0.2358824759721756,
-0.11645426601171494,
0.05510624870657921,
-0.539310097694397,
0.547964870929718,
-0.1027088537812233,
0.3167248070240021,
-0.20522712171077728,
-0.658274233341217,
-0.07365857064723969,
0.3193858861923218,
-0.30177047848701477,
0.9159263372421265,
0.30223384499549866,
-0.5349562168121338,
0.45808082818984985,
-0.752200186252594,
-0.6215682625770569,
0.06577698141336441,
0.016612421721220016,
-0.11156827956438065,
0.3605268597602844,
0.08122474700212479,
0.754327118396759,
-0.4494713246822357,
0.48421788215637207,
-0.1363448202610016,
-0.44991403818130493,
0.3057774305343628,
-0.23773333430290222,
0.20754854381084442,
0.2390490472316742,
-0.38659191131591797,
0.5119925141334534,
-0.6252462863922119,
0.10688728839159012,
-0.26353344321250916,
-0.7534466981887817,
-0.03242729976773262,
-0.04447133094072342,
0.14311759173870087,
0.14029647409915924,
-0.11060076206922531,
-0.34566745162010193,
0.2690507769584656,
-0.2166898250579834,
0.7237392067909241,
0.3895423412322998,
0.09671714901924133,
0.41977450251579285,
-0.6298711895942688,
0.7210862040519714,
-0.28111717104911804,
-0.05883192643523216,
-0.12985411286354065,
-0.1120382621884346,
-0.9807958006858826,
-0.07867302745580673,
0.26242688298225403,
0.2787040174007416,
-0.7671042680740356,
0.49743714928627014,
-0.012454147450625896,
-0.5712253451347351,
-0.4327329695224762,
0.6709558367729187,
0.4564563035964966,
0.3693564534187317,
-0.05471792444586754,
-0.46226438879966736,
-0.5249203443527222,
-0.612416684627533,
0.08602584898471832,
-0.1762833297252655,
-0.09582296758890152,
0.10518868267536163,
0.5721873044967651,
-0.23387135565280914,
0.681924045085907,
-0.03910217061638832,
-0.2440893054008484,
-0.7080649733543396,
0.17408205568790436,
0.34900063276290894,
0.4053553342819214,
0.2657533884048462,
-0.3514673113822937,
-0.32388463616371155,
-0.12765465676784515,
-0.671890139579773,
-0.2510567903518677,
-0.38875600695610046,
-0.33344995975494385,
0.34089839458465576,
0.45365390181541443,
-0.5798736810684204,
0.14980058372020721,
0.4778918921947479,
-0.11613411456346512,
0.7106725573539734,
-0.31090089678764343,
0.22767463326454163,
-0.9005436897277832,
0.16429759562015533,
0.2696766257286072,
-0.42203834652900696,
-0.4169784486293793,
0.3182438015937805,
-0.04200126230716705,
-0.22688765823841095,
-0.31519845128059387,
0.44266632199287415,
-0.2533089220523834,
0.10516072064638138,
-0.4602985978126526,
0.20190295577049255,
0.05594714730978012,
0.36273929476737976,
0.10424171388149261,
0.630165696144104,
0.4076905846595764,
-0.8397932052612305,
0.29322028160095215,
-0.07171323895454407,
-0.80267733335495,
0.824532687664032,
-0.7074052095413208,
0.2125295251607895,
0.01234530471265316,
0.3394182622432709,
-0.6941202282905579,
-0.3165203928947449,
0.06522735208272934,
-0.21774008870124817,
0.39559832215309143,
-0.0365225113928318,
-0.721703290939331,
-0.580221951007843,
-0.16549475491046906,
-0.17485205829143524,
0.42157894372940063,
-0.34832847118377686,
0.3312808871269226,
0.3227273225784302,
-0.048354849219322205,
-0.11404924094676971,
-0.5237736701965332,
0.18083757162094116,
-0.23735754191875458,
-0.30865979194641113,
0.05710930377244949,
-0.18743908405303955,
-0.2296786606311798,
-0.13828615844249725,
0.14684323966503143,
0.09217541664838791,
0.2702772319316864,
0.32989880442619324,
0.16871069371700287,
-0.012100696563720703,
0.08837668597698212,
-0.20626983046531677,
0.0739467442035675,
0.16819621622562408,
-0.27566325664520264,
0.6116668581962585,
0.03698834404349327,
-0.5936541557312012,
-0.668550431728363,
0.40017271041870117,
0.6246070265769958,
-0.2572842240333557,
0.30678337812423706,
0.5493435263633728,
-0.3104989528656006,
-0.5037848353385925,
-0.6529850363731384,
-0.20673903822898865,
-0.43883413076400757,
0.4196252226829529,
-0.15226131677627563,
-1.084481120109558,
0.14228147268295288,
0.06307050585746765,
0.33710572123527527,
0.19553199410438538,
0.9737117290496826,
-0.16649918258190155,
0.8634089231491089,
0.7531436085700989,
-0.08221109956502914,
0.39513087272644043,
-0.20804864168167114,
0.40206965804100037,
-0.9875572919845581,
-0.0485355406999588,
-0.5383483171463013,
-0.04623285308480263,
-0.14131298661231995,
-0.6185950636863708,
0.06470853835344315,
0.291843056678772,
-0.22046729922294617,
0.3175213038921356,
-0.5725721716880798,
0.4231927692890167,
0.6027415990829468,
0.02298494428396225,
0.02108805440366268,
0.011727494187653065,
-0.35336703062057495,
0.09203950315713882,
-0.5616188645362854,
-0.9950509071350098,
0.9411006569862366,
0.2815645933151245,
0.9083013534545898,
-0.19915816187858582,
0.7367209792137146,
0.5476470589637756,
0.7500929832458496,
-0.8731939196586609,
0.6835184693336487,
0.025589125230908394,
-0.4274766743183136,
-0.19051498174667358,
-0.45081597566604614,
-0.5893558263778687,
0.0259057879447937,
-0.07029648870229721,
-0.6943392753601074,
-0.4415075480937958,
0.2351188361644745,
-0.40623077750205994,
0.16880273818969727,
-0.6272034049034119,
0.7135096192359924,
-0.36920151114463806,
-0.4096876382827759,
-0.24655696749687195,
-0.1964884251356125,
0.4502424895763397,
-0.04707186669111252,
0.2900611460208893,
-0.07862842082977295,
0.25958874821662903,
0.7140219807624817,
-0.38029181957244873,
1.3604069948196411,
-0.27142372727394104,
-0.39293062686920166,
0.6906565427780151,
0.20122329890727997,
0.48036056756973267,
0.07858489453792572,
-0.323966920375824,
-0.46157610416412354,
0.018168475478887558,
-0.027164295315742493,
-0.5776167511940002,
0.6959283351898193,
-0.42341184616088867,
-0.65480637550354,
-0.06719208508729935,
-0.5701178908348083,
-0.25557056069374084,
-0.038759421557188034,
0.02167453244328499,
0.6688417196273804,
0.051370084285736084,
0.1654980629682541,
0.09495357424020767,
-0.20499493181705475,
0.3017772138118744,
0.5391597747802734,
-0.30780351161956787,
-0.20805911719799042,
0.9194469451904297,
-0.07256492972373962,
0.43507784605026245,
0.2789371907711029,
0.22499245405197144,
-0.2613164186477661,
-0.6030868887901306,
-0.43801549077033997,
0.31392955780029297,
-0.9497671723365784,
-0.24327446520328522,
-0.34351521730422974,
-0.09430515021085739,
-0.32918012142181396,
-0.2966964840888977,
0.09389976412057877,
-0.208095982670784,
-0.24507947266101837,
-0.01610664650797844,
0.04813224449753761,
0.9841822385787964,
0.19626042246818542,
0.27925005555152893,
-0.8089459538459778,
0.10439681261777878,
0.3206963837146759,
0.2680951952934265,
0.33801016211509705,
-0.7658616900444031,
-0.22118881344795227,
0.11844994127750397,
-0.5061746835708618,
-0.44411802291870117,
0.34240224957466125,
0.32342636585235596,
0.8057012557983398,
0.22348959743976593,
-0.035152219235897064,
0.565455973148346,
-0.39858293533325195,
0.896763265132904,
0.16760705411434174,
-1.2042608261108398,
0.7950258851051331,
-0.4058383107185364,
0.36084139347076416,
0.511146068572998,
0.28392085433006287,
-0.761150598526001,
-0.7542528510093689,
-0.021012522280216217,
-0.6009320020675659,
0.5128084421157837,
0.04928881302475929,
0.48555269837379456,
-0.00772867863997817,
0.6798506379127502,
0.2289147824048996,
0.40602898597717285,
-0.8428670167922974,
0.37573227286338806,
-0.017276737838983536,
-0.39293372631073,
-0.09101825207471848,
-0.3811109662055969,
-0.16015949845314026,
-0.3566165864467621,
0.5642163157463074,
-0.3682878613471985,
0.26541540026664734,
0.1580086201429367,
-0.4073675870895386,
-0.14642594754695892,
0.4397715628147125,
0.7888402938842773,
1.1684753894805908,
0.06738658994436264,
0.07482380419969559,
0.1577257364988327,
-0.040189243853092194,
0.09150070697069168,
-0.2155217081308365,
-0.19627498090267181,
-0.16949725151062012,
0.6918807625770569,
0.7345954179763794,
0.4152475893497467,
-0.8637471199035645,
0.28094518184661865,
0.0864063948392868,
-0.4006735682487488,
-0.13882219791412354,
0.3502441346645355,
0.16586032509803772,
0.10515927523374557,
0.018689937889575958,
-0.4387558698654175,
-0.013757343403995037,
-0.8330438733100891,
0.22366605699062347,
0.2726621627807617,
-0.6068761944770813,
-0.3325421214103699,
0.43453121185302734,
0.35720211267471313,
-0.4007333815097809,
0.5462502241134644,
-0.3146737813949585,
-0.6908437609672546,
0.6104519367218018,
0.6411040425300598,
0.631753146648407,
0.12820222973823547,
0.3956971764564514,
0.49669402837753296,
0.20749378204345703,
-0.30007505416870117,
0.29895851016044617,
-0.35328495502471924,
-0.2600548267364502,
-0.7159051895141602,
-1.0876511335372925,
-0.660913348197937,
-0.0787658616900444,
-0.5545195937156677,
0.3382914960384369,
-0.48787617683410645,
-0.14399388432502747,
0.09094357490539551,
0.10800801217556,
-0.5955652594566345,
0.029427653178572655,
0.25110870599746704,
0.6192525029182434,
-0.6644469499588013,
0.8551185727119446,
0.7825689315795898,
-0.5019696354866028,
-0.9251030683517456,
-0.15913890302181244,
0.004133677575737238,
-0.5128439664840698,
0.7027806043624878,
0.34984487295150757,
0.09022210538387299,
-0.3259012997150421,
-0.6908646821975708,
-0.5071539282798767,
0.6965967416763306,
0.21122047305107117,
-0.6609475612640381,
0.047185298055410385,
0.10012674331665039,
0.7254874110221863,
-0.7356135249137878,
0.2962084114551544,
0.44174724817276,
0.5683283805847168,
0.12660810351371765,
-1.1105459928512573,
0.13340610265731812,
-0.2773435115814209,
-0.003942416049540043,
-0.023902148008346558,
-0.35633739829063416,
0.5401871204376221,
-0.43174228072166443,
-0.15406733751296997,
0.35943982005119324,
0.5652320384979248,
0.22125214338302612,
0.06460455060005188,
0.5378876328468323,
0.40701067447662354,
0.7713222503662109,
-0.04352772235870361,
1.3329179286956787,
-0.12972486019134521,
0.25029781460762024,
1.1751612424850464,
-0.5282611846923828,
0.9285880327224731,
0.30645421147346497,
-0.11533313989639282,
0.47236791253089905,
0.5495796203613281,
-0.13632404804229736,
0.22481679916381836,
0.8821759819984436,
0.009365429170429707,
-0.455436646938324,
-0.383129745721817,
0.005544913932681084,
0.39375442266464233,
0.2748873233795166,
-0.29823678731918335,
-0.1354297548532486,
0.17356108129024506,
0.03156905248761177,
0.2984630763530731,
-0.35962069034576416,
0.6479761004447937,
0.20490802824497223,
-1.1644340753555298,
0.510382354259491,
0.05361201614141464,
0.861867368221283,
-0.6340653300285339,
-0.2536723017692566,
-0.1369432508945465,
0.21666935086250305,
-0.22901372611522675,
-0.7845339775085449,
0.38216888904571533,
0.30455806851387024,
-0.20970307290554047,
-0.17312969267368317,
0.37367838621139526,
-0.5485572814941406,
-0.8019686937332153,
0.10992193222045898,
0.05421137064695358,
0.0887233316898346,
0.06421173363924026,
-0.35138267278671265,
0.11343754827976227,
-0.14631740748882294,
-0.07331990450620651,
0.28454309701919556,
0.33458390831947327,
-0.12067431211471558,
0.768739640712738,
0.6181210279464722,
0.2936641275882721,
-0.19281268119812012,
0.57247394323349,
0.7138217091560364,
-0.5544494390487671,
-0.21595612168312073,
-0.7176969647407532,
0.3734152019023895,
-0.18141832947731018,
-0.2405993938446045,
0.7817806005477905,
0.40389591455459595,
0.8598233461380005,
0.04278293624520302,
0.9293376803398132,
-0.13518935441970825,
0.5405847430229187,
-0.6861894130706787,
0.6558577418327332,
-0.5699924230575562,
0.3156208097934723,
-0.22709637880325317,
-1.1288081407546997,
-0.30189141631126404,
0.6566333770751953,
-0.19143512845039368,
0.15544162690639496,
0.8588025569915771,
0.7934603691101074,
0.07519836723804474,
-0.13519269227981567,
0.32560351490974426,
-0.03665090352296829,
0.5842090845108032,
0.5996052026748657,
1.0891631841659546,
0.08282501250505447,
0.44432851672172546,
-0.2934827208518982,
-0.05472452566027641,
-0.19323456287384033,
-0.8981014490127563,
-1.2338106632232666,
-0.5783929824829102,
-0.5263018012046814,
-0.30688410997390747,
0.049229029566049576,
1.0586388111114502,
0.8686591982841492,
-0.7760472893714905,
-0.5176457762718201,
0.07770951092243195,
0.06435796618461609,
-0.05795866250991821,
-0.20261794328689575,
0.15391996502876282,
-0.7698550820350647,
-0.6465484499931335,
0.18035441637039185,
0.24132290482521057,
-0.19497156143188477,
-0.45771902799606323,
-0.10677208006381989,
0.00003844148886855692,
0.11469981074333191,
0.6792467832565308,
0.00932527519762516,
-0.7952407002449036,
-0.4337438642978668,
-0.22463317215442657,
-0.2496490478515625,
-0.2944507300853729,
1.255090355873108,
-0.4000347852706909,
0.31963711977005005,
0.39018431305885315,
0.5450124740600586,
0.2534870505332947,
-0.2639600932598114,
0.7775534987449646,
-0.4643414616584778,
-0.17188937962055206,
0.18116803467273712,
0.2692127227783203,
0.6169294714927673,
-0.13048729300498962,
0.4091021716594696,
-0.04347311705350876,
-0.628849983215332,
-0.906441330909729,
0.025636982172727585,
-0.8741044998168945,
-0.0466063991189003,
1.4758728742599487,
-0.2554342448711395,
-0.18597851693630219,
-0.04537591710686684,
-0.3952081501483917,
0.0782330110669136,
-0.23576423525810242,
0.8712960481643677,
0.8658948540687561,
0.12031310051679611,
-0.12570463120937347,
-0.7564316987991333,
0.3387894332408905,
0.2516593933105469,
-1.0538665056228638,
0.22509969770908356,
0.5051846504211426,
0.3212350010871887,
-0.15735405683517456,
0.5364391207695007,
-0.031011482700705528,
0.274929940700531,
-0.36443206667900085,
0.035747114568948746,
0.04078465327620506,
-0.34389424324035645,
-0.21600931882858276,
0.2250651866197586,
0.5004028677940369,
0.3034694790840149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01063v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01063v1
|
FaiMA: Feature-aware In-context Learning for Multi-domain Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-03-02T02:00:51 | 2024-03-02T02:00:51 |
Songhua Yang, Xinke Jiang, Hanjie Zhao, Wenxuan Zeng, Hongde Liu, Yuxiang Jia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-domain aspect-based sentiment analysis (ABSA) seeks to capture
fine-grained sentiment across diverse domains. While existing research narrowly
focuses on single-domain applications constrained by methodological limitations
and data scarcity, the reality is that sentiment naturally traverses multiple
domains. Although large language models (LLMs) offer a promising solution for
ABSA, it is difficult to integrate effectively with established techniques,
including graph-based models and linguistics, because modifying their internal
architecture is not easy. To alleviate this problem, we propose a novel
framework, Feature-aware In-context Learning for Multi-domain ABSA (FaiMA). The
core insight of FaiMA is to utilize in-context learning (ICL) as a
feature-aware mechanism that facilitates adaptive learning in multi-domain ABSA
tasks. Specifically, we employ a multi-head graph attention network as a text
encoder optimized by heuristic rules for linguistic, domain, and sentiment
features. Through contrastive learning, we optimize sentence representations by
focusing on these diverse features. Additionally, we construct an efficient
indexing mechanism, allowing FaiMA to stably retrieve highly relevant examples
across multiple dimensions for any given input. To evaluate the efficacy of
FaiMA, we build the first multi-domain ABSA benchmark dataset. Extensive
experimental results demonstrate that FaiMA achieves significant performance
improvements in multiple domains compared to baselines, increasing F1 by 2.07%
on average. Source code and data sets are anonymously available at
https://github.com/SupritYoung/FaiMA.
|
[
-0.7546859979629517,
-0.6804007291793823,
0.29671889543533325,
0.4723367989063263,
-0.34899288415908813,
0.08745434880256653,
-0.22203004360198975,
-0.4550222158432007,
0.28361040353775024,
0.3913436233997345,
-0.48904794454574585,
-0.683983325958252,
-0.6939561367034912,
0.15753112733364105,
-0.16983357071876526,
0.9627802968025208,
-0.13930878043174744,
-0.020288869738578796,
-0.5521446466445923,
-0.7370392084121704,
-0.3613985776901245,
-0.6695746183395386,
-0.3855953514575958,
-0.15124967694282532,
0.2501898407936096,
0.5897868871688843,
0.2598501145839691,
0.09294358640909195,
0.5412635207176208,
0.23861373960971832,
0.0758974626660347,
0.6081833243370056,
-0.3259164094924927,
0.18832828104496002,
-0.21433600783348083,
-0.030853595584630966,
-0.5483160614967346,
-0.16201025247573853,
0.5821787118911743,
0.745776891708374,
0.26139286160469055,
-0.05354837700724602,
0.3882104754447937,
0.8249014616012573,
-0.6690830588340759,
0.4739951193332672,
-0.616629958152771,
-0.18984337151050568,
-0.13235364854335785,
-0.13206499814987183,
-0.2827052175998688,
-0.1485360860824585,
0.23335500061511993,
-0.5300946831703186,
0.10857334733009338,
0.03313259035348892,
0.874802827835083,
0.1351625919342041,
-0.3340895473957062,
-0.3155283033847809,
-0.1556878387928009,
0.7834458351135254,
-0.42354923486709595,
0.486959308385849,
0.3278883695602417,
-0.05823648348450661,
0.11817673593759537,
-0.5674375891685486,
-0.49001839756965637,
0.3026904761791229,
-0.085354283452034,
0.11656881123781204,
-0.03172197937965393,
-0.20473362505435944,
-0.22443053126335144,
0.4474565088748932,
-0.36118388175964355,
-0.2279151827096939,
0.08216258883476257,
-0.00862463004887104,
0.4926791787147522,
-0.09157583862543106,
0.020150812342762947,
0.028809404000639915,
-0.619355320930481,
-0.026624714955687523,
-0.7641245126724243,
0.3269820809364319,
0.04711711034178734,
0.780403733253479,
-0.32658109068870544,
-0.06595925986766815,
-0.2669411897659302,
0.4783220887184143,
0.033984120935201645,
-0.05254783108830452,
0.628092885017395,
-0.09080240875482559,
-0.29703351855278015,
-0.08879182487726212,
0.898137092590332,
0.09930280596017838,
-0.11444631218910217,
0.042609717696905136,
-0.23487557470798492,
-0.04200224578380585,
0.26305776834487915,
-0.9251073598861694,
-0.1771625131368637,
0.2960224449634552,
-0.25294017791748047,
-0.11541738361120224,
0.25464269518852234,
-0.7508822083473206,
-0.40929949283599854,
-0.16176727414131165,
0.40355879068374634,
-0.6867880821228027,
-0.15776893496513367,
0.06091557443141937,
0.3003789186477661,
0.020561065524816513,
0.2379656434059143,
-0.6221439242362976,
0.17955610156059265,
0.8671279549598694,
0.962402880191803,
-0.12936271727085114,
-0.4574618637561798,
-0.5953973531723022,
-0.2027449607849121,
-0.28807371854782104,
0.8671960830688477,
-0.6803041696548462,
-0.3916400372982025,
0.0899529829621315,
-0.0851057842373848,
-0.21346214413642883,
-0.6508107781410217,
0.42839089035987854,
-0.5710656642913818,
0.03272577002644539,
-0.2870679199695587,
-0.47068193554878235,
-0.8321889638900757,
0.44153574109077454,
-0.5801406502723694,
0.845581591129303,
0.3551504909992218,
-0.7294387817382812,
0.2919715344905853,
-0.8926995992660522,
-0.7730970978736877,
-0.24018831551074982,
-0.06737907230854034,
-0.7712957859039307,
0.046908315271139145,
0.4722626209259033,
0.7691464424133301,
-0.2802125811576843,
0.21360176801681519,
-0.5295145511627197,
-0.19280599057674408,
0.4003686308860779,
-0.2181832194328308,
0.6057942509651184,
0.12648345530033112,
-0.20275752246379852,
0.34183627367019653,
-0.2744396924972534,
-0.36470386385917664,
-0.049344502389431,
-0.058206651359796524,
-0.42685747146606445,
-0.21819831430912018,
0.18405590951442719,
0.35411375761032104,
0.09623720496892929,
-0.505148708820343,
-0.0557117834687233,
-0.5295774340629578,
0.2337682545185089,
0.5708258748054504,
0.19207872450351715,
0.3891143500804901,
-0.30306246876716614,
0.3977140486240387,
0.603011429309845,
0.12441189587116241,
-0.40908312797546387,
-0.47977396845817566,
-0.675340473651886,
-0.5933952927589417,
0.18130388855934143,
0.14208288490772247,
-0.6606783270835876,
0.5366853475570679,
-0.23683741688728333,
-0.08745979517698288,
-0.5087823271751404,
0.4970255196094513,
0.4143441319465637,
0.5726917386054993,
0.46895742416381836,
-0.6955142617225647,
-0.17231696844100952,
-0.7458025217056274,
-0.08689720928668976,
-0.04970970004796982,
0.3634224236011505,
0.4406338036060333,
0.46802470088005066,
-0.35467520356178284,
1.1237051486968994,
-0.45910778641700745,
-1.0285013914108276,
-0.38104552030563354,
0.07303306460380554,
-0.15623235702514648,
0.21599717438220978,
0.8299396634101868,
-0.967045247554779,
-0.589766800403595,
0.19018368422985077,
-0.888361930847168,
0.04670464247465134,
-0.04076631739735603,
-0.20040884613990784,
0.28172820806503296,
0.17183305323123932,
-0.315577894449234,
0.10364874452352524,
0.5020744204521179,
-0.19139666855335236,
0.006280715111643076,
0.229402557015419,
0.07737484574317932,
-1.3534934520721436,
0.0766117125749588,
0.44086718559265137,
-0.25829559564590454,
-0.43393969535827637,
0.19040589034557343,
0.1797182559967041,
0.04086197912693024,
-0.5026929378509521,
0.5187816023826599,
-0.2604522407054901,
-0.0655754804611206,
-0.5053667426109314,
0.2540230453014374,
0.39481204748153687,
0.6955899000167847,
0.02850419469177723,
0.7921215891838074,
0.7435991764068604,
-0.552349865436554,
-0.043647147715091705,
0.30716392397880554,
-0.18335875868797302,
0.7466438412666321,
-0.025419097393751144,
0.09178676456212997,
-0.05368439108133316,
0.30522117018699646,
-0.8274470567703247,
-0.25278523564338684,
0.3679846525192261,
-0.4200836718082428,
0.35599640011787415,
0.057593125849962234,
-0.07035243511199951,
0.09968666732311249,
-0.5586550235748291,
0.3279144763946533,
-0.044343527406454086,
-0.7679615616798401,
0.9099928736686707,
0.7224743366241455,
-0.21986795961856842,
-0.8631604313850403,
-0.2756483554840088,
-0.020835326984524727,
-0.3053799271583557,
-0.36055320501327515,
0.420226514339447,
0.002853924408555031,
-0.21537016332149506,
0.0337505117058754,
-0.0656539648771286,
-0.18797346949577332,
0.381311297416687,
0.39212727546691895,
-0.16133001446723938,
-0.21020008623600006,
0.1447691172361374,
0.3802703320980072,
-0.051865700632333755,
0.0682503953576088,
-0.3867095410823822,
0.45856213569641113,
-0.5366935133934021,
-0.22137929499149323,
-0.5299374461174011,
0.4479658901691437,
0.48970523476600647,
-0.4581221044063568,
0.530785322189331,
0.5886508822441101,
-0.5718977451324463,
-0.551331102848053,
-0.07012420892715454,
-0.14440663158893585,
-0.46097713708877563,
0.4295622408390045,
-0.5772579312324524,
-1.0591099262237549,
0.4587405025959015,
-0.3994796872138977,
-0.0216366034001112,
0.41088035702705383,
0.5048633217811584,
-0.08101008087396622,
0.501750111579895,
0.7616970539093018,
-0.3902355134487152,
0.47146743535995483,
-0.6670500040054321,
0.2939073443412781,
-1.0167814493179321,
-0.16617877781391144,
-0.3318934440612793,
-0.20494934916496277,
0.03434227779507637,
-0.4435073733329773,
0.38790079951286316,
0.26341262459754944,
-0.16514812409877777,
0.05943578481674194,
-0.20301344990730286,
0.3961995542049408,
0.22010178864002228,
0.08186466991901398,
0.13485002517700195,
-0.10604698210954666,
0.057136308401823044,
0.17184603214263916,
-0.6039214730262756,
-0.26630088686943054,
0.9683565497398376,
0.3057653307914734,
0.4008083641529083,
0.10539204627275467,
0.5627387166023254,
0.37171196937561035,
0.7921608090400696,
-1.0541428327560425,
0.3216562569141388,
-0.45637047290802,
-0.052414704114198685,
0.010776907205581665,
-0.3331846296787262,
-0.47351551055908203,
0.45256489515304565,
-0.19119615852832794,
-0.38302329182624817,
0.4064081907272339,
-0.1017458364367485,
-0.316816508769989,
0.29490357637405396,
-0.26545250415802,
0.9369269609451294,
-0.07501283288002014,
-0.2532787024974823,
-0.10051213949918747,
-0.5448126196861267,
0.43274810910224915,
-0.47430676221847534,
0.3538528084754944,
-0.26107990741729736,
0.03666898235678673,
0.4145631790161133,
-0.1981930434703827,
1.086262822151184,
-0.2582588493824005,
-0.15899072587490082,
0.3486293852329254,
0.05303112417459488,
0.08472520858049393,
0.4475858509540558,
-0.013480273075401783,
0.6152059435844421,
-0.48936206102371216,
-0.06437615305185318,
-0.482932984828949,
1.026559829711914,
-0.8266193866729736,
-0.34439322352409363,
-0.3696660101413727,
-0.5555328726768494,
-0.645689070224762,
0.10758640617132187,
0.11153599619865417,
0.6137681007385254,
-0.3938203752040863,
0.34456294775009155,
0.6247537136077881,
0.020449914038181305,
0.48418128490448,
0.3783267140388489,
-0.16919772326946259,
-0.4457610547542572,
1.1611850261688232,
-0.17670850455760956,
-0.1665695160627365,
0.6412448883056641,
0.10553526878356934,
-0.323877215385437,
-0.5080404281616211,
-0.5272713899612427,
0.08806707710027695,
-0.8655247092247009,
-0.7114546895027161,
-0.8853740096092224,
-0.018712764605879784,
-0.32345473766326904,
-0.2589878737926483,
-0.3104718327522278,
-0.10963384807109833,
-0.42716434597969055,
0.0392870269715786,
0.5313217639923096,
0.6240074038505554,
0.22647058963775635,
0.4260261058807373,
-0.701521098613739,
0.2836143970489502,
0.0805942565202713,
0.4397851824760437,
0.0715315043926239,
-0.3911340832710266,
-0.4855383038520813,
-0.150079607963562,
-0.522482693195343,
-0.5234028100967407,
0.5470008850097656,
0.7109537720680237,
0.30763477087020874,
0.7037428617477417,
0.17378951609134674,
0.36173027753829956,
-0.111097551882267,
0.675049364566803,
-0.06727735698223114,
-1.1914496421813965,
0.40637901425361633,
-0.0829085186123848,
0.07321178168058395,
0.636319100856781,
0.5087077617645264,
-0.49087798595428467,
-0.4720872938632965,
-0.2303381860256195,
-0.9065667390823364,
0.7703568935394287,
-0.1025991216301918,
0.23325131833553314,
-0.16720452904701233,
0.4044812321662903,
0.4214290976524353,
0.1462990641593933,
-0.36469849944114685,
-0.3039688766002655,
-0.4719279110431671,
-0.6078708171844482,
-0.014837455935776234,
0.05562502145767212,
-0.23447299003601074,
-0.06006579101085663,
0.8697296380996704,
-0.8980118632316589,
0.08639924228191376,
0.17725041508674622,
-0.42667824029922485,
0.11842186003923416,
0.1359695941209793,
0.48990052938461304,
0.6346818804740906,
-0.011003020219504833,
-0.00958994496613741,
0.11687237024307251,
-0.33781898021698,
-0.08085528016090393,
0.18822455406188965,
-0.12824667990207672,
-0.1700143963098526,
0.3177010416984558,
0.8693100214004517,
0.29380348324775696,
-0.4627175033092499,
0.767169177532196,
-0.10331602394580841,
-0.14436227083206177,
-0.031770430505275726,
-0.06193344667553902,
0.017511986196041107,
0.2993658185005188,
0.45020198822021484,
0.31276077032089233,
0.2025485783815384,
-0.4263271689414978,
0.5122086405754089,
0.5014545321464539,
-0.7632836103439331,
-0.40990644693374634,
0.5830497741699219,
0.29130229353904724,
-0.013070646673440933,
0.21020826697349548,
-0.15930768847465515,
-0.6173563003540039,
0.5810432434082031,
0.4545942544937134,
1.281769037246704,
-0.14424195885658264,
0.359923392534256,
-0.03655996918678284,
-0.05770445987582207,
0.16771189868450165,
0.2646351754665375,
-0.03398424759507179,
-1.037268042564392,
-0.10866282135248184,
-0.766354501247406,
-0.5988669395446777,
-0.14201052486896515,
-0.5731764435768127,
-0.06552039831876755,
-0.6067153811454773,
-0.15714751183986664,
-0.0788738802075386,
-0.07157549262046814,
-0.5116973519325256,
0.30420851707458496,
-0.07009978592395782,
0.6504007577896118,
-0.7457552552223206,
0.9681118726730347,
0.8303453326225281,
-0.40749600529670715,
-0.395141065120697,
0.46945491433143616,
0.04340426251292229,
-0.370049387216568,
0.2651374340057373,
0.6025604605674744,
-0.509722113609314,
-0.2921900153160095,
-0.13828438520431519,
-0.5738114714622498,
0.97980135679245,
0.2929801344871521,
-0.07249533385038376,
0.7265229821205139,
0.11694596707820892,
0.45684871077537537,
-1.1551381349563599,
-0.15757916867733002,
0.3704512119293213,
0.04179711267352104,
-0.24776601791381836,
-0.4947027266025543,
-0.004646428395062685,
-0.20222340524196625,
-0.03530646860599518,
0.15209227800369263,
-1.1723711490631104,
0.8595619797706604,
-0.11009291559457779,
0.0009751997422426939,
-0.3281513452529907,
1.1774948835372925,
0.11563559621572495,
0.5367777347564697,
0.4694291353225708,
0.3619481325149536,
0.7420396208763123,
-0.0904722809791565,
0.8710523247718811,
-0.6660521030426025,
0.4292038083076477,
0.8642745018005371,
-0.5497286319732666,
0.9712129831314087,
0.22296598553657532,
0.21802201867103577,
0.7193662524223328,
0.5815574526786804,
0.622706413269043,
0.6466788649559021,
-0.3767628073692322,
-0.411767840385437,
-0.22594493627548218,
-0.2358211725950241,
-0.15370777249336243,
0.6187899708747864,
0.740014910697937,
-0.33883577585220337,
-0.00809476152062416,
0.35098591446876526,
0.08370339125394821,
0.2532537579536438,
-0.2706420123577118,
0.8392924666404724,
0.39229050278663635,
-0.19717000424861908,
0.24920283257961273,
0.25305914878845215,
0.896760106086731,
-0.6436221599578857,
0.07632297277450562,
-0.6178807616233826,
0.3566019833087921,
-0.19420258700847626,
-0.6644939184188843,
0.390815794467926,
-0.08859117329120636,
-0.3239228129386902,
-0.13381130993366241,
0.5858258605003357,
-0.5188726782798767,
-0.406578004360199,
0.5374180674552917,
0.44988933205604553,
-0.2953803241252899,
-0.3994961380958557,
-0.7732676863670349,
0.12783585488796234,
-0.211837500333786,
-0.30040255188941956,
0.5963255763053894,
0.5266041159629822,
-0.33819371461868286,
0.5954748392105103,
0.3177154064178467,
-0.36406010389328003,
-0.6205448508262634,
0.2624972462654114,
1.0183414220809937,
-0.46775171160697937,
-0.7468535304069519,
-0.6733237504959106,
0.10798179358243942,
0.06248188763856888,
-0.5495954751968384,
0.6723963022232056,
0.7025564908981323,
1.0180507898330688,
0.05876380205154419,
0.9195955395698547,
0.26810887455940247,
0.2823857367038727,
-0.45140331983566284,
0.8582372069358826,
-0.713364839553833,
0.20646041631698608,
-0.23346276581287384,
-0.98700350522995,
-0.6297940611839294,
0.6017876267433167,
0.04644319415092468,
0.10413765162229538,
0.7280179858207703,
0.7177668213844299,
-0.19646230340003967,
0.2486531138420105,
0.1015041172504425,
0.07624194025993347,
0.3611403703689575,
0.47265157103538513,
0.405085951089859,
-0.4824111759662628,
0.13669665157794952,
-0.43374815583229065,
-0.17087532579898834,
-0.19339391589164734,
-0.7009742856025696,
-0.7210565209388733,
-0.8445502519607544,
-0.44100749492645264,
-0.2617228329181671,
-0.17017146944999695,
1.1148613691329956,
0.6893787980079651,
-1.0350080728530884,
-0.167465478181839,
0.42765605449676514,
0.32408589124679565,
-0.7115656137466431,
-0.28351449966430664,
0.6592754125595093,
-0.5779815912246704,
-0.7366558313369751,
0.6648075580596924,
0.5991156697273254,
-0.3915993571281433,
-0.2729792892932892,
-0.13425104320049286,
-0.15433958172798157,
0.2748175263404846,
0.8932972550392151,
0.06325166672468185,
-0.543426513671875,
-0.4093402326107025,
-0.2893397808074951,
-0.07999876886606216,
0.3839968144893646,
0.9091331362724304,
-0.7720662355422974,
0.37146976590156555,
0.38830357789993286,
0.9183247685432434,
0.08184178918600082,
0.2226693481206894,
0.312761127948761,
-1.2131664752960205,
0.1066189780831337,
0.1034868136048317,
0.6025521755218506,
0.7021675705909729,
-0.40937045216560364,
0.29864591360092163,
0.36000242829322815,
-0.12107672542333603,
-0.5480656623840332,
0.06423462927341461,
-1.0675712823867798,
-0.5071162581443787,
0.9336788654327393,
-0.435384064912796,
-0.22600267827510834,
-0.32385510206222534,
-0.050259001553058624,
-0.020574962720274925,
-0.622812807559967,
0.8105195164680481,
0.47369953989982605,
-0.24432332813739777,
-0.016314363107085228,
0.054768580943346024,
0.6382639408111572,
0.11936342716217041,
-0.9936854243278503,
0.3118637502193451,
0.522422194480896,
0.1788019984960556,
0.03377183526754379,
0.7472389340400696,
-0.04446797072887421,
0.1205679178237915,
-0.25939083099365234,
-0.08333457261323929,
-0.3312695026397705,
-0.9240807294845581,
-0.6588481664657593,
0.6943140625953674,
-0.0416523739695549,
-0.11292634159326553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01061v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01061v1
|
Reading Subtext: Evaluating Large Language Models on Short Story Summarization with Writers
| 2024-03-02T01:52:14 | 2024-03-02T01:52:14 |
Melanie Subbiah, Sean Zhang, Lydia B. Chilton, Kathleen McKeown
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We evaluate recent Large language Models (LLMs) on the challenging task of
summarizing short stories, which can be lengthy, and include nuanced subtext or
scrambled timelines. Importantly, we work directly with authors to ensure that
the stories have not been shared online (and therefore are unseen by the
models), and to obtain informed evaluations of summary quality using judgments
from the authors themselves. Through quantitative and qualitative analysis
grounded in narrative theory, we compare GPT-4, Claude-2.1, and LLama-2-70B. We
find that all three models make faithfulness mistakes in over 50% of summaries
and struggle to interpret difficult subtext. However, at their best, the models
can provide thoughtful thematic analysis of stories. We additionally
demonstrate that LLM judgments of summary quality do not match the feedback
from the writers.
|
[
-0.11183686554431915,
-0.665213942527771,
1.0827833414077759,
0.347309947013855,
-0.5562266707420349,
0.1951446384191513,
-0.05528910830616951,
-0.8618884682655334,
0.28699207305908203,
0.606519341468811,
-0.5491189360618591,
-0.32914772629737854,
-0.6843974590301514,
0.3574332594871521,
-0.600958526134491,
1.1881017684936523,
-0.19706706702709198,
-0.09367775917053223,
-0.46538493037223816,
-0.10934137552976608,
-0.23959745466709137,
-0.46975943446159363,
-0.40667209029197693,
-0.5206973552703857,
0.5827248096466064,
0.14487780630588531,
0.832245409488678,
0.4498588442802429,
0.48474207520484924,
0.2545960545539856,
-0.35386061668395996,
0.007873537950217724,
-0.7912752032279968,
0.05226597562432289,
-0.20778462290763855,
-0.3595752716064453,
-0.6363461017608643,
-0.041855957359075546,
0.4970836639404297,
0.6179459691047668,
0.13094693422317505,
0.19109225273132324,
0.004042080137878656,
0.658162534236908,
-0.23616747558116913,
0.0952368900179863,
-0.18584184348583221,
0.025007521733641624,
-0.0769835039973259,
-0.04100966453552246,
-0.27056756615638733,
-0.5562623739242554,
0.3598966598510742,
-0.35979488492012024,
0.3049944043159485,
0.06870058923959732,
0.6697552800178528,
0.0755918025970459,
-0.6296391487121582,
-0.47459927201271057,
-0.6559164524078369,
0.8373538255691528,
-0.8285840749740601,
0.033997878432273865,
0.5969033241271973,
0.06206115335226059,
0.1335621327161789,
-0.8648050427436829,
-0.4146117866039276,
-0.5114704370498657,
-0.3272353410720825,
0.2633732259273529,
-0.3633687198162079,
-0.13507050275802612,
0.07295377552509308,
0.6298316121101379,
-0.6642810702323914,
0.09917937964200974,
-0.5132105350494385,
-0.11124756932258606,
0.6874867677688599,
0.5217481851577759,
0.3188788890838623,
-0.20825932919979095,
-0.27013450860977173,
0.2647162675857544,
-0.7584320902824402,
-0.053807929158210754,
0.6423752903938293,
-0.15262679755687714,
-0.28430551290512085,
0.7720354795455933,
-0.07524757832288742,
0.3155546188354492,
-0.26294100284576416,
-0.3593725264072418,
0.029160333797335625,
-0.7128553986549377,
-0.1265789121389389,
-0.05899715796113014,
0.8405648469924927,
0.7491504549980164,
0.5406554937362671,
-0.10806305706501007,
-0.32297834753990173,
-0.2915864884853363,
0.022764980792999268,
-0.6569828987121582,
-0.0653112381696701,
0.21492478251457214,
-0.6587008237838745,
-0.30602648854255676,
-0.16650570929050446,
-0.4777865707874298,
-0.499939501285553,
-0.2920057475566864,
0.19120532274246216,
-0.28968504071235657,
0.12443523108959198,
0.13889557123184204,
-0.2700214385986328,
0.06822766363620758,
0.47836676239967346,
-0.9339932799339294,
0.2857987880706787,
0.616277813911438,
0.9549366235733032,
-0.12549149990081787,
-0.46775108575820923,
-0.16341447830200195,
0.15116067230701447,
-0.35554805397987366,
0.854102373123169,
-0.21308083832263947,
-0.6355226039886475,
-0.22510486841201782,
-0.12746359407901764,
0.060189153999090195,
-0.32041415572166443,
0.5154298543930054,
-0.30108705163002014,
0.29931318759918213,
-0.2869037389755249,
-0.554620087146759,
-0.16931293904781342,
0.22558587789535522,
-0.7397398352622986,
0.7359350919723511,
0.15323378145694733,
-0.7811617851257324,
-0.03222004696726799,
-0.22434265911579132,
-0.41381052136421204,
-0.21257443726062775,
0.11570607870817184,
-0.17539821565151215,
0.42204347252845764,
0.6094846725463867,
0.4600321054458618,
-0.35913753509521484,
0.21018506586551666,
-0.0955856591463089,
-0.4417929947376251,
0.23285642266273499,
-0.23138728737831116,
0.5727952122688293,
0.02297413907945156,
-0.011026072315871716,
0.25227171182632446,
-0.256034255027771,
-0.2517952620983124,
0.30756351351737976,
-0.28139975666999817,
-0.3342989385128021,
0.024699052795767784,
0.11227589100599289,
-0.12961606681346893,
0.32544317841529846,
-0.2622797191143036,
0.2239583134651184,
-0.3516967296600342,
0.46392834186553955,
0.48588335514068604,
0.13139665126800537,
0.2299853265285492,
-0.5718135833740234,
0.7324904203414917,
-0.11119811236858368,
0.18651367723941803,
-0.44015932083129883,
-0.3700876235961914,
-0.6621342301368713,
-0.15333105623722076,
0.3511795401573181,
0.47001370787620544,
-0.786570131778717,
-0.11907629668712616,
-0.231739342212677,
-0.6970399022102356,
-0.37686842679977417,
0.15617795288562775,
0.5571762919425964,
0.3123480975627899,
0.35840708017349243,
-0.2724585235118866,
-0.36270391941070557,
-0.9621194005012512,
-0.5812373757362366,
-0.2992951273918152,
-0.15752045810222626,
0.049990780651569366,
0.8511918187141418,
-0.297795832157135,
0.8023853898048401,
-0.4976706802845001,
-0.10970413684844971,
-0.9033073782920837,
0.33949679136276245,
0.22397568821907043,
0.21317361295223236,
0.8316023349761963,
-0.538970410823822,
-0.4508713483810425,
-0.24965175986289978,
-0.704610288143158,
-0.19341450929641724,
0.07163145393133163,
0.4033948481082916,
0.19355624914169312,
0.5299404263496399,
-0.6017480492591858,
0.40502506494522095,
0.7373895049095154,
-0.3791104555130005,
0.723115086555481,
-0.17270362377166748,
0.21315814554691315,
-0.9479345083236694,
-0.17200469970703125,
0.09666755795478821,
-0.5173261761665344,
-0.2918343245983124,
0.007742824964225292,
-0.051099229604005814,
0.25222355127334595,
-0.42249852418899536,
0.47412800788879395,
-0.3993616998195648,
-0.22804291546344757,
-0.3444884717464447,
0.23556773364543915,
0.12642596662044525,
0.18555235862731934,
0.014532702974975109,
0.632990300655365,
-0.054862916469573975,
-0.21373793482780457,
0.3687567710876465,
0.1143076941370964,
-0.6663556098937988,
0.3211331069469452,
-0.9837870001792908,
0.037651028484106064,
-0.20343075692653656,
0.5764121413230896,
-0.7967001795768738,
-0.3690594732761383,
0.03531306982040405,
-0.3273611068725586,
0.14870552718639374,
-0.08943251520395279,
-0.6415817141532898,
-0.027709176763892174,
-0.3825274705886841,
0.4990883767604828,
0.5084009766578674,
-0.2712670862674713,
0.5108790993690491,
0.2962290942668915,
-0.5638758540153503,
-0.46075716614723206,
-0.81033855676651,
0.21448399126529694,
-0.17215174436569214,
-0.28108254075050354,
0.18563596904277802,
-0.0769776999950409,
-0.5101244449615479,
0.14884597063064575,
-0.19248761236667633,
-0.06771035492420197,
-0.1065826341509819,
-0.08333468437194824,
0.0575268380343914,
-0.22015036642551422,
-0.2020522505044937,
0.18532031774520874,
-0.1606307178735733,
0.10203584283590317,
0.08560531586408615,
0.2903400957584381,
-0.17613743245601654,
-0.19574229419231415,
-0.3494403660297394,
0.48023420572280884,
0.6345113515853882,
-0.10674743354320526,
0.5665347576141357,
0.3621389865875244,
-0.24585893750190735,
0.15286174416542053,
-0.4310626685619354,
0.0547180213034153,
-0.3719549775123596,
0.4227354824542999,
-0.20143553614616394,
-1.0673787593841553,
0.5065076351165771,
0.24048031866550446,
0.0020662888418883085,
0.6921756267547607,
0.5556503534317017,
-0.2808641791343689,
0.7998806834220886,
1.039117693901062,
-0.09813641011714935,
0.3752857744693756,
-0.0818474292755127,
0.14172612130641937,
-0.6289164423942566,
-0.08914143592119217,
-0.4588452875614166,
-0.17243726551532745,
-0.20129132270812988,
-0.24051980674266815,
0.32586735486984253,
0.12241292744874954,
0.04512256756424904,
0.24895308911800385,
0.12820389866828918,
0.9064178466796875,
0.36839908361434937,
-0.021165909245610237,
0.6755706667900085,
-0.21901996433734894,
-0.03601354360580444,
-0.2685692608356476,
-0.39834627509117126,
-0.7922217845916748,
0.7705700397491455,
0.6289637088775635,
1.0187304019927979,
0.34189996123313904,
0.42301592230796814,
0.3532570004463196,
0.3240598738193512,
-0.8575698733329773,
0.4970366358757019,
-0.1836724877357483,
-0.46729549765586853,
-0.26399680972099304,
-0.5261402130126953,
-0.692142903804779,
0.294225811958313,
-0.05620701238512993,
-0.7785261273384094,
-0.02664267271757126,
-0.08756564557552338,
-0.2673807740211487,
0.18048402667045593,
-0.6364942789077759,
0.682321310043335,
-0.202848419547081,
0.04643529653549194,
-0.1981872320175171,
-0.8087583780288696,
0.7006590366363525,
-0.17492614686489105,
0.20897488296031952,
-0.15050473809242249,
-0.20469363033771515,
0.649956464767456,
-0.2378588169813156,
0.9431852102279663,
0.4281158447265625,
-0.2053627073764801,
0.3396061360836029,
0.33478307723999023,
0.28345009684562683,
0.2916892170906067,
0.09154200553894043,
0.22153134644031525,
0.300309956073761,
-0.5215697288513184,
-0.5779896974563599,
0.5445659756660461,
-0.7296916246414185,
-0.5156348943710327,
-0.5933898687362671,
-0.7273317575454712,
-0.1800214946269989,
0.2710094451904297,
0.3892023265361786,
0.4488840401172638,
-0.3778212368488312,
0.25798043608665466,
0.3898651599884033,
-0.18781736493110657,
0.5479407906532288,
0.4168768525123596,
-0.38931745290756226,
-0.5595550537109375,
0.3435952961444855,
0.09266509860754013,
0.41337111592292786,
0.4868660569190979,
0.21760523319244385,
-0.36794134974479675,
-0.75838303565979,
-0.33993804454803467,
0.502566397190094,
-0.8026825189590454,
0.04568590596318245,
-0.6540815830230713,
-0.0710148811340332,
-0.209995836019516,
-0.11320772767066956,
-0.32885241508483887,
-0.5308864712715149,
-0.2629023492336273,
-0.36088111996650696,
0.18756866455078125,
1.247084140777588,
0.21349479258060455,
0.456685334444046,
-1.0432467460632324,
0.27389419078826904,
0.09338679164648056,
0.04888700693845749,
-0.07097279280424118,
-0.5461723804473877,
-0.44046857953071594,
-0.16586634516716003,
-0.27819472551345825,
-0.9006834626197815,
0.4086187779903412,
-0.19371840357780457,
0.21504947543144226,
-0.03843560069799423,
0.06390697509050369,
0.5788535475730896,
-0.43191957473754883,
1.0757156610488892,
0.0947103351354599,
-1.1905344724655151,
0.3734426498413086,
-0.6013170480728149,
0.4877924621105194,
0.41660869121551514,
0.5546117424964905,
-0.4198934733867645,
-0.5942857265472412,
-0.43701738119125366,
-0.9090123772621155,
0.49534833431243896,
0.3461241126060486,
0.2570229470729828,
0.14349141716957092,
0.3718706965446472,
0.2416166067123413,
0.3150778114795685,
-0.9009771943092346,
-0.07947366684675217,
-0.13405485451221466,
-0.3625556230545044,
-0.6176514029502869,
-0.9391148686408997,
-0.08096330612897873,
-0.019657282158732414,
0.5406913757324219,
-0.041415996849536896,
-0.028964901342988014,
0.30503255128860474,
-0.2861515283584595,
-0.11768165230751038,
0.2511114180088043,
1.0375758409500122,
1.1320836544036865,
-0.23886652290821075,
0.10235530138015747,
0.38290318846702576,
-0.6220109462738037,
-0.0905192643404007,
-0.24684526026248932,
-0.014618147164583206,
0.1929628849029541,
1.1712251901626587,
0.5722671747207642,
0.36810630559921265,
-0.7202653288841248,
0.5560862421989441,
-0.4744764268398285,
-0.1930180937051773,
-0.25222527980804443,
-0.20368799567222595,
0.2536128759384155,
0.48016759753227234,
0.2321728765964508,
-0.3303092420101166,
0.06368531286716461,
-0.7080641388893127,
-0.1559937745332718,
-0.00071790034417063,
-0.38502737879753113,
-0.37487301230430603,
0.5107415318489075,
0.10135525465011597,
0.0061008562333881855,
0.5506815314292908,
0.13195987045764923,
-0.39595481753349304,
0.6528015732765198,
0.5720306038856506,
0.9454115629196167,
0.09533615410327911,
0.1281883269548416,
0.015079955570399761,
0.8199600577354431,
-0.21797798573970795,
0.050797805190086365,
0.27811399102211,
-0.3907865583896637,
-0.8230245113372803,
-0.54317706823349,
-0.8452789187431335,
0.24476075172424316,
-0.6201642751693726,
-0.023910654708743095,
-0.13348151743412018,
0.02121848240494728,
-0.16043251752853394,
-0.029286324977874756,
-0.06428351253271103,
0.11850416660308838,
-0.2555946707725525,
0.906524121761322,
-0.7514743208885193,
0.560847282409668,
0.5510163307189941,
-0.4789270758628845,
-0.5090488791465759,
0.3389686048030853,
-0.04654468223452568,
-0.35970640182495117,
0.4001128673553467,
-0.0706169605255127,
-0.07206142693758011,
0.07149698585271835,
-0.4676423668861389,
-0.7088127732276917,
1.1784040927886963,
0.5389791131019592,
-0.5328955054283142,
-0.06612467765808105,
-0.09913942217826843,
0.8143643736839294,
-0.3169836699962616,
0.2713972330093384,
0.5110162496566772,
0.30652087926864624,
-0.032989226281642914,
-1.1289880275726318,
-0.06979639083147049,
0.05213242396712303,
-0.13599853217601776,
0.044401999562978745,
-0.7455074787139893,
0.8861154317855835,
-0.3306574821472168,
-0.07781046628952026,
0.5006319284439087,
0.7870478630065918,
0.2598068118095398,
0.5348472595214844,
0.33097290992736816,
0.48030543327331543,
0.43509751558303833,
-0.05181662365794182,
1.4371607303619385,
0.1907203644514084,
0.5532098412513733,
1.2623212337493896,
-0.17693142592906952,
0.6766740679740906,
0.45074373483657837,
-0.16308718919754028,
0.4344818890094757,
0.7555980086326599,
0.23048880696296692,
0.5003382563591003,
0.1447790265083313,
-0.05505175143480301,
-0.1243799477815628,
-0.01908981055021286,
-0.39433786273002625,
0.24852050840854645,
0.19712597131729126,
-0.41610628366470337,
-0.3614502251148224,
-0.16369333863258362,
0.0674160048365593,
0.11873460561037064,
-0.42912033200263977,
0.7015483975410461,
0.5501609444618225,
-0.5639565587043762,
0.09406449645757675,
0.30137017369270325,
0.2972080409526825,
-0.4402035176753998,
0.12874455749988556,
-0.6056583523750305,
0.10932452976703644,
-0.14120060205459595,
-0.8723032474517822,
0.4549572765827179,
0.3569103479385376,
-0.45231038331985474,
-0.25003841519355774,
0.4340934157371521,
-0.2721444070339203,
-0.44705650210380554,
0.19526782631874084,
0.6086384654045105,
0.2792939245700836,
0.042701225727796555,
-0.484906405210495,
0.1781274676322937,
-0.19686907529830933,
-0.48518213629722595,
0.3300612270832062,
0.3765626847743988,
-0.21972376108169556,
0.5549463629722595,
0.4869363605976105,
-0.11284606158733368,
-0.30486661195755005,
0.18761920928955078,
0.5915889143943787,
-0.9383818507194519,
-0.49032655358314514,
-1.0930964946746826,
0.4113795757293701,
0.1419382244348526,
-0.40122896432876587,
0.856131374835968,
0.5504922866821289,
0.7461441159248352,
-0.24054236710071564,
0.6318703889846802,
0.2606317102909088,
0.4629780352115631,
-0.891008734703064,
0.6829769611358643,
-0.4581505060195923,
0.45699170231819153,
-0.33268216252326965,
-1.064194679260254,
-0.26100292801856995,
0.3720560073852539,
-0.400316059589386,
0.19533394277095795,
1.0530692338943481,
0.24006332457065582,
-0.046635471284389496,
0.15783977508544922,
0.3052375614643097,
0.3785609304904938,
0.24509607255458832,
0.5362419486045837,
1.281031847000122,
-0.30042245984077454,
0.4170253276824951,
-0.049942560493946075,
-0.011621488258242607,
-0.2561141550540924,
-1.1611199378967285,
-1.1784166097640991,
-0.3487926423549652,
-0.21847571432590485,
-0.3039257228374481,
0.03156587481498718,
0.539249062538147,
0.18282175064086914,
-0.551597535610199,
-0.2161208540201187,
0.1852084845304489,
0.4117387533187866,
-0.08523177355527878,
-0.19780392944812775,
0.28211116790771484,
0.1333562582731247,
-0.8912217617034912,
0.4642677903175354,
0.43699634075164795,
0.36874160170555115,
-0.297126829624176,
-0.026539387181401253,
0.09946876019239426,
0.28924867510795593,
0.7070997357368469,
-0.11232765763998032,
-0.8369711637496948,
-0.228330597281456,
-0.22848939895629883,
-0.2691290080547333,
-0.3298749625682831,
0.9327725768089294,
-0.4391452968120575,
0.05257817357778549,
0.6922764778137207,
0.41938716173171997,
0.6183788776397705,
0.19271354377269745,
0.6181834936141968,
-0.5403230786323547,
-0.10763522237539291,
0.34902703762054443,
0.5728315114974976,
0.21539781987667084,
-0.2885262668132782,
0.5644506812095642,
0.2226262241601944,
-0.6608529686927795,
-0.9634897708892822,
0.26490554213523865,
-1.0178598165512085,
-0.38291189074516296,
1.0275261402130127,
-0.3421051502227783,
-0.22119438648223877,
-0.09506864100694656,
-0.29913416504859924,
-0.08571247011423111,
0.04843103140592575,
0.5729728937149048,
1.031613826751709,
-0.20723111927509308,
-0.30226877331733704,
-0.8344956636428833,
0.31513187289237976,
0.3024592995643616,
-0.7438629269599915,
-0.1351054161787033,
0.5925522446632385,
0.4077285826206207,
-0.07592102140188217,
0.8347153067588806,
-0.18305236101150513,
0.21625925600528717,
-0.06935396790504456,
-0.3206028342247009,
-0.2000121921300888,
-0.4100610613822937,
-0.3737788796424866,
0.06518811732530594,
-0.03969164565205574,
0.4621184468269348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01031v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01031v2
|
Peacock: A Family of Arabic Multimodal Large Language Models and Benchmarks
| 2024-03-01T23:38:02 | 2024-05-24T20:24:36 |
Fakhraddin Alwajih, El Moatez Billah Nagoudi, Gagan Bhatia, Abdelrahman Mohamed, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have proven effective in a wide
range of tasks requiring complex reasoning and linguistic comprehension.
However, due to a lack of high-quality multimodal resources in languages other
than English, success of MLLMs remains relatively limited to English-based
settings. This poses significant challenges in developing comparable models for
other languages, including even those with large speaker populations such as
Arabic. To alleviate this challenge, we introduce a comprehensive family of
Arabic MLLMs, dubbed \textit{Peacock}, with strong vision and language
capabilities. Through comprehensive qualitative and quantitative analysis, we
demonstrate the solid performance of our models on various visual reasoning
tasks and further show their emerging dialectal potential. Additionally, we
introduce ~\textit{Henna}, a new benchmark specifically designed for assessing
MLLMs on aspects related to Arabic culture, setting the first stone for
culturally-aware Arabic MLLMs.The GitHub repository for the \textit{Peacock}
project is available at \url{https://github.com/UBC-NLP/peacock}.
|
[
-0.5048768520355225,
-0.5574764609336853,
0.06189001351594925,
0.5283499956130981,
-0.18078432977199554,
0.21542520821094513,
-0.21133022010326385,
-0.6934688687324524,
-0.14351710677146912,
0.2816278636455536,
-0.24173274636268616,
-0.48615509271621704,
-0.27585849165916443,
0.25350865721702576,
-0.3292883038520813,
0.5669335722923279,
0.018604282289743423,
0.15698769688606262,
0.37667837738990784,
-0.6019235849380493,
-0.23415276408195496,
-0.35236361622810364,
-0.46029898524284363,
-0.0037570116110146046,
0.9711121320724487,
0.2688864469528198,
0.9906779527664185,
0.6056442260742188,
0.3295700252056122,
0.3050989806652069,
0.0621703565120697,
0.5306468605995178,
-0.2351887822151184,
0.3905538320541382,
-0.36094748973846436,
0.04367215558886528,
-0.16819249093532562,
-0.15335020422935486,
0.8506319522857666,
0.9069427251815796,
0.008286980912089348,
0.4161808490753174,
-0.00833121407777071,
0.7290710806846619,
-0.9780495166778564,
0.2410762757062912,
-0.6859816312789917,
0.18097439408302307,
-0.2083592712879181,
-0.09984665364027023,
-0.3875770568847656,
-0.12174122780561447,
0.05922822654247284,
-0.37881043553352356,
-0.32821574807167053,
0.41429227590560913,
0.7208194136619568,
-0.06403620541095734,
-0.9788300395011902,
0.15493708848953247,
-0.4613220989704132,
1.105708122253418,
-0.5259454250335693,
0.7023336291313171,
0.2515805959701538,
0.7098471522331238,
0.024017442017793655,
-0.6821494698524475,
-0.5411786437034607,
-0.278655081987381,
0.27645620703697205,
-0.05068277567625046,
-0.1258084625005722,
-0.3710307776927948,
0.11316873133182526,
0.14980527758598328,
-0.5255406498908997,
-0.29633888602256775,
-0.0545213520526886,
-0.24009621143341064,
0.42865046858787537,
0.18084026873111725,
0.4207180440425873,
-0.08252841234207153,
-0.21473628282546997,
0.14259935915470123,
-0.8226638436317444,
0.31206607818603516,
0.2277669608592987,
0.48391735553741455,
-0.15286000072956085,
0.6443307399749756,
-0.31526657938957214,
0.7195963859558105,
-0.2950015366077423,
-0.0671418085694313,
0.08146896213293076,
-0.27290281653404236,
-0.21197521686553955,
-0.1852382868528366,
0.44585761427879333,
0.34554043412208557,
0.4282509982585907,
-0.009678979404270649,
-0.13019882142543793,
-0.03115404024720192,
-0.09722486138343811,
-0.9499844908714294,
-0.10773254185914993,
0.15584121644496918,
-0.8787574768066406,
-0.16772279143333435,
-0.2597830593585968,
-0.6816639304161072,
-0.7870723605155945,
-0.3366687297821045,
0.11385390162467957,
-0.42782336473464966,
-0.772902250289917,
-0.12709614634513855,
-0.05201275274157524,
0.5888304114341736,
0.4607406258583069,
-0.7419691681861877,
-0.07225275039672852,
0.5536332726478577,
0.6547628045082092,
-0.13725298643112183,
-0.6237085461616516,
-0.7735288143157959,
0.18851079046726227,
-0.7050439715385437,
0.5992161631584167,
-0.9616662859916687,
-0.2230953574180603,
0.49996596574783325,
-0.07066202163696289,
0.07848822325468063,
-0.4839896261692047,
0.636579692363739,
-0.7030853033065796,
-0.3857990503311157,
-0.582238495349884,
-0.1485801637172699,
-0.5112305879592896,
0.5551605820655823,
-0.7535637617111206,
0.6746439933776855,
0.08085127919912338,
-0.8620502948760986,
0.39626607298851013,
-0.31683579087257385,
-0.4847371578216553,
0.10102013498544693,
-0.2786634862422943,
-0.16903547942638397,
-0.13882140815258026,
0.21319055557250977,
0.3600578010082245,
-0.4205550253391266,
0.037805765867233276,
-0.6427311301231384,
-0.40416738390922546,
0.506586492061615,
-0.5474156737327576,
0.9986218810081482,
0.4731542766094208,
-0.35872504115104675,
0.5836589336395264,
-0.9105424284934998,
0.24036960303783417,
-0.14927196502685547,
-0.46904873847961426,
-0.09221073240041733,
0.014088100753724575,
0.8164309859275818,
0.34762123227119446,
0.22261254489421844,
-0.35502320528030396,
0.029778411611914635,
-0.0629335567355156,
0.37530893087387085,
0.6715782284736633,
-0.344858318567276,
0.05737771466374397,
-0.32408377528190613,
0.527603268623352,
0.209380641579628,
0.26594072580337524,
-0.27077382802963257,
-0.4596029222011566,
-0.9773809909820557,
-0.5094358325004578,
0.16076955199241638,
0.36217647790908813,
-0.9983962178230286,
-0.23984134197235107,
0.001995445229113102,
-0.44782793521881104,
-0.4589889347553253,
0.14810870587825775,
0.3940041661262512,
0.202786386013031,
0.3278368413448334,
0.20195214450359344,
-0.5509069561958313,
-1.1146321296691895,
-0.46142300963401794,
0.05751101300120354,
0.3777823746204376,
0.30439600348472595,
0.5435881018638611,
-0.38310760259628296,
0.7050386071205139,
0.19019049406051636,
-0.044600117951631546,
-0.35552677512168884,
0.27554336190223694,
0.1399155855178833,
0.4390103220939636,
0.6393408179283142,
-1.0990958213806152,
-0.7776920199394226,
0.484806090593338,
-0.8106065988540649,
0.1275426149368286,
0.07721692323684692,
-0.13958317041397095,
0.4738682806491852,
0.18380843102931976,
-0.4547363221645355,
0.443454384803772,
0.6862809658050537,
-0.5295460820198059,
1.052353858947754,
0.10880494117736816,
0.45350754261016846,
-0.9246177673339844,
0.22040729224681854,
0.02472282573580742,
-0.3623467981815338,
-0.5151379108428955,
0.2918564975261688,
0.21438300609588623,
-0.1914244294166565,
-0.6070393323898315,
0.7414156198501587,
-0.7368170619010925,
-0.24942167103290558,
-0.15535646677017212,
-0.30352920293807983,
-0.0765499398112297,
0.567059338092804,
0.12269658595323563,
0.9941608309745789,
0.8645278215408325,
-0.3559863567352295,
0.4866972267627716,
0.0038677649572491646,
-0.6530855298042297,
0.6500664353370667,
-0.6722956299781799,
-0.12356996536254883,
0.1323491781949997,
-0.1316363364458084,
-0.8867347836494446,
-0.09132614731788635,
0.0455559566617012,
-0.15011796355247498,
0.27694547176361084,
-0.1130320131778717,
-0.5024212002754211,
-0.19806179404258728,
-0.4868484139442444,
0.7052675485610962,
0.4326517581939697,
-0.5838468670845032,
0.9063493013381958,
0.1835513561964035,
-0.1979823112487793,
-0.948527455329895,
-0.4762563705444336,
0.4538663923740387,
-0.18477952480316162,
-0.6796040534973145,
-0.08279445767402649,
0.10856259614229202,
-0.46893802285194397,
-0.13633953034877777,
0.20275740325450897,
-0.20135946571826935,
-0.15169021487236023,
0.1340334266424179,
0.2569126784801483,
-0.5719550251960754,
0.15068770945072174,
-0.12153175473213196,
0.05878361314535141,
-0.15625125169754028,
-0.37001100182533264,
0.3998209536075592,
-0.6989619135856628,
-0.6252110600471497,
-0.3075220584869385,
0.7130423784255981,
0.9339906573295593,
-0.8881216645240784,
0.8657118082046509,
0.9355821013450623,
-0.2785394489765167,
-0.2407948225736618,
-0.767559826374054,
0.15677084028720856,
-0.4503999352455139,
0.5834057927131653,
-0.7046396732330322,
-0.6204414963722229,
0.5622170567512512,
-0.10206625610589981,
-0.023154160007834435,
0.229745015501976,
0.599126935005188,
-0.13503387570381165,
1.4663045406341553,
0.6439521908760071,
0.013533244840800762,
0.2826269865036011,
-0.1603347361087799,
0.010269022546708584,
-0.9995197057723999,
0.029954206198453903,
-0.4155118763446808,
-0.1935395747423172,
-0.6252604722976685,
-0.5685431361198425,
0.34674906730651855,
0.08633419126272202,
-0.6941344738006592,
-0.13421683013439178,
-0.13322480022907257,
0.38909056782722473,
0.6734077334403992,
-0.05314657837152481,
0.4304218888282776,
-0.02673463150858879,
-0.29604247212409973,
-0.00518708536401391,
-0.6409198045730591,
-0.7413231134414673,
1.1117701530456543,
0.15178655087947845,
0.6762934923171997,
0.5374212861061096,
0.013505549170076847,
0.34683674573898315,
0.3903608024120331,
-0.46182718873023987,
0.6577048301696777,
-0.03622196614742279,
-0.5259395241737366,
-0.30032598972320557,
-0.19140230119228363,
-0.9460626244544983,
0.6619322299957275,
-0.2778685390949249,
-0.613398015499115,
0.20169639587402344,
0.047569114714860916,
-0.016440700739622116,
0.37375473976135254,
-0.33477702736854553,
1.0805058479309082,
-0.2828039526939392,
-0.9633076786994934,
-0.3904598355293274,
-0.526513397693634,
0.467260479927063,
-0.02757151983678341,
0.2987675368785858,
-0.2678622305393219,
-0.26151978969573975,
0.3718782663345337,
-0.43400654196739197,
0.8051415085792542,
-0.003889947896823287,
-0.04416868835687637,
0.32113006711006165,
0.22035925090312958,
0.44165533781051636,
-0.22907325625419617,
-0.34313109517097473,
0.15073487162590027,
0.2291773110628128,
-0.8082606196403503,
-0.4049130082130432,
0.7699651122093201,
-0.7894669771194458,
-0.34189262986183167,
-0.49281391501426697,
-0.7009300589561462,
-0.5818514227867126,
0.2890545129776001,
-0.2638637125492096,
0.7032973766326904,
-0.021546900272369385,
0.45318230986595154,
0.2953720688819885,
-0.3957112729549408,
0.5324186086654663,
0.6056398153305054,
-0.7328619956970215,
-0.3417474925518036,
0.9550994038581848,
0.04760394245386124,
-0.0344291627407074,
0.2198438197374344,
0.22141553461551666,
-0.6143759489059448,
-0.7664355635643005,
-0.8665568828582764,
0.017961902543902397,
-0.9694883227348328,
0.051866315305233,
-0.38382717967033386,
-0.042668212205171585,
-0.25062835216522217,
-0.005903991870582104,
-0.09976236522197723,
-0.21665139496326447,
0.12714985013008118,
0.41193774342536926,
0.1348569542169571,
0.7166112065315247,
0.09691745042800903,
-0.3192427456378937,
-0.8262556195259094,
0.3015282452106476,
0.6595276594161987,
0.26737716794013977,
0.3124655783176422,
-0.33832117915153503,
-0.2025109976530075,
0.22209079563617706,
-0.1776708960533142,
-0.9355068802833557,
0.2813059687614441,
0.203897163271904,
0.6703916192054749,
0.6113284230232239,
0.047058675438165665,
0.6954634189605713,
-0.5710218548774719,
0.7123056054115295,
0.30883145332336426,
-0.9334280490875244,
0.23575067520141602,
-0.8624684810638428,
0.393456369638443,
0.30391204357147217,
0.28688162565231323,
-0.6816837787628174,
-0.15789318084716797,
0.16647730767726898,
-0.5769139528274536,
0.09553013741970062,
0.23358625173568726,
-0.0008171296794898808,
0.0018228782573714852,
-0.17907562851905823,
0.1272144466638565,
0.48390892148017883,
-0.7589357495307922,
-0.14590886235237122,
-0.4975423216819763,
-0.19058506190776825,
0.04215088486671448,
-0.3884860873222351,
0.07155688852071762,
-0.5551319718360901,
0.711984395980835,
-0.2752451002597809,
-0.29543668031692505,
0.01314748264849186,
-0.281283974647522,
-0.003465739544481039,
0.3775409758090973,
0.5970979332923889,
0.976169228553772,
0.1153574287891388,
0.26872143149375916,
0.03758503124117851,
-0.2517111003398895,
0.03472006693482399,
0.04130684211850166,
-0.07047780603170395,
-0.2035110592842102,
0.6226898431777954,
0.42033517360687256,
0.29414820671081543,
-1.0319840908050537,
0.45590800046920776,
0.1781584471464157,
0.24714499711990356,
-0.23030170798301697,
-0.3249454200267792,
0.2998603880405426,
0.5971194505691528,
0.4338078200817108,
0.06410600244998932,
0.33922824263572693,
-0.8998001217842102,
0.040452562272548676,
0.7723193168640137,
-0.26769542694091797,
-0.028200170025229454,
0.5422987937927246,
0.5442242622375488,
-0.21489731967449188,
0.45592716336250305,
-0.3333907425403595,
-0.710631787776947,
0.4567846357822418,
0.5024542212486267,
0.7268335223197937,
-0.14596499502658844,
0.22220420837402344,
0.29563814401626587,
0.2354145050048828,
0.3439323306083679,
0.6065878868103027,
-0.2799278199672699,
-0.773222804069519,
-0.4293391704559326,
-0.81825852394104,
-0.5002679228782654,
-0.1589937061071396,
-0.3860071301460266,
0.12925375998020172,
-0.2822086811065674,
-0.03936871141195297,
-0.0227790717035532,
-0.022066812962293625,
-0.6256104707717896,
-0.0522703118622303,
0.31437060236930847,
1.0944252014160156,
-0.42892059683799744,
0.9240514636039734,
0.858011782169342,
-0.5946823954582214,
-0.7749735713005066,
-0.2772681713104248,
0.0021429327316582203,
-0.8173293471336365,
1.073401689529419,
0.26880255341529846,
-0.7628592848777771,
-0.10073433071374893,
-0.2644234597682953,
-0.6927527189254761,
0.6542752981185913,
0.20287355780601501,
-0.5369933247566223,
0.33631235361099243,
0.2820839285850525,
0.39880111813545227,
-0.46123141050338745,
0.23894686996936798,
0.31897956132888794,
0.8231873512268066,
0.17374549806118011,
-0.9807659983634949,
-0.08824831992387772,
-0.6929934024810791,
0.14244063198566437,
-0.05548761039972305,
-0.6941176056861877,
1.239160418510437,
-0.39313259720802307,
-0.09653154760599136,
0.4541321098804474,
0.7293331623077393,
0.25892776250839233,
0.22190771996974945,
0.4508133828639984,
0.10438892990350723,
0.722442090511322,
0.04022713750600815,
0.9275487661361694,
-0.3841562271118164,
0.1688622236251831,
1.0500633716583252,
-0.6292645931243896,
1.3027279376983643,
0.47346991300582886,
-0.34510040283203125,
0.5965202450752258,
0.6812318563461304,
0.12662851810455322,
0.21318687498569489,
0.3044814467430115,
-0.41373151540756226,
-0.6119785308837891,
-0.49140021204948425,
-0.5905314683914185,
0.5605314373970032,
0.011777007021009922,
-0.14919330179691315,
-0.12218385189771652,
0.18798886239528656,
-0.2386305034160614,
0.29101812839508057,
-0.6314786672592163,
0.3392443060874939,
-0.18302419781684875,
-0.46764519810676575,
0.8567631244659424,
-0.16139358282089233,
0.6530843377113342,
-0.6262860894203186,
-0.3161320984363556,
-0.009640243835747242,
0.27156415581703186,
-0.11248204857110977,
-0.6880318522453308,
0.06656594574451447,
-0.08778883516788483,
-0.0632202997803688,
-0.07769643515348434,
0.6620308756828308,
-0.595383882522583,
-0.9562981128692627,
0.20959274470806122,
0.616435706615448,
0.094705730676651,
-0.2724470794200897,
-0.6682722568511963,
0.3792789578437805,
-0.19874462485313416,
-0.21533076465129852,
0.042122747749090195,
0.45766574144363403,
-0.16553592681884766,
0.9970516562461853,
0.6885508298873901,
0.12327683717012405,
0.2621884047985077,
0.2820277810096741,
0.6165041923522949,
-0.7823188900947571,
-0.42413973808288574,
-0.79875248670578,
0.3940792679786682,
-0.3261444866657257,
-0.3084045648574829,
1.0653353929519653,
0.795301616191864,
0.2987046539783478,
-0.2775859534740448,
0.7737454771995544,
0.36252012848854065,
0.46391770243644714,
-0.3482796847820282,
1.0731370449066162,
-0.9292581081390381,
-0.05092905834317207,
-0.20226682722568512,
-0.8513375520706177,
-0.08623441308736801,
0.7507240772247314,
-0.06868704408407211,
0.2777441740036011,
0.7437850832939148,
0.6092886328697205,
0.0026357751339673996,
0.21867600083351135,
0.6456924080848694,
0.41124650835990906,
0.24088138341903687,
0.5725796818733215,
1.4275392293930054,
0.019948061555624008,
0.5657592415809631,
-0.08925627917051315,
-0.1417296826839447,
-0.33672329783439636,
-1.0584746599197388,
-1.2268292903900146,
-0.6791654825210571,
-0.22376735508441925,
-0.08290331065654755,
0.10486867278814316,
1.0161157846450806,
1.0998117923736572,
-0.9333847761154175,
-0.35692569613456726,
0.14434228837490082,
0.1875985711812973,
-0.39939969778060913,
-0.17042873799800873,
0.33431947231292725,
-0.28285783529281616,
-0.6658071279525757,
0.16398607194423676,
0.5357732176780701,
0.1524505913257599,
-0.7241529822349548,
-0.1542014181613922,
-0.29926592111587524,
0.18149755895137787,
0.9759429097175598,
0.22760099172592163,
-1.073534369468689,
-0.2493015080690384,
-0.15983982384204865,
-0.18834225833415985,
-0.2704634964466095,
0.6345720887184143,
-0.739565372467041,
0.3236235976219177,
0.1987345963716507,
0.6791574358940125,
0.2943150997161865,
-0.3571353554725647,
0.46078914403915405,
-0.1698693484067917,
0.2965593636035919,
0.31502777338027954,
0.711320698261261,
0.5127943158149719,
0.23897041380405426,
0.38872674107551575,
-0.03881506621837616,
-0.2220723181962967,
-0.8272231817245483,
0.5607909560203552,
-0.9678537845611572,
-0.4843927025794983,
1.1343345642089844,
-0.13198933005332947,
-0.21289323270320892,
-0.4486634433269501,
-0.6149561405181885,
-0.02515108697116375,
-0.1453675627708435,
0.6185309886932373,
0.7423279285430908,
0.09492474794387817,
-0.3496939539909363,
-0.425314724445343,
0.43326571583747864,
0.395634263753891,
-0.8532363176345825,
0.18119050562381744,
0.60135817527771,
0.12307044118642807,
-0.0006549031240865588,
0.26216933131217957,
0.21514232456684113,
0.6111841797828674,
0.14429502189159393,
-0.08252037316560745,
-0.3168646991252899,
-0.4451051950454712,
0.07676371932029724,
0.4822942912578583,
0.27898111939430237,
-0.17500801384449005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01002v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01002v1
|
Attribute Structuring Improves LLM-Based Evaluation of Clinical Text Summaries
| 2024-03-01T21:59:03 | 2024-03-01T21:59:03 |
Zelalem Gero, Chandan Singh, Yiqing Xie, Sheng Zhang, Tristan Naumann, Jianfeng Gao, Hoifung Poon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Summarizing clinical text is crucial in health decision-support and clinical
research. Large language models (LLMs) have shown the potential to generate
accurate clinical text summaries, but still struggle with issues regarding
grounding and evaluation, especially in safety-critical domains such as health.
Holistically evaluating text summaries is challenging because they may contain
unsubstantiated information. Here, we explore a general mitigation framework
using Attribute Structuring (AS), which structures the summary evaluation
process. It decomposes the evaluation process into a grounded procedure that
uses an LLM for relatively simple structuring and scoring tasks, rather than
the full task of holistic summary evaluation. Experiments show that AS
consistently improves the correspondence between human annotations and
automated metrics in clinical text summarization. Additionally, AS yields
interpretations in the form of a short text span corresponding to each output,
which enables efficient human auditing, paving the way towards trustworthy
evaluation of clinical information in resource-constrained scenarios. We
release our code, prompts, and an open-source benchmark at
https://github.com/microsoft/attribute-structuring.
|
[
0.2756056785583496,
-0.463622123003006,
0.7115620374679565,
0.37747058272361755,
-0.38785284757614136,
-0.02955101802945137,
-0.180068239569664,
-0.5135257244110107,
0.13466978073120117,
0.3573674261569977,
-0.3149717450141907,
-0.6452808976173401,
-0.5244951844215393,
0.11507882177829742,
-0.035226065665483475,
1.3709447383880615,
-0.08223707973957062,
0.0667751356959343,
-0.8812625408172607,
-0.4269779622554779,
-0.28733423352241516,
-0.4929211437702179,
-0.6470819115638733,
-0.6225570440292358,
0.5796105861663818,
0.3943089544773102,
0.787387490272522,
0.8819065093994141,
0.8959004878997803,
0.2880692481994629,
-0.24551697075366974,
0.1520698368549347,
-0.31218451261520386,
0.3438304364681244,
0.11187434941530228,
-0.28195720911026,
-0.969423770904541,
-0.15554608404636383,
0.5621200203895569,
0.9035518765449524,
-0.07477065175771713,
0.1765855997800827,
0.21601040661334991,
0.9278355836868286,
-0.6594966053962708,
0.11531352996826172,
-0.2990732192993164,
0.021945279091596603,
0.15546442568302155,
-0.5036563873291016,
-0.3262598514556885,
-0.19148264825344086,
0.3409057855606079,
-0.23623186349868774,
0.22683386504650116,
-0.05148846283555031,
0.8151689171791077,
0.3028038442134857,
-0.4105546176433563,
-0.28867167234420776,
-0.1828073114156723,
0.6029273867607117,
-0.5649769902229309,
0.31722167134284973,
0.602341890335083,
0.08737614005804062,
0.11474893242120743,
-0.5446476936340332,
-0.08349286019802094,
-0.44694820046424866,
-0.39575767517089844,
0.26168808341026306,
-0.07997766137123108,
0.3020286560058594,
-0.028027119114995003,
0.5441409945487976,
-0.4207237958908081,
0.2603749632835388,
-0.33600112795829773,
-0.4736911654472351,
0.8937665224075317,
0.33302468061447144,
0.366436630487442,
-0.26747360825538635,
-0.25229936838150024,
-0.013048812747001648,
-0.8261734843254089,
-0.20304302871227264,
0.02361552231013775,
0.067000612616539,
-0.3707827627658844,
0.581072986125946,
-0.1388600468635559,
0.12245331704616547,
-0.10073434561491013,
-0.4633806645870209,
0.41132667660713196,
-0.3956058621406555,
-0.3895452320575714,
0.15600872039794922,
0.7276829481124878,
0.9048890471458435,
-0.12889230251312256,
-0.42283010482788086,
-0.021804625168442726,
0.06505156308412552,
0.3021240532398224,
-0.9720589518547058,
-0.3253730535507202,
0.5892462134361267,
-0.7926576733589172,
-0.6741307973861694,
-0.21791541576385498,
-0.34717878699302673,
-0.5428571701049805,
-0.2852090001106262,
0.1722998321056366,
-0.6256351470947266,
0.16397538781166077,
-0.08061030507087708,
-0.1120028868317604,
-0.13279519975185394,
0.7687011957168579,
-0.5210621953010559,
0.3579052984714508,
0.5284572839736938,
0.8552417755126953,
-0.3290523886680603,
-0.14631202816963196,
-0.7370902895927429,
0.25447919964790344,
0.024084899574518204,
0.8298077583312988,
-0.3058854341506958,
-0.5088471174240112,
-0.1422465294599533,
-0.25440120697021484,
0.27288082242012024,
-0.5455499887466431,
0.5305626392364502,
-0.08018422871828079,
0.10128560662269592,
-0.04386769235134125,
-0.3060404658317566,
0.20524516701698303,
0.17884957790374756,
-0.6730209589004517,
0.9201712012290955,
0.07114863395690918,
-0.6169013977050781,
0.471688449382782,
-0.5398417115211487,
-0.7563007473945618,
0.020752768963575363,
-0.27274221181869507,
-1.0221960544586182,
0.44026878476142883,
0.3062329888343811,
0.4691012501716614,
-0.39090001583099365,
0.06703995913267136,
-0.08153954148292542,
-0.07249363511800766,
0.37785133719444275,
-0.10596393793821335,
0.4295402765274048,
0.1480027288198471,
0.12222769111394882,
0.389607697725296,
-0.8612785339355469,
0.06167379394173622,
-0.17447559535503387,
-0.24322395026683807,
-0.43266868591308594,
0.13556142151355743,
0.0836726501584053,
-0.021220052614808083,
0.024574005976319313,
-0.2126931995153427,
-0.07001141458749771,
-0.3945671319961548,
0.1748223602771759,
0.46718597412109375,
0.23826362192630768,
0.6129739880561829,
-0.5691794753074646,
0.45528966188430786,
0.07944820076227188,
-0.04278389737010002,
-0.30932894349098206,
-0.13052807748317719,
-0.5362980365753174,
-0.5987811088562012,
0.051813866943120956,
0.3501946032047272,
-0.5767349600791931,
0.48930132389068604,
-0.384112149477005,
-0.5046417713165283,
-0.5797115564346313,
-0.04599044844508171,
0.8778762817382812,
0.6438030004501343,
0.45522749423980713,
-0.20859970152378082,
-0.28503429889678955,
-1.138344407081604,
-0.3993411958217621,
-0.4423183798789978,
-0.4877414405345917,
0.1232943907380104,
0.6024465560913086,
-0.22611896693706512,
0.7474135756492615,
-0.6788924932479858,
-0.601857602596283,
-0.6620151996612549,
0.42411500215530396,
-0.12606042623519897,
0.4613151550292969,
0.4623536765575409,
-0.5435118079185486,
-0.19028359651565552,
0.003535100957378745,
-0.5720875263214111,
-0.6199737787246704,
-0.25982850790023804,
-0.06592873483896255,
0.008920815773308277,
0.23819324374198914,
-0.4569932222366333,
0.8716268539428711,
0.012703079730272293,
-0.38095417618751526,
0.7405791878700256,
-0.3977064788341522,
0.33087730407714844,
-0.716357409954071,
0.2413095086812973,
-0.21039317548274994,
-0.3210234045982361,
-0.5552238821983337,
0.17953963577747345,
0.2318631410598755,
0.08264151960611343,
-0.2694721817970276,
0.3285229206085205,
-0.47379958629608154,
0.2112189084291458,
-0.16523605585098267,
0.08194418996572495,
0.26723429560661316,
0.27332136034965515,
0.08693938702344894,
0.6667810082435608,
0.11873286962509155,
-0.6601826548576355,
-0.07771605998277664,
0.38607874512672424,
-0.20339623093605042,
0.8201286792755127,
-0.8477843999862671,
-0.10513987392187119,
-0.4195311963558197,
0.14841072261333466,
-0.6779158115386963,
-0.25906631350517273,
-0.23373031616210938,
-0.4215412139892578,
0.23150821030139923,
0.14181235432624817,
-0.4037356376647949,
0.06270018965005875,
-0.9313806891441345,
0.36621251702308655,
0.07776933908462524,
-0.006316371727734804,
0.5818809866905212,
0.5087634325027466,
-0.2632506489753723,
-0.2334095984697342,
-0.8797244429588318,
0.16520822048187256,
-0.22104333341121674,
-0.6161574721336365,
0.6377471685409546,
-0.037810202687978745,
-0.36211371421813965,
0.027708305045962334,
-0.35954397916793823,
-0.12554708123207092,
0.43466293811798096,
0.26737651228904724,
0.4003135561943054,
-0.08533518761396408,
0.4007832407951355,
0.07694792747497559,
-0.18745069205760956,
0.10184365510940552,
0.3241799473762512,
0.15393131971359253,
-0.08923421055078506,
-0.380347341299057,
-0.5583745241165161,
0.5402894020080566,
0.462230384349823,
-0.23357313871383667,
0.8448012471199036,
0.17054866254329681,
-0.46052247285842896,
-0.22622275352478027,
-0.4620925784111023,
-0.09432313591241837,
-0.33237507939338684,
0.7141963243484497,
-0.10712791979312897,
-0.7382665276527405,
0.6293284893035889,
0.24264506995677948,
-0.02929941564798355,
0.532355785369873,
0.680737316608429,
-0.266895055770874,
0.6423451900482178,
0.4931719899177551,
0.0665845274925232,
0.14637310802936554,
0.11647000163793564,
0.15848538279533386,
-0.8849501609802246,
-0.3267402946949005,
-0.4832516610622406,
-0.21643947064876556,
-0.2109198123216629,
-0.4026131331920624,
0.9472811818122864,
0.029369642958045006,
0.10656817257404327,
-0.1123868077993393,
-0.4010748863220215,
0.5507783889770508,
0.06993681192398071,
0.47811079025268555,
0.5923956036567688,
0.03933735191822052,
-0.07803661376237869,
-0.14378298819065094,
-0.3710920214653015,
-0.6227394938468933,
1.036816954612732,
0.5977567434310913,
0.645023763179779,
0.21169185638427734,
0.5678635239601135,
0.3441038429737091,
0.7948080897331238,
-0.7120470404624939,
0.40494346618652344,
0.04523516446352005,
0.008598637767136097,
-0.24069805443286896,
-0.4881267845630646,
-0.5695419907569885,
0.45908746123313904,
-0.34307166934013367,
-0.8544617295265198,
-0.19146420061588287,
0.18692390620708466,
-0.4687619209289551,
-0.11292363703250885,
-0.5813412666320801,
0.5748236775398254,
-0.26367661356925964,
-0.4381854832172394,
-0.21633872389793396,
-0.6766257882118225,
0.18935240805149078,
0.02428544871509075,
0.010189912281930447,
-0.06507602334022522,
-0.14183224737644196,
0.620622992515564,
-0.8924076557159424,
0.6193228363990784,
0.22726225852966309,
-0.0667121633887291,
-0.013686423189938068,
0.041011009365320206,
0.2899135947227478,
0.18603014945983887,
-0.07874026894569397,
0.01724812760949135,
0.11396908760070801,
-0.1138482391834259,
-0.8406730890274048,
0.31423869729042053,
-0.48451098799705505,
-0.4621528685092926,
-0.543329119682312,
-0.5568168759346008,
-0.35029253363609314,
0.08973649889230728,
0.16238299012184143,
0.6040992736816406,
-0.31011533737182617,
0.44035011529922485,
0.4190327227115631,
-0.3737381100654602,
0.17919035255908966,
0.4366901218891144,
0.10668744891881943,
-0.7380580306053162,
0.403787225484848,
-0.11948172748088837,
0.46249085664749146,
0.5262399911880493,
0.28317204117774963,
-0.2639469802379608,
-0.765424907207489,
-0.09979255497455597,
0.3337806463241577,
-0.7469896078109741,
-0.5239080786705017,
-0.5921536684036255,
-0.19384391605854034,
-0.31388869881629944,
-0.2398662567138672,
-0.045568689703941345,
-0.48960867524147034,
-0.11623240262269974,
-0.3612312972545624,
0.2502334713935852,
0.5728853940963745,
0.22776620090007782,
0.44891005754470825,
-0.7353521585464478,
0.25308454036712646,
-0.04865038022398949,
0.41288459300994873,
0.15636152029037476,
-0.2504880726337433,
-0.41604694724082947,
-0.1874135136604309,
-0.42441970109939575,
-0.7806797623634338,
0.22662308812141418,
0.3432807922363281,
0.42105963826179504,
0.4633532464504242,
0.26931098103523254,
1.04096257686615,
-0.6916090846061707,
0.5925345420837402,
0.4416658580303192,
-0.9153140783309937,
0.6221845149993896,
-0.11163488030433655,
0.24553729593753815,
0.9392818808555603,
-0.14251230657100677,
-0.42351093888282776,
-0.6797566413879395,
-0.3499893248081207,
-1.1822117567062378,
0.5474545359611511,
0.6466615200042725,
-0.4819848835468292,
0.16337265074253082,
0.1972641944885254,
0.002003472065553069,
0.35231053829193115,
-0.6855407357215881,
-0.33707302808761597,
0.16609154641628265,
-0.531822681427002,
0.020918913185596466,
-0.6701821088790894,
-0.3571927845478058,
-0.26255640387535095,
0.3722602427005768,
-0.14558273553848267,
0.2350156605243683,
0.5434291362762451,
-0.5952528715133667,
0.05167771503329277,
0.42103004455566406,
0.59577476978302,
0.7432948350906372,
-0.25121721625328064,
0.40041422843933105,
0.20463308691978455,
-0.6886242032051086,
-0.02260822057723999,
-0.16099730134010315,
-0.07657694071531296,
-0.13065385818481445,
1.0520319938659668,
0.6061641573905945,
0.5267829298973083,
-0.606208086013794,
0.6439106464385986,
0.009729201905429363,
-0.172804594039917,
-0.08902905136346817,
-0.10607192665338516,
-0.14691303670406342,
-0.01867515780031681,
0.4092356264591217,
-0.19824813306331635,
0.23449116945266724,
-0.35548722743988037,
0.26097238063812256,
0.30603763461112976,
-0.17323780059814453,
-0.36385849118232727,
0.684217095375061,
0.19500569999217987,
-0.11404625326395035,
0.30193382501602173,
0.16907088458538055,
-0.4032309353351593,
0.549454927444458,
0.5449332594871521,
1.1210979223251343,
-0.09393870085477829,
0.30008089542388916,
-0.047247014939785004,
0.4002835750579834,
0.23572571575641632,
0.1624399572610855,
-0.35910847783088684,
-0.30037668347358704,
-0.31227654218673706,
-0.6104875802993774,
-0.49886420369148254,
-0.014829268679022789,
-0.7165464758872986,
0.22167609632015228,
-0.33335474133491516,
0.09872368723154068,
0.04307584837079048,
-0.12376437336206436,
-0.4376026690006256,
0.3176599144935608,
-0.040179312229156494,
0.8468652367591858,
-0.7902180552482605,
0.4279889166355133,
0.6757891774177551,
-0.5344844460487366,
-0.4678238332271576,
-0.06266475468873978,
0.21223574876785278,
-0.5753143429756165,
0.5101830959320068,
0.2857148349285126,
-0.018646106123924255,
-0.6058701276779175,
-0.3032286763191223,
-0.6264476776123047,
1.2427126169204712,
0.29001712799072266,
-0.04501453787088394,
-0.09128420799970627,
0.33902689814567566,
0.8898823857307434,
-0.4693664014339447,
0.46200117468833923,
0.5072826743125916,
0.2554156184196472,
0.09261451661586761,
-1.0219097137451172,
0.3104579746723175,
-0.41292890906333923,
0.006586287170648575,
-0.023713311180472374,
-0.26861435174942017,
0.4311572015285492,
-0.27468839287757874,
-0.23148372769355774,
0.10918989032506943,
0.626767098903656,
0.2585527002811432,
0.5441340208053589,
0.32382580637931824,
0.5169853568077087,
0.9555582404136658,
-0.10338471829891205,
1.132096290588379,
0.010441661812365055,
0.14619329571723938,
1.2568975687026978,
-0.3525756299495697,
0.5321993231773376,
0.3958754539489746,
-0.2885594666004181,
0.3517303466796875,
0.2137373387813568,
0.29514193534851074,
0.46243199706077576,
0.127676859498024,
-0.21344490349292755,
-0.11804922670125961,
-0.2734077274799347,
-0.26201188564300537,
0.3619029223918915,
0.23165911436080933,
-0.5873150825500488,
-0.34242892265319824,
-0.16352318227291107,
0.2776467800140381,
0.03149037063121796,
-0.3878497779369354,
0.9764065742492676,
0.20370624959468842,
-0.5688716173171997,
0.21956925094127655,
-0.054393380880355835,
0.08662869781255722,
-0.6443156003952026,
-0.024075891822576523,
-0.15772032737731934,
0.21862146258354187,
-0.6041744947433472,
-0.6401147842407227,
0.478287011384964,
0.1866808384656906,
-0.2702343165874481,
-0.42117345333099365,
0.6453151702880859,
-0.5341183543205261,
-0.4768066108226776,
-0.129325270652771,
0.2089064121246338,
-0.010957219637930393,
0.0409003347158432,
-0.22464410960674286,
0.0946008637547493,
-0.19650346040725708,
-0.11703405529260635,
0.41310983896255493,
0.543743371963501,
-0.364629864692688,
0.6518998742103577,
0.5818971395492554,
0.40036532282829285,
-0.7626713514328003,
0.27178025245666504,
1.020983099937439,
-0.6859614253044128,
-0.8795664310455322,
-1.1160988807678223,
0.8661875128746033,
-0.46489813923835754,
-0.29122793674468994,
0.6907835602760315,
0.702401340007782,
0.09363897144794464,
0.11460844427347183,
0.5476529002189636,
0.20774152874946594,
0.3796870708465576,
-0.6069611310958862,
1.255248785018921,
-0.551218569278717,
0.5175674557685852,
-0.4797693192958832,
-0.42068707942962646,
-0.853233814239502,
0.5363427996635437,
-0.17429815232753754,
-0.20832563936710358,
0.9142971634864807,
0.4292987287044525,
0.2513907551765442,
-0.14340940117835999,
0.11114473640918732,
0.2610478401184082,
0.537209153175354,
0.4341999888420105,
0.46420538425445557,
-0.19813422858715057,
0.14731097221374512,
-0.10110735148191452,
-0.519389808177948,
-0.2531032860279083,
-1.2368707656860352,
-1.0538800954818726,
-0.2670056223869324,
-0.5684771537780762,
-0.47454169392585754,
-0.09987972676753998,
0.9203120470046997,
0.3333698511123657,
-0.8178952932357788,
-0.017556577920913696,
0.27817076444625854,
0.3311455547809601,
-0.1969263106584549,
-0.16255134344100952,
0.8411902785301208,
-0.24715447425842285,
-0.09886174649000168,
0.0630268007516861,
0.7491260170936584,
-0.14072301983833313,
0.025868680328130722,
-0.091861791908741,
0.18402284383773804,
-0.23642471432685852,
0.751006543636322,
-0.10997600108385086,
-0.5118807554244995,
-0.43591731786727905,
-0.2504091262817383,
-0.18443036079406738,
0.12571381032466888,
0.7831286191940308,
-0.6813595294952393,
0.35800573229789734,
0.2814435660839081,
0.6135445237159729,
0.12523439526557922,
0.2776165306568146,
0.714543342590332,
-0.9453195929527283,
0.06814704835414886,
0.3517187833786011,
0.32991504669189453,
0.26979637145996094,
-0.5280243158340454,
0.5226128697395325,
0.06464560329914093,
-0.3906398117542267,
-1.106196641921997,
0.049708425998687744,
-0.9468540549278259,
0.049612242728471756,
1.0676003694534302,
-0.009384173899888992,
-0.37829676270484924,
-0.008402555249631405,
-0.16892218589782715,
0.060310278087854385,
-0.23471461236476898,
0.9032192826271057,
0.5783581137657166,
-0.24135532975196838,
0.017179470509290695,
-0.05012128874659538,
0.699074387550354,
0.4255051016807556,
-0.9934470653533936,
0.07980803400278091,
0.6567365527153015,
0.10385030508041382,
0.12322591990232468,
0.7650769948959351,
-0.23773522675037384,
0.5001450777053833,
-0.5660188794136047,
-0.10115084797143936,
-0.3417106866836548,
-0.13403986394405365,
-0.4138783812522888,
0.21070905029773712,
-0.23677708208560944,
-0.05895274132490158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00998v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00998v1
|
Predictions from language models for multiple-choice tasks are not robust under variation of scoring methods
| 2024-03-01T21:48:08 | 2024-03-01T21:48:08 |
Polina Tsvilodub, Hening Wang, Sharon Grosch, Michael Franke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper systematically compares different methods of deriving item-level
predictions of language models for multiple-choice tasks. It compares scoring
methods for answer options based on free generation of responses, various
probability-based scores, a Likert-scale style rating method, and embedding
similarity. In a case study on pragmatic language interpretation, we find that
LLM predictions are not robust under variation of method choice, both within a
single LLM and across different LLMs. As this variability entails pronounced
researcher degrees of freedom in reporting results, knowledge of the
variability is crucial to secure robustness of results and research integrity.
|
[
-0.18574567139148712,
-0.7395896911621094,
0.40988853573799133,
0.08987222611904144,
-0.09433985501527786,
0.09387736767530441,
-0.2584284543991089,
-0.675760805606842,
0.08020403236150742,
0.1986204981803894,
-0.49875763058662415,
-0.33418601751327515,
-0.6356321573257446,
0.12819932401180267,
-0.06132287532091141,
0.9090280532836914,
-0.13046947121620178,
0.33721283078193665,
-0.3875576853752136,
-0.053451623767614365,
-0.31571486592292786,
-0.39712318778038025,
-0.3279358148574829,
-0.24013327062129974,
0.5137688517570496,
0.3863852620124817,
0.8299676179885864,
0.48779943585395813,
0.7819004654884338,
0.19486212730407715,
0.00465026218444109,
0.06289181858301163,
-0.1737622171640396,
0.4469418227672577,
-0.026386333629488945,
-0.850748598575592,
-0.3330298364162445,
0.25399249792099,
0.4308925271034241,
0.26920798420906067,
-0.18782329559326172,
0.10666687041521072,
0.15881149470806122,
0.13385261595249176,
-0.579075276851654,
0.1819019913673401,
-0.7199724912643433,
-0.29275569319725037,
-0.1637391746044159,
0.05411067605018616,
-0.3985901474952698,
-0.28012099862098694,
0.2476276010274887,
-0.20809075236320496,
0.1133652776479721,
0.1437421441078186,
0.7996623516082764,
0.11705034226179123,
-0.17305608093738556,
-0.496082067489624,
-0.6827750205993652,
1.2292183637619019,
-0.853229820728302,
0.04322722554206848,
0.7556509375572205,
0.505471408367157,
0.060747720301151276,
-0.470203161239624,
-0.23972757160663605,
-0.5297543406486511,
0.21108366549015045,
0.16462865471839905,
0.20410233736038208,
0.017104310914874077,
0.08020910620689392,
0.429328978061676,
-0.4842087924480438,
0.22654414176940918,
-0.1487719714641571,
-0.14172375202178955,
0.7509462833404541,
0.1920216828584671,
-0.024351941421628,
-0.40963083505630493,
-0.4730740785598755,
-0.12989285588264465,
-0.5529728531837463,
0.3971889615058899,
0.5397283434867859,
0.6137878894805908,
-0.09547893702983856,
0.7143819332122803,
-0.1489827185869217,
0.8202384114265442,
-0.11495581269264221,
-0.6443196535110474,
0.32955262064933777,
-0.2886732220649719,
-0.3172346353530884,
-0.6076240539550781,
0.787260890007019,
0.4503352642059326,
0.06242698058485985,
0.03231225535273552,
-0.22269019484519958,
0.031506720930337906,
-0.03788675740361214,
-0.23757143318653107,
-0.040729328989982605,
0.19708116352558136,
-0.5160498023033142,
-0.3789321482181549,
-0.01102925930172205,
-0.9249611496925354,
-0.3441777229309082,
0.042921580374240875,
0.2335028052330017,
-0.36302146315574646,
-0.24353903532028198,
0.08239740878343582,
0.009972505271434784,
0.23688535392284393,
0.46042755246162415,
-0.6601887345314026,
0.09443968534469604,
0.41868481040000916,
0.5751872062683105,
-0.49393078684806824,
-0.575125515460968,
-0.26319852471351624,
-0.3852514624595642,
-0.37389272451400757,
0.8277645707130432,
-0.6649417877197266,
-0.6359529495239258,
0.04879821091890335,
-0.2587476372718811,
-0.09817647933959961,
-0.46208885312080383,
0.6885327696800232,
-0.2642227113246918,
0.38402488827705383,
-0.3153849244117737,
-0.40575385093688965,
-0.11721666157245636,
0.08734047412872314,
-0.523838460445404,
0.9028857946395874,
0.19692103564739227,
-0.9864975214004517,
0.6383213400840759,
-0.21353818476200104,
-0.22294266521930695,
-0.024247299879789352,
-0.41347840428352356,
-0.3403356671333313,
0.262545108795166,
-0.14315123856067657,
0.3081933557987213,
-0.14395153522491455,
0.3392201364040375,
-0.6752176284790039,
-0.12591849267482758,
0.727279543876648,
-0.7045844793319702,
0.7644217014312744,
0.2803654968738556,
-0.21646688878536224,
0.05326439440250397,
-0.7662656903266907,
0.21774423122406006,
0.04533356428146362,
-0.6295244097709656,
-0.18691764771938324,
0.29285353422164917,
-0.09561623632907867,
0.48047226667404175,
0.3699009120464325,
-0.5917937159538269,
0.04837573319673538,
-0.34346804022789,
-0.0014014927437528968,
0.831364631652832,
-0.28869304060935974,
0.2617693543434143,
-0.8281697034835815,
0.9098410606384277,
-0.10618040710687637,
-0.13555282354354858,
0.3257097005844116,
-0.7757996916770935,
-0.4768998622894287,
-0.1282041370868683,
0.3772054612636566,
0.725213348865509,
-0.48737776279449463,
0.0014773127622902393,
-0.14363792538642883,
-0.5855443477630615,
-0.6910122036933899,
-0.07413224130868912,
0.4655167758464813,
0.2602764666080475,
0.16740137338638306,
-0.20654457807540894,
-0.5283660888671875,
-0.8814641237258911,
-0.7865370512008667,
-0.38499099016189575,
-0.08360225707292557,
0.39700087904930115,
0.427104651927948,
0.23068971931934357,
0.8072085380554199,
-0.3092101812362671,
0.10952871292829514,
-0.4416446089744568,
0.26478925347328186,
0.11362948268651962,
0.28973624110221863,
0.5384576916694641,
-0.6742100119590759,
-0.4930587112903595,
-0.29776063561439514,
-0.43645578622817993,
0.10030827671289444,
0.18934433162212372,
0.408448189496994,
0.1708618849515915,
0.12365985661745071,
-0.515651524066925,
0.4598209857940674,
0.706831157207489,
-0.29571986198425293,
0.892997682094574,
0.10167147219181061,
0.1502496898174286,
-1.0668458938598633,
-0.3172145187854767,
0.1039000079035759,
-0.15543371438980103,
-0.6978572010993958,
0.17169708013534546,
-0.03403385728597641,
0.19878685474395752,
-0.5040621161460876,
0.4363132119178772,
-0.1530909240245819,
-0.024003634229302406,
-0.2939072549343109,
-0.06964676827192307,
-0.0877811536192894,
0.20763789117336273,
0.034165821969509125,
0.8208333849906921,
0.5913981199264526,
-0.4122486710548401,
0.12070253491401672,
0.002182761672884226,
-0.49237582087516785,
0.33097004890441895,
-0.3059524595737457,
0.13735854625701904,
-0.12494497746229172,
-0.19604520499706268,
-1.2078216075897217,
-0.3515622913837433,
0.0633196234703064,
-0.684687614440918,
0.493763267993927,
0.253441721200943,
-0.37671738862991333,
-0.2650620937347412,
-0.6091023683547974,
0.1043562963604927,
0.3651420474052429,
-0.07923801243305206,
0.48044559359550476,
0.1696857362985611,
-0.2619190812110901,
-0.9460710287094116,
-1.2456005811691284,
-0.41955795884132385,
-0.5587045550346375,
-0.3260657787322998,
0.08507382124662399,
-0.4974089562892914,
-0.7585622072219849,
-0.21208049356937408,
-0.41485604643821716,
0.020899251103401184,
0.4177619218826294,
0.23448936641216278,
0.4362665116786957,
-0.12075527012348175,
0.03414520248770714,
-0.17452532052993774,
-0.022960646077990532,
-0.011959348805248737,
0.20753857493400574,
0.17284074425697327,
-0.09043455123901367,
-0.5959364771842957,
0.07896251976490021,
0.5473089218139648,
0.4212903678417206,
0.021943548694252968,
0.6740894317626953,
0.15098603069782257,
-0.2898939549922943,
-0.1387760043144226,
-0.4718113839626312,
0.01407333742827177,
-0.4346790909767151,
0.232676699757576,
-0.5688779354095459,
-1.0382615327835083,
0.4427441954612732,
0.37484773993492126,
0.322200208902359,
0.5851395726203918,
0.7539379000663757,
-0.2438288927078247,
1.0336424112319946,
0.43470942974090576,
0.26812756061553955,
0.4898672103881836,
0.2785460352897644,
0.17175304889678955,
-0.5132899880409241,
0.03700384125113487,
-0.9108141660690308,
-0.15108752250671387,
-1.0075862407684326,
-0.4435093402862549,
0.013813070952892303,
0.11440888792276382,
-0.0564187690615654,
0.14266996085643768,
-0.2963705360889435,
0.28579285740852356,
0.6985333561897278,
-0.21675710380077362,
0.29555949568748474,
0.18642455339431763,
-0.23879438638687134,
-0.2761601507663727,
-0.5592918395996094,
-0.5655995607376099,
1.5329493284225464,
0.2699994742870331,
0.9750027656555176,
0.11888942122459412,
0.8121205568313599,
-0.024822939187288284,
0.3633185923099518,
-0.7160159349441528,
0.5137078762054443,
-0.18217647075653076,
-0.763873815536499,
-0.4676680564880371,
-0.3896094560623169,
-0.7678651213645935,
0.5311084985733032,
-0.09580149501562119,
-1.0840593576431274,
0.19450335204601288,
-0.3488657474517822,
-0.2681424617767334,
0.22460661828517914,
-0.5409473776817322,
0.27779313921928406,
-0.18823674321174622,
-0.16887906193733215,
0.19836509227752686,
-0.641817569732666,
0.19593684375286102,
-0.06260700523853302,
0.5470006465911865,
-0.36401551961898804,
0.07625699788331985,
0.821851372718811,
0.21248459815979004,
0.9026236534118652,
0.06516356021165848,
-0.09129557758569717,
0.4034745991230011,
0.42868679761886597,
0.25782251358032227,
0.1485709398984909,
-0.647484540939331,
0.05607915297150612,
-0.15672972798347473,
-0.36829954385757446,
-0.2302352637052536,
0.6711613535881042,
-0.8552103638648987,
-0.9611603617668152,
-0.6035712957382202,
-0.8002586364746094,
-0.49932950735092163,
0.13988764584064484,
0.7282004952430725,
0.21997356414794922,
-0.14012493193149567,
0.1495954841375351,
0.4117458462715149,
0.00990375317633152,
0.6500816345214844,
0.36747926473617554,
-0.1089019626379013,
-0.33481565117836,
0.5388625264167786,
0.362635999917984,
0.4720240533351898,
0.43887320160865784,
0.1498645544052124,
-0.37541061639785767,
-0.701094388961792,
-0.017255231738090515,
-0.04685965180397034,
-0.90846186876297,
-0.2614802122116089,
-0.06928692013025284,
-0.06412538886070251,
-0.3663959503173828,
-0.10609792172908783,
-0.09108182787895203,
-0.5856066942214966,
-0.508997917175293,
-0.6152772903442383,
0.09146886318922043,
0.7108717560768127,
-0.17895139753818512,
0.025904560461640358,
-0.295884370803833,
0.02069328911602497,
0.24575059115886688,
0.4144289195537567,
-0.27749186754226685,
-0.5859135985374451,
-0.251161128282547,
0.08062713593244553,
-0.44978779554367065,
-1.0477368831634521,
0.39943599700927734,
0.17059661448001862,
0.8195744752883911,
0.2845430374145508,
-0.08788634836673737,
0.28688398003578186,
-0.07671578973531723,
1.154468297958374,
0.24329189956188202,
-0.6799225211143494,
0.562023937702179,
-0.3039971888065338,
0.13913266360759735,
0.5190317630767822,
0.41550788283348083,
-0.023955071344971657,
-0.5892561674118042,
-0.7790194153785706,
-0.5818173885345459,
0.6957061886787415,
-0.12104902416467667,
0.007610855624079704,
-0.08921331912279129,
-0.008082077838480473,
0.6752699017524719,
0.3535270392894745,
-1.1028465032577515,
-0.4881325960159302,
-0.17510567605495453,
-0.08591777086257935,
-0.41516056656837463,
-0.43209072947502136,
-0.15656794607639313,
0.037043496966362,
0.42998215556144714,
-0.07063677161931992,
0.37786629796028137,
0.23229987919330597,
0.1197749450802803,
-0.2628178596496582,
0.5529728531837463,
0.6333602666854858,
0.9789736270904541,
-0.22578412294387817,
0.21819959580898285,
0.30094465613365173,
-0.2270544320344925,
0.08440463989973068,
-0.004433048889040947,
-0.052076105028390884,
0.16833904385566711,
0.5605459213256836,
0.8854920268058777,
-0.008770146407186985,
-0.6223734021186829,
0.2827093005180359,
-0.034983228892087936,
-0.4652760326862335,
-0.006675383076071739,
0.08786934614181519,
0.07983240485191345,
0.11184395104646683,
0.19034381210803986,
0.11940077692270279,
0.043197982013225555,
-0.38660770654678345,
0.033872637897729874,
0.3900417387485504,
-0.289247989654541,
-0.25211989879608154,
0.47836825251579285,
-0.31554168462753296,
-0.5987944006919861,
0.3083711862564087,
-0.23003697395324707,
-0.015060871839523315,
0.6268273591995239,
0.6275007128715515,
0.7936678528785706,
-0.7165879011154175,
0.28653740882873535,
-0.0036461015697568655,
0.1613001525402069,
-0.17398208379745483,
0.7697078585624695,
0.3732844293117523,
-0.7657623291015625,
-0.4925667643547058,
-0.6747925281524658,
-0.4575503170490265,
0.37565159797668457,
-0.7052870392799377,
-0.014340762048959732,
-0.29049232602119446,
-0.48365625739097595,
-0.21158954501152039,
0.00695117237046361,
-0.6577434539794922,
0.29688820242881775,
-0.007189168594777584,
0.9176627397537231,
-0.825605034828186,
0.7173105478286743,
0.8562482595443726,
-0.3046203553676605,
-1.060651421546936,
0.15119849145412445,
0.05865039676427841,
-0.670437753200531,
0.35581710934638977,
0.058048997074365616,
-0.061546918004751205,
-0.4984685480594635,
-0.42977944016456604,
-0.9756483435630798,
0.9059435725212097,
0.3390665650367737,
-0.41403311491012573,
-0.21054962277412415,
0.22596138715744019,
0.45170435309410095,
-0.4926142692565918,
0.39399227499961853,
0.32428640127182007,
0.3255879878997803,
-0.19459103047847748,
-1.1263132095336914,
-0.16926603019237518,
0.07499527931213379,
0.04083560034632683,
-0.07042859494686127,
-0.4614191949367523,
1.2797571420669556,
-0.17262066900730133,
-0.04458681866526604,
0.11553152650594711,
0.47961440682411194,
0.5164830088615417,
0.2959117293357849,
0.21115565299987793,
0.3675520718097687,
0.8076612949371338,
-0.11314194649457932,
1.1376606225967407,
-0.18232065439224243,
0.6591437458992004,
1.0444817543029785,
-0.277431845664978,
1.0435264110565186,
0.4854564368724823,
-0.475404292345047,
0.6651750802993774,
0.8007514476776123,
-0.000409795087762177,
0.6234959959983826,
0.2633686661720276,
-0.09510716050863266,
-0.3201577365398407,
0.18109595775604248,
-0.21956641972064972,
0.6748111248016357,
0.4190531075000763,
-0.33913612365722656,
-0.1937650591135025,
-0.07606542855501175,
-0.13718363642692566,
-0.037517987191677094,
-0.19434984028339386,
0.6293060183525085,
0.24401484429836273,
-0.8444964289665222,
0.45604851841926575,
0.11880642175674438,
0.8475578427314758,
-0.4205722510814667,
0.3204299211502075,
-0.06811778247356415,
-0.07288464158773422,
-0.16447807848453522,
-0.9760825037956238,
0.2260141372680664,
-0.170076385140419,
-0.09747745841741562,
-0.18182595074176788,
0.9967551231384277,
-0.04166293144226074,
-0.37471097707748413,
0.3495396077632904,
1.0396729707717896,
-0.02846575528383255,
0.35365694761276245,
-0.8432795405387878,
-0.24738304316997528,
0.1976964771747589,
-0.6088541746139526,
0.7247313857078552,
0.12116382271051407,
-0.07504274696111679,
0.8931111097335815,
0.45935317873954773,
0.1523035764694214,
0.16002435982227325,
-0.18916065990924835,
0.36620455980300903,
-0.37346184253692627,
-0.3869609236717224,
-0.9167571067810059,
0.45000362396240234,
0.29963961243629456,
-0.3900676667690277,
0.7742019891738892,
0.28614139556884766,
0.7929288744926453,
-0.19142752885818481,
1.0028027296066284,
0.022826483473181725,
0.7782802581787109,
-0.2436078041791916,
0.1128208264708519,
-0.48570194840431213,
0.31424885988235474,
-0.1942347139120102,
-0.6041398048400879,
-0.2107008844614029,
0.5086493492126465,
-0.6387637257575989,
0.3109859824180603,
0.825537383556366,
0.6118135452270508,
0.17687803506851196,
0.08584138751029968,
0.41044431924819946,
0.06399679183959961,
0.02140653505921364,
0.3580840229988098,
0.944977343082428,
0.12109065800905228,
0.5666195750236511,
-0.11467667669057846,
-0.24444325268268585,
-0.3314073085784912,
-0.8242491483688354,
-0.6922551989555359,
-0.5402892827987671,
-0.15822842717170715,
-0.4750336706638336,
-0.08203393220901489,
0.6376973986625671,
0.5202149748802185,
-0.8638497591018677,
-0.45187273621559143,
-0.10171924531459808,
0.26129844784736633,
-0.486278772354126,
-0.28144320845603943,
0.18125450611114502,
-0.30345484614372253,
-0.6094377636909485,
0.5617866516113281,
0.0955842062830925,
0.08238185942173004,
-0.18347667157649994,
0.1130913570523262,
-0.11987128108739853,
0.26064518094062805,
0.04128687083721161,
0.05349469557404518,
-1.0437791347503662,
-0.43342775106430054,
0.0644051656126976,
-0.174077570438385,
0.38704580068588257,
0.5218336582183838,
-0.4439575672149658,
0.25756561756134033,
0.7069594860076904,
0.2595939636230469,
0.13431717455387115,
-0.06323342770338058,
0.5345817804336548,
-0.7295650243759155,
-0.12348685413599014,
0.4411848485469818,
0.47768592834472656,
0.213516503572464,
-0.28326356410980225,
0.18665918707847595,
0.008854646235704422,
-0.7270100116729736,
-0.8183372616767883,
0.8187898397445679,
-0.8194058537483215,
-0.5345889329910278,
1.3047505617141724,
-0.6026118397712708,
0.10165178775787354,
-0.26323485374450684,
0.05580196529626846,
0.1336967796087265,
-0.36678263545036316,
0.6768915057182312,
1.1424450874328613,
-0.3225668668746948,
-0.09752504527568817,
-0.7638107538223267,
0.6265531182289124,
0.427612841129303,
-0.4713466763496399,
0.04541081190109253,
0.15295688807964325,
0.5400623679161072,
0.37483856081962585,
0.5452927947044373,
0.03380965813994408,
0.2131221741437912,
0.16461502015590668,
-0.3398689925670624,
0.22554521262645721,
-0.17918545007705688,
-0.49614888429641724,
0.4830889403820038,
0.7313069105148315,
-0.1012522280216217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00994v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00994v1
|
Leveraging Prompt-Based Large Language Models: Predicting Pandemic Health Decisions and Outcomes Through Social Media Language
| 2024-03-01T21:29:32 | 2024-03-01T21:29:32 |
Xiaohan Ding, Buse Carik, Uma Sushmitha Gunturi, Valerie Reyna, Eugenia H. Rho
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SI
|
We introduce a multi-step reasoning framework using prompt-based LLMs to
examine the relationship between social media language patterns and trends in
national health outcomes. Grounded in fuzzy-trace theory, which emphasizes the
importance of gists of causal coherence in effective health communication, we
introduce Role-Based Incremental Coaching (RBIC), a prompt-based LLM framework,
to identify gists at-scale. Using RBIC, we systematically extract gists from
subreddit discussions opposing COVID-19 health measures (Study 1). We then
track how these gists evolve across key events (Study 2) and assess their
influence on online engagement (Study 3). Finally, we investigate how the
volume of gists is associated with national health trends like vaccine uptake
and hospitalizations (Study 4). Our work is the first to empirically link
social media linguistic patterns to real-world public health trends,
highlighting the potential of prompt-based LLMs in identifying critical online
discussion patterns that can form the basis of public health communication
strategies.
|
[
-0.17112325131893158,
-1.202314853668213,
0.8421406149864197,
0.3859293460845947,
-0.2544155418872833,
0.16053088009357452,
-0.211150661110878,
-0.3416607677936554,
0.6646619439125061,
0.18275326490402222,
-0.7882519364356995,
-0.6635228395462036,
-0.7064424753189087,
0.26316431164741516,
-0.36592745780944824,
0.9455995559692383,
0.2076706439256668,
0.3029464781284332,
-0.18784458935260773,
0.38737329840660095,
-0.3785175681114197,
-0.33609530329704285,
-1.088686227798462,
-0.2165696918964386,
0.9146555066108704,
0.8931769728660583,
0.5521993041038513,
0.3941347897052765,
0.5414410829544067,
0.11956480890512466,
-0.1566997766494751,
-0.06995850801467896,
-0.39147159457206726,
0.23230096697807312,
-0.20484711229801178,
-0.22374598681926727,
-0.19687141478061676,
0.11115037649869919,
0.16209445893764496,
0.4865530729293823,
-0.25841036438941956,
0.3169112801551819,
0.1328006088733673,
0.33175989985466003,
-0.23860274255275726,
0.2344406247138977,
-0.3283156454563141,
-0.12003783136606216,
0.05659361928701401,
-0.4289102256298065,
-0.16966687142848969,
-0.43114691972732544,
0.23206627368927002,
-0.3015468418598175,
0.08158556371927261,
-0.41433554887771606,
0.5517556071281433,
0.0010182287078350782,
-0.5159066915512085,
-0.515587329864502,
-0.5444008111953735,
0.4286127984523773,
-0.7480338215827942,
0.26687687635421753,
0.7542899250984192,
0.4172421395778656,
-0.35915133357048035,
-0.6318574547767639,
-0.32300928235054016,
-0.13836318254470825,
0.23429247736930847,
0.06440798193216324,
-0.10850287228822708,
0.04695913568139076,
0.09772361069917679,
0.026844816282391548,
-0.6388453245162964,
-0.05155745521187782,
-0.31779950857162476,
-0.0760044977068901,
0.8086881637573242,
0.16385972499847412,
0.520251452922821,
-0.356253057718277,
-0.1387084573507309,
0.3695860505104065,
-0.4059249758720398,
0.48997271060943604,
-0.12355459481477737,
0.4444221556186676,
-0.568406343460083,
0.23624484241008759,
-0.16411040723323822,
0.3686940670013428,
0.2950344681739807,
-0.6563177704811096,
-0.09447512030601501,
-0.5576037764549255,
-0.027865873649716377,
0.241215780377388,
0.7084037661552429,
0.37754759192466736,
0.1031932607293129,
0.07468806207180023,
0.335904061794281,
0.12971927225589752,
0.22051715850830078,
-0.7746243476867676,
-0.19044436514377594,
0.25300437211990356,
-0.5473687052726746,
-0.13947676122188568,
0.12810243666172028,
-0.8606482744216919,
-0.8122979998588562,
-0.21096812188625336,
0.12832897901535034,
-0.37952837347984314,
-0.16776274144649506,
0.07139755040407181,
-0.14460361003875732,
0.28283247351646423,
0.5966402888298035,
-0.4377659559249878,
0.1281995326280594,
0.8827542662620544,
1.0746949911117554,
0.06766242533922195,
0.09755977988243103,
-0.5634705424308777,
-0.20011669397354126,
-0.47799211740493774,
0.8377357125282288,
-0.6043664216995239,
-0.28827863931655884,
0.38225921988487244,
-0.11280873417854309,
-0.056303080171346664,
-0.23516106605529785,
0.5748448967933655,
-0.2609078586101532,
0.13643299043178558,
-0.5615583062171936,
-0.3055626153945923,
-0.0640873834490776,
0.32275769114494324,
-0.3851522207260132,
0.663200855255127,
-0.22241923213005066,
-0.8377387523651123,
0.41545769572257996,
-0.4123639762401581,
-0.8337494730949402,
0.12313567101955414,
-0.30086952447891235,
-0.4040500521659851,
-0.1444040983915329,
0.36400485038757324,
0.8604817986488342,
-0.7544814944267273,
0.6078994870185852,
-0.677056074142456,
-0.17580296099185944,
0.16602829098701477,
-0.2828982472419739,
0.6850401759147644,
0.21517308056354523,
-0.356762170791626,
0.24849924445152283,
-0.5111545920372009,
-0.28042617440223694,
-0.04868779331445694,
-0.19618771970272064,
-0.3560248911380768,
0.34559085965156555,
-0.4137094020843506,
0.3197958469390869,
-0.06656734645366669,
-0.07791970670223236,
0.08361917734146118,
-0.171385258436203,
0.6527330279350281,
0.3608139455318451,
0.7232229709625244,
0.2134704440832138,
-0.5177873373031616,
0.7031742930412292,
-0.08714424818754196,
0.6481450796127319,
-0.4304017424583435,
-0.9255140423774719,
-0.18480633199214935,
-0.5799304246902466,
-0.3343995213508606,
0.6361669898033142,
-0.7058749794960022,
0.40907174348831177,
-0.2429063320159912,
-0.6784310936927795,
-0.2805022895336151,
-0.019841603934764862,
0.03542707487940788,
0.5614179372787476,
0.34856802225112915,
0.002243535593152046,
-0.4632927179336548,
-0.6031142473220825,
-0.34708961844444275,
-0.37664276361465454,
0.34200429916381836,
0.19593662023544312,
0.186380073428154,
-0.3174160420894623,
0.7034823894500732,
-0.14684832096099854,
0.03365897387266159,
-0.5416942238807678,
0.3783826529979706,
0.24766521155834198,
0.009822842665016651,
0.25464004278182983,
-0.6209368705749512,
-0.6298040151596069,
-0.12235014885663986,
-0.6880421042442322,
-0.4012538492679596,
-0.2636050879955292,
0.1474040448665619,
-0.1982453614473343,
0.6997413635253906,
-0.39754530787467957,
0.527057409286499,
0.5477021336555481,
-0.43564146757125854,
0.40486761927604675,
0.09937382489442825,
0.57064288854599,
-1.2975153923034668,
-0.2438947707414627,
0.4911819100379944,
-0.0964212417602539,
-0.8374876976013184,
-0.33778637647628784,
-0.06859664618968964,
-0.2165188193321228,
-0.3401132822036743,
0.46236610412597656,
-0.23980611562728882,
0.275675892829895,
-0.19401343166828156,
-0.18320558965206146,
-0.147323340177536,
-0.1954837441444397,
-0.22721752524375916,
0.7015365362167358,
0.6665967106819153,
-0.6211116313934326,
0.2987309396266937,
0.0537496842443943,
-0.4732895493507385,
0.6092696189880371,
-0.658398449420929,
-0.4091014266014099,
-0.16649340093135834,
0.4811587929725647,
-1.0074197053909302,
-0.5709073543548584,
0.45207828283309937,
-0.5591647624969482,
-0.08069213479757309,
0.019664350897073746,
-0.3942798972129822,
-0.6458937525749207,
-0.379802942276001,
0.0038650622591376305,
0.29819953441619873,
-0.19080014526844025,
0.26136618852615356,
0.6239942312240601,
-0.637212872505188,
-0.23141434788703918,
-0.6377609372138977,
0.20312286913394928,
-0.31565243005752563,
-0.7446756362915039,
-0.1087002083659172,
-0.030271658673882484,
-0.538762092590332,
-0.26189279556274414,
-0.07298287004232407,
-0.16435879468917847,
0.3715897798538208,
0.34816446900367737,
0.0602865144610405,
-0.14249174296855927,
0.25971242785453796,
0.03605927526950836,
0.174250066280365,
0.2083507478237152,
-0.07113701105117798,
0.6150932312011719,
0.043271444737911224,
-0.32697030901908875,
-0.6913356184959412,
0.7105681300163269,
0.6386063694953918,
0.1227034330368042,
0.6283338069915771,
0.40606436133384705,
-0.28873687982559204,
0.15489532053470612,
-0.5378358960151672,
-0.3325847089290619,
-0.3708488345146179,
0.05448693782091141,
0.18453000485897064,
-0.8329454660415649,
0.6064645648002625,
-0.05573922395706177,
-0.31351563334465027,
0.09297045320272446,
0.5657857060432434,
-0.05068163201212883,
0.8935847878456116,
0.4037480652332306,
-0.10551167279481888,
0.616269588470459,
0.006514269392937422,
0.18084558844566345,
-0.20001807808876038,
-0.29768452048301697,
-0.46554291248321533,
0.008713977411389351,
-0.5303384065628052,
-0.5336170792579651,
0.6407679319381714,
0.32562288641929626,
-0.3439266085624695,
0.1488468050956726,
-0.2328518182039261,
0.07634095102548599,
0.45473799109458923,
0.3123522996902466,
0.022727033123373985,
-0.20373189449310303,
-0.10687053948640823,
0.049820855259895325,
-0.8964428901672363,
-0.420489102602005,
0.4608196020126343,
0.21192432940006256,
0.922922670841217,
0.06729023158550262,
0.6075575947761536,
0.6286797523498535,
0.20178258419036865,
-0.8568055629730225,
0.453263521194458,
0.1877756118774414,
-0.38016068935394287,
-0.1914030760526657,
-0.346038281917572,
-1.0523390769958496,
-0.19047848880290985,
-0.2820703983306885,
-0.7162489295005798,
0.11234762519598007,
0.07872168719768524,
-0.5804125070571899,
-0.09927674382925034,
-0.6237287521362305,
0.6053656339645386,
-0.2690911591053009,
-0.40849196910858154,
-0.3544120788574219,
-0.8724923133850098,
0.17536716163158417,
0.06849361956119537,
0.6363526582717896,
-0.36243700981140137,
0.16203849017620087,
0.4603712260723114,
-0.32341474294662476,
1.134639859199524,
0.19744741916656494,
-0.12718534469604492,
0.502826988697052,
-0.2720297574996948,
0.4120737910270691,
0.6033689975738525,
-0.13828891515731812,
0.2568725049495697,
-0.030890848487615585,
-0.4340870976448059,
-0.3323676586151123,
0.8284347057342529,
-0.662993848323822,
-0.9231980443000793,
-0.5825158357620239,
-0.01979913003742695,
-0.24736866354942322,
0.056934699416160583,
0.04599868506193161,
0.47577333450317383,
-0.4507324695587158,
-0.05168088898062706,
0.6275773644447327,
-0.4424385726451874,
0.4936366081237793,
0.4871349036693573,
-0.017564576119184494,
-0.5908165574073792,
0.5447012186050415,
0.1265951544046402,
0.12703850865364075,
0.44407859444618225,
0.7642073035240173,
-0.05024741217494011,
-0.20421619713306427,
-0.11628956347703934,
0.3186660408973694,
-0.64216148853302,
-0.32570868730545044,
-0.621380627155304,
-0.22711822390556335,
-0.937105119228363,
-0.42452964186668396,
0.17137721180915833,
0.14518585801124573,
-0.5515755414962769,
-0.1562633067369461,
0.7051011323928833,
0.9147416353225708,
-0.47693926095962524,
0.23145340383052826,
-0.9630488157272339,
0.20757092535495758,
0.30240127444267273,
0.2154339998960495,
0.03911770507693291,
-0.2737773358821869,
-0.4026780128479004,
0.2332201600074768,
-0.03055412322282791,
-1.3940995931625366,
0.3530735671520233,
0.025823166593909264,
0.6648770570755005,
0.7023412585258484,
0.09682207554578781,
0.7405581474304199,
-0.5450096726417542,
1.0686943531036377,
0.4361334443092346,
-0.7806564569473267,
0.7850790023803711,
-0.6618609428405762,
0.36862170696258545,
0.5452544689178467,
0.7132379412651062,
-1.1187292337417603,
-0.33751681447029114,
-0.5408016443252563,
-0.8133550882339478,
0.4977428615093231,
-0.4505477249622345,
-0.04029921442270279,
-0.5989413857460022,
0.1253882646560669,
0.18499219417572021,
-0.02586180903017521,
-0.14584629237651825,
-0.18967001140117645,
-0.15662531554698944,
-0.11634622514247894,
-0.04409874975681305,
-0.49114876985549927,
-0.05949622392654419,
-0.3951355516910553,
0.5913131237030029,
-0.08987346291542053,
0.1811155527830124,
0.41942161321640015,
0.1622779220342636,
-0.21880944073200226,
0.44789764285087585,
0.7635349631309509,
0.6886581778526306,
0.06809552758932114,
0.30779391527175903,
-0.15358835458755493,
-0.394378662109375,
0.1277163177728653,
0.053599607199430466,
-0.07189902663230896,
0.06435170769691467,
0.545774519443512,
0.6754383444786072,
0.38363340497016907,
-0.5388332009315491,
0.6305840015411377,
0.05101313069462776,
0.049937743693590164,
-0.28333669900894165,
-0.005725563503801823,
0.3192496597766876,
0.3884265422821045,
0.4415879249572754,
-0.19659127295017242,
0.16705787181854248,
-0.610618531703949,
0.5730483531951904,
0.45352602005004883,
-0.42358165979385376,
-0.5832120776176453,
0.4376581609249115,
0.32514822483062744,
-0.4123731851577759,
-0.03256099671125412,
0.13034850358963013,
-0.1372808814048767,
0.5746978521347046,
0.2515018582344055,
0.7066179513931274,
-0.44407111406326294,
0.7576685547828674,
0.5073171854019165,
0.22367063164710999,
-0.5128726959228516,
0.39243781566619873,
0.10807469487190247,
-0.2945096492767334,
-0.6424651145935059,
-0.2884223759174347,
-0.2928053140640259,
0.22657695412635803,
-0.685286283493042,
0.5803629755973816,
-0.4923012852668762,
-0.3538770079612732,
0.2361694872379303,
-0.11134497821331024,
-0.5978038311004639,
0.022748656570911407,
0.4193791449069977,
0.9838536381721497,
-1.0410960912704468,
0.6380230784416199,
0.6358931660652161,
-0.6272104978561401,
-0.9192476868629456,
0.5994876027107239,
0.29786476492881775,
-0.7851988673210144,
0.2501634657382965,
0.3610619902610779,
0.025466738268733025,
-0.20152367651462555,
-0.8504210114479065,
-1.0130451917648315,
1.053342342376709,
0.31717637181282043,
-0.337539404630661,
0.13960950076580048,
0.23576956987380981,
0.4990759491920471,
-0.3885153830051422,
0.29837045073509216,
0.14708134531974792,
0.4650183916091919,
0.22711977362632751,
-1.0336230993270874,
-0.0562346912920475,
-0.10514495521783829,
-0.07224837690591812,
-0.14259910583496094,
-0.5389493107795715,
0.6067640781402588,
-0.4959205090999603,
-0.5123469829559326,
-0.2461927831172943,
0.532532811164856,
0.019097037613391876,
0.680457353591919,
0.17944888770580292,
0.2793252170085907,
0.8523714542388916,
0.2640591263771057,
1.1701966524124146,
-0.3338022530078888,
0.18797358870506287,
0.9997313618659973,
-0.24619606137275696,
0.6719695329666138,
0.3390924632549286,
0.07694141566753387,
0.6284911036491394,
0.7797756791114807,
0.4670282006263733,
0.5709882974624634,
0.10339106619358063,
-0.3755267560482025,
-0.4798294007778168,
-0.3455829322338104,
-0.4160020351409912,
0.18920478224754333,
0.6612021327018738,
-0.5344327688217163,
-0.4374590218067169,
0.2462502121925354,
0.31869247555732727,
0.1604287028312683,
-0.5057273507118225,
0.9708796739578247,
0.2452910840511322,
-0.6174576282501221,
0.42769208550453186,
-0.1301400363445282,
0.5908327698707581,
-0.6144734025001526,
-0.15894214808940887,
-0.1456242799758911,
-0.07806996256113052,
-0.0188895370811224,
-0.7244839072227478,
0.39342477917671204,
-0.11409369856119156,
-0.354676216840744,
-0.23091425001621246,
0.8864305019378662,
-0.608024537563324,
-0.49968138337135315,
0.3972136378288269,
0.904003918170929,
0.00026894829352386296,
-0.03380511701107025,
-0.8154551982879639,
0.1294865757226944,
-0.3788995146751404,
-0.13053977489471436,
0.3053724467754364,
0.5617961287498474,
-0.24860861897468567,
0.6243394613265991,
0.645487368106842,
0.1942397952079773,
-0.05342162773013115,
0.0106531186029315,
0.5371153950691223,
-0.5324864387512207,
-0.6333708763122559,
-1.0311533212661743,
0.17074421048164368,
-0.22571773827075958,
-0.06455419212579727,
0.8278359174728394,
0.12992936372756958,
0.4790496230125427,
0.13853423297405243,
1.1026736497879028,
0.008387462235987186,
0.683259129524231,
-0.14791682362556458,
0.7570957541465759,
-0.37061524391174316,
0.053094420582056046,
-0.03287409991025925,
0.01801191456615925,
-0.42906880378723145,
0.5428178310394287,
-0.6815895438194275,
-0.3553646504878998,
0.5472747683525085,
0.6609659790992737,
0.4184719920158386,
0.10510435700416565,
0.25867849588394165,
0.22291052341461182,
0.4179595708847046,
-0.049807604402303696,
0.7565587162971497,
0.09861614555120468,
0.30103400349617004,
0.011947749182581902,
-0.35306286811828613,
-0.4923502802848816,
-0.824583888053894,
-0.9904918074607849,
-0.5384904742240906,
-0.31814882159233093,
-0.6016370058059692,
0.4478916823863983,
1.488305687904358,
0.29395318031311035,
-0.7993983626365662,
-0.07103452831506729,
-0.22703300416469574,
0.2713380455970764,
-0.3958416283130646,
-0.31542399525642395,
0.1614164561033249,
-0.2844164967536926,
-0.17970512807369232,
0.30403679609298706,
0.46814167499542236,
-0.16828233003616333,
-0.1617215871810913,
0.14422859251499176,
-0.5943406224250793,
0.3999103605747223,
0.8332255482673645,
0.3652329444885254,
-0.8309779167175293,
-0.29763326048851013,
0.21788673102855682,
-0.5890783667564392,
0.01087777316570282,
0.9475110769271851,
-0.531669557094574,
0.2598622739315033,
0.6922031044960022,
0.5315442085266113,
-0.242332324385643,
0.024265673011541367,
0.5566953420639038,
-0.3559817969799042,
-0.23691552877426147,
0.23214471340179443,
0.27841559052467346,
0.5399883985519409,
-0.407765656709671,
0.35157135128974915,
0.44888201355934143,
-0.34558334946632385,
-0.4193587601184845,
0.19522938132286072,
-0.8859568238258362,
-0.3482480049133301,
1.909697413444519,
0.01593361608684063,
-0.22253462672233582,
-0.4542604982852936,
-0.16806377470493317,
0.4189084470272064,
-0.8278168439865112,
0.9727610945701599,
0.6652200222015381,
-0.15213415026664734,
-0.25575166940689087,
-0.49086424708366394,
0.5800507664680481,
-0.042534198611974716,
-0.9352167248725891,
-0.06837188452482224,
0.46864163875579834,
0.20597027242183685,
-0.09403206408023834,
0.9511114954948425,
0.21697069704532623,
0.19554324448108673,
-0.24397791922092438,
-0.1941579282283783,
0.17981219291687012,
-0.33251655101776123,
-0.25334301590919495,
0.005219840444624424,
-0.17545659840106964,
0.22074082493782043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00990v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00990v1
|
Formulation Comparison for Timeline Construction using LLMs
| 2024-03-01T21:24:24 | 2024-03-01T21:24:24 |
Kimihiro Hasegawa, Nikhil Kandukuri, Susan Holm, Yukari Yamakawa, Teruko Mitamura
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Constructing a timeline requires identifying the chronological order of
events in an article. In prior timeline construction datasets, temporal orders
are typically annotated by either event-to-time anchoring or event-to-event
pairwise ordering, both of which suffer from missing temporal information. To
mitigate the issue, we develop a new evaluation dataset, TimeSET, consisting of
single-document timelines with document-level order annotation. TimeSET
features saliency-based event selection and partial ordering, which enable a
practical annotation workload. Aiming to build better automatic timeline
construction systems, we propose a novel evaluation framework to compare
multiple task formulations with TimeSET by prompting open LLMs, i.e., Llama 2
and Flan-T5. Considering that identifying temporal orders of events is a core
subtask in timeline construction, we further benchmark open LLMs on existing
event temporal ordering datasets to gain a robust understanding of their
capabilities. Our experiments show that (1) NLI formulation with Flan-T5
demonstrates a strong performance among others, while (2) timeline construction
and event temporal ordering are still challenging tasks for few-shot LLMs. Our
code and data are available at https://github.com/kimihiroh/timeset.
|
[
-0.09724054485559464,
-0.6287908554077148,
0.598236083984375,
0.6539089679718018,
-0.26779288053512573,
-0.07549059391021729,
0.0702693834900856,
-0.5220009684562683,
0.18624068796634674,
0.20763076841831207,
-0.8338826894760132,
-0.562568187713623,
-0.44578713178634644,
0.08920344710350037,
-0.25126123428344727,
0.8039170503616333,
-0.3307322561740875,
-0.2620092034339905,
-0.15369194746017456,
-0.27222636342048645,
-0.12409647554159164,
-0.23809492588043213,
-0.6683946847915649,
-0.4408074915409088,
0.5939933657646179,
-0.04908101260662079,
0.6423175930976868,
0.9139479994773865,
0.5532603859901428,
0.22538696229457855,
-0.2199225127696991,
0.4199769198894501,
-0.27437475323677063,
-0.06726350635290146,
0.10409694910049438,
-0.3236650824546814,
-0.8312044143676758,
0.06926993280649185,
0.6083713173866272,
0.6641282439231873,
0.07685994356870651,
0.5601677894592285,
-0.2129558026790619,
0.38740894198417664,
-0.8440654277801514,
0.28276440501213074,
-0.360024631023407,
0.7960585951805115,
-0.624150812625885,
-0.4867672622203827,
-0.2053680121898651,
-0.39992547035217285,
0.19012050330638885,
-0.8018621802330017,
0.15146231651306152,
0.15009434521198273,
0.7524362206459045,
0.3852260112762451,
-0.34832385182380676,
0.015218307264149189,
-0.6321495771408081,
0.7615875005722046,
-0.6765220165252686,
0.4394631087779999,
0.009560116566717625,
0.45275694131851196,
-0.28294625878334045,
-0.9035344123840332,
-0.32920747995376587,
-0.041578397154808044,
0.132435142993927,
0.402422696352005,
0.05671070143580437,
0.03471865504980087,
0.5480958223342896,
0.378422349691391,
-0.6632630825042725,
0.3171573877334595,
-0.20945164561271667,
-0.11638118326663971,
0.3757873773574829,
0.35654976963996887,
-0.08582985401153564,
-0.41427046060562134,
-0.7626808881759644,
0.03503764793276787,
-0.7974866628646851,
-0.14808392524719238,
0.2620002329349518,
0.20069527626037598,
-0.23000401258468628,
0.8128805160522461,
-0.2014070302248001,
0.48638513684272766,
0.06669773161411285,
-0.3596137464046478,
0.34156036376953125,
-0.42551106214523315,
-0.5799390077590942,
-0.10350453853607178,
0.587391197681427,
0.7198819518089294,
0.11525333672761917,
-0.25047433376312256,
-0.1749350130558014,
0.1847362369298935,
0.20389164984226227,
-0.6551330089569092,
0.30663275718688965,
0.4102744460105896,
-0.45068976283073425,
-0.2793443202972412,
0.08389265835285187,
-0.592361569404602,
-0.36949145793914795,
-0.3024344742298126,
0.20349076390266418,
-0.04638130962848663,
0.17014120519161224,
-0.3260086476802826,
-0.08848999440670013,
0.19523844122886658,
0.36509665846824646,
-0.27907007932662964,
0.07949382811784744,
0.7589012980461121,
0.9652745723724365,
-0.22964629530906677,
-0.3216071128845215,
-0.8720782995223999,
0.39150363206863403,
-0.5671720504760742,
0.6137260794639587,
-0.33025455474853516,
-0.3509087562561035,
0.0855918750166893,
-0.3336853086948395,
0.14654453098773956,
-0.5046645998954773,
0.6414887309074402,
-0.6185638308525085,
0.24217404425144196,
0.029038384556770325,
-0.5598397254943848,
0.2507901191711426,
0.15833386778831482,
-0.7607259750366211,
1.3035857677459717,
0.1740490198135376,
-0.7161033153533936,
0.7285500168800354,
-0.7477167844772339,
-0.4696546792984009,
-0.1337701827287674,
-0.25554773211479187,
-0.447785347700119,
-0.030629457905888557,
0.4001353681087494,
0.45342764258384705,
-0.14058704674243927,
0.15821366012096405,
-0.35929161310195923,
-0.30686628818511963,
0.030864136293530464,
-0.16241031885147095,
0.5018523931503296,
0.37109124660491943,
-0.44424426555633545,
0.1521856039762497,
-0.5941555500030518,
0.1415705382823944,
0.027016812935471535,
-0.31032443046569824,
0.0925116166472435,
0.06358280032873154,
-0.14532612264156342,
0.18827709555625916,
0.3276917040348053,
-0.3411006033420563,
0.20844773948192596,
-0.674103319644928,
0.1586093157529831,
0.767475426197052,
0.37729519605636597,
0.39463695883750916,
-0.39063403010368347,
0.48900309205055237,
0.12829077243804932,
0.49654117226600647,
-0.08599039167165756,
-0.22068172693252563,
-0.8435747623443604,
0.1308470070362091,
0.06979071348905563,
0.6946901082992554,
-0.8271824717521667,
0.1083238422870636,
-0.486083984375,
-0.2911604940891266,
-0.08700749278068542,
0.05531706288456917,
0.6321510672569275,
0.3247598707675934,
0.26150286197662354,
-0.2062307894229889,
-0.8869022727012634,
-0.8375155925750732,
0.009587645530700684,
-0.15793216228485107,
-0.14933453500270844,
-0.031187793239951134,
0.25890499353408813,
0.1354760229587555,
0.8460986614227295,
-0.37014099955558777,
-0.09373494237661362,
0.09321238845586777,
0.39909958839416504,
0.27918216586112976,
0.07047180086374283,
0.7078166007995605,
-0.6084799766540527,
-0.025506729260087013,
-0.0905635878443718,
-0.9162294864654541,
-0.11710070073604584,
-0.12065065652132034,
-0.12867242097854614,
0.34523794054985046,
0.29805994033813477,
-0.29235443472862244,
0.7886123657226562,
0.1535293310880661,
-0.2469322681427002,
0.4298112690448761,
0.06819633394479752,
0.23852179944515228,
-0.9563645720481873,
0.12316659837961197,
-0.27293527126312256,
-0.25793713331222534,
-0.5295430421829224,
-0.09308438748121262,
-0.007533713709563017,
-0.1251879781484604,
-0.712283194065094,
0.8267229199409485,
-0.4818762242794037,
-0.46217215061187744,
-0.017306119203567505,
0.42942702770233154,
-0.08162472397089005,
0.5879149436950684,
-0.1263894885778427,
0.6301412582397461,
-0.004453964997082949,
-0.6953380703926086,
-0.07200551778078079,
0.2674788534641266,
-0.44723114371299744,
0.5123512148857117,
-0.5932461619377136,
0.2421519160270691,
-0.01263591181486845,
0.07679403573274612,
-0.6207348704338074,
-0.1186695247888565,
0.36395788192749023,
-0.1385229229927063,
0.08081582188606262,
-0.25229746103286743,
-0.7715842127799988,
-0.500984251499176,
-0.6678072810173035,
0.2679474651813507,
0.20104029774665833,
-0.5385738611221313,
0.5585396885871887,
0.07131735235452652,
-0.11159737408161163,
-0.875910758972168,
-0.7369743585586548,
-0.07945921272039413,
-0.23055148124694824,
-0.6331517696380615,
0.5383365154266357,
-0.16935832798480988,
-0.41440874338150024,
-0.08053696900606155,
-0.6939780712127686,
-0.020146096125245094,
0.16345669329166412,
0.4531124532222748,
0.2318941056728363,
-0.22682785987854004,
-0.16849477589130402,
0.19256845116615295,
-0.19213959574699402,
-0.2018958181142807,
-0.2528470754623413,
0.01907682791352272,
0.20238950848579407,
-0.4047988951206207,
-0.2782505452632904,
0.20089010894298553,
0.41232362389564514,
-0.16218695044517517,
0.3641207218170166,
0.656925618648529,
-0.534541130065918,
-0.23180271685123444,
-0.759641170501709,
0.33117690682411194,
-0.3704209327697754,
0.05646255984902382,
-0.42444926500320435,
-0.6941384673118591,
0.41870105266571045,
0.07953303307294846,
0.5778779983520508,
0.5024077892303467,
0.49042952060699463,
-0.031880415976047516,
0.3780929148197174,
0.24707889556884766,
-0.060497820377349854,
0.738580584526062,
-0.2746943235397339,
-0.18831869959831238,
-0.6285847425460815,
-0.05835539847612381,
-0.19385099411010742,
-0.32769575715065,
-0.1360911875963211,
-0.4984588623046875,
0.5947787761688232,
0.21135598421096802,
-0.3232041597366333,
0.33171042799949646,
0.0038862978108227253,
0.41157442331314087,
0.3306877613067627,
0.07256519794464111,
0.522354245185852,
0.1338052898645401,
-0.1285296231508255,
0.010160582140088081,
-0.6418547630310059,
-0.810786247253418,
1.0387173891067505,
0.10032537579536438,
0.20684966444969177,
0.1284576952457428,
0.7592882513999939,
0.5714453458786011,
0.4671972990036011,
-0.2892057001590729,
0.6072127819061279,
-0.20036089420318604,
-0.4682120084762573,
-0.21636003255844116,
-0.2910831570625305,
-0.8960715532302856,
0.04919785261154175,
-0.11074066907167435,
-0.8357673287391663,
0.17142392694950104,
-0.09144476801156998,
-0.5193029642105103,
0.17415286600589752,
-0.7047250270843506,
0.7794686555862427,
-0.26715540885925293,
-0.4226241409778595,
-0.04451320320367813,
-0.7963899970054626,
0.004843214992433786,
0.2221316546201706,
0.08773434907197952,
-0.5239719152450562,
-0.27255645394325256,
0.7831934094429016,
-0.6903743147850037,
0.8485669493675232,
-0.07259703427553177,
0.07519304752349854,
0.413972944021225,
0.15588143467903137,
0.48859313130378723,
0.24697642028331757,
-0.43730035424232483,
0.14412283897399902,
-0.010960553772747517,
-0.14314205944538116,
-0.821933925151825,
0.6044200658798218,
-0.5001659989356995,
-0.18958871066570282,
-0.2623900771141052,
-0.541313648223877,
0.009138318710029125,
0.1914733499288559,
0.1594313383102417,
0.8921483159065247,
-0.36550775170326233,
-0.4713747799396515,
0.06617996096611023,
0.2658400535583496,
0.8280331492424011,
0.27228376269340515,
-0.1505771428346634,
-0.5165629386901855,
0.44228363037109375,
0.17977596819400787,
0.08719304949045181,
0.7667334675788879,
-0.2019105702638626,
-0.2262432724237442,
-0.6272699236869812,
-0.39386916160583496,
0.2090710997581482,
-0.8058626055717468,
-0.3269587457180023,
-0.2638910412788391,
-0.029203224927186966,
-0.27818623185157776,
-0.320908784866333,
-0.32291266322135925,
-0.7287676930427551,
-0.27837398648262024,
-0.11887849867343903,
0.14634113013744354,
0.8649400472640991,
0.15284602344036102,
0.11770966649055481,
-0.4808081090450287,
0.33230987191200256,
-0.1543010175228119,
0.4660361707210541,
-0.0028250934556126595,
-0.09767423570156097,
-0.03989989310503006,
-0.27778562903404236,
-0.5671092867851257,
-0.6127713322639465,
0.010119082406163216,
0.017186393961310387,
0.7076206207275391,
0.3697705566883087,
-0.02575875259935856,
1.0217162370681763,
-0.6144853830337524,
0.6363570094108582,
-0.07672704011201859,
-0.8765667676925659,
0.7934817671775818,
-0.3250937759876251,
0.332148015499115,
0.38556233048439026,
0.19304101169109344,
-0.33584722876548767,
-0.3010525703430176,
-0.7760380506515503,
-0.9235760569572449,
0.7356575727462769,
0.7275838851928711,
-0.7792381644248962,
-0.040470220148563385,
0.692890465259552,
0.0159751009196043,
0.42266300320625305,
-0.6267287135124207,
-0.42050600051879883,
-0.041356611996889114,
-0.07536584883928299,
-0.012108095921576023,
-0.4419417679309845,
-0.2538036108016968,
0.48397260904312134,
0.3031281530857086,
0.08148417621850967,
0.5126780867576599,
0.32592034339904785,
-0.2296265959739685,
-0.15566383302211761,
0.48084306716918945,
0.5449991226196289,
1.0379538536071777,
-0.4124163091182709,
-0.04829735681414604,
0.4716288447380066,
-0.09249407052993774,
-0.14228855073451996,
0.37184932827949524,
-0.1344374418258667,
-0.06282603740692139,
1.00640070438385,
0.8543307781219482,
0.6504106521606445,
-0.2844054102897644,
0.3684166371822357,
0.29709142446517944,
0.05199216306209564,
-0.276457816362381,
-0.130399689078331,
-0.24157625436782837,
0.6716680526733398,
0.4335310459136963,
-0.3656015694141388,
0.05051831156015396,
-0.25733429193496704,
0.12429837882518768,
-0.04426008462905884,
-0.014193490147590637,
-0.24631184339523315,
0.7382062673568726,
0.1314457356929779,
-0.3667442202568054,
0.4548036754131317,
-0.2977692186832428,
-0.17992743849754333,
0.662241518497467,
0.22114062309265137,
0.800614595413208,
0.0011309061665087938,
-0.09430617839097977,
0.23561976850032806,
0.34725600481033325,
0.02151321806013584,
0.4675363302230835,
0.017459671944379807,
-0.1770244687795639,
-0.5365868210792542,
-0.6205552816390991,
-0.4464626610279083,
-0.052279580384492874,
-0.5007096529006958,
0.2763126790523529,
-0.6264926195144653,
-0.34455665946006775,
-0.053992148488759995,
0.2828032374382019,
-0.9044107794761658,
-0.018914273008704185,
0.02631538175046444,
0.9899764060974121,
-0.7050606608390808,
0.26739227771759033,
0.7428855299949646,
-0.4070235788822174,
-0.37176039814949036,
0.11538778245449066,
0.4044019877910614,
-0.465334415435791,
0.5982561111450195,
0.11772721260786057,
-0.06025352329015732,
-0.3180195987224579,
-0.06336448341608047,
-0.7716711163520813,
1.662231206893921,
0.3435297906398773,
-0.3953685462474823,
-0.3559568524360657,
-0.046471007168293,
0.566544771194458,
-0.47461652755737305,
0.3371567130088806,
0.26068738102912903,
0.5754823684692383,
0.13333816826343536,
-1.0991218090057373,
0.052588097751140594,
-0.15829648077487946,
0.2134544849395752,
0.3732603192329407,
-0.46158212423324585,
0.41767606139183044,
-0.26450058817863464,
-0.7008280158042908,
0.5291252732276917,
0.9980736970901489,
0.17398416996002197,
0.8363273739814758,
0.47351765632629395,
0.45297157764434814,
0.6049305200576782,
-0.29199081659317017,
1.2388572692871094,
-0.03252176567912102,
0.19034361839294434,
1.3398213386535645,
-0.3739539384841919,
0.6580896973609924,
0.3909471929073334,
-0.5189939141273499,
0.18238720297813416,
0.8743512034416199,
0.08370178937911987,
0.444566935300827,
-0.051157694309949875,
-0.0425882488489151,
-0.10789310932159424,
-0.08923604339361191,
-0.38814109563827515,
-0.02198607102036476,
0.11741888523101807,
0.05259506776928902,
-0.5794965624809265,
-0.2087498903274536,
-0.019670072942972183,
-0.22337564826011658,
-0.26254066824913025,
0.4681253731250763,
0.14792393147945404,
-0.40648698806762695,
0.18758559226989746,
-0.03216131776571274,
0.3097861707210541,
-0.6831567883491516,
0.04530396685004234,
-0.3845418691635132,
-0.04542180150747299,
-0.2468176633119583,
-0.6188802719116211,
0.3893415927886963,
-0.07473257184028625,
-0.19345532357692719,
-0.11868038028478622,
0.3027653694152832,
-0.24995043873786926,
-0.39336925745010376,
0.14921553432941437,
0.4766821265220642,
0.02362893708050251,
0.3998863101005554,
-0.593778669834137,
0.22603152692317963,
-0.44029924273490906,
-0.3294050395488739,
-0.10986403375864029,
0.35558685660362244,
-0.4025854170322418,
0.5134314298629761,
0.24776434898376465,
-0.1788751482963562,
0.06896578520536423,
0.42264342308044434,
0.5504459738731384,
-0.5313571095466614,
-0.4287378787994385,
-0.7050542235374451,
0.4700145125389099,
-0.08119041472673416,
-0.4487683176994324,
0.7379410862922668,
0.7599443197250366,
0.7235934138298035,
0.013293500989675522,
0.3774004280567169,
-0.07923896610736847,
0.47546544671058655,
-0.8656551837921143,
0.1036667674779892,
-0.6261518597602844,
0.4388912320137024,
-0.563471794128418,
-0.9844744801521301,
-0.5604518055915833,
0.18664608895778656,
-0.44023072719573975,
0.12602609395980835,
0.8296718597412109,
0.6775588989257812,
-0.0923025980591774,
0.06094014272093773,
-0.09813201427459717,
0.18374913930892944,
0.21368974447250366,
0.6715831160545349,
0.7997962832450867,
-0.3865543305873871,
0.5336694121360779,
-0.3217625617980957,
-0.05570952966809273,
-0.1398010104894638,
-1.4399179220199585,
-1.026154637336731,
-0.5059497952461243,
-0.3591223657131195,
-0.2241344302892685,
0.500255286693573,
1.1097615957260132,
0.5367488265037537,
-0.4863984286785126,
-0.26950255036354065,
0.3526303470134735,
0.16446267068386078,
-0.3467442989349365,
-0.19561779499053955,
0.5642433166503906,
-0.12963548302650452,
-0.7700790166854858,
0.8809642791748047,
0.5079169273376465,
0.22250886261463165,
0.08971255272626877,
0.2780594527721405,
-0.28000161051750183,
-0.25661271810531616,
0.7443748712539673,
0.21979527175426483,
-0.7992976307868958,
-0.3772619962692261,
-0.1445399969816208,
0.18648949265480042,
0.2439405769109726,
0.930293083190918,
-0.5461475849151611,
0.3850996494293213,
0.288458913564682,
0.46403753757476807,
0.8265068531036377,
-0.08744320273399353,
0.5067028403282166,
-1.2835352420806885,
0.22144140303134918,
-0.09825016558170319,
0.3754403293132782,
0.16849933564662933,
-0.33795738220214844,
1.1196269989013672,
0.13961344957351685,
-0.1725553423166275,
-0.7056344151496887,
0.24592047929763794,
-1.356971025466919,
0.14845050871372223,
0.7917271256446838,
0.020222527906298637,
-0.062283534556627274,
0.010417099110782146,
0.27995648980140686,
0.3546442687511444,
-0.29078245162963867,
0.49688002467155457,
0.5432403087615967,
-0.32287198305130005,
0.397975355386734,
-0.5162962675094604,
0.2003966122865677,
0.17385432124137878,
-0.7539849281311035,
-0.24919746816158295,
0.491057813167572,
0.0626186728477478,
0.19821123778820038,
0.7717470526695251,
-0.13303133845329285,
0.4166180193424225,
-0.2774536907672882,
-0.18716438114643097,
-0.5362357497215271,
-0.5346494913101196,
-0.1611713021993637,
0.3066125810146332,
-0.039559878408908844,
-0.08374515175819397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00986v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00986v2
|
Merging Text Transformer Models from Different Initializations
| 2024-03-01T21:16:29 | 2024-03-07T18:45:09 |
Neha Verma, Maha Elbayad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent work on one-shot permutation-based model merging has shown impressive
low- or zero-barrier mode connectivity between models from completely different
initializations. However, this line of work has not yet extended to the
Transformer architecture, despite its dominant popularity in the language
domain. Therefore, in this work, we investigate the extent to which separate
Transformer minima learn similar features, and propose a model merging
technique to investigate the relationship between these minima in the loss
landscape. The specifics of the architecture, like its residual connections,
multi-headed attention, and discrete, sequential input, require specific
interventions in order to compute model permutations that remain within the
same functional equivalence class. In merging these models with our method, we
consistently find lower loss barriers between minima compared to model
averaging for several models trained on a masked-language modeling task or
fine-tuned on a language understanding benchmark. Our results show that the
minima of these models are less sharp and isolated than previously understood,
and provide a basis for future work on merging separately trained Transformer
models.
|
[
-0.6231687068939209,
-0.5055453181266785,
0.5821225643157959,
-0.3098977208137512,
0.004811988212168217,
-0.20669573545455933,
-0.1229829266667366,
-0.431039422750473,
-0.20467163622379303,
0.5812246799468994,
-0.7964712977409363,
-0.23994317650794983,
-0.8192055225372314,
-0.046614985913038254,
-0.527366578578949,
0.9670236706733704,
-0.029020538553595543,
-0.22221191227436066,
-0.1667366325855255,
-0.3967404067516327,
-0.5343963503837585,
-0.33328160643577576,
-0.4613068103790283,
-0.6915989518165588,
0.5423505902290344,
0.31352952122688293,
0.6603802442550659,
0.642667293548584,
0.6556853652000427,
0.3206179738044739,
-0.29497411847114563,
-0.1054336354136467,
-0.5396894216537476,
-0.23800915479660034,
-0.0635451003909111,
-0.4481668472290039,
-0.23489633202552795,
-0.008682862855494022,
0.7112211585044861,
0.9639244079589844,
0.1337948739528656,
0.24539916217327118,
0.40839889645576477,
0.38389837741851807,
-0.5875058770179749,
-0.15789924561977386,
-0.6619323492050171,
0.30553293228149414,
-0.11631245166063309,
-0.0006999095203354955,
-0.6912323832511902,
0.12795883417129517,
0.3006279170513153,
-0.15841369330883026,
0.42485859990119934,
-0.22901910543441772,
0.9858918190002441,
0.41262611746788025,
-0.5576217174530029,
0.10919900983572006,
-0.8351880311965942,
0.7206395864486694,
-0.6137807965278625,
0.5797272324562073,
-0.033655159175395966,
0.3892705738544464,
0.28962644934654236,
-0.3342593312263489,
-0.7250430583953857,
0.14835084974765778,
-0.5735089778900146,
-0.0905677080154419,
-0.6658791899681091,
-0.02085011452436447,
0.0447954498231411,
0.13205893337726593,
-0.5719759464263916,
0.3747148811817169,
-0.4769721031188965,
-0.13783012330532074,
0.26836755871772766,
0.36229395866394043,
0.08137616515159607,
-0.15309005975723267,
-0.4112100303173065,
-0.4013575613498688,
-0.7970910668373108,
0.04061027243733406,
0.2993243336677551,
0.39968404173851013,
-0.5702570080757141,
0.4535275399684906,
0.06713145971298218,
0.6837590932846069,
0.04801641404628754,
-0.23661784827709198,
0.17720116674900055,
-0.5249462723731995,
-0.40063440799713135,
-0.20711809396743774,
0.8612903356552124,
0.07864796370267868,
0.0022723760921508074,
-0.20419088006019592,
-0.1179843544960022,
0.05035022273659706,
0.23118647933006287,
-0.5935420989990234,
-0.3776565194129944,
-0.28542912006378174,
-0.8196189403533936,
-0.439856618642807,
-0.22784090042114258,
-0.3418290913105011,
-0.3387710750102997,
-0.2491416037082672,
0.45679935812950134,
-0.41502076387405396,
-0.1508084088563919,
0.06290196627378464,
0.0285925455391407,
0.419172465801239,
0.031847499310970306,
-0.8945344686508179,
0.4301678240299225,
0.6340734958648682,
0.7874699234962463,
-0.15792450308799744,
-0.4135785698890686,
-0.16376006603240967,
-0.12821438908576965,
-0.10710859298706055,
0.8004999160766602,
-0.40592068433761597,
-0.267065167427063,
-0.042021602392196655,
-0.1313580870628357,
-0.3861137926578522,
-0.5263575315475464,
0.26759836077690125,
-0.5168373584747314,
0.4275091886520386,
0.12191679328680038,
-0.2955590784549713,
-0.45438262820243835,
0.22231274843215942,
-0.7891865968704224,
0.7448297739028931,
0.10260681807994843,
-0.8811071515083313,
0.16376441717147827,
-0.5500773787498474,
-0.36401766538619995,
-0.1907084435224533,
-0.20736382901668549,
-0.5061728954315186,
0.28409433364868164,
0.041920725256204605,
0.2230362743139267,
-0.38871699571609497,
-0.19661524891853333,
0.017264433205127716,
-0.2635287344455719,
0.10398971289396286,
-0.5825572609901428,
0.9032058119773865,
-0.04961476847529411,
-0.08455237001180649,
0.23678475618362427,
-0.7690386772155762,
-0.36524736881256104,
0.15823087096214294,
-0.17069143056869507,
-0.5372971296310425,
-0.0963534489274025,
0.17517176270484924,
0.28389352560043335,
0.12716691195964813,
-0.21077388525009155,
0.2536368668079376,
-0.4768202006816864,
0.3023988902568817,
0.5925881862640381,
0.022716790437698364,
0.9032976627349854,
-0.6282263398170471,
0.3545924127101898,
0.3777957856655121,
0.018999753519892693,
-0.47308260202407837,
-0.5297335982322693,
-1.1341632604599,
-0.22729311883449554,
0.39098384976387024,
0.5081884860992432,
-0.5657695531845093,
0.4112452566623688,
-0.5000408887863159,
-0.5558983683586121,
-0.6202273964881897,
0.02644783817231655,
0.5524625182151794,
0.7733338475227356,
0.3579903841018677,
-0.32581424713134766,
-0.46744683384895325,
-1.0733731985092163,
-0.2798932194709778,
-0.11655934900045395,
-0.240004301071167,
0.31205278635025024,
0.2411436289548874,
-0.38048169016838074,
1.0808619260787964,
-0.5384684205055237,
-0.45135629177093506,
-0.4289996027946472,
0.052044644951820374,
0.32968172430992126,
0.5065150856971741,
0.7940781116485596,
-0.5456034541130066,
-0.6460921764373779,
0.14295946061611176,
-0.38903141021728516,
0.08065395057201385,
-0.11740154027938843,
-0.0046101282350718975,
-0.20343753695487976,
0.28213736414909363,
-0.5449094772338867,
0.39791762828826904,
0.6049513220787048,
-0.056014806032180786,
0.1516098529100418,
-0.008215542882680893,
0.1504584103822708,
-0.9783045053482056,
-0.24172109365463257,
0.058517102152109146,
-0.06552445143461227,
-1.0740602016448975,
-0.0933246836066246,
-0.018856002017855644,
-0.09692510217428207,
-0.6014133095741272,
0.5884454250335693,
-0.3247130215167999,
0.14611199498176575,
-0.33249011635780334,
0.21863022446632385,
-0.13755251467227936,
0.5798019766807556,
-0.27607104182243347,
0.5307773947715759,
0.5949354767799377,
-0.6695569753646851,
-0.1968594491481781,
0.5770873427391052,
-0.08546100556850433,
0.13107702136039734,
-0.38927119970321655,
0.33456340432167053,
-0.3423320949077606,
-0.026746824383735657,
-1.221977949142456,
0.07524935901165009,
0.36322736740112305,
-0.24914053082466125,
0.1354815661907196,
-0.25731727480888367,
-0.19242888689041138,
-0.16873064637184143,
-0.25951555371284485,
0.6437017917633057,
0.7745092511177063,
-0.48805513978004456,
0.8694277405738831,
0.27247315645217896,
-0.09327439218759537,
-0.2684355080127716,
-0.8204935193061829,
-0.1317744255065918,
-0.2676166594028473,
-0.8559976816177368,
0.6568475365638733,
-0.004987548105418682,
0.03094959445297718,
0.1722618192434311,
-0.055240679532289505,
-0.223435178399086,
0.019353438168764114,
0.19734960794448853,
0.2872476577758789,
-0.4639084041118622,
0.019187409430742264,
0.26931774616241455,
-0.18089492619037628,
-0.34016552567481995,
-0.07087114453315735,
0.5837366580963135,
0.09556692838668823,
-0.279192715883255,
-0.6135244965553284,
0.3658285439014435,
0.48005586862564087,
-0.26848962903022766,
1.1337721347808838,
0.22624991834163666,
-0.5442487001419067,
-0.07518339902162552,
-0.6425042152404785,
-0.3887287974357605,
-0.4949168562889099,
0.25731566548347473,
-0.8504922389984131,
-1.0482109785079956,
0.720889687538147,
0.033197011798620224,
0.10226557403802872,
0.6678731441497803,
0.48789775371551514,
-0.07854660600423813,
0.7455541491508484,
1.3860745429992676,
-0.08261807262897491,
0.6304771900177002,
-0.3152907192707062,
0.44999024271965027,
-0.7472385764122009,
-0.13531358540058136,
-0.523453414440155,
-0.5023030042648315,
-0.6325598955154419,
-0.32050445675849915,
0.2540391683578491,
-0.06569331884384155,
-0.10235583037137985,
0.6918500661849976,
-0.47218021750450134,
0.5477511882781982,
0.2665806710720062,
0.07280633598566055,
0.5219598412513733,
0.21605528891086578,
-0.1299867480993271,
-0.21822446584701538,
-1.0738791227340698,
-0.489681214094162,
0.864172101020813,
0.416467547416687,
0.6860621571540833,
0.06262380629777908,
0.7815021872520447,
-0.09962734580039978,
0.6401331424713135,
-0.7656068205833435,
0.4183204472064972,
-0.4816998839378357,
-0.24636021256446838,
-0.2850189805030823,
-0.5517619252204895,
-0.8967552185058594,
0.5332934856414795,
-0.44069015979766846,
-0.7876282930374146,
0.2726573944091797,
0.2118752896785736,
-0.5071282982826233,
0.14840459823608398,
-0.6394822001457214,
1.0352888107299805,
0.2769155502319336,
0.279704749584198,
-0.19619259238243103,
-0.6196329593658447,
0.7533701062202454,
-0.14845366775989532,
0.13047251105308533,
0.08525805920362473,
0.0962139293551445,
0.6993395090103149,
-0.294514000415802,
0.7086666822433472,
0.37042784690856934,
-0.1404048204421997,
0.1654587835073471,
0.15891849994659424,
0.350813090801239,
-0.44562670588493347,
0.33835214376449585,
0.34695345163345337,
-0.26614782214164734,
-0.11364848911762238,
-0.5149396657943726,
0.41267696022987366,
-0.7055598497390747,
-0.47967156767845154,
-0.028753912076354027,
-0.4656483232975006,
-0.12729021906852722,
0.2861957550048828,
0.49366408586502075,
0.4081944227218628,
-0.1241455152630806,
0.11937905848026276,
0.7028117179870605,
0.044992562383413315,
0.5266445875167847,
0.6281253695487976,
0.06134087219834328,
-0.27213355898857117,
0.566358208656311,
-0.1452690213918686,
0.15431436896324158,
0.6217823028564453,
0.11448219418525696,
-0.04425616189837456,
-0.4733845591545105,
-0.04236934706568718,
0.39938420057296753,
-0.7649698257446289,
-0.288592129945755,
-0.6949129104614258,
-0.5887651443481445,
-0.36108291149139404,
-0.12368044257164001,
-0.42183199524879456,
-0.1812058389186859,
-0.1765376478433609,
0.04492652788758278,
0.00901282113045454,
0.6161351203918457,
0.27171826362609863,
0.9155977368354797,
-1.1165175437927246,
0.2662121653556824,
0.19877170026302338,
0.25687387585639954,
0.23758511245250702,
-0.9100210070610046,
-0.36673504114151,
-0.1813979148864746,
-0.3863942623138428,
-1.1703295707702637,
0.21959379315376282,
0.19078554213047028,
0.4368346631526947,
0.5011545419692993,
-0.18656568229198456,
0.6907693147659302,
-0.9026404619216919,
0.3648301959037781,
0.5470409989356995,
-1.059604525566101,
0.2483428567647934,
-0.07450752705335617,
0.47911250591278076,
0.6524309515953064,
0.3149658739566803,
-0.664013683795929,
-0.3788551986217499,
-0.5403350591659546,
-0.4835095703601837,
0.784362256526947,
0.30769243836402893,
0.07107877731323242,
0.36940687894821167,
0.06746125966310501,
0.08940696716308594,
-0.05353368818759918,
-0.8516697883605957,
-0.5238568186759949,
0.18241626024246216,
-0.47051921486854553,
-0.039703141897916794,
-0.08322154730558395,
-0.3543328642845154,
-0.23480871319770813,
0.25151708722114563,
-0.005665169097483158,
0.24784962832927704,
-0.2140669971704483,
-0.45452049374580383,
0.03931429237127304,
0.2142167091369629,
0.549135148525238,
0.24356238543987274,
0.2009918987751007,
0.38796377182006836,
0.41591519117355347,
-0.30827954411506653,
0.40867117047309875,
0.043145034462213516,
-0.3866322934627533,
0.08384916186332703,
0.5674914717674255,
1.0461763143539429,
0.4131130576133728,
-0.4325341582298279,
0.5896070003509521,
-0.10719213634729385,
-0.23765940964221954,
0.2828913629055023,
0.033960942178964615,
0.018292337656021118,
0.3289109468460083,
0.23989318311214447,
0.5388990044593811,
0.09371598064899445,
-0.34964296221733093,
0.33730462193489075,
0.4180350601673126,
-0.42934760451316833,
-0.36614179611206055,
0.6084175705909729,
0.20602825284004211,
-0.44145628809928894,
0.5887661576271057,
-0.09330485016107559,
-0.5355749726295471,
0.5482597351074219,
0.44654807448387146,
1.1677228212356567,
-0.14976002275943756,
0.005699581000953913,
0.1532655954360962,
0.7327837347984314,
0.027195049449801445,
-0.39069971442222595,
-0.04300788417458534,
-0.8702499270439148,
-0.547259509563446,
-0.45483776926994324,
-0.22845788300037384,
0.15435102581977844,
-0.3186037540435791,
0.5199846625328064,
-0.10784107446670532,
-0.1503409743309021,
0.1400231271982193,
-0.40464046597480774,
-0.8839653134346008,
0.0017647790955379605,
0.16439729928970337,
0.8338237404823303,
-1.2146337032318115,
0.7501329779624939,
0.6277614235877991,
-0.31130170822143555,
-0.8072646856307983,
0.10971953719854355,
-0.08534398674964905,
-0.23880648612976074,
0.5271742939949036,
0.23909907042980194,
-0.20574381947517395,
-0.11165675520896912,
-0.0006593798752874136,
-0.7705076336860657,
1.0169366598129272,
0.47275418043136597,
-0.5604159832000732,
-0.2698637843132019,
0.2009127140045166,
0.35284024477005005,
-0.6824733018875122,
0.23163361847400665,
0.6968761682510376,
0.18193919956684113,
0.011886871419847012,
-0.990459144115448,
0.09409619122743607,
-0.021081343293190002,
0.12377871572971344,
0.38697725534439087,
-0.573851466178894,
0.9833527207374573,
0.07975184172391891,
-0.6901895999908447,
0.02926211804151535,
0.6083795428276062,
-0.09828425198793411,
0.1428374946117401,
0.7688020467758179,
0.495126873254776,
0.3767150044441223,
-0.017490122467279434,
0.6248918175697327,
-0.3881383538246155,
0.6942399144172668,
1.2264893054962158,
-0.020391512662172318,
0.7972650527954102,
0.22498556971549988,
-0.09152422100305557,
0.39230582118034363,
0.2916947603225708,
0.1344245821237564,
0.6957709789276123,
-0.16422319412231445,
-0.07813027501106262,
-0.17748595774173737,
0.17133420705795288,
-0.2219894826412201,
0.518663227558136,
-0.14611537754535675,
-0.36399853229522705,
-0.4539508521556854,
0.21862614154815674,
-0.09054923057556152,
-0.009916101582348347,
0.012669723480939865,
0.8805350661277771,
-0.041838616132736206,
-0.46163633465766907,
0.6121711134910583,
0.261623740196228,
0.8427332043647766,
-0.48311758041381836,
0.1773185282945633,
-0.4134185314178467,
0.12420158088207245,
-0.06884033232927322,
-0.3955093026161194,
0.5859884023666382,
0.034842196851968765,
-0.5585288405418396,
-0.40146008133888245,
0.7440118193626404,
-0.7081162333488464,
-0.31904712319374084,
0.26910480856895447,
0.427702397108078,
-0.19676394760608673,
0.16266950964927673,
-0.3851134181022644,
0.23924341797828674,
0.0030161261092871428,
-0.04944683611392975,
0.3322388827800751,
0.004897784907370806,
0.19064313173294067,
0.5252468585968018,
0.3397100865840912,
-0.2931652367115021,
0.41903385519981384,
0.07496679574251175,
0.9954114556312561,
-0.5022010803222656,
-0.5908345580101013,
-0.9172070026397705,
0.6740861535072327,
0.034092895686626434,
-0.22250056266784668,
0.6315696239471436,
0.5193682909011841,
0.819007933139801,
-0.31457582116127014,
0.5980608463287354,
0.2219730019569397,
0.2484985888004303,
-0.3827036917209625,
0.9650136232376099,
-0.6120123267173767,
0.23334796726703644,
-0.01772068627178669,
-1.1700847148895264,
-0.15982367098331451,
0.4923606514930725,
-0.0155003871768713,
-0.22887982428073883,
0.8036209344863892,
0.8402110934257507,
-0.36642318964004517,
-0.41405901312828064,
0.4239720106124878,
0.19963623583316803,
0.22198016941547394,
0.7880752682685852,
0.506493091583252,
-0.7781609892845154,
0.7555907368659973,
-0.2763287127017975,
-0.271401971578598,
-0.1701582968235016,
-0.7036617398262024,
-0.9334072470664978,
-0.6692350506782532,
-0.41036877036094666,
-0.12337721139192581,
-0.14228177070617676,
0.43764981627464294,
0.5800941586494446,
-0.6495620012283325,
-0.126134991645813,
0.005788735114037991,
0.37723803520202637,
-0.26842254400253296,
-0.19390197098255157,
0.13939668238162994,
-0.22148677706718445,
-0.7106075286865234,
0.3702494502067566,
0.46059709787368774,
0.18724565207958221,
-0.2420821487903595,
-0.03605634719133377,
-0.08507537841796875,
0.49800562858581543,
0.4694470167160034,
0.23688054084777832,
-0.6215459704399109,
-0.3130896985530853,
0.036527324467897415,
-0.32617902755737305,
0.188514843583107,
0.9697592854499817,
-0.9084380865097046,
0.3185883164405823,
0.798366367816925,
0.8221627473831177,
0.5577607154846191,
-0.24567389488220215,
0.29430484771728516,
-0.85426265001297,
0.39161932468414307,
0.01741900108754635,
0.3058859407901764,
0.2519732415676117,
0.03436556085944176,
0.2733631432056427,
0.14114652574062347,
-0.05186840891838074,
-0.9178823828697205,
0.5329967737197876,
-0.9291679859161377,
-0.052052151411771774,
0.6534004807472229,
0.10166429728269577,
-0.04533501714468002,
0.25402384996414185,
-0.0024968634825199842,
0.31533804535865784,
0.2664981782436371,
0.6220827102661133,
0.6678146123886108,
-0.1480562537908554,
-0.5130053758621216,
-0.04502122476696968,
0.43661925196647644,
0.36533287167549133,
-0.7426899671554565,
-0.18465836346149445,
0.015530756674706936,
0.3291347026824951,
0.48034778237342834,
0.4992482662200928,
0.17260333895683289,
0.1104453057050705,
0.2187132090330124,
0.012010021135210991,
0.16377416253089905,
-0.5594550967216492,
-0.6357807517051697,
0.29200246930122375,
-0.17646558582782745,
-0.2326437383890152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00982v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00982v1
|
LocalRQA: From Generating Data to Locally Training, Testing, and Deploying Retrieval-Augmented QA Systems
| 2024-03-01T21:10:20 | 2024-03-01T21:10:20 |
Xiao Yu, Yunan Lu, Zhou Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented question-answering systems combine retrieval techniques
with large language models to provide answers that are more accurate and
informative. Many existing toolkits allow users to quickly build such systems
using off-the-shelf models, but they fall short in supporting researchers and
developers to customize the model training, testing, and deployment process. We
propose LocalRQA, an open-source toolkit that features a wide selection of
model training algorithms, evaluation methods, and deployment tools curated
from the latest research. As a showcase, we build QA systems using online
documentation obtained from Databricks and Faire's websites. We find 7B-models
trained and deployed using LocalRQA reach a similar performance compared to
using OpenAI's text-ada-002 and GPT-4-turbo.
|
[
-0.5748329758644104,
-0.8389250636100769,
0.4834490716457367,
-0.011668732389807701,
0.2786886394023895,
0.12296321243047714,
0.376740038394928,
-0.2850155532360077,
0.19242623448371887,
0.5033761858940125,
-0.1792844980955124,
-0.07591375708580017,
0.23816624283790588,
0.12556307017803192,
-0.4207635521888733,
0.7027980089187622,
-0.29232752323150635,
0.13435062766075134,
-0.42379292845726013,
-0.16421294212341309,
-0.4792419672012329,
-0.596729576587677,
-0.5220235586166382,
-0.015242801047861576,
0.48143792152404785,
0.3875414729118347,
1.0907772779464722,
0.4368066191673279,
0.42547890543937683,
0.12242033332586288,
-0.057666581124067307,
-0.1973208338022232,
-0.28009283542633057,
0.12290789186954498,
-0.26089784502983093,
-0.5305025577545166,
-0.28289809823036194,
-0.09967005252838135,
0.5701758861541748,
0.4889070689678192,
-0.41432249546051025,
0.6095376014709473,
-0.6201652884483337,
0.5342801809310913,
-0.9320460557937622,
-0.3412262499332428,
-0.2626674771308899,
-0.06582927703857422,
-0.0790010318160057,
0.2481103241443634,
-0.15146641433238983,
-1.0476561784744263,
-0.04243657365441322,
-0.6582995057106018,
0.09480977803468704,
-0.050240617245435715,
0.6941125988960266,
0.13662636280059814,
-0.6955094933509827,
-0.14019642770290375,
-0.6651239991188049,
0.6668114066123962,
-0.7950928807258606,
0.7796267867088318,
0.518586277961731,
0.8166825175285339,
-0.2185155749320984,
-0.9317360520362854,
-0.5839956998825073,
-0.1865643858909607,
0.17670223116874695,
-0.005828517489135265,
-0.08906568586826324,
-0.24733202159404755,
0.17976151406764984,
0.7909011244773865,
-0.7878401875495911,
-0.24692244827747345,
-0.5548166632652283,
-0.14009463787078857,
0.3942754566669464,
0.12872587144374847,
0.20754797756671906,
-0.22392039000988007,
-0.1378175914287567,
-0.02733510546386242,
-0.9855197072029114,
0.08596834540367126,
0.23773080110549927,
0.21966366469860077,
0.22064870595932007,
0.6171653270721436,
-0.7649544477462769,
0.6647523045539856,
0.08159207552671432,
0.0689406469464302,
0.3185395896434784,
-0.5035467147827148,
-0.3331466317176819,
-0.19939884543418884,
0.4580947756767273,
-0.3390147387981415,
-0.3556916117668152,
-0.22878606617450714,
-0.4482325613498688,
0.024766206741333008,
0.27079495787620544,
-0.7632266283035278,
-0.26268041133880615,
0.20822323858737946,
-0.40571972727775574,
-0.30103692412376404,
-0.3035123646259308,
-0.34386777877807617,
-0.33002907037734985,
-0.2889446020126343,
0.8546595573425293,
-0.07181502133607864,
-0.44322115182876587,
0.013850482180714607,
-0.0963086485862732,
0.3597757816314697,
-0.03646400198340416,
-0.3701600730419159,
0.27519071102142334,
0.2078191637992859,
0.7125569581985474,
0.05289595574140549,
-0.009730668738484383,
-0.7638298869132996,
-0.22329968214035034,
-0.5012575387954712,
0.6097326278686523,
-0.4651336371898651,
-0.2701127231121063,
0.19922402501106262,
-0.05837897211313248,
0.2543431520462036,
-0.7283967137336731,
0.3503105044364929,
-1.0978443622589111,
0.3989224433898926,
-0.41138750314712524,
-0.31900179386138916,
-0.09669032692909241,
0.2561158239841461,
-0.6759913563728333,
1.4441542625427246,
0.4860653877258301,
-0.6901366710662842,
0.15424583852291107,
-0.7264319658279419,
-0.1966685801744461,
0.06858731806278229,
0.01791466772556305,
0.052222687751054764,
-0.020250778645277023,
0.5110260248184204,
0.4384397566318512,
-0.3700234889984131,
-0.03397544473409653,
-0.03737051784992218,
-0.5351871252059937,
0.010667025111615658,
-0.04173672944307327,
0.9846588373184204,
0.7313964366912842,
-0.06839954853057861,
0.07644890993833542,
-0.7071569561958313,
0.14703018963336945,
0.09718592464923859,
-0.4245252013206482,
-0.06674610078334808,
-0.214410662651062,
-0.13650324940681458,
0.15891438722610474,
0.4015253484249115,
-0.6088126301765442,
0.15762442350387573,
-0.5542502403259277,
0.33017927408218384,
0.11714401841163635,
0.19049133360385895,
0.6910528540611267,
-0.4900965094566345,
0.955119252204895,
-0.16210772097110748,
0.49065566062927246,
-0.09849407523870468,
-0.5803820490837097,
-0.514305830001831,
-0.21429069340229034,
0.3932221531867981,
0.6701602339744568,
-1.1938996315002441,
-0.2702272832393646,
-0.08325688540935516,
-0.908595085144043,
-0.6899492740631104,
0.18522603809833527,
0.29721248149871826,
0.3522207736968994,
0.2584388256072998,
-0.4058231711387634,
-0.30855676531791687,
-0.7563354969024658,
0.015907002612948418,
-0.10537189990282059,
-0.19950564205646515,
0.08367575705051422,
0.33633488416671753,
-0.2397906482219696,
1.2715699672698975,
-0.4260055124759674,
0.0409405380487442,
0.04377942532300949,
0.07896561920642853,
0.044838447123765945,
0.24785752594470978,
0.4584386646747589,
-0.8820602893829346,
-0.16905032098293304,
0.01311025582253933,
-0.5713146328926086,
-0.010338104330003262,
0.3382017910480499,
-0.08873952925205231,
0.062209438532590866,
0.1523783653974533,
-0.4972805678844452,
0.48475778102874756,
0.3977832496166229,
-0.11865175515413284,
0.7412113547325134,
-0.04904940351843834,
0.40443721413612366,
-1.174454927444458,
0.2754201292991638,
-0.32653194665908813,
-0.3561209738254547,
-0.5331910848617554,
0.5258309841156006,
0.03845609351992607,
-0.36386576294898987,
-0.5649014115333557,
0.9183910489082336,
-0.398613840341568,
-0.40295735001564026,
-0.006657151505351067,
0.2216958850622177,
0.11777406930923462,
0.22011864185333252,
-0.08102997392416,
1.159203290939331,
0.2845623195171356,
-0.5947038531303406,
0.49711376428604126,
0.6804350018501282,
-0.5568227171897888,
0.38065436482429504,
-0.5312830805778503,
0.4400189518928528,
-0.007077387534081936,
-0.049153514206409454,
-0.507070779800415,
-0.4625042974948883,
0.059266820549964905,
-0.43454816937446594,
-0.20828935503959656,
-0.30949580669403076,
-0.6693705320358276,
-0.31112006306648254,
-0.1491895318031311,
0.7924019694328308,
0.7099131941795349,
-0.7391882538795471,
0.6415330767631531,
0.5867509841918945,
-0.30725857615470886,
-0.5538359880447388,
-0.4286756217479706,
-0.27992963790893555,
0.14024297893047333,
-0.5849266648292542,
-0.1290169209241867,
0.03480285778641701,
-0.36869528889656067,
-0.08573844283819199,
0.043337441980838776,
-0.6235218048095703,
0.12365780770778656,
0.23062573373317719,
-0.04443247243762016,
-0.48496484756469727,
0.2461841106414795,
0.04613134637475014,
0.37744006514549255,
0.03452393412590027,
0.14268609881401062,
0.1719258427619934,
-0.3189711272716522,
-0.3735978901386261,
-0.19071908295154572,
0.3219323754310608,
0.28397583961486816,
-0.7199608087539673,
0.42978933453559875,
0.37435606122016907,
-0.4127840995788574,
0.008748790249228477,
-0.6572250127792358,
-0.1903153955936432,
-0.5097612142562866,
0.14366193115711212,
-0.39228135347366333,
-0.8057982921600342,
0.6305858492851257,
0.026518816128373146,
0.15559716522693634,
0.1452130377292633,
0.46143561601638794,
0.1484280675649643,
1.2513238191604614,
0.4912866950035095,
0.28953254222869873,
0.48941513895988464,
-0.06636658310890198,
0.26770052313804626,
-0.6106480956077576,
-0.20501084625720978,
-0.7221159338951111,
0.11720499396324158,
-0.10502251237630844,
-0.6398548483848572,
0.26595771312713623,
0.3284376263618469,
-0.7678545117378235,
0.23448768258094788,
-0.6261748671531677,
0.5180581212043762,
0.8247169256210327,
-0.08352973312139511,
0.28925082087516785,
0.005440361797809601,
0.025184057652950287,
0.25273191928863525,
-0.8285956978797913,
-0.47734129428863525,
0.9144614338874817,
0.3619304895401001,
0.7080484628677368,
0.1566171944141388,
0.592865526676178,
0.20287953317165375,
0.5007796883583069,
-0.47093403339385986,
0.3067915141582489,
0.42141950130462646,
-0.9963194131851196,
-0.171518936753273,
-0.6610308885574341,
-0.7803776264190674,
-0.30221807956695557,
-0.020042400807142258,
-0.5424458384513855,
0.4292091727256775,
0.08423827588558197,
-0.48871827125549316,
0.23314808309078217,
-0.8782480955123901,
0.9766359329223633,
-0.09192166477441788,
0.1294649988412857,
0.06783629208803177,
-0.4623725116252899,
0.34351786971092224,
-0.21210110187530518,
0.26245418190956116,
0.031240124255418777,
0.21249990165233612,
0.6423768401145935,
-0.29230234026908875,
0.529961109161377,
-0.39927157759666443,
-0.23257170617580414,
0.6200903654098511,
0.5059390664100647,
0.4090062081813812,
0.07882862538099289,
-0.19038307666778564,
-0.06705950200557709,
0.8151268362998962,
-0.7019933462142944,
-0.7247159481048584,
0.6606401801109314,
-0.6538682579994202,
-0.22387124598026276,
-0.3094838261604309,
-0.4426323175430298,
-0.5134874582290649,
0.07681632041931152,
-0.06652527302503586,
0.7038919925689697,
-0.1372990757226944,
-0.08107222616672516,
0.6031377911567688,
-0.31399476528167725,
-0.12173033505678177,
0.2980186641216278,
-0.8403132557868958,
-0.5097962617874146,
0.9674817323684692,
-0.0020442313980311155,
0.2817419171333313,
0.3613530695438385,
-0.0614771842956543,
-0.404074490070343,
-0.43565887212753296,
-0.4178885519504547,
0.06271116435527802,
-0.964802622795105,
-0.41674792766571045,
-0.023707039654254913,
-0.12937405705451965,
-0.4329396188259125,
-0.14519229531288147,
-0.32342207431793213,
-0.716588020324707,
-0.08361516892910004,
-0.04425763711333275,
0.5317583084106445,
1.27070152759552,
0.03778044879436493,
0.37986162304878235,
-0.9385034441947937,
0.40280744433403015,
0.46981966495513916,
0.4568970799446106,
-0.030765574425458908,
-0.5372676253318787,
-0.47846391797065735,
0.2429066300392151,
-0.3328932225704193,
-1.0656771659851074,
0.22835427522659302,
-0.004971446003764868,
0.410433292388916,
-0.03587491437792778,
0.12228475511074066,
0.2918892502784729,
-0.21758566796779633,
0.9927533864974976,
-0.19059927761554718,
-0.7852379083633423,
0.679645299911499,
-0.4255005717277527,
0.46455249190330505,
0.6259851455688477,
0.5647867321968079,
-0.42079949378967285,
-0.27908581495285034,
-0.27516910433769226,
-0.6371573805809021,
0.38760867714881897,
0.09611225128173828,
0.17332221567630768,
-0.19778868556022644,
0.8091015219688416,
0.11077325791120529,
0.14129027724266052,
-0.386140912771225,
-0.21678867936134338,
-0.35733649134635925,
-0.37178659439086914,
0.4068622589111328,
-0.14425069093704224,
-0.02874869480729103,
-0.04374738410115242,
1.0614101886749268,
-0.2757578194141388,
0.41711223125457764,
0.33932584524154663,
-0.23345263302326202,
0.12853477895259857,
0.22571711242198944,
-0.010628658346831799,
0.9043651223182678,
-0.26306164264678955,
-0.12079207599163055,
0.2641279101371765,
-0.3657895028591156,
0.2770908772945404,
0.09654546529054642,
-0.4729668200016022,
-0.13687707483768463,
-0.32457640767097473,
0.5919670462608337,
0.07257945835590363,
-0.9219582080841064,
0.49154573678970337,
-0.29723724722862244,
-0.06232977285981178,
-0.17680566012859344,
-0.042779166251420975,
0.00014808258856646717,
0.3703421354293823,
0.4940653443336487,
-0.20043368637561798,
0.3041481673717499,
-0.5107911825180054,
0.2153097540140152,
0.2135242521762848,
-0.38444316387176514,
-0.26066529750823975,
0.6806822419166565,
0.13626891374588013,
-0.35332736372947693,
0.5858317017555237,
-0.43026262521743774,
-0.3245537579059601,
0.414546936750412,
0.33643409609794617,
0.6116371750831604,
-0.14195369184017181,
0.6733418107032776,
0.42159202694892883,
0.036984242498874664,
-0.25907474756240845,
0.7482665181159973,
-0.0554550439119339,
-0.3844205141067505,
-0.7455838918685913,
-0.6253584027290344,
-0.6558951139450073,
-0.14078205823898315,
-0.7795149087905884,
0.004347736947238445,
-0.4680368900299072,
-0.1585180163383484,
-0.2124801129102707,
0.1277572065591812,
-0.7266790270805359,
0.36521807312965393,
-0.11806701123714447,
1.2978216409683228,
-0.4350854456424713,
0.5798904299736023,
0.9983857870101929,
-0.7138656377792358,
-1.1503326892852783,
-0.3277633786201477,
-0.48085907101631165,
-0.44124847650527954,
0.585448145866394,
-0.15263551473617554,
0.06494041532278061,
0.17200171947479248,
-0.42734548449516296,
-1.142628788948059,
1.1796623468399048,
0.5201868414878845,
-0.07494310289621353,
-0.13890725374221802,
-0.11783638596534729,
0.45184463262557983,
-0.14031097292900085,
0.5320754647254944,
0.4248654842376709,
0.14144021272659302,
-0.052528396248817444,
-1.2798287868499756,
0.09771817922592163,
-0.13262280821800232,
-0.09527121484279633,
0.27497172355651855,
-0.364106148481369,
0.5853191018104553,
-0.1626206338405609,
-0.22270488739013672,
0.44439786672592163,
0.6270313858985901,
0.08369249105453491,
0.08771803975105286,
0.08335093408823013,
0.5133987665176392,
0.9301007986068726,
-0.021763967350125313,
1.1438592672348022,
-0.024115800857543945,
0.12816400825977325,
1.055855631828308,
-0.2709358334541321,
1.3558933734893799,
0.21245799958705902,
-0.09869714826345444,
0.5810796022415161,
0.6361498832702637,
0.25479644536972046,
0.3739514946937561,
-0.0634583905339241,
-0.3010067939758301,
-0.2954539954662323,
-0.18323858082294464,
-0.3804948329925537,
0.20107780396938324,
-0.17691370844841003,
0.057225242257118225,
-0.22777409851551056,
0.16663959622383118,
-0.426066130399704,
0.023359501734375954,
-0.5088940262794495,
0.5528042912483215,
-0.0782446339726448,
-0.49728551506996155,
0.7312548160552979,
-0.0009106240468099713,
0.2997489273548126,
-0.4241088330745697,
0.05398774519562721,
-0.608538806438446,
-0.05339060351252556,
-0.13662196695804596,
-0.587562620639801,
0.2831237316131592,
0.08579394966363907,
-0.16616573929786682,
0.12928955256938934,
0.5895089507102966,
-0.18347403407096863,
-0.3654184639453888,
-0.11591716855764389,
0.803260862827301,
0.31754109263420105,
-0.2783390283584595,
-0.5661492943763733,
-0.38271644711494446,
-0.15115439891815186,
-0.17648543417453766,
0.26304084062576294,
0.24162977933883667,
-0.3034828007221222,
0.939039409160614,
0.6041892170906067,
0.0028838394209742546,
0.42744842171669006,
0.0020617772825062275,
0.654313862323761,
-0.6414651870727539,
-0.2705051898956299,
0.12384317070245743,
0.3362230658531189,
0.27648279070854187,
-0.30977123975753784,
0.6156063675880432,
0.6739961504936218,
0.8652061820030212,
0.06359026581048965,
0.5877168774604797,
-0.18559768795967102,
0.8629186153411865,
-0.2869526743888855,
0.7417272925376892,
-0.6019324064254761,
0.02297641709446907,
0.30969128012657166,
-0.9332289099693298,
-0.24345408380031586,
0.4655435383319855,
-0.3351263403892517,
0.1159251257777214,
0.3328497111797333,
1.0330922603607178,
-0.10142724215984344,
-0.06831587105989456,
0.2253851443529129,
0.09762617200613022,
0.1676265001296997,
0.34078723192214966,
1.1394110918045044,
-0.7890118360519409,
0.7008604407310486,
-0.3147209882736206,
0.020926568657159805,
0.10927373915910721,
-0.6173717379570007,
-0.8837233185768127,
-0.6112578511238098,
-0.16936343908309937,
-0.2333042323589325,
0.12306158244609833,
0.8039856553077698,
0.7498020529747009,
-0.870619535446167,
-0.02425001561641693,
0.12601147592067719,
0.13708800077438354,
-0.08264432847499847,
-0.24815386533737183,
0.23060713708400726,
-0.32766878604888916,
-0.32950887084007263,
0.6504696607589722,
-0.21125862002372742,
0.05923467129468918,
-0.4843321144580841,
-0.3108619749546051,
-0.26963749527931213,
0.19846832752227783,
0.23830312490463257,
0.7106744647026062,
-0.38400402665138245,
-0.11110565811395645,
0.2856649160385132,
-0.0984959676861763,
0.13031639158725739,
0.5065308213233948,
-1.3861569166183472,
0.5088908672332764,
0.6258009076118469,
0.9248504042625427,
0.3579910397529602,
-0.0056740171276032925,
0.8327028155326843,
-0.8376872539520264,
-0.18615250289440155,
0.3917694091796875,
0.151651531457901,
0.5949367880821228,
-0.216491237282753,
0.5301974415779114,
-0.288341224193573,
-0.8867123126983643,
-1.082736611366272,
0.18276558816432953,
-0.5235189199447632,
-0.005572558846324682,
1.0213329792022705,
-0.002621436957269907,
-0.22564895451068878,
-0.33083727955818176,
-0.37984925508499146,
0.13793888688087463,
-0.19623516499996185,
0.5656368136405945,
0.24587848782539368,
0.1847134232521057,
0.04973844438791275,
-0.7855123281478882,
0.7303164005279541,
0.3018691837787628,
-0.9911813139915466,
-0.1398451030254364,
0.6561249494552612,
0.4989679157733917,
0.34778013825416565,
0.7460917234420776,
-0.04309668391942978,
0.755939781665802,
-0.03210984542965889,
0.30093225836753845,
-0.05797417089343071,
-0.08344824612140656,
-0.4304354786872864,
0.22572143375873566,
0.4244652986526489,
0.06446658819913864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00964v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00964v1
|
MALTO at SemEval-2024 Task 6: Leveraging Synthetic Data for LLM Hallucination Detection
| 2024-03-01T20:31:10 | 2024-03-01T20:31:10 |
Federico Borra, Claudio Savelli, Giacomo Rosso, Alkis Koudounas, Flavio Giobergia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In Natural Language Generation (NLG), contemporary Large Language Models
(LLMs) face several challenges, such as generating fluent yet inaccurate
outputs and reliance on fluency-centric metrics. This often leads to neural
networks exhibiting "hallucinations". The SHROOM challenge focuses on
automatically identifying these hallucinations in the generated text. To tackle
these issues, we introduce two key components, a data augmentation pipeline
incorporating LLM-assisted pseudo-labelling and sentence rephrasing, and a
voting ensemble from three models pre-trained on Natural Language Inference
(NLI) tasks and fine-tuned on diverse datasets.
|
[
-0.42687201499938965,
-0.8890005350112915,
0.7148157954216003,
-0.003033344866707921,
-0.4067888855934143,
-0.16198284924030304,
-0.06844212114810944,
-0.5835622549057007,
0.44291597604751587,
0.993761420249939,
-0.9631625413894653,
-0.5144989490509033,
-0.5202926993370056,
0.7150406241416931,
-0.36528825759887695,
0.7047882080078125,
0.17182795703411102,
0.1256929636001587,
-0.2940922677516937,
0.08876907080411911,
-0.7784900069236755,
-0.7376819252967834,
-0.3562931716442108,
-0.30911970138549805,
0.39654865860939026,
0.36199671030044556,
0.5467197895050049,
0.5218757390975952,
0.2901468873023987,
0.38703757524490356,
0.26066914200782776,
0.6239396333694458,
-0.27793586254119873,
0.5217896699905396,
0.04421844705939293,
-0.33136478066444397,
-0.25760358572006226,
-0.16712430119514465,
0.16162768006324768,
0.556187093257904,
-0.08950678259134293,
-0.3557160496711731,
0.07078547030687332,
0.44077032804489136,
-0.4561190605163574,
0.11709512770175934,
-0.9666049480438232,
0.19755448400974274,
-0.2912772297859192,
-0.44334059953689575,
-0.42705443501472473,
-0.22880390286445618,
-0.140565887093544,
-0.3881668448448181,
0.32605260610580444,
0.16537466645240784,
0.6375532150268555,
0.7477689385414124,
-0.27637171745300293,
-0.7028049230575562,
-0.4081176817417145,
0.6770298480987549,
-0.8619377017021179,
0.5223803520202637,
0.5142840147018433,
0.1876196563243866,
-0.3264141082763672,
-0.9735527038574219,
-0.6352102160453796,
-0.2594550549983978,
-0.2038005143404007,
-0.01760810986161232,
0.07871997356414795,
0.10812889039516449,
0.20886607468128204,
0.3379955589771271,
-0.6071961522102356,
-0.0171367060393095,
-0.5219126343727112,
-0.4449041783809662,
0.7373377680778503,
0.36395302414894104,
0.276332288980484,
-0.4080692231655121,
-0.056615907698869705,
0.0843825563788414,
-0.25116708874702454,
-0.7217634320259094,
0.45614752173423767,
0.352407306432724,
0.3716897964477539,
0.7251983284950256,
-0.07889708131551743,
0.6498584151268005,
-0.09444686025381088,
0.24101176857948303,
0.4230186343193054,
-0.42451637983322144,
-0.2904779016971588,
0.4331299364566803,
0.6279819011688232,
0.2296445518732071,
0.13175420463085175,
-0.1232607513666153,
-0.4701293110847473,
0.24574466049671173,
0.6354612112045288,
-0.5746760964393616,
-0.4496632218360901,
0.17065484821796417,
-0.22135937213897705,
-0.7355173826217651,
-0.09139776229858398,
-0.9288487434387207,
-0.844555675983429,
-0.5459762215614319,
0.8440588712692261,
-0.40277543663978577,
0.16771326959133148,
0.09393104165792465,
-0.22969651222229004,
0.20336014032363892,
0.18877366185188293,
-0.7768092751502991,
0.17764724791049957,
0.5790438652038574,
0.6617201566696167,
-0.3581346273422241,
-0.23976166546344757,
-0.5989366173744202,
0.010958194732666016,
-0.31127575039863586,
0.8298155069351196,
-0.5818254947662354,
-0.3489363193511963,
-0.15479327738285065,
0.33542850613594055,
-0.06592971831560135,
-0.775230884552002,
0.7941921353340149,
0.06636723130941391,
0.5928875207901001,
-0.1895292103290558,
-0.48723945021629333,
-0.10867124795913696,
0.18206897377967834,
-0.6436855792999268,
1.047502040863037,
0.28018587827682495,
-0.6865186095237732,
0.26197636127471924,
-0.3269434869289398,
-0.5008949041366577,
0.23710021376609802,
-0.37265744805336,
-0.5339358448982239,
0.47687387466430664,
0.35650634765625,
0.4197944700717926,
-0.12328966706991196,
0.5832877159118652,
-0.18514400720596313,
-0.5417205691337585,
0.12321750819683075,
-0.6143778562545776,
0.489084929227829,
0.19887325167655945,
-0.4487226903438568,
0.37715357542037964,
-0.986035943031311,
-0.23535630106925964,
0.05796976760029793,
-0.019871696829795837,
-0.15058889985084534,
-0.07434261590242386,
0.027151046320796013,
0.037820249795913696,
0.1620807945728302,
-0.22802825272083282,
0.08923029899597168,
-0.5928422212600708,
0.379722535610199,
0.8805436491966248,
0.3439674377441406,
0.17558223009109497,
-0.43876808881759644,
0.4459872245788574,
-0.152411550283432,
0.03074292652308941,
-0.24007007479667664,
-0.5792403221130371,
-0.8007304668426514,
-0.18830326199531555,
0.03406986594200134,
0.5237458348274231,
-0.9140843152999878,
0.6863788962364197,
-0.13759759068489075,
-0.3439023494720459,
-0.629080057144165,
0.0821726843714714,
-0.16267621517181396,
0.49700960516929626,
0.4948998987674713,
-0.03953169658780098,
-1.032001256942749,
-1.0656781196594238,
-0.19247967004776,
0.08892995864152908,
-0.1557205617427826,
0.2571255564689636,
0.5401846766471863,
-0.68310546875,
0.4825502038002014,
-0.29490581154823303,
-0.6121042966842651,
-0.24338282644748688,
0.3080829381942749,
0.0780177116394043,
0.3500504195690155,
0.09963908046483994,
-0.5836531519889832,
-0.02463201992213726,
-0.057843275368213654,
-0.9951441884040833,
-0.7050022482872009,
-0.2469833791255951,
0.03984343260526657,
0.5386180281639099,
0.801003634929657,
-0.35525211691856384,
0.41328611969947815,
0.4154910147190094,
-0.05319388210773468,
0.48799964785575867,
-0.09359468519687653,
0.3425884544849396,
-1.2502691745758057,
-0.31902071833610535,
-0.40308481454849243,
-0.15593427419662476,
-0.8378090262413025,
-0.21193264424800873,
-0.1712035834789276,
-0.05915313586592674,
-0.22840969264507294,
0.3629445731639862,
-0.317324697971344,
0.12047789990901947,
-0.4675259590148926,
0.08221584558486938,
-0.06925268471240997,
0.47701379656791687,
0.21320129930973053,
0.7333407998085022,
0.1973532885313034,
-0.47884413599967957,
0.3282613158226013,
0.06969005614519119,
-0.16260434687137604,
0.29430314898490906,
-0.3901752829551697,
0.36703234910964966,
-0.029665842652320862,
0.05346312373876572,
-1.0278385877609253,
-0.7142139673233032,
0.44074347615242004,
-0.5425230860710144,
0.04151858761906624,
0.21208447217941284,
-0.48158782720565796,
-0.39011189341545105,
-0.38505324721336365,
0.17417874932289124,
0.35983866453170776,
-0.505955696105957,
0.8873818516731262,
0.41998589038848877,
0.18651755154132843,
-0.4078209102153778,
-0.7926304936408997,
0.4346230924129486,
-0.3777848780155182,
-0.5730724930763245,
0.3965820372104645,
0.19830381870269775,
-0.273021936416626,
-0.2473902404308319,
-0.22895397245883942,
0.13609646260738373,
0.09448204189538956,
0.41785627603530884,
0.21154113113880157,
-0.07447431236505508,
0.04606180265545845,
0.059805504977703094,
-0.08404716849327087,
0.2795671820640564,
-0.2637677788734436,
0.8538751006126404,
0.06730440258979797,
-0.4064590036869049,
-0.4400244355201721,
0.08190037310123444,
0.5608701705932617,
0.2155834287405014,
0.5577105283737183,
0.6700667142868042,
-0.8608863949775696,
-0.42528894543647766,
-0.7189309597015381,
-0.6380138397216797,
-0.5167495608329773,
0.29953497648239136,
-0.4030890464782715,
-0.8150920271873474,
0.5243508815765381,
0.12992660701274872,
-0.1491919755935669,
0.39371058344841003,
0.6726678013801575,
-0.015507528558373451,
1.078848958015442,
0.13950370252132416,
0.2106315940618515,
0.034134943038225174,
-0.06821000576019287,
0.5095164179801941,
-0.5154514312744141,
-0.3921259343624115,
-0.44794321060180664,
-0.29219675064086914,
-0.6600512862205505,
-0.6384157538414001,
0.26233381032943726,
-0.1420009583234787,
0.3269973397254944,
0.5074368715286255,
-0.7137147784233093,
0.3903158903121948,
0.48750829696655273,
0.02233104594051838,
0.3066368103027344,
-0.0006133623537607491,
-0.06935258954763412,
-0.3052615523338318,
-0.411978155374527,
-0.5991600155830383,
0.8762953281402588,
0.13076424598693848,
0.5601599812507629,
-0.2542915940284729,
0.9529001116752625,
0.503505289554596,
0.06062938645482063,
-0.7788590788841248,
0.696410059928894,
0.010542573407292366,
-0.4213239848613739,
-0.3324262201786041,
-0.32743924856185913,
-0.7325108051300049,
0.41211503744125366,
-0.21424229443073273,
-0.6464982628822327,
0.21795468032360077,
-0.23463313281536102,
-0.08996347337961197,
0.11619274318218231,
-0.5202511548995972,
0.6244124174118042,
-0.22354361414909363,
-0.3088371455669403,
-0.0579206682741642,
-0.4041946828365326,
0.591638445854187,
-0.4147621989250183,
0.19598309695720673,
0.12939129769802094,
0.11328312009572983,
0.6772730350494385,
-0.46425750851631165,
0.7617090940475464,
-0.07959842681884766,
-0.27398794889450073,
0.3380022644996643,
0.1255761682987213,
0.6105851531028748,
0.11876863986253738,
-0.13238243758678436,
0.031156467273831367,
-0.1150551587343216,
0.02171461097896099,
-0.6289957165718079,
0.6690673828125,
-0.3746167719364166,
-0.7485345602035522,
-0.5189079642295837,
-0.496967077255249,
-0.38521847128868103,
-0.05040501803159714,
0.5974757075309753,
0.29057812690734863,
0.02012280561029911,
0.31786417961120605,
0.48783522844314575,
-0.2959868907928467,
0.23673798143863678,
-0.06278123706579208,
-0.2967955768108368,
-0.699728786945343,
0.996876060962677,
0.03304503113031387,
-0.09893310815095901,
-0.008132329210639,
0.1099986806511879,
-0.5820252299308777,
-0.6711354851722717,
-0.23231972754001617,
0.16851459443569183,
-0.6251999735832214,
-0.23496386408805847,
-0.9519607424736023,
-0.6351311206817627,
-0.603397786617279,
-0.2711733877658844,
-0.19006182253360748,
-0.41073599457740784,
-0.477883517742157,
-0.31104975938796997,
0.10394071787595749,
0.7497599124908447,
-0.21869586408138275,
0.3403190076351166,
-0.7669810652732849,
0.3976065218448639,
0.33668190240859985,
-0.12404593080282211,
-0.24459698796272278,
-0.7355429530143738,
0.047760769724845886,
-0.004127544350922108,
-0.319612056016922,
-1.0233004093170166,
0.8517447113990784,
-0.02302894927561283,
0.5966756939888,
0.3871590197086334,
0.03618777170777321,
0.8884445428848267,
-0.2609993517398834,
0.7922460436820984,
-0.08931998163461685,
-0.8834323287010193,
0.8625792264938354,
-0.2278188318014145,
0.006019801367074251,
0.7637848258018494,
0.1794857680797577,
-0.46139419078826904,
-0.7304546236991882,
-0.5722522139549255,
-0.7602128386497498,
0.5622081160545349,
0.5426207184791565,
0.30545538663864136,
-0.3040916323661804,
0.29060015082359314,
0.36714667081832886,
0.2747175097465515,
-0.8485340476036072,
0.21219947934150696,
-0.04198743775486946,
-0.4186626970767975,
0.15683116018772125,
-0.2776792347431183,
0.17291449010372162,
-0.2111234962940216,
0.7295634150505066,
-0.05650012195110321,
0.033844973891973495,
0.3515859842300415,
-0.30973076820373535,
0.0013468693941831589,
0.14411582052707672,
0.7648541927337646,
0.4367642402648926,
-0.2920718789100647,
0.2757602632045746,
0.5754976272583008,
-0.46854615211486816,
0.027032766491174698,
-0.13404573500156403,
0.03937834873795509,
0.23077021539211273,
0.6956425905227661,
0.8379579186439514,
0.08902519196271896,
-0.8042147159576416,
0.24650943279266357,
0.014176242984831333,
-0.6482120752334595,
-0.39211007952690125,
0.2778242230415344,
-0.19141744077205658,
0.22212065756320953,
0.45704925060272217,
0.033103734254837036,
0.3802366256713867,
-0.5524560213088989,
0.7911020517349243,
0.2753734886646271,
-0.6603220701217651,
-0.34174177050590515,
0.7552129030227661,
-0.08226945251226425,
-0.6304779648780823,
0.674085795879364,
-0.2893252372741699,
-0.7486192584037781,
0.45077836513519287,
0.5251376032829285,
0.9875165224075317,
-0.31083372235298157,
0.0939701572060585,
0.389507532119751,
0.4875759184360504,
-0.032305117696523666,
0.3673011362552643,
0.00979702454060316,
-0.7249553799629211,
-0.1869920790195465,
-0.6910064220428467,
-0.05681257322430611,
0.7288905382156372,
-0.4363352358341217,
0.7069687247276306,
-0.16433104872703552,
-0.08732379972934723,
-0.16667582094669342,
-0.07507877796888351,
-0.24708858132362366,
0.11041006445884705,
0.3377000093460083,
0.36084237694740295,
-1.0100438594818115,
0.7128760814666748,
0.26588454842567444,
-0.12598870694637299,
-0.42484480142593384,
-0.014462027698755264,
0.16016589105129242,
-0.6986232995986938,
0.3177720904350281,
0.5320591330528259,
-0.16997218132019043,
0.022579634562134743,
-0.5612562894821167,
-0.2130148708820343,
0.985205352306366,
0.07226923108100891,
-0.6983028650283813,
-0.21587790548801422,
0.3148162364959717,
0.6189426779747009,
-0.387636661529541,
-0.0964752733707428,
0.7724074125289917,
0.6861622929573059,
0.2921608090400696,
-0.58065265417099,
-0.02735177055001259,
-0.13363106548786163,
-0.17075838148593903,
0.09539952129125595,
0.06419779360294342,
0.5015217065811157,
-0.043977897614240646,
-0.2571699321269989,
-0.035143136978149414,
0.6696226596832275,
0.6187009215354919,
0.6335898041725159,
0.7241815328598022,
0.7666208148002625,
0.908646285533905,
-0.1321684569120407,
0.6751005053520203,
-0.2436549812555313,
-0.1499074399471283,
1.3183659315109253,
-0.4217062294483185,
0.5223256349563599,
0.6924682259559631,
0.12187417596578598,
0.046399038285017014,
0.830065131187439,
-0.33651015162467957,
0.5144597887992859,
0.4266721308231354,
-0.1623743623495102,
-0.3339960277080536,
-0.2623603045940399,
-0.358318567276001,
0.5885506868362427,
0.5461028814315796,
-0.4006980359554291,
0.0014669696101918817,
0.3932146728038788,
-0.3384558856487274,
0.1709069311618805,
0.0957997664809227,
0.8899000287055969,
0.1779903620481491,
-0.6920276880264282,
0.429229736328125,
-0.05123968422412872,
0.7354527711868286,
-0.1962490677833557,
-0.2599119544029236,
-0.38347914814949036,
-0.06237611919641495,
-0.15069806575775146,
-0.4637316167354584,
0.7072404623031616,
-0.2192019373178482,
0.2908026874065399,
-0.12198431044816971,
0.9438742399215698,
-0.3647041916847229,
-0.5879514813423157,
0.2957325577735901,
0.5101971626281738,
0.2697755992412567,
-0.2982341945171356,
-0.3211461007595062,
0.19517715275287628,
0.2133994996547699,
-0.03297842666506767,
-0.038022302091121674,
0.6806596517562866,
-0.2776910960674286,
0.6018527150154114,
0.5749224424362183,
0.1032692939043045,
0.23739711940288544,
0.5033502578735352,
0.6704582571983337,
-0.5753023624420166,
-0.2357524037361145,
-1.0292474031448364,
0.2269083857536316,
-0.16421349346637726,
-0.019603844732046127,
0.5997908115386963,
0.6974700689315796,
0.6624467968940735,
-0.24021117389202118,
0.5966728329658508,
0.1256553828716278,
0.11844293773174286,
-0.6455248594284058,
0.6302818655967712,
-0.707771360874176,
0.43780258297920227,
-0.16178813576698303,
-1.0463309288024902,
-0.3044924736022949,
0.826389729976654,
-0.07849804311990738,
-0.09215422719717026,
0.8655456304550171,
1.206652283668518,
0.1229490414261818,
0.37795311212539673,
0.4785005748271942,
0.15177643299102783,
0.09151101857423782,
0.4149723947048187,
1.2029601335525513,
-0.5671899318695068,
0.3772737681865692,
-0.33644792437553406,
0.3214193880558014,
-0.22668522596359253,
-0.5884569883346558,
-1.0180727243423462,
-1.0922869443893433,
-0.3491947650909424,
-0.39430907368659973,
0.052343662828207016,
0.88604336977005,
0.47876831889152527,
-1.1104469299316406,
-0.03934172913432121,
-0.5022957921028137,
0.06341826915740967,
0.16288547217845917,
-0.30571433901786804,
0.15329070389270782,
-0.6082828640937805,
-0.8305901885032654,
0.6168020963668823,
0.43827131390571594,
0.2625637948513031,
-0.24332450330257416,
0.05516332387924194,
-0.09083663672208786,
0.35206541419029236,
0.5109109282493591,
-0.578369677066803,
-0.8140401840209961,
-0.3329664468765259,
0.11378610879182816,
-0.07185348868370056,
0.009382064454257488,
0.7656745314598083,
-0.7412538528442383,
0.3271331191062927,
0.737819492816925,
0.7117234468460083,
0.33879151940345764,
0.08947448432445526,
0.5845867395401001,
-0.6362271308898926,
0.02312495745718479,
0.5607336163520813,
0.20551058650016785,
0.21260973811149597,
-0.5410534739494324,
0.8636873960494995,
0.4922926425933838,
-0.4588537812232971,
-1.3637983798980713,
-0.1204429641366005,
-0.7788561582565308,
-0.48943495750427246,
0.8000078201293945,
0.633955717086792,
-0.3113248944282532,
-0.3666146695613861,
-0.3867245316505432,
0.29145556688308716,
0.04200342297554016,
1.0940008163452148,
0.992434561252594,
-0.05527789890766144,
-0.35180991888046265,
-0.7764051556587219,
0.7876107692718506,
0.4322294592857361,
-1.0211001634597778,
0.04287536442279816,
0.6538237929344177,
-0.24080021679401398,
0.14194950461387634,
0.6116078495979309,
-0.1564175933599472,
-0.023053450509905815,
-0.044419001787900925,
-0.08748595416545868,
-0.060403451323509216,
-0.6117351055145264,
-0.4500155448913574,
0.1766902655363083,
-0.4131818413734436,
-0.20221765339374542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00953v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00953v1
|
AutoRD: An Automatic and End-to-End System for Rare Disease Knowledge Graph Construction Based on Ontologies-enhanced Large Language Models
| 2024-03-01T20:06:39 | 2024-03-01T20:06:39 |
Lang Cao, Jimeng Sun, Adam Cross
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Objectives: Our objective is to create an end-to-end system called AutoRD,
which automates extracting information from clinical text about rare diseases.
We have conducted various tests to evaluate the performance of AutoRD and
highlighted its strengths and limitations in this paper.
Materials and Methods: Our system, AutoRD, is a software pipeline involving
data preprocessing, entity extraction, relation extraction, entity calibration,
and knowledge graph construction. We implement this using large language models
and medical knowledge graphs developed from open-source medical ontologies. We
quantitatively evaluate our system on entity extraction, relation extraction,
and the performance of knowledge graph construction.
Results: AutoRD achieves an overall F1 score of 47.3%, a 14.4% improvement
compared to the base LLM. In detail, AutoRD achieves an overall entity
extraction F1 score of 56.1% (rare_disease: 83.5%, disease: 35.8%,
symptom_and_sign: 46.1%, anaphor: 67.5%) and an overall relation extraction F1
score of 38.6% (produces: 34.7%, increases_risk_of: 12.4%, is_a: 37.4%,
is_acronym: 44.1%, is_synonym: 16.3%, anaphora: 57.5%). Our qualitative
experiment also demonstrates that the performance in constructing the knowledge
graph is commendable.
Discussion: AutoRD demonstrates the potential of LLM applications in rare
disease detection. This improvement is attributed to several design, including
the integration of ontologies-enhanced LLMs.
Conclusion: AutoRD is an automated end-to-end system for extracting rare
disease information from text to build knowledge graphs. It uses
ontologies-enhanced LLMs for a robust medical knowledge base. The superior
performance of AutoRD is validated by experimental evaluations, demonstrating
the potential of LLMs in healthcare.
|
[
-0.3028573989868164,
-0.7950443625450134,
0.411527156829834,
-0.43717408180236816,
-0.2888938784599304,
0.2210894525051117,
0.12379610538482666,
-0.607520580291748,
0.5512937903404236,
0.47992849349975586,
-0.22426317632198334,
-0.6896753311157227,
-0.7191773653030396,
0.3459855914115906,
-0.4194895625114441,
0.9947527050971985,
0.0441078245639801,
0.19766658544540405,
-0.011304778046905994,
-0.1753486543893814,
0.04925301671028137,
-0.4203580915927887,
-0.470186710357666,
-0.2978014051914215,
0.2054193615913391,
0.6071186065673828,
0.9731042385101318,
0.884666919708252,
0.7510629296302795,
0.2645706534385681,
0.04295323044061661,
0.1765626072883606,
-0.6856319308280945,
0.3745731711387634,
-0.02182924933731556,
0.03747024014592171,
-1.0610395669937134,
-0.16546131670475006,
0.27353331446647644,
0.7787171602249146,
-0.1242169663310051,
-0.10710350424051285,
0.008113833144307137,
0.7251827120780945,
-0.15254035592079163,
0.13775667548179626,
-0.2702612578868866,
0.41813260316848755,
-0.35576218366622925,
-0.24489489197731018,
0.10417033731937408,
-0.23962032794952393,
0.30631178617477417,
-0.7677204608917236,
0.03145657852292061,
0.27407732605934143,
0.79750657081604,
0.4397457540035248,
-0.47571253776550293,
-0.5305933356285095,
-0.514092743396759,
0.33373749256134033,
-0.6414048075675964,
0.30767181515693665,
0.20567192137241364,
0.4863458573818207,
-0.18662723898887634,
-1.1356561183929443,
-0.4725308418273926,
-0.13611827790737152,
-0.097050741314888,
0.24874798953533173,
-0.4154142737388611,
0.30265066027641296,
0.18673382699489594,
0.7633740901947021,
-0.9189004302024841,
0.28548696637153625,
-0.2956424057483673,
-0.2632575035095215,
0.622742235660553,
0.6235225796699524,
0.4142773747444153,
-0.44467148184776306,
-0.400164932012558,
0.25978419184684753,
-0.6621313095092773,
-0.5404645800590515,
0.09920896589756012,
-0.07860002666711807,
0.04743274673819542,
0.8083324432373047,
-0.6083347201347351,
1.1193734407424927,
0.041928187012672424,
-0.00984992366284132,
0.5210859179496765,
-0.4724917709827423,
-0.23890775442123413,
0.026178652420639992,
0.8885593414306641,
0.38688188791275024,
0.30465835332870483,
-0.33044981956481934,
-0.1431465446949005,
-0.13493363559246063,
-0.06384976953268051,
-0.5540719628334045,
-0.6263877153396606,
0.21915853023529053,
-0.8310075998306274,
-0.4429008662700653,
-0.36757057905197144,
-0.785548746585846,
-0.23794956505298615,
0.0805421993136406,
0.3666107952594757,
-0.5504857301712036,
-0.1610991656780243,
-0.052105486392974854,
-0.13661575317382812,
0.05179637670516968,
0.46672406792640686,
-0.4568749964237213,
0.4569147229194641,
0.132572740316391,
0.6845914125442505,
-0.7221381664276123,
-0.03348417207598686,
-0.5216196179389954,
0.33593523502349854,
-0.03290276601910591,
1.055548071861267,
-0.48239314556121826,
-0.5521655082702637,
-0.49648845195770264,
0.08865334838628769,
0.05706537887454033,
-0.4557836949825287,
0.1763889193534851,
-0.4852164089679718,
0.1564839780330658,
-0.04454372823238373,
-0.7825050354003906,
0.06498714536428452,
0.12553070485591888,
-0.8426944017410278,
0.6899868249893188,
0.43438243865966797,
-0.656408429145813,
0.37806880474090576,
-0.5189341902732849,
-0.5397042036056519,
0.4743797183036804,
-0.42788246273994446,
-0.0012557122390717268,
-0.28045740723609924,
0.10159670561552048,
0.3407363295555115,
-0.6525576114654541,
0.027090858668088913,
-0.33910471200942993,
0.09579205513000488,
-0.03745843470096588,
-0.3152470290660858,
0.6505967974662781,
0.5771887898445129,
-0.3314632177352905,
-0.3631952404975891,
-0.8988585472106934,
0.28561490774154663,
0.20626020431518555,
-0.23285408318042755,
-0.35677510499954224,
-0.2870636582374573,
-0.1701764464378357,
0.280909925699234,
0.4019376337528229,
-0.47744548320770264,
0.3246159851551056,
-0.7408134937286377,
0.14239080250263214,
0.422952264547348,
0.13334937393665314,
0.2784405052661896,
-0.4505082666873932,
0.7382524013519287,
-0.07157021760940552,
0.3230646848678589,
0.05299438163638115,
-0.8048200011253357,
-0.4562761187553406,
-0.1972629576921463,
0.5374294519424438,
0.6731182336807251,
-0.5323910117149353,
0.8750940561294556,
-0.29984375834465027,
-0.21083945035934448,
-0.3693092465400696,
0.11936644464731216,
0.4526926577091217,
0.8507493734359741,
0.355832040309906,
-0.8189583420753479,
-0.3802016079425812,
-0.5343236923217773,
-0.04292750358581543,
-0.16605286300182343,
0.34366780519485474,
0.5254523158073425,
0.36276358366012573,
-0.40330541133880615,
1.002941370010376,
-0.8706998825073242,
-0.7403059601783752,
-0.1925177127122879,
-0.11878267675638199,
0.08440373837947845,
0.3619033992290497,
0.48045244812965393,
-0.421774685382843,
-0.7587315440177917,
0.27843132615089417,
-1.0847870111465454,
-0.3015943467617035,
0.5869849920272827,
0.19183824956417084,
0.3394108712673187,
0.47731706500053406,
-0.532332718372345,
0.6277817487716675,
0.5247003436088562,
-0.4737105071544647,
0.46362408995628357,
-0.5415160655975342,
0.09548944979906082,
-0.800321638584137,
0.3327568471431732,
-0.5180065035820007,
-0.5326413512229919,
-0.37957727909088135,
-0.19857262074947357,
-0.32044345140457153,
-0.008731626905500889,
-0.0016429995885118842,
0.6480923295021057,
-0.6500056982040405,
-0.07833641022443771,
-0.20128878951072693,
0.2006932646036148,
0.1554669439792633,
-0.08310280740261078,
-0.14499177038669586,
0.25020459294319153,
0.5534749627113342,
-0.4307589828968048,
0.6355093717575073,
0.25265783071517944,
-0.2570256292819977,
0.579460620880127,
-0.7186682820320129,
-0.1553783267736435,
0.2456209361553192,
0.2131481021642685,
-1.151549220085144,
-0.2688467800617218,
0.23602105677127838,
-0.7216925024986267,
0.5409192442893982,
-0.03741873800754547,
-0.6028262376785278,
-0.6595678925514221,
0.2502354085445404,
0.12953810393810272,
0.46768391132354736,
-0.048948436975479126,
0.45876190066337585,
0.8714885115623474,
-0.34907618165016174,
-0.5133659243583679,
-0.8190804123878479,
0.23962873220443726,
0.06961673498153687,
-0.5847118496894836,
0.15243734419345856,
-0.08758877217769623,
-0.28273338079452515,
0.5300984382629395,
0.023659899830818176,
-0.4106394350528717,
-0.025564778596162796,
0.01920546218752861,
-0.048147596418857574,
-0.13840429484844208,
0.3268773555755615,
0.15464933216571808,
-0.39088672399520874,
-0.19892102479934692,
-0.2647632658481598,
0.49742603302001953,
-0.11788808554410934,
-0.5777242183685303,
-0.2345825433731079,
0.3012765645980835,
0.51676344871521,
-0.03223605081439018,
0.14673185348510742,
0.2171233892440796,
-0.33797383308410645,
-0.0338183268904686,
-0.48020678758621216,
-0.07186185568571091,
-0.42289942502975464,
0.32612156867980957,
-0.22336958348751068,
-0.7040538787841797,
0.6892970204353333,
-0.09403117746114731,
-0.09361725300550461,
0.8352574110031128,
0.5147103071212769,
-0.10591559112071991,
0.8909737467765808,
0.5145077109336853,
-0.038041964173316956,
-0.24085918068885803,
-0.23262768983840942,
0.022002998739480972,
-0.5059940814971924,
-0.24550853669643402,
-0.301396906375885,
-0.11619098484516144,
-0.4290563464164734,
-0.5970993638038635,
0.5766375064849854,
-0.007248724810779095,
-0.01732066459953785,
0.001977217383682728,
-0.7971265912055969,
0.06468674540519714,
0.020002061501145363,
0.08642082661390305,
0.8151172399520874,
0.03262367472052574,
-0.3217049837112427,
-0.1102706640958786,
-1.0524547100067139,
-0.3570866286754608,
1.7003535032272339,
0.20237421989440918,
0.9392839670181274,
0.015762751922011375,
0.7908098697662354,
0.567121684551239,
0.5088356733322144,
-0.7005816102027893,
0.28343403339385986,
-0.44489267468452454,
-0.7882164716720581,
-0.5863525867462158,
-0.4603624939918518,
-1.1520336866378784,
-0.04261293262243271,
-0.07120884954929352,
-0.46363991498947144,
0.28159603476524353,
0.2159471958875656,
-0.5723883509635925,
0.16345830261707306,
-0.4815223217010498,
0.6833691596984863,
-0.5786815285682678,
0.04054049402475357,
-0.09457593411207199,
-0.8822983503341675,
0.26928848028182983,
-0.41773632168769836,
0.32054078578948975,
0.20623807609081268,
-0.08195251226425171,
0.7773215174674988,
-1.011849284172058,
0.7035605907440186,
0.023137837648391724,
-0.07389244437217712,
0.11988364905118942,
-0.0354238823056221,
0.6387165784835815,
0.14730092883110046,
-0.1766480803489685,
0.24951428174972534,
-0.05239913612604141,
-0.01300048641860485,
-0.46749189496040344,
0.8260358572006226,
-0.7512392401695251,
-0.4198743402957916,
-0.6342897415161133,
-0.5320062637329102,
-0.08115313947200775,
0.5851611495018005,
0.3454948365688324,
0.6059132814407349,
-0.5982936024665833,
-0.19964230060577393,
0.7478278875350952,
-0.318927526473999,
0.0548400804400444,
0.8544061183929443,
-0.2106548547744751,
-0.6376160383224487,
0.8725964426994324,
0.38713860511779785,
0.4559744596481323,
0.27603527903556824,
0.12846045196056366,
-0.12335020303726196,
-0.44913050532341003,
-0.6711583137512207,
0.11020133644342422,
-0.997912585735321,
-0.3067498505115509,
-1.2820619344711304,
-0.31872695684432983,
-0.7506768703460693,
0.08064837753772736,
-0.36517369747161865,
-0.798803448677063,
-0.46587690711021423,
0.1226361095905304,
0.7018754482269287,
0.9955185055732727,
-0.4513203799724579,
0.012379416264593601,
-0.651119589805603,
0.5122795701026917,
0.21167200803756714,
0.16020365059375763,
-0.0936744436621666,
-0.6608190536499023,
-0.07750565558671951,
-0.2197515219449997,
-0.06110202148556709,
-0.882063090801239,
0.6764518022537231,
0.3478144705295563,
0.9206312298774719,
0.5329160094261169,
0.25161197781562805,
0.7448968291282654,
-0.3172869384288788,
0.4637738764286041,
0.20807161927223206,
-0.6236114501953125,
0.36180374026298523,
-0.17448052763938904,
0.19891148805618286,
0.5718382596969604,
0.45892876386642456,
-0.2240866869688034,
-0.4057275354862213,
-0.9630846977233887,
-1.0081701278686523,
0.5534412264823914,
0.0671302080154419,
-0.5472438335418701,
-0.06048079580068588,
0.2718578279018402,
0.13483168184757233,
0.10008736699819565,
-0.4277670681476593,
-0.8684694766998291,
-0.06137511879205704,
-0.16787207126617432,
-0.0731392502784729,
-0.20964014530181885,
-0.4190959334373474,
-0.3368971049785614,
0.27516815066337585,
-0.11781470477581024,
0.26165303587913513,
0.5673686861991882,
-0.4038795530796051,
-0.4008476734161377,
-0.06814552843570709,
0.0035805855877697468,
0.5724346041679382,
-0.07549768686294556,
0.03079415112733841,
0.3042633831501007,
-0.6181442737579346,
-0.10355185717344284,
0.6194573044776917,
0.04104327782988548,
0.1588183045387268,
0.2980009913444519,
0.30110272765159607,
0.08619621396064758,
-0.6359714269638062,
0.7263550758361816,
-0.08016566932201385,
-0.06789494305849075,
-0.3609728217124939,
0.0006868482450954616,
-0.026219969615340233,
0.052220579236745834,
0.4074677526950836,
-0.15591756999492645,
0.3145008385181427,
-0.2055312693119049,
0.7292554378509521,
0.5357279777526855,
-0.560961127281189,
-0.1365533471107483,
0.6187770962715149,
0.26365789771080017,
0.023560330271720886,
0.4681423306465149,
-0.3905045688152313,
-0.20431794226169586,
0.8124710321426392,
0.44849827885627747,
0.4794219434261322,
-0.2923157215118408,
-0.0016308506019413471,
0.037186987698078156,
0.4370152950286865,
0.16018159687519073,
0.5033014416694641,
0.1139821708202362,
-0.35996291041374207,
-0.36604705452919006,
-0.6670889854431152,
-0.2272547036409378,
-0.08884484320878983,
-0.4060281813144684,
0.3460730016231537,
-0.033417098224163055,
-0.12163429707288742,
0.012579287402331829,
0.016028784215450287,
-0.6002284288406372,
0.48906224966049194,
-0.2067055106163025,
0.7943914532661438,
-0.5434858798980713,
0.989483654499054,
0.7568411827087402,
-0.3908224403858185,
-0.6754959225654602,
-0.13270996510982513,
0.05016402527689934,
-0.997316300868988,
1.0740715265274048,
-0.3604179322719574,
0.11133809387683868,
0.5516545176506042,
-0.1934814453125,
-1.3734570741653442,
1.2108803987503052,
-0.07621721923351288,
-0.6239494681358337,
-0.1482669860124588,
0.12571291625499725,
0.7074565887451172,
-0.44402775168418884,
0.5279994606971741,
0.3745608627796173,
0.5682205557823181,
0.07818952202796936,
-1.3346837759017944,
0.19789808988571167,
-0.17759492993354797,
-0.5569123029708862,
0.13904666900634766,
-0.5049614310264587,
0.7187064290046692,
-0.4263592064380646,
-0.20150594413280487,
0.18617968261241913,
0.31910866498947144,
-0.007576120551675558,
0.2685084342956543,
0.3545168340206146,
1.0478161573410034,
0.9413241147994995,
0.06734716147184372,
1.002227783203125,
-0.7797071933746338,
0.319025456905365,
0.7464763522148132,
-0.47594282031059265,
0.11699001491069794,
-0.02257530391216278,
-0.041148267686367035,
0.47129979729652405,
0.3487441837787628,
0.10922476649284363,
0.5649338364601135,
0.25094544887542725,
-0.0019198826048523188,
-0.2850516438484192,
0.12362704426050186,
-0.7868958115577698,
0.42101815342903137,
0.7014167308807373,
-0.6659000515937805,
-0.48141518235206604,
0.03434948995709419,
-0.10318221151828766,
-0.4184523820877075,
0.07836951315402985,
0.7556173205375671,
0.21335600316524506,
-0.3609229028224945,
0.8019613027572632,
-0.371940016746521,
0.198395237326622,
-0.6531587243080139,
-0.09598195552825928,
-0.09712249040603638,
0.15561777353286743,
-0.3692144453525543,
-0.8524447679519653,
0.3354044258594513,
-0.11618984490633011,
-0.22038599848747253,
0.06754429638385773,
1.0305991172790527,
-0.2155507355928421,
-0.3163631856441498,
0.4206438958644867,
0.9596020579338074,
0.6260021328926086,
0.43190088868141174,
-0.768101155757904,
-0.10799507051706314,
-0.11286631226539612,
-0.366216242313385,
0.42351603507995605,
0.8476258516311646,
-0.12175323814153671,
0.6678435802459717,
0.5939300656318665,
0.48686304688453674,
-0.34796205163002014,
-0.1400177925825119,
1.0575567483901978,
-0.8069503307342529,
-0.3884117305278778,
-0.5328782200813293,
0.015147545374929905,
-0.15046639740467072,
-0.5285259485244751,
0.7742376923561096,
0.7121309041976929,
0.46069201827049255,
0.3821641802787781,
1.1096025705337524,
-0.44197362661361694,
0.6574101448059082,
-0.18265341222286224,
1.2005964517593384,
-0.7196174263954163,
0.31716856360435486,
-0.42340731620788574,
-0.4217630624771118,
-0.5707380175590515,
0.449735552072525,
-0.18692944943904877,
0.07043725997209549,
0.9922177195549011,
0.6492018699645996,
0.05365479364991188,
-0.1814357340335846,
0.46264147758483887,
0.508405864238739,
0.1572292298078537,
0.5964098572731018,
0.42551159858703613,
-0.3402416706085205,
0.847844123840332,
-0.007616425398737192,
-0.6216371655464172,
-0.3590751588344574,
-0.7131205797195435,
-0.47991493344306946,
-0.233366921544075,
-0.29790711402893066,
-0.6089909076690674,
0.5287060141563416,
0.5359833240509033,
0.452631413936615,
-0.630584716796875,
-0.16233891248703003,
-0.13048899173736572,
0.07193265855312347,
-0.04621998220682144,
-0.20499975979328156,
0.5427783131599426,
-0.23370784521102905,
-0.3626178801059723,
0.5093257427215576,
0.49744391441345215,
-0.07057034224271774,
-0.2751557528972626,
-0.17966799437999725,
-0.07096824049949646,
-0.6082206964492798,
0.45133423805236816,
0.5717988014221191,
-0.3910709619522095,
0.12381041049957275,
0.07587571442127228,
-0.429646760225296,
0.09661692380905151,
0.5167787075042725,
-1.0000159740447998,
0.8249849081039429,
0.6006149649620056,
0.24909864366054535,
0.3935639560222626,
-0.06795726716518402,
0.8173880577087402,
0.06726349145174026,
-0.249994695186615,
0.5522884726524353,
0.2708999216556549,
0.10291291773319244,
-0.5196244120597839,
0.457349568605423,
0.6707842350006104,
-0.8503574132919312,
-0.7280834317207336,
0.17474736273288727,
-0.8576254844665527,
-0.3020809590816498,
1.4766902923583984,
-0.12373935431241989,
-0.1272275596857071,
-1.019544005393982,
0.16069301962852478,
0.4521571099758148,
-0.3025992512702942,
0.7231721878051758,
0.11766668409109116,
-0.6367140412330627,
0.3277490437030792,
-0.534210205078125,
0.6626291871070862,
0.34739041328430176,
-0.8770942091941833,
-0.12792682647705078,
0.5597931742668152,
0.5136404633522034,
-0.1106722429394722,
1.1970224380493164,
-0.6245877742767334,
0.41841667890548706,
-0.3719770610332489,
0.24916566908359528,
-0.02001456916332245,
0.019978562369942665,
-0.3382627069950104,
0.03655378893017769,
-0.01817907579243183,
0.3232586979866028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00952v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00952v1
|
MediSwift: Efficient Sparse Pre-trained Biomedical Language Models
| 2024-03-01T20:03:44 | 2024-03-01T20:03:44 |
Vithursan Thangarasa, Mahmoud Salem, Shreyas Saxena, Kevin Leong, Joel Hestness, Sean Lie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are typically trained on general source data for
various domains, but a recent surge in domain-specific LLMs has shown their
potential to outperform general-purpose models in domain-specific tasks (e.g.,
biomedicine). Although domain-specific pre-training enhances efficiency and
leads to smaller models, the computational costs of training these LLMs remain
high, posing budgeting challenges. We introduce MediSwift, a suite of
biomedical LMs that leverage sparse pre-training on domain-specific biomedical
text data. By inducing up to 75% weight sparsity during the pre-training phase,
MediSwift achieves a 2-2.5x reduction in training FLOPs. Notably, all sparse
pre-training was performed on the Cerebras CS-2 system, which is specifically
designed to realize the acceleration benefits from unstructured weight
sparsity, thereby significantly enhancing the efficiency of the MediSwift
models. Through subsequent dense fine-tuning and strategic soft prompting,
MediSwift models outperform existing LLMs up to 7B parameters on biomedical
tasks, setting new benchmarks w.r.t efficiency-accuracy on tasks such as
PubMedQA. Our results show that sparse pre-training, along with dense
fine-tuning and soft prompting, offers an effective method for creating
high-performing, computationally efficient models in specialized domains.
|
[
-0.10540488362312317,
-0.6153871417045593,
0.7672098875045776,
0.10111437737941742,
-0.29949629306793213,
0.07094026356935501,
-0.4616435766220093,
-0.2900506556034088,
0.40225350856781006,
0.5954156517982483,
-0.756898045539856,
-0.4137231409549713,
-0.6714038848876953,
0.0899626687169075,
-0.3567526638507843,
1.1449155807495117,
-0.02215457893908024,
0.24490471184253693,
-0.20747558772563934,
-0.26228225231170654,
-0.07128150761127472,
-0.3654578924179077,
-0.45226892828941345,
-0.5121505856513977,
0.9233861565589905,
0.2619592845439911,
0.7517001628875732,
0.4061468541622162,
0.44412171840667725,
0.26366326212882996,
0.0874902531504631,
0.29084542393684387,
-0.6610040068626404,
0.07612726837396622,
-0.10821041464805603,
-0.17978942394256592,
-0.537373960018158,
-0.02420259825885296,
0.4585273563861847,
1.1833418607711792,
-0.19205042719841003,
0.1935892552137375,
0.14927811920642853,
0.7942306995391846,
-0.5122501850128174,
-0.22165705263614655,
-0.6136643290519714,
-0.1534431129693985,
-0.2567136883735657,
-0.1943177431821823,
-0.3133563697338104,
-0.15211087465286255,
0.1780330091714859,
-0.740750789642334,
0.13915765285491943,
-0.17092199623584747,
0.9124724268913269,
0.44731611013412476,
-0.1192655935883522,
0.11975093930959702,
-0.4470013678073883,
0.6958419680595398,
-0.43871310353279114,
0.638258695602417,
0.4301125705242157,
-0.13048921525478363,
-0.39036431908607483,
-1.1711134910583496,
-0.14608971774578094,
-0.18286627531051636,
0.07098688930273056,
0.002143512014299631,
-0.35616016387939453,
0.26768335700035095,
0.05464620888233185,
-0.09018882364034653,
-0.8171818256378174,
0.199503555893898,
-0.3457472622394562,
0.0482267290353775,
0.25395461916923523,
0.10291258990764618,
0.0383664034307003,
0.2782827913761139,
-0.08775252848863602,
-0.026789307594299316,
-0.748041033744812,
-0.20148581266403198,
-0.12019258737564087,
0.24192523956298828,
-0.10483352094888687,
0.47293999791145325,
0.07743223011493683,
0.5464854836463928,
0.14098362624645233,
-0.1551639586687088,
0.4144839346408844,
-0.09202507883310318,
-0.23148126900196075,
-0.4323994815349579,
0.618812084197998,
-0.09262268990278244,
0.4579026401042938,
-0.3422258496284485,
-0.14593687653541565,
-0.0982404574751854,
0.40416279435157776,
-1.0134944915771484,
-0.31158095598220825,
0.34669309854507446,
-0.7103351354598999,
-0.19946430623531342,
-0.7095105648040771,
-0.4188849627971649,
-0.37953945994377136,
-0.44786810874938965,
0.5008209347724915,
-0.5913630723953247,
-0.21012242138385773,
0.4246975779533386,
0.17790944874286652,
-0.27036425471305847,
0.27682480216026306,
-0.769292950630188,
0.5670532584190369,
0.3124607503414154,
0.913195013999939,
-0.38135191798210144,
-0.2215336114168167,
-0.5905918478965759,
0.19971559941768646,
-0.2090432196855545,
0.9216792583465576,
-0.3941280245780945,
-0.37382689118385315,
-0.13958129286766052,
0.031001249328255653,
-0.27144166827201843,
-0.463008314371109,
0.405285507440567,
-0.40302133560180664,
-0.22905756533145905,
-0.010563524439930916,
-0.5737450122833252,
0.3651633858680725,
-0.11026084423065186,
-0.47566258907318115,
0.8027209639549255,
0.28658851981163025,
-0.5972758531570435,
0.42809364199638367,
-0.6091017723083496,
-0.6315802931785583,
0.42607632279396057,
-0.4335577189922333,
-0.5370326042175293,
0.2351687103509903,
0.12068762630224228,
0.72585529088974,
-0.3446770906448364,
0.35690391063690186,
-0.42464062571525574,
-0.47149190306663513,
0.35388970375061035,
-0.21583683788776398,
0.48301956057548523,
0.3614124059677124,
-0.14192678034305573,
0.04508579522371292,
-0.725605309009552,
0.13824397325515747,
0.19455116987228394,
-0.3181721568107605,
-0.4307679831981659,
0.15468040108680725,
0.3867175877094269,
-0.025315824896097183,
0.12511782348155975,
-0.33968713879585266,
0.18479023873806,
-0.6899846196174622,
0.4064726233482361,
0.5030017495155334,
-0.21079353988170624,
0.44533637166023254,
-0.22873128950595856,
0.37286728620529175,
-0.2867683470249176,
0.2162049412727356,
0.18808512389659882,
-0.2910879850387573,
-0.3244239091873169,
-0.9097574353218079,
0.4610372483730316,
0.40605980157852173,
-0.6746068596839905,
0.33430323004722595,
-0.2462601512670517,
-0.4966045022010803,
-0.5125588774681091,
0.14608760178089142,
0.24795201420783997,
0.42020440101623535,
0.5695354342460632,
0.049773044884204865,
-0.20840021967887878,
-0.8297035694122314,
-0.34570860862731934,
0.19352200627326965,
-0.26798561215400696,
0.3296397030353546,
0.3992631733417511,
-0.6248803734779358,
0.7152109742164612,
-0.5269374847412109,
-0.15478087961673737,
-0.25035369396209717,
0.22673991322517395,
0.30401358008384705,
0.5966387987136841,
0.6914340257644653,
-0.696343719959259,
-0.2573961615562439,
-0.18521688878536224,
-0.18846313655376434,
-0.364473819732666,
-0.085354283452034,
-0.041055284440517426,
-0.034866683185100555,
0.530705988407135,
-0.8499654531478882,
0.22132854163646698,
0.6715694069862366,
-0.42144277691841125,
0.3526179790496826,
-0.590805172920227,
0.14164213836193085,
-0.9331699013710022,
0.33190101385116577,
-0.05775441229343414,
-0.2913672924041748,
-0.6822341680526733,
-0.37953221797943115,
0.23549510538578033,
-0.09622161090373993,
-0.22716999053955078,
0.5689184069633484,
-0.38344109058380127,
0.14767369627952576,
-0.3445119261741638,
-0.11730020493268967,
-0.011712150648236275,
0.4337122440338135,
0.19003188610076904,
0.7700092792510986,
0.3879767656326294,
-0.4412861764431,
-0.2904762327671051,
0.16700224578380585,
-0.23695075511932373,
0.1623486876487732,
-0.9316067099571228,
-0.16235744953155518,
-0.15766239166259766,
0.14194603264331818,
-0.77189701795578,
-0.14948426187038422,
-0.09214434772729874,
-0.249375581741333,
0.5631318688392639,
-0.155182883143425,
-0.5377177596092224,
-0.3622521162033081,
-0.12226207554340363,
0.43621280789375305,
0.7174726128578186,
-0.4784129858016968,
0.4935537278652191,
0.4789719879627228,
-0.3887636363506317,
-0.5120136141777039,
-0.721936047077179,
-0.16493970155715942,
0.02335161156952381,
-0.39579689502716064,
0.5230302214622498,
-0.1701265573501587,
0.1393008828163147,
-0.15141810476779938,
-0.014674575068056583,
-0.16512194275856018,
0.11285991966724396,
0.260580837726593,
0.29374462366104126,
-0.04673958942294121,
0.2707047462463379,
0.4301286041736603,
-0.21715742349624634,
-0.23706795275211334,
-0.501643180847168,
0.40848731994628906,
0.09525730460882187,
-0.4139697551727295,
-0.10198888182640076,
0.3482080399990082,
0.4864597022533417,
-0.18001201748847961,
0.7549456357955933,
0.505741536617279,
-0.4818382263183594,
-0.21504509449005127,
-0.6551088094711304,
-0.2600231468677521,
-0.5136467814445496,
0.8591564893722534,
-0.21438893675804138,
-1.0539127588272095,
0.11413345485925674,
-0.5089183449745178,
0.08683318644762039,
0.2676648199558258,
0.6498486995697021,
-0.1937410533428192,
1.3324519395828247,
0.7551844120025635,
0.1001533642411232,
0.3374752402305603,
0.013507687486708164,
-0.03332100063562393,
-0.16937723755836487,
-0.15774892270565033,
-0.7228288650512695,
-0.15823335945606232,
-0.31188321113586426,
-0.5716390013694763,
0.6011497974395752,
-0.16412794589996338,
-0.40755316615104675,
0.05427529662847519,
-0.49390891194343567,
0.48277103900909424,
0.11465369910001755,
0.217641681432724,
0.010783347301185131,
0.42965057492256165,
-0.2555687129497528,
-0.18184010684490204,
-0.9286240339279175,
-0.37158045172691345,
1.050935983657837,
0.43580880761146545,
1.0324286222457886,
-0.3675205409526825,
0.5095383524894714,
0.17799311876296997,
0.46375834941864014,
-0.5080457329750061,
0.2823876440525055,
-0.5338879823684692,
-0.1488347202539444,
-0.1153550073504448,
-0.5695607662200928,
-1.202043890953064,
0.014246721751987934,
-0.6376034617424011,
-0.5945184230804443,
0.1561686396598816,
0.2820970416069031,
-0.6061770915985107,
0.19143067300319672,
-0.5951282382011414,
0.7914445400238037,
-0.17795410752296448,
-0.38005468249320984,
-0.3686705529689789,
-0.5659827589988708,
0.12111293524503708,
-0.4123880863189697,
0.31509363651275635,
-0.08829667419195175,
-0.40513309836387634,
0.817686915397644,
-0.4530273377895355,
0.6957648992538452,
-0.18802706897258759,
0.16193489730358124,
-0.08482088148593903,
0.08079619705677032,
0.34784063696861267,
-0.038995224982500076,
0.21918094158172607,
0.36366400122642517,
0.27139294147491455,
-0.49371665716171265,
-0.25025999546051025,
0.7383206486701965,
-0.8374972939491272,
-0.053436439484357834,
-0.23012244701385498,
-0.5940559506416321,
-0.7719027996063232,
0.26517152786254883,
0.42122507095336914,
0.5318000912666321,
-0.08909343183040619,
0.1019788384437561,
1.0588594675064087,
-0.46209999918937683,
0.016071660444140434,
0.712510347366333,
0.09727079421281815,
-0.4217314124107361,
0.6698907017707825,
0.13215167820453644,
0.1538058966398239,
0.1763296276330948,
-0.030563833191990852,
-0.23860064148902893,
-0.8495849370956421,
-0.322845458984375,
0.49596765637397766,
-0.23940140008926392,
-0.5066912770271301,
-0.9576146602630615,
-0.17709079384803772,
-0.3544800281524658,
-0.40198391675949097,
-0.5293365716934204,
-0.38740870356559753,
-0.28530412912368774,
0.27461421489715576,
0.5300384163856506,
0.5588136911392212,
-0.0693383514881134,
0.45048344135284424,
-1.0433592796325684,
0.400744765996933,
-0.02898154780268669,
0.7194653153419495,
-0.3720352053642273,
-0.5675442218780518,
-0.531559944152832,
-0.12892132997512817,
-0.021130818873643875,
-0.7303335070610046,
0.38597571849823,
0.2914428412914276,
0.42245325446128845,
0.30644354224205017,
-0.3438127338886261,
0.6927725076675415,
-0.8351584672927856,
0.5189366936683655,
0.5159168243408203,
-0.5560323596000671,
0.3186214566230774,
-0.30452990531921387,
0.29327574372291565,
0.7389222979545593,
0.537621259689331,
-0.10876742005348206,
-0.29998859763145447,
-0.4772137999534607,
-0.8357394933700562,
0.4615303575992584,
0.10200563818216324,
0.019400963559746742,
-0.03366454690694809,
0.7156325578689575,
0.1664930284023285,
0.10929891467094421,
-0.42554914951324463,
-0.25164172053337097,
0.23130127787590027,
-0.6202228665351868,
-0.11467871069908142,
-0.19371676445007324,
0.008085393346846104,
-0.3532044589519501,
0.6402557492256165,
-0.34172242879867554,
0.16547851264476776,
0.19854937493801117,
-0.16437165439128876,
-0.30137360095977783,
0.044771019369363785,
0.40998074412345886,
0.31016862392425537,
-0.025056267157197,
0.026449134573340416,
0.24718286097049713,
-0.9137622714042664,
0.05958428606390953,
0.46852344274520874,
0.08885592967271805,
0.011796088889241219,
0.2823925316333771,
0.3943883180618286,
0.3946492075920105,
-1.0736169815063477,
0.7147136330604553,
-0.1974106729030609,
-0.4991450011730194,
0.06483398377895355,
-0.08242350816726685,
0.21781806647777557,
0.3307042717933655,
0.27882686257362366,
0.21776752173900604,
0.22125935554504395,
0.1642284095287323,
0.2469746321439743,
0.4844115674495697,
-0.1118190661072731,
-0.08627062290906906,
0.8129909634590149,
0.029720226302742958,
0.14258742332458496,
0.32994213700294495,
0.34183037281036377,
-0.046367015689611435,
0.2460215538740158,
0.42281317710876465,
0.6571161150932312,
-0.21024303138256073,
0.004610711708664894,
0.17013129591941833,
0.1740276962518692,
-0.23392434418201447,
0.2910420298576355,
-0.07360271364450455,
-0.4724920690059662,
-0.8872283101081848,
-0.8880810141563416,
-0.18961505591869354,
0.3232419490814209,
-0.2834324240684509,
0.2784560024738312,
-0.3479510247707367,
-0.44864553213119507,
0.11812668293714523,
0.08171162754297256,
-0.6893642544746399,
0.26649609208106995,
0.20606718957424164,
1.1753478050231934,
-0.7167428135871887,
0.9590203762054443,
0.6053886413574219,
-0.20228883624076843,
-0.7642737030982971,
-0.34766948223114014,
-0.3683231472969055,
-0.754330039024353,
0.6626226305961609,
-0.17684026062488556,
-0.2761048972606659,
-0.06775705516338348,
-0.7978609204292297,
-1.0056203603744507,
0.7862960696220398,
0.6170117259025574,
-0.8129560351371765,
-0.07449313998222351,
0.223971888422966,
0.566116213798523,
-0.12333370745182037,
0.1357409954071045,
0.5691380500793457,
0.11772991716861725,
-0.10627591609954834,
-0.8412010073661804,
-0.05092068016529083,
-0.3166750371456146,
-0.15990328788757324,
0.20819661021232605,
-0.3481416404247284,
0.7794700264930725,
-0.17271380126476288,
0.1029081642627716,
0.31905102729797363,
0.5843001008033752,
0.33013588190078735,
0.14090898633003235,
0.540978193283081,
0.26571714878082275,
0.8123672008514404,
0.02905348688364029,
0.8382037281990051,
-0.4152517318725586,
0.06100281700491905,
0.7013591527938843,
-0.4533844590187073,
0.6189403533935547,
0.5984011292457581,
-0.17024174332618713,
0.34953776001930237,
0.4995594918727875,
0.2060190737247467,
0.4699597656726837,
0.23156005144119263,
-0.2622070610523224,
-0.48283272981643677,
0.03109690546989441,
-0.39892420172691345,
-0.011564572341740131,
0.7087736129760742,
-0.2237931340932846,
-0.0873604416847229,
0.3639891445636749,
0.12968450784683228,
0.07940040528774261,
-0.385672390460968,
0.6489366888999939,
0.19579488039016724,
-0.5031448602676392,
0.7087783217430115,
-0.049312710762023926,
0.6663730144500732,
-1.1274429559707642,
0.06731199473142624,
-0.08675272017717361,
0.45856040716171265,
-0.132486954331398,
-0.4162190556526184,
0.07700005918741226,
0.18978841602802277,
-0.18282665312290192,
-0.33371472358703613,
1.053858995437622,
-0.49151214957237244,
-0.3556458055973053,
0.36544352769851685,
0.656914472579956,
0.11456071585416794,
0.028340181335806847,
-0.9346373081207275,
0.09161518514156342,
-0.33417758345603943,
-0.5583341717720032,
0.5975764989852905,
0.3169797956943512,
0.09777366369962692,
0.5585967302322388,
0.6027045249938965,
0.5223193764686584,
-0.2907695472240448,
0.31144142150878906,
1.0615397691726685,
-0.4147576093673706,
-0.3585848808288574,
-0.5517095923423767,
0.23980917036533356,
-0.08483066409826279,
-0.16734935343265533,
0.2631905972957611,
0.48727306723594666,
0.3276363015174866,
-0.11105434596538544,
0.6741558313369751,
0.2861591577529907,
0.8823502659797668,
-0.43500590324401855,
0.9833548069000244,
-0.8183236718177795,
0.005631929729133844,
-0.2750421464443207,
-0.42252764105796814,
-0.5280063152313232,
0.5677171945571899,
-0.15672416985034943,
0.25031113624572754,
0.6006113886833191,
0.801535964012146,
-0.18454968929290771,
-0.10714437067508698,
0.4295971989631653,
0.22356270253658295,
-0.03926743566989899,
0.5754647850990295,
0.5894830822944641,
-0.13464374840259552,
0.3416280448436737,
0.06269767135381699,
-0.5233520865440369,
-0.04009576141834259,
-0.6780266761779785,
-0.9672126173973083,
-0.42997628450393677,
-0.2736051380634308,
-0.4796549081802368,
0.2099984884262085,
1.3239248991012573,
0.9952749609947205,
-0.7304161787033081,
-0.046758022159338,
0.03128587454557419,
-0.4152759313583374,
-0.022553037852048874,
-0.07813198119401932,
0.510846734046936,
-0.6949445605278015,
-0.33292239904403687,
0.5725529193878174,
0.4038451611995697,
0.1591697633266449,
0.007559706456959248,
-0.13581253588199615,
-0.08560482412576675,
0.3784124553203583,
0.548248827457428,
0.3315099775791168,
-0.22095058858394623,
0.058596812188625336,
0.14798426628112793,
-0.38686439394950867,
-0.33747342228889465,
1.0258899927139282,
-0.9938245415687561,
-0.17342312633991241,
0.1385243833065033,
0.9157644510269165,
0.6738969087600708,
-0.3102126121520996,
0.3997417092323303,
-0.5854719281196594,
0.3101288378238678,
0.3156597912311554,
0.47576940059661865,
0.15149760246276855,
-0.2723712623119354,
0.44233500957489014,
0.27925118803977966,
-0.7183098196983337,
-0.8234103918075562,
-0.07522013038396835,
-0.8761292695999146,
-0.7112826704978943,
1.0235230922698975,
0.12567734718322754,
-0.2898394763469696,
-0.21456000208854675,
-0.2497035413980484,
0.15661443769931793,
0.033468686044216156,
0.5075300931930542,
0.07449503988027573,
-0.16914241015911102,
0.3197474777698517,
-0.45435047149658203,
0.8533973097801208,
0.8641169667243958,
-0.8021073937416077,
0.036413706839084625,
0.508324384689331,
0.48184049129486084,
-0.310615599155426,
1.0472846031188965,
-0.19429631531238556,
0.3340805768966675,
-0.17262090742588043,
0.08421057462692261,
0.04151058942079544,
-0.3481118679046631,
-0.32377195358276367,
0.12684839963912964,
0.0219908244907856,
0.21712921559810638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00932v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00932v2
|
Differentially Private Knowledge Distillation via Synthetic Text Generation
| 2024-03-01T19:22:24 | 2024-06-05T03:07:44 |
James Flemings, Murali Annavaram
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Large Language models (LLMs) are achieving state-of-the-art performance in
many different downstream tasks. However, the increasing urgency of data
privacy puts pressure on practitioners to train LLMs with Differential Privacy
(DP) on private data. Concurrently, the exponential growth in parameter size of
LLMs necessitates model compression before deployment of LLMs on
resource-constrained devices or latency-sensitive applications. Differential
privacy and model compression generally must trade off utility loss to achieve
their objectives. Moreover, simultaneously applying both schemes can compound
the utility degradation. To this end, we propose DistilDP: a novel
differentially private knowledge distillation algorithm that exploits synthetic
data generated by a differentially private teacher LLM. The knowledge of a
teacher LLM is transferred onto the student in two ways: one way from the
synthetic data itself -- the hard labels, and the other way by the output
distribution of the teacher evaluated on the synthetic data -- the soft labels.
Furthermore, if the teacher and student share a similar architectural
structure, we can further distill knowledge by aligning the hidden
representations between both. Our experimental results demonstrate that
DistilDP can substantially improve the utility over existing baselines, at
least $9.0$ PPL on the Big Patent dataset, with strong privacy parameters,
$\epsilon=2$. These promising results progress privacy-preserving compression
of autoregressive LLMs. Our code can be accessed here:
https://github.com/james-flemings/dp_compress.
|
[
-0.18254904448986053,
-0.3641771972179413,
0.6565936803817749,
0.11234261840581894,
-0.304349809885025,
0.5940146446228027,
-0.22705526649951935,
-0.20095689594745636,
-0.028942011296749115,
0.3839243948459625,
-0.3980685770511627,
-0.6328086256980896,
-0.8988412618637085,
-0.033809561282396317,
-0.5233161449432373,
0.906484067440033,
0.17553001642227173,
-0.07657056301832199,
0.02559550106525421,
0.10351797193288803,
-0.0841328576207161,
-0.8067456483840942,
-0.1730555295944214,
-0.10060504823923111,
0.31186389923095703,
0.15752153098583221,
0.4532295763492584,
0.6505118012428284,
0.05357448011636734,
0.4533681273460388,
-0.2735077142715454,
0.37476077675819397,
-0.5998120903968811,
0.36186566948890686,
-0.19035501778125763,
-0.32400426268577576,
-0.37011292576789856,
0.20103096961975098,
0.5971980690956116,
0.7129077911376953,
-0.22216546535491943,
0.20614342391490936,
0.5395094752311707,
1.0026859045028687,
-0.7057006359100342,
0.31373441219329834,
-0.7809831500053406,
0.1645357459783554,
-0.029475202783942223,
-0.09618989378213882,
-0.3711778223514557,
-0.6186034679412842,
0.03216272220015526,
-0.20624031126499176,
0.3730810880661011,
-0.15006668865680695,
0.4651894271373749,
0.587936282157898,
-0.2883354723453522,
0.06869348883628845,
-0.8073275685310364,
0.6330355405807495,
-0.541953444480896,
0.18636766076087952,
0.29511603713035583,
0.33765271306037903,
-0.2694563865661621,
-0.823370099067688,
-0.6744655966758728,
0.044605884701013565,
-0.15594109892845154,
-0.10185461491346359,
-0.05940159037709236,
0.022222748026251793,
0.19466464221477509,
0.8038449287414551,
-0.23584653437137604,
0.1248549297451973,
-0.45713984966278076,
-0.07229399681091309,
0.8397420048713684,
0.002620853716507554,
-0.07914559543132782,
0.008720368146896362,
-0.4090091288089752,
-0.1972460150718689,
-0.4890766441822052,
-0.20641684532165527,
0.7173243165016174,
0.010546939447522163,
-0.14407791197299957,
0.49564456939697266,
-0.15476447343826294,
0.6175289154052734,
0.09548869729042053,
-0.2701840400695801,
0.04802373796701431,
-0.0393281988799572,
-0.22383764386177063,
0.30916163325309753,
0.8278806805610657,
0.2524245083332062,
0.13216885924339294,
-0.06093310937285423,
-0.02409905567765236,
0.027422068640589714,
-0.10388100892305374,
-0.7904596328735352,
-0.5192181468009949,
0.15562039613723755,
-0.06077435240149498,
-0.6447138786315918,
-0.07677793502807617,
-0.9405977725982666,
-0.7126753926277161,
-0.4421289563179016,
0.2758769690990448,
0.009466338902711868,
-0.21019518375396729,
0.2935950458049774,
-0.33334264159202576,
-0.48854202032089233,
-0.027123577892780304,
-1.0705927610397339,
0.5620360374450684,
0.6502625942230225,
0.8486143946647644,
-0.05838293209671974,
-0.057700421661138535,
-0.453763484954834,
0.5107848048210144,
0.08887284994125366,
0.11057130247354507,
-0.21492362022399902,
-0.5608378648757935,
-0.19624875485897064,
-0.06557366997003555,
0.4185684323310852,
-0.5335426926612854,
0.21470747888088226,
-0.4689077138900757,
0.26286330819129944,
0.15214338898658752,
-0.5297071933746338,
0.07900878041982651,
0.018854854628443718,
-0.6708382964134216,
0.6665648221969604,
0.07218268513679504,
-0.7722935080528259,
0.1312463879585266,
-0.2965306341648102,
-0.170416921377182,
-0.018950235098600388,
-0.4177483320236206,
-0.5853271484375,
0.21091175079345703,
0.1958303600549698,
0.6555760502815247,
-0.20157521963119507,
0.5171985626220703,
-0.35732173919677734,
-0.22092199325561523,
0.4199634790420532,
-0.7040955424308777,
0.8985701203346252,
0.16763266921043396,
-0.4652058482170105,
-0.531466543674469,
-1.008774995803833,
-0.02262972481548786,
0.16929477453231812,
-0.3750424385070801,
-0.7271111607551575,
-0.3299243450164795,
-0.5320901870727539,
-0.0358390137553215,
0.490119993686676,
-0.5302192568778992,
0.48856937885284424,
-0.3712691068649292,
0.5309028625488281,
1.1260401010513306,
-0.12767720222473145,
0.645715057849884,
-0.1271105259656906,
0.33278611302375793,
-0.12834656238555908,
0.2891586124897003,
0.25525525212287903,
-0.3676074743270874,
-0.33970463275909424,
-0.5699250102043152,
0.5602681636810303,
0.14837901294231415,
-0.36614352464675903,
0.48492899537086487,
-0.289871484041214,
-0.45583295822143555,
-0.31419187784194946,
0.12012834846973419,
0.3414137661457062,
0.5643974542617798,
0.3206186294555664,
-0.02197212539613247,
-0.32541096210479736,
-0.7390692234039307,
-0.3059012293815613,
0.01824112981557846,
-0.10147915035486221,
0.29047664999961853,
0.016298426315188408,
0.01781504787504673,
0.799289345741272,
-1.0332449674606323,
-0.5416001081466675,
0.017590368166565895,
0.20294252038002014,
0.24885129928588867,
0.6039744019508362,
0.4764277935028076,
-0.7023648023605347,
-0.7504166960716248,
-0.36170685291290283,
-0.3336128294467926,
-0.37048056721687317,
0.21499024331569672,
-0.29684340953826904,
0.2251344472169876,
0.06813140213489532,
-0.44914406538009644,
0.38391661643981934,
1.0764367580413818,
-0.31388112902641296,
0.30113619565963745,
-0.5148208141326904,
0.04478120803833008,
-1.2504503726959229,
-0.17982912063598633,
-0.25075802206993103,
-0.43652814626693726,
-0.25248026847839355,
-0.1534392237663269,
0.06125786527991295,
-0.2425295114517212,
-0.5015669465065002,
0.3701733648777008,
-0.6873745918273926,
0.1384592205286026,
-0.41098839044570923,
-0.08082004636526108,
0.2794128656387329,
0.35663917660713196,
0.1205725371837616,
0.5556156039237976,
0.5078738927841187,
-0.6828077435493469,
0.38401734828948975,
0.1392822563648224,
-0.14111874997615814,
0.04366069287061691,
-0.4587269127368927,
0.4082586467266083,
-0.020015038549900055,
0.23425191640853882,
-0.7549548745155334,
-0.11609695851802826,
0.17258495092391968,
-0.16596607863903046,
0.6349135637283325,
-0.46329304575920105,
-0.6189550161361694,
-0.16685336828231812,
-0.3858932554721832,
0.1817794144153595,
0.9728265404701233,
-0.9149343967437744,
0.4206959903240204,
0.5806390643119812,
-0.09202685952186584,
-0.727312445640564,
-0.9809150695800781,
0.06794284284114838,
-0.3285875618457794,
-0.4710098206996918,
0.7833383679389954,
0.01907704956829548,
-0.25121474266052246,
0.11137564480304718,
-0.3205592930316925,
-0.37758418917655945,
0.015110420994460583,
0.31074944138526917,
0.3096467852592468,
0.3325139284133911,
-0.09037187695503235,
0.6645520925521851,
-0.22435951232910156,
0.1569814383983612,
-0.5235256552696228,
0.460886687040329,
0.22902365028858185,
-0.10151854157447815,
-0.4131445586681366,
0.23312032222747803,
0.2590477168560028,
0.27991968393325806,
0.9999996423721313,
0.025329258292913437,
-0.07090624421834946,
-0.7424640655517578,
-0.33213773369789124,
-0.3417321443557739,
-0.6423154473304749,
-0.025295836851000786,
-0.06521125882863998,
-0.6906712055206299,
0.04647740721702576,
-0.5508273243904114,
0.08890756964683533,
0.004857000429183245,
0.43356919288635254,
0.32827484607696533,
0.7736656069755554,
0.6301184892654419,
-0.17780618369579315,
0.17748230695724487,
-0.535950243473053,
0.27813321352005005,
-0.3256503641605377,
-0.2235005646944046,
-0.45708540081977844,
-0.6010576486587524,
-0.771024227142334,
-0.4424559473991394,
0.4746219217777252,
0.07633698731660843,
0.07574541121721268,
0.22860363125801086,
-1.12301766872406,
0.8078562617301941,
0.6210243105888367,
0.1762099713087082,
0.8100437521934509,
0.1661260724067688,
0.08285202831029892,
-0.1896226704120636,
-0.44791287183761597,
-0.5280821919441223,
1.2318434715270996,
0.2692779302597046,
0.9385579228401184,
0.2506614923477173,
1.3795433044433594,
0.1966840922832489,
0.07534736394882202,
-0.27346014976501465,
0.7180994749069214,
-0.618109941482544,
-0.529800295829773,
-0.19848744571208954,
-0.5197774171829224,
-0.5960408449172974,
0.09362828731536865,
0.06504164636135101,
-0.5782915353775024,
0.24240465462207794,
0.32849839329719543,
-0.2169162929058075,
0.25086742639541626,
-0.8756340146064758,
0.2900657653808594,
-0.16115039587020874,
-0.746773898601532,
-0.17882466316223145,
-0.5495585203170776,
0.5746695399284363,
-0.3852260112762451,
0.16885115206241608,
-0.1492958813905716,
0.05821772664785385,
0.5122513771057129,
-0.6667222380638123,
0.8870607018470764,
-0.5669229626655579,
-0.20839138329029083,
-0.03686758130788803,
0.1980404555797577,
0.5578424334526062,
0.502918541431427,
-0.010387714952230453,
0.48711884021759033,
0.06016068160533905,
-0.09241091459989548,
-0.8278211355209351,
1.033305048942566,
-0.6378892064094543,
-0.8914583325386047,
-0.5722595453262329,
-0.39757031202316284,
-0.13035012781620026,
-0.04855131730437279,
0.11179963499307632,
0.12850230932235718,
0.29480597376823425,
0.11430815607309341,
0.6264445781707764,
-0.2986798882484436,
0.34138792753219604,
0.7552929520606995,
-0.07098324596881866,
-0.14550675451755524,
0.8080967664718628,
0.2753601670265198,
0.20888575911521912,
0.2798762023448944,
0.5531623363494873,
-0.7694269418716431,
-0.5655619502067566,
-0.21000520884990692,
0.16221199929714203,
-0.5022252202033997,
-0.2997298538684845,
-0.6029929518699646,
-0.5086764693260193,
-0.4780389368534088,
-0.035485122352838516,
-0.6663954257965088,
-0.8607358932495117,
-0.366252064704895,
-0.13328441977500916,
0.5731465816497803,
0.5276896357536316,
-0.6229081153869629,
-0.06799813359975815,
-0.8693258166313171,
0.5584945678710938,
0.48375797271728516,
0.22031334042549133,
-0.21396444737911224,
-0.39070120453834534,
0.16011221706867218,
0.19869768619537354,
-0.5017072558403015,
-0.7080733180046082,
0.5713598728179932,
0.3300637900829315,
0.23482415080070496,
0.10443554073572159,
0.8423144817352295,
0.5094475746154785,
-0.6024178266525269,
0.7629266977310181,
0.14584089815616608,
-0.9049473404884338,
0.3548027575016022,
0.0739569440484047,
-0.10793943703174591,
0.5090619921684265,
0.5451714396476746,
0.0742315798997879,
-0.7962934970855713,
-0.5608185529708862,
-0.9263314008712769,
0.5812127590179443,
0.2344672679901123,
0.5615633726119995,
0.42575374245643616,
0.3498976528644562,
0.5119900107383728,
0.39718884229660034,
-0.7242177128791809,
-0.5080860257148743,
-0.08860879391431808,
-0.5104901790618896,
0.0847386047244072,
-0.2680070102214813,
-0.39271339774131775,
-0.3646920919418335,
0.5640933513641357,
0.22287103533744812,
0.035311371088027954,
0.14963114261627197,
0.27977386116981506,
0.5145311951637268,
0.30408304929733276,
0.15567085146903992,
0.25128793716430664,
-0.060205552726984024,
0.5513736605644226,
-0.1872510015964508,
-0.7318004369735718,
0.6855108737945557,
0.6268101334571838,
-0.12768973410129547,
0.04864347353577614,
-0.3401256799697876,
0.2083732932806015,
-0.18291647732257843,
-0.30395740270614624,
0.45377424359321594,
-0.3213202953338623,
-0.4756961762905121,
-0.35170671343803406,
0.3617417514324188,
-0.04501472786068916,
0.47273555397987366,
0.23108918964862823,
-0.16492755711078644,
0.35848280787467957,
-0.18185366690158844,
0.039635878056287766,
0.03861038386821747,
0.141012504696846,
-0.26846763491630554,
0.9311308860778809,
0.3080257773399353,
-0.0977436751127243,
0.2978459894657135,
-0.05759386345744133,
-0.23677434027194977,
0.07410356402397156,
0.2690105140209198,
0.9157395958900452,
-0.19326262176036835,
0.20404386520385742,
-0.003869507694616914,
-0.20482848584651947,
-0.20792359113693237,
0.074965700507164,
-0.557962954044342,
-0.323768675327301,
-0.2963215708732605,
-0.7091379761695862,
-0.28021904826164246,
0.4665886461734772,
-0.33428722620010376,
0.2480425387620926,
-0.6599644422531128,
-0.17596568167209625,
-0.045438095927238464,
0.10161547362804413,
-0.3735973834991455,
-0.05690063163638115,
0.2040928155183792,
0.36023247241973877,
-0.48168742656707764,
0.9862639904022217,
0.120529904961586,
0.0121406065300107,
-0.9800052046775818,
0.2126668095588684,
0.034590352326631546,
-0.5901288390159607,
0.9917270541191101,
-0.039996784180402756,
-0.18421171605587006,
0.10788844525814056,
-0.3801061511039734,
-0.5721696019172668,
0.9911981821060181,
0.8442070484161377,
-1.2367864847183228,
-0.02751067467033863,
0.6611186265945435,
0.6077730655670166,
0.21682339906692505,
-0.4899163544178009,
0.20840701460838318,
0.2757303714752197,
0.019081488251686096,
-0.7484111785888672,
0.2645809054374695,
0.030283795669674873,
-0.123405821621418,
0.07746808975934982,
-0.5465584993362427,
0.6929821968078613,
0.06681346893310547,
-0.22986023128032684,
-0.18331335484981537,
0.2956676781177521,
0.43784475326538086,
0.4522208273410797,
0.3247348666191101,
0.501704752445221,
0.8131816387176514,
0.12355071306228638,
0.7348594069480896,
-0.6919864416122437,
0.31467196345329285,
1.2537039518356323,
-0.30246496200561523,
0.34601595997810364,
0.7281590104103088,
-0.22524964809417725,
0.350419282913208,
0.17507709562778473,
0.16926388442516327,
0.9827646017074585,
0.5412718653678894,
-0.6245967745780945,
0.23815777897834778,
-0.014032816514372826,
-0.6394840478897095,
0.2427685707807541,
-0.14414411783218384,
-0.6737741231918335,
-0.10516253113746643,
-0.14902275800704956,
-0.03483292832970619,
0.4369964003562927,
0.11453425884246826,
0.7106198668479919,
0.2868933081626892,
-0.38953742384910583,
0.7950598001480103,
0.06184886768460274,
0.6779369711875916,
-0.472873717546463,
-0.017691288143396378,
-0.17688807845115662,
0.43448591232299805,
-0.18900975584983826,
-0.6643694043159485,
0.5255157947540283,
0.25921890139579773,
-0.0910894051194191,
-0.6405791640281677,
0.6006474494934082,
-0.5555346608161926,
-0.2769208252429962,
0.18546746671199799,
0.20321659743785858,
0.1684659719467163,
-0.04468058422207832,
-0.5053434371948242,
-0.09462863951921463,
-0.0652085468173027,
-0.28324252367019653,
0.5202497839927673,
0.5917617678642273,
0.439174622297287,
0.27529993653297424,
0.6175468564033508,
0.337985634803772,
0.19137471914291382,
0.0762997418642044,
1.334952473640442,
-0.24327999353408813,
-0.6393808722496033,
-1.1626901626586914,
0.47644758224487305,
-0.358158677816391,
0.04468967765569687,
0.7968963384628296,
0.532481849193573,
0.7612512111663818,
-0.06134544685482979,
0.7821770906448364,
0.13313812017440796,
0.6018431782722473,
-0.6726856231689453,
1.0499261617660522,
-0.461064875125885,
0.622170090675354,
-0.22134727239608765,
-0.8332598209381104,
-0.08032678067684174,
0.33772024512290955,
-0.27214527130126953,
-0.3981601297855377,
0.4764598608016968,
0.7298668026924133,
-0.10738790035247803,
-0.07031060010194778,
0.25465142726898193,
0.10800394415855408,
0.4391371011734009,
0.44837886095046997,
0.946838915348053,
-0.31871217489242554,
0.39246630668640137,
-0.8377366662025452,
-0.2769750654697418,
0.3000248968601227,
-0.9590570330619812,
-0.8910561800003052,
-0.6215941905975342,
-0.5429286360740662,
-0.27896296977996826,
0.17488010227680206,
0.58580482006073,
0.8280797004699707,
-0.2623831629753113,
0.09755009412765503,
-0.5679079294204712,
0.02626039832830429,
0.1712886542081833,
-0.2285272628068924,
0.3047465682029724,
0.05667192116379738,
-1.140975832939148,
0.36416319012641907,
0.08221763372421265,
0.546529233455658,
-0.6605150103569031,
-0.04832206293940544,
0.3723333775997162,
-0.06262414902448654,
0.2296091765165329,
-0.04732199385762215,
-0.11812646687030792,
0.1765034943819046,
-0.29160991311073303,
0.00889616645872593,
-0.2918168008327484,
0.7677187323570251,
-0.8089486956596375,
0.27511030435562134,
0.4732816815376282,
0.5040311217308044,
0.7069826126098633,
0.0050217281095683575,
0.6434780359268188,
-1.1793161630630493,
0.6533350348472595,
0.4857628047466278,
-0.0624472014605999,
0.1646994799375534,
-0.8300837278366089,
0.28269752860069275,
0.26811543107032776,
-0.7197017073631287,
-1.1746817827224731,
0.052869297564029694,
-0.6530604362487793,
-0.5540453791618347,
1.0632152557373047,
-0.4569336175918579,
-0.3441295325756073,
-0.04079000651836395,
-0.22110220789909363,
0.28139248490333557,
-0.6220478415489197,
1.4524227380752563,
0.288179874420166,
0.11464740335941315,
0.1322452276945114,
-0.13456423580646515,
0.6876323819160461,
0.05044734477996826,
-0.5521963238716125,
0.3119180500507355,
0.5002456307411194,
0.2132265418767929,
-0.12501122057437897,
0.5275275707244873,
-0.2802065312862396,
-0.3261352777481079,
0.020744189620018005,
-0.36209097504615784,
-0.6664981245994568,
-0.3481876254081726,
-0.27600106596946716,
0.33341431617736816,
-0.10848730057477951,
-0.5468814373016357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00923v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00923v1
|
An Interpretable Ensemble of Graph and Language Models for Improving Search Relevance in E-Commerce
| 2024-03-01T19:08:25 | 2024-03-01T19:08:25 |
Nurendra Choudhary, Edward W Huang, Karthik Subbian, Chandan K. Reddy
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, H.3.3; I.2.7; J.7
|
The problem of search relevance in the E-commerce domain is a challenging one
since it involves understanding the intent of a user's short nuanced query and
matching it with the appropriate products in the catalog. This problem has
traditionally been addressed using language models (LMs) and graph neural
networks (GNNs) to capture semantic and inter-product behavior signals,
respectively. However, the rapid development of new architectures has created a
gap between research and the practical adoption of these techniques. Evaluating
the generalizability of these models for deployment requires extensive
experimentation on complex, real-world datasets, which can be non-trivial and
expensive. Furthermore, such models often operate on latent space
representations that are incomprehensible to humans, making it difficult to
evaluate and compare the effectiveness of different models. This lack of
interpretability hinders the development and adoption of new techniques in the
field. To bridge this gap, we propose Plug and Play Graph LAnguage Model
(PP-GLAM), an explainable ensemble of plug and play models. Our approach uses a
modular framework with uniform data processing pipelines. It employs additive
explanation metrics to independently decide whether to include (i) language
model candidates, (ii) GNN model candidates, and (iii) inter-product behavioral
signals. For the task of search relevance, we show that PP-GLAM outperforms
several state-of-the-art baselines as well as a proprietary model on real-world
multilingual, multi-regional e-commerce datasets. To promote better model
comprehensibility and adoption, we also provide an analysis of the
explainability and computational complexity of our model. We also provide the
public codebase and provide a deployment strategy for practical implementation.
|
[
-0.23725296556949615,
-0.7846124172210693,
0.6093445420265198,
0.2210943102836609,
-0.3052252531051636,
0.15891173481941223,
-0.23328275978565216,
-0.6077229976654053,
0.22442275285720825,
0.282335102558136,
-0.4311991333961487,
-0.6478851437568665,
-0.36453065276145935,
-0.1554591953754425,
-0.5752353072166443,
0.857310950756073,
0.1024605855345726,
-0.3697509467601776,
-0.28284746408462524,
-0.1122872605919838,
-0.18214359879493713,
-0.4942784905433655,
-0.4845116138458252,
-0.21659968793392181,
0.5611013174057007,
0.0035301127936691046,
0.8623982071876526,
0.33305755257606506,
0.2782614827156067,
0.2781730592250824,
-0.2270251214504242,
0.29688167572021484,
-0.736644446849823,
-0.04819519817829132,
-0.08692612498998642,
-0.35351279377937317,
-0.5598532557487488,
-0.21026074886322021,
0.2594190835952759,
0.8313460350036621,
-0.40896719694137573,
0.14861679077148438,
0.21122442185878754,
0.1890205293893814,
-0.5192920565605164,
0.38313838839530945,
-0.6997832655906677,
-0.3384631872177124,
0.12826302647590637,
-0.20715387165546417,
-0.6812044978141785,
-0.36790940165519714,
0.24372506141662598,
-1.0063170194625854,
0.3542172908782959,
0.32414501905441284,
0.9167147874832153,
-0.35569867491722107,
-0.4665251672267914,
-0.4198119044303894,
-0.8463941216468811,
0.6690027117729187,
-0.7014839053153992,
0.4337587356567383,
0.308661550283432,
0.3691962659358978,
-0.3519386649131775,
-1.0693137645721436,
-0.3971925973892212,
0.024941634386777878,
-0.5201806426048279,
0.1752413511276245,
-0.3345271348953247,
0.014011304825544357,
-0.03331415727734566,
0.3584161698818207,
-0.9408340454101562,
0.07259218394756317,
-0.2221629023551941,
-0.2142566740512848,
0.49876463413238525,
0.1297566145658493,
0.64240562915802,
0.14579032361507416,
-0.043629325926303864,
0.19641034305095673,
-0.5396201610565186,
0.12249936163425446,
0.5520415902137756,
0.5630343556404114,
-0.06527608633041382,
0.3275398910045624,
-0.2876822352409363,
0.9398794174194336,
-0.016758158802986145,
0.08513259142637253,
0.07691965252161026,
-0.4326806366443634,
-0.10197392851114273,
-0.11713014543056488,
0.5303123593330383,
0.34092584252357483,
0.005294053349643946,
-0.4610297679901123,
-0.05443112924695015,
0.08318203687667847,
0.49831539392471313,
-0.6872937679290771,
-0.24670830368995667,
0.34717607498168945,
-0.6943174600601196,
-0.2585470676422119,
-0.023443439975380898,
-0.7740227580070496,
0.0052225710824131966,
-0.31477469205856323,
0.42011040449142456,
-0.09474015980958939,
-0.4013654887676239,
0.3225288987159729,
-0.0488126277923584,
0.0537063293159008,
0.30133718252182007,
-0.9514515399932861,
0.5907759070396423,
0.9506338238716125,
0.9797711968421936,
-0.0304424986243248,
-0.1236695721745491,
-0.30970004200935364,
0.0724172368645668,
-0.2632012665271759,
0.6439122557640076,
-0.693385899066925,
-0.20010770857334137,
0.15237504243850708,
0.24552606046199799,
-0.3757307231426239,
-0.4102620482444763,
0.5109943151473999,
-1.2085834741592407,
0.3448084890842438,
0.09465158730745316,
-0.7000370025634766,
-0.6235306262969971,
0.22160275280475616,
-0.7881838083267212,
0.6553484797477722,
0.21576005220413208,
-0.5544102787971497,
0.42917707562446594,
-0.4996500611305237,
-0.5224769711494446,
0.3036303222179413,
-0.09482453763484955,
-0.5982674360275269,
0.22180548310279846,
0.2628445029258728,
0.24642616510391235,
-0.26737791299819946,
0.2172471135854721,
-0.580354630947113,
-0.8034919500350952,
-0.023540074005723,
-0.09041009843349457,
0.7343427538871765,
0.22508357465267181,
-0.2422809898853302,
0.028455248102545738,
-0.4960191249847412,
0.17162883281707764,
0.31266871094703674,
-0.33202970027923584,
-0.2687704861164093,
0.24404694139957428,
0.15294510126113892,
0.22681884467601776,
0.2708026170730591,
-0.10332268476486206,
0.24256856739521027,
-0.4923405647277832,
0.611770510673523,
0.5794472694396973,
-0.14728274941444397,
0.47493988275527954,
-0.05340803787112236,
0.8200142979621887,
-0.24002277851104736,
0.3512410819530487,
-0.2504566013813019,
-0.9350113272666931,
-0.35486599802970886,
-0.06352932006120682,
0.3623974919319153,
0.428361713886261,
-0.5596548318862915,
0.30750471353530884,
-0.44694238901138306,
-0.43062934279441833,
-0.37033388018608093,
0.11640086024999619,
0.061927542090415955,
0.6375228762626648,
0.26207706332206726,
-0.4448600113391876,
-0.20269104838371277,
-0.7420923709869385,
-0.2732903063297272,
-0.2722764015197754,
-0.2092950940132141,
0.8441022634506226,
0.15191416442394257,
-0.28539541363716125,
0.8861334919929504,
-0.6128787994384766,
-0.048404790461063385,
-0.2636447548866272,
0.12150243669748306,
0.744361400604248,
-0.0348573736846447,
0.5097881555557251,
-1.101749300956726,
-0.5129695534706116,
0.35740092396736145,
-0.5581114292144775,
-0.11228388547897339,
0.2550722062587738,
-0.01262510847300291,
-0.04659396782517433,
0.20577701926231384,
-0.36319097876548767,
0.47730180621147156,
0.5246990323066711,
-0.23853850364685059,
0.5276179313659668,
-0.4494369924068451,
0.1623591184616089,
-0.7238036394119263,
0.35060033202171326,
0.06363135576248169,
-0.23274943232536316,
-0.794420063495636,
0.2165701538324356,
0.024134937673807144,
-0.3223276734352112,
-0.4352887272834778,
0.527029275894165,
-0.17910988628864288,
-0.4271245002746582,
-0.1006508469581604,
0.47936922311782837,
0.5740252137184143,
0.4865717887878418,
-0.24420668184757233,
0.8035445213317871,
0.4925788938999176,
-0.9888210296630859,
0.17286913096904755,
0.2122504711151123,
-0.5301244258880615,
0.22335289418697357,
-0.8391612768173218,
0.08073170483112335,
-0.03859700262546539,
0.251214861869812,
-1.1538037061691284,
-0.17668072879314423,
0.18973201513290405,
-0.2773403227329254,
0.12543335556983948,
-0.5831550359725952,
-0.615280270576477,
-0.48145031929016113,
0.17674238979816437,
0.6839160323143005,
0.5078673958778381,
-0.6706042289733887,
0.719009280204773,
0.3094891905784607,
-0.21359264850616455,
-0.38465699553489685,
-0.31243258714675903,
0.053514111787080765,
-0.48655885457992554,
-0.8750234842300415,
0.5835071206092834,
-0.027526460587978363,
0.08308585733175278,
-0.006991194095462561,
0.1739719659090042,
-0.009106004610657692,
0.4337967336177826,
-0.3044532835483551,
0.3757174015045166,
-0.249932199716568,
0.38083699345588684,
-0.15944033861160278,
-0.1745890974998474,
-0.17399945855140686,
-0.7557575702667236,
0.6877301931381226,
-0.12902025878429413,
-0.512538731098175,
-0.041157107800245285,
0.1670617163181305,
0.33627310395240784,
-0.30239447951316833,
0.5797818303108215,
0.6052908897399902,
-0.2790548801422119,
-0.11691943556070328,
-0.19554612040519714,
-0.10709550231695175,
-0.514090895652771,
0.3641522526741028,
-0.1994943767786026,
-0.7859871983528137,
0.7908017039299011,
-0.35754644870758057,
-0.25492149591445923,
0.2423049509525299,
0.5032942891120911,
0.03913406282663345,
1.5887302160263062,
0.6517587304115295,
0.0858376994729042,
0.3560221493244171,
-0.08491530269384384,
0.8426558971405029,
-0.7763744592666626,
-0.2607971727848053,
-0.4570620656013489,
-0.36809736490249634,
-0.8543369174003601,
-0.2835906147956848,
0.215081125497818,
0.2126627117395401,
-0.10145111382007599,
0.3876214027404785,
-0.6871397495269775,
0.4303578734397888,
0.4443278908729553,
0.19645220041275024,
0.28670552372932434,
0.369752436876297,
-0.2090318650007248,
0.11908335238695145,
-0.8290289640426636,
-0.40398985147476196,
1.1262218952178955,
0.1042833998799324,
0.7284121513366699,
0.42067840695381165,
0.2670358121395111,
0.17751763761043549,
0.027694618329405785,
-0.8178301453590393,
0.27688702940940857,
-0.4541075825691223,
-0.5398819446563721,
-0.04726067930459976,
-0.41688933968544006,
-1.2394561767578125,
0.3592331111431122,
0.1291581690311432,
-1.2607487440109253,
0.3434845805168152,
0.22839760780334473,
-0.32710105180740356,
0.08489921689033508,
-0.6841341853141785,
1.0024287700653076,
-0.5157930850982666,
-0.5212265253067017,
-0.2040514498949051,
-0.3625301718711853,
0.22462430596351624,
0.0018275132169947028,
0.5350073575973511,
0.1049947589635849,
0.0039545344188809395,
0.3551611602306366,
-0.1550499051809311,
0.5258005261421204,
0.16624073684215546,
-0.09023335576057434,
0.2627571225166321,
0.17235159873962402,
0.8083311319351196,
-0.2197457104921341,
-0.10853239893913269,
0.13968676328659058,
-0.39278632402420044,
-0.4333363473415375,
-0.9622522592544556,
0.6319481134414673,
-0.48208311200141907,
-0.45263049006462097,
0.1510201245546341,
-0.2989887595176697,
-0.1793329268693924,
0.3131496012210846,
0.2395494282245636,
0.49572300910949707,
-0.19121703505516052,
-0.018458789214491844,
0.5576297044754028,
-0.3621547818183899,
0.18493136763572693,
0.30971360206604004,
-0.8474623560905457,
-0.15233822166919708,
1.2445991039276123,
0.11572277545928955,
0.18932992219924927,
0.2357454001903534,
0.302166223526001,
-0.5633067488670349,
-0.48532938957214355,
-0.339256227016449,
0.06546026468276978,
-0.8264747858047485,
0.23872314393520355,
-0.6893906593322754,
0.048960041254758835,
-0.3479039967060089,
-0.15812283754348755,
0.21570134162902832,
-0.34077540040016174,
-0.30503010749816895,
-0.009416716173291206,
0.24417567253112793,
0.7902266979217529,
0.16490593552589417,
0.38041865825653076,
-0.5183888077735901,
0.22049832344055176,
0.44136446714401245,
0.6863549947738647,
0.2998288869857788,
-0.44131097197532654,
-0.6116682887077332,
0.057538263499736786,
-0.10299642384052277,
-0.7391284704208374,
0.45155060291290283,
0.25822073221206665,
0.7015060186386108,
0.46485045552253723,
-0.28156739473342896,
0.650341272354126,
-0.37914949655532837,
0.6541681885719299,
0.008478977717459202,
-0.8532601594924927,
0.5198172330856323,
-0.6394025087356567,
-0.04870961233973503,
0.20208914577960968,
0.4876110255718231,
-0.5419274568557739,
-0.09877002239227295,
-0.7534915804862976,
-1.3623765707015991,
0.7602552175521851,
0.28093069791793823,
0.09035392850637436,
0.08306749910116196,
0.33969101309776306,
-0.007043836172670126,
0.48453211784362793,
-0.4817618131637573,
-0.13386429846286774,
-0.18047118186950684,
-0.14781567454338074,
-0.11836355924606323,
-0.037788569927215576,
0.030687857419252396,
-0.15719671547412872,
0.7471276521682739,
-0.45498308539390564,
0.3030412793159485,
-0.24881550669670105,
-0.302400678396225,
0.1850917786359787,
0.13258473575115204,
0.47519630193710327,
0.8927215933799744,
-0.16783608496189117,
-0.0565689355134964,
-0.1562267243862152,
-0.32004258036613464,
0.0011087475577369332,
0.12477623671293259,
-0.3485758304595947,
0.032893773168325424,
0.1300532966852188,
0.7727629542350769,
0.38531988859176636,
-0.5294636487960815,
0.47154921293258667,
-0.29054585099220276,
0.27141398191452026,
-0.010343137197196484,
-0.07682066410779953,
0.2981169819831848,
0.0898665189743042,
0.14728529751300812,
-0.24543511867523193,
0.6079818606376648,
-0.6063697934150696,
0.27004560828208923,
0.3658606708049774,
-0.3195957839488983,
-0.40098652243614197,
0.7040766477584839,
-0.06539630889892578,
-0.44748255610466003,
0.8763823509216309,
-0.4604344964027405,
-0.6694083213806152,
0.8103540539741516,
0.7132143378257751,
0.7739607691764832,
-0.008043374866247177,
0.470314085483551,
0.2429533153772354,
0.21135468780994415,
-0.013563272543251514,
0.10444971174001694,
0.1177092045545578,
-0.7623098492622375,
-0.4337361454963684,
-0.51795494556427,
-0.3719056248664856,
0.07761780172586441,
-0.665016233921051,
0.422035813331604,
-0.16553297638893127,
-0.2607598602771759,
-0.021589307114481926,
-0.22635339200496674,
-0.923628032207489,
0.1108282059431076,
0.00307606253772974,
0.44594377279281616,
-0.7806478142738342,
0.46853548288345337,
0.615832507610321,
-0.458635151386261,
-0.7901322245597839,
-0.14263904094696045,
-0.1369418501853943,
-0.9343698620796204,
0.5133861899375916,
0.2869982421398163,
0.0668792650103569,
-0.010311216115951538,
-0.3436419367790222,
-0.9303098917007446,
1.1865787506103516,
0.4083227813243866,
-0.543707013130188,
0.01574188657104969,
0.09335236996412277,
0.7210123538970947,
-0.6772330403327942,
0.5974530577659607,
0.4916479289531708,
0.33733007311820984,
0.020701555535197258,
-0.8123216032981873,
-0.1431683897972107,
-0.3262847661972046,
0.08607237786054611,
0.1486668884754181,
-0.49681517481803894,
0.9144014120101929,
0.08219542354345322,
-0.3508027195930481,
-0.08482784777879715,
0.028349393978714943,
0.22809243202209473,
0.5173777937889099,
0.41032522916793823,
0.5348221659660339,
1.005027174949646,
-0.011122522875666618,
1.211294412612915,
-0.5811923146247864,
0.8244724273681641,
1.1915960311889648,
-0.4436771273612976,
0.8103896975517273,
0.05213630571961403,
-0.2764250636100769,
0.738305926322937,
0.7822099924087524,
-0.01489165984094143,
0.4293802082538605,
0.26113229990005493,
-0.17545996606349945,
-0.5145332217216492,
-0.22573961317539215,
-0.16437047719955444,
0.2655628025531769,
0.5937616229057312,
-0.5184334516525269,
-0.3425460457801819,
-0.26862961053848267,
-0.2428303062915802,
-0.08423172682523727,
-0.2845064401626587,
0.7137247323989868,
0.05488637089729309,
-0.34773319959640503,
0.32533693313598633,
-0.1887766718864441,
0.18523745238780975,
-0.4911838173866272,
-0.13304266333580017,
0.08829354494810104,
0.12443103641271591,
-0.32649126648902893,
-0.4772603213787079,
0.07974039018154144,
-0.32272079586982727,
-0.11281099915504456,
0.021234486252069473,
0.971754789352417,
-0.19166848063468933,
-0.7379224896430969,
0.8039445281028748,
0.6008973717689514,
0.08782096952199936,
-0.017260972410440445,
-0.7602472901344299,
0.024032244458794594,
-0.24394555389881134,
-0.0731140598654747,
0.37905123829841614,
0.21992899477481842,
-0.00022547441767528653,
0.7289270758628845,
0.6916394829750061,
-0.01103081926703453,
0.03547034412622452,
0.19552826881408691,
0.8157070279121399,
-0.22082598507404327,
-0.8321565389633179,
-0.6147478222846985,
0.5398290753364563,
-0.16322444379329681,
0.11964605003595352,
0.666465699672699,
0.6445521116256714,
0.6709029674530029,
0.2240016609430313,
0.8323217034339905,
0.1928466260433197,
0.17283575236797333,
-0.400603711605072,
0.7272220849990845,
-0.7566912174224854,
0.46203988790512085,
-0.32439079880714417,
-1.032978892326355,
-0.2529973089694977,
0.6524238586425781,
-0.37832802534103394,
0.2793404161930084,
0.40478119254112244,
0.7182680368423462,
-0.5864623785018921,
0.1632995903491974,
0.3454272449016571,
0.2882941663265228,
0.4776477813720703,
0.370880126953125,
0.6124231815338135,
-0.48626983165740967,
0.688796877861023,
-0.054692547768354416,
-0.24632810056209564,
-0.5636271834373474,
-0.9948065876960754,
-0.43795332312583923,
-0.3418964147567749,
-0.32426854968070984,
-0.4143894612789154,
-0.015770651400089264,
0.5884284973144531,
0.7246266007423401,
-0.7027106285095215,
-0.3579425811767578,
-0.14434784650802612,
0.3544806241989136,
-0.4692486524581909,
-0.22092083096504211,
0.45165473222732544,
-0.38022440671920776,
-0.5306451320648193,
0.34588465094566345,
0.45547306537628174,
-0.1023259237408638,
-0.22184397280216217,
-0.046358685940504074,
-0.1233987957239151,
0.17845703661441803,
0.6898259520530701,
0.13822457194328308,
-0.6751315593719482,
-0.345549076795578,
0.30884599685668945,
0.3815782368183136,
0.16590678691864014,
0.7840928435325623,
-0.8267390727996826,
0.8001487851142883,
0.5212169885635376,
0.44970768690109253,
0.4976542294025421,
-0.05067028850317001,
0.7105072736740112,
-0.5764901638031006,
-0.12374888360500336,
0.12453814595937729,
0.5704280138015747,
0.1915598064661026,
-0.39587733149528503,
0.5894291400909424,
0.05142654478549957,
-0.6343573331832886,
-0.6283474564552307,
0.5565549731254578,
-0.6256642937660217,
-0.23478519916534424,
0.9705164432525635,
-0.4361017048358917,
-0.27754780650138855,
-0.5281834602355957,
0.11510283499956131,
0.10038100928068161,
-0.27056029438972473,
0.8911696076393127,
0.6932207942008972,
-0.03723514452576637,
0.07375658303499222,
-0.45345255732536316,
0.011815645731985569,
0.016478437930345535,
-0.4887032210826874,
0.010663343593478203,
0.2512322664260864,
0.10458357632160187,
0.4270944893360138,
0.43284785747528076,
0.07733304053544998,
0.3837069869041443,
-0.16261309385299683,
-0.30771782994270325,
0.102615125477314,
-0.27312934398651123,
-0.4973607659339905,
0.24361175298690796,
0.17197315394878387,
0.22376678884029388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00758v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00758v3
|
Mitigating Reversal Curse in Large Language Models via Semantic-aware Permutation Training
| 2024-03-01T18:55:20 | 2024-03-20T07:37:24 |
Qingyan Guo, Rui Wang, Junliang Guo, Xu Tan, Jiang Bian, Yujiu Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
While large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance
across diverse tasks, recent studies showcase that causal LLMs suffer from the
"reversal curse". It is a typical example that the model knows "A's father is
B", but is unable to reason "B's child is A". This limitation poses a challenge
to the advancement of artificial general intelligence (AGI), as it suggests a
gap in the models' ability to comprehend and apply bidirectional reasoning. In
this paper, we first conduct substantial evaluation and identify that the root
cause of the reversal curse lies in the different word order between the
training and inference stage, namely, the poor ability of causal language
models to predict antecedent words within the training data. Accordingly,
permutation on the training data is considered as a potential solution, since
this can make the model predict antecedent words or tokens. However, previous
permutation methods may disrupt complete phrases or entities, thereby posing
challenges for the model to comprehend and learn from training data. To address
this issue, we propose Semantic-aware Permutation Training (SPT), which
addresses this issue by segmenting the training sentences into semantic units
(i.e., entities or phrases) with an assistant language model and permuting
these units before feeding into the model. Extensive experiments demonstrate
that SPT effectively mitigates the reversal curse since the performance on
reversed questions approximates that on the forward ones, and significantly
advances the performance of existing works.
|
[
-0.11442535370588303,
-0.8204056620597839,
0.48609688878059387,
0.28870171308517456,
-0.47835206985473633,
0.13084940612316132,
-0.07242254167795181,
-0.3771910071372986,
0.2463553249835968,
0.8692975044250488,
-0.7226678729057312,
-0.1534886360168457,
-0.9185208678245544,
0.3061217665672302,
-0.6625979542732239,
1.0177427530288696,
0.14379945397377014,
0.3796934187412262,
-0.29160478711128235,
-0.033896610140800476,
-0.7376341223716736,
-0.3962385058403015,
-0.8303516507148743,
-0.49190619587898254,
0.3999299108982086,
0.4517829716205597,
0.7011402249336243,
0.4919683635234833,
0.3056308627128601,
0.32681307196617126,
0.07364226132631302,
0.11990534514188766,
-0.7653805017471313,
0.20788396894931793,
-0.33401113748550415,
-0.6300644874572754,
-0.20709432661533356,
-0.10290022194385529,
0.7355547547340393,
0.9397335052490234,
0.0762520506978035,
-0.021576587110757828,
-0.13529764115810394,
0.40468737483024597,
-0.6398725509643555,
-0.07468580454587936,
-1.341363787651062,
0.05082681402564049,
-0.13534046709537506,
-0.36623257398605347,
-0.3660135269165039,
-0.058590181171894073,
0.11171381920576096,
-0.5251350998878479,
0.33123958110809326,
-0.09642155468463898,
0.8782798051834106,
0.45905351638793945,
-0.43443500995635986,
-0.17113420367240906,
-0.7706805467605591,
0.7436289191246033,
-0.59620201587677,
0.481167197227478,
0.4433910548686981,
0.072687067091465,
-0.4586481750011444,
-0.3958776891231537,
-0.9457522034645081,
0.004687955603003502,
-0.02184407040476799,
0.29482197761535645,
-0.018101874738931656,
-0.12536925077438354,
0.1457371860742569,
0.04501521214842796,
-0.5662999749183655,
0.37564700841903687,
-0.10165613889694214,
-0.14757758378982544,
0.45948997139930725,
0.21528559923171997,
0.44924551248550415,
0.04636755585670471,
-0.6547354459762573,
0.03568125516176224,
-1.1148651838302612,
-0.3038271963596344,
0.6471783518791199,
0.332217276096344,
0.4164675772190094,
0.53761225938797,
0.011069935746490955,
0.5868171453475952,
0.07041504234075546,
-0.0825866237282753,
0.2223121076822281,
-0.21198874711990356,
-0.17137213051319122,
0.3485936224460602,
0.29258033633232117,
0.028137248009443283,
0.24250751733779907,
-0.3943377137184143,
-0.25225919485092163,
0.32579824328422546,
0.4031558930873871,
-0.6796386241912842,
-0.0059842681512236595,
0.056914072483778,
0.06456197053194046,
-0.16072411835193634,
-0.0029194604139775038,
-0.38925784826278687,
-0.6777374148368835,
-0.3810405731201172,
0.6632724404335022,
-0.533034086227417,
-0.25032103061676025,
0.23776675760746002,
-0.04013381525874138,
0.42911022901535034,
0.334157258272171,
-0.7140056490898132,
0.12424495071172714,
0.9220739006996155,
0.19677139818668365,
-0.09347417205572128,
-0.6702843308448792,
-0.5753166079521179,
0.29508551955223083,
-0.11358071863651276,
0.7189474105834961,
-0.7209654450416565,
-0.4588865637779236,
-0.3055843412876129,
-0.06840350478887558,
-0.4331692159175873,
-0.4750250279903412,
0.3528926372528076,
-0.6114711761474609,
0.1993580162525177,
0.0025867128279060125,
-0.5124249458312988,
-0.27646511793136597,
0.18896989524364471,
-0.3104582726955414,
0.442303329706192,
-0.29687103629112244,
-0.9194642305374146,
0.3322707414627075,
0.04433376342058182,
-0.6936379671096802,
-0.12877269089221954,
-0.33039236068725586,
-0.8061846494674683,
0.26434624195098877,
0.25382694602012634,
0.16633112728595734,
-0.3980047404766083,
0.33851194381713867,
-0.17132803797721863,
-0.3525846600532532,
0.12479328364133835,
-0.7402642965316772,
0.8304110169410706,
-0.024426737800240517,
-0.4353683888912201,
0.18803466856479645,
-0.8197249174118042,
-0.41845211386680603,
0.2917798161506653,
-0.012636084109544754,
-0.6330407857894897,
0.10132115334272385,
-0.5567455887794495,
0.18996334075927734,
0.11069025099277496,
-0.4891664385795593,
0.05163463577628136,
-0.6284092664718628,
0.07586874067783356,
1.0058395862579346,
-0.10725075006484985,
0.3856876492500305,
0.14860568940639496,
0.46390461921691895,
0.3016526401042938,
0.1841978132724762,
0.07584308832883835,
-0.5174933671951294,
-0.9105054140090942,
-0.16126546263694763,
0.05973087623715401,
0.795055627822876,
-1.0267343521118164,
0.4455436170101166,
-0.3992078900337219,
-0.1273537576198578,
-0.6164619326591492,
0.15973567962646484,
0.697425127029419,
0.7014163136482239,
0.4210909903049469,
-0.4769009053707123,
-0.5062221884727478,
-0.8290170431137085,
-0.4603419005870819,
-0.18440106511116028,
0.24868685007095337,
0.1539333611726761,
0.5623065829277039,
-0.22426600754261017,
1.0060977935791016,
-0.5438047051429749,
-0.07674850523471832,
-0.27946650981903076,
0.23364754021167755,
0.019557496532797813,
0.4861074388027191,
0.05413594841957092,
-1.1326768398284912,
0.04330101236701012,
-0.2997679114341736,
-0.4533209204673767,
-0.19697165489196777,
-0.21532653272151947,
-0.27308568358421326,
0.22954706847667694,
0.5437179207801819,
-0.5992944836616516,
0.664817750453949,
0.3246506154537201,
-0.8679141402244568,
0.8621571660041809,
-0.17307938635349274,
-0.2050299346446991,
-0.8859469294548035,
-0.0721283033490181,
-0.6423447728157043,
-0.01340329460799694,
-0.6525536179542542,
0.04788266494870186,
-0.25518491864204407,
0.10852120816707611,
-0.101000115275383,
0.5783236622810364,
-0.42298150062561035,
-0.17763473093509674,
-0.2885560989379883,
0.02951989509165287,
-0.18733659386634827,
0.15665645897388458,
0.025781216099858284,
0.5613293647766113,
0.421457439661026,
-0.6986705660820007,
0.02798345498740673,
0.36800384521484375,
-0.011516964063048363,
0.5380874276161194,
-0.24230915307998657,
0.20327754318714142,
-0.24732914566993713,
0.19551919400691986,
-1.1066381931304932,
0.14448589086532593,
0.16905158758163452,
-0.6348384618759155,
0.5574591755867004,
0.07052857428789139,
-0.39432859420776367,
-0.43643173575401306,
-0.08685041964054108,
0.4343702495098114,
0.13415774703025818,
-0.6310921907424927,
0.8247352838516235,
0.13958556950092316,
0.022784428671002388,
-0.9266378283500671,
-0.6390585899353027,
0.2557477355003357,
-0.17442187666893005,
-0.6382358074188232,
0.2758835256099701,
0.16338981688022614,
-0.04111260175704956,
-0.0005703696515411139,
-0.4493437111377716,
0.1101614460349083,
0.39838075637817383,
0.15403695404529572,
0.21202895045280457,
0.0037089709658175707,
0.2026582509279251,
0.060730237513780594,
-0.44489142298698425,
-0.07535003870725632,
-0.5843876600265503,
0.760988175868988,
0.10418464988470078,
-0.4223862290382385,
0.03704932704567909,
0.09993727505207062,
0.38741546869277954,
-0.4063401520252228,
0.9191330075263977,
0.5208923816680908,
-0.26306888461112976,
-0.15721724927425385,
-0.7774659991264343,
-0.33017203211784363,
-0.39861902594566345,
0.48570185899734497,
-0.5005931854248047,
-0.8048917651176453,
0.7069255113601685,
0.04878285154700279,
-0.2279161512851715,
0.28596800565719604,
0.48887544870376587,
0.36727964878082275,
1.0933096408843994,
0.46245354413986206,
-0.23512251675128937,
0.434691458940506,
-0.18223640322685242,
0.5474641919136047,
-0.6533797383308411,
0.08584770560264587,
-0.45604243874549866,
-0.13721448183059692,
-0.48802614212036133,
-0.39410170912742615,
0.3413922190666199,
0.29695188999176025,
-0.3376326262950897,
0.28950485587120056,
-0.2617528438568115,
0.49989762902259827,
0.5184329748153687,
0.20526918768882751,
0.6060065627098083,
-0.04380800202488899,
-0.18414123356342316,
0.5127374529838562,
-0.5838727951049805,
-0.3562667965888977,
0.8520422577857971,
0.005487856920808554,
0.6087352633476257,
-0.029944928362965584,
0.903952956199646,
-0.3426826000213623,
0.1902279555797577,
-0.5470063090324402,
0.8990695476531982,
-0.4988503158092499,
-0.5765159726142883,
-0.4597344994544983,
-0.6749326586723328,
-1.2550634145736694,
0.474363774061203,
-0.18834781646728516,
-0.7183389663696289,
0.11029157042503357,
-0.021128034219145775,
-0.1977836787700653,
0.4071595370769501,
-0.8901686668395996,
0.7977277040481567,
-0.27097585797309875,
-0.3665045201778412,
-0.5330597162246704,
-0.8413496613502502,
0.395844966173172,
0.0033727658446878195,
0.06329155713319778,
0.051719389855861664,
0.18695011734962463,
0.4454887807369232,
-0.7131699919700623,
0.8741471767425537,
-0.23493129014968872,
-0.17210809886455536,
0.08904508501291275,
0.2171739637851715,
0.6688474416732788,
-0.04796786606311798,
0.25002387166023254,
-0.17038588225841522,
-0.3753800690174103,
-0.5103337168693542,
-0.6067931056022644,
0.7545871734619141,
-0.8005408644676208,
-1.004874348640442,
-0.2618464231491089,
-0.5113733410835266,
-0.5510554909706116,
0.1944119781255722,
0.2625618577003479,
0.26593124866485596,
0.1282891184091568,
-0.3655153810977936,
0.6081058979034424,
-0.5799124836921692,
0.05556626245379448,
0.727952241897583,
-0.21002407371997833,
-0.23296548426151276,
1.1625574827194214,
0.165490061044693,
0.28939318656921387,
0.42082419991493225,
0.3928866684436798,
-0.0036500918213278055,
-0.6321883201599121,
-0.36416417360305786,
0.35720211267471313,
-0.619873046875,
-0.15536536276340485,
-0.5870809555053711,
0.012977304868400097,
-0.4283352792263031,
-0.09458554536104202,
-0.2950499355792999,
-0.594210684299469,
-0.2935827672481537,
-0.25976499915122986,
0.18462231755256653,
0.32032647728919983,
0.35358721017837524,
0.13507632911205292,
-0.3621162474155426,
0.30700936913490295,
0.4520033001899719,
0.3980856239795685,
0.3202526271343231,
-0.5968688130378723,
0.29511386156082153,
-0.18459565937519073,
-0.058906491845846176,
-0.679547905921936,
0.20942454040050507,
-0.11689022183418274,
0.38600701093673706,
0.5176472067832947,
-0.18368326127529144,
0.9166420102119446,
-0.6317571401596069,
0.5688000321388245,
0.3531452417373657,
-0.7466782331466675,
0.36323100328445435,
-0.15126655995845795,
0.22530776262283325,
0.510022759437561,
0.12268427014350891,
-0.4403475522994995,
-0.7807765603065491,
-0.6820465922355652,
-1.2224490642547607,
0.6552212834358215,
0.22414304316043854,
0.22160188853740692,
-0.14571057260036469,
0.224968820810318,
0.41409990191459656,
0.21286249160766602,
-0.4443983733654022,
-0.17375682294368744,
-0.225350484251976,
-0.11903886497020721,
-0.20201639831066132,
-0.16733847558498383,
0.13638967275619507,
-0.34587299823760986,
0.9915112257003784,
0.13847771286964417,
0.25038596987724304,
0.12586607038974762,
-0.5231034159660339,
0.062333766371011734,
0.21467503905296326,
0.5531007051467896,
0.6369653940200806,
0.050458312034606934,
0.35762834548950195,
0.166148841381073,
-0.6540230512619019,
-0.07473801076412201,
0.3416823446750641,
-0.42059653997421265,
-0.35242903232574463,
0.47847187519073486,
0.9646775126457214,
0.11755471676588058,
-0.39201414585113525,
0.3863695561885834,
0.1056639775633812,
0.1571820080280304,
-0.3698126971721649,
-0.05975702032446861,
0.12081379443407059,
0.1437717229127884,
0.2863066494464874,
-0.1290881186723709,
0.021926149725914,
-0.5870241522789001,
0.15080051124095917,
0.5317776203155518,
-0.15454839169979095,
-0.29091736674308777,
0.5126138925552368,
0.05732876807451248,
-0.12545563280582428,
0.8578671813011169,
-0.15401634573936462,
-0.9208375811576843,
0.6877648234367371,
0.8939713835716248,
1.0042948722839355,
-0.42746832966804504,
0.03655492514371872,
0.053003065288066864,
0.22953012585639954,
0.007026222068816423,
0.20325233042240143,
0.1434754729270935,
-1.308151364326477,
-0.39738577604293823,
-0.6905842423439026,
-0.07889064401388168,
-0.11129175871610641,
-0.37512877583503723,
0.15268900990486145,
-0.2931605279445648,
0.1186363622546196,
-0.09086797386407852,
-0.23456794023513794,
-0.7642821073532104,
0.2230433076620102,
0.21882140636444092,
0.7091599106788635,
-0.7743278741836548,
0.804657518863678,
0.6450119614601135,
-0.6446928381919861,
-0.8302767872810364,
0.10957033187150955,
-0.21715304255485535,
-1.1106972694396973,
0.7546470761299133,
0.10156376659870148,
-0.4749269485473633,
0.16560199856758118,
-0.7011157274246216,
-0.4791766107082367,
0.9084966778755188,
0.3945210874080658,
-0.3812336027622223,
-0.03608066216111183,
0.25883913040161133,
0.4459885060787201,
-0.22499413788318634,
0.19232605397701263,
0.8048880100250244,
0.5101351141929626,
0.23837321996688843,
-0.7485776543617249,
0.10729719698429108,
0.055843304842710495,
0.018302790820598602,
0.4220860004425049,
-0.43668556213378906,
0.6434379816055298,
-0.21019229292869568,
-0.187175452709198,
0.07605022937059402,
0.39757776260375977,
0.12388620525598526,
0.39924192428588867,
0.8482276797294617,
0.8576850891113281,
0.6653295159339905,
-0.06023131310939789,
1.130240797996521,
0.09226300567388535,
0.13334877789020538,
1.397457480430603,
-0.3722539246082306,
0.550225555896759,
0.7205327749252319,
0.07727643102407455,
0.44548138976097107,
0.049407217651605606,
0.16940444707870483,
0.3037300109863281,
0.39466866850852966,
-0.23931032419204712,
-0.41153305768966675,
0.07376335561275482,
-0.07655544579029083,
0.692570686340332,
0.4122891426086426,
-0.2788310945034027,
-0.3614182770252228,
0.29568126797676086,
0.2530617415904999,
0.1442960798740387,
-0.5550312399864197,
0.8680148720741272,
0.02330802194774151,
-0.6179473400115967,
0.5820062160491943,
-0.10413718968629837,
0.6219634413719177,
-0.6307646632194519,
0.013993333093822002,
-0.3786351978778839,
0.39359650015830994,
-0.20359916985034943,
-0.49411511421203613,
0.34132254123687744,
-0.1561412662267685,
-0.08268522471189499,
-0.13881638646125793,
0.8908528685569763,
-0.5093283653259277,
-0.5023671984672546,
0.5059723258018494,
0.358857661485672,
0.008663089014589787,
0.003185825189575553,
-0.5563310384750366,
-0.1993018239736557,
-0.13810543715953827,
-0.2291732281446457,
0.3062320947647095,
0.44810569286346436,
-0.39765676856040955,
0.7460471391677856,
0.34230944514274597,
0.2357209324836731,
0.13267457485198975,
0.3453698456287384,
0.850480318069458,
-0.6103235483169556,
-0.4634319841861725,
-0.8579193949699402,
0.2791663706302643,
0.13032269477844238,
-0.22602705657482147,
0.7694254517555237,
0.3907593786716461,
0.9446160197257996,
-0.15708518028259277,
0.45797309279441833,
0.23241887986660004,
0.4911981225013733,
-0.5482150316238403,
0.5449517965316772,
-0.35110169649124146,
0.4623546004295349,
-0.4962009787559509,
-0.6548870205879211,
-0.5851563811302185,
0.47701671719551086,
-0.9182600975036621,
-0.17807810008525848,
0.47930991649627686,
0.8775400519371033,
0.10467590391635895,
0.252474308013916,
0.23793604969978333,
0.7472481727600098,
0.2617495357990265,
0.5417134165763855,
0.9582943320274353,
-0.1335366815328598,
0.5739163756370544,
0.031760428100824356,
-0.04699204862117767,
-0.10448584705591202,
-0.6889358162879944,
-0.5874617695808411,
-0.4976767301559448,
-0.11116119474172592,
-0.42753371596336365,
0.3953753113746643,
0.7569461464881897,
0.2134363353252411,
-0.8576951026916504,
-0.07819583266973495,
-0.5004991888999939,
0.6327545046806335,
-0.3534950017929077,
-0.20696298778057098,
0.4667847156524658,
-0.38597211241722107,
-0.3387424647808075,
0.18237820267677307,
0.30854159593582153,
-0.13585448265075684,
-0.1969083547592163,
0.10243373364210129,
-0.5536037683486938,
0.1295083463191986,
0.714747965335846,
0.11145839840173721,
-0.6711546778678894,
-0.6000925302505493,
-0.3450688421726227,
0.17735415697097778,
-0.18846313655376434,
0.9056529402732849,
-0.9570691585540771,
0.5007931590080261,
0.5289493203163147,
0.9001297950744629,
0.3193387985229492,
0.033451616764068604,
0.5810638070106506,
-0.6460326313972473,
0.15347477793693542,
0.3364691138267517,
0.21010786294937134,
0.31444236636161804,
-0.43456053733825684,
0.47166532278060913,
0.49036237597465515,
-0.2919592261314392,
-0.7737380862236023,
0.5800299644470215,
-0.6501789689064026,
-0.6539411544799805,
1.0276494026184082,
0.07071887701749802,
-0.0929817333817482,
-0.17401930689811707,
-0.14628994464874268,
0.5227712392807007,
-0.02835044078528881,
0.9158046245574951,
0.642510175704956,
-0.02431059442460537,
0.18505404889583588,
-0.1700243502855301,
0.1995697021484375,
0.9311052560806274,
-0.39098435640335083,
0.20267680287361145,
0.34834954142570496,
0.2988056242465973,
0.17231737077236176,
0.3777823746204376,
-0.33939728140830994,
0.048279985785484314,
-0.14223375916481018,
0.014405817724764347,
-0.006279840134084225,
-0.42939937114715576,
-0.5039796233177185,
-0.22651037573814392,
0.043866585940122604,
-0.11937010288238525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00745v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00745v1
|
AtP*: An efficient and scalable method for localizing LLM behaviour to components
| 2024-03-01T18:43:51 | 2024-03-01T18:43:51 |
János Kramár, Tom Lieberum, Rohin Shah, Neel Nanda
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Activation Patching is a method of directly computing causal attributions of
behavior to model components. However, applying it exhaustively requires a
sweep with cost scaling linearly in the number of model components, which can
be prohibitively expensive for SoTA Large Language Models (LLMs). We
investigate Attribution Patching (AtP), a fast gradient-based approximation to
Activation Patching and find two classes of failure modes of AtP which lead to
significant false negatives. We propose a variant of AtP called AtP*, with two
changes to address these failure modes while retaining scalability. We present
the first systematic study of AtP and alternative methods for faster activation
patching and show that AtP significantly outperforms all other investigated
methods, with AtP* providing further significant improvement. Finally, we
provide a method to bound the probability of remaining false negatives of AtP*
estimates.
|
[
-0.06520992517471313,
-0.9554742574691772,
0.46219682693481445,
0.6434721946716309,
0.0992993637919426,
0.18489228188991547,
-0.17112776637077332,
-0.3701128661632538,
0.4657447934150696,
0.29744216799736023,
-0.48269039392471313,
-0.05278501287102699,
-0.4669686555862427,
-0.2037636637687683,
-0.3361714780330658,
0.33270835876464844,
-0.35138458013534546,
0.2136610895395279,
-0.12160694599151611,
-0.1279834508895874,
-0.09634596854448318,
-0.4185955226421356,
-0.9275087118148804,
-0.802910566329956,
0.6606668829917908,
0.46807077527046204,
0.30672287940979004,
0.863562822341919,
0.64258873462677,
0.29793137311935425,
-0.057932689785957336,
-0.2040863037109375,
-0.3229010999202728,
-0.01902541145682335,
0.0817142054438591,
-0.8110036849975586,
-0.7066616415977478,
0.22026778757572174,
0.7958109378814697,
0.6463591456413269,
-0.07594778388738632,
0.16466814279556274,
-0.46971872448921204,
0.7705464363098145,
-0.8176236152648926,
-0.0016232242342084646,
-0.4971883296966553,
-0.023600101470947266,
-0.4120215177536011,
-0.4422778785228729,
-0.5595123767852783,
-0.5241810083389282,
-0.2606266736984253,
-0.3044891655445099,
-0.025495748966932297,
0.05501144751906395,
0.5306614637374878,
0.1857118010520935,
-0.6868319511413574,
-0.11363521218299866,
-0.6163985729217529,
1.0830763578414917,
-0.5850331783294678,
0.12920494377613068,
0.4951981008052826,
0.5043724775314331,
-0.26346102356910706,
-0.47657182812690735,
-0.3246864676475525,
-0.29067686200141907,
0.03816819563508034,
-0.4839443564414978,
-0.15919703245162964,
0.08028708398342133,
0.2309577465057373,
0.6086724996566772,
-0.03966645523905754,
0.06953629106283188,
-0.1991651952266693,
-0.44926467537879944,
0.26245370507240295,
-0.1433500498533249,
0.5597373843193054,
-0.04555222764611244,
-0.6855977177619934,
-0.03176666423678398,
-1.1725399494171143,
0.06474589556455612,
0.5934842228889465,
0.31186601519584656,
0.27841219305992126,
0.6540984511375427,
-0.16940486431121826,
0.7065812945365906,
0.12519867718219757,
-0.11423271894454956,
0.21606799960136414,
-0.41904497146606445,
-0.1864999532699585,
0.3041537404060364,
0.4980263113975525,
0.18278414011001587,
0.16197046637535095,
-0.09845999628305435,
-0.3935886025428772,
0.11694042384624481,
0.18442457914352417,
-0.703955352306366,
-0.25767266750335693,
0.29670634865760803,
-0.21310308575630188,
-0.3777584433555603,
-0.5567455887794495,
-0.5031996369361877,
-0.1700601428747177,
-0.22947226464748383,
0.5523260235786438,
-0.49087435007095337,
-0.2596585750579834,
0.14974166452884674,
0.14962680637836456,
0.06511486321687698,
0.09212200343608856,
-0.8426207900047302,
0.3875744938850403,
0.42545920610427856,
0.8315033912658691,
-0.16803988814353943,
-0.3820810616016388,
-0.678436279296875,
0.08503655344247818,
-0.3256627321243286,
1.2342209815979004,
-0.6092578172683716,
0.07136354595422745,
0.06314177811145782,
-0.08769911527633667,
-0.27536311745643616,
-0.6429153680801392,
0.13487139344215393,
-0.8737271428108215,
-0.2083490937948227,
-0.4291687309741974,
-0.541940450668335,
-0.19616329669952393,
0.3770160675048828,
-0.742212176322937,
1.0561888217926025,
0.18620197474956512,
-0.38113683462142944,
0.2695273160934448,
-0.785663902759552,
-0.4797169864177704,
-0.36919456720352173,
0.4712742865085602,
-0.5311440229415894,
-0.07343828678131104,
0.09575389325618744,
0.1710340529680252,
-0.1629454344511032,
0.052264001220464706,
-0.19030416011810303,
-0.31007465720176697,
0.3289062976837158,
-0.2584783732891083,
0.8621220588684082,
-0.004464376252144575,
-0.5633593797683716,
0.33671674132347107,
-1.2202943563461304,
-0.003682547714561224,
-0.04968252778053284,
-0.5508960485458374,
-0.4273240864276886,
0.10263944417238235,
-0.14740121364593506,
0.1553739458322525,
0.06193722039461136,
-0.5656691789627075,
0.4485187530517578,
-0.2910178005695343,
0.3990213871002197,
0.9721947312355042,
0.13464972376823425,
0.7465396523475647,
-0.1510292887687683,
0.6902776956558228,
-0.057884227484464645,
0.025915641337633133,
-0.41231220960617065,
-0.5496096611022949,
-0.7717891335487366,
-0.5386996269226074,
0.1458703577518463,
0.4338151514530182,
-0.7753929495811462,
0.07861024141311646,
-0.1525425910949707,
-0.6905158162117004,
-0.0810287594795227,
0.11182795464992523,
0.9438123106956482,
0.5387850999832153,
0.47467130422592163,
-0.23062904179096222,
-0.4182298481464386,
-1.0600899457931519,
-0.5444557666778564,
-0.3090100884437561,
0.04297889396548271,
0.2212700992822647,
0.4089730679988861,
-0.1675599366426468,
0.7619567513465881,
-0.3655378818511963,
-0.26909366250038147,
-0.1677103042602539,
0.3343021869659424,
0.028465192764997482,
0.71645587682724,
0.4929453134536743,
-0.2635597586631775,
-0.5518927574157715,
-0.22342051565647125,
-0.3480362892150879,
-0.3075084686279297,
-0.02191806770861149,
0.021131103858351707,
0.2067072093486786,
0.5901594161987305,
-0.45933327078819275,
0.12435401231050491,
0.7411919236183167,
-0.47208812832832336,
0.4283491373062134,
-0.1474386304616928,
0.4370531737804413,
-0.5434699654579163,
0.02577308565378189,
-0.012143896892666817,
-0.39283373951911926,
-0.9374198913574219,
0.15323084592819214,
0.42614972591400146,
-0.032324641942977905,
-1.0153825283050537,
0.5753521919250488,
-0.6415953040122986,
-0.000857782200910151,
-0.06809540092945099,
-0.24458098411560059,
-0.28118762373924255,
0.7910184264183044,
-0.40954387187957764,
1.015515923500061,
0.5539215803146362,
-0.6184120774269104,
0.5887457132339478,
0.05857647582888603,
-0.4165615141391754,
0.3832484781742096,
-0.3921205997467041,
0.04963892698287964,
0.03724411875009537,
0.6006336808204651,
-0.9542352557182312,
-0.1829390674829483,
0.2380734235048294,
0.011764138005673885,
0.43581101298332214,
-0.39057329297065735,
-0.5119235515594482,
-0.11335274577140808,
-0.6320023536682129,
1.2757529020309448,
0.5251392126083374,
-0.7029137015342712,
0.5346577763557434,
0.41394656896591187,
0.07906045764684677,
-0.1658657193183899,
-0.690577507019043,
-0.0665164440870285,
-0.395865261554718,
-0.8486659526824951,
0.11780719459056854,
0.1960126757621765,
-0.2913271188735962,
-0.3594050407409668,
-0.08988630771636963,
-0.2346295565366745,
0.04976913705468178,
-0.06096632778644562,
-0.1803615689277649,
-0.4132544994354248,
-0.0647953599691391,
-0.23622407019138336,
-0.5961237549781799,
0.1204063668847084,
-0.19219674170017242,
0.6563428044319153,
-0.11415913701057434,
-0.7063626646995544,
-0.36537232995033264,
0.28818202018737793,
0.6601578593254089,
-0.1385158747434616,
0.6337347626686096,
0.2521416246891022,
-0.334869921207428,
-0.01529325544834137,
-0.5889114737510681,
-0.3396361470222473,
-0.5037943720817566,
0.2481062412261963,
-0.09916353970766068,
-0.3676362633705139,
0.8025161623954773,
-0.3376644551753998,
-0.36830422282218933,
0.3743784725666046,
0.6298958659172058,
0.15035401284694672,
0.807457685470581,
0.5481519103050232,
-0.04842229187488556,
0.8115293383598328,
-0.2944759130477905,
0.38179007172584534,
-0.90828937292099,
-0.01363235991448164,
-0.4594483971595764,
-0.6302731037139893,
-0.1798463761806488,
-0.7863940596580505,
0.3796451985836029,
0.19447238743305206,
-0.1728922426700592,
0.49426090717315674,
0.009313631802797318,
0.7357632517814636,
0.6787763833999634,
0.05583479627966881,
0.21888387203216553,
0.3048411011695862,
0.16951024532318115,
-0.029335951432585716,
-0.7788349986076355,
-0.14232861995697021,
1.197928786277771,
0.34101271629333496,
0.6434727907180786,
0.32063883543014526,
0.5000513195991516,
0.15323887765407562,
0.8244643807411194,
-0.5642903447151184,
0.5386629104614258,
0.25490260124206543,
-0.7842980027198792,
-0.4036993980407715,
-0.3348109722137451,
-0.8238942623138428,
-0.10404352098703384,
-0.009939967654645443,
-0.9367716312408447,
0.2907567620277405,
0.7314890027046204,
-0.12220827490091324,
0.6585860252380371,
-0.826002299785614,
0.8090547323226929,
0.26159778237342834,
-0.4028806984424591,
-0.20292657613754272,
-0.3933030366897583,
0.586902916431427,
-0.17092837393283844,
0.2298494428396225,
0.0179410632699728,
0.021791592240333557,
0.6530519127845764,
-0.5617563724517822,
0.8150840401649475,
-0.29560545086860657,
-0.4291430413722992,
0.3705958425998688,
0.2385597676038742,
1.1359162330627441,
-0.33720311522483826,
-0.12049918621778488,
0.1616278439760208,
-0.4632206857204437,
-0.8517308235168457,
-0.7571879029273987,
0.8029494881629944,
-0.34633493423461914,
-0.41050007939338684,
-0.26150596141815186,
-0.419836163520813,
-0.27759644389152527,
0.11763393878936768,
0.02798854559659958,
0.7233841419219971,
0.21852010488510132,
-0.07970289885997772,
0.7798001766204834,
-0.16467051208019257,
0.4913761019706726,
0.6822509169578552,
-0.259533554315567,
-0.21236597001552582,
1.4689902067184448,
0.09624829888343811,
0.6036839485168457,
0.35930535197257996,
0.12417364865541458,
-0.07588318735361099,
-0.3864830434322357,
-0.45553767681121826,
0.2896677851676941,
-0.6872632503509521,
-0.20884181559085846,
-0.4735361933708191,
0.15433040261268616,
-0.046094752848148346,
-0.41402965784072876,
-0.9307782649993896,
-0.7317621111869812,
-0.00839174259454012,
-0.08782269060611725,
0.3354024589061737,
0.22816681861877441,
-0.22364379465579987,
0.3698387145996094,
-0.5910423994064331,
0.3919791281223297,
0.42868107557296753,
0.6634592413902283,
-0.06282112747430801,
-0.16219095885753632,
-0.2909865975379944,
-0.023407405242323875,
-0.32174429297447205,
-0.9789943099021912,
0.13484935462474823,
0.2919243574142456,
0.3550266623497009,
0.25635644793510437,
-0.12805604934692383,
0.7677093148231506,
-0.7826300859451294,
0.9610164165496826,
0.2909013628959656,
-0.9115654826164246,
0.6372854113578796,
-0.4680039882659912,
0.0029398768674582243,
0.34541526436805725,
0.002194399945437908,
-0.19292062520980835,
-0.550176203250885,
-0.6022747159004211,
-1.2533069849014282,
0.7001159191131592,
0.4008386433124542,
0.06355758756399155,
-0.32340168952941895,
0.3498254418373108,
-0.2954275608062744,
-0.106517493724823,
-0.661540150642395,
-0.7440273761749268,
0.19914735853672028,
0.21971678733825684,
-0.3192579746246338,
-0.6959748268127441,
-0.2912440299987793,
-0.10384117811918259,
1.076816439628601,
-0.09193200618028641,
0.3956650197505951,
0.13471989333629608,
-0.3431926667690277,
-0.6388444900512695,
0.25045204162597656,
0.9336427450180054,
0.5722373127937317,
-0.384463369846344,
0.3970381021499634,
-0.009219247847795486,
-0.2736539840698242,
0.6715736985206604,
-0.38770154118537903,
-0.1471601277589798,
-0.1499914526939392,
0.5726081132888794,
0.5179741382598877,
0.5219465494155884,
-0.6559021472930908,
0.6296138167381287,
0.17761731147766113,
0.06384582072496414,
-0.026087561622262,
-0.01636047661304474,
-0.08544447273015976,
0.21281877160072327,
0.1150384470820427,
0.43391960859298706,
0.08337349444627762,
-0.6868659257888794,
0.17929288744926453,
0.35707393288612366,
-0.6341791152954102,
-0.4235062897205353,
0.6188452839851379,
0.26446643471717834,
-0.6093989014625549,
0.40856194496154785,
-0.012953524477779865,
-0.5765416026115417,
0.8487998843193054,
0.7561334371566772,
0.9199426770210266,
-0.4278850257396698,
0.01330341026186943,
0.28273022174835205,
0.17877832055091858,
-0.3346126079559326,
0.11771844327449799,
0.026572762057185173,
-0.5303181409835815,
-0.6969305276870728,
-0.5750578045845032,
-0.23527391254901886,
-0.2680125832557678,
-0.483939528465271,
0.005807072389870882,
-0.22280913591384888,
-0.02362624555826187,
-0.0945470929145813,
-0.18279904127120972,
-0.13508349657058716,
0.021791543811559677,
-0.2660459280014038,
1.1496659517288208,
-1.1660345792770386,
0.9250406622886658,
0.7931362986564636,
-0.11859811097383499,
-0.6923942565917969,
-0.03249068185687065,
0.1302417665719986,
-1.0141916275024414,
0.9097011089324951,
-0.12381795793771744,
0.006360223051160574,
0.1317557692527771,
-0.22921720147132874,
-1.0883169174194336,
1.008908748626709,
0.666041910648346,
-0.21360071003437042,
0.39696821570396423,
-0.03170605003833771,
0.37777382135391235,
-0.12143080681562424,
0.21424418687820435,
0.6565922498703003,
0.7763979434967041,
-0.012948017567396164,
-0.7270004153251648,
0.22360149025917053,
-0.33341920375823975,
-0.20635999739170074,
0.3965272009372711,
-0.6767979860305786,
1.0027309656143188,
-0.015878826379776,
0.050118036568164825,
-0.08151956647634506,
0.28424307703971863,
0.2926401197910309,
0.12297496199607849,
0.6402668356895447,
0.5280793905258179,
0.5795300006866455,
0.03782140463590622,
1.5312786102294922,
-0.5961379408836365,
0.5892895460128784,
0.6542083621025085,
0.17880114912986755,
0.5753856897354126,
0.9158928394317627,
-0.5391888618469238,
0.43936479091644287,
0.5079115629196167,
0.2778262794017792,
0.6032686233520508,
0.5836973190307617,
-0.409781277179718,
-0.3762129545211792,
0.08910267055034637,
-0.35870933532714844,
-0.21539364755153656,
-0.12682287395000458,
-0.12938612699508667,
-0.19687330722808838,
-0.09751512855291367,
0.09482787549495697,
-0.1898566633462906,
-0.43627360463142395,
0.42383724451065063,
-0.0585779994726181,
-0.5989488959312439,
0.6637137532234192,
0.11870807409286499,
0.37248143553733826,
-0.6902100443840027,
-0.08735043555498123,
-0.420265793800354,
0.31134429574012756,
-0.25736290216445923,
-0.18420682847499847,
0.4250171482563019,
-0.18713971972465515,
-0.5785527229309082,
-0.625633716583252,
0.649001955986023,
-0.49297502636909485,
-0.629910409450531,
0.2850135862827301,
0.02395554631948471,
0.05105935409665108,
-0.12474081665277481,
-0.2150411158800125,
0.025731785222887993,
-0.03573951497673988,
-0.766772449016571,
0.6048035025596619,
0.1800331175327301,
-0.34014472365379333,
1.0725343227386475,
0.7592296004295349,
0.294260174036026,
0.3728298544883728,
-0.19436348974704742,
1.0643160343170166,
-0.5412670969963074,
-0.3258879482746124,
-0.9157228469848633,
0.6320492029190063,
0.1991603821516037,
0.04463563486933708,
0.7768529057502747,
0.49373793601989746,
0.28848016262054443,
-0.08014723658561707,
0.2424226850271225,
0.20287594199180603,
0.06460513174533844,
-0.7976595759391785,
0.39311689138412476,
-0.6549428105354309,
0.8716727495193481,
-0.2206246256828308,
-1.1044881343841553,
-0.6332193613052368,
0.4581490457057953,
-0.42224740982055664,
-0.290106862783432,
0.9298804998397827,
0.9140764474868774,
-0.3817219138145447,
-0.3255464732646942,
0.14551156759262085,
0.5637337565422058,
0.6180663704872131,
0.4366470277309418,
0.5183098912239075,
-0.6559039354324341,
0.30898964405059814,
-0.17334821820259094,
-0.5471861362457275,
-0.32872921228408813,
-1.0541746616363525,
-0.6188095808029175,
-0.24371598660945892,
-0.48813745379447937,
-0.5982365012168884,
-0.034090593457221985,
0.8593429923057556,
0.6803379654884338,
-0.9592235088348389,
0.01157139241695404,
-0.2938718795776367,
0.48009032011032104,
-0.35743165016174316,
-0.17837867140769958,
0.565575897693634,
-0.6915476322174072,
-0.48878076672554016,
0.6075963973999023,
0.5233514308929443,
-0.2180141657590866,
-0.4476373493671417,
-0.1362997144460678,
-0.34720051288604736,
0.40745073556900024,
0.41377758979797363,
0.5499611496925354,
-0.5228855013847351,
-0.44909873604774475,
-0.3232864737510681,
-0.10284195095300674,
0.21379421651363373,
1.3706872463226318,
-0.7677210569381714,
0.33555689454078674,
0.3258161246776581,
0.5403637886047363,
0.411055326461792,
-0.2636457681655884,
0.8612894415855408,
-0.9545493721961975,
0.40147167444229126,
-0.09828317165374756,
0.4660433828830719,
0.13887400925159454,
-0.1403632014989853,
0.29493626952171326,
0.5216360092163086,
-0.5842580795288086,
-1.0224053859710693,
0.5252800583839417,
-0.9450544118881226,
-0.05477939173579216,
1.4418001174926758,
-0.4641134738922119,
-0.6003125309944153,
-0.04582632705569267,
-0.08832797408103943,
-0.1739421784877777,
-0.290803462266922,
1.0201034545898438,
0.4696810245513916,
-0.16843564808368683,
0.15638050436973572,
-0.18091309070587158,
0.6330537796020508,
0.5000410676002502,
-0.4361973702907562,
0.15553541481494904,
0.40119120478630066,
0.38297200202941895,
0.4268454313278198,
0.9853354692459106,
0.017618706449866295,
0.16359484195709229,
0.04974551498889923,
-0.019556820392608643,
-0.0721423551440239,
-0.16930362582206726,
-0.26392093300819397,
0.32733672857284546,
-0.12138912826776505,
0.06798604130744934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00742v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00742v1
|
Dialect prejudice predicts AI decisions about people's character, employability, and criminality
| 2024-03-01T18:43:09 | 2024-03-01T18:43:09 |
Valentin Hofmann, Pratyusha Ria Kalluri, Dan Jurafsky, Sharese King
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Hundreds of millions of people now interact with language models, with uses
ranging from serving as a writing aid to informing hiring decisions. Yet these
language models are known to perpetuate systematic racial prejudices, making
their judgments biased in problematic ways about groups like African Americans.
While prior research has focused on overt racism in language models, social
scientists have argued that racism with a more subtle character has developed
over time. It is unknown whether this covert racism manifests in language
models. Here, we demonstrate that language models embody covert racism in the
form of dialect prejudice: we extend research showing that Americans hold
raciolinguistic stereotypes about speakers of African American English and find
that language models have the same prejudice, exhibiting covert stereotypes
that are more negative than any human stereotypes about African Americans ever
experimentally recorded, although closest to the ones from before the civil
rights movement. By contrast, the language models' overt stereotypes about
African Americans are much more positive. We demonstrate that dialect prejudice
has the potential for harmful consequences by asking language models to make
hypothetical decisions about people, based only on how they speak. Language
models are more likely to suggest that speakers of African American English be
assigned less prestigious jobs, be convicted of crimes, and be sentenced to
death. Finally, we show that existing methods for alleviating racial bias in
language models such as human feedback training do not mitigate the dialect
prejudice, but can exacerbate the discrepancy between covert and overt
stereotypes, by teaching language models to superficially conceal the racism
that they maintain on a deeper level. Our findings have far-reaching
implications for the fair and safe employment of language technology.
|
[
-0.381387323141098,
-0.6091333031654358,
0.6106244325637817,
-0.11623473465442657,
0.12047384679317474,
-0.2311319261789322,
-0.31854239106178284,
-0.6379058957099915,
0.4523182809352875,
0.7619266510009766,
-0.11138760298490524,
-0.0986633375287056,
-0.41011831164360046,
-0.42304131388664246,
-0.5947861671447754,
0.7796183824539185,
0.5348160862922668,
0.2924526035785675,
0.24680350720882416,
-0.17800651490688324,
-0.2518756091594696,
-1.0044159889221191,
-0.556118905544281,
-0.29716843366622925,
0.4265645444393158,
0.3300033509731293,
1.005415439605713,
0.39445993304252625,
0.05122803896665573,
0.30198580026626587,
-0.0002082143910229206,
-0.5439620614051819,
-0.46465009450912476,
0.22637228667736053,
-0.35562899708747864,
-0.8336355686187744,
-0.1045447364449501,
0.29021579027175903,
-0.05990706384181976,
0.9727301001548767,
-0.10512936860322952,
-0.13699068129062653,
-0.31203722953796387,
0.6477945446968079,
-0.513420581817627,
-0.015081433579325676,
-0.8573641180992126,
-0.21274824440479279,
-0.5599960684776306,
0.5041110515594482,
-0.384919673204422,
-0.4716086685657501,
-0.15980631113052368,
-0.24998489022254944,
0.639354944229126,
0.19244587421417236,
0.8645758032798767,
0.11088542640209198,
-0.7426100969314575,
-0.277314692735672,
-0.8247464299201965,
0.7033728361129761,
-0.9236215949058533,
0.4586586356163025,
0.636849582195282,
0.5605611205101013,
0.30850908160209656,
-0.3320693373680115,
-0.9030393362045288,
-0.6409996151924133,
-0.1265467405319214,
0.08380868285894394,
0.22010602056980133,
0.22290544211864471,
0.43966609239578247,
0.20688606798648834,
-0.5498153567314148,
0.1458897590637207,
-0.7287535667419434,
-0.21122083067893982,
0.7216482162475586,
0.18142788112163544,
0.32676059007644653,
-0.12413301318883896,
0.052894413471221924,
-0.08684088289737701,
-0.5981180667877197,
-0.07222051918506622,
0.6191548109054565,
0.516861617565155,
0.07479409873485565,
0.35618138313293457,
-0.11462725698947906,
0.276466965675354,
-0.294589102268219,
0.20798780024051666,
0.0774465799331665,
0.11855889856815338,
0.08321858942508698,
-0.015602211467921734,
0.40130701661109924,
0.4978671967983246,
0.8564897775650024,
-0.11545418947935104,
-0.19351498782634735,
0.8222976326942444,
0.3367646634578705,
-0.4127136766910553,
-0.10825751721858978,
-0.01648617535829544,
-0.14723023772239685,
-0.1760581135749817,
0.04886164516210556,
-0.8827952146530151,
-0.6889846324920654,
0.04292291775345802,
0.0964006558060646,
-0.31270354986190796,
-0.20839735865592957,
0.17239980399608612,
-0.4848295748233795,
0.14558997750282288,
0.16411930322647095,
-0.9678750038146973,
0.26260241866111755,
0.7777458429336548,
0.3773635923862457,
0.24008223414421082,
-0.1619645208120346,
0.16756080090999603,
0.11226208508014679,
-0.5182863473892212,
0.16647134721279144,
-0.6662580370903015,
-0.32478973269462585,
0.28923219442367554,
0.06948960572481155,
0.11607515066862106,
-0.6422773003578186,
0.6405040621757507,
-0.35037240386009216,
0.13511699438095093,
-0.4042622447013855,
-0.19868363440036774,
-0.25570768117904663,
-0.019678890705108643,
-0.436125248670578,
0.6028717160224915,
-0.05741332098841667,
-0.5597782135009766,
0.5256942510604858,
-0.2081923931837082,
-0.4939204454421997,
-0.09918162226676941,
-0.153617262840271,
-0.46998608112335205,
0.3178097903728485,
-0.06961874663829803,
0.03411458805203438,
-0.18387411534786224,
0.31672385334968567,
-0.7399165034294128,
-0.30527129769325256,
0.3049710988998413,
-0.2392597645521164,
1.1404540538787842,
0.3257073163986206,
-0.6620151996612549,
-0.4901432693004608,
-0.48801717162132263,
-0.39325833320617676,
0.2630195915699005,
-0.01557875331491232,
-0.8007665276527405,
0.07772529125213623,
-0.3452877104282379,
0.12312784045934677,
-0.26655998826026917,
-0.8301324844360352,
-0.02922920137643814,
-0.4777434468269348,
0.13270732760429382,
0.7605876922607422,
-0.20774880051612854,
0.5844802856445312,
-0.48683100938796997,
0.47044289112091064,
-0.21523338556289673,
0.33809947967529297,
0.20542339980602264,
-0.6206973791122437,
-1.3034014701843262,
0.18959806859493256,
0.06770685315132141,
0.4701540768146515,
-0.41500943899154663,
0.16007129848003387,
-0.0335807166993618,
-0.31367045640945435,
-0.5206161141395569,
-0.1130489930510521,
0.23660902678966522,
0.3995650112628937,
0.2708582580089569,
-0.2514386475086212,
-0.307233989238739,
-1.07835853099823,
-0.6613388061523438,
-0.49332067370414734,
-0.0630129724740982,
0.49634355306625366,
0.3447840213775635,
-0.19467011094093323,
0.7561787366867065,
-0.31771284341812134,
-0.3193829357624054,
-0.17240400612354279,
0.20194579660892487,
0.06195785850286484,
0.3117307424545288,
0.8471368551254272,
-0.4798114001750946,
-0.45784035325050354,
-0.009164457209408283,
-0.47699692845344543,
-0.3882052004337311,
-0.03507426381111145,
0.03315652534365654,
0.1600951850414276,
0.5913410782814026,
-0.4891684949398041,
0.44704362750053406,
0.26135677099227905,
-0.5587329864501953,
0.5706238746643066,
0.34062302112579346,
0.009616771712899208,
-0.7011736035346985,
-0.2894451916217804,
-0.1414593756198883,
0.06679132580757141,
-0.7144280672073364,
0.2559416890144348,
-0.03584204614162445,
-0.40654999017715454,
-0.049746960401535034,
0.7276567220687866,
-0.29914820194244385,
0.16987080872058868,
-0.03782821446657181,
0.007645863573998213,
0.3022698163986206,
0.25329840183258057,
0.04852234572172165,
0.37753450870513916,
0.3847505748271942,
-0.38724222779273987,
0.16486166417598724,
-0.01693873107433319,
-0.449392169713974,
0.2577352523803711,
-0.5172449350357056,
0.2283451408147812,
-0.4701097905635834,
-0.03879295662045479,
-0.8244054913520813,
0.003597310744225979,
-0.22794269025325775,
-0.5736100673675537,
0.3202654719352722,
-0.1313951015472412,
0.3137061893939972,
-0.5422667860984802,
-0.19619804620742798,
0.23025046288967133,
0.649005115032196,
-0.27759188413619995,
0.3129647374153137,
0.35068824887275696,
-0.5580481886863708,
-0.6005155444145203,
-1.2046880722045898,
0.14243173599243164,
-0.14850737154483795,
-0.631744384765625,
0.09709986299276352,
0.2995224595069885,
-0.9986124634742737,
-0.21098175644874573,
0.06858324259519577,
-0.20224744081497192,
-0.07890336960554123,
0.2916499674320221,
0.0923934355378151,
-0.18645310401916504,
0.05487287417054176,
-0.045790448784828186,
0.1678645759820938,
0.27797290682792664,
-0.0169881172478199,
0.3384249806404114,
0.4660801887512207,
-0.3923525810241699,
0.2625948488712311,
0.6239567995071411,
0.7694602012634277,
-0.06228001043200493,
0.7587123513221741,
0.05684714764356613,
-0.05390673875808716,
-0.5210501551628113,
-0.9875229001045227,
-0.5715354681015015,
-0.4427984654903412,
0.5024243593215942,
-0.15191996097564697,
-0.689512312412262,
0.5042501091957092,
0.3026489317417145,
-0.04621635004878044,
-0.03474992513656616,
0.29905232787132263,
-0.21115492284297943,
0.8611586689949036,
0.8132251501083374,
-0.3296736180782318,
0.7119014263153076,
-0.197157084941864,
0.3827608525753021,
-0.24077582359313965,
-0.1588451862335205,
-0.8846642374992371,
-0.09878234565258026,
-0.4429704248905182,
-0.3375588655471802,
0.32889750599861145,
-0.06002415344119072,
-0.3075820803642273,
0.04919532313942909,
-0.17158541083335876,
0.4905204474925995,
0.6267107129096985,
0.08711294084787369,
-0.1442515105009079,
-0.021872228011488914,
-0.2853742241859436,
-0.26280850172042847,
-0.33988672494888306,
-0.4606747627258301,
1.0097332000732422,
0.31727486848831177,
0.870642900466919,
0.24124054610729218,
0.5210463404655457,
0.5000222325325012,
0.33986997604370117,
-0.5078535079956055,
0.4786311984062195,
-0.13786254823207855,
-1.196415662765503,
-0.3446834087371826,
-0.2659090757369995,
-0.7486985325813293,
0.1658703088760376,
0.04348335787653923,
-0.5558822751045227,
0.7495619654655457,
0.33921220898628235,
-0.035276733338832855,
0.16927194595336914,
-0.9849080443382263,
0.7689619660377502,
-0.3316974937915802,
-0.37783101201057434,
-0.4345937967300415,
-0.5661455392837524,
0.5758551955223083,
-0.11530987918376923,
0.49384522438049316,
-0.20605160295963287,
0.3574794828891754,
0.37456899881362915,
-0.8176666498184204,
0.9471669793128967,
-0.3399403691291809,
0.11669906973838806,
-0.03838740661740303,
0.38578036427497864,
0.5387015342712402,
-0.24080577492713928,
-0.6613850593566895,
0.37157946825027466,
-0.5800849795341492,
-0.5280864834785461,
-0.5957028865814209,
0.3656740188598633,
-0.6786109209060669,
-1.0120593309402466,
-0.34759846329689026,
-0.29302096366882324,
-0.21675831079483032,
0.02429923787713051,
0.2322165071964264,
0.21823562681674957,
-0.24716858565807343,
-0.267057865858078,
0.2651938199996948,
-0.42237719893455505,
0.19067168235778809,
0.6360505819320679,
-0.13816218078136444,
-0.03769801929593086,
0.7962459921836853,
0.03562947362661362,
0.7197895646095276,
-0.0244478490203619,
0.21546806395053864,
-0.18760523200035095,
-0.45401355624198914,
-0.0480257049202919,
0.486642450094223,
-0.7290951013565063,
0.03833582252264023,
-0.5070415139198303,
-0.009764095768332481,
-0.9064265489578247,
-0.5217691659927368,
-0.22164955735206604,
-0.7736793756484985,
0.2703094482421875,
-0.22457462549209595,
0.1321769654750824,
0.8955061435699463,
-0.11631408333778381,
0.3525976836681366,
-0.1602347493171692,
0.3632580041885376,
0.8430243134498596,
-0.008755584247410297,
-0.0890074223279953,
-0.9082513451576233,
-0.1932486742734909,
0.17066188156604767,
-0.1995597779750824,
-0.9748391509056091,
0.4034295380115509,
0.1618756353855133,
0.5506370663642883,
0.6358627676963806,
0.3843878209590912,
0.1619066596031189,
-0.49426382780075073,
0.8814163208007812,
-0.04496325924992561,
-0.7890467047691345,
0.3644636869430542,
-0.2448393553495407,
-0.18721434473991394,
0.525507926940918,
0.5382933616638184,
-0.7738993167877197,
-1.024327039718628,
-0.38713186979293823,
-0.7292428016662598,
0.752887487411499,
-0.06483057141304016,
0.5347233414649963,
-0.17972932755947113,
0.09182138741016388,
-0.07951416820287704,
0.06446830928325653,
-1.0701484680175781,
-0.4210084080696106,
-0.6939979791641235,
0.10531259328126907,
-0.2578295171260834,
-0.5940807461738586,
-0.04623017460107803,
-0.3289138376712799,
0.5645571947097778,
0.17199240624904633,
0.020037328824400902,
-0.12229087203741074,
-0.15048184990882874,
0.02322736196219921,
0.47136959433555603,
0.3948712944984436,
0.35427096486091614,
-0.13391223549842834,
0.23197509348392487,
-0.02442965656518936,
-0.24377675354480743,
0.34396037459373474,
0.009238306432962418,
-0.43934524059295654,
0.1692807823419571,
0.40277954936027527,
0.8373563289642334,
-0.4580017030239105,
-0.23698215186595917,
0.5841579437255859,
0.15289555490016937,
0.03759056329727173,
-0.2525494396686554,
0.028952917084097862,
0.04227809980511665,
0.15598221123218536,
0.16843563318252563,
0.10387279838323593,
0.29508623480796814,
-1.130946397781372,
0.014822951517999172,
0.8067095875740051,
-0.25772279500961304,
-0.3220127820968628,
0.8300512433052063,
0.5645832419395447,
-0.3817325532436371,
0.58455491065979,
-0.1424330323934555,
-1.0564391613006592,
0.6564352512359619,
0.4881725013256073,
0.8265430331230164,
-0.6410980224609375,
0.11727098375558853,
0.19687911868095398,
0.779114305973053,
0.22590339183807373,
-0.048417828977108,
-0.010445619001984596,
-1.184801697731018,
-0.024786600843071938,
-0.7561666965484619,
-0.2474898397922516,
0.01707005500793457,
-0.48447439074516296,
0.27901265025138855,
-0.4047478139400482,
-0.31745097041130066,
0.050535764545202255,
-0.3524235188961029,
-0.1898583322763443,
0.246224507689476,
0.3743847608566284,
0.7876682877540588,
-1.2048228979110718,
0.9187552332878113,
0.39398103952407837,
-0.44050636887550354,
-0.56553715467453,
0.237342968583107,
0.1898653358221054,
-0.7588602304458618,
0.8903018236160278,
0.11226406693458557,
0.05423237383365631,
-0.29794150590896606,
-0.24912558495998383,
-0.3713715076446533,
0.20758208632469177,
0.6930707097053528,
-0.4966152608394623,
-0.23415707051753998,
0.6072418689727783,
0.41454991698265076,
0.005662581883370876,
0.43783140182495117,
0.6392181515693665,
0.517408013343811,
-0.14448556303977966,
-0.9906111359596252,
-0.11507969349622726,
-0.21905814111232758,
0.03782947361469269,
0.10969489067792892,
-0.5795402526855469,
1.1443419456481934,
-0.3361513614654541,
-0.21994154155254364,
-0.2812061607837677,
0.18226853013038635,
-0.3308100402355194,
0.15335503220558167,
0.4812459945678711,
0.4806502163410187,
0.474791020154953,
-0.18050570785999298,
0.9995326399803162,
-0.1902771145105362,
0.034013211727142334,
0.8100619912147522,
-0.5300060510635376,
0.15236391127109528,
0.20171043276786804,
-0.2525625228881836,
0.6996448636054993,
-0.03127455338835716,
0.36872246861457825,
0.47589313983917236,
0.274751752614975,
-0.42085206508636475,
-0.1846948266029358,
-0.2256011962890625,
-0.3245534598827362,
0.46955400705337524,
0.5632334351539612,
-0.3797541856765747,
-0.0415608175098896,
0.006102759391069412,
0.16452689468860626,
0.5544964671134949,
-0.23954829573631287,
0.45348861813545227,
0.1399906724691391,
-0.5636237859725952,
0.681290864944458,
-0.035540103912353516,
0.7376691699028015,
-0.5866778492927551,
0.10880301147699356,
-0.7950136065483093,
0.33058565855026245,
-0.07568968832492828,
-0.19554118812084198,
0.3728829622268677,
-0.32291436195373535,
-0.3439410924911499,
-0.07483706623315811,
0.45562103390693665,
-0.5591809749603271,
-0.29264384508132935,
0.50739985704422,
0.20287059247493744,
0.11647744476795197,
-0.2638988792896271,
-0.68421471118927,
-0.0272431168705225,
0.20377442240715027,
-0.02353297360241413,
0.09345932304859161,
0.4385764002799988,
-0.25285017490386963,
0.6622444987297058,
0.3904115557670593,
0.6614241600036621,
0.44924014806747437,
0.351261168718338,
0.6278594136238098,
-0.8947828412055969,
-0.5565187335014343,
-0.6455815434455872,
0.282274454832077,
-0.34721988439559937,
0.13846071064472198,
0.8057582378387451,
0.338209331035614,
0.9467136859893799,
0.02465866692364216,
0.9196208715438843,
0.002038350561633706,
0.7455443739891052,
-0.3564489483833313,
0.8770795464515686,
-0.47050753235816956,
0.2520447373390198,
-0.4573005437850952,
-0.7737315893173218,
0.044788334518671036,
0.5925131440162659,
-0.4378358721733093,
0.49674978852272034,
0.6859286427497864,
1.1769568920135498,
0.000007094472493918147,
-0.06433606147766113,
0.7154509425163269,
0.49596190452575684,
0.19292306900024414,
0.24628017842769623,
0.9312413930892944,
0.008390516974031925,
0.4367997348308563,
-0.45700305700302124,
-0.1593836098909378,
-0.28069183230400085,
-0.27141594886779785,
-0.9435223340988159,
-0.31975793838500977,
-0.04302457720041275,
-0.33100593090057373,
0.3903728723526001,
0.3306654393672943,
0.8777104616165161,
-1.00087571144104,
-0.47671639919281006,
0.08307554572820663,
0.13065055012702942,
0.15039829909801483,
-0.33665624260902405,
-0.35992059111595154,
-0.27370110154151917,
-0.8249460458755493,
0.27168938517570496,
0.0718008503317833,
0.15029893815517426,
-0.2665095031261444,
-0.023540852591395378,
0.08428466320037842,
0.4157455563545227,
0.3850865066051483,
0.48763248324394226,
-0.7540880441665649,
-0.29163703322410583,
-0.34350377321243286,
-0.2751311957836151,
-0.32309356331825256,
1.0658490657806396,
-0.589625358581543,
0.5249603390693665,
0.20638717710971832,
0.18226617574691772,
0.3884029984474182,
-0.0772814229130745,
0.8790261745452881,
-0.8019973039627075,
0.7442663908004761,
0.5577602386474609,
0.5628519058227539,
0.30068862438201904,
-0.3607315123081207,
0.36258465051651,
0.39762812852859497,
-0.4910120964050293,
-0.9212445020675659,
0.5766507983207703,
-0.2271862030029297,
-0.5426749587059021,
0.9706329107284546,
0.07622292637825012,
0.09219492226839066,
-0.6684082746505737,
-0.04066804423928261,
0.1176321879029274,
-0.417915940284729,
0.9935001730918884,
0.465862512588501,
0.13712531328201294,
0.012093853205442429,
-0.5310634970664978,
0.7585389614105225,
0.8964584469795227,
-0.35326820611953735,
0.3455314040184021,
0.6779918670654297,
0.09599777311086655,
0.2576194405555725,
0.5013874769210815,
0.1349390149116516,
0.20216244459152222,
0.2656223773956299,
0.472187340259552,
0.027183489874005318,
-0.24174360930919647,
-0.3511742353439331,
-0.060475077480077744,
0.3010219633579254,
0.08715765178203583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00724v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00724v1
|
Few-Shot Relation Extraction with Hybrid Visual Evidence
| 2024-03-01T18:20:11 | 2024-03-01T18:20:11 |
Jiaying Gong, Hoda Eldardiry
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The goal of few-shot relation extraction is to predict relations between name
entities in a sentence when only a few labeled instances are available for
training. Existing few-shot relation extraction methods focus on uni-modal
information such as text only. This reduces performance when there are no clear
contexts between the name entities described in text. We propose a multi-modal
few-shot relation extraction model (MFS-HVE) that leverages both textual and
visual semantic information to learn a multi-modal representation jointly. The
MFS-HVE includes semantic feature extractors and multi-modal fusion components.
The MFS-HVE semantic feature extractors are developed to extract both textual
and visual features. The visual features include global image features and
local object features within the image. The MFS-HVE multi-modal fusion unit
integrates information from various modalities using image-guided attention,
object-guided attention, and hybrid feature attention to fully capture the
semantic interaction between visual regions of images and relevant texts.
Extensive experiments conducted on two public datasets demonstrate that
semantic visual information significantly improves the performance of few-shot
relation prediction.
|
[
-0.4207969307899475,
-0.9458211660385132,
0.6600161790847778,
-0.2838960587978363,
-0.46763503551483154,
-0.24184678494930267,
-0.017897751182317734,
-0.763177216053009,
0.1894386112689972,
0.42897921800613403,
-0.8289400935173035,
-0.26720917224884033,
-0.6278368234634399,
0.19077427685260773,
-0.09783674776554108,
0.9238623380661011,
0.2601769268512726,
0.12355592101812363,
-0.27215489745140076,
-0.12457098066806793,
-0.3912127614021301,
-0.20450147986412048,
0.11436433345079422,
-0.24729545414447784,
0.6197512149810791,
0.4250444769859314,
0.6603506803512573,
0.5417481660842896,
0.7572728991508484,
0.3341984450817108,
0.22570504248142242,
0.36023834347724915,
-0.6745853424072266,
0.09918206185102463,
0.0352247878909111,
-0.2960434854030609,
-0.23696021735668182,
0.04669718071818352,
0.7000837922096252,
0.20118509232997894,
0.4215238094329834,
0.12131871283054352,
-0.24125166237354279,
0.1755020171403885,
-1.0149717330932617,
0.3618309795856476,
-0.698485791683197,
-0.156195729970932,
-0.5380783081054688,
-0.36373573541641235,
-0.382563054561615,
0.2756485044956207,
0.3602915108203888,
-0.8198667764663696,
-0.06875790655612946,
0.200792595744133,
1.1791408061981201,
0.08173998445272446,
-0.6881714463233948,
0.34400731325149536,
-0.7106824517250061,
0.7839275002479553,
-0.3202127516269684,
0.5635488629341125,
0.4159136414527893,
0.45157620310783386,
-0.21475139260292053,
-0.37174394726753235,
-0.7010716795921326,
-0.05660450831055641,
-0.5424498319625854,
0.28775250911712646,
-0.11776882410049438,
0.03164273872971535,
0.2297193706035614,
0.2434101551771164,
-0.245614156126976,
-0.17982809245586395,
-0.3671450614929199,
-0.20390984416007996,
0.424258291721344,
0.3777742385864258,
0.18978632986545563,
-0.845503568649292,
-0.9611083269119263,
0.06034369766712189,
-0.551412045955658,
0.05091513693332672,
-0.1958504021167755,
0.22301433980464935,
-0.30027538537979126,
0.955906093120575,
-0.20489448308944702,
0.802510142326355,
-0.15172332525253296,
-0.9540295600891113,
0.12776899337768555,
-0.7495712041854858,
-0.4088185429573059,
-0.33550432324409485,
1.0958340167999268,
0.24572136998176575,
0.10056625306606293,
-0.12861573696136475,
-0.11589071899652481,
0.2499540150165558,
-0.2191556841135025,
-0.763702929019928,
-0.0282755084335804,
-0.2200389802455902,
-0.6952681541442871,
-0.2501741051673889,
0.22768084704875946,
-1.1341090202331543,
-0.2810012996196747,
-0.20307792723178864,
0.4933623671531677,
-0.658825159072876,
-0.32280024886131287,
-0.41586023569107056,
-0.6008358597755432,
0.39976370334625244,
0.36019080877304077,
-0.7722921967506409,
0.16862675547599792,
0.5489386320114136,
0.738269031047821,
-0.30823060870170593,
-0.566500186920166,
-0.8004469275474548,
0.6710138320922852,
0.296688973903656,
1.0655040740966797,
-0.8825299739837646,
-0.2718620300292969,
-0.09229128062725067,
0.0041903965175151825,
-0.17326493561267853,
-0.19438104331493378,
0.17047031223773956,
-0.49289077520370483,
0.4462401866912842,
-0.18227985501289368,
-0.5178777575492859,
-0.04890482500195503,
0.3245934247970581,
-0.818848192691803,
0.9115023612976074,
0.06042522192001343,
-1.0150407552719116,
0.5775473713874817,
-0.3593125343322754,
-0.34518784284591675,
0.0660846158862114,
-0.658711850643158,
-0.4158669710159302,
-0.15910983085632324,
0.2382485568523407,
0.5367600917816162,
-0.41274017095565796,
-0.21262168884277344,
-0.45838260650634766,
-0.07770096510648727,
0.18359629809856415,
-0.20870831608772278,
0.38309353590011597,
-0.11582373827695847,
0.16788344085216522,
0.07371325045824051,
-0.9472621083259583,
-0.43117251992225647,
0.20054148137569427,
-0.3684804439544678,
-0.6065584421157837,
-0.32290735840797424,
0.24998274445533752,
0.5573745369911194,
-0.02679087035357952,
-0.7844868898391724,
0.08094464987516403,
-0.4073095917701721,
-0.18199507892131805,
0.4093361496925354,
0.5166975855827332,
0.7175659537315369,
-0.19407330453395844,
0.5354461073875427,
0.45122048258781433,
-0.025630218908190727,
-0.7098760008811951,
-0.5235639810562134,
-0.5885562300682068,
-0.7140778303146362,
0.17197422683238983,
0.37216460704803467,
-1.2164560556411743,
0.11844942718744278,
-0.38280609250068665,
-0.0163420457392931,
-0.2999103367328644,
0.548677384853363,
0.48653683066368103,
0.5674416422843933,
0.34284746646881104,
-0.15421782433986664,
-0.419359028339386,
-0.9872219562530518,
-0.14552338421344757,
-0.12625451385974884,
0.2021445333957672,
0.39475202560424805,
0.6904674768447876,
-0.05726658180356026,
1.3127952814102173,
-0.6720044612884521,
-0.8800961375236511,
-0.38010114431381226,
0.35686734318733215,
-0.14949342608451843,
0.2048802226781845,
0.570827066898346,
-0.8474171757698059,
-0.13605700433254242,
0.09531442821025848,
-0.900195300579071,
0.6026636362075806,
-0.14939942955970764,
-0.3688449561595917,
-0.06688814610242844,
0.15393786132335663,
-0.8397748470306396,
0.5084326863288879,
0.12752138078212738,
-0.23009757697582245,
0.3194204568862915,
0.22666975855827332,
0.11911594122648239,
-1.1233313083648682,
-0.2737607955932617,
0.4488641619682312,
-0.4957449436187744,
-0.36854758858680725,
-0.1564861685037613,
0.015305318869650364,
-0.011660175397992134,
-0.7786083817481995,
0.6274855136871338,
-0.5881098508834839,
-0.21200482547283173,
-0.20934435725212097,
0.2648988664150238,
0.10742857307195663,
0.49513909220695496,
0.28336113691329956,
0.34957945346832275,
0.4583737850189209,
-0.3105417490005493,
0.4324588477611542,
0.5288925170898438,
-0.02274814061820507,
0.5506010055541992,
-0.10370039194822311,
-0.1299281269311905,
-0.24348704516887665,
0.16888543963432312,
-0.808371901512146,
-0.48115667700767517,
0.26461511850357056,
-0.3265179991722107,
0.32905399799346924,
-0.3867902159690857,
-0.419009804725647,
-0.1286369115114212,
-0.47868847846984863,
0.3815781772136688,
0.03492981567978859,
-0.3282657861709595,
0.7701340913772583,
0.3286518454551697,
0.10573948174715042,
-0.46862685680389404,
-0.7458042502403259,
-0.09323305636644363,
0.011930985376238823,
-0.7024345993995667,
0.2843679189682007,
0.5487677454948425,
-0.07308197766542435,
0.2905711531639099,
0.027722207829356194,
-0.574533998966217,
-0.19764426350593567,
0.330483078956604,
0.7405223846435547,
-0.41979312896728516,
0.42309844493865967,
-0.12514443695545197,
-0.32320302724838257,
-0.24760791659355164,
0.3754879832267761,
0.12041370570659637,
-0.0027643428184092045,
-0.03363500162959099,
-0.5826125741004944,
0.6399630904197693,
0.6327353715896606,
-0.36286625266075134,
0.7665451169013977,
0.8203372359275818,
-0.6582531332969666,
0.204946830868721,
-0.5874001383781433,
-0.43851161003112793,
-0.33830809593200684,
0.32502350211143494,
-0.6823284029960632,
-0.710665762424469,
0.2045697122812271,
-0.2839944362640381,
-0.3168955147266388,
0.47288835048675537,
0.4283211827278137,
-0.22461126744747162,
0.6945765614509583,
1.006205439567566,
-0.06005432456731796,
0.6735835671424866,
-0.4681265652179718,
-0.09400174766778946,
-0.649392306804657,
-0.43075838685035706,
-0.12821945548057556,
-0.13997650146484375,
-0.2901216745376587,
-0.12149441242218018,
0.5868155360221863,
0.06385823339223862,
0.31812405586242676,
0.5659613609313965,
0.00010343731992179528,
0.5706220865249634,
0.4179476797580719,
0.3864023685455322,
0.6695674657821655,
-0.12344501167535782,
0.016579994931817055,
-0.373904824256897,
-0.6327232718467712,
-0.3376665711402893,
0.7794374823570251,
0.2499651312828064,
0.8450818657875061,
0.1365129053592682,
0.9618510007858276,
-0.182308629155159,
0.133649080991745,
-1.106360673904419,
0.2947220504283905,
0.052680984139442444,
-0.6793416142463684,
-0.20083168148994446,
-0.32509371638298035,
-0.8777106404304504,
0.5657384991645813,
-1.1238017082214355,
-0.6993073225021362,
0.3429425358772278,
-0.10154198110103607,
-0.5233117341995239,
-0.10167454928159714,
-0.7540582418441772,
0.9625168442726135,
-0.20904549956321716,
-0.46699923276901245,
-0.10949410498142242,
-0.7935492396354675,
0.8264347314834595,
0.02831248939037323,
0.07979673892259598,
-0.19050250947475433,
-0.09418760985136032,
0.7173089981079102,
-0.31493300199508667,
0.8241055607795715,
0.206272155046463,
0.3820400536060333,
0.05058744549751282,
0.056788135319948196,
0.2706739008426666,
-0.051915645599365234,
0.24794207513332367,
-0.11135796457529068,
0.15334923565387726,
-0.17410677671432495,
-0.49720117449760437,
0.4878571331501007,
-0.47146856784820557,
-0.1392781138420105,
-0.5038160085678101,
-0.45151713490486145,
-0.1875080019235611,
0.36176836490631104,
0.3986841142177582,
0.3763231635093689,
-0.348125159740448,
0.007650826126337051,
0.21887566149234772,
0.3065018057823181,
0.7895644903182983,
0.15374068915843964,
-0.1266285926103592,
-0.5845409035682678,
0.7710079550743103,
-0.05837291479110718,
0.2551954984664917,
0.4774790406227112,
0.2305716574192047,
-0.10898220539093018,
0.06466519832611084,
-0.49936771392822266,
0.4679219424724579,
-0.7015203833580017,
-0.5887958407402039,
-0.5767451524734497,
0.02861088328063488,
-0.3118428587913513,
0.10140906274318695,
-0.3618813157081604,
-0.29208651185035706,
-0.455667108297348,
0.12475859373807907,
0.5452581644058228,
0.5707477331161499,
0.34003719687461853,
0.3859996199607849,
-1.1880683898925781,
0.9296529293060303,
0.4999758005142212,
-0.13914375007152557,
-0.3222726583480835,
-0.13939709961414337,
0.0032341983169317245,
-0.3676851987838745,
-0.42606550455093384,
-1.2313865423202515,
0.31829971075057983,
0.41090139746665955,
0.4400670826435089,
0.7000181078910828,
-0.05807378143072128,
0.8854683637619019,
-0.28192970156669617,
0.6145670413970947,
0.8173814415931702,
-0.6185944676399231,
0.7626572251319885,
-0.28159376978874207,
0.20107229053974152,
0.6816471219062805,
0.34559935331344604,
0.013843778520822525,
-0.09164198487997055,
-0.5196442604064941,
-0.21719126403331757,
0.780512273311615,
0.32039815187454224,
-0.17551878094673157,
0.1642124503850937,
0.12518906593322754,
0.22596170008182526,
0.17784970998764038,
-0.9173383712768555,
-0.23753465712070465,
0.15483182668685913,
-0.12650015950202942,
0.30831417441368103,
-0.2707298696041107,
-0.31406286358833313,
-0.3383827209472656,
0.21960529685020447,
-0.2611736059188843,
0.2592972218990326,
0.137229785323143,
-0.4491727948188782,
-0.2556246221065521,
0.2928852438926697,
0.40396371483802795,
0.57976895570755,
-0.21644337475299835,
0.3089161515235901,
0.06466875225305557,
-0.08656425029039383,
0.08316928148269653,
0.10424487292766571,
-0.099183589220047,
0.17498546838760376,
0.6988918781280518,
0.639569103717804,
0.5697503089904785,
-0.3061825931072235,
1.1411598920822144,
0.09706172347068787,
-0.01909707859158516,
0.04284643009305,
-0.11425864696502686,
-0.09453747421503067,
0.4358357787132263,
0.15724699199199677,
0.19631828367710114,
0.25194188952445984,
-0.8556463122367859,
0.42438313364982605,
0.5505252480506897,
-0.26260438561439514,
-0.25492024421691895,
0.3952907919883728,
0.3524326980113983,
0.07517141103744507,
0.20383092761039734,
-0.11516299098730087,
-0.4536265432834625,
0.17914411425590515,
0.5194982290267944,
0.6724278330802917,
0.31058961153030396,
0.21152158081531525,
0.24882672727108002,
0.1402284801006317,
0.024910878390073776,
-0.005662995856255293,
-0.2518295645713806,
-0.7733139395713806,
-0.3816121816635132,
-0.46887215971946716,
-0.20850220322608948,
0.011747902259230614,
-0.46538132429122925,
0.7192070484161377,
-0.37388020753860474,
-0.25769519805908203,
0.3334876000881195,
-0.2036951631307602,
-0.7821354269981384,
0.02188594453036785,
0.4064844250679016,
0.4724687933921814,
-1.0003739595413208,
1.0017051696777344,
0.552460789680481,
-0.9786635041236877,
-0.480819970369339,
-0.17554907500743866,
0.3371644616127014,
-0.6236833333969116,
0.842021644115448,
0.1238962933421135,
-0.387673944234848,
-0.21966654062271118,
-0.46978214383125305,
-0.7538624405860901,
1.1931384801864624,
0.4962286651134491,
-0.38369572162628174,
-0.026807622984051704,
-0.12979164719581604,
0.14993193745613098,
-0.7131021022796631,
0.2337103933095932,
0.5866367816925049,
0.45388099551200867,
0.4304632842540741,
-0.7328725457191467,
-0.020678652450442314,
0.05804740637540817,
-0.05040000379085541,
0.32056939601898193,
-0.5471246242523193,
0.586326539516449,
-0.27070826292037964,
-0.3897654712200165,
0.030290815979242325,
0.8047614693641663,
0.12870074808597565,
0.42587509751319885,
0.44279488921165466,
0.3721330463886261,
0.4181120693683624,
0.045900795608758926,
1.0789008140563965,
0.19504699110984802,
0.4545862078666687,
1.2981593608856201,
-0.2417622208595276,
1.0387282371520996,
0.80168217420578,
0.07751688361167908,
0.4844427704811096,
0.3920792043209076,
-0.07825282216072083,
0.7206346988677979,
-0.5795652866363525,
-0.2464907467365265,
-0.6830800175666809,
-0.2773948907852173,
-0.10918667912483215,
0.8901693224906921,
0.06820998340845108,
-0.5489327311515808,
-0.5019626617431641,
0.22722920775413513,
-0.1292777806520462,
-0.24427339434623718,
0.08864989131689072,
1.23958158493042,
0.14464393258094788,
-0.2462996542453766,
0.31998923420906067,
-0.21830926835536957,
0.7293868064880371,
-0.488371342420578,
-0.3084380626678467,
0.31367501616477966,
-0.019662749022245407,
-0.3774208128452301,
-0.3972300589084625,
-0.07562076300382614,
-0.163198322057724,
-0.5265854001045227,
0.23947592079639435,
1.1195828914642334,
-0.7143976092338562,
-0.5062873959541321,
0.33350616693496704,
0.8855499029159546,
-0.10736345499753952,
0.01851976104080677,
-0.5726673007011414,
-0.1014287918806076,
-0.31127431988716125,
-0.13019226491451263,
0.3278542160987854,
0.36946913599967957,
0.1750277429819107,
0.3289736211299896,
0.6303765773773193,
0.07958760857582092,
0.21998360753059387,
0.02316286787390709,
1.071865200996399,
-0.8147231936454773,
-0.2563220262527466,
-0.8894580602645874,
0.5779170989990234,
-0.3035017251968384,
-0.5117182731628418,
0.4069689214229584,
0.3615080714225769,
0.453968346118927,
-0.14633144438266754,
0.66851407289505,
0.0896332785487175,
0.2093772143125534,
-0.6750271320343018,
0.2759440541267395,
-0.5588666200637817,
-0.07517847418785095,
-0.40305885672569275,
-0.9572115540504456,
-0.3537485897541046,
0.38280653953552246,
-0.17291539907455444,
-0.31609630584716797,
1.0541479587554932,
0.6486434936523438,
-0.3832088112831116,
-0.04738810658454895,
0.5218045115470886,
-0.13583332300186157,
0.1173647940158844,
0.5542267560958862,
0.9570379853248596,
-0.6621566414833069,
0.791929304599762,
-0.6065953373908997,
-0.24103190004825592,
-0.12789049744606018,
-0.8600075840950012,
-1.0430399179458618,
-0.44725552201271057,
-0.42620667815208435,
-0.12213656306266785,
-0.2991373538970947,
0.9812406301498413,
0.8517950177192688,
-0.4197089374065399,
0.1164264902472496,
0.38298046588897705,
0.14506562054157257,
0.03708796203136444,
-0.2643914520740509,
0.22571471333503723,
-0.11281775683164597,
-0.4902647137641907,
0.4674125611782074,
0.6449486613273621,
0.20384086668491364,
-0.12926219403743744,
-0.030632199719548225,
-0.7007403373718262,
-0.35842880606651306,
0.8202221393585205,
0.1200874000787735,
-0.8303750157356262,
-0.31766632199287415,
-0.07041922211647034,
-0.24676966667175293,
0.2889706790447235,
0.8557240962982178,
-0.7812728881835938,
0.5839189887046814,
0.7146216630935669,
0.608046293258667,
0.8300249576568604,
0.10602493584156036,
0.4598526954650879,
-0.8542720675468445,
0.40638700127601624,
0.0739239975810051,
0.5002337694168091,
0.17792107164859772,
-0.43800273537635803,
0.2437993735074997,
0.5709641575813293,
-0.05111650750041008,
-0.394071489572525,
0.27617111802101135,
-1.346594214439392,
-0.07467087358236313,
1.2880287170410156,
-0.05880946293473244,
-0.39539268612861633,
-0.14377474784851074,
-0.2836918234825134,
0.09975490719079971,
-0.645510196685791,
0.18798187375068665,
0.6539573073387146,
-0.44603243470191956,
-0.6070632338523865,
-0.36213475465774536,
0.3647180199623108,
0.12068159878253937,
-0.9206436276435852,
-0.25371184945106506,
0.8105605244636536,
0.12173981964588165,
0.28032854199409485,
0.49108779430389404,
-0.12380319833755493,
0.47063517570495605,
0.09977111965417862,
-0.14922112226486206,
-0.09771962463855743,
-0.4660857021808624,
-0.23802141845226288,
0.3147563338279724,
-0.21607263386249542,
-0.5442906022071838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00696v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00696v1
|
Self-Consistent Decoding for More Factual Open Responses
| 2024-03-01T17:31:09 | 2024-03-01T17:31:09 |
Christopher Malon, Xiaodan Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Self-consistency has emerged as a powerful method for improving the accuracy
of short answers generated by large language models. As previously defined, it
only concerns the accuracy of a final answer parsed from generated text. In
this work, we extend the idea to open response generation, by integrating
voting into the decoding method. Each output sentence is selected from among
multiple samples, conditioning on the previous selections, based on a simple
token overlap score. We compare this "Sample & Select" method to greedy
decoding, beam search, nucleus sampling, and the recently introduced
hallucination avoiding decoders of DoLA, P-CRR, and S-CRR. We show that Sample
& Select improves factuality by a 30% relative margin against these decoders in
NLI-based evaluation on the subsets of CNN/DM and XSum used in the FRANK
benchmark, while maintaining comparable ROUGE-1 F1 scores against reference
summaries. We collect human verifications of the generated summaries,
confirming the factual superiority of our method.
|
[
-0.26081568002700806,
-0.3677402436733246,
0.5792843103408813,
0.2943500876426697,
-0.1295202672481537,
-0.09262680262327194,
-0.3353344798088074,
-0.3781155049800873,
0.37167173624038696,
0.45143571496009827,
-0.30817675590515137,
-0.430181086063385,
-0.3278583586215973,
0.5816965699195862,
-0.29647842049598694,
1.0300301313400269,
0.002522881142795086,
-0.022639544680714607,
-0.3664397895336151,
-0.23729240894317627,
-0.09630299359560013,
-0.6340004801750183,
-0.18277332186698914,
-0.06690382957458496,
0.5013770461082458,
0.43202218413352966,
0.5761419534683228,
0.818054735660553,
0.5969260931015015,
0.2765837609767914,
0.22212405502796173,
0.39276063442230225,
-0.572473406791687,
0.12186455726623535,
-0.2511396110057831,
-0.45861440896987915,
-0.35146450996398926,
0.13872016966342926,
0.4329235255718231,
0.3125065565109253,
-0.2895740568637848,
0.19659839570522308,
0.050532955676317215,
0.707558810710907,
-0.9445950388908386,
0.027460316196084023,
-0.5792486667633057,
0.023322999477386475,
-0.1808590292930603,
-0.3505522608757019,
-0.7674834132194519,
-0.5850276947021484,
-0.23362824320793152,
-0.30278530716896057,
0.7106421589851379,
-0.10342266410589218,
0.7170849442481995,
0.3879537582397461,
-0.18964608013629913,
-0.5541769862174988,
-0.845265805721283,
0.575363278388977,
-0.7018807530403137,
0.3951130211353302,
0.34298190474510193,
0.3039208650588989,
0.030712563544511795,
-0.6314062476158142,
-0.7477678656578064,
-0.1779298335313797,
-0.30742597579956055,
0.531929612159729,
-0.08375602960586548,
-0.0016354568069800735,
0.1960006207227707,
0.4264003038406372,
-0.5811970233917236,
-0.34363436698913574,
-0.5103636384010315,
-0.4509424567222595,
0.6780880093574524,
0.1740669161081314,
-0.0019606025889515877,
-0.3616199493408203,
-0.26349523663520813,
-0.4140359163284302,
-0.5587403774261475,
0.11922620981931686,
0.38731181621551514,
0.46632298827171326,
0.11706995964050293,
0.8807677030563354,
-0.5258302092552185,
0.6039332151412964,
0.34003525972366333,
0.012978172861039639,
0.3461780548095703,
-0.730749785900116,
-0.26886025071144104,
0.09921734780073166,
0.8513098955154419,
0.36972546577453613,
0.13339386880397797,
-0.214079350233078,
-0.10644994676113129,
-0.023114033043384552,
0.1984846293926239,
-0.8073310852050781,
-0.33735549449920654,
0.4587162137031555,
-0.6758243441581726,
-0.0903603583574295,
0.5933593511581421,
-0.8003272414207458,
-0.013765922747552395,
-0.1985211968421936,
0.12671729922294617,
-0.2454783320426941,
-0.28002670407295227,
0.3323706090450287,
-0.13935993611812592,
0.23906105756759644,
0.37406373023986816,
-0.8117652535438538,
0.42088475823402405,
0.3968433439731598,
0.7938253879547119,
-0.2120261788368225,
-0.17204970121383667,
-1.044775128364563,
-0.06836971640586853,
-0.5768857598304749,
0.8747104406356812,
-0.2586430609226227,
-0.14987356960773468,
-0.10589127987623215,
-0.21225164830684662,
0.11065202206373215,
-0.7724082469940186,
0.43234413862228394,
-0.550087571144104,
0.2955280840396881,
-0.6802109479904175,
-0.439333438873291,
0.17732183635234833,
0.32111111283302307,
-0.7895721793174744,
0.9312140345573425,
-0.0718894898891449,
-0.771573007106781,
0.3966202735900879,
-0.37241330742836,
-0.15126420557498932,
-0.32422757148742676,
-0.3033948242664337,
-0.24319693446159363,
0.22537373006343842,
0.48817262053489685,
0.24136140942573547,
0.2712642550468445,
0.002662756945937872,
-0.4284057319164276,
-0.3290883004665375,
0.3953857123851776,
-0.4003455638885498,
0.6417325139045715,
0.37204068899154663,
-0.32384034991264343,
0.12144731730222702,
-0.6866090297698975,
0.2224302738904953,
0.008930080570280552,
-0.4477181136608124,
-0.013798415660858154,
-0.13912950456142426,
-0.18328577280044556,
0.21979920566082,
0.04620587080717087,
-0.8646688461303711,
0.02722620777785778,
-0.4987252950668335,
-0.0219962690025568,
0.7453299760818481,
-0.03587557002902031,
0.21538162231445312,
-0.38151660561561584,
0.33804965019226074,
0.17587770521640778,
-0.19005322456359863,
-0.37734222412109375,
-0.2681596577167511,
-0.5332649350166321,
-0.3050236999988556,
0.5831149816513062,
0.4272676706314087,
-0.5296183228492737,
0.5853781700134277,
-0.3750859498977661,
-0.19192717969417572,
-0.8021212816238403,
0.001426834729500115,
0.25337690114974976,
0.4374321699142456,
0.45081543922424316,
-0.1741820126771927,
-0.6301234364509583,
-0.6493175029754639,
-0.18712468445301056,
-0.3116306662559509,
-0.1721157729625702,
0.1911492943763733,
0.32631781697273254,
0.2564191222190857,
1.250810980796814,
-0.6248382329940796,
-0.1925896555185318,
-0.08384578675031662,
-0.06974758952856064,
0.18449053168296814,
0.3157016634941101,
0.4439893066883087,
-0.6150355339050293,
-0.48940059542655945,
-0.24746809899806976,
-0.8647285103797913,
0.1257910430431366,
-0.05041923001408577,
-0.14821700751781464,
0.29415369033813477,
0.48454076051712036,
-0.5134381055831909,
0.5413082838058472,
0.44064193964004517,
-0.28178274631500244,
0.3903956115245819,
-0.31152820587158203,
0.45632290840148926,
-0.9472469687461853,
0.18167957663536072,
-0.27280715107917786,
-0.5906766057014465,
-0.29274120926856995,
0.12783806025981903,
0.0982043445110321,
0.31661659479141235,
-0.2916278541088104,
0.4389951229095459,
-0.4307566285133362,
-0.05758046358823776,
-0.2991471290588379,
0.2949950098991394,
0.02815459482371807,
0.2722914516925812,
0.10403195768594742,
0.9506309032440186,
0.020539604127407074,
-0.5050410032272339,
0.37039363384246826,
0.4646095037460327,
-0.3156138062477112,
0.04924693703651428,
-0.9171897172927856,
0.39421331882476807,
-0.43546509742736816,
0.3294382095336914,
-1.2152172327041626,
-0.2645745873451233,
0.44821879267692566,
-0.621420681476593,
0.030887924134731293,
0.15743358433246613,
-0.299001544713974,
-0.2410709261894226,
-0.36217066645622253,
0.40544435381889343,
0.5397033095359802,
-0.8473181128501892,
0.4807681143283844,
0.010402780026197433,
0.07404404133558273,
-0.8346607089042664,
-0.6659186482429504,
-0.13938382267951965,
0.37901821732521057,
-0.42132893204689026,
0.0849018320441246,
-0.45823854207992554,
-0.31379279494285583,
0.17127640545368195,
-0.34408819675445557,
0.08383937925100327,
-0.36862966418266296,
-0.08940698206424713,
0.09392765164375305,
-0.3839046359062195,
-0.062401287257671356,
-0.16483181715011597,
-0.06761390715837479,
0.10192571580410004,
-0.08166845142841339,
0.44964900612831116,
-0.14659370481967926,
-0.5150003433227539,
-0.24432983994483948,
0.4586089551448822,
0.39175641536712646,
-0.4952808916568756,
0.5065280199050903,
0.2664184272289276,
-0.11145096272230148,
-0.06560562551021576,
-0.550360918045044,
-0.394427627325058,
-0.4124062955379486,
-0.03512262925505638,
-0.5133677124977112,
-0.8698781728744507,
0.5263806581497192,
0.46501708030700684,
0.04349297285079956,
0.36031898856163025,
0.5568454265594482,
0.059383612126111984,
0.9189603924751282,
0.4298647344112396,
0.1106124073266983,
0.0410887748003006,
-0.04022383689880371,
0.16615097224712372,
-0.4850882589817047,
-0.16822195053100586,
-0.7113426327705383,
-0.09044753760099411,
-0.4745635986328125,
-0.4397706985473633,
0.3172929584980011,
-0.05152693763375282,
0.2964847683906555,
-0.03649824485182762,
-0.49208515882492065,
0.6558504104614258,
0.6779107451438904,
0.41251856088638306,
0.42675575613975525,
0.14023980498313904,
-0.0788956955075264,
-0.16155558824539185,
-0.5652891397476196,
-0.3598255515098572,
1.1985759735107422,
0.09831580519676208,
0.7600655555725098,
0.23865817487239838,
0.9874194860458374,
0.39263030886650085,
0.23886051774024963,
-0.5650326013565063,
0.46504390239715576,
0.04434087872505188,
-0.6860812902450562,
-0.4235042333602905,
-0.6062052249908447,
-0.795561671257019,
0.32850828766822815,
-0.18870390951633453,
-0.33719033002853394,
0.21235345304012299,
0.26620155572891235,
-0.5886226892471313,
0.10343950986862183,
-0.3588564991950989,
0.6170626282691956,
0.16766740381717682,
-0.18924351036548615,
-0.12861068546772003,
-0.675447940826416,
0.40129825472831726,
0.2611379623413086,
-0.166451558470726,
-0.13531535863876343,
0.19667373597621918,
0.4566500782966614,
-0.2713645100593567,
0.7120915055274963,
-0.026619944721460342,
0.030969660729169846,
0.49840158224105835,
-0.1305617243051529,
0.3682417869567871,
0.21256881952285767,
-0.2278740406036377,
-0.00937032699584961,
-0.010081765241920948,
-0.5755161643028259,
-0.9769649505615234,
0.3756502866744995,
-0.6247689723968506,
-0.5868587493896484,
-0.5828603506088257,
-0.23101705312728882,
0.0032614057417958975,
0.13813993334770203,
0.4485493004322052,
0.7047277092933655,
-0.3734697103500366,
0.3878387212753296,
0.7877058386802673,
0.17792217433452606,
0.49669522047042847,
0.372181236743927,
-0.1990022361278534,
-0.789017915725708,
0.6134285926818848,
-0.08116608113050461,
0.2434682846069336,
0.512616753578186,
0.1945761889219284,
-0.5399847626686096,
-0.4105185568332672,
-0.5894449949264526,
0.35227158665657043,
-0.7319392561912537,
-0.370395302772522,
-0.7591745853424072,
-0.20261073112487793,
-0.8285744190216064,
0.1316305547952652,
-0.3277263939380646,
-0.3222595155239105,
0.012195054441690445,
-0.35213586688041687,
-0.02681148424744606,
0.7425482273101807,
-0.4457562267780304,
-0.17603939771652222,
-0.9169255495071411,
0.7555084228515625,
0.279649019241333,
0.3440603017807007,
-0.1470918357372284,
-0.30859842896461487,
-0.07639287412166595,
0.20617695152759552,
-0.02338690310716629,
-1.0186136960983276,
-0.03171876445412636,
0.12751777470111847,
0.641261637210846,
0.38649794459342957,
0.6816670298576355,
0.5502814054489136,
-0.4289710223674774,
0.7882828712463379,
0.07253745943307877,
-0.7979552745819092,
0.49109676480293274,
-0.007439343724399805,
0.36886128783226013,
0.7603926062583923,
0.273413747549057,
-0.18018151819705963,
-0.6517773866653442,
-0.5501562356948853,
-0.445471853017807,
0.6101207137107849,
0.3766041100025177,
0.16392399370670319,
-0.5216023921966553,
0.36005398631095886,
0.1483682096004486,
0.1853163093328476,
-0.679739773273468,
-0.18806977570056915,
-0.4793414771556854,
-0.47581201791763306,
-0.03986441344022751,
-0.3284231722354889,
-0.32649460434913635,
0.004534689709544182,
0.5534018278121948,
-0.5080052018165588,
0.23815052211284637,
0.8871668577194214,
0.1049233078956604,
-0.12584809958934784,
0.2821432650089264,
0.6976388096809387,
0.7590575218200684,
-0.408563494682312,
0.18497835099697113,
-0.015707334503531456,
-0.4614614248275757,
0.12209562957286835,
-0.1834321767091751,
-0.31030508875846863,
0.2973507046699524,
0.38483262062072754,
0.44117408990859985,
-0.19049283862113953,
-0.6694275140762329,
0.7985437512397766,
-0.26568710803985596,
-0.2257961928844452,
-0.06501995027065277,
0.092283234000206,
-0.3412017226219177,
0.14228704571723938,
0.30265215039253235,
0.30718994140625,
0.32434797286987305,
-0.5755302309989929,
0.4661863446235657,
0.3487718105316162,
-0.2582142949104309,
-0.20510299503803253,
0.6229410171508789,
0.029239578172564507,
0.004464412573724985,
0.8196088671684265,
-0.19584089517593384,
-0.25078102946281433,
0.43587470054626465,
0.6559216976165771,
0.8428827524185181,
-0.17075403034687042,
0.420504629611969,
0.7188873291015625,
0.44360947608947754,
-0.206771120429039,
0.4827691316604614,
-0.23335441946983337,
-0.9268376231193542,
-0.6430480480194092,
-0.5463911890983582,
-0.47496411204338074,
-0.09911021590232849,
-1.0535892248153687,
-0.005274205468595028,
-0.2926574647426605,
0.09876331686973572,
-0.2777272164821625,
-0.11758231371641159,
-0.3362983763217926,
0.4320661723613739,
-0.02037549577653408,
1.0829839706420898,
-0.7104112505912781,
0.6431448459625244,
0.3807234764099121,
-0.4324192404747009,
-0.842179000377655,
0.4429900050163269,
-0.228610098361969,
-0.4752187132835388,
0.34072181582450867,
0.21493306756019592,
-0.37386783957481384,
-0.2552335560321808,
-0.6593002080917358,
-0.9441465139389038,
0.7332945466041565,
0.49637851119041443,
-0.3043435215950012,
-0.030292456969618797,
-0.07298342883586884,
0.4073067903518677,
-0.3958509564399719,
0.45786261558532715,
0.46597397327423096,
0.24104362726211548,
0.29665252566337585,
-0.6444104313850403,
0.26610180735588074,
-0.18370887637138367,
-0.21733686327934265,
0.0038825678639113903,
-0.5691345930099487,
0.5024045705795288,
-0.4905366003513336,
-0.32087987661361694,
0.2706962525844574,
1.326032280921936,
0.4705791473388672,
0.42677071690559387,
0.5584070086479187,
0.33297449350357056,
0.8205414414405823,
0.02677801623940468,
0.9122393727302551,
-0.2840212881565094,
0.24844591319561005,
1.2984154224395752,
-0.2803873121738434,
1.0932942628860474,
0.373863160610199,
-0.048107367008924484,
0.4309321939945221,
0.3187029957771301,
0.04340364411473274,
0.6237068176269531,
-0.0673312395811081,
-0.14080537855625153,
-0.3051243722438812,
0.22524546086788177,
-0.36526256799697876,
0.6056217551231384,
-0.15975266695022583,
0.024352798238396645,
-0.4722105860710144,
-0.17138810455799103,
-0.09239104390144348,
0.5834765434265137,
-0.01857858896255493,
0.8171160221099854,
-0.16676345467567444,
-0.9398284554481506,
0.5673554539680481,
-0.1358352154493332,
0.43191853165626526,
-0.6333614587783813,
-0.210474893450737,
-0.32840073108673096,
0.12475591897964478,
-0.2233307659626007,
-0.8072935938835144,
0.4849735200405121,
-0.007672416977584362,
-0.5924003720283508,
-0.11344563961029053,
0.5282987356185913,
-0.5670182704925537,
-0.22856567800045013,
0.1127750426530838,
0.4807681739330292,
0.22230949997901917,
-0.005898845382034779,
-0.20915186405181885,
0.08000143617391586,
0.09303722530603409,
-0.13942024111747742,
0.0015495026018470526,
0.225754514336586,
0.3363349139690399,
0.23469482362270355,
0.7372992634773254,
0.0506824254989624,
0.22602546215057373,
-0.05564466863870621,
0.7548474073410034,
-0.5760003328323364,
-0.6272286176681519,
-0.7834184169769287,
0.49670669436454773,
-0.37144869565963745,
-0.3262380361557007,
0.8844597935676575,
0.7952077388763428,
1.0666086673736572,
-0.20340581238269806,
0.8480862975120544,
-0.1371287852525711,
0.7127204537391663,
-0.7848303914070129,
0.38043180108070374,
-0.29342249035835266,
-0.11700256913900375,
-0.09401234984397888,
-0.8235555291175842,
-0.15254999697208405,
0.5419300198554993,
-0.09020258486270905,
0.04874911904335022,
0.7646799683570862,
0.765169084072113,
-0.11496657878160477,
0.04329726845026016,
0.3851224184036255,
0.1427670270204544,
0.2935565114021301,
0.1498456597328186,
0.7171407341957092,
-0.5004128813743591,
0.7297158241271973,
-0.14669248461723328,
-0.3155423104763031,
-0.12637215852737427,
-0.8117465972900391,
-0.8442606329917908,
-0.43253976106643677,
-0.2591492235660553,
-0.8424501419067383,
-0.023399516940116882,
0.9453654885292053,
0.6698667407035828,
-1.035862684249878,
-0.23775188624858856,
0.14511916041374207,
-0.0023938200902193785,
-0.4976189434528351,
-0.20962107181549072,
0.1995682716369629,
-0.5962797999382019,
-0.6471047401428223,
0.5032880902290344,
0.25652796030044556,
-0.10085171461105347,
-0.09729859232902527,
-0.09085632860660553,
0.1763298511505127,
0.3331160545349121,
0.39532560110092163,
0.3389844596385956,
-0.8073930144309998,
-0.4210158586502075,
0.4580538868904114,
-0.2887363135814667,
0.4791051149368286,
1.022018313407898,
-0.8161041140556335,
0.5185495615005493,
0.7369903326034546,
0.6704665422439575,
0.4247061312198639,
0.46034032106399536,
0.5577461123466492,
-0.6667019128799438,
-0.1532796174287796,
0.20166054368019104,
0.14470826089382172,
0.3555556833744049,
-0.4503768980503082,
0.4648280143737793,
0.17476077377796173,
-0.509427011013031,
-0.6946700811386108,
0.26046329736709595,
-1.097530484199524,
-0.1481657475233078,
0.91973876953125,
-0.188648983836174,
-0.3588152229785919,
-0.007249478716403246,
-0.1677408069372177,
0.0032252955716103315,
-0.3585663437843323,
0.939397931098938,
0.6256297826766968,
-0.196187362074852,
-0.04797719791531563,
-0.19468344748020172,
0.47035863995552063,
0.2883014380931854,
-0.7589042782783508,
0.20226094126701355,
0.5356061458587646,
0.34581100940704346,
0.3893084228038788,
1.1607109308242798,
-0.14259456098079681,
0.4283337891101837,
-0.009557529352605343,
-0.030329296365380287,
-0.01371213048696518,
-0.6705047488212585,
-0.30408337712287903,
0.5757075548171997,
-0.1600329428911209,
-0.44294336438179016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00686v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00686v1
|
A Bit of a Problem: Measurement Disparities in Dataset Sizes Across Languages
| 2024-03-01T17:20:11 | 2024-03-01T17:20:11 |
Catherine Arnett, Tyler A. Chang, Benjamin K. Bergen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
How should text dataset sizes be compared across languages? Even for
content-matched (parallel) corpora, UTF-8 encoded text can require a
dramatically different number of bytes for different languages. In our work, we
define the byte premium between two languages as the ratio of bytes used to
encode content-matched text in those languages. We compute byte premiums for
1155 languages, and we use linear regressions to estimate byte premiums for
other languages. We release a tool to obtain byte premiums for any two
languages, enabling comparisons of dataset sizes across languages for more
equitable multilingual model development and data practices.
|
[
-0.4809611141681671,
-0.3831193447113037,
0.32644516229629517,
0.5543218851089478,
-0.17260470986366272,
0.09562315046787262,
-0.1313585489988327,
-0.7247171998023987,
0.3027222454547882,
0.22595854103565216,
-0.26798298954963684,
-0.22702820599079132,
-0.597690761089325,
0.30521607398986816,
0.003353853477165103,
0.7236620187759399,
0.00964768324047327,
0.39883092045783997,
-0.4372760057449341,
-0.5509742498397827,
-0.8723526000976562,
-0.29679369926452637,
-0.16291925311088562,
-0.002946489956229925,
0.5011411905288696,
0.673444926738739,
1.0143461227416992,
0.6231788396835327,
1.0003135204315186,
0.27282392978668213,
0.0010053322184830904,
0.26153093576431274,
-0.32596713304519653,
-0.08850780874490738,
-0.16795402765274048,
-0.365781307220459,
-0.2894614338874817,
-0.1301591694355011,
0.8357648849487305,
1.0516724586486816,
-0.062387291342020035,
0.4496636688709259,
-0.15946191549301147,
1.0182809829711914,
-0.8517372012138367,
0.10002543032169342,
-0.32531610131263733,
0.3283030390739441,
-0.318558931350708,
-0.07136301696300507,
-0.4272707998752594,
-0.24791699647903442,
-0.26768404245376587,
-0.5116211175918579,
0.04790045693516731,
0.45791131258010864,
0.6255614757537842,
0.07753989845514297,
-0.4204529821872711,
-0.39849773049354553,
-0.4819674491882324,
0.948442280292511,
-0.4440644383430481,
0.5342229604721069,
0.42939090728759766,
0.1309197098016739,
0.022494042292237282,
-0.28351086378097534,
-0.5501806735992432,
-0.1248968243598938,
-0.31688737869262695,
-0.26110145449638367,
-0.3530910015106201,
-0.13875135779380798,
0.4544297754764557,
0.7222610712051392,
-0.8996416330337524,
0.13088640570640564,
-0.5356900691986084,
-0.40328821539878845,
0.7610028982162476,
0.3858608603477478,
0.4753102958202362,
-0.10593555867671967,
-0.27870169281959534,
-0.2139018028974533,
-0.7600377798080444,
-0.03991583734750748,
0.8757444024085999,
0.3650623559951782,
-0.23840250074863434,
0.5435113310813904,
0.00790969468653202,
0.8143270611763,
-0.15314611792564392,
-0.11173359304666519,
0.45427563786506653,
-0.4785429537296295,
-0.28656187653541565,
0.3644987940788269,
0.6020415425300598,
0.45787134766578674,
0.31004995107650757,
-0.1743643581867218,
-0.16547229886054993,
0.2063390612602234,
-0.00146319973282516,
-0.8287885785102844,
0.055061232298612595,
0.1661696583032608,
-0.37578248977661133,
0.13970528542995453,
-0.1396288126707077,
-0.8291705846786499,
-0.5195530652999878,
-0.24393287301063538,
0.43734514713287354,
-0.13874295353889465,
-0.3885461390018463,
0.5553610324859619,
-0.3367580771446228,
0.19345465302467346,
-0.3030276298522949,
-1.0187053680419922,
0.1914450228214264,
0.3890465795993805,
0.7644666433334351,
-0.033677536994218826,
-0.16273073852062225,
-0.2743074893951416,
-0.14761972427368164,
-0.613225519657135,
0.6227922439575195,
-0.6233982443809509,
-0.38125190138816833,
0.20906007289886475,
-0.02057219110429287,
-0.05164218693971634,
-0.6341619491577148,
0.489280641078949,
-0.5251042246818542,
-0.03363104164600372,
-0.5502899885177612,
-0.677895724773407,
0.1032024472951889,
0.16756394505500793,
-0.9581400156021118,
0.984680712223053,
0.4031205177307129,
-1.119301438331604,
0.615294337272644,
-0.08433753252029419,
-0.3202092945575714,
0.24831312894821167,
-0.3964247703552246,
-0.570885419845581,
0.13931623101234436,
-0.015267758630216122,
0.17008833587169647,
-0.4681113362312317,
0.0782046765089035,
-0.47691407799720764,
-0.6003325581550598,
0.4235251247882843,
-0.3041803240776062,
0.943387508392334,
0.3402642607688904,
0.027595359832048416,
-0.1421445906162262,
-0.8781923055648804,
0.18705375492572784,
-0.07586514949798584,
-0.22332024574279785,
-0.5168868899345398,
-0.020954100415110588,
0.2564528286457062,
0.01169680431485176,
0.4918336570262909,
-0.6815594434738159,
0.09821436554193497,
-0.03883148357272148,
0.45955437421798706,
0.30836641788482666,
-0.3719732463359833,
0.4314534068107605,
-0.36542901396751404,
0.3048534691333771,
0.15624886751174927,
0.09300193935632706,
-0.10098888725042343,
-0.12443862110376358,
-0.5949336290359497,
-0.43364518880844116,
0.6171007752418518,
0.4362853169441223,
-0.4682450592517853,
0.32647594809532166,
-0.48307332396507263,
-0.38014116883277893,
-0.772791862487793,
-0.04039715602993965,
0.4393487870693207,
0.040816426277160645,
0.305795282125473,
-0.4348459541797638,
-0.5934327840805054,
-1.3231680393218994,
-0.05440565198659897,
-0.1733662635087967,
-0.026065582409501076,
0.041502807289361954,
0.2964937686920166,
0.026636652648448944,
0.7363963723182678,
-0.4017118215560913,
-0.23978067934513092,
-0.3548685908317566,
0.019444279372692108,
0.03800307586789131,
0.5256336331367493,
0.8374987244606018,
-0.9481359124183655,
-0.9259209632873535,
0.10502765327692032,
-0.6315474510192871,
-0.10852587223052979,
0.08069691061973572,
-0.12590648233890533,
0.19306574761867523,
0.4118340313434601,
-0.24316388368606567,
0.20951123535633087,
0.8043374419212341,
-0.5535566210746765,
0.543391227722168,
-0.41161561012268066,
0.6293289661407471,
-0.9755141735076904,
-0.04209180921316147,
0.08107493072748184,
-0.315085768699646,
-0.3579331636428833,
0.04289659857749939,
0.3479376435279846,
0.034301530569791794,
-0.43998974561691284,
0.21385590732097626,
-0.6821848750114441,
-0.605597734451294,
-0.029503416270017624,
0.03355931118130684,
0.19861730933189392,
0.03216293454170227,
-0.1153893694281578,
1.2808820009231567,
0.557840883731842,
-0.386140912771225,
0.2851933240890503,
0.45273101329803467,
-0.6222422122955322,
0.7581333518028259,
-0.6389692425727844,
-0.178096741437912,
-0.19932349026203156,
0.03774221986532211,
-0.9629406332969666,
-0.06899847835302353,
-0.2315913736820221,
-0.5537851452827454,
0.21406318247318268,
-0.23445387184619904,
-0.6396806836128235,
-0.19898580014705658,
-0.41806551814079285,
0.6289390921592712,
0.3587522506713867,
-0.3578568398952484,
0.050105027854442596,
0.7313387989997864,
-0.1351376622915268,
-0.9353671669960022,
-1.0691204071044922,
-0.05198328569531441,
-0.3060256540775299,
-0.95411217212677,
0.38242286443710327,
-0.26347702741622925,
-0.26640984416007996,
0.08766336739063263,
-0.04222990199923515,
-0.31574746966362,
-0.14893579483032227,
-0.12032443284988403,
0.410966694355011,
-0.39777451753616333,
0.30259764194488525,
-0.023400206118822098,
0.009912649169564247,
-0.019053703173995018,
-0.3549432158470154,
0.4146151542663574,
-0.19340185821056366,
-0.29651328921318054,
0.06508471816778183,
0.8021895289421082,
0.3006550073623657,
-0.12889212369918823,
1.0249022245407104,
0.4246179163455963,
-0.20743167400360107,
-0.02465685084462166,
-0.49612003564834595,
0.23070229589939117,
-0.4988442361354828,
0.29924631118774414,
-0.46885573863983154,
-0.8676157593727112,
0.6741341948509216,
0.6201181411743164,
0.021526113152503967,
0.3899306058883667,
0.4868164658546448,
0.11055594682693481,
1.03010892868042,
1.0017939805984497,
-0.22742818295955658,
0.31682106852531433,
0.2683026194572449,
0.18126626312732697,
-0.34081417322158813,
-0.10313834995031357,
-0.8570862412452698,
-0.35619795322418213,
-1.0682214498519897,
-0.3317144215106964,
0.2671695053577423,
0.11182162910699844,
-0.4916077256202698,
0.6185996532440186,
-0.37778207659721375,
0.7873647809028625,
0.43383681774139404,
-0.12280575186014175,
0.30912870168685913,
0.41939404606819153,
-0.04413868486881256,
-0.3372703492641449,
-0.540925920009613,
-0.5083533525466919,
0.8435274362564087,
0.2683401107788086,
0.610252857208252,
0.459769070148468,
0.272733211517334,
0.6675606369972229,
-0.2288695126771927,
-0.7408288717269897,
0.1927034854888916,
-0.5371037125587463,
-0.6965747475624084,
-0.2899816036224365,
-0.751795768737793,
-1.0110379457473755,
0.23396460711956024,
-0.06371917575597763,
-0.6682114005088806,
0.35085228085517883,
0.06344572454690933,
0.08830979466438293,
0.18305905163288116,
-0.9152442216873169,
1.1019550561904907,
0.23107418417930603,
-0.24940557777881622,
-0.3260515630245209,
-0.5476776957511902,
-0.12087821960449219,
0.14697939157485962,
0.28341448307037354,
-0.4584614634513855,
0.11330419033765793,
0.6652480363845825,
-0.10114970058202744,
0.42261743545532227,
-0.01037360168993473,
0.052177704870700836,
0.34933874011039734,
0.22708289325237274,
0.06294839084148407,
0.004316060803830624,
-0.1232227087020874,
0.29228609800338745,
0.4511822760105133,
-0.9272913336753845,
-0.19887135922908783,
0.45072436332702637,
-0.8122655153274536,
-0.10135915130376816,
-0.4316469728946686,
-0.7453842163085938,
-0.33684608340263367,
0.05068514868617058,
0.29985710978507996,
0.5798662900924683,
-0.30662888288497925,
0.23713253438472748,
0.8495833873748779,
-0.43158528208732605,
0.6674560308456421,
0.8811674118041992,
0.09617490321397781,
-0.008767182938754559,
0.9673656821250916,
0.12090016901493073,
0.41184186935424805,
0.773524820804596,
0.03204982355237007,
-0.3774831295013428,
-0.3220681846141815,
-0.6164078712463379,
-0.10090430825948715,
-0.6980272531509399,
-0.33768394589424133,
-0.46087393164634705,
-0.010815582238137722,
-0.36801594495773315,
-0.13785813748836517,
-0.4454744756221771,
-0.2865087389945984,
0.21208034455776215,
-0.06017374247312546,
0.33184367418289185,
0.5920021533966064,
-0.34078553318977356,
0.2277614176273346,
-0.9374688863754272,
-0.062321167439222336,
-0.14950251579284668,
0.3365758955478668,
-0.18445047736167908,
-0.5291200280189514,
-0.45215466618537903,
0.014447287656366825,
-0.10374727845191956,
-0.8384337425231934,
0.48419275879859924,
-0.023603161796927452,
0.5208811163902283,
-0.019165892153978348,
0.037640225142240524,
0.48431921005249023,
-0.6603161692619324,
0.7134217023849487,
0.4377252161502838,
-1.0073268413543701,
0.012938735075294971,
-0.04655034467577934,
0.04065489023923874,
0.5849336981773376,
0.7139132022857666,
-0.9495643377304077,
-0.13749445974826813,
-0.2657409608364105,
-0.7597257494926453,
0.4398825764656067,
0.14313359558582306,
0.20193731784820557,
-0.16951999068260193,
-0.1959735006093979,
0.34535473585128784,
0.142033189535141,
-0.7023503184318542,
-0.4201524555683136,
0.05717368423938751,
-0.48823195695877075,
-0.2606641948223114,
-0.4000008702278137,
0.11006016284227371,
0.04638993740081787,
0.4213635325431824,
-0.09786795824766159,
0.34949445724487305,
-0.029245875775814056,
-0.36117827892303467,
0.014555811882019043,
0.5491697788238525,
0.25922149419784546,
0.6593459248542786,
-0.06570576876401901,
0.39431849122047424,
0.08554040640592575,
-0.7871872186660767,
0.2962830662727356,
0.1505826711654663,
0.06184333562850952,
0.05219951644539833,
0.2599067986011505,
0.9044240117073059,
-0.07669152319431305,
-0.7561722993850708,
0.5501459240913391,
-0.2142917960882187,
-0.05134451389312744,
-0.08302721381187439,
-0.3591410517692566,
0.1669006049633026,
-0.04269108548760414,
0.05014815554022789,
-0.40057629346847534,
0.38144195079803467,
-0.3591707646846771,
0.35082751512527466,
0.0750996470451355,
-0.5689020752906799,
-0.11168253421783447,
0.15384796261787415,
0.1974373310804367,
-0.01956440880894661,
0.8467877507209778,
-0.4415426552295685,
-0.10487863421440125,
0.8928220868110657,
0.467525839805603,
0.31738582253456116,
-0.08906985819339752,
0.46633854508399963,
0.40125173330307007,
0.4399558901786804,
-0.19773927330970764,
0.32034292817115784,
0.3020790219306946,
-0.9053577780723572,
-0.4858762323856354,
-0.6971815228462219,
-0.252964586019516,
-0.05219203978776932,
-0.8563684821128845,
0.15521788597106934,
0.20953156054019928,
-0.008209653198719025,
0.6281985640525818,
0.32389354705810547,
-0.7218008637428284,
0.05523024499416351,
0.25726747512817383,
0.9636427164077759,
-1.2291905879974365,
0.6051638722419739,
0.6302376985549927,
-0.7144734263420105,
-0.6948915123939514,
-0.25301045179367065,
-0.25858110189437866,
-0.7458264231681824,
0.5884762406349182,
0.3353293240070343,
0.11217373609542847,
-0.41519612073898315,
-0.26030397415161133,
-0.7853502035140991,
0.7406035661697388,
0.6179853677749634,
-0.8449723720550537,
0.40011167526245117,
0.9045628905296326,
0.5195245146751404,
-0.27507930994033813,
0.40060853958129883,
0.6565094590187073,
0.3406829833984375,
-0.37338313460350037,
-1.1455459594726562,
-0.30279093980789185,
-0.053504616022109985,
-0.0546455904841423,
0.5491004586219788,
-0.6338764429092407,
1.0850696563720703,
0.1571679562330246,
-0.1343497931957245,
-0.2671632468700409,
0.5808019042015076,
0.034245334565639496,
0.28436577320098877,
0.495624840259552,
0.3112136423587799,
0.657404363155365,
0.04558765888214111,
1.0329784154891968,
-0.33096975088119507,
0.502059280872345,
0.9153833389282227,
-0.33840009570121765,
0.6681222915649414,
0.4905657470226288,
-0.3975624144077301,
0.21033945679664612,
0.7681277990341187,
0.02779351733624935,
0.4155738353729248,
0.38100048899650574,
-0.33076855540275574,
-0.22212854027748108,
-0.3125733435153961,
-0.3431766927242279,
0.13531145453453064,
0.2789393961429596,
-0.054958026856184006,
-0.22998449206352234,
-0.023145310580730438,
-0.13384640216827393,
0.4768843650817871,
-0.39475321769714355,
0.5075773000717163,
-0.055613305419683456,
-0.5175706744194031,
0.3764522671699524,
0.3346690535545349,
0.5922784805297852,
-0.42027920484542847,
0.1954910308122635,
-0.6176639795303345,
0.35018888115882874,
-0.10108740627765656,
-1.1502282619476318,
0.5824928283691406,
0.09101284295320511,
-0.5942457318305969,
0.16237139701843262,
0.4823193848133087,
-0.6188040375709534,
-0.5367302298545837,
0.3659566640853882,
0.4725627303123474,
0.30588653683662415,
0.10838540643453598,
-0.6319056749343872,
0.4157562553882599,
-0.045468203723430634,
0.17844222486019135,
0.5975296497344971,
0.47177207469940186,
-0.21605199575424194,
0.44509831070899963,
0.05628117918968201,
0.026155441999435425,
0.2450404018163681,
0.20544247329235077,
0.5277021527290344,
-0.43621543049812317,
-0.6872068643569946,
-0.7231813669204712,
0.3519248068332672,
-0.33299702405929565,
-0.24072858691215515,
0.6680924892425537,
0.9724294543266296,
1.2657556533813477,
-0.21718499064445496,
0.7880899310112,
-0.4422069191932678,
0.3813329339027405,
-0.38815420866012573,
0.2918919026851654,
-0.5633989572525024,
0.12048977613449097,
0.10010070353746414,
-0.9039641618728638,
0.004334453027695417,
0.7008512616157532,
-0.12412942200899124,
-0.28136762976646423,
0.6962385177612305,
0.961382269859314,
-0.17942899465560913,
-0.04871835187077522,
0.5178069472312927,
-0.20744939148426056,
0.08841393142938614,
0.6284456849098206,
0.6568924188613892,
-0.5191839337348938,
0.5655657052993774,
-0.09956219792366028,
-0.17824476957321167,
0.12200180441141129,
-0.9617509841918945,
-0.8754671216011047,
-0.6669999361038208,
-0.32967692613601685,
-0.35984373092651367,
0.22917956113815308,
0.9136236906051636,
0.6077741384506226,
-0.8858588933944702,
-0.42948123812675476,
0.06958531588315964,
0.04702672362327576,
-0.22506389021873474,
-0.16466650366783142,
0.31303271651268005,
-0.4445493519306183,
-0.8172820806503296,
0.046327363699674606,
0.10234302282333374,
0.06288735568523407,
-0.4730241000652313,
0.1737608015537262,
0.16116201877593994,
0.33028891682624817,
0.33277398347854614,
0.12910281121730804,
-0.03257744386792183,
-0.2736254334449768,
-0.05051647126674652,
-0.6403505206108093,
0.2498033046722412,
0.9652150273323059,
-0.22536832094192505,
0.2827431559562683,
0.6442255973815918,
0.6611021161079407,
0.3849383592605591,
-0.5267051458358765,
0.4399055242538452,
-1.2732839584350586,
0.6233795881271362,
-0.10498557984828949,
0.3320155441761017,
0.6391001343727112,
-0.44715428352355957,
0.454886257648468,
-0.0027386893052607775,
-0.5222500562667847,
-0.8506162762641907,
0.41611388325691223,
-0.9535764455795288,
-0.42985519766807556,
1.040313720703125,
-0.27097758650779724,
0.013667575083673,
0.03849919140338898,
-0.08946740627288818,
-0.08841907232999802,
-0.22363018989562988,
0.6764816045761108,
0.9553289413452148,
0.4708324074745178,
0.284311443567276,
-0.7041758894920349,
0.5989931225776672,
0.18673349916934967,
-0.5965809226036072,
0.25399264693260193,
0.47587719559669495,
0.2785565257072449,
0.12305305153131485,
0.6243703365325928,
-0.23657117784023285,
0.16642551124095917,
0.6904635429382324,
0.2695375382900238,
0.15786196291446686,
-0.3642646372318268,
-0.09229700267314911,
-0.05928521603345871,
-0.07407994568347931,
-0.340813010931015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00662v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00662v1
|
Modeling the Quality of Dialogical Explanations
| 2024-03-01T16:49:55 | 2024-03-01T16:49:55 |
Milad Alshomary, Felix Lange, Meisam Booshehri, Meghdut Sengupta, Philipp Cimiano, Henning Wachsmuth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Explanations are pervasive in our lives. Mostly, they occur in dialogical
form where an {\em explainer} discusses a concept or phenomenon of interest
with an {\em explainee}. Leaving the explainee with a clear understanding is
not straightforward due to the knowledge gap between the two participants.
Previous research looked at the interaction of explanation moves, dialogue
acts, and topics in successful dialogues with expert explainers. However,
daily-life explanations often fail, raising the question of what makes a
dialogue successful. In this work, we study explanation dialogues in terms of
the interactions between the explainer and explainee and how they correlate
with the quality of explanations in terms of a successful understanding on the
explainee's side. In particular, we first construct a corpus of 399 dialogues
from the Reddit forum {\em Explain Like I am Five} and annotate it for
interaction flows and explanation quality. We then analyze the interaction
flows, comparing them to those appearing in expert dialogues. Finally, we
encode the interaction flows using two language models that can handle long
inputs, and we provide empirical evidence for the effectiveness boost gained
through the encoding in predicting the success of explanation dialogues.
|
[
-0.5315792560577393,
-0.950684666633606,
0.8804486989974976,
0.09077179431915283,
-0.4073723554611206,
-0.09200750291347504,
-0.0949438288807869,
-0.4882289171218872,
0.13838154077529907,
0.186252623796463,
-0.8442093729972839,
-0.22668959200382233,
-0.4968676269054413,
0.2706923186779022,
-0.41578948497772217,
0.7714906930923462,
0.026582414284348488,
0.2855377495288849,
-0.4951479434967041,
0.012152060866355896,
-0.5518275499343872,
-0.3694550096988678,
-0.7722262144088745,
-0.5071086883544922,
0.6412071585655212,
0.3193466365337372,
0.8087592124938965,
0.5749423503875732,
0.2389473021030426,
0.37649622559547424,
-0.28671661019325256,
0.10341768711805344,
-0.8424383997917175,
0.21915209293365479,
-0.23668533563613892,
-0.41199585795402527,
-0.266644686460495,
0.05537369102239609,
0.2650873064994812,
0.9990909695625305,
-0.13280034065246582,
-0.05436325445771217,
0.00242567528039217,
0.24799224734306335,
-0.1620471328496933,
0.12985506653785706,
-0.3345436155796051,
-0.03232114017009735,
0.30219781398773193,
-0.46757298707962036,
-0.3675099313259125,
-0.37355270981788635,
0.15172195434570312,
-0.6744722127914429,
0.36532503366470337,
-0.12945517897605896,
1.0385503768920898,
0.17053809762001038,
-0.08024448156356812,
-0.4979783892631531,
-0.7696946263313293,
0.5631967186927795,
-0.8050765991210938,
0.17355136573314667,
0.3960034251213074,
0.572935938835144,
-0.38139626383781433,
-0.5845924019813538,
-0.8214548230171204,
0.22485560178756714,
-0.2732658386230469,
0.2700516879558563,
-0.11191064119338989,
0.16882988810539246,
0.05825502425432205,
0.284016877412796,
-0.3579895496368408,
-0.0020885770209133625,
-0.5578877329826355,
-0.2106330543756485,
0.637586772441864,
0.190043106675148,
0.3273969292640686,
-0.28135642409324646,
-0.2777544856071472,
0.2456602305173874,
-0.28666335344314575,
0.3234561085700989,
0.35173362493515015,
-0.3098331689834595,
-0.04371277987957001,
0.316228449344635,
-0.03854610025882721,
0.7362874150276184,
0.4333784282207489,
-0.20722675323486328,
-0.22275744378566742,
-0.7177350521087646,
-0.1323426067829132,
-0.3276732861995697,
0.7138403654098511,
0.6530488729476929,
0.4946443736553192,
-0.015874315053224564,
0.12869365513324738,
-0.21136844158172607,
0.2724023461341858,
-0.8199011087417603,
-0.150955930352211,
0.5458235740661621,
-0.9310246706008911,
-0.30891746282577515,
-0.21810978651046753,
-0.7278102040290833,
-0.4384039342403412,
-0.34955283999443054,
0.5161318778991699,
-0.47771263122558594,
-0.44787168502807617,
0.14723406732082367,
-0.21634414792060852,
-0.09432751685380936,
0.5009689927101135,
-0.9528669118881226,
0.35014739632606506,
0.5931159257888794,
0.4549754559993744,
0.1390191912651062,
-0.19826513528823853,
-0.3850928544998169,
-0.09027761220932007,
-0.21514470875263214,
0.863792359828949,
-0.5704014301300049,
-0.2913927733898163,
-0.00013973457680549473,
-0.014081776142120361,
-0.2788854241371155,
-0.4380207061767578,
0.47779542207717896,
-0.5431604981422424,
0.419672429561615,
0.01831793040037155,
-0.9057129621505737,
-0.6443170309066772,
-0.03085138648748398,
-0.47313621640205383,
0.15236885845661163,
-0.1624296009540558,
-0.43769407272338867,
0.19005019962787628,
-0.9313624501228333,
-0.0495658777654171,
0.06297586858272552,
-0.03762048855423927,
-0.06223373860120773,
0.19740331172943115,
0.23765923082828522,
0.38816434144973755,
-0.06177525222301483,
0.26839950680732727,
-0.189540296792984,
-0.436736136674881,
0.9423374533653259,
-0.583060085773468,
0.6832457780838013,
0.2761816680431366,
-0.07758994400501251,
0.033551305532455444,
-0.3996305763721466,
-0.06572657823562622,
-0.024912355467677116,
0.08420472592115402,
-0.1391170173883438,
0.059201911091804504,
-0.5233820080757141,
0.19989733397960663,
0.19272460043430328,
-0.3276785612106323,
-0.15303610265254974,
-0.418417364358902,
0.7938784956932068,
0.31306949257850647,
0.5072087049484253,
0.31741106510162354,
-0.15426838397979736,
0.6346549391746521,
0.11897897720336914,
0.42627236247062683,
-0.5755529403686523,
-0.461420476436615,
-0.6661691069602966,
0.07819981873035431,
0.39417585730552673,
0.0984743982553482,
-0.4379584491252899,
-0.12082500755786896,
-0.2905036509037018,
-0.12885215878486633,
-0.733957052230835,
0.12592971324920654,
0.4132395088672638,
0.3399413824081421,
0.2147122323513031,
-0.17451681196689606,
-0.2079855501651764,
-0.8005696535110474,
-0.4306735098361969,
-0.2731388509273529,
-0.16141358017921448,
0.24267850816249847,
0.2801337242126465,
-0.05723530799150467,
1.166115164756775,
-0.11741320788860321,
0.38318976759910583,
-0.5058781504631042,
0.5389023423194885,
0.2784534990787506,
0.32872891426086426,
0.4576021134853363,
-0.8269941806793213,
-0.20968115329742432,
-0.27715179324150085,
-0.736610472202301,
-0.03530063107609749,
-0.28053349256515503,
-0.21765002608299255,
0.02513977512717247,
0.465519517660141,
-0.6257954835891724,
0.42805734276771545,
0.43673673272132874,
-0.4525390565395355,
0.5874851942062378,
-0.22108010947704315,
0.33771756291389465,
-0.889492928981781,
-0.26066720485687256,
-0.059407562017440796,
-0.3601755201816559,
-0.863507091999054,
-0.048007987439632416,
-0.3295672535896301,
-0.18345634639263153,
-0.29880842566490173,
0.4979182779788971,
-0.385074645280838,
0.04653666168451309,
-0.07740919291973114,
0.2777019739151001,
0.0853242427110672,
0.5981940031051636,
0.046219825744628906,
0.5926069617271423,
0.2933940589427948,
-0.5699364542961121,
0.06664682179689407,
0.19218243658542633,
-0.005057740956544876,
0.4813136160373688,
-0.9648246169090271,
0.05767134577035904,
-0.1436830759048462,
0.23934409022331238,
-1.2215759754180908,
-0.583142101764679,
0.2972909212112427,
-1.0156162977218628,
-0.1170940026640892,
-0.44071653485298157,
-0.27373796701431274,
-0.3904414772987366,
-0.001740031293593347,
0.3278026580810547,
0.4952985942363739,
-0.4990016222000122,
0.741798460483551,
0.09516476839780807,
-0.22798828780651093,
-0.26282942295074463,
-0.2979333996772766,
-0.1173163428902626,
-0.40475937724113464,
-0.9031932950019836,
0.050930626690387726,
-0.3609907329082489,
-0.3807245194911957,
0.05697711929678917,
-0.21465329825878143,
-0.5237817764282227,
0.17413882911205292,
0.37684550881385803,
-0.06668384373188019,
-0.30138593912124634,
0.2652764618396759,
0.07351145148277283,
-0.2736997902393341,
0.5183674097061157,
0.1023101732134819,
0.4740622341632843,
0.1389649510383606,
-0.5069637298583984,
-0.9536024332046509,
0.4480802118778229,
0.8633864521980286,
-0.06424447894096375,
1.1396257877349854,
0.5846605896949768,
-0.1732451468706131,
0.0833713635802269,
-0.5180900692939758,
-0.5719841122627258,
-0.44497057795524597,
-0.012676272541284561,
-0.7370079159736633,
-0.6564375162124634,
0.8418552279472351,
-0.0004943240201100707,
0.18802787363529205,
0.4591291546821594,
0.2277870774269104,
-0.49487385153770447,
1.460248589515686,
0.3404708206653595,
0.4877476990222931,
0.30407795310020447,
-0.1302938610315323,
0.739133894443512,
-0.45769503712654114,
-0.3291008472442627,
-0.3852185904979706,
-0.05518638715147972,
-0.41515856981277466,
-0.4490147829055786,
0.23747701942920685,
0.6183809041976929,
0.06727316975593567,
0.22249622642993927,
-0.14689430594444275,
0.5352569222450256,
0.3925088346004486,
-0.07615368068218231,
0.37713176012039185,
0.09882128983736038,
0.15333355963230133,
-0.07367482781410217,
-1.0248991250991821,
-0.6587463021278381,
0.5410939455032349,
0.821415364742279,
0.8334671258926392,
0.17764393985271454,
0.6883643269538879,
0.13673490285873413,
0.06596621870994568,
-0.54914790391922,
0.43996140360832214,
0.09958571940660477,
-0.39697790145874023,
-0.517068088054657,
-0.40811601281166077,
-1.013938307762146,
0.2024179846048355,
-0.24079766869544983,
-0.7012301087379456,
0.11783912777900696,
0.3961138427257538,
-0.5745211839675903,
-0.25395146012306213,
-0.919021725654602,
1.1257308721542358,
-0.07167716324329376,
-0.4725445508956909,
-0.6528878211975098,
-0.7494567632675171,
0.3025052547454834,
0.44121530652046204,
0.4721776247024536,
-0.022559793666005135,
0.6343565583229065,
0.6734944581985474,
-0.596804678440094,
0.7706591486930847,
-0.15382929146289825,
0.04693102464079857,
0.3726097047328949,
0.24961315095424652,
0.12323597073554993,
0.2796017825603485,
-0.010375548154115677,
0.15810458362102509,
-0.0019457812886685133,
-0.4825229346752167,
-1.1107161045074463,
0.31705722212791443,
-0.6729404926300049,
-0.646491527557373,
0.25537195801734924,
-0.2713732421398163,
0.17467671632766724,
-0.2831408381462097,
0.28503698110580444,
0.7995940446853638,
0.06023649126291275,
-0.1359669268131256,
0.7926725745201111,
-0.23637500405311584,
0.24725429713726044,
0.6316035985946655,
0.004273625556379557,
-0.12450923025608063,
0.9465073943138123,
-0.09805206954479218,
0.5662133097648621,
0.022126710042357445,
0.1928984373807907,
-0.4461217522621155,
-0.6314325332641602,
-0.6291645169258118,
0.4883275628089905,
-0.875033974647522,
0.18839195370674133,
-0.7993945479393005,
-0.36806520819664,
-0.18532809615135193,
-0.22983422875404358,
-0.08450350910425186,
-0.5127822160720825,
-0.14781968295574188,
-0.10879843682050705,
0.32496440410614014,
0.9138549566268921,
-0.08565051853656769,
0.18510685861110687,
-0.6270888447761536,
0.2085203230381012,
0.5839945673942566,
0.26628732681274414,
0.3840973973274231,
-0.6398918032646179,
-0.3624740540981293,
0.4123231768608093,
-0.13524022698402405,
-1.14137864112854,
0.2872481346130371,
0.07200668752193451,
0.6726359128952026,
0.845461368560791,
-0.21408885717391968,
0.8201192021369934,
-0.1985960304737091,
1.070678949356079,
0.15289592742919922,
-0.9986324906349182,
0.5940432548522949,
-0.3686900734901428,
0.3109086751937866,
0.34859997034072876,
0.3318677246570587,
-0.6979880928993225,
-0.7093228101730347,
-0.7406587600708008,
-0.759792685508728,
0.49344274401664734,
0.46292412281036377,
0.10022849589586258,
0.035609543323516846,
0.5679388642311096,
0.40697500109672546,
0.12580522894859314,
-0.6757811903953552,
-0.1881483793258667,
-0.4131932258605957,
-0.31244659423828125,
0.24449342489242554,
-0.6078182458877563,
-0.3474512994289398,
0.031097840517759323,
0.5624224543571472,
0.00027526088524609804,
0.6070047616958618,
0.11317582428455353,
-0.2670137882232666,
-0.16334590315818787,
0.3119336664676666,
0.9748073220252991,
1.099972128868103,
-0.04211727902293205,
0.29536646604537964,
-0.15607231855392456,
-0.05610308796167374,
-0.235582172870636,
0.05662817507982254,
0.33524322509765625,
0.3410795331001282,
0.7639835476875305,
0.7527090311050415,
0.07900809496641159,
-0.5563064813613892,
0.3404710590839386,
-0.3010185956954956,
-0.14870348572731018,
-0.1714722067117691,
0.22842669486999512,
0.33100631833076477,
0.11968746781349182,
0.3063850402832031,
-0.2676962614059448,
0.3066517114639282,
-0.7318138480186462,
-0.07555122673511505,
0.2364846169948578,
-0.41990768909454346,
-0.5358927845954895,
0.6441373825073242,
0.8012287616729736,
-0.5557692050933838,
0.5020563006401062,
-0.2548416554927826,
-0.7016080021858215,
0.6866118907928467,
0.278513640165329,
0.48255154490470886,
-0.021206382662057877,
0.45252472162246704,
0.545883059501648,
-0.19088944792747498,
0.2427002489566803,
-0.033212218433618546,
-0.2283693253993988,
-0.7367357015609741,
-0.8078716397285461,
-0.4984889030456543,
-0.5826820135116577,
0.14235709607601166,
-0.5602136850357056,
-0.20502504706382751,
0.2005181461572647,
0.12930092215538025,
0.49954771995544434,
-0.2635895609855652,
-0.5956088304519653,
-0.005029768217355013,
-0.18792259693145752,
0.8649741411209106,
-0.9613350629806519,
0.0883823037147522,
0.45316845178604126,
-0.6812405586242676,
-0.8324434757232666,
0.0758870542049408,
-0.06303740292787552,
-0.6910405158996582,
0.550512969493866,
0.18685567378997803,
-0.29592713713645935,
-0.18304073810577393,
-0.5928785800933838,
-0.540920078754425,
0.6559524536132812,
0.1064453274011612,
-0.4084516763687134,
0.1906600147485733,
-0.01781274378299713,
0.9248746037483215,
-0.49292507767677307,
0.7807591557502747,
0.558567225933075,
0.5355038046836853,
0.04787139594554901,
-0.9424759745597839,
-0.1491488367319107,
-0.3091036379337311,
-0.10811139643192291,
-0.005686191841959953,
-0.3713236451148987,
0.3844850957393646,
-0.2688908576965332,
-0.1875642091035843,
0.202800452709198,
0.6032915115356445,
-0.021010201424360275,
0.5528905391693115,
0.5714378356933594,
0.09898154437541962,
0.46246689558029175,
-0.1800031214952469,
1.0608724355697632,
-0.4284210503101349,
0.4070186913013458,
0.8883064389228821,
0.4071532189846039,
0.5331759452819824,
0.46923887729644775,
0.11907701939344406,
0.9976330399513245,
1.1462702751159668,
0.4827991724014282,
0.2979026734828949,
0.05356113612651825,
-0.16765013337135315,
-0.6321401000022888,
-0.1526441127061844,
-0.17372319102287292,
0.26573827862739563,
0.5106797814369202,
-0.6597402095794678,
-0.04054756462574005,
0.09218129515647888,
-0.0637672170996666,
0.12585990130901337,
-0.215272456407547,
0.9857642650604248,
-0.1120835393667221,
-0.9151920080184937,
0.7678690552711487,
-0.3290560841560364,
0.02072843164205551,
-0.1799754798412323,
-0.3101029098033905,
-0.4960809051990509,
-0.11042431741952896,
-0.23850660026073456,
-1.0143848657608032,
0.09152267873287201,
-0.10940765589475632,
-0.45959940552711487,
-0.36091357469558716,
0.5540369749069214,
-0.7360385060310364,
-0.09840218722820282,
0.09589704126119614,
0.6398528218269348,
0.8370193839073181,
0.3943309485912323,
-0.4994414746761322,
-0.016820110380649567,
-0.10067018121480942,
-0.02060643956065178,
-0.12411942332983017,
0.6267638206481934,
0.016105366870760918,
0.7680463194847107,
0.3527393639087677,
-0.37435364723205566,
-0.1040695309638977,
0.43932992219924927,
0.6082884669303894,
-0.4961805045604706,
-0.36236074566841125,
-0.7453558444976807,
0.7805142998695374,
-0.36087846755981445,
-0.1899372637271881,
0.47430142760276794,
0.17240330576896667,
0.37915223836898804,
-0.1177491843700409,
0.42778342962265015,
0.15553022921085358,
0.7065662145614624,
-0.5792564749717712,
0.5267640352249146,
-0.42529019713401794,
0.25822538137435913,
0.18515092134475708,
-0.6864243149757385,
0.2692886292934418,
0.7535711526870728,
-0.07975941151380539,
0.0662720650434494,
0.7627797722816467,
0.6243062019348145,
-0.18267256021499634,
0.2606023848056793,
0.23723289370536804,
0.7294777631759644,
0.17492565512657166,
0.34841910004615784,
0.9698730111122131,
-0.013231266289949417,
0.5178677439689636,
0.006122640334069729,
-0.0798199251294136,
-0.586640477180481,
-0.6131741404533386,
-1.0769590139389038,
-0.48893657326698303,
-0.33955034613609314,
-0.24856500327587128,
0.30531319975852966,
0.6145933866500854,
0.9642179012298584,
-0.5449159145355225,
-0.05390239506959915,
-0.38171735405921936,
0.5409192442893982,
-0.4607292413711548,
-0.2810003161430359,
-0.007282557897269726,
-0.3344734311103821,
-0.7920113801956177,
0.29397472739219666,
0.1551022231578827,
-0.008988437242805958,
-0.4833877980709076,
-0.15921998023986816,
0.3428035378456116,
0.4189188480377197,
0.4692613184452057,
0.10570825636386871,
-0.9719460606575012,
-0.36776313185691833,
0.0644054263830185,
0.28075936436653137,
0.04369393363595009,
0.7832615971565247,
-0.6751754879951477,
0.7965165376663208,
0.4869149327278137,
0.3228190243244171,
0.44869464635849,
0.348298579454422,
1.109437346458435,
-0.15834690630435944,
-0.4466552436351776,
-0.10103683918714523,
0.101789191365242,
0.2767355144023895,
-0.3092048764228821,
0.48106902837753296,
-0.023880263790488243,
-0.6557547450065613,
-0.5204420685768127,
0.2632337212562561,
-0.7982470393180847,
-0.36210253834724426,
1.0689116716384888,
-0.38702064752578735,
-0.031784359365701675,
-0.3749716877937317,
-0.27722325921058655,
0.2534583806991577,
-0.5285792946815491,
1.0283490419387817,
1.0864839553833008,
-0.7055501937866211,
-0.37863942980766296,
-0.6512149572372437,
0.5950233340263367,
0.5072845816612244,
-0.7614123225212097,
0.037752095609903336,
0.4219009280204773,
0.3773801028728485,
0.32769423723220825,
0.4278627038002014,
0.10890942066907883,
0.7656110525131226,
-0.16671378910541534,
-0.27846166491508484,
0.013338827528059483,
-0.13602295517921448,
-0.48188668489456177,
0.1926575005054474,
0.20066221058368683,
-0.20455792546272278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00632v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00632v1
|
Metamorpheus: Interactive, Affective, and Creative Dream Narration Through Metaphorical Visual Storytelling
| 2024-03-01T16:09:32 | 2024-03-01T16:09:32 |
Qian Wan, Xin Feng, Yining Bei, Zhiqi Gao, Zhicong Lu
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Human emotions are essentially molded by lived experiences, from which we
construct personalised meaning. The engagement in such meaning-making process
has been practiced as an intervention in various psychotherapies to promote
wellness. Nevertheless, to support recollecting and recounting lived
experiences in everyday life remains under explored in HCI. It also remains
unknown how technologies such as generative AI models can facilitate the
meaning making process, and ultimately support affective mindfulness. In this
paper we present Metamorpheus, an affective interface that engages users in a
creative visual storytelling of emotional experiences during dreams.
Metamorpheus arranges the storyline based on a dream's emotional arc, and
provokes self-reflection through the creation of metaphorical images and text
depictions. The system provides metaphor suggestions, and generates visual
metaphors and text depictions using generative AI models, while users can apply
generations to recolour and re-arrange the interface to be visually affective.
Our experience-centred evaluation manifests that, by interacting with
Metamorpheus, users can recall their dreams in vivid detail, through which they
relive and reflect upon their experiences in a meaningful way.
|
[
-0.38052302598953247,
-0.39322376251220703,
0.498066246509552,
0.24476748704910278,
-0.6563729643821716,
-0.0351298563182354,
0.05076732113957405,
-0.6333358883857727,
1.127925992012024,
0.30308008193969727,
-0.8895559906959534,
-0.27478426694869995,
-0.27140119671821594,
0.09444454312324524,
-0.11656306684017181,
0.7145359516143799,
-0.2421996146440506,
-0.4061218500137329,
-0.19858793914318085,
-0.3335014581680298,
-0.713941216468811,
-0.2074301689863205,
-0.33902257680892944,
-0.08405441790819168,
0.6745297312736511,
0.17409475147724152,
1.0496424436569214,
0.16883793473243713,
0.2783297002315521,
0.2677791118621826,
0.4453994333744049,
0.28256258368492126,
-0.24156342446804047,
0.508467972278595,
0.0049265599809587,
-0.3984108865261078,
-0.17696481943130493,
0.16775758564472198,
0.43514376878738403,
0.23782692849636078,
-0.4060072898864746,
0.25629541277885437,
0.2530413866043091,
0.601810097694397,
-0.896670937538147,
0.12987053394317627,
-0.029115308076143265,
0.6890953779220581,
-0.05328575521707535,
-0.34736913442611694,
-0.15198834240436554,
-0.37510743737220764,
-0.16117046773433685,
-0.7567511200904846,
-0.17524096369743347,
0.14725323021411896,
0.5252528190612793,
0.4768907129764557,
-0.3682251572608948,
-0.40987512469291687,
-0.8751264810562134,
0.4341447651386261,
-0.46291404962539673,
0.42688509821891785,
-0.02676554024219513,
0.49475041031837463,
0.24270819127559662,
-0.6991000771522522,
-1.006530523300171,
-0.12854139506816864,
-0.21794575452804565,
0.40165477991104126,
-0.2680317163467407,
0.13207502663135529,
0.08223717659711838,
0.40399205684661865,
-0.5961500406265259,
-0.2956727147102356,
-0.27884113788604736,
-0.0882192999124527,
0.47856301069259644,
0.7090962529182434,
0.7811880111694336,
-0.47338056564331055,
-0.1972774863243103,
-0.22097143530845642,
-0.3024115562438965,
-0.18669210374355316,
0.22829270362854004,
-0.004658765625208616,
-0.27871569991111755,
0.7676692008972168,
0.25452902913093567,
0.7357237935066223,
-0.2851427495479584,
-0.22519096732139587,
0.3642069101333618,
0.36797651648521423,
-0.40383514761924744,
0.007493417244404554,
0.743270754814148,
0.7929723262786865,
-0.08583223074674606,
-0.16382236778736115,
-0.0441659651696682,
0.23094089329242706,
0.7127293348312378,
-0.7672026753425598,
0.03745272755622864,
0.27954035997390747,
-0.9310489296913147,
-0.29348957538604736,
0.035347599536180496,
-1.1381388902664185,
-0.6100706458091736,
-0.4610983431339264,
0.48487067222595215,
-0.6475909948348999,
-0.47098150849342346,
-0.034971680492162704,
-0.4158666431903839,
0.039792485535144806,
0.3249642848968506,
-0.8609004020690918,
-0.1196357011795044,
0.4317212402820587,
0.7323947548866272,
0.02205415815114975,
-0.38491639494895935,
-0.030130397528409958,
0.4667302668094635,
-0.11698419600725174,
0.4458436369895935,
-0.8453354835510254,
-0.5917757153511047,
0.10901505500078201,
-0.26596537232398987,
-0.11483713984489441,
-0.36098945140838623,
0.553312361240387,
-0.04254980757832527,
0.4033397138118744,
0.03948531672358513,
-0.3239855468273163,
-0.27913999557495117,
0.2913089990615845,
-0.6885582804679871,
0.3283250629901886,
0.016679631546139717,
-0.7562130093574524,
0.14000515639781952,
-0.9295802116394043,
-0.2973670959472656,
0.4044075310230255,
-0.486202210187912,
-0.02165396884083748,
0.5252129435539246,
-0.19955496490001678,
0.2597843408584595,
-0.04797494411468506,
-0.2214737832546234,
-0.006841829977929592,
-0.3974474370479584,
0.19581034779548645,
-0.358086496591568,
0.3518696427345276,
0.6234269142150879,
-0.520539402961731,
0.25461235642433167,
-0.45675989985466003,
-0.02713172324001789,
0.17489440739154816,
0.05081301927566528,
-0.36803963780403137,
-0.14229312539100647,
0.2777530252933502,
0.31625813245773315,
-0.1356070637702942,
-0.5549429059028625,
0.19700290262699127,
-0.06052262708544731,
0.3877241909503937,
0.4112901985645294,
-0.194034606218338,
0.1204770877957344,
-0.5177724957466125,
1.067092776298523,
-0.012754619121551514,
0.21253958344459534,
-0.5196459889411926,
-0.44000697135925293,
-0.6694435477256775,
-0.14808602631092072,
-0.26005592942237854,
0.3261619508266449,
-0.9824473857879639,
-0.21770018339157104,
-0.2107478827238083,
-0.5132982730865479,
-0.842069149017334,
-0.18599756062030792,
0.11031436920166016,
0.3451659381389618,
0.2877670228481293,
-0.08665543794631958,
-0.5018298029899597,
-0.8888751268386841,
-0.30584612488746643,
-0.25240322947502136,
-0.301673024892807,
0.581307590007782,
0.3276121914386749,
-0.7073832750320435,
0.7150367498397827,
-0.6556578278541565,
-0.3566344380378723,
-0.18520872294902802,
0.5665231347084045,
0.057606495916843414,
0.4871468245983124,
0.6670215129852295,
-0.9161940813064575,
-0.13100919127464294,
-0.27198317646980286,
-1.071318507194519,
0.12306094169616699,
-0.5350551605224609,
-0.05687755346298218,
0.10397545248270035,
-0.027189156040549278,
-1.0107499361038208,
0.47722065448760986,
0.6228651404380798,
-0.6540624499320984,
0.6360346078872681,
-0.3083558976650238,
0.7244871258735657,
-1.0999294519424438,
0.30740058422088623,
-0.3842129409313202,
0.08379200100898743,
-0.20236827433109283,
0.21562112867832184,
-0.22409696877002716,
-0.6072116494178772,
-0.5423418283462524,
0.5930487513542175,
-0.37465932965278625,
0.0040068309754133224,
-0.3060765862464905,
-0.01035365741699934,
0.004693242255598307,
0.47266680002212524,
0.3566766381263733,
0.339769572019577,
0.40193721652030945,
-0.13225214183330536,
0.6276630163192749,
0.3218230605125427,
-0.22459948062896729,
0.7289926409721375,
-0.20249536633491516,
0.27006796002388,
-0.2912987172603607,
0.2245950549840927,
-0.8478286266326904,
-0.1869897097349167,
0.63741534948349,
-0.2819291055202484,
0.06950488686561584,
0.44132137298583984,
-0.4253978431224823,
-0.5364586710929871,
-0.14975956082344055,
0.6589093208312988,
0.6315141320228577,
-0.43288302421569824,
1.417925238609314,
0.17304597795009613,
-0.042826518416404724,
-0.17459335923194885,
-0.6772143244743347,
0.517124354839325,
-0.5666913390159607,
-0.4699896275997162,
0.4170714020729065,
-0.3523752689361572,
-0.16447857022285461,
0.14235453307628632,
0.22416551411151886,
0.17525142431259155,
-0.2892524003982544,
0.9959640502929688,
0.15237148106098175,
0.11110366135835648,
0.20610328018665314,
0.27655357122421265,
-0.14184536039829254,
0.3262292444705963,
-0.048522576689720154,
0.32862305641174316,
-0.24635091423988342,
-0.4188386797904968,
-0.7039440870285034,
0.7097183465957642,
1.0691947937011719,
-0.011843440122902393,
0.6000756621360779,
0.7252421975135803,
-0.575051486492157,
0.048308998346328735,
-0.6930645108222961,
0.005062649957835674,
-0.39132073521614075,
-0.23202654719352722,
-0.6051662564277649,
-0.6219319105148315,
0.3561282455921173,
-0.06817013025283813,
0.1030430719256401,
0.3146689832210541,
0.38632604479789734,
-0.6664158701896667,
0.7095808982849121,
0.46154314279556274,
0.1463603377342224,
0.41293901205062866,
-0.1508851796388626,
-0.04508303478360176,
-0.8499788045883179,
-0.40838906168937683,
0.0999615490436554,
-0.8750162124633789,
-0.27182644605636597,
-0.5636041164398193,
0.3973333537578583,
-0.34390801191329956,
-0.02486960031092167,
-0.030849982053041458,
-0.6164770722389221,
0.12221499532461166,
0.5686880946159363,
0.34089356660842896,
0.18546675145626068,
-0.2123999148607254,
-0.09651520848274231,
-0.4243485629558563,
-0.21438921988010406,
-0.6001973152160645,
0.5812563300132751,
0.051887258887290955,
0.74400794506073,
0.03450971096754074,
0.7690529823303223,
0.5606906414031982,
0.6270432472229004,
-0.5330958962440491,
0.5634512901306152,
0.3372507095336914,
-0.4383179545402527,
-0.22429031133651733,
-0.12380237132310867,
-0.8687127232551575,
0.19928498566150665,
-0.5169939398765564,
-0.6556241512298584,
0.2431056797504425,
0.33613044023513794,
-0.543166995048523,
0.5171046853065491,
-0.3580954670906067,
0.8378452658653259,
-0.3585749566555023,
-0.19975145161151886,
-0.908195436000824,
-0.6073622107505798,
0.2609870731830597,
0.379675954580307,
0.1708574742078781,
0.16891856491565704,
-0.053972914814949036,
0.57136470079422,
-0.19715066254138947,
0.8780665397644043,
-0.1008823812007904,
0.10548657178878784,
0.5483136773109436,
0.685973048210144,
0.12129899114370346,
-0.1531764417886734,
-0.04557134956121445,
0.005989043973386288,
-0.028809934854507446,
-0.18921983242034912,
-0.7058397531509399,
0.6083767414093018,
-0.4987677037715912,
-0.6070423126220703,
-0.27949073910713196,
-0.5207927227020264,
0.03803670033812523,
0.020771443843841553,
0.13057690858840942,
0.16286659240722656,
-0.6309570670127869,
0.00480657210573554,
0.3128661513328552,
-0.42359939217567444,
0.6199859976768494,
0.20006980001926422,
-0.48196542263031006,
-0.5670413374900818,
0.7756123542785645,
-0.06440971791744232,
-0.34039464592933655,
0.3982314169406891,
0.29074689745903015,
-0.009380834177136421,
0.025200888514518738,
-0.4231535494327545,
0.1723945587873459,
-0.4517681300640106,
-0.16992498934268951,
-0.7231179475784302,
-0.030846374109387398,
-0.028644699603319168,
-0.3283354640007019,
-0.20186544954776764,
-0.3156469762325287,
-0.16510944068431854,
-0.4408043920993805,
-0.03825190290808678,
0.5085481405258179,
-0.32565465569496155,
-0.13384374976158142,
-0.8940527439117432,
0.6735212206840515,
0.8535836338996887,
0.3245945870876312,
0.27078381180763245,
0.06619112193584442,
-0.28660571575164795,
0.22335653007030487,
-0.4445347189903259,
-1.03269362449646,
0.5922509431838989,
0.1108560860157013,
0.35312944650650024,
0.6894021034240723,
0.07400213927030563,
0.6218789219856262,
-0.27509814500808716,
0.8110895752906799,
0.5233898758888245,
-0.857982337474823,
0.937964677810669,
-0.35344070196151733,
0.339834064245224,
0.29624518752098083,
0.35771551728248596,
-1.0025132894515991,
-0.19566158950328827,
-0.6586337089538574,
-0.5595805048942566,
0.2623002231121063,
0.4434307813644409,
0.46944108605384827,
-0.08127898722887039,
0.6819015741348267,
0.35507071018218994,
0.45487716794013977,
-0.8631505966186523,
-0.15825189650058746,
-0.6653416156768799,
-0.41733086109161377,
-0.06006492301821709,
-0.5871938467025757,
-0.17357449233531952,
-0.17881755530834198,
0.2456538826227188,
-0.11437302827835083,
0.549140453338623,
0.16412971913814545,
-0.00627715140581131,
-0.38274386525154114,
0.018477899953722954,
0.43285131454467773,
0.4700835049152374,
-0.11725722253322601,
0.2997357249259949,
0.03264365345239639,
-0.37237805128097534,
-0.046252213418483734,
-0.09342186897993088,
0.1340385228395462,
0.14352086186408997,
0.3775707483291626,
0.8566668629646301,
0.14555267989635468,
-0.8477146625518799,
0.18003539741039276,
-0.18850958347320557,
0.03383850306272507,
-0.3945609927177429,
0.11237584054470062,
0.2725581228733063,
0.5039260387420654,
0.31849971413612366,
-0.01545771211385727,
0.5153235793113708,
-0.7291770577430725,
-0.13202005624771118,
0.13616429269313812,
-0.6501435041427612,
-0.40211859345436096,
1.0104480981826782,
0.5696189999580383,
-0.6583472490310669,
0.9744889140129089,
0.14899466931819916,
-0.23672930896282196,
0.4796249568462372,
0.5233340263366699,
1.3418233394622803,
-0.5612515807151794,
0.479889452457428,
0.3265891969203949,
0.144085094332695,
0.574099063873291,
0.5285536050796509,
-0.48466482758522034,
-0.6537203192710876,
0.14022719860076904,
-0.6218556761741638,
-0.5580108165740967,
-0.2092355489730835,
-0.699597179889679,
0.006732637993991375,
-0.07396548241376877,
-0.037115346640348434,
-0.2668921649456024,
-0.619504988193512,
-0.6864725947380066,
0.49634605646133423,
0.8557632565498352,
0.6285386681556702,
-1.0399259328842163,
0.41152605414390564,
0.7356186509132385,
-0.3786792755126953,
-0.47614699602127075,
0.07648308575153351,
0.06933186203241348,
-0.5389131903648376,
0.4910980463027954,
0.5305671095848083,
-0.2383974939584732,
-0.10642566531896591,
-0.14685672521591187,
-0.39163392782211304,
1.2507935762405396,
0.38907793164253235,
-0.5873512029647827,
-0.08507221192121506,
0.33453309535980225,
0.7253084778785706,
-0.657551109790802,
0.4296731650829315,
0.2860746681690216,
0.569083571434021,
0.2720731198787689,
-0.5116795897483826,
0.1487138420343399,
-0.45288923382759094,
0.008962465450167656,
0.09688745439052582,
-0.7585769891738892,
0.282040536403656,
-0.49219638109207153,
-0.3126648962497711,
-0.10979126393795013,
0.8950724601745605,
0.21192891895771027,
0.550011157989502,
0.7222878932952881,
0.8010675311088562,
0.4755430221557617,
0.051280442625284195,
1.1114791631698608,
-0.2915979027748108,
-0.016404859721660614,
1.0271780490875244,
0.1041373685002327,
0.6488533020019531,
0.6989821195602417,
0.06364858895540237,
0.810071587562561,
0.6723201870918274,
0.21894975006580353,
0.4540577232837677,
0.18383261561393738,
-0.41376277804374695,
-0.29837384819984436,
-0.1033458262681961,
-0.284537672996521,
0.30731189250946045,
0.20537063479423523,
-0.28380030393600464,
0.0554681234061718,
0.8194138407707214,
-0.2661857306957245,
-0.03650524467229843,
-0.13113003969192505,
0.6765596866607666,
0.20219047367572784,
-0.609021782875061,
-0.02761550433933735,
-0.5239392518997192,
0.2964431345462799,
-0.4191364347934723,
-0.5152010917663574,
-0.3217643201351166,
-0.20054279267787933,
-0.1961735039949417,
-0.8823896050453186,
0.6294234991073608,
-0.2763589322566986,
0.009539248421788216,
-0.6419447660446167,
0.5231715440750122,
-0.3025078773498535,
-0.4780958592891693,
0.18022271990776062,
0.3155347406864166,
0.14760184288024902,
-0.25452929735183716,
-0.6587226986885071,
0.2478993684053421,
-0.10552755743265152,
-0.23495496809482574,
-0.07116049528121948,
0.47291526198387146,
0.2935543656349182,
0.943077564239502,
0.09409290552139282,
-0.26052749156951904,
-0.39309385418891907,
0.012851813808083534,
0.6695666909217834,
-0.9988290667533875,
-0.7719936966896057,
-0.7658509016036987,
0.8466564416885376,
0.20924049615859985,
-0.335588663816452,
0.4023466408252716,
0.5050631761550903,
0.11513756215572357,
-0.3944053649902344,
0.5944207906723022,
-0.4126032590866089,
-0.011204509064555168,
-0.22335167229175568,
0.6955577731132507,
-0.6608801484107971,
-0.26064014434814453,
-0.5209285616874695,
-1.0731796026229858,
-0.12761184573173523,
0.42232418060302734,
0.21295930445194244,
-0.1892469823360443,
0.5299451351165771,
0.1508253961801529,
0.0834147110581398,
0.15812329947948456,
0.42923665046691895,
0.2986888289451599,
0.2106473445892334,
0.4638533592224121,
1.180087685585022,
-0.043404147028923035,
0.21210196614265442,
-0.11237664520740509,
-0.30530476570129395,
-0.3321145474910736,
-0.8648493885993958,
-0.5696101784706116,
-0.8951553106307983,
-0.4380228817462921,
-0.17929810285568237,
0.09790713340044022,
0.9830807447433472,
0.473070353269577,
-0.38601645827293396,
-0.22831399738788605,
-0.03951450437307358,
0.09198017418384552,
-0.3463088572025299,
-0.2651754915714264,
0.26826831698417664,
0.004088300745934248,
-0.6877468824386597,
0.21231849491596222,
0.6466836333274841,
0.2910242974758148,
-0.4091753363609314,
-0.11906013637781143,
0.43539613485336304,
0.11289513856172562,
0.5645835399627686,
0.18723945319652557,
-0.635438084602356,
-0.2726435661315918,
-0.5624448657035828,
-0.001363741117529571,
0.014844032935798168,
1.0378735065460205,
-1.0802546739578247,
0.8533660173416138,
0.2726118266582489,
0.2289953976869583,
0.8343367576599121,
-0.24256348609924316,
0.7861931324005127,
0.0018995841965079308,
0.14269432425498962,
0.45855221152305603,
0.36597126722335815,
0.022029384970664978,
-0.44706517457962036,
0.5847840905189514,
0.12980212271213531,
-0.12951591610908508,
-0.5660707950592041,
0.14805051684379578,
-1.0783532857894897,
-0.409417986869812,
0.7384641766548157,
-0.011595631018280983,
-0.02288021519780159,
0.5337775349617004,
-0.7220871448516846,
0.10756831616163254,
0.15706346929073334,
1.2325797080993652,
0.5644457936286926,
-0.5809487104415894,
-0.3381170928478241,
-0.22419962286949158,
0.35940688848495483,
0.2827811539173126,
-0.8186352252960205,
-0.10514359921216965,
0.7522460222244263,
-0.05345058813691139,
0.24243603646755219,
0.34270521998405457,
0.20420584082603455,
0.24639365077018738,
0.23372158408164978,
0.5228951573371887,
-0.23935122787952423,
-0.2261282503604889,
0.03557327762246132,
0.3737369775772095,
-0.3562602698802948,
-0.41627293825149536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00896v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00896v2
|
DiaHalu: A Dialogue-level Hallucination Evaluation Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-01T15:38:55 | 2024-06-17T15:11:20 |
Kedi Chen, Qin Chen, Jie Zhou, Yishen He, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Since large language models (LLMs) achieve significant success in recent
years, the hallucination issue remains a challenge, numerous benchmarks are
proposed to detect the hallucination. Nevertheless, some of these benchmarks
are not naturally generated by LLMs but are intentionally induced. Also, many
merely focus on the factuality hallucination while ignoring the faithfulness
hallucination. Additionally, although dialogue pattern is more widely utilized
in the era of LLMs, current benchmarks only concentrate on sentence-level and
passage-level hallucination. In this study, we propose DiaHalu, the first
dialogue-level hallucination evaluation benchmark to our knowledge. Initially,
we integrate the collected topics into system prompts and facilitate a dialogue
between two ChatGPT3.5. Subsequently, we manually modify the contents that do
not adhere to human language conventions and then have LLMs re-generate,
simulating authentic human-machine interaction scenarios. Finally, professional
scholars annotate all the samples in the dataset. DiaHalu covers four common
multi-turn dialogue domains and five hallucination subtypes, extended from
factuality and faithfulness hallucination. Experiments through some well-known
LLMs and detection methods on the dataset show that DiaHalu is a challenging
benchmark, holding significant value for further research.
|
[
-0.47714751958847046,
-1.06853187084198,
0.5690189599990845,
0.36455968022346497,
-0.38219091296195984,
0.07939505577087402,
-0.2511431872844696,
-0.47198155522346497,
0.13435497879981995,
0.5201343894004822,
-0.5391630530357361,
-0.7573227286338806,
-0.3943004310131073,
0.41830819845199585,
-0.5972698926925659,
0.6273462176322937,
0.09571847319602966,
-0.08416273444890976,
-0.28800931572914124,
0.0199494119733572,
-0.6601224541664124,
-0.5893154740333557,
-0.43625691533088684,
-0.2506833076477051,
0.30551761388778687,
0.22025175392627716,
0.5866496562957764,
0.14702241122722626,
0.42330682277679443,
0.31768348813056946,
-0.0018373781349509954,
0.3340549170970917,
-0.677970290184021,
0.33186104893684387,
0.33171480894088745,
-0.3285209834575653,
-0.5187621712684631,
-0.008393104188144207,
0.7605717182159424,
0.7091493606567383,
-0.27198949456214905,
-0.14960235357284546,
0.09513192623853683,
0.4282318651676178,
-0.5379951596260071,
0.2433570772409439,
-0.6804871559143066,
0.0825352668762207,
-0.24721188843250275,
-0.20795191824436188,
-0.5838804244995117,
-0.6680657863616943,
0.0671994537115097,
-0.45007088780403137,
0.05755853280425072,
0.05034933239221573,
0.7735925316810608,
0.5508544445037842,
-0.09263208508491516,
-0.3762846887111664,
-0.8298701643943787,
0.8081455230712891,
-0.81462162733078,
0.6645991206169128,
0.4538164734840393,
0.3130292296409607,
-0.2811296582221985,
-0.39121437072753906,
-0.7192598581314087,
-0.47035643458366394,
-0.30191943049430847,
-0.023296533152461052,
-0.2727341055870056,
0.023472176864743233,
0.3277842700481415,
0.3143869638442993,
-0.7743180394172668,
0.03516034036874771,
-0.00802659336477518,
-0.24136604368686676,
0.3736967146396637,
0.32504385709762573,
0.23141618072986603,
-0.10922302305698395,
-0.21035096049308777,
-0.019861306995153427,
-0.6026740074157715,
-0.4321940541267395,
0.2411688268184662,
-0.02473634108901024,
-0.05193237215280533,
0.2807403802871704,
-0.2556624710559845,
0.6994813680648804,
-0.2260817140340805,
-0.14655819535255432,
0.39455485343933105,
-0.36417487263679504,
-0.227559432387352,
0.279516339302063,
0.891387939453125,
0.37214672565460205,
0.32494333386421204,
-0.24923668801784515,
-0.23826101422309875,
0.2440713346004486,
0.22012363374233246,
-0.9828706383705139,
-0.3912241458892822,
0.23558713495731354,
-0.36637845635414124,
-0.2729213237762451,
-0.049164485186338425,
-0.9906657338142395,
-0.5887671709060669,
-0.08363707363605499,
0.17889702320098877,
-0.4627981185913086,
-0.36282628774642944,
0.2481636255979538,
0.3875463902950287,
0.40968236327171326,
0.4380472004413605,
-0.7639720439910889,
0.5466083288192749,
0.8387312889099121,
0.8682974576950073,
-0.4549025297164917,
-0.3825945258140564,
-0.6270228028297424,
-0.05207822099328041,
-0.5339321494102478,
0.9017911553382874,
-0.7469812631607056,
-0.46285825967788696,
0.04075079783797264,
-0.1617092341184616,
-0.1083487793803215,
-0.919532299041748,
0.6308626532554626,
-0.40252265334129333,
0.11728033423423767,
-0.1264335960149765,
-0.5142661333084106,
-0.2099391520023346,
0.33808189630508423,
-0.6958832740783691,
0.922787070274353,
0.004248755984008312,
-0.6367056369781494,
0.296852707862854,
-0.3972861170768738,
-0.31949272751808167,
0.1789235919713974,
-0.42514488101005554,
-0.5889804363250732,
-0.07173523306846619,
0.028724774718284607,
0.28964725136756897,
-0.4761695861816406,
0.6108372807502747,
-0.3101186156272888,
-0.7388527393341064,
0.4025736153125763,
-0.6404387354850769,
0.45718446373939514,
0.0023972128983587027,
-0.33067086338996887,
0.05521583557128906,
-0.7334488034248352,
-0.3713279664516449,
0.04687170311808586,
-0.17438183724880219,
-0.3173588216304779,
-0.10715939849615097,
-0.0943729504942894,
-0.016478952020406723,
0.11112112551927567,
-0.4787222743034363,
0.2608034014701843,
-0.3156747817993164,
0.1622164100408554,
0.7085294723510742,
-0.027749694883823395,
-0.13766370713710785,
-0.283820778131485,
0.42036694288253784,
0.1463180035352707,
0.09044450521469116,
0.024046268314123154,
-0.4879637658596039,
-0.8895782828330994,
-0.3709386885166168,
0.2554231584072113,
0.4780102074146271,
-0.4792473614215851,
0.5043112635612488,
-0.23495587706565857,
-0.29854971170425415,
-0.6903248429298401,
0.13037486374378204,
0.4195905923843384,
0.29072311520576477,
0.3218831419944763,
-0.2970787584781647,
-0.5945872664451599,
-0.9371652603149414,
-0.039833132177591324,
-0.508372962474823,
0.04702649265527725,
0.3689686954021454,
0.40611785650253296,
-0.4400298595428467,
0.7226179242134094,
-0.39184871315956116,
-0.3745795786380768,
-0.22984875738620758,
0.3038080632686615,
0.18002675473690033,
0.17118142545223236,
0.26032906770706177,
-0.6629880666732788,
-0.30491411685943604,
-0.19584479928016663,
-1.1390167474746704,
-0.4057464897632599,
-0.32718056440353394,
-0.07931049913167953,
0.33417901396751404,
0.55824875831604,
-0.7520284056663513,
0.32548773288726807,
0.519646942615509,
-0.1705675721168518,
0.7818402051925659,
-0.0007443763897754252,
0.36515527963638306,
-0.8502180576324463,
0.057752352207899094,
-0.156030535697937,
-0.10255450755357742,
-0.7684400677680969,
-0.24259749054908752,
-0.24093006551265717,
0.16194844245910645,
-0.15980315208435059,
0.3477398157119751,
-0.12044601142406464,
-0.23978285491466522,
-0.05839530751109123,
0.3615228235721588,
-0.08806207031011581,
0.47379961609840393,
0.1704770177602768,
0.7958196401596069,
0.5238892436027527,
-0.4975351095199585,
0.4775753617286682,
0.5554341673851013,
-0.6493815183639526,
0.5484927892684937,
-0.7491080164909363,
0.2736302316188812,
0.17406679689884186,
0.3274746835231781,
-0.9550639390945435,
-0.011376389302313328,
0.35699424147605896,
-0.17758452892303467,
0.06033793091773987,
0.07926338911056519,
-0.6206173300743103,
0.01157466322183609,
-0.2955838143825531,
0.6375191807746887,
0.4072502851486206,
-0.44939514994621277,
0.34060949087142944,
0.29086747765541077,
-0.04802663251757622,
-0.3569333553314209,
-0.31193625926971436,
0.45893609523773193,
-0.5274540781974792,
-0.48365873098373413,
0.24209584295749664,
-0.3583895266056061,
-0.42774662375450134,
-0.5290647149085999,
-0.05086590349674225,
0.29317834973335266,
0.11950371414422989,
0.26084378361701965,
0.34524062275886536,
-0.19076696038246155,
-0.09114047139883041,
-0.13022632896900177,
-0.31526628136634827,
0.27274084091186523,
0.05447370558977127,
0.9943251013755798,
-0.18115097284317017,
-0.47172173857688904,
-0.7886341214179993,
0.13498809933662415,
0.5552557110786438,
0.004953473340719938,
0.4309806525707245,
0.6133377552032471,
-0.48368456959724426,
0.029526907950639725,
-0.760053813457489,
-0.364827036857605,
-0.4218578338623047,
0.3067629039287567,
-0.7446251511573792,
-0.6991313099861145,
0.3922789394855499,
-0.28466475009918213,
0.1242906004190445,
0.04479140415787697,
0.7293044924736023,
0.16876189410686493,
0.933260977268219,
0.25012001395225525,
-0.15781909227371216,
0.13093392550945282,
-0.16682815551757812,
0.3756685256958008,
-0.8443015813827515,
-0.28453823924064636,
-0.5209758281707764,
-0.14599183201789856,
-0.7081064581871033,
-0.396536260843277,
0.4223288893699646,
0.2139757126569748,
0.1192135214805603,
0.44488558173179626,
-0.2343355417251587,
0.18883918225765228,
0.26024365425109863,
-0.00423172814771533,
0.6529352068901062,
-0.11174142360687256,
-0.12066375464200974,
-0.10142409801483154,
-0.4220847189426422,
-0.6838529109954834,
0.7085412740707397,
0.3099967837333679,
0.847801923751831,
0.22384114563465118,
0.9204974174499512,
0.524547815322876,
0.13633239269256592,
-0.6538926362991333,
0.8737292885780334,
0.20924843847751617,
-0.1893906146287918,
-0.403869092464447,
-0.5975663661956787,
-1.0033003091812134,
0.2534247040748596,
-0.011476980522274971,
-0.8885871171951294,
0.2041938751935959,
-0.2075393944978714,
-0.3819401264190674,
-0.01565741002559662,
-0.2606298327445984,
0.933010995388031,
0.0655890554189682,
-0.2161622941493988,
-0.3758814334869385,
-0.4372873604297638,
0.5479040741920471,
-0.256450891494751,
0.2641383707523346,
-0.23812200129032135,
0.23221595585346222,
0.7486488819122314,
-0.13559164106845856,
0.8800498843193054,
0.008990519680082798,
-0.5591683983802795,
0.06320704519748688,
0.5623267292976379,
0.34385913610458374,
0.3406122326850891,
-0.04770845174789429,
0.37049856781959534,
-0.006875315215438604,
-0.08690069615840912,
-0.4619153141975403,
0.8460521101951599,
-0.6803886294364929,
-0.6760137677192688,
-0.4955843389034271,
-0.46891841292381287,
-0.2814885377883911,
-0.005954922642558813,
0.008371739648282528,
0.40108194947242737,
-0.5501285791397095,
0.05146176740527153,
0.8379431962966919,
-0.46752631664276123,
0.23134395480155945,
0.5081363320350647,
-0.5369052290916443,
-0.2555363178253174,
1.1734319925308228,
-0.35213226079940796,
0.2269870489835739,
0.353564977645874,
0.15492676198482513,
-0.230812206864357,
-0.5464330315589905,
-0.6175745725631714,
0.3177400231361389,
-0.5997310280799866,
-0.06723903119564056,
-0.7683146595954895,
-0.42007023096084595,
-0.3110714554786682,
0.15047526359558105,
-0.3311407268047333,
-0.1384963095188141,
-0.22421948611736298,
0.06686826050281525,
0.081749826669693,
0.7301080822944641,
-0.008379269391298294,
-0.1498999297618866,
-0.6601999998092651,
0.6800857782363892,
0.32234376668930054,
0.28165048360824585,
-0.058151546865701675,
-0.5436922907829285,
-0.05012287572026253,
-0.015516341663897038,
-0.19907024502754211,
-0.5617881417274475,
0.2494405061006546,
0.20435798168182373,
0.5653672218322754,
0.6284061074256897,
0.20788460969924927,
0.6340091228485107,
-0.3917526602745056,
0.7709195613861084,
0.06707555800676346,
-0.8641032576560974,
0.5103534460067749,
-0.08208272606134415,
0.18127261102199554,
0.5045490860939026,
0.35381603240966797,
-0.685428261756897,
-0.5346144437789917,
-0.256399929523468,
-0.2688370645046234,
0.5080649256706238,
0.47792887687683105,
0.0666709691286087,
-0.13065223395824432,
0.045839257538318634,
0.43716302514076233,
0.16160665452480316,
-0.4861714541912079,
-0.09642941504716873,
0.01268470287322998,
0.016176212579011917,
-0.03369312360882759,
-0.35342735052108765,
-0.11701404303312302,
-0.27262839674949646,
0.5034999847412109,
0.02658691443502903,
0.28014686703681946,
0.09550848603248596,
-0.3568790853023529,
-0.11292751878499985,
0.18592534959316254,
0.7021386623382568,
0.667574942111969,
-0.38360631465911865,
0.2069859504699707,
0.24242915213108063,
-0.5440796613693237,
0.07613185793161392,
0.02749466337263584,
-0.1896945685148239,
0.2825641930103302,
0.4895241856575012,
0.8401461243629456,
0.19468171894550323,
-0.802470862865448,
0.3261789083480835,
-0.3485293388366699,
-0.07017070055007935,
-0.22093407809734344,
0.04875019192695618,
-0.10012561827898026,
0.22598107159137726,
0.15661469101905823,
-0.4216693937778473,
0.3459247350692749,
-0.6811082363128662,
0.3141099810600281,
0.4834793508052826,
-0.4279251992702484,
-0.3076934218406677,
0.5318962335586548,
0.198692187666893,
-0.41970202326774597,
0.7985671758651733,
-0.244537353515625,
-0.5418838262557983,
0.12920984625816345,
0.43337804079055786,
1.078368067741394,
-0.3156442940235138,
0.40402957797050476,
0.3410715162754059,
0.32117322087287903,
0.09640577435493469,
0.32257571816444397,
-0.11715713888406754,
-0.815289318561554,
-0.22959165275096893,
-1.052675485610962,
-0.5098590850830078,
0.3706856071949005,
-0.5062406063079834,
0.3961236774921417,
-0.045872677117586136,
0.018203089013695717,
-0.07488983869552612,
-0.05533654987812042,
-0.24639654159545898,
-0.15469685196876526,
0.32981905341148376,
0.5235559344291687,
-0.6917516589164734,
0.8483332991600037,
0.11728441715240479,
-0.17409537732601166,
0.05058443918824196,
0.25558409094810486,
-0.046726129949092865,
-0.7079783082008362,
0.386240154504776,
0.39090967178344727,
-0.328204870223999,
-0.03075181506574154,
-0.2827405035495758,
-0.25164544582366943,
0.8681788444519043,
0.2897978723049164,
-0.6858896017074585,
-0.006375215481966734,
0.5940951108932495,
0.45523256063461304,
-0.4030180871486664,
0.3332163393497467,
1.1297588348388672,
0.5567131638526917,
0.08624216169118881,
-0.9447800517082214,
0.28872019052505493,
-0.22772809863090515,
-0.0016231831395998597,
0.06829456239938736,
-0.6471663117408752,
0.5775110721588135,
-0.0344928503036499,
-0.2752612233161926,
0.3336777985095978,
0.6263602375984192,
0.5010827779769897,
0.30373916029930115,
0.7099835872650146,
0.6389375925064087,
0.6210954189300537,
-0.11643997579813004,
0.5847548246383667,
-0.3800722360610962,
0.16531449556350708,
0.898716151714325,
-0.5790143013000488,
0.615325391292572,
0.38342034816741943,
-0.18359078466892242,
0.704954981803894,
0.679198145866394,
-0.03729165345430374,
0.5419605374336243,
0.3956119120121002,
-0.4301016330718994,
-0.45377448201179504,
-0.22754500806331635,
-0.4351102113723755,
0.5060139894485474,
0.5175825357437134,
0.03484370559453964,
-0.15014909207820892,
-0.024966904893517494,
-0.13920779526233673,
-0.11834976077079773,
0.3599368631839752,
1.1451479196548462,
0.1449373960494995,
-0.5603545904159546,
1.1640756130218506,
-0.144795760512352,
0.4272795617580414,
-0.351696640253067,
-0.4616701900959015,
-0.5883965492248535,
0.0014436334604397416,
-0.10261180251836777,
-0.4216651916503906,
0.12449116259813309,
0.03176622465252876,
0.27832257747650146,
-0.04719962552189827,
0.4734342396259308,
-0.41768917441368103,
-0.3004853129386902,
0.4133502244949341,
0.4621899127960205,
0.6869992017745972,
-0.13441966474056244,
-0.5197656154632568,
0.701471745967865,
-0.14833290874958038,
-0.13460999727249146,
0.23058463633060455,
0.5352519154548645,
-0.024744050577282906,
0.6069623827934265,
0.4955914616584778,
-0.12122879922389984,
-0.14695030450820923,
0.6113839745521545,
0.9311130046844482,
-0.5383555293083191,
-0.0463826023042202,
-1.0432547330856323,
0.061827559024095535,
-0.15990430116653442,
-0.3230069577693939,
0.7266456484794617,
0.7767059206962585,
0.8154481649398804,
0.11439488083124161,
0.7452617287635803,
0.1682697832584381,
0.15981502830982208,
-0.6524278521537781,
0.6678899526596069,
-0.4037644565105438,
0.49068114161491394,
-0.5128375291824341,
-1.3325225114822388,
-0.18446747958660126,
0.7977797389030457,
-0.14265893399715424,
0.01141677238047123,
0.8668108582496643,
1.0064127445220947,
-0.07985879480838776,
0.35079702734947205,
0.6615647673606873,
0.5175259113311768,
0.3114594519138336,
0.685511589050293,
1.1502522230148315,
-0.40845030546188354,
0.4823448956012726,
-0.21489404141902924,
-0.42360934615135193,
-0.40285611152648926,
-0.5510389804840088,
-1.136655569076538,
-0.6524355411529541,
-0.48723962903022766,
-0.3725769519805908,
0.13017426431179047,
0.7019006013870239,
0.511092483997345,
-1.0013428926467896,
-0.5427222847938538,
-0.17137010395526886,
0.11538077890872955,
-0.24111555516719818,
-0.18665233254432678,
0.27097195386886597,
-0.2617209255695343,
-0.8271827101707458,
0.5613890290260315,
0.46125978231430054,
-0.07898281514644623,
-0.8097676038742065,
-0.3067459166049957,
-0.1937655210494995,
0.1319383680820465,
0.5938542485237122,
-0.12474367767572403,
-0.8871088624000549,
-0.2286384254693985,
0.06516765803098679,
-0.10049213469028473,
0.20660224556922913,
0.8322094082832336,
-0.7850915789604187,
0.42391642928123474,
0.2911562919616699,
0.5334341526031494,
0.4440248906612396,
-0.08945074677467346,
0.42456313967704773,
-0.433887243270874,
-0.08705785125494003,
0.2356037199497223,
0.23843532800674438,
0.3724302649497986,
-0.0815880298614502,
0.5034103393554688,
0.36809688806533813,
-0.5360308289527893,
-1.1531745195388794,
0.18623732030391693,
-0.9307889938354492,
-0.06382039934396744,
1.2238171100616455,
-0.03627103194594383,
0.014858024194836617,
-0.31939905881881714,
-0.29188454151153564,
0.24294205009937286,
-0.2994459867477417,
1.320745825767517,
0.8904889822006226,
-0.09087003767490387,
-0.18997184932231903,
-0.6505715847015381,
0.6333670616149902,
0.409867525100708,
-1.0070282220840454,
0.5349308252334595,
0.45152974128723145,
-0.2221650630235672,
0.16907469928264618,
0.5348269939422607,
-0.017058061435818672,
0.10941725224256516,
0.005046500358730555,
-0.02460535056889057,
0.321404367685318,
-0.6710806488990784,
-0.22573217749595642,
-0.2022390067577362,
0.005146618001163006,
-0.01912860944867134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00894v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00894v1
|
A systematic evaluation of large language models for generating programming code
| 2024-03-01T14:43:06 | 2024-03-01T14:43:06 |
Wenpin Hou, Zhicheng Ji
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
We systematically evaluated the performance of seven large language models in
generating programming code using various prompt strategies, programming
languages, and task difficulties. GPT-4 substantially outperforms other large
language models, including Gemini Ultra and Claude 2. The coding performance of
GPT-4 varies considerably with different prompt strategies. In most LeetCode
and GeeksforGeeks coding contests evaluated in this study, GPT-4 employing the
optimal prompt strategy outperforms 85 percent of human participants.
Additionally, GPT-4 demonstrates strong capabilities in translating code
between different programming languages and in learning from past errors. The
computational efficiency of the code generated by GPT-4 is comparable to that
of human programmers. These results suggest that GPT-4 has the potential to
serve as a reliable assistant in programming code generation and software
development.
|
[
-0.22996044158935547,
-0.5035778284072876,
0.7958384156227112,
0.442002534866333,
0.03248722851276398,
0.19061359763145447,
-0.3707086145877838,
-0.23886127769947052,
-0.12019218504428864,
-0.0031220540404319763,
-0.41406360268592834,
-0.4530399739742279,
-0.3372343182563782,
0.5796635746955872,
-0.3473837971687317,
1.087093710899353,
0.041895560920238495,
0.127604141831398,
0.19667693972587585,
0.4146503806114197,
-0.650029718875885,
-0.7347336411476135,
-0.6472097039222717,
0.022185908630490303,
0.30712899565696716,
0.26866981387138367,
0.5949487090110779,
0.22080190479755402,
0.7496771812438965,
0.39562779664993286,
0.44056782126426697,
-0.28416451811790466,
-0.4661356806755066,
0.08030833303928375,
-0.19449447095394135,
-0.2793136537075043,
-0.3627887964248657,
0.12297684699296951,
0.439432293176651,
0.19160018861293793,
-0.2371852993965149,
0.16091366112232208,
-0.07896534353494644,
0.49952131509780884,
-0.09427690505981445,
0.3296555280685425,
-0.538661539554596,
-0.09623584151268005,
-0.3950372636318207,
-0.3086181581020355,
-0.394391268491745,
-0.7280101180076599,
-0.17134104669094086,
-0.4998447299003601,
0.34272322058677673,
-0.08077210932970047,
0.6028307676315308,
0.022133104503154755,
-0.03944838419556618,
-0.738430917263031,
-0.5307115316390991,
0.572433590888977,
-0.7614654898643494,
0.21828994154930115,
0.11669382452964783,
0.29238730669021606,
-0.1392562836408615,
-0.962806761264801,
-0.626030683517456,
-0.5644471645355225,
0.4531005322933197,
0.12262405455112457,
-0.2283461093902588,
0.05210164189338684,
0.6433616280555725,
0.27998340129852295,
-0.7791686058044434,
0.019687499850988388,
-0.6163138151168823,
-0.1773659735918045,
0.40625,
0.06883295625448227,
0.5206834673881531,
-0.3527350425720215,
0.14962276816368103,
0.041395433247089386,
-0.7379711866378784,
-0.14175328612327576,
0.6684001088142395,
-0.0037624426186084747,
0.043189290910959244,
0.5503943562507629,
-0.21126654744148254,
0.6573630571365356,
0.06289734691381454,
-0.24764396250247955,
0.3376333713531494,
-0.6008107662200928,
-0.0354163758456707,
-0.2961643636226654,
0.741887629032135,
0.39865294098854065,
0.2191743105649948,
-0.16638709604740143,
-0.4809921979904175,
0.24842941761016846,
0.364650696516037,
-0.8176132440567017,
-0.5011098980903625,
0.03332686424255371,
-0.4900693893432617,
-0.28355225920677185,
-0.0295953880995512,
-0.44618600606918335,
-0.08223676681518555,
-0.13771870732307434,
0.21641908586025238,
-0.40187668800354004,
-0.2736763656139374,
-0.05810124799609184,
-0.29241809248924255,
0.2912319302558899,
0.20730967819690704,
-0.8028947114944458,
0.10556896775960922,
0.6170384287834167,
0.913861095905304,
-0.27369850873947144,
-0.29327359795570374,
-0.46580687165260315,
-0.19749604165554047,
-0.5549465417861938,
0.41108107566833496,
-0.5400851368904114,
-0.4681001305580139,
-0.045554518699645996,
-0.3575579822063446,
0.17819100618362427,
-0.40852120518684387,
0.4316379725933075,
-0.5859460830688477,
0.01539464108645916,
-0.38450145721435547,
-0.4984029531478882,
0.10850993543863297,
0.19434325397014618,
-0.6597951650619507,
0.70231693983078,
0.5402733683586121,
-0.6746137142181396,
0.24938428401947021,
-0.8815444111824036,
-0.15885713696479797,
0.3972747325897217,
-0.42851224541664124,
-0.18175505101680756,
0.11565226316452026,
-0.042732737958431244,
0.45667511224746704,
-0.47747373580932617,
0.20387890934944153,
-0.030738526955246925,
-0.4892413318157196,
0.3133731484413147,
-0.17389611899852753,
0.5384199619293213,
0.3410528302192688,
-0.6825324296951294,
0.11218173056840897,
-0.552406907081604,
0.0727180764079094,
0.31972065567970276,
-0.588961660861969,
0.11866626143455505,
-0.3915829658508301,
-0.2134391814470291,
0.31774741411209106,
0.22157754004001617,
-0.5128107666969299,
0.5520966053009033,
-0.10760173201560974,
0.5771644115447998,
0.7095162272453308,
0.20959265530109406,
0.21042250096797943,
0.10823360830545425,
0.983387291431427,
-0.4976653754711151,
0.09289924055337906,
-0.2766045033931732,
-0.8017640113830566,
-0.3105015754699707,
0.009782437235116959,
0.31108421087265015,
0.48869094252586365,
-1.206612229347229,
0.006944033782929182,
-0.024726057425141335,
-0.35364603996276855,
0.016179339960217476,
0.22967316210269928,
0.6015118360519409,
0.30933165550231934,
0.04109548404812813,
-0.30109813809394836,
-0.4048227369785309,
-0.816021203994751,
-0.024080220609903336,
-0.09207846224308014,
-0.0810888335108757,
0.1613442748785019,
0.45852571725845337,
-0.4103702902793884,
0.5758013725280762,
-0.4067193865776062,
0.4574911594390869,
-0.4888569116592407,
0.2407451570034027,
0.49933645129203796,
0.41617265343666077,
0.7078930735588074,
-0.42522796988487244,
-0.6370528340339661,
0.10255716741085052,
-0.576870858669281,
-0.23617881536483765,
-0.0929521769285202,
-0.07195784151554108,
0.424379825592041,
0.2554314136505127,
-0.6039091348648071,
0.265946626663208,
0.7046370506286621,
-0.2870226502418518,
0.9777767062187195,
-0.29562652111053467,
0.4094115197658539,
-0.7000693678855896,
0.2719724774360657,
-0.2579791843891144,
-0.10940423607826233,
-0.42687276005744934,
0.25498563051223755,
0.21970348060131073,
-0.4011376202106476,
-0.05514727905392647,
0.15018954873085022,
-0.5947446227073669,
-0.33757126331329346,
-0.10844817757606506,
0.059440623968839645,
-0.3675265908241272,
0.3647461235523224,
0.023146135732531548,
1.1153355836868286,
0.6142366528511047,
-0.377383828163147,
0.6711517572402954,
-0.02882022224366665,
-0.38508981466293335,
0.27920782566070557,
-0.8851646780967712,
0.5175848007202148,
0.2502267062664032,
0.2290385514497757,
-0.9479467272758484,
-0.3587473928928375,
-0.09712838381528854,
-0.545744001865387,
0.4403567314147949,
-0.057990867644548416,
-0.513630747795105,
-0.9007812738418579,
-0.32006967067718506,
0.3250695466995239,
0.8579912185668945,
-0.30000466108322144,
-0.0898340716958046,
0.01505248062312603,
-0.4951614737510681,
-0.3693961799144745,
-0.24371491372585297,
0.21990564465522766,
-0.07006362825632095,
-0.4807995557785034,
-0.03832419216632843,
-0.14785906672477722,
-0.025545815005898476,
-0.290431946516037,
0.0873418003320694,
0.2228257954120636,
-0.1306907683610916,
0.07635345309972763,
0.3656107783317566,
-0.10508586466312408,
-0.23726913332939148,
-0.33767613768577576,
-0.23394903540611267,
0.09796342998743057,
-0.4940347373485565,
0.6907774806022644,
-0.25121527910232544,
-0.4145081043243408,
-0.16315039992332458,
0.3681556284427643,
0.3237856924533844,
-0.13233770430088043,
0.2729373872280121,
0.37743860483169556,
0.03235333040356636,
-0.18861651420593262,
-0.4756287634372711,
0.013481072150170803,
-0.48642510175704956,
0.47095629572868347,
-0.6692442893981934,
-0.6940195560455322,
0.43116480112075806,
-0.028493080288171768,
0.18539442121982574,
0.339041143655777,
0.815026044845581,
0.4438129663467407,
1.1804897785186768,
0.5984145998954773,
-0.028385164216160774,
0.3513681888580322,
-0.2579519748687744,
0.3049048185348511,
-0.3928704857826233,
-0.11651340872049332,
-0.7188200950622559,
0.04446917399764061,
-0.6365805864334106,
-0.5001106262207031,
0.379257470369339,
0.0269582811743021,
-0.47916004061698914,
0.34176012873649597,
-0.7797025442123413,
0.536641538143158,
0.6926952600479126,
-0.2242458015680313,
0.10894755274057388,
-0.10796499252319336,
-0.20689573884010315,
-0.03217260539531708,
-0.723701000213623,
-0.5283824801445007,
1.2210618257522583,
0.33224260807037354,
0.7843921780586243,
0.3459874987602234,
0.8407604694366455,
0.1919213980436325,
0.4728412628173828,
-0.3086569905281067,
0.33223241567611694,
0.13149216771125793,
-0.621543824672699,
-0.19539405405521393,
-0.6938357353210449,
-0.7234044671058655,
-0.23281554877758026,
0.19543787837028503,
-0.6053540706634521,
-0.2609383165836334,
0.20028221607208252,
-0.4305170476436615,
-0.07982560247182846,
-0.9422934651374817,
0.938040554523468,
-0.2524864673614502,
-0.26036572456359863,
-0.019550584256649017,
-0.565876841545105,
0.5224471092224121,
-0.41923826932907104,
0.0749179869890213,
0.24552227556705475,
0.045132748782634735,
0.7153681516647339,
-0.2901226282119751,
0.4181154668331146,
-0.32121434807777405,
-0.21869927644729614,
0.40918204188346863,
0.2765960991382599,
0.5691759586334229,
0.10664671659469604,
-0.21344558894634247,
-0.008581061847507954,
-0.2007783055305481,
-0.35600191354751587,
-0.49776148796081543,
0.8870304822921753,
-0.8430261015892029,
-0.3884541690349579,
-0.33739903569221497,
-0.28177547454833984,
-0.15059328079223633,
0.30901041626930237,
0.5999354720115662,
0.71818608045578,
-0.1536821871995926,
-0.03192039951682091,
0.3035440444946289,
-0.6844229102134705,
0.6688118577003479,
0.3167949318885803,
-0.3553828299045563,
-0.3350735902786255,
0.8186810612678528,
-0.06962253153324127,
0.2939728796482086,
0.03996153920888901,
-0.01296944823116064,
-0.3587420582771301,
-0.7147394418716431,
-0.6385548710823059,
0.15331514179706573,
-0.6981300711631775,
-0.3848142623901367,
-0.4942006468772888,
-0.076356902718544,
-0.46137693524360657,
-0.4248899221420288,
-0.2686615288257599,
-0.31189221143722534,
0.26820099353790283,
-0.1503296047449112,
0.13662084937095642,
1.3149256706237793,
-0.04691873490810394,
0.1344573199748993,
-0.8354925513267517,
0.2718314826488495,
0.30169838666915894,
0.31537729501724243,
-0.1236264780163765,
-0.10039801895618439,
-0.1697348952293396,
-0.24909137189388275,
-0.4024372100830078,
-1.0920722484588623,
0.2850683629512787,
-0.22639013826847076,
0.5668606758117676,
0.16169527173042297,
-0.33244964480400085,
0.3707205057144165,
-0.7445963621139526,
1.272323489189148,
0.532589852809906,
-1.1175658702850342,
0.4396539628505707,
-0.7523018717765808,
0.4698205590248108,
0.29023027420043945,
0.23054827749729156,
-0.30404946208000183,
-0.32085418701171875,
-0.7659640908241272,
-0.5634251236915588,
0.7251086235046387,
0.5099827647209167,
0.09025046974420547,
-0.24358457326889038,
0.47822314500808716,
0.12924909591674805,
0.3593392074108124,
-0.8448590040206909,
0.11669235676527023,
-0.4628303050994873,
-0.004256062209606171,
-0.031548745930194855,
-0.11896821856498718,
0.23384501039981842,
-0.06524752080440521,
0.45286503434181213,
-0.16209839284420013,
0.6048820614814758,
-0.07642451673746109,
0.17699426412582397,
0.08212999999523163,
0.16006819903850555,
0.678192675113678,
0.9454965591430664,
0.08587755262851715,
-0.038400303572416306,
-0.13773375749588013,
-0.5076180100440979,
0.03059474565088749,
0.0031470097601413727,
-0.11992810666561127,
-0.060238245874643326,
0.44414427876472473,
0.517234206199646,
-0.00729597732424736,
-0.5756614804267883,
0.6726019382476807,
-0.18258430063724518,
-0.26302483677864075,
-0.10703322291374207,
0.23240898549556732,
0.1995231658220291,
0.04593677073717117,
0.297277569770813,
-0.011917110532522202,
0.45833471417427063,
-0.654552161693573,
0.13038164377212524,
0.3269011378288269,
0.21323543787002563,
-0.44567200541496277,
0.6316448450088501,
0.530450165271759,
-0.19986023008823395,
0.7773276567459106,
-0.7063804268836975,
-0.7181478142738342,
0.5819258689880371,
0.8580706715583801,
0.7232872247695923,
-0.4296134114265442,
0.2788999676704407,
0.6434274315834045,
0.24906791746616364,
-0.18895858526229858,
0.47542014718055725,
-0.008827544748783112,
-0.3392272889614105,
-0.7274391651153564,
-0.5915403962135315,
-0.3066151738166809,
-0.07146814465522766,
-0.2478654980659485,
0.1359325349330902,
-0.4383552074432373,
-0.2598452866077423,
-0.09497729688882828,
0.1437501460313797,
-0.7928465008735657,
-0.18749414384365082,
0.21932601928710938,
0.8129003643989563,
-0.5336172580718994,
0.7390486001968384,
0.7649603486061096,
-0.5239624977111816,
-1.3508403301239014,
-0.15527915954589844,
-0.002591688185930252,
-0.4821969270706177,
0.7265691757202148,
0.09815729409456253,
-0.07662054151296616,
0.0923052653670311,
-0.6758200526237488,
-0.8387490510940552,
0.858344316482544,
0.33420848846435547,
-0.6136309504508972,
-0.06933306902647018,
-0.22344282269477844,
0.39128580689430237,
-0.2738344073295593,
0.41671881079673767,
0.7311593890190125,
0.44197818636894226,
0.21783511340618134,
-1.3155269622802734,
-0.05867975577712059,
-0.36023861169815063,
0.29192695021629333,
0.19078263640403748,
-0.3727022409439087,
0.98065584897995,
-0.40402987599372864,
-0.13634470105171204,
0.4015410840511322,
0.353715181350708,
0.5310450792312622,
0.04086162894964218,
0.018987447023391724,
0.06690428406000137,
0.814125120639801,
-0.16833727061748505,
1.3641818761825562,
-0.43043282628059387,
0.3612726628780365,
0.6037122011184692,
-0.4205607771873474,
0.4598255157470703,
-0.049357302486896515,
-0.39008569717407227,
0.45224088430404663,
0.4237010180950165,
0.027924194931983948,
0.4279567003250122,
0.3435654938220978,
0.07021487504243851,
0.1362873762845993,
0.6388112306594849,
-0.5606610178947449,
0.2354295253753662,
0.12604352831840515,
-0.17916829884052277,
-0.0838557556271553,
-0.042653780430555344,
0.2872216999530792,
-0.22180449962615967,
-0.2975118160247803,
0.6045145392417908,
-0.07440637052059174,
-1.0536623001098633,
0.6906068921089172,
0.28096804022789,
0.6311857104301453,
-0.658087968826294,
-0.24678678810596466,
-0.23815856873989105,
0.2846909165382385,
-0.18318429589271545,
-0.6873109936714172,
0.06180039793252945,
0.3879719376564026,
0.037301067262887955,
-0.08653172105550766,
0.5427767038345337,
-0.12014839798212051,
-0.29328039288520813,
-0.1921282708644867,
0.4141339063644409,
0.32186004519462585,
0.00686710886657238,
-0.7841286063194275,
0.2224188596010208,
0.35181599855422974,
-0.39674854278564453,
0.1186678484082222,
0.5581069588661194,
0.012927110306918621,
0.4443291127681732,
0.7361310124397278,
0.0843193382024765,
0.1917121261358261,
0.11760424822568893,
0.7835760116577148,
-0.6749956607818604,
-0.8097684979438782,
-0.7257856726646423,
0.219562366604805,
-0.21936769783496857,
-0.34538960456848145,
1.108070731163025,
0.5910459756851196,
0.47701311111450195,
-0.4192162752151489,
1.001571536064148,
-0.45208296179771423,
0.39228731393814087,
-0.5184724926948547,
0.3142405152320862,
0.08069441467523575,
0.18899519741535187,
-0.7675700187683105,
-1.254317045211792,
-0.1803017556667328,
0.6814571619033813,
-0.2866523265838623,
0.4772176146507263,
0.8429636359214783,
0.6168925166130066,
0.11952466517686844,
0.02499239891767502,
0.3424125611782074,
0.1772764027118683,
0.6586612462997437,
0.7783534526824951,
0.9511164426803589,
0.025951271876692772,
0.39177823066711426,
-0.03698192909359932,
-0.6195585131645203,
-0.06779251992702484,
-0.8653059601783752,
-0.79301518201828,
-0.45251229405403137,
-0.08977644890546799,
-0.4578533470630646,
-0.10524217784404755,
0.7073347568511963,
0.6134709119796753,
-0.4729852080345154,
-0.04541897773742676,
-0.16864261031150818,
-0.31237512826919556,
-0.1116434782743454,
-0.15182606875896454,
0.2964790463447571,
-0.50703364610672,
-0.6926884055137634,
0.3403717875480652,
0.21640217304229736,
-0.18360726535320282,
-0.37570276856422424,
-0.5399312973022461,
0.3494039475917816,
-0.0037116394378244877,
0.7105847597122192,
0.24693140387535095,
-0.4388648569583893,
-0.1620084047317505,
0.2554968595504761,
-0.23578563332557678,
-0.29056593775749207,
1.1654711961746216,
-0.535015881061554,
0.2495785504579544,
0.5624397397041321,
0.4840501844882965,
0.37616345286369324,
0.26234522461891174,
0.7544159293174744,
-0.5336575508117676,
-0.040669072419404984,
0.14151212573051453,
0.3375564515590668,
0.3898776173591614,
-0.4793260395526886,
0.7173099517822266,
0.1048261895775795,
-1.0463560819625854,
-0.5250253677368164,
0.17347441613674164,
-0.7879192233085632,
-0.2787249982357025,
1.4946813583374023,
-0.12270539253950119,
0.10701214522123337,
-0.1276458501815796,
-0.5171656012535095,
-0.08064117282629013,
-0.5463462471961975,
0.4758559465408325,
0.6559411287307739,
-0.4790216386318207,
-0.028528479859232903,
-0.9602305889129639,
0.732629120349884,
-0.07294803857803345,
-0.7776885032653809,
-0.22186270356178284,
0.91634202003479,
0.4667142629623413,
0.38183167576789856,
1.040014386177063,
-0.29391220211982727,
0.656732439994812,
0.31095001101493835,
0.3130747377872467,
-0.11088128387928009,
-0.19052942097187042,
-0.14470471441745758,
0.2878847122192383,
0.45267802476882935,
0.14414101839065552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00553v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00553v1
|
Standardizing the Measurement of Text Diversity: A Tool and a Comparative Analysis of Scores
| 2024-03-01T14:23:12 | 2024-03-01T14:23:12 |
Chantal Shaib, Joe Barrow, Jiuding Sun, Alexa F. Siu, Byron C. Wallace, Ani Nenkova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The diversity across outputs generated by large language models shapes the
perception of their quality and utility. Prompt leaks, templated answer
structure, and canned responses across different interactions are readily
noticed by people, but there is no standard score to measure this aspect of
model behavior. In this work we empirically investigate diversity scores on
English texts. We find that computationally efficient compression algorithms
capture information similar to what is measured by slow to compute $n$-gram
overlap homogeneity scores. Further, a combination of measures -- compression
ratios, self-repetition of long $n$-grams and Self-BLEU and BERTScore -- are
sufficient to report, as they have low mutual correlation with each other. The
applicability of scores extends beyond analysis of generative models; for
example, we highlight applications on instruction-tuning datasets and
human-produced texts. We release a diversity score package to facilitate
research and invite consistency across reports.
|
[
-0.5663889050483704,
-0.28724807500839233,
0.10143940895795822,
0.6120541095733643,
-0.23281806707382202,
0.11879127472639084,
-0.3245033621788025,
-0.7096287608146667,
0.39903023838996887,
0.016392212361097336,
0.018475376069545746,
-0.6200252175331116,
-0.8320357799530029,
0.4149826467037201,
-0.6374521255493164,
0.9650458097457886,
0.23085908591747284,
-0.2010427564382553,
-0.2751152217388153,
-0.3965579569339752,
-0.27431726455688477,
-0.3081660270690918,
-0.11969444900751114,
-0.08932490646839142,
0.7888761162757874,
0.3530248701572418,
0.7663194537162781,
0.6089359521865845,
0.5926019549369812,
0.3206636905670166,
-0.24369920790195465,
0.08092910796403885,
-0.5739728808403015,
0.39669597148895264,
-0.2542566657066345,
-0.23526953160762787,
-0.16757594048976898,
0.2894008457660675,
0.8463398814201355,
0.8281168937683105,
0.0312718003988266,
0.21583935618400574,
0.5828129649162292,
0.4972696602344513,
-0.5404907464981079,
-0.20666518807411194,
-0.13064906001091003,
-0.03329743817448616,
-0.24999704957008362,
-0.12361680716276169,
-0.3578631579875946,
-0.5734795928001404,
-0.09485810995101929,
-0.1918954849243164,
0.2695295214653015,
-0.041686948388814926,
0.7956709861755371,
-0.03521617874503136,
-0.5116392970085144,
-0.539356529712677,
-0.6119040250778198,
1.2575109004974365,
-0.37056031823158264,
0.3071407377719879,
0.07785993069410324,
0.2511596977710724,
0.1584850400686264,
-0.280730664730072,
-0.2890584170818329,
-0.07306905835866928,
-0.1690455675125122,
0.2308255434036255,
-0.1696455180644989,
-0.22038502991199493,
-0.05963179096579552,
0.8883090019226074,
-0.6979061961174011,
0.2567931115627289,
-0.4885828197002411,
-0.2003428190946579,
0.9285368919372559,
0.2316460758447647,
0.36701875925064087,
-0.12097378820180893,
-0.14934828877449036,
-0.3542570173740387,
-0.23673689365386963,
0.15348392724990845,
0.7741987705230713,
0.2038324773311615,
-0.15712279081344604,
0.30100178718566895,
-0.16666589677333832,
0.6695098876953125,
-0.23484985530376434,
-0.050201885402202606,
0.39261141419410706,
-0.3901311159133911,
-0.11269284784793854,
-0.4513947665691376,
0.9570974707603455,
0.3835347890853882,
0.14972850680351257,
-0.19590523838996887,
-0.23546472191810608,
-0.15500952303409576,
0.11762024462223053,
-0.8400489091873169,
-0.1933518350124359,
-0.1302625685930252,
-0.6323462128639221,
-0.16779793798923492,
0.38675928115844727,
-1.1023536920547485,
-0.17131181061267853,
-0.0441165566444397,
0.2752763032913208,
-0.2651567757129669,
-0.04714279621839523,
0.25286880135536194,
-0.5599669218063354,
0.22183111310005188,
0.3193313479423523,
-0.9625329971313477,
0.430737167596817,
0.4985028803348541,
0.8663390874862671,
-0.5207314491271973,
-0.4548960030078888,
-0.10025923699140549,
-0.401472806930542,
-0.2922891080379486,
0.7002488374710083,
-0.6326260566711426,
-0.7908836603164673,
-0.16700328886508942,
-0.28652074933052063,
0.32896682620048523,
-0.6409335732460022,
0.541250467300415,
-0.13292352855205536,
0.5358682870864868,
-0.3754352331161499,
-0.686388373374939,
-0.00410479074344039,
0.2893350124359131,
-0.6563395261764526,
1.12711501121521,
0.2516326308250427,
-0.6836527585983276,
0.5082677006721497,
-0.2183084785938263,
-0.339777410030365,
0.13199211657047272,
-0.21801097691059113,
-0.21566690504550934,
0.22295022010803223,
-0.0015459543792530894,
0.18743698298931122,
-0.3461383879184723,
0.0003490470699034631,
-0.12746788561344147,
-0.6362336277961731,
0.11348341405391693,
-0.5203041434288025,
0.7272288799285889,
0.20658698678016663,
0.028501104563474655,
-0.24820192158222198,
-0.5013585090637207,
0.11572080105543137,
-0.13966889679431915,
-0.6570594310760498,
-0.4378029704093933,
-0.35623133182525635,
0.11831477284431458,
-0.08789345622062683,
0.3651001453399658,
-0.48953360319137573,
0.19712644815444946,
-0.222298264503479,
-0.14863891899585724,
0.5917326807975769,
-0.23282504081726074,
0.3012934923171997,
-0.6545064449310303,
0.5307389497756958,
-0.18662816286087036,
0.15494713187217712,
-0.36787036061286926,
-0.8278219699859619,
-0.4112849533557892,
-0.45632317662239075,
0.6949604153633118,
0.249814972281456,
0.09591035544872284,
0.8257692456245422,
-0.29548531770706177,
-0.8728275299072266,
-0.7045899033546448,
0.12322472035884857,
0.02356627583503723,
-0.09111232310533524,
0.3593919575214386,
-0.5851194262504578,
-0.3642047941684723,
-0.7603642344474792,
-0.8579891324043274,
-0.006729245651513338,
-0.46625038981437683,
0.39830511808395386,
0.403454065322876,
-0.07552438974380493,
1.0473952293395996,
-0.347755491733551,
0.07424068450927734,
-0.13771095871925354,
0.6652923226356506,
0.30912265181541443,
0.5577820539474487,
0.6678919792175293,
-0.5586427450180054,
-0.6636729836463928,
-0.24451743066310883,
-0.47163325548171997,
-0.42529913783073425,
0.1038920059800148,
0.21933943033218384,
-0.12996132671833038,
0.07448935508728027,
-0.13549362123012543,
0.17049628496170044,
1.146406650543213,
-0.501213788986206,
0.5973409414291382,
-0.08308147639036179,
0.7595745921134949,
-0.8565765619277954,
-0.0960308238863945,
-0.05357930064201355,
-0.29601579904556274,
-0.2913396656513214,
0.15752485394477844,
0.02897939831018448,
0.1828988939523697,
-0.09475111216306686,
0.5205578207969666,
-0.4075886607170105,
-0.10713985562324524,
-0.12220793962478638,
-0.0014357103500515223,
0.4425889551639557,
-0.0012530955718830228,
-0.5309054255485535,
0.8296741843223572,
0.10487988591194153,
-0.4392968714237213,
0.1384638249874115,
-0.09209684282541275,
-0.4487572908401489,
0.35642939805984497,
-0.6280180811882019,
0.21754269301891327,
-0.27146783471107483,
-0.08439064025878906,
-1.0589666366577148,
-0.10488962382078171,
-0.24479079246520996,
-0.6617262363433838,
0.13786174356937408,
0.07387308776378632,
-0.42057567834854126,
0.008142867125570774,
-0.6222137808799744,
0.7466397285461426,
0.8659020066261292,
-0.4608556032180786,
0.4239802062511444,
0.27156174182891846,
-0.11093991994857788,
-0.5094280242919922,
-0.9640434980392456,
0.028204109519720078,
-0.07893543690443039,
-0.6372286677360535,
0.40636900067329407,
-0.6010200381278992,
-0.3358060419559479,
-0.013786421157419682,
-0.2542705535888672,
-0.06068744882941246,
0.12979364395141602,
0.13194841146469116,
0.027222637087106705,
-0.14168410003185272,
0.3103872835636139,
0.3032417893409729,
0.44551578164100647,
-0.09807537496089935,
-0.12062181532382965,
0.41772937774658203,
0.03612753003835678,
-0.32172122597694397,
0.1592581868171692,
0.7649117708206177,
0.4335308372974396,
0.09102816134691238,
0.8063728213310242,
0.15427763760089874,
-0.12164720892906189,
-0.3185660243034363,
-0.3820604085922241,
-0.09308630228042603,
-0.4772331416606903,
0.03747805953025818,
-0.10517121851444244,
-1.3651701211929321,
0.4670022428035736,
0.2408861219882965,
0.24726206064224243,
0.6127409934997559,
0.5312485098838806,
-0.11259317398071289,
0.7928006649017334,
0.5874196887016296,
-0.022598234936594963,
0.313676655292511,
0.36268070340156555,
0.26506441831588745,
-0.16005630791187286,
0.0070091187953948975,
-0.9124528765678406,
-0.5513160824775696,
-0.6942921876907349,
-0.38955625891685486,
0.2659603953361511,
0.4023726284503937,
0.15317033231258392,
-0.033839333802461624,
-0.600433886051178,
1.0619844198226929,
0.244642972946167,
-0.458773672580719,
0.3483806848526001,
-0.13300086557865143,
-0.05718686431646347,
-0.23027829825878143,
-0.36210644245147705,
-0.5136133432388306,
0.9496076107025146,
0.4285060167312622,
0.6309895515441895,
0.2607749402523041,
1.1477185487747192,
0.5270667672157288,
0.4825822710990906,
-0.5967657566070557,
0.37087419629096985,
-0.7008708119392395,
-0.396514892578125,
-0.3790927827358246,
-0.8692449927330017,
-1.1289441585540771,
0.3251819610595703,
-0.1456814557313919,
-0.6876681447029114,
0.16204893589019775,
-0.05656011402606964,
-0.09671533107757568,
-0.12523727118968964,
-0.7213278412818909,
0.7785016894340515,
0.12619014084339142,
-0.03734888136386871,
-0.06386005878448486,
-0.12485583871603012,
0.4580892324447632,
0.03950076550245285,
0.33928242325782776,
-0.24766874313354492,
0.07745593786239624,
0.9766112565994263,
0.19114038348197937,
0.6942383646965027,
0.4271198511123657,
-0.12104353308677673,
0.1684742569923401,
0.1600782424211502,
-0.05372671037912369,
-0.011279022321105003,
-0.2405567318201065,
0.49007946252822876,
-0.039012130349874496,
-0.49701792001724243,
-0.6644578576087952,
0.7928950786590576,
-0.8415433168411255,
-0.382975310087204,
-0.3166005313396454,
-0.6793619990348816,
0.06693368405103683,
-0.002282419940456748,
0.48536205291748047,
0.23761962354183197,
-0.40858423709869385,
0.352211058139801,
0.41913288831710815,
-0.2952662706375122,
0.3971269726753235,
0.5577491521835327,
-0.2402743697166443,
-0.2685921788215637,
0.7748419046401978,
0.3527994155883789,
0.2762148976325989,
0.23046079277992249,
0.5093064308166504,
-0.07394278049468994,
-0.354458212852478,
0.069552943110466,
-0.030196573585271835,
-0.8460255861282349,
-0.2170744389295578,
-0.5023278594017029,
-0.3004968762397766,
-0.39124995470046997,
-0.2222864031791687,
-0.17690414190292358,
-0.3881591260433197,
-0.1223822757601738,
-0.12047220021486282,
0.08953502029180527,
0.9824850559234619,
-0.06665008515119553,
-0.05447860807180405,
-1.1265006065368652,
0.07035981118679047,
0.5948355197906494,
0.5321449041366577,
-0.08017932623624802,
-0.6546540260314941,
-0.2461952269077301,
-0.3419572412967682,
-0.33469122648239136,
-1.1216918230056763,
0.21439217031002045,
0.20149941742420197,
0.5372374653816223,
0.2583675682544708,
-0.05257757008075714,
0.1676626354455948,
-0.08114437758922577,
1.11470627784729,
0.11761746555566788,
-1.1940854787826538,
0.30733200907707214,
-0.08030620962381363,
0.6069822907447815,
0.5175054669380188,
0.5187118053436279,
-0.8194764256477356,
-0.9745839834213257,
-0.45044416189193726,
-0.7362897396087646,
0.258337140083313,
0.2711539566516876,
0.45447129011154175,
-0.22834503650665283,
0.04780730977654457,
0.48458200693130493,
0.014375305734574795,
-0.7021448016166687,
-0.3166595995426178,
-0.25300103425979614,
-0.7094126343727112,
-0.1890714019536972,
-0.31921663880348206,
-0.03446665033698082,
-0.2270684689283371,
0.1272631734609604,
-0.011524895206093788,
-0.19220693409442902,
0.21252864599227905,
-0.1525970697402954,
0.22166851162910461,
0.6605201959609985,
0.4229885935783386,
0.36222413182258606,
-0.04564682021737099,
0.4000963568687439,
-0.028314752504229546,
-0.7017472982406616,
0.20846378803253174,
-0.08752800524234772,
-0.11804927885532379,
0.21978607773780823,
0.4608011245727539,
0.1882021576166153,
0.08359986543655396,
-0.6755101084709167,
0.4887787997722626,
-0.28997161984443665,
-0.18522340059280396,
0.38087400794029236,
0.24234236776828766,
-0.08191730082035065,
0.02896927297115326,
0.12912799417972565,
-0.027846770361065865,
0.5125290751457214,
-0.5904586315155029,
0.3066176176071167,
0.17556880414485931,
-0.36392489075660706,
-0.2688629627227783,
0.011659041047096252,
0.4346114993095398,
-0.3731788098812103,
0.4198096990585327,
-0.6023356318473816,
-0.25291481614112854,
0.6416112780570984,
0.4603535830974579,
0.7027561664581299,
-0.5622376203536987,
0.21587246656417847,
0.43465250730514526,
0.5727074146270752,
-0.3360287547111511,
0.24930021166801453,
0.04203922674059868,
-0.7814533114433289,
-0.28247109055519104,
-0.7809804677963257,
-0.4332301914691925,
-0.14370845258235931,
-0.5944904685020447,
0.17666484415531158,
-0.3272841274738312,
0.05065092816948891,
-0.01904834248125553,
-0.1268398016691208,
-0.49118664860725403,
0.21501144766807556,
0.18042722344398499,
1.0230450630187988,
-0.9706224203109741,
0.5858785510063171,
0.4204252362251282,
-0.401235967874527,
-0.6591383218765259,
0.19849681854248047,
-0.08012280613183975,
-0.3140212893486023,
0.5286591053009033,
0.4464431703090668,
-0.05321845784783363,
-0.3509238064289093,
-0.3277412950992584,
-0.5764079689979553,
0.6644930839538574,
0.29559287428855896,
-0.671740710735321,
0.2703816294670105,
0.21722474694252014,
0.6549534797668457,
-0.38344070315361023,
0.6330094337463379,
0.6932138800621033,
0.4333845376968384,
-0.23717521131038666,
-0.8211815357208252,
-0.1657152771949768,
-0.4463362991809845,
-0.2418803870677948,
0.3668656051158905,
-0.4679414629936218,
1.042418360710144,
0.2443106472492218,
-0.4868520200252533,
-0.03577391058206558,
0.4358728528022766,
0.057643771171569824,
0.188922718167305,
0.5850726962089539,
0.41729268431663513,
0.9512917995452881,
-0.014405759051442146,
0.9808170795440674,
-0.13648299872875214,
0.5767638087272644,
0.7945804595947266,
0.032825179398059845,
0.6307240724563599,
0.31211599707603455,
-0.18256354331970215,
0.6142602562904358,
0.27343088388442993,
-0.26381006836891174,
0.07601878046989441,
0.4377466142177582,
-0.18985499441623688,
-0.17121584713459015,
0.03150492534041405,
-0.118449367582798,
0.4884757399559021,
0.08728540688753128,
-0.4740065038204193,
-0.3689247965812683,
-0.1850399523973465,
-0.2403143346309662,
0.41005739569664,
-0.17089293897151947,
0.6546522378921509,
0.030266113579273224,
-0.7254400849342346,
0.48624387383461,
0.09906591475009918,
1.0050171613693237,
-0.45256462693214417,
0.07681487500667572,
-0.559084951877594,
-0.3684976100921631,
-0.15905031561851501,
-1.1957523822784424,
0.46433109045028687,
0.12426307052373886,
-0.6356449723243713,
-0.1825542002916336,
0.32490891218185425,
-0.5831090807914734,
-0.3582417368888855,
0.40501758456230164,
0.3846658170223236,
0.31347984075546265,
0.0917503833770752,
-0.28575634956359863,
0.14489321410655975,
-0.1522989124059677,
-0.06523685902357101,
0.3957519233226776,
0.3131888508796692,
0.10713938623666763,
0.19675607979297638,
0.2835581302642822,
-0.11046641319990158,
0.3236570656299591,
0.2790304720401764,
0.5696465969085693,
-0.7040631175041199,
-0.5799896717071533,
-0.8674713373184204,
0.4163106381893158,
-0.48042193055152893,
-0.7805869579315186,
0.9084873199462891,
0.6191854476928711,
0.7191843390464783,
0.2006050944328308,
0.6687180399894714,
0.12988321483135223,
0.4764106571674347,
-0.2829051613807678,
0.5520727634429932,
-0.6239867210388184,
0.33241215348243713,
-0.09423162043094635,
-0.9381835460662842,
-0.33743342757225037,
0.2417234480381012,
-0.0696953535079956,
0.10621748864650726,
0.6262708902359009,
0.5997835397720337,
-0.11440151184797287,
0.060322318226099014,
0.40516379475593567,
-0.03334623575210571,
0.2718781530857086,
0.256631076335907,
0.89204341173172,
-0.32710203528404236,
0.7506403923034668,
0.2603103518486023,
-0.3847670257091522,
-0.17007498443126678,
-0.7495965957641602,
-0.7271155118942261,
-0.40124329924583435,
-0.24352459609508514,
-0.16282227635383606,
-0.09720362722873688,
0.4936986267566681,
0.5673773288726807,
-0.7359762191772461,
-0.3635183274745941,
0.16295374929904938,
0.37967896461486816,
-0.30959466099739075,
-0.26471614837646484,
-0.1687411218881607,
-0.47805002331733704,
-0.6407220959663391,
0.271563321352005,
0.4726714789867401,
0.1720518171787262,
-0.4104788899421692,
-0.24923646450042725,
0.3068655729293823,
0.6483336687088013,
0.20371073484420776,
0.13675551116466522,
-0.4275893568992615,
-0.3461724817752838,
-0.0791286826133728,
-0.4207363426685333,
0.29780885577201843,
0.9065722227096558,
-0.39113640785217285,
0.4736490547657013,
0.9268419146537781,
0.5113261938095093,
0.028595618903636932,
-0.07065892964601517,
0.6429231762886047,
-1.2443997859954834,
-0.02423732541501522,
0.4512844681739807,
0.2926582992076874,
0.47493815422058105,
-0.21524657309055328,
0.1178714781999588,
0.05526508018374443,
-0.6700189113616943,
-0.6581515073776245,
0.4445117712020874,
-0.8160645365715027,
-0.5690137147903442,
0.8815673589706421,
-0.37366676330566406,
-0.042146824300289154,
-0.06560913473367691,
0.09881100803613663,
-0.23324723541736603,
-0.44147831201553345,
1.088113784790039,
1.0144941806793213,
0.32787084579467773,
-0.22897295653820038,
-0.08927956968545914,
0.48791077733039856,
0.48896294832229614,
-0.9043800830841064,
-0.10153776407241821,
0.12372910231351852,
0.28727659583091736,
0.4411124587059021,
0.35602688789367676,
-0.16827991604804993,
0.2516520619392395,
0.14128008484840393,
0.1828942447900772,
0.3407588303089142,
-0.28559258580207825,
-0.6049593091011047,
0.4610869288444519,
0.11865145713090897,
-0.03814071789383888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00528v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00528v1
|
Large Language Models for Simultaneous Named Entity Extraction and Spelling Correction
| 2024-03-01T13:36:04 | 2024-03-01T13:36:04 |
Edward Whittaker, Ikuo Kitagishi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, H.3.3; H.3.4; I.2.7; I.7.1; I.7.5
|
Language Models (LMs) such as BERT, have been shown to perform well on the
task of identifying Named Entities (NE) in text. A BERT LM is typically used as
a classifier to classify individual tokens in the input text, or to classify
spans of tokens, as belonging to one of a set of possible NE categories.
In this paper, we hypothesise that decoder-only Large Language Models (LLMs)
can also be used generatively to extract both the NE, as well as potentially
recover the correct surface form of the NE, where any spelling errors that were
present in the input text get automatically corrected.
We fine-tune two BERT LMs as baselines, as well as eight open-source LLMs, on
the task of producing NEs from text that was obtained by applying Optical
Character Recognition (OCR) to images of Japanese shop receipts; in this work,
we do not attempt to find or evaluate the location of NEs in the text.
We show that the best fine-tuned LLM performs as well as, or slightly better
than, the best fine-tuned BERT LM, although the differences are not
significant. However, the best LLM is also shown to correct OCR errors in some
cases, as initially hypothesised.
|
[
-0.1476082056760788,
-0.7687215209007263,
0.7655772566795349,
-0.031239548698067665,
-0.29007238149642944,
0.04037146642804146,
-0.7092568278312683,
-0.9182921051979065,
0.31606826186180115,
0.9852693676948547,
-0.31129443645477295,
-0.640103280544281,
-0.6318694353103638,
0.5748820304870605,
-0.4980696141719818,
0.8317927122116089,
-0.07343977689743042,
0.18885377049446106,
0.14514197409152985,
0.18253523111343384,
-0.2102460116147995,
-0.571167528629303,
-0.9500725865364075,
-0.12167038768529892,
0.7512680292129517,
0.19532667100429535,
0.5880651473999023,
0.5702963471412659,
0.3396744728088379,
0.3263057768344879,
-0.13859090209007263,
0.5657838582992554,
-0.2515973448753357,
0.2729489803314209,
-0.12005751579999924,
-0.640110433101654,
-0.5838339328765869,
-0.3510757386684418,
0.8511794209480286,
0.6366756558418274,
0.008558549918234348,
-0.228772833943367,
0.07179461419582367,
0.4184257984161377,
-0.5450725555419922,
0.18173179030418396,
-0.8152178525924683,
-0.17856815457344055,
-0.3138091266155243,
-0.02079574018716812,
-0.8186283111572266,
-0.28282296657562256,
0.10236172378063202,
-0.5247060656547546,
0.37429842352867126,
0.08167123049497604,
1.0973198413848877,
0.11538680642843246,
-0.18379096686840057,
-0.5074544548988342,
-0.8402187824249268,
0.8102522492408752,
-0.9056702852249146,
0.4728231430053711,
0.09394550323486328,
-0.008742105215787888,
-0.4207616150379181,
-0.5585358142852783,
-0.6762885451316833,
-0.11286324262619019,
-0.07674873620271683,
0.03875388950109482,
-0.020865583792328835,
0.3702516555786133,
0.5842736959457397,
0.2834179103374481,
-0.1672370731830597,
0.621780276298523,
-0.217792347073555,
-0.26850762963294983,
0.5514182448387146,
-0.12364348769187927,
0.7845233082771301,
-0.2782764732837677,
-0.3013002574443817,
-0.07924474775791168,
-0.8750715255737305,
-0.335682213306427,
0.28197163343429565,
0.6707219481468201,
0.3975924253463745,
0.886466920375824,
0.16433610022068024,
0.5725421905517578,
-0.19035567343235016,
-0.5835818648338318,
-0.03806629404425621,
0.11412140727043152,
-0.3854632079601288,
0.40324071049690247,
0.6847681403160095,
0.11523952335119247,
0.2910977602005005,
-0.44763559103012085,
-0.5248206853866577,
-0.23834864795207977,
0.030433742329478264,
-0.5968500971794128,
-0.3483293950557709,
-0.007132998201996088,
-0.4268607795238495,
0.057054851204156876,
0.046188272535800934,
-0.7675349712371826,
-0.4405505657196045,
-0.4739550054073334,
0.549225389957428,
-0.4575998783111572,
-0.17308878898620605,
0.009906104765832424,
-0.17797407507896423,
0.06216451898217201,
0.6288337707519531,
-0.916707456111908,
0.058987438678741455,
0.6957533955574036,
0.6966145038604736,
-0.07006194442510605,
-0.12461642175912857,
-0.5349091291427612,
0.19394932687282562,
-0.4750540852546692,
0.9426444172859192,
-0.35315343737602234,
-0.16413363814353943,
0.04167298972606659,
0.140486940741539,
-0.10770779103040695,
-0.6716086268424988,
0.4657241106033325,
-0.8661941289901733,
0.08145006000995636,
-0.3569045960903168,
-0.8448684811592102,
-0.1182587519288063,
0.1229972243309021,
-1.080274224281311,
0.8439616560935974,
-0.1903124302625656,
-0.5717608332633972,
0.49935615062713623,
-0.38993364572525024,
-0.5331583023071289,
0.245516836643219,
0.025492381304502487,
-0.37099790573120117,
0.2662912607192993,
0.44372862577438354,
0.5497525334358215,
-0.12708382308483124,
0.2956843078136444,
-0.16068561375141144,
-0.2460382878780365,
0.16090238094329834,
-0.4960411489009857,
0.7055211067199707,
-0.07137635350227356,
-0.3600406348705292,
-0.12962475419044495,
-1.0322082042694092,
0.0344272255897522,
0.1995806097984314,
-0.7650709748268127,
-0.6987075805664062,
0.22853770852088928,
0.12402661889791489,
-0.17404696345329285,
0.3111531734466553,
-0.7658725380897522,
0.3686087727546692,
-0.38566163182258606,
0.49906229972839355,
0.7009149193763733,
-0.3030349314212799,
0.2557015120983124,
-0.05658837780356407,
0.19059711694717407,
-0.2012726068496704,
-0.4564144015312195,
-0.22088094055652618,
-0.4289877414703369,
-1.188380479812622,
-0.7591467499732971,
0.7231488823890686,
0.49599167704582214,
-1.0049482583999634,
0.5141797661781311,
-0.4275256395339966,
-0.3271293342113495,
-0.4980298578739166,
-0.05111828073859215,
0.27401673793792725,
0.37385210394859314,
0.20407548546791077,
-0.20864801108837128,
-0.5830729603767395,
-0.825072705745697,
-0.2968684732913971,
-0.010299394838511944,
-0.0407479926943779,
0.20467369258403778,
0.2170901745557785,
-0.11488869786262512,
0.773392379283905,
-0.2865174114704132,
-0.385150283575058,
-0.1618432253599167,
0.20735269784927368,
0.20872585475444794,
0.18917906284332275,
0.29600054025650024,
-0.5789628624916077,
-0.4269712567329407,
-0.007966352626681328,
-0.5751903653144836,
-0.1322053223848343,
-0.10779847949743271,
0.02434391714632511,
0.8000717163085938,
0.5877664685249329,
-0.6383864879608154,
0.3150084316730499,
0.2966145873069763,
0.09815975278615952,
0.4913758635520935,
-0.5485970973968506,
0.0553923174738884,
-1.0203030109405518,
0.014697866514325142,
0.023412048816680908,
-0.38745176792144775,
-0.6145688891410828,
0.18018150329589844,
0.3687014579772949,
0.028692256659269333,
-0.11748221516609192,
0.5530105233192444,
-0.8826735615730286,
-0.2922261655330658,
-0.3190555274486542,
0.1877443790435791,
0.03663981705904007,
0.2959093153476715,
0.42294296622276306,
0.8476269841194153,
0.3632749021053314,
-0.6987051963806152,
0.29507631063461304,
0.14677655696868896,
-0.8293604254722595,
0.43811389803886414,
-0.40717482566833496,
0.20368292927742004,
-0.5133939385414124,
0.10007860511541367,
-0.8625068068504333,
-0.3495286703109741,
0.2335001528263092,
-0.1382976472377777,
0.7160683274269104,
-0.09815604239702225,
-1.0730648040771484,
-0.34078678488731384,
0.15219524502754211,
-0.05145712196826935,
0.3879666328430176,
-0.9760916829109192,
0.679796576499939,
0.35282719135284424,
-0.3434200882911682,
-0.3997191786766052,
-0.783515453338623,
0.23319111764431,
0.06711596250534058,
-0.2937227487564087,
0.41961047053337097,
0.062094803899526596,
0.13223688304424286,
0.09962792694568634,
0.09882136434316635,
-0.12082947790622711,
0.11131948232650757,
0.0531163215637207,
0.5278285145759583,
-0.3909034729003906,
0.3641442060470581,
0.0876355916261673,
-0.0014561021234840155,
-0.12194832414388657,
-0.15805913507938385,
0.5028904676437378,
0.36507511138916016,
-0.29562774300575256,
-0.22195717692375183,
0.2645937204360962,
0.6390215158462524,
-0.16893881559371948,
0.919693112373352,
0.38315412402153015,
-0.734113872051239,
-0.2736815810203552,
-0.8393256664276123,
0.0481051504611969,
-0.3904546797275543,
0.4485955536365509,
-0.5742339491844177,
-0.9634382724761963,
0.588410496711731,
0.04212401807308197,
0.20484107732772827,
0.6360523104667664,
0.35370713472366333,
-0.10991412401199341,
1.0587122440338135,
0.6239293217658997,
-0.07917583733797073,
0.3106979429721832,
0.05530577525496483,
0.754560112953186,
-0.9415969848632812,
-0.40472814440727234,
-0.6454359292984009,
-0.24134688079357147,
-0.5413528680801392,
-0.13613852858543396,
0.22307206690311432,
0.30990517139434814,
0.09835110604763031,
0.5169975757598877,
-0.4296789765357971,
0.5656364560127258,
0.8496549129486084,
0.3228335678577423,
0.3932560384273529,
0.35792407393455505,
-0.21280638873577118,
-0.13601087033748627,
-0.44224753975868225,
-0.6752568483352661,
0.9218874573707581,
0.28617799282073975,
0.6142301559448242,
0.07923032343387604,
0.9919557571411133,
-0.1499648094177246,
0.3099009692668915,
-1.0131032466888428,
0.7364339232444763,
-0.6895082592964172,
-0.6922276616096497,
-0.32655808329582214,
-0.40389007329940796,
-1.0794743299484253,
0.1617809385061264,
-0.3323638439178467,
-0.8727060556411743,
0.23363664746284485,
-0.0017551531782373786,
-0.4206286668777466,
0.7329327464103699,
-0.5374691486358643,
0.5507296919822693,
-0.49058374762535095,
-0.0072476924397051334,
-0.03667793050408363,
-0.18427763879299164,
0.18607589602470398,
-0.368039608001709,
0.11876659095287323,
-0.25864771008491516,
-0.08280976861715317,
0.6825000047683716,
-0.43617817759513855,
0.6648995280265808,
-0.038313835859298706,
-0.5388703346252441,
0.07722865045070648,
0.0014287272933870554,
0.4955757260322571,
-0.2898484766483307,
-0.13387636840343475,
0.4388844072818756,
-0.007654948625713587,
-0.06132064759731293,
-0.4792940616607666,
0.7600942850112915,
-0.7772767543792725,
-0.5442039966583252,
-0.2645728588104248,
-0.28169935941696167,
0.04226617142558098,
0.6411609053611755,
0.4030187427997589,
0.5410789847373962,
0.009030040353536606,
0.12721207737922668,
0.8079535961151123,
-0.37760499119758606,
0.4145221412181854,
0.5848878622055054,
-0.19492846727371216,
-0.448392778635025,
0.8216040730476379,
0.3132733702659607,
0.0905933678150177,
0.6758605241775513,
-0.061542533338069916,
-0.2872248888015747,
-0.5687304735183716,
-0.5792208313941956,
0.35172760486602783,
-0.8233753442764282,
-0.28051498532295227,
-0.7393980026245117,
-0.36260077357292175,
-0.3850511908531189,
0.13632960617542267,
-0.3747142553329468,
-0.13753394782543182,
-0.6599818468093872,
0.25687193870544434,
0.14942359924316406,
0.7238577008247375,
-0.014018368907272816,
0.11223961412906647,
-1.0812617540359497,
0.40001845359802246,
0.3245629370212555,
0.3882193863391876,
0.12840454280376434,
-0.2912728488445282,
-0.0021461634896695614,
0.2366357147693634,
0.17372049391269684,
-0.8064447045326233,
0.49178266525268555,
0.20986957848072052,
0.4814841151237488,
0.25704169273376465,
-0.055627770721912384,
1.0256154537200928,
-0.7127350568771362,
0.7625802755355835,
0.22856199741363525,
-0.9339767694473267,
0.37140434980392456,
-0.08977922052145004,
-0.059192925691604614,
0.29323217272758484,
0.29580259323120117,
-0.5286815762519836,
-0.3196125030517578,
-0.40955784916877747,
-0.9130224585533142,
1.0429195165634155,
-0.07132460176944733,
0.1410849243402481,
-0.38961654901504517,
0.5107830762863159,
0.16332286596298218,
0.1274874210357666,
-0.7180471420288086,
-0.1504458785057068,
0.4912945032119751,
-0.31760361790657043,
-0.05655016750097275,
-0.6092591881752014,
0.23989778757095337,
0.06716503202915192,
0.9620970487594604,
0.13870985805988312,
0.3319818079471588,
0.2909011244773865,
-0.3634772300720215,
-0.23380257189273834,
0.32255271077156067,
0.4248001277446747,
0.46848076581954956,
-0.05930275470018387,
0.06885810196399689,
0.0024687645491212606,
-0.19884152710437775,
-0.10771306604146957,
0.1997688263654709,
-0.3397309184074402,
0.2860356569290161,
0.3888568878173828,
0.8570342063903809,
0.5405400395393372,
-0.8093381524085999,
0.23889368772506714,
0.021216019988059998,
-0.10464204847812653,
-0.41044560074806213,
0.015657683834433556,
-0.03225551173090935,
0.29561346769332886,
0.3284080922603607,
-0.07613776624202728,
0.11795585602521896,
-0.5759245753288269,
-0.0940462127327919,
0.5475894212722778,
0.315623939037323,
-0.030206378549337387,
0.5447744727134705,
0.010276611894369125,
-0.4513828456401825,
1.0031472444534302,
-0.16582000255584717,
-0.7288504242897034,
0.6905661225318909,
0.6804877519607544,
0.8004261255264282,
-0.13035902380943298,
0.005989768076688051,
0.46939533948898315,
0.29532116651535034,
-0.6258198022842407,
0.025666549801826477,
0.037820540368556976,
-1.0117461681365967,
-0.4977444112300873,
-0.8123122453689575,
-0.3891299366950989,
0.4679791033267975,
-0.7694061398506165,
0.4883030354976654,
-0.41572046279907227,
-0.1260317713022232,
0.3979113698005676,
-0.19140474498271942,
-0.7140505313873291,
0.1406446397304535,
0.544987678527832,
0.6202023029327393,
-0.48925331234931946,
0.8658743500709534,
0.8319945931434631,
-0.2380848228931427,
-1.0520365238189697,
-0.043845195323228836,
-0.3605235815048218,
-0.9462739825248718,
0.7460024356842041,
0.3124467432498932,
0.06051678583025932,
0.17168501019477844,
-0.4046477675437927,
-1.1339346170425415,
0.754734456539154,
0.36904221773147583,
-1.1631709337234497,
-0.3500381112098694,
0.051418643444776535,
0.5501113533973694,
0.04082058370113373,
0.23701505362987518,
0.44327113032341003,
0.4178251028060913,
0.07701487839221954,
-1.133032202720642,
-0.21007850766181946,
0.048190273344516754,
0.30107831954956055,
0.5432119965553284,
-0.2766772210597992,
0.7594355344772339,
-0.15853935480117798,
-0.5736619830131531,
0.5567796230316162,
0.49698957800865173,
0.22074009478092194,
-0.04568004235625267,
0.541716992855072,
0.6875074505805969,
1.020786166191101,
-0.16586746275424957,
0.7711398005485535,
-0.15806232392787933,
0.3795229494571686,
1.0726760625839233,
-0.41213467717170715,
1.1066614389419556,
0.2345232367515564,
-0.17893747985363007,
0.5413996577262878,
0.5398299694061279,
-0.23512253165245056,
0.44501781463623047,
0.11771978437900543,
-0.06456360965967178,
-0.3360368013381958,
0.2846778333187103,
0.017659008502960205,
0.46650373935699463,
0.4556005299091339,
-0.6199425458908081,
-0.2336530089378357,
0.2688726782798767,
0.061548445373773575,
-0.10652031749486923,
-0.530379593372345,
0.9330309629440308,
0.021554678678512573,
-0.8289418816566467,
0.44228115677833557,
0.36621662974357605,
0.772739589214325,
-0.27150458097457886,
0.0006602818029932678,
-0.007538209669291973,
0.31984370946884155,
-0.07073065638542175,
-0.5944108963012695,
0.0021685229148715734,
0.19371218979358673,
-0.4109474718570709,
-0.05172235518693924,
0.9030184745788574,
-0.7840409278869629,
-0.6327616572380066,
0.2776339650154114,
0.06528855115175247,
0.39978736639022827,
-0.10607759654521942,
-0.3806148171424866,
0.1837877631187439,
0.0212660264223814,
-0.09234672039747238,
0.12266602367162704,
0.4507630467414856,
0.1039247140288353,
0.39042311906814575,
0.5257614254951477,
0.3534615635871887,
0.23696449398994446,
0.22771352529525757,
0.3638930022716522,
-0.58332359790802,
-0.26442962884902954,
-0.9149507284164429,
0.2864232659339905,
-0.11818481236696243,
0.12129692733287811,
0.5795673131942749,
0.5179203748703003,
0.9572595357894897,
-0.25106683373451233,
0.7214694619178772,
0.08190547674894333,
0.6048642992973328,
-0.9124269485473633,
0.5619853734970093,
-0.6916196346282959,
0.24001455307006836,
-0.29805776476860046,
-1.2912402153015137,
-0.46093320846557617,
0.69073086977005,
-0.13002394139766693,
-0.1081935241818428,
0.6089549660682678,
0.7183045148849487,
0.12194594740867615,
-0.0014414998004212976,
0.32365116477012634,
0.19905255734920502,
0.2763330340385437,
0.5764432549476624,
0.62315434217453,
-0.4912101626396179,
0.3241825997829437,
-0.216221883893013,
-0.048865292221307755,
-0.3566872477531433,
-0.8423500657081604,
-0.9439286589622498,
-0.5364946722984314,
-0.5257644653320312,
-0.3174744248390198,
0.14997658133506775,
0.9374182820320129,
0.4966430068016052,
-0.9152594804763794,
0.1550213247537613,
-0.0397631973028183,
0.019101744517683983,
0.08954734355211258,
-0.21571937203407288,
0.4651099443435669,
-0.33322253823280334,
-1.2822024822235107,
0.336910218000412,
0.3482106328010559,
0.10472793132066727,
-0.025177162140607834,
0.28143471479415894,
0.15094660222530365,
-0.01776679791510105,
0.6775455474853516,
0.14493632316589355,
-1.1947948932647705,
-0.4562632143497467,
-0.03360280767083168,
-0.2741945683956146,
0.04155317321419716,
0.5889163613319397,
-0.5137201547622681,
0.661247968673706,
0.36122921109199524,
0.7428798079490662,
0.2630356550216675,
-0.3501112759113312,
0.29886218905448914,
-0.6016616821289062,
-0.158138245344162,
0.13436129689216614,
0.6219937801361084,
0.40793725848197937,
-0.5236676335334778,
0.056627899408340454,
0.07883764803409576,
-0.5056644678115845,
-0.8196828365325928,
-0.045447878539562225,
-0.8842971920967102,
-0.3335857689380646,
1.259375810623169,
-0.2323961704969406,
-0.42231330275535583,
0.14399391412734985,
-0.34962454438209534,
0.42946478724479675,
-0.2568090856075287,
0.6908289790153503,
0.9507085680961609,
0.31464800238609314,
-0.43079572916030884,
-0.19376465678215027,
0.16910304129123688,
0.25439855456352234,
-0.6682449579238892,
-0.004496862180531025,
0.5831053256988525,
0.5487772226333618,
0.38164979219436646,
0.4687711000442505,
-0.13313736021518707,
0.06589720398187637,
-0.2795855402946472,
0.4464840888977051,
0.04400276020169258,
-0.4344174563884735,
-0.2402355819940567,
0.049223367124795914,
0.24984212219715118,
-0.08125382661819458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00510v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00510v3
|
ROME: Memorization Insights from Text, Logits and Representation
| 2024-03-01T13:15:30 | 2024-06-16T13:53:44 |
Bo Li, Qinghua Zhao, Lijie Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Previous works have evaluated memorization by comparing model outputs with
training corpora, examining how factors such as data duplication, model size,
and prompt length influence memorization. However, analyzing these extensive
training corpora is highly time-consuming. To address this challenge, this
paper proposes an innovative approach named ROME that bypasses direct
processing of the training data. Specifically, we select datasets categorized
into three distinct types -- context-independent, conventional, and factual --
and redefine memorization as the ability to produce correct answers under these
conditions. Our analysis then focuses on disparities between memorized and
non-memorized samples by examining the logits and representations of generated
texts. Experimental findings reveal that longer words are less likely to be
memorized, higher confidence correlates with greater memorization, and
representations of the same concepts are more similar across different
contexts. Our code and data will be publicly available when the paper is
accepted.
|
[
-0.2580205202102661,
-0.7767999768257141,
0.6993392705917358,
0.0980224758386612,
-0.18291707336902618,
0.15606383979320526,
-0.5046382546424866,
-0.35917142033576965,
0.12463779002428055,
0.12303738296031952,
-0.19522428512573242,
-0.5262912511825562,
-0.5112764835357666,
0.1633239984512329,
-0.5140944719314575,
1.2137778997421265,
-0.17714746296405792,
0.2628917396068573,
-0.5205496549606323,
-0.4093209505081177,
-0.3289891183376312,
-0.6565488576889038,
-0.5907495617866516,
-0.2657805383205414,
0.7345009446144104,
0.37942296266555786,
0.16278593242168427,
0.9540508389472961,
0.5994703769683838,
0.25894251465797424,
-0.20763292908668518,
0.0856727585196495,
-0.7038903832435608,
-0.26885974407196045,
-0.05045023187994957,
-0.45702579617500305,
-0.2615135610103607,
0.03145451098680496,
1.0247379541397095,
0.6082432270050049,
-0.012917444109916687,
0.3751552402973175,
-0.08554672449827194,
0.8739054203033447,
-0.7758508324623108,
0.15009012818336487,
-0.7538588643074036,
0.09703906625509262,
-0.09682855010032654,
-0.48365527391433716,
-0.7478406429290771,
-0.29682019352912903,
-0.045557498931884766,
-0.8136065602302551,
0.7082732319831848,
-0.07060949504375458,
0.6366913914680481,
0.17989614605903625,
-0.2232043296098709,
-0.7155218124389648,
-0.9397876262664795,
0.5392984747886658,
-0.14437180757522583,
0.38310062885284424,
0.33381596207618713,
0.05788189172744751,
0.2312908172607422,
-0.8348217606544495,
-0.5499811172485352,
-0.10240243375301361,
-0.3980042636394501,
0.17047318816184998,
0.20528383553028107,
-0.09988721460103989,
0.6232433319091797,
0.4256225824356079,
-0.4494502544403076,
-0.30386605858802795,
-0.672153890132904,
-0.07897695153951645,
0.5319359302520752,
0.014360838569700718,
0.3008488118648529,
0.18033793568611145,
-0.4566570520401001,
-0.28941723704338074,
-0.6693013906478882,
-0.18644914031028748,
0.07910532504320145,
-0.04415560141205788,
0.1934015154838562,
0.5279170870780945,
0.16055557131767273,
0.3881624937057495,
-0.07988700270652771,
-0.15128999948501587,
0.2548913359642029,
-0.038312267512083054,
-0.36877161264419556,
0.15965598821640015,
0.5165387988090515,
0.09378475695848465,
0.23182319104671478,
-0.5591751933097839,
-0.07540368288755417,
-0.09432051330804825,
0.19909128546714783,
-0.8919091820716858,
-0.02836865372955799,
-0.06644582003355026,
-0.24316370487213135,
0.2543855905532837,
0.2913559675216675,
-0.6624346971511841,
-0.3429504334926605,
-0.294567734003067,
0.24685142934322357,
-0.7055796384811401,
0.07477254420518875,
-0.0828140377998352,
-0.288214772939682,
-0.15437224507331848,
0.29736897349357605,
-1.0727579593658447,
0.5274578928947449,
0.6208858489990234,
0.9226622581481934,
-0.16049057245254517,
-0.352008193731308,
-0.7227216362953186,
0.43958011269569397,
-0.5731343030929565,
0.5449044704437256,
-0.473135381937027,
-0.48417288064956665,
0.008819750510156155,
-0.10465367138385773,
-0.5198133587837219,
-0.6076152920722961,
0.41879802942276,
-0.610815703868866,
0.11100766062736511,
-0.3826373219490051,
-0.9519595503807068,
-0.2535177767276764,
0.3155524730682373,
-1.1183878183364868,
1.0886574983596802,
0.03155288100242615,
-1.0895315408706665,
0.3735361695289612,
-0.5473265647888184,
-0.29912614822387695,
-0.016420722007751465,
-0.43806228041648865,
-0.3751903176307678,
0.4092218577861786,
-0.07802479714155197,
0.27357444167137146,
-0.027584107592701912,
0.16173698008060455,
-0.07383152097463608,
-0.7754507660865784,
0.4106268286705017,
-0.34742313623428345,
0.3644725978374481,
0.1318097561597824,
-0.4751150608062744,
-0.19938355684280396,
-0.8284164071083069,
-0.020555870607495308,
-0.06187138333916664,
-0.4087978005409241,
-0.5852799415588379,
0.13247954845428467,
-0.11230380088090897,
-0.12308286130428314,
0.3673078715801239,
-0.5089496970176697,
0.1428653746843338,
0.04068602994084358,
0.31195569038391113,
0.4162410497665405,
-0.15658800303936005,
0.5860674381256104,
-0.33760929107666016,
0.07529501616954803,
0.07389276474714279,
-0.19363181293010712,
-0.1969386488199234,
0.002146116690710187,
-0.8830334544181824,
-0.2554643452167511,
0.3960154354572296,
0.5158625245094299,
-0.4939834475517273,
-0.2528228461742401,
-0.6667467355728149,
-0.30963948369026184,
-0.18516035377979279,
0.37113285064697266,
0.5634915232658386,
0.2985978424549103,
0.406156450510025,
-0.255542129278183,
-0.4850885570049286,
-0.8525772094726562,
-0.18709859251976013,
-0.48541855812072754,
0.08354663848876953,
0.11220681667327881,
0.8670613765716553,
-0.1411042958498001,
0.8080549240112305,
-0.6780511736869812,
-0.208809956908226,
-0.07154583930969238,
0.4578794836997986,
-0.21473367512226105,
0.42855313420295715,
0.32458195090293884,
-1.0307209491729736,
-0.31194546818733215,
-0.013963484205305576,
-0.6929870843887329,
0.5463957786560059,
-0.3878783881664276,
0.1032806783914566,
0.32235610485076904,
0.9664787650108337,
-0.3868924379348755,
0.6010544896125793,
0.14877822995185852,
-0.1892600804567337,
0.2827037572860718,
-0.5248537659645081,
0.08074673265218735,
-0.8328295350074768,
0.47248411178588867,
-0.42323094606399536,
-0.08402740210294724,
-0.5108267068862915,
-0.060401614755392075,
0.27572503685951233,
0.08329169452190399,
-0.21334075927734375,
0.4488891363143921,
-0.6369974613189697,
-0.17902857065200806,
0.11878728121519089,
0.10341601818799973,
0.06945110857486725,
0.48058611154556274,
0.39659467339515686,
1.217718482017517,
-0.16916830837726593,
-0.6431009769439697,
-0.08761215955018997,
0.24426452815532684,
-0.4210178554058075,
0.15989620983600616,
-0.5158673524856567,
0.3213750720024109,
-0.2935977578163147,
-0.02377188950777054,
-0.8322156667709351,
-0.11454526335000992,
-0.18412615358829498,
-0.4675060510635376,
0.26031938195228577,
0.008138570934534073,
-0.6829730272293091,
-0.10417454689741135,
-0.09601467847824097,
0.4416610598564148,
0.2620900273323059,
-0.40387728810310364,
0.33890578150749207,
0.11008894443511963,
0.027622750028967857,
-0.6145022511482239,
-0.6813745498657227,
-0.17297258973121643,
-0.45653796195983887,
-0.20112772285938263,
0.41892993450164795,
-0.5456789135932922,
-0.5836362242698669,
-0.10832323879003525,
-0.18315336108207703,
-0.5072506666183472,
0.07852263003587723,
0.282100647687912,
0.19916747510433197,
-0.017032288014888763,
0.6084467768669128,
-0.3248310983181,
0.18133924901485443,
0.031662631779909134,
-0.16225187480449677,
0.4496932923793793,
-0.3074684143066406,
-0.08799464255571365,
-0.11156145483255386,
0.4831435978412628,
0.7014789581298828,
-0.24770981073379517,
0.9216485023498535,
0.6307764053344727,
-0.4092215895652771,
-0.21539925038814545,
-0.46257293224334717,
-0.05063892900943756,
-0.41197842359542847,
0.2742105722427368,
-0.29346203804016113,
-0.8001863956451416,
0.3865683078765869,
0.06497077643871307,
0.24930770695209503,
0.04057658836245537,
0.3119053542613983,
-0.07820587605237961,
0.5217786431312561,
0.8604793548583984,
0.11780573427677155,
0.5993006825447083,
-0.42659303545951843,
0.03154533728957176,
-0.6964859366416931,
-0.41518208384513855,
-0.3509677052497864,
-0.07033912092447281,
-0.4735473096370697,
-0.5733336210250854,
0.10754100233316422,
0.12880609929561615,
-0.16527003049850464,
0.2158520668745041,
-0.21753792464733124,
0.6146400570869446,
0.5200238823890686,
0.047524888068437576,
0.4139478802680969,
0.26874735951423645,
-0.1586010456085205,
-0.05955314636230469,
-0.5570651292800903,
-0.706325113773346,
1.0063667297363281,
0.24454469978809357,
0.2089463621377945,
-0.11889704316854477,
0.9591363668441772,
0.3512745797634125,
0.5860596895217896,
-0.7957864999771118,
0.6062958240509033,
-0.19439978897571564,
-0.9884423017501831,
-0.2797858417034149,
-0.6638955473899841,
-0.6019879579544067,
0.055839475244283676,
-0.08394874632358551,
-0.5993785858154297,
-0.07200533151626587,
0.006587435491383076,
-0.39837005734443665,
0.4398725628852844,
-0.8617685437202454,
0.6857612133026123,
-0.02301366627216339,
-0.5547890067100525,
-0.1412322074174881,
-0.4030405879020691,
0.14975285530090332,
-0.057116053998470306,
0.3456425666809082,
0.02692699246108532,
0.08164072781801224,
0.929635226726532,
-0.07954682409763336,
0.5267590284347534,
0.12479577213525772,
0.01672854833304882,
0.5353555083274841,
0.02453944832086563,
0.12914057075977325,
0.43546584248542786,
-0.0427120216190815,
-0.25173360109329224,
0.007424965035170317,
-0.33407092094421387,
-0.7952349781990051,
0.5652132034301758,
-0.6353452205657959,
-0.4160432517528534,
-0.5965273380279541,
-0.588010311126709,
-0.18495436012744904,
0.1512063592672348,
0.49534180760383606,
0.548725962638855,
-0.7993615865707397,
0.015135785564780235,
1.0767446756362915,
0.11372262239456177,
0.6470224857330322,
0.5028271079063416,
0.1117706224322319,
-0.6052520275115967,
0.9222564697265625,
0.3604956269264221,
0.19237971305847168,
0.674008846282959,
-0.4059445261955261,
-0.15607325732707977,
-0.5402742028236389,
-0.3294849097728729,
0.38693767786026,
-0.7700643539428711,
0.25020352005958557,
-0.3247016966342926,
-0.07707846909761429,
-0.18952108919620514,
-0.03280043229460716,
-0.3637731373310089,
-0.4936104118824005,
-0.4813844561576843,
-0.3234008252620697,
0.12469043582677841,
0.9586403965950012,
-0.05096639320254326,
0.33064237236976624,
-0.6367990970611572,
0.3653842508792877,
0.3851889967918396,
0.499101847410202,
-0.19352269172668457,
-0.056196991354227066,
-0.5717422962188721,
-0.051781389862298965,
-0.0848538726568222,
-0.8018941879272461,
0.1638413965702057,
0.26486140489578247,
0.15704628825187683,
0.5306223630905151,
-0.07892371714115143,
0.9018341898918152,
-0.7818853855133057,
0.4904082119464874,
0.2388787716627121,
-1.0011597871780396,
0.20564164221286774,
-0.11380241066217422,
0.003976383712142706,
1.0669333934783936,
0.348309189081192,
-0.5340386629104614,
-0.15277257561683655,
-0.76866614818573,
-0.687743604183197,
0.5025980472564697,
0.4554494023323059,
0.027790438383817673,
-0.25912418961524963,
0.5426810383796692,
-0.021996021270751953,
0.20657946169376373,
-0.6071924567222595,
-0.18300028145313263,
-0.029205886647105217,
-0.1457156091928482,
-0.44171252846717834,
-0.3433191180229187,
-0.396791934967041,
-0.32583165168762207,
0.4766560196876526,
0.02770095132291317,
0.47811320424079895,
0.5391215085983276,
-0.5679495334625244,
0.33200883865356445,
0.47605088353157043,
0.8408591151237488,
0.9119674563407898,
-0.2717028856277466,
0.30359867215156555,
0.5200971364974976,
-0.8505457043647766,
0.12036155164241791,
-0.11993557959794998,
-0.25376787781715393,
0.4608730673789978,
0.546509861946106,
0.6627323031425476,
0.07818607985973358,
-0.7384958267211914,
0.2907162606716156,
-0.4453764259815216,
-0.13071759045124054,
-0.9741798043251038,
0.028144147247076035,
0.12076587975025177,
-0.06061313673853874,
0.3424992263317108,
-0.06663722544908524,
0.07449754327535629,
-0.7076355814933777,
0.27861979603767395,
-0.06267329305410385,
-0.6019247770309448,
-0.3189179599285126,
0.5106611251831055,
-0.06367503851652145,
-0.08535762876272202,
0.7666128873825073,
-0.17264212667942047,
-0.21607659757137299,
0.6874053478240967,
0.46200665831565857,
0.5910363793373108,
0.07730544358491898,
0.4278471767902374,
0.6838088035583496,
0.23707078397274017,
-0.31571292877197266,
0.027921875938773155,
-0.09870940446853638,
-0.46025192737579346,
-0.15371082723140717,
-0.3556143045425415,
-0.1818581521511078,
0.2262263298034668,
-1.0906623601913452,
0.13419412076473236,
-0.7829226851463318,
-0.22536396980285645,
-0.11121860146522522,
0.24344660341739655,
-0.5402811765670776,
0.46944859623908997,
0.24518845975399017,
1.089082956314087,
-0.7352083921432495,
0.8418921232223511,
0.808424711227417,
-0.4839896559715271,
-0.6569001078605652,
0.10872988402843475,
-0.3102280795574188,
-0.4024868905544281,
0.7269420623779297,
0.4853743016719818,
-0.12736566364765167,
-0.09096087515354156,
-0.5097101926803589,
-0.45851168036460876,
1.2771782875061035,
0.46972545981407166,
-0.7138531804084778,
-0.2768618166446686,
0.18598809838294983,
0.6004799008369446,
-0.3482888340950012,
0.36186230182647705,
0.8267478346824646,
0.25656405091285706,
0.10055248439311981,
-0.5738546252250671,
-0.22888398170471191,
-0.5252625346183777,
-0.031222427263855934,
0.09117653220891953,
-0.6615989208221436,
0.8166491985321045,
-0.29033178091049194,
-0.6663522720336914,
0.19738581776618958,
0.7451776266098022,
0.16765634715557098,
0.6829841136932373,
0.364736944437027,
0.6484128832817078,
1.0989516973495483,
-0.1040194183588028,
0.8018206357955933,
-0.18443527817726135,
0.3266622722148895,
1.3465383052825928,
-0.04928547516465187,
0.8671874403953552,
0.7002156376838684,
0.18333066999912262,
0.7837011814117432,
0.4737812578678131,
0.09845283627510071,
0.37171560525894165,
0.28809642791748047,
-0.5666406154632568,
-0.12261734157800674,
0.09901580959558487,
-0.39177942276000977,
0.26406002044677734,
0.4440484046936035,
-0.4992207884788513,
0.04896780475974083,
-0.15931855142116547,
0.35371214151382446,
0.39837250113487244,
-0.20295865833759308,
0.9415610432624817,
-0.022028816863894463,
-0.8589819669723511,
0.7986093759536743,
-0.18813471496105194,
0.1585555523633957,
-0.6151344180107117,
-0.030247872695326805,
-0.38419094681739807,
0.39422109723091125,
-0.04017604887485504,
-0.37041333317756653,
0.38647595047950745,
0.19035357236862183,
-0.4535672068595886,
-0.2548981308937073,
0.14871840178966522,
-0.5328337550163269,
-0.4416830837726593,
0.4194019138813019,
0.23082982003688812,
0.19233518838882446,
0.11514152586460114,
-0.2105380892753601,
0.1261376291513443,
-0.12425483763217926,
0.04287487268447876,
-0.061474189162254333,
0.5704650282859802,
-0.06970669329166412,
0.5425561666488647,
0.2217346876859665,
0.02239220030605793,
0.2222200483083725,
-0.16655930876731873,
0.7563791275024414,
-0.7712326049804688,
-0.32363176345825195,
-1.0040919780731201,
0.3019035756587982,
-0.3215387165546417,
-0.49571287631988525,
0.7154262661933899,
0.9849705100059509,
0.9408599138259888,
-0.14786900579929352,
0.7799757719039917,
-0.07463794946670532,
0.36674419045448303,
-0.6106064915657043,
0.6322717666625977,
-0.43653929233551025,
0.2135339081287384,
-0.30373263359069824,
-0.6773480176925659,
-0.1865851730108261,
0.6319478750228882,
-0.3912215828895569,
-0.3819112181663513,
1.1337050199508667,
0.4649132192134857,
-0.09345020353794098,
0.1326712965965271,
0.12518823146820068,
-0.05027259886264801,
0.1010865792632103,
0.7557860612869263,
0.7681602835655212,
-0.4380156993865967,
0.7900948524475098,
0.013819990679621696,
-0.09684494882822037,
-0.03646498918533325,
-0.5999979376792908,
-1.248844027519226,
-0.9006597995758057,
-0.1689121276140213,
-0.2215801328420639,
0.2210836261510849,
0.5294080972671509,
0.452288955450058,
-0.6700618863105774,
-0.39357972145080566,
-0.26454654335975647,
0.2196902334690094,
-0.15377624332904816,
-0.09634819626808167,
0.4645790159702301,
-0.4220448434352875,
-0.7938644289970398,
0.13666310906410217,
-0.11054935306310654,
0.2570457458496094,
0.06947556883096695,
-0.10248622298240662,
0.06840096414089203,
0.10374397039413452,
0.4378522038459778,
0.3715716302394867,
-0.2303793579339981,
-0.1087317019701004,
0.18567682802677155,
-0.23454558849334717,
0.2826562821865082,
1.3083624839782715,
-0.6488520503044128,
0.3771280348300934,
0.62689608335495,
0.3717363178730011,
0.7881990671157837,
-0.010881971567869186,
0.5463753938674927,
-0.7496628761291504,
0.33821284770965576,
0.20766867697238922,
0.3644355237483978,
0.47799935936927795,
-0.2645264267921448,
0.5636743903160095,
0.2577992081642151,
-0.18750104308128357,
-0.675999104976654,
0.23960404098033905,
-0.6464866995811462,
-0.4870636463165283,
1.1400736570358276,
-0.5021149516105652,
-0.35966989398002625,
0.08160305768251419,
-0.09322074800729752,
0.4860368072986603,
-0.13558177649974823,
0.9482143521308899,
1.0867116451263428,
0.24444593489170074,
0.10763968527317047,
-0.5883165001869202,
0.6162860989570618,
0.48660025000572205,
-0.6698766946792603,
0.2732778489589691,
0.5650323033332825,
0.4417365789413452,
0.6663015484809875,
0.809686541557312,
-0.26138967275619507,
0.2800018787384033,
-0.05948110297322273,
-0.08927460014820099,
-0.12204079329967499,
-0.8187673687934875,
-0.19494125247001648,
0.28628385066986084,
-0.04392233118414879,
-0.12352045625448227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00509v1
|
Surveying the Dead Minds: Historical-Psychological Text Analysis with Contextualized Construct Representation (CCR) for Classical Chinese
| 2024-03-01T13:14:45 | 2024-03-01T13:14:45 |
Yuqi Chen, Sixuan Li, Ying Li, Mohammad Atari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
In this work, we develop a pipeline for historical-psychological text
analysis in classical Chinese. Humans have produced texts in various languages
for thousands of years; however, most of the computational literature is
focused on contemporary languages and corpora. The emerging field of historical
psychology relies on computational techniques to extract aspects of psychology
from historical corpora using new methods developed in natural language
processing (NLP). The present pipeline, called Contextualized Construct
Representations (CCR), combines expert knowledge in psychometrics (i.e.,
psychological surveys) with text representations generated via
transformer-based language models to measure psychological constructs such as
traditionalism, norm strength, and collectivism in classical Chinese corpora.
Considering the scarcity of available data, we propose an indirect supervised
contrastive learning approach and build the first Chinese historical psychology
corpus (C-HI-PSY) to fine-tune pre-trained models. We evaluate the pipeline to
demonstrate its superior performance compared with other approaches. The CCR
method outperforms word-embedding-based approaches across all of our tasks and
exceeds prompting with GPT-4 in most tasks. Finally, we benchmark the pipeline
against objective, external data to further verify its validity.
|
[
-0.4535284638404846,
-0.5472368001937866,
0.6100677251815796,
-0.028847282752394676,
-0.25763532519340515,
0.026755575090646744,
-0.600377082824707,
-0.20614026486873627,
0.1108202263712883,
0.3422556519508362,
-0.5972201228141785,
-0.511001467704773,
-0.3830920159816742,
0.040367670357227325,
0.05697131156921387,
1.022512674331665,
0.07469434291124344,
0.307733416557312,
-0.11310828477144241,
0.021381497383117676,
-0.11117829382419586,
-0.9131693243980408,
-0.7621026635169983,
-0.3063758909702301,
0.3093933165073395,
-0.10985901951789856,
0.5454308986663818,
0.3129684031009674,
0.43260958790779114,
0.20324374735355377,
0.03480806201696396,
0.11004679650068283,
-0.5785731673240662,
0.023984801024198532,
-0.04779906943440437,
-0.23937039077281952,
-0.19713562726974487,
0.057562731206417084,
0.4453412890434265,
0.8184170126914978,
0.07651779055595398,
0.07901490479707718,
0.12560127675533295,
0.5315402746200562,
-0.8633158206939697,
0.16934695839881897,
-0.4581022262573242,
0.3548831045627594,
-0.07574615627527237,
-0.5582900047302246,
-0.6135923266410828,
-0.3422943353652954,
0.2696406841278076,
-0.47510600090026855,
0.5470356941223145,
-0.33331963419914246,
0.5025350451469421,
0.20764757692813873,
-0.4364010989665985,
-0.2277926355600357,
-0.587285041809082,
1.0576597452163696,
-0.6870436668395996,
0.2863222658634186,
0.38949859142303467,
0.18122510612010956,
-0.08649023622274399,
-0.8220692276954651,
-0.40837815403938293,
-0.3724033832550049,
-0.33176520466804504,
0.4189310073852539,
-0.0339086540043354,
-0.1042427271604538,
0.26047536730766296,
0.45820215344429016,
-0.6321805119514465,
-0.15277709066867828,
-0.5323655009269714,
-0.47503039240837097,
0.7021647691726685,
0.40516749024391174,
0.5210497975349426,
-0.19108733534812927,
-0.05505604296922684,
-0.17693763971328735,
-0.3887673020362854,
-0.06584249436855316,
0.10365187376737595,
0.272972971200943,
-0.2013344168663025,
0.26673078536987305,
-0.14754880964756012,
0.6511656641960144,
0.29420313239097595,
-0.15416733920574188,
0.0029424934182316065,
-0.28642791509628296,
-0.06657696515321732,
0.05155257508158684,
0.9044610261917114,
0.4820719361305237,
0.20294921100139618,
-0.2809872627258301,
0.16200444102287292,
0.2152535766363144,
0.30996471643447876,
-0.6777924299240112,
-0.6238856911659241,
0.13263332843780518,
-0.5063713192939758,
0.05120271444320679,
-0.19395741820335388,
-0.5885336399078369,
-0.5199736952781677,
-0.4277186393737793,
-0.2736508548259735,
-0.693701446056366,
-0.33765530586242676,
-0.26092293858528137,
-0.20127739012241364,
0.4090323746204376,
0.2790064513683319,
-0.9286683201789856,
0.1378321647644043,
0.5046466588973999,
0.9564459323883057,
-0.37425312399864197,
-0.1327063888311386,
-0.39549118280410767,
0.1251365840435028,
-0.4629446268081665,
0.6577193140983582,
-0.31355926394462585,
-0.27087005972862244,
0.3109472692012787,
0.08994641155004501,
0.11492713540792465,
-0.2966538965702057,
0.7055164575576782,
-0.38351207971572876,
0.639153778553009,
-0.41996264457702637,
-0.1888243407011032,
-0.09095937013626099,
0.40677306056022644,
-0.6831318140029907,
1.0029748678207397,
0.02720334567129612,
-1.005630373954773,
0.19854027032852173,
-0.11756632477045059,
-0.2721901535987854,
0.1288597285747528,
-0.5169857740402222,
-0.14308764040470123,
-0.08510634303092957,
0.3011113703250885,
0.62897127866745,
-0.014038953930139542,
0.2423483282327652,
-0.2793424725532532,
-0.7350484728813171,
0.1105341762304306,
-0.21861635148525238,
1.1822277307510376,
0.330584853887558,
-0.26799726486206055,
-0.15909700095653534,
-0.7851149439811707,
-0.10191331058740616,
-0.17956650257110596,
-0.09267918020486832,
-0.7574687004089355,
0.25451934337615967,
0.3837500810623169,
0.1646386682987213,
0.3611049950122833,
-0.438298761844635,
-0.15547463297843933,
-0.5511583685874939,
0.2507033944129944,
0.5124835968017578,
0.03952573612332344,
0.32263001799583435,
-0.09628534317016602,
0.3255309760570526,
-0.03615303710103035,
-0.3461070656776428,
-0.19613860547542572,
-0.04721999913454056,
-0.5228807926177979,
-0.08467872440814972,
-0.2642061710357666,
0.4359126091003418,
-0.8502327799797058,
0.5546532273292542,
-0.23962898552417755,
-0.6370387673377991,
-0.11423639953136444,
-0.19361017644405365,
0.1540917307138443,
0.49265918135643005,
0.43631380796432495,
-0.40427863597869873,
-0.720308244228363,
-0.7289412021636963,
-0.08527305722236633,
-0.4876663386821747,
-0.5051553249359131,
-0.10380246490240097,
0.31130924820899963,
-0.015171337872743607,
0.8407425880432129,
-0.6144514083862305,
-0.25475406646728516,
-0.006179155316203833,
0.36264023184776306,
0.1302887499332428,
0.49025553464889526,
0.4595443904399872,
-0.7695624828338623,
-0.22653652727603912,
0.18149890005588531,
-1.0038055181503296,
0.09385029971599579,
-0.21668992936611176,
-0.24929210543632507,
0.09107021242380142,
0.4798707664012909,
-0.22378748655319214,
0.12127876281738281,
0.37451913952827454,
-0.12287088483572006,
0.7014926075935364,
-0.050453998148441315,
0.19524379074573517,
-1.0677582025527954,
0.3346671164035797,
0.15921640396118164,
0.16267015039920807,
-0.6268849968910217,
0.18481037020683289,
0.17266800999641418,
-0.22342534363269806,
-0.4503882825374603,
0.25398343801498413,
-0.6880468726158142,
0.36845892667770386,
-0.2882693409919739,
0.329811692237854,
-0.6019158363342285,
0.7570344805717468,
0.6610122919082642,
0.5061143040657043,
0.2232026606798172,
-0.5702823996543884,
0.3663267493247986,
0.11541890352964401,
0.1098770722746849,
0.8328166007995605,
-0.2239912450313568,
0.20199309289455414,
-0.2606099843978882,
0.3070417642593384,
-1.0523093938827515,
-0.16495883464813232,
0.29420003294944763,
-0.6033080816268921,
-0.005053516943007708,
0.17069528996944427,
-0.2646576166152954,
-0.30182212591171265,
-0.38691312074661255,
0.4391268193721771,
0.43641379475593567,
-0.30647727847099304,
0.6264747381210327,
0.1979752629995346,
-0.09034979343414307,
-0.6342095732688904,
-0.8728407621383667,
0.1428554505109787,
-0.2878594696521759,
-0.2855367362499237,
0.29698827862739563,
-0.2408057451248169,
-0.22515182197093964,
-0.08692248910665512,
-0.008253071457147598,
-0.36306944489479065,
-0.16957038640975952,
0.02610304392874241,
0.47382137179374695,
-0.3685683012008667,
-0.057893022894859314,
0.01147264614701271,
-0.07644908130168915,
0.43539682030677795,
-0.023346159607172012,
0.40539026260375977,
0.045668501406908035,
-0.2472534477710724,
-0.30652645230293274,
0.10488922148942947,
0.3806804418563843,
-0.19596250355243683,
0.6260231733322144,
0.7220370173454285,
-0.6193816661834717,
0.016836456954479218,
-0.6620447039604187,
-0.06149115785956383,
-0.37700656056404114,
0.38571301102638245,
-0.12134553492069244,
-0.8723970055580139,
0.3647352457046509,
-0.02234620600938797,
0.10474815964698792,
0.2861943244934082,
0.7134354114532471,
0.08809355646371841,
0.8075523376464844,
0.7263985872268677,
-0.4151098132133484,
0.5164284706115723,
-0.054967302829027176,
0.0891612246632576,
-0.6597926020622253,
0.09364946186542511,
-0.23410531878471375,
-0.06378868222236633,
-0.678351879119873,
-0.15438833832740784,
0.4248572587966919,
-0.2811416983604431,
-0.49864593148231506,
0.14133165776729584,
-0.6635436415672302,
0.13588346540927887,
0.2456900030374527,
0.4204830825328827,
0.5642332434654236,
-0.0642731562256813,
0.13082285225391388,
-0.5318884253501892,
-0.13107196986675262,
-0.7101656794548035,
0.9517825841903687,
0.09942178428173065,
0.39258894324302673,
-0.2353285849094391,
0.544874906539917,
0.3133413791656494,
0.6429310441017151,
-0.7877423763275146,
0.3622696101665497,
-0.12162160128355026,
-0.4936174154281616,
-0.19042378664016724,
-0.14054682850837708,
-0.6733461618423462,
0.4824472665786743,
-0.005566334817558527,
-0.7600788474082947,
0.24831634759902954,
-0.03377648815512657,
-0.4470447599887848,
0.2896353304386139,
-0.2690280079841614,
0.7118382453918457,
-0.16440905630588531,
-0.41666680574417114,
-0.1251375824213028,
-0.7900795936584473,
0.7995606064796448,
-0.03749258443713188,
0.050246186554431915,
0.353346586227417,
0.0007531481678597629,
0.7599989771842957,
-0.17317628860473633,
0.8097829222679138,
-0.12217983603477478,
-0.22359232604503632,
0.08732406049966812,
0.10892567783594131,
0.29402846097946167,
-0.138501837849617,
-0.2550275921821594,
-0.13538667559623718,
0.4751370847225189,
-0.5753099322319031,
-0.4752027988433838,
0.6355316638946533,
-0.7059869766235352,
-0.3519156277179718,
-0.6492968797683716,
-0.4554668962955475,
-0.27009183168411255,
0.1572645604610443,
0.4463326036930084,
0.23078513145446777,
-0.7801810503005981,
0.22802725434303284,
0.48188281059265137,
-0.2325528860092163,
0.3860676884651184,
0.5325287580490112,
0.17323580384254456,
-0.3753798305988312,
0.5849602222442627,
-0.009018435142934322,
-0.03372591733932495,
0.5260502099990845,
-0.2131519764661789,
0.014726382680237293,
-0.4467076063156128,
-0.20277178287506104,
0.2960180342197418,
-0.5392113924026489,
0.24097879230976105,
-0.4657589793205261,
-0.19680120050907135,
-0.298218309879303,
-0.24519367516040802,
-0.3718779385089874,
0.2801801562309265,
-0.41403281688690186,
-0.17918312549591064,
-0.05395328998565674,
0.2965168356895447,
-0.2015860676765442,
0.23787884414196014,
-0.36527636647224426,
0.3006638288497925,
-0.04746934399008751,
0.025618450716137886,
0.2770451009273529,
-0.14666947722434998,
-0.5675420761108398,
0.043196480721235275,
-0.4661829173564911,
-1.0440213680267334,
0.565847635269165,
-0.32590505480766296,
0.3731299936771393,
0.6482558846473694,
0.4006493091583252,
0.7690567970275879,
-0.3846028745174408,
1.1163647174835205,
0.16692465543746948,
-0.7167915105819702,
0.4264133870601654,
-0.4761248528957367,
0.1172567754983902,
0.6234703063964844,
0.684207558631897,
-0.9292863607406616,
-0.5924697518348694,
-0.3880235552787781,
-0.6587474942207336,
0.5647863149642944,
-0.023968879133462906,
0.18588455021381378,
-0.21189658343791962,
0.28347283601760864,
0.03130358085036278,
-0.13367481529712677,
-0.8370592594146729,
-0.4598158001899719,
-0.31794649362564087,
-0.2674049139022827,
-0.22719372808933258,
0.1319379210472107,
-0.030983151867985725,
-0.17264632880687714,
0.32152026891708374,
-0.32551929354667664,
0.21070526540279388,
0.4478706419467926,
-0.10220803320407867,
-0.18924137949943542,
0.26510459184646606,
0.04321043938398361,
0.8645212054252625,
-0.4100114405155182,
0.36074915528297424,
0.3584637939929962,
-0.5797320008277893,
0.0964137613773346,
0.291734904050827,
-0.24701309204101562,
0.0792405903339386,
0.4864749312400818,
0.4251137673854828,
0.1897037774324417,
-0.8415747880935669,
0.40173229575157166,
-0.05964231118559837,
0.07402747124433517,
-0.9621523022651672,
-0.22577814757823944,
0.06420230120420456,
0.1337563395500183,
0.8267483711242676,
-0.2470884919166565,
0.35209545493125916,
-0.6720619201660156,
0.08707787841558456,
0.4268186092376709,
-0.6778174042701721,
-0.39043161273002625,
0.7225378155708313,
-0.1591881364583969,
0.09016639739274979,
0.7284929156303406,
-0.05635116621851921,
-0.4219112992286682,
0.26212799549102783,
0.4007769823074341,
0.845214307308197,
0.026285896077752113,
0.331453800201416,
0.7758476734161377,
0.2592581510543823,
-0.2172856330871582,
-0.17952170968055725,
-0.34361809492111206,
-0.6859521865844727,
-0.44545450806617737,
-0.31781476736068726,
-0.5707259178161621,
0.41369566321372986,
-0.9241734147071838,
0.22142742574214935,
-0.3141460418701172,
-0.01758301444351673,
-0.5354077219963074,
0.2846987247467041,
-0.6500115990638733,
0.5232399106025696,
0.43239203095436096,
0.5288435220718384,
-0.9401739835739136,
0.5886380672454834,
0.6777687072753906,
-0.7596216201782227,
-0.3986310064792633,
0.23160624504089355,
0.010775390081107616,
-0.4572429656982422,
0.6926261782646179,
-0.07032589614391327,
-0.07566789537668228,
-0.020660994574427605,
-0.7688384056091309,
-0.6624639630317688,
1.0806447267532349,
0.28412073850631714,
-0.3223569691181183,
-0.22149211168289185,
-0.28438594937324524,
1.0716580152511597,
-0.06029195338487625,
0.5190578103065491,
0.5601956844329834,
0.37871044874191284,
-0.32633280754089355,
-0.4637400805950165,
0.43856409192085266,
-0.4111146926879883,
-0.10388138145208359,
-0.07891515642404556,
-0.6178173422813416,
0.6892448663711548,
0.07909539341926575,
-0.8367767333984375,
0.5058586597442627,
1.1571828126907349,
0.66370689868927,
0.5124636888504028,
0.18237930536270142,
0.26560723781585693,
0.7337223291397095,
-0.06466124206781387,
0.9685507416725159,
-0.35727018117904663,
0.1765432506799698,
0.8826947212219238,
-0.0768035501241684,
0.9232094883918762,
0.5797173976898193,
-0.43254461884498596,
0.807878315448761,
0.8217858076095581,
-0.03743889927864075,
0.49792346358299255,
0.30181142687797546,
-0.3019920289516449,
-0.07687073945999146,
-0.1250855028629303,
-0.5410070419311523,
-0.017030607908964157,
0.1314258873462677,
-0.3397237956523895,
-0.13403713703155518,
-0.09631279110908508,
0.07533501088619232,
0.4452002942562103,
-0.18584337830543518,
0.4732982814311981,
0.1635919064283371,
-0.698552668094635,
0.6383432745933533,
-0.14845731854438782,
1.0236666202545166,
-0.6722671389579773,
0.11536192148923874,
-0.43725818395614624,
0.16899718344211578,
-0.1334131360054016,
-0.390970379114151,
0.22880394756793976,
-0.13144329190254211,
0.017303258180618286,
-0.012391511350870132,
0.550599217414856,
-0.4944588840007782,
-0.4443321228027344,
0.29512882232666016,
0.7075194716453552,
0.27639296650886536,
-0.18014000356197357,
-0.27282920479774475,
-0.18196509778499603,
-0.14277943968772888,
-0.16588009893894196,
0.30107754468917847,
0.6091086268424988,
-0.0979963168501854,
0.37662601470947266,
0.547058641910553,
0.3660210967063904,
-0.354780912399292,
-0.039091385900974274,
0.6905283331871033,
-1.1712433099746704,
-0.6514625549316406,
-0.8975800275802612,
0.35235363245010376,
0.010211914777755737,
-0.278872013092041,
0.7801611423492432,
0.5668440461158752,
0.9733973741531372,
-0.25078997015953064,
0.9838210344314575,
0.00480229826644063,
0.4274768531322479,
-0.2514055073261261,
0.8635610342025757,
-0.3585211932659149,
-0.17321713268756866,
-0.6463457942008972,
-0.5996752977371216,
-0.432016521692276,
0.49440252780914307,
-0.47452372312545776,
-0.19251815974712372,
0.9554794430732727,
0.6468135118484497,
-0.022506415843963623,
0.08532174676656723,
0.18472544848918915,
0.06152219697833061,
0.12424789369106293,
0.9191611409187317,
1.1726707220077515,
-0.4217693507671356,
0.5210451483726501,
-0.29201367497444153,
-0.2877208888530731,
0.29589971899986267,
-0.8339142203330994,
-0.9165424704551697,
-0.7993163466453552,
-0.23969803750514984,
-0.11381694674491882,
0.13833744823932648,
0.7848870754241943,
0.37871330976486206,
-0.8735766410827637,
-0.550755500793457,
0.20953895151615143,
-0.10124392807483673,
-0.541705310344696,
-0.30218273401260376,
0.7556877136230469,
-0.3422060012817383,
-0.8849602937698364,
0.1611042469739914,
0.04829871281981468,
-0.3127938210964203,
-0.5827868580818176,
-0.13955837488174438,
0.07451064884662628,
-0.37268659472465515,
0.6666045784950256,
0.33181673288345337,
-0.8669965267181396,
-0.15059517323970795,
-0.057095322757959366,
-0.2471376657485962,
0.01624007523059845,
1.1424955129623413,
-0.8998076319694519,
0.37129199504852295,
0.6223904490470886,
0.6979442238807678,
0.5058339834213257,
0.0482780858874321,
0.8099634647369385,
-0.4920366406440735,
0.053484249860048294,
0.19820044934749603,
0.399488627910614,
0.6386820673942566,
-0.49297192692756653,
0.6597163081169128,
0.4462341070175171,
-0.24744108319282532,
-0.7560320496559143,
-0.23038449883460999,
-1.1375609636306763,
-0.5039755702018738,
0.7616721987724304,
0.0411095917224884,
-0.06624040752649307,
-0.3294501006603241,
-0.487396240234375,
0.6671259999275208,
-0.2921549081802368,
0.9811291098594666,
0.9201173782348633,
-0.2813395857810974,
-0.3614380359649658,
-0.38967016339302063,
0.4590364098548889,
0.27677783370018005,
-0.5474408268928528,
0.05245188623666763,
0.8950815200805664,
0.052851833403110504,
0.3827749788761139,
1.0206172466278076,
-0.2258167266845703,
0.30326902866363525,
-0.11425574868917465,
0.1795235276222229,
0.26637202501296997,
0.40348267555236816,
-0.053085267543792725,
0.5578795671463013,
-0.28039005398750305,
0.11468638479709625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00506v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00506v1
|
PoTeC: A German Naturalistic Eye-tracking-while-reading Corpus
| 2024-03-01T13:07:39 | 2024-03-01T13:07:39 |
Deborah N. Jakobi, Thomas Kern, David R. Reich, Patrick Haller, Lena A. Jäger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Potsdam Textbook Corpus (PoTeC) is a naturalistic
eye-tracking-while-reading corpus containing data from 75 participants reading
12 scientific texts. PoTeC is the first naturalistic eye-tracking-while-reading
corpus that contains eye-movements from domain-experts as well as novices in a
within-participant manipulation: It is based on a 2x2x2 fully-crossed factorial
design which includes the participants' level of study and the participants'
discipline of study as between-subject factors and the text domain as a
within-subject factor. The participants' reading comprehension was assessed by
a series of text comprehension questions and their domain knowledge was tested
by text-independent background questions for each of the texts. The materials
are annotated for a variety of linguistic features at different levels. We
envision PoTeC to be used for a wide range of studies including but not limited
to analyses of expert and non-expert reading strategies. The corpus and all the
accompanying data at all stages of the preprocessing pipeline and all code used
to preprocess the data are made available via GitHub:
https://github.com/DiLi-Lab/PoTeC.
|
[
-0.6389634609222412,
-0.8027167916297913,
0.4898105561733246,
0.05437780171632767,
-0.4682367146015167,
0.24381287395954132,
-0.4172249138355255,
-0.4132295846939087,
0.12644001841545105,
0.45854711532592773,
-0.3751278221607208,
-0.9304253458976746,
-0.34569212794303894,
0.5144326686859131,
-0.4212690591812134,
0.6897910237312317,
0.1108592227101326,
0.32269397377967834,
0.14463408291339874,
0.13659144937992096,
-0.25994816422462463,
-0.13479451835155487,
-0.2412198930978775,
0.0859333947300911,
0.6928151845932007,
1.0328559875488281,
0.4003642201423645,
0.4834708571434021,
0.7266840934753418,
0.21374733746051788,
0.2325110286474228,
0.0852012187242508,
-0.24631847441196442,
-0.19299760460853577,
0.005619855597615242,
-0.6852453351020813,
-0.5078625679016113,
0.10253466665744781,
0.9272732734680176,
0.9071815013885498,
-0.019116466864943504,
0.2400779277086258,
0.23221220076084137,
0.616021454334259,
-0.8089203834533691,
0.09857762604951859,
-0.05757630988955498,
0.010546086356043816,
-0.6376438140869141,
-0.5471464991569519,
-0.9016531705856323,
-0.08718959242105484,
0.3789953291416168,
-1.0068777799606323,
0.5360488891601562,
0.2340778261423111,
0.8923236727714539,
0.16455039381980896,
-0.3808395266532898,
-0.19340035319328308,
-0.4029390811920166,
0.6820113062858582,
-0.38511213660240173,
0.4060557186603546,
0.7209541201591492,
0.20409159362316132,
0.05894121900200844,
-0.898425817489624,
-0.8068552613258362,
-0.15693804621696472,
-0.15940608084201813,
0.44226109981536865,
0.14436425268650055,
-0.11700445413589478,
0.00047003067447803915,
0.1424006223678589,
-0.6903311014175415,
-0.016220111399888992,
-0.5718502998352051,
0.0038887911941856146,
0.47535809874534607,
-0.20304320752620697,
0.2895646095275879,
-0.19059966504573822,
-0.3561966121196747,
-0.21093687415122986,
-0.23020058870315552,
-0.027231888845562935,
0.3804938495159149,
0.20253008604049683,
-0.14017558097839355,
0.5515384674072266,
-0.20979131758213043,
0.7286015152931213,
0.09204873442649841,
0.08554394543170929,
0.26480403542518616,
-0.2900281548500061,
-0.15198606252670288,
0.06699958443641663,
0.7963451147079468,
0.3861328363418579,
0.4551474153995514,
-0.3000998795032501,
0.28458696603775024,
0.17894260585308075,
0.5777838230133057,
-0.45053353905677795,
-0.49498802423477173,
0.33323705196380615,
-0.1629500687122345,
-0.40155360102653503,
0.37231355905532837,
-1.293182373046875,
0.04070892930030823,
-0.4923936128616333,
0.0982377678155899,
-0.7014050483703613,
0.04902101308107376,
0.09772580862045288,
0.03892171010375023,
0.37728744745254517,
0.3774769902229309,
-1.100230097770691,
0.4717598259449005,
0.528952419757843,
0.98554527759552,
-0.45640861988067627,
-0.5711789727210999,
-0.4782789945602417,
0.08130201697349548,
-0.6043297648429871,
1.2553328275680542,
-0.5049520134925842,
-0.48634061217308044,
0.0015504820039495826,
0.42324358224868774,
-0.0975404754281044,
-0.01857050694525242,
0.5321778059005737,
-0.5779110789299011,
0.4723965525627136,
-0.3972572684288025,
-0.7428381443023682,
-0.2445184886455536,
-0.09959778189659119,
-0.7666277885437012,
1.1218875646591187,
0.07342514395713806,
-0.9676592350006104,
0.7881492376327515,
-0.8459024429321289,
-0.35201212763786316,
0.678342878818512,
0.013029670342803001,
-0.2852804362773895,
-0.41070860624313354,
0.10868226736783981,
0.13838663697242737,
0.05653694272041321,
0.009235991165041924,
-0.15768936276435852,
-0.33488625288009644,
0.2711960971355438,
-0.11418795585632324,
1.0323725938796997,
0.1861194521188736,
-0.4838505983352661,
0.3215710520744324,
-0.6193028092384338,
-0.06381571292877197,
-0.32500800490379333,
0.164223313331604,
-0.4058503806591034,
0.04898035153746605,
0.16697359085083008,
-0.17810989916324615,
0.13573400676250458,
-0.7660146355628967,
0.4386773407459259,
-0.01167505607008934,
0.2900257706642151,
0.6110474467277527,
0.06146731600165367,
0.48777395486831665,
0.1472676396369934,
0.25800246000289917,
-0.3965928554534912,
0.48093512654304504,
0.03966345638036728,
-0.3831084966659546,
-0.6751205921173096,
-0.6818175315856934,
0.6609025597572327,
0.8112207055091858,
-0.8110494017601013,
0.21371933817863464,
-0.04229632765054703,
-0.5022153258323669,
-0.4512724280357361,
0.08679141849279404,
0.13320735096931458,
0.560380756855011,
0.2780457139015198,
-0.32364895939826965,
-0.2089834064245224,
-0.7693468928337097,
0.3594532907009125,
-0.23925304412841797,
-0.4197358191013336,
0.2643401622772217,
0.7582830190658569,
-0.26176270842552185,
0.6527223587036133,
-0.6000500917434692,
-0.4935886859893799,
-0.11223088204860687,
0.3549655079841614,
-0.3204864263534546,
0.3280346393585205,
0.5368900299072266,
-0.828862190246582,
-0.6859999895095825,
0.1775500327348709,
-0.9070689082145691,
-0.520082950592041,
-0.09440063685178757,
-0.731056272983551,
0.25810813903808594,
0.6937282681465149,
-0.4621759057044983,
0.39240559935569763,
0.4236536920070648,
-0.7156766057014465,
0.6853295564651489,
-0.315300852060318,
0.5024734735488892,
-0.9507977962493896,
0.6113384366035461,
0.05850940942764282,
-0.2047484815120697,
-0.5956847667694092,
0.1948937624692917,
0.3656793236732483,
0.31730636954307556,
-0.5870873332023621,
0.3747181296348572,
-0.42702516913414,
0.05129917711019516,
-0.1956799328327179,
0.27489274740219116,
-0.03401188552379608,
0.33469143509864807,
0.3050554692745209,
1.048168420791626,
0.818401038646698,
-0.7033898234367371,
0.0776483342051506,
0.5899656414985657,
-0.3802567720413208,
0.7896940112113953,
-0.5009515285491943,
0.08181672543287277,
0.12823344767093658,
-0.07627526670694351,
-0.7831252217292786,
-0.6924018263816833,
0.2375606745481491,
-0.5223546028137207,
0.35979539155960083,
0.42218267917633057,
-0.5997971296310425,
-0.30441197752952576,
-0.4730439782142639,
0.3062610626220703,
0.10818963497877121,
-0.3003169000148773,
0.5625536441802979,
0.5264195203781128,
-0.17697466909885406,
-0.6276945471763611,
-0.5906150937080383,
0.26279962062835693,
-0.21636399626731873,
-0.299345999956131,
0.3831537961959839,
-0.056013405323028564,
-0.3309611678123474,
-0.04619218409061432,
0.14441858232021332,
-0.17615382373332977,
-0.21391750872135162,
-0.03240359574556351,
0.7550461888313293,
0.09169986844062805,
0.06916215270757675,
-0.11089007556438446,
-0.101939357817173,
-0.037376951426267624,
-0.03287649527192116,
0.34049755334854126,
-0.29578179121017456,
0.19090794026851654,
-0.6361167430877686,
0.3781968355178833,
0.4185248613357544,
-0.024299347773194313,
0.4972597658634186,
0.5651737451553345,
-0.1572025567293167,
-0.27485352754592896,
-0.36263415217399597,
-0.39630797505378723,
-0.447594553232193,
-0.08473262190818787,
-0.38035449385643005,
-0.6012555956840515,
0.43313342332839966,
0.12155164033174515,
0.20213404297828674,
0.34585902094841003,
0.7138047218322754,
-0.6430325508117676,
0.47449299693107605,
0.9422308802604675,
0.21992702782154083,
0.6057764291763306,
-0.2536372244358063,
-0.12653996050357819,
-0.8697677850723267,
-0.295797735452652,
-0.3381054401397705,
-0.12580926716327667,
-0.5418188571929932,
-0.41214215755462646,
0.13681147992610931,
-0.12997101247310638,
0.0780944675207138,
0.6101654767990112,
-0.563827633857727,
0.4482010006904602,
0.9435582160949707,
0.35779669880867004,
0.5383598804473877,
-0.10524359345436096,
-0.2074013203382492,
-0.019409947097301483,
-0.6989100575447083,
-0.9051903486251831,
1.554734706878662,
-0.010011068545281887,
0.31591230630874634,
-0.19663752615451813,
0.3615543842315674,
0.7520003914833069,
0.651125967502594,
-0.8532501459121704,
0.7249248623847961,
0.05680355057120323,
-0.9016814231872559,
-0.5410616993904114,
-0.131327286362648,
-1.2135448455810547,
0.17240041494369507,
-0.1313522756099701,
-0.9638556838035583,
0.4125449061393738,
0.02251802198588848,
-0.2721903622150421,
0.19320005178451538,
-0.7884963154792786,
1.2565478086471558,
-0.09738650918006897,
-0.5011744499206543,
-0.1894204467535019,
-1.043770670890808,
0.2433953732252121,
-0.38190945982933044,
0.0032673447858542204,
0.2584315240383148,
-0.437221497297287,
0.7101130485534668,
-0.3725852370262146,
0.8589907288551331,
0.2996235489845276,
0.15047982335090637,
0.7430638074874878,
0.06502263247966766,
-0.017802074551582336,
0.15167467296123505,
0.23842254281044006,
0.5611458420753479,
0.35804614424705505,
-0.7343565821647644,
-0.07055070251226425,
0.39898577332496643,
-0.6962561011314392,
-0.14490240812301636,
-0.9710502028465271,
-0.3829929828643799,
-0.04205068200826645,
0.5745862126350403,
0.4445151090621948,
0.10354022681713104,
-0.34987735748291016,
0.40363237261772156,
0.42450881004333496,
0.11902255564928055,
0.45776623487472534,
0.9521444439888,
-0.03774185851216316,
-0.41901618242263794,
0.7223235964775085,
0.07475816458463669,
0.2429456263780594,
0.4580334424972534,
-0.05490197613835335,
-0.19276610016822815,
-0.41752731800079346,
-0.4275776445865631,
0.31374385952949524,
-0.4488082826137543,
0.2027035504579544,
-0.4575059711933136,
0.2574019134044647,
-0.16994445025920868,
-0.3069681227207184,
-0.144109308719635,
0.09580232203006744,
-0.34877699613571167,
-0.18398742377758026,
0.0326274111866951,
0.06046219915151596,
-0.20040781795978546,
0.5673688650131226,
-0.2655155658721924,
0.6585854291915894,
0.2948850989341736,
0.33509671688079834,
-0.6956968307495117,
-0.11975942552089691,
-0.2078511267900467,
-0.28288859128952026,
-0.30552223324775696,
-1.060112714767456,
0.6349754333496094,
0.23530727624893188,
0.08601216226816177,
0.4507230520248413,
0.2950030565261841,
0.2570655047893524,
-0.48877832293510437,
0.6856411099433899,
-0.09136432409286499,
-0.846697986125946,
0.42487582564353943,
-0.3516874611377716,
0.4397718012332916,
0.973594605922699,
0.36533185839653015,
-0.19133929908275604,
-0.6723620891571045,
-0.5510231256484985,
-0.7534809112548828,
0.7585826516151428,
0.501832902431488,
-0.5215534567832947,
-0.07571691274642944,
0.13308550417423248,
0.548037052154541,
0.3641798496246338,
-0.4622836410999298,
-0.12025337666273117,
-0.22439906001091003,
-0.15735973417758942,
-0.1081218272447586,
-0.008407815359532833,
-0.16245560348033905,
-0.41529381275177,
0.683245837688446,
-0.3628806173801422,
0.1485545039176941,
0.579089879989624,
-0.29600760340690613,
-0.3184610903263092,
0.15020602941513062,
0.35972610116004944,
0.7833465337753296,
-0.5520048141479492,
0.14279860258102417,
0.09923803806304932,
-1.130906105041504,
-0.4563634693622589,
0.14847277104854584,
-0.7272112369537354,
0.03361906111240387,
0.3642694354057312,
0.5009877681732178,
0.2522379755973816,
-0.8621495366096497,
0.13105174899101257,
-0.07762081921100616,
-0.3333664834499359,
-0.5818935632705688,
-0.19791856408119202,
-0.39419451355934143,
0.01842024363577366,
0.5173642039299011,
-0.03745473176240921,
0.5891507267951965,
-0.489493727684021,
0.6108971834182739,
0.11403565108776093,
-0.1435556411743164,
-0.40557295083999634,
0.7020732164382935,
0.2761394679546356,
-0.07194028794765472,
0.3487508296966553,
-0.1410914957523346,
-0.2973996698856354,
0.5436321496963501,
-0.0342799611389637,
0.9452736973762512,
-0.1484508514404297,
0.7306210994720459,
0.45693835616111755,
0.472954124212265,
0.16194263100624084,
0.45447826385498047,
-0.35673022270202637,
-0.513229489326477,
-0.6480630040168762,
-0.5447688102722168,
-0.8474107384681702,
0.06897923350334167,
-0.7044358253479004,
0.5589901804924011,
-0.19676801562309265,
-0.39204248785972595,
0.3828374743461609,
0.07394155859947205,
-0.5413457155227661,
0.10619286447763443,
0.2639197111129761,
0.9184909462928772,
-0.6612736582756042,
0.9469423890113831,
0.6182982921600342,
-0.3119127154350281,
-0.4779607951641083,
0.14838117361068726,
-0.03706829622387886,
-0.38355278968811035,
0.3115186095237732,
0.1644531786441803,
-0.09287457913160324,
0.19621340930461884,
-0.5690760016441345,
-0.5782474279403687,
0.8947365283966064,
0.07260231673717499,
-0.6928139925003052,
0.0026361579075455666,
0.19736042618751526,
0.8620983362197876,
-0.15381589531898499,
0.1487266719341278,
0.723839521408081,
0.7417296767234802,
-0.16143685579299927,
-0.8538798689842224,
-0.33571091294288635,
-0.2219812422990799,
-0.6613301038742065,
0.2256973385810852,
-0.8376291394233704,
0.4782094359397888,
-0.10286619514226913,
-0.484419584274292,
-0.05326377600431442,
0.5649731755256653,
-0.24142423272132874,
0.6090629696846008,
0.354302316904068,
0.4059901535511017,
0.6822994947433472,
-0.18251091241836548,
1.1896659135818481,
-0.6837377548217773,
0.3693271577358246,
0.9036353230476379,
-0.2276800274848938,
1.0758700370788574,
0.6936952471733093,
-0.21055154502391815,
0.6392568349838257,
0.8773535490036011,
-0.15520788729190826,
0.6384825706481934,
-0.5156405568122864,
-0.2772192358970642,
-0.2348274439573288,
0.06738433241844177,
-0.14028945565223694,
0.30585694313049316,
0.2774028778076172,
-0.09549422562122345,
0.17312754690647125,
0.1927134245634079,
-0.23361705243587494,
-0.11984474956989288,
-0.18364883959293365,
0.6587482690811157,
0.07131185382604599,
-0.815669059753418,
0.36178016662597656,
-0.37976086139678955,
0.2039058357477188,
-0.7150453925132751,
0.20582634210586548,
0.10528307408094406,
0.24841082096099854,
-0.15614953637123108,
-1.118031620979309,
0.10116526484489441,
0.17784865200519562,
0.14704442024230957,
0.04713866859674454,
0.26168036460876465,
-0.36175352334976196,
-0.7736419439315796,
0.18405506014823914,
0.4884662628173828,
0.2702505886554718,
0.21818792819976807,
-0.3712843656539917,
-0.22745366394519806,
-0.24010628461837769,
-0.6431361436843872,
0.0852479487657547,
0.5433661937713623,
-0.14505058526992798,
0.7392377257347107,
0.7418707013130188,
0.1488763391971588,
0.03681787848472595,
0.2823980748653412,
0.552186906337738,
-0.6218264698982239,
-0.7190988659858704,
-0.6103687882423401,
0.5044373869895935,
-0.190397247672081,
-0.6066058874130249,
0.9809274673461914,
0.5419585704803467,
0.7756574749946594,
-0.33442071080207825,
0.4344557821750641,
-0.030992740765213966,
0.266437828540802,
-0.20358562469482422,
0.5139304995536804,
-0.4870184063911438,
-0.18711693584918976,
-0.46883225440979004,
-1.1606221199035645,
-0.5067994594573975,
0.6893939971923828,
-0.4010619521141052,
-0.47606196999549866,
1.2848279476165771,
0.27360472083091736,
0.09984949976205826,
0.09500337392091751,
0.0640198215842247,
0.001036632340401411,
-0.09362314641475677,
0.3312148153781891,
0.19429375231266022,
-0.1636486053466797,
0.369634211063385,
-0.5121864080429077,
-0.6967926025390625,
-0.3546943664550781,
-0.5135452151298523,
-1.0158687829971313,
-0.532307505607605,
-0.6109938621520996,
0.03989681974053383,
0.02383739873766899,
0.4816482663154602,
0.6548824310302734,
-1.037151575088501,
-0.3400923013687134,
-0.5498467087745667,
-0.43227872252464294,
-0.504501223564148,
-0.33654481172561646,
0.6381151080131531,
-0.37632352113723755,
-1.0801045894622803,
0.1354682743549347,
0.3872396945953369,
-0.1102059930562973,
-0.2867937386035919,
0.170781210064888,
-0.5349237322807312,
0.0631946474313736,
0.5674422979354858,
0.592448353767395,
-0.492337703704834,
-0.14275091886520386,
0.4750901460647583,
-0.21272388100624084,
0.13921479880809784,
0.583314836025238,
-0.5898193120956421,
0.9440659880638123,
0.4673989713191986,
0.21279031038284302,
0.7065649032592773,
0.1758049875497818,
0.47843092679977417,
-0.38559308648109436,
0.4028494656085968,
0.4606264531612396,
0.31813475489616394,
0.19843246042728424,
-0.29903584718704224,
0.771786630153656,
0.425558477640152,
-0.6968358159065247,
-0.956026017665863,
0.0015776276122778654,
-1.581600546836853,
-0.35360726714134216,
0.8967029452323914,
0.052605874836444855,
-0.7187185287475586,
-0.14831659197807312,
-0.603659987449646,
0.43017736077308655,
-0.5692630410194397,
1.2571799755096436,
1.1172707080841064,
-0.01092672348022461,
-0.23287218809127808,
-1.116082787513733,
0.40895456075668335,
0.4181883633136749,
-1.0627135038375854,
0.010901151224970818,
0.6002607941627502,
0.12416844069957733,
0.2496033012866974,
0.33464348316192627,
-0.14385700225830078,
0.48261988162994385,
0.27577778697013855,
0.376191645860672,
0.22074496746063232,
-0.6929613947868347,
0.31854307651519775,
0.307971328496933,
-0.4043690860271454,
-0.400983601808548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00891v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00891v1
|
A Regularization-based Transfer Learning Method for Information Extraction via Instructed Graph Decoder
| 2024-03-01T13:04:12 | 2024-03-01T13:04:12 |
Kedi Chen, Jie Zhou, Qin Chen, Shunyu Liu, Liang He
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Information extraction (IE) aims to extract complex structured information
from the text. Numerous datasets have been constructed for various IE tasks,
leading to time-consuming and labor-intensive data annotations. Nevertheless,
most prevailing methods focus on training task-specific models, while the
common knowledge among different IE tasks is not explicitly modeled. Moreover,
the same phrase may have inconsistent labels in different tasks, which poses a
big challenge for knowledge transfer using a unified model. In this study, we
propose a regularization-based transfer learning method for IE (TIE) via an
instructed graph decoder. Specifically, we first construct an instruction pool
for datasets from all well-known IE tasks, and then present an instructed graph
decoder, which decodes various complex structures into a graph uniformly based
on corresponding instructions. In this way, the common knowledge shared with
existing datasets can be learned and transferred to a new dataset with new
labels. Furthermore, to alleviate the label inconsistency problem among various
IE tasks, we introduce a task-specific regularization strategy, which does not
update the gradients of two tasks with 'opposite direction'. We conduct
extensive experiments on 12 datasets spanning four IE tasks, and the results
demonstrate the great advantages of our proposed method
|
[
0.07453463226556778,
-0.6889998912811279,
0.038266848772764206,
0.00838506780564785,
-0.30717700719833374,
0.13227063417434692,
-0.41367554664611816,
-0.5340738892555237,
0.08178211003541946,
0.1275327205657959,
-0.27216410636901855,
-0.6565135717391968,
-1.02577805519104,
0.27715060114860535,
-0.21848717331886292,
1.0132179260253906,
-0.40241822600364685,
-0.19041581451892853,
0.07597717642784119,
0.3108571171760559,
-0.721208393573761,
-0.0785880908370018,
-0.6021272540092468,
-0.1393503099679947,
0.3875458836555481,
0.6292654275894165,
-0.0995025783777237,
1.0005501508712769,
0.5213671922683716,
0.14912912249565125,
0.36999252438545227,
0.6185731887817383,
-0.9170078039169312,
-0.17655344307422638,
-0.2278248816728592,
-0.3754030764102936,
-0.09612500667572021,
0.10019087791442871,
0.404673308134079,
0.8013205528259277,
0.19863781332969666,
0.2987383306026459,
0.557307243347168,
0.5118405818939209,
-0.8372144103050232,
0.8486747145652771,
-0.6565096974372864,
-0.018467620015144348,
-0.030574407428503036,
-0.46448764204978943,
-0.7449138760566711,
-0.34860116243362427,
0.13267478346824646,
-1.1509348154067993,
0.13080835342407227,
0.07786941528320312,
1.1519526243209839,
0.17134179174900055,
-0.486772358417511,
-0.2762303650379181,
-0.7371802926063538,
0.6389180421829224,
-0.1893908679485321,
0.4023057818412781,
0.486508309841156,
0.024370821192860603,
0.1156793013215065,
-0.970371425151825,
-0.3022116422653198,
0.3430745601654053,
-0.3210488259792328,
0.3275783956050873,
-0.3370271921157837,
-0.0810946598649025,
0.06831217557191849,
-0.25033795833587646,
-0.5533587336540222,
0.02780047617852688,
-0.5331000089645386,
-0.08186487853527069,
0.31813567876815796,
-0.22455130517482758,
0.2069505751132965,
-0.0041205668821930885,
-0.6260744333267212,
-0.2128840535879135,
-0.29842841625213623,
0.33862170577049255,
-0.19930525124073029,
0.4192160964012146,
0.09239073097705841,
0.11524366587400436,
-0.12650899589061737,
0.7170597910881042,
0.42256560921669006,
-0.12014355510473251,
0.1623365730047226,
-0.0012162178754806519,
-0.28198614716529846,
0.31288865208625793,
0.7472360730171204,
0.3029841482639313,
0.5327996015548706,
-0.633364200592041,
0.08854024112224579,
-0.18459391593933105,
0.09250740706920624,
-0.7283371686935425,
-0.31298160552978516,
-0.22520342469215393,
-0.24574686586856842,
-0.059058528393507004,
0.4812023341655731,
-0.7130817174911499,
0.0540439635515213,
-0.29503268003463745,
0.23193898797035217,
-0.38594403862953186,
0.1840968281030655,
0.1639980971813202,
-0.04545532912015915,
0.23206892609596252,
0.45322901010513306,
-0.6501192450523376,
0.348861962556839,
0.42427462339401245,
0.6109935641288757,
-0.5287483334541321,
-0.3124694228172302,
-0.8584135174751282,
0.7077481150627136,
-0.2535504996776581,
0.7996432185173035,
-0.5345653295516968,
0.07473921775817871,
-0.11205841600894928,
0.39236634969711304,
-0.5665917992591858,
-0.08042127639055252,
0.24294090270996094,
-0.658298909664154,
0.05120199918746948,
0.009434211067855358,
-0.7063676118850708,
-0.4677984118461609,
0.3886944055557251,
-0.5128413438796997,
0.7873361706733704,
0.20107857882976532,
-0.9990530610084534,
0.11073897033929825,
-0.5104740858078003,
-0.6269793510437012,
0.1464371681213379,
-0.2540757656097412,
-0.17829447984695435,
-0.5674430727958679,
0.3104332685470581,
0.5099989771842957,
-0.25069814920425415,
0.19032391905784607,
-0.03328569233417511,
-0.6619145274162292,
-0.246198371052742,
-0.20083151757717133,
0.722801685333252,
0.008516750298440456,
-0.5062434077262878,
-0.24557265639305115,
-0.6091348528862,
-0.12036459147930145,
0.13748104870319366,
-0.4880990982055664,
-0.40910574793815613,
-0.3995695114135742,
-0.23362165689468384,
-0.07046075165271759,
0.3483787178993225,
-0.6211101412773132,
0.6561746001243591,
-0.08579627424478531,
0.12829960882663727,
0.9715651273727417,
0.2707354426383972,
0.41731560230255127,
-0.05217227339744568,
0.4001469314098358,
-0.177193745970726,
-0.08671421557664871,
0.16179849207401276,
-0.3505391776561737,
-0.6077238917350769,
-0.3934744596481323,
0.665159285068512,
1.165371060371399,
-0.770346462726593,
0.48579245805740356,
-0.5571091175079346,
-0.1820896714925766,
-0.5128567218780518,
0.07018938660621643,
0.3863152861595154,
0.9948291778564453,
0.5719146728515625,
-0.030652163550257683,
-0.38041070103645325,
-0.5181870460510254,
-0.20300063490867615,
0.1251354068517685,
-0.020814592018723488,
0.2920348644256592,
0.10522275418043137,
-0.155195951461792,
0.7526773810386658,
-0.8449234962463379,
-0.6345388293266296,
-0.10516759008169174,
0.46999508142471313,
0.019973203539848328,
0.6424462199211121,
0.2347974330186844,
-0.6738752722740173,
-0.7135881185531616,
0.43343546986579895,
-0.9558078050613403,
0.09835779666900635,
-0.40152493119239807,
-0.3234139382839203,
-0.4559068977832794,
0.5576328039169312,
-0.24298015236854553,
0.5553041696548462,
0.18331538140773773,
-0.08178306370973587,
0.15774764120578766,
-0.012225800193846226,
0.2197970300912857,
-1.185820460319519,
0.2291288822889328,
0.05761232227087021,
-0.49542275071144104,
-0.3762529194355011,
-0.3280743360519409,
0.0072293514385819435,
-0.06473344564437866,
-0.071200892329216,
0.47580698132514954,
-0.6592903733253479,
0.3114273250102997,
-0.13871699571609497,
0.2976725101470947,
0.35757648944854736,
0.8099384307861328,
-0.2990269660949707,
0.5556543469429016,
0.7479314208030701,
-0.6218880414962769,
0.43140026926994324,
0.5003108382225037,
0.14753535389900208,
0.2587185502052307,
-0.30867481231689453,
0.70075523853302,
-0.4119943380355835,
0.07461030036211014,
-0.9769245386123657,
0.024058494716882706,
0.5221095681190491,
-0.45188581943511963,
0.9550046920776367,
-0.44400861859321594,
-0.1388465017080307,
-0.09665793925523758,
-0.04113762825727463,
0.08687727153301239,
0.399587482213974,
-0.45376017689704895,
0.6707452535629272,
0.17828160524368286,
-0.3573608696460724,
-0.7491357326507568,
-0.4940433204174042,
-0.14382889866828918,
-0.06616281718015671,
-0.4978121817111969,
0.5172284841537476,
-0.0286243986338377,
0.2982616126537323,
0.3039397597312927,
-0.4069121778011322,
-0.5653733611106873,
0.2032887488603592,
-0.03293222561478615,
0.2149706482887268,
-0.05958964303135872,
0.03004392609000206,
0.3477860987186432,
-0.15780560672283173,
-0.2582760751247406,
-0.47453004121780396,
0.045876625925302505,
0.0636572316288948,
-0.014681622385978699,
-1.0002241134643555,
0.35510048270225525,
0.1194719523191452,
-0.39039942622184753,
0.5176939964294434,
0.7491558790206909,
-0.4977461099624634,
-0.035355571657419205,
-0.14988449215888977,
-0.24947428703308105,
-0.37693965435028076,
0.4478967785835266,
-0.5357041358947754,
-0.662283718585968,
0.22291211783885956,
-0.7241238355636597,
0.1945033073425293,
0.2663561999797821,
-0.2730962634086609,
-0.27325013279914856,
0.904137134552002,
0.9365077614784241,
-0.305970162153244,
0.6463232040405273,
-0.5779483914375305,
0.08603984862565994,
-0.80000901222229,
-0.35278207063674927,
-0.45461133122444153,
-0.3926202952861786,
0.011733004823327065,
-0.015565557405352592,
0.00790678896009922,
0.7003632187843323,
0.0017406139522790909,
0.37254828214645386,
-0.5677424669265747,
0.359514057636261,
0.35479533672332764,
0.47474586963653564,
0.2223069965839386,
0.48329421877861023,
0.12724798917770386,
0.16553282737731934,
-0.7688003778457642,
-0.21548402309417725,
0.9531745314598083,
0.01533628348261118,
0.7616175413131714,
-0.2399064153432846,
0.7791453003883362,
0.598694384098053,
0.3277953863143921,
-0.7238191366195679,
0.16074003279209137,
-0.31104594469070435,
0.44328612089157104,
-0.4081176519393921,
-0.5917584896087646,
-1.3876149654388428,
-0.13633623719215393,
-0.1477440893650055,
-0.9747101068496704,
0.5904603600502014,
-0.042224954813718796,
0.10245336592197418,
0.2095828652381897,
-0.6771901249885559,
0.6887432932853699,
0.25026389956474304,
-0.23738877475261688,
0.4205876886844635,
-0.7772823572158813,
-0.17121639847755432,
-0.008899515494704247,
0.25950488448143005,
0.13279299437999725,
0.24999399483203888,
1.0913782119750977,
0.0901855081319809,
0.8047624826431274,
-0.31648388504981995,
0.1427341252565384,
0.2075119912624359,
0.26655784249305725,
1.2987602949142456,
-0.25337734818458557,
-0.06316094845533371,
-0.021919241175055504,
-0.4175792634487152,
-0.39087867736816406,
-0.7850984930992126,
0.29123252630233765,
-0.7943557500839233,
-0.35032182931900024,
0.020218385383486748,
-0.6821385025978088,
-0.18340696394443512,
0.6340860724449158,
0.5326399207115173,
0.38746628165245056,
0.17069220542907715,
0.13035908341407776,
0.6283495426177979,
0.49465158581733704,
0.11596988141536713,
0.3133845925331116,
0.5510236620903015,
-0.26397451758384705,
1.1305574178695679,
0.20787076652050018,
-0.03933195024728775,
0.6024624109268188,
0.2359384149312973,
0.0496324859559536,
-0.40003931522369385,
-0.291515052318573,
0.04044733941555023,
-0.831651508808136,
-0.5432896018028259,
-0.7634375095367432,
-0.05259937420487404,
-0.5883688926696777,
-0.2694421708583832,
-0.25183621048927307,
-0.1622275412082672,
-0.5637551546096802,
-0.1675211787223816,
0.22836485505104065,
0.5808574557304382,
0.1770167350769043,
0.07344309240579605,
-0.811937153339386,
0.20821881294250488,
0.32895180583000183,
0.00112647726200521,
-0.20455719530582428,
-0.5457639694213867,
-0.25348377227783203,
0.035402894020080566,
0.008920867927372456,
-1.1151115894317627,
0.009206741116940975,
0.3578881323337555,
0.6313362717628479,
0.5129101276397705,
0.522508442401886,
0.6672734618186951,
-0.26955580711364746,
0.20814292132854462,
0.044832728803157806,
-0.7767853140830994,
0.4323577582836151,
-0.05109832435846329,
-0.19367247819900513,
0.5866826176643372,
0.6853924989700317,
-0.1612265706062317,
-0.23372633755207062,
-0.5039340257644653,
-0.7027797698974609,
0.8825162649154663,
0.18053875863552094,
-0.3129841089248657,
0.019669508561491966,
0.5357585549354553,
0.1394851803779602,
-0.038467906415462494,
-0.7701401710510254,
-0.35824498534202576,
-0.11682290583848953,
-0.42835861444473267,
0.369346559047699,
0.12874460220336914,
-0.12537403404712677,
-0.1378161609172821,
0.6785740256309509,
-0.4219660758972168,
0.2783445417881012,
0.5256859660148621,
-0.5272069573402405,
-0.030194168910384178,
0.1627754420042038,
0.1804392784833908,
0.6418116688728333,
-0.26426470279693604,
0.2145906537771225,
0.0021998987067490816,
-0.536465048789978,
0.15705537796020508,
0.49168604612350464,
-0.29572793841362,
0.008774740621447563,
0.45857518911361694,
0.8116973638534546,
-0.07199116796255112,
-0.11854460835456848,
0.8080893754959106,
0.0053442842327058315,
-0.1491231918334961,
0.34175926446914673,
-0.22302353382110596,
-0.23542846739292145,
0.026378313079476357,
0.4209645092487335,
0.13650941848754883,
0.2846657633781433,
-0.07459892332553864,
0.34255093336105347,
0.04041485860943794,
-0.6181409955024719,
-0.1486331671476364,
0.2910979688167572,
0.1312466561794281,
-0.14304736256599426,
0.8101689219474792,
-0.44888919591903687,
-0.3112618923187256,
0.5867400765419006,
0.9027554988861084,
0.7610266804695129,
-0.26170918345451355,
0.05944850295782089,
0.42287859320640564,
0.330623596906662,
0.11346939206123352,
0.12375544011592865,
-0.09310643374919891,
-0.5954549908638,
-0.5270761847496033,
-0.11816346645355225,
0.16678394377231598,
-0.07288143038749695,
-1.0648249387741089,
0.16771472990512848,
-0.18477661907672882,
0.20949263870716095,
-0.19249624013900757,
-0.2676602005958557,
-0.8471699357032776,
0.06046539172530174,
-0.10892791301012039,
0.7240106463432312,
-0.7892544269561768,
0.7896752953529358,
0.6274774074554443,
-0.24132874608039856,
-1.113826870918274,
0.11241505295038223,
-0.425069123506546,
-0.7264500260353088,
0.7897148728370667,
0.2558966875076294,
-0.23783114552497864,
0.47542092204093933,
-0.602482259273529,
-0.7277437448501587,
1.26875638961792,
0.6722621321678162,
-0.6584179401397705,
-0.38602009415626526,
-0.26966387033462524,
-0.07380875200033188,
-0.4727983772754669,
-0.1676425039768219,
0.14771494269371033,
0.5109742879867554,
0.08988088369369507,
-0.6110429167747498,
0.2292928397655487,
-0.27903300523757935,
-0.2608942985534668,
0.08130285143852234,
-0.5204969644546509,
0.6809459924697876,
-0.2001921832561493,
-0.5863662958145142,
-0.43470537662506104,
0.6273007988929749,
-0.2577510476112366,
0.09438629448413849,
0.4569900333881378,
0.06055784225463867,
1.1848591566085815,
0.20578809082508087,
0.8720828294754028,
-0.41385209560394287,
0.750674843788147,
1.2903302907943726,
-0.09689708054065704,
0.4823526442050934,
0.316384494304657,
0.07727489620447159,
0.5089529156684875,
0.5493036508560181,
-0.168984517455101,
0.6343528628349304,
0.12445378303527832,
0.03453989699482918,
-0.23589357733726501,
-0.31599780917167664,
-0.23217935860157013,
0.501234769821167,
0.24410709738731384,
-0.17508761584758759,
-0.46083182096481323,
0.20295126736164093,
0.13376083970069885,
-0.1312853842973709,
-0.30386751890182495,
1.139714241027832,
-0.2471802979707718,
-0.370797336101532,
0.7498980760574341,
-0.07048940658569336,
0.3117663860321045,
-0.6912105083465576,
-0.642828106880188,
-0.14592987298965454,
-0.09252046048641205,
-0.23120640218257904,
-0.4042235016822815,
-0.032655347138643265,
-0.11564597487449646,
-0.26044321060180664,
-0.1436600536108017,
0.9916583895683289,
-0.5689204335212708,
-0.22035010159015656,
0.30359897017478943,
0.22341565787792206,
0.3854491710662842,
0.0556473508477211,
-0.5665051937103271,
-0.21570536494255066,
0.4275246560573578,
-0.13271313905715942,
0.1022585928440094,
0.5452635884284973,
-0.06845296919345856,
0.2850725054740906,
0.6475281119346619,
0.13464535772800446,
0.1992328017950058,
-0.3883196711540222,
0.9248363375663757,
-0.32893136143684387,
-0.6891155242919922,
-0.4725293219089508,
0.3468421697616577,
-0.1080097034573555,
-0.011878455057740211,
0.5115135908126831,
0.5776734948158264,
0.781135618686676,
-0.06879010051488876,
0.9579368233680725,
0.006295449566096067,
0.10239512473344803,
-0.6722201108932495,
0.41942575573921204,
-0.1920347511768341,
0.082309789955616,
-0.3157716393470764,
-0.9189561605453491,
-0.15201877057552338,
0.6550920009613037,
-0.12930193543434143,
-0.31420689821243286,
0.7534715533256531,
0.34238240122795105,
-0.27225103974342346,
-0.21614083647727966,
0.006649119779467583,
0.16569127142429352,
0.29429149627685547,
0.7274739742279053,
0.23259839415550232,
-0.6002846956253052,
0.8012111783027649,
-0.13137339055538177,
-0.660182535648346,
-0.08867622911930084,
-0.7258361577987671,
-0.6477106213569641,
-0.3577011227607727,
-0.5780414938926697,
-0.3657543361186981,
0.409251868724823,
0.6565492749214172,
0.8732976913452148,
-0.5851886868476868,
0.12761126458644867,
-0.2355770468711853,
0.11959657818078995,
-0.5564786791801453,
-0.34183642268180847,
0.9984416961669922,
-0.3692072331905365,
-0.7406688928604126,
0.44713813066482544,
0.09382183849811554,
0.1207355409860611,
0.5258404016494751,
0.1968591809272766,
-0.5561971664428711,
-0.285013347864151,
0.23993198573589325,
0.45400291681289673,
-0.21370363235473633,
-0.5501278042793274,
-0.11719031631946564,
-0.17463631927967072,
0.38503941893577576,
0.6257357001304626,
-0.4860612154006958,
0.6788569688796997,
0.4221884310245514,
1.1457322835922241,
0.6891655921936035,
0.16833209991455078,
0.3604501783847809,
-1.1272246837615967,
0.1066524013876915,
-0.012857941910624504,
0.12865878641605377,
0.16409482061862946,
-0.9523013830184937,
0.5000163912773132,
0.4578065276145935,
-0.17782828211784363,
-0.459035187959671,
0.09483379870653152,
-1.1402078866958618,
-0.22104254364967346,
0.9305329322814941,
-0.824317216873169,
-0.2953047752380371,
-0.3456880748271942,
-0.15332575142383575,
0.7587825059890747,
-0.46695172786712646,
0.6418651342391968,
0.29255008697509766,
-0.27160418033599854,
0.008169552311301231,
-0.07563816010951996,
0.30790334939956665,
-0.14904047548770905,
-0.9718835949897766,
0.13101528584957123,
0.04644101858139038,
0.5830610990524292,
0.31734374165534973,
0.5284808278083801,
0.2508566379547119,
0.11536765098571777,
-0.07497313618659973,
0.21687310934066772,
-0.5661892294883728,
-0.6475295424461365,
-0.01496617216616869,
0.19143913686275482,
-0.32698607444763184,
-0.6451547741889954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00499v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00499v1
|
Do Zombies Understand? A Choose-Your-Own-Adventure Exploration of Machine Cognition
| 2024-03-01T12:42:47 | 2024-03-01T12:42:47 |
Ariel Goldstein, Gabriel Stanovsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances in LLMs have sparked a debate on whether they understand
text. In this position paper, we argue that opponents in this debate hold
different definitions for understanding, and particularly differ in their view
on the role of consciousness. To substantiate this claim, we propose a thought
experiment involving an open-source chatbot $Z$ which excels on every possible
benchmark, seemingly without subjective experience. We ask whether $Z$ is
capable of understanding, and show that different schools of thought within
seminal AI research seem to answer this question differently, uncovering their
terminological disagreement. Moving forward, we propose two distinct working
definitions for understanding which explicitly acknowledge the question of
consciousness, and draw connections with a rich literature in philosophy,
psychology and neuroscience.
|
[
-0.5013532042503357,
-0.620730459690094,
1.0546082258224487,
0.008398163132369518,
-0.3863614499568939,
0.16533125936985016,
-0.2603118121623993,
-0.7237733006477356,
0.31231746077537537,
0.31956157088279724,
-0.7042865753173828,
-0.13571935892105103,
-0.6119691133499146,
0.3370952606201172,
0.0033201167825609446,
0.7736550569534302,
0.06221630051732063,
0.00042427421431057155,
-0.5582895278930664,
-0.012610426172614098,
-0.25287923216819763,
-0.4853729009628296,
-0.8045241236686707,
-0.5501337647438049,
0.7687735557556152,
0.2414361983537674,
0.794526219367981,
0.326317697763443,
0.40063047409057617,
0.4094898998737335,
-0.050741150975227356,
-0.022976160049438477,
-0.46390193700790405,
-0.018121229484677315,
-0.13442263007164001,
-0.8877955079078674,
-0.08182574808597565,
-0.16217686235904694,
0.3483017385005951,
0.763843834400177,
0.18432946503162384,
-0.04523441195487976,
-0.1938793808221817,
0.5140973329544067,
-0.6535613536834717,
-0.08581361919641495,
-0.6924728751182556,
0.42197293043136597,
0.2183975726366043,
-0.04423093795776367,
-0.5569348335266113,
0.3080868422985077,
-0.04811129719018936,
-0.5029822587966919,
0.26718470454216003,
0.06102003529667854,
0.5287914872169495,
0.4534037113189697,
-0.39124542474746704,
-0.28849413990974426,
-0.6615346074104309,
0.4549812078475952,
-0.5239885449409485,
0.3119359016418457,
0.44661515951156616,
0.4453834295272827,
0.009458674117922783,
-0.47736042737960815,
-1.0629150867462158,
-0.03551917150616646,
0.07867302000522614,
0.6184999942779541,
-0.36100032925605774,
0.1429692804813385,
0.012681355699896812,
0.4843122363090515,
-0.4877297580242157,
0.26135575771331787,
-0.4321293830871582,
-0.17596282064914703,
0.6161643862724304,
-0.02429879643023014,
0.6066802740097046,
-0.33562004566192627,
-0.7739524841308594,
0.18609288334846497,
0.167339026927948,
0.11582231521606445,
0.3177553415298462,
-0.10514050722122192,
-0.26011279225349426,
0.6525357961654663,
0.017777571454644203,
0.9255419969558716,
-0.5547642707824707,
0.34326183795928955,
0.23628374934196472,
0.020181572064757347,
-0.7086370587348938,
-0.026913996785879135,
0.6463355422019958,
0.5961815714836121,
0.4258822500705719,
-0.6068649888038635,
-0.1407463103532791,
0.034845657646656036,
0.8005586862564087,
-0.23445521295070648,
-0.5262017250061035,
0.585361659526825,
-0.5492451786994934,
0.0874037817120552,
-0.19159984588623047,
-0.1962449848651886,
-0.622406542301178,
-0.25281617045402527,
0.49160370230674744,
-0.47885578870773315,
-0.36969855427742004,
0.5476688742637634,
-0.6776993274688721,
0.18822862207889557,
0.8198367357254028,
-0.6447982788085938,
0.037925250828266144,
0.6207870841026306,
1.081450343132019,
-0.36368274688720703,
-0.17468710243701935,
0.17187286913394928,
-0.03139317408204079,
-0.4391392469406128,
1.1243748664855957,
-0.4060472249984741,
-0.7167797088623047,
-0.41412353515625,
-0.10695666074752808,
-0.2398253083229065,
-0.2631528377532959,
0.3720315098762512,
-0.49550172686576843,
0.21041108667850494,
-0.204457625746727,
-0.4330511689186096,
-0.5506758689880371,
0.18516989052295685,
-0.23823614418506622,
0.24993814527988434,
-0.0132858632132411,
-0.5937454104423523,
0.21838858723640442,
-0.48154935240745544,
-0.03206871449947357,
0.3141205310821533,
-0.352803111076355,
0.38964617252349854,
0.3135305345058441,
-0.2444307804107666,
0.3042082190513611,
0.26154959201812744,
-0.27602601051330566,
-0.18703852593898773,
-0.3796771764755249,
0.7127341628074646,
-0.34480947256088257,
0.9035501480102539,
0.02520756982266903,
0.09350153058767319,
0.0037822595331817865,
-0.6439154148101807,
0.27093225717544556,
0.22550852596759796,
0.13018009066581726,
-0.4420413672924042,
0.397562175989151,
-0.24853964149951935,
0.17810291051864624,
0.3517412543296814,
-0.5916233062744141,
0.039609748870134354,
-0.5876127481460571,
0.7243052124977112,
0.9761582612991333,
-0.060439471155405045,
0.6186408996582031,
-0.4511685371398926,
0.29619377851486206,
0.050037842243909836,
0.03829875960946083,
-0.18802256882190704,
-0.6910507678985596,
-0.8579410314559937,
-0.10198729485273361,
-0.10794361680746078,
0.5789169073104858,
-0.4724675118923187,
0.3791811168193817,
0.08506432175636292,
-0.48854953050613403,
-0.7737368941307068,
0.00916320737451315,
0.14157648384571075,
0.7499375343322754,
0.601203203201294,
-0.3498533070087433,
-0.415690153837204,
-1.0916424989700317,
-0.20460635423660278,
-0.4351615607738495,
-0.4376518428325653,
0.6342127323150635,
0.4655435085296631,
-0.35608357191085815,
0.9281447529792786,
-0.5633646845817566,
0.08469624072313309,
-0.2963074743747711,
-0.02158130332827568,
-0.057834818959236145,
0.39368268847465515,
0.3905649483203888,
-0.7103806138038635,
0.10336216539144516,
0.06659440696239471,
-1.0219980478286743,
0.35138317942619324,
-0.32628414034843445,
-0.17300575971603394,
-0.5107042789459229,
0.311128705739975,
-0.4482190012931824,
0.5236387848854065,
0.31708836555480957,
-0.4246615171432495,
-0.12831845879554749,
-0.589168906211853,
0.03414035961031914,
-0.7775917053222656,
-0.4717727601528168,
-0.26670175790786743,
-0.15191249549388885,
-0.62797611951828,
-0.09437448531389236,
0.11341987550258636,
0.2807595729827881,
-0.4741736650466919,
0.3301897644996643,
-0.26960110664367676,
-0.5246321558952332,
-0.4641711711883545,
1.0585193634033203,
0.06774677336215973,
0.4409685730934143,
0.16442225873470306,
0.741975724697113,
0.37464797496795654,
-0.7937929034233093,
-0.048737864941358566,
0.4323095679283142,
-0.5429008603096008,
0.23626703023910522,
-0.6258512139320374,
0.7324522137641907,
-0.5984308123588562,
0.20716674625873566,
-1.4146084785461426,
-0.054321322590112686,
0.5205234289169312,
-0.8931570053100586,
-0.42096665501594543,
-0.03757580369710922,
-0.19472075998783112,
-0.2124226838350296,
0.1564950942993164,
0.09023455530405045,
0.6657121181488037,
-0.1002139151096344,
0.49705010652542114,
0.4058776795864105,
0.378998339176178,
-0.48775383830070496,
-1.14029860496521,
0.2504747211933136,
0.06734820455312729,
-0.4902459681034088,
0.26863405108451843,
-0.4601389169692993,
-1.1011985540390015,
-0.14326994121074677,
-0.15235856175422668,
-0.16046427190303802,
0.39973539113998413,
0.5003169775009155,
0.047766055911779404,
-0.23530730605125427,
0.430897980928421,
-0.06912888586521149,
-0.03843311220407486,
0.14846675097942352,
-0.3185817301273346,
0.4767414927482605,
0.262142151594162,
-0.36292514204978943,
-0.47375568747520447,
-0.012904801405966282,
0.2596111297607422,
-0.02461986616253853,
0.5152783989906311,
0.20037096738815308,
-0.18030007183551788,
-0.3380194306373596,
-0.2553102374076843,
0.17613987624645233,
-0.48350536823272705,
0.0431516058743,
-0.36999908089637756,
-0.6421772241592407,
0.6333876252174377,
0.13784392178058624,
0.15036863088607788,
0.5983441472053528,
0.6859672665596008,
-0.6442117094993591,
0.5367709994316101,
0.750914454460144,
0.388410747051239,
0.20724788308143616,
-0.06310843676328659,
0.1204221323132515,
-0.845888078212738,
-0.4721619486808777,
-0.4992886781692505,
-0.6128209233283997,
-0.29002925753593445,
-0.6276500225067139,
-0.010478891432285309,
0.098111093044281,
-0.13713453710079193,
0.11885906010866165,
-0.455698698759079,
0.4583737552165985,
-0.001791086862795055,
0.406621515750885,
0.3195347785949707,
-0.4811495542526245,
0.13483399152755737,
0.22638104856014252,
-0.5002605319023132,
-0.8273584842681885,
0.6483929753303528,
0.020665664225816727,
0.2846386134624481,
0.2036781758069992,
0.656327486038208,
0.5949834585189819,
0.10424941778182983,
-0.8981799483299255,
0.5945337414741516,
0.3366377651691437,
-0.5105717778205872,
-0.26551008224487305,
-0.06288798153400421,
-1.0489369630813599,
0.5944337844848633,
0.05852099880576134,
-1.006597638130188,
0.17026184499263763,
-0.24511176347732544,
-0.48245757818222046,
0.7511048913002014,
-1.1206300258636475,
0.6844377517700195,
-0.26224666833877563,
0.16381525993347168,
-0.3982820212841034,
-0.7355367541313171,
0.42456600069999695,
0.2340431660413742,
0.4804568290710449,
-0.4288249909877777,
-0.8205620050430298,
0.8406341075897217,
0.0022771316580474377,
0.7319337725639343,
0.12552328407764435,
-0.3537307381629944,
0.3515523076057434,
0.0689220130443573,
-0.28096669912338257,
0.34501421451568604,
-0.2511949837207794,
0.37366995215415955,
-0.20534667372703552,
-0.5690687894821167,
-0.7523870468139648,
0.20810766518115997,
-1.046557068824768,
-0.7799987196922302,
-0.27013644576072693,
-0.5345579385757446,
-0.10144644975662231,
0.19604294002056122,
0.2805326282978058,
-0.09421762079000473,
-0.342326819896698,
-0.08509011566638947,
0.7411758899688721,
-0.14883826673030853,
0.6946812868118286,
0.6330455541610718,
-0.1638149917125702,
-0.11506804823875427,
0.509205162525177,
-0.0605868399143219,
0.4913766086101532,
0.5284598469734192,
-0.01422806829214096,
0.12138067930936813,
-0.6309636831283569,
-0.6202136874198914,
-0.14346431195735931,
-1.139299988746643,
0.23507918417453766,
-1.2043280601501465,
-0.28533419966697693,
0.11817604303359985,
-0.41962575912475586,
0.01888304390013218,
-0.2639772593975067,
-0.5182362198829651,
-0.2835428714752197,
0.47847872972488403,
1.0158652067184448,
-0.05194482579827309,
0.4173338711261749,
-0.6468061804771423,
0.5241410732269287,
0.37838733196258545,
-0.025705106556415558,
0.29919639229774475,
-0.4295089542865753,
-0.13744856417179108,
0.28952527046203613,
0.01539626158773899,
-1.1791682243347168,
0.04662312567234039,
-0.19861774146556854,
0.6280417442321777,
0.5181522965431213,
0.10604609549045563,
0.42128387093544006,
-0.5910714864730835,
1.1574500799179077,
0.1879962831735611,
-1.0779211521148682,
0.6417968273162842,
0.05817039683461189,
0.16511794924736023,
0.5259582996368408,
0.37689727544784546,
-0.6587908267974854,
-0.4140753448009491,
-0.8886763453483582,
-0.3389531970024109,
0.4311825931072235,
0.3369333744049072,
0.4808868169784546,
-0.1766662299633026,
0.5268431901931763,
0.40934351086616516,
0.1161939948797226,
-0.5779984593391418,
-0.22716020047664642,
-0.04534357786178589,
0.20470136404037476,
-0.6725297570228577,
-0.003463400760665536,
-0.0007579089724458754,
-0.0251090656965971,
-0.07237356156110764,
0.05867522582411766,
0.5895798802375793,
0.5095085501670837,
-0.22811870276927948,
-0.12596052885055542,
0.07706854492425919,
0.5320227742195129,
0.9955936074256897,
0.03225969150662422,
0.4057295024394989,
0.20782537758350372,
-0.6956106424331665,
0.021589526906609535,
-0.6427181363105774,
-0.03858856111764908,
-0.03259442746639252,
0.5208941698074341,
0.7696616053581238,
0.17640741169452667,
-0.8101518154144287,
0.24968141317367554,
-0.30743587017059326,
-0.21233274042606354,
-0.3701665699481964,
0.7227412462234497,
0.1921984851360321,
0.38025254011154175,
0.3103671967983246,
0.6943355798721313,
0.07123877108097076,
-0.5659709572792053,
0.20041197538375854,
0.42762890458106995,
-0.5796937346458435,
-0.20982137322425842,
0.5156965851783752,
-0.007602924481034279,
-1.1167066097259521,
0.5552814602851868,
-0.06224066764116287,
-0.36912351846694946,
1.1566954851150513,
0.32156625390052795,
1.0022270679473877,
0.1628265380859375,
0.14896196126937866,
-0.04276414215564728,
0.6006975769996643,
0.3569783568382263,
0.5086112022399902,
-0.5999353528022766,
-1.3102867603302002,
-0.3139188587665558,
-0.2317403107881546,
-0.7897592186927795,
-0.11531195044517517,
-0.4301646649837494,
-0.029503237456083298,
-0.48217836022377014,
-0.1426086574792862,
0.29005756974220276,
-0.2781875729560852,
-0.6406069993972778,
0.31127798557281494,
0.2727702856063843,
1.027937650680542,
-0.3956274390220642,
0.624278724193573,
0.39802953600883484,
-0.6087203621864319,
-0.03505986928939819,
0.4994143545627594,
-0.2611585557460785,
-1.1510570049285889,
0.5783892273902893,
0.097939632833004,
-0.370850533246994,
0.142207533121109,
-0.6978176236152649,
-0.5470139980316162,
0.8249635696411133,
0.08532053232192993,
-0.29442158341407776,
-0.0845472663640976,
-0.7162875533103943,
0.40039554238319397,
-0.3556268513202667,
0.4177221953868866,
0.11165713518857956,
0.44508668780326843,
-0.25247982144355774,
-0.3853965997695923,
-0.5500980615615845,
-0.045696426182985306,
-0.24055692553520203,
-0.01240603532642126,
-0.8505370616912842,
0.7696319818496704,
-0.6493797302246094,
-0.2358846217393875,
-0.18003395199775696,
0.9382649660110474,
-0.5089191794395447,
0.7121191024780273,
0.5311092734336853,
0.3216648995876312,
0.9357398152351379,
0.20645099878311157,
0.892848789691925,
-0.14205065369606018,
0.07944007217884064,
1.0084081888198853,
-0.0652918666601181,
0.9145410656929016,
0.2910381257534027,
-0.4523579180240631,
0.6984551548957825,
1.0233993530273438,
0.3311600387096405,
0.3214244544506073,
0.3204057812690735,
-0.33039382100105286,
-0.6728945970535278,
0.45632609724998474,
-0.28327733278274536,
0.6144492626190186,
0.4949359595775604,
-0.3497048020362854,
-0.10931683331727982,
0.3046734631061554,
-0.318269819021225,
0.15816311538219452,
-0.37414273619651794,
1.1027028560638428,
0.21617509424686432,
-0.4400922656059265,
0.31270766258239746,
-0.15931712090969086,
0.33031612634658813,
-0.45897340774536133,
0.16833285987377167,
0.0643116906285286,
-0.16463373601436615,
-0.19872373342514038,
-1.0685696601867676,
0.16132351756095886,
-0.040944382548332214,
-0.10440333187580109,
-0.3895972669124603,
0.6132357120513916,
0.16348344087600708,
-0.20605234801769257,
0.40907377004623413,
0.9105495810508728,
0.6685917377471924,
0.3168807327747345,
-0.5817662477493286,
0.17496328055858612,
0.014582698233425617,
0.16274259984493256,
0.16664372384548187,
0.6453428268432617,
0.5538680553436279,
0.8440727591514587,
0.4124687612056732,
-0.2377629429101944,
-0.1814178228378296,
-0.3370814919471741,
0.6608833074569702,
-0.6317899227142334,
-0.4797760248184204,
-1.1829326152801514,
0.3625640273094177,
-0.1416531205177307,
-0.5393968224525452,
1.0006647109985352,
0.45342588424682617,
0.9904161691665649,
0.06869912892580032,
1.0325478315353394,
-0.08522353321313858,
0.05854056030511856,
-0.4276418387889862,
0.7701498866081238,
-0.6557314991950989,
-0.18268530070781708,
-0.04855205491185188,
-0.33865857124328613,
-0.07533390074968338,
0.8920323848724365,
-0.5634738802909851,
-0.07101676613092422,
0.42631226778030396,
0.07998843491077423,
0.1124940812587738,
0.6189272403717041,
0.6370635628700256,
0.18986430764198303,
-0.22494597733020782,
0.6727255582809448,
1.0107195377349854,
0.06211579591035843,
-0.012297945097088814,
0.04297584667801857,
-0.3191441595554352,
-0.020892487838864326,
-0.5166456699371338,
-1.0533076524734497,
-0.7426367998123169,
-0.18643328547477722,
-0.30651453137397766,
-0.006363996304571629,
0.8993074893951416,
0.32828739285469055,
-0.24722936749458313,
-0.25044378638267517,
-0.33588430285453796,
0.6700026988983154,
-0.27241554856300354,
-0.06326895952224731,
0.061465002596378326,
-0.8012756109237671,
-0.7824819684028625,
0.49995315074920654,
0.6398894190788269,
0.14896851778030396,
-0.5226432681083679,
0.11570186167955399,
-0.17383480072021484,
0.43016526103019714,
0.5353955626487732,
0.188993439078331,
-0.843895435333252,
-0.3946843147277832,
-0.04057373106479645,
-0.03728006035089493,
0.5663546323776245,
1.001853346824646,
-1.0419082641601562,
0.8450330495834351,
0.5362416505813599,
0.7825374603271484,
0.30582907795906067,
-0.3307391107082367,
0.44023624062538147,
0.09884506464004517,
0.2363676130771637,
0.4826471507549286,
0.1586456596851349,
0.086541548371315,
-0.5386328101158142,
0.42604681849479675,
0.25969618558883667,
-0.4468417167663574,
-0.5864835381507874,
0.520997941493988,
-1.114719271659851,
-0.68234783411026,
0.8770307302474976,
-0.009662674739956856,
-0.5383175015449524,
-0.4239952266216278,
-0.27566811442375183,
0.31809043884277344,
0.02798398584127426,
0.5411916971206665,
0.7767617106437683,
-0.4885982573032379,
-0.20538567006587982,
-1.1542655229568481,
0.4737820625305176,
0.1937623769044876,
-0.41909343004226685,
0.0007837395532988012,
0.12225545942783356,
-0.05755046755075455,
0.07242216169834137,
0.9721041917800903,
0.3793213963508606,
-0.08838989585638046,
0.04343963786959648,
-0.048986904323101044,
0.30810612440109253,
-0.007723108399659395,
-0.29501575231552124,
0.09587843716144562,
-0.07272572815418243,
-0.4459204375743866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00888v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00888v1
|
Margin Discrepancy-based Adversarial Training for Multi-Domain Text Classification
| 2024-03-01T11:54:14 | 2024-03-01T11:54:14 |
Yuan Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Multi-domain text classification (MDTC) endeavors to harness available
resources from correlated domains to enhance the classification accuracy of the
target domain. Presently, most MDTC approaches that embrace adversarial
training and the shared-private paradigm exhibit cutting-edge performance.
Unfortunately, these methods face a non-negligible challenge: the absence of
theoretical guarantees in the design of MDTC algorithms. The dearth of
theoretical underpinning poses a substantial impediment to the advancement of
MDTC algorithms. To tackle this problem, we first provide a theoretical
analysis of MDTC by decomposing the MDTC task into multiple domain adaptation
tasks. We incorporate the margin discrepancy as the measure of domain
divergence and establish a new generalization bound based on Rademacher
complexity. Subsequently, we propose a margin discrepancy-based adversarial
training (MDAT) approach for MDTC, in accordance with our theoretical analysis.
To validate the efficacy of the proposed MDAT method, we conduct empirical
studies on two MDTC benchmarks. The experimental results demonstrate that our
MDAT approach surpasses state-of-the-art baselines on both datasets.
|
[
-0.4681841731071472,
-0.7744550108909607,
0.4601495563983917,
-0.07370320707559586,
-0.016006076708436012,
0.48990413546562195,
-0.2682058811187744,
-0.24517764151096344,
-0.4192623496055603,
0.28582465648651123,
-0.642219603061676,
-0.5471081137657166,
-1.109647274017334,
-0.03399137780070305,
0.0882989913225174,
1.1147249937057495,
-0.41280344128608704,
-0.11804986000061035,
-0.030062852427363396,
-0.656494140625,
-0.44537684321403503,
-0.7648788690567017,
-0.42023468017578125,
-0.0706648975610733,
0.4199512302875519,
0.34423160552978516,
0.4902876317501068,
0.6371011734008789,
0.56584233045578,
0.2065155804157257,
0.07930159568786621,
0.781497061252594,
-0.1488979309797287,
-0.01680014096200466,
0.0395481176674366,
-0.3997782766819,
-0.26480066776275635,
0.18364711105823517,
0.3094674050807953,
0.33940786123275757,
-0.3260950446128845,
-0.3185271620750427,
0.37156111001968384,
0.9173334836959839,
-0.8403157591819763,
0.06753070652484894,
-0.4810970425605774,
-0.019169336184859276,
-0.2819742262363434,
-0.4084074795246124,
-0.7151437997817993,
-0.36456236243247986,
0.18243621289730072,
-0.7512266635894775,
0.7016472220420837,
-0.21153540909290314,
0.8043586611747742,
0.26057666540145874,
-0.9683539271354675,
-0.4528406262397766,
-0.8140993118286133,
0.872223973274231,
-0.3248337209224701,
0.39271408319473267,
0.2981426417827606,
0.3393650949001312,
-0.0039011910557746887,
-0.4954889118671417,
-0.34019458293914795,
0.09693325310945511,
0.2814626693725586,
0.23656973242759705,
-0.4312405288219452,
0.03471449017524719,
-0.052017975598573685,
0.33638662099838257,
-0.7218459248542786,
0.1269572377204895,
-0.1161346510052681,
-0.011482378467917442,
0.346829354763031,
0.03956712782382965,
0.04712150990962982,
0.45203930139541626,
-0.8011581301689148,
-0.4832037687301636,
-0.5619999170303345,
0.04232388362288475,
0.5562056303024292,
0.2804931700229645,
-0.02689484879374504,
0.12909995019435883,
0.12761756777763367,
0.3356785178184509,
0.21240881085395813,
0.0483870655298233,
0.1323433816432953,
-0.027407914400100708,
-0.11756722629070282,
-0.01435630489140749,
0.5904338359832764,
0.32356104254722595,
-0.041298869997262955,
0.02950158901512623,
0.023585529997944832,
0.16870270669460297,
0.5369649529457092,
-0.5822255611419678,
-0.2812231481075287,
0.0752979964017868,
-0.2937556505203247,
-0.35940489172935486,
0.2513032853603363,
-0.880579948425293,
-0.7658560872077942,
-0.27838242053985596,
0.34384384751319885,
-0.49598896503448486,
-0.35173729062080383,
0.1041199341416359,
-0.0572371743619442,
-0.4026959538459778,
0.42128294706344604,
-0.609197735786438,
0.3967806398868561,
0.5549217462539673,
0.9028276801109314,
-0.5142108798027039,
-0.34357234835624695,
-0.06443843990564346,
-0.006913107354193926,
-0.20195312798023224,
0.8757957816123962,
-0.283374547958374,
-0.40347081422805786,
0.09593959152698517,
-0.331145703792572,
-0.43833446502685547,
-0.40633919835090637,
0.8872036337852478,
-0.6466449499130249,
0.17197704315185547,
-0.21882040798664093,
-0.45737379789352417,
-0.5074671506881714,
0.4868065416812897,
-0.737799346446991,
0.5552121996879578,
-0.010872261598706245,
-1.2182228565216064,
0.4187402129173279,
-0.5580585598945618,
-0.5317150950431824,
-0.3526492118835449,
-0.0881262868642807,
-0.8855562806129456,
0.043501466512680054,
0.3973165452480316,
0.44101816415786743,
-0.22302381694316864,
0.10035284608602524,
-0.3251352906227112,
-0.22569993138313293,
0.5401079654693604,
-1.048721194267273,
0.7669597864151001,
0.22821658849716187,
-0.4336760640144348,
-0.14547087252140045,
-0.7911278605461121,
-0.06241058558225632,
0.019592350348830223,
-0.3552513122558594,
-0.6230894923210144,
-0.19201797246932983,
0.06433888524770737,
0.030809612944722176,
-0.08901789039373398,
-0.3080289661884308,
0.41456475853919983,
-0.20960205793380737,
0.18890680372714996,
0.9875361919403076,
0.11906542629003525,
0.4952024221420288,
-0.5146464109420776,
0.4616566002368927,
0.20393745601177216,
0.0059125227853655815,
0.278119295835495,
-0.2529030442237854,
-0.6244317889213562,
-0.5486381649971008,
0.5164300799369812,
0.5657080411911011,
-0.9805626273155212,
0.21898816525936127,
-0.11108153313398361,
-0.4613272547721863,
-0.25461921095848083,
-0.29140788316726685,
0.3975890874862671,
0.11998804658651352,
0.6722603440284729,
-0.20056629180908203,
-0.545904815196991,
-0.7130385637283325,
-0.27686503529548645,
0.04925190284848213,
0.286289244890213,
0.15066151320934296,
0.2746763527393341,
-0.24789300560951233,
0.6218773722648621,
-0.7466086745262146,
-0.7800284624099731,
-0.10020218789577484,
0.395163893699646,
-0.12149520218372345,
0.3649788796901703,
0.4563317596912384,
-1.0432182550430298,
-0.5396161675453186,
0.1802920401096344,
-0.6176825165748596,
0.4201000928878784,
-0.24898770451545715,
0.1234123632311821,
0.4519360661506653,
-0.04886624962091446,
-0.4769819974899292,
0.5832966566085815,
0.5957942605018616,
0.03644014522433281,
0.663905918598175,
-0.38115134835243225,
0.5004065632820129,
-0.8433979749679565,
-0.255135178565979,
0.25125810503959656,
0.13610661029815674,
-0.8737887144088745,
-0.03768443316221237,
0.3286776542663574,
0.23180070519447327,
-0.09572573751211166,
0.2512097954750061,
-0.4229097068309784,
0.5188549160957336,
-0.4669612646102905,
-0.1644614189863205,
0.13055731356143951,
0.6380664110183716,
-0.07068893313407898,
0.9041876792907715,
0.47452953457832336,
-0.9215271472930908,
-0.04066275805234909,
0.1633145958185196,
0.1850043684244156,
0.8259670734405518,
-0.09469597041606903,
0.13653549551963806,
0.23017194867134094,
0.5350502729415894,
-0.7720955610275269,
0.07992231100797653,
0.1808774471282959,
-0.6867185235023499,
0.592593789100647,
-0.1884927898645401,
-0.3251141607761383,
-0.2065950483083725,
-0.33343076705932617,
0.4852749705314636,
0.20369386672973633,
-0.8045710325241089,
0.6106033325195312,
0.34401723742485046,
0.16112393140792847,
-1.136325716972351,
-0.6983728408813477,
-0.057366251945495605,
-0.3727878928184509,
-0.3893715441226959,
0.37359917163848877,
0.038686640560626984,
0.011603901162743568,
-0.2708921432495117,
-0.41745585203170776,
-0.40626490116119385,
0.13440939784049988,
0.32560470700263977,
0.12500981986522675,
-0.10393471270799637,
0.004774824250489473,
0.23236720263957977,
-0.06847255676984787,
-0.0769810825586319,
-0.5557377338409424,
0.27121901512145996,
-0.15712502598762512,
-0.4326905310153961,
-0.4119740128517151,
0.2713123857975006,
0.47239255905151367,
-0.2532884180545807,
0.6630110144615173,
0.6327717304229736,
-0.2503220736980438,
-0.6080958247184753,
-0.4940001666545868,
0.21234650909900665,
-0.44784361124038696,
0.2044524848461151,
-0.5009041428565979,
-0.669089138507843,
0.27758553624153137,
-0.2846089005470276,
-0.14215077459812164,
0.5529153347015381,
0.3388945460319519,
0.2059892863035202,
0.9779525995254517,
0.7546206712722778,
0.2458219677209854,
0.19864186644554138,
-0.568417489528656,
0.01934177614748478,
-0.7567024230957031,
-0.015036116354167461,
-0.5352423787117004,
-0.006283009424805641,
-0.5624332427978516,
-0.22309920191764832,
0.09101559966802597,
-0.1806289106607437,
-0.2151518315076828,
0.5334861278533936,
-0.5956544280052185,
0.3554771840572357,
0.640228271484375,
0.28297436237335205,
0.29457369446754456,
0.2164633870124817,
-0.21660172939300537,
-0.21442995965480804,
-0.6489735841751099,
-0.2742783725261688,
1.1833380460739136,
0.2808154225349426,
0.6158719658851624,
0.3255953788757324,
0.5770675539970398,
0.5749059319496155,
0.3059590458869934,
-0.4347865879535675,
0.13242226839065552,
-0.49289318919181824,
-0.4144597351551056,
0.11694983392953873,
-0.6575369238853455,
-0.8150708675384521,
0.31508898735046387,
0.10626262426376343,
-0.2940472960472107,
0.5549253821372986,
-0.12680606544017792,
-0.025130348280072212,
0.7428877949714661,
-0.5869648456573486,
0.6610938310623169,
-0.06665433943271637,
-0.1540789157152176,
-0.2201102375984192,
-0.5423895716667175,
0.37347880005836487,
-0.252663254737854,
0.28713634610176086,
0.1475679874420166,
0.07239729166030884,
0.7719738483428955,
-0.1692579984664917,
0.7948074340820312,
-0.4681340157985687,
-0.16544696688652039,
0.21501797437667847,
0.2515529990196228,
0.5090093612670898,
-0.09217634052038193,
0.05978476256132126,
0.3670789897441864,
-0.16700197756290436,
-0.3751348555088043,
-0.5313491821289062,
0.6033180952072144,
-0.9896051287651062,
-0.3222658634185791,
-0.8753197193145752,
-0.5077165961265564,
-0.555277943611145,
0.06457077711820602,
0.42253759503364563,
0.4034181833267212,
-0.4077361524105072,
0.024173472076654434,
0.7594426870346069,
-0.12404075264930725,
0.24344077706336975,
0.4185084402561188,
0.6866444945335388,
-0.611595630645752,
0.9863643050193787,
0.08101735264062881,
0.22093772888183594,
0.6103737354278564,
0.04162992909550667,
-0.5235169529914856,
-0.8708121180534363,
-0.44381067156791687,
-0.16019679605960846,
-0.8317949175834656,
-0.5483008027076721,
-0.5862525701522827,
-0.2509014308452606,
-0.31432291865348816,
-0.21776358783245087,
-0.3164484202861786,
-0.4215738773345947,
-0.4187915325164795,
0.036178864538669586,
0.3180786669254303,
0.7391303181648254,
-0.18515455722808838,
0.38161590695381165,
-0.6925970911979675,
0.08046237379312515,
-0.020665308460593224,
0.31252729892730713,
0.10473565757274628,
-0.549587607383728,
-0.3568207025527954,
0.2922707200050354,
-0.8958202600479126,
-0.618539571762085,
0.27203553915023804,
0.08579874783754349,
0.5476926565170288,
0.3638080358505249,
0.4908089339733124,
0.4564019739627838,
-0.5374119281768799,
0.3667924106121063,
0.37600985169410706,
-0.809388279914856,
0.32848674058914185,
-0.18123625218868256,
-0.1615670621395111,
0.586076557636261,
0.4592839181423187,
-0.31799280643463135,
-0.31444451212882996,
-0.7642475366592407,
-0.5618563890457153,
0.5777602195739746,
0.28120487928390503,
-0.19782042503356934,
0.3106801509857178,
0.0449957400560379,
0.534752368927002,
0.0020982027053833008,
-0.49051180481910706,
-0.4011075794696808,
-0.2756299376487732,
-0.4509890675544739,
0.06585975736379623,
0.08895013481378555,
-0.26157641410827637,
0.2997276782989502,
0.7669166326522827,
-0.18110233545303345,
0.11952265352010727,
0.28024762868881226,
-0.2635413110256195,
0.10385308414697647,
0.4697440564632416,
0.8155069351196289,
0.6469992995262146,
-0.11624903976917267,
0.3369255065917969,
0.19492697715759277,
-0.8227598667144775,
0.6534736752510071,
0.5196859836578369,
0.07416711002588272,
-0.1439182609319687,
0.3261190354824066,
0.5606400966644287,
-0.3695972263813019,
-0.2130688577890396,
0.7714595794677734,
-0.5403306484222412,
-0.5429307818412781,
0.011328174732625484,
-0.15807324647903442,
-0.544526994228363,
0.29729488492012024,
0.7249030470848083,
0.925674319267273,
0.23688779771327972,
0.12701940536499023,
0.4921974241733551,
0.24636825919151306,
-0.5312665104866028,
-0.029499907046556473,
0.5183207392692566,
0.032243307679891586,
-0.07724782824516296,
0.10936856269836426,
-0.1827603429555893,
-0.733991801738739,
0.5926181077957153,
0.1965092122554779,
0.9456979632377625,
-0.3407090902328491,
0.354876309633255,
-0.0753440260887146,
0.29897451400756836,
-0.28800076246261597,
-0.5312811136245728,
-0.009497134946286678,
-0.5712643265724182,
-0.1908901035785675,
-0.1874065101146698,
-0.5856887102127075,
-0.08067434281110764,
-0.6938673853874207,
0.10669396072626114,
-0.46744006872177124,
-0.18717195093631744,
-0.06800969690084457,
0.33886831998825073,
-0.3988701403141022,
0.16066545248031616,
-0.15163086354732513,
0.6087381839752197,
-0.6680203080177307,
0.8411898016929626,
0.5211183428764343,
-0.36350882053375244,
-0.38295209407806396,
0.4125124216079712,
0.24887433648109436,
-0.52121502161026,
0.5356742143630981,
0.32098695635795593,
-0.40252912044525146,
-0.22821228206157684,
-0.07861270755529404,
-0.34561192989349365,
0.9287872910499573,
-0.06956833600997925,
-0.38291245698928833,
0.22548270225524902,
0.1814182996749878,
0.43387913703918457,
-0.16355091333389282,
-0.21025151014328003,
0.24943242967128754,
0.24861307442188263,
-0.08397288620471954,
-0.59859699010849,
0.22195537388324738,
0.10054051876068115,
-0.07090678066015244,
0.13761134445667267,
-0.5477842092514038,
0.8445397615432739,
-0.2483530044555664,
-0.5396230816841125,
-0.04952958971261978,
0.5248714089393616,
0.246694415807724,
0.6090301871299744,
0.5378687381744385,
0.5132290124893188,
0.8284900188446045,
-0.20224565267562866,
0.8626516461372375,
0.10558192431926727,
0.7390722036361694,
0.8945516347885132,
-0.3959123194217682,
0.5040531754493713,
0.10126296430826187,
-0.4102344512939453,
0.28538134694099426,
0.7227807641029358,
-0.07111998647451401,
0.6958375573158264,
0.10053745657205582,
-0.3904460370540619,
0.166351780295372,
0.18940547108650208,
-0.5683147311210632,
0.09209178388118744,
0.25762805342674255,
-0.015787245705723763,
-0.2101477086544037,
0.3613099157810211,
0.022318869829177856,
0.36052969098091125,
-0.01564386487007141,
0.6554375290870667,
0.06137091666460037,
-0.24678459763526917,
0.7067300081253052,
0.3318619728088379,
0.9058531522750854,
-0.41031715273857117,
0.07599479705095291,
-0.16221405565738678,
1.0296047925949097,
0.07426591217517853,
-0.6656829118728638,
0.20864078402519226,
-0.14169152081012726,
-0.1974305361509323,
-0.07933258265256882,
0.6712560653686523,
-0.2700740694999695,
-0.2725220322608948,
0.29086315631866455,
0.37630680203437805,
-0.47155988216400146,
-0.3645114004611969,
-0.7626526951789856,
-0.09560172259807587,
0.06336136162281036,
0.00952890794724226,
0.41326889395713806,
0.8313974142074585,
0.19005520641803741,
0.5543501377105713,
0.6302729249000549,
-0.06708338856697083,
-0.16599412262439728,
-0.08486029505729675,
0.7271161079406738,
-0.33026090264320374,
-0.5911094546318054,
-0.8915721774101257,
0.14797084033489227,
-0.030497068539261818,
-0.3871751129627228,
0.7428704500198364,
0.5012019276618958,
0.8113983869552612,
-0.13410183787345886,
1.0261709690093994,
0.14975127577781677,
0.5224899649620056,
-0.5613997578620911,
0.7065510153770447,
-0.5489394068717957,
0.27276861667633057,
-0.10698723793029785,
-0.6153742671012878,
-0.640741229057312,
0.3345547318458557,
-0.04570169746875763,
0.04257339984178543,
1.128253698348999,
0.4262921214103699,
-0.2653706967830658,
0.20376484096050262,
0.1734638214111328,
-0.01704566739499569,
0.5061666965484619,
0.6914598345756531,
0.9490496516227722,
-0.6987977027893066,
1.0054452419281006,
-0.24772223830223083,
-0.3985998332500458,
-0.22232884168624878,
-0.5081942677497864,
-0.9929726123809814,
-0.711006224155426,
-0.4015692174434662,
-0.6346738338470459,
0.5550679564476013,
0.5608038902282715,
0.7921916246414185,
-0.7962507605552673,
0.06699931621551514,
-0.1627608686685562,
0.08468036353588104,
-0.6593555212020874,
-0.231135293841362,
0.7897366285324097,
-0.18247663974761963,
-0.45667654275894165,
0.1915498524904251,
0.01833699829876423,
0.3508475124835968,
-0.05823609605431557,
-0.08139966428279877,
-0.26620835065841675,
-0.013795481063425541,
0.2701858580112457,
0.15771271288394928,
-0.5008581280708313,
-0.11507519334554672,
-0.11358149349689484,
-0.2908286154270172,
0.3880142569541931,
1.040905475616455,
-0.3378913700580597,
0.019865402951836586,
0.09332455694675446,
1.0711712837219238,
0.360158771276474,
0.08258451521396637,
0.41582849621772766,
-1.1164557933807373,
-0.13155119121074677,
0.14971457421779633,
0.07020597159862518,
0.32897043228149414,
-0.4707288146018982,
0.40544557571411133,
0.4046994149684906,
-0.5816807746887207,
-0.7979646325111389,
0.2179776430130005,
-0.9631089568138123,
-0.5966701507568359,
0.9340425133705139,
-0.2178376168012619,
0.03138747811317444,
-0.2157680243253708,
-0.40366965532302856,
0.2882240116596222,
-0.4339653551578522,
0.719779372215271,
0.8306516408920288,
-0.020032843574881554,
-0.05343339964747429,
-0.4227038621902466,
0.5349187850952148,
0.0769941583275795,
-0.7067682147026062,
0.5312162041664124,
0.222425177693367,
0.15657024085521698,
0.27737531065940857,
0.27639633417129517,
0.05924392491579056,
0.23967166244983673,
0.3237168788909912,
-0.06483745574951172,
-0.27106958627700806,
-0.5069111585617065,
-0.5167962908744812,
0.35981547832489014,
-0.13418592512607574,
-0.36750802397727966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00462v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00462v2
|
LUCID: LLM-Generated Utterances for Complex and Interesting Dialogues
| 2024-03-01T11:33:53 | 2024-05-03T16:57:07 |
Joe Stacey, Jianpeng Cheng, John Torr, Tristan Guigue, Joris Driesen, Alexandru Coca, Mark Gaynor, Anders Johannsen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Spurred by recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs), virtual
assistants are poised to take a leap forward in terms of their dialogue
capabilities. Yet a major bottleneck to achieving genuinely transformative
task-oriented dialogue capabilities remains the scarcity of high quality data.
Existing datasets, while impressive in scale, have limited domain coverage and
contain few genuinely challenging conversational phenomena; those which are
present are typically unlabelled, making it difficult to assess the strengths
and weaknesses of models without time-consuming and costly human evaluation.
Moreover, creating high quality dialogue data has until now required
considerable human input, limiting both the scale of these datasets and the
ability to rapidly bootstrap data for a new target domain. We aim to overcome
these issues with LUCID, a modularised and highly automated LLM-driven data
generation system that produces realistic, diverse and challenging dialogues.
We use LUCID to generate a seed dataset of 4,277 conversations across 100
intents to demonstrate its capabilities, with a human review finding
consistently high quality labels in the generated data.
|
[
-0.34349822998046875,
-0.7431251406669617,
0.5809692144393921,
0.04488702118396759,
-0.2157706767320633,
0.30733203887939453,
-0.13189968466758728,
-0.40345919132232666,
0.39722415804862976,
0.8460939526557922,
-0.5805189609527588,
-0.6580056548118591,
-0.23798498511314392,
0.10527455061674118,
-0.29240256547927856,
1.0437495708465576,
0.25848889350891113,
0.05813780054450035,
-0.47385174036026,
-0.10697437077760696,
-0.5326143503189087,
-0.5581179261207581,
-0.6062694191932678,
-0.1435227394104004,
0.3159118890762329,
0.8272811770439148,
0.5563284158706665,
0.2886316776275635,
0.22551943361759186,
0.30349910259246826,
0.0948869064450264,
0.792339563369751,
-0.8496218919754028,
0.613125741481781,
-0.03559093922376633,
-0.26939815282821655,
-0.6420843005180359,
-0.3456782102584839,
0.5996457934379578,
0.8233008980751038,
-0.18583175539970398,
-0.05665206536650658,
0.03760378807783127,
0.45969972014427185,
-0.09584224969148636,
0.1035727858543396,
-0.8310366868972778,
-0.18724267184734344,
-0.09172488749027252,
-0.16275987029075623,
-0.3909514248371124,
-0.07972496747970581,
0.12229377031326294,
-0.70088791847229,
0.07233978807926178,
0.156368687748909,
0.839363694190979,
0.2785913348197937,
-0.19608844816684723,
-0.36766117811203003,
-1.1170880794525146,
0.9012973308563232,
-0.6374201774597168,
-0.03326774388551712,
0.22998103499412537,
0.3135257065296173,
-0.3084733784198761,
-0.6953709721565247,
-0.6563605070114136,
-0.23438706994056702,
0.23265361785888672,
-0.12035401165485382,
-0.04023504629731178,
0.2983049154281616,
0.2619568407535553,
0.13499869406223297,
-0.2968266010284424,
0.11062072962522507,
-0.2400347739458084,
0.09245060384273529,
0.9803974628448486,
0.6862682700157166,
0.2990418076515198,
-0.2553679645061493,
-0.0919031947851181,
0.09868597984313965,
-0.594688355922699,
-0.13226480782032013,
0.4323155879974365,
0.21943886578083038,
0.025627639144659042,
0.5785559415817261,
-0.3399052917957306,
0.7135676145553589,
-0.11166604608297348,
-0.37017467617988586,
0.2138233184814453,
-0.7197532057762146,
-0.05462280660867691,
-0.001388234319165349,
0.8208032250404358,
0.5221595168113708,
0.331773042678833,
-0.0654866024851799,
-0.35323524475097656,
-0.4025493860244751,
0.378722220659256,
-0.864612340927124,
0.04998643696308136,
0.6105536818504333,
-0.028995361179113388,
-0.3013538718223572,
0.007735666818916798,
-0.4428989887237549,
-0.2543143928050995,
-0.45336490869522095,
-0.11704451590776443,
-0.28904473781585693,
-0.20867225527763367,
0.05676792562007904,
0.17243868112564087,
0.11000965535640717,
0.6650586724281311,
-0.8621422052383423,
0.3400026857852936,
0.7119495272636414,
0.6348668932914734,
-0.4220319092273712,
-0.022262541577219963,
-0.5688209533691406,
0.22573517262935638,
-0.3891594111919403,
0.7936031222343445,
-0.5910316705703735,
-0.6679919958114624,
-0.011207574978470802,
-0.1625215709209442,
0.1148700937628746,
-0.7405974268913269,
0.626754641532898,
-0.14126577973365784,
0.05354256182909012,
-0.1592179834842682,
-0.4716320335865021,
0.1353335827589035,
0.18547309935092926,
-0.4750922620296478,
0.7681294679641724,
0.22022351622581482,
-0.6221879124641418,
0.2740876376628876,
-0.5816811919212341,
-0.30855298042297363,
0.5281981825828552,
-0.6984021663665771,
-0.30522623658180237,
0.09524930268526077,
0.11471142619848251,
0.4399295151233673,
-0.6917794942855835,
0.5975366234779358,
-0.06205805391073227,
-0.3165771961212158,
0.5197954773902893,
-0.4658680558204651,
0.43084195256233215,
0.28210029006004333,
-0.24526502192020416,
0.36971771717071533,
-0.7939277291297913,
0.06089332327246666,
-0.05469947308301926,
0.0684615895152092,
-0.0727434977889061,
0.03006094880402088,
0.22621718049049377,
0.14056241512298584,
0.09320249408483505,
-0.6965001821517944,
0.4020690619945526,
-0.45116618275642395,
0.5543707609176636,
0.7244053483009338,
0.17822204530239105,
0.09257974475622177,
-0.5422511100769043,
0.6123183965682983,
0.18459925055503845,
0.09859539568424225,
-0.22871313989162445,
-0.6175604462623596,
-0.8224165439605713,
-0.37845084071159363,
0.1309356689453125,
0.5590587258338928,
-0.8427577018737793,
0.35906195640563965,
-0.6697204113006592,
-0.4051033556461334,
-0.8442911505699158,
0.37977612018585205,
0.25645560026168823,
0.34131959080696106,
-0.09069342911243439,
-0.35858669877052307,
-0.4650234580039978,
-1.0970115661621094,
0.3231746554374695,
-0.16859452426433563,
-0.2652477025985718,
1.021970272064209,
0.26075923442840576,
-0.43424031138420105,
1.1498141288757324,
-0.3759208023548126,
-0.19113701581954956,
-0.4674759805202484,
0.20039261877536774,
0.18122492730617523,
0.3899877071380615,
0.09271562844514847,
-0.910973072052002,
-0.3579067587852478,
0.06967611610889435,
-0.8701712489128113,
-0.18097108602523804,
-0.47757476568222046,
-0.06073624640703201,
0.10646890103816986,
0.2849275767803192,
-0.8595563769340515,
0.09973028302192688,
0.382718026638031,
-0.0315389484167099,
0.5322201251983643,
-0.20260222256183624,
0.21427424252033234,
-1.4788590669631958,
0.06306122243404388,
-0.41601380705833435,
-0.257977157831192,
-0.7345181703567505,
-0.5123215317726135,
-0.5480622053146362,
-0.3334354758262634,
-0.6146490573883057,
0.539880096912384,
-0.35340172052383423,
-0.3236997127532959,
-0.02395148202776909,
0.341192364692688,
-0.024468885734677315,
0.39390742778778076,
0.08535932749509811,
1.0157246589660645,
0.3146151900291443,
-0.40993180871009827,
0.5753451585769653,
0.5364229679107666,
-0.5219890475273132,
0.6250988245010376,
-0.8290744423866272,
0.25067394971847534,
0.020716749131679535,
0.243991881608963,
-1.0227793455123901,
-0.6125355958938599,
-0.04980989545583725,
-0.4019058346748352,
0.11860240250825882,
-0.05817054584622383,
-0.5025559663772583,
0.02183743752539158,
-0.1291942447423935,
0.6269060969352722,
0.48426321148872375,
-0.34476909041404724,
0.5302807092666626,
0.6208575963973999,
-0.6616151332855225,
-0.5646950006484985,
-0.29300954937934875,
0.5599103569984436,
-0.08860678225755692,
-0.8500169515609741,
0.39631664752960205,
-0.38937756419181824,
-0.502660870552063,
-0.2737079858779907,
0.281858891248703,
-0.014165119268000126,
-0.0824240893125534,
0.7483844757080078,
0.17790034413337708,
0.012088734656572342,
0.00553350942209363,
0.12090659886598587,
-0.11709464341402054,
0.035642318427562714,
-0.2268427461385727,
0.49807053804397583,
-0.09360680729150772,
-0.5557958483695984,
-0.674960732460022,
0.5433822274208069,
0.9812706708908081,
0.15442830324172974,
0.3976466655731201,
0.3860020339488983,
-0.23519080877304077,
-0.4021368622779846,
-0.6352746486663818,
-0.11906813085079193,
-0.44104763865470886,
0.1905556172132492,
-0.5645075440406799,
-0.8019102215766907,
0.35032597184181213,
-0.08942577242851257,
0.28382885456085205,
-0.09300102293491364,
0.5903247594833374,
-0.17993514239788055,
1.0383720397949219,
0.4331890642642975,
0.18323194980621338,
0.2173447459936142,
-0.17981764674186707,
0.2086016684770584,
-0.7818005681037903,
-0.33216017484664917,
-0.05348317697644234,
-0.10645367205142975,
-0.48717308044433594,
-0.6287747621536255,
0.5457924008369446,
-0.18243755400180817,
0.29469072818756104,
-0.013321975246071815,
-0.46868234872817993,
0.19281858205795288,
0.44578275084495544,
-0.0972275510430336,
0.34739577770233154,
0.09758643805980682,
0.22041848301887512,
-0.2325769066810608,
-0.7148629426956177,
-0.8242186307907104,
1.2415838241577148,
0.2032189965248108,
0.7076146602630615,
0.10985209792852402,
0.712554395198822,
0.48026835918426514,
0.30257561802864075,
-0.8100653290748596,
0.7963687777519226,
0.12775364518165588,
-0.3147168457508087,
-0.3855798840522766,
-0.46296849846839905,
-1.036007046699524,
-0.07842090725898743,
-0.28231924772262573,
-0.5370379686355591,
0.03608115762472153,
0.08005429059267044,
-0.5313209891319275,
0.12399732321500778,
-0.554834246635437,
0.6284717321395874,
-0.2768859565258026,
-0.5925045609474182,
-0.2414538562297821,
-0.5156116485595703,
0.4395017921924591,
-0.1213938444852829,
0.0850120335817337,
-0.28420284390449524,
0.037434209138154984,
0.537886381149292,
-0.5699500441551208,
0.8381065726280212,
0.04517725482583046,
-0.17087212204933167,
0.5269824266433716,
0.09828789532184601,
0.4064215421676636,
0.28306543827056885,
-0.06149546802043915,
0.11767075210809708,
-0.2037213146686554,
-0.49287837743759155,
-0.5220285058021545,
0.8766393065452576,
-0.6893764138221741,
-0.7064189910888672,
-0.09091179072856903,
-0.7986502647399902,
-0.36371317505836487,
-0.07074195146560669,
-0.01782558485865593,
0.4489445090293884,
-0.49025535583496094,
0.2729138731956482,
0.8575624227523804,
-0.25254836678504944,
0.12810871005058289,
0.3505741357803345,
-0.053881846368312836,
-0.42187270522117615,
1.189433217048645,
0.1864844560623169,
0.49192968010902405,
0.14436474442481995,
-0.23838134109973907,
-0.058003589510917664,
-0.6812291741371155,
-0.711135983467102,
0.2640150785446167,
-0.42290565371513367,
-0.11517293006181717,
-0.7479550838470459,
-0.3525508940219879,
-0.45838335156440735,
-0.20821350812911987,
-0.3844044506549835,
-0.4499431848526001,
-0.40364962816238403,
-0.18348906934261322,
0.23371334373950958,
0.9776289463043213,
0.062430087476968765,
0.0879722610116005,
-0.6838675737380981,
0.30859071016311646,
0.5404117703437805,
-0.020342985168099403,
-0.4520302414894104,
-0.37560418248176575,
-0.13093562424182892,
0.21899935603141785,
-0.09123285859823227,
-0.5385670065879822,
0.7171310782432556,
0.2507305443286896,
0.4382973313331604,
0.46146243810653687,
0.15055349469184875,
0.43111979961395264,
-0.37364259362220764,
1.0511679649353027,
-0.007919789291918278,
-0.6053032279014587,
0.5875284075737,
-0.47639915347099304,
0.10471359640359879,
0.5329803228378296,
0.2920094430446625,
-0.3138335645198822,
-0.3130432069301605,
-0.8867319226264954,
-0.9030221104621887,
0.6242355108261108,
0.3760615289211273,
0.24402488768100739,
0.05805187299847603,
0.40084341168403625,
0.25720903277397156,
0.42318907380104065,
-0.25284504890441895,
-0.03703197091817856,
-0.03232609108090401,
-0.2516423463821411,
-0.01645156554877758,
-0.5522284507751465,
-0.341885507106781,
-0.04808572307229042,
0.43230828642845154,
-0.20526382327079773,
0.054344214498996735,
0.22005543112754822,
0.06153775379061699,
-0.018647318705916405,
0.4000147581100464,
0.8013284802436829,
0.7219057679176331,
-0.1861725151538849,
-0.23093098402023315,
0.18911713361740112,
-0.26655152440071106,
0.032431408762931824,
-0.0945022851228714,
-0.18842309713363647,
0.2144082486629486,
0.20914994180202484,
0.8897092342376709,
0.11524734646081924,
-1.3160920143127441,
0.5252746939659119,
-0.3007659614086151,
-0.2595662474632263,
-0.5238197445869446,
0.27531346678733826,
0.04170568659901619,
-0.06468969583511353,
0.20090647041797638,
-0.25026729702949524,
0.1375143975019455,
-0.4347006380558014,
0.2877061665058136,
0.3941459059715271,
-0.1950969099998474,
-0.18425102531909943,
0.4418821930885315,
0.6933950781822205,
-0.49760669469833374,
0.8661900162696838,
-0.24230648577213287,
-0.05929740518331528,
0.3888883888721466,
0.19069935381412506,
0.9056742191314697,
-0.1888725459575653,
0.35321149230003357,
0.3014991879463196,
0.05145086348056793,
0.27850449085235596,
0.26681584119796753,
-0.44491490721702576,
-0.7748733162879944,
-0.27396032214164734,
-0.5858764052391052,
-0.8619208335876465,
0.3636139929294586,
-0.6019237041473389,
0.14248177409172058,
-0.4185258150100708,
-0.2050439566373825,
-0.004048880655318499,
-0.12814904749393463,
-0.49566563963890076,
0.01736438274383545,
0.13979725539684296,
0.46039730310440063,
-0.6685492396354675,
0.9245893955230713,
0.27417439222335815,
-0.32700493931770325,
-0.49653172492980957,
-0.3364388644695282,
-0.19505080580711365,
-0.7761278748512268,
0.8338510394096375,
0.07427023351192474,
-0.3705780804157257,
0.06799431145191193,
-0.6310349702835083,
-0.5090881586074829,
1.1276423931121826,
0.4150863587856293,
-0.8425304889678955,
-0.21197262406349182,
0.3913734555244446,
0.5564106106758118,
-0.802703320980072,
0.35145407915115356,
0.5370835065841675,
0.1987345814704895,
0.3011940121650696,
-0.9956476092338562,
-0.28090840578079224,
-0.4379357099533081,
0.04320737347006798,
-0.2185945063829422,
-0.46592479944229126,
0.5747179388999939,
-0.4412301480770111,
-0.3380107581615448,
0.08486346900463104,
0.601837694644928,
0.24088451266288757,
0.18532022833824158,
0.5496713519096375,
0.39879781007766724,
0.630682110786438,
-0.04111102223396301,
0.8847116231918335,
-0.4961603283882141,
-0.21614010632038116,
1.1857391595840454,
-0.5649458765983582,
0.8493765592575073,
0.4928230047225952,
0.27666422724723816,
0.45776310563087463,
0.5298665761947632,
0.2168193906545639,
-0.028019428253173828,
0.3803626298904419,
-0.6955782771110535,
-0.5570391416549683,
-0.7478169798851013,
0.059766367077827454,
0.30482983589172363,
0.9511969089508057,
-0.12782365083694458,
0.27455341815948486,
0.21767985820770264,
-0.28332412242889404,
0.19434800744056702,
0.11695024371147156,
1.166927695274353,
0.039174117147922516,
-0.88523930311203,
0.8600807785987854,
-0.3493427634239197,
0.46776652336120605,
-0.5436900854110718,
-0.42700234055519104,
-0.3516990840435028,
-0.13842643797397614,
-0.27126142382621765,
-0.7909175157546997,
0.03745301812887192,
0.13148505985736847,
-0.0005747634568251669,
-0.5750854015350342,
0.4091804325580597,
-0.7029489278793335,
-0.26565295457839966,
0.05833495035767555,
0.5573143362998962,
0.6209191679954529,
0.2528115510940552,
-0.6701545715332031,
0.41220715641975403,
0.18199612200260162,
-0.17066599428653717,
0.10043644160032272,
0.5239933729171753,
-0.021910523995757103,
1.0425968170166016,
0.5856227874755859,
0.14976206421852112,
-0.22028663754463196,
0.18218371272087097,
0.9674124121665955,
-0.5529199838638306,
-0.16146297752857208,
-0.21736793220043182,
0.651716947555542,
-0.39488181471824646,
-0.3670662045478821,
0.5672370791435242,
0.6143878698348999,
0.6740832328796387,
0.1821848750114441,
0.9558249711990356,
0.15177281200885773,
0.5604739189147949,
-0.48074570298194885,
0.42109471559524536,
-0.29730984568595886,
0.5565750598907471,
-0.05605664104223251,
-0.6574867367744446,
0.10758019238710403,
0.4010690748691559,
-0.12985429167747498,
-0.11886148154735565,
0.28264614939689636,
1.057806372642517,
0.023715268820524216,
-0.109226293861866,
0.7556992769241333,
0.4183512032032013,
0.6676093339920044,
0.7161552309989929,
0.9177888631820679,
-0.15621349215507507,
0.5693541169166565,
0.09762245416641235,
-0.15722724795341492,
-0.4299774169921875,
-0.5544366240501404,
-0.8867968916893005,
-0.8494767546653748,
-0.2622159421443939,
-0.4000791013240814,
0.13385994732379913,
1.0858335494995117,
0.9897668957710266,
-0.6448963284492493,
-0.45003440976142883,
-0.2239464819431305,
0.1406107395887375,
0.2025591880083084,
-0.2290520966053009,
-0.007120685651898384,
-0.4051676094532013,
-1.0972167253494263,
0.7321609258651733,
0.3831355571746826,
0.2117471694946289,
-0.5691393613815308,
-0.17062050104141235,
0.2506692409515381,
0.2948210835456848,
0.5761477947235107,
0.3332141041755676,
-0.7408954501152039,
-0.108793243765831,
-0.2165164351463318,
-0.28839147090911865,
0.035292040556669235,
0.8622910976409912,
-0.6686898469924927,
0.7879481315612793,
0.28290167450904846,
0.8713762164115906,
0.5774487853050232,
0.07770231366157532,
0.9466400742530823,
-0.67896968126297,
0.08615842461585999,
0.538224458694458,
0.05216304957866669,
0.5226897597312927,
-0.3916390538215637,
0.3176141679286957,
0.22549520432949066,
-0.5911977291107178,
-1.15639066696167,
0.36756059527397156,
-1.2897365093231201,
-0.09173504263162613,
1.2050869464874268,
-0.11893071979284286,
-0.1402687132358551,
-0.3339720368385315,
-0.5918809771537781,
-0.24989956617355347,
-0.5037021636962891,
0.7143020033836365,
0.5592426061630249,
-0.5401206016540527,
-0.02155853807926178,
-0.6913204789161682,
0.8367041349411011,
0.541689395904541,
-1.1088706254959106,
0.367098867893219,
0.6838182806968689,
0.08381284028291702,
0.15260499715805054,
0.7984327077865601,
0.22632785141468048,
0.14566555619239807,
0.12299752235412598,
0.07857780158519745,
-0.09834606945514679,
-0.5526294112205505,
-0.06060781702399254,
0.28611889481544495,
0.24247440695762634,
-0.02577073499560356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00887v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00887v1
|
SEGAA: A Unified Approach to Predicting Age, Gender, and Emotion in Speech
| 2024-03-01T11:28:37 | 2024-03-01T11:28:37 |
Aron R, Indra Sigicharla, Chirag Periwal, Mohanaprasad K, Nithya Darisini P S, Sourabh Tiwari, Shivani Arora
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
The interpretation of human voices holds importance across various
applications. This study ventures into predicting age, gender, and emotion from
vocal cues, a field with vast applications. Voice analysis tech advancements
span domains, from improving customer interactions to enhancing healthcare and
retail experiences. Discerning emotions aids mental health, while age and
gender detection are vital in various contexts. Exploring deep learning models
for these predictions involves comparing single, multi-output, and sequential
models highlighted in this paper. Sourcing suitable data posed challenges,
resulting in the amalgamation of the CREMA-D and EMO-DB datasets. Prior work
showed promise in individual predictions, but limited research considered all
three variables simultaneously. This paper identifies flaws in an individual
model approach and advocates for our novel multi-output learning architecture
Speech-based Emotion Gender and Age Analysis (SEGAA) model. The experiments
suggest that Multi-output models perform comparably to individual models,
efficiently capturing the intricate relationships between variables and speech
inputs, all while achieving improved runtime.
|
[
-0.33716893196105957,
-0.4670380651950836,
0.592261791229248,
0.23930105566978455,
0.02465660497546196,
0.14009703695774078,
0.1686546802520752,
-0.4191335141658783,
-0.15142488479614258,
0.3566095232963562,
-1.0646867752075195,
-0.5780526995658875,
-0.6069782972335815,
-0.09720250964164734,
-0.12095855176448822,
0.4212491512298584,
0.5046125650405884,
0.4830630421638489,
0.09094201028347015,
-0.017792094498872757,
-0.8110820055007935,
-0.537150502204895,
-0.9788699746131897,
-0.2794674336910248,
0.5046558380126953,
0.595593273639679,
0.301663339138031,
0.10480035096406937,
0.01995946653187275,
0.37819185853004456,
-0.002555068349465728,
0.06311769783496857,
-0.2817050516605377,
0.4327206313610077,
0.392404168844223,
-0.42352962493896484,
-0.4830895960330963,
0.16565629839897156,
0.40104109048843384,
0.836799144744873,
-0.3594070076942444,
0.012436301447451115,
-0.15835776925086975,
1.0086320638656616,
-0.5853245258331299,
0.4074040651321411,
-0.5703315734863281,
0.3637377619743347,
-0.009962250478565693,
-0.009212261997163296,
-0.32630714774131775,
-0.38722455501556396,
0.35404786467552185,
-0.2547185719013214,
0.17700950801372528,
-0.33994150161743164,
0.34616830945014954,
0.3514866232872009,
-0.6509785652160645,
-0.39062100648880005,
-0.8706508874893188,
0.6269862651824951,
-0.9235029220581055,
0.4533326327800751,
0.0954589694738388,
0.4933590590953827,
0.06216134503483772,
-0.4514237940311432,
-0.32835158705711365,
-0.07952389121055603,
0.27983275055885315,
0.41306033730506897,
-0.49560874700546265,
-0.04724367335438728,
-0.10141972452402115,
0.044529661536216736,
-0.38462305068969727,
0.33755263686180115,
-0.638702929019928,
0.36451706290245056,
0.5682680010795593,
0.19826066493988037,
0.4839043617248535,
-0.24043580889701843,
-0.24514129757881165,
-0.25916939973831177,
-0.44739803671836853,
0.10244899243116379,
0.6846998333930969,
0.6459064483642578,
-0.22738873958587646,
0.35270991921424866,
-0.12148602306842804,
0.1311381459236145,
0.3708116412162781,
0.26865309476852417,
0.29037582874298096,
0.2701452672481537,
-0.39099016785621643,
0.4502931535243988,
0.9412091374397278,
-0.14991898834705353,
0.12227360904216766,
-0.06900832056999207,
0.35000181198120117,
0.10856229066848755,
0.4983585476875305,
-0.8180272579193115,
0.038380641490221024,
0.5055326819419861,
-0.6211555600166321,
-0.36466464400291443,
0.1253529042005539,
-1.3699448108673096,
-0.7619589567184448,
-0.5348251461982727,
-0.010888206772506237,
-0.39610716700553894,
-0.3407215476036072,
0.06009477749466896,
0.0930141881108284,
-0.2856890559196472,
0.23024453222751617,
-0.8154656887054443,
0.25207817554473877,
0.5966960191726685,
0.4908320903778076,
0.10429742932319641,
-0.058636508882045746,
-0.32836735248565674,
-0.21468952298164368,
-0.4618603587150574,
0.44450944662094116,
-0.7127857804298401,
-0.29040294885635376,
-0.07963000237941742,
-0.25022250413894653,
-0.14956936240196228,
-0.412091463804245,
0.6214169859886169,
-0.2295563817024231,
0.39027467370033264,
-0.0018491788068786263,
-0.40022012591362,
-0.5433333516120911,
-0.6823691725730896,
-0.7978217601776123,
0.4690244495868683,
0.014076649211347103,
-0.4420037269592285,
0.5629942417144775,
-0.7963594794273376,
-0.15324118733406067,
-0.09843317419290543,
-0.19273602962493896,
-0.4786943197250366,
0.6223747730255127,
0.3543577492237091,
0.6824902892112732,
-0.4013494551181793,
0.6874797940254211,
-0.710613489151001,
-0.23411984741687775,
0.37512412667274475,
-0.5701169371604919,
0.5709375739097595,
0.37972140312194824,
-0.3630676865577698,
0.20097056031227112,
-0.8719267845153809,
-0.14597417414188385,
0.08747319877147675,
0.11218972504138947,
-0.07536769658327103,
0.23777057230472565,
-0.21846820414066315,
0.2926296889781952,
-0.019840463995933533,
-0.4617367088794708,
-0.09957954287528992,
-0.21632088720798492,
0.3156989514827728,
0.6974793076515198,
-0.2665017545223236,
0.39980995655059814,
0.22070425748825073,
0.7911994457244873,
0.3216077983379364,
0.2149723917245865,
0.033135976642370224,
-0.5137187838554382,
-0.2843656837940216,
-0.2049100548028946,
0.09480224549770355,
0.44882839918136597,
-0.12148766964673996,
0.37185823917388916,
0.04009917750954628,
-0.8825597763061523,
-0.8136398792266846,
-0.09076722711324692,
0.1342555582523346,
0.3010229766368866,
0.061917051672935486,
-0.3552674353122711,
-0.9465885758399963,
-0.8008371591567993,
-0.17535048723220825,
-0.3446294665336609,
-0.04954570531845093,
0.5754256248474121,
-0.045501142740249634,
-0.2757568061351776,
0.6436142921447754,
-0.3700859248638153,
-0.35445117950439453,
-0.16065944731235504,
0.71245276927948,
0.15117275714874268,
0.3444215655326843,
0.4966491758823395,
-0.5963490009307861,
-0.13513681292533875,
-0.06950023770332336,
-0.7295895218849182,
-0.2645814120769501,
-0.014048328623175621,
0.07706062495708466,
-0.03881654143333435,
0.08460252732038498,
-0.37248557806015015,
0.35265105962753296,
0.7755674123764038,
-0.2864265441894531,
0.34322333335876465,
-0.028188396245241165,
0.4437357485294342,
-0.8500589728355408,
-0.10864348709583282,
0.29957115650177,
0.2779245674610138,
-0.781518280506134,
-0.546555757522583,
-0.047811876982450485,
-0.6093404293060303,
-0.4243968725204468,
-0.016579627990722656,
-0.27488359808921814,
-0.4296153783798218,
-0.3459508717060089,
-0.21241545677185059,
-0.15880151093006134,
0.5150713324546814,
-0.021194303408265114,
0.726204514503479,
0.47856009006500244,
-0.429908812046051,
0.31999292969703674,
0.10680059343576431,
-0.14724336564540863,
0.6340963840484619,
-0.5507745742797852,
0.5932087898254395,
-0.5010387897491455,
0.23149609565734863,
-1.133461594581604,
-0.09743919968605042,
0.07912629097700119,
-0.7842199802398682,
0.5140280723571777,
-0.0632442906498909,
0.0366077683866024,
-0.2679968774318695,
-0.15007881820201874,
0.11649547517299652,
0.4406435489654541,
-0.41432124376296997,
1.1052011251449585,
0.553864598274231,
-0.47696447372436523,
-0.6580033898353577,
-0.2620090842247009,
0.08274742215871811,
-0.5812478065490723,
-0.5876240730285645,
0.05370811000466347,
0.053729668259620667,
-0.11101239174604416,
-0.08110751211643219,
-0.10392817109823227,
-0.3833548128604889,
0.385429322719574,
0.6905652284622192,
0.2444518506526947,
-0.4019809067249298,
0.2461247444152832,
0.25749075412750244,
-0.17494192719459534,
0.3119162619113922,
0.20658311247825623,
0.5125395059585571,
-0.19938579201698303,
0.015603589825332165,
-0.6298012733459473,
0.735079288482666,
0.8250120282173157,
-0.029282625764608383,
0.6656313538551331,
0.9629228115081787,
-0.40061208605766296,
-0.09161344915628433,
-0.32466578483581543,
0.021517420187592506,
-0.40986743569374084,
0.48718181252479553,
-0.40084972977638245,
-0.48761919140815735,
0.4420344829559326,
-0.32999667525291443,
-0.24581106007099152,
0.6756336092948914,
0.5405470132827759,
-0.38008490204811096,
1.5984909534454346,
0.5655340552330017,
-0.1568087488412857,
0.5229998230934143,
-0.14459075033664703,
-0.0013322483282536268,
-0.904782772064209,
-0.31334686279296875,
-0.8948638439178467,
-0.3047449290752411,
-0.4639396369457245,
-0.054490912705659866,
0.1648247390985489,
-0.1721186488866806,
-0.5591003894805908,
0.0016138397622853518,
-0.38403648138046265,
-0.1443527787923813,
0.4668741226196289,
-0.062057528644800186,
-0.06578432768583298,
-0.21787048876285553,
0.27175283432006836,
-0.30246490240097046,
-0.5262100100517273,
-0.5204926133155823,
0.9434201121330261,
0.5160089135169983,
0.8677287697792053,
0.19424979388713837,
0.5125916004180908,
0.36539700627326965,
0.24530409276485443,
-0.6539283394813538,
0.21874384582042694,
-0.7890774607658386,
-0.6354018449783325,
-0.16089588403701782,
-0.7304849624633789,
-1.1455618143081665,
0.3421291708946228,
-0.1681588888168335,
-1.0210049152374268,
0.6808745265007019,
-0.17499200999736786,
-0.5009867548942566,
0.2531147003173828,
-0.8674643635749817,
0.7878405451774597,
-0.39451953768730164,
-0.026449380442500114,
-0.2111848145723343,
-0.5988813638687134,
0.7207022309303284,
-0.15190620720386505,
0.20084281265735626,
-0.5952980518341064,
0.13690240681171417,
0.8182992935180664,
0.18421514332294464,
1.1550185680389404,
-0.3142891526222229,
-0.2003975808620453,
-0.07693137228488922,
0.06119535490870476,
-0.24204514920711517,
-0.06543642282485962,
-0.08618815988302231,
0.40382349491119385,
-0.03456614166498184,
0.13440607488155365,
-0.5879855751991272,
0.7409473061561584,
-1.17290461063385,
-0.26274049282073975,
-0.4576508402824402,
-0.5987908244132996,
-0.5259663462638855,
-0.2879331409931183,
-0.09254154562950134,
0.4874221086502075,
-0.3498002588748932,
0.16755527257919312,
0.40369755029678345,
-0.5502897500991821,
0.16864100098609924,
0.44040682911872864,
-0.06841814517974854,
-0.5741641521453857,
0.5702872276306152,
-0.04502846673130989,
0.13258224725723267,
0.09091191738843918,
0.496865838766098,
-0.45743969082832336,
-0.04780948534607887,
-0.49363210797309875,
0.11040031164884567,
-0.6750196218490601,
-0.050438184291124344,
-0.6846624612808228,
0.008476649411022663,
-0.6403795480728149,
0.2694985270500183,
-0.6044067740440369,
-0.03395606949925423,
-0.741333544254303,
0.00010649819887476042,
0.07846444845199585,
0.9713719487190247,
-0.09377829730510712,
0.25923800468444824,
-0.8808565735816956,
0.5063839554786682,
0.5550687909126282,
0.1131853312253952,
0.27180081605911255,
-0.09254588931798935,
0.2847002446651459,
0.09511618316173553,
-0.38742879033088684,
-1.4847558736801147,
0.8165876865386963,
0.4023407995700836,
0.3683871030807495,
0.5849034190177917,
-0.1868942379951477,
0.6103219985961914,
-0.32101956009864807,
0.6883593201637268,
0.3824496865272522,
-1.1976308822631836,
0.6965959668159485,
-0.07232165336608887,
0.1385827213525772,
0.4957331418991089,
0.3811213970184326,
-0.7782878279685974,
0.13101531565189362,
-0.7743998169898987,
-0.800056517124176,
0.7958880662918091,
-0.050699397921562195,
0.07422678917646408,
0.27040988206863403,
0.18963780999183655,
0.5210605263710022,
0.31561869382858276,
-0.06977014243602753,
-0.34026461839675903,
-0.17082473635673523,
-0.6043558120727539,
-0.09391437470912933,
-0.20703959465026855,
0.18978479504585266,
-0.08462408185005188,
0.6579712629318237,
-0.2413725107908249,
0.5891169905662537,
-0.1237204372882843,
0.10756463557481766,
-0.5161908268928528,
0.4817846119403839,
0.4511837661266327,
0.5404300093650818,
-0.48204565048217773,
-0.039685726165771484,
0.07263477146625519,
-0.2372647523880005,
0.27575090527534485,
0.07142393290996552,
0.21456225216388702,
0.05319343879818916,
0.11925293505191803,
1.2905346155166626,
0.3479216992855072,
-0.5563213229179382,
0.17977118492126465,
-0.4246552586555481,
0.12005122750997543,
-0.3547999858856201,
-0.14980174601078033,
0.2690301835536957,
0.3639912009239197,
0.5044060349464417,
0.13724997639656067,
0.49762383103370667,
-0.9164202809333801,
0.05510733276605606,
0.15675227344036102,
-0.7971031069755554,
-0.29470527172088623,
0.8010222911834717,
0.15055838227272034,
-0.1491241455078125,
0.6893448233604431,
0.2163798063993454,
-0.5673637390136719,
1.0346579551696777,
0.29967164993286133,
1.2485264539718628,
-0.5685672163963318,
0.4433209300041199,
0.3939663767814636,
0.01076465006917715,
0.2648826837539673,
0.3430367410182953,
0.2632608711719513,
-0.6242048740386963,
-0.39331725239753723,
-0.1995578408241272,
-0.5217577219009399,
0.14780427515506744,
-0.9934993386268616,
0.042572397738695145,
-0.1930084079504013,
-0.42678242921829224,
0.23081043362617493,
0.20530226826667786,
-0.9841125011444092,
0.37621819972991943,
0.7876853346824646,
0.2242623269557953,
-1.1552120447158813,
0.48151659965515137,
0.31741878390312195,
-0.3870156407356262,
-0.8410111665725708,
-0.3623645603656769,
0.23914869129657745,
-0.6328097581863403,
0.9322792887687683,
0.2644403576850891,
-0.15268957614898682,
-0.24442923069000244,
-0.44148069620132446,
-0.6977243423461914,
0.9886026978492737,
0.5281884074211121,
-0.7018665075302124,
0.006994244176894426,
-0.10032239556312561,
0.4553990662097931,
-0.6893823742866516,
0.4528464674949646,
0.7581312656402588,
0.42315763235092163,
-0.020274678245186806,
-0.47442641854286194,
-0.16789917647838593,
-0.12015245854854584,
0.01794249564409256,
-0.08765755593776703,
-0.36688750982284546,
1.0242536067962646,
-0.18938644230365753,
-0.46125924587249756,
0.07786653935909271,
0.9197580218315125,
0.40035852789878845,
0.6024377346038818,
0.7112281322479248,
0.38054171204566956,
0.929142415523529,
-0.13265641033649445,
0.9572048783302307,
0.20765650272369385,
0.16604796051979065,
1.1677924394607544,
-0.4624718427658081,
0.660827100276947,
-0.013431177474558353,
-0.45960262417793274,
0.5678642988204956,
0.6798359751701355,
0.168831005692482,
0.489178866147995,
0.1789674013853073,
0.023586330935359,
-0.08036217093467712,
-0.15186314284801483,
-0.3975510001182556,
0.8036338686943054,
0.5415774583816528,
-0.3873685300350189,
0.09320199489593506,
0.16669170558452606,
0.025963013991713524,
-0.31830647587776184,
-0.07973875105381012,
0.928839921951294,
0.22080501914024353,
-0.37328270077705383,
-0.010418280027806759,
-0.30053117871284485,
0.5552953481674194,
-0.5421419143676758,
-0.17424827814102173,
-0.05308510363101959,
0.09583837538957596,
-0.023595120757818222,
-0.4219963252544403,
0.06954938918352127,
0.026406606659293175,
-0.05672242119908333,
0.1492176353931427,
0.7365943193435669,
-0.5384188294410706,
-0.6343346834182739,
0.5252500772476196,
0.7361822128295898,
0.15537172555923462,
-0.27651306986808777,
-0.90560382604599,
0.13382643461227417,
-0.2216624915599823,
-0.06524915248155594,
0.18868210911750793,
0.6046680212020874,
0.4399672746658325,
0.584374189376831,
0.5909745693206787,
0.2008785903453827,
0.21313408017158508,
0.4764421880245209,
0.20470724999904633,
-0.6043646335601807,
-0.4139041304588318,
-0.5610355734825134,
0.35228216648101807,
-0.016446130350232124,
-0.4493389427661896,
0.21896441280841827,
0.11227932572364807,
0.11293226480484009,
-0.10676941275596619,
0.7254700064659119,
0.22067365050315857,
0.4375940263271332,
-0.31023234128952026,
0.6891813278198242,
-0.4540191888809204,
-0.06423135846853256,
-0.47817304730415344,
-0.7051635384559631,
0.16900022327899933,
0.538299024105072,
-0.05973842367529869,
0.3498300015926361,
0.5526138544082642,
0.2374681979417801,
0.14275826513767242,
0.5192537903785706,
0.29637566208839417,
0.16612929105758667,
0.40052875876426697,
0.7894527912139893,
0.999435544013977,
-0.33860838413238525,
0.09185679256916046,
-0.5005884170532227,
0.024200374260544777,
-0.20091655850410461,
-0.8149935603141785,
-0.33858931064605713,
-0.748670756816864,
-0.3124334216117859,
-0.05273187533020973,
-0.09431025385856628,
0.8132641315460205,
0.9006401896476746,
-0.7682002186775208,
-0.29587727785110474,
0.29599422216415405,
-0.1654997318983078,
-0.6060193777084351,
-0.19512201845645905,
0.35855934023857117,
-0.21701644361019135,
-0.9922395348548889,
0.7578538060188293,
0.06658861041069031,
-0.15535485744476318,
-0.5099189877510071,
-0.002811879152432084,
0.002983628073707223,
0.3090294599533081,
0.39713436365127563,
0.03628372400999069,
-0.7712352871894836,
-0.17419390380382538,
-0.23659856617450714,
0.05054233595728874,
0.14961466193199158,
0.8691517114639282,
-0.8508051037788391,
0.4751400053501129,
0.37668314576148987,
0.5492806434631348,
0.39868301153182983,
-0.010840337723493576,
0.975395679473877,
-0.5943061113357544,
-0.3352796137332916,
0.34069404006004333,
0.6427741646766663,
0.48514628410339355,
-0.5911315083503723,
0.6435843110084534,
-0.1751696765422821,
-0.35187828540802,
-0.6435851454734802,
0.040894489735364914,
-1.2226507663726807,
-0.3861684501171112,
0.6695939302444458,
-0.13469573855400085,
-0.20523349940776825,
0.05121035501360893,
-0.4034428000450134,
0.7633564472198486,
-0.7713743448257446,
0.8932167291641235,
0.5581023097038269,
0.01624356023967266,
-0.34139618277549744,
-0.7208461761474609,
0.0668993890285492,
0.4455203711986542,
-1.1017658710479736,
-0.02082723379135132,
0.5145809650421143,
0.005072687286883593,
0.01731671765446663,
0.2660669684410095,
-0.1437431424856186,
0.3360857665538788,
-0.06250927597284317,
0.2735339105129242,
0.060285378247499466,
-0.4826754927635193,
-0.8174259662628174,
0.5892130136489868,
-0.45450764894485474,
-0.2941398322582245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00438v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00438v1
|
Your Model Is Not Predicting Depression Well And That Is Why: A Case Study of PRIMATE Dataset
| 2024-03-01T10:47:02 | 2024-03-01T10:47:02 |
Kirill Milintsevich, Kairit Sirts, Gaël Dias
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper addresses the quality of annotations in mental health datasets
used for NLP-based depression level estimation from social media texts. While
previous research relies on social media-based datasets annotated with binary
categories, i.e. depressed or non-depressed, recent datasets such as D2S and
PRIMATE aim for nuanced annotations using PHQ-9 symptoms. However, most of
these datasets rely on crowd workers without the domain knowledge for
annotation. Focusing on the PRIMATE dataset, our study reveals concerns
regarding annotation validity, particularly for the lack of interest or
pleasure symptom. Through reannotation by a mental health professional, we
introduce finer labels and textual spans as evidence, identifying a notable
number of false positives. Our refined annotations, to be released under a Data
Use Agreement, offer a higher-quality test set for anhedonia detection. This
study underscores the necessity of addressing annotation quality issues in
mental health datasets, advocating for improved methodologies to enhance NLP
model reliability in mental health assessments.
|
[
-0.37270429730415344,
-0.5993552207946777,
0.43898260593414307,
0.7038823366165161,
-0.4200752079486847,
-0.014787126332521439,
-0.014106116257607937,
-0.5714594721794128,
0.5757031440734863,
0.2492559254169464,
-0.5550664663314819,
-0.6236700415611267,
-0.9390250444412231,
0.4675843417644501,
-0.5115594863891602,
1.1283243894577026,
0.14518819749355316,
-0.1426260620355606,
-0.2965906858444214,
-0.18089905381202698,
-0.3313521444797516,
-0.5941638946533203,
-0.8012245297431946,
-0.25493142008781433,
0.38117656111717224,
0.27046290040016174,
1.1042187213897705,
0.2915499806404114,
0.7008271217346191,
0.004023578483611345,
-0.5148366689682007,
0.2480710744857788,
-0.5871115922927856,
-0.11490488797426224,
0.021087434142827988,
-0.1951092779636383,
-0.4807281196117401,
0.26307520270347595,
-0.0421612374484539,
0.6191484928131104,
-0.03006638213992119,
0.33499807119369507,
-0.03288722038269043,
0.40410053730010986,
-0.5784381031990051,
-0.026289621368050575,
-0.1423182487487793,
0.5338689684867859,
-0.2387368530035019,
0.08619413524866104,
-0.07394666224718094,
-0.3300808072090149,
-0.06773629784584045,
-0.5967986583709717,
0.22344434261322021,
-0.07854504883289337,
0.9227972030639648,
0.8352421522140503,
-0.2643001973628998,
-0.20430341362953186,
-0.519379734992981,
0.612807035446167,
-1.1048755645751953,
-0.16526484489440918,
1.3004682064056396,
0.13879959285259247,
-0.13521206378936768,
-0.3665545582771301,
-0.4128051996231079,
-0.20489300787448883,
-0.3080761730670929,
0.08705553412437439,
-0.025054818019270897,
-0.26757463812828064,
0.6134084463119507,
0.5462386012077332,
-0.3994210958480835,
0.07358473539352417,
-0.387759804725647,
-0.2607938051223755,
0.9659867286682129,
0.15931811928749084,
0.3806953728199005,
-0.6201016306877136,
-0.09753047674894333,
0.4810786247253418,
-0.15826278924942017,
0.28908970952033997,
0.18490120768547058,
0.06423371285200119,
-0.42533424496650696,
0.7860404849052429,
0.039044804871082306,
0.4892784357070923,
-0.0974913015961647,
-0.2051580846309662,
0.2741776406764984,
-0.032265737652778625,
-0.10286690294742584,
-0.060455720871686935,
0.8132830858230591,
0.7479891180992126,
0.2787107825279236,
-0.13944914937019348,
-0.2452905923128128,
0.17403140664100647,
0.6057339310646057,
-0.5722219347953796,
-0.6592903733253479,
0.6188984513282776,
-0.6884444355964661,
-0.2525758445262909,
-0.3739398419857025,
-0.7121769189834595,
-0.760134220123291,
-0.20920932292938232,
0.22824609279632568,
-0.4963657259941101,
-0.4751805365085602,
0.04796142131090164,
-0.15459898114204407,
-0.5844187140464783,
0.45612001419067383,
-0.809441864490509,
0.2908565104007721,
0.5472697019577026,
1.146966814994812,
-0.03692226484417915,
0.028052322566509247,
-0.01486833207309246,
-0.26673415303230286,
-0.6475867033004761,
0.7438724040985107,
-0.3484354317188263,
-0.36166101694107056,
-0.1997225284576416,
0.2910361886024475,
0.002193199237808585,
-0.4809829592704773,
0.8014974594116211,
0.14207950234413147,
0.32973235845565796,
-0.4700033962726593,
-0.4964333474636078,
-0.26399046182632446,
0.2357969880104065,
-0.753829300403595,
1.0046007633209229,
0.36504673957824707,
-1.3497803211212158,
0.29658982157707214,
-0.4412696063518524,
-0.49359583854675293,
-0.013373985886573792,
-0.06990033388137817,
-0.3956635296344757,
0.2404174655675888,
0.26610782742500305,
0.6025152802467346,
0.023877229541540146,
0.43601107597351074,
-0.8449057340621948,
-0.417460560798645,
0.47123533487319946,
-0.0311027392745018,
0.9167466163635254,
-0.11166932433843613,
0.007234335411339998,
-0.36169084906578064,
-0.8156306743621826,
-0.36560916900634766,
-0.12700486183166504,
-0.21159160137176514,
-0.450063556432724,
0.2607853412628174,
0.1326145976781845,
0.46827763319015503,
0.06658795475959778,
-0.6970006227493286,
0.02893603965640068,
-0.12184374779462814,
0.6655386090278625,
0.3545168340206146,
0.13412557542324066,
-0.15777020156383514,
-0.3431597352027893,
0.40481799840927124,
-0.006015920080244541,
0.31652265787124634,
0.2822641432285309,
-0.8732415437698364,
-0.054742299020290375,
-0.588676929473877,
0.4249125123023987,
0.49202850461006165,
-0.41013434529304504,
0.6289002299308777,
0.14636670053005219,
-0.5557589530944824,
-0.5856486558914185,
-0.12407299131155014,
-0.0310739167034626,
0.6630258560180664,
0.6971266269683838,
-0.4883098602294922,
-0.44040486216545105,
-0.864126980304718,
0.18017445504665375,
-0.20733115077018738,
-0.1340223252773285,
0.14310063421726227,
0.5405171513557434,
-0.4397525191307068,
0.8315631151199341,
-0.2124660611152649,
-0.4463707208633423,
-0.021073170006275177,
0.5082190036773682,
0.1859450787305832,
0.5012502074241638,
0.5677844882011414,
-0.7205754518508911,
-0.052621398121118546,
-0.37454795837402344,
-1.0082049369812012,
0.016750792041420937,
-0.07850054651498795,
-0.10633305460214615,
-0.08884893357753754,
-0.3422492742538452,
-0.6391109824180603,
0.7112305760383606,
0.569577157497406,
-0.24256658554077148,
0.5220026969909668,
0.11616400629281998,
0.08344343304634094,
-0.7711135149002075,
0.18429870903491974,
0.28547918796539307,
-0.03947903588414192,
-0.5269030332565308,
-0.7788308262825012,
-0.01765822246670723,
-0.22625523805618286,
0.00533865625038743,
0.20804090797901154,
0.18681803345680237,
0.11869658529758453,
-0.4773537516593933,
0.13119326531887054,
0.21191231906414032,
0.16806267201900482,
0.09622371941804886,
0.37294474244117737,
0.6787545084953308,
-0.4288303852081299,
0.19241711497306824,
0.6991944313049316,
-0.1210496723651886,
0.5319816470146179,
-0.5701851844787598,
-0.231154665350914,
-0.16687607765197754,
0.19486506283283234,
-0.8958905935287476,
-0.46445685625076294,
0.4371369481086731,
-0.6369922757148743,
0.07060135155916214,
0.26885345578193665,
-0.3305497467517853,
-0.4751901626586914,
-0.22745782136917114,
0.32949990034103394,
-0.010010152123868465,
-0.27003809809684753,
0.08218559622764587,
0.45141172409057617,
-0.11539111286401749,
-0.6371578574180603,
-0.9157318472862244,
0.2784135937690735,
-0.4174271523952484,
-0.4691016972064972,
0.43935227394104004,
0.31783732771873474,
-0.20788808166980743,
0.122291699051857,
-0.26354533433914185,
-0.33082079887390137,
0.5469318628311157,
0.4809240996837616,
0.022920217365026474,
0.12114914506673813,
0.5263312458992004,
-0.04708657041192055,
-0.1315814107656479,
0.3050380051136017,
0.5656341314315796,
0.0583135150372982,
0.5278126001358032,
0.09797678142786026,
-0.9462604522705078,
0.2745154798030853,
0.30424463748931885,
0.06483878940343857,
0.6844449639320374,
0.5697343945503235,
-0.9952190518379211,
0.02397381328046322,
-0.313986599445343,
-0.11658523976802826,
-0.2509225904941559,
-0.03447882458567619,
-0.03826306387782097,
-0.5709085464477539,
0.7003260254859924,
0.06643322855234146,
-0.048684392124414444,
0.41345909237861633,
0.1035335510969162,
-0.22679120302200317,
1.2935017347335815,
0.8040105104446411,
-0.22677521407604218,
0.15051287412643433,
-0.1746370494365692,
0.36601054668426514,
-0.7997857928276062,
0.02035953290760517,
-0.32414790987968445,
-0.24484266340732574,
-0.6560373902320862,
-0.017891183495521545,
-0.17412081360816956,
0.4397124946117401,
-0.29128095507621765,
0.3894907832145691,
-0.6647533178329468,
-0.2677861452102661,
0.22923560440540314,
0.36696329712867737,
0.22241529822349548,
-0.1886587142944336,
0.3856993317604065,
-0.4146218001842499,
-0.4412202835083008,
-0.8922803997993469,
0.7566351294517517,
0.5341756343841553,
0.5621345043182373,
-0.029516208916902542,
0.47872745990753174,
0.7564900517463684,
0.5180597305297852,
-0.5255375504493713,
0.12009741365909576,
-0.3664635717868805,
-0.7620090842247009,
-0.36356329917907715,
-0.52311110496521,
-0.6232609748840332,
-0.05685509368777275,
-0.3724587857723236,
-1.0929096937179565,
0.6287668943405151,
0.05923843756318092,
-0.7834282517433167,
-0.03980625048279762,
-0.39303311705589294,
1.0329499244689941,
-0.19157496094703674,
0.07315613329410553,
-0.02832016348838806,
-0.6196276545524597,
0.7138596773147583,
-0.3608899712562561,
0.2764126658439636,
-0.8982664942741394,
0.047851551324129105,
0.9785935282707214,
-0.4550250470638275,
0.780809760093689,
-0.09861268848180771,
0.08335259556770325,
0.20618364214897156,
0.08023258298635483,
-0.03784665837883949,
0.5447710752487183,
-0.538639485836029,
0.29154565930366516,
0.3660790026187897,
-0.5499400496482849,
-0.33398890495300293,
0.21826153993606567,
-0.9737309813499451,
-0.42864179611206055,
-0.26591619849205017,
-0.2627003490924835,
-0.10432577133178711,
-0.13367889821529388,
0.3221176862716675,
0.39844557642936707,
0.0891731008887291,
-0.10796941816806793,
0.03379404544830322,
-0.4116115868091583,
0.21812516450881958,
0.005511261057108641,
-0.08650216460227966,
-0.6993533968925476,
0.735601007938385,
0.316860556602478,
-0.0326269157230854,
-0.0963054895401001,
0.11839242279529572,
-0.058438487350940704,
-0.289118230342865,
-0.2869943380355835,
0.3964154124259949,
-0.5797300338745117,
-0.3220256567001343,
-0.6736955642700195,
-0.07661991566419601,
-0.6507536172866821,
0.12249770760536194,
-0.39449018239974976,
-0.6871461272239685,
-0.5867571234703064,
-0.3459111750125885,
0.6376098990440369,
0.7793412208557129,
-0.472947895526886,
0.20509479939937592,
-0.4847997725009918,
0.5470083951950073,
-0.1612267941236496,
0.22503218054771423,
0.0874815434217453,
-0.46963369846343994,
-0.3475945293903351,
0.18595226109027863,
-0.4261273741722107,
-1.0929176807403564,
0.8121222853660583,
0.10361172258853912,
0.3349469006061554,
0.6049038767814636,
0.559131920337677,
0.7857522964477539,
0.1131826639175415,
0.8523606657981873,
0.08559509366750717,
-1.0712909698486328,
0.7642650604248047,
0.019750118255615234,
-0.09418488293886185,
0.6682132482528687,
1.0769212245941162,
-0.8400183320045471,
-0.5605468153953552,
-0.6609781980514526,
-0.893754243850708,
0.7736369967460632,
0.3985939621925354,
0.015613218769431114,
-0.2876344621181488,
0.7558543086051941,
0.3366096019744873,
0.29427117109298706,
-0.785517692565918,
-0.33570799231529236,
-0.8069507479667664,
-0.08664485812187195,
-0.35754138231277466,
-0.42390578985214233,
-0.028658274561166763,
-0.21953114867210388,
0.6422221660614014,
-0.025144584476947784,
0.22554990649223328,
0.406471848487854,
0.2504296600818634,
-0.36530449986457825,
-0.3174213469028473,
0.24697968363761902,
0.8436759114265442,
-0.572293221950531,
0.2989904284477234,
-0.05384808033704758,
-0.4493500888347626,
-0.037760138511657715,
0.260673850774765,
-0.20001831650733948,
0.34953048825263977,
0.5667585730552673,
0.6267151236534119,
-0.13187724351882935,
-0.4975109100341797,
0.4971795678138733,
-0.11729733645915985,
-0.03310651332139969,
-0.3287625312805176,
-0.05734778568148613,
0.15788549184799194,
0.026827944442629814,
0.2586354613304138,
-0.11613243818283081,
0.4086856245994568,
-0.21984434127807617,
0.05325471609830856,
0.11838686466217041,
-0.6322354078292847,
-0.5330987572669983,
0.5960134267807007,
-0.057696420699357986,
-0.5291895866394043,
0.82137131690979,
-0.15076084434986115,
-0.2369777411222458,
0.6511983871459961,
0.0982527881860733,
0.400674968957901,
-0.11878494918346405,
0.5894208550453186,
0.6346579790115356,
0.38148704171180725,
-0.3932030498981476,
0.3084612488746643,
0.14683181047439575,
-0.47376060485839844,
-0.44606584310531616,
-0.6269724369049072,
-0.5797695517539978,
0.34561887383461,
-0.7900602221488953,
0.3222821354866028,
-0.4354616701602936,
-0.8696398735046387,
0.09766995161771774,
0.0618336983025074,
-0.24661128222942352,
0.6643590331077576,
0.3250998854637146,
0.7210066914558411,
-1.1488127708435059,
0.48803362250328064,
0.5871833562850952,
-0.7347745895385742,
-0.45411184430122375,
0.1896985024213791,
-0.05070493370294571,
-0.27694806456565857,
0.40116947889328003,
0.7215264439582825,
0.5252435207366943,
-0.34942811727523804,
-0.569085955619812,
-1.0507311820983887,
0.9229686260223389,
0.2746097147464752,
-0.14225070178508759,
0.2282627671957016,
0.23633335530757904,
0.7821545600891113,
-0.3980594873428345,
0.3088855743408203,
0.23157379031181335,
0.3907817006111145,
-0.07146419584751129,
-0.775364339351654,
0.19068937003612518,
-0.34206798672676086,
0.0761626660823822,
-0.2353108525276184,
-0.33738455176353455,
0.8082883358001709,
-0.22392752766609192,
-0.5538778901100159,
0.06198261305689812,
0.4303235113620758,
0.03593205660581589,
0.5474579930305481,
0.2851651906967163,
0.8214500546455383,
0.9259820580482483,
0.11946538835763931,
0.9167096018791199,
-0.11783072352409363,
0.6148592829704285,
0.9900160431861877,
-0.2980310618877411,
0.9572855234146118,
0.06136220321059227,
-0.12024260312318802,
0.24113966524600983,
1.5034817457199097,
-0.1443711817264557,
0.4985108971595764,
0.3377867341041565,
-0.0631714016199112,
-0.5561062097549438,
-0.2878299057483673,
-0.31955283880233765,
0.042941782623529434,
0.5420206189155579,
-0.5757958889007568,
-0.17790468037128448,
0.18091131746768951,
-0.1264658272266388,
-0.1222105473279953,
-0.06354774534702301,
0.6401325464248657,
0.37985312938690186,
-0.10871008038520813,
0.654220700263977,
-0.10756651312112808,
0.45381489396095276,
0.20682267844676971,
0.08486650884151459,
-0.37197116017341614,
-0.15580250322818756,
-0.6244193315505981,
-0.6378270387649536,
0.7142230868339539,
-0.035603173077106476,
-0.3383241593837738,
0.08373015373945236,
0.6169227957725525,
-0.04954412207007408,
-0.6136370301246643,
0.4491933584213257,
0.590796172618866,
0.6120874285697937,
-0.14195840060710907,
-0.8409895896911621,
-0.3088987469673157,
-0.28762397170066833,
-0.2651483714580536,
0.12331746518611908,
0.784070611000061,
-0.1793275624513626,
0.7330631017684937,
0.3007294237613678,
0.05671371892094612,
-0.42013683915138245,
-0.018181191757321358,
0.6411969065666199,
-0.74175626039505,
-0.12172816693782806,
-0.7685699462890625,
0.3751571774482727,
-0.22766710817813873,
-0.6431393027305603,
0.5934506058692932,
0.295544296503067,
0.531326413154602,
0.3154643476009369,
0.6766929626464844,
-0.16315792500972748,
0.7816013693809509,
0.045695189386606216,
0.6822012066841125,
-0.6416687965393066,
0.09806552529335022,
-0.038247887045145035,
-0.6917827725410461,
-0.5777037739753723,
0.8866976499557495,
-0.6458287835121155,
-0.15646038949489594,
0.4801553785800934,
0.5649085640907288,
0.08249408006668091,
0.5113627910614014,
0.3002999722957611,
0.44076141715049744,
0.08667691797018051,
0.2641160190105438,
1.0283511877059937,
-0.14303702116012573,
-0.029755037277936935,
-0.9297657608985901,
-0.1894289255142212,
-0.06931190192699432,
-0.8148337006568909,
-0.9968624114990234,
-0.2750808298587799,
-0.8145402669906616,
-0.38416820764541626,
0.22699210047721863,
0.7321048974990845,
0.49174532294273376,
-0.7326875925064087,
-0.022130118682980537,
0.1580570787191391,
0.06254377216100693,
-0.4609733819961548,
-0.21994300186634064,
0.4431867003440857,
-0.3822861909866333,
-0.12490590661764145,
-0.25999215245246887,
0.15791572630405426,
0.03561300039291382,
-0.2543904483318329,
0.32841408252716064,
-0.3012312948703766,
-0.34689009189605713,
0.3057859241962433,
0.09738526493310928,
-0.6235001683235168,
-0.2951720058917999,
-0.36546561121940613,
-0.22770312428474426,
0.2192152440547943,
0.15433090925216675,
-0.4535636603832245,
0.030783193185925484,
0.11909252405166626,
0.2740788757801056,
0.15651176869869232,
0.34953922033309937,
0.35549846291542053,
-0.3115489184856415,
-0.3583446443080902,
0.4299986958503723,
0.34573420882225037,
0.787074863910675,
-0.7165853381156921,
0.7427079081535339,
0.30778583884239197,
-0.6361439228057861,
-0.7568844556808472,
-0.2828364670276642,
-0.8912954926490784,
-0.2943286597728729,
0.9882838129997253,
-0.6837764978408813,
-0.4374784827232361,
-0.506976842880249,
-0.2911511957645416,
0.23962317407131195,
-0.471004456281662,
1.5465036630630493,
0.8014037609100342,
-0.5205177068710327,
0.12566818296909332,
-0.8461868762969971,
0.7623947858810425,
0.31556272506713867,
-0.6008455157279968,
0.2724486291408539,
0.35471028089523315,
-0.06870036572217941,
0.38931286334991455,
0.5516093373298645,
0.1638682782649994,
0.32346078753471375,
-0.07431769371032715,
0.21394477784633636,
0.16867445409297943,
0.13886377215385437,
-0.25312885642051697,
0.1102636530995369,
-0.04382169246673584,
0.021786002442240715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00435v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00435v1
|
Hierarchical Indexing for Retrieval-Augmented Opinion Summarization
| 2024-03-01T10:38:07 | 2024-03-01T10:38:07 |
Tom Hosking, Hao Tang, Mirella Lapata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose a method for unsupervised abstractive opinion summarization, that
combines the attributability and scalability of extractive approaches with the
coherence and fluency of Large Language Models (LLMs). Our method, HIRO, learns
an index structure that maps sentences to a path through a semantically
organized discrete hierarchy. At inference time, we populate the index and use
it to identify and retrieve clusters of sentences containing popular opinions
from input reviews. Then, we use a pretrained LLM to generate a readable
summary that is grounded in these extracted evidential clusters. The modularity
of our approach allows us to evaluate its efficacy at each stage. We show that
HIRO learns an encoding space that is more semantically structured than prior
work, and generates summaries that are more representative of the opinions in
the input reviews. Human evaluation confirms that HIRO generates more coherent,
detailed and accurate summaries that are significantly preferred by annotators
compared to prior work.
|
[
-0.3341178596019745,
-0.5790786147117615,
0.48159584403038025,
-0.07197598367929459,
-0.274821013212204,
0.2852657437324524,
-0.09411630779504776,
-0.5235705375671387,
0.7530513405799866,
0.3816068768501282,
0.03812772035598755,
-0.5947232842445374,
-0.47430065274238586,
0.0642286017537117,
-0.38115671277046204,
1.423335313796997,
0.2224119007587433,
-0.25115036964416504,
-0.14808154106140137,
-0.03545626252889633,
0.24330511689186096,
-0.6442428827285767,
-0.18997524678707123,
-0.4440842270851135,
0.582760751247406,
0.4403913915157318,
0.7407940030097961,
0.5407533645629883,
0.540228009223938,
0.27958908677101135,
-0.34074023365974426,
0.23874413967132568,
-0.5665246844291687,
0.023419702425599098,
-0.09605003893375397,
-0.4591939449310303,
-0.7567248940467834,
-0.012330937199294567,
0.7347071766853333,
0.8530095219612122,
-0.3149075508117676,
0.11776986718177795,
0.10050243139266968,
0.9198590517044067,
-0.7374311089515686,
0.12197965383529663,
-0.5787526369094849,
0.11089897155761719,
-0.07949234545230865,
-0.33791443705558777,
-0.2155393362045288,
-0.5811960697174072,
0.28998345136642456,
-0.6169038414955139,
0.06932365149259567,
0.1633240282535553,
0.5641008615493774,
-0.05992210656404495,
-0.32226744294166565,
-0.3620009124279022,
-0.6504300832748413,
0.9239981174468994,
-0.6393681764602661,
-0.04134321212768555,
0.14574050903320312,
0.2649413049221039,
0.1660260409116745,
-0.5912182927131653,
-0.35583141446113586,
0.22496835887432098,
-0.15587544441223145,
0.5534803867340088,
-0.14470534026622772,
0.09698544442653656,
-0.2254050374031067,
0.9039452075958252,
-0.3584902584552765,
-0.061012815684080124,
-0.2580798268318176,
0.049347855150699615,
0.5482465028762817,
0.10415834933519363,
0.05308092013001442,
-0.7096680998802185,
-0.29866427183151245,
-0.026928814128041267,
-0.7487133145332336,
0.10398069024085999,
0.37642738223075867,
0.015668703243136406,
0.21324244141578674,
0.7039060592651367,
-0.5434054136276245,
0.15864033997058868,
0.2738397419452667,
-0.30775508284568787,
0.5405439734458923,
-0.3461402654647827,
-0.11987045407295227,
0.10257498174905777,
0.8622279763221741,
0.5307562351226807,
0.036340873688459396,
-0.11490528285503387,
-0.3758189380168915,
-0.11943815648555756,
0.3230549991130829,
-0.7896934747695923,
-0.04944184422492981,
0.28449463844299316,
-0.6952006220817566,
-0.5878894329071045,
0.38120347261428833,
-1.0468140840530396,
-0.21623511612415314,
-0.09034813195466995,
0.409410297870636,
-0.028996944427490234,
-0.13607622683048248,
-0.009413902647793293,
-0.3306863009929657,
-0.0750778540968895,
0.3140557110309601,
-1.1141748428344727,
0.46021759510040283,
0.8408947587013245,
0.684119462966919,
-0.4374590814113617,
-0.2785181999206543,
-0.3596114218235016,
0.1939093917608261,
-0.4641842842102051,
1.083978295326233,
-0.6090016961097717,
-0.5096398591995239,
0.04105125740170479,
-0.19666998088359833,
0.057535089552402496,
-0.8288260698318481,
0.12227170169353485,
-0.6108322739601135,
0.24027420580387115,
-0.08826765418052673,
-0.36811578273773193,
-0.2634355425834656,
0.4243902266025543,
-0.43484610319137573,
1.1913728713989258,
0.028913816437125206,
-0.9291067123413086,
0.26381295919418335,
-0.6741600036621094,
-0.6004733443260193,
-0.06893040239810944,
-0.18586695194244385,
-0.32036927342414856,
0.3667297065258026,
0.5116357803344727,
0.37782904505729675,
0.046100541949272156,
0.09305248409509659,
-0.004893335048109293,
-0.3749779164791107,
-0.14802345633506775,
0.11308471858501434,
0.33020415902137756,
0.15716294944286346,
-0.10893639922142029,
0.4496510624885559,
-0.6469413042068481,
-0.13500739634037018,
-0.28795650601387024,
-0.518197774887085,
-0.6123619079589844,
0.22644655406475067,
-0.16317400336265564,
-0.1133103296160698,
0.5318220853805542,
-0.5434744954109192,
0.07568542659282684,
-0.8948805332183838,
0.33309367299079895,
0.6491655111312866,
0.5125951766967773,
0.5559453964233398,
-0.1958046853542328,
0.34302160143852234,
0.25860634446144104,
0.11356624215841293,
-0.3979039490222931,
-0.21935516595840454,
-0.6606488823890686,
-0.2743734121322632,
0.1111186221241951,
0.41454681754112244,
-0.5282477140426636,
0.7153620719909668,
-0.3233006000518799,
-0.39447322487831116,
-0.6770210862159729,
0.006512303836643696,
0.3854580521583557,
0.5280048847198486,
0.3780233561992645,
-0.47497740387916565,
-0.6169400215148926,
-1.021589994430542,
-0.2125086933374405,
-0.5060795545578003,
0.04750743880867958,
0.1871887594461441,
0.8587514758110046,
-0.2701174318790436,
0.8276371955871582,
-0.5524466037750244,
-0.055635806173086166,
-0.385701447725296,
0.7464604377746582,
0.35992613434791565,
0.17877189815044403,
0.2295324206352234,
-0.5242000818252563,
-0.28952911496162415,
0.2503887116909027,
-0.826102614402771,
0.17355501651763916,
0.15633730590343475,
-0.09000543504953384,
-0.07040048390626907,
0.3344651758670807,
-0.3220786452293396,
0.23700672388076782,
0.011820854619145393,
0.33727872371673584,
0.4173727333545685,
-0.3106449842453003,
0.4559887647628784,
-1.3547948598861694,
0.10914899408817291,
-0.14660178124904633,
-0.24255891144275665,
-0.18447783589363098,
0.20848122239112854,
-0.25001251697540283,
-0.011563336476683617,
-0.2579444348812103,
0.12133248150348663,
-0.3819587230682373,
-0.3417162597179413,
-0.435546875,
0.16222739219665527,
0.0012899431167170405,
0.6401532888412476,
0.17888644337654114,
0.7332473993301392,
0.14180076122283936,
-0.3588232696056366,
0.09748746454715729,
0.3441862165927887,
-0.682944118976593,
0.37814071774482727,
-0.9525327086448669,
0.06105925515294075,
-0.3951876163482666,
0.17963650822639465,
-0.9340248107910156,
-0.42446109652519226,
-0.2808442711830139,
-0.3359730541706085,
-0.03602976351976395,
0.05336236208677292,
-0.4456861913204193,
-0.1642100214958191,
-0.8812752962112427,
0.2142876237630844,
0.599202573299408,
-0.6622035503387451,
0.3530631959438324,
0.9140447378158569,
-0.43710023164749146,
-0.7901468873023987,
-0.2722843289375305,
0.06372325867414474,
-0.18738089501857758,
-0.11892282217741013,
0.4427790641784668,
0.050186604261398315,
-0.48115670680999756,
-0.007772915530949831,
-0.02493024803698063,
-0.03412901237607002,
0.10906041413545609,
0.13575340807437897,
0.22816826403141022,
-0.1864057332277298,
-0.12503720819950104,
0.21273571252822876,
-0.04402679577469826,
0.12257575988769531,
0.12373938411474228,
0.136921688914299,
-0.4432257115840912,
0.11741723865270615,
-0.19117054343223572,
0.751240611076355,
0.7103855013847351,
-0.21760070323944092,
0.33122459053993225,
0.15642522275447845,
-0.436484694480896,
-0.057855475693941116,
-0.3622875511646271,
0.02360854670405388,
-0.334123820066452,
0.6369935870170593,
-0.16180798411369324,
-0.8983354568481445,
0.5341359376907349,
-0.08077584952116013,
0.30955296754837036,
0.7415198683738708,
0.7593463659286499,
-0.47772809863090515,
1.297716498374939,
0.6926291584968567,
-0.47023409605026245,
0.5511577725410461,
-0.29563403129577637,
0.2868536412715912,
-0.975372850894928,
-0.1553686559200287,
-0.5666999220848083,
-0.2426227331161499,
-0.47099703550338745,
0.0046192132867872715,
0.9017053842544556,
0.09810168296098709,
0.04316048324108124,
-0.1283441185951233,
-0.23836779594421387,
0.7316891551017761,
0.39620596170425415,
0.0724731981754303,
0.5718725919723511,
0.17667360603809357,
-0.02416122332215309,
0.015844883397221565,
-0.4916383624076843,
-0.5498347878456116,
0.8290476202964783,
0.2116040736436844,
0.7032017111778259,
0.06836856156587601,
0.8223461508750916,
0.35260209441185,
0.404506117105484,
-1.0521982908248901,
0.46239563822746277,
-0.08889233320951462,
-0.42333728075027466,
-0.18018805980682373,
-0.30394673347473145,
-0.8623235821723938,
0.5521998405456543,
-0.40352702140808105,
-0.5583791136741638,
0.40069684386253357,
0.0005784062086604536,
-0.47046002745628357,
0.13351048529148102,
-0.4453471004962921,
0.5746767520904541,
0.14473026990890503,
-0.0632614716887474,
-0.6127438545227051,
-0.8013588786125183,
0.4447876811027527,
0.05568629875779152,
0.20572271943092346,
0.30363693833351135,
-0.018320413306355476,
1.0642610788345337,
-0.662464439868927,
0.7580287456512451,
0.17509816586971283,
0.19679875671863556,
0.1949545443058014,
-0.22979632019996643,
0.08938905596733093,
0.016440073028206825,
-0.21744205057621002,
0.08391328155994415,
-0.023390967398881912,
-0.19623184204101562,
-0.8056684732437134,
0.5866255164146423,
-0.9386755228042603,
-0.6018600463867188,
-0.5334079265594482,
-0.49673551321029663,
-0.2390766441822052,
0.35073351860046387,
0.23692914843559265,
0.6338633298873901,
-0.4186646342277527,
0.3687014579772949,
0.6025075912475586,
0.1409239023923874,
0.40264928340911865,
0.29209405183792114,
-0.24570800364017487,
-0.7667081952095032,
0.688867449760437,
0.174888014793396,
-0.06327924132347107,
0.7691153883934021,
0.4509856104850769,
-0.21780529618263245,
-0.7035776972770691,
-0.3088606297969818,
0.19900745153427124,
-0.634650468826294,
-0.009959874674677849,
-0.6270456910133362,
-0.10311228781938553,
-0.22515569627285004,
-0.059691958129405975,
-0.2693413496017456,
-0.6798169016838074,
0.11039276421070099,
-0.26441091299057007,
0.09652672708034515,
1.1517161130905151,
0.057053204625844955,
0.3158617913722992,
-0.72723388671875,
0.35553357005119324,
0.30217406153678894,
0.1291821300983429,
0.22349771857261658,
-0.44993188977241516,
-0.6538583040237427,
-0.24564789235591888,
-0.23389865458011627,
-0.6318308115005493,
0.47228798270225525,
0.18142685294151306,
0.3609442412853241,
0.46779659390449524,
0.12246058136224747,
0.8678339719772339,
-0.4815932512283325,
0.8006942272186279,
0.13825616240501404,
-0.6867634057998657,
0.8061916828155518,
-0.3595714271068573,
0.3916521966457367,
0.8787857890129089,
0.6037454605102539,
-0.18972332775592804,
-0.4047193229198456,
-0.5001408457756042,
-0.9096094369888306,
0.1963728368282318,
-0.19821743667125702,
-0.1444339007139206,
-0.3882412314414978,
0.3550597131252289,
0.4084606170654297,
0.5947816371917725,
-0.37762466073036194,
0.044557176530361176,
-0.06447722017765045,
-0.36352723836898804,
-0.11245845258235931,
-0.6469060778617859,
-0.16502068936824799,
-0.26554733514785767,
0.6264344453811646,
-0.05208699405193329,
-0.041033342480659485,
0.3671775460243225,
-0.3089958429336548,
-0.14460401237010956,
0.48422935605049133,
0.02551509626209736,
0.8379274606704712,
-0.4638308584690094,
0.40611931681632996,
-0.1670563668012619,
-0.5228604674339294,
-0.21465948224067688,
-0.36138466000556946,
-0.31335917115211487,
-0.0021352919284254313,
0.5337955355644226,
0.5279291868209839,
0.46843859553337097,
-0.44039222598075867,
0.6049545407295227,
-0.005440600216388702,
-0.1124829649925232,
-0.08575451374053955,
-0.16854891180992126,
-0.265208899974823,
0.04412640631198883,
0.3830869495868683,
0.22479547560214996,
0.6550328135490417,
-1.100467562675476,
0.08222981542348862,
0.3607819378376007,
-0.2618463933467865,
-0.5538652539253235,
0.31246036291122437,
0.36840352416038513,
-0.003691595746204257,
0.37095877528190613,
0.20253466069698334,
-0.5106832385063171,
0.22958149015903473,
0.43724629282951355,
1.056840419769287,
-0.007046102080494165,
0.07127019762992859,
0.4048222005367279,
0.09725132584571838,
-0.1310458928346634,
0.18294553458690643,
-0.4338207244873047,
-0.4944343864917755,
-0.48862800002098083,
-0.5965928435325623,
-0.701178789138794,
-0.27504608035087585,
-0.9466675519943237,
-0.33871757984161377,
-0.3065628707408905,
0.1337326169013977,
0.18796706199645996,
0.05189352482557297,
0.14941738545894623,
0.1366722583770752,
-0.29210183024406433,
0.48695629835128784,
-0.8089089393615723,
0.4451620876789093,
0.7769325375556946,
-0.445475697517395,
-0.2703302204608917,
0.1529538780450821,
-0.23535187542438507,
-0.5840343832969666,
0.24768073856830597,
-0.014711997471749783,
-0.5112132430076599,
-0.14658798277378082,
-0.43851134181022644,
-0.580033540725708,
0.8568241000175476,
-0.08904583752155304,
-0.191018745303154,
-0.07888481765985489,
-0.2665022611618042,
0.7629163861274719,
-0.6079016923904419,
0.4177287817001343,
0.4842720329761505,
0.04049745202064514,
0.09689350426197052,
-0.6458930373191833,
-0.37706121802330017,
-0.5465705394744873,
-0.14008575677871704,
0.20130838453769684,
-0.4642285406589508,
0.5875658392906189,
-0.333657830953598,
-0.15359808504581451,
0.08570075780153275,
1.020551085472107,
0.11210209131240845,
0.20924463868141174,
0.5127695202827454,
0.45894181728363037,
0.9721202254295349,
0.11684278398752213,
1.192678451538086,
-0.22586560249328613,
0.2371496856212616,
1.045023798942566,
-0.12411534786224365,
1.5163326263427734,
0.4949987530708313,
-0.026830023154616356,
0.8447456955909729,
0.6012684106826782,
0.4718796908855438,
0.5735398530960083,
-0.15619225800037384,
-0.1392301619052887,
-0.03621750324964523,
-0.24052278697490692,
-0.2695545554161072,
0.2345729023218155,
0.15017452836036682,
-0.11174409836530685,
-0.140883207321167,
-0.29739928245544434,
-0.0277097187936306,
0.27586379647254944,
-0.6534409523010254,
1.1350429058074951,
0.08079561591148376,
-0.8566893935203552,
0.3747882544994354,
-0.09139962494373322,
0.719567596912384,
-0.4609355330467224,
-0.17046469449996948,
-0.220694899559021,
0.14004333317279816,
-0.5343058705329895,
-0.7782235741615295,
0.4222380816936493,
0.2853788435459137,
-0.6372724175453186,
-0.24312354624271393,
0.3793729543685913,
-0.3887765407562256,
-0.4954489767551422,
-0.10911167412996292,
0.6068495512008667,
0.36985352635383606,
0.20018945634365082,
-0.2232196182012558,
-0.34911903738975525,
-0.2608381509780884,
-0.3763614296913147,
0.40272167325019836,
0.2324482649564743,
-0.233491912484169,
0.15383696556091309,
0.39059996604919434,
0.10482817888259888,
-0.31855714321136475,
0.34147152304649353,
0.6762014031410217,
-0.6670832633972168,
-0.8314238786697388,
-0.7678889632225037,
0.35531559586524963,
-0.25775155425071716,
-0.2155531346797943,
0.9074854254722595,
0.8873701691627502,
0.6474134922027588,
0.009886955842375755,
0.7368058562278748,
0.2244579941034317,
0.7784970998764038,
-0.4230685532093048,
0.6390817761421204,
-0.6452573537826538,
0.26862961053848267,
-0.2768607437610626,
-0.9187334179878235,
-0.22768187522888184,
0.6695648431777954,
-0.35425689816474915,
-0.07665370404720306,
0.9988107085227966,
0.7302126884460449,
0.061791323125362396,
0.05853072553873062,
0.02176697924733162,
0.46404576301574707,
-0.08873555809259415,
0.465165376663208,
0.9357870817184448,
-0.4524540603160858,
0.17194588482379913,
-0.027038708329200745,
-0.48366275429725647,
-0.24399203062057495,
-0.6898579001426697,
-0.842229962348938,
-0.45199134945869446,
-0.28187379240989685,
-0.13843989372253418,
0.08626152575016022,
0.7465111613273621,
0.6425474882125854,
-0.7961789965629578,
-0.6524192690849304,
0.10542426258325577,
0.34717071056365967,
-0.30356812477111816,
-0.1810983121395111,
0.5195024013519287,
-0.21288199722766876,
-0.7773576378822327,
0.43743696808815,
0.5701517462730408,
-0.37807193398475647,
-0.3287408947944641,
0.13725315034389496,
-0.13224542140960693,
0.0723663866519928,
0.8572121858596802,
0.10110627859830856,
-0.55184006690979,
-0.37726715207099915,
-0.12716734409332275,
-0.025348393246531487,
0.4337272644042969,
0.8122771382331848,
-0.6913802623748779,
0.5003781318664551,
0.8483437895774841,
0.47114723920822144,
0.6926146745681763,
0.35598984360694885,
0.5580434799194336,
-0.6294617652893066,
-0.08203934133052826,
0.10546048730611801,
0.40354838967323303,
0.1252535581588745,
-0.3038942515850067,
0.34985145926475525,
0.05459810048341751,
-0.5133490562438965,
-0.6474041938781738,
-0.025307664647698402,
-1.0570809841156006,
-0.06363183259963989,
0.7654880881309509,
-0.05400365591049194,
-0.5831400156021118,
0.0333373099565506,
-0.09822721779346466,
-0.16066624224185944,
-0.42705217003822327,
0.9844537973403931,
0.4528123736381531,
-0.28792738914489746,
0.0466439425945282,
-0.12207107245922089,
0.24300846457481384,
0.2219957560300827,
-0.9879119992256165,
-0.05780317261815071,
0.5262829065322876,
0.03189076855778694,
0.3365207314491272,
0.6963881254196167,
-0.5332362055778503,
0.26811137795448303,
-0.23487533628940582,
0.12591056525707245,
0.07093968242406845,
-0.590490460395813,
-0.5225294232368469,
0.5755231380462646,
0.12815865874290466,
0.008468352258205414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00418v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00418v2
|
LLMs for Targeted Sentiment in News Headlines: Exploring the Descriptive-Prescriptive Dilemma
| 2024-03-01T10:10:34 | 2024-05-28T11:04:32 |
Jana Juroš, Laura Majer, Jan Šnajder
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
News headlines often evoke sentiment by intentionally portraying entities in
particular ways, making targeted sentiment analysis (TSA) of headlines a
worthwhile but difficult task. Due to its subjectivity, creating TSA datasets
can involve various annotation paradigms, from descriptive to prescriptive,
either encouraging or limiting subjectivity. LLMs are a good fit for TSA due to
their broad linguistic and world knowledge and in-context learning abilities,
yet their performance depends on prompt design. In this paper, we compare the
accuracy of state-of-the-art LLMs and fine-tuned encoder models for TSA of news
headlines using descriptive and prescriptive datasets across several languages.
Exploring the descriptive--prescriptive continuum, we analyze how performance
is affected by prompt prescriptiveness, ranging from plain zero-shot to
elaborate few-shot prompts. Finally, we evaluate the ability of LLMs to
quantify uncertainty via calibration error and comparison to human label
variation. We find that LLMs outperform fine-tuned encoders on descriptive
datasets, while calibration and F1-score generally improve with increased
prescriptiveness, yet the optimal level varies.
|
[
-0.2652814984321594,
-0.7663193941116333,
0.8779247999191284,
0.5874121785163879,
-0.6473407745361328,
0.25565990805625916,
-0.26576513051986694,
-0.16475512087345123,
0.417529433965683,
0.2634073495864868,
-0.54897540807724,
-0.8906353116035461,
-0.7292284965515137,
0.3982089161872864,
-0.26638856530189514,
1.1810696125030518,
0.0441867969930172,
0.1362181305885315,
-0.36087682843208313,
0.17432522773742676,
-0.21389678120613098,
-0.4098615348339081,
-0.59012371301651,
0.15015535056591034,
0.8936951160430908,
0.19052650034427643,
0.8028126358985901,
0.36376282572746277,
0.6238771080970764,
0.16290636360645294,
-0.24653369188308716,
0.0600564144551754,
-0.28610149025917053,
-0.1568826287984848,
-0.08996068686246872,
-0.5236714482307434,
-0.3967794179916382,
0.10943758487701416,
0.572732150554657,
0.6045543551445007,
0.1589503288269043,
0.24635736644268036,
0.0723087340593338,
0.7762384414672852,
-0.3791297972202301,
-0.1412540227174759,
-0.3771417737007141,
0.08792731165885925,
-0.19326815009117126,
-0.43114131689071655,
-0.17502251267433167,
-0.6801508069038391,
0.297477126121521,
-0.6340921521186829,
-0.03248356282711029,
0.23590128123760223,
1.0819944143295288,
0.45480817556381226,
-0.6159855127334595,
-0.536288321018219,
-0.7127518653869629,
0.8574767112731934,
-0.5805073380470276,
0.3677597939968109,
0.13720814883708954,
0.06472092121839523,
-0.1385386437177658,
-0.38566717505455017,
0.02028345689177513,
-0.3458610773086548,
0.02015475369989872,
0.28654053807258606,
-0.3848057985305786,
0.08270446211099625,
0.27456486225128174,
0.14594998955726624,
-0.6208916306495667,
0.5430940985679626,
-0.31560420989990234,
-0.30856236815452576,
0.3116284906864166,
0.10544674843549728,
-0.1011517122387886,
-0.3979054391384125,
-0.6013737320899963,
0.21714577078819275,
-0.8128670454025269,
0.30032575130462646,
0.6669639348983765,
0.5946227312088013,
-0.12503597140312195,
0.5808085203170776,
-0.4558512270450592,
0.8593899011611938,
0.2643108069896698,
-0.30077752470970154,
0.24687997996807098,
-0.30871522426605225,
-0.1487281322479248,
0.1384526938199997,
0.8773245215415955,
0.6906239986419678,
0.3178054392337799,
-0.00493871234357357,
-0.4293741285800934,
0.04964910075068474,
0.3397367298603058,
-0.5597929954528809,
0.38294264674186707,
0.30316615104675293,
-0.41613537073135376,
-0.5339264869689941,
0.1310393214225769,
-0.9621066451072693,
-0.43239131569862366,
-0.4320620000362396,
0.3683701753616333,
0.024682000279426575,
0.1454792618751526,
0.23147203028202057,
0.0001366176293231547,
0.492113322019577,
0.3323788046836853,
-0.3595440983772278,
-0.14253540337085724,
0.40887483954429626,
0.7751637697219849,
-0.21677418053150177,
0.04692580923438072,
-0.31626731157302856,
-0.2670261561870575,
-0.4561242163181305,
0.9842726588249207,
-0.4810374677181244,
-0.39244264364242554,
0.07283490896224976,
-0.2698805034160614,
0.07784056663513184,
-0.4345809817314148,
0.8489694595336914,
-0.4845656752586365,
0.2468724250793457,
-0.4778134226799011,
-0.29079872369766235,
-0.019163483753800392,
0.578329861164093,
-0.5690252184867859,
0.6237657070159912,
0.15154121816158295,
-0.6442628502845764,
0.5625728368759155,
-0.41028186678886414,
-0.7560907006263733,
-0.38615018129348755,
0.07468490302562714,
-0.40687957406044006,
0.40886935591697693,
0.5620142817497253,
0.5092843770980835,
-0.2893730401992798,
0.3760471045970917,
0.030510444194078445,
-0.24040572345256805,
0.43551087379455566,
-0.28099554777145386,
0.20867428183555603,
0.5144799947738647,
0.08543377369642258,
0.12441977113485336,
-0.6932809948921204,
-0.3299841582775116,
-0.06517752259969711,
-0.4301184415817261,
-0.2833245098590851,
-0.1961464136838913,
-0.11093586683273315,
0.1973716914653778,
0.4630199074745178,
-0.4262186884880066,
-0.15652596950531006,
-0.29077619314193726,
0.1308259665966034,
0.6717039942741394,
0.21976318955421448,
0.5671048164367676,
-0.43699654936790466,
0.8236293792724609,
0.38874176144599915,
0.2790253162384033,
-0.08847640454769135,
-0.20981459319591522,
-0.40035781264305115,
-0.09629758447408676,
0.23262830078601837,
0.613516628742218,
-0.5458544492721558,
0.4388093948364258,
-0.12220654636621475,
-0.39377546310424805,
-0.30242955684661865,
-0.10401663929224014,
0.3055835962295532,
0.5628673434257507,
0.3144235908985138,
0.002969783963635564,
-0.7476239204406738,
-0.784952700138092,
-0.7690743207931519,
0.019230524078011513,
-0.040086306631565094,
0.0731012150645256,
-0.006471638567745686,
-0.025868825614452362,
1.1235440969467163,
-0.44170400500297546,
-0.44029778242111206,
-0.4089648425579071,
0.038362305611371994,
0.4770521819591522,
0.18277859687805176,
0.47928011417388916,
-0.6961081624031067,
-0.28874266147613525,
-0.32699495553970337,
-0.6883541941642761,
-0.31186148524284363,
-0.3191283643245697,
0.17456559836864471,
0.09553925693035126,
0.4538000524044037,
-0.6993788480758667,
0.19029927253723145,
0.23984012007713318,
-0.22402630746364594,
0.6403371691703796,
0.13681241869926453,
0.20651353895664215,
-1.222839117050171,
-0.2331063449382782,
0.4932710528373718,
-0.126678004860878,
-0.6147852540016174,
-0.30340513586997986,
-0.06170947477221489,
0.024898065254092216,
-0.7887059450149536,
0.4611372947692871,
-0.3013536334037781,
-0.0914466381072998,
-0.1766788214445114,
0.14724543690681458,
0.14242759346961975,
0.15201865136623383,
0.09115038812160492,
0.6576007604598999,
0.6048506498336792,
-0.7508482336997986,
0.27879467606544495,
-0.09473997354507446,
-0.40409374237060547,
0.7750399708747864,
-0.49830102920532227,
-0.21694056689739227,
-0.6111077070236206,
0.3075537383556366,
-0.897163450717926,
-0.23196332156658173,
0.29274117946624756,
-0.5743556022644043,
0.19791974127292633,
0.11036957055330276,
-0.4234980046749115,
-0.3595442771911621,
-0.4525150656700134,
0.22623690962791443,
0.6498548984527588,
-0.18761911988258362,
0.5355284810066223,
0.13444407284259796,
-0.03842605650424957,
-0.6198644042015076,
-0.6666192412376404,
0.20083566009998322,
-0.5706620216369629,
-0.04514780268073082,
0.09243190288543701,
0.10646030306816101,
-0.38709452748298645,
-0.12356268614530563,
-0.2655278742313385,
0.19572550058364868,
0.1110495775938034,
0.06205149367451668,
0.1102801114320755,
-0.16889286041259766,
0.024162717163562775,
0.0611339807510376,
-0.10746316611766815,
0.3198392987251282,
-0.20900259912014008,
0.3935469090938568,
-0.10689058154821396,
-0.07842564582824707,
-0.5526038408279419,
0.039181508123874664,
0.5437406897544861,
-0.08088512718677521,
0.4721719026565552,
0.5478799343109131,
-0.2678537368774414,
-0.0010056192986667156,
-0.5677268505096436,
-0.19769898056983948,
-0.4177740216255188,
0.3527074456214905,
-0.35928452014923096,
-0.5263857245445251,
0.5353347063064575,
-0.1704179346561432,
-0.2197704166173935,
0.4414459764957428,
0.38139820098876953,
-0.3756466209888458,
0.9190523028373718,
0.3412645161151886,
-0.2412770390510559,
0.45336055755615234,
0.04469812661409378,
0.06807494163513184,
-0.5754970908164978,
-0.22941800951957703,
-0.5631222128868103,
-0.3625618517398834,
-0.464318186044693,
0.017027854919433594,
0.41788405179977417,
-0.1380506306886673,
-0.17288224399089813,
0.015261489897966385,
-0.2907797396183014,
0.5508735179901123,
0.560306966304779,
0.2742077708244324,
0.27152514457702637,
0.01812922954559326,
0.29452699422836304,
-0.03673404082655907,
-0.3871227204799652,
-0.7222957015037537,
1.0592304468154907,
0.42411676049232483,
1.1409934759140015,
-0.2113720029592514,
0.5967524647712708,
0.2515327036380768,
0.03004017472267151,
-1.0378780364990234,
0.5956833362579346,
-0.26966843008995056,
-0.2884663939476013,
0.014860164374113083,
-0.3913508951663971,
-0.8525853157043457,
-0.1523744910955429,
-0.14632755517959595,
-0.2964063882827759,
0.10887067764997482,
0.009725003503262997,
-0.7250808477401733,
0.1646667718887329,
-0.3688291907310486,
0.6720031499862671,
-0.37973183393478394,
0.06739608943462372,
0.20250679552555084,
-0.6401960849761963,
0.17402394115924835,
-0.1411806344985962,
0.34138473868370056,
-0.3537049889564514,
-0.42215830087661743,
0.7252472639083862,
0.14998577535152435,
1.0851303339004517,
-0.272744357585907,
-0.430713415145874,
0.27471157908439636,
-0.24041873216629028,
0.45626136660575867,
0.11188244819641113,
-0.017196139320731163,
0.16869094967842102,
-0.26260533928871155,
-0.3074330985546112,
-0.46536174416542053,
0.4593379497528076,
-0.8585571646690369,
-0.7489752769470215,
-0.41592860221862793,
-0.5019105076789856,
-0.4537319839000702,
0.11798787862062454,
0.7105317115783691,
0.5281955003738403,
-0.34213724732398987,
-0.03440318629145622,
0.5950360894203186,
-0.14211112260818481,
0.2736797034740448,
0.4916844069957733,
-0.10586724430322647,
-0.3830629885196686,
0.7679190039634705,
0.2731754779815674,
0.0157962404191494,
0.8129732608795166,
0.31959354877471924,
-0.473744660615921,
-0.8115440607070923,
-0.2925356328487396,
0.06524468958377838,
-0.6189085245132446,
-0.4412617087364197,
-0.5391944050788879,
-0.011602528393268585,
-0.30450648069381714,
-0.44074249267578125,
-0.2603471875190735,
-0.14905603229999542,
-0.8236117959022522,
-0.3010798692703247,
0.2485550493001938,
0.5695143938064575,
0.18659834563732147,
0.36996695399284363,
-0.8571578860282898,
0.31672409176826477,
-0.05476304516196251,
0.1997705101966858,
-0.6141555905342102,
-0.7052760720252991,
-0.15102645754814148,
0.08946643024682999,
-0.19737085700035095,
-0.9862458109855652,
0.31202274560928345,
-0.09537011384963989,
0.40212124586105347,
0.5150285959243774,
0.4560978412628174,
0.4581660330295563,
-0.11016970872879028,
0.9279136061668396,
0.026551930233836174,
-0.7110906839370728,
0.8264575004577637,
-0.4675257205963135,
0.46414709091186523,
0.5615344643592834,
0.6310979127883911,
-0.22079408168792725,
-0.6900854110717773,
-0.129274383187294,
-0.5329877138137817,
0.4342103898525238,
-0.20817671716213226,
0.24814318120479584,
-0.2761048376560211,
0.40453094244003296,
0.11880408972501755,
0.3234713077545166,
-0.5881710648536682,
-0.09458217024803162,
-0.25877952575683594,
-0.5016257762908936,
-0.24107599258422852,
-0.458831250667572,
-0.05293611064553261,
0.16274023056030273,
0.3899987041950226,
-0.12071936577558517,
0.08375824242830276,
0.33224910497665405,
-0.15114924311637878,
-0.09604918211698532,
0.453743040561676,
0.8165432810783386,
0.5269070863723755,
-0.2965002954006195,
0.13016948103904724,
0.11903231590986252,
-0.39859524369239807,
0.3745790421962738,
0.01735483668744564,
-0.33389315009117126,
0.12044892460107803,
0.33230891823768616,
0.8448516130447388,
0.3857641816139221,
-0.5453247427940369,
0.5638023018836975,
0.008397772908210754,
-0.12552955746650696,
-0.1784122884273529,
-0.34918212890625,
-0.2735164761543274,
0.23553118109703064,
0.5145760178565979,
0.1807352900505066,
0.16146494448184967,
-0.3870830237865448,
-0.1413424164056778,
0.5171743631362915,
-0.2548685073852539,
-0.49010443687438965,
0.5309233069419861,
0.32102540135383606,
-0.11247167736291885,
0.3111903667449951,
-0.2509806454181671,
-0.43000468611717224,
0.7329743504524231,
0.5035726428031921,
1.0119198560714722,
-0.08985894918441772,
0.3516335189342499,
0.32726988196372986,
0.5236459374427795,
-0.07725749164819717,
0.3374599516391754,
0.18810904026031494,
-0.8757179379463196,
-0.24565787613391876,
-0.6789966225624084,
-0.480828195810318,
-0.09888053685426712,
-0.7888371348381042,
0.35045596957206726,
-0.6183264255523682,
-0.4922139644622803,
-0.37804827094078064,
0.03206239268183708,
-0.7633221745491028,
0.40429210662841797,
0.09438466280698776,
0.8299828171730042,
-0.8139222860336304,
0.3735012114048004,
1.0183541774749756,
-0.29462793469429016,
-0.6006012558937073,
0.35815930366516113,
-0.06533988565206528,
-0.6300251483917236,
0.545333743095398,
0.38695937395095825,
0.09723912924528122,
0.24986594915390015,
-0.3335091471672058,
-0.7739856243133545,
0.8480883836746216,
0.40148603916168213,
-0.656649112701416,
-0.26374614238739014,
0.4757813811302185,
0.4446554481983185,
-0.3042348027229309,
0.11781608313322067,
0.6313207149505615,
0.6821613311767578,
0.18804818391799927,
-0.8400561809539795,
0.010355337522923946,
0.4093882143497467,
-0.19041311740875244,
-0.03237609565258026,
-0.6477963924407959,
0.6274795532226562,
-0.44162142276763916,
-0.2832208573818207,
-0.19017870724201202,
0.7001601457595825,
0.07935353368520737,
0.5442161560058594,
0.39162370562553406,
0.5895103216171265,
0.526941180229187,
-0.32558438181877136,
1.1070301532745361,
-0.25919830799102783,
0.180439293384552,
0.6578115224838257,
-0.14694368839263916,
0.5476003289222717,
0.5238255858421326,
-0.3264356553554535,
0.4719531238079071,
0.9519810676574707,
0.19873665273189545,
0.6147714853286743,
0.10497564822435379,
-0.21594442427158356,
-0.09009776264429092,
-0.3601488471031189,
-0.12674236297607422,
0.5108284950256348,
0.37775498628616333,
-0.3272612690925598,
-0.42660364508628845,
0.3854067921638489,
0.10433445870876312,
0.18417255580425262,
-0.8664679527282715,
0.8397585153579712,
0.27948832511901855,
-0.6764716506004333,
0.22824400663375854,
0.030089229345321655,
0.9426444172859192,
-0.6747195720672607,
0.699731707572937,
-0.3762197494506836,
-0.15336494147777557,
-0.38855859637260437,
-0.9742103815078735,
0.3995792269706726,
0.186899796128273,
-0.1959364265203476,
-0.14055605232715607,
0.7113983631134033,
-0.38550087809562683,
-0.46543046832084656,
-0.00943020824342966,
0.6352560520172119,
0.02164846658706665,
-0.2921644151210785,
-0.5062470436096191,
0.29891860485076904,
-0.2178727090358734,
-0.5670087337493896,
0.26324743032455444,
0.37661710381507874,
0.07306356728076935,
0.4570595622062683,
0.6236072778701782,
0.21536780893802643,
0.06600304692983627,
0.20583823323249817,
0.7126034498214722,
-0.8712242841720581,
-0.6685104370117188,
-0.9611606597900391,
0.2687605023384094,
0.2245551496744156,
-0.39447668194770813,
0.8268105983734131,
0.49332723021507263,
0.5538565516471863,
-0.43179988861083984,
0.5298416018486023,
0.24573960900306702,
0.4560593068599701,
-0.8790634870529175,
0.2859591841697693,
-0.29899269342422485,
0.21093524992465973,
-0.08755411952733994,
-0.9742246270179749,
-0.7195467948913574,
0.3358471393585205,
-0.4070613980293274,
0.1252623349428177,
0.5331777334213257,
0.7755008935928345,
0.3477024435997009,
-0.22412437200546265,
0.3187001347541809,
0.051162466406822205,
0.16282126307487488,
0.6071453094482422,
1.1619125604629517,
-0.04020785167813301,
0.49585530161857605,
-0.10127336531877518,
-0.04724988713860512,
-0.2150907963514328,
-1.1704593896865845,
-0.9117925763130188,
-0.18470703065395355,
-0.2870577871799469,
-0.16702920198440552,
0.11394762992858887,
1.2050076723098755,
0.46158385276794434,
-0.6675645112991333,
0.17569899559020996,
-0.0640355572104454,
0.3549800217151642,
-0.12381842732429504,
-0.30242639780044556,
0.31100353598594666,
-0.8078995943069458,
-0.9120557904243469,
0.3352082073688507,
0.17803381383419037,
0.260363906621933,
-0.18281994760036469,
0.1051846370100975,
0.1813836395740509,
0.3273477554321289,
0.5615752339363098,
0.147808238863945,
-0.7902355194091797,
-0.21979564428329468,
0.11124461889266968,
-0.31621649861335754,
-0.0036932448856532574,
0.8713410496711731,
-0.9716195464134216,
0.11419790238142014,
0.37091967463493347,
0.6890102028846741,
-0.17892886698246002,
0.3697545528411865,
0.3363150656223297,
-1.0785919427871704,
0.08834321051836014,
0.35263946652412415,
0.2257550060749054,
0.3378751575946808,
-0.6110429763793945,
0.09483758360147476,
0.08254748582839966,
-0.3795793950557709,
-0.803970456123352,
0.1780250370502472,
-1.1892443895339966,
-0.09591321647167206,
1.440600037574768,
0.19145467877388,
-0.14753533899784088,
-0.022832533344626427,
-0.2860136926174164,
-0.04142631217837334,
-0.5751348733901978,
0.4632164239883423,
0.5277486443519592,
0.19042176008224487,
-0.18525508046150208,
-0.29996198415756226,
0.6723647713661194,
0.21174819767475128,
-0.7218549251556396,
-0.2751605808734894,
0.36295053362846375,
0.16198447346687317,
-0.10482850670814514,
0.5865150690078735,
0.028043696656823158,
0.19230876863002777,
-0.39944684505462646,
-0.22969664633274078,
-0.21896857023239136,
-0.52805095911026,
-0.5580620169639587,
0.18071570992469788,
0.009966186247766018,
-0.4374452531337738
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.