id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02718v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02718v1
|
DP-CRE: Continual Relation Extraction via Decoupled Contrastive Learning and Memory Structure Preservation
| 2024-03-05T07:16:51 | 2024-03-05T07:16:51 |
Mengyi Huang, Meng Xiao, Ludi Wang, Yi Du
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Continuous Relation Extraction (CRE) aims to incrementally learn relation
knowledge from a non-stationary stream of data. Since the introduction of new
relational tasks can overshadow previously learned information, catastrophic
forgetting becomes a significant challenge in this domain. Current replay-based
training paradigms prioritize all data uniformly and train memory samples
through multiple rounds, which would result in overfitting old tasks and
pronounced bias towards new tasks because of the imbalances of the replay set.
To handle the problem, we introduce the DecouPled CRE (DP-CRE) framework that
decouples the process of prior information preservation and new knowledge
acquisition. This framework examines alterations in the embedding space as new
relation classes emerge, distinctly managing the preservation and acquisition
of knowledge. Extensive experiments show that DP-CRE significantly outperforms
other CRE baselines across two datasets.
|
[
-0.3971578776836395,
-0.6453843116760254,
0.35819247364997864,
0.025591805577278137,
-0.21756918728351593,
0.15061792731285095,
-0.1375798135995865,
-0.3458893895149231,
0.062263280153274536,
0.30509936809539795,
-0.4903569221496582,
-0.30051150918006897,
-0.62979656457901,
-0.05802113562822342,
-0.13577109575271606,
0.9925358295440674,
-0.05964168906211853,
0.07849980890750885,
-0.3349479138851166,
-0.3136034309864044,
-0.7434602975845337,
-0.5532416105270386,
-0.8117356300354004,
-0.4377894401550293,
0.44083288311958313,
0.47063830494880676,
0.4614664912223816,
0.6846683621406555,
0.506334125995636,
0.12732724845409393,
0.0492020845413208,
0.15016694366931915,
-0.8271833658218384,
0.3637572228908539,
-0.4983590841293335,
-0.41010597348213196,
-0.3855893909931183,
-0.19419388473033905,
0.8241621851921082,
0.901824951171875,
-0.3940031826496124,
0.08019416034221649,
0.2201380431652069,
1.000380039215088,
-1.1302659511566162,
0.42194145917892456,
-0.8001147508621216,
-0.006150213070213795,
0.1765168160200119,
-0.3042043447494507,
-0.4171324074268341,
-0.2150057852268219,
0.33979469537734985,
-0.40861454606056213,
0.19737695157527924,
-0.25060030817985535,
0.9804511070251465,
0.11345422267913818,
-0.2629481554031372,
-0.24789510667324066,
-0.8511533141136169,
0.757218599319458,
-0.15113410353660583,
0.700171947479248,
0.23924963176250458,
0.2547798752784729,
-0.17838414013385773,
-0.7777063250541687,
-0.4350460469722748,
-0.09713095426559448,
0.058780524879693985,
0.35664984583854675,
0.03783850744366646,
-0.11429325491189957,
0.18977899849414825,
0.6268861889839172,
-0.24939489364624023,
-0.15856719017028809,
-0.04987819492816925,
0.23161081969738007,
0.3103847801685333,
0.14547458291053772,
0.2885218858718872,
0.044563814997673035,
-0.78133225440979,
-0.08011303097009659,
-0.7410035133361816,
-0.3408149182796478,
-0.3579410910606384,
-0.10830525308847427,
0.017674937844276428,
0.15998345613479614,
-0.0347258560359478,
0.2024204134941101,
0.20694929361343384,
-0.13050557672977448,
0.12639877200126648,
-0.1911092847585678,
-0.33927518129348755,
-0.1837712973356247,
0.5264280438423157,
0.36067676544189453,
0.38417962193489075,
-0.37794923782348633,
0.05976242572069168,
0.2865351736545563,
0.11640483886003494,
-0.6080853343009949,
-0.7203136086463928,
0.05350911244750023,
-0.40204426646232605,
0.054924409836530685,
0.08259278535842896,
-0.9575225114822388,
-0.04297693818807602,
-0.5112767815589905,
-0.08155397325754166,
-0.7688312530517578,
-0.45241647958755493,
0.06652851402759552,
-0.3827207684516907,
0.16851089894771576,
0.2552190124988556,
-0.8476409316062927,
0.5703173279762268,
0.3771691918373108,
0.48944640159606934,
-0.43911194801330566,
-0.3939635157585144,
-0.4688786268234253,
0.43751591444015503,
-0.1434703916311264,
0.7214051485061646,
-0.48711779713630676,
-0.3991365432739258,
-0.00592117290943861,
-0.007668993901461363,
-0.3568963408470154,
-0.9501723051071167,
0.2741805613040924,
-0.8852257132530212,
0.1530432552099228,
-0.403535395860672,
-0.7262967824935913,
-0.06470707058906555,
0.5801164507865906,
-0.580173909664154,
0.9258291721343994,
0.37037599086761475,
-0.8234384059906006,
0.536449134349823,
-0.05073476582765579,
-0.004128456115722656,
-0.03128981590270996,
-0.38435032963752747,
-0.6578534245491028,
-0.20230059325695038,
0.14063629508018494,
0.2358330339193344,
-0.2048654854297638,
0.25001752376556396,
-0.5194616913795471,
-0.0860615149140358,
-0.014986268244683743,
-0.18450365960597992,
0.6386664509773254,
0.1647845208644867,
-0.1517259031534195,
-0.3571245074272156,
-0.7836126685142517,
-0.15235313773155212,
0.19065184891223907,
-0.4805260896682739,
-0.5057477355003357,
0.2206285446882248,
-0.37716972827911377,
0.45134180784225464,
0.08648034185171127,
-0.4530459940433502,
0.1582985669374466,
-0.09037661552429199,
0.3298090100288391,
0.2645113170146942,
0.7516695261001587,
0.6098297834396362,
-0.5568828582763672,
0.34861376881599426,
0.6257239580154419,
0.09016354382038116,
-0.43446245789527893,
0.1448165625333786,
-0.7073603272438049,
-0.16032889485359192,
0.22321724891662598,
0.7948444485664368,
-0.6201843023300171,
0.32521697878837585,
-0.5622124075889587,
-0.05427766218781471,
0.18426010012626648,
0.34395265579223633,
0.4722519516944885,
0.48237845301628113,
0.5840816497802734,
-0.39016473293304443,
-0.6548818945884705,
-0.8785514831542969,
0.13767102360725403,
0.11475933343172073,
-0.11801201105117798,
0.19582486152648926,
0.3753466010093689,
-0.3732852339744568,
0.7525134682655334,
-0.5901617407798767,
-0.3865426778793335,
-0.02517830766737461,
-0.19046355783939362,
-0.27124926447868347,
0.7429040670394897,
0.4663689136505127,
-0.8016311526298523,
-0.3150599002838135,
-0.19201582670211792,
-1.1394317150115967,
0.5385353565216064,
-0.4325945973396301,
-0.3393702507019043,
0.15444327890872955,
0.49794095754623413,
-0.5359315276145935,
0.21854592859745026,
0.07463773339986801,
0.08314374834299088,
0.33344632387161255,
0.03288489952683449,
0.17456023395061493,
-0.9436630606651306,
-0.03437332436442375,
-0.16260065138339996,
-0.0989634245634079,
-0.21886307001113892,
0.06078697368502617,
0.2664087414741516,
-0.1568203866481781,
-0.20263344049453735,
0.19672925770282745,
-0.9844367504119873,
0.0705011785030365,
-0.026629535481333733,
0.693148672580719,
0.20283688604831696,
0.7075523734092712,
0.28097066283226013,
0.16093431413173676,
0.40132060647010803,
-0.8136968612670898,
-0.05889144539833069,
0.6284956932067871,
-0.021518386900424957,
0.6747530102729797,
-0.03703472763299942,
0.18229834735393524,
-0.1724446564912796,
0.12201698869466782,
-0.833486020565033,
0.12464945018291473,
0.12989939749240875,
-0.3019973635673523,
0.7764824032783508,
-0.37464579939842224,
-0.2223622351884842,
-0.030049214139580727,
-0.39513370394706726,
0.5024363994598389,
0.37390345335006714,
-0.6811169385910034,
0.47891172766685486,
0.571746826171875,
-0.16457848250865936,
-0.7548295259475708,
-0.37480640411376953,
0.060909077525138855,
-0.09434571862220764,
-0.4703298807144165,
0.5411439538002014,
0.12589812278747559,
-0.365754634141922,
0.2092330902814865,
-0.49460551142692566,
-0.5660792589187622,
-0.22074507176876068,
0.1474764496088028,
0.39222532510757446,
-0.18705426156520844,
0.28705400228500366,
-0.019001616165041924,
-0.04794683679938316,
0.15560998022556305,
-0.10546763986349106,
0.5998008251190186,
0.34860727190971375,
-0.013999953866004944,
-0.47957661747932434,
0.4719525873661041,
0.484855055809021,
-0.1166112944483757,
0.7625640630722046,
0.033315036445856094,
-0.6124261021614075,
-0.2244814932346344,
-0.7285659909248352,
-0.17885956168174744,
-0.3734879195690155,
0.49843376874923706,
-0.39895176887512207,
-0.4933202564716339,
0.5632767081260681,
-0.4112551510334015,
0.22633180022239685,
0.3430122137069702,
0.06862140446901321,
-0.06526464968919754,
0.24594339728355408,
0.6594810485839844,
-0.2406933605670929,
0.6846588850021362,
-0.5051331520080566,
-0.13331174850463867,
-0.8658045530319214,
-0.4855843782424927,
-0.19586487114429474,
-0.11556731164455414,
-0.17416192591190338,
-0.1154523640871048,
-0.05042106658220291,
0.8020728826522827,
-0.40746983885765076,
0.3483901917934418,
-0.2828024923801422,
0.47175878286361694,
0.019414598122239113,
0.5112423300743103,
0.4556373357772827,
0.07385518401861191,
0.22518666088581085,
-0.11361651867628098,
-0.8600156307220459,
-0.29030102491378784,
0.9014008045196533,
0.24403375387191772,
0.4370587468147278,
-0.32167723774909973,
0.9579644203186035,
0.08226700872182846,
0.42336902022361755,
-0.6197119951248169,
0.4059849679470062,
0.10429446399211884,
-0.27664875984191895,
-0.09776380658149719,
-0.49751704931259155,
-0.9852465987205505,
0.2544209063053131,
-0.24881455302238464,
-0.45595279335975647,
0.6651306748390198,
0.5268303751945496,
-0.014091819524765015,
0.49091729521751404,
-0.43747392296791077,
0.610804557800293,
0.16762420535087585,
-0.6891803741455078,
-0.5060513615608215,
-0.6778402924537659,
0.5514421463012695,
0.16252224147319794,
0.08515874296426773,
0.09493110328912735,
0.025741606950759888,
0.46034520864486694,
0.013912026770412922,
0.6254743337631226,
-0.3100218176841736,
0.12303756177425385,
0.3705209493637085,
0.5067603588104248,
0.5306521654129028,
0.42738234996795654,
-0.013097170740365982,
0.12704439461231232,
0.14957909286022186,
-0.6057381629943848,
-0.8032472729682922,
0.5874956250190735,
-0.4211387038230896,
-0.22046269476413727,
-0.3050331175327301,
-0.3164218068122864,
-0.26785561442375183,
0.1783563792705536,
0.20664018392562866,
0.4755885899066925,
-0.6005608439445496,
0.11943090707063675,
0.9148269891738892,
-0.15890280902385712,
0.35716497898101807,
0.47110220789909363,
0.22063104808330536,
-0.8356691002845764,
0.6569575667381287,
-0.049150530248880386,
0.4358128011226654,
0.6681767106056213,
-0.25966888666152954,
-0.1854296177625656,
-0.5727828741073608,
0.03201501816511154,
0.2934657335281372,
-0.829107940196991,
-0.22833910584449768,
-0.6629534959793091,
-0.20209351181983948,
0.04049299284815788,
-0.15533247590065002,
-0.5856758952140808,
-0.30454516410827637,
-0.13501232862472534,
0.003095239633694291,
-0.12096836417913437,
0.3913589119911194,
-0.0470418781042099,
-0.11882257461547852,
-1.0381578207015991,
0.459828644990921,
0.12509015202522278,
0.16747388243675232,
0.0673191174864769,
-0.2277207225561142,
-0.182093545794487,
0.07837530970573425,
-0.5668555498123169,
-0.7803900241851807,
0.15885359048843384,
0.2245360165834427,
0.6910281777381897,
0.3156605660915375,
0.1485142707824707,
0.6371831893920898,
-0.37159663438796997,
0.5176572799682617,
0.3598477244377136,
-0.5176658630371094,
0.44945213198661804,
-0.28850263357162476,
0.19439604878425598,
0.8133261203765869,
0.4962230324745178,
-0.4131162464618683,
-0.06758628785610199,
-0.8779581189155579,
-0.952294647693634,
0.17752881348133087,
0.06372682750225067,
-0.1362743079662323,
-0.6101250648498535,
0.9383454918861389,
-0.05590257793664932,
0.3161814510822296,
-0.541297197341919,
-0.27198153734207153,
-0.07298130542039871,
0.05605039745569229,
0.27113205194473267,
-0.6717151999473572,
-0.10687533766031265,
-0.1489824503660202,
0.4921901822090149,
0.4107627272605896,
0.2922171950340271,
0.37843263149261475,
-0.4685826301574707,
0.046491771936416626,
0.21890856325626373,
0.19020617008209229,
0.9232282042503357,
-0.2891349494457245,
0.0532943457365036,
0.4198057949542999,
-0.4974641501903534,
-0.011010528542101383,
-0.20239436626434326,
0.07799219340085983,
-0.19662751257419586,
0.46548038721084595,
0.28993484377861023,
0.6596195101737976,
-0.4175429940223694,
0.3720914423465729,
0.1877119094133377,
-0.4057377278804779,
-0.686677873134613,
0.03182403743267059,
0.07935409247875214,
0.014985519461333752,
0.17133928835391998,
0.2028975933790207,
-0.04185281693935394,
-0.7004421353340149,
0.7856938242912292,
0.3339442312717438,
-0.3169917166233063,
-0.15956076979637146,
0.4782896041870117,
0.10295701026916504,
-0.10841605812311172,
1.0739648342132568,
0.0689898282289505,
-0.21303102374076843,
0.39547863602638245,
0.505165696144104,
0.7862212657928467,
-0.31950217485427856,
-0.18895551562309265,
0.8409897089004517,
-0.09137090295553207,
-0.3211360573768616,
0.17360837757587433,
-0.4518342912197113,
-0.8375529050827026,
-0.21061228215694427,
-0.3700268268585205,
-0.37390410900115967,
0.1616753786802292,
-1.2021640539169312,
0.19523705542087555,
-0.4522057771682739,
0.1666763722896576,
-0.41966110467910767,
-0.02721365913748741,
-0.6257569789886475,
0.2775585949420929,
-0.30194157361984253,
0.8642720580101013,
-0.6297236084938049,
0.9643597602844238,
0.32139620184898376,
-0.5531169176101685,
-0.5027360320091248,
0.026588398963212967,
-0.2133801132440567,
-0.5287755131721497,
0.6747705936431885,
-0.22260117530822754,
-0.13724885880947113,
0.062310218811035156,
-0.126763716340065,
-0.6865875720977783,
1.0668212175369263,
0.4680922031402588,
-0.9054152965545654,
-0.15222236514091492,
-0.21756087243556976,
0.3012121915817261,
-0.3769274055957794,
-0.09341329336166382,
0.7758854031562805,
0.12075542658567429,
0.004092243034392595,
-0.4285542964935303,
-0.01041832659393549,
-0.13849616050720215,
-0.14590822160243988,
0.5836366415023804,
-0.5577517151832581,
0.5802868604660034,
-0.08499418944120407,
-0.6235073804855347,
-0.19401811063289642,
0.35674312710762024,
0.29833704233169556,
0.20873457193374634,
0.5197747945785522,
0.7028059959411621,
0.49161529541015625,
-0.017661603167653084,
0.7542264461517334,
-0.31537196040153503,
0.30103275179862976,
1.686618685722351,
-0.36297744512557983,
0.9741122126579285,
0.37151235342025757,
-0.25587430596351624,
0.609345018863678,
0.44664567708969116,
-0.13371963798999786,
0.5268845558166504,
-0.16911707818508148,
-0.3480173349380493,
-0.25997209548950195,
0.4148709177970886,
-0.3945559859275818,
0.1865672767162323,
0.3389407694339752,
-0.5081730484962463,
-0.5302196741104126,
-0.20056280493736267,
-0.023252030834555626,
0.3680611848831177,
-0.15213192999362946,
0.9480519890785217,
0.4244576394557953,
-0.7023380398750305,
0.8404316902160645,
-0.7536101341247559,
0.2054504007101059,
-0.6271786689758301,
-0.3756558299064636,
-0.3609141409397125,
0.5215578079223633,
-0.2229585200548172,
-0.3833034336566925,
0.5496408939361572,
-0.669541597366333,
-0.6629680395126343,
0.007143615745007992,
0.4632842242717743,
-0.7077783346176147,
0.0921853631734848,
0.6580063104629517,
0.5137779116630554,
-0.1625358611345291,
-0.04277389496564865,
-0.5870686769485474,
-0.010050881654024124,
0.039530862122774124,
-0.254326194524765,
0.6650563478469849,
0.42341527342796326,
0.02576306276023388,
0.6788427829742432,
0.2892562448978424,
-0.00746174668893218,
-0.07029931992292404,
-0.15217073261737823,
1.0715020895004272,
-0.7934786677360535,
-0.33137959241867065,
-0.9613009691238403,
0.5158108472824097,
-0.2014206349849701,
-0.08100803941488266,
0.6905500292778015,
0.7112300395965576,
0.8050121068954468,
-0.09401766955852509,
0.550860583782196,
0.1134885847568512,
0.5376928448677063,
-0.5298736095428467,
0.2738313674926758,
-0.22261586785316467,
0.31593307852745056,
-0.4555727243423462,
-0.9767364263534546,
-0.26544034481048584,
0.39392250776290894,
-0.03795580193400383,
-0.12250527739524841,
1.1774948835372925,
0.43634575605392456,
-0.11220531165599823,
-0.10500925779342651,
0.1900090128183365,
-0.15638333559036255,
0.26427343487739563,
0.9586595296859741,
0.6136497259140015,
-0.5511594414710999,
0.7454119324684143,
-0.3517560660839081,
-0.4093029201030731,
0.33454030752182007,
-0.8334745764732361,
-0.9048574566841125,
-0.5570945143699646,
-0.6777341365814209,
-0.2605384290218353,
0.17835907638072968,
0.6723280549049377,
0.6813350915908813,
-0.757942259311676,
-0.11875370889902115,
-0.3742738664150238,
-0.03040929138660431,
-0.42848604917526245,
-0.28949010372161865,
0.4892120957374573,
-0.5549537539482117,
-0.5380369424819946,
0.38771650195121765,
0.43402084708213806,
0.048047762364149094,
0.19302889704704285,
0.13206326961517334,
-0.31371429562568665,
-0.3917921781539917,
0.6117386221885681,
0.6194007396697998,
-0.10993807762861252,
-0.1794816106557846,
-0.31985148787498474,
0.1790638566017151,
0.51229327917099,
0.9893964529037476,
-0.8179895877838135,
0.20877644419670105,
0.37269875407218933,
0.6518776416778564,
0.8499680161476135,
0.2198706716299057,
0.8384647369384766,
-0.5750756859779358,
0.28714120388031006,
0.32901236414909363,
0.5456424355506897,
0.10526027530431747,
-0.49125176668167114,
0.5198633074760437,
0.3537268042564392,
-0.7921395897865295,
-0.7540265917778015,
0.5968878269195557,
-1.0104888677597046,
-0.4362075924873352,
0.7357825040817261,
-0.42428603768348694,
0.1351759135723114,
-0.4413846731185913,
0.021497560665011406,
0.4931967854499817,
-0.1213262677192688,
1.0012950897216797,
0.4356345236301422,
-0.2153167873620987,
-0.5544915795326233,
-0.4157756567001343,
0.626311719417572,
0.26572147011756897,
-0.6714459657669067,
0.4786917269229889,
0.7276042699813843,
0.7304720878601074,
0.11291246116161346,
0.7464438676834106,
-0.5565744042396545,
0.3040044605731964,
0.3589254319667816,
0.06093647703528404,
-0.1064281091094017,
-0.4188840985298157,
-0.0954517275094986,
0.6215264797210693,
0.07540081441402435,
-0.4492914080619812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02715v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02715v2
|
Crossing Linguistic Horizons: Finetuning and Comprehensive Evaluation of Vietnamese Large Language Models
| 2024-03-05T07:13:28 | 2024-05-26T17:13:32 |
Sang T. Truong, Duc Q. Nguyen, Toan Nguyen, Dong D. Le, Nhi N. Truong, Tho Quan, Sanmi Koyejo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have underscored their
importance in the evolution of artificial intelligence. However, despite
extensive pretraining on multilingual datasets, available open-sourced LLMs
exhibit limited effectiveness in processing Vietnamese. The challenge is
exacerbated by the absence of systematic benchmark datasets and metrics
tailored for Vietnamese LLM evaluation. To mitigate these issues, we have
finetuned LLMs specifically for Vietnamese and developed a comprehensive
evaluation framework encompassing 10 common tasks and 31 metrics. Our
evaluation results reveal that the fine-tuned LLMs exhibit enhanced
comprehension and generative capabilities in Vietnamese. Moreover, our analysis
indicates that models with more parameters can introduce more biases and
uncalibrated outputs and the key factor influencing LLM performance is the
quality of the training or fine-tuning datasets. These insights underscore the
significance of meticulous fine-tuning with high-quality datasets in enhancing
LLM performance.
|
[
-0.4241348206996918,
-0.8410070538520813,
0.7331245541572571,
0.05635572969913483,
-0.22915680706501007,
0.1707383394241333,
-0.7415123581886292,
-0.3508385121822357,
-0.3006857931613922,
0.8300079107284546,
-0.44274285435676575,
-0.6944355964660645,
-0.8247642517089844,
0.2311539202928543,
-0.2382250428199768,
0.8405645489692688,
-0.021798672154545784,
0.009780433028936386,
-0.05361250415444374,
-0.359920859336853,
-0.5161483883857727,
-0.3486465811729431,
-0.6218286752700806,
-0.5650978088378906,
0.4499002993106842,
0.633983314037323,
0.6359734535217285,
0.8605231642723083,
0.4668852686882019,
0.27321016788482666,
0.0091756172478199,
0.42112335562705994,
-0.7907775640487671,
-0.06930344551801682,
-0.11428900063037872,
-0.5097017884254456,
-0.3304007053375244,
0.023637091740965843,
0.7768887877464294,
0.9169498682022095,
0.14690761268138885,
0.24729035794734955,
0.2048262655735016,
0.82352215051651,
-0.5292245149612427,
0.2590087354183197,
-0.6733263731002808,
-0.17987331748008728,
-0.2234814316034317,
-0.20165444910526276,
-0.16546304523944855,
-0.17801345884799957,
0.30459076166152954,
-0.5589045286178589,
-0.16810697317123413,
-0.5064039826393127,
0.7445055246353149,
0.4183299243450165,
-0.5556487441062927,
-0.12425288558006287,
-0.8447738885879517,
0.9150934815406799,
-0.7083092331886292,
0.6200677156448364,
0.19275809824466705,
0.2943059504032135,
0.043553050607442856,
-0.5225203633308411,
-0.23958785831928253,
-0.5127276182174683,
0.21947672963142395,
0.013572346419095993,
-0.08113269507884979,
0.23800191283226013,
0.2542395293712616,
0.43747052550315857,
-0.5506303310394287,
0.6130229234695435,
-0.4514772295951843,
-0.09127546101808548,
0.7759668231010437,
0.2516191601753235,
0.0032142556738108397,
-0.09446767717599869,
-0.22598384320735931,
0.09173161536455154,
-0.6680750846862793,
-0.0833829864859581,
0.2728337049484253,
0.6528088450431824,
-0.1633729636669159,
0.7848144173622131,
-0.5387398600578308,
0.938533365726471,
-0.3522709906101227,
-0.1724380999803543,
0.25494495034217834,
-0.482026606798172,
-0.23366519808769226,
-0.3998924195766449,
0.726679265499115,
0.48390281200408936,
0.7537182569503784,
-0.1694534569978714,
-0.4366980195045471,
0.14121398329734802,
0.04175347462296486,
-0.42833685874938965,
0.0114922309294343,
0.30190950632095337,
-0.3941463232040405,
0.07880880683660507,
0.11741241067647934,
-0.5939314961433411,
-0.214009627699852,
-0.9515140652656555,
0.3120470345020294,
-0.4463110566139221,
-0.2438969761133194,
0.28306418657302856,
-0.036626387387514114,
0.2668831944465637,
0.30113455653190613,
-0.5650654435157776,
0.13642947375774384,
1.029679536819458,
0.9432071447372437,
-0.5413028001785278,
-0.5147623419761658,
-0.6977847814559937,
-0.0651203915476799,
-0.369948148727417,
0.6370481252670288,
-0.5887832045555115,
-0.1641806960105896,
0.38331884145736694,
-0.04979492723941803,
0.016734248027205467,
-0.8537565469741821,
0.539425253868103,
-0.30830422043800354,
-0.14886704087257385,
0.020047765225172043,
-0.6251406669616699,
-0.17904086410999298,
0.21807298064231873,
-0.6773408651351929,
0.9016344547271729,
0.44437074661254883,
-0.31138068437576294,
0.38718897104263306,
-0.3939027190208435,
-0.37716445326805115,
0.2237735092639923,
-0.03855815529823303,
-0.021444253623485565,
0.27890947461128235,
0.21485449373722076,
0.690887451171875,
-0.5384608507156372,
0.3033972680568695,
-0.185618057847023,
-0.3617313802242279,
-0.02974552847445011,
-0.43449002504348755,
0.7129899859428406,
0.30436599254608154,
-0.19226661324501038,
0.4205764830112457,
-0.9752126932144165,
0.21614903211593628,
-0.10123516619205475,
-0.46030426025390625,
-0.4241379201412201,
-0.43280091881752014,
0.34477728605270386,
0.19549815356731415,
0.3511557877063751,
-0.18460358679294586,
-0.012505533173680305,
-0.4121072590351105,
0.641815185546875,
0.5769972801208496,
-0.19836640357971191,
0.48312151432037354,
-0.25966256856918335,
0.6123969554901123,
-0.05729597434401512,
-0.034774333238601685,
-0.19256407022476196,
-0.2939382493495941,
-1.0091360807418823,
-0.3145770728588104,
0.15613894164562225,
0.6718411445617676,
-0.7677582502365112,
0.5853598117828369,
-0.35043540596961975,
-0.7532572150230408,
-0.8131037354469299,
0.4250142574310303,
0.3078792989253998,
0.2169678956270218,
0.35289397835731506,
-0.4187111258506775,
-0.47099483013153076,
-0.9066108465194702,
-0.4347299039363861,
0.09103863686323166,
-0.2728549540042877,
0.19256527721881866,
0.3979608118534088,
-0.5541875958442688,
0.7594178318977356,
-0.19498229026794434,
-0.3021391034126282,
-0.3421243727207184,
-0.018707595765590668,
0.2596767246723175,
0.39374157786369324,
0.4314238727092743,
-0.5399611592292786,
-0.2807149887084961,
0.3388298451900482,
-0.6862274408340454,
-0.29935261607170105,
-0.17592178285121918,
-0.02489091269671917,
0.17487774789333344,
0.7933732271194458,
-0.5771957039833069,
-0.09868843108415604,
0.5165742635726929,
-0.1957688331604004,
0.6156111359596252,
-0.1772562861442566,
-0.03389203920960426,
-0.6813433170318604,
-0.06006511300802231,
0.23295626044273376,
-0.1573023796081543,
-0.6412655711174011,
0.3961734473705292,
-0.13963523507118225,
0.09947922825813293,
-0.4469902217388153,
0.728561282157898,
-0.30014827847480774,
0.03070639632642269,
-0.2672860026359558,
0.25523656606674194,
-0.29384493827819824,
0.16848516464233398,
-0.05335686728358269,
0.5169065594673157,
0.5899486541748047,
-0.6742462515830994,
0.5126644968986511,
-0.08607664704322815,
-0.39610472321510315,
0.6453192234039307,
-0.6478124260902405,
-0.015308713540434837,
-0.06765255331993103,
-0.14280617237091064,
-0.7507137656211853,
-0.15479163825511932,
-0.034916263073682785,
-0.10087063908576965,
0.2299102544784546,
-0.038662854582071304,
-0.39033734798431396,
-0.190810889005661,
-0.12499246746301651,
0.2910684645175934,
0.2955307066440582,
-0.41001206636428833,
0.2849559783935547,
0.3494274318218231,
-0.15729522705078125,
-0.22572298347949982,
-0.4878815710544586,
0.20970982313156128,
-0.6516814231872559,
-0.3745797872543335,
0.07340876013040543,
0.055914487689733505,
-0.5129192471504211,
-0.4494290053844452,
0.17830504477024078,
0.0350431427359581,
0.04885079711675644,
-0.07831202447414398,
0.022252148017287254,
-0.4706065356731415,
0.02559340000152588,
0.01599738746881485,
-0.2999275326728821,
0.0695238783955574,
-0.721449077129364,
0.5846812725067139,
-0.19811441004276276,
-0.040045566856861115,
-0.3791656196117401,
0.05476927384734154,
0.6862377524375916,
-0.49711576104164124,
0.5085835456848145,
0.6711379885673523,
-0.40107208490371704,
-0.09790117293596268,
-0.663561999797821,
0.00423885602504015,
-0.418621301651001,
0.7753949165344238,
-0.5422312021255493,
-1.2154977321624756,
0.41057148575782776,
-0.2537219226360321,
0.06925071030855179,
0.5713640451431274,
0.6712645888328552,
0.30851924419403076,
0.7770876884460449,
0.8875939249992371,
-0.17372378706932068,
0.41807860136032104,
-0.26411670446395874,
-0.12139904499053955,
-0.6762222647666931,
-0.05723245441913605,
-0.5417042970657349,
0.05466657131910324,
-1.1636216640472412,
-0.6488627791404724,
0.17099222540855408,
0.05853378772735596,
-0.5121235847473145,
0.20740824937820435,
-0.2135487049818039,
0.3837590217590332,
0.469551682472229,
-0.12186586111783981,
0.4963426887989044,
0.11831130087375641,
-0.0048940726555883884,
-0.13923762738704681,
-0.7311763167381287,
-0.9548401832580566,
1.2880653142929077,
0.5084851980209351,
0.691778302192688,
-0.33663180470466614,
0.4836118221282959,
0.0004271807847544551,
-0.029805881902575493,
-0.7285716533660889,
0.41915586590766907,
-0.5177411437034607,
-0.10402224957942963,
-0.5701472759246826,
-0.5834751129150391,
-0.8638929128646851,
0.18534879386425018,
-0.12188290804624557,
-0.6180266737937927,
-0.2272876352071762,
-0.3639075458049774,
-0.24887679517269135,
-0.0544840507209301,
-0.5543326735496521,
0.8790680766105652,
-0.37701916694641113,
-0.23263360559940338,
-0.38988590240478516,
-0.5689921379089355,
0.35860520601272583,
-0.3295849561691284,
0.13789485394954681,
-0.28831374645233154,
-0.12874814867973328,
0.6894944310188293,
-0.04526093602180481,
0.536552906036377,
0.0008280111360363662,
-0.4505029022693634,
0.16041608154773712,
-0.12395276129245758,
-0.0845469981431961,
0.3211156725883484,
-0.2337648719549179,
0.5080985426902771,
-0.03993704915046692,
-0.4470568001270294,
-0.3510226607322693,
0.8708575367927551,
-0.8939328193664551,
-0.5712485313415527,
-0.04699532687664032,
-0.6922322511672974,
-0.3831576406955719,
0.4185343086719513,
0.2785857021808624,
-0.044204406440258026,
-0.3033468425273895,
0.011060375720262527,
0.3765813112258911,
-0.40527772903442383,
-0.031167808920145035,
0.4397571086883545,
-0.12790022790431976,
-0.45003634691238403,
0.9828684329986572,
0.2221130132675171,
0.41273561120033264,
0.3810212016105652,
0.042197179049253464,
-0.17947377264499664,
-0.5695748925209045,
-0.3817637264728546,
0.3567560315132141,
-0.6129372715950012,
-0.08560093492269516,
-0.44004204869270325,
-0.44932740926742554,
-0.24997985363006592,
0.01692270115017891,
-0.534792423248291,
-0.3253761827945709,
-0.2579648196697235,
-0.030259158462285995,
0.2761727273464203,
0.9481341242790222,
0.03268253803253174,
0.47923919558525085,
-0.8628113865852356,
0.3917652368545532,
0.08163301646709442,
0.4442705512046814,
-0.06566229462623596,
-0.632034957408905,
-0.3692825734615326,
0.22046612203121185,
-0.18607856333255768,
-0.34784331917762756,
0.2740548551082611,
0.30613934993743896,
0.5251946449279785,
0.3976026475429535,
-0.2319115698337555,
0.7690116167068481,
-0.5213313102722168,
0.5378783941268921,
-0.1967032551765442,
-0.9550261497497559,
0.5415753722190857,
-0.5216366648674011,
0.6211742758750916,
0.5335609912872314,
0.37064895033836365,
-0.4983590841293335,
-0.6423563361167908,
-0.30124297738075256,
-0.9244070649147034,
0.4245383143424988,
-0.011187701486051083,
0.1648910492658615,
0.24852566421031952,
0.6377554535865784,
0.4764113128185272,
0.13049764931201935,
-0.48886826634407043,
-0.045358847826719284,
0.16289202868938446,
-0.024463746696710587,
-0.7119762897491455,
-0.11554593592882156,
-0.04326048865914345,
-0.4204486310482025,
0.28914186358451843,
-0.27151599526405334,
-0.11202755570411682,
-0.15141601860523224,
-0.07483451813459396,
-0.11054771393537521,
0.14290161430835724,
0.545786440372467,
1.0295567512512207,
0.14974363148212433,
-0.031186627224087715,
0.23287653923034668,
-0.27024567127227783,
0.06692012399435043,
0.3101445734500885,
-0.045280180871486664,
-0.014369080774486065,
0.7331975698471069,
0.8392532467842102,
-0.09713658690452576,
-0.8152576088905334,
-0.036019936203956604,
0.013895632699131966,
0.10647542029619217,
-0.17190758883953094,
0.2097165882587433,
0.005213578697293997,
0.32614946365356445,
0.35721272230148315,
-0.20686158537864685,
-0.025329481810331345,
-0.44604071974754333,
0.16817916929721832,
0.40572890639305115,
-0.4836854338645935,
-0.16800667345523834,
0.5735024809837341,
0.09939457476139069,
-0.193663090467453,
0.8618136644363403,
0.2561233341693878,
-0.45055872201919556,
0.6138226985931396,
0.2480398416519165,
0.7356715202331543,
-0.23503398895263672,
0.07243853807449341,
0.36326536536216736,
0.5729082226753235,
-0.019207576289772987,
0.21573776006698608,
0.16842153668403625,
-0.51258385181427,
-0.5368965268135071,
-0.8819878101348877,
-0.22559112310409546,
0.410888671875,
-0.6766580939292908,
0.5134759545326233,
-0.178055539727211,
-0.09401099383831024,
-0.23980802297592163,
0.19377700984477997,
-0.9812833070755005,
0.43367210030555725,
0.2841872274875641,
1.0139989852905273,
-0.7707309126853943,
0.6973220109939575,
0.7321191430091858,
-0.2250927835702896,
-0.42458197474479675,
0.06204955652356148,
-0.12214288115501404,
-0.7222790718078613,
0.454826295375824,
0.42613574862480164,
0.13345462083816528,
0.017106184735894203,
-0.2817367911338806,
-0.8052829504013062,
0.7559146285057068,
0.718352198600769,
-0.7747494578361511,
0.07009977102279663,
0.7020326256752014,
0.7732609510421753,
-0.5430721640586853,
0.2587481737136841,
1.3175642490386963,
0.5153650641441345,
-0.324538916349411,
-1.2743010520935059,
-0.20284058153629303,
-0.02099992148578167,
0.171758770942688,
-0.07280631363391876,
-0.6481826901435852,
0.6810916066169739,
-0.17815284430980682,
-0.006812035106122494,
0.260721355676651,
0.7811403274536133,
0.3663810193538666,
0.23350857198238373,
0.29885974526405334,
0.47452014684677124,
0.7386726140975952,
-0.21923983097076416,
0.761982262134552,
-0.31742459535598755,
0.08237602561712265,
0.916587233543396,
-0.2103697657585144,
0.8867048025131226,
0.489969938993454,
-0.1151897981762886,
0.027639681473374367,
0.8813651204109192,
0.04312130808830261,
0.24239198863506317,
0.360565185546875,
0.06289523839950562,
-0.2838717997074127,
-0.32642239332199097,
-0.2916037142276764,
0.9045116901397705,
0.5328049659729004,
-0.1157640665769577,
-0.0931168645620346,
0.2973845303058624,
-0.19753989577293396,
0.3027530908584595,
-0.45879507064819336,
0.6605995893478394,
0.3009631037712097,
-0.7495129108428955,
0.8281758427619934,
0.09276033192873001,
0.8061412572860718,
-0.46479591727256775,
0.030030498281121254,
-0.26495760679244995,
0.30409982800483704,
-0.20852410793304443,
-0.8309889435768127,
0.25749683380126953,
0.031116243451833725,
0.029385950416326523,
-0.1659868210554123,
0.34757405519485474,
-0.6396709680557251,
-0.42044597864151,
0.5821232795715332,
0.800071656703949,
0.07374444603919983,
-0.1285025030374527,
-0.5491350889205933,
0.3273550570011139,
-0.19289621710777283,
-0.07518631219863892,
0.16962981224060059,
0.8238596320152283,
-0.19923833012580872,
0.6890208125114441,
0.4591371417045593,
0.35830727219581604,
-0.07287392765283585,
0.2393052577972412,
0.7946380376815796,
-0.6100153923034668,
-0.44795358180999756,
-0.9578089714050293,
0.3904726207256317,
0.2931465208530426,
-0.6282056570053101,
0.7896413803100586,
0.6816307902336121,
1.3878682851791382,
-0.11280450969934464,
0.8317998051643372,
0.44902700185775757,
0.3175479471683502,
-0.6815280318260193,
0.8579810261726379,
-0.5683135390281677,
0.24396011233329773,
-0.2716755270957947,
-1.2528555393218994,
-0.3125930428504944,
0.49822214245796204,
-0.24934910237789154,
0.3439900279045105,
0.3324888050556183,
0.46113908290863037,
-0.03322310745716095,
-0.28130820393562317,
0.516019880771637,
0.3710557222366333,
0.32108548283576965,
0.6079030632972717,
0.8403942584991455,
-0.35004347562789917,
0.21034148335456848,
-0.18731267750263214,
-0.31372353434562683,
-0.006225996185094118,
-0.5909379720687866,
-0.926227331161499,
-0.6845331788063049,
-0.28782472014427185,
-0.03570525720715523,
0.2704966962337494,
0.7188683748245239,
0.6216853857040405,
-0.7106435298919678,
-0.7526835203170776,
-0.07767343521118164,
-0.03501303866505623,
-0.06065159663558006,
-0.2448730170726776,
0.1638866513967514,
-0.44274574518203735,
-0.9817402362823486,
0.3161061704158783,
0.3772388696670532,
-0.08404815196990967,
-0.5375523567199707,
-0.25647836923599243,
-0.09204164892435074,
-0.10693615674972534,
0.9399364590644836,
0.04995900020003319,
-0.9262148141860962,
-0.14102567732334137,
-0.07413601875305176,
-0.19209590554237366,
-0.03143889084458351,
0.5953977108001709,
-0.8526025414466858,
0.46978044509887695,
0.2701391577720642,
0.7099449038505554,
0.09080754220485687,
-0.2171422243118286,
0.9631524682044983,
-0.37217262387275696,
0.33730530738830566,
0.21340511739253998,
0.17142382264137268,
0.5670372247695923,
-0.15381085872650146,
0.6000689268112183,
-0.09625811129808426,
-0.6040929555892944,
-0.8053021430969238,
0.09684691578149796,
-0.6817955374717712,
-0.08135998249053955,
1.3034182786941528,
-0.04649142175912857,
-0.01229108963161707,
-0.14673641324043274,
-0.22510480880737305,
0.4518510401248932,
-0.08388257771730423,
0.6642353534698486,
0.8413456678390503,
-0.026393035426735878,
-0.08249347656965256,
-0.9645363688468933,
0.44475066661834717,
0.5734168291091919,
-0.8176636099815369,
0.2579580545425415,
0.47079455852508545,
0.11314214766025543,
-0.12877751886844635,
0.28179964423179626,
0.12132220715284348,
0.2896352708339691,
-0.28275439143180847,
-0.45802226662635803,
0.27261650562286377,
-0.5052322745323181,
-0.7063777446746826,
-0.15007780492305756,
0.386216402053833,
0.2842029333114624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02713v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02713v1
|
Android in the Zoo: Chain-of-Action-Thought for GUI Agents
| 2024-03-05T07:09:35 | 2024-03-05T07:09:35 |
Jiwen Zhang, Jihao Wu, Yihua Teng, Minghui Liao, Nuo Xu, Xiao Xiao, Zhongyu Wei, Duyu Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Large language model (LLM) leads to a surge of autonomous GUI agents for
smartphone, which completes a task triggered by natural language through
predicting a sequence of actions of API. Even though the task highly relies on
past actions and visual observations, existing studies typical consider little
semantic information carried out by intermediate screenshots and screen
operations. To address this, this work presents Chain-of-Action-Thought (dubbed
CoAT), which takes the description of the previous actions, the current screen,
and more importantly the action thinking of what actions should be performed
and the outcomes led by the chosen action. We demonstrate that, in a zero-shot
setting upon an off-the-shell LLM, CoAT significantly improves the goal
progress compared to standard context modeling. To further facilitate the
research in this line, we construct a benchmark Android-In-The-Zoo (AitZ),
which contains 18,643 screen-action pairs together with chain-of-action-thought
annotations. Experiments show that fine-tuning a 200M model on our AitZ dataset
achieves on par performance with CogAgent-Chat-18B.
|
[
-0.5636292695999146,
-0.8000432252883911,
0.3921746611595154,
-0.0718667060136795,
-0.11852771788835526,
0.14561724662780762,
0.08595320582389832,
-0.6610268950462341,
0.41016581654548645,
0.7554869651794434,
-0.5498692393302917,
-0.3633517324924469,
-0.27984854578971863,
0.05880797281861305,
-0.2848462164402008,
0.9002008438110352,
-0.33085060119628906,
-0.634403645992279,
0.16804523766040802,
-0.15102146565914154,
-0.27002570033073425,
-0.04844065383076668,
-0.6179903745651245,
-0.5911060571670532,
0.6278353333473206,
0.4224747121334076,
0.8303192257881165,
0.795896589756012,
0.51899254322052,
0.31164371967315674,
0.4051225185394287,
0.20851458609104156,
-0.40358102321624756,
0.20594008266925812,
-0.43861424922943115,
-0.12954044342041016,
-0.8589795231819153,
0.29925084114074707,
0.12120527029037476,
0.1675690859556198,
0.058433037251234055,
0.17806485295295715,
-0.21039153635501862,
0.8836638927459717,
-0.7371805310249329,
0.30015912652015686,
-0.4781203269958496,
0.10803766548633575,
0.19918394088745117,
-0.042664580047130585,
-0.305646687746048,
0.2859625518321991,
0.10125982761383057,
-0.886738657951355,
-0.4150542914867401,
0.020229190587997437,
0.6130453944206238,
0.016808224841952324,
-0.46667295694351196,
-0.2957117557525635,
-0.7284886240959167,
0.5352633595466614,
-0.5062331557273865,
-0.0425124317407608,
0.578349769115448,
0.1687450110912323,
-0.5157344937324524,
-0.7101724147796631,
-0.732914388179779,
-0.2348266839981079,
0.17555373907089233,
0.23031775653362274,
0.042864516377449036,
0.2420680969953537,
0.3703162968158722,
0.3028564453125,
-0.22337065637111664,
-0.1869710236787796,
0.058207809925079346,
-0.14476436376571655,
0.753154993057251,
0.2873843014240265,
0.5861068367958069,
0.10492386668920517,
-0.6450157761573792,
-0.35241204500198364,
-0.5140259265899658,
0.3562811613082886,
-0.19153277575969696,
0.07095330208539963,
-0.22897332906723022,
0.6821369528770447,
-0.7486284971237183,
0.5720430612564087,
0.0626472532749176,
-0.0882667526602745,
-0.16329261660575867,
-0.2993127405643463,
-0.27684128284454346,
0.07654555886983871,
0.6791618466377258,
0.783129096031189,
0.11833180487155914,
-0.2571294903755188,
-0.42482560873031616,
0.24159233272075653,
0.4557395875453949,
-0.9046012759208679,
-0.36471161246299744,
0.4148535430431366,
-0.31320565938949585,
-0.2727491557598114,
-0.08547892421483994,
-0.38268861174583435,
-0.6519237756729126,
-0.24703878164291382,
0.8358816504478455,
-0.36142653226852417,
-0.39387205243110657,
0.1449965238571167,
-0.2755765914916992,
0.37600624561309814,
0.5607628226280212,
-0.9108506441116333,
0.8015942573547363,
0.7046147584915161,
0.9293845891952515,
-0.009076143614947796,
-0.29832491278648376,
-0.6941220760345459,
0.3527754843235016,
-0.6890202164649963,
0.821774423122406,
-0.4861467778682709,
-0.23630812764167786,
-0.215737983584404,
-0.20039597153663635,
-0.4434312582015991,
-0.16757410764694214,
0.10093879699707031,
-0.5109806060791016,
-0.3056116998195648,
-0.14572833478450775,
-0.7126403450965881,
-0.41436994075775146,
0.49454978108406067,
-0.7492682337760925,
0.7622681260108948,
0.1354294866323471,
-0.665174126625061,
0.6380590200424194,
-1.0083049535751343,
-0.3300732672214508,
0.2815631330013275,
-0.19409041106700897,
-0.16706034541130066,
-0.08474855870008469,
0.1909453272819519,
0.5541576147079468,
0.09073932468891144,
-0.08101966977119446,
-0.4983156621456146,
-0.46307724714279175,
0.27249929308891296,
0.2662515342235565,
0.3260929584503174,
0.09612137824296951,
-0.7162566781044006,
0.21530316770076752,
-0.4982583224773407,
0.14080454409122467,
-0.18311358988285065,
-0.05733880400657654,
-0.5214584469795227,
0.17454203963279724,
-0.449810653924942,
0.6280398368835449,
0.0467844195663929,
-0.6340993046760559,
0.49332496523857117,
-0.042092397809028625,
0.3160124719142914,
0.5503110289573669,
-0.09201200306415558,
0.8453546166419983,
-0.7089240550994873,
0.3516443371772766,
-0.29498475790023804,
0.277213454246521,
-0.3830662965774536,
-0.5163612365722656,
-0.5228784680366516,
-0.5056804418563843,
-0.06810631603002548,
0.442376047372818,
-0.9526839256286621,
0.04022042453289032,
-0.21086162328720093,
-0.6199601888656616,
0.10618624836206436,
0.11294973641633987,
0.584015429019928,
0.3439532220363617,
0.04330630227923393,
-0.6893071532249451,
-0.16262447834014893,
-0.45905566215515137,
-0.2948632538318634,
-0.26054009795188904,
0.19907189905643463,
0.47587376832962036,
0.8346292972564697,
-0.4418129622936249,
1.0332845449447632,
-0.1014091819524765,
-0.30103799700737,
-0.36521968245506287,
0.44782939553260803,
0.24312724173069,
0.34981176257133484,
0.421701043844223,
-0.4738316237926483,
-0.46232104301452637,
0.40275534987449646,
-0.841931939125061,
0.16535022854804993,
-0.06923918426036835,
-0.4120020568370819,
0.17861831188201904,
0.4701164960861206,
-0.9194558262825012,
0.7307040095329285,
0.4299294352531433,
-0.4250805675983429,
0.4863002896308899,
-0.3751634657382965,
0.24531538784503937,
-0.8385080695152283,
0.1078331470489502,
0.00007271838694578037,
-0.0977056473493576,
-0.76310133934021,
-0.03948203846812248,
0.24096538126468658,
-0.0022523498628288507,
-0.37307974696159363,
1.0803778171539307,
-0.39985042810440063,
-0.41488274931907654,
-0.609296441078186,
0.11102890223264694,
-0.10694804042577744,
0.5961644649505615,
0.3140116035938263,
0.7756512761116028,
0.5201130509376526,
-1.0186951160430908,
0.4196409583091736,
0.35954391956329346,
-0.5516882538795471,
0.10605438798666,
-0.14505945146083832,
0.20298177003860474,
0.38949504494667053,
0.7362908124923706,
-0.7666580677032471,
-0.4658554196357727,
0.3763236701488495,
-0.0001425139926141128,
-0.06746654957532883,
0.044870585203170776,
-0.4411529302597046,
-0.5317689180374146,
-0.7222052812576294,
0.22588041424751282,
0.21971730887889862,
-0.4865138530731201,
0.8142057657241821,
0.4969591796398163,
-0.0759253278374672,
-0.5998507738113403,
-0.24502795934677124,
0.2461761087179184,
-0.23074352741241455,
-0.5416614413261414,
0.4400169551372528,
0.24444368481636047,
-0.5621767640113831,
-0.32604432106018066,
-0.2060752809047699,
0.2554786503314972,
0.21282026171684265,
0.4631728529930115,
0.10580652207136154,
0.028607340529561043,
0.10507021844387054,
-0.12084650993347168,
0.10992977023124695,
0.10586582869291306,
-0.12782159447669983,
0.4708361029624939,
-0.1361461579799652,
-0.025066949427127838,
-0.39933568239212036,
0.012435459531843662,
0.7167620062828064,
-0.005793469492346048,
0.35658007860183716,
0.3212648332118988,
-0.22257065773010254,
-0.3100917935371399,
-0.20552784204483032,
-0.20194284617900848,
-0.48129433393478394,
-0.028849143534898758,
-0.4543197453022003,
-0.3288208246231079,
0.9394068717956543,
-0.43385618925094604,
0.32794278860092163,
0.09820619225502014,
0.32646140456199646,
-0.3876364231109619,
0.9926459193229675,
0.6339243650436401,
-0.08443964272737503,
0.886755645275116,
-0.4939650595188141,
0.05731097608804703,
-1.1383507251739502,
-0.0009984381031244993,
0.06507110595703125,
-0.6290209889411926,
-0.6232859492301941,
-0.33173441886901855,
0.2546457350254059,
0.3131387531757355,
-0.67073655128479,
0.640478253364563,
-0.1554335653781891,
0.2644076347351074,
0.6331796050071716,
0.3751508295536041,
0.2163601517677307,
-0.09729462116956711,
-0.32096347212791443,
0.6374548077583313,
-0.67681485414505,
-0.8065747022628784,
1.1798925399780273,
0.201812744140625,
1.0651344060897827,
-0.16174344718456268,
0.7374215126037598,
0.5653907060623169,
0.5515829920768738,
-0.748370349407196,
0.9101356863975525,
0.003372280392795801,
-0.46114617586135864,
-0.6441056132316589,
0.04192117974162102,
-0.9312793016433716,
0.5241227746009827,
-0.0244075246155262,
-1.1638991832733154,
0.05957749858498573,
0.09244288504123688,
-0.377106636762619,
0.33731013536453247,
-0.5855189561843872,
0.8036718964576721,
-0.22906500101089478,
-0.6704521775245667,
-0.449724406003952,
-0.5422530174255371,
0.39313986897468567,
0.07629474252462387,
0.2553400695323944,
-0.3632025122642517,
-0.16278432309627533,
0.75755375623703,
-0.8442546725273132,
0.7951626777648926,
-0.022954048588871956,
-0.3742128610610962,
0.5752303004264832,
0.20015256106853485,
0.793584942817688,
-0.15168993175029755,
0.011461203917860985,
-0.21398180723190308,
-0.11437910050153732,
-0.10670852661132812,
-0.3860592544078827,
0.5543215274810791,
-0.6087311506271362,
-0.520961344242096,
-0.531874418258667,
-0.597632646560669,
-0.2827172577381134,
0.17022457718849182,
0.0546170212328434,
0.7470577359199524,
-0.16695238649845123,
-0.16865591704845428,
0.31340569257736206,
-0.32639095187187195,
0.8888499140739441,
0.7367299795150757,
-0.6711477637290955,
-0.31410032510757446,
0.7204000949859619,
0.012982207350432873,
0.20054247975349426,
0.38390278816223145,
0.13134272396564484,
-0.26011183857917786,
-0.1256406605243683,
-0.7460108995437622,
0.10270781069993973,
-0.44458967447280884,
-0.15869379043579102,
-0.7235444188117981,
-0.11658898741006851,
-0.05831227824091911,
-0.2091151475906372,
-0.2771509885787964,
-0.36463141441345215,
0.17816556990146637,
0.003321794094517827,
0.6370678544044495,
0.834270179271698,
-0.16878902912139893,
0.33469751477241516,
-0.6727586388587952,
0.625232458114624,
0.4745893180370331,
0.4149836301803589,
0.006332535296678543,
-0.24369147419929504,
-0.48624297976493835,
0.3658878803253174,
-0.5910021066665649,
-0.47421467304229736,
0.3435404598712921,
0.37552782893180847,
0.4914240539073944,
0.5239564180374146,
0.330843985080719,
0.6614673137664795,
-0.2555994987487793,
0.5923187732696533,
0.2622787356376648,
-0.7410197257995605,
0.6290524005889893,
-0.749810516834259,
0.4795026481151581,
0.1411847621202469,
-0.04457738623023033,
-0.512309193611145,
-0.7921059131622314,
-0.43646517395973206,
-0.6251456141471863,
0.9602590799331665,
0.21678248047828674,
0.13305869698524475,
-0.04854511097073555,
-0.04767432063817978,
0.09805349260568619,
0.03756602853536606,
-0.567687451839447,
0.2484419196844101,
-0.05309145152568817,
0.27010688185691833,
-0.043437372893095016,
0.016174325719475746,
-0.1284070611000061,
-0.31964293122291565,
0.45875316858291626,
-0.20362627506256104,
0.3244574964046478,
0.15399715304374695,
-0.4028841555118561,
-0.36176401376724243,
0.13447578251361847,
0.750796377658844,
0.6076050400733948,
-0.31839439272880554,
0.003427953226491809,
-0.06399281322956085,
-0.861514151096344,
0.08568534255027771,
-0.24736551940441132,
0.09306095540523529,
-0.26894617080688477,
0.3098183870315552,
0.697529137134552,
0.3387695252895355,
-0.7909155488014221,
0.4412928819656372,
-0.13778330385684967,
-0.23649762570858002,
-0.11856681108474731,
0.3419511616230011,
-0.267390638589859,
0.4461125433444977,
0.4203498959541321,
-0.05515412241220474,
0.29932162165641785,
-0.8846352696418762,
0.36714106798171997,
0.34539923071861267,
-0.325703501701355,
-0.2876211702823639,
0.3527112901210785,
0.5543721318244934,
-0.12380059063434601,
0.6561043858528137,
-0.04231862723827362,
-0.5081280469894409,
0.9106975793838501,
0.3272760510444641,
0.9712541699409485,
-0.20312513411045074,
0.5326372385025024,
0.23214036226272583,
0.14469294250011444,
-0.33773598074913025,
0.33582043647766113,
-0.48948633670806885,
-0.8418166637420654,
-0.4936824440956116,
-0.5015032887458801,
-0.6231085062026978,
0.1456817239522934,
-0.5099171996116638,
0.13990162312984467,
-0.29836907982826233,
-0.47492995858192444,
-0.222224161028862,
0.2911531627178192,
-0.4639393091201782,
0.3585974872112274,
0.08150853961706161,
1.0527631044387817,
-0.5140747427940369,
1.0409859418869019,
0.6443622708320618,
-0.16742226481437683,
-0.7829405665397644,
-0.12722720205783844,
-0.3092600107192993,
-0.4885493814945221,
0.7233310341835022,
0.5169011950492859,
-0.4713313579559326,
-0.22779199481010437,
-0.3794364035129547,
-0.7326025366783142,
1.251405119895935,
-0.031955987215042114,
-0.7463308572769165,
0.2499309927225113,
-0.12761378288269043,
0.5236362814903259,
-0.5262280106544495,
0.30959925055503845,
0.46330803632736206,
0.3279261887073517,
0.08627913147211075,
-1.2524728775024414,
-0.009197869338095188,
-0.5048472881317139,
-0.20210902392864227,
0.20940253138542175,
-0.477319598197937,
0.8501318693161011,
-0.48180916905403137,
-0.2512686252593994,
0.25901493430137634,
0.2716391682624817,
0.22011761367321014,
0.8308075070381165,
0.40812626481056213,
0.48153164982795715,
0.4725266098976135,
0.15436753630638123,
1.30867338180542,
-0.4431688189506531,
-0.004161310847848654,
1.1255834102630615,
-0.5852305889129639,
0.9764054417610168,
0.2543569803237915,
0.13960695266723633,
0.6133653521537781,
0.7092049717903137,
0.4060230255126953,
0.8428221344947815,
0.10451406240463257,
-0.3782714605331421,
-0.1944972574710846,
0.11427915096282959,
-0.16655461490154266,
0.6437736749649048,
0.6251810193061829,
-0.30139878392219543,
-0.15348491072654724,
0.4277608096599579,
-0.16267096996307373,
-0.1527109295129776,
-0.8100600838661194,
1.1591836214065552,
0.13131053745746613,
-0.8446826338768005,
0.4094163477420807,
-0.32091033458709717,
0.4421009123325348,
-0.298374742269516,
-0.14370860159397125,
-0.27708929777145386,
0.3240484893321991,
-0.02391570433974266,
-0.7870768308639526,
-0.07710812985897064,
-0.05952109396457672,
0.048833560198545456,
-0.42943060398101807,
0.9220281839370728,
-0.13719113171100616,
0.01834661327302456,
0.3620665967464447,
0.3192107379436493,
0.20478549599647522,
-0.26269420981407166,
-0.729604959487915,
0.10400256514549255,
-0.5965942740440369,
-0.39262518286705017,
0.42125076055526733,
0.4246833622455597,
-0.5812529921531677,
1.1623740196228027,
0.2629762887954712,
-0.20404265820980072,
-0.029914934188127518,
-0.3300139009952545,
0.9240025281906128,
-0.7525538206100464,
-0.6636434197425842,
-0.7719022631645203,
0.16704213619232178,
-0.36422601342201233,
-0.15929362177848816,
0.6084910035133362,
0.6619662046432495,
0.7128007411956787,
-0.11422894895076752,
0.81688392162323,
-0.141310453414917,
0.2403358370065689,
-0.40231406688690186,
0.7477053999900818,
-0.3328000605106354,
0.05423201993107796,
-0.47750595211982727,
-0.755335807800293,
0.13304153084754944,
0.722332239151001,
-0.6334487795829773,
0.001813677605241537,
0.6827847957611084,
0.7224106192588806,
0.05635283514857292,
0.1840645670890808,
0.5215722918510437,
-0.10331513732671738,
0.11016029119491577,
0.5192573070526123,
1.1058318614959717,
-0.5543875098228455,
0.2265430986881256,
-0.23884306848049164,
-0.24661284685134888,
-0.44535887241363525,
-0.8715887665748596,
-0.8118072152137756,
-0.5971193313598633,
-0.41491660475730896,
-0.12167824059724808,
0.03594561666250229,
0.8619124889373779,
0.7345083355903625,
-0.6648322939872742,
-0.699654221534729,
-0.4876766800880432,
0.04180700704455376,
-0.722926676273346,
-0.07436081767082214,
0.16992740333080292,
-0.2765595316886902,
-0.29726746678352356,
0.14223186671733856,
0.7156254649162292,
0.005000741686671972,
0.2186816781759262,
-0.4033318758010864,
-0.23186327517032623,
0.3526185154914856,
0.8960916996002197,
0.550501823425293,
-0.7072179913520813,
-0.2563268542289734,
-0.3244853615760803,
-0.48717883229255676,
-0.1843699812889099,
0.8330445289611816,
-0.9787366390228271,
0.7317405939102173,
0.15838605165481567,
0.18406598269939423,
0.6695960760116577,
0.03877647593617439,
0.9219835996627808,
-0.03421270102262497,
0.01771124079823494,
0.04243508353829384,
0.160805344581604,
-0.10147576034069061,
-0.06861548125743866,
0.5973781943321228,
-0.2868739664554596,
-0.3409563899040222,
-0.4788515865802765,
0.18006330728530884,
-1.1644372940063477,
-0.2821454107761383,
1.1603882312774658,
-0.22453175485134125,
-0.6121938824653625,
-0.18235668540000916,
-0.4128718078136444,
0.15988202393054962,
-0.5617623925209045,
1.0349501371383667,
0.677446186542511,
-0.4495255947113037,
-0.34562256932258606,
-0.3260595500469208,
0.7727290391921997,
-0.15546056628227234,
-0.9675717353820801,
0.14103896915912628,
0.30168265104293823,
-0.05930763855576515,
-0.03728969395160675,
0.9497972726821899,
0.1373227834701538,
0.4528457224369049,
0.1536124348640442,
-0.04335019364953041,
0.10911406576633453,
-0.23479218780994415,
0.3111777603626251,
-0.3530847132205963,
-0.1866709142923355,
-0.4531591832637787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02712v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02712v2
|
Breeze-7B Technical Report
| 2024-03-05T07:08:06 | 2024-04-03T14:29:41 |
Chan-Jan Hsu, Chang-Le Liu, Feng-Ting Liao, Po-Chun Hsu, Yi-Chang Chen, Da-Shan Shiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Breeze-7B is an open-source language model based on Mistral-7B, designed to
address the need for improved language comprehension and chatbot-oriented
capabilities in Traditional Chinese. This technical report provides an overview
of the additional pretraining, finetuning, and evaluation stages for the
Breeze-7B model. The Breeze-7B family of base and chat models exhibits good
performance on language comprehension and chatbot-oriented tasks, reaching the
top in several benchmarks among models comparable in its complexity class.
|
[
-0.28572842478752136,
-0.7461386322975159,
0.11892767250537872,
0.607819676399231,
-0.07590046525001526,
0.03860163316130638,
-0.12004702538251877,
-0.492417573928833,
0.027555245906114578,
0.8020175695419312,
-0.5683672428131104,
-0.18886958062648773,
-0.16782350838184357,
-0.22056400775909424,
-0.7302083373069763,
0.6208505630493164,
0.2342754304409027,
0.1277739256620407,
0.266105979681015,
0.20739597082138062,
-0.6105347275733948,
-0.3611604571342468,
-0.5911089777946472,
-0.0916542336344719,
0.3438427150249481,
0.29381823539733887,
1.079962968826294,
0.5638079643249512,
0.8137285113334656,
0.3290875554084778,
-0.26876726746559143,
-0.3259873688220978,
-0.6845061779022217,
0.1305932104587555,
-0.21685148775577545,
-0.805560827255249,
-0.5188676118850708,
-0.19179578125476837,
0.30804768204689026,
0.6186920404434204,
-0.5127213597297668,
0.22990967333316803,
-0.11476536840200424,
0.9334056377410889,
-0.5444772839546204,
0.28131401538848877,
-0.7144972085952759,
-0.5310298800468445,
-0.6098534464836121,
0.17224112153053284,
-0.35155123472213745,
-0.21659956872463226,
-0.08884496986865997,
-0.4670540988445282,
0.49534961581230164,
0.024158617481589317,
1.1732420921325684,
0.09658622741699219,
-0.23488622903823853,
-0.36641770601272583,
-0.6593775153160095,
0.44817548990249634,
-0.8801536560058594,
0.973268985748291,
0.16217227280139923,
0.7214034795761108,
-0.5320504307746887,
-0.7581873536109924,
-0.6296228170394897,
-0.4822455942630768,
0.2640530467033386,
0.24063310027122498,
-0.03940349817276001,
0.4439195692539215,
-0.20436128973960876,
0.7085658311843872,
-0.585910975933075,
-0.13272956013679504,
-1.0290244817733765,
-0.14510421454906464,
0.4277857840061188,
0.131297767162323,
0.5809441804885864,
-0.22146107256412506,
-0.1619432419538498,
0.18829789757728577,
-0.49441686272621155,
0.3220360279083252,
0.2585846781730652,
0.6019593477249146,
-0.17516343295574188,
0.2507985830307007,
-0.5413835644721985,
1.0387359857559204,
0.1853797286748886,
-0.40612173080444336,
0.18800190091133118,
-0.22170992195606232,
-0.5038848519325256,
-0.04454416409134865,
0.39040255546569824,
0.25526219606399536,
-0.10266343504190445,
-0.18580032885074615,
-0.39155757427215576,
-0.16424109041690826,
0.18386423587799072,
-0.703218400478363,
-0.3141651749610901,
0.2757691442966461,
-0.9222667813301086,
-0.4248030185699463,
0.39257341623306274,
-0.268007755279541,
-0.4132072627544403,
-0.44205254316329956,
0.21293985843658447,
-0.5815806984901428,
-0.8917734622955322,
0.13690727949142456,
-0.6160128116607666,
0.36988088488578796,
0.701154351234436,
-0.46458005905151367,
0.22773930430412292,
0.6520939469337463,
1.048814296722412,
-0.034398648887872696,
-0.3695441484451294,
-0.06030815467238426,
-0.11914228647947311,
-0.6267344355583191,
0.8160378932952881,
-0.6427088975906372,
-0.583432674407959,
-0.08018984645605087,
0.02832241915166378,
-0.20280078053474426,
-0.5621919631958008,
0.4348316788673401,
-0.6904236674308777,
0.2894386351108551,
-0.2623799443244934,
-0.3987167477607727,
-0.5622389912605286,
0.18618755042552948,
-0.909013032913208,
1.0329869985580444,
0.5508648157119751,
-0.7464700937271118,
-0.01689470000565052,
-0.528937816619873,
-0.023238182067871094,
0.2413066327571869,
0.0906062051653862,
0.31245195865631104,
0.3865799009799957,
-0.2571234107017517,
0.06847076863050461,
-0.658480167388916,
0.38164129853248596,
-0.3832815885543823,
-0.3268652856349945,
-0.02937336638569832,
-0.45193299651145935,
1.241181492805481,
0.8323947787284851,
0.029402010142803192,
0.3452557623386383,
-0.9404600858688354,
-0.10933372378349304,
-0.0731397494673729,
-0.21874713897705078,
-0.22049646079540253,
-0.3597315549850464,
0.05448617413640022,
0.46043992042541504,
0.48177093267440796,
-0.26999616622924805,
-0.06436984241008759,
-0.6807637214660645,
0.0206264927983284,
0.3698883354663849,
-0.20279845595359802,
0.4155789613723755,
-0.549258828163147,
0.7826654314994812,
0.12389075756072998,
0.37450897693634033,
-0.5346812009811401,
-0.3545253872871399,
-1.1420625448226929,
-0.21475310623645782,
0.09384871274232864,
0.6749088764190674,
-0.9829107522964478,
0.26381051540374756,
0.09681335836648941,
-1.1999870538711548,
-0.7021656632423401,
0.4543066918849945,
0.40663185715675354,
0.4421331286430359,
0.13673293590545654,
-0.03497594967484474,
-0.27944451570510864,
-0.7843337655067444,
-0.24454611539840698,
-0.4773885905742645,
0.262744665145874,
-0.40318164229393005,
0.06787021458148956,
0.08001110702753067,
0.9422062635421753,
-0.2297048568725586,
-0.08323865383863449,
-0.8840277791023254,
-0.2897992432117462,
0.38178807497024536,
0.38679102063179016,
0.925248920917511,
-0.7374036312103271,
-0.45454058051109314,
0.08974485844373703,
-0.5068296194076538,
-0.4950072169303894,
0.009319016709923744,
-0.5448324680328369,
0.21996420621871948,
0.7000104188919067,
-0.6011911630630493,
0.6209039688110352,
0.6631495356559753,
-0.38706129789352417,
0.57078617811203,
0.20361188054084778,
0.24918703734874725,
-1.2144495248794556,
0.03981916978955269,
-0.20785780251026154,
-0.05253283306956291,
-0.794159471988678,
0.46885502338409424,
0.20323927700519562,
-0.11894553899765015,
-0.8834104537963867,
0.7782455682754517,
-0.6939289569854736,
0.3873639404773712,
-0.6592718958854675,
-0.061803702265024185,
-0.004698228556662798,
0.28258025646209717,
0.04911087825894356,
0.3422924280166626,
0.6988875865936279,
-0.8512523770332336,
0.592633843421936,
-0.13761132955551147,
0.009138284251093864,
0.5899918079376221,
-0.6841440200805664,
0.011016642674803734,
-0.26695355772972107,
0.17666377127170563,
-0.8073185086250305,
-0.43385517597198486,
0.18488016724586487,
-0.6410858035087585,
0.01052180863916874,
-0.08871874958276749,
-0.12068457156419754,
-0.7181466221809387,
-0.22727729380130768,
-0.16418087482452393,
0.41330328583717346,
-0.39481717348098755,
0.854600727558136,
0.11529110372066498,
0.060925643891096115,
-0.3397253155708313,
-0.43422356247901917,
-0.2341221570968628,
0.06307464092969894,
-0.9701610207557678,
0.003665228607133031,
0.03931236267089844,
-0.43638139963150024,
-0.09220478683710098,
-0.23774076998233795,
-0.35660138726234436,
0.3324924409389496,
0.6797373294830322,
0.3456123173236847,
-0.5043606162071228,
-0.011244849301874638,
0.04211023077368736,
0.3527025580406189,
-0.06819594651460648,
0.04598948359489441,
0.6921112537384033,
-0.23173373937606812,
-0.31684327125549316,
-0.406983345746994,
0.02822388894855976,
0.4387006461620331,
-0.24107584357261658,
0.9936038851737976,
0.4295863211154938,
-0.5215611457824707,
-0.2774582803249359,
-0.6717947721481323,
0.2175440937280655,
-0.6377524137496948,
0.2353931963443756,
-0.6933976411819458,
-0.6302169561386108,
0.7073612809181213,
0.11735804378986359,
0.3129052519798279,
0.6652171611785889,
0.6170623302459717,
0.21587052941322327,
0.42098861932754517,
0.9108462333679199,
-0.11168236285448074,
0.7131532430648804,
0.30040088295936584,
-0.15080174803733826,
-0.23459817469120026,
-0.45575255155563354,
-1.072672963142395,
0.21673451364040375,
-0.20416490733623505,
-0.38231366872787476,
-0.0747845247387886,
0.7172091007232666,
-0.5137673616409302,
0.3737344443798065,
-0.26447561383247375,
0.35604116320610046,
0.7731509804725647,
-0.06434469670057297,
0.4235321581363678,
-0.6128572821617126,
0.06746262311935425,
0.5223382711410522,
-0.4965795576572418,
-0.4559535086154938,
0.6352102756500244,
0.4674692749977112,
1.1168785095214844,
0.37809285521507263,
0.5264583230018616,
0.015277916565537453,
0.4311525821685791,
-0.49939483404159546,
0.4036311209201813,
0.14527079463005066,
-1.1574962139129639,
-0.09216349571943283,
-0.2818332016468048,
-0.9572285413742065,
0.35567110776901245,
0.18209439516067505,
-0.7573758959770203,
-0.22870972752571106,
0.3413102924823761,
-0.05028003454208374,
0.14640486240386963,
-0.9713868498802185,
0.8437845706939697,
-0.25121936202049255,
0.2819283902645111,
-0.06693188846111298,
-0.5234942436218262,
1.00346040725708,
0.10409796237945557,
0.38375407457351685,
-0.1021321639418602,
0.29827722907066345,
0.7172885537147522,
-0.7016467452049255,
0.6968686580657959,
-0.3233456313610077,
-0.08750951290130615,
0.7039793729782104,
0.4806700348854065,
-0.07529676705598831,
-0.3061443567276001,
-0.14403648674488068,
0.08202773332595825,
0.3139890134334564,
-0.47922614216804504,
-0.6280364990234375,
0.6761216521263123,
-0.9011807441711426,
-0.9529215097427368,
-0.28826865553855896,
-0.137295663356781,
-0.11161523312330246,
0.6197711229324341,
0.15152625739574432,
0.3802911937236786,
-0.37971949577331543,
0.2692795991897583,
0.32446539402008057,
-0.46428537368774414,
0.5453000664710999,
0.7751179933547974,
-1.1422159671783447,
-0.27693605422973633,
0.8109756112098694,
0.10486198216676712,
0.5498210787773132,
0.42493346333503723,
0.15120114386081696,
0.031754020601511,
-0.4920812249183655,
-0.5026574730873108,
0.10126751661300659,
-0.755210280418396,
-0.22730734944343567,
-0.5323100090026855,
-0.6797690987586975,
-0.7739600539207458,
-0.16923826932907104,
-0.6858393549919128,
-0.33822521567344666,
-0.13430218398571014,
-0.06458126753568649,
0.22423197329044342,
1.0192197561264038,
0.19904427230358124,
0.8975639939308167,
-1.1631172895431519,
0.4651179611682892,
-0.2662983238697052,
0.420393705368042,
0.17844872176647186,
-0.7256621718406677,
-0.5135257840156555,
0.0668306052684784,
-0.6826318502426147,
-1.0402889251708984,
0.39377570152282715,
-0.03377261757850647,
0.9680678248405457,
0.6086459159851074,
0.025629490613937378,
0.7224184274673462,
-0.10622186213731766,
1.1681504249572754,
0.3875887095928192,
-1.2602565288543701,
0.676408588886261,
-0.5667991638183594,
0.4501563608646393,
0.44128164649009705,
0.16671475768089294,
-0.6568049788475037,
-0.7074337601661682,
-0.7312514185905457,
-0.46919679641723633,
0.7615641951560974,
0.18412895500659943,
0.10152463614940643,
0.09270072728395462,
0.25712963938713074,
0.21609628200531006,
0.33546993136405945,
-0.29059526324272156,
-0.28464454412460327,
-0.6101155281066895,
-0.2822648882865906,
0.281716912984848,
0.23274847865104675,
0.5357738733291626,
0.05702859163284302,
0.6476951241493225,
0.10716435313224792,
0.08948899805545807,
-0.044992268085479736,
-0.2512507438659668,
-0.024573057889938354,
-0.029509514570236206,
0.38488924503326416,
0.6260682940483093,
-0.18693006038665771,
-0.1238250583410263,
-0.14929725229740143,
-0.7687706351280212,
-0.18510626256465912,
-0.08033087849617004,
-0.07011715322732925,
0.12360617518424988,
0.5762940645217896,
0.7601743936538696,
-0.32953035831451416,
-0.633938729763031,
0.4372566342353821,
0.08143036812543869,
0.03841474652290344,
-0.08479861915111542,
0.5708160996437073,
0.40827125310897827,
0.10680396854877472,
0.32408109307289124,
0.06125916168093681,
0.4265810251235962,
-0.6103967428207397,
-0.06185325235128403,
0.2584124207496643,
-0.5468075275421143,
-0.619145393371582,
0.7539961338043213,
0.607776403427124,
-0.2844083309173584,
0.5068835616111755,
-0.04175301268696785,
-0.5786961913108826,
0.6005319356918335,
0.5950416922569275,
0.7122952938079834,
-0.4672522246837616,
0.21849539875984192,
0.20716053247451782,
0.4552626311779022,
-0.37647801637649536,
0.7102834582328796,
0.27637502551078796,
-0.6872113347053528,
-0.0470348559319973,
-0.6356216073036194,
-0.42865779995918274,
-0.042447373270988464,
-0.6874526739120483,
0.800473153591156,
-0.5452659130096436,
-0.15084289014339447,
-0.2143040895462036,
-0.21650561690330505,
-0.9305557012557983,
0.3274116814136505,
0.34794652462005615,
1.6881221532821655,
-0.5449078679084778,
0.9435740113258362,
0.6235623359680176,
-0.7123311161994934,
-1.1937808990478516,
-0.15448489785194397,
0.2372269183397293,
-0.736057460308075,
0.7639434337615967,
0.09000632166862488,
-0.23143604397773743,
-0.26045361161231995,
-0.7271386384963989,
-1.1150486469268799,
1.0336111783981323,
0.529456615447998,
-0.7026278972625732,
-0.36623141169548035,
-0.3077942728996277,
0.4644918143749237,
0.043246444314718246,
0.5630244016647339,
0.418643593788147,
0.2581687569618225,
0.16206440329551697,
-1.6390458345413208,
-0.1675601452589035,
-0.5381656885147095,
0.3576664924621582,
0.04227828606963158,
-1.2592374086380005,
0.9584408402442932,
0.18642666935920715,
-0.14857573807239532,
0.16173531115055084,
1.205012321472168,
0.31618601083755493,
0.36340567469596863,
0.43505415320396423,
0.2014624923467636,
0.8690254092216492,
0.009931554086506367,
0.8441208004951477,
-0.5918618440628052,
0.12899474799633026,
1.1246525049209595,
-0.10119026899337769,
0.7630918025970459,
0.08605221658945084,
-0.038002222776412964,
0.6391663551330566,
0.6353671550750732,
0.5944584608078003,
0.301684707403183,
0.298417866230011,
0.10379019379615784,
-0.0825323611497879,
-0.11458301544189453,
-0.4635055363178253,
0.4361802339553833,
0.3980282247066498,
-0.13979104161262512,
-0.25302863121032715,
0.06855875253677368,
0.14893251657485962,
-0.03410607948899269,
-0.7131450772285461,
0.6269699931144714,
0.16496926546096802,
-0.8353146910667419,
0.431540846824646,
0.2341068983078003,
0.58091801404953,
-0.6544894576072693,
0.10143258422613144,
-0.33158060908317566,
0.15755291283130646,
-0.2425662875175476,
-0.6356433629989624,
0.3089795410633087,
-0.15013869106769562,
0.040356192737817764,
0.22036688029766083,
1.0226680040359497,
-0.22001567482948303,
-0.546963632106781,
0.1623426377773285,
0.8057165741920471,
0.12089049816131592,
-0.20003728568553925,
-0.8256651163101196,
0.4093511700630188,
0.0574411116540432,
-0.6150391697883606,
0.059382062405347824,
0.8172685503959656,
-0.2098272740840912,
0.8999006152153015,
0.45719143748283386,
-0.04330863803625107,
0.48695892095565796,
0.2412215769290924,
0.9757171869277954,
-1.1306401491165161,
-0.7897922992706299,
-0.5249063372612,
0.48476481437683105,
0.13905124366283417,
-0.27389565110206604,
0.8435267210006714,
0.5777441263198853,
0.6729424595832825,
-0.05237533897161484,
1.0854778289794922,
-0.3698563575744629,
0.6321733593940735,
-0.5188022255897522,
0.5415380597114563,
-0.24145649373531342,
0.04342258349061012,
-0.22206468880176544,
-0.7487960457801819,
-0.062084268778562546,
0.2759005129337311,
0.15308238565921783,
0.1978767365217209,
0.6080177426338196,
0.9332623481750488,
0.08315730839967728,
0.29213252663612366,
0.41849035024642944,
0.18567870557308197,
0.6670955419540405,
0.2688333988189697,
0.9851669669151306,
-0.21564164757728577,
0.5526910424232483,
-0.3081342577934265,
-0.33497798442840576,
-0.2058534324169159,
-0.5793918967247009,
-1.3450446128845215,
-0.6731422543525696,
0.06473217904567719,
-0.7672533392906189,
0.06581750512123108,
1.2053766250610352,
0.5748509764671326,
-0.6424031853675842,
-0.4036122262477875,
0.0040000081062316895,
0.06982005387544632,
-0.18460270762443542,
-0.3253105580806732,
0.02030448615550995,
-0.6871703863143921,
-0.5901569128036499,
0.323757141828537,
0.1997426301240921,
0.06815832853317261,
-0.5704628825187683,
-0.08371537178754807,
0.2175920009613037,
0.4479347765445709,
0.30820485949516296,
0.09689260274171829,
-0.7454641461372375,
0.07275091111660004,
0.29203352332115173,
-0.2689431309700012,
-0.29691556096076965,
0.6423376202583313,
-0.5794263482093811,
0.30741041898727417,
0.7988913655281067,
0.4378659725189209,
0.053058188408613205,
0.14658024907112122,
0.7804692983627319,
-0.08376127481460571,
0.23927666246891022,
-0.25922003388404846,
0.38338056206703186,
0.2588939368724823,
-0.27368420362472534,
0.32556504011154175,
0.23034872114658356,
-0.303969144821167,
-0.6683104038238525,
-0.09665875136852264,
-1.3945937156677246,
-0.5928571820259094,
1.2891263961791992,
-0.017644604668021202,
-0.4872843027114868,
-0.20416359603405,
-0.7426870465278625,
0.20952264964580536,
-0.739182710647583,
0.3486550748348236,
0.8524645566940308,
0.06890437752008438,
-0.23238274455070496,
-0.6144682765007019,
0.4129675626754761,
-0.2978455126285553,
-0.7263238430023193,
-0.04888371750712395,
0.4865214228630066,
0.35214537382125854,
0.12131102383136749,
0.9913133978843689,
-0.010422896593809128,
0.48271092772483826,
0.3783334195613861,
0.26371848583221436,
-0.033471930772066116,
-0.40911996364593506,
0.06420736014842987,
0.39497998356819153,
0.5593847632408142,
-0.04461301118135452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02698v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02698v1
|
Causal Walk: Debiasing Multi-Hop Fact Verification with Front-Door Adjustment
| 2024-03-05T06:28:02 | 2024-03-05T06:28:02 |
Congzhi Zhang, Linhai Zhang, Deyu Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Conventional multi-hop fact verification models are prone to rely on spurious
correlations from the annotation artifacts, leading to an obvious performance
decline on unbiased datasets. Among the various debiasing works, the causal
inference-based methods become popular by performing theoretically guaranteed
debiasing such as casual intervention or counterfactual reasoning. However,
existing causal inference-based debiasing methods, which mainly formulate fact
verification as a single-hop reasoning task to tackle shallow bias patterns,
cannot deal with the complicated bias patterns hidden in multiple hops of
evidence. To address the challenge, we propose Causal Walk, a novel method for
debiasing multi-hop fact verification from a causal perspective with front-door
adjustment. Specifically, in the structural causal model, the reasoning path
between the treatment (the input claim-evidence graph) and the outcome (the
veracity label) is introduced as the mediator to block the confounder. With the
front-door adjustment, the causal effect between the treatment and the outcome
is decomposed into the causal effect between the treatment and the mediator,
which is estimated by applying the idea of random walk, and the causal effect
between the mediator and the outcome, which is estimated with normalized
weighted geometric mean approximation. To investigate the effectiveness of the
proposed method, an adversarial multi-hop fact verification dataset and a
symmetric multi-hop fact verification dataset are proposed with the help of the
large language model. Experimental results show that Causal Walk outperforms
some previous debiasing methods on both existing datasets and the newly
constructed datasets. Code and data will be released at
https://github.com/zcccccz/CausalWalk.
|
[
-0.022836904972791672,
-1.2712923288345337,
0.8424813151359558,
0.21236562728881836,
-0.1619645208120346,
-0.08302904665470123,
0.3421947956085205,
-0.12604361772537231,
0.21277019381523132,
0.30451148748397827,
-0.457327276468277,
-0.5857288837432861,
-1.0233476161956787,
-0.14444196224212646,
-0.1969466209411621,
0.5845399498939514,
0.2183479517698288,
0.23431898653507233,
-0.07496150583028793,
-0.2752748727798462,
-0.6288779377937317,
-0.026054706424474716,
-0.4455409049987793,
-0.5233590602874756,
0.6688506007194519,
0.08241122961044312,
0.9120926260948181,
0.576966404914856,
0.3555258810520172,
0.24137870967388153,
-0.16264910995960236,
0.25907033681869507,
-0.12104302644729614,
-0.1520988792181015,
-0.252462238073349,
-0.32032328844070435,
-0.3136444389820099,
0.3332657814025879,
0.49583035707473755,
0.5843350291252136,
0.11356747150421143,
0.2289867252111435,
-0.2351735532283783,
0.5257630348205566,
-0.6341035962104797,
0.08352728933095932,
-0.27253976464271545,
-0.20709824562072754,
-0.16992956399917603,
-0.41086265444755554,
-0.5274456739425659,
-0.6147891879081726,
-0.18608558177947998,
-0.30992233753204346,
0.012105648405849934,
0.22109124064445496,
0.5220987796783447,
0.467540979385376,
-0.8467074036598206,
0.03671915456652641,
-0.8001508116722107,
0.47799670696258545,
-0.4158502221107483,
0.7666803598403931,
0.3910544514656067,
0.20092034339904785,
-0.4448526203632355,
-0.25173598527908325,
-0.4092472493648529,
-0.4467106759548187,
-0.29569849371910095,
-0.1667965203523636,
-0.24427534639835358,
-0.23450714349746704,
0.4881235361099243,
-0.07244449108839035,
-0.4342074394226074,
-0.25281399488449097,
-0.10615000873804092,
-0.2375851422548294,
0.5090166926383972,
0.04148046299815178,
0.2128811627626419,
-0.08069989830255508,
-0.8015614151954651,
-0.1356128752231598,
-0.6894394755363464,
0.3377547264099121,
0.11673473566770554,
0.3143067955970764,
-0.2797934114933014,
0.2932499945163727,
-0.3556102514266968,
0.7479187846183777,
0.1530112773180008,
-0.21519552171230316,
0.28815484046936035,
-0.2370838224887848,
-0.22812575101852417,
0.310078501701355,
0.6693980693817139,
0.48835083842277527,
-0.19589298963546753,
-0.3688737154006958,
0.4217853248119354,
0.03893286734819412,
-0.034775856882333755,
-0.7623677253723145,
-0.005936571396887302,
0.4051419794559479,
-0.3695420026779175,
-0.38022470474243164,
0.014888103120028973,
-1.0000604391098022,
-0.9439186453819275,
-0.1976102888584137,
0.6328421831130981,
-0.3359086513519287,
-0.10101086646318436,
0.3354123830795288,
-0.22073876857757568,
0.15617410838603973,
0.7064715027809143,
-0.11228920519351959,
0.0651378408074379,
0.48103731870651245,
1.1939724683761597,
0.33010411262512207,
-0.47202083468437195,
-1.0497952699661255,
0.27721723914146423,
-0.5558367967605591,
0.557364284992218,
-0.31137076020240784,
0.05896574258804321,
-0.3306170701980591,
-0.20017707347869873,
-0.18806518614292145,
0.2077055275440216,
0.5905396342277527,
-0.6010729074478149,
-0.19547602534294128,
-0.44903814792633057,
-0.07670284062623978,
-0.44290128350257874,
0.7010499835014343,
-0.727651834487915,
0.6473215818405151,
-0.2179449200630188,
-1.1164824962615967,
0.6378671526908875,
-0.32327941060066223,
-0.6545244455337524,
-0.5824846625328064,
-0.03805850073695183,
-0.4235394299030304,
-0.07256584614515305,
0.31052693724632263,
0.24593158066272736,
-0.5263540744781494,
0.616858720779419,
-0.7346400022506714,
-0.3308731019496918,
0.25951364636421204,
-0.5605511665344238,
1.2674155235290527,
0.04277234151959419,
-0.5658784508705139,
0.18275895714759827,
-1.2395099401474,
-0.49600300192832947,
0.13162359595298767,
-0.17285923659801483,
-0.6136512756347656,
0.15891128778457642,
-0.6154428720474243,
0.5391654968261719,
-0.14961805939674377,
-0.8272214531898499,
0.20361416041851044,
0.17675238847732544,
-0.40646517276763916,
0.8658117651939392,
0.4136889576911926,
0.019361963495612144,
-0.2746914327144623,
0.21291483938694,
0.2535124719142914,
0.4597599506378174,
0.1753409504890442,
-0.7319031357765198,
-0.3755509555339813,
-0.4538913369178772,
0.1631515473127365,
0.5027397871017456,
-0.25201988220214844,
0.38187792897224426,
-0.23341161012649536,
-0.39634183049201965,
-0.32317376136779785,
-0.21720661222934723,
0.008715011179447174,
0.6336967945098877,
0.6657829284667969,
-0.033378563821315765,
-0.4228131175041199,
-0.3351882994174957,
-0.4204062819480896,
-0.3833498954772949,
0.32040154933929443,
-0.061049651354551315,
0.37602218985557556,
-0.34635651111602783,
0.7806673049926758,
-0.7286962866783142,
-0.23134227097034454,
0.1903160959482193,
0.5523233413696289,
0.3196547329425812,
0.3461531400680542,
0.32669535279273987,
-0.7557464241981506,
0.01219068095088005,
-0.5260336995124817,
-0.48515892028808594,
0.07605332881212234,
-0.7022041082382202,
-0.3246038854122162,
-0.4219500422477722,
0.5088980197906494,
-0.7326322197914124,
0.6336387395858765,
0.31132757663726807,
-0.8511291146278381,
0.6386705636978149,
-0.07618697732686996,
0.5941949486732483,
-0.5724278688430786,
0.13439957797527313,
-0.05642252042889595,
-0.07198828458786011,
-0.586317241191864,
-0.10217340290546417,
-0.32722747325897217,
0.18887346982955933,
-0.20537008345127106,
0.3869728147983551,
-0.15749084949493408,
0.12082722783088684,
-0.05433039739727974,
0.20409713685512543,
-0.07294954359531403,
0.5744746327400208,
-0.04967128857970238,
-0.018796337768435478,
0.8328762650489807,
-0.6988974809646606,
0.28637808561325073,
0.5766513347625732,
-0.19552238285541534,
0.3360544443130493,
-0.2311047613620758,
-0.05303288623690605,
-0.3188420236110687,
0.6681772470474243,
-1.1359126567840576,
0.0989561527967453,
0.5836820006370544,
-0.3404405117034912,
0.016519568860530853,
-0.3639884293079376,
-0.2170114368200302,
-0.31340181827545166,
-0.4300028681755066,
0.10056011378765106,
-0.00733294989913702,
-0.6969190835952759,
0.7561455368995667,
-0.27082332968711853,
0.6571709513664246,
-0.5829772353172302,
-0.5406696796417236,
0.10425680130720139,
-0.2412366420030594,
-0.677701473236084,
-0.10981886833906174,
-0.19382326304912567,
-0.3660106062889099,
-0.3044377565383911,
-0.5143340229988098,
0.18179209530353546,
0.41629478335380554,
0.29831066727638245,
0.1053861752152443,
0.154583141207695,
0.024170413613319397,
-0.19127218425273895,
-0.26050370931625366,
0.3513660132884979,
-0.08543979376554489,
0.2384793758392334,
0.29076066613197327,
-0.7650250792503357,
-0.14188958704471588,
0.0956900492310524,
0.9003997445106506,
-0.1429343968629837,
0.7388758659362793,
0.9114008545875549,
-0.2148260772228241,
0.1453310251235962,
-0.37729412317276,
-0.12332632392644882,
-0.31397974491119385,
-0.03038928098976612,
-0.46473228931427,
-0.38000407814979553,
0.2195512056350708,
-0.27155637741088867,
0.19126218557357788,
0.22956156730651855,
0.3968932330608368,
0.40575599670410156,
0.9227418303489685,
0.3408764898777008,
-0.1906886249780655,
0.11461576819419861,
0.139886274933815,
0.5823467373847961,
-0.5702552795410156,
-0.3540920317173004,
-0.6815942525863647,
-0.3071489930152893,
-0.569031834602356,
-0.703454315662384,
0.4025780260562897,
0.3908027708530426,
-0.4606081247329712,
0.07678371667861938,
0.14748574793338776,
-0.2511172890663147,
0.6265196204185486,
0.6168673038482666,
0.6599194407463074,
-0.37115228176116943,
-0.31420841813087463,
0.3826371133327484,
-0.6066834330558777,
-0.08690599352121353,
0.8336271643638611,
0.38551685214042664,
0.9589952230453491,
0.39037662744522095,
0.6847102642059326,
0.4624534547328949,
0.18208372592926025,
-0.7040090560913086,
0.4849774241447449,
0.3168735206127167,
-0.6054335832595825,
-0.3801867961883545,
-0.4732409417629242,
-0.49082857370376587,
0.43589720129966736,
-0.2861720323562622,
-0.905992329120636,
0.6321496963500977,
0.3258882761001587,
-0.4647333025932312,
0.4122524857521057,
-0.32245755195617676,
0.6926931142807007,
-0.4306713342666626,
-0.7439363598823547,
-0.46141624450683594,
-0.8696920871734619,
0.6705263257026672,
0.005466259550303221,
0.6275829672813416,
-0.12845927476882935,
0.5799107551574707,
0.58263099193573,
-0.36012735962867737,
0.9570644497871399,
-0.6104266047477722,
-0.024540051817893982,
0.2661009430885315,
0.4370543956756592,
0.9436423778533936,
0.22137700021266937,
0.23978687822818756,
0.3315635323524475,
-0.4255163073539734,
-0.1492554396390915,
-0.7044188380241394,
0.22273309528827667,
-0.3885737955570221,
-0.755022406578064,
-0.6302786469459534,
-0.26154646277427673,
-0.5532338619232178,
0.0881618931889534,
-0.18445317447185516,
0.404552698135376,
-0.16350871324539185,
0.12761959433555603,
0.37677547335624695,
-0.24857942759990692,
0.22380542755126953,
0.7250589728355408,
-0.04408798739314079,
-0.2939932942390442,
0.39132004976272583,
-0.4264649450778961,
-0.05702947825193405,
0.7559993267059326,
0.9205389022827148,
-0.29970595240592957,
-0.529259979724884,
-0.33405089378356934,
-0.08439785242080688,
-0.39267855882644653,
-0.14186638593673706,
-0.8363421559333801,
0.23252566158771515,
-0.5495347380638123,
0.05878618359565735,
-0.40975221991539,
-0.4240347445011139,
0.5766772031784058,
-0.20922376215457916,
0.5058002471923828,
0.28471240401268005,
-0.6176603436470032,
0.2103515863418579,
-0.6275514364242554,
0.7865320444107056,
0.3925206661224365,
0.2295800745487213,
0.09109897166490555,
-0.49187448620796204,
-0.4487048089504242,
0.1290409415960312,
-0.2489539533853531,
-0.9324438571929932,
-0.35799118876457214,
-0.35625022649765015,
0.42756861448287964,
0.6651114225387573,
0.17145511507987976,
0.7926626205444336,
-0.47396835684776306,
0.5907120108604431,
0.506456196308136,
-0.6134141087532043,
0.6623347997665405,
-0.3033427298069,
-0.18739446997642517,
0.19033074378967285,
0.3767896890640259,
-0.5156623125076294,
-0.28724732995033264,
-0.7352420687675476,
-0.6196948289871216,
0.5794466733932495,
0.07261814922094345,
-0.6289659738540649,
0.14182451367378235,
-0.1560046523809433,
-0.3248078227043152,
0.08283081650733948,
-0.6931241154670715,
-0.42557358741760254,
-0.28995123505592346,
0.2509012818336487,
-0.07250091433525085,
-0.11452022939920425,
-0.4738999307155609,
-0.24367114901542664,
0.9959020614624023,
-0.08191736787557602,
0.11853010207414627,
0.27960270643234253,
-0.2337293177843094,
-0.2850618064403534,
0.4554605782032013,
0.4124935269355774,
0.6681521534919739,
-0.6000578999519348,
0.29172950983047485,
-0.13765135407447815,
-0.4311174154281616,
0.47529780864715576,
0.3083184063434601,
-0.4291384220123291,
-0.0041345092467963696,
0.5760594606399536,
0.692582905292511,
0.19704972207546234,
-0.0907839983701706,
0.7672309875488281,
0.16234008967876434,
0.16722336411476135,
0.4090847373008728,
-0.058971572667360306,
-0.2993756830692291,
0.5253390669822693,
0.07858989387750626,
0.42087867856025696,
0.2239561825990677,
-0.3690569996833801,
0.5286529064178467,
0.2993805408477783,
-0.24793100357055664,
-0.3133476674556732,
0.8000484108924866,
-0.013010759837925434,
0.1472182422876358,
0.36077645421028137,
-0.11496436595916748,
-0.3853110373020172,
0.29457300901412964,
0.5169966816902161,
1.1404367685317993,
-0.37702685594558716,
0.5088896155357361,
0.7658979296684265,
0.7302748560905457,
-0.18444286286830902,
-0.19534169137477875,
-0.0010619444074109197,
-0.8119080066680908,
-0.4334677755832672,
-0.6464030146598816,
-0.2704398036003113,
0.19878117740154266,
-0.38914236426353455,
0.26978790760040283,
-0.2865164577960968,
0.01745859533548355,
-0.26570573449134827,
0.0666482225060463,
-0.44586625695228577,
0.5884447693824768,
0.009905391372740269,
0.9327065944671631,
-1.449607014656067,
0.5636134743690491,
0.5358814001083374,
-0.587349534034729,
-0.6196252703666687,
0.3724340796470642,
0.3798764944076538,
-0.5785597562789917,
0.47593769431114197,
-0.05127432569861412,
-0.5187864899635315,
-0.4278714656829834,
-0.32421377301216125,
-0.887298583984375,
0.9221940636634827,
0.22644959390163422,
-0.4020176827907562,
0.10716468840837479,
-0.060760874301195145,
0.09762031584978104,
0.02209913730621338,
0.23737522959709167,
0.6440308690071106,
0.886040985584259,
0.3032691180706024,
-0.08430701494216919,
0.5485661029815674,
0.21474610269069672,
-0.5371983051300049,
-0.11616699397563934,
-0.8843042850494385,
0.5460302829742432,
-0.6133056879043579,
0.27219825983047485,
-0.23886877298355103,
0.44725272059440613,
0.5239523649215698,
0.581148624420166,
0.8880664110183716,
0.5239311456680298,
0.8270688652992249,
0.1610800176858902,
0.7004772424697876,
-0.3292214870452881,
0.2624626159667969,
1.3821721076965332,
-0.22774313390254974,
0.07903473824262619,
0.5922116041183472,
-0.22738704085350037,
0.6792929768562317,
0.4222605526447296,
0.044906675815582275,
0.579053521156311,
0.08948947489261627,
0.0839385837316513,
-0.369828462600708,
0.1751926839351654,
-0.0995941087603569,
0.8284241557121277,
-0.004206047859042883,
-0.029319049790501595,
-0.6575718522071838,
-0.334073930978775,
0.19951507449150085,
-0.3728521466255188,
-0.107426717877388,
0.2616961598396301,
-0.22015707194805145,
-0.4666662812232971,
0.23376153409481049,
0.22994162142276764,
0.07276863604784012,
-0.8057310581207275,
-0.2265763133764267,
-0.16154082119464874,
0.03453909605741501,
-0.23599520325660706,
-0.15947860479354858,
0.15845850110054016,
-0.21584728360176086,
-0.02333667129278183,
-0.3266938030719757,
0.7110483646392822,
-0.11056811362504959,
-0.3815487027168274,
0.46684592962265015,
0.5712657570838928,
-0.1130375787615776,
-0.13676777482032776,
-0.590683102607727,
-0.14629250764846802,
0.1464407593011856,
-0.3771817684173584,
-0.04923630878329277,
0.5800536274909973,
-0.3074342906475067,
0.4540823996067047,
0.8146541118621826,
0.25317880511283875,
0.05084724351763725,
0.3277137279510498,
0.6322625875473022,
-0.6966933012008667,
-0.6834142208099365,
-1.0438390970230103,
0.6261369585990906,
-0.024102572351694107,
-0.21730045974254608,
1.0133640766143799,
0.5093488097190857,
0.2599315941333771,
0.14284087717533112,
0.47287437319755554,
-0.42920875549316406,
0.2748212218284607,
-0.60797119140625,
0.37997967004776,
-0.27637600898742676,
0.21439129114151,
-0.7254230976104736,
-0.34894394874572754,
-0.2922748029232025,
0.5003116130828857,
-0.1837632656097412,
-0.13437937200069427,
0.9583481550216675,
0.7342180013656616,
-0.194360613822937,
0.09070771932601929,
0.2888508439064026,
0.6020426750183105,
0.44901150465011597,
0.10997764766216278,
0.6072954535484314,
-0.5667974948883057,
0.2896510064601898,
-0.09116986393928528,
-0.7081760764122009,
-0.12244559824466705,
-1.0979644060134888,
-0.7189804315567017,
-0.26461613178253174,
-0.7208691835403442,
-0.5811585783958435,
0.022220833227038383,
0.755366861820221,
0.6282627582550049,
-0.6298772096633911,
0.009467094205319881,
-0.23573380708694458,
0.6393058896064758,
-0.9138392210006714,
-0.1740608960390091,
0.7072722911834717,
-0.1838289499282837,
-0.034753113985061646,
0.5818326473236084,
0.1340072900056839,
-0.3269343972206116,
-0.035858333110809326,
0.04447747766971588,
-0.9430807828903198,
0.21727913618087769,
0.588862955570221,
-0.05179693177342415,
-0.3077392578125,
-0.5029918551445007,
-0.5013018250465393,
0.38078218698501587,
0.19398841261863708,
1.1940373182296753,
-0.7144748568534851,
0.5215127468109131,
0.361736923456192,
0.5875642895698547,
0.38233694434165955,
0.29932284355163574,
0.17971625924110413,
-0.7321193218231201,
0.1431640386581421,
-0.4165779650211334,
0.3870050013065338,
0.03986804187297821,
-0.6303457021713257,
0.44444143772125244,
0.7554832696914673,
-0.18693239986896515,
-0.3991197347640991,
0.3196626603603363,
-0.865268886089325,
-0.243108332157135,
1.165786623954773,
-0.06611641496419907,
-0.205563485622406,
-0.3010441064834595,
0.10499650239944458,
0.5032281875610352,
-0.2893647849559784,
0.97883141040802,
0.6017887592315674,
-0.4772357940673828,
0.2750985324382782,
-0.31726014614105225,
0.37728461623191833,
-0.059478510171175,
-0.6543229222297668,
0.469463586807251,
0.8261400461196899,
0.25635066628456116,
0.36901912093162537,
0.8005883693695068,
-0.019204674288630486,
0.2176125943660736,
0.3519420921802521,
-0.2779442071914673,
-0.2968341112136841,
-0.762727677822113,
-0.1929675191640854,
0.03794259950518608,
-0.06446053087711334,
-0.7011641263961792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02694v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02694v2
|
Privacy-Aware Semantic Cache for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-05T06:23:50 | 2024-04-03T16:06:30 |
Waris Gill, Mohamed Elidrisi, Pallavi Kalapatapu, Ali Anwar, Muhammad Ali Gulzar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.DC, I.2.7
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT and Llama2 have revolutionized
natural language processing and search engine dynamics. However, these models
incur exceptionally high computational costs. For instance, GPT-3 consists of
175 billion parameters where inference demands billions of floating-point
operations. Caching is a natural solution to reduce LLM inference costs on
repeated queries which constitute about 31% of the total queries. However,
existing caching methods are incapable of finding semantic similarities among
LLM queries, leading to unacceptable false hit-and-miss rates.
This paper introduces MeanCache, a user-centric semantic cache for LLMs that
identifies semantically similar queries to determine cache hit or miss. Using
MeanCache, the response to a user's semantically similar query can be retrieved
from a local cache rather than re-querying the LLM, thus reducing costs,
service provider load, and environmental impact. Existing caching solutions for
LLMs raise privacy and scalability concerns and perform wasteful query
requests. MeanCache leverages Federated Learning (FL) to collaboratively train
a query similarity model across LLM users without violating privacy. By placing
a local cache in each user's device and using FL, MeanCache reduces the latency
and costs and enhances model performance, resulting in lower false hit rates.
MeanCache compresses the embedding dimensions to minimize cache storage and
also finds the optimal cosine similarity threshold. Our experiments benchmarked
against the state-of-the-art caching method, reveal that MeanCache attains an
approximately 17% higher F-score and a 20% increase in precision during
semantic cache hit-and-miss decisions. It also reduces the storage requirement
by 83% and accelerates semantic cache hit-and-miss decisions by 11%.
|
[
-0.40536704659461975,
-0.6323471665382385,
0.4506533443927765,
0.2021801620721817,
-0.13512487709522247,
-0.030671197921037674,
-0.27545735239982605,
-0.6230977177619934,
0.5861945152282715,
0.5671896934509277,
-0.7404115796089172,
-0.8200585842132568,
-0.3367561995983124,
-0.18072013556957245,
-0.4414407014846802,
0.6380287408828735,
0.017107902094721794,
-0.27381595969200134,
-0.1572396457195282,
-0.09780053794384003,
-0.18087774515151978,
-0.3208954930305481,
-0.7498098611831665,
-0.07968149334192276,
0.682223379611969,
0.20830872654914856,
0.9270324110984802,
0.45837458968162537,
0.2229037582874298,
0.321950763463974,
0.0129817770794034,
0.30206605792045593,
-0.6285387873649597,
0.31893569231033325,
-0.26769962906837463,
-0.5304674506187439,
-0.28443798422813416,
-0.004027745686471462,
0.40804943442344666,
0.27053675055503845,
-0.38499557971954346,
-0.19231663644313812,
-0.004038768820464611,
0.6633210778236389,
-1.1187397241592407,
0.37872952222824097,
-0.6980846524238586,
-0.05924246460199356,
-0.37929052114486694,
-0.11455415934324265,
-0.3253972828388214,
-0.48174363374710083,
0.18429158627986908,
-0.677452564239502,
0.4112292528152466,
0.044192127883434296,
0.5752562284469604,
0.2825870215892792,
-0.03790166229009628,
-0.31838539242744446,
-0.26132410764694214,
0.863105297088623,
-0.6505677103996277,
0.5375303030014038,
0.6729099750518799,
0.2526555061340332,
-0.5873671770095825,
-0.6333291530609131,
-0.771965742111206,
0.009179938584566116,
0.06644128262996674,
0.1364118456840515,
-0.11801662296056747,
-0.007989753037691116,
-0.013173322193324566,
0.3886331021785736,
-0.7023220062255859,
0.38463419675827026,
0.12275766581296921,
-0.4853983223438263,
0.34107765555381775,
0.24764379858970642,
0.21785248816013336,
0.0707143023610115,
-0.4111573398113251,
-0.22594855725765228,
-0.783321738243103,
-0.13187457621097565,
0.450099378824234,
0.30990248918533325,
0.022524697706103325,
0.21456937491893768,
-0.6898804306983948,
0.42267248034477234,
-0.36280393600463867,
-0.15178462862968445,
0.13175274431705475,
-0.3372425138950348,
-0.03846801072359085,
0.1290530562400818,
0.6749287843704224,
0.43056148290634155,
0.3128272593021393,
-0.36327412724494934,
0.04191337898373604,
-0.15356779098510742,
0.05634741112589836,
-0.9642800688743591,
-0.15330925583839417,
0.11405150592327118,
-0.08312097191810608,
-0.16653181612491608,
0.18736626207828522,
-0.8597191572189331,
-0.41069167852401733,
-0.020153677091002464,
0.2388775795698166,
-0.030977372080087662,
-0.0028463162016123533,
0.35970887541770935,
0.36877158284187317,
0.15350720286369324,
0.38287240266799927,
-1.1881601810455322,
0.6482380628585815,
0.8655176162719727,
0.9064455628395081,
-0.31635528802871704,
-0.3239034414291382,
-0.48932453989982605,
0.33858299255371094,
-0.10195162147283554,
0.6302251815795898,
-0.43272194266319275,
-0.5880138278007507,
0.062441498041152954,
0.1276187151670456,
0.051127839833498,
-0.426347017288208,
0.12729822099208832,
-0.8954702615737915,
0.25360721349716187,
-0.6893327832221985,
-0.49707654118537903,
-0.2890580892562866,
0.2643475830554962,
-0.8960908651351929,
0.9794026017189026,
-0.09566528350114822,
-0.8495810031890869,
0.40417513251304626,
-0.41832655668258667,
-0.22485405206680298,
-0.022043444216251373,
-0.18164314329624176,
-0.5127936601638794,
-0.08089544624090195,
0.2592056095600128,
0.4309659004211426,
-0.4871026575565338,
0.04551979526877403,
-0.3326674699783325,
-0.5426936149597168,
0.05413329601287842,
-0.17575304210186005,
0.6558881402015686,
0.20917345583438873,
-0.4124230742454529,
-0.027122842147946358,
-0.6456296443939209,
0.18285821378231049,
0.02114284783601761,
-0.35308215022087097,
-0.38718700408935547,
0.08619318157434464,
-0.13073967397212982,
0.06132319197058678,
0.5526607036590576,
-0.7281534075737,
-0.042492032051086426,
-0.6911196112632751,
0.361310750246048,
0.7737398147583008,
-0.06526536494493484,
0.3329775333404541,
-0.26657435297966003,
0.11602191627025604,
0.0386548787355423,
0.1673848181962967,
-0.05079219490289688,
-0.5813602209091187,
-0.6465681195259094,
-0.29399725794792175,
0.06054939329624176,
0.2942439913749695,
-0.14888930320739746,
0.3060692250728607,
-0.3062022626399994,
-0.4152204394340515,
-0.5375760197639465,
0.31207871437072754,
0.3356958031654358,
0.4293532967567444,
0.28798502683639526,
-0.626174807548523,
0.08738141506910324,
-0.8302122354507446,
-0.12500718235969543,
-0.13986989855766296,
-0.13193610310554504,
0.7135259509086609,
0.3007790744304657,
-0.17156288027763367,
1.013444185256958,
-0.6320789456367493,
-0.5890032052993774,
0.43633997440338135,
0.054517634212970734,
-0.043594926595687866,
0.34535765647888184,
0.14906038343906403,
-0.736527144908905,
-0.3439876437187195,
-0.20424604415893555,
-0.4342307448387146,
-0.05516054108738899,
0.33844250440597534,
-0.15056340396404266,
0.4417901933193207,
0.27786147594451904,
-0.7469662427902222,
0.6265689134597778,
0.5389838814735413,
-0.1658489853143692,
0.2831435799598694,
-0.38215920329093933,
0.21053241193294525,
-0.8885985612869263,
0.013268292881548405,
-0.5770044326782227,
-0.29436764121055603,
-0.09362207353115082,
0.3156565725803375,
0.18266284465789795,
-0.13395027816295624,
-0.5751569867134094,
0.6421852111816406,
-0.3624782860279083,
-0.24665887653827667,
-0.39276906847953796,
0.19339439272880554,
0.030843758955597878,
0.4137309789657593,
-0.20093250274658203,
1.0194042921066284,
0.40949833393096924,
-0.5826308131217957,
0.3291008174419403,
0.03493078798055649,
-0.20680823922157288,
0.13745151460170746,
-0.4929546117782593,
0.48673978447914124,
0.27916407585144043,
0.6229650378227234,
-0.8232832551002502,
-0.28611284494400024,
-0.02343141660094261,
-0.19778387248516083,
0.05072030425071716,
0.07077440619468689,
-1.127248764038086,
-0.190596804022789,
-0.48206236958503723,
0.3024955987930298,
0.15749454498291016,
-0.8962236046791077,
0.6043919920921326,
0.36419913172721863,
0.3430674970149994,
-0.7844523787498474,
-0.7255903482437134,
0.02681717835366726,
-0.05134006217122078,
-0.968136191368103,
0.4603929817676544,
0.05071108043193817,
0.1175842210650444,
-0.029005667194724083,
-0.1946909874677658,
-0.010791043750941753,
0.24771128594875336,
0.3809211850166321,
-0.13465067744255066,
-0.04807216301560402,
0.21478034555912018,
-0.13739627599716187,
-0.4413521885871887,
-0.120838962495327,
-0.3873044550418854,
0.7709026336669922,
-0.37341898679733276,
-0.5225744843482971,
-0.44014260172843933,
0.41549691557884216,
0.34236055612564087,
-0.36695346236228943,
1.0582557916641235,
0.5562743544578552,
-0.4983808994293213,
-0.135457843542099,
-0.8591740727424622,
-0.4146910011768341,
-0.5591461658477783,
0.08849003165960312,
-0.179096981883049,
-1.2748578786849976,
0.9490051865577698,
0.13625086843967438,
0.1144975945353508,
0.0343368835747242,
1.005958914756775,
0.23162804543972015,
0.6047592759132385,
0.489633172750473,
-0.41308093070983887,
0.2900072932243347,
0.00636903615668416,
0.3303300440311432,
-0.3315097689628601,
-0.22566087543964386,
-0.4449637532234192,
-0.41196247935295105,
-0.9405149221420288,
-0.5926409363746643,
0.18984299898147583,
-0.4422663450241089,
-0.2676975429058075,
0.21148021519184113,
-0.27101725339889526,
0.8822302222251892,
0.6268438100814819,
0.42600125074386597,
0.46377378702163696,
-0.16395458579063416,
-0.15736769139766693,
-0.09847568720579147,
-0.06822418421506882,
-0.12948200106620789,
0.9732246994972229,
0.010892460122704506,
1.0869637727737427,
0.3930414915084839,
0.9883449673652649,
-0.03576749935746193,
-0.03769301250576973,
-0.6810120344161987,
0.6137248873710632,
-0.10573098808526993,
-0.7582188248634338,
-0.265866219997406,
-0.36891597509384155,
-1.0283671617507935,
0.3162592947483063,
0.12861794233322144,
-0.9807753562927246,
0.024338852614164352,
0.02238425426185131,
-0.04386046156287193,
0.3551109731197357,
-0.581423282623291,
0.6377227306365967,
0.15545576810836792,
-0.8249331116676331,
-0.5565246939659119,
-0.7097609639167786,
0.16018326580524445,
-0.18865647912025452,
-0.010949878953397274,
-0.11230890452861786,
-0.29671743512153625,
0.6876479983329773,
-0.538663387298584,
0.9057267308235168,
-0.366914302110672,
0.07935064285993576,
0.2767674922943115,
0.35194841027259827,
0.7817562818527222,
-0.06548432260751724,
-0.028925972059369087,
0.03587441146373749,
-0.15969927608966827,
-0.47649630904197693,
-0.6609832048416138,
1.3953031301498413,
-0.5999128818511963,
-0.788458526134491,
-0.2709883153438568,
-0.631542444229126,
-0.2193264663219452,
0.3540903329849243,
-0.09241878986358643,
0.008804774843156338,
-0.14533089101314545,
0.226409912109375,
0.9078688621520996,
-0.29355788230895996,
0.4030105173587799,
0.8509057760238647,
-0.14805884659290314,
0.18206489086151123,
0.6808394193649292,
0.026158316060900688,
0.21943342685699463,
0.38877424597740173,
0.38083943724632263,
-0.3722413182258606,
-0.30122217535972595,
0.006709777284413576,
0.3676362633705139,
-0.8050761222839355,
-0.23753035068511963,
-0.8970397114753723,
-0.045632507652044296,
-0.19072715938091278,
-0.17402344942092896,
-0.7389557957649231,
-0.21471187472343445,
-0.34169554710388184,
-0.06281234323978424,
0.6241522431373596,
0.05706683546304703,
0.09173455834388733,
0.5972859859466553,
-0.37917178869247437,
-0.0968078076839447,
0.2715168297290802,
0.6335817575454712,
0.24847660958766937,
-0.01606312207877636,
-0.03777429088950157,
-0.1801779568195343,
-0.4857454001903534,
-0.46985864639282227,
0.29121264815330505,
0.12396202981472015,
0.2788536250591278,
0.43508729338645935,
0.04694819077849388,
0.6853299140930176,
-0.267041951417923,
0.7130576372146606,
-0.002346871653571725,
-0.6275294423103333,
0.35128989815711975,
-0.11469870060682297,
0.2796822488307953,
0.8255785703659058,
0.29258695244789124,
-0.2930026650428772,
-0.42910996079444885,
-0.5150902271270752,
-0.8120945692062378,
0.3775891065597534,
-0.060105424374341965,
0.38736575841903687,
-0.2667638063430786,
0.14465762674808502,
0.14152342081069946,
-0.04540346935391426,
-0.45877647399902344,
-0.06873127073049545,
0.13590474426746368,
-0.11116404086351395,
0.07730381190776825,
-0.03774566575884819,
0.13242512941360474,
0.18215157091617584,
0.5400934219360352,
-0.08697780221700668,
0.160854309797287,
-0.03358517587184906,
0.08738076686859131,
-0.08852297812700272,
0.2551420032978058,
0.2102590948343277,
0.5388650298118591,
-0.36000925302505493,
0.22517840564250946,
0.17111584544181824,
-0.5760807991027832,
-0.07046478986740112,
0.01894875429570675,
0.031942885369062424,
-0.2320278286933899,
-0.2105368673801422,
0.12727998197078705,
0.7219098806381226,
-0.6614598035812378,
0.694516122341156,
-0.3336065709590912,
-0.006552491802722216,
-0.213263601064682,
0.378451406955719,
0.5329326391220093,
0.17249108850955963,
-0.11354467272758484,
-0.3620745539665222,
0.30371060967445374,
-0.3151756227016449,
0.28040704131126404,
0.4039267897605896,
-0.2852446138858795,
-0.07981545478105545,
0.6732116937637329,
-0.0388733372092247,
0.014033223502337933,
0.8056943416595459,
0.22544604539871216,
-0.37747713923454285,
0.2561177909374237,
0.5504441261291504,
0.7628787159919739,
-0.33166471123695374,
-0.15036626160144806,
0.19491352140903473,
0.02199871651828289,
-0.18317385017871857,
0.21102507412433624,
-0.35258644819259644,
-0.5463742017745972,
-0.10314557701349258,
-0.6830852627754211,
-0.577908992767334,
0.018080152571201324,
-0.6035422682762146,
0.33644577860832214,
-0.6004086136817932,
0.03653477132320404,
-0.15756924450397491,
0.45859798789024353,
-0.7867879271507263,
-0.043617021292448044,
-0.20712971687316895,
0.965096116065979,
-0.5845811367034912,
0.8877306580543518,
-0.027511151507496834,
-0.27239423990249634,
-0.6292510628700256,
-0.2707555890083313,
0.4225892126560211,
-1.1752909421920776,
0.3528986871242523,
0.42116111516952515,
-0.4585475027561188,
-0.09602028876543045,
-0.46015650033950806,
-0.7581861019134521,
1.285740852355957,
0.20602168142795563,
-0.5770647525787354,
0.045664869248867035,
0.0936618372797966,
0.5576450228691101,
-0.27422213554382324,
0.1318347305059433,
0.47457826137542725,
0.287387877702713,
0.3200197219848633,
-0.7579806447029114,
0.4440396726131439,
0.30926358699798584,
-0.10851947963237762,
0.2850108742713928,
-0.8495984673500061,
0.7254184484481812,
-0.177838996052742,
-0.22892017662525177,
0.10098540782928467,
0.6434706449508667,
0.41408592462539673,
0.4060763716697693,
0.3773103356361389,
0.8065826892852783,
0.9694470763206482,
0.2649078667163849,
1.214892029762268,
-0.13297462463378906,
0.3127371370792389,
1.2226390838623047,
-0.33306434750556946,
0.961813747882843,
0.4061106741428375,
-0.08198972046375275,
0.23442646861076355,
0.5354377627372742,
0.3179408311843872,
0.820013701915741,
0.4304434657096863,
-0.6002046465873718,
-0.13196420669555664,
-0.04446790739893913,
-0.3217402994632721,
0.409579873085022,
0.32174861431121826,
-0.4715942144393921,
-0.6323642134666443,
-0.4224589765071869,
0.45601123571395874,
-0.028600702062249184,
0.0636691004037857,
0.850757896900177,
0.17908740043640137,
-0.4859512150287628,
0.387160062789917,
0.16129659116268158,
0.5456475615501404,
-0.649667501449585,
0.2719380855560303,
-0.361569344997406,
0.2793892025947571,
-0.19790953397750854,
-0.61493319272995,
0.19280505180358887,
-0.0816408097743988,
-0.23873288929462433,
0.07514993846416473,
0.5078461766242981,
-0.19229744374752045,
0.04556775093078613,
0.5597882866859436,
0.2788125276565552,
0.38031893968582153,
-0.1377696692943573,
-0.661334216594696,
0.08040569722652435,
-0.10330843180418015,
-0.27277064323425293,
0.7272903323173523,
0.2410709708929062,
-0.2710752785205841,
0.725763738155365,
0.7964230179786682,
0.006327526643872261,
0.2688078284263611,
0.3219163715839386,
1.1291983127593994,
-0.454549103975296,
-0.8974026441574097,
-0.9224653244018555,
-0.19443778693675995,
0.20978185534477234,
-0.037784893065690994,
0.5067839026451111,
0.5829956531524658,
0.9110972285270691,
0.34788843989372253,
0.2565862834453583,
0.2876456081867218,
0.45637398958206177,
-0.7221540212631226,
0.9102786183357239,
-0.4069230556488037,
0.3032101094722748,
-0.030885916203260422,
-0.990878164768219,
-0.42765384912490845,
0.48889413475990295,
-0.4190918207168579,
0.04727807641029358,
0.4843786656856537,
1.4351009130477905,
-0.2388463318347931,
0.5228925347328186,
0.22483637928962708,
0.03225091099739075,
0.7128803730010986,
0.6751931309700012,
0.4623759984970093,
-0.3037559986114502,
0.3582446277141571,
-0.1832151710987091,
-0.3357654809951782,
-0.19040906429290771,
-0.8711215257644653,
-0.7074353694915771,
-0.41337645053863525,
-0.030277855694293976,
-0.14449149370193481,
0.18239207565784454,
0.5937963128089905,
0.7581557035446167,
-0.691247820854187,
0.018875762820243835,
-0.1020631417632103,
0.005492399912327528,
0.11411643028259277,
-0.20895586907863617,
0.6099556088447571,
-0.2796057164669037,
-0.4967114329338074,
0.09140830487012863,
0.2690484821796417,
-0.038805827498435974,
-0.31979459524154663,
-0.06341513991355896,
-0.20977476239204407,
0.013651659712195396,
0.046492960304021835,
0.21353936195373535,
-0.8425774574279785,
-0.3454952538013458,
-0.18379637598991394,
-0.22739769518375397,
-0.00846970546990633,
0.6915770769119263,
-0.7489261031150818,
0.785774827003479,
0.3173523247241974,
0.8355303406715393,
0.9543002843856812,
-0.10606943070888519,
0.15746332705020905,
-0.6675223708152771,
0.23847165703773499,
0.017907189205288887,
0.2858245074748993,
0.3926944136619568,
-0.572488009929657,
0.3465937376022339,
0.05705215409398079,
-0.7469448447227478,
-0.3246620297431946,
-0.05016415938735008,
-1.2119773626327515,
-0.022246096283197403,
0.7511189579963684,
-0.4515811502933502,
-0.5466288328170776,
-0.07491421699523926,
0.20025859773159027,
0.07258446514606476,
-0.6191897988319397,
0.954657793045044,
0.8134217858314514,
0.14527320861816406,
0.1644328087568283,
-0.7085932493209839,
0.3467448353767395,
0.4149811565876007,
-0.5880170464515686,
0.35858121514320374,
0.406393438577652,
0.4535687565803528,
-0.0567217580974102,
0.606919527053833,
-0.593891978263855,
0.21914105117321014,
-0.1068238615989685,
-0.3089779317378998,
-0.13084182143211365,
-0.20294982194900513,
0.14027449488639832,
-0.0880293995141983,
-0.2846073508262634,
-0.18633125722408295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02691v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02691v2
|
InjecAgent: Benchmarking Indirect Prompt Injections in Tool-Integrated Large Language Model Agents
| 2024-03-05T06:21:45 | 2024-03-25T17:25:10 |
Qiusi Zhan, Zhixiang Liang, Zifan Ying, Daniel Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Recent work has embodied LLMs as agents, allowing them to access tools,
perform actions, and interact with external content (e.g., emails or websites).
However, external content introduces the risk of indirect prompt injection
(IPI) attacks, where malicious instructions are embedded within the content
processed by LLMs, aiming to manipulate these agents into executing detrimental
actions against users. Given the potentially severe consequences of such
attacks, establishing benchmarks to assess and mitigate these risks is
imperative.
In this work, we introduce InjecAgent, a benchmark designed to assess the
vulnerability of tool-integrated LLM agents to IPI attacks. InjecAgent
comprises 1,054 test cases covering 17 different user tools and 62 attacker
tools. We categorize attack intentions into two primary types: direct harm to
users and exfiltration of private data. We evaluate 30 different LLM agents and
show that agents are vulnerable to IPI attacks, with ReAct-prompted GPT-4
vulnerable to attacks 24% of the time. Further investigation into an enhanced
setting, where the attacker instructions are reinforced with a hacking prompt,
shows additional increases in success rates, nearly doubling the attack success
rate on the ReAct-prompted GPT-4. Our findings raise questions about the
widespread deployment of LLM Agents. Our benchmark is available at
https://github.com/uiuc-kang-lab/InjecAgent.
|
[
-0.26952385902404785,
-0.6948620676994324,
0.6932802796363831,
0.3642508089542389,
0.04931589961051941,
0.1931232064962387,
0.046709224581718445,
-0.5399571657180786,
-0.3466932773590088,
0.403063029050827,
-0.5295896530151367,
-0.4996701776981354,
-0.3761121332645416,
0.4263173043727875,
-0.41982024908065796,
0.5939487218856812,
-0.15488681197166443,
0.20153822004795074,
-0.4672708809375763,
0.0356210395693779,
-0.7328203320503235,
-0.39993593096733093,
-0.7161117196083069,
-0.06736231595277786,
0.2980833947658539,
0.2737515866756439,
0.37281349301338196,
0.09045366197824478,
0.6187018752098083,
0.28589949011802673,
0.032380860298871994,
-0.07220445573329926,
-0.3052924871444702,
0.18569746613502502,
-0.2629704475402832,
-0.5156104564666748,
-0.2868741750717163,
0.04788210615515709,
0.5620006918907166,
0.5117118954658508,
0.15432605147361755,
0.18217243254184723,
0.3029709458351135,
0.11832111328840256,
-0.987078845500946,
-0.07580377906560898,
-0.5163675546646118,
0.028041258454322815,
-0.4347875416278839,
-0.16541026532649994,
-0.8226451277732849,
-0.5838878154754639,
-0.08417331427335739,
-0.23879416286945343,
-0.1970631331205368,
-0.13952761888504028,
0.5800363421440125,
0.43165236711502075,
-0.6064354181289673,
-0.32127615809440613,
-0.18036159873008728,
0.48980605602264404,
-0.8366174101829529,
0.041584454476833344,
0.02989804744720459,
0.5028248429298401,
-0.9222755432128906,
-0.8070433139801025,
-0.557073175907135,
-0.6727357506752014,
-0.193154439330101,
0.2240111529827118,
-0.48248594999313354,
0.18493342399597168,
0.5562162399291992,
-0.08833430707454681,
-0.7434307336807251,
0.28154245018959045,
0.46587318181991577,
-0.044038865715265274,
0.4915347993373871,
0.47724249958992004,
0.48934289813041687,
0.1967020481824875,
-0.6984525322914124,
-0.24562114477157593,
-1.153847336769104,
0.16651633381843567,
0.9161929488182068,
0.28157055377960205,
-0.06489251554012299,
0.4521487355232239,
-0.20226773619651794,
0.506048321723938,
0.018274866044521332,
-0.014366833493113518,
0.19000858068466187,
-0.3996405601501465,
-0.08465991914272308,
0.29274415969848633,
0.7705910801887512,
0.1565372496843338,
0.029219556599855423,
-0.05095136910676956,
-0.25315770506858826,
-0.06936241686344147,
0.2899165153503418,
-1.0227696895599365,
0.040374185889959335,
0.02644156478345394,
-0.04934396222233772,
-0.45875173807144165,
0.23205099999904633,
-0.5279152989387512,
-0.7188818454742432,
0.2212585061788559,
0.4698735177516937,
-0.25495216250419617,
-0.13811372220516205,
-0.16400490701198578,
-0.1488269865512848,
0.4873622953891754,
0.33686697483062744,
-0.20287856459617615,
0.5933423042297363,
0.7670069336891174,
0.7348822355270386,
-0.4069308638572693,
-0.20387370884418488,
-0.754368245601654,
0.28662481904029846,
-0.2896471619606018,
0.7619532942771912,
-0.45157569646835327,
-0.5513553023338318,
0.32797911763191223,
0.07864296436309814,
0.013710403814911842,
-0.5951092839241028,
0.6007646918296814,
-0.4351150393486023,
-0.11146759241819382,
-0.41954368352890015,
-0.6106073260307312,
-0.08564533293247223,
0.5899181962013245,
-0.420418918132782,
1.0249948501586914,
0.031011642888188362,
-0.7149651646614075,
0.25024592876434326,
-0.6516697406768799,
-0.2815251052379608,
0.20868362486362457,
-0.18349000811576843,
-0.15564368665218353,
-0.015727339312434196,
0.1056739091873169,
0.41844597458839417,
-0.7106518149375916,
0.12937213480472565,
-0.5624424815177917,
-0.5475773215293884,
0.5233019590377808,
-0.657483696937561,
0.95904541015625,
0.007547910325229168,
-0.4648307263851166,
0.18508799374103546,
-0.4990168809890747,
0.03746916353702545,
0.16974027454853058,
-0.1592896431684494,
-0.1648540198802948,
-0.31241968274116516,
-0.08489848673343658,
0.09848807752132416,
0.18447811901569366,
-0.5983639359474182,
0.2779676914215088,
-0.4177492558956146,
-0.0559551902115345,
0.8927960395812988,
0.335464209318161,
0.1305294930934906,
-0.092391237616539,
0.6286429166793823,
0.19032852351665497,
0.4412361979484558,
-0.17364177107810974,
-0.47284990549087524,
-0.32207152247428894,
-0.50923752784729,
-0.07688495516777039,
0.4964766502380371,
-0.8754172921180725,
0.16709978878498077,
-0.2707407474517822,
-0.6533489227294922,
-0.1403239518404007,
-0.10091102123260498,
0.6895180940628052,
0.698501706123352,
0.06284811347723007,
-0.18721799552440643,
0.18939347565174103,
-1.0229706764221191,
-0.5788180828094482,
-0.3410469591617584,
-0.1314777284860611,
0.36882829666137695,
0.3997684419155121,
-0.24081110954284668,
0.7836384773254395,
-0.18057091534137726,
0.1253610998392105,
-0.17027680575847626,
0.12943002581596375,
0.6178854703903198,
0.3293476998806,
0.5871766209602356,
-0.3496033549308777,
-0.8424490690231323,
-0.19602081179618835,
-0.7522839903831482,
-0.5686747431755066,
-0.13378269970417023,
-0.007036438211798668,
0.0629456415772438,
0.5870649814605713,
-0.7082315683364868,
0.5092673897743225,
0.40417319536209106,
-0.3460533618927002,
0.526725172996521,
-0.20653367042541504,
0.17399916052818298,
-0.8499373197555542,
0.07546710222959518,
0.0045433565974235535,
-0.24981582164764404,
-0.7913532853126526,
0.21894457936286926,
0.4491007924079895,
-0.11196582764387131,
-0.9136142134666443,
0.7351970076560974,
-0.44310030341148376,
-0.1481875330209732,
-0.08366706967353821,
-0.014581508934497833,
-0.16849590837955475,
0.2238491326570511,
-0.5906352400779724,
1.3392752408981323,
0.3976952135562897,
-0.46787649393081665,
0.2490738332271576,
-0.05730504170060158,
-0.3845132887363434,
0.6468270421028137,
-0.8026957511901855,
0.4487074315547943,
0.25503140687942505,
0.5199459791183472,
-1.124114751815796,
-0.23329280316829681,
0.6918265223503113,
-0.08994371443986893,
0.5285765528678894,
-0.24198001623153687,
-1.0290580987930298,
-0.04103926196694374,
-0.6417223811149597,
0.5472201108932495,
0.28992077708244324,
-0.9060899019241333,
0.6746572852134705,
0.11199123412370682,
-0.005599733907729387,
-0.7528563737869263,
-0.3250933885574341,
0.4041793644428253,
-0.41026389598846436,
-0.6968101859092712,
0.34457090497016907,
-0.2609589099884033,
-0.45051443576812744,
-0.061088282614946365,
0.12465070933103561,
0.13521674275398254,
0.38902121782302856,
0.4580349028110504,
0.24090896546840668,
0.04890512675046921,
-0.244969442486763,
0.005864632315933704,
-0.206160306930542,
0.39632102847099304,
0.16047848761081696,
0.49463507533073425,
-0.09455075860023499,
-0.9091143608093262,
-0.5274096131324768,
0.38274845480918884,
0.5121365189552307,
0.12257516384124756,
0.5528931617736816,
0.1633819192647934,
-0.0543040968477726,
-0.11300153285264969,
-0.5027300119400024,
-0.1603838950395584,
-0.514193058013916,
0.19902196526527405,
-0.7312819361686707,
-0.18707357347011566,
0.46370193362236023,
-0.5523860454559326,
-0.14090657234191895,
0.08326757699251175,
0.38924044370651245,
0.02294117957353592,
1.277588963508606,
0.3866058588027954,
-0.14586633443832397,
0.4616665840148926,
-0.031576402485370636,
0.002932524075731635,
-0.7235694527626038,
0.09563229233026505,
-0.44214391708374023,
0.008859596215188503,
-0.684779167175293,
-0.17641043663024902,
0.5602530837059021,
-0.24632789194583893,
-0.36302450299263,
0.32168149948120117,
-0.16354010999202728,
0.5609959959983826,
0.4896804988384247,
-0.02921784296631813,
0.023892151191830635,
-0.6712819337844849,
-0.11464513838291168,
0.2983624041080475,
-0.4316437542438507,
-0.5210384726524353,
1.1209778785705566,
0.36361372470855713,
0.8941711187362671,
0.461729496717453,
0.5633717179298401,
0.3409026563167572,
0.3784479796886444,
-0.41601529717445374,
0.8479029536247253,
0.328563392162323,
-0.29925817251205444,
0.23473326861858368,
-0.16881367564201355,
-0.8424133658409119,
0.16874071955680847,
0.0690586045384407,
-0.7100597023963928,
0.18838123977184296,
-0.01721920818090439,
-0.06962520629167557,
0.0647067055106163,
-0.8818151950836182,
0.8145778775215149,
-0.23525913059711456,
-0.5566701292991638,
-0.09132753312587738,
-0.7899028658866882,
0.3041124641895294,
-0.16136255860328674,
-0.19793115556240082,
-0.2805975079536438,
-0.23583805561065674,
0.14592231810092926,
-0.4606790840625763,
1.00586998462677,
-0.35525476932525635,
0.08023039251565933,
-0.043226346373558044,
0.1320049911737442,
1.2633758783340454,
0.28919410705566406,
-0.010816964320838451,
0.3942631483078003,
-0.2246275395154953,
-0.3475218117237091,
-0.4463619291782379,
0.8191861510276794,
-0.6261903643608093,
-0.7974755764007568,
-0.7029145359992981,
-0.4525776505470276,
-0.32046738266944885,
0.006676791701465845,
0.15505807101726532,
0.41524291038513184,
-0.27404695749282837,
-0.259391188621521,
0.7818883061408997,
-0.4151686728000641,
0.7121162414550781,
0.6733583211898804,
0.27465251088142395,
-0.22427883744239807,
0.5791953802108765,
-0.08276232331991196,
0.3921341598033905,
0.19201518595218658,
0.02762887068092823,
-0.1091524288058281,
-0.7184616327285767,
-0.4785020351409912,
0.17536459863185883,
-0.9964744448661804,
-0.5024334788322449,
-0.47116774320602417,
-0.024176372215151787,
-0.20918457210063934,
-0.20520809292793274,
-0.23254859447479248,
0.21040065586566925,
-0.20725944638252258,
0.10629982501268387,
0.15068915486335754,
0.7248965501785278,
0.329556405544281,
0.3436313569545746,
-0.43966490030288696,
-0.2463238537311554,
0.10567682236433029,
0.06620672345161438,
-0.39403319358825684,
-0.39264795184135437,
-0.00477465009316802,
-0.3347083032131195,
-0.19146151840686798,
-1.0969003438949585,
0.24861189723014832,
-0.13721507787704468,
0.7420586943626404,
0.4292966425418854,
0.3342999517917633,
0.6118733882904053,
-0.5259702801704407,
0.7994702458381653,
-0.03970332443714142,
-0.9771763682365417,
0.4597069323062897,
-0.2704821228981018,
0.5240739583969116,
0.753821611404419,
0.3552659749984741,
-0.37290889024734497,
-0.7233482003211975,
-0.38712260127067566,
-0.9314383268356323,
0.5472986102104187,
-0.06209983676671982,
0.19750666618347168,
-0.21819500625133514,
0.18440358340740204,
0.28044393658638,
0.07266278564929962,
-0.45439010858535767,
-0.21900153160095215,
0.2801315486431122,
-0.18678654730319977,
0.262484610080719,
-0.3696238100528717,
-0.175442174077034,
0.19114674627780914,
0.6899999380111694,
-0.2736418545246124,
0.14269916713237762,
-0.032435063272714615,
-0.3409240245819092,
0.17615795135498047,
0.019016457721590996,
0.39698293805122375,
0.44554784893989563,
-0.1625385880470276,
0.24086566269397736,
0.5563486218452454,
-0.48223915696144104,
0.2959207594394684,
0.23320834338665009,
-0.09652967751026154,
-0.052931755781173706,
0.5376247763633728,
0.2481023520231247,
0.19899357855319977,
-0.9179920554161072,
0.9828590154647827,
-0.5097275376319885,
0.34915921092033386,
-0.6242467164993286,
0.0814589262008667,
-0.34448692202568054,
0.4170668125152588,
0.04700295627117157,
-0.10868179798126221,
0.4407185912132263,
-0.45343369245529175,
-0.111493781208992,
0.5563875436782837,
-0.48939675092697144,
-0.3477363586425781,
0.3385486900806427,
0.152157261967659,
-0.11379804462194443,
0.6046079993247986,
-0.1894867718219757,
-0.1198568120598793,
0.4264886677265167,
0.678401529788971,
1.2921199798583984,
-0.16118861734867096,
-0.18543781340122223,
0.21150349080562592,
0.2866367995738983,
0.21518059074878693,
0.23097488284111023,
0.0862741470336914,
-0.3650176525115967,
-0.2625354528427124,
0.033909086138010025,
-0.6663676500320435,
-0.16324517130851746,
-0.4656981825828552,
0.3578265607357025,
-0.3828286826610565,
-0.12886035442352295,
-0.1769629865884781,
-0.1360282152891159,
-0.8072938323020935,
-0.43195587396621704,
0.013825819827616215,
1.214297890663147,
-0.7869561314582825,
0.7885386347770691,
0.6101034879684448,
-0.44361481070518494,
-0.49082887172698975,
0.3715289235115051,
0.3447200059890747,
-0.6738058924674988,
0.7822815775871277,
0.4575737714767456,
-0.2551235258579254,
-0.2334544062614441,
-0.6346233487129211,
-0.7409822344779968,
1.131738543510437,
0.7543565630912781,
-0.30009645223617554,
0.4335337281227112,
0.3138185441493988,
0.14969587326049805,
-0.2891877591609955,
0.776728093624115,
0.545495867729187,
0.5013013482093811,
-0.28257763385772705,
-0.5814695954322815,
0.4656427204608917,
-0.3570359945297241,
0.017292408272624016,
0.2808445394039154,
-0.39502111077308655,
0.7021726965904236,
0.23142753541469574,
-0.41711342334747314,
0.029423292726278305,
0.24851761758327484,
0.15567639470100403,
0.3215939402580261,
0.5636906027793884,
0.4904208183288574,
0.5479392409324646,
-0.1789153665304184,
1.4430469274520874,
-0.2032604217529297,
-0.2560098469257355,
1.2392305135726929,
-0.6562503576278687,
0.6039292812347412,
0.5830567479133606,
-0.008389206603169441,
0.35457730293273926,
0.6148810386657715,
0.15957868099212646,
0.6650553345680237,
0.30842822790145874,
-0.808736264705658,
0.22985577583312988,
-0.5913013815879822,
-0.29768139123916626,
0.18201345205307007,
0.17351266741752625,
-0.06740988790988922,
-0.11324556916952133,
0.15614433586597443,
0.41781753301620483,
-0.19309768080711365,
-0.007884051650762558,
1.1037111282348633,
-0.20971210300922394,
-0.3994806110858917,
0.13147802650928497,
-0.27747678756713867,
0.38398033380508423,
-0.7000537514686584,
-0.12641674280166626,
-0.32307684421539307,
0.25152403116226196,
0.13814228773117065,
-0.826511800289154,
-0.12995211780071259,
0.0982179194688797,
0.23222190141677856,
-0.17562250792980194,
0.6304646730422974,
0.03462217375636101,
0.056032657623291016,
0.4853954315185547,
0.2490643411874771,
0.15876515209674835,
-0.1627788543701172,
-0.6030067801475525,
0.12995071709156036,
-0.3991679847240448,
-0.434175968170166,
0.5497356057167053,
0.3939042091369629,
-0.13334155082702637,
0.7148574590682983,
0.6637648344039917,
0.01793059892952442,
-0.10352220386266708,
0.2588002681732178,
1.1687259674072266,
-0.43413710594177246,
-0.16061660647392273,
-1.1550328731536865,
0.570044219493866,
-0.4683785140514374,
-0.27797582745552063,
0.9915090799331665,
0.42985936999320984,
0.8658195734024048,
0.12396670877933502,
0.5240358710289001,
0.265678346157074,
0.1084146723151207,
-0.31522852182388306,
0.5472710728645325,
-0.20496535301208496,
0.4475105106830597,
-0.3813460171222687,
-0.7902306914329529,
-0.21315090358257294,
-0.24533085525035858,
-0.26123976707458496,
-0.18188606202602386,
0.5848595499992371,
1.172021508216858,
0.1490246206521988,
-0.3537394404411316,
0.3633612096309662,
0.10764438658952713,
0.7682217359542847,
0.32370585203170776,
1.3722418546676636,
-0.18715576827526093,
0.4440523386001587,
-0.22181887924671173,
-0.3362661600112915,
-0.2806909382343292,
-1.0814244747161865,
-1.0636814832687378,
-0.14437119662761688,
-0.16890686750411987,
-0.24683424830436707,
0.3723208010196686,
1.1502481698989868,
0.4104357957839966,
-0.6042876243591309,
-0.09429789334535599,
-0.2701716423034668,
0.05890483036637306,
-0.23168301582336426,
-0.20099714398384094,
0.2503487467765808,
-0.4456885755062103,
-0.6101533770561218,
0.7368313074111938,
0.4626309275627136,
0.07297369837760925,
-0.22713585197925568,
0.02317529357969761,
0.07574069499969482,
0.3220246434211731,
0.2488325834274292,
0.14019550383090973,
-0.6473943591117859,
-0.35846391320228577,
-0.25043296813964844,
-0.2586091458797455,
-0.11262118816375732,
0.6937521696090698,
-0.6990787982940674,
0.5801367163658142,
0.5059248208999634,
0.8026472926139832,
0.20097973942756653,
-0.2422199696302414,
0.6276296973228455,
-0.9148332476615906,
0.23034031689167023,
0.2943309247493744,
0.5049498677253723,
0.18728876113891602,
-0.5253814458847046,
0.6817793846130371,
-0.10230422765016556,
-0.5205396413803101,
-1.2135368585586548,
0.21559680998325348,
-0.7377803325653076,
-0.24211475253105164,
0.9223918318748474,
-0.5045047998428345,
-0.2797124981880188,
-0.08166320621967316,
-0.14464034140110016,
-0.04217997565865517,
-0.5469745993614197,
0.4481903612613678,
0.30037596821784973,
-0.07886891812086105,
0.08700072020292282,
-0.786118745803833,
0.35898154973983765,
0.10764890909194946,
-1.1058286428451538,
0.015149657614529133,
0.27619531750679016,
0.019373612478375435,
-0.18221741914749146,
0.30866873264312744,
-0.09308184683322906,
0.2666790783405304,
0.16335587203502655,
0.13373729586601257,
-0.15804702043533325,
-0.23216980695724487,
-0.5369598865509033,
0.06996067613363266,
0.18580104410648346,
-0.2336706966161728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02677v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02677v1
|
Finetuned Multimodal Language Models Are High-Quality Image-Text Data Filters
| 2024-03-05T06:05:15 | 2024-03-05T06:05:15 |
Weizhi Wang, Khalil Mrini, Linjie Yang, Sateesh Kumar, Yu Tian, Xifeng Yan, Heng Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
We propose a novel framework for filtering image-text data by leveraging
fine-tuned Multimodal Language Models (MLMs). Our approach outperforms
predominant filtering methods (e.g., CLIPScore) via integrating the recent
advances in MLMs. We design four distinct yet complementary metrics to
holistically measure the quality of image-text data. A new pipeline is
established to construct high-quality instruction data for fine-tuning MLMs as
data filters. Comparing with CLIPScore, our MLM filters produce more precise
and comprehensive scores that directly improve the quality of filtered data and
boost the performance of pre-trained models. We achieve significant
improvements over CLIPScore on popular foundation models (i.e., CLIP and BLIP2)
and various downstream tasks. Our MLM filter can generalize to different models
and tasks, and be used as a drop-in replacement for CLIPScore. An additional
ablation study is provided to verify our design choices for the MLM filter.
|
[
-0.7903354167938232,
-0.8199885487556458,
0.21109625697135925,
0.024253569543361664,
-0.35646337270736694,
0.008011631667613983,
-0.5708214044570923,
-0.3971453309059143,
-0.1985221952199936,
0.8487714529037476,
-0.6684296727180481,
-0.8379439115524292,
-0.5788226127624512,
-0.051803894340991974,
-0.5746495127677917,
1.002206563949585,
0.03403453901410103,
0.32900822162628174,
-0.2380661815404892,
-0.39533722400665283,
-0.267950177192688,
-0.17166900634765625,
-0.40249988436698914,
-0.4694216549396515,
0.574112594127655,
0.5816065073013306,
1.203784465789795,
0.8479831218719482,
0.7217153310775757,
0.29446518421173096,
-0.05050666630268097,
0.36942431330680847,
-0.5061232447624207,
-0.14147408306598663,
-0.20559051632881165,
-0.4571797549724579,
-0.3602975010871887,
0.09700214117765427,
0.39010563492774963,
0.5123910903930664,
-0.04932352900505066,
0.13382360339164734,
0.1926344782114029,
0.7625622153282166,
-0.6654649376869202,
-0.003858031239360571,
-0.6441167593002319,
0.18599317967891693,
-0.16182978451251984,
-0.3020230233669281,
-0.2777475416660309,
-0.2940937280654907,
-0.2736130952835083,
-0.2954399883747101,
0.3908082842826843,
0.07273781299591064,
0.8959369659423828,
0.25174880027770996,
-0.2842826545238495,
-0.35309144854545593,
-0.7519611120223999,
0.9522804021835327,
-0.5998165607452393,
0.6526982188224792,
0.5006114840507507,
0.3732891082763672,
0.030055593699216843,
-0.8627219796180725,
-0.5392259955406189,
-0.05957894027233124,
-0.03322336822748184,
-0.011738135479390621,
-0.023257242515683174,
0.2530420124530792,
-0.03234093636274338,
0.7526571750640869,
-0.5893756747245789,
0.15494515001773834,
-0.3801513612270355,
-0.18455061316490173,
0.37235796451568604,
0.2049599140882492,
0.28506729006767273,
-0.08088385313749313,
-0.49721720814704895,
-0.09022586792707443,
-0.5844132304191589,
0.1237817034125328,
0.2623831629753113,
0.32364922761917114,
0.09375962615013123,
0.5770442485809326,
-0.270510733127594,
0.891096830368042,
-0.110414057970047,
-0.24009408056735992,
-0.11639312654733658,
-0.4904317259788513,
-0.5035647749900818,
-0.27347418665885925,
0.7392032146453857,
0.6427139639854431,
0.37466007471084595,
0.04265313223004341,
-0.3629457950592041,
0.24351483583450317,
0.03161065652966499,
-1.3306466341018677,
-0.6413725018501282,
-0.03429199382662773,
-0.6952776908874512,
-0.3166435658931732,
-0.009766164235770702,
-0.7419224977493286,
-0.1844516396522522,
-0.6075728535652161,
0.45587602257728577,
-0.5053496360778809,
-0.17470841109752655,
0.23131819069385529,
0.006849253550171852,
-0.14169973134994507,
0.10701651871204376,
-0.8365257978439331,
0.2940514385700226,
0.5386872887611389,
0.9406965970993042,
-0.19986416399478912,
-0.11334217339754105,
-0.6222206950187683,
-0.23294952511787415,
-0.340552419424057,
0.943898618221283,
-0.790145993232727,
-0.17881722748279572,
0.12162615358829498,
0.05987534299492836,
0.18928328156471252,
-0.6393080353736877,
0.6816841959953308,
-0.6348422169685364,
0.01224860455840826,
0.2678956389427185,
-0.6428619027137756,
-0.3655182421207428,
0.3150833547115326,
-0.7003606557846069,
0.9239581823348999,
0.04329749569296837,
-0.2984490692615509,
0.4497946500778198,
-0.3521561026573181,
-0.35006827116012573,
0.05983355641365051,
-0.006642738822847605,
-0.2783008813858032,
-0.10262642800807953,
0.6311001777648926,
0.8842677474021912,
-0.4088868796825409,
0.4069810211658478,
-0.6593416929244995,
-0.3494247794151306,
0.21757593750953674,
-0.7072515487670898,
0.36992841958999634,
0.5525695085525513,
0.14355728030204773,
0.25936317443847656,
-1.0929014682769775,
0.2877819836139679,
-0.3646007478237152,
-0.4181216359138489,
-0.3186851143836975,
-0.037393372505903244,
0.7454766035079956,
0.49713465571403503,
-0.07776980847120285,
-0.5963013768196106,
-0.2328176498413086,
-0.21261559426784515,
0.5726194977760315,
0.556191623210907,
-0.10541356354951859,
0.5488700270652771,
-0.4330556094646454,
0.468412309885025,
0.2675802707672119,
0.25343915820121765,
-0.5603733062744141,
-0.3620803654193878,
-0.6755515933036804,
-0.6102725267410278,
0.2108144313097,
0.2746836841106415,
-0.8260061740875244,
0.19701065123081207,
-0.038630180060863495,
-0.7305561304092407,
-0.6398314833641052,
0.6511566042900085,
0.3836652338504791,
0.4091417193412781,
0.5246991515159607,
-0.4461651146411896,
-0.2582806646823883,
-0.9155330061912537,
-0.3174671530723572,
0.46486425399780273,
0.02617879956960678,
0.40052857995033264,
0.11434927582740784,
-0.47278666496276855,
0.9271700978279114,
-0.591495931148529,
-0.6677696704864502,
-0.05165567621588707,
0.11418665945529938,
0.4213067889213562,
0.6197178363800049,
0.7986000776290894,
-0.9367436766624451,
-0.4084402322769165,
-0.07038657367229462,
-0.4505126178264618,
0.08975765109062195,
-0.08749187737703323,
-0.0944477766752243,
-0.13388745486736298,
0.49624237418174744,
-0.4409271776676178,
0.052640318870544434,
0.8895251154899597,
-0.5344837307929993,
0.4592982828617096,
-0.18236654996871948,
0.39459970593452454,
-0.9624513387680054,
-0.2256295531988144,
0.4021156132221222,
-0.5879085659980774,
-0.4804437756538391,
-0.027895765379071236,
0.12130971252918243,
-0.21777379512786865,
-0.5834077596664429,
0.5484877824783325,
-0.36598360538482666,
0.1449700891971588,
-0.44160687923431396,
0.015022946521639824,
0.46149545907974243,
0.5973184704780579,
-0.16216154396533966,
0.6239367127418518,
0.6103942394256592,
-0.8472761511802673,
0.3972555696964264,
0.15334708988666534,
-0.6550087332725525,
0.9752715229988098,
-0.48559632897377014,
-0.13636089861392975,
-0.30226463079452515,
-0.15307246148586273,
-1.2630388736724854,
-0.18152117729187012,
-0.16695673763751984,
-0.3722723126411438,
0.2967963218688965,
-0.3954329788684845,
-0.5077527165412903,
-0.11564662307500839,
-0.2448040246963501,
0.13060878217220306,
0.22533591091632843,
-0.7053648829460144,
0.4376526474952698,
0.3649385869503021,
-0.15989716351032257,
-0.29671281576156616,
-0.7391687035560608,
0.065902940928936,
-0.07797669619321823,
-0.6329453587532043,
0.4455195665359497,
-0.13233362138271332,
0.29001548886299133,
0.13845472037792206,
0.09797095507383347,
-0.6296536326408386,
-0.01470078807324171,
0.2324102371931076,
0.26427963376045227,
-0.4683981239795685,
0.09311952441930771,
0.13603004813194275,
0.07907269895076752,
-0.16362819075584412,
-0.16103103756904602,
0.47809723019599915,
-0.09518726915121078,
-0.25316035747528076,
-0.47603991627693176,
0.36052051186561584,
0.7607395648956299,
-0.3524019122123718,
0.586097776889801,
1.3002839088439941,
-0.500003457069397,
-0.06762465834617615,
-0.48700422048568726,
-0.39949142932891846,
-0.5557253956794739,
0.5168529152870178,
-0.2751837968826294,
-1.212658405303955,
0.24032573401927948,
0.007316939532756805,
0.13637620210647583,
0.30459386110305786,
0.47741541266441345,
-0.4238581359386444,
1.397504210472107,
0.49204277992248535,
0.18056146800518036,
0.8183841705322266,
-0.3336006999015808,
0.006237843539565802,
-0.6909828186035156,
0.05202176421880722,
-0.35272160172462463,
-0.47444695234298706,
-0.5749288201332092,
-0.3311232030391693,
0.24980175495147705,
0.3462707996368408,
-0.23926885426044464,
0.1653076410293579,
-0.4853505492210388,
0.5668408274650574,
0.5714010000228882,
0.4321390688419342,
0.35806745290756226,
0.2235928475856781,
-0.1521793007850647,
-0.2134646624326706,
-0.665608823299408,
-0.6416365504264832,
1.060400128364563,
0.41482973098754883,
1.1795955896377563,
-0.06308232992887497,
0.10142120718955994,
0.1901732087135315,
0.3257836401462555,
-0.7514051198959351,
0.3173459768295288,
-0.8713260889053345,
-0.7038856744766235,
-0.08055585622787476,
-0.2448265701532364,
-0.6044880151748657,
0.37889206409454346,
-0.533237874507904,
-0.32877299189567566,
0.08334190398454666,
0.4112783968448639,
-0.37841448187828064,
0.3730676770210266,
-0.7634194493293762,
0.9581464529037476,
-0.23534250259399414,
-0.5619124174118042,
-0.39056286215782166,
-0.24578475952148438,
0.48683321475982666,
0.27243590354919434,
0.37847426533699036,
-0.5332836508750916,
0.3018278479576111,
0.48989689350128174,
-0.2628580331802368,
0.8810462951660156,
-0.2458936870098114,
0.13893839716911316,
0.2703869044780731,
0.08718498051166534,
0.2548215091228485,
0.12002207338809967,
0.054873332381248474,
0.04867886006832123,
0.2758021950721741,
-0.2467486709356308,
-0.4951721131801605,
1.0484859943389893,
-0.5769451260566711,
-0.06167540326714516,
0.0742676705121994,
-0.5024439692497253,
-0.1716725379228592,
0.4299027919769287,
0.17499184608459473,
0.9209400415420532,
-0.016769051551818848,
0.6001835465431213,
0.5047755241394043,
-0.1510409116744995,
0.5241797566413879,
0.41324812173843384,
-0.28182563185691833,
-0.6997489333152771,
1.016372561454773,
0.001070840866304934,
0.24213126301765442,
0.27045363187789917,
0.19990909099578857,
-0.45440545678138733,
-0.5513297915458679,
-0.6348966956138611,
-0.051468122750520706,
-0.8622505068778992,
-0.45162126421928406,
-0.5635775327682495,
-0.1551504135131836,
-0.24199940264225006,
0.052192963659763336,
-0.7535040378570557,
-0.1999831199645996,
-0.6052303910255432,
0.19541701674461365,
0.5971546173095703,
0.43036165833473206,
0.09784799814224243,
0.45091772079467773,
-1.106189250946045,
0.7101668119430542,
0.2907256484031677,
0.913262665271759,
-0.3328523635864258,
-0.5145924687385559,
-0.37924841046333313,
0.2063576728105545,
-0.4128481149673462,
-0.40804973244667053,
0.38500046730041504,
0.7885859608650208,
0.3409421741962433,
0.5554029941558838,
-0.07680422812700272,
0.9740058779716492,
-0.5584918260574341,
0.6453129053115845,
0.2592252790927887,
-0.7181443572044373,
0.41755396127700806,
-0.19270576536655426,
0.3882151246070862,
0.5959829688072205,
0.2556155323982239,
-0.5239327549934387,
-0.3501526713371277,
-0.11345663666725159,
-0.7502335906028748,
0.5755688548088074,
0.03214059770107269,
0.3968948721885681,
0.1579483300447464,
0.32468998432159424,
0.10211651772260666,
0.23081448674201965,
-0.5999882221221924,
-0.2660914361476898,
-0.33044591546058655,
-0.5126224756240845,
-0.31998124718666077,
-0.42740747332572937,
0.04186960309743881,
-0.41701221466064453,
0.479067325592041,
-0.28518596291542053,
0.05423012003302574,
0.11044605076313019,
-0.4085809290409088,
-0.09389839321374893,
0.3153511881828308,
0.6140287518501282,
0.42287513613700867,
-0.0854191929101944,
0.29850053787231445,
-0.3381274938583374,
-0.5925776958465576,
0.08415976166725159,
-0.03716931864619255,
-0.04221297428011894,
0.19767576456069946,
0.07102292776107788,
1.0817948579788208,
0.5795413851737976,
-0.7327686548233032,
0.4784909784793854,
0.04695616662502289,
0.02467445284128189,
-0.033834125846624374,
0.402962327003479,
-0.054110411554574966,
0.21138036251068115,
0.14461283385753632,
0.555363118648529,
0.38614410161972046,
-0.4037182927131653,
0.6585474014282227,
0.4309244155883789,
-0.6826906800270081,
-0.3267565369606018,
0.739353597164154,
0.20248864591121674,
-0.11565934121608734,
0.2664633095264435,
0.09616897255182266,
-0.25984230637550354,
0.41664108633995056,
0.5323168039321899,
0.4614057242870331,
-0.08360922336578369,
0.3113708198070526,
0.3952883780002594,
0.32100826501846313,
-0.12021462619304657,
0.3371228277683258,
-0.05455807223916054,
-0.9156651496887207,
-0.4007485508918762,
-0.8447591662406921,
-0.30784061551094055,
0.14039990305900574,
-0.6878239512443542,
0.5233782529830933,
-0.4361914396286011,
-0.3618761897087097,
0.13932347297668457,
-0.31348827481269836,
-0.923895537853241,
0.6380500197410583,
0.17497746646404266,
0.8414093255996704,
-0.6265799403190613,
0.8162062764167786,
0.8457605838775635,
-0.059328947216272354,
-0.560981810092926,
-0.5396868586540222,
-0.2111787348985672,
-0.5997335910797119,
0.37438732385635376,
0.384191632270813,
-0.22188788652420044,
0.3147655129432678,
-0.41760796308517456,
-0.8883470892906189,
0.8391355872154236,
0.4859638214111328,
-0.5935343503952026,
0.15093839168548584,
0.041846394538879395,
0.40211308002471924,
-0.4832603633403778,
0.30544736981391907,
0.7720611095428467,
0.25488558411598206,
0.15220552682876587,
-0.6191089153289795,
-0.5667610764503479,
-0.21579720079898834,
0.2809547781944275,
0.08289745450019836,
-0.3946491777896881,
0.8752021789550781,
-0.03913750872015953,
-0.22646617889404297,
-0.08450735360383987,
0.4042322635650635,
0.004625068046152592,
0.33942699432373047,
0.31970784068107605,
0.45850107073783875,
0.3759361505508423,
-0.15139418840408325,
0.7720780372619629,
-0.37144505977630615,
0.5447858572006226,
1.0485162734985352,
0.04285931959748268,
0.9865972399711609,
0.5461368560791016,
-0.009031110443174839,
0.2726527154445648,
0.7194108366966248,
-0.19017809629440308,
0.7231458425521851,
-0.21683193743228912,
0.1268710345029831,
-0.39045000076293945,
-0.21441157162189484,
0.03555947169661522,
0.6216461658477783,
0.4714181423187256,
-0.5022720098495483,
-0.3909967541694641,
0.5990234017372131,
-0.21317237615585327,
0.4435262680053711,
-0.5391618609428406,
0.6161518096923828,
0.0621400885283947,
-0.4849855899810791,
0.6860365271568298,
0.3228873014450073,
1.0428372621536255,
-0.20431581139564514,
0.13391351699829102,
-0.18765544891357422,
0.566247284412384,
-0.41834133863449097,
-1.1439411640167236,
0.4298136532306671,
0.07908357679843903,
-0.3840633034706116,
-0.27599194645881653,
0.8284764289855957,
-0.9813820719718933,
-0.6785224676132202,
0.04810767620801926,
0.09721273183822632,
-0.03911884129047394,
-0.30902397632598877,
-0.7851529121398926,
0.13135771453380585,
-0.206760972738266,
-0.20948541164398193,
0.01838909462094307,
0.14936701953411102,
0.2026485949754715,
0.7371166944503784,
0.7708251476287842,
0.07882966846227646,
0.26489001512527466,
0.2367980033159256,
0.7975863218307495,
-0.5278367400169373,
-0.4767831265926361,
-0.9797720909118652,
0.4731924533843994,
0.10951195657253265,
-0.26050570607185364,
0.3571026027202606,
0.5872940421104431,
0.8069750070571899,
-0.32635876536369324,
0.4159896671772003,
0.3032548725605011,
0.3983106017112732,
-0.8750379681587219,
1.0546324253082275,
-0.6697112321853638,
0.012337037362158298,
-0.37342461943626404,
-1.0180399417877197,
-0.43785014748573303,
0.521316409111023,
0.3182760775089264,
-0.013268272392451763,
0.36492592096328735,
1.016937017440796,
-0.3843598961830139,
-0.003611341817304492,
0.6418696045875549,
0.046835172921419144,
0.4023888409137726,
0.43062731623649597,
0.6214163303375244,
-0.8521333336830139,
0.6604902148246765,
-0.5016515851020813,
0.010526617057621479,
-0.227121040225029,
-0.8226664066314697,
-1.1364883184432983,
-0.6919540762901306,
-0.38083478808403015,
0.19457320868968964,
-0.4241483807563782,
0.793765664100647,
1.1648648977279663,
-0.9668499827384949,
0.003941453993320465,
-0.08616310358047485,
0.09221772849559784,
-0.149433434009552,
-0.24450193345546722,
-0.010979675687849522,
-0.4675002992153168,
-0.8838261365890503,
0.21093663573265076,
0.4669237434864044,
0.11604908108711243,
-0.37541329860687256,
-0.04731724411249161,
-0.050936922430992126,
-0.0355045460164547,
0.8734657764434814,
-0.29422929883003235,
-0.6314595937728882,
-0.2334134578704834,
0.06539179384708405,
-0.339824914932251,
0.2624390721321106,
0.7662429213523865,
-0.47772878408432007,
0.5293557643890381,
0.23802900314331055,
0.6376786828041077,
0.4009394645690918,
-0.19376666843891144,
0.3049507439136505,
-0.9730762243270874,
0.3578989505767822,
0.24833810329437256,
0.428130179643631,
0.610879123210907,
-0.23176243901252747,
0.18045486509799957,
0.09043176472187042,
-0.39856505393981934,
-0.8292458057403564,
0.1670726239681244,
-0.7316983342170715,
-0.22650040686130524,
1.1127172708511353,
-0.06470684707164764,
-0.016735466197133064,
0.04195185378193855,
-0.3601798713207245,
0.07804714888334274,
-0.18757076561450958,
0.5092984437942505,
0.9534279108047485,
0.13005203008651733,
-0.7955554127693176,
-0.5639862418174744,
0.5552337765693665,
0.17193983495235443,
-0.5519615411758423,
-0.19952426850795746,
0.7247174978256226,
0.38647550344467163,
-0.15340273082256317,
0.3138121962547302,
-0.22577223181724548,
0.36807146668434143,
-0.49210551381111145,
0.008317068219184875,
-0.3086799383163452,
-0.5042869448661804,
-0.22330418229103088,
0.35456883907318115,
0.04042641073465347,
-0.3523869812488556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02674v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02674v2
|
Revisiting Meta-evaluation for Grammatical Error Correction
| 2024-03-05T05:53:09 | 2024-05-26T12:05:35 |
Masamune Kobayashi, Masato Mita, Mamoru Komachi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Metrics are the foundation for automatic evaluation in grammatical error
correction (GEC), with their evaluation of the metrics (meta-evaluation)
relying on their correlation with human judgments. However, conventional
meta-evaluations in English GEC encounter several challenges including biases
caused by inconsistencies in evaluation granularity, and an outdated setup
using classical systems. These problems can lead to misinterpretation of
metrics and potentially hinder the applicability of GEC techniques. To address
these issues, this paper proposes SEEDA, a new dataset for GEC meta-evaluation.
SEEDA consists of corrections with human ratings along two different
granularities: edit-based and sentence-based, covering 12 state-of-the-art
systems including large language models (LLMs), and two human corrections with
different focuses. The results of improved correlations by aligning the
granularity in the sentence-level meta-evaluation, suggest that edit-based
metrics may have been underestimated in existing studies. Furthermore,
correlations of most metrics decrease when changing from classical to neural
systems, indicating that traditional metrics are relatively poor at evaluating
fluently corrected sentences with many edits.
|
[
0.04757944494485855,
-0.8477632999420166,
0.6299788355827332,
0.4324248731136322,
0.25840795040130615,
-0.21361488103866577,
-0.4255867898464203,
-0.09665627032518387,
0.4207260310649872,
-0.07038655877113342,
-0.4352297782897949,
-0.48698189854621887,
-0.6670222282409668,
0.5065280199050903,
-0.3479277491569519,
1.0148029327392578,
-0.026559673249721527,
0.34293487668037415,
-0.6019548177719116,
-0.1579548716545105,
-0.7798023223876953,
-0.34605371952056885,
-0.31521549820899963,
-0.08827964216470718,
0.5739843249320984,
0.65155428647995,
0.7420066595077515,
0.3507693111896515,
0.6615134477615356,
0.2792176604270935,
-0.30397382378578186,
0.40090328454971313,
-0.25540095567703247,
-0.3176179528236389,
-0.3261931836605072,
-0.25121012330055237,
-0.8419833183288574,
0.06214271858334541,
0.6392802000045776,
0.8998735547065735,
-0.15123917162418365,
0.1813366562128067,
0.24957536160945892,
0.7794110178947449,
-1.1591668128967285,
0.027053227648139,
-0.5314943790435791,
0.19004826247692108,
-0.22230535745620728,
-0.1793496012687683,
-0.6147837042808533,
-0.3419809341430664,
-0.18826356530189514,
-0.6890203952789307,
0.3121177852153778,
-0.3016403615474701,
0.6871581077575684,
0.24338121712207794,
-0.2820996940135956,
-0.3772515654563904,
-1.0312258005142212,
0.4723828136920929,
-0.7786045074462891,
-0.017983650788664818,
0.4221828877925873,
0.12085351347923279,
-0.30331990122795105,
-0.4972587525844574,
-0.3561093509197235,
0.03573529049754143,
-0.22440555691719055,
0.154556542634964,
-0.23330466449260712,
0.04906262457370758,
0.1209556832909584,
0.33678051829338074,
-0.3039288818836212,
-0.08630367368459702,
-0.2712201178073883,
-0.17689017951488495,
0.48142316937446594,
0.1942404806613922,
0.21415242552757263,
-0.35090988874435425,
0.19591385126113892,
-0.11245301365852356,
-0.4854174554347992,
-0.1360468864440918,
0.4510837197303772,
0.3600503206253052,
0.24904315173625946,
0.36278706789016724,
-0.08927057683467865,
0.8334660530090332,
0.3118053376674652,
-0.05735141038894653,
0.5711258053779602,
-0.46625596284866333,
-0.17734166979789734,
-0.3654497265815735,
0.9390804171562195,
0.5991737842559814,
0.3298121392726898,
-0.1757485419511795,
-0.08396095037460327,
0.20662496984004974,
0.36880436539649963,
-0.26696354150772095,
-0.152007594704628,
-0.01801818609237671,
-0.28795716166496277,
-0.42144012451171875,
0.596771240234375,
-0.9042916297912598,
-0.008806750178337097,
0.007313739042729139,
0.5565344095230103,
-0.19967114925384521,
0.25845474004745483,
0.3006361126899719,
-0.0005798417842015624,
-0.29245927929878235,
0.22096562385559082,
-0.9170072674751282,
0.4095253348350525,
0.7283393144607544,
0.834879457950592,
0.3905092477798462,
-0.5937904119491577,
-0.40103334188461304,
-0.13320402801036835,
-0.5312824249267578,
0.7770117521286011,
-0.7121089100837708,
-0.5724772810935974,
0.1226203516125679,
0.14041723310947418,
-0.483502060174942,
-0.3568400740623474,
0.9045528769493103,
-0.2968881130218506,
0.6109292507171631,
-0.5194556713104248,
-0.4943411648273468,
-0.05623439699411392,
0.023438064381480217,
-0.642909049987793,
1.0612579584121704,
-0.11699803173542023,
-0.9370558261871338,
0.597732424736023,
-0.6134462952613831,
-0.6204966902732849,
-0.4094354212284088,
0.04692014679312706,
-0.5237764120101929,
0.3249706029891968,
0.509134829044342,
0.2722336947917938,
0.05580345541238785,
0.5424171090126038,
-0.10508224368095398,
-0.5631650686264038,
0.16664238274097443,
-0.42201074957847595,
0.4521194398403168,
0.01960747316479683,
-0.369480699300766,
0.07709043473005295,
-0.8813393712043762,
0.1449771225452423,
-0.29109302163124084,
-0.25022077560424805,
-0.3440629243850708,
0.2484518140554428,
-0.31557393074035645,
0.04199619218707085,
-0.04952181875705719,
-0.4831734597682953,
0.25928881764411926,
-0.21183307468891144,
0.3286162316799164,
0.6378564238548279,
-0.03675520420074463,
0.6437137722969055,
-0.02581156976521015,
0.44426825642585754,
-0.32674920558929443,
0.2500816285610199,
-0.10179842263460159,
-0.4422208070755005,
-0.8148739337921143,
0.11905449628829956,
0.7290476560592651,
0.7397665977478027,
-0.33932173252105713,
0.775768518447876,
-0.536768913269043,
-0.3215041160583496,
-0.6838575005531311,
0.029213720932602882,
0.5113469958305359,
0.3663031756877899,
0.25465601682662964,
-0.2740679979324341,
-0.7827450633049011,
-0.719765841960907,
-0.6009947657585144,
-0.174229234457016,
0.09004735946655273,
0.5178903341293335,
0.7041176557540894,
-0.2959079146385193,
1.1736327409744263,
-0.5070028305053711,
-0.4008970260620117,
0.11090018600225449,
0.3554411232471466,
0.1873628944158554,
0.3049578070640564,
0.33737894892692566,
-0.22960790991783142,
-0.45831435918807983,
-0.09390071034431458,
-0.6657959222793579,
-0.6538020372390747,
0.003125563031062484,
0.029270701110363007,
-0.0067116878926754,
0.4842824637889862,
-0.4245406687259674,
0.36278438568115234,
0.6499701142311096,
-0.6822744011878967,
0.8482697606086731,
-0.3525836765766144,
0.5856850743293762,
-0.9514551758766174,
0.168686181306839,
-0.20073813199996948,
-0.2912423014640808,
-0.3104897141456604,
0.006862783804535866,
0.2579828202724457,
0.17539046704769135,
-0.17669740319252014,
0.1383722722530365,
-0.4283004701137543,
-0.16402265429496765,
-0.24659347534179688,
0.15232810378074646,
0.04062693193554878,
-0.0001745959307299927,
-0.5348034501075745,
1.065773367881775,
0.20052917301654816,
-0.4406190514564514,
0.17317280173301697,
0.23902495205402374,
-0.03734723478555679,
0.659447431564331,
-0.45923924446105957,
0.3270953893661499,
-0.25792309641838074,
0.514847457408905,
-0.6225133538246155,
-0.335457980632782,
0.2836325168609619,
-0.5861372947692871,
0.037803154438734055,
0.053745198994874954,
-0.3615274429321289,
-0.411296010017395,
-0.2174389511346817,
0.4323258399963379,
0.21131116151809692,
-0.2619657516479492,
0.35026150941848755,
-0.08274179697036743,
0.05652262642979622,
-0.7358550429344177,
-0.5146922469139099,
0.4948015511035919,
0.14370402693748474,
-0.9066283702850342,
0.21036095917224884,
0.2650600075721741,
-0.42178934812545776,
0.3403248190879822,
0.2400272637605667,
0.2153904139995575,
0.018176935613155365,
0.08034034073352814,
-0.0392596609890461,
-0.09310707449913025,
0.39816704392433167,
-0.1826150119304657,
-0.18885734677314758,
0.0515725202858448,
-0.433040052652359,
0.1568252444267273,
-0.2637612819671631,
-0.4098820388317108,
-0.26931798458099365,
0.06741579622030258,
0.3959070146083832,
-0.027325741946697235,
0.5837878584861755,
0.305701345205307,
-0.38635703921318054,
0.08060373365879059,
-0.5607514381408691,
-0.04837903380393982,
-0.32846465706825256,
0.4290582239627838,
-0.18008972704410553,
-0.5007445216178894,
0.35465008020401,
0.22893382608890533,
-0.17548303306102753,
0.9629340171813965,
0.23733527958393097,
-0.3450942933559418,
0.46584174036979675,
0.4943215548992157,
-0.20690491795539856,
0.18868711590766907,
-0.0468563474714756,
0.006949308328330517,
-0.9393025040626526,
-0.12228062003850937,
-0.7633072137832642,
-0.6241232752799988,
-0.38219088315963745,
-0.7363868355751038,
0.29958656430244446,
-0.012761666439473629,
0.22678625583648682,
0.274122029542923,
0.02615322172641754,
0.7787042856216431,
0.3201708197593689,
0.05364018306136131,
0.41587597131729126,
-0.23968464136123657,
-0.22284537553787231,
-0.37814435362815857,
-0.7319926619529724,
-0.7085369229316711,
1.3111464977264404,
0.13657711446285248,
0.665499210357666,
-0.14427563548088074,
0.3522680699825287,
0.4636977016925812,
0.19771333038806915,
-0.5486066341400146,
0.34956663846969604,
-0.6812694668769836,
-0.5963637828826904,
-0.3018769919872284,
-0.576623260974884,
-0.5802680850028992,
0.40673965215682983,
-0.38513118028640747,
-0.5597397089004517,
0.26851949095726013,
0.3537461459636688,
-0.5371639132499695,
0.546501636505127,
-0.7903339862823486,
0.9212085008621216,
-0.057579733431339264,
-0.2966771423816681,
-0.07857022434473038,
-0.5529574751853943,
0.2908196747303009,
0.0760602280497551,
0.49783191084861755,
0.2986161410808563,
0.16089683771133423,
0.8084813356399536,
-0.7271233797073364,
0.8521442413330078,
-0.014928384684026241,
-0.056595150381326675,
0.29421794414520264,
-0.0013450388796627522,
0.6328162550926208,
-0.09343089163303375,
0.015254558064043522,
-0.037441007792949677,
-0.3701726496219635,
-0.3040078580379486,
-0.7424762845039368,
0.5577031373977661,
-0.544582724571228,
-0.35933399200439453,
-0.6977375149726868,
-0.3516794443130493,
-0.36084139347076416,
-0.23871363699436188,
0.48351743817329407,
0.23226094245910645,
-0.7682713270187378,
0.2399374097585678,
0.2610141932964325,
0.05443234741687775,
0.33218449354171753,
0.5370229482650757,
-0.15069535374641418,
-0.6842635869979858,
0.46350398659706116,
0.12543414533138275,
0.2150617390871048,
0.2113502025604248,
0.24501259624958038,
0.22500406205654144,
-0.36868783831596375,
-0.4654979705810547,
0.16687671840190887,
-0.5159181356430054,
-0.15799467265605927,
-0.6993593573570251,
0.0865347608923912,
-0.47768667340278625,
-0.1207919791340828,
-0.25541022419929504,
-0.22798451781272888,
-0.552050769329071,
-0.27831321954727173,
0.10780993849039078,
0.8973381519317627,
-0.3328372538089752,
0.6471709609031677,
-0.8453800678253174,
-0.04196179285645485,
0.1345890909433365,
0.33452779054641724,
-0.17745359241962433,
-0.7900184988975525,
-0.2902967035770416,
0.09230895340442657,
-0.3400551974773407,
-0.9272143244743347,
0.0018899906426668167,
0.6194086670875549,
-0.012525024823844433,
0.34388452768325806,
-0.7580506205558777,
1.0262706279754639,
-0.9564387202262878,
0.7720817923545837,
-0.014890284277498722,
-1.1595672369003296,
0.6219135522842407,
-0.2816530764102936,
0.20777654647827148,
0.8049954771995544,
-0.21278613805770874,
-1.147664189338684,
-0.13859665393829346,
-0.7746588587760925,
-0.6706345081329346,
0.4971400797367096,
0.1360921412706375,
0.09525591135025024,
-0.12451440095901489,
0.6346027255058289,
0.14156171679496765,
0.05892316251993179,
-0.661702036857605,
0.08176731318235397,
0.1939820796251297,
-0.17296425998210907,
-0.346955269575119,
-0.6277744770050049,
-0.03264099359512329,
-0.1540008932352066,
0.99021315574646,
-0.12083478271961212,
-0.11549916118383408,
0.4014575481414795,
-0.31190547347068787,
-0.5536253452301025,
0.6122652888298035,
0.5203827619552612,
0.8214519619941711,
-0.1335088163614273,
-0.023787502199411392,
0.5373249053955078,
-0.47786223888397217,
0.2116658091545105,
-0.3298444151878357,
-0.5862945318222046,
0.23367814719676971,
0.8819538950920105,
0.7496089935302734,
0.6670892238616943,
-0.1864881068468094,
0.7295583486557007,
0.2589016854763031,
-0.190899059176445,
-0.1445261389017105,
-0.2571754455566406,
-0.09578259289264679,
-0.19950427114963531,
0.10183501243591309,
0.5789802074432373,
0.2006923258304596,
-0.4891945719718933,
0.38865286111831665,
0.3501618802547455,
-0.24194574356079102,
-0.6800693869590759,
0.4381875991821289,
0.6672830581665039,
-0.2904307246208191,
0.34328657388687134,
-0.36518239974975586,
-0.5667504072189331,
0.4488356113433838,
0.38246142864227295,
1.1561039686203003,
-0.3144664466381073,
0.5601429343223572,
0.5570757389068604,
0.6691678762435913,
-0.28647518157958984,
0.08342847973108292,
0.6753098964691162,
-0.6386124491691589,
-0.7247071862220764,
-0.3795558214187622,
-0.16566479206085205,
-0.015000906772911549,
-0.48606082797050476,
0.35723331570625305,
-0.4951171278953552,
-0.3744087517261505,
-0.40365317463874817,
-0.25015708804130554,
-0.5076369643211365,
0.3311445116996765,
-0.09878095239400864,
0.8184380531311035,
-1.3939248323440552,
0.1905338019132614,
0.7396106123924255,
-0.1840863823890686,
-0.5883132815361023,
0.19895578920841217,
0.14995822310447693,
-0.415275514125824,
0.4432576894760132,
-0.1318691223859787,
-0.17707659304141998,
-0.5507898926734924,
-0.15927094221115112,
-0.8227396011352539,
0.9316558837890625,
0.25145480036735535,
-0.8541178107261658,
-0.10886382311582565,
0.01899346150457859,
0.7597793936729431,
-0.3314436376094818,
0.4927405118942261,
0.6908899545669556,
0.6647244095802307,
-0.1568678319454193,
-1.1292530298233032,
-0.31573203206062317,
-0.21037133038043976,
0.00769593333825469,
0.16107651591300964,
-0.5406977534294128,
0.8690659999847412,
-0.25389066338539124,
-0.32180097699165344,
0.06564904004335403,
0.6873856782913208,
-0.3992573916912079,
0.20702654123306274,
0.5532714128494263,
1.0854911804199219,
0.8908212184906006,
-0.4142686724662781,
0.9945125579833984,
0.11262790113687515,
0.7185710072517395,
1.2080886363983154,
-0.1463555097579956,
0.8626505732536316,
0.5054569244384766,
-0.6771193742752075,
0.8325068950653076,
0.5499380826950073,
0.08665705472230911,
0.14873361587524414,
0.0763661339879036,
-0.050738267600536346,
0.00671418895944953,
0.2795616686344147,
-0.2655426263809204,
0.3532836139202118,
0.01562065351754427,
-0.49307867884635925,
-0.22489677369594574,
-0.2658388018608093,
0.23072274029254913,
0.47972092032432556,
-0.3341538906097412,
0.7756493091583252,
-0.1964227557182312,
-0.5335265398025513,
0.12235943973064423,
0.3036559522151947,
0.7657948732376099,
-0.3854057192802429,
0.14658477902412415,
-0.34621185064315796,
0.23531395196914673,
-0.5828273296356201,
-0.4720788896083832,
0.3722096085548401,
0.46770361065864563,
-0.42631813883781433,
0.0495557077229023,
0.7129408121109009,
-0.36803868412971497,
-0.8864051103591919,
0.23038482666015625,
0.4989930987358093,
-0.04624193534255028,
-0.13404884934425354,
-0.2821291983127594,
-0.11231009662151337,
-0.16542375087738037,
0.1705927848815918,
-0.2561841309070587,
0.4650283753871918,
-0.008336597122251987,
0.3004891872406006,
0.4650806188583374,
0.37897104024887085,
0.09827720373868942,
0.3865133225917816,
0.4364539384841919,
-0.7584502100944519,
-0.5491589903831482,
-0.945500910282135,
0.5025925040245056,
-0.031065287068486214,
-0.5300155878067017,
0.7414368987083435,
0.4953998923301697,
0.8739010095596313,
-0.3122554421424866,
0.8464592695236206,
-0.20459777116775513,
0.32848721742630005,
-0.7835795283317566,
0.30949774384498596,
-0.3583722412586212,
0.20531931519508362,
-0.6760424971580505,
-1.1956002712249756,
-0.4035753309726715,
0.4071236848831177,
-0.5376211404800415,
0.24955710768699646,
1.2202190160751343,
0.6216980814933777,
-0.026321716606616974,
0.005512895993888378,
0.18074703216552734,
0.432097464799881,
0.09810841083526611,
0.5194895267486572,
0.6050513386726379,
-0.7619311809539795,
0.30009427666664124,
-0.029681814834475517,
-0.4014987051486969,
-0.49952995777130127,
-0.9321775436401367,
-0.2600945830345154,
-0.3371419906616211,
-0.14947359263896942,
-0.27009648084640503,
0.6267369389533997,
0.9567080140113831,
0.2975946068763733,
-1.0084296464920044,
-0.12342360615730286,
-0.06748765707015991,
-0.1339077204465866,
-0.4569198489189148,
-0.19184979796409607,
0.27261069416999817,
-0.6622161269187927,
-0.8816084265708923,
0.34155571460723877,
0.18067263066768646,
-0.24734702706336975,
-0.2189270257949829,
-0.004314605612307787,
-0.25753238797187805,
-0.007123963907361031,
0.4356967508792877,
0.10457120835781097,
-0.6940394639968872,
-0.6996631622314453,
0.09393178671598434,
-0.13363982737064362,
0.07708106189966202,
1.1575746536254883,
-0.7179475426673889,
0.521434485912323,
0.4985238313674927,
0.5564911365509033,
-0.256693959236145,
0.341037392616272,
0.6947228908538818,
-0.8816916942596436,
-0.07480181008577347,
0.043464966118335724,
0.6263318657875061,
0.5985814929008484,
-0.26575517654418945,
0.6320242881774902,
0.6460514068603516,
-0.5402379631996155,
-0.43238016963005066,
-0.18062426149845123,
-0.4739112854003906,
0.023003678768873215,
1.3347160816192627,
-0.07430003583431244,
-0.28226491808891296,
0.47570064663887024,
-0.26223477721214294,
-0.06573669612407684,
-0.16685612499713898,
0.9338666200637817,
1.4672491550445557,
0.3493705093860626,
0.43011945486068726,
-0.27653437852859497,
0.3584952652454376,
0.8525421619415283,
-0.9127808809280396,
0.0914631336927414,
0.7527992129325867,
0.2869032919406891,
0.28523069620132446,
0.5274118781089783,
-0.3563935458660126,
0.4865606725215912,
-0.003822261467576027,
0.1394117772579193,
0.23316651582717896,
-0.7294696569442749,
-0.7212215662002563,
-0.22533535957336426,
-0.04481794685125351,
-0.31825998425483704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04797v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04797v1
|
Found in the Middle: How Language Models Use Long Contexts Better via Plug-and-Play Positional Encoding
| 2024-03-05T04:58:37 | 2024-03-05T04:58:37 |
Zhenyu Zhang, Runjin Chen, Shiwei Liu, Zhewei Yao, Olatunji Ruwase, Beidi Chen, Xiaoxia Wu, Zhangyang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper aims to overcome the "lost-in-the-middle" challenge of large
language models (LLMs). While recent advancements have successfully enabled
LLMs to perform stable language modeling with up to 4 million tokens, the
persistent difficulty faced by most LLMs in identifying relevant information
situated in the middle of the context has not been adequately tackled. To
address this problem, this paper introduces Multi-scale Positional Encoding
(Ms-PoE) which is a simple yet effective plug-and-play approach to enhance the
capacity of LLMs to handle the relevant information located in the middle of
the context, without fine-tuning or introducing any additional overhead. Ms-PoE
leverages the position indice rescaling to relieve the long-term decay effect
introduced by RoPE, while meticulously assigning distinct scaling ratios to
different attention heads to preserve essential knowledge learned during the
pre-training step, forming a multi-scale context fusion from short to long
distance. Extensive experiments with a wide range of LLMs demonstrate the
efficacy of our approach. Notably, Ms-PoE achieves an average accuracy gain of
up to 3.8 on the Zero-SCROLLS benchmark over the original LLMs. Code are
available at https://github.com/VITA-Group/Ms-PoE.
|
[
-0.16259808838367462,
-0.41131505370140076,
0.6023556590080261,
0.555885910987854,
-0.2439984828233719,
0.07317313551902771,
-0.5547433495521545,
-0.18255852162837982,
0.29290178418159485,
0.31297436356544495,
-0.21540069580078125,
-0.3772827982902527,
-0.7012701630592346,
-0.0630175992846489,
-0.3066054880619049,
0.581477701663971,
-0.021153472363948822,
-0.14109623432159424,
0.015545087866485119,
-0.18905788660049438,
-0.359211266040802,
-0.8765170574188232,
-0.5722166299819946,
-0.06448528915643692,
0.804361879825592,
0.6134716272354126,
0.4698680341243744,
0.6430956721305847,
0.4231022596359253,
0.1988365799188614,
-0.15604430437088013,
0.22387254238128662,
-0.5207984447479248,
-0.18871794641017914,
-0.13024656474590302,
-0.4734702408313751,
-0.5736899375915527,
0.03561457246541977,
1.029774785041809,
0.5452895760536194,
-0.47938549518585205,
0.1413974016904831,
-0.09758979827165604,
0.8978180289268494,
-0.7234136462211609,
-0.056998416781425476,
-0.7394939661026001,
0.004726075101643801,
-0.5700267553329468,
-0.38993901014328003,
-0.8170871734619141,
0.2898881137371063,
-0.07484272867441177,
-0.4424935281276703,
0.036183156073093414,
0.2822946012020111,
0.7756507396697998,
-0.021866191178560257,
-0.729216456413269,
-0.06283476203680038,
-0.8002825379371643,
0.840446412563324,
-0.8274643421173096,
0.5141516327857971,
0.21219022572040558,
0.2672743797302246,
-0.34173324704170227,
-0.4936622977256775,
-0.7208375334739685,
0.15171831846237183,
-0.12853334844112396,
-0.1241612434387207,
-0.11716567724943161,
0.15642984211444855,
0.323381632566452,
0.10976000875234604,
-0.49961742758750916,
0.24555081129074097,
-0.44601672887802124,
0.09089148789644241,
0.49840936064720154,
-0.15770180523395538,
0.416955828666687,
-0.0072429305873811245,
-0.41636303067207336,
0.13630059361457825,
-1.1164474487304688,
0.19946101307868958,
0.18589471280574799,
0.408378541469574,
-0.25636008381843567,
0.5277537703514099,
0.1041259765625,
0.7975948452949524,
0.26095348596572876,
-0.30965456366539,
0.29384753108024597,
-0.06870035082101822,
-0.3161236047744751,
0.022112440317869186,
0.5791757106781006,
0.46694573760032654,
-0.014868822880089283,
0.038288988173007965,
-0.20970302820205688,
-0.19547605514526367,
0.2695946991443634,
-0.5870698690414429,
0.20459473133087158,
0.10810317099094391,
-0.3997446298599243,
0.11605475842952728,
-0.49995139241218567,
-0.3988695442676544,
-0.13009223341941833,
-0.4517904222011566,
0.21440979838371277,
-0.21557509899139404,
-0.26969870924949646,
0.3599926233291626,
0.213327556848526,
0.4621739387512207,
0.177450492978096,
-1.1274389028549194,
0.14487963914871216,
0.6373552680015564,
0.9880243539810181,
-0.09031382948160172,
-0.43471425771713257,
-0.7444981336593628,
0.4073261022567749,
-0.36198464035987854,
0.3765420615673065,
-0.5479172468185425,
-0.14118851721286774,
0.13950413465499878,
0.27472761273384094,
-0.07471471279859543,
-0.24532850086688995,
0.5603384971618652,
-0.8035204410552979,
0.2427527904510498,
-0.23567324876785278,
-0.44511130452156067,
0.18761689960956573,
0.405817449092865,
-0.712743878364563,
0.9916403293609619,
-0.08170593529939651,
-0.8356860280036926,
0.1421944797039032,
-0.5034984946250916,
-0.4141637682914734,
-0.24232140183448792,
-0.2132362276315689,
-0.246792733669281,
0.20165906846523285,
0.2865229547023773,
0.5537998080253601,
-0.0829799547791481,
0.21935808658599854,
-0.2032708078622818,
-0.5208912491798401,
0.1110999584197998,
-0.4595714509487152,
0.500273585319519,
-0.13607802987098694,
-0.20310905575752258,
0.03973986953496933,
-0.707764208316803,
-0.46150073409080505,
0.10597090423107147,
-0.4266219437122345,
-0.4375867545604706,
0.07248932868242264,
-0.001977455336600542,
0.5835544466972351,
0.17947369813919067,
-0.5880259275436401,
0.29281085729599,
-0.473788857460022,
0.5701133608818054,
0.6349644064903259,
-0.40229031443595886,
0.784272313117981,
-0.03926140442490578,
0.37977248430252075,
0.19606095552444458,
0.051530178636312485,
-0.32874107360839844,
-0.28022482991218567,
-0.7045633792877197,
-0.012441660277545452,
0.05838946998119354,
0.3376120328903198,
-0.6764708757400513,
0.3668254613876343,
-0.39097392559051514,
-0.34735360741615295,
-0.4116056263446808,
-0.018033549189567566,
0.1976543664932251,
0.6624352335929871,
0.3814098536968231,
-0.27008503675460815,
-0.4435555040836334,
-0.8633264303207397,
-0.0005154875689186156,
0.027275431901216507,
-0.07775218784809113,
0.2489086538553238,
0.17905813455581665,
-0.14699921011924744,
0.8717610836029053,
-0.2864372432231903,
-0.25816765427589417,
-0.13333728909492493,
-0.09727615863084793,
0.5230847001075745,
0.48236414790153503,
0.538343071937561,
-0.6668698787689209,
-0.47070571780204773,
-0.036220625042915344,
-0.5437982678413391,
0.2077292799949646,
-0.10194110870361328,
-0.11682283133268356,
0.023510389029979706,
0.6851285696029663,
-0.8642796277999878,
0.09688223898410797,
1.04712975025177,
-0.1193767786026001,
0.6840658187866211,
-0.5183876156806946,
0.007475307211279869,
-1.1441420316696167,
0.28529995679855347,
-0.07754947990179062,
-0.22459571063518524,
-0.7877732515335083,
-0.04879237338900566,
0.4760585427284241,
-0.2965506911277771,
-0.4293261170387268,
0.5327618718147278,
-0.7029141783714294,
-0.09010414779186249,
-0.24016709625720978,
0.6529741883277893,
0.27529072761535645,
0.710930347442627,
-0.003884705947712064,
0.9768732190132141,
0.4698891043663025,
-0.26276451349258423,
0.1203799918293953,
-0.25330016016960144,
-0.22906775772571564,
0.3756507337093353,
-0.5674134492874146,
0.16305868327617645,
-0.35163816809654236,
0.794087827205658,
-0.9631592035293579,
-0.2749634385108948,
-0.15039753913879395,
-0.14626434445381165,
0.5702193379402161,
-0.4043102264404297,
-0.508013129234314,
-0.34814003109931946,
-0.2223665863275528,
0.7651296854019165,
0.34705832600593567,
-0.5997782945632935,
0.44676512479782104,
0.6291447281837463,
-0.0861617848277092,
-1.0596113204956055,
-0.6390994191169739,
0.22736786305904388,
-0.5069774985313416,
-0.5823361873626709,
0.48589980602264404,
0.0007257261895574629,
0.23766283690929413,
-0.5814896821975708,
-0.0516287162899971,
0.21969027817249298,
-0.14184050261974335,
-0.0364985466003418,
0.06185782700777054,
-0.3545536398887634,
0.533735454082489,
0.14389163255691528,
-0.19093148410320282,
-0.02928999997675419,
-0.3352142870426178,
0.5082231163978577,
-0.39753198623657227,
-0.42713865637779236,
-0.19544070959091187,
0.4594968557357788,
0.9307721853256226,
-0.42672207951545715,
0.8130685091018677,
0.5938969254493713,
-0.4525221586227417,
-0.2653403878211975,
-0.653602659702301,
-0.002799029229208827,
-0.4875687062740326,
0.27189961075782776,
-0.269314706325531,
-1.052856206893921,
0.5582175254821777,
-0.5041816234588623,
0.0028778945561498404,
0.24054290354251862,
0.28049904108047485,
-0.23373697698116302,
0.9071721434593201,
0.9590279459953308,
-0.2706456184387207,
0.660589873790741,
-0.14965635538101196,
0.6547814011573792,
-1.277099370956421,
-0.17686393857002258,
-0.3565477132797241,
-0.39205995202064514,
-0.3415904939174652,
-0.7761811017990112,
0.5040384531021118,
0.506787896156311,
-0.13530075550079346,
0.39384129643440247,
-0.43706709146499634,
0.7446749210357666,
0.2379177212715149,
-0.024900605902075768,
0.029442982748150826,
-0.03133260831236839,
-0.19707301259040833,
-0.11030280590057373,
-0.9526820182800293,
-0.5387592315673828,
0.9138914942741394,
0.5812475681304932,
0.574809193611145,
0.24035301804542542,
0.530180037021637,
0.015643250197172165,
0.19609254598617554,
-0.6416530013084412,
0.38726359605789185,
-0.4196127653121948,
-0.41705232858657837,
-0.4153105914592743,
0.08308037370443344,
-1.0061687231063843,
0.37647104263305664,
0.07080205529928207,
-0.8584080934524536,
0.23935560882091522,
0.18512028455734253,
-0.5798747539520264,
0.4962354004383087,
-0.7048642039299011,
0.7769272923469543,
-0.13932600617408752,
-0.4609903395175934,
-0.2608765959739685,
-1.0796343088150024,
0.16306346654891968,
0.19210872054100037,
0.5729870200157166,
-0.17984803020954132,
-0.02741698920726776,
0.6789629459381104,
-0.2516268789768219,
0.9725627899169922,
-0.15517425537109375,
-0.3297801911830902,
0.17516492307186127,
-0.13600227236747742,
0.728624165058136,
0.08532184362411499,
-0.05257640406489372,
0.11049528419971466,
-0.24416960775852203,
-0.6450176239013672,
-0.6269820332527161,
0.800977349281311,
-0.7895883917808533,
-0.5790210962295532,
-0.24360308051109314,
-0.559191882610321,
-0.23840057849884033,
0.2845156788825989,
0.08109045028686523,
0.6233933568000793,
0.06479872018098831,
0.3557267487049103,
0.9195020794868469,
-0.2672080993652344,
0.8113401532173157,
0.2838999032974243,
-0.14862358570098877,
-0.23990750312805176,
0.5548678040504456,
0.11291196942329407,
0.15227970480918884,
0.6420504450798035,
0.0525570809841156,
-0.24055948853492737,
-0.22758547961711884,
-0.6785920262336731,
0.4588172733783722,
-0.7361184358596802,
-0.18800029158592224,
-0.577824592590332,
-0.2598670721054077,
-0.15171843767166138,
-0.5363008975982666,
-0.6317233443260193,
-0.16942434012889862,
-0.18441620469093323,
-0.031411778181791306,
0.026017019525170326,
0.2963472306728363,
-0.09367939829826355,
0.7471141219139099,
-0.8691983819007874,
0.006410179194062948,
0.2509790062904358,
0.4303508996963501,
0.137240931391716,
-0.37567421793937683,
-0.6499470472335815,
-0.07050640136003494,
0.1006888821721077,
-0.712195634841919,
0.29096686840057373,
0.02951822802424431,
0.33305519819259644,
0.36770936846733093,
-0.28642725944519043,
0.7355313301086426,
-0.7998858094215393,
0.906781792640686,
0.4015290141105652,
-0.9610141515731812,
0.31555983424186707,
-0.4293942153453827,
0.5938778519630432,
0.2734767496585846,
0.22203820943832397,
-0.8425850868225098,
-0.03472652658820152,
-0.4300311505794525,
-1.0273149013519287,
0.6274811625480652,
-0.060229863971471786,
0.2581207752227783,
-0.031771063804626465,
0.3343009650707245,
-0.05037727579474449,
0.18305456638336182,
-0.9459666609764099,
0.09057693928480148,
0.2629476487636566,
-0.09543049335479736,
-0.20560182631015778,
-0.4438309669494629,
-0.2662726938724518,
-0.07218777388334274,
0.43025410175323486,
-0.20189142227172852,
0.1610499918460846,
0.14905737340450287,
-0.18328779935836792,
-0.15664343535900116,
0.5051925182342529,
0.8406132459640503,
0.7779490351676941,
-0.13797502219676971,
0.511951744556427,
0.20343591272830963,
-0.19882866740226746,
0.07997246086597443,
-0.21013545989990234,
0.2582545876502991,
0.12565040588378906,
0.47903963923454285,
0.7473056316375732,
0.5279729962348938,
-0.4842265546321869,
0.8531655073165894,
-0.008617570623755455,
0.45768609642982483,
-0.35002753138542175,
-0.3445422947406769,
0.34008729457855225,
0.15845319628715515,
0.3366848826408386,
0.1634160280227661,
-0.11216462403535843,
-0.4446587562561035,
0.2391817271709442,
0.16704078018665314,
-0.25245171785354614,
-0.48567166924476624,
0.39749667048454285,
0.37348437309265137,
-0.27488332986831665,
0.6636713147163391,
-0.00399544695392251,
-0.42007482051849365,
0.43161898851394653,
0.81952965259552,
0.6124426126480103,
-0.3140346109867096,
-0.09192339330911636,
0.42271554470062256,
0.3471375107765198,
-0.09357917308807373,
0.12275631725788116,
-0.11018899828195572,
-0.6877961158752441,
-0.6699484586715698,
-0.6055793166160583,
-0.07959888130426407,
0.14396508038043976,
-0.43388575315475464,
0.3214763402938843,
-0.28353992104530334,
-0.14955884218215942,
-0.3230067789554596,
-0.2654073238372803,
-0.5566418170928955,
0.09945591539144516,
0.29952704906463623,
0.9722453951835632,
-0.922576367855072,
1.234323263168335,
0.4368860423564911,
-0.038222216069698334,
-0.780012309551239,
-0.09493683278560638,
-0.13789133727550507,
-0.6439430117607117,
0.36937183141708374,
0.3924955427646637,
-0.4646068811416626,
-0.18650147318840027,
-0.7003719806671143,
-1.1392563581466675,
1.2124860286712646,
0.19979754090309143,
-1.0645424127578735,
-0.3730469048023224,
-0.023113325238227844,
0.6251032948493958,
-0.6520654559135437,
0.16460020840168,
0.5374202132225037,
-0.0524311400949955,
0.039357200264930725,
-0.9967629909515381,
-0.027225423604249954,
-0.23998938500881195,
0.20387019217014313,
0.22105573117733002,
-0.986852765083313,
1.0447101593017578,
-0.24862965941429138,
-0.1884596198797226,
-0.3193013370037079,
0.5502448678016663,
0.602376401424408,
0.26611536741256714,
0.41577184200286865,
0.4393143057823181,
0.6719793677330017,
0.17377610504627228,
0.782311737537384,
-0.7191591858863831,
0.314572274684906,
1.3522754907608032,
-0.22353370487689972,
1.2528984546661377,
0.865036129951477,
0.06313647329807281,
0.6145268082618713,
0.676810085773468,
0.47318217158317566,
0.4660297930240631,
0.28498417139053345,
-0.28120824694633484,
-0.10837949812412262,
0.028465278446674347,
-0.46538540720939636,
0.1960766762495041,
0.7056358456611633,
-0.22993719577789307,
-0.10800982266664505,
0.0812717154622078,
0.18660306930541992,
-0.06848712265491486,
-0.19743360579013824,
0.41389602422714233,
0.2813115119934082,
-0.3932040333747864,
0.5692168474197388,
0.22087004780769348,
0.6923474669456482,
-0.640916645526886,
-0.027659472078084946,
-0.29802897572517395,
0.13106149435043335,
-0.09311728179454803,
-0.7507311701774597,
0.12481103092432022,
-0.2260751724243164,
-0.2962866723537445,
-0.3792015314102173,
0.7439671158790588,
-0.8591597080230713,
-0.2196723371744156,
0.5171604752540588,
0.15346059203147888,
0.0628218725323677,
0.13470269739627838,
-0.34971562027931213,
0.20914964377880096,
-0.4199181795120239,
-0.14702843129634857,
0.27443927526474,
0.7243960499763489,
-0.16539832949638367,
0.5506598949432373,
0.5334345698356628,
0.0627705305814743,
0.07684463262557983,
0.1780601441860199,
0.8622214794158936,
-0.6427313089370728,
-0.6881169080734253,
-0.7716531753540039,
0.7288488745689392,
-0.16106818616390228,
-0.2583881914615631,
0.5724842548370361,
0.5283510684967041,
0.8722938299179077,
-0.06815779209136963,
0.47136929631233215,
0.15693719685077667,
0.12706618010997772,
-0.451925665140152,
0.6600757837295532,
-0.6683849096298218,
0.3394281566143036,
-0.15165288746356964,
-0.8702523112297058,
-0.581362247467041,
0.2615662217140198,
-0.2704832851886749,
-0.2277744561433792,
0.5506300926208496,
0.6957896947860718,
-0.5353170037269592,
-0.39453473687171936,
0.4402068257331848,
0.2124832421541214,
0.3789709508419037,
0.6559704542160034,
0.6017817854881287,
-0.5321987271308899,
0.1803034245967865,
-0.10395041108131409,
-0.45253756642341614,
-0.47518447041511536,
-0.9299240112304688,
-0.6265817284584045,
-0.6604099869728088,
0.09675224870443344,
-0.19134195148944855,
-0.11810088902711868,
0.9411081075668335,
0.9713410139083862,
-0.5765705704689026,
-0.6420698761940002,
0.1134706437587738,
0.1317874640226364,
-0.054390739649534225,
-0.12138403952121735,
0.628043532371521,
-0.43411871790885925,
-0.5668042302131653,
0.6776740550994873,
0.8686977624893188,
-0.13103075325489044,
-0.3169451653957367,
-0.10228872299194336,
-0.6365038752555847,
0.17062243819236755,
1.1812084913253784,
0.15901929140090942,
-0.8283912539482117,
-0.491275429725647,
0.053838882595300674,
-0.31908461451530457,
0.23387305438518524,
0.9047081470489502,
-0.5034817457199097,
0.6465210914611816,
0.4689008891582489,
0.5190702080726624,
0.5077089667320251,
-0.15371529757976532,
0.6970268487930298,
-1.1960134506225586,
0.34345248341560364,
0.016373410820961,
0.5911080241203308,
0.4500163495540619,
-0.34018614888191223,
0.42008453607559204,
0.06417978554964066,
-0.6243435740470886,
-0.7593728303909302,
0.19299539923667908,
-1.121883749961853,
-0.03162330016493797,
1.1136913299560547,
-0.2970196008682251,
-0.3351820111274719,
0.18112865090370178,
-0.2178124338388443,
0.2665613293647766,
-0.2738075256347656,
0.8726730346679688,
0.868521511554718,
-0.038605060428380966,
-0.17158102989196777,
-0.33842629194259644,
0.5070464611053467,
0.4027280807495117,
-0.4394422173500061,
0.2094072699546814,
0.29160478711128235,
0.18758751451969147,
0.32727399468421936,
0.768979012966156,
-0.08525741100311279,
-0.0035706795752048492,
-0.030564719811081886,
-0.04492485150694847,
0.39300844073295593,
-0.7661004066467285,
-0.48422080278396606,
0.33267101645469666,
0.08089790493249893,
-0.1139678806066513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02647v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02647v1
|
FinReport: Explainable Stock Earnings Forecasting via News Factor Analyzing Model
| 2024-03-05T04:33:36 | 2024-03-05T04:33:36 |
Xiangyu Li, Xinjie Shen, Yawen Zeng, Xiaofen Xing, Jin Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The task of stock earnings forecasting has received considerable attention
due to the demand investors in real-world scenarios. However, compared with
financial institutions, it is not easy for ordinary investors to mine factors
and analyze news. On the other hand, although large language models in the
financial field can serve users in the form of dialogue robots, it still
requires users to have financial knowledge to ask reasonable questions. To
serve the user experience, we aim to build an automatic system, FinReport, for
ordinary investors to collect information, analyze it, and generate reports
after summarizing.
Specifically, our FinReport is based on financial news announcements and a
multi-factor model to ensure the professionalism of the report. The FinReport
consists of three modules: news factorization module, return forecasting
module, risk assessment module. The news factorization module involves
understanding news information and combining it with stock factors, the return
forecasting module aim to analysis the impact of news on market sentiment, and
the risk assessment module is adopted to control investment risk. Extensive
experiments on real-world datasets have well verified the effectiveness and
explainability of our proposed FinReport. Our codes and datasets are available
at https://github.com/frinkleko/FinReport.
|
[
-0.07923077046871185,
-0.6706007719039917,
0.2682328224182129,
0.4712825119495392,
-0.4390164017677307,
0.2580990791320801,
0.20603536069393158,
-0.7371560335159302,
0.5679395794868469,
0.39209696650505066,
-0.7278146147727966,
-0.2872816026210785,
-0.37770867347717285,
-0.1174762174487114,
-0.45457911491394043,
1.1807186603546143,
0.1083611398935318,
0.42942506074905396,
0.1197795644402504,
0.20860587060451508,
-0.24051973223686218,
-0.32517731189727783,
-0.6836422085762024,
0.08942166715860367,
0.32905930280685425,
0.4464198052883148,
0.7541088461875916,
0.5717127323150635,
0.7501604557037354,
0.28755900263786316,
0.29348626732826233,
0.1378522515296936,
-0.38529616594314575,
-0.14991417527198792,
-0.04111821576952934,
-0.40803179144859314,
-0.8150748610496521,
0.13673549890518188,
0.4240444302558899,
0.6225588321685791,
-0.19301599264144897,
0.3663066029548645,
-0.01777726225554943,
0.8203086853027344,
-0.23563136160373688,
0.5350662469863892,
-0.3028182089328766,
0.15647630393505096,
-0.19074992835521698,
-0.5513933897018433,
-0.3170284032821655,
-0.40550005435943604,
0.1842156946659088,
-0.661801278591156,
0.12975871562957764,
0.5359123349189758,
0.9038388729095459,
-0.24900192022323608,
-0.4557882845401764,
-0.2727615237236023,
-0.8500582575798035,
0.589124321937561,
-0.5705317854881287,
0.5533603429794312,
0.22161930799484253,
0.30610233545303345,
-0.10607653856277466,
-0.43085575103759766,
-0.2868594825267792,
0.05854422226548195,
-0.20411625504493713,
0.2247425764799118,
-0.5411807894706726,
-0.10033870488405228,
-0.2993701696395874,
0.444208562374115,
-0.4415681064128876,
-0.04903785139322281,
-0.7179235219955444,
-0.16515743732452393,
0.770055890083313,
0.052822284400463104,
0.07207175344228745,
-0.10215864330530167,
-0.7502567172050476,
-0.1440354883670807,
-0.5400128960609436,
0.29835546016693115,
0.8212782740592957,
0.4279498755931854,
-0.11649150401353836,
0.4097438156604767,
-0.24729545414447784,
0.44041186571121216,
0.038408245891332626,
-0.2869642674922943,
0.3066982626914978,
-0.21402931213378906,
-0.07487206161022186,
0.2731018662452698,
0.3944491744041443,
0.7503483295440674,
0.03461907058954239,
0.0059865983203053474,
-0.3112430274486542,
-0.351631760597229,
0.25067460536956787,
-0.7001640200614929,
-0.1889052391052246,
0.6142528653144836,
-0.7798198461532593,
-0.6208695769309998,
0.4011392593383789,
-1.125783085823059,
-0.13412249088287354,
-0.04952497407793999,
0.5494679808616638,
-0.22199878096580505,
-0.38826602697372437,
0.26385030150413513,
-0.4220990240573883,
0.03849218040704727,
0.28201809525489807,
-0.7233660221099854,
0.4319189488887787,
0.7040072679519653,
0.5927582383155823,
-0.12614278495311737,
-0.13837726414203644,
-1.0797715187072754,
0.1989997923374176,
-0.18023397028446198,
0.980744481086731,
-0.16571784019470215,
-0.3013593256473541,
-0.027011830359697342,
-0.16249392926692963,
-0.08165132999420166,
-0.14512765407562256,
0.2237282693386078,
-0.44618871808052063,
0.3549897074699402,
0.005452043376863003,
-0.5886521935462952,
-0.6601930856704712,
-0.1587352752685547,
-0.5056390166282654,
0.3362758159637451,
0.046485137194395065,
-0.8077635169029236,
0.49430355429649353,
-1.073455810546875,
-0.3057428300380707,
0.3121890425682068,
0.10494528710842133,
-0.19295449554920197,
-0.1784093677997589,
0.24332734942436218,
0.5519171357154846,
-0.18404048681259155,
0.2075680047273636,
-0.23152302205562592,
-0.21940962970256805,
0.4825592637062073,
-0.33124470710754395,
0.3705081641674042,
0.13981866836547852,
-0.15066298842430115,
0.3348858058452606,
-0.7307058572769165,
-0.17907573282718658,
0.16247837245464325,
0.24027284979820251,
-0.38912349939346313,
0.295168936252594,
0.10286924242973328,
0.0016786890337243676,
0.29335641860961914,
-0.6015657782554626,
-0.15926089882850647,
-0.5195873379707336,
0.27221906185150146,
0.6493567228317261,
0.20430919528007507,
0.21468234062194824,
-0.1686370074748993,
0.8934532403945923,
0.10100128501653671,
0.5149146914482117,
-0.3100909888744354,
-0.030503448098897934,
-0.268365740776062,
-0.2788349688053131,
0.34820613265037537,
0.8024184107780457,
-0.40104782581329346,
0.09928887337446213,
-0.02098407968878746,
-0.4724233150482178,
-0.2636771500110626,
0.17699353396892548,
0.1563922017812729,
0.4739304482936859,
0.18035489320755005,
-0.31496816873550415,
-0.5400745272636414,
-1.1062290668487549,
-0.24160543084144592,
-0.25770336389541626,
-0.10943124443292618,
-0.07812607288360596,
0.2445431500673294,
0.2771599590778351,
0.7860589027404785,
-1.0744659900665283,
-0.1656823456287384,
-0.4985031485557556,
0.38960590958595276,
0.44967934489250183,
0.2636759579181671,
0.6565188765525818,
-0.9945698380470276,
0.40572306513786316,
-0.23752230405807495,
-0.4168662130832672,
0.3952879309654236,
-0.3432081639766693,
-0.13305263221263885,
-0.010335460305213928,
0.44947704672813416,
-0.27245205640792847,
0.4690968096256256,
0.4857054054737091,
-0.8077999353408813,
0.5294988751411438,
-0.0850277692079544,
0.09910807758569717,
-0.9856509566307068,
0.05088016018271446,
0.6049714684486389,
-0.503584623336792,
-0.4580381512641907,
-0.18123391270637512,
-0.27088209986686707,
-0.28770703077316284,
-0.3106430172920227,
0.48460453748703003,
-0.06328553706407547,
-0.42747247219085693,
-0.3871212303638458,
0.3842971920967102,
0.067772276699543,
0.5170763731002808,
-0.13190385699272156,
0.4877833425998688,
0.342863529920578,
-0.5068087577819824,
0.17976398766040802,
0.15915340185165405,
-0.38186782598495483,
0.2224150002002716,
-0.5992122292518616,
-0.3820357322692871,
-0.024128153920173645,
0.13816098868846893,
-1.244165301322937,
-0.16664306819438934,
0.4162297546863556,
-0.4810580909252167,
-0.036010973155498505,
0.1677643358707428,
-0.08595933765172958,
-0.25336122512817383,
-0.6828451156616211,
-0.056749437004327774,
0.042056795209646225,
-0.39846718311309814,
0.5738272070884705,
0.6087838411331177,
-0.9748960733413696,
-0.47832152247428894,
-0.30538222193717957,
0.03326733782887459,
-0.30646923184394836,
-0.7328828573226929,
0.3385828733444214,
-0.04012638330459595,
-0.4805155098438263,
0.25522086024284363,
-0.1487693190574646,
-0.2858169376850128,
0.15262427926063538,
0.2162468284368515,
1.288216233253479,
-0.3692343831062317,
0.16415207087993622,
0.036292776465415955,
-0.42427581548690796,
0.14682266116142273,
0.163919135928154,
0.20391704142093658,
-0.41211557388305664,
0.0263576190918684,
-0.5357608199119568,
0.4215453267097473,
0.4615373909473419,
-0.398896723985672,
0.7178604006767273,
0.3927733898162842,
-0.20783020555973053,
0.047037698328495026,
-0.24144744873046875,
-0.32933303713798523,
-0.4657233953475952,
0.521109402179718,
0.07263710349798203,
-0.700130045413971,
0.7313444018363953,
0.06024898588657379,
0.32220831513404846,
0.882943868637085,
0.25248345732688904,
-0.027055498212575912,
1.233620047569275,
0.9091103076934814,
0.0567677840590477,
0.29691654443740845,
-0.008211414329707623,
0.5464207530021667,
-0.12361238151788712,
-0.22313658893108368,
-0.179580956697464,
-0.32798564434051514,
-0.31561243534088135,
0.2436392456293106,
0.22180601954460144,
0.2040797472000122,
-0.0010961922816932201,
0.15177209675312042,
-0.3428082764148712,
0.33523449301719666,
0.6471744775772095,
-0.28368687629699707,
0.4942340850830078,
-0.012461631558835506,
0.09826366603374481,
0.17038346827030182,
-0.5560338497161865,
-0.36857786774635315,
0.7068116068840027,
0.7282878756523132,
0.7689868807792664,
-0.17805743217468262,
0.3213615119457245,
0.5506094694137573,
0.09155373275279999,
-0.6683319807052612,
0.3059651553630829,
-0.4062541723251343,
-0.24686644971370697,
-0.21630924940109253,
-0.4245792329311371,
-0.3752497136592865,
0.051171962171792984,
-0.3862327039241791,
-0.6544615030288696,
0.5620723366737366,
-0.02218845672905445,
-0.8212851285934448,
0.23816241323947906,
-0.8088160753250122,
0.7526221871376038,
-0.21618710458278656,
0.06564495712518692,
-0.30848240852355957,
-0.30237314105033875,
0.6644978523254395,
-0.15845905244350433,
0.5768024325370789,
-0.16979646682739258,
-0.026309430599212646,
1.1317331790924072,
-0.6315080523490906,
0.9167190194129944,
-0.26600390672683716,
-0.08336348086595535,
-0.0014363317750394344,
-0.07235939800739288,
0.3282777965068817,
0.3097308278083801,
-0.06361515074968338,
0.13722997903823853,
0.24087847769260406,
-0.11374975740909576,
-0.4542781114578247,
0.38189488649368286,
-0.44023722410202026,
-0.33576497435569763,
-0.6423309445381165,
-0.5415093898773193,
-0.1762731671333313,
-0.0395238921046257,
-0.031100314110517502,
0.5828390717506409,
0.07866450399160385,
0.10176693648099899,
-0.21021577715873718,
-0.0614342987537384,
0.4600127339363098,
0.7563830018043518,
-0.605819821357727,
-0.5189645290374756,
1.1212046146392822,
0.12084107846021652,
-0.24319565296173096,
0.23617613315582275,
0.17717844247817993,
-0.32037535309791565,
-0.3445477783679962,
-0.27508673071861267,
0.07674262672662735,
-0.3007328510284424,
-0.4710324704647064,
-0.3052142262458801,
-0.26419350504875183,
-0.2143775075674057,
-0.14366020262241364,
-0.5590685606002808,
-0.6363998651504517,
-0.08931614458560944,
-0.5950855612754822,
0.7081866264343262,
0.8917620182037354,
-0.21347543597221375,
0.175131157040596,
-1.0453256368637085,
0.39761027693748474,
0.3734506666660309,
0.46032631397247314,
0.06967927515506744,
-0.1426934003829956,
-0.5941907167434692,
0.05300535261631012,
-0.2838101089000702,
-0.641769528388977,
0.6461862921714783,
-0.006934342905879021,
0.36067938804626465,
0.7262244820594788,
0.28055688738822937,
0.5902178883552551,
0.08782629668712616,
0.4912937879562378,
0.23620310425758362,
-0.839598536491394,
0.559000551700592,
-0.39850306510925293,
-0.1750544011592865,
0.49121466279029846,
0.4557986557483673,
-0.33456307649612427,
-0.668779730796814,
-0.6898950338363647,
-1.1839982271194458,
0.8521956205368042,
0.19169053435325623,
-0.22105205059051514,
0.08346202224493027,
0.34650635719299316,
0.4736776053905487,
0.3835945427417755,
-0.5637227296829224,
-0.26694148778915405,
-0.27333173155784607,
-0.12376674264669418,
-0.04015915468335152,
-0.4930514395236969,
0.011996183544397354,
-0.13341780006885529,
0.9399318099021912,
0.13539355993270874,
0.3009835481643677,
0.204660102725029,
0.22891947627067566,
-0.27084681391716003,
0.06820639222860336,
0.6211050748825073,
1.0869488716125488,
-0.7565015554428101,
-0.17244619131088257,
-0.21517790853977203,
-0.3532875180244446,
-0.3626812994480133,
0.5744857788085938,
0.09933026134967804,
0.0394526906311512,
0.33307915925979614,
0.6294797658920288,
0.6008638739585876,
-0.924079179763794,
0.6354327201843262,
-0.20731917023658752,
-0.393388032913208,
-0.5311594605445862,
0.07987145334482193,
0.07194874435663223,
0.6043118834495544,
0.9651983380317688,
0.2534221410751343,
0.3174913823604584,
-0.6470088362693787,
0.2505119740962982,
-0.03979424387216568,
-0.587507426738739,
-0.3031279742717743,
0.8947295546531677,
0.41596829891204834,
0.023553404957056046,
0.5605140328407288,
-0.3177860975265503,
-0.4749394953250885,
0.554702639579773,
0.40892934799194336,
0.8162184357643127,
-0.1392950862646103,
0.618953287601471,
0.1409318894147873,
0.04626764357089996,
-0.2679329514503479,
0.4914535582065582,
0.47931957244873047,
-0.8613048791885376,
-0.7930002212524414,
-0.47308027744293213,
-0.5798109173774719,
0.17708495259284973,
-0.8874233961105347,
0.26637911796569824,
-0.3807997703552246,
-0.10191582888364792,
0.6031208038330078,
0.004877620376646519,
-0.21285617351531982,
0.2469092160463333,
-0.10044723749160767,
0.8909323215484619,
-0.7840927243232727,
0.2789256274700165,
0.487747460603714,
-0.4120604395866394,
-0.6440321803092957,
-0.2458765208721161,
0.12995383143424988,
-0.7934779524803162,
0.7851681709289551,
0.12187029421329498,
-0.20660720765590668,
-0.24614806473255157,
-0.4841057062149048,
-0.5069573521614075,
0.8541229367256165,
0.30767375230789185,
-0.3655412793159485,
0.12270699441432953,
-0.3352941572666168,
-0.06692250072956085,
-0.8390796184539795,
-0.1956312656402588,
0.23763707280158997,
0.49962037801742554,
0.14916005730628967,
-0.42393743991851807,
-0.11105695366859436,
-0.5821947455406189,
-0.6214821934700012,
0.3811468780040741,
-0.6343348026275635,
0.7658570408821106,
-0.27968940138816833,
0.061965689063072205,
-0.36883285641670227,
0.7667507529258728,
0.14503692090511322,
0.7518676519393921,
0.6400390863418579,
-0.09036444872617722,
0.7173584699630737,
0.1502559930086136,
1.1672462224960327,
-0.623626172542572,
0.10686565190553665,
1.039351224899292,
-0.062297165393829346,
1.199326753616333,
0.2654823362827301,
-0.10026572644710541,
0.4937862753868103,
0.4600540101528168,
-0.42717668414115906,
0.24665629863739014,
-0.14864695072174072,
-0.19634312391281128,
-0.43181031942367554,
-0.20825251936912537,
-0.15281343460083008,
0.8371220827102661,
0.15708687901496887,
-0.3409338891506195,
0.0021042327862232924,
0.01998688466846943,
-0.044186610728502274,
-0.19793108105659485,
-0.4627830386161804,
0.4272303283214569,
0.07725159078836441,
-0.1198529452085495,
-0.4057655334472656,
0.364967405796051,
0.49694544076919556,
-0.9711251258850098,
-0.04367811605334282,
-0.09880783408880234,
-0.027544066309928894,
-0.17784985899925232,
-0.7047321200370789,
0.3345518112182617,
0.11722806841135025,
-0.18343095481395721,
-0.3028205931186676,
0.8351989388465881,
-0.3334589898586273,
-0.8678868412971497,
0.09100190550088882,
0.5702311992645264,
0.04781326279044151,
-0.12847256660461426,
-0.37383759021759033,
-0.5881444215774536,
0.21503420174121857,
-0.43086302280426025,
0.2835783362388611,
0.04561396315693855,
0.21330344676971436,
0.889615535736084,
0.9017159342765808,
0.11404219269752502,
-0.6004633903503418,
-0.17959138751029968,
0.5742638111114502,
-1.053613305091858,
-0.9203818440437317,
-0.7083602547645569,
0.2882057726383209,
-0.1793537735939026,
-0.40407347679138184,
0.6555210947990417,
0.9627317190170288,
0.10165061801671982,
-0.14103403687477112,
0.36417973041534424,
0.42026767134666443,
0.8437504768371582,
-0.5954223871231079,
0.8729556798934937,
-0.4310995042324066,
0.28777995705604553,
-0.2653931975364685,
-0.6241239309310913,
-0.17308194935321808,
0.38091525435447693,
-0.28049910068511963,
-0.2508561909198761,
0.5039647221565247,
0.3731561005115509,
-0.03105413168668747,
0.8178827166557312,
0.07195746898651123,
0.4051132798194885,
-0.032882917672395706,
-0.24406158924102783,
0.2901991307735443,
-0.31313246488571167,
0.7182756066322327,
-0.42455732822418213,
-0.21449801325798035,
-0.5566849708557129,
-1.0751641988754272,
-0.3924693167209625,
-0.5025050044059753,
-0.6643372774124146,
-0.06958215683698654,
-0.05301706865429878,
0.8348386883735657,
0.4183497726917267,
-0.6607593297958374,
-0.35851410031318665,
0.3362141251564026,
0.24815234541893005,
-0.4222916066646576,
-0.4074705243110657,
0.7086777687072754,
-0.14414472877979279,
-0.40320467948913574,
0.524071455001831,
0.5801860690116882,
0.13155242800712585,
-0.15479761362075806,
0.24112780392169952,
-0.0989079549908638,
0.07362876087427139,
0.6401748657226562,
0.4088875651359558,
-0.0017660522134974599,
-0.3717899024486542,
-0.017605198547244072,
0.3515321612358093,
-0.15166214108467102,
0.6014626026153564,
-0.4098852276802063,
0.07926677912473679,
0.47658929228782654,
0.17394131422042847,
0.22379259765148163,
0.20504719018936157,
1.1809126138687134,
-0.38146308064460754,
0.10561611503362656,
-0.2089453935623169,
0.3735002875328064,
-0.11466312408447266,
-0.6604380011558533,
0.4706723392009735,
-0.010496747680008411,
-0.2778209447860718,
-0.7228599786758423,
-0.49419328570365906,
-1.0762089490890503,
-0.3545823395252228,
0.5412850379943848,
0.14423683285713196,
-0.41549283266067505,
-0.018343577161431313,
-0.010227707214653492,
0.019540786743164062,
-0.7751006484031677,
0.6654666662216187,
0.5740803480148315,
-0.33472517132759094,
0.0875437781214714,
-1.0072489976882935,
0.2866761088371277,
0.007642707321792841,
-0.5414615273475647,
0.16118933260440826,
0.1502223163843155,
0.20446448028087616,
0.04731050506234169,
0.49801892042160034,
-0.1566675901412964,
0.6027899384498596,
0.07566118985414505,
-0.028008967638015747,
-0.4453020691871643,
-0.18827272951602936,
-0.009808650240302086,
0.37707972526550293,
-0.2169814556837082,
-0.5226336121559143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02615v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02615v1
|
Exploring the Limitations of Large Language Models in Compositional Relation Reasoning
| 2024-03-05T03:07:10 | 2024-03-05T03:07:10 |
Jinman Zhao, Xueyan Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present a comprehensive evaluation of large language models(LLMs)' ability
to reason about composition relations through a benchmark encompassing 1,500
test cases in English, designed to cover six distinct types of composition
relations: Positional, Comparative, Personal, Mathematical, Identity, and
Other. Acknowledging the significance of multilingual capabilities, we expanded
our assessment to include translations of these cases into Chinese, Japanese,
French, and Korean. Our Multilingual Composition Relation (MCR) benchmark aims
at investigating the robustness and adaptability of LLMs in handling
composition relation reasoning across diverse linguistic contexts.
|
[
-0.3389091193675995,
-0.5608783960342407,
0.9773805737495422,
0.5303632020950317,
-0.03498004004359245,
0.03210466355085373,
-0.4450583755970001,
-0.5392206311225891,
-0.2934337854385376,
0.5202941298484802,
-0.5904426574707031,
-0.4097498655319214,
-0.422676146030426,
0.44579577445983887,
-0.13194984197616577,
0.6482923030853271,
-0.4149617850780487,
0.39988139271736145,
-0.6586427092552185,
-0.4185918867588043,
-0.5457116365432739,
-0.7251369953155518,
-0.609682559967041,
-0.45926421880722046,
0.7030978202819824,
0.24471113085746765,
0.5858443975448608,
0.37546804547309875,
0.8366417288780212,
0.35872209072113037,
-0.13860465586185455,
0.24119062721729279,
-0.206073597073555,
0.20365822315216064,
-0.3570491373538971,
-0.6585347056388855,
-0.22790151834487915,
-0.04399572312831879,
0.9009186625480652,
0.9458383321762085,
0.08109965920448303,
0.13565194606781006,
-0.304182767868042,
0.6059849262237549,
-0.7993579506874084,
0.2554927170276642,
-0.6084586381912231,
-0.04357672855257988,
-0.09675698727369308,
0.1568291038274765,
-0.7210971713066101,
-0.07016624510288239,
-0.035368748009204865,
-0.33905166387557983,
-0.22097226977348328,
-0.17843176424503326,
0.6500542163848877,
0.1311577558517456,
-0.8470198512077332,
-0.1469404250383377,
-0.6971604228019714,
1.0204862356185913,
-0.6940422058105469,
0.6983045935630798,
0.35629788041114807,
0.6416342258453369,
-0.016538025811314583,
-0.65240478515625,
-0.47800445556640625,
-0.49045810103416443,
-0.20154230296611786,
0.1897125244140625,
0.15258677303791046,
-0.12851695716381073,
0.3591729402542114,
0.539601743221283,
-0.6519838571548462,
-0.08817233890295029,
-0.08977732062339783,
-0.1829156130552292,
0.8915676474571228,
0.4903886616230011,
0.5408309102058411,
-0.08016389608383179,
-0.2268361896276474,
0.012209989130496979,
-0.6418190002441406,
-0.13932862877845764,
0.20718209445476532,
0.17199937999248505,
-0.29447832703590393,
0.8124301433563232,
-0.003219127655029297,
0.7622471451759338,
-0.31927230954170227,
-0.5497191548347473,
0.013932814821600914,
-0.5610736608505249,
-0.17227217555046082,
-0.07540127635002136,
0.9124159216880798,
0.4349088966846466,
0.41718119382858276,
-0.2144099771976471,
-0.09463600814342499,
0.32284972071647644,
-0.19526292383670807,
-0.6714515686035156,
0.12707622349262238,
0.16510024666786194,
-0.3255816698074341,
0.3572539687156677,
0.13003285229206085,
-0.31308791041374207,
-0.16981881856918335,
-0.38068050146102905,
0.16016843914985657,
-0.3608376681804657,
-0.3152233362197876,
0.2970220148563385,
0.05281605198979378,
0.3579252362251282,
-0.04903974011540413,
-0.7059372663497925,
0.3180798590183258,
0.8923748731613159,
0.7416191101074219,
-0.501829981803894,
-0.698310375213623,
-0.05758772790431976,
0.4012922942638397,
-0.28435614705085754,
0.7671319842338562,
-0.6033470630645752,
-0.44134941697120667,
0.01885846070945263,
0.1438341736793518,
-0.45609769225120544,
-0.794249951839447,
0.6108812689781189,
-0.3076823055744171,
0.03228319063782692,
-0.5005314350128174,
-0.5637185573577881,
-0.06669355183839798,
0.557499885559082,
-0.798452615737915,
0.8087649941444397,
0.26486828923225403,
-0.5969758033752441,
0.0460677333176136,
-0.19527660310268402,
-0.7812694311141968,
-0.2240784615278244,
-0.27820321917533875,
-0.10404056310653687,
-0.017533738166093826,
0.03611348569393158,
0.5776416063308716,
-0.6115413904190063,
0.3663152754306793,
-0.48595133423805237,
-0.1172165498137474,
0.6812487840652466,
-0.13343656063079834,
0.7126844525337219,
0.3427630662918091,
0.06232982128858566,
0.10930568724870682,
-0.924622118473053,
-0.09915424138307571,
0.24657802283763885,
-0.39903613924980164,
-0.3116050660610199,
0.013478826731443405,
-0.15173254907131195,
0.4357474744319916,
0.34547683596611023,
-0.3360113501548767,
0.007011540699750185,
-0.1813497245311737,
0.44748109579086304,
0.32696133852005005,
0.04187007248401642,
0.36159616708755493,
-0.4265167713165283,
0.6575513482093811,
0.19303393363952637,
-0.057084713131189346,
-0.4469771087169647,
-0.2561156451702118,
-0.7826972603797913,
-0.17273373901844025,
0.1739107370376587,
0.5805585384368896,
-0.6381242275238037,
0.208091601729393,
-0.4965246021747589,
-0.4548293948173523,
-0.12888522446155548,
0.2324613481760025,
0.6100626587867737,
0.2647570073604584,
0.13497194647789001,
-0.03788357973098755,
-0.6127461194992065,
-0.9966559410095215,
-0.3447895050048828,
-0.13425792753696442,
0.06881687790155411,
0.28709083795547485,
0.6953545808792114,
-0.1824420839548111,
0.409809410572052,
-0.29926949739456177,
-0.11425941437482834,
-0.461378812789917,
-0.2887565791606903,
0.21861320734024048,
0.1821521520614624,
0.668883740901947,
-0.607880175113678,
-0.8477484583854675,
0.3470222055912018,
-0.7849032282829285,
-0.07453243434429169,
0.009732910431921482,
-0.20629829168319702,
0.09473995119333267,
0.5944255590438843,
-0.7472057342529297,
0.04817238450050354,
0.843703031539917,
-0.3521295189857483,
0.7266594767570496,
0.0913698822259903,
0.1659023016691208,
-1.1502512693405151,
-0.04201008751988411,
0.1053318977355957,
-0.19912175834178925,
-0.4128299355506897,
0.5197737812995911,
0.16057679057121277,
-0.07516413182020187,
-0.5001010894775391,
0.6559810638427734,
-0.5745992660522461,
-0.1193060427904129,
0.008270258083939552,
0.12631238996982574,
0.0013511269353330135,
0.17763714492321014,
0.09667515009641647,
0.7059110403060913,
0.3533354103565216,
-0.7615940570831299,
0.48805955052375793,
0.21188397705554962,
-0.48830124735832214,
0.9991835951805115,
-0.666612446308136,
-0.1628476083278656,
-0.019974322989583015,
0.2942851781845093,
-1.1620292663574219,
-0.35046160221099854,
-0.11050766706466675,
-0.26365727186203003,
0.23955488204956055,
-0.12049372494220734,
-0.5791444778442383,
-0.34171032905578613,
-0.037787020206451416,
0.538984477519989,
0.07282127439975739,
-0.39445871114730835,
0.8678034543991089,
0.08872108906507492,
-0.13434864580631256,
-0.4651317596435547,
-0.9441712498664856,
-0.010030539706349373,
-0.18826045095920563,
-0.8522477149963379,
0.21857155859470367,
-0.39337822794914246,
-0.7552060484886169,
-0.08283840119838715,
-0.07763589918613434,
-0.2896934151649475,
0.028071241453289986,
0.011322404257953167,
0.20261609554290771,
-0.4510192573070526,
0.00772845046594739,
-0.07704056054353714,
0.0657614916563034,
0.43314704298973083,
0.3326849341392517,
0.5402889847755432,
0.0027134958654642105,
-0.547944962978363,
-0.12027695029973984,
0.4463225305080414,
0.967417299747467,
-0.3121579885482788,
0.8354998826980591,
0.22982293367385864,
-0.35381072759628296,
-0.1536773145198822,
-0.6943767666816711,
0.11015721410512924,
-0.41035863757133484,
0.37350040674209595,
-0.9702317118644714,
-1.0037873983383179,
0.9640859961509705,
0.20512211322784424,
-0.22100220620632172,
0.6502355337142944,
0.654451847076416,
0.3639369010925293,
1.0809768438339233,
0.02008289471268654,
-0.24281147122383118,
-0.045067258179187775,
-0.07765007019042969,
0.13701824843883514,
-0.9380068778991699,
-0.2865249812602997,
-0.5153661370277405,
-0.14616365730762482,
-0.5959101319313049,
-0.3222530782222748,
0.21731184422969818,
-0.10723371058702469,
-0.448287695646286,
0.2839578688144684,
-0.10850603133440018,
0.6868399381637573,
0.01530423667281866,
-0.05205368623137474,
0.6344527006149292,
-0.37455838918685913,
-0.40007492899894714,
-0.286223441362381,
-0.36763519048690796,
-0.5003436207771301,
0.9022486805915833,
0.36274299025535583,
0.5108771920204163,
0.551466703414917,
0.3244474530220032,
-0.2952222526073456,
0.38885360956192017,
-1.0083907842636108,
0.711490273475647,
-0.23669421672821045,
-0.943996012210846,
-0.10220828652381897,
-0.7103469371795654,
-0.7760075330734253,
0.45827189087867737,
0.09069003909826279,
-0.7574524879455566,
-0.2023278921842575,
-0.399218887090683,
0.11734893172979355,
0.2841625213623047,
-0.5392550230026245,
0.8674401044845581,
-0.5222140550613403,
-0.3768587112426758,
0.05830998346209526,
-0.511895477771759,
0.8652748465538025,
-0.0771527960896492,
0.293949693441391,
-0.24715924263000488,
-0.07328689098358154,
0.5155187249183655,
-0.22167199850082397,
0.589048445224762,
0.28895705938339233,
-0.40265926718711853,
0.2263050377368927,
0.4022749364376068,
0.27456924319267273,
0.055837780237197876,
-0.2766711115837097,
0.019725637510418892,
0.23977474868297577,
-0.28215429186820984,
-0.49884819984436035,
0.8452590107917786,
-0.734218955039978,
-0.48007214069366455,
-0.4196324348449707,
-0.8537886142730713,
-0.5584351420402527,
0.2331182360649109,
0.13505913317203522,
-0.06726635992527008,
-0.3298952579498291,
0.30690887570381165,
0.3874135911464691,
-0.1627051830291748,
0.5002143383026123,
0.8417586088180542,
-0.5473445057868958,
-0.5521368980407715,
0.6818744540214539,
0.05262957885861397,
0.3667200803756714,
0.6244223117828369,
0.2351980209350586,
-0.44397979974746704,
-0.42962753772735596,
-0.25256097316741943,
0.5960426330566406,
-0.8890775442123413,
0.07229538261890411,
-0.5620114803314209,
-0.2763920724391937,
-0.40086549520492554,
0.053104598075151443,
-0.4662790894508362,
-0.12063077092170715,
-0.11848514527082443,
0.06917692720890045,
-0.2225029319524765,
0.6729283928871155,
0.4757446348667145,
0.12429226189851761,
-0.9019502401351929,
0.254983514547348,
0.28400719165802,
0.411836713552475,
0.11180108040571213,
-0.7266953587532043,
-0.13705860078334808,
-0.1914091557264328,
-0.35029226541519165,
-0.7368695735931396,
0.10495511442422867,
0.02020590752363205,
0.7445096373558044,
0.5008813738822937,
-0.2104180008172989,
0.7361770272254944,
-0.5682037472724915,
0.9210253357887268,
0.3213629722595215,
-1.0530939102172852,
0.17637836933135986,
-0.42879050970077515,
0.4384964406490326,
0.5211352109909058,
0.6649938225746155,
-0.5915594100952148,
-0.20867447555065155,
-0.3061676025390625,
-0.4883333444595337,
0.22851967811584473,
-0.08662586659193039,
0.24888542294502258,
-0.1418132483959198,
0.3587495982646942,
-0.04880889505147934,
0.05791182070970535,
-0.9762678146362305,
-0.36101216077804565,
0.3310597836971283,
-0.1401888132095337,
-0.4504866898059845,
-0.48252806067466736,
-0.07904377579689026,
-0.4684300124645233,
0.5419339537620544,
-0.04796254262328148,
-0.1141432672739029,
0.10064278542995453,
-0.14524422585964203,
-0.08191844820976257,
0.43810564279556274,
0.8875344395637512,
1.1368855237960815,
0.21061813831329346,
0.40505343675613403,
0.34490594267845154,
-0.06354758143424988,
0.47149360179901123,
0.14170801639556885,
0.1022203117609024,
-0.09303929656744003,
0.6673199534416199,
0.5516515374183655,
0.4983111321926117,
-0.8294186592102051,
0.4748513102531433,
0.018335144966840744,
-0.34618520736694336,
-0.2689109146595001,
-0.16356569528579712,
0.750706136226654,
0.14082758128643036,
0.036722492426633835,
-0.5878709554672241,
-0.046485140919685364,
-0.8575837016105652,
0.017331790179014206,
0.44664573669433594,
-0.234871044754982,
-0.2919653654098511,
0.6217312216758728,
-0.10913439840078354,
0.05979190394282341,
0.3726899325847626,
-0.1810225397348404,
-0.7041503190994263,
0.4754798114299774,
0.7542643547058105,
0.5846018195152283,
-0.5328555107116699,
0.0668533593416214,
0.47720110416412354,
0.4015897214412689,
-0.29919078946113586,
0.30647796392440796,
0.15302258729934692,
-0.9469816088676453,
-0.8859146237373352,
-0.49386948347091675,
-0.5842462182044983,
0.27728256583213806,
-0.6046852469444275,
0.13426963984966278,
-0.3370321989059448,
-0.038297075778245926,
0.17906183004379272,
-0.01457886304706335,
-0.46269941329956055,
0.1263854056596756,
0.12485034018754959,
0.8090214729309082,
-0.8901011347770691,
0.6848447322845459,
0.9865424036979675,
-0.4894660711288452,
-0.9601700305938721,
-0.33428192138671875,
-0.15075093507766724,
-0.5949975848197937,
0.8214244246482849,
0.2375860959291458,
-0.00761908246204257,
-0.3874114453792572,
-0.31350845098495483,
-0.7397997379302979,
0.8205247521400452,
0.7201595902442932,
-0.6616601943969727,
0.31544849276542664,
0.5170073509216309,
0.6013567447662354,
-0.4931652545928955,
0.1776147037744522,
0.8282344341278076,
0.759064793586731,
0.10100391507148743,
-1.1798511743545532,
0.09949140250682831,
-0.24704386293888092,
-0.04570221155881882,
0.22220031917095184,
-0.9810861349105835,
1.1334980726242065,
0.07870297133922577,
-0.22243160009384155,
0.2530392110347748,
0.5046923160552979,
0.3998181223869324,
0.5250935554504395,
0.22640590369701385,
0.9112810492515564,
0.42725732922554016,
-0.18265347182750702,
1.2951486110687256,
-0.2658235430717468,
0.16503170132637024,
1.3228169679641724,
-0.7597723603248596,
0.7813247442245483,
0.47454607486724854,
-0.649053692817688,
0.6275076270103455,
0.5638551115989685,
-0.023372860625386238,
0.10568497329950333,
0.3428191542625427,
-0.5505330562591553,
-0.46461501717567444,
-0.35444357991218567,
-0.40800368785858154,
0.5177517533302307,
0.20596493780612946,
-0.4937993288040161,
0.17525480687618256,
-0.32154008746147156,
0.18058080971240997,
0.4141099154949188,
-0.29315197467803955,
0.7017903923988342,
0.36850008368492126,
-1.0596102476119995,
0.4369605779647827,
0.15735656023025513,
0.3499734699726105,
-0.593964695930481,
0.23748183250427246,
-0.16630731523036957,
0.28197795152664185,
-0.19127477705478668,
-0.8304744958877563,
0.2704790532588959,
-0.32224658131599426,
-0.24654589593410492,
0.3180513381958008,
0.6497330069541931,
-0.5678314566612244,
-0.6662340760231018,
0.5005729794502258,
0.791096568107605,
0.00224689906463027,
-0.08812735974788666,
-0.5139424204826355,
0.4357489049434662,
-0.2539537847042084,
-0.18888850510120392,
0.33133625984191895,
0.4985227882862091,
-0.15298695862293243,
0.8372365236282349,
0.48400241136550903,
0.13378620147705078,
0.02396881766617298,
0.2579335868358612,
0.5528982281684875,
-0.7445928454399109,
-0.25392335653305054,
-1.102198839187622,
0.33170947432518005,
0.04443491995334625,
-0.1927889734506607,
0.9441478252410889,
0.7814337015151978,
0.9633657932281494,
-0.25553521513938904,
0.8611273169517517,
0.3241001069545746,
0.31995588541030884,
-0.5757405757904053,
0.25530919432640076,
-0.5120894312858582,
0.13293680548667908,
-0.2919541001319885,
-1.218058705329895,
-0.5585415363311768,
0.45461443066596985,
-0.43764904141426086,
0.2691710293292999,
1.1493650674819946,
0.4411470890045166,
-0.19489410519599915,
-0.1256711632013321,
0.6613637208938599,
0.13669326901435852,
0.17341476678848267,
0.8881233930587769,
1.1954413652420044,
-0.2795175015926361,
0.5559787750244141,
-0.337586373090744,
0.2679390013217926,
0.16367575526237488,
-1.021467685699463,
-1.3011852502822876,
-0.3902379870414734,
-0.29238659143447876,
-0.3838416039943695,
-0.39772409200668335,
0.7091112732887268,
0.4683215916156769,
-0.7798699736595154,
-0.579041600227356,
0.08397229015827179,
0.20026157796382904,
-0.06549479067325592,
-0.2665384113788605,
0.07165329903364182,
-0.09228245913982391,
-0.7394894957542419,
0.4112255871295929,
0.23860476911067963,
0.12318943440914154,
-0.5900070667266846,
-0.35272783041000366,
-0.15815995633602142,
0.2008523941040039,
0.9450362920761108,
0.08081045001745224,
-0.806536078453064,
-0.16123493015766144,
0.015476279892027378,
-0.19107913970947266,
-0.10662016272544861,
1.0836181640625,
0.010861292481422424,
0.38219085335731506,
0.5233343839645386,
0.6630817651748657,
0.44939860701560974,
-0.2312447428703308,
0.5426558256149292,
-0.6009758114814758,
0.18203231692314148,
0.028877785429358482,
0.7372841835021973,
0.5282852649688721,
-0.07130692899227142,
0.6695783734321594,
0.19122005999088287,
-0.6091169714927673,
-0.7542971968650818,
0.4256787598133087,
-1.1544266939163208,
-0.3275464177131653,
1.4013904333114624,
-0.333940327167511,
-0.10647052526473999,
0.09303908795118332,
-0.05756330490112305,
0.032842498272657394,
0.15398769080638885,
0.3706131875514984,
1.2031363248825073,
-0.0342402458190918,
-0.4106515049934387,
-0.6588070392608643,
0.037179406732320786,
0.2976076900959015,
-0.8864802718162537,
-0.03203819692134857,
0.5362539291381836,
0.3959333598613739,
0.14151905477046967,
0.455020546913147,
-0.2585020661354065,
0.2621345818042755,
-0.2023211568593979,
-0.21193037927150726,
0.1681249737739563,
-0.24552923440933228,
-0.033422913402318954,
0.042188920080661774,
0.3569876551628113,
0.2857266068458557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02586v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02586v1
|
Improving Event Definition Following For Zero-Shot Event Detection
| 2024-03-05T01:46:50 | 2024-03-05T01:46:50 |
Zefan Cai, Po-Nien Kung, Ashima Suvarna, Mingyu Derek Ma, Hritik Bansal, Baobao Chang, P. Jeffrey Brantingham, Wei Wang, Nanyun Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing approaches on zero-shot event detection usually train models on
datasets annotated with known event types, and prompt them with unseen event
definitions. These approaches yield sporadic successes, yet generally fall
short of expectations. In this work, we aim to improve zero-shot event
detection by training models to better follow event definitions. We hypothesize
that a diverse set of event types and definitions are the key for models to
learn to follow event definitions while existing event extraction datasets
focus on annotating many high-quality examples for a few event types. To verify
our hypothesis, we construct an automatically generated Diverse Event
Definition (DivED) dataset and conduct comparative studies. Our experiments
reveal that a large number of event types (200) and diverse event definitions
can significantly boost event extraction performance; on the other hand, the
performance does not scale with over ten examples per event type. Beyond
scaling, we incorporate event ontology information and hard-negative samples
during training, further boosting the performance. Based on these findings, we
fine-tuned a LLaMA-2-7B model on our DivED dataset, yielding performance that
surpasses SOTA large language models like GPT-3.5 across three open benchmarks
on zero-shot event detection.
|
[
-0.1781710982322693,
-0.3883375823497772,
0.6372051239013672,
-0.21257272362709045,
-0.6259927749633789,
0.15165001153945923,
-0.048814281821250916,
-0.9028477668762207,
0.1661718785762787,
0.23832525312900543,
-0.37316566705703735,
-0.7330901026725769,
-0.7636259198188782,
0.2713075876235962,
-0.3444082736968994,
1.1655857563018799,
-0.08878130465745926,
-0.3487228453159332,
0.2410842627286911,
-0.330471396446228,
-0.3923269212245941,
-0.24726901948451996,
-0.7429966926574707,
-0.33930906653404236,
0.5297346711158752,
0.5038527250289917,
0.24777323007583618,
0.9968017339706421,
0.5185437798500061,
-0.009419345296919346,
-0.14574341475963593,
0.0647640973329544,
-0.5770424604415894,
0.00007156414358178154,
-0.04830089583992958,
-0.5198326110839844,
-0.3430674970149994,
-0.09107550233602524,
0.495144784450531,
0.2933882176876068,
-0.020579416304826736,
0.3425506353378296,
-0.3810558617115021,
0.030721724033355713,
-1.0482524633407593,
0.23940908908843994,
-0.7538437247276306,
0.3614487051963806,
-0.4423604905605316,
-0.21516695618629456,
-0.23102140426635742,
0.13862326741218567,
-0.06891263276338577,
-0.6466023325920105,
0.42160534858703613,
-0.4175419509410858,
1.0074717998504639,
0.0240453090518713,
-0.36096248030662537,
0.06283850222826004,
-0.7493881583213806,
0.6095619201660156,
-0.6888615489006042,
0.25113701820373535,
0.28685498237609863,
0.24091704189777374,
0.06623052060604095,
-0.40402573347091675,
-0.6854985356330872,
0.003696857951581478,
0.37155961990356445,
0.1443961262702942,
-0.2300727218389511,
0.09647825360298157,
0.49045270681381226,
0.03910426050424576,
-0.4656669795513153,
0.499898225069046,
-0.13611173629760742,
-0.0632849633693695,
0.8616933226585388,
0.4470217227935791,
-0.03527115657925606,
-0.05304247885942459,
0.005888808518648148,
0.09717726707458496,
-0.9448128938674927,
0.010067557916045189,
0.2527201175689697,
0.4001098573207855,
-0.16042259335517883,
0.4672381281852722,
-0.8394017219543457,
0.5817569494247437,
-0.050059329718351364,
-0.34288862347602844,
0.3710068464279175,
-0.4579685926437378,
-0.11653758585453033,
0.03444709628820419,
0.32535919547080994,
0.42709454894065857,
0.4518563747406006,
-0.27561378479003906,
-0.09515703469514847,
0.11990955471992493,
-0.14403581619262695,
-1.1864497661590576,
-0.32238689064979553,
0.20904360711574554,
-0.4015914797782898,
-0.5465986132621765,
-0.27082958817481995,
-0.45080801844596863,
-0.5201087594032288,
-0.2687987983226776,
0.5757980346679688,
-0.3390367925167084,
-0.3614422082901001,
0.405383437871933,
-0.49828198552131653,
0.5342263579368591,
0.6045893430709839,
-0.6796756386756897,
-0.1287584751844406,
0.6575437784194946,
0.794549286365509,
-0.07900804281234741,
-0.006174143403768539,
-0.7135899066925049,
0.20128101110458374,
-0.4442834258079529,
1.0365097522735596,
-0.5743080377578735,
-0.24854937195777893,
-0.10899025201797485,
-0.18394631147384644,
0.2613051235675812,
-0.4313018321990967,
0.35473453998565674,
-0.36761677265167236,
0.08582945168018341,
-0.09411782771348953,
-0.7024385333061218,
-0.21416285634040833,
0.34140685200691223,
-0.302419513463974,
0.7916468381881714,
-0.14530140161514282,
-0.4916408658027649,
1.014859914779663,
-0.6861017346382141,
-0.5479499697685242,
0.5325864553451538,
-0.29993605613708496,
-0.6212986707687378,
0.34059932827949524,
0.17889852821826935,
0.5376805067062378,
0.07907921820878983,
0.06747538596391678,
-0.6680240631103516,
-0.4186142683029175,
-0.058838970959186554,
-0.08339450508356094,
0.6244584321975708,
-0.11354917287826538,
-0.31767696142196655,
-0.16166746616363525,
-1.2524067163467407,
-0.23261435329914093,
0.2190229296684265,
-0.29638269543647766,
-0.21287015080451965,
0.18202149868011475,
-0.05710437521338463,
0.11789735406637192,
-0.14227013289928436,
-0.8244757056236267,
0.35010409355163574,
-0.3539297580718994,
0.04319513216614723,
0.5069528818130493,
0.2715345323085785,
0.3146423399448395,
0.1090312972664833,
0.4822002351284027,
0.31579914689064026,
0.07730840891599655,
-0.5092949867248535,
-0.45253539085388184,
-0.5961743593215942,
-0.39748579263687134,
0.14663052558898926,
0.5951915979385376,
-0.6769108176231384,
0.4778607189655304,
-0.15808887779712677,
-0.519631564617157,
-0.2753138840198517,
0.15486471354961395,
0.19207754731178284,
0.7510260343551636,
0.4842587113380432,
-0.34788358211517334,
-0.8542324304580688,
-0.49407315254211426,
-0.21595385670661926,
-0.20022232830524445,
-0.22527383267879486,
0.07308457046747208,
0.59000563621521,
-0.1655997931957245,
0.9913175106048584,
-0.6285112500190735,
-0.348105788230896,
-0.31256622076034546,
0.2900806963443756,
0.26010963320732117,
0.05729818716645241,
0.6417028307914734,
-0.4492422342300415,
-0.4193153977394104,
0.26910656690597534,
-0.8048957586288452,
-0.12537306547164917,
-0.055666904896497726,
0.16285446286201477,
0.17468397319316864,
0.17087393999099731,
-0.1813611388206482,
0.9620886445045471,
-0.10926290601491928,
-0.41323286294937134,
0.5889057517051697,
0.40788766741752625,
-0.08938340842723846,
-0.9340294003486633,
-0.13919226825237274,
-0.08205563575029373,
-0.293449342250824,
-0.9422895908355713,
0.1886177659034729,
0.2223505973815918,
0.17474481463432312,
-0.7550260424613953,
0.5124712586402893,
-0.2015404999256134,
-0.10666927695274353,
-0.5569782257080078,
0.22038161754608154,
0.1095002293586731,
0.09963014721870422,
0.5275064706802368,
0.31102076172828674,
0.786107063293457,
-0.6334449052810669,
0.2926578223705292,
0.44733908772468567,
-0.3481496572494507,
0.4534814953804016,
-0.5642605423927307,
-0.04683955758810043,
-0.23293252289295197,
0.3287152945995331,
-0.962334930896759,
-0.18940101563930511,
0.10226810723543167,
-0.32816246151924133,
0.34398141503334045,
-0.5051143765449524,
-0.5051298141479492,
-0.17175033688545227,
-0.4567352533340454,
0.3409658968448639,
0.3586045503616333,
-0.5369646549224854,
0.3755587041378021,
0.03256281837821007,
0.19770532846450806,
-0.5871411561965942,
-0.5938807129859924,
0.25763100385665894,
-0.30088895559310913,
-0.2989889681339264,
0.23755982518196106,
0.19721175730228424,
0.0523909330368042,
-0.2769789397716522,
-0.25356563925743103,
-0.098524309694767,
0.22619786858558655,
0.09752077609300613,
0.4546438157558441,
-0.4429754316806793,
0.3909139931201935,
-0.24478565156459808,
-0.06090589240193367,
-0.45154377818107605,
-0.3057880699634552,
0.41319984197616577,
0.22146496176719666,
-0.17347721755504608,
-0.7758187055587769,
0.042290009558200836,
0.22503650188446045,
-0.11001512408256531,
0.7423458695411682,
0.8112314343452454,
-0.36010313034057617,
0.09708577394485474,
-0.5971506834030151,
-0.2552199959754944,
-0.35221976041793823,
0.342302143573761,
-0.4262472689151764,
-0.9918412566184998,
0.7902226448059082,
0.2258877009153366,
0.09493661671876907,
0.3361184298992157,
0.4615291953086853,
-0.2700074315071106,
0.6969447135925293,
0.7914896607398987,
-0.032197434455156326,
0.6379315853118896,
-0.2568996250629425,
0.13808117806911469,
-0.7844244241714478,
-0.02107488363981247,
-0.372984379529953,
-0.2564341723918915,
-0.49831700325012207,
-0.34342047572135925,
0.11400669813156128,
0.19283880293369293,
-0.09250593185424805,
0.6016154885292053,
-0.1001029759645462,
0.6935364603996277,
0.032113343477249146,
-0.03131004795432091,
0.4217044413089752,
-0.06747158616781235,
0.27557069063186646,
0.10941363126039505,
-0.6764783263206482,
-0.33045050501823425,
1.4538614749908447,
0.22433984279632568,
0.5456514954566956,
0.029593193903565407,
1.065617561340332,
0.078828364610672,
0.3412616550922394,
-0.7664064168930054,
0.17315304279327393,
-0.15108168125152588,
-0.7482829689979553,
-0.23727162182331085,
-0.28061044216156006,
-0.8899558782577515,
0.13725905120372772,
-0.28583261370658875,
-0.8387599587440491,
0.42999958992004395,
-0.0488620363175869,
-0.6497093439102173,
0.31555119156837463,
-0.3736394941806793,
0.6446490287780762,
0.2439006119966507,
-0.047387734055519104,
-0.027915727347135544,
-0.3643973767757416,
0.4242698848247528,
-0.15033921599388123,
-0.009894759394228458,
-0.6017652153968811,
-0.16701918840408325,
0.6164626479148865,
0.05145641788840294,
0.9884210228919983,
-0.030570531263947487,
-0.15684285759925842,
0.46990418434143066,
0.26964619755744934,
0.5310651659965515,
0.1793823391199112,
-0.06521179527044296,
0.3830953538417816,
0.041492532938718796,
-0.5461554527282715,
-0.2966652810573578,
0.07155373692512512,
-0.6610460877418518,
-0.1193922832608223,
-0.006319650914520025,
-0.24502582848072052,
0.040829848498106,
-0.09039998054504395,
0.5013454556465149,
0.6315785646438599,
-0.20136606693267822,
0.1403941661119461,
0.5263378620147705,
0.016812201589345932,
0.7514825463294983,
1.0653588771820068,
-0.14542639255523682,
-0.09415356069803238,
0.655143678188324,
0.27301645278930664,
0.18615083396434784,
0.43126538395881653,
-0.056845203042030334,
-0.3029954135417938,
-0.7387455105781555,
-0.4482521116733551,
0.050526466220617294,
-0.6298797726631165,
-0.6567091345787048,
-0.7646746635437012,
-0.14815010130405426,
-0.6886802911758423,
-0.01584872230887413,
-0.27854275703430176,
-0.7473725080490112,
-0.7229229807853699,
-0.4479571580886841,
0.4848191738128662,
0.3837087154388428,
-0.2079399973154068,
0.5970677137374878,
-0.7792272567749023,
0.48179003596305847,
-0.11162134259939194,
0.3655414581298828,
-0.1430346816778183,
-1.0015671253204346,
-0.17819306254386902,
-0.28992703557014465,
-0.4075039327144623,
-0.7820223569869995,
0.2760620713233948,
0.5708836913108826,
0.5570839047431946,
0.8790330290794373,
-0.08362072706222534,
0.7055750489234924,
-0.4606492519378662,
0.6142786145210266,
0.24194902181625366,
-0.8764510154724121,
0.9837002754211426,
-0.4002209007740021,
0.3888113498687744,
0.43271058797836304,
0.404202401638031,
-0.6124631762504578,
-0.30233919620513916,
-0.6934080123901367,
-0.5559779405593872,
0.7467836737632751,
0.15897253155708313,
0.23161275684833527,
-0.08955714106559753,
0.5980047583580017,
0.3201412856578827,
0.267117440700531,
-0.9082591533660889,
0.07395848631858826,
0.027152784168720245,
0.011931604705750942,
-0.23660650849342346,
-0.20123574137687683,
0.052788980305194855,
0.001574765658006072,
0.41754308342933655,
-0.3083236515522003,
-0.08639736473560333,
-0.01653287187218666,
-0.08979050815105438,
-0.20191077888011932,
0.06988485902547836,
0.5375121831893921,
0.6497104167938232,
-0.2992112636566162,
0.026855891570448875,
0.4377377927303314,
-0.5044256448745728,
0.1512724906206131,
-0.09657134860754013,
-0.38428783416748047,
-0.08716778457164764,
0.8704994320869446,
0.816693127155304,
-0.05664955824613571,
-0.7325833439826965,
0.39440566301345825,
-0.007015341427177191,
-0.19179953634738922,
-0.006528081372380257,
0.389912486076355,
-0.2625172734260559,
0.2949370741844177,
0.3966781795024872,
-0.3087320923805237,
0.2695814371109009,
-0.6454657912254333,
0.4084970951080322,
0.341575562953949,
-0.3752540647983551,
-0.5099416375160217,
0.3008211553096771,
0.2684255838394165,
-0.22002150118350983,
0.5180515646934509,
-0.5035004615783691,
-0.44729816913604736,
0.7463985681533813,
0.4411161541938782,
0.8270049095153809,
-0.06278813630342484,
0.28550928831100464,
0.3886549174785614,
0.35902145504951477,
0.17315009236335754,
0.4180860221385956,
-0.32478031516075134,
-1.1328918933868408,
-0.7769855856895447,
-0.7659675478935242,
-0.36859869956970215,
0.32709744572639465,
-0.5261045694351196,
0.6458093523979187,
-0.530890941619873,
-0.012680660001933575,
0.19107545912265778,
0.1389884054660797,
-0.7864763736724854,
0.020084857940673828,
0.5267891883850098,
1.0893945693969727,
-1.1545881032943726,
0.632868766784668,
0.39169251918792725,
-0.6519673466682434,
-0.5058923959732056,
-0.19166776537895203,
0.1567063182592392,
-0.6728708744049072,
0.5136191248893738,
0.30678674578666687,
0.3780471682548523,
-0.045912690460681915,
-0.47711092233657837,
-0.8480604290962219,
1.0490543842315674,
0.04467014968395233,
-0.621579647064209,
0.22537492215633392,
-0.0077704209834337234,
0.6898916363716125,
-0.5763665437698364,
0.37985721230506897,
0.7423303723335266,
0.3003627061843872,
0.34790414571762085,
-0.7521244883537292,
-0.33100205659866333,
0.3669298589229584,
-0.15276634693145752,
0.2973303496837616,
-0.28702807426452637,
0.423968106508255,
-0.2868187427520752,
-0.34482207894325256,
-0.0016090850112959743,
0.525172770023346,
0.14721843600273132,
0.7510488629341125,
0.03463621065020561,
0.8132073879241943,
0.4836462736129761,
0.006549463607370853,
0.9249271750450134,
0.17780393362045288,
0.40972408652305603,
1.2965141534805298,
-0.7260419130325317,
0.970853328704834,
0.05251016840338707,
-0.16179786622524261,
0.41903552412986755,
0.737423837184906,
-0.19074846804141998,
0.5460500121116638,
0.006289215758442879,
-0.3871300518512726,
-0.5901080369949341,
-0.1054336428642273,
-0.29468604922294617,
0.9406266212463379,
0.27354198694229126,
-0.1412268579006195,
-0.7982641458511353,
0.19433297216892242,
-0.10773475468158722,
-0.3708558678627014,
-0.5466635227203369,
0.9997280240058899,
-0.311053991317749,
-0.12271267920732498,
0.4016832113265991,
-0.02433825470507145,
0.5153428912162781,
-0.31780606508255005,
0.022937212139368057,
-0.3725390136241913,
0.06970974057912827,
-0.25468483567237854,
-0.8149592280387878,
0.33457446098327637,
0.09363508224487305,
-0.048308566212654114,
0.20646917819976807,
0.8984795808792114,
-0.26939475536346436,
-0.3856397867202759,
0.28261256217956543,
0.5494446754455566,
0.4219300448894501,
-0.2684912085533142,
-0.308830589056015,
0.1860412359237671,
-0.023287685588002205,
-0.05966437608003616,
0.29100239276885986,
0.5115442276000977,
-0.17901988327503204,
0.36165308952331543,
0.554527759552002,
0.05543258413672447,
0.21397031843662262,
0.06666872650384903,
0.5734154582023621,
-0.5483083128929138,
-0.28707361221313477,
-0.9462268948554993,
0.3964734971523285,
-0.15954940021038055,
-0.42373326420783997,
0.28382885456085205,
0.5941429734230042,
0.9952284693717957,
0.010369065217673779,
0.7432479858398438,
0.02223181538283825,
0.430881142616272,
-0.14510874450206757,
0.33432483673095703,
-0.33484628796577454,
-0.08810985833406448,
0.1249341368675232,
-0.7983637452125549,
-0.6554003357887268,
0.5356096029281616,
-0.2966499328613281,
-0.20431992411613464,
0.08416438102722168,
0.5470149517059326,
-0.11985404044389725,
-0.04511420428752899,
0.6679502129554749,
0.16426312923431396,
0.5946997404098511,
0.4995991289615631,
0.9206500053405762,
-0.542226254940033,
0.49585971236228943,
-0.028558535501360893,
-0.3587528467178345,
-0.7010396718978882,
-1.2715535163879395,
-0.8202726244926453,
-0.3387698531150818,
-0.7569243311882019,
0.041426993906497955,
0.07260573655366898,
0.5551398396492004,
0.9398516416549683,
-0.9254845380783081,
-0.012381995096802711,
0.022199269384145737,
0.07670184969902039,
-0.06708024442195892,
-0.21835775673389435,
-0.11863426864147186,
-0.48424798250198364,
-0.2742847502231598,
0.38004088401794434,
0.6379159688949585,
0.18657219409942627,
0.2667995095252991,
0.21997733414173126,
-0.3311493396759033,
0.231576606631279,
0.9500197172164917,
0.5594084858894348,
-0.4201675355434418,
-0.7176900506019592,
-0.2509291172027588,
0.1659451276063919,
0.09699034690856934,
0.46736884117126465,
-0.8581178784370422,
0.31942424178123474,
0.24018236994743347,
0.5218372941017151,
0.806199312210083,
-0.3001517653465271,
0.11397780478000641,
-0.9281392693519592,
0.24975131452083588,
0.23007729649543762,
0.12273154407739639,
0.21030639111995697,
-0.32805341482162476,
0.8353923559188843,
0.4316434860229492,
-0.16873015463352203,
-0.8784370422363281,
0.5086872577667236,
-0.8888434767723083,
-0.14458067715168,
1.1064060926437378,
-0.1511605978012085,
0.0989622175693512,
-0.2897171974182129,
0.08852185308933258,
0.28997802734375,
-0.1610749512910843,
0.9707678556442261,
0.6798564195632935,
-0.6314965486526489,
-0.13318480551242828,
-0.31137892603874207,
0.4149005711078644,
-0.07368127256631851,
-0.7276882529258728,
0.15586264431476593,
0.4679994583129883,
0.6404978036880493,
0.27241215109825134,
0.6330116391181946,
0.0775078684091568,
0.696002185344696,
-0.1450134515762329,
0.3897216320037842,
-0.02907450683414936,
-0.5414325594902039,
-0.7046036124229431,
0.10300720483064651,
-0.18954840302467346,
-0.3972046673297882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02574v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02574v1
|
ChatCite: LLM Agent with Human Workflow Guidance for Comparative Literature Summary
| 2024-03-05T01:13:56 | 2024-03-05T01:13:56 |
Yutong Li, Lu Chen, Aiwei Liu, Kai Yu, Lijie Wen
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
The literature review is an indispensable step in the research process. It
provides the benefit of comprehending the research problem and understanding
the current research situation while conducting a comparative analysis of prior
works. However, literature summary is challenging and time consuming. The
previous LLM-based studies on literature review mainly focused on the complete
process, including literature retrieval, screening, and summarization. However,
for the summarization step, simple CoT method often lacks the ability to
provide extensive comparative summary. In this work, we firstly focus on the
independent literature summarization step and introduce ChatCite, an LLM agent
with human workflow guidance for comparative literature summary. This agent, by
mimicking the human workflow, first extracts key elements from relevant
literature and then generates summaries using a Reflective Incremental
Mechanism. In order to better evaluate the quality of the generated summaries,
we devised a LLM-based automatic evaluation metric, G-Score, in refer to the
human evaluation criteria. The ChatCite agent outperformed other models in
various dimensions in the experiments. The literature summaries generated by
ChatCite can also be directly used for drafting literature reviews.
|
[
-0.26467424631118774,
-0.2126833200454712,
0.2359645813703537,
0.1831822246313095,
-0.3774765133857727,
0.42920076847076416,
-0.08643835783004761,
-0.43382275104522705,
0.34080770611763,
0.5078048706054688,
-0.5125138759613037,
-0.6764733195304871,
-0.08176050335168839,
0.4320929944515228,
-0.37481242418289185,
1.004282832145691,
0.03603513538837433,
0.19055378437042236,
-0.351017564535141,
0.019037356600165367,
-0.21097318828105927,
-0.43627801537513733,
-0.6382452845573425,
-0.8423887491226196,
0.6183527112007141,
0.154218390583992,
0.7301005125045776,
-0.30305805802345276,
0.678226113319397,
0.4089692234992981,
-0.3294812738895416,
0.5314215421676636,
-0.5552598834037781,
0.42280223965644836,
-0.08849508315324783,
-0.6858432292938232,
-0.5679810047149658,
-0.014511197805404663,
0.5426963567733765,
0.31322818994522095,
-0.1004360243678093,
0.27976757287979126,
0.49071377515792847,
0.992885947227478,
-0.3088885247707367,
0.2851744592189789,
-0.4404872953891754,
0.2396669089794159,
0.09686055779457092,
-0.47438371181488037,
-0.23941300809383392,
-0.6729316711425781,
-0.06964024156332016,
-0.4630160331726074,
0.4396178424358368,
0.23684532940387726,
0.8055799603462219,
0.16019538044929504,
-0.23796308040618896,
-0.42135339975357056,
-0.6362303495407104,
0.6370241045951843,
-0.5794249773025513,
-0.2880725562572479,
0.06606465578079224,
0.44227343797683716,
-0.2715003490447998,
-0.6475621461868286,
-0.32154369354248047,
-0.35752397775650024,
-0.4671168327331543,
0.3849228024482727,
0.11000864207744598,
0.1692226082086563,
-0.07866145670413971,
0.5145685076713562,
-0.6440005302429199,
-0.013751122169196606,
-0.5913206338882446,
-0.6376391649246216,
0.748994767665863,
0.6846978068351746,
0.14947369694709778,
-0.42278310656547546,
-0.43969711661338806,
-0.0232582688331604,
-0.6765927672386169,
0.17699742317199707,
0.4314609169960022,
0.11008784174919128,
0.08903349190950394,
0.49337896704673767,
-0.3482385277748108,
0.06637562811374664,
-0.22448739409446716,
-0.11043964326381683,
0.2947174608707428,
-0.4138754904270172,
-0.15671056509017944,
-0.0023411023430526257,
0.9374340772628784,
0.7996212244033813,
0.046662941575050354,
-0.05072209984064102,
-0.27892938256263733,
-0.29555198550224304,
0.3549261689186096,
-1.0231006145477295,
0.05338443070650101,
0.3450529873371124,
-0.8413112759590149,
-0.5405155420303345,
-0.269550621509552,
-0.7507322430610657,
-0.6754310131072998,
-0.4684080481529236,
0.21156282722949982,
-0.35448014736175537,
-0.09417910128831863,
-0.28326383233070374,
-0.03469487279653549,
0.5915224552154541,
0.7311981916427612,
-0.42010319232940674,
0.41196197271347046,
0.6354131102561951,
1.2192577123641968,
-0.4767330288887024,
-0.3252928555011749,
-0.2934231162071228,
-0.3366893529891968,
-0.3494512736797333,
1.232175350189209,
-0.29125335812568665,
-0.812373161315918,
0.06459925323724747,
-0.001904753502458334,
-0.11292142421007156,
-0.618901252746582,
0.6685188412666321,
-0.4941021502017975,
0.5258081555366516,
-0.15377488732337952,
-0.5162625908851624,
-0.3494844436645508,
0.4910832643508911,
-0.5802415609359741,
1.0288774967193604,
0.04213651269674301,
-0.9453358054161072,
0.06578606367111206,
-0.5210721492767334,
-0.11717308312654495,
0.04250342771410942,
-0.3234763741493225,
-0.5283981561660767,
-0.015663813799619675,
0.15202735364437103,
0.2626672387123108,
-0.6359691023826599,
0.018114600330591202,
-0.18894031643867493,
-0.7402625679969788,
0.1581614464521408,
-0.20162051916122437,
0.9835958480834961,
0.4934855103492737,
-0.019802942872047424,
0.44630691409111023,
-0.32486531138420105,
0.07045385241508484,
-0.051129017025232315,
-0.23541080951690674,
0.010056083090603352,
-0.1570345163345337,
-0.002300687599927187,
-0.03444284200668335,
0.11598733067512512,
-0.20164336264133453,
0.2586900293827057,
-0.2981177568435669,
0.04643428325653076,
0.483037531375885,
0.3277420997619629,
0.46000438928604126,
-0.931062638759613,
0.8263247013092041,
-0.46773338317871094,
0.22403940558433533,
-0.2860402464866638,
-0.5897470712661743,
-0.3900798261165619,
-0.26743578910827637,
0.520915150642395,
0.676616907119751,
-0.6486976742744446,
0.2413816601037979,
-0.11365430057048798,
-0.7029439806938171,
-0.6139910221099854,
0.28769969940185547,
0.5509447455406189,
0.3046824038028717,
-0.027232099324464798,
-0.4836602210998535,
-0.3508259952068329,
-0.6792099475860596,
-0.16895630955696106,
-0.4327862858772278,
0.005573359318077564,
0.1658795177936554,
0.5115125775337219,
-0.10913079977035522,
0.8131481409072876,
-0.5704909563064575,
-0.7996125221252441,
-0.5043197870254517,
0.375469833612442,
0.38561567664146423,
0.1251354068517685,
0.4685370922088623,
-0.5575737357139587,
-0.6052290201187134,
-0.05100583657622337,
-0.8038957715034485,
-0.31293338537216187,
-0.156229630112648,
-0.49871206283569336,
0.16235843300819397,
0.5258027911186218,
-0.4610113203525543,
0.49046793580055237,
0.14829549193382263,
-0.2572780251502991,
0.8505819439888,
-0.5205764174461365,
0.5838054418563843,
-0.9911170601844788,
0.1367555558681488,
-0.2599538564682007,
-0.2543032765388489,
-0.286525160074234,
-0.04284105822443962,
0.04680787771940231,
-0.15812048316001892,
-0.397976279258728,
0.522183358669281,
-0.5422340631484985,
-0.10421258211135864,
-0.49128904938697815,
0.19571690261363983,
0.36986014246940613,
0.5628098845481873,
0.011459065601229668,
0.8109594583511353,
0.3072487711906433,
-0.4768129587173462,
0.3100261688232422,
0.22345419228076935,
-0.30903908610343933,
0.5180779099464417,
-0.6622629761695862,
-0.1265062540769577,
-0.12957429885864258,
0.3808795213699341,
-1.0061386823654175,
0.014647546224296093,
0.25122639536857605,
-0.6539685726165771,
0.26929107308387756,
-0.21582713723182678,
-0.6974942088127136,
-0.0915025845170021,
-0.9361226558685303,
-0.06894375383853912,
0.6644834280014038,
-0.2343418300151825,
0.7466924786567688,
0.23573976755142212,
-0.3813319206237793,
-0.4068988859653473,
-0.4027717709541321,
0.036203451454639435,
-0.26099926233291626,
-0.500562310218811,
0.5790168642997742,
-0.26772576570510864,
-0.4559134840965271,
-0.10575000941753387,
0.14687004685401917,
0.04186169058084488,
-0.11344791948795319,
0.40761256217956543,
0.454731285572052,
-0.036084406077861786,
0.1329997181892395,
0.036363597959280014,
-0.15030443668365479,
0.2920435965061188,
0.3611968755722046,
0.2592354416847229,
-0.0750042200088501,
-0.33552250266075134,
-0.37587398290634155,
0.34089192748069763,
0.6070096492767334,
0.07107312232255936,
0.36072424054145813,
0.8013067245483398,
-0.0674421563744545,
0.015418276190757751,
-0.4287203252315521,
-0.07420124113559723,
-0.41739988327026367,
0.009013853967189789,
-0.12340814620256424,
-0.4187256097793579,
0.7464055418968201,
0.00897652842104435,
0.18236245214939117,
0.37900876998901367,
0.8765166401863098,
-0.22071094810962677,
0.7103629112243652,
0.3253231942653656,
-0.29853108525276184,
0.3828545808792114,
-0.358327716588974,
-0.2269018292427063,
-1.0194834470748901,
-0.3256816565990448,
-0.7121438384056091,
-0.32484355568885803,
-0.4782605767250061,
-0.5425218939781189,
0.44995439052581787,
-0.07805781066417694,
0.12442738562822342,
-0.01468193344771862,
-0.5740393996238708,
0.6463666558265686,
0.4865838289260864,
0.12084132432937622,
0.6551975011825562,
0.015676919370889664,
-0.4968462586402893,
0.25952574610710144,
-0.3152574896812439,
-0.8345844149589539,
1.0349611043930054,
0.010764841921627522,
0.8579645156860352,
-0.04540509730577469,
0.9995974898338318,
0.8358551263809204,
0.6218825578689575,
-0.6332111358642578,
0.6233872175216675,
0.3524039387702942,
-0.5640893578529358,
-0.20054996013641357,
-0.20785734057426453,
-1.2755060195922852,
0.9516978859901428,
-0.1467205286026001,
-0.6074990034103394,
-0.014942800626158714,
-0.06511297076940536,
-0.3155818581581116,
0.12084103375673294,
-0.81368488073349,
0.4495055377483368,
-0.16075575351715088,
-0.49501192569732666,
-0.33924010396003723,
-0.3779700696468353,
0.29969173669815063,
0.17559665441513062,
0.25206688046455383,
-0.34717050194740295,
-0.3189311921596527,
0.4120945632457733,
-0.5856552124023438,
0.9174728989601135,
-0.17356853187084198,
-0.07600000500679016,
0.6263015270233154,
0.2538543939590454,
0.45738571882247925,
0.11670412868261337,
-0.3562797009944916,
-0.1067388728260994,
0.07967454940080643,
-0.30643704533576965,
-0.5248498916625977,
0.6190049052238464,
-0.7106262445449829,
-0.5054224133491516,
-0.5402083396911621,
-0.24675536155700684,
-0.0946652814745903,
0.07560481131076813,
0.4345129430294037,
0.39065879583358765,
-0.32176095247268677,
-0.056581251323223114,
0.17606455087661743,
-0.2088293582201004,
0.5487739443778992,
0.5854586362838745,
-0.6043518781661987,
-0.5462493300437927,
0.5097090005874634,
-0.19287733733654022,
-0.08123952150344849,
0.48998895287513733,
0.10829386115074158,
-0.5324708819389343,
-0.6473949551582336,
-0.2539230287075043,
0.18705275654792786,
-0.692537784576416,
-0.3063153624534607,
-0.556687593460083,
-0.20948509871959686,
-0.28136441111564636,
-0.10111973434686661,
-0.011606529355049133,
-0.14335604012012482,
-0.14251215755939484,
0.2395971417427063,
0.1503460854291916,
0.7023256421089172,
0.09812527894973755,
0.06775481253862381,
-0.796718180179596,
0.36946579813957214,
0.1787545531988144,
0.16821101307868958,
0.14313142001628876,
-0.5918082594871521,
-0.2223326414823532,
-0.3451479375362396,
-0.6351823210716248,
-0.7794519066810608,
0.6106910705566406,
0.10971403121948242,
0.5382790565490723,
0.18652202188968658,
0.31185445189476013,
0.4395596385002136,
-0.19844114780426025,
0.736687958240509,
0.001994914375245571,
-0.45059654116630554,
0.3398955464363098,
-0.22033029794692993,
0.4867938160896301,
0.6874329447746277,
0.3236945867538452,
-0.21816928684711456,
-0.6016619205474854,
-0.36365291476249695,
-0.9352210760116577,
0.5647029280662537,
0.7646476626396179,
-0.03402891010046005,
0.42628660798072815,
-0.04218699783086777,
0.30004414916038513,
0.07101906090974808,
-0.5298766493797302,
-0.0795055478811264,
0.13423778116703033,
-0.009519594721496105,
0.005875991657376289,
-0.06345729529857635,
-0.18326888978481293,
0.09210892021656036,
0.7385354042053223,
-0.23290957510471344,
0.34660017490386963,
0.4928308427333832,
-0.5261356234550476,
0.19626666605472565,
0.3791646361351013,
0.3934638798236847,
0.5194037556648254,
-0.4761192202568054,
-0.1954132616519928,
0.23990820348262787,
-0.5785170197486877,
-0.017854277044534683,
0.07811101526021957,
-0.1789291799068451,
0.1749299019575119,
0.5000330805778503,
0.13817305862903595,
0.1121273934841156,
-0.691031277179718,
0.38860416412353516,
-0.6585875153541565,
-0.37954404950141907,
-0.5320343375205994,
0.2662857174873352,
0.07340985536575317,
0.6821954846382141,
0.3755844235420227,
0.059526726603507996,
0.5408259630203247,
-0.29090917110443115,
-0.19243410229682922,
0.15633514523506165,
-0.24376434087753296,
-0.10943924635648727,
0.3926781117916107,
0.4657436013221741,
-0.3117256462574005,
0.35467207431793213,
-0.4464997947216034,
-0.21361443400382996,
0.716702401638031,
0.0439138263463974,
1.074681282043457,
0.3286484181880951,
0.3095896542072296,
0.38383668661117554,
0.19572047889232635,
0.10573986172676086,
0.3987419903278351,
-0.3547308146953583,
-0.2766319215297699,
-0.46975716948509216,
-0.5237333178520203,
-0.9392931461334229,
-0.17917455732822418,
-0.6072669625282288,
0.32938945293426514,
-0.044415183365345,
-0.05239725857973099,
-0.14066243171691895,
0.38572174310684204,
-0.5957373380661011,
0.004017005208879709,
0.1204904317855835,
0.699980616569519,
-0.3823992908000946,
0.709496021270752,
0.6108226776123047,
-0.6627575159072876,
-0.4431810677051544,
0.09602826833724976,
0.2956659495830536,
-0.5533432960510254,
0.25805118680000305,
0.21558518707752228,
-0.4488590657711029,
-0.4426949918270111,
-0.11977893114089966,
-0.5463147759437561,
1.5637763738632202,
0.2509325444698334,
-0.3126124441623688,
0.07705139368772507,
-0.29128360748291016,
1.0098423957824707,
-0.5217521786689758,
1.0236413478851318,
0.190007284283638,
0.16816727817058563,
0.2895580530166626,
-0.7369949221611023,
0.072525754570961,
-0.5782960653305054,
-0.015467999503016472,
-0.03601947799324989,
-0.8029705286026001,
0.5713043212890625,
-0.29516279697418213,
-0.22140467166900635,
0.34048789739608765,
0.42708417773246765,
0.22839467227458954,
0.553734302520752,
0.41862067580223083,
0.007815761491656303,
0.8562588691711426,
0.2028632014989853,
1.093148946762085,
-0.24766109883785248,
0.3624880909919739,
1.2648506164550781,
-0.564572811126709,
0.6791321039199829,
-0.015648530796170235,
-0.42751145362854004,
0.7086771726608276,
0.8386987447738647,
0.09537474811077118,
0.28991585969924927,
0.22206909954547882,
-0.2915940284729004,
-0.01133241318166256,
0.018338674679398537,
-0.4461677670478821,
0.3462858498096466,
0.11488896608352661,
-0.49396175146102905,
-0.4557250440120697,
-0.4019469916820526,
-0.04082293435931206,
0.12324197590351105,
-0.4850803315639496,
0.9379940629005432,
0.01869317702949047,
-1.0232906341552734,
0.6662817597389221,
-0.1888018697500229,
0.5496001243591309,
-0.5546193718910217,
0.005830185487866402,
-0.6213131546974182,
0.13249005377292633,
-0.34695538878440857,
-0.7714903354644775,
0.2483431100845337,
0.24084003269672394,
-0.2169528752565384,
-0.2245745211839676,
0.9216271042823792,
-0.06985163688659668,
-0.31396937370300293,
0.31414759159088135,
0.6761239767074585,
0.5032402276992798,
-0.17917770147323608,
-0.8401843905448914,
-0.15758492052555084,
0.028883999213576317,
-0.3888639211654663,
0.4624531865119934,
0.5194944739341736,
-0.09012788534164429,
0.8310757875442505,
0.47361278533935547,
0.2286081165075302,
-0.18611356616020203,
0.4522612690925598,
0.8923484086990356,
-0.9131765961647034,
-0.5577459335327148,
-0.7899924516677856,
0.4587904214859009,
-0.477941632270813,
-0.15331456065177917,
0.39428454637527466,
0.700802743434906,
0.31557497382164,
-0.06632992625236511,
0.7908362150192261,
0.04307594895362854,
0.758933961391449,
-0.5048664808273315,
0.7955964803695679,
-0.3714020848274231,
0.5112845301628113,
-0.11335604637861252,
-0.9069294333457947,
-0.2771068215370178,
0.3063846826553345,
-0.12171497195959091,
-0.07462701201438904,
1.0460609197616577,
1.2038605213165283,
0.34319257736206055,
0.008938324637711048,
0.24582722783088684,
-0.15282860398292542,
0.25264838337898254,
0.19111433625221252,
0.9773082733154297,
-0.13680048286914825,
0.9857865571975708,
-0.07432335615158081,
-0.0866902694106102,
-0.4572924077510834,
-1.0130983591079712,
-1.1514780521392822,
-0.38553091883659363,
-0.2660948634147644,
-0.3758288621902466,
-0.1186082661151886,
1.0395222902297974,
0.6615196466445923,
-0.7288426160812378,
-0.48127269744873047,
0.24490587413311005,
0.471896767616272,
-0.1854858249425888,
-0.2660369873046875,
0.37108102440834045,
-0.8252854943275452,
-0.6696774363517761,
-0.03446202352643013,
0.36920350790023804,
-0.06160789728164673,
-0.42803630232810974,
-0.3173758089542389,
0.10610301792621613,
0.11744799464941025,
0.44716617465019226,
0.033586353063583374,
-0.4628000557422638,
0.47578054666519165,
-0.27336862683296204,
-0.32731154561042786,
0.1620902270078659,
1.033594012260437,
-0.7954040765762329,
0.5333108901977539,
0.7211498022079468,
0.28452160954475403,
0.5567309856414795,
0.004740072414278984,
0.6486907005310059,
-0.38126668334007263,
-0.08978469669818878,
0.29315224289894104,
0.5703076124191284,
0.18430574238300323,
-0.49815043807029724,
0.8575447797775269,
-0.02536519058048725,
-0.7820171117782593,
-0.5351454019546509,
-0.09733104705810547,
-0.9672142267227173,
-0.19529202580451965,
1.1045231819152832,
-0.26916658878326416,
-0.4218013286590576,
-0.08512972295284271,
-0.9528928995132446,
0.07524711638689041,
-0.7469280362129211,
1.1280105113983154,
0.5528613924980164,
-0.4885755479335785,
0.07393281906843185,
-0.35726597905158997,
0.354977011680603,
0.17414629459381104,
-1.084233283996582,
-0.22485677897930145,
0.418050616979599,
0.052185848355293274,
0.05016973614692688,
0.9032196402549744,
-0.38344940543174744,
0.27590397000312805,
0.07809635251760483,
0.20846135914325714,
0.03265794366598129,
0.2273973971605301,
-0.14290383458137512,
0.4036419093608856,
0.2900886535644531,
-0.28109976649284363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02567v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02567v2
|
Eliciting Better Multilingual Structured Reasoning from LLMs through Code
| 2024-03-05T00:48:56 | 2024-06-12T07:13:01 |
Bryan Li, Tamer Alkhouli, Daniele Bonadiman, Nikolaos Pappas, Saab Mansour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The development of large language models (LLM) has shown progress on
reasoning, though studies have largely considered either English or simple
reasoning tasks. To address this, we introduce a multilingual structured
reasoning and explanation dataset, termed xSTREET, that covers four tasks
across six languages. xSTREET exposes a gap in base LLM performance between
English and non-English reasoning tasks.
We then propose two methods to remedy this gap, building on the insight that
LLMs trained on code are better reasoners. First, at training time, we augment
a code dataset with multilingual comments using machine translation while
keeping program code as-is. Second, at inference time, we bridge the gap
between training and inference by employing a prompt structure that
incorporates step-by-step code primitives to derive new facts and find a
solution. Our methods show improved multilingual performance on xSTREET, most
notably on the scientific commonsense reasoning subtask. Furthermore, the
models show no regression on non-reasoning tasks, thus demonstrating our
techniques maintain general-purpose abilities.
|
[
-0.06528393924236298,
-0.42988792061805725,
0.6826414465904236,
0.1611597090959549,
-0.1878148913383484,
0.326628178358078,
-0.4979702830314636,
-0.4838607609272003,
0.12325314432382584,
0.2410653531551361,
-0.5728966593742371,
-0.5923586487770081,
-0.2806795835494995,
0.4259518086910248,
0.013878239318728447,
0.9308534264564514,
-0.20881663262844086,
0.19458742439746857,
-0.33863046765327454,
-0.15940892696380615,
-0.33419305086135864,
-0.7980633974075317,
-0.5082942247390747,
-0.5160697102546692,
0.7819030284881592,
0.45253264904022217,
0.6440427303314209,
0.5829315185546875,
0.11076470464468002,
0.27809786796569824,
-0.05867387726902962,
0.4691735506057739,
-0.22145435214042664,
0.040374644100666046,
-0.24821244180202484,
-0.6120865941047668,
-0.264191597700119,
-0.2640678584575653,
0.37062400579452515,
0.8188294768333435,
-0.047198738902807236,
-0.029026921838521957,
-0.044340044260025024,
0.33950677514076233,
-0.301107257604599,
0.5085322260856628,
-0.4769318997859955,
0.03346572816371918,
-0.04812324419617653,
-0.45749756693840027,
-0.4626588821411133,
-0.19374264776706696,
-0.23136959969997406,
-0.7095130681991577,
-0.03200661391019821,
0.11333593726158142,
0.6519294381141663,
0.26484596729278564,
-0.5825660824775696,
-0.12151326984167099,
-0.3953579068183899,
0.9401272535324097,
-0.6526102423667908,
0.736504077911377,
0.40099024772644043,
0.020425349473953247,
0.029216771945357323,
-0.514948308467865,
-0.3485271632671356,
-0.43807318806648254,
-0.29254069924354553,
0.04964134842157364,
-0.06678891181945801,
-0.17141669988632202,
0.3984898328781128,
0.20623119175434113,
-0.8976182341575623,
-0.02464788407087326,
-0.218471959233284,
-0.1387481987476349,
0.7170316576957703,
-0.13966377079486847,
0.2681048512458801,
-0.35819005966186523,
-0.26497966051101685,
0.027570893988013268,
-0.8311184048652649,
0.20052190124988556,
0.27195870876312256,
0.2775866389274597,
-0.19169273972511292,
0.5922977924346924,
-0.09055469930171967,
0.6263795495033264,
-0.28407707810401917,
-0.30213192105293274,
0.2746340036392212,
-0.42526212334632874,
-0.131085604429245,
0.15963947772979736,
0.3668237030506134,
0.35314229130744934,
0.44934675097465515,
-0.22843094170093536,
-0.18413494527339935,
0.20525062084197998,
-0.1399431675672531,
-0.5042642951011658,
-0.3985479176044464,
0.33138319849967957,
-0.3675013482570648,
0.05222700163722038,
-0.2640240788459778,
-0.20629575848579407,
-0.1404179036617279,
-0.5660068988800049,
-0.21506930887699127,
-0.4446631073951721,
-0.32197466492652893,
0.23931045830249786,
-0.12956760823726654,
0.17349427938461304,
0.2634047865867615,
-0.7020227909088135,
0.022755078971385956,
0.6103147268295288,
0.6682625412940979,
-0.13134124875068665,
-0.3152756989002228,
-0.5520187616348267,
0.24061144888401031,
-0.4991351366043091,
0.9703353643417358,
-0.589417576789856,
-0.21966685354709625,
-0.17420046031475067,
0.1388920247554779,
-0.2124125361442566,
-0.3176333010196686,
0.573162317276001,
-0.45425713062286377,
0.3499775826931,
-0.233404278755188,
-0.4140506982803345,
-0.2874976396560669,
0.6301319599151611,
-0.5510021448135376,
1.2769511938095093,
0.054536428302526474,
-0.7619374990463257,
0.3449346125125885,
-0.6796817183494568,
-0.6064810156822205,
0.07917553186416626,
-0.37118446826934814,
0.014338611625134945,
-0.029733365401625633,
0.6168888211250305,
0.3270415663719177,
0.025394098833203316,
0.3606369197368622,
-0.1628858745098114,
-0.23464027047157288,
0.24574878811836243,
-0.46980196237564087,
0.7386930584907532,
0.17004431784152985,
-0.1757533848285675,
0.2874300181865692,
-0.7719213962554932,
0.4188520014286041,
0.14515438675880432,
-0.6951340436935425,
-0.4282362461090088,
0.08066057413816452,
-0.10932110995054245,
0.3820604979991913,
-0.021120775490999222,
-0.5065166354179382,
0.3003256022930145,
-0.4312921166419983,
0.6148502230644226,
0.5149590969085693,
-0.2129557728767395,
0.3465685248374939,
-0.3230951726436615,
0.7624845504760742,
-0.14078210294246674,
-0.2377694994211197,
-0.5742784738540649,
-0.45438557863235474,
-0.46711593866348267,
-0.21161839365959167,
0.04050108790397644,
0.8303812742233276,
-0.9428769946098328,
-0.11459475010633469,
-0.32300418615341187,
0.05910121649503708,
-0.2717363238334656,
0.32361552119255066,
0.6209167242050171,
0.5212634205818176,
0.46513625979423523,
0.3119727075099945,
-0.8106706142425537,
-0.7697823643684387,
-0.20987679064273834,
-0.22190961241722107,
0.018231485038995743,
0.2824312746524811,
0.4642954170703888,
-0.010860670357942581,
0.5365957021713257,
-0.29547804594039917,
0.34931373596191406,
-0.620699405670166,
-0.24996504187583923,
0.4552007019519806,
0.29341790080070496,
0.28014856576919556,
-0.719942569732666,
-0.4099741578102112,
0.24400100111961365,
-0.8285555839538574,
-0.18807938694953918,
-0.2722908854484558,
-0.23805256187915802,
0.5049042701721191,
0.5862151384353638,
-0.49623677134513855,
0.0042768982239067554,
0.5558908581733704,
-0.24107351899147034,
0.7714603543281555,
-0.08390489220619202,
0.2617068886756897,
-1.0381048917770386,
-0.08376806229352951,
-0.015819348394870758,
-0.5437155365943909,
-0.3849737048149109,
0.3487791419029236,
0.1740266978740692,
0.009086919017136097,
-0.5278383493423462,
0.5967399477958679,
-0.7392759919166565,
0.060913942754268646,
0.05315103754401207,
0.23778627812862396,
0.4245329201221466,
0.6026415228843689,
0.3815758228302002,
0.9060178995132446,
0.5087363123893738,
-0.44827526807785034,
0.24519306421279907,
0.3300475776195526,
-0.5389600396156311,
0.4428406059741974,
-0.6035420298576355,
0.03680792078375816,
-0.03971842676401138,
0.32474687695503235,
-0.8484922647476196,
-0.2707870304584503,
-0.03683922812342644,
-0.32020580768585205,
0.18946419656276703,
-0.4058834910392761,
-0.4770152270793915,
-0.4910770356655121,
-0.17830172181129456,
0.33038148283958435,
0.22013422846794128,
-0.758604884147644,
0.326642245054245,
-0.028009822592139244,
-0.1813925802707672,
-0.6079275012016296,
-0.9105642437934875,
0.2975727319717407,
-0.32958605885505676,
-0.9351734519004822,
0.3405175805091858,
-0.10197003930807114,
-0.5910205245018005,
-0.12713798880577087,
-0.33440449833869934,
-0.16036264598369598,
0.11964651197195053,
-0.13903196156024933,
0.19894373416900635,
-0.46200644969940186,
0.30575263500213623,
0.0445975586771965,
-0.3455951511859894,
0.1953563243150711,
-0.6178423166275024,
0.2577148675918579,
-0.11484821140766144,
-0.5411869287490845,
-0.08006156980991364,
0.6894676685333252,
0.23792454600334167,
-0.37626639008522034,
0.42638519406318665,
0.2499588131904602,
-0.01765739545226097,
-0.3286714553833008,
-0.1817152500152588,
-0.09864925593137741,
-0.398504376411438,
0.3177505135536194,
-0.7248718738555908,
-0.8749344944953918,
0.3390009105205536,
-0.003726260969415307,
0.24222786724567413,
0.0010954682948067784,
0.5827549695968628,
-0.0923461988568306,
1.4263054132461548,
0.42373138666152954,
0.29910534620285034,
0.25782474875450134,
-0.359643816947937,
0.3487638533115387,
-0.5683054327964783,
-0.3057449460029602,
-0.31890156865119934,
-0.07995014637708664,
-0.31655171513557434,
-0.6592873334884644,
0.21810133755207062,
0.26290327310562134,
-0.19485093653202057,
0.11270633339881897,
-0.476470023393631,
0.8116354942321777,
0.6226698756217957,
0.01524531189352274,
0.5321962833404541,
0.037017304450273514,
-0.44799113273620605,
0.06306420266628265,
-1.0074468851089478,
-0.7160357236862183,
0.701280415058136,
0.07541187852621078,
0.7034959197044373,
0.267294317483902,
0.7031329870223999,
-0.030429188162088394,
0.177736297249794,
-0.6502532362937927,
0.365238755941391,
0.010517658665776253,
-0.4204012155532837,
0.08607509732246399,
-0.4201015532016754,
-0.8888400793075562,
0.438498854637146,
0.2032153606414795,
-0.6796072125434875,
-0.13114425539970398,
0.20606306195259094,
-0.26759421825408936,
0.2508964240550995,
-0.8045255541801453,
0.8785766363143921,
-0.5424196720123291,
-0.41283971071243286,
-0.14683866500854492,
-0.6020599007606506,
0.5799210667610168,
0.09456925094127655,
0.5750178694725037,
-0.18026921153068542,
0.08454656600952148,
0.40001991391181946,
-0.5477725863456726,
0.7957942485809326,
-0.08522424101829529,
-0.3872068226337433,
0.13846318423748016,
0.03832435607910156,
0.5659348368644714,
0.3612470328807831,
-0.29646310210227966,
0.10671079158782959,
0.12225189805030823,
-0.5792784094810486,
-0.7292843461036682,
0.6009634137153625,
-0.4973486661911011,
-0.7910798788070679,
-0.16749313473701477,
-0.9829779863357544,
-0.2874141335487366,
-0.025927484035491943,
0.14719735085964203,
0.4921874403953552,
0.13875284790992737,
-0.09280643612146378,
0.5433196425437927,
-0.13752469420433044,
0.38764283061027527,
0.538115918636322,
-0.2777440547943115,
-0.19412314891815186,
0.5352892875671387,
-0.04865146055817604,
0.271891325712204,
0.6104878783226013,
0.309546560049057,
-0.6530458927154541,
-0.44585585594177246,
-0.7826036810874939,
0.10175102949142456,
-1.0200259685516357,
-0.2003396600484848,
-0.6530239582061768,
0.20237790048122406,
-0.3169706463813782,
-0.2783183157444,
0.1164710521697998,
-0.7901931405067444,
0.172781839966774,
-0.45152607560157776,
0.5303309559822083,
0.4993976652622223,
-0.15595731139183044,
0.06752839684486389,
-0.9103662371635437,
0.269119530916214,
-0.04974764212965965,
0.16290798783302307,
-0.1307377815246582,
-0.48758232593536377,
-0.4786547124385834,
0.13210967183113098,
0.09713289886713028,
-0.9639157652854919,
0.3029830753803253,
0.21796369552612305,
0.7745962738990784,
0.2677749693393707,
-0.10571081936359406,
0.9005458950996399,
-0.559669554233551,
0.6772911548614502,
0.07088631391525269,
-0.8585789799690247,
0.5924142003059387,
-0.3030945956707001,
0.2959956228733063,
0.17124804854393005,
0.3003045916557312,
-0.6600884199142456,
-0.4550611674785614,
-0.33734405040740967,
-0.7733833193778992,
0.6215940713882446,
-0.04251525551080704,
0.1812293976545334,
-0.38142096996307373,
0.19598910212516785,
0.15223169326782227,
-0.038220666348934174,
-0.9680346250534058,
-0.12196140736341476,
-0.3186972141265869,
-0.10051724314689636,
-0.01955585740506649,
-0.015623199753463268,
-0.18638718128204346,
-0.432380735874176,
0.7219752073287964,
-0.607723593711853,
-0.06409373134374619,
0.20656174421310425,
-0.49780726432800293,
0.15380294620990753,
0.5313655734062195,
0.5210900902748108,
0.8012633919715881,
0.2132403701543808,
0.4655609726905823,
0.29045015573501587,
0.062183819711208344,
0.2941721975803375,
0.2073950469493866,
0.04505884274840355,
0.04337853565812111,
0.8485566973686218,
0.7567093968391418,
0.5181047320365906,
-0.8236992359161377,
0.26282891631126404,
0.005532740615308285,
-0.319904625415802,
-0.13614146411418915,
0.03394888713955879,
0.3455040454864502,
0.4632343649864197,
0.20235157012939453,
-0.0905136689543724,
-0.13777533173561096,
-0.3501597046852112,
0.3131113648414612,
0.28152596950531006,
0.007333970163017511,
-0.22173626720905304,
0.6756905317306519,
0.0871632844209671,
-0.15409134328365326,
0.5784314870834351,
-0.3891705274581909,
-0.71685791015625,
0.6466123461723328,
0.7546905279159546,
0.39592045545578003,
-0.03479250892996788,
0.23885120451450348,
0.3853231966495514,
0.3070608079433441,
0.005577374715358019,
0.6812620759010315,
-0.3837372958660126,
-0.7459229826927185,
-1.2456315755844116,
-0.40695416927337646,
-0.38129115104675293,
-0.19698664546012878,
-0.4711930751800537,
0.10956539958715439,
-0.06759040057659149,
0.30177316069602966,
-0.08258157968521118,
0.11048916727304459,
-0.40236908197402954,
0.00225798599421978,
0.3973137438297272,
1.2244988679885864,
-0.8561367988586426,
1.0564647912979126,
0.9532437324523926,
-0.454291433095932,
-1.1929630041122437,
-0.39762061834335327,
0.021447621285915375,
-1.0105981826782227,
0.7688214778900146,
0.28576454520225525,
-0.06698767840862274,
-0.04645200073719025,
-0.504643976688385,
-1.0046387910842896,
0.6782350540161133,
0.5556859970092773,
-0.6217347979545593,
0.08350197225809097,
-0.030885955318808556,
0.3067704141139984,
-0.2652776539325714,
0.3461748957633972,
0.6051757335662842,
0.7824674844741821,
0.07584985345602036,
-0.6450857520103455,
-0.032175544649362564,
-0.5485633015632629,
-0.1974506825208664,
0.17238454520702362,
-0.15543095767498016,
0.7057725787162781,
-0.6696091294288635,
-0.19568170607089996,
-0.042519617825746536,
0.5136146545410156,
0.6627015471458435,
0.2100929170846939,
0.409279465675354,
0.4816263020038605,
1.2637746334075928,
-0.017711836844682693,
1.4482542276382446,
-0.48908939957618713,
0.054837021976709366,
1.3308026790618896,
-0.5537316799163818,
0.5826995968818665,
0.5042248368263245,
-0.15076766908168793,
0.9396065473556519,
0.8903787136077881,
0.06787630170583725,
0.23908093571662903,
0.1485683023929596,
-0.2702166736125946,
-0.6226444840431213,
-0.09545987099409103,
-0.17179100215435028,
0.3436702489852905,
0.26394981145858765,
-0.1845298856496811,
-0.39244943857192993,
0.17208845913410187,
0.31877845525741577,
0.24560031294822693,
-0.2516798973083496,
0.6336885690689087,
0.10269101709127426,
-0.8676810264587402,
0.8359073996543884,
0.0225500650703907,
0.44519370794296265,
-0.6079094409942627,
-0.17645810544490814,
-0.4342930018901825,
0.16294412314891815,
-0.5249943137168884,
-0.9288324117660522,
0.51567143201828,
0.16233570873737335,
-0.47563305497169495,
-0.5394695997238159,
0.3941233456134796,
-0.6486729979515076,
-0.6209191083908081,
0.4537447392940521,
0.8150222897529602,
0.5443959832191467,
-0.04423876106739044,
-0.8914206027984619,
-0.11137204617261887,
0.20180025696754456,
-0.27402034401893616,
-0.048038989305496216,
0.5975318551063538,
-0.7081378698348999,
0.6750717759132385,
0.9345065951347351,
0.10331153124570847,
0.20764213800430298,
0.5732974410057068,
0.8506187796592712,
-0.5837658643722534,
-0.5770725011825562,
-0.9364391565322876,
0.5705207586288452,
-0.03070942312479019,
-0.020669247955083847,
1.043552041053772,
0.741393506526947,
0.9143674969673157,
0.10137126594781876,
0.8641127943992615,
0.04742281511425972,
0.5212664008140564,
-0.8198023438453674,
0.16688215732574463,
-0.5646593570709229,
0.468147337436676,
0.06717569380998611,
-0.7730904817581177,
-0.5024780035018921,
0.801473081111908,
-0.34852704405784607,
0.04005679115653038,
1.0511120557785034,
0.91069096326828,
-0.2270108312368393,
-0.04141044616699219,
0.4011184573173523,
0.2421991229057312,
0.37467384338378906,
0.7698163986206055,
1.1249966621398926,
-0.023238250985741615,
0.7194392085075378,
-0.1759912669658661,
-0.05895377695560455,
0.1761961281299591,
-1.05953049659729,
-0.9099757075309753,
-0.13844744861125946,
-0.40601691603660583,
-0.27466776967048645,
-0.03217868134379387,
1.0720040798187256,
0.9343470335006714,
-0.86189204454422,
-0.13887405395507812,
-0.13077425956726074,
0.6218172311782837,
-0.44435903429985046,
-0.22149746119976044,
0.3088943660259247,
-0.6465430855751038,
-0.6392698884010315,
0.8712705969810486,
0.22825460135936737,
-0.3381652534008026,
-0.17158178985118866,
-0.39546334743499756,
-0.15819500386714935,
0.11219611018896103,
0.8609722852706909,
0.1578017622232437,
-0.7954331636428833,
-0.22631007432937622,
0.22082042694091797,
0.12229770421981812,
0.4164484441280365,
1.1259106397628784,
-0.8977156281471252,
0.06181039288640022,
0.466521680355072,
0.31092557311058044,
0.38681647181510925,
0.0585564561188221,
0.576081395149231,
-1.0327807664871216,
0.2696016728878021,
0.11906523257493973,
0.7798248529434204,
0.5311121344566345,
-0.2945311665534973,
0.7155177593231201,
0.03604387119412422,
-0.38035374879837036,
-0.7400941252708435,
0.27000460028648376,
-0.6955497860908508,
-0.5826442241668701,
1.3335788249969482,
-0.41498082876205444,
-0.32940414547920227,
-0.5836549401283264,
-0.26940107345581055,
0.011760551482439041,
-0.31348639726638794,
0.3105783462524414,
0.537356972694397,
-0.3407755494117737,
-0.4627063572406769,
-0.5617159008979797,
0.3040308654308319,
0.4280736446380615,
-1.0137073993682861,
0.30924537777900696,
0.5798844695091248,
0.2559029757976532,
0.04809204116463661,
0.6801712512969971,
-0.018332690000534058,
0.36941835284233093,
-0.06826542317867279,
0.045062076300382614,
-0.24005886912345886,
-0.4003383219242096,
-0.30909401178359985,
0.017744744196534157,
0.10793992131948471,
0.19572791457176208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02563v1
|
Systemic Biases in Sign Language AI Research: A Deaf-Led Call to Reevaluate Research Agendas
| 2024-03-05T00:37:36 | 2024-03-05T00:37:36 |
Aashaka Desai, Maartje De Meulder, Julie A. Hochgesang, Annemarie Kocab, Alex X. Lu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Growing research in sign language recognition, generation, and translation AI
has been accompanied by calls for ethical development of such technologies.
While these works are crucial to helping individual researchers do better,
there is a notable lack of discussion of systemic biases or analysis of
rhetoric that shape the research questions and methods in the field, especially
as it remains dominated by hearing non-signing researchers. Therefore, we
conduct a systematic review of 101 recent papers in sign language AI. Our
analysis identifies significant biases in the current state of sign language AI
research, including an overfocus on addressing perceived communication
barriers, a lack of use of representative datasets, use of annotations lacking
linguistic foundations, and development of methods that build on flawed models.
We take the position that the field lacks meaningful input from Deaf
stakeholders, and is instead driven by what decisions are the most convenient
or perceived as important to hearing researchers. We end with a call to action:
the field must make space for Deaf researchers to lead the conversation in sign
language AI.
|
[
-0.15287944674491882,
-0.12873433530330658,
0.3428332507610321,
0.15383361279964447,
-0.06905096769332886,
0.20647452771663666,
0.12107957154512405,
-0.9086978435516357,
0.41234689950942993,
0.5014026165008545,
-0.28735294938087463,
-0.2482900768518448,
-1.010284185409546,
0.19644039869308472,
-0.3576942980289459,
0.7234490513801575,
-0.13230082392692566,
0.4944036602973938,
0.07893741875886917,
-0.5335496664047241,
-0.4708237946033478,
-0.17887930572032928,
-0.628649890422821,
-0.08274256438016891,
0.18798355758190155,
0.23386834561824799,
0.4724977910518646,
0.237121120095253,
0.3974277675151825,
0.20474520325660706,
-0.2779790759086609,
-0.11754434555768967,
-0.15170571208000183,
0.3645886778831482,
0.24200032651424408,
-0.36640986800193787,
-0.6750015616416931,
0.3163171708583832,
0.6041112542152405,
0.8647578358650208,
0.5343972444534302,
0.39382442831993103,
-0.2432604283094406,
0.5866155624389648,
-0.264093816280365,
0.1033056229352951,
-0.2255394160747528,
0.22094714641571045,
-0.4078482985496521,
0.12111014127731323,
-0.2840236723423004,
-0.48478183150291443,
0.20740924775600433,
-0.609199047088623,
0.2892216444015503,
0.1862124502658844,
0.2294003963470459,
0.31478431820869446,
-0.3386271595954895,
-0.3351099491119385,
-0.8257009387016296,
0.7857121825218201,
-0.8028263449668884,
0.643599271774292,
0.39736488461494446,
-0.15097995102405548,
0.0007338071591220796,
-0.4780748188495636,
-0.31727951765060425,
-0.27258947491645813,
0.15708503127098083,
-0.06652700901031494,
-0.010707330889999866,
0.12172520905733109,
0.5544347763061523,
0.09983160346746445,
-0.2105407863855362,
0.08264505118131638,
-0.7655349969863892,
-0.21689346432685852,
0.6660022139549255,
-0.08096205443143845,
0.5873242020606995,
0.08945531398057938,
-0.08685361593961716,
-0.03949737176299095,
-0.6477071046829224,
-0.15414035320281982,
0.3092762231826782,
0.3807305693626404,
-0.0340360626578331,
0.5783752202987671,
-0.21158167719841003,
0.6316682696342468,
-0.022577261552214622,
-0.07668297737836838,
0.33390477299690247,
-0.3215627670288086,
0.11629805713891983,
0.21407738327980042,
0.585095226764679,
0.3047756552696228,
0.15736451745033264,
-0.010132675990462303,
-0.1790202409029007,
0.083136186003685,
0.14929461479187012,
-0.37547779083251953,
0.3450891673564911,
0.3140377104282379,
-0.4994140565395355,
-0.12563644349575043,
0.0027093724347651005,
-0.5969280004501343,
-0.6008011698722839,
-0.2780759334564209,
-0.2379905730485916,
-0.061083629727363586,
-0.48750805854797363,
-0.173378586769104,
-0.49834203720092773,
0.4199106693267822,
0.368325412273407,
-0.6110106706619263,
0.09528722614049911,
0.7242083549499512,
0.8895028233528137,
0.14211107790470123,
-0.19778048992156982,
-0.23966246843338013,
-0.13243311643600464,
-0.4865604043006897,
0.6192408800125122,
-0.7254028916358948,
-0.7407177686691284,
-0.008133448660373688,
-0.29365870356559753,
-0.007148128468543291,
-0.3240872919559479,
0.6480919718742371,
-0.20390741527080536,
0.45306649804115295,
-0.4048694670200348,
-0.2679367959499359,
0.1778014749288559,
-0.048032764345407486,
-0.5448129177093506,
0.6131225228309631,
-0.09107820689678192,
-0.5616623163223267,
0.8590900897979736,
-0.6999069452285767,
-0.7198774218559265,
0.14637373387813568,
-0.6349328756332397,
-0.5585895776748657,
0.3815873861312866,
0.15169496834278107,
-0.15662378072738647,
-0.329998254776001,
0.3861861526966095,
-0.23101311922073364,
-0.2905457317829132,
0.12610526382923126,
-0.3642379641532898,
1.263055682182312,
0.14206822216510773,
-1.0654892921447754,
0.18970443308353424,
-0.6650192141532898,
-0.08671831339597702,
-0.2397802472114563,
-0.00823616050183773,
-0.41629037261009216,
-0.1481458991765976,
0.09004446864128113,
0.21158738434314728,
-0.15343429148197174,
-0.6877642869949341,
-0.2762226164340973,
-0.30687323212623596,
0.53449547290802,
0.7544732093811035,
-0.3919546604156494,
0.7084710001945496,
-0.23034414649009705,
0.6791720986366272,
-0.29982760548591614,
0.607344925403595,
0.145626038312912,
-0.7930147647857666,
-0.5322733521461487,
-0.04392368346452713,
0.07089556008577347,
0.16048815846443176,
-0.14079855382442474,
0.38328301906585693,
0.05974723771214485,
-0.15995779633522034,
-1.0277096033096313,
-0.2657933533191681,
0.5383377075195312,
0.5044030547142029,
0.1475857049226761,
-0.7357732653617859,
-0.43453535437583923,
-0.804946780204773,
-0.33146679401397705,
-0.6346348524093628,
0.12463247776031494,
0.16199465095996857,
0.4329463839530945,
-0.014606492593884468,
0.9268102645874023,
0.2760379910469055,
-0.7299520373344421,
0.1878744512796402,
0.18449220061302185,
-0.2762446105480194,
0.5444415807723999,
0.2770104706287384,
-0.8477787375450134,
-0.3159875273704529,
-0.1789405196905136,
-0.8060332536697388,
-0.2117106020450592,
-0.08398319780826569,
0.19099298119544983,
0.06171867251396179,
0.6284521222114563,
-0.6588084697723389,
0.4272272288799286,
0.42751452326774597,
-0.5991939306259155,
0.45566123723983765,
0.4946427047252655,
0.24373427033424377,
-0.5411370396614075,
0.49112316966056824,
-0.14504802227020264,
0.21775151789188385,
-0.6509092450141907,
-0.05756918340921402,
-0.28382033109664917,
-0.22391612827777863,
-0.1411125212907791,
0.7511789798736572,
-1.0398372411727905,
-0.4345507323741913,
-0.5624074339866638,
0.31233441829681396,
-0.172532856464386,
-0.1118120476603508,
0.04194660112261772,
0.6274429559707642,
0.7926855683326721,
-0.332550585269928,
0.06541283428668976,
0.5148392915725708,
-0.323508620262146,
0.6239074468612671,
-0.7433431148529053,
0.06752359122037888,
0.003803693223744631,
0.6496554017066956,
-0.7260145545005798,
0.20640723407268524,
0.7144737243652344,
-0.7937957644462585,
0.11470574885606766,
-0.06307903677225113,
0.07408677041530609,
-0.4633373022079468,
-0.28806671500205994,
0.6816698908805847,
0.39792418479919434,
0.013301734812557697,
0.6210322976112366,
1.0296839475631714,
-0.09429041296243668,
-0.7435290813446045,
-0.7348801493644714,
0.20386162400245667,
-0.15288898348808289,
-0.4955565631389618,
-0.037402790039777756,
0.23538170754909515,
-0.8029890060424805,
-0.20731015503406525,
-0.34492382407188416,
0.15805917978286743,
0.2187204211950302,
0.27561628818511963,
-0.1881357729434967,
-0.31275561451911926,
-0.10595902800559998,
-0.06195234879851341,
-0.385969340801239,
0.43058687448501587,
-0.23823241889476776,
0.06208127364516258,
0.10925983637571335,
-0.5644328594207764,
-0.6367868185043335,
0.35433563590049744,
0.8417348265647888,
-0.23974832892417908,
0.20463213324546814,
0.3975354731082916,
-0.21433521807193756,
0.06075967475771904,
-0.4382953941822052,
-0.4121682643890381,
-0.3436453938484192,
0.09457182884216309,
0.18924053013324738,
-1.0366231203079224,
0.31205397844314575,
-0.027568941935896873,
0.557526171207428,
0.2419724315404892,
0.3386114537715912,
-0.09087514132261276,
0.9397029280662537,
0.43750083446502686,
-0.17956702411174774,
0.714847207069397,
0.03237234055995941,
0.4061439335346222,
-0.93511962890625,
-0.1272713840007782,
-0.7801082730293274,
-0.3567737638950348,
-0.39033812284469604,
-0.3039405643939972,
0.23046237230300903,
-0.33852076530456543,
0.1254655122756958,
-0.07116042822599411,
-0.8384183645248413,
0.06467340141534805,
0.584568977355957,
-0.08389446884393692,
0.37990304827690125,
-0.29243311285972595,
0.23764994740486145,
0.0036879030521959066,
-0.5568511486053467,
-0.5840427875518799,
1.1396476030349731,
0.5235360264778137,
0.4114685356616974,
-0.09958995133638382,
0.6368018388748169,
0.39597269892692566,
0.7244215607643127,
-0.4820534884929657,
0.4701826274394989,
0.5880252718925476,
-0.9681840538978577,
-0.7193720936775208,
-0.10698791593313217,
-0.9254916906356812,
0.45244768261909485,
0.048895567655563354,
-0.4391220211982727,
0.5206313133239746,
0.1734517365694046,
-0.0430421344935894,
0.0839201807975769,
-0.6127832531929016,
0.659778356552124,
-0.33435189723968506,
-0.03503681719303131,
-0.035664912313222885,
-0.8133307695388794,
0.46413254737854004,
0.1408972144126892,
0.44453081488609314,
-0.34034496545791626,
0.145302414894104,
1.1514049768447876,
-0.43610864877700806,
1.1765406131744385,
-0.38844749331474304,
-0.4569430947303772,
0.3817533850669861,
-0.2548334300518036,
0.33473125100135803,
0.03305257111787796,
-0.04318827763199806,
0.3462957739830017,
-0.19855158030986786,
-0.4912787973880768,
-0.04277828708291054,
0.39842328429222107,
-0.5235660076141357,
-0.8150839805603027,
-0.7974786162376404,
-0.005386891774833202,
-0.44954535365104675,
0.3608291745185852,
0.24914690852165222,
0.2335357964038849,
-0.5974076390266418,
-0.1727469116449356,
0.4366838335990906,
0.219204381108284,
0.05204199254512787,
0.19240880012512207,
0.10267837345600128,
-0.2641523480415344,
0.4921177625656128,
0.1339564323425293,
0.08250648528337479,
-0.05133097618818283,
-0.0031610087025910616,
-0.07386310398578644,
-0.7832719087600708,
-0.5667915940284729,
0.3489127457141876,
-0.35323622822761536,
0.17449870705604553,
-0.32998526096343994,
0.0683058351278305,
-0.8436022996902466,
0.021888500079512596,
-0.40773215889930725,
-0.38475310802459717,
-0.24627447128295898,
-0.20328202843666077,
0.2228585183620453,
0.625352680683136,
-0.1328238993883133,
0.05344302952289581,
-0.3895992636680603,
0.2771683931350708,
-0.02346724458038807,
0.31039223074913025,
0.15539616346359253,
-0.49404454231262207,
-0.20883296430110931,
0.025562776252627373,
-0.17745843529701233,
-0.6537711024284363,
-0.2165393978357315,
-0.148253932595253,
0.5875559449195862,
0.30716797709465027,
0.19207587838172913,
0.5599538683891296,
-0.447103351354599,
0.7226726412773132,
0.4489510655403137,
-0.9424318671226501,
0.6051387786865234,
-0.23601798713207245,
0.19737255573272705,
0.5289769172668457,
0.24564754962921143,
-0.6795398592948914,
-0.8807628154754639,
-0.9100722670555115,
-0.9324994087219238,
0.6846669316291809,
0.3589347302913666,
-0.0331600047647953,
0.31248655915260315,
-0.06107453629374504,
0.10536378622055054,
0.19494162499904633,
-0.4719761312007904,
-0.2815715968608856,
-0.1022375151515007,
0.019998349249362946,
0.2816345691680908,
0.020661408081650734,
-0.49083948135375977,
-0.19355030357837677,
0.3784016966819763,
-0.0867084488272667,
0.20292024314403534,
0.30358952283859253,
0.058665886521339417,
-0.3228296637535095,
0.08197315782308578,
0.6538771986961365,
0.8776894211769104,
0.27303507924079895,
-0.021144870668649673,
-0.03928864002227783,
-0.6189514398574829,
0.14382202923297882,
0.08657708764076233,
-0.7589174509048462,
0.18191087245941162,
0.5711404085159302,
0.8096544742584229,
0.07928261905908585,
-0.5298576951026917,
0.4219193160533905,
0.03043566457927227,
-0.30256155133247375,
-0.49673041701316833,
-0.12288295477628708,
-0.23632219433784485,
0.2175903469324112,
0.24050818383693695,
0.44552862644195557,
0.13597294688224792,
-0.5968079566955566,
0.2219642549753189,
0.6508194208145142,
-0.6613211035728455,
-0.4412400722503662,
0.7618740200996399,
0.702055811882019,
-0.5994275212287903,
0.4714586138725281,
0.5286094546318054,
-0.2876443564891815,
0.5491239428520203,
0.14374998211860657,
1.0666520595550537,
-0.13477806746959686,
0.45109567046165466,
0.014241255819797516,
0.5986876487731934,
-0.21320393681526184,
0.0748838260769844,
-0.2321653515100479,
-0.506371259689331,
-0.15120117366313934,
-0.18609817326068878,
-0.6668004989624023,
-0.15062905848026276,
-0.4043616056442261,
-0.021974314004182816,
-0.6218616366386414,
-0.513041079044342,
-0.14792495965957642,
-0.17260223627090454,
-0.25374817848205566,
0.10988052934408188,
0.2123471051454544,
0.7574915289878845,
-0.8823311924934387,
0.3699553906917572,
0.32735952734947205,
-0.4837786555290222,
-0.06172919645905495,
0.15670956671237946,
0.10488343238830566,
-0.7013423442840576,
0.4158233106136322,
-0.15457367897033691,
-0.28669166564941406,
-0.14463578164577484,
-0.5715461373329163,
-1.0389373302459717,
0.8006003499031067,
0.23926898837089539,
-0.3672146797180176,
-0.030836330726742744,
0.02203342318534851,
0.6809978485107422,
-0.2626582682132721,
0.36218515038490295,
0.40145421028137207,
0.7771384716033936,
-0.28476351499557495,
-1.0787837505340576,
0.15402252972126007,
-0.0022831675596535206,
-0.17482344806194305,
0.12136679142713547,
-0.9428043961524963,
0.23849162459373474,
-0.2824552655220032,
-0.44486185908317566,
-0.05661575123667717,
0.8282808661460876,
0.5035193562507629,
0.7715362310409546,
0.1876598447561264,
-0.025251377373933792,
0.7564446330070496,
0.06771806627511978,
0.612170934677124,
-0.10443150252103806,
-0.07228758931159973,
0.5862025618553162,
-0.6530337333679199,
0.3703513741493225,
0.6958732604980469,
-0.09978809952735901,
0.06755989789962769,
0.3279789090156555,
0.17403577268123627,
0.03775022178888321,
0.2681823670864105,
-0.14951889216899872,
0.09281116724014282,
-0.2346881479024887,
-0.4517669379711151,
0.06650283187627792,
0.30404147505760193,
-0.4775407612323761,
0.0948324128985405,
0.05426403880119324,
-0.009831487201154232,
0.20512612164020538,
0.05098773166537285,
0.49876007437705994,
0.46224063634872437,
-0.6478152871131897,
0.2519463002681732,
-0.1172182708978653,
0.5968918204307556,
-0.492153525352478,
0.1207660511136055,
-0.2567978799343109,
-0.10551289469003677,
-0.15169692039489746,
-0.5475269556045532,
0.35372310876846313,
0.018535662442445755,
-0.0571557842195034,
-0.7726993560791016,
0.7043784856796265,
0.04227791354060173,
-0.23710569739341736,
0.32338085770606995,
0.6362301111221313,
0.3420400023460388,
0.25418511033058167,
-1.0134081840515137,
0.5170283913612366,
-0.033822473138570786,
-0.276746541261673,
0.2017209529876709,
0.370374858379364,
-0.3876856565475464,
0.5243650078773499,
0.7184295654296875,
0.3766156733036041,
0.23997189104557037,
0.31848108768463135,
0.521980345249176,
-0.8091109395027161,
-0.4467187821865082,
-0.3927452862262726,
0.3175739049911499,
-0.17221258580684662,
-0.9376691579818726,
0.8752332329750061,
0.398673415184021,
0.792682945728302,
0.24957530200481415,
1.0153659582138062,
-0.19348251819610596,
0.2458316534757614,
-0.35422831773757935,
0.6871635317802429,
-0.28115415573120117,
-0.01609065756201744,
-0.4239014685153961,
-0.7051846981048584,
-0.5474809408187866,
0.6591777801513672,
-0.3221941590309143,
0.5611675381660461,
0.49024444818496704,
0.4305591881275177,
0.2022482007741928,
0.35582610964775085,
0.0627773255109787,
0.09745088219642639,
0.3596688210964203,
-0.009002763777971268,
0.6549715399742126,
-0.7247620224952698,
0.2856665849685669,
0.17471188306808472,
-0.42355573177337646,
-0.2686213552951813,
-0.4008365869522095,
-0.5503960847854614,
-0.6904515027999878,
-0.5519744157791138,
-0.2820841670036316,
0.23506642878055573,
0.5857514142990112,
0.5533771514892578,
-0.8459606766700745,
-0.46123963594436646,
-0.20583130419254303,
0.4559324383735657,
-0.453056275844574,
-0.1720181107521057,
0.358115017414093,
-0.058273736387491226,
-0.7644461393356323,
0.3607874810695648,
0.1541881412267685,
-0.11978041380643845,
-0.4612557590007782,
-0.3062983751296997,
0.008546018041670322,
-0.2204630970954895,
0.4069407880306244,
0.9628286361694336,
-0.911706268787384,
-0.20435133576393127,
-0.12789005041122437,
-0.25227561593055725,
-0.1250341534614563,
1.1679033041000366,
-0.41857850551605225,
0.16903804242610931,
0.5372809767723083,
0.44885846972465515,
0.1271696835756302,
-0.09922827780246735,
0.824822723865509,
-0.34418949484825134,
-0.027524488046765327,
0.6653136610984802,
0.2720904052257538,
0.3084012269973755,
-0.11310960352420807,
0.4816281497478485,
0.5437960624694824,
-0.40552133321762085,
-1.0674477815628052,
0.24620255827903748,
-0.7052106857299805,
-0.31475892663002014,
1.1028931140899658,
0.32636743783950806,
-0.3075702488422394,
-0.5949028134346008,
-0.24924519658088684,
0.15598095953464508,
-0.45614781975746155,
0.8072704076766968,
0.4982701241970062,
-0.31580600142478943,
-0.22220125794410706,
-0.2207261472940445,
0.823193371295929,
0.5476188063621521,
-0.30769720673561096,
0.36969074606895447,
0.7141824960708618,
-0.10623378306627274,
0.4322417080402374,
1.1854026317596436,
-0.36832648515701294,
0.42216601967811584,
0.2812598645687103,
0.14600178599357605,
0.24561040103435516,
-0.30218061804771423,
-0.29412612318992615,
-0.08909063041210175,
0.4778682291507721,
-0.04658166319131851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02558v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02558v1
|
Updating the Minimum Information about CLinical Artificial Intelligence (MI-CLAIM) checklist for generative modeling research
| 2024-03-05T00:27:43 | 2024-03-05T00:27:43 |
Brenda Y. Miao, Irene Y. Chen, Christopher YK Williams, Jaysón Davidson, Augusto Garcia-Agundez, Harry Sun, Travis Zack, Atul J. Butte, Madhumita Sushil
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Recent advances in generative models, including large language models (LLMs),
vision language models (VLMs), and diffusion models, have accelerated the field
of natural language and image processing in medicine and marked a significant
paradigm shift in how biomedical models can be developed and deployed. While
these models are highly adaptable to new tasks, scaling and evaluating their
usage presents new challenges not addressed in previous frameworks. In
particular, the ability of these models to produce useful outputs with little
to no specialized training data ("zero-" or "few-shot" approaches), as well as
the open-ended nature of their outputs, necessitate the development of updated
guidelines in using and evaluating these models. In response to gaps in
standards and best practices for the development of clinical AI tools
identified by US Executive Order 141103 and several emerging national networks
for clinical AI evaluation, we begin to formalize some of these guidelines by
building on the "Minimum information about clinical artificial intelligence
modeling" (MI-CLAIM) checklist. The MI-CLAIM checklist, originally developed in
2020, provided a set of six steps with guidelines on the minimum information
necessary to encourage transparent, reproducible research for artificial
intelligence (AI) in medicine. Here, we propose modifications to the original
checklist that highlight differences in training, evaluation, interpretability,
and reproducibility of generative models compared to traditional AI models for
clinical research. This updated checklist also seeks to clarify cohort
selection reporting and adds additional items on alignment with ethical
standards.
|
[
-0.25605329871177673,
-0.2549663484096527,
0.5192831754684448,
-0.028810210525989532,
0.13115645945072174,
-0.3285026252269745,
-0.09164680540561676,
-0.6442500352859497,
0.05397395044565201,
0.7280029654502869,
-0.43915385007858276,
-0.44891083240509033,
-0.7511082887649536,
0.18041734397411346,
-0.29812091588974,
1.0096765756607056,
-0.058862000703811646,
0.1341795027256012,
-0.6706653237342834,
-0.31583619117736816,
-0.2655600905418396,
-0.185512512922287,
-0.4621035158634186,
-0.3111284077167511,
0.5096428990364075,
0.32197999954223633,
0.6502259373664856,
0.63105708360672,
1.1016002893447876,
0.21573150157928467,
-0.012367711402475834,
0.07811244577169418,
-0.07359224557876587,
-0.28904014825820923,
0.04811066389083862,
-0.49467530846595764,
-0.8912254571914673,
-0.024553630501031876,
0.42900002002716064,
1.034409999847412,
-0.19905094802379608,
0.2191188633441925,
-0.13808925449848175,
0.7368399500846863,
-0.7157552242279053,
0.24241432547569275,
-0.4051859974861145,
0.13707643747329712,
0.00001581414653628599,
-0.12029259651899338,
-0.5201414823532104,
-0.23167844116687775,
0.45811623334884644,
-0.47980567812919617,
0.5665679574012756,
-0.15086904168128967,
0.8091976046562195,
0.337175577878952,
-0.2327011525630951,
-0.29388776421546936,
-0.6511311531066895,
0.47044089436531067,
-0.8225134015083313,
0.0874912217259407,
0.805937647819519,
0.37775394320487976,
-0.05525659769773483,
-0.7077711820602417,
-0.246878519654274,
-0.833056628704071,
-0.09789150208234787,
-0.01958809420466423,
-0.5446811318397522,
0.35546714067459106,
0.5093421339988708,
0.40912729501724243,
-0.4061810076236725,
0.26708099246025085,
-0.7277381420135498,
-0.33811694383621216,
0.9802538752555847,
0.2801947295665741,
0.4890921711921692,
0.29275476932525635,
-0.2593114972114563,
0.2382974624633789,
-0.9749232530593872,
-0.33876004815101624,
-0.1630253791809082,
0.1650751829147339,
-0.4793832302093506,
0.8327122926712036,
-0.4496624767780304,
0.557937502861023,
-0.160147562623024,
-0.03963390737771988,
0.18231245875358582,
-0.6240007877349854,
-0.3889268934726715,
-0.07611285150051117,
0.747959315776825,
0.5748428702354431,
-0.32842758297920227,
-0.08403529971837997,
-0.10514960438013077,
0.13205692172050476,
0.42906883358955383,
-0.5688809156417847,
-0.2635658085346222,
0.07001557946205139,
-0.6111681461334229,
-0.3662213385105133,
-0.29783371090888977,
-0.6190775632858276,
-0.6368306279182434,
-0.26758724451065063,
0.2360602766275406,
-0.5080076456069946,
0.039120715111494064,
0.04617816582322121,
-0.06482495367527008,
0.07459819316864014,
0.6905486583709717,
-0.6498766541481018,
0.3489472270011902,
0.2635396718978882,
0.6827461123466492,
0.10751468688249588,
-0.08632408827543259,
-0.29785284399986267,
-0.10149863362312317,
-0.5256343483924866,
0.7031089067459106,
-0.3122120201587677,
-0.3206430971622467,
0.1559261679649353,
-0.13368526101112366,
-0.2636440396308899,
-0.6955154538154602,
0.48532602190971375,
-0.27712100744247437,
0.2544282376766205,
-0.27960044145584106,
-0.5796191096305847,
-0.03475198149681091,
0.25425079464912415,
-0.6207640171051025,
0.3972533047199249,
0.4393298625946045,
-0.4867207407951355,
0.379233717918396,
-1.062913179397583,
-0.1973302662372589,
0.3247392475605011,
-0.23794130980968475,
-0.46531662344932556,
0.1203342154622078,
-0.021845243871212006,
0.13209785521030426,
-0.5252427458763123,
0.22885994613170624,
-0.2192157655954361,
-0.14713624119758606,
-0.15299686789512634,
-0.3248172998428345,
1.032080888748169,
0.22717052698135376,
-0.1737392395734787,
0.402250200510025,
-0.7956933975219727,
-0.15434633195400238,
-0.030668869614601135,
-0.24241775274276733,
-0.108587346971035,
-0.0019318964332342148,
-0.16637322306632996,
-0.1415785402059555,
0.20883092284202576,
-0.5533143281936646,
0.23700015246868134,
-0.3604271113872528,
0.5478602647781372,
0.6026735901832581,
-0.225155308842659,
0.2468491941690445,
-0.8413100838661194,
0.6512452960014343,
0.020899293944239616,
0.385078489780426,
-0.2613680362701416,
-0.6731081604957581,
-0.9905250072479248,
-0.37306633591651917,
0.321289598941803,
0.456815242767334,
-0.5770631432533264,
0.5578131675720215,
-0.1680356115102768,
-0.6850834488868713,
-0.8421496748924255,
-0.08815540373325348,
0.12011179327964783,
0.6113653779029846,
0.5816690325737,
-0.326011061668396,
-0.6207489371299744,
-1.1642714738845825,
-0.06702835112810135,
-0.44760045409202576,
0.05452478677034378,
0.23193782567977905,
0.7312675714492798,
-0.6498903036117554,
0.7506169676780701,
-0.1360664963722229,
-0.40587738156318665,
-0.2109556794166565,
0.3938482105731964,
-0.10358519107103348,
0.506285548210144,
0.486875057220459,
-0.4556272625923157,
-0.26381126046180725,
0.028339574113488197,
-0.6812836527824402,
0.018484314903616905,
-0.1818966120481491,
0.014572497457265854,
-0.039288364350795746,
0.1985088735818863,
-0.5981203317642212,
0.8790584802627563,
0.39537522196769714,
-0.27362143993377686,
0.40281230211257935,
-0.35892099142074585,
0.21790313720703125,
-0.6948170065879822,
0.08209821581840515,
0.1458175927400589,
-0.1807536780834198,
-0.6059002876281738,
0.18842381238937378,
-0.01333414576947689,
0.15698589384555817,
-0.22375167906284332,
0.6938315629959106,
-0.1824979931116104,
0.1947571039199829,
-0.2060479074716568,
-0.2683385908603668,
-0.21170666813850403,
0.03438199311494827,
-0.3059192895889282,
0.6375499963760376,
0.6484076380729675,
-0.8028830289840698,
0.2829474210739136,
0.42592164874076843,
-0.3202979266643524,
0.6145132780075073,
-0.6000584363937378,
0.06391686946153641,
-0.26240503787994385,
0.12722168862819672,
-0.6434986591339111,
-0.3316827416419983,
0.48090070486068726,
-0.44896018505096436,
0.22615857422351837,
-0.04282359033823013,
-0.18856403231620789,
-0.4044821262359619,
-0.18540091812610626,
0.46833181381225586,
0.5220216512680054,
-0.1920517534017563,
0.6421002745628357,
0.4811284840106964,
-0.07889385521411896,
-0.30630263686180115,
-0.5301968455314636,
0.3346105217933655,
-0.014643778093159199,
-0.47041335701942444,
0.7670512795448303,
-0.25251463055610657,
-0.40033388137817383,
0.04585511237382889,
0.1545359194278717,
-0.22919300198554993,
0.0786001980304718,
-0.0051731327548623085,
0.44811105728149414,
-0.3644571006298065,
0.040503863245248795,
-0.07317394018173218,
-0.13119587302207947,
0.13530685007572174,
0.3627963364124298,
0.17743456363677979,
0.017308346927165985,
-0.5430887341499329,
-0.6622705459594727,
0.352866530418396,
0.5715916752815247,
-0.2589852809906006,
0.373511403799057,
0.5353749990463257,
-0.7908547520637512,
0.25038886070251465,
-0.4742562174797058,
-0.13588859140872955,
-0.33132612705230713,
0.4121994078159332,
0.06095293536782265,
-0.8067496418952942,
0.13442565500736237,
0.018529077991843224,
0.2982666492462158,
0.9219557642936707,
0.844167947769165,
-0.27565282583236694,
1.1616913080215454,
0.9432535767555237,
0.10087532550096512,
0.19275231659412384,
-0.11525760591030121,
0.1752202808856964,
-1.0006994009017944,
-0.22660192847251892,
-0.6683446764945984,
0.01369419228285551,
-0.5904280543327332,
-0.5934852361679077,
0.5572510957717896,
-0.20559747517108917,
-0.18842709064483643,
-0.08952295780181885,
-0.4217508137226105,
0.07429718226194382,
0.5002651810646057,
0.2113064080476761,
0.19257107377052307,
-0.031398192048072815,
-0.06028801202774048,
0.1749095767736435,
-0.7511293888092041,
-0.4960194230079651,
1.322690725326538,
0.29581665992736816,
0.5327089428901672,
0.030133599415421486,
0.5506423115730286,
0.8898224234580994,
0.8107218742370605,
-0.6488006711006165,
0.40979596972465515,
-0.13446611166000366,
-0.47553083300590515,
0.011107681319117546,
-0.2757638692855835,
-0.9206875562667847,
0.026441462337970734,
-0.28192827105522156,
-0.6239016652107239,
0.09141992777585983,
0.29043513536453247,
-0.703241229057312,
0.1308736503124237,
-0.3846932053565979,
0.6396573781967163,
-0.1246751919388771,
0.15662579238414764,
-0.25069665908813477,
-0.5610268712043762,
0.30802562832832336,
0.3090037405490875,
-0.12946438789367676,
-0.23774804174900055,
-0.04474799335002899,
0.7841882705688477,
-0.6412687301635742,
1.0349483489990234,
-0.08683381974697113,
0.2251104712486267,
0.34815719723701477,
-0.1600397527217865,
0.43524375557899475,
-0.289471298456192,
0.16868776082992554,
0.33652642369270325,
0.337663471698761,
-0.4244864881038666,
-0.17755413055419922,
0.20218269526958466,
-0.7507742643356323,
-0.5405831933021545,
-0.59587162733078,
-0.4997420310974121,
-0.30604225397109985,
0.18683463335037231,
0.4428198039531708,
0.212679922580719,
-0.4362133741378784,
0.2639666199684143,
0.5624894499778748,
-0.3709607422351837,
-0.041920922696590424,
0.48899737000465393,
0.05957949534058571,
-0.3958055078983307,
0.6588210463523865,
0.07452332973480225,
0.11178108304738998,
0.26299673318862915,
0.1339227706193924,
-0.09305629879236221,
-0.845915675163269,
-0.356223464012146,
0.29840752482414246,
-0.4881904423236847,
-0.3097415566444397,
-0.4617321491241455,
-0.5543439984321594,
-0.5473237037658691,
0.09161308407783508,
-0.30505451560020447,
-0.15346118807792664,
-0.3268033266067505,
0.09186599403619766,
0.2827101945877075,
0.656231701374054,
0.0011305594816803932,
0.19817857444286346,
-0.7937633991241455,
0.39820605516433716,
-0.14141973853111267,
0.25239378213882446,
-0.41533735394477844,
-0.39994126558303833,
-0.2913370132446289,
0.2912119925022125,
-0.22447799146175385,
-0.686636209487915,
0.07936134934425354,
0.2154703140258789,
0.6247504949569702,
0.22508394718170166,
-0.04935150966048241,
0.778746485710144,
-0.4400295317173004,
0.7677067518234253,
0.45610666275024414,
-0.5228793025016785,
0.7447995543479919,
-0.13741332292556763,
-0.010125217027962208,
0.42716947197914124,
0.32721617817878723,
-0.45603084564208984,
-0.11747115850448608,
-0.7026846408843994,
-0.5043044090270996,
0.34736743569374084,
0.21653391420841217,
0.10688462108373642,
0.08916809409856796,
0.25202035903930664,
0.09520479291677475,
0.11168627440929413,
-0.25840774178504944,
-0.09637492150068283,
0.2957107126712799,
-0.6412702798843384,
0.16625861823558807,
-0.28570741415023804,
-0.6808770895004272,
-0.35466575622558594,
0.47057974338531494,
-0.35054346919059753,
0.7318403720855713,
0.4703039824962616,
-0.062009070068597794,
-0.2046503722667694,
0.22189797461032867,
0.7555192708969116,
0.7936434149742126,
0.05570879951119423,
-0.12309107184410095,
-0.04976684972643852,
-0.5463940501213074,
-0.07088875770568848,
0.2926017940044403,
-0.5965813994407654,
-0.05661339685320854,
0.5909154415130615,
0.78033846616745,
-0.1591738909482956,
-1.000148892402649,
0.47606050968170166,
0.02110355719923973,
-0.35023757815361023,
-0.4107455313205719,
0.3558816611766815,
-0.46586865186691284,
0.21903511881828308,
-0.18647201359272003,
0.7026919722557068,
0.24020354449748993,
-0.32631915807724,
0.21305522322654724,
0.2867368757724762,
-0.6596490740776062,
-0.25641921162605286,
0.638145923614502,
-0.04261196777224541,
-0.2779664099216461,
0.7148593664169312,
-0.010391631163656712,
0.09603163599967957,
0.806963324546814,
0.3883122503757477,
0.7179267406463623,
-0.10810590535402298,
0.48970115184783936,
0.30088645219802856,
0.4832005202770233,
-0.06480634957551956,
0.29937848448753357,
0.05554759502410889,
-0.7666906714439392,
-0.0693119615316391,
-0.11697332561016083,
-0.464591383934021,
0.15435825288295746,
-0.6902002692222595,
0.3039100468158722,
-0.7586202621459961,
-0.42420727014541626,
0.09714221209287643,
-0.25329917669296265,
-0.8762805461883545,
0.24787217378616333,
0.3240850865840912,
0.9241490364074707,
-0.4668177664279938,
0.463234543800354,
0.6338363885879517,
-0.547677218914032,
-0.220671147108078,
-0.37560635805130005,
0.2708296477794647,
-1.022850751876831,
0.12525634467601776,
-0.14337097108364105,
0.14912380278110504,
-0.3127884566783905,
-0.8606985211372375,
-0.7612177729606628,
1.137329339981079,
0.3296976387500763,
-0.4422239065170288,
-0.21820823848247528,
0.07411464303731918,
0.6707568764686584,
-0.7127460241317749,
0.2934565842151642,
0.44588494300842285,
0.19960013031959534,
0.19884346425533295,
-0.8333011865615845,
-0.15891650319099426,
-0.3426932692527771,
-0.11648979783058167,
-0.22317244112491608,
-0.46844926476478577,
0.7425727248191833,
-0.6916457414627075,
-0.030893957242369652,
0.6663091778755188,
0.4748419523239136,
0.5055127143859863,
0.6238189935684204,
0.2767661511898041,
0.680826723575592,
1.0719903707504272,
-0.14068028330802917,
1.1733533143997192,
-0.18791435658931732,
0.17988859117031097,
1.1671162843704224,
-0.4440315067768097,
0.6998639106750488,
0.23272545635700226,
-0.487592488527298,
0.25858834385871887,
0.6814112067222595,
-0.4118539094924927,
0.22285863757133484,
0.02362801693379879,
-0.1717357039451599,
0.016781266778707504,
-0.48858147859573364,
-0.592300534248352,
0.33642399311065674,
0.3729899823665619,
-0.829499363899231,
-0.061273153871297836,
-0.037495292723178864,
0.052406396716833115,
-0.45924437046051025,
-0.39963677525520325,
0.6737070083618164,
-0.06761512160301208,
-0.6380314230918884,
0.367667555809021,
0.22499200701713562,
0.2480810433626175,
-0.4704029858112335,
-0.3255181312561035,
-0.17879371345043182,
-0.0006702860118821263,
-0.2381436973810196,
-0.2448519468307495,
0.21693788468837738,
0.34268683195114136,
-0.25059986114501953,
0.07894061505794525,
0.6306026577949524,
-0.1928177773952484,
-0.7536013722419739,
-0.06517395377159119,
0.40489670634269714,
-0.03411150723695755,
0.2845769226551056,
-0.9000405669212341,
-0.15995678305625916,
-0.006770453881472349,
0.3491209149360657,
0.27247047424316406,
-0.08033179491758347,
-0.08557052910327911,
0.8453681468963623,
0.6091938018798828,
0.3804077208042145,
0.23875173926353455,
0.2678588926792145,
0.667312502861023,
-0.6126518845558167,
-0.2067720592021942,
-0.6161174178123474,
0.5172179937362671,
0.042105089873075485,
-0.2519597113132477,
0.2798793911933899,
0.3531052768230438,
0.5607109665870667,
0.13624908030033112,
0.9329918026924133,
-0.21153958141803741,
0.33345434069633484,
-0.5857670307159424,
0.7380526065826416,
-0.6160269975662231,
0.19660697877407074,
0.13450565934181213,
-0.3253859579563141,
-0.5038118362426758,
0.5520550608634949,
-0.12080787867307663,
0.266218364238739,
0.4950430989265442,
0.5945391654968262,
0.2995535135269165,
0.15713246166706085,
0.33590877056121826,
0.586637020111084,
0.44604191184043884,
0.4539048969745636,
0.7620680332183838,
-0.6535915732383728,
-0.07159090042114258,
-0.35475683212280273,
-0.3186158537864685,
-0.3606000542640686,
-0.5829777121543884,
-0.4713496267795563,
-0.36695846915245056,
-0.86935955286026,
-0.4364476799964905,
-0.007754211779683828,
1.0648201704025269,
0.7261353731155396,
-0.7251856327056885,
-0.09172410517930984,
-0.13291166722774506,
0.020086921751499176,
-0.421602725982666,
-0.13915695250034332,
0.41033077239990234,
-0.23025058209896088,
-0.34941330552101135,
0.31642526388168335,
0.622042179107666,
0.1006174385547638,
-0.17954358458518982,
-0.18857528269290924,
-0.04757028818130493,
0.09235448390245438,
0.5410784482955933,
0.46668824553489685,
-0.8607149124145508,
-0.17545126378536224,
-0.12074556201696396,
-0.32242661714553833,
0.425063818693161,
0.6776134371757507,
-0.5775332450866699,
0.679131031036377,
0.36124327778816223,
0.7123862504959106,
-0.03114396706223488,
-0.43408629298210144,
0.420421302318573,
-0.07291489839553833,
-0.164590984582901,
0.5873401165008545,
0.5845121741294861,
0.15464124083518982,
-0.2062191516160965,
0.578871488571167,
0.34919312596321106,
-0.35931068658828735,
-0.8941336870193481,
0.190127432346344,
-0.9621649384498596,
0.24916866421699524,
0.6531862020492554,
-0.178178071975708,
-0.20330725610256195,
-0.07286190241575241,
-0.1337272971868515,
0.14609330892562866,
0.15608130395412445,
0.8592609763145447,
0.5443503856658936,
-0.6286343932151794,
-0.21288295090198517,
-0.6136505007743835,
0.6104408502578735,
0.22715361416339874,
-1.0480213165283203,
-0.08446545898914337,
0.6246934533119202,
0.1629112809896469,
0.08303045481443405,
0.9958702325820923,
-0.35525164008140564,
0.6375672817230225,
-0.031235432252287865,
0.0771489292383194,
0.20581161975860596,
-0.4947036802768707,
-0.3263895511627197,
-0.09944088757038116,
0.17642608284950256,
-0.04991133511066437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02528v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02528v1
|
DACO: Towards Application-Driven and Comprehensive Data Analysis via Code Generation
| 2024-03-04T22:47:58 | 2024-03-04T22:47:58 |
Xueqing Wu, Rui Zheng, Jingzhen Sha, Te-Lin Wu, Hanyu Zhou, Mohan Tang, Kai-Wei Chang, Nanyun Peng, Haoran Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Data analysis is a crucial analytical process to generate in-depth studies
and conclusive insights to comprehensively answer a given user query for
tabular data. In this work, we aim to propose new resources and benchmarks to
inspire future research on this crucial yet challenging and under-explored
task. However, collecting data analysis annotations curated by experts can be
prohibitively expensive. We propose to automatically generate high-quality
answer annotations leveraging the code-generation capabilities of LLMs with a
multi-turn prompting technique. We construct the DACO dataset, containing (1)
440 databases (of tabular data) collected from real-world scenarios, (2) ~2k
query-answer pairs that can serve as weak supervision for model training, and
(3) a concentrated but high-quality test set with human refined annotations
that serves as our main evaluation benchmark. We train a 6B supervised
fine-tuning (SFT) model on DACO dataset, and find that the SFT model learns
reasonable data analysis capabilities. To further align the models with human
preference, we use reinforcement learning to encourage generating analysis
perceived by human as helpful, and design a set of dense rewards to propagate
the sparse human preference reward to intermediate code generation steps. Our
DACO-RL algorithm is evaluated by human annotators to produce more helpful
answers than SFT model in 57.72% cases, validating the effectiveness of our
proposed algorithm. Data and code are released at
https://github.com/shirley-wu/daco
|
[
-0.5783783197402954,
-0.9843673706054688,
0.4546978771686554,
0.016319531947374344,
-0.01752515882253647,
0.16024982929229736,
-0.10106144100427628,
-0.12335168570280075,
0.12756524980068207,
0.6750174164772034,
-0.6975887417793274,
-0.7194978594779968,
-0.14554136991500854,
0.21687453985214233,
-0.23638588190078735,
1.1902211904525757,
0.0636756643652916,
-0.25042247772216797,
-0.4444751441478729,
0.052219122648239136,
-0.5292164087295532,
-0.391107439994812,
-0.6135808825492859,
0.06964245438575745,
0.6638228893280029,
0.8863318562507629,
0.5328772664070129,
0.6669396758079529,
0.433869868516922,
0.27773329615592957,
0.29001468420028687,
0.7344622015953064,
-0.48986998200416565,
0.22321617603302002,
0.030560800805687904,
-0.30740031599998474,
-0.8408173322677612,
-0.026399122551083565,
-0.01224090252071619,
0.6197044849395752,
-0.23497457802295685,
0.3353402316570282,
-0.048356492072343826,
0.8281723856925964,
-0.5751031637191772,
0.32188352942466736,
-0.8799437284469604,
-0.061595894396305084,
-0.032236140221357346,
-0.4589899182319641,
-0.35706827044487,
-0.47431033849716187,
-0.2838454842567444,
-0.6730120778083801,
0.2473789006471634,
0.0006607213872484863,
0.5137662291526794,
0.5583627223968506,
-0.49074679613113403,
-0.7168871760368347,
-0.38870367407798767,
0.7209455370903015,
-0.5310249328613281,
-0.24449092149734497,
0.3916880488395691,
0.5453305840492249,
-0.3783307671546936,
-0.6421187520027161,
-0.7773138880729675,
-0.3413380980491638,
0.0008194404072128236,
0.06567496806383133,
0.13886196911334991,
-0.09137146919965744,
0.2832418978214264,
0.24874870479106903,
-0.43743687868118286,
0.04135402664542198,
-0.3098345696926117,
0.07649106532335281,
1.296449065208435,
0.5870065093040466,
-0.023956945165991783,
-0.2517905533313751,
-0.19566775858402252,
-0.060850467532873154,
-0.39733368158340454,
0.1266106367111206,
0.45405012369155884,
0.23446930944919586,
-0.07338655740022659,
0.27733954787254333,
-0.43458783626556396,
0.9490980505943298,
0.02030511014163494,
0.09674453735351562,
0.20082852244377136,
-0.35489583015441895,
-0.09018140286207199,
-0.07617110013961792,
0.9260019063949585,
0.38227275013923645,
0.31221824884414673,
-0.19754499197006226,
-0.24155282974243164,
0.19610661268234253,
0.7686563730239868,
-0.7862794995307922,
-0.3664917051792145,
0.5921928882598877,
-0.08748169243335724,
-0.8674777150154114,
0.34076592326164246,
-1.1112111806869507,
-0.5007182955741882,
-0.4143924117088318,
-0.15785011649131775,
0.10412529110908508,
-0.15148472785949707,
0.17391130328178406,
0.2886427938938141,
-0.04895956814289093,
0.16855110228061676,
-0.9229716062545776,
0.23982280492782593,
0.52781081199646,
0.5946719646453857,
-0.49687549471855164,
-0.08038891106843948,
-0.9517570734024048,
0.11405499279499054,
-0.44208186864852905,
0.7506008744239807,
-0.3869319558143616,
-0.399392694234848,
0.041928600519895554,
-0.1500382274389267,
0.1661202758550644,
-0.6028194427490234,
0.5523020029067993,
-0.6199395656585693,
-0.25925594568252563,
-0.384066641330719,
-0.37976202368736267,
0.04788937792181969,
0.27704158425331116,
-0.7484923601150513,
1.1594138145446777,
0.06490392982959747,
-0.6655703783035278,
0.6746974587440491,
-0.9781959652900696,
-0.21971893310546875,
0.13835209608078003,
-0.6010092496871948,
-0.7748523950576782,
0.012450198642909527,
0.6411899328231812,
0.6898557543754578,
-0.27460047602653503,
0.5384990572929382,
-0.4090687334537506,
-0.34042006731033325,
0.5276584625244141,
-0.11488606780767441,
0.5484952926635742,
0.4860018193721771,
-0.5157209038734436,
0.2773842215538025,
-0.9919303059577942,
0.26780155301094055,
0.2525557279586792,
-0.30875325202941895,
0.024020329117774963,
-0.034087564796209335,
-0.07104401290416718,
0.21833568811416626,
-0.002036555903032422,
-0.45668265223503113,
0.6881919503211975,
0.0329727828502655,
0.35212117433547974,
0.7308139801025391,
0.23108333349227905,
0.060302261263132095,
-0.23046711087226868,
0.780798077583313,
0.14238491654396057,
0.22968855500221252,
-0.15441738069057465,
-0.13062599301338196,
-0.5828059315681458,
-0.2730162739753723,
0.1645132452249527,
0.3300832509994507,
-0.9357393383979797,
0.5678590536117554,
-0.2536270022392273,
-0.32654935121536255,
-0.4794844388961792,
0.3291001617908478,
0.17467394471168518,
0.6292930245399475,
0.41644909977912903,
-0.25292733311653137,
-0.6275842189788818,
-0.7531641721725464,
0.1433214396238327,
-0.024474816396832466,
0.1586916148662567,
0.45897042751312256,
0.5556498765945435,
-0.3094824254512787,
1.2429654598236084,
-0.8622767329216003,
-0.22349461913108826,
-0.26264524459838867,
0.17398160696029663,
0.12198366969823837,
0.26258429884910583,
0.5184450745582581,
-0.9550349712371826,
-0.4206793010234833,
0.07590892165899277,
-0.918713390827179,
-0.1993931382894516,
-0.21073207259178162,
-0.19976870715618134,
0.13254638016223907,
0.384185791015625,
0.04131711274385452,
0.49229946732521057,
0.24333526194095612,
-0.11429477483034134,
0.41710078716278076,
-0.16102340817451477,
0.31710636615753174,
-0.9578810334205627,
0.3004775047302246,
-0.23280955851078033,
-0.06601463258266449,
-0.41421225666999817,
-0.31360670924186707,
-0.012729217298328876,
-0.19352000951766968,
-0.11593406647443771,
0.3161747455596924,
-0.2865583598613739,
-0.18524986505508423,
-0.43653324246406555,
0.10929043591022491,
0.14839443564414978,
0.5914821624755859,
-0.11277303844690323,
0.864712119102478,
0.2868199050426483,
-0.8653321266174316,
0.6671400666236877,
0.3528328835964203,
-0.2720416486263275,
0.3529842495918274,
-0.7753986120223999,
0.4708712100982666,
0.018101941794157028,
0.06797513365745544,
-1.041978120803833,
-0.5159206390380859,
0.030051808804273605,
-0.5027104020118713,
0.04805630445480347,
-0.19587306678295135,
-0.46515339612960815,
-0.5249818563461304,
-0.28625163435935974,
0.11827144026756287,
0.19415301084518433,
-0.7037525177001953,
0.05610010400414467,
0.5651422142982483,
-0.12710317969322205,
-0.4867345988750458,
-0.6085372567176819,
0.02348419465124607,
-0.29076245427131653,
-0.6653189659118652,
0.10312413424253464,
-0.05367086082696915,
-0.2229040414094925,
-0.2743161916732788,
-0.08093813061714172,
-0.3171350657939911,
0.32257089018821716,
0.25948482751846313,
0.3909706175327301,
0.31876474618911743,
0.08338507264852524,
0.20861196517944336,
-0.2065924108028412,
0.1723601371049881,
-0.23975183069705963,
0.27713876962661743,
-0.15033946931362152,
-0.25384148955345154,
-0.34152910113334656,
0.2194322794675827,
0.4159002900123596,
-0.5141801834106445,
0.32913145422935486,
0.40974944829940796,
0.05680449306964874,
-0.4836394488811493,
-0.43908822536468506,
-0.015522531233727932,
-0.48649778962135315,
0.22971279919147491,
-0.5051709413528442,
-0.47770267724990845,
0.42664140462875366,
0.06663763523101807,
0.31517869234085083,
0.12178324162960052,
0.7391356229782104,
-0.0803477019071579,
1.0056672096252441,
0.42464664578437805,
0.07167275249958038,
0.3725575804710388,
-0.6539381146430969,
-0.12588036060333252,
-0.3652075529098511,
-0.1351369172334671,
-0.49069878458976746,
-0.18174557387828827,
-0.6114068627357483,
-0.12214541435241699,
0.664328396320343,
-0.03831518813967705,
0.17768898606300354,
0.1116073802113533,
-0.897861659526825,
0.3140748143196106,
0.3251878321170807,
0.05867934599518776,
0.4209253191947937,
0.0026906852144747972,
0.15609009563922882,
0.19951465725898743,
-0.6002169251441956,
-0.6985944509506226,
1.3822071552276611,
0.11603376269340515,
0.8262787461280823,
-0.20267151296138763,
0.9969777464866638,
0.6244198679924011,
0.15297916531562805,
-0.6901237964630127,
0.49272575974464417,
0.21273325383663177,
-0.4222169816493988,
-0.2222960740327835,
-0.7171798944473267,
-1.053022861480713,
-0.09015702456235886,
-0.05542914569377899,
-0.21316710114479065,
0.14603039622306824,
0.3999907672405243,
-0.5177275538444519,
-0.1304297000169754,
-0.6754561066627502,
0.9373296499252319,
-0.4054754078388214,
-0.7544137239456177,
-0.02526691183447838,
-0.42127907276153564,
0.316165030002594,
-0.010044190101325512,
0.3089376986026764,
0.10696914792060852,
-0.008805657736957073,
0.5716161727905273,
-0.36998578906059265,
0.5876246094703674,
-0.5436915755271912,
-0.26680827140808105,
0.7140393853187561,
0.04473400488495827,
0.5297127366065979,
0.6143472790718079,
-0.2995407283306122,
-0.15087516605854034,
-0.06993937492370605,
-0.502681314945221,
-0.7932319045066833,
0.6969176530838013,
-0.3906685411930084,
-0.17625798285007477,
-0.2948634922504425,
-0.6664467453956604,
-0.23318515717983246,
-0.10291194915771484,
-0.11663531512022018,
0.4163745045661926,
0.16088618338108063,
0.026592988520860672,
0.44919928908348083,
-0.233992800116539,
0.33807846903800964,
0.4028884172439575,
-0.0882737934589386,
-0.5467148423194885,
0.7565590143203735,
0.04456115514039993,
-0.15815386176109314,
0.02074999362230301,
0.14214487373828888,
-0.2532860040664673,
-0.662378191947937,
-0.7206872701644897,
-0.2201748937368393,
-0.2533266544342041,
-0.4070594906806946,
-0.3554486036300659,
0.31889498233795166,
-0.3112616240978241,
-0.20566023886203766,
-0.2875438332557678,
-0.16156017780303955,
0.04212622344493866,
-0.24026085436344147,
0.5594508647918701,
0.891716718673706,
0.08443642407655716,
0.04490407183766365,
-0.6901839971542358,
0.4540976583957672,
0.3259490132331848,
0.20837028324604034,
0.03452678024768829,
0.03733329847455025,
-0.5662533640861511,
0.17039217054843903,
-0.5382254719734192,
-0.6327078938484192,
0.28261056542396545,
-0.18872104585170746,
0.38710489869117737,
-0.003819051431491971,
0.43695786595344543,
0.7255566716194153,
-0.09837129712104797,
0.6210356950759888,
-0.12173134088516235,
-0.6783837080001831,
0.8703851699829102,
-0.3073959946632385,
-0.01865421235561371,
0.9354814887046814,
0.2121288925409317,
-0.07915205508470535,
-0.15950965881347656,
-0.5779323577880859,
-0.8628079295158386,
0.7957506775856018,
0.04122348502278328,
-0.1491251289844513,
-0.25401821732521057,
0.6156043410301208,
0.38023680448532104,
0.4109431803226471,
-0.5298537611961365,
-0.0782376080751419,
-0.20410607755184174,
-0.4021266996860504,
0.21631745994091034,
-0.06136469915509224,
-0.09152001887559891,
-0.08122607320547104,
0.4927150309085846,
-0.6132073402404785,
-0.05849981680512428,
0.2782004177570343,
-0.14410753548145294,
0.11989925056695938,
0.2866315543651581,
0.2831519842147827,
0.7826401591300964,
-0.11416414380073547,
-0.1997910737991333,
0.05722198635339737,
-0.41179075837135315,
0.09441933035850525,
0.05496515333652496,
-0.17857488989830017,
-0.34761562943458557,
0.2020474374294281,
0.600365400314331,
-0.21833443641662598,
-0.7095332145690918,
0.39929407835006714,
-0.14141704142093658,
-0.16323578357696533,
-0.36405476927757263,
0.35750362277030945,
-0.17124304175376892,
-0.1257995218038559,
0.42223984003067017,
-0.4821130037307739,
0.3332836925983429,
-0.3912245035171509,
0.47445228695869446,
0.34591013193130493,
-0.21783827245235443,
-0.03418403118848801,
0.6047329306602478,
0.4185693860054016,
0.16093823313713074,
0.6749984622001648,
-0.5681809782981873,
-0.1172054260969162,
0.7748952507972717,
0.004864598624408245,
0.7125519514083862,
0.24158832430839539,
0.26523175835609436,
0.5325875878334045,
-0.17767857015132904,
0.37747621536254883,
0.4569649398326874,
-0.4761565625667572,
-0.31261295080184937,
-0.4531148374080658,
-0.6168878078460693,
-0.42935580015182495,
-0.09861107170581818,
-1.0480960607528687,
0.45688846707344055,
-0.24820277094841003,
-0.010932842269539833,
-0.09044689685106277,
0.4275508224964142,
-0.49705779552459717,
0.2878306210041046,
-0.09330019354820251,
0.5374796986579895,
-0.554949939250946,
0.9152266979217529,
0.6395376324653625,
-0.7284368872642517,
-0.6731935143470764,
-0.11342746019363403,
-0.23355861008167267,
-0.6081144213676453,
0.7397283911705017,
0.15079247951507568,
-0.015469502657651901,
-0.05173049867153168,
-0.7428800463676453,
-0.28971028327941895,
1.2498620748519897,
0.20461751520633698,
-0.6160666346549988,
0.11636152118444443,
0.25201642513275146,
0.48800066113471985,
-0.569320797920227,
0.4340158998966217,
0.8659389019012451,
0.40250593423843384,
0.038588616997003555,
-0.6150250434875488,
-0.03695410117506981,
-0.17074309289455414,
0.009831612929701805,
0.18194128572940826,
-0.5030346512794495,
0.5776113271713257,
-0.4000127613544464,
0.07981207221746445,
-0.17712417244911194,
0.6101590394973755,
0.37052273750305176,
0.5439996123313904,
0.5346091389656067,
0.3080821931362152,
0.7043331265449524,
0.03428319841623306,
1.020418405532837,
-0.20539350807666779,
0.4637487232685089,
1.1128215789794922,
-0.3237050473690033,
0.507953405380249,
0.42525821924209595,
-0.17412544786930084,
0.4697505235671997,
0.4583871066570282,
-0.15517204999923706,
0.4396677017211914,
0.5142197608947754,
-0.027645107358694077,
-0.08077111095190048,
-0.08416259288787842,
-0.08860813081264496,
0.6289392709732056,
0.16278298199176788,
-0.08467540144920349,
-0.019837049767374992,
-0.15612569451332092,
-0.08388984203338623,
0.43914544582366943,
-0.2833261489868164,
1.085628867149353,
-0.2351490706205368,
-0.6896252036094666,
0.838377833366394,
-0.2763221263885498,
0.5465596318244934,
-0.5570977330207825,
-0.20874953269958496,
-0.5308246612548828,
0.15742610394954681,
-0.6385840177536011,
-0.7072552442550659,
0.5056406259536743,
0.38157734274864197,
-0.12071840465068817,
-0.12222624570131302,
0.22692470252513885,
-0.30801019072532654,
-0.33860763907432556,
0.18967179954051971,
0.3263625204563141,
0.07833395153284073,
-0.040217578411102295,
-0.6506644487380981,
0.21572443842887878,
0.26466259360313416,
-0.38162684440612793,
0.1457197517156601,
0.40402334928512573,
-0.1270914524793625,
0.6847353577613831,
0.6923677325248718,
0.0034276193473488092,
0.08985765278339386,
0.10977276414632797,
1.0094484090805054,
-0.7355167269706726,
-0.5278452634811401,
-0.7188377976417542,
0.8502132296562195,
-0.3520960509777069,
-0.22666025161743164,
0.5282458066940308,
0.7206838726997375,
0.7910487651824951,
-0.10291880369186401,
0.988929033279419,
-0.35250312089920044,
0.4539003372192383,
-0.6194565892219543,
0.5348880887031555,
-0.6037629842758179,
0.4545901119709015,
-0.30112817883491516,
-0.6855611205101013,
-0.051937833428382874,
0.4153287410736084,
-0.3809877038002014,
0.04716004058718681,
0.4081280529499054,
0.8622686266899109,
0.05923805758357048,
-0.05316755548119545,
0.14112573862075806,
-0.049115728586912155,
0.7325025796890259,
0.6252554655075073,
0.6768602728843689,
-0.4750453531742096,
0.7567036151885986,
-0.42489686608314514,
-0.3635830879211426,
-0.14308901131153107,
-0.7838531732559204,
-0.9005256295204163,
-0.49812620878219604,
-0.38953903317451477,
-0.26250115036964417,
-0.14542557299137115,
0.8007816076278687,
0.7305805087089539,
-0.8297303318977356,
-0.38221609592437744,
-0.45443326234817505,
-0.020680395886301994,
-0.22104912996292114,
-0.2889304757118225,
0.394043892621994,
-0.7385229468345642,
-0.7191110253334045,
0.3980189859867096,
0.08523163199424744,
-0.28413423895835876,
-0.34558698534965515,
-0.037160612642765045,
0.08080891519784927,
-0.29689282178878784,
0.38402482867240906,
0.06343963742256165,
-0.34293705224990845,
-0.01643984764814377,
0.0011428833240643144,
-0.07958414405584335,
0.19880586862564087,
0.9764158129692078,
-0.8169844150543213,
0.5920560359954834,
0.2026229351758957,
0.914118230342865,
0.5946469306945801,
0.33327004313468933,
0.5163388848304749,
-0.8650388121604919,
-0.007593775633722544,
0.38233432173728943,
-0.018925365060567856,
0.3057767152786255,
-0.6215655207633972,
0.7443115711212158,
-0.22148235142230988,
-0.6750279664993286,
-0.9265576004981995,
0.27732786536216736,
-1.0191102027893066,
0.013987239450216293,
1.0471630096435547,
-0.17072853446006775,
-0.1915319710969925,
-0.19644401967525482,
-0.5307509899139404,
0.1441485732793808,
-0.5383045077323914,
1.0659984350204468,
0.42762109637260437,
-0.5559089779853821,
0.11150874942541122,
-0.6773773431777954,
0.5925365090370178,
0.210452139377594,
-1.3608404397964478,
0.47429290413856506,
0.5462164282798767,
0.06796562671661377,
-0.01671600714325905,
0.493645042181015,
-0.14187778532505035,
0.40272849798202515,
0.02332732081413269,
0.3123069107532501,
-0.7210204005241394,
-0.3396036624908447,
-0.31051209568977356,
0.24617280066013336,
0.1440308541059494,
-0.37744849920272827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02513v1
|
Balancing Enhancement, Harmlessness, and General Capabilities: Enhancing Conversational LLMs with Direct RLHF
| 2024-03-04T22:02:12 | 2024-03-04T22:02:12 |
Chen Zheng, Ke Sun, Hang Wu, Chenguang Xi, Xun Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent advancements in Conversational Large Language Models (LLMs), a
concerning trend has emerged, showing that many new base LLMs experience a
knowledge reduction in their foundational capabilities following Supervised
Fine-Tuning (SFT). This process often leads to issues such as forgetting or a
decrease in the base model's abilities. Moreover, fine-tuned models struggle to
align with user preferences, inadvertently increasing the generation of toxic
outputs when specifically prompted. To overcome these challenges, we adopted an
innovative approach by completely bypassing SFT and directly implementing
Harmless Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF). Our method not only
preserves the base model's general capabilities but also significantly enhances
its conversational abilities, while notably reducing the generation of toxic
outputs. Our approach holds significant implications for fields that demand a
nuanced understanding and generation of responses, such as customer service. We
applied this methodology to Mistral, the most popular base model, thereby
creating Mistral-Plus. Our validation across 11 general tasks demonstrates that
Mistral-Plus outperforms similarly sized open-source base models and their
corresponding instruct versions. Importantly, the conversational abilities of
Mistral-Plus were significantly improved, indicating a substantial advancement
over traditional SFT models in both safety and user preference alignment.
|
[
-0.3325845003128052,
-1.0324512720108032,
0.2731914520263672,
0.23024843633174896,
-0.12561483681201935,
-0.005134247709065676,
-0.4062599539756775,
-0.7214540839195251,
-0.06357366591691971,
0.8506016731262207,
-0.5493226051330566,
-0.49583005905151367,
-0.3861125111579895,
-0.19397735595703125,
-0.16362568736076355,
1.366520643234253,
0.3342696726322174,
0.040935903787612915,
-0.16840219497680664,
-0.07429787516593933,
-0.6574594974517822,
-0.7353240251541138,
-0.94719398021698,
-0.5160607099533081,
0.5924381017684937,
0.5036783814430237,
0.8845588564872742,
0.6341758966445923,
0.4725140333175659,
0.2782350182533264,
-0.12485837191343307,
0.3669242858886719,
-0.7968724966049194,
0.4672034978866577,
-0.3091661036014557,
-0.3825240135192871,
-0.7290236949920654,
-0.4234054982662201,
0.34294626116752625,
0.7063138484954834,
-0.34153541922569275,
-0.16286611557006836,
0.3016691505908966,
0.7210919857025146,
-0.5700294971466064,
0.17780539393424988,
-0.7330173850059509,
-0.11484300345182419,
0.3169088065624237,
-0.2419523298740387,
-0.529995858669281,
-0.18565824627876282,
0.23122894763946533,
-0.6262176036834717,
0.19178953766822815,
-0.2770501375198364,
0.7448288202285767,
0.5683403611183167,
-0.4254733920097351,
-0.19252221286296844,
-0.8925479650497437,
0.8270682692527771,
-0.5080822110176086,
0.3767029047012329,
0.3203471302986145,
0.22486485540866852,
-0.29671645164489746,
-0.449687123298645,
-0.010182604193687439,
-0.6949476003646851,
-0.03743471950292587,
0.11209798604249954,
-0.4914216995239258,
0.5199347138404846,
0.23677721619606018,
0.09014518558979034,
-0.12937743961811066,
0.39427831768989563,
-0.16824960708618164,
-0.3679575026035309,
0.5924682021141052,
0.3535114824771881,
0.03501012176275253,
0.11151517182588577,
-0.3552951514720917,
-0.0077561368234455585,
-0.7503119707107544,
0.3918348252773285,
0.1931135207414627,
0.4282695949077606,
0.007437958847731352,
0.4034454822540283,
-0.38054314255714417,
0.5821518301963806,
0.38280901312828064,
-0.05065202713012695,
-0.06295367330312729,
-0.13421586155891418,
-0.25206390023231506,
-0.053584933280944824,
0.6402866244316101,
0.44976097345352173,
0.30431869626045227,
-0.22302474081516266,
-0.1026938259601593,
0.21896450221538544,
0.36263713240623474,
-0.8301213979721069,
-0.2839387059211731,
0.10921448469161987,
-0.11005236208438873,
-0.725605309009552,
-0.010676620528101921,
-0.41167446970939636,
-0.6938655972480774,
-0.31286197900772095,
0.1666756123304367,
-0.4144878089427948,
-0.35364800691604614,
0.04223702475428581,
0.03239425644278526,
0.003210862400010228,
0.5519145727157593,
-0.8711089491844177,
0.5348868370056152,
0.8098086714744568,
0.3728620707988739,
-0.42371630668640137,
-0.06556592881679535,
-0.8036212921142578,
0.18557296693325043,
-0.3948521614074707,
0.6172538995742798,
-0.3188517689704895,
-0.612601101398468,
-0.09330152720212936,
-0.09932436048984528,
0.23998239636421204,
-0.9213609099388123,
0.7235896587371826,
-0.42004692554473877,
0.10387628525495529,
-0.2621499300003052,
-0.19592849910259247,
-0.23057974874973297,
0.2692808210849762,
-0.24956850707530975,
0.7292697429656982,
0.16678541898727417,
-0.6405006647109985,
0.26893189549446106,
-0.30438506603240967,
-0.5616519451141357,
0.0010067373514175415,
-0.05405792221426964,
-0.3657093644142151,
-0.03343803435564041,
0.1708851009607315,
0.46079152822494507,
-0.0016603142721578479,
0.5140420794487,
-0.5044363737106323,
-0.4165098965167999,
0.3873797059059143,
-0.61981600522995,
0.6036979556083679,
0.1738375872373581,
-0.3589182496070862,
0.5793672800064087,
-0.7025840282440186,
0.0023804751690477133,
-0.21182061731815338,
-0.5258926153182983,
-0.27520835399627686,
-0.1412581503391266,
-0.010898645035922527,
0.18864648044109344,
0.1376437097787857,
-0.16378986835479736,
-0.15731827914714813,
-0.5865203738212585,
0.3018658459186554,
0.8295087218284607,
0.3151709735393524,
0.6951432824134827,
-0.6313111782073975,
0.5014509558677673,
0.061782367527484894,
0.3515281081199646,
-0.11770743876695633,
-0.3983544111251831,
-0.8770274519920349,
-0.48674821853637695,
-0.05825896933674812,
0.6613739728927612,
-0.6701831221580505,
0.6019943356513977,
-0.18162637948989868,
-0.4313821494579315,
-0.2803419828414917,
0.4072719216346741,
0.6755483150482178,
0.7828910946846008,
0.2998366355895996,
-0.31674474477767944,
-0.5332799553871155,
-0.9818325042724609,
-0.21564540266990662,
-0.24407394230365753,
0.004049359820783138,
0.4815092980861664,
-0.2409442514181137,
-0.5092854499816895,
0.9093995690345764,
-0.2965686023235321,
-0.32035186886787415,
-0.2298700362443924,
-0.11427345871925354,
0.05030065402388573,
0.447602242231369,
0.2559122145175934,
-0.6154931783676147,
-0.4721251428127289,
0.21005946397781372,
-0.5930794477462769,
-0.32464200258255005,
-0.0822644978761673,
0.010698718950152397,
0.3957470655441284,
0.3721263110637665,
-0.6675822734832764,
0.25243332982063293,
0.27645230293273926,
-0.2852573096752167,
0.49918264150619507,
-0.29511842131614685,
0.13734948635101318,
-0.7112157344818115,
-0.08184341341257095,
0.1319180577993393,
-0.41084691882133484,
-0.9014754891395569,
0.16193602979183197,
0.13106639683246613,
-0.0927116796374321,
-0.5194923281669617,
0.5119587779045105,
-0.14748439192771912,
0.21037252247333527,
-0.3472713530063629,
-0.12168559432029724,
-0.12423048168420792,
0.7101893424987793,
0.048954129219055176,
0.773032546043396,
0.48524314165115356,
-1.0187870264053345,
0.2729114294052124,
0.022301675751805305,
0.18755199015140533,
0.5514663457870483,
-0.727030873298645,
-0.12938536703586578,
-0.09440094977617264,
0.3011535704135895,
-0.865511417388916,
-0.31636369228363037,
0.40120649337768555,
-0.405165433883667,
0.24924980103969574,
-0.14729905128479004,
-0.1449737846851349,
-0.04942667484283447,
-0.3832450807094574,
-0.011787006631493568,
0.6254574656486511,
-0.31689783930778503,
0.5607444643974304,
0.240752711892128,
-0.2489585131406784,
-0.5515101552009583,
-0.6129339337348938,
0.16709661483764648,
-0.399627685546875,
-0.543987512588501,
0.2364652454853058,
-0.11208391189575195,
-0.3097535967826843,
-0.20512567460536957,
-0.2211724817752838,
-0.003767949528992176,
0.4097368121147156,
0.44478708505630493,
0.34890472888946533,
-0.07646521180868149,
0.03699791431427002,
0.16660137474536896,
-0.22046269476413727,
0.11874822527170181,
0.02509782649576664,
0.3906770348548889,
-0.28253260254859924,
-0.3513725996017456,
-0.5208576917648315,
0.004277184139937162,
0.5068165063858032,
-0.10260799527168274,
0.4391048550605774,
0.6480399966239929,
-0.08861450850963593,
-0.2670873701572418,
-0.5801016688346863,
-0.4697253406047821,
-0.526330292224884,
0.4738651216030121,
-0.053243279457092285,
-1.321494221687317,
0.4389322102069855,
0.0024073217064142227,
0.1702396273612976,
0.10071701556444168,
0.46341168880462646,
0.05531366169452667,
1.2022274732589722,
0.5231513381004333,
-0.0749494805932045,
0.7429549098014832,
0.22128726541996002,
0.1453111171722412,
-0.5439477562904358,
-0.22413873672485352,
-0.2914339601993561,
0.04388891160488129,
-0.6167927384376526,
-0.15175077319145203,
0.34775838255882263,
0.2636774182319641,
-0.5641567707061768,
0.20700550079345703,
-0.5062344670295715,
0.21434356272220612,
0.42778897285461426,
0.44685450196266174,
0.5108155608177185,
0.1607372909784317,
0.11359255015850067,
-0.1682165116071701,
-0.5403684973716736,
-0.2517598271369934,
0.9111294746398926,
0.7533408999443054,
1.1193056106567383,
0.19211696088314056,
0.7750397324562073,
0.30459335446357727,
0.567825973033905,
-0.9240856766700745,
0.5244120359420776,
-0.032138410955667496,
-0.3956301510334015,
-0.30568909645080566,
-0.7114580869674683,
-0.8310113549232483,
0.35483017563819885,
-0.3493858277797699,
-0.6981244683265686,
-0.10040722787380219,
0.37071987986564636,
-0.5604579448699951,
-0.1551670879125595,
-0.988236665725708,
0.5341269373893738,
-0.4310202896595001,
-0.6424775719642639,
-0.36338311433792114,
-0.5133770108222961,
0.7077789306640625,
0.03400605171918869,
0.19807560741901398,
0.0893489420413971,
-0.1933375746011734,
0.35424819588661194,
-0.048922132700681686,
1.1107144355773926,
-0.30191707611083984,
-0.5507725477218628,
0.08010955899953842,
0.2450520396232605,
0.6018274426460266,
0.22987577319145203,
0.10826471447944641,
-0.1580944061279297,
-0.06878125667572021,
-0.1629178822040558,
-0.7947688698768616,
0.7640860080718994,
-0.7542654871940613,
-0.9577447772026062,
-0.0826476514339447,
-0.4781465232372284,
-0.5655099153518677,
0.32552212476730347,
-0.08305230736732483,
0.08047346025705338,
-0.4075752794742584,
0.37340685725212097,
1.1535156965255737,
-0.4078003168106079,
-0.04136215150356293,
0.6421257257461548,
-0.5015239715576172,
-0.6301228404045105,
0.8814359307289124,
-0.2785675823688507,
0.5831160545349121,
0.3116734027862549,
0.2635002136230469,
-0.28981253504753113,
-0.4054521918296814,
-0.15417572855949402,
0.07316998392343521,
-0.6481398344039917,
-0.2588692307472229,
-0.8750531077384949,
-0.2543213665485382,
-0.49646931886672974,
-0.04295664280653,
-0.17121522128582,
-0.3811732530593872,
-0.44390174746513367,
-0.19517581164836884,
0.219063401222229,
0.6095216870307922,
-0.0856272503733635,
0.3776279091835022,
-0.8102656006813049,
0.4119851589202881,
0.48651236295700073,
0.2315494865179062,
0.1483522206544876,
-0.599277138710022,
-0.09019491076469421,
0.25387829542160034,
-0.5735244750976562,
-0.5532038807868958,
0.18566273152828217,
0.012403476051986217,
0.7071160674095154,
0.6103029251098633,
0.1589125692844391,
0.6132895350456238,
-0.06385863572359085,
0.6114411950111389,
0.4130273759365082,
-0.6854946613311768,
0.4037468731403351,
-0.768528163433075,
0.06407618522644043,
0.49383941292762756,
-0.02811109460890293,
-0.4411429762840271,
-0.5543548464775085,
-0.7257708311080933,
-0.7598810791969299,
0.5741584300994873,
-0.036253251135349274,
0.5041980147361755,
0.006668529007583857,
0.12451498210430145,
-0.022837793454527855,
0.21312379837036133,
-0.6674720048904419,
-0.21473312377929688,
-0.12172578275203705,
-0.017780927941203117,
-0.04034850373864174,
-0.2725316286087036,
-0.30394020676612854,
-0.3337322473526001,
0.7786645889282227,
0.058933075517416,
0.004284291062504053,
0.002125547733157873,
-0.053355615586042404,
-0.24884718656539917,
0.4870137572288513,
0.7405462265014648,
0.33146217465400696,
-0.19928963482379913,
0.11580761522054672,
0.3437514901161194,
-0.2740503251552582,
0.020664071664214134,
0.08140911906957626,
-0.0662272647023201,
-0.3846953213214874,
0.18911679089069366,
0.6476887464523315,
0.515856921672821,
-0.7412953972816467,
0.4348827004432678,
0.06810936331748962,
-0.30148646235466003,
-0.03133155405521393,
0.6914783716201782,
0.17376400530338287,
0.2295876294374466,
0.260348916053772,
0.3408310115337372,
0.016733065247535706,
-0.3289807140827179,
0.4975142180919647,
0.6043176651000977,
-0.7954480648040771,
-0.03318613022565842,
0.47988632321357727,
0.3695354461669922,
-0.2603929042816162,
0.18682464957237244,
0.027930893003940582,
-0.39526841044425964,
0.5109114050865173,
0.5398685932159424,
0.7545474171638489,
-0.022378571331501007,
0.2419317066669464,
0.17316333949565887,
0.21767167747020721,
-0.09654764086008072,
-0.16425535082817078,
-0.3096279501914978,
-0.8285921216011047,
-0.2332109808921814,
-0.2604985237121582,
-0.42646855115890503,
0.2663334906101227,
-0.7627725601196289,
0.22262461483478546,
-0.8832482099533081,
-0.28638526797294617,
-0.22378376126289368,
-0.05551595613360405,
-0.4880208969116211,
-0.01562632992863655,
-0.06791882961988449,
0.6674760580062866,
-0.6096587777137756,
0.7814905047416687,
0.6031696200370789,
-0.37543004751205444,
-0.8356945514678955,
0.0018768856534734368,
-0.09310845285654068,
-0.8473933339118958,
0.6157993078231812,
-0.00908746849745512,
-0.3295658826828003,
0.0729728490114212,
-0.5772067904472351,
-0.4974963665008545,
1.0469224452972412,
0.4730059802532196,
-0.4711799621582031,
0.03191526234149933,
0.009561252780258656,
0.7830017805099487,
-0.11691531538963318,
0.07905802130699158,
0.5198220014572144,
0.32703885436058044,
0.1311040222644806,
-0.856208860874176,
0.10154186189174652,
-0.028882181271910667,
0.04196795076131821,
0.015837160870432854,
-0.5034881234169006,
0.48297151923179626,
-0.27172794938087463,
-0.391804575920105,
0.11915237456560135,
0.6431108713150024,
0.4781564474105835,
0.14251621067523956,
0.49489131569862366,
0.5834178924560547,
0.6696927547454834,
0.1435910314321518,
0.8138816952705383,
-0.07017511874437332,
0.09519629180431366,
1.2151216268539429,
-0.3141161799430847,
0.5804567933082581,
0.5391395688056946,
0.0033893517684191465,
0.27185001969337463,
0.40927571058273315,
0.16917040944099426,
0.623006284236908,
0.26008349657058716,
-0.39430859684944153,
-0.4588695466518402,
-0.41352275013923645,
-0.4214237332344055,
0.1864546835422516,
0.4055749475955963,
-0.1610696166753769,
-0.4839821457862854,
-0.0907934233546257,
0.0993354320526123,
0.2841147184371948,
-0.22339116036891937,
1.0804121494293213,
0.2205197513103485,
-0.825117290019989,
0.8715066909790039,
0.03258908540010452,
1.1658886671066284,
-0.6422833204269409,
-0.14389438927173615,
-0.24751147627830505,
0.4433598220348358,
-0.40805914998054504,
-0.7222318649291992,
0.19071827828884125,
0.021198712289333344,
-0.05115244537591934,
-0.28434258699417114,
0.9869946837425232,
-0.44388213753700256,
-0.12285739928483963,
0.40849778056144714,
0.5053728222846985,
-0.22512264549732208,
-0.04732241481542587,
-0.7644419074058533,
-0.12577112019062042,
0.19053035974502563,
-0.03262928128242493,
0.5020312070846558,
0.4884924590587616,
-0.2294939011335373,
0.8957617878913879,
0.7579101324081421,
0.08661134541034698,
-0.13040603697299957,
0.2808574438095093,
0.9680226445198059,
-0.40138790011405945,
-0.4814192056655884,
-0.6839246153831482,
0.5164867639541626,
0.06350339204072952,
-0.13284245133399963,
0.7389262318611145,
0.2634349465370178,
0.7514196038246155,
-0.018757043406367302,
0.8932170867919922,
0.2879348397254944,
0.5528616309165955,
-0.28798627853393555,
0.6658324599266052,
-0.2789973020553589,
0.5230357646942139,
-0.31864479184150696,
-0.6951450109481812,
-0.3304715156555176,
0.46101921796798706,
-0.27612540125846863,
0.07846641540527344,
0.3043871819972992,
1.0799261331558228,
-0.038600530475378036,
-0.11770111322402954,
0.5707975029945374,
-0.025520948693156242,
0.6076201796531677,
0.5392112135887146,
1.0987133979797363,
-0.052764181047677994,
0.6353164911270142,
-0.22281305491924286,
-0.4703035056591034,
-0.17165875434875488,
-0.7986317276954651,
-1.0273158550262451,
-0.142406165599823,
-0.05840902775526047,
-0.5941572189331055,
0.12480461597442627,
0.9221253991127014,
0.5795682668685913,
-0.92213374376297,
-0.11807485669851303,
-0.43426021933555603,
0.1583029329776764,
-0.26389360427856445,
-0.2932201325893402,
-0.20893460512161255,
-0.5767918825149536,
-0.24990566074848175,
0.34715017676353455,
0.12437069416046143,
0.17333990335464478,
-0.17072515189647675,
-0.5134039521217346,
0.28705528378486633,
-0.1795264631509781,
0.6407187581062317,
0.35343918204307556,
-0.8112002015113831,
-0.31600865721702576,
0.043013181537389755,
-0.442798912525177,
-0.12335675209760666,
0.6945218443870544,
-0.625320315361023,
0.0990900918841362,
0.2651776671409607,
0.9232924580574036,
0.2870684266090393,
0.2899232506752014,
0.7343592047691345,
-0.6629825234413147,
0.10471133142709732,
0.24467608332633972,
-0.003145380411297083,
0.3039979636669159,
-0.7032368779182434,
0.3435574173927307,
0.036616191267967224,
-0.441890150308609,
-0.6971674561500549,
0.49060869216918945,
-1.011534333229065,
-0.35589921474456787,
1.4155166149139404,
0.013497631065547466,
0.17804822325706482,
-0.22138461470603943,
-0.5814452171325684,
0.30903199315071106,
-0.7231835722923279,
0.861926794052124,
0.461944043636322,
-0.281823068857193,
-0.2790193557739258,
-0.35174909234046936,
0.7481817603111267,
0.5672664046287537,
-0.8478466868400574,
0.37199974060058594,
0.6962200999259949,
0.4742254316806793,
-0.006797879468649626,
0.7398761510848999,
-0.056873805820941925,
0.2997150421142578,
-0.4457714557647705,
-0.19111014902591705,
-0.44246718287467957,
-0.3282603323459625,
-0.5724788904190063,
-0.03651297092437744,
0.4816156327724457,
0.07701083272695541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02509v1
|
SPUQ: Perturbation-Based Uncertainty Quantification for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-04T21:55:22 | 2024-03-04T21:55:22 |
Xiang Gao, Jiaxin Zhang, Lalla Mouatadid, Kamalika Das
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have become increasingly
prevalent, offering remarkable text generation capabilities. However, a
pressing challenge is their tendency to make confidently wrong predictions,
highlighting the critical need for uncertainty quantification (UQ) in LLMs.
While previous works have mainly focused on addressing aleatoric uncertainty,
the full spectrum of uncertainties, including epistemic, remains inadequately
explored. Motivated by this gap, we introduce a novel UQ method, sampling with
perturbation for UQ (SPUQ), designed to tackle both aleatoric and epistemic
uncertainties. The method entails generating a set of perturbations for LLM
inputs, sampling outputs for each perturbation, and incorporating an
aggregation module that generalizes the sampling uncertainty approach for text
generation tasks. Through extensive experiments on various datasets, we
investigated different perturbation and aggregation techniques. Our findings
show a substantial improvement in model uncertainty calibration, with a
reduction in Expected Calibration Error (ECE) by 50\% on average. Our findings
suggest that our proposed UQ method offers promising steps toward enhancing the
reliability and trustworthiness of LLMs.
|
[
-0.15327133238315582,
-1.1859291791915894,
0.8001369833946228,
0.13788147270679474,
-0.22966283559799194,
0.12588760256767273,
-0.24750161170959473,
0.12348316609859467,
0.002961297519505024,
0.5331571102142334,
-0.25586822628974915,
-0.39303433895111084,
-0.4923161566257477,
-0.16421416401863098,
-0.3726275861263275,
0.854487419128418,
0.08158235251903534,
-0.08678083121776581,
-0.40439513325691223,
0.02437097579240799,
0.04463474079966545,
-0.5757089853286743,
-0.4537593424320221,
-0.2646820843219757,
0.44452810287475586,
0.39054420590400696,
0.8103936314582825,
0.35673877596855164,
0.05811445415019989,
0.1920652538537979,
-0.3304980397224426,
0.21683436632156372,
-0.4591769576072693,
0.4121847450733185,
0.15085476636886597,
-0.47784823179244995,
-0.27867817878723145,
-0.15587705373764038,
0.9255084991455078,
0.7515895962715149,
-0.5703919529914856,
0.31036341190338135,
-0.0957922637462616,
0.41108953952789307,
-0.8871107697486877,
-0.27071458101272583,
-0.7507346868515015,
-0.024945827201008797,
-0.29042163491249084,
-0.18202047049999237,
-0.47157397866249084,
-0.12034149467945099,
-0.20410920679569244,
-0.5953278541564941,
-0.058079320937395096,
0.039455000311136246,
0.8562669157981873,
0.5423623323440552,
-0.553808331489563,
0.06347034871578217,
-0.9543220400810242,
1.0369096994400024,
-0.8908901810646057,
0.3837108314037323,
0.43648430705070496,
-0.03726968914270401,
-0.3911917507648468,
-0.8233070373535156,
-0.6854041218757629,
-0.10326200723648071,
0.2831651270389557,
0.11606702208518982,
-0.031996484845876694,
-0.05711193010210991,
0.11397669464349747,
0.4478110373020172,
-0.16436032950878143,
0.10116789489984512,
0.07793807238340378,
-0.3703942596912384,
0.7271134257316589,
-0.015374002046883106,
0.19672326743602753,
0.14914408326148987,
-0.4766382575035095,
-0.29916173219680786,
-1.0516833066940308,
0.09116439521312714,
0.8509941101074219,
0.10886368155479431,
0.23855486512184143,
0.5231413245201111,
-0.09572692960500717,
0.6267486214637756,
0.03762246295809746,
0.07418085634708405,
-0.0529780350625515,
-0.11445093899965286,
-0.3438034951686859,
-0.1841253936290741,
0.9869505763053894,
-0.028743617236614227,
-0.08829982578754425,
0.20518887042999268,
-0.34577423334121704,
-0.2898327708244324,
-0.0021944884210824966,
-0.5424146056175232,
-0.3225269019603729,
0.6165122985839844,
0.18342436850070953,
-0.37287643551826477,
0.04400038719177246,
-0.8446767926216125,
-0.45994243025779724,
-0.01257641613483429,
0.536556601524353,
-0.40856751799583435,
-0.2962121367454529,
0.11655893921852112,
0.3087790906429291,
-0.13382571935653687,
0.4460197687149048,
-0.5676257014274597,
0.06003547087311745,
0.3298550546169281,
0.08558867871761322,
0.11170729249715805,
-0.5179702639579773,
-0.6570869088172913,
0.08117993175983429,
-0.44313639402389526,
0.9780178070068359,
-0.4269186854362488,
-0.37557315826416016,
0.014817653223872185,
-0.7345179319381714,
0.14594490826129913,
-0.12572665512561798,
0.5915277600288391,
-0.36880260705947876,
0.08434146642684937,
0.1292153149843216,
-0.7399813532829285,
0.10514163970947266,
0.10117722302675247,
-0.6974818706512451,
1.5547016859054565,
0.19267402589321136,
-0.864082396030426,
0.0995941236615181,
-0.07474489510059357,
-0.2623465657234192,
0.22053216397762299,
-0.5520247220993042,
-0.7581337690353394,
0.40286046266555786,
0.35743996500968933,
0.4349318742752075,
-0.4563616216182709,
0.3468362092971802,
-0.1876027137041092,
-0.32165899872779846,
0.737857460975647,
-0.7152058482170105,
0.6764897108078003,
0.3469139337539673,
-0.004036301746964455,
0.09142753481864929,
-0.7713009715080261,
0.3455730676651001,
-0.05293605104088783,
-0.4819040596485138,
-0.3494132161140442,
0.2625666558742523,
-0.10711680352687836,
-0.1955801248550415,
0.2529439330101013,
-0.44996052980422974,
-0.00009512810356682166,
-0.3121054768562317,
0.2831653952598572,
0.6515122652053833,
0.37957167625427246,
0.40162476897239685,
-0.17603756487369537,
0.5932435989379883,
-0.04067293182015419,
-0.004254885483533144,
-0.2047705054283142,
-0.5444201827049255,
-0.549777626991272,
-0.344023734331131,
0.6059256792068481,
0.3405602276325226,
-0.7783367037773132,
0.7109546661376953,
-0.12427877634763718,
-0.6873705983161926,
-0.4535011053085327,
-0.14289018511772156,
0.2472299188375473,
0.11694221198558807,
0.21317996084690094,
0.12500137090682983,
-0.2400042712688446,
-0.4155965745449066,
-0.5022294521331787,
-0.590157151222229,
-0.4023795425891876,
0.1224890872836113,
0.1853124350309372,
-0.1856921762228012,
0.868493378162384,
-0.42883339524269104,
0.08956947177648544,
0.01589922048151493,
0.3107459843158722,
0.037013281136751175,
0.3759392201900482,
0.18420609831809998,
-0.7530310153961182,
-0.30870264768600464,
-0.1719144880771637,
-0.22864310443401337,
-0.21060994267463684,
-0.17959167063236237,
-0.06136436387896538,
0.21818289160728455,
0.5016497373580933,
-0.573922872543335,
0.5374013781547546,
0.7193154096603394,
-0.4791569411754608,
0.6547708511352539,
-0.2219303697347641,
0.18741527199745178,
-1.1236737966537476,
-0.10268834978342056,
-0.03546427562832832,
-0.2744203209877014,
-0.6195886135101318,
0.5261877775192261,
0.10231627523899078,
0.11653930693864822,
-0.49987903237342834,
0.40692853927612305,
-0.3740815222263336,
0.1276954561471939,
0.11933467537164688,
-0.09133421629667282,
-0.10114353150129318,
0.04593205079436302,
-0.1898040622472763,
0.5106717348098755,
0.5795751810073853,
-0.6816810965538025,
0.37247657775878906,
0.0738285705447197,
-0.2358870953321457,
0.45501571893692017,
-0.48263102769851685,
0.2656973600387573,
-0.1418013572692871,
0.48079681396484375,
-1.274267554283142,
-0.2504960596561432,
-0.08118995279073715,
-0.7584782242774963,
0.2974211573600769,
0.04280944541096687,
-0.5283480286598206,
-0.03433825448155403,
-0.20846109092235565,
0.42989712953567505,
0.1741916686296463,
-0.1918533891439438,
0.9661116600036621,
0.4162241518497467,
-0.22074156999588013,
-0.767987072467804,
-0.7236312627792358,
-0.13719512522220612,
-0.23990938067436218,
-0.3517545163631439,
0.055875398218631744,
-0.27968689799308777,
-0.3530588448047638,
-0.2357500195503235,
-0.3132053017616272,
0.02145780809223652,
0.39880844950675964,
0.04567829892039299,
0.17139314115047455,
0.0275732334703207,
0.18760079145431519,
0.3045712411403656,
0.11735831946134567,
-0.1709059625864029,
-0.260692298412323,
0.5950310826301575,
0.030574867501854897,
-0.35338494181632996,
-0.3071143329143524,
0.2240116447210312,
0.38379013538360596,
-0.2819889187812805,
0.5565980076789856,
0.6634686589241028,
-0.4411587119102478,
-0.5820416808128357,
-0.6064004302024841,
-0.30324167013168335,
-0.42669376730918884,
0.3763403594493866,
-0.4670167863368988,
-0.9688013195991516,
0.510096549987793,
-0.11959146708250046,
0.014894089661538601,
0.49014171957969666,
0.7719281315803528,
-0.20120468735694885,
0.7015899419784546,
0.3646073341369629,
0.014331405982375145,
0.3691120147705078,
0.14931164681911469,
0.1268775910139084,
-0.5483796000480652,
0.22371825575828552,
-0.6719347834587097,
0.12999828159809113,
-0.4176861345767975,
-0.6806750893592834,
0.4118911027908325,
0.19972695410251617,
-0.43203672766685486,
-0.035356421023607254,
-0.2899629473686218,
0.3964737057685852,
0.49927818775177,
-0.04299282282590866,
0.41490456461906433,
0.32805588841438293,
-0.39802485704421997,
-0.01833229511976242,
-0.6053288578987122,
-0.5834509134292603,
1.2519071102142334,
0.4144749939441681,
0.9386838674545288,
0.27846333384513855,
0.6592938899993896,
0.10759074240922928,
0.2070249766111374,
-0.6204841136932373,
0.4497300088405609,
-0.021661287173628807,
-0.6131060123443604,
-0.8072733879089355,
-0.8304445147514343,
-0.7278195023536682,
0.16202959418296814,
-0.4685896635055542,
-1.0969165563583374,
0.039405304938554764,
0.2512089014053345,
-0.8898826241493225,
0.40737706422805786,
-0.36124473810195923,
0.3405146896839142,
0.05207555368542671,
-0.2478751540184021,
0.1091708168387413,
-0.5767261385917664,
0.10978677868843079,
-0.3535703718662262,
0.31193065643310547,
-0.10563823580741882,
-0.1665629744529724,
0.27613478899002075,
-0.3167145848274231,
0.6235252618789673,
0.043884292244911194,
-0.5083045363426208,
0.6529021859169006,
0.3742274045944214,
0.7450636029243469,
0.43193480372428894,
-0.3009122610092163,
0.0799163430929184,
0.1765250265598297,
-0.38356029987335205,
-0.4984566569328308,
0.6006190180778503,
-0.807343602180481,
-0.3275523781776428,
-0.40793555974960327,
-0.6567848324775696,
-0.5613436102867126,
0.02239825204014778,
0.7017402648925781,
0.20969104766845703,
-0.05979415401816368,
0.33196738362312317,
0.9365290999412537,
-0.4660595953464508,
0.2858828902244568,
0.5101262927055359,
-0.30936193466186523,
-0.4441923499107361,
0.6722169518470764,
0.11610031872987747,
0.39530351758003235,
0.5633273124694824,
0.2896735370159149,
-0.2014881670475006,
-0.5962993502616882,
-0.4430105984210968,
0.024940498173236847,
-0.33149057626724243,
-0.4172671139240265,
-0.4067193865776062,
-0.18272599577903748,
-0.5341174006462097,
0.23782330751419067,
-0.6817306280136108,
-0.47134676575660706,
-0.34337329864501953,
-0.19454903900623322,
0.32290947437286377,
0.4884343445301056,
0.11341902613639832,
0.5148212313652039,
-0.8943725824356079,
-0.050294071435928345,
0.3358493447303772,
0.3084504306316376,
-0.3481833040714264,
-0.6916993260383606,
-0.14040842652320862,
0.1486969143152237,
-0.21290923655033112,
-0.9693204760551453,
0.3540988564491272,
0.27759793400764465,
0.6087271571159363,
0.33955180644989014,
0.44025301933288574,
0.4251564145088196,
-0.31728309392929077,
1.072981357574463,
0.002583593362942338,
-1.0615283250808716,
0.26332810521125793,
-0.39631155133247375,
0.20172685384750366,
0.5672343373298645,
0.33299627900123596,
-0.39238762855529785,
-0.771399199962616,
-0.8823297023773193,
-1.2251399755477905,
0.3258902430534363,
0.42832911014556885,
0.22925303876399994,
0.23848672211170197,
0.4838085472583771,
-0.20984217524528503,
0.2759323716163635,
-0.5252395868301392,
-0.45799389481544495,
0.17010708153247833,
-0.3383396565914154,
-0.115657277405262,
-0.45868706703186035,
-0.01661182940006256,
-0.0400831401348114,
0.8149498701095581,
-0.19747844338417053,
0.36526423692703247,
0.22393296658992767,
-0.06178895756602287,
-0.6022513508796692,
0.35073256492614746,
0.3458397090435028,
0.5276394486427307,
-0.15283523499965668,
0.1606265753507614,
0.21475332975387573,
-0.4716871380805969,
0.14450857043266296,
0.29334011673927307,
-0.36591076850891113,
-0.11466535180807114,
-0.06358170509338379,
0.6403965353965759,
0.023080773651599884,
-0.7608660459518433,
0.47377923130989075,
-0.27758514881134033,
-0.05404137820005417,
-0.5047750473022461,
-0.2054179310798645,
-0.003153124824166298,
0.07383030652999878,
0.8162126541137695,
-0.14987140893936157,
-0.04952097684144974,
-0.3357476592063904,
0.3697572350502014,
0.01366688683629036,
-0.2729787528514862,
-0.15933747589588165,
0.7144631147384644,
-0.06557394564151764,
-0.15095917880535126,
0.40967053174972534,
-0.13783180713653564,
-0.3827442526817322,
0.42611005902290344,
0.5333176255226135,
0.4210492670536041,
-0.6379913091659546,
0.18298675119876862,
0.27669620513916016,
0.3169782757759094,
-0.27141132950782776,
0.38958922028541565,
0.20168864727020264,
-1.1507179737091064,
-0.6762469410896301,
-0.8284939527511597,
-0.6066051721572876,
0.34347525238990784,
-0.6957754492759705,
0.01893024891614914,
-0.3293949067592621,
-0.3169083297252655,
-0.26897162199020386,
0.11993245035409927,
-0.1914636790752411,
0.5288804769515991,
0.14477461576461792,
0.5421643853187561,
-0.8091030120849609,
0.8169735074043274,
1.1406211853027344,
-0.25448086857795715,
-1.3314465284347534,
0.42322635650634766,
0.03339603543281555,
-0.28216981887817383,
-0.10462632030248642,
-0.5021838545799255,
-0.013284128159284592,
0.3904637396335602,
-0.7643142342567444,
-0.9184198975563049,
0.9556246995925903,
0.4776632785797119,
-0.6061501502990723,
0.11484576016664505,
0.07181637734174728,
0.3983162045478821,
0.05131561681628227,
0.2556386888027191,
0.5844386219978333,
0.41672196984291077,
0.18873071670532227,
-0.4672633707523346,
0.048491187393665314,
0.07604535669088364,
0.14200977981090546,
0.3069656193256378,
-0.7105368375778198,
1.1034876108169556,
0.048597488552331924,
-0.33582326769828796,
0.4344043433666229,
0.9607656002044678,
0.6286860704421997,
0.012887569144368172,
0.5666176676750183,
0.7558027505874634,
1.1088343858718872,
-0.17212657630443573,
1.0694262981414795,
-0.3642962872982025,
0.6896273493766785,
1.3212249279022217,
-0.21505886316299438,
1.0530983209609985,
0.7939820885658264,
-0.5759028792381287,
0.08654603362083435,
0.6581653356552124,
0.3351058065891266,
-0.18453802168369293,
0.3366430401802063,
-0.5357534289360046,
-0.5082855820655823,
0.22793042659759521,
-0.10737918317317963,
0.3859110176563263,
0.7595403790473938,
-0.16231802105903625,
0.09763253480195999,
-0.30383995175361633,
0.21682068705558777,
0.3641170859336853,
-0.20082178711891174,
0.480020135641098,
0.04902735352516174,
-0.6568675637245178,
0.38120511174201965,
0.09725115448236465,
0.5898362994194031,
-0.4518141448497772,
0.25400200486183167,
-0.2760132849216461,
0.14013192057609558,
-0.09674972295761108,
-0.7308509349822998,
-0.04981032758951187,
-0.12611046433448792,
0.3194521367549896,
-0.07219456881284714,
0.5651817321777344,
-0.6409550309181213,
-0.7163675427436829,
-0.10856888443231583,
0.6380214691162109,
0.1262807548046112,
-0.33227381110191345,
-0.24014773964881897,
0.0653674304485321,
0.272357314825058,
-0.5307635068893433,
0.22363518178462982,
0.6509031057357788,
0.16609156131744385,
0.447526216506958,
0.4629843235015869,
0.4792666733264923,
0.12543033063411713,
-0.07861879467964172,
0.6350833177566528,
-0.31422287225723267,
-0.24921713769435883,
-0.6972569227218628,
0.6189445853233337,
0.18057608604431152,
-0.5808351039886475,
0.7344656586647034,
0.29543396830558777,
0.772175669670105,
0.028450634330511093,
0.8178173899650574,
0.06185031309723854,
0.5759400129318237,
-0.4379045367240906,
0.8820537328720093,
-0.5586069822311401,
0.5040293335914612,
-0.2640773057937622,
-0.9895929098129272,
-0.7177329063415527,
0.661867618560791,
-0.010911463759839535,
-0.162659153342247,
0.6133065819740295,
0.7638580799102783,
0.2823082506656647,
-0.1658754050731659,
0.6831963658332825,
0.4253736436367035,
0.19328667223453522,
0.24773168563842773,
1.0610134601593018,
-0.6483343243598938,
0.5326244831085205,
-0.18715089559555054,
-0.22237662971019745,
-0.05879504606127739,
-0.9073463678359985,
-0.3750041127204895,
-0.6026971936225891,
-0.31429028511047363,
-0.581794023513794,
0.017817996442317963,
1.0434633493423462,
0.46842360496520996,
-0.7888702154159546,
-0.20063428580760956,
-0.05647185072302818,
0.008049007505178452,
-0.20233024656772614,
-0.21012750267982483,
0.2996220290660858,
-0.2296220064163208,
-0.940240204334259,
0.32600685954093933,
-0.09456321597099304,
0.07829443365335464,
-0.3357285261154175,
0.1347346305847168,
-0.348418265581131,
0.6128284335136414,
0.31677547097206116,
0.1360066831111908,
-0.4621438682079315,
-0.14937502145767212,
-0.3371049761772156,
-0.11725325137376785,
-0.11549950391054153,
0.6624625325202942,
-0.5375813841819763,
0.33400243520736694,
0.43021583557128906,
0.7154161334037781,
0.4953259825706482,
0.16210347414016724,
0.7975072264671326,
-1.1439777612686157,
0.08719278872013092,
0.44472968578338623,
0.4534280300140381,
0.28884294629096985,
-0.4997387230396271,
0.2822086215019226,
-0.007016549352556467,
-0.7991371154785156,
-0.9980254173278809,
0.48517775535583496,
-0.649652361869812,
-0.3092178702354431,
1.4271334409713745,
-0.427692174911499,
-0.3313356935977936,
0.08809925615787506,
-0.0989542081952095,
0.47321817278862,
-0.634192168712616,
0.6558103561401367,
0.7025328278541565,
0.25796830654144287,
-0.040645502507686615,
-0.3015597462654114,
0.34470000863075256,
0.5727974772453308,
-0.7518073916435242,
0.0886484757065773,
0.6674872636795044,
0.1445324569940567,
0.13110491633415222,
0.37942031025886536,
-0.11529196053743362,
0.12061161547899246,
0.05482295900583267,
0.16208507120609283,
0.20819154381752014,
-0.2531045377254486,
-0.3321082293987274,
0.25098052620887756,
0.29240942001342773,
0.2853851020336151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02504v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02504v1
|
A Tutorial on the Pretrain-Finetune Paradigm for Natural Language Processing
| 2024-03-04T21:51:11 | 2024-03-04T21:51:11 |
Yu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The pretrain-finetune paradigm represents a transformative approach in
natural language processing (NLP). This paradigm distinguishes itself through
the use of large pretrained language models, demonstrating remarkable
efficiency in finetuning tasks, even with limited training data. This
efficiency is especially beneficial for research in social sciences, where the
number of annotated samples is often quite limited. Our tutorial offers a
comprehensive introduction to the pretrain-finetune paradigm. We first delve
into the fundamental concepts of pretraining and finetuning, followed by
practical exercises using real-world applications. We demonstrate the
application of the paradigm across various tasks, including multi-class
classification and regression. Emphasizing its efficacy and user-friendliness,
the tutorial aims to encourage broader adoption of this paradigm. To this end,
we have provided open access to all our code and datasets. The tutorial is
particularly valuable for quantitative researchers in psychology, offering them
an insightful guide into this innovative approach.
|
[
-0.6646022200584412,
-0.8899509906768799,
0.29711905121803284,
0.41773518919944763,
-0.1665913462638855,
-0.07096649706363678,
-0.6890872120857239,
-0.3510603606700897,
-0.03255227953195572,
0.33071523904800415,
-0.6593648195266724,
-0.42466166615486145,
-0.4301792085170746,
0.14918546378612518,
-0.4137229025363922,
1.1529592275619507,
0.26531797647476196,
0.38907134532928467,
0.004179841838777065,
0.0625595971941948,
-0.22009959816932678,
-0.47952795028686523,
-0.9160550236701965,
-0.14658483862876892,
0.432992547750473,
0.43792176246643066,
0.5606607794761658,
0.4358624517917633,
0.49184170365333557,
0.24436329305171967,
0.0837869644165039,
-0.2654868960380554,
-0.6379372477531433,
0.019486192613840103,
-0.051601920276880264,
-0.678972065448761,
-0.28187787532806396,
0.2854730784893036,
0.4476661682128906,
1.062690019607544,
-0.14174433052539825,
0.21264469623565674,
0.3778410255908966,
0.7650253772735596,
-0.607792317867279,
0.24787366390228271,
-0.28172212839126587,
0.08048874139785767,
-0.48013296723365784,
-0.36240047216415405,
-0.33860087394714355,
-0.6516261100769043,
0.39422616362571716,
-0.9235755801200867,
0.5297401547431946,
-0.09314154833555222,
0.44178900122642517,
0.3041873276233673,
-0.17682555317878723,
0.015624982304871082,
-0.8043830394744873,
0.7517425417900085,
-0.5485294461250305,
0.5060785412788391,
0.5454861521720886,
0.507840096950531,
-0.08019768446683884,
-1.0385056734085083,
-0.5343748331069946,
-0.16263629496097565,
-0.11266247183084488,
-0.22275815904140472,
0.09881541877985,
0.39816516637802124,
0.22400280833244324,
0.5840785503387451,
-0.6883839964866638,
0.17675191164016724,
-0.4032175838947296,
-0.17271335422992706,
0.4763967990875244,
-0.0949946939945221,
0.1821613758802414,
-0.06427126377820969,
-0.04643736407160759,
-0.022891348227858543,
-0.29202955961227417,
-0.060732144862413406,
0.24517114460468292,
0.6848793625831604,
-0.07610210031270981,
0.3556460440158844,
-0.3846827447414398,
0.8342363238334656,
-0.07440196722745895,
0.014727572910487652,
0.2448798567056656,
-0.46530959010124207,
-0.3028215169906616,
0.09784894436597824,
0.8642674088478088,
0.11207502335309982,
0.5948957204818726,
-0.20223990082740784,
-0.042659856379032135,
0.11569427698850632,
0.3737814128398895,
-0.7456167936325073,
-0.4711204469203949,
0.06483670324087143,
-0.4439285397529602,
-0.3219083547592163,
-0.24549371004104614,
-0.8106215596199036,
-0.20976077020168304,
-0.9556921124458313,
0.330160528421402,
-0.5825899839401245,
-0.28203079104423523,
0.4750042259693146,
0.08018244802951813,
0.22040824592113495,
0.0831245630979538,
-1.0279948711395264,
0.6902682185173035,
0.7083889842033386,
0.7901189923286438,
0.10933499783277512,
-0.2836638391017914,
-0.35784298181533813,
-0.23664821684360504,
0.05865628644824028,
0.7122052311897278,
-0.398266464471817,
0.07422605901956558,
0.11853741109371185,
-0.1021149531006813,
0.10636526346206665,
-0.3009713888168335,
0.6604071855545044,
-0.3114023804664612,
0.3554060459136963,
0.04710586369037628,
-0.6528012156486511,
-0.0749472975730896,
0.29432445764541626,
-0.6146286129951477,
0.7950865030288696,
0.12161027640104294,
-0.7596201300621033,
0.2993678152561188,
-1.071721076965332,
-0.39136290550231934,
-0.005535977892577648,
-0.049582596868276596,
0.04935478791594505,
0.05300043895840645,
-0.0007081747171469033,
0.7131575345993042,
-0.4204215705394745,
0.4129444360733032,
-0.25657445192337036,
-0.24397648870944977,
-0.09590379893779755,
-0.30832040309906006,
0.8886283040046692,
0.35175201296806335,
-0.10075351595878601,
0.14017914235591888,
-1.2749515771865845,
0.0497819259762764,
0.07208523899316788,
-0.018035853281617165,
-0.583109974861145,
-0.35806965827941895,
0.5065222978591919,
0.07931114733219147,
0.11358723044395447,
-0.37541651725769043,
0.12536776065826416,
-0.46178898215293884,
0.6523353457450867,
0.5853195786476135,
-0.37420493364334106,
0.8145736455917358,
0.08475902676582336,
0.34398967027664185,
-0.33505865931510925,
0.3381091058254242,
0.010627614334225655,
0.023686623200774193,
-0.6549859642982483,
-0.12786638736724854,
0.5954030752182007,
0.5413038730621338,
-0.6819225549697876,
0.38733384013175964,
0.06803158670663834,
-0.5355510115623474,
-0.6044123768806458,
0.0013787868665531278,
0.24240823090076447,
0.3434387147426605,
0.7056318521499634,
-0.2481079399585724,
-0.827237069606781,
-0.7800865173339844,
-0.33341798186302185,
0.3439050018787384,
-0.15857084095478058,
-0.2130938470363617,
0.19130639731884003,
-0.2062670737504959,
0.9726452231407166,
-0.6285954713821411,
-0.5446718335151672,
-0.20287229120731354,
0.4501493573188782,
0.041478876024484634,
0.8485292196273804,
0.44441258907318115,
-0.6373963952064514,
-0.19447006285190582,
-0.4524722695350647,
-0.6430292129516602,
-0.018144581466913223,
-0.005283110775053501,
-0.38932859897613525,
-0.031087540090084076,
0.7329421043395996,
-0.349355548620224,
0.12865418195724487,
0.3286631107330322,
-0.28012609481811523,
0.6406406760215759,
0.02349262684583664,
-0.18738576769828796,
-0.8400439620018005,
0.07271580398082733,
0.14097003638744354,
-0.24476318061351776,
-0.9569026827812195,
-0.09856162220239639,
-0.28961747884750366,
-0.0523468442261219,
-0.24067823588848114,
0.367404043674469,
-0.10516634583473206,
0.12308106571435928,
-0.017091291025280952,
0.002522086026147008,
-0.1515025943517685,
0.45903337001800537,
0.0458625890314579,
0.5911387205123901,
0.49363645911216736,
-0.7477132081985474,
0.08013375848531723,
0.29026830196380615,
-0.37907227873802185,
0.5031376481056213,
-0.5287739038467407,
0.0813342034816742,
-0.45250484347343445,
0.029948431998491287,
-0.7923444509506226,
-0.10857273638248444,
0.10715257376432419,
-0.24706394970417023,
0.43651267886161804,
0.0706145316362381,
-0.44561660289764404,
-0.11262581497430801,
-0.19730144739151,
0.38304397463798523,
0.23194655776023865,
-0.375511109828949,
0.26523298025131226,
0.39081427454948425,
-0.2751938998699188,
-0.5570118427276611,
-0.5127614736557007,
-0.26223915815353394,
-0.21765008568763733,
-0.27115699648857117,
0.3189845681190491,
-0.06477673351764679,
-0.11019495874643326,
-0.13404691219329834,
0.02894621714949608,
-0.4753085970878601,
0.32682299613952637,
-0.08281740546226501,
0.0786452516913414,
-0.39306965470314026,
0.2425367832183838,
-0.17528031766414642,
-0.46352794766426086,
0.09027720987796783,
-0.3768705129623413,
0.8177880644798279,
-0.34913691878318787,
0.23631003499031067,
-0.6564476490020752,
0.17644131183624268,
0.1608211100101471,
-0.24666117131710052,
0.6083241105079651,
0.907394289970398,
-0.41452786326408386,
0.04575401172041893,
-0.5633901953697205,
-0.4506215751171112,
-0.43088218569755554,
0.41285115480422974,
0.019745076075196266,
-0.8854847550392151,
0.05238904431462288,
-0.09908647835254669,
0.23252758383750916,
0.21944762766361237,
-0.014052996411919594,
-0.18197433650493622,
0.7824025750160217,
1.1089563369750977,
0.09610778093338013,
0.7589950561523438,
-0.4038815200328827,
0.31361955404281616,
-0.5636737942695618,
0.019485225901007652,
-0.7766348123550415,
-0.19099242985248566,
-0.44047707319259644,
-0.10569456219673157,
-0.10233242809772491,
0.4210439622402191,
-0.7106115221977234,
0.19711968302726746,
-0.6263779997825623,
0.6159762144088745,
0.6846806406974792,
-0.09110011905431747,
0.3479430377483368,
-0.13285985589027405,
0.10895545035600662,
-0.21356314420700073,
-0.6972922086715698,
-0.7717674970626831,
1.160554051399231,
0.2082468867301941,
0.6697158217430115,
-0.17886613309383392,
0.7241711020469666,
-0.00710753258317709,
0.3709578812122345,
-0.9321110248565674,
0.4450616240501404,
-0.2743922770023346,
-0.5359460711479187,
-0.5850087404251099,
-0.23773165047168732,
-0.9747246503829956,
0.008035877719521523,
-0.6251974701881409,
-0.469068706035614,
-0.06837738305330276,
0.47318434715270996,
-0.6674419641494751,
-0.0206892229616642,
-0.7600640654563904,
1.192670464515686,
-0.16805864870548248,
-0.31435877084732056,
-0.10795950144529343,
-0.8664436936378479,
0.44096413254737854,
-0.09546498954296112,
0.28053680062294006,
-0.09542793035507202,
0.4787711799144745,
0.997151792049408,
-0.13550426065921783,
0.8120673298835754,
-0.42478734254837036,
0.23067371547222137,
-0.1034596711397171,
-0.006033717188984156,
-0.04606003686785698,
-0.03623725846409798,
0.01685522310435772,
0.05057269707322121,
0.45233380794525146,
-0.3897729218006134,
-0.5378264784812927,
0.2551843225955963,
-0.7620788812637329,
-0.1978873312473297,
-0.2842261791229248,
-0.44691261649131775,
-0.36284592747688293,
0.4895496666431427,
0.28139474987983704,
0.4417755603790283,
-0.4931214451789856,
0.19052258133888245,
0.6010948419570923,
-0.12071716785430908,
0.2402525246143341,
0.29316726326942444,
-0.31545478105545044,
-0.23829658329486847,
0.7028478980064392,
0.27413320541381836,
0.19215922057628632,
0.2890164256095886,
0.3687644302845001,
-0.48056668043136597,
-0.5548626184463501,
0.01344007346779108,
0.0970933809876442,
-0.5547509789466858,
-0.04610064625740051,
-0.614391028881073,
-0.17944152653217316,
-0.4142920672893524,
-0.2784425616264343,
-0.5705711245536804,
-0.5533221364021301,
-0.2916925251483917,
-0.016384214162826538,
0.27375683188438416,
0.5063874125480652,
-0.11373190581798553,
0.7588614225387573,
-0.5998303294181824,
0.5553106069564819,
0.5040326118469238,
0.557603120803833,
0.07287686318159103,
-0.11127009242773056,
-0.2775837182998657,
0.14414948225021362,
-0.21783319115638733,
-0.49097245931625366,
0.23163674771785736,
0.2641946077346802,
0.5280393958091736,
0.3914318084716797,
0.2947086691856384,
0.7020741105079651,
-0.6403294801712036,
0.5529260635375977,
0.3941571116447449,
-0.862293541431427,
0.417393296957016,
-0.24131152033805847,
0.12620359659194946,
1.1209027767181396,
0.7057052850723267,
-0.5047428607940674,
-0.1983482539653778,
-0.6530281901359558,
-0.9379369616508484,
0.6232097148895264,
0.045368045568466187,
0.002649572677910328,
0.12028764933347702,
0.36877763271331787,
0.3606162667274475,
0.37672480940818787,
-0.6388421058654785,
-0.35087820887565613,
-0.527823269367218,
-0.44956088066101074,
-0.516984224319458,
-0.3106590211391449,
-0.2595721185207367,
-0.5221670866012573,
0.576076090335846,
-0.18999215960502625,
0.2503755986690521,
0.22574622929096222,
-0.38256967067718506,
0.30046018958091736,
0.4311370849609375,
0.4412125051021576,
0.6043993234634399,
-0.30223017930984497,
0.2971065044403076,
-0.08860953897237778,
-0.6058418154716492,
0.055880602449178696,
0.4875863492488861,
0.07420296221971512,
-0.19714370369911194,
0.21697789430618286,
0.7218224406242371,
0.3867115080356598,
-0.3577164113521576,
0.40157708525657654,
-0.39390861988067627,
-0.12904420495033264,
-0.4937914311885834,
-0.06611891090869904,
-0.09132872521877289,
0.23296549916267395,
0.29421693086624146,
0.1747758686542511,
0.36404696106910706,
-0.5375364422798157,
0.06434659659862518,
0.21177056431770325,
-0.39270076155662537,
-0.30490925908088684,
0.6466072797775269,
0.28465741872787476,
-0.39669501781463623,
0.5465068221092224,
-0.19930793344974518,
-0.24902833998203278,
0.2149888128042221,
0.6339794397354126,
0.8011534810066223,
-0.05848447605967522,
0.12496165186166763,
0.4057992994785309,
0.04718873277306557,
-0.4557230770587921,
0.24374525249004364,
-0.2807827591896057,
-0.8032052516937256,
-0.6970760226249695,
-0.8998533487319946,
-0.20492735505104065,
0.33832862973213196,
-0.955586850643158,
0.2986641228199005,
-0.5970967411994934,
-0.14126573503017426,
0.4838379919528961,
-0.06420436501502991,
-0.94631028175354,
0.07861776649951935,
0.26161444187164307,
0.8473798036575317,
-0.8599498271942139,
0.7568431496620178,
0.6539091467857361,
-0.2631428837776184,
-0.7120882868766785,
-0.12993746995925903,
-0.054367419332265854,
-0.4769948422908783,
0.6111662983894348,
0.414616197347641,
0.12443748116493225,
0.46014031767845154,
-0.7010738849639893,
-0.5990520119667053,
0.5260069966316223,
0.4031030237674713,
-0.5436981916427612,
-0.15901236236095428,
0.17724278569221497,
0.5860030651092529,
-0.02743193693459034,
0.07890886813402176,
1.0666574239730835,
0.4393865168094635,
-0.4368026852607727,
-0.9687590599060059,
-0.10963746905326843,
-0.08358021825551987,
-0.10253476351499557,
0.0905185267329216,
-0.17988251149654388,
0.7137374877929688,
0.06022532284259796,
-0.07430954277515411,
-0.03602821007370949,
0.6582979559898376,
0.014919287525117397,
0.20337064564228058,
0.5221768021583557,
0.3240188658237457,
0.864395022392273,
-0.15477681159973145,
0.7407616376876831,
-0.35241129994392395,
0.39520180225372314,
1.2257249355316162,
0.177035853266716,
0.6916636228561401,
0.5570562481880188,
-0.42980363965034485,
0.23674142360687256,
0.4984535872936249,
0.39276179671287537,
0.4505665898323059,
0.327827513217926,
-0.19020982086658478,
-0.2575739920139313,
-0.1630343645811081,
-0.3362509310245514,
0.422391414642334,
0.2155468612909317,
-0.004031944088637829,
-0.24276667833328247,
0.3460675776004791,
-0.03074813075363636,
0.27206099033355713,
-0.6063835620880127,
0.6457440257072449,
0.3091571033000946,
-0.34410008788108826,
0.6640295386314392,
-0.3558449447154999,
0.9563531875610352,
-0.7513921856880188,
-0.0031351312063634396,
0.13008394837379456,
0.2069218009710312,
-0.41917547583580017,
-0.696174144744873,
0.5467378497123718,
-0.07290301471948624,
-0.19604086875915527,
-0.4400636553764343,
0.6158872842788696,
-0.4328036606311798,
-0.1463640332221985,
0.08480309695005417,
0.4833296239376068,
0.13017544150352478,
-0.08347912132740021,
-0.5713872313499451,
-0.34990838170051575,
-0.16129888594150543,
-0.1709132343530655,
0.2664814591407776,
0.4343220889568329,
-0.03625062480568886,
0.44103172421455383,
0.8477283120155334,
-0.010571862570941448,
0.1318751871585846,
0.2453193962574005,
0.7618005275726318,
-0.776515007019043,
-0.5926114916801453,
-0.7963396906852722,
0.3217485249042511,
-0.006431310437619686,
-0.3104362487792969,
0.549752950668335,
0.49127480387687683,
1.1450914144515991,
-0.13707752525806427,
0.6232695579528809,
-0.08164336532354355,
0.4077420234680176,
-0.5175548791885376,
0.6627362966537476,
-0.114400215446949,
-0.1417747437953949,
-0.4923044443130493,
-0.8684521317481995,
-0.7267677783966064,
1.135880708694458,
-0.4679306149482727,
-0.257168173789978,
0.718910813331604,
0.47978341579437256,
-0.16598458588123322,
0.5171489119529724,
-0.027459057047963142,
0.24985243380069733,
0.19771403074264526,
0.26627349853515625,
0.8388206958770752,
-0.11800093948841095,
0.29650044441223145,
-0.6550483703613281,
-0.1684398353099823,
0.06402143836021423,
-0.8922982811927795,
-0.7866725325584412,
-0.540283739566803,
-0.06583533436059952,
-0.21027681231498718,
-0.003059360198676586,
1.3759511709213257,
0.8692039251327515,
-0.6801351308822632,
-0.2396266609430313,
-0.5018698573112488,
-0.19086536765098572,
-0.17269636690616608,
-0.29187971353530884,
0.2512635290622711,
-0.7658076882362366,
-0.686926543712616,
0.1661633402109146,
-0.09465852379798889,
0.17489245533943176,
-0.2727693021297455,
0.1754959672689438,
-0.3272027373313904,
-0.3656306862831116,
0.6862822771072388,
0.4162977337837219,
-0.15905748307704926,
-0.11355003714561462,
-0.258004367351532,
0.08783754706382751,
0.06143823266029358,
0.8975384831428528,
-0.8795434832572937,
0.2516286373138428,
0.32931193709373474,
0.7209630608558655,
0.442563533782959,
-0.15900865197181702,
0.7279151678085327,
-0.655332624912262,
0.6283594369888306,
0.46091601252555847,
0.1761423647403717,
0.3661893904209137,
-0.11620991677045822,
0.6794475317001343,
0.0802881047129631,
-0.504850447177887,
-1.0337603092193604,
0.11189258098602295,
-0.9333204627037048,
-0.17656318843364716,
0.8415539860725403,
0.09255260229110718,
-0.00024190761905629188,
-0.5287767052650452,
-0.34289732575416565,
0.5748599171638489,
-0.18009185791015625,
0.6629354357719421,
0.4706542491912842,
-0.15099549293518066,
-0.06341341882944107,
-0.9585058093070984,
1.0020710229873657,
0.4534854292869568,
-0.7626690864562988,
0.1323399394750595,
0.2434982806444168,
0.24097904562950134,
0.22694505751132965,
0.7381766438484192,
0.06773672997951508,
-0.07941054552793503,
-0.22492855787277222,
0.36618971824645996,
-0.06808880716562271,
-0.28960657119750977,
-0.46783462166786194,
0.19063061475753784,
0.18716444075107574,
-0.024402089416980743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02502v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02502v1
|
Trial and Error: Exploration-Based Trajectory Optimization for LLM Agents
| 2024-03-04T21:50:29 | 2024-03-04T21:50:29 |
Yifan Song, Da Yin, Xiang Yue, Jie Huang, Sujian Li, Bill Yuchen Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become integral components in various
autonomous agent systems. In this study, we present an exploration-based
trajectory optimization approach, referred to as ETO. This learning method is
designed to enhance the performance of open LLM agents. Contrary to previous
studies that exclusively train on successful expert trajectories, our method
allows agents to learn from their exploration failures. This leads to improved
performance through an iterative optimization framework. During the exploration
phase, the agent interacts with the environment while completing given tasks,
gathering failure trajectories to create contrastive trajectory pairs. In the
subsequent training phase, the agent utilizes these trajectory preference pairs
to update its policy using contrastive learning methods like DPO. This
iterative cycle of exploration and training fosters continued improvement in
the agents. Our experiments on three complex tasks demonstrate that ETO
consistently surpasses baseline performance by a large margin. Furthermore, an
examination of task-solving efficiency and potential in scenarios lacking
expert trajectory underscores the effectiveness of our approach.
|
[
0.1343332827091217,
-0.5775896310806274,
0.9809353947639465,
0.014944491907954216,
-0.004678706638514996,
0.5052775144577026,
-0.35739845037460327,
-0.36133432388305664,
0.1432584971189499,
0.4730704724788666,
-0.8008846640586853,
-0.6778818964958191,
-0.5627402663230896,
-0.01241418905556202,
0.12659965455532074,
0.733668863773346,
-0.4596722722053528,
-0.22257623076438904,
-0.026986876502633095,
0.09426714479923248,
-0.6322311758995056,
0.03422803804278374,
-1.1503795385360718,
-0.32277971506118774,
0.3429484963417053,
0.7179211974143982,
0.36763375997543335,
0.8648449778556824,
0.2661021053791046,
0.3433498442173004,
-0.14794610440731049,
0.7683749794960022,
-1.0531110763549805,
0.247846320271492,
-0.12872488796710968,
-0.5226631164550781,
0.008573135361075401,
-0.3006058633327484,
0.5324669480323792,
0.5777644515037537,
-0.46645084023475647,
-0.7420401573181152,
-0.059501755982637405,
0.6571973562240601,
-0.46274444460868835,
0.23088231682777405,
-0.5991923213005066,
0.2715497612953186,
0.20523837208747864,
-0.6557555198669434,
-0.2713867723941803,
-0.4363365173339844,
0.2502792477607727,
-1.1607286930084229,
-0.06326815485954285,
0.21112175285816193,
0.48540279269218445,
0.347893625497818,
-0.45900601148605347,
-0.5616698861122131,
-1.0828936100006104,
1.0551373958587646,
-0.3190946877002716,
0.11972688883543015,
-0.1367284059524536,
0.4367343485355377,
-0.5426178574562073,
-0.36413541436195374,
-0.2672589421272278,
-0.6448463201522827,
0.2595145106315613,
0.29265227913856506,
0.17332063615322113,
0.31676411628723145,
-0.12061505764722824,
0.04872775450348854,
-0.36985543370246887,
0.42265287041664124,
-0.24556706845760345,
-0.1203504279255867,
0.5784327387809753,
0.4182175099849701,
0.051434475928545,
0.5613481402397156,
-0.3962244391441345,
-0.39935851097106934,
-0.7955862879753113,
0.4758533537387848,
0.3721694052219391,
0.49668270349502563,
0.0762021616101265,
0.4931919276714325,
-0.2845911681652069,
0.3498304784297943,
-0.022167891263961792,
-0.23177945613861084,
0.11321961879730225,
-0.13031360507011414,
0.26522591710090637,
0.002039337297901511,
0.372355192899704,
0.5220845341682434,
0.16237983107566833,
-0.40506961941719055,
-0.4937957227230072,
-0.27660229802131653,
0.3562774360179901,
-0.5304664969444275,
0.19800759851932526,
0.39998453855514526,
0.17036749422550201,
-0.3643281161785126,
-0.04357294365763664,
-0.7224645614624023,
-0.3976873457431793,
-0.1530866175889969,
0.477602481842041,
-0.5564044117927551,
-0.018542034551501274,
0.3242464065551758,
-0.14696896076202393,
0.0702529102563858,
0.644591748714447,
-0.5885298848152161,
0.3307223618030548,
0.690517008304596,
0.9477745890617371,
-0.3825412392616272,
-0.585163950920105,
-0.897334098815918,
0.19792617857456207,
-0.6780149340629578,
0.5435104966163635,
-0.6717602610588074,
-0.7341189980506897,
0.32207345962524414,
-0.338883638381958,
-0.22846463322639465,
-0.5493776798248291,
0.5537332892417908,
-0.6911844611167908,
-0.15825584530830383,
-0.06043930724263191,
-0.5857290625572205,
-0.38274314999580383,
0.4338158071041107,
-0.399370014667511,
1.1484631299972534,
0.26783400774002075,
-0.023275041952729225,
0.2857149541378021,
-1.1368054151535034,
-0.2428400218486786,
-0.17664766311645508,
-0.1604931354522705,
-0.22907328605651855,
0.12418566644191742,
0.02725415863096714,
0.15868255496025085,
-0.09613145887851715,
0.021321121603250504,
0.005110567901283503,
-0.5508381128311157,
-0.249752014875412,
0.3224133849143982,
0.46973398327827454,
0.018692823126912117,
-0.6147817373275757,
0.28003910183906555,
-0.7833804488182068,
-0.12163220345973969,
0.308893620967865,
-0.5450126528739929,
-0.3878677189350128,
0.5162945985794067,
-0.46148842573165894,
-0.1326119601726532,
0.17460860311985016,
-0.5385034680366516,
0.37782320380210876,
-0.724761426448822,
0.09953724592924118,
1.0537481307983398,
0.2406516969203949,
0.46236544847488403,
-0.3784656524658203,
0.648384153842926,
0.028821805492043495,
0.22564756870269775,
-0.1818222999572754,
-0.17166195809841156,
-0.9590129852294922,
-0.0179024338722229,
-0.315626859664917,
0.5489034056663513,
-0.8704333901405334,
0.4181811809539795,
-0.2137565314769745,
-0.4284280240535736,
-0.1764882653951645,
0.08979688584804535,
0.26210102438926697,
0.4532153606414795,
0.2911132872104645,
-0.09979923814535141,
-0.2847667336463928,
-0.4578365683555603,
-0.04963036626577377,
-0.08148451149463654,
0.2820313274860382,
0.6607178449630737,
0.4186076819896698,
-0.4661130905151367,
0.6737272143363953,
-0.545795738697052,
-0.296301931142807,
-0.231893852353096,
0.03628835454583168,
0.11562507599592209,
0.42922264337539673,
0.4870791435241699,
-0.45917484164237976,
-0.5618561506271362,
0.4312097430229187,
-0.5397694706916809,
0.14371168613433838,
-0.19239866733551025,
-0.2220279425382614,
0.19107572734355927,
0.2689359486103058,
-0.3207995891571045,
0.21332137286663055,
0.17338672280311584,
-0.14808402955532074,
0.21085180342197418,
-0.5484892725944519,
0.13676047325134277,
-0.4843161702156067,
-0.30059871077537537,
-0.06266074627637863,
-0.2979564964771271,
-0.5932456851005554,
0.3482239246368408,
-0.3172290325164795,
0.23309603333473206,
-0.5368903875350952,
0.3613206446170807,
-0.501252293586731,
-0.06511930376291275,
-0.4725041687488556,
0.329006165266037,
-0.2735666334629059,
0.6272750496864319,
0.06519981473684311,
0.7748907208442688,
0.8536666035652161,
-0.7908507585525513,
0.3876343071460724,
-0.023516759276390076,
0.2620897889137268,
0.23735199868679047,
-0.5321266651153564,
0.6824151277542114,
-0.22164727747440338,
-0.2308642566204071,
-0.968273937702179,
0.07677455246448517,
0.2075301706790924,
-0.10837108641862869,
0.3778914511203766,
0.3131888210773468,
-0.33381322026252747,
-0.13782425224781036,
-0.725131630897522,
0.08317352831363678,
0.28173086047172546,
-0.5269536972045898,
0.8513678908348083,
0.04433656856417656,
0.15215031802654266,
-0.7622824907302856,
0.09539545327425003,
-0.152595654129982,
-0.25564560294151306,
-0.582831084728241,
0.18374595046043396,
-0.18524405360221863,
-0.31391382217407227,
-0.26516902446746826,
-0.010098411701619625,
0.3474729657173157,
0.4273056387901306,
0.1322495937347412,
0.17759987711906433,
0.08626184612512589,
-0.0196638572961092,
0.07756052911281586,
-0.05915268138051033,
-0.012333153747022152,
-0.4171508252620697,
0.7354738116264343,
0.03961050510406494,
-0.2146885097026825,
-0.05722732096910477,
0.3526003658771515,
0.12719950079917908,
0.11582428961992264,
0.49004799127578735,
0.05014471337199211,
-0.20751139521598816,
-0.642932116985321,
-0.17924045026302338,
-0.21852557361125946,
-0.5087663531303406,
0.5661290287971497,
-0.4320552349090576,
-0.7765051126480103,
0.4297873377799988,
-0.38951247930526733,
0.3921658992767334,
0.37698453664779663,
0.2514645457267761,
-0.2768732011318207,
0.6749639511108398,
1.2032957077026367,
0.07795315235853195,
0.38619858026504517,
-0.5250733494758606,
-0.1424829512834549,
-0.43244296312332153,
-0.3639334738254547,
-0.45058107376098633,
-0.3875386714935303,
-0.6596135497093201,
-0.5223885178565979,
0.6731628179550171,
-0.2968050539493561,
-0.216328963637352,
0.10575871914625168,
-0.4052017629146576,
0.5091535449028015,
0.7437383532524109,
0.29102274775505066,
0.41649559140205383,
0.14332441985607147,
-0.19682571291923523,
-0.05348234623670578,
-0.6517972350120544,
-0.48655325174331665,
1.4342575073242188,
0.23070494830608368,
0.6260555982589722,
-0.001646313932724297,
1.0370728969573975,
0.2627444565296173,
0.033180929720401764,
-0.8411343693733215,
0.5557520985603333,
0.2188778966665268,
-0.1577838808298111,
-0.6498120427131653,
-0.3041461110115051,
-1.1123663187026978,
0.027862781658768654,
0.02462167479097843,
-0.8306383490562439,
0.19859679043293,
0.14053884148597717,
-0.43999210000038147,
0.10035201162099838,
-0.2172466367483139,
0.5319179892539978,
-0.47678565979003906,
-0.458461195230484,
-0.5515720248222351,
-0.7340980768203735,
-0.005743369460105896,
-0.13427011668682098,
-0.038683731108903885,
0.3159787654876709,
-0.5625008344650269,
0.548626720905304,
-0.3144872784614563,
0.6469667553901672,
-0.31506022810935974,
-0.12031102925539017,
0.2876455783843994,
0.1529359519481659,
1.172027826309204,
-0.3802317976951599,
-0.19145826995372772,
-0.23843999207019806,
-0.5541185140609741,
-0.12186653167009354,
-0.5416700839996338,
0.6565233469009399,
-1.0451562404632568,
-0.5267126560211182,
-0.37866702675819397,
-0.6228960156440735,
-0.3553691506385803,
0.09504515677690506,
-0.03810212388634682,
0.10216377675533295,
-0.22793567180633545,
-0.06160241737961769,
0.6655474901199341,
-0.223923921585083,
0.609643816947937,
0.7269929647445679,
-0.0839872732758522,
-0.23025980591773987,
0.7663120031356812,
-0.09579715877771378,
0.4113064706325531,
0.587793231010437,
0.29403239488601685,
-0.270571231842041,
-1.1792573928833008,
-0.3148341774940491,
0.14199209213256836,
-0.7750683426856995,
0.22108252346515656,
-0.6346192359924316,
0.19088931381702423,
-0.033092714846134186,
-0.3010513484477997,
-0.439199298620224,
-0.07346641272306442,
-0.3197745978832245,
-0.25810328125953674,
0.2884904444217682,
0.8079162836074829,
-0.2132190614938736,
0.5813703536987305,
-0.4641590118408203,
-0.06469231843948364,
-0.03319196030497551,
-0.06619872152805328,
-0.28244683146476746,
-0.420128732919693,
-0.35577383637428284,
-0.03761283680796623,
-0.6790536046028137,
-0.766006588935852,
0.3735974133014679,
0.32512667775154114,
0.7887653708457947,
0.4806686043739319,
0.006924179848283529,
0.4335474669933319,
-0.407895565032959,
0.4902426302433014,
-0.1659039407968521,
-0.5627217292785645,
0.855859637260437,
-0.5627483129501343,
-0.321087121963501,
0.6276389956474304,
0.584480881690979,
-0.15435804426670074,
-0.4022882282733917,
-0.44090333580970764,
-0.9959885478019714,
0.8753918409347534,
0.21937642991542816,
-0.22932477295398712,
0.4869794547557831,
0.6895574331283569,
0.2917458713054657,
0.41096237301826477,
-0.6711663007736206,
-0.3997562527656555,
0.21001730859279633,
0.025114715099334717,
-0.3457965850830078,
0.0636489987373352,
-0.5054504871368408,
0.19428543746471405,
0.8363814949989319,
-0.3119986355304718,
0.13458070158958435,
0.21975077688694,
-0.05895311385393143,
-0.4882403016090393,
-0.08749685436487198,
0.8220751881599426,
0.7679707407951355,
-0.4475579559803009,
-0.3068631589412689,
-0.027945348992943764,
-0.3410864770412445,
0.3182491362094879,
0.2704121470451355,
-0.28640982508659363,
-0.1641612946987152,
0.11960605531930923,
0.8226650357246399,
-0.09446831047534943,
-0.9988377690315247,
0.2764863073825836,
0.3649505078792572,
0.00047320235171355307,
-0.3568597733974457,
0.39941278100013733,
-0.2799205183982849,
0.5363408327102661,
0.5714620351791382,
-0.06410767138004303,
0.44955724477767944,
-0.8186749219894409,
-0.0627877339720726,
0.3362591564655304,
-0.2688405513763428,
-0.009350532665848732,
0.40321823954582214,
0.2940990924835205,
-0.5208887457847595,
0.18946652114391327,
-0.37926045060157776,
-0.6400076746940613,
0.990080714225769,
0.23988588154315948,
0.9781665802001953,
-0.17519398033618927,
0.18033060431480408,
0.2046765387058258,
0.6553823351860046,
-0.17523953318595886,
0.3600997030735016,
0.0645940974354744,
-0.8124200701713562,
-0.3783135414123535,
-0.13419286906719208,
-0.7978578209877014,
-0.10511285811662674,
-0.10383177548646927,
0.3721555769443512,
-0.483073890209198,
0.3299234211444855,
-0.6082242727279663,
0.29752102494239807,
-0.6671000123023987,
0.284885048866272,
-0.14682041108608246,
0.61665278673172,
-0.5341282486915588,
0.3465133607387543,
0.7781444787979126,
-0.10623390972614288,
-0.8081547617912292,
0.0005927602178417146,
0.059562087059020996,
-1.0639678239822388,
0.6802060008049011,
0.23933999240398407,
-0.4938531219959259,
0.15555858612060547,
-0.32926520705223083,
-0.8615120053291321,
1.271132469177246,
0.20458509027957916,
-0.839654266834259,
0.04395506903529167,
0.2975178062915802,
0.5803283452987671,
-0.7275421023368835,
0.46706029772758484,
0.4857420325279236,
0.42081862688064575,
0.16307136416435242,
-0.6866264343261719,
-0.007767389994114637,
0.22183355689048767,
0.02637397311627865,
0.10311656445264816,
-0.8767043948173523,
0.6669594645500183,
-0.574133038520813,
-0.1979578584432602,
0.04755447432398796,
0.5238340497016907,
0.5706068277359009,
0.6296085119247437,
0.8529596328735352,
0.37672170996665955,
0.5996384620666504,
-0.12141475826501846,
1.021187663078308,
-0.22880983352661133,
0.3565692901611328,
1.0120575428009033,
-0.42046767473220825,
0.654797375202179,
0.6004682779312134,
-0.12258736044168472,
0.4204511344432831,
0.8518748879432678,
0.35206741094589233,
0.9725175499916077,
0.3224025368690491,
-0.146368607878685,
-0.09443528205156326,
0.07816154509782791,
0.04589715227484703,
0.3294125199317932,
0.10566949844360352,
-0.14630164206027985,
-0.23869602382183075,
0.12047382444143295,
-0.0867273360490799,
0.3936631679534912,
-0.38471344113349915,
0.7120135426521301,
-0.26404067873954773,
-0.8168325424194336,
0.2667969763278961,
-0.056581947952508926,
0.49538037180900574,
-0.57259601354599,
-0.20162813365459442,
-0.33784613013267517,
0.31366994976997375,
0.10165772587060928,
-0.4602605700492859,
-0.007750063668936491,
-0.3271057605743408,
0.4164799153804779,
-0.047825880348682404,
0.5226501226425171,
-0.2951180338859558,
-0.17490816116333008,
0.6153531670570374,
0.4830029606819153,
0.06307647377252579,
-0.07381173223257065,
-0.3992486000061035,
0.007113314233720303,
0.14769847691059113,
-0.389629989862442,
-0.04330923780798912,
0.40807977318763733,
0.2624097764492035,
0.8921137452125549,
0.3238671123981476,
0.1786550134420395,
0.031091157346963882,
-0.3244147300720215,
0.9662877917289734,
-0.7222369909286499,
-0.5082923769950867,
-0.6788433790206909,
0.616395115852356,
-0.12515436112880707,
-0.2100140005350113,
0.41643640398979187,
0.6396836638450623,
0.8135733604431152,
0.03584180399775505,
0.7235716581344604,
0.27075129747390747,
0.5383073091506958,
-0.8375321626663208,
-0.049574680626392365,
-0.7793329358100891,
0.5090016722679138,
0.12006289511919022,
-0.9963342547416687,
0.20172640681266785,
0.3830903470516205,
-0.2213890701532364,
0.1686980426311493,
0.77071613073349,
0.8967676758766174,
0.2090148627758026,
-0.24637047946453094,
0.3447040915489197,
0.21831706166267395,
0.5664110779762268,
0.9726067781448364,
1.0565927028656006,
-0.33010807633399963,
0.5548986792564392,
-0.5014946460723877,
-0.32862868905067444,
-0.3976156413555145,
-0.8763107657432556,
-0.7958423495292664,
-0.1564633548259735,
-0.254936546087265,
-0.18055371940135956,
0.5595281720161438,
1.1911258697509766,
0.4292391836643219,
-0.4728556275367737,
-0.4167857766151428,
-0.3811432719230652,
0.05403655022382736,
-0.4058047831058502,
-0.18902918696403503,
0.04494911804795265,
-0.43099576234817505,
-1.2165454626083374,
0.8433601260185242,
0.3694736063480377,
0.02765848860144615,
-0.32144859433174133,
-0.49292126297950745,
0.012106976471841335,
0.05429516360163689,
0.2485996037721634,
0.37344786524772644,
-0.4683738052845001,
-0.3621370792388916,
0.276431143283844,
0.09151210635900497,
0.3240523338317871,
0.7636186480522156,
-0.41118690371513367,
0.6499297022819519,
0.13728508353233337,
0.8982119560241699,
0.6776169538497925,
-0.28993287682533264,
0.8113449811935425,
-0.5660797953605652,
0.06811948120594025,
0.39268049597740173,
0.34223610162734985,
0.14595970511436462,
-0.6463260650634766,
0.876961886882782,
0.27602478861808777,
-0.5022576451301575,
-0.7006132006645203,
0.03526090830564499,
-1.2565271854400635,
0.04581933096051216,
1.2492358684539795,
-0.2029145210981369,
-0.053898222744464874,
0.03441840037703514,
-0.40564367175102234,
0.091158427298069,
-0.8695434927940369,
0.9960469007492065,
0.46383434534072876,
-0.33799251914024353,
-0.02864234521985054,
-0.6124800443649292,
0.34024330973625183,
0.38457152247428894,
-1.04751455783844,
-0.40385809540748596,
0.4723750948905945,
0.044625502079725266,
0.2959323227405548,
0.5846270322799683,
0.3135848641395569,
0.24064503610134125,
-0.20771704614162445,
-0.003190046874806285,
-0.16072437167167664,
-0.5741350054740906,
-0.3166189193725586,
0.06779326498508453,
0.27171042561531067,
-0.4169600307941437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02496v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02496v1
|
Choose Your Own Adventure: Interactive E-Books to Improve Word Knowledge and Comprehension Skills
| 2024-03-04T21:43:59 | 2024-03-04T21:43:59 |
Stephanie Day, Jin K. Hwang, Tracy Arner, Danielle McNamara, Carol Connor
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The purpose of this feasibility study was to examine the potential impact of
reading digital interactive e-books on essential skills that support reading
comprehension with third-fifth grade students. Students read two e-Books that
taught word learning and comprehension monitoring strategies in the service of
learning difficult vocabulary and targeted science concepts about hurricanes.
We investigated whether specific comprehension strategies including word
learning and strategies that supported general reading comprehension,
summarization, and question generation, show promise of effectiveness in
building vocabulary knowledge and comprehension skills in the e-Books. Students
were assigned to read one of three versions of each of the e-Books, each
version implemented one strategy. The books employed a choose-your-adventure
format with embedded comprehension questions that provided students with
immediate feedback on their responses. Paired samples t-tests were run to
examine pre-to-post differences in learning the targeted vocabulary and science
concepts taught in both e-Books. For both e-Books, students demonstrated
significant gains in word learning and on the targeted hurricane concepts.
Additionally, Hierarchical Linear Modeling (HLM) revealed that no one strategy
was more associated with larger gains than the other. Performance on the
embedded questions in the books was also associated with greater posttest
outcomes for both e-Books. This work discusses important considerations for
implementation and future development of e-books that can enhance student
engagement and improve reading comprehension.
|
[
-0.6101928353309631,
-0.8531611561775208,
0.7009153366088867,
-0.1596917062997818,
-0.3089334964752197,
0.540693461894989,
0.349852055311203,
-0.47231143712997437,
0.44382205605506897,
0.5053306818008423,
-0.4545362591743469,
-0.40599995851516724,
-0.17663469910621643,
0.5608687400817871,
-0.06016752868890762,
0.8590726256370544,
-0.08376570045948029,
-0.35884222388267517,
-0.5917077660560608,
0.07823698967695236,
-0.43355101346969604,
-0.27311477065086365,
-0.39868876338005066,
-0.3642480969429016,
1.070434331893921,
0.6671815514564514,
0.5437970161437988,
0.7027919888496399,
0.4753066897392273,
0.310242235660553,
-0.1892639547586441,
0.038715753704309464,
-0.3066491186618805,
0.15415064990520477,
-0.2622971832752228,
-0.5989600419998169,
-0.05635903775691986,
-0.2880588471889496,
0.3677968978881836,
0.44289064407348633,
-0.44000905752182007,
0.15287108719348907,
0.1500772088766098,
0.5608000755310059,
-0.4869474470615387,
-0.025425560772418976,
-0.2432062178850174,
-0.05456826463341713,
0.16237223148345947,
-0.5188920497894287,
-0.21845310926437378,
-0.058959994465112686,
0.417089581489563,
-1.1836438179016113,
0.06047571450471878,
0.46252837777137756,
0.8141623139381409,
0.16936838626861572,
-0.8482696413993835,
-0.68235182762146,
-0.5967808961868286,
0.651332437992096,
-0.23373539745807648,
0.2730795741081238,
0.6890267729759216,
0.16475288569927216,
0.13239510357379913,
-0.7894635200500488,
-1.0055922269821167,
0.04994601011276245,
0.193015918135643,
0.7008766531944275,
-0.004962008912116289,
0.47944051027297974,
0.005612129345536232,
0.16894838213920593,
-0.32628411054611206,
0.043112482875585556,
-0.5031639337539673,
0.14577919244766235,
0.6563463807106018,
0.32565200328826904,
0.5525856614112854,
-0.5748963952064514,
-0.23581397533416748,
-0.4183403551578522,
-0.25159603357315063,
0.7137386202812195,
0.8775065541267395,
-0.07700450718402863,
0.1157052293419838,
0.7292357683181763,
0.055232804268598557,
0.5634059906005859,
-0.18685364723205566,
-0.5958295464515686,
0.11648237705230713,
-0.2739439308643341,
0.0192736629396677,
-0.00382537255063653,
-0.16100597381591797,
0.39337801933288574,
0.0583941787481308,
0.07048845291137695,
-0.08514676243066788,
-0.46626001596450806,
0.5928184986114502,
-0.41462916135787964,
-0.2589123249053955,
0.45332324504852295,
-0.45296329259872437,
-0.40161746740341187,
-0.36019089818000793,
-0.6754876971244812,
-0.3434206247329712,
-0.4702119529247284,
1.0490386486053467,
-0.43089795112609863,
-0.10320446640253067,
0.027754129841923714,
-0.7311939001083374,
0.1555701643228531,
0.564241349697113,
-1.0653247833251953,
0.41204702854156494,
0.24355767667293549,
1.0241758823394775,
-0.27504056692123413,
-0.3840959966182709,
0.08620604872703552,
0.3316058814525604,
-0.03231635317206383,
0.9702749252319336,
-0.36627399921417236,
-0.5245139002799988,
0.1423095017671585,
-0.19142913818359375,
-0.3960969150066376,
-0.0005504825385287404,
0.3097444772720337,
-0.9573422074317932,
0.01940598525106907,
-0.31334757804870605,
-0.5976265668869019,
-0.6797828078269958,
0.550315260887146,
-0.6351433992385864,
0.7222559452056885,
-0.11311134696006775,
-0.8005971908569336,
0.11314361542463303,
-0.30455121397972107,
-0.33180591464042664,
0.14747671782970428,
0.10001666098833084,
0.06273483484983444,
-0.01864096336066723,
0.19243812561035156,
-0.11312426626682281,
0.3134238123893738,
-0.4427047371864319,
-0.10356815159320831,
-0.3771442174911499,
-0.09225629270076752,
-0.12815646827220917,
0.6651744842529297,
-0.1363155096769333,
-0.23343631625175476,
-0.11297860741615295,
-0.4497874975204468,
0.4978300929069519,
0.23337776958942413,
-0.52065509557724,
-0.6795142889022827,
0.26220834255218506,
0.055165939033031464,
-0.10207300633192062,
0.05143878608942032,
-0.45075154304504395,
0.31888651847839355,
-0.32798323035240173,
0.028568867594003677,
0.5199538469314575,
0.3862887918949127,
0.11067143827676773,
-0.9194642305374146,
1.0003939867019653,
0.0018318038200959563,
-0.00564203318208456,
-0.5790156126022339,
-0.6431277990341187,
-0.6856692433357239,
-0.023855766281485558,
0.37029707431793213,
0.8775577545166016,
-1.0190452337265015,
0.1326076090335846,
0.0031587688717991114,
-0.5665987730026245,
-0.3492389917373657,
0.23694291710853577,
-0.03312857076525688,
0.4778452515602112,
0.6339066028594971,
-0.15788112580776215,
-0.09117506444454193,
-0.327284574508667,
-0.4264221489429474,
-0.39813071489334106,
0.1169019266963005,
0.6496195793151855,
0.8574769496917725,
-0.0660729706287384,
0.7541130185127258,
-0.4749605357646942,
-0.13480086624622345,
-0.4631322920322418,
0.006393698509782553,
-0.3118175268173218,
-0.05996471270918846,
0.31398114562034607,
-0.8557073473930359,
-0.6846576929092407,
-0.049477215856313705,
-0.24992021918296814,
0.048130713403224945,
-0.15713490545749664,
0.1552041918039322,
-0.19593869149684906,
0.26151329278945923,
0.048957712948322296,
0.23102563619613647,
0.36393773555755615,
-0.5688785314559937,
0.44119954109191895,
-0.678508460521698,
0.26471146941185,
-0.7134470343589783,
-0.4449932873249054,
-0.15726280212402344,
-0.12074390798807144,
-0.4834343492984772,
0.06918759644031525,
0.1515103578567505,
0.06151614338159561,
-0.4392637312412262,
0.6621524691581726,
-0.3163529634475708,
0.1786859780550003,
-0.09726578742265701,
0.30302244424819946,
0.30901992321014404,
0.0871482640504837,
0.14609354734420776,
0.42719873785972595,
0.23008939623832703,
-0.8845471739768982,
0.0818084254860878,
0.4956960678100586,
-0.10862687975168228,
0.3987581431865692,
-0.6382002830505371,
0.1773553192615509,
-0.42125681042671204,
0.0709390640258789,
-0.9719176888465881,
-0.20937061309814453,
0.038234926760196686,
-0.19358959794044495,
0.16067816317081451,
0.1962943971157074,
-0.10938544571399689,
-0.29937034845352173,
-0.4378504157066345,
-0.1260879933834076,
0.2467951774597168,
-0.6758449673652649,
0.7714852094650269,
0.34587180614471436,
-0.509443998336792,
-0.3517968952655792,
-0.43680331110954285,
-0.03190574795007706,
-0.38090941309928894,
-0.3524755537509918,
0.6445470452308655,
-0.4884800314903259,
-0.36112532019615173,
0.11990105360746384,
-0.03379103168845177,
-0.1943293660879135,
-0.043833840638399124,
0.12666447460651398,
-0.04168304428458214,
0.03540278226137161,
0.43947556614875793,
0.7047606706619263,
0.07514751702547073,
-0.29498788714408875,
0.03649568185210228,
0.0777910128235817,
-0.1381109207868576,
-0.0414007343351841,
-0.01107834279537201,
0.5915631055831909,
0.2547634243965149,
-0.14562948048114777,
0.8101507425308228,
0.31430864334106445,
-0.08358290791511536,
-0.22176039218902588,
-0.4468114972114563,
-0.18627630174160004,
-0.4524495005607605,
0.006960681639611721,
-0.5326045751571655,
-0.6681355834007263,
0.43099871277809143,
0.08300267159938812,
0.3318656086921692,
0.1008213609457016,
0.07103341072797775,
-0.7538237571716309,
0.9378373026847839,
0.8173142671585083,
0.5074881315231323,
0.5281073451042175,
-0.07999520748853683,
0.07645095139741898,
-0.6475093960762024,
-0.5492264628410339,
-0.3578110337257385,
-0.36606737971305847,
-0.24843569099903107,
-0.18733197450637817,
0.30379071831703186,
0.33027365803718567,
-0.26931288838386536,
-0.004036813974380493,
-0.04159355163574219,
0.5914516448974609,
0.7414243221282959,
0.28811588883399963,
0.7821149230003357,
0.45442432165145874,
-0.4681325852870941,
-0.34846508502960205,
-0.6014658808708191,
-0.77732914686203,
1.1318964958190918,
0.21272096037864685,
0.2890290319919586,
0.49580901861190796,
1.1339069604873657,
0.4940697252750397,
0.15582360327243805,
-1.1503121852874756,
0.2550203204154968,
0.6184810996055603,
-0.5665752291679382,
-0.6856511235237122,
-0.09745059907436371,
-1.1414098739624023,
0.5486851334571838,
-0.12621214985847473,
-0.574831485748291,
0.08977682143449783,
-0.08906762301921844,
-0.6891980171203613,
0.20331324636936188,
-0.941903829574585,
0.690013587474823,
-0.5582402944564819,
-0.1928432434797287,
-0.4827518165111542,
-0.5229350328445435,
-0.09088009595870972,
-0.22521863877773285,
0.38318097591400146,
0.41225945949554443,
-0.7553694248199463,
0.7865475416183472,
-0.24259072542190552,
0.6094430088996887,
0.1939493715763092,
0.3068121373653412,
0.8102538585662842,
0.1434779167175293,
0.28104230761528015,
-0.01882677525281906,
-0.14966325461864471,
-0.19411344826221466,
0.6588645577430725,
-0.392047643661499,
-0.28949370980262756,
0.5661120414733887,
-1.007728934288025,
-0.9319671392440796,
-0.9311835765838623,
-0.4023510217666626,
-0.13643787801265717,
0.5734975337982178,
-0.0034843431785702705,
0.16116733849048615,
-0.0931253507733345,
0.1865989863872528,
0.7094694972038269,
-0.14993508160114288,
0.8526637554168701,
0.7362177968025208,
-0.07892408967018127,
-0.601232647895813,
0.971787691116333,
0.6042630076408386,
0.3705323040485382,
0.15936939418315887,
0.3941343426704407,
-0.5091320872306824,
-0.8436146378517151,
-0.31316596269607544,
0.24937906861305237,
-0.7134444713592529,
0.22011448442935944,
-0.9608592391014099,
0.20561766624450684,
-0.13368593156337738,
-0.35939663648605347,
0.42765873670578003,
-0.10537763684988022,
-0.34118908643722534,
-0.37162071466445923,
0.2824251055717468,
1.1410551071166992,
-0.09872938692569733,
0.5836395025253296,
-0.8128147721290588,
0.08091270923614502,
0.5189245939254761,
-0.21325741708278656,
0.014262001030147076,
-0.5782585144042969,
-0.21743664145469666,
-0.20533053576946259,
-0.9108838438987732,
-1.1957252025604248,
0.5602356791496277,
0.33365538716316223,
0.4644741714000702,
0.3960338830947876,
0.25830644369125366,
0.5094283223152161,
-0.2425922304391861,
0.7477098107337952,
-0.07710430771112442,
-0.8203765749931335,
0.3253517150878906,
-0.5744787454605103,
0.27284905314445496,
0.6470740437507629,
0.8385151028633118,
-0.40605154633522034,
-0.013945930637419224,
-0.981663703918457,
-0.6972095966339111,
0.42924997210502625,
0.06647448986768723,
0.2785572409629822,
0.19661054015159607,
0.14132799208164215,
0.027682313695549965,
0.6971160173416138,
-0.7600030899047852,
-0.2767331898212433,
-0.22165201604366302,
-0.13968004286289215,
-0.1892387568950653,
-0.09994140267372131,
0.0676494836807251,
-0.498757541179657,
0.4815158545970917,
-0.3102487623691559,
-0.12171689420938492,
0.5016849040985107,
-0.05611037462949753,
-0.12995149195194244,
0.07962899655103683,
0.39257532358169556,
0.6707738637924194,
-0.021723832935094833,
-0.0052886237390339375,
0.34006237983703613,
-1.01784348487854,
0.04602658376097679,
-0.24230824410915375,
-0.18825559318065643,
-0.16489434242248535,
0.3410904109477997,
0.3416122496128082,
0.2384129762649536,
-0.7693044543266296,
0.26878735423088074,
-0.22849099338054657,
-0.12458580732345581,
-0.3487207591533661,
0.14401966333389282,
0.37842556834220886,
0.2664717435836792,
0.3169821798801422,
-0.11556483060121536,
0.040670596063137054,
-0.33872267603874207,
0.08388786017894745,
-0.06150638312101364,
-0.08013314008712769,
0.006067820359021425,
0.3479936420917511,
0.41717252135276794,
-0.44159039855003357,
0.46115338802337646,
-0.3039156496524811,
-0.3806249499320984,
0.9571849703788757,
0.7300230264663696,
0.46193063259124756,
-0.2716412842273712,
0.7198627591133118,
0.4681633412837982,
0.720152735710144,
0.21107281744480133,
0.5496481657028198,
-0.33280834555625916,
-0.6741892695426941,
0.13067105412483215,
-0.5026626586914062,
-0.7895346283912659,
0.11722150444984436,
-0.5023230910301208,
0.31295672059059143,
-0.45956626534461975,
-0.053983353078365326,
-0.35280343890190125,
0.34892261028289795,
-0.6705291271209717,
0.4872835576534271,
0.1359594315290451,
0.7191949486732483,
-0.6079195141792297,
0.33514001965522766,
0.9086253046989441,
-0.5441412329673767,
-1.061649203300476,
0.296183705329895,
0.11710753291845322,
-0.22355495393276215,
0.2283523678779602,
0.13414087891578674,
0.07959091663360596,
0.6988276839256287,
0.17823751270771027,
-1.1887993812561035,
1.2915366888046265,
-0.3424558639526367,
-0.6445580124855042,
-0.2817048132419586,
-0.19934161007404327,
0.43097132444381714,
-0.33974719047546387,
0.7859316468238831,
0.24587923288345337,
0.5090517401695251,
0.08097920566797256,
-0.5236037969589233,
-0.5879144668579102,
0.2094663679599762,
-0.15652041137218475,
-0.09852158278226852,
-0.5880011320114136,
0.39142367243766785,
-0.7533474564552307,
-0.037290818989276886,
-0.1452578604221344,
0.7392923831939697,
0.1590101569890976,
0.7429622411727905,
0.6063324213027954,
0.5228986144065857,
1.107033371925354,
0.10874942690134048,
1.0917623043060303,
-0.1265513151884079,
0.2526269853115082,
0.5205244421958923,
0.17656414210796356,
1.2209815979003906,
0.6131026744842529,
-0.09455035626888275,
0.8170207142829895,
1.024216651916504,
0.400021493434906,
0.5920612812042236,
0.044203076511621475,
-0.5837530493736267,
-0.33480146527290344,
-0.14366960525512695,
-0.42596277594566345,
0.09316889941692352,
0.6558783054351807,
-0.04597475752234459,
-0.19495777785778046,
0.33774906396865845,
-0.21062642335891724,
0.05146351456642151,
-0.6203770637512207,
0.528508722782135,
0.23240067064762115,
-0.6865688562393188,
0.20908987522125244,
-0.016237352043390274,
0.2963408827781677,
-0.5984286665916443,
0.11334018409252167,
0.1509677618741989,
-0.04307886213064194,
-0.4065798223018646,
-0.6587657928466797,
-0.06909212470054626,
-0.22950422763824463,
0.017369719222187996,
-0.28529322147369385,
0.6091251373291016,
-0.32940390706062317,
-0.46928858757019043,
0.08154432475566864,
0.7379576563835144,
-0.07625135779380798,
0.10929283499717712,
-0.6787633895874023,
-0.311794251203537,
-0.027997255325317383,
-0.9111632108688354,
0.3012005090713501,
0.15752026438713074,
0.3014303147792816,
0.6047277450561523,
0.6543207168579102,
0.14496375620365143,
0.18358303606510162,
-0.26933762431144714,
0.4534984529018402,
-0.6804853677749634,
-1.0015206336975098,
-0.3314802348613739,
0.6083449125289917,
0.0020378173794597387,
-0.7126097083091736,
1.064256191253662,
0.3530042767524719,
0.8045411705970764,
-0.24674956500530243,
0.9118180274963379,
-0.07308463752269745,
0.32615140080451965,
-0.22300876677036285,
0.4787035286426544,
-0.7634658813476562,
-0.03077799081802368,
-0.10891707986593246,
-0.9568660855293274,
0.043511323630809784,
0.4549039900302887,
-0.4998248219490051,
0.03637245297431946,
1.110228419303894,
0.4252139925956726,
0.2652202248573303,
0.3033141493797302,
0.35524359345436096,
-0.2987608015537262,
0.25710222125053406,
0.12983907759189606,
0.7417731881141663,
-0.39411666989326477,
0.48355671763420105,
-0.286003440618515,
-0.4115883708000183,
-0.27692148089408875,
-0.7026240825653076,
-1.1826400756835938,
-0.5882847905158997,
-0.3910752236843109,
-0.32155102491378784,
0.11885737627744675,
0.6843165159225464,
-0.06361767649650574,
-0.1047806367278099,
-0.12079668045043945,
-0.2389504462480545,
0.583901047706604,
-0.31848663091659546,
-0.20258326828479767,
0.06510382890701294,
-0.3407335579395294,
-0.8340211510658264,
0.4015926420688629,
0.04564607888460159,
0.39093899726867676,
-0.11275651305913925,
-0.08694898337125778,
-0.26108261942863464,
0.47397753596305847,
0.6526180505752563,
0.5862046480178833,
-0.3993587791919708,
-0.17085738480091095,
0.2615272104740143,
0.009636273607611656,
-0.2880534529685974,
0.7095202207565308,
-0.7668970227241516,
0.8689093589782715,
0.8007697463035583,
0.6186050176620483,
0.5507424473762512,
0.11484332382678986,
0.13985277712345123,
0.023303596302866936,
-0.3318212926387787,
0.45578616857528687,
0.09820552915334702,
0.010418574325740337,
-0.3305131793022156,
0.013385321944952011,
0.3583183288574219,
-0.6111010313034058,
-0.6565438508987427,
-0.05520227551460266,
-0.7040754556655884,
0.1309678703546524,
1.0711559057235718,
-0.09294632822275162,
-0.3242086172103882,
-0.523511528968811,
-0.44614899158477783,
-0.09016871452331543,
-0.14748115837574005,
0.7313559055328369,
1.25525963306427,
-0.2000405490398407,
-0.10913866013288498,
-0.7867702841758728,
0.2948257327079773,
0.4410880208015442,
-0.8557531237602234,
-0.6674968600273132,
0.16624902188777924,
0.29935896396636963,
0.1319919377565384,
0.3150412142276764,
0.2900815010070801,
0.036765821278095245,
0.24079836905002594,
-0.06892865896224976,
-0.4762057363986969,
-0.7924013733863831,
-0.5103914141654968,
0.18271128833293915,
0.01939479447901249,
0.022127974778413773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02475v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02475v1
|
Enhancing LLM Safety via Constrained Direct Preference Optimization
| 2024-03-04T20:39:24 | 2024-03-04T20:39:24 |
Zixuan Liu, Xiaolin Sun, Zizhan Zheng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The rapidly increasing capabilities of large language models (LLMs) raise an
urgent need to align AI systems with diverse human preferences to
simultaneously enhance their usefulness and safety, despite the often
conflicting nature of these goals. To address this important problem, a
promising approach is to enforce a safety constraint at the fine-tuning stage
through a constrained Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF)
framework. This approach, however, is computationally expensive and often
unstable. In this work, we introduce Constrained DPO (C-DPO), a novel extension
of the recently proposed Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) approach for
fine-tuning LLMs that is both efficient and lightweight. By integrating dual
gradient descent and DPO, our method identifies a nearly optimal trade-off
between helpfulness and harmlessness without using reinforcement learning.
Empirically, our approach provides a safety guarantee to LLMs that is missing
in DPO while achieving significantly higher rewards under the same safety
constraint compared to a recently proposed safe RLHF approach.
Warning: This paper contains example data that may be offensive or harmful.
|
[
-0.23061108589172363,
-0.34319552779197693,
0.48272770643234253,
0.07784850895404816,
-0.245075061917305,
0.18448178470134735,
-0.38572537899017334,
-0.36371198296546936,
-0.27025139331817627,
0.5619844794273376,
-0.8173976540565491,
-0.44582197070121765,
-0.4858987331390381,
0.17657527327537537,
0.43527594208717346,
0.8682928681373596,
-0.0816706120967865,
-0.21296203136444092,
-0.13600598275661469,
0.19578970968723297,
-0.38413533568382263,
-0.5641108751296997,
-0.6768706440925598,
-0.3411513864994049,
0.7339696288108826,
0.6694386005401611,
0.6822810769081116,
0.8930924534797668,
0.4970439374446869,
0.2945406138896942,
-0.11038258671760559,
0.5718188285827637,
-0.4714760184288025,
0.07371408492326736,
-0.2328459620475769,
-0.21367965638637543,
-0.4806464612483978,
0.03989739716053009,
0.46681615710258484,
0.5754682421684265,
-0.27816876769065857,
-0.42924416065216064,
0.31695717573165894,
0.8761783838272095,
-0.9075915217399597,
0.17322157323360443,
-0.7113733887672424,
0.17420603334903717,
0.2033843845129013,
-0.2416324019432068,
-0.40575581789016724,
-0.3712393045425415,
0.11621157824993134,
-0.731371283531189,
-0.2636009156703949,
0.09459256380796432,
0.5541132092475891,
0.9825149178504944,
-0.4622642993927002,
-0.17179173231124878,
-0.607498288154602,
0.9972522854804993,
-0.3828198313713074,
0.14378662407398224,
0.547710120677948,
-0.040565453469753265,
-0.5239858627319336,
-0.08559170365333557,
-0.3947540819644928,
-0.6381182670593262,
-0.04733923450112343,
-0.09324705600738525,
0.06617569923400879,
0.5957561135292053,
-0.004258757457137108,
0.01927649974822998,
-0.26484057307243347,
0.6861162185668945,
0.10837742686271667,
-0.36532625555992126,
0.7632757425308228,
0.24254362285137177,
0.077365942299366,
-0.13425764441490173,
-0.4956077039241791,
-0.23182527720928192,
-0.7566267848014832,
0.21643003821372986,
0.5602839589118958,
0.44220197200775146,
-0.04569892957806587,
0.26911720633506775,
-0.2500540316104889,
0.37676504254341125,
0.14094777405261993,
-0.41994237899780273,
0.08422622829675674,
-0.03181303292512894,
0.0036339606158435345,
-0.003129755612462759,
0.809058666229248,
0.5469805002212524,
0.29480138421058655,
-0.09962782263755798,
-0.2741061747074127,
0.15555055439472198,
0.1492861956357956,
-0.6985178589820862,
0.0018345365533605218,
0.13998402655124664,
-0.10659666359424591,
-0.7377457022666931,
-0.22800306975841522,
-0.7231501936912537,
-0.620698094367981,
-0.19627977907657623,
-0.07600771635770798,
-0.2739464342594147,
-0.24538348615169525,
0.3919563591480255,
0.18478967249393463,
-0.10440879315137863,
0.20756657421588898,
-1.2674132585525513,
0.1523420512676239,
0.8746737241744995,
0.44310081005096436,
-0.31193387508392334,
-0.2369535267353058,
-0.8097690939903259,
0.38675183057785034,
-0.30682796239852905,
0.35413843393325806,
-0.4225238859653473,
-0.6482619047164917,
0.07438772916793823,
-0.15173985064029694,
0.10265488922595978,
-0.568689227104187,
1.110594630241394,
-0.3101779818534851,
-0.3311639428138733,
-0.23321548104286194,
-0.3353964686393738,
-0.016506953164935112,
0.3058609962463379,
-0.36251121759414673,
0.7824658155441284,
-0.14196081459522247,
-0.6627385020256042,
0.4361705482006073,
-0.23448766767978668,
-0.5417308211326599,
-0.18066461384296417,
-0.26421329379081726,
-0.4918527603149414,
-0.10185977071523666,
0.21357224881649017,
0.33180052042007446,
-0.1179509162902832,
0.5080951452255249,
-0.7042114734649658,
-0.3270110487937927,
0.17063884437084198,
-0.3631036877632141,
0.3848596513271332,
0.11478403210639954,
-0.25334009528160095,
0.3864600360393524,
-0.7663264274597168,
-0.13004647195339203,
0.05397772043943405,
-0.7633260488510132,
-0.472054660320282,
0.3252021074295044,
-0.36615535616874695,
0.1837332546710968,
0.4644736051559448,
-0.5344943404197693,
0.2204887866973877,
-0.5540695786476135,
0.3377017676830292,
1.2287694215774536,
-0.16523100435733795,
0.6865626573562622,
-0.32042399048805237,
0.529503345489502,
-0.20996780693531036,
0.4768334925174713,
0.5829761028289795,
-0.03353818133473396,
-0.6151617765426636,
-0.390362948179245,
0.08055324107408524,
0.7440781593322754,
-0.698959231376648,
0.9361151456832886,
-0.023105336353182793,
0.019312914460897446,
-0.2678321301937103,
0.27871450781822205,
0.5742626190185547,
0.6342614889144897,
0.1754690557718277,
0.16733019053936005,
-0.4959283471107483,
-0.9960105419158936,
0.07200948894023895,
-0.42347386479377747,
-0.03795002028346062,
0.5763347744941711,
-0.017689457163214684,
-0.4049367904663086,
0.6322188377380371,
-0.5687036514282227,
-0.1413196474313736,
-0.1752794235944748,
-0.38724982738494873,
-0.031533464789390564,
0.7714828848838806,
0.5133248567581177,
-0.690521240234375,
-0.4426616132259369,
-0.07641484588384628,
-0.32535824179649353,
-0.06563509255647659,
0.11414990574121475,
-0.08807948231697083,
0.33875635266304016,
0.30178597569465637,
-0.4086199700832367,
0.1824379414319992,
0.5134809017181396,
-0.17922623455524445,
0.29219508171081543,
-0.4099791944026947,
-0.1336555927991867,
-0.5950763821601868,
-0.11614260822534561,
-0.08401590585708618,
-0.26238489151000977,
-0.5029237866401672,
-0.07944949716329575,
0.08366025239229202,
-0.13606593012809753,
-0.37517520785331726,
0.46472328901290894,
-0.1498580276966095,
0.5144017338752747,
-0.463384747505188,
0.05577346682548523,
-0.23879115283489227,
0.7166624069213867,
0.23385244607925415,
0.5968915820121765,
0.5772032141685486,
-0.8873761296272278,
0.08338931202888489,
0.2868986129760742,
-0.0012352580670267344,
0.25246649980545044,
-0.6591672301292419,
0.3091103136539459,
-0.09990272670984268,
0.08125794678926468,
-0.5150759220123291,
-0.2494487315416336,
0.5848468542098999,
-0.012897615320980549,
0.5545032620429993,
-0.3841291069984436,
-0.1836431324481964,
-0.1958872675895691,
-0.6307030916213989,
0.35881307721138,
0.5763000249862671,
-0.5917350053787231,
0.09131621569395065,
0.6005315780639648,
-0.0937788262963295,
-1.0866237878799438,
-0.3130822777748108,
-0.10528059303760529,
-0.3913213610649109,
-0.4162117838859558,
0.48818692564964294,
-0.2620381712913513,
-0.1927480548620224,
-0.24348247051239014,
-0.35793304443359375,
0.1552923023700714,
0.487209290266037,
0.3373320996761322,
0.4190075993537903,
0.48176664113998413,
0.09653192013502121,
0.2868892550468445,
-0.4487658441066742,
-0.054522834718227386,
-0.09191897511482239,
0.26705655455589294,
-0.05014367401599884,
-0.16821588575839996,
-0.4915786683559418,
0.28350991010665894,
0.3562151789665222,
0.05232441425323486,
0.4160919487476349,
0.18184062838554382,
-0.05242772027850151,
-0.4885421097278595,
-0.22598275542259216,
-0.32160016894340515,
-0.6322537660598755,
0.3717293441295624,
-0.26784956455230713,
-1.082842469215393,
0.003357904264703393,
-0.18779805302619934,
0.021689726039767265,
0.06248793751001358,
0.30620434880256653,
0.12502627074718475,
1.1390312910079956,
0.614100992679596,
-0.27827128767967224,
0.6561295986175537,
0.22165371477603912,
-0.05327881872653961,
-0.6550218462944031,
-0.18196450173854828,
-0.5072637796401978,
-0.30645987391471863,
-0.9011281728744507,
-0.2204306572675705,
0.4216219484806061,
0.11554806679487228,
-0.35369589924812317,
0.08441446721553802,
-0.6145609021186829,
0.392194002866745,
0.6640220880508423,
0.4024910628795624,
0.20788469910621643,
-0.19922566413879395,
-0.22527681291103363,
-0.08477195352315903,
-0.6686481237411499,
-0.4361664056777954,
0.9507868885993958,
0.38797080516815186,
1.0011166334152222,
0.015708472579717636,
0.9639474153518677,
0.10061083734035492,
-0.03611830621957779,
-0.8607105612754822,
0.7023434042930603,
-0.2696285843849182,
-0.36419913172721863,
-0.3469986021518707,
-0.6603735089302063,
-0.9085657596588135,
0.014378592371940613,
-0.28536608815193176,
-0.6696745753288269,
0.298733651638031,
0.47592929005622864,
-0.473952054977417,
0.005084681790322065,
-0.5056085586547852,
0.4497223496437073,
-0.5417795777320862,
-0.6690491437911987,
-0.4666610360145569,
-0.688230574131012,
0.3534683287143707,
0.22174768149852753,
0.05843536555767059,
-0.6416595578193665,
-0.47284913063049316,
0.33892950415611267,
-0.2904026508331299,
0.9336806535720825,
-0.28808221220970154,
-0.2878238260746002,
-0.05400537699460983,
0.06239982694387436,
0.8586617112159729,
0.42379167675971985,
-0.24959033727645874,
-0.17204955220222473,
-0.21111249923706055,
-0.32583698630332947,
-0.37181907892227173,
0.9549292325973511,
-0.8539289236068726,
-1.0305333137512207,
-0.49832525849342346,
-0.5710383653640747,
-0.49133267998695374,
0.20659789443016052,
-0.12905903160572052,
0.0709138736128807,
-0.14041993021965027,
-0.05289512127637863,
0.8290514349937439,
-0.4251519739627838,
0.546336829662323,
0.5585846900939941,
0.06933494657278061,
-0.6242771148681641,
0.7081048488616943,
-0.3434234857559204,
0.24282756447792053,
0.5459970831871033,
0.5068543553352356,
-0.46054691076278687,
-0.9784599542617798,
-0.4161188006401062,
0.05372218042612076,
-0.4951576590538025,
-0.2077498435974121,
-0.3099842667579651,
0.10263124108314514,
-0.2349853217601776,
-0.18820254504680634,
-0.4546033442020416,
-0.4970957040786743,
-0.4719582796096802,
-0.2784820795059204,
0.2876318097114563,
0.3876122534275055,
-0.37715384364128113,
-0.15857915580272675,
-0.6566754579544067,
0.19062842428684235,
0.5062499046325684,
0.590674638748169,
-0.2714800238609314,
-0.24724605679512024,
-0.011457446962594986,
-0.028920700773596764,
-0.27063485980033875,
-0.4065099060535431,
0.17472918331623077,
0.03524224832653999,
0.6448326110839844,
0.47125616669654846,
0.7691901922225952,
0.2866699695587158,
-0.5259257555007935,
0.24400083720684052,
0.25743499398231506,
-0.6196025013923645,
0.6419490575790405,
-0.5879210233688354,
-0.1758849024772644,
0.8863418102264404,
0.3173287510871887,
-0.1541784256696701,
0.09312444925308228,
-0.2868143916130066,
-0.7993896007537842,
0.5731492042541504,
-0.04247277230024338,
0.23187477886676788,
-0.11244162917137146,
0.6056128144264221,
0.11043204367160797,
0.1729007214307785,
-0.6524719595909119,
-0.2410120666027069,
0.17119964957237244,
-0.1160915419459343,
0.0241558775305748,
-0.41780024766921997,
-0.528790295124054,
-0.20139920711517334,
0.7907683253288269,
-0.355014443397522,
-0.1672639101743698,
0.17774493992328644,
0.12713265419006348,
-0.12835019826889038,
0.39688804745674133,
0.7347008585929871,
0.2505996525287628,
-0.38992756605148315,
0.1290520280599594,
0.05833963677287102,
-0.35323765873908997,
0.4739724397659302,
0.3078249990940094,
-0.29990091919898987,
-0.5322635769844055,
-0.0928940400481224,
0.8362153768539429,
0.3627656400203705,
-0.841251790523529,
0.24909205734729767,
-0.12448087334632874,
-0.1665264368057251,
-0.12887433171272278,
0.5469110608100891,
-0.15675678849220276,
0.07666077464818954,
0.0834430605173111,
0.09175613522529602,
-0.008510979823768139,
-0.2284533977508545,
0.1638210415840149,
0.585006058216095,
-0.49609196186065674,
-0.08532574772834778,
0.6013989448547363,
0.8038278818130493,
-0.37000933289527893,
0.23219364881515503,
-0.29296544194221497,
-0.4295814335346222,
0.4925991892814636,
0.26760929822921753,
0.9551469683647156,
-0.028930243104696274,
0.1274747997522354,
0.30975931882858276,
0.40070614218711853,
-0.14341513812541962,
0.14513131976127625,
-0.09184364229440689,
-0.916078507900238,
-0.23553961515426636,
-0.5320926904678345,
-0.6588528752326965,
0.010209170170128345,
-0.44527730345726013,
0.2842496931552887,
-0.8926215171813965,
-0.19100938737392426,
-0.41821980476379395,
0.1964201182126999,
-0.210320845246315,
0.02373739518225193,
0.20351922512054443,
0.527067244052887,
-0.30472299456596375,
0.967272937297821,
0.4764465391635895,
-0.10658767819404602,
-0.7561028003692627,
0.17116118967533112,
0.035558365285396576,
-0.8609476089477539,
0.3720497786998749,
0.054563868790864944,
-0.490319162607193,
-0.0635862872004509,
-0.2723136246204376,
-0.6183256506919861,
0.9250695705413818,
0.7634649276733398,
-1.010328769683838,
0.007499470375478268,
0.13225899636745453,
0.3016006350517273,
-0.1111685037612915,
-0.41094446182250977,
0.5585022568702698,
0.5239481925964355,
0.023081643506884575,
-0.9314712882041931,
0.34209656715393066,
0.12873680889606476,
-0.0234852135181427,
0.3369297981262207,
-1.0196256637573242,
0.30099567770957947,
-0.44175878167152405,
-0.20451176166534424,
0.005163644906133413,
0.33121034502983093,
0.43494367599487305,
0.2782292366027832,
0.8682867884635925,
0.6307375431060791,
0.8260307312011719,
0.1308712214231491,
1.0427345037460327,
-0.23704107105731964,
0.2290153205394745,
1.044019341468811,
-0.402854859828949,
0.6512585878372192,
0.6835324764251709,
-0.22791054844856262,
0.22031717002391815,
0.721590518951416,
0.39886173605918884,
0.9411817193031311,
0.4365963935852051,
-0.5559321641921997,
-0.4828715920448303,
-0.3517285883426666,
-0.18019592761993408,
0.301727294921875,
0.21186181902885437,
-0.057178743183612823,
0.20281164348125458,
-0.31129512190818787,
0.16838479042053223,
0.3720235824584961,
-0.3357086777687073,
0.8156256675720215,
0.16341376304626465,
-0.8550972938537598,
0.801405131816864,
-0.14455361664295197,
0.9695941209793091,
-0.5126477479934692,
0.21096159517765045,
-0.2181423455476761,
0.5150554180145264,
-0.0447026789188385,
-0.4292498826980591,
0.2325596958398819,
-0.1588931530714035,
-0.1171751320362091,
-0.2709061801433563,
0.8897979259490967,
-0.3688482642173767,
-0.252644419670105,
0.5596574544906616,
0.10109096020460129,
-0.4694427251815796,
0.21512112021446228,
-0.6685413122177124,
0.01584204100072384,
0.07725318521261215,
-0.1428314745426178,
0.579776406288147,
0.20420239865779877,
0.23354333639144897,
0.9429712891578674,
0.4724324941635132,
0.021477971225976944,
-0.3174116313457489,
-0.11672043800354004,
0.9607263207435608,
-0.44200846552848816,
-0.5690920352935791,
-0.9138457179069519,
0.3782646954059601,
-0.017722968012094498,
-0.19755062460899353,
0.4337671995162964,
0.14075012505054474,
0.6331973671913147,
-0.012832341715693474,
0.9336181282997131,
0.08038638532161713,
0.3850046694278717,
-0.643896222114563,
0.5718940496444702,
-0.580288290977478,
0.45628821849823,
-0.1846482902765274,
-0.4885714054107666,
-0.3164348304271698,
0.39715075492858887,
-0.2557804584503174,
-0.17651426792144775,
0.45791059732437134,
0.9457840323448181,
0.2032056599855423,
-0.42225202918052673,
0.41475680470466614,
-0.3191525638103485,
0.22597636282444,
0.9318786263465881,
0.9424260854721069,
0.24615132808685303,
0.7697256803512573,
-0.6940918564796448,
-0.39286237955093384,
-0.26724299788475037,
-1.2004077434539795,
-1.0754523277282715,
-0.1507073938846588,
-0.39846858382225037,
-0.2916492521762848,
0.1457325518131256,
1.1723612546920776,
0.8027351498603821,
-0.7958766222000122,
-0.014912000857293606,
-0.32504284381866455,
0.5003352761268616,
-0.11277499049901962,
-0.12076660245656967,
0.19184796512126923,
-0.34390559792518616,
-1.0104947090148926,
0.7305094599723816,
0.40641680359840393,
0.2140146791934967,
-0.16154451668262482,
-0.5557485222816467,
0.004382242914289236,
0.013840442523360252,
0.19040867686271667,
0.4580754339694977,
-0.5318607687950134,
-0.7389848828315735,
-0.0631491094827652,
-0.12785306572914124,
-0.03366129845380783,
0.8752843737602234,
-0.3514370918273926,
0.1996930092573166,
0.4537936747074127,
0.9005814790725708,
0.205718994140625,
0.012401577085256577,
0.8275400996208191,
-0.8566465377807617,
0.5733987092971802,
0.506112813949585,
0.3078700602054596,
0.2441127449274063,
-0.7635860443115234,
0.5233292579650879,
0.16703975200653076,
-0.7438554167747498,
-0.8584127426147461,
0.7251176834106445,
-1.0157612562179565,
-0.2540028989315033,
1.2622889280319214,
-0.21921132504940033,
0.1620582640171051,
-0.11660048365592957,
-0.2563011646270752,
0.18434277176856995,
-0.7852247357368469,
1.0311098098754883,
0.31676989793777466,
-0.2844637632369995,
-0.16177448630332947,
-0.09065239131450653,
1.06566321849823,
0.6658782362937927,
-0.702844500541687,
0.23023110628128052,
0.5680118203163147,
0.24454514682292938,
-0.29261514544487,
0.4497697949409485,
0.2989136874675751,
0.18668335676193237,
-0.23599770665168762,
-0.07329794019460678,
-0.35592886805534363,
-0.33939722180366516,
-0.43140584230422974,
0.047387730330228806,
0.4746708869934082,
-0.4507507383823395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02474v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02474v1
|
The Emotion Dynamics of Literary Novels
| 2024-03-04T20:39:21 | 2024-03-04T20:39:21 |
Krishnapriya Vishnubhotla, Adam Hammond, Graeme Hirst, Saif M. Mohammad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Stories are rich in the emotions they exhibit in their narratives and evoke
in the readers. The emotional journeys of the various characters within a story
are central to their appeal. Computational analysis of the emotions of novels,
however, has rarely examined the variation in the emotional trajectories of the
different characters within them, instead considering the entire novel to
represent a single story arc. In this work, we use character dialogue to
distinguish between the emotion arcs of the narration and the various
characters. We analyze the emotion arcs of the various characters in a dataset
of English literary novels using the framework of Utterance Emotion Dynamics.
Our findings show that the narration and the dialogue largely express disparate
emotions through the course of a novel, and that the commonalities or
differences in the emotional arcs of stories are more accurately captured by
those associated with individual characters.
|
[
-0.1585695445537567,
-0.3581596314907074,
0.6834431886672974,
-0.04521331563591957,
0.048025041818618774,
0.4215560555458069,
0.07048648595809937,
-0.5356265306472778,
0.39500030875205994,
0.2580205202102661,
-0.8780452013015747,
-0.2255806028842926,
-0.3130362927913666,
0.5091685056686401,
-0.03657201677560806,
0.8609633445739746,
-0.23869647085666656,
-0.14203451573848724,
-0.15680000185966492,
-0.3204866051673889,
-0.14596275985240936,
-0.5766938924789429,
-0.09976470470428467,
-0.24560050666332245,
0.9654574394226074,
-0.12349849939346313,
0.8192907571792603,
-0.03757556900382042,
0.4610893130302429,
0.36783817410469055,
-0.22454918920993805,
0.07335813343524933,
-0.5960392951965332,
0.8662601113319397,
-0.03358888998627663,
-0.6118607521057129,
0.3180452585220337,
-0.0706922709941864,
0.4384351670742035,
0.3087288737297058,
0.16403435170650482,
-0.4873008131980896,
0.18445588648319244,
1.0189142227172852,
-0.5612723231315613,
0.08738955855369568,
0.18721039593219757,
0.2416040152311325,
-0.41373515129089355,
-0.4194248616695404,
-0.2664446234703064,
-0.6144651770591736,
0.405366450548172,
-0.5506583452224731,
0.09551221877336502,
0.15319687128067017,
0.8475790023803711,
-0.15576553344726562,
-0.7055252194404602,
-0.8239157199859619,
-0.80538409948349,
0.7104170918464661,
-0.24599480628967285,
-0.26316097378730774,
-0.2201482206583023,
0.04426858574151993,
0.134172260761261,
-0.10197077691555023,
-0.5574374198913574,
-0.43981727957725525,
-0.3758945167064667,
0.1651570051908493,
-0.3446022570133209,
0.42995575070381165,
0.21666337549686432,
0.5084785223007202,
-0.5951641201972961,
-0.08424892276525497,
-0.10468246787786484,
0.12458094954490662,
0.7512210607528687,
0.7162342667579651,
0.8777075409889221,
-0.38165539503097534,
-0.2547067701816559,
-0.38315510749816895,
-0.37396788597106934,
0.5088940262794495,
0.5720522403717041,
0.11506392806768417,
-0.17745371162891388,
0.2900286018848419,
0.3525252044200897,
0.013138437643647194,
-0.1608986258506775,
-0.15624049305915833,
0.3963935077190399,
-0.20955152809619904,
-0.01691010221838951,
0.31855881214141846,
0.9121813178062439,
0.48461639881134033,
0.3560563027858734,
0.038696274161338806,
-0.05431605130434036,
0.17475152015686035,
0.3007282316684723,
-0.7009199261665344,
0.0713004395365715,
0.5549840331077576,
-0.39077261090278625,
-0.29531338810920715,
-0.19441238045692444,
-0.9581371545791626,
-0.8968107104301453,
-0.07389329373836517,
0.012350252829492092,
-0.5759150981903076,
-0.2190805822610855,
-0.002413305453956127,
-0.5997896194458008,
0.3546387553215027,
0.40802499651908875,
-1.0888173580169678,
0.12806516885757446,
0.41990822553634644,
0.7694026231765747,
-0.21579033136367798,
-0.3249792158603668,
0.13742104172706604,
-0.12943090498447418,
-0.5043003559112549,
0.8903074860572815,
-0.6979863047599792,
-0.3840346038341522,
0.08494103699922562,
0.06379538774490356,
-0.5415264368057251,
0.0334940180182457,
0.40644150972366333,
-0.16675806045532227,
0.027379171922802925,
-0.5146563649177551,
-0.5603922605514526,
-0.39584892988204956,
0.027314258739352226,
-0.9832918047904968,
0.6967805624008179,
0.048228006809949875,
-0.7015627026557922,
-0.21590986847877502,
-0.33691680431365967,
-0.5619820952415466,
-0.1723117232322693,
-0.2504381239414215,
-0.05295708775520325,
0.6485647559165955,
0.05214160680770874,
0.1601153016090393,
-0.36469191312789917,
-0.22523973882198334,
-0.14797063171863556,
-0.5265530943870544,
0.47137323021888733,
0.00950354803353548,
0.6411465406417847,
0.42276325821876526,
-0.15206947922706604,
-0.13393822312355042,
-0.3986639082431793,
-0.3048946261405945,
-0.03289003297686577,
0.21754468977451324,
-0.5145788192749023,
0.18692775070667267,
0.15881215035915375,
-0.3503614366054535,
-0.011840671300888062,
-0.26867297291755676,
0.5681425333023071,
-0.45200127363204956,
0.20683209598064423,
0.4565347135066986,
0.4852559268474579,
0.5722488164901733,
-0.6775911450386047,
1.2285460233688354,
0.06592496484518051,
-0.283208429813385,
-0.7024023532867432,
-0.36171168088912964,
-0.5421005487442017,
-0.17014405131340027,
0.08912826329469681,
0.637714147567749,
-0.323506623506546,
0.19434355199337006,
0.2657907009124756,
-0.3904055058956146,
-0.6448299884796143,
-0.6253036260604858,
0.260164737701416,
-0.24105378985404968,
-0.16263090074062347,
0.11103776097297668,
-0.01239286083728075,
-0.11966601759195328,
-0.5011274814605713,
-0.44312775135040283,
0.10380850732326508,
0.13960853219032288,
0.26995888352394104,
0.11884746700525284,
0.7811128497123718,
-0.5150147080421448,
0.1254597008228302,
-0.39637506008148193,
0.533700168132782,
-0.08594051003456116,
0.2962038516998291,
0.8974131345748901,
-0.6671673059463501,
-0.5419551134109497,
0.4341903626918793,
-0.8030324578285217,
-0.11198345571756363,
-0.7623743414878845,
-0.24813947081565857,
-0.10503911972045898,
0.12297425419092178,
-0.6432236433029175,
0.5358601808547974,
0.09588506817817688,
-0.33908626437187195,
0.6546580195426941,
-0.06061648949980736,
0.9647010564804077,
-0.6814718246459961,
-0.097947858273983,
-0.04794217273592949,
0.08811008930206299,
-0.4485410153865814,
-0.024958115071058273,
-0.21212758123874664,
-0.02136862836778164,
-0.21901600062847137,
0.5262427926063538,
-0.7649203538894653,
-0.07096008956432343,
0.2759638726711273,
0.3762897551059723,
0.6860209703445435,
0.6225293874740601,
-0.01330783125013113,
0.34878242015838623,
0.5180029273033142,
-0.5364250540733337,
0.6606492400169373,
0.30265602469444275,
-0.4124370217323303,
0.796461820602417,
-0.44935113191604614,
0.1330515295267105,
-0.48773428797721863,
-0.011034509167075157,
-1.3549569845199585,
-0.20065054297447205,
0.030804650858044624,
-0.2988171875476837,
0.22048446536064148,
-0.009617988020181656,
-0.21896763145923615,
0.008214364759624004,
-0.3802054226398468,
0.26929813623428345,
0.6404227614402771,
-0.056600358337163925,
0.8630711436271667,
0.0418662503361702,
-0.5655513405799866,
-0.4303826689720154,
-0.5224552154541016,
-0.10160727798938751,
-0.43084895610809326,
-0.6146991848945618,
0.1793312430381775,
-0.4813701808452606,
-0.5344900488853455,
-0.16762268543243408,
0.11767654120922089,
-0.21351638436317444,
-0.10596666485071182,
0.4312424063682556,
-0.012446369975805283,
-0.08289212733507156,
0.31631556153297424,
0.5503646731376648,
0.20703093707561493,
-0.028244687244296074,
0.5071811079978943,
0.08121810853481293,
0.16931277513504028,
-0.19877929985523224,
-0.621129035949707,
0.7891906499862671,
0.9031851887702942,
-0.06354347616434097,
0.4802943468093872,
0.20373709499835968,
-0.09010860323905945,
-0.11773385107517242,
0.1498604118824005,
0.2743125259876251,
-0.38636353611946106,
0.3400893211364746,
-0.6586414575576782,
-0.5215495824813843,
0.8519612550735474,
0.07830768078565598,
-0.019795747473835945,
0.6011315584182739,
0.4575825333595276,
-0.5616385340690613,
0.86318439245224,
0.43202805519104004,
-0.07351420074701309,
0.4119877815246582,
0.03149527683854103,
0.1457308679819107,
-0.5988361239433289,
-0.10671893507242203,
-1.036596655845642,
-0.561177670955658,
-0.5585665702819824,
0.13093416392803192,
0.38382500410079956,
0.24772123992443085,
-0.10487813502550125,
0.0006045998889021575,
-0.38845953345298767,
0.9550050497055054,
0.023211857303977013,
-0.2732878625392914,
0.09279535710811615,
-0.125462606549263,
-0.2239329218864441,
-0.4216320514678955,
-0.1250481903553009,
-0.49954697489738464,
0.49473291635513306,
0.42428189516067505,
0.7988442182540894,
0.5354354381561279,
0.6343167424201965,
0.579505443572998,
-0.3147582709789276,
-0.827131450176239,
0.18512755632400513,
-0.053515709936618805,
-0.4113110899925232,
-0.25407615303993225,
-0.44268688559532166,
-1.2840123176574707,
0.20726287364959717,
-0.12892766296863556,
-1.0277024507522583,
0.7606561183929443,
-0.3344564139842987,
-0.61281418800354,
0.13397854566574097,
-0.4923069179058075,
1.005454421043396,
-0.2563322186470032,
-0.0467035286128521,
-0.2634391784667969,
-0.6424655318260193,
0.07855185121297836,
0.22599095106124878,
0.06069989502429962,
-0.18474265933036804,
0.4515686333179474,
0.3741269111633301,
-0.47309020161628723,
0.7441036105155945,
0.08341355621814728,
-0.11239013820886612,
0.6751059889793396,
0.6538927555084229,
0.31962528824806213,
-0.457413911819458,
-0.30292701721191406,
-0.03034908138215542,
0.34041303396224976,
-0.13304424285888672,
-0.7791703939437866,
0.40986117720603943,
-0.7464654445648193,
0.019084922969341278,
-0.8778577446937561,
-0.5632343888282776,
-0.1218295693397522,
-0.40064090490341187,
0.4673655033111572,
0.7554998397827148,
-0.6719878911972046,
-0.2928885221481323,
0.29205867648124695,
-0.33633339405059814,
0.7055392265319824,
0.15853098034858704,
-0.23976071178913116,
-0.26785773038864136,
0.5000394582748413,
0.037401314824819565,
0.3701135516166687,
0.5822684168815613,
0.20049403607845306,
-0.3460642993450165,
-0.28730103373527527,
-0.33481812477111816,
0.1056136041879654,
-0.7202768325805664,
-0.005807297769933939,
-0.44048237800598145,
-0.041619736701250076,
-0.19401049613952637,
-0.474488765001297,
-0.01782497949898243,
-0.2951843738555908,
-0.4356273412704468,
-0.23340260982513428,
0.6752757430076599,
1.2691876888275146,
0.3269931375980377,
0.41075363755226135,
-1.013403058052063,
0.0018575291614979506,
0.09654312580823898,
-0.15191981196403503,
0.11847977340221405,
-0.4316340684890747,
-0.34031417965888977,
-0.36125677824020386,
-0.5031993985176086,
-1.2883529663085938,
0.8678537011146545,
0.25076591968536377,
0.04732806980609894,
0.635723352432251,
0.6185188293457031,
0.45650213956832886,
-0.43018838763237,
1.1105608940124512,
0.36491912603378296,
-1.0922260284423828,
0.2855299115180969,
-0.38737237453460693,
0.3489542305469513,
0.5592261552810669,
0.7179545164108276,
-0.8552749156951904,
-0.3215632736682892,
-0.3674558401107788,
-0.5356644988059998,
0.7353004217147827,
0.39174938201904297,
0.05890999734401703,
0.1387108713388443,
0.07832501828670502,
0.07820228487253189,
0.26093581318855286,
-0.5450631380081177,
-0.19563916325569153,
0.22052206099033356,
-0.6686999201774597,
-0.06094836816191673,
-0.15856198966503143,
-0.10154420137405396,
0.06299804896116257,
0.07466070353984833,
0.18354307115077972,
0.38511160016059875,
0.34363365173339844,
-0.22935199737548828,
-0.32308080792427063,
0.2078561633825302,
0.37395697832107544,
0.21444731950759888,
-0.2404995858669281,
-0.1148279532790184,
-0.40178003907203674,
-0.5060266852378845,
0.295780748128891,
-0.23265476524829865,
0.24364398419857025,
0.43692851066589355,
0.7117006778717041,
1.2239832878112793,
0.265024870634079,
-0.6375263333320618,
0.521091103553772,
0.019871054217219353,
0.04285711050033569,
0.027773462235927582,
0.07601074874401093,
-0.035763975232839584,
0.9676324725151062,
0.2098621428012848,
0.22122980654239655,
0.37847840785980225,
-0.7437010407447815,
-0.27375805377960205,
-0.002556934952735901,
-0.4499078691005707,
-0.3614155352115631,
0.21907712519168854,
0.5876537561416626,
-0.30080410838127136,
0.5640977621078491,
-0.4175247251987457,
-0.5376310348510742,
0.9914311170578003,
0.06566520780324936,
1.266825556755066,
-0.36532536149024963,
0.43847382068634033,
0.2626574635505676,
0.26511141657829285,
0.22303366661071777,
0.13948871195316315,
0.07087574154138565,
-0.6218728423118591,
-0.1287466138601303,
-0.6975738406181335,
-0.6523585915565491,
-0.2879471778869629,
-0.6534156203269958,
0.028956133872270584,
-0.14175944030284882,
0.06772821396589279,
0.12230759114027023,
-0.1496555209159851,
-0.1167856752872467,
0.02433869242668152,
0.37069573998451233,
0.11378704756498337,
-0.7088268399238586,
0.39599600434303284,
0.3560687303543091,
-0.5734903812408447,
-0.6957827806472778,
0.2584804892539978,
0.29123812913894653,
0.04637380316853523,
0.5372777581214905,
0.4679070711135864,
-0.19093619287014008,
-0.30993664264678955,
-0.34567591547966003,
-0.31159672141075134,
0.7404812574386597,
0.3186718225479126,
-0.8193621635437012,
-0.34560486674308777,
0.2334873527288437,
0.8368551731109619,
-0.7191431522369385,
0.8918993473052979,
0.24165497720241547,
0.36554229259490967,
0.24342934787273407,
-0.6150731444358826,
-0.4990875720977783,
-0.40878891944885254,
-0.0046698711812496185,
0.1789509654045105,
-0.5141778588294983,
0.776709258556366,
-0.12208554148674011,
-0.661737859249115,
0.3615669310092926,
0.5351133346557617,
0.056367117911577225,
0.5893869400024414,
0.2563844323158264,
-0.043308075517416,
1.0304181575775146,
-0.35205239057540894,
1.2748363018035889,
-0.3461149036884308,
0.4196070730686188,
0.5182205438613892,
-0.5546981692314148,
0.4933941066265106,
0.005045935977250338,
-0.6038388013839722,
1.0264546871185303,
0.8277252912521362,
0.3649110794067383,
0.30543145537376404,
0.4322640895843506,
-0.4664972424507141,
-0.03682127222418785,
0.20570701360702515,
-0.24543114006519318,
0.16050435602664948,
0.21849793195724487,
-0.18829400837421417,
0.1864662766456604,
0.30383098125457764,
-0.08046887814998627,
0.0820297971367836,
-0.337089866399765,
0.7679863572120667,
0.15253181755542755,
-0.452149361371994,
0.40668776631355286,
-0.31140780448913574,
0.15949450433254242,
-0.8475982546806335,
-0.10621565580368042,
-0.36506175994873047,
-0.08541744202375412,
-0.16287465393543243,
-0.7162518501281738,
0.0517885759472847,
0.06546256691217422,
-0.4793577194213867,
-0.16970348358154297,
0.4279063940048218,
-0.5247541666030884,
-0.27313756942749023,
0.2669607102870941,
-0.02172037400305271,
0.5993265509605408,
-0.21818949282169342,
-0.519372284412384,
0.3975946009159088,
0.2643149495124817,
-0.5816815495491028,
0.07131833583116531,
0.9877670407295227,
0.4721769690513611,
0.21072916686534882,
-0.04608932510018349,
-0.2327994406223297,
-0.18801544606685638,
0.11313354969024658,
0.25370079278945923,
-1.0636200904846191,
-0.7301027774810791,
-0.7115702033042908,
0.9300397038459778,
0.08367870002985,
-0.6621135473251343,
0.370388001203537,
-0.007344123441725969,
-0.24307586252689362,
-0.13646875321865082,
0.8627499938011169,
0.04024520143866539,
0.3651775121688843,
-0.565349280834198,
0.6401576995849609,
-0.45486903190612793,
0.25350221991539,
-0.6129580736160278,
-0.8405025005340576,
0.3175588548183441,
0.7837886810302734,
0.10449488461017609,
0.008522724732756615,
1.1261285543441772,
0.45133623480796814,
0.47981399297714233,
0.5900014638900757,
0.349127858877182,
0.3710462152957916,
-0.1453188955783844,
0.6975356936454773,
1.1605613231658936,
-0.40541353821754456,
-0.16894559562206268,
0.5731683373451233,
-0.21356236934661865,
-0.09502677619457245,
-0.7168722152709961,
-0.7581658959388733,
-0.723945140838623,
-0.4140855073928833,
-0.44231030344963074,
0.2124907672405243,
0.496219664812088,
0.2479000985622406,
-0.6502084732055664,
-0.45305463671684265,
0.015875378623604774,
0.3623477816581726,
-0.30620595812797546,
-0.2619284391403198,
0.06418637931346893,
-0.3389167785644531,
-0.9878802299499512,
0.2883301079273224,
0.44749191403388977,
-0.09216932952404022,
-0.2911277711391449,
-0.16010455787181854,
0.09974641352891922,
0.8334984183311462,
0.13404197990894318,
0.22276057302951813,
-0.3305213451385498,
-0.06381511688232422,
-0.355270117521286,
-0.3754037618637085,
0.3937101662158966,
1.0142946243286133,
-0.4194711148738861,
0.5631034970283508,
0.583884596824646,
0.38453951478004456,
0.5668519735336304,
-0.3095357418060303,
0.7834985256195068,
-0.7395712733268738,
-0.04424884915351868,
0.3220882713794708,
0.24853432178497314,
0.08227919787168503,
-0.8158677816390991,
0.23117278516292572,
0.40610283613204956,
-0.8616116642951965,
-0.5806078910827637,
0.44420742988586426,
-1.3667371273040771,
-0.4012342095375061,
0.9284650087356567,
-0.4096500277519226,
-0.27863696217536926,
0.1061333492398262,
-0.417264848947525,
-0.014251293614506721,
-0.42980700731277466,
0.1204783171415329,
1.222525954246521,
-0.5493595004081726,
-0.18705205619335175,
-0.21200478076934814,
0.5564109086990356,
0.3254640996456146,
-0.9809502363204956,
0.35620278120040894,
0.7669041156768799,
-0.3661515712738037,
0.3572114408016205,
0.3512425422668457,
-0.010313545353710651,
-0.26871392130851746,
0.2848845422267914,
0.23789718747138977,
0.642615795135498,
-0.47991281747817993,
-0.43373411893844604,
0.4055785834789276,
-0.4200001358985901,
0.09322052448987961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02472v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02472v6
|
OffensiveLang: A Community Based Implicit Offensive Language Dataset
| 2024-03-04T20:34:58 | 2024-06-17T18:23:06 |
Amit Das, Mostafa Rahgouy, Dongji Feng, Zheng Zhang, Tathagata Bhattacharya, Nilanjana Raychawdhary, Fatemeh Jamshidi, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha, Mary Sandage, Lauramarie Pope, Gerry Dozier, Cheryl Seals
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The widespread presence of hateful languages on social media has resulted in
adverse effects on societal well-being. As a result, addressing this issue with
high priority has become very important. Hate speech or offensive languages
exist in both explicit and implicit forms, with the latter being more
challenging to detect. Current research in this domain encounters several
challenges. Firstly, the existing datasets primarily rely on the collection of
texts containing explicit offensive keywords, making it challenging to capture
implicitly offensive contents that are devoid of these keywords. Secondly,
common methodologies tend to focus solely on textual analysis, neglecting the
valuable insights that community information can provide. In this research
paper, we introduce a novel dataset OffensiveLang, a community based implicit
offensive language dataset generated by ChatGPT 3.5 containing data for 38
different target groups. Despite limitations in generating offensive texts
using ChatGPT due to ethical constraints, we present a prompt-based approach
that effectively generates implicit offensive languages. To ensure data
quality, we evaluate the dataset with human. Additionally, we employ a
prompt-based zero-shot method with ChatGPT and compare the detection results
between human annotation and ChatGPT annotation. We utilize existing
state-of-the-art models to see how effective they are in detecting such
languages. The dataset is available here:
https://github.com/AmitDasRup123/OffensiveLang
|
[
-0.14665056765079498,
-1.0054669380187988,
-0.03564169257879257,
0.24628573656082153,
-0.154798224568367,
0.23144134879112244,
-0.26253607869148254,
-0.5432612895965576,
-0.12766651809215546,
0.3708266019821167,
-0.34177544713020325,
-0.6190170645713806,
-0.8089668154716492,
0.3391929566860199,
-0.5546590685844421,
1.1113415956497192,
0.0650569275021553,
-0.18143577873706818,
0.5519586801528931,
-0.6234424710273743,
-0.24371950328350067,
-0.4271266758441925,
-1.0321518182754517,
0.23215655982494354,
0.4098740518093109,
0.32708874344825745,
0.6136897802352905,
0.41858944296836853,
0.309889554977417,
0.3451664447784424,
-0.06055472418665886,
0.08901511877775192,
-0.7327209711074829,
0.35688260197639465,
0.037856101989746094,
-0.04428417608141899,
-0.2484496831893921,
-0.3947604298591614,
0.280648797750473,
0.032360173761844635,
0.01896202377974987,
0.060030799359083176,
-0.11464907974004745,
0.4072863757610321,
-0.7023467421531677,
0.08921600878238678,
-0.7793333530426025,
0.010327954776585102,
-0.48405471444129944,
0.269102543592453,
-0.1901886910200119,
-0.6537894010543823,
-0.023893726989626884,
-0.525763750076294,
0.24698452651500702,
-0.11874701827764511,
0.2065459042787552,
-0.0005440233508124948,
-0.19896702468395233,
-0.7920985817909241,
-0.4602186679840088,
0.5681202411651611,
-0.7684043049812317,
0.17671401798725128,
0.30925196409225464,
0.2848380208015442,
-0.010209678672254086,
-0.26450514793395996,
-0.7656599283218384,
-0.008557163178920746,
-0.12045113742351532,
-0.000533442769665271,
-0.6259187459945679,
-0.11101926118135452,
0.09812100231647491,
0.03611041232943535,
-0.7547903060913086,
0.13693636655807495,
-0.31283068656921387,
-0.12960907816886902,
0.6058163642883301,
0.007332909852266312,
0.6469166874885559,
-0.41975679993629456,
-0.21952059864997864,
0.3226079046726227,
-0.6093368530273438,
-0.25413087010383606,
0.6666681170463562,
0.655886709690094,
-0.15200303494930267,
0.3502357006072998,
-0.303979754447937,
0.340716153383255,
-0.012756616808474064,
0.19987046718597412,
0.3777642846107483,
0.2695101797580719,
0.09294711798429489,
0.20821677148342133,
1.0275300741195679,
0.3469153046607971,
0.7904343605041504,
-0.036606963723897934,
-0.334176629781723,
0.3461672067642212,
0.03537238761782646,
-0.5407559871673584,
-0.16143916547298431,
0.2473931759595871,
-0.09349478036165237,
-0.5940629839897156,
-0.6077694892883301,
-0.9601359963417053,
-0.9028414487838745,
0.14620737731456757,
-0.23016683757305145,
-0.5619702935218811,
-0.593313992023468,
-0.3199498653411865,
-0.09188353270292282,
0.22770926356315613,
0.24107353389263153,
-0.8678538799285889,
0.4137206971645355,
0.7402862310409546,
0.7746098041534424,
-0.20620186626911163,
0.10507532954216003,
-0.4118959605693817,
0.016207421198487282,
-0.17826858162879944,
0.6462613344192505,
-0.772330641746521,
-0.2519473731517792,
0.3735915720462799,
-0.06493843346834183,
0.3028177320957184,
-0.5393867492675781,
0.8891928791999817,
-0.5291102528572083,
0.06228962168097496,
-0.18581907451152802,
-0.23016437888145447,
-0.055296722799539566,
0.37563106417655945,
-0.4432262182235718,
1.1960172653198242,
0.06350618600845337,
-0.8420706987380981,
0.15767571330070496,
-0.7361832857131958,
-0.521928608417511,
0.4364505708217621,
-0.31649911403656006,
-0.4129655361175537,
-0.08758564293384552,
0.3292256295681,
0.27544257044792175,
-0.07245885580778122,
0.2907903492450714,
-0.478703111410141,
-0.1750982105731964,
0.22510187327861786,
-0.6142919659614563,
0.9262598156929016,
0.5012125968933105,
-0.6500243544578552,
-0.1259586215019226,
-0.4785066545009613,
-0.30497410893440247,
0.3475620150566101,
-0.052215658128261566,
-0.5305859446525574,
0.14606766402721405,
0.2666340172290802,
0.2159584015607834,
-0.03899483010172844,
-0.8881611824035645,
-0.12472011893987656,
-0.39334121346473694,
0.2455611526966095,
1.0014299154281616,
-0.18624642491340637,
0.11803727596998215,
0.00372391939163208,
0.5935336947441101,
-0.05712403729557991,
0.19831570982933044,
0.03289804607629776,
-0.7279239296913147,
-0.47670114040374756,
0.009214657358825207,
-0.27019011974334717,
0.7316021919250488,
-0.860359787940979,
0.056843481957912445,
-0.1715521514415741,
-0.3327952027320862,
-0.4240674078464508,
0.06148025393486023,
0.6497737765312195,
0.48516806960105896,
0.2706441283226013,
-0.010540235787630081,
-0.6701045632362366,
-0.9058899879455566,
-0.26525381207466125,
-0.6381317973136902,
0.07828716188669205,
0.5136743783950806,
0.21090452373027802,
0.17065979540348053,
0.9265286326408386,
-0.4600456655025482,
-0.1394394040107727,
-0.2822524607181549,
0.4318926930427551,
-0.029144827276468277,
0.35892626643180847,
0.6737647652626038,
-0.8562839031219482,
-0.8460210561752319,
0.08020438998937607,
-0.7685015797615051,
-0.6370607614517212,
0.3880833685398102,
-0.006575952284038067,
0.35450422763824463,
0.1493569165468216,
-0.11745232343673706,
0.23198966681957245,
0.5138341784477234,
-0.33509597182273865,
0.40923482179641724,
0.40474429726600647,
0.5625223517417908,
-0.6939399838447571,
0.07596474885940552,
0.05871162191033363,
-0.20646455883979797,
-0.8984031677246094,
0.2034951001405716,
-0.14157941937446594,
-0.28376272320747375,
-0.7374368906021118,
0.7145858407020569,
-0.20670180022716522,
0.3289601802825928,
-0.24559251964092255,
0.11713125556707382,
-0.5030808448791504,
0.579527735710144,
0.07458972185850143,
0.47711601853370667,
0.31678715348243713,
0.03714563325047493,
0.686551570892334,
0.2810943126678467,
-0.017677580937743187,
0.5003404021263123,
-0.5882852673530579,
0.25033241510391235,
-0.2907818555831909,
0.06577432155609131,
-1.0330026149749756,
-0.04387873038649559,
0.9669348001480103,
-0.5784862637519836,
-0.00021414380171336234,
-0.6097438931465149,
-0.39370831847190857,
-0.1566152274608612,
-0.10108540207147598,
0.5853568315505981,
0.5230079293251038,
-0.30932122468948364,
0.2395785003900528,
0.5155726075172424,
-0.4114227890968323,
-0.9240313172340393,
-0.48719099164009094,
0.029388656839728355,
-0.5221728682518005,
-0.5579929947853088,
-0.3316791355609894,
0.03479636088013649,
-0.3833014667034149,
-0.14463017880916595,
0.16700300574302673,
-0.37143024802207947,
-0.05359134078025818,
0.24889303743839264,
-0.04040755704045296,
-0.20291166007518768,
0.015119963325560093,
-0.014897908084094524,
0.15739093720912933,
0.17127200961112976,
-0.14983877539634705,
0.3824349343776703,
-0.34871187806129456,
-0.19860343635082245,
0.04201871529221535,
0.5288228988647461,
0.3681859076023102,
-0.1013432964682579,
0.417542427778244,
0.567852795124054,
-0.2738337516784668,
-0.16451410949230194,
-0.531671941280365,
0.2467462420463562,
-0.46499451994895935,
0.5067671537399292,
0.09397412091493607,
-0.9103018045425415,
0.6187758445739746,
0.2318127602338791,
0.18910172581672668,
0.0731988176703453,
0.49911242723464966,
0.14267568290233612,
0.7294845581054688,
0.12049669027328491,
-0.42174234986305237,
0.3428070545196533,
0.3000378906726837,
0.039748650044202805,
-0.3593781590461731,
-0.00812445767223835,
-0.6730951070785522,
-0.04317536577582359,
-0.5423648953437805,
-0.5083778500556946,
0.13045640289783478,
-0.2860274016857147,
-0.26628074049949646,
0.3283032476902008,
-0.4011838436126709,
0.4824809432029724,
-0.15950289368629456,
0.11914970725774765,
0.22912411391735077,
0.09279946982860565,
0.16341987252235413,
-0.17283813655376434,
-0.4677090346813202,
-0.39660972356796265,
1.0279468297958374,
0.2695225477218628,
0.44545745849609375,
0.5593826770782471,
0.2578153610229492,
0.7464890480041504,
0.5481296181678772,
-0.6331003308296204,
0.46957287192344666,
-0.40335771441459656,
-0.9913780689239502,
-0.3013109266757965,
-0.4671057164669037,
-0.8119280934333801,
0.0973544493317604,
-0.018380019813776016,
-0.6552069187164307,
0.06925934553146362,
0.25056028366088867,
-0.1579260677099228,
0.4120071232318878,
-0.6431005597114563,
0.7097856402397156,
-0.3492013216018677,
-0.6421555876731873,
0.23760750889778137,
-0.4941176772117615,
0.41899195313453674,
-0.23487986624240875,
0.680995523929596,
-0.5128175616264343,
-0.11943954229354858,
0.521979808807373,
-0.13315674662590027,
1.1624120473861694,
-0.43905529379844666,
-0.22571340203285217,
0.3287806808948517,
0.1058453768491745,
0.5327549576759338,
-0.054664142429828644,
-0.3206983804702759,
0.3308120667934418,
-0.6407646536827087,
-0.43350449204444885,
-0.4196860194206238,
0.6358256340026855,
-0.45884016156196594,
-0.32492709159851074,
-0.22984065115451813,
-0.3066560924053192,
-0.0782037302851677,
0.27499476075172424,
0.17030425369739532,
0.594653308391571,
-0.6181642413139343,
-0.28475818037986755,
0.7575678825378418,
-0.6825860142707825,
0.34773245453834534,
0.7441114187240601,
-0.291807621717453,
-0.043587952852249146,
1.10567045211792,
-0.0799793228507042,
0.26901769638061523,
0.11199111491441727,
0.011616040021181107,
-0.2868400514125824,
-0.5398799180984497,
-0.7133875489234924,
-0.2154098004102707,
-0.6192412972450256,
-0.025363251566886902,
-0.7913333773612976,
0.002721827244386077,
-0.6462223529815674,
-0.27623066306114197,
-0.38747620582580566,
-0.2400432676076889,
0.1893031746149063,
0.12013853341341019,
0.495404988527298,
0.8742575645446777,
-0.09946157783269882,
0.44585558772087097,
-0.48939248919487,
0.4054838716983795,
0.06984303146600723,
0.4248279631137848,
-0.10393955558538437,
-0.5235151052474976,
0.1786763221025467,
0.057598013430833817,
-0.07544832676649094,
-1.017176866531372,
0.6044620871543884,
0.12661294639110565,
0.5025145411491394,
0.4290608763694763,
0.4214446544647217,
0.3777541220188141,
-0.5442050099372864,
0.4355887472629547,
0.03914424777030945,
-0.562501072883606,
0.5427035689353943,
-0.7936620116233826,
0.22251620888710022,
0.4574175477027893,
0.6950527429580688,
-1.019945502281189,
-0.8877342343330383,
-0.5903013348579407,
-0.9108420014381409,
0.7210121154785156,
0.5987445712089539,
0.37306317687034607,
-0.471708744764328,
0.022163497284054756,
0.15699158608913422,
0.08357198536396027,
-0.7245981097221375,
-0.6003352999687195,
-0.21940241754055023,
-0.25853025913238525,
0.27425867319107056,
-0.17866230010986328,
0.0007461403729394078,
0.008837814442813396,
0.6042720675468445,
-0.09995708614587784,
0.18635891377925873,
-0.16214948892593384,
-0.20862527191638947,
0.0006224319222383201,
0.3686368763446808,
0.255192369222641,
0.296825647354126,
-0.14076288044452667,
-0.015287170186638832,
0.17439135909080505,
-0.5273469090461731,
0.21673521399497986,
0.07826513797044754,
-0.3123234212398529,
0.19919641315937042,
0.2891824245452881,
0.6037173271179199,
0.27332979440689087,
-0.7470593452453613,
0.8275780081748962,
-0.225068137049675,
0.2041550874710083,
-0.5380165576934814,
-0.10613074898719788,
-0.1296815425157547,
0.042321354150772095,
0.35967451333999634,
0.13829459249973297,
0.3803379535675049,
-0.13576169312000275,
0.31347694993019104,
0.2321544736623764,
-0.6803613901138306,
-0.1899394541978836,
0.4795786142349243,
0.6079506278038025,
-0.26761916279792786,
0.7741345763206482,
-0.23425549268722534,
-0.7189972400665283,
0.6390047669410706,
0.375576913356781,
0.9021444916725159,
-0.33115333318710327,
0.4553263187408447,
0.5752788186073303,
0.5027164220809937,
0.5096273422241211,
-0.03756313398480415,
-0.027181405574083328,
-0.9038275480270386,
-0.166097953915596,
-0.6639659404754639,
-0.06293127685785294,
0.3008115589618683,
-0.3166937530040741,
0.26876136660575867,
-0.6665714383125305,
0.27650392055511475,
-0.11968966573476791,
-0.3116376996040344,
-0.30404889583587646,
0.0049117631278932095,
0.5873937606811523,
0.7108066082000732,
-1.1890026330947876,
0.6461495757102966,
0.42944756150245667,
-0.19817356765270233,
-0.40888726711273193,
-0.20154905319213867,
0.5621422529220581,
-1.0928477048873901,
0.5095019340515137,
0.053271181881427765,
0.05921464040875435,
0.01012894045561552,
-0.6904337406158447,
-0.3442452549934387,
0.27654099464416504,
0.20268936455249786,
-0.26254647970199585,
0.29832085967063904,
0.4056617319583893,
0.5703588724136353,
-0.13351309299468994,
0.4786730706691742,
0.5659050941467285,
0.3402303159236908,
0.1824546605348587,
-0.4112776815891266,
0.24916209280490875,
-0.603749692440033,
-0.3155585527420044,
0.3119805157184601,
-0.5006924867630005,
0.5128071904182434,
0.1932012140750885,
-0.4179975092411041,
-0.15569636225700378,
0.5089754462242126,
0.28604206442832947,
0.12711191177368164,
0.4987308979034424,
0.3175736367702484,
0.5361687541007996,
0.03570980206131935,
0.760454535484314,
0.11396756768226624,
0.23797112703323364,
1.1928271055221558,
-0.08306732773780823,
0.5153384208679199,
0.009728598408401012,
-0.13813823461532593,
0.27945518493652344,
0.33199530839920044,
0.0535658597946167,
0.19944551587104797,
0.31362658739089966,
-0.6722108721733093,
0.013746204786002636,
-0.2631566822528839,
-0.37319377064704895,
0.4927268922328949,
0.5557027459144592,
-0.2914706766605377,
-0.535901665687561,
-0.10698584467172623,
0.34613776206970215,
0.14879751205444336,
-0.2062568962574005,
0.7831530570983887,
-0.23322069644927979,
-0.2514536380767822,
0.5600523352622986,
-0.033265694975852966,
1.0097301006317139,
-0.6855195760726929,
-0.05126549303531647,
-0.5252801775932312,
-0.15007492899894714,
-0.12742261588573456,
-0.7578921914100647,
0.42308324575424194,
0.5835290551185608,
0.11090459674596786,
-0.13627935945987701,
0.75703364610672,
-0.4131547510623932,
-0.3719416856765747,
0.33701959252357483,
0.15556327998638153,
0.37573689222335815,
-0.14185912907123566,
-0.9889096617698669,
0.2165389508008957,
0.07212234288454056,
-0.013651561923325062,
0.0835874080657959,
0.7305285930633545,
-0.2423297017812729,
0.5259495973587036,
0.5267059206962585,
0.12639009952545166,
0.193330779671669,
-0.10457048565149307,
0.8097735047340393,
-0.34321829676628113,
-0.29261836409568787,
-0.9014309048652649,
0.397409051656723,
-0.2554227113723755,
-0.5125520825386047,
0.6399206519126892,
0.5766468048095703,
0.751496434211731,
0.15768758952617645,
1.2501534223556519,
-0.6122398972511292,
0.6219062805175781,
-0.10343095660209656,
0.8844585418701172,
-0.29540562629699707,
0.25338780879974365,
-0.7232881188392639,
-0.41500258445739746,
-0.28669649362564087,
0.2876945436000824,
-0.4086064398288727,
-0.06043402850627899,
0.23115868866443634,
0.9184065461158752,
-0.09674076735973358,
0.3112927973270416,
0.31905290484428406,
0.4944705367088318,
0.4023912847042084,
0.6481164693832397,
0.9565316438674927,
-0.3837585151195526,
0.8043926358222961,
-0.1755378693342209,
-0.412177711725235,
-0.0947117805480957,
-0.8435707092285156,
-0.7026235461235046,
-0.3841267228126526,
-0.22736185789108276,
-0.18261082470417023,
0.529085636138916,
0.6810526847839355,
0.37015700340270996,
-1.1229711771011353,
-0.2451896220445633,
0.04911165311932564,
0.021756663918495178,
0.23996752500534058,
-0.21236512064933777,
0.06259644031524658,
-0.037182409316301346,
-0.97213214635849,
0.18025805056095123,
0.1015448346734047,
-0.12910951673984528,
-0.008099180646240711,
-0.19581803679466248,
-0.3555149734020233,
-0.18965213000774384,
0.6153860092163086,
0.6510725021362305,
-0.585987389087677,
-0.354153037071228,
-0.15318810939788818,
-0.2340070605278015,
-0.04737280309200287,
0.7468855977058411,
-0.6612194180488586,
0.47028040885925293,
0.35578736662864685,
0.7256081104278564,
0.041055988520383835,
0.07348261028528214,
0.7067893147468567,
-1.0394266843795776,
0.3225483000278473,
0.31612998247146606,
0.11190775781869888,
0.4897858500480652,
-0.5018104314804077,
0.5952032804489136,
0.34917280077934265,
-0.4227469563484192,
-0.43449854850769043,
0.15341144800186157,
-0.6912007331848145,
-0.3359759747982025,
1.3488636016845703,
-0.37277087569236755,
-0.22593428194522858,
-0.7456386685371399,
-0.3678845763206482,
0.37664470076560974,
-0.973759114742279,
0.7047368884086609,
0.49231287837028503,
0.053356949239969254,
-0.23258620500564575,
-0.5695604681968689,
0.6032775044441223,
0.27331605553627014,
-0.5719754695892334,
0.5301807522773743,
0.8518550992012024,
0.15532204508781433,
-0.16559076309204102,
0.8094227910041809,
-0.18633520603179932,
0.20865021646022797,
0.0013929024571552873,
0.07054721564054489,
-0.054026175290346146,
0.1181955561041832,
-0.2745590806007385,
0.31846341490745544,
-0.27856361865997314,
0.04542042687535286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02451v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02451v2
|
Views Are My Own, but Also Yours: Benchmarking Theory of Mind Using Common Ground
| 2024-03-04T20:07:17 | 2024-06-06T00:30:01 |
Adil Soubki, John Murzaku, Arash Yousefi Jordehi, Peter Zeng, Magdalena Markowska, Seyed Abolghasem Mirroshandel, Owen Rambow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Evaluating the theory of mind (ToM) capabilities of language models (LMs) has
recently received a great deal of attention. However, many existing benchmarks
rely on synthetic data, which risks misaligning the resulting experiments with
human behavior. We introduce the first ToM dataset based on naturally occurring
spoken dialogs, Common-ToM, and show that LMs struggle to demonstrate ToM. We
then show that integrating a simple, explicit representation of beliefs
improves LM performance on Common-ToM.
|
[
-0.8681790828704834,
-0.8096174001693726,
0.8932920694351196,
-0.16214770078659058,
-0.3689488172531128,
-0.08196570724248886,
-0.599208414554596,
-0.5253937840461731,
0.08705036342144012,
0.35155537724494934,
-0.4421199858188629,
-0.26965048909187317,
-0.4779672622680664,
-0.0813242718577385,
-0.10412450134754181,
0.48834097385406494,
0.19888997077941895,
0.40204572677612305,
-0.35849738121032715,
-0.6365468502044678,
-0.45753735303878784,
-0.8897681832313538,
-0.6799644827842712,
-0.8028604984283447,
0.29798170924186707,
0.1176978051662445,
0.7711802124977112,
0.3903711140155792,
0.5950115323066711,
0.24402715265750885,
-0.056868817657232285,
0.2898698151111603,
-0.4361366033554077,
0.14554160833358765,
-0.3606627583503723,
-0.6936490535736084,
-0.2849765121936798,
0.3518492877483368,
0.6464461088180542,
0.9549353718757629,
-0.21085213124752045,
-0.10242333263158798,
0.0717773362994194,
0.5733262896537781,
-0.46754834055900574,
0.14051498472690582,
-0.766049325466156,
-0.0023522120900452137,
-0.12013007700443268,
-0.3588733971118927,
-0.37682828307151794,
-0.5594446659088135,
0.4624174237251282,
-0.5369723439216614,
0.3203875422477722,
0.30169129371643066,
0.681448221206665,
0.26933732628822327,
-0.5998781323432922,
-0.23377558588981628,
-0.7099904417991638,
1.1445391178131104,
-0.5612526535987854,
0.4730863571166992,
0.4277951717376709,
0.6983649730682373,
-0.3514813780784607,
-0.42214205861091614,
-0.9410719275474548,
-0.23735688626766205,
-0.058534689247608185,
0.051611773669719696,
-0.10958146303892136,
0.32285425066947937,
0.4580579102039337,
0.7631720304489136,
-0.4548703730106354,
-0.4476379454135895,
-0.15529084205627441,
0.08112943917512894,
0.6971545815467834,
0.3239913284778595,
0.15365420281887054,
0.16594868898391724,
-0.28677383065223694,
-0.5458263754844666,
-0.5439007878303528,
-0.09010574966669083,
-0.12314034253358841,
0.4642620384693146,
0.08616504073143005,
0.34366095066070557,
-0.30230751633644104,
0.7698237299919128,
-0.07244671881198883,
0.13057971000671387,
0.27048259973526,
0.09175709635019302,
-0.5475737452507019,
-0.2492794692516327,
0.4938584268093109,
0.8110628128051758,
0.7433517575263977,
-0.16303898394107819,
-0.08324853330850601,
0.473760724067688,
0.3699733316898346,
-0.3858559727668762,
-0.18457213044166565,
0.16666056215763092,
-0.2914551794528961,
0.07816088944673538,
0.015238868072628975,
-0.8526895642280579,
-0.6287398934364319,
-0.5027929544448853,
0.410653293132782,
-0.5151829719543457,
-0.37512004375457764,
0.37991583347320557,
-0.24142330884933472,
0.04054807126522064,
0.3312166631221771,
-0.5482927560806274,
0.8767523765563965,
0.6983115077018738,
0.7446386814117432,
-0.14916394650936127,
-0.35154783725738525,
-0.20126470923423767,
0.09403692185878754,
-0.49254006147384644,
0.8436847925186157,
-0.42354288697242737,
-0.5096821784973145,
0.009480810724198818,
-0.16869409382343292,
0.002323665888980031,
-0.798341691493988,
0.40163278579711914,
-0.15880320966243744,
0.44485852122306824,
-0.8742591738700867,
-0.965213418006897,
-0.5078366994857788,
0.33700108528137207,
-0.5733227133750916,
1.039247989654541,
-0.16513200104236603,
-0.5407897233963013,
0.49165448546409607,
-0.8180248141288757,
-0.21918191015720367,
0.00422245217487216,
-0.6805506944656372,
0.20204585790634155,
0.35319983959198,
-0.04671693220734596,
0.5040116906166077,
-0.6269561648368835,
0.6531660556793213,
-0.5283676981925964,
-0.5633571743965149,
0.4090634882450104,
-0.36580947041511536,
0.7473354935646057,
0.5032328367233276,
-0.3324955701828003,
-0.36966636776924133,
-0.8512669205665588,
0.35364654660224915,
0.3546384572982788,
-0.1737227439880371,
-0.6764312982559204,
0.16083887219429016,
-0.14350923895835876,
-0.041931286454200745,
0.015811335295438766,
-0.271397203207016,
0.1990460753440857,
-0.2805319130420685,
0.025445854291319847,
0.5587917566299438,
0.06342488527297974,
0.14752764999866486,
-0.8735536932945251,
0.24604898691177368,
0.004144423175603151,
-0.4043464660644531,
0.010129260830581188,
-0.44755619764328003,
-0.8814144730567932,
-0.10655420273542404,
-0.12432190030813217,
0.24371662735939026,
-0.31983405351638794,
0.43508636951446533,
-0.2929061949253082,
-0.5188801288604736,
-0.43240392208099365,
0.047756582498550415,
0.544782280921936,
0.14477650821208954,
0.3842535614967346,
-0.5453790426254272,
-0.5337784290313721,
-1.0767160654067993,
-0.8058050870895386,
-0.2912234663963318,
-0.20330283045768738,
0.49600890278816223,
0.19624482095241547,
0.06503535807132721,
1.1195858716964722,
-0.6528567671775818,
0.1114688366651535,
-0.26375824213027954,
0.41064855456352234,
0.25975435972213745,
0.6200388073921204,
0.622164785861969,
-0.5337880253791809,
-0.15787602961063385,
-0.18577273190021515,
-0.8394026756286621,
0.0008705775835551322,
0.1481429487466812,
0.04422854632139206,
-0.10979396849870682,
0.1541374772787094,
-0.7478355765342712,
0.1677256077528,
0.4915967583656311,
-0.135395810008049,
-0.06280287355184555,
-0.08332997560501099,
0.3466196060180664,
-1.0918996334075928,
0.09925473481416702,
0.33202260732650757,
-0.3432949483394623,
-0.7463205456733704,
0.285238653421402,
-0.1645590215921402,
0.0505974180996418,
-0.30058565735816956,
0.664909839630127,
-0.32189473509788513,
-0.2630208730697632,
-0.21559444069862366,
0.2442900389432907,
-0.020092850551009178,
0.7526859045028687,
0.03068208508193493,
0.8677214980125427,
0.3973850607872009,
-0.9447908401489258,
0.2302914261817932,
0.006170519627630711,
-0.5637215375900269,
0.8241153955459595,
-0.5431174635887146,
0.6392479538917542,
-0.17796525359153748,
0.2830452620983124,
-0.9503182172775269,
-0.30563610792160034,
0.001659363741055131,
-0.2345573604106903,
-0.009372975677251816,
0.12315943092107773,
-0.5457229614257812,
-0.2462371587753296,
-0.06894907355308533,
0.29194796085357666,
0.6620959043502808,
-0.5211460590362549,
0.5372273325920105,
0.585112452507019,
0.3386094570159912,
0.08364076167345047,
-0.8408374786376953,
-0.018636047840118408,
-0.49357402324676514,
-0.355586439371109,
0.37103381752967834,
-0.42734622955322266,
-0.8429409861564636,
-0.3305957019329071,
-0.19223925471305847,
-0.38459837436676025,
0.18545189499855042,
0.1982773095369339,
-0.2708553373813629,
-0.20658980309963226,
0.4696453809738159,
-0.43770289421081543,
0.02829560451209545,
0.25780007243156433,
0.025630393996834755,
0.6281223893165588,
-0.43528056144714355,
-0.3470257520675659,
-0.3650650680065155,
0.20796974003314972,
0.6815928816795349,
0.2401932030916214,
0.4131719172000885,
-0.07022884488105774,
-0.6344175934791565,
-0.32892152667045593,
-0.6993647813796997,
-0.15538378059864044,
-0.47492480278015137,
0.26645326614379883,
-0.5206702351570129,
-0.5343912839889526,
0.2507804334163666,
-0.4656077027320862,
-0.03490876406431198,
0.1377687007188797,
0.3688608705997467,
-0.1309005469083786,
0.966298520565033,
0.5668237805366516,
-0.1523643583059311,
0.2530252933502197,
-0.024911152198910713,
0.15505065023899078,
-0.5624130964279175,
0.09995739161968231,
-0.5041120648384094,
-0.29416391253471375,
-0.4510546028614044,
-0.5672715306282043,
0.09081891179084778,
0.14707963168621063,
-0.2524542510509491,
0.32156264781951904,
-0.32919299602508545,
0.6145603060722351,
0.6596463918685913,
0.1347852349281311,
0.38537049293518066,
-0.1431639939546585,
-0.3324856162071228,
-0.2570737600326538,
-0.49950385093688965,
-0.8493004441261292,
1.219438076019287,
0.32451680302619934,
0.43193092942237854,
0.19440104067325592,
0.4441787898540497,
0.33891966938972473,
0.331052303314209,
-0.4357158839702606,
1.0507161617279053,
-0.06681430339813232,
-1.1257376670837402,
-0.02250553108751774,
-0.23135434091091156,
-0.5969801545143127,
0.40049251914024353,
-0.1475997269153595,
-0.831231951713562,
-0.03609217330813408,
0.1914723664522171,
-0.21602237224578857,
0.2186778038740158,
-0.7356506586074829,
0.5091544389724731,
-0.08869905024766922,
-0.15971654653549194,
-0.6491768956184387,
-0.26970547437667847,
0.3831981122493744,
-0.03512751683592796,
0.023867953568696976,
-0.2897622883319855,
0.34701961278915405,
0.9823101162910461,
-0.18358838558197021,
0.7470001578330994,
-0.3618105351924896,
-0.06516776233911514,
0.3669494390487671,
-0.008427259512245655,
0.2630362808704376,
-0.12467202544212341,
-0.19608980417251587,
0.09460235387086868,
0.056559789925813675,
-0.513192892074585,
-0.7907623052597046,
0.5323553681373596,
-0.7164322137832642,
-0.7541691064834595,
-0.5124791860580444,
-0.5321386456489563,
-0.8971572518348694,
0.18721692264080048,
-0.015267415903508663,
0.17241233587265015,
-0.6718431115150452,
0.4012793004512787,
0.5347226858139038,
0.007710963021963835,
0.21904660761356354,
0.6392520666122437,
-0.4431605041027069,
-0.39335915446281433,
0.477700799703598,
0.05602528527379036,
0.26018887758255005,
0.03169729560613632,
0.10827004164457321,
-0.12114468961954117,
-0.39326053857803345,
0.2226029336452484,
-0.10239343345165253,
-1.0181565284729004,
0.22342781722545624,
-0.5522301197052002,
-0.006337644532322884,
-0.026052379980683327,
-0.010393764823675156,
-0.5455565452575684,
-0.236300528049469,
0.34329697489738464,
-0.19778016209602356,
0.27384838461875916,
0.9359219670295715,
0.26680585741996765,
0.5283448696136475,
-0.5019854307174683,
0.34245312213897705,
0.5506502389907837,
0.6109637022018433,
-0.036482073366642,
-0.0682397112250328,
-0.20686624944210052,
0.4756694734096527,
-0.3310334086418152,
-0.6993487477302551,
0.13647475838661194,
0.022487737238407135,
0.8428264260292053,
0.3696182072162628,
-0.04898104816675186,
1.0940382480621338,
-0.1578170210123062,
0.7360407114028931,
0.10437469184398651,
-1.1793487071990967,
0.6276515126228333,
-0.3888767957687378,
0.07079587876796722,
0.8556967377662659,
0.3177776038646698,
-0.565605640411377,
-0.35069790482521057,
-0.7221301794052124,
-0.0769289955496788,
0.4398477077484131,
0.14900924265384674,
-0.07519400864839554,
-0.2911575436592102,
0.03313775360584259,
0.1465599536895752,
0.3539053797721863,
-0.7363429665565491,
-0.341257244348526,
0.11745443940162659,
-0.2701285779476166,
-0.5040843486785889,
-0.017123986035585403,
-0.45711758732795715,
-0.41838476061820984,
0.30063125491142273,
-0.2725430727005005,
0.3267880380153656,
0.3747130036354065,
-0.11918161064386368,
-0.3729090690612793,
0.09283391386270523,
0.605324387550354,
0.7468606233596802,
-0.5826965570449829,
0.3421385586261749,
0.46068477630615234,
-0.2172822207212448,
0.09309697896242142,
-0.25801074504852295,
0.15375111997127533,
0.1850508749485016,
0.3412921726703644,
0.6747618913650513,
0.3043416738510132,
-0.7675498127937317,
0.22079016268253326,
-0.10094495862722397,
-0.19433875381946564,
-0.30150261521339417,
0.4696079194545746,
0.07965170592069626,
0.32444676756858826,
0.48656630516052246,
0.0753718838095665,
-0.15914128720760345,
-0.8065011501312256,
0.26318684220314026,
0.5489792227745056,
-0.15991400182247162,
-0.40250810980796814,
0.4631868302822113,
0.33441510796546936,
-0.4878963828086853,
0.15415796637535095,
0.11900312453508377,
-0.43282753229141235,
0.5331895351409912,
0.43614548444747925,
1.0835741758346558,
0.011929250322282314,
-0.37439659237861633,
0.28820422291755676,
0.16100439429283142,
-0.3505108654499054,
0.48238685727119446,
-0.09690351784229279,
-1.1327706575393677,
-0.007811990100890398,
-0.23281140625476837,
-0.7058259844779968,
0.38972872495651245,
-0.8453021049499512,
0.22706252336502075,
-0.7902669906616211,
-0.43645763397216797,
-0.057032160460948944,
0.5357852578163147,
-0.9946876764297485,
0.6149917840957642,
0.3244028091430664,
0.8655381798744202,
-0.8295163512229919,
1.1166716814041138,
0.8426098823547363,
-0.18091952800750732,
-0.5799203515052795,
0.29799193143844604,
0.1773398518562317,
-0.904537558555603,
0.49219536781311035,
0.3260827362537384,
-0.23266255855560303,
0.03849821910262108,
-0.6389533281326294,
-0.7484945058822632,
1.256011962890625,
0.2896058261394501,
-0.6798408627510071,
0.2183193862438202,
0.12429983168840408,
0.7151864767074585,
-0.6851916313171387,
0.24735179543495178,
0.5108043551445007,
0.48107999563217163,
-0.33899426460266113,
-0.8285439610481262,
-0.009395248256623745,
-0.32437828183174133,
-0.05838877335190773,
-0.1030658632516861,
-0.8424409627914429,
0.9824948310852051,
0.35996297001838684,
-0.5602598786354065,
-0.05191497877240181,
0.49529537558555603,
0.5065831542015076,
0.6638861894607544,
0.6469222903251648,
0.7707544565200806,
1.1990662813186646,
0.003697896609082818,
1.0111372470855713,
-0.5932826995849609,
0.43757084012031555,
1.1948662996292114,
-0.7820733189582825,
0.749107301235199,
0.5666915774345398,
-0.6514801979064941,
0.2693297564983368,
0.4574275612831116,
0.12910081446170807,
0.5372648239135742,
0.3406488299369812,
-0.1669720858335495,
-0.2563251852989197,
-0.021621232852339745,
-0.5797795057296753,
0.3938273787498474,
0.2505049705505371,
-0.2242843508720398,
-0.06776738911867142,
-0.4187038838863373,
-0.20862571895122528,
0.4050815999507904,
0.011694378219544888,
0.6732363104820251,
0.1861896961927414,
-0.9633336067199707,
0.7462581396102905,
-0.26469549536705017,
0.6105805039405823,
-0.30833899974823,
-0.12798279523849487,
-0.4543779790401459,
0.18577368557453156,
0.42291176319122314,
-0.5467419624328613,
0.19832861423492432,
-0.1105106770992279,
-0.12144608795642853,
-0.2521456480026245,
0.5931357741355896,
-0.33347102999687195,
-0.07022663950920105,
0.5287354588508606,
0.7442151308059692,
0.33689022064208984,
0.10172300040721893,
-0.44739171862602234,
0.11249876767396927,
-0.11496798694133759,
-0.33790165185928345,
0.28179287910461426,
0.5179004669189453,
0.1712402105331421,
0.8785919547080994,
0.6580348610877991,
0.19529572129249573,
-0.14679403603076935,
0.008700789883732796,
0.7554657459259033,
-1.373136281967163,
-0.521946907043457,
-0.9032741785049438,
0.20816178619861603,
-0.29245904088020325,
-0.4721049964427948,
0.6505749225616455,
0.38629552721977234,
0.8717158436775208,
0.052911970764398575,
0.8667349815368652,
0.1811508685350418,
0.8075399994850159,
-0.5945652723312378,
0.6904141306877136,
-0.5947366952896118,
0.31754353642463684,
-0.2561715245246887,
-1.2017673254013062,
-0.06959567219018936,
0.7155351638793945,
-0.10596277564764023,
0.21451373398303986,
1.0484271049499512,
0.6446666717529297,
-0.03908857703208923,
0.44499772787094116,
0.5980494618415833,
0.15777209401130676,
0.27866578102111816,
0.7342708110809326,
0.9226400256156921,
-0.33191239833831787,
-0.0618537999689579,
-0.2433752417564392,
-0.022739989683032036,
-0.1683158129453659,
-0.886258602142334,
-1.161939263343811,
-0.579440712928772,
-0.19213013350963593,
-0.1487588733434677,
0.3343016803264618,
1.2595815658569336,
0.8421704173088074,
-0.750994861125946,
-0.4423697292804718,
-0.5558438301086426,
-0.2157110869884491,
-0.21920259296894073,
-0.21179480850696564,
-0.1050068587064743,
-0.23887550830841064,
-0.9016726613044739,
0.6669986844062805,
0.09748422354459763,
0.2690221667289734,
-0.38476091623306274,
-0.2979058623313904,
-0.1820816546678543,
0.557689368724823,
0.15771158039569855,
0.14349234104156494,
-0.9610580801963806,
-0.6368467211723328,
-0.3873038589954376,
-0.34789952635765076,
0.17378288507461548,
0.9875204563140869,
-0.9772570133209229,
0.41354238986968994,
0.23168906569480896,
0.6529598832130432,
0.18822349607944489,
0.1170189380645752,
1.168994426727295,
-0.5632598996162415,
0.31143271923065186,
0.2314143180847168,
0.5382422804832458,
0.2170960158109665,
0.014925133436918259,
0.7678605914115906,
0.41311973333358765,
-0.3671230375766754,
-1.0904664993286133,
0.1337675154209137,
-0.9363304376602173,
-0.25703704357147217,
0.779752254486084,
-0.11449301242828369,
-0.17674367129802704,
-0.11789077520370483,
-0.0376715250313282,
0.23036418855190277,
-0.2148517221212387,
0.9415467381477356,
1.259187936782837,
0.09369935095310211,
-0.030568553134799004,
-0.6778358221054077,
0.5709577798843384,
0.9925059676170349,
-0.6017457246780396,
0.1273217648267746,
0.33745718002319336,
0.17872503399848938,
0.27689316868782043,
0.9404240250587463,
0.36191436648368835,
0.01734049804508686,
0.1765846610069275,
0.0809367448091507,
0.24457642436027527,
-0.16889707744121552,
-0.47185200452804565,
0.01923597976565361,
0.20052412152290344,
-0.23342891037464142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02436v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02436v1
|
How does Architecture Influence the Base Capabilities of Pre-trained Language Models? A Case Study Based on FFN-Wider Transformer Models
| 2024-03-04T19:33:39 | 2024-03-04T19:33:39 |
Xin Lu, Yanyan Zhao, Bing Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models have been proven to possess strong base
capabilities, which not only excel in in-distribution language modeling but
also show powerful abilities in out-of-distribution language modeling, transfer
learning and few-shot learning. Unlike existing work focusing on the influence
of scale on base capabilities, our work examines the influence of architecture
on those. Specifically, our concern is: How does architecture influence the
base capabilities of pre-trained language models? In this work, we attempt to
explain and reverse the decline in base capabilities caused by the architecture
of FFN-Wider Transformers, seeking to provide some insights. Through analysis,
we found the contribution ratio of Multi-Head Attention (a combination
function) to pre-trained language modeling is a key factor affecting base
capabilities. FFN-Wider Transformers reduce the contribution ratio of this
combination function, leading to a decline in base capabilities. We confirmed
this by experiments and proposed Combination Enhancement Architecture (CEA) to
address the decline in base capabilities of such models. Significantly, we
extended our explanation and CEA to Mixture of Experts (MoE) architecture
Transformers, which also alleviated their decline in base capabilities to some
extent, proving our work can offer useful guidance for architecture analysis,
architecture improvement and architecture design.
|
[
-0.8120834827423096,
-0.5240738391876221,
0.3080354630947113,
0.2732275724411011,
0.07963947206735611,
-0.09802453219890594,
-0.19725875556468964,
-0.5028244256973267,
0.00023762656201142818,
0.640679657459259,
-0.12276680767536163,
0.12022918462753296,
-0.8028602004051208,
-0.16180068254470825,
-0.2677229046821594,
0.745491623878479,
0.11868520826101303,
0.14885170757770538,
-0.3293860852718353,
-0.2627091407775879,
-0.7807379961013794,
-0.528148889541626,
-0.2672492265701294,
-0.45175662636756897,
-0.030580764636397362,
0.27525871992111206,
0.8019996881484985,
0.5955628156661987,
0.6494532823562622,
0.42156344652175903,
-0.18928883969783783,
-0.5541512966156006,
-0.5296182632446289,
-0.3571878969669342,
-0.19815780222415924,
-0.6423667073249817,
-0.7758141160011292,
-0.3267236351966858,
0.8292385339736938,
0.9050049781799316,
0.08428610861301422,
0.15982528030872345,
0.37591734528541565,
0.7473587989807129,
-0.6514978408813477,
0.35731324553489685,
-0.558910608291626,
-0.13713301718235016,
-0.23729455471038818,
-0.06081308051943779,
-0.5029856562614441,
0.4247237741947174,
0.45180317759513855,
-0.11368220299482346,
0.16764599084854126,
-0.21320100128650665,
0.5387829542160034,
0.43601080775260925,
-0.365299791097641,
0.09370241314172745,
-1.1429755687713623,
0.8265634179115295,
-0.48268428444862366,
0.6334667205810547,
0.04211373254656792,
0.22570490837097168,
0.06214867904782295,
-0.40218469500541687,
-0.20916546881198883,
-0.3167468011379242,
-0.3035491406917572,
0.03096523880958557,
-0.35860079526901245,
0.01276196725666523,
0.2246468961238861,
0.5615938305854797,
-0.34177711606025696,
-0.005174076650291681,
-0.5475425124168396,
-0.11704985797405243,
0.10821431875228882,
-0.14916503429412842,
0.3328237533569336,
0.08044259995222092,
-0.1713159680366516,
-0.3913530111312866,
-0.9557604789733887,
0.12040615826845169,
0.2907026708126068,
0.12205404043197632,
-0.04520060122013092,
0.3359249532222748,
-0.001424166839569807,
0.4180131256580353,
0.16510385274887085,
0.02054845541715622,
0.4318193793296814,
-0.2659851014614105,
-0.3114621043205261,
-0.05647745728492737,
0.3654994070529938,
-0.28632840514183044,
0.38648998737335205,
-0.33808767795562744,
-0.13142839074134827,
-0.09974397718906403,
0.5679367184638977,
-0.7155892252922058,
-0.1439688354730606,
-0.10163166373968124,
-0.7573948502540588,
-0.004280542954802513,
0.05870027840137482,
-0.4785431921482086,
0.07643748074769974,
-0.28618693351745605,
0.5638092160224915,
-0.4606265127658844,
-0.8059585094451904,
0.03787419945001602,
-0.16283932328224182,
0.6442252397537231,
-0.15873079001903534,
-1.0223219394683838,
0.45739108324050903,
0.7025126218795776,
0.588155210018158,
-0.1440923810005188,
-0.376270055770874,
-0.11916381865739822,
-0.0329415537416935,
-0.21008098125457764,
0.6715304255485535,
-0.40996691584587097,
-0.6648430228233337,
-0.1740279346704483,
-0.1960909068584442,
-0.3087112605571747,
-0.7083785533905029,
0.24991333484649658,
-0.7529043555259705,
0.12125211209058762,
0.13325025141239166,
-0.1525246649980545,
-0.2081112265586853,
0.017318682745099068,
-0.8603429198265076,
0.4343411922454834,
0.30741581320762634,
-0.7822747826576233,
0.13825587928295135,
-0.75979083776474,
-0.7454256415367126,
0.1010514572262764,
-0.3478944003582001,
-0.2677902579307556,
0.430436909198761,
0.20769646763801575,
0.2654417157173157,
-0.09349030256271362,
0.022383015602827072,
-0.20224328339099884,
-0.29208484292030334,
0.04311896488070488,
-0.4137100875377655,
0.7809968590736389,
-0.04280804842710495,
-0.5189670920372009,
0.14798428118228912,
-0.8790216445922852,
-0.25342991948127747,
0.058533016592264175,
-0.23472021520137787,
-0.3835434019565582,
0.023584945127367973,
-0.20630347728729248,
0.33501625061035156,
0.19631589949131012,
-0.027713270857930183,
-0.25489455461502075,
-0.7323214411735535,
-0.041079699993133545,
0.5657477974891663,
-0.03550704941153526,
1.1657164096832275,
-0.245632603764534,
0.772765576839447,
0.11313805729150772,
0.1502555012702942,
-0.18974485993385315,
-0.5954675674438477,
-0.6652572751045227,
-0.1736195832490921,
0.11971969157457352,
0.5819190144538879,
-0.5334749817848206,
0.3610481023788452,
-0.7092750668525696,
-0.3547949194908142,
-0.44163191318511963,
0.24598029255867004,
0.49559450149536133,
0.4600391387939453,
0.34807291626930237,
-0.5710994601249695,
-0.585925281047821,
-1.2448010444641113,
0.1079450249671936,
-0.1802462637424469,
-0.053904805332422256,
0.29726535081863403,
0.274404376745224,
-0.36529457569122314,
1.0497180223464966,
-0.2378218173980713,
-0.27285441756248474,
-0.6166772842407227,
-0.09562652558088303,
0.31000781059265137,
0.4712965786457062,
1.0462088584899902,
-0.860921323299408,
-0.31151288747787476,
-0.008268865756690502,
-0.14030873775482178,
-0.10550529509782791,
0.027196353301405907,
-0.09148889034986496,
0.052700284868478775,
0.2338869869709015,
-0.8168550133705139,
0.3762350082397461,
0.6970131397247314,
0.08699388802051544,
0.5552893280982971,
-0.17577213048934937,
-0.0523972287774086,
-1.2341926097869873,
-0.03411282226443291,
-0.20748235285282135,
0.41989508271217346,
-0.7741395235061646,
0.13480083644390106,
0.013755282387137413,
0.035521045327186584,
-0.4444785714149475,
0.3811931908130646,
-0.3570157289505005,
-0.4468569755554199,
-0.44021257758140564,
-0.4940163493156433,
-0.028965461999177933,
0.5288214087486267,
0.21546272933483124,
0.8898311853408813,
0.8208656907081604,
-0.7135000228881836,
-0.1333426535129547,
0.2873230576515198,
-0.16209766268730164,
0.38952499628067017,
-0.5634832978248596,
-0.03718019649386406,
-0.1309591382741928,
0.15306279063224792,
-1.0447931289672852,
0.07751277089118958,
0.007260092534124851,
-0.33724546432495117,
0.34456866979599,
-0.08111396431922913,
-0.1862659901380539,
-0.24656035006046295,
-0.23901133239269257,
0.35645920038223267,
0.5143210291862488,
-0.41089969873428345,
1.1630842685699463,
0.21573419868946075,
0.05119151249527931,
-0.578009307384491,
-0.9412845969200134,
-0.10294963419437408,
-0.186886265873909,
-0.9535038471221924,
0.5942983031272888,
-0.21618051826953888,
-0.6003789305686951,
0.019007829949259758,
-0.08967611193656921,
-0.19604051113128662,
0.26265013217926025,
0.517744243144989,
0.19721835851669312,
-0.9779005646705627,
0.014909257180988789,
-0.11056213080883026,
-0.1685633808374405,
0.3260685205459595,
-0.20760603249073029,
0.7959279417991638,
-0.6442800760269165,
-0.2594608962535858,
-0.16185976564884186,
0.2552632689476013,
0.828885018825531,
-0.6872224807739258,
1.1495996713638306,
0.3621264100074768,
-0.00576668931171298,
-0.17293104529380798,
-0.48612180352211,
-0.17030936479568481,
-0.5417647361755371,
0.5657339692115784,
-0.5897664427757263,
-0.640034019947052,
0.7961185574531555,
-0.044078223407268524,
0.021815940737724304,
0.774266242980957,
0.7846853733062744,
0.18763351440429688,
0.7138933539390564,
0.8874510526657104,
-0.3420961797237396,
0.8571059703826904,
-0.4496195912361145,
0.2174789160490036,
-0.8151189088821411,
0.09325514733791351,
-0.4497600495815277,
-0.24814891815185547,
-0.5383386015892029,
-0.11094159632921219,
0.058967508375644684,
-0.06839524209499359,
-0.20398060977458954,
0.583150327205658,
-0.17568181455135345,
0.2793649733066559,
0.4440300166606903,
0.05788492411375046,
0.11753372102975845,
-0.061247311532497406,
0.13607962429523468,
0.3698272705078125,
-0.8028174042701721,
-0.3539919853210449,
1.1639761924743652,
0.6267661452293396,
0.5454042553901672,
0.13098059594631195,
0.5516135096549988,
0.008999085985124111,
0.4094665050506592,
-0.7316539883613586,
0.4391777515411377,
-0.06941019743680954,
-0.61045241355896,
-0.1762252151966095,
-0.41847488284111023,
-0.6222420334815979,
0.20632265508174896,
-0.06896109879016876,
-0.29882973432540894,
0.4133760333061218,
0.10538732260465622,
-0.4181969165802002,
0.1499774307012558,
-0.9860288500785828,
0.8710657954216003,
-0.3818484842777252,
0.03499171882867813,
-0.39885997772216797,
-0.493755042552948,
0.27502474188804626,
-0.178400918841362,
0.2573098838329315,
0.5663653016090393,
0.26461243629455566,
0.5025774836540222,
-0.06809239089488983,
0.7678894996643066,
0.035544950515031815,
-0.2680043876171112,
0.22305910289287567,
-0.06162133067846298,
0.2440028339624405,
-0.22890862822532654,
-0.14461927115917206,
0.28451472520828247,
-0.4848983585834503,
-0.3736465573310852,
-0.49745315313339233,
0.5379819869995117,
-1.103547215461731,
-0.8461028337478638,
0.3615568280220032,
-0.44557681679725647,
-0.5064725279808044,
0.18861711025238037,
0.370942085981369,
0.6118079423904419,
-0.32926636934280396,
0.7047626972198486,
0.7408933043479919,
0.06387460976839066,
0.5490128397941589,
0.3548790514469147,
0.04738360270857811,
-0.14591801166534424,
0.4619579613208771,
0.18245646357536316,
0.4770839214324951,
0.6905456781387329,
0.2404680848121643,
-0.03029690869152546,
-0.8919845819473267,
-0.3966086804866791,
-0.12232706695795059,
-0.9285587668418884,
0.14843787252902985,
-0.596736490726471,
-0.3479117453098297,
-0.7086226940155029,
-0.15316978096961975,
-0.5292572975158691,
-0.2471199333667755,
-0.23530057072639465,
-0.2488863319158554,
-0.04369654506444931,
0.6943924427032471,
0.22338451445102692,
0.9365959763526917,
-0.8097627758979797,
0.1878315508365631,
0.3522850275039673,
0.43743178248405457,
0.35894298553466797,
-0.738441526889801,
-0.4896179735660553,
-0.11442603170871735,
-0.057334452867507935,
-0.7378571629524231,
0.033848393708467484,
0.08212626725435257,
0.9242963194847107,
0.6977311968803406,
-0.40909814834594727,
0.36566162109375,
-0.5124712586402893,
0.48044613003730774,
-0.08718222379684448,
-0.7914744019508362,
0.08070967346429825,
-0.22199365496635437,
0.5439675450325012,
0.4899684488773346,
0.031445570290088654,
0.2419266700744629,
-0.35409510135650635,
-0.7745329141616821,
-0.6912312507629395,
0.7627337574958801,
0.1542704701423645,
0.5210514068603516,
0.2606487572193146,
0.13082604110240936,
-0.04182237759232521,
-0.02281031757593155,
-0.7557558417320251,
-0.3437570333480835,
-0.3592527508735657,
0.14061398804187775,
-0.05405360087752342,
-0.34066301584243774,
0.2687019109725952,
-0.22941158711910248,
0.712786078453064,
0.13529570400714874,
0.16761840879917145,
-0.36719030141830444,
-0.36500805616378784,
-0.1008807048201561,
0.49316588044166565,
0.6268824934959412,
0.8016886711120605,
0.012922077439725399,
-0.056440770626068115,
0.44572994112968445,
-0.41454803943634033,
-0.21545879542827606,
-0.08274596184492111,
0.13125881552696228,
-0.25319913029670715,
0.7209084630012512,
0.9890847206115723,
0.459675669670105,
-0.24070625007152557,
0.43306705355644226,
0.06149628758430481,
-0.10438046604394913,
-0.11682186275720596,
0.30261313915252686,
0.23175150156021118,
0.2747604548931122,
0.5711895227432251,
0.5829347372055054,
0.08449723571538925,
-0.49153730273246765,
0.4561282992362976,
0.5116882920265198,
-0.04929279908537865,
-0.4810657203197479,
0.23107163608074188,
0.16586309671401978,
-0.5515928268432617,
0.45155394077301025,
0.305049866437912,
-0.6261034607887268,
0.8409662842750549,
0.6240122318267822,
1.0049071311950684,
-0.5794805288314819,
0.005833348259329796,
-0.13694579899311066,
0.5881270170211792,
-0.10754482448101044,
-0.29898038506507874,
-0.34851792454719543,
-0.9814828634262085,
-0.620847761631012,
-0.5926149487495422,
-0.09103560447692871,
0.181878462433815,
-0.5070120692253113,
0.11086175590753555,
-0.3729180097579956,
-0.11086586117744446,
-0.2593826651573181,
-0.2541297674179077,
-0.8365170359611511,
0.17113018035888672,
0.4395798444747925,
0.7875813841819763,
-0.7776963710784912,
0.8814849257469177,
0.7568493485450745,
-0.3459829092025757,
-0.9580667614936829,
0.24332323670387268,
-0.481263130903244,
-0.6572046279907227,
0.8974776268005371,
0.19309228658676147,
-0.5128805637359619,
0.2152286022901535,
-0.10632828623056412,
-0.893771231174469,
0.8973314762115479,
0.3411468267440796,
-0.2606353759765625,
-0.1335151046514511,
0.5384098291397095,
0.9454018473625183,
-0.6329022645950317,
0.20797452330589294,
0.5773210525512695,
0.37870925664901733,
0.15739719569683075,
-1.0839647054672241,
-0.31982994079589844,
-0.19040130078792572,
0.1331457793712616,
0.23273739218711853,
-0.4135832190513611,
0.8557701110839844,
-0.04731924086809158,
-0.14726054668426514,
-0.261504203081131,
0.689459502696991,
-0.15664532780647278,
-0.07108969986438751,
0.6114532351493835,
0.5879995226860046,
-0.047559257596731186,
0.3201560378074646,
1.1301190853118896,
-0.6038322448730469,
0.11551301181316376,
0.8564425110816956,
-0.1547309011220932,
1.0379718542099,
0.47958505153656006,
-0.027655743062496185,
0.6314775347709656,
0.043626703321933746,
0.19649401307106018,
0.672221839427948,
-0.09201870113611221,
-0.06940026581287384,
-0.1309709995985031,
0.2113225907087326,
-0.5306889414787292,
0.820460855960846,
0.27076342701911926,
-0.6269059777259827,
-0.3609318137168884,
0.274371474981308,
-0.38992559909820557,
-0.16356180608272552,
-0.4992786645889282,
0.7056775689125061,
0.09680436551570892,
-0.481200248003006,
0.2675968408584595,
-0.0791015774011612,
0.6351410150527954,
-0.5998721122741699,
0.22823676466941833,
-0.10355622321367264,
0.5676450729370117,
-0.040640007704496384,
-0.48971158266067505,
0.6339284777641296,
-0.4103320240974426,
-0.3675228953361511,
-0.5187282562255859,
0.8726539015769958,
-0.10497353225946426,
-0.34845057129859924,
0.686938464641571,
0.85661381483078,
-0.3135603964328766,
-0.3457094728946686,
-0.45078757405281067,
0.003064848482608795,
-0.20850379765033722,
-0.5181638598442078,
0.4589923024177551,
0.25423961877822876,
-0.09322808682918549,
0.3691224157810211,
0.4329290986061096,
-0.06839629262685776,
0.12610767781734467,
-0.021853314712643623,
0.9255596995353699,
-0.15369614958763123,
-0.5471924543380737,
-1.0056824684143066,
0.36579906940460205,
0.21215571463108063,
0.031046072021126747,
0.7016608119010925,
0.48211291432380676,
0.8489683866500854,
-0.4844145178794861,
0.5563697218894958,
0.0017133136279881,
-0.04352964833378792,
-0.24152028560638428,
0.9043447375297546,
-0.24968566000461578,
0.39056578278541565,
-0.10207900404930115,
-1.2368080615997314,
-0.19971293210983276,
0.3129502534866333,
-0.757970929145813,
0.11122781783342361,
0.36734890937805176,
0.7653616070747375,
-0.24181340634822845,
-0.08501388877630234,
0.39613181352615356,
0.22304971516132355,
0.3608884811401367,
0.4223253130912781,
0.690784215927124,
-0.11322230100631714,
0.8053011298179626,
-0.354228675365448,
-0.2848193049430847,
-0.23188237845897675,
-0.5500744581222534,
-1.0297898054122925,
-0.589504599571228,
-0.04069552570581436,
0.0030943986494094133,
-0.3153456747531891,
0.5245875120162964,
0.7470222115516663,
-0.9462323188781738,
-0.1383131891489029,
-0.3008008301258087,
0.05267620086669922,
-0.17137163877487183,
-0.25550442934036255,
0.41070055961608887,
-0.2559639513492584,
-0.34636810421943665,
0.43621838092803955,
0.48549920320510864,
-0.013593793846666813,
-0.48600703477859497,
-0.06488553434610367,
0.020557869225740433,
0.201593279838562,
0.6589611172676086,
0.11754277348518372,
-0.32321619987487793,
-0.2383299618959427,
0.3022691011428833,
-0.19483429193496704,
0.4146644175052643,
0.9106138944625854,
-1.013337254524231,
0.09982328116893768,
0.6908051371574402,
1.0094927549362183,
-0.08310970664024353,
-0.04683004319667816,
0.7282987833023071,
-0.7643054127693176,
0.2513072192668915,
0.019300688058137894,
0.6246225833892822,
0.15520735085010529,
-0.4044671952724457,
0.07206610590219498,
0.06161355599761009,
-0.17634020745754242,
-0.26036274433135986,
0.2815524637699127,
-0.660682201385498,
-0.2965957522392273,
0.9882649183273315,
0.08630934357643127,
-0.35811847448349,
-0.10268020629882812,
-0.30392149090766907,
0.16173870861530304,
0.017495380714535713,
0.8295565843582153,
0.9130255579948425,
-0.20018760859966278,
-0.37871095538139343,
-0.28008124232292175,
0.23891882598400116,
0.588264524936676,
-0.7240742444992065,
-0.10114256292581558,
0.2764780521392822,
0.2368706315755844,
0.7165011167526245,
0.5144044160842896,
-0.08104201406240463,
0.29473745822906494,
-0.006710336543619633,
-0.12455417215824127,
-0.1531071811914444,
-0.5066004395484924,
-0.42709019780158997,
0.3874605596065521,
0.0535990372300148,
-0.22819340229034424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02419v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02419v2
|
Are More LLM Calls All You Need? Towards Scaling Laws of Compound Inference Systems
| 2024-03-04T19:12:48 | 2024-06-04T21:20:33 |
Lingjiao Chen, Jared Quincy Davis, Boris Hanin, Peter Bailis, Ion Stoica, Matei Zaharia, James Zou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SY, eess.SY
|
Many recent state-of-the-art results in language tasks were achieved using
compound systems that perform multiple Language Model (LM) calls and aggregate
their responses. However, there is little understanding of how the number of LM
calls - e.g., when asking the LM to answer each question multiple times and
taking a majority vote - affects such a compound system's performance. In this
paper, we initiate the study of scaling properties of compound inference
systems. We analyze, theoretically and empirically, how the number of LM calls
affects the performance of Vote and Filter-Vote, two of the simplest compound
system designs, which aggregate LM responses via majority voting, optionally
applying LM filters. We find, surprisingly, that across multiple language
tasks, the performance of both Vote and Filter-Vote can first increase but then
decrease as a function of the number of LM calls. Our theoretical results
suggest that this non-monotonicity is due to the diversity of query
difficulties within a task: more LM calls lead to higher performance on "easy"
queries, but lower performance on "hard" queries, and non-monotone behavior can
emerge when a task contains both types of queries. This insight then allows us
to compute, from a small number of samples, the number of LM calls that
maximizes system performance, and define an analytical scaling model for both
systems. Experiments show that our scaling model can accurately predict the
performance of Vote and Filter-Vote systems and thus find the optimal number of
LM calls to make.
|
[
-0.5916652083396912,
-0.8645254969596863,
0.7265365719795227,
0.6398305892944336,
0.05515739694237709,
0.09079381078481674,
-0.261222779750824,
-0.5622861981391907,
0.09507180005311966,
0.7505457401275635,
-0.483310729265213,
-0.05085965618491173,
-0.49558359384536743,
0.28647559881210327,
-0.42851462960243225,
0.8951401114463806,
0.3165317475795746,
0.30296507477760315,
-0.2875381410121918,
-0.4983642101287842,
-0.05334226042032242,
-0.39666420221328735,
-0.7278674840927124,
-0.47430434823036194,
0.8005460500717163,
0.512263834476471,
0.8000544905662537,
0.7032108306884766,
0.5196577906608582,
0.3437783420085907,
-0.28072574734687805,
0.06298241764307022,
-0.4794210195541382,
-0.014112675562500954,
0.08543580770492554,
-1.03450345993042,
-0.644947350025177,
-0.07268178462982178,
0.7467551827430725,
1.1381192207336426,
-0.10131054371595383,
0.0716177225112915,
0.1983090043067932,
0.637765109539032,
-0.5132390260696411,
0.025234341621398926,
-0.4194929003715515,
-0.2837011516094208,
-0.2199917584657669,
-0.05714160576462746,
-0.6239672303199768,
-0.25174680352211,
-0.0244059506803751,
-0.43830063939094543,
0.2788488566875458,
0.21866659820079803,
0.4279763996601105,
0.0477648563683033,
-0.7021011114120483,
-0.5211828351020813,
-0.5863531827926636,
1.2209197282791138,
-0.8463911414146423,
-0.005469188094139099,
-0.10841015726327896,
-0.019472453743219376,
-0.23278409242630005,
-0.4874926805496216,
-0.5214947462081909,
-0.44118431210517883,
-0.3148811459541321,
-0.16570603847503662,
0.09727132320404053,
0.4389877915382385,
0.14455868303775787,
0.5329474210739136,
-0.3597893714904785,
0.20111246407032013,
-0.3078940212726593,
0.02348669432103634,
0.5297273993492126,
0.3574899137020111,
0.26937803626060486,
0.10802415013313293,
-0.3423686921596527,
0.097311832010746,
-0.5994203090667725,
0.06211609020829201,
0.294077068567276,
0.7040777802467346,
0.1364550143480301,
0.584587574005127,
-0.25343945622444153,
0.8651227355003357,
0.23476079106330872,
-0.2508513629436493,
-0.09949129074811935,
-0.5145284533500671,
-0.1989392787218094,
-0.20357491075992584,
0.6225280165672302,
0.16999785602092743,
0.18330468237400055,
0.04705709591507912,
-0.17814435064792633,
-0.007219371851533651,
0.010971988551318645,
-1.0725854635238647,
-0.16220194101333618,
0.16064748167991638,
-0.2720526158809662,
-0.2319963425397873,
-0.029485128819942474,
-0.5593681931495667,
-0.4151175618171692,
-0.6538453102111816,
0.554463267326355,
-0.013194462284445763,
-0.40216708183288574,
0.09728498011827469,
0.005161940585821867,
0.014608146622776985,
0.347457617521286,
-0.8618854880332947,
1.03481125831604,
0.7520386576652527,
0.8986691236495972,
-0.3895646035671234,
-0.2625569701194763,
-0.6811676025390625,
-0.41832390427589417,
-0.4333242177963257,
0.7725141048431396,
-0.41791000962257385,
-0.5970664620399475,
-0.2891290485858917,
-0.09053901582956314,
-0.2224109172821045,
-0.9551963806152344,
0.22281233966350555,
-0.8647342920303345,
-0.23405277729034424,
-0.538609504699707,
-0.5647133588790894,
0.22268491983413696,
-0.13708840310573578,
-0.8251428008079529,
0.6865424513816833,
-0.32644444704055786,
-0.40007033944129944,
0.649234414100647,
-0.7248041033744812,
-0.6798807382583618,
-0.0030462555587291718,
0.10681913048028946,
-0.1961624175310135,
0.27340996265411377,
-0.014023836702108383,
0.03618622571229935,
-0.36708274483680725,
-0.1026609018445015,
-0.7555188536643982,
-0.20281527936458588,
0.29016512632369995,
-0.2972935438156128,
0.9065247774124146,
0.1762295961380005,
-0.1248881071805954,
0.274662047624588,
-0.44829097390174866,
0.25565305352211,
-0.4237118065357208,
-0.6335170269012451,
-0.15954670310020447,
0.18180911242961884,
-0.07409483194351196,
-0.1214422807097435,
0.0825645849108696,
-0.6331445574760437,
0.10378605872392654,
-0.16998562216758728,
0.25212332606315613,
0.8364648818969727,
0.09666391462087631,
0.8416967391967773,
-0.3098398447036743,
0.32698529958724976,
-0.07325723022222519,
0.02360767126083374,
0.04945351928472519,
-0.48503774404525757,
-0.9852864146232605,
-0.391602486371994,
0.13503600656986237,
0.590289831161499,
-0.29548531770706177,
-0.08746260404586792,
-0.2680758833885193,
-0.40053045749664307,
-0.016978615894913673,
0.3863259553909302,
0.18439726531505585,
0.12212945520877838,
0.18719032406806946,
-0.11924084275960922,
-0.24078840017318726,
-0.9818429350852966,
-0.4037802815437317,
-0.29873257875442505,
-0.1623734086751938,
0.4210255444049835,
0.6040306687355042,
0.2832484543323517,
1.0498971939086914,
-0.5204797387123108,
-0.0971522107720375,
-0.1484183818101883,
0.3850504755973816,
0.6705791354179382,
0.08429611474275589,
0.3404783010482788,
-0.7983410358428955,
-0.39588627219200134,
0.0505233108997345,
-0.4234844744205475,
-0.5609176754951477,
-0.020891938358545303,
-0.006975126918405294,
0.04369325563311577,
0.2622205913066864,
-0.43735772371292114,
0.04347344487905502,
0.5091603994369507,
-0.1380739063024521,
0.5354723930358887,
-0.3752695918083191,
0.07995960861444473,
-0.6624994277954102,
-0.373299777507782,
0.08675378561019897,
-0.18798713386058807,
-0.7164040803909302,
0.3417554199695587,
0.014355351217091084,
0.23962131142616272,
-0.33362361788749695,
0.48024314641952515,
-0.6429917812347412,
-0.020280390977859497,
-0.50513756275177,
-0.07909905910491943,
-0.1565592736005783,
0.46396344900131226,
-0.08878380805253983,
0.6626298427581787,
0.607811450958252,
-1.0520358085632324,
0.4472860097885132,
-0.48138830065727234,
-0.22779223322868347,
0.8388625979423523,
-0.6717207431793213,
0.09775755554437637,
0.21712443232536316,
0.253014475107193,
-1.3249611854553223,
-0.09479435533285141,
-0.3662579357624054,
-0.17301397025585175,
0.1406480073928833,
-0.1711062639951706,
-0.7869647145271301,
-0.222278892993927,
-0.2027161717414856,
0.3678346872329712,
0.04049215093255043,
-0.4940786361694336,
0.5743693113327026,
0.3820783197879791,
-0.22295311093330383,
-0.24432674050331116,
-0.5994325876235962,
-0.07263005524873734,
-0.14897769689559937,
-0.776922881603241,
0.01996227167546749,
-0.1702159345149994,
-0.6009436249732971,
-0.11935208737850189,
-0.23747561872005463,
-0.22770018875598907,
-0.012363688088953495,
0.37337392568588257,
0.17758573591709137,
-0.4209533631801605,
0.20003966987133026,
0.17217524349689484,
0.12395823001861572,
0.20643076300621033,
-0.2862567603588104,
0.44075798988342285,
-0.3909040093421936,
-0.47002944350242615,
-0.016955658793449402,
0.5122252702713013,
0.839488685131073,
0.06335151940584183,
0.5967093706130981,
0.1250438392162323,
-0.03896452113986015,
-0.23442119359970093,
-0.37091389298439026,
-0.5124961733818054,
-0.48161616921424866,
0.1987486034631729,
-0.657123327255249,
-0.9116020798683167,
0.6192737221717834,
-0.08969978243112564,
0.29198119044303894,
0.4026094973087311,
0.8572326302528381,
0.021194152534008026,
1.124871850013733,
0.191039577126503,
0.012851369567215443,
0.28732213377952576,
0.013834439218044281,
0.07527889311313629,
-0.5258735418319702,
0.3307647705078125,
-0.4251050353050232,
-0.6393138766288757,
-0.913032591342926,
-0.6196340322494507,
0.6499573588371277,
-0.049304138869047165,
-0.378256231546402,
0.0037985120434314013,
-0.13721275329589844,
0.6490888595581055,
0.6789670586585999,
0.25583016872406006,
0.5891491174697876,
0.12118444591760635,
-0.07763966172933578,
0.05722402408719063,
-0.5244763493537903,
-0.16436752676963806,
1.0778861045837402,
-0.05848121643066406,
0.8623144626617432,
0.40294983983039856,
0.683076024055481,
0.357270747423172,
0.6038950681686401,
-0.8677787780761719,
0.7208725810050964,
-0.12108003348112106,
-1.0808383226394653,
-0.647167980670929,
-0.7268425226211548,
-0.6679108142852783,
0.6851241588592529,
0.1311671882867813,
-0.5199849009513855,
0.3473169505596161,
-0.06064879894256592,
-0.5280311703681946,
0.53385329246521,
-0.6659637689590454,
0.2362862378358841,
-0.19459255039691925,
-0.5780665278434753,
-0.5170637965202332,
-0.5965383648872375,
0.40602660179138184,
-0.09869777411222458,
0.3376503586769104,
-0.015501461923122406,
-0.21244549751281738,
0.5942278504371643,
-0.8094715476036072,
1.08572518825531,
-0.10093843936920166,
-0.1320209801197052,
0.5089244842529297,
0.24967454373836517,
0.47820574045181274,
0.06999944150447845,
-0.008834559470415115,
-0.09503332525491714,
0.23075717687606812,
-0.6844462156295776,
-0.5542298555374146,
0.9581193923950195,
-0.7506418228149414,
-0.6686301827430725,
-0.3926059603691101,
-0.48688772320747375,
0.014049339108169079,
0.14838849008083344,
0.20851263403892517,
0.2927887439727783,
0.13714466989040375,
0.2474663108587265,
0.5867220163345337,
0.3214462101459503,
0.48461055755615234,
0.6919788122177124,
-0.5464221835136414,
-0.04651205986738205,
1.0270988941192627,
0.5752354860305786,
0.7772567868232727,
0.3622925281524658,
0.1753658652305603,
-0.19199807941913605,
-0.4996706247329712,
-0.3622225821018219,
0.2949075400829315,
-0.44922688603401184,
0.15778590738773346,
-0.6745019555091858,
0.16492599248886108,
-0.2515334486961365,
0.2580270767211914,
-0.30018094182014465,
-0.46844482421875,
-0.2828163802623749,
-0.07186343520879745,
0.32148003578186035,
0.7980082631111145,
-0.3593701422214508,
0.3494953513145447,
-0.2823164165019989,
0.37857550382614136,
0.6877977252006531,
0.4897994101047516,
0.03343972936272621,
-0.5550923347473145,
-0.08592037111520767,
-0.1833653301000595,
-0.2308981716632843,
-0.949395477771759,
0.20740287005901337,
0.3377068340778351,
0.2602618932723999,
0.38443002104759216,
0.16619202494621277,
0.7773000001907349,
-0.5283153057098389,
0.5595808029174805,
-0.06533500552177429,
-0.7435446381568909,
0.10918835550546646,
-0.258761465549469,
0.1898844987154007,
0.4156356155872345,
-0.06753973662853241,
-0.432598352432251,
-0.3555891215801239,
-0.1609104722738266,
-0.8088603615760803,
0.6189337372779846,
0.16736070811748505,
0.421518474817276,
0.06444907933473587,
0.24646686017513275,
-0.12272285670042038,
0.09685057401657104,
-0.5387927293777466,
-0.3100719749927521,
0.4341376721858978,
0.42778441309928894,
0.12367648631334305,
-0.25180330872535706,
-0.18759316205978394,
-0.0634644478559494,
0.3717716336250305,
-0.1934417486190796,
0.04853673651814461,
0.05916609242558479,
0.0034810483921319246,
-0.313760370016098,
0.47346264123916626,
0.6839262247085571,
0.556278645992279,
-0.20416726171970367,
0.06251426041126251,
0.4057237505912781,
-0.2717852294445038,
0.24767059087753296,
-0.2605447471141815,
0.09463895112276077,
-0.17107149958610535,
0.41455763578414917,
0.7442739009857178,
0.2400660514831543,
-0.43039435148239136,
0.08147676289081573,
0.16139033436775208,
-0.184458389878273,
-0.06158694997429848,
0.11021596938371658,
0.1363610476255417,
0.058834999799728394,
0.6173550486564636,
0.11194466799497604,
0.3107350170612335,
-0.6003929972648621,
0.3997851610183716,
0.48537489771842957,
-0.1502014696598053,
-0.20994868874549866,
0.35860002040863037,
0.24979926645755768,
-0.35825979709625244,
0.3876173794269562,
-0.18828034400939941,
-0.3681449592113495,
0.7048414945602417,
0.38116124272346497,
0.28694456815719604,
-0.19504821300506592,
0.26995599269866943,
0.2022945135831833,
0.3524124324321747,
-0.16672752797603607,
0.2109580785036087,
-0.20035278797149658,
-0.6732414960861206,
-0.6382066607475281,
-0.5795422792434692,
-0.689935028553009,
-0.20041927695274353,
-0.8345218300819397,
-0.015005002729594707,
-0.47466665506362915,
-0.35633614659309387,
0.040645647794008255,
0.4029856324195862,
-0.31836968660354614,
0.18114453554153442,
0.1386207789182663,
0.6476936340332031,
-0.8748486638069153,
0.32422229647636414,
0.4149308204650879,
0.013003429397940636,
-0.514518141746521,
-0.3583731949329376,
0.5144529342651367,
-0.7534688711166382,
0.7260987162590027,
-0.031243886798620224,
-0.484250009059906,
-0.0835128128528595,
-0.4712029695510864,
-0.8013932704925537,
0.7329891920089722,
0.28691163659095764,
-0.4520602226257324,
0.03678245469927788,
0.35998284816741943,
0.6355567574501038,
-0.5293145179748535,
0.41335511207580566,
0.6333668828010559,
0.5084474086761475,
0.15941815078258514,
-1.150256633758545,
-0.03125657141208649,
-0.07474474608898163,
-0.1610894352197647,
0.3121222257614136,
-0.7763831615447998,
1.2537509202957153,
-0.5430541634559631,
-0.34436529874801636,
0.2259131819009781,
0.5819970965385437,
0.35678669810295105,
0.416188508272171,
0.855443000793457,
0.4446794390678406,
0.7619145512580872,
0.03814474865794182,
1.388898253440857,
-0.08358192443847656,
0.40676218271255493,
1.347665548324585,
-0.5391088724136353,
0.909850001335144,
0.7245210409164429,
-0.6379303932189941,
0.38696563243865967,
0.8524582982063293,
0.23570212721824646,
-0.007228503003716469,
0.6426149010658264,
-0.6064633727073669,
-0.4866291582584381,
-0.06080229952931404,
0.13772433996200562,
-0.09313056617975235,
0.3915119171142578,
-0.3058694303035736,
-0.255567342042923,
-0.11664225906133652,
-0.13290362060070038,
-0.1608462929725647,
-0.27016013860702515,
0.7572225332260132,
0.14143522083759308,
-0.5382193326950073,
0.22380666434764862,
-0.16761060059070587,
0.4984050393104553,
-0.2947934567928314,
0.26086631417274475,
-0.46315696835517883,
0.2402048110961914,
-0.2907036542892456,
-0.8378332257270813,
-0.055215492844581604,
-0.20166906714439392,
-0.515238881111145,
-0.11463993042707443,
0.3171061873435974,
-0.18729357421398163,
-0.7860937714576721,
0.6220497488975525,
0.6284879446029663,
0.18953542411327362,
-0.2706765830516815,
-0.3178033232688904,
-0.07697205990552902,
-0.09095817059278488,
-0.497551292181015,
0.45633020997047424,
0.3352234363555908,
-0.20614610612392426,
0.7877157926559448,
0.8596364259719849,
0.404678612947464,
0.662300705909729,
0.1699008196592331,
0.7125398516654968,
-0.20660798251628876,
-0.17804457247257233,
-0.9701792001724243,
0.12473036348819733,
-0.1587095707654953,
-0.05230670049786568,
0.41730472445487976,
0.49446481466293335,
0.4188825488090515,
0.10178469121456146,
0.6044619679450989,
0.05466586351394653,
0.4569936990737915,
-0.2870774269104004,
0.4039176106452942,
-0.5104920864105225,
0.5317344665527344,
0.18654781579971313,
-0.821301281452179,
-0.4915126860141754,
-0.03021775372326374,
-0.5473318696022034,
0.1316443234682083,
0.4520875811576843,
1.1458120346069336,
0.031179970130324364,
-0.016460707411170006,
0.3952617943286896,
0.34004029631614685,
0.43025901913642883,
0.388522207736969,
0.4367915987968445,
-0.08340144902467728,
0.8378061056137085,
-0.056278519332408905,
-0.4432987868785858,
-0.35190701484680176,
-0.43553152680397034,
-0.5371717810630798,
-0.3427427411079407,
-0.23830147087574005,
-0.2328014224767685,
-0.30910536646842957,
0.5033519268035889,
0.9655576348304749,
-0.9498457312583923,
-0.936083972454071,
-0.2486102133989334,
0.3483582139015198,
-0.3111219108104706,
-0.3034830391407013,
0.029535887762904167,
-0.6387882828712463,
-0.89854496717453,
0.2286841869354248,
0.3517814874649048,
-0.31808069348335266,
-0.16549012064933777,
-0.06533437967300415,
-0.2279566526412964,
0.49442049860954285,
0.6954586505889893,
0.28760600090026855,
-0.8091062307357788,
-0.00951254554092884,
0.2742711007595062,
-0.19132964313030243,
0.21867573261260986,
1.195699691772461,
-0.43170851469039917,
0.59311842918396,
0.5883742570877075,
0.2645166218280792,
0.5150261521339417,
-0.10477747023105621,
0.5732613205909729,
-0.6535792350769043,
-0.25829848647117615,
-0.06315173208713531,
0.15313218533992767,
0.049789655953645706,
-0.20283156633377075,
0.32332396507263184,
0.18589697778224945,
-0.6683656573295593,
-0.7924264669418335,
0.5679792165756226,
-0.8805719017982483,
-0.22836144268512726,
1.0299961566925049,
-0.039051901549100876,
-0.08310441672801971,
0.07262491434812546,
-0.34021997451782227,
-0.13019981980323792,
-0.5737806558609009,
0.2000386118888855,
0.9970449209213257,
-0.8888145685195923,
-0.44522085785865784,
-0.5010550618171692,
0.09546131640672684,
0.6743388772010803,
-0.4033072888851166,
0.13781985640525818,
0.4402945041656494,
0.2747965455055237,
0.6534730792045593,
0.4998202323913574,
0.06570949405431747,
0.05443499982357025,
-0.01284013967961073,
-0.6053653955459595,
0.6020833253860474,
-0.1430748850107193,
-0.2761370837688446,
0.6086048483848572,
0.24420595169067383,
-0.1397203952074051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02333v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02333v3
|
Key-Point-Driven Data Synthesis with its Enhancement on Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-03-04T18:58:30 | 2024-05-08T01:48:46 |
Yiming Huang, Xiao Liu, Yeyun Gong, Zhibin Gou, Yelong Shen, Nan Duan, Weizhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown great potential in complex reasoning
tasks, yet their performance is often hampered by the scarcity of high-quality
and reasoning-focused training datasets. Addressing this challenge, we propose
Key-Point-Driven Data Synthesis (KPDDS), a novel data synthesis framework that
synthesizes question-answer pairs by leveraging key points and exemplar
practices from authentic data sources. KPDDS ensures the generation of novel
questions with rigorous quality control and substantial scalability. As a
result, we present KPMath, an extensive synthetic dataset tailored for
mathematical reasoning, comprising over 800K question-answer pairs. Utilizing
KPMath and augmenting it with additional reasoning-intensive corpora, we create
the comprehensive KPMath-Plus dataset. The Qwen1.5-72B model, fine-tuned on
KPMath-Plus, achieves 87.0% PASS@1 accuracy on GSM8K and 58.3% on MATH,
surpassing competitors in the 7B to 70B range and best commercial models like
GPT-4 across multiple math reasoning datasets.
|
[
-0.40345361828804016,
-0.6201634407043457,
0.9009365439414978,
0.17967498302459717,
-0.2332019805908203,
0.19074255228042603,
0.11438911408185959,
-0.07314413040876389,
-0.1772911697626114,
0.5174902677536011,
-0.6317934989929199,
-0.8034061789512634,
-0.17809650301933289,
-0.12538789212703705,
-0.2862531840801239,
0.8817158937454224,
-0.1445637345314026,
0.10325930267572403,
-0.1044314056634903,
-0.12976284325122833,
-0.14264293015003204,
-0.6710919141769409,
-0.23596563935279846,
-0.22695733606815338,
0.3682441711425781,
0.46006065607070923,
0.8737929463386536,
0.5572932362556458,
0.39673811197280884,
0.09924954175949097,
0.15203198790550232,
0.2675112783908844,
-0.15344728529453278,
0.5025994777679443,
-0.2665197551250458,
-0.5233702659606934,
-0.7467706799507141,
0.07302231341600418,
0.45630237460136414,
1.05512535572052,
0.10008179396390915,
0.08404746651649475,
-0.1950983703136444,
0.6903836727142334,
-0.46134984493255615,
0.37877941131591797,
-0.8948237895965576,
-0.03834497183561325,
0.10824567079544067,
-0.0718405693769455,
-0.3933550715446472,
-0.7812135219573975,
0.17090937495231628,
-0.7925359010696411,
0.31945809721946716,
-0.35661524534225464,
0.2965025305747986,
0.20890390872955322,
-0.4236491620540619,
-0.4748387634754181,
-0.5764023661613464,
0.4775733947753906,
-0.6888375282287598,
0.6146773099899292,
0.3185184895992279,
0.4763747751712799,
-0.08942130208015442,
-0.6163413524627686,
-0.6387436389923096,
0.07037906348705292,
0.17060531675815582,
0.03130558505654335,
0.38024476170539856,
-0.0560135543346405,
0.40837362408638,
0.05745801702141762,
-0.7010225057601929,
-0.49447253346443176,
-0.43873995542526245,
-0.015153047628700733,
0.8703476190567017,
0.38514283299446106,
-0.1174156591296196,
-0.2576877474784851,
0.1478813886642456,
-0.2764323651790619,
-1.209505558013916,
0.27090293169021606,
0.3288426995277405,
0.4146599769592285,
0.18702447414398193,
0.745392382144928,
-0.3715458810329437,
0.7798283696174622,
0.058072347193956375,
-0.20114083588123322,
-0.06767569482326508,
-0.6155247688293457,
-0.09022589027881622,
0.021955158561468124,
0.45633164048194885,
0.4720035493373871,
0.25789329409599304,
-0.09285159409046173,
-0.06558042764663696,
0.48458486795425415,
-0.1268533617258072,
-1.0472251176834106,
-0.7658185362815857,
0.450007826089859,
-0.1010812371969223,
-0.5051472783088684,
-0.10902368277311325,
-0.6749049425125122,
-0.22661763429641724,
-0.6156885027885437,
0.2133735716342926,
-0.5233418345451355,
-0.2130734920501709,
0.4085101783275604,
0.03955930098891258,
0.09852989763021469,
0.47031545639038086,
-0.49251025915145874,
0.2178722470998764,
0.6395907402038574,
0.45766499638557434,
0.022916559129953384,
-0.27788400650024414,
-0.43066954612731934,
0.2676061987876892,
-0.8288189768791199,
0.5590599775314331,
-0.7784002423286438,
-0.48295828700065613,
-0.16003547608852386,
-0.4070700407028198,
0.12202674895524979,
-0.7573122382164001,
0.5750362873077393,
-0.520479679107666,
0.12212951481342316,
-0.45251333713531494,
-0.6323524117469788,
-0.04433952271938324,
0.23924750089645386,
-0.49332207441329956,
1.0528085231781006,
0.22423426806926727,
-0.11453088372945786,
0.4300498366355896,
-0.5418290495872498,
-0.600814938545227,
-0.15520595014095306,
-0.26154282689094543,
-0.22364239394664764,
-0.040882013738155365,
0.47129562497138977,
0.3893686532974243,
-0.4806855022907257,
0.4909919798374176,
-0.5675527453422546,
-0.12159689515829086,
0.5938996076583862,
-0.22901800274848938,
0.5540444254875183,
0.085634246468544,
-0.1673373132944107,
-0.07585515081882477,
-1.3889799118041992,
0.3949589133262634,
0.12239717692136765,
-0.24782398343086243,
-0.18904495239257812,
-0.14766041934490204,
-0.34896326065063477,
0.5900099277496338,
0.0791701078414917,
-0.2936778962612152,
0.2488548308610916,
-0.283673495054245,
0.6470077633857727,
0.6980143189430237,
0.2103753238916397,
0.6625077724456787,
-0.44904017448425293,
0.594223141670227,
-0.06400012224912643,
0.013312206603586674,
-0.21464790403842926,
-0.5309280157089233,
-0.3845153748989105,
-0.16234953701496124,
0.25360816717147827,
0.4334299564361572,
-0.5775763988494873,
0.3536645770072937,
-0.3648856580257416,
-0.6350564360618591,
-0.5998960137367249,
0.0025185770355165005,
0.16315411031246185,
0.7039069533348083,
0.2779240012168884,
0.3422630727291107,
-0.29285866022109985,
-0.6108977198600769,
-0.06822731345891953,
-0.1463472545146942,
-0.25338560342788696,
0.34722471237182617,
0.34043630957603455,
0.32066038250923157,
1.0108668804168701,
-0.8725554943084717,
0.17545665800571442,
-0.035543836653232574,
-0.20062462985515594,
0.4967971742153168,
0.41685110330581665,
0.29014113545417786,
-0.7379195690155029,
-0.693223237991333,
-0.3648744225502014,
-0.5048498511314392,
-0.3258880078792572,
-0.18852044641971588,
-0.3798738718032837,
-0.23242759704589844,
0.497829407453537,
-0.9344853758811951,
0.22381652891635895,
0.281220942735672,
-0.15929700434207916,
0.7644147276878357,
0.10903926193714142,
0.17318712174892426,
-1.0835760831832886,
0.21221411228179932,
-0.20172114670276642,
0.12576964497566223,
-0.589633047580719,
0.22085514664649963,
0.08914882689714432,
-0.6522786021232605,
-0.12849250435829163,
0.47774267196655273,
-0.037474386394023895,
-0.03351432830095291,
0.047049857676029205,
0.12843596935272217,
0.33367472887039185,
0.6693172454833984,
0.024624302983283997,
0.7166909575462341,
0.525887668132782,
-0.6971386075019836,
0.4794830083847046,
0.49792492389678955,
-0.32031095027923584,
0.9082186222076416,
-1.0186569690704346,
0.20500315725803375,
0.12305756658315659,
0.3681768774986267,
-1.0708930492401123,
-0.3735850155353546,
0.20173025131225586,
-0.5867640972137451,
-0.23937039077281952,
-0.3733493685722351,
-0.6683900952339172,
0.0013894086005166173,
-0.2607167661190033,
0.6768199801445007,
0.43084338307380676,
-0.5958107113838196,
0.35629141330718994,
0.14983351528644562,
-0.7288614511489868,
0.16220799088478088,
-0.30862879753112793,
-0.1391977220773697,
0.022236941382288933,
-0.8577213287353516,
0.47170114517211914,
-0.36723917722702026,
-0.3259485960006714,
-0.011127029545605183,
-0.22994577884674072,
-0.19299837946891785,
-0.1742844134569168,
0.18497295677661896,
0.43262341618537903,
-0.005158366169780493,
0.22833608090877533,
0.48314791917800903,
-0.24867817759513855,
0.22502122819423676,
-0.31749096512794495,
0.5177307724952698,
0.24085989594459534,
-0.654358446598053,
-0.16579267382621765,
0.5833247900009155,
1.0234893560409546,
-0.3712575435638428,
0.11011745780706406,
-0.04168795049190521,
-0.49603942036628723,
-0.3650882840156555,
0.0477200523018837,
-0.3456917107105255,
-0.43863409757614136,
0.1515662968158722,
-0.8390706777572632,
-0.6514790058135986,
0.4321655035018921,
-0.06575003266334534,
0.23451858758926392,
0.29173219203948975,
0.44028401374816895,
0.007386599201709032,
1.5900375843048096,
-0.2375180721282959,
0.11415235698223114,
-0.005779640283435583,
-0.2911626398563385,
0.5844036936759949,
-0.5835044384002686,
-0.17325975000858307,
-0.31477221846580505,
-0.23260995745658875,
-0.5320611000061035,
-0.5025756359100342,
0.8866974711418152,
0.16326788067817688,
-0.371326744556427,
0.12426207214593887,
-0.5608383417129517,
0.2241719663143158,
0.6253706216812134,
0.24627694487571716,
0.2566780149936676,
-0.08083056658506393,
-0.15446723997592926,
-0.1870301514863968,
-0.5454905033111572,
-0.19873099029064178,
1.6216305494308472,
-0.011685541830956936,
0.7204415202140808,
0.011186239309608936,
0.4254089891910553,
-0.11169902235269547,
-0.15512944757938385,
-0.5661644339561462,
0.7617927193641663,
0.29493218660354614,
-0.6346234083175659,
-0.2602759301662445,
-0.5893353819847107,
-0.5269465446472168,
0.21102620661258698,
-0.037149835377931595,
-0.15400031208992004,
-0.020990215241909027,
0.05105279013514519,
-0.5018213391304016,
-0.06185461953282356,
-0.7130326628684998,
0.63762366771698,
-0.0066955373622477055,
-0.25540101528167725,
-0.26651957631111145,
-0.5525315999984741,
0.30901890993118286,
-0.1436709463596344,
0.11879841983318329,
-0.2101890593767166,
0.22464396059513092,
0.3751867711544037,
-0.7754843235015869,
0.4558013379573822,
-0.27066826820373535,
-0.2659182846546173,
0.4171827733516693,
0.4067409634590149,
0.7352553009986877,
0.41369280219078064,
-0.14081579446792603,
-0.25788822770118713,
0.07873265445232391,
-0.4533877968788147,
-0.9471544623374939,
0.8310654759407043,
-0.3393920660018921,
-0.42170119285583496,
-0.04747697338461876,
-1.0425366163253784,
-0.7107290625572205,
0.018014514818787575,
-0.040404532104730606,
0.8596590757369995,
0.3214446008205414,
-0.021460728719830513,
0.5847046971321106,
0.017178921028971672,
-0.09163279086351395,
0.28573310375213623,
-0.2230074554681778,
-0.9079870581626892,
0.9359294772148132,
0.09564657509326935,
0.4676438271999359,
0.3663599491119385,
0.07400883734226227,
-0.5496600866317749,
-0.4678974449634552,
-0.6062347888946533,
0.17098313570022583,
-0.7288239002227783,
-0.16346393525600433,
-0.41062986850738525,
-0.3378745913505554,
-0.6324285268783569,
-0.502936840057373,
-0.4107133150100708,
-0.9332816004753113,
0.0759633332490921,
-0.2658788561820984,
0.44760531187057495,
0.18739211559295654,
-0.07445680350065231,
-0.00324580748565495,
-0.7080898284912109,
0.5374320149421692,
0.4860994219779968,
0.31817781925201416,
-0.17473554611206055,
-0.12266375124454498,
0.18221385776996613,
0.24000857770442963,
-0.21300970017910004,
-0.8336367607116699,
0.22314518690109253,
0.07674302160739899,
0.1729394495487213,
0.1916438639163971,
0.2309277057647705,
0.5285969376564026,
-0.4734446108341217,
0.6163346767425537,
0.058233682066202164,
-0.8985642194747925,
0.7165951132774353,
-0.43523505330085754,
0.39876824617385864,
0.41355037689208984,
0.3582923114299774,
-0.28218841552734375,
-0.3697997033596039,
-0.7088879346847534,
-0.5704768300056458,
0.3752286434173584,
0.3279708921909332,
-0.26716095209121704,
0.19284145534038544,
0.35964009165763855,
0.33269795775413513,
0.41138628125190735,
-0.23209168016910553,
-0.18626664578914642,
-0.08183599263429642,
-0.5164716243743896,
0.22412823140621185,
0.05245690792798996,
-0.07487841695547104,
-0.5145426392555237,
0.7075650095939636,
-0.27218952775001526,
0.09633398801088333,
0.11481895297765732,
-0.05371028557419777,
0.033060502260923386,
0.17970602214336395,
0.5574111938476562,
1.1225484609603882,
-0.2296404093503952,
0.27573907375335693,
-0.29187291860580444,
-0.3126280605792999,
0.3592558801174164,
0.472648561000824,
-0.38180601596832275,
0.26365792751312256,
-0.03391816467046738,
0.4355711042881012,
0.00560420798137784,
-0.7929348349571228,
0.20168417692184448,
0.25380128622055054,
-0.3591233789920807,
-0.0593307726085186,
0.0648973137140274,
0.10152007639408112,
0.24224388599395752,
0.36420005559921265,
0.06431086361408234,
-0.10640044510364532,
-0.3810114860534668,
0.1880386918783188,
0.25766614079475403,
0.16121147572994232,
-0.6261921525001526,
0.7077305912971497,
0.02277190238237381,
-0.037578802555799484,
0.46077775955200195,
-0.33236750960350037,
-0.7526078224182129,
0.41522887349128723,
0.31602320075035095,
0.3161199390888214,
-0.25486329197883606,
0.30128931999206543,
0.52216637134552,
0.05597713217139244,
0.3166598677635193,
0.8259575963020325,
-0.2794034779071808,
-0.6833363175392151,
-0.4198743999004364,
-0.3094309866428375,
-0.5119072198867798,
0.23436331748962402,
-0.6516349911689758,
0.2465869039297104,
-0.7499861717224121,
0.1924683004617691,
0.1159813180565834,
0.03458854556083679,
-0.519010066986084,
0.49146729707717896,
-0.38716650009155273,
0.7732534408569336,
-0.7368045449256897,
0.6776902675628662,
0.4974849224090576,
-0.2744811475276947,
-0.7893007397651672,
-0.20558114349842072,
-0.35568156838417053,
-0.8075371980667114,
0.4407758116722107,
-0.2058989703655243,
0.3830649256706238,
0.0888308733701706,
-0.43312495946884155,
-0.7007073760032654,
0.8776815533638,
0.446162611246109,
-0.4383370578289032,
-0.03868498653173447,
0.7510637640953064,
0.3360838294029236,
-0.1940930187702179,
-0.2237081229686737,
0.6027234792709351,
0.2913265526294708,
0.40020662546157837,
-0.6559229493141174,
0.13093118369579315,
-0.34875357151031494,
-0.2406725138425827,
0.5678891539573669,
-0.18427690863609314,
0.7838624715805054,
-0.20226122438907623,
0.11001832038164139,
0.046956226229667664,
0.2503640949726105,
0.9313985109329224,
0.3769330680370331,
0.35781192779541016,
0.8866782784461975,
0.7701681852340698,
-0.08199630677700043,
0.6430710554122925,
-0.5042221546173096,
0.10649196803569794,
1.1865519285202026,
-0.6199747920036316,
0.6654322147369385,
0.4377174377441406,
-0.5022562742233276,
0.2411111444234848,
0.5172690153121948,
0.10597366839647293,
0.7972143888473511,
0.20494171977043152,
-0.4414145350456238,
-0.5188736319541931,
0.09928110241889954,
-0.5857570767402649,
0.18225963413715363,
0.47581353783607483,
-0.2508369982242584,
-0.3220286965370178,
-0.1863180547952652,
-0.1280401051044464,
0.011350260116159916,
-0.21427522599697113,
0.35464245080947876,
0.052103959023952484,
-0.7362818121910095,
0.6113075017929077,
-0.030794359743595123,
-0.06307598203420639,
-0.46332767605781555,
-0.30211591720581055,
-0.23251141607761383,
0.1318480521440506,
0.09356816112995148,
-0.9760032296180725,
0.22990497946739197,
-0.09573441743850708,
-0.3708694279193878,
-0.33155620098114014,
0.58647620677948,
-0.6633866429328918,
-0.6941505074501038,
-0.43636223673820496,
0.5218237638473511,
-0.12029339373111725,
-0.5912483334541321,
-0.5931910276412964,
-0.07744310796260834,
-0.15704913437366486,
0.20379121601581573,
0.26639989018440247,
0.6643322110176086,
0.11509367823600769,
0.5805450677871704,
1.13199782371521,
0.14439640939235687,
0.09043505042791367,
-0.06494880467653275,
1.0715320110321045,
-0.6503779888153076,
-0.6227273941040039,
-0.590376079082489,
0.3602229356765747,
-0.03810904175043106,
-0.5026228427886963,
0.4890696108341217,
0.7069637179374695,
0.9608063101768494,
-0.05348379164934158,
1.1262032985687256,
0.02337714284658432,
0.73225998878479,
-0.5567804574966431,
0.3833022713661194,
-0.21670874953269958,
0.058510661125183105,
-0.21709343791007996,
-0.9534822702407837,
-0.20333172380924225,
0.6599944233894348,
-0.25797542929649353,
-0.2386699765920639,
0.507932722568512,
0.9489296078681946,
-0.1622294932603836,
0.21114641427993774,
0.34960341453552246,
0.039654720574617386,
0.6885342597961426,
0.9368452429771423,
0.8986324667930603,
-0.6485288143157959,
0.7988440990447998,
-0.39326924085617065,
-0.08635901659727097,
-0.019724639132618904,
-0.666557788848877,
-0.6687723398208618,
-0.688508927822113,
-0.39792126417160034,
-0.45683401823043823,
-0.21898122131824493,
0.9261396527290344,
0.5607802867889404,
-0.8784247636795044,
0.07483860850334167,
-0.5949190855026245,
0.11474097520112991,
-0.02963954396545887,
-0.27226322889328003,
0.5229685306549072,
-0.11664769798517227,
-0.5974602103233337,
0.458131343126297,
0.41646409034729004,
-0.12535279989242554,
-0.27259910106658936,
-0.19575725495815277,
0.25297409296035767,
0.177364781498909,
0.6964042782783508,
-0.044991061091423035,
-0.36721256375312805,
-0.07924255728721619,
0.46456772089004517,
-0.032010458409786224,
0.013646540232002735,
1.0241597890853882,
-0.6410444974899292,
0.3154648542404175,
0.6122128963470459,
0.7173691391944885,
0.3378520607948303,
-0.10263270884752274,
0.721751868724823,
-0.3959621787071228,
-0.0782201737165451,
0.5058443546295166,
0.24384818971157074,
0.19061380624771118,
-0.002475572982802987,
0.36079490184783936,
0.524408757686615,
-0.2944616377353668,
-0.9230992794036865,
0.45341330766677856,
-0.8583702445030212,
-0.27681079506874084,
1.1364736557006836,
-0.031646545976400375,
0.05188937857747078,
0.10978349298238754,
-0.3953133225440979,
-0.056087467819452286,
-0.3173922002315521,
0.8358924388885498,
0.773775041103363,
-0.14218898117542267,
0.038466453552246094,
-0.22511357069015503,
0.44596025347709656,
0.4658089876174927,
-0.926072359085083,
0.12428667396306992,
0.7667933702468872,
0.20213094353675842,
-0.060576554387807846,
0.4276050925254822,
-0.22512589395046234,
0.5838359594345093,
0.1635124385356903,
-0.433815598487854,
-0.0453546978533268,
-0.44508010149002075,
0.26072847843170166,
0.48884689807891846,
-0.1580047309398651,
-0.11325474828481674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02325v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02325v1
|
Contrastive Region Guidance: Improving Grounding in Vision-Language Models without Training
| 2024-03-04T18:55:30 | 2024-03-04T18:55:30 |
David Wan, Jaemin Cho, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Highlighting particularly relevant regions of an image can improve the
performance of vision-language models (VLMs) on various vision-language (VL)
tasks by guiding the model to attend more closely to these regions of interest.
For example, VLMs can be given a "visual prompt", where visual markers such as
bounding boxes delineate key image regions. However, current VLMs that can
incorporate visual guidance are either proprietary and expensive or require
costly training on curated data that includes visual prompts. We introduce
Contrastive Region Guidance (CRG), a training-free guidance method that enables
open-source VLMs to respond to visual prompts. CRG contrasts model outputs
produced with and without visual prompts, factoring out biases revealed by the
model when answering without the information required to produce a correct
answer (i.e., the model's prior). CRG achieves substantial improvements in a
wide variety of VL tasks: When region annotations are provided, CRG increases
absolute accuracy by up to 11.1% on ViP-Bench, a collection of six diverse
region-based tasks such as recognition, math, and object relationship
reasoning. We also show CRG's applicability to spatial reasoning, with 10%
improvement on What'sUp, as well as to compositional generalization --
improving accuracy by 11.5% and 7.5% on two challenging splits from SugarCrepe
-- and to image-text alignment for generated images, where we improve by up to
8.4 AUROC and 6.8 F1 points on SeeTRUE. When reference regions are absent, CRG
allows us to re-rank proposed regions in referring expression comprehension and
phrase grounding benchmarks like RefCOCO/+/g and Flickr30K Entities, with an
average gain of 3.2% in accuracy. Our analysis explores alternative masking
strategies for CRG, quantifies CRG's probability shift, and evaluates the role
of region guidance strength, empirically validating CRG's design choices.
|
[
-0.4744599461555481,
-0.5959691405296326,
0.46082207560539246,
0.2268703728914261,
-0.571030855178833,
-0.44579946994781494,
-0.4257528483867645,
-0.2677074074745178,
-0.16742174327373505,
0.6724350452423096,
-0.4876890480518341,
-0.9599250555038452,
-0.4703001379966736,
-0.2785734534263611,
-0.21042409539222717,
0.5915523767471313,
0.11657071858644485,
0.35167038440704346,
-0.26276668906211853,
-0.31220999360084534,
-0.9817593097686768,
-0.43239685893058777,
-0.5972342491149902,
-0.4416784942150116,
0.3346329629421234,
0.4284360110759735,
0.5145662426948547,
1.0086864233016968,
0.7391431927680969,
0.25102052092552185,
-0.32125815749168396,
0.13830281794071198,
-0.28920191526412964,
-0.09359148889780045,
-0.24788160622119904,
-0.6937439441680908,
-0.2847811281681061,
-0.16494272649288177,
0.12390456348657608,
0.7047026753425598,
-0.16057655215263367,
-0.2707888185977936,
0.08507609367370605,
1.043899416923523,
-0.6394321322441101,
0.17231783270835876,
-0.591858983039856,
0.19930072128772736,
-0.10311935842037201,
-0.3690624535083771,
-0.2853281795978546,
-0.1677704006433487,
0.4073288142681122,
-0.6928438544273376,
0.6334500908851624,
0.1172492504119873,
1.048927903175354,
0.4926159977912903,
-0.20062580704689026,
0.029707029461860657,
-0.431657999753952,
0.8947667479515076,
-0.3902747929096222,
0.49879002571105957,
0.41709527373313904,
0.3583677411079407,
-0.013574542477726936,
-0.5863351821899414,
-0.16107448935508728,
-0.12052374333143234,
-0.18358565866947174,
0.5459895730018616,
-0.15022465586662292,
0.3441801369190216,
0.49623239040374756,
0.35797199606895447,
-0.4824886620044708,
-0.1927122175693512,
-0.35565975308418274,
-0.14663593471050262,
0.14106866717338562,
-0.04772139713168144,
0.19999921321868896,
0.10965488106012344,
-0.3863821029663086,
-0.299594521522522,
-0.8214426040649414,
0.34057632088661194,
-0.14388452470302582,
0.3459530472755432,
-0.2521752417087555,
0.46836546063423157,
-0.44436466693878174,
1.0581318140029907,
0.30265963077545166,
-0.13645362854003906,
0.14389674365520477,
-0.42876628041267395,
-0.17417234182357788,
-0.22216856479644775,
0.11880902945995331,
0.9142277240753174,
0.2951529622077942,
0.05186430364847183,
-0.2662121057510376,
0.3361847996711731,
0.21556463837623596,
-0.47551026940345764,
-0.6669047474861145,
-0.20921145379543304,
-0.5565451979637146,
0.027093999087810516,
-0.03705241158604622,
-0.8250005841255188,
-0.646335244178772,
-0.7322081923484802,
-0.038752615451812744,
-0.4017440378665924,
0.18439888954162598,
0.08294099569320679,
-0.31913846731185913,
0.6950992941856384,
0.7784426808357239,
-0.6931527853012085,
0.08707089722156525,
0.34859734773635864,
0.7492292523384094,
-0.06989634782075882,
-0.1363094598054886,
-0.6940978169441223,
-0.07343528419733047,
-0.5552219152450562,
1.1283621788024902,
-0.6383347511291504,
-0.3368034362792969,
-0.0077453250996768475,
-0.0019026361405849457,
0.17332330346107483,
-0.8620890974998474,
0.46054714918136597,
-0.1455584615468979,
0.22628086805343628,
-0.808485209941864,
0.02658660151064396,
-0.2619531750679016,
0.39078158140182495,
-0.3589543402194977,
0.9071989059448242,
-0.0005396421765908599,
-0.6160711050033569,
0.7050814032554626,
-0.42144501209259033,
-0.27771902084350586,
0.11814237385988235,
-0.4399092495441437,
-0.1372397541999817,
0.10589799284934998,
0.8891171813011169,
0.060328882187604904,
-0.1538727879524231,
0.051451992243528366,
-0.04167122021317482,
-0.4206324517726898,
-0.2254876047372818,
0.0015048851491883397,
0.39793696999549866,
0.02441454865038395,
-0.6207806468009949,
0.47617244720458984,
-0.6557615995407104,
0.04456396400928497,
-0.07220734655857086,
-0.14546185731887817,
-0.42089933156967163,
0.0799918994307518,
-0.2255244255065918,
0.09890652447938919,
-0.01905357651412487,
-0.08748166263103485,
-0.04733654484152794,
-0.20122480392456055,
-0.05410600081086159,
0.6018159985542297,
-0.01854838617146015,
0.8316941857337952,
-0.18600139021873474,
0.5261088609695435,
0.29811882972717285,
0.23703016340732574,
-0.39489856362342834,
-0.647630512714386,
-1.3011059761047363,
-0.16121172904968262,
0.1885046511888504,
0.8546920418739319,
-1.118739366531372,
0.4199914336204529,
0.13945302367210388,
-0.3856804370880127,
-0.3633294105529785,
0.07671643048524857,
0.546503484249115,
0.9216275811195374,
0.672508180141449,
-0.38222846388816833,
-0.47640103101730347,
-1.097532033920288,
-0.038378629833459854,
0.010048499330878258,
0.03103058598935604,
0.48868298530578613,
0.17682142555713654,
-0.00017825762915890664,
0.7113320827484131,
-0.557307243347168,
-0.42184075713157654,
-0.1142735406756401,
-0.09588633477687836,
-0.05401661619544029,
0.4137686789035797,
0.6187841296195984,
-1.014741063117981,
-0.4537500739097595,
0.19431264698505402,
-0.7700464129447937,
-0.5142778158187866,
0.09224128723144531,
-0.3477144241333008,
0.06716642528772354,
0.5930212140083313,
-0.10330788046121597,
0.7131770849227905,
0.4282522201538086,
-0.4897827208042145,
0.3685322403907776,
-0.2465749830007553,
0.29112178087234497,
-0.5894808173179626,
-0.04584341123700142,
0.5122587084770203,
-0.2322225421667099,
-0.7002401947975159,
0.3062550723552704,
0.05387343093752861,
-0.17989902198314667,
-0.43319469690322876,
0.5591461062431335,
-0.4828382730484009,
0.06945541501045227,
-0.40444415807724,
0.4217381179332733,
-0.0126724224537611,
0.5298223495483398,
0.43050190806388855,
0.8784272074699402,
0.9281597137451172,
-0.6918846964836121,
0.04953644052147865,
0.22268430888652802,
-0.2811068594455719,
0.7583962082862854,
-0.5149596929550171,
0.01519926730543375,
-0.346448689699173,
0.12885119020938873,
-0.8242946267127991,
0.09426309168338776,
0.38713228702545166,
-0.2421988546848297,
0.07387149333953857,
-0.5016733407974243,
0.11135908961296082,
-0.10782349109649658,
-0.06226208806037903,
0.3073061406612396,
0.7334128618240356,
-0.7249628305435181,
0.5657261610031128,
0.06682490557432175,
-0.034748274832963943,
-0.7336491942405701,
-0.8952574729919434,
0.06940851360559464,
-0.3602944314479828,
-0.5002561211585999,
0.31615105271339417,
-0.026085466146469116,
-0.4305194616317749,
0.0403568334877491,
-0.242477148771286,
-0.0657268688082695,
0.01988624408841133,
0.23802949488162994,
0.17484647035598755,
-0.21942554414272308,
-0.022772155702114105,
-0.28270941972732544,
-0.31158336997032166,
-0.25921618938446045,
-0.37229493260383606,
0.4143752455711365,
-0.28743577003479004,
-0.17567643523216248,
-0.2347370684146881,
0.22974705696105957,
0.036453671753406525,
-0.5470050573348999,
0.33205708861351013,
0.5683531165122986,
-0.3848389685153961,
-0.34334796667099,
-0.5113046169281006,
-0.14204953610897064,
-0.48533740639686584,
0.3001473844051361,
-0.25279465317726135,
-0.7802661657333374,
0.5263160467147827,
-0.008300193585455418,
-0.03805708512663841,
0.15192095935344696,
0.27911821007728577,
0.01067874301224947,
0.7825218439102173,
0.9603288173675537,
0.3183799386024475,
1.0492937564849854,
-0.1631872057914734,
0.17001700401306152,
-0.7464119791984558,
-0.48337212204933167,
-0.4488915801048279,
-0.14831818640232086,
-0.23605859279632568,
-0.7421268820762634,
0.3425874710083008,
0.4971771836280823,
0.20462273061275482,
0.07017649710178375,
-0.7134107947349548,
0.8803911805152893,
0.6963648200035095,
0.3084057867527008,
0.03832231089472771,
0.32557791471481323,
-0.23034530878067017,
-0.41580379009246826,
-0.879658579826355,
-0.34678491950035095,
0.6837827563285828,
-0.027344323694705963,
0.8124544024467468,
-0.2216220498085022,
0.47724640369415283,
0.25997668504714966,
0.2422075718641281,
-0.7391392588615417,
0.6346853971481323,
-0.4148063361644745,
-0.0060143000446259975,
0.0022135598119348288,
-0.29187431931495667,
-0.5843586921691895,
0.6143632531166077,
-0.30356842279434204,
-0.7086254358291626,
0.40664851665496826,
0.6168919205665588,
-0.1778893917798996,
0.11520513147115707,
-0.7795096039772034,
0.7473374605178833,
-0.2517942786216736,
-0.38844034075737,
-0.006044141016900539,
-0.43805938959121704,
0.28086698055267334,
0.3789273500442505,
-0.11601750552654266,
0.1813485473394394,
0.05810442566871643,
0.43876439332962036,
-0.06381770968437195,
0.9101009964942932,
-0.5072717070579529,
0.07683411985635757,
0.35753723978996277,
-0.06579338759183884,
0.30011510848999023,
-0.2774251699447632,
0.2575450539588928,
0.193261981010437,
-0.38469043374061584,
-0.5301317572593689,
-0.7730087637901306,
0.6035735607147217,
-0.42501041293144226,
-0.7824878692626953,
-0.18373464047908783,
-0.4159509241580963,
-0.13380374014377594,
0.1638617068529129,
0.3430284261703491,
0.6819893717765808,
0.18916437029838562,
0.17770175635814667,
1.0467545986175537,
-0.46785467863082886,
0.19928748905658722,
0.1864064335823059,
-0.17895002663135529,
-0.6786103248596191,
0.7920092344284058,
-0.1967574506998062,
0.04822519049048424,
0.42709606885910034,
0.20946544408798218,
-0.4204482436180115,
-0.8030745983123779,
-0.29148387908935547,
0.17161959409713745,
-1.2454774379730225,
-0.16477245092391968,
-0.31249821186065674,
0.0984097495675087,
-0.2834629714488983,
-0.5492025017738342,
-0.041544463485479355,
-0.19217713177204132,
-0.1380406767129898,
0.013157554902136326,
0.05497825890779495,
0.6150638461112976,
0.0671079233288765,
0.4350760877132416,
-0.4865123927593231,
0.2708406150341034,
0.20933766663074493,
0.2386140078306198,
-0.12550786137580872,
-0.48726022243499756,
-0.23737645149230957,
-0.10298699885606766,
-0.12956885993480682,
-0.6437217593193054,
0.21628236770629883,
-0.1617335081100464,
0.659105122089386,
0.4039416015148163,
-0.14901971817016602,
1.2323997020721436,
-0.4134974479675293,
1.0995367765426636,
0.3497122824192047,
-0.9206407070159912,
0.857139527797699,
-0.28530752658843994,
0.5134440660476685,
0.4848174452781677,
-0.18634411692619324,
-0.5775209665298462,
-0.28226426243782043,
-0.2769370675086975,
-0.9413210153579712,
0.5552335381507874,
0.11948487907648087,
-0.23920519649982452,
0.0436696819961071,
0.6126469969749451,
-0.26626768708229065,
0.08264851570129395,
-0.8973226547241211,
-0.3393978178501129,
-0.41087403893470764,
-0.08173476904630661,
0.03226006031036377,
-0.12644308805465698,
-0.4558109641075134,
-0.11215458810329437,
0.49351900815963745,
-0.35611456632614136,
0.18778592348098755,
0.6753700971603394,
-0.07389460504055023,
0.03189977630972862,
0.1868361383676529,
0.8952546715736389,
0.7381269931793213,
0.10603456199169159,
0.32631349563598633,
0.2714720368385315,
-0.09345095604658127,
-0.17122143507003784,
-0.06572584062814713,
-0.45560526847839355,
-0.16795656085014343,
0.45482540130615234,
0.7734981775283813,
-0.13210120797157288,
-0.6096022129058838,
0.5094203352928162,
-0.17141062021255493,
-0.23445294797420502,
-0.05193118751049042,
0.2698482871055603,
-0.33398452401161194,
0.44741523265838623,
0.15842211246490479,
0.30655813217163086,
0.05015552043914795,
-0.15399110317230225,
0.10250046849250793,
0.29757359623908997,
-0.8803611993789673,
-0.08221986889839172,
0.5215293169021606,
0.34012314677238464,
-0.12729276716709137,
0.39894357323646545,
-0.011022095568478107,
-0.7669369578361511,
0.6875827312469482,
0.5142133831977844,
0.7046330571174622,
0.1287723183631897,
0.005950618535280228,
0.3880252242088318,
0.4713148772716522,
-0.23789666593074799,
0.3264100253582001,
-0.11329072713851929,
-0.6773747205734253,
-0.29806649684906006,
-0.07502982765436172,
-0.37107616662979126,
0.09307683259248734,
-0.5707601308822632,
0.20413413643836975,
-0.5164454579353333,
-0.12118882685899734,
-0.46022647619247437,
-0.14411047101020813,
-0.745224118232727,
0.5966309309005737,
0.35588786005973816,
1.04124915599823,
-0.7426806092262268,
0.4767564535140991,
1.2841953039169312,
-0.2890569865703583,
-0.5301599502563477,
0.21142283082008362,
-0.0763440951704979,
-0.6402217149734497,
0.5372529625892639,
0.184354767203331,
-0.26402515172958374,
-0.37114831805229187,
-0.7547194957733154,
-0.6274064779281616,
1.0995787382125854,
0.1702658236026764,
-0.5526585578918457,
0.13082489371299744,
-0.21963243186473846,
0.6505848169326782,
-0.43689069151878357,
0.002278711413964629,
0.3111232817173004,
0.3269312381744385,
0.10493981093168259,
-0.5860393047332764,
0.02955249324440956,
-0.22371259331703186,
0.15105168521404266,
0.13269644975662231,
-0.7557345032691956,
0.5498438477516174,
-0.2658175230026245,
-0.3623591959476471,
0.09861738234758377,
0.5723577737808228,
0.41247767210006714,
0.3611892759799957,
0.6227161288261414,
0.5170117616653442,
0.8110590577125549,
-0.49237576127052307,
1.0998361110687256,
-0.38709479570388794,
0.08224526792764664,
1.0007963180541992,
-0.09917252510786057,
0.46239230036735535,
0.5521920919418335,
0.40443599224090576,
0.43440374732017517,
0.5255053043365479,
-0.049110297113657,
0.8932111859321594,
0.08977010101079941,
-0.22987675666809082,
-0.607958972454071,
-0.3607979416847229,
-0.3177124261856079,
0.14991579949855804,
0.24341899156570435,
-0.3479507267475128,
-0.3824702799320221,
-0.13101617991924286,
-0.41171541810035706,
0.391750305891037,
-0.4880940914154053,
0.5745627880096436,
0.15548457205295563,
-0.802685558795929,
0.3878295421600342,
0.03444438427686691,
0.5594192147254944,
-0.6369350552558899,
-0.4153396189212799,
-0.6641222238540649,
0.305080384016037,
-0.23865389823913574,
-0.5768446326255798,
0.03266308084130287,
0.01917126402258873,
-0.27185752987861633,
-0.25010597705841064,
0.8625107407569885,
-0.6001573801040649,
-0.10160284489393234,
0.3180737793445587,
0.4944790303707123,
-0.11521919071674347,
0.014246568083763123,
-0.8135408759117126,
-0.12643647193908691,
0.2731858193874359,
0.03529101237654686,
0.12283206731081009,
0.5509901642799377,
-0.3557194173336029,
0.7972882390022278,
0.5706728100776672,
0.20493671298027039,
-0.0006103886407800019,
0.15817013382911682,
0.8608267903327942,
-0.944960355758667,
-0.5798754096031189,
-0.5252695083618164,
0.5990766882896423,
-0.10357306152582169,
-0.34990429878234863,
0.6449338793754578,
0.30026134848594666,
0.9730708003044128,
-0.0068253567442297935,
0.657474160194397,
0.03928627818822861,
0.013778132386505604,
-1.0301109552383423,
0.3281552493572235,
-0.6115756630897522,
0.28955352306365967,
-0.05236480385065079,
-1.0186268091201782,
-0.7387233376502991,
0.9173755645751953,
-0.5351361632347107,
0.07107894867658615,
0.8257128596305847,
0.9202854633331299,
-0.10086443275213242,
-0.40666133165359497,
0.5510894060134888,
-0.21773789823055267,
0.4564197361469269,
0.30539271235466003,
0.8802000880241394,
-0.16406750679016113,
0.5896120667457581,
-0.50418621301651,
-0.29033589363098145,
0.17787128686904907,
-0.8154632449150085,
-1.2087229490280151,
-0.3556170165538788,
-0.4178852438926697,
-0.41336435079574585,
0.17348653078079224,
0.7222684621810913,
1.0463542938232422,
-0.6874015927314758,
-0.06263227015733719,
-0.20905397832393646,
0.006156253162771463,
-0.2742649018764496,
-0.22976285219192505,
0.2489936351776123,
-0.34860631823539734,
-0.48893851041793823,
0.5325027704238892,
0.3501445949077606,
0.30846625566482544,
0.08352790772914886,
-0.060172341763973236,
0.3389902114868164,
-0.2140270322561264,
0.5765066146850586,
0.15682893991470337,
-1.059126377105713,
-0.3447684943675995,
-0.05509746074676514,
-0.029697362333536148,
0.31204938888549805,
1.0206009149551392,
-0.7208124399185181,
0.49167391657829285,
0.3146451413631439,
0.44139420986175537,
0.26485052704811096,
0.5648757815361023,
0.5396921038627625,
-0.8254891037940979,
0.40747204422950745,
0.05835984647274017,
0.6396278142929077,
0.6391301155090332,
-0.2400655597448349,
0.7013003826141357,
0.433327853679657,
-0.3915371000766754,
-0.33668839931488037,
0.4120815694332123,
-1.0300359725952148,
-0.1548675298690796,
1.1995047330856323,
-0.22954264283180237,
-0.39039191603660583,
0.052304401993751526,
-0.7154576182365417,
-0.038148511201143265,
-0.48544976115226746,
0.6783338785171509,
0.638577938079834,
-0.15779677033424377,
-0.621555507183075,
-0.2579416334629059,
0.6289640069007874,
0.5722478032112122,
-0.8450688719749451,
0.17912328243255615,
0.8873163461685181,
0.24135597050189972,
0.10943944752216339,
0.5835360288619995,
-0.03803712874650955,
0.43225184082984924,
0.04617898166179657,
0.2774457037448883,
0.013325733132660389,
-0.6381464600563049,
-0.7808437943458557,
-0.007783462293446064,
0.16076357662677765,
-0.15544770658016205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02285v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02285v1
|
Detection of Non-recorded Word Senses in English and Swedish
| 2024-03-04T18:15:14 | 2024-03-04T18:15:14 |
Jonathan Lautenschlager, Emma Sköldberg, Simon Hengchen, Dominik Schlechtweg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study addresses the task of Unknown Sense Detection in English and
Swedish. The primary objective of this task is to determine whether the meaning
of a particular word usage is documented in a dictionary or not. For this
purpose, sense entries are compared with word usages from modern and historical
corpora using a pre-trained Word-in-Context embedder that allows us to model
this task in a few-shot scenario. Additionally, we use human annotations to
adapt and evaluate our models. Compared to a random sample from a corpus, our
model is able to considerably increase the detected number of word usages with
non-recorded senses.
|
[
-0.5704377889633179,
-0.3535618782043457,
0.7087494134902954,
-0.22976695001125336,
-0.533684253692627,
-0.5586154460906982,
-0.11388850212097168,
-0.7562636137008667,
0.34340763092041016,
0.12141108512878418,
-0.3852936923503876,
-0.6234769821166992,
-0.6662778258323669,
0.4182312488555908,
-0.3760630786418915,
0.38979285955429077,
-0.26847556233406067,
0.3059031665325165,
-0.5465114116668701,
-0.4942588806152344,
-0.6442312598228455,
-0.690401554107666,
-0.1889832764863968,
-0.2207803577184677,
0.3300175368785858,
0.2831760048866272,
0.10836561769247055,
0.271511048078537,
0.297423392534256,
0.24248945713043213,
-0.09085161238908768,
0.22686775028705597,
-0.14712612330913544,
0.053726110607385635,
-0.2112129032611847,
-0.7003164887428284,
0.00549275940284133,
0.09978538751602173,
0.5068613290786743,
0.6970838308334351,
0.21038728952407837,
0.09798707813024521,
-0.04135924205183983,
0.06946402043104172,
-0.8072768449783325,
0.012766849249601364,
-0.6528694033622742,
0.09004519134759903,
-0.1975180059671402,
-0.39082059264183044,
-0.20065315067768097,
0.17603760957717896,
0.014246468432247639,
-0.696743905544281,
0.4696221649646759,
0.2081581950187683,
0.9027726054191589,
0.09792625159025192,
-0.3912571370601654,
-0.45490920543670654,
-0.4240972101688385,
0.8339153528213501,
-0.47960013151168823,
0.9094620943069458,
0.9381048679351807,
-0.049016717821359634,
-0.11430341750383377,
-0.5066729784011841,
-0.9517773985862732,
-0.22110223770141602,
-0.20996934175491333,
0.1904807686805725,
-0.25258108973503113,
0.1106407418847084,
0.271881639957428,
0.0653086006641388,
-0.5744863152503967,
0.10318722575902939,
-0.30478113889694214,
-0.2904934287071228,
0.5151849389076233,
0.08076368272304535,
0.3109646439552307,
-0.4096650183200836,
-0.3795541524887085,
-0.03866614028811455,
-0.5206558704376221,
-0.1493958979845047,
0.2799523174762726,
0.2532789409160614,
-0.26379382610321045,
0.808956503868103,
0.1244182288646698,
1.0177814960479736,
-0.22461029887199402,
-0.19976623356342316,
0.3268451690673828,
-0.4260624945163727,
-0.24159735441207886,
-0.026400620117783546,
0.15018196403980255,
0.5316706895828247,
0.22455774247646332,
-0.09731098264455795,
-0.7480341196060181,
0.46059685945510864,
0.05339241027832031,
-0.25834402441978455,
-0.14854229986667633,
0.009181748144328594,
-0.46534547209739685,
-0.21625107526779175,
-0.03214378282427788,
-0.2603108584880829,
-0.40119096636772156,
-0.4346168041229248,
0.7203563451766968,
-0.5842810869216919,
-0.49874985218048096,
-0.011637398973107338,
-0.9373151659965515,
0.18585504591464996,
0.0717826783657074,
-0.6880501508712769,
0.09376492351293564,
0.48876136541366577,
0.874309241771698,
-0.11204367130994797,
-0.2525073289871216,
-0.2454000860452652,
-0.15024185180664062,
-0.553389847278595,
1.1332790851593018,
-0.38574934005737305,
-0.821559727191925,
0.20700877904891968,
0.2715422213077545,
-0.033370375633239746,
-0.5807211995124817,
0.5272485613822937,
-0.3240519165992737,
0.5549793243408203,
-0.4352470934391022,
-1.0276175737380981,
-0.3944205641746521,
0.46189209818840027,
-0.37270236015319824,
1.004309892654419,
0.409086138010025,
-0.8161754608154297,
1.002389669418335,
-0.68491131067276,
-0.27463826537132263,
0.48723334074020386,
-0.286414235830307,
0.21259109675884247,
0.6460217833518982,
-0.05544351786375046,
0.33859503269195557,
0.27032825350761414,
0.04873732477426529,
-0.045026250183582306,
-0.6725047826766968,
0.11637585610151291,
-0.29479074478149414,
0.6979580521583557,
0.047691505402326584,
0.1512008160352707,
-0.09466845542192459,
-0.7168465256690979,
-0.10211187601089478,
0.07854567468166351,
-0.45718491077423096,
-1.1772340536117554,
0.01858171634376049,
0.2957286834716797,
0.1422969251871109,
0.3515639305114746,
-0.9220635890960693,
-0.008587599731981754,
-0.7163628339767456,
0.08749063313007355,
0.4297214150428772,
0.3062691390514374,
0.31914299726486206,
-0.32570379972457886,
0.5971989035606384,
0.21141301095485687,
-0.0767335519194603,
-0.2681773006916046,
-0.5021036863327026,
-0.6245304942131042,
-0.2683439254760742,
0.4819297194480896,
0.4634568691253662,
-0.8870120644569397,
0.4284895360469818,
0.015418746508657932,
-0.22894279658794403,
-0.3839222490787506,
0.033021774142980576,
0.27115535736083984,
0.41459476947784424,
0.27772027254104614,
-0.04207291826605797,
-0.8467333912849426,
-0.751224935054779,
-0.6056651473045349,
-0.294715940952301,
-0.28602832555770874,
0.36174243688583374,
0.7789648175239563,
-0.09011972695589066,
1.0111289024353027,
-0.2823542058467865,
-0.6152406334877014,
0.0376075841486454,
0.2823653817176819,
0.18294553458690643,
0.17242677509784698,
0.7506605386734009,
-0.8510434031486511,
-0.0920465961098671,
-0.24908769130706787,
-1.02446711063385,
-0.13489879667758942,
0.19835269451141357,
0.42808493971824646,
0.5540816783905029,
0.6851224899291992,
-0.28346124291419983,
0.4952225983142853,
0.7032266855239868,
-0.5420718193054199,
0.2935478985309601,
-0.4328382909297943,
-0.06371397525072098,
-1.0226547718048096,
0.1588401049375534,
-0.16241058707237244,
-0.05818045884370804,
-0.6046815514564514,
-0.1403215378522873,
0.39632079005241394,
-0.11282496154308319,
-0.9046590924263,
0.9225888252258301,
-0.7448086142539978,
0.03015139140188694,
-0.5041841864585876,
0.3342077434062958,
0.07897688448429108,
0.20409008860588074,
0.42903342843055725,
0.7748133540153503,
0.45651310682296753,
-0.8703453540802002,
0.11261284351348877,
0.24347539246082306,
-0.8140905499458313,
1.013616681098938,
-0.40251031517982483,
0.27770212292671204,
-0.510476291179657,
-0.3629230260848999,
-1.2809944152832031,
-0.14748501777648926,
0.11580368876457214,
-0.8896998763084412,
0.0847577303647995,
-0.12629123032093048,
-0.5149295330047607,
-0.46321937441825867,
-0.17307761311531067,
0.15790924429893494,
0.15705819427967072,
-0.5987052321434021,
0.544475793838501,
0.4818785786628723,
0.525784969329834,
-0.3124083876609802,
-0.8522905111312866,
-0.06975085288286209,
-0.2765347957611084,
-0.3284814953804016,
0.08564310520887375,
0.20735426247119904,
-0.5233625173568726,
0.2170589119195938,
-0.19474418461322784,
-0.17637573182582855,
0.22416655719280243,
0.38488200306892395,
0.28332582116127014,
-0.16738516092300415,
0.6240881085395813,
0.009497101418673992,
0.02174283005297184,
-0.024426927790045738,
-0.3329656422138214,
0.3950919806957245,
0.38988953828811646,
-0.39848804473876953,
-0.15154531598091125,
0.7721021175384521,
0.4112902879714966,
-0.23405031859874725,
0.7259363532066345,
0.3127696216106415,
-0.9223194122314453,
-0.11510728299617767,
-0.5400635600090027,
-0.27478843927383423,
-0.43869930505752563,
0.11724457144737244,
-0.705730140209198,
-0.7090051174163818,
0.43059661984443665,
-0.010494289919734001,
-0.12017287313938141,
0.36023443937301636,
0.10982418060302734,
-0.47265249490737915,
0.8891291618347168,
0.6836813688278198,
0.11983417719602585,
0.340103417634964,
-0.10981746762990952,
0.337331086397171,
-0.7696607708930969,
-0.07233480364084244,
-0.5152203440666199,
-0.3215973675251007,
-0.41209661960601807,
-0.25290611386299133,
0.49743372201919556,
0.29244327545166016,
0.3306882679462433,
0.39883267879486084,
-0.39984798431396484,
0.33932119607925415,
0.5962098240852356,
-0.16164810955524445,
0.16536302864551544,
-0.2969345450401306,
-0.4880036413669586,
0.028999248519539833,
-0.6795112490653992,
-0.4523039758205414,
0.9807878136634827,
0.0903540700674057,
0.24099941551685333,
0.03709624707698822,
0.8527529835700989,
0.371823251247406,
0.0036225239746272564,
-1.3736355304718018,
0.45375511050224304,
0.03514547646045685,
-0.844048798084259,
-0.25156912207603455,
0.1552356332540512,
-1.1680678129196167,
0.33587419986724854,
-0.3832554221153259,
-0.5750015377998352,
0.6667972207069397,
0.18823818862438202,
-0.22486694157123566,
0.14313939213752747,
-0.8933057188987732,
0.7122617363929749,
-0.10728510469198227,
0.14774928987026215,
0.056853361427783966,
-0.17825433611869812,
0.12547388672828674,
-0.15003947913646698,
0.27549657225608826,
-0.07117484509944916,
-0.2941451668739319,
0.9845609068870544,
-0.17350439727306366,
0.7806629538536072,
-0.7701584696769714,
-0.11155969649553299,
0.35204607248306274,
0.11699852347373962,
0.5379472374916077,
-0.30328524112701416,
0.01348006259649992,
0.46935099363327026,
0.5379650592803955,
-0.04331435635685921,
-0.1587139517068863,
0.4740496873855591,
-0.2794300615787506,
-0.38364192843437195,
-0.6800498366355896,
-0.3609958291053772,
-0.23237957060337067,
0.4255921542644501,
0.77838134765625,
0.1518813967704773,
-0.6648983955383301,
-0.018578404560685158,
0.3797166645526886,
-0.22229719161987305,
0.5509710311889648,
1.044433832168579,
-0.14713993668556213,
0.1766418218612671,
0.47358736395835876,
0.5058789253234863,
-0.2361215204000473,
0.28019946813583374,
0.25699156522750854,
-0.7827536463737488,
-0.6471561193466187,
-0.23560728132724762,
0.17323365807533264,
-0.8171868920326233,
-0.21116748452186584,
-0.5780108571052551,
0.21019011735916138,
-0.46519702672958374,
-0.20734013617038727,
0.0411858931183815,
0.020944830030202866,
-0.36390286684036255,
-0.2356269210577011,
0.6380215287208557,
0.5865941047668457,
-0.3337242007255554,
0.1804097294807434,
-0.6932343244552612,
0.4511907994747162,
0.06556840240955353,
0.4012027084827423,
-0.34238943457603455,
-0.5468882918357849,
-0.15418581664562225,
-0.014780843630433083,
0.31885242462158203,
-1.02961003780365,
0.5832090973854065,
0.12393579632043839,
0.5858125686645508,
0.6626880168914795,
0.1496090292930603,
0.48356086015701294,
-0.33225372433662415,
0.8248075842857361,
-0.04850814864039421,
-0.9442461133003235,
0.6627619862556458,
-0.3447911739349365,
0.41094133257865906,
0.5401079058647156,
0.5067182183265686,
-0.8727332949638367,
-0.27650365233421326,
-0.5925127863883972,
-0.6674742102622986,
0.5255258679389954,
-0.3855465352535248,
0.24194422364234924,
-0.5401184558868408,
0.041137855499982834,
-0.04687823727726936,
0.10134539753198624,
-0.09664174169301987,
0.08572859317064285,
0.04668789729475975,
0.013045643456280231,
-0.3528788089752197,
-0.40425819158554077,
-0.15073801577091217,
-0.37593874335289,
0.22066667675971985,
-0.018702927976846695,
0.48315054178237915,
0.33058735728263855,
-0.5075022578239441,
-0.03173989802598953,
0.06503552198410034,
0.7373603582382202,
0.7713469862937927,
-0.19201332330703735,
0.33415237069129944,
0.5579829812049866,
-0.6113221645355225,
0.025508277118206024,
-0.2740820348262787,
-0.06354907155036926,
0.6301990151405334,
0.5020467638969421,
0.7005646824836731,
0.36456727981567383,
-0.7878000736236572,
0.9272738099098206,
0.058108072727918625,
-0.54461270570755,
-1.0416498184204102,
-0.19530829787254333,
0.04025614261627197,
-0.0017644150648266077,
0.24389199912548065,
-0.04377419501543045,
0.08946488052606583,
-0.4376247823238373,
0.3074478507041931,
0.5537638664245605,
-0.3427784740924835,
-0.2528848648071289,
0.44017061591148376,
0.0559297576546669,
-0.415268212556839,
0.44129160046577454,
-0.5307621359825134,
-0.5579453706741333,
0.3555227220058441,
0.794252336025238,
0.5419410467147827,
-0.25187942385673523,
-0.2191857546567917,
0.3838292062282562,
0.30967485904693604,
-0.04214683920145035,
1.0440596342086792,
-0.20566141605377197,
-1.39677095413208,
-0.05508369579911232,
-0.48439595103263855,
-0.12000231444835663,
0.331871896982193,
-0.7793775200843811,
0.5649019479751587,
-0.19399483501911163,
-0.1205182671546936,
0.09456026554107666,
-0.250284343957901,
-0.9868703484535217,
0.31949999928474426,
0.21063654124736786,
1.039494276046753,
-1.341176152229309,
1.0208475589752197,
0.9136529564857483,
-0.16957391798496246,
-0.6782544851303101,
-0.1123114675283432,
0.12941963970661163,
-1.0883469581604004,
0.6020478010177612,
0.021213112398982048,
-0.1856960654258728,
0.042161181569099426,
-0.438677579164505,
-0.601223349571228,
0.7307634949684143,
-0.05690300092101097,
-0.6231017112731934,
0.36711037158966064,
-0.20742285251617432,
0.6020801067352295,
0.11116689443588257,
-0.056967467069625854,
0.6113172173500061,
0.8418445587158203,
-0.18198183178901672,
-0.8660987615585327,
-0.2857089340686798,
-0.22369889914989471,
-0.008730745874345303,
0.6435548663139343,
0.12132268399000168,
0.7540291547775269,
0.12488561123609543,
-0.6947596669197083,
-0.2209061235189438,
0.4353022575378418,
0.046761687844991684,
0.566586434841156,
0.7314819097518921,
0.6974259614944458,
0.9931968450546265,
0.057895734906196594,
1.059733510017395,
-0.2717834711074829,
-0.06652636080980301,
0.9884936809539795,
-0.3562092185020447,
0.9428560733795166,
0.8418251276016235,
-0.13713163137435913,
0.04482349008321762,
0.6832374334335327,
-0.16952286660671234,
0.5404869318008423,
0.16343404352664948,
-0.687227189540863,
-0.03344966843724251,
-0.4303990304470062,
-0.3575316071510315,
1.0797218084335327,
0.6105031371116638,
-0.473601758480072,
-0.08212350308895111,
0.5250813961029053,
-0.027297059074044228,
0.05562552809715271,
-0.3967951238155365,
0.9389256238937378,
0.08415199816226959,
-0.7364535927772522,
0.8155992031097412,
0.11360247433185577,
1.0755829811096191,
-0.5280442237854004,
-0.021662255749106407,
-0.24156256020069122,
0.025020333006978035,
-0.13332806527614594,
-0.6776716709136963,
0.6113807559013367,
0.09342899918556213,
-0.07409930974245071,
0.04267682135105133,
1.0489671230316162,
-0.41667380928993225,
-0.37416890263557434,
0.4606521427631378,
0.8349987864494324,
0.6685139536857605,
-0.3721427023410797,
-0.010176846757531166,
-0.23259109258651733,
-0.3494831621646881,
0.048250358551740646,
0.18486464023590088,
0.5594073534011841,
-0.32190385460853577,
-0.06701938807964325,
0.5236116051673889,
0.19628317654132843,
0.0504782609641552,
0.15195180475711823,
0.37529340386390686,
-0.6497180461883545,
-0.4950430989265442,
-0.4890914261341095,
0.09951160848140717,
0.17461729049682617,
-0.5439907908439636,
0.9524056911468506,
0.5531901121139526,
1.2093946933746338,
-0.37022051215171814,
0.9196319580078125,
-0.06789923459291458,
0.784019947052002,
-0.312384694814682,
0.664334237575531,
-0.6905216574668884,
-0.2636858820915222,
0.06327328085899353,
-0.7082031965255737,
-0.35616034269332886,
0.7909506559371948,
-0.21585915982723236,
-0.3760099411010742,
0.7915846705436707,
0.7863048911094666,
-0.07967224717140198,
0.059211622923612595,
0.8505552411079407,
-0.04853840917348862,
-0.36675772070884705,
0.29912421107292175,
0.9406951069831848,
-0.1679353564977646,
0.04949500039219856,
-0.0974772572517395,
-0.1116090714931488,
-0.006464799400418997,
-0.9774595499038696,
-0.8264515399932861,
-0.9567492008209229,
0.10970180481672287,
0.049025293439626694,
-0.03971489518880844,
0.7904001474380493,
0.5049528479576111,
-0.95074063539505,
-0.07831677049398422,
0.038064680993556976,
-0.14560313522815704,
-0.3550558388233185,
-0.17459505796432495,
0.24466441571712494,
-0.19663739204406738,
-0.6649385690689087,
0.9515568017959595,
-0.07558362185955048,
0.3286914527416229,
-0.16091108322143555,
0.21495521068572998,
-0.35677585005760193,
0.11508302390575409,
0.7966801524162292,
0.29364511370658875,
-0.5283963084220886,
-0.6649076342582703,
0.06796794384717941,
0.2554415464401245,
-0.10673745721578598,
0.6949235796928406,
-0.8398343324661255,
0.6330312490463257,
0.9496812224388123,
0.225777268409729,
0.397765189409256,
-0.14589516818523407,
0.34236690402030945,
-1.1860264539718628,
0.5907222032546997,
0.34600603580474854,
0.5409478545188904,
0.21554970741271973,
-0.3201095759868622,
0.3854096531867981,
0.5183778405189514,
0.0735240951180458,
-1.0006412267684937,
-0.015382124111056328,
-0.6250416040420532,
-0.4843055307865143,
1.0810133218765259,
-0.1615266054868698,
-0.15288110077381134,
-0.7516193389892578,
-0.014107072725892067,
0.24701561033725739,
-0.12208906561136246,
0.4631460905075073,
1.0700026750564575,
-0.19312797486782074,
-0.058891698718070984,
-0.6668544411659241,
0.4297065734863281,
0.19813524186611176,
-0.19397403299808502,
-0.39486080408096313,
0.40662699937820435,
0.3158586025238037,
0.16516242921352386,
0.8073014616966248,
-0.05146018788218498,
0.1570921689271927,
0.2703673839569092,
0.21446190774440765,
-0.17944209277629852,
-0.3105011582374573,
-0.5860300660133362,
0.09854990988969803,
0.13826780021190643,
-0.9325695037841797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02281v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02281v1
|
Emotion Granularity from Text: An Aggregate-Level Indicator of Mental Health
| 2024-03-04T18:12:10 | 2024-03-04T18:12:10 |
Krishnapriya Vishnubhotla, Daniela Teodorescu, Mallory J. Feldman, Kristen A. Lindquist, Saif M. Mohammad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We are united in how emotions are central to shaping our experiences; and
yet, individuals differ greatly in how we each identify, categorize, and
express emotions. In psychology, variation in the ability of individuals to
differentiate between emotion concepts is called emotion granularity
(determined through self-reports of one's emotions). High emotion granularity
has been linked with better mental and physical health; whereas low emotion
granularity has been linked with maladaptive emotion regulation strategies and
poor health outcomes. In this work, we propose computational measures of
emotion granularity derived from temporally-ordered speaker utterances in
social media (in lieu of self-reports that suffer from various biases). We then
investigate the effectiveness of such text-derived measures of emotion
granularity in functioning as markers of various mental health conditions
(MHCs). We establish baseline measures of emotion granularity derived from
textual utterances, and show that, at an aggregate level, emotion granularities
are significantly lower for people self-reporting as having an MHC than for the
control population. This paves the way towards a better understanding of the
MHCs, and specifically the role emotions play in our well-being.
|
[
-0.3967629373073578,
-1.2004611492156982,
0.7529904246330261,
0.3052668869495392,
-0.035711243748664856,
0.01634036749601364,
-0.09750967472791672,
-0.5852463245391846,
0.7649092078208923,
-0.11864724010229111,
-0.6205215454101562,
-0.5800533294677734,
-0.790729820728302,
0.09609445184469223,
-0.3783724308013916,
1.3272534608840942,
0.20597109198570251,
-0.16286709904670715,
-0.2488337606191635,
0.16906435787677765,
-0.12661105394363403,
-0.79560786485672,
-0.47812211513519287,
-0.504310667514801,
0.9450302124023438,
0.1663074642419815,
0.7336970567703247,
0.21624861657619476,
0.5793379545211792,
0.2927331328392029,
-0.23936180770397186,
-0.14947602152824402,
-0.5946805477142334,
-0.20286913216114044,
-0.1429489552974701,
0.07947959005832672,
-0.8364183306694031,
0.16177380084991455,
0.20905105769634247,
0.47373807430267334,
-0.30001479387283325,
0.23235203325748444,
-0.12252873927354813,
0.9514376521110535,
-0.7696435451507568,
0.024633176624774933,
-0.203580841422081,
0.4680907726287842,
-0.20716410875320435,
-0.5290665030479431,
0.10412759333848953,
-0.08232748508453369,
-0.057704608887434006,
-0.34750714898109436,
-0.23235274851322174,
-0.21618372201919556,
0.6649085879325867,
0.1927000880241394,
-0.7421262860298157,
-0.5204670429229736,
-0.6879901885986328,
0.4806881248950958,
-0.4770803153514862,
0.05795665457844734,
0.7479782104492188,
-0.01664411462843418,
0.23484842479228973,
-0.3726753294467926,
-0.3553217947483063,
0.09073197841644287,
-0.30249273777008057,
0.44772613048553467,
-0.4899114668369293,
0.154652401804924,
0.24937710165977478,
0.523877739906311,
-0.4803348183631897,
-0.44018808007240295,
-0.27191808819770813,
-0.28088194131851196,
0.7066183090209961,
0.47751370072364807,
0.5418452620506287,
-0.33292022347450256,
0.15726788341999054,
0.2687602937221527,
0.19042277336120605,
0.14910700917243958,
0.1368255466222763,
0.1210758164525032,
-0.48287147283554077,
0.43309569358825684,
-0.32280707359313965,
0.0821240246295929,
0.46044453978538513,
-0.6657439470291138,
0.414186954498291,
-0.2646212875843048,
-0.0719154104590416,
0.050843093544244766,
0.78152996301651,
0.408793181180954,
0.0975605919957161,
-0.2290707528591156,
-0.01581832766532898,
0.1405264139175415,
0.5698928833007812,
-0.9870774745941162,
-0.05585566908121109,
0.46878424286842346,
-0.834529459476471,
-0.20672699809074402,
-0.044280461966991425,
-0.9964647889137268,
-0.38557538390159607,
-0.26923295855522156,
0.2922767996788025,
-0.6932838559150696,
-0.21175506711006165,
-0.2138790786266327,
0.07821090519428253,
-0.2937878370285034,
0.03830835968255997,
-1.1264551877975464,
0.5843555927276611,
0.6424264907836914,
0.9526582360267639,
-0.10426057875156403,
-0.2507266402244568,
-0.33332887291908264,
-0.09542261809110641,
-0.384354829788208,
0.8618756532669067,
-0.6503458023071289,
-0.5843502283096313,
0.06314472109079361,
-0.25981318950653076,
-0.13791772723197937,
-0.32022836804389954,
0.7429828643798828,
0.06835822761058807,
0.005797935649752617,
-0.4724859595298767,
-0.369247168302536,
0.14417316019535065,
0.1266687959432602,
-0.2783336341381073,
1.0665174722671509,
0.4177968204021454,
-0.9804429411888123,
0.2747874855995178,
-0.42888450622558594,
-0.6120944023132324,
0.0868154838681221,
-0.21143010258674622,
-0.12905631959438324,
0.4115065634250641,
-0.10692036151885986,
0.45732080936431885,
0.014317772351205349,
0.12477317452430725,
-0.44269314408302307,
-0.2979266047477722,
0.42463070154190063,
-0.2846139669418335,
-0.06959214061498642,
0.31347835063934326,
-0.1739652305841446,
-0.06515398621559143,
-0.5117543339729309,
0.17212258279323578,
-0.3024749457836151,
-0.33888304233551025,
-0.6129997968673706,
0.2821066379547119,
0.05641520395874977,
0.5262067317962646,
0.3462614417076111,
-0.22488966584205627,
-0.1963040977716446,
-0.07319179177284241,
0.17719660699367523,
0.6206854581832886,
0.302180677652359,
0.38827115297317505,
-0.456045001745224,
0.4390288293361664,
0.06589357554912567,
0.20721521973609924,
0.066998690366745,
-0.33809804916381836,
0.020629102364182472,
-0.5895439386367798,
-0.13861370086669922,
0.5583208799362183,
-0.205536887049675,
0.7386359572410583,
-0.354238361120224,
-0.5025081038475037,
-0.40731483697891235,
-0.10665231198072433,
0.35617804527282715,
0.40636834502220154,
0.30631256103515625,
-0.16530533134937286,
-0.018593620508909225,
-0.7266139984130859,
-0.4406859278678894,
-0.2594550848007202,
-0.014859423041343689,
0.7395924925804138,
0.4209743142127991,
-0.6458621025085449,
0.8523094654083252,
-0.44466525316238403,
-0.08221607655286789,
0.18327397108078003,
0.6674185395240784,
-0.2817937731742859,
0.06156248599290848,
0.4389766752719879,
-0.6233268976211548,
-0.21994535624980927,
0.27209722995758057,
-0.7950865030288696,
-0.599126935005188,
0.002260827925056219,
-0.2726694643497467,
-0.0175948403775692,
0.27680641412734985,
-0.41269057989120483,
0.41004127264022827,
0.6221832036972046,
-0.7706746459007263,
0.7122499942779541,
-0.27509763836860657,
0.4645129144191742,
-0.774364709854126,
-0.035870909690856934,
0.07781174033880234,
-0.03113691136240959,
-0.6320622563362122,
-0.469788134098053,
-0.030404889956116676,
0.012642299756407738,
-0.2987428605556488,
0.3705659508705139,
-0.1825217753648758,
0.11812766641378403,
-0.187595397233963,
0.0991896316409111,
0.011708365753293037,
0.15892086923122406,
-0.38958320021629333,
0.6519783139228821,
0.38800954818725586,
-0.4493073523044586,
-0.09002333879470825,
0.0900341272354126,
0.07428380846977234,
1.1947416067123413,
-0.3850056827068329,
0.06326772272586823,
-0.3873556852340698,
0.262702077627182,
-0.5201628804206848,
-0.5474610924720764,
-0.08285291492938995,
-0.47623714804649353,
0.09546373039484024,
0.4057984948158264,
-0.2560361325740814,
-0.25686371326446533,
-0.16817636787891388,
0.46659719944000244,
0.5274760723114014,
0.19477438926696777,
0.77583247423172,
0.7001335024833679,
-0.46800023317337036,
-0.21406537294387817,
-0.7212280631065369,
0.21009671688079834,
-0.3865465521812439,
-0.5782762765884399,
0.5352903008460999,
-0.42106208205223083,
-0.6024688482284546,
-0.07347840815782547,
-0.16868561506271362,
-0.2915789484977722,
-0.08753280341625214,
0.5552632808685303,
-0.28342127799987793,
0.2530563473701477,
0.7148760557174683,
0.2440866380929947,
0.033655647188425064,
0.35023370385169983,
0.1729603409767151,
0.5966184735298157,
-0.23859356343746185,
-0.1510356366634369,
-0.45376333594322205,
0.8265138864517212,
0.5008233785629272,
0.1279296875,
0.588268518447876,
0.7140501141548157,
-0.5423093438148499,
0.12018980830907822,
-0.3953774571418762,
0.04721827059984207,
-0.40777841210365295,
0.31381964683532715,
-0.32025378942489624,
-0.800699770450592,
0.6624639630317688,
-0.01755049265921116,
-0.5718801021575928,
0.5113465785980225,
0.7236801981925964,
-0.4131562113761902,
1.0939171314239502,
0.3449985682964325,
-0.292971134185791,
0.6204214692115784,
0.07887697964906693,
0.3466506898403168,
-0.5158205628395081,
-0.04340789094567299,
-0.4796423614025116,
-0.3166775703430176,
-0.7223161458969116,
-0.26743337512016296,
0.3488994836807251,
-0.13986575603485107,
-0.15054312348365784,
-0.46386364102363586,
-0.30305594205856323,
0.2527317404747009,
-0.1994999200105667,
0.40798836946487427,
0.08096729964017868,
-0.04840048775076866,
0.1988672912120819,
-0.3582342863082886,
-0.32547181844711304,
-0.6506313681602478,
0.35990989208221436,
0.4051797688007355,
0.6938648819923401,
-0.0052496884018182755,
0.8553568124771118,
0.831900954246521,
0.16664788126945496,
-0.9870955348014832,
0.4171571135520935,
-0.28917020559310913,
-0.4611401855945587,
-0.30453768372535706,
-0.8681319952011108,
-0.9333600997924805,
-0.05366959050297737,
-0.39156031608581543,
-1.2841745615005493,
0.09031467884778976,
0.020165536552667618,
-0.3114531338214874,
-0.05362457409501076,
-0.5009143352508545,
0.7350137233734131,
-0.3029176592826843,
-0.1171669289469719,
-0.260976105928421,
-0.47822049260139465,
0.16639745235443115,
-0.3859255909919739,
0.6973753571510315,
-0.5940990447998047,
0.07395816594362259,
0.8651978969573975,
-0.48249176144599915,
0.7127090692520142,
0.20897525548934937,
-0.04038999602198601,
0.20519405603408813,
0.052463602274656296,
0.11984333395957947,
0.19469186663627625,
0.004435207229107618,
0.3087805509567261,
0.3200443387031555,
-0.5452388525009155,
-0.7798596620559692,
0.6385640501976013,
-1.029571533203125,
-0.20062102377414703,
-0.356193482875824,
-0.6644278168678284,
0.013447282835841179,
0.2365148812532425,
0.26845648884773254,
0.5653644800186157,
-0.5045027732849121,
-0.09422475099563599,
0.5332804918289185,
0.04631078615784645,
0.49378329515457153,
0.3834199905395508,
-0.08582746982574463,
-0.6211241483688354,
0.9663787484169006,
0.3210923671722412,
0.25572872161865234,
0.4219723641872406,
0.6370037198066711,
0.08431021124124527,
-0.18294377624988556,
0.33265921473503113,
0.23823921382427216,
-0.5537419319152832,
0.032543692737817764,
-0.8526596426963806,
-0.008537312038242817,
-0.577534556388855,
-0.3176163136959076,
-0.2728407680988312,
-0.13926972448825836,
-0.2568718194961548,
-0.08917942643165588,
0.15055838227272034,
0.778538167476654,
-0.2051127851009369,
0.3104661703109741,
-0.9526998996734619,
0.3105669915676117,
0.6809714436531067,
0.39564499258995056,
-0.07409288734197617,
-0.31812584400177,
-0.2902980148792267,
0.11875956505537033,
-0.40301477909088135,
-0.9653757810592651,
0.5539953708648682,
0.3782404363155365,
0.25715920329093933,
0.8651112914085388,
-0.0019942806102335453,
0.9444159269332886,
-0.3819732069969177,
0.7910653352737427,
0.20705579221248627,
-1.364539384841919,
0.4802740812301636,
-0.6429734230041504,
0.4410106837749481,
0.7520238757133484,
0.17525750398635864,
-0.9723084568977356,
-0.1621134877204895,
-0.8013778924942017,
-0.8189607858657837,
0.41610223054885864,
0.4945148825645447,
0.26194578409194946,
-0.5165693759918213,
0.4975307881832123,
-0.0896010547876358,
0.018254587426781654,
-0.4887676239013672,
-0.39952552318573,
-0.03833329677581787,
-0.3583163022994995,
-0.1226368322968483,
-0.576413094997406,
-0.3941023647785187,
-0.1045946478843689,
0.39889612793922424,
-0.21377018094062805,
0.641004204750061,
0.47006523609161377,
0.08432672917842865,
-0.3812382221221924,
0.3970527946949005,
0.43157824873924255,
0.3505536615848541,
-0.4378976821899414,
0.413587749004364,
0.12361801415681839,
-0.7444391846656799,
0.1294155716896057,
-0.10511907935142517,
0.10079881548881531,
-0.09340957552194595,
0.5157420635223389,
0.4506712555885315,
0.26579147577285767,
-0.46167945861816406,
0.44462698698043823,
0.04296506196260452,
-0.05931011587381363,
0.023821569979190826,
-0.040481969714164734,
0.1657557636499405,
0.2047228217124939,
0.21857354044914246,
-0.18738313019275665,
0.5527580380439758,
-0.9396287202835083,
0.16495919227600098,
0.4288613200187683,
-0.7963176369667053,
-0.47888362407684326,
0.17230600118637085,
0.19792915880680084,
-0.6880830526351929,
0.17615200579166412,
-0.3433755934238434,
-0.07319249212741852,
0.5737928152084351,
0.4177621006965637,
0.9333981871604919,
-0.04250451922416687,
0.5966291427612305,
0.07270977646112442,
0.11427957564592361,
0.019580669701099396,
0.4418228268623352,
-0.10172563046216965,
-0.5170406699180603,
-0.11404082924127579,
-0.7080285549163818,
-0.3088376224040985,
-0.2271832376718521,
-0.9511480331420898,
-0.18417198956012726,
-0.180128812789917,
-0.8250415325164795,
-0.041495900601148605,
0.03545508161187172,
-0.5299078226089478,
0.6527464985847473,
0.6884427070617676,
0.7232558727264404,
-0.969567060470581,
0.2911510169506073,
0.7731027007102966,
-0.07888171076774597,
-0.5171318054199219,
0.4744815528392792,
0.19556060433387756,
-0.19210557639598846,
0.11732345074415207,
0.40545162558555603,
-0.28638574481010437,
-0.4099422097206116,
-0.4626710116863251,
-0.9287311434745789,
1.0296136140823364,
0.00008793327288003638,
-0.12409182637929916,
0.09688691049814224,
0.2666544020175934,
0.9457905888557434,
-0.5591511130332947,
0.6054036021232605,
0.6090054512023926,
0.5112680792808533,
0.02163897641003132,
-0.7367194294929504,
-0.12437287718057632,
-0.5467702746391296,
0.13568302989006042,
0.2157757729291916,
-0.6352182030677795,
0.8030091524124146,
-0.03469555079936981,
-0.46277371048927307,
-0.5006481409072876,
0.4830571711063385,
0.19465884566307068,
0.769406259059906,
0.358235239982605,
0.45339009165763855,
1.057555079460144,
-0.13657155632972717,
1.1545567512512207,
-0.5022101998329163,
0.5577560663223267,
0.8744567632675171,
-0.005235688295215368,
0.6023670434951782,
0.3494096100330353,
-0.3806104063987732,
0.581716775894165,
0.749817967414856,
0.6060522198677063,
0.28974828124046326,
0.13658741116523743,
-0.32085704803466797,
-0.09057794511318207,
-0.3150923550128937,
-0.3236951529979706,
0.3419461250305176,
0.6001879572868347,
-0.3948878347873688,
0.035169344395399094,
-0.22407245635986328,
0.2931743264198303,
-0.12331413477659225,
-0.4247701168060303,
0.9312530755996704,
0.25989827513694763,
-0.15216064453125,
0.2394743114709854,
-0.3477742075920105,
0.594196617603302,
-0.5838344693183899,
0.29670947790145874,
-0.28253260254859924,
-0.16371870040893555,
-0.6101131439208984,
-0.6074081063270569,
0.5168887972831726,
0.05590898543596268,
-0.6276401281356812,
-0.24428454041481018,
0.835913896560669,
-0.30195319652557373,
-0.7294080257415771,
0.6095041036605835,
0.773038923740387,
0.31818675994873047,
-0.32384222745895386,
-0.530361533164978,
-0.07822235673666,
-0.5549811720848083,
-0.39005517959594727,
0.5575312376022339,
0.9340333342552185,
0.03819539025425911,
0.46337905526161194,
0.2929113507270813,
0.2512892782688141,
-0.12626926600933075,
0.13508456945419312,
0.5404611229896545,
-0.916093647480011,
-0.5579829216003418,
-0.9591360688209534,
0.5387530326843262,
-0.27460306882858276,
-0.5691195726394653,
0.3796876072883606,
0.12768159806728363,
0.1411031037569046,
0.22788356244564056,
0.8598557710647583,
-0.21894408762454987,
0.11469815671443939,
-0.23300915956497192,
0.784049928188324,
-0.6208295822143555,
-0.2841089963912964,
-0.7855582237243652,
-0.5256323218345642,
-0.0683504268527031,
0.4270962178707123,
-0.4268094301223755,
0.1462564319372177,
0.9419547915458679,
0.3681342303752899,
0.29861557483673096,
-0.15556703507900238,
0.4785175323486328,
0.3460162580013275,
0.12987707555294037,
0.36684519052505493,
0.5607470870018005,
0.029286473989486694,
0.15837916731834412,
-0.5040789842605591,
-0.4182099401950836,
-0.1468588411808014,
-0.9138659238815308,
-0.8463940024375916,
-0.499781996011734,
-0.41495993733406067,
-0.25563785433769226,
0.0670730397105217,
0.7887185215950012,
0.4651621878147125,
-0.4545125961303711,
-0.0642794668674469,
0.20261426270008087,
0.07246638834476471,
-0.28763607144355774,
-0.26431119441986084,
0.06964002549648285,
-0.22019372880458832,
-0.26437607407569885,
-0.035049501806497574,
0.7187926769256592,
0.06371040642261505,
0.1692674309015274,
0.022083483636379242,
0.0683189406991005,
0.6382901072502136,
0.8303353786468506,
0.03709122911095619,
-0.5322533249855042,
-0.3251887559890747,
-0.23649825155735016,
-0.5197916030883789,
0.22569617629051208,
0.7353236079216003,
-0.2404334396123886,
0.37361085414886475,
0.6044027209281921,
0.01524833682924509,
0.08584830164909363,
0.32973623275756836,
0.09310692548751831,
-0.5073724389076233,
-0.23831692337989807,
0.1391739547252655,
0.38008245825767517,
0.22825868427753448,
-0.8314835429191589,
0.24111182987689972,
0.16014796495437622,
-0.795473575592041,
-0.32933101058006287,
0.1061532124876976,
-1.1700016260147095,
-0.024643851444125175,
1.252363681793213,
0.12276846170425415,
-0.31639382243156433,
0.07837416231632233,
-0.31751003861427307,
0.12374941259622574,
-0.7849391102790833,
1.4135105609893799,
0.8356485366821289,
-0.49855664372444153,
0.12264325469732285,
-0.4008781611919403,
0.333808571100235,
0.14324256777763367,
-1.3624287843704224,
0.0788501426577568,
0.4941631257534027,
-0.06274159997701645,
0.40263527631759644,
1.0404382944107056,
-0.15937335789203644,
0.14607523381710052,
0.10062868893146515,
0.16422344744205475,
0.5574789047241211,
-0.01755906455218792,
-0.32862532138824463,
0.26620492339134216,
-0.6464307308197021,
0.4893985390663147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02271v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02271v2
|
RIFF: Learning to Rephrase Inputs for Few-shot Fine-tuning of Language Models
| 2024-03-04T17:58:09 | 2024-06-06T14:43:30 |
Saeed Najafi, Alona Fyshe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) can be accurately fine-tuned for
downstream text processing tasks. Recently, researchers have introduced several
parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods that optimize input prompts or adjust a
small number of model parameters (e.g LoRA). In this study, we explore the
impact of altering the input text of the original task in conjunction with
parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods. To most effectively rewrite the input
text, we train a few-shot paraphrase model with a Maximum-Marginal Likelihood
objective. Using six few-shot text classification datasets, we show that
enriching data with paraphrases at train and test time enhances the performance
beyond what can be achieved with parameter-efficient fine-tuning alone. The
code used for our experiments can be found at
https://github.com/SaeedNajafi/RIFF.
|
[
-0.17650477588176727,
-0.8358058929443359,
0.6796712875366211,
-0.15482065081596375,
-0.6973214745521545,
-0.19851794838905334,
-0.3383764326572418,
-0.132637619972229,
-0.18196848034858704,
0.8753001689910889,
-0.6834219694137573,
-0.38315173983573914,
-0.42143872380256653,
0.22704105079174042,
-0.26238107681274414,
1.1220455169677734,
-0.0644247755408287,
0.04794105887413025,
0.02584017440676689,
-0.2795347273349762,
-0.2722456455230713,
-0.38488486409187317,
-0.6908977031707764,
-0.23463153839111328,
1.1829229593276978,
0.6175209879875183,
0.6062076687812805,
0.6974275708198547,
0.5841957926750183,
0.3078382909297943,
-0.1627654731273651,
0.27559465169906616,
-0.6330920457839966,
0.23553521931171417,
-0.33251816034317017,
-0.6534081697463989,
0.08372412621974945,
-0.0715218037366867,
0.8795019388198853,
0.8744425773620605,
0.1106070727109909,
0.20935969054698944,
0.4349978566169739,
0.38987997174263,
-0.6474307179450989,
-0.08698401600122452,
-0.9184681177139282,
-0.43588292598724365,
-0.47832879424095154,
-0.45563533902168274,
-0.5925312042236328,
-0.192570298910141,
-0.010151900351047516,
-0.650065004825592,
0.333920419216156,
0.03458381071686745,
1.015644907951355,
0.5770328640937805,
0.052675697952508926,
0.05386197566986084,
-0.6447952389717102,
0.9171244502067566,
-1.022973895072937,
0.06721879541873932,
0.2498769909143448,
0.29189661145210266,
-0.24658340215682983,
-1.0256861448287964,
-0.4436693787574768,
0.06599804759025574,
-0.27914515137672424,
-0.41388946771621704,
0.16324692964553833,
0.37458711862564087,
0.39626356959342957,
0.17369289696216583,
-0.26527461409568787,
0.05252617597579956,
-0.4829040467739105,
-0.07593639940023422,
0.3287336230278015,
0.3161427080631256,
0.3051689863204956,
-0.07400964945554733,
-0.015251846052706242,
-0.017100665718317032,
-0.7197011113166809,
0.18010999262332916,
0.3384571671485901,
0.7745205163955688,
0.24426297843456268,
0.6518122553825378,
-0.4383951723575592,
1.0815232992172241,
0.05219324678182602,
-0.2287163883447647,
0.09690587967634201,
-0.5289612412452698,
-0.37054580450057983,
-0.34918513894081116,
0.6428508758544922,
0.07283347100019455,
0.07174476236104965,
-0.0863633006811142,
-0.09765049815177917,
-0.31939202547073364,
0.23681260645389557,
-0.9507119059562683,
-0.14871303737163544,
-0.049837540835142136,
-0.41201862692832947,
-0.27732574939727783,
-0.1588134467601776,
-0.5235430002212524,
-0.38468077778816223,
-0.4564609229564667,
0.5948575735092163,
-0.7715997099876404,
0.5122071504592896,
0.1634586751461029,
-0.39798858761787415,
0.2847968637943268,
0.46784037351608276,
-0.7401712536811829,
0.025585392490029335,
0.8627372980117798,
0.756322979927063,
0.12218200415372849,
-0.6891238689422607,
-0.9167574644088745,
0.1904236376285553,
-0.13690665364265442,
1.0151896476745605,
-0.9030258059501648,
-0.06937199085950851,
-0.2825695276260376,
-0.13028880953788757,
-0.07457844913005829,
-0.5794195532798767,
0.6956526637077332,
-0.46367695927619934,
0.19910219311714172,
-0.45960238575935364,
-0.6705219745635986,
0.062133342027664185,
-0.043014004826545715,
-0.5296027064323425,
0.7132835388183594,
0.07190132141113281,
-0.7533221244812012,
0.4746173322200775,
-0.4377034604549408,
-0.5812380909919739,
-0.06070691719651222,
0.03246369957923889,
-0.4367820918560028,
0.3933984935283661,
0.3614058196544647,
0.32209062576293945,
-0.1319558024406433,
-0.0286671482026577,
-0.41560599207878113,
-0.6204045414924622,
0.19168637692928314,
-0.5497395992279053,
0.5495855212211609,
0.18698234856128693,
0.015939956530928612,
0.10449934005737305,
-0.7606284618377686,
0.13314174115657806,
-0.29500794410705566,
-0.6793545484542847,
-0.3048088848590851,
-0.07612612843513489,
-0.005186774302273989,
0.10888968408107758,
0.16592516005039215,
-0.5518642067909241,
0.20973262190818787,
-0.9564552307128906,
0.4662628769874573,
0.68122398853302,
0.24555611610412598,
0.5766399502754211,
-0.6007634997367859,
0.4127615690231323,
-0.16347551345825195,
0.03112192451953888,
-0.47562527656555176,
-0.15138429403305054,
-0.7090912461280823,
-0.4485743045806885,
0.6976231336593628,
0.31161290407180786,
-0.928019642829895,
-0.12414111196994781,
-0.186677947640419,
-0.46507778763771057,
-0.92696613073349,
0.7254631519317627,
0.3547375202178955,
0.46094170212745667,
0.49959179759025574,
0.05245412513613701,
-0.707770586013794,
-0.9223155975341797,
-0.9378941655158997,
0.1939309686422348,
-0.06593980640172958,
0.1772991269826889,
0.1949031800031662,
0.10023972392082214,
1.0314898490905762,
-0.47904857993125916,
-0.27488797903060913,
-0.6655856966972351,
0.44143426418304443,
0.12441258132457733,
0.48305371403694153,
0.47457155585289,
-0.4352342188358307,
-0.7892091870307922,
-0.3008735775947571,
-0.22020579874515533,
-0.41110458970069885,
-0.27752384543418884,
-0.06683329492807388,
-0.06137768179178238,
0.6392912268638611,
-0.5223402380943298,
0.25377410650253296,
0.11936042457818985,
-0.04427395761013031,
0.30639374256134033,
-0.19776587188243866,
0.14940714836120605,
-0.9357786774635315,
-0.09965352714061737,
-0.22058726847171783,
-0.29830747842788696,
-0.5612978339195251,
0.26200518012046814,
-0.17440757155418396,
-0.10156768560409546,
-0.7334374785423279,
0.5694182515144348,
-0.2565990090370178,
0.18731793761253357,
-0.7486965656280518,
0.12790755927562714,
0.14801517128944397,
0.5518794655799866,
-0.19395151734352112,
0.8064241409301758,
0.444112092256546,
-0.6138287782669067,
0.0022448813542723656,
0.05302612483501434,
-0.5139391422271729,
0.3786080777645111,
-0.7346088290214539,
0.15579846501350403,
-0.28465530276298523,
0.24391888082027435,
-1.0233889818191528,
-0.3289470970630646,
0.22759872674942017,
-0.32850927114486694,
0.24747823178768158,
-0.2090119868516922,
-0.7129350304603577,
0.16470207273960114,
-0.3300161361694336,
0.2975521683692932,
0.4364866316318512,
-0.513071596622467,
0.5495265126228333,
-0.09176048636436462,
-0.3669986426830292,
-0.40155932307243347,
-0.7654625177383423,
-0.00017020553059410304,
-0.3142121434211731,
-0.24086128175258636,
0.5278690457344055,
0.0413956493139267,
-0.06356527656316757,
-0.30025404691696167,
0.0235764067620039,
-0.32513850927352905,
0.17730987071990967,
0.06885740160942078,
-0.0787043571472168,
-0.19801682233810425,
0.12282594293355942,
0.4074464440345764,
-0.03284920006990433,
-0.24796272814273834,
-0.017404047772288322,
0.5237857103347778,
0.24370604753494263,
-0.18477460741996765,
-0.8112994432449341,
0.3074566721916199,
0.32720714807510376,
-0.19747991859912872,
0.9090180993080139,
0.4912334978580475,
-0.13105297088623047,
-0.277961790561676,
-0.26898670196533203,
-0.34889528155326843,
-0.5241913795471191,
0.12194608896970749,
-0.7010955810546875,
-0.7905625104904175,
0.23903770744800568,
-0.07177574187517166,
0.27460476756095886,
0.3503548204898834,
0.28518494963645935,
-0.5866404175758362,
0.7887385487556458,
0.6000572443008423,
-0.04237062484025955,
0.7029333710670471,
0.06594341993331909,
0.0762443095445633,
-0.5637778043746948,
0.3920007348060608,
-0.6679473519325256,
-0.7259605526924133,
-0.37886717915534973,
-0.5556892156600952,
0.103775255382061,
0.2699147164821625,
-0.06497368961572647,
0.37314921617507935,
-0.07107788324356079,
0.8153098225593567,
0.7988806366920471,
0.4603898823261261,
0.2228740155696869,
0.028100470080971718,
-0.11647504568099976,
-0.18242870271205902,
-0.6678366661071777,
-0.6696802973747253,
1.2253233194351196,
0.22114700078964233,
0.8456152081489563,
-0.17519862949848175,
0.9706716537475586,
-0.054328758269548416,
0.07773204892873764,
-0.5673626065254211,
0.5423489809036255,
-0.5208132266998291,
-0.6061663031578064,
-0.4813123643398285,
-0.2786760926246643,
-0.7981136441230774,
0.2339295595884323,
-0.03651277720928192,
-0.49222686886787415,
0.16402460634708405,
0.4522979259490967,
-0.7946703433990479,
0.1957026869058609,
-0.670657217502594,
0.8581551909446716,
0.01916372776031494,
-0.45852386951446533,
-0.3760968744754791,
-0.5444024205207825,
0.03694390505552292,
-0.06640398502349854,
-0.0016406815266236663,
0.05879375338554382,
-0.13541452586650848,
0.602689802646637,
-0.7333935499191284,
1.090760588645935,
-0.24276205897331238,
-0.001758881495334208,
0.37966862320899963,
-0.13893848657608032,
0.6027118563652039,
-0.062130071222782135,
-0.21265994012355804,
-0.2242959588766098,
0.036934301257133484,
-0.5643666386604309,
-0.8941479921340942,
0.5974382162094116,
-0.4373796880245209,
-0.6808704137802124,
-0.028029626235365868,
-0.6027248501777649,
-0.43826398253440857,
0.2100321501493454,
0.46568769216537476,
0.5593116283416748,
0.014572657644748688,
0.5722880959510803,
0.6037139296531677,
-0.2317621111869812,
0.29703301191329956,
0.48650825023651123,
0.008084767498075962,
-0.24432523548603058,
0.8181402087211609,
0.07271401584148407,
0.3416405916213989,
0.6402400135993958,
0.12033133208751678,
0.009860393591225147,
-0.6527490019798279,
-0.34565889835357666,
0.2964729964733124,
-0.8057567477226257,
-0.22396665811538696,
-0.5714303255081177,
0.04191102087497711,
-0.39139723777770996,
-0.18766003847122192,
-0.2584661841392517,
-0.42593830823898315,
-0.6005155444145203,
0.05813293531537056,
0.2725215256214142,
0.33296826481819153,
0.20566333830356598,
0.9186503887176514,
-0.6869534850120544,
0.506534218788147,
0.24391257762908936,
0.35994288325309753,
-0.5106045007705688,
-1.1103248596191406,
-0.25086477398872375,
0.21090318262577057,
-0.1688605397939682,
-0.7296130657196045,
0.18192148208618164,
0.5311761498451233,
0.4696982800960541,
0.16827596724033356,
0.09685063362121582,
0.9522275924682617,
-0.7586063742637634,
0.7196829319000244,
-0.25466230511665344,
-0.9113644957542419,
0.5361977815628052,
-0.23637546598911285,
0.4710131883621216,
1.1630877256393433,
0.06442764401435852,
-0.10696491599082947,
-0.5491452217102051,
-0.4048463702201843,
-0.6170648336410522,
0.8447284698486328,
0.08649294078350067,
0.38650086522102356,
0.3445988595485687,
0.5942931771278381,
0.3555562496185303,
0.195379376411438,
-0.5718086957931519,
-0.21630938351154327,
0.09312127530574799,
-0.5581013560295105,
-0.2747306525707245,
-0.48427242040634155,
0.07199018448591232,
-0.40536177158355713,
0.6117175817489624,
-0.039310868829488754,
-0.16301678121089935,
-0.0549137219786644,
-0.40504708886146545,
0.04065733030438423,
0.6334970593452454,
0.6944100260734558,
0.540556013584137,
-0.1436767280101776,
0.09432005137205124,
0.4529581367969513,
-0.08363477885723114,
0.02390696294605732,
0.09494366496801376,
-0.41319331526756287,
0.3774549067020416,
0.3524891138076782,
1.0362844467163086,
0.6370388865470886,
-0.6785048842430115,
0.17742453515529633,
0.12871070206165314,
-0.29048919677734375,
0.39867210388183594,
0.381590873003006,
-0.10213344544172287,
0.2537151575088501,
0.11131782084703445,
0.1145775318145752,
0.2391377091407776,
-0.5351032018661499,
0.23277835547924042,
0.30876660346984863,
-0.06764963269233704,
-0.15576210618019104,
0.49977797269821167,
0.15147686004638672,
-0.2695661783218384,
0.19736456871032715,
-0.13830426335334778,
-0.3068510591983795,
0.08963492512702942,
0.4227942228317261,
0.7705286741256714,
-0.17285048961639404,
0.20210924744606018,
0.2638060450553894,
0.38432419300079346,
-0.09738343209028244,
0.18445086479187012,
-0.0809699147939682,
-0.45373085141181946,
-0.5891058444976807,
-0.7994070649147034,
-0.40556150674819946,
0.25696879625320435,
-0.4049948453903198,
0.5900290012359619,
-0.5717794299125671,
-0.05642075091600418,
0.27431613206863403,
-0.2270113080739975,
-0.5311135649681091,
0.22123683989048004,
0.00632557412609458,
0.8464328646659851,
-0.6167253851890564,
0.9740001559257507,
0.8168640732765198,
-0.3855530321598053,
-0.6936315894126892,
0.25134700536727905,
-0.4505981504917145,
-0.39389604330062866,
0.6003602743148804,
0.021055221557617188,
-0.14190776646137238,
0.15486229956150055,
-0.6940688490867615,
-0.8477710485458374,
0.5774199962615967,
0.7455536723136902,
-0.5914653539657593,
-0.2403876632452011,
0.36971315741539,
0.6960451602935791,
-0.1362374871969223,
0.031118739396333694,
0.7094285488128662,
0.3569716811180115,
-0.024381553754210472,
-0.8791546821594238,
-0.2770531475543976,
0.06653660535812378,
0.13656193017959595,
0.04567987471818924,
-0.2744658887386322,
0.8588809967041016,
-0.15384523570537567,
-0.21890920400619507,
0.22695885598659515,
0.7546351552009583,
0.09944804012775421,
0.15807989239692688,
0.41608020663261414,
0.48975807428359985,
0.5603582262992859,
-0.03221973404288292,
0.9788733124732971,
-0.158974289894104,
0.20426589250564575,
1.8023993968963623,
-0.17391547560691833,
1.1239995956420898,
0.7498632073402405,
-0.11167533695697784,
0.5387671589851379,
0.48731836676597595,
0.1664663851261139,
0.8171564340591431,
0.138560488820076,
-0.12519873678684235,
-0.36190488934516907,
0.1209053248167038,
0.0068677933886647224,
0.5023000836372375,
0.14747661352157593,
-0.6069902777671814,
-0.5261005759239197,
0.4574003219604492,
-0.12293067574501038,
0.3061557412147522,
-0.301727831363678,
0.9055958390235901,
0.08042815327644348,
-0.7150810956954956,
0.6437766551971436,
0.3436180651187897,
0.696800708770752,
-0.46529465913772583,
0.09108472615480423,
-0.1863768994808197,
0.23421145975589752,
-0.07710143178701401,
-0.5368983149528503,
0.44357725977897644,
0.22375735640525818,
-0.3179723024368286,
-0.35930192470550537,
0.7445331811904907,
-0.5142528414726257,
-0.4863806366920471,
-0.24921567738056183,
0.16022591292858124,
0.1136346086859703,
-0.42299139499664307,
-0.8440619111061096,
0.08727558702230453,
0.13940215110778809,
-0.2757647931575775,
0.2662574052810669,
0.39820176362991333,
0.3715819716453552,
0.608658492565155,
0.47923433780670166,
0.05107001215219498,
0.11858441680669785,
0.1583472043275833,
0.9051728844642639,
-0.714048445224762,
-0.3778936266899109,
-1.099017858505249,
0.4919337034225464,
-0.007328811101615429,
-0.33550307154655457,
0.7405906319618225,
0.6077509522438049,
0.8154686689376831,
-0.2208269238471985,
0.8350375294685364,
0.1774393916130066,
0.9229311943054199,
-0.6329692006111145,
0.49699485301971436,
-0.5464364886283875,
0.3425230085849762,
-0.29253071546554565,
-0.568982720375061,
-0.22037513554096222,
0.3900526463985443,
-0.5185903906822205,
-0.07423514127731323,
0.6624805927276611,
0.8702536821365356,
0.031082982197403908,
-0.2764529883861542,
0.3486560583114624,
0.09536243975162506,
0.07144444435834885,
0.3894774913787842,
0.6478725075721741,
-0.5566933155059814,
0.7567170262336731,
-0.47009217739105225,
0.21514476835727692,
-0.2608787417411804,
-0.5629317164421082,
-0.9690841436386108,
-0.40410810708999634,
-0.4726451337337494,
-0.036789558827877045,
0.11607031524181366,
0.8202556371688843,
0.4258987009525299,
-0.8915613293647766,
0.08510842174291611,
-0.14924487471580505,
0.2058563381433487,
-0.2503957450389862,
-0.20534658432006836,
0.0861780196428299,
-1.027427077293396,
-0.9999074935913086,
0.4923439919948578,
0.22214028239250183,
-0.06161937117576599,
0.155387744307518,
0.17986427247524261,
-0.1549079418182373,
0.2371630221605301,
0.4774174988269806,
0.17898055911064148,
-0.8499714136123657,
-0.24845317006111145,
-0.05318786948919296,
-0.31078216433525085,
0.015773538500070572,
0.9613643288612366,
-0.754945695400238,
0.2788432836532593,
0.6571148633956909,
0.8956794738769531,
0.12341461330652237,
0.3479510545730591,
0.7407597899436951,
-0.9624848961830139,
0.039505064487457275,
0.09182016551494598,
0.33357903361320496,
0.2974453866481781,
-0.1252656728029251,
0.052409086376428604,
0.10434756428003311,
-0.4014589488506317,
-1.1326508522033691,
0.08751130104064941,
-0.7377447485923767,
-0.620241105556488,
1.1671078205108643,
-0.2044912874698639,
-0.29174911975860596,
-0.10181338340044022,
-0.700082540512085,
0.3548683226108551,
-0.07828260958194733,
0.4954456686973572,
0.7318286299705505,
-0.006031560245901346,
-0.41958776116371155,
-0.23794308304786682,
0.7628360390663147,
0.6672746539115906,
-0.7849107384681702,
0.1596686691045761,
0.30956125259399414,
0.5515411496162415,
-0.30318889021873474,
0.5016839504241943,
0.29867586493492126,
0.3080754280090332,
-0.18302889168262482,
-0.3031010925769806,
-0.03088308870792389,
-0.22355568408966064,
-0.4581102132797241,
0.22031138837337494,
0.3655693233013153,
-0.25262030959129333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02270v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02270v2
|
FENICE: Factuality Evaluation of summarization based on Natural language Inference and Claim Extraction
| 2024-03-04T17:57:18 | 2024-03-26T13:14:52 |
Alessandro Scirè, Karim Ghonim, Roberto Navigli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in text summarization, particularly with the advent of
Large Language Models (LLMs), have shown remarkable performance. However, a
notable challenge persists as a substantial number of automatically-generated
summaries exhibit factual inconsistencies, such as hallucinations. In response
to this issue, various approaches for the evaluation of consistency for
summarization have emerged. Yet, these newly-introduced metrics face several
limitations, including lack of interpretability, focus on short document
summaries (e.g., news articles), and computational impracticality, especially
for LLM-based metrics. To address these shortcomings, we propose Factuality
Evaluation of summarization based on Natural language Inference and Claim
Extraction (FENICE), a more interpretable and efficient factuality-oriented
metric. FENICE leverages an NLI-based alignment between information in the
source document and a set of atomic facts, referred to as claims, extracted
from the summary. Our metric sets a new state of the art on AGGREFACT, the
de-facto benchmark for factuality evaluation. Moreover, we extend our
evaluation to a more challenging setting by conducting a human annotation
process of long-form summarization.
|
[
-0.10740143060684204,
-0.4406980872154236,
0.5303736329078674,
0.38927793502807617,
-0.06652308255434036,
0.049507468938827515,
-0.2586989104747772,
-0.644502580165863,
0.4316137731075287,
0.2959715723991394,
-0.1381346583366394,
-0.46898049116134644,
-0.6485999822616577,
0.3736559748649597,
-0.4287141263484955,
1.4286680221557617,
0.1571120321750641,
-0.31076857447624207,
-0.5603941082954407,
-0.28406450152397156,
-0.37918826937675476,
-0.2508082389831543,
-0.227141872048378,
-0.23763316869735718,
0.5016284584999084,
0.10665643215179443,
0.5209912657737732,
0.549007773399353,
0.655876100063324,
0.29307740926742554,
-0.05692365765571594,
0.41563209891319275,
-0.26157233119010925,
-0.038544390350580215,
-0.377151221036911,
-0.315017968416214,
-0.48247575759887695,
0.028339534997940063,
0.6800322532653809,
0.46747449040412903,
-0.07481074333190918,
0.06424717605113983,
-0.17085674405097961,
0.7031533122062683,
-0.7098362445831299,
-0.09412865340709686,
-0.6142777800559998,
0.07985508441925049,
0.005769489333033562,
-0.1540643572807312,
-0.3909132182598114,
-0.802735447883606,
0.21379710733890533,
-0.4618343114852905,
0.47947901487350464,
0.1757020354270935,
1.1798851490020752,
0.1702852100133896,
-0.4296703040599823,
-0.5789189338684082,
-0.6693300604820251,
0.7920061349868774,
-1.0765202045440674,
0.1912069469690323,
0.20358403027057648,
0.42273226380348206,
-0.05293143168091774,
-0.6598366498947144,
-0.5675384998321533,
-0.3862664997577667,
-0.4826287627220154,
0.31235572695732117,
-0.2227906584739685,
0.06903689354658127,
0.3573697507381439,
0.5746009945869446,
-0.8132937550544739,
-0.14369718730449677,
-0.3678121864795685,
-0.5294688940048218,
0.8989056348800659,
0.07651546597480774,
0.5392646193504333,
-0.5361123085021973,
-0.5856395363807678,
0.25280797481536865,
-0.3038949966430664,
-0.302603542804718,
0.38113945722579956,
0.13816654682159424,
-0.27485111355781555,
0.700117826461792,
-0.5186042785644531,
0.505918562412262,
-0.17128044366836548,
-0.5076525807380676,
0.2618664503097534,
-0.6120299100875854,
-0.28838762640953064,
0.3045622706413269,
0.7767072319984436,
0.6522343754768372,
0.08158363401889801,
-0.5363744497299194,
-0.21975955367088318,
0.13645145297050476,
0.1530873328447342,
-0.715842068195343,
-0.07849205285310745,
0.5755425691604614,
-0.5056868195533752,
-0.4527819752693176,
0.3374623656272888,
-1.008554458618164,
-0.5734474658966064,
-0.28469157218933105,
0.5206103920936584,
-0.3957953155040741,
-0.20303404331207275,
0.12592071294784546,
-0.527504026889801,
0.07162875682115555,
0.49173682928085327,
-0.8432251811027527,
0.46381914615631104,
0.797048032283783,
1.1178693771362305,
-0.32236090302467346,
-0.15146373212337494,
-0.5865734815597534,
0.12396007776260376,
-0.29106011986732483,
1.0147737264633179,
-0.015930457040667534,
-0.15729622542858124,
-0.13287797570228577,
-0.1626998633146286,
-0.21403257548809052,
-0.710425853729248,
0.8252615332603455,
-0.0726129561662674,
0.38021472096443176,
-0.3394303321838379,
-0.7265028357505798,
-0.1571808159351349,
0.6510660648345947,
-0.5968700647354126,
0.7856214046478271,
-0.18429432809352875,
-0.9509121179580688,
0.3422450125217438,
-0.4142986536026001,
-0.49779486656188965,
-0.21070030331611633,
-0.2946379780769348,
-0.26643604040145874,
0.40608125925064087,
-0.01927424594759941,
0.21145959198474884,
-0.24681565165519714,
0.6078466773033142,
0.05179201439023018,
-0.24046653509140015,
0.23004865646362305,
-0.6466457843780518,
0.8300443291664124,
0.10122532397508621,
-0.2672504186630249,
0.041812408715486526,
-0.8345694541931152,
-0.4342220723628998,
-0.11241383105516434,
-0.22257348895072937,
-0.292315274477005,
0.14277295768260956,
-0.18012067675590515,
0.02358987368643284,
0.40611350536346436,
-0.5628491044044495,
0.2808677554130554,
-0.6782466173171997,
-0.07540135085582733,
0.4366897642612457,
0.09668666869401932,
0.19135227799415588,
-0.6983259916305542,
0.26465386152267456,
-0.4165003299713135,
-0.0013229879550635815,
-0.17933741211891174,
-0.34570032358169556,
-0.6710247993469238,
-0.5024512410163879,
0.3857102394104004,
0.660442590713501,
-0.42888152599334717,
0.4692312180995941,
-0.570415735244751,
-0.3443487882614136,
-0.03449324145913124,
0.046478401869535446,
0.3030283451080322,
0.7591539621353149,
0.17002716660499573,
0.07076065987348557,
-0.7468100190162659,
-1.0764087438583374,
-0.4494430720806122,
-0.3290560245513916,
-0.03196990489959717,
-0.16474640369415283,
0.6460639834403992,
-0.1272134780883789,
1.162583589553833,
-0.36089733242988586,
-0.27855411171913147,
-0.27509403228759766,
0.8458669185638428,
0.4664878845214844,
0.24981218576431274,
0.5633435249328613,
-0.7010773420333862,
-0.34600749611854553,
0.26346179842948914,
-0.9646754264831543,
-0.3147277235984802,
-0.4631495177745819,
-0.005505871027708054,
0.24101631343364716,
0.20675523579120636,
-0.7278764247894287,
0.5761014223098755,
0.3146093487739563,
-0.2026381641626358,
1.0766373872756958,
-0.2359110414981842,
0.3203342854976654,
-0.9312533736228943,
0.21037383377552032,
-0.09173515439033508,
-0.3134409189224243,
-0.34316009283065796,
-0.2998037040233612,
-0.029140407219529152,
0.24130511283874512,
-0.0781375840306282,
0.770551860332489,
-0.41611334681510925,
-0.16046470403671265,
-0.42246755957603455,
0.40423446893692017,
0.4453333914279938,
0.13297776877880096,
-0.1699770838022232,
0.7879998087882996,
0.09385447204113007,
-0.4851585924625397,
0.4009212255477905,
0.12008616328239441,
-0.25201714038848877,
0.5930662751197815,
-0.6209667325019836,
-0.40302687883377075,
-0.07505286484956741,
0.18646684288978577,
-0.8429285883903503,
-0.5375444293022156,
0.1760263592004776,
-0.6224109530448914,
-0.031937383115291595,
-0.11323170363903046,
-0.3650582730770111,
0.20376087725162506,
-0.5421432852745056,
0.02061016485095024,
0.3891366720199585,
-0.5542861819267273,
0.8850482702255249,
0.06043686717748642,
-0.22446544468402863,
-0.7938374280929565,
-0.4952261447906494,
0.5181238651275635,
-0.24664679169654846,
-0.5669965744018555,
0.3821374475955963,
0.148270383477211,
-0.8113166689872742,
0.019588250666856766,
-0.29927223920822144,
-0.08518212288618088,
-0.006760838441550732,
0.02804146148264408,
0.3548978269100189,
-0.14709898829460144,
0.2955702543258667,
0.03338349610567093,
-0.009823200292885303,
0.4312141537666321,
-0.00019889102259185165,
0.01137997955083847,
-0.06675556302070618,
-0.14561529457569122,
-0.49360039830207825,
0.3562968969345093,
0.601934552192688,
-0.1498735398054123,
0.4977938234806061,
0.4705689251422882,
-0.6568350195884705,
-0.12879295647144318,
-0.7425644397735596,
0.060495905578136444,
-0.30806827545166016,
0.24648411571979523,
0.13591136038303375,
-0.2921026051044464,
0.6725699305534363,
0.008368926122784615,
0.35276976227760315,
0.7912862300872803,
0.20852753520011902,
-0.08793056011199951,
0.6503754258155823,
0.34561532735824585,
-0.05912519618868828,
-0.0003917768190149218,
-0.007486731745302677,
0.19178827106952667,
-0.5677430033683777,
-0.22265435755252838,
-0.6333827376365662,
-0.07696092873811722,
-0.209987074136734,
-0.2221064567565918,
0.24349234998226166,
0.03320176899433136,
0.4575442373752594,
0.1040794774889946,
-0.06082111969590187,
0.4990908205509186,
0.05023878812789917,
-0.23616598546504974,
0.7031747698783875,
-0.04808466508984566,
0.030915401875972748,
-0.10998959839344025,
-0.44373318552970886,
-0.6555913686752319,
0.8622490763664246,
0.16484025120735168,
0.25260433554649353,
0.49629443883895874,
0.6585863828659058,
0.7674658298492432,
0.5278290510177612,
-0.780672550201416,
0.3199375867843628,
-0.16880781948566437,
-0.7827970385551453,
-0.07349687814712524,
-0.539219081401825,
-0.44113314151763916,
0.384350448846817,
-0.6686217188835144,
-0.998900830745697,
0.24318867921829224,
0.20895904302597046,
-0.6105712056159973,
0.19303354620933533,
-0.6958221197128296,
0.6956877112388611,
-0.4287882149219513,
-0.37355607748031616,
-0.17220894992351532,
-0.3737846314907074,
0.7367535829544067,
0.0967760756611824,
0.321572482585907,
-0.25123727321624756,
0.10911109298467636,
0.7649775743484497,
-0.5763595104217529,
0.7742584943771362,
0.009738573804497719,
-0.16905784606933594,
0.11008379608392715,
-0.16407154500484467,
0.7005358338356018,
0.45877230167388916,
-0.07703212648630142,
0.12007353454828262,
-0.03996814042329788,
-0.26131007075309753,
-1.010529637336731,
0.47492825984954834,
-0.20123593509197235,
-0.42031940817832947,
-0.8526965975761414,
-0.4491751194000244,
-0.16240613162517548,
0.3148227035999298,
0.5327492356300354,
0.7644724249839783,
-0.5389882326126099,
0.04348957538604736,
0.7849748730659485,
-0.22705960273742676,
0.442903071641922,
0.20814836025238037,
-0.5351026058197021,
-0.7176991701126099,
1.2480241060256958,
0.12860681116580963,
0.07516572624444962,
0.42664387822151184,
0.4005106985569,
-0.42393526434898376,
-0.6293788552284241,
-0.3131802976131439,
0.3563135266304016,
-0.49141260981559753,
-0.1361769735813141,
-0.8915643095970154,
-0.3093331456184387,
-0.5522891879081726,
-0.1995154768228531,
-0.45268014073371887,
-0.4782411456108093,
0.03430890664458275,
-0.08168044686317444,
0.17331668734550476,
0.7317447066307068,
-0.1798468977212906,
0.09516234695911407,
-0.8576375246047974,
0.5550450682640076,
0.332947313785553,
0.13474510610103607,
-0.1600642204284668,
-0.5417342185974121,
-0.43638941645622253,
-0.16223430633544922,
0.01915833353996277,
-0.8165022730827332,
0.2076043337583542,
0.1181144043803215,
0.4402971565723419,
0.6651046276092529,
0.3341785967350006,
0.48900067806243896,
-0.23128922283649445,
0.5556456446647644,
0.2574942708015442,
-0.8536465167999268,
0.4299516975879669,
-0.43609002232551575,
-0.12913894653320312,
0.6890168786048889,
0.10559480637311935,
-0.44581958651542664,
-0.2408631294965744,
-0.6723591089248657,
-0.7703105211257935,
0.14210347831249237,
0.4243534207344055,
-0.249667227268219,
-0.03300996124744415,
0.13690626621246338,
0.3105522394180298,
0.19145020842552185,
-0.4463074505329132,
0.11529660224914551,
-0.04400553181767464,
-0.3959500193595886,
0.046171437948942184,
-0.41399577260017395,
-0.3798476755619049,
-0.051055390387773514,
0.5769924521446228,
-0.026699768379330635,
-0.03234770894050598,
0.4913778603076935,
-0.28982415795326233,
0.43632251024246216,
0.39758843183517456,
0.9490218758583069,
1.0577069520950317,
-0.6246206760406494,
0.10542824864387512,
0.24627377092838287,
-0.48830729722976685,
-0.05536104366183281,
0.14550809562206268,
-0.22014300525188446,
0.5497648119926453,
0.8589980602264404,
0.6688533425331116,
0.2079351544380188,
-0.8882782459259033,
0.7601410150527954,
-0.2169862985610962,
-0.27700018882751465,
-0.6188352108001709,
0.03841889649629593,
-0.26153624057769775,
0.17015469074249268,
0.4492664337158203,
0.1625174880027771,
0.5073077082633972,
-0.43122199177742004,
0.2588876485824585,
0.348762184381485,
-0.08380827307701111,
-0.3246243894100189,
0.4644092321395874,
0.36949700117111206,
-0.06015729904174805,
0.2648465931415558,
-0.34238430857658386,
-0.2278887927532196,
0.683170735836029,
0.2969154715538025,
1.0922672748565674,
0.3218546211719513,
0.47578558325767517,
0.5190936923027039,
0.6111661791801453,
-0.2555570602416992,
-0.0841115415096283,
0.11125066131353378,
-0.6597481369972229,
-0.7140212059020996,
-0.47180303931236267,
-0.5270719528198242,
0.07064194232225418,
-0.7594324350357056,
0.11773113906383514,
-0.4945761263370514,
0.0022537880577147007,
-0.025515101850032806,
0.029412269592285156,
0.0717497169971466,
0.3931811451911926,
-0.05909903720021248,
0.8935035467147827,
-1.035536289215088,
0.37769055366516113,
0.4810255467891693,
-0.2331993281841278,
-0.29006630182266235,
0.2836282551288605,
0.2831902503967285,
-0.06184504181146622,
0.4199525713920593,
0.28164422512054443,
-0.21794430911540985,
-0.4785307049751282,
-0.35564082860946655,
-0.5088993310928345,
0.939586877822876,
0.48634862899780273,
-0.4203519821166992,
0.022322876378893852,
-0.219283789396286,
0.362247109413147,
-0.27380695939064026,
0.2732503116130829,
0.4457646310329437,
0.5250749588012695,
-0.06874987483024597,
-0.6030919551849365,
-0.08149024844169617,
-0.3766328990459442,
-0.25817495584487915,
-0.06924790143966675,
-0.48921334743499756,
0.623217761516571,
-0.19883951544761658,
-0.34645938873291016,
-0.05547983944416046,
0.9900282621383667,
0.24262100458145142,
0.5968352556228638,
0.42164361476898193,
0.48228681087493896,
1.0592573881149292,
-0.11031471192836761,
1.0142422914505005,
0.016725681722164154,
0.3670547306537628,
1.404016375541687,
-0.25095513463020325,
0.5714361667633057,
0.36353930830955505,
-0.037017300724983215,
0.32481592893600464,
0.16190870106220245,
0.033292435109615326,
0.1257018744945526,
-0.12582634389400482,
-0.3885814845561981,
-0.016374576836824417,
-0.13526834547519684,
-0.27832528948783875,
0.4316380023956299,
0.1497042030096054,
-0.20830774307250977,
-0.511120617389679,
-0.36402428150177,
0.19039657711982727,
0.2910171151161194,
0.03044974058866501,
0.6382620930671692,
-0.1783807873725891,
-0.5392634272575378,
0.3187485635280609,
-0.09207338839769363,
0.7157015204429626,
-0.5634444952011108,
-0.42267659306526184,
-0.4457613229751587,
-0.2021261304616928,
-0.5461862683296204,
-0.1926032155752182,
0.6379980444908142,
0.4688751697540283,
-0.5244554281234741,
0.25371789932250977,
0.6304079294204712,
-0.1797548085451126,
-0.492049902677536,
0.09104180335998535,
0.12152771651744843,
0.20012693107128143,
-0.024643506854772568,
-0.2986019253730774,
0.0410768985748291,
0.0111229931935668,
-0.03095516376197338,
0.14414581656455994,
0.4350976347923279,
0.09395693242549896,
0.3378537595272064,
0.5571131110191345,
0.4932803511619568,
-0.10424409806728363,
-0.005400962196290493,
0.46862155199050903,
-0.5952818393707275,
-0.38016051054000854,
-0.9186179637908936,
0.7395082116127014,
-0.7526240944862366,
-0.49715569615364075,
0.9178991913795471,
0.774293065071106,
0.37377214431762695,
0.2003386914730072,
1.1566280126571655,
-0.24349060654640198,
0.6039633750915527,
-0.8746126890182495,
0.9352836608886719,
-0.48813119530677795,
0.3063814342021942,
-0.2739671468734741,
-0.9159653782844543,
-0.21774011850357056,
0.5325966477394104,
-0.3308805823326111,
-0.19658532738685608,
0.8333890438079834,
0.5616396069526672,
0.04030940309166908,
0.08039657771587372,
0.22543126344680786,
0.3792416751384735,
0.2201690971851349,
0.09787043929100037,
0.6455046534538269,
-0.42585018277168274,
0.38441890478134155,
-0.27170053124427795,
-0.33473238348960876,
-0.47229599952697754,
-1.1911147832870483,
-0.7739388942718506,
-0.2576531767845154,
-0.5265782475471497,
-0.3516034483909607,
0.19629929959774017,
0.7904937863349915,
0.23887303471565247,
-0.8664323687553406,
-0.1429758220911026,
-0.06337257474660873,
0.3349589407444,
-0.18471410870552063,
-0.2545985281467438,
0.3376266360282898,
-0.45459505915641785,
-0.7195295095443726,
0.3642422556877136,
0.5118107795715332,
-0.02634105272591114,
-0.08362264186143875,
-0.04320758953690529,
-0.401521235704422,
0.2961615025997162,
0.4223705530166626,
0.5792937278747559,
-0.6396415829658508,
-0.3689906895160675,
-0.25667086243629456,
-0.08088857680559158,
0.08183518797159195,
0.5874300003051758,
-0.41224202513694763,
0.5608367919921875,
0.6065075397491455,
0.8126752972602844,
-0.025531094521284103,
0.45987674593925476,
0.6600846648216248,
-0.6324673891067505,
0.055440012365579605,
0.09023237973451614,
0.31319358944892883,
0.2679208815097809,
-0.3687184453010559,
0.4758863151073456,
0.4160912036895752,
-0.3093556761741638,
-0.9904983639717102,
-0.06256511807441711,
-0.9562650918960571,
-0.0554894283413887,
0.9111099243164062,
-0.1673387885093689,
-0.3614005744457245,
-0.17380015552043915,
-0.13494467735290527,
0.2030397653579712,
-0.11566063016653061,
1.0437448024749756,
0.8327515125274658,
-0.11416371911764145,
0.16754494607448578,
-0.7023729681968689,
0.5266080498695374,
0.34574490785598755,
-0.9681373238563538,
0.2392260581254959,
0.6936147809028625,
0.18539808690547943,
0.46439996361732483,
0.5902655124664307,
-0.14235174655914307,
0.15921883285045624,
0.11423905938863754,
0.29864856600761414,
0.006595010869204998,
-0.5543085932731628,
-0.33403804898262024,
0.03420695289969444,
-0.25690996646881104,
-0.12006686627864838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02268v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02268v1
|
Subjective $\textit{Isms}$? On the Danger of Conflating Hate and Offence in Abusive Language Detection
| 2024-03-04T17:56:28 | 2024-03-04T17:56:28 |
Amanda Cercas Curry, Gavin Abercrombie, Zeerak Talat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Natural language processing research has begun to embrace the notion of
annotator subjectivity, motivated by variations in labelling. This approach
understands each annotator's view as valid, which can be highly suitable for
tasks that embed subjectivity, e.g., sentiment analysis. However, this
construction may be inappropriate for tasks such as hate speech detection, as
it affords equal validity to all positions on e.g., sexism or racism. We argue
that the conflation of hate and offence can invalidate findings on hate speech,
and call for future work to be situated in theory, disentangling hate from its
orthogonal concept, offence.
|
[
-0.4186288118362427,
-0.7797778248786926,
0.2768646776676178,
0.18922552466392517,
-0.39956384897232056,
-0.023311184719204903,
-0.298348605632782,
-0.6528170108795166,
0.06793014705181122,
0.544807493686676,
-0.08690422028303146,
-0.2948751151561737,
-1.2711368799209595,
0.07521088421344757,
-0.5252719521522522,
1.3498188257217407,
0.11405034363269806,
-0.03149104490876198,
-0.3777051866054535,
-0.7310064435005188,
-0.3430650234222412,
-1.007432460784912,
-0.6119930744171143,
-0.23417839407920837,
0.5294578671455383,
0.16880567371845245,
0.6921440362930298,
0.3657674193382263,
0.8909257054328918,
0.44067808985710144,
0.11042184382677078,
-0.10578877478837967,
-0.023039933294057846,
0.8100125193595886,
-0.5020056366920471,
-0.32645267248153687,
-0.39118537306785583,
0.32954543828964233,
0.14576935768127441,
0.5235071182250977,
0.3497947156429291,
-0.02080010063946247,
-0.02643393538892269,
0.5946678519248962,
-0.740127444267273,
-0.32806938886642456,
-0.7912417054176331,
0.06866564601659775,
-0.3793330490589142,
-0.0735662505030632,
-0.40715938806533813,
-0.326841801404953,
0.1013827845454216,
-0.2809801995754242,
0.04781847074627876,
0.08017612248659134,
0.5262595415115356,
0.4501323103904724,
-0.4667333960533142,
-0.6499899625778198,
-0.7694056034088135,
0.7282542586326599,
-0.5953080654144287,
0.06928893178701401,
0.2954416275024414,
0.0699053406715393,
0.20501002669334412,
-0.11402533948421478,
-0.7045842409133911,
-0.21157807111740112,
-0.2259528785943985,
-0.1897871494293213,
-0.6438270807266235,
0.20284393429756165,
0.4656173586845398,
0.5425546765327454,
-0.23948082327842712,
0.27406221628189087,
-0.4998401999473572,
-0.08033683896064758,
0.8332539200782776,
0.13523533940315247,
0.46980422735214233,
-0.1352599412202835,
-0.6194538474082947,
0.5464605689048767,
-0.49028754234313965,
-0.10732308775186539,
0.711597204208374,
0.5440101623535156,
-0.05523879453539848,
0.3947021961212158,
0.13167352974414825,
0.38749903440475464,
0.25742053985595703,
-0.15102022886276245,
0.36522263288497925,
0.17259754240512848,
-0.04051116481423378,
0.30592581629753113,
1.0102821588516235,
0.7000415325164795,
0.4238821268081665,
-0.2057671993970871,
-0.15733471512794495,
0.697040319442749,
0.81768798828125,
-0.5813173055648804,
-0.003525758860632777,
0.26833173632621765,
-0.1460539549589157,
-0.595161497592926,
-0.12004464119672775,
-0.5539623498916626,
-0.5745287537574768,
-0.2801925241947174,
0.34945061802864075,
-0.3155469298362732,
-0.5177999138832092,
-0.11011288315057755,
-0.07442347705364227,
-0.03842616453766823,
0.0893564373254776,
-0.6451908946037292,
0.6557649374008179,
0.9069424271583557,
0.45977985858917236,
-0.3525051176548004,
-0.15802326798439026,
-0.5059974789619446,
-0.04700864478945732,
0.08224701881408691,
0.7092710733413696,
-0.8271497488021851,
-0.45856982469558716,
0.1330638825893402,
-0.08240137994289398,
0.4160071611404419,
-0.7075344920158386,
0.9882891774177551,
-0.4641920328140259,
0.19510133564472198,
-0.1129421517252922,
-0.43112894892692566,
-0.5297623872756958,
0.4488701820373535,
-0.06911233812570572,
1.1222320795059204,
0.162072092294693,
-0.7660372257232666,
0.5162193775177002,
-0.7571381330490112,
-0.6356821060180664,
0.06744387745857239,
0.0860835537314415,
-0.6211424469947815,
0.210535928606987,
-0.4103679656982422,
0.3259213864803314,
0.0765933245420456,
0.5498915910720825,
-0.5795389413833618,
-0.174732968211174,
0.5437610149383545,
-0.23054687678813934,
0.5715652704238892,
0.4737895131111145,
-0.6204038262367249,
0.09848994761705399,
-0.6909693479537964,
-0.48183852434158325,
-0.07561317831277847,
-0.20953714847564697,
-0.9774028658866882,
0.1720850169658661,
0.0746731162071228,
0.3444710671901703,
-0.12246623635292053,
-0.8579710125923157,
-0.1894376277923584,
-0.28421488404273987,
0.057183001190423965,
0.7355019450187683,
-0.13561463356018066,
0.5412196516990662,
-0.22207312285900116,
0.48976272344589233,
0.5388289093971252,
0.1222708523273468,
0.5754664540290833,
-0.4898577332496643,
-0.7236501574516296,
0.07677395641803741,
-0.11019877344369888,
0.5574175715446472,
-0.3188079297542572,
0.5368260145187378,
-0.04080938175320625,
-0.39924144744873047,
-0.11786264181137085,
-0.04337615519762039,
0.7309769988059998,
0.49966979026794434,
0.3784884214401245,
-0.42288002371788025,
-0.922929048538208,
-1.0157803297042847,
-0.6180855631828308,
-0.3621581196784973,
0.39465707540512085,
-0.24200037121772766,
0.41547417640686035,
-0.16620385646820068,
0.9174248576164246,
-0.20914922654628754,
-0.21169190108776093,
0.007154600694775581,
0.38987207412719727,
0.11444582045078278,
0.6937484741210938,
0.8193352818489075,
-0.9185575842857361,
-0.43097826838493347,
-0.34480512142181396,
-0.9056341052055359,
-0.4220302104949951,
0.47140759229660034,
0.09604709595441818,
-0.022747697308659554,
0.38663214445114136,
-0.12577997148036957,
0.32710015773773193,
0.18557819724082947,
-0.42115700244903564,
0.213716521859169,
0.29084473848342896,
0.2705176770687103,
-0.872562050819397,
-0.33413997292518616,
0.2551101744174957,
-0.24002866446971893,
-0.9967703819274902,
0.08414659649133682,
-0.4021771252155304,
-0.008282904513180256,
-0.7008875608444214,
0.10780740529298782,
-0.015883225947618484,
0.3466545343399048,
-0.5790867805480957,
0.272635281085968,
-0.3111293315887451,
0.25588908791542053,
-0.1416088342666626,
0.382977694272995,
0.39096859097480774,
-0.7799295783042908,
0.15992659330368042,
0.0058080884627997875,
0.09039834141731262,
1.2356704473495483,
-0.14673051238059998,
0.18297459185123444,
-0.5292516350746155,
-0.42123913764953613,
-0.8634619116783142,
-0.04250948131084442,
0.8700294494628906,
-0.458473801612854,
0.2276809960603714,
-0.21887169778347015,
-0.14332908391952515,
-0.3488941192626953,
-0.5372337102890015,
0.6828835010528564,
0.051847778260707855,
-0.149179607629776,
0.5472959280014038,
0.7865379452705383,
-0.022531574591994286,
-0.7545480132102966,
-0.9092854857444763,
0.06948183476924896,
-0.7013519406318665,
-0.16917209327220917,
0.18929705023765564,
-0.010672135278582573,
-0.9825114607810974,
0.13180364668369293,
0.22180287539958954,
0.02123325504362583,
0.4548218250274658,
0.7340245842933655,
-0.036923252046108246,
-0.14167720079421997,
0.21554888784885406,
0.11089091747999191,
-0.20521032810211182,
0.5049208998680115,
-0.006456851959228516,
0.10618697851896286,
0.2051205039024353,
-0.17657466232776642,
-0.07595938444137573,
0.8128911256790161,
0.6165526509284973,
0.03613663464784622,
0.45589563250541687,
0.20589439570903778,
-0.6655511260032654,
-0.08016001433134079,
-0.3495853841304779,
0.23678338527679443,
-0.45915544033050537,
0.2778862416744232,
-0.12368407845497131,
-1.0373162031173706,
0.25083768367767334,
0.2764776647090912,
-0.0787220224738121,
0.44679003953933716,
0.6511831879615784,
-0.1187446117401123,
0.5995939373970032,
0.46398597955703735,
-0.134673610329628,
0.28124698996543884,
0.04798204451799393,
0.6907075047492981,
-0.7155369520187378,
-0.08854155987501144,
-0.5786055326461792,
-0.46852242946624756,
-0.746932864189148,
-0.043440088629722595,
0.24414940178394318,
-0.27438730001449585,
-0.3027689456939697,
0.1643657386302948,
-0.8464348912239075,
0.5402260422706604,
0.12559477984905243,
-0.006802906282246113,
0.3336992859840393,
-0.14485116302967072,
0.45705923438072205,
-0.5554754734039307,
-0.05691172182559967,
-0.9017465114593506,
0.9461082220077515,
0.38255399465560913,
0.2933255434036255,
0.4326060116291046,
0.42554622888565063,
0.5930357575416565,
1.028447151184082,
-0.9285255074501038,
0.4912686049938202,
-0.3447660803794861,
-1.1643316745758057,
0.15429386496543884,
0.14443908631801605,
-0.5999307632446289,
0.5695352554321289,
-0.15368595719337463,
-0.905715823173523,
0.24276939034461975,
0.30933645367622375,
-0.254790335893631,
0.7095222473144531,
-0.46565237641334534,
0.5465644598007202,
-0.012516806833446026,
-0.2374071627855301,
-0.002098707715049386,
-0.5185443758964539,
0.7244395017623901,
0.0026762031484395266,
0.7172611355781555,
-0.3872721791267395,
-0.11057575047016144,
0.9389024972915649,
-0.5768668055534363,
0.9662700295448303,
-0.4590616524219513,
-0.3277130722999573,
0.41447606682777405,
0.26242583990097046,
0.05890245363116264,
-0.35732194781303406,
-0.2151765674352646,
-0.0837559923529625,
-0.29169541597366333,
-0.07089662551879883,
-0.44624871015548706,
0.4496598541736603,
-0.5645046234130859,
-0.8106300830841064,
-0.7644200921058655,
-0.5879626870155334,
-0.2339344620704651,
-0.08634120970964432,
0.2820205092430115,
0.4303520619869232,
-0.13744890689849854,
-0.08960986882448196,
0.5141016840934753,
0.18098659813404083,
0.1957913339138031,
0.49849939346313477,
-0.31037580966949463,
-0.32701337337493896,
0.9693287014961243,
0.02267305739223957,
0.20438987016677856,
0.19303368031978607,
0.11911078542470932,
-0.12430082261562347,
-0.8885946273803711,
-0.00030855898512527347,
-0.03952953219413757,
-0.7897276282310486,
-0.40395134687423706,
-1.0994298458099365,
0.14120230078697205,
-0.2544900178909302,
-0.18364757299423218,
-0.11419189721345901,
-0.06128758192062378,
-0.09211375564336777,
-0.1240449771285057,
0.49921685457229614,
0.8618091940879822,
-0.3985092043876648,
0.6988020539283752,
-0.48753979802131653,
0.20404085516929626,
0.15823742747306824,
0.15613538026809692,
-0.32396987080574036,
-0.6659928560256958,
-0.1660107970237732,
-0.06688683480024338,
-0.5291967391967773,
-0.9837343096733093,
0.00655159680172801,
-0.24963641166687012,
0.30526044964790344,
0.5613700747489929,
0.2683423161506653,
0.19649451971054077,
-0.34203413128852844,
0.7652265429496765,
0.1851995587348938,
-0.9006329774856567,
0.6161246299743652,
-0.30233708024024963,
-0.3129903972148895,
0.8758689165115356,
0.7684531211853027,
-0.6356604099273682,
-0.9956548810005188,
-0.735221266746521,
-0.5775160789489746,
0.7130069732666016,
-0.030611131340265274,
0.3601904809474945,
-0.17994706332683563,
0.1709761619567871,
0.2690627872943878,
0.30888664722442627,
-1.0465078353881836,
-0.6151084899902344,
-0.10700621455907822,
-0.3041926622390747,
0.07385458797216415,
-0.6432745456695557,
-0.19434790313243866,
-0.3990621268749237,
0.5946791768074036,
0.18848110735416412,
0.2544143795967102,
-0.21329477429389954,
-0.2544066905975342,
-0.21201731264591217,
0.309844046831131,
0.3644433915615082,
0.39156070351600647,
-0.20911693572998047,
0.6930724382400513,
0.11896513402462006,
-0.560174822807312,
0.6243268251419067,
-0.21092043817043304,
-0.1722913682460785,
0.07463275641202927,
0.2750905156135559,
0.6052802801132202,
0.2511523365974426,
-0.22342592477798462,
0.853904128074646,
0.31585317850112915,
-0.23901407420635223,
-0.24042601883411407,
0.10116283595561981,
-0.3835363984107971,
0.12338966131210327,
0.029510363936424255,
0.2465505748987198,
0.398757666349411,
-0.7313427329063416,
0.2020280957221985,
0.2784699499607086,
-0.692224383354187,
-0.41372567415237427,
0.7268738150596619,
0.2659498155117035,
-0.5922028422355652,
0.06495709717273712,
-0.42394641041755676,
-1.1057180166244507,
0.25956785678863525,
0.48008736968040466,
0.9396184682846069,
-0.3958417773246765,
0.036357149481773376,
0.38147053122520447,
0.39659249782562256,
0.5630431175231934,
0.3070850968360901,
-0.10223917663097382,
-1.0507941246032715,
-0.07405123859643936,
-0.5656866431236267,
-0.5359353423118591,
0.12451540678739548,
-0.5765879154205322,
0.02162577025592327,
-0.5957470536231995,
-0.20172271132469177,
0.13476760685443878,
-0.472808837890625,
-0.17511600255966187,
0.42084062099456787,
0.5353372097015381,
0.42227277159690857,
-1.085496425628662,
0.4066500663757324,
0.6488797664642334,
-0.3364819586277008,
-0.2241099774837494,
0.02998117171227932,
0.27329394221305847,
-0.3150838017463684,
0.7814050316810608,
0.22733566164970398,
-0.3314538896083832,
-0.470989853143692,
-0.767013430595398,
-0.4911764860153198,
0.14483585953712463,
0.07977166026830673,
-0.14934247732162476,
0.2900986969470978,
0.3142133951187134,
0.5578380823135376,
-0.455291748046875,
-0.007702618837356567,
0.46498599648475647,
0.4227183163166046,
-0.16927041113376617,
-0.29210785031318665,
0.2970254719257355,
-0.21662403643131256,
-0.21112151443958282,
0.46144843101501465,
-0.40922611951828003,
0.7374177575111389,
0.19937458634376526,
-0.3259972035884857,
-0.38379278779029846,
0.6418253183364868,
-0.0824035108089447,
0.34616562724113464,
0.7289256453514099,
0.7117506265640259,
0.47863319516181946,
-0.2215229868888855,
0.8556438088417053,
0.15228433907032013,
0.23725968599319458,
1.1178131103515625,
-0.1665070652961731,
0.3656078577041626,
0.4946892261505127,
-0.5457301139831543,
0.6293166875839233,
0.2865936756134033,
0.14891377091407776,
0.4235363304615021,
0.33680132031440735,
-0.5529354214668274,
-0.3017500340938568,
-0.32668837904930115,
-0.12970063090324402,
0.6464033126831055,
0.5402922630310059,
-0.2007015496492386,
-0.3492547273635864,
0.30594438314437866,
0.5660874247550964,
0.7196840047836304,
-0.22789423167705536,
0.6468358635902405,
0.1803453415632248,
-0.47936978936195374,
0.16176094114780426,
0.054633352905511856,
1.238869309425354,
-0.30670902132987976,
0.36046507954597473,
0.18537917733192444,
0.06494387239217758,
-0.41051286458969116,
-0.9819294810295105,
0.8811563849449158,
0.2930830419063568,
-0.22186969220638275,
-0.19087426364421844,
0.8134407997131348,
-0.18526765704154968,
-0.1844366043806076,
0.34562328457832336,
0.30933424830436707,
0.20228077471256256,
-0.16030387580394745,
-0.5701998472213745,
0.12598341703414917,
-0.17436473071575165,
0.051266539841890335,
0.13808028399944305,
0.6615680456161499,
0.009360636584460735,
0.3584028482437134,
0.44975537061691284,
-0.0802466943860054,
0.08799514174461365,
-0.2035754919052124,
0.8941227197647095,
-0.5733251571655273,
-0.2713530957698822,
-1.2546544075012207,
0.6981757879257202,
-0.16701634228229523,
-0.6239722967147827,
0.697939932346344,
0.6228725910186768,
0.9849349856376648,
0.17100532352924347,
0.7673843502998352,
-0.27317357063293457,
0.7070690393447876,
-0.10132789611816406,
0.28108322620391846,
-0.427491694688797,
-0.20830589532852173,
-0.6979143023490906,
-0.6151392459869385,
-0.630295991897583,
0.33120396733283997,
-0.7251091599464417,
-0.17168810963630676,
0.648814857006073,
0.7150954008102417,
-0.07041837275028229,
0.3623950183391571,
0.4469081163406372,
0.11218534409999847,
0.24036279320716858,
0.235745370388031,
1.2951819896697998,
-0.529732346534729,
0.2501741051673889,
-0.5304285287857056,
-0.1329762488603592,
-0.2017560452222824,
-0.7512407898902893,
-0.7546648979187012,
-0.6824985146522522,
-0.5873675346374512,
-0.44312426447868347,
-0.16669028997421265,
0.9466014504432678,
0.2407853752374649,
-1.0330302715301514,
-0.12606091797351837,
0.40234610438346863,
0.3468257486820221,
0.06956016272306442,
-0.23495101928710938,
-0.24636995792388916,
-0.4830491244792938,
-0.9892463684082031,
-0.036630209535360336,
0.5505799651145935,
-0.1663878709077835,
-0.2828357219696045,
0.09162662923336029,
-0.5484151244163513,
-0.0896187275648117,
0.9956279397010803,
0.10818631201982498,
-0.6693031787872314,
-0.6639659404754639,
-0.6605297923088074,
-0.15209010243415833,
0.32407721877098083,
0.9630812406539917,
-0.4159955084323883,
0.24487990140914917,
0.13928373157978058,
0.5376675128936768,
-0.16986176371574402,
-0.04224448278546333,
0.25023382902145386,
-0.7162147164344788,
0.3608666956424713,
0.3905044496059418,
0.39685502648353577,
0.5250184535980225,
-0.49177229404449463,
0.4721713066101074,
0.6695631742477417,
-0.26685041189193726,
-1.0357086658477783,
0.4746513068675995,
-0.8474071621894836,
-0.1508684605360031,
0.9477524161338806,
0.13571494817733765,
-0.27221065759658813,
-0.45705536007881165,
-0.2568415403366089,
0.23090338706970215,
-0.39326080679893494,
0.5024377107620239,
0.593529999256134,
-0.12219921499490738,
0.2680419981479645,
-0.24392183125019073,
0.5711526870727539,
0.21601855754852295,
-0.69009929895401,
-0.004528219811618328,
0.3287855386734009,
0.21386530995368958,
0.4663374722003937,
0.4912571907043457,
-0.21802881360054016,
0.03313490003347397,
-0.1597072035074234,
0.14395524561405182,
0.17349350452423096,
0.036186471581459045,
-0.3661591112613678,
0.3318890631198883,
0.2568140923976898,
-0.43894580006599426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02253v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02253v2
|
KnowPhish: Large Language Models Meet Multimodal Knowledge Graphs for Enhancing Reference-Based Phishing Detection
| 2024-03-04T17:38:32 | 2024-06-15T11:34:45 |
Yuexin Li, Chengyu Huang, Shumin Deng, Mei Lin Lock, Tri Cao, Nay Oo, Hoon Wei Lim, Bryan Hooi
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Phishing attacks have inflicted substantial losses on individuals and
businesses alike, necessitating the development of robust and efficient
automated phishing detection approaches. Reference-based phishing detectors
(RBPDs), which compare the logos on a target webpage to a known set of logos,
have emerged as the state-of-the-art approach. However, a major limitation of
existing RBPDs is that they rely on a manually constructed brand knowledge
base, making it infeasible to scale to a large number of brands, which results
in false negative errors due to the insufficient brand coverage of the
knowledge base. To address this issue, we propose an automated knowledge
collection pipeline, using which we collect a large-scale multimodal brand
knowledge base, KnowPhish, containing 20k brands with rich information about
each brand. KnowPhish can be used to boost the performance of existing RBPDs in
a plug-and-play manner. A second limitation of existing RBPDs is that they
solely rely on the image modality, ignoring useful textual information present
in the webpage HTML. To utilize this textual information, we propose a Large
Language Model (LLM)-based approach to extract brand information of webpages
from text. Our resulting multimodal phishing detection approach, KnowPhish
Detector (KPD), can detect phishing webpages with or without logos. We evaluate
KnowPhish and KPD on a manually validated dataset, and a field study under
Singapore's local context, showing substantial improvements in effectiveness
and efficiency compared to state-of-the-art baselines.
|
[
-0.20823656022548676,
-0.5766595602035522,
-0.07659780979156494,
-0.12239982932806015,
-0.31249377131462097,
0.05175218731164932,
0.09654971957206726,
-0.8116934895515442,
0.3010488748550415,
0.3843335509300232,
-0.3774791359901428,
-0.4055625796318054,
-0.33231085538864136,
0.1271643042564392,
-0.2675327956676483,
0.8306677937507629,
0.2595216929912567,
-0.08278927952051163,
0.31226232647895813,
-0.1436307579278946,
0.18727998435497284,
-0.19090023636817932,
-0.6515026688575745,
-0.09809181094169617,
0.561708390712738,
0.5743585824966431,
0.36660826206207275,
0.3623942732810974,
0.7262876629829407,
0.2982991635799408,
0.2397293597459793,
0.23103362321853638,
-0.3232731521129608,
0.5103082656860352,
-0.22707755863666534,
-0.31211158633232117,
-0.5234135985374451,
-0.16300861537456512,
0.26226645708084106,
0.20399793982505798,
-0.10111349821090698,
0.24928629398345947,
-0.3288075923919678,
0.4188365340232849,
-1.1120259761810303,
0.45626240968704224,
-0.6579321026802063,
-0.05134935677051544,
-0.3698837459087372,
-0.48343226313591003,
-0.5728728175163269,
-0.2958616316318512,
0.38801971077919006,
-0.593946099281311,
0.024853277951478958,
0.3917805850505829,
0.48184898495674133,
-0.2980850636959076,
-0.7723525762557983,
-0.42971858382225037,
-0.48802489042282104,
0.6545597314834595,
-0.6986815929412842,
0.5954931378364563,
0.4388739764690399,
0.6303807497024536,
0.005768330302089453,
-0.9026928544044495,
-0.6081765294075012,
-0.1309531033039093,
0.012086830101907253,
-0.0037360014393925667,
-0.3325515389442444,
-0.002829213859513402,
0.2647877335548401,
0.4194740355014801,
-0.60463547706604,
0.03048831783235073,
-0.4925614595413208,
-0.574743390083313,
0.26269519329071045,
-0.06768950074911118,
0.5858811736106873,
-0.28606265783309937,
-0.20298928022384644,
0.006322735920548439,
-0.6863316297531128,
0.18554279208183289,
0.17009076476097107,
0.20794577896595,
-0.019496211782097816,
0.3465539515018463,
-0.2557253837585449,
0.6645047664642334,
0.21699172258377075,
-0.7373282313346863,
0.29570260643959045,
-0.301008403301239,
-0.2577919065952301,
0.03337588161230087,
0.7114043831825256,
0.35869255661964417,
0.6346399784088135,
-0.0776728093624115,
-0.07883892953395844,
-0.01140169519931078,
0.07302278280258179,
-1.1321181058883667,
-0.7868894338607788,
0.18493178486824036,
-0.46539193391799927,
-0.5064117312431335,
-0.13205267488956451,
-0.9488958120346069,
-0.7485969662666321,
0.08491156250238419,
-0.07664801180362701,
-0.6034262180328369,
-0.620091438293457,
0.02627917192876339,
-0.49622461199760437,
0.3224034905433655,
0.2782896161079407,
-0.8875375986099243,
-0.03215257450938225,
0.3108402192592621,
0.5094918012619019,
0.07815156131982803,
-0.10649421066045761,
-0.6424974799156189,
0.6988059282302856,
-0.1494470089673996,
0.6651021838188171,
-0.6983871459960938,
-0.15160919725894928,
0.331269234418869,
-0.20329034328460693,
0.2216499298810959,
-0.5855030417442322,
0.5808547139167786,
-0.9978179335594177,
0.13972008228302002,
-0.29767900705337524,
-0.580931544303894,
-0.2452651709318161,
0.7148489356040955,
-0.7172341346740723,
0.5853179097175598,
-0.038844507187604904,
-1.1262788772583008,
0.5912941694259644,
-0.38164693117141724,
-0.6927590370178223,
0.37609949707984924,
0.020021753385663033,
-0.30028945207595825,
-0.02700006403028965,
0.23370672762393951,
0.6738574504852295,
-0.34943467378616333,
-0.024948546662926674,
-0.8440015912055969,
0.04363927245140076,
0.24781352281570435,
-0.18651704490184784,
0.8163269758224487,
0.2095201462507248,
-0.46758171916007996,
-0.07417681068181992,
-0.824198305606842,
-0.0589430071413517,
0.10536971688270569,
-0.25089362263679504,
-0.6702675819396973,
-0.39052075147628784,
0.13046757876873016,
0.16669519245624542,
0.14521469175815582,
-0.5302920937538147,
0.0822795182466507,
-0.2965289056301117,
0.3481135368347168,
0.7236161231994629,
0.1958211064338684,
0.29576149582862854,
-0.30962255597114563,
0.5098155736923218,
0.17111313343048096,
0.103207066655159,
-0.6443371176719666,
-0.46146559715270996,
-0.8529284000396729,
-0.5060828328132629,
0.04994269087910652,
0.49417319893836975,
-0.9383738040924072,
0.25911253690719604,
-0.5828468203544617,
-0.6495240926742554,
-0.0464627631008625,
0.0546361543238163,
0.28273335099220276,
0.7771453261375427,
0.26118525862693787,
-0.34468507766723633,
-0.35558784008026123,
-0.9381537437438965,
-0.2269078642129898,
-0.4976578950881958,
-0.03244328871369362,
0.23235198855400085,
0.5479395985603333,
0.04793956130743027,
0.8770595192909241,
-0.5666574239730835,
-0.30480095744132996,
-0.107664093375206,
0.08709768205881119,
-0.09398770332336426,
0.2653653919696808,
0.510774552822113,
-0.8845264315605164,
-0.6465520262718201,
0.07234694808721542,
-0.8256328105926514,
0.11149851232767105,
0.1987084001302719,
0.219074085354805,
-0.19185397028923035,
0.41502416133880615,
-0.6882646083831787,
0.09364259988069534,
0.24527086317539215,
-0.375313401222229,
0.817418098449707,
-0.05239953100681305,
0.5611782073974609,
-1.1673527956008911,
0.33865293860435486,
0.3636043667793274,
-0.21618831157684326,
-0.7708190679550171,
0.2606271207332611,
0.5666767954826355,
-0.4202759563922882,
-0.38263827562332153,
0.8173141479492188,
-0.4319378435611725,
-0.04458939656615257,
-0.015871834009885788,
0.1274927705526352,
0.13851109147071838,
0.5899708867073059,
0.04060416296124458,
0.7066612243652344,
0.6367430090904236,
-0.7777509093284607,
0.8905378580093384,
-0.11881397664546967,
-0.5382740497589111,
1.244422197341919,
-0.33986395597457886,
-0.10559047013521194,
0.04805649071931839,
0.57096928358078,
-1.053073763847351,
-0.561870813369751,
0.7393106818199158,
-0.519508421421051,
0.3223254084587097,
-0.19025596976280212,
-0.6038855314254761,
-0.4044863283634186,
-0.5093674659729004,
0.5055237412452698,
0.21834883093833923,
-0.46918851137161255,
0.7807594537734985,
0.5542149543762207,
-0.2133200466632843,
-0.6574828624725342,
-0.7187639474868774,
0.13333550095558167,
-0.3875514566898346,
-1.02274489402771,
0.2242385596036911,
-0.010791904293000698,
-0.2891053557395935,
-0.3797283172607422,
-0.12332209944725037,
-0.6380788087844849,
-0.09546120464801788,
-0.0189379770308733,
0.09800931066274643,
-0.22558645904064178,
0.44918757677078247,
-0.31119468808174133,
-0.03448030352592468,
0.05788551643490791,
-0.5174994468688965,
0.4420163929462433,
0.1484757512807846,
-0.6238484978675842,
-0.8742569088935852,
-0.04911824315786362,
1.0849488973617554,
-0.4924006462097168,
0.7482864260673523,
0.641531229019165,
-0.49815574288368225,
-0.07334781438112259,
-0.7728939056396484,
-0.3554784059524536,
-0.5302039980888367,
-0.052472177892923355,
-0.2499205321073532,
-0.5716382265090942,
0.41262733936309814,
-0.20089977979660034,
0.22012746334075928,
0.259962260723114,
0.34262362122535706,
-0.014748478308320045,
0.48577186465263367,
0.6647111773490906,
-0.4973893165588379,
0.4149473011493683,
0.18738730251789093,
0.5102083683013916,
-0.3070356249809265,
-0.3365398645401001,
-0.42945754528045654,
-0.11308864504098892,
-0.40223559737205505,
-0.3185121715068817,
0.19928932189941406,
-0.15414918959140778,
-0.36356446146965027,
0.3930318057537079,
-0.23254555463790894,
0.14350612461566925,
0.5409296154975891,
0.12199786305427551,
0.5270823240280151,
0.40373095870018005,
-0.21505048871040344,
-0.08908926695585251,
-0.4722481369972229,
-0.1809161752462387,
1.4795469045639038,
0.16870629787445068,
0.7284390330314636,
0.4072938561439514,
0.2694973945617676,
0.4626633822917938,
0.3965320587158203,
-0.6063939332962036,
0.47966647148132324,
0.259814977645874,
-0.8107938170433044,
-0.1265721172094345,
-0.24751870334148407,
-0.926323413848877,
0.12477420270442963,
-0.0344279520213604,
-0.6155772805213928,
-0.06860387325286865,
0.3734954595565796,
-0.38612979650497437,
0.5156365633010864,
-0.6657453775405884,
0.5932525992393494,
-0.057759642601013184,
-0.3126169741153717,
-0.39847415685653687,
-0.342437207698822,
0.7260215282440186,
-0.25199827551841736,
0.36455509066581726,
-0.08439313620328903,
0.0456385500729084,
0.5941129326820374,
-0.218337744474411,
0.7926215529441833,
-0.07543982565402985,
-0.2619149088859558,
0.21763062477111816,
0.07609176635742188,
0.8165777325630188,
-0.05796953663229942,
-0.013837077654898167,
-0.32311397790908813,
-0.1925199180841446,
-0.5445502996444702,
-0.5692093372344971,
0.5651454925537109,
-0.21740159392356873,
-0.11154764890670776,
-0.330488383769989,
-0.2851247191429138,
-0.3788708746433258,
0.3561367094516754,
0.20609521865844727,
0.5150322914123535,
-0.10208255797624588,
0.27035051584243774,
1.0719828605651855,
-0.27304884791374207,
0.17397747933864594,
0.7189899682998657,
-0.3592897057533264,
-0.5621331930160522,
0.7614585161209106,
-0.28779345750808716,
0.09603694826364517,
0.47048360109329224,
0.07616502791643143,
-0.4273362457752228,
-0.39208945631980896,
-0.46883946657180786,
0.26358816027641296,
-0.9488734006881714,
-0.3000807464122772,
-0.5476131439208984,
-0.09958300739526749,
-0.9702995419502258,
0.05362873151898384,
-0.05075262486934662,
-0.20739848911762238,
0.3348178267478943,
0.12192820012569427,
0.3730790913105011,
0.30113929510116577,
0.20778971910476685,
0.3924087584018707,
-0.8139267563819885,
0.5297963619232178,
0.7126486301422119,
0.21241897344589233,
0.05087671056389809,
-0.4104306399822235,
0.008607722818851471,
-0.04286612570285797,
-0.024309424683451653,
-0.9939028024673462,
0.2455935776233673,
-0.03945307433605194,
0.4191916584968567,
1.0365040302276611,
0.23976892232894897,
0.5352250337600708,
-0.08026369661092758,
0.4520774483680725,
0.5844993591308594,
-0.6275668740272522,
0.4623892903327942,
-0.6560551524162292,
0.3595208525657654,
0.4062754213809967,
0.4727361500263214,
-0.9980217218399048,
-0.20966172218322754,
-0.5454218983650208,
-0.46362292766571045,
0.3767300248146057,
0.2841021418571472,
0.0211167074739933,
0.22499197721481323,
0.046817801892757416,
-0.07862448692321777,
0.4132513999938965,
-1.0529500246047974,
-0.3306785225868225,
0.26768311858177185,
-0.059298619627952576,
0.2581179141998291,
-0.4980792701244354,
-0.10958516597747803,
-0.035762686282396317,
0.8031139969825745,
-0.0678512379527092,
0.0005629531224258244,
-0.23100294172763824,
-0.3823229968547821,
-0.05579471215605736,
0.2789348363876343,
0.2958308160305023,
0.8825029730796814,
0.0805073231458664,
0.2451881617307663,
-0.060142744332551956,
-0.5574695467948914,
-0.026484934613108635,
0.030001793056726456,
-0.31223124265670776,
0.0065842000767588615,
0.5727288722991943,
0.23074254393577576,
0.339234322309494,
-0.9217986464500427,
0.6142162680625916,
0.057766567915678024,
0.1598028838634491,
-0.5653971433639526,
-0.11557130515575409,
0.04076235741376877,
0.17984820902347565,
0.4607272148132324,
0.06575877964496613,
0.13669416308403015,
-0.4646724760532379,
0.5382087826728821,
0.6216312646865845,
-0.2393994927406311,
-0.14465320110321045,
0.21261735260486603,
0.6375235915184021,
-0.18765808641910553,
0.7905023097991943,
-0.11501381546258926,
-0.6259809732437134,
0.5588945746421814,
0.2911997139453888,
0.5826412439346313,
-0.776030957698822,
0.13225184381008148,
0.37155836820602417,
0.41399338841438293,
0.10264864563941956,
-0.08618436008691788,
-0.32907846570014954,
-0.8803784251213074,
-0.1088588759303093,
-0.4787316918373108,
-0.35821333527565,
0.5148160457611084,
-0.37624868750572205,
0.5072336792945862,
-0.6138094663619995,
-0.028112560510635376,
0.1927623748779297,
-0.24697956442832947,
-0.48710697889328003,
0.15614211559295654,
0.10029898583889008,
1.0724903345108032,
-0.7400485873222351,
0.8513746857643127,
0.42820197343826294,
-0.22643373906612396,
-0.6173810362815857,
0.18524420261383057,
0.41606244444847107,
-0.9252260327339172,
0.7179945111274719,
0.4537750780582428,
-0.27614790201187134,
-0.02126132696866989,
-0.11154433339834213,
-0.6877219080924988,
0.983944296836853,
0.20319238305091858,
-0.4399436116218567,
-0.08693400770425797,
0.1212819293141365,
0.30737921595573425,
-0.03488147631287575,
0.2311972826719284,
0.31968244910240173,
0.49481114745140076,
0.2516242563724518,
-0.9359805583953857,
-0.1329670548439026,
-0.35116010904312134,
-0.6576699614524841,
0.3410798907279968,
-0.3623625636100769,
0.5179216265678406,
0.1683637648820877,
-0.17988312244415283,
-0.2620715796947479,
0.5235453844070435,
0.35932621359825134,
0.20640729367733002,
0.417675256729126,
0.6647420525550842,
0.9432148933410645,
0.3322177827358246,
0.6483823657035828,
-0.6607658863067627,
0.19577589631080627,
0.8819119334220886,
-0.19488507509231567,
0.7259864211082458,
0.2736092209815979,
-0.091575488448143,
0.4833908677101135,
0.558314323425293,
-0.08371289074420929,
0.29958197474479675,
0.2921786904335022,
-0.6366097927093506,
-0.365386962890625,
-0.10454872250556946,
-0.5193098187446594,
0.48352232575416565,
0.32814550399780273,
-0.6430763006210327,
-0.5016462206840515,
0.013280794024467468,
0.06991851329803467,
-0.29413077235221863,
-0.40235936641693115,
0.23790200054645538,
-0.11515343189239502,
-0.6952981352806091,
0.4356066584587097,
0.16288036108016968,
0.8115933537483215,
-0.83906090259552,
0.32748785614967346,
-0.15421542525291443,
0.47595953941345215,
-0.027459392324090004,
-0.3966704308986664,
-0.02277282625436783,
0.09435063600540161,
0.15091219544410706,
-0.25472232699394226,
1.290900468826294,
-0.27424320578575134,
-0.4549979269504547,
0.07807569205760956,
0.46438077092170715,
0.07337255030870438,
-0.25386756658554077,
-0.8083181977272034,
-0.14661768078804016,
-0.07999001443386078,
-0.25488045811653137,
0.2659260630607605,
0.4364725351333618,
0.19825032353401184,
1.2392455339431763,
0.7126395106315613,
-0.08185049146413803,
0.08843780308961868,
-0.17349156737327576,
0.691210150718689,
-0.3439711332321167,
-0.6407653093338013,
-0.9096446633338928,
0.3115120232105255,
-0.6178619265556335,
-0.1557377725839615,
0.9119884371757507,
0.8634056448936462,
0.8171659708023071,
0.03166818618774414,
0.8066710829734802,
-0.0032661007717251778,
0.4536660611629486,
-0.19075600802898407,
0.5789000391960144,
-0.49269264936447144,
0.15798337757587433,
-0.31335657835006714,
-0.7450372576713562,
-0.33430030941963196,
0.3553718030452728,
-0.17012183368206024,
0.03823745995759964,
0.563109278678894,
0.7486958503723145,
-0.4160707890987396,
0.14886893332004547,
0.350757360458374,
-0.12271025031805038,
0.39903223514556885,
0.5215962529182434,
0.597954273223877,
-0.3062170445919037,
0.9855051040649414,
-0.32927563786506653,
-0.259272962808609,
-0.40018489956855774,
-0.757620632648468,
-1.0379328727722168,
-0.5546234250068665,
-0.34174686670303345,
-0.33364248275756836,
-0.141850084066391,
0.5886372327804565,
1.0053478479385376,
-0.89472895860672,
-0.14238403737545013,
0.1300908625125885,
-0.19188620150089264,
0.17893558740615845,
-0.18110935389995575,
0.17698200047016144,
-0.3764162063598633,
-0.5531487464904785,
0.0863746926188469,
0.7192778587341309,
0.1860942840576172,
-0.48468226194381714,
0.11413069814443588,
-0.06287845224142075,
0.09495670348405838,
0.5936548113822937,
0.4658288359642029,
-0.7249335050582886,
0.022257806733250618,
0.07766707241535187,
-0.38470250368118286,
-0.04090499505400658,
1.123826265335083,
-0.6812474131584167,
0.5298998951911926,
0.590349018573761,
0.6905032992362976,
0.42290017008781433,
-0.33811965584754944,
0.540196418762207,
-0.4333623945713043,
0.14351427555084229,
0.29900306463241577,
0.5474309921264648,
0.23550155758857727,
-0.14359724521636963,
0.2238108068704605,
0.6127281188964844,
-0.13117477297782898,
-0.4931633770465851,
0.6627463698387146,
-0.7418582439422607,
-0.5614815354347229,
1.0561273097991943,
-0.45325276255607605,
0.0048752278089523315,
-0.5582482218742371,
0.02843206375837326,
0.17144286632537842,
-0.4607880413532257,
0.9416249990463257,
0.8501920700073242,
0.282887727022171,
-0.29754820466041565,
-0.358731746673584,
0.6632948517799377,
0.2451980859041214,
-1.134076476097107,
0.2257857769727707,
0.7316843867301941,
0.45814961194992065,
0.2426883727312088,
0.909879744052887,
0.27270492911338806,
0.5145378708839417,
-0.11012402921915054,
-0.16524770855903625,
0.06226162612438202,
-0.3099637031555176,
0.2087196707725525,
0.6368649005889893,
-0.06056831777095795,
-0.021293142810463905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02247v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02247v1
|
Birbal: An efficient 7B instruct-model fine-tuned with curated datasets
| 2024-03-04T17:34:46 | 2024-03-04T17:34:46 |
Ashvini Kumar Jindal, Pawan Kumar Rajpoot, Ankur Parikh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
LLMOps incur significant costs due to hardware requirements, hindering their
widespread accessibility. Additionally, a lack of transparency in model
training methods and data contributes to the majority of models being
non-reproducible. To tackle these challenges, the LLM Efficiency Challenge was
introduced at NeurIPS Workshop, aiming to adapt foundation models on a diverse
set of tasks via fine-tuning on a single GPU (RTX 4090 or A100 with 40GB)
within a 24-hour timeframe. In this system description paper, we introduce
Birbal, our Mistral-7B based winning model, fine-tuned on a single RTX 4090 for
16 hours. Birbal's success lies in curating high-quality instructions covering
diverse tasks, resulting in a 35% performance improvement over second-best
Qwen-14B based submission.
|
[
-0.3740866780281067,
-0.7509512305259705,
0.01769779622554779,
0.529960572719574,
-0.41421040892601013,
-0.001987988827750087,
0.051611922681331635,
-0.5501608848571777,
-0.5695495009422302,
0.4230700135231018,
-0.5598146319389343,
-0.22682759165763855,
-0.6797910332679749,
0.09768809378147125,
-0.3941672742366791,
0.7967349886894226,
0.13413019478321075,
-0.021203551441431046,
-0.13371765613555908,
-0.13862895965576172,
-0.5254780650138855,
-0.14721889793872833,
-0.651334285736084,
-0.6453684568405151,
0.27831292152404785,
0.46563372015953064,
0.8349169492721558,
0.603905439376831,
0.7926578521728516,
0.2663424611091614,
-0.436336487531662,
0.4615030288696289,
-0.8725317120552063,
0.0314970389008522,
-0.37800663709640503,
-0.5318068861961365,
-0.4120890498161316,
-0.22811216115951538,
0.5294577479362488,
0.6740383505821228,
-0.6098634004592896,
0.487969309091568,
0.4307422637939453,
0.9201430678367615,
-0.7304759621620178,
0.26461249589920044,
-0.5811166763305664,
-0.08431538939476013,
-0.3220290243625641,
-0.19730228185653687,
-0.5004221796989441,
-0.36041417717933655,
-0.14821845293045044,
-0.4597855806350708,
0.4980354607105255,
0.24256651103496552,
0.8459472060203552,
0.6956815123558044,
-0.1580657958984375,
-0.26428472995758057,
-0.652706503868103,
0.353256493806839,
-0.8559052348136902,
0.4218268096446991,
0.109737828373909,
0.6204356551170349,
-0.40874847769737244,
-0.8653053045272827,
-0.15079118311405182,
0.04189785197377205,
0.32533273100852966,
0.03696611896157265,
-0.3448149859905243,
0.024106713011860847,
0.4924367666244507,
0.3261357545852661,
-0.40678703784942627,
0.0888432040810585,
-0.4484935998916626,
0.03211821988224983,
0.45173218846321106,
0.42275798320770264,
-0.21152101457118988,
0.045498233288526535,
-0.3394412100315094,
0.07213921844959259,
-0.850870668888092,
0.21203731000423431,
0.4394226372241974,
0.1625547856092453,
-0.39168238639831543,
0.519020140171051,
-0.31950321793556213,
0.8585938811302185,
0.5294066071510315,
-0.18139511346817017,
-0.015020991675555706,
-0.13040916621685028,
-0.5274501442909241,
-0.06196279078722,
0.05792580172419548,
0.19368086755275726,
-0.16037999093532562,
-0.30551549792289734,
-0.4486438035964966,
0.22625283896923065,
0.36732983589172363,
-1.1477690935134888,
-0.46155571937561035,
-0.08217799663543701,
-0.47370755672454834,
-0.21691422164440155,
-0.16929316520690918,
-0.3845743238925934,
-0.1930556744337082,
-0.40217849612236023,
0.4034268260002136,
-0.2534589171409607,
0.04819805547595024,
0.2236352115869522,
-0.1490367203950882,
0.18461410701274872,
0.681897759437561,
-0.7337155938148499,
0.30028656125068665,
0.7180782556533813,
0.8889696002006531,
0.02277723327279091,
-0.014377635903656483,
-0.7742390632629395,
0.20553924143314362,
-0.5510705709457397,
0.677229106426239,
-0.5202829241752625,
-0.7401648759841919,
-0.36423608660697937,
0.06561692804098129,
0.1780235916376114,
-0.8106849789619446,
0.46000635623931885,
-0.5523810386657715,
-0.0893634632229805,
-0.332810640335083,
-0.5109072327613831,
-0.36876073479652405,
0.24994821846485138,
-0.49548813700675964,
1.2757456302642822,
0.5081475973129272,
-0.5272753238677979,
0.1718709021806717,
-0.5189822912216187,
-0.31999558210372925,
0.31837186217308044,
0.162284255027771,
-0.3573411703109741,
0.6579310297966003,
-0.06139689311385155,
0.5490970015525818,
-0.8566804528236389,
0.4718601107597351,
-0.4374177157878876,
-0.5145608186721802,
-0.16247214376926422,
-0.5325019955635071,
0.732876718044281,
0.07799936830997467,
-0.5868797898292542,
0.005528779234737158,
-0.8529722690582275,
-0.03572200611233711,
-0.21789589524269104,
-0.609962522983551,
0.18998154997825623,
-0.3434407711029053,
0.12771831452846527,
0.14711709320545197,
0.2580800950527191,
-0.3682001531124115,
0.2979063093662262,
-0.3451124131679535,
0.34060490131378174,
1.0273094177246094,
-0.37772417068481445,
0.32390284538269043,
-0.5461809635162354,
0.5344732999801636,
-0.26001518964767456,
0.7124442458152771,
0.4125586152076721,
-0.503146767616272,
-0.6767366528511047,
-0.3446536064147949,
0.34685564041137695,
0.2138056755065918,
-0.5837863087654114,
-0.13837280869483948,
-0.095488041639328,
-0.8376466631889343,
-0.4648519456386566,
0.4438307285308838,
0.6572185158729553,
0.7525306940078735,
0.3570168614387512,
-0.2230975478887558,
-0.06234346330165863,
-1.2345805168151855,
0.16774068772792816,
0.30932846665382385,
0.4966888129711151,
0.4620097875595093,
0.5529521703720093,
-0.25186946988105774,
0.3575468063354492,
-0.24126078188419342,
-0.02604268118739128,
-0.20194515585899353,
0.08428123593330383,
0.5397419929504395,
0.4320177137851715,
0.7051825523376465,
-0.6583427786827087,
-0.6849058270454407,
0.22416837513446808,
-0.7383137941360474,
-0.42930975556373596,
0.4009974002838135,
-0.23421232402324677,
0.30133092403411865,
0.4729228615760803,
-0.5217682123184204,
0.7187284827232361,
0.6767983436584473,
-0.3026590943336487,
0.6823285222053528,
-0.48147737979888916,
0.0611901730298996,
-0.7441424131393433,
0.010749868117272854,
-0.40407997369766235,
-0.12652713060379028,
-0.2442101240158081,
0.048544991761446,
0.23826035857200623,
-0.20991064608097076,
-0.40722474455833435,
0.641951322555542,
-0.7260279059410095,
-0.17453087866306305,
-0.5510683655738831,
-0.3710857331752777,
0.013145074248313904,
0.4214358925819397,
-0.3395776152610779,
0.7081414461135864,
0.5813706517219543,
-0.725834310054779,
0.3282659351825714,
0.10012451559305191,
-0.4525393545627594,
0.5974790453910828,
-0.8793918490409851,
0.21482007205486298,
-0.19519782066345215,
0.028924254700541496,
-0.5887119770050049,
-0.27639979124069214,
0.15971960127353668,
-0.09849287569522858,
0.5196262001991272,
-0.43505746126174927,
-0.5227642059326172,
-0.04924502968788147,
-0.00193101167678833,
0.24751895666122437,
0.49290698766708374,
-0.8664416670799255,
0.9330511093139648,
0.0766199380159378,
-0.021150607615709305,
-0.7332164645195007,
-0.5434387922286987,
-0.15774191915988922,
-0.08037494868040085,
-0.807355523109436,
0.5073254704475403,
-0.1664617657661438,
-0.025529878214001656,
0.22499121725559235,
-0.2821582555770874,
0.171913281083107,
0.4787498414516449,
0.7857207655906677,
0.2968355119228363,
-0.1557878851890564,
-0.13411474227905273,
0.2825692594051361,
-0.12193229794502258,
-0.1771724671125412,
0.09958399832248688,
0.5786787867546082,
-0.15819278359413147,
-0.4832250475883484,
-0.685084879398346,
0.19802255928516388,
0.4811682403087616,
-0.005230758339166641,
0.46292346715927124,
0.4304264187812805,
-0.4236130714416504,
-0.7182513475418091,
-0.6969584226608276,
0.10338135808706284,
-0.5204887986183167,
0.2510213553905487,
-0.4866112172603607,
-0.6513690948486328,
0.44120052456855774,
-0.27256613969802856,
0.41706743836402893,
0.3261227607727051,
0.7657840847969055,
0.0804990753531456,
0.8422858715057373,
0.7532837986946106,
0.03648877143859863,
0.4722020924091339,
-0.5325906872749329,
-0.10123156756162643,
-0.769792377948761,
-0.6034131646156311,
-0.7273639440536499,
-0.6577519178390503,
-0.15863913297653198,
-0.6478487849235535,
0.45819973945617676,
0.5919618606567383,
-0.5022542476654053,
0.08799975365400314,
-0.7338293194770813,
0.3822553753852844,
0.7021253705024719,
0.2689802944660187,
0.1816127598285675,
-0.052757568657398224,
0.08934774994850159,
0.36602669954299927,
-1.1674365997314453,
-0.42450329661369324,
1.1193510293960571,
-0.12007221579551697,
1.0823642015457153,
0.44704073667526245,
0.7046555876731873,
0.39509230852127075,
0.73680579662323,
-0.11768180131912231,
0.35383063554763794,
-0.12180589884519577,
-0.6773317456245422,
-0.00602684635668993,
-0.17379216849803925,
-0.7971090078353882,
0.24590229988098145,
-0.21689526736736298,
-0.46972912549972534,
0.5308883786201477,
0.3613704442977905,
-0.3111763298511505,
0.17122988402843475,
-0.7472834587097168,
0.7880261540412903,
-0.34776321053504944,
-0.7501497268676758,
-0.4210110902786255,
-0.5236859917640686,
0.28719431161880493,
0.3007538318634033,
0.05311378091573715,
-0.29082995653152466,
0.17844527959823608,
0.44998690485954285,
-0.5228739380836487,
0.6324151754379272,
-0.3609599471092224,
0.488912969827652,
0.20540711283683777,
0.13598991930484772,
0.5840034484863281,
0.20765338838100433,
-0.28809234499931335,
0.17237280309200287,
0.03223465755581856,
-0.5565214157104492,
-0.6689649820327759,
0.7890982627868652,
-0.8499299883842468,
-0.6042267680168152,
-0.4359123110771179,
-0.7549412250518799,
-0.1812552660703659,
-0.06164296716451645,
0.30282852053642273,
0.8371731042861938,
-0.10934696346521378,
0.7153970003128052,
0.5588880181312561,
0.04184606671333313,
0.5564061403274536,
0.4373038411140442,
-0.20792648196220398,
-0.28550752997398376,
0.6366396546363831,
0.05558580905199051,
0.3442363142967224,
0.21504710614681244,
0.23511143028736115,
-0.23364488780498505,
-0.8494129180908203,
-0.6955591440200806,
-0.023799287155270576,
-0.5731179118156433,
-0.5925114154815674,
-0.3530970811843872,
-0.08882590383291245,
-0.31411105394363403,
-0.4413043260574341,
-0.43983903527259827,
-0.20267029106616974,
-0.5503830909729004,
0.05069156736135483,
0.11107328534126282,
0.8285149335861206,
-0.31345584988594055,
0.5636932849884033,
-0.5448217391967773,
0.3923241198062897,
0.01610291376709938,
0.22262682020664215,
0.19690968096256256,
-0.8995938897132874,
-0.29998284578323364,
-0.02163049578666687,
-0.5901166200637817,
-0.6084445118904114,
0.5179604291915894,
0.2219611406326294,
0.7375422716140747,
0.431857705116272,
-0.1711588054895401,
0.9122360348701477,
-0.09145733714103699,
0.2882237136363983,
0.1498454362154007,
-0.8248376250267029,
0.3801169693470001,
-0.061731595546007156,
0.3040682077407837,
0.4959222674369812,
0.22998382151126862,
0.0780043825507164,
0.06320815533399582,
-0.8374021053314209,
-0.5623327493667603,
0.5793399214744568,
0.08021151274442673,
-0.21034874022006989,
0.2819737195968628,
0.5798136591911316,
0.28347063064575195,
0.26422786712646484,
-0.347753643989563,
-0.020574692636728287,
-0.33516359329223633,
-0.06345025449991226,
-0.11317586153745651,
-0.2931392192840576,
-0.20305073261260986,
-0.2345997542142868,
1.047646403312683,
-0.07826663553714752,
-0.175265371799469,
0.12517979741096497,
-0.2554704248905182,
0.19261498749256134,
0.0991700068116188,
0.4939466714859009,
0.8837489485740662,
-0.3505699932575226,
-0.0893750935792923,
0.07644153386354446,
-0.22286584973335266,
-0.07596269249916077,
0.19713124632835388,
-0.3541991412639618,
-0.023780716583132744,
0.34201905131340027,
0.8984119296073914,
0.42225268483161926,
-0.5086135268211365,
0.07779720425605774,
0.03898175060749054,
-0.1178421825170517,
0.2523592710494995,
0.32989487051963806,
0.38754546642303467,
0.6752148866653442,
0.20324088633060455,
0.15074993669986725,
0.17592935264110565,
-0.5251397490501404,
-0.2087997943162918,
0.5850978493690491,
-0.1983071118593216,
-0.28075626492500305,
0.7359645366668701,
0.219229593873024,
-0.48062705993652344,
0.6835045218467712,
-0.23536145687103271,
-0.24704815447330475,
0.7789238691329956,
0.6212893724441528,
0.5004681944847107,
-0.2541210651397705,
0.039133209735155106,
0.21023444831371307,
0.4191048741340637,
-0.3298960328102112,
0.5294066071510315,
0.031295087188482285,
-0.4896116554737091,
-0.1116279885172844,
-0.8239401578903198,
-0.5485327243804932,
-0.2413434386253357,
-0.702542781829834,
0.3746810853481293,
-0.987557053565979,
-0.17031538486480713,
0.10340004414319992,
-0.052481651306152344,
-0.9452622532844543,
0.19140560925006866,
-0.11023205518722534,
1.104771614074707,
-0.5857788920402527,
0.7010852098464966,
0.4631904661655426,
0.020009834319353104,
-1.000672698020935,
-1.0953370332717896,
-0.0855310708284378,
-0.7395321130752563,
0.8116569519042969,
0.03357750177383423,
-0.2228439897298813,
-0.0008593920501880348,
-0.6211091876029968,
-0.6270590424537659,
1.33896803855896,
0.86589515209198,
-0.9140593409538269,
-0.10691291093826294,
-0.12390229851007462,
0.329723984003067,
-0.3888654112815857,
0.09392854571342468,
0.17552122473716736,
0.4260016977787018,
0.09365162998437881,
-0.8312163352966309,
-0.28213995695114136,
-0.34359461069107056,
-0.07226932048797607,
0.2748529613018036,
-0.7299858927726746,
0.9705485105514526,
-0.3420989513397217,
-0.04740143194794655,
-0.020666269585490227,
0.5715940594673157,
0.2163778841495514,
0.43252113461494446,
0.2920321226119995,
0.9261578321456909,
0.7918298244476318,
-0.06229354813694954,
1.2741413116455078,
-0.6198952794075012,
0.3647317886352539,
1.334856629371643,
-0.14041545987129211,
0.589243471622467,
0.3069228529930115,
-0.07104621082544327,
0.23877882957458496,
0.6193939447402954,
-0.12142568826675415,
0.5987362861633301,
0.25430378317832947,
-0.23840223252773285,
-0.6226391196250916,
-0.1804814636707306,
-0.5600126385688782,
0.40640488266944885,
0.14474332332611084,
-0.02402927353978157,
-0.5769634246826172,
-0.11185620725154877,
-0.38518044352531433,
-0.23255889117717743,
-0.4440530240535736,
0.4431159198284149,
0.08737219125032425,
-0.442754864692688,
0.5389657020568848,
0.1314663589000702,
0.5567598938941956,
-0.6699041128158569,
-0.15247799456119537,
-0.5043056011199951,
0.37774530053138733,
-0.31647437810897827,
-0.22285649180412292,
0.16755889356136322,
-0.26476436853408813,
-0.46750718355178833,
-0.010509531944990158,
0.6991142630577087,
0.01694788597524166,
-0.7956830263137817,
0.19104865193367004,
0.44621753692626953,
-0.010950825177133083,
-0.17569421231746674,
-0.6997188329696655,
0.18411758542060852,
-0.08455206453800201,
-0.21216461062431335,
0.35497552156448364,
0.4232161045074463,
-0.14554248750209808,
1.2064414024353027,
0.9206066727638245,
-0.05654928460717201,
0.38668909668922424,
-0.026529043912887573,
0.9450427293777466,
-0.47428444027900696,
-0.3389597535133362,
-0.6569644808769226,
0.27667924761772156,
0.030333423987030983,
-0.674357533454895,
0.5633055567741394,
1.087705373764038,
0.7729395627975464,
0.01885383203625679,
0.6757497191429138,
-0.0888785645365715,
0.22308726608753204,
-0.39098116755485535,
0.3480295240879059,
-0.7223895192146301,
0.23232968151569366,
0.06259646266698837,
-0.8754025101661682,
0.11811941117048264,
0.4140191376209259,
0.03465194255113602,
-0.199082151055336,
0.35835617780685425,
1.2039459943771362,
-0.3399488627910614,
0.18986888229846954,
0.33862629532814026,
0.13111168146133423,
0.17209908366203308,
0.7354624271392822,
0.6130141019821167,
-0.3245686888694763,
0.3386669158935547,
-0.6075277328491211,
-0.36067599058151245,
-0.4979092478752136,
-0.9025920033454895,
-0.7903662323951721,
-0.17522238194942474,
-0.31506744027137756,
-0.32793882489204407,
0.48348724842071533,
0.6522438526153564,
0.756741464138031,
-0.5590664744377136,
-0.31359416246414185,
0.12078515440225601,
0.1825634390115738,
-0.30421748757362366,
-0.09793659299612045,
0.4473360776901245,
-0.14475426077842712,
-0.6385471820831299,
0.3423071503639221,
0.7015978097915649,
-0.11290791630744934,
-0.08084066212177277,
-0.05765019729733467,
-0.17914432287216187,
-0.0597909651696682,
0.5497511625289917,
0.03165801987051964,
-0.6263795495033264,
-0.16521750390529633,
-0.04747610166668892,
-0.0862022116780281,
-0.0458318255841732,
0.6487664580345154,
-0.5926525592803955,
0.2905332148075104,
0.5417059659957886,
0.9383233785629272,
0.9087920188903809,
0.07835542410612106,
0.3486109673976898,
-0.03148640692234039,
0.08958707004785538,
0.27106302976608276,
0.4547547996044159,
0.32351553440093994,
-0.1509234458208084,
0.8569449782371521,
0.34374234080314636,
-0.6553221344947815,
-0.9978335499763489,
-0.02536742202937603,
-1.482590675354004,
-0.3036705553531647,
0.8835464715957642,
-0.0628906786441803,
-0.3686012327671051,
-0.07298752665519714,
-0.24579961597919464,
0.12435968220233917,
-0.21527501940727234,
0.8590452671051025,
0.5827475786209106,
-0.314217746257782,
-0.059984371066093445,
-0.6839231848716736,
0.26205748319625854,
0.3298143148422241,
-0.8040271401405334,
-0.13927879929542542,
0.6613097190856934,
0.5194617509841919,
-0.28868311643600464,
0.4218997359275818,
-0.08160503953695297,
0.576483428478241,
0.20434299111366272,
0.17448781430721283,
-0.6642046570777893,
-0.43751293420791626,
0.06760390102863312,
0.653160035610199,
0.10428395122289658,
0.06049289181828499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02246v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02246v2
|
PHAnToM: Personality Has An Effect on Theory-of-Mind Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-03-04T17:34:34 | 2024-03-19T03:42:31 |
Fiona Anting Tan, Gerard Christopher Yeo, Fanyou Wu, Weijie Xu, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha, Kokil Jaidka, Yang Liu, See-Kiong Ng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) demonstrate that their
capabilities are comparable, or even superior, to humans in many tasks in
natural language processing. Despite this progress, LLMs are still inadequate
at social-cognitive reasoning, which humans are naturally good at. Drawing
inspiration from psychological research on the links between certain
personality traits and Theory-of-Mind (ToM) reasoning, and from prompt
engineering research on the hyper-sensitivity of prompts in affecting LLMs
capabilities, this study investigates how inducing personalities in LLMs using
prompts affects their ToM reasoning capabilities. Our findings show that
certain induced personalities can significantly affect the LLMs' reasoning
capabilities in three different ToM tasks. In particular, traits from the Dark
Triad have a larger variable effect on LLMs like GPT-3.5, Llama 2, and Mistral
across the different ToM tasks. We find that LLMs that exhibit a higher
variance across personality prompts in ToM also tends to be more controllable
in personality tests: personality traits in LLMs like GPT-3.5, Llama 2 and
Mistral can be controllably adjusted through our personality prompts. In
today's landscape where role-play is a common strategy when using LLMs, our
research highlights the need for caution, as models that adopt specific
personas with personalities potentially also alter their reasoning abilities in
an unexpected manner.
|
[
-0.6396118998527527,
-0.7210493087768555,
1.0864551067352295,
0.2054104506969452,
-0.10702690482139587,
-0.02601812779903412,
-0.2845986783504486,
-0.44481074810028076,
0.3095834255218506,
0.5215935111045837,
-0.4844163656234741,
0.16334544122219086,
-0.4139087200164795,
0.2737342417240143,
-0.0434131994843483,
0.6577218174934387,
0.38684558868408203,
0.19767063856124878,
-0.1253381222486496,
0.014963824301958084,
-0.6240643858909607,
-0.9391471147537231,
-0.7162362337112427,
-0.4344944953918457,
1.033766508102417,
0.3277278244495392,
0.7235956788063049,
0.20360229909420013,
0.2019212245941162,
0.30757832527160645,
-0.11626864969730377,
-0.010452035814523697,
-0.4671851694583893,
0.36209598183631897,
-0.6337904334068298,
-0.6826806664466858,
-0.5309299230575562,
0.04779081046581268,
0.6732608079910278,
0.6206894516944885,
-0.0004192008636891842,
-0.1779826134443283,
0.04375078156590462,
0.6156135201454163,
-0.5851088762283325,
-0.1281920224428177,
-0.66637122631073,
-0.42432358860969543,
-0.2708930969238281,
-0.4496806859970093,
-0.4135110080242157,
-0.11751790344715118,
0.29500114917755127,
-0.34192806482315063,
-0.029735254123806953,
0.3612142503261566,
0.6349679231643677,
0.34813547134399414,
-0.5325838327407837,
0.027926582843065262,
-0.7881975173950195,
0.7281786799430847,
-0.4740189015865326,
0.17479240894317627,
0.306754469871521,
0.2963927686214447,
-0.36760255694389343,
0.042086079716682434,
-1.027742624282837,
-0.19824928045272827,
-0.16963927447795868,
-0.06092320755124092,
0.041155654937028885,
0.2871602773666382,
0.6803916096687317,
0.26688724756240845,
-0.23749621212482452,
0.14840580523014069,
-0.072754867374897,
0.01189178042113781,
0.5541284084320068,
0.2666154205799103,
0.01124169584363699,
-0.24658459424972534,
0.17225749790668488,
-0.12657707929611206,
-0.6926320791244507,
-0.02293674647808075,
0.5010536313056946,
-0.010665724985301495,
0.07054953277111053,
0.5710871815681458,
-0.13910341262817383,
0.6166759729385376,
0.4411989450454712,
-0.10007207095623016,
-0.24086995422840118,
0.023412400856614113,
-0.26400524377822876,
-0.12418495118618011,
0.4238455295562744,
0.3836127519607544,
0.7229193449020386,
0.041566457599401474,
-0.10028478503227234,
0.3120289742946625,
0.28951364755630493,
-0.45134779810905457,
-0.04616788029670715,
0.3231152892112732,
-0.35168319940567017,
-0.1561591923236847,
0.12240584194660187,
-0.5638503432273865,
-0.9955551028251648,
-0.47833535075187683,
0.20590420067310333,
-0.570281982421875,
-0.5110085010528564,
0.3091702461242676,
-0.38948318362236023,
0.4826516807079315,
0.44794410467147827,
-0.9366017580032349,
0.014985940419137478,
0.630142092704773,
0.5053654909133911,
-0.23497016727924347,
-0.33708152174949646,
-0.3585015833377838,
0.18518421053886414,
-0.25653302669525146,
0.7127057909965515,
-0.6428799033164978,
-0.5775014758110046,
-0.2475317269563675,
-0.23986564576625824,
-0.04441239312291145,
-0.4649755358695984,
0.24902646243572235,
-0.20128127932548523,
0.2445307970046997,
-0.9349433183670044,
-0.3328789174556732,
-0.11535140872001648,
0.060823921114206314,
-0.31333526968955994,
0.5180143117904663,
0.18850712478160858,
-0.5915395021438599,
0.3310333788394928,
-0.4873259663581848,
-0.3331575095653534,
0.07882657647132874,
-0.5202756524085999,
0.21887238323688507,
0.3076024651527405,
-0.1208142638206482,
0.7709423303604126,
-0.4773288369178772,
0.33949485421180725,
-0.5445886254310608,
-0.4091237485408783,
1.0024627447128296,
-0.127055823802948,
0.8667338490486145,
-0.10668476670980453,
-0.2846935987472534,
0.095726378262043,
-0.4820074737071991,
-0.10700450837612152,
0.18223096430301666,
0.006835144478827715,
-0.5881115198135376,
0.22702381014823914,
-0.27255120873451233,
0.45810744166374207,
-0.13228486478328705,
-0.29967695474624634,
0.35380464792251587,
-0.228822723031044,
0.29738232493400574,
1.0019341707229614,
0.2797011137008667,
0.4380572736263275,
-0.7258235216140747,
0.4364873170852661,
0.004375620745122433,
-0.08697477728128433,
-0.0037250490859150887,
-0.5629627108573914,
-1.0167722702026367,
-0.4109726846218109,
-0.23996660113334656,
0.43230944871902466,
-0.7426480650901794,
0.6988612413406372,
-0.04286311939358711,
-0.4955112040042877,
-0.10174823552370071,
-0.18201644718647003,
0.5420040488243103,
0.332765132188797,
0.15777678787708282,
-0.10501650720834732,
-0.4041326344013214,
-0.9050645232200623,
-0.45866402983665466,
-0.31232789158821106,
-0.05008013918995857,
0.46469685435295105,
0.4555683135986328,
-0.0018681002547964454,
0.9190683364868164,
-0.581587016582489,
0.04760678485035896,
-0.45575442910194397,
-0.19975611567497253,
0.125703826546669,
0.5123194456100464,
0.7669376730918884,
-0.4862886667251587,
-0.09888727217912674,
-0.34319818019866943,
-0.4901736080646515,
-0.1907404065132141,
-0.4074757695198059,
-0.26418372988700867,
0.18174703419208527,
0.33252525329589844,
-0.9598706364631653,
0.22266614437103271,
0.2622326910495758,
-0.788704514503479,
0.8569802641868591,
0.11614024639129639,
0.16510097682476044,
-0.7685228586196899,
-0.028053313493728638,
0.14904962480068207,
0.15592065453529358,
-0.5265169739723206,
0.12364459782838821,
-0.1492667943239212,
0.30988311767578125,
-0.17988033592700958,
0.8465251922607422,
-0.2927713096141815,
-0.2608162462711334,
-0.17187055945396423,
0.18879126012325287,
0.04996644705533981,
0.5799393057823181,
0.04739676043391228,
0.8982937335968018,
0.7049452662467957,
-1.1255921125411987,
0.2580123245716095,
0.08746474981307983,
-0.16923284530639648,
1.04608154296875,
-0.47485047578811646,
0.28123441338539124,
-0.24967211484909058,
0.42442938685417175,
-0.9334414601325989,
-0.37651365995407104,
0.34768247604370117,
-0.43616369366645813,
0.2249511033296585,
0.3366573452949524,
-0.5494058728218079,
-0.2331564575433731,
-0.050209492444992065,
-0.05943871662020683,
0.6072070598602295,
-0.37742117047309875,
0.8284205198287964,
0.03797899931669235,
-0.03909032791852951,
-0.1088290736079216,
-0.6463677883148193,
-0.0004516145563684404,
-0.4924008250236511,
-0.3421097695827484,
0.355383038520813,
-0.4609813094139099,
-0.9498300552368164,
-0.47176221013069153,
-0.07410790026187897,
0.04394556209445,
0.3743056058883667,
0.22483523190021515,
0.2259342223405838,
0.10527744889259338,
0.265044629573822,
0.18093159794807434,
-0.09167387336492538,
0.3778098225593567,
-0.21391522884368896,
0.4838383197784424,
-0.10692581534385681,
-0.19571566581726074,
-0.4614937901496887,
0.23659227788448334,
0.7870707511901855,
-0.19233345985412598,
0.8603385090827942,
0.0035264259204268456,
-0.18499869108200073,
-0.23788009583950043,
-0.8110121488571167,
-0.6015126705169678,
-0.4905238151550293,
0.11113845556974411,
-0.563021719455719,
-0.9087638258934021,
0.5081095695495605,
0.1496250480413437,
-0.23153987526893616,
0.20421148836612701,
0.6439627408981323,
-0.2598583996295929,
1.1030741930007935,
0.3923342525959015,
0.18843583762645721,
0.48678722977638245,
-0.007466204464435577,
0.14634329080581665,
-1.108821153640747,
0.005919629707932472,
-0.4052436947822571,
-0.46395185589790344,
-0.44352099299430847,
-0.20078986883163452,
0.12945227324962616,
-0.07493886351585388,
-0.3286762833595276,
-0.01235482469201088,
-0.5236549973487854,
0.5438187718391418,
0.1991897076368332,
0.09838835150003433,
0.25990161299705505,
-0.5006734728813171,
-0.08921618014574051,
-0.016101494431495667,
-0.3720279037952423,
-0.599712610244751,
1.0432355403900146,
0.2501847445964813,
0.4626985788345337,
0.460889607667923,
0.2410891205072403,
0.0029498350340873003,
0.1571044623851776,
-0.6342307925224304,
0.9051620364189148,
0.1950654238462448,
-0.8670666813850403,
-0.2012479305267334,
-0.007535697426646948,
-0.5543509125709534,
0.23476605117321014,
-0.3548385202884674,
-0.9335971474647522,
0.4308537542819977,
0.26501724123954773,
-0.5975420475006104,
0.07319378107786179,
-0.6941542625427246,
0.23737302422523499,
-0.27237188816070557,
-0.431025892496109,
-0.43241527676582336,
-0.5253324508666992,
0.63048255443573,
-0.170301616191864,
-0.24786967039108276,
-0.09993667155504227,
-0.012498239055275917,
0.42968225479125977,
-0.08001267164945602,
0.8198513388633728,
-0.19573703408241272,
-0.35183510184288025,
-0.06899826973676682,
0.3961612582206726,
0.4839613139629364,
0.271674782037735,
-0.28250429034233093,
0.049823958426713943,
0.0685620903968811,
-0.3136642277240753,
-1.020506739616394,
0.6958282589912415,
-0.7635247111320496,
-1.2401115894317627,
-0.7124338150024414,
-0.5495407581329346,
-0.4648903012275696,
-0.06932476907968521,
0.25309574604034424,
-0.04618820548057556,
-0.08474405109882355,
0.17728208005428314,
0.9182896614074707,
-0.2797956168651581,
0.1758394092321396,
0.6208066344261169,
-0.4077145755290985,
-0.03145942464470863,
0.6230117678642273,
0.05720867961645126,
0.6460926532745361,
0.17951658368110657,
0.31486397981643677,
-0.02719464898109436,
-0.33614271879196167,
-0.04686538130044937,
0.4578845202922821,
-0.6994654536247253,
0.23659823834896088,
-0.6616100072860718,
0.05503737926483154,
-0.26565614342689514,
-0.44241923093795776,
-0.08108093589544296,
-0.384198933839798,
-0.34512582421302795,
0.04060697555541992,
0.3816412091255188,
0.5279896259307861,
0.39693328738212585,
0.5229209065437317,
-0.17472133040428162,
0.15156027674674988,
0.45916441082954407,
0.2254263162612915,
0.2567693591117859,
-0.4524959325790405,
0.10283578932285309,
-0.09553913027048111,
-0.27812641859054565,
-1.0205336809158325,
-0.03513075411319733,
-0.24702748656272888,
0.5525317192077637,
0.8546890616416931,
-0.150432288646698,
0.6439746618270874,
-0.10014647990465164,
0.8269684314727783,
-0.04639243707060814,
-1.031617283821106,
0.3291999399662018,
-0.8671805262565613,
0.2551722526550293,
0.3317726254463196,
0.1038435697555542,
-0.6261528134346008,
-0.5769255757331848,
-0.7194401621818542,
-0.025135569274425507,
0.5192474722862244,
0.047835733741521835,
0.13870607316493988,
-0.15141312777996063,
0.8317543268203735,
0.04821614548563957,
0.1661752313375473,
-0.6197351813316345,
-0.3405817151069641,
-0.08336031436920166,
0.2881571054458618,
-0.12556886672973633,
-0.30991607904434204,
-0.02389572560787201,
-0.6366122961044312,
0.4310804307460785,
-0.14900505542755127,
0.41043615341186523,
0.31227514147758484,
0.2983863353729248,
-0.20896108448505402,
0.31878745555877686,
0.7170171737670898,
0.6998835206031799,
-0.06671517342329025,
0.08644359558820724,
0.30829983949661255,
-0.1672893613576889,
0.09835311025381088,
-0.27620676159858704,
0.03442453593015671,
-0.41450968384742737,
0.3303520977497101,
0.6323891282081604,
0.1887011080980301,
-0.5481170415878296,
0.33436331152915955,
0.06367361545562744,
-0.23185521364212036,
-0.5284039378166199,
0.7440289855003357,
0.10721725225448608,
0.3481515645980835,
0.3725564777851105,
0.1643444150686264,
-0.23558413982391357,
-0.6178376078605652,
-0.2666948735713959,
0.5492178201675415,
0.0922468826174736,
-0.40959158539772034,
0.550851583480835,
0.21512086689472198,
-0.4265400171279907,
0.4065127372741699,
-0.3019537031650543,
-0.4292966425418854,
0.5766795873641968,
0.49820876121520996,
0.8878763914108276,
-0.4148738384246826,
-0.0864587128162384,
0.14991727471351624,
0.1061834767460823,
0.02228204533457756,
0.371975839138031,
0.1095593124628067,
-1.1427192687988281,
-0.5157554745674133,
-0.20135502517223358,
-0.4619377851486206,
0.3034979999065399,
-0.28182119131088257,
0.4166319966316223,
-0.8492265939712524,
-0.22500453889369965,
-0.082831472158432,
-0.03154941648244858,
-0.6397338509559631,
0.030358564108610153,
0.18295833468437195,
0.6759724617004395,
-0.4520168602466583,
0.9698799848556519,
0.6660239696502686,
-0.3016990125179291,
-0.8061820864677429,
0.2660578191280365,
0.24969400465488434,
-0.4506867825984955,
0.7020498514175415,
0.1353147029876709,
-0.17271314561367035,
0.2892478108406067,
-0.49658045172691345,
-0.9525935649871826,
1.0767637491226196,
0.42982563376426697,
-0.5036576390266418,
-0.2548676133155823,
-0.2521303594112396,
0.5649824738502502,
-0.45642244815826416,
0.2856276035308838,
0.7055878043174744,
0.7759844660758972,
0.06223195791244507,
-0.8305878043174744,
0.16090139746665955,
-0.019123414531350136,
-0.013822147622704506,
0.004890523850917816,
-0.7340077757835388,
0.9347665905952454,
-0.3755527436733246,
-0.028531424701213837,
0.13229002058506012,
0.6175487637519836,
0.741349458694458,
-0.0991133451461792,
0.6137644648551941,
0.14416514337062836,
0.8269134163856506,
0.054652705788612366,
1.2443504333496094,
-0.32685211300849915,
-0.30538156628608704,
0.8156481981277466,
-0.7179611921310425,
0.39052414894104004,
0.663699209690094,
-0.017006386071443558,
0.8434543609619141,
0.4635370969772339,
0.1026371419429779,
0.14535319805145264,
0.20531679689884186,
-0.10547849535942078,
-0.42704540491104126,
-0.048876915127038956,
-0.1879545897245407,
0.6033273339271545,
0.509713351726532,
-0.30788686871528625,
0.4391317069530487,
0.04615975171327591,
0.33086711168289185,
0.19402310252189636,
-0.18781286478042603,
0.2664261758327484,
0.11718282103538513,
-1.0081278085708618,
0.3485616147518158,
-0.025223959237337112,
0.7987692356109619,
-0.5023414492607117,
0.12090210616588593,
-0.19609853625297546,
0.23701854050159454,
-0.06614720821380615,
-0.6624735593795776,
0.15631286799907684,
-0.16484679281711578,
-0.2917531728744507,
-0.45138636231422424,
0.6578182578086853,
0.05146469548344612,
-0.020680449903011322,
0.2977006733417511,
0.8213933706283569,
0.0854823961853981,
-0.4022696018218994,
-0.47360163927078247,
-0.1823524683713913,
-0.19730466604232788,
-0.5345661640167236,
0.46694350242614746,
0.5095381140708923,
-0.2167125642299652,
0.8074242472648621,
0.8069204092025757,
0.27183181047439575,
-0.38244137167930603,
-0.11745414137840271,
0.9634608030319214,
-0.9399327635765076,
-0.5564092397689819,
-1.0492829084396362,
0.5825617909431458,
-0.1137455627322197,
-0.4691365957260132,
0.8692741990089417,
0.1638074368238449,
0.5532035827636719,
-0.10370051115751266,
0.7497110962867737,
-0.20259998738765717,
0.47538432478904724,
-0.4389759302139282,
0.8195458054542542,
-0.40880364179611206,
0.3522672951221466,
-0.48916029930114746,
-1.0789692401885986,
-0.005160228814929724,
0.41818228363990784,
-0.5521514415740967,
0.3561002016067505,
1.0067448616027832,
0.7981517314910889,
0.4352509081363678,
0.10923797637224197,
0.3823358416557312,
0.5106564164161682,
0.3899081349372864,
0.59186851978302,
0.9646210074424744,
0.3799704909324646,
-0.022864297032356262,
-0.08470766246318817,
-0.3016371428966522,
-0.14035922288894653,
-0.9110960364341736,
-1.3515106439590454,
-0.6997196078300476,
-0.17616461217403412,
-0.41264817118644714,
-0.08427240699529648,
0.9001327157020569,
0.43778756260871887,
-0.36361685395240784,
-0.03271177411079407,
-0.3177778720855713,
0.3621305823326111,
-0.3600570559501648,
-0.3039848804473877,
-0.05861243978142738,
0.010131966322660446,
-0.5771892070770264,
0.21834468841552734,
0.3052767217159271,
0.11178170144557953,
-0.9025312662124634,
-0.14207564294338226,
-0.2101602852344513,
0.41509103775024414,
0.639882504940033,
0.10389528423547745,
-1.1050434112548828,
-0.8379237055778503,
0.26444777846336365,
-0.17442919313907623,
-0.03711051866412163,
1.0205581188201904,
-1.0405632257461548,
0.09539858996868134,
0.36521944403648376,
0.07955393195152283,
-0.17514289915561676,
-0.14028069376945496,
0.6815118789672852,
-0.5141919851303101,
0.16838394105434418,
0.2737474739551544,
0.4117739200592041,
0.19373127818107605,
-0.8566813468933105,
0.327107310295105,
0.5558426380157471,
-0.605310320854187,
-0.6184083819389343,
0.5519503951072693,
-0.966123640537262,
-0.44167473912239075,
1.5266729593276978,
0.3813551068305969,
-0.07539688795804977,
-0.31489336490631104,
-0.4990250766277313,
0.07244560867547989,
-0.3504849970340729,
0.887457013130188,
1.1882585287094116,
-0.5146121978759766,
-0.41311123967170715,
-0.5000455975532532,
0.5822904109954834,
0.6557998061180115,
-0.7121455669403076,
0.2475523203611374,
0.5395084619522095,
-0.028155850246548653,
0.1390320509672165,
0.653298556804657,
0.20794466137886047,
0.23192472755908966,
-0.31531545519828796,
0.10538077354431152,
-0.09638594090938568,
-0.19492115080356598,
-0.32478925585746765,
-0.17445418238639832,
0.23913702368736267,
0.5062376260757446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02185v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02185v1
|
Distilled ChatGPT Topic & Sentiment Modeling with Applications in Finance
| 2024-03-04T16:27:21 | 2024-03-04T16:27:21 |
Olivier Gandouet, Mouloud Belbahri, Armelle Jezequel, Yuriy Bodjov
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CE, cs.CL
|
In this study, ChatGPT is utilized to create streamlined models that generate
easily interpretable features. These features are then used to evaluate
financial outcomes from earnings calls. We detail a training approach that
merges knowledge distillation and transfer learning, resulting in lightweight
topic and sentiment classification models without significant loss in accuracy.
These models are assessed through a dataset annotated by experts. The paper
also delves into two practical case studies, highlighting how the generated
features can be effectively utilized in quantitative investing scenarios.
|
[
-0.09233178943395615,
-0.726909339427948,
0.3261317014694214,
0.36318111419677734,
-0.3771834075450897,
0.5042089223861694,
-0.04141480475664139,
-0.27158215641975403,
0.09675616025924683,
0.26323840022087097,
-0.4072912633419037,
-0.30863288044929504,
-0.8408017754554749,
-0.5028988122940063,
-0.5826193690299988,
1.6854400634765625,
0.17914877831935883,
0.2819109261035919,
0.12078282237052917,
0.14246712625026703,
-0.305982768535614,
-0.6036182641983032,
-0.900307834148407,
-0.276262491941452,
0.014861092902719975,
0.18247118592262268,
0.7445603013038635,
-0.05789140239357948,
0.7715396881103516,
0.29298436641693115,
-0.17037458717823029,
-0.2752477526664734,
-0.5974705815315247,
-0.11804868280887604,
0.12043978273868561,
-0.3441099226474762,
-0.6009211540222168,
0.47516492009162903,
0.12504543364048004,
0.9206935167312622,
-0.5872491002082825,
0.16466188430786133,
0.32986849546432495,
0.6331207156181335,
-0.2944668233394623,
0.6359041333198547,
-0.6246128678321838,
0.10336267203092575,
-0.101976178586483,
-0.32600390911102295,
-0.35771098732948303,
-0.8187108039855957,
0.9948170781135559,
-0.2522590458393097,
0.3565880358219147,
-0.08866208791732788,
0.7184098362922668,
0.15505266189575195,
-0.5326405167579651,
-0.7288227081298828,
-0.6491849422454834,
0.7969359159469604,
-0.761242151260376,
0.032796360552310944,
0.20234225690364838,
0.4769321084022522,
0.11253400146961212,
-0.8982592225074768,
-0.2012096494436264,
-0.24872633814811707,
-0.09911599010229111,
0.33301830291748047,
-0.22212938964366913,
0.08117954432964325,
-0.0633310005068779,
0.687582790851593,
-0.21482188999652863,
-0.36718639731407166,
-0.6967997550964355,
0.09498274326324463,
0.7525076270103455,
0.12317544221878052,
-0.06009066477417946,
-0.1007753536105156,
-0.6551245450973511,
-0.3138217329978943,
-0.36065658926963806,
0.07611551135778427,
0.5655931234359741,
0.3876679539680481,
0.07742710411548615,
0.42869171500205994,
-0.04883324354887009,
0.39606213569641113,
0.13427145779132843,
-0.3558007478713989,
0.2500840425491333,
-0.082631416618824,
-0.08505137264728546,
0.4035887122154236,
0.43612411618232727,
0.37205538153648376,
0.2501472532749176,
0.010388558730483055,
-0.1355408877134323,
-0.3039891719818115,
0.12320556491613388,
-0.8665601015090942,
-0.7126458287239075,
0.2877022624015808,
-0.6472482681274414,
-0.7443774342536926,
0.18374475836753845,
-0.8281294107437134,
-0.3201337456703186,
-0.4323769807815552,
0.2826493978500366,
-0.7216305136680603,
-0.38556647300720215,
0.4614904820919037,
-0.7877860069274902,
0.4733982980251312,
0.3796060085296631,
-0.9069930911064148,
0.2886212170124054,
0.8753870129585266,
0.7698615789413452,
0.18208137154579163,
-0.007427094038575888,
-0.5385821461677551,
-0.08305315673351288,
-0.12748311460018158,
0.8812680840492249,
-0.3206154406070709,
-0.6475335359573364,
-0.27948158979415894,
-0.49894577264785767,
-0.019740672782063484,
-0.2811385989189148,
0.21823975443840027,
-0.36852532625198364,
0.24735307693481445,
-0.055384498089551926,
-0.7303354740142822,
-0.32667362689971924,
0.20370757579803467,
-0.35556212067604065,
0.9575329422950745,
0.26468995213508606,
-1.07736074924469,
0.7666813135147095,
-1.082581877708435,
-0.2614676356315613,
0.14891396462917328,
0.06290808320045471,
-0.4460982382297516,
0.1322842836380005,
-0.08091799914836884,
0.40635213255882263,
-0.14692644774913788,
0.37091970443725586,
-0.39505741000175476,
-0.05707002803683281,
0.822659432888031,
-0.6472207903862,
0.422477662563324,
0.4010491669178009,
-0.25553712248802185,
-0.1709916591644287,
-0.7112547755241394,
-0.15297161042690277,
-0.042814478278160095,
-0.07136064767837524,
-0.5918553471565247,
0.27701061964035034,
0.2735999524593353,
-0.15905721485614777,
0.2732571065425873,
-0.24152612686157227,
0.18475811183452606,
-0.17782732844352722,
0.8823599815368652,
0.661508321762085,
0.30256059765815735,
0.17724201083183289,
-0.10304518043994904,
0.42269018292427063,
0.2967551648616791,
0.2356906533241272,
0.12246351689100266,
-0.2981727719306946,
-0.5232132077217102,
-0.49582529067993164,
0.555633544921875,
0.781464159488678,
-0.4602747857570648,
0.25731152296066284,
0.04919480159878731,
-0.753511369228363,
-0.2756732106208801,
-0.013497735373675823,
-0.07316800206899643,
0.5317428708076477,
0.0940871462225914,
-0.2521263659000397,
-0.20627717673778534,
-0.9762776494026184,
-0.11508132517337799,
-0.324741929769516,
-0.03871331736445427,
-0.014545355923473835,
0.29803478717803955,
0.17764762043952942,
0.921050488948822,
-1.1130342483520508,
0.052740197628736496,
-0.30590465664863586,
0.8321319818496704,
0.3682904839515686,
0.32177990674972534,
0.7598369717597961,
-1.0981920957565308,
-0.5081905126571655,
0.05073580890893936,
-0.508857786655426,
0.2882261276245117,
-0.13661986589431763,
-0.06767892092466354,
-0.3701589107513428,
0.32689520716667175,
-0.35028696060180664,
0.5976844429969788,
0.22611135244369507,
-0.3862375319004059,
0.2744590938091278,
-0.041911590844392776,
0.31929993629455566,
-1.3396283388137817,
0.051227450370788574,
0.43191468715667725,
-0.5179502964019775,
-0.49470314383506775,
-0.5923914313316345,
-0.31628158688545227,
-0.42388156056404114,
-0.3977459967136383,
0.21406136453151703,
-0.19923722743988037,
-0.08594590425491333,
-0.4547387957572937,
0.1895948201417923,
0.09050261974334717,
0.24034126102924347,
0.21657976508140564,
0.7153002023696899,
0.5889981985092163,
-0.3348240554332733,
0.5068992972373962,
0.41980528831481934,
-0.3489876091480255,
0.555014431476593,
-0.7479006052017212,
-0.04226387292146683,
-0.015344139188528061,
-0.13803666830062866,
-1.4195388555526733,
0.031427327543497086,
0.06528405100107193,
-0.35944849252700806,
0.37389928102493286,
-0.37317216396331787,
-0.10682766139507294,
-0.08425422757863998,
-0.43604689836502075,
-0.07026827335357666,
0.804180383682251,
-0.1791515052318573,
0.315178781747818,
0.29757368564605713,
-0.7792045474052429,
-0.5242399573326111,
-0.5447314381599426,
-0.1379099041223526,
-0.9134827852249146,
-0.3385128676891327,
0.18978004157543182,
0.26134881377220154,
-0.48383381962776184,
0.11819319427013397,
0.1923118233680725,
-0.19741220772266388,
0.20196034014225006,
0.24983066320419312,
0.6480721235275269,
-0.1458558738231659,
0.21186217665672302,
-0.021674348041415215,
-0.19004137814044952,
-0.2762796878814697,
-0.20457768440246582,
0.3479556143283844,
-0.3801054060459137,
-0.15659792721271515,
-0.15303197503089905,
0.34280070662498474,
0.4638306200504303,
-0.13979938626289368,
0.7434853315353394,
0.5869936347007751,
0.06784865260124207,
-0.07818050682544708,
-0.3050438463687897,
-0.1988951861858368,
-0.528898298740387,
0.5389726161956787,
-0.2270275503396988,
-0.8048276305198669,
0.607923150062561,
-0.4669969081878662,
0.12193098664283752,
0.5757144093513489,
0.5858919620513916,
-0.24828338623046875,
0.7204171419143677,
0.9036739468574524,
-0.058151084929704666,
0.8196900486946106,
-0.38362917304039,
0.5979167819023132,
-0.41259175539016724,
-0.11115925759077072,
-0.4355282187461853,
-0.37053602933883667,
-0.7212188839912415,
-0.1417311728000641,
0.3248864412307739,
0.4084712564945221,
-0.08508278429508209,
0.31087368726730347,
-0.45822855830192566,
0.33969005942344666,
0.49643152952194214,
0.03683855012059212,
0.16887976229190826,
-0.09135102480649948,
0.2171526402235031,
-0.06868132948875427,
-0.4970540404319763,
-0.6819082498550415,
1.0587397813796997,
0.6359840631484985,
1.024168848991394,
-0.21120232343673706,
0.622797429561615,
0.7282095551490784,
0.4361991584300995,
-0.9973112940788269,
0.1095392107963562,
-0.3637961447238922,
-0.4192231297492981,
-0.2917492687702179,
-0.41571125388145447,
-0.24545826017856598,
-0.037443555891513824,
-0.09535939991474152,
-0.7078393697738647,
0.2836819887161255,
-0.0025804582983255386,
-0.60345458984375,
0.12649692595005035,
-1.1497459411621094,
0.9219401478767395,
-0.25067514181137085,
-0.02298818901181221,
0.0005496685043908656,
-0.18670345842838287,
0.4377155005931854,
-0.23065057396888733,
-0.0707596018910408,
-0.2929254472255707,
0.34013715386390686,
0.7373571395874023,
-0.6758313775062561,
1.0731382369995117,
-0.2070959061384201,
-0.18815000355243683,
0.7018757462501526,
-0.09810663759708405,
0.25316083431243896,
0.5440164804458618,
-0.08771172910928726,
0.060094598680734634,
0.31065091490745544,
-0.37027692794799805,
-0.5956376194953918,
0.2731988728046417,
-0.7145751714706421,
-0.4545299708843231,
-0.5178719162940979,
-0.4770178496837616,
-0.34873583912849426,
-0.40640556812286377,
0.09782671928405762,
0.33950334787368774,
-0.5045615434646606,
0.09196998178958893,
0.2873001992702484,
-0.020798765122890472,
0.47226765751838684,
0.1731567233800888,
-0.19601081311702728,
-0.5028502941131592,
0.885201096534729,
-0.020020749419927597,
0.3410957455635071,
0.1003548726439476,
0.23365001380443573,
-0.6133074164390564,
-0.49067258834838867,
-0.2469765990972519,
-0.2035844922065735,
-0.784070611000061,
-0.14920537173748016,
-0.4131629168987274,
-0.3756538927555084,
-0.31144338846206665,
-0.1776842176914215,
-0.7347764372825623,
-0.5787028670310974,
-0.10443728417158127,
-0.5136304497718811,
1.1219466924667358,
0.6753706932067871,
-0.1559806615114212,
0.49220412969589233,
-1.0126274824142456,
0.05341142416000366,
0.6083804965019226,
0.16432048380374908,
-0.14278750121593475,
-0.30576059222221375,
-0.16082991659641266,
0.2732061743736267,
-0.6401289105415344,
-0.9236301183700562,
0.6006708741188049,
0.30963584780693054,
0.37438714504241943,
0.46704378724098206,
0.10534952580928802,
0.669837474822998,
-0.09191782772541046,
0.654944658279419,
0.34048715233802795,
-1.1646157503128052,
0.7543362379074097,
-0.28508442640304565,
-0.29864540696144104,
0.8076127767562866,
0.6915393471717834,
-0.4489406645298004,
-0.2204878181219101,
-0.6174599528312683,
-0.8764912486076355,
0.4644826650619507,
0.28330057859420776,
0.133334681391716,
-0.02214941196143627,
0.4541465640068054,
0.4967420697212219,
0.6266458630561829,
-0.33194050192832947,
-0.023791825398802757,
-0.43833810091018677,
-0.299768328666687,
0.011048279702663422,
-0.39438748359680176,
0.058463338762521744,
-0.09956441819667816,
0.5522096157073975,
-0.1592360883951187,
0.06521143019199371,
0.07058695703744888,
0.25207871198654175,
0.45035839080810547,
0.21650272607803345,
0.04303201287984848,
0.77936190366745,
-0.7256949543952942,
-0.25906902551651,
0.16009975969791412,
-0.48407992720603943,
0.05819561332464218,
0.30838343501091003,
0.2120140939950943,
0.06947750598192215,
0.027996735647320747,
0.7824717164039612,
0.32410740852355957,
-0.6773773431777954,
0.48914027214050293,
-0.314690500497818,
-0.4554692506790161,
-0.40019309520721436,
-0.10526455193758011,
0.18809504806995392,
0.5316338539123535,
0.5969298481941223,
0.12064047157764435,
0.6351699233055115,
-0.8880605697631836,
0.42693036794662476,
0.20523637533187866,
-0.6177756190299988,
-0.26483744382858276,
0.477370947599411,
0.24266721308231354,
0.34365081787109375,
0.932733952999115,
-0.006222046911716461,
-0.6666167378425598,
0.5390852689743042,
0.029630862176418304,
1.0890071392059326,
0.19901080429553986,
0.5088372230529785,
0.02841143123805523,
-0.22273579239845276,
-0.10099348425865173,
0.2419777512550354,
-0.06547822058200836,
-0.6137796640396118,
-0.48283904790878296,
-0.8704420924186707,
-0.7820008993148804,
-0.18422898650169373,
-0.9140716195106506,
0.5613154172897339,
-0.2260652482509613,
-0.4340859055519104,
0.6547061800956726,
-0.05937863141298294,
-0.4690852165222168,
0.14065445959568024,
0.1448359489440918,
0.5331633687019348,
-0.8899833559989929,
0.7206542491912842,
0.6905495524406433,
-0.5606144070625305,
-0.6974976658821106,
-0.14271779358386993,
-0.1849856823682785,
-0.6396505236625671,
0.8190540075302124,
-0.1460600197315216,
0.09920185804367065,
-0.16740207374095917,
-0.4520535469055176,
-0.48287495970726013,
1.1627084016799927,
0.17891228199005127,
-0.3858181834220886,
0.11400843411684036,
0.18545369803905487,
0.3432552218437195,
-0.3860915005207062,
0.3303176462650299,
0.55204838514328,
0.08848021924495697,
0.7990145683288574,
-0.8784961104393005,
-0.579991340637207,
-0.24113726615905762,
-0.12398464232683182,
0.28660109639167786,
-0.8176903128623962,
0.9534422159194946,
0.018399536609649658,
0.004830053076148033,
-0.38923630118370056,
0.5942718386650085,
0.2406845986843109,
0.43063217401504517,
0.2631508409976959,
0.3403903841972351,
0.7526639699935913,
-0.23604513704776764,
0.8805967569351196,
-0.4120822548866272,
0.7851952314376831,
1.090804100036621,
-0.38866910338401794,
0.9332075119018555,
0.4495599865913391,
-0.4803887605667114,
0.20200581848621368,
0.9643391370773315,
0.036675769835710526,
0.7843426465988159,
0.35579508543014526,
-0.3182375431060791,
-0.1949985921382904,
-0.027652230113744736,
-0.46960514783859253,
0.7510105967521667,
0.43687745928764343,
-0.33568519353866577,
-0.22983916103839874,
-0.02088700234889984,
-0.18654008209705353,
-0.3097009062767029,
-0.1542368233203888,
0.9542908668518066,
0.5624212026596069,
-0.09440194815397263,
-0.2188938558101654,
-0.10411067306995392,
0.7506422996520996,
-0.7640336155891418,
-0.23315849900245667,
-0.2958723306655884,
0.23249506950378418,
0.07938969880342484,
-0.9050999879837036,
0.7234808206558228,
0.1737198382616043,
-0.011755481362342834,
-0.36199069023132324,
0.8866025805473328,
-0.31444138288497925,
-0.7512753009796143,
-0.08632899075746536,
0.6583418250083923,
0.19752098619937897,
-0.257535845041275,
-0.6822954416275024,
-0.5787379145622253,
0.2142491340637207,
-0.5299138426780701,
0.33912304043769836,
0.9832044839859009,
0.13769464194774628,
0.6667201519012451,
0.7229773998260498,
-0.0109679214656353,
-0.14315882325172424,
0.011009018868207932,
0.98817378282547,
-0.97920161485672,
-0.6948047280311584,
-1.0868335962295532,
0.5375273823738098,
-0.1504683494567871,
-0.3704625368118286,
0.5500400066375732,
0.6890451908111572,
0.4520943760871887,
-0.26371484994888306,
1.0806704759597778,
-0.0013292536605149508,
0.38997316360473633,
-0.5481082797050476,
0.8913634419441223,
-0.07941406220197678,
0.20391780138015747,
-0.37581512331962585,
-0.8491536974906921,
0.1494045853614807,
0.4668751060962677,
-0.7578198909759521,
-0.07540398836135864,
0.3441137969493866,
0.24534784257411957,
-0.22664114832878113,
0.5313249826431274,
0.30371880531311035,
-0.27831515669822693,
0.2172742336988449,
0.3256601095199585,
1.153997778892517,
-0.5264412760734558,
0.29108673334121704,
-0.4500108063220978,
-0.08771892637014389,
-0.2836902141571045,
-1.1336990594863892,
-0.8921003341674805,
-0.4339050054550171,
-0.9210535883903503,
-0.068483866751194,
-0.11089887470006943,
0.6414484977722168,
0.6834855675697327,
-0.5858429074287415,
-0.12841950356960297,
0.15513886511325836,
-0.264827162027359,
-0.1315731257200241,
-0.3439203202724457,
0.5171623826026917,
-0.4347245395183563,
-0.7052159905433655,
-0.11199188232421875,
0.37754306197166443,
0.5313266515731812,
-0.17733505368232727,
0.3146601617336273,
0.17978797852993011,
0.1053914949297905,
0.6157861351966858,
-0.26019445061683655,
0.0644741803407669,
-0.1261024922132492,
-0.10079505294561386,
0.12176923453807831,
0.0399516262114048,
0.8102496266365051,
-0.2923818528652191,
-0.0034048613160848618,
0.47335487604141235,
0.32799774408340454,
0.8134269118309021,
0.37887829542160034,
0.8064887523651123,
-0.6102458238601685,
0.5959258675575256,
0.19646568596363068,
0.38402652740478516,
0.19440533220767975,
-0.44800475239753723,
0.5202083587646484,
0.11192500591278076,
-0.3367981016635895,
-0.4530063569545746,
-0.23687931895256042,
-1.2252897024154663,
-0.19163362681865692,
0.7147567868232727,
-0.34109923243522644,
-0.38577964901924133,
0.11475065350532532,
-0.41516414284706116,
-0.010451016016304493,
-0.5392516255378723,
0.8243128657341003,
0.7610135078430176,
-0.2343323826789856,
-0.1423533856868744,
-0.9226688146591187,
0.6458554267883301,
-0.0010271713836118579,
-0.5903571248054504,
0.07223108410835266,
0.2877919375896454,
0.42175132036209106,
0.04512587562203407,
0.4448108375072479,
-0.27395644783973694,
0.0011492276098579168,
0.5312106609344482,
0.12764111161231995,
0.058006711304187775,
0.16484686732292175,
0.08329138159751892,
0.23578128218650818,
0.4353407025337219,
-0.553683340549469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02181v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02181v2
|
Not all Layers of LLMs are Necessary during Inference
| 2024-03-04T16:23:58 | 2024-04-15T03:57:44 |
Siqi Fan, Xin Jiang, Xiang Li, Xuying Meng, Peng Han, Shuo Shang, Aixin Sun, Yequan Wang, Zhongyuan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The inference phase of Large Language Models (LLMs) is very expensive. An
ideal inference stage of LLMs could utilize fewer computational resources while
still maintaining its capabilities (e.g., generalization and in-context
learning ability). In this paper, we try to answer the question, "During LLM
inference, can we use shallow layers for easy instances; and deep layers for
hard ones?" To answer this question, we first indicate that Not all Layers are
Necessary during Inference by statistically analyzing the activated layers
across tasks. Then, we propose a simple algorithm named AdaInfer to determine
the inference termination moment based on the input instance adaptively. More
importantly, AdaInfer does not alter LLM parameters and maintains
generalizability across tasks. Experiments on well-known LLMs (i.e., Llama2
series and OPT) show that AdaInfer saves an average of 14.8% of computational
resources, even up to 50% on sentiment tasks, while maintaining comparable
performance. Additionally, this method is orthogonal to other model
acceleration techniques, potentially boosting inference efficiency further.
|
[
-0.3904341757297516,
-1.070243239402771,
0.8962880969047546,
0.002705460414290428,
-0.2015499770641327,
-0.25298765301704407,
-0.20786434412002563,
-0.2855592370033264,
-0.1805904060602188,
0.4138632118701935,
-0.5155985951423645,
-0.522423267364502,
-0.4440559446811676,
-0.20686882734298706,
-0.21643990278244019,
0.7454887628555298,
0.18645432591438293,
-0.05278274044394493,
-0.487726092338562,
-0.02469480037689209,
0.031191006302833557,
-0.21323370933532715,
-1.0142401456832886,
-0.6804682016372681,
0.5580229163169861,
0.581916332244873,
0.6192147135734558,
0.7877272367477417,
0.20710346102714539,
0.36503300070762634,
-0.43187591433525085,
0.25768598914146423,
-0.16506054997444153,
0.146576926112175,
-0.05391761660575867,
-0.686862051486969,
-0.5701323747634888,
-0.01927892677485943,
0.4089219868183136,
1.1537373065948486,
-0.21365191042423248,
0.05018716678023338,
0.08088439702987671,
0.8322725892066956,
-0.7185490131378174,
-0.08458030968904495,
-0.6116389632225037,
0.15532931685447693,
0.013474104925990105,
0.17589062452316284,
-0.30350401997566223,
-0.09221091866493225,
0.06860122084617615,
-0.35511574149131775,
0.366068571805954,
-0.007443850394338369,
0.45732495188713074,
0.16182921826839447,
-0.3039276897907257,
0.052052419632673264,
-0.6011963486671448,
0.9936683773994446,
-0.9145300984382629,
0.0831131562590599,
0.2751583755016327,
-0.039250489324331284,
-0.288021057844162,
-0.5928756594657898,
-0.4976249039173126,
-0.2708599269390106,
0.11263608932495117,
-0.01454035472124815,
-0.11306431889533997,
0.47550609707832336,
0.2507339119911194,
0.31594419479370117,
0.009380797855556011,
0.47416454553604126,
-0.21247152984142303,
-0.08414995670318604,
0.2532951831817627,
0.1781901866197586,
0.2720763087272644,
-0.402454137802124,
-0.3163204789161682,
-0.010518312454223633,
-0.6614508032798767,
0.18589499592781067,
0.19100844860076904,
0.28441277146339417,
-0.17497113347053528,
0.32696765661239624,
-0.0003965900978073478,
0.37024620175361633,
-0.026775524020195007,
-0.18916277587413788,
0.1783914417028427,
0.21858181059360504,
-0.5266126394271851,
0.0023228314239531755,
0.72761470079422,
0.046828459948301315,
0.12464222311973572,
-0.20328812301158905,
-0.1884772777557373,
0.0007941076182760298,
0.18491551280021667,
-0.7573456168174744,
-0.053227633237838745,
0.7010459899902344,
-0.24456125497817993,
-0.1536848396062851,
-0.31212490797042847,
-0.7125847339630127,
-0.3414468467235565,
-0.22411751747131348,
0.37017571926116943,
-0.38406240940093994,
-0.16880348324775696,
0.011790016666054726,
-0.009638502262532711,
0.25478631258010864,
0.4502132833003998,
-0.5854276418685913,
0.5855300426483154,
0.762972891330719,
0.9529916644096375,
-0.16998134553432465,
-0.2618746757507324,
-0.5484133958816528,
0.07440982758998871,
-0.5909377932548523,
0.8977344036102295,
-0.46519091725349426,
-0.22827376425266266,
-0.20931333303451538,
0.04148264229297638,
-0.12462852150201797,
-0.5837798118591309,
0.8446663618087769,
-0.6342265009880066,
-0.005323318764567375,
-0.17451035976409912,
-0.8039131164550781,
-0.45339128375053406,
-0.058087725192308426,
-0.849831223487854,
0.7573285698890686,
-0.2809132933616638,
-0.6827012300491333,
0.22798791527748108,
-0.5452000498771667,
-0.7499747276306152,
-0.11406025290489197,
0.06253156065940857,
-0.5393111705780029,
0.5074951648712158,
0.44844573736190796,
0.6462815999984741,
-0.4008188545703888,
0.039576977491378784,
-0.48433080315589905,
-0.37897372245788574,
0.16775918006896973,
-0.18341124057769775,
0.718499481678009,
0.31205612421035767,
-0.5154641270637512,
-0.11817770451307297,
-0.6155827641487122,
-0.006479318253695965,
-0.04197551682591438,
-0.3773263096809387,
-0.35125744342803955,
0.43230506777763367,
-0.38943591713905334,
-0.15363000333309174,
-0.061067186295986176,
-0.4660298228263855,
-0.07387561351060867,
-0.47678378224372864,
0.5395293831825256,
1.0063259601593018,
0.026391277089715004,
0.7495399713516235,
-0.10726185142993927,
0.5999168753623962,
0.22744865715503693,
-0.13341303169727325,
0.10346239060163498,
-0.26830872893333435,
-1.2456215620040894,
-0.4810048043727875,
0.3677895665168762,
0.6457610130310059,
-0.45803144574165344,
0.26857689023017883,
0.0935618132352829,
-0.2266995906829834,
-0.3951667845249176,
0.4685612916946411,
0.5157155990600586,
0.5568433403968811,
0.27279484272003174,
-0.09519056230783463,
-0.390474408864975,
-0.9774130582809448,
-0.1655266284942627,
-0.24485717713832855,
-0.007041397970169783,
0.45891350507736206,
0.2883448898792267,
0.10286470502614975,
0.6448157429695129,
-0.29632553458213806,
0.037961654365062714,
-0.44577452540397644,
-0.05920117720961571,
0.4606672525405884,
0.44686824083328247,
0.41978323459625244,
-0.4500161409378052,
0.05774665251374245,
-0.14123210310935974,
-0.9131432771682739,
-0.36379632353782654,
-0.19105762243270874,
-0.46996551752090454,
-0.01139790564775467,
0.7055396437644958,
-0.6159298419952393,
-0.05277298390865326,
0.514680027961731,
-0.051697585731744766,
0.22137658298015594,
-0.23616917431354523,
-0.07065649330615997,
-0.5184042453765869,
-0.10474666953086853,
0.2546228766441345,
-0.3238871991634369,
-0.8750748634338379,
0.02578459121286869,
0.10733535140752792,
0.1451960951089859,
-0.553422212600708,
0.7127808332443237,
-0.706947386264801,
-0.027050849050283432,
-0.37683987617492676,
0.04752420634031296,
0.25060147047042847,
0.5274412631988525,
-0.17016169428825378,
0.7228567600250244,
0.7140139937400818,
-0.8978001475334167,
0.09829302877187729,
-0.16475871205329895,
-0.6114135384559631,
0.348604679107666,
-0.7000203132629395,
0.3906523287296295,
-0.3043532371520996,
-0.16855470836162567,
-1.055767297744751,
-0.045229941606521606,
0.1427605003118515,
-0.04885072261095047,
0.29680362343788147,
-0.06812924146652222,
-0.1910158395767212,
-0.17923787236213684,
-0.3518125116825104,
0.17649149894714355,
0.5978566408157349,
-0.5160212516784668,
0.7947565913200378,
0.44746506214141846,
-0.11057528108358383,
-0.48020467162132263,
-0.9627469778060913,
0.13396941125392914,
-0.4783812463283539,
-0.5865446329116821,
0.14817625284194946,
0.04953040927648544,
-0.4516364634037018,
0.0846339538693428,
-0.05559832230210304,
0.10178767144680023,
0.29140403866767883,
0.36812499165534973,
-0.08135808259248734,
-0.3129860758781433,
0.18279717862606049,
0.36232641339302063,
0.06814302504062653,
0.11010051518678665,
-0.0939517393708229,
0.2031569927930832,
-0.13389980792999268,
-0.53574538230896,
-0.40599754452705383,
0.24533876776695251,
0.40331530570983887,
0.13779982924461365,
0.708523690700531,
0.2627490162849426,
-0.24787713587284088,
-0.613011360168457,
-0.8733433485031128,
-0.03866980969905853,
-0.4943923056125641,
0.33993104100227356,
-0.4279524087905884,
-0.8520651459693909,
0.7517715096473694,
-0.058929916471242905,
-0.019344612956047058,
0.4398837685585022,
0.4857456088066101,
-0.257464200258255,
0.9521978497505188,
0.4349920451641083,
-0.22319234907627106,
0.39737826585769653,
-0.2208673357963562,
0.08098848909139633,
-0.9822790026664734,
-0.05406675115227699,
-0.30499616265296936,
-0.3918742835521698,
-0.19352392852306366,
-0.4365781247615814,
0.43058323860168457,
0.36620980501174927,
-0.3075132966041565,
-0.17207439243793488,
-0.07849433273077011,
0.5656768679618835,
0.5851765871047974,
0.4911932349205017,
0.20401827991008759,
0.46791669726371765,
-0.18304292857646942,
0.2095787078142166,
-0.7124788761138916,
-0.44400906562805176,
0.7268547415733337,
0.393250048160553,
0.9049814343452454,
0.12909378111362457,
0.45539236068725586,
0.341759592294693,
0.08883707225322723,
-0.9691466093063354,
0.7876333594322205,
-0.402109295129776,
-0.4448195695877075,
-0.2851371765136719,
-0.5613591074943542,
-0.9017736911773682,
0.39386656880378723,
0.20671771466732025,
-0.43446287512779236,
0.3232245445251465,
0.21313227713108063,
-0.4140677750110626,
0.44422614574432373,
-0.7834155559539795,
0.6164232492446899,
-0.06013501062989235,
-0.5306177735328674,
-0.23412437736988068,
-0.3665913939476013,
0.434746652841568,
0.059774525463581085,
0.2967601418495178,
-0.4388754665851593,
-0.3631684184074402,
0.7614385485649109,
-0.4997824430465698,
1.038264513015747,
-0.2791915535926819,
0.11295431107282639,
0.6654651165008545,
0.266469806432724,
0.35801881551742554,
-0.11161349713802338,
-0.5861850380897522,
0.15500137209892273,
-0.40830156207084656,
-0.5224226117134094,
-0.4736481308937073,
0.6614407300949097,
-0.8547925353050232,
-0.8327354788780212,
-0.18548209965229034,
-0.30287423729896545,
-0.23232251405715942,
-0.04660249501466751,
-0.05042450129985809,
0.4657440483570099,
-0.04175576940178871,
0.021405745297670364,
0.6266831755638123,
-0.2761451005935669,
0.4809078574180603,
0.14606517553329468,
0.22130344808101654,
-0.2701958119869232,
0.5538559556007385,
0.013654722832143307,
0.4414648413658142,
0.2922811210155487,
0.5285528302192688,
-0.1328032910823822,
-0.8699060678482056,
-0.3225177824497223,
0.31781965494155884,
-1.0112076997756958,
-0.1890420913696289,
-0.7534520030021667,
-0.18645437061786652,
-0.12733839452266693,
-0.08166716247797012,
-0.21574248373508453,
-0.39181381464004517,
-0.36004361510276794,
-0.34855782985687256,
0.5154455304145813,
0.3265624940395355,
-0.2653007507324219,
0.45765677094459534,
-0.536105215549469,
0.30254507064819336,
0.5139674544334412,
0.1351781189441681,
0.34376057982444763,
-0.6788687705993652,
-0.12279131263494492,
-0.1301126778125763,
0.01956167444586754,
-0.5045762658119202,
0.20139087736606598,
0.829533576965332,
0.8777864575386047,
0.572514533996582,
-0.0847635269165039,
0.6807006597518921,
-0.48042935132980347,
0.8038920760154724,
0.008948734030127525,
-0.9853724241256714,
0.4174209237098694,
-0.12246524542570114,
0.40066078305244446,
0.44006603956222534,
0.1967259794473648,
-0.3040231466293335,
-0.36005812883377075,
-0.3093186020851135,
-0.9260215759277344,
0.7622815370559692,
0.036767683923244476,
0.4785080552101135,
-0.16424643993377686,
0.6973813772201538,
-0.07098959386348724,
0.24213860929012299,
-0.5446978211402893,
-0.24916236102581024,
0.1903207004070282,
0.019599372521042824,
0.044035904109478,
-0.6594239473342896,
-0.12868711352348328,
-0.18113648891448975,
0.44172728061676025,
-0.1112329363822937,
0.204661026597023,
0.21618980169296265,
-0.26602137088775635,
-0.05258287861943245,
0.2619004249572754,
0.15791620314121246,
0.686677873134613,
-0.2453845888376236,
0.5313798189163208,
0.5103110671043396,
-0.37726643681526184,
0.19096560776233673,
-0.28553852438926697,
-0.09081554412841797,
-0.34124037623405457,
0.671890914440155,
0.9713990092277527,
0.15688659250736237,
-0.6314396858215332,
0.4240093529224396,
0.2063707560300827,
-0.3458422124385834,
-0.1736319214105606,
0.43211889266967773,
0.20249374210834503,
0.6622720956802368,
0.2675102949142456,
-0.18367324769496918,
0.13316363096237183,
-0.47462591528892517,
0.026144156232476234,
0.42870062589645386,
-0.3024386465549469,
-0.21288028359413147,
0.6289797425270081,
0.17207203805446625,
0.059758204966783524,
0.6066407561302185,
-0.16282573342323303,
-0.4230594038963318,
0.8604918718338013,
0.22068825364112854,
1.0581644773483276,
-0.2904720604419708,
0.16767291724681854,
0.09536055475473404,
0.1368725597858429,
-0.28491756319999695,
0.14835724234580994,
0.05194258317351341,
-0.9574575424194336,
-0.7375105619430542,
-0.9492742419242859,
-0.4043123424053192,
0.22602228820323944,
-0.33051565289497375,
0.041672706604003906,
-0.8173131346702576,
-0.1838129758834839,
0.09672726690769196,
-0.09487341344356537,
-0.48861953616142273,
0.4033913016319275,
0.4359298050403595,
0.6910613775253296,
-0.9576566219329834,
0.5882965922355652,
0.5411450266838074,
0.05643446743488312,
-0.4763358235359192,
-0.345093309879303,
0.18115538358688354,
-0.9595887064933777,
0.6889126896858215,
0.0185997411608696,
-0.4590962529182434,
-0.15119139850139618,
-0.6755632758140564,
-0.5740327835083008,
0.8106465339660645,
0.4484565854072571,
-0.36026731133461,
-0.12039528787136078,
-0.08011405169963837,
0.4588986039161682,
-0.46458667516708374,
0.2972877323627472,
0.6562403440475464,
0.34698617458343506,
0.26521798968315125,
-0.42550745606422424,
0.030707208439707756,
-0.22541750967502594,
0.26634764671325684,
0.02889503911137581,
-0.458700031042099,
1.1284817457199097,
-0.39706146717071533,
-0.2765664756298065,
0.02777848392724991,
0.7424351572990417,
0.12922678887844086,
0.07015197724103928,
0.9971964359283447,
0.5751409530639648,
0.5499489307403564,
0.2008371502161026,
1.0555319786071777,
-0.1507994383573532,
0.17019523680210114,
0.8413287401199341,
0.006693053990602493,
0.7134875059127808,
0.35557788610458374,
-0.3802278935909271,
0.5269721746444702,
0.7074970602989197,
0.029305018484592438,
0.4675271213054657,
0.20121918618679047,
-0.35681694746017456,
-0.6970089673995972,
0.05352511256933212,
-0.04531287029385567,
0.4053761661052704,
0.4732702672481537,
-0.30337920784950256,
-0.12021484971046448,
-0.026163607835769653,
0.32923048734664917,
-0.20950999855995178,
-0.4158359467983246,
0.710282564163208,
0.46904996037483215,
-0.5984392762184143,
0.4759487807750702,
0.002352333627641201,
0.48029714822769165,
-0.36116763949394226,
0.12110492587089539,
-0.4866708219051361,
0.33093374967575073,
-0.3341105580329895,
-0.6737383604049683,
-0.07941009849309921,
-0.1061578169465065,
-0.1617249846458435,
0.08585032820701599,
0.7308655977249146,
-0.26496461033821106,
-0.924444317817688,
0.524522602558136,
0.7440571188926697,
0.28098881244659424,
-0.12480859458446503,
-0.6296204924583435,
-0.055944766849279404,
-0.10127164423465729,
-0.9273142218589783,
0.2541159689426422,
0.56382155418396,
0.1302972286939621,
0.6491890549659729,
0.6096013784408569,
0.43943101167678833,
0.0780150294303894,
0.5068946480751038,
0.8150533437728882,
-0.652441143989563,
-0.2996180057525635,
-1.0756429433822632,
0.4689216911792755,
-0.02392374537885189,
0.04429979249835014,
0.6383077502250671,
0.1959930658340454,
0.3599308431148529,
0.2576833665370941,
0.8492980003356934,
0.10255564749240875,
0.5460065603256226,
-0.9997563362121582,
0.3143158555030823,
-0.9479451775550842,
0.49751701951026917,
-0.313281387090683,
-1.0463086366653442,
-0.331958144903183,
0.5440251231193542,
-0.46606218814849854,
0.2186824083328247,
0.6688979864120483,
0.7817036509513855,
-0.27399903535842896,
-0.19242382049560547,
0.27350759506225586,
0.3675961494445801,
0.360382080078125,
0.498762845993042,
0.5652860403060913,
-0.1924111694097519,
0.3217547833919525,
-0.4183194935321808,
-0.2957577705383301,
-0.1505756825208664,
-1.0455420017242432,
-1.0542700290679932,
-0.06535858660936356,
-0.4245639741420746,
-0.41487544775009155,
0.051047105342149734,
0.7163282632827759,
0.678164005279541,
-0.7891072630882263,
-0.4624116122722626,
-0.10956046730279922,
0.28046920895576477,
-0.3488938510417938,
-0.12258817255496979,
0.652624785900116,
-0.6295607686042786,
-0.9227102994918823,
0.4525746703147888,
0.12704351544380188,
-0.19295763969421387,
-0.17833003401756287,
0.25639575719833374,
-0.17927786707878113,
0.1184520497918129,
0.6833644509315491,
0.21269232034683228,
-0.7152019143104553,
-0.409802109003067,
-0.1519889086484909,
-0.05987144634127617,
0.2466646134853363,
0.6558623909950256,
-0.5817234516143799,
0.35639193654060364,
0.6318314671516418,
0.7382599115371704,
0.6150217652320862,
0.07599477469921112,
0.4895998537540436,
-0.6125214099884033,
0.3762831687927246,
0.03323281928896904,
0.5171414613723755,
0.36011672019958496,
-0.22445830702781677,
0.3376273214817047,
0.09158802032470703,
-0.5753287076950073,
-0.7593320608139038,
0.19820311665534973,
-0.8166977167129517,
-0.567253053188324,
1.299953579902649,
0.004822947550565004,
-0.5942348837852478,
-0.024662794545292854,
0.1664362996816635,
0.01495878305286169,
-0.4241864085197449,
0.48216497898101807,
0.585730791091919,
-0.404295951128006,
-0.5966477990150452,
-0.7809582352638245,
0.44067996740341187,
0.6753672361373901,
-0.6431708335876465,
-0.06273125112056732,
0.3710786998271942,
0.25901657342910767,
-0.013983520679175854,
0.48575225472450256,
0.20881177484989166,
-0.11402576416730881,
0.06385288387537003,
0.07401317358016968,
-0.10386273264884949,
-0.2926420569419861,
-0.37105944752693176,
0.32738229632377625,
0.2587531507015228,
-0.07014191895723343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02178v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02178v1
|
Masked Thought: Simply Masking Partial Reasoning Steps Can Improve Mathematical Reasoning Learning of Language Models
| 2024-03-04T16:21:54 | 2024-03-04T16:21:54 |
Changyu Chen, Xiting Wang, Ting-En Lin, Ang Lv, Yuchuan Wu, Xin Gao, Ji-Rong Wen, Rui Yan, Yongbin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In reasoning tasks, even a minor error can cascade into inaccurate results,
leading to suboptimal performance of large language models in such domains.
Earlier fine-tuning approaches sought to mitigate this by leveraging more
precise supervisory signals from human labeling, larger models, or
self-sampling, although at a high cost. Conversely, we develop a method that
avoids external resources, relying instead on introducing perturbations to the
input. Our training approach randomly masks certain tokens within the chain of
thought, a technique we found to be particularly effective for reasoning tasks.
When applied to fine-tuning with GSM8K, this method achieved a 5% improvement
in accuracy over standard supervised fine-tuning with a few codes modified and
no additional labeling effort. Furthermore, it is complementary to existing
methods. When integrated with related data augmentation methods, it leads to an
average improvement of 3% improvement in GSM8K accuracy and 1% improvement in
MATH accuracy across five datasets of various quality and size, as well as two
base models. We further investigate the mechanisms behind this improvement
through case studies and quantitative analysis, suggesting that our approach
may provide superior support for the model in capturing long-distance
dependencies, especially those related to questions. This enhancement could
deepen understanding of premises in questions and prior steps. Our code is
available at Github.
|
[
-0.5234537720680237,
-0.7869651317596436,
0.6923277974128723,
0.0406365692615509,
-0.20112672448158264,
0.24685612320899963,
-0.21905294060707092,
-0.42394593358039856,
0.18481357395648956,
0.7418356537818909,
-0.6844958066940308,
-0.4411540627479553,
-0.5241037011146545,
-0.0997045710682869,
0.07482573390007019,
0.6932362914085388,
0.045734189450740814,
0.12256988137960434,
-0.1482163965702057,
0.06558499485254288,
-0.4743724465370178,
-0.43638211488723755,
-0.7650529146194458,
-0.6103911399841309,
0.318716824054718,
0.3062479794025421,
0.6104769110679626,
0.7473165392875671,
0.5077967643737793,
0.23284058272838593,
0.03887426108121872,
0.6303451657295227,
-0.2533124089241028,
-0.022594306617975235,
-0.3459770679473877,
-0.5898803472518921,
-0.5808514952659607,
-0.006618454121053219,
0.346438467502594,
0.9054398536682129,
-0.25789812207221985,
0.24757027626037598,
-0.05703292414546013,
1.0231759548187256,
-0.8632239103317261,
0.43059009313583374,
-0.7508615255355835,
0.047574471682310104,
-0.13413605093955994,
-0.04703616350889206,
-0.36490148305892944,
-0.12561117112636566,
-0.037588223814964294,
-0.7024189233779907,
0.21754424273967743,
-0.012219827622175217,
0.6568764448165894,
0.5146647691726685,
-0.006230972241610289,
-0.2466680109500885,
-0.5630487203598022,
0.7592561841011047,
-0.5898318886756897,
0.3052615225315094,
0.8990775346755981,
0.3325418531894684,
-0.19189687073230743,
-0.502636194229126,
-0.44242703914642334,
0.0511842705309391,
-0.03089265525341034,
0.15072867274284363,
-0.09273538738489151,
0.32409942150115967,
0.917801022529602,
0.2656958997249603,
-0.2196335345506668,
-0.25012192130088806,
-0.5121171474456787,
-0.4449123442173004,
0.6260051131248474,
0.10885587334632874,
0.10318738222122192,
-0.05641835927963257,
0.11256137490272522,
0.1038600280880928,
-0.7828387022018433,
0.19615155458450317,
0.6147536039352417,
0.2588697075843811,
0.18389829993247986,
0.3042559325695038,
-0.7541675567626953,
0.884687066078186,
0.21109867095947266,
-0.08157537877559662,
0.1261824667453766,
-0.1047205775976181,
-0.41650015115737915,
0.09570057690143585,
0.37241196632385254,
0.011603403836488724,
0.23953698575496674,
0.016276927664875984,
-0.26508501172065735,
0.36947283148765564,
0.20468902587890625,
-0.610659658908844,
-0.6980632543563843,
0.08644625544548035,
-0.0436004102230072,
-0.08486785739660263,
0.10240454226732254,
-0.4426220655441284,
-0.3659380078315735,
-0.9049183130264282,
0.48106980323791504,
-0.1771550178527832,
-0.09737510234117508,
0.6685951948165894,
0.15655097365379333,
-0.20175385475158691,
0.6078875064849854,
-0.9368014931678772,
0.4011150896549225,
0.8508576154708862,
0.5528775453567505,
0.06851915270090103,
0.09505737572908401,
-0.7121983170509338,
0.011302368715405464,
-0.5614242553710938,
0.7124931216239929,
-0.6563739776611328,
0.06294838339090347,
-0.19078940153121948,
-0.0824723094701767,
-0.18691252171993256,
-0.7531483173370361,
0.6402642130851746,
-0.5232357382774353,
0.14250445365905762,
-0.2907792627811432,
-0.3882388472557068,
-0.2610134780406952,
0.14177395403385162,
-0.5025128126144409,
1.1744059324264526,
0.005352128762751818,
-0.5566461086273193,
0.15980015695095062,
-0.6282913088798523,
-0.448916494846344,
-0.05035547539591789,
-0.11242540925741196,
-0.48468977212905884,
0.10612766444683075,
0.6673587560653687,
0.4628852307796478,
-0.052418921142816544,
0.24335311353206635,
-0.33526283502578735,
-0.5157449245452881,
0.15263842046260834,
-0.03903651237487793,
0.8391488790512085,
0.24149104952812195,
-0.4959673285484314,
0.07888433337211609,
-0.9428083896636963,
0.18829327821731567,
-0.07683845609426498,
0.052038341760635376,
-0.5919997096061707,
-0.25594642758369446,
-0.7215660214424133,
0.32381579279899597,
-0.15205739438533783,
-0.5030010938644409,
0.10192003101110458,
-0.6112266182899475,
0.5176534056663513,
0.8206580877304077,
-0.0875786691904068,
0.5794774293899536,
-0.2667641043663025,
0.4955627918243408,
0.1978914886713028,
0.1990543156862259,
-0.4599030017852783,
-0.6156114935874939,
-1.012800693511963,
-0.4548109471797943,
0.5167962908744812,
0.4646327793598175,
-0.9466385841369629,
0.27521756291389465,
-0.04462140426039696,
-0.22445181012153625,
-0.6915269494056702,
0.2515200972557068,
0.5007972121238708,
0.7082393765449524,
0.3592611849308014,
-0.38259437680244446,
-0.6036096811294556,
-0.9079490303993225,
-0.34105387330055237,
0.27869221568107605,
-0.21174076199531555,
0.12188392132520676,
0.5250073671340942,
-0.032690513879060745,
0.7216895222663879,
-0.7848386764526367,
-0.08948586881160736,
0.08602593094110489,
-0.036932140588760376,
0.21914133429527283,
0.5753442645072937,
0.003272875677794218,
-0.5684096217155457,
-0.3998849093914032,
-0.07142521440982819,
-0.6468184590339661,
-0.10535182803869247,
-0.11680030822753906,
-0.5214470624923706,
-0.061182696372270584,
0.3959003984928131,
-0.6801671385765076,
0.5631330609321594,
0.11659806221723557,
-0.11946392804384232,
0.3873103857040405,
-0.09879245609045029,
0.03293948993086815,
-0.8308790922164917,
-0.31909671425819397,
0.15677790343761444,
-0.3645675480365753,
-0.5836876034736633,
0.07286857068538666,
0.33059701323509216,
-0.21322891116142273,
-0.21885234117507935,
0.2521859109401703,
-0.4789568781852722,
0.09300191700458527,
-0.22461175918579102,
-0.06457371264696121,
0.09298408031463623,
0.6762683987617493,
-0.15105988085269928,
0.7515888810157776,
0.6514393091201782,
-0.5483397841453552,
0.3188408613204956,
-0.12526163458824158,
-0.5448846817016602,
0.40884119272232056,
-0.39898085594177246,
0.5103453993797302,
-0.11094719916582108,
0.20611582696437836,
-0.7457785606384277,
-0.3437865972518921,
0.5288814902305603,
-0.4268341362476349,
0.2170594185590744,
-0.3587510883808136,
-0.5225975513458252,
-0.2677294611930847,
-0.2372158318758011,
0.3760311007499695,
0.5407432913780212,
-0.5894321203231812,
0.6261518001556396,
0.4972460865974426,
0.007093703839927912,
-0.5302090048789978,
-0.4828726351261139,
0.008382893167436123,
-0.22984352707862854,
-0.6251469850540161,
0.244756817817688,
0.01670490950345993,
-0.38888096809387207,
-0.24836958944797516,
-0.4804427921772003,
0.005525806453078985,
0.07720884680747986,
0.21510186791419983,
0.2613825500011444,
-0.11073770374059677,
0.19911785423755646,
0.2773616313934326,
-0.24894395470619202,
0.3935762345790863,
-0.7917619347572327,
0.37206602096557617,
0.02087605744600296,
-0.45091304183006287,
-0.33144330978393555,
0.24063782393932343,
0.23886419832706451,
-0.312241792678833,
0.5569317936897278,
0.2917982041835785,
-0.7235107421875,
-0.6680036187171936,
-0.6580407023429871,
-0.32191750407218933,
-0.5552746057510376,
0.006885559298098087,
-0.6064713001251221,
-0.9521076679229736,
0.6593480706214905,
-0.18641223013401031,
-0.29680442810058594,
0.22296345233917236,
0.33818840980529785,
-0.13978682458400726,
1.198281168937683,
0.5277324318885803,
0.21671199798583984,
0.5167920589447021,
-0.1405593901872635,
0.4964863657951355,
-0.840258002281189,
-0.24105393886566162,
-0.30545416474342346,
-0.04198933765292168,
-0.4409225285053253,
-0.618678867816925,
0.2492436021566391,
0.22073158621788025,
-0.19466929137706757,
0.1411484032869339,
-0.6861984133720398,
0.8759809136390686,
0.704533040523529,
0.5629683136940002,
0.2719711363315582,
0.22670961916446686,
-0.12950915098190308,
-0.134280264377594,
-0.7017606496810913,
-0.3300876021385193,
1.057384967803955,
0.25261345505714417,
0.7861988544464111,
-0.2525286078453064,
0.5840299725532532,
0.19707068800926208,
0.08348772674798965,
-0.6876427531242371,
0.5392922163009644,
0.13314351439476013,
-0.4824674427509308,
-0.2578521966934204,
-0.5485416054725647,
-0.5522842407226562,
0.26836612820625305,
-0.03236716613173485,
-0.8016064763069153,
0.05769263952970505,
0.2740091383457184,
-0.4694127142429352,
0.20394723117351532,
-1.0440597534179688,
0.507041871547699,
0.22158102691173553,
-0.513117253780365,
-0.15008167922496796,
-0.5427942872047424,
0.5152289867401123,
-0.24002020061016083,
0.15724048018455505,
-0.14965054392814636,
0.39199578762054443,
0.7344447374343872,
-0.3652443587779999,
0.9867427945137024,
-0.0919441282749176,
-0.1373954564332962,
0.4262106716632843,
0.1627052277326584,
0.6648850440979004,
0.11350304633378983,
0.0749061182141304,
0.31945207715034485,
-0.24239014089107513,
-0.6722708344459534,
-1.082556128501892,
0.6652875542640686,
-0.4000389873981476,
-0.9205819368362427,
-0.22612616419792175,
-0.6500381827354431,
-0.42938563227653503,
0.08661817759275436,
-0.09595154970884323,
0.43756264448165894,
0.7671958804130554,
-0.09684845805168152,
1.1807405948638916,
0.00312802754342556,
0.1536790430545807,
0.1844678670167923,
-0.06718616932630539,
-0.5464134812355042,
0.7998349666595459,
0.2901814877986908,
0.3987678587436676,
0.2839828133583069,
0.11597710847854614,
-0.1987750381231308,
-0.4462239742279053,
-0.425987184047699,
0.24579235911369324,
-0.8652496933937073,
-0.28470733761787415,
-0.5656583905220032,
-0.21470406651496887,
-0.48078829050064087,
0.0772465169429779,
-0.3199461102485657,
-0.7422162294387817,
0.022329695522785187,
-0.20403322577476501,
0.2023269236087799,
0.5126243829727173,
0.09308107942342758,
0.1646498441696167,
-0.44442012906074524,
0.32444673776626587,
0.3570546805858612,
0.4644263684749603,
0.05858096852898598,
-0.523468554019928,
-0.49152395129203796,
0.27498680353164673,
-0.3317093551158905,
-0.4972705841064453,
0.11155301332473755,
-0.11886260658502579,
0.4038192629814148,
0.2535836100578308,
0.23782166838645935,
1.071142554283142,
-0.3969520032405853,
0.5254916548728943,
0.15053723752498627,
-1.2584247589111328,
0.8095069527626038,
-0.40554311871528625,
0.47036296129226685,
0.27478137612342834,
0.04584575816988945,
-0.13760867714881897,
-0.43989890813827515,
-0.6124545931816101,
-0.49993896484375,
0.7315037250518799,
0.41312453150749207,
-0.0017232310492545366,
0.2998352646827698,
0.5422394871711731,
-0.04934454336762428,
0.15928898751735687,
-0.4024467170238495,
-0.19248953461647034,
-0.12929058074951172,
-0.20736205577850342,
-0.00323092401959002,
-0.10281996428966522,
-0.28369593620300293,
-0.7247158288955688,
0.7152547240257263,
-0.3763531446456909,
0.2800940275192261,
0.23212960362434387,
-0.05506664887070656,
-0.08235050737857819,
0.06823572516441345,
0.9493091702461243,
1.0242197513580322,
0.027655281126499176,
0.46848225593566895,
0.3450711965560913,
-0.5575680136680603,
-0.21887022256851196,
0.0669558122754097,
-0.21778534352779388,
-0.14446359872817993,
0.2109893262386322,
0.8089216947555542,
-0.001984233036637306,
-0.4656704366207123,
0.07102390378713608,
0.16468749940395355,
-0.28091639280319214,
-0.04458192363381386,
0.24854964017868042,
0.07458039373159409,
0.2587922215461731,
0.36212947964668274,
0.41431939601898193,
0.19342027604579926,
-0.3548988401889801,
0.18306851387023926,
0.3379172384738922,
-0.3431250751018524,
-0.3722573518753052,
0.49456652998924255,
-0.11867976188659668,
-0.3756229281425476,
0.2904670834541321,
-0.2122378945350647,
-0.7139439582824707,
0.674974799156189,
0.606478750705719,
0.7324192523956299,
-0.12940244376659393,
0.1546168327331543,
0.35772836208343506,
0.4317561089992523,
-0.3150064945220947,
0.15456369519233704,
-0.37174564599990845,
-0.7210201621055603,
-0.8269193768501282,
-0.4807800352573395,
-0.4457649290561676,
0.08838015049695969,
-0.5834559202194214,
0.14255785942077637,
-0.6331901550292969,
-0.045928921550512314,
0.14035280048847198,
0.12666435539722443,
-0.46013951301574707,
0.3709418773651123,
0.2083030492067337,
0.7188529372215271,
-0.716518759727478,
1.022384524345398,
0.7617960572242737,
-0.1433684229850769,
-1.0688843727111816,
-0.12241844832897186,
-0.23833000659942627,
-0.8155031800270081,
0.5619059205055237,
0.22596512734889984,
-0.34366098046302795,
-0.16044260561466217,
-0.6133529543876648,
-0.7052344083786011,
0.6931360960006714,
0.5726954936981201,
-0.6476437449455261,
0.2416396588087082,
0.23785872757434845,
0.5430200099945068,
-0.4403722882270813,
0.20531810820102692,
0.5985304117202759,
0.030852707102894783,
0.24481698870658875,
-0.9345930218696594,
0.148134246468544,
-0.22654016315937042,
-0.13623075187206268,
0.5380004048347473,
-0.4512975811958313,
0.6705266237258911,
-0.21246454119682312,
-0.11581125110387802,
-0.44492632150650024,
0.4415295124053955,
0.16217178106307983,
0.6993198394775391,
0.39696672558784485,
0.711095929145813,
1.112107515335083,
-0.19333301484584808,
0.7726153135299683,
-0.08344361931085587,
0.44474419951438904,
1.2229095697402954,
-0.10921712964773178,
0.4480886161327362,
0.47036561369895935,
-0.232889786362648,
0.33148401975631714,
0.6547583341598511,
0.25355061888694763,
0.6508412957191467,
0.3621041774749756,
-0.33263450860977173,
-0.68876713514328,
0.03740204870700836,
-0.2551354169845581,
0.012673722580075264,
0.5071304440498352,
-0.2606678307056427,
-0.09776072949171066,
0.10178317874670029,
-0.00033571282983757555,
0.1910148411989212,
-0.5823100805282593,
0.5923815965652466,
0.3596440553665161,
-0.7460108399391174,
0.6515668630599976,
-0.08976742625236511,
0.4366210699081421,
-0.3375408947467804,
-0.2535302937030792,
-0.30750781297683716,
0.33298608660697937,
-0.4003051221370697,
-0.5814850330352783,
0.38056567311286926,
-0.12164098769426346,
-0.20876960456371307,
-0.30445414781570435,
0.8767095804214478,
-0.3335172235965729,
-0.5843079090118408,
-0.12417832016944885,
0.39516016840934753,
-0.06792906671762466,
-0.33054375648498535,
-0.651523232460022,
-0.059779711067676544,
0.14093536138534546,
0.08688952773809433,
0.43847405910491943,
0.6098414659500122,
-0.3536626100540161,
0.8104049563407898,
1.0091179609298706,
0.12865248322486877,
0.165485218167305,
0.18847371637821198,
1.0520203113555908,
-0.6429992318153381,
-0.6188624501228333,
-0.9426913261413574,
0.3365824818611145,
-0.3475170135498047,
-0.16610340774059296,
0.8263598680496216,
0.5438547730445862,
1.2361918687820435,
-0.1279972940683365,
0.527049720287323,
0.512436032295227,
0.5328874588012695,
-0.8041303753852844,
0.4929041564464569,
-0.14217698574066162,
0.6376507878303528,
-0.3524402379989624,
-0.7507768273353577,
-0.6084504127502441,
0.847771406173706,
-0.6117238998413086,
-0.26563432812690735,
0.7476961016654968,
0.9176581501960754,
-0.332666277885437,
0.23402394354343414,
0.5041369199752808,
-0.19130480289459229,
0.20290514826774597,
0.5715659260749817,
0.996798574924469,
-0.5738390684127808,
0.17674264311790466,
-0.618054986000061,
-0.20228780806064606,
0.282026082277298,
-0.5586333274841309,
-1.2374194860458374,
-0.3410065174102783,
-0.6645190119743347,
-0.45612019300460815,
0.19296471774578094,
0.8661748170852661,
0.9401952028274536,
-0.825310230255127,
0.10253306478261948,
-0.25156229734420776,
0.38654154539108276,
-0.3017422556877136,
-0.20497393608093262,
0.33284467458724976,
-0.387214720249176,
-0.5667408108711243,
0.19585305452346802,
0.3745511770248413,
-0.32889628410339355,
-0.033072806894779205,
0.10742396861314774,
0.20018456876277924,
0.2505897879600525,
0.6720104813575745,
-0.02988182194530964,
-0.865893542766571,
-0.3684593141078949,
0.0756261795759201,
0.044884294271469116,
0.23185044527053833,
0.9560750126838684,
-0.8347220420837402,
0.7167246341705322,
0.3154261112213135,
0.7686681151390076,
0.6462251543998718,
0.0965045690536499,
0.3471919894218445,
-0.4978138506412506,
0.16559156775474548,
0.1760719120502472,
0.22932223975658417,
0.22148363292217255,
-0.5624140501022339,
0.5476813316345215,
0.39876264333724976,
-0.4197132885456085,
-0.9814030528068542,
0.33254870772361755,
-0.8793217539787292,
-0.065767802298069,
0.9656056761741638,
-0.2978210747241974,
-0.29796579480171204,
-0.2778886556625366,
-0.3397873044013977,
0.11825671792030334,
-0.5022016167640686,
1.0139859914779663,
0.9453145861625671,
-0.26477736234664917,
-0.27627813816070557,
-0.7597945928573608,
0.6307322978973389,
0.49701613187789917,
-0.8655181527137756,
-0.08191109448671341,
0.3406529128551483,
0.30946576595306396,
0.1578720659017563,
0.48497387766838074,
0.07846184819936752,
0.17411477863788605,
-0.09467065334320068,
-0.2973640561103821,
-0.23683229088783264,
-0.33440259099006653,
-0.31047794222831726,
0.17925158143043518,
-0.3637223243713379,
-0.3134308159351349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02177v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02177v2
|
ProTrix: Building Models for Planning and Reasoning over Tables with Sentence Context
| 2024-03-04T16:21:19 | 2024-07-01T11:31:21 |
Zirui Wu, Yansong Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Tables play a crucial role in conveying information in various domains. We
propose a Plan-then-Reason framework to answer different types of user queries
over tables with sentence context. The framework first plans the reasoning
paths over the context, then assigns each step to program-based or textual
reasoning to reach the final answer. This framework enhances the table
reasoning abilities for both in-context learning and fine-tuning methods.
GPT-3.5-Turbo following Plan-then-Reason framework surpasses other prompting
baselines without self-consistency while using less API calls and in-context
demonstrations. We also construct an instruction tuning set TrixInstruct to
evaluate the effectiveness of fine-tuning with this framework. We present
ProTrix model family by finetuning models on TrixInstruct. Our experiments show
that ProTrix family generalizes to diverse unseen tabular tasks with only 6k
training instances. We further demonstrate that ProTrix can generate accurate
and faithful explanations to answer complex free-form questions. Our work
underscores the importance of the planning and reasoning abilities towards a
model over tabular tasks with generalizability and interpretability. We
open-source our dataset and models at https://github.com/WilliamZR/ProTrix.
|
[
-0.36381494998931885,
-0.8177345395088196,
0.7877117395401001,
-0.01869889907538891,
-0.023802826181054115,
-0.5587928295135498,
0.15740710496902466,
-0.05643610283732414,
-0.14897426962852478,
0.5968422889709473,
-0.7101039886474609,
-0.3562089502811432,
0.03291656821966171,
-0.17416700720787048,
-0.4940321147441864,
0.9454648494720459,
-0.2942199110984802,
0.09399797767400742,
-0.15950775146484375,
0.2741459608078003,
-0.6797292828559875,
-0.16075477004051208,
-0.46219390630722046,
-0.2815376818180084,
0.46512913703918457,
1.1589815616607666,
0.872745931148529,
0.7174573540687561,
0.24262182414531708,
0.21166913211345673,
0.25350022315979004,
0.35894930362701416,
-0.345520943403244,
0.23888066411018372,
-0.46100398898124695,
-0.2830740809440613,
-0.6734673976898193,
-0.31691300868988037,
0.1884250044822693,
0.5440228581428528,
-0.09886014461517334,
0.20383962988853455,
-0.009028562344610691,
0.3555081784725189,
-0.5728935599327087,
0.4938086271286011,
-0.370876669883728,
0.06721553951501846,
-0.2304181009531021,
-0.131653293967247,
-0.4714741110801697,
-0.37592387199401855,
0.13040019571781158,
-0.8443717360496521,
0.2004614770412445,
0.1981085240840912,
0.6350141167640686,
0.055835455656051636,
-0.5166007280349731,
-0.19932077825069427,
-0.724108874797821,
0.22998836636543274,
-0.41530054807662964,
0.5702418684959412,
0.201839879155159,
0.5464985370635986,
-0.5172629952430725,
-1.168979525566101,
-0.7585803270339966,
-0.44177114963531494,
-0.18687544763088226,
-0.07815667986869812,
-0.18741388618946075,
0.27495503425598145,
0.2970861792564392,
0.08845497667789459,
-0.7856311798095703,
-0.16025683283805847,
-0.12991181015968323,
-0.08261125534772873,
0.1325741559267044,
0.3268190026283264,
0.35537421703338623,
0.05187095329165459,
-0.24002708494663239,
-0.05797050893306732,
-0.8718873858451843,
0.11677774041891098,
0.01541636697947979,
0.08128167688846588,
0.1713247001171112,
0.7057026624679565,
-0.460330992937088,
1.1391795873641968,
-0.15020325779914856,
0.46278083324432373,
-0.6034450531005859,
-0.3283900022506714,
-0.44944822788238525,
-0.10192335397005081,
0.28728631138801575,
0.4369828402996063,
0.6984436511993408,
-0.4681468605995178,
0.02954735793173313,
0.17807146906852722,
0.46353915333747864,
-0.824074387550354,
-0.33082708716392517,
0.3401985168457031,
-0.14860033988952637,
0.07649365812540054,
0.0669906735420227,
-0.658929705619812,
-0.15434594452381134,
-0.5535049438476562,
0.586986243724823,
-0.535876452922821,
-0.09075646102428436,
0.3939301371574402,
0.07573085278272629,
0.08487436175346375,
0.3357965648174286,
-1.005993127822876,
0.5446965098381042,
0.832843542098999,
0.5127394199371338,
0.1308501809835434,
-0.2685146927833557,
-0.9286996722221375,
0.34195077419281006,
-0.44612276554107666,
0.9363620281219482,
-0.38815099000930786,
-0.2058587521314621,
0.0607977919280529,
-0.14444540441036224,
-0.0432022362947464,
-0.42412763833999634,
0.6838818788528442,
-0.38149765133857727,
0.29769688844680786,
-0.5872375965118408,
-0.5011704564094543,
-0.20402750372886658,
0.29805517196655273,
-0.45464470982551575,
0.4504297077655792,
0.32090526819229126,
-0.6011919379234314,
0.5785728096961975,
-0.7841448187828064,
-0.3520720303058624,
0.2622649371623993,
-0.13804198801517487,
-0.23514758050441742,
-0.03356918320059776,
0.18568740785121918,
0.494735985994339,
-0.2833121716976166,
0.5820997953414917,
-0.12445244938135147,
-0.36203670501708984,
-0.058427151292562485,
0.3106493055820465,
0.46098801493644714,
0.2813628017902374,
-0.39596399664878845,
0.7424473762512207,
-0.5409150123596191,
0.35793477296829224,
-0.19514502584934235,
-0.16297698020935059,
0.0334530808031559,
0.18069104850292206,
-0.09413386881351471,
0.14021027088165283,
-0.27990710735321045,
-0.3004661500453949,
0.32311251759529114,
-0.2834884822368622,
0.5811535716056824,
0.27838146686553955,
-0.014327089302241802,
0.5247413516044617,
-0.3393735885620117,
0.4790734648704529,
-0.009752549231052399,
0.3514876961708069,
0.20488077402114868,
-0.35331669449806213,
-0.8726446628570557,
0.25699901580810547,
0.15469056367874146,
0.6138752698898315,
-0.9939025640487671,
-0.2031150460243225,
-0.267118364572525,
-0.46335917711257935,
0.11288736015558243,
-0.3178316652774811,
0.5146164894104004,
1.0516316890716553,
0.7075716257095337,
0.06752979755401611,
-0.7027189135551453,
-1.0641032457351685,
-0.5090469121932983,
-0.19138720631599426,
-0.14948157966136932,
0.12688344717025757,
0.576244056224823,
-0.06560860574245453,
1.231597900390625,
-0.5345412492752075,
-0.37616974115371704,
-0.7517152428627014,
0.07620115578174591,
0.12440793961286545,
0.43825846910476685,
0.3144966959953308,
-0.831280529499054,
-0.2627873718738556,
-0.19881412386894226,
-0.5596121549606323,
-0.18057166039943695,
-0.20405103266239166,
-0.3294721841812134,
-0.1622971147298813,
0.3922235071659088,
-0.7903139591217041,
0.35812613368034363,
-0.1925075799226761,
-0.7503726482391357,
0.7328766584396362,
-0.31460604071617126,
-0.20156747102737427,
-0.8247590661048889,
-0.047638632357120514,
0.01230554562062025,
-0.1920866221189499,
-0.9753608703613281,
0.05493856593966484,
0.27056920528411865,
-0.0011207963107153773,
-0.4770028591156006,
0.6414918303489685,
-0.26104968786239624,
-0.15253888070583344,
-0.06625640392303467,
-0.10949888080358505,
0.0646132081747055,
0.48202234506607056,
0.09312697499990463,
1.1470892429351807,
0.24117396771907806,
-0.9138729572296143,
0.09279633313417435,
0.5747417211532593,
-0.5183712244033813,
0.5231513977050781,
-0.7466873526573181,
-0.12533891201019287,
0.007104102987796068,
0.10936791449785233,
-0.7117706537246704,
-0.46660488843917847,
0.31536024808883667,
-0.20902878046035767,
-0.03951718658208847,
0.18144525587558746,
-0.365500271320343,
-0.437166690826416,
0.061547648161649704,
-0.2669578492641449,
0.030005235224962234,
-0.38866525888442993,
0.7487297654151917,
0.27680811285972595,
0.08315511047840118,
-0.5174340605735779,
-0.4460931718349457,
0.056596167385578156,
-0.19312898814678192,
-0.7983503341674805,
0.8005251884460449,
0.15792249143123627,
-0.6048038005828857,
-0.028854990378022194,
-0.4037647247314453,
-0.13073274493217468,
0.04433927685022354,
0.16566139459609985,
-0.015996795147657394,
-0.08844053745269775,
0.18806131184101105,
0.060028523206710815,
-0.2354239970445633,
0.031152112409472466,
-0.611371636390686,
0.5203803777694702,
-0.3941138684749603,
0.10927671194076538,
-0.22733934223651886,
0.41578802466392517,
0.24572451412677765,
-0.25002679228782654,
0.7735060453414917,
0.4264083206653595,
-0.4615129232406616,
-0.3132523000240326,
-0.4413597285747528,
-0.42697614431381226,
-0.3957740366458893,
0.33455735445022583,
-0.7109182476997375,
-0.7780352830886841,
0.5997514128684998,
0.053751882165670395,
0.11138257384300232,
0.27664509415626526,
0.5200967788696289,
-0.12110256403684616,
0.8090078234672546,
0.6073082089424133,
0.6759573221206665,
0.3230355679988861,
-0.4083406627178192,
0.19075869023799896,
-0.48520320653915405,
-0.4380202293395996,
-0.43322882056236267,
-0.1957341432571411,
-0.17003962397575378,
-0.019382063299417496,
0.4142307937145233,
0.15639199316501617,
-0.6571266651153564,
0.5776271820068359,
-0.3467899560928345,
0.5701811909675598,
0.8283259272575378,
0.1116897240281105,
0.06627477705478668,
-0.24588678777217865,
-0.3819928467273712,
0.12802797555923462,
-0.6727703809738159,
-0.6974756121635437,
0.5543436408042908,
-0.026451895013451576,
0.5160571336746216,
0.17857787013053894,
0.2769876718521118,
0.2526141405105591,
0.22027750313282013,
-0.3879740238189697,
0.8448061943054199,
-0.1404842585325241,
-0.6424927711486816,
-0.29500842094421387,
-0.3462238609790802,
-0.6634921431541443,
0.2709232270717621,
-0.13737350702285767,
-1.0091196298599243,
0.31697288155555725,
0.4227820634841919,
-0.7550930380821228,
0.1019543930888176,
-1.102409839630127,
1.433434009552002,
-0.13002586364746094,
-0.825946033000946,
0.14973901212215424,
-0.5398914217948914,
0.30408239364624023,
0.2501082718372345,
-0.17145943641662598,
0.03387289121747017,
0.189512237906456,
0.6833242177963257,
-0.7320639491081238,
0.4460839033126831,
-0.346645712852478,
0.2604127526283264,
0.33902743458747864,
0.5439223051071167,
0.32777777314186096,
0.3365458548069,
-0.1405998021364212,
-0.310867577791214,
0.1944459080696106,
0.11867276579141617,
-0.5922545790672302,
0.5331390500068665,
-0.4105317294597626,
-0.7731646299362183,
-0.16903522610664368,
-0.7038265466690063,
-0.34329041838645935,
0.3373952805995941,
0.2249690294265747,
0.6660693883895874,
0.13185061514377594,
0.19399161636829376,
0.47396624088287354,
0.043869033455848694,
0.34238287806510925,
0.4441863000392914,
-0.10981414467096329,
-0.11219417303800583,
0.46526509523391724,
0.3050459027290344,
-0.04321949928998947,
0.6250045299530029,
0.2253357619047165,
-0.6020936965942383,
-0.47672799229621887,
-0.5464515686035156,
-0.1888921707868576,
-0.6361241936683655,
-0.32143881916999817,
-0.6658239960670471,
0.12350163608789444,
-0.356845885515213,
-0.06538208574056625,
0.054284680634737015,
-0.576951265335083,
-0.20985305309295654,
-0.24461331963539124,
0.21012963354587555,
0.5180970430374146,
0.06956572085618973,
0.7824705243110657,
-0.47981736063957214,
0.42951080203056335,
0.45269080996513367,
0.4722335636615753,
-0.2762584388256073,
-0.15844224393367767,
0.010468739084899426,
-0.11912882328033447,
-0.4582318663597107,
-1.3495553731918335,
0.5263319611549377,
0.2370319366455078,
0.6269122362136841,
0.12542742490768433,
0.08027980476617813,
0.702153205871582,
-0.43056216835975647,
0.46036675572395325,
-0.31520190834999084,
-1.028835415840149,
0.6596741676330566,
-0.5217878222465515,
0.3637581169605255,
0.7019261121749878,
0.32564014196395874,
-0.38117605447769165,
0.09528838843107224,
-0.44703856110572815,
-0.6378589868545532,
0.8198870420455933,
0.2136959582567215,
-0.41543635725975037,
0.032266389578580856,
0.8012197613716125,
0.036071229726076126,
-0.03224329650402069,
-0.7275592088699341,
0.2544027268886566,
-0.20674476027488708,
-0.18379776179790497,
0.19032976031303406,
-0.5692272782325745,
0.023156972602009773,
-0.1921897977590561,
0.3534088730812073,
-0.290175199508667,
0.2049466371536255,
0.27267390489578247,
-0.29196682572364807,
0.03969539701938629,
0.5582407116889954,
0.8978428244590759,
1.11249840259552,
-0.3591954708099365,
0.34995004534721375,
0.21631060540676117,
-0.3955380916595459,
0.0342259518802166,
0.1673024445772171,
-0.20106779038906097,
-0.2583664059638977,
0.19321878254413605,
0.6839221715927124,
0.33075466752052307,
-0.39991265535354614,
0.1841680109500885,
-0.35330837965011597,
-0.34259065985679626,
-0.30547645688056946,
0.5048049688339233,
0.1514495611190796,
0.3719480633735657,
-0.016519198194146156,
-0.22196058928966522,
0.2635955512523651,
-0.4696032702922821,
0.48437291383743286,
0.13961352407932281,
-0.43382853269577026,
-0.06687771528959274,
1.1579948663711548,
-0.18284659087657928,
-0.5039922595024109,
0.7331106066703796,
-0.21392588317394257,
-0.2673123776912689,
0.5535946488380432,
0.5758211016654968,
0.5714717507362366,
-0.1588108390569687,
0.41081199049949646,
0.2302200347185135,
0.15924113988876343,
-0.32319071888923645,
0.8653918504714966,
-0.21942541003227234,
-0.6683386564254761,
-0.3364311456680298,
-0.4017567038536072,
-0.5791621208190918,
0.08501919358968735,
-0.255107581615448,
0.4120194911956787,
-0.298202246427536,
-0.1761550009250641,
-0.024430036544799805,
-0.11557035893201828,
-0.5131778717041016,
0.1608920395374298,
-0.19534577429294586,
1.1923121213912964,
-0.5352948307991028,
0.8209734559059143,
0.5998640060424805,
-0.5581569671630859,
-1.0725903511047363,
-0.18569204211235046,
-0.18243476748466492,
-0.3963724672794342,
0.7682799100875854,
0.34433513879776,
-0.020546121522784233,
0.1609961837530136,
-0.2664014995098114,
-0.5804594159126282,
0.8955112099647522,
0.5661944150924683,
-0.6549201011657715,
-0.4019383490085602,
0.3381898105144501,
0.5042448043823242,
-0.40014776587486267,
0.45741504430770874,
0.8356751799583435,
0.5216622948646545,
0.09668079018592834,
-0.7675039172172546,
0.05421478673815727,
-0.07893328368663788,
-0.15236283838748932,
0.030654428526759148,
0.010004844516515732,
1.0323845148086548,
-0.36854761838912964,
-0.06374700367450714,
-0.2744675874710083,
0.7021345496177673,
0.3139752447605133,
0.17660778760910034,
0.5394571423530579,
0.47688496112823486,
0.4143005907535553,
-0.44477036595344543,
0.9850374460220337,
-0.09814471006393433,
-0.15962640941143036,
1.2483220100402832,
-0.3399384915828705,
0.6414114832878113,
0.2835558354854584,
0.23924778401851654,
0.5159123539924622,
0.6728453040122986,
0.32737967371940613,
0.5655306577682495,
0.3324105143547058,
-0.0011895331554114819,
-0.43260931968688965,
-0.0029509970918297768,
-0.180123969912529,
0.6432831883430481,
0.4952920377254486,
0.007540081162005663,
-0.6797988414764404,
0.044974349439144135,
0.17210617661476135,
0.16253958642482758,
-0.4627586305141449,
0.5827738046646118,
-0.031153565272688866,
-1.1276003122329712,
0.34743714332580566,
0.0430096834897995,
-0.0707254484295845,
-0.5128085613250732,
-0.10962902754545212,
-0.33398836851119995,
0.6507183313369751,
-0.18686604499816895,
-0.983616054058075,
0.5891690850257874,
0.00446042837575078,
0.027240030467510223,
-0.5566269755363464,
0.8164270520210266,
-0.18481892347335815,
-0.110195092856884,
-0.1097022071480751,
0.5917953252792358,
-0.042346227914094925,
-0.2788879871368408,
-0.43254518508911133,
-0.3080017864704132,
-0.07668296992778778,
-0.15681259334087372,
-0.0356941856443882,
0.2791247069835663,
-0.5999354124069214,
0.8289104700088501,
0.35776984691619873,
-0.12230255454778671,
-0.12161456048488617,
0.1338265985250473,
0.8413308262825012,
-0.33999359607696533,
-0.7709008455276489,
-0.9614623785018921,
0.5054552555084229,
-0.022037874907255173,
-0.35104525089263916,
0.4772244095802307,
0.6627164483070374,
0.7528402805328369,
-0.2745794653892517,
0.10143925994634628,
0.014724714681506157,
0.4163343012332916,
-0.6119619607925415,
0.6109353303909302,
-0.37298783659935,
0.024448666721582413,
-0.015389420092105865,
-0.8829650282859802,
-0.624339759349823,
0.7094065546989441,
-0.7308187484741211,
-0.020549649372696877,
0.5755836367607117,
0.7436250448226929,
-0.11154229938983917,
0.2986789643764496,
-0.016803646460175514,
0.0762878879904747,
0.6885244846343994,
0.6496363282203674,
0.7056160569190979,
-0.021783659234642982,
0.5583555698394775,
-0.033925533294677734,
-0.168964684009552,
-0.24482440948486328,
-0.8065810203552246,
-0.6139558553695679,
-0.6597022414207458,
0.009789809584617615,
-0.16688258945941925,
0.2380024641752243,
0.6315143704414368,
0.7962602972984314,
-0.7644698023796082,
-0.3477388024330139,
-0.7844740748405457,
0.17160648107528687,
-0.2734162211418152,
-0.18116623163223267,
0.4203481376171112,
-0.33169177174568176,
-0.09410492330789566,
0.2815822660923004,
0.139267697930336,
-0.05549108609557152,
-0.022891275584697723,
0.059383098036050797,
-0.33511969447135925,
-0.10090510547161102,
0.40633687376976013,
0.34150558710098267,
-0.5400670170783997,
-0.34517204761505127,
0.27278396487236023,
0.11992274969816208,
-0.10566438734531403,
0.9388744831085205,
-0.8906238079071045,
0.31740623712539673,
0.6605821251869202,
0.21064265072345734,
0.5406712889671326,
0.002077127108350396,
0.7624905705451965,
-0.6224474310874939,
-0.026840878650546074,
0.2690940797328949,
0.465943306684494,
0.08819419145584106,
-0.4445979595184326,
0.7162811756134033,
-0.24990728497505188,
-0.596567690372467,
-0.6179094910621643,
0.36874884366989136,
-0.921440601348877,
-0.303396612405777,
0.9769250750541687,
0.13270722329616547,
-0.2708747088909149,
-0.3093089163303375,
-0.34498751163482666,
0.4948142170906067,
-0.0794941782951355,
0.7296617031097412,
0.40229332447052,
-0.6044290065765381,
-0.3810141682624817,
-0.8015156984329224,
0.9590225219726562,
0.4478739798069,
-1.1547352075576782,
0.1714363992214203,
0.5054140090942383,
0.0851154774427414,
-0.03581126779317856,
0.7899043560028076,
0.097212053835392,
0.49279576539993286,
-0.17816734313964844,
-0.09469863027334213,
-0.5923384428024292,
-0.8723315000534058,
0.3513904809951782,
0.47768673300743103,
-0.18015213310718536,
-0.1274360567331314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02176v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02176v1
|
EEE-QA: Exploring Effective and Efficient Question-Answer Representations
| 2024-03-04T16:21:13 | 2024-03-04T16:21:13 |
Zhanghao Hu, Yijun Yang, Junjie Xu, Yifu Qiu, Pinzhen Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current approaches to question answering rely on pre-trained language models
(PLMs) like RoBERTa. This work challenges the existing question-answer encoding
convention and explores finer representations. We begin with testing various
pooling methods compared to using the begin-of-sentence token as a question
representation for better quality. Next, we explore opportunities to
simultaneously embed all answer candidates with the question. This enables
cross-reference between answer choices and improves inference throughput via
reduced memory usage. Despite their simplicity and effectiveness, these methods
have yet to be widely studied in current frameworks. We experiment with
different PLMs, and with and without the integration of knowledge graphs.
Results prove that the memory efficacy of the proposed techniques with little
sacrifice in performance. Practically, our work enhances 38-100% throughput
with 26-65% speedups on consumer-grade GPUs by allowing for considerably larger
batch sizes. Our work sends a message to the community with promising
directions in both representation quality and efficiency for the
question-answering task in natural language processing.
|
[
-0.698830246925354,
-0.9507113695144653,
0.9128299951553345,
-0.08878345042467117,
-0.2104347199201584,
0.05161150172352791,
0.01109930407255888,
-0.34494662284851074,
0.1528979390859604,
0.3937201499938965,
-0.12401331961154938,
-0.22780954837799072,
-0.4846690595149994,
0.13498522341251373,
-0.3802226185798645,
0.34469857811927795,
0.0010156987700611353,
0.21449287235736847,
-0.6109656691551208,
-0.3169843852519989,
-0.4484052360057831,
-0.6783398389816284,
-0.8713556528091431,
-0.008568176999688148,
0.5400225520133972,
0.25969740748405457,
0.4976184666156769,
0.4132066071033478,
0.16093431413173676,
0.23295661807060242,
0.05274074524641037,
0.2679716944694519,
-0.38838276267051697,
0.1455405056476593,
0.01729324646294117,
-0.7878612279891968,
-0.25566965341567993,
0.06895744055509567,
0.4409533441066742,
0.7001789808273315,
-0.27399060130119324,
0.25327739119529724,
0.005862730089575052,
0.46045321226119995,
-0.7285571098327637,
-0.08030824363231659,
-0.5577983260154724,
-0.2261996567249298,
-0.047251176089048386,
-0.25037628412246704,
-0.6124645471572876,
-0.48920348286628723,
0.16562600433826447,
-0.6753430366516113,
-0.12867389619350433,
0.3040330708026886,
0.8577035069465637,
0.2323267161846161,
-0.3916517198085785,
-0.23638829588890076,
-0.6382812261581421,
0.7986878752708435,
-0.5519669651985168,
0.419109582901001,
0.45301204919815063,
0.3323448598384857,
0.15577934682369232,
-0.8722327947616577,
-0.5951142311096191,
0.16391274333000183,
0.01378230657428503,
0.3481733202934265,
-0.2191331684589386,
0.19766083359718323,
0.21156390011310577,
0.3953143060207367,
-0.72549968957901,
-0.10228689014911652,
-0.17898282408714294,
0.03241854906082153,
0.34677594900131226,
0.01720621809363365,
0.5019735097885132,
0.09611427783966064,
-0.20705781877040863,
-0.1783825159072876,
-0.6400793790817261,
0.0933932214975357,
0.10410737246274948,
-0.06454214453697205,
0.5003657341003418,
0.6935311555862427,
0.028333822265267372,
0.7143021821975708,
-0.08867333829402924,
0.32442817091941833,
0.046517375856637955,
-0.2620834410190582,
-0.14453275501728058,
-0.40236136317253113,
0.359897643327713,
0.12989483773708344,
0.24645379185676575,
-0.29856181144714355,
0.08944999426603317,
-0.09545084089040756,
0.19834256172180176,
-0.8490676283836365,
-0.20424404740333557,
0.5474132299423218,
-0.43074020743370056,
0.4390276074409485,
0.32082268595695496,
-0.8458012342453003,
-0.028644781559705734,
-0.0410052165389061,
0.6247090697288513,
-0.6489517092704773,
-0.11120545864105225,
0.44931313395500183,
-0.3676467537879944,
0.5461865067481995,
0.27482032775878906,
-0.5200183391571045,
0.4970609247684479,
0.38125768303871155,
0.29226788878440857,
0.17937205731868744,
0.019616086035966873,
-0.7654014825820923,
0.2987222373485565,
-0.11897023022174835,
0.8331241607666016,
-0.7414316534996033,
-0.20227472484111786,
0.06669990718364716,
-0.30459216237068176,
-0.27947819232940674,
-0.6774486303329468,
0.3052947223186493,
-1.078905701637268,
0.6228193640708923,
-0.44003134965896606,
-1.1102125644683838,
-0.3572666645050049,
0.24797265231609344,
-0.7229755520820618,
0.994414746761322,
0.02660348452627659,
-0.4964906871318817,
0.09520488232374191,
-0.7335420846939087,
-0.09081406146287918,
-0.05684264376759529,
-0.0769660472869873,
-0.000999567797407508,
0.2513103783130646,
0.5981711745262146,
0.3144179880619049,
-0.2290044128894806,
-0.36398476362228394,
-0.07552959024906158,
-0.43641194701194763,
0.42417317628860474,
-0.20900559425354004,
0.6918859481811523,
0.36745700240135193,
0.08555880934000015,
-0.25194036960601807,
-0.6320679783821106,
0.42456939816474915,
0.11336187273263931,
-0.1921006739139557,
-0.5242807865142822,
-0.13277174532413483,
-0.2977991998195648,
-0.04155870899558067,
0.44149085879325867,
-0.6322407126426697,
-0.08030492067337036,
-0.3277325928211212,
0.2696300148963928,
0.45703813433647156,
0.005368430633097887,
0.6120650172233582,
-0.41506800055503845,
0.7931907773017883,
-0.02491050586104393,
0.1417645961046219,
-0.45438122749328613,
-0.5622578263282776,
-0.6647671461105347,
-0.1348070204257965,
0.4820854067802429,
0.6777421236038208,
-0.87389075756073,
0.11667954921722412,
0.054765064269304276,
-0.2730944752693176,
-0.7558141350746155,
0.05419008806347847,
0.21063733100891113,
0.31202444434165955,
0.6570501327514648,
-0.2262025624513626,
-0.3705812096595764,
-0.6276234984397888,
-0.4222448170185089,
-0.44683191180229187,
-0.3074318468570709,
0.36232611536979675,
0.07432956993579865,
0.27687591314315796,
0.8713659644126892,
-0.7129555940628052,
0.31373706459999084,
-0.3736009895801544,
0.24209949374198914,
-0.00779394805431366,
0.2374916821718216,
0.7038869857788086,
-0.7417270541191101,
-0.450143963098526,
-0.5343004465103149,
-0.6010483503341675,
-0.027003437280654907,
0.08088661730289459,
-0.21244561672210693,
0.030806634575128555,
0.4067364037036896,
-0.557201623916626,
0.22388632595539093,
0.4588145315647125,
-0.39070168137550354,
0.16908034682273865,
-0.4052547514438629,
0.39742475748062134,
-1.0279490947723389,
-0.054471857845783234,
-0.1273561269044876,
-0.41154128313064575,
-0.5296646952629089,
0.3066388666629791,
0.08168955892324448,
-0.23255372047424316,
-0.43183594942092896,
0.3586213290691376,
-0.7123076319694519,
-0.02234742045402527,
-0.04382859915494919,
0.451587051153183,
0.3038213849067688,
0.4123057723045349,
-0.2238660305738449,
1.1780517101287842,
0.3811373710632324,
-0.564971387386322,
0.03930976614356041,
0.31030306220054626,
0.09767812490463257,
0.4191916286945343,
-0.8583523035049438,
0.5737229585647583,
-0.5799027681350708,
-0.015393502078950405,
-1.0435055494308472,
0.14684800803661346,
-0.009955535642802715,
-0.4532639682292938,
0.2995794713497162,
0.04875538498163223,
-0.7019275426864624,
-0.4084092974662781,
-0.5350502133369446,
0.5227903127670288,
1.0387704372406006,
-0.4718617796897888,
0.7794159650802612,
0.5412817597389221,
-0.12605205178260803,
-0.19742795825004578,
-0.6407151222229004,
-0.12781791388988495,
-0.27138325572013855,
-0.7503643035888672,
0.33888745307922363,
-0.13454386591911316,
-0.05274214223027229,
0.0804690271615982,
-0.015412977896630764,
-0.46857866644859314,
0.05275635048747063,
-0.34095829725265503,
-0.00032278895378112793,
-0.2968844473361969,
0.38017538189888,
-0.0362853929400444,
0.05567874386906624,
0.0959891676902771,
-0.3892838656902313,
0.7399464249610901,
-0.10229921340942383,
-0.40142545104026794,
-0.35223013162612915,
0.7450833916664124,
0.34090426564216614,
-0.5511409044265747,
0.9005308747291565,
0.25681790709495544,
-0.37933090329170227,
-0.1867278814315796,
-0.6620103716850281,
-0.33794301748275757,
-0.40757742524147034,
0.3131711781024933,
-0.2573477625846863,
-0.9386397004127502,
0.7531121969223022,
-0.09063505381345749,
-0.020281029865145683,
0.09961584955453873,
0.036536503583192825,
-0.6083323359489441,
0.9663839936256409,
0.5116962790489197,
0.3631614148616791,
0.4845713973045349,
-0.265197217464447,
0.3910658657550812,
-0.7446044087409973,
-0.03948124498128891,
-0.7042495012283325,
-0.14730022847652435,
-0.34609413146972656,
-0.8282952904701233,
0.44878247380256653,
0.3498309552669525,
-0.2198021560907364,
0.2135012298822403,
-0.18293921649456024,
0.4610336422920227,
0.5473583936691284,
0.27628225088119507,
0.20901480317115784,
-0.23213757574558258,
0.2321968972682953,
0.06297323852777481,
-1.0745514631271362,
-0.6851629018783569,
1.274755835533142,
0.28457897901535034,
0.4684743583202362,
-0.07034427672624588,
0.8612709641456604,
-0.11968009173870087,
0.21323262155056,
-0.1511656790971756,
0.7181609272956848,
-0.31915169954299927,
-0.5381274819374084,
-0.5820285081863403,
-0.21376287937164307,
-0.9452546238899231,
0.30032625794410706,
-0.027916479855775833,
-0.6758068799972534,
0.026398207992315292,
0.17366719245910645,
-0.5900205969810486,
0.41893887519836426,
-0.9118232131004333,
0.8797906637191772,
-0.06350085139274597,
-0.28980472683906555,
-0.275400847196579,
-0.2490929663181305,
-0.007049343083053827,
0.3541506230831146,
-0.18979665637016296,
0.15876872837543488,
-0.1733233779668808,
0.7730799317359924,
-0.49281439185142517,
0.3661210238933563,
-0.3904704749584198,
0.1035289391875267,
0.8182496428489685,
-0.3426339626312256,
0.43411773443222046,
0.18430478870868683,
-0.14414730668067932,
-0.2704412043094635,
0.2669065296649933,
-0.830009937286377,
-0.9478891491889954,
0.3113643527030945,
-0.6167292594909668,
-0.7284863591194153,
-0.18477316200733185,
-0.396684855222702,
-0.5608342885971069,
-0.13729920983314514,
-0.14177927374839783,
0.44252678751945496,
-0.16117654740810394,
0.10433963686227798,
1.1492576599121094,
-0.47846031188964844,
0.3230725824832916,
0.21747758984565735,
-0.3448849618434906,
-0.25230157375335693,
0.6888298392295837,
0.34685543179512024,
0.20244047045707703,
0.3973245620727539,
-0.12295382469892502,
-0.5721670985221863,
-0.6876091361045837,
-0.3223726153373718,
0.293605238199234,
-0.5773918032646179,
-0.09188313037157059,
-0.7074683308601379,
-0.14649221301078796,
-0.21988628804683685,
0.11534329503774643,
-0.25507652759552,
-0.4988706409931183,
-0.34264278411865234,
-0.1801242083311081,
0.28007474541664124,
0.45847320556640625,
0.3176094591617584,
0.25963565707206726,
-0.8576993346214294,
0.4366031289100647,
0.7312204241752625,
0.4235144555568695,
0.046580877155065536,
-0.1954883337020874,
-0.062150437384843826,
0.08040208369493484,
-0.2216005027294159,
-1.3343467712402344,
0.11907482147216797,
0.20998837053775787,
0.7605029940605164,
-0.020414697006344795,
0.186691015958786,
0.724268913269043,
-0.26408764719963074,
0.9915941953659058,
0.018357886001467705,
-0.790831446647644,
0.6049532294273376,
-0.10731755197048187,
0.2581808269023895,
0.8743380904197693,
0.4378194808959961,
-0.17010079324245453,
-0.6048248410224915,
-0.6571602821350098,
-0.8868580460548401,
0.1633903682231903,
0.09166812896728516,
0.2928698658943176,
-0.3941836357116699,
0.45092305541038513,
0.12189719825983047,
0.21294650435447693,
-0.26752737164497375,
-0.40988561511039734,
-0.14148904383182526,
-0.30138304829597473,
0.14400865137577057,
-0.4463668465614319,
0.21877099573612213,
-0.21986067295074463,
0.531264066696167,
-0.08083569258451462,
0.5316124558448792,
0.4801596999168396,
-0.3456423878669739,
0.3161117434501648,
0.46634408831596375,
0.16109074652194977,
0.8035248517990112,
-0.12621764838695526,
0.14454308152198792,
0.32181811332702637,
-0.23899461328983307,
0.040698178112506866,
0.24228714406490326,
-0.252749502658844,
0.05483442172408104,
-0.011539829894900322,
0.3416406512260437,
-0.03136351332068443,
-0.8148290514945984,
0.5327016115188599,
-0.38651251792907715,
0.16653506457805634,
-0.3317326605319977,
-0.00021449742780532688,
0.3056929409503937,
0.0740804597735405,
0.4869948923587799,
-0.322230726480484,
0.1371830254793167,
-0.6822954416275024,
0.2382560670375824,
0.43927738070487976,
-0.22258412837982178,
-0.17985031008720398,
0.7674622535705566,
0.37938547134399414,
-0.045771900564432144,
0.7484040856361389,
-0.3074733316898346,
-0.3958723545074463,
0.6418687105178833,
0.4410380721092224,
0.7269100546836853,
-0.06117909774184227,
0.4145558178424835,
0.30453523993492126,
0.11602341383695602,
0.11542030423879623,
0.8840088844299316,
0.08264925330877304,
-0.7573780417442322,
-0.6795702576637268,
-0.39308038353919983,
-0.3410209119319916,
-0.10159449279308319,
-0.7592431306838989,
-0.17651282250881195,
-0.27901139855384827,
-0.12142980098724365,
-0.4053328037261963,
0.0015564973000437021,
-0.9135599136352539,
0.021018633618950844,
0.08060199022293091,
1.2242889404296875,
-0.6321106553077698,
0.7117900252342224,
0.9821413159370422,
-0.660165011882782,
-0.9936171174049377,
0.08576058596372604,
-0.7104741334915161,
-0.6269230246543884,
0.32054027915000916,
0.04474155232310295,
0.24859599769115448,
0.4033665657043457,
-0.43600574135780334,
-0.6970629692077637,
1.323791742324829,
0.4900642931461334,
-0.33468422293663025,
0.022172946482896805,
0.2678780257701874,
0.5835127234458923,
-0.3221704959869385,
0.6021649241447449,
0.4966839849948883,
0.4584130644798279,
-0.21419672667980194,
-0.5694124102592468,
0.0034054580610245466,
-0.2847130596637726,
0.07420199364423752,
0.08486656844615936,
-0.5557094216346741,
0.7194517254829407,
-0.11040180176496506,
-0.4183204770088196,
0.1878327876329422,
1.0159626007080078,
0.4405752718448639,
0.3682851791381836,
0.4519895613193512,
0.7420468330383301,
1.1272156238555908,
-0.30479440093040466,
1.3109586238861084,
-0.5120553374290466,
0.08356279134750366,
0.7644792199134827,
-0.18982358276844025,
0.9251199960708618,
0.8639195561408997,
-0.4501948058605194,
0.659990131855011,
0.4548768103122711,
0.3768782615661621,
0.3948494791984558,
0.4241907596588135,
-0.20311930775642395,
-0.4764745235443115,
-0.14781729876995087,
-0.23629038035869598,
0.17695608735084534,
-0.04034772887825966,
-0.06561238318681717,
-0.22498086094856262,
0.13799235224723816,
-0.2263791412115097,
0.5930541753768921,
-0.3629376292228699,
0.7367522120475769,
0.06651133298873901,
-0.6709246039390564,
0.2773462235927582,
-0.25932326912879944,
0.6189283728599548,
-0.558179497718811,
-0.2786042392253876,
-0.4317503571510315,
-0.3299793601036072,
0.22908620536327362,
-0.7277052998542786,
0.22434523701667786,
-0.04370428994297981,
-0.1365230679512024,
-0.44484224915504456,
0.6587368845939636,
-0.6410402655601501,
-0.18604139983654022,
0.24426671862602234,
1.048906922340393,
0.135118305683136,
-0.16821067035198212,
-0.38010838627815247,
-0.22427543997764587,
-0.29276925325393677,
-0.36500051617622375,
0.2022981494665146,
0.4648343622684479,
0.16668641567230225,
0.5571317672729492,
0.3125339448451996,
0.09274394810199738,
0.5397525429725647,
0.1108565405011177,
0.76463383436203,
-0.5482960343360901,
-0.5240656137466431,
-0.3969426155090332,
0.6604767441749573,
-0.38005581498146057,
-0.1675114780664444,
0.7328463792800903,
0.5632714033126831,
0.9474371075630188,
-0.030938398092985153,
0.648750364780426,
-0.012374049983918667,
0.39603620767593384,
-0.6180357933044434,
0.46053773164749146,
-0.41519173979759216,
0.4228730797767639,
0.10001228004693985,
-0.792150616645813,
-0.10429257154464722,
0.42506906390190125,
-0.2519213855266571,
0.10639812052249908,
0.9400110244750977,
0.5198062062263489,
0.16608774662017822,
0.20230449736118317,
0.3672395348548889,
-0.04627152159810066,
0.23619098961353302,
0.862491250038147,
0.8933493494987488,
-0.8023683428764343,
0.6781564950942993,
-0.19527022540569305,
-0.07536409795284271,
0.16892969608306885,
-0.4890840947628021,
-0.80327308177948,
-0.5567856431007385,
-0.39976027607917786,
-0.1580754816532135,
0.2701340615749359,
0.6896825432777405,
0.5181537866592407,
-0.6974238157272339,
-0.0026625406462699175,
-0.07841043919324875,
0.08275358378887177,
-0.3315598666667938,
-0.18302926421165466,
0.41559579968452454,
-0.5545592904090881,
-0.7801440954208374,
0.19529350101947784,
0.08126009255647659,
0.01836681179702282,
-0.20342016220092773,
-0.004403416533023119,
-0.2769249975681305,
0.3286224901676178,
0.5749133229255676,
0.20693092048168182,
-0.47612422704696655,
-0.5950741171836853,
0.3631157875061035,
0.011095767840743065,
0.09524396806955338,
0.8216686844825745,
-0.9658246636390686,
0.3158400058746338,
0.7361590266227722,
1.0970547199249268,
0.46722081303596497,
0.2577112019062042,
0.8084811568260193,
-0.5298610329627991,
-0.1049850732088089,
0.5939688682556152,
0.41632646322250366,
0.06385959684848785,
-0.18237219750881195,
0.37163466215133667,
-0.23375990986824036,
-0.3936454653739929,
-0.5866117477416992,
0.08844629675149918,
-1.0557136535644531,
-0.45561257004737854,
0.8734411597251892,
-0.40686774253845215,
-0.37730833888053894,
-0.18015816807746887,
-0.23369355499744415,
0.16882102191448212,
-0.2592969536781311,
0.6772969961166382,
0.7245832085609436,
-0.3506717383861542,
-0.5638058185577393,
-0.5634358525276184,
0.22052279114723206,
0.7356172800064087,
-1.0674854516983032,
-0.10637246817350388,
0.3128730356693268,
0.18968483805656433,
0.09322470426559448,
0.806982159614563,
-0.3501775562763214,
0.3763590455055237,
-0.14851395785808563,
-0.04892779514193535,
-0.1624792516231537,
-0.09112762659788132,
-0.3487902283668518,
0.7215551733970642,
0.29338908195495605,
-0.37112757563591003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02173v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02173v1
|
What has LeBenchmark Learnt about French Syntax?
| 2024-03-04T16:20:14 | 2024-03-04T16:20:14 |
Zdravko Dugonjić, Adrien Pupier, Benjamin Lecouteux, Maximin Coavoux
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The paper reports on a series of experiments aiming at probing LeBenchmark, a
pretrained acoustic model trained on 7k hours of spoken French, for syntactic
information. Pretrained acoustic models are increasingly used for downstream
speech tasks such as automatic speech recognition, speech translation, spoken
language understanding or speech parsing. They are trained on very low level
information (the raw speech signal), and do not have explicit lexical
knowledge. Despite that, they obtained reasonable results on tasks that
requires higher level linguistic knowledge. As a result, an emerging question
is whether these models encode syntactic information. We probe each
representation layer of LeBenchmark for syntax, using the Orf\'eo treebank, and
observe that it has learnt some syntactic information. Our results show that
syntactic information is more easily extractable from the middle layers of the
network, after which a very sharp decrease is observed.
|
[
-0.4027490019798279,
-0.8121986985206604,
0.4868847727775574,
0.005589290522038937,
-0.03270496055483818,
-0.07071266323328018,
-0.3465912640094757,
-0.6946762204170227,
0.10037986934185028,
0.5030683875083923,
-0.33624526858329773,
-0.38096144795417786,
-0.6657404899597168,
0.07576072216033936,
-0.6278768181800842,
0.5960246920585632,
0.15605883300304413,
0.22458848357200623,
0.2045634388923645,
-0.08493352681398392,
0.20208871364593506,
-1.1031211614608765,
-0.8116593360900879,
-0.37957563996315,
0.5740277767181396,
0.23434822261333466,
0.1448851376771927,
0.4602998197078705,
0.1853356957435608,
0.31278273463249207,
-0.22420521080493927,
-0.3905405104160309,
-0.3903544247150421,
-0.006849620956927538,
-0.25674933195114136,
-0.6283155679702759,
-0.2678206264972687,
-0.20791037380695343,
0.8381844162940979,
1.0630053281784058,
-0.30692699551582336,
0.22919844090938568,
0.06917332112789154,
0.7292380332946777,
-0.5258451104164124,
0.3652004897594452,
-0.5291080474853516,
0.20874060690402985,
-0.3140299916267395,
0.011334477923810482,
-0.5278570652008057,
0.18110695481300354,
-0.1102372407913208,
-0.3714827001094818,
0.25409799814224243,
-0.1720183938741684,
0.9398871064186096,
0.16423913836479187,
-0.38234367966651917,
0.0898127630352974,
-0.7224236130714417,
0.50617915391922,
-0.4707096219062805,
0.794986367225647,
0.4715043604373932,
0.5330567359924316,
0.10360080748796463,
-0.7726989984512329,
-0.5196234583854675,
-0.13632504642009735,
-0.19497895240783691,
0.19884651899337769,
-0.16145455837249756,
-0.02918877825140953,
0.48664116859436035,
0.20094624161720276,
-0.38263991475105286,
0.31277647614479065,
-0.32948389649391174,
-0.22630296647548676,
0.557217538356781,
-0.2486208975315094,
0.18824325501918793,
-0.2026449292898178,
-0.27566972374916077,
-0.3702951967716217,
-0.5694843530654907,
0.23748600482940674,
0.3990243673324585,
0.3807542324066162,
-0.20404520630836487,
0.3344477415084839,
-0.25686880946159363,
0.774108350276947,
-0.3467845618724823,
0.10800586640834808,
0.29146870970726013,
-0.1992303878068924,
-0.28730276226997375,
0.33419638872146606,
0.5446187853813171,
-0.022787678986787796,
0.5604003667831421,
0.00651106983423233,
-0.4518018364906311,
-0.04232555255293846,
-0.016550827771425247,
-0.5591460466384888,
-0.45976316928863525,
-0.16163702309131622,
-0.3209027945995331,
0.1649366021156311,
-0.06538740545511246,
-0.3826899826526642,
-0.10413163900375366,
-0.2213677614927292,
0.0735914409160614,
-0.3492802381515503,
-0.3789888322353363,
0.24399329721927643,
-0.2965461313724518,
0.259969025850296,
0.42137792706489563,
-0.978137195110321,
0.48026466369628906,
0.3843311369419098,
0.448133647441864,
0.24041196703910828,
-0.24579046666622162,
-0.5519716143608093,
-0.07443135231733322,
-0.1771763563156128,
0.7001201510429382,
-0.5327455997467041,
-0.37001684308052063,
-0.08612821251153946,
0.24265018105506897,
-0.39636412262916565,
-0.5039049983024597,
0.22028382122516632,
-0.3940567970275879,
0.0031532575376331806,
-0.33972078561782837,
-0.5423687100410461,
-0.18552309274673462,
-0.09992743283510208,
-0.7900955080986023,
0.9538785219192505,
0.341118723154068,
-0.5914028882980347,
0.3280646800994873,
-0.33209657669067383,
-0.2857767641544342,
-0.119764544069767,
-0.47131818532943726,
-0.12933240830898285,
0.26026979088783264,
0.3029344081878662,
0.3244723081588745,
-0.18789321184158325,
-0.060561370104551315,
-0.12673208117485046,
-0.20505228638648987,
0.20151658356189728,
-0.13342168927192688,
0.8761094212532043,
0.04896628484129906,
-0.405560702085495,
-0.5029476881027222,
-0.897810697555542,
-0.2282881885766983,
0.43597280979156494,
-0.36180776357650757,
-0.19712133705615997,
-0.24194984138011932,
0.20735470950603485,
0.16218014061450958,
-0.06651660799980164,
-0.7809064984321594,
-0.06612881273031235,
-0.45751112699508667,
0.4661399722099304,
0.6995360255241394,
0.16796208918094635,
0.3744250237941742,
0.19630928337574005,
0.4844617247581482,
-0.19301150739192963,
-0.1661558896303177,
-0.12778310477733612,
-0.18318012356758118,
-0.8676782250404358,
0.2252446711063385,
0.6885663866996765,
0.46388518810272217,
-0.2794354259967804,
0.12618359923362732,
-0.018474366515874863,
-0.2192690223455429,
-0.10208664834499359,
0.28033164143562317,
0.4958627223968506,
0.453776091337204,
0.38371512293815613,
-0.4522659480571747,
-0.2756747901439667,
-1.0044926404953003,
-0.4531100392341614,
-0.08364181220531464,
0.3464880883693695,
0.33513298630714417,
0.428344190120697,
0.07231683284044266,
0.48466184735298157,
-0.2622913420200348,
-0.1640542894601822,
-0.5303455591201782,
0.09622903168201447,
0.2228424996137619,
0.46522942185401917,
0.947196364402771,
-0.7044124007225037,
-0.41284507513046265,
-0.013303403742611408,
-0.5407147407531738,
-0.25145870447158813,
0.21332161128520966,
-0.07049018889665604,
-0.014843294396996498,
1.1796488761901855,
-0.4917384386062622,
0.15323346853256226,
0.5540255904197693,
-0.1100509837269783,
0.29820919036865234,
0.20250211656093597,
-0.32859712839126587,
-0.7069517970085144,
-0.012159543111920357,
-0.16136376559734344,
-0.45596039295196533,
-0.43598616123199463,
-0.18747060000896454,
-0.049278631806373596,
-0.2075878381729126,
-0.5145552158355713,
0.7623448371887207,
-0.609628438949585,
-0.29826995730400085,
-0.005643636453896761,
0.3719351887702942,
0.02077331580221653,
0.637759804725647,
0.22452737390995026,
0.5614985227584839,
0.5037761926651001,
-0.31194305419921875,
0.07989448308944702,
-0.004275328945368528,
-0.3486219644546509,
0.4116875231266022,
-0.4814935624599457,
0.40790480375289917,
-0.13031187653541565,
0.09961061924695969,
-0.7675918340682983,
-0.3670574724674225,
-0.08228962868452072,
-0.36239591240882874,
0.41224363446235657,
-0.33436232805252075,
-0.7286825776100159,
-0.1197928786277771,
0.4257432520389557,
0.46243226528167725,
0.6186085939407349,
-0.46082261204719543,
0.5070656538009644,
0.4470311105251312,
-0.20156867802143097,
-0.45751091837882996,
-0.7418212890625,
-0.3716411292552948,
0.06275595724582672,
-0.12569831311702728,
-0.021545182913541794,
0.5459873676300049,
-0.31630125641822815,
0.040951017290353775,
-0.5300959944725037,
0.015169969759881496,
0.23487427830696106,
0.19453319907188416,
-0.41482818126678467,
-0.4526795744895935,
0.447245717048645,
-0.13770394027233124,
-0.06456925719976425,
0.2476547807455063,
-0.39220547676086426,
0.711685836315155,
-0.1901712268590927,
-0.3394361436367035,
-0.3048173487186432,
0.11453884094953537,
-0.071101114153862,
-0.3099784851074219,
0.6397266983985901,
0.6645554304122925,
-0.3413558304309845,
-0.7356077432632446,
-0.348940372467041,
-0.3208893835544586,
-0.4366093575954437,
0.3690272271633148,
-0.39034315943717957,
-0.9053937792778015,
0.5030837655067444,
-0.43606656789779663,
-0.43020737171173096,
0.7197238206863403,
0.11068741232156754,
-0.4198744297027588,
0.7258630394935608,
0.8575905561447144,
0.12933042645454407,
0.7168572545051575,
-0.5778632760047913,
-0.11678211390972137,
-0.45876872539520264,
-0.14616157114505768,
-0.7275369763374329,
-0.22447344660758972,
-0.2581103444099426,
-0.06808678805828094,
0.17977073788642883,
0.6579461693763733,
-0.21462476253509521,
0.35157662630081177,
-0.09764610230922699,
0.5978766679763794,
0.5055489540100098,
0.09029938280582428,
0.013311125338077545,
0.09127847850322723,
-0.37086912989616394,
0.20874089002609253,
-0.7064241766929626,
-0.279442697763443,
0.7878769040107727,
0.20261250436306,
0.521789014339447,
0.017715580761432648,
0.840842068195343,
0.22916638851165771,
-0.16146941483020782,
-0.3422784209251404,
0.4983212351799011,
-0.1637362539768219,
-0.4868242144584656,
-0.17286354303359985,
-0.40733376145362854,
-0.7754287719726562,
0.05177008733153343,
-0.09246088564395905,
-1.0064325332641602,
0.5455459952354431,
0.3877107501029968,
-0.30603694915771484,
0.13714081048965454,
-0.8588771224021912,
1.1478370428085327,
-0.3426077961921692,
-0.00339281908236444,
-0.18337060511112213,
-0.7163503170013428,
-0.09942806512117386,
-0.22923347353935242,
0.2753860354423523,
-0.18516409397125244,
0.22404566407203674,
1.0069490671157837,
-0.34977394342422485,
0.9483926892280579,
-0.4185534417629242,
-0.020930970087647438,
0.1830255538225174,
0.1320740431547165,
0.36670175194740295,
0.04073915630578995,
-0.030701560899615288,
0.26252785325050354,
-0.01236028503626585,
-0.5443841814994812,
-0.5758084058761597,
0.36061951518058777,
-0.8022997379302979,
-0.4307992160320282,
-0.35044801235198975,
-0.06141791492700577,
-0.4176681339740753,
0.34611502289772034,
0.33509737253189087,
0.7392970323562622,
-0.31329184770584106,
0.2020745426416397,
0.28468406200408936,
-0.15837439894676208,
0.5329110622406006,
0.44762858748435974,
-0.3138856589794159,
0.007663029246032238,
0.5464858412742615,
0.0971502810716629,
0.439432829618454,
0.743898332118988,
-0.02817191183567047,
-0.07518567144870758,
-0.49304723739624023,
-0.3626067638397217,
0.37093353271484375,
-1.225253701210022,
0.10867570340633392,
-0.678345263004303,
-0.5792914032936096,
-0.10223961621522903,
-0.003554188646376133,
-0.4677148759365082,
-0.9942247271537781,
-0.03674907609820366,
-0.4106581509113312,
0.29853060841560364,
0.8880318403244019,
-0.13374146819114685,
0.6766662001609802,
-0.7835453152656555,
0.023266803473234177,
0.17125718295574188,
-0.05777455493807793,
-0.24646097421646118,
-0.2877175807952881,
-0.5887945890426636,
-0.060528382658958435,
0.17042820155620575,
-0.8791880011558533,
0.2209954708814621,
0.516269326210022,
0.6973196864128113,
0.06505145877599716,
-0.18552947044372559,
0.0720607191324234,
-0.40623873472213745,
0.7347213625907898,
0.03827393800020218,
-1.0167380571365356,
0.5993726849555969,
-0.21721413731575012,
0.4218941628932953,
0.607061505317688,
0.35866108536720276,
-0.19378411769866943,
-0.3819299638271332,
-0.7918930053710938,
-0.601589024066925,
0.8217095732688904,
-0.03640688955783844,
0.12902382016181946,
0.028902992606163025,
0.33747807145118713,
0.06267895549535751,
0.40863752365112305,
-0.7052807807922363,
-0.07821208983659744,
-0.20578661561012268,
0.09099185466766357,
-0.5582113265991211,
-0.19937697052955627,
-0.2418741136789322,
-0.3839825689792633,
0.22409085929393768,
0.03917602077126503,
0.2952765226364136,
0.20907902717590332,
-0.5556511878967285,
0.029554732143878937,
0.33970585465431213,
0.2855955958366394,
0.7390041947364807,
-0.2841870188713074,
0.49307283759117126,
0.07654911279678345,
-0.44660642743110657,
0.019149228930473328,
0.2382933348417282,
0.14909227192401886,
0.15627671778202057,
0.8447776436805725,
0.9040815234184265,
0.13786369562149048,
-0.6044948697090149,
0.5529682636260986,
0.12817998230457306,
-0.27746737003326416,
-0.3898504972457886,
0.23212195932865143,
0.14110982418060303,
0.23226681351661682,
-0.015216168947517872,
0.17699167132377625,
0.04988788068294525,
-0.6683391332626343,
0.2615237236022949,
0.06091765686869621,
-0.4109964966773987,
-0.512248158454895,
0.5759326219558716,
0.10844194889068604,
-0.13730491697788239,
0.6375930905342102,
-0.0038478749338537455,
-0.722222626209259,
0.6028664708137512,
0.3363575339317322,
0.7707361578941345,
-0.3972550928592682,
0.10304655134677887,
0.34910300374031067,
0.3721811771392822,
0.24617666006088257,
0.4323474168777466,
-0.464990496635437,
-0.867222785949707,
-0.3380853533744812,
-0.981628954410553,
-0.22393938899040222,
-0.06838172674179077,
-0.7987416386604309,
-0.016782186925411224,
-0.6682108640670776,
-0.33918026089668274,
0.37689828872680664,
-0.429580956697464,
-0.9750756025314331,
0.2722761034965515,
0.18631437420845032,
1.0212730169296265,
-0.9349822998046875,
0.9738004803657532,
0.4458446204662323,
-0.4616919457912445,
-1.0902053117752075,
-0.08904071897268295,
-0.056039705872535706,
-0.9901330471038818,
1.2704733610153198,
0.150013267993927,
-0.3014805018901825,
0.19568946957588196,
-0.4747614860534668,
-0.6840605139732361,
0.5334991812705994,
0.6964637041091919,
-0.9446898698806763,
0.019985655322670937,
0.18315918743610382,
0.6667410731315613,
-0.30626434087753296,
0.06376440078020096,
0.6758657097816467,
0.34457629919052124,
-0.3867394030094147,
-1.2004584074020386,
-0.17282693088054657,
-0.5508443117141724,
-0.21129460632801056,
0.19032810628414154,
-0.5360376238822937,
1.1871932744979858,
0.02188125066459179,
-0.4076601564884186,
-0.42879074811935425,
0.1069735735654831,
-0.5407495498657227,
-0.1133132055401802,
0.5905897617340088,
0.653800904750824,
0.5787966251373291,
-0.34354066848754883,
1.3753231763839722,
-0.41354241967201233,
0.15686887502670288,
1.2173458337783813,
-0.29593217372894287,
1.0951133966445923,
0.2555490732192993,
-0.09830101579427719,
0.8113468885421753,
0.7596678733825684,
0.20718854665756226,
0.5951176285743713,
0.14589031040668488,
-0.04195627570152283,
-0.5386356115341187,
-0.21289893984794617,
-0.5498693585395813,
0.6544436812400818,
0.4829503893852234,
-0.6056111454963684,
-0.27233898639678955,
0.14212104678153992,
-0.040900278836488724,
0.1065535917878151,
-0.19027775526046753,
1.0050333738327026,
0.6159273982048035,
-0.29516124725341797,
0.9396309852600098,
-0.11926471441984177,
-0.31777384877204895,
-0.537928581237793,
-0.1533966213464737,
-0.08774152398109436,
0.3861329257488251,
-0.07363855093717575,
-0.4973524212837219,
0.06904266029596329,
-0.41568973660469055,
0.08801057934761047,
-0.34125229716300964,
0.600180447101593,
-0.33046555519104004,
-0.33206379413604736,
0.749869704246521,
0.8352014422416687,
0.13538333773612976,
-0.07510437071323395,
-0.712834358215332,
0.1128605380654335,
-0.3324756920337677,
-0.21863341331481934,
0.13013114035129547,
0.45352989435195923,
0.07697320729494095,
0.14610826969146729,
0.46896931529045105,
0.35578054189682007,
0.20497539639472961,
0.6302319765090942,
0.9449158310890198,
-0.7620301842689514,
-0.6375232934951782,
-0.6966033577919006,
0.13681674003601074,
-0.19626443088054657,
-0.10068298876285553,
0.8988621830940247,
0.46754470467567444,
1.2898030281066895,
0.00735825439915061,
0.7676656246185303,
0.3013979494571686,
0.5058717727661133,
-1.0127891302108765,
0.39214226603507996,
-0.6920550465583801,
0.16246862709522247,
-0.10404788702726364,
-1.2958433628082275,
-0.06481484323740005,
0.616093635559082,
-0.4568794369697571,
0.18281403183937073,
0.9891826510429382,
0.5266823768615723,
-0.3516799211502075,
0.17466087639331818,
0.11128327995538712,
0.3545692563056946,
-0.100921131670475,
0.4811742305755615,
0.926342785358429,
-0.027138331905007362,
0.14977248013019562,
-0.3642478287220001,
-0.03253195434808731,
-0.15789738297462463,
-0.5471009612083435,
-1.0196561813354492,
-0.554016649723053,
0.04174298793077469,
-0.34052979946136475,
0.46068304777145386,
0.7786299586296082,
0.7147361040115356,
-0.8963449597358704,
-0.4837716519832611,
-0.2892248332500458,
-0.2164033204317093,
-0.21268442273139954,
-0.13470439612865448,
0.5060461163520813,
-0.2098713517189026,
-0.41655924916267395,
0.6223265528678894,
0.3747510015964508,
0.18973718583583832,
-0.05298054590821266,
-0.0071023995988070965,
-0.18629765510559082,
-0.021297115832567215,
0.2443305253982544,
0.47348374128341675,
-0.4939080476760864,
-0.24310332536697388,
-0.01399057824164629,
-0.07988584041595459,
0.10636129230260849,
0.8574925661087036,
-0.5359730124473572,
0.5603771209716797,
0.36618924140930176,
0.4866703748703003,
0.9310191869735718,
-0.09757659584283829,
0.7286039590835571,
-1.0401828289031982,
0.6877421140670776,
0.19708682596683502,
0.686871349811554,
0.46397292613983154,
-0.12134681642055511,
0.5397298336029053,
0.42817145586013794,
-0.22067537903785706,
-0.8409206867218018,
0.3346669375896454,
-0.8392362594604492,
-0.25481101870536804,
1.067602515220642,
-0.13171960413455963,
-0.5198916792869568,
-0.03048156015574932,
0.03671320900321007,
0.08076760917901993,
-0.28387966752052307,
0.006870822515338659,
0.6352261304855347,
-0.15869435667991638,
-0.4777047038078308,
-0.7426743507385254,
0.8681588768959045,
0.4182337820529938,
-0.4833999276161194,
-0.07924745231866837,
0.2087462991476059,
0.18394726514816284,
0.32946011424064636,
0.9803587794303894,
0.07660892605781555,
0.34131360054016113,
0.43513691425323486,
-0.06292807310819626,
0.07845019549131393,
-0.53334641456604,
-0.25409695506095886,
0.10435361415147781,
0.27657344937324524,
0.152193084359169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04795v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04795v1
|
Large Language Models in Fire Engineering: An Examination of Technical Questions Against Domain Knowledge
| 2024-03-04T16:18:36 | 2024-03-04T16:18:36 |
Haley Hostetter, M. Z. Naser, Xinyan Huang, John Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This communication presents preliminary findings from comparing two recent
chatbots, OpenAI's ChatGPT and Google's Bard, in the context of fire
engineering by evaluating their responses in handling fire safety related
queries. A diverse range of fire engineering questions and scenarios were
created and examined, including structural fire design, fire prevention
strategies, evacuation, building code compliance, and fire suppression systems
(some of which resemble those commonly present in the Fire Protection exam
(FPE)). The results reveal some key differences in the performance of the
chatbots, with ChatGPT demonstrating a relatively superior performance. Then,
this communication highlights the potential for chatbot technology to
revolutionize fire engineering practices by providing instant access to
critical information while outlining areas for further improvement and
research. Evidently, and when it matures, this technology will likely be
elemental to our engineers' practice and education.
|
[
-0.2119414359331131,
-1.1334056854248047,
0.1702527403831482,
0.3079012632369995,
0.36594146490097046,
0.12822037935256958,
-0.11147423088550568,
-0.5461499691009521,
-0.11777931451797485,
0.46943750977516174,
-0.25610214471817017,
0.03383005037903786,
-0.2349994033575058,
-0.3165377974510193,
-0.7108168601989746,
0.7947583794593811,
-0.1401553750038147,
-0.2959562838077545,
0.14334876835346222,
0.5378559231758118,
-0.42600059509277344,
-0.42292672395706177,
-0.8491787314414978,
-0.21013708412647247,
0.588886022567749,
0.11914525926113129,
0.8403167128562927,
-0.4944019317626953,
0.7718992233276367,
0.29144367575645447,
-0.26535865664482117,
-0.5608580112457275,
-0.5207861661911011,
-0.07017693668603897,
-0.06790990382432938,
-0.3116295635700226,
-0.2648916244506836,
0.004536466673016548,
0.3240675926208496,
0.46773791313171387,
0.10006692260503769,
-0.05495880916714668,
0.23400455713272095,
0.8142279386520386,
-0.5185630321502686,
0.3502669632434845,
-0.6636773347854614,
0.05942180007696152,
0.23066049814224243,
-0.49750614166259766,
-0.6006995439529419,
-0.5767597556114197,
0.3246036469936371,
-0.350713849067688,
0.08056995272636414,
0.26359808444976807,
0.9354342222213745,
0.12581774592399597,
-0.6159330606460571,
-0.48363369703292847,
-1.117710828781128,
0.3410666286945343,
-0.5253177285194397,
0.4432605803012848,
0.26105672121047974,
0.628838300704956,
-0.4968768060207367,
-0.6880769729614258,
-0.5576646327972412,
-0.5686533451080322,
0.01589590683579445,
0.20451538264751434,
-0.037306517362594604,
0.34536075592041016,
0.25148576498031616,
0.524128794670105,
-1.0251669883728027,
0.08363422006368637,
-0.7203863263130188,
-0.3711264431476593,
0.9577205181121826,
-0.1817181259393692,
0.42182767391204834,
-0.0898125022649765,
-0.17948751151561737,
-0.3583652973175049,
-0.8489187955856323,
-0.0006323739071376622,
0.6370768547058105,
0.06752359867095947,
0.030630294233560562,
0.42962029576301575,
-0.21343371272087097,
0.4837857484817505,
-0.452655166387558,
0.01010358426719904,
0.195688396692276,
-0.09863236546516418,
-0.5024210214614868,
-0.06391540169715881,
0.8326495885848999,
0.27690932154655457,
0.5083320736885071,
-0.11696415394544601,
0.008126538246870041,
-0.05836198851466179,
0.37404346466064453,
-0.8691858649253845,
-0.42236122488975525,
0.4956721067428589,
-0.49472808837890625,
-0.5382301211357117,
-0.03608448803424835,
-0.8175345063209534,
-0.5526862144470215,
-0.10144693404436111,
0.5894263982772827,
0.010954280383884907,
-0.7325030565261841,
0.38338783383369446,
-0.2801571190357208,
0.18239125609397888,
0.3725036084651947,
-0.8205782175064087,
-0.17995236814022064,
0.8095241189002991,
0.5930545926094055,
0.4482814371585846,
0.05613046512007713,
-0.03704188019037247,
-0.3124046325683594,
-0.2828579545021057,
0.5876392722129822,
-0.7223920226097107,
-0.8748255372047424,
0.09388034045696259,
-0.04479349032044411,
-0.20459258556365967,
-0.33101123571395874,
0.5319808125495911,
-0.7173514366149902,
0.43305474519729614,
0.18177425861358643,
-0.47120630741119385,
-0.37737321853637695,
0.15571655333042145,
-0.49543288350105286,
0.9790932536125183,
0.06922298669815063,
-0.6055632829666138,
0.13098248839378357,
-1.0329502820968628,
-0.188569575548172,
0.01239797379821539,
-0.1847062110900879,
-0.08539559692144394,
0.017111439257860184,
-0.20703445374965668,
0.539308488368988,
-0.46230053901672363,
0.151763454079628,
-0.2272018939256668,
0.011726072058081627,
0.21469247341156006,
-0.498290091753006,
0.7676129341125488,
0.45414042472839355,
-0.17798461019992828,
0.20083574950695038,
-0.4604569673538208,
0.3050024211406708,
0.04690389707684517,
-0.11733025312423706,
-0.172653928399086,
0.08441583812236786,
0.27722397446632385,
0.38535064458847046,
0.010485191829502583,
-0.8454611301422119,
0.0792156308889389,
-0.4705384075641632,
0.5492578744888306,
0.6142399907112122,
-0.14724726974964142,
0.2188265174627304,
-0.4818650484085083,
0.5676791071891785,
-0.55143803358078,
0.07199525088071823,
-0.3150004744529724,
-0.8682365417480469,
-0.4828898310661316,
0.18407846987247467,
0.2633720636367798,
0.8599873185157776,
-0.6464843153953552,
0.3329612910747528,
-0.08480364829301834,
-0.9171021580696106,
-0.14631465077400208,
-0.16597239673137665,
0.32516053318977356,
0.39109304547309875,
-0.11866740137338638,
-0.14959236979484558,
-0.13457147777080536,
-0.4558986723423004,
-0.165946826338768,
-0.4677879512310028,
-0.23977208137512207,
0.3999173939228058,
0.6708218455314636,
0.08395149558782578,
0.891643762588501,
-0.6741233468055725,
0.033165253698825836,
-0.1925269365310669,
0.12889359891414642,
-0.025708410888910294,
0.563133180141449,
0.9666235446929932,
-1.102444052696228,
-0.8342313766479492,
0.6641046404838562,
-0.8489285707473755,
0.12226125597953796,
-0.15478353202342987,
-0.21128658950328827,
-0.21652063727378845,
0.739008903503418,
-0.47556933760643005,
0.6241893172264099,
0.5879931449890137,
-0.5566514134407043,
0.6438232064247131,
0.11358461529016495,
0.42764100432395935,
-0.9493442177772522,
0.07161817699670792,
-0.06321173906326294,
0.21026036143302917,
-0.8794333338737488,
0.3519379198551178,
0.05048477277159691,
-0.7962610721588135,
-0.5973086357116699,
1.0071802139282227,
-0.17020215094089508,
0.00761847198009491,
-0.3922015130519867,
0.16476190090179443,
-0.18695496022701263,
0.4289107620716095,
-0.0291662085801363,
1.0107837915420532,
0.6082809567451477,
-0.5208132863044739,
0.6390592455863953,
0.2708812952041626,
-0.5698220133781433,
0.25116273760795593,
-1.0218037366867065,
0.22604410350322723,
0.17683187127113342,
0.2779097259044647,
-1.3756892681121826,
-0.6105970740318298,
-0.15913613140583038,
-0.7401560544967651,
0.1796027272939682,
-0.028282614424824715,
-0.7404796481132507,
-0.8980380892753601,
0.01928291656076908,
0.02624768204987049,
0.7104950547218323,
-0.20100082457065582,
0.38784006237983704,
0.2543674111366272,
-0.5459001064300537,
-0.4156872034072876,
-0.4176928400993347,
-0.20587249100208282,
-0.049570322036743164,
-1.273845911026001,
-0.16413772106170654,
-0.11460975557565689,
-0.27593961358070374,
-0.26134732365608215,
-0.2033829241991043,
-0.4560518264770508,
0.40186288952827454,
0.2357361763715744,
0.027856364846229553,
-0.44025909900665283,
0.4801715910434723,
-0.22225207090377808,
0.10072466731071472,
0.2174980491399765,
-0.030434004962444305,
0.6664386987686157,
0.03474297374486923,
-0.4927997887134552,
-0.5728059411048889,
0.3698551058769226,
0.6122662425041199,
-0.08321729302406311,
0.7129729390144348,
0.15537042915821075,
-0.2914847135543823,
0.27041351795196533,
-0.6124798059463501,
-0.276765376329422,
-0.5807455778121948,
0.2604779899120331,
-0.3648790419101715,
-1.2406748533248901,
0.5739175081253052,
-0.25240248441696167,
0.7055429220199585,
0.4533323049545288,
0.4679909348487854,
-0.2954331934452057,
0.6768938899040222,
0.627582311630249,
-0.1703236997127533,
0.705123245716095,
-0.008268200792372227,
0.4765653610229492,
-0.35468652844429016,
-0.031464945524930954,
-0.9805663824081421,
-0.39797621965408325,
-0.3241903781890869,
-0.029511146247386932,
0.3116876184940338,
-0.11148877441883087,
-0.17918185889720917,
0.4656202495098114,
-0.4394572675228119,
0.5795128345489502,
0.1852489560842514,
0.051879867911338806,
0.1219874694943428,
-0.1399257332086563,
0.0871611088514328,
0.2860768437385559,
-0.3774317502975464,
-0.5452280640602112,
1.0476120710372925,
0.4814058542251587,
0.7839480638504028,
0.13695213198661804,
0.27883127331733704,
0.2927456200122833,
0.3337656855583191,
-0.7645010948181152,
0.49789923429489136,
0.34976908564567566,
-1.2368361949920654,
-0.725797176361084,
-0.5536043047904968,
-1.1573017835617065,
0.4674936532974243,
0.06681451946496964,
-0.7087700366973877,
-0.08431541174650192,
0.1446758359670639,
-0.23294904828071594,
0.4626329243183136,
-1.1077685356140137,
1.0602178573608398,
-0.2700131833553314,
0.15075740218162537,
-0.5522556304931641,
-0.4994167685508728,
0.5033693909645081,
-0.3217686414718628,
0.209024578332901,
-0.10192737728357315,
0.4201337993144989,
0.5467785000801086,
-0.3951009511947632,
0.6447152495384216,
-0.08799321949481964,
-0.5947428345680237,
0.7273344397544861,
0.08456522971391678,
0.46248045563697815,
-0.30575716495513916,
-0.44920822978019714,
-0.28146520256996155,
0.10918544232845306,
-0.5784623622894287,
-0.688834011554718,
0.5328670144081116,
-0.5999655723571777,
-0.48145124316215515,
-0.13081778585910797,
-0.30496782064437866,
-0.301667183637619,
0.060099899768829346,
0.12525929510593414,
0.5200666785240173,
-0.5928493142127991,
0.44935694336891174,
0.6403695344924927,
-0.6630145907402039,
0.5172120928764343,
0.32422101497650146,
-0.42939335107803345,
0.10276883095502853,
0.8338326811790466,
-0.11756875365972519,
0.595215380191803,
0.634463906288147,
0.27454543113708496,
0.08226115256547928,
-0.14687897264957428,
-0.17630544304847717,
0.055595673620700836,
-0.5139698386192322,
0.04829223453998566,
-0.5505418181419373,
-0.6359549164772034,
-0.4477837085723877,
-0.35624074935913086,
-0.15168866515159607,
-0.5072407126426697,
0.23627306520938873,
-0.1302168071269989,
0.4677363634109497,
0.8570917248725891,
0.4485841691493988,
0.721443235874176,
-1.0519565343856812,
0.020515477284789085,
0.4852614402770996,
0.06073770299553871,
0.07234188169240952,
-0.31102919578552246,
0.09728704392910004,
-0.03536424785852432,
-0.7270534634590149,
-0.5885777473449707,
0.01250146608799696,
0.06542227417230606,
0.37455129623413086,
0.4418518841266632,
0.1716543436050415,
-0.0009652042645029724,
-0.5107780694961548,
0.9900250434875488,
0.32805135846138,
-0.5956723093986511,
0.6750650405883789,
-0.718586802482605,
0.05527849122881889,
0.15100468695163727,
0.62042236328125,
-0.6225199103355408,
-0.3428807556629181,
-0.6505076885223389,
-0.3706163763999939,
0.46999332308769226,
0.6148232221603394,
0.5370440483093262,
0.24626410007476807,
-0.08368035405874252,
-0.006694129668176174,
0.22195230424404144,
-0.4613412916660309,
0.017195185646414757,
0.10983482748270035,
0.15168523788452148,
0.17304742336273193,
-0.24297378957271576,
-0.0675768330693245,
-0.009812910109758377,
0.501882791519165,
0.025625154376029968,
0.7167540788650513,
-0.17326712608337402,
0.04091687127947807,
0.21315371990203857,
0.6313702464103699,
0.9619362950325012,
0.4831894040107727,
-0.10912643373012543,
-0.5370256304740906,
-0.04426489770412445,
-0.75913006067276,
0.11117778718471527,
-0.16284260153770447,
0.18060040473937988,
-0.07148884981870651,
0.2818760573863983,
0.6017020344734192,
0.10932794213294983,
-0.5958355069160461,
0.445063054561615,
0.14311037957668304,
-0.5433597564697266,
-0.15357853472232819,
0.32213637232780457,
0.03927277773618698,
0.2445848137140274,
0.3193986415863037,
0.1270681917667389,
0.1237504780292511,
-0.8938167095184326,
0.08667749911546707,
0.3584829866886139,
-0.1513770967721939,
-0.4087701141834259,
0.7279609441757202,
0.9925495982170105,
-0.3887036144733429,
0.32797160744667053,
0.13020610809326172,
-0.5522805452346802,
0.8508204221725464,
0.1430172473192215,
1.0921409130096436,
-0.31086790561676025,
0.2119119018316269,
0.27462342381477356,
0.4670718014240265,
-0.027260439470410347,
0.6389952898025513,
-0.022157197818160057,
-0.5343108773231506,
-0.47023725509643555,
-0.28313499689102173,
-0.7241132855415344,
0.0765133649110794,
-0.1873026192188263,
0.16864249110221863,
-0.6141691207885742,
-0.0330810546875,
0.013701856136322021,
-0.12310062348842621,
-0.549229621887207,
0.3855689764022827,
-0.10487823188304901,
1.1905187368392944,
-0.6923805475234985,
0.6636180877685547,
0.5710151195526123,
-0.37093526124954224,
-0.7005983591079712,
0.2516755759716034,
0.08547089993953705,
-0.528375506401062,
0.7803821563720703,
0.11222342401742935,
0.10541404038667679,
-0.16793648898601532,
-0.5501881837844849,
-0.7746124863624573,
0.7257605195045471,
0.09992935508489609,
-0.5986810922622681,
-0.36712220311164856,
0.08060895651578903,
0.6516672372817993,
0.20272475481033325,
0.648451030254364,
0.14786864817142487,
0.39838942885398865,
0.13563820719718933,
-1.7113069295883179,
-0.3483971655368805,
-0.3756021559238434,
-0.2721191644668579,
0.48601460456848145,
-0.9140928387641907,
0.44988009333610535,
0.18951399624347687,
-0.16387638449668884,
0.33875271677970886,
0.7200285196304321,
-0.3581492006778717,
0.4641440510749817,
0.30995988845825195,
0.14369133114814758,
0.7707949876785278,
-0.3069442808628082,
1.1003658771514893,
-0.3324371576309204,
0.36462610960006714,
0.9429638981819153,
-0.3519361913204193,
0.9496124982833862,
-0.02017856203019619,
-0.41139182448387146,
0.2837502658367157,
0.5865194797515869,
0.46265044808387756,
0.2248447984457016,
0.25452443957328796,
-0.3337281048297882,
-0.10757569968700409,
0.19885782897472382,
-0.8382741212844849,
0.42464151978492737,
0.48607319593429565,
-0.23368503153324127,
-0.2065875232219696,
0.33830615878105164,
-0.16804608702659607,
-0.12578724324703217,
-0.14540086686611176,
0.5856814384460449,
0.10626566410064697,
-0.36697331070899963,
0.35691091418266296,
-0.20421059429645538,
0.44048669934272766,
-0.5650576949119568,
0.3191995918750763,
-0.044207848608493805,
0.3205619752407074,
-0.24132633209228516,
-1.1170421838760376,
0.5317165851593018,
0.07026858627796173,
0.20964372158050537,
-0.46112915873527527,
0.5864803194999695,
0.11752533912658691,
-0.33203959465026855,
0.028165303170681,
0.19247879087924957,
0.5057120323181152,
-0.32073110342025757,
-0.6307671666145325,
-0.11587239801883698,
0.02328353188931942,
-0.2715687155723572,
0.2665484845638275,
0.5369459390640259,
-0.031116366386413574,
0.8998379707336426,
0.558137059211731,
-0.2564607262611389,
0.2912808060646057,
-0.08010173588991165,
0.8490192890167236,
-0.6293933391571045,
-0.4430554211139679,
-0.283499151468277,
0.48464080691337585,
-0.19533272087574005,
-0.6090642213821411,
0.6608250737190247,
0.41465726494789124,
0.7760255932807922,
-0.2780289649963379,
0.9899106025695801,
-0.30427226424217224,
0.7639869451522827,
-0.5894740223884583,
0.7898314595222473,
-0.5538152456283569,
-0.04109952226281166,
-0.6533477306365967,
-1.068856954574585,
-0.23075848817825317,
0.5549795031547546,
-0.42569705843925476,
0.05744057148694992,
0.7727809548377991,
0.8196543455123901,
-0.05567077174782753,
0.5226143002510071,
0.6222487688064575,
-0.016335880383849144,
0.6748499274253845,
0.5389525890350342,
0.9507198929786682,
-0.6638537049293518,
0.7230658531188965,
0.12491804361343384,
-0.16321371495723724,
-0.3363354802131653,
-0.5287055969238281,
-1.2536098957061768,
-0.5306157469749451,
-0.40259623527526855,
-0.2383420318365097,
-0.23257292807102203,
0.8533427715301514,
0.524756669998169,
-0.9490320086479187,
-0.21238479018211365,
0.09631455689668655,
0.1051621213555336,
0.09545021504163742,
-0.288582444190979,
0.08461061120033264,
-0.24219875037670135,
-0.6095147132873535,
0.4776199758052826,
0.13443554937839508,
0.1106356605887413,
-0.37393924593925476,
0.13406871259212494,
0.08323971927165985,
0.25834718346595764,
0.8427833318710327,
0.552939772605896,
-0.6131914258003235,
-0.5224958658218384,
0.05181945115327835,
-0.23419713973999023,
-0.09985020756721497,
0.8592263460159302,
-0.345335453748703,
0.340259850025177,
1.1988083124160767,
0.9664794206619263,
0.08449019491672516,
-0.3291027843952179,
0.6984390616416931,
-0.5165958404541016,
0.4030699133872986,
0.08111816644668579,
0.22485284507274628,
0.0408078171312809,
-0.571171760559082,
0.920617938041687,
-0.01775316894054413,
-1.0612525939941406,
-0.7451172471046448,
0.3289436101913452,
-0.7206608057022095,
-0.17975524067878723,
1.2407639026641846,
-0.10513908416032791,
0.2875593900680542,
-0.18696586787700653,
-0.7001920938491821,
-0.3215342164039612,
-0.3477790653705597,
0.6943248510360718,
1.080609917640686,
0.13845956325531006,
-0.09392160177230835,
-1.1263842582702637,
0.37476441264152527,
0.423255056142807,
-1.0229767560958862,
-0.005338609684258699,
0.33781859278678894,
0.1054539680480957,
0.46689948439598083,
0.4552927613258362,
0.018099026754498482,
0.421010822057724,
0.10409761220216751,
-0.005338412709534168,
0.5317895412445068,
-0.4111451208591461,
0.05355200171470642,
0.26707229018211365,
-0.05593114718794823,
-0.16149389743804932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02371v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02371v2
|
NeuroVoz: a Castillian Spanish corpus of parkinsonian speech
| 2024-03-04T16:17:39 | 2024-03-06T11:08:02 |
Janaína Mendes-Laureano, Jorge A. Gómez-García, Alejandro Guerrero-López, Elisa Luque-Buzo, Julián D. Arias-Londoño, Francisco J. Grandas-Pérez, Juan I. Godino-Llorente
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
The advancement of Parkinson's Disease (PD) diagnosis through speech analysis
is hindered by a notable lack of publicly available, diverse language datasets,
limiting the reproducibility and further exploration of existing research.
In response to this gap, we introduce a comprehensive corpus from 108 native
Castilian Spanish speakers, comprising 55 healthy controls and 53 individuals
diagnosed with PD, all of whom were under pharmacological treatment and
recorded in their medication-optimized state. This unique dataset features a
wide array of speech tasks, including sustained phonation of the five Spanish
vowels, diadochokinetic tests, 16 listen-and-repeat utterances, and free
monologues. The dataset emphasizes accuracy and reliability through specialist
manual transcriptions of the listen-and-repeat tasks and utilizes Whisper for
automated monologue transcriptions, making it the most complete public corpus
of Parkinsonian speech, and the first in Castillian Spanish.
NeuroVoz is composed by 2,903 audio recordings averaging $26.88 \pm 3.35$
recordings per participant, offering a substantial resource for the scientific
exploration of PD's impact on speech. This dataset has already underpinned
several studies, achieving a benchmark accuracy of 89% in PD speech pattern
identification, indicating marked speech alterations attributable to PD.
Despite these advances, the broader challenge of conducting a
language-agnostic, cross-corpora analysis of Parkinsonian speech patterns
remains an open area for future research. This contribution not only fills a
critical void in PD speech analysis resources but also sets a new standard for
the global research community in leveraging speech as a diagnostic tool for
neurodegenerative diseases.
|
[
-0.34385499358177185,
-0.46633380651474,
-0.008316641673445702,
0.6260122060775757,
-0.07247889786958694,
0.014868202619254589,
-0.2929205894470215,
-0.16552263498306274,
0.8507547378540039,
0.7004468441009521,
-0.620081901550293,
-0.7174189686775208,
-0.5894705653190613,
0.14907827973365784,
-0.6387011408805847,
0.8305448889732361,
0.4034777879714966,
0.4724680185317993,
0.1510661244392395,
-0.030127188190817833,
0.17827945947647095,
-0.34888994693756104,
-0.6552667021751404,
-0.38751742243766785,
0.947637140750885,
0.26023098826408386,
0.7895813584327698,
0.3593156337738037,
-0.04085922613739967,
0.15387015044689178,
-0.3573484718799591,
-0.10681261867284775,
-0.14154097437858582,
0.21436627209186554,
-0.11576006561517715,
-0.15248242020606995,
-0.7199854254722595,
-0.2415299415588379,
0.6517049670219421,
1.1328799724578857,
-0.4764268398284912,
-0.12727858126163483,
0.18492376804351807,
0.521275520324707,
-0.32973164319992065,
-0.05726485699415207,
-0.050716642290353775,
0.4305059313774109,
-0.5885753631591797,
-0.0254806075245142,
-0.2851925194263458,
-0.5972999334335327,
0.3182038366794586,
-0.3909764587879181,
0.47028857469558716,
-0.4462977647781372,
0.3026898205280304,
0.2554265260696411,
-0.15497073531150818,
-0.11296844482421875,
-0.38815295696258545,
0.20526021718978882,
-0.7171249985694885,
0.03255174309015274,
0.4658941626548767,
0.3841455280780792,
-0.723933219909668,
-0.7283958196640015,
-0.5988161563873291,
-0.27902573347091675,
0.6079742908477783,
0.02591564506292343,
-0.43991348147392273,
0.24908588826656342,
0.08231426030397415,
0.39109542965888977,
-0.9377573132514954,
0.3681339621543884,
-0.5309619903564453,
-0.546360433101654,
0.27000993490219116,
0.15535399317741394,
0.5659568905830383,
-0.2703129053115845,
0.19664834439754486,
-0.07199951261281967,
-0.8456220626831055,
-0.16749028861522675,
0.8057422637939453,
0.43942534923553467,
-0.05866825208067894,
0.6055963039398193,
-0.4716518521308899,
1.0660111904144287,
-0.19886745512485504,
-0.01695462502539158,
0.46253883838653564,
-0.031486961990594864,
-0.17897944152355194,
0.35231778025627136,
1.0851974487304688,
0.23067863285541534,
0.1333605796098709,
-0.6263449788093567,
0.5604381561279297,
-0.16100801527500153,
0.24567162990570068,
-0.7853186130523682,
-0.7522638440132141,
0.4310325086116791,
-0.4102852940559387,
-0.0851028710603714,
-0.3891744613647461,
-1.0332244634628296,
-0.8154088258743286,
-0.12100774794816971,
0.18185952305793762,
-0.2742352783679962,
-0.6173583269119263,
0.2721739709377289,
-0.42011600732803345,
-0.10447727888822556,
0.02597230114042759,
-0.9712747931480408,
0.42020392417907715,
0.33288323879241943,
0.8256151676177979,
-0.3081827163696289,
-0.48013344407081604,
-0.4551423192024231,
-0.12866145372390747,
-0.49727970361709595,
0.7266843318939209,
-0.3126279413700104,
-0.349945604801178,
0.0029563982971012592,
0.20750756561756134,
-0.14685122668743134,
-0.7773411273956299,
0.39729398488998413,
0.053014907985925674,
0.07874452322721481,
-0.3968949615955353,
-0.036608025431632996,
-0.2272775024175644,
-0.2519620358943939,
-0.7920380234718323,
0.7581344246864319,
0.2544293701648712,
-0.41056323051452637,
0.504221498966217,
-0.32602182030677795,
-0.4584035873413086,
0.15249031782150269,
-0.056171100586652756,
0.025666173547506332,
-0.0003384427400305867,
-0.07624521106481552,
0.381570428609848,
-0.3314789831638336,
0.46137475967407227,
-0.36568862199783325,
0.11218651384115219,
0.3110208213329315,
-0.5768319368362427,
0.8972772359848022,
-0.14652976393699646,
-0.4348035752773285,
-0.005146621726453304,
-1.042696237564087,
-0.14079321920871735,
-0.34102872014045715,
-0.08183737099170685,
0.020899208262562752,
0.2992968261241913,
-0.07800568640232086,
0.18544724583625793,
0.14168253540992737,
-0.7614672780036926,
0.08101549744606018,
-0.7272605299949646,
0.2988702058792114,
0.3329850435256958,
-0.17087699472904205,
0.14870862662792206,
-0.28023889660835266,
0.7149885296821594,
-0.2866036295890808,
0.4035797119140625,
0.3660908043384552,
-0.6420451998710632,
-0.36774110794067383,
-0.3695959448814392,
0.5419882535934448,
0.4837496876716614,
-0.49286410212516785,
0.23525433242321014,
-0.28345823287963867,
-0.5697113871574402,
-0.35968369245529175,
-0.13909803330898285,
0.2478615641593933,
0.7085692286491394,
0.43275728821754456,
-0.5319433212280273,
-0.4964663088321686,
-1.026439905166626,
0.1480499804019928,
0.3334274888038635,
-0.2659955322742462,
0.1122106984257698,
0.15777304768562317,
0.2156270146369934,
0.5754146575927734,
0.04948507249355316,
-0.31921854615211487,
-0.30841442942619324,
0.19304180145263672,
0.65012127161026,
0.1779424101114273,
0.3641977906227112,
-0.2778647840023041,
-0.5133646130561829,
0.20976345241069794,
-0.45639583468437195,
-0.2037602961063385,
0.26720085740089417,
0.2282802313566208,
-0.25275105237960815,
0.23689967393875122,
-0.1719142347574234,
0.2760447561740875,
0.9408798217773438,
-0.37249183654785156,
0.34649258852005005,
-0.3838377892971039,
0.019424881786108017,
-0.7478291988372803,
-0.009926981292665005,
-0.03639417886734009,
0.046736352145671844,
-0.544898271560669,
-0.7890161871910095,
-0.27279385924339294,
-0.07603734731674194,
-0.3740966320037842,
-0.0279596708714962,
-0.2366950660943985,
0.035017307847738266,
-0.5967485904693604,
0.2194012552499771,
-0.24251019954681396,
0.15073958039283752,
-0.10392462462186813,
0.605056643486023,
1.1345858573913574,
-0.6810240745544434,
0.6787903904914856,
0.1960771232843399,
-0.4844166934490204,
0.30565145611763,
-0.8650388121604919,
-0.01079292967915535,
-0.08077529817819595,
0.11510241776704788,
-0.6311520338058472,
-0.17055417597293854,
0.47965458035469055,
-0.5002745985984802,
0.17796914279460907,
-0.3615933656692505,
-0.44376683235168457,
-0.2225968986749649,
0.11699823290109634,
-0.04031100496649742,
0.18356941640377045,
-0.4470607042312622,
0.44090965390205383,
0.8183456659317017,
-0.6420606970787048,
-0.833450973033905,
-0.6307995319366455,
0.41404056549072266,
0.09462164342403412,
-0.6525828838348389,
0.7449869513511658,
0.27205148339271545,
-0.040043093264102936,
-0.09356875717639923,
-0.28585681319236755,
-0.17777220904827118,
-0.09098662436008453,
0.24612706899642944,
-0.05291404947638512,
-0.045896440744400024,
-0.004793400876224041,
0.3089753985404968,
0.02279459685087204,
0.20146779716014862,
-0.07146645337343216,
0.9644026160240173,
0.2999451160430908,
-0.0940241664648056,
-0.28144899010658264,
0.444179892539978,
0.7171575427055359,
0.07351965457201004,
0.5134182572364807,
0.230230912566185,
-0.33645904064178467,
-0.42652085423469543,
-0.11383916437625885,
0.2643292546272278,
-0.36148327589035034,
0.17619840800762177,
-0.368869423866272,
-0.241260826587677,
0.6678901314735413,
0.04049530252814293,
-0.46791088581085205,
0.25658613443374634,
0.5950829982757568,
0.18724371492862701,
0.9055894017219543,
0.32215970754623413,
-0.2259969562292099,
0.2846463620662689,
-0.041167162358760834,
0.032135818153619766,
-0.8378087282180786,
-0.5243863463401794,
-0.749659538269043,
-0.12780994176864624,
-0.42742928862571716,
-0.35824093222618103,
0.2597782015800476,
-0.32219427824020386,
0.14003534615039825,
0.35290271043777466,
-0.7273998260498047,
0.3406127095222473,
0.44488710165023804,
0.3940543234348297,
-0.032026562839746475,
-0.2859320640563965,
0.037829793989658356,
-0.1813989281654358,
-0.7933061122894287,
-0.41624581813812256,
1.3336317539215088,
-0.05650593712925911,
0.5608296394348145,
0.24410566687583923,
0.2907167673110962,
0.5167663097381592,
0.14962634444236755,
-0.6213697791099548,
0.373615026473999,
-0.41264376044273376,
-0.47687169909477234,
-0.261420339345932,
-0.2701463997364044,
-1.2049921751022339,
0.4495035707950592,
0.08019981533288956,
-0.7914105653762817,
0.7409092783927917,
-0.028784943744540215,
-0.5396620035171509,
-0.015402264893054962,
-0.46138739585876465,
1.2209523916244507,
-0.07622659206390381,
-0.27030301094055176,
-0.2139234095811844,
-0.5257722735404968,
0.2064700722694397,
0.32234838604927063,
-0.2307014763355255,
-0.3429504930973053,
0.058432940393686295,
0.938120424747467,
-0.3360047936439514,
0.8190840482711792,
-0.245611771941185,
-0.13362371921539307,
-0.174813374876976,
-0.09306568652391434,
0.08815626800060272,
0.01249771285802126,
-0.2826162874698639,
0.1756652295589447,
0.18040992319583893,
-0.1284128874540329,
-0.4109055697917938,
0.7006813883781433,
-0.39797621965408325,
-0.12407133728265762,
-0.6710672378540039,
-0.18992838263511658,
-0.24331526458263397,
0.004805754404515028,
0.36578020453453064,
0.8364357948303223,
-0.5801888108253479,
0.08267851173877716,
0.9017572999000549,
-0.38536709547042847,
0.36481326818466187,
0.5449735522270203,
-0.10763844102621078,
-0.6684592366218567,
0.9506956934928894,
0.17637281119823456,
0.008135100826621056,
0.20308363437652588,
0.10883747786283493,
-0.30258190631866455,
-0.9835319519042969,
-0.4199926555156708,
0.15221810340881348,
-0.38078993558883667,
0.14684860408306122,
-0.732022225856781,
0.1235467791557312,
-0.4751814007759094,
0.4825853407382965,
-0.3070601522922516,
-0.4510095417499542,
-0.3160554766654968,
0.01149484422057867,
0.21256636083126068,
0.44556286931037903,
-0.41259875893592834,
0.29336103796958923,
-0.22461357712745667,
0.8138286471366882,
0.22028525173664093,
0.24819619953632355,
-0.2620657980442047,
-0.3880242109298706,
0.07495363801717758,
0.21626374125480652,
0.013709110207855701,
-1.343301773071289,
1.0274312496185303,
0.2977462112903595,
0.7999449372291565,
0.2454119771718979,
-0.007706363685429096,
0.5257269740104675,
-0.4559241235256195,
0.6495671272277832,
0.23902449011802673,
-0.8928605318069458,
0.7334068417549133,
-0.2405065894126892,
-0.08636286854743958,
0.47701647877693176,
0.4488959312438965,
-0.8346186876296997,
-0.35649895668029785,
-0.5827040672302246,
-0.8821752667427063,
0.7428289651870728,
-0.07668383419513702,
-0.10123927891254425,
-0.24019362032413483,
0.07804474979639053,
0.36864060163497925,
0.13086867332458496,
-0.42830127477645874,
-0.5218760371208191,
-0.38098496198654175,
-0.07665915787220001,
-0.29872262477874756,
0.029224785044789314,
-0.4807170033454895,
-0.6733600497245789,
0.6268627047538757,
-0.1779179871082306,
0.3223109841346741,
0.42276832461357117,
-0.04523575305938721,
0.12465742230415344,
0.13934127986431122,
0.5582078099250793,
0.9058218002319336,
-0.173928901553154,
-0.015157205983996391,
-0.07441917061805725,
-0.7105603814125061,
-0.2386697381734848,
0.5223263502120972,
-0.10943865031003952,
0.5771859884262085,
-0.36124536395072937,
0.7550773620605469,
0.01358090527355671,
-0.7765017151832581,
0.7296304702758789,
-0.06481725722551346,
-0.3382814824581146,
-0.6982192993164062,
0.03956937417387962,
-0.018888184800744057,
0.4028223752975464,
0.22706495225429535,
0.1600448340177536,
0.47913506627082825,
-0.45868319272994995,
0.05902582034468651,
0.4470411539077759,
-0.5027756094932556,
-0.2454501837491989,
0.5574622750282288,
0.08594807982444763,
-0.43637901544570923,
0.5359285473823547,
-0.021377282217144966,
-0.34471938014030457,
0.6869912147521973,
0.32724156975746155,
0.7818778157234192,
0.05869681388139725,
0.7103846669197083,
0.12904132902622223,
0.146661639213562,
-0.29563283920288086,
0.25440406799316406,
-0.15938620269298553,
-0.6104226112365723,
-0.5981535315513611,
-0.3893078565597534,
-0.847922682762146,
0.18146300315856934,
-0.7024057507514954,
0.06083320826292038,
-0.3464944362640381,
-0.32130542397499084,
0.2765316367149353,
-0.26861104369163513,
0.002811326878145337,
0.003235788084566593,
0.16930419206619263,
0.7246243357658386,
-0.5551243424415588,
1.1596086025238037,
0.10153868794441223,
-0.3551483452320099,
-0.020805606618523598,
-0.16252361238002777,
-0.3185155689716339,
-0.5046177506446838,
0.45109668374061584,
-0.18745645880699158,
-0.24714277684688568,
-0.01910003088414669,
-0.39722204208374023,
-0.7630432844161987,
0.7021912336349487,
0.6738443970680237,
-0.2890748381614685,
0.19589009881019592,
-0.04562050476670265,
0.6229485273361206,
0.05265616998076439,
0.03063049353659153,
0.7009710669517517,
0.40450939536094666,
-0.15169838070869446,
-1.0965298414230347,
-0.12857645750045776,
-0.3778473734855652,
-0.36966219544410706,
0.29002782702445984,
-0.2624140679836273,
0.7779264450073242,
0.13019399344921112,
-0.17959436774253845,
0.01915518008172512,
0.507919430732727,
-0.1695185750722885,
0.07248377799987793,
-0.07502763718366623,
0.4561990797519684,
1.177086353302002,
-0.25097814202308655,
1.1172469854354858,
-0.16904745995998383,
-0.09679940342903137,
0.9036855697631836,
-0.12336362898349762,
0.6273229122161865,
0.38709235191345215,
-0.28421223163604736,
0.5424044728279114,
0.37806272506713867,
-0.13119369745254517,
0.6270038485527039,
0.5731931924819946,
-0.6235966682434082,
-0.23943156003952026,
-0.13981372117996216,
-0.6032081246376038,
0.3069913387298584,
0.47596055269241333,
-0.42045673727989197,
-0.09633871167898178,
0.20775757730007172,
-0.17221292853355408,
0.1475248783826828,
-0.055681560188531876,
0.5050222277641296,
-0.17973972856998444,
-0.5754382610321045,
0.5641337037086487,
-0.3544386029243469,
0.7103700041770935,
-0.7225514054298401,
0.11598540842533112,
-0.03157884255051613,
0.10865627974271774,
-0.21544764935970306,
-0.5148139595985413,
0.37317347526550293,
-0.1482076346874237,
-0.37601467967033386,
-0.374880313873291,
0.1810833215713501,
-0.21659968793392181,
-0.07610189914703369,
0.2113368809223175,
0.22433727979660034,
0.4432019889354706,
-0.3855576813220978,
-0.2855193018913269,
-0.14119800925254822,
-0.0734010562300682,
0.20111635327339172,
0.4993407726287842,
0.19784536957740784,
0.5225128531455994,
0.7301062941551208,
0.4549573063850403,
0.709736704826355,
0.40743324160575867,
0.40130379796028137,
0.3761732578277588,
-0.6416852474212646,
-0.1064339205622673,
-0.6612034440040588,
0.3107086420059204,
-0.4586707353591919,
-0.8577063083648682,
0.6266555786132812,
0.5229100584983826,
0.3771374523639679,
0.00625431165099144,
0.7037466168403625,
-0.27142763137817383,
0.635675847530365,
-0.38519278168678284,
0.8385167717933655,
-0.044476915150880814,
-0.25095134973526,
-0.06806200742721558,
-0.4806145429611206,
-0.47157177329063416,
0.6680172681808472,
-0.2412848174571991,
-0.43608585000038147,
0.6681993007659912,
0.9388602375984192,
0.42105430364608765,
0.29012808203697205,
0.29462307691574097,
0.009427467361092567,
0.013693412765860558,
0.6037765741348267,
0.8747573494911194,
-0.3331153988838196,
0.593994140625,
-0.4579503536224365,
-0.289080411195755,
-0.006972170900553465,
-0.6457086801528931,
-0.516400158405304,
-0.5255706906318665,
-0.4662151038646698,
-0.5405927896499634,
0.3285597562789917,
0.6815474033355713,
0.474547415971756,
-0.6835482716560364,
-0.4035239815711975,
-0.44542422890663147,
0.4385238587856293,
-0.6484248638153076,
-0.15770363807678223,
0.24354968965053558,
-0.035337138921022415,
-0.971452534198761,
1.078173041343689,
0.28138089179992676,
-0.006499269511550665,
-0.2633622884750366,
0.07818984240293503,
0.2483198344707489,
-0.5095821619033813,
0.4086795151233673,
0.9223451018333435,
-0.5552409887313843,
0.3206808865070343,
-0.013367676176130772,
-0.12332074344158173,
0.21535956859588623,
0.8039005994796753,
-0.8643573522567749,
0.4933932423591614,
0.7570129632949829,
0.15934373438358307,
0.6956019401550293,
-0.6434528827667236,
0.8938726186752319,
-0.12236499041318893,
0.05793265253305435,
0.8232073783874512,
0.39802682399749756,
0.1928732544183731,
0.026273194700479507,
0.03326473385095596,
0.2258419543504715,
-0.3909524083137512,
-0.7973207235336304,
-0.1664799302816391,
-1.4894458055496216,
-0.14660105109214783,
0.8866420984268188,
0.1862500011920929,
-0.27815377712249756,
-0.7314637899398804,
-0.2515980303287506,
0.15192075073719025,
-0.42197421193122864,
0.7143986821174622,
0.5575168132781982,
-0.44578468799591064,
-0.13856220245361328,
-0.5798577070236206,
0.7134973406791687,
0.260394811630249,
-0.4540802538394928,
0.1647508442401886,
0.7082808613777161,
0.1968424916267395,
-0.05193532630801201,
0.5718541145324707,
-0.33682945370674133,
0.4996444582939148,
0.2791128158569336,
0.3199126422405243,
0.09679998457431793,
-0.3542863130569458,
-0.5077288150787354,
0.7162682414054871,
-0.26856717467308044,
-0.4012362062931061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02167v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02167v2
|
EMOVOME Database: Advancing Emotion Recognition in Speech Beyond Staged Scenarios
| 2024-03-04T16:13:39 | 2024-06-13T13:05:56 |
Lucía Gómez-Zaragozá, Rocío del Amor, María José Castro-Bleda, Valery Naranjo, Mariano Alcañiz Raya, Javier Marín-Morales
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD, I.5.1; I.5.4
|
Natural databases for Speech Emotion Recognition (SER) are scarce and often
rely on staged scenarios, such as films or television shows, limiting their
application in real-world contexts. We developed and publicly released the
Emotional Voice Messages (EMOVOME) database, including 999 voice messages from
real conversations of 100 Spanish speakers on a messaging app, labeled in
continuous and discrete emotions by expert and non-expert annotators. We
evaluated speaker-independent SER models using a standard set of acoustic
features and transformer-based models. We compared the results with reference
databases including acted and elicited speech, and analyzed the influence of
annotators and gender fairness. The pre-trained UniSpeech-SAT-Large model
achieved the highest results, 61.64% and 55.57% Unweighted Accuracy (UA) for
3-class valence and arousal prediction respectively on EMOVOME, a 10%
improvement over baseline models. For the emotion categories, 42.58% UA was
obtained. EMOVOME performed lower than the acted RAVDESS database. The elicited
IEMOCAP database also outperformed EMOVOME in predicting emotion categories,
while similar results were obtained in valence and arousal. EMOVOME outcomes
varied with annotator labels, showing better results and fairness when
combining expert and non-expert annotations. This study highlights the gap
between staged and real-life scenarios, supporting further advancements in
recognizing genuine emotions.
|
[
-0.387064665555954,
-0.42680367827415466,
0.23189465701580048,
0.3600675165653229,
-0.07031852751970291,
0.06023632735013962,
-0.2537109851837158,
-0.5391130447387695,
0.5003226399421692,
0.3217364251613617,
-0.5289310812950134,
-0.5182570815086365,
-0.3456244468688965,
0.26087644696235657,
-0.2920648157596588,
0.45262080430984497,
0.1919175088405609,
0.27616196870803833,
-0.1502099335193634,
-0.15769150853157043,
-0.20962506532669067,
-0.6780300140380859,
-0.5666689872741699,
-0.023233160376548767,
0.4299345910549164,
0.42712536454200745,
0.09249838441610336,
0.14409376680850983,
0.1388975977897644,
0.3129747807979584,
0.03577274829149246,
0.10036725550889969,
-0.39436519145965576,
0.5154838562011719,
0.2675226926803589,
-0.42841964960098267,
-0.5146707892417908,
0.1326560378074646,
0.269072562456131,
0.1496291607618332,
-0.40140485763549805,
-0.07929839938879013,
-0.15599259734153748,
0.534044623374939,
-0.7930541634559631,
0.2344600409269333,
-0.39489221572875977,
0.734043538570404,
-0.002872622571885586,
-0.16710668802261353,
-0.5493790507316589,
-0.45299234986305237,
0.3003813326358795,
-0.29847750067710876,
0.022383328527212143,
0.217909574508667,
0.5075887441635132,
0.36150676012039185,
-0.6168071627616882,
-0.4429199695587158,
-0.8668467402458191,
0.487742155790329,
-0.47893503308296204,
0.6081437468528748,
0.36312443017959595,
0.5737375020980835,
-0.14587797224521637,
-0.5957636833190918,
-0.5346813201904297,
-0.3453592360019684,
0.3058958351612091,
0.39332315325737,
-0.45377662777900696,
0.30092307925224304,
0.293500155210495,
0.2898567020893097,
-0.3824117183685303,
0.30428066849708557,
-0.023398254066705704,
-0.12851443886756897,
0.5037261843681335,
0.24455970525741577,
0.16362319886684418,
-0.322657972574234,
-0.1538051813840866,
-0.22938326001167297,
-0.5916821360588074,
0.042479000985622406,
0.18814672529697418,
0.1309008002281189,
-0.16025355458259583,
0.49197515845298767,
-0.12163946032524109,
0.2796195447444916,
0.14513035118579865,
0.04810120165348053,
0.2571365237236023,
0.37926074862480164,
-0.3725416660308838,
0.4560827910900116,
0.7569708228111267,
0.2544325590133667,
0.14835262298583984,
-0.0012537144357338548,
-0.12036099284887314,
-0.10068675875663757,
0.20307612419128418,
-0.7956979274749756,
-0.10683169215917587,
0.4507574141025543,
-0.2340024709701538,
-0.13090670108795166,
-0.17876364290714264,
-1.2423491477966309,
-0.8843750953674316,
-0.2412920743227005,
0.34159931540489197,
-0.16132603585720062,
-0.2487894743680954,
-0.29736965894699097,
0.12934152781963348,
0.08956257253885269,
0.47485747933387756,
-0.6183512210845947,
0.3512544333934784,
0.6130284667015076,
0.9309943318367004,
0.43474265933036804,
0.2742706835269928,
-0.5838609933853149,
-0.14707224071025848,
-0.17824305593967438,
0.5735830068588257,
-0.6007176041603088,
-0.3911878764629364,
0.2935960590839386,
0.14774297177791595,
-0.21132764220237732,
-0.5513811111450195,
0.7500321865081787,
-0.034077566117048264,
0.2875347137451172,
-0.1756558120250702,
-0.7703286409378052,
-0.10778851807117462,
0.08189689368009567,
-0.719466507434845,
0.8430477976799011,
-0.4167885482311249,
-0.3397067189216614,
0.2537783086299896,
-0.5831992626190186,
-0.2691519260406494,
-0.1819647252559662,
-0.4204597473144531,
-0.349344402551651,
0.3818531334400177,
0.1278388798236847,
0.6211798191070557,
-0.39828163385391235,
0.09599770605564117,
-0.3832527697086334,
-0.19258791208267212,
0.4904683828353882,
-0.3908108174800873,
0.2659054696559906,
0.37884122133255005,
-0.5196805000305176,
-0.20200052857398987,
-0.8282039761543274,
-0.39157217741012573,
-0.2028198540210724,
0.0050144805572927,
-0.19455422461032867,
0.0921589583158493,
0.11527466773986816,
0.5759254097938538,
-0.2333640158176422,
-1.0735067129135132,
-0.16017326712608337,
-0.25265708565711975,
0.31148096919059753,
0.5925372838973999,
-0.1896156519651413,
0.3742472529411316,
0.07191448658704758,
0.7904707789421082,
0.015156020410358906,
0.16665348410606384,
-0.24489887058734894,
-0.5291432738304138,
-0.6822222471237183,
-0.4474431872367859,
0.2050773650407791,
0.7653858661651611,
-0.19510766863822937,
0.3647909462451935,
-0.18386310338974,
-0.6688863039016724,
-0.8448534607887268,
-0.6426752805709839,
0.4216187000274658,
0.663745105266571,
0.146654412150383,
-0.05449838191270828,
-0.8053445816040039,
-0.6881165504455566,
-0.18028533458709717,
-0.26514554023742676,
-0.08297687768936157,
0.9845505952835083,
0.1954573690891266,
-0.087915800511837,
0.7958188056945801,
-0.23907019197940826,
-0.30881816148757935,
0.031632810831069946,
0.5835561156272888,
-0.13292284309864044,
0.41828393936157227,
0.3147105574607849,
-0.7091798186302185,
-0.24093329906463623,
0.1065472811460495,
-0.6662784814834595,
-0.28556787967681885,
0.02138066291809082,
0.16736096143722534,
0.34047141671180725,
0.0548563227057457,
-0.36786821484565735,
0.42190808057785034,
0.5169070363044739,
-0.16608573496341705,
0.08607488125562668,
0.0000620366699877195,
0.720892608165741,
-1.0091921091079712,
-0.07397405058145523,
0.13681557774543762,
-0.20566807687282562,
-0.7758474349975586,
-0.8092402219772339,
0.0521276518702507,
-0.4366649091243744,
-0.6358247995376587,
0.51811683177948,
-0.33262720704078674,
-0.4439018666744232,
0.0010002320632338524,
0.31575798988342285,
-0.11512797325849533,
0.29531219601631165,
0.23544029891490936,
0.38689494132995605,
0.3811708092689514,
-0.38115206360816956,
0.7082213163375854,
0.3953438103199005,
-0.23422424495220184,
0.8448240160942078,
-0.4244508743286133,
0.3491869568824768,
-0.25032997131347656,
0.3124319016933441,
-1.0555180311203003,
-0.40957769751548767,
0.11954718083143234,
-0.4880701005458832,
0.3696669936180115,
-0.37138503789901733,
-0.18698540329933167,
-0.27856549620628357,
-0.17050738632678986,
0.011341376230120659,
0.6877949237823486,
-0.5568813681602478,
1.0095927715301514,
0.6059271097183228,
-0.3774977922439575,
-0.4345349073410034,
-0.777664303779602,
0.34155288338661194,
-0.3652052581310272,
-0.6176856756210327,
0.04898468777537346,
0.3027893304824829,
-0.18353746831417084,
-0.1973138451576233,
-0.013063909485936165,
-0.38680922985076904,
-0.030692946165800095,
0.7721899151802063,
-0.186432346701622,
0.03376535698771477,
0.4719316363334656,
0.196955606341362,
0.156342014670372,
0.053586188703775406,
0.27234870195388794,
0.3236348628997803,
-0.143613800406456,
0.029229195788502693,
-0.5856138467788696,
0.2901177406311035,
0.5111419558525085,
-0.09074278175830841,
0.6985788941383362,
0.7830572128295898,
-0.769424557685852,
-0.11429082602262497,
-0.7081156373023987,
-0.1343289166688919,
-0.39454808831214905,
0.21896696090698242,
-0.375340074300766,
-1.0607399940490723,
0.842062771320343,
-0.3200990855693817,
-0.11865203827619553,
0.10332959145307541,
0.3849457800388336,
-0.357162207365036,
1.17793607711792,
0.18287555873394012,
0.08591651171445847,
0.6648416519165039,
0.17842760682106018,
0.06690403819084167,
-0.8460591435432434,
-0.6503896117210388,
-0.798791229724884,
-0.34649741649627686,
-0.7134965062141418,
-0.22208847105503082,
0.392806738615036,
-0.4492020010948181,
-0.05484795197844505,
0.030930010601878166,
-0.1677502542734146,
0.15256556868553162,
0.14394564926624298,
0.07443983852863312,
-0.12309562414884567,
-0.052533991634845734,
0.29078733921051025,
-0.4128178358078003,
-0.5645078420639038,
-0.5271320939064026,
0.861083984375,
0.35606443881988525,
0.6580810546875,
0.08326578140258789,
0.6197545528411865,
0.5189753770828247,
0.3922502398490906,
-0.6815509796142578,
0.5801916718482971,
-0.19433799386024475,
-0.6591691970825195,
-0.03375101462006569,
-0.5379472970962524,
-0.7898810505867004,
0.2254123091697693,
-0.24814894795417786,
-0.7442870140075684,
0.6405113339424133,
0.25609612464904785,
-0.40186500549316406,
0.07332182675600052,
-0.6272054314613342,
0.8504147529602051,
-0.26767081022262573,
-0.2511402368545532,
-0.18283416330814362,
-0.6722902059555054,
0.2014550119638443,
-0.020724773406982422,
0.161615252494812,
-0.5338674783706665,
-0.0881558209657669,
0.9215609431266785,
-0.39541029930114746,
0.8692595362663269,
-0.38513174653053284,
0.01977924257516861,
0.20521585643291473,
0.1281728595495224,
0.42170822620391846,
-0.16276352107524872,
-0.39164599776268005,
-0.0693092867732048,
-0.13432921469211578,
-0.0505632646381855,
-0.6528046131134033,
0.6610568761825562,
-0.672283947467804,
-0.16032685339450836,
-0.44709569215774536,
0.03138802945613861,
-0.3426826000213623,
-0.2627391219139099,
0.2289775311946869,
0.763188362121582,
-0.531607449054718,
0.3421190083026886,
0.763547420501709,
-0.5637738108634949,
0.2535940408706665,
0.6345774531364441,
0.0735623762011528,
-0.6592404246330261,
0.6889986395835876,
0.27266913652420044,
-0.03764570876955986,
0.48385700583457947,
0.16420699656009674,
-0.5377207398414612,
0.12481443583965302,
-0.23389600217342377,
-0.09439022839069366,
-0.714965283870697,
-0.2147485464811325,
-0.8572805523872375,
0.3430037796497345,
-0.5515689253807068,
-0.015596779063344002,
-0.6700705289840698,
-0.6424204111099243,
-0.27436575293540955,
-0.3482421934604645,
0.6471773982048035,
0.6509559750556946,
-0.21643491089344025,
0.214283749461174,
-0.8314425349235535,
-0.040009353309869766,
0.4243457019329071,
0.15316668152809143,
-0.23174557089805603,
-0.6417996883392334,
-0.18970966339111328,
0.12879393994808197,
0.03119278885424137,
-1.3304446935653687,
0.7683035731315613,
0.7316233515739441,
0.17881760001182556,
0.5637911558151245,
0.29906871914863586,
0.6476351618766785,
-0.38228851556777954,
0.7109548449516296,
-0.08521439135074615,
-1.1296930313110352,
0.8793909549713135,
-0.21684953570365906,
-0.29492107033729553,
0.3914746344089508,
0.4397760331630707,
-0.7342016696929932,
-0.0670090839266777,
-0.5988576412200928,
-0.8403818011283875,
0.7447482347488403,
0.31220340728759766,
0.00375175173394382,
-0.05923328548669815,
0.40359634160995483,
-0.024538664147257805,
0.4792523980140686,
-0.4197814464569092,
-0.1718243956565857,
-0.2575860321521759,
-0.5849553942680359,
0.09508872777223587,
-0.18161465227603912,
0.03328157961368561,
-0.15028659999370575,
0.3905230462551117,
0.22369083762168884,
0.8066371083259583,
0.3391594886779785,
-0.1475684642791748,
-0.202474907040596,
0.398282527923584,
0.46090608835220337,
-0.17783786356449127,
-0.6099792718887329,
0.12082052230834961,
0.2719131410121918,
-0.3698662519454956,
0.24366821348667145,
0.283041387796402,
0.3676754832267761,
0.16506078839302063,
0.10527688264846802,
1.162740707397461,
0.49795541167259216,
-0.9969006180763245,
0.4239763617515564,
-0.3061513900756836,
0.16499286890029907,
-0.5968624949455261,
-0.18911036849021912,
-0.2731190025806427,
0.4300849139690399,
0.18487443029880524,
-0.24320818483829498,
0.5861280560493469,
-0.650033175945282,
0.058443568646907806,
-0.04779084399342537,
-0.6924387216567993,
-0.4750446081161499,
0.6555589437484741,
0.6146159172058105,
-0.2845953106880188,
0.49128466844558716,
-0.14658527076244354,
-0.5240936875343323,
0.8307562470436096,
0.34234383702278137,
1.1421232223510742,
-0.8042622208595276,
0.342207670211792,
0.31386232376098633,
0.20328304171562195,
-0.146437868475914,
0.4910569190979004,
0.005679038818925619,
-0.6496260166168213,
0.002736942609772086,
-0.3229972720146179,
-1.0025148391723633,
-0.2901993691921234,
-0.7842264771461487,
0.01163510512560606,
-0.5310847759246826,
-0.3892790675163269,
-0.30664291977882385,
-0.08305084705352783,
-0.6691988110542297,
0.46173667907714844,
0.5051239132881165,
0.5369023680686951,
-1.1106078624725342,
0.5141720175743103,
0.8474010229110718,
-0.21105270087718964,
-0.6023169755935669,
-0.5101235508918762,
0.2511623501777649,
-0.3665214478969574,
0.3814745545387268,
0.4520209729671478,
-0.11093898862600327,
0.1276998519897461,
-0.22948046028614044,
-0.3920428454875946,
1.1450098752975464,
0.44817647337913513,
-0.8595772385597229,
0.49544838070869446,
0.048364683985710144,
0.7956801652908325,
-0.6219900250434875,
0.6547513008117676,
0.48032456636428833,
0.2069818675518036,
0.15750129520893097,
-0.8542909026145935,
-0.21711283922195435,
-0.4026196300983429,
-0.3559826612472534,
0.1832130402326584,
-0.5607693195343018,
0.5958417654037476,
0.09663660079240799,
-0.3262808620929718,
-0.16025105118751526,
0.5785501003265381,
0.21935009956359863,
0.7477551102638245,
0.44436365365982056,
0.49461764097213745,
1.1603304147720337,
-0.3940766453742981,
1.0458972454071045,
0.08631781488656998,
0.10269834101200104,
1.0060038566589355,
-0.685124397277832,
1.1128560304641724,
0.020588958635926247,
-0.1708771139383316,
0.4331417679786682,
0.8864675164222717,
0.22240781784057617,
0.31442990899086,
0.06202288344502449,
-0.6864471435546875,
-0.2530689537525177,
-0.5891565680503845,
-0.34664976596832275,
0.3784773647785187,
0.5749120712280273,
-0.27132144570350647,
0.48127710819244385,
0.5030249953269958,
0.06573604792356491,
-0.2073778510093689,
-0.3038651943206787,
0.7470075488090515,
0.30438685417175293,
-0.1615089327096939,
0.15846365690231323,
-0.28997594118118286,
0.3932035267353058,
-0.1326509267091751,
0.1207800954580307,
-0.401452898979187,
-0.045437127351760864,
-0.29629191756248474,
-0.45463308691978455,
-0.020054033026099205,
0.4803863763809204,
0.20093192160129547,
-0.049636296927928925,
0.7116718888282776,
-0.6399624943733215,
-0.37395596504211426,
0.2325589507818222,
0.3425307273864746,
0.486054390668869,
-0.17794188857078552,
-0.5170544981956482,
0.1337626725435257,
-0.33912983536720276,
-0.445404052734375,
0.07784080505371094,
0.8402032256126404,
0.3231792151927948,
0.7377462387084961,
0.16397298872470856,
0.043597262352705,
0.38999268412590027,
0.3210281431674957,
0.5683521032333374,
-0.8442660570144653,
-0.7007359266281128,
-0.4916629195213318,
0.5171621441841125,
-0.1739184409379959,
-0.26499462127685547,
0.5574610233306885,
0.3393053114414215,
0.3327926695346832,
-0.08592769503593445,
0.5119742751121521,
-0.02594875544309616,
0.5396389961242676,
-0.3156680762767792,
0.28698036074638367,
-0.5229689478874207,
0.05500928685069084,
-0.5750432014465332,
-0.7523620128631592,
-0.2589605748653412,
0.7252836227416992,
-0.2688114643096924,
0.066743403673172,
0.20627498626708984,
0.6882835030555725,
0.2906968593597412,
0.3382769525051117,
0.3612339198589325,
0.4774320125579834,
0.34564244747161865,
0.6240631937980652,
1.1112830638885498,
-0.31393739581108093,
0.2371698021888733,
-0.2524603307247162,
-0.1106191948056221,
-0.5327714681625366,
-0.8595734238624573,
-0.6147086024284363,
-0.425446480512619,
-0.5180898308753967,
-0.1140885204076767,
0.17730917036533356,
1.4894675016403198,
0.5566911697387695,
-0.7440559267997742,
-0.13755376636981964,
0.16351079940795898,
-0.19927233457565308,
0.10529284179210663,
-0.1575980931520462,
0.018161343410611153,
0.1407330334186554,
-0.9011945724487305,
0.6115081906318665,
0.4215671122074127,
0.1736524999141693,
0.10562790930271149,
-0.37400925159454346,
0.1908484548330307,
0.3012990653514862,
0.5349011421203613,
0.5765871405601501,
-0.4689117670059204,
-0.1183694526553154,
-0.12129472941160202,
0.0297804344445467,
0.056928087025880814,
0.6016104817390442,
-0.7157401442527771,
0.7183012366294861,
0.5370522737503052,
0.4792071580886841,
0.40482351183891296,
-0.07009389996528625,
0.6574468016624451,
-0.8089327812194824,
0.34408628940582275,
0.5221264362335205,
0.514242947101593,
0.35592347383499146,
-0.32907888293266296,
0.4907264709472656,
0.10653907805681229,
-0.5685917735099792,
-1.0804206132888794,
0.06428932398557663,
-0.9600381851196289,
0.3260340392589569,
0.9010513424873352,
-0.39833104610443115,
-0.17858901619911194,
0.0005444801645353436,
-0.23157760500907898,
0.49565547704696655,
-0.8074167370796204,
0.7953037619590759,
0.49761322140693665,
-0.3503929674625397,
-0.6169195771217346,
-0.47147101163864136,
0.5634640455245972,
0.4961867928504944,
-1.0588340759277344,
-0.0876641795039177,
0.8817191123962402,
-0.27185875177383423,
-0.09884575009346008,
0.42419296503067017,
-0.05394844338297844,
0.3625395894050598,
-0.15061329305171967,
0.424493670463562,
0.05454183742403984,
-0.43483367562294006,
-0.8341719508171082,
0.23286809027194977,
-0.21981920301914215,
-0.15702326595783234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02130v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02130v2
|
Using LLMs for the Extraction and Normalization of Product Attribute Values
| 2024-03-04T15:39:59 | 2024-03-05T08:12:18 |
Nick Baumann, Alexander Brinkmann, Christian Bizer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Product offers on e-commerce websites often consist of a textual product
title and a textual product description. In order to provide features such as
faceted product filtering or content-based product recommendation, the websites
need to extract attribute-value pairs from the unstructured product
descriptions. This paper explores the potential of using large language models
(LLMs), such as OpenAI's GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, to extract and normalize attribute
values from product titles and product descriptions. For our experiments, we
introduce the WDC Product Attribute-Value Extraction (WDC PAVE) dataset. WDC
PAVE consists of product offers from 87 websites that provide schema$.$org
annotations. The offers belong to five different categories, each featuring a
specific set of attributes. The dataset provides manually verified
attribute-value pairs in two forms: (i) directly extracted values and (ii)
normalized attribute values. The normalization of the attribute values requires
systems to perform the following types of operations: name expansion,
generalization, unit of measurement normalization, and string wrangling. Our
experiments demonstrate that GPT-4 outperforms PLM-based extraction methods by
10%, achieving an F1-Score of 91%. For the extraction and normalization of
product attribute values, GPT-4 achieves a similar performance to the
extraction scenario, while being particularly strong at string wrangling and
name expansion.
|
[
-0.337416410446167,
-0.6996465921401978,
0.38054749369621277,
0.2856983244419098,
-0.4136655628681183,
-0.05820336192846298,
-0.528809666633606,
-0.8118906617164612,
-0.12489273399114609,
0.4664557874202728,
-0.42674803733825684,
-0.6973119378089905,
-0.45451265573501587,
0.11148107051849365,
-0.22324824333190918,
1.2920825481414795,
-0.0012196943862363696,
-0.2645888924598694,
-0.03787039592862129,
-0.1511753350496292,
-0.12956111133098602,
-0.48958471417427063,
-0.42656776309013367,
-0.1460876762866974,
0.5498127341270447,
0.20820368826389313,
0.8140557408332825,
0.5474992394447327,
0.9314494132995605,
0.29864850640296936,
-0.014003734104335308,
0.10906004160642624,
-0.3841914236545563,
0.3318612575531006,
-0.09815853089094162,
-0.21940085291862488,
-0.7768821716308594,
0.45672714710235596,
0.38582170009613037,
0.5182541608810425,
-0.22382347285747528,
0.3631057143211365,
0.004987422376871109,
0.39514854550361633,
-0.6490582227706909,
0.3730561435222626,
-0.5144227743148804,
0.09295601397752762,
0.013557975180447102,
-0.013012616895139217,
-0.181406632065773,
-0.5218467712402344,
0.15388301014900208,
-0.7784402966499329,
0.10632413625717163,
0.18108507990837097,
1.457633137702942,
-0.14244486391544342,
-0.13131177425384521,
-0.4237692356109619,
-0.9525624513626099,
1.2003508806228638,
-0.8974742293357849,
0.45719122886657715,
0.41269609332084656,
0.2893505394458771,
-0.21539868414402008,
-0.7698596119880676,
-0.6887016296386719,
-0.14455580711364746,
-0.2053327113389969,
0.0012909326469525695,
-0.43874555826187134,
0.1595376580953598,
0.4059043228626251,
0.9243913292884827,
-0.36887112259864807,
0.5286861658096313,
-0.46636396646499634,
-0.0003734475467354059,
0.763799786567688,
0.0030499971471726894,
0.3179987967014313,
-0.12691906094551086,
-0.4719912111759186,
-0.09672411531209946,
-0.8331039547920227,
0.2432076334953308,
0.4020225405693054,
0.3023829460144043,
0.12638889253139496,
0.8453345894813538,
-0.5412279963493347,
0.6340329051017761,
-0.049097370356321335,
-0.6881129145622253,
0.1956973373889923,
-0.3663504719734192,
-0.6418138146400452,
-0.26040077209472656,
0.8279745578765869,
0.377401739358902,
0.24372746050357819,
-0.34252840280532837,
-0.5805507302284241,
-0.24136076867580414,
-0.09499803930521011,
-0.899908185005188,
-0.24356235563755035,
0.19917602837085724,
-0.8645560145378113,
-0.418610543012619,
0.16903530061244965,
-0.7768828868865967,
-0.17641165852546692,
-0.48815298080444336,
0.3898642659187317,
-0.11726077646017075,
-0.07317419350147247,
0.04311976209282875,
-0.1824043244123459,
0.7098570466041565,
0.38410598039627075,
-0.8424556255340576,
0.4935373067855835,
0.7151547074317932,
0.7793365120887756,
-0.5343812108039856,
0.20281864702701569,
-0.41049569845199585,
0.41680845618247986,
0.08900810033082962,
0.8772538900375366,
-0.5769829154014587,
-0.2639612555503845,
-0.17864879965782166,
0.05131102725863457,
0.4681156277656555,
-0.7159783840179443,
0.43087440729141235,
-0.987695574760437,
0.09165677428245544,
-0.19622057676315308,
-0.5631625056266785,
-0.13347609341144562,
0.46319580078125,
-1.0104256868362427,
0.8515225052833557,
0.042741380631923676,
-0.31434258818626404,
0.3191729485988617,
-0.8464602828025818,
-0.6105631589889526,
0.29583868384361267,
-0.0809715986251831,
-0.532051682472229,
0.2500772774219513,
0.49087533354759216,
0.569627046585083,
-0.8383482098579407,
-0.15769051015377045,
-0.2779199182987213,
-0.11804033070802689,
0.3981131613254547,
-0.5087754726409912,
0.6358605623245239,
0.3736228942871094,
-0.31983768939971924,
-0.17815600335597992,
-0.6951567530632019,
0.08787552267313004,
0.20379450917243958,
-0.5463061928749084,
-0.3131365478038788,
-0.168765589594841,
0.18263058364391327,
0.2547719180583954,
0.4245246946811676,
-0.649961531162262,
0.3187614381313324,
-0.3009297847747803,
0.22340300679206848,
1.0519481897354126,
-0.05057036504149437,
0.37178200483322144,
-0.10116200894117355,
0.684992253780365,
-0.08186957985162735,
0.1444404572248459,
0.07935592532157898,
-0.6297041773796082,
-0.7255638837814331,
-0.5993066430091858,
0.3114159405231476,
0.34822797775268555,
-0.5141351222991943,
0.2963455319404602,
-0.3048889636993408,
-0.29691800475120544,
-0.37990838289260864,
0.24900519847869873,
0.3054354190826416,
0.4435674250125885,
0.36472052335739136,
-0.27421486377716064,
-0.15639539062976837,
-1.167309284210205,
-0.3688742518424988,
0.0253947414457798,
-0.6473921537399292,
0.3488992750644684,
0.11946643888950348,
-0.08157693594694138,
1.1932882070541382,
-1.14280104637146,
-0.513484001159668,
-0.15552571415901184,
0.5416860580444336,
0.4221588671207428,
0.148561030626297,
0.17871356010437012,
-0.9640277028083801,
-0.4820956587791443,
0.30396589636802673,
-0.4749537706375122,
-0.28901147842407227,
0.058657627552747726,
0.20942942798137665,
0.1612209677696228,
-0.09152883291244507,
-0.6249034404754639,
0.5212902426719666,
0.3688117563724518,
-0.002223540563136339,
0.6868271231651306,
-0.3055262267589569,
0.3079183101654053,
-1.0643255710601807,
0.01883869245648384,
0.568333625793457,
-0.2103780061006546,
-0.48176077008247375,
-0.012114977464079857,
-0.0893976241350174,
0.004598019178956747,
-0.609541118144989,
0.212296724319458,
-0.6608892679214478,
-0.5742781162261963,
-0.1798967719078064,
0.271065890789032,
0.33667197823524475,
0.4639681279659271,
-0.0037446755450218916,
0.8918896913528442,
0.01957082375884056,
-0.7277083992958069,
0.7512087821960449,
0.1667775809764862,
-0.405331015586853,
0.8837782740592957,
-0.6300400495529175,
0.030874572694301605,
0.0037779472768306732,
0.058017995208501816,
-0.6902270317077637,
0.03181307017803192,
-0.07801638543605804,
-0.1591312438249588,
0.09384670108556747,
-0.10159380733966827,
-0.7862191796302795,
-0.08688987791538239,
-0.5107826590538025,
0.2617892324924469,
0.6526504158973694,
-0.49601227045059204,
0.5831132531166077,
0.47730782628059387,
-0.36167168617248535,
-0.254729688167572,
-0.474557101726532,
0.1208852156996727,
-0.4743838310241699,
-0.5716139078140259,
0.47756317257881165,
-0.15199223160743713,
-0.2566937506198883,
0.04090544953942299,
0.06437655538320541,
-0.10568426549434662,
0.14528746902942657,
0.01527608372271061,
0.46362489461898804,
-0.2337656319141388,
0.14780613780021667,
-0.1421942263841629,
-0.2073001116514206,
-0.12949500977993011,
-0.33033284544944763,
0.2618466317653656,
-0.23170360922813416,
-0.18192587792873383,
-0.44096463918685913,
0.31543222069740295,
0.1514846682548523,
-0.4530680775642395,
0.5952013731002808,
0.6071743965148926,
-0.5539121627807617,
-0.16878700256347656,
-0.6366371512413025,
-0.035954348742961884,
-0.5300982594490051,
0.22728095948696136,
-0.48043984174728394,
-0.8416315913200378,
0.4279342591762543,
-0.08335769176483154,
-0.05913250893354416,
0.5846181511878967,
0.6137138605117798,
-0.3837781250476837,
1.1342369318008423,
0.680372416973114,
-0.07190709561109543,
0.2827981114387512,
-0.17102527618408203,
0.6702294945716858,
-0.890322744846344,
-0.3278675675392151,
-0.5398316979408264,
-0.6552220582962036,
-0.8084086775779724,
-0.2800537347793579,
0.3292478919029236,
0.0412052720785141,
-0.22776679694652557,
0.34031519293785095,
-0.5363298058509827,
0.5829943418502808,
0.7381523847579956,
0.2209807187318802,
0.5309635400772095,
0.4629196226596832,
0.30823996663093567,
-0.17120710015296936,
0.15241825580596924,
-0.35366085171699524,
1.16661536693573,
0.3401133120059967,
0.8668071031570435,
0.408698707818985,
0.09298957139253616,
0.3506070375442505,
0.47549501061439514,
-1.0098944902420044,
0.3567727506160736,
-0.45044687390327454,
-0.21450908482074738,
-0.30361413955688477,
-0.40289777517318726,
-0.8158118724822998,
0.1527062952518463,
-0.09184141457080841,
-0.8518400192260742,
0.1902138590812683,
-0.21578308939933777,
-0.4289645552635193,
0.31998246908187866,
-0.3537176847457886,
0.5601484775543213,
-0.5904181003570557,
-0.16199210286140442,
-0.03842631354928017,
-0.3865815997123718,
0.18958115577697754,
-0.08295189589262009,
0.2041827291250229,
-0.3077458441257477,
-0.19142602384090424,
0.7985065579414368,
-0.2181132435798645,
0.3885498046875,
0.0692434161901474,
-0.4000627398490906,
-0.04087280482053757,
-0.1278100311756134,
0.6223278045654297,
-0.2326529324054718,
0.19228501617908478,
0.0400540716946125,
-0.23087552189826965,
-0.2084234207868576,
-0.7259203791618347,
0.7769008278846741,
-0.8587217926979065,
-0.6292030811309814,
-0.4295981824398041,
-0.5067963004112244,
-0.20076143741607666,
0.2413710057735443,
-0.1091654971241951,
-0.01818399503827095,
-0.0008214307017624378,
0.4243382215499878,
0.8179492354393005,
-0.37776967883110046,
0.5451180934906006,
0.4237527549266815,
0.030590109527111053,
-0.5005630254745483,
0.9687547087669373,
-0.05433379113674164,
0.47961440682411194,
0.4082944691181183,
0.33900007605552673,
-0.2491932362318039,
-0.5409806966781616,
0.04209919646382332,
0.1718420684337616,
-0.8393208384513855,
-0.6802389621734619,
-0.6160906553268433,
-0.21907100081443787,
-0.5679461359977722,
0.04213862493634224,
0.025158967822790146,
-0.5864880681037903,
-0.3328688442707062,
-0.25935351848602295,
0.5582351088523865,
0.9458827376365662,
-0.021357698366045952,
0.46945518255233765,
-0.8337948322296143,
0.6585163474082947,
0.5272801518440247,
0.4960048496723175,
-0.3042885363101959,
-0.16255605220794678,
-0.27718767523765564,
0.15899904072284698,
-0.4381619989871979,
-0.8577021360397339,
0.4759990870952606,
0.2819559574127197,
0.5010107159614563,
0.6414989829063416,
-0.07652507722377777,
0.7339460849761963,
-0.17807835340499878,
0.9670807123184204,
0.18200281262397766,
-0.7106504440307617,
0.38022297620773315,
-0.230682373046875,
-0.1012553721666336,
0.24225205183029175,
0.47591498494148254,
-0.6084604263305664,
0.09087657928466797,
-0.35863804817199707,
-0.9764407277107239,
0.8100243210792542,
0.327778160572052,
-0.11368648707866669,
0.1904161125421524,
0.3302290141582489,
0.05048254132270813,
0.35750481486320496,
-0.9760167002677917,
-0.1629338562488556,
0.12816612422466278,
-0.302996963262558,
-0.004301025532186031,
-0.2755880057811737,
-0.00605143653228879,
-0.1597835272550583,
0.6268768310546875,
-0.08163074404001236,
0.1400141417980194,
-0.21773983538150787,
-0.34672364592552185,
0.26352882385253906,
0.4245757460594177,
0.32892554998397827,
0.4231952130794525,
-0.22217971086502075,
0.057877738028764725,
-0.026084303855895996,
-0.38132163882255554,
0.013776418752968311,
0.17648479342460632,
0.010061126202344894,
-0.39128735661506653,
-0.00004399128374643624,
0.519364058971405,
-0.05049922689795494,
-0.5293871760368347,
0.706181526184082,
0.0036061389837414026,
0.21710383892059326,
-0.1015864908695221,
-0.3984980583190918,
0.03080671653151512,
0.06339907646179199,
0.26232340931892395,
-0.5228231549263,
0.5311117172241211,
-0.5369709134101868,
0.1870407611131668,
0.4911309778690338,
-0.11814670264720917,
-0.40707269310951233,
0.34581130743026733,
0.023768246173858643,
-0.16020271182060242,
0.8940297365188599,
-0.08032490313053131,
-0.3887886703014374,
0.6203256249427795,
0.7691319584846497,
1.0071120262145996,
-0.1253579705953598,
0.2486044019460678,
0.022763261571526527,
0.2715441882610321,
0.007600030861794949,
0.13771197199821472,
-0.202164888381958,
-0.633686363697052,
-0.22291207313537598,
-0.9944900274276733,
-0.3431260883808136,
0.21173487603664398,
-0.522851824760437,
0.4239235818386078,
-0.4041002690792084,
0.01209166832268238,
0.02486453391611576,
0.09508366137742996,
-1.014347791671753,
0.470084547996521,
0.13388459384441376,
0.410481333732605,
-0.8735378980636597,
0.6901372075080872,
0.4178410470485687,
-0.896173357963562,
-0.8333104252815247,
-0.2914402484893799,
-0.08123959600925446,
-0.6570231318473816,
0.9395382404327393,
0.1576562523841858,
0.016606612130999565,
-0.41295838356018066,
-0.38954824209213257,
-0.8696328401565552,
1.4152257442474365,
0.11532562226057053,
-0.36521467566490173,
-0.20041991770267487,
0.7859427332878113,
0.4741622805595398,
-0.5507162809371948,
0.3221150040626526,
0.823115885257721,
0.65281742811203,
0.17589688301086426,
-0.7666077613830566,
0.16494528949260712,
-0.11560229957103729,
0.30422157049179077,
0.03133672848343849,
-0.20715728402137756,
1.101554036140442,
0.2943120002746582,
-0.2105165421962738,
0.015699446201324463,
0.46718069911003113,
0.12011919170618057,
-0.08200705051422119,
0.3834848403930664,
0.7238746881484985,
0.5877776741981506,
-0.01661403849720955,
0.8397083878517151,
0.04749615862965584,
0.5534788966178894,
1.0242341756820679,
-0.34165167808532715,
1.04751455783844,
0.4124594032764435,
-0.4557540714740753,
0.5152820348739624,
0.624442458152771,
-0.23531199991703033,
0.5241900682449341,
0.21278831362724304,
-0.3243129551410675,
0.044806107878685,
-0.033197853714227676,
-0.04480120167136192,
0.3627224862575531,
0.5385434031486511,
-0.43196290731430054,
-0.22636543214321136,
-0.003913192544132471,
0.12815722823143005,
-0.24197711050510406,
-0.23042331635951996,
1.240147352218628,
0.08794887363910675,
-0.3107205927371979,
0.23942147195339203,
0.35079434514045715,
0.6568529009819031,
-0.4536096751689911,
-0.17927226424217224,
-0.26728883385658264,
0.229364812374115,
-0.30662521719932556,
-0.7519283890724182,
0.010135944001376629,
0.11796752363443375,
-0.06213125213980675,
-0.46169614791870117,
0.7733160853385925,
-0.3901502192020416,
-0.7453798651695251,
0.0833813026547432,
0.1063937172293663,
0.0171420369297266,
-0.21040576696395874,
-0.5331763029098511,
-0.14023225009441376,
-0.19383594393730164,
-0.47105348110198975,
0.329730749130249,
0.2824763357639313,
-0.16174355149269104,
0.3167787790298462,
0.848384439945221,
0.2702489495277405,
-0.03221190720796585,
-0.12304489314556122,
0.9359756708145142,
-0.6781772971153259,
-0.32173314690589905,
-0.7773997187614441,
0.49627920985221863,
-0.5716180801391602,
-0.029247969388961792,
0.8207844495773315,
0.7075026035308838,
0.7997170686721802,
0.1806689202785492,
0.7845507860183716,
0.08655774593353271,
0.12227434664964676,
-0.47895681858062744,
0.7214335203170776,
-0.513587474822998,
0.5204482078552246,
-0.22025690972805023,
-1.3230873346328735,
-0.507169246673584,
0.3437550961971283,
-0.2297433763742447,
0.022517992183566093,
0.5632684826850891,
0.7088883519172668,
-0.19791735708713531,
0.09974101185798645,
0.3126853108406067,
0.18080933392047882,
0.8231570720672607,
0.38664984703063965,
0.4551689028739929,
-0.3592199683189392,
0.5577055811882019,
-0.14427193999290466,
-0.5187810063362122,
-0.09894721955060959,
-1.1103401184082031,
-0.536517322063446,
-0.25212663412094116,
-0.26598039269447327,
-0.3360195457935333,
-0.09036868810653687,
0.8724580407142639,
0.4744548201560974,
-0.8473039269447327,
-0.3592294156551361,
0.37535223364830017,
-0.021565910428762436,
-0.2496478259563446,
-0.23824095726013184,
0.530832827091217,
-0.3796231746673584,
-0.6794211268424988,
0.1546439826488495,
0.5042824149131775,
0.03698411211371422,
-0.2940591275691986,
0.038633108139038086,
-0.13463236391544342,
0.15029846131801605,
0.6952694654464722,
0.14109283685684204,
-0.7417058944702148,
-0.3584609031677246,
0.03494615480303764,
0.13231335580348969,
0.356426864862442,
0.8159734010696411,
-0.6096336245536804,
0.37628674507141113,
0.43126603960990906,
0.5757049918174744,
0.6519699096679688,
0.07190612703561783,
0.7744870781898499,
-0.7091790437698364,
-0.018518324941396713,
0.022114822641015053,
0.3357228934764862,
0.40467214584350586,
-0.34548917412757874,
0.25844404101371765,
0.08167977631092072,
-0.45607438683509827,
-0.5375390648841858,
0.4642161726951599,
-0.8980802893638611,
-0.15343469381332397,
1.3925162553787231,
-0.45030683279037476,
-0.2427874058485031,
0.15661107003688812,
0.0007776663987897336,
0.02853246219456196,
-0.22548821568489075,
0.6981411576271057,
0.5935145616531372,
0.004877136088907719,
-0.12113683670759201,
-0.23790019750595093,
0.523658812046051,
-0.20072008669376373,
-1.048142671585083,
-0.10050061345100403,
0.5094632506370544,
0.26882749795913696,
0.04756493866443634,
0.2590748071670532,
-0.3576393127441406,
0.10090930014848709,
-0.6161190867424011,
0.1199919655919075,
-0.05181213095784187,
0.02550020068883896,
-0.39473196864128113,
0.289327472448349,
0.1382347196340561,
-0.2526862919330597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02127v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02127v1
|
LOCR: Location-Guided Transformer for Optical Character Recognition
| 2024-03-04T15:34:12 | 2024-03-04T15:34:12 |
Yu Sun, Dongzhan Zhou, Chen Lin, Conghui He, Wanli Ouyang, Han-Sen Zhong
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Academic documents are packed with texts, equations, tables, and figures,
requiring comprehensive understanding for accurate Optical Character
Recognition (OCR). While end-to-end OCR methods offer improved accuracy over
layout-based approaches, they often grapple with significant repetition issues,
especially with complex layouts in Out-Of-Domain (OOD) documents.To tackle this
issue, we propose LOCR, a model that integrates location guiding into the
transformer architecture during autoregression. We train the model on a dataset
comprising over 77M text-location pairs from 125K academic document pages,
including bounding boxes for words, tables and mathematical symbols. LOCR
adeptly handles various formatting elements and generates content in Markdown
language. It outperforms all existing methods in our test set constructed from
arXiv, as measured by edit distance, BLEU, METEOR and F-measure.LOCR also
reduces repetition frequency from 4.4% of pages to 0.5% in the arXiv dataset,
from 13.2% to 1.3% in OOD quantum physics documents and from 8.1% to 1.8% in
OOD marketing documents. Additionally, LOCR features an interactive OCR mode,
facilitating the generation of complex documents through a few location prompts
from human.
|
[
-0.25224408507347107,
-0.6173545122146606,
0.6239441633224487,
-0.35982292890548706,
-0.269334077835083,
0.01800823211669922,
0.019655602052807808,
-0.6682849526405334,
0.06524575501680374,
0.7060158848762512,
-0.05187351629137993,
-0.4809410870075226,
-0.36245855689048767,
0.4099997282028198,
-0.7120496034622192,
0.7649494409561157,
-0.4641120731830597,
0.07465577125549316,
0.17172671854496002,
-0.2371174395084381,
-0.30516090989112854,
-0.45381179451942444,
-0.47094962000846863,
-0.12747253477573395,
0.322944313287735,
0.2022562474012375,
0.38335540890693665,
0.7793309688568115,
1.0325571298599243,
0.3610903322696686,
-0.030776116997003555,
0.4955768287181854,
-0.15701834857463837,
0.10784124583005905,
-0.0735289603471756,
-0.4187564551830292,
-0.5099943280220032,
-0.18989114463329315,
1.0088322162628174,
0.5533905029296875,
-0.1764238178730011,
-0.49420198798179626,
0.2028675377368927,
0.7986196875572205,
-0.31268230080604553,
-0.21362239122390747,
-0.3907880187034607,
0.4067128598690033,
-0.11344205588102341,
-0.10273443907499313,
-0.5432538390159607,
-0.3516456186771393,
0.11094804108142853,
-0.7625524997711182,
0.5781816840171814,
0.3611212372779846,
0.7465037107467651,
0.3005801737308502,
-0.4836271107196808,
-0.390789657831192,
-0.792187511920929,
0.6490433812141418,
-0.2787843346595764,
0.7703505158424377,
0.34052181243896484,
0.4464462995529175,
-0.0820290669798851,
-0.6687612533569336,
-0.6112597584724426,
0.0794486328959465,
-0.27078163623809814,
0.2625190317630768,
-0.0098985955119133,
-0.2983546853065491,
0.48282918334007263,
0.4122290313243866,
-0.4621972143650055,
-0.08816968649625778,
-0.6188957691192627,
-0.05009504407644272,
0.3465690314769745,
0.07932812720537186,
0.11416077613830566,
0.048124805092811584,
-0.4325692355632782,
-0.20318803191184998,
-0.4135909676551819,
-0.2146035134792328,
0.20962882041931152,
0.07630038261413574,
0.20494236052036285,
0.6042996644973755,
0.22844170033931732,
0.7941471338272095,
0.48489755392074585,
-0.19066108763217926,
0.131073996424675,
-0.34986796975135803,
0.04633912071585655,
0.49069610238075256,
0.831229031085968,
-0.052670612931251526,
-0.1989409476518631,
-0.05276903882622719,
-0.39235401153564453,
-0.3387656807899475,
0.5099141597747803,
-0.6096828579902649,
0.029086599126458168,
-0.20178870856761932,
-0.44567739963531494,
-0.047704897820949554,
0.24515442550182343,
-0.799095094203949,
-0.5305097699165344,
-0.3243486285209656,
0.15971872210502625,
-0.7615648508071899,
0.5107717514038086,
0.17266398668289185,
-0.10047398507595062,
0.3506699800491333,
0.7782863974571228,
-0.7103557586669922,
-0.004757847636938095,
0.23645782470703125,
1.0589858293533325,
-0.5322824120521545,
-0.43965262174606323,
-0.5951130390167236,
0.3506351411342621,
-0.25072288513183594,
1.120005488395691,
-0.35466885566711426,
-0.7127342820167542,
-0.06929833441972733,
-0.09646429866552353,
0.018175149336457253,
-0.4932975172996521,
0.6252678632736206,
-0.7501052618026733,
0.6139130592346191,
-0.06268917769193649,
-0.3031104803085327,
-0.06324072182178497,
0.2867285907268524,
-1.0519771575927734,
1.0911504030227661,
0.28596118092536926,
-0.4325000047683716,
0.25434544682502747,
-0.8196210861206055,
-0.5870903730392456,
0.3270847797393799,
-0.33111444115638733,
-0.6251177787780762,
-0.039399344474077225,
0.1765272468328476,
-0.004322964698076248,
-0.19005116820335388,
-0.23104821145534515,
0.29708731174468994,
-0.492996484041214,
0.1335051953792572,
-0.48788538575172424,
0.3345184326171875,
0.22068144381046295,
-0.41235679388046265,
-0.5152029395103455,
-1.1751362085342407,
-0.19171826541423798,
0.08744855225086212,
-0.7629173398017883,
-0.4820817708969116,
-0.009772994555532932,
0.15394501388072968,
-0.09775115549564362,
0.5696358680725098,
-0.7866367697715759,
0.6129925847053528,
-0.22931115329265594,
0.672016978263855,
0.2847493588924408,
-0.11386536806821823,
0.723535418510437,
-0.13230903446674347,
0.3507016599178314,
-0.11182865500450134,
0.13873440027236938,
-0.366890549659729,
-0.39503762125968933,
-0.5550625324249268,
-0.3418213725090027,
0.16129527986049652,
0.5832411050796509,
-0.7738388180732727,
0.8011797070503235,
-0.31064048409461975,
-0.5010162591934204,
-0.12788154184818268,
0.022706691175699234,
0.4387738108634949,
0.8989546895027161,
0.6036366820335388,
-0.4421952962875366,
-0.35275352001190186,
-0.41052451729774475,
0.034283705055713654,
-0.03694724291563034,
0.09421231597661972,
0.14104197919368744,
0.4925432801246643,
-0.24186301231384277,
1.0529389381408691,
-0.6351640224456787,
-1.0650825500488281,
-0.15657734870910645,
0.35403838753700256,
0.18282637000083923,
0.44338688254356384,
0.33285120129585266,
-1.0706110000610352,
-0.9192308187484741,
0.3570878803730011,
-0.7747383117675781,
-0.09810199588537216,
-0.1406629979610443,
-0.17647984623908997,
0.6577906012535095,
0.6575489044189453,
-0.42213204503059387,
0.7891749739646912,
0.2746196985244751,
-0.34694704413414,
0.3002770245075226,
-0.5033512115478516,
0.41581135988235474,
-0.9647713303565979,
0.31383517384529114,
-0.1817256212234497,
-0.13454830646514893,
-0.6180709004402161,
-0.08007563650608063,
0.14985615015029907,
-0.397630512714386,
-0.17768853902816772,
0.38787201046943665,
-0.5882663726806641,
-0.1748466193675995,
-0.08452548086643219,
0.35680830478668213,
0.6053908467292786,
0.31602129340171814,
0.5200378894805908,
1.0029122829437256,
-0.25886350870132446,
-0.22373363375663757,
0.14497621357440948,
0.7631955742835999,
-0.7020314931869507,
0.9350817203521729,
-0.5836724638938904,
0.21397653222084045,
0.004840484820306301,
0.3328719735145569,
-0.9507360458374023,
-0.07566870748996735,
0.13670241832733154,
-0.31732651591300964,
0.23029200732707977,
-0.058546751737594604,
-0.601578414440155,
-0.17132943868637085,
0.0018525458872318268,
0.663698136806488,
0.4740869104862213,
-0.746839702129364,
1.2840734720230103,
0.08829688280820847,
0.12391229718923569,
-0.48112547397613525,
-0.9220097661018372,
-0.227466881275177,
0.03519083186984062,
-0.47096118330955505,
0.5427339673042297,
-0.0678609311580658,
0.1015399694442749,
-0.22826853394508362,
0.1631796956062317,
-0.24499455094337463,
-0.28974467515945435,
0.12601882219314575,
0.35568031668663025,
-0.21014542877674103,
-0.2062048763036728,
-0.16945011913776398,
-0.17643894255161285,
-0.3479459881782532,
-0.35545122623443604,
0.7406989336013794,
0.022901561111211777,
-0.7260984182357788,
-0.40466299653053284,
0.5009092092514038,
0.6338120698928833,
-0.37853994965553284,
0.35394927859306335,
0.3940289616584778,
-0.2889748513698578,
-0.14549656212329865,
-0.471680223941803,
0.2098170667886734,
-0.5426661372184753,
0.44256916642189026,
-0.1698044240474701,
-0.4401033818721771,
0.571258008480072,
0.269824355840683,
0.13429000973701477,
0.4820981025695801,
0.025213822722434998,
-0.373963862657547,
0.781973123550415,
0.4454757571220398,
0.016051150858402252,
0.7440242767333984,
-0.22770771384239197,
0.6647718548774719,
-1.0018380880355835,
-0.31458163261413574,
-0.6854588389396667,
-0.36054351925849915,
-0.012371380813419819,
-0.27106019854545593,
0.622811496257782,
0.11422561854124069,
-0.06603311002254486,
0.6606968641281128,
-0.9152603149414062,
0.7308828234672546,
0.6001846790313721,
0.2148529589176178,
0.5619350075721741,
0.4290197193622589,
-0.009350103326141834,
-0.19831490516662598,
-0.3789849579334259,
-0.4292515218257904,
0.612258791923523,
0.16902263462543488,
0.8086792230606079,
0.04681362956762314,
0.7942991256713867,
0.6017387509346008,
-0.014275122433900833,
-0.8771953582763672,
0.6020270586013794,
-0.4104207456111908,
-0.25019320845603943,
-0.575279176235199,
-0.30504846572875977,
-0.7951393723487854,
-0.07401173561811447,
0.047937970608472824,
-0.27311548590660095,
0.5990793704986572,
0.3041509985923767,
-0.49451157450675964,
0.636715829372406,
-0.4158865213394165,
0.44391369819641113,
-0.5284649133682251,
-0.16720400750637054,
0.21921208500862122,
-0.43292203545570374,
-0.4555196762084961,
-0.45324084162712097,
0.13000205159187317,
0.569675087928772,
0.09669778496026993,
0.6654513478279114,
-0.5681523084640503,
0.6127104163169861,
-0.052425920963287354,
-0.571928858757019,
0.3743700385093689,
0.11913033574819565,
0.8122458457946777,
-0.5546677112579346,
-0.27276119589805603,
0.48313722014427185,
-0.2118821144104004,
0.19450151920318604,
-0.5270728468894958,
0.5201104879379272,
-0.7416127920150757,
-0.10593916475772858,
-0.5112261772155762,
-0.44346368312835693,
0.2189895659685135,
0.7610040307044983,
0.6698241829872131,
0.6486538052558899,
-0.12142506241798401,
0.21591372787952423,
1.0940264463424683,
-0.08741602301597595,
0.3474871814250946,
0.6657121181488037,
-0.04649239033460617,
-0.7249066829681396,
0.9822168350219727,
0.23101840913295746,
0.0621216855943203,
0.792323887348175,
0.04100341722369194,
-0.2958199977874756,
-0.5048545598983765,
-0.415211945772171,
0.18117743730545044,
-0.9653373956680298,
-0.23991627991199493,
-0.49709245562553406,
-0.3003261387348175,
-0.3174380362033844,
-0.882099449634552,
-0.36775875091552734,
-0.1807732731103897,
-0.46524617075920105,
0.3594827950000763,
0.1168031170964241,
0.8824981451034546,
0.09752018004655838,
0.6165671944618225,
-0.7921731472015381,
0.25670990347862244,
0.15644992887973785,
0.2679675817489624,
-0.2091764211654663,
-0.8902353644371033,
-0.2573321759700775,
-0.3588348925113678,
-0.4099983870983124,
-0.40883827209472656,
0.6196132898330688,
0.36055317521095276,
0.23566731810569763,
0.6220657825469971,
0.050307147204875946,
0.6825304627418518,
-0.9176926016807556,
0.8109731078147888,
0.326006144285202,
-0.8971256017684937,
0.5110768675804138,
-0.21260999143123627,
0.3667471408843994,
0.6209032535552979,
0.21227745711803436,
-0.33687421679496765,
0.07015468925237656,
-0.10228247940540314,
-0.7782191038131714,
0.7218276262283325,
-0.05927668884396553,
-0.43815818428993225,
0.16861772537231445,
0.4961458742618561,
0.12398222833871841,
-0.04722614958882332,
-0.7391225695610046,
0.04022527486085892,
-0.23126354813575745,
-0.4402618110179901,
0.09737733751535416,
-0.08389674127101898,
-0.059366654604673386,
0.24664083123207092,
0.5457708239555359,
-0.19612516462802887,
0.5552959442138672,
0.6089226603507996,
-0.3173108398914337,
-0.29510697722435,
0.014267407357692719,
0.6701914668083191,
0.2664774954319,
-0.16625621914863586,
0.0005086572491563857,
0.05904928222298622,
-0.9991484880447388,
0.007266737055033445,
0.19381986558437347,
-0.3526529371738434,
0.18776684999465942,
0.47423186898231506,
0.4070951044559479,
0.06494172662496567,
-0.5959490537643433,
0.5000863671302795,
-0.1276572197675705,
-0.32644882798194885,
-0.6842190027236938,
0.01592397131025791,
-0.7631940841674805,
0.16164568066596985,
0.6130547523498535,
0.13271963596343994,
0.2882381081581116,
-0.2915276288986206,
0.12520569562911987,
0.2845742404460907,
-0.6330184936523438,
-0.04896925017237663,
0.7609867453575134,
0.1485985517501831,
-0.6269611120223999,
0.9199052453041077,
0.18829023838043213,
-0.7241893410682678,
0.5448942184448242,
0.5322564244270325,
0.6339646577835083,
-0.2743144631385803,
-0.17771674692630768,
0.3470850884914398,
0.14535148441791534,
-0.26284605264663696,
0.0781964585185051,
-0.3510233461856842,
-0.5123860836029053,
0.08170753717422485,
-0.6196070313453674,
-0.5464373230934143,
-0.2350904941558838,
-0.7258105278015137,
0.6266720294952393,
-0.45444515347480774,
0.017854953184723854,
-0.11548609286546707,
-0.07295374572277069,
-0.3010665774345398,
0.13546784222126007,
0.14429830014705658,
0.9454304575920105,
-0.35996556282043457,
0.8131636381149292,
0.558466374874115,
-0.25552183389663696,
-0.29690858721733093,
-0.06518464535474777,
-0.3537242114543915,
-0.9669229388237,
0.7984371185302734,
0.30786600708961487,
-0.48737621307373047,
-0.03191850334405899,
-0.5037655234336853,
-0.9565764665603638,
1.453263521194458,
-0.15583015978336334,
-1.0315340757369995,
-0.33554720878601074,
0.747230052947998,
0.6318826675415039,
-0.26763084530830383,
0.14991365373134613,
0.09740282595157623,
0.3169029653072357,
0.219232439994812,
-0.7306899428367615,
-0.18668462336063385,
-0.1802489310503006,
0.030831361189484596,
0.5861813426017761,
-0.6344207525253296,
0.7121706604957581,
0.010186402127146721,
-0.12031093239784241,
0.34511882066726685,
0.4633919596672058,
0.20339316129684448,
0.18492259085178375,
0.5839633941650391,
0.490759938955307,
0.5545489192008972,
-0.1407446712255478,
0.797424852848053,
-0.4390217959880829,
0.23771266639232635,
1.2293930053710938,
-0.7114769220352173,
0.8682913780212402,
0.487839013338089,
0.0836348906159401,
0.6408222317695618,
0.08780761808156967,
-0.5360531806945801,
0.7105745077133179,
-0.3331977128982544,
-0.06820559501647949,
0.03339531272649765,
0.04673346132040024,
-0.4059720039367676,
0.3536878824234009,
0.283689945936203,
-0.7464286088943481,
-0.06622357666492462,
0.16257256269454956,
-0.196549654006958,
0.10292571783065796,
-0.2778586447238922,
0.6694043278694153,
-0.08586076647043228,
-0.647682785987854,
0.28511863946914673,
-0.07054156810045242,
0.46515506505966187,
-0.9955446720123291,
-0.30037495493888855,
-0.3768611550331116,
0.5033887028694153,
-0.18786580860614777,
-0.8682996034622192,
0.14272888004779816,
-0.15355184674263,
-0.47930070757865906,
-0.4156193137168884,
0.5254455804824829,
-0.531644344329834,
-0.3437589406967163,
0.13049492239952087,
-0.1814601868391037,
0.09473946690559387,
0.10045510530471802,
-0.3183867037296295,
0.03865315020084381,
0.0655888170003891,
-0.1613910049200058,
0.4017344117164612,
0.6765051484107971,
-0.04626138135790825,
0.392301082611084,
0.5980575680732727,
-0.03599961847066879,
-0.11310236155986786,
-0.1490580141544342,
0.5807887315750122,
-0.6189727783203125,
-0.7543075084686279,
-0.4438014030456543,
0.26310214400291443,
-0.05045684054493904,
-0.46101364493370056,
0.6779090166091919,
0.6960539221763611,
0.770933210849762,
-0.09308852255344391,
0.5884349942207336,
-0.08870209008455276,
0.44873717427253723,
-0.5834792852401733,
0.8845666646957397,
-0.6824148893356323,
0.2784937918186188,
-0.0901155099272728,
-0.9214485883712769,
-0.5232393741607666,
1.0485395193099976,
-0.36248260736465454,
-0.1309153437614441,
0.8053785562515259,
0.41488271951675415,
-0.1705046147108078,
-0.11135543137788773,
0.3491664528846741,
-0.019556637853384018,
0.4401789903640747,
0.2736358046531677,
0.7448019981384277,
-0.8750407695770264,
0.8661731481552124,
-0.19160392880439758,
-0.05242761969566345,
-0.2674545347690582,
-0.7955578565597534,
-0.9160588383674622,
-0.7248797416687012,
-0.33973756432533264,
-0.4168321490287781,
-0.323761910200119,
0.675186038017273,
0.5190228819847107,
-0.7771314978599548,
-0.03785187378525734,
-0.10170295834541321,
-0.20082399249076843,
-0.05940936878323555,
-0.2585284411907196,
0.6296536326408386,
-0.062131356447935104,
-0.7384551167488098,
0.33654090762138367,
0.33473700284957886,
0.3580358922481537,
-0.19965441524982452,
0.002835123101249337,
0.08582036197185516,
-0.13083064556121826,
0.5502035617828369,
0.5499259829521179,
-0.3980480432510376,
-0.004017808008939028,
0.1585240215063095,
-0.24517537653446198,
0.4681110084056854,
0.7557598352432251,
-0.5588553547859192,
0.35318249464035034,
0.37798282504081726,
0.3412874639034271,
-0.01398640125989914,
0.2704389989376068,
0.31232839822769165,
-0.4651523232460022,
-0.1513577550649643,
0.17608678340911865,
0.6947171688079834,
0.27474552392959595,
-0.7930072546005249,
0.5824705362319946,
0.21621085703372955,
-0.8398383855819702,
-0.7995488047599792,
0.043648362159729004,
-1.1031368970870972,
-0.0009462430607527494,
0.9292271733283997,
-0.2415611445903778,
-0.45111289620399475,
-0.15173546969890594,
-0.5865259170532227,
0.0011921155964955688,
-0.6097685098648071,
1.020382285118103,
0.27307939529418945,
-0.2124321013689041,
-0.043570686131715775,
0.00166621757671237,
0.2229936569929123,
0.1533096581697464,
-0.7514205574989319,
-0.0032678977586328983,
0.6634734869003296,
-0.004917560610920191,
0.9457845687866211,
0.3797573149204254,
-0.3808785676956177,
0.21109060943126678,
-0.2083929479122162,
0.26477497816085815,
-0.13310496509075165,
-0.5051915049552917,
-0.5831772685050964,
0.28915444016456604,
-0.2647208571434021,
0.06858517974615097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02121v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02121v1
|
Leveraging Weakly Annotated Data for Hate Speech Detection in Code-Mixed Hinglish: A Feasibility-Driven Transfer Learning Approach with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-04T15:27:49 | 2024-03-04T15:27:49 |
Sargam Yadav, Abhishek Kaushik, Kevin McDaid
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has advanced the benchmark in
various Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks. However, large amounts of
labelled training data are required to train LLMs. Furthermore, data annotation
and training are computationally expensive and time-consuming. Zero and
few-shot learning have recently emerged as viable options for labelling data
using large pre-trained models. Hate speech detection in mix-code low-resource
languages is an active problem area where the use of LLMs has proven
beneficial. In this study, we have compiled a dataset of 100 YouTube comments,
and weakly labelled them for coarse and fine-grained misogyny classification in
mix-code Hinglish. Weak annotation was applied due to the labor-intensive
annotation process. Zero-shot learning, one-shot learning, and few-shot
learning and prompting approaches have then been applied to assign labels to
the comments and compare them to human-assigned labels. Out of all the
approaches, zero-shot classification using the Bidirectional Auto-Regressive
Transformers (BART) large model and few-shot prompting using Generative
Pre-trained Transformer- 3 (ChatGPT-3) achieve the best results
|
[
-0.48789897561073303,
-0.8326393365859985,
-0.011607350781559944,
0.09294237941503525,
-0.16255266964435577,
-0.13501238822937012,
-0.3921586573123932,
-0.5875412225723267,
0.1757279336452484,
0.5899081826210022,
-0.33145952224731445,
-0.42577531933784485,
-0.6526098251342773,
0.1169113963842392,
-0.4782813489437103,
1.3284022808074951,
0.18861497938632965,
0.023958668112754822,
0.255568265914917,
-0.30495062470436096,
-0.2637300193309784,
-0.5684521794319153,
-0.3376052975654602,
-0.2261735051870346,
0.7406205534934998,
0.6468062996864319,
0.6451810002326965,
0.38438349962234497,
0.3784087896347046,
0.15700292587280273,
-0.14846812188625336,
-0.06942509114742279,
-0.6714649200439453,
0.17995420098304749,
-0.09361119568347931,
-0.3280814588069916,
-0.024850882589817047,
-0.07260698825120926,
0.1643158197402954,
0.4913494884967804,
0.30516332387924194,
0.33870068192481995,
0.23146755993366241,
0.08226887136697769,
-0.7786852717399597,
0.00524082500487566,
-0.8246117830276489,
0.2422381192445755,
-0.4192899465560913,
0.03147946298122406,
-0.2616473138332367,
-0.34588924050331116,
-0.09632692486047745,
-0.2130538374185562,
0.1075889840722084,
-0.12804517149925232,
0.554810643196106,
0.30749550461769104,
-0.05059218034148216,
-0.3610822260379791,
-0.7358922958374023,
0.8876697421073914,
-0.9113219976425171,
0.1486106812953949,
0.6032106280326843,
0.13723427057266235,
0.16920726001262665,
-0.1226617619395256,
-0.5989766716957092,
-0.18195928633213043,
-0.0347125343978405,
-0.09140799194574356,
-0.2712886333465576,
0.015478030778467655,
0.26719650626182556,
0.21449978649616241,
-0.49136924743652344,
0.6378706693649292,
-0.4398423433303833,
-0.47545766830444336,
0.567844569683075,
-0.14432701468467712,
0.1154627725481987,
-0.5604287385940552,
-0.39085349440574646,
0.30477938055992126,
-0.577782154083252,
-0.2960280179977417,
0.4736657440662384,
0.8295827507972717,
-0.38958436250686646,
0.6422079801559448,
-0.14512062072753906,
0.48416727781295776,
0.06115962192416191,
-0.4115043580532074,
0.4539559483528137,
-0.11179929226636887,
-0.1649569272994995,
0.02651614136993885,
1.0192642211914062,
-0.005550090689212084,
0.6354575753211975,
-0.14491982758045197,
-0.10238436609506607,
0.33443117141723633,
0.15825927257537842,
-0.7917072772979736,
-0.1909765601158142,
-0.10332251340150833,
-0.2183883786201477,
-0.5399274230003357,
-0.5594592690467834,
-0.9938279390335083,
-0.5952920317649841,
-0.263427734375,
0.6202461123466492,
-0.27963414788246155,
-0.2345346212387085,
-0.3342612385749817,
0.15166985988616943,
0.0848698765039444,
0.3081216812133789,
-0.8375676274299622,
0.10756820440292358,
0.2356692999601364,
0.6832625269889832,
-0.3631593883037567,
-0.2543505132198334,
-0.6015627384185791,
-0.016621707007288933,
-0.16424685716629028,
0.6069378852844238,
-0.4136025309562683,
0.0035470498260110617,
0.344129353761673,
-0.1573929786682129,
0.136287122964859,
-0.7390554547309875,
0.7020328044891357,
-0.346017986536026,
-0.04751721769571304,
0.17323321104049683,
-0.18782226741313934,
-0.08499925583600998,
0.44029003381729126,
-0.36298277974128723,
1.1889944076538086,
0.27837908267974854,
-0.8458022475242615,
0.29938268661499023,
-0.24370934069156647,
-0.7014096975326538,
0.24394218623638153,
-0.05233357101678848,
-0.6220669150352478,
-0.1220448687672615,
0.09684203565120697,
0.7163745760917664,
0.09360910952091217,
0.1623416244983673,
-0.7007289528846741,
-0.5194857120513916,
0.12955376505851746,
-0.46441683173179626,
0.6049137115478516,
0.2753347158432007,
-0.7216662764549255,
-0.05781741812825203,
-0.6794735193252563,
-0.3031795620918274,
0.10639956593513489,
-0.2568550109863281,
-0.21535703539848328,
-0.2801838517189026,
0.27677929401397705,
0.45991793274879456,
-0.12550273537635803,
-0.5043447017669678,
-0.037513379007577896,
-0.337502658367157,
-0.042604606598615646,
0.7342329621315002,
0.0030681442003697157,
0.32480940222740173,
-0.20615100860595703,
0.584299623966217,
0.17156516015529633,
0.10853474587202072,
0.17456404864788055,
-0.30863556265830994,
-0.8095337152481079,
-0.21199625730514526,
0.13138897716999054,
0.5426486134529114,
-0.8810681104660034,
0.1371486932039261,
0.06272009015083313,
-0.3633149266242981,
-0.6192020177841187,
0.5172616243362427,
0.33301714062690735,
0.4691602289676666,
0.527565598487854,
-0.17813001573085785,
-0.8300517201423645,
-0.8703054785728455,
-0.12014385312795639,
-0.3291064500808716,
0.184051051735878,
0.4673721492290497,
0.48120996356010437,
-0.19311614334583282,
0.5434581637382507,
-0.2535437047481537,
-0.6563354134559631,
-0.47870123386383057,
0.43966180086135864,
0.09550248831510544,
0.20855508744716644,
0.4702688753604889,
-0.5877662897109985,
-0.7982411980628967,
-0.11003762483596802,
-0.5347964763641357,
-0.4081009030342102,
0.004851317964494228,
-0.000011660759810183663,
0.11070571839809418,
0.40660789608955383,
-0.11324059963226318,
0.41716280579566956,
0.5818371772766113,
0.18823710083961487,
0.7033281326293945,
0.5414584279060364,
0.16809162497520447,
-0.7629570960998535,
-0.24692857265472412,
0.20469503104686737,
-0.2661677300930023,
-0.6652600765228271,
-0.25523000955581665,
-0.4563421308994293,
-0.0906948521733284,
-0.8369603157043457,
0.2768097519874573,
-0.22369328141212463,
0.21977345645427704,
-0.46032217144966125,
0.1407487988471985,
-0.5750319957733154,
0.7263138890266418,
0.07543425261974335,
0.6049426198005676,
0.5603119730949402,
-0.579791247844696,
0.32702523469924927,
0.054904334247112274,
0.027027364820241928,
0.559455394744873,
-0.22412417829036713,
0.2295774519443512,
-0.07725060731172562,
-0.23317159712314606,
-0.888308048248291,
-0.2786182761192322,
0.4157055914402008,
-0.40476498007774353,
0.21721433103084564,
-0.8332746624946594,
-0.4641893804073334,
-0.2290305495262146,
-0.3856312334537506,
0.3889632523059845,
0.5102047324180603,
-0.5533651113510132,
0.1911846250295639,
0.5347005724906921,
-0.27943533658981323,
-0.4221401810646057,
-0.9455095529556274,
0.03728499263525009,
-0.40504908561706543,
-0.2318984717130661,
0.046399228274822235,
-0.007158048450946808,
-0.11690516024827957,
-0.11627981811761856,
0.19589932262897491,
-0.3049655556678772,
-0.020781898871064186,
0.3675239682197571,
0.17550453543663025,
-0.3429930806159973,
-0.09039168804883957,
-0.3155130445957184,
0.15804900228977203,
-0.05844023823738098,
0.029608339071273804,
0.34175148606300354,
0.05611853674054146,
-0.11356810480356216,
-0.1824699342250824,
0.2843191623687744,
0.40256309509277344,
0.17871707677841187,
0.5748187303543091,
0.9381253719329834,
-0.31855207681655884,
-0.6080279350280762,
-0.43640169501304626,
-0.06693202257156372,
-0.3227963447570801,
0.3859725892543793,
-0.03909379616379738,
-1.1574909687042236,
0.23378680646419525,
0.0840701162815094,
-0.21901606023311615,
0.2719210088253021,
0.798995852470398,
-0.13486038148403168,
0.6864357590675354,
0.5574992299079895,
-0.5665371417999268,
0.5812313556671143,
0.07342752069234848,
0.2550288140773773,
-0.2904861569404602,
0.1429695188999176,
-0.6008394956588745,
-0.2097778171300888,
-0.7571918368339539,
-0.4334079623222351,
0.3470176160335541,
0.10216180235147476,
-0.20987257361412048,
0.4813157021999359,
-0.33555641770362854,
0.4199650287628174,
0.20068752765655518,
-0.016004566103219986,
0.15053586661815643,
0.17979858815670013,
0.18207009136676788,
-0.38369473814964294,
-0.5473824739456177,
-0.23249691724777222,
1.0901546478271484,
0.3706001043319702,
0.9390363693237305,
0.1895969808101654,
0.7206276059150696,
0.5464306473731995,
0.5121458768844604,
-1.0592236518859863,
0.3854009807109833,
-0.18920661509037018,
-0.5865521430969238,
-0.04653550684452057,
-0.503354549407959,
-0.5809986591339111,
0.21459193527698517,
-0.42512792348861694,
-0.7565780878067017,
0.003977712709456682,
0.17129983007907867,
-0.2611045241355896,
0.45002281665802,
-0.7280017137527466,
0.774106502532959,
-0.0990247055888176,
-0.6723520159721375,
0.08400087058544159,
-0.5387938022613525,
0.5476236939430237,
-0.15399427711963654,
0.48853325843811035,
-0.11694154143333435,
0.3374031186103821,
0.8657570481300354,
-0.1590115875005722,
1.2218613624572754,
-0.28203535079956055,
-0.12055384367704391,
0.39846569299697876,
0.14202125370502472,
0.3784216642379761,
-0.3150639832019806,
0.013886190950870514,
0.16809934377670288,
-0.49941134452819824,
-0.22154423594474792,
-0.2783709764480591,
0.5901153087615967,
-0.5454487204551697,
-0.22147516906261444,
-0.2340444177389145,
-0.32649001479148865,
-0.35444095730781555,
0.1588834673166275,
0.16742269694805145,
0.21499131619930267,
0.07256419211626053,
0.0669957846403122,
0.5348907113075256,
-0.06580719351768494,
0.2657197117805481,
0.3742767572402954,
-0.24264311790466309,
-0.2727131247520447,
0.9688873887062073,
0.13598167896270752,
0.23940972983837128,
-0.0024497047998011112,
0.23987461626529694,
-0.0639762207865715,
-0.7289361357688904,
-0.36153778433799744,
0.26245033740997314,
-0.5895086526870728,
-0.44148558378219604,
-0.4734119176864624,
-0.31627362966537476,
-0.37626346945762634,
-0.1697726994752884,
-0.5043079853057861,
-0.07509005069732666,
-0.25752827525138855,
0.0830892026424408,
0.22552144527435303,
0.8140816688537598,
-0.17282730340957642,
0.3818480670452118,
-0.38960081338882446,
0.7057978510856628,
0.22715052962303162,
0.3881934881210327,
-0.029025623574852943,
-1.0047765970230103,
-0.5164971947669983,
-0.009015030227601528,
-0.25600939989089966,
-1.1775952577590942,
0.30997979640960693,
-0.046409305185079575,
0.12999698519706726,
0.24986037611961365,
0.1911286860704422,
0.6691204905509949,
-0.1194489598274231,
0.6599235534667969,
0.13323974609375,
-0.6292916536331177,
0.5106066465377808,
-0.2838820219039917,
-0.009725896641612053,
0.7661880254745483,
0.6558204889297485,
-0.4116043746471405,
-0.6124370098114014,
-0.47884601354599,
-0.8570511937141418,
0.8465594053268433,
0.18069499731063843,
0.2132347673177719,
-0.005719889421015978,
-0.1438264697790146,
0.2366412729024887,
0.08082010596990585,
-1.2298755645751953,
-0.5051741600036621,
-0.09090915322303772,
-0.20143280923366547,
0.21823650598526,
-0.2917574942111969,
0.11613607406616211,
-0.3325808346271515,
0.8723106980323792,
-0.22331547737121582,
-0.0685068666934967,
-0.15940998494625092,
-0.50422203540802,
-0.025023290887475014,
0.753790020942688,
0.21150583028793335,
0.05291476845741272,
-0.29843586683273315,
0.3746260702610016,
0.19725407660007477,
-0.4916839003562927,
0.25724467635154724,
-0.04976702108979225,
-0.4220501184463501,
0.21810807287693024,
0.314483106136322,
0.7886855602264404,
0.31358975172042847,
-0.4538377821445465,
0.7789430022239685,
0.4290391504764557,
-0.22577081620693207,
-0.04323823004961014,
-0.06056780368089676,
-0.1963273286819458,
0.015300914645195007,
0.12524791061878204,
0.07778861373662949,
0.14998626708984375,
-0.47965681552886963,
0.2581074833869934,
0.18184533715248108,
-0.6073281764984131,
-0.2927539646625519,
0.41466885805130005,
0.11316058784723282,
-0.06973996758460999,
0.2858734726905823,
-0.5022821426391602,
-0.7871566414833069,
0.14375536143779755,
0.5823298692703247,
0.7520126700401306,
-0.1311081200838089,
0.4179747998714447,
0.44750356674194336,
0.2814512550830841,
0.1781701147556305,
-0.11970582604408264,
-0.32386791706085205,
-0.7555994987487793,
-0.6013051867485046,
-0.720069169998169,
-0.3746439218521118,
0.5929833650588989,
-0.6086591482162476,
0.42635080218315125,
-0.5003971457481384,
0.08328815549612045,
0.12141995131969452,
-0.16450785100460052,
-0.6495129466056824,
0.13246245682239532,
0.6817769408226013,
0.2864176034927368,
-1.3127880096435547,
0.6671444773674011,
0.38664501905441284,
-0.6072474718093872,
-0.7690885066986084,
0.01803179457783699,
0.2567182183265686,
-0.7705392241477966,
0.8127996921539307,
0.1498854160308838,
-0.20569387078285217,
-0.1370367705821991,
-0.7892844080924988,
-0.3653429448604584,
0.08179345726966858,
0.38302814960479736,
-0.48990681767463684,
0.3849150538444519,
0.2631183862686157,
0.5833836793899536,
-0.03592517971992493,
0.2642747163772583,
0.5298482179641724,
0.2515935003757477,
0.2984679639339447,
-0.8522579669952393,
-0.14388997852802277,
-0.06746399402618408,
-0.42834118008613586,
0.12589213252067566,
-0.378861665725708,
0.5701836347579956,
0.005228128749877214,
-0.08662696182727814,
-0.2760237455368042,
0.6396811008453369,
-0.0013333738315850496,
0.2537022531032562,
0.5818767547607422,
0.49128487706184387,
0.2676112949848175,
0.2183663249015808,
0.5473306179046631,
0.290645033121109,
0.4480683505535126,
1.1523323059082031,
-0.3295658826828003,
0.9130911827087402,
0.4743066132068634,
-0.41405564546585083,
0.2880803644657135,
0.24210992455482483,
-0.10869190096855164,
0.2746317386627197,
0.3431187570095062,
-0.2903089225292206,
-0.10731005668640137,
-0.5228449702262878,
-0.033982742577791214,
0.5459576845169067,
0.1549067497253418,
-0.09266073256731033,
-0.4458397626876831,
0.2152048945426941,
0.4029293954372406,
0.09296517819166183,
-0.39894378185272217,
0.938901424407959,
0.05578364059329033,
-0.3752462863922119,
0.836007833480835,
-0.11748203635215759,
1.3677836656570435,
-0.4880209267139435,
-0.03249902278184891,
-0.18381504714488983,
-0.033978171646595,
-0.5964263677597046,
-0.7650758624076843,
0.3343762457370758,
0.5774227976799011,
-0.15186874568462372,
-0.12261632084846497,
0.7777293920516968,
-0.6909269690513611,
-0.2790510952472687,
0.4418414831161499,
0.2707674205303192,
0.33439356088638306,
-0.037242352962493896,
-0.65785813331604,
0.1465766429901123,
0.19859978556632996,
0.1128433346748352,
0.4808471202850342,
0.29085874557495117,
0.011795646511018276,
0.17862866818904877,
0.5400864481925964,
0.4803120493888855,
0.25430139899253845,
0.41032421588897705,
0.8032649159431458,
-0.5943453311920166,
-0.24854961037635803,
-0.8287245035171509,
0.2258618324995041,
0.18168063461780548,
-0.2398315966129303,
0.9381923675537109,
0.5762842297554016,
1.0556594133377075,
-0.06957484781742096,
0.9975776672363281,
-0.08672796189785004,
0.7146964073181152,
-0.4285358488559723,
0.4043341875076294,
-0.3124173581600189,
0.10519533604383469,
-0.6402490735054016,
-0.6909385323524475,
-0.3982025384902954,
0.4824413061141968,
-0.3224557936191559,
0.0011926207225769758,
0.4529561996459961,
0.9128496050834656,
-0.2984674572944641,
-0.18816639482975006,
0.45589154958724976,
0.5295239090919495,
0.12560640275478363,
0.5511069297790527,
0.8496598601341248,
-0.4087144732475281,
0.798338770866394,
-0.4945654571056366,
-0.05452922359108925,
-0.33946800231933594,
-0.5977792739868164,
-0.8641858696937561,
-0.13802263140678406,
-0.5493830442428589,
-0.5637427568435669,
-0.09309183061122894,
0.8197823762893677,
0.7611303925514221,
-0.9393346905708313,
-0.17518681287765503,
0.2505375146865845,
0.23729197680950165,
0.18938378989696503,
-0.3204256296157837,
0.13516570627689362,
-0.38882917165756226,
-0.5821239948272705,
0.36565399169921875,
0.28142568469047546,
0.12403859198093414,
-0.23260773718357086,
-0.10824757814407349,
-0.44039517641067505,
-0.28108370304107666,
0.5272341370582581,
0.5124045610427856,
-0.3569179177284241,
-0.294719934463501,
-0.4852575361728668,
-0.2082282304763794,
0.15725192427635193,
0.6957230567932129,
-0.6663424968719482,
0.26149827241897583,
0.3239663243293762,
0.7944373488426208,
0.6970791220664978,
0.08351138234138489,
-0.04966337978839874,
-0.9444843530654907,
0.4711669385433197,
0.441936194896698,
0.11238270998001099,
0.49047574400901794,
-0.22155000269412994,
0.25140655040740967,
0.5093048214912415,
-0.324030339717865,
-0.8908481597900391,
0.19299352169036865,
-0.9497149586677551,
-0.13562250137329102,
1.3750683069229126,
0.06621478497982025,
-0.3302880525588989,
-0.4052524268627167,
-0.22081272304058075,
0.20349861681461334,
-0.3445463478565216,
0.4850304424762726,
0.5431830286979675,
-0.14506898820400238,
-0.18786482512950897,
-0.5750125646591187,
0.5682970285415649,
0.531121015548706,
-0.7623591423034668,
0.07034499943256378,
0.5278128981590271,
0.21966032683849335,
0.034277163445949554,
0.6324084997177124,
-0.10558562725782394,
0.13873593509197235,
-0.028624149039387703,
0.12031085044145584,
0.11108391731977463,
-0.37715721130371094,
-0.5644289255142212,
0.4180132746696472,
0.11072590202093124,
-0.19097380340099335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02370v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02370v1
|
adaptMLLM: Fine-Tuning Multilingual Language Models on Low-Resource Languages with Integrated LLM Playgrounds
| 2024-03-04T14:49:18 | 2024-03-04T14:49:18 |
Séamus Lankford, Haithem Afli, Andy Way
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advent of Multilingual Language Models (MLLMs) and Large Language Models
has spawned innovation in many areas of natural language processing. Despite
the exciting potential of this technology, its impact on developing
high-quality Machine Translation (MT) outputs for low-resource languages
remains relatively under-explored. Furthermore, an open-source application,
dedicated to both fine-tuning MLLMs and managing the complete MT workflow for
low-resources languages, remains unavailable. We aim to address these
imbalances through the development of adaptMLLM, which streamlines all
processes involved in the fine-tuning of MLLMs for MT. This open-source
application is tailored for developers, translators, and users who are engaged
in MT. An intuitive interface allows for easy customisation of hyperparameters,
and the application offers a range of metrics for model evaluation and the
capability to deploy models as a translation service directly within the
application. As a multilingual tool, we used adaptMLLM to fine-tune models for
two low-resource language pairs: English to Irish (EN$\leftrightarrow$GA) and
English to Marathi (EN$\leftrightarrow$MR). Compared with baselines from the
LoResMT2021 Shared Task, the adaptMLLM system demonstrated significant
improvements. In the EN$\rightarrow$GA direction, an improvement of 5.2 BLEU
points was observed and an increase of 40.5 BLEU points was recorded in the
GA$\rightarrow$EN direction. Significant improvements in the translation
performance of the EN$\leftrightarrow$MR pair were also observed notably in the
MR$\rightarrow$EN direction with an increase of 21.3 BLEU points. Finally, a
fine-grained human evaluation of the MLLM output on the EN$\rightarrow$GA pair
was conducted using the Multidimensional Quality Metrics and Scalar Quality
Metrics error taxonomies. The application and models are freely available.
|
[
-0.3497888743877411,
-0.6873383522033691,
0.25741711258888245,
0.38346654176712036,
-0.241968035697937,
-0.015591645613312721,
-0.5693753361701965,
-0.40662381052970886,
0.016243813559412956,
0.6136757135391235,
-0.5071499943733215,
-0.5349797010421753,
-0.5742254853248596,
0.14164726436138153,
-0.0396425724029541,
0.9883925318717957,
-0.27221837639808655,
0.24137276411056519,
-0.10155664384365082,
-0.7875456213951111,
-0.6214285492897034,
-0.36036932468414307,
-0.5918558835983276,
-0.2592824399471283,
0.5740084052085876,
0.552871823310852,
0.7361080646514893,
0.5356515049934387,
0.6819482445716858,
0.188609316945076,
-0.1583763062953949,
0.6178826093673706,
-0.5816307067871094,
0.24615468084812164,
-0.24112729728221893,
-0.33928149938583374,
-0.6355440020561218,
-0.12811537086963654,
0.5822900533676147,
0.5923522710800171,
-0.23640096187591553,
0.6459253430366516,
0.3497784435749054,
0.6871530413627625,
-0.6258720755577087,
0.012804927304387093,
-0.7182917594909668,
-0.057005807757377625,
-0.3382878303527832,
-0.32884448766708374,
-0.43465447425842285,
-0.19168725609779358,
-0.37670600414276123,
-0.5384242534637451,
-0.05733304098248482,
0.24358756840229034,
0.6010042428970337,
0.3117072284221649,
-0.23581869900226593,
-0.15502621233463287,
-0.8551679849624634,
1.0512423515319824,
-0.961492121219635,
0.4884397089481354,
0.28279343247413635,
0.4000684320926666,
-0.15902502834796906,
-0.5101740956306458,
-0.3995301127433777,
-0.1876705437898636,
-0.22318421304225922,
0.12883590161800385,
-0.05976809561252594,
-0.1267189085483551,
0.10930240899324417,
0.318255215883255,
-0.7268781661987305,
0.29642748832702637,
-0.43852126598358154,
0.025702064856886864,
0.5942920446395874,
0.5433550477027893,
0.2994600534439087,
0.2708836495876312,
-0.1556485891342163,
0.01273503340780735,
-0.7251258492469788,
0.034948479384183884,
0.20815181732177734,
0.7551953792572021,
-0.2533807158470154,
0.7943577766418457,
-0.11958327889442444,
0.968864917755127,
-0.22265779972076416,
-0.19906973838806152,
0.18149416148662567,
-0.6170052289962769,
-0.209117129445076,
-0.13947920501232147,
0.7033477425575256,
0.4506920278072357,
0.04733336344361305,
0.021336348727345467,
-0.5290089249610901,
-0.16005495190620422,
-0.060464855283498764,
-0.6966719627380371,
-0.0849762037396431,
-0.030827049165964127,
-0.5585725903511047,
-0.010799857787787914,
-0.45898008346557617,
-0.6251821517944336,
-0.45874327421188354,
-0.4837038218975067,
0.4287004768848419,
-0.39439132809638977,
-0.36300021409988403,
0.07220076024532318,
0.11207852512598038,
0.05951095372438431,
0.469576895236969,
-0.7375693321228027,
0.17215779423713684,
0.4328092336654663,
1.0692247152328491,
-0.43723538517951965,
-0.508441150188446,
-0.8290029764175415,
0.16242530941963196,
-0.16130787134170532,
0.6182225942611694,
-0.517742395401001,
-0.30821529030799866,
-0.06760869175195694,
0.07414868474006653,
-0.24456477165222168,
-0.7120899558067322,
0.6793690919876099,
-0.3585565686225891,
0.1468118280172348,
0.1835094392299652,
-0.25130051374435425,
-0.08511670678853989,
0.49108633399009705,
-0.45269015431404114,
1.1539108753204346,
0.07979755848646164,
-0.5403768420219421,
0.24017870426177979,
-0.9917060136795044,
-0.39017632603645325,
0.05529867485165596,
0.3371700048446655,
-0.2644801139831543,
0.21583697199821472,
0.21412187814712524,
0.18823857605457306,
-0.4622618556022644,
0.04480959102511406,
-0.39065876603126526,
-0.27752721309661865,
-0.005787691567093134,
-0.668067991733551,
0.7816872596740723,
0.44974786043167114,
0.03641826659440994,
0.5470261573791504,
-0.7901244759559631,
0.1582919806241989,
0.05583658069372177,
-0.6246539950370789,
-0.4552483558654785,
-0.2443418651819229,
0.4913034737110138,
0.47107458114624023,
0.3231278657913208,
-0.39545854926109314,
0.05294746905565262,
-0.3563540279865265,
0.3707611560821533,
0.5394039154052734,
-0.3298169672489166,
0.5173202753067017,
-0.15496082603931427,
0.5001550316810608,
0.3149006962776184,
0.4508436322212219,
-0.03136402741074562,
-0.6148685216903687,
-0.7092710137367249,
-0.283628910779953,
0.1964835375547409,
0.5470640659332275,
-0.6601428985595703,
0.1301691085100174,
-0.2310316264629364,
-0.4757750630378723,
-1.2694679498672485,
0.48003390431404114,
0.31997716426849365,
0.493640661239624,
0.5788608193397522,
-0.2036423236131668,
-0.37149858474731445,
-0.872996985912323,
-0.48028093576431274,
0.06117565557360649,
-0.02492421492934227,
0.2601874768733978,
0.05535270646214485,
-0.43353360891342163,
0.6931723952293396,
-0.30563491582870483,
-0.40569910407066345,
-0.22767110168933868,
-0.10193157941102982,
0.48636922240257263,
0.5154675245285034,
0.6314745545387268,
-0.8358617424964905,
-0.7893319129943848,
0.4336444139480591,
-0.4476645588874817,
-0.17425985634326935,
0.32671889662742615,
-0.27663159370422363,
0.4185555875301361,
0.2593090832233429,
-0.4864791929721832,
0.15090712904930115,
0.9465374946594238,
-0.5517152547836304,
0.6192920207977295,
-0.5968191027641296,
0.02465352788567543,
-1.0294735431671143,
0.25279587507247925,
-0.14613427221775055,
-0.36942532658576965,
-0.6090143322944641,
0.39353683590888977,
0.10403048247098923,
-0.08015359938144684,
-0.7261494994163513,
0.84026700258255,
-0.26593589782714844,
-0.0918455421924591,
-0.20965445041656494,
0.24045315384864807,
0.1525985598564148,
0.3404441475868225,
-0.3120206594467163,
0.9653366208076477,
0.2532040774822235,
-0.45165586471557617,
0.34682533144950867,
0.06217227876186371,
-0.14733915030956268,
0.6393614411354065,
-0.22775258123874664,
0.059097930788993835,
0.04310154542326927,
-0.25541216135025024,
-0.652766227722168,
0.0034202393144369125,
0.3095128536224365,
-0.2392573207616806,
0.16947969794273376,
-0.23523271083831787,
-0.5139232873916626,
-0.15011532604694366,
-0.0717792734503746,
0.28431007266044617,
0.3936106562614441,
-0.5551164746284485,
0.6010985970497131,
0.3462359607219696,
-0.1769934892654419,
-0.4071199893951416,
-0.7117704749107361,
0.16935870051383972,
-0.18597467243671417,
-0.5386130213737488,
-0.010698999278247356,
-0.3936820924282074,
-0.400337815284729,
0.24745586514472961,
0.21463967859745026,
-0.2922954857349396,
0.11758358031511307,
-0.04813789948821068,
0.2795644700527191,
-0.581375002861023,
0.004302024841308594,
0.10003355145454407,
-0.10754448175430298,
-0.4178970158100128,
-0.44741034507751465,
0.48225122690200806,
-0.2456587851047516,
-0.4609404504299164,
-0.021997671574354172,
0.2672750651836395,
0.7504447102546692,
-0.501711905002594,
1.0562158823013306,
1.0271974802017212,
-0.2261466085910797,
-0.04304739832878113,
-0.35921114683151245,
0.11150884628295898,
-0.40444448590278625,
0.30078014731407166,
-0.41175511479377747,
-0.8766947388648987,
0.5095517039299011,
0.08644088357686996,
0.34714147448539734,
0.5403493642807007,
0.8559079766273499,
0.05456527695059776,
1.1057430505752563,
0.6573195457458496,
0.06816954165697098,
0.3579608201980591,
0.03186285123229027,
0.11216820776462555,
-0.9159883856773376,
0.019348327070474625,
-0.45843306183815,
-0.4070574939250946,
-0.5993288159370422,
-0.558550238609314,
0.27828001976013184,
0.281223326921463,
-0.029544023796916008,
0.32895517349243164,
-0.3504510521888733,
0.34759530425071716,
0.6600690484046936,
-0.09169450402259827,
0.6040636897087097,
-0.10179468989372253,
-0.3748668134212494,
-0.24961136281490326,
-0.797042191028595,
-0.6764805912971497,
0.9577920436859131,
0.14152371883392334,
0.7996344566345215,
0.40328988432884216,
0.47312241792678833,
0.18344363570213318,
0.5789134502410889,
-0.70867520570755,
0.342874139547348,
-0.45433229207992554,
-0.46190518140792847,
-0.4442996680736542,
-0.4430146813392639,
-0.7729820013046265,
0.48140138387680054,
-0.32478421926498413,
-0.38606786727905273,
-0.0855865627527237,
0.39115238189697266,
-0.19237633049488068,
0.3637021780014038,
-0.9514820575714111,
0.988772451877594,
-0.3697783946990967,
-0.6064478158950806,
-0.38298919796943665,
-0.32523801922798157,
0.33174803853034973,
-0.28125301003456116,
0.4758894145488739,
-0.37852320075035095,
0.14475952088832855,
0.26667675375938416,
-0.14087677001953125,
0.5384092330932617,
-0.23237501084804535,
-0.27546408772468567,
0.07756897807121277,
0.26675793528556824,
0.5355073809623718,
-0.015950562432408333,
-0.3832021653652191,
0.22512374818325043,
0.06699327379465103,
-0.4318977892398834,
-0.5221922993659973,
1.024746060371399,
-0.5990700125694275,
-0.5693556666374207,
0.09127780795097351,
-1.025051236152649,
-0.16032825410366058,
0.45425695180892944,
0.0006832589861005545,
0.1686534285545349,
-0.12576375901699066,
0.0728972926735878,
0.29118940234184265,
-0.4228861927986145,
0.3046855032444,
0.8653770685195923,
-0.46969708800315857,
-0.33651575446128845,
0.9925657510757446,
0.08223340660333633,
0.3720623552799225,
0.22718122601509094,
0.18474596738815308,
-0.25959113240242004,
-0.7181679606437683,
-0.8541654348373413,
0.061020080000162125,
-0.5669371485710144,
-0.19929192960262299,
-0.39144405722618103,
-0.12921465933322906,
-0.2544427812099457,
0.04474225640296936,
-0.4065319895744324,
-0.5353764295578003,
-0.19759272038936615,
0.2579149305820465,
0.2918166220188141,
0.6346972584724426,
0.02816329151391983,
0.09388400614261627,
-1.1203776597976685,
0.16781741380691528,
-0.05003039911389351,
0.529330313205719,
-0.15041835606098175,
-0.7295949459075928,
-0.7388885021209717,
0.23970629274845123,
-0.3481296896934509,
-0.292284220457077,
0.5263630151748657,
0.28470587730407715,
0.45703741908073425,
0.12554866075515747,
0.08178210258483887,
0.8644769191741943,
-0.7951678037643433,
0.6262757778167725,
0.05399902164936066,
-0.6120625734329224,
0.41727280616760254,
-0.1867149919271469,
0.40468281507492065,
0.45494380593299866,
-0.08650050312280655,
-0.7690020203590393,
-0.5694634318351746,
-0.14934343099594116,
-0.7526856660842896,
0.7683314681053162,
0.1947755068540573,
0.012043630704283714,
0.3378466069698334,
0.08467666804790497,
0.31364017724990845,
0.028382882475852966,
-0.5792217254638672,
-0.22984826564788818,
0.05071920156478882,
-0.4644640386104584,
-0.4268719553947449,
-0.1369306445121765,
-0.19471973180770874,
-0.26098692417144775,
0.649127185344696,
-0.14560405910015106,
-0.1532105654478073,
-0.1162094995379448,
-0.4457659125328064,
-0.34109440445899963,
0.3763537108898163,
0.8511269688606262,
0.7246184945106506,
-0.2385367751121521,
0.25240832567214966,
0.445167601108551,
-0.42324042320251465,
0.12168362736701965,
0.14510874450206757,
-0.303909033536911,
0.1582338511943817,
0.3398602604866028,
0.9524381160736084,
0.12148711085319519,
-0.6726111769676208,
0.17334209382534027,
-0.16780707240104675,
0.19807648658752441,
0.021234776824712753,
0.11849378794431686,
0.21514678001403809,
0.3287738859653473,
0.05602622032165527,
0.45959049463272095,
-0.03713333234190941,
-0.24793121218681335,
-0.0346323698759079,
0.4296170473098755,
-0.5474976897239685,
-0.5004404187202454,
0.8005439043045044,
0.35917603969573975,
-0.6035647392272949,
0.3273981213569641,
-0.07415152341127396,
-0.1159716546535492,
0.2266933172941208,
0.7904081344604492,
0.7916238903999329,
-0.3152041733264923,
-0.09497274458408356,
0.3344065546989441,
0.5484998226165771,
0.002396252704784274,
0.16457657516002655,
0.20880302786827087,
-0.5921915769577026,
-0.5858592987060547,
-0.979607343673706,
-0.3461802303791046,
0.04173539578914642,
-0.6026384830474854,
0.45557934045791626,
0.01019938476383686,
-0.051105134189128876,
-0.3408237099647522,
-0.23148560523986816,
-0.8514556288719177,
-0.1337401419878006,
0.009623239748179913,
1.2237763404846191,
-0.754353404045105,
0.9802263975143433,
1.0370430946350098,
-0.2045585662126541,
-0.41920170187950134,
-0.09344283491373062,
-0.04716792330145836,
-0.9053769111633301,
0.6166213154792786,
-0.014823400415480137,
-0.20128053426742554,
0.2043444812297821,
-0.0691165030002594,
-0.7499377727508545,
0.9889776706695557,
0.598876953125,
-0.7023560404777527,
0.20764225721359253,
0.3100115954875946,
0.6522277593612671,
-0.32819169759750366,
0.08382707834243774,
0.4573240876197815,
0.6260066032409668,
-0.21775254607200623,
-1.2063754796981812,
-0.12667690217494965,
-0.1854800581932068,
0.019551869481801987,
0.41979891061782837,
-0.41718339920043945,
0.6796265840530396,
-0.180450439453125,
-0.052127186208963394,
-0.0026888204738497734,
0.27012184262275696,
0.3008367121219635,
0.3753978908061981,
0.29835259914398193,
0.5289485454559326,
0.6559655666351318,
0.10352643579244614,
0.9129959940910339,
-0.5363110303878784,
0.4409487545490265,
1.1525166034698486,
-0.352035254240036,
1.0524665117263794,
0.7422211170196533,
-0.1678771674633026,
0.08619793504476547,
0.4149167239665985,
0.3184516429901123,
0.493438720703125,
-0.08800826966762543,
-0.20369520783424377,
-0.18530510365962982,
-0.28195735812187195,
-0.1981118768453598,
0.2414179891347885,
0.46056920289993286,
-0.23170630633831024,
-0.307813435792923,
0.23402941226959229,
-0.18215468525886536,
0.16035844385623932,
-0.4333234131336212,
0.6394190788269043,
0.11419961601495743,
-0.47921258211135864,
0.6141912341117859,
0.24261586368083954,
0.7233143448829651,
-0.47108981013298035,
-0.03955767676234245,
-0.4906439185142517,
0.5123457908630371,
-0.09992565214633942,
-0.8788484930992126,
0.5751956701278687,
0.1327383667230606,
-0.2570532262325287,
-0.3672446608543396,
0.7267425060272217,
-0.8370290994644165,
-0.6614385843276978,
0.6227164268493652,
0.6222611665725708,
-0.015482796356081963,
0.10836713016033173,
-0.760104775428772,
0.027374276891350746,
-0.12889628112316132,
-0.13265521824359894,
0.3991721272468567,
0.6045264005661011,
-0.08064301311969757,
0.6482123136520386,
0.7804479002952576,
0.4001936912536621,
0.19702650606632233,
0.1032756045460701,
0.6779623031616211,
-0.5508924126625061,
-0.2570243775844574,
-0.9873639941215515,
0.5637305378913879,
0.1010415181517601,
-0.31881850957870483,
0.877438485622406,
0.7281064987182617,
0.8770168423652649,
-0.25531116127967834,
0.5498483777046204,
0.11716308444738388,
0.5726696252822876,
-0.614000678062439,
0.9140229821205139,
-0.8005916476249695,
0.1829887330532074,
0.07300399243831635,
-1.1073601245880127,
-0.558911144733429,
0.1263963282108307,
-0.00034501816844567657,
-0.44999954104423523,
0.36920490860939026,
0.8076903820037842,
-0.4207308888435364,
-0.49995315074920654,
0.6399569511413574,
0.2782200574874878,
0.34370657801628113,
0.38207578659057617,
0.7140176892280579,
-0.28097227215766907,
0.7629748582839966,
0.04063072428107262,
-0.13335254788398743,
-0.46496278047561646,
-0.6982499957084656,
-0.6619705557823181,
-0.4250304698944092,
0.09334119409322739,
-0.24321162700653076,
0.028501909226179123,
1.0952609777450562,
0.5172820687294006,
-0.9824570417404175,
-0.42779091000556946,
0.2375984787940979,
0.1748850792646408,
-0.3335510194301605,
-0.20987078547477722,
0.033093858510255814,
-0.5039888620376587,
-0.7646543979644775,
0.4745704233646393,
0.7035868167877197,
-0.026070982217788696,
-0.32039323449134827,
-0.5626571774482727,
-0.17189477384090424,
-0.1395401656627655,
0.8128233551979065,
0.06853596866130829,
-0.844834566116333,
-0.06883925944566727,
0.030074968934059143,
-0.2750559449195862,
0.13011832535266876,
0.6177418231964111,
-0.32056760787963867,
0.5862442255020142,
0.29241275787353516,
0.5873197317123413,
0.32880428433418274,
-0.3168177902698517,
0.6674907207489014,
-0.8351482152938843,
0.45911791920661926,
0.12378138303756714,
0.44345927238464355,
0.3958702087402344,
-0.1217474415898323,
0.5604940056800842,
0.0808693990111351,
-0.43299978971481323,
-1.0200910568237305,
0.218824565410614,
-0.48299673199653625,
-0.011193229816854,
0.9945559501647949,
-0.15892183780670166,
-0.13793590664863586,
-0.07463780790567398,
-0.48517125844955444,
0.2387837916612625,
-0.10204394161701202,
0.5360131859779358,
0.7695971727371216,
0.008989090099930763,
-0.24618206918239594,
-0.7752591371536255,
0.2983333468437195,
0.4204612970352173,
-0.707569420337677,
0.259918212890625,
0.2565401792526245,
0.06849592924118042,
0.08472084254026413,
0.4535352289676666,
-0.06088368594646454,
0.020339278504252434,
-0.3809625506401062,
0.15225204825401306,
-0.1956234872341156,
-0.024926386773586273,
-0.5150054693222046,
-0.1257639080286026,
0.49634256958961487,
-0.14238695800304413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02090v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02090v3
|
Modeling Multimodal Social Interactions: New Challenges and Baselines with Densely Aligned Representations
| 2024-03-04T14:46:58 | 2024-04-29T12:16:04 |
Sangmin Lee, Bolin Lai, Fiona Ryan, Bikram Boote, James M. Rehg
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Understanding social interactions involving both verbal and non-verbal cues
is essential for effectively interpreting social situations. However, most
prior works on multimodal social cues focus predominantly on single-person
behaviors or rely on holistic visual representations that are not aligned to
utterances in multi-party environments. Consequently, they are limited in
modeling the intricate dynamics of multi-party interactions. In this paper, we
introduce three new challenging tasks to model the fine-grained dynamics
between multiple people: speaking target identification, pronoun coreference
resolution, and mentioned player prediction. We contribute extensive data
annotations to curate these new challenges in social deduction game settings.
Furthermore, we propose a novel multimodal baseline that leverages densely
aligned language-visual representations by synchronizing visual features with
their corresponding utterances. This facilitates concurrently capturing verbal
and non-verbal cues pertinent to social reasoning. Experiments demonstrate the
effectiveness of the proposed approach with densely aligned multimodal
representations in modeling fine-grained social interactions. Project website:
https://sangmin-git.github.io/projects/MMSI.
|
[
-0.34663262963294983,
-1.0892904996871948,
0.5520642995834351,
0.23719486594200134,
0.051160406321287155,
0.07415187358856201,
-0.41686010360717773,
-0.42417630553245544,
0.2203838974237442,
0.2392062097787857,
-0.7110041379928589,
-0.2085670828819275,
-0.5698204636573792,
-0.26482731103897095,
-0.001030578394420445,
0.7275558710098267,
0.06645877659320831,
-0.12177784740924835,
-0.42084524035453796,
-0.2200637310743332,
-0.7510644197463989,
-0.5857486128807068,
-0.44984763860702515,
-0.5477609634399414,
0.4960472881793976,
0.7768115401268005,
0.8119065761566162,
0.40928518772125244,
0.4693170189857483,
0.3930421471595764,
0.07538475096225739,
0.27435749769210815,
-0.7645277380943298,
0.416252464056015,
-0.08838552981615067,
0.26253563165664673,
-0.4393138289451599,
0.12531284987926483,
0.6038861274719238,
0.8461363911628723,
0.03438292816281319,
0.28118211030960083,
0.3363937437534332,
0.20191112160682678,
-0.7660695314407349,
0.5357023477554321,
-0.40098026394844055,
-0.22407756745815277,
-0.3625342547893524,
-0.06245905160903931,
-0.21993595361709595,
0.2526366412639618,
0.061039168387651443,
-0.633129358291626,
-0.25080081820487976,
-0.3310064971446991,
0.876659631729126,
0.08003504574298859,
-0.5742427110671997,
-0.07718156278133392,
-0.9448041319847107,
0.6743578314781189,
-0.09248337894678116,
0.22234833240509033,
0.264936625957489,
0.433783620595932,
-0.146883025765419,
-0.29814016819000244,
-0.48857179284095764,
0.016835199669003487,
0.1622103750705719,
0.100065216422081,
-0.05599023401737213,
0.1058698445558548,
0.18878202140331268,
-0.13178589940071106,
-0.0895877331495285,
0.005323206540197134,
-0.18829619884490967,
-0.07165195792913437,
0.598334550857544,
0.39799001812934875,
-0.03000415861606598,
-0.4546568691730499,
-0.6443464159965515,
-0.06728238612413406,
-0.07951446622610092,
0.3928241431713104,
0.171025350689888,
0.45281681418418884,
-0.5818228721618652,
0.7517715692520142,
-0.14949864149093628,
0.38311198353767395,
0.3821179270744324,
-0.16304518282413483,
0.24204546213150024,
-0.7047145366668701,
0.1575351059436798,
-0.1349216252565384,
0.6416924595832825,
1.008865475654602,
0.40156733989715576,
0.1549665331840515,
0.1366051584482193,
0.2690255045890808,
-0.15945446491241455,
-0.45135945081710815,
-0.14243239164352417,
0.22482174634933472,
-0.5082114934921265,
-0.29294952750205994,
-0.1015063002705574,
-1.0281447172164917,
-0.7127935886383057,
-0.44218602776527405,
0.36532342433929443,
-0.5956584811210632,
-0.4498673975467682,
-0.07580947875976562,
-0.30523645877838135,
0.2589549422264099,
0.5852917432785034,
-0.8743636608123779,
0.3022855520248413,
0.5903664827346802,
0.8044559359550476,
0.3509728014469147,
-0.4594937264919281,
-0.5326527953147888,
0.6646239161491394,
0.09408600628376007,
0.7413214445114136,
-0.9551324844360352,
-0.2549775242805481,
-0.17782379686832428,
-0.057413507252931595,
0.12776191532611847,
-0.05625486746430397,
0.3426911532878876,
0.05525194853544235,
-0.29555651545524597,
-0.4112565815448761,
-0.4189682602882385,
0.3143913149833679,
0.5866854190826416,
-0.5883786678314209,
0.7248615622520447,
-0.2426140308380127,
-0.6450647115707397,
0.20885832607746124,
-0.3504702150821686,
-0.20578068494796753,
0.15807747840881348,
-0.18084323406219482,
-0.06443290412425995,
0.1743467152118683,
0.2008979171514511,
0.5944609642028809,
0.045700374990701675,
0.34785196185112,
-0.8056551218032837,
-0.313950777053833,
0.19565217196941376,
-0.36671367287635803,
0.4656590521335602,
0.053594060242176056,
0.044612277299165726,
0.2457537055015564,
-0.6011361479759216,
-0.09195631742477417,
0.008657039143145084,
0.05727497488260269,
-0.385924369096756,
0.3782801628112793,
0.067117840051651,
0.21369312703609467,
0.4298185408115387,
-0.3671055734157562,
0.15082980692386627,
0.2768954336643219,
0.5631955862045288,
0.7088135480880737,
0.026982802897691727,
0.6718470454216003,
-0.3126062750816345,
0.09301988780498505,
0.14312994480133057,
0.42952585220336914,
-0.4144727289676666,
-0.4791122376918793,
-0.08727974444627762,
-0.4586641788482666,
0.17264507710933685,
0.5136077404022217,
-0.9125383496284485,
0.07382162660360336,
-0.2560754716396332,
-0.3449486196041107,
-0.28576338291168213,
-0.05470389872789383,
0.32101136445999146,
0.09148754924535751,
0.24443766474723816,
-0.2480178028345108,
-0.7541201710700989,
-0.7372433543205261,
-0.03742311894893646,
-0.21781544387340546,
0.24262836575508118,
0.45372864603996277,
0.29656368494033813,
-0.3162612318992615,
0.8425132036209106,
-0.2438238263130188,
-0.49313104152679443,
-0.17048262059688568,
0.42887023091316223,
-0.37300628423690796,
0.7440170645713806,
0.3093830943107605,
-0.7774763703346252,
-0.25268980860710144,
-0.10739748179912567,
-0.6072088479995728,
-0.11632004380226135,
-0.12121154367923737,
-0.043935056775808334,
-0.3370881676673889,
0.7506235241889954,
-0.44503962993621826,
0.10621179640293121,
0.7144994735717773,
-0.16639693081378937,
0.46224233508110046,
-0.011088019236922264,
0.37647390365600586,
-1.0307291746139526,
-0.1085982695221901,
0.21250157058238983,
-0.1801348328590393,
-0.728359043598175,
0.021475644782185555,
-0.2116755247116089,
-0.2488006055355072,
-0.2735172510147095,
0.6879295706748962,
-0.7659568190574646,
0.12495708465576172,
0.01345871388912201,
0.43379077315330505,
-0.04176453500986099,
0.45571595430374146,
-0.08607739955186844,
0.37181556224823,
0.5275168418884277,
-0.24749603867530823,
0.41757744550704956,
0.1893928050994873,
-0.32728222012519836,
1.0165326595306396,
-0.5707172155380249,
-0.12674298882484436,
-0.4066910147666931,
0.27212244272232056,
-1.150612473487854,
-0.6431761384010315,
0.17380955815315247,
-0.4849841892719269,
0.08989114314317703,
-0.37352392077445984,
-0.532764732837677,
-0.14477647840976715,
-0.47110500931739807,
0.6488488912582397,
0.25733911991119385,
-0.07048335671424866,
0.792885959148407,
0.8143525719642639,
0.037181440740823746,
-0.5204488635063171,
-0.5314578413963318,
0.14517153799533844,
-0.0901840552687645,
-0.6236441135406494,
0.28162631392478943,
0.05332445725798607,
-0.40081408619880676,
-0.06641735136508942,
-0.0023357756435871124,
-0.11900731176137924,
0.10063716769218445,
0.5373013615608215,
0.21569137275218964,
0.1612577885389328,
-0.05774995684623718,
-0.14210127294063568,
-0.10236997157335281,
-0.25509804487228394,
0.19799847900867462,
0.5534013509750366,
-0.1678095906972885,
-0.35658395290374756,
-0.4670634865760803,
0.6454822421073914,
0.5707708597183228,
-0.34439557790756226,
0.5690749287605286,
0.8230425715446472,
-0.5907313823699951,
0.46190816164016724,
-0.7318808436393738,
-0.10641919821500778,
-0.4550963044166565,
0.3195834755897522,
-0.6145963668823242,
-0.882289469242096,
0.8767827153205872,
-0.15232853591442108,
-0.16705408692359924,
-0.03474508225917816,
0.5722565054893494,
-0.33389490842819214,
1.3361226320266724,
0.4190322756767273,
0.30541300773620605,
0.6998773813247681,
0.10225429385900497,
-0.11030294746160507,
-0.9679533839225769,
-0.38221031427383423,
-0.2348860800266266,
-0.6045984625816345,
-0.3615199625492096,
-0.806521475315094,
0.2559654414653778,
0.3318120539188385,
0.02506905421614647,
0.26978787779808044,
-0.019767429679632187,
0.7536988854408264,
0.31796935200691223,
0.35084980726242065,
0.16146032512187958,
-0.2432018518447876,
-0.2173982411623001,
-0.11214280873537064,
-0.4385056495666504,
-0.5011990666389465,
0.5153188109397888,
0.2191247195005417,
0.9712128639221191,
0.18360953032970428,
0.7076007723808289,
0.05004418268799782,
0.05208369717001915,
-0.5718629956245422,
0.6227224469184875,
-0.1020311489701271,
-0.7941653728485107,
-0.22274065017700195,
-0.4997868537902832,
-0.9012123942375183,
0.044307414442300797,
-0.7242676019668579,
-1.0473146438598633,
0.38163596391677856,
0.16841810941696167,
-0.6162230968475342,
0.023105399683117867,
-0.9872304797172546,
1.1081548929214478,
0.07665883004665375,
-0.6609017252922058,
-0.05963896960020065,
-0.8477560877799988,
0.4252524673938751,
0.5812712907791138,
0.4065159857273102,
-0.5480181574821472,
0.1720714271068573,
0.17806902527809143,
0.14217907190322876,
1.2945618629455566,
-0.31233978271484375,
0.12418269366025925,
0.3408064842224121,
0.07745447754859924,
0.3287981450557709,
0.2084915041923523,
0.2368314117193222,
0.22986112534999847,
0.31102967262268066,
-0.4789198637008667,
-0.35027560591697693,
0.7591516375541687,
-0.6526643633842468,
-0.2925127446651459,
-0.27324360609054565,
-0.8523408770561218,
-0.1734744906425476,
0.003373316954821348,
-0.0175558440387249,
0.6432677507400513,
-0.5880774259567261,
0.29549482464790344,
0.2330455482006073,
0.22732220590114594,
0.3028538227081299,
0.06423863023519516,
0.11470676213502884,
-0.3634886145591736,
0.828550398349762,
0.13770850002765656,
0.26263970136642456,
0.2268276959657669,
0.03653715178370476,
-0.11728765815496445,
-0.14921635389328003,
-0.23807896673679352,
0.03835051879286766,
-0.5647227764129639,
-0.09729177504777908,
-0.49865272641181946,
0.03410223498940468,
-0.3708062171936035,
-0.1791239231824875,
-0.323546439409256,
-0.4018126428127289,
-0.23750807344913483,
0.21842513978481293,
-0.190291628241539,
0.5076144933700562,
-0.44722795486450195,
0.3412237763404846,
-0.832695484161377,
0.4576132893562317,
0.40767577290534973,
0.4793945252895355,
0.2000427395105362,
0.11247914284467697,
-0.16418561339378357,
0.3199482858181,
-0.2659033536911011,
-1.15883469581604,
-0.1653529554605484,
0.21374164521694183,
0.4782508313655853,
0.5004594326019287,
-0.04428109526634216,
1.2291207313537598,
-0.8079214692115784,
0.7438704371452332,
0.23027873039245605,
-0.9947288036346436,
0.3679601848125458,
-0.42585697770118713,
0.36386653780937195,
0.7333812713623047,
0.08719722926616669,
-0.8084964752197266,
-0.2593366205692291,
-0.5066480040550232,
-0.6883128881454468,
0.5762396454811096,
0.11966992169618607,
0.20415781438350677,
-0.3406277894973755,
0.27855533361434937,
-0.031922243535518646,
0.01116903219372034,
-0.536749005317688,
0.05798076093196869,
-0.03812132403254509,
-0.2818017899990082,
-0.16508467495441437,
-0.4614957571029663,
-0.26464399695396423,
-0.1268785297870636,
0.06815103441476822,
-0.17101870477199554,
0.14459815621376038,
-0.04671124741435051,
-0.21813276410102844,
-0.23025380074977875,
0.1959686130285263,
0.686825692653656,
0.31200987100601196,
-0.190311461687088,
0.4054746627807617,
-0.02534322626888752,
-0.13373824954032898,
0.13882219791412354,
0.26094338297843933,
0.29827696084976196,
-0.29205322265625,
0.5194630026817322,
0.5350838899612427,
0.7500815391540527,
-0.4977683126926422,
0.6113620400428772,
-0.10247059166431427,
-0.10268919169902802,
-0.12388802319765091,
-0.18118254840373993,
0.14374107122421265,
0.825651228427887,
0.09016501903533936,
0.24230194091796875,
-0.028380149975419044,
-0.8711794018745422,
0.2781866192817688,
0.6947005391120911,
-0.5752090215682983,
-0.5366381406784058,
0.6428723931312561,
0.4842858612537384,
-0.009762575849890709,
0.25260141491889954,
-0.3970666527748108,
-0.194126158952713,
0.34512028098106384,
0.12285371124744415,
0.5636059641838074,
-0.25959452986717224,
0.3368455767631531,
0.2769683301448822,
0.14743949472904205,
-0.1356925517320633,
0.23418888449668884,
-0.23256011307239532,
-0.9372333884239197,
-0.5040488839149475,
-0.1540837287902832,
-0.5335566997528076,
-0.133199542760849,
-0.6195718050003052,
0.4507777988910675,
-0.23754288256168365,
-0.5143892168998718,
0.376985639333725,
-0.13874022662639618,
-0.4541969299316406,
-0.5313726663589478,
0.6294052004814148,
0.29786843061447144,
-1.0019595623016357,
0.5083249807357788,
0.6618320941925049,
-0.37340810894966125,
-0.394669771194458,
-0.20370948314666748,
0.4318337142467499,
-0.6648598313331604,
0.3902709484100342,
0.2078850418329239,
-0.21189874410629272,
-0.17999164760112762,
-0.6721619367599487,
-0.7844632863998413,
0.9217061996459961,
0.4620625972747803,
-0.3273504674434662,
-0.20412229001522064,
0.03297784924507141,
0.3494555354118347,
-0.3706922233104706,
0.35745060443878174,
0.29862335324287415,
0.529904842376709,
0.2423233985900879,
-0.8851355910301208,
-0.06238703057169914,
-0.19893695414066315,
0.05756453052163124,
0.11343201249837875,
-0.8957120180130005,
1.0352007150650024,
-0.23378553986549377,
-0.40491604804992676,
0.1078762635588646,
0.5340114831924438,
0.3798721134662628,
0.455678254365921,
0.6207395195960999,
0.4811166226863861,
0.40275126695632935,
-0.2601121664047241,
0.6615960001945496,
-0.20009011030197144,
0.3049151301383972,
1.3250768184661865,
-0.7199646234512329,
0.6425195336341858,
0.5479538440704346,
0.3817287087440491,
0.2605600953102112,
0.5004716515541077,
0.08032340556383133,
0.32847267389297485,
-0.08039887249469757,
-0.08010757714509964,
-0.547328531742096,
-0.3407685160636902,
-0.18052072823047638,
0.8706117272377014,
0.5164211392402649,
0.17988315224647522,
-0.6102252006530762,
0.24265550076961517,
-0.1725391447544098,
0.2304629385471344,
-0.26973530650138855,
0.875700056552887,
-0.24129655957221985,
-0.48618438839912415,
0.19361253082752228,
-0.1745203286409378,
0.6350638270378113,
-0.42628541588783264,
-0.3533913195133209,
0.09479337930679321,
0.3375101387500763,
-0.10913410782814026,
-0.9375276565551758,
0.17771495878696442,
-0.25141602754592896,
-0.2889229357242584,
-0.2758583724498749,
0.7648385167121887,
-0.8277425765991211,
-0.2530510425567627,
0.3991087079048157,
0.5544619560241699,
0.01103400532156229,
-0.07245125621557236,
-0.7699177861213684,
0.41956838965415955,
-0.32993292808532715,
0.04944486916065216,
0.17334583401679993,
0.8109561204910278,
-0.2700450122356415,
0.4264054596424103,
0.3942182958126068,
-0.31308412551879883,
0.1726653277873993,
0.3366660177707672,
0.7125610113143921,
-0.3937857747077942,
-0.29762282967567444,
-0.9848037362098694,
0.5162789225578308,
-0.24591894447803497,
-0.15525197982788086,
0.7866942286491394,
0.24955308437347412,
0.6637112498283386,
0.20586957037448883,
0.2234807163476944,
-0.16152921319007874,
0.07049388438463211,
-0.2810481786727905,
0.21428491175174713,
-0.45058292150497437,
-0.16907556354999542,
-0.568299412727356,
-0.6140133738517761,
-0.08163358271121979,
0.5563479661941528,
-0.00047314263065345585,
0.012389854528009892,
0.29563990235328674,
0.41640278697013855,
-0.17169716954231262,
-0.11488130688667297,
0.30488523840904236,
0.12943971157073975,
0.2692500650882721,
0.760688841342926,
1.0295182466506958,
-0.20185139775276184,
0.6720179319381714,
-0.33255887031555176,
-0.40935251116752625,
-0.3071264624595642,
-0.8359991312026978,
-0.9363390207290649,
-0.8225989937782288,
-0.26840507984161377,
-0.27643945813179016,
-0.09026110917329788,
1.0365426540374756,
0.8627803921699524,
-0.44310298562049866,
-0.43501362204551697,
0.44731467962265015,
0.07552490383386612,
-0.6723349690437317,
-0.23391887545585632,
-0.2958900034427643,
-0.2971137464046478,
-0.8468916416168213,
0.15993377566337585,
0.3196694254875183,
0.09314614534378052,
-0.22060279548168182,
0.040215637534856796,
-0.7181921005249023,
0.08654827624559402,
0.8092647194862366,
0.08318618685007095,
-0.6563953161239624,
-0.5870084762573242,
-0.11409927159547806,
-0.13450010120868683,
-0.0005525251035578549,
0.7079340219497681,
-0.4640202820301056,
0.5411303043365479,
0.4508098065853119,
0.25196728110313416,
0.5203800201416016,
0.35672685503959656,
0.4020161032676697,
-1.1979334354400635,
0.4065437912940979,
0.03926844894886017,
0.3420035243034363,
0.35106053948402405,
-0.1723746508359909,
0.24303019046783447,
0.20879299938678741,
-0.3114643692970276,
-0.8280567526817322,
0.5193259716033936,
-1.209557056427002,
-0.21285320818424225,
1.0531896352767944,
0.16504447162151337,
-0.4044119715690613,
-0.12143450230360031,
-0.3240882158279419,
0.2754572033882141,
-0.4953906536102295,
0.5413928627967834,
1.2184195518493652,
-0.07772918045520782,
-0.5113526582717896,
-0.5155222415924072,
0.2720547914505005,
0.17746268212795258,
-0.4564277231693268,
0.34997987747192383,
0.8298097252845764,
-0.2087121605873108,
0.5315992832183838,
0.5768490433692932,
-0.1043894812464714,
0.1902356594800949,
0.1810951828956604,
0.07931315153837204,
-0.20862987637519836,
-0.4476557970046997,
-0.13950839638710022,
0.285281777381897,
-0.3885769248008728,
-0.20847228169441223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02078v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02078v1
|
Automated Generation of Multiple-Choice Cloze Questions for Assessing English Vocabulary Using GPT-turbo 3.5
| 2024-03-04T14:24:47 | 2024-03-04T14:24:47 |
Qiao Wang, Ralph Rose, Naho Orita, Ayaka Sugawara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A common way of assessing language learners' mastery of vocabulary is via
multiple-choice cloze (i.e., fill-in-the-blank) questions. But the creation of
test items can be laborious for individual teachers or in large-scale language
programs. In this paper, we evaluate a new method for automatically generating
these types of questions using large language models (LLM). The VocaTT
(vocabulary teaching and training) engine is written in Python and comprises
three basic steps: pre-processing target word lists, generating sentences and
candidate word options using GPT, and finally selecting suitable word options.
To test the efficiency of this system, 60 questions were generated targeting
academic words. The generated items were reviewed by expert reviewers who
judged the well-formedness of the sentences and word options, adding comments
to items judged not well-formed. Results showed a 75% rate of well-formedness
for sentences and 66.85% rate for suitable word options. This is a marked
improvement over the generator used earlier in our research which did not take
advantage of GPT's capabilities. Post-hoc qualitative analysis reveals several
points for improvement in future work including cross-referencing
part-of-speech tagging, better sentence validation, and improving GPT prompts.
|
[
-0.6186268329620361,
-1.0634616613388062,
0.33172720670700073,
0.07095993310213089,
-0.30115368962287903,
-0.031352847814559937,
-0.35967057943344116,
-0.28559058904647827,
0.03659835085272789,
0.3666183054447174,
-0.2196764051914215,
-0.23928187787532806,
-0.2673289179801941,
0.3663756251335144,
-0.5521593689918518,
0.9842028021812439,
-0.3216151297092438,
-0.07466622442007065,
-0.33799901604652405,
0.08872740715742111,
-0.7779343724250793,
-0.36615896224975586,
-0.8862513899803162,
-0.13536889851093292,
0.2979156970977783,
0.35140207409858704,
0.4698055386543274,
0.27016639709472656,
0.3646564483642578,
0.3212152123451233,
0.07605689018964767,
0.25638577342033386,
-0.31257957220077515,
0.2522414028644562,
-0.21906901895999908,
-0.11738470196723938,
-0.3076355457305908,
-0.1661350578069687,
0.4715813100337982,
0.3267659842967987,
-0.2070220559835434,
0.4566584825515747,
0.2927074730396271,
0.35836413502693176,
-0.42843130230903625,
-0.17712746560573578,
-1.0751222372055054,
-0.09548654407262802,
-0.19484150409698486,
-0.23800243437290192,
-0.07132726162672043,
-0.3367547392845154,
0.3790300488471985,
-0.3683113157749176,
0.19373391568660736,
-0.14157578349113464,
0.9152509570121765,
0.22931282222270966,
-0.32157930731773376,
-0.6420153975486755,
-0.413152813911438,
0.6426059603691101,
-0.44011303782463074,
0.3468555212020874,
0.3299557566642761,
0.2125718891620636,
-0.1459190994501114,
-0.814902663230896,
-0.6940401792526245,
-0.7978808879852295,
0.1861116886138916,
0.5239599943161011,
0.1995922178030014,
-0.05328405275940895,
0.11115200072526932,
0.28564485907554626,
-1.0333118438720703,
-0.02521386742591858,
-0.5099908709526062,
-0.24571780860424042,
0.5956788659095764,
0.09036924690008163,
0.30137795209884644,
-0.239212304353714,
-0.36645445227622986,
-0.12406366318464279,
-0.6112962365150452,
-0.017157237976789474,
0.4189113676548004,
0.10400661081075668,
0.5736650228500366,
0.8712725043296814,
-0.03783315047621727,
0.9033927917480469,
-0.1654379814863205,
-0.13875916600227356,
0.0634012445807457,
-0.44275468587875366,
-0.08451568335294724,
-0.07812152802944183,
0.7271209955215454,
0.35590770840644836,
0.4549780488014221,
0.14138540625572205,
-0.18010760843753815,
0.015981940552592278,
0.19279247522354126,
-0.6932661533355713,
0.003124233800917864,
0.7089221477508545,
0.42579689621925354,
-0.17256596684455872,
0.012630053795874119,
-0.34809133410453796,
-0.026880813762545586,
-0.2710404396057129,
0.596208393573761,
-0.6150875687599182,
0.008895213715732098,
0.30919554829597473,
-0.21866826713085175,
0.28894102573394775,
0.27494341135025024,
-0.5537782907485962,
0.13476207852363586,
0.37004297971725464,
0.7813313603401184,
-0.4243372976779938,
-0.5142512321472168,
-0.4791506826877594,
-0.10776630789041519,
-0.1483345627784729,
1.0164037942886353,
-0.2710823118686676,
-0.45441505312919617,
0.03563337028026581,
-0.16617295145988464,
-0.17925433814525604,
-0.5368167161941528,
0.16795751452445984,
-0.4393967390060425,
0.6132704615592957,
0.06135236471891403,
-0.912879467010498,
-0.08673959225416183,
0.6463491916656494,
-0.31420761346817017,
1.5165972709655762,
0.034151703119277954,
-0.6543437242507935,
0.3500479757785797,
-0.7882382869720459,
-0.2843441665172577,
0.6062583923339844,
-0.08460395038127899,
-0.20303785800933838,
-0.2686314880847931,
0.25218263268470764,
0.5666491389274597,
0.17957064509391785,
0.2140752226114273,
0.13055868446826935,
-0.173740953207016,
0.3146028220653534,
-0.344318151473999,
0.5979102253913879,
-0.06176590919494629,
-0.42369410395622253,
-0.08827421814203262,
-0.5132919549942017,
0.3931334614753723,
0.08072293549776077,
-0.5215650200843811,
-0.189456045627594,
-0.08472323417663574,
0.13444770872592926,
-0.004721824079751968,
0.5023801326751709,
-0.293753981590271,
0.4020499885082245,
-0.4682295620441437,
0.20128367841243744,
0.6231951117515564,
0.24892833828926086,
-0.04932139813899994,
-0.27747851610183716,
0.8585293889045715,
-0.3338242769241333,
-0.018278155475854874,
0.11490457504987717,
-0.6167437434196472,
-0.6884424090385437,
-0.11403951048851013,
0.5362042188644409,
0.9341387152671814,
-0.789175271987915,
0.6384624242782593,
-0.08851690590381622,
-0.8135623931884766,
-0.2788744568824768,
0.342469185590744,
0.010865901596844196,
0.2491203248500824,
0.3255002796649933,
-0.15841104090213776,
-0.3163524866104126,
-0.6347464323043823,
-0.06918828189373016,
-0.06780931353569031,
-0.14660127460956573,
0.28350830078125,
0.9247733950614929,
0.04471641033887863,
1.0790382623672485,
-0.6487587094306946,
-0.11536760628223419,
-0.44226476550102234,
0.19862209260463715,
-0.08163350075483322,
0.14569833874702454,
0.25496071577072144,
-0.6598418354988098,
-0.8131722807884216,
0.1243787631392479,
-0.15017729997634888,
-0.16487611830234528,
-0.0896809846162796,
-0.032023124396800995,
-0.02872459962964058,
0.21821404993534088,
-0.5335853695869446,
0.21552135050296783,
0.4320969879627228,
0.04552203789353371,
0.9799942374229431,
-0.13952253758907318,
-0.09374108910560608,
-1.1969692707061768,
0.14738525450229645,
-0.37465694546699524,
-0.19894884526729584,
-0.45847252011299133,
0.09039604663848877,
-0.13103936612606049,
-0.11513124406337738,
-0.7165662050247192,
0.7549765706062317,
-0.4687165915966034,
0.16141247749328613,
-0.36466675996780396,
0.7276934385299683,
-0.1700817346572876,
0.10028044879436493,
0.08231394737958908,
1.0785129070281982,
0.5189995169639587,
-0.8531062602996826,
0.4475805163383484,
0.026133723556995392,
-0.3777831196784973,
0.4062958061695099,
-0.6771913766860962,
0.375112384557724,
-0.06484423577785492,
0.10593017935752869,
-1.2261264324188232,
-0.19437843561172485,
-0.1621800810098648,
-0.6100001931190491,
-0.1695864349603653,
0.12418883293867111,
-0.3315574526786804,
-0.6675496697425842,
-0.402700811624527,
0.08024024963378906,
0.4931073486804962,
-0.303149551153183,
0.32419803738594055,
0.2588697671890259,
-0.4326292872428894,
-0.6745911240577698,
-0.3044707477092743,
0.005614134017378092,
-0.24365314841270447,
-0.5616323947906494,
-0.06718418002128601,
-0.36657169461250305,
-0.18677304685115814,
-0.18906313180923462,
0.1321895569562912,
-0.21932482719421387,
0.21053701639175415,
-0.276872456073761,
0.16064296662807465,
-0.19610969722270966,
0.3616665303707123,
0.0928439050912857,
0.3141539990901947,
-0.14853398501873016,
-0.4404248297214508,
0.8963278532028198,
-0.3647557199001312,
-0.10791349411010742,
0.05802307277917862,
0.2015431523323059,
0.2611382305622101,
-0.5107752084732056,
0.1853882521390915,
0.738037109375,
-0.2572576105594635,
-0.5846684575080872,
-0.6004473567008972,
-0.18114544451236725,
-0.4512845575809479,
0.46430930495262146,
-0.18591563403606415,
-0.9303933382034302,
0.36864620447158813,
0.19857627153396606,
0.34020915627479553,
0.369368314743042,
0.8316865563392639,
0.07383447140455246,
0.7102592587471008,
0.07030907273292542,
0.16139408946037292,
0.26078733801841736,
-0.3425526022911072,
0.079337477684021,
-0.6239534616470337,
0.4046218693256378,
-0.32867804169654846,
0.06716988235712051,
-0.44513610005378723,
-0.3677777349948883,
0.5304766893386841,
0.12421543896198273,
-0.0036119348369538784,
0.5227963328361511,
-0.7242718935012817,
0.590844452381134,
0.36888933181762695,
-0.24088111519813538,
0.2662718594074249,
-0.0077998023480176926,
-0.3244803249835968,
0.30361124873161316,
-0.3999565839767456,
-0.7260555624961853,
1.1421452760696411,
0.020239366218447685,
0.13574428856372833,
-0.06945499032735825,
0.8317000865936279,
0.05527418479323387,
0.5888575315475464,
-1.1112847328186035,
0.7555979490280151,
0.07198552787303925,
-0.7866962552070618,
-0.6948380470275879,
-0.07427626103162766,
-1.1557846069335938,
0.6649432182312012,
-0.11220299452543259,
-0.6452850103378296,
-0.5543085932731628,
0.21166248619556427,
-0.5363175272941589,
0.01226330827921629,
-0.7230081558227539,
0.5769875049591064,
-0.32707682251930237,
-0.41204407811164856,
0.14137166738510132,
-0.19748429954051971,
0.36401432752609253,
-0.29146426916122437,
-0.1936388909816742,
0.08462021499872208,
-0.05823202058672905,
0.794245719909668,
-0.41523411870002747,
0.4944063723087311,
-0.06391865760087967,
-0.17821496725082397,
0.9157580137252808,
0.1495315283536911,
0.32206159830093384,
0.23640765249729156,
-0.02623804472386837,
-0.09758709371089935,
0.16798336803913116,
-0.1768902987241745,
-0.4927639663219452,
0.431098610162735,
-0.36422964930534363,
-0.6455199718475342,
-0.6164940595626831,
-0.4746188223361969,
-0.3532852530479431,
0.43857628107070923,
0.34575024247169495,
0.4041758179664612,
-0.3665938079357147,
0.1093839779496193,
0.33145299553871155,
-0.2182273417711258,
0.27558085322380066,
0.5303065180778503,
-0.3448830544948578,
-0.4740782082080841,
0.9197254180908203,
0.5041065216064453,
0.37160739302635193,
0.16659873723983765,
0.531261146068573,
-0.5052362680435181,
-0.6170164346694946,
-0.5355783104896545,
0.231436088681221,
-0.44428953528404236,
-0.1467449814081192,
-0.45472824573516846,
-0.21987110376358032,
-0.46141910552978516,
-0.2863636612892151,
-0.24574057757854462,
-0.17197614908218384,
0.09792093932628632,
-0.16330558061599731,
0.27917423844337463,
0.7582463622093201,
0.22559215128421783,
0.33155715465545654,
-0.5629281997680664,
-0.05471889302134514,
0.5362927317619324,
-0.06874154508113861,
-0.12018386274576187,
-0.44444844126701355,
-0.04178560897707939,
-0.04256599396467209,
-0.673643946647644,
-0.8102169036865234,
0.29699617624282837,
0.11925239861011505,
0.20958055555820465,
0.09476228803396225,
-0.3500733971595764,
0.6230629682540894,
-0.7527958750724792,
1.3216509819030762,
-0.17093749344348907,
-0.9673733115196228,
0.48723340034484863,
-0.4530877470970154,
0.267499715089798,
0.5910051465034485,
0.38573822379112244,
-0.4735416769981384,
-0.6958532333374023,
-0.7338783144950867,
-0.9764215350151062,
0.00036950712092220783,
0.244991734623909,
0.08242912590503693,
-0.38502177596092224,
0.19702276587486267,
0.16149483621120453,
0.2910497784614563,
-0.7038564085960388,
-0.06451503932476044,
-0.23277485370635986,
-0.17079351842403412,
-0.007196316495537758,
0.055601947009563446,
0.22375774383544922,
-0.24190382659435272,
0.7496238946914673,
-0.22929172217845917,
-0.006336795631796122,
0.4016945958137512,
-0.18632100522518158,
0.43883216381073,
0.6000201106071472,
0.8390817046165466,
0.7470588684082031,
-0.20737209916114807,
-0.030760424211621284,
0.6610296964645386,
-0.8225132822990417,
0.04485071823000908,
-0.046151019632816315,
-0.14085553586483002,
0.07679468393325806,
0.14899364113807678,
0.4374910891056061,
-0.3308037221431732,
-0.9298299551010132,
0.7249824404716492,
0.07338045537471771,
-0.5547159314155579,
-0.8170520067214966,
0.10590574145317078,
0.12314073741436005,
-0.30616509914398193,
0.09337428957223892,
-0.38718855381011963,
0.11580298840999603,
-0.22333966195583344,
0.4045918881893158,
0.5353655815124512,
0.011788291856646538,
-0.08008303493261337,
0.3789505064487457,
0.02689548395574093,
-0.2082393914461136,
0.5023173093795776,
-0.4510594606399536,
-0.6059247851371765,
0.5282227993011475,
0.6078039407730103,
0.727255642414093,
-0.4020649194717407,
0.3756310045719147,
0.4550606310367584,
0.5015907287597656,
-0.19830279052257538,
0.6310215592384338,
0.11741995811462402,
-0.7747464776039124,
-0.5445247292518616,
-0.5470892190933228,
-0.5168190002441406,
0.6586881875991821,
-0.45897749066352844,
0.26483771204948425,
-0.23566757142543793,
-0.30288413166999817,
-0.3033919334411621,
0.11780060082674026,
-0.8210235238075256,
0.352762371301651,
-0.07609297335147858,
0.8410235047340393,
-0.64974045753479,
0.6583553552627563,
0.9807246327400208,
-0.39470794796943665,
-1.1177946329116821,
-0.05545729026198387,
-0.3953542709350586,
-0.9691228270530701,
0.6208335757255554,
0.19372627139091492,
-0.16915492713451385,
0.25168377161026,
-0.4347883462905884,
-0.7952979803085327,
0.9198805689811707,
-0.14561109244823456,
-0.37931114435195923,
0.07136515527963638,
0.3608933687210083,
0.6705326437950134,
-0.11670072376728058,
0.6906230449676514,
0.3476513922214508,
0.5995240807533264,
-0.2601233124732971,
-0.9475798606872559,
-0.19134832918643951,
-0.0817032903432846,
-0.02500862255692482,
0.1292235106229782,
-0.38347887992858887,
0.7770523428916931,
0.008185038343071938,
-0.26945286989212036,
0.06009970232844353,
0.6418712139129639,
0.23355071246623993,
-0.0336611345410347,
0.8315357565879822,
0.38267821073532104,
0.9962872266769409,
0.1283579021692276,
0.9405564665794373,
-0.38700103759765625,
0.458572655916214,
0.9541481137275696,
-0.492379367351532,
1.2155262231826782,
0.47970089316368103,
-0.19833555817604065,
0.28969505429267883,
0.5120325684547424,
-0.15341582894325256,
-0.09598731994628906,
0.803691565990448,
-0.20011113584041595,
-0.22103464603424072,
0.04784020036458969,
-0.27342304587364197,
0.6147987842559814,
0.3176822364330292,
0.15119363367557526,
-0.30122652649879456,
0.20854774117469788,
0.05113496258854866,
-0.10941553860902786,
-0.2185831367969513,
0.6088826060295105,
-0.04714919999241829,
-1.022193193435669,
0.7100853323936462,
-0.2931901216506958,
0.6250187754631042,
-0.7254176735877991,
0.030344096943736076,
-0.22822162508964539,
-0.01864406280219555,
-0.08660280704498291,
-0.8684724569320679,
-0.044082220643758774,
0.2793911099433899,
0.3080289661884308,
0.06936522573232651,
0.49970799684524536,
-0.7663878202438354,
-0.5231676697731018,
-0.10548563301563263,
0.668212354183197,
0.5633960366249084,
-0.06711671501398087,
-0.7521331906318665,
-0.3835202753543854,
-0.0820617526769638,
-0.47048479318618774,
0.04557419568300247,
0.0989561602473259,
-0.10218732804059982,
0.49594223499298096,
0.5641290545463562,
0.37919652462005615,
0.20573073625564575,
-0.02450079470872879,
0.43502360582351685,
-0.3808853328227997,
-0.48137345910072327,
-0.5851606726646423,
0.6390271782875061,
-0.05494827404618263,
-0.6802761554718018,
0.8645384907722473,
0.7223650813102722,
1.0717945098876953,
-0.22630293667316437,
1.1390100717544556,
-0.08506368845701218,
0.6980100274085999,
-0.5499236583709717,
0.5385030508041382,
-0.7054125666618347,
-0.11883470416069031,
-0.1241794005036354,
-0.8975616693496704,
-0.15438005328178406,
0.5853729844093323,
-0.4159213900566101,
-0.04098646342754364,
1.2469241619110107,
0.9581934809684753,
0.08453789353370667,
-0.18467651307582855,
0.2704016864299774,
0.0905936062335968,
0.39502301812171936,
0.4939528703689575,
0.9644033908843994,
-0.4686363637447357,
0.6108822226524353,
-0.12660305202007294,
-0.1776377409696579,
0.09229672700166702,
-0.7453229427337646,
-1.073181390762329,
-0.6854349374771118,
-0.16394759714603424,
-0.30661171674728394,
-0.21297593414783478,
1.0724238157272339,
0.09670289605855942,
-0.620888888835907,
-0.4595458507537842,
0.051510415971279144,
-0.19716286659240723,
-0.2903933525085449,
-0.31008440256118774,
0.6455650329589844,
-0.5593657493591309,
-0.7087293267250061,
0.4042508006095886,
-0.06359203159809113,
0.007653107866644859,
-0.35135984420776367,
0.39073997735977173,
-0.13306553661823273,
0.20732520520687103,
0.7852621674537659,
0.05012812837958336,
-0.682623565196991,
-0.5722256898880005,
0.24328504502773285,
0.053274720907211304,
-0.15079660713672638,
0.6455578804016113,
-0.3581101596355438,
0.3452663719654083,
0.6388140320777893,
0.6969530582427979,
0.13571414351463318,
0.23017950356006622,
0.3437875509262085,
-0.5763537287712097,
-0.16230012476444244,
0.408857136964798,
0.29312053322792053,
0.22830384969711304,
-0.28327327966690063,
0.2505481243133545,
0.13407109677791595,
-0.657629668712616,
-0.802609384059906,
0.0024078693240880966,
-1.0489131212234497,
-0.16245137155056,
1.3860939741134644,
0.1898430436849594,
-0.28607916831970215,
-0.17807340621948242,
-0.6401940584182739,
-0.0004459527845028788,
-0.11736711114645004,
0.6519094109535217,
1.0736967325210571,
-0.11887454241514206,
0.36456018686294556,
-0.7968201041221619,
0.4560430645942688,
0.5210014581680298,
-0.8323417901992798,
-0.14621952176094055,
0.19272556900978088,
0.6403037309646606,
0.28277695178985596,
0.7547693252563477,
0.15378765761852264,
0.23013804852962494,
-0.27938300371170044,
0.26946520805358887,
-0.11678199470043182,
-0.06252621859312057,
-0.10794208198785782,
0.3972032964229584,
0.05322572588920593,
-0.09648134559392929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04792v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04792v1
|
Breaking the Language Barrier: Can Direct Inference Outperform Pre-Translation in Multilingual LLM Applications?
| 2024-03-04T14:01:11 | 2024-03-04T14:01:11 |
Yotam Intrator, Matan Halfon, Roman Goldenberg, Reut Tsarfaty, Matan Eyal, Ehud Rivlin, Yossi Matias, Natalia Aizenberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models hold significant promise in multilingual applications.
However, inherent biases stemming from predominantly English-centric
pre-training have led to the widespread practice of pre-translation, i.e.,
translating non-English inputs to English before inference, leading to
complexity and information loss. This study re-evaluates the need for
pre-translation in the context of PaLM2 models (Anil et al., 2023), which have
been established as highly performant in multilingual tasks. We offer a
comprehensive investigation across 108 languages and 6 diverse benchmarks,
including open-end generative tasks, which were excluded from previous similar
studies. Our findings challenge the pre-translation paradigm established in
prior research, highlighting the advantages of direct inference in PaLM2.
Specifically, PaLM2-L consistently outperforms pre-translation in 94 out of 108
languages. These findings pave the way for more efficient and effective
multilingual applications, alleviating the limitations associated with
pre-translation and unlocking linguistic authenticity.
|
[
-0.2022356539964676,
-0.5684031248092651,
0.7514443397521973,
0.3713679313659668,
-0.21091113984584808,
0.04897020757198334,
-0.35738033056259155,
-0.7594165205955505,
-0.2109055370092392,
0.5439013242721558,
-0.37609177827835083,
-0.5089768767356873,
-0.9032388925552368,
0.24894441664218903,
-0.4553072452545166,
0.7856311202049255,
-0.4343127906322479,
0.20591959357261658,
-0.14511485397815704,
-0.05697985738515854,
0.014576810412108898,
-0.6822128891944885,
-0.5414974689483643,
-0.26198989152908325,
0.6114867925643921,
0.3620453476905823,
0.9598727822303772,
0.6147285103797913,
0.27730873227119446,
0.232507586479187,
0.28364428877830505,
0.13219907879829407,
-0.11985253542661667,
-0.14307640492916107,
-0.1543140858411789,
-0.8409786224365234,
-0.5342637300491333,
0.3009744882583618,
0.5927960276603699,
1.0981593132019043,
0.1482090801000595,
-0.045314330607652664,
0.21778716146945953,
0.6856081485748291,
-0.8263517022132874,
-0.04943859577178955,
-0.4736139476299286,
0.1369522362947464,
-0.6867743730545044,
0.10569276660680771,
-0.7250770330429077,
-0.2772989273071289,
-0.05907198041677475,
-0.7449398636817932,
0.33125048875808716,
-0.015441810712218285,
0.6968914866447449,
0.16244207322597504,
-0.7745034694671631,
-0.29360055923461914,
-0.968093991279602,
0.845795214176178,
-0.7298837900161743,
0.7682108879089355,
0.5052230954170227,
0.18780438601970673,
-0.12024687230587006,
-0.727939784526825,
-0.7027883529663086,
-0.1661043018102646,
0.057123590260744095,
0.1204250231385231,
-0.18805930018424988,
0.09291954338550568,
0.14692877233028412,
0.1931668519973755,
-0.5706259608268738,
0.5175155997276306,
-0.09808088093996048,
-0.17150573432445526,
0.49922114610671997,
-0.3333999216556549,
0.35320693254470825,
0.26628005504608154,
-0.3393557071685791,
-0.17528298497200012,
-1.1857537031173706,
-0.0929555594921112,
0.5139116048812866,
0.1599995493888855,
-0.3503732681274414,
0.43560388684272766,
0.14763027429580688,
0.5836784243583679,
-0.23500657081604004,
-0.14970237016677856,
0.1227828860282898,
-0.4414197504520416,
-0.04636503383517265,
0.012383517809212208,
0.9188311696052551,
0.11091464757919312,
0.5602838397026062,
-0.045896369963884354,
-0.03756823018193245,
0.006435449235141277,
-0.18750330805778503,
-0.6811965703964233,
-0.21355509757995605,
0.32487329840660095,
-0.14089511334896088,
0.15952374041080475,
-0.15539008378982544,
-0.7313973307609558,
-0.5144652128219604,
-0.187920480966568,
-0.13762861490249634,
-0.13635191321372986,
-0.7123153805732727,
0.09389346837997437,
0.2806389331817627,
0.39048269391059875,
0.5731514692306519,
-0.5784297585487366,
0.301531046628952,
0.4770529866218567,
0.7774261832237244,
-0.32065337896347046,
-0.5758885145187378,
-0.4087826609611511,
0.16002824902534485,
-0.7700707912445068,
0.5645297169685364,
-0.45219501852989197,
-0.45473867654800415,
0.10904889553785324,
-0.12594029307365417,
-0.16922339797019958,
-0.6979190111160278,
0.5937798619270325,
-0.6850741505622864,
0.10368271172046661,
-0.1650739163160324,
-0.21474319696426392,
-0.09636276960372925,
-0.07601891458034515,
-0.6290658712387085,
0.7536792159080505,
-0.18571345508098602,
-0.543832540512085,
0.4588477611541748,
-0.33405837416648865,
-0.850288450717926,
-0.2631343901157379,
-0.22745367884635925,
-0.19416552782058716,
0.09546671062707901,
0.4876421391963959,
0.22989608347415924,
-0.7203775644302368,
0.40829113125801086,
-0.4936571717262268,
-0.1468559354543686,
0.11914443224668503,
-0.6529242992401123,
0.6462464332580566,
0.2395855337381363,
-0.5425263047218323,
0.15308520197868347,
-0.34564584493637085,
-0.24008411169052124,
0.2469070702791214,
-0.07957199960947037,
-0.20581282675266266,
-0.006834609899669886,
0.01715571992099285,
0.4441169202327728,
0.229736790060997,
-0.5581375360488892,
-0.11207158118486404,
-0.3906537890434265,
0.22162160277366638,
0.6118684411048889,
-0.5978375673294067,
0.7454190850257874,
0.20694434642791748,
0.7889682054519653,
0.45876118540763855,
0.10956930369138718,
-0.1618952751159668,
-0.45680302381515503,
-0.635625422000885,
-0.17445127665996552,
0.49574241042137146,
0.7858474850654602,
-0.8609020709991455,
0.09544041752815247,
-0.3632645308971405,
-0.44626539945602417,
-0.6901680827140808,
0.4219759702682495,
0.5415520071983337,
0.3916221261024475,
0.33667823672294617,
-0.38003408908843994,
-0.31078892946243286,
-0.9991685748100281,
-0.3524923026561737,
-0.08372591435909271,
0.039454180747270584,
0.2355920672416687,
0.19264976680278778,
-0.2490324079990387,
0.5522612929344177,
-0.11088788509368896,
-0.21061813831329346,
-0.7027205228805542,
-0.03955705836415291,
0.3583891689777374,
0.587432324886322,
0.5289362668991089,
-0.9616425633430481,
-0.624203622341156,
0.19609282910823822,
-0.8968539834022522,
-0.15477879345417023,
-0.27800115942955017,
-0.1995018571615219,
0.28805404901504517,
0.43216776847839355,
-0.8059120774269104,
0.5038722157478333,
0.7705686688423157,
-0.014278041198849678,
0.5227346420288086,
-0.5358187556266785,
0.22020946443080902,
-0.7514328956604004,
0.14339418709278107,
0.015279101207852364,
-0.13513663411140442,
-0.5595212578773499,
0.0529937818646431,
0.3578740656375885,
-0.104458287358284,
-0.48760873079299927,
0.7093530893325806,
-0.7907450199127197,
-0.30872997641563416,
-0.3018300533294678,
0.2836405038833618,
0.17007479071617126,
0.15285421907901764,
0.3920000493526459,
1.0505297183990479,
0.5541167855262756,
-0.7317956686019897,
-0.044882506132125854,
0.1165207251906395,
-0.5823181867599487,
0.2004147320985794,
-0.6156319975852966,
0.23732978105545044,
-0.2852497696876526,
0.5485929250717163,
-0.9491753578186035,
-0.13418124616146088,
0.2382483035326004,
-0.25163835287094116,
0.519769549369812,
0.049403801560401917,
-0.6070677042007446,
-0.39044737815856934,
-0.12912964820861816,
0.7125993371009827,
0.46686169505119324,
-0.588604748249054,
0.5339486002922058,
0.21602478623390198,
-0.30067604780197144,
-0.672675609588623,
-0.8086196184158325,
0.2587057948112488,
-0.10609236359596252,
-0.46026092767715454,
0.253412127494812,
0.0837012305855751,
-0.29813504219055176,
-0.42389214038848877,
-0.18130409717559814,
-0.07368973642587662,
0.17288824915885925,
0.13807547092437744,
0.04982913285493851,
-0.17334945499897003,
-0.3061618208885193,
0.31706538796424866,
-0.14253117144107819,
-0.001773519441485405,
-0.2840668559074402,
0.4694991111755371,
0.4162728786468506,
-0.556158721446991,
-0.5118740797042847,
0.45864391326904297,
0.6354379653930664,
-0.6238312721252441,
0.702525794506073,
0.4583185017108917,
-0.14334367215633392,
-0.08204452693462372,
-0.5919198989868164,
-0.0416017584502697,
-0.42408594489097595,
0.4066452980041504,
-0.9159943461418152,
-0.4802235960960388,
0.34038057923316956,
-0.3992961347103119,
-0.027479199692606926,
0.3114822804927826,
0.37943533062934875,
0.08082286268472672,
1.05928635597229,
0.4675452411174774,
-0.062133412808179855,
0.28818023204803467,
0.004834671504795551,
0.35646089911460876,
-0.6530256271362305,
0.0074899583123624325,
-0.40690091252326965,
-0.06315791606903076,
-0.45295044779777527,
-0.6441166996955872,
0.2997775673866272,
0.5941000580787659,
-0.08963107317686081,
0.36743003129959106,
0.010568217374384403,
0.26406821608543396,
0.5622678399085999,
0.019576946273446083,
0.2207360714673996,
-0.0649101585149765,
-0.11541815847158432,
-0.1398419588804245,
-0.7011712193489075,
-0.6315019130706787,
1.3530194759368896,
0.3061041533946991,
0.5041388869285583,
0.40685027837753296,
0.612221360206604,
0.2123456746339798,
0.6692488789558411,
-0.2694184482097626,
0.427604615688324,
-0.21090634167194366,
-0.7295697331428528,
-0.11374077945947647,
-0.2230367511510849,
-1.2076364755630493,
0.4951086640357971,
0.12819309532642365,
-0.5170500874519348,
0.09571341425180435,
0.28556400537490845,
-0.07389970123767853,
0.3027527630329132,
-0.8514887690544128,
1.1621832847595215,
-0.5868180990219116,
-0.7911627888679504,
-0.2683229446411133,
-0.7370540499687195,
0.5382626056671143,
-0.4468318521976471,
0.7262599468231201,
-0.17661722004413605,
-0.19612279534339905,
0.6302897930145264,
-0.3247671127319336,
0.794806957244873,
-0.3466279208660126,
-0.6877939105033875,
0.3186808228492737,
0.20711493492126465,
0.6478589773178101,
-0.10466213524341583,
-0.37432143092155457,
0.3778192698955536,
0.010944540612399578,
-0.6353126764297485,
-0.5758424997329712,
0.5546980500221252,
-0.8702234625816345,
-0.8255017399787903,
-0.4165474474430084,
-0.3394342362880707,
-0.2834610044956207,
0.2535858452320099,
0.37378785014152527,
0.03480516001582146,
-0.17584754526615143,
-0.3727008104324341,
0.3541331887245178,
-0.4872576594352722,
0.31551069021224976,
0.6724231839179993,
-0.2437034696340561,
-0.2618519067764282,
0.6904895305633545,
0.02971143275499344,
0.43962952494621277,
0.6030336022377014,
0.0014541138662025332,
-0.6082077026367188,
-0.8601241707801819,
-0.9013844728469849,
0.3401155173778534,
-0.5771874189376831,
0.23936472833156586,
-0.6388386487960815,
0.30948740243911743,
-0.7294056415557861,
-0.03270640969276428,
-0.45952025055885315,
-0.08294125646352768,
-0.033899564296007156,
-0.17549516260623932,
-0.2900122106075287,
0.6841315627098083,
-0.18554233014583588,
0.28233495354652405,
-0.8215811848640442,
0.4522261619567871,
-0.09602818638086319,
-0.1329353153705597,
-0.15442748367786407,
-0.49496668577194214,
-0.09964060038328171,
0.1671520322561264,
-0.10882330685853958,
-1.1210600137710571,
0.2442721128463745,
0.3435118794441223,
0.5590776801109314,
0.4395335912704468,
0.13742244243621826,
0.6427130699157715,
-0.6976792812347412,
0.7505478858947754,
0.33558642864227295,
-0.9793956279754639,
0.536811888217926,
-0.271514892578125,
0.29219236969947815,
0.410999059677124,
0.6803781986236572,
-0.21382953226566315,
-0.22183455526828766,
-0.3403744697570801,
-0.958308756351471,
0.45142295956611633,
-0.056070346385240555,
0.05337449535727501,
0.08001302927732468,
0.2199748158454895,
0.3143519163131714,
0.3531366288661957,
-0.7592669725418091,
-0.19166912138462067,
0.07225536555051804,
-0.026136593893170357,
-0.7547361850738525,
-0.3780383765697479,
0.18913576006889343,
-0.2979130744934082,
0.412880539894104,
-0.09704747796058655,
-0.007997151464223862,
0.15090937912464142,
-0.5336523652076721,
0.059117391705513,
0.246845543384552,
0.5800318121910095,
0.7089386582374573,
0.20079971849918365,
0.31978046894073486,
0.10118374228477478,
-0.29610195755958557,
0.4170602560043335,
0.3114491403102875,
-0.10656663775444031,
0.010236803442239761,
0.7082547545433044,
0.659674346446991,
0.13845223188400269,
-0.7000833749771118,
0.6005223989486694,
0.31577035784721375,
0.004297209903597832,
-0.3477184474468231,
-0.3134290277957916,
-0.06418953090906143,
0.0012364162830635905,
0.2106523960828781,
-0.05346966162323952,
0.10489348322153091,
-0.511498749256134,
0.045492272824048996,
0.3070105314254761,
-0.13252295553684235,
-0.5001585483551025,
1.0544480085372925,
0.4135582447052002,
0.11781101673841476,
0.424461305141449,
-0.19037258625030518,
-0.4006853401660919,
0.49719658493995667,
0.5802624821662903,
0.6700947284698486,
-0.4374659061431885,
0.05019679293036461,
0.2930355668067932,
0.4770612418651581,
-0.11673270165920258,
0.17118683457374573,
-0.4471912086009979,
-0.9556689858436584,
-0.8298736810684204,
-0.6084670424461365,
-0.4694640040397644,
-0.05598685145378113,
-0.5966944694519043,
-0.10724338889122009,
-0.26722320914268494,
-0.11258134990930557,
-0.08654781430959702,
-0.2797963619232178,
-0.8957025408744812,
0.2582927346229553,
0.32800939679145813,
1.010606050491333,
-0.8436265587806702,
1.3582290410995483,
0.6618419289588928,
-0.20582522451877594,
-0.5101000666618347,
-0.001583970501087606,
-0.05551927164196968,
-0.6758399605751038,
0.9734526872634888,
0.21428266167640686,
-0.2535935044288635,
0.04707316681742668,
-0.1538354456424713,
-0.7226155400276184,
0.7649694681167603,
0.8566124439239502,
-0.7495972514152527,
-0.12195143103599548,
0.5549184679985046,
0.19562985002994537,
-0.020740263164043427,
0.4045611619949341,
0.9384278059005737,
0.655906081199646,
-0.20620465278625488,
-1.2373709678649902,
-0.06104018911719322,
-0.15105466544628143,
-0.015840250998735428,
0.2502466142177582,
-0.28291162848472595,
0.781609058380127,
-0.4290285110473633,
-0.38762035965919495,
0.07585233449935913,
0.7932727932929993,
0.15541736781597137,
0.36351513862609863,
0.38991087675094604,
0.36267897486686707,
0.7120258808135986,
-0.04611477255821228,
1.3789550065994263,
-0.5700411796569824,
-0.22328154742717743,
1.2385668754577637,
-0.8405170440673828,
0.9820371866226196,
0.5168855786323547,
-0.6103100180625916,
0.4616756737232208,
0.7527591586112976,
0.7593642473220825,
0.3370113670825958,
0.22538144886493683,
-0.5271126627922058,
-0.34142813086509705,
-0.17122399806976318,
-0.46142640709877014,
0.4920998811721802,
0.45397546887397766,
-0.30428895354270935,
-0.2263382226228714,
0.17187437415122986,
0.2668692469596863,
0.373574823141098,
-0.2238137125968933,
0.4896148145198822,
0.318676620721817,
-0.9272170066833496,
0.6217817068099976,
0.1384032815694809,
0.7208012342453003,
-0.7933753728866577,
0.07382647693157196,
-0.3528939187526703,
0.3818676173686981,
-0.09048576653003693,
-0.5598940849304199,
0.11089281737804413,
0.03831655532121658,
0.07260527461767197,
-0.5807396173477173,
0.5365769267082214,
-0.5697320103645325,
-0.3831976354122162,
0.7530710697174072,
0.9734277129173279,
0.45074254274368286,
-0.374787300825119,
-0.615537166595459,
0.22898346185684204,
-0.015902163460850716,
-0.3667636215686798,
0.34949246048927307,
0.3680395483970642,
-0.08735858649015427,
0.5230117440223694,
0.7367541193962097,
0.26351210474967957,
0.23094192147254944,
0.10971562564373016,
0.322164922952652,
-0.4909081757068634,
-0.3571133017539978,
-0.992538571357727,
0.21052026748657227,
0.10198711603879929,
-0.20172780752182007,
1.012951374053955,
0.8352579474449158,
1.0317962169647217,
-0.16634872555732727,
0.9838599562644958,
0.2338889241218567,
0.2806045711040497,
-0.5903370380401611,
0.48535633087158203,
-0.48104357719421387,
0.00303164916113019,
-0.2023157775402069,
-0.8980289697647095,
-0.22827106714248657,
0.3691770136356354,
-0.6764535307884216,
0.0669722855091095,
0.6731031537055969,
0.6682119369506836,
-0.0010363251203671098,
-0.2660854756832123,
0.49696382880210876,
0.014260238967835903,
0.34693679213523865,
0.8866689205169678,
0.6125494837760925,
-0.4404783844947815,
0.4229539930820465,
-0.20374678075313568,
-0.32177120447158813,
0.13270054757595062,
-0.8060229420661926,
-0.6593912839889526,
-0.4232051968574524,
-0.3501147925853729,
-0.3655228018760681,
0.015974264591932297,
0.6788589358329773,
0.7151463627815247,
-0.9757918119430542,
-0.4647628962993622,
-0.30678027868270874,
0.10500986129045486,
-0.21066612005233765,
-0.08090904355049133,
0.26337680220603943,
-0.26216644048690796,
-1.024245023727417,
0.7407740354537964,
0.16321143507957458,
0.23695838451385498,
-0.24395404756069183,
-0.3095826506614685,
-0.12833280861377716,
-0.05516737699508667,
0.7145897150039673,
0.4859553873538971,
-0.8966870903968811,
0.09404150396585464,
-0.2806984484195709,
-0.12477527558803558,
-0.06727616488933563,
0.8935471773147583,
-0.7741696238517761,
0.2766970694065094,
0.09509725868701935,
0.7299487590789795,
0.6970059871673584,
-0.21070468425750732,
1.0557280778884888,
-0.5241720676422119,
0.6306586265563965,
-0.01759643480181694,
0.345731645822525,
0.4453854560852051,
0.0642135739326477,
0.583989143371582,
0.26872605085372925,
-0.05085988715291023,
-0.8762245774269104,
0.6585733890533447,
-0.5440308451652527,
-0.3423009514808655,
1.2268871068954468,
-0.42618119716644287,
-0.08847033977508545,
-0.06702066212892532,
-0.1108640804886818,
0.3657948970794678,
-0.06093214079737663,
0.07187668234109879,
0.5730049014091492,
-0.0204697884619236,
-0.44999778270721436,
-0.761440634727478,
0.5371475219726562,
0.6705090403556824,
-0.832287609577179,
0.1282295435667038,
0.3517884612083435,
-0.05013566464185715,
0.08018110692501068,
0.9338154792785645,
-0.015539531596004963,
0.16978302597999573,
0.06027907133102417,
0.20088855922222137,
0.13957630097866058,
-0.4577721357345581,
-0.17072518169879913,
0.19733399152755737,
0.5960215926170349,
-0.18909873068332672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02009v1
|
Topic Aware Probing: From Sentence Length Prediction to Idiom Identification how reliant are Neural Language Models on Topic?
| 2024-03-04T13:10:08 | 2024-03-04T13:10:08 |
Vasudevan Nedumpozhimana, John D. Kelleher
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Transformer-based Neural Language Models achieve state-of-the-art performance
on various natural language processing tasks. However, an open question is the
extent to which these models rely on word-order/syntactic or word
co-occurrence/topic-based information when processing natural language. This
work contributes to this debate by addressing the question of whether these
models primarily use topic as a signal, by exploring the relationship between
Transformer-based models' (BERT and RoBERTa's) performance on a range of
probing tasks in English, from simple lexical tasks such as sentence length
prediction to complex semantic tasks such as idiom token identification, and
the sensitivity of these tasks to the topic information. To this end, we
propose a novel probing method which we call topic-aware probing. Our initial
results indicate that Transformer-based models encode both topic and non-topic
information in their intermediate layers, but also that the facility of these
models to distinguish idiomatic usage is primarily based on their ability to
identify and encode topic. Furthermore, our analysis of these models'
performance on other standard probing tasks suggests that tasks that are
relatively insensitive to the topic information are also tasks that are
relatively difficult for these models.
|
[
-0.655803918838501,
-1.0490031242370605,
0.46819165349006653,
0.10033201426267624,
-0.2991030216217041,
-0.197215273976326,
-0.16455936431884766,
-0.3778202533721924,
0.3241264224052429,
0.48970094323158264,
-0.4998186230659485,
0.028536852449178696,
-0.7325999736785889,
0.03377177566289902,
-0.7200838327407837,
0.8206160068511963,
0.404467910528183,
-0.009488715790212154,
-0.4629448354244232,
0.07172320038080215,
-0.41757091879844666,
-0.4002615809440613,
-0.3401237726211548,
-0.42636939883232117,
0.4412957727909088,
0.18373094499111176,
0.6172943115234375,
0.5851063132286072,
0.5919227004051208,
0.2760644257068634,
-0.5120223164558411,
-0.2688455283641815,
-0.3181810677051544,
0.27117919921875,
-0.2798900902271271,
-0.6154110431671143,
-0.053180016577243805,
0.11980752646923065,
0.3577423393726349,
0.7233151197433472,
0.3653412163257599,
0.12705367803573608,
0.04767351225018501,
0.3738679587841034,
-0.36145034432411194,
-0.09816141426563263,
-0.9114201664924622,
0.00007034297595964745,
-0.17940890789031982,
-0.31391096115112305,
-0.6312745213508606,
0.024416863918304443,
0.6384832262992859,
-0.17333796620368958,
0.5896702408790588,
-0.2083752602338791,
1.1078027486801147,
0.23128797113895416,
-0.613906741142273,
-0.383416086435318,
-0.6380564570426941,
0.5409473180770874,
-0.5941959023475647,
0.42310255765914917,
0.5256712436676025,
-0.09107641130685806,
0.11992961168289185,
-0.8407413959503174,
-0.6007184386253357,
-0.3811645209789276,
-0.5913153290748596,
-0.01872347667813301,
-0.40721338987350464,
-0.10098244994878769,
0.16499581933021545,
0.30908671021461487,
-0.5065143704414368,
0.05591980740427971,
-0.38612014055252075,
-0.23948749899864197,
0.3724215626716614,
0.16948120296001434,
0.18218356370925903,
-0.45937788486480713,
-0.3259386420249939,
0.19515006244182587,
-0.4513978958129883,
0.14828667044639587,
0.19917891919612885,
0.29110589623451233,
0.1026400476694107,
0.541747510433197,
0.057323843240737915,
0.7555817365646362,
0.19982726871967316,
0.31755223870277405,
-0.1632281094789505,
-0.26650166511535645,
0.03460119664669037,
-0.009920522570610046,
0.5351064205169678,
0.09836134314537048,
0.17213565111160278,
-0.33943507075309753,
-0.265542209148407,
0.293843537569046,
0.5297361016273499,
-0.7969943284988403,
-0.32644811272621155,
0.2747361660003662,
-0.3903922736644745,
-0.16891849040985107,
0.07057055830955505,
-0.5625104308128357,
-0.2537628710269928,
-0.25953054428100586,
0.6126531958580017,
-0.6048024892807007,
-0.3552239239215851,
0.026639467105269432,
-0.1355944126844406,
0.4332138001918793,
0.0376959927380085,
-0.9015982151031494,
0.4728984236717224,
1.0274674892425537,
0.8049734234809875,
-0.232770636677742,
-0.3720467686653137,
-0.4489872455596924,
-0.08809156715869904,
-0.2271050363779068,
0.797041118144989,
-0.5187740325927734,
-0.412365585565567,
-0.24614572525024414,
0.0756797343492508,
-0.12892301380634308,
-0.38303622603416443,
0.46917831897735596,
-0.797516405582428,
0.44729143381118774,
-0.25374695658683777,
-0.8706350922584534,
-0.19301621615886688,
0.28439861536026,
-0.6935773491859436,
1.0148768424987793,
-0.12919382750988007,
-1.1831203699111938,
0.19141443073749542,
-0.9048186540603638,
-0.5058493614196777,
0.030100500211119652,
-0.07668726146221161,
-0.2338549643754959,
0.3343929648399353,
0.1764311045408249,
0.5060514211654663,
-0.20926542580127716,
0.5728937387466431,
0.15467827022075653,
-0.5147640109062195,
0.5201560258865356,
-0.6507285833358765,
0.5686652064323425,
0.1381697952747345,
-0.27171099185943604,
0.38964399695396423,
-0.46054700016975403,
-0.13680757582187653,
0.18911957740783691,
-0.050919581204652786,
-0.5038526058197021,
0.13458983600139618,
-0.14139346778392792,
-0.11279437690973282,
0.2656315267086029,
-0.6333381533622742,
-0.1467990130186081,
-0.5110892653465271,
0.5090422034263611,
0.6275930404663086,
0.19876514375209808,
0.4553599953651428,
-0.16144707798957825,
0.34577831625938416,
-0.02052990533411503,
-0.011969046667218208,
-0.3617037236690521,
-0.615726113319397,
-0.9343371391296387,
-0.26011037826538086,
0.5511345267295837,
0.45933210849761963,
-0.3818725049495697,
0.4614752233028412,
-0.39123091101646423,
-0.7450128793716431,
-0.47475412487983704,
-0.5522120594978333,
0.06359992921352386,
0.6494486331939697,
0.27463531494140625,
-0.2617112994194031,
-0.11347583681344986,
-0.9340891242027283,
-0.30867254734039307,
-0.1330679953098297,
0.12457416206598282,
0.3338005542755127,
0.5061768889427185,
0.06177724897861481,
1.1386045217514038,
-0.6451501846313477,
0.1571875512599945,
-0.3336518704891205,
0.515649676322937,
0.46111658215522766,
0.24614553153514862,
0.5882314443588257,
-1.1242868900299072,
-0.4804489016532898,
-0.27979791164398193,
-0.40305742621421814,
0.006929048337042332,
-0.021324077621102333,
0.03988341614603996,
-0.11942441016435623,
0.5473575592041016,
-0.643539309501648,
0.3591514825820923,
0.5200174450874329,
-0.642066478729248,
0.2906157374382019,
-0.32420551776885986,
-0.2023760825395584,
-0.9959193468093872,
0.008776603266596794,
0.07574791461229324,
0.05052866414189339,
-1.0612543821334839,
0.027049340307712555,
0.3125125765800476,
-0.20818763971328735,
-0.30781176686286926,
0.6059662699699402,
-0.48480185866355896,
-0.02166246436536312,
-0.7885813117027283,
-0.05588415637612343,
0.020877311006188393,
0.23767255246639252,
0.16825072467327118,
0.9497994780540466,
0.7413530945777893,
-0.7231608629226685,
-0.04580264165997505,
0.23645766079425812,
-0.4082815945148468,
0.14018282294273376,
-0.7063937187194824,
0.30709144473075867,
-0.2497871071100235,
-0.1683739423751831,
-1.176034927368164,
0.057936202734708786,
-0.0266109686344862,
-0.7292032837867737,
0.1925186961889267,
-0.05307522788643837,
-0.3473036587238312,
-0.13692709803581238,
0.08829161524772644,
0.18778882920742035,
0.3666117489337921,
-0.34657204151153564,
0.6064456105232239,
0.2906125783920288,
-0.1953868269920349,
-0.4514378607273102,
-0.5849369168281555,
0.05633721873164177,
-0.3971382677555084,
-0.53515625,
0.5233738422393799,
0.07417134940624237,
-0.31608814001083374,
0.08267853409051895,
-0.1062319353222847,
-0.37208932638168335,
0.4233269989490509,
0.2734318971633911,
0.04364633560180664,
-0.29686665534973145,
0.5128591656684875,
-0.08270437270402908,
-0.16516312956809998,
0.2645260989665985,
0.015602508559823036,
0.9193300604820251,
-0.11821119487285614,
-0.38065585494041443,
-0.3843075633049011,
0.550639808177948,
0.7099931240081787,
-0.9274507164955139,
0.6265692710876465,
0.5525391697883606,
-0.38740959763526917,
-0.03864722698926926,
-0.4445613622665405,
-0.8942648768424988,
-0.5012373328208923,
0.47524213790893555,
-0.5126465559005737,
-0.8517922163009644,
0.4481810927391052,
0.04904114082455635,
-0.3353256583213806,
0.4675654172897339,
0.3349011540412903,
-0.13814425468444824,
0.46679386496543884,
0.8632647395133972,
-0.2309349775314331,
0.5273205041885376,
-0.24668702483177185,
0.39903709292411804,
-0.6338925957679749,
0.17922693490982056,
-0.667716920375824,
-0.3221527636051178,
-0.5803999304771423,
-0.30231449007987976,
0.2555978298187256,
-0.27531760931015015,
0.051335688680410385,
0.3502233028411865,
-0.45944318175315857,
0.3322893977165222,
0.804703414440155,
0.06048833951354027,
0.14614734053611755,
-0.16883184015750885,
0.16268768906593323,
-0.3538987934589386,
-0.4826829433441162,
-0.43787428736686707,
0.8986986875534058,
0.43749263882637024,
0.39086222648620605,
-0.13773776590824127,
0.3276558816432953,
0.24817034602165222,
0.0454183891415596,
-0.9944650530815125,
0.7618049383163452,
-0.21592047810554504,
-0.7189847230911255,
-0.2916094958782196,
-0.06921889632940292,
-0.9875604510307312,
0.15939302742481232,
0.013492224738001823,
-0.6971294283866882,
0.12449272722005844,
-0.20072554051876068,
-0.17795903980731964,
0.293186217546463,
-0.481804758310318,
0.6207029819488525,
-0.36384132504463196,
-0.13430380821228027,
-0.2152641862630844,
-0.4928143322467804,
-0.19732274115085602,
0.000054069056204752997,
-0.20874157547950745,
-0.0410313606262207,
0.02920326218008995,
0.7470988035202026,
0.06111256778240204,
0.9040771126747131,
-0.1860901564359665,
-0.033724118024110794,
0.35454660654067993,
0.18218791484832764,
0.414111465215683,
0.06778634339570999,
-0.10315650701522827,
0.0353706069290638,
-0.13610859215259552,
-0.13391539454460144,
-0.565682053565979,
0.47656312584877014,
-0.4982090890407562,
-0.9822189807891846,
-0.4901103973388672,
-0.6748443841934204,
-0.16641683876514435,
0.29909881949424744,
0.4255303144454956,
0.37751829624176025,
-0.002790207276120782,
0.3490273952484131,
0.8624879121780396,
0.04500582069158554,
0.587165892124176,
0.6643468141555786,
-0.05387430265545845,
0.0752948448061943,
0.7622771263122559,
0.16294272243976593,
0.17396116256713867,
0.7575551271438599,
0.3764367401599884,
-0.13958069682121277,
-0.8386287093162537,
-0.0659254938364029,
0.19981282949447632,
-0.5403914451599121,
0.05877339094877243,
-0.914040744304657,
-0.37111058831214905,
-0.10128448158502579,
0.070501908659935,
-0.43736985325813293,
-0.14136762917041779,
-0.3613707721233368,
-0.3415863513946533,
0.7002913951873779,
0.45842209458351135,
0.24375322461128235,
0.2903371751308441,
-0.5550666451454163,
0.22731545567512512,
0.41662031412124634,
0.285685271024704,
-0.18526557087898254,
-0.6443743109703064,
0.03405094891786575,
-0.10005281865596771,
0.016187304630875587,
-1.2135907411575317,
0.33973953127861023,
0.069014772772789,
0.6480209231376648,
0.30441439151763916,
0.11289169639348984,
0.15605488419532776,
-0.2885909974575043,
0.8676257133483887,
-0.39686092734336853,
-1.0574102401733398,
0.7539928555488586,
-0.42733025550842285,
0.240089550614357,
0.3108106851577759,
0.4539220631122589,
-0.5729276537895203,
-0.42574089765548706,
-0.47437411546707153,
-0.8356816172599792,
0.5959396958351135,
0.017727280035614967,
0.6542543768882751,
-0.23245424032211304,
0.4405396580696106,
0.2964213192462921,
0.15636992454528809,
-0.7379998564720154,
-0.1941027045249939,
-0.16848355531692505,
0.0809328556060791,
-0.032104019075632095,
-0.3773045837879181,
-0.04557150602340698,
-0.16723082959651947,
0.29293960332870483,
-0.3874501585960388,
0.7054934501647949,
0.2264409363269806,
-0.03066474385559559,
0.30631276965141296,
0.28566139936447144,
0.471488356590271,
0.5534456968307495,
-0.3625003695487976,
0.19066618382930756,
-0.029389508068561554,
-0.5333049297332764,
0.012185008265078068,
0.11354706436395645,
-0.2506365478038788,
0.3125110864639282,
0.27689996361732483,
0.8492762446403503,
-0.007144925184547901,
-0.5290206074714661,
0.5877750515937805,
-0.11180239170789719,
0.04235630854964256,
-0.1872696578502655,
-0.021616075187921524,
0.29769769310951233,
0.22368094325065613,
0.25184065103530884,
-0.03626410290598869,
0.19407397508621216,
-0.47648346424102783,
0.5204181671142578,
0.40364208817481995,
-0.846015989780426,
-0.4544728398323059,
0.3436528444290161,
-0.013566902838647366,
-0.499697744846344,
0.7986403703689575,
-0.12457317113876343,
-0.5998321175575256,
0.8008822798728943,
0.6985316276550293,
0.9258148670196533,
-0.19424863159656525,
0.18968406319618225,
0.1759950965642929,
0.3381507694721222,
0.28400662541389465,
0.56107097864151,
0.020502585917711258,
-0.9839542508125305,
-0.31615713238716125,
-0.21269619464874268,
-0.31005367636680603,
0.2278471142053604,
-0.9317026138305664,
0.06084281578660011,
-0.11905649304389954,
-0.24546484649181366,
0.06820453703403473,
-0.16761057078838348,
-0.3942101299762726,
0.4138531982898712,
-0.08403909206390381,
1.0831953287124634,
-0.7351374626159668,
0.9569220542907715,
0.8151456117630005,
-0.08677350729703903,
-0.4852812588214874,
0.5346441864967346,
-0.2582453489303589,
-0.39595699310302734,
0.6276590824127197,
0.302155077457428,
-0.04950782656669617,
0.02271106094121933,
-0.16933317482471466,
-0.8989866375923157,
1.056462049484253,
0.14794974029064178,
-0.0747784748673439,
0.054058268666267395,
0.1026122197508812,
0.6740506291389465,
-0.31443071365356445,
0.2783641219139099,
0.2573135495185852,
0.2881968021392822,
-0.2620392441749573,
-0.8619447350502014,
-0.10346359014511108,
-0.3961470127105713,
-0.17197293043136597,
0.4507461488246918,
-0.6234999299049377,
1.0395175218582153,
0.008849582634866238,
-0.08739499747753143,
-0.07762709259986877,
0.8979425430297852,
-0.17709900438785553,
0.3320350646972656,
0.5277345776557922,
0.2548827826976776,
0.7089748978614807,
-0.34589049220085144,
0.9148544669151306,
-0.636529803276062,
0.25668075680732727,
1.031822919845581,
-0.19064049422740936,
0.882433295249939,
0.6755510568618774,
0.09834598004817963,
0.09728065133094788,
0.5381709933280945,
-0.12806890904903412,
0.865320086479187,
0.30246204137802124,
-0.11382554471492767,
0.02113303542137146,
-0.3440028131008148,
-0.23509235680103302,
0.9039139151573181,
0.5660781860351562,
-0.464528888463974,
-0.04547419771552086,
0.06517000496387482,
-0.02688358724117279,
0.22204723954200745,
-0.06701642274856567,
0.8505365252494812,
-0.19812767207622528,
-0.8226252794265747,
0.24983114004135132,
0.08489080518484116,
0.8609673976898193,
-0.7540667057037354,
0.3046579957008362,
-0.34902751445770264,
0.020565273240208626,
0.3534422218799591,
-0.8748133778572083,
0.521274745464325,
-0.08384091407060623,
-0.36161866784095764,
-0.25241419672966003,
0.945684552192688,
-0.12135268747806549,
-0.2995889186859131,
0.5341101288795471,
0.7555333971977234,
-0.16808806359767914,
-0.24685107171535492,
-0.36982640624046326,
-0.22441691160202026,
0.04477320984005928,
-0.3627455532550812,
0.27658015489578247,
0.3945373296737671,
0.02336268685758114,
0.6565520167350769,
0.19949419796466827,
-0.06486555933952332,
0.1203237995505333,
-0.10656755417585373,
0.6363215446472168,
-0.7645866274833679,
-0.5703860521316528,
-0.6600679159164429,
0.4182400107383728,
0.05584513396024704,
-0.4737982451915741,
0.5571383237838745,
0.4419037401676178,
0.7763647437095642,
-0.12194107472896576,
0.6918988823890686,
0.11537931114435196,
0.7094621658325195,
-0.3908784091472626,
0.8650400042533875,
-0.4012051224708557,
0.16952821612358093,
0.033303745090961456,
-0.6775108575820923,
-0.007664470002055168,
0.3634548485279083,
-0.5493850111961365,
-0.19973166286945343,
0.5582252144813538,
0.910223126411438,
-0.32035204768180847,
0.527330756187439,
0.21439944207668304,
0.14956295490264893,
0.29903602600097656,
0.08463665843009949,
0.931265115737915,
-0.22816166281700134,
0.2547569274902344,
-0.5644869208335876,
0.08472996950149536,
-0.09637071192264557,
-0.7376253008842468,
-0.7630172371864319,
-0.9070807099342346,
-0.25313687324523926,
0.07104823738336563,
-0.036738257855176926,
0.4745929539203644,
0.49964842200279236,
-0.7176233530044556,
-0.24721664190292358,
-0.3262351453304291,
-0.14573630690574646,
-0.23901121318340302,
-0.2990180552005768,
0.5559589266777039,
-0.16836096346378326,
-0.74215167760849,
0.5201740264892578,
0.14356908202171326,
0.0007222218555398285,
-0.201724573969841,
0.3408116400241852,
-0.4217176139354706,
0.2737616002559662,
0.34753718972206116,
-0.16024714708328247,
-0.8130841255187988,
-0.32780733704566956,
0.420378714799881,
-0.10548589378595352,
0.12043147534132004,
0.9570276737213135,
-0.8054422736167908,
0.42029136419296265,
0.6971396207809448,
0.7930387854576111,
0.36571934819221497,
-0.18659134209156036,
0.5719776749610901,
-0.6994361281394958,
0.1545153260231018,
0.42351034283638,
0.3738594055175781,
0.2915138006210327,
-0.5192099809646606,
0.4042062759399414,
0.09263481944799423,
-0.3153473734855652,
-0.7291159629821777,
0.40919092297554016,
-0.7010528445243835,
-0.4053921401500702,
0.8488852977752686,
-0.18801626563072205,
-0.010909960605204105,
0.055123221129179,
-0.09528999775648117,
0.18316303193569183,
-0.050043001770973206,
0.6751870512962341,
0.7745936512947083,
-0.1352253258228302,
-0.2764478623867035,
-0.4911116063594818,
0.15958958864212036,
0.7900549173355103,
-0.49092063307762146,
-0.10650245100259781,
-0.014521315693855286,
0.23831993341445923,
0.4518112540245056,
0.39389362931251526,
0.10771406441926956,
0.1283058524131775,
-0.031200677156448364,
-0.375845342874527,
0.024180041626095772,
-0.4641670882701874,
-0.35950973629951477,
0.39934223890304565,
-0.0007172329351305962,
-0.34008750319480896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01999v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01999v1
|
LLM-Oriented Retrieval Tuner
| 2024-03-04T12:50:25 | 2024-03-04T12:50:25 |
Si Sun, Hanqing Zhang, Zhiyuan Liu, Jie Bao, Dawei Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dense Retrieval (DR) is now considered as a promising tool to enhance the
memorization capacity of Large Language Models (LLM) such as GPT3 and GPT-4 by
incorporating external memories. However, due to the paradigm discrepancy
between text generation of LLM and DR, it is still an open challenge to
integrate the retrieval and generation tasks in a shared LLM. In this paper, we
propose an efficient LLM-Oriented Retrieval Tuner, namely LMORT, which
decouples DR capacity from base LLM and non-invasively coordinates the
optimally aligned and uniform layers of the LLM towards a unified DR space,
achieving an efficient and effective DR without tuning the LLM itself. The
extensive experiments on six BEIR datasets show that our approach could achieve
competitive zero-shot retrieval performance compared to a range of strong DR
models while maintaining the generation ability of LLM.
|
[
-0.10859460383653641,
-0.8491612076759338,
0.5043267011642456,
-0.21728214621543884,
-0.6630512475967407,
0.17211683094501495,
-0.37196701765060425,
-0.08331121504306793,
0.033171236515045166,
0.4887719452381134,
-0.2451220005750656,
-0.3751685917377472,
-0.3146365284919739,
-0.09330011159181595,
-0.3020452558994293,
0.8261641263961792,
-0.009490085765719414,
-0.08469627797603607,
0.007583606522530317,
-0.2031126171350479,
-0.68431156873703,
-0.47128963470458984,
-0.5307661890983582,
-0.439634770154953,
0.5271137356758118,
0.4478934407234192,
0.285400927066803,
0.8032069802284241,
0.7714539170265198,
0.37050750851631165,
-0.00550354877486825,
0.45092281699180603,
-0.9372740387916565,
0.3076205849647522,
0.037209704518318176,
-0.26976272463798523,
-0.5753535628318787,
-0.5353049039840698,
0.8449157476425171,
0.2370714396238327,
-0.40521636605262756,
-0.043403755873441696,
0.06379949301481247,
0.7548069357872009,
-0.4864608347415924,
0.003991428297013044,
-0.9191937446594238,
-0.059513043612241745,
-0.35424965620040894,
-0.44486814737319946,
-0.424087792634964,
-0.300793319940567,
-0.10046908259391785,
-0.5153182744979858,
0.41484665870666504,
-0.11583898216485977,
0.621823787689209,
0.3278655707836151,
-0.587682843208313,
0.10237255692481995,
-0.7029159665107727,
0.9889055490493774,
-0.5357431769371033,
0.6099293828010559,
0.21566292643547058,
0.25706809759140015,
-0.12971210479736328,
-0.6138018369674683,
-0.36791619658470154,
0.16756822168827057,
-0.04220397770404816,
0.3294436037540436,
-0.03429466485977173,
0.08116080611944199,
-0.029650690034031868,
0.525517463684082,
-0.6510258913040161,
-0.036320969462394714,
-0.31221601366996765,
-0.27529391646385193,
0.5098005533218384,
0.22897616028785706,
0.09676902741193771,
-0.13956785202026367,
-0.44279009103775024,
0.16853061318397522,
-0.6467077732086182,
-0.2609233856201172,
0.04199244827032089,
0.3346688151359558,
0.1835469901561737,
0.7291069030761719,
0.02337520755827427,
0.7643490433692932,
0.3393365442752838,
-0.46208280324935913,
0.22701583802700043,
-0.43597733974456787,
-0.24734404683113098,
0.03599158674478531,
0.8394162654876709,
0.22627973556518555,
0.016706913709640503,
-0.2552303671836853,
-0.6717960238456726,
-0.13992786407470703,
0.2261151373386383,
-0.8717353940010071,
-0.06630201637744904,
-0.08619412779808044,
-0.20563018321990967,
0.02664254978299141,
-0.10711140930652618,
-0.4320833384990692,
0.07264009118080139,
-0.15368199348449707,
0.5067388415336609,
-0.7719704508781433,
-0.1632559597492218,
0.2130538672208786,
-0.035368092358112335,
0.3210983872413635,
0.24879929423332214,
-0.7218645215034485,
0.10972689092159271,
0.5901557207107544,
0.7950741648674011,
-0.195353701710701,
0.1450033187866211,
-0.6439076662063599,
0.5140377879142761,
-0.016469893977046013,
0.6924937963485718,
-0.4116491973400116,
-0.571695864200592,
-0.27696841955184937,
-0.23294053971767426,
-0.19355742633342743,
-0.7272849082946777,
0.68282151222229,
-0.8816660046577454,
0.20980289578437805,
-0.19882138073444366,
-0.6606842875480652,
-0.24929985404014587,
0.23994366824626923,
-0.6676067113876343,
1.0206234455108643,
0.2649053633213043,
-0.6826454997062683,
0.25830626487731934,
-0.37898632884025574,
-0.45297175645828247,
0.397707462310791,
-0.40297457575798035,
-0.5856273770332336,
0.257938414812088,
0.19990412890911102,
0.39717698097229004,
-0.1519557386636734,
0.5200169086456299,
-0.11848621815443039,
-0.6983746886253357,
0.0055655851028859615,
-0.4498743712902069,
0.3518425524234772,
0.3516513407230377,
-0.1677238494157791,
-0.059439096599817276,
-0.6569276452064514,
0.2847311496734619,
0.21813152730464935,
-0.9087373614311218,
-0.5620887875556946,
-0.09655988961458206,
0.08188284188508987,
-0.1260099709033966,
0.5641099810600281,
-0.6272408366203308,
0.5168365836143494,
-0.006380198523402214,
0.37996023893356323,
0.6070513725280762,
-0.08655678480863571,
0.5766145586967468,
-0.26225122809410095,
0.2959534525871277,
0.06386609375476837,
-0.30001333355903625,
0.04480778053402901,
-0.12752790749073029,
-0.7354705929756165,
-0.8009846806526184,
0.0684194266796112,
0.4169563353061676,
-0.6700202226638794,
0.5114772915840149,
-0.5207367539405823,
-0.2199011743068695,
-0.7146005630493164,
0.41817528009414673,
0.5725221037864685,
0.6946946978569031,
0.3735212981700897,
-0.20318995416164398,
-0.5230540037155151,
-0.903279721736908,
-0.1463262438774109,
0.19739483296871185,
0.0847095474600792,
0.592512845993042,
0.1241113618016243,
-0.13474200665950775,
0.7007617950439453,
-0.4284762144088745,
-0.5634241104125977,
-0.5999308824539185,
-0.1209554523229599,
0.36302947998046875,
0.27658340334892273,
0.2988166809082031,
-0.6545113325119019,
-0.6515198349952698,
0.3716818392276764,
-0.7995046973228455,
-0.04496273770928383,
0.23061253130435944,
-0.06476695090532303,
0.2572026252746582,
0.553311824798584,
-0.7611686587333679,
-0.11935918033123016,
0.35599181056022644,
-0.17710812389850616,
0.06853816658258438,
-0.41082802414894104,
0.10366608947515488,
-1.0037530660629272,
0.18665358424186707,
-0.4907895624637604,
-0.3835112452507019,
-0.6282920837402344,
-0.03771156817674637,
0.49135738611221313,
0.1257977932691574,
-0.20650415122509003,
0.4721865952014923,
-0.7096664905548096,
0.02789284847676754,
-0.2337379902601242,
0.44633519649505615,
0.11418980360031128,
0.3225533962249756,
0.09963367134332657,
1.0837161540985107,
0.11681920289993286,
-0.5320490002632141,
0.02260170318186283,
0.19005735218524933,
-0.5795475244522095,
0.32450464367866516,
-0.4865244925022125,
0.44018658995628357,
-0.45699721574783325,
0.19016705453395844,
-0.6266482472419739,
-0.1920514851808548,
-0.20692230761051178,
0.014381518587470055,
0.5860398411750793,
-0.10210224986076355,
-0.24526450037956238,
-0.09649461507797241,
-0.2241588830947876,
0.7604237794876099,
0.5762138962745667,
-0.44043827056884766,
0.49297159910202026,
0.2717059552669525,
-0.027998486533761024,
-0.7950629591941833,
-0.5538879632949829,
-0.2353266328573227,
-0.38581788539886475,
-0.5609611868858337,
0.391802579164505,
-0.1788744479417801,
-0.167307510972023,
-0.05701163411140442,
-0.14890624582767487,
0.001641443115659058,
-0.22392994165420532,
-0.1508074551820755,
0.22914119064807892,
-0.5715301632881165,
0.07364323735237122,
0.07244157791137695,
-0.008584918454289436,
-0.5616880655288696,
-0.1479177325963974,
0.6003581285476685,
0.005445439834147692,
-0.334882915019989,
-0.28327643871307373,
0.3474527597427368,
0.3729707896709442,
-0.31473469734191895,
0.3803490996360779,
0.3820643126964569,
0.14986073970794678,
-0.43114709854125977,
-0.7893299460411072,
0.03968096151947975,
-0.5467804074287415,
0.6134195327758789,
-0.51478511095047,
-1.0962400436401367,
0.24629156291484833,
0.16280308365821838,
-0.055764563381671906,
0.12917375564575195,
0.6044286489486694,
0.04272555932402611,
0.8340262174606323,
0.5446627736091614,
-0.2857551574707031,
0.6383252739906311,
-0.16882473230361938,
0.16594064235687256,
-1.133771538734436,
-0.23410102725028992,
-0.21071206033229828,
-0.3815889060497284,
-0.08556228131055832,
-0.5663954615592957,
0.34893688559532166,
0.29660409688949585,
-0.336984246969223,
0.3632825016975403,
-0.5681002736091614,
0.6795225739479065,
0.42743605375289917,
0.12575118243694305,
0.697409987449646,
0.1495124250650406,
-0.3102761209011078,
-0.10960313677787781,
-0.7297127842903137,
-0.13063469529151917,
0.9766945838928223,
-0.06883575022220612,
0.7963383793830872,
0.3309215307235718,
1.0978422164916992,
-0.07968082278966904,
0.025505032390356064,
-0.8433048129081726,
0.7108657360076904,
-0.3333224654197693,
-0.49146121740341187,
-0.25607535243034363,
-0.6545519828796387,
-0.8710409998893738,
0.5609455704689026,
0.2748945951461792,
-0.27338293194770813,
0.0020785534288734198,
-0.06428830325603485,
-0.1716061532497406,
0.32518038153648376,
-0.5386664271354675,
0.449454128742218,
-0.30638906359672546,
-0.44159165024757385,
-0.17923492193222046,
-0.27606645226478577,
0.6313987970352173,
-0.35338568687438965,
0.02965552732348442,
-0.14460539817810059,
-0.16501937806606293,
0.45486554503440857,
-0.2242199033498764,
0.4368133842945099,
-0.28702789545059204,
-0.2112654596567154,
0.2690964341163635,
0.2656586766242981,
0.6136175394058228,
-0.03854005038738251,
-0.3666827976703644,
-0.06379672139883041,
-0.310731440782547,
-0.17938707768917084,
-0.5965113043785095,
0.830043613910675,
-0.8915631175041199,
-0.5478322505950928,
-0.10053814947605133,
-0.889352023601532,
-0.1353953331708908,
0.47244536876678467,
0.1801990419626236,
0.3838624656200409,
-0.345842570066452,
0.4656771123409271,
0.7446296811103821,
-0.05986408516764641,
0.31344717741012573,
0.774222731590271,
-0.10442142933607101,
-0.5340284109115601,
0.9708536267280579,
0.06340914964675903,
0.33140885829925537,
0.7864227294921875,
0.026952845975756645,
-0.1806543618440628,
-0.7542609572410583,
-0.10179344564676285,
0.3538834750652313,
-0.4453902542591095,
-0.5467973947525024,
-0.5196565985679626,
-0.37147951126098633,
0.016604479402303696,
-0.15961861610412598,
-0.40858158469200134,
-0.37347647547721863,
-0.2138427495956421,
-0.10385475307703018,
0.3738407492637634,
0.5490665435791016,
-0.06839422136545181,
0.27331870794296265,
-0.8705304265022278,
0.5030908584594727,
0.10483872890472412,
0.36694008111953735,
-0.16670170426368713,
-0.7137910723686218,
-0.18549880385398865,
-0.08122246712446213,
-0.2501235902309418,
0.003096655011177063,
0.6142287254333496,
0.3313429355621338,
0.48130089044570923,
0.49540260434150696,
-0.0308675616979599,
1.0376795530319214,
-0.6431523561477661,
0.37115177512168884,
0.07191795110702515,
-0.6038695573806763,
0.253328412771225,
-0.5205873250961304,
0.4372110366821289,
0.5764551162719727,
-0.08534494787454605,
-0.19006340205669403,
-0.31417834758758545,
-0.02434178814291954,
-0.8612310290336609,
0.644819438457489,
0.025018060579895973,
-0.07388610392808914,
-0.11942201107740402,
0.39293932914733887,
0.2886587381362915,
0.019830146804451942,
-0.6195216774940491,
-0.1354222595691681,
-0.13107948005199432,
-0.2719776928424835,
-0.2969864308834076,
-0.3325761556625366,
-0.07496248185634613,
-0.2371547818183899,
0.6335622668266296,
-0.04515909403562546,
0.20763692259788513,
0.3383433520793915,
-0.28333574533462524,
-0.358250230550766,
0.5435076355934143,
0.42543289065361023,
0.2588191628456116,
-0.5917093753814697,
0.1893714964389801,
-0.04685766622424126,
-0.5524992346763611,
0.1294037103652954,
-0.10931740701198578,
-0.5033530592918396,
-0.12206543236970901,
0.28625935316085815,
0.695647120475769,
0.40594279766082764,
-0.6303528547286987,
0.3920987546443939,
-0.029798299074172974,
-0.481785386800766,
-0.14462079107761383,
0.11013644188642502,
0.1699695736169815,
0.4607097804546356,
0.23410597443580627,
-0.26564010977745056,
-0.03783898428082466,
-0.27582356333732605,
0.33845654129981995,
0.8745527863502502,
-0.3339144289493561,
-0.2619059085845947,
0.6947606205940247,
0.13680747151374817,
-0.05237630382180214,
0.9664806127548218,
0.17035487294197083,
-0.21426115930080414,
0.14484277367591858,
0.877918004989624,
0.8911386132240295,
-0.19725465774536133,
-0.1112731322646141,
0.33098462224006653,
0.04048871621489525,
-0.021833432838320732,
0.45092952251434326,
-0.21833834052085876,
-0.8747351765632629,
-0.477864533662796,
-0.6734336614608765,
0.14048270881175995,
0.3156879246234894,
-0.6623334884643555,
0.09742177277803421,
-0.313574880361557,
-0.06066613644361496,
-0.416288286447525,
0.024248309433460236,
-0.44231563806533813,
-0.23254922032356262,
-0.07933633029460907,
0.711921751499176,
-0.03472226858139038,
1.5410093069076538,
0.24926571547985077,
-0.31323713064193726,
-0.783860981464386,
-0.20228971540927887,
0.05409128591418266,
-1.0849552154541016,
0.7140170931816101,
-0.130717933177948,
-0.41598382592201233,
0.05601435527205467,
-0.22311080992221832,
-0.8945612907409668,
1.4969403743743896,
0.5351247787475586,
-0.9065951704978943,
-0.077804796397686,
-0.056163255125284195,
0.3617493212223053,
-0.17341700196266174,
0.10101576894521713,
0.37270209193229675,
0.47180837392807007,
0.20055201649665833,
-0.9087420105934143,
0.048675376921892166,
-0.11317552626132965,
-0.1241491287946701,
0.5584954619407654,
-0.9747039675712585,
0.8994053602218628,
-0.36009007692337036,
-0.41916272044181824,
0.22455498576164246,
0.463929682970047,
0.29184871912002563,
-0.08904299885034561,
0.18679898977279663,
0.5752353668212891,
0.5576223134994507,
-0.009366043843328953,
0.894396960735321,
-0.268532395362854,
0.34836167097091675,
1.1301823854446411,
-0.560722827911377,
0.9997003078460693,
0.6213390231132507,
0.20849300920963287,
0.12739548087120056,
-0.017815914005041122,
0.012091758660972118,
0.8970344066619873,
-0.11924250423908234,
-0.5303292870521545,
-0.41835635900497437,
0.08762926608324051,
-0.4075428247451782,
0.4483702778816223,
0.2675843834877014,
-0.18866309523582458,
-0.3470174968242645,
-0.4076356291770935,
-0.08360778540372849,
-0.005244729574769735,
-0.2660805881023407,
0.9546231627464294,
0.24952203035354614,
-0.5548996925354004,
0.7655519843101501,
0.03336704522371292,
0.7974488139152527,
-0.9283998012542725,
0.020938487723469734,
-0.5065916776657104,
0.7667169570922852,
-0.16727860271930695,
-0.5209515690803528,
0.09527219831943512,
-0.31090685725212097,
-0.046052757650613785,
-0.2960658669471741,
0.802017867565155,
-0.755003809928894,
-0.32316818833351135,
0.5550894737243652,
0.7683327794075012,
-0.01001731213182211,
0.2046782523393631,
-0.45199820399284363,
0.13481222093105316,
0.2396519035100937,
-0.5057994723320007,
0.6628057956695557,
0.79788738489151,
0.14244891703128815,
0.6747775077819824,
0.5544607043266296,
0.046676889061927795,
0.14522795379161835,
0.05634965002536774,
0.8154227137565613,
-0.9880307912826538,
-0.025027384981513023,
-0.6828543543815613,
0.3936113119125366,
0.197182759642601,
0.11098551005125046,
0.867831826210022,
0.9395291209220886,
0.716335654258728,
-0.15205100178718567,
0.8513014316558838,
-0.017325736582279205,
0.6838014125823975,
-0.5219081044197083,
0.7188486456871033,
-0.7176465392112732,
0.40672656893730164,
-0.08411185443401337,
-0.8997731804847717,
-0.3735602796077728,
0.5541936159133911,
-0.021676354110240936,
0.07499860227108002,
0.6195301413536072,
0.8506321310997009,
-0.53194659948349,
-0.28535446524620056,
0.703790545463562,
0.4077981412410736,
0.26379647850990295,
0.758204996585846,
0.7111321687698364,
-0.3214908242225647,
0.7282182574272156,
-0.1645044982433319,
0.003583379788324237,
-0.22150519490242004,
-0.565958559513092,
-0.8321325182914734,
-0.34548577666282654,
0.09313645958900452,
0.07608306407928467,
0.06897023320198059,
0.5849864482879639,
0.3828370273113251,
-0.5803747177124023,
-0.4207758903503418,
0.019342154264450073,
-0.026989849284291267,
-0.02755749598145485,
-0.26659277081489563,
0.4862787425518036,
-0.3248382806777954,
-0.7126792669296265,
0.8779784440994263,
0.40903669595718384,
-0.1784704476594925,
0.069411501288414,
-0.1659298986196518,
-0.19135279953479767,
-0.0019611890893429518,
0.7820814847946167,
0.10460764914751053,
-0.6803024411201477,
-0.3426609933376312,
0.08948948979377747,
-0.20949091017246246,
0.25275918841362,
1.0155858993530273,
-0.8195045590400696,
0.2890666723251343,
0.3642798364162445,
0.5509600639343262,
0.6759648323059082,
0.06291668862104416,
0.6820333003997803,
-0.6195929050445557,
0.08478152751922607,
0.20441389083862305,
0.44079452753067017,
0.17807768285274506,
-0.32445865869522095,
0.46462851762771606,
-0.024122854694724083,
-0.7863689661026001,
-0.7944086194038391,
0.1979103535413742,
-1.2429335117340088,
-0.14252904057502747,
1.115730881690979,
0.09503204375505447,
-0.014313675463199615,
-0.16632363200187683,
-0.37027427554130554,
0.11204404383897781,
-0.7023252844810486,
0.6680938005447388,
0.32073310017585754,
-0.2239416390657425,
-0.1313370168209076,
-0.6284418702125549,
0.3053581118583679,
0.3375496566295624,
-0.3001629412174225,
0.2645684480667114,
0.617568850517273,
0.5194814205169678,
-0.23783279955387115,
1.0024889707565308,
-0.28664878010749817,
-0.08260823786258698,
-0.11469956487417221,
-0.03782675787806511,
-0.40331488847732544,
-0.11399228870868683,
-0.29446884989738464,
0.28694337606430054,
0.055238764733076096,
0.06051996350288391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01994v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01994v1
|
Vanilla Transformers are Transfer Capability Teachers
| 2024-03-04T12:40:28 | 2024-03-04T12:40:28 |
Xin Lu, Yanyan Zhao, Bing Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, Mixture of Experts (MoE) Transformers have garnered increasing
attention due to their advantages in model capacity and computational
efficiency. However, studies have indicated that MoE Transformers underperform
vanilla Transformers in many downstream tasks, significantly diminishing the
practical value of MoE models. To explain this issue, we propose that the
pre-training performance and transfer capability of a model are joint
determinants of its downstream task performance. MoE models, in comparison to
vanilla models, have poorer transfer capability, leading to their subpar
performance in downstream tasks. To address this issue, we introduce the
concept of transfer capability distillation, positing that although vanilla
models have weaker performance, they are effective teachers of transfer
capability. The MoE models guided by vanilla models can achieve both strong
pre-training performance and transfer capability, ultimately enhancing their
performance in downstream tasks. We design a specific distillation method and
conduct experiments on the BERT architecture. Experimental results show a
significant improvement in downstream performance of MoE models, and many
further evidences also strongly support the concept of transfer capability
distillation. Finally, we attempt to interpret transfer capability distillation
and provide some insights from the perspective of model feature.
|
[
-0.6447557210922241,
-0.4572509527206421,
0.7069515585899353,
0.16146349906921387,
-0.3186887502670288,
0.3444765508174896,
-0.16591310501098633,
-0.5815402269363403,
-0.16620376706123352,
0.32123732566833496,
-0.4357108175754547,
0.35002216696739197,
-1.4609707593917847,
0.08197548240423203,
-0.9291893839836121,
1.058664083480835,
0.048134949058294296,
-0.23797035217285156,
-0.1945364624261856,
0.48133161664009094,
-0.8422202467918396,
-0.40393534302711487,
-0.4097200334072113,
-0.5358073115348816,
0.1663200557231903,
0.297830194234848,
0.5758950710296631,
0.27083462476730347,
0.5792993307113647,
0.42725878953933716,
0.013297166675329208,
-0.2583807408809662,
-0.8251386284828186,
0.0883505567908287,
-0.5603556036949158,
-0.6402037143707275,
-0.5409716367721558,
0.029393956065177917,
0.2020602524280548,
0.6328518390655518,
0.005769318901002407,
0.1715773642063141,
0.38450154662132263,
0.5671740770339966,
-0.5996081233024597,
0.3180595934391022,
-0.9957717657089233,
-0.08727344870567322,
0.012752847746014595,
0.05850469321012497,
-0.5521339774131775,
-0.30712419748306274,
0.7160715460777283,
-0.5677168369293213,
0.3615509867668152,
-0.1710818111896515,
0.866935133934021,
0.44326281547546387,
-0.6602181196212769,
-0.07765235751867294,
-1.1577153205871582,
0.9391778111457825,
-0.6697797179222107,
-0.1869569569826126,
0.4087452292442322,
0.7404452562332153,
0.08463679254055023,
-1.1633853912353516,
-0.7516964673995972,
0.09399603307247162,
-0.4351966679096222,
0.03851348161697388,
-0.2274324744939804,
-0.23595696687698364,
0.09258927404880524,
0.5152528285980225,
0.18095791339874268,
0.02146267704665661,
-0.9872373342514038,
-0.1187165305018425,
0.5644384622573853,
-0.08010461181402206,
-0.06605955213308334,
0.31206053495407104,
-0.5788816213607788,
-0.3513484597206116,
0.07504177838563919,
0.14035451412200928,
0.12724964320659637,
0.29903361201286316,
-0.07080624252557755,
0.1469338983297348,
-0.09617847949266434,
0.4199061095714569,
0.33751457929611206,
-0.4118422269821167,
0.0365213081240654,
0.010319232940673828,
0.049418509006500244,
0.167964905500412,
0.3217216432094574,
-0.0006414022063836455,
0.4666299521923065,
-0.17085206508636475,
-0.3483855724334717,
-0.2612135708332062,
0.7946228384971619,
-0.9981675148010254,
-0.6549103856086731,
-0.261227011680603,
-0.5974096655845642,
-0.650297999382019,
0.14793550968170166,
-0.5445719957351685,
0.0552574060857296,
-0.6934628486633301,
0.9422537088394165,
-0.530076801776886,
-0.7123213410377502,
-0.15554063022136688,
-0.6132389307022095,
0.0011348791886121035,
0.2978571653366089,
-1.3274152278900146,
0.5016729235649109,
0.7822490334510803,
0.7398592233657837,
-0.4559411406517029,
-0.1267918199300766,
-0.13108831644058228,
0.3741762638092041,
0.09406404942274094,
0.692439615726471,
-0.4148784875869751,
-0.8063399195671082,
-0.3449215590953827,
-0.08283878117799759,
-0.08807195723056793,
-0.5090876221656799,
0.4805322289466858,
-0.34985262155532837,
-0.23174938559532166,
-0.3879472017288208,
-0.3310339152812958,
-0.4472062885761261,
-0.18274877965450287,
-0.4415275454521179,
0.8481089472770691,
0.421142578125,
-0.3165109157562256,
0.517631471157074,
-0.4054236114025116,
-0.8165960311889648,
-0.197410449385643,
0.3185335397720337,
0.03672346472740173,
0.6758837699890137,
0.08070170134305954,
0.5855300426483154,
-0.29806092381477356,
0.13633395731449127,
-0.39246538281440735,
-0.389585018157959,
0.43876412510871887,
-0.583861768245697,
0.6636483073234558,
0.4655973017215729,
-0.20525667071342468,
-0.2143600434064865,
-0.8157795667648315,
-0.1674153208732605,
-0.4614396095275879,
-0.20606155693531036,
-0.5658446550369263,
-0.2697018086910248,
-0.20800946652889252,
0.18154451251029968,
0.110358826816082,
-0.29260873794555664,
0.26174086332321167,
0.2884329557418823,
0.45237672328948975,
1.0976979732513428,
-0.34030717611312866,
0.9306393265724182,
-0.44452252984046936,
0.22295522689819336,
0.20312483608722687,
0.28627946972846985,
0.11598969995975494,
-0.48674947023391724,
-0.9527691006660461,
-0.6548166871070862,
0.49210456013679504,
0.28525686264038086,
-0.6680582761764526,
0.4987454116344452,
-0.47379782795906067,
-0.6569328904151917,
-0.5211102962493896,
0.1461319625377655,
-0.07877007126808167,
1.0796452760696411,
0.556667685508728,
-0.5474242568016052,
-0.12000832706689835,
-1.1213070154190063,
0.13985349237918854,
-0.317533940076828,
-0.07332976162433624,
-0.28137075901031494,
0.3498806953430176,
0.21803869307041168,
1.1112061738967896,
-0.7092397212982178,
-0.4398301839828491,
-0.24440544843673706,
0.5941190123558044,
0.5269794464111328,
0.6253659725189209,
1.0362763404846191,
-0.8410341143608093,
-0.7869144082069397,
0.16396483778953552,
-0.5920013189315796,
-0.1842760592699051,
0.09434038400650024,
-0.522894561290741,
-0.22706657648086548,
0.22352637350559235,
-0.4819723963737488,
0.3404759466648102,
0.5405387282371521,
0.11710364371538162,
0.46900224685668945,
-0.2784992456436157,
0.3727138340473175,
-1.133669137954712,
0.0992925688624382,
-0.3913232088088989,
-0.10549935698509216,
-0.6176326870918274,
-0.204440638422966,
-0.03810060769319534,
0.16811512410640717,
-0.5401766896247864,
0.08052107691764832,
-0.2547881603240967,
0.1275668889284134,
-0.41335585713386536,
-0.47017812728881836,
0.128183513879776,
0.2561747431755066,
-0.09678415209054947,
0.7356656789779663,
0.8736704587936401,
-1.059630036354065,
0.5194178819656372,
0.15685270726680756,
-0.09004898369312286,
1.0004886388778687,
-0.5503104329109192,
0.1143374815583229,
0.16007588803768158,
0.04598142206668854,
-1.1182550191879272,
0.08677875250577927,
-0.23511868715286255,
-0.3029312789440155,
0.893750011920929,
-0.5452671647071838,
-0.07930492609739304,
-0.3252379894256592,
0.1591721475124359,
0.07373379170894623,
1.542442798614502,
-0.1787564754486084,
1.1843163967132568,
-0.14042708277702332,
-0.286456435918808,
-0.5196511149406433,
-1.1059285402297974,
-0.37587887048721313,
-0.2995111346244812,
-0.7370100617408752,
0.6810541749000549,
0.27262717485427856,
0.039207376539707184,
0.43877631425857544,
-0.2392263561487198,
-0.529865026473999,
0.27077218890190125,
0.20276853442192078,
0.4032721221446991,
-0.3104361295700073,
-0.23190321028232574,
0.3990679085254669,
-0.2911593019962311,
0.28941401839256287,
-0.22694917023181915,
0.06811321526765823,
0.22136232256889343,
-0.3213304579257965,
-0.4958239793777466,
-0.03749528527259827,
0.7164192795753479,
-0.017492346465587616,
1.010978102684021,
0.6212127804756165,
0.12575507164001465,
-0.25060775876045227,
-0.667729914188385,
-0.7004842758178711,
-0.5138397216796875,
0.2849807143211365,
-0.7637338042259216,
-0.12996836006641388,
0.6352002620697021,
-0.30263346433639526,
0.17616569995880127,
0.4333987534046173,
0.2559167444705963,
-0.22467225790023804,
0.5004029870033264,
0.7600908279418945,
-0.0001506131811765954,
0.40597105026245117,
-0.4423127770423889,
0.366036981344223,
-0.5670987963676453,
-0.22598733007907867,
-0.6491849422454834,
-0.9257615804672241,
-0.23701263964176178,
-0.13347694277763367,
0.10278378427028656,
0.23217788338661194,
-0.07921528071165085,
0.5360507369041443,
-0.42354997992515564,
0.27041029930114746,
0.5821566581726074,
-0.05033901706337929,
0.5293567180633545,
0.14198344945907593,
0.08811067044734955,
-0.10127471387386322,
-0.5575577020645142,
-0.4535788595676422,
1.112111210823059,
0.2887013852596283,
1.0458630323410034,
0.09927818179130554,
0.5055009126663208,
0.5725806355476379,
0.6465623378753662,
-0.5999118089675903,
0.3670610189437866,
-0.4499449133872986,
-0.8748325109481812,
0.06894077360630035,
-0.28989240527153015,
-0.32766231894493103,
0.33718690276145935,
-0.45163893699645996,
-0.526617705821991,
0.43874305486679077,
0.15629205107688904,
-0.21204021573066711,
0.6179370880126953,
-1.1041265726089478,
0.5226442217826843,
-0.3200140595436096,
-0.35765573382377625,
-0.37562280893325806,
-0.4420924484729767,
0.4872368574142456,
-0.5352740287780762,
0.03490382805466652,
-0.19147486984729767,
0.2687075734138489,
0.14228186011314392,
-0.396528035402298,
0.5630656480789185,
-0.323873907327652,
-0.07626444846391678,
0.28648293018341064,
0.37065204977989197,
0.19763223826885223,
-0.2572716176509857,
-0.2517511248588562,
0.4089833199977875,
-0.01918337121605873,
-0.34912312030792236,
-0.773064136505127,
0.6726058125495911,
-0.9369155168533325,
-1.0161528587341309,
-0.28662559390068054,
-0.4799579083919525,
-0.1800774186849594,
0.2684174180030823,
0.4271487593650818,
0.01936541497707367,
0.1906370371580124,
0.4718618392944336,
0.6317445039749146,
0.34540697932243347,
0.47493353486061096,
0.3640913963317871,
-0.10341712087392807,
0.2870063781738281,
0.5812363624572754,
0.41537001729011536,
0.743908166885376,
0.3642652928829193,
0.047465816140174866,
-0.3627954423427582,
-0.7481822967529297,
-0.3654468059539795,
-0.3338915705680847,
-0.8037080764770508,
-0.07087000459432602,
-0.5678133964538574,
-0.424591064453125,
-0.3021888732910156,
-0.3521086275577545,
-0.7595208883285522,
-0.5613760948181152,
-0.5077993273735046,
-0.07069386541843414,
0.4787110984325409,
0.6650654673576355,
-0.06633397936820984,
0.4492233693599701,
-1.0835380554199219,
0.2704452872276306,
0.7895391583442688,
0.07784975320100784,
0.332882821559906,
-1.0763447284698486,
0.009578014723956585,
0.25816187262535095,
-0.6997978687286377,
-0.5928098559379578,
0.1545892357826233,
0.22542981803417206,
0.7553911209106445,
0.5866146087646484,
0.4976562559604645,
0.9187915325164795,
-0.22482191026210785,
0.6149274110794067,
0.20547890663146973,
-1.176434874534607,
0.22055767476558685,
0.0794573426246643,
-0.26378294825553894,
0.6924035549163818,
0.5758193135261536,
0.3126291036605835,
-0.37259697914123535,
-0.3337240517139435,
-0.7898966670036316,
0.9295495748519897,
0.5207918882369995,
0.607145369052887,
0.5648497343063354,
0.1385105699300766,
0.6663138270378113,
0.16027401387691498,
-0.4068375825881958,
-0.21177902817726135,
-0.3358515799045563,
0.14645466208457947,
0.08121096342802048,
-0.1415623426437378,
0.11835556477308273,
-0.3774638772010803,
0.7027118802070618,
0.2890835404396057,
-0.0677429586648941,
0.14259889721870422,
-0.08201709389686584,
0.0819334164261818,
0.12755119800567627,
0.13140103220939636,
0.8729434609413147,
-0.3492140769958496,
0.30232542753219604,
0.3995428681373596,
-0.5874089002609253,
0.515052855014801,
0.012493809685111046,
0.1598937213420868,
-0.1331205517053604,
0.5667528510093689,
0.5913047194480896,
0.09252539277076721,
0.16519813239574432,
0.3138478696346283,
-0.10861621052026749,
-0.3957662582397461,
-0.1097409576177597,
0.5460783243179321,
0.10727079212665558,
0.25559473037719727,
0.9439103007316589,
0.5917631983757019,
0.3260648548603058,
-0.6546383500099182,
0.024778276681900024,
-0.13167881965637207,
-0.2356933355331421,
-0.5330027937889099,
0.6482241749763489,
0.6112598776817322,
0.09341000765562057,
1.015613079071045,
0.3036365807056427,
-0.2616475224494934,
0.6135497093200684,
0.3238775134086609,
0.8545168042182922,
-0.2925841212272644,
-0.08477643877267838,
0.10745998471975327,
0.18636685609817505,
-0.31868496537208557,
-0.36562713980674744,
-0.22565677762031555,
-0.43120256066322327,
-0.6044442653656006,
-0.6637539267539978,
-0.0477607287466526,
-0.0950358659029007,
-1.0625497102737427,
0.5348933935165405,
0.013477004133164883,
-0.6415812373161316,
0.04366429150104523,
-0.66615891456604,
-0.8396966457366943,
-0.2073759287595749,
-0.03497633337974548,
0.7279173731803894,
-0.8893954157829285,
0.9286298751831055,
0.4924619495868683,
-0.3268337845802307,
-0.8630461692810059,
-0.1698543131351471,
-0.4058975577354431,
-0.45348453521728516,
1.2048331499099731,
0.003409826895222068,
-0.0030141319148242474,
-0.016308272257447243,
0.02930055744946003,
-0.6678720116615295,
1.2099272012710571,
0.6520559787750244,
-0.695016086101532,
-0.07386995851993561,
0.2190321683883667,
0.5910949110984802,
-0.2633412182331085,
0.4548317492008209,
0.6201947331428528,
0.6656385660171509,
0.5249213576316833,
-1.454392433166504,
-0.03282883018255234,
-0.018045175820589066,
0.33256423473358154,
-0.13138039410114288,
-0.3648371398448944,
1.160142183303833,
-0.04947653040289879,
-0.06289755553007126,
-0.030545420944690704,
0.5998629927635193,
-0.24480965733528137,
0.06273738294839859,
0.4122808873653412,
0.5980228781700134,
0.1147504448890686,
-0.3496271073818207,
1.1749533414840698,
-0.023053497076034546,
0.2339574694633484,
0.7264498472213745,
-0.22530904412269592,
0.7643523812294006,
0.7777315974235535,
-0.4036843180656433,
0.674206554889679,
0.0928100049495697,
0.2052045315504074,
0.9862716794013977,
0.05456066504120827,
-0.12537845969200134,
-0.16159364581108093,
0.1653544306755066,
-0.6487451195716858,
0.5359834432601929,
-0.005024555139243603,
-0.5527443289756775,
-0.15143650770187378,
0.06511719524860382,
-0.2526658773422241,
0.1031988188624382,
-0.25531110167503357,
0.8669277429580688,
0.1830064356327057,
-0.8659176826477051,
0.6091635227203369,
-0.568629801273346,
0.7954851388931274,
-0.8329465389251709,
-0.21308870613574982,
-0.04251043125987053,
0.4854200482368469,
-0.24245016276836395,
-0.8462875485420227,
0.5903326272964478,
-0.21563056111335754,
-0.466039776802063,
-0.5855556726455688,
0.8310016393661499,
-0.09550309181213379,
-0.4358101785182953,
0.40227726101875305,
0.4777681827545166,
0.041766099631786346,
-0.07620418816804886,
-0.2603377401828766,
-0.23611341416835785,
-0.025273330509662628,
-0.09914824366569519,
0.46114739775657654,
0.8652099370956421,
0.25413259863853455,
0.5060341358184814,
0.7659258842468262,
0.2617063820362091,
0.17670804262161255,
-0.3195900022983551,
0.9981517791748047,
-0.011100221425294876,
-0.5327929854393005,
-0.925455629825592,
0.8921372890472412,
-0.09790032356977463,
-0.06064329296350479,
0.5419809222221375,
0.1691790521144867,
0.9873594641685486,
-0.6893075108528137,
0.8381235599517822,
-0.49392908811569214,
0.03075571171939373,
-0.4597282409667969,
1.0054126977920532,
-0.28230804204940796,
0.30502864718437195,
-0.08400196582078934,
-1.3329839706420898,
0.659874677658081,
0.5590490102767944,
-0.38783568143844604,
0.17118261754512787,
0.4789585769176483,
0.3032612204551697,
-0.675678551197052,
-0.06802120804786682,
0.4617546498775482,
0.2870982885360718,
0.44297516345977783,
0.4710811376571655,
1.0148357152938843,
-0.3528163433074951,
0.5476709008216858,
-0.8143498301506042,
-0.1236596554517746,
-0.37812718749046326,
-1.0872942209243774,
-0.8405448198318481,
-0.7271762490272522,
-0.18715910613536835,
0.004615526646375656,
-0.30618786811828613,
0.25466668605804443,
1.3603230714797974,
-0.646134614944458,
-0.13876448571681976,
-0.039200540632009506,
-0.19155806303024292,
-0.38468241691589355,
-0.27454060316085815,
-0.06864196062088013,
-0.47113510966300964,
-0.9296365976333618,
-0.07931694388389587,
-0.016893712803721428,
0.27838972210884094,
-0.2668006420135498,
0.14536182582378387,
0.08111997693777084,
-0.14615359902381897,
0.49161115288734436,
-0.2105736881494522,
-0.38090428709983826,
-0.18466131389141083,
-0.22937314212322235,
0.13935808837413788,
-0.38867393136024475,
0.8429254293441772,
-0.778820812702179,
0.520311176776886,
0.6221935749053955,
0.6114470958709717,
0.7593837380409241,
0.073867566883564,
0.7982946634292603,
-0.6949535608291626,
0.4307435154914856,
0.19559389352798462,
0.2913246154785156,
0.010480647906661034,
-0.4295032024383545,
0.4127108156681061,
0.1471700817346573,
-0.2978036403656006,
-0.6436346769332886,
-0.010688339360058308,
-0.8843634724617004,
-0.4991217851638794,
0.6538878679275513,
-0.4734038710594177,
-0.005850857123732567,
-0.11065959185361862,
-0.36395788192749023,
0.3383198082447052,
-0.4860348105430603,
1.1041085720062256,
1.0905479192733765,
-0.11574004590511322,
0.1443883180618286,
-0.5651256442070007,
0.3611886501312256,
0.4231027066707611,
-0.5488064885139465,
-0.3181755542755127,
0.033467020839452744,
0.5868591070175171,
0.4793989360332489,
0.0452541783452034,
-0.17423595488071442,
-0.019289324060082436,
0.20782513916492462,
-0.12876860797405243,
-0.5511924028396606,
-0.20743101835250854,
0.22017021477222443,
0.07448190450668335,
0.13196243345737457,
-0.23374013602733612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01988v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01988v1
|
FakeNewsGPT4: Advancing Multimodal Fake News Detection through Knowledge-Augmented LVLMs
| 2024-03-04T12:35:09 | 2024-03-04T12:35:09 |
Xuannan Liu, Peipei Li, Huaibo Huang, Zekun Li, Xing Cui, Jiahao Liang, Lixiong Qin, Weihong Deng, Zhaofeng He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The massive generation of multimodal fake news exhibits substantial
distribution discrepancies, prompting the need for generalized detectors.
However, the insulated nature of training within specific domains restricts the
capability of classical detectors to obtain open-world facts. In this paper, we
propose FakeNewsGPT4, a novel framework that augments Large Vision-Language
Models (LVLMs) with forgery-specific knowledge for manipulation reasoning while
inheriting extensive world knowledge as complementary. Knowledge augmentation
in FakeNewsGPT4 involves acquiring two types of forgery-specific knowledge,
i.e., semantic correlation and artifact trace, and merging them into LVLMs.
Specifically, we design a multi-level cross-modal reasoning module that
establishes interactions across modalities for extracting semantic
correlations. Concurrently, a dual-branch fine-grained verification module is
presented to comprehend localized details to encode artifact traces. The
generated knowledge is translated into refined embeddings compatible with
LVLMs. We also incorporate candidate answer heuristics and soft prompts to
enhance input informativeness. Extensive experiments on the public benchmark
demonstrate that FakeNewsGPT4 achieves superior cross-domain performance
compared to previous methods. Code will be available.
|
[
-0.32891401648521423,
-0.9078829884529114,
0.7270617485046387,
-0.033332664519548416,
-0.2668909430503845,
0.10179107636213303,
0.025916632264852524,
-0.6753320097923279,
0.15648923814296722,
0.3630855083465576,
-0.3841264545917511,
-0.2717667520046234,
-0.4180150032043457,
-0.11676712334156036,
-0.3379194438457489,
0.859803318977356,
-0.0560917891561985,
0.05403857305645943,
-0.1558186262845993,
-0.06853125989437103,
-0.15555593371391296,
-0.5823155045509338,
-0.17104105651378632,
0.020610563457012177,
0.47271281480789185,
-0.0008037721854634583,
0.5989970564842224,
0.2477046251296997,
0.13013973832130432,
0.24973678588867188,
0.3441690504550934,
0.7572969794273376,
-0.11972635239362717,
-0.2462836056947708,
-0.2666182219982147,
-0.27150219678878784,
-0.3546689450740814,
-0.00616350956261158,
0.34033241868019104,
-0.04691605642437935,
0.1126619502902031,
-0.01790504902601242,
-0.3110572397708893,
0.06908087432384491,
-0.7508669495582581,
0.22967293858528137,
-0.762243926525116,
-0.13436929881572723,
-0.2448275089263916,
-0.3847885727882385,
-0.35811370611190796,
-0.08071764558553696,
-0.04380179941654205,
-0.7206164002418518,
0.25509509444236755,
0.08665347844362259,
0.842132031917572,
0.06994561105966568,
-0.6747106909751892,
-0.14516118168830872,
-0.4684726297855377,
0.5876243710517883,
-0.6639291048049927,
0.7421631217002869,
0.21844391524791718,
0.4032462239265442,
0.019844206050038338,
-0.9756650328636169,
-0.9253836870193481,
-0.07894126325845718,
-0.008663821034133434,
0.1435813307762146,
-0.20668651163578033,
-0.01130906492471695,
0.278486967086792,
0.3534844219684601,
-0.7203999161720276,
-0.2673429548740387,
-0.37302547693252563,
-0.741478681564331,
0.15583936870098114,
-0.20308354496955872,
0.43144986033439636,
-0.1925925612449646,
-0.6069496273994446,
0.17559193074703217,
-0.45843493938446045,
-0.15241582691669464,
0.44198328256607056,
0.041711628437042236,
-0.08358480036258698,
0.47232306003570557,
-0.33922672271728516,
0.9476026892662048,
0.0007828682428225875,
-0.4026789963245392,
0.540410041809082,
-0.6462742686271667,
-0.31210964918136597,
-0.03245949372649193,
0.42519310116767883,
0.35734814405441284,
-0.12319750338792801,
-0.13596709072589874,
-0.2447785586118698,
0.24419376254081726,
0.2758568823337555,
-0.5042944550514221,
-0.16977795958518982,
-0.02277669683098793,
-0.3868200182914734,
-0.44864189624786377,
0.03212764114141464,
-0.5969624519348145,
-0.3917428255081177,
-0.3892505466938019,
0.8625756502151489,
-0.48832082748413086,
-0.4613434970378876,
0.27652066946029663,
-0.46806421875953674,
0.22299669682979584,
0.6019167304039001,
-0.26950445771217346,
-0.2539557218551636,
0.5366935729980469,
0.5889981389045715,
-0.037401337176561356,
-0.1752549558877945,
-0.7735105156898499,
0.29651880264282227,
-0.12323003262281418,
0.7771978974342346,
-0.5510799884796143,
0.2749735116958618,
0.16367338597774506,
-0.01770641840994358,
0.18865542113780975,
-0.25652071833610535,
0.6757388710975647,
-0.9295952916145325,
0.5473588705062866,
-0.3146102726459503,
-0.412002831697464,
-0.3394079804420471,
0.8923830986022949,
-0.6455990672111511,
0.8371483087539673,
0.17600956559181213,
-0.9050300717353821,
0.4503050446510315,
-0.3531961441040039,
-0.427939236164093,
0.013015462085604668,
-0.09750572592020035,
-0.2958853840827942,
-0.22012774646282196,
0.5117141604423523,
0.3184605836868286,
0.17339256405830383,
0.1803899109363556,
-0.38095030188560486,
-0.13688910007476807,
-0.03422723710536957,
-0.8096904754638672,
0.5165020823478699,
0.05247323587536812,
-0.4540588855743408,
0.19533132016658783,
-0.8051964640617371,
-0.03778870031237602,
-0.146903395652771,
-0.41939371824264526,
-0.4884442985057831,
-0.4251895844936371,
-0.1275220513343811,
0.31918254494667053,
0.3170035183429718,
-0.6761139035224915,
0.2598360478878021,
-0.14960218966007233,
0.19500882923603058,
0.6388283967971802,
0.16774649918079376,
0.4495653212070465,
-0.2561419606208801,
0.11271879822015762,
0.357712060213089,
0.5081148147583008,
-0.34150758385658264,
-0.47683727741241455,
-0.6830644607543945,
-0.2189277708530426,
0.037126000970602036,
0.5005202889442444,
-1.72334623336792,
-0.06810267269611359,
-0.2230256050825119,
-0.14278066158294678,
-0.14023347198963165,
0.07450241595506668,
0.37294670939445496,
0.42162448167800903,
0.6190844774246216,
0.01066911593079567,
-0.6935650706291199,
-0.9429800510406494,
-0.8213257193565369,
0.0726434513926506,
0.1349167823791504,
-0.11110500246286392,
0.5040012001991272,
-0.1717265397310257,
0.8327338695526123,
-0.04634173586964607,
-0.3482300043106079,
-0.14063231647014618,
0.10756585001945496,
-0.15352292358875275,
0.21635328233242035,
0.5181260704994202,
-1.195752501487732,
-0.17360249161720276,
0.014766152948141098,
-0.767015278339386,
0.19071203470230103,
-0.1415034681558609,
-0.004474228248000145,
0.4461280405521393,
0.4756147563457489,
-0.791648268699646,
0.617295503616333,
0.6779367327690125,
-0.4716101288795471,
0.8242579698562622,
-0.05616166070103645,
0.41683056950569153,
-0.9027941226959229,
-0.36902961134910583,
-0.0057399389334023,
-0.7458203434944153,
-0.6120920777320862,
0.10568210482597351,
0.16618040204048157,
0.1200454831123352,
-0.5858041048049927,
0.5711771249771118,
-0.6500452756881714,
-0.1757008284330368,
-0.26981478929519653,
0.17245614528656006,
0.22818313539028168,
0.4905467927455902,
0.011819835752248764,
0.4459904432296753,
0.2532290816307068,
-0.3563707768917084,
0.7135763168334961,
-0.15019848942756653,
-0.3773278295993805,
0.5368411540985107,
-0.15290330350399017,
-0.05281643196940422,
-0.02210409753024578,
0.592722475528717,
-0.4613625109195709,
-0.4271399974822998,
0.380911648273468,
-0.6547134518623352,
0.07867356389760971,
-0.28643494844436646,
-0.7472149133682251,
-0.33271893858909607,
-0.1253872662782669,
0.4416157007217407,
0.3805105984210968,
-0.7840368151664734,
1.0641875267028809,
0.17845310270786285,
0.4908931851387024,
-0.6168515682220459,
-0.6991368532180786,
0.09744638949632645,
0.1545918881893158,
-0.8471141457557678,
0.3022584319114685,
-0.024945029988884926,
-0.3498062491416931,
0.23235836625099182,
-0.33834919333457947,
-0.16060204803943634,
-0.43104109168052673,
-0.037286754697561264,
0.07918497174978256,
-0.26411205530166626,
0.1902931183576584,
-0.026289664208889008,
0.222894549369812,
-0.058939386159181595,
-0.6181731224060059,
0.3687937259674072,
-0.22287768125534058,
-0.7139579057693481,
-0.3710941672325134,
-0.052906978875398636,
0.7948392033576965,
-0.38938671350479126,
0.6265124082565308,
1.0395629405975342,
-0.4339616000652313,
-0.3410680294036865,
-0.9135477542877197,
-0.326464980840683,
-0.4562305510044098,
0.14696820080280304,
-0.43850576877593994,
-0.8427404761314392,
0.23938295245170593,
-0.02849331684410572,
0.006201800890266895,
0.15556128323078156,
0.5860412120819092,
0.39164209365844727,
0.8892931342124939,
0.3498302400112152,
0.12945719063282013,
0.3451252579689026,
-0.10722250491380692,
0.3823012411594391,
-0.3469108045101166,
-0.3794246315956116,
0.2799253463745117,
-0.15377821028232574,
0.018724750727415085,
-1.1268373727798462,
0.3868388831615448,
-0.09411650151014328,
-0.13984307646751404,
0.04091889038681984,
-0.2859688699245453,
0.594139575958252,
0.6981726288795471,
0.2717764675617218,
0.7132383584976196,
0.13655409216880798,
0.047041818499565125,
0.040318164974451065,
-0.6710016131401062,
-0.05413138121366501,
0.9155974388122559,
0.2848983407020569,
0.5931733846664429,
0.23918934166431427,
0.1920344978570938,
0.47961750626564026,
0.2938747704029083,
-0.5473355650901794,
0.3226187825202942,
0.1729459911584854,
-0.6726911067962646,
0.08447320014238358,
-0.41198304295539856,
-0.24677684903144836,
0.5388173460960388,
-0.2273128181695938,
-0.11445506662130356,
0.11004113405942917,
0.39228495955467224,
-0.12127440422773361,
0.7753358483314514,
-0.6720890998840332,
0.6491267681121826,
-0.2832128405570984,
-0.37373873591423035,
-0.24717392027378082,
-0.5034177303314209,
0.9281538128852844,
-0.06334110349416733,
0.5375547409057617,
0.050963327288627625,
0.014116080477833748,
0.12972819805145264,
-0.2909947335720062,
1.0186890363693237,
-0.3700523376464844,
-0.1225016638636589,
0.22141195833683014,
0.27460619807243347,
0.6801730990409851,
0.2851051390171051,
0.3084007501602173,
0.1347220540046692,
-0.21073101460933685,
-0.33000555634498596,
-0.6649519801139832,
0.8773533701896667,
-0.3582541346549988,
-0.6325374841690063,
-0.5055387020111084,
-0.6831141710281372,
-0.40557029843330383,
0.23496486246585846,
0.2842106521129608,
0.6920598745346069,
0.11718771606683731,
0.08230558037757874,
0.7492805123329163,
-0.2638135850429535,
0.2510887682437897,
0.583665668964386,
-0.38817012310028076,
-0.2720670700073242,
1.0954712629318237,
-0.13217423856258392,
0.29281583428382874,
0.30622631311416626,
0.039887379854917526,
-0.28125688433647156,
-0.269168496131897,
-0.8226948380470276,
0.03204025700688362,
-0.8321715593338013,
-0.3406274616718292,
-0.6673187613487244,
-0.2003137618303299,
-0.5328015685081482,
-0.06894557923078537,
-0.3800746202468872,
-0.36653900146484375,
-0.018991559743881226,
-0.23464080691337585,
0.33937618136405945,
0.3498549163341522,
-0.3393734097480774,
-0.061797790229320526,
-0.842808187007904,
0.8016508221626282,
0.5084194540977478,
0.20310024917125702,
-0.21982428431510925,
-0.6227224469184875,
-0.12789076566696167,
0.2985413670539856,
-0.07942074537277222,
-0.7113195657730103,
0.43014270067214966,
-0.11403074115514755,
0.5876941084861755,
0.45145469903945923,
0.20669309794902802,
0.6061409115791321,
-0.38838502764701843,
0.9399852752685547,
0.25680291652679443,
-0.906630277633667,
0.34205570816993713,
-0.5163781046867371,
0.04719417914748192,
-0.06013039872050285,
0.21725647151470184,
-0.30700740218162537,
-0.4137568175792694,
-0.6006448268890381,
-0.4952801764011383,
0.5178295969963074,
0.14710673689842224,
0.1839577704668045,
0.11722686141729355,
0.05372198298573494,
0.06476780772209167,
0.16965138912200928,
-1.203540563583374,
-0.030364153906702995,
-0.6179426312446594,
-0.13088218867778778,
0.4645034670829773,
-0.23823297023773193,
-0.3910945653915405,
-0.35444405674934387,
0.8423078060150146,
-0.2232796549797058,
0.17252510786056519,
0.3315957486629486,
-0.4126269519329071,
0.17326411604881287,
0.03721076622605324,
0.9984192848205566,
0.7376125454902649,
0.14398889243602753,
0.47905805706977844,
0.035684600472450256,
-0.26239216327667236,
-0.16351288557052612,
0.01615172252058983,
-0.1132822260260582,
0.20815666019916534,
0.5242554545402527,
0.9280626773834229,
0.06578605622053146,
-0.5690428614616394,
0.9894043207168579,
-0.03262455388903618,
-0.4939315915107727,
-0.511925220489502,
-0.25788649916648865,
-0.1108681708574295,
0.5562206506729126,
0.4927522838115692,
0.42018455266952515,
0.08374989777803421,
-0.6558365821838379,
0.3903419077396393,
0.4777417480945587,
-0.34592047333717346,
-0.5322450995445251,
0.606817364692688,
0.2366270124912262,
0.08662699908018112,
0.17705975472927094,
-0.32510924339294434,
-0.8656291961669922,
0.22168327867984772,
0.511528491973877,
0.21109510958194733,
-0.14549323916435242,
0.33004799485206604,
0.08559121936559677,
0.6292246580123901,
-0.19626860320568085,
0.15823282301425934,
0.0456937775015831,
-1.0377345085144043,
-0.6476732492446899,
-0.5742404460906982,
-0.019149810075759888,
0.42883747816085815,
-0.1861739605665207,
0.3381236791610718,
-0.3062433898448944,
0.2324836552143097,
-0.3028812110424042,
-0.47754716873168945,
-0.4882524311542511,
0.12069033831357956,
0.2536512315273285,
0.9560195803642273,
-0.7183454632759094,
0.8496359586715698,
0.4567934572696686,
-0.421080082654953,
-0.6311510801315308,
0.19162090122699738,
0.3789043426513672,
-0.928784966468811,
0.8265546560287476,
0.1401723176240921,
-0.03456467017531395,
-0.045527879148721695,
-0.47806596755981445,
-0.7348366975784302,
0.7220931649208069,
0.3764609396457672,
-0.3506130576133728,
-0.3192289173603058,
0.016670679673552513,
0.13507594168186188,
-0.10780525207519531,
-0.05856679379940033,
0.248220294713974,
0.7932936549186707,
0.06851441413164139,
-0.8940712213516235,
-0.01370149850845337,
-0.03436533361673355,
-0.4230535328388214,
0.2670370638370514,
-0.4394869804382324,
0.9189878106117249,
-0.06290090829133987,
-0.014448849484324455,
-0.2946220934391022,
0.6430701613426208,
0.2030348926782608,
0.5565643906593323,
0.4828318953514099,
0.9190382361412048,
0.36187535524368286,
-0.0869649350643158,
1.085646390914917,
-0.23234419524669647,
0.09845329076051712,
0.9626138210296631,
0.022874552756547928,
0.3844124972820282,
0.42618438601493835,
0.3286118805408478,
0.8548384308815002,
0.2852465808391571,
0.02267465926706791,
0.5335249304771423,
-0.13555414974689484,
-0.7831811904907227,
-0.5815010070800781,
0.1231779232621193,
-0.4063236117362976,
0.46001529693603516,
0.42848166823387146,
-0.40809908509254456,
-0.3813575208187103,
0.6407623291015625,
0.07450126111507416,
-0.08305557072162628,
-0.5029477477073669,
0.37703779339790344,
-0.11124823987483978,
-0.4929330348968506,
0.4110814332962036,
0.15658588707447052,
0.8890672326087952,
-0.6359845995903015,
-0.2215101271867752,
0.0100015914067626,
0.38898569345474243,
-0.3122118413448334,
-0.5978507399559021,
0.19173191487789154,
-0.22481314837932587,
-0.22757066786289215,
-0.30230802297592163,
1.2070040702819824,
-0.6363522410392761,
-0.2516855001449585,
0.18749995529651642,
0.6581383347511292,
-0.08737970143556595,
-0.4596654176712036,
-0.40691739320755005,
0.21593734622001648,
0.1110125407576561,
-0.40117013454437256,
0.36679449677467346,
0.5548731684684753,
-0.32543227076530457,
0.48027363419532776,
1.1460405588150024,
-0.0417054109275341,
0.34794101119041443,
0.08936707675457001,
1.025420904159546,
-0.2991521954536438,
-0.4080299139022827,
-0.7133148312568665,
0.4759548306465149,
-0.3399012088775635,
0.041404690593481064,
1.1438794136047363,
0.6565761566162109,
0.9415870308876038,
-0.26829737424850464,
0.9808473587036133,
-0.036133334040641785,
0.5285018086433411,
-0.7053112387657166,
0.4240252375602722,
-0.6757773160934448,
0.19610969722270966,
0.0246190894395113,
-0.776706874370575,
-0.31407734751701355,
0.4223807752132416,
-0.2291613221168518,
-0.13023000955581665,
0.5447295904159546,
0.7283710241317749,
-0.495429128408432,
-0.05735015124082565,
0.6155951619148254,
0.2501157224178314,
0.43233662843704224,
0.3885563015937805,
0.9389710426330566,
-0.3948119282722473,
0.845750629901886,
-0.1371343582868576,
-0.03420282155275345,
-0.2308093011379242,
-0.8812000751495361,
-0.8207311034202576,
-0.4991980493068695,
-0.10161364823579788,
-0.4871705174446106,
0.08232621103525162,
0.33027154207229614,
0.7877804040908813,
-0.3857997953891754,
0.6303114891052246,
-0.031682148575782776,
0.12363212555646896,
0.05999153107404709,
-0.3541332185268402,
0.18450874090194702,
-0.19432945549488068,
-0.529415488243103,
0.6891301274299622,
0.3422926664352417,
0.03714580088853836,
-0.4436732530593872,
-0.06718208640813828,
-0.1712619662284851,
0.08936958014965057,
0.9678940176963806,
0.2793753445148468,
-0.9801288843154907,
-0.6049380898475647,
-0.08221358060836792,
0.09440524876117706,
-0.22042012214660645,
0.9688330292701721,
-1.1780065298080444,
0.510046660900116,
0.5755987167358398,
0.5595967173576355,
0.5677803754806519,
0.16507264971733093,
0.36925622820854187,
-1.1056689023971558,
0.4021505117416382,
0.1877213567495346,
0.35985633730888367,
0.3415205180644989,
-0.43604379892349243,
0.192814439535141,
0.8950073719024658,
-0.3291601538658142,
-0.901910662651062,
0.5120198130607605,
-0.9006382822990417,
-0.6653755307197571,
1.256390929222107,
0.04580919072031975,
-0.17474022507667542,
-0.576154351234436,
-0.14067116379737854,
0.023351594805717468,
-0.289276123046875,
0.24357888102531433,
0.5198761820793152,
-0.08821340650320053,
-0.5366840958595276,
-0.7366470694541931,
0.66689532995224,
-0.05626135692000389,
-0.83905029296875,
-0.14071254432201385,
0.9237003922462463,
0.5030789971351624,
0.3481382429599762,
0.6305590867996216,
-0.19902817904949188,
0.4851498305797577,
0.05993342399597168,
0.18618370592594147,
-0.6078252196311951,
-0.3005135953426361,
0.1523999273777008,
0.22688451409339905,
-0.6065520644187927,
-0.0015179322799667716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01985v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01985v1
|
Transformers for Low-Resource Languages:Is Féidir Linn!
| 2024-03-04T12:29:59 | 2024-03-04T12:29:59 |
Séamus Lankford, Haithem Afli, Andy Way
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The Transformer model is the state-of-the-art in Machine Translation.
However, in general, neural translation models often under perform on language
pairs with insufficient training data. As a consequence, relatively few
experiments have been carried out using this architecture on low-resource
language pairs. In this study, hyperparameter optimization of Transformer
models in translating the low-resource English-Irish language pair is
evaluated. We demonstrate that choosing appropriate parameters leads to
considerable performance improvements. Most importantly, the correct choice of
subword model is shown to be the biggest driver of translation performance.
SentencePiece models using both unigram and BPE approaches were appraised.
Variations on model architectures included modifying the number of layers,
testing various regularisation techniques and evaluating the optimal number of
heads for attention. A generic 55k DGT corpus and an in-domain 88k public admin
corpus were used for evaluation. A Transformer optimized model demonstrated a
BLEU score improvement of 7.8 points when compared with a baseline RNN model.
Improvements were observed across a range of metrics, including TER, indicating
a substantially reduced post editing effort for Transformer optimized models
with 16k BPE subword models. Bench-marked against Google Translate, our
translation engines demonstrated significant improvements. The question of
whether or not Transformers can be used effectively in a low-resource setting
of English-Irish translation has been addressed. Is f\'eidir linn - yes we can.
|
[
-0.3804795742034912,
-0.37446075677871704,
0.281181275844574,
0.23867179453372955,
-0.2948814630508423,
-0.20851588249206543,
-0.5028973817825317,
-0.4032350480556488,
0.1575474739074707,
0.5833063721656799,
-0.16301216185092926,
0.08818329870700836,
-0.803580105304718,
0.5344346165657043,
-0.5191613435745239,
0.9366267919540405,
-0.08547952771186829,
0.13193367421627045,
0.10804472863674164,
-0.37190330028533936,
-0.34878188371658325,
-0.07506584376096725,
-0.5798918604850769,
-0.5213208198547363,
0.6355936527252197,
0.30443334579467773,
0.900165319442749,
0.8536402583122253,
1.030616044998169,
0.4203852415084839,
-0.4150504767894745,
0.17089591920375824,
-0.6045730710029602,
-0.1753445565700531,
-0.3035329282283783,
-0.4986087679862976,
-0.4831903278827667,
0.01350623369216919,
0.30917832255363464,
0.7163888812065125,
0.08488190919160843,
0.5141264200210571,
0.06922096014022827,
0.5486478209495544,
-0.5939041972160339,
0.07157431542873383,
-0.7957631349563599,
0.14428168535232544,
-0.11212195456027985,
-0.04951632022857666,
-0.5541319251060486,
-0.09940988570451736,
0.11950478702783585,
-0.38444241881370544,
0.3238641023635864,
0.24225589632987976,
0.783649742603302,
0.5491718649864197,
-0.13596701622009277,
0.06525694578886032,
-1.0109539031982422,
1.0467346906661987,
-0.5327674150466919,
0.6529160141944885,
0.11138468235731125,
0.17125490307807922,
0.15172484517097473,
-0.6825224757194519,
-0.4665101170539856,
-0.2120470255613327,
-0.5105469226837158,
0.33080583810806274,
-0.5478920936584473,
0.18685148656368256,
0.28672176599502563,
0.4276386499404907,
-0.35834431648254395,
0.18889163434505463,
-0.6489057540893555,
-0.0853186696767807,
0.35947227478027344,
0.18931186199188232,
0.07332343608140945,
-0.4853777587413788,
-0.4236001968383789,
-0.18211805820465088,
-0.17308375239372253,
0.013008801266551018,
0.18326875567436218,
0.42544108629226685,
-0.2615097165107727,
0.7028824687004089,
-0.00037929508835077286,
0.410075306892395,
0.1809138059616089,
-0.27519625425338745,
-0.10045388340950012,
-0.5501229763031006,
-0.13515998423099518,
-0.09472686052322388,
0.7099044322967529,
0.35446327924728394,
0.2554719150066376,
-0.453080415725708,
-0.5761899352073669,
0.2474326193332672,
0.29490330815315247,
-0.8144976496696472,
-0.05652601644396782,
-0.17696557939052582,
-0.6086835861206055,
-0.30868425965309143,
-0.4349673390388489,
-0.7563098669052124,
0.12784819304943085,
-0.30724725127220154,
0.27925580739974976,
-0.1533338725566864,
-0.03953445330262184,
0.2684124708175659,
0.09235726296901703,
0.1293032318353653,
0.07851561158895493,
-0.7883466482162476,
0.45906123518943787,
0.2903512120246887,
0.9221625328063965,
-0.3951258063316345,
-0.21789877116680145,
-0.4381580352783203,
-0.12326968461275101,
-0.2762690484523773,
0.5545190572738647,
-0.2513708174228668,
-0.34106218814849854,
-0.05332639068365097,
0.09825850278139114,
-0.3027456998825073,
-0.5679335594177246,
0.8944684863090515,
-0.49547913670539856,
0.1234036237001419,
0.11510909348726273,
-0.12594129145145416,
0.01996380090713501,
-0.16254058480262756,
-0.9946100115776062,
1.0434670448303223,
0.3412918746471405,
-0.6036441922187805,
0.0772542804479599,
-0.8468925356864929,
-0.5336207151412964,
0.17415130138397217,
0.36620715260505676,
-0.14706633985042572,
0.4652688503265381,
0.1830802857875824,
0.20598429441452026,
-0.8256135582923889,
0.02163682132959366,
0.3937981426715851,
-0.32781466841697693,
0.13240638375282288,
-0.6863791346549988,
0.45478418469429016,
0.380415678024292,
-0.3786434531211853,
-0.27303147315979004,
-0.5386068224906921,
-0.07798956334590912,
-0.035218533128499985,
-0.5594228506088257,
-0.1306385099887848,
-0.3882785439491272,
0.5836008787155151,
0.3132542669773102,
0.14688652753829956,
-0.6309566497802734,
-0.22075101733207703,
-0.5611563324928284,
0.6372042298316956,
0.3424232006072998,
-0.3142799437046051,
0.8198424577713013,
-0.11218401044607162,
0.6543070673942566,
0.2247736006975174,
0.30791765451431274,
0.16837526857852936,
-0.48140260577201843,
-0.8325341939926147,
0.014127129688858986,
0.6354162096977234,
0.7087029218673706,
-0.8014584183692932,
0.26037833094596863,
-0.34220781922340393,
-0.33492356538772583,
-1.1193621158599854,
0.3527357578277588,
0.5884139537811279,
0.7496104836463928,
0.6858728528022766,
-0.3509964048862457,
-0.2835598587989807,
-1.1037895679473877,
-0.24837858974933624,
-0.23929284512996674,
0.09714774042367935,
0.22840149700641632,
0.3823238015174866,
-0.40032148361206055,
0.5371794104576111,
-0.28964120149612427,
-0.15547019243240356,
-0.5798402428627014,
0.0665854811668396,
0.4189029037952423,
0.3752613067626953,
0.55343097448349,
-0.9307683706283569,
-0.4530954360961914,
0.3923931121826172,
-0.31641143560409546,
-0.18759039044380188,
0.05389329418540001,
-0.2601858079433441,
0.23734933137893677,
0.19749528169631958,
-0.6676062941551208,
0.3394523859024048,
0.7628027200698853,
0.2516728937625885,
0.23204413056373596,
-0.22706037759780884,
-0.041861992329359055,
-1.0347355604171753,
0.10125919431447983,
0.2494385987520218,
-0.2549898028373718,
-0.5400487184524536,
0.09958046674728394,
0.02469608373939991,
-0.4995238184928894,
-0.8434271812438965,
0.6288244724273682,
-0.13408322632312775,
0.1288553923368454,
-0.1970214694738388,
0.1314094215631485,
0.11858192831277847,
0.4454191327095032,
-0.08271357417106628,
0.9794747233390808,
0.070816770195961,
-0.3531612753868103,
0.3785252273082733,
0.5089049339294434,
-0.29176315665245056,
0.37272071838378906,
-0.7660757303237915,
0.13488373160362244,
-0.0934210941195488,
-0.09381701797246933,
-0.7629551887512207,
-0.05045508220791817,
-0.07634548842906952,
-0.12491763383150101,
0.18311399221420288,
-0.14841431379318237,
-0.17171166837215424,
-0.4716286361217499,
0.13432937860488892,
0.44677090644836426,
0.6676410436630249,
-0.389134019613266,
0.40631717443466187,
0.1414393037557602,
-0.06732910871505737,
-0.40035420656204224,
-0.9348067045211792,
0.1267857551574707,
-0.14587658643722534,
-0.7492871284484863,
0.5464859008789062,
0.07499352097511292,
-0.25264203548431396,
0.19316516816616058,
-0.14006519317626953,
-0.11611444503068924,
-0.21749307215213776,
-0.4186306893825531,
0.12038186192512512,
-0.5779520273208618,
-0.05946572124958038,
-0.24092738330364227,
-0.5056390166282654,
-0.4227336049079895,
-0.47984975576400757,
0.40911760926246643,
-0.14230124652385712,
0.12304042279720306,
-0.560308575630188,
0.384593665599823,
0.6180669665336609,
-0.4566144049167633,
0.7802504301071167,
0.7908715605735779,
-0.24380752444267273,
-0.052324410527944565,
-0.7480149865150452,
-0.3234644830226898,
-0.4300953149795532,
0.46890583634376526,
-0.3859443664550781,
-0.5867009162902832,
0.35066521167755127,
-0.19005903601646423,
-0.20612603425979614,
0.5380100011825562,
0.5472807288169861,
-0.09483086317777634,
0.8449609875679016,
0.7663201093673706,
-0.26761287450790405,
0.29344725608825684,
-0.5086238980293274,
0.5183736681938171,
-0.885685384273529,
0.23804828524589539,
-0.5037600994110107,
-0.6683686375617981,
-1.0764051675796509,
-0.34041643142700195,
0.619847297668457,
0.1205967590212822,
0.2826760709285736,
0.9784674644470215,
-0.4820293188095093,
0.5583983659744263,
0.5337626934051514,
0.08977346122264862,
0.14444176852703094,
-0.10292103886604309,
-0.08381757140159607,
-0.13044917583465576,
-0.9965249300003052,
-0.794892430305481,
0.7378619909286499,
0.23751096427440643,
0.8401544094085693,
-0.10924559086561203,
0.38708966970443726,
0.1037648394703865,
-0.011521919630467892,
-0.9535833597183228,
0.4415972828865051,
-0.7335819005966187,
-0.47496506571769714,
-0.43048378825187683,
-0.5166228413581848,
-0.898300290107727,
0.2609310448169708,
-0.18175680935382843,
-0.3117409944534302,
0.23082099854946136,
0.04548174887895584,
-0.44470417499542236,
0.4912319481372833,
-0.9272223114967346,
0.9569945931434631,
-0.37774980068206787,
-0.4096439778804779,
-0.13248726725578308,
-0.3319622874259949,
0.013927729800343513,
-0.2254343330860138,
-0.0648844763636589,
0.17402303218841553,
0.013661975041031837,
0.5708986520767212,
-0.1381484866142273,
0.33221957087516785,
0.17415393888950348,
0.07410350441932678,
0.16880768537521362,
0.13883091509342194,
0.576998233795166,
0.012629696168005466,
-0.41754835844039917,
0.21221964061260223,
-0.1748354583978653,
-0.49232977628707886,
-0.5722755789756775,
0.47523051500320435,
-0.7801848649978638,
-0.6471356749534607,
0.12143819779157639,
-0.7519789338111877,
0.16468791663646698,
0.09771283715963364,
0.5811821818351746,
0.3540957272052765,
0.010633672587573528,
0.5000910758972168,
0.43197914958000183,
-0.06613155454397202,
0.6785036325454712,
0.3199424147605896,
0.37974676489830017,
-0.22837531566619873,
0.5757290720939636,
0.2299584001302719,
0.363334596157074,
0.5239958167076111,
0.29581162333488464,
-0.20519036054611206,
-0.5540090799331665,
-0.677174985408783,
0.3096468448638916,
-0.4309748411178589,
-0.31836560368537903,
-0.6473008394241333,
-0.24357613921165466,
-0.21467134356498718,
-0.2628442049026489,
-0.550603985786438,
-0.5506722331047058,
0.021484985947608948,
-0.022799251601099968,
0.20564986765384674,
0.5893359184265137,
0.1337214559316635,
0.6836168169975281,
-0.7543624043464661,
0.27672114968299866,
0.1786111742258072,
0.17242303490638733,
-0.17817683517932892,
-0.5972976088523865,
-0.7088467478752136,
-0.107926145195961,
-0.37081578373908997,
-0.5704593062400818,
0.42591214179992676,
-0.023841887712478638,
0.31911227107048035,
0.06685787439346313,
-0.00478320149704814,
0.5055320858955383,
-0.8321091532707214,
0.5518274307250977,
0.19592411816120148,
-0.7838873267173767,
0.31254062056541443,
-0.08347681164741516,
0.2762681841850281,
0.5363582968711853,
0.3200733959674835,
-0.5636418461799622,
-0.20546919107437134,
-0.46667635440826416,
-0.7211791276931763,
0.7810972929000854,
0.4835051894187927,
0.3791971504688263,
0.02610795386135578,
0.35422059893608093,
-0.07447818666696548,
0.09276949614286423,
-0.5983286499977112,
-0.06663651764392853,
0.07219333201646805,
-0.05271095782518387,
-0.18165186047554016,
-0.124700628221035,
0.03629142418503761,
-0.24873018264770508,
0.5131127238273621,
-0.0011150311911478639,
0.32068994641304016,
0.11149158328771591,
-0.30917879939079285,
-0.4119732081890106,
0.24992945790290833,
0.5175753235816956,
0.5889036059379578,
-0.11473049968481064,
-0.014395040459930897,
0.6495415568351746,
-0.5320768356323242,
0.3626731038093567,
-0.03127894178032875,
-0.26952093839645386,
0.3845073878765106,
0.5092676877975464,
0.8890893459320068,
0.3536105751991272,
-0.014702120795845985,
0.47615066170692444,
0.0635630190372467,
0.20396758615970612,
-0.06761084496974945,
-0.05922205373644829,
-0.007506752852350473,
0.22377459704875946,
0.016486799344420433,
0.5698537230491638,
-0.05119101330637932,
-0.10252439230680466,
0.09965304285287857,
-0.04741799458861351,
-0.45476478338241577,
-0.5979072451591492,
0.7853302359580994,
0.4993840754032135,
-0.6740148067474365,
0.35284942388534546,
-0.07418471574783325,
-0.5127893090248108,
0.3976302742958069,
0.5881949663162231,
0.9844755530357361,
-0.24960526823997498,
0.17950962483882904,
0.24383799731731415,
0.6556316018104553,
-0.24864931404590607,
-0.08337248861789703,
0.1812049001455307,
-0.6409075260162354,
-0.5822357535362244,
-0.8477654457092285,
-0.37531858682632446,
0.1746513694524765,
-0.6549863219261169,
0.44030314683914185,
0.13141825795173645,
-0.45394906401634216,
0.08467113226652145,
-0.022715076804161072,
-1.154101848602295,
0.17503686249256134,
-0.269711434841156,
0.9992696642875671,
-0.8035264611244202,
0.7129431366920471,
0.6215386390686035,
-0.5079750418663025,
-0.6204313635826111,
-0.12016764283180237,
-0.4240245819091797,
-0.5890716314315796,
0.9713441729545593,
-0.2843404710292816,
-0.23296329379081726,
0.11269886046648026,
-0.04395401105284691,
-0.6850840449333191,
0.7796427011489868,
0.636821448802948,
-0.6993483304977417,
-0.2641899585723877,
0.534474790096283,
0.6856513619422913,
-0.21827343106269836,
0.40896034240722656,
0.5882725715637207,
0.6050884127616882,
-0.3192307651042938,
-1.1396563053131104,
-0.3380744457244873,
-0.014090243726968765,
0.4641038477420807,
0.46027863025665283,
-0.8431426286697388,
0.7925516963005066,
0.16100464761257172,
-0.07392663508653641,
0.07819832861423492,
0.4550067186355591,
-0.5337258577346802,
-0.08693619817495346,
0.46190714836120605,
0.6158574223518372,
0.336745947599411,
-0.1047571673989296,
1.2674270868301392,
-0.633987307548523,
0.24459578096866608,
0.5202292799949646,
-0.17443124949932098,
0.8067094087600708,
0.6593192219734192,
-0.09345495700836182,
0.07568036019802094,
0.025430187582969666,
0.16483014822006226,
0.46516260504722595,
0.1256001740694046,
-0.09789837896823883,
-0.20773953199386597,
-0.4097585082054138,
-0.020751504227519035,
0.838977575302124,
-0.1058618351817131,
-0.4532206654548645,
-0.21546778082847595,
0.13318338990211487,
-0.10626055300235748,
0.29643723368644714,
-0.24635809659957886,
0.6831163167953491,
0.14304348826408386,
-0.5371941924095154,
0.7420176267623901,
0.37308838963508606,
0.7224045991897583,
-0.2450713813304901,
0.24106264114379883,
-0.6719189286231995,
0.2669362425804138,
-0.03043390065431595,
-0.28408095240592957,
0.3401605188846588,
0.2968561053276062,
-0.3916383683681488,
-0.5243602991104126,
0.6763375401496887,
-0.44314834475517273,
-0.8906221389770508,
0.6902024149894714,
0.7087617516517639,
0.0885685607790947,
0.3625871539115906,
-0.500907301902771,
-0.16114257276058197,
-0.25710323452949524,
-0.09054173529148102,
0.016570325940847397,
0.6596904993057251,
-0.05753860995173454,
0.24502991139888763,
0.4639357030391693,
0.5459242463111877,
0.04393830522894859,
-0.05067327618598938,
0.5936987400054932,
-0.49546435475349426,
-0.21258395910263062,
-0.700480043888092,
0.38934415578842163,
0.18142534792423248,
-0.47853145003318787,
0.3941841721534729,
0.6637203693389893,
1.162696361541748,
-0.3356325626373291,
0.43438297510147095,
0.3314984440803528,
0.2950739562511444,
-0.5184653401374817,
0.6605034470558167,
-0.40222811698913574,
-0.17386120557785034,
-0.1543428897857666,
-1.4135664701461792,
-0.031647298485040665,
0.3983975350856781,
-0.3148970305919647,
-0.2728653848171234,
0.8322371244430542,
0.9062806367874146,
-0.49112749099731445,
-0.17430007457733154,
0.6520311236381531,
-0.012542166747152805,
-0.0654229074716568,
0.635427713394165,
0.5970222353935242,
-0.8858045935630798,
0.9405509829521179,
-0.47788363695144653,
-0.07946593314409256,
-0.08196010440587997,
-0.6421823501586914,
-0.7356760501861572,
-0.4942843019962311,
-0.1828019767999649,
-0.1073523461818695,
0.01532129105180502,
0.9493914842605591,
0.7379831075668335,
-0.8569610118865967,
-0.5336927771568298,
0.22894585132598877,
-0.11102544516324997,
-0.2105921357870102,
-0.13307751715183258,
0.14368218183517456,
-0.5254991054534912,
-1.0575562715530396,
0.4820246696472168,
0.3246355354785919,
-0.06587386876344681,
-0.3254249691963196,
-0.07463964074850082,
-0.22099141776561737,
0.2296522855758667,
0.6614341139793396,
-0.2517688572406769,
-0.7547795176506042,
-0.2684926986694336,
0.3990246057510376,
-0.36156708002090454,
0.195817232131958,
0.7957293391227722,
-0.46855106949806213,
0.1676766276359558,
0.5824094414710999,
1.0521459579467773,
0.5169362425804138,
-0.0641246885061264,
0.4916978180408478,
-0.6974152326583862,
0.48956307768821716,
0.32674670219421387,
0.48200345039367676,
0.2928420603275299,
-0.38190627098083496,
0.6847125291824341,
0.1550712287425995,
-0.45775872468948364,
-0.6485435366630554,
0.18258021771907806,
-0.48265719413757324,
0.3531487286090851,
0.9774446487426758,
0.09617920219898224,
-0.46114665269851685,
0.17083138227462769,
-0.07224403321743011,
0.4099004566669464,
-0.2056102603673935,
0.6530385613441467,
0.834175705909729,
0.136698916554451,
-0.1796862781047821,
-0.8394094109535217,
0.35251080989837646,
0.8343443274497986,
-0.31450214982032776,
-0.18850630521774292,
-0.1220226064324379,
-0.34266355633735657,
0.5496876835823059,
0.06349587440490723,
-0.05897848308086395,
0.08538097143173218,
-0.2402278035879135,
-0.0330280140042305,
0.18400457501411438,
-0.4440251886844635,
-0.27330929040908813,
-0.15329702198505402,
-0.15485602617263794,
-0.23956231772899628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01983v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01983v1
|
Language and Speech Technology for Central Kurdish Varieties
| 2024-03-04T12:27:32 | 2024-03-04T12:27:32 |
Sina Ahmadi, Daban Q. Jaff, Md Mahfuz Ibn Alam, Antonios Anastasopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Kurdish, an Indo-European language spoken by over 30 million speakers, is
considered a dialect continuum and known for its diversity in language
varieties. Previous studies addressing language and speech technology for
Kurdish handle it in a monolithic way as a macro-language, resulting in
disparities for dialects and varieties for which there are few resources and
tools available. In this paper, we take a step towards developing resources for
language and speech technology for varieties of Central Kurdish, creating a
corpus by transcribing movies and TV series as an alternative to fieldwork.
Additionally, we report the performance of machine translation, automatic
speech recognition, and language identification as downstream tasks evaluated
on Central Kurdish varieties. Data and models are publicly available under an
open license at https://github.com/sinaahmadi/CORDI.
|
[
-0.6647531390190125,
-0.7509208917617798,
0.1230364590883255,
-0.05241728201508522,
-0.5043835043907166,
0.5090672969818115,
-0.42047739028930664,
-0.11038939654827118,
0.3542410731315613,
0.7196937799453735,
-0.31048041582107544,
-0.6003336310386658,
-0.7067426443099976,
0.1368473917245865,
-0.6677752137184143,
0.6306464672088623,
0.2435620278120041,
-0.06340774893760681,
0.4497586488723755,
-0.5405827760696411,
-0.40955495834350586,
-0.46214917302131653,
-0.3354954421520233,
0.22409257292747498,
0.28011026978492737,
0.7688796520233154,
0.7788706421852112,
0.4031999409198761,
0.07029958069324493,
0.3374084234237671,
-0.3836352527141571,
-0.11339616775512695,
-0.14441142976284027,
0.18747209012508392,
-0.14710460603237152,
-0.043244656175374985,
-0.008519929833710194,
-0.17479351162910461,
0.9450379014015198,
0.7633344531059265,
-0.02225019596517086,
0.3899892568588257,
0.16739521920681,
1.0498713254928589,
-0.6756894588470459,
-0.25133511424064636,
-0.07455229759216309,
0.044283103197813034,
-0.8217153549194336,
0.23238688707351685,
-0.18082939088344574,
-0.6159347295761108,
0.2097604125738144,
-0.45894333720207214,
0.36942872405052185,
-0.3043895959854126,
0.3875980079174042,
-0.0073002297431230545,
-0.5499452352523804,
-0.2697412073612213,
-1.1165626049041748,
0.7752811908721924,
-0.5263036489486694,
0.675273060798645,
0.5305845141410828,
0.595811665058136,
0.13414837419986725,
-0.48633715510368347,
-0.5945907235145569,
-0.309119313955307,
-0.20427532494068146,
-0.2736038565635681,
-0.24872416257858276,
-0.07751642912626266,
0.07838939130306244,
0.3845081329345703,
-0.6780832409858704,
-0.23244255781173706,
-0.7626257538795471,
0.04233743995428085,
0.45410144329071045,
0.009430652484297752,
0.11302178353071213,
-0.15719574689865112,
0.4376339614391327,
-0.06569942831993103,
-0.5347394347190857,
0.1338140070438385,
0.604766309261322,
0.28254470229148865,
-0.13240613043308258,
1.0049896240234375,
-0.5986424684524536,
1.1513316631317139,
0.14797808229923248,
-0.3729836344718933,
0.18303591012954712,
-0.46707212924957275,
-0.28618261218070984,
0.4673656225204468,
0.47955572605133057,
-0.18889255821704865,
-0.0893915668129921,
-0.10076732188463211,
0.31998586654663086,
-0.2527477443218231,
0.2747059166431427,
-0.3553042709827423,
-0.0344049371778965,
-0.011789008043706417,
-0.5177130103111267,
-0.051799848675727844,
-0.28764283657073975,
-0.9052237868309021,
-0.4695294499397278,
-0.3025542199611664,
0.2123575657606125,
-0.9255397915840149,
-0.7280788421630859,
-0.18293772637844086,
-0.22190020978450775,
0.29232797026634216,
-0.04143653064966202,
-0.8640314340591431,
0.40348348021507263,
0.4985271692276001,
0.8985950350761414,
0.180143803358078,
-0.03348802402615547,
-0.6574795842170715,
0.0857807919383049,
-0.30619314312934875,
0.7029788494110107,
-0.706257700920105,
-1.0507264137268066,
0.049931254237890244,
0.04030635207891464,
0.004516818094998598,
-0.6666556000709534,
0.841000497341156,
-0.3388221561908722,
0.032617922872304916,
-0.08732963353395462,
-0.23818784952163696,
-0.48589184880256653,
-0.03167786821722984,
-0.9764555096626282,
0.5720306038856506,
0.4286613464355469,
-0.7670524716377258,
0.36973464488983154,
-0.3682100474834442,
-0.5108127593994141,
0.3553345799446106,
-0.23208178579807281,
-0.4114190340042114,
0.19100402295589447,
0.018588276579976082,
0.1805853396654129,
-0.14334851503372192,
0.17283505201339722,
0.20075254142284393,
-0.1769629865884781,
0.08862520009279251,
-0.2695612609386444,
0.7684289813041687,
0.6663543581962585,
-0.42293205857276917,
-0.026825135573744774,
-1.0234997272491455,
-0.3515610992908478,
-0.438936322927475,
-0.47782090306282043,
-0.29794690012931824,
0.1752854436635971,
0.3366469740867615,
-0.2070845067501068,
-0.11759673804044724,
-0.8011995553970337,
0.02328493446111679,
-0.1777711808681488,
0.23733669519424438,
0.16224418580532074,
-0.47654199600219727,
0.5818580985069275,
-0.3734167814254761,
0.6364736557006836,
0.024577386677265167,
-0.06574063748121262,
0.2946334183216095,
-0.5536303520202637,
-0.8270072340965271,
-0.6903730034828186,
0.45818841457366943,
0.5730081796646118,
-0.5606868863105774,
0.42776867747306824,
-0.1263701319694519,
-0.9378513097763062,
-0.7358599305152893,
0.06703483313322067,
0.02773261070251465,
0.5803653597831726,
0.013343648053705692,
-0.32299190759658813,
-0.9186931848526001,
-0.9360249042510986,
-0.007639086339622736,
-0.23923178017139435,
0.06737503409385681,
0.20880970358848572,
-0.335502952337265,
-0.040006499737501144,
1.0002198219299316,
0.2735668420791626,
-0.13752049207687378,
-0.4520754814147949,
0.3558790683746338,
0.3502625524997711,
0.45669564604759216,
0.1805492788553238,
-0.814291775226593,
-0.7132192254066467,
0.41481849551200867,
-0.4401279389858246,
-0.11679132282733917,
0.3880961239337921,
0.1552039533853531,
0.6629183888435364,
0.5466328263282776,
-0.34371426701545715,
0.28510725498199463,
0.8903520107269287,
-0.5009267330169678,
0.6474170684814453,
0.22199292480945587,
0.4345133900642395,
-0.9254133105278015,
0.4078432321548462,
-0.27039921283721924,
-0.3233228027820587,
-0.8963323831558228,
-0.27435481548309326,
-0.44555988907814026,
-0.35370680689811707,
-0.6886118054389954,
0.344949871301651,
-0.2802731990814209,
-0.03570934385061264,
-0.15698550641536713,
-0.11965925246477127,
-0.3825860321521759,
-0.09729992598295212,
0.462760329246521,
0.9643903374671936,
0.6194932460784912,
-0.604534387588501,
0.4253006875514984,
0.04024219885468483,
-0.8740949034690857,
0.6185446381568909,
-0.3032335042953491,
-0.0407695434987545,
-0.12015314400196075,
-0.07002487033605576,
-0.5439396500587463,
-0.08275851607322693,
0.3555620312690735,
-0.2077403962612152,
0.29082372784614563,
-0.3497708737850189,
-0.20628032088279724,
0.09597588330507278,
0.1351013332605362,
0.6064828038215637,
0.7150421142578125,
-0.0095988679677248,
0.6439386010169983,
0.7257595658302307,
-0.7198402881622314,
-0.444303959608078,
-0.35855743288993835,
0.0552145354449749,
-0.5845226049423218,
-0.6891592144966125,
0.03578545153141022,
0.40693920850753784,
-0.359404981136322,
0.284023255109787,
0.407869815826416,
-0.22704119980335236,
-0.14367304742336273,
0.15123452246189117,
-0.07017668336629868,
-0.397428959608078,
0.12856632471084595,
0.17563949525356293,
0.2335888296365738,
-0.5663174986839294,
-0.4101272523403168,
0.6090187430381775,
-0.12591153383255005,
-0.24714471399784088,
-0.23213577270507812,
0.878976583480835,
0.5797929167747498,
-0.06872007995843887,
0.6985242366790771,
0.8667970299720764,
-0.19045661389827728,
0.33837994933128357,
-0.7358343601226807,
0.41990792751312256,
-0.4170885384082794,
0.34659653902053833,
-0.5856003165245056,
-1.2127989530563354,
0.08930202573537827,
-0.30115655064582825,
-0.15401776134967804,
0.5237576961517334,
0.689850389957428,
0.00856724288314581,
0.5640678405761719,
0.6408743262290955,
-0.24506627023220062,
0.5134672522544861,
0.002197184367105365,
0.1931588500738144,
-0.7158963084220886,
-0.2366589456796646,
-0.8309404850006104,
-0.06715833395719528,
-0.9179384112358093,
-0.40832293033599854,
0.6574981212615967,
0.35959720611572266,
-0.16971759498119354,
0.4216243028640747,
-0.4866548478603363,
0.26186254620552063,
1.0786223411560059,
-0.20766402781009674,
0.4694368541240692,
0.2795430123806,
0.14403624832630157,
0.005312586203217506,
-0.6952359676361084,
-0.8692988753318787,
1.025535225868225,
0.11420714855194092,
0.5975685715675354,
0.3700636923313141,
0.722082793712616,
0.5431506633758545,
-0.16882896423339844,
-0.43114203214645386,
0.3825150430202484,
-0.5556054711341858,
-0.4729592502117157,
-0.683849573135376,
-0.01858658343553543,
-1.0161629915237427,
-0.03739435598254204,
0.00079301034566015,
-0.6661481261253357,
0.5160885453224182,
-0.16439498960971832,
-0.4292750060558319,
0.2637089490890503,
-0.7809681296348572,
0.6507893800735474,
0.23358134925365448,
0.07227618247270584,
-0.7702943682670593,
-0.5487207770347595,
0.301961749792099,
-0.11999750882387161,
0.43018218874931335,
0.011682014912366867,
0.401271253824234,
0.7819303274154663,
-0.21466493606567383,
0.6328544020652771,
0.05147259309887886,
0.29079726338386536,
0.7087526917457581,
0.2360009253025055,
-0.10460009425878525,
0.08196870982646942,
-0.22005943953990936,
0.20517712831497192,
0.29246628284454346,
-0.5989563465118408,
-0.1687014251947403,
0.5132554769515991,
-0.9422734975814819,
-0.6966941356658936,
-0.36689892411231995,
-0.31887367367744446,
-0.06893522292375565,
0.12423887848854065,
0.054534684866666794,
0.37789660692214966,
-0.8178480267524719,
0.11237082630395889,
0.6222477555274963,
-0.47586315870285034,
0.33095496892929077,
0.2477790266275406,
-0.15202471613883972,
-0.5005765557289124,
1.0154951810836792,
0.1805620640516281,
0.14082151651382446,
-0.0006682168459519744,
-0.0009497979772277176,
-0.22981777787208557,
-0.1876629739999771,
-0.8831369876861572,
0.19745038449764252,
-0.5405226349830627,
0.37006476521492004,
-0.5698142051696777,
-0.4252849817276001,
-0.776405930519104,
-0.12378859519958496,
-0.20621037483215332,
-0.8857879638671875,
-0.1025470420718193,
0.07091880589723587,
0.2852388918399811,
0.9919517636299133,
-0.4722520709037781,
0.36334550380706787,
-1.0459307432174683,
0.25445565581321716,
0.693352222442627,
0.0031598047353327274,
-0.5403186082839966,
-0.422217458486557,
-0.366750031709671,
-0.014074906706809998,
-0.4149506688117981,
-0.6929182410240173,
0.5668631792068481,
0.3497321307659149,
0.37080106139183044,
0.13238035142421722,
-0.26386532187461853,
0.2297714799642563,
-0.6370072960853577,
0.8947409987449646,
0.03894484043121338,
-1.051019549369812,
0.48145246505737305,
-0.09800246357917786,
0.49188461899757385,
0.42135170102119446,
0.22065739333629608,
-1.0922507047653198,
-0.44056034088134766,
-0.3596571683883667,
-0.4633522033691406,
0.7686387896537781,
0.24743038415908813,
0.11967942118644714,
0.3316252529621124,
-0.3823361396789551,
0.5898657441139221,
0.3168851435184479,
0.027377480641007423,
-0.06359919905662537,
-0.5704005360603333,
0.010510659776628017,
-0.3790380358695984,
-0.31620165705680847,
-0.26536795496940613,
-0.2210002988576889,
0.6485143303871155,
0.30117759108543396,
0.19978752732276917,
0.3308286666870117,
-0.07100972533226013,
-0.2138855904340744,
0.797214925289154,
0.7699868679046631,
0.5100845694541931,
-0.2170296609401703,
0.2464946210384369,
-0.047733988612890244,
-0.6887156963348389,
0.36776697635650635,
0.49725401401519775,
-0.22301644086837769,
0.6514194011688232,
0.017598925158381462,
0.8585682511329651,
-0.6317092776298523,
-0.8428781032562256,
0.02066904492676258,
0.007974818348884583,
-0.13077114522457123,
-0.48764750361442566,
-0.34321579337120056,
0.13066408038139343,
0.4299089312553406,
0.3027079403400421,
-0.11291148513555527,
0.4240057170391083,
-0.6481925845146179,
0.043534766882658005,
0.2203102707862854,
-0.3235323131084442,
-0.07605648040771484,
0.1686473935842514,
0.2666570842266083,
-0.510928750038147,
0.5880923271179199,
-0.27820882201194763,
-0.387704461812973,
0.3627825379371643,
0.13928447663784027,
0.853274941444397,
-0.3818266689777374,
0.7141993045806885,
0.3544767498970032,
0.1854953169822693,
0.49697116017341614,
0.2345978319644928,
-0.343922883272171,
-0.2761079668998718,
-0.42367249727249146,
-0.8013811111450195,
-0.5088926553726196,
-0.022247906774282455,
-0.17971475422382355,
0.5483779907226562,
-0.05182845517992973,
-0.26055529713630676,
-0.17679215967655182,
-0.21309705078601837,
-0.47826194763183594,
-0.0021346346475183964,
0.6642712354660034,
0.846893310546875,
-0.8190980553627014,
1.159170389175415,
0.8558870553970337,
-0.11864814907312393,
-0.3553166091442108,
-0.42414262890815735,
-0.22885942459106445,
-0.23948253691196442,
0.9878731369972229,
-0.1914314329624176,
-0.1869322657585144,
0.0586698092520237,
-0.06242407485842705,
-1.0067038536071777,
0.6926805377006531,
0.3202725946903229,
-0.7216824293136597,
0.11688089370727539,
0.6936825513839722,
0.26892974972724915,
-0.041241928935050964,
0.08903629332780838,
0.7486743330955505,
0.363434761762619,
-0.06584329158067703,
-1.3809895515441895,
-0.2905518412590027,
-0.05423249304294586,
0.03177943080663681,
0.14541614055633545,
-0.48873427510261536,
0.4676189720630646,
0.4048351049423218,
-0.3975689709186554,
0.13836881518363953,
0.6159858703613281,
0.2946264445781708,
0.19266130030155182,
0.5590305328369141,
0.6670757532119751,
0.47641852498054504,
0.23999200761318207,
0.6606018543243408,
-0.331519216299057,
-0.09636678546667099,
0.6243439316749573,
-0.021653294563293457,
0.35645076632499695,
0.6578183174133301,
-0.2319255769252777,
0.6065883040428162,
0.5929364562034607,
0.4866718053817749,
0.885928213596344,
0.24321532249450684,
-1.0750842094421387,
-0.07469309121370316,
-0.5850092172622681,
-0.3482871949672699,
0.443632572889328,
0.6487360596656799,
-0.22915790975093842,
-0.2659667134284973,
0.0968909040093422,
-0.11090059578418732,
0.005868768319487572,
-0.22842960059642792,
0.6843442320823669,
0.00896678026765585,
-0.5880250334739685,
0.6435933113098145,
-0.015488429926335812,
0.4005429446697235,
-0.4502555727958679,
-0.17207187414169312,
-0.032529909163713455,
-0.12682831287384033,
0.0346481055021286,
-0.6489013433456421,
0.8984397649765015,
0.0889294445514679,
-0.09228923171758652,
0.1429833620786667,
0.5291754603385925,
-0.44431382417678833,
-0.8002541065216064,
-0.18704313039779663,
0.5035715699195862,
0.29194343090057373,
0.19166837632656097,
-0.16605915129184723,
0.20670749247074127,
-0.1101970449090004,
-0.017424726858735085,
0.08627957105636597,
0.3844538927078247,
-0.20923909544944763,
0.4201304614543915,
0.15728463232517242,
0.49135658144950867,
0.5542528629302979,
-0.16799746453762054,
0.6380907297134399,
-0.3950892388820648,
-0.23863905668258667,
-0.7198593020439148,
0.4844042956829071,
0.026134509593248367,
-0.272925466299057,
0.44320276379585266,
0.6507627367973328,
1.0821260213851929,
-0.2201099842786789,
1.1637276411056519,
-0.678585946559906,
0.8751178979873657,
-0.26651108264923096,
0.5928906798362732,
-0.022899704053997993,
-0.28620240092277527,
-0.17926301062107086,
-0.8227901458740234,
-0.09755771607160568,
0.3646402060985565,
-0.11930812150239944,
-0.5116532444953918,
0.4899078607559204,
0.7395864725112915,
-0.10475964099168777,
0.16722673177719116,
0.5372948050498962,
-0.0730941966176033,
-0.036289263516664505,
0.09096720814704895,
0.6836488842964172,
-0.0671488493680954,
0.636410653591156,
-0.6328918933868408,
-0.233695849776268,
0.022455869242548943,
-0.4868144094944,
-0.5156933069229126,
-1.0260918140411377,
-0.12820611894130707,
-0.39324089884757996,
0.41329720616340637,
0.6064885854721069,
0.8415082693099976,
-1.0499335527420044,
-0.9316730499267578,
-0.09274010360240936,
0.0049412925727665424,
-0.19835855066776276,
-0.14278355240821838,
0.2526834309101105,
-0.1384156346321106,
-1.003814935684204,
0.5266886353492737,
0.12821558117866516,
-0.15328942239284515,
-0.4060966372489929,
-0.16879238188266754,
-0.3326084613800049,
-0.25483158230781555,
0.5388259887695312,
0.6259947419166565,
-0.6331023573875427,
-0.06972812116146088,
0.0903763473033905,
0.02638927660882473,
-0.059558168053627014,
0.9663376212120056,
-0.9654173254966736,
0.7703092694282532,
0.5765367746353149,
0.7052475810050964,
0.5653746128082275,
0.04863780736923218,
0.8329222202301025,
-0.5228211879730225,
0.3227839767932892,
0.26910340785980225,
0.16151374578475952,
0.5236967206001282,
-0.16412925720214844,
0.38814908266067505,
0.3512072265148163,
-0.6727145314216614,
-0.32727664709091187,
0.32314565777778625,
-0.8275899887084961,
-0.09875956177711487,
1.0227329730987549,
-0.0008222765754908323,
-0.0559566468000412,
-0.5078259110450745,
-0.6576562523841858,
0.7626351714134216,
-0.4357599914073944,
0.65633225440979,
0.8795648217201233,
-0.04303619638085365,
-0.4992249608039856,
-0.41513052582740784,
0.6016188263893127,
0.38679131865501404,
-0.14248251914978027,
-0.32301831245422363,
0.4892273247241974,
0.12378595024347305,
0.23728197813034058,
0.6273942589759827,
-0.07884726673364639,
0.30054476857185364,
-0.08148802816867828,
0.0749422013759613,
0.45562219619750977,
0.08238827437162399,
-0.5069186687469482,
-0.03332504630088806,
0.4273933470249176,
-0.4876709282398224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01976v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01976v4
|
SciAssess: Benchmarking LLM Proficiency in Scientific Literature Analysis
| 2024-03-04T12:19:28 | 2024-06-18T05:45:33 |
Hengxing Cai, Xiaochen Cai, Junhan Chang, Sihang Li, Lin Yao, Changxin Wang, Zhifeng Gao, Hongshuai Wang, Yongge Li, Mujie Lin, Shuwen Yang, Jiankun Wang, Mingjun Xu, Jin Huang, Fang Xi, Jiaxi Zhuang, Yuqi Yin, Yaqi Li, Changhong Chen, Zheng Cheng, Zifeng Zhao, Linfeng Zhang, Guolin Ke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent breakthroughs in Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized
natural language understanding and generation, sparking significant interest in
applying them to scientific literature analysis. However, existing benchmarks
fail to adequately evaluate the proficiency of LLMs in this domain,
particularly in scenarios requiring higher-level abilities beyond mere
memorization and the handling of multimodal data. In response to this gap, we
introduce SciAssess, a benchmark specifically designed for the comprehensive
evaluation of LLMs in scientific literature analysis. SciAssess aims to
thoroughly assess the efficacy of LLMs by focusing on their capabilities in
Memorization (L1), Comprehension (L2), and Analysis \& Reasoning (L3). It
encompasses a variety of tasks drawn from diverse scientific fields, including
fundamental science, alloy materials, biomedicine, drug discovery, and organic
materials. To ensure the reliability of SciAssess, rigorous quality control
measures have been implemented, ensuring accuracy, anonymization, and
compliance with copyright standards. SciAssess evaluates 11 LLMs, including
GPT, Claude, and Gemini, highlighting their strengths and areas for
improvement. This evaluation supports the ongoing development of LLM
applications in the analysis of scientific literature. SciAssess and its
resources are available at \url{https://sci-assess.github.io/}.
|
[
0.13287949562072754,
-0.3026772737503052,
0.7082933783531189,
0.589407742023468,
-0.0971016064286232,
0.4645525813102722,
-0.16086837649345398,
-0.2330225259065628,
0.07108955830335617,
0.20974387228488922,
-0.13602694869041443,
-0.7923912405967712,
-0.48653751611709595,
0.530780553817749,
-0.4115534722805023,
0.8238485455513,
-0.12476203590631485,
0.5239844918251038,
-0.84320467710495,
-0.21056868135929108,
-0.014017300680279732,
-0.3125801682472229,
-0.3345561921596527,
-0.35631293058395386,
0.6678571701049805,
0.10416261106729507,
0.2575203478336334,
0.4803054630756378,
0.9297841787338257,
0.30518627166748047,
-0.33176741003990173,
0.20434029400348663,
-0.5454790592193604,
0.4595945179462433,
-0.3124578297138214,
-0.5023046135902405,
-0.6324508786201477,
0.10803542286157608,
1.1207542419433594,
0.8375636339187622,
0.12720893323421478,
0.37329885363578796,
0.05958627536892891,
0.6559706330299377,
-0.6854988932609558,
0.03454114869236946,
-0.53841632604599,
0.11097577214241028,
-0.37836721539497375,
-0.22367317974567413,
-0.38712844252586365,
-0.7109551429748535,
0.045914798974990845,
-0.5686405301094055,
0.17757649719715118,
0.23926745355129242,
0.6475531458854675,
0.1624462753534317,
-0.3304334878921509,
-0.1501021385192871,
-0.3547220230102539,
0.9522145986557007,
-0.5869460701942444,
0.42305830121040344,
0.12508787214756012,
0.11770959198474884,
-0.4054403305053711,
-1.085249900817871,
-0.3916800320148468,
-0.6063283681869507,
0.02566455863416195,
0.30495163798332214,
-0.1604701429605484,
-0.10055408626794815,
0.37781432271003723,
0.4453219473361969,
-0.9018844962120056,
0.17813889682292938,
-0.48742905259132385,
-0.43272578716278076,
0.5052616596221924,
0.35567519068717957,
0.13382355868816376,
-0.3566846251487732,
-0.5349284410476685,
-0.0344499833881855,
-0.8585920333862305,
-0.03484371677041054,
0.033687762916088104,
-0.10828296095132828,
0.2397056668996811,
0.8223434686660767,
-0.15068599581718445,
0.2546316683292389,
-0.49216973781585693,
-0.3479851186275482,
0.3287208080291748,
-0.5300127267837524,
-0.09102849662303925,
0.0859183818101883,
1.110996961593628,
0.48470380902290344,
-0.20604665577411652,
-0.04679974168539047,
0.031539931893348694,
0.06400254368782043,
0.008955102413892746,
-0.986380398273468,
-0.21759694814682007,
0.17187941074371338,
-0.4070557653903961,
-0.17052054405212402,
-0.22906677424907684,
-0.8199242353439331,
-0.6634001135826111,
-0.016161775216460228,
0.2529350817203522,
-0.4124656021595001,
0.08469324558973312,
-0.11880560964345932,
-0.18069235980510712,
-0.039924073964357376,
0.2220730483531952,
-0.5404302477836609,
0.36885541677474976,
0.8970338106155396,
1.2745431661605835,
-0.6080533266067505,
-0.43006834387779236,
-0.4273636043071747,
0.08973848074674606,
-0.44229063391685486,
1.0564601421356201,
-0.348248690366745,
-0.43558070063591003,
-0.38475558161735535,
-0.1992257535457611,
-0.18522629141807556,
-0.5091614127159119,
0.8209395408630371,
-0.3334897458553314,
0.026819830760359764,
-0.2965672016143799,
-0.7493876218795776,
0.13342002034187317,
0.34947943687438965,
-0.5412557125091553,
1.1489746570587158,
-0.03136106953024864,
-0.8393309712409973,
0.30508551001548767,
-0.4303797483444214,
-0.09460573643445969,
0.19339779019355774,
-0.018163029104471207,
-0.28634050488471985,
0.1902165710926056,
-0.054712388664484024,
0.3722202777862549,
-0.547336995601654,
0.38856565952301025,
-0.5868406891822815,
-0.47605645656585693,
0.5325141549110413,
-0.4355088770389557,
0.3968529999256134,
0.3000933527946472,
0.18575981259346008,
0.1791631430387497,
-0.8134632110595703,
0.28311386704444885,
-0.09893888980150223,
-0.21143509447574615,
-0.28911545872688293,
0.1626788228750229,
-0.04898655042052269,
-0.09386073797941208,
0.3919096291065216,
-0.6863487958908081,
0.22223635017871857,
-0.5162448883056641,
0.48924949765205383,
0.5349517464637756,
-0.01584777422249317,
0.151080921292305,
-0.2539401650428772,
0.5571269392967224,
-0.38920989632606506,
-0.18363861739635468,
-0.10575881600379944,
-0.25201699137687683,
-0.4661438763141632,
-0.491702675819397,
0.6058992147445679,
0.5446764230728149,
-0.44691216945648193,
0.29369959235191345,
-0.4497719407081604,
-0.8207045197486877,
-0.4613722264766693,
0.23063549399375916,
0.48522359132766724,
0.4611714482307434,
0.3955617845058441,
-0.44703564047813416,
-0.4285186231136322,
-0.7532872557640076,
-0.5351013541221619,
-0.3378063440322876,
-0.3212434649467468,
-0.09959782660007477,
0.7323921322822571,
-0.0066790105774998665,
0.7782849073410034,
-0.39484044909477234,
-0.21688693761825562,
-0.08435393869876862,
0.2992982864379883,
0.2053542137145996,
0.20795217156410217,
0.24606846272945404,
-0.3620108664035797,
-0.3413195013999939,
-0.08504670858383179,
-0.9195019602775574,
-0.3797585070133209,
0.1814512461423874,
0.06524208188056946,
0.052557215094566345,
0.6911213397979736,
-0.5351395010948181,
0.04281318932771683,
0.4745663106441498,
-0.23752565681934357,
0.8217275142669678,
-0.2045545130968094,
0.26022762060165405,
-0.8175176382064819,
0.4795025885105133,
0.03861387073993683,
0.09906923770904541,
-0.5089625120162964,
-0.07322641462087631,
0.2611864507198334,
0.08863954246044159,
-0.5303956270217896,
0.5763149261474609,
-0.4581432640552521,
-0.3753081262111664,
-0.1547086089849472,
0.31642580032348633,
0.2843315601348877,
-0.11816765367984772,
-0.09790510684251785,
1.0083192586898804,
0.4091378450393677,
-0.19739161431789398,
0.13956795632839203,
0.16456793248653412,
-0.6685056686401367,
0.7088825106620789,
-0.860433042049408,
-0.01964537799358368,
0.013616206124424934,
0.31718459725379944,
-0.8653727173805237,
-0.1765909343957901,
-0.025418810546398163,
-0.3204880952835083,
0.16590677201747894,
0.16317716240882874,
-0.6670771241188049,
-0.23321504890918732,
-0.5624719262123108,
0.22716616094112396,
0.1780368834733963,
-0.29534584283828735,
0.6161018013954163,
0.16074509918689728,
-0.6142780184745789,
-0.6387105584144592,
-0.31102630496025085,
0.28212684392929077,
-0.363874226808548,
-0.5171085596084595,
0.49624529480934143,
-0.29396364092826843,
-0.4604281485080719,
-0.13328786194324493,
-0.28058528900146484,
-0.018882066011428833,
0.06457766145467758,
0.13836288452148438,
0.483355849981308,
-0.23858289420604706,
0.08319523185491562,
0.2560347318649292,
-0.1996668130159378,
0.33317336440086365,
0.17616493999958038,
0.35897794365882874,
-0.32704877853393555,
-0.44289979338645935,
-0.12849530577659607,
-0.06388522684574127,
0.8363440632820129,
-0.20968538522720337,
0.2772925794124603,
0.4196617305278778,
-0.11480012536048889,
0.10751225799322128,
-0.5405209064483643,
-0.006906185299158096,
-0.46494022011756897,
0.5521922707557678,
-0.23134800791740417,
-0.8335400819778442,
0.4542582929134369,
-0.18829791247844696,
-0.027790242806077003,
0.4805220365524292,
0.3819705545902252,
-0.21834024786949158,
0.8862002491950989,
0.14498230814933777,
-0.07252822816371918,
-0.09316251426935196,
0.11136341094970703,
0.10865297168493271,
-1.0804738998413086,
-0.4766212999820709,
-0.784313440322876,
-0.1240423396229744,
-0.4225262403488159,
-0.6214525103569031,
0.6580211520195007,
0.20130868256092072,
-0.26349368691444397,
0.08460097759962082,
-0.39838171005249023,
0.6954352259635925,
0.21506614983081818,
-0.1910240799188614,
0.7415021657943726,
0.0410025417804718,
-0.3432067036628723,
-0.32250547409057617,
-0.5618918538093567,
-0.813079833984375,
1.1567378044128418,
0.519156813621521,
0.6636661887168884,
-0.08963380753993988,
0.6098253726959229,
0.21199825406074524,
0.5248816609382629,
-0.818682849407196,
0.9095529913902283,
-0.1731792837381363,
-0.36266064643859863,
-0.1797090768814087,
-0.5713358521461487,
-0.8579478859901428,
0.5667001605033875,
-0.17492133378982544,
-0.6241703629493713,
0.041920147836208344,
-0.1594955325126648,
-0.23757685720920563,
0.04131819307804108,
-0.4183700382709503,
0.7714264988899231,
-0.5585933327674866,
-0.6691681146621704,
-0.2983599901199341,
-0.4406379163265228,
0.4534190893173218,
-0.24459387362003326,
0.10296781361103058,
-0.41985994577407837,
-0.3530808687210083,
0.9798950552940369,
0.01063715573400259,
0.5900500416755676,
0.19535982608795166,
0.07376605272293091,
-0.06623201817274094,
0.24174875020980835,
0.18436726927757263,
0.1786818504333496,
-0.4433521032333374,
0.2988489866256714,
0.48996004462242126,
-0.32591915130615234,
-0.26406383514404297,
1.0301347970962524,
-0.5288849472999573,
-0.3676922023296356,
-0.980291485786438,
-0.6125398278236389,
-0.2949981093406677,
0.277902215719223,
0.16729819774627686,
0.07797980308532715,
-0.6211263537406921,
0.35017022490501404,
0.7092337012290955,
-0.20701314508914948,
0.3170449435710907,
0.8631534576416016,
-0.17446468770503998,
-0.5621187686920166,
1.0477608442306519,
0.09777083992958069,
0.21004915237426758,
0.20071418583393097,
0.12854929268360138,
-0.39383989572525024,
-0.9399239420890808,
-0.10447676479816437,
0.3055732250213623,
-0.7808657884597778,
-0.2475939244031906,
-0.6663364171981812,
-0.162273108959198,
-0.3369230628013611,
0.05461296811699867,
-0.23274578154087067,
-0.4015147089958191,
-0.2926531136035919,
-0.028932198882102966,
0.3668779134750366,
0.6590088605880737,
0.16043224930763245,
-0.10956903547048569,
-0.7662994265556335,
0.19707562029361725,
-0.0658007264137268,
0.42032429575920105,
-0.3749764859676361,
-0.5840820670127869,
-0.04548751562833786,
-0.4631705582141876,
-0.49383440613746643,
-0.6462123394012451,
0.5016576647758484,
0.4384329319000244,
0.6755726337432861,
0.21540243923664093,
-0.16767634451389313,
0.6369035840034485,
-0.5837540626525879,
0.9228678941726685,
0.1966564804315567,
-0.8718758225440979,
0.4408860504627228,
-0.18359282612800598,
0.3337405025959015,
0.7987637519836426,
0.6173696517944336,
-0.3696162700653076,
-0.5969724059104919,
-0.36226317286491394,
-0.9338793754577637,
0.26688629388809204,
0.0401107594370842,
-0.22864840924739838,
0.06478255987167358,
0.026570988819003105,
0.06403520703315735,
0.0664655864238739,
-0.6734384894371033,
0.11726851016283035,
-0.021471912041306496,
-0.3204168975353241,
-0.17698682844638824,
-0.240371972322464,
-0.25505781173706055,
-0.37127697467803955,
0.6380549073219299,
-0.2911684215068817,
-0.10154152661561966,
0.21449869871139526,
-0.28617629408836365,
0.08707266300916672,
0.3922382891178131,
0.664924144744873,
0.8469430208206177,
-0.27444833517074585,
0.20976659655570984,
0.4055595397949219,
-0.7634177803993225,
-0.058989446610212326,
0.3450632095336914,
-0.11004883050918579,
-0.1323269158601761,
0.6106278896331787,
0.3067462146282196,
0.44592902064323425,
-0.9865396618843079,
0.29936283826828003,
-0.060093097388744354,
-0.33019202947616577,
-0.20355436205863953,
0.22382742166519165,
0.18183396756649017,
0.23768702149391174,
0.4750778377056122,
0.05664214864373207,
0.2629285752773285,
-0.24961382150650024,
0.02089819125831127,
0.4417519271373749,
-0.24156123399734497,
-0.1460285782814026,
0.5046147108078003,
0.0035369705874472857,
0.03570617362856865,
0.3718736171722412,
-0.07934142649173737,
-0.32600367069244385,
0.5868431329727173,
0.4269905984401703,
0.6621295213699341,
-0.10216719657182693,
0.20404163002967834,
0.4828483760356903,
0.3302747309207916,
-0.21512363851070404,
0.17309576272964478,
0.2781473994255066,
-0.3870633542537689,
-0.510281503200531,
-0.8885063529014587,
-0.7967175245285034,
0.06328941136598587,
-0.5086050033569336,
0.15017016232013702,
-0.3891132175922394,
-0.08182035386562347,
0.18576332926750183,
0.2915263772010803,
-0.24608924984931946,
-0.16594989597797394,
-0.1625550240278244,
1.0794321298599243,
-0.8751857280731201,
0.7048150300979614,
0.5965942144393921,
-0.276547908782959,
-0.3714497685432434,
-0.25831013917922974,
0.18915481865406036,
-0.47611382603645325,
0.7362495064735413,
0.1547240912914276,
-0.1247558742761612,
-0.18127374351024628,
-0.4524499475955963,
-1.0066566467285156,
1.4311769008636475,
0.35013166069984436,
-0.6003590226173401,
0.2725565731525421,
-0.027408501133322716,
1.0005708932876587,
-0.33419832587242126,
0.6303718686103821,
0.7503979802131653,
0.6086173057556152,
0.14513282477855682,
-0.9466313123703003,
-0.029003607109189034,
-0.4947798252105713,
-0.08385816216468811,
-0.11172627657651901,
-0.558821976184845,
0.6615980863571167,
-0.08950935304164886,
-0.18450623750686646,
0.4853740334510803,
0.7766410112380981,
0.8589850068092346,
0.8233299851417542,
0.16901221871376038,
0.4025721549987793,
1.057482361793518,
-0.2612743079662323,
0.7956222891807556,
-0.25711590051651,
0.19159376621246338,
0.8947005867958069,
-0.9160411357879639,
1.0379891395568848,
0.5145739316940308,
-0.41667860746383667,
0.509309709072113,
0.6095110774040222,
-0.3879297971725464,
0.18996931612491608,
0.3769703209400177,
-0.39119696617126465,
-0.03472200408577919,
-0.2712436616420746,
-0.501806914806366,
0.28771811723709106,
0.6239800453186035,
-0.2972748279571533,
-0.15752269327640533,
-0.05327494442462921,
-0.01702829636633396,
0.14848648011684418,
-0.24868926405906677,
0.5394789576530457,
0.19299186766147614,
-0.6452950239181519,
0.5798105597496033,
-0.17504888772964478,
0.4356273412704468,
-0.8145049810409546,
0.019780270755290985,
-0.24692650139331818,
0.10051164031028748,
-0.239955872297287,
-0.9007013440132141,
0.0863417536020279,
0.2222307324409485,
-0.05072851851582527,
-0.13968606293201447,
0.716311514377594,
-0.33129367232322693,
-0.731201171875,
0.16473659873008728,
0.32267600297927856,
0.4443742334842682,
0.33602026104927063,
-0.6342981457710266,
0.31039926409721375,
-0.33752748370170593,
-0.4051065444946289,
0.5583807826042175,
0.18877150118350983,
-0.15824824571609497,
0.9003738760948181,
0.6999679207801819,
0.3929052948951721,
-0.24671562016010284,
0.13382500410079956,
0.810126543045044,
-0.5841541886329651,
0.08655358850955963,
-0.7074593305587769,
0.32009178400039673,
-0.28286483883857727,
-0.4668123424053192,
1.0748240947723389,
0.9081453084945679,
0.4296216666698456,
0.07355770468711853,
0.5630049705505371,
0.16231776773929596,
0.6781783699989319,
-0.4511517584323883,
0.8569634556770325,
-0.3643035292625427,
0.5777552127838135,
-0.3498464822769165,
-0.9862984418869019,
-0.5846548080444336,
0.44713863730430603,
-0.3939504623413086,
-0.17868968844413757,
1.1366820335388184,
0.872308611869812,
0.161917582154274,
0.06314468383789062,
0.07592901587486267,
0.3161069452762604,
0.2311214804649353,
0.27483418583869934,
0.9896549582481384,
-0.12943151593208313,
0.4163159430027008,
-0.0008570576319471002,
-0.3014574348926544,
-0.05035080760717392,
-1.2013887166976929,
-0.8827692270278931,
-0.144845113158226,
-0.29795408248901367,
-0.2997659146785736,
0.11654312908649445,
0.763467013835907,
0.18363966047763824,
-0.7894374132156372,
-0.3273639380931854,
0.08109100908041,
0.12260821461677551,
-0.25486108660697937,
-0.21244403719902039,
0.5179420709609985,
-0.37448662519454956,
-0.5085328221321106,
0.9661756753921509,
0.5216084122657776,
-0.15992197394371033,
-0.46811774373054504,
-0.10155282914638519,
-0.003960163798183203,
0.07044810801744461,
0.7222913503646851,
0.37665611505508423,
-0.6893953084945679,
0.10137848556041718,
0.2841007113456726,
-0.30460622906684875,
-0.12760326266288757,
0.7706725001335144,
-0.6587700843811035,
0.3521409034729004,
0.7602406740188599,
0.38928234577178955,
0.49407854676246643,
-0.1297837644815445,
0.401324987411499,
-0.4704574644565582,
-0.270593523979187,
0.5245797038078308,
0.3373219072818756,
0.36508697271347046,
-0.0010496329050511122,
0.6873777508735657,
0.2266300916671753,
-0.8072265982627869,
-1.30983567237854,
-0.2254033237695694,
-1.1117918491363525,
-0.24474157392978668,
0.8795196413993835,
-0.2342246025800705,
-0.19806449115276337,
-0.07619234174489975,
-0.03086702525615692,
-0.21643133461475372,
-0.24269922077655792,
0.7500592470169067,
0.7370986342430115,
-0.09082092344760895,
0.022551529109477997,
-0.6989660263061523,
0.21526657044887543,
0.7900261282920837,
-0.9617549180984497,
0.04342922940850258,
0.5698446035385132,
0.31441381573677063,
0.30283504724502563,
0.557630717754364,
-0.29716756939888,
0.2850612998008728,
-0.3108777701854706,
-0.00017512660997454077,
0.02452058717608452,
-0.39319199323654175,
-0.32035666704177856,
0.40540507435798645,
0.17295588552951813,
0.44874703884124756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01972v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01972v1
|
Multi-perspective Improvement of Knowledge Graph Completion with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-04T12:16:15 | 2024-03-04T12:16:15 |
Derong Xu, Ziheng Zhang, Zhenxi Lin, Xian Wu, Zhihong Zhu, Tong Xu, Xiangyu Zhao, Yefeng Zheng, Enhong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge graph completion (KGC) is a widely used method to tackle
incompleteness in knowledge graphs (KGs) by making predictions for missing
links. Description-based KGC leverages pre-trained language models to learn
entity and relation representations with their names or descriptions, which
shows promising results. However, the performance of description-based KGC is
still limited by the quality of text and the incomplete structure, as it lacks
sufficient entity descriptions and relies solely on relation names, leading to
sub-optimal results. To address this issue, we propose MPIKGC, a general
framework to compensate for the deficiency of contextualized knowledge and
improve KGC by querying large language models (LLMs) from various perspectives,
which involves leveraging the reasoning, explanation, and summarization
capabilities of LLMs to expand entity descriptions, understand relations, and
extract structures, respectively. We conducted extensive evaluation of the
effectiveness and improvement of our framework based on four description-based
KGC models and four datasets, for both link prediction and triplet
classification tasks.
|
[
-0.5992431044578552,
-0.503947377204895,
0.8155584931373596,
-0.10344184935092926,
-0.20165155827999115,
0.1267862468957901,
-0.15890341997146606,
-0.31902486085891724,
0.2645665407180786,
0.5171467065811157,
-0.4624784588813782,
-0.8631352782249451,
-0.6750807166099548,
0.2192716747522354,
-0.04152004048228264,
1.029167652130127,
-0.3914256691932678,
-0.1322239339351654,
-0.6765938401222229,
-0.09179007261991501,
-0.3924892246723175,
-0.11871684342622757,
-0.5578683614730835,
-0.5643205046653748,
0.7135226130485535,
0.5028880834579468,
0.6061294078826904,
0.6700664758682251,
0.17022395133972168,
0.17715705931186676,
-0.26354315876960754,
0.5042579770088196,
-0.5003102421760559,
-0.07713840156793594,
0.1298946589231491,
-0.23364780843257904,
-0.6970316767692566,
0.04991022124886513,
0.9720478653907776,
1.2346203327178955,
-0.2891414165496826,
-0.15809063613414764,
0.31978556513786316,
0.9144191741943359,
-0.7393093705177307,
0.8074924945831299,
-0.33310773968696594,
0.24079087376594543,
0.2547948956489563,
-0.01224589254707098,
-0.4232822358608246,
-0.34494251012802124,
0.4140032231807709,
-0.6766805648803711,
-0.11097849160432816,
-0.07424888759851456,
0.44255003333091736,
0.01383019145578146,
-0.8792427778244019,
-0.1981358528137207,
-0.5899426341056824,
0.4718194007873535,
-0.7137554287910461,
0.6622421145439148,
0.6223670244216919,
0.31203293800354004,
-0.3712700605392456,
-0.6061694025993347,
-0.4357946813106537,
-0.3342556059360504,
-0.5450509190559387,
0.31862571835517883,
0.2765342891216278,
0.34684935212135315,
0.33423352241516113,
0.21159255504608154,
-0.28798940777778625,
-0.16909858584403992,
-0.2681189477443695,
-0.34079957008361816,
0.3213038742542267,
0.16887111961841583,
0.05189234018325806,
-0.4850274324417114,
-0.28693363070487976,
0.11099553853273392,
-0.8576859831809998,
-0.011194293387234211,
0.47468963265419006,
0.18775516748428345,
-0.0320880189538002,
0.456279456615448,
-0.7315546274185181,
1.0995696783065796,
-0.24908937513828278,
-0.4544113874435425,
0.3691033124923706,
-0.3386874496936798,
-0.0495232418179512,
-0.012065555900335312,
0.5848285555839539,
0.34444907307624817,
-0.04850047826766968,
-0.540657103061676,
0.34289371967315674,
-0.5138688087463379,
0.23829400539398193,
-0.6744018197059631,
-0.461161345243454,
0.1938539445400238,
-0.5303019285202026,
-0.1758756935596466,
-0.01340224128216505,
-0.5615182518959045,
-0.47038787603378296,
-0.5963465571403503,
0.09896190464496613,
-0.5034703016281128,
-0.46537989377975464,
-0.303462415933609,
0.019223280251026154,
-0.054691437631845474,
0.4638826251029968,
-0.4727902412414551,
-0.10728971660137177,
0.5496929287910461,
0.7372695207595825,
-0.0065998053178191185,
-0.537182629108429,
-0.30890050530433655,
0.6618301272392273,
-0.2985723316669464,
0.6196329593658447,
-0.5445005297660828,
-0.2341156005859375,
-0.15709839761257172,
-0.061669524759054184,
-0.06223922222852707,
-0.3766699433326721,
0.47848832607269287,
-0.5640087127685547,
0.1656481772661209,
-0.5417733192443848,
-0.5986093282699585,
-0.44568267464637756,
0.6553925275802612,
-0.7296803593635559,
0.7844581007957458,
0.10597722232341766,
-1.1840298175811768,
0.3811925947666168,
-0.527118444442749,
-0.7189521789550781,
-0.07032153010368347,
-0.07338177412748337,
-0.3016444742679596,
-0.2477838397026062,
0.4792480170726776,
0.7851969003677368,
-0.20911183953285217,
0.37515953183174133,
-0.5574770569801331,
-0.11172198504209518,
-0.1844732016324997,
0.13959617912769318,
0.39440593123435974,
0.11855471134185791,
-0.002722101518884301,
0.0754978284239769,
-0.9640487432479858,
0.23460766673088074,
-0.177592471241951,
-0.7547356486320496,
-0.2760295271873474,
0.3362977206707001,
-0.5793478488922119,
0.1806338131427765,
0.1384751945734024,
-0.23618213832378387,
0.39224228262901306,
-0.4735147953033447,
0.4150203466415405,
0.6634892821311951,
-0.08551981300115585,
0.564693033695221,
0.20149533450603485,
0.4925570487976074,
0.20189428329467773,
0.11442346125841141,
-0.16194479167461395,
-0.5410424470901489,
-0.5424238443374634,
-0.06675854325294495,
0.3451460301876068,
0.3439614474773407,
-1.266602635383606,
0.2952456772327423,
-0.5678814053535461,
-0.3632581830024719,
0.026124341413378716,
0.0718824714422226,
0.3664834797382355,
0.9541216492652893,
0.3267229497432709,
-0.30705350637435913,
-0.4666033089160919,
-1.0383713245391846,
-0.1518332064151764,
-0.27242016792297363,
-0.03617791086435318,
0.6582469940185547,
0.2690022587776184,
-0.18644610047340393,
0.8644780516624451,
-0.6531743407249451,
-0.3231276869773865,
-0.38588809967041016,
0.051720526069402695,
0.2871159017086029,
0.05223595350980759,
0.2081017643213272,
-1.0336146354675293,
-0.7037471532821655,
0.18466965854167938,
-0.7777149081230164,
0.1411943882703781,
0.40714871883392334,
-0.16202250123023987,
-0.026323486119508743,
0.3490781784057617,
-0.6557450294494629,
0.3655194044113159,
0.5116558074951172,
0.007699242793023586,
0.6595045328140259,
-0.09347487986087799,
0.30595651268959045,
-1.2676308155059814,
0.08750255405902863,
-0.23211003839969635,
-0.2559345066547394,
-0.5352943539619446,
-0.022723691537976265,
0.2108420431613922,
-0.1406104564666748,
-0.05045676603913307,
0.25325021147727966,
-0.561665415763855,
-0.02893131598830223,
-0.225694939494133,
0.47427666187286377,
-0.12972888350486755,
0.742149293422699,
-0.08795888721942902,
0.47075143456459045,
0.6394909024238586,
-0.6387116312980652,
0.5575647950172424,
0.15033915638923645,
-0.15413230657577515,
0.48607203364372253,
-0.2963244616985321,
0.04032070189714432,
-0.3535420894622803,
0.6890186667442322,
-0.971210777759552,
-0.7414410710334778,
0.44993990659713745,
-0.3768598139286041,
0.38453125953674316,
-0.5058091878890991,
-0.5505778789520264,
-0.6261088252067566,
-0.07642125338315964,
0.3075142800807953,
0.10726658999919891,
-0.6358025074005127,
1.143662452697754,
0.314223974943161,
0.03724090754985809,
-0.9626783728599548,
-0.29524198174476624,
0.1691516786813736,
0.04889269918203354,
-0.5475614666938782,
0.2648656964302063,
0.08945261687040329,
0.3633839190006256,
0.19702808558940887,
-0.2895978093147278,
-0.09794657677412033,
-0.11789695918560028,
0.19140371680259705,
-0.003273285925388336,
0.008296338841319084,
0.2706010937690735,
0.010483426973223686,
-0.06945589184761047,
-0.013046298176050186,
-0.6973234415054321,
0.5449206829071045,
0.03189210593700409,
-0.22307509183883667,
-0.125958651304245,
0.1550632268190384,
0.46712759137153625,
-0.22311046719551086,
1.0947362184524536,
0.477417528629303,
-0.33301815390586853,
0.030373571440577507,
-0.5866262912750244,
0.17879563570022583,
-0.38015642762184143,
0.5874917507171631,
-0.3993493914604187,
-1.0415340662002563,
0.6688933372497559,
-0.32076314091682434,
-0.4084528982639313,
0.3002902567386627,
0.1588747799396515,
0.142898291349411,
1.1622376441955566,
0.7240996360778809,
-0.3184364140033722,
0.1703629046678543,
-0.19644726812839508,
0.4709952473640442,
-1.0513617992401123,
-0.5102779269218445,
-0.2671080529689789,
-0.005636378191411495,
-0.4947137236595154,
-0.15368913114070892,
0.6752879023551941,
0.6579656600952148,
-0.05169622600078583,
0.42408353090286255,
-0.4616387188434601,
0.7179734110832214,
0.3038467764854431,
0.23768459260463715,
0.3691498339176178,
0.15205302834510803,
-0.5824154019355774,
0.12479674071073532,
-0.8959919214248657,
-0.23196883499622345,
1.28499174118042,
0.08618010580539703,
0.37325960397720337,
0.15246933698654175,
0.6729109883308411,
-0.1648588478565216,
0.44767963886260986,
-0.7516488432884216,
0.4643905460834503,
-0.025644484907388687,
-0.42875194549560547,
-0.1776590794324875,
-1.035603642463684,
-0.6179437637329102,
0.3047177493572235,
-0.07722350209951401,
-0.9477858543395996,
-0.2112063616514206,
0.39256519079208374,
-0.14043863117694855,
0.42364808917045593,
-0.6076526641845703,
0.9061393737792969,
0.031161561608314514,
-0.23526373505592346,
-0.24750329554080963,
-0.6760557293891907,
0.6125015020370483,
0.05493364855647087,
0.3204962909221649,
0.013783874921500683,
0.18593253195285797,
0.5468590259552002,
-0.35030341148376465,
0.6905765533447266,
-0.2599337697029114,
-0.16573548316955566,
0.28976184129714966,
-0.055372245609760284,
0.8254914879798889,
0.023926978930830956,
0.07676089555025101,
-0.057718586176633835,
-0.2899315655231476,
-0.4413544833660126,
-0.7318616509437561,
0.8095335960388184,
-0.6957883238792419,
-0.4160524308681488,
0.27018800377845764,
-0.581635057926178,
-0.6217089295387268,
0.3433406352996826,
0.01438765600323677,
0.437029629945755,
0.05667445436120033,
0.1522134393453598,
0.5487151145935059,
-0.4518028199672699,
0.10468074679374695,
0.2058149129152298,
-0.34028640389442444,
-0.7399001121520996,
0.6341384649276733,
0.08164381235837936,
0.28885623812675476,
0.4304637908935547,
0.05650974437594414,
-0.3410045802593231,
-0.5845078825950623,
-0.40697622299194336,
0.22093702852725983,
-1.0235280990600586,
-0.4079092741012573,
-0.9680125117301941,
-0.1563207358121872,
-0.7176350355148315,
0.33965370059013367,
-0.2016127109527588,
-0.23194047808647156,
0.09633660316467285,
-0.17257119715213776,
0.23121735453605652,
0.8986226916313171,
0.05857608839869499,
0.3914557099342346,
-0.7609383463859558,
0.2898138165473938,
0.34196609258651733,
0.7942436933517456,
0.5073077082633972,
0.04350442811846733,
-0.5137666463851929,
0.06272412836551666,
-0.24991284310817719,
-0.837412416934967,
0.06294026970863342,
0.01956580951809883,
0.565635085105896,
0.2382519245147705,
-0.1475130021572113,
0.7404803037643433,
-0.6519955396652222,
0.4683419167995453,
0.4548930823802948,
-0.7126854658126831,
0.6109376549720764,
-0.5359271168708801,
0.20602907240390778,
0.23244543373584747,
0.6202992796897888,
-0.5626847743988037,
-0.19317586719989777,
-0.4164123833179474,
-0.9971676468849182,
0.9182813763618469,
0.20710207521915436,
-0.25800424814224243,
0.11350288987159729,
0.7389755845069885,
-0.17699798941612244,
0.3549412488937378,
-0.9869363307952881,
-0.28111180663108826,
-0.16972558200359344,
-0.26378655433654785,
0.060962531715631485,
-0.3929078280925751,
-0.1931500881910324,
-0.19274376332759857,
0.8662417531013489,
-0.41234490275382996,
0.1213100329041481,
0.13097140192985535,
0.03733157366514206,
-0.108983114361763,
0.27548083662986755,
0.1320728212594986,
0.9906710982322693,
0.06332062929868698,
0.23290424048900604,
0.2692912817001343,
-0.25269800424575806,
-0.07072369009256363,
0.35259637236595154,
-0.03413443639874458,
-0.4012373089790344,
0.5666308999061584,
0.7552083134651184,
0.11418423056602478,
-0.3312881886959076,
0.5027145743370056,
0.0947083905339241,
0.06799139827489853,
-0.1550513207912445,
0.04012936353683472,
0.41744405031204224,
0.2008558213710785,
0.2543952465057373,
0.008270172402262688,
0.16344793140888214,
-0.4276653826236725,
0.03133523836731911,
0.3887556195259094,
-0.29823681712150574,
-0.027597825974225998,
0.5761003494262695,
-0.013669406063854694,
0.16300088167190552,
0.7326427102088928,
-0.20517583191394806,
-0.8602596521377563,
0.5821276903152466,
0.20619888603687286,
0.45985499024391174,
0.04069323092699051,
0.36429813504219055,
0.5558428764343262,
0.20943547785282135,
-0.1546855866909027,
-0.1721237599849701,
-0.35551533102989197,
-0.7457340359687805,
-1.0138447284698486,
-0.720361053943634,
-0.1706274300813675,
0.02341752126812935,
-0.4422944188117981,
0.16052615642547607,
-0.31313276290893555,
-0.05568119138479233,
-0.14267338812351227,
-0.001833615591749549,
-0.6060355305671692,
-0.0022612905595451593,
0.04638287052512169,
0.6730098128318787,
-0.7072152495384216,
1.020564317703247,
0.7597715258598328,
-0.49646657705307007,
-1.3332732915878296,
0.09697715193033218,
-0.18607956171035767,
-0.4592859148979187,
0.7440917491912842,
0.22713102400302887,
-0.19861659407615662,
-0.05312083661556244,
-0.5237810015678406,
-1.096380352973938,
1.2509748935699463,
0.2765975594520569,
-0.36423107981681824,
-0.03641356900334358,
0.2797541916370392,
0.565619707107544,
-0.47474390268325806,
0.08750946074724197,
0.37057769298553467,
0.5705549120903015,
0.35651156306266785,
-1.0788028240203857,
-0.04388485848903656,
0.093766950070858,
0.06251481175422668,
0.44289788603782654,
-0.5298370122909546,
0.6657006144523621,
-0.11014505475759506,
0.02385287918150425,
0.05179501324892044,
0.5408421754837036,
0.1947638988494873,
0.14152345061302185,
0.4533116817474365,
0.9759231805801392,
0.6037898659706116,
-0.06885524094104767,
1.2966907024383545,
-0.08356331288814545,
0.6675666570663452,
1.2869210243225098,
-0.20930123329162598,
0.5657994151115417,
0.15699946880340576,
-0.37685704231262207,
0.48275336623191833,
0.6021572947502136,
0.3523577153682709,
0.6019135117530823,
-0.1182289570569992,
-0.08144319802522659,
-0.37126895785331726,
-0.0408392995595932,
-0.4128802716732025,
0.20397846400737762,
0.2011098712682724,
-0.44703271985054016,
-0.3411460220813751,
0.03269098326563835,
0.07090117037296295,
-0.24030935764312744,
-0.45951664447784424,
0.7993623614311218,
-0.06146514043211937,
-0.7554625868797302,
0.5494309663772583,
0.05119293928146362,
0.25372377038002014,
-0.5355915427207947,
-0.1481539011001587,
-0.2224046289920807,
0.22129687666893005,
-0.2741185128688812,
-0.6861199736595154,
0.10239419341087341,
-0.42603227496147156,
-0.4288109838962555,
-0.03392099216580391,
0.9039071798324585,
-0.7296940088272095,
-0.40515974164009094,
0.6037825345993042,
0.41190800070762634,
0.03798378258943558,
-0.16071975231170654,
-0.51579749584198,
-0.4110585153102875,
0.13013853132724762,
-0.003632941981777549,
0.18184106051921844,
0.5249682068824768,
0.10629430413246155,
0.7354676127433777,
0.30018773674964905,
0.1090967208147049,
0.03416307643055916,
0.0455048643052578,
0.9781792759895325,
-0.3832831382751465,
-0.4213601052761078,
-0.7274742722511292,
0.32791510224342346,
-0.27564242482185364,
0.21719540655612946,
0.7268889546394348,
0.606895923614502,
1.110787272453308,
-0.026073887944221497,
0.7379970550537109,
-0.25024592876434326,
0.6782581210136414,
-0.6541637182235718,
0.811528742313385,
-0.6294834613800049,
0.2219896912574768,
-0.49085742235183716,
-1.192800521850586,
-0.3497902750968933,
0.42277684807777405,
-0.385632187128067,
0.16761840879917145,
0.8098283410072327,
0.5064969062805176,
-0.37588343024253845,
-0.005772959906607866,
0.0929231122136116,
0.45961794257164,
0.22986046969890594,
0.5210020542144775,
0.9119764566421509,
-0.2536905109882355,
0.8989349007606506,
-0.319335401058197,
-0.1817653626203537,
0.1786387413740158,
-0.9999169707298279,
-0.9797433018684387,
-0.5271256566047668,
-0.2853317856788635,
-0.46560901403427124,
-0.10342931747436523,
0.5840142965316772,
0.7867674231529236,
-0.6073358058929443,
0.051842644810676575,
-0.09223082661628723,
0.4713096022605896,
0.0427982322871685,
-0.22116731107234955,
0.6165322661399841,
-0.23961344361305237,
-0.39053797721862793,
0.17346933484077454,
0.3378004729747772,
-0.2782727777957916,
-0.1098911389708519,
-0.15817350149154663,
-0.12792156636714935,
-0.657810628414154,
0.8850156664848328,
-0.07292835414409637,
-0.845367968082428,
-0.45487356185913086,
-0.33227598667144775,
0.3498428165912628,
0.11779148131608963,
0.9202710390090942,
-0.8089803457260132,
0.4929273724555969,
0.34588274359703064,
0.5737186670303345,
0.4705336093902588,
-0.12744376063346863,
0.5109488368034363,
-0.9716072082519531,
0.03572683408856392,
-0.07012496143579483,
0.47656339406967163,
0.4564668834209442,
-0.3658781051635742,
0.6897029876708984,
0.2806800901889801,
-0.35220518708229065,
-0.39598119258880615,
0.5623109936714172,
-0.6842014789581299,
-0.38135361671447754,
1.09223210811615,
-0.37747710943222046,
-0.24473336338996887,
0.0808853805065155,
-0.08803341537714005,
0.5254092216491699,
-0.12668092548847198,
0.7132458686828613,
1.0471867322921753,
-0.3081042170524597,
-0.08314128965139389,
-0.7161996364593506,
0.36370399594306946,
0.10048893839120865,
-0.7382016181945801,
0.28637969493865967,
0.8497886061668396,
0.3885161280632019,
0.24932190775871277,
0.5704700350761414,
-0.14558622241020203,
-0.14307047426700592,
-0.47140055894851685,
-0.03345787525177002,
-0.12124444544315338,
-0.6049058437347412,
0.2026367336511612,
0.3634796738624573,
0.07826081663370132,
0.3565247654914856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01969v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01969v1
|
AS-ES Learning: Towards Efficient CoT Learning in Small Models
| 2024-03-04T12:13:59 | 2024-03-04T12:13:59 |
Nuwa Xi, Yuhan Chen, Sendong Zhao, Haochun Wang, Bing Qin, Ting Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) serves as a critical emerging ability in LLMs,
especially when it comes to logical reasoning. Attempts have been made to
induce such ability in small models as well by distilling from the data with
CoT generated by Large Language Models (LLMs). However, existing methods often
simply generate and incorporate more data from LLMs and fail to note the
importance of efficiently utilizing existing CoT data. We here propose a new
training paradigm AS-ES (Abstractive Segments - Extractive Segments) learning,
which exploits the inherent information in CoT for iterative generation.
Experiments show that our methods surpass the direct seq2seq training on
CoT-extensive tasks like MWP and PET summarization, without data augmentation
or altering the model itself. Furthermore, we explore the reason behind the
inefficiency of small models in learning CoT and provide an explanation of why
AS-ES learning works, giving insights into the underlying mechanism of CoT.
|
[
-0.36378687620162964,
-0.6689735054969788,
0.8306084275245667,
-0.24474135041236877,
-0.5102323293685913,
0.3709328770637512,
-0.3385319113731384,
-0.48692432045936584,
0.12624682486057281,
0.513792872428894,
-0.6356790065765381,
-0.4354608952999115,
-0.49443334341049194,
0.044477012008428574,
-0.5327973365783691,
0.8286253213882446,
-0.026808248832821846,
0.0020399978384375572,
-0.23426638543605804,
-0.06620204448699951,
-0.0982055738568306,
-0.5333251953125,
-0.9395518898963928,
-0.32980284094810486,
0.3425367772579193,
0.6038010716438293,
0.09567299485206604,
0.6931990385055542,
0.07518593966960907,
0.2683543562889099,
-0.09787371754646301,
0.5077041983604431,
-0.3868352174758911,
0.01939866691827774,
-0.26096194982528687,
-0.6960095167160034,
-0.19790147244930267,
-0.23192434012889862,
0.6123487949371338,
0.8741825819015503,
-0.14405719935894012,
0.10650478303432465,
0.18796402215957642,
0.9602276086807251,
-0.7937703132629395,
-0.019213424995541573,
-1.1201977729797363,
0.0064959414303302765,
0.10152663290500641,
-0.07096422463655472,
-0.6368414759635925,
-0.1930101364850998,
0.257424920797348,
-0.2514209747314453,
0.3306201696395874,
0.16081707179546356,
0.581038773059845,
0.12201210856437683,
-0.5276964902877808,
-0.7188413143157959,
-0.6313057541847229,
0.7258063554763794,
-0.4045952260494232,
0.3713289797306061,
0.19252315163612366,
0.20262491703033447,
0.03793058171868324,
-0.7708388566970825,
-0.590356707572937,
-0.11273473501205444,
0.10904952138662338,
-0.142024427652359,
-0.021958177909255028,
0.10118306428194046,
0.2195933610200882,
0.36122065782546997,
-0.08113442361354828,
0.037492118775844574,
-0.7020149230957031,
0.28831881284713745,
0.6910512447357178,
0.13647010922431946,
0.030825426802039146,
-0.003861781908199191,
-0.7232822179794312,
-0.010452058166265488,
-1.0698513984680176,
0.11100927740335464,
0.17754703760147095,
0.40255334973335266,
-0.010344037786126137,
0.5196720957756042,
0.03213027864694595,
0.5878966450691223,
0.033696696162223816,
0.045923467725515366,
0.215269073843956,
-0.06385441869497299,
-0.300439715385437,
0.08074726164340973,
0.6481303572654724,
-0.24943137168884277,
0.16812612116336823,
-0.09483298659324646,
-0.39711639285087585,
0.1088525578379631,
0.3851139545440674,
-0.45336654782295227,
-0.3289581537246704,
0.07308030873537064,
-0.19392548501491547,
-0.43036043643951416,
0.10598357766866684,
-0.4831234812736511,
-0.09975939244031906,
-0.4785880446434021,
0.2592315077781677,
-0.6313310265541077,
-0.0709926187992096,
0.1611253321170807,
-0.21088744699954987,
0.15710681676864624,
0.31230634450912476,
-0.7629736661911011,
0.6631917953491211,
0.4863255023956299,
0.6260631680488586,
-0.3188004493713379,
-0.447292298078537,
-0.6689202785491943,
0.1608140766620636,
-0.47191962599754333,
1.0062528848648071,
-0.6149510145187378,
-0.37521445751190186,
-0.29421618580818176,
-0.12414699792861938,
-0.19338712096214294,
-0.5887494683265686,
0.00029796137823723257,
-0.43200868368148804,
-0.08596047013998032,
-0.30663275718688965,
-0.4853973686695099,
-0.13433146476745605,
0.30119404196739197,
-0.5052524209022522,
0.9568135738372803,
-0.15175296366214752,
-0.5215340852737427,
0.2574668228626251,
-0.5269960165023804,
-0.4030112028121948,
-0.4525231420993805,
-0.7133363485336304,
-0.3512980043888092,
0.4303676187992096,
0.1845211535692215,
0.2915559411048889,
-0.448611319065094,
-0.007619709707796574,
-0.17575187981128693,
-0.000604727363679558,
0.36944106221199036,
-0.2838665544986725,
0.6053789258003235,
0.24097618460655212,
-0.34432700276374817,
0.048067156225442886,
-0.8461675047874451,
0.11478365957736969,
0.23192211985588074,
-0.1455763578414917,
-0.3759295642375946,
0.2562456429004669,
-0.4317961633205414,
0.4363347589969635,
-0.11688145995140076,
-0.42332637310028076,
0.11077417433261871,
-0.5331135392189026,
0.3786989152431488,
0.9430896639823914,
0.27650612592697144,
0.6385705471038818,
-0.22508206963539124,
0.3362642228603363,
0.15185686945915222,
-0.029975272715091705,
0.06323442608118057,
-0.1942460834980011,
-0.9976131319999695,
-0.39303165674209595,
0.36488115787506104,
-0.053665682673454285,
-0.9840251803398132,
0.2477184534072876,
-0.013826104812324047,
-0.44095492362976074,
-0.2022341936826706,
0.1546449512243271,
0.4649282395839691,
0.48295560479164124,
0.39215031266212463,
-0.397937536239624,
-0.5871708393096924,
-0.5926098227500916,
-0.1293455809354782,
-0.005649069789797068,
-0.11101499944925308,
0.10854032635688782,
0.5801292061805725,
-0.17283499240875244,
0.8614081740379333,
-0.6696569919586182,
-0.04792386293411255,
-0.6274123191833496,
0.09349878132343292,
-0.22445785999298096,
0.388110876083374,
0.15154844522476196,
-0.6088600754737854,
-0.3751663267612457,
-0.16752703487873077,
-0.6161366105079651,
0.10849390923976898,
-0.13363714516162872,
-0.04214996099472046,
0.18183843791484833,
0.7343882918357849,
-0.3383288085460663,
0.44831350445747375,
0.14904850721359253,
-0.29458197951316833,
0.5113539695739746,
-0.22304023802280426,
-0.331455796957016,
-0.9261755347251892,
-0.19770096242427826,
-0.20320649445056915,
-0.39229583740234375,
-0.4486069083213806,
0.06309732049703598,
0.028643283993005753,
-0.15400420129299164,
-0.47669368982315063,
0.35347869992256165,
-0.8240692615509033,
-0.38378608226776123,
-0.5220004320144653,
0.4474466145038605,
0.23167569935321808,
0.7341264486312866,
0.2893806993961334,
0.4308445453643799,
0.5397807359695435,
-0.9072505831718445,
-0.14191895723342896,
0.31105169653892517,
-0.22028830647468567,
-0.00834987685084343,
-0.4254883825778961,
0.3337942659854889,
-0.2247992753982544,
0.22358743846416473,
-0.5712704062461853,
0.15997028350830078,
-0.09625963121652603,
-0.23264934122562408,
0.2140762209892273,
0.04824512451887131,
-0.34782978892326355,
-0.24691006541252136,
-0.48148486018180847,
0.45331844687461853,
0.6310079097747803,
-0.846722424030304,
0.7292819023132324,
0.4339529573917389,
0.054037872701883316,
-0.5012912154197693,
-0.5157420039176941,
-0.5251132845878601,
-0.18560506403446198,
-0.24797245860099792,
0.2433767020702362,
0.38137298822402954,
-0.1992015838623047,
0.14409950375556946,
-0.49613845348358154,
0.09724023193120956,
0.06852942705154419,
0.030076300725340843,
0.20438840985298157,
-0.10177110880613327,
0.3526134192943573,
0.13112570345401764,
-0.13937252759933472,
0.07809409499168396,
-0.4084070026874542,
0.7423752546310425,
-0.3029429018497467,
-0.463954895734787,
-0.02725282683968544,
0.3672623932361603,
0.3564196825027466,
-0.3520413935184479,
0.6583589315414429,
0.06237359717488289,
-0.3677408695220947,
-0.8684297204017639,
-0.19860126078128815,
-0.2546967566013336,
-0.46776360273361206,
0.2706691026687622,
-0.5290032625198364,
-0.6739553213119507,
0.36672258377075195,
-0.4314039349555969,
-0.011271903291344643,
0.6167740225791931,
0.4321194887161255,
-0.17054791748523712,
0.9411545991897583,
0.8251250386238098,
0.21161919832229614,
0.5488926768302917,
-0.7215741872787476,
0.2978563606739044,
-1.07736337184906,
-0.34954655170440674,
-0.3598356544971466,
-0.17112946510314941,
-0.42590412497520447,
-0.6851539611816406,
0.42212584614753723,
0.17793266475200653,
-0.4547847509384155,
0.1803731918334961,
-0.309020459651947,
0.7105363011360168,
0.33405601978302,
0.40299394726753235,
0.43496963381767273,
0.013122825883328915,
-0.23579834401607513,
0.48473450541496277,
-0.9895305037498474,
-0.5210327506065369,
1.072342038154602,
0.3779583275318146,
0.9216493368148804,
-0.17325425148010254,
0.7934584021568298,
0.16688352823257446,
-0.046114902943372726,
-0.8946405649185181,
0.5532670021057129,
-0.1694445013999939,
-0.19406408071517944,
-0.2462431639432907,
-0.3378564417362213,
-0.8108983039855957,
0.22503256797790527,
-0.21048083901405334,
-0.8341358304023743,
0.40553557872772217,
0.32664698362350464,
-0.42339977622032166,
0.48806485533714294,
-0.6630111336708069,
0.36175885796546936,
-0.447364866733551,
-0.34496623277664185,
-0.5059744119644165,
-0.678294837474823,
0.15128366649150848,
-0.0024511953815817833,
0.09255887567996979,
-0.002830768469721079,
-0.11111026257276535,
0.7725234627723694,
-0.7823249697685242,
0.8800575733184814,
-0.08789422363042831,
0.0755835548043251,
0.7922925353050232,
-0.09142345935106277,
0.7529183030128479,
-0.0710613876581192,
0.12773676216602325,
-0.12446554005146027,
-0.2989669740200043,
-0.4910700023174286,
-0.5669662356376648,
0.3923490643501282,
-0.8207907676696777,
-0.41245195269584656,
-0.46674132347106934,
-0.1585540473461151,
-0.5547766089439392,
-0.137976735830307,
0.49855056405067444,
0.6096228361129761,
0.004654803313314915,
0.015003741718828678,
0.7545456886291504,
-0.06765101104974747,
0.1900106519460678,
0.21732063591480255,
-0.24474377930164337,
-0.3352912664413452,
0.9078133702278137,
-0.006487266160547733,
0.6858882308006287,
0.19923163950443268,
0.12132245302200317,
-0.29110512137413025,
-0.521958589553833,
-0.21240603923797607,
0.252340704202652,
-0.9397860765457153,
-0.26055246591567993,
-0.7396277785301208,
-0.4801658093929291,
0.1759795844554901,
-0.4839172661304474,
-0.7508574724197388,
-0.5276907086372375,
0.0073653217405080795,
-0.407652884721756,
0.185408353805542,
0.9117047786712646,
0.0754217803478241,
0.21587494015693665,
-0.5800420641899109,
0.38043442368507385,
0.43532437086105347,
0.20036081969738007,
0.42252007126808167,
-0.2237720489501953,
-0.30352866649627686,
0.19810189306735992,
-0.5605895519256592,
-0.6583946943283081,
0.22813554108142853,
0.20399361848831177,
0.3792707324028015,
0.3654536008834839,
-0.044513292610645294,
0.8313309550285339,
-0.6325193643569946,
0.7138402462005615,
0.40779387950897217,
-1.149090051651001,
0.6252912878990173,
0.14296866953372955,
0.05783715471625328,
0.8513292074203491,
0.4142841696739197,
-0.06468924134969711,
-0.35549843311309814,
-1.0366569757461548,
-1.161635160446167,
0.660754382610321,
0.10619466751813889,
-0.23111805319786072,
-0.2303076684474945,
0.0859539806842804,
0.43070152401924133,
0.3597779870033264,
-0.6378148794174194,
0.056357551366090775,
0.21484123170375824,
-0.2296936959028244,
0.14537985622882843,
-0.22216013073921204,
0.051973845809698105,
-0.3496790826320648,
0.875683069229126,
-0.3674294352531433,
0.46624547243118286,
0.32565078139305115,
-0.36845818161964417,
0.03552161902189255,
0.12816961109638214,
0.15274038910865784,
0.6032643914222717,
0.05448625609278679,
0.4179932177066803,
0.4949977397918701,
-0.0739079937338829,
0.13191644847393036,
-0.5360209345817566,
0.16426728665828705,
-0.17586489021778107,
0.24985896050930023,
0.9507980942726135,
0.1974407434463501,
-0.9495716691017151,
0.5122703909873962,
-0.015475086867809296,
-0.233111172914505,
-0.5612680912017822,
0.28524690866470337,
-0.025649655610322952,
0.35456356406211853,
0.3217008709907532,
0.2928088307380676,
0.0986253023147583,
-0.9350169897079468,
0.20617876946926117,
0.3406880795955658,
-0.4392305314540863,
-0.2643861174583435,
0.3857627809047699,
0.22600916028022766,
-0.07482381910085678,
0.6765092015266418,
-0.15475808084011078,
-0.5621243715286255,
0.6905005574226379,
0.7909789085388184,
0.9275172352790833,
0.1719907969236374,
0.007074559573084116,
0.17564347386360168,
0.1427873969078064,
-0.1946990191936493,
0.32623550295829773,
-0.5239468812942505,
-0.772345244884491,
-0.32305634021759033,
-0.5601674914360046,
-0.4288378059864044,
0.03004419431090355,
-0.7800265550613403,
0.4838481545448303,
-0.5129440426826477,
0.29248547554016113,
-0.20714300870895386,
-0.20236821472644806,
-0.6687279939651489,
0.3589547574520111,
0.29981398582458496,
1.075531244277954,
-0.957372784614563,
0.9696543216705322,
0.47061753273010254,
-0.27553611993789673,
-0.9577720761299133,
0.2741575539112091,
-0.28652942180633545,
-0.8914760947227478,
0.30255210399627686,
0.2343258261680603,
-0.5251450538635254,
0.09950796514749527,
-0.5077275037765503,
-0.7550419569015503,
1.1329342126846313,
0.1705063283443451,
-0.5323461294174194,
-0.35029155015945435,
-0.06127587705850601,
0.49602532386779785,
-0.8990488052368164,
0.02826133742928505,
0.6599159836769104,
-0.2768699526786804,
0.27156350016593933,
-0.4334139823913574,
0.013999400660395622,
-0.17751780152320862,
0.05650030076503754,
0.29604899883270264,
-0.6597110033035278,
0.728428304195404,
-0.49528610706329346,
-0.19368605315685272,
-0.12773209810256958,
0.5841740369796753,
0.5634918808937073,
0.3902367353439331,
0.7091217637062073,
0.35158365964889526,
0.9663594961166382,
0.09935491532087326,
0.9314883351325989,
0.09395968168973923,
0.3377496004104614,
1.4351134300231934,
-0.31461650133132935,
1.0343512296676636,
0.6164578795433044,
0.02926231361925602,
0.8319153785705566,
0.525013267993927,
0.29457756876945496,
0.8088014125823975,
0.23449543118476868,
-0.2674848735332489,
-0.28221720457077026,
0.37349939346313477,
-0.11353792250156403,
0.6995013952255249,
0.6212223768234253,
-0.5824053883552551,
-0.17806373536586761,
0.2213556468486786,
-0.23258818686008453,
0.24088235199451447,
-0.5660069584846497,
1.2111698389053345,
0.32600146532058716,
-0.4509282112121582,
0.5828281044960022,
-0.18013441562652588,
0.3681566119194031,
-0.6102670431137085,
0.11694975942373276,
0.16614888608455658,
0.11039447039365768,
-0.10029488056898117,
-0.41144245862960815,
0.5622866749763489,
0.35126733779907227,
-0.15585841238498688,
-0.17055748403072357,
0.7347773313522339,
-0.3759101331233978,
-0.5183308720588684,
0.34363770484924316,
0.7534490823745728,
0.03252191096544266,
0.01257351879030466,
-0.44032374024391174,
-0.10113845765590668,
0.17361027002334595,
-0.26445576548576355,
0.30318066477775574,
0.6439268589019775,
-0.10343990474939346,
0.6304591298103333,
0.32509180903434753,
0.216764435172081,
-0.07429246604442596,
-0.22918255627155304,
1.2916927337646484,
-0.8670346140861511,
-0.7004783153533936,
-1.0229036808013916,
0.6609812378883362,
-0.3181646168231964,
-0.00015979049203451723,
0.3659178614616394,
0.6680277585983276,
1.0641460418701172,
-0.08794534206390381,
1.0120383501052856,
-0.19344808161258698,
0.3182773292064667,
-0.8332199454307556,
0.33062273263931274,
-0.43946632742881775,
0.6416587233543396,
-0.02528553642332554,
-0.6689491868019104,
0.22267210483551025,
0.6052775979042053,
-0.6315400004386902,
-0.20784950256347656,
1.2935906648635864,
0.34141239523887634,
-0.1118423268198967,
0.3680531978607178,
0.21200644969940186,
0.14116932451725006,
0.15014442801475525,
0.6833635568618774,
0.9842184782028198,
-0.36574652791023254,
0.21089620888233185,
-0.2921340763568878,
-0.1435779333114624,
0.12863384187221527,
-0.6059997081756592,
-1.0371739864349365,
-0.8059796094894409,
-0.182725727558136,
-0.2442215383052826,
-0.021788978949189186,
1.5384302139282227,
0.373315691947937,
-0.6765957474708557,
-0.224130779504776,
-0.7202669382095337,
0.30117806792259216,
-0.2759041488170624,
-0.14303939044475555,
0.40657612681388855,
-0.673702597618103,
-0.5638270974159241,
0.3689235746860504,
0.24669234454631805,
-0.11394482105970383,
0.028181076049804688,
0.056714147329330444,
-0.20336343348026276,
0.30373939871788025,
0.8686631917953491,
0.24210728704929352,
-0.41784703731536865,
-0.2522066533565521,
-0.2201424539089203,
0.11830811202526093,
0.19173334538936615,
1.0250208377838135,
-1.118985891342163,
0.3516961634159088,
0.1890525072813034,
0.702401876449585,
0.8108589053153992,
0.009044033475220203,
0.728653073310852,
-0.9775176048278809,
0.2926170527935028,
0.37482380867004395,
0.390512615442276,
0.13703958690166473,
-0.25631728768348694,
0.5540854334831238,
0.08443603664636612,
-0.32202333211898804,
-0.8314111232757568,
0.47358062863349915,
-0.7760671973228455,
-0.47473999857902527,
1.18703031539917,
-0.008095229975879192,
-0.5936342477798462,
0.01814000867307186,
-0.19727426767349243,
0.19142462313175201,
-0.14161443710327148,
0.895169734954834,
0.19865305721759796,
-0.5191923975944519,
0.10240551829338074,
-0.08388574421405792,
0.6267803907394409,
0.14717046916484833,
-0.8691970705986023,
0.12870855629444122,
0.3200758695602417,
0.26384809613227844,
0.030368871986865997,
0.8016538619995117,
-0.12528946995735168,
0.20554101467132568,
0.2635033130645752,
-0.0821322500705719,
0.04845430329442024,
-0.6733976602554321,
-0.1884576976299286,
0.3102707862854004,
0.4126378893852234,
-0.3046572208404541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02367v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02367v1
|
adaptNMT: an open-source, language-agnostic development environment for Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-03-04T12:10:17 | 2024-03-04T12:10:17 |
Séamus Lankford, Haithem Afli, Andy Way
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
adaptNMT streamlines all processes involved in the development and deployment
of RNN and Transformer neural translation models. As an open-source
application, it is designed for both technical and non-technical users who work
in the field of machine translation. Built upon the widely-adopted OpenNMT
ecosystem, the application is particularly useful for new entrants to the field
since the setup of the development environment and creation of train,
validation and test splits is greatly simplified. Graphing, embedded within the
application, illustrates the progress of model training, and SentencePiece is
used for creating subword segmentation models. Hyperparameter customization is
facilitated through an intuitive user interface, and a single-click model
development approach has been implemented. Models developed by adaptNMT can be
evaluated using a range of metrics, and deployed as a translation service
within the application. To support eco-friendly research in the NLP space, a
green report also flags the power consumption and kgCO$_{2}$ emissions
generated during model development. The application is freely available.
|
[
-0.33044523000717163,
-0.5210959911346436,
0.3222344219684601,
0.5668026804924011,
-0.31133419275283813,
-0.25570952892303467,
-0.5051249265670776,
-0.21909712255001068,
0.23986633121967316,
0.7196443676948547,
-0.4300827383995056,
-0.46939799189567566,
-0.396570086479187,
0.18340419232845306,
-0.1427057385444641,
0.8480507135391235,
-0.250941663980484,
0.1203686073422432,
0.04644707590341568,
-0.5147267580032349,
-0.37685129046440125,
-0.2599896490573883,
-0.7461123466491699,
-0.3792968690395355,
0.6631922721862793,
0.2105715274810791,
0.7564702033996582,
0.8180679082870483,
0.8418973684310913,
0.213262140750885,
-0.24310098588466644,
-0.11745021492242813,
0.1734827309846878,
0.35879337787628174,
-0.35874032974243164,
-0.4599798917770386,
-0.5879175066947937,
-0.1556319147348404,
0.22740891575813293,
0.4059934914112091,
-0.25643280148506165,
0.5858941078186035,
-0.1526140570640564,
0.46766093373298645,
-0.38016125559806824,
0.014097239822149277,
-0.7379066944122314,
0.2002706080675125,
-0.03160971403121948,
-0.23158976435661316,
-0.3195633888244629,
-0.5301789045333862,
-0.003356135915964842,
-0.6965181827545166,
0.005736123770475388,
-0.038567885756492615,
0.5671120285987854,
0.3507741093635559,
-0.3358670771121979,
-0.30714020133018494,
-0.7683249711990356,
0.653401255607605,
-0.8391255736351013,
0.43178531527519226,
-0.08198555558919907,
0.6886035203933716,
-0.19936461746692657,
-1.035239577293396,
-0.6736341714859009,
-0.07613769918680191,
0.0616002157330513,
0.3036273121833801,
-0.2966015040874481,
0.007711133919656277,
-0.14731809496879578,
0.5234085917472839,
-0.554395318031311,
0.14098313450813293,
-0.32930055260658264,
0.05979909747838974,
-0.025077953934669495,
0.22384384274482727,
0.43651947379112244,
-0.2153456211090088,
-0.3759313225746155,
-0.06642001867294312,
-0.5876558423042297,
-0.4573970139026642,
0.26641592383384705,
0.6920878887176514,
-0.08175166696310043,
0.8360887169837952,
-0.019849048927426338,
0.6900771856307983,
-0.5762112140655518,
0.43687018752098083,
0.18272900581359863,
-0.47859275341033936,
-0.36588698625564575,
0.04122129827737808,
0.7679205536842346,
0.4289223253726959,
0.1793479174375534,
-0.22368133068084717,
-0.2758975028991699,
-0.24348300695419312,
0.39440086483955383,
-0.8895504474639893,
-0.3467658460140228,
0.07874201983213425,
-0.48661959171295166,
-0.31138086318969727,
-0.49199458956718445,
-0.7843298316001892,
-0.24607203900814056,
-0.3509838581085205,
0.4233076274394989,
-0.40472984313964844,
-0.5825912356376648,
0.07698535919189453,
-0.2679099142551422,
0.11016946285963058,
0.24956487119197845,
-0.622866690158844,
0.3084857761859894,
0.40929895639419556,
1.3952289819717407,
-0.11597401648759842,
-0.12323179841041565,
0.03918997198343277,
0.012833785265684128,
0.005336402915418148,
0.6058969497680664,
-0.1454707682132721,
-0.35042500495910645,
-0.2747882604598999,
0.22693727910518646,
-0.15925195813179016,
-0.5742757320404053,
0.5410694479942322,
-0.5860504508018494,
0.3121868968009949,
0.3139408528804779,
-0.0929458886384964,
-0.3850887715816498,
0.508371114730835,
-0.4809929132461548,
0.8705908060073853,
0.3456750214099884,
-0.7795204520225525,
0.028268583118915558,
-1.5632215738296509,
-0.14131225645542145,
0.08010625839233398,
0.475070983171463,
-0.38356173038482666,
0.32828572392463684,
0.041116245090961456,
-0.0493895560503006,
-0.2872799038887024,
0.13004720211029053,
-0.17820556461811066,
0.05970391258597374,
0.12440672516822815,
-0.41973915696144104,
0.9816508889198303,
0.6888079047203064,
-0.129941925406456,
0.5902207493782043,
-0.8667036890983582,
0.13280805945396423,
0.14579707384109497,
-0.6011059880256653,
-0.47646135091781616,
-0.27409452199935913,
0.28893139958381653,
0.4595329761505127,
0.13099424540996552,
-0.6249462962150574,
0.07346540689468384,
-0.36470484733581543,
0.6969776749610901,
0.6247255802154541,
-0.027786850929260254,
0.1335119605064392,
0.16561192274093628,
0.6776411533355713,
0.26545459032058716,
0.19011664390563965,
-0.3694375157356262,
-0.5369907021522522,
-0.7332282066345215,
-0.027591068297624588,
0.6451332569122314,
0.7049033045768738,
-0.6779753565788269,
0.3208996057510376,
-0.22565358877182007,
-0.5530338883399963,
-0.9896047711372375,
0.0569683238863945,
0.020270973443984985,
0.7561091780662537,
0.6292704343795776,
0.06206081807613373,
-0.6578682661056519,
-1.0318902730941772,
-0.3277393579483032,
0.11689690500497818,
-0.247786283493042,
0.04353975132107735,
0.4952714145183563,
-0.42411375045776367,
0.826751172542572,
-0.36487242579460144,
-0.1908801943063736,
-0.07070048153400421,
-0.24438101053237915,
0.32409682869911194,
0.6597822308540344,
0.5669974684715271,
-0.7277011275291443,
-0.527491569519043,
0.5183117389678955,
-0.7229183912277222,
-0.05649130046367645,
0.31100183725357056,
-0.22356991469860077,
-0.06880854815244675,
0.4352762699127197,
-0.5603171586990356,
0.2686299979686737,
0.7940520644187927,
-0.2836045026779175,
0.367765337228775,
-0.37518078088760376,
-0.13702824711799622,
-1.5947794914245605,
0.5140506625175476,
0.04344870522618294,
-0.37111952900886536,
-0.42753463983535767,
0.4719294607639313,
0.08172309398651123,
-0.34055113792419434,
-0.7440447211265564,
0.4807904064655304,
-0.15452177822589874,
-0.011943160556256771,
-0.33108285069465637,
0.1383424550294876,
-0.02328033372759819,
0.18546666204929352,
-0.05749409645795822,
0.9697363972663879,
0.20338194072246552,
-0.5770350098609924,
0.15673096477985382,
0.3040943741798401,
-0.23128420114517212,
0.26095110177993774,
-0.8803043961524963,
0.3084377646446228,
0.25564414262771606,
-0.07906696945428848,
-0.5799369812011719,
-0.07499144226312637,
0.38436001539230347,
-0.4432113468647003,
-0.2043052464723587,
-0.05909902602434158,
-0.6880044341087341,
-0.16708286106586456,
0.10190633684396744,
0.14753322303295135,
0.602156937122345,
-0.5296452641487122,
0.4114660620689392,
0.20694458484649658,
-0.23432154953479767,
-0.008990621194243431,
-1.040905237197876,
0.2882516384124756,
-0.3282916247844696,
-0.5115041732788086,
0.033356714993715286,
-0.0879063606262207,
-0.2301037609577179,
0.19918252527713776,
0.0654170885682106,
-0.2036399394273758,
0.22724033892154694,
0.008513141423463821,
0.049112480133771896,
-0.7787941098213196,
-0.016230089589953423,
0.11690971255302429,
-0.1110607236623764,
-0.009528537280857563,
-0.7040806412696838,
0.3775131404399872,
-0.04015432298183441,
-0.06463561952114105,
-0.04500730335712433,
0.19771601259708405,
0.6873374581336975,
-0.263959676027298,
0.6917396783828735,
0.6932982802391052,
-0.48294690251350403,
-0.1303594410419464,
0.06017661094665527,
0.23627310991287231,
-0.4705076813697815,
0.4055177867412567,
-0.1608475148677826,
-0.7039198279380798,
0.4064825773239136,
-0.39281511306762695,
0.30044400691986084,
0.5875242948532104,
0.635945200920105,
0.36623623967170715,
1.0273900032043457,
0.8159651160240173,
0.6567835211753845,
0.38423120975494385,
0.20097509026527405,
0.09968355298042297,
-1.2592649459838867,
-0.1316015124320984,
-0.6038660407066345,
-0.5603938698768616,
-0.3159688115119934,
-0.3730023205280304,
0.24817520380020142,
0.014144248329102993,
-0.20146366953849792,
0.6112818121910095,
-0.9013376235961914,
0.36145681142807007,
0.5410493612289429,
-0.017794637009501457,
0.33843639492988586,
-0.13637764751911163,
-0.37395259737968445,
-0.3336292505264282,
-0.7073652148246765,
-0.5304632782936096,
1.0171277523040771,
0.41084736585617065,
0.336910218000412,
0.3314460813999176,
0.2206958681344986,
-0.014550217427313328,
0.64219069480896,
-0.9278360605239868,
0.415203332901001,
-0.16320863366127014,
-0.5496960282325745,
-0.009868782013654709,
-0.5757785439491272,
-0.922714114189148,
0.1956927627325058,
0.15490521490573883,
-0.5248074531555176,
-0.12032287567853928,
0.0665908232331276,
-0.16371941566467285,
0.4631195068359375,
-0.8537245988845825,
1.107216477394104,
-0.26819780468940735,
0.09950188547372818,
-0.05216095969080925,
-0.5019908547401428,
0.24930790066719055,
-0.15427863597869873,
0.00758423050865531,
-0.10364757478237152,
-0.21653243899345398,
0.5749930739402771,
-0.38035351037979126,
0.42903485894203186,
-0.34953466057777405,
0.1277741640806198,
0.27334412932395935,
0.2117055505514145,
0.07744685560464859,
-0.141525536775589,
-0.4199320375919342,
0.10870233178138733,
-0.32481345534324646,
-0.10751574486494064,
-0.4510360360145569,
0.8895052075386047,
-0.5430914163589478,
-0.3652215003967285,
-0.1829216182231903,
-1.022640585899353,
-0.13783428072929382,
0.7608477473258972,
0.13923686742782593,
-0.1925484985113144,
-0.3583991825580597,
0.3956226706504822,
0.6758585572242737,
-0.6047572493553162,
0.31931790709495544,
0.658098578453064,
-0.7580863237380981,
-0.7332854270935059,
0.6939674615859985,
0.08216103166341782,
0.33669930696487427,
0.20803508162498474,
0.5771574378013611,
-0.2879420518875122,
-0.844083845615387,
-0.7240402102470398,
-0.2326822429895401,
-0.7666845321655273,
-0.24229106307029724,
-0.8006020188331604,
-0.14769937098026276,
-0.40951013565063477,
0.047411248087882996,
-0.40972083806991577,
-0.8035755753517151,
0.006937145255506039,
-0.151021346449852,
0.6549415588378906,
0.5384498238563538,
0.08857119828462601,
0.6458882093429565,
-0.6882950067520142,
0.18329167366027832,
-0.09640208631753922,
0.4146553874015808,
-0.21622194349765778,
-0.46308329701423645,
-0.513174295425415,
0.16110087931156158,
-0.5572409629821777,
-0.43869200348854065,
0.46542057394981384,
0.17158105969429016,
0.32274651527404785,
-0.0849529430270195,
-0.19971615076065063,
0.2845843732357025,
-0.4283551573753357,
0.8756018280982971,
0.24983960390090942,
-0.702274739742279,
0.732254147529602,
-0.47113680839538574,
0.8042428493499756,
0.5965099930763245,
0.254717081785202,
-0.6021340489387512,
-0.25337645411491394,
-0.38095155358314514,
-0.9506836533546448,
0.5960875749588013,
0.2172940969467163,
0.165901780128479,
-0.03879699110984802,
0.27839529514312744,
0.26060113310813904,
0.40451380610466003,
-0.6961613297462463,
-0.035723790526390076,
-0.5209294557571411,
-0.3647381067276001,
-0.04369569569826126,
0.3663145899772644,
-0.03713013231754303,
-0.3126010298728943,
0.723272442817688,
-0.1726960390806198,
0.27750495076179504,
0.12347675859928131,
-0.08946583420038223,
0.06310955435037613,
0.02617800235748291,
0.7151283621788025,
0.40723103284835815,
-0.26745516061782837,
0.23295728862285614,
0.12596207857131958,
-0.5217190384864807,
0.05238810554146767,
-0.06861522793769836,
-0.3618847727775574,
0.4090927541255951,
-0.21390213072299957,
0.8733727335929871,
0.1544465571641922,
-0.3225253224372864,
0.16273123025894165,
-0.25394895672798157,
-0.2727380394935608,
-0.1899932324886322,
0.022506913170218468,
0.6048861742019653,
0.04293271154165268,
-0.2645595967769623,
0.6529805660247803,
0.0501365065574646,
-0.2821572721004486,
0.08167403936386108,
-0.000905198568943888,
-0.8818517923355103,
-0.5827506184577942,
1.085892677307129,
0.2908981442451477,
-0.7733749151229858,
0.7052638530731201,
0.08185582607984543,
-0.39080965518951416,
0.6123124957084656,
0.9741830825805664,
1.3116871118545532,
-0.2405930757522583,
-0.012985949404537678,
0.21120236814022064,
0.6495018005371094,
0.04377714917063713,
0.28969940543174744,
0.2343456745147705,
-0.3341078758239746,
-0.3021332621574402,
-0.7372770309448242,
-0.4090759754180908,
0.07870198786258698,
-0.4553300440311432,
0.5501068830490112,
-0.452423095703125,
-0.2140667736530304,
-0.03644181415438652,
-0.6542001962661743,
-0.6252204179763794,
0.06939143687486649,
-0.3564651310443878,
1.5210442543029785,
-0.44821569323539734,
0.9302355647087097,
1.1169254779815674,
-0.3933173418045044,
-0.3333078622817993,
-0.0861113891005516,
-0.20896168053150177,
-0.8618835806846619,
0.43751218914985657,
0.0908319279551506,
0.12976957857608795,
0.2652064859867096,
-0.18425463140010834,
-0.4852122962474823,
1.1250444650650024,
0.6695489287376404,
-0.18620455265045166,
0.012471162714064121,
0.24934346973896027,
0.6962390542030334,
-0.29980239272117615,
0.14260505139827728,
0.09086524695158005,
0.7807793617248535,
-0.2224867194890976,
-0.7347098588943481,
0.043702997267246246,
-0.36546599864959717,
0.18634411692619324,
0.45295995473861694,
-0.6206942200660706,
0.7923560738563538,
0.24946586787700653,
0.04885802045464516,
0.03629732504487038,
0.542607843875885,
-0.19106310606002808,
0.35009652376174927,
0.309914231300354,
0.5054879784584045,
0.3810286521911621,
-0.10565561801195145,
0.9260308742523193,
-0.510421872138977,
0.2707674503326416,
1.0723682641983032,
0.015350067988038063,
0.7639778852462769,
0.6716834902763367,
-0.012760394252836704,
0.2651466131210327,
0.45109835267066956,
0.027211157605051994,
0.42837414145469666,
0.3911673128604889,
-0.17668738961219788,
0.1653469055891037,
-0.3575071692466736,
-0.3347916901111603,
0.2677447199821472,
0.3569104075431824,
-0.653407871723175,
-0.4594566226005554,
0.14600911736488342,
0.0774071142077446,
0.0018359968671575189,
-0.3564927279949188,
0.6100470423698425,
0.42739492654800415,
-0.5897090435028076,
0.22741049528121948,
0.2558094561100006,
0.6833329796791077,
-0.7951933741569519,
0.05764363333582878,
-0.05133306235074997,
0.505179762840271,
-0.17012695968151093,
-0.7936331629753113,
1.0457338094711304,
0.06101234257221222,
-0.1080610454082489,
-0.3280468285083771,
0.707784116268158,
-0.3128466010093689,
-0.48746782541275024,
0.2890182137489319,
0.5355971455574036,
0.11237625032663345,
-0.1548076719045639,
-0.8485933542251587,
-0.13836699724197388,
-0.048049572855234146,
-0.4872683882713318,
0.4270172417163849,
0.7036324739456177,
0.046277966350317,
0.5445103645324707,
0.6649774312973022,
0.2426844835281372,
0.2022976577281952,
-0.17439576983451843,
0.628338634967804,
-0.5904102921485901,
-0.3730628490447998,
-0.8008167743682861,
0.5003004670143127,
0.0659426748752594,
-0.7382651567459106,
0.9953214526176453,
0.7913591265678406,
0.5287760496139526,
-0.2723492980003357,
0.8373913168907166,
0.00839383713901043,
0.3487800061702728,
-0.3095676302909851,
0.811241090297699,
-0.40320709347724915,
0.04843367636203766,
0.06974562257528305,
-1.20184326171875,
-0.5704103708267212,
0.0982113853096962,
0.1186409741640091,
-0.2533821761608124,
0.5772058963775635,
0.5384398102760315,
-0.6410201787948608,
0.033033549785614014,
0.18530143797397614,
-0.0019885876681655645,
0.31807777285575867,
0.24400022625923157,
0.5076708197593689,
-0.44313424825668335,
0.7283880114555359,
-0.0850672647356987,
-0.06969402730464935,
-0.1154758557677269,
-1.0683072805404663,
-0.5684447288513184,
-0.16247405111789703,
-0.43879857659339905,
-0.49664533138275146,
0.004529732745140791,
1.0058904886245728,
0.4977019131183624,
-0.725676417350769,
-0.20705778896808624,
-0.48438477516174316,
-0.07211311161518097,
-0.46409425139427185,
-0.24024975299835205,
0.094710573554039,
-0.18333929777145386,
-0.6810699701309204,
0.5939975380897522,
0.3925279974937439,
0.021361321210861206,
-0.3748372793197632,
-0.11908123642206192,
-0.2317868322134018,
0.11329372972249985,
0.40061938762664795,
0.23203511536121368,
-0.24842211604118347,
-0.15312543511390686,
0.2499261349439621,
0.024511804804205894,
0.3055727779865265,
0.7139503955841064,
-0.4483802914619446,
0.670595645904541,
0.4774273931980133,
0.954695999622345,
0.17031323909759521,
-0.4338400065898895,
0.8949572443962097,
-0.6652688384056091,
0.30264773964881897,
0.2642507553100586,
0.19871099293231964,
0.39123818278312683,
-0.16185276210308075,
0.6320472955703735,
0.19214196503162384,
-0.5783879160881042,
-0.9473902583122253,
0.2321815937757492,
-0.707221269607544,
-0.04264111444354057,
0.8954724073410034,
-0.3016970753669739,
-0.4613371789455414,
-0.054622139781713486,
-0.23449712991714478,
0.36019739508628845,
-0.015525498427450657,
0.5184597969055176,
0.621074378490448,
0.04373038560152054,
-0.03852866590023041,
-0.9781210422515869,
0.08458522707223892,
0.30788999795913696,
-0.7457581162452698,
-0.006305497605353594,
-0.061862763017416,
0.3294879198074341,
0.29798057675361633,
0.20203174650669098,
-0.2881430387496948,
-0.0005557825206778944,
0.10196799039840698,
0.47076258063316345,
-0.4849109649658203,
0.10252988338470459,
-0.4805830419063568,
0.057393062859773636,
0.20833317935466766,
-0.48951324820518494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01954v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01954v2
|
DECIDER: A Rule-Controllable Decoding Strategy for Language Generation by Imitating Dual-System Cognitive Theory
| 2024-03-04T11:49:08 | 2024-05-09T09:21:47 |
Chen Xu, Tian Lan, Changlong Yu, Wei Wang, Jun Gao, Yu Ji, Qunxi Dong, Kun Qian, Piji Li, Wei Bi, Bin Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LO
|
Lexicon-based constrained decoding approaches aim to control the meaning or
style of the generated text through certain target concepts. Existing
approaches over-focus the targets themselves, leading to a lack of high-level
reasoning about how to achieve them. However, human usually tackles tasks by
following certain rules that not only focuses on the targets but also on
semantically relevant concepts that induce the occurrence of targets. In this
work, we present DECIDER, a rule-controllable decoding strategy for constrained
language generation inspired by dual-system cognitive theory. Specifically, in
DECIDER, a pre-trained language model (PLM) is equiped with a logic reasoner
that takes high-level rules as input. Then, the DECIDER allows rule signals to
flow into the PLM at each decoding step. Extensive experimental results
demonstrate that DECIDER can effectively follow given rules to guide generation
direction toward the targets in a more human-like manner.
|
[
-0.3857482969760895,
-0.6517671942710876,
0.4016832411289215,
0.1677088439464569,
-0.2929164171218872,
0.12532807886600494,
-0.44281572103500366,
-0.07072465866804123,
-0.11313341557979584,
0.9280167818069458,
-0.5138841867446899,
-0.11685037612915039,
-0.4834655821323395,
0.1489841639995575,
-0.045586902648210526,
1.068488359451294,
-0.2454187422990799,
-0.08731602132320404,
-0.12062788009643555,
0.3686513304710388,
-0.7266294956207275,
-0.841529369354248,
-0.8609553575515747,
-0.5555524826049805,
0.2454979121685028,
0.4521060883998871,
0.9156359434127808,
0.49309101700782776,
0.3144088387489319,
0.3046749234199524,
-0.2283725142478943,
0.15933352708816528,
-0.47823482751846313,
0.0649198591709137,
-0.41897520422935486,
-0.6488623023033142,
-0.10913143306970596,
-0.15259994566440582,
0.4150353968143463,
0.2734183371067047,
-0.30785828828811646,
-0.05133659020066261,
-0.023005936294794083,
0.5406957268714905,
-0.822050154209137,
0.15265671908855438,
-0.5600023865699768,
0.10724984109401703,
-0.27932268381118774,
-0.38375890254974365,
-0.6973471641540527,
-0.3947792649269104,
-0.16986742615699768,
-0.43737637996673584,
0.3268125057220459,
-0.05882381647825241,
0.7098823189735413,
0.3220581114292145,
-0.6456210017204285,
-0.4279104769229889,
-1.1261507272720337,
0.8130745887756348,
-0.4095299541950226,
0.41763851046562195,
0.41936275362968445,
0.20555715262889862,
-0.36573269963264465,
-0.4642159640789032,
-0.7959101796150208,
-0.05358172208070755,
-0.22423362731933594,
0.11241516470909119,
-0.05823853611946106,
0.29917487502098083,
0.22321490943431854,
0.13623908162117004,
-0.254107266664505,
-0.39979270100593567,
-0.3628009259700775,
-0.42979010939598083,
0.4821622371673584,
0.07075906544923782,
0.42326492071151733,
-0.32462066411972046,
-0.26238417625427246,
-0.31238627433776855,
-0.46916162967681885,
0.2726675271987915,
0.35298874974250793,
0.2315945327281952,
0.08835378289222717,
0.6009003520011902,
-0.200129434466362,
0.8160435557365417,
0.5376299619674683,
-0.08945836871862411,
-0.0776638463139534,
-0.38736310601234436,
-0.09114222973585129,
0.4530445337295532,
0.7112283110618591,
0.28055092692375183,
0.09051550924777985,
-0.1301814764738083,
-0.4012798070907593,
0.7173385620117188,
0.34373345971107483,
-0.7236748933792114,
-0.29156363010406494,
-0.023855039849877357,
-0.307451993227005,
-0.2986109256744385,
-0.08494773507118225,
-0.7022360563278198,
0.06540246307849884,
-0.4486904740333557,
0.3443405330181122,
-0.6288071274757385,
-0.4478975832462311,
0.5327933430671692,
-0.24580074846744537,
0.7418943047523499,
-0.06553944945335388,
-1.1424355506896973,
0.6237277388572693,
0.4773883521556854,
0.40831539034843445,
-0.03830457106232643,
0.05094034597277641,
-0.4965507984161377,
0.4172849953174591,
-0.5271029472351074,
0.5590401291847229,
-0.6328163743019104,
-0.38188138604164124,
-0.0947856456041336,
-0.4259909391403198,
-0.014133886434137821,
-0.396234393119812,
0.9575886726379395,
-0.9435831904411316,
0.1776430904865265,
-0.3395785689353943,
-0.4425177276134491,
-0.1016981303691864,
0.10964927822351456,
-0.5218970775604248,
0.7051966786384583,
-0.021891262382268906,
-0.7160505652427673,
0.7609909176826477,
-0.476104199886322,
-0.8262499570846558,
0.31929436326026917,
-0.6087719798088074,
-0.22176992893218994,
-0.039498042315244675,
-0.002230830257758498,
0.1592608392238617,
-0.32155707478523254,
0.5713090300559998,
0.14111296832561493,
-0.008631706237792969,
0.24878787994384766,
-0.4183976352214813,
0.6253631114959717,
0.46030229330062866,
-0.48187655210494995,
0.1527290642261505,
-0.5834059715270996,
0.39104053378105164,
0.49554020166397095,
-0.8890495300292969,
-0.218942329287529,
0.46381810307502747,
-0.05293675884604454,
0.5342065691947937,
0.27013906836509705,
-0.6020636558532715,
-0.17068436741828918,
-0.054083507508039474,
0.5095932483673096,
0.413665771484375,
-0.06591247767210007,
0.43594735860824585,
-0.47786736488342285,
0.6443698406219482,
-0.09982413053512573,
-0.018939968198537827,
0.17322351038455963,
-0.010601037181913853,
-1.0133367776870728,
-0.14549271762371063,
0.09105728566646576,
0.7398282289505005,
-0.8153853416442871,
0.7621035575866699,
-0.12945106625556946,
-0.10308850556612015,
-0.5377573370933533,
0.18373240530490875,
0.6973257660865784,
0.27198779582977295,
0.36318323016166687,
0.03787316381931305,
-0.7105663418769836,
-0.8351543545722961,
-0.1427251100540161,
-0.10724543780088425,
0.08328858017921448,
-0.025882499292492867,
0.23138169944286346,
-0.07991400361061096,
0.9770687222480774,
-0.45531725883483887,
-0.14838983118534088,
-0.7727181911468506,
-0.3033207654953003,
0.013295034877955914,
0.5653743147850037,
0.015743901953101158,
-1.118199348449707,
-0.12996536493301392,
-0.1083354651927948,
-0.5701379179954529,
0.0008870490128174424,
-0.39948710799217224,
-0.36376139521598816,
0.12254437804222107,
0.8918328285217285,
-0.6346330046653748,
0.37545961141586304,
0.3497219383716583,
-0.6802310347557068,
0.5910494327545166,
-0.4872526228427887,
-0.059373024851083755,
-0.8227726817131042,
-0.1292153000831604,
-0.3423290252685547,
-0.12741033732891083,
-0.5170167088508606,
0.0947495549917221,
0.2248702347278595,
0.019640816375613213,
-0.12723952531814575,
0.15777616202831268,
-0.37735164165496826,
0.43818119168281555,
-0.2513190805912018,
-0.15577813982963562,
0.10396655648946762,
0.46415024995803833,
0.35907480120658875,
0.6154927611351013,
0.39601609110832214,
-0.8533697724342346,
0.11334320902824402,
0.4002707004547119,
-0.27071884274482727,
0.501244306564331,
-0.6575802564620972,
0.15469405055046082,
-0.26926934719085693,
0.1996450573205948,
-0.6968131065368652,
-0.08495818823575974,
0.12995308637619019,
-0.12428444623947144,
0.5049248933792114,
-0.03849828615784645,
-0.485076367855072,
-0.52305668592453,
0.13153992593288422,
0.558202862739563,
0.7478894591331482,
-0.5678073763847351,
0.5991598963737488,
0.38639235496520996,
0.11063418537378311,
-0.17315544188022614,
-0.8000550866127014,
0.12412375211715698,
-0.16235452890396118,
-0.5085001587867737,
0.4482184648513794,
-0.44827714562416077,
-0.3565104007720947,
-0.2998526990413666,
-0.15597742795944214,
0.3760988414287567,
-0.12497541308403015,
0.20884686708450317,
0.08121885359287262,
0.006777810864150524,
-0.27667272090911865,
0.4165695309638977,
-0.2881869077682495,
0.278300017118454,
-0.36102402210235596,
0.606939435005188,
-0.10134591907262802,
-0.11767762899398804,
-0.3253909945487976,
0.47729209065437317,
0.5163941383361816,
-0.6007446646690369,
0.5418059825897217,
0.0013171047903597355,
0.0416572168469429,
-0.6394462585449219,
-0.42139554023742676,
-0.11480922251939774,
-0.5593377351760864,
0.05680156499147415,
-0.8224045634269714,
-0.6391556262969971,
0.1207897737622261,
-0.15438702702522278,
-0.16844730079174042,
0.020701825618743896,
0.5552290678024292,
0.35540270805358887,
1.195399284362793,
0.6156651377677917,
0.2729075849056244,
0.45639434456825256,
-0.09641463309526443,
0.11676066368818283,
-0.5905755162239075,
-0.3406502902507782,
-0.2807525396347046,
-0.14468303322792053,
-0.42968904972076416,
-0.3816544711589813,
-0.02770453877747059,
0.5651511549949646,
-0.3042422831058502,
0.2835101783275604,
-0.6972231864929199,
0.562628448009491,
0.6655493378639221,
0.30610617995262146,
0.21873651444911957,
-0.24609452486038208,
-0.6558382511138916,
0.07447023689746857,
-0.9793444871902466,
-0.5905976295471191,
0.7714060544967651,
-0.13344958424568176,
0.734779417514801,
0.25116443634033203,
0.9207879304885864,
0.28665584325790405,
-0.1107652559876442,
-0.8064770698547363,
0.7561931014060974,
-0.04764014855027199,
-0.7849020957946777,
-0.08687179535627365,
-0.490325391292572,
-0.9747639298439026,
0.3514869809150696,
-0.25936609506607056,
-0.19884513318538666,
0.1589077264070511,
0.31516221165657043,
-0.14570751786231995,
0.3422907292842865,
-0.6203408241271973,
0.753856897354126,
-0.36607569456100464,
-0.2518467307090759,
-0.1283925175666809,
-0.6394541263580322,
0.27870848774909973,
-0.020076993852853775,
0.1959700733423233,
0.18912512063980103,
-0.014113403856754303,
0.6868476867675781,
-0.5056086778640747,
0.7377403974533081,
-0.18924076855182648,
-0.13652026653289795,
0.4708855152130127,
0.4943293035030365,
0.46076929569244385,
-0.16891580820083618,
-0.11691921949386597,
-0.27614104747772217,
0.017841588705778122,
-0.4557352066040039,
-0.1358606070280075,
0.4381664991378784,
-0.8653000593185425,
-0.7109283208847046,
-0.3625810742378235,
-0.4001758396625519,
0.00398501381278038,
0.6575766205787659,
0.6522620916366577,
0.370854914188385,
-0.3548071086406708,
-0.11336847394704819,
0.6499484777450562,
0.07114962488412857,
0.2760244607925415,
0.5788189172744751,
-0.11707359552383423,
-0.47284895181655884,
0.7979701161384583,
-0.1865706592798233,
0.5546219944953918,
0.7226005792617798,
0.2949932813644409,
-0.1795504242181778,
-0.6892535090446472,
-0.2288343459367752,
0.02373533323407173,
-0.5640747547149658,
-0.13022322952747345,
-0.3089982867240906,
-0.3820434808731079,
-0.12431550025939941,
-0.5094500184059143,
-0.2669313848018646,
0.04646933823823929,
-0.0925285741686821,
-0.14517559111118317,
0.06427125632762909,
0.6029549837112427,
-0.12692080438137054,
0.31125473976135254,
-0.40616774559020996,
0.5639228820800781,
0.3847009539604187,
0.35282978415489197,
-0.4846346378326416,
-0.2302199751138687,
0.15603449940681458,
0.06309688836336136,
-0.055938366800546646,
-0.6911318302154541,
0.1907966434955597,
-0.073490209877491,
0.5927972197532654,
0.47548526525497437,
0.43624433875083923,
0.27573615312576294,
-0.5595681071281433,
0.2482074648141861,
0.3001724183559418,
-1.044849157333374,
0.8544596433639526,
-0.2712874710559845,
0.5122621059417725,
0.540198028087616,
-0.22961120307445526,
-0.4395647644996643,
-0.5312903523445129,
-0.4511881172657013,
-0.5206858515739441,
0.9897025227546692,
0.27706634998321533,
0.09430944174528122,
-0.3701171576976776,
0.39630934596061707,
0.04885786399245262,
-0.046466901898384094,
-0.48197999596595764,
-0.03265322744846344,
-0.3035615384578705,
-0.23009169101715088,
-0.1719878911972046,
-0.3204306364059448,
-0.08319777995347977,
0.13214638829231262,
0.5307784676551819,
-0.09311509132385254,
-0.015992265194654465,
0.3517151176929474,
-0.21051184833049774,
-0.34152349829673767,
0.6269858479499817,
0.4331815540790558,
0.32794493436813354,
-0.21261721849441528,
0.31051918864250183,
-0.13960140943527222,
-0.47765418887138367,
0.30442047119140625,
0.09861700981855392,
-0.8157771229743958,
-0.38557493686676025,
-0.003722115885466337,
0.8984470367431641,
0.1596367061138153,
-0.6232062578201294,
0.32656458020210266,
-0.3425818979740143,
-0.4595153033733368,
-0.366656094789505,
0.4669096767902374,
-0.06018448248505592,
0.23401005566120148,
0.08629972487688065,
0.46459344029426575,
-0.21144011616706848,
-0.0617830753326416,
0.15064556896686554,
0.4872066080570221,
-0.4134792387485504,
-0.308488667011261,
0.8728018403053284,
0.27516084909439087,
-0.36682409048080444,
0.38227954506874084,
-0.5265257358551025,
-0.5461408495903015,
0.5191458463668823,
1.0088410377502441,
0.6698189973831177,
-0.18028020858764648,
0.2956300675868988,
0.1871892362833023,
0.47180575132369995,
-0.23225419223308563,
0.5985679030418396,
-0.3919694125652313,
-1.3400862216949463,
-0.4877505600452423,
-0.7596140503883362,
-0.14674946665763855,
-0.05758417025208473,
-0.9151608347892761,
0.206532284617424,
-0.7539551854133606,
-0.23586060106754303,
-0.04655386507511139,
-0.09852811694145203,
-0.6560534834861755,
0.23396240174770355,
0.4851219654083252,
0.782410204410553,
-0.37630289793014526,
0.991487979888916,
0.63981693983078,
-0.37070193886756897,
-0.8297447562217712,
-0.05076909810304642,
0.0695192888379097,
-0.507500946521759,
0.5748968720436096,
-0.08984813094139099,
-0.7065386772155762,
0.22371993958950043,
-0.4747545123100281,
-0.8660725951194763,
0.9698619246482849,
0.48599642515182495,
-0.49628207087516785,
-0.015884973108768463,
-0.034372635185718536,
0.3522365987300873,
-0.1194370687007904,
-0.1763135939836502,
0.7877691984176636,
0.47005578875541687,
0.3687700927257538,
-0.6449142694473267,
0.41945916414260864,
-0.23297399282455444,
0.006390067283064127,
0.800640344619751,
-0.7004085779190063,
0.5156079530715942,
-0.6109201908111572,
-0.4917757213115692,
0.02334185689687729,
0.6404231786727905,
0.3769678771495819,
-0.05998757854104042,
0.5405551195144653,
0.47140148282051086,
0.544086217880249,
0.2958739995956421,
1.014283537864685,
-0.2837604284286499,
0.0930863544344902,
1.063096046447754,
-0.2601226568222046,
0.8243979811668396,
0.45818424224853516,
-0.18306128680706024,
0.6311506628990173,
0.00004355961209512316,
0.19127552211284637,
0.6628296971321106,
0.3116203844547272,
-0.38080570101737976,
-0.6275185346603394,
-0.0035006890539079905,
-0.02027176506817341,
0.7325565814971924,
0.7489273548126221,
-0.0855964794754982,
-0.09907907247543335,
-0.012010825797915459,
0.2972351312637329,
0.3670746088027954,
-0.4155271351337433,
0.9785701632499695,
-0.20790964365005493,
-0.9439154863357544,
0.8863213658332825,
0.12075905501842499,
0.8508930206298828,
-0.9724926948547363,
0.1184496060013771,
0.07803389430046082,
0.6217975616455078,
-0.014021659269928932,
-0.6119449734687805,
0.08014222234487534,
-0.25557419657707214,
-0.45031338930130005,
-0.4446224868297577,
0.9366554617881775,
-0.6495471000671387,
-0.47367045283317566,
0.5882725119590759,
0.2848058044910431,
-0.23989762365818024,
0.23702774941921234,
-0.5767091512680054,
-0.01880667544901371,
0.31379133462905884,
-0.11028361320495605,
0.1011449322104454,
0.48126739263534546,
-0.03823515772819519,
0.5128808617591858,
0.7150582671165466,
0.13545635342597961,
0.20389902591705322,
-0.15764282643795013,
0.7409884333610535,
-0.8129687309265137,
-0.7176457643508911,
-0.6449639201164246,
0.1259821653366089,
0.21177522838115692,
-0.20979230105876923,
0.4592006802558899,
0.36526617407798767,
1.0621973276138306,
0.005109316203743219,
1.0287245512008667,
-0.41112077236175537,
0.13993044197559357,
-0.6193627715110779,
0.5662166476249695,
-0.06916753947734833,
0.03220224007964134,
0.07983270287513733,
-0.5187549591064453,
-0.3428458869457245,
0.3681885898113251,
-0.4334319829940796,
0.11998859792947769,
0.5775266289710999,
0.8650026917457581,
-0.022472823038697243,
0.015309191308915615,
0.3293244540691376,
0.04423055797815323,
0.3576081693172455,
0.822625458240509,
0.9750649333000183,
0.06438299268484116,
1.0200356245040894,
-0.30035993456840515,
-0.45302441716194153,
-0.05063183233141899,
-0.6063262820243835,
-0.8572962880134583,
-0.3566686511039734,
-0.19070680439472198,
-0.3691611588001251,
-0.03680399805307388,
0.7840948700904846,
0.8159610033035278,
-0.907476544380188,
-0.37762388586997986,
-0.5760015845298767,
0.18167883157730103,
-0.3259446322917938,
-0.21255095303058624,
0.18899047374725342,
-0.5068932771682739,
-0.35888537764549255,
0.4062948226928711,
0.030346812680363655,
-0.0914197638630867,
0.08216080814599991,
-0.5053592324256897,
-0.20385484397411346,
0.3418338894844055,
0.5801588892936707,
0.45069795846939087,
-0.7374188899993896,
-0.09340249001979828,
-0.3526607155799866,
-0.24597901105880737,
-0.06548754125833511,
1.3030943870544434,
-0.9263440370559692,
0.7063326835632324,
0.40456321835517883,
0.37071555852890015,
0.4794389009475708,
-0.11203809082508087,
0.778314471244812,
-0.535633385181427,
0.03915045037865639,
0.21611225605010986,
0.2601874768733978,
0.21130526065826416,
-0.39505016803741455,
-0.003878240706399083,
0.028906742110848427,
-0.5495756268501282,
-0.17017967998981476,
0.5201650261878967,
-0.9584716558456421,
-0.5943167805671692,
1.1520384550094604,
0.25089696049690247,
-0.1824621558189392,
-0.18470467627048492,
-0.5728928446769714,
0.3818754255771637,
-0.6262369751930237,
0.36371707916259766,
0.26990196108818054,
-0.11955524981021881,
-0.08154520392417908,
-0.2388470470905304,
0.7941199541091919,
0.6280415058135986,
-0.5783553719520569,
0.25566336512565613,
0.6803621649742126,
0.25493302941322327,
0.24101941287517548,
0.6044555306434631,
-0.1416553556919098,
0.18098516762256622,
0.23328855633735657,
0.3217310309410095,
-0.022412989288568497,
-0.22184091806411743,
-0.2299252599477768,
0.13482539355754852,
0.1598319411277771,
-0.22112725675106049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.02366v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.02366v1
|
Human Evaluation of English--Irish Transformer-Based NMT
| 2024-03-04T11:45:46 | 2024-03-04T11:45:46 |
Séamus Lankford, Haithem Afli, Andy Way
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this study, a human evaluation is carried out on how hyperparameter
settings impact the quality of Transformer-based Neural Machine Translation
(NMT) for the low-resourced English--Irish pair. SentencePiece models using
both Byte Pair Encoding (BPE) and unigram approaches were appraised. Variations
in model architectures included modifying the number of layers, evaluating the
optimal number of heads for attention and testing various regularisation
techniques. The greatest performance improvement was recorded for a
Transformer-optimized model with a 16k BPE subword model. Compared with a
baseline Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) model, a Transformer-optimized model
demonstrated a BLEU score improvement of 7.8 points. When benchmarked against
Google Translate, our translation engines demonstrated significant
improvements. Furthermore, a quantitative fine-grained manual evaluation was
conducted which compared the performance of machine translation systems. Using
the Multidimensional Quality Metrics (MQM) error taxonomy, a human evaluation
of the error types generated by an RNN-based system and a Transformer-based
system was explored. Our findings show the best-performing Transformer system
significantly reduces both accuracy and fluency errors when compared with an
RNN-based model.
|
[
-0.2479003220796585,
-0.2902117967605591,
0.14473247528076172,
0.33962205052375793,
-0.33744120597839355,
-0.05188547819852829,
-0.25155356526374817,
-0.3967328369617462,
0.3446124792098999,
0.5016288161277771,
-0.09558551013469696,
-0.08021893352270126,
-0.6815488338470459,
0.6196064352989197,
-0.16120971739292145,
0.7112925052642822,
0.004793629050254822,
0.35836082696914673,
0.18943758308887482,
-0.13731448352336884,
-0.7526994347572327,
-0.2340279221534729,
-0.6885464787483215,
-0.6447383165359497,
0.5059533715248108,
0.34832271933555603,
0.8900529742240906,
0.5286401510238647,
1.0879489183425903,
0.3318089246749878,
-0.23853608965873718,
0.15595117211341858,
-0.19696666300296783,
-0.0970698818564415,
-0.39495575428009033,
-0.39167964458465576,
-0.5709666609764099,
0.04471319541335106,
0.388257771730423,
0.5985399484634399,
-0.11655575782060623,
0.28224295377731323,
0.19459369778633118,
0.7263492345809937,
-0.39070138335227966,
0.05862695351243019,
-0.5548504590988159,
0.34599804878234863,
0.08804719895124435,
-0.20862331986427307,
-0.5903487205505371,
0.02680809050798416,
0.32090166211128235,
-0.4331527352333069,
0.1868823766708374,
0.2567056119441986,
0.8121973872184753,
0.32008248567581177,
-0.4557795524597168,
0.014471564441919327,
-0.7580049633979797,
0.8139914870262146,
-0.6449792981147766,
0.6866422295570374,
0.1924496740102768,
0.3106779158115387,
-0.2094254344701767,
-0.47271451354026794,
-0.2716405391693115,
-0.36957553029060364,
-0.2642357051372528,
0.5717305541038513,
-0.28987058997154236,
0.07483267784118652,
0.0032398353796452284,
0.3712071478366852,
-0.6344560384750366,
-0.03267037123441696,
-0.643121063709259,
-0.29255449771881104,
0.39832448959350586,
0.1349075436592102,
0.16107715666294098,
-0.7341618537902832,
-0.5982850790023804,
-0.11140303313732147,
-0.15662254393100739,
-0.1511894166469574,
0.2696070969104767,
0.28031542897224426,
0.0541885681450367,
0.7150897979736328,
-0.3033946454524994,
0.4728821814060211,
0.05979626998305321,
-0.15100610256195068,
0.06287969648838043,
-0.4026342034339905,
-0.20935651659965515,
-0.18360549211502075,
0.9362258315086365,
0.7483314275741577,
0.33216625452041626,
-0.5843663811683655,
-0.5772591829299927,
0.20972321927547455,
0.5154010057449341,
-0.6812834143638611,
-0.008637242019176483,
-0.19784991443157196,
-0.5617703199386597,
-0.28373444080352783,
0.09342688322067261,
-0.727834939956665,
-0.022317856550216675,
-0.3791339099407196,
0.7020055055618286,
-0.2954387664794922,
-0.07918704301118851,
0.3953906297683716,
-0.2131960690021515,
0.2426236867904663,
0.08816532045602798,
-0.5978013873100281,
0.33639535307884216,
0.3039706349372864,
0.9874489307403564,
-0.613274335861206,
-0.3599820137023926,
-0.19458039104938507,
-0.12620015442371368,
-0.1990477740764618,
0.6963681578636169,
0.13225935399532318,
-0.22829654812812805,
-0.28706467151641846,
0.03182733431458473,
-0.28406059741973877,
-0.808052659034729,
0.8822668790817261,
-0.5034630298614502,
0.30640101432800293,
0.13721561431884766,
-0.20515838265419006,
-0.05444886535406113,
0.13219185173511505,
-0.8531986474990845,
0.9201269149780273,
0.3997003734111786,
-0.5776082277297974,
0.17818348109722137,
-0.9296817779541016,
-0.4604584872722626,
0.17608052492141724,
0.31194615364074707,
-0.1694716364145279,
0.30584052205085754,
0.1254027783870697,
0.4857209622859955,
-0.6947669982910156,
0.159948468208313,
0.4530782997608185,
-0.5204158425331116,
0.3105050325393677,
-0.8335397243499756,
0.5941815376281738,
0.15733212232589722,
-0.5055831074714661,
-0.2368462234735489,
-0.881679356098175,
0.03453128784894943,
-0.05455251410603523,
-0.5832933783531189,
0.07118590921163559,
-0.49846360087394714,
0.4765521287918091,
0.4712643623352051,
-0.06246831268072128,
-0.6799371242523193,
-0.2339908331632614,
-0.41755372285842896,
0.8002603650093079,
0.27123671770095825,
-0.03765527531504631,
0.3745901882648468,
-0.22577640414237976,
0.5691566467285156,
0.2951546013355255,
0.22376476228237152,
0.029753385111689568,
-0.7474083304405212,
-0.5691989660263062,
0.21094673871994019,
0.5920373201370239,
0.9099162817001343,
-0.850376307964325,
0.49292024970054626,
-0.4226810932159424,
-0.21105757355690002,
-0.9421629309654236,
0.192543163895607,
0.6483311057090759,
0.7840357422828674,
0.5907230973243713,
-0.6632959842681885,
-0.23835459351539612,
-1.1739813089370728,
-0.2105989158153534,
-0.20696181058883667,
-0.2545320391654968,
-0.023922687396407127,
0.5290144085884094,
-0.42398640513420105,
0.746653139591217,
-0.13355529308319092,
-0.2275245487689972,
-0.11954744905233383,
0.25901541113853455,
0.16568692028522491,
0.513931155204773,
0.03981901705265045,
-0.7564221024513245,
-0.24545983970165253,
0.27810561656951904,
-0.448860764503479,
-0.06245150789618492,
-0.05296478420495987,
-0.24125325679779053,
0.23956257104873657,
-0.029705572873353958,
-0.6297079920768738,
0.5644025802612305,
0.5996506810188293,
-0.2768060266971588,
0.7957844138145447,
-0.2430780827999115,
0.47398945689201355,
-1.1446946859359741,
-0.05578158050775528,
0.18252123892307281,
-0.2445623278617859,
-0.37463822960853577,
0.022018147632479668,
0.20322206616401672,
-0.18432721495628357,
-0.7041802406311035,
0.344270795583725,
-0.172036811709404,
-0.04554469883441925,
-0.0667135939002037,
0.07051756978034973,
0.5113548636436462,
0.4041794240474701,
-0.08618183434009552,
1.1462664604187012,
-0.22437891364097595,
-0.1110227108001709,
0.5307988524436951,
0.420084685087204,
-0.3933664560317993,
0.7959319949150085,
-0.9092655777931213,
0.19549162685871124,
0.17775258421897888,
-0.09640545397996902,
-1.0095821619033813,
-0.22470824420452118,
0.01670036092400551,
-0.5977936387062073,
0.11360310763120651,
-0.10835660248994827,
-0.15994535386562347,
-0.3769879937171936,
-0.020001128315925598,
0.16655206680297852,
0.4527808725833893,
-0.3259405195713043,
0.3283196985721588,
-0.15414759516716003,
0.1239805743098259,
-0.5140575766563416,
-1.2290979623794556,
0.5039000511169434,
-0.14063677191734314,
-0.9395536780357361,
0.3968430757522583,
0.14755503833293915,
-0.1645224392414093,
-0.12282304465770721,
-0.22696484625339508,
-0.2833576202392578,
-0.015137002803385258,
-0.1899021416902542,
0.18459635972976685,
-0.5873666405677795,
-0.00044159471872262657,
-0.2977322041988373,
-0.4660520851612091,
0.1455717384815216,
-0.5328453779220581,
0.2676555812358856,
-0.25926849246025085,
0.03822094202041626,
-0.8634926676750183,
0.31891751289367676,
0.5346367955207825,
-0.30324140191078186,
0.6624888181686401,
0.7941225171089172,
-0.3328035771846771,
0.09450018405914307,
-0.7705371975898743,
-0.347174733877182,
-0.39053642749786377,
0.41920408606529236,
-0.4503780007362366,
-0.6251559257507324,
0.4733729064464569,
0.11949635297060013,
-0.2993117570877075,
0.677280068397522,
0.4307381808757782,
-0.31796151399612427,
0.67082279920578,
0.28869354724884033,
0.17625099420547485,
0.08740312606096268,
-0.23848100006580353,
0.06486811488866806,
-1.1254149675369263,
0.02021593600511551,
-0.37184780836105347,
-0.5060838460922241,
-0.7584720849990845,
-0.2980022132396698,
0.36418673396110535,
0.07850553840398788,
-0.03825926408171654,
0.8010028004646301,
-0.6287493109703064,
0.5230709314346313,
0.5540323853492737,
0.44433099031448364,
0.34352749586105347,
-0.12403999269008636,
-0.21115079522132874,
-0.16536229848861694,
-0.7140640616416931,
-0.9528458714485168,
1.0717828273773193,
0.3295850157737732,
0.5888445377349854,
0.058776333928108215,
0.39100056886672974,
0.39815017580986023,
0.10976578295230865,
-0.9390860199928284,
0.2171401083469391,
-0.26750075817108154,
-0.598991334438324,
-0.5050521492958069,
-0.7059751152992249,
-0.939479410648346,
0.26597410440444946,
-0.2327379286289215,
-0.3968098759651184,
0.010966422036290169,
0.016159916296601295,
-0.5219963788986206,
0.36726000905036926,
-1.1853551864624023,
0.9898461103439331,
-0.2295398712158203,
-0.36094796657562256,
0.22401055693626404,
-0.6512289643287659,
0.11952490359544754,
-0.01480018813163042,
-0.22460736334323883,
0.15596555173397064,
-0.07341697067022324,
0.7698827385902405,
-0.06350497901439667,
0.3757902681827545,
0.09481951594352722,
0.10166388750076294,
0.04443660378456116,
0.11928308010101318,
0.33874157071113586,
0.08681507408618927,
-0.3749885857105255,
0.3030932545661926,
-0.08329214155673981,
-0.4830165207386017,
-0.8004146814346313,
0.2634403109550476,
-0.8392985463142395,
-0.5475881695747375,
-0.04840805009007454,
-0.5859575867652893,
-0.13050906360149384,
0.15950040519237518,
0.5168207883834839,
0.6601272225379944,
-0.03235050290822983,
0.5203096866607666,
0.5512538552284241,
-0.07680635899305344,
0.3311068117618561,
0.15608525276184082,
0.19087232649326324,
-0.7401557564735413,
0.540641188621521,
0.2725011706352234,
0.5028595328330994,
0.6032266020774841,
0.4475524127483368,
-0.26286739110946655,
-0.6672375798225403,
-0.7950153946876526,
0.0580768920481205,
-0.5220778584480286,
-0.3690768778324127,
-0.4358507990837097,
-0.13879427313804626,
-0.16524331271648407,
-0.0663846805691719,
-0.4013162851333618,
-0.5303048491477966,
0.05963796004652977,
0.016940103843808174,
0.14097365736961365,
0.7169294953346252,
0.3972703218460083,
0.8269954323768616,
-0.7158161997795105,
0.15775088965892792,
0.24763093888759613,
0.4706961214542389,
-0.26861828565597534,
-0.8227757215499878,
-0.5286505818367004,
-0.06398647278547287,
-0.3603213131427765,
-0.6984906196594238,
0.3847041428089142,
-0.14011940360069275,
0.1053619384765625,
0.05538361892104149,
-0.17887645959854126,
0.5395166873931885,
-0.7699748873710632,
0.7663367390632629,
0.28405678272247314,
-0.8245178461074829,
0.1641208827495575,
-0.18091776967048645,
0.43020468950271606,
0.6453951001167297,
0.13028669357299805,
-0.7402077317237854,
-0.1286131739616394,
-0.3907723128795624,
-0.6468966603279114,
0.571037769317627,
0.48300549387931824,
0.008058539591729641,
-0.06723996251821518,
0.6285949945449829,
-0.07932530343532562,
0.03825012966990471,
-0.5437099933624268,
-0.09325727075338364,
-0.15172319114208221,
-0.1488567590713501,
-0.16716518998146057,
-0.09082808345556259,
0.2270914912223816,
-0.15790823101997375,
0.5802685022354126,
0.017358075827360153,
0.5440775156021118,
0.4993881583213806,
-0.5157034397125244,
-0.1305532455444336,
0.4244275689125061,
0.7606887817382812,
0.7869797348976135,
-0.4275047779083252,
0.053619641810655594,
0.4481077492237091,
-0.8028478026390076,
0.44316238164901733,
-0.2385384440422058,
-0.13628223538398743,
0.30858689546585083,
0.4749698042869568,
0.6846926808357239,
0.35429224371910095,
-0.11124027520418167,
0.5204827785491943,
-0.21353751420974731,
0.05826583877205849,
-0.11716071516275406,
-0.19718562066555023,
0.15581519901752472,
0.032464686781167984,
0.36689087748527527,
0.4987403154373169,
0.27341631054878235,
-0.028224807232618332,
0.3965655565261841,
-0.04427522048354149,
-0.5692186951637268,
-0.46696946024894714,
0.6162432432174683,
0.4709852337837219,
-0.891922652721405,
0.3751630485057831,
-0.16826801002025604,
-0.5356564521789551,
0.5073325037956238,
0.5958747863769531,
1.0092031955718994,
-0.4555615782737732,
0.11906915158033371,
0.19859927892684937,
0.8695104122161865,
-0.2521004378795624,
-0.014102442190051079,
0.35309016704559326,
-0.7335732579231262,
-0.6935293674468994,
-0.6296419501304626,
-0.5396468043327332,
0.03345312923192978,
-0.8987260460853577,
0.24580027163028717,
-0.0071633909828960896,
-0.46383482217788696,
0.1199818104505539,
0.13297133147716522,
-0.9721310138702393,
0.4254838526248932,
-0.30820897221565247,
1.0235673189163208,
-0.6337725520133972,
0.56461101770401,
0.8662155270576477,
-0.41044655442237854,
-0.6970577239990234,
-0.13011109828948975,
-0.2214624583721161,
-0.598124623298645,
0.8111563324928284,
0.12071848660707474,
-0.3338145613670349,
0.04732685908675194,
0.22114503383636475,
-0.5665484070777893,
1.1327918767929077,
0.3946980834007263,
-0.6410240530967712,
-0.047015100717544556,
0.594068169593811,
0.6109720468521118,
-0.163839653134346,
0.7172559499740601,
0.6991987228393555,
0.5493580102920532,
-0.3272194266319275,
-1.1681228876113892,
-0.2935476303100586,
-0.0765940248966217,
0.3859812319278717,
0.3826383650302887,
-0.7659187316894531,
0.4593415856361389,
0.40587475895881653,
0.04572225734591484,
-0.15526920557022095,
0.5025659203529358,
-0.3950999677181244,
0.07244852185249329,
0.4065089225769043,
0.5839700698852539,
0.3938022553920746,
-0.1342896670103073,
1.0520148277282715,
-0.2928469479084015,
0.28831207752227783,
0.8412353992462158,
-0.09353282302618027,
0.927868127822876,
0.563842236995697,
-0.1820569485425949,
0.0429634191095829,
0.14644022285938263,
0.24088983237743378,
0.12089648842811584,
0.28992602229118347,
0.005109161138534546,
-0.02611485682427883,
0.08450932800769806,
0.05362667515873909,
0.7312085032463074,
-0.06814272701740265,
-0.36056625843048096,
-0.1418813019990921,
0.1887822151184082,
-0.18711990118026733,
0.13347318768501282,
-0.18113680183887482,
0.759763777256012,
0.0006083041080273688,
-0.6069656014442444,
0.5909194350242615,
0.3056952953338623,
1.0350277423858643,
-0.17469505965709686,
0.16406846046447754,
-0.5155355334281921,
0.12818863987922668,
-0.2603379189968109,
-0.6102433204650879,
0.5303943157196045,
0.11696816980838776,
-0.42410874366760254,
-0.25940319895744324,
0.5993379354476929,
-0.372737318277359,
-0.6465378999710083,
0.3740207254886627,
0.614266037940979,
0.29397979378700256,
-0.019883301109075546,
-0.6850663423538208,
-0.21550458669662476,
-0.17836403846740723,
-0.3915419280529022,
0.054505590349435806,
0.5941166877746582,
-0.10688278079032898,
0.33800873160362244,
0.36210018396377563,
0.20210127532482147,
0.17430467903614044,
-0.06767600774765015,
0.28082916140556335,
-0.8806877136230469,
-0.21463480591773987,
-0.7209906578063965,
0.4944268763065338,
0.13776373863220215,
-0.6944728493690491,
0.4873145520687103,
0.5469245910644531,
0.9742749333381653,
-0.27791836857795715,
0.29090267419815063,
0.47585687041282654,
0.3715529143810272,
-0.4743812680244446,
0.8696805834770203,
-0.202791228890419,
-0.08478469401597977,
-0.1221301332116127,
-1.2179512977600098,
-0.46206724643707275,
0.5869190692901611,
-0.12376345694065094,
-0.20888690650463104,
0.9028927683830261,
0.9004387259483337,
-0.24941343069076538,
0.05120168626308441,
0.804298460483551,
-0.022148404270410538,
-0.0839882344007492,
0.5353963375091553,
0.8453648090362549,
-0.9460668563842773,
0.5985276699066162,
-0.373161643743515,
-0.22344672679901123,
-0.06793662905693054,
-0.8099405169487,
-0.6875958442687988,
-0.43067046999931335,
-0.27544906735420227,
-0.3560371994972229,
0.17996235191822052,
1.3121581077575684,
0.640649676322937,
-0.8219259977340698,
-0.4633163809776306,
0.33093827962875366,
-0.1747436374425888,
-0.34006768465042114,
-0.22704251110553741,
0.2565678358078003,
-0.41257244348526,
-0.6840378642082214,
0.36175963282585144,
0.382990300655365,
-0.1688230186700821,
-0.3340829312801361,
-0.05318913236260414,
-0.14422836899757385,
-0.0013402996119111776,
0.8731299638748169,
-0.3889716863632202,
-0.7248804569244385,
-0.4288712739944458,
0.335295170545578,
-0.25219136476516724,
0.4714207351207733,
0.528822660446167,
-0.46999597549438477,
0.3887231647968292,
0.3809066712856293,
1.030957818031311,
0.19673731923103333,
-0.017604287713766098,
0.5398806929588318,
-0.5448760390281677,
0.07387249916791916,
0.3704604506492615,
0.5158641338348389,
0.4137895703315735,
-0.401924192905426,
0.7001075744628906,
0.313376247882843,
-0.7168213129043579,
-0.4603955149650574,
-0.08453993499279022,
-0.8191800117492676,
0.41491296887397766,
1.0064983367919922,
-0.2676066756248474,
-0.48981374502182007,
-0.2896585166454315,
-0.177686408162117,
0.3035745322704315,
-0.3068769574165344,
0.7157558798789978,
0.9738547801971436,
0.17060314118862152,
0.04497232288122177,
-0.9725939035415649,
0.028988609090447426,
0.7079539895057678,
-0.5023126006126404,
-0.4096331298351288,
0.007769055664539337,
0.15567924082279205,
0.48903003334999084,
-0.15998686850070953,
-0.23275013267993927,
0.41235145926475525,
-0.2915843725204468,
0.41803309321403503,
-0.06834819167852402,
-0.32314935326576233,
-0.649310827255249,
0.0017136844107881188,
-0.18224355578422546,
-0.279092937707901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01931v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01931v2
|
VariErr NLI: Separating Annotation Error from Human Label Variation
| 2024-03-04T10:57:14 | 2024-06-06T06:18:54 |
Leon Weber-Genzel, Siyao Peng, Marie-Catherine de Marneffe, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Human label variation arises when annotators assign different labels to the
same item for valid reasons, while annotation errors occur when labels are
assigned for invalid reasons. These two issues are prevalent in NLP benchmarks,
yet existing research has studied them in isolation. To the best of our
knowledge, there exists no prior work that focuses on teasing apart error from
signal, especially in cases where signal is beyond black-and-white. To fill
this gap, we introduce a systematic methodology and a new dataset, VariErr
(variation versus error), focusing on the NLI task in English. We propose a
2-round annotation procedure with annotators explaining each label and
subsequently judging the validity of label-explanation pairs. VariErr contains
7,732 validity judgments on 1,933 explanations for 500 re-annotated MNLI items.
We assess the effectiveness of various automatic error detection (AED) methods
and GPTs in uncovering errors versus human label variation. We find that
state-of-the-art AED methods significantly underperform GPTs and humans. While
GPT-4 is the best system, it still falls short of human performance. Our
methodology is applicable beyond NLI, offering fertile ground for future
research on error versus plausible variation, which in turn can yield better
and more trustworthy NLP systems.
|
[
-0.4867079257965088,
-0.5247186422348022,
-0.007022724486887455,
0.2781524956226349,
-0.08747123181819916,
0.28907322883605957,
-0.04130326956510544,
-0.8991361856460571,
0.05929802730679512,
0.3228025436401367,
-0.597760021686554,
-0.33066657185554504,
-0.6808288097381592,
0.3875851333141327,
-0.15712156891822815,
1.0123521089553833,
-0.3385506570339203,
0.06508795917034149,
-0.0059412564150989056,
-0.5148610472679138,
-0.6745894551277161,
-0.7171481251716614,
-0.5605770349502563,
-0.4142342507839203,
0.9430040717124939,
0.3645792007446289,
0.4665994346141815,
0.4566628634929657,
0.6073150634765625,
0.152678444981575,
-0.17411254346370697,
0.5434414148330688,
-0.12706699967384338,
-0.021891234442591667,
-0.1187996119260788,
-0.5686337351799011,
-0.33704787492752075,
-0.13145984709262848,
0.5325369834899902,
0.536374568939209,
-0.04831526055932045,
0.16063334047794342,
-0.03964514285326004,
0.7626329064369202,
-0.7265681028366089,
-0.08042147755622864,
-0.26991090178489685,
0.25573644042015076,
-0.3688217103481293,
-0.06763558089733124,
-0.2525479197502136,
-0.3130273222923279,
0.04968222603201866,
-0.4947056174278259,
0.5902921557426453,
0.1112096905708313,
1.2460896968841553,
0.570037841796875,
-0.2757275700569153,
-0.12358386814594269,
-1.0484371185302734,
0.8358944654464722,
-0.6686707139015198,
0.44228076934814453,
0.4595772922039032,
0.44194358587265015,
0.07067259401082993,
-0.6852226853370667,
-0.5461981892585754,
0.05857829004526138,
-0.03423440828919411,
0.11042563617229462,
-0.1465214639902115,
-0.19812873005867004,
0.2932528555393219,
0.23669318854808807,
-0.3420204520225525,
0.15618661046028137,
-0.41549456119537354,
-0.16866421699523926,
0.7374528050422668,
-0.14587093889713287,
0.35736730694770813,
-0.03191748633980751,
-0.18746031820774078,
-0.3981022238731384,
-0.48951587080955505,
-0.08302102237939835,
0.5636240839958191,
0.04758155718445778,
0.06151825934648514,
0.44154953956604004,
0.03092823550105095,
0.6195715069770813,
-0.0323842354118824,
0.17058832943439484,
0.6194310188293457,
-0.27705010771751404,
-0.10109548270702362,
-0.11932222545146942,
0.8852659463882446,
0.5075576305389404,
0.10387808084487915,
-0.23152783513069153,
-0.35595908761024475,
-0.09729237109422684,
0.25034403800964355,
-0.3905622959136963,
-0.23748649656772614,
0.10895608365535736,
-0.36856210231781006,
-0.23763762414455414,
0.2169792801141739,
-0.9954009652137756,
-0.42617666721343994,
-0.11233209073543549,
0.3242359459400177,
-0.3519667685031891,
-0.3599953055381775,
-0.006685951258987188,
-0.3250749707221985,
0.2118423730134964,
0.12953679263591766,
-0.8758466839790344,
0.3742307424545288,
0.5256384611129761,
0.5613188147544861,
-0.3658859431743622,
-0.32348504662513733,
-0.4380512833595276,
-0.3552244007587433,
-0.374451220035553,
0.7707380652427673,
-0.2493164986371994,
-0.48450905084609985,
-0.02122110314667225,
-0.15647463500499725,
0.03418689966201782,
-0.5743626952171326,
1.0456780195236206,
-0.39284607768058777,
0.12118081003427505,
-0.50950026512146,
-0.6069573163986206,
-0.3113986849784851,
-0.046168480068445206,
-1.0190808773040771,
1.1420854330062866,
0.23002873361110687,
-1.1280007362365723,
0.6748785376548767,
-0.8578639626502991,
-0.1844436079263687,
0.19429151713848114,
-0.31863492727279663,
-0.6682223081588745,
0.20570950210094452,
0.2691846489906311,
0.10373999923467636,
-0.2666667103767395,
0.2088567018508911,
-0.0890120193362236,
-0.30804070830345154,
0.824421226978302,
-0.9398995637893677,
0.596482515335083,
0.12212007492780685,
-0.4156228303909302,
-0.2918534576892853,
-1.0546029806137085,
0.1425577849149704,
-0.051016468554735184,
-0.2406073808670044,
-0.22969047725200653,
0.30387669801712036,
0.546320915222168,
0.11390470713376999,
-0.007283645216375589,
-0.5540986061096191,
-0.026618828997015953,
-0.263926237821579,
0.14881840348243713,
0.4275154769420624,
0.04527973011136055,
0.046797290444374084,
-0.51352459192276,
0.516243040561676,
-0.176674947142601,
0.2866402566432953,
0.20702120661735535,
-0.6764850616455078,
-0.7275972962379456,
-0.10627233982086182,
0.7496290802955627,
0.5921752452850342,
-0.6242892742156982,
0.4567050039768219,
-0.15600399672985077,
-0.24531729519367218,
-0.8142185211181641,
-0.06100250408053398,
0.3798663020133972,
0.3868245482444763,
0.5332919359207153,
-0.4320577383041382,
-0.8130353093147278,
-0.9283266663551331,
-0.4779471158981323,
-0.12913411855697632,
-0.21835508942604065,
0.2755582630634308,
0.3855816721916199,
-0.6150475144386292,
1.2486398220062256,
-0.2388378381729126,
-0.12359876185655594,
0.10408689826726913,
0.709263265132904,
0.09295245260000229,
0.4474896192550659,
0.35408586263656616,
-1.110298991203308,
-0.3348959982395172,
0.01620849221944809,
-0.5119984745979309,
-0.3324836194515228,
-0.20079848170280457,
0.04083574563264847,
0.3518504798412323,
0.2473304122686386,
-0.12892059981822968,
0.621485710144043,
0.43379929661750793,
-0.06639526039361954,
0.7773049473762512,
-0.33825358748435974,
0.07280504703521729,
-0.6785881519317627,
-0.12603266537189484,
0.23363961279392242,
-0.05850014090538025,
-0.7394337058067322,
-0.22761660814285278,
-0.012292814441025257,
0.6881584525108337,
-0.1694396734237671,
0.36665570735931396,
-0.18276168406009674,
0.2566766142845154,
-0.2500367760658264,
-0.21000316739082336,
0.0834413394331932,
0.07611516863107681,
-0.10655558109283447,
0.7055867910385132,
0.10981572419404984,
-0.218174010515213,
0.2023911476135254,
0.04731073975563049,
-0.043207451701164246,
0.5229280591011047,
-0.6514872908592224,
0.16787496209144592,
-0.13305290043354034,
0.1685340851545334,
-1.2179290056228638,
-0.5654790997505188,
0.5664805173873901,
-0.4520533084869385,
0.5356582403182983,
-0.08308713138103485,
-0.4692781865596771,
-0.464658260345459,
-0.1481005996465683,
0.4949680268764496,
0.554665744304657,
-0.6258077621459961,
0.746638834476471,
0.08615714311599731,
0.13875150680541992,
-0.8599148988723755,
-0.9553368091583252,
0.09495701640844345,
-0.23965618014335632,
-0.3580710291862488,
0.15299364924430847,
-0.1210470125079155,
-0.28584593534469604,
-0.09499038755893707,
-0.5788721442222595,
-0.47819310426712036,
0.01920241117477417,
0.3133966326713562,
0.13376906514167786,
-0.23107577860355377,
0.3568836748600006,
-0.13800576329231262,
-0.2226693034172058,
0.13214772939682007,
-0.20188024640083313,
0.08200151473283768,
-0.3130582571029663,
-0.6366894245147705,
-0.4410124719142914,
0.4113595187664032,
0.16408872604370117,
-0.16059130430221558,
0.3423473834991455,
0.9626572728157043,
-0.3686445653438568,
0.08135168254375458,
-0.8896715044975281,
0.21292440593242645,
-0.43437501788139343,
0.18353554606437683,
-0.32634037733078003,
-0.5905303955078125,
0.34789586067199707,
-0.03924914821982384,
0.03024589829146862,
0.7581517100334167,
0.20159980654716492,
-0.2901524007320404,
0.7655802369117737,
0.8032119274139404,
0.19739821553230286,
0.2617564797401428,
-0.14680719375610352,
0.24141822755336761,
-0.8464969992637634,
-0.1300598382949829,
-0.5797876715660095,
-0.27229592204093933,
-0.9099153280258179,
-0.608487069606781,
-0.10854290425777435,
0.33176374435424805,
0.06643951684236526,
-0.14542926847934723,
-0.8526607155799866,
0.6617810726165771,
0.6971939206123352,
0.02232418581843376,
0.09765715152025223,
0.02112681232392788,
0.14059993624687195,
-0.407268226146698,
-0.6934731602668762,
-0.6076843738555908,
1.1498692035675049,
0.34325823187828064,
0.47089630365371704,
-0.05851170793175697,
1.1071254014968872,
0.29778626561164856,
0.7380806803703308,
-0.42989447712898254,
-0.000054798969358671457,
-0.2316521555185318,
-0.6103225946426392,
-0.39586421847343445,
-0.36471423506736755,
-0.9210242629051208,
0.32484185695648193,
-0.140102356672287,
-1.046864628791809,
0.6433787941932678,
0.22268015146255493,
-0.18133309483528137,
0.361192911863327,
-0.8673734664916992,
0.6999872922897339,
-0.35858285427093506,
-0.10148043930530548,
0.6278889179229736,
-0.9671596884727478,
0.2594514489173889,
-0.4269290268421173,
0.510786771774292,
-0.1985873430967331,
0.09424266964197159,
0.9477567076683044,
-0.44347745180130005,
0.9821355938911438,
-0.03938983380794525,
-0.12635929882526398,
0.16241610050201416,
-0.27870914340019226,
0.4386504292488098,
-0.06534075736999512,
-0.04955756664276123,
0.27728956937789917,
-0.07238594442605972,
-0.2962815463542938,
-0.6256516575813293,
-0.008854159153997898,
-0.9365843534469604,
-0.20268818736076355,
-0.4871779978275299,
-0.47983095049858093,
-0.0035560326650738716,
-0.07365439087152481,
0.817240297794342,
0.244136780500412,
-0.1628561019897461,
-0.06506499648094177,
0.7177841067314148,
0.010715675540268421,
0.4068656265735626,
0.21740882098674774,
-0.12443280220031738,
-0.43443843722343445,
1.0166581869125366,
0.19944386184215546,
0.04023004323244095,
0.5079295635223389,
0.21968334913253784,
-0.16898897290229797,
-0.5276474952697754,
-0.21192610263824463,
0.08884035050868988,
-0.836086094379425,
-0.0018856379901990294,
-0.5900149345397949,
-0.19152326881885529,
0.172688290476799,
-0.06845371425151825,
-0.4649496376514435,
-0.2967425584793091,
-0.32576918601989746,
0.03233843296766281,
0.4677227735519409,
0.611039936542511,
-0.37760573625564575,
0.18370181322097778,
-0.6182680726051331,
0.3431321680545807,
0.46367302536964417,
0.2994699478149414,
-0.37948036193847656,
-0.3252113163471222,
-0.1131579577922821,
0.34295403957366943,
0.026237988844513893,
-0.9495114684104919,
0.3246890604496002,
0.17465819418430328,
0.42695242166519165,
0.24121882021427155,
0.020052915439009666,
0.49146613478660583,
-0.5159043073654175,
0.8288194537162781,
0.3979843556880951,
-0.8841404318809509,
0.3327231705188751,
-0.10218945890665054,
0.06082412973046303,
0.5494781732559204,
0.2882848083972931,
-0.8422090411186218,
-0.46851250529289246,
-0.8276304006576538,
-1.369348168373108,
0.39965367317199707,
0.38254278898239136,
-0.3728601932525635,
0.10876303911209106,
0.4577135443687439,
0.35468313097953796,
-0.005462172441184521,
-0.7441288828849792,
-0.6201944947242737,
-0.31178683042526245,
-0.3027811646461487,
-0.23136191070079803,
-0.3715212941169739,
-0.4311385154724121,
-0.16224545240402222,
0.5268003344535828,
-0.0884779766201973,
0.3772057890892029,
0.3973485231399536,
-0.13232842087745667,
-0.21182633936405182,
0.31581345200538635,
0.7141317129135132,
0.9452135562896729,
-0.2676580250263214,
0.23474106192588806,
0.42388397455215454,
-0.6724914908409119,
0.3313521444797516,
0.43057969212532043,
-0.14850829541683197,
0.4945135712623596,
0.46103575825691223,
0.9011895060539246,
-0.10946325957775116,
-0.5806636810302734,
0.5395195484161377,
-0.4508638381958008,
-0.2823459506034851,
-0.3208409547805786,
0.018124926835298538,
-0.20820321142673492,
0.25631892681121826,
0.5983741879463196,
0.31906822323799133,
0.17145653069019318,
0.20687295496463776,
0.37687060236930847,
-0.12748830020427704,
-0.503566324710846,
-0.19224271178245544,
0.6731550097465515,
-0.05396836996078491,
-0.7777928113937378,
0.2543659210205078,
-0.3268737196922302,
-0.3589135706424713,
0.6060386300086975,
0.22232286632061005,
1.061079502105713,
-0.3484848141670227,
0.4253081977367401,
-0.07881421595811844,
0.5022571086883545,
-0.15989843010902405,
0.17391487956047058,
0.11979624629020691,
-0.7534582018852234,
-0.837540864944458,
-0.3485420346260071,
-0.6959149837493896,
0.07208418101072311,
-0.9184157252311707,
-0.06058807298541069,
0.002963443985208869,
-0.18079057335853577,
0.30921024084091187,
-0.1965228170156479,
-0.8716312050819397,
0.376487135887146,
0.10287187993526459,
0.5176063179969788,
-1.0447014570236206,
0.46853888034820557,
0.7957547307014465,
-0.3784540891647339,
-0.8392545580863953,
0.29750120639801025,
-0.022214151918888092,
-0.3843567967414856,
0.9366579651832581,
0.16551703214645386,
-0.14582180976867676,
-0.39536648988723755,
-0.5110359191894531,
-0.8253644704818726,
0.7732959389686584,
-0.11929739266633987,
-0.798846960067749,
0.2505618631839752,
0.2992369532585144,
0.7130206227302551,
-0.09385669976472855,
0.3992760479450226,
0.7717363238334656,
0.6369192004203796,
-0.037460364401340485,
-0.7338609099388123,
-0.07752349972724915,
-0.2243584394454956,
0.24186210334300995,
0.20796462893486023,
-0.36891865730285645,
0.5990435481071472,
0.10590803623199463,
0.02478732541203499,
-0.12729358673095703,
0.5414835810661316,
0.18829332292079926,
0.48339515924453735,
0.5403925180435181,
0.2220015823841095,
1.2063120603561401,
-0.3282194137573242,
1.073287010192871,
0.13395798206329346,
0.4203726351261139,
1.2470078468322754,
-0.09122458100318909,
0.7161316275596619,
0.6486777067184448,
-0.3151676058769226,
0.34121373295783997,
0.7638896703720093,
-0.24616648256778717,
0.33949223160743713,
0.394912987947464,
-0.33034926652908325,
0.08292937278747559,
0.21737459301948547,
-0.3271750509738922,
0.2043120265007019,
0.4103146493434906,
-0.09962829202413559,
-0.07189802080392838,
0.24500422179698944,
-0.14351041615009308,
-0.33930519223213196,
0.24513430893421173,
0.6243899464607239,
-0.10146238654851913,
-0.4024597108364105,
0.9020375609397888,
-0.04306492581963539,
0.6798538565635681,
-0.2268049567937851,
-0.03234359622001648,
-0.18893679976463318,
0.06441701203584671,
-0.24045723676681519,
-0.3952708840370178,
0.21334990859031677,
-0.019063139334321022,
-0.24993854761123657,
-0.006993715651333332,
0.740617573261261,
-0.31029319763183594,
-0.550441324710846,
0.04187975078821182,
0.39181187748908997,
0.18016712367534637,
0.20655019581317902,
-0.5847499370574951,
0.1927604079246521,
0.13177989423274994,
-0.12795546650886536,
-0.13623711466789246,
0.6240147352218628,
-0.03794350102543831,
0.5139901041984558,
0.3486088514328003,
0.012421997264027596,
0.28687894344329834,
0.1828555464744568,
0.4759421944618225,
-0.4286591410636902,
-0.13839749991893768,
-0.7926853895187378,
0.6747242212295532,
-0.38748329877853394,
-0.4962385594844818,
0.5916065573692322,
0.3407905399799347,
0.7105948328971863,
-0.06083090230822563,
1.0210239887237549,
0.09747746586799622,
0.5617836117744446,
-0.3168034851551056,
0.30116933584213257,
-0.3782196640968323,
0.3666676878929138,
-0.35562664270401,
-0.7995960116386414,
-0.7272700071334839,
0.6655619144439697,
-0.17332565784454346,
0.03809613734483719,
0.8005196452140808,
0.5397142767906189,
0.08252391964197159,
0.18228018283843994,
0.15358000993728638,
0.14279057085514069,
0.42212632298469543,
0.22599205374717712,
1.0312674045562744,
-0.6256763935089111,
0.5461788177490234,
-0.1287376880645752,
-0.2922618091106415,
-0.6205568909645081,
-0.9180286526679993,
-0.5736057162284851,
-0.4477737843990326,
-0.7432686686515808,
-0.36352279782295227,
0.38645052909851074,
0.7766951322555542,
0.6244786381721497,
-0.76682049036026,
-0.0321233756840229,
-0.480959951877594,
0.28641587495803833,
-0.6335117816925049,
-0.17486034333705902,
0.5261285901069641,
-0.48713362216949463,
-0.5331223011016846,
0.12260665744543076,
0.11208476126194,
0.24172267317771912,
0.0429362878203392,
-0.051036931574344635,
-0.016596443951129913,
0.033105771988630295,
0.15139178931713104,
0.5922532677650452,
-0.8824541568756104,
-0.43668946623802185,
-0.3897061049938202,
0.09734439849853516,
0.4376983642578125,
0.6210353970527649,
-0.3546152710914612,
0.7892359495162964,
0.290632039308548,
0.7164666056632996,
0.6826795935630798,
-0.1837114542722702,
0.500502347946167,
-1.134802222251892,
-0.10647789388895035,
0.385039359331131,
0.1873323917388916,
0.4685978889465332,
-0.2345093935728073,
0.6480039954185486,
0.3002268075942993,
-0.6177157163619995,
-0.8505026698112488,
0.2820207178592682,
-0.8243990540504456,
-0.1984567940235138,
1.1126741170883179,
-0.048026688396930695,
-0.30808383226394653,
-0.3948502838611603,
-0.2929501235485077,
0.33356553316116333,
-0.07558434456586838,
0.917724609375,
0.9634035229682922,
-0.12115714699029922,
-0.010280274786055088,
-0.929351806640625,
0.6732815504074097,
0.39432328939437866,
-0.7419065833091736,
-0.09635166823863983,
0.2548401951789856,
0.2320711314678192,
0.5420445799827576,
0.5396316051483154,
0.18913638591766357,
0.4418546259403229,
0.14168082177639008,
0.49998244643211365,
0.23184427618980408,
-0.034366946667432785,
-0.4145147502422333,
0.016131926327943802,
0.1464947611093521,
-0.4910029172897339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01929v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01929v1
|
Analyzing and Adapting Large Language Models for Few-Shot Multilingual NLU: Are We There Yet?
| 2024-03-04T10:48:13 | 2024-03-04T10:48:13 |
Evgeniia Razumovskaia, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Supervised fine-tuning (SFT), supervised instruction tuning (SIT) and
in-context learning (ICL) are three alternative, de facto standard approaches
to few-shot learning. ICL has gained popularity recently with the advent of
LLMs due to its simplicity and sample efficiency. Prior research has conducted
only limited investigation into how these approaches work for multilingual
few-shot learning, and the focus so far has been mostly on their performance.
In this work, we present an extensive and systematic comparison of the three
approaches, testing them on 6 high- and low-resource languages, three different
NLU tasks, and a myriad of language and domain setups. Importantly, performance
is only one aspect of the comparison, where we also analyse the approaches
through the optics of their computational, inference and financial costs. Our
observations show that supervised instruction tuning has the best trade-off
between performance and resource requirements. As another contribution, we
analyse the impact of target language adaptation of pretrained LLMs and find
that the standard adaptation approaches can (superficially) improve target
language generation capabilities, but language understanding elicited through
ICL does not improve and remains limited, with low scores especially for
low-resource languages.
|
[
-0.4350390136241913,
-0.9168156981468201,
0.3981150984764099,
0.012102262116968632,
-0.11451994627714157,
0.040802810341119766,
-0.6208366751670837,
-0.42344537377357483,
-0.3105985224246979,
0.4388525187969208,
-0.6716188788414001,
-0.4165266156196594,
-0.353488951921463,
0.3813420236110687,
-0.00628600362688303,
1.0676337480545044,
0.06467301398515701,
0.09331747144460678,
-0.052493397146463394,
-0.22060070931911469,
-0.3735795319080353,
-0.35805389285087585,
-0.8653689622879028,
-0.3458598554134369,
0.5161803364753723,
0.6359861493110657,
0.3894789218902588,
0.3396303057670593,
0.7190080285072327,
0.18135875463485718,
-0.03469593822956085,
0.24093054234981537,
-0.650006890296936,
-0.49065378308296204,
-0.01658903993666172,
-0.5654363036155701,
-0.2781468629837036,
-0.07700279355049133,
0.8194918632507324,
0.7804691791534424,
-0.049088649451732635,
0.30516135692596436,
0.45565521717071533,
0.7095718383789062,
-0.9131746888160706,
-0.05914430692791939,
-0.8882653713226318,
0.06743615865707397,
-0.25592222809791565,
-0.17268003523349762,
-0.8200960159301758,
-0.10005371272563934,
0.044010575860738754,
-0.6747768521308899,
0.012368466705083847,
0.11215086281299591,
0.5195513963699341,
0.6860015392303467,
-0.3651898503303528,
-0.28938645124435425,
-0.5883398056030273,
1.248948574066162,
-0.9420910477638245,
0.2941915988922119,
0.4935780167579651,
0.275029718875885,
-0.18480916321277618,
-0.27872538566589355,
-0.13648918271064758,
-0.3486715853214264,
-0.23310942947864532,
0.23406200110912323,
-0.2690132260322571,
0.1368119716644287,
0.4090060293674469,
-0.06922497600317001,
-0.649246871471405,
0.69838547706604,
-0.25345152616500854,
0.14754565060138702,
0.6400700211524963,
0.031014656648039818,
-0.007046655286103487,
-0.010679632425308228,
-0.4525813162326813,
0.017947474494576454,
-0.9616751074790955,
0.10257291793823242,
0.26074060797691345,
0.7384926080703735,
-0.4702419936656952,
0.3254421353340149,
-0.06367365270853043,
1.0443936586380005,
0.10423952341079712,
-0.45809027552604675,
-0.20589801669120789,
-0.33594825863838196,
-0.3331337869167328,
0.1528312861919403,
0.7994387745857239,
0.08975029736757278,
0.3154865801334381,
-0.1506817787885666,
-0.03236926719546318,
-0.22995661199092865,
0.10612669587135315,
-0.5889080166816711,
-0.0791153833270073,
-0.14136680960655212,
-0.37925025820732117,
0.027201276272535324,
-0.23096047341823578,
-0.5439563393592834,
-0.11907663196325302,
-0.34703609347343445,
0.3016270101070404,
-0.5190303325653076,
-0.06723598390817642,
-0.093781977891922,
0.2420964539051056,
0.5045872330665588,
0.3444838225841522,
-1.0025463104248047,
0.3996331989765167,
0.6204928755760193,
0.8387016654014587,
-0.5982670187950134,
-0.5423656702041626,
-0.6585402488708496,
0.03834393620491028,
-0.6283593773841858,
0.8333644270896912,
-0.348072350025177,
-0.1633715182542801,
0.038408730179071426,
-0.248100146651268,
-0.3372897505760193,
-0.5539994239807129,
0.28868523240089417,
-0.5040130615234375,
0.070505790412426,
-0.2777131497859955,
-0.48055708408355713,
-0.12284190952777863,
0.24754902720451355,
-0.5930627584457397,
1.0475547313690186,
0.21396160125732422,
-0.6130265593528748,
0.5844128131866455,
-0.8211798071861267,
-0.5526612401008606,
0.03378186747431755,
0.05954866483807564,
-0.18129730224609375,
0.2607804536819458,
0.1649925410747528,
0.6066268682479858,
-0.28836166858673096,
-0.05603152886033058,
-0.19399669766426086,
-0.7688603401184082,
0.09994520992040634,
-0.6515435576438904,
0.7606425285339355,
0.21217447519302368,
-0.17930619418621063,
-0.008783015422523022,
-0.9160320162773132,
0.09994569420814514,
-0.07358193397521973,
-0.631300151348114,
-0.15018555521965027,
0.040093112736940384,
0.12399487942457199,
0.1664333939552307,
-0.05207150802016258,
-0.2349310964345932,
0.2374950349330902,
-0.5490646362304688,
0.3920259177684784,
0.6663121581077576,
-0.2759262025356293,
0.6480971574783325,
-0.054810717701911926,
0.6557971239089966,
-0.06431692093610764,
0.01976047456264496,
-0.23717132210731506,
-0.06721961498260498,
-0.8413076400756836,
-0.2522248327732086,
0.2627650499343872,
0.5141500234603882,
-0.9233118891716003,
-0.0892706885933876,
-0.09807465970516205,
-0.16750261187553406,
-0.7099102735519409,
0.5361241698265076,
0.5158910155296326,
0.34198930859565735,
0.5003224015235901,
-0.09986863285303116,
-0.3707320988178253,
-0.7747539281845093,
-0.3687926232814789,
-0.18938343226909637,
0.11329177021980286,
0.3871358036994934,
0.40494397282600403,
0.08372626453638077,
0.7521939873695374,
-0.21916164457798004,
-0.36964645981788635,
-0.4875662326812744,
-0.015421506948769093,
0.2239290326833725,
0.32824862003326416,
1.0001276731491089,
-0.30170738697052,
-0.7388943433761597,
0.3715131878852844,
-0.7317448854446411,
0.20160958170890808,
-0.0868452787399292,
0.19943366944789886,
0.5882664918899536,
0.6735000014305115,
-0.13168209791183472,
0.09026343375444412,
0.8235077857971191,
0.2930261194705963,
0.32973194122314453,
-0.13460244238376617,
-0.02703213319182396,
-0.9345170855522156,
-0.21178773045539856,
0.07839464396238327,
-0.21070298552513123,
-0.609821081161499,
0.2971343994140625,
0.011038973927497864,
-0.0037509731482714415,
-0.8617269992828369,
0.604834794998169,
-0.440007746219635,
-0.2068503051996231,
-0.4975666403770447,
0.14700913429260254,
-0.25846490263938904,
0.5839667916297913,
0.019900530576705933,
0.9082987308502197,
0.5510060787200928,
-0.600986123085022,
0.05434875935316086,
-0.11790142208337784,
-0.386929988861084,
0.4807455539703369,
-0.4418336749076843,
0.3239639103412628,
-0.11453016847372055,
0.1919594556093216,
-0.8326902985572815,
-0.30263733863830566,
0.01335978228598833,
0.005441577639430761,
0.5798923969268799,
-0.42232435941696167,
-0.5079550743103027,
-0.1095249205827713,
-0.1781034916639328,
0.35673242807388306,
0.2291661649942398,
-0.6422632932662964,
0.2915152907371521,
-0.055038418620824814,
0.03623887151479721,
-0.6593276858329773,
-0.945725679397583,
0.033522829413414,
-0.3905141353607178,
-0.2552128732204437,
0.17737318575382233,
-0.1738235205411911,
-0.3957531154155731,
-0.18905693292617798,
0.06173742562532425,
-0.19666515290737152,
0.5296010375022888,
-0.169660285115242,
0.11774373054504395,
-0.7276560664176941,
0.03475632146000862,
-0.010990525595843792,
-0.22244733572006226,
-0.3710816204547882,
-0.20726917684078217,
0.20250464975833893,
-0.34907686710357666,
-0.3788367211818695,
-0.3644806146621704,
0.33737385272979736,
0.2593642771244049,
-0.14443203806877136,
0.8002235889434814,
0.778595507144928,
-0.21265432238578796,
-0.3361565172672272,
-0.5218477845191956,
-0.18110017478466034,
-0.41667625308036804,
0.32462769746780396,
-0.49955636262893677,
-0.9915653467178345,
0.22967389225959778,
-0.2168268859386444,
0.31403863430023193,
0.3243657052516937,
0.6775217652320862,
-0.21779508888721466,
0.8239195346832275,
0.9970474243164062,
-0.12515299022197723,
0.5176891088485718,
-0.268093079328537,
0.28350773453712463,
-0.6840878129005432,
0.2822248339653015,
-0.45433923602104187,
-0.4184902608394623,
-0.8881856203079224,
-0.1318608671426773,
0.4304006099700928,
0.3598788380622864,
0.06081213057041168,
0.4478333294391632,
-0.11938536912202835,
0.7932403087615967,
0.5508004426956177,
-0.14206497371196747,
0.34819310903549194,
-0.13095299899578094,
0.09184441715478897,
-0.04554383084177971,
-1.1710526943206787,
-0.47540053725242615,
1.031540870666504,
-0.01833745650947094,
0.7737318277359009,
0.2071458250284195,
0.7877776026725769,
-0.2114112228155136,
0.33837980031967163,
-1.0495612621307373,
0.20105791091918945,
-0.4865412414073944,
-0.5843757390975952,
-0.38061758875846863,
-0.1966000646352768,
-0.8944914937019348,
0.4422309398651123,
-0.3401154577732086,
-0.7336610555648804,
-0.1629486232995987,
0.21584102511405945,
-0.5899480581283569,
0.24134178459644318,
-0.9464535713195801,
0.8945909738540649,
-0.40525662899017334,
-0.5024436712265015,
-0.18529734015464783,
-0.60027015209198,
0.45424848794937134,
-0.43033239245414734,
0.31043893098831177,
-0.18859468400478363,
0.06934858858585358,
0.5308300852775574,
0.11406902223825455,
0.954775869846344,
0.039636172354221344,
-0.04544927179813385,
0.11945173889398575,
-0.10931143164634705,
0.29149600863456726,
-0.0011439750669524074,
-0.32350870966911316,
0.20935481786727905,
0.1524651050567627,
-0.6229658722877502,
-0.4463692903518677,
0.8263373374938965,
-0.7662549018859863,
-0.43005135655403137,
-0.22917062044143677,
-0.6814389824867249,
-0.33430108428001404,
0.19631054997444153,
0.4065690040588379,
0.1927693486213684,
-0.3268848657608032,
0.2741777002811432,
0.44987955689430237,
-0.3625211715698242,
0.7850406169891357,
0.6967192888259888,
0.1207401379942894,
0.02015039324760437,
0.7143411636352539,
0.13732469081878662,
0.34283533692359924,
0.5188133120536804,
0.24154242873191833,
0.09600099921226501,
-0.7673665881156921,
-0.5224001407623291,
0.1309511512517929,
-0.5649991631507874,
-0.24962545931339264,
-0.24353331327438354,
0.006263199727982283,
-0.3438980281352997,
-0.49148571491241455,
-0.5922190546989441,
-0.05514870211482048,
-0.5359935164451599,
0.03157959505915642,
0.30662602186203003,
0.5994804501533508,
0.05329836159944534,
0.6956512331962585,
-0.6070199608802795,
0.23758329451084137,
0.044005800038576126,
0.26516443490982056,
-0.14612434804439545,
-0.5965694189071655,
-0.5361088514328003,
-0.09529338032007217,
-0.28905507922172546,
-0.32933512330055237,
0.0993339866399765,
0.6568894386291504,
0.5650811195373535,
0.3835151791572571,
0.013995438814163208,
1.0115652084350586,
-0.7972802519798279,
0.8167610168457031,
0.046871889382600784,
-0.713583767414093,
0.5801595449447632,
-0.034624386578798294,
0.45840954780578613,
0.831276535987854,
0.5112890005111694,
-0.24964891374111176,
-0.13726556301116943,
-0.33042633533477783,
-0.5061920285224915,
1.0423022508621216,
-0.20957982540130615,
0.22099225223064423,
0.048437755554914474,
0.3497692048549652,
0.3207134008407593,
-0.15239004790782928,
-0.7083675265312195,
-0.2433159202337265,
0.23011520504951477,
-0.115920789539814,
-0.37475571036338806,
-0.03856370598077774,
-0.04317113012075424,
-0.011813370510935783,
0.48870810866355896,
-0.7054943442344666,
-0.17925839126110077,
-0.3480314612388611,
-0.46991148591041565,
-0.20135635137557983,
0.4859916567802429,
0.591557502746582,
0.7597025036811829,
-0.12470439821481705,
-0.07706265896558762,
0.575911283493042,
-0.07687587291002274,
-0.009775614365935326,
-0.17812396585941315,
-0.19643619656562805,
-0.153212770819664,
0.853107213973999,
1.039009690284729,
0.7660072445869446,
-0.5808721780776978,
0.3563443422317505,
0.1343538612127304,
-0.2703763246536255,
-0.014255210757255554,
0.16043411195278168,
-0.0992128774523735,
0.23218020796775818,
0.20048633217811584,
0.0431838259100914,
-0.03890078887343407,
-0.5400906801223755,
-0.025797072798013687,
0.5359724164009094,
-0.4883749485015869,
-0.32678699493408203,
0.4245802164077759,
-0.036954741925001144,
-0.1470281183719635,
0.5619755983352661,
-0.13987873494625092,
-0.03457043692469597,
0.328252911567688,
0.744057834148407,
0.7020861506462097,
0.017531080171465874,
0.08966352790594101,
0.3602302670478821,
0.4684576094150543,
-0.08043630421161652,
-0.0880330428481102,
-0.13855934143066406,
-0.711428165435791,
-0.8856032490730286,
-0.663006603717804,
-0.3796859681606293,
0.16419005393981934,
-0.7756725549697876,
0.3901936411857605,
-0.4279095232486725,
0.011571350507438183,
0.12680384516716003,
0.18350344896316528,
-0.872835099697113,
-0.21883733570575714,
0.16035926342010498,
0.8260706663131714,
-0.9656936526298523,
0.9646572470664978,
0.8995103240013123,
-0.13446177542209625,
-0.5516260862350464,
0.03684770688414574,
0.3187066614627838,
-0.7156208753585815,
0.6047162413597107,
-0.09670349210500717,
-0.21014724671840668,
0.2520036995410919,
-0.513576865196228,
-0.8782040476799011,
0.7755312323570251,
0.7389079332351685,
-0.6210049390792847,
-0.025233859196305275,
0.022376427426934242,
0.512402355670929,
-0.11832667142152786,
0.22438383102416992,
0.9126465320587158,
0.35087549686431885,
-0.03987037017941475,
-1.0221984386444092,
-0.4658104479312897,
0.3129642605781555,
0.04296678677201271,
0.056135524064302444,
-0.6750199198722839,
0.5056223273277283,
-0.33628761768341064,
-0.14279009401798248,
0.10186415910720825,
0.5330036878585815,
0.30050036311149597,
0.293031245470047,
0.2327936291694641,
0.31389757990837097,
0.5420359969139099,
-0.09917180985212326,
1.1909632682800293,
-0.26970577239990234,
0.42481040954589844,
1.143548846244812,
-0.38236019015312195,
1.0999573469161987,
0.6156792640686035,
-0.41866713762283325,
0.1067340299487114,
0.716689944267273,
0.1419769823551178,
0.5649241805076599,
0.052960675209760666,
-0.02441287226974964,
-0.3235626816749573,
-0.28112855553627014,
-0.0722353383898735,
0.7290803790092468,
0.37474164366722107,
0.05416014418005943,
-0.3234621584415436,
0.28195202350616455,
-0.1119145080447197,
0.07887227833271027,
-0.3151921331882477,
1.0995910167694092,
0.3348407745361328,
-0.6129294037818909,
0.7907900810241699,
0.03882612660527229,
0.9578903317451477,
-0.5421671867370605,
0.04397285729646683,
-0.2487451434135437,
0.16234377026557922,
-0.2357781082391739,
-0.47530147433280945,
0.14074307680130005,
0.3354478180408478,
-0.07445045560598373,
-0.27171799540519714,
0.6209842562675476,
-0.3631993532180786,
-0.5651137828826904,
0.352141410112381,
0.5918699502944946,
0.25812411308288574,
0.22483006119728088,
-0.8395699858665466,
0.07271789014339447,
-0.21992003917694092,
-0.05584997311234474,
0.6124602556228638,
0.2967706024646759,
-0.036321885883808136,
0.4630347192287445,
0.5525950789451599,
0.1053810566663742,
0.22769767045974731,
0.19123820960521698,
0.4074461758136749,
-0.3937878906726837,
-0.057483214884996414,
-0.923717737197876,
0.25914204120635986,
0.4312779903411865,
-0.49945980310440063,
0.7453439235687256,
0.414431631565094,
1.3771499395370483,
-0.09126879274845123,
0.6356931924819946,
0.39338812232017517,
0.15876954793930054,
-0.9559410810470581,
0.3734251856803894,
-0.7670513987541199,
0.05902199447154999,
-0.3947186768054962,
-0.9128851890563965,
-0.6310510039329529,
0.6596009731292725,
-0.20522651076316833,
-0.0858297124505043,
0.75149005651474,
0.6180298924446106,
-0.24255944788455963,
-0.2579587697982788,
0.5835515856742859,
0.007582074962556362,
0.07687017321586609,
0.694645345211029,
0.8774574995040894,
-0.49008709192276,
0.3335742652416229,
-0.38715291023254395,
-0.09404071420431137,
-0.4710651636123657,
-0.9730361104011536,
-0.8832032680511475,
-0.24961638450622559,
-0.3873423933982849,
0.2546933889389038,
0.0829278975725174,
1.0257412195205688,
0.787295401096344,
-0.9397659301757812,
-0.3642745614051819,
0.22906693816184998,
0.16884075105190277,
-0.4695007801055908,
-0.15672294795513153,
0.41328978538513184,
-0.6225384473800659,
-0.9034901261329651,
0.8493552207946777,
0.46211516857147217,
-0.1548391878604889,
-0.12121041864156723,
-0.12197154015302658,
-0.1550251543521881,
-0.24602144956588745,
0.9739965200424194,
0.29256579279899597,
-1.0618305206298828,
-0.15447935461997986,
0.11674284189939499,
-0.10058681666851044,
0.15398859977722168,
0.7766065001487732,
-0.5707849860191345,
0.2591143846511841,
0.3062014579772949,
0.8332062363624573,
0.52015221118927,
-0.1939890831708908,
0.2512208819389343,
-1.0161473751068115,
0.3987351953983307,
0.12394033372402191,
0.25030213594436646,
0.1997319459915161,
-0.07653440535068512,
0.5658022165298462,
-0.2330130785703659,
-0.3635050356388092,
-0.858049750328064,
0.2111249566078186,
-0.9118552207946777,
-0.3779984712600708,
1.1901404857635498,
-0.1736939549446106,
-0.08894460648298264,
0.10700105130672455,
0.009528569877147675,
0.04663163423538208,
-0.06628361344337463,
0.4727042317390442,
0.736661970615387,
-0.2898632287979126,
-0.2931407392024994,
-0.8851361274719238,
0.4775872528553009,
0.3758580684661865,
-0.7721436619758606,
-0.055299241095781326,
0.29606056213378906,
0.07532665133476257,
-0.0427391417324543,
0.495699942111969,
0.17693907022476196,
0.35862234234809875,
-0.2982851564884186,
-0.27218419313430786,
0.25071075558662415,
-0.41638362407684326,
-0.6577655076980591,
-0.07309718430042267,
0.49709492921829224,
0.05047396570444107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01926v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01926v1
|
IndicVoices: Towards building an Inclusive Multilingual Speech Dataset for Indian Languages
| 2024-03-04T10:42:08 | 2024-03-04T10:42:08 |
Tahir Javed, Janki Atul Nawale, Eldho Ittan George, Sakshi Joshi, Kaushal Santosh Bhogale, Deovrat Mehendale, Ishvinder Virender Sethi, Aparna Ananthanarayanan, Hafsah Faquih, Pratiti Palit, Sneha Ravishankar, Saranya Sukumaran, Tripura Panchagnula, Sunjay Murali, Kunal Sharad Gandhi, Ambujavalli R, Manickam K M, C Venkata Vaijayanthi, Krishnan Srinivasa Raghavan Karunganni, Pratyush Kumar, Mitesh M Khapra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present INDICVOICES, a dataset of natural and spontaneous speech
containing a total of 7348 hours of read (9%), extempore (74%) and
conversational (17%) audio from 16237 speakers covering 145 Indian districts
and 22 languages. Of these 7348 hours, 1639 hours have already been
transcribed, with a median of 73 hours per language. Through this paper, we
share our journey of capturing the cultural, linguistic and demographic
diversity of India to create a one-of-its-kind inclusive and representative
dataset. More specifically, we share an open-source blueprint for data
collection at scale comprising of standardised protocols, centralised tools, a
repository of engaging questions, prompts and conversation scenarios spanning
multiple domains and topics of interest, quality control mechanisms,
comprehensive transcription guidelines and transcription tools. We hope that
this open source blueprint will serve as a comprehensive starter kit for data
collection efforts in other multilingual regions of the world. Using
INDICVOICES, we build IndicASR, the first ASR model to support all the 22
languages listed in the 8th schedule of the Constitution of India. All the
data, tools, guidelines, models and other materials developed as a part of this
work will be made publicly available
|
[
-0.18717336654663086,
0.02789595164358616,
-0.2730260491371155,
0.5949243903160095,
-0.4243465065956116,
0.12265035510063171,
-0.5285038948059082,
-0.606951892375946,
0.14538399875164032,
0.5208116173744202,
-0.16622233390808105,
-0.37678030133247375,
-0.2938043773174286,
0.25513705611228943,
-0.4024893343448639,
0.6821895837783813,
0.48713168501853943,
0.20013123750686646,
-0.11793972551822662,
-0.5132759213447571,
-0.4492107331752777,
-0.16652792692184448,
-0.19349373877048492,
-0.013552713207900524,
-0.005357490852475166,
0.5184144377708435,
0.25080716609954834,
0.6927229762077332,
-0.061756979674100876,
0.23103563487529755,
-0.19321571290493011,
0.33793404698371887,
0.1840483695268631,
0.4658615291118622,
-0.2576045095920563,
-0.3942529261112213,
-0.08923502266407013,
-0.010448009707033634,
0.746860921382904,
0.6027310490608215,
-0.5467255115509033,
0.40986910462379456,
0.40007367730140686,
0.39123132824897766,
-0.5702744722366333,
0.37455135583877563,
-0.35084742307662964,
-0.10671434551477432,
-0.8875892758369446,
-0.25584709644317627,
-0.30705171823501587,
-0.49384430050849915,
-0.38890334963798523,
-0.3909699320793152,
-0.037411753088235855,
-0.45474275946617126,
0.041719917207956314,
-0.04992986470460892,
-0.3333708345890045,
-0.6817083954811096,
-0.8985506892204285,
0.44445037841796875,
-0.5487616062164307,
0.42205706238746643,
0.41324183344841003,
0.4391985237598419,
0.2322547435760498,
-0.7723681926727295,
-0.504055380821228,
-0.09173975139856339,
0.09227388352155685,
0.18287234008312225,
-0.09278430789709091,
-0.24172581732273102,
0.0376390665769577,
0.6304546594619751,
-0.4894617795944214,
0.13877984881401062,
-0.8980000615119934,
-0.09672405570745468,
0.6250720024108887,
0.19983603060245514,
0.4782465696334839,
-0.2987077236175537,
0.010113389231264591,
0.2388514280319214,
-0.5975390672683716,
0.37630295753479004,
0.7574734687805176,
0.8569667339324951,
-0.6176673173904419,
0.8842083215713501,
-0.22196488082408905,
0.9507977366447449,
-0.20019853115081787,
-0.21129488945007324,
0.3147692084312439,
-0.5953404307365417,
-0.011405788362026215,
0.3128049969673157,
0.6833102107048035,
-0.20448245108127594,
0.20823480188846588,
-0.04078715667128563,
-0.07340601831674576,
0.17444393038749695,
-0.1709398478269577,
-0.33406880497932434,
0.05896463245153427,
0.26040199398994446,
-0.26595476269721985,
0.31171271204948425,
-0.3953571319580078,
-0.9513611197471619,
-0.7565726041793823,
-0.6524328589439392,
-0.2406224012374878,
-0.5236321687698364,
-0.5267337560653687,
-0.1868337094783783,
0.010493969544768333,
0.3327758014202118,
0.17932657897472382,
-0.9706155061721802,
0.334547758102417,
0.6307216286659241,
0.8309004902839661,
0.020114149898290634,
-0.24543358385562897,
-0.49315834045410156,
0.13063561916351318,
-0.31890982389450073,
0.9569748044013977,
-0.8770051598548889,
-0.6035823225975037,
0.283169686794281,
-0.34132683277130127,
0.06165289133787155,
-0.4447859525680542,
0.636884331703186,
-0.02051510661840439,
0.17537204921245575,
0.017263542860746384,
-0.3541865646839142,
0.17001383006572723,
0.2849082946777344,
-0.5415988564491272,
0.5674574971199036,
-0.16819840669631958,
-0.5872122049331665,
0.5285069346427917,
-0.8882520198822021,
-0.518593966960907,
0.7483062148094177,
-0.8246895670890808,
0.17846640944480896,
-0.09945546835660934,
0.3296665549278259,
0.03923019394278526,
-0.5538932681083679,
0.033799223601818085,
0.05020099878311157,
-0.02209371142089367,
-0.08405620604753494,
-0.5169596076011658,
1.4732756614685059,
0.6696400046348572,
-0.2233993262052536,
0.09717357903718948,
-0.9121728539466858,
-0.09181156009435654,
-0.3641121983528137,
-0.27521592378616333,
-0.3481181561946869,
-0.1304606944322586,
0.4191988408565521,
0.3539574146270752,
0.10786581039428711,
-0.9951639771461487,
0.2723000645637512,
-0.496094673871994,
0.37010517716407776,
0.6696164608001709,
-0.10562346130609512,
0.34163129329681396,
-0.11372172087430954,
0.8532280921936035,
0.06130741164088249,
0.29239383339881897,
-0.3760662078857422,
-0.5028972029685974,
-0.28659820556640625,
-0.4482673108577728,
0.36307206749916077,
0.4585963189601898,
-0.4751867353916168,
-0.10039317607879639,
-0.37352585792541504,
-0.6167528629302979,
-0.985809326171875,
0.09561148285865784,
0.22259609401226044,
0.28593695163726807,
-0.009166000410914421,
-0.08293785899877548,
-0.5935897827148438,
-0.8829677700996399,
-0.23274928331375122,
-0.1180490031838417,
0.05598871037364006,
-0.010495094582438469,
0.1467566341161728,
-0.03300389647483826,
0.9789461493492126,
0.22410869598388672,
-0.515509843826294,
-0.2676405608654022,
-0.05005492642521858,
0.22866228222846985,
0.5370355844497681,
0.14325933158397675,
-0.859092116355896,
-0.6665989756584167,
0.1555982530117035,
-0.6652853488922119,
0.13484503328800201,
0.11728397756814957,
0.2923242151737213,
0.4980641007423401,
0.35317692160606384,
-0.4341924786567688,
0.4336223602294922,
0.613873302936554,
-0.36837247014045715,
0.24250999093055725,
-0.20202197134494781,
0.24262072145938873,
-1.2921677827835083,
0.08914395421743393,
-0.21291130781173706,
0.08084861934185028,
-0.39711910486221313,
-0.1122995987534523,
-0.004149462562054396,
-0.5253200531005859,
-0.49305933713912964,
0.6614394783973694,
-0.6630333662033081,
-0.013733360916376114,
0.10833901911973953,
0.1243281364440918,
-0.40038588643074036,
0.20312480628490448,
-0.3203340768814087,
1.0833954811096191,
0.5540996789932251,
-0.3316478133201599,
0.1604701578617096,
0.5540325045585632,
-0.6277500987052917,
0.6576958298683167,
-0.4597684144973755,
-0.005636685062199831,
-0.07432028651237488,
-0.15277254581451416,
-0.9136900305747986,
-0.1421678364276886,
0.3199346959590912,
-0.7310789823532104,
0.36467641592025757,
-0.2872573137283325,
-0.6105263829231262,
0.1388365626335144,
-0.11300172656774521,
0.35378628969192505,
0.2631432116031647,
-0.48130157589912415,
0.7287566661834717,
1.077892541885376,
-0.6117572784423828,
-0.6833312511444092,
-0.9371107220649719,
0.1674903929233551,
-0.08550473302602768,
-0.5213562846183777,
-0.10754411667585373,
-0.03266267850995064,
-0.4535890221595764,
-0.001282736542634666,
0.11725358664989471,
-0.08274304866790771,
-0.40683478116989136,
0.5639391541481018,
-0.1312258541584015,
0.06086243689060211,
0.14902955293655396,
-0.08211567997932434,
-0.02200617827475071,
-0.17663270235061646,
-0.2013222575187683,
0.48944327235221863,
-0.07171072065830231,
-0.5856661200523376,
-0.31414997577667236,
0.8664642572402954,
0.6528530120849609,
-0.6440991759300232,
0.20149007439613342,
0.3407663404941559,
-0.6284675598144531,
-0.17319069802761078,
-0.49498605728149414,
0.3304176330566406,
-0.3815056085586548,
-0.07260361313819885,
-0.3764686584472656,
-0.6358867883682251,
0.7911941409111023,
0.45597004890441895,
0.39661934971809387,
0.5527291297912598,
0.6774129271507263,
0.4018450081348419,
0.7447731494903564,
0.6665940880775452,
-0.11551974713802338,
0.4318103790283203,
0.0498332604765892,
0.03349541127681732,
-0.6644242405891418,
-0.5655062198638916,
-0.8695858716964722,
0.2882224917411804,
-0.9518463611602783,
-0.2809767425060272,
0.376090943813324,
-0.3967660963535309,
-0.011560032144188881,
-0.06337785720825195,
-0.818558394908905,
0.29563388228416443,
0.593734085559845,
-0.2834600508213043,
0.37064093351364136,
0.15316151082515717,
-0.03223896771669388,
-0.271901398897171,
-0.5192698240280151,
-0.5516414046287537,
0.9857949614524841,
-0.08564428985118866,
0.7450841665267944,
0.28225669264793396,
0.3413841128349304,
0.46607065200805664,
0.36210089921951294,
-0.31638050079345703,
0.1859613060951233,
-0.22090895473957062,
-0.9619789123535156,
-0.5312654376029968,
-0.02820563316345215,
-0.9757072329521179,
0.3327920436859131,
0.21759778261184692,
-0.6489347815513611,
0.6668874621391296,
0.13823646306991577,
-0.36205920577049255,
0.20846159756183624,
-0.652988076210022,
0.5731230974197388,
-0.012950382195413113,
-0.24607284367084503,
-0.19380606710910797,
-0.6640781164169312,
0.4091319143772125,
0.29397115111351013,
0.4329308271408081,
-0.1141078844666481,
0.06281324476003647,
0.7936784625053406,
-0.2304738610982895,
0.6996262073516846,
-0.33188310265541077,
0.14339861273765564,
0.4778444468975067,
-0.2678585648536682,
0.11772754043340683,
0.08507024496793747,
-0.2925450801849365,
0.25451934337615967,
0.023598574101924896,
-0.42284584045410156,
-0.11585254967212677,
0.5068647265434265,
-0.7112337350845337,
0.09823023527860641,
-0.733426570892334,
-0.4946932792663574,
-0.19235478341579437,
0.03739344701170921,
0.3461056053638458,
1.0352624654769897,
0.06250569224357605,
0.37469619512557983,
0.3163059949874878,
-0.20025739073753357,
0.62319016456604,
0.6267732381820679,
0.059193193912506104,
-0.618585467338562,
0.8672555685043335,
0.6774376034736633,
-0.10527848452329636,
0.2336702197790146,
-0.16337276995182037,
-0.6653233170509338,
-0.5762315988540649,
-0.6231383085250854,
0.22507624328136444,
-0.9280898571014404,
-0.20849066972732544,
-0.7615253329277039,
-0.050813257694244385,
-0.971418559551239,
0.11125379800796509,
-0.35997530817985535,
-0.5093485713005066,
-0.07237504422664642,
0.06871652603149414,
0.4978691041469574,
0.891417920589447,
-0.595074474811554,
-0.23159685730934143,
-0.5770010352134705,
0.1296396702528,
0.27893322706222534,
0.6055637001991272,
-0.3067309558391571,
-0.5605287551879883,
-0.23542968928813934,
0.11674584448337555,
0.056828442960977554,
-0.564069926738739,
0.5810967683792114,
0.2275487631559372,
0.7946453094482422,
0.07639811187982559,
0.16874772310256958,
0.7368966341018677,
-0.3845538794994354,
1.0247341394424438,
-0.052969399839639664,
-0.8394361734390259,
0.5709824562072754,
-0.3420957624912262,
0.4137764573097229,
0.6452471017837524,
0.25314825773239136,
-0.8472729325294495,
-0.5078479051589966,
-0.4011254906654358,
-1.0791807174682617,
0.6452274322509766,
0.07647493481636047,
0.0749635398387909,
0.05330582335591316,
0.0021967822685837746,
0.37023529410362244,
0.14364659786224365,
-0.37582656741142273,
-0.35429954528808594,
-0.20733705163002014,
-0.19231894612312317,
-0.2927216589450836,
-0.20762334764003754,
-0.35204389691352844,
-0.21227483451366425,
0.4693750739097595,
0.05636105313897133,
0.1906103640794754,
0.20640598237514496,
-0.22112669050693512,
0.08774716407060623,
0.7377217411994934,
0.8601288795471191,
1.0128419399261475,
-0.04765525087714195,
-0.1336841881275177,
-0.17566628754138947,
-0.726200520992279,
0.04698937386274338,
0.6707325577735901,
0.17577752470970154,
0.12792596220970154,
0.24082395434379578,
0.6085290908813477,
-0.3076353967189789,
-0.7424002289772034,
0.2645227015018463,
-0.4020686745643616,
0.2786317467689514,
-0.9913645386695862,
-0.2945684492588043,
0.0705755352973938,
0.2987801432609558,
0.4759228527545929,
-0.03686374053359032,
0.3120667040348053,
-0.3915926516056061,
0.09527935832738876,
0.13041085004806519,
-0.5612879991531372,
-0.21848322451114655,
0.8540617823600769,
0.3626602590084076,
-0.5941722393035889,
0.5799131989479065,
-0.12966042757034302,
0.20661938190460205,
0.3385073244571686,
0.35733434557914734,
0.8066359162330627,
-0.5388113260269165,
0.0622432678937912,
0.2590811550617218,
0.5810244679450989,
0.33953526616096497,
0.5736977458000183,
-0.37022027373313904,
-0.21133725345134735,
-0.40765541791915894,
-0.5290918946266174,
-0.6558272242546082,
-0.006856298539787531,
-0.7803566455841064,
0.22185970842838287,
-0.08215899020433426,
0.3051309287548065,
0.17608356475830078,
0.07524576783180237,
-0.6637089848518372,
0.0166140329092741,
0.27711331844329834,
1.1483256816864014,
-0.9937007427215576,
0.8360433578491211,
0.6521919369697571,
-0.7353534698486328,
-0.7586517333984375,
-0.49555882811546326,
0.04656155779957771,
-0.3943827450275421,
0.25779610872268677,
-0.029801813885569572,
-0.08326175808906555,
-0.05373984947800636,
-0.4188198447227478,
-0.5748317837715149,
0.861416757106781,
0.5246383547782898,
-0.5448503494262695,
0.44596752524375916,
0.2695164680480957,
0.5146472454071045,
-0.38128912448883057,
0.18926867842674255,
0.4137558341026306,
0.2881329357624054,
-0.09980309754610062,
-0.8533770442008972,
-0.34677207469940186,
-0.891356348991394,
-0.25060462951660156,
0.17156744003295898,
-0.3829837739467621,
1.075134515762329,
0.1308729350566864,
-0.403473824262619,
-0.11001098155975342,
0.6370996236801147,
0.1518927961587906,
0.22207719087600708,
0.42854994535446167,
0.18780417740345,
0.7128185629844666,
0.13074138760566711,
1.317278504371643,
-0.5280817747116089,
-0.18170218169689178,
1.3497400283813477,
-0.3004821836948395,
0.49861857295036316,
0.3559553325176239,
-0.13472354412078857,
-0.021080151200294495,
0.569733202457428,
0.43039897084236145,
0.31861722469329834,
-0.16412946581840515,
-0.6192210912704468,
0.08639572560787201,
-0.5630286931991577,
-0.8029999136924744,
0.6668604016304016,
0.6541098356246948,
0.14795318245887756,
-0.21563255786895752,
0.2894604504108429,
-0.258281409740448,
0.2381996363401413,
-0.28112778067588806,
0.6908531188964844,
-0.17578329145908356,
-0.654333233833313,
0.21974650025367737,
-0.3312610983848572,
0.5564855933189392,
-0.7738479971885681,
-0.15617460012435913,
-0.4745037257671356,
0.20100471377372742,
-0.08161953836679459,
-0.8811926245689392,
0.45244649052619934,
0.18808044493198395,
-0.22803300619125366,
-0.19092611968517303,
0.40414556860923767,
-0.8893157839775085,
-0.4408470094203949,
0.05758242309093475,
0.28189584612846375,
0.2711137533187866,
0.16705922782421112,
-0.25452920794487,
0.15605692565441132,
0.017247844487428665,
0.2034812569618225,
0.20448873937129974,
0.5557151436805725,
-0.15670140087604523,
0.4786826968193054,
0.3977884352207184,
0.39259079098701477,
0.3605969548225403,
-0.03789913281798363,
0.6409642100334167,
-0.4929053783416748,
-0.7991634607315063,
-0.5726019144058228,
1.0530439615249634,
-0.12828660011291504,
-0.8174929022789001,
0.8185206651687622,
0.9218147397041321,
0.9414122700691223,
0.04485940560698509,
1.0319371223449707,
-0.18653395771980286,
0.8441467881202698,
-0.07810164988040924,
0.7591913342475891,
-0.4310777485370636,
-0.004560576751828194,
-0.0026824234519153833,
-0.4448668658733368,
-0.30955037474632263,
0.19959507882595062,
0.028354862704873085,
-0.40221989154815674,
0.09502018243074417,
0.7667921781539917,
-0.06301490217447281,
0.2588253915309906,
0.1729959100484848,
-0.08675959706306458,
0.5474665760993958,
-0.13824234902858734,
0.6755895018577576,
-0.11154356598854065,
0.7432367205619812,
-0.3190331757068634,
-0.23892322182655334,
0.10567881911993027,
-0.5261231660842896,
-0.18280090391635895,
-0.999734103679657,
-0.08036201447248459,
-0.24787214398384094,
0.04176253825426102,
1.3656284809112549,
0.5478321313858032,
-0.9810673594474792,
-0.7707640528678894,
0.2710005044937134,
-0.07839595526456833,
0.06250406801700592,
-0.13950864970684052,
0.22090376913547516,
-0.19130368530750275,
-0.8703508973121643,
0.44112586975097656,
0.5414348840713501,
-0.10421932488679886,
-0.35949966311454773,
0.09807812422513962,
-0.6063775420188904,
-0.10808361321687698,
0.5603703856468201,
0.8509253859519958,
-0.39975112676620483,
0.1861892193555832,
-0.32899975776672363,
-0.14084434509277344,
0.18381726741790771,
1.048920750617981,
-0.4519035220146179,
1.0898473262786865,
0.4363288879394531,
0.4723415672779083,
0.4460086226463318,
-0.2668021023273468,
0.39992251992225647,
-0.7654331922531128,
0.7387812733650208,
0.6216645836830139,
0.264545738697052,
0.7289911508560181,
-0.07044358551502228,
0.6113831400871277,
-0.04515644907951355,
-0.5483664870262146,
-1.049201250076294,
0.02791631780564785,
-0.8531791567802429,
0.09640005230903625,
0.9128783345222473,
-0.01872078888118267,
0.021115396171808243,
-0.4759715795516968,
-0.08154211938381195,
0.534332811832428,
-0.5236793160438538,
0.5622374415397644,
0.33610600233078003,
-0.1980387270450592,
-0.10757407546043396,
-0.5976018905639648,
0.39419639110565186,
-0.26501569151878357,
-0.8505065441131592,
0.17428475618362427,
0.5534948110580444,
0.184271901845932,
0.32689788937568665,
1.1416895389556885,
-0.5242102742195129,
0.23228572309017181,
0.34570789337158203,
0.5412108898162842,
-0.07659630477428436,
-0.3736054301261902,
-0.8158708214759827,
0.4091893136501312,
0.07925155758857727,
-0.6314732432365417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01924v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01924v2
|
To Generate or to Retrieve? On the Effectiveness of Artificial Contexts for Medical Open-Domain Question Answering
| 2024-03-04T10:41:52 | 2024-06-13T08:42:05 |
Giacomo Frisoni, Alessio Cocchieri, Alex Presepi, Gianluca Moro, Zaiqiao Meng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Medical open-domain question answering demands substantial access to
specialized knowledge. Recent efforts have sought to decouple knowledge from
model parameters, counteracting architectural scaling and allowing for training
on common low-resource hardware. The retrieve-then-read paradigm has become
ubiquitous, with model predictions grounded on relevant knowledge pieces from
external repositories such as PubMed, textbooks, and UMLS. An alternative path,
still under-explored but made possible by the advent of domain-specific large
language models, entails constructing artificial contexts through prompting. As
a result, "to generate or to retrieve" is the modern equivalent of Hamlet's
dilemma. This paper presents MedGENIE, the first generate-then-read framework
for multiple-choice question answering in medicine. We conduct extensive
experiments on MedQA-USMLE, MedMCQA, and MMLU, incorporating a practical
perspective by assuming a maximum of 24GB VRAM. MedGENIE sets a new
state-of-the-art in the open-book setting of each testbed, allowing a
small-scale reader to outcompete zero-shot closed-book 175B baselines while
using up to 706$\times$ fewer parameters. Our findings reveal that generated
passages are more effective than retrieved ones in attaining higher accuracy.
|
[
-0.530097484588623,
-0.7076835036277771,
0.8556883931159973,
-0.34839609265327454,
-0.1529761105775833,
-0.30298855900764465,
-0.21301165223121643,
-0.44468650221824646,
-0.10390795022249222,
0.276807963848114,
-0.8152509927749634,
-0.12384647130966187,
-0.28850242495536804,
0.35953259468078613,
0.0030756837222725153,
0.9298151731491089,
-0.1414155662059784,
0.15821050107479095,
-0.4368687868118286,
-0.18415504693984985,
-0.5172786712646484,
-0.4297376871109009,
-0.5679876804351807,
-0.21643826365470886,
0.7727262377738953,
0.20616668462753296,
0.5078780651092529,
0.40682879090309143,
0.224827378988266,
0.3110824525356293,
0.14576295018196106,
0.3929458260536194,
-0.48565673828125,
0.17057998478412628,
-0.18519176542758942,
-0.4503245949745178,
0.022845281288027763,
0.20078028738498688,
0.396192342042923,
0.5685237050056458,
-0.07133655250072479,
0.18968962132930756,
-0.254086971282959,
0.5545085072517395,
-0.574364960193634,
-0.3589375913143158,
-0.5612503886222839,
0.06961118429899216,
-0.13687142729759216,
-0.43430596590042114,
-0.7487485408782959,
-0.2819686233997345,
0.39327868819236755,
-0.742504358291626,
0.12479916214942932,
0.11672823131084442,
0.7976296544075012,
0.33356401324272156,
-0.4642355442047119,
-0.4468444287776947,
-0.8182979226112366,
0.6525784730911255,
-0.32775217294692993,
0.21163687109947205,
0.26842331886291504,
0.5646442770957947,
-0.11728112399578094,
-1.0297924280166626,
-0.6148887276649475,
-0.12608425319194794,
-0.1436091959476471,
0.3531332015991211,
-0.2169266641139984,
-0.13306009769439697,
0.0442052036523819,
0.23223291337490082,
-0.500381350517273,
-0.18702350556850433,
-0.6816062927246094,
0.045986808836460114,
0.30219486355781555,
0.08621279150247574,
0.3956034481525421,
-0.21167275309562683,
-0.41455480456352234,
-0.033465009182691574,
-0.7708784341812134,
0.10364587604999542,
-0.13405193388462067,
0.11101240664720535,
0.35970786213874817,
0.7119030356407166,
0.08780353516340256,
0.7928513288497925,
0.179298996925354,
0.04130084067583084,
0.14698879420757294,
-0.28136271238327026,
-0.35904043912887573,
-0.25439178943634033,
0.22848105430603027,
0.18146084249019623,
0.21561545133590698,
-0.2676326334476471,
-0.002751276595517993,
-0.1696368157863617,
0.7573166489601135,
-0.7980953454971313,
-0.23659947514533997,
0.7448709011077881,
-0.6949944496154785,
-0.20332379639148712,
-0.14680929481983185,
-0.6499453783035278,
-0.39936563372612,
-0.23237644135951996,
0.7126928567886353,
-0.6102982759475708,
-0.16998614370822906,
0.24263615906238556,
-0.2967221438884735,
0.3715910017490387,
0.46755728125572205,
-0.7232351303100586,
-0.033639729022979736,
0.4113689661026001,
0.6025110483169556,
-0.14777159690856934,
0.03184914588928223,
-0.6704868674278259,
-0.15235179662704468,
-0.37738510966300964,
1.0418161153793335,
-0.14473214745521545,
-0.40654483437538147,
0.049842339009046555,
-0.02058933489024639,
-0.4022405445575714,
-0.899625837802887,
0.18657948076725006,
-0.6105790734291077,
0.45291659235954285,
-0.37691959738731384,
-0.509776771068573,
0.14375315606594086,
0.24360772967338562,
-0.5561075210571289,
0.6384045481681824,
0.3352885842323303,
-0.5502363443374634,
0.5184759497642517,
-0.7043513655662537,
-0.176299586892128,
0.15928585827350616,
-0.6226364374160767,
-0.07608328759670258,
0.39574915170669556,
0.10862869024276733,
0.07096650451421738,
-0.36096876859664917,
0.2654748857021332,
0.06139286980032921,
0.019399328157305717,
0.41233354806900024,
-0.6637631058692932,
0.7106048464775085,
0.36787286400794983,
-0.12438508123159409,
-0.06278157234191895,
-0.6439387798309326,
0.22057469189167023,
0.31231439113616943,
-0.589701771736145,
-0.42942073941230774,
0.11994517594575882,
-0.10848654806613922,
0.33387601375579834,
-0.03417587652802467,
-0.7937984466552734,
0.08479010313749313,
-0.5678812265396118,
0.4039725959300995,
0.6779114007949829,
0.06694275140762329,
0.36885368824005127,
-0.5852065086364746,
0.6121890544891357,
-0.11101878434419632,
0.011703355237841606,
-0.10759113729000092,
-0.47849729657173157,
-0.17628437280654907,
-0.5408382415771484,
0.3397226333618164,
0.5787949562072754,
-1.1002976894378662,
-0.20505626499652863,
0.10185311734676361,
-0.38231298327445984,
-1.014872431755066,
-0.28382718563079834,
0.3299185633659363,
0.8936088681221008,
0.4970506429672241,
0.04473801329731941,
-0.14416776597499847,
-0.8513978719711304,
-0.17868879437446594,
-0.06159977987408638,
-0.23153077065944672,
1.03474760055542,
0.5253604054450989,
-0.2075272798538208,
0.9254730939865112,
-0.7455847859382629,
-0.04166269302368164,
-0.1493607610464096,
-0.05597160384058952,
0.07456806302070618,
0.37736964225769043,
0.7770163416862488,
-0.8966579437255859,
-0.1962900459766388,
-0.0497429259121418,
-0.8703367114067078,
0.04474819079041481,
-0.09852342307567596,
-0.5760205388069153,
0.17029087245464325,
0.4867832064628601,
-0.7985222339630127,
0.35460057854652405,
0.3202480673789978,
-0.3341519832611084,
0.7086979150772095,
-0.37501293420791626,
0.27178525924682617,
-1.3055505752563477,
0.4984005093574524,
-0.40220481157302856,
-0.04415808990597725,
-0.7128440737724304,
0.29352667927742004,
0.1676304042339325,
-0.12840016186237335,
-0.6081898808479309,
0.8293185830116272,
-0.3821946382522583,
0.2936255633831024,
0.008431412279605865,
0.30899184942245483,
0.011499576270580292,
0.13659530878067017,
-0.0013021734775975347,
1.2123589515686035,
0.0664914920926094,
-0.5960624814033508,
-0.1135033592581749,
0.5974233746528625,
-0.2476690113544464,
0.699413001537323,
-0.5597814917564392,
0.1732097864151001,
-0.4796034097671509,
0.09677917510271072,
-1.0763617753982544,
-0.40847402811050415,
0.014053110964596272,
-0.6155610680580139,
0.3299945294857025,
0.11184103786945343,
-0.20100709795951843,
-0.4906340539455414,
-0.08970902860164642,
0.5541698932647705,
0.6946762800216675,
-0.704055905342102,
0.6312581896781921,
0.3852386474609375,
-0.21091888844966888,
-0.5382212400436401,
-0.46754664182662964,
-0.23285025358200073,
0.00949005875736475,
-0.5348948836326599,
0.13436460494995117,
-0.3617667555809021,
-0.3276750147342682,
0.030054528266191483,
-0.27457723021507263,
-0.1261909157037735,
-0.09591967612504959,
-0.09210407733917236,
0.4020581841468811,
-0.4475144147872925,
0.46219801902770996,
0.35468998551368713,
-0.1480674147605896,
0.1604662388563156,
-0.6167727112770081,
0.2952887713909149,
0.18656781315803528,
-0.24280588328838348,
0.08494336903095245,
0.8250217437744141,
0.3318980038166046,
-0.35751476883888245,
0.7570168972015381,
0.15905353426933289,
-0.4888894557952881,
-0.2788776755332947,
-0.3036532998085022,
-0.28316670656204224,
-0.4954926371574402,
0.26271262764930725,
-0.4059267044067383,
-0.9661230444908142,
0.18117107450962067,
-0.3813938498497009,
0.4683908224105835,
0.6139751076698303,
0.7523150444030762,
-0.291498601436615,
1.0455818176269531,
0.3261409401893616,
0.27313584089279175,
0.10475518554449081,
-0.047299034893512726,
0.027484416961669922,
-0.5091249346733093,
-0.32905393838882446,
-0.6517016887664795,
-0.18125411868095398,
-0.14224155247211456,
-0.4240962266921997,
0.9351052045822144,
-0.2311863750219345,
-0.08207277208566666,
-0.047991879284381866,
-0.4992496371269226,
0.31967926025390625,
0.6594465970993042,
0.3051917850971222,
0.18051083385944366,
0.06554360687732697,
-0.5835639238357544,
0.13247373700141907,
-0.9930126667022705,
-0.39365580677986145,
1.082011103630066,
-0.1470390260219574,
0.4559946060180664,
0.14671990275382996,
0.823033332824707,
-0.04496233910322189,
0.5573857426643372,
-0.8132982850074768,
0.307871013879776,
-0.0642794594168663,
-0.962674617767334,
-0.20570184290409088,
-0.2639998197555542,
-1.448851227760315,
0.4868837893009186,
-0.2909223139286041,
-0.46216240525245667,
0.22444504499435425,
0.3546731472015381,
-0.8428334593772888,
0.27151644229888916,
-0.5962822437286377,
0.9066967964172363,
0.08641751855611801,
-0.16296637058258057,
-0.045651111751794815,
-0.901247501373291,
0.24982774257659912,
-0.06550519913434982,
0.15164531767368317,
0.40542030334472656,
-0.10506695508956909,
0.26701465249061584,
-0.42629528045654297,
0.46810418367385864,
-0.10346630960702896,
-0.13674426078796387,
0.47008293867111206,
0.1451200246810913,
0.02760785073041916,
0.05986366793513298,
-0.11682674288749695,
-0.31323304772377014,
0.41094017028808594,
-0.41601836681365967,
-0.5836591124534607,
0.45932430028915405,
-0.7969770431518555,
-0.5739773511886597,
-0.39968299865722656,
-0.5435128808021545,
-0.27064990997314453,
0.29970288276672363,
0.5502894520759583,
0.7996780276298523,
-0.29550087451934814,
0.06739053875207901,
1.0201985836029053,
-0.5151529312133789,
0.13185298442840576,
0.5558167695999146,
0.06702054291963577,
-0.4132269620895386,
0.6130434274673462,
0.06074212118983269,
0.4570883512496948,
0.2625589966773987,
0.049984779208898544,
-0.31804755330085754,
-0.30171623826026917,
-0.8973425626754761,
0.3324214220046997,
-0.5997508764266968,
-0.19520512223243713,
-0.6581024527549744,
-0.5416301488876343,
-0.08221332728862762,
-0.29757392406463623,
-0.11214052885770798,
-0.09427058696746826,
-0.43561750650405884,
-0.005126067437231541,
0.24027325212955475,
0.5122114419937134,
-0.03608515486121178,
-0.08583751320838928,
-0.9848018288612366,
0.41783103346824646,
0.3298538029193878,
0.1661669760942459,
-0.1220492273569107,
-0.27306920289993286,
-0.0600222609937191,
-0.14209158718585968,
-0.06688906252384186,
-1.1334426403045654,
0.2539176642894745,
-0.005662871990352869,
0.5415086150169373,
0.22428138554096222,
0.1952916532754898,
0.48314136266708374,
-0.9955326914787292,
0.6453734040260315,
-0.10012637078762054,
-0.2856382727622986,
0.5553092956542969,
-0.2682878077030182,
0.36668112874031067,
0.7895939946174622,
0.41855788230895996,
-0.3572463095188141,
-0.2164020985364914,
-0.6712023615837097,
-0.7498653531074524,
0.6054995656013489,
0.08542781323194504,
0.23407752811908722,
-0.41667529940605164,
0.6664016842842102,
0.4786742925643921,
0.5327555537223816,
-0.21770444512367249,
-0.1802964210510254,
0.2943964898586273,
-0.32980313897132874,
-0.1456974297761917,
-0.016618695110082626,
-0.27024635672569275,
-0.2190110683441162,
0.3838338851928711,
-0.07489283382892609,
0.6494389176368713,
0.571609377861023,
-0.055495381355285645,
-0.25468456745147705,
0.2854103446006775,
0.5343737602233887,
0.7256829738616943,
-0.17128901183605194,
0.0321727953851223,
-0.22640131413936615,
-0.5768850445747375,
0.06411358714103699,
0.17544643580913544,
-0.4180396795272827,
-0.019131915643811226,
0.035594113171100616,
0.40146997570991516,
-0.2726505696773529,
-1.144511103630066,
0.2938496768474579,
-0.0484367199242115,
-0.5428895950317383,
-0.32124918699264526,
0.02402893826365471,
-0.18401381373405457,
0.4017643332481384,
0.16990499198436737,
0.28326430916786194,
0.18700990080833435,
-0.47317466139793396,
0.4306454360485077,
0.4074137508869171,
-0.24266815185546875,
0.030730925500392914,
0.9455985426902771,
0.08053085207939148,
-0.2549382448196411,
0.8052828907966614,
0.12139308452606201,
0.03796982392668724,
0.5206958055496216,
0.5827429294586182,
0.6246489882469177,
-0.13143986463546753,
0.4333334267139435,
0.3408692479133606,
0.20161017775535583,
0.06639648228883743,
0.7702544331550598,
0.06073259189724922,
-0.6351483464241028,
-0.29517263174057007,
-0.33232948184013367,
-0.24807427823543549,
0.2968548536300659,
-0.685775876045227,
-0.2905609905719757,
-0.19817477464675903,
-0.2524421513080597,
0.16227193176746368,
-0.24104830622673035,
-0.6090801954269409,
0.2641724944114685,
-0.2025775909423828,
1.1597771644592285,
-0.46946555376052856,
0.48812252283096313,
0.8621271252632141,
-0.48106443881988525,
-0.736631453037262,
0.10475141555070877,
0.0312812440097332,
-0.7128097414970398,
0.06222765892744064,
0.05681411176919937,
0.0338035486638546,
0.18685507774353027,
-0.7359547019004822,
-0.6315376162528992,
1.0304571390151978,
0.20554977655410767,
-0.03953489288687706,
-0.03826552629470825,
-0.39918413758277893,
0.525437593460083,
-0.2883720099925995,
-0.022147338837385178,
0.6397536993026733,
0.279070645570755,
0.05146797001361847,
-0.5882990956306458,
0.07841290533542633,
-0.5163439512252808,
-0.27785107493400574,
0.26327064633369446,
-0.24526190757751465,
0.909166157245636,
-0.49036693572998047,
-0.10710661858320236,
0.4797857701778412,
0.2856549918651581,
0.44158491492271423,
0.47553780674934387,
0.31541889905929565,
0.19902628660202026,
0.8189797401428223,
0.07023430615663528,
1.3176075220108032,
-0.13065123558044434,
-0.09578973054885864,
0.7492126226425171,
-0.13834413886070251,
1.0706899166107178,
0.6613818407058716,
0.044026799499988556,
0.3348117470741272,
0.7986427545547485,
0.3791798949241638,
0.6488447785377502,
0.24007375538349152,
-0.4048609733581543,
-0.35565266013145447,
0.07963116466999054,
-0.3576630651950836,
0.04069895297288895,
0.2430681586265564,
-0.4669511914253235,
-0.31968703866004944,
0.28730013966560364,
0.059366483241319656,
0.10392154008150101,
-0.05439380928874016,
0.9217814207077026,
0.15758265554904938,
-1.1942527294158936,
0.5961965322494507,
-0.08185867220163345,
-0.12678056955337524,
-0.6556985378265381,
-0.14358964562416077,
-0.11107759922742844,
0.10710617154836655,
0.21462494134902954,
-0.553535521030426,
-0.04012766107916832,
-0.029866473749279976,
-0.30415141582489014,
-0.04127217084169388,
0.7865983843803406,
-0.42251086235046387,
-0.22430695593357086,
0.03610515967011452,
1.103977918624878,
0.12780225276947021,
0.10440496355295181,
-0.5134434700012207,
-0.46590322256088257,
-0.20033371448516846,
-0.27463802695274353,
0.4888845682144165,
0.45366013050079346,
0.11802162975072861,
0.521616518497467,
0.5498322248458862,
0.1026223823428154,
-0.04537969082593918,
-0.10347903519868851,
0.9889898300170898,
-0.23432831466197968,
-0.33982306718826294,
-0.5143624544143677,
0.6672699451446533,
0.08269645273685455,
-0.43524840474128723,
0.37833690643310547,
0.35203829407691956,
0.7382508516311646,
-0.35467448830604553,
0.9465873837471008,
-0.27681398391723633,
0.5532482862472534,
-0.5449486374855042,
0.6875815987586975,
-1.0405765771865845,
-0.2568742632865906,
0.10593027621507645,
-0.3343840539455414,
-0.1659395694732666,
0.5924482941627502,
-0.279104083776474,
0.17942063510417938,
0.9124382138252258,
0.6486928462982178,
-0.010131584480404854,
-0.06731712818145752,
0.2765960395336151,
0.2354230135679245,
-0.043901227414608,
0.6945251226425171,
0.7481211423873901,
-0.07048430293798447,
0.3816620707511902,
0.3660809397697449,
-0.5244821310043335,
-0.04904094710946083,
-0.3618506193161011,
-0.8800865411758423,
-0.5678059458732605,
0.05014749616384506,
-0.7001010775566101,
0.1374589204788208,
1.1572734117507935,
0.43393072485923767,
-0.5994333028793335,
0.05260048806667328,
0.2189178764820099,
-0.15826325118541718,
-0.3828355073928833,
-0.11799686402082443,
0.4253566563129425,
-0.516018271446228,
-0.5178714990615845,
0.5073720812797546,
0.23626579344272614,
-0.044071611016988754,
0.03396306186914444,
0.1963847577571869,
-0.22508877515792847,
0.5818962454795837,
0.698305070400238,
0.549696147441864,
-0.5228633880615234,
-0.18651516735553741,
0.3983518183231354,
-0.2486594319343567,
0.22436420619487762,
0.9482058882713318,
-0.87491774559021,
0.6941693425178528,
0.45291873812675476,
1.002144455909729,
0.2075442224740982,
0.21731355786323547,
0.6919891834259033,
-0.4388861060142517,
-0.25830498337745667,
0.2829170227050781,
0.12855204939842224,
-0.37559324502944946,
-0.30387401580810547,
0.342519074678421,
0.1942833811044693,
-0.45932313799858093,
-0.6062076687812805,
0.3031350374221802,
-0.6564270853996277,
-0.6964622139930725,
0.9020012617111206,
0.09546278417110443,
-0.2783656716346741,
-0.10601434111595154,
-0.7052372694015503,
0.07095162570476532,
-0.014801912009716034,
0.7877772450447083,
0.43683719635009766,
-0.1832866221666336,
0.08912725001573563,
-1.1002857685089111,
0.7461159229278564,
0.5224056243896484,
-1.0412466526031494,
-0.24474270641803741,
0.7377679944038391,
0.23182329535484314,
-0.09267350286245346,
1.1140094995498657,
-0.31642115116119385,
0.49518272280693054,
0.03563091903924942,
-0.27272555232048035,
0.06636933982372284,
-0.5135315656661987,
-0.22686751186847687,
0.3965666890144348,
-0.057236362248659134,
-0.3078652322292328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01921v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01921v1
|
Arabic Text Sentiment Analysis: Reinforcing Human-Performed Surveys with Wider Topic Analysis
| 2024-03-04T10:37:48 | 2024-03-04T10:37:48 |
Latifah Almurqren, Ryan Hodgson, Alexandra Cristea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sentiment analysis (SA) has been, and is still, a thriving research area.
However, the task of Arabic sentiment analysis (ASA) is still underrepresented
in the body of research. This study offers the first in-depth and in-breadth
analysis of existing ASA studies of textual content and identifies their common
themes, domains of application, methods, approaches, technologies and
algorithms used. The in-depth study manually analyses 133 ASA papers published
in the English language between 2002 and 2020 from four academic databases
(SAGE, IEEE, Springer, WILEY) and from Google Scholar. The in-breadth study
uses modern, automatic machine learning techniques, such as topic modelling and
temporal analysis, on Open Access resources, to reinforce themes and trends
identified by the prior study, on 2297 ASA publications between 2010-2020. The
main findings show the different approaches used for ASA: machine learning,
lexicon-based and hybrid approaches. Other findings include ASA 'winning'
algorithms (SVM, NB, hybrid methods). Deep learning methods, such as LSTM can
provide higher accuracy, but for ASA sometimes the corpora are not large enough
to support them. Additionally, whilst there are some ASA corpora and lexicons,
more are required. Specifically, Arabic tweets corpora and datasets are
currently only moderately sized. Moreover, Arabic lexicons that have high
coverage contain only Modern Standard Arabic (MSA) words, and those with Arabic
dialects are quite small. Thus, new corpora need to be created. On the other
hand, ASA tools are stringently lacking. There is a need to develop ASA tools
that can be used in industry, as well as in academia, for Arabic text SA.
Hence, our study offers insights into the challenges associated with ASA
research and provides suggestions for ways to move the field forward such as
lack of Dialectical Arabic resource, Arabic tweets, corpora and data sets for
SA.
|
[
-0.6341628432273865,
-0.3496442437171936,
0.24722877144813538,
0.2195974737405777,
-0.5460181832313538,
0.5687170028686523,
0.20811115205287933,
-0.47937482595443726,
0.43714219331741333,
0.14235420525074005,
-0.39664506912231445,
-0.8490782380104065,
-0.9875143766403198,
0.3267037570476532,
-0.5162011384963989,
1.0718255043029785,
-0.27913621068000793,
0.04000069200992584,
-0.08291169255971909,
-0.6409264802932739,
-0.17810940742492676,
-0.7527336478233337,
-0.5812097191810608,
0.07917837053537369,
0.39156410098075867,
0.5685926079750061,
0.7478607892990112,
-0.2261102795600891,
0.5504968166351318,
0.2227804809808731,
-0.4172416627407074,
0.1404266655445099,
0.02383149228990078,
0.016303900629281998,
0.006988855078816414,
-0.038480743765830994,
-0.3415592610836029,
-0.09456121176481247,
0.5404179692268372,
0.7382214665412903,
0.2140478789806366,
0.10351811349391937,
0.09044691175222397,
1.1837096214294434,
-0.6996278166770935,
-0.33018261194229126,
-0.19451652467250824,
0.08827848732471466,
-0.42311879992485046,
0.1450882852077484,
-0.010890389792621136,
-0.5955773591995239,
0.3400070369243622,
0.3419611155986786,
-0.05261725187301636,
-0.027950741350650787,
0.7465797066688538,
-0.010050383396446705,
-0.854607105255127,
-0.6848154664039612,
-0.45909395813941956,
1.1368156671524048,
-0.7695028185844421,
0.13999977707862854,
0.11921583861112595,
0.15786521136760712,
-0.015914343297481537,
-0.5049413442611694,
-0.3762229382991791,
-0.043913476169109344,
0.11641637235879898,
0.15076369047164917,
-0.3339187800884247,
-0.21130338311195374,
-0.414434015750885,
0.531221866607666,
-0.2369781881570816,
-0.10070353746414185,
-0.24521635472774506,
-0.09150425344705582,
0.690403401851654,
0.025030476972460747,
0.389820396900177,
-0.27271318435668945,
-0.2943960726261139,
0.14964134991168976,
-0.8219359517097473,
0.1613704413175583,
0.21767473220825195,
-0.0715167224407196,
0.05704636499285698,
0.5250878930091858,
-0.15117567777633667,
0.28581103682518005,
-0.45719966292381287,
0.06243521347641945,
0.23246614634990692,
-0.2159785032272339,
-0.10287782549858093,
0.1708400696516037,
0.8001415729522705,
0.1739726960659027,
-0.008798306807875633,
0.010038032196462154,
-0.2638760805130005,
0.2125125676393509,
0.3696995675563812,
-0.7942816019058228,
0.10331857949495316,
0.5356630682945251,
-0.6656572222709656,
-0.15090076625347137,
0.06274071335792542,
-0.9048718810081482,
-0.6286272406578064,
-0.10903716832399368,
0.115373894572258,
-0.2906414866447449,
-0.28498369455337524,
-0.12347352504730225,
-0.18797361850738525,
0.3324427604675293,
0.08099649846553802,
-0.3058774173259735,
0.33131876587867737,
0.5919145345687866,
1.167158842086792,
-0.19679699838161469,
0.028535032644867897,
0.09848858416080475,
-0.26989492774009705,
-0.5280774831771851,
0.7854611277580261,
-0.5670892596244812,
-0.7214759588241577,
0.27981236577033997,
-0.5488170385360718,
0.2730010747909546,
-0.3839404284954071,
0.9013692736625671,
-0.7419729232788086,
0.2218867391347885,
-0.47478625178337097,
-0.4469573199748993,
-0.4408387839794159,
0.30642372369766235,
-0.6444327235221863,
0.8521175980567932,
0.05526918172836304,
-0.9550194144248962,
0.15791168808937073,
-0.897942841053009,
-0.5131469368934631,
-0.37611815333366394,
-0.15574903786182404,
-0.6669269800186157,
0.35475653409957886,
0.5503513813018799,
0.2970898449420929,
-0.39663955569267273,
-0.11580923199653625,
0.06645896285772324,
-0.4278867542743683,
0.533919632434845,
-0.13553503155708313,
0.7024921774864197,
0.48331958055496216,
-0.26862284541130066,
0.10293067991733551,
-0.45708954334259033,
-0.2541428804397583,
-0.3330259323120117,
0.0668628066778183,
-0.3328954577445984,
0.16010838747024536,
0.28450894355773926,
0.23594196140766144,
0.24287748336791992,
-0.6250371336936951,
0.08069391548633575,
-0.6910685300827026,
0.1553262174129486,
0.46740657091140747,
0.4171440303325653,
0.4013136923313141,
-0.23120225965976715,
0.934055507183075,
0.03795241937041283,
-0.09932086616754532,
0.22266924381256104,
-0.375542551279068,
-0.8262039422988892,
-0.3466024398803711,
0.3794828951358795,
0.16691574454307556,
-0.48009592294692993,
0.2878386974334717,
-0.11541242152452469,
-0.636701762676239,
-0.7634825110435486,
-0.08499906957149506,
0.15698669850826263,
0.006525665055960417,
0.4070291221141815,
-0.737679123878479,
-0.615593671798706,
-0.7837298512458801,
-0.49800536036491394,
-0.10905330628156662,
0.2320566326379776,
0.029428662732243538,
0.48030829429626465,
-0.5794391632080078,
1.0690796375274658,
-0.39548274874687195,
-0.5368993282318115,
-0.5127792954444885,
0.638292133808136,
0.14453445374965668,
-0.01931902766227722,
0.6782492399215698,
-0.7724316716194153,
-0.6748325228691101,
0.015314734540879726,
-0.6151724457740784,
-0.13975490629673004,
0.26623645424842834,
0.010516488924622536,
0.6442462205886841,
0.33727216720581055,
-0.3724147081375122,
0.6365465521812439,
0.525762677192688,
-0.38294288516044617,
0.26392754912376404,
0.5699087381362915,
0.22229021787643433,
-1.1449015140533447,
0.2071664035320282,
0.28073832392692566,
0.13641321659088135,
-0.4832002520561218,
-0.015633920207619667,
-0.33515819907188416,
-0.21302446722984314,
-0.30989325046539307,
0.5426408052444458,
-0.41305074095726013,
-0.002032330958172679,
-0.804194450378418,
-0.23442132771015167,
-0.03518080711364746,
0.05735251307487488,
-0.11236432939767838,
0.8896300196647644,
0.3779135048389435,
-0.4043138027191162,
0.03813925385475159,
0.26916369795799255,
-0.4336411654949188,
0.2070092409849167,
-0.652519702911377,
0.2149823009967804,
-0.33322617411613464,
0.219879150390625,
-1.1303561925888062,
0.05168996378779411,
0.3939504027366638,
-0.6295294761657715,
-0.005685498937964439,
-0.003198235062882304,
-0.1834036260843277,
-0.09592710435390472,
-0.5006657242774963,
0.4422120451927185,
0.5809712409973145,
-0.13129913806915283,
0.827682614326477,
0.6947101950645447,
-0.5573503971099854,
-0.8352480530738831,
-0.3002314567565918,
0.26359087228775024,
-0.3850642740726471,
-0.34233546257019043,
0.19426807761192322,
0.3810729384422302,
-0.8184694647789001,
0.07467332482337952,
-0.4367643892765045,
-0.3978182375431061,
0.193625345826149,
0.39618581533432007,
0.04818679764866829,
0.022963080555200577,
0.16516311466693878,
0.36897748708724976,
0.033318448811769485,
0.4322104752063751,
0.02860085479915142,
0.39862149953842163,
-0.39724835753440857,
-0.1817534863948822,
-0.5727349519729614,
0.7642792463302612,
0.5686878561973572,
-0.4536251723766327,
0.9271746873855591,
0.535277247428894,
-0.16691531240940094,
0.0030196530278772116,
-0.26943260431289673,
0.12705278396606445,
-0.4052240550518036,
0.3173166811466217,
-0.13840948045253754,
-0.5062870383262634,
0.16975915431976318,
-0.3973342776298523,
0.26045316457748413,
0.8041622638702393,
0.5113905072212219,
-0.41359901428222656,
0.8575421571731567,
0.8483508229255676,
-0.8687463998794556,
0.16451005637645721,
-0.23501743376255035,
0.33875805139541626,
-0.4173649251461029,
-0.22607119381427765,
-0.8109108805656433,
-0.5648926496505737,
-0.4393133819103241,
0.1087016761302948,
0.556038498878479,
-0.2581821084022522,
-0.020565342158079147,
-0.18545006215572357,
-0.13279162347316742,
0.1898212730884552,
0.3305879533290863,
-0.1994045227766037,
0.12531034648418427,
0.3227265179157257,
0.15720421075820923,
-0.06850671768188477,
-0.3462596535682678,
-0.8827363848686218,
0.9215031266212463,
0.5561785101890564,
0.33374056220054626,
0.37484362721443176,
0.8456701040267944,
0.8564072251319885,
0.6223615407943726,
-0.9248121380805969,
0.4379010498523712,
-0.08415175974369049,
-0.44610795378685,
-0.11968518793582916,
-0.17631351947784424,
-0.8872150778770447,
0.22245937585830688,
-0.008584043942391872,
-0.2184881567955017,
0.1256767362356186,
-0.24839311838150024,
-0.2037365734577179,
-0.08258289843797684,
-0.26118004322052,
0.5234238505363464,
0.10462494939565659,
-0.039123162627220154,
-0.37760522961616516,
-0.5931792855262756,
0.008190528489649296,
0.012355247512459755,
0.5181390047073364,
-0.10912737250328064,
-0.15765556693077087,
1.0015637874603271,
-0.3951577842235565,
0.7986233234405518,
-0.17891700565814972,
-0.25104820728302,
0.7230665683746338,
-0.03264365345239639,
0.048681389540433884,
-0.05836949124932289,
-0.3614487946033478,
0.2671295702457428,
0.058267127722501755,
-0.5420483946800232,
-0.2890315055847168,
0.62223881483078,
-1.0972198247909546,
-0.4561305046081543,
-1.071397066116333,
-0.329413503408432,
-0.5712828040122986,
-0.23901411890983582,
0.15593531727790833,
0.33772680163383484,
-0.39109164476394653,
0.15472614765167236,
0.26931366324424744,
-0.04431493952870369,
0.4230007231235504,
0.05650108680129051,
-0.09762271493673325,
-0.34286943078041077,
0.8101294040679932,
0.07842092216014862,
-0.3879295289516449,
0.21114808320999146,
0.05576096102595329,
-0.354047566652298,
-0.7231769561767578,
-0.4276284873485565,
-0.031791578978300095,
-0.630395770072937,
-0.2119823694229126,
-0.4541921615600586,
-0.17738717794418335,
-0.2792789936065674,
-0.06113081052899361,
-0.2020079493522644,
-0.2639562487602234,
-0.4088869094848633,
0.008230398409068584,
0.5150038599967957,
0.6553955078125,
0.23261524736881256,
0.5611288547515869,
-1.1076688766479492,
0.20562994480133057,
-0.07853672653436661,
-0.018855230882763863,
0.1794300377368927,
-0.5120158195495605,
-0.3190859258174896,
0.004992688540369272,
-0.40426063537597656,
-1.0198791027069092,
0.6136162877082825,
0.20736461877822876,
-0.07663062959909439,
0.4691709280014038,
0.09891358017921448,
0.43098244071006775,
-0.17103241384029388,
0.9637203812599182,
-0.07812906801700592,
-1.156380534172058,
0.4082412123680115,
-0.03798183426260948,
0.2451888471841812,
0.8102094531059265,
0.9911730885505676,
-0.7487781047821045,
-0.13460156321525574,
-0.4275805950164795,
-1.0301088094711304,
0.33372750878334045,
0.41626349091529846,
0.19656145572662354,
0.1121833398938179,
0.2814740836620331,
0.287534236907959,
0.509833812713623,
-0.32528313994407654,
-0.26061591506004333,
-0.18120674788951874,
-0.6636882424354553,
-0.032149288803339005,
-0.5785658359527588,
-0.00004971636371919885,
-0.18540464341640472,
0.7952423691749573,
0.09501077234745026,
0.05967634543776512,
0.1378215104341507,
-0.16463808715343475,
0.013835052028298378,
0.5426169633865356,
-0.04827427491545677,
0.7975419163703918,
-0.19917234778404236,
0.018173834308981895,
0.15841320157051086,
-0.42033979296684265,
0.2193976640701294,
0.0035150672774761915,
-0.26633989810943604,
0.24676476418972015,
0.3403792977333069,
0.21995161473751068,
-0.16247867047786713,
-0.7329786419868469,
0.4819263815879822,
0.07565508037805557,
-0.039490729570388794,
-0.6174585223197937,
-0.3364216685295105,
-0.15660126507282257,
-0.023477869108319283,
0.6933906078338623,
0.11007124185562134,
0.4246568977832794,
-0.8207659125328064,
-0.034145813435316086,
0.5326091051101685,
-0.6396368741989136,
-0.26330095529556274,
0.035564668476581573,
0.377025306224823,
0.13664276897907257,
0.4764076769351959,
-0.21656861901283264,
-0.6694643497467041,
0.6301338076591492,
0.16950762271881104,
0.8158267140388489,
0.18112173676490784,
0.3958493769168854,
-0.10079576075077057,
0.09465084224939346,
0.19566690921783447,
0.5953711271286011,
0.17394012212753296,
-0.5534666776657104,
-0.2709257900714874,
-0.7149063944816589,
-0.6649226546287537,
-0.06556319445371628,
-0.47561997175216675,
-0.156652569770813,
-0.44602659344673157,
-0.2833176255226135,
-0.16775088012218475,
0.5029006600379944,
-0.41422736644744873,
0.5825038552284241,
-0.040862660855054855,
0.9076753258705139,
-0.7104635238647461,
0.5342391729354858,
1.1414923667907715,
-0.38884955644607544,
-0.2709432542324066,
0.4102279841899872,
0.216303288936615,
-0.34795933961868286,
0.3442973494529724,
0.20404380559921265,
-0.5741609930992126,
-0.11714226752519608,
-0.6397119760513306,
-0.6447862386703491,
0.669875979423523,
-0.33678096532821655,
-0.1249193325638771,
0.33364424109458923,
0.09989061951637268,
0.5989968180656433,
-0.1747768670320511,
0.03950241580605507,
0.5359388589859009,
0.2215435802936554,
0.05962852016091347,
-0.2907215356826782,
-0.1837638020515442,
-0.26550137996673584,
-0.2111225426197052,
0.4141717553138733,
-0.6936156749725342,
0.6312096118927002,
0.2933421730995178,
-0.2685220241546631,
0.3247625231742859,
1.2896333932876587,
0.08059106022119522,
0.6247962713241577,
0.20874734222888947,
0.4464622437953949,
0.593931257724762,
0.07771531492471695,
0.8104419112205505,
-0.16015663743019104,
-0.002020049374550581,
0.4294205904006958,
-0.3990815579891205,
0.8557573556900024,
0.5680791735649109,
-0.2636638283729553,
1.0092591047286987,
0.410936564207077,
0.1650676727294922,
0.5024067759513855,
0.16156625747680664,
-0.6930052638053894,
0.1502010077238083,
-0.4902850091457367,
-0.5358109474182129,
0.6294705867767334,
0.5335410237312317,
-0.2587822675704956,
-0.10569717735052109,
0.0030349537264555693,
0.10907784104347229,
0.3144552409648895,
-0.5799711346626282,
0.7061475515365601,
0.3357544243335724,
-0.3564817011356354,
0.07512345165014267,
0.5821918845176697,
0.6142722368240356,
-0.553192138671875,
0.20894290506839752,
-0.45961812138557434,
0.15449276566505432,
-0.28231045603752136,
-0.658991813659668,
0.7114747762680054,
0.3387286961078644,
0.12258023768663406,
0.03236765414476395,
0.9450849890708923,
0.12084724009037018,
-0.5898786187171936,
-0.06302749365568161,
0.7749350070953369,
0.21179494261741638,
-0.36346015334129333,
-0.24034483730793,
0.317719966173172,
-0.04565305635333061,
-0.10432080179452896,
0.33932405710220337,
0.5533226728439331,
-0.15230025351047516,
0.40659409761428833,
0.2297125607728958,
-0.011561266146600246,
-0.4826166331768036,
0.09493263810873032,
0.8029842972755432,
-1.06527578830719,
-0.2702365815639496,
-0.9910792112350464,
0.3585945665836334,
-0.16649536788463593,
-0.4652877151966095,
1.0639305114746094,
0.33453169465065,
0.3602275848388672,
0.03613756597042084,
0.9577212929725647,
0.07412699609994888,
0.5828684568405151,
-0.302199125289917,
0.9781343936920166,
-0.6402131915092468,
0.12349620461463928,
-0.2999909818172455,
-0.6816762089729309,
-0.31160596013069153,
0.4117104113101959,
-0.24942637979984283,
-0.07073727995157242,
0.4051896035671234,
0.32776960730552673,
0.14390325546264648,
0.39267033338546753,
-0.37783175706863403,
-0.05234964191913605,
0.1055913120508194,
0.2099197953939438,
1.066972255706787,
-0.40545031428337097,
0.28092893958091736,
-0.05915992334485054,
-0.19056639075279236,
-0.18780195713043213,
-0.6209850907325745,
-0.9636937379837036,
-0.4612968862056732,
-0.22973664104938507,
-0.29477202892303467,
0.10814579576253891,
1.2083426713943481,
0.13479410111904144,
-0.9783035516738892,
-0.33869466185569763,
0.06892886757850647,
0.1488814502954483,
-0.11223585903644562,
-0.1814354658126831,
0.6553493738174438,
-0.24668093025684357,
-0.5561539530754089,
0.20798736810684204,
0.007874834351241589,
0.003121563931927085,
-0.11427365243434906,
0.11493383347988129,
-0.1295507699251175,
0.2763124406337738,
0.8644854426383972,
0.35156843066215515,
-0.3631129264831543,
0.104824960231781,
-0.11993268132209778,
-0.11714165657758713,
0.040093399584293365,
0.6650553345680237,
-0.8872427940368652,
-0.08914564549922943,
0.28181931376457214,
0.9249730706214905,
0.1162136122584343,
0.03210079297423363,
0.3825269341468811,
-1.0102448463439941,
0.003783277003094554,
0.6754742860794067,
0.2994222640991211,
0.3119225800037384,
0.00560565572232008,
0.33973488211631775,
-0.1543172001838684,
-0.33265525102615356,
-0.6458640694618225,
0.2785586714744568,
-0.692026674747467,
-0.5310044884681702,
1.025646448135376,
0.17061495780944824,
-0.01768362708389759,
-0.28952130675315857,
-0.6054508686065674,
0.23260821402072906,
-0.6489571928977966,
1.2732435464859009,
0.9188848733901978,
-0.10764180123806,
-0.0053753540851175785,
0.019500527530908585,
0.6019597053527832,
0.6985610127449036,
-0.8542994260787964,
-0.4491712152957916,
0.47766268253326416,
-0.18431150913238525,
0.023944741114974022,
0.5946955680847168,
-0.08369860053062439,
0.15323352813720703,
-0.32149985432624817,
-0.03573281690478325,
0.3125408887863159,
-0.5602414608001709,
-0.48348185420036316,
0.5953259468078613,
0.45862093567848206,
-0.12046699970960617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07553v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07553v1
|
Inference Acceleration for Large Language Models on CPUs
| 2024-03-04T10:27:23 | 2024-03-04T10:27:23 |
Ditto PS, Jithin VG, Adarsh MS
|
cs.DC
|
cs.DC, cs.CL
|
In recent years, large language models have demonstrated remarkable
performance across various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However,
deploying these models for real-world applications often requires efficient
inference solutions to handle the computational demands. In this paper, we
explore the utilization of CPUs for accelerating the inference of large
language models. Specifically, we introduce a parallelized approach to enhance
throughput by 1) Exploiting the parallel processing capabilities of modern CPU
architectures, 2) Batching the inference request. Our evaluation shows the
accelerated inference engine gives an 18-22x improvement in the generated token
per sec. The improvement is more with longer sequence and larger models. In
addition to this, we can also run multiple workers in the same machine with
NUMA node isolation to further improvement in tokens/s. Table 2, we have
received 4x additional improvement with 4 workers. This would also make Gen-AI
based products and companies environment friendly, our estimates shows that CPU
usage for Inference could reduce the power consumption of LLMs by 48.9% while
providing production ready throughput and latency.
|
[
-0.43652233481407166,
-0.9639700651168823,
0.6393733024597168,
0.4714518189430237,
-0.11666066944599152,
-0.07512830942869186,
-0.5251894593238831,
-0.6669743657112122,
-0.013514816761016846,
0.7886265516281128,
-0.4009048342704773,
-0.1663358509540558,
-0.5939972996711731,
0.1646863967180252,
-0.14733438193798065,
0.3939676880836487,
0.336810827255249,
0.18645386397838593,
-0.3694509267807007,
0.14718888700008392,
-0.3220234215259552,
-0.4348819851875305,
-1.0322911739349365,
-0.38224488496780396,
0.1944710910320282,
0.26646724343299866,
0.6442621350288391,
0.9341811537742615,
0.34914669394493103,
0.45407649874687195,
-0.048455528914928436,
0.2726757228374481,
-0.17231619358062744,
0.4486236572265625,
-0.024078812450170517,
-0.5352809429168701,
-0.5743082761764526,
-0.27246129512786865,
0.7409025430679321,
0.8793122172355652,
0.09950505197048187,
0.2580130994319916,
-0.08583099395036697,
0.7400479912757874,
-0.859714150428772,
0.23495006561279297,
-0.5548605918884277,
0.06606391072273254,
-0.2352352887392044,
0.14076043665409088,
-0.6778845191001892,
-0.09437233209609985,
-0.1602584719657898,
-0.5946054458618164,
0.051220137625932693,
0.33582842350006104,
0.3677484095096588,
0.418600469827652,
0.054239556193351746,
0.17159788310527802,
-0.6605549454689026,
1.2025833129882812,
-1.125909447669983,
0.48523393273353577,
0.08203604817390442,
0.24496686458587646,
-0.29226288199424744,
-1.1245520114898682,
-0.4860791265964508,
-0.12235625833272934,
0.0470033660531044,
-0.1753409057855606,
-0.17295755445957184,
0.20631510019302368,
0.7583982944488525,
0.3168924152851105,
-0.2907237410545349,
0.5752370357513428,
0.017854303121566772,
0.08036882430315018,
0.45894497632980347,
0.11588720232248306,
0.14943790435791016,
0.11758994311094284,
-0.20266185700893402,
-0.05582839250564575,
-0.5131803154945374,
-0.16605420410633087,
0.1982349306344986,
0.4432492256164551,
0.1280476450920105,
0.41131025552749634,
-0.477291464805603,
0.7074894309043884,
-0.12506452202796936,
-0.06291098892688751,
0.36737188696861267,
-0.2555771470069885,
-0.645384669303894,
0.11422927677631378,
0.6608240008354187,
0.17449216544628143,
0.3756617307662964,
-0.25452128052711487,
0.021210893988609314,
0.027074158191680908,
0.10967027395963669,
-1.2731717824935913,
0.11762364208698273,
0.4366826117038727,
-0.38652417063713074,
0.08823181688785553,
-0.07698697596788406,
-1.1009126901626587,
-0.4760492146015167,
-0.277802973985672,
-0.13621005415916443,
-0.07016526907682419,
-0.2676859498023987,
0.28361746668815613,
-0.4200771152973175,
0.19062748551368713,
0.20570339262485504,
-1.000301480293274,
0.5172659158706665,
0.9977918267250061,
0.7566848397254944,
-0.15754935145378113,
-0.09601373225450516,
-0.9115638732910156,
-0.03916092962026596,
-0.32044076919555664,
0.7683928608894348,
-0.6195380687713623,
-0.1307384967803955,
-0.2505201995372772,
-0.014156283810734749,
-0.15767928957939148,
-0.668682336807251,
0.6040810346603394,
-0.5982212424278259,
-0.10073801130056381,
-0.10904243588447571,
-0.6658639907836914,
-0.09498388320207596,
-0.004207335878163576,
-0.7561779618263245,
1.089377522468567,
-0.40281790494918823,
-0.7511562705039978,
-0.014508578926324844,
-0.7646397948265076,
-0.5086246728897095,
0.03340018913149834,
-0.026429353281855583,
-0.36556413769721985,
0.30044227838516235,
0.6697030067443848,
0.46469807624816895,
-0.754340410232544,
0.4308801293373108,
-0.4940459728240967,
-0.47893011569976807,
-0.04393761605024338,
-0.5368238687515259,
0.9888002872467041,
0.26934516429901123,
-0.5233101844787598,
0.17356336116790771,
-0.6500654816627502,
0.12878179550170898,
-0.14542600512504578,
-0.08540782332420349,
-0.27885571122169495,
0.1958380490541458,
-0.3234637677669525,
-0.04153290018439293,
0.22347140312194824,
-0.6585959792137146,
0.05041138082742691,
-0.49498409032821655,
0.33013468980789185,
0.6372858285903931,
-0.08113151043653488,
0.5513756275177002,
0.07598578929901123,
0.6115191578865051,
-0.27286359667778015,
0.06437204033136368,
-0.31280049681663513,
-0.7407689094543457,
-0.687231183052063,
-0.6351602673530579,
0.29033321142196655,
0.6084535121917725,
-0.6593982577323914,
0.37940555810928345,
-0.28336504101753235,
-0.35033634305000305,
-0.643452525138855,
0.0987628921866417,
0.4688270390033722,
0.5131036043167114,
0.2201734483242035,
-0.11168365180492401,
-0.6143321990966797,
-0.9381664395332336,
-0.48641687631607056,
0.05968958139419556,
-0.4659331440925598,
0.24713806807994843,
0.17553389072418213,
-0.029328422620892525,
0.6774942874908447,
-0.37868255376815796,
0.4743858873844147,
-0.2656722664833069,
0.19405953586101532,
0.568030595779419,
0.6120136380195618,
0.4435384273529053,
-0.6260979175567627,
-0.3499283492565155,
0.09664876013994217,
-0.8543238043785095,
-0.43498849868774414,
0.010007372125983238,
-0.3186093866825104,
0.1613362580537796,
0.8614680171012878,
-0.6409373879432678,
0.13716457784175873,
0.5812524557113647,
-0.0201627928763628,
0.6576166152954102,
-0.17038151621818542,
0.09169545769691467,
-0.8465287685394287,
0.08533613383769989,
-0.15499286353588104,
-0.36774107813835144,
-0.6470975279808044,
0.33028465509414673,
-0.10290998220443726,
-0.019636500626802444,
-0.4440362751483917,
0.5987644195556641,
-0.6754127740859985,
-0.45811575651168823,
-0.419784814119339,
-0.04612259939312935,
0.2027527540922165,
0.2816501259803772,
0.053258832544088364,
1.0595420598983765,
0.8137421011924744,
-0.5857533812522888,
0.2369685173034668,
-0.23700441420078278,
-0.35496509075164795,
0.17196577787399292,
-0.5412371754646301,
0.23727519810199738,
0.023079169914126396,
0.39974722266197205,
-0.6699684262275696,
-0.06495983898639679,
-0.1258946806192398,
-0.16660885512828827,
0.07422386109828949,
0.15615899860858917,
-0.7001253366470337,
-0.530827522277832,
-0.29777970910072327,
0.19750866293907166,
0.5581615567207336,
-0.7270153164863586,
0.842284083366394,
0.2945907711982727,
-0.18757158517837524,
-0.7037215828895569,
-0.7929219603538513,
0.13248999416828156,
-0.16782166063785553,
-0.7003686428070068,
0.158107727766037,
0.0388370156288147,
-0.6744591593742371,
-0.22528193891048431,
0.1581961214542389,
-0.035960838198661804,
0.3577367663383484,
0.3554612100124359,
0.023742567747831345,
-0.6746785640716553,
0.17689771950244904,
0.05650714784860611,
-0.04165779799222946,
0.2500757873058319,
-0.5108494758605957,
0.5709546208381653,
-0.0820394903421402,
-0.2807462513446808,
-0.7961911559104919,
0.34519708156585693,
0.6813849210739136,
-0.2045433074235916,
0.879028856754303,
0.5373694896697998,
-0.3834806978702545,
-0.25938889384269714,
-0.789081871509552,
-0.31158459186553955,
-0.48767831921577454,
0.3187703788280487,
-0.31923332810401917,
-0.759996771812439,
0.4743010699748993,
-0.5010642409324646,
0.21434922516345978,
0.542077898979187,
0.7592936754226685,
0.300733745098114,
1.1078860759735107,
0.39372768998146057,
-0.3153843879699707,
0.6018653512001038,
-0.16377776861190796,
0.26857954263687134,
-0.7908399701118469,
0.2132813185453415,
-0.8095963597297668,
-0.2663790285587311,
-0.6147811412811279,
-0.856665313243866,
-0.002263562986627221,
0.10656330734491348,
-0.37137919664382935,
0.07711626589298248,
-0.2575269341468811,
0.5637782216072083,
0.7608508467674255,
0.011177102103829384,
0.5332611799240112,
0.10021652281284332,
-0.0102522112429142,
0.22300772368907928,
-0.6594834327697754,
-0.3522959351539612,
0.9380707740783691,
0.2575024664402008,
0.44172483682632446,
-0.22689330577850342,
0.2814769148826599,
0.21512329578399658,
0.46533486247062683,
-0.41245928406715393,
0.6410814523696899,
-0.37494227290153503,
-0.560093343257904,
-0.21834003925323486,
-0.4449536204338074,
-0.6545497179031372,
0.4064300060272217,
-0.218556210398674,
-0.9138365387916565,
0.08433311432600021,
0.09639576822519302,
-0.2873518168926239,
0.4941987991333008,
-0.911242663860321,
0.8549555540084839,
-0.10500970482826233,
-0.6164658069610596,
-0.6001216173171997,
-0.39097630977630615,
0.4966890811920166,
-0.09421522170305252,
0.20641463994979858,
-0.23054808378219604,
0.12083390355110168,
0.5194736123085022,
-0.6289265751838684,
0.8217779994010925,
-0.24206393957138062,
0.27383366227149963,
0.28772425651550293,
-0.402420312166214,
0.6582304239273071,
-0.07796625047922134,
-0.9495847225189209,
0.26453858613967896,
-0.6665346622467041,
-0.5332976579666138,
-0.6482751369476318,
0.7571642994880676,
-0.23419705033302307,
-0.748253583908081,
0.02197464182972908,
-0.8600636720657349,
-0.2632666230201721,
0.2864568829536438,
-0.11318068951368332,
0.28336983919143677,
0.05064587667584419,
0.31137728691101074,
0.34124258160591125,
-0.3324529826641083,
0.6750975847244263,
0.2765692472457886,
-0.19599412381649017,
-0.11411987245082855,
0.5144879817962646,
-0.14422565698623657,
0.5005695819854736,
0.26118648052215576,
0.35958701372146606,
-0.2772577404975891,
-0.6796385645866394,
-0.7235143780708313,
0.11249639838933945,
-0.3352002799510956,
-0.10408371686935425,
-0.8551740050315857,
0.0721893236041069,
-0.6292337775230408,
-0.19475801289081573,
-0.46382346749305725,
-0.5700209140777588,
-0.18438473343849182,
-0.059847768396139145,
0.4633193016052246,
0.43038102984428406,
0.12130783498287201,
0.6191291809082031,
-0.4911826550960541,
0.4142135977745056,
0.2509758174419403,
0.1969219446182251,
0.3023589253425598,
-0.41474831104278564,
-0.27922889590263367,
-0.058128904551267624,
-0.12288155406713486,
-0.34468045830726624,
0.4176892638206482,
0.22431977093219757,
0.48182472586631775,
0.505216121673584,
0.10826330631971359,
0.9621257185935974,
-0.499000608921051,
0.6426646709442139,
-0.10390976816415787,
-0.8708574771881104,
0.04780606925487518,
-0.10891027748584747,
0.5456591248512268,
0.41685816645622253,
0.16443878412246704,
-0.10725820809602737,
-0.5503993630409241,
-0.5683860778808594,
-0.881637454032898,
0.4943560063838959,
0.020237896591424942,
0.09157058596611023,
-0.08409558981657028,
0.3883683979511261,
-0.07706373184919357,
0.2898247241973877,
-0.16870896518230438,
-0.1424093246459961,
0.37731191515922546,
0.0717943087220192,
-0.010273945517838001,
-0.03886435925960541,
0.30788812041282654,
-0.4035254716873169,
0.9018745422363281,
-0.19947122037410736,
0.10347721725702286,
-0.03709561005234718,
-0.04140065237879753,
0.10641413927078247,
0.07323691248893738,
0.281218558549881,
0.6483475565910339,
-0.15312959253787994,
0.20835255086421967,
0.3179461359977722,
-0.317471981048584,
-0.35219666361808777,
0.292527437210083,
0.053773872554302216,
-0.09706055372953415,
0.2571825087070465,
1.0821638107299805,
0.06364957988262177,
-0.9194457530975342,
0.1484949290752411,
-0.23295146226882935,
0.2412538230419159,
-0.020434562116861343,
0.12562556564807892,
0.48972582817077637,
0.579696536064148,
0.2570716142654419,
-0.06954612582921982,
0.2251083254814148,
-0.3067193031311035,
0.18683961033821106,
0.5905429720878601,
0.0961257666349411,
0.03853950276970863,
0.8827119469642639,
0.14776857197284698,
-0.4052059054374695,
0.7935436367988586,
-0.1427927017211914,
-0.3999478816986084,
0.9871870279312134,
0.745136022567749,
1.0364762544631958,
-0.14270390570163727,
-0.3344891667366028,
0.4505033493041992,
0.15140531957149506,
-0.3841626048088074,
0.03605710342526436,
-0.08918745070695877,
-0.6487336158752441,
-1.0762231349945068,
-0.9513481259346008,
-0.6462023854255676,
-0.12002149969339371,
-0.44306159019470215,
-0.07012063264846802,
-0.4013546109199524,
-0.14786605536937714,
0.4013144373893738,
-0.02471369318664074,
-0.48338887095451355,
0.09490987658500671,
0.3706313669681549,
0.993539571762085,
-0.9053035378456116,
0.9936360120773315,
0.33511218428611755,
0.2329140603542328,
-0.5543373823165894,
-0.2341366857290268,
-0.2986827790737152,
-0.747195839881897,
0.6255646347999573,
0.4537821412086487,
-0.27467548847198486,
0.17060880362987518,
-0.37017422914505005,
-0.5680338144302368,
0.7738597393035889,
0.7266724705696106,
-0.6407507658004761,
0.23386438190937042,
0.13310350477695465,
0.6369228363037109,
-0.6045929193496704,
0.5020908117294312,
0.7872462272644043,
0.6825968623161316,
-0.25948789715766907,
-0.7064153552055359,
0.05284494161605835,
-0.1897406131029129,
0.07868285477161407,
0.19250930845737457,
-0.1607985943555832,
0.9138956069946289,
-0.1259920597076416,
0.0028946937527507544,
0.11753669381141663,
0.9899774193763733,
0.4723361134529114,
0.366508424282074,
0.6418607831001282,
0.6856837272644043,
0.936163604259491,
0.1900191605091095,
1.495337724685669,
-0.3788580000400543,
0.08188100159168243,
1.1645969152450562,
-0.3317168951034546,
0.9708073139190674,
0.5830467343330383,
-0.20696811378002167,
0.48643118143081665,
0.37599435448646545,
0.13776816427707672,
-0.07915918529033661,
0.27308839559555054,
-0.49168336391448975,
-0.3717101514339447,
-0.4597522020339966,
-0.11720801144838333,
0.19173233211040497,
0.40066224336624146,
-0.5440183877944946,
-0.13166724145412445,
-0.05314105749130249,
0.2081775814294815,
-0.032302748411893845,
-0.48426419496536255,
0.4347769320011139,
0.06798457354307175,
-0.9443957805633545,
0.42787620425224304,
0.09555242210626602,
0.6337804794311523,
-0.24372638761997223,
-0.09089990705251694,
-0.03533241152763367,
0.34745997190475464,
-0.04609894007444382,
-0.24639323353767395,
0.29199302196502686,
0.16197603940963745,
-0.3481881022453308,
-0.3880043625831604,
0.6598988771438599,
-0.09778142720460892,
-0.8511081337928772,
0.47313785552978516,
0.36873719096183777,
0.3838314116001129,
-0.4607217609882355,
-0.4895009994506836,
0.14847621321678162,
-0.10906334966421127,
-0.5040967464447021,
0.3805273771286011,
0.23474158346652985,
-0.33899298310279846,
0.5555331110954285,
0.8797669410705566,
0.15681025385856628,
0.44560253620147705,
0.2332019954919815,
0.817008912563324,
-0.3528083264827728,
-0.3516894280910492,
-1.0994420051574707,
0.23488032817840576,
-0.34296905994415283,
0.010220936499536037,
0.7625580430030823,
0.6289069652557373,
0.40581750869750977,
0.03406428545713425,
0.5317999720573425,
0.08352020382881165,
0.36685359477996826,
-0.5601306557655334,
0.36453548073768616,
-0.3145756721496582,
0.2958691120147705,
0.03404079005122185,
-0.8703274130821228,
-0.4215744733810425,
0.23161174356937408,
-0.45687997341156006,
-0.168503537774086,
0.5581449866294861,
0.828606128692627,
-0.060841239988803864,
0.21728597581386566,
0.13508273661136627,
0.5079430341720581,
0.23788754642009735,
0.2161562591791153,
0.08807961642742157,
-0.2161320596933365,
0.028431756421923637,
-0.4474778473377228,
-0.21446970105171204,
-0.06309504061937332,
-1.2330909967422485,
-0.649800181388855,
0.10928046703338623,
-0.22073660790920258,
-0.13250288367271423,
0.22327302396297455,
0.740129828453064,
0.7150179743766785,
-0.8740484118461609,
-0.4450015425682068,
-0.35291364789009094,
0.18800994753837585,
-0.6484650373458862,
-0.20245327055454254,
0.3688557744026184,
-0.5688740611076355,
-1.197047472000122,
0.7496626973152161,
0.23365017771720886,
-0.633513867855072,
-0.248571515083313,
0.10806305706501007,
-0.3831149935722351,
0.1373053938150406,
0.6269046664237976,
0.38968926668167114,
-0.5492450594902039,
-0.04240601509809494,
-0.10040389746427536,
0.16595637798309326,
0.10740473121404648,
0.9029703140258789,
-1.0021964311599731,
0.513938844203949,
0.7605536580085754,
1.2138562202453613,
0.7827950716018677,
0.3055346608161926,
0.8283790349960327,
-0.6835089921951294,
0.6086186766624451,
0.13991643488407135,
0.42424649000167847,
0.2747742235660553,
-0.31822147965431213,
0.3302363157272339,
0.21379445493221283,
-0.5787879228591919,
-0.8888373970985413,
0.0677054151892662,
-0.7375354170799255,
-0.3822805881500244,
0.9013383984565735,
-0.23211438953876495,
-0.5714229345321655,
-0.0022079702466726303,
0.19071684777736664,
0.43690600991249084,
-0.4305029511451721,
0.3635701537132263,
0.3575997054576874,
-0.3404195308685303,
-0.03697432950139046,
-1.1359460353851318,
0.10100628435611725,
0.7556426525115967,
-1.0166417360305786,
0.3800855278968811,
0.37747785449028015,
-0.14914491772651672,
0.12695194780826569,
0.5314294695854187,
0.04691594839096069,
-0.00040757269016467035,
0.13102412223815918,
0.30573877692222595,
-0.006396007724106312,
-0.1407080441713333,
-0.34531885385513306,
0.38716185092926025,
-0.0363038145005703,
-0.2549004852771759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04791v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04791v1
|
LLM vs. Lawyers: Identifying a Subset of Summary Judgments in a Large UK Case Law Dataset
| 2024-03-04T10:13:30 | 2024-03-04T10:13:30 |
Ahmed Izzidien, Holli Sargeant, Felix Steffek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
To undertake computational research of the law, efficiently identifying
datasets of court decisions that relate to a specific legal issue is a crucial
yet challenging endeavour. This study addresses the gap in the literature
working with large legal corpora about how to isolate cases, in our case
summary judgments, from a large corpus of UK court decisions. We introduce a
comparative analysis of two computational methods: (1) a traditional natural
language processing-based approach leveraging expert-generated keywords and
logical operators and (2) an innovative application of the Claude 2 large
language model to classify cases based on content-specific prompts. We use the
Cambridge Law Corpus of 356,011 UK court decisions and determine that the large
language model achieves a weighted F1 score of 0.94 versus 0.78 for keywords.
Despite iterative refinement, the search logic based on keywords fails to
capture nuances in legal language. We identify and extract 3,102 summary
judgment cases, enabling us to map their distribution across various UK courts
over a temporal span. The paper marks a pioneering step in employing advanced
natural language processing to tackle core legal research tasks, demonstrating
how these technologies can bridge systemic gaps and enhance the accessibility
of legal information. We share the extracted dataset metrics to support further
research on summary judgments.
|
[
-0.36314037442207336,
-0.5436255931854248,
0.9046760201454163,
-0.23449087142944336,
-0.43106263875961304,
0.1760455071926117,
-0.21504619717597961,
-0.4711882770061493,
0.1907958835363388,
0.6588318943977356,
-0.1339331567287445,
-0.5082255005836487,
-0.6875969171524048,
0.1686895489692688,
-0.7210338711738586,
0.7678592205047607,
0.24828265607357025,
0.376434862613678,
-0.3422864079475403,
-0.25178882479667664,
-0.26651638746261597,
-0.6214767694473267,
-0.5597243309020996,
-0.10678263753652573,
0.3969323933124542,
0.14948202669620514,
0.6785275936126709,
0.4296652674674988,
0.667228102684021,
0.3677040934562683,
-0.3970651924610138,
0.008117474615573883,
-0.298138827085495,
-0.035705965012311935,
-0.21464374661445618,
-0.5905569791793823,
-0.3116005063056946,
-0.054190896451473236,
0.22518397867679596,
0.5679101347923279,
-0.3249332904815674,
-0.01900210604071617,
-0.3310530185699463,
1.1246241331100464,
-0.7818531394004822,
0.15419936180114746,
-0.5250532627105713,
0.5031628012657166,
-0.18795280158519745,
-0.11991041153669357,
-0.4820237457752228,
-0.2971550226211548,
-0.012658215127885342,
-0.4776530861854553,
0.4305099546909332,
0.21458756923675537,
0.6192867159843445,
0.11317548900842667,
-0.5381678938865662,
-0.642116904258728,
-0.4099036157131195,
0.6126251816749573,
-0.7289850115776062,
0.34234023094177246,
0.2569507658481598,
0.5393238067626953,
-0.08412390947341919,
-0.7400235533714294,
-0.3793692886829376,
-0.4514625072479248,
-0.20264677703380585,
0.3993484377861023,
-0.412257581949234,
0.13645917177200317,
0.2718071937561035,
0.12782856822013855,
-0.5637699961662292,
0.2413967102766037,
-0.8949406743049622,
-0.4780557155609131,
0.8271405100822449,
-0.007139264140278101,
0.13333436846733093,
-0.3847268521785736,
0.20763278007507324,
0.20315349102020264,
-0.7700376510620117,
0.09843151271343231,
0.5587021708488464,
0.4177165627479553,
-0.18569765985012054,
0.7984340786933899,
-0.11419552564620972,
0.7053424119949341,
-0.05274725332856178,
-0.43183186650276184,
0.057627540081739426,
-0.2824608385562897,
-0.2387961894273758,
0.3076029121875763,
1.013710856437683,
0.46702250838279724,
0.5121813416481018,
-0.12468944489955902,
-0.2480734884738922,
-0.26050683856010437,
0.2357630431652069,
-0.5079526305198669,
0.0012607035459950566,
0.2727145552635193,
-0.585797131061554,
-0.12368529289960861,
0.3264138400554657,
-0.4765688180923462,
-0.878218412399292,
-0.6312159895896912,
-0.1826017200946808,
-0.03040855936706066,
0.0037201722152531147,
0.15546342730522156,
-0.3297610878944397,
0.3501386046409607,
0.5246757864952087,
-0.5220414400100708,
0.4993976354598999,
0.874750018119812,
0.5958602428436279,
0.046214066445827484,
0.45367637276649475,
-0.5489819645881653,
-0.061340730637311935,
-0.43749889731407166,
0.6932349801063538,
-0.6776379942893982,
-0.5183483362197876,
0.3152172565460205,
-0.0009982716292142868,
0.22240737080574036,
-0.8348551988601685,
0.7811356782913208,
-0.7825937271118164,
0.2834392189979553,
-0.3229421377182007,
-0.5804831981658936,
-0.1863817721605301,
0.06977368146181107,
-0.7631032466888428,
0.4687590003013611,
-0.056197863072156906,
-0.8755149245262146,
0.7369629740715027,
-0.5144021511077881,
-0.771297812461853,
0.10398885607719421,
-0.737364649772644,
-0.33867737650871277,
0.347412645816803,
0.08708727359771729,
0.474422812461853,
-0.5314799547195435,
0.39761799573898315,
-0.3292618989944458,
-0.31810423731803894,
0.15860910713672638,
-0.006103260442614555,
0.7048054933547974,
0.3273968994617462,
-0.043614789843559265,
0.033101171255111694,
-0.5724115371704102,
-0.4182450473308563,
0.057761162519454956,
-0.27748340368270874,
-0.23245149850845337,
0.3468259871006012,
0.019259657710790634,
0.26316648721694946,
0.05679246410727501,
-0.3198471963405609,
0.1544744372367859,
-0.2615952789783478,
0.5627267360687256,
0.47685807943344116,
-0.06313704699277878,
0.38138797879219055,
-0.13262178003787994,
0.6637814044952393,
-0.1275743693113327,
-0.15099215507507324,
0.16404488682746887,
-0.39882150292396545,
-0.39503395557403564,
-0.2767717242240906,
0.7052528262138367,
0.6535168290138245,
-0.39473119378089905,
0.24781709909439087,
-0.4655993580818176,
-0.05923071131110191,
-0.6960502862930298,
0.14725574851036072,
0.13382607698440552,
0.3464302718639374,
0.141716867685318,
-0.2038135528564453,
-0.7200372815132141,
-1.3173508644104004,
-0.37740713357925415,
-0.24569071829319,
-0.04640588536858559,
0.5099838376045227,
0.4981077015399933,
0.05030716210603714,
1.1205744743347168,
-0.23181718587875366,
-0.18547676503658295,
-0.434003621339798,
-0.022989269345998764,
0.5674005746841431,
-0.16428729891777039,
0.5065197348594666,
-1.0754019021987915,
-0.2644457221031189,
0.17701831459999084,
-0.9508163332939148,
-0.16480983793735504,
-0.16092942655086517,
0.17011193931102753,
0.052768342196941376,
0.8255851864814758,
-0.3820488452911377,
0.4817825257778168,
-0.3454206585884094,
-0.44590237736701965,
0.5307803750038147,
-0.12324456870555878,
0.37294867634773254,
-0.7305973768234253,
-0.15985596179962158,
0.00599572854116559,
-0.596336841583252,
-0.38291051983833313,
0.11895056068897247,
0.15847858786582947,
0.335628479719162,
-0.7119930982589722,
0.1759994775056839,
-0.5557599067687988,
-0.40355443954467773,
-0.3370943069458008,
0.5004838705062866,
-0.10445471107959747,
0.03288464993238449,
-0.09338486939668655,
0.8141550421714783,
0.30327123403549194,
-0.6115114092826843,
0.28122907876968384,
0.13053740561008453,
-0.36770251393318176,
0.5443326234817505,
-0.3564758598804474,
-0.03379771113395691,
-0.24178187549114227,
0.0029758885502815247,
-0.7584578394889832,
-0.3077464699745178,
0.019379915669560432,
-0.1806478351354599,
0.41317513585090637,
-0.37131381034851074,
-0.7726898193359375,
-0.48840034008026123,
-0.424736350774765,
0.19604498147964478,
0.534950852394104,
-0.0012939843581989408,
0.685402512550354,
0.7030407786369324,
-0.3885118365287781,
-0.5739117860794067,
-0.5911626815795898,
0.31698116660118103,
-0.40817737579345703,
-0.27290070056915283,
0.19154179096221924,
0.13531048595905304,
-0.8898071646690369,
0.022881969809532166,
-0.13208375871181488,
-0.11248162388801575,
0.11688119173049927,
0.3542206287384033,
0.022815842181444168,
-0.05543484538793564,
-0.015968263149261475,
0.15250509977340698,
0.08887996524572372,
0.4707554876804352,
0.0827280730009079,
0.3400563597679138,
0.15727688372135162,
-0.4658244550228119,
-0.19796735048294067,
0.4071201682090759,
0.6551021337509155,
0.1226288452744484,
0.17954283952713013,
-0.004217301495373249,
-0.18660126626491547,
-0.03207878768444061,
-0.6554133892059326,
0.2952951490879059,
-0.4085596203804016,
0.2704518139362335,
-0.38164225220680237,
-0.9725197553634644,
0.35674044489860535,
0.10613010078668594,
0.2317517250776291,
0.8170565366744995,
0.6760922074317932,
-0.174295112490654,
0.4133337736129761,
0.5685742497444153,
-0.5008076429367065,
0.2558932900428772,
-0.0008970199851319194,
0.40624213218688965,
-0.42317095398902893,
-0.014127373695373535,
-0.46897441148757935,
-0.037976302206516266,
-0.4313603937625885,
-0.16526007652282715,
0.4222686290740967,
0.14815767109394073,
0.06124427542090416,
0.23188592493534088,
-0.09862728416919708,
0.632551908493042,
0.510334312915802,
0.1945890486240387,
0.399434357881546,
0.016742518171668053,
-0.3876548111438751,
0.23497019708156586,
-0.4594178795814514,
-0.5329042077064514,
1.2598482370376587,
-0.09451407194137573,
0.08637349307537079,
0.3548770248889923,
0.6399819850921631,
0.9124349355697632,
0.16010838747024536,
-1.0277107954025269,
0.8100144267082214,
-0.27368858456611633,
-0.44256705045700073,
0.18605642020702362,
-0.5027824640274048,
-0.9553084373474121,
0.33569157123565674,
-0.3162389099597931,
-0.6061502695083618,
-0.03645577281713486,
-0.3799440264701843,
-0.5424407124519348,
0.10109654068946838,
-0.4500926733016968,
0.40941035747528076,
-0.11043404042720795,
-0.673493504524231,
-0.43436184525489807,
-0.6872369647026062,
0.47697293758392334,
-0.3171071708202362,
0.8009539246559143,
-0.07672944664955139,
0.11233926564455032,
0.8351611495018005,
-0.6634619832038879,
0.5617449283599854,
0.00869129877537489,
-0.09477837383747101,
0.6184970736503601,
0.00008931682532420382,
0.25498539209365845,
0.008421598002314568,
-0.021793385967612267,
-0.24755452573299408,
0.12546849250793457,
-0.2533119022846222,
-0.6050557494163513,
0.28504109382629395,
-0.4458227753639221,
-0.5841951966285706,
-0.5602594017982483,
-0.34704461693763733,
-0.04245949536561966,
0.07751473784446716,
0.09696661680936813,
0.3352031707763672,
0.012173881754279137,
0.13656176626682281,
0.26830577850341797,
-0.15029394626617432,
0.7084081768989563,
0.9825562238693237,
-0.11967790126800537,
-0.5498179793357849,
0.5893124938011169,
0.27639079093933105,
-0.20127563178539276,
0.5556127429008484,
0.15851373970508575,
-0.48759108781814575,
-0.8312761783599854,
-0.18032731115818024,
0.2431659996509552,
-0.8546728491783142,
-0.1627858281135559,
-0.3720317482948303,
-0.02600337751209736,
-0.5427126288414001,
-0.2093491405248642,
-0.05965342000126839,
-0.5140807628631592,
-0.016231711953878403,
-0.2568643391132355,
0.2756115794181824,
0.9383675456047058,
0.11481594294309616,
0.04353012517094612,
-0.6183076500892639,
0.5018234252929688,
0.11120494455099106,
0.03475843742489815,
-0.5064144730567932,
-0.7112765312194824,
-0.06612896919250488,
-0.36849066615104675,
0.05569670349359512,
-0.7958967089653015,
0.2724664509296417,
-0.11430291831493378,
0.5427700877189636,
0.7163428068161011,
0.06524641811847687,
0.741171658039093,
-0.7157581448554993,
0.7579677700996399,
0.22971683740615845,
-0.5715793371200562,
0.4901297688484192,
-0.24532660841941833,
-0.056927602738142014,
0.9481737017631531,
0.3053268492221832,
-0.2188645601272583,
-0.18677400052547455,
-0.5773012042045593,
-1.0866838693618774,
0.42022866010665894,
0.2164342701435089,
-0.13779449462890625,
0.1651107221841812,
0.630405843257904,
0.05727517232298851,
0.4706268906593323,
-0.4497467279434204,
-0.05277658998966217,
0.5968849062919617,
-0.18143247067928314,
-0.028736265376210213,
-0.2387859970331192,
-0.1494428813457489,
-0.4778249263763428,
0.4526250660419464,
0.03584713488817215,
0.07606629282236099,
0.17800959944725037,
-0.4819585084915161,
0.41667985916137695,
0.354764461517334,
0.4534669518470764,
0.7039414048194885,
-0.10907729715108871,
0.018239587545394897,
0.13782860338687897,
-0.5070970058441162,
0.042390696704387665,
0.11655502766370773,
-0.202044278383255,
0.13104471564292908,
0.7345724105834961,
0.2266775667667389,
0.17078359425067902,
-0.9966779947280884,
0.7103173732757568,
-0.21942506730556488,
-0.5466213822364807,
-0.6117304563522339,
-0.11520615220069885,
-0.06263970583677292,
0.43405434489250183,
0.2767741084098816,
-0.10657300055027008,
0.6895090937614441,
-0.5812855362892151,
0.5098294019699097,
0.3388557434082031,
-0.22964513301849365,
0.1572105586528778,
0.4834584593772888,
-0.015611665323376656,
-0.14117100834846497,
0.3906862437725067,
-0.2960672080516815,
-0.2825429141521454,
0.6937728524208069,
-0.04916355386376381,
0.8634558320045471,
0.533540666103363,
-0.08832628279924393,
0.037869758903980255,
0.1011289581656456,
-0.3917562961578369,
0.2354225218296051,
-0.4404517114162445,
-0.3798637390136719,
-0.4528835117816925,
-0.5593468546867371,
-0.4623239040374756,
-0.20874127745628357,
-0.7612084150314331,
0.2057264745235443,
-0.4803115129470825,
-0.16432307660579681,
0.03458165377378464,
-0.010267104022204876,
-0.7179035544395447,
0.03101680800318718,
0.28036919236183167,
0.8415936827659607,
-0.7071632146835327,
0.5553368926048279,
0.4845804274082184,
-0.29285097122192383,
-0.3959135413169861,
-0.12518736720085144,
0.4772659242153168,
-0.5332373380661011,
0.5319199562072754,
0.12560425698757172,
-0.13631536066532135,
-0.5977697968482971,
-0.5279579162597656,
-0.3005383014678955,
0.9634539484977722,
0.3201897144317627,
-0.9216614961624146,
0.1888243407011032,
0.25640538334846497,
0.5436490178108215,
-0.14330299198627472,
0.6090284585952759,
0.8652730584144592,
0.35537615418434143,
0.2970433831214905,
-0.8027920722961426,
-0.04500240832567215,
-0.4695066213607788,
-0.4374120533466339,
0.14501139521598816,
-0.36022257804870605,
0.36405491828918457,
-0.22911322116851807,
-0.2431681603193283,
-0.22849127650260925,
0.6467635631561279,
0.2521396279335022,
0.43514782190322876,
0.383126437664032,
0.41831111907958984,
1.0878877639770508,
-0.20422782003879547,
1.27048921585083,
-0.4906109869480133,
0.2723505198955536,
1.0336277484893799,
-0.3871592879295349,
0.9069464206695557,
0.449127197265625,
-0.6888230443000793,
0.18789726495742798,
0.6585510969161987,
-0.06166259944438934,
0.43994343280792236,
0.5964215397834778,
-0.2910606861114502,
-0.24795426428318024,
-0.04351349174976349,
-0.045059189200401306,
0.3109975755214691,
0.24639342725276947,
-0.5374926924705505,
-0.1426323652267456,
-0.20134446024894714,
0.12025153636932373,
0.17791064083576202,
-0.5028460621833801,
1.0685269832611084,
0.1560365855693817,
-0.5141833424568176,
0.034353483468294144,
0.1193585991859436,
0.5072458386421204,
-0.5089784264564514,
0.04734351858496666,
-0.32232266664505005,
-0.037936802953481674,
-0.4020855724811554,
-0.6951761841773987,
0.22819186747074127,
0.20097973942756653,
-0.2858693301677704,
-0.18796655535697937,
0.4605504274368286,
0.13851892948150635,
-0.7671765685081482,
0.3651772439479828,
0.537889838218689,
0.4760529696941376,
-0.13600750267505646,
-0.6268460154533386,
-0.11675378680229187,
-0.17028814554214478,
-0.26376914978027344,
0.27659109234809875,
0.49608883261680603,
-0.11948379874229431,
0.535899817943573,
0.33848807215690613,
0.1453695148229599,
0.006269002333283424,
0.3998998999595642,
0.8992213010787964,
-1.060009479522705,
-0.34025710821151733,
-0.9707878828048706,
0.39003029465675354,
-0.349153995513916,
-0.2045750766992569,
0.5513657331466675,
0.9438473582267761,
0.48054876923561096,
0.13897281885147095,
0.9682247042655945,
-0.14791476726531982,
0.5594114065170288,
-0.8193882703781128,
0.4509427547454834,
-0.3218669891357422,
0.5811044573783875,
-0.13776877522468567,
-0.5444146990776062,
-0.38803768157958984,
0.5115771293640137,
-0.4091205596923828,
-0.06562051177024841,
0.5353882908821106,
0.6688041090965271,
-0.1363617181777954,
0.0549437515437603,
0.30716097354888916,
0.2413574904203415,
0.21417729556560516,
0.4012438654899597,
0.6457706093788147,
-0.19893093407154083,
0.3034336566925049,
0.20624065399169922,
0.12281664460897446,
-0.21501806378364563,
-0.6343110203742981,
-0.8614499568939209,
-0.08030396699905396,
-0.2615218460559845,
-0.3089512586593628,
0.1543658822774887,
0.8541359305381775,
0.4052630662918091,
-1.0230685472488403,
-0.3830372989177704,
-0.2592483460903168,
0.10693009942770004,
0.041425954550504684,
-0.20445644855499268,
0.43607446551322937,
-0.388376384973526,
-0.44035086035728455,
0.6698154211044312,
0.25386932492256165,
-0.30079448223114014,
0.07678361237049103,
0.0219905823469162,
-0.09925295412540436,
0.006877567153424025,
0.7181548476219177,
0.18714605271816254,
-0.8309871554374695,
0.03568372130393982,
-0.5298011302947998,
-0.044495366513729095,
0.2053224742412567,
1.0202829837799072,
-0.7283821105957031,
0.43453845381736755,
0.40976953506469727,
0.6537186503410339,
0.5564277172088623,
0.07783839106559753,
0.6864593029022217,
-0.503321647644043,
0.02564879134297371,
0.18362730741500854,
0.9790812134742737,
0.11144285649061203,
-0.014309264719486237,
0.6953390836715698,
0.3452131748199463,
-0.1895143985748291,
-0.578780472278595,
0.04914788529276848,
-1.2086296081542969,
-0.6205267310142517,
1.1256834268569946,
0.04771808907389641,
-0.20699508488178253,
-0.3053748905658722,
-0.2616744041442871,
-0.0686173290014267,
-0.44054412841796875,
0.6282650828361511,
0.8139142990112305,
-0.09992612153291702,
-0.12540940940380096,
-1.1622188091278076,
0.20871682465076447,
0.04955364391207695,
-0.5795319080352783,
-0.34471839666366577,
0.7860326766967773,
0.2819729447364807,
0.21603335440158844,
0.5262421369552612,
-0.3959844708442688,
0.0439249612390995,
-0.20338226854801178,
-0.05822579190135002,
0.04125387966632843,
-0.18747547268867493,
-0.4915584921836853,
0.7648811340332031,
-0.2320363074541092,
0.1722864806652069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04790v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04790v1
|
Online Training of Large Language Models: Learn while chatting
| 2024-03-04T10:00:55 | 2024-03-04T10:00:55 |
Juhao Liang, Ziwei Wang, Zhuoheng Ma, Jianquan Li, Zhiyi Zhang, Xiangbo Wu, Benyou Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models(LLMs) have dramatically revolutionized the field of
Natural Language Processing(NLP), offering remarkable capabilities that have
garnered widespread usage. However, existing interaction paradigms between LLMs
and users are constrained by either inflexibility, limitations in
customization, or a lack of persistent learning. This inflexibility is
particularly evident as users, especially those without programming skills,
have restricted avenues to enhance or personalize the model. Existing
frameworks further complicate the model training and deployment process due to
their computational inefficiencies and lack of user-friendly interfaces. To
overcome these challenges, this paper introduces a novel interaction
paradigm-'Online Training using External Interactions'-that merges the benefits
of persistent, real-time model updates with the flexibility for individual
customization through external interactions such as AI agents or online/offline
knowledge bases.
|
[
-0.30088144540786743,
-0.8347461819648743,
0.4919397532939911,
0.1282825917005539,
0.09354854375123978,
0.40399131178855896,
-0.493158757686615,
-0.9553105235099792,
0.3353968560695648,
0.2795190215110779,
-0.7168037295341492,
-0.08949980139732361,
-0.3318224549293518,
0.040204718708992004,
-0.16864672303199768,
0.8507466912269592,
0.13822343945503235,
0.28448396921157837,
-0.3914336860179901,
-0.12323475629091263,
-0.2481316179037094,
-0.7280869483947754,
-1.0454670190811157,
-0.3385387361049652,
0.4374418258666992,
0.17404355108737946,
0.6524388194084167,
0.2265044003725052,
0.49237534403800964,
0.47646623849868774,
-0.015777943655848503,
0.2905530631542206,
-0.742939829826355,
0.34305304288864136,
-0.06248693913221359,
-0.5273847579956055,
-0.1582246720790863,
-0.32482433319091797,
0.5922039747238159,
0.8278239965438843,
-0.20475022494792938,
-0.10438889265060425,
0.1425161212682724,
0.5117358565330505,
-0.28376489877700806,
0.164093017578125,
-0.7537505030632019,
-0.014622042886912823,
0.018728334456682205,
-0.16243429481983185,
-0.42963019013404846,
-0.47676002979278564,
0.2865968644618988,
-0.5902801752090454,
-0.20615021884441376,
-0.09713569283485413,
0.7447798848152161,
0.10098128020763397,
-0.32604295015335083,
-0.33797383308410645,
-0.9815956354141235,
0.652222216129303,
-1.0054335594177246,
0.5929682850837708,
0.6153076887130737,
0.560354471206665,
-0.25337958335876465,
-0.7661871910095215,
-0.5274978876113892,
-0.6308676600456238,
-0.05562504380941391,
-0.26564568281173706,
0.1668889969587326,
0.22492219507694244,
0.2746979594230652,
0.2046487033367157,
-0.19428403675556183,
0.3784604072570801,
-0.3138529062271118,
0.150016650557518,
0.5732922554016113,
0.20236505568027496,
0.3957122266292572,
0.3336496949195862,
-0.16269345581531525,
0.1993805319070816,
-0.6747540235519409,
0.0841999426484108,
0.5382672548294067,
0.46446171402931213,
-0.4571947455406189,
0.47009971737861633,
-0.2219526618719101,
0.609032392501831,
0.12924963235855103,
-0.28195154666900635,
0.2291349172592163,
-0.03515561297535896,
-0.23172318935394287,
-0.22573734819889069,
0.745556652545929,
0.1442006528377533,
0.07836219668388367,
-0.14774754643440247,
-0.0740329921245575,
-0.3495066463947296,
0.11151765286922455,
-0.6037188768386841,
-0.08231383562088013,
0.3574908971786499,
-0.3730504810810089,
-0.3222702741622925,
-0.18445704877376556,
-0.6207204461097717,
-0.6041367650032043,
-0.43853506445884705,
0.43520587682724,
-0.36875119805336,
-0.3414868414402008,
-0.1796245127916336,
0.09375791251659393,
0.06210416555404663,
0.44253090023994446,
-1.178326964378357,
0.2630349397659302,
0.5079694390296936,
1.0823179483413696,
-0.1440092772245407,
-0.10000766813755035,
-0.5142087340354919,
0.22177131474018097,
-0.10572492331266403,
0.5704928040504456,
-0.6841617822647095,
-0.3716110289096832,
0.2803274989128113,
-0.1697474867105484,
-0.1895049661397934,
-0.3879367709159851,
-0.15837936103343964,
-0.7054055333137512,
0.2869753837585449,
0.05165914073586464,
-0.771528959274292,
0.042165569961071014,
0.5631431937217712,
-0.32205814123153687,
1.0133466720581055,
0.14148621261119843,
-0.7582133412361145,
0.03240111842751503,
-0.7932313084602356,
-0.2320946753025055,
0.3343101441860199,
-0.2685191035270691,
-0.2789102792739868,
-0.18518677353858948,
-0.07586415857076645,
0.47951310873031616,
0.05575690045952797,
0.21921834349632263,
-0.6892464756965637,
-0.13932740688323975,
0.5350547432899475,
0.03623059391975403,
0.7060546875,
0.13603200018405914,
-0.17795690894126892,
0.6368604898452759,
-0.9625813364982605,
-0.04077931493520737,
0.07571876794099808,
-0.57480788230896,
-0.23957720398902893,
0.11720316112041473,
-0.015505931340157986,
0.36573526263237,
0.2732793390750885,
-0.6064395904541016,
0.3321591913700104,
-0.8079999685287476,
0.5589146614074707,
0.6868761777877808,
0.12272916734218597,
0.40524768829345703,
-0.38984933495521545,
0.4837929904460907,
-0.2458426058292389,
0.1863662302494049,
-0.1732640117406845,
-0.4138805866241455,
-0.9862227439880371,
-0.2326592355966568,
-0.16573511064052582,
0.5262724757194519,
-1.08968985080719,
0.2461104393005371,
-0.3955022692680359,
-0.5388067364692688,
-0.45497986674308777,
0.5156206488609314,
0.24201038479804993,
0.17360883951187134,
0.23095369338989258,
-0.18024936318397522,
-0.6882613301277161,
-0.5587735176086426,
-0.08552799373865128,
-0.11209583282470703,
-0.41589733958244324,
0.35358497500419617,
0.3459382653236389,
-0.5254215598106384,
1.0475562810897827,
-0.25369709730148315,
-0.43625280261039734,
-0.8211847543716431,
-0.028191599994897842,
-0.13572126626968384,
0.3709429204463959,
0.2400265783071518,
-0.4793957769870758,
-0.801515519618988,
0.22779273986816406,
-0.7794448733329773,
0.14112849533557892,
-0.3252912759780884,
0.22736947238445282,
0.39697909355163574,
0.8896251320838928,
-0.44973117113113403,
0.1518547236919403,
0.7121778130531311,
0.11127478629350662,
0.16995732486248016,
-0.47001543641090393,
0.002076397417113185,
-1.0785937309265137,
-0.13346201181411743,
-0.06893181800842285,
-0.4769999384880066,
-0.8663933277130127,
0.23489634692668915,
-0.12226539105176926,
-0.2540171146392822,
-0.6288189888000488,
0.6937094330787659,
-0.5998911261558533,
-0.0259335208684206,
-0.35488536953926086,
0.21848931908607483,
-0.294022798538208,
0.629525899887085,
0.26248693466186523,
0.4845621883869171,
0.41416239738464355,
-0.6783629059791565,
0.4617123603820801,
0.42405587434768677,
-0.257108598947525,
0.45925137400627136,
-0.45999622344970703,
0.420112282037735,
-0.004224908538162708,
0.47743523120880127,
-0.6614884734153748,
-0.48290765285491943,
0.1863958239555359,
-0.2930614650249481,
0.3851473033428192,
-0.07928558439016342,
-0.3272820711135864,
0.05245732143521309,
-0.4443168342113495,
0.011530165560543537,
0.24798114597797394,
-0.6598470211029053,
0.8876155614852905,
0.48844459652900696,
-0.046547770500183105,
-0.2245900183916092,
-0.6087182760238647,
0.23991884291172028,
-0.27692824602127075,
-0.6688973307609558,
-0.02857179194688797,
-0.2199370115995407,
-0.4693358838558197,
-0.42326977849006653,
0.5165193676948547,
-0.17803215980529785,
0.08664387464523315,
0.4200752377510071,
0.30076318979263306,
-0.024569712579250336,
0.33958014845848083,
-0.36069467663764954,
0.06238183379173279,
-0.11207898706197739,
0.02512347511947155,
0.5244534015655518,
-0.0697154775261879,
-0.5087575912475586,
-0.8205145597457886,
0.24277691543102264,
0.2619071304798126,
-0.059359531849622726,
1.2658545970916748,
0.5293866395950317,
-0.38783159852027893,
-0.17320616543293,
-0.6400347948074341,
-0.43650099635124207,
-0.6437299847602844,
0.46150216460227966,
-0.26975217461586,
-1.034429669380188,
0.36548149585723877,
-0.12564292550086975,
0.3446617126464844,
-0.047583382576704025,
0.5055410265922546,
-0.2649102509021759,
0.9468397498130798,
1.0263458490371704,
-0.015957061201334,
0.7990915179252625,
0.05875009298324585,
0.3474501073360443,
-0.7370142936706543,
-0.45148828625679016,
-0.3184511959552765,
-0.18188825249671936,
-0.5276222825050354,
-0.34400689601898193,
0.18257176876068115,
-0.10799349844455719,
-0.3068857192993164,
0.2343924641609192,
-0.12480194866657257,
0.39573168754577637,
0.41958698630332947,
0.26448777318000793,
0.35620826482772827,
-0.06240985170006752,
0.0853080078959465,
-0.32071152329444885,
-0.6483204364776611,
-0.24325178563594818,
0.9360556602478027,
0.6258588433265686,
1.0228325128555298,
0.26362311840057373,
0.4175296723842621,
0.019000587984919548,
0.5022782683372498,
-0.8026208877563477,
0.5644294619560242,
0.3355712592601776,
-0.4949515759944916,
-0.31767538189888,
-0.6557409763336182,
-0.8440027236938477,
0.059592295438051224,
-0.7317475080490112,
-1.1353839635849,
-0.22508910298347473,
0.45786288380622864,
-0.32699793577194214,
0.6309678554534912,
-0.8021154403686523,
0.6358380913734436,
-0.34385260939598083,
-0.46602410078048706,
-0.5082892775535583,
-0.8699652552604675,
0.27757689356803894,
-0.1580008715391159,
0.4910285472869873,
0.07490226626396179,
0.013493194244801998,
0.33447355031967163,
-0.38976919651031494,
1.3621488809585571,
-0.008249973878264427,
-0.04048290476202965,
0.10642459243535995,
0.2559000849723816,
0.7924860715866089,
-0.07595499604940414,
0.16413289308547974,
0.16642020642757416,
-0.12055148929357529,
-0.043218471109867096,
-0.5280730128288269,
0.8416272401809692,
-0.8327315449714661,
-0.4568435251712799,
-0.40487128496170044,
-0.4545997083187103,
-0.6836897134780884,
-0.18813501298427582,
-0.07410837709903717,
0.42905381321907043,
-0.18474289774894714,
0.27898621559143066,
0.5309605598449707,
-0.5582544803619385,
0.4488163888454437,
0.5202346444129944,
-0.43119707703590393,
-0.23625504970550537,
0.9498419761657715,
-0.12507744133472443,
0.7438880801200867,
0.5502724647521973,
0.27138105034828186,
-0.287882924079895,
-0.35640281438827515,
-0.13282226026058197,
0.2585822343826294,
-0.9687897562980652,
0.23065075278282166,
-0.8276300430297852,
-0.36485061049461365,
-0.2918281555175781,
-0.2767925560474396,
-0.18341392278671265,
-0.30083560943603516,
-0.41683706641197205,
-0.07687938213348389,
0.4203057885169983,
0.8896897435188293,
0.12142085283994675,
0.591906726360321,
-1.101625919342041,
0.027881497517228127,
0.4355596899986267,
0.5211654305458069,
0.24133330583572388,
-0.6807721853256226,
-0.49485549330711365,
-0.01631586253643036,
-0.29349157214164734,
-0.6889594793319702,
0.3907410800457001,
0.5856117606163025,
0.46919721364974976,
0.6608611941337585,
-0.18725833296775818,
0.5935664772987366,
-0.44733983278274536,
0.7565405368804932,
0.1873418241739273,
-0.7712011933326721,
0.1572861224412918,
-0.47973182797431946,
0.32719460129737854,
0.43862268328666687,
0.7796876430511475,
-0.9888238906860352,
-0.666111409664154,
-0.4486309587955475,
-0.8996347784996033,
0.6965508460998535,
-0.029397308826446533,
0.4475514888763428,
0.0941184014081955,
0.16147775948047638,
0.043472424149513245,
0.26777592301368713,
-1.038956880569458,
-0.11677167564630508,
-0.031281959265470505,
-0.2672726511955261,
0.07697489112615585,
-0.107415571808815,
-0.03710214048624039,
-0.20037926733493805,
0.968100368976593,
-0.20738163590431213,
0.04576294496655464,
-0.2687581777572632,
-0.23153921961784363,
-0.04156125336885452,
0.0321650505065918,
0.4394095540046692,
0.9005331993103027,
-0.12434156984090805,
-0.0761275440454483,
0.5443703532218933,
-0.06461067497730255,
-0.25384521484375,
-0.3120672106742859,
0.11388825625181198,
-0.22018031775951385,
0.3808765709400177,
1.0105491876602173,
0.6126310229301453,
-1.029097557067871,
0.32994869351387024,
-0.21062758564949036,
0.10374581068754196,
-0.6777708530426025,
0.13304086029529572,
0.48542776703834534,
0.4093044400215149,
0.1211927980184555,
-0.05073706433176994,
-0.23144914209842682,
-0.5627396702766418,
-0.037276312708854675,
0.5924046039581299,
-0.5534146428108215,
-0.27393877506256104,
0.6612311005592346,
0.5577465295791626,
-0.6067593097686768,
0.5936160087585449,
-0.10258960723876953,
-0.3757261633872986,
0.14181938767433167,
0.37252190709114075,
0.6415982842445374,
-0.28369614481925964,
0.11922893673181534,
0.5013741850852966,
0.08976607024669647,
-0.025045618414878845,
-0.15847544372081757,
-0.05047294870018959,
-0.8227874636650085,
-0.33966225385665894,
-0.45834779739379883,
-0.919303834438324,
0.40445324778556824,
-0.2572973966598511,
0.4285714328289032,
-0.5792680978775024,
-0.07010173052549362,
-0.1605818122625351,
-0.37845665216445923,
-0.4426954686641693,
0.003236070740967989,
0.22230537235736847,
0.5724974274635315,
-0.47853320837020874,
0.942224383354187,
0.45453977584838867,
-0.3535242974758148,
-0.5198981165885925,
-0.22321417927742004,
0.20133076608181,
-0.5489852428436279,
0.5848724246025085,
0.37928298115730286,
0.007096556480973959,
0.07256654649972916,
-0.4126899838447571,
-0.7840786576271057,
0.5972732305526733,
0.46308577060699463,
-0.6018273830413818,
-0.06971772015094757,
0.19457413256168365,
0.6669822931289673,
-0.2961124777793884,
0.5620137453079224,
0.2980080544948578,
0.07284329831600189,
0.13527272641658783,
-1.0531885623931885,
-0.25448936223983765,
-0.04913662374019623,
-0.08761870861053467,
0.04670172184705734,
-0.5754178166389465,
0.31570208072662354,
-0.2201818823814392,
-0.25158417224884033,
-0.12284477800130844,
0.7780906558036804,
-0.10511007905006409,
-0.22373656928539276,
0.5512404441833496,
0.09787030518054962,
0.6649742126464844,
0.11572647094726562,
0.9273579716682434,
-0.39905989170074463,
0.2374984174966812,
1.511696457862854,
-0.37968769669532776,
1.2754848003387451,
0.4906308650970459,
-0.287844181060791,
0.45978406071662903,
0.6919270753860474,
0.13843530416488647,
0.2033994346857071,
0.079546257853508,
-0.6682511568069458,
-0.2457347810268402,
0.00235752179287374,
-0.19474062323570251,
0.13602548837661743,
0.5168429017066956,
0.03322910517454147,
-0.07533954083919525,
0.294188529253006,
-0.0699954554438591,
0.1945182830095291,
-0.24158552289009094,
1.046275019645691,
0.32806313037872314,
-0.3923676311969757,
0.340432345867157,
0.10936921834945679,
1.0175505876541138,
-1.181825876235962,
0.06954672932624817,
0.017678072676062584,
0.31980112195014954,
-0.41225478053092957,
-0.3690278232097626,
0.45602256059646606,
-0.09759258478879929,
0.3121982514858246,
-0.3634035289287567,
0.5603512525558472,
-0.6121678948402405,
-0.358498752117157,
0.6508350372314453,
0.40578219294548035,
0.04300561174750328,
0.14504024386405945,
-0.5864747166633606,
0.04084697738289833,
-0.12648127973079681,
-0.4159547984600067,
0.735446572303772,
-0.05905678868293762,
-0.04518426954746246,
1.3866952657699585,
0.8183535933494568,
0.1010880097746849,
0.18842151761054993,
0.27309393882751465,
0.9188876748085022,
-0.25464656949043274,
-0.6890401840209961,
-0.7405862212181091,
0.32563918828964233,
-0.08522862941026688,
-0.24948850274085999,
0.7371124029159546,
0.38460099697113037,
1.0157147645950317,
-0.02386685460805893,
0.7288820743560791,
-0.006649077404290438,
0.6328945159912109,
-0.4105077385902405,
0.7251746654510498,
-0.41535428166389465,
0.3750514090061188,
0.01644052192568779,
-0.5743608474731445,
-0.08167435973882675,
0.5677222013473511,
-0.2843568027019501,
0.08440344780683517,
0.6146042943000793,
0.6542950868606567,
-0.1057388037443161,
-0.007047077175229788,
0.4306735694408417,
0.3223326802253723,
0.4893956184387207,
0.27754294872283936,
0.7792642712593079,
0.19461332261562347,
0.5037532448768616,
-0.2840917408466339,
-0.16365772485733032,
-0.25654956698417664,
-0.873822808265686,
-1.3917092084884644,
-0.6462652683258057,
-0.2275761514902115,
-0.29634153842926025,
0.04252711310982704,
1.743398904800415,
0.6804235577583313,
-0.7986538410186768,
-0.5704110264778137,
0.06429240852594376,
-0.22678092122077942,
-0.005407923832535744,
-0.21872790157794952,
0.07401525229215622,
-0.6085869073867798,
-0.7763017416000366,
0.7425158619880676,
0.15441586077213287,
0.3074686527252197,
-0.5185791254043579,
-0.10570327192544937,
-0.4697604179382324,
0.1253504604101181,
0.5517799258232117,
0.5882670879364014,
-0.3825569450855255,
-0.325875848531723,
-0.37060314416885376,
-0.09612710773944855,
0.39809414744377136,
0.7405328750610352,
-0.7337401509284973,
0.6779322028160095,
0.45936593413352966,
1.1337034702301025,
0.686141312122345,
-0.019340895116329193,
0.7014629244804382,
-0.8932371735572815,
0.46673455834388733,
-0.05541275069117546,
0.17575234174728394,
0.7574907541275024,
-0.4334909915924072,
0.15415197610855103,
0.14005298912525177,
-0.4575071334838867,
-0.8346998691558838,
0.2944691777229309,
-0.6220985651016235,
-0.15919284522533417,
1.198413610458374,
-0.31450018286705017,
0.04934649541974068,
-0.5128501653671265,
-0.23837700486183167,
0.18708935379981995,
-0.2963913381099701,
1.0057547092437744,
0.6395326256752014,
-0.24363824725151062,
-0.15209843218326569,
-0.89092618227005,
0.7617714405059814,
0.004318383056670427,
-1.2506906986236572,
-0.1822156459093094,
0.24495331943035126,
0.3409205377101898,
-0.055163003504276276,
0.5895845293998718,
0.454938143491745,
-0.29881739616394043,
-0.294856995344162,
0.19625693559646606,
-0.19430454075336456,
-0.11371014267206192,
-0.4442838430404663,
0.037550073117017746,
0.2676006853580475,
0.05957135558128357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01897v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01897v2
|
Fostering the Ecosystem of Open Neural Encoders for Portuguese with Albertina PT* Family
| 2024-03-04T09:56:47 | 2024-03-05T10:49:17 |
Rodrigo Santos, João Rodrigues, Luís Gomes, João Silva, António Branco, Henrique Lopes Cardoso, Tomás Freitas Osório, Bernardo Leite
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To foster the neural encoding of Portuguese, this paper contributes
foundation encoder models that represent an expansion of the still very scarce
ecosystem of large language models specifically developed for this language
that are fully open, in the sense that they are open source and openly
distributed for free under an open license for any purpose, thus including
research and commercial usages. Like most languages other than English,
Portuguese is low-resourced in terms of these foundational language resources,
there being the inaugural 900 million parameter Albertina and 335 million
Bertimbau. Taking this couple of models as an inaugural set, we present the
extension of the ecosystem of state-of-the-art open encoders for Portuguese
with a larger, top performance-driven model with 1.5 billion parameters, and a
smaller, efficiency-driven model with 100 million parameters. While achieving
this primary goal, further results that are relevant for this ecosystem were
obtained as well, namely new datasets for Portuguese based on the SuperGLUE
benchmark, which we also distribute openly.
|
[
-0.29643991589546204,
-0.18411938846111298,
-0.022828487679362297,
0.30886635184288025,
-0.25596487522125244,
-0.3247741758823395,
-0.5512858033180237,
-0.5381666421890259,
0.17293477058410645,
0.7653840780258179,
-0.1999720335006714,
-0.26010602712631226,
-0.9034199714660645,
0.11083707213401794,
-0.4310239553451538,
1.0781902074813843,
-0.05407858267426491,
0.2984731197357178,
-0.13101306557655334,
-0.3466638922691345,
0.013784878887236118,
-0.512751579284668,
-0.6591514348983765,
-0.037158697843551636,
0.549837052822113,
-0.03894883394241333,
0.6896278858184814,
0.8487697839736938,
0.29275745153427124,
0.25945183634757996,
-0.37789976596832275,
0.022005988284945488,
-0.7378313541412354,
0.28550466895103455,
-0.2523616552352905,
-0.45430880784988403,
-0.39421355724334717,
-0.5630748867988586,
0.5744327306747437,
0.6671644449234009,
-0.23965103924274445,
0.07316210120916367,
0.24912531673908234,
0.4191933572292328,
-0.7673459053039551,
0.4364425539970398,
-0.4214531481266022,
-0.12330402433872223,
-0.0024436176754534245,
-0.03055674582719803,
-0.2937156856060028,
-0.4978178143501282,
0.16272900998592377,
-0.6203480958938599,
-0.14681938290596008,
-0.4632667601108551,
0.7732242345809937,
0.2284795492887497,
-0.097541943192482,
-0.3168315887451172,
-0.8520843386650085,
0.5073914527893066,
-0.10127034783363342,
0.7562268376350403,
0.11580578237771988,
0.2049380987882614,
0.042949043214321136,
-0.40700095891952515,
-0.18739484250545502,
-0.22418047487735748,
0.25224101543426514,
0.001415908569470048,
-0.712571382522583,
0.017259126529097557,
-0.07320938259363174,
0.3037320673465729,
-0.2640325427055359,
0.11296246200799942,
-0.5906189680099487,
0.024609537795186043,
0.18972115218639374,
-0.20638181269168854,
-0.015684280544519424,
0.3777773380279541,
-0.14122365415096283,
-0.1994466632604599,
-1.0262019634246826,
-0.22775708138942719,
0.5520417094230652,
0.2345932275056839,
0.030183911323547363,
0.45153507590293884,
-0.16205206513404846,
0.6884260177612305,
-0.3719702959060669,
0.14150427281856537,
0.026359491050243378,
-0.04673014208674431,
-0.14454293251037598,
0.0714513435959816,
0.6130240559577942,
-0.06165079027414322,
0.5209865570068359,
-0.30951011180877686,
-0.4594482481479645,
0.15400362014770508,
0.08438340574502945,
-0.8297699093818665,
0.06384746730327606,
0.1423650085926056,
-0.6406011581420898,
0.061806246638298035,
-0.023352202028036118,
-0.7196926474571228,
-0.2590525448322296,
-0.12103468924760818,
0.28246766328811646,
-0.5674909353256226,
-0.5262740254402161,
0.4148619472980499,
-0.10223452746868134,
0.13582725822925568,
0.1403489112854004,
-1.044474482536316,
0.40540337562561035,
0.736339807510376,
0.6621721982955933,
0.42718079686164856,
-0.12401249259710312,
-0.06708361208438873,
0.15296398103237152,
-0.2899387776851654,
0.4721459150314331,
-0.6477838158607483,
-0.4736851155757904,
0.2891235947608948,
0.1696104258298874,
0.15535381436347961,
-0.4819682538509369,
0.6569124460220337,
-0.745691180229187,
0.05220980942249298,
-0.2031162530183792,
-0.1254785805940628,
-0.20309032499790192,
0.06110037490725517,
-0.7096199989318848,
0.58195561170578,
0.4965912699699402,
-0.4592328369617462,
0.1647898107767105,
-0.855256199836731,
-0.009008822031319141,
0.43321630358695984,
0.08753491193056107,
0.07179278880357742,
0.14699812233448029,
0.2794951796531677,
0.11606016010046005,
-0.5045543909072876,
0.23608417809009552,
-0.2535698711872101,
-0.15280453860759735,
0.19680838286876678,
-0.49685338139533997,
0.9848855137825012,
0.3116125166416168,
0.022649742662906647,
-0.12273231148719788,
-0.7216852903366089,
-0.3075422942638397,
0.060841724276542664,
-0.3769635558128357,
-0.6341215968132019,
-0.16106168925762177,
0.0447760671377182,
0.0949304923415184,
0.3460814356803894,
-0.8240863680839539,
0.32053279876708984,
-0.4819166660308838,
0.9414348602294922,
0.5530351400375366,
-0.21180935204029083,
0.4246865510940552,
0.023428086191415787,
0.6823606491088867,
0.18299148976802826,
0.2985694706439972,
-0.3624235689640045,
-0.5250951051712036,
-1.0030980110168457,
-0.4349733591079712,
0.8381009101867676,
0.19716207683086395,
-0.6937854886054993,
0.35115233063697815,
-0.6452053189277649,
-0.44946175813674927,
-1.3338932991027832,
-0.22913473844528198,
0.5780785083770752,
0.301317036151886,
0.2821196913719177,
-0.5483533143997192,
-0.6347505450248718,
-1.016006350517273,
0.4163255989551544,
0.11636097729206085,
-0.20817522704601288,
0.34750235080718994,
0.7004184126853943,
-0.1630449891090393,
0.598242461681366,
-0.01822402887046337,
-0.1439073085784912,
0.12540164589881897,
-0.044478632509708405,
0.4046371281147003,
0.6854249835014343,
0.8722666501998901,
-0.3954056203365326,
-0.10515765845775604,
0.20255279541015625,
-0.6985023617744446,
0.06471796333789825,
0.6196622252464294,
-0.11213691532611847,
0.3506014347076416,
0.0802425667643547,
-0.48330608010292053,
-0.04043857380747795,
0.8894758224487305,
-0.13411079347133636,
-0.04786411672830582,
-0.5458312630653381,
-0.03910497948527336,
-0.8249087929725647,
0.18394161760807037,
-0.15739130973815918,
0.2742142081260681,
-0.4325208365917206,
0.4108962118625641,
-0.0929768905043602,
-0.16459667682647705,
-0.6977289915084839,
0.35589978098869324,
-0.45043113827705383,
-0.1963035762310028,
-0.0871066227555275,
-0.1319098174571991,
-0.30263572931289673,
0.3556119501590729,
0.3445710241794586,
0.4941790699958801,
0.9565842151641846,
-0.46830588579177856,
0.19899623095989227,
0.3427981436252594,
-0.26736876368522644,
0.4604794681072235,
-0.9235267043113708,
0.04695577546954155,
-0.47695091366767883,
0.2529788315296173,
-0.536145806312561,
-0.014170504175126553,
0.4146369993686676,
-0.32997027039527893,
0.21625471115112305,
-0.5327810645103455,
-0.3690512180328369,
-0.451366126537323,
0.10310813039541245,
0.21176330745220184,
0.6967276930809021,
-0.8002676367759705,
0.532869279384613,
0.501157820224762,
-0.08446525037288666,
-0.6881014108657837,
-0.7955026626586914,
0.017092203721404076,
0.06163584440946579,
-0.9654614329338074,
0.174842968583107,
0.0525248721241951,
-0.022260094061493874,
0.46126070618629456,
0.2358960509300232,
-0.22709523141384125,
-0.031243817880749702,
0.2826178967952728,
0.07942979782819748,
-0.8231525421142578,
0.030761925503611565,
0.23557645082473755,
-0.20014384388923645,
0.061594586819410324,
-0.9440842866897583,
0.47928914427757263,
-0.23009982705116272,
0.11452329903841019,
0.09139082580804825,
0.425139844417572,
0.46958398818969727,
-0.6823999881744385,
1.0907397270202637,
0.16134800016880035,
-0.4971879720687866,
-0.28627192974090576,
-0.07901028543710709,
-0.09597288072109222,
-0.42023053765296936,
0.13237294554710388,
-0.3504166603088379,
-1.2118384838104248,
0.5378159284591675,
0.27516689896583557,
-0.07306641340255737,
0.41260358691215515,
0.610776960849762,
0.30885061621665955,
0.987561047077179,
0.7383862137794495,
-0.14993515610694885,
0.2490808218717575,
-0.5989935398101807,
-0.03526495397090912,
-0.7403138279914856,
-0.21032215654850006,
-0.8646816611289978,
-0.23101717233657837,
-0.7137677073478699,
-0.2567555904388428,
0.38407421112060547,
0.042003385722637177,
-0.22590434551239014,
0.5400703549385071,
-0.6939743161201477,
0.6238133311271667,
0.9480211138725281,
0.10305897146463394,
0.2222367376089096,
-0.08904357254505157,
-0.031139817088842392,
0.16472455859184265,
-1.0726476907730103,
-0.5987836122512817,
1.2622520923614502,
0.3986673951148987,
0.5839726328849792,
0.10533614456653595,
0.5548051595687866,
-0.13440339267253876,
0.4300440549850464,
-0.3557107448577881,
0.37022995948791504,
-0.3456078767776489,
-0.5844707489013672,
0.019966108724474907,
-0.20574770867824554,
-1.281596064567566,
0.38974952697753906,
-0.3110334575176239,
-0.41063717007637024,
0.5673111081123352,
0.15625596046447754,
-0.5510575771331787,
0.1353505402803421,
-0.4683831036090851,
0.8181011080741882,
-0.17229527235031128,
-0.5328737497329712,
-0.14547868072986603,
-0.4796157777309418,
0.33205124735832214,
0.10504494607448578,
0.051145631819963455,
0.1885526031255722,
-0.3582226037979126,
0.668589174747467,
-0.42438679933547974,
0.5597931742668152,
-0.3044993281364441,
-0.1216415986418724,
0.5502102375030518,
0.038522686809301376,
0.25052541494369507,
-0.14731277525424957,
-0.07634852081537247,
0.6895157694816589,
-0.1936037391424179,
-0.24378736317157745,
-0.1953308880329132,
0.8929705619812012,
-1.171960473060608,
-0.12321953475475311,
-0.3446287512779236,
-0.22056598961353302,
-0.013245593756437302,
0.17295758426189423,
0.1192275881767273,
0.27209532260894775,
-0.3221155107021332,
0.6448025703430176,
0.8675563335418701,
-0.13498516380786896,
0.46286338567733765,
0.6537484526634216,
0.12379738688468933,
-0.6275120377540588,
0.8445231914520264,
0.2645965814590454,
-0.17288871109485626,
0.41546767950057983,
0.0879589170217514,
-0.14337554574012756,
-0.700770378112793,
-0.567768931388855,
0.21677269041538239,
-0.5074335336685181,
-0.21204136312007904,
-0.8779544234275818,
-0.06998369842767715,
-0.49638083577156067,
-0.14882557094097137,
-0.3332470953464508,
-0.4623395800590515,
-0.41392984986305237,
-0.18090368807315826,
0.3250972628593445,
0.5121886730194092,
-0.2983510494232178,
0.6474272012710571,
-1.0326969623565674,
-0.10848677158355713,
0.14978106319904327,
0.5307391881942749,
0.12930937111377716,
-0.2498386800289154,
-0.3453262448310852,
0.28496578335762024,
-0.08478224277496338,
-0.8001590967178345,
0.7396547198295593,
0.07737208157777786,
0.6233724355697632,
0.6080934405326843,
-0.33709636330604553,
0.17940852046012878,
-0.3464587330818176,
0.5900207757949829,
-0.03549005091190338,
-0.713042140007019,
0.4269326627254486,
-0.6654568314552307,
-0.028649676591157913,
0.3480793535709381,
0.8979465365409851,
-0.37603381276130676,
-0.10792221128940582,
-0.7917736172676086,
-0.7548003196716309,
0.8867083787918091,
0.22714859247207642,
0.22550438344478607,
-0.16046887636184692,
0.1279076188802719,
0.31529873609542847,
0.35832127928733826,
-0.6448297500610352,
0.21572357416152954,
-0.5041140913963318,
-0.09847933053970337,
0.08827577531337738,
-0.2815116345882416,
-0.18027597665786743,
-0.024278415367007256,
0.827214241027832,
-0.08823875337839127,
0.4867715537548065,
-0.028326917439699173,
0.0752619132399559,
-0.3841852843761444,
0.08613619208335876,
0.3655742108821869,
0.21087618172168732,
-0.123349629342556,
-0.25536856055259705,
-0.3166534900665283,
-0.18997028470039368,
-0.14787065982818604,
0.2655729353427887,
-0.41128501296043396,
-0.11900021880865097,
0.2113281488418579,
0.9584513306617737,
0.36784255504608154,
-0.7994569540023804,
0.4593370854854584,
0.11061333864927292,
-0.19389474391937256,
-0.14900103211402893,
0.19913338124752045,
0.2731282413005829,
0.2425977736711502,
-0.057191986590623856,
0.015080652199685574,
0.009641041047871113,
-0.4233894944190979,
-0.11638770252466202,
0.25701600313186646,
-0.5836814641952515,
-0.4633067846298218,
0.7909789085388184,
0.7155507206916809,
-0.21432706713676453,
0.8524689078330994,
-0.04757852852344513,
-0.40685954689979553,
0.6873581409454346,
0.5072992444038391,
1.0443142652511597,
-0.3434845805168152,
-0.06005674600601196,
0.4445199966430664,
0.6085852980613708,
-0.16804715991020203,
0.7197420597076416,
-0.004306313581764698,
-0.8969191908836365,
-0.22028623521327972,
-0.8472791314125061,
-0.41858482360839844,
0.15164414048194885,
-0.5047975182533264,
0.22968672215938568,
-0.16417323052883148,
0.16303864121437073,
-0.2361471801996231,
-0.606909453868866,
-0.634445071220398,
0.03426410257816315,
0.2990929186344147,
1.1416064500808716,
-0.6715747714042664,
0.9645068645477295,
0.545040488243103,
-0.7368984222412109,
-0.18295618891716003,
-0.7029456496238708,
-0.5176219940185547,
-0.9375578165054321,
0.48724639415740967,
-0.06377452611923218,
0.13999633491039276,
-0.027738507837057114,
-0.6099407076835632,
-0.9828783869743347,
0.8159940838813782,
0.7332764267921448,
-0.6424093246459961,
-0.09652209281921387,
0.22072471678256989,
0.927979588508606,
-0.7001789808273315,
0.4541099965572357,
0.38554927706718445,
0.5664320588111877,
-0.01640155166387558,
-0.6639211177825928,
-0.34094905853271484,
-0.3333585560321808,
0.02770993672311306,
0.5894305109977722,
-0.6691542863845825,
0.8383005261421204,
0.14695517718791962,
0.12007392942905426,
0.27465176582336426,
0.7300200462341309,
-0.04851863533258438,
-0.23880118131637573,
0.22383593022823334,
0.6659020781517029,
0.3322075605392456,
-0.4742140471935272,
1.0659635066986084,
-0.8827890157699585,
0.10900350660085678,
0.8393569588661194,
-0.08807918429374695,
0.8853504061698914,
0.18169158697128296,
0.020892653614282608,
0.481450617313385,
0.456758588552475,
-0.12069743126630783,
0.45018067955970764,
0.22887985408306122,
-0.31582388281822205,
0.023286206647753716,
-0.48136088252067566,
-0.510582447052002,
0.5534627437591553,
0.5514490604400635,
-0.7925136685371399,
-0.2700396478176117,
0.1224747896194458,
0.1273011714220047,
-0.11998756229877472,
-0.7461225390434265,
0.5200498104095459,
-0.10347780585289001,
-0.923071026802063,
0.5462765693664551,
0.031998537480831146,
0.6103522777557373,
-0.8053602576255798,
0.0064681051298975945,
-0.18466627597808838,
0.3067614734172821,
0.0763639435172081,
-0.6324142813682556,
0.34064576029777527,
0.09213428944349289,
0.1058870255947113,
-0.6515710949897766,
0.6628748178482056,
-0.49494731426239014,
-0.16694487631320953,
0.48520931601524353,
0.43550485372543335,
0.15203015506267548,
-0.08991797268390656,
-0.4698484241962433,
0.05237594619393349,
-0.37692150473594666,
-0.1497844159603119,
0.2850089967250824,
0.5959793329238892,
-0.02926023304462433,
0.3833169937133789,
0.5879401564598083,
0.1495218575000763,
0.17298559844493866,
-0.15025821328163147,
0.9459369778633118,
-0.3296053111553192,
-0.5353730916976929,
-0.399336576461792,
0.40747925639152527,
0.23697702586650848,
-0.756132185459137,
0.43428146839141846,
0.5958043932914734,
1.1410645246505737,
-0.3331138491630554,
0.755711555480957,
0.04455418884754181,
0.18631304800510406,
-0.17115682363510132,
0.8484619855880737,
-0.2148820012807846,
-0.2732250690460205,
0.2748905122280121,
-1.1439285278320312,
-0.1064482256770134,
0.3032628297805786,
0.010058710351586342,
-0.12341190129518509,
0.3437066674232483,
0.8158069849014282,
-0.018931977450847626,
0.3945213556289673,
0.2939598858356476,
0.6075751781463623,
-0.04163426533341408,
0.8654598593711853,
0.8729400038719177,
-0.24005301296710968,
0.6868354678153992,
-0.30657339096069336,
-0.45761290192604065,
-0.33053797483444214,
-0.8414244055747986,
-0.33969274163246155,
-0.4210600256919861,
-0.21495983004570007,
-0.5052204132080078,
0.5407525300979614,
0.9150645732879639,
0.7177123427391052,
-0.8259509801864624,
-0.41953423619270325,
-0.1767110526561737,
-0.126564621925354,
-0.404925137758255,
-0.06729400902986526,
0.02067859284579754,
0.3198845684528351,
-0.9391027092933655,
0.4548506438732147,
0.2778046727180481,
-0.10728126764297485,
-0.7115402817726135,
-0.24739211797714233,
0.08189950883388519,
0.31567174196243286,
0.47132930159568787,
0.5351144671440125,
-0.3429831564426422,
-0.20694361627101898,
0.16157478094100952,
0.0377238467335701,
0.10835890471935272,
0.5293700695037842,
-0.999117374420166,
0.4476091265678406,
0.6420565843582153,
0.5549959540367126,
0.2758493423461914,
-0.6074352860450745,
0.5527033805847168,
-0.383192241191864,
0.23160576820373535,
0.5738196969032288,
0.7978766560554504,
0.22257065773010254,
-0.008943205699324608,
0.773960292339325,
0.207479327917099,
-0.43425944447517395,
-0.6043424606323242,
-0.015308271162211895,
-0.8723775148391724,
-0.07706550508737564,
0.9316176176071167,
-0.2006295621395111,
-0.7008740901947021,
0.23989373445510864,
-0.09392045438289642,
0.20224834978580475,
-0.6732460260391235,
0.4536914825439453,
0.5799809694290161,
0.15657122433185577,
0.046636782586574554,
-0.1532396674156189,
0.02785402536392212,
0.016536472365260124,
-0.43762877583503723,
-0.13761462271213531,
0.5759111642837524,
-0.17622369527816772,
0.269424706697464,
0.39094239473342896,
-0.29153499007225037,
0.3479461371898651,
0.321021169424057,
0.4053325951099396,
-0.21474653482437134,
-0.584087610244751,
-0.6598766446113586,
0.6391938924789429,
-0.08682527393102646,
-0.14698565006256104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01886v1
|
FCDS: Fusing Constituency and Dependency Syntax into Document-Level Relation Extraction
| 2024-03-04T09:48:55 | 2024-03-04T09:48:55 |
Xudong Zhu, Zhao Kang, Bei Hui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Document-level Relation Extraction (DocRE) aims to identify relation labels
between entities within a single document. It requires handling several
sentences and reasoning over them. State-of-the-art DocRE methods use a graph
structure to connect entities across the document to capture dependency syntax
information. However, this is insufficient to fully exploit the rich syntax
information in the document. In this work, we propose to fuse constituency and
dependency syntax into DocRE. It uses constituency syntax to aggregate the
whole sentence information and select the instructive sentences for the pairs
of targets. It exploits the dependency syntax in a graph structure with
constituency syntax enhancement and chooses the path between entity pairs based
on the dependency graph. The experimental results on datasets from various
domains demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method. The code is
publicly available at this url.
|
[
-0.5802465677261353,
-0.6691421270370483,
0.683809220790863,
0.006406452506780624,
-0.21917502582073212,
0.03529936820268631,
0.03304467350244522,
-0.2828778028488159,
0.12354204058647156,
0.7296144962310791,
-0.560665488243103,
-0.5150097012519836,
-0.524019718170166,
0.011645916849374771,
-0.46610739827156067,
0.8636130690574646,
0.12418980151414871,
0.000003149327994833584,
-0.6301950216293335,
-0.04983128234744072,
-0.07311374694108963,
-0.5443359613418579,
-0.29479625821113586,
0.021904006600379944,
0.3188198506832123,
0.6606744527816772,
0.18761132657527924,
0.5818591117858887,
0.4905256927013397,
0.38295409083366394,
0.01951408199965954,
0.043803904205560684,
-0.5111613273620605,
0.3262428343296051,
-0.37409213185310364,
-0.20588751137256622,
-0.3052818775177002,
-0.03807612136006355,
0.8070356845855713,
0.8705857992172241,
0.004140825476497412,
-0.43107870221138,
-0.02469511143863201,
0.6334591507911682,
-0.5473825335502625,
0.41494807600975037,
-0.6875869631767273,
-0.35803043842315674,
-0.27777299284935,
-0.10898203402757645,
-0.26637932658195496,
-0.23219215869903564,
-0.026602745056152344,
-0.5234664678573608,
0.4910142421722412,
-0.010436342097818851,
1.2084883451461792,
0.09051497280597687,
-0.6081529855728149,
-0.2186242789030075,
-0.41219401359558105,
0.24728922545909882,
-0.4306156039237976,
0.7453446388244629,
0.2348082810640335,
0.19482168555259705,
-0.09516989439725876,
-1.1042089462280273,
-0.5433199405670166,
-0.06826157867908478,
-0.5666034817695618,
0.12879356741905212,
0.08806359022855759,
0.2606506943702698,
0.2659411132335663,
0.7765604853630066,
-0.338631272315979,
-0.0973367914557457,
-0.2896542251110077,
-0.11604633182287216,
0.4260517954826355,
-0.010460862889885902,
0.29568564891815186,
-0.558992862701416,
-0.5730114579200745,
-0.10514932125806808,
-0.6063210368156433,
-0.12408702075481415,
0.2630520164966583,
0.42014771699905396,
-0.11126309633255005,
0.6382637619972229,
-0.13688582181930542,
0.6562713384628296,
0.34448322653770447,
-0.11351072043180466,
-0.012505550868809223,
-0.4391734004020691,
-0.3650171756744385,
-0.029379546642303467,
1.0751526355743408,
0.07892780005931854,
0.1190367043018341,
-0.4510191082954407,
-0.1615198850631714,
0.21649444103240967,
0.14305976033210754,
-0.9090536236763,
-0.1255541890859604,
0.2823874354362488,
-0.4423297941684723,
-0.5298925042152405,
0.4416366517543793,
-1.2904925346374512,
-0.2827804684638977,
-0.2607920169830322,
-0.16242271661758423,
-0.6015840768814087,
-0.3791634440422058,
-0.22184106707572937,
-0.48381978273391724,
0.22911511361598969,
0.08202429860830307,
-1.0394670963287354,
0.6377062201499939,
0.9650688767433167,
0.5219681859016418,
0.05668433755636215,
-0.3003338873386383,
-0.8281694650650024,
0.45361924171447754,
0.092302605509758,
1.0169028043746948,
-0.8138236403465271,
-0.7098504900932312,
0.02593722566962242,
0.07335235923528671,
-0.3530021011829376,
-0.47711852192878723,
0.5940245985984802,
-0.2729954719543457,
0.3237278163433075,
-0.2658836543560028,
-0.8038836717605591,
0.255251944065094,
-0.01872028037905693,
-0.8002650141716003,
0.8574699759483337,
1.0542242527008057,
-0.9662346243858337,
0.24191895127296448,
-0.47337454557418823,
-0.738922119140625,
0.07509821653366089,
-0.5037919878959656,
-0.21282660961151123,
-0.24928615987300873,
0.36667943000793457,
0.3873876929283142,
-0.35050973296165466,
0.39168089628219604,
-0.25684040784835815,
0.060460664331912994,
-0.14589636027812958,
0.1390094757080078,
0.9478616118431091,
0.18388451635837555,
-0.320240318775177,
0.10009486973285675,
-0.9144778251647949,
-0.3532319962978363,
-0.05833914503455162,
-0.2056722193956375,
-0.38302990794181824,
0.05056857690215111,
0.01977788843214512,
0.3813464641571045,
-0.10122153908014297,
-0.43529582023620605,
0.5197350978851318,
-0.5889148712158203,
0.281046062707901,
0.5735172033309937,
0.5106358528137207,
0.9864964485168457,
-0.10657957196235657,
0.7457414865493774,
0.08454820513725281,
-0.04716712608933449,
-0.2093997448682785,
-0.12340910732746124,
-0.6497236490249634,
-0.439625084400177,
0.3743725121021271,
0.3292127251625061,
-0.6856828927993774,
0.7041930556297302,
-0.4252808094024658,
-0.2656596302986145,
-0.32439208030700684,
0.2530306279659271,
0.2239341139793396,
0.9546833038330078,
0.12924669682979584,
0.016849735751748085,
-0.5601028203964233,
-0.7971767783164978,
0.0888567566871643,
-0.3529694080352783,
0.11460608243942261,
0.1764800101518631,
0.23729896545410156,
-0.016127925366163254,
1.1226775646209717,
-0.9066560864448547,
-0.6993694305419922,
-0.3612784445285797,
0.001974573591724038,
-0.30640584230422974,
0.3980175852775574,
0.9327459931373596,
-0.7796450257301331,
-0.42302098870277405,
0.07037723809480667,
-0.5985464453697205,
-0.22287918627262115,
-0.12290120869874954,
-0.41179755330085754,
0.036308132112026215,
0.6881976127624512,
-0.8512106537818909,
0.3274289071559906,
0.18811851739883423,
-0.36038994789123535,
0.4887412190437317,
0.17654849588871002,
0.05195404216647148,
-1.2522624731063843,
0.03893858939409256,
0.06434255838394165,
-0.23759131133556366,
-0.3309504985809326,
0.35339951515197754,
0.2280815839767456,
-0.281461238861084,
-0.23152032494544983,
0.34567293524742126,
-0.7572521567344666,
-0.1445191502571106,
0.15910641849040985,
0.3534557819366455,
0.2890253961086273,
0.37743517756462097,
-0.019943641498684883,
0.4938676357269287,
0.5769288539886475,
-0.2403223067522049,
0.21660681068897247,
0.5545960068702698,
-0.10768132656812668,
0.8067664504051208,
-0.28768521547317505,
0.011375079862773418,
-0.07368825376033783,
0.39344915747642517,
-1.0437523126602173,
-0.2351643592119217,
0.3587110638618469,
-0.3284851610660553,
0.6577644944190979,
-0.3392762839794159,
-0.43819087743759155,
-0.1554412990808487,
-0.2149694263935089,
-0.16600027680397034,
0.03220513090491295,
-0.5215115547180176,
0.7581915855407715,
0.5591042637825012,
-0.2574527859687805,
-0.3537195324897766,
-0.2501239776611328,
0.03665095940232277,
-0.10145602375268936,
-0.7730492353439331,
0.6240004897117615,
0.23628997802734375,
-0.48018431663513184,
0.33869102597236633,
-0.1639474779367447,
-0.26501911878585815,
-0.11366038769483566,
0.34541258215904236,
0.3158889710903168,
-0.4116705060005188,
-0.09398093074560165,
0.31519708037376404,
-0.24122576415538788,
0.18832001090049744,
-0.1205926388502121,
0.48429983854293823,
0.1488196849822998,
-0.26037320494651794,
-0.029107756912708282,
0.9442649483680725,
0.867098867893219,
-0.637477695941925,
0.5280318856239319,
0.3818352222442627,
-0.4161573350429535,
-0.32918158173561096,
-0.43675103783607483,
-0.010958483442664146,
-0.49760666489601135,
0.08929965645074844,
-0.6439564228057861,
-0.7315093278884888,
0.3651787340641022,
-0.29658812284469604,
-0.23115622997283936,
0.5657117366790771,
0.0743696317076683,
0.042562637478113174,
0.5603111386299133,
0.6264715790748596,
-0.39941954612731934,
0.3583942949771881,
-0.5461794137954712,
0.23270103335380554,
-0.8254026174545288,
-0.3451524078845978,
-0.953919529914856,
0.16028492152690887,
-0.3538441061973572,
-0.13038845360279083,
0.045405562967061996,
0.3420926332473755,
0.1941756159067154,
0.5238229632377625,
-0.5227655172348022,
0.042847391217947006,
0.19937874376773834,
-0.013255811296403408,
0.046780336648225784,
0.05314948409795761,
-0.4301528036594391,
-0.030231812968850136,
-0.49725523591041565,
-0.12849751114845276,
0.5002962350845337,
-0.15187254548072815,
0.4631682336330414,
0.165033757686615,
0.9163751006126404,
0.02920330874621868,
0.3685801923274994,
-0.9582715034484863,
0.6257675290107727,
-0.3056199550628662,
-0.270973265171051,
-0.02763974852859974,
-0.4701650142669678,
-0.9834795594215393,
0.1977539211511612,
-0.14909715950489044,
-0.9040393233299255,
0.6807863712310791,
-0.2316683828830719,
0.24083556234836578,
0.16795329749584198,
-0.8098374009132385,
0.9691169857978821,
-0.12341964989900589,
-0.2703072428703308,
0.09125107526779175,
-0.796596348285675,
0.25461575388908386,
-0.011599903926253319,
0.07657764106988907,
0.24208931624889374,
0.1480202078819275,
0.6475509405136108,
-0.850222110748291,
0.506626307964325,
-0.12743715941905975,
-0.06657347828149796,
0.12602916359901428,
0.009852872230112553,
0.4204883277416229,
-0.0064708213321864605,
-0.3181350529193878,
-0.2601495683193207,
0.03355884179472923,
-0.12457194179296494,
-0.7990843057632446,
0.9445838928222656,
-0.3719654977321625,
-0.6200231313705444,
-0.43823251128196716,
-0.3593091666698456,
-0.5085864067077637,
0.5110284686088562,
0.06848558038473129,
0.8932719826698303,
-0.5463867783546448,
0.07645802199840546,
0.17820142209529877,
0.2858375906944275,
0.48676541447639465,
0.40413784980773926,
-0.2419782131910324,
-0.7238797545433044,
0.7337243556976318,
-0.11805997043848038,
0.3853488564491272,
0.7068251967430115,
0.04874810948967934,
-0.4567185640335083,
-0.11140502989292145,
-0.3258591294288635,
0.4305144250392914,
-0.7860252261161804,
-0.28097033500671387,
-0.9133256673812866,
-0.35771870613098145,
-0.9244362115859985,
-0.3577103316783905,
0.06234953552484512,
-0.4760130047798157,
-0.3920699954032898,
-0.34435322880744934,
0.119259312748909,
0.6642515659332275,
0.03151752054691315,
0.15696828067302704,
-0.8230853080749512,
0.7343268990516663,
0.19927319884300232,
0.15971267223358154,
-0.10755840688943863,
0.2327498197555542,
0.20510068535804749,
-0.20567481219768524,
-0.24420107901096344,
-1.2640689611434937,
0.2513939440250397,
0.15151762962341309,
0.6611369848251343,
0.8036666512489319,
0.263907253742218,
0.7473334670066833,
-0.36195245385169983,
0.5172377228736877,
0.27319401502609253,
-0.8997188210487366,
0.7986570596694946,
-0.5579008460044861,
-0.023125402629375458,
0.862618088722229,
0.2757950723171234,
-0.1836346685886383,
-0.6795101165771484,
-1.0044687986373901,
-0.8307355642318726,
0.746540904045105,
0.18552133440971375,
-0.3483617305755615,
-0.14213897287845612,
0.23827558755874634,
0.010805117897689342,
-0.035647567361593246,
-0.09447667747735977,
-0.26305365562438965,
-0.0525246299803257,
-0.308395653963089,
0.20868980884552002,
-0.2646327614784241,
-0.22238212823867798,
-0.515469491481781,
0.3435039818286896,
-0.05901725962758064,
0.07253636419773102,
0.39710837602615356,
-0.05176309868693352,
-0.17875032126903534,
0.299822598695755,
0.08903766423463821,
0.7249990701675415,
-0.3564981520175934,
0.14513124525547028,
-0.5024936199188232,
-0.3543144762516022,
-0.007823570631444454,
0.7007789611816406,
-0.1733265072107315,
0.16953881084918976,
0.32162368297576904,
0.5206321477890015,
0.3826090395450592,
-0.1404361128807068,
0.7688243985176086,
-0.08335895836353302,
-0.4675750732421875,
-0.0864170640707016,
0.05429771542549133,
0.4391782581806183,
-0.10079566389322281,
0.1445741355419159,
0.13954010605812073,
-0.03185358643531799,
-0.7144904732704163,
0.7442168593406677,
0.4446989893913269,
-0.6234502196311951,
0.0004894901649095118,
0.6895715594291687,
0.48459798097610474,
-0.4701327383518219,
0.6741744875907898,
-0.06198086589574814,
-0.6741368174552917,
0.7363446950912476,
0.7149090766906738,
0.7395038604736328,
-0.13762949407100677,
0.3670024871826172,
0.3780536353588104,
0.1273839920759201,
0.39182040095329285,
0.018705422058701515,
-0.32761964201927185,
-0.6395682096481323,
-0.1796187460422516,
-0.5730135440826416,
-0.2861175239086151,
0.05744234472513199,
-0.8374930024147034,
0.4668503701686859,
-0.3078448176383972,
0.2769828140735626,
0.43996959924697876,
0.08389260619878769,
-0.3191278576850891,
0.23402923345565796,
-0.34503549337387085,
0.9735168218612671,
-0.7542576789855957,
1.1146259307861328,
0.48964235186576843,
-0.9194142818450928,
-1.011414885520935,
0.21106363832950592,
0.04962100833654404,
-0.30131059885025024,
0.41198912262916565,
0.06189756840467453,
0.030283277854323387,
0.18759074807167053,
-0.3330412209033966,
-0.28390681743621826,
0.902245819568634,
0.5601181387901306,
-0.5354107022285461,
-0.02586962841451168,
0.06135988608002663,
0.26258131861686707,
-0.6352443695068359,
0.038207996636629105,
0.6366727352142334,
0.5562438368797302,
0.10072805732488632,
-0.5236461758613586,
0.43532371520996094,
-0.3482220768928528,
-0.4471018314361572,
0.641645073890686,
-0.4206923246383667,
0.5103179812431335,
0.014059564098715782,
-0.38710087537765503,
0.04490219056606293,
0.4581243395805359,
0.06125025078654289,
0.21332617104053497,
0.8357879519462585,
0.5741792321205139,
0.6983680725097656,
-0.1569339483976364,
1.1559144258499146,
-0.25874894857406616,
0.3210553824901581,
1.1045140027999878,
-0.5845869779586792,
0.7093601226806641,
0.4601764678955078,
-0.10488330572843552,
0.6993304491043091,
0.28968411684036255,
0.08893560618162155,
0.6068226099014282,
-0.12357413023710251,
-0.3960280120372772,
0.11268466711044312,
-0.13481150567531586,
-0.457121878862381,
0.36515119671821594,
0.5898080468177795,
-0.5276719331741333,
-0.30436399579048157,
-0.44008487462997437,
0.314772367477417,
0.18613392114639282,
0.18784044682979584,
0.954434871673584,
0.1534104347229004,
-0.9425550699234009,
0.2940139174461365,
-0.30876457691192627,
0.09545483440160751,
-0.828212559223175,
-0.3203123211860657,
-0.2095934897661209,
0.13629880547523499,
-0.35526055097579956,
-0.562700092792511,
0.2539503276348114,
-0.1937122792005539,
-0.26163411140441895,
-0.3252622187137604,
1.1815510988235474,
-0.6158747673034668,
-0.4691358506679535,
0.6530038714408875,
0.5436919331550598,
-0.19904030859470367,
-0.060136664658784866,
-0.4611448347568512,
-0.21055720746517181,
0.10292676091194153,
0.18137624859809875,
0.45169737935066223,
0.7043283581733704,
0.23655715584754944,
0.12996062636375427,
0.8960134983062744,
0.29232674837112427,
-0.4759122133255005,
0.41407957673072815,
1.4310057163238525,
-0.5990229249000549,
-0.5041770339012146,
-0.5514285564422607,
0.524238109588623,
-0.6549222469329834,
-0.23872581124305725,
0.35245662927627563,
0.7591914534568787,
0.47886422276496887,
0.13238081336021423,
0.825761616230011,
-0.553405225276947,
0.2847604751586914,
-0.3902321755886078,
0.7570872902870178,
-0.4475575387477875,
0.16423596441745758,
-0.5714386105537415,
-1.0069729089736938,
-0.09385797381401062,
0.2713579833507538,
0.006170175038278103,
-0.29159584641456604,
1.3900848627090454,
1.0501176118850708,
-0.35721343755722046,
0.009898764081299305,
0.04992752522230148,
0.12749741971492767,
0.3961440324783325,
0.36372873187065125,
0.6985113024711609,
-0.21596750617027283,
0.7431922554969788,
-0.5403373837471008,
-0.2414914220571518,
0.10737419128417969,
-0.754314661026001,
-0.6433756351470947,
-0.8779681921005249,
-0.33242881298065186,
-0.52730393409729,
-0.06023272126913071,
0.2802783250808716,
0.7411931157112122,
-0.5741237998008728,
-0.04591081291437149,
-0.2847355604171753,
0.37568116188049316,
-0.10352319478988647,
-0.40200912952423096,
0.6551402807235718,
-0.40156108140945435,
-0.5933583378791809,
0.49523070454597473,
0.3286631405353546,
-0.2666357457637787,
-0.11654268205165863,
-0.06620438396930695,
-0.59345942735672,
-0.3186558485031128,
0.4192371070384979,
0.15055035054683685,
-0.48837608098983765,
-0.27484747767448425,
-0.0726170688867569,
-0.3162350356578827,
0.15300050377845764,
1.1878193616867065,
-0.7333564758300781,
0.313770055770874,
0.6850630044937134,
0.3726922869682312,
0.6338340640068054,
0.4534720480442047,
0.897771418094635,
-0.7758263945579529,
0.17057690024375916,
0.04230498895049095,
0.5590733289718628,
0.3566657304763794,
-0.5913264751434326,
0.8003569841384888,
0.4843951165676117,
-0.3502100706100464,
-0.5285228490829468,
0.22000300884246826,
-1.557971477508545,
-0.3665159344673157,
1.2570509910583496,
-0.2431110292673111,
-0.13253521919250488,
-0.20949342846870422,
-0.4982636868953705,
0.21904727816581726,
-0.3252333104610443,
0.34005123376846313,
0.4726100265979767,
-0.013958257623016834,
-0.21518129110336304,
-0.016801226884126663,
0.40031898021698,
-0.06154065951704979,
-1.0915865898132324,
-0.04841763898730278,
0.7677894234657288,
0.18570178747177124,
-0.005804373417049646,
1.128106713294983,
-0.2108866423368454,
0.010518637485802174,
0.3358002007007599,
-0.2922666370868683,
-0.009609566070139408,
-0.06381735950708389,
0.026374977082014084,
0.5520419478416443,
-0.24411363899707794,
-0.14517393708229065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01858v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01858v1
|
An Improved Traditional Chinese Evaluation Suite for Foundation Model
| 2024-03-04T09:13:33 | 2024-03-04T09:13:33 |
Zhi-Rui Tam, Ya-Ting Pai, Yen-Wei Lee, Sega Cheng, Hong-Han Shuai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present TMMLU+, a comprehensive dataset designed for the Traditional
Chinese massive multitask language understanding dataset. TMMLU+ is a
multiple-choice question-answering dataset with 66 subjects from elementary to
professional level. Compared to its predecessor, TMMLU, TMMLU+ is six times
larger and boasts a more balanced subject distribution. We included benchmark
results in TMMLU+ from closed-source models and 24 open-weight Chinese large
language models of parameters ranging from 1.8B to 72B. Our findings reveal
that Traditional Chinese models still trail behind their Simplified Chinese
counterparts. Additionally, current large language models have yet to
outperform human performance in average scores. We publicly release our dataset
and the corresponding benchmark source code.
|
[
-0.12793993949890137,
-0.6882652044296265,
0.331848680973053,
0.2241992950439453,
-0.11139241605997086,
0.17119745910167694,
-0.42151015996932983,
-0.45036593079566956,
-0.20950907468795776,
0.4547763466835022,
-0.608600378036499,
-0.5497300624847412,
-0.29917478561401367,
-0.07628528773784637,
-0.2128008008003235,
0.7770890593528748,
-0.05433933064341545,
0.42244651913642883,
0.10539201647043228,
-0.35840904712677,
-0.393477201461792,
-0.28060176968574524,
-0.6740771532058716,
-0.7800790071487427,
0.3729122281074524,
0.41247278451919556,
0.710919976234436,
0.5033017992973328,
0.37632453441619873,
0.148056298494339,
0.10842770338058472,
-0.04697900265455246,
-0.5829899311065674,
-0.37310728430747986,
0.02655210718512535,
-0.35938817262649536,
-0.8025257587432861,
-0.014948511496186256,
0.7911214232444763,
1.0544052124023438,
-0.24217696487903595,
0.49776726961135864,
-0.15961293876171112,
0.7134174108505249,
-0.6013773083686829,
-0.0236219372600317,
-0.17974495887756348,
0.1238233894109726,
-0.4050534665584564,
-0.12636590003967285,
-0.6603071689605713,
-0.39442211389541626,
0.34408727288246155,
-0.5175009965896606,
0.09028850495815277,
-0.20333480834960938,
0.7754465937614441,
-0.0007278223638422787,
-0.6156172752380371,
-0.041424937546253204,
-0.3109755516052246,
1.1026278734207153,
-0.6932131052017212,
0.48481830954551697,
0.4171704351902008,
0.7224299311637878,
0.018312476575374603,
-0.6140052676200867,
-0.18736062943935394,
-0.6810221672058105,
0.005352037493139505,
0.17637194693088531,
0.3982941210269928,
0.09371168166399002,
0.27607694268226624,
0.6925891041755676,
-0.9351643919944763,
-0.0025820001028478146,
-0.6305651068687439,
-0.10810643434524536,
0.8591868877410889,
0.39199474453926086,
0.36691537499427795,
-0.12357501685619354,
-0.17967793345451355,
-0.044163960963487625,
-0.7325455546379089,
0.29274699091911316,
0.06358359754085541,
0.09376384317874908,
-0.17461243271827698,
0.5642073154449463,
-0.3681040406227112,
1.1708295345306396,
-0.17266888916492462,
-0.25031954050064087,
0.37737587094306946,
-0.517943799495697,
-0.6181074976921082,
-0.03819727525115013,
0.5936447978019714,
0.3382352888584137,
0.2928451895713806,
-0.20117664337158203,
-0.11424876749515533,
-0.01774005964398384,
0.11855968832969666,
-0.7942730784416199,
-0.19330838322639465,
0.5487961173057556,
-0.6372188329696655,
-0.3911941945552826,
0.28787878155708313,
-0.4412071704864502,
-0.48548299074172974,
-0.30695417523384094,
0.3681868314743042,
-0.29785290360450745,
-0.7275292277336121,
0.5924429893493652,
-0.23511336743831635,
0.5205581188201904,
0.5019143223762512,
-0.4627406597137451,
0.37214332818984985,
0.8103737831115723,
0.7183694243431091,
-0.3090120851993561,
-0.41714000701904297,
-0.5878527164459229,
-0.10340191423892975,
-0.6293498277664185,
0.48229917883872986,
-0.6137295961380005,
-0.3272899091243744,
-0.1296636313199997,
0.13024625182151794,
-0.2124301791191101,
-0.5019841194152832,
0.7125431895256042,
-0.2764366567134857,
0.46869540214538574,
-0.561194121837616,
-0.278889924287796,
-0.3626610338687897,
0.4093031585216522,
-0.9453461766242981,
1.0463206768035889,
0.429916650056839,
-0.732367992401123,
0.2733575105667114,
-0.9937529563903809,
-0.34962964057922363,
0.10013677179813385,
0.028301499783992767,
-0.06383998692035675,
-0.14105959236621857,
0.07627329230308533,
0.37074270844459534,
-0.4998404085636139,
0.7432758212089539,
-0.5700362324714661,
-0.5050576329231262,
0.13114440441131592,
-0.23523373901844025,
1.385954737663269,
0.353054404258728,
-0.2562141418457031,
0.3598136603832245,
-0.7478021383285522,
0.11527910828590393,
0.09677017480134964,
-0.274768590927124,
-0.1777494102716446,
-0.2614012360572815,
0.16548338532447815,
0.494797021150589,
0.3845791518688202,
-0.6188340783119202,
0.1344701647758484,
-0.0727369412779808,
0.5952510237693787,
0.5480166673660278,
-0.42288634181022644,
0.26601091027259827,
-0.5748769640922546,
0.4558928310871124,
-0.23924009501934052,
-0.03185546398162842,
-0.30257371068000793,
-0.3664548099040985,
-0.7924085259437561,
0.14772093296051025,
0.2935190796852112,
0.47535252571105957,
-0.6875838041305542,
0.22118975222110748,
-0.47237086296081543,
-0.6075134873390198,
-0.7631160020828247,
0.09481003135442734,
0.33457034826278687,
0.5517268776893616,
0.09814471006393433,
-0.04691009595990181,
-0.36022713780403137,
-0.8875753283500671,
0.12713667750358582,
-0.19749468564987183,
-0.31012195348739624,
0.3501904010772705,
0.40427476167678833,
0.1363702118396759,
0.6137478947639465,
-0.5482245683670044,
0.07284919172525406,
-0.37957340478897095,
-0.0014539666008204222,
0.24213197827339172,
0.2893409729003906,
0.7337605357170105,
-0.8744773864746094,
-0.35120901465415955,
0.21061646938323975,
-0.8602709174156189,
-0.022443311288952827,
-0.005954079795628786,
-0.35461926460266113,
-0.02954244241118431,
-0.039778005331754684,
-0.5001400709152222,
-0.07643397897481918,
0.7020823359489441,
-0.41302186250686646,
0.9584572911262512,
0.1204923540353775,
0.28344735503196716,
-1.267533302307129,
0.5905232429504395,
0.04910923168063164,
-0.1667306274175644,
-0.784678041934967,
0.6134251356124878,
0.503547191619873,
-0.34493309259414673,
-0.5686993598937988,
0.6237335801124573,
-0.2700232267379761,
-0.06943823397159576,
-0.06671363860368729,
0.2763389050960541,
0.20658639073371887,
0.4257218837738037,
0.10624399781227112,
0.6818547248840332,
0.6752543449401855,
-0.5687028169631958,
0.7276135683059692,
-0.03898856043815613,
-0.5200656652450562,
0.4484266936779022,
-0.8830522894859314,
0.07255221903324127,
-0.06602364778518677,
0.38787928223609924,
-1.1210212707519531,
-0.353571355342865,
0.007640125695616007,
-0.3244742751121521,
0.25947844982147217,
0.3021997809410095,
-0.41023126244544983,
-0.7036150097846985,
-0.8354454040527344,
0.2498844861984253,
0.05507389083504677,
-0.4837648868560791,
0.35950571298599243,
0.13460874557495117,
0.1660579890012741,
-0.9431115984916687,
-1.0213903188705444,
0.15241561830043793,
-0.19250978529453278,
-1.0509757995605469,
0.06634832918643951,
-0.45193248987197876,
-0.23814773559570312,
-0.15467646718025208,
-0.07592231035232544,
-0.33605262637138367,
0.37807735800743103,
-0.14567285776138306,
0.34830063581466675,
-0.7937155961990356,
0.21698720753192902,
-0.20576529204845428,
-0.0005334828747436404,
0.013073630630970001,
-0.09942717850208282,
0.5461932420730591,
-0.2284652441740036,
-0.11264081299304962,
-0.19573533535003662,
0.15259864926338196,
0.7605562806129456,
-0.43963658809661865,
0.4681697189807892,
0.5751614570617676,
-0.6097837090492249,
0.0013257407117635012,
-0.4545891284942627,
0.1283777356147766,
-0.46759024262428284,
0.5823953151702881,
-0.6293896436691284,
-0.7792102098464966,
0.5663237571716309,
0.44130221009254456,
0.8134614825248718,
0.5680769085884094,
0.6843041181564331,
0.25255802273750305,
0.7273494005203247,
0.35281091928482056,
-0.3473479449748993,
0.2035464346408844,
-0.18267711997032166,
-0.3143223822116852,
-0.5878130793571472,
-0.09290439635515213,
-0.38358065485954285,
-0.25056979060173035,
-0.2383067011833191,
-0.1912716180086136,
-0.1932198405265808,
-0.09584271162748337,
-0.3100581467151642,
0.4856146275997162,
-0.2303917557001114,
0.16056492924690247,
0.1644786298274994,
0.30148252844810486,
0.4333413541316986,
-0.43258222937583923,
0.11742035299539566,
0.12661118805408478,
-0.40490278601646423,
-0.324077844619751,
1.3422209024429321,
0.44925254583358765,
0.6159821152687073,
0.2770204246044159,
0.2325877696275711,
0.05973202735185623,
0.7148993611335754,
-0.8234001994132996,
0.40301617980003357,
-0.39002954959869385,
-0.9978454113006592,
-0.3642424941062927,
-0.5042887926101685,
-0.6472423076629639,
0.4194580316543579,
0.09496796876192093,
-0.6245368123054504,
-0.3128606379032135,
-0.22858826816082,
-0.45575833320617676,
0.23679767549037933,
-0.8444859385490417,
1.0695370435714722,
-0.3094128966331482,
-0.049759767949581146,
-0.09575163573026657,
-0.43599069118499756,
1.027435064315796,
-0.26120954751968384,
-0.010649822652339935,
-0.1594335287809372,
-0.1010890007019043,
0.7310864925384521,
0.02425699308514595,
0.442079097032547,
-0.06841124594211578,
-0.2333475798368454,
0.1285477727651596,
-0.04360940307378769,
0.1328423023223877,
0.02789866365492344,
-0.759978175163269,
-0.08143439888954163,
0.05164137855172157,
-0.6983591914176941,
-0.42509618401527405,
0.8499842286109924,
-0.7399859428405762,
-0.5773171186447144,
0.029761819168925285,
-0.5410746335983276,
-0.0017315796576440334,
0.3193263113498688,
0.13855460286140442,
0.6614440083503723,
-0.3140053153038025,
0.679547905921936,
0.2879183292388916,
-0.2807024419307709,
0.5300726890563965,
0.6406701803207397,
-0.17078319191932678,
-0.3501299321651459,
0.6807892918586731,
0.2539462149143219,
0.29793596267700195,
0.4002400040626526,
0.4965890347957611,
-0.2104814201593399,
-0.29898694157600403,
-0.8340558409690857,
0.18483661115169525,
-0.6524723768234253,
0.08264128118753433,
-0.7583987712860107,
-0.3131616711616516,
-0.3108448386192322,
0.11732316017150879,
-0.23069243133068085,
-0.3668087422847748,
-0.04153567925095558,
-0.32010388374328613,
-0.16422148048877716,
0.645018458366394,
0.5783905386924744,
0.16753411293029785,
-0.8180108666419983,
0.4566114842891693,
0.12555581331253052,
0.6005045175552368,
0.2710999846458435,
-0.4606849253177643,
-0.2755187451839447,
0.11787056922912598,
-0.3101930022239685,
-0.8005053400993347,
0.008059144020080566,
0.32473132014274597,
0.6492213606834412,
0.6699346899986267,
0.21101175248622894,
0.8848861455917358,
-0.3957439661026001,
1.1568036079406738,
-0.001931309001520276,
-0.9274981617927551,
0.2803473174571991,
-0.43373966217041016,
0.605352520942688,
0.4744623303413391,
0.22582799196243286,
-0.7103426456451416,
-0.28576263785362244,
-0.5709543228149414,
-0.2037963569164276,
0.8741137385368347,
0.06824380904436111,
0.09249870479106903,
0.49422383308410645,
0.1391960084438324,
0.4460473358631134,
0.2194550335407257,
-0.8032317161560059,
-0.45137155055999756,
-0.3063410222530365,
-0.12578828632831573,
-0.3601774573326111,
-0.14178016781806946,
-0.05487850680947304,
-0.18629290163516998,
0.22868923842906952,
-0.0022504094522446394,
-0.04457799345254898,
-0.27136674523353577,
-0.1796576976776123,
-0.3523235619068146,
0.31964004039764404,
0.8328430652618408,
1.3222907781600952,
-0.4900018572807312,
-0.19343945384025574,
0.22159412503242493,
-0.5810968279838562,
-0.11297028511762619,
0.20080731809139252,
0.07553659379482269,
0.07127448171377182,
0.4984528720378876,
0.618384063243866,
0.08185490220785141,
-0.8394194841384888,
0.3971761465072632,
-0.041333336383104324,
-0.4258825182914734,
-0.2947600781917572,
0.12618742883205414,
0.3013942241668701,
-0.1467408686876297,
0.7930708527565002,
-0.31029045581817627,
0.3630262017250061,
-0.4423431158065796,
0.4493563175201416,
0.15813222527503967,
-0.3251129984855652,
-0.4599548876285553,
0.455598920583725,
0.21362411975860596,
-0.13115903735160828,
0.3680218756198883,
0.13035564124584198,
-0.44165149331092834,
0.811082661151886,
0.34064698219299316,
0.8528020977973938,
-0.3691447377204895,
0.315187931060791,
0.6009922027587891,
0.3543306887149811,
-0.3881681561470032,
0.3481208086013794,
-0.14207422733306885,
-0.4576968252658844,
-0.6739012598991394,
-0.39159759879112244,
-0.5500067472457886,
0.6420081257820129,
-0.5601107478141785,
0.5017411112785339,
-0.3729582726955414,
0.06326042115688324,
0.043226055800914764,
0.6317706108093262,
-0.4208711087703705,
0.4799668788909912,
0.21254630386829376,
1.0762255191802979,
-0.9253045916557312,
1.2683888673782349,
0.8383910059928894,
-0.11981573700904846,
-0.719712495803833,
-0.12497954070568085,
-0.09680012613534927,
-0.5386808514595032,
0.492934912443161,
0.6397719383239746,
0.09599967300891876,
-0.34316080808639526,
-0.5600636005401611,
-0.8626934885978699,
1.2568857669830322,
0.46500006318092346,
-0.24360716342926025,
-0.08681043237447739,
-0.03650662302970886,
0.507315993309021,
-0.3425689935684204,
0.40901514887809753,
0.8003621101379395,
0.5431982278823853,
0.1230304017663002,
-1.0450578927993774,
0.14482466876506805,
-0.49234962463378906,
-0.44066256284713745,
0.1155061349272728,
-0.7142636179924011,
1.074301838874817,
-0.18923437595367432,
-0.35128432512283325,
0.25513291358947754,
0.40584009885787964,
0.5530295968055725,
0.544204592704773,
0.45150113105773926,
0.32661598920822144,
0.8271978497505188,
-0.11416509002447128,
1.1199603080749512,
-0.16665449738502502,
0.43501073122024536,
1.0646297931671143,
-0.08364538848400116,
0.7556105852127075,
0.014408735558390617,
-0.275995135307312,
0.10992041975259781,
1.2186299562454224,
-0.014334946870803833,
0.11140454560518265,
0.16921007633209229,
0.11932654678821564,
-0.3870127499103546,
-0.11565873771905899,
-0.5940161943435669,
0.17361986637115479,
0.29068389534950256,
-0.1723155528306961,
-0.6371933817863464,
-0.12284840643405914,
-0.09962073713541031,
-0.10997568070888519,
-0.2687379717826843,
0.263958215713501,
0.2167096585035324,
-0.5824681520462036,
0.8226633667945862,
0.1286839246749878,
0.7350793480873108,
-0.6109490394592285,
0.042016249150037766,
-0.2068323791027069,
0.016744980588555336,
-0.37704893946647644,
-1.016395926475525,
0.08842729777097702,
-0.23455823957920074,
0.22906020283699036,
0.11760423332452774,
0.6110993027687073,
-0.6023758053779602,
-0.5292218327522278,
0.3196539580821991,
0.42410746216773987,
0.09476794302463531,
-0.057731810957193375,
-0.9157583117485046,
-0.27795249223709106,
-0.002752340864390135,
-0.46711549162864685,
-0.04370272904634476,
0.3363174796104431,
-0.14749076962471008,
0.8896703124046326,
0.609054446220398,
-0.19029995799064636,
0.024326536804437637,
0.24120938777923584,
0.7121351957321167,
-0.6859505772590637,
-0.7041105628013611,
-0.8471546173095703,
0.5408295392990112,
-0.13778989017009735,
-0.43879327178001404,
0.6875158548355103,
0.51510089635849,
0.6957420110702515,
-0.05757652968168259,
0.7218223214149475,
0.03205576166510582,
0.3268353044986725,
-0.28346070647239685,
0.8362181782722473,
-1.012206792831421,
-0.08863283693790436,
-0.32950806617736816,
-0.9087146520614624,
-0.4002396762371063,
0.19695542752742767,
-0.3217444121837616,
0.014738623984158039,
0.6691698431968689,
0.39605608582496643,
-0.1836092621088028,
0.2693343758583069,
0.6655784845352173,
-0.08421044051647186,
0.46932947635650635,
1.113371729850769,
0.6724563837051392,
-0.5454673171043396,
0.5892548561096191,
-0.33747395873069763,
-0.21289154887199402,
-0.2938719391822815,
-0.7096692323684692,
-1.087146520614624,
-0.3000400960445404,
-0.11457102745771408,
-0.24824224412441254,
-0.1486385613679886,
0.8643049597740173,
0.6501880288124084,
-1.0836979150772095,
-0.5685837268829346,
0.4119236469268799,
0.08566205948591232,
-0.31119826436042786,
-0.23806433379650116,
0.6258280873298645,
-0.09834996610879898,
-0.683365523815155,
0.22903653979301453,
0.04517466947436333,
-0.20909273624420166,
-0.47527217864990234,
-0.3293987512588501,
-0.09366066753864288,
-0.2565540671348572,
0.6286463141441345,
0.1345786303281784,
-0.7690152525901794,
-0.2020014077425003,
0.403365820646286,
-0.3533150255680084,
0.21063010394573212,
0.7942457795143127,
-0.3063616454601288,
0.6120301485061646,
0.7184128165245056,
0.7354233860969543,
0.3445018231868744,
0.0021238040644675493,
0.9826623797416687,
-0.5262848138809204,
0.12619423866271973,
0.01657520793378353,
0.4233710467815399,
0.4455735385417938,
-0.2543930411338806,
0.7151170969009399,
-0.09234669804573059,
-0.09926780313253403,
-0.7775254845619202,
0.042956896126270294,
-1.0761263370513916,
-0.41776952147483826,
1.1565444469451904,
-0.255216121673584,
-0.16022539138793945,
-0.18320710957050323,
-0.20573508739471436,
0.10671169310808182,
-0.4082356095314026,
0.5590256452560425,
1.2157764434814453,
0.3425629138946533,
-0.4907182455062866,
-0.9098458290100098,
0.21551448106765747,
0.3893342614173889,
-0.6706042885780334,
0.2042062133550644,
0.36468783020973206,
0.3715081512928009,
0.1547316163778305,
0.5969732999801636,
-0.2813684344291687,
0.8107026219367981,
-0.28954386711120605,
-0.23576436936855316,
-0.2667456567287445,
-0.16930654644966125,
-0.3938753604888916,
0.375615656375885,
-0.011576632969081402,
-0.24824921786785126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01851v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01851v1
|
Rethinking LLM Language Adaptation: A Case Study on Chinese Mixtral
| 2024-03-04T09:01:10 | 2024-03-04T09:01:10 |
Yiming Cui, Xin Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Mixtral, a representative sparse mixture of experts (SMoE) language model,
has received significant attention due to its unique model design and superior
performance. Based on Mixtral-8x7B-v0.1, in this paper, we propose
Chinese-Mixtral and Chinese-Mixtral-Instruct with improved Chinese language
abilities by adopting further pre-training and instruction fine-tuning.
Experimental results show that our Chinese-Mixtral and Chinese-Mixtral-Instruct
successfully improve Chinese understanding and generation performance while
retaining the original English abilities. Then, we discuss several key
questions when performing language adaptation on large language models,
including the necessity of extending the language-specific vocabulary and the
choice of the initialization model (foundation model v.s. instruction model),
by providing empirical results and analysis. We also present the visualizations
of each expert to examine their importance on downstream tasks. Our resources
are publicly available through \url{https://github.com/ymcui/Chinese-Mixtral}.
|
[
-0.2006995528936386,
-0.6140559315681458,
0.2743472158908844,
0.255673885345459,
-0.2301541119813919,
0.05658397451043129,
-0.5733301043510437,
-0.5000967979431152,
0.09198243916034698,
0.6295851469039917,
-0.4757396876811981,
0.02137216366827488,
-0.5498853325843811,
0.011142568662762642,
-0.21490567922592163,
0.8552608489990234,
-0.045151155441999435,
0.18310405313968658,
0.20751869678497314,
-0.2216344177722931,
-0.6791987419128418,
-0.27835679054260254,
-0.7392283082008362,
-0.2182488590478897,
0.39080363512039185,
0.4753934442996979,
0.8862156867980957,
0.5884065628051758,
0.056423015892505646,
0.2670779228210449,
-0.08202293515205383,
0.1492072343826294,
-0.7706915140151978,
-0.2659136652946472,
-0.020884409546852112,
-0.5021606683731079,
-0.6087508797645569,
-0.09866934269666672,
0.7009565830230713,
0.7921741008758545,
-0.46816423535346985,
-0.15980176627635956,
0.31614887714385986,
0.452077180147171,
-0.36818405985832214,
-0.18149131536483765,
-0.9807031750679016,
-0.0980653241276741,
0.10250993072986603,
-0.32623860239982605,
-0.5574941039085388,
0.09588397294282913,
0.043170902878046036,
-0.8224560022354126,
0.20734234154224396,
0.10572829097509384,
0.45005691051483154,
0.25020983815193176,
-0.2061024159193039,
-0.28183573484420776,
-0.6149478554725647,
0.7339572906494141,
-1.1237409114837646,
0.46020328998565674,
-0.05658423900604248,
0.39601898193359375,
-0.5172657370567322,
-0.5534501075744629,
-0.3811294436454773,
-0.39610716700553894,
0.1508173644542694,
0.2362111359834671,
0.43269243836402893,
0.06114950031042099,
-0.06017162650823593,
0.41419702768325806,
-0.24070867896080017,
0.4698755145072937,
-0.4494570195674896,
-0.12351571768522263,
0.8969787359237671,
0.11824767291545868,
0.6624218821525574,
0.3752746880054474,
-0.21522073447704315,
0.11977314949035645,
-0.7170358896255493,
-0.13972976803779602,
0.17934472858905792,
0.5881691575050354,
-0.3484143316745758,
0.056564826518297195,
-0.10761421173810959,
0.8105071783065796,
0.37577906250953674,
-0.3817426860332489,
0.29699766635894775,
-0.40549466013908386,
-0.19918063282966614,
0.11476263403892517,
0.463821679353714,
0.12310100346803665,
0.33055707812309265,
-0.12951485812664032,
-0.3287692368030548,
-0.39364859461784363,
0.10610317438840866,
-0.6565567255020142,
-0.3959493637084961,
0.1546228677034378,
-0.3239859342575073,
-0.08093825727701187,
-0.10489197075366974,
-0.37011727690696716,
-0.5864395499229431,
-0.497125506401062,
0.5475232601165771,
-0.32720375061035156,
-0.6133326292037964,
0.2915004789829254,
0.07422501593828201,
0.426771342754364,
0.6718885898590088,
-1.0904209613800049,
0.38867583870887756,
0.5940070748329163,
0.4764411747455597,
-0.38302987813949585,
-0.7246903777122498,
-0.26857230067253113,
0.16108833253383636,
-0.384295791387558,
0.7219573855400085,
-0.3602684438228607,
-0.23244380950927734,
-0.08622898161411285,
0.08528419584035873,
-0.3199114203453064,
-0.8151353597640991,
0.1747940480709076,
-0.17025911808013916,
0.3663172721862793,
-0.16422230005264282,
-0.33043625950813293,
-0.11334183812141418,
-0.15733812749385834,
-0.5896148085594177,
0.9565321803092957,
0.05885310471057892,
-0.66938716173172,
0.440997451543808,
-0.41585561633110046,
-0.48356524109840393,
0.2113502323627472,
-0.1631082147359848,
0.19241182506084442,
0.2304607778787613,
0.34107327461242676,
0.532185435295105,
-0.05457299202680588,
0.09013941138982773,
-0.1973576545715332,
-0.5147601962089539,
0.1311807632446289,
-0.24578583240509033,
0.9803592562675476,
0.11003026366233826,
-0.18092703819274902,
0.32501283288002014,
-0.8229488134384155,
-0.07498487085103989,
0.011517887003719807,
-0.36056554317474365,
-0.26688331365585327,
-0.0029960223473608494,
0.06175106018781662,
0.2423299252986908,
0.204143688082695,
0.07354144006967545,
0.04658089205622673,
-0.4335932731628418,
0.299215704202652,
0.9814680814743042,
-0.09365767985582352,
0.7234171032905579,
-0.2860831320285797,
0.4871831238269806,
0.12518680095672607,
0.09836284816265106,
-0.153057262301445,
-0.2577282190322876,
-1.0398647785186768,
-0.2890922427177429,
0.39272382855415344,
0.6362155675888062,
-0.9120738506317139,
0.06504347920417786,
-0.09783200919628143,
-0.2873884439468384,
-0.8541414141654968,
0.532329261302948,
-0.013975461944937706,
0.13692830502986908,
0.18239609897136688,
-0.41477277874946594,
-0.4561183750629425,
-0.5637450814247131,
-0.08738983422517776,
-0.10197357088327408,
-0.06858918070793152,
0.3973166048526764,
0.023502731695771217,
-0.34661394357681274,
0.3261577785015106,
-0.12631268799304962,
0.2930300533771515,
-0.7304299473762512,
-0.35186731815338135,
0.2615881562232971,
0.34878087043762207,
0.781782329082489,
-0.521682858467102,
-0.504207968711853,
0.29561764001846313,
-0.6011950969696045,
-0.2820201814174652,
-0.5284317135810852,
-0.2803843915462494,
0.003419846063479781,
0.49297282099723816,
-0.23147356510162354,
-0.03780028969049454,
0.7438593506813049,
-0.062355056405067444,
0.7878384590148926,
-0.5028191208839417,
-0.1162036806344986,
-1.318488359451294,
-0.37184175848960876,
-0.08787666261196136,
-0.046464111655950546,
-0.9805850386619568,
0.5362007021903992,
0.04813472554087639,
-0.0005143748130649328,
-0.5877680778503418,
0.4651957154273987,
-0.7315950989723206,
-0.13819745182991028,
-0.5617195963859558,
0.3498370051383972,
-0.3401108682155609,
0.5269775390625,
-0.022698815912008286,
0.8343967199325562,
0.551803708076477,
-0.8626696467399597,
0.18078814446926117,
-0.28827086091041565,
-0.17725469172000885,
0.06216081231832504,
-0.4712020754814148,
0.3029327094554901,
-0.0577947236597538,
-0.05098487436771393,
-0.9573370218276978,
-0.14997459948062897,
0.34803855419158936,
-0.08651065081357956,
0.479863703250885,
0.20382605493068695,
-0.3618611693382263,
0.09884276241064072,
-0.28079622983932495,
0.2311031073331833,
0.4919518828392029,
-0.5480831265449524,
0.6346704363822937,
0.35185304284095764,
-0.14171218872070312,
-0.3927668631076813,
-0.5416538715362549,
0.09528633207082748,
-0.13385216891765594,
-0.7268549203872681,
0.22169804573059082,
-0.4778018891811371,
-0.429458886384964,
-0.204935684800148,
-0.0901486948132515,
-0.312776654958725,
0.40451398491859436,
-0.05310341343283653,
0.22541050612926483,
-0.6883710622787476,
-0.29526564478874207,
0.313461571931839,
0.12279325723648071,
-0.17568257451057434,
-0.07036745548248291,
0.30102571845054626,
0.07311857491731644,
-0.0961829274892807,
-0.3051058053970337,
0.040226761251688004,
0.30567342042922974,
0.08664648979902267,
0.8501870036125183,
0.486519455909729,
-0.2636435329914093,
-0.5260306000709534,
-0.4239717125892639,
-0.20429672300815582,
-0.5296123623847961,
0.6468798518180847,
-0.3191054165363312,
-0.9129267930984497,
0.5049386620521545,
-0.07245072722434998,
0.386037141084671,
0.3366375267505646,
0.8611981868743896,
0.0858975425362587,
0.5921651124954224,
0.9391962289810181,
-0.33830776810646057,
0.722114622592926,
0.16787481307983398,
0.1324748396873474,
-0.655851423740387,
0.10846401751041412,
-0.1350693255662918,
0.04460160806775093,
-0.5292007327079773,
-0.5272656679153442,
-0.1256224811077118,
0.08274496346712112,
0.15462733805179596,
0.37748798727989197,
-0.1723344475030899,
0.29866868257522583,
-0.04979155585169792,
0.25650712847709656,
0.08190212398767471,
0.024938490241765976,
-0.08465854078531265,
0.02519066073000431,
-1.1009089946746826,
-0.2581076920032501,
0.858856201171875,
0.38262420892715454,
0.7418381571769714,
0.09886089712381363,
0.5807849764823914,
0.24640564620494843,
0.5216042995452881,
-0.5050408244132996,
0.5532304644584656,
-0.22402004897594452,
-0.4822810888290405,
-0.2759508490562439,
-0.22815436124801636,
-0.6503732204437256,
0.7757298350334167,
-0.3791857957839966,
-0.45801836252212524,
-0.035145409405231476,
0.148540198802948,
-0.3115585744380951,
-0.07240968197584152,
-0.9060231447219849,
0.7452313899993896,
-0.5515482425689697,
-0.22648362815380096,
-0.3271804749965668,
-0.2832795977592468,
0.5745822191238403,
-0.3026675879955292,
0.6563341021537781,
0.11684500426054001,
0.03098876029253006,
0.5375823974609375,
-0.07680429518222809,
0.8337835073471069,
-0.021928591653704643,
-0.352056086063385,
0.2554584741592407,
-0.13089358806610107,
0.2611209750175476,
-0.20822910964488983,
-0.24501162767410278,
-0.10688640177249908,
-0.08954186737537384,
-0.6042234301567078,
-0.7587817907333374,
0.5827776789665222,
-1.087948203086853,
-0.8831757307052612,
0.08881708979606628,
-0.7758045196533203,
-0.05607854947447777,
0.17278552055358887,
-0.1448618769645691,
0.1897183507680893,
-0.08210247755050659,
0.027143128216266632,
0.5624350905418396,
-0.509490966796875,
0.20425449311733246,
0.536710798740387,
-0.36314526200294495,
-0.4477934241294861,
0.9321569800376892,
0.12968949973583221,
0.5564056634902954,
0.18237797915935516,
0.27102145552635193,
0.31488463282585144,
-0.8599537014961243,
-0.5676369667053223,
0.4141916334629059,
-0.721401572227478,
0.4457170367240906,
-0.2943649888038635,
-0.4529235363006592,
-0.46023061871528625,
-0.17885039746761322,
-0.3753677308559418,
-0.2337506264448166,
-0.4611468017101288,
-0.06968977302312851,
-0.19970948994159698,
0.6585240364074707,
0.2569253146648407,
0.6396910548210144,
-0.4651290774345398,
0.2706950306892395,
0.19842420518398285,
0.034959468990564346,
0.13275404274463654,
-1.1702461242675781,
-0.6691335439682007,
0.08079365640878677,
0.02738938108086586,
-0.7985015511512756,
0.15819498896598816,
0.3292526304721832,
1.1669756174087524,
0.41558578610420227,
-0.20717737078666687,
0.899176299571991,
-0.5821785926818848,
0.6415776014328003,
-0.08568606525659561,
-0.7877673506736755,
0.16982504725456238,
-0.16531017422676086,
0.15314626693725586,
0.3579641282558441,
0.0265028215944767,
-0.47123438119888306,
-0.4126906394958496,
-0.5159837007522583,
-0.8843843936920166,
0.7146780490875244,
-0.042689986526966095,
0.25941264629364014,
0.6094059348106384,
0.6818191409111023,
0.4083026647567749,
0.06253735721111298,
-1.0036789178848267,
-0.1298806518316269,
-0.186229407787323,
-0.3638741970062256,
-0.20001544058322906,
-0.5432805418968201,
0.1444292664527893,
-0.25575053691864014,
0.5563867688179016,
-0.11145837604999542,
0.0220544021576643,
-0.2908508777618408,
-0.5335738062858582,
-0.015168305486440659,
0.2840191721916199,
0.6872807741165161,
0.9018234610557556,
0.016425779089331627,
-0.08031514286994934,
0.7100456953048706,
-0.4395363926887512,
-0.13099120557308197,
-0.12418021261692047,
-0.059503622353076935,
-0.23097868263721466,
0.7329382300376892,
0.8407495021820068,
0.5104233026504517,
-0.672836422920227,
0.12323561310768127,
0.11543198674917221,
-0.20069153606891632,
-0.16550371050834656,
0.6267342567443848,
0.16940678656101227,
0.15228919684886932,
0.335477739572525,
-0.24163566529750824,
0.0604541189968586,
-0.6438360810279846,
0.14230965077877045,
0.10212121158838272,
-0.03340107575058937,
-0.5205978155136108,
0.6247932314872742,
0.40601009130477905,
-0.26164260506629944,
0.15823085606098175,
-0.0022417032159864902,
-0.44873833656311035,
0.5116564035415649,
0.8243191838264465,
0.5993749499320984,
-0.5132117867469788,
-0.10586202889680862,
0.09380006045103073,
0.6478468179702759,
-0.29851430654525757,
0.14435052871704102,
0.002651361981406808,
-1.0198527574539185,
-0.5943858623504639,
-0.14209586381912231,
-0.5287046432495117,
0.1234860047698021,
-0.36727893352508545,
0.3797617554664612,
-0.8317705988883972,
0.4274006187915802,
-0.060092806816101074,
-0.06628101319074631,
-0.3287105858325958,
0.2860204577445984,
0.41284066438674927,
0.9510663747787476,
-1.0570998191833496,
0.9912546873092651,
0.7548550963401794,
-0.003927711863070726,
-0.9553266167640686,
0.15288029611110687,
-0.22029824554920197,
-0.9302826523780823,
0.2874593734741211,
-0.011297816410660744,
-0.009101301431655884,
-0.1408700793981552,
-0.6617183089256287,
-0.7341241240501404,
1.1324454545974731,
0.526483416557312,
-0.48147052526474,
0.245522141456604,
-0.08140520751476288,
0.7240450382232666,
-0.7260242700576782,
0.39935800433158875,
0.5369298458099365,
0.08478201180696487,
0.03488566726446152,
-0.9210678935050964,
0.09886240214109421,
-0.15670765936374664,
0.038067564368247986,
-0.264240562915802,
-0.6995604634284973,
0.9282017946243286,
-0.23300154507160187,
-0.17453217506408691,
-0.012119321152567863,
1.010719656944275,
0.4806775748729706,
0.2816123068332672,
0.6343787312507629,
0.06075020879507065,
0.7425081133842468,
0.37609100341796875,
0.8071771264076233,
-0.4010726809501648,
-0.056168317794799805,
1.1172579526901245,
-0.29642030596733093,
0.9083185195922852,
0.4600474536418915,
-0.32354480028152466,
0.5507476925849915,
0.7269960045814514,
0.2475186288356781,
0.37684980034828186,
-0.04533616825938225,
-0.0024986974895000458,
-0.2907189428806305,
0.11608598381280899,
-0.4278210997581482,
0.1637510508298874,
0.45528948307037354,
-0.20934157073497772,
0.1773339956998825,
-0.34307143092155457,
-0.013243141584098339,
0.004458873067051172,
-0.4367614686489105,
0.5193209648132324,
0.20093770325183868,
-0.35819441080093384,
0.6435548067092896,
0.0789647102355957,
0.7573485374450684,
-0.22600331902503967,
0.09098058938980103,
-0.3829067051410675,
0.1095968708395958,
-0.3530101776123047,
-0.48165154457092285,
-0.1894080936908722,
-0.3602360785007477,
0.11268849670886993,
0.11915707588195801,
0.929454505443573,
-0.6481021642684937,
-0.5682638883590698,
0.373993843793869,
0.5306700468063354,
0.2728605270385742,
0.2665857970714569,
-0.8335421085357666,
0.09450355917215347,
0.3437550663948059,
-0.034886620938777924,
0.4929761290550232,
0.7634289860725403,
0.005346321035176516,
0.7074400186538696,
0.6279283761978149,
0.3564133942127228,
0.43881577253341675,
0.3680255115032196,
0.8791624903678894,
-0.5901345610618591,
-0.5485654473304749,
-0.6269112825393677,
0.49182942509651184,
0.09102184325456619,
-0.1319333165884018,
0.8668516874313354,
0.16634026169776917,
1.0148292779922485,
-0.1320577710866928,
0.7953997850418091,
0.17289121448993683,
0.16076436638832092,
-0.6697452068328857,
0.5032488107681274,
-0.8360781669616699,
0.42033660411834717,
-0.40773263573646545,
-0.8555501103401184,
-0.08877342194318771,
0.45395269989967346,
-0.10195453464984894,
0.3049132227897644,
0.4838019907474518,
0.8589321374893188,
-0.19820678234100342,
-0.15942883491516113,
0.573066234588623,
0.4627223014831543,
0.11206889897584915,
0.5041157007217407,
0.8414071202278137,
-0.37024566531181335,
0.3791464865207672,
-0.280821293592453,
-0.3807141184806824,
-0.4587729275226593,
-0.7058064937591553,
-0.9906623959541321,
-0.13631939888000488,
-0.3536568582057953,
-0.04431368410587311,
0.15019778907299042,
0.972419798374176,
0.49500319361686707,
-0.9086344838142395,
-0.5948377251625061,
0.22864533960819244,
0.15237300097942352,
-0.31333687901496887,
-0.1235666424036026,
0.10536976903676987,
-0.4106062948703766,
-0.5224512815475464,
0.3868494927883148,
0.3728307783603668,
0.060812316834926605,
-0.19058427214622498,
-0.47626832127571106,
0.07385208457708359,
0.07988010346889496,
0.5470414161682129,
0.2076658010482788,
-0.8241771459579468,
-0.17894169688224792,
-0.019562048837542534,
-0.026417307555675507,
-0.05539399012923241,
0.8858595490455627,
-0.3041178286075592,
0.2894330620765686,
0.25220611691474915,
0.8818562030792236,
0.011315110139548779,
-0.1387528032064438,
0.8014589548110962,
-0.3015907406806946,
0.5283353924751282,
-0.39715105295181274,
0.5561273694038391,
0.4711521565914154,
-0.4093286991119385,
0.284052312374115,
0.30192697048187256,
-0.36005011200904846,
-0.809490442276001,
-0.007388632278889418,
-1.0331791639328003,
-0.30213555693626404,
1.4361038208007812,
-0.06578139960765839,
-0.2639811635017395,
-0.018398869782686234,
-0.5646278262138367,
0.19091099500656128,
-0.19632531702518463,
0.7526454329490662,
0.727418839931488,
-0.012146654538810253,
-0.7278689742088318,
-0.7009508013725281,
0.05288032442331314,
0.6045152544975281,
-0.6152483820915222,
0.07571962475776672,
0.1491786539554596,
0.4698116183280945,
-0.3368053734302521,
0.7253314256668091,
0.26238325238227844,
0.33219099044799805,
0.1272650957107544,
0.0906670093536377,
0.07089389115571976,
-0.27392613887786865,
-0.41646602749824524,
-0.2655002176761627,
0.8250275254249573,
0.10605009645223618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01848v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01848v1
|
CET2: Modelling Topic Transitions for Coherent and Engaging Knowledge-Grounded Conversations
| 2024-03-04T08:55:34 | 2024-03-04T08:55:34 |
Lin Xu, Qixian Zhou, Jinlan Fu, See-Kiong Ng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge-grounded dialogue systems aim to generate coherent and engaging
responses based on the dialogue contexts and selected external knowledge.
Previous knowledge selection methods tend to rely too heavily on the dialogue
contexts or over-emphasize the new information in the selected knowledge,
resulting in the selection of repetitious or incongruous knowledge and further
generating repetitive or incoherent responses, as the generation of the
response depends on the chosen knowledge. To address these shortcomings, we
introduce a Coherent and Engaging Topic Transition (CET2) framework to model
topic transitions for selecting knowledge that is coherent to the context of
the conversations while providing adequate knowledge diversity for topic
development. Our CET2 framework considers multiple factors for knowledge
selection, including valid transition logic from dialogue contexts to the
following topics and systematic comparisons between available knowledge
candidates. Extensive experiments on two public benchmarks demonstrate the
superiority and the better generalization ability of CET2 on knowledge
selection. This is due to our well-designed transition features and comparative
knowledge selection strategy, which are more transferable to conversations
about unseen topics. Analysis of fine-grained knowledge selection accuracy also
shows that CET2 can better balance topic entailment (contextual coherence) and
development (knowledge diversity) in dialogue than existing approaches.
|
[
-0.5269313454627991,
-0.7595961689949036,
0.8660057187080383,
0.1783897876739502,
-0.37521031498908997,
0.091126449406147,
-0.09548027068376541,
-0.3538426458835602,
-0.3367452025413513,
0.383937269449234,
-0.30505385994911194,
-0.3094550669193268,
-0.612071692943573,
-0.42853572964668274,
-0.49237796664237976,
0.9778454899787903,
-0.04041584953665733,
-0.0041037132032215595,
-0.36567240953445435,
0.08655929565429688,
-0.8405086398124695,
-0.11481583118438721,
-0.584308922290802,
-0.5035751461982727,
0.12808898091316223,
0.6086968779563904,
0.5162525773048401,
0.08508455008268356,
0.1066933274269104,
0.12690845131874084,
-0.5460070371627808,
-0.028317948803305626,
-0.8539491891860962,
0.2550366222858429,
-0.7229229807853699,
-0.34522363543510437,
0.01020505279302597,
-0.20284955203533173,
0.2777692973613739,
0.7284004092216492,
0.017466630786657333,
-0.12976650893688202,
0.6147700548171997,
0.2964414060115814,
-0.5492969155311584,
0.14055125415325165,
-0.7411257028579712,
-0.059871524572372437,
0.2117120623588562,
-0.013905477710068226,
-0.3439272940158844,
-0.2134345918893814,
0.7466647028923035,
-0.6821984052658081,
0.10507601499557495,
-0.47785285115242004,
0.6249330043792725,
0.02105032652616501,
-1.0017714500427246,
-0.2551071047782898,
-0.9058473110198975,
0.7122135162353516,
-0.24086415767669678,
0.5670768618583679,
0.26466143131256104,
0.152683287858963,
0.019990045577287674,
-0.9864343404769897,
-0.39965730905532837,
0.19612209498882294,
0.22028377652168274,
0.4353058934211731,
0.05156761407852173,
0.09300746768712997,
-0.12536689639091492,
0.10526826232671738,
-0.3103998899459839,
-0.3479352295398712,
-0.18531057238578796,
-0.20827879011631012,
0.17925362288951874,
0.15669341385364532,
-0.05816648527979851,
-0.0848044827580452,
-0.4625501334667206,
-0.12075553834438324,
-0.5077415704727173,
0.02544400468468666,
0.19586549699306488,
-0.06513824313879013,
-0.04393542557954788,
0.19952163100242615,
-0.45041024684906006,
0.35620030760765076,
0.3832626938819885,
-0.20648036897182465,
-0.20920954644680023,
-0.6210419535636902,
0.12355855107307434,
-0.1246027797460556,
0.12287139892578125,
0.6741006374359131,
-0.14012561738491058,
-0.07227207720279694,
0.33021315932273865,
0.15888667106628418,
0.06721125543117523,
-0.9568328261375427,
-0.33088207244873047,
0.14839932322502136,
-0.4496651589870453,
-0.1298622339963913,
0.10457369685173035,
-1.0541855096817017,
-0.19464533030986786,
-0.3736901581287384,
0.07939224690198898,
-0.48322388529777527,
-0.7549728751182556,
0.19825194776058197,
-0.33035808801651,
0.43137890100479126,
0.8559740781784058,
-0.718569278717041,
0.46129176020622253,
0.9289417862892151,
0.5746178030967712,
-0.4196546971797943,
0.16884875297546387,
-0.14620958268642426,
0.26769036054611206,
-0.3026822507381439,
0.7589874267578125,
-0.720121443271637,
-0.8440729975700378,
0.1235525831580162,
-0.11606893688440323,
-0.13036015629768372,
-0.19930700957775116,
0.5513181090354919,
-0.5723466873168945,
0.4898526668548584,
-0.6054846048355103,
-0.6065027713775635,
-0.2959505617618561,
0.42725977301597595,
-0.08627717941999435,
0.7875404953956604,
0.05180490389466286,
-0.9389361143112183,
0.363538533449173,
-0.7028554677963257,
-0.28689122200012207,
-0.22285804152488708,
-0.18842044472694397,
0.11764860153198242,
0.006041414104402065,
-0.15451018512248993,
-0.03978670388460159,
-0.42745235562324524,
0.6606141328811646,
-0.21810056269168854,
0.002606806345283985,
0.028547493740916252,
-0.4719547927379608,
0.20313002169132233,
0.6096251010894775,
-0.3310256898403168,
-0.19995400309562683,
-0.25724199414253235,
0.19382110238075256,
-0.2124968320131302,
-0.16212007403373718,
-0.22716669738292694,
0.25811901688575745,
0.07048624753952026,
0.3025062680244446,
0.14387497305870056,
-0.32240763306617737,
-0.1335964947938919,
-0.47616443037986755,
0.5632590055465698,
0.2991563677787781,
0.5968824625015259,
0.6354585886001587,
-0.348436176776886,
0.1297185719013214,
0.4007266163825989,
-0.017723986878991127,
-0.26528555154800415,
-1.0286455154418945,
-0.8356205821037292,
0.3802378177642822,
0.3557586967945099,
0.6001297235488892,
-0.7912179827690125,
0.5271539092063904,
-0.08713623881340027,
-0.3519379794597626,
0.20537203550338745,
-0.2184770405292511,
0.3586696684360504,
0.6900423765182495,
0.24907845258712769,
-0.3229955732822418,
-0.17175759375095367,
-0.6415684223175049,
-0.2571902573108673,
-0.6494899988174438,
0.10913006961345673,
0.2636193633079529,
0.38553962111473083,
-0.2179577797651291,
1.353477954864502,
-0.5177330374717712,
0.22911329567432404,
-0.19940051436424255,
0.4233754873275757,
-0.1413375586271286,
0.6529210209846497,
0.037516724318265915,
-1.1123793125152588,
-0.45577406883239746,
0.22617168724536896,
-0.5773447751998901,
0.06672433763742447,
-0.10860917717218399,
-0.34020671248435974,
-0.2511661946773529,
0.3460489809513092,
-0.5241371393203735,
0.47300586104393005,
0.19461874663829803,
-0.6880243420600891,
0.18993186950683594,
0.3714372217655182,
0.3732267916202545,
-1.4654138088226318,
0.021321028470993042,
-0.4275955259799957,
-0.05812137573957443,
-0.7074483036994934,
-0.2690453827381134,
0.020601605996489525,
-0.2935987412929535,
-0.607334315776825,
0.7656122446060181,
-0.07423615455627441,
0.11658276617527008,
-0.11555588990449905,
0.1594771444797516,
0.262300044298172,
0.3133087158203125,
0.4019535481929779,
0.6635859608650208,
0.283089280128479,
-0.6676548719406128,
-0.14350071549415588,
0.797987699508667,
-0.3197613060474396,
0.6011001467704773,
-0.4393904507160187,
0.26735007762908936,
0.25393685698509216,
0.38363268971443176,
-0.9739707708358765,
-0.2752531170845032,
0.06916962563991547,
-0.31298065185546875,
0.1506311148405075,
-0.3718976676464081,
-0.2909368574619293,
0.02038918063044548,
-0.07604383677244186,
0.6365569233894348,
0.5068600177764893,
-0.18448501825332642,
0.39833658933639526,
0.21496622264385223,
-0.5566207766532898,
-0.17965660989284515,
-0.539376437664032,
0.04064236581325531,
-0.11614247411489487,
-0.9262890219688416,
0.460077702999115,
-0.11554431915283203,
-0.3076966106891632,
0.011343130841851234,
-0.3332051634788513,
-0.12371443212032318,
0.03121563233435154,
0.07117214053869247,
-0.26959311962127686,
-0.19090887904167175,
0.3302421271800995,
0.7115804553031921,
-0.27578702569007874,
-0.0198997650295496,
-0.648226261138916,
0.7164086103439331,
-0.06597714871168137,
-0.7685985565185547,
-0.33770081400871277,
0.3888905644416809,
0.4565218687057495,
-0.07773754745721817,
0.4812973439693451,
0.5599523186683655,
-0.2552519738674164,
0.21400529146194458,
-0.5452193021774292,
-0.49956604838371277,
-0.3476135730743408,
0.6092756986618042,
-0.46098634600639343,
-1.0507415533065796,
0.6080085635185242,
-0.647606372833252,
0.0050351740792393684,
0.5492323637008667,
0.5885857939720154,
0.05803944543004036,
0.7994182109832764,
0.45182016491889954,
0.6585735082626343,
0.6058631539344788,
-0.25233274698257446,
0.1353440284729004,
-0.8609742522239685,
-0.4812605082988739,
-0.2745104134082794,
-0.12256840616464615,
-0.27691927552223206,
-0.6471015810966492,
0.33670127391815186,
0.5138843655586243,
-0.22748221457004547,
0.10211312025785446,
-0.35252079367637634,
0.3409881293773651,
0.2246740460395813,
0.09875641763210297,
0.30417782068252563,
-0.005494949873536825,
-0.18211592733860016,
-0.3101383149623871,
-0.6015591025352478,
-0.5219902396202087,
1.0094670057296753,
0.6040443181991577,
0.6471410393714905,
0.21608339250087738,
0.5495747923851013,
0.2262088805437088,
-0.08214760571718216,
-0.5304089188575745,
0.49843111634254456,
0.16695618629455566,
-0.6040640473365784,
-0.3811195194721222,
-0.07717042416334152,
-0.7145875692367554,
0.3008887469768524,
0.030273959040641785,
-0.7707048058509827,
0.6538649201393127,
-0.15331661701202393,
-0.2970629036426544,
0.295541912317276,
-0.7737195491790771,
0.6765831112861633,
0.1546514928340912,
-0.5676942467689514,
-0.42424994707107544,
-0.7348270416259766,
0.3562812805175781,
-0.10188121348619461,
-0.025958077982068062,
-0.2177502065896988,
-0.048332635313272476,
0.8494006991386414,
-0.2818167209625244,
0.8467262983322144,
-0.32363107800483704,
-0.22107064723968506,
0.6628596782684326,
0.2462698221206665,
0.30459821224212646,
0.7675836086273193,
-0.0493607297539711,
0.16535277664661407,
0.08438234031200409,
-0.1846449077129364,
-0.5957757234573364,
0.4245837926864624,
-0.8632346391677856,
-0.7849696278572083,
-0.11938240379095078,
-0.27333691716194153,
-0.5024672746658325,
0.028464363887906075,
0.5413968563079834,
0.2992730438709259,
-0.7509204745292664,
0.38412198424339294,
1.0535976886749268,
-0.07128890603780746,
0.07679932564496994,
0.49333691596984863,
-0.029439765959978104,
-0.5782505869865417,
0.6166689395904541,
0.031050030142068863,
0.6067291498184204,
0.3706550598144531,
0.10192123800516129,
-0.48965588212013245,
-0.44806456565856934,
-0.17179185152053833,
-0.37591809034347534,
-0.7749126553535461,
-0.24591663479804993,
-0.9681026935577393,
-0.3925502598285675,
-0.5487090945243835,
-0.16857722401618958,
-0.4483083486557007,
-0.6365083456039429,
-0.4372399151325226,
-0.16578909754753113,
0.13027718663215637,
0.4865725338459015,
-0.17842036485671997,
0.26858800649642944,
-0.6442776918411255,
0.23136989772319794,
0.9190055727958679,
0.028955494984984398,
-0.2961886525154114,
-0.8601120710372925,
0.02314549684524536,
0.17197619378566742,
-1.018272042274475,
-1.120041012763977,
-0.07124482095241547,
0.14743943512439728,
0.5078431367874146,
0.6650474667549133,
0.25566229224205017,
0.3991020619869232,
-0.16256333887577057,
1.0080152750015259,
0.3456937372684479,
-1.0461498498916626,
0.9656301140785217,
-0.6423340439796448,
0.2920966148376465,
0.8194947242736816,
-0.1270509958267212,
-0.5937086343765259,
-0.28003859519958496,
-0.8333501815795898,
-0.8768259882926941,
0.6739023923873901,
0.6983931660652161,
0.21583810448646545,
-0.0854136198759079,
0.16188621520996094,
0.3738219439983368,
0.3942883610725403,
-0.3068181574344635,
0.13776364922523499,
-0.4790753126144409,
0.05430580675601959,
0.3671422004699707,
-0.5045038461685181,
-0.42868107557296753,
-0.11503737419843674,
0.47038814425468445,
-0.2567382752895355,
0.5690678954124451,
0.31926095485687256,
0.017613671720027924,
-0.09753638505935669,
0.4819740653038025,
0.6465968489646912,
0.6928628087043762,
0.0581749863922596,
-0.04045155644416809,
0.5108851790428162,
-0.3158605992794037,
0.13523665070533752,
0.009702221490442753,
-0.27025046944618225,
-0.05949578434228897,
0.12748827040195465,
0.7674948573112488,
0.6842728853225708,
-0.19103430211544037,
0.4829130172729492,
-0.02975357510149479,
-0.6236730217933655,
-0.03868230804800987,
0.22074635326862335,
0.33814293146133423,
0.4664423167705536,
0.13907994329929352,
0.23123721778392792,
0.42507827281951904,
-0.6548629999160767,
0.3801117241382599,
0.05138807371258736,
-0.48224207758903503,
-0.17513391375541687,
0.6861292719841003,
0.7797347903251648,
-0.16558215022087097,
0.4534342288970947,
-0.19650676846504211,
-0.5091899633407593,
0.5812582969665527,
0.47378766536712646,
0.9146366119384766,
-0.07844723016023636,
0.4285217523574829,
0.281460165977478,
-0.12779627740383148,
-0.3336193859577179,
0.31704315543174744,
-0.504202663898468,
-0.9309224486351013,
-0.10052662342786789,
-0.41697457432746887,
-0.7073165774345398,
-0.17035627365112305,
-0.9352194666862488,
0.39234235882759094,
-0.2650948762893677,
-0.25446683168411255,
-0.6683738231658936,
0.023693498224020004,
-0.531527578830719,
0.14955706894397736,
0.08589327335357666,
1.0809088945388794,
-0.8024114966392517,
0.7466214299201965,
0.5253728628158569,
-0.0246760081499815,
-0.4194665849208832,
0.4615528881549835,
-0.008396218530833721,
-0.4717380702495575,
0.37368929386138916,
0.020513270050287247,
0.028381580486893654,
0.08201078325510025,
-0.4261794686317444,
-0.880636990070343,
1.350999116897583,
0.3810705840587616,
-0.5095905661582947,
-0.06145855784416199,
0.2338544875383377,
0.31901100277900696,
-0.39459550380706787,
0.30980026721954346,
0.5169889330863953,
0.5337793231010437,
0.7515549659729004,
-0.9842249155044556,
-0.27037766575813293,
-0.04695437103509903,
0.08510876446962357,
0.10521634668111801,
-0.910102903842926,
0.6474969387054443,
0.01744091510772705,
-0.29928648471832275,
0.4703458547592163,
0.7039978504180908,
0.3639611303806305,
0.7939407229423523,
0.3688215911388397,
0.4713275134563446,
0.6595845818519592,
-0.417936772108078,
0.29471591114997864,
-0.6975732445716858,
0.42087942361831665,
1.0954715013504028,
-0.42698928713798523,
0.7959190011024475,
0.3238797187805176,
-0.06404697895050049,
0.592380702495575,
0.8034639954566956,
0.3658042848110199,
0.7809215784072876,
-0.19594261050224304,
-0.3811885714530945,
-0.49262335896492004,
-0.08579901605844498,
-0.885469377040863,
0.34787726402282715,
0.735889732837677,
-0.027780525386333466,
-0.3293679356575012,
-0.005323627032339573,
-0.18643976747989655,
-0.027821160852909088,
0.16718582808971405,
1.2732597589492798,
0.2660757303237915,
-0.8457633256912231,
0.2105991393327713,
-0.014503405429422855,
0.20466601848602295,
-0.682774007320404,
-0.14731083810329437,
-0.32547494769096375,
-0.2560936510562897,
0.03498266637325287,
-1.0636085271835327,
0.269131064414978,
-0.2662445902824402,
-0.23132535815238953,
-0.42203783988952637,
1.063450574874878,
-0.5279372930526733,
-0.07706061750650406,
0.3134455978870392,
0.7568021416664124,
0.06839434802532196,
-0.13031786680221558,
-0.6433039307594299,
-0.02446177788078785,
0.20449180901050568,
-0.20378516614437103,
0.2582777738571167,
0.8684134483337402,
-0.246344193816185,
0.3601985275745392,
0.5128641128540039,
-0.5122928023338318,
-0.4207232594490051,
-0.12892448902130127,
1.0375579595565796,
-0.5721487402915955,
-0.9896785020828247,
-0.3269772529602051,
0.8837189674377441,
-0.3093360960483551,
-0.4861704707145691,
0.28748229146003723,
0.5387129783630371,
0.4759376347064972,
0.11484907567501068,
0.8135573863983154,
-0.08393754810094833,
0.48306116461753845,
-0.6574903130531311,
0.5853095650672913,
-0.19929203391075134,
0.2705022990703583,
-0.2579025328159332,
-1.025270700454712,
0.3634905219078064,
0.48510876297950745,
-0.4620434045791626,
0.18262606859207153,
0.835021436214447,
0.48390811681747437,
-0.06048312410712242,
0.3813531696796417,
0.6193963885307312,
0.06767431646585464,
0.32648810744285583,
0.6186140179634094,
1.1982630491256714,
-0.39371457695961,
0.5260143280029297,
0.29244229197502136,
-0.11792271584272385,
-0.24211953580379486,
-0.5594465732574463,
-0.7815849781036377,
-0.7250353693962097,
-0.4493756890296936,
-0.4338591992855072,
0.329635351896286,
0.5618573427200317,
1.0638725757598877,
-0.8787922859191895,
-0.02494797483086586,
-0.5616489052772522,
0.2581719756126404,
0.2668362557888031,
-0.26056939363479614,
-0.09809983521699905,
-0.36056646704673767,
-0.48299434781074524,
0.3061313033103943,
0.3290695250034332,
0.030791401863098145,
-0.06382426619529724,
-0.33346620202064514,
0.14496862888336182,
0.09811361879110336,
0.6142133474349976,
0.30258893966674805,
-0.7932595014572144,
-0.3277687132358551,
-0.2195987105369568,
0.06908475607633591,
0.08382712304592133,
0.9588099122047424,
-0.7789342403411865,
0.3620091676712036,
0.5645749568939209,
0.5967152118682861,
0.762376070022583,
0.014654261991381645,
0.7802039384841919,
-0.40991461277008057,
0.2488330900669098,
0.2175537347793579,
-0.0011346846586093307,
0.07678655534982681,
-0.19856388866901398,
0.5652734041213989,
0.6325351595878601,
-0.5554632544517517,
-0.6238259673118591,
0.6918339729309082,
-0.9141693711280823,
-0.3430004119873047,
1.5693426132202148,
-0.060938213020563126,
0.4916008412837982,
-0.7417669892311096,
-0.3986366093158722,
0.2365993708372116,
-0.5916930437088013,
0.5347814559936523,
0.6713061332702637,
-0.1394072324037552,
-0.039202649146318436,
-0.5170885324478149,
0.696746826171875,
0.5663827657699585,
-0.8047196865081787,
-0.0639229342341423,
0.22821198403835297,
0.3125835955142975,
0.2982119917869568,
0.5741976499557495,
-0.12218000739812851,
0.320465624332428,
0.226313054561615,
-0.2799976170063019,
0.49135154485702515,
-0.40777817368507385,
0.06562244892120361,
0.31153130531311035,
0.13661080598831177,
-0.007049406412988901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01841v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01841v2
|
Making Pre-trained Language Models Great on Tabular Prediction
| 2024-03-04T08:38:56 | 2024-03-12T07:34:28 |
Jiahuan Yan, Bo Zheng, Hongxia Xu, Yiheng Zhu, Danny Z. Chen, Jimeng Sun, Jian Wu, Jintai Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The transferability of deep neural networks (DNNs) has made significant
progress in image and language processing. However, due to the heterogeneity
among tables, such DNN bonus is still far from being well exploited on tabular
data prediction (e.g., regression or classification tasks). Condensing
knowledge from diverse domains, language models (LMs) possess the capability to
comprehend feature names from various tables, potentially serving as versatile
learners in transferring knowledge across distinct tables and diverse
prediction tasks, but their discrete text representation space is inherently
incompatible with numerical feature values in tables. In this paper, we present
TP-BERTa, a specifically pre-trained LM for tabular data prediction.
Concretely, a novel relative magnitude tokenization converts scalar numerical
feature values to finely discrete, high-dimensional tokens, and an
intra-feature attention approach integrates feature values with the
corresponding feature names. Comprehensive experiments demonstrate that our
pre-trained TP-BERTa leads the performance among tabular DNNs and is
competitive with Gradient Boosted Decision Tree models in typical tabular data
regime.
|
[
-0.3699263334274292,
-0.6534268260002136,
0.5579372644424438,
0.3045155107975006,
-0.27136799693107605,
0.048701632767915726,
-0.30904722213745117,
-0.36073020100593567,
0.2127091884613037,
0.4912016689777374,
-0.07934645563364029,
-0.6062269806861877,
-0.4838508665561676,
-0.3499034643173218,
-0.40987664461135864,
1.1961579322814941,
0.11395459622144699,
0.16216333210468292,
-0.12240075320005417,
0.2616482675075531,
-0.4652574956417084,
-0.6333053708076477,
-0.08204692602157593,
-0.11924420297145844,
0.8949655294418335,
0.3902749717235565,
0.6437022089958191,
0.5150907039642334,
0.7051571607589722,
0.2861649692058563,
0.23632380366325378,
-0.11168040335178375,
-0.3308924734592438,
-0.28400006890296936,
-0.062480781227350235,
-0.46034467220306396,
-0.7448392510414124,
-0.06732163578271866,
0.8660816550254822,
0.8345860838890076,
-0.05895019695162773,
0.04756862297654152,
0.04492347687482834,
0.7097751498222351,
-0.12316375970840454,
0.5872175693511963,
-1.1876072883605957,
0.4191392660140991,
-0.43889597058296204,
-0.02318277396261692,
-0.4001083970069885,
-0.8296511769294739,
0.30857986211776733,
-0.42145010828971863,
0.14071524143218994,
-0.0451199896633625,
0.9682086706161499,
0.33648189902305603,
-0.06893850117921829,
0.14313934743404388,
-0.7801951766014099,
0.49044767022132874,
-0.580371081829071,
0.3661375045776367,
0.5330551266670227,
0.4573054015636444,
-0.1704593449831009,
-0.9243704080581665,
-0.6780088543891907,
-0.5258113741874695,
-0.03705058991909027,
-0.244516521692276,
0.16891281306743622,
0.11437391489744186,
0.108224056661129,
0.30337730050086975,
-0.45980045199394226,
0.26790815591812134,
-0.22318769991397858,
0.33141377568244934,
0.19299744069576263,
-0.1135978177189827,
0.23603302240371704,
0.04958439618349075,
-0.2437799572944641,
-0.25608956813812256,
-0.5627433061599731,
0.2907816469669342,
-0.0024752572644501925,
0.7756994366645813,
-0.11711879819631577,
0.2341185361146927,
0.2590634226799011,
0.8683518767356873,
-0.03455217927694321,
0.006141595542430878,
0.23622673749923706,
-0.11602169275283813,
-0.34447234869003296,
-0.03160274028778076,
0.7078472971916199,
-0.21845605969429016,
0.4432247281074524,
-0.4841824471950531,
-0.1116759330034256,
0.04809402674436569,
0.47874632477760315,
-0.8321900367736816,
-0.586226761341095,
-0.029573088511824608,
-0.25819671154022217,
-0.5677563548088074,
0.1235562339425087,
-0.9273015260696411,
-0.23487748205661774,
-0.2888157069683075,
0.37261277437210083,
-0.1708468645811081,
0.04244780167937279,
-0.2907894551753998,
0.3690792918205261,
-0.12207891047000885,
0.35590118169784546,
-1.0903199911117554,
0.2398441880941391,
0.6432701945304871,
0.5156734585762024,
-0.10872276872396469,
-0.32100093364715576,
-0.6022696495056152,
-0.07551143318414688,
-0.5904241800308228,
0.8017351031303406,
-0.7420533895492554,
0.08738425374031067,
0.30732664465904236,
-0.20673814415931702,
0.020111316815018654,
-0.3903511166572571,
0.4081924557685852,
-0.5222501754760742,
-0.059456199407577515,
-0.3358570635318756,
-0.30796515941619873,
-0.1509166657924652,
0.25704020261764526,
-0.7588851451873779,
0.6570709347724915,
0.21114349365234375,
-0.609409749507904,
0.924702525138855,
-0.4403458833694458,
-0.5733358860015869,
0.185357466340065,
-0.369238018989563,
-0.760922372341156,
0.22946538031101227,
0.23165377974510193,
0.623097836971283,
-0.03451485559344292,
0.6792305111885071,
-0.5923346877098083,
-0.12287058681249619,
0.3954998552799225,
-0.22174639999866486,
-0.032444681972265244,
-0.038322895765304565,
-0.09595444798469543,
0.26318344473838806,
-0.6588932871818542,
0.12863527238368988,
-0.1589442491531372,
-0.40980440378189087,
0.17625105381011963,
0.011512613855302334,
0.13871461153030396,
0.3716590404510498,
0.0465012788772583,
-0.2747599482536316,
0.3738943338394165,
-0.21038827300071716,
0.3068162202835083,
0.6726710200309753,
-0.4924080967903137,
0.6406850814819336,
-0.17538291215896606,
0.3571600615978241,
0.18668389320373535,
-0.22543415427207947,
0.2895156145095825,
-0.36911457777023315,
-0.45663008093833923,
-0.20168735086917877,
0.7531298995018005,
0.4712371230125427,
-0.8428133130073547,
0.49125170707702637,
-0.6076706647872925,
-0.4524717628955841,
-0.21216878294944763,
-0.023616164922714233,
0.15931105613708496,
0.7578170895576477,
0.3559601306915283,
-0.11767261475324631,
-0.5717597007751465,
-0.8004204630851746,
-0.16632485389709473,
-0.2906658947467804,
-0.033462043851614,
0.42231041193008423,
0.2557665705680847,
0.021627863869071007,
0.8686993718147278,
-0.21183574199676514,
-0.8638162612915039,
-0.5980415940284729,
0.22569327056407928,
0.5360886454582214,
0.552786111831665,
0.582071840763092,
-0.7505630254745483,
-0.889912486076355,
0.33433762192726135,
-0.49132755398750305,
-0.0061322604306042194,
-0.19003869593143463,
0.06937383860349655,
0.06515190005302429,
0.17146345973014832,
-0.4072268307209015,
0.5063784718513489,
0.39520180225372314,
-0.3112928867340088,
0.41142353415489197,
-0.20251084864139557,
-0.07804320752620697,
-0.9917393326759338,
0.08149619400501251,
0.11541429162025452,
-0.18822446465492249,
-0.892225444316864,
-0.5096068978309631,
0.18351569771766663,
-0.20649652183055878,
-0.38680991530418396,
0.3836253583431244,
-0.151119664311409,
-0.4323183298110962,
-0.0858716294169426,
-0.035688336938619614,
-0.21249425411224365,
0.5570347309112549,
0.3066193759441376,
0.7556905150413513,
0.3717903792858124,
-0.46055909991264343,
0.06016645208001137,
0.4849984347820282,
-0.4404132068157196,
0.3612667918205261,
-0.368863970041275,
-0.1623198390007019,
0.08409571647644043,
0.296094685792923,
-0.7725538015365601,
-0.0962420105934143,
-0.10959190130233765,
-0.4790641665458679,
0.7396000027656555,
-0.057616692036390305,
-0.3061389625072479,
-0.6148672103881836,
-0.20643524825572968,
0.36699891090393066,
0.3472602665424347,
-0.5848903656005859,
0.7308505773544312,
0.569270670413971,
-0.27468159794807434,
-0.7767888903617859,
-1.0144035816192627,
0.24850504100322723,
-0.15701384842395782,
-0.42314600944519043,
0.7325019240379333,
0.2146870493888855,
-0.007093304768204689,
-0.09037163108587265,
0.11693381518125534,
-0.4862089455127716,
-0.10158674418926239,
0.23556707799434662,
0.3310021758079529,
-0.14114205539226532,
0.5019998550415039,
-0.2782759964466095,
0.057140372693538666,
-0.08083389699459076,
-0.4106679856777191,
0.5457606911659241,
-0.4421178698539734,
0.2578934133052826,
-0.4923190474510193,
-0.22438116371631622,
0.3901132643222809,
-0.24513956904411316,
0.8151563405990601,
0.71140456199646,
-0.5133077502250671,
-0.17651475965976715,
-0.65641188621521,
-0.18437890708446503,
-0.43591392040252686,
0.7542749047279358,
-0.6701145172119141,
-0.5324068069458008,
0.7569543123245239,
0.2075636088848114,
-0.09590200334787369,
0.14505654573440552,
0.36531922221183777,
-0.3101765513420105,
0.5264894366264343,
0.643852710723877,
-0.3721531927585602,
0.7807897329330444,
-0.182791069149971,
0.30083733797073364,
-0.44440120458602905,
-0.2558099031448364,
-0.8407013416290283,
-0.431863933801651,
-0.6981244683265686,
-0.3489590585231781,
0.27258172631263733,
-0.20744822919368744,
-0.1423523724079132,
0.275127112865448,
-0.24369865655899048,
0.4449576735496521,
0.36258986592292786,
0.17625801265239716,
-0.06721889972686768,
0.3086186945438385,
-0.03843432664871216,
-0.21299003064632416,
-0.7266117334365845,
-0.2903638780117035,
1.1191061735153198,
0.6188247203826904,
0.8098117709159851,
-0.38343867659568787,
0.4591006934642792,
0.3351103961467743,
0.5449686646461487,
-0.5347778797149658,
0.4269137382507324,
-0.7426914572715759,
-0.25658804178237915,
-0.5393471717834473,
-0.664699375629425,
-0.713451623916626,
0.25859305262565613,
-0.34098735451698303,
-0.7638706564903259,
0.15007877349853516,
0.149591326713562,
-0.4014896750450134,
0.6827746033668518,
-0.5443046689033508,
1.097030520439148,
-0.28046292066574097,
-0.41509175300598145,
0.04741387814283371,
-0.46615418791770935,
0.08587327599525452,
-0.28250551223754883,
0.07119015604257584,
-0.046666085720062256,
0.14887186884880066,
0.5900373458862305,
-0.3102495074272156,
0.712510347366333,
-0.3480004370212555,
-0.01099346112459898,
-0.06364783644676208,
0.19900929927825928,
0.4049789309501648,
0.07993093132972717,
-0.1220724806189537,
0.19671307504177094,
-0.37712472677230835,
-0.2517894208431244,
-0.4449225962162018,
0.7021716833114624,
-0.7835995554924011,
-0.4234502911567688,
-0.242521271109581,
-0.658627986907959,
-0.49794140458106995,
0.12543362379074097,
0.0047083389945328236,
0.33852720260620117,
-0.1879485845565796,
0.4419068992137909,
0.6607363224029541,
-0.09807050973176956,
0.5197030305862427,
0.1303032487630844,
-0.3248506188392639,
-0.5084830522537231,
1.0141302347183228,
0.42698201537132263,
-0.19694487750530243,
0.8120189309120178,
0.1779862344264984,
-0.5566034913063049,
-0.6854935884475708,
-0.41658568382263184,
-0.040504809468984604,
-0.38908180594444275,
-0.33723506331443787,
-0.5696312785148621,
-0.3036879003047943,
-0.1732812374830246,
-0.14378604292869568,
-0.34230709075927734,
-0.47810298204421997,
-0.45539477467536926,
-0.3396952450275421,
0.03172165900468826,
0.6822863817214966,
0.10386624187231064,
0.20474588871002197,
-0.8498811721801758,
0.27673399448394775,
0.5676769614219666,
0.6878484487533569,
0.06842292845249176,
-0.638395369052887,
-0.17739927768707275,
-0.3015372157096863,
-0.021935228258371353,
-0.744543731212616,
0.6199448108673096,
0.3654617965221405,
0.4974307715892792,
0.24504448473453522,
-0.2558654844760895,
0.5952439308166504,
-0.6084951758384705,
0.45671793818473816,
0.218051940202713,
-0.7789072394371033,
0.28850799798965454,
-0.34783118963241577,
0.1970234215259552,
0.6879261136054993,
0.2138557881116867,
-0.13109007477760315,
-0.03241242095828056,
-0.2972932457923889,
-0.46670496463775635,
0.7622477412223816,
-0.05803336575627327,
0.035404521971940994,
0.26695460081100464,
0.165609210729599,
0.45279523730278015,
0.49458104372024536,
-1.3199371099472046,
0.24273040890693665,
-0.36426618695259094,
-0.3534378409385681,
0.03474602475762367,
-0.26584360003471375,
0.3985051214694977,
-0.4533923268318176,
0.45321881771087646,
-0.12604014575481415,
0.14490628242492676,
-0.09493234008550644,
-0.12839703261852264,
-0.21837812662124634,
0.27185049653053284,
0.5124444961547852,
0.7648014426231384,
-0.39804738759994507,
0.11154219508171082,
0.2549613118171692,
-0.5315906405448914,
-0.028926102444529533,
0.37214574217796326,
0.1060238927602768,
-0.03431951627135277,
0.13831989467144012,
0.8599900603294373,
0.12675105035305023,
0.024554485455155373,
0.3736528158187866,
-0.24435226619243622,
-0.13689419627189636,
-0.26997169852256775,
-0.4846685230731964,
-0.09491485357284546,
0.015505400486290455,
0.41388264298439026,
-0.20394454896450043,
-0.0468892902135849,
-0.5762119293212891,
0.4835778474807739,
0.48785707354545593,
-0.5412830114364624,
-0.45699137449264526,
0.5317861437797546,
0.15869762003421783,
-0.15906192362308502,
0.5619813203811646,
0.0726795494556427,
-0.6195631623268127,
0.643393337726593,
0.4049329459667206,
0.8602306246757507,
-0.2821502983570099,
0.33749449253082275,
0.2259901612997055,
0.16526056826114655,
0.23994499444961548,
0.4382072985172272,
-0.10944671183824539,
-0.5849860310554504,
-0.13103988766670227,
-0.8776992559432983,
-0.06016957387328148,
0.2777286469936371,
-0.28997352719306946,
0.023288900032639503,
-0.620623767375946,
-0.42785027623176575,
0.20920683443546295,
0.038492102175951004,
-0.9278970956802368,
0.17068085074424744,
0.4242040812969208,
0.7194842100143433,
-0.6956239938735962,
1.222550392150879,
0.46270763874053955,
-0.5049928426742554,
-0.8641116619110107,
-0.01610051468014717,
-0.8520053029060364,
-0.521719217300415,
0.9904347658157349,
0.21533548831939697,
0.47976112365722656,
-0.2637892961502075,
-0.2477237433195114,
-0.7239031791687012,
0.593991756439209,
0.3867555856704712,
-0.7232548594474792,
-0.41180914640426636,
0.7893547415733337,
0.6591021418571472,
-0.41314250230789185,
0.25268134474754333,
0.6590878963470459,
0.6608070731163025,
0.050884030759334564,
-1.172935962677002,
-0.20875541865825653,
-0.02984248660504818,
0.28258323669433594,
0.07310552895069122,
-0.24979190528392792,
1.0360236167907715,
-0.16835860908031464,
0.19492001831531525,
-0.14044880867004395,
0.8156241774559021,
-0.06223142147064209,
0.08796422928571701,
0.28393852710723877,
0.8246432542800903,
0.5835371613502502,
-0.42962905764579773,
0.8124006390571594,
-0.09126885235309601,
0.0995272547006607,
1.1614360809326172,
-0.41418641805648804,
0.9659508466720581,
0.4174915850162506,
-0.46075981855392456,
0.7156063914299011,
0.5275464057922363,
-0.10286527127027512,
0.6432863473892212,
0.34615904092788696,
0.04496566206216812,
-0.1180589571595192,
-0.1905864030122757,
-0.475841760635376,
0.33615511655807495,
0.5280727744102478,
-0.4439969062805176,
-0.26808950304985046,
-0.024520643055438995,
-0.32213833928108215,
0.21373526751995087,
-0.6051681637763977,
0.8688995242118835,
0.07956334948539734,
-0.520469605922699,
0.5077733397483826,
-0.4550636112689972,
0.40650230646133423,
-0.5040249824523926,
-0.11676903069019318,
-0.212049201130867,
0.2719382047653198,
-0.23749899864196777,
-0.8229372501373291,
0.04027999937534332,
-0.20234957337379456,
-0.17155000567436218,
-0.20908144116401672,
0.73466956615448,
-0.5769289135932922,
-0.5348510146141052,
0.05694151669740677,
0.43019789457321167,
-0.019552074372768402,
-0.23301631212234497,
-0.5293201804161072,
-0.1301497519016266,
-0.09463470429182053,
-0.025523969903588295,
0.5129209756851196,
0.5324479341506958,
0.004159584175795317,
0.7159092426300049,
0.4549494981765747,
0.2422521561384201,
0.09627072513103485,
0.302949458360672,
1.0961958169937134,
-0.6213969588279724,
-0.9328556060791016,
-0.6829022169113159,
0.32510823011398315,
0.15312078595161438,
0.12661461532115936,
0.22399906814098358,
0.3495996296405792,
0.535121738910675,
-0.4533783793449402,
0.4876607358455658,
0.26355335116386414,
0.35033056139945984,
-0.4444397985935211,
1.0173122882843018,
-0.309995174407959,
0.03851081058382988,
-0.2827168405056,
-1.2363969087600708,
-0.471729040145874,
0.4948192834854126,
-0.5538227558135986,
0.17878089845180511,
0.602231502532959,
0.37575528025627136,
0.1584833711385727,
-0.27168384194374084,
0.5456939935684204,
0.31233277916908264,
0.44922322034835815,
0.5707083940505981,
0.6828293800354004,
-0.10521148145198822,
0.5734308958053589,
-0.19266387820243835,
-0.18968871235847473,
-0.2930873930454254,
-0.8972774147987366,
-1.164674162864685,
-0.6104632019996643,
0.1340002864599228,
0.020992891862988472,
0.06639905273914337,
0.671639084815979,
0.9982596039772034,
-0.9472106099128723,
-0.17586162686347961,
-0.36676302552223206,
0.04744211956858635,
0.16909363865852356,
-0.229193776845932,
0.6469243764877319,
-0.5475411415100098,
-0.44864529371261597,
0.11995815485715866,
0.15794077515602112,
0.3817242681980133,
-0.2893575131893158,
0.2983322739601135,
-0.0802561417222023,
-0.1706383228302002,
0.34485363960266113,
0.2810558080673218,
-0.6371729969978333,
-0.12748776376247406,
-0.2913055419921875,
-0.25840482115745544,
0.3868849575519562,
0.628570020198822,
-1.11886465549469,
0.24774326384067535,
0.5539318919181824,
0.8028463125228882,
0.5396301746368408,
0.09308638423681259,
0.5656481981277466,
-0.7765786647796631,
0.3987926244735718,
0.6661438941955566,
0.43654653429985046,
0.3066778779029846,
-0.3750247061252594,
0.2758778929710388,
-0.19579172134399414,
-0.5184046030044556,
-0.8681156635284424,
-0.07117612659931183,
-0.9072369337081909,
-0.06295833736658096,
0.6722646951675415,
-0.18801578879356384,
-0.3151266872882843,
0.15816685557365417,
0.019199088215827942,
0.16367442905902863,
-0.5500033497810364,
1.2361373901367188,
0.3665520250797272,
0.24023465812206268,
-0.05298194661736488,
-0.3538982570171356,
0.9365214109420776,
0.464833527803421,
-1.1060023307800293,
0.05899796262383461,
0.20042702555656433,
-0.21009260416030884,
0.15865375101566315,
0.3578415811061859,
-0.21656417846679688,
0.31263118982315063,
-0.1282804012298584,
0.16726817190647125,
-0.10127168148756027,
-0.8407070636749268,
-0.19831591844558716,
0.3624812066555023,
0.28392571210861206,
-0.15115109086036682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04789v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04789v2
|
TopicDiff: A Topic-enriched Diffusion Approach for Multimodal Conversational Emotion Detection
| 2024-03-04T08:38:53 | 2024-03-11T01:04:28 |
Jiamin Luo, Jingjing Wang, Guodong Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Multimodal Conversational Emotion (MCE) detection, generally spanning across
the acoustic, vision and language modalities, has attracted increasing interest
in the multimedia community. Previous studies predominantly focus on learning
contextual information in conversations with only a few considering the topic
information in single language modality, while always neglecting the acoustic
and vision topic information. On this basis, we propose a model-agnostic
Topic-enriched Diffusion (TopicDiff) approach for capturing multimodal topic
information in MCE tasks. Particularly, we integrate the diffusion model into
neural topic model to alleviate the diversity deficiency problem of neural
topic model in capturing topic information. Detailed evaluations demonstrate
the significant improvements of TopicDiff over the state-of-the-art MCE
baselines, justifying the importance of multimodal topic information to MCE and
the effectiveness of TopicDiff in capturing such information. Furthermore, we
observe an interesting finding that the topic information in acoustic and
vision is more discriminative and robust compared to the language.
|
[
-0.824939489364624,
-0.9205038547515869,
0.47529345750808716,
0.24085715413093567,
-0.30351385474205017,
-0.19005897641181946,
0.011011040769517422,
0.11464300751686096,
0.5465149879455566,
-0.007931388914585114,
-0.575823187828064,
-0.4717358350753784,
-0.9534410834312439,
-0.34770911931991577,
-0.20590974390506744,
0.6729781031608582,
0.15981833636760712,
-0.04453040659427643,
-0.22285409271717072,
-0.2116662561893463,
-0.21650129556655884,
-0.27006250619888306,
-0.7471607327461243,
-0.003313936060294509,
0.7205054759979248,
0.4156380891799927,
0.21364568173885345,
-0.07649451494216919,
0.31918174028396606,
0.31309983134269714,
-0.29212671518325806,
0.16462095081806183,
-0.28494733572006226,
0.3052504360675812,
-0.11339490115642548,
-0.231446772813797,
-0.49278759956359863,
0.04320286959409714,
0.3311130106449127,
0.36666223406791687,
-0.4299505949020386,
-0.24616862833499908,
-0.2746094763278961,
0.5762050151824951,
-1.0621541738510132,
-0.06477966159582138,
-0.4058375060558319,
0.3305615186691284,
0.04939407482743263,
-0.30192190408706665,
-0.23950126767158508,
-0.05850136652588844,
0.24260267615318298,
-0.2014465183019638,
0.08825894445180893,
-0.33848807215690613,
0.44682636857032776,
0.21239373087882996,
-0.9226073026657104,
-0.24130640923976898,
-0.23949989676475525,
0.523400604724884,
-0.5926491022109985,
0.5335177183151245,
0.5989343523979187,
0.09080842137336731,
0.4383152425289154,
-0.3248218297958374,
-0.910255491733551,
-0.08094635605812073,
0.29861748218536377,
0.4822360575199127,
-0.5658038854598999,
0.08649139851331711,
-0.10262055695056915,
0.32046520709991455,
-0.48214930295944214,
-0.16459354758262634,
0.14967620372772217,
-0.22900418937206268,
0.3433026671409607,
-0.04039398953318596,
0.5228307247161865,
-0.4911123216152191,
-0.19922895729541779,
-0.17775313556194305,
-0.20104476809501648,
-0.1778230220079422,
0.3579005002975464,
-0.32931873202323914,
-0.4434458613395691,
0.3070039451122284,
-0.17208154499530792,
0.21970587968826294,
-0.018488576635718346,
-0.13313832879066467,
0.3716104030609131,
-0.2997455596923828,
-0.17758113145828247,
-0.01043232623487711,
0.5383478999137878,
0.7427502274513245,
-0.06630966812372208,
-0.0032269409857690334,
0.10936540365219116,
0.152515709400177,
0.04264562577009201,
-1.0591235160827637,
-0.2847820818424225,
0.42457613348960876,
-0.5380125045776367,
-0.11418963223695755,
-0.2593541741371155,
-1.1932117938995361,
-0.4837832748889923,
-0.09828174859285355,
0.2972080409526825,
-0.30994361639022827,
-0.994811475276947,
-0.028697429224848747,
-0.49284204840660095,
-0.13547231256961823,
0.43138375878334045,
-0.714494526386261,
-0.162086620926857,
0.31928327679634094,
1.0299164056777954,
-0.34786418080329895,
-0.12295561283826828,
-0.4153793454170227,
0.02718420699238777,
-0.16569793224334717,
0.8847846388816833,
-0.735348105430603,
-0.6825860738754272,
-0.15217722952365875,
-0.07890643924474716,
-0.14821162819862366,
-0.44717517495155334,
0.3950347900390625,
-0.3375759422779083,
0.2402288168668747,
-0.30117669701576233,
-0.42430198192596436,
-0.21639958024024963,
0.34887242317199707,
-0.4933944046497345,
0.6175404191017151,
-0.10671583563089371,
-0.984147846698761,
0.20850716531276703,
-0.8683357834815979,
-0.14518944919109344,
-0.2582772970199585,
0.011589367873966694,
-0.23900999128818512,
0.14478982985019684,
0.10665325820446014,
0.49181559681892395,
0.03948559984564781,
0.5211876630783081,
-0.7790108919143677,
-0.01935206726193428,
0.21655108034610748,
-0.9873893857002258,
0.2917662560939789,
0.5342991948127747,
-0.21524229645729065,
-0.06091034784913063,
-0.5794405937194824,
-0.42937085032463074,
-0.24790845811367035,
-0.1520034223794937,
-0.2941202223300934,
-0.0025193525943905115,
0.024586597457528114,
0.3379735052585602,
-0.22169286012649536,
-0.5256147384643555,
-0.18982666730880737,
0.17103146016597748,
0.2973859906196594,
0.7347112894058228,
0.18772202730178833,
0.6192877888679504,
-0.13270068168640137,
0.5037204623222351,
0.804287314414978,
-0.1555391550064087,
-0.48290351033210754,
-0.5655789971351624,
-0.7581194639205933,
-0.7070851922035217,
0.1073932871222496,
0.560278594493866,
-0.8985485434532166,
0.2418190836906433,
0.239199697971344,
-0.21017956733703613,
-0.48077794909477234,
-0.1869044005870819,
0.07641714811325073,
0.6898545622825623,
0.27621594071388245,
-0.41021719574928284,
-0.3529285192489624,
-0.9259977340698242,
0.31265369057655334,
-0.1470579206943512,
0.22475872933864594,
0.7301726937294006,
0.32102614641189575,
-0.4999762177467346,
0.8099935054779053,
-0.5689381957054138,
0.1437976211309433,
0.06544392555952072,
0.8425009846687317,
-0.2617541551589966,
0.6136634945869446,
0.6373203992843628,
-1.298791527748108,
-0.49601271748542786,
-0.08185774832963943,
-0.7347032427787781,
-0.19288270175457,
0.010608386248350143,
-0.25903889536857605,
0.09515273571014404,
0.35110247135162354,
-0.6175650358200073,
0.5330294370651245,
0.594788134098053,
-0.47043555974960327,
0.1065807044506073,
-0.22636957466602325,
0.7944253087043762,
-1.0963997840881348,
-0.11432486772537231,
0.4801647365093231,
0.02811889536678791,
-0.7354699373245239,
-0.3999389111995697,
0.22659234702587128,
-0.23256847262382507,
-0.5404639840126038,
0.5618487596511841,
-0.2022901475429535,
0.12779587507247925,
-0.6038756370544434,
0.24668660759925842,
-0.04925242066383362,
0.5129796266555786,
0.507802426815033,
0.6860625147819519,
0.921642541885376,
-0.5765236020088196,
0.3117414116859436,
0.2531191110610962,
0.05259156599640846,
1.1613999605178833,
-0.21168047189712524,
0.17076809704303741,
-0.4607445299625397,
0.165368914604187,
-1.2666878700256348,
-0.16611525416374207,
0.226772278547287,
-0.49040141701698303,
0.36048591136932373,
-0.17833083868026733,
-0.02996615134179592,
0.08105818927288055,
-0.2482038289308548,
0.35850808024406433,
0.3787522315979004,
-0.42706581950187683,
0.7961682081222534,
0.3395378589630127,
-0.6280249953269958,
-0.575534462928772,
-0.6860818266868591,
0.21342694759368896,
-0.4671100378036499,
-0.8640554547309875,
0.2987314760684967,
-0.4679297208786011,
-0.19599148631095886,
-0.0043312180787324905,
-0.1000678688287735,
-0.49797195196151733,
0.18446536362171173,
0.1644481122493744,
-0.09481009840965271,
-0.31889015436172485,
0.4569789469242096,
0.2059992253780365,
-0.09589846432209015,
-0.023271754384040833,
0.2918623983860016,
0.43246743083000183,
-0.017012882977724075,
-0.6964269876480103,
-0.53216952085495,
0.8680334687232971,
0.5750023722648621,
-0.31946879625320435,
0.505923330783844,
1.127844214439392,
-0.2164665311574936,
0.03119359165430069,
-0.7110269069671631,
-0.33871906995773315,
-0.4285312592983246,
0.577607274055481,
-0.32761067152023315,
-0.8123462200164795,
0.5848754644393921,
-0.3471478521823883,
-0.4762362539768219,
0.2610468566417694,
0.5464975237846375,
-0.3504379689693451,
0.9922599196434021,
0.7252155542373657,
0.033601064234972,
0.6918781995773315,
-0.13054850697517395,
0.24602770805358887,
-0.7902437448501587,
-0.244344562292099,
-0.38177675008773804,
-0.4171692132949829,
-0.1716371476650238,
-0.5548922419548035,
0.292677104473114,
0.005582648795098066,
0.09386388212442398,
-0.37081190943717957,
0.005152779631316662,
0.25193676352500916,
0.3805743157863617,
0.2918477952480316,
0.0719001442193985,
-0.013231831602752209,
0.2553446292877197,
-0.2488255798816681,
-0.5239424705505371,
-0.0990818589925766,
0.6681186556816101,
0.2860168218612671,
0.4495483636856079,
0.4029197096824646,
0.5752673149108887,
0.5817787051200867,
0.039712000638246536,
-0.49567461013793945,
0.44038912653923035,
-0.13488134741783142,
-0.35320937633514404,
0.19008737802505493,
-0.5153809189796448,
-0.4497092068195343,
0.42570948600769043,
-0.1275460124015808,
-0.7617999315261841,
0.8875586986541748,
0.13681796193122864,
-0.06697961688041687,
0.3646436631679535,
-0.8848540186882019,
0.9273794293403625,
0.013389874249696732,
-0.40541136264801025,
-0.5776672959327698,
-0.3796406686306,
0.42732083797454834,
-0.22386698424816132,
0.3004356324672699,
-0.15015871822834015,
-0.006997624412178993,
0.5464927554130554,
-0.07485971599817276,
0.8054961562156677,
-0.40951868891716003,
-0.18444378674030304,
0.23531754314899445,
0.12321072816848755,
0.1399678736925125,
0.48976650834083557,
-0.07996530085802078,
-0.10968033224344254,
-0.39674079418182373,
-0.34553444385528564,
-0.6568215489387512,
0.629339337348938,
-0.566367506980896,
-0.5590361952781677,
-0.21396824717521667,
-0.638423502445221,
-0.18337862193584442,
-0.345795214176178,
0.0392521396279335,
0.5157493352890015,
-0.07339513301849365,
0.4543127715587616,
1.114183783531189,
-0.31326404213905334,
0.8631733059883118,
0.7944004535675049,
0.21730110049247742,
-0.43871739506721497,
0.9184106588363647,
-0.33283278346061707,
0.3929273784160614,
0.25470206141471863,
0.09804731607437134,
-0.30071917176246643,
-0.4709799885749817,
-0.17344160377979279,
-0.08823202550411224,
-1.0571318864822388,
-0.03675874322652817,
-1.1490623950958252,
0.21621346473693848,
-0.2198505401611328,
-0.11926129460334778,
-0.39305686950683594,
-0.16387665271759033,
-0.5501523017883301,
-0.15735965967178345,
0.46236640214920044,
0.03172716498374939,
-0.5414484739303589,
0.3711914122104645,
-0.7249729037284851,
0.6524856090545654,
0.46833494305610657,
0.14629292488098145,
-0.06806286424398422,
-0.4955650269985199,
0.24907125532627106,
0.2882597744464874,
-0.4215337932109833,
-1.0636060237884521,
0.4154314398765564,
0.45144325494766235,
0.7097181081771851,
0.6857095956802368,
0.0035534861963242292,
0.7490814328193665,
-0.03262331336736679,
0.879962146282196,
0.5440594553947449,
-1.1274381875991821,
0.6102833151817322,
-0.027838921174407005,
0.24080152809619904,
0.3766785264015198,
0.5640424489974976,
-0.8660920858383179,
-0.1772245317697525,
-0.5506892800331116,
-0.7614940404891968,
0.7758468389511108,
0.19462519884109497,
0.5264036655426025,
-0.28353801369667053,
-0.02919769287109375,
-0.15769392251968384,
0.3844362199306488,
-0.8158976435661316,
-0.20260363817214966,
-0.5202800631523132,
-0.3557184934616089,
-0.026043057441711426,
-0.42228052020072937,
-0.019361047074198723,
-0.11987734586000443,
0.2946324944496155,
-0.1706443428993225,
0.41913658380508423,
0.24671413004398346,
-0.17669986188411713,
0.055227089673280716,
0.35982248187065125,
0.6792533993721008,
0.11433476209640503,
-0.4688139855861664,
0.47902074456214905,
0.09169532358646393,
-0.3835292160511017,
0.050975337624549866,
0.09237997233867645,
0.3965895175933838,
0.17489612102508545,
0.08324737101793289,
0.9816390872001648,
0.20697066187858582,
-0.6295884847640991,
0.6939294338226318,
-0.10357148200273514,
-0.23959477245807648,
0.26369211077690125,
-0.13242179155349731,
0.441606342792511,
0.703341543674469,
0.1917726993560791,
0.2760731279850006,
0.6608593463897705,
-0.6031642556190491,
0.5613650679588318,
0.44198012351989746,
-0.4706398844718933,
-0.19892825186252594,
0.3857448399066925,
0.484664648771286,
-0.08461155742406845,
0.4220746159553528,
-0.3017084002494812,
-0.5367540717124939,
0.8409483432769775,
0.42156729102134705,
0.9518088698387146,
-0.29670727252960205,
0.5426815152168274,
0.12645581364631653,
-0.12930673360824585,
0.1772695779800415,
0.4292021095752716,
-0.570837676525116,
-0.7359274625778198,
-0.19669382274150848,
-0.32309505343437195,
-0.395039439201355,
-0.2906496524810791,
-0.5040971040725708,
0.003993047401309013,
0.016954747959971428,
-0.21727780997753143,
-0.21282681822776794,
-0.4177626371383667,
-0.19957509636878967,
0.2838478684425354,
0.5087996125221252,
0.6941810250282288,
-0.8321086168289185,
0.8577779531478882,
0.44348573684692383,
-0.301689475774765,
-0.1730440855026245,
0.03384149819612503,
0.13717545568943024,
-0.4111943542957306,
0.9309659004211426,
-0.09401579946279526,
-0.1842411756515503,
-0.03477314114570618,
-0.2449958324432373,
-0.49330416321754456,
1.104859709739685,
0.36442625522613525,
-0.19223454594612122,
0.1613985151052475,
-0.30662819743156433,
0.14949306845664978,
-0.3891911208629608,
0.8449300527572632,
0.11311188340187073,
0.4936630427837372,
0.6029603481292725,
-0.640860915184021,
-0.6202121376991272,
-0.5813749432563782,
-0.06074901670217514,
0.1500505656003952,
-0.5795134902000427,
0.9197614192962646,
0.09616430848836899,
-0.045746706426143646,
-0.5241973400115967,
0.6357422471046448,
0.14178305864334106,
0.7373368144035339,
0.6574132442474365,
0.5045546889305115,
0.7564190626144409,
-0.11365173757076263,
0.8202387690544128,
-0.16168461740016937,
0.2962954044342041,
0.6541306972503662,
-0.33744674921035767,
0.8133974671363831,
0.3827241361141205,
0.11568410694599152,
0.255451500415802,
0.8066781759262085,
0.19453558325767517,
0.7954855561256409,
-0.2928228974342346,
-0.568048357963562,
-0.4137323200702667,
-0.2868424654006958,
-0.48751750588417053,
0.3607155978679657,
0.3940756916999817,
-0.20697003602981567,
-0.3908260762691498,
0.4048415422439575,
0.01168496161699295,
-0.16447553038597107,
-0.19974228739738464,
0.781885027885437,
0.10882364213466644,
-0.3591330647468567,
0.423464298248291,
-0.14040957391262054,
1.0613644123077393,
-0.6645122766494751,
0.02477671019732952,
-0.697637140750885,
-0.11146415770053864,
-0.15016475319862366,
-0.6530102491378784,
0.3644990622997284,
0.10959188640117645,
-0.25878098607063293,
-0.19795821607112885,
0.8079793453216553,
-0.7985173463821411,
-0.22281154990196228,
0.3627694547176361,
0.3945348560810089,
0.08462421596050262,
-0.3149682879447937,
-0.7508701682090759,
0.1309506744146347,
0.0935426875948906,
-0.3703409433364868,
0.33433395624160767,
0.679151713848114,
0.3727942407131195,
0.7248468995094299,
0.19527575373649597,
-0.2523399889469147,
-0.008564257062971592,
0.07523256540298462,
0.664732038974762,
-0.4459453523159027,
-0.6991721987724304,
-0.9515737295150757,
0.8674378395080566,
-0.31523236632347107,
-0.3137568235397339,
0.3997424244880676,
0.1270899772644043,
0.2756448984146118,
-0.09562700986862183,
0.5847293734550476,
-0.00680021196603775,
0.022869698703289032,
-0.5986368060112,
0.5456849336624146,
-1.037941336631775,
0.035281963646411896,
-0.6080730557441711,
-0.7196571826934814,
0.0449201837182045,
0.62814861536026,
-0.06007779389619827,
0.111552894115448,
0.6507034301757812,
0.8374099731445312,
-0.4230403006076813,
0.303052693605423,
0.49965977668762207,
-0.12090930342674255,
0.33618950843811035,
0.7173399925231934,
1.0006656646728516,
0.031491491943597794,
0.2854129374027252,
-0.3789216876029968,
-0.2353525161743164,
-0.36504626274108887,
-1.1807339191436768,
-0.5934540629386902,
-0.6967008113861084,
-0.8928780555725098,
0.14308585226535797,
-0.10060254484415054,
0.6596953868865967,
1.0647950172424316,
-0.5824901461601257,
-0.010874203406274319,
0.040222086012363434,
0.10913631319999695,
0.21679933369159698,
-0.18449318408966064,
0.2086445689201355,
-0.05867503583431244,
-0.8994210958480835,
0.40247660875320435,
0.48218226432800293,
0.2178972214460373,
0.031132789328694344,
-0.31187060475349426,
-0.5059250593185425,
0.1412113606929779,
0.6253823637962341,
-0.06982728093862534,
-0.5848047733306885,
-0.018399080261588097,
-0.18497128784656525,
0.04901896044611931,
0.2707475423812866,
0.6720585823059082,
-0.2987618148326874,
0.6492986679077148,
0.46582791209220886,
0.708538830280304,
0.581878125667572,
-0.0021325387060642242,
0.44788146018981934,
-0.7371306419372559,
0.5857652425765991,
0.09277494251728058,
0.6606170535087585,
0.333583265542984,
-0.2626631259918213,
0.1676713079214096,
0.5464531779289246,
-0.21749550104141235,
-0.7504701614379883,
0.3457360863685608,
-1.1877557039260864,
-0.5704087615013123,
1.002207636833191,
-0.278888463973999,
0.13445375859737396,
0.17557501792907715,
-0.5166881680488586,
0.07582148164510727,
-0.6509165167808533,
0.508582353591919,
0.9361758828163147,
0.09603215754032135,
-0.8158342242240906,
-0.44991353154182434,
0.16585102677345276,
0.6366978287696838,
-0.9667313098907471,
-0.1273825615644455,
0.7134463787078857,
-0.06526806950569153,
0.27330443263053894,
0.7764007449150085,
0.21080850064754486,
0.5247552394866943,
0.10290250182151794,
0.09054397791624069,
0.12565065920352936,
-0.3283236622810364,
-0.39883947372436523,
0.38732796907424927,
-0.25906088948249817,
-0.04192279279232025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01832v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01832v1
|
Model-Based Data-Centric AI: Bridging the Divide Between Academic Ideals and Industrial Pragmatism
| 2024-03-04T08:29:15 | 2024-03-04T08:29:15 |
Chanjun Park, Minsoo Khang, Dahyun Kim
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper delves into the contrasting roles of data within academic and
industrial spheres, highlighting the divergence between Data-Centric AI and
Model-Agnostic AI approaches. We argue that while Data-Centric AI focuses on
the primacy of high-quality data for model performance, Model-Agnostic AI
prioritizes algorithmic flexibility, often at the expense of data quality
considerations. This distinction reveals that academic standards for data
quality frequently do not meet the rigorous demands of industrial applications,
leading to potential pitfalls in deploying academic models in real-world
settings. Through a comprehensive analysis, we address these disparities,
presenting both the challenges they pose and strategies for bridging the gap.
Furthermore, we propose a novel paradigm: Model-Based Data-Centric AI, which
aims to reconcile these differences by integrating model considerations into
data optimization processes. This approach underscores the necessity for
evolving data requirements that are sensitive to the nuances of both academic
research and industrial deployment. By exploring these discrepancies, we aim to
foster a more nuanced understanding of data's role in AI development and
encourage a convergence of academic and industrial standards to enhance AI's
real-world applicability.
|
[
-0.3267739713191986,
-0.8765105605125427,
0.6510578989982605,
-0.1823088824748993,
0.09891054034233093,
0.08270867168903351,
0.2537301480770111,
-0.6407656669616699,
-0.1685829758644104,
0.06598734110593796,
-0.6435908079147339,
-0.26958510279655457,
-0.2529700696468353,
-0.11376076936721802,
-0.5357659459114075,
0.828504204750061,
-0.0926995724439621,
0.06882582604885101,
-1.0882301330566406,
-0.15121497213840485,
-0.46489858627319336,
-0.8096557855606079,
-0.38495466113090515,
-0.5937342643737793,
0.5257808566093445,
0.27523675560951233,
1.0592349767684937,
1.1801258325576782,
0.7414005398750305,
0.11188650131225586,
0.3700978457927704,
0.188401997089386,
-0.24240992963314056,
-0.000572467572055757,
-0.15138556063175201,
-0.6112335324287415,
-0.36682257056236267,
0.2418542504310608,
0.3937617838382721,
0.9414796233177185,
-0.31338074803352356,
0.2268873155117035,
-0.35008931159973145,
0.7412053346633911,
-0.42192474007606506,
0.2928749620914459,
-0.4383319318294525,
0.03700963780283928,
-0.28939005732536316,
0.3463304042816162,
-0.29102379083633423,
-0.19016225636005402,
-0.09449564665555954,
-0.7349346280097961,
0.32938966155052185,
0.10973850637674332,
1.1389893293380737,
0.6531796455383301,
-0.11529796570539474,
0.062299638986587524,
-1.1680011749267578,
1.0230499505996704,
-0.8698534369468689,
0.39394816756248474,
-0.07331782579421997,
0.5021889805793762,
0.01702265813946724,
-0.7927266955375671,
-0.5425418019294739,
0.008758286945521832,
0.1574387401342392,
0.04273835942149162,
0.015027141198515892,
-0.12191379815340042,
0.13814154267311096,
0.39937400817871094,
-0.5959951877593994,
0.380875825881958,
-0.7065341472625732,
0.2879919707775116,
0.9155959486961365,
0.48271021246910095,
-0.03654394671320915,
0.5699366331100464,
-0.24804238975048065,
-0.18154564499855042,
-0.6570149064064026,
0.12718245387077332,
0.534457266330719,
0.4687313735485077,
-0.02730308473110199,
0.25495514273643494,
-0.23866882920265198,
0.7201853394508362,
-0.33488336205482483,
0.12626010179519653,
0.2379608154296875,
-0.12447142601013184,
-0.14529216289520264,
-0.2865159809589386,
0.6019431948661804,
0.18450680375099182,
0.037999555468559265,
-0.278364896774292,
-0.3614156246185303,
0.5706386566162109,
0.7767273783683777,
-0.557355523109436,
-0.24443642795085907,
0.4092697203159332,
-0.42082974314689636,
-0.32906562089920044,
0.14542049169540405,
-0.6982702016830444,
-0.23967279493808746,
-0.8147193789482117,
0.24599014222621918,
-0.1290852129459381,
-0.21968838572502136,
0.027085792273283005,
-0.09971702098846436,
0.3670003116130829,
0.4226146340370178,
-0.45550835132598877,
-0.11398991197347641,
1.0980331897735596,
0.8416150212287903,
-0.09270423650741577,
-0.09307510405778885,
0.24098920822143555,
0.14620345830917358,
-0.566446840763092,
0.5747313499450684,
-0.7811397910118103,
-0.6622174382209778,
-0.16167700290679932,
-0.35498249530792236,
-0.1213083416223526,
-0.6137731671333313,
0.7465772032737732,
-0.2158048301935196,
0.0765300840139389,
0.024207668378949165,
-0.5397591590881348,
-0.6935437321662903,
0.22814123332500458,
-0.682410717010498,
0.7948670387268066,
0.06724721193313599,
-0.5920875072479248,
0.44502368569374084,
-0.8375368714332581,
-0.3441084325313568,
0.07085788995027542,
-0.6374155282974243,
-0.8087241649627686,
0.26925626397132874,
-0.34125158190727234,
0.43801596760749817,
-0.6021099090576172,
0.5986081957817078,
-0.9163155555725098,
-0.27183201909065247,
0.05405302718281746,
-0.58687424659729,
0.4580317437648773,
0.47300300002098083,
0.07056090980768204,
-0.05021664500236511,
-0.8319963812828064,
-0.02314220368862152,
0.19889245927333832,
0.2864309847354889,
-0.27538353204727173,
0.45452842116355896,
0.0035722956527024508,
0.22491121292114258,
0.3967922627925873,
-0.43658116459846497,
0.2762356698513031,
-0.12805625796318054,
0.5597899556159973,
0.7301800847053528,
-0.4400458335876465,
0.21543607115745544,
-1.0044718980789185,
0.2743837833404541,
0.13320833444595337,
0.5697237849235535,
0.20393551886081696,
-0.2518461048603058,
-0.6214483380317688,
-0.16690728068351746,
0.2436952292919159,
0.5644940137863159,
-0.2524746060371399,
0.25466188788414,
-0.1376650184392929,
-0.8934395909309387,
-1.1099056005477905,
-0.28441452980041504,
-0.22672227025032043,
0.9457297325134277,
0.37002667784690857,
-0.45474734902381897,
-0.2909413278102875,
-1.2371492385864258,
0.05713987722992897,
-0.43706634640693665,
0.13181674480438232,
0.43303462862968445,
0.3179957866668701,
-0.437498539686203,
1.1678608655929565,
-0.309487909078598,
-0.12129389494657516,
-0.026677489280700684,
0.19925789535045624,
0.5416229963302612,
0.6737491488456726,
0.5285716652870178,
-1.0951247215270996,
-0.23967577517032623,
0.16237980127334595,
-1.0361367464065552,
0.058282703161239624,
-0.1962585747241974,
-0.07997097820043564,
-0.134895920753479,
0.11260662972927094,
-0.5043298006057739,
0.7051540017127991,
0.08366207778453827,
-0.010973883792757988,
0.669948935508728,
-0.1971656233072281,
0.0673867017030716,
-0.8204306364059448,
0.5939162969589233,
0.16834382712841034,
0.05078844726085663,
-1.1444730758666992,
0.04435041546821594,
-0.26539283990859985,
-0.12470884621143341,
-0.19236846268177032,
0.23332837224006653,
-0.024590078741312027,
-0.1133989468216896,
-0.1435564011335373,
-0.4896482527256012,
0.45496320724487305,
0.15044346451759338,
0.2573223412036896,
0.8168765306472778,
0.6277225613594055,
-0.5979667901992798,
0.06032024323940277,
0.4128148555755615,
0.011384031735360622,
0.6998804807662964,
-0.8831189870834351,
0.15766365826129913,
-0.24212773144245148,
-0.005547326989471912,
-0.39863839745521545,
-0.10128733515739441,
0.19639849662780762,
-0.44787919521331787,
0.25811657309532166,
-0.07131372392177582,
-0.5353597402572632,
-0.2681124806404114,
-0.006532054394483566,
0.6098579168319702,
0.373075395822525,
-0.3339432179927826,
0.5208059549331665,
0.4065907299518585,
-0.17289988696575165,
-0.4372352957725525,
-0.7421542406082153,
-0.23660671710968018,
-0.4522527754306793,
-0.826288640499115,
0.41844114661216736,
-0.10073953866958618,
-0.5483113527297974,
-0.1118256226181984,
-0.10184352099895477,
-0.3885819613933563,
0.499870240688324,
0.3519100844860077,
0.7599595189094543,
-0.12064316868782043,
-0.20122665166854858,
-0.07199516892433167,
-0.04983605816960335,
0.28957420587539673,
-0.26646724343299866,
0.1820361465215683,
0.19264985620975494,
-0.539823055267334,
-0.8385235071182251,
0.3989817798137665,
0.9742128849029541,
-0.3267000615596771,
0.776918888092041,
0.28491151332855225,
-0.17251425981521606,
-0.24485015869140625,
-0.2568323612213135,
-0.1602420061826706,
-0.4519221782684326,
0.08525774627923965,
-0.29412445425987244,
-0.24135398864746094,
0.4532109797000885,
-0.059074029326438904,
0.6543598771095276,
0.46466386318206787,
0.22028984129428864,
-0.28471627831459045,
1.166320562362671,
0.6987432241439819,
-0.24711748957633972,
0.3947257399559021,
-0.43445971608161926,
0.6062228679656982,
-0.8074238300323486,
-0.17362962663173676,
-0.7064434885978699,
-0.5300939083099365,
-0.3517599403858185,
-0.07258988916873932,
0.45540350675582886,
-0.24881792068481445,
-0.532299816608429,
-0.18517228960990906,
-0.9267292022705078,
-0.1512749046087265,
0.5260822772979736,
-0.18874165415763855,
0.28610873222351074,
-0.26182547211647034,
0.5869386792182922,
0.04540394991636276,
-0.9970815181732178,
-0.7379626035690308,
1.0801955461502075,
0.6094121932983398,
0.689163863658905,
-0.32831627130508423,
0.379701167345047,
0.4335974156856537,
0.27835679054260254,
-0.503075122833252,
0.1480737030506134,
-0.26532086730003357,
-0.8467664122581482,
0.012794649228453636,
-0.4327397346496582,
-0.580692708492279,
0.016888916492462158,
0.0840701088309288,
-0.21791662275791168,
0.6305529475212097,
0.07383263111114502,
-0.2480497658252716,
0.39821210503578186,
-0.7418708205223083,
1.0049419403076172,
-0.298775315284729,
-0.5311510562896729,
-0.28167521953582764,
-0.5555440783500671,
0.29081451892852783,
-0.028155187144875526,
0.5324795842170715,
-0.4034675061702728,
0.2079523205757141,
0.6017805337905884,
-0.43123742938041687,
0.5099663734436035,
-0.4138394594192505,
0.20276731252670288,
0.2880004942417145,
-0.09225386381149292,
0.33641600608825684,
-0.01206948235630989,
-0.413846492767334,
0.5580416917800903,
0.21334441006183624,
-0.4661838412284851,
-0.35010311007499695,
0.4269438683986664,
-0.9825282096862793,
-0.5564350485801697,
-0.4819625914096832,
-0.7392719984054565,
-0.2606641352176666,
0.03384454920887947,
0.09992995858192444,
0.3444611728191376,
-0.09035022556781769,
0.3376626670360565,
0.5794022679328918,
0.10099811851978302,
0.12182583659887314,
0.28489482402801514,
0.27782413363456726,
0.20353423058986664,
1.1953980922698975,
0.36732423305511475,
0.16088517010211945,
0.06907512247562408,
-0.2587827742099762,
-0.20538589358329773,
-0.804530918598175,
-0.5070624351501465,
0.05434447154402733,
-0.26214680075645447,
-0.06894335895776749,
-0.17892858386039734,
-0.32446300983428955,
-0.14166685938835144,
-0.5735743641853333,
-0.5951642394065857,
-0.19856049120426178,
-0.6280632019042969,
0.0774180144071579,
0.4685535728931427,
0.5510232448577881,
0.005951644852757454,
0.054220959544181824,
-0.42322447896003723,
0.031783509999513626,
-0.28127163648605347,
0.2929335832595825,
0.05096333846449852,
-0.3051270842552185,
-0.38903704285621643,
0.43690016865730286,
-0.25511467456817627,
-0.11069205403327942,
0.3945254385471344,
-0.040826600044965744,
0.6318149566650391,
0.3835706412792206,
0.21717551350593567,
0.4027782380580902,
-0.3173763155937195,
0.7066461443901062,
-0.0842515230178833,
-0.5472927689552307,
0.25335633754730225,
-0.3978195786476135,
-0.21423739194869995,
0.886502742767334,
0.494213342666626,
-0.3725740909576416,
-0.14253167808055878,
-0.6953409314155579,
-1.1647745370864868,
0.670100748538971,
0.015478410758078098,
-0.03317401185631752,
0.6265925765037537,
0.5230745077133179,
0.5374199748039246,
0.5359665155410767,
-0.3922596275806427,
-0.26942363381385803,
-0.3464657962322235,
-0.45504119992256165,
0.11252844333648682,
0.5953338146209717,
-0.27555638551712036,
-0.14640378952026367,
0.7061066627502441,
-0.020852526649832726,
0.3452257215976715,
-0.0014445435954257846,
0.1647801697254181,
0.3533374071121216,
0.024257361888885498,
-0.016193408519029617,
0.8624562621116638,
-0.11624253541231155,
-0.4972761869430542,
-0.39461761713027954,
-0.39791494607925415,
0.15992602705955505,
0.40762484073638916,
-0.7686299681663513,
-0.045269668102264404,
-0.014002484269440174,
0.8159928321838379,
-0.5976662635803223,
-0.6594682931900024,
0.032830338925123215,
0.05396341159939766,
-0.16840463876724243,
-0.36467137932777405,
0.42386364936828613,
-0.3195899426937103,
0.17209982872009277,
0.33304867148399353,
0.039673805236816406,
0.18393820524215698,
-0.5678333640098572,
0.3707658350467682,
0.48477768898010254,
-0.16042567789554596,
-0.3034834861755371,
1.1101559400558472,
0.14354705810546875,
-0.21506242454051971,
0.7686288356781006,
0.35112547874450684,
0.005111774895340204,
1.004654884338379,
-0.11356139183044434,
0.6488361954689026,
-0.039912182837724686,
0.13887247443199158,
-0.060096900910139084,
-0.031023109331727028,
-0.06654871255159378,
0.19537219405174255,
0.22531403601169586,
-0.6264102458953857,
0.002846750197932124,
-0.4258061945438385,
-0.8048644065856934,
0.10577164590358734,
-0.8497945666313171,
0.2567272186279297,
-0.7369642853736877,
-0.12693116068840027,
0.13290078938007355,
0.05714842677116394,
-0.644790530204773,
0.40282177925109863,
0.05464788153767586,
0.7796028852462769,
-0.702028751373291,
0.7541276216506958,
0.5079365372657776,
-0.5279819369316101,
-0.6178420782089233,
-0.20710940659046173,
-0.029177837073802948,
-0.47796833515167236,
0.051802314817905426,
0.24907808005809784,
0.18194778263568878,
0.06272085756063461,
-0.46617284417152405,
-0.5997745394706726,
1.3479853868484497,
0.09928075969219208,
-0.6776794791221619,
-0.049823325127363205,
0.2481607049703598,
0.6058896780014038,
-0.5670108795166016,
0.19432277977466583,
0.6375924348831177,
0.5007697939872742,
-0.07539258152246475,
-0.4578063488006592,
-0.5358157157897949,
-0.281136155128479,
-0.16247425973415375,
0.2137220948934555,
-0.9563068151473999,
0.9790840148925781,
0.4218064546585083,
-0.200708270072937,
-0.24263808131217957,
0.6694402694702148,
0.092857725918293,
0.9395594000816345,
0.16161079704761505,
0.6221210956573486,
0.6872714757919312,
-0.04667622596025467,
0.8758758306503296,
-0.5630982518196106,
0.13568244874477386,
0.810762882232666,
-0.7828823328018188,
0.591377854347229,
0.3107610046863556,
-0.45308956503868103,
0.5446025729179382,
0.8765044808387756,
-0.3996076285839081,
0.2433716058731079,
-0.13972552120685577,
-0.09865770488977432,
0.10831600427627563,
-0.34551459550857544,
-0.33340227603912354,
0.27433523535728455,
0.5648884773254395,
-0.05938981473445892,
-0.042089544236660004,
-0.19109991192817688,
-0.09978815168142319,
0.19464485347270966,
-0.33891260623931885,
0.47515514492988586,
-0.10908786952495575,
-0.3056352138519287,
0.25757482647895813,
0.06139836460351944,
0.44751590490341187,
-0.432292103767395,
0.0036370684392750263,
-0.30789780616760254,
0.11041989177465439,
-0.11662670969963074,
-0.733069121837616,
0.8304864168167114,
-0.016962489113211632,
-0.5883191823959351,
-0.14802303910255432,
0.3145180642604828,
0.008955933153629303,
-0.4608968198299408,
-0.02659478597342968,
0.5568270087242126,
-0.011077726259827614,
0.34624171257019043,
-0.8948691487312317,
0.21556834876537323,
-0.08658482879400253,
0.1012638658285141,
0.28451329469680786,
0.27483126521110535,
-0.18794286251068115,
0.9052972197532654,
0.6214550137519836,
-0.05323604866862297,
-0.381314754486084,
-0.2697960436344147,
0.7864605784416199,
-0.48152458667755127,
-0.473836213350296,
-0.5563985109329224,
0.5893168449401855,
0.16062821447849274,
-0.13450945913791656,
0.3171718418598175,
0.6760649085044861,
0.8199869394302368,
0.23543936014175415,
1.1852868795394897,
-0.27225878834724426,
0.6302565932273865,
-0.11461663246154785,
0.792430579662323,
-0.677882194519043,
0.253057599067688,
0.11853011697530746,
-0.6858844757080078,
-0.2645818591117859,
0.574648916721344,
-0.5593293309211731,
0.09640687704086304,
-0.07096041738986969,
0.7775445580482483,
-0.2038947343826294,
-0.007430347613990307,
0.21204137802124023,
0.035166848450899124,
0.578935980796814,
0.3758223056793213,
0.7235144376754761,
-0.2262544184923172,
-0.030273282900452614,
-0.16528061032295227,
-0.10567974299192429,
-0.41344699263572693,
-0.3865933120250702,
-0.23242594301700592,
-0.6220532655715942,
-0.45469930768013,
0.12244433164596558,
-0.005317091941833496,
0.6465361714363098,
0.8000264167785645,
-0.6291042566299438,
-0.2908027172088623,
-0.4853692948818207,
0.10251416265964508,
-0.3667908310890198,
-0.2858589291572571,
0.021306630223989487,
-0.11396335065364838,
-0.8284345865249634,
0.3899160921573639,
0.12675462663173676,
0.10837893187999725,
-0.5349341630935669,
0.05130630359053612,
-0.11394146829843521,
0.5669624209403992,
0.034964848309755325,
0.5449331402778625,
-0.11050187796354294,
-0.09506743401288986,
-0.09195452928543091,
0.06137096881866455,
0.37448954582214355,
0.5005353093147278,
-0.7295829653739929,
0.36316582560539246,
0.39518803358078003,
0.8301537036895752,
0.20776329934597015,
0.34344401955604553,
0.8660027980804443,
-0.40030863881111145,
0.2793552875518799,
0.7168763279914856,
-0.018625732511281967,
0.5275469422340393,
-0.6232884526252747,
0.6863193511962891,
0.3867545425891876,
-0.8395501971244812,
-1.3617550134658813,
0.3161593973636627,
-0.5165669918060303,
-0.42511463165283203,
0.4682268798351288,
-0.10924576967954636,
-0.2511439025402069,
-0.11723047494888306,
0.179829940199852,
0.1609855592250824,
-0.30572056770324707,
1.0828748941421509,
0.5696271061897278,
-0.6317760944366455,
0.18888162076473236,
-0.9783097505569458,
0.3646893799304962,
0.4727766513824463,
-0.8279679417610168,
0.27795839309692383,
0.6869125962257385,
-0.21564260125160217,
-0.013278065249323845,
-0.22205856442451477,
-0.03420339152216911,
0.226747527718544,
0.18312565982341766,
0.1834714710712433,
-0.328918993473053,
-0.6943425536155701,
-0.42307353019714355,
0.08158168941736221,
0.18282024562358856,
-0.26902586221694946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14668v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14668v1
|
Predicting Learning Performance with Large Language Models: A Study in Adult Literacy
| 2024-03-04T08:14:07 | 2024-03-04T08:14:07 |
Liang Zhang, Jionghao Lin, Conrad Borchers, John Sabatini, John Hollander, Meng Cao, Xiangen Hu
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Intelligent Tutoring Systems (ITSs) have significantly enhanced adult
literacy training, a key factor for societal participation, employment
opportunities, and lifelong learning. Our study investigates the application of
advanced AI models, including Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4, for
predicting learning performance in adult literacy programs in ITSs. This
research is motivated by the potential of LLMs to predict learning performance
based on its inherent reasoning and computational capabilities. By using
reading comprehension datasets from the ITS, AutoTutor, we evaluate the
predictive capabilities of GPT-4 versus traditional machine learning methods in
predicting learning performance through five-fold cross-validation techniques.
Our findings show that the GPT-4 presents the competitive predictive abilities
with traditional machine learning methods such as Bayesian Knowledge Tracing,
Performance Factor Analysis, Sparse Factor Analysis Lite (SPARFA-Lite), tensor
factorization and eXtreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost). While XGBoost (trained
on local machine) outperforms GPT-4 in predictive accuracy, GPT-4-selected
XGBoost and its subsequent tuning on the GPT-4 platform demonstrates superior
performance compared to local machine execution. Moreover, our investigation
into hyper-parameter tuning by GPT-4 versus grid-search suggests comparable
performance, albeit with less stability in the automated approach, using
XGBoost as the case study. Our study contributes to the field by highlighting
the potential of integrating LLMs with traditional machine learning models to
enhance predictive accuracy and personalize adult literacy education, setting a
foundation for future research in applying LLMs within ITSs.
|
[
-0.3218097388744354,
-0.6996806263923645,
0.43238189816474915,
-0.21662592887878418,
0.018764981999993324,
0.42615991830825806,
-0.2551445960998535,
-0.4603400230407715,
-0.369863361120224,
0.3225918114185333,
-0.38697361946105957,
-0.5182221531867981,
-0.44228821992874146,
0.2806593179702759,
-0.2441236525774002,
0.7427717447280884,
-0.05923705920577049,
0.37480106949806213,
-0.4256441295146942,
0.2575152814388275,
-0.5875643491744995,
-0.5696898102760315,
-0.859682559967041,
-0.5400802493095398,
0.4052862823009491,
0.32619765400886536,
0.6102215051651001,
0.898800253868103,
0.3162972331047058,
0.34994417428970337,
0.2085256725549698,
0.026153869926929474,
-0.2705846428871155,
0.008193866349756718,
-0.14272725582122803,
-0.57967609167099,
-0.3133755922317505,
-0.11307500302791595,
0.7560480833053589,
0.1607765406370163,
0.0026068631559610367,
-0.04293176159262657,
0.21474701166152954,
0.582318127155304,
-0.28342461585998535,
0.5745010375976562,
-0.6706934571266174,
0.012273027561604977,
-0.24733947217464447,
-0.2221289575099945,
-0.299953818321228,
-0.30711400508880615,
0.22477121651172638,
-0.4539223313331604,
0.325762540102005,
0.3606410622596741,
0.5096625089645386,
0.2648656368255615,
-0.31526172161102295,
-0.386003702878952,
-0.5829275846481323,
0.7514280080795288,
-0.7223966121673584,
0.6045260429382324,
0.5821149349212646,
0.5304466485977173,
0.19932782649993896,
-0.5754294395446777,
-0.5318876504898071,
-0.43408510088920593,
-0.04410799965262413,
0.16984951496124268,
0.14733651280403137,
0.16373756527900696,
0.1256694197654724,
0.3479762375354767,
-0.7365387678146362,
0.42249369621276855,
-0.5965883731842041,
-0.0433705672621727,
0.5743063688278198,
0.3921870291233063,
0.04889795556664467,
0.045902516692876816,
-0.4074748456478119,
0.06451293081045151,
-0.7060549259185791,
0.2740733027458191,
0.27306821942329407,
0.2991885840892792,
0.18520621955394745,
0.5532864928245544,
-0.04589569568634033,
0.45022398233413696,
-0.1798064410686493,
-0.17774075269699097,
0.19141022861003876,
-0.3343677222728729,
0.06154792010784149,
-0.1593862920999527,
0.7334909439086914,
0.0704316794872284,
0.5870137214660645,
-0.18114155530929565,
-0.4144030809402466,
-0.09594400227069855,
0.17041708528995514,
-0.7232377529144287,
-0.3302518427371979,
-0.02713005058467388,
-0.12386239320039749,
0.007702379487454891,
-0.28794386982917786,
-0.7920868396759033,
-0.3078230321407318,
-0.607912003993988,
0.3425896167755127,
-0.7537562251091003,
0.16278456151485443,
-0.02112502045929432,
0.15848331153392792,
0.01716666854918003,
0.37815219163894653,
-1.0613240003585815,
0.3457852602005005,
0.7224181890487671,
0.8900966048240662,
-0.6262909770011902,
-0.5295181274414062,
-0.22964785993099213,
0.09118716418743134,
-0.07609745860099792,
0.6030528545379639,
-0.7481420040130615,
-0.27669650316238403,
0.22541773319244385,
-0.41603654623031616,
-0.4340748190879822,
-0.362870991230011,
0.6118465065956116,
-0.6712358593940735,
0.049105796962976456,
-0.019791172817349434,
-0.8600530624389648,
-0.30946269631385803,
0.36487212777137756,
-0.7182058095932007,
0.9179779887199402,
0.16017434000968933,
-0.6437413692474365,
0.18978063762187958,
-0.6425601840019226,
-0.2591485381126404,
0.2332812249660492,
-0.3150936961174011,
-0.6762580871582031,
-0.22156500816345215,
0.3417285084724426,
0.6436406373977661,
-0.4268094003200531,
0.16395093500614166,
-0.1560778170824051,
-0.6092444658279419,
0.1241525337100029,
-0.7049821019172668,
0.3934229016304016,
0.061527591198682785,
-0.5399951338768005,
0.34352725744247437,
-0.5016497373580933,
0.12247132509946823,
0.027558287605643272,
-0.42881423234939575,
0.16563597321510315,
0.022158732637763023,
-0.26106423139572144,
0.10175258666276932,
0.30409303307533264,
-0.5366974472999573,
0.19392289221286774,
-0.06959425657987595,
0.3916395604610443,
0.8702523708343506,
-0.3257932960987091,
0.23849546909332275,
-0.25771820545196533,
0.8510286808013916,
-0.23942463099956512,
0.008771764114499092,
-0.37385448813438416,
-0.7055136561393738,
-0.5047409534454346,
-0.44742488861083984,
0.49185994267463684,
0.7096081972122192,
-0.916888952255249,
0.2775413990020752,
-0.2974877953529358,
-0.372099906206131,
-0.4480639696121216,
0.20844341814517975,
0.34576937556266785,
0.30694475769996643,
0.4840873181819916,
0.3246952295303345,
-0.3662092983722687,
-0.45683351159095764,
-0.36160802841186523,
-0.1624135673046112,
-0.025662513449788094,
0.36554983258247375,
0.520264208316803,
-0.39061444997787476,
0.6842495799064636,
-0.281607449054718,
-0.49802327156066895,
-0.30646950006484985,
-0.07160142809152603,
-0.036535367369651794,
0.2955247759819031,
0.3757523000240326,
-0.61276775598526,
-0.7504668831825256,
0.1515633463859558,
-0.6303971409797668,
0.2116835117340088,
0.1694917529821396,
0.29879337549209595,
0.19884277880191803,
0.40512794256210327,
-0.3917059898376465,
0.4904385805130005,
0.5758846998214722,
-0.4369572699069977,
0.8965365290641785,
-0.35086455941200256,
0.11404147744178772,
-0.5709797739982605,
-0.11209797114133835,
0.16271840035915375,
-0.20176637172698975,
-0.3722374141216278,
0.007911143824458122,
0.24312303960323334,
-0.08226019144058228,
0.06529415398836136,
0.6283109188079834,
-0.37902870774269104,
-0.2506899833679199,
-0.08524730056524277,
0.08900926262140274,
-0.2733839750289917,
0.3893985450267792,
0.06548070162534714,
1.1048535108566284,
0.44694778323173523,
-0.24152490496635437,
0.3300216495990753,
0.24287497997283936,
-0.5354453325271606,
0.13030478358268738,
-0.6955969333648682,
-0.11877258121967316,
0.12170287221670151,
0.2333381474018097,
-0.9681083559989929,
-0.11298397928476334,
-0.14613252878189087,
-0.5155609846115112,
0.3693888187408447,
0.2239283174276352,
-0.4704880118370056,
-0.5654981136322021,
-0.17110052704811096,
0.25792840123176575,
0.4037824869155884,
-0.5018965601921082,
0.707716166973114,
-0.07149503380060196,
-0.5939487814903259,
-0.7035604119300842,
-0.3091586232185364,
-0.007612569257616997,
-0.07489286363124847,
-0.53958660364151,
0.2778318226337433,
-0.25910329818725586,
0.10586623847484589,
-0.15174101293087006,
0.3126430809497833,
-0.011575773358345032,
0.05315009504556656,
0.0970226377248764,
0.5787354111671448,
-0.25884830951690674,
0.09878632426261902,
0.0774196907877922,
-0.2672837972640991,
0.10129766911268234,
-0.14406359195709229,
0.40133729577064514,
-0.4020042419433594,
-0.3265105187892914,
-0.21273277699947357,
0.06736345589160919,
0.4900397062301636,
-0.498578816652298,
0.6360641121864319,
0.8124774694442749,
-0.12625183165073395,
-0.26500338315963745,
-0.5340108275413513,
-0.2981242537498474,
-0.4929044544696808,
0.5221748352050781,
-0.4107035994529724,
-1.0844844579696655,
0.44990429282188416,
0.11175869405269623,
0.11823707818984985,
0.18208983540534973,
0.5912368893623352,
-0.04176563769578934,
1.3792328834533691,
0.3029383718967438,
-0.24169164896011353,
0.5957008600234985,
-0.36636659502983093,
0.10570121556520462,
-0.771900475025177,
-0.3760616183280945,
-0.43489277362823486,
-0.10280093550682068,
-0.6061776280403137,
-0.44725146889686584,
0.3425180912017822,
-0.08246778696775436,
-0.46067681908607483,
-0.052320562303066254,
-0.1822720617055893,
0.5291269421577454,
0.598005473613739,
-0.12148553133010864,
0.49583104252815247,
0.11482340842485428,
-0.43556779623031616,
-0.0035557292867451906,
-0.6169661283493042,
-0.5337490439414978,
1.2126456499099731,
0.5441468954086304,
0.5597851276397705,
-0.042672716081142426,
0.44298529624938965,
0.3350902497768402,
0.5516074299812317,
-0.5727189183235168,
0.39048635959625244,
-0.24086464941501617,
-0.6825217008590698,
-0.4113493263721466,
-0.48262715339660645,
-0.8864385485649109,
0.30363306403160095,
-0.18166540563106537,
-0.6768479347229004,
-0.2500481605529785,
0.11763717234134674,
-0.26305511593818665,
0.3794827461242676,
-0.49410879611968994,
0.6909657120704651,
-0.4905606508255005,
-0.47323423624038696,
-0.28168028593063354,
-0.4926382601261139,
0.10231412947177887,
-0.3657400608062744,
0.19670766592025757,
0.03730594739317894,
-0.2644593417644501,
0.5243683457374573,
0.0525999553501606,
0.8344970941543579,
0.007099633105099201,
0.09764575958251953,
0.10245203971862793,
-0.11896036565303802,
0.46953290700912476,
-0.07347125560045242,
-0.624882698059082,
0.30225902795791626,
-0.02092737890779972,
-0.3972035050392151,
-0.5168613791465759,
0.9447881579399109,
-1.1728107929229736,
-0.583371639251709,
-0.4091179370880127,
-0.43093031644821167,
-0.47648876905441284,
0.3769836127758026,
0.3409167230129242,
0.3783054053783417,
0.021517258137464523,
0.3264316916465759,
0.5635781288146973,
0.18601861596107483,
0.3428495228290558,
0.3679252564907074,
-0.28876832127571106,
-0.6473002433776855,
1.1294219493865967,
0.4161151349544525,
0.09517251700162888,
0.3399635851383209,
0.3981226980686188,
-0.653728187084198,
-1.0106240510940552,
-0.6938669681549072,
0.2323630154132843,
-0.739991307258606,
-0.22195914387702942,
-0.4341793358325958,
-0.22107183933258057,
-0.3797294795513153,
-0.19746749103069305,
-0.0549871064722538,
-0.022078797221183777,
-0.29471203684806824,
-0.27546969056129456,
0.06466149538755417,
1.031470775604248,
0.23680415749549866,
0.4661233723163605,
-0.7270260453224182,
0.0175402220338583,
0.1675596535205841,
0.470704585313797,
0.06527838855981827,
-0.5803902745246887,
-0.5039774179458618,
-0.09714852273464203,
-0.4267358183860779,
-0.4205395579338074,
0.4643518626689911,
0.299277126789093,
0.7278172373771667,
0.22835253179073334,
-0.16075316071510315,
0.30301812291145325,
-0.6289515495300293,
0.7320055961608887,
-0.08194750547409058,
-0.6746607422828674,
-0.03518882766366005,
-0.6072396039962769,
0.15647248923778534,
0.517460823059082,
0.7689102292060852,
-0.0079678138718009,
-0.007168228272348642,
-0.3516237735748291,
-0.6787135601043701,
0.4890919327735901,
0.0512579008936882,
-0.18115484714508057,
0.25822708010673523,
0.5387191772460938,
0.37870559096336365,
0.45395249128341675,
-0.6444713473320007,
-0.12508730590343475,
-0.16284282505512238,
-0.36188098788261414,
-0.47555285692214966,
-0.07757814228534698,
0.4035300314426422,
-0.4305194914340973,
0.8740649223327637,
-0.3994894325733185,
0.3229770362377167,
-0.3484218716621399,
0.19460074603557587,
-0.05059799179434776,
-0.12494056671857834,
0.31335172057151794,
0.8611423969268799,
0.03241392970085144,
-0.21184715628623962,
0.09852121025323868,
-0.39537861943244934,
-0.0026744601782411337,
0.15968678891658783,
-0.11793030053377151,
-0.2756006717681885,
0.5044112205505371,
1.0131721496582031,
0.16460373997688293,
-0.6950037479400635,
0.4291432797908783,
-0.06312902271747589,
-0.12011086940765381,
-0.6252089738845825,
0.29411807656288147,
0.153702512383461,
0.413522332906723,
0.3931005597114563,
0.0036109669599682093,
0.06054640933871269,
-0.35554414987564087,
0.08468402177095413,
0.3388766944408417,
-0.2670610845088959,
-0.36484089493751526,
0.6185539960861206,
0.27656736969947815,
-0.3586023449897766,
0.8261803388595581,
0.050465621054172516,
-0.7316995859146118,
0.5632002949714661,
0.6577644348144531,
0.7157431244850159,
-0.5578934550285339,
0.043764736503362656,
0.33387818932533264,
0.10479828715324402,
-0.03833157196640968,
0.0979330837726593,
-0.10852520167827606,
-0.6384093761444092,
-0.5661419630050659,
-0.6185401082038879,
-0.48393839597702026,
0.04942638799548149,
-0.43148764967918396,
0.26889678835868835,
-0.4374672472476959,
-0.028721634298563004,
-0.09785893559455872,
0.29563164710998535,
-0.8223901391029358,
0.45341038703918457,
0.23809143900871277,
0.908602774143219,
-0.5959994792938232,
0.996397078037262,
0.5651087760925293,
-0.23328976333141327,
-0.6958986520767212,
0.07811933010816574,
-0.037371743470430374,
-0.8431520462036133,
0.46514275670051575,
0.3644203543663025,
-0.06775100529193878,
0.3425654172897339,
-0.05198150500655174,
-0.9425988793373108,
1.2185598611831665,
0.16787080466747284,
-0.6566793322563171,
-0.4147263169288635,
0.3131890594959259,
0.49393174052238464,
-0.49502894282341003,
0.6842195987701416,
0.6763252019882202,
0.49879494309425354,
0.15257082879543304,
-0.7960083484649658,
-0.2518732249736786,
-0.09467656165361404,
0.0030526812188327312,
0.013354122638702393,
-0.538074791431427,
0.9356822371482849,
-0.3458907902240753,
0.15464118123054504,
0.3189898133277893,
0.704796314239502,
0.3740764558315277,
0.48255208134651184,
0.22794926166534424,
0.1901881843805313,
0.8428605794906616,
-0.08874638378620148,
1.091115951538086,
-0.4195632338523865,
0.2713921070098877,
0.8526635766029358,
-0.25877678394317627,
1.1132491827011108,
-0.10565744340419769,
-0.37695783376693726,
0.6352506279945374,
0.6301988959312439,
0.03832419216632843,
0.2660946249961853,
0.06018468737602234,
-0.36249804496765137,
-0.17388448119163513,
0.44663500785827637,
-0.1921648532152176,
0.4633080065250397,
0.5935087203979492,
-0.4179549515247345,
0.17398439347743988,
0.29606857895851135,
-0.18313832581043243,
0.08058708161115646,
-0.4479980766773224,
0.6832112073898315,
-0.10741649568080902,
-0.7871853709220886,
0.6218596696853638,
-0.0369240865111351,
0.6712697148323059,
-0.6671086549758911,
0.033967599272727966,
0.10922780632972717,
0.5764063000679016,
-0.06712540984153748,
-0.90615314245224,
-0.11912650614976883,
-0.26463204622268677,
-0.06673526018857956,
-0.0009775971993803978,
0.69491046667099,
-0.47968295216560364,
-0.47638458013534546,
0.3635514974594116,
0.43169841170310974,
-0.0808250680565834,
0.0001933347957674414,
-0.9536966681480408,
0.07592134177684784,
0.22762253880500793,
-0.37311264872550964,
0.5798671245574951,
0.344646692276001,
-0.10665563493967056,
1.1015515327453613,
0.6251533031463623,
0.07791005820035934,
0.17247770726680756,
-0.2167234569787979,
0.7175053954124451,
-0.5454317927360535,
-0.6720739006996155,
-0.700471043586731,
0.31661441922187805,
0.07274289429187775,
-0.3694911301136017,
0.9501569867134094,
0.5234588980674744,
0.8192880153656006,
0.032097361981868744,
1.1434985399246216,
0.5106338262557983,
0.6857656836509705,
-0.40562570095062256,
0.48471206426620483,
-0.21595042943954468,
0.3236665427684784,
0.07370105385780334,
-0.9784553050994873,
-0.07244844734668732,
0.414137065410614,
-0.7120429277420044,
0.5232176780700684,
0.5777977108955383,
0.5882344245910645,
0.16463448107242584,
0.4245537221431732,
0.6203163862228394,
0.06650761514902115,
0.489746630191803,
0.16255883872509003,
0.6763006448745728,
0.020512012764811516,
0.32643789052963257,
-0.2871086597442627,
-0.2442999631166458,
-0.4959053099155426,
-0.5916715264320374,
-1.0488667488098145,
-0.5354418158531189,
-0.02763771265745163,
-0.01224021427333355,
0.3221842348575592,
0.8042208552360535,
0.445130318403244,
-0.6550710201263428,
-0.20295952260494232,
-0.09531240165233612,
-0.2187807857990265,
-0.18656432628631592,
-0.22485485672950745,
0.42192816734313965,
-0.349680095911026,
-0.8482688665390015,
0.48491403460502625,
-0.17838817834854126,
-0.17765137553215027,
-0.7363012433052063,
-0.3242418169975281,
-0.03249891847372055,
0.09634339064359665,
0.6556357145309448,
0.13797426223754883,
-0.6679779887199402,
-0.034384336322546005,
-0.007042494602501392,
0.10290785878896713,
-0.07214849442243576,
0.7837429642677307,
-0.9626026749610901,
0.49863889813423157,
0.5090028643608093,
0.8584132194519043,
0.6209259629249573,
0.14195095002651215,
0.5678165555000305,
-0.37179461121559143,
-0.4804425835609436,
0.48691582679748535,
0.430595725774765,
0.38808074593544006,
-0.5039966702461243,
0.4972721040248871,
0.10319849848747253,
-1.1244090795516968,
-0.41162505745887756,
-0.09736291319131851,
-0.3239061236381531,
-0.21896301209926605,
1.1096364259719849,
-0.4384388327598572,
-0.17825616896152496,
-0.4454697370529175,
-0.30588117241859436,
0.05286630615592003,
-0.5419622659683228,
0.6011343598365784,
0.5040160417556763,
-0.3954041302204132,
-0.2811647057533264,
-1.008857250213623,
0.4354431927204132,
0.4718289375305176,
-0.6526147127151489,
0.1847183108329773,
0.4706922769546509,
0.28237301111221313,
-0.030476240441203117,
0.18107996881008148,
0.07690519094467163,
0.26764199137687683,
-0.10651910305023193,
-0.12663593888282776,
-0.5192246437072754,
-0.4048807621002197,
-0.24563506245613098,
0.21978658437728882,
0.08082634210586548,
0.19117316603660583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01817v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01817v1
|
NusaBERT: Teaching IndoBERT to be Multilingual and Multicultural
| 2024-03-04T08:05:34 | 2024-03-04T08:05:34 |
Wilson Wongso, David Samuel Setiawan, Steven Limcorn, Ananto Joyoadikusumo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Indonesia's linguistic landscape is remarkably diverse, encompassing over 700
languages and dialects, making it one of the world's most linguistically rich
nations. This diversity, coupled with the widespread practice of code-switching
and the presence of low-resource regional languages, presents unique challenges
for modern pre-trained language models. In response to these challenges, we
developed NusaBERT, building upon IndoBERT by incorporating vocabulary
expansion and leveraging a diverse multilingual corpus that includes regional
languages and dialects. Through rigorous evaluation across a range of
benchmarks, NusaBERT demonstrates state-of-the-art performance in tasks
involving multiple languages of Indonesia, paving the way for future natural
language understanding research for under-represented languages.
|
[
-0.6730412840843201,
-0.335235059261322,
-0.15366019308567047,
0.6149927973747253,
-0.20759926736354828,
0.48796555399894714,
-0.7291144728660583,
-0.3643132150173187,
0.3721090853214264,
0.8104028105735779,
-0.1659894734621048,
-0.39921703934669495,
-0.8091267943382263,
0.6217622756958008,
-0.15535438060760498,
0.9213533401489258,
0.031479354947805405,
-0.16126792132854462,
0.23041562736034393,
-0.7166925072669983,
-0.2342442274093628,
-0.5574130415916443,
-0.13839341700077057,
-0.1176525354385376,
0.2977313995361328,
0.8238292932510376,
0.49956634640693665,
0.2162974327802658,
0.20003199577331543,
0.24418753385543823,
-0.22769629955291748,
0.14677174389362335,
-0.13374030590057373,
0.3261157274246216,
-0.0028659640811383724,
-0.6189686059951782,
0.04958926513791084,
-0.3232528269290924,
0.718856692314148,
0.9349808692932129,
0.11172666400671005,
0.23494580388069153,
0.18440590798854828,
0.8155888915061951,
-0.9383638501167297,
0.2956252098083496,
-0.32313600182533264,
-0.13463497161865234,
-0.2501356601715088,
-0.15200889110565186,
-0.46171078085899353,
-0.6608723402023315,
0.36962395906448364,
-0.6089004874229431,
-0.17854298651218414,
-0.6509056091308594,
0.4967481195926666,
0.3387127220630646,
-1.1437287330627441,
-0.27060577273368835,
-0.6765658259391785,
1.0016778707504272,
-0.19314563274383545,
0.3277144134044647,
0.4626210927963257,
0.3652547001838684,
0.22966493666172028,
-0.6327160000801086,
-0.2870117723941803,
-0.17545387148857117,
0.10819951444864273,
0.04303330183029175,
0.029907969757914543,
-0.15933996438980103,
0.026329753920435905,
0.16772249341011047,
-0.5077799558639526,
-0.05654871091246605,
-0.8171203136444092,
0.15286606550216675,
0.6922003030776978,
-0.15234950184822083,
0.41582536697387695,
-0.3842538297176361,
-0.15079183876514435,
-0.1006104126572609,
-0.6466037631034851,
0.14265857636928558,
0.42125871777534485,
0.5320778489112854,
-0.18478599190711975,
0.38048991560935974,
-0.2101966142654419,
0.966656506061554,
-0.5701090097427368,
-0.051321130245923996,
0.4964614808559418,
-0.11392362415790558,
-0.07883719354867935,
0.4377005994319916,
0.2711329162120819,
0.3661932647228241,
0.5462305545806885,
0.19040590524673462,
0.28192806243896484,
0.28259390592575073,
-0.005149136297404766,
-0.6992027163505554,
-0.36229538917541504,
0.2433348000049591,
-0.2866043746471405,
-0.24251776933670044,
-0.2121594101190567,
-0.8711822628974915,
-0.2831383943557739,
-0.42117759585380554,
0.10412479192018509,
-0.718293309211731,
-0.7681058049201965,
0.022263605147600174,
-0.1636543571949005,
0.16795745491981506,
0.11326569318771362,
-1.1446961164474487,
0.16175805032253265,
0.48786139488220215,
0.7492958903312683,
0.22754491865634918,
-0.5258077383041382,
-0.3529641032218933,
0.12367670238018036,
-0.4570811092853546,
0.6804174184799194,
-0.9101226925849915,
-0.4013984203338623,
0.3218269646167755,
-0.17485304176807404,
0.017448648810386658,
-0.3261893689632416,
0.31491076946258545,
-0.22679948806762695,
0.10320746153593063,
-0.2628079652786255,
-0.09084289520978928,
-0.5454580783843994,
0.3261956572532654,
-0.7351473569869995,
1.202935814857483,
0.3092953860759735,
-0.8074729442596436,
0.5394364595413208,
-0.8965122103691101,
-0.5440948009490967,
0.4180622100830078,
-0.3078097105026245,
0.17660509049892426,
0.16959306597709656,
0.320212185382843,
0.2600996494293213,
0.04069479554891586,
0.16004832088947296,
0.012229256331920624,
-0.3952002227306366,
0.09805087745189667,
-0.1552196741104126,
1.373788833618164,
0.2742792069911957,
-0.3081928491592407,
0.08906904608011246,
-0.9207087755203247,
0.050489988178014755,
-0.21960008144378662,
-0.32486188411712646,
-0.9390296936035156,
-0.46186304092407227,
0.3137741684913635,
0.1971915066242218,
0.10245227068662643,
-0.46029403805732727,
0.6122827529907227,
-0.5674633979797363,
0.3989225924015045,
0.2533628046512604,
-0.18729698657989502,
0.6769477725028992,
-0.039984408766031265,
0.8655170202255249,
-0.16421028971672058,
0.0035065701231360435,
-0.346637099981308,
-0.4754053056240082,
-0.820473313331604,
-0.43950846791267395,
0.29713988304138184,
0.6530721187591553,
-1.0299596786499023,
0.11081105470657349,
-0.2588166296482086,
-0.644633948802948,
-0.7068001627922058,
0.5015749931335449,
0.007662701420485973,
-0.1140594333410263,
0.39706704020500183,
-0.39271652698516846,
-0.7211479544639587,
-0.7618776559829712,
-0.41801708936691284,
0.0019164037657901645,
0.16668635606765747,
0.06208540499210358,
0.46412956714630127,
-0.47768938541412354,
0.8477502465248108,
-0.19350866973400116,
-0.30644479393959045,
-0.8183223009109497,
0.39754509925842285,
0.262443482875824,
0.4058559834957123,
0.9007068872451782,
-0.8239625692367554,
-0.8219383955001831,
0.05045197904109955,
-0.7028210759162903,
-0.07742597907781601,
0.19505652785301208,
0.02639526128768921,
0.36427533626556396,
0.5822905898094177,
-0.28923988342285156,
0.480855256319046,
0.823056697845459,
-0.10949593037366867,
0.42661213874816895,
-0.3831959068775177,
0.16600725054740906,
-1.2301721572875977,
-0.04802974313497543,
-0.0980922058224678,
0.29055991768836975,
-0.7767695784568787,
0.058459993451833725,
0.21504348516464233,
-0.14769433438777924,
-0.6492597460746765,
0.4892120957374573,
-0.5806925892829895,
0.197088360786438,
-0.19871634244918823,
-0.08187717199325562,
-0.10796695947647095,
0.18822452425956726,
-0.007144899107515812,
0.7218979001045227,
0.7090038061141968,
-0.7239905595779419,
0.23326051235198975,
0.39600837230682373,
-0.5838195085525513,
0.632932722568512,
-0.3280423581600189,
-0.34740743041038513,
-0.5057467818260193,
0.2073451429605484,
-0.8023464679718018,
-0.35026341676712036,
-0.09502371400594711,
-0.3193596303462982,
0.23149675130844116,
-0.5884071588516235,
-0.32966774702072144,
-0.04164183884859085,
-0.08925359696149826,
0.6487810611724854,
0.4729485511779785,
-0.6745820045471191,
0.8149973154067993,
0.3866936266422272,
-0.3666645586490631,
-1.0833969116210938,
-0.8280901312828064,
0.23259353637695312,
-0.5029345750808716,
-0.4747683107852936,
-0.07197831571102142,
0.25791600346565247,
-0.5337867736816406,
-0.17676667869091034,
0.10295484960079193,
-0.5046409964561462,
0.3915288746356964,
0.29921114444732666,
-0.028532931581139565,
-0.2348792999982834,
0.3393230736255646,
0.24710725247859955,
-0.12320759147405624,
-0.00020981463603675365,
-0.3498098850250244,
0.639748215675354,
-0.5647832155227661,
-0.08303874731063843,
0.06639327853918076,
0.41026321053504944,
0.5727109313011169,
-0.795051634311676,
0.8468664884567261,
0.6763846278190613,
-0.262407511472702,
-0.2667776644229889,
-0.25296998023986816,
0.015133262611925602,
-0.43914780020713806,
0.3889494240283966,
-0.4910712242126465,
-0.9726072549819946,
0.3981820344924927,
-0.390993595123291,
0.2409704178571701,
0.3542921841144562,
0.5222444534301758,
0.30487239360809326,
0.529869556427002,
1.0644149780273438,
0.14024284482002258,
0.33088991045951843,
-0.4831826686859131,
0.3632620871067047,
-0.6997271180152893,
-0.11584119498729706,
-0.5941057205200195,
-0.0017099113902077079,
-0.9305726289749146,
-0.37840092182159424,
0.240359827876091,
0.013292265124619007,
-0.1905386596918106,
0.7018940448760986,
-0.5640060901641846,
0.777320146560669,
0.5420891642570496,
-0.5085525512695312,
0.24937723577022552,
0.1655234396457672,
-0.24843604862689972,
-0.3997846245765686,
-0.8273702263832092,
-0.8671298027038574,
1.429842472076416,
0.05198391526937485,
0.8843088746070862,
0.6273877024650574,
0.9808752536773682,
0.017817562445998192,
0.5029321312904358,
-0.3051562011241913,
0.2783382833003998,
-0.3618581295013428,
-0.804288387298584,
-0.30041947960853577,
-0.05635396018624306,
-1.1936765909194946,
0.7670624256134033,
0.05492580682039261,
-0.7195993065834045,
0.23056668043136597,
-0.003016501432284713,
-0.4000853896141052,
0.27616193890571594,
-0.6741260290145874,
0.9059107899665833,
-0.39218613505363464,
-0.08885996043682098,
-0.28578686714172363,
-0.893651008605957,
0.5562753677368164,
0.019430553540587425,
0.4319874942302704,
-0.25259363651275635,
0.00230810372158885,
0.5531413555145264,
0.22664761543273926,
0.8384234309196472,
0.07462271302938461,
0.07442396879196167,
0.30537256598472595,
0.25800594687461853,
-0.5382592678070068,
0.38907590508461,
-0.135087251663208,
0.22374854981899261,
0.26858967542648315,
-0.5482794046401978,
-0.41914400458335876,
0.7750726342201233,
-1.0072060823440552,
-0.05905071273446083,
-0.8397072553634644,
-0.5459505319595337,
-0.031445685774087906,
0.15614749491214752,
0.1336984634399414,
0.5689405202865601,
-0.20856234431266785,
0.356765478849411,
0.5524290204048157,
-0.6021387577056885,
0.3417952358722687,
0.470488041639328,
-0.5250118970870972,
-0.4590669572353363,
0.993181049823761,
0.33619722723960876,
0.2823735177516937,
0.24824777245521545,
-0.03821051865816116,
-0.3125801682472229,
0.12427248060703278,
-0.32091274857521057,
0.10603802651166916,
-1.152479887008667,
0.24843119084835052,
-0.9937798976898193,
-0.022651225328445435,
-0.5502415895462036,
-0.4557165205478668,
-0.31644049286842346,
-0.7105069756507874,
-0.082656130194664,
0.0646355003118515,
0.3277096748352051,
0.7544347047805786,
-0.4353795349597931,
0.48469069600105286,
-0.7859387397766113,
0.07008088380098343,
0.3290558457374573,
0.3058300018310547,
-0.19522257149219513,
-0.39364853501319885,
0.04805579036474228,
-0.25824350118637085,
-0.012440563179552555,
-0.8907273411750793,
0.5410746932029724,
0.35904085636138916,
0.5698165893554688,
0.20026428997516632,
0.23786911368370056,
0.34848350286483765,
-0.03565863147377968,
0.6877092123031616,
-0.05334417521953583,
-0.8509500622749329,
0.691567599773407,
-0.14636261761188507,
0.5847494006156921,
0.9501776099205017,
0.7375079393386841,
-0.8472247123718262,
-0.28754523396492004,
-0.667303740978241,
-1.2086008787155151,
0.4620376527309418,
-0.05397003889083862,
0.4030725359916687,
-0.07940692454576492,
-0.03624220937490463,
0.3739788830280304,
0.3974915146827698,
-0.7909253835678101,
-0.18302695453166962,
-0.5741539597511292,
-0.1611829549074173,
-0.332385390996933,
-0.37327542901039124,
-0.22072002291679382,
-0.5838577747344971,
0.5544846057891846,
-0.3376752734184265,
0.018547039479017258,
-0.008684009313583374,
-0.6582537293434143,
0.32938462495803833,
0.63999342918396,
0.8241147994995117,
0.9816619753837585,
-0.18508024513721466,
0.42452430725097656,
0.3338606655597687,
-0.3471446633338928,
0.32350268959999084,
0.14530615508556366,
0.12856467068195343,
0.17842654883861542,
0.488410085439682,
0.6530035734176636,
0.2665729820728302,
-0.7444971203804016,
0.32098788022994995,
-0.21832168102264404,
-0.10624062269926071,
-0.6931040287017822,
0.06636541336774826,
-0.04817010089755058,
-0.0687459409236908,
0.4842073321342468,
0.12031432241201401,
-0.10947757959365845,
-0.225545272231102,
0.21335309743881226,
-0.09654344618320465,
-0.5034596920013428,
-0.059198539704084396,
0.4263108968734741,
0.5051931738853455,
-0.19536970555782318,
0.7523691654205322,
-0.2322075366973877,
-0.8500801920890808,
0.7127362489700317,
0.3324506878852844,
0.7432765364646912,
-0.396319717168808,
0.41380438208580017,
0.5709230899810791,
0.8088531494140625,
0.1600540727376938,
0.5507704615592957,
-0.3083753287792206,
-0.49543455243110657,
-0.7098425030708313,
-0.42029300332069397,
-0.511120080947876,
-0.08484157174825668,
-0.7233762741088867,
0.2235666662454605,
-0.5006171464920044,
-0.06824298202991486,
-0.14032766222953796,
-0.08059971779584885,
-0.7629331350326538,
-0.12233467400074005,
-0.07703716307878494,
1.1257175207138062,
-1.3286067247390747,
0.9054768085479736,
1.1110002994537354,
-0.5584220886230469,
-0.5072493553161621,
-0.08180206269025803,
-0.021349532529711723,
-0.5728843808174133,
1.1586629152297974,
0.6717128157615662,
0.14591588079929352,
-0.07408202439546585,
-0.39945468306541443,
-0.8176096081733704,
0.5276519060134888,
0.32913780212402344,
-0.1229146420955658,
0.6797888875007629,
0.19669142365455627,
0.6268725395202637,
-0.29949238896369934,
0.5252994894981384,
0.6298332810401917,
0.44468823075294495,
-0.30030885338783264,
-0.8553704619407654,
-0.4534686207771301,
-0.36545172333717346,
0.00197429908439517,
0.263713538646698,
-0.6049803495407104,
0.9757529497146606,
-0.04524725675582886,
0.06633413583040237,
-0.17411518096923828,
0.7834497690200806,
0.176065132021904,
-0.030092062428593636,
0.299725204706192,
0.33459150791168213,
0.5688819289207458,
-0.11261437833309174,
0.8709802031517029,
-0.7466588616371155,
0.25521254539489746,
1.0442019701004028,
-0.4915788471698761,
0.6495712995529175,
0.5650554299354553,
0.07197924703359604,
0.7197948098182678,
0.4131256341934204,
0.2160457819700241,
0.452630877494812,
0.1746387779712677,
-0.8410298824310303,
-0.32738083600997925,
-0.3038952648639679,
-0.5493088960647583,
0.8271587491035461,
0.5063844919204712,
0.07658638805150986,
-0.47355011105537415,
0.3181323707103729,
-0.10541167110204697,
0.3563760221004486,
0.04612286388874054,
0.3220849633216858,
0.041927676647901535,
-0.7152259349822998,
0.6513177156448364,
-0.1353609263896942,
0.7869121432304382,
-0.5239840149879456,
-0.233414888381958,
-0.3189201354980469,
0.38022470474243164,
-0.18482095003128052,
-0.9428873658180237,
0.41329458355903625,
-0.21175740659236908,
0.3858566880226135,
-0.2511546313762665,
0.6049175262451172,
-0.6870947480201721,
-0.46539267897605896,
0.309869647026062,
0.2240217626094818,
0.2664603590965271,
0.29010283946990967,
-0.3801441490650177,
0.23951761424541473,
-0.0010956362821161747,
0.15533266961574554,
0.046239223331213,
0.4137395918369293,
-0.30784016847610474,
0.8754208087921143,
0.4368184208869934,
-0.11086590588092804,
0.14578117430210114,
0.15617752075195312,
0.4662324786186218,
-0.456461638212204,
-0.7925109267234802,
-0.7134428024291992,
0.5508710741996765,
-0.30601486563682556,
-0.6929886937141418,
0.9453049898147583,
0.5466462969779968,
1.0156587362289429,
-0.16730518639087677,
1.213995099067688,
-0.21435029804706573,
0.33165523409843445,
0.08038809895515442,
0.520033061504364,
-0.37678414583206177,
-0.0831541046500206,
-0.21272985637187958,
-1.0732665061950684,
-0.6527457237243652,
1.0664328336715698,
-0.29259681701660156,
-0.0869121104478836,
0.4673047363758087,
0.39586055278778076,
-0.13172343373298645,
0.21664732694625854,
0.03906627744436264,
0.0135060865432024,
0.4581912159919739,
0.4446190893650055,
0.938700258731842,
-0.22609277069568634,
0.5437257885932922,
-0.3702589273452759,
-0.5122024416923523,
-0.2721697986125946,
-0.8811690807342529,
-1.1885182857513428,
-0.6342704892158508,
-0.24919810891151428,
-0.4194410741329193,
-0.07438721507787704,
1.2849763631820679,
0.5267302393913269,
-0.7684177160263062,
-0.6185765266418457,
0.23097635805606842,
0.004263622220605612,
-0.23032163083553314,
-0.15696831047534943,
0.04352223500609398,
-0.22902342677116394,
-0.6153798699378967,
0.2848846912384033,
0.610539972782135,
0.007807006128132343,
-0.5432568192481995,
-0.04239137843251228,
-0.4993137717247009,
-0.19615834951400757,
0.8295212388038635,
0.6682615280151367,
-0.6478682160377502,
0.05102301388978958,
-0.10021410882472992,
-0.181528240442276,
-0.10842064023017883,
0.6734001040458679,
-0.7935375571250916,
0.7049512267112732,
0.40681585669517517,
0.9600844979286194,
0.5385922193527222,
-0.41536784172058105,
0.5098045468330383,
-0.8148326873779297,
0.8354193568229675,
0.19362539052963257,
0.1439100056886673,
0.6013649106025696,
0.08975061774253845,
0.6418012976646423,
-0.05601029843091965,
-0.3760051727294922,
-0.8115094900131226,
0.2566474676132202,
-0.7561970353126526,
-0.2936743199825287,
1.015211582183838,
0.18545934557914734,
0.021761750802397728,
-0.49815744161605835,
-0.34896332025527954,
0.23340414464473724,
-0.06843848526477814,
0.687816858291626,
0.7293050289154053,
-0.06278804689645767,
-0.31191420555114746,
-0.8450950384140015,
0.4401157796382904,
0.7803085446357727,
-0.6478750109672546,
-0.1615934520959854,
0.10796274244785309,
0.4583717882633209,
0.2783544957637787,
0.5730783343315125,
0.11328297853469849,
0.3316143751144409,
-0.12128380686044693,
0.2689949870109558,
0.3108782470226288,
-0.4653187692165375,
-0.4197423756122589,
0.01918615959584713,
0.24327252805233002,
-0.09301605820655823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01811v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01811v2
|
Enhancing Multi-Domain Automatic Short Answer Grading through an Explainable Neuro-Symbolic Pipeline
| 2024-03-04T07:58:26 | 2024-03-19T15:40:52 |
Felix Künnecke, Anna Filighera, Colin Leong, Tim Steuer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Grading short answer questions automatically with interpretable reasoning
behind the grading decision is a challenging goal for current transformer
approaches. Justification cue detection, in combination with logical reasoners,
has shown a promising direction for neuro-symbolic architectures in ASAG. But,
one of the main challenges is the requirement of annotated justification cues
in the students' responses, which only exist for a few ASAG datasets. To
overcome this challenge, we contribute (1) a weakly supervised annotation
procedure for justification cues in ASAG datasets, and (2) a neuro-symbolic
model for explainable ASAG based on justification cues. Our approach improves
upon the RMSE by 0.24 to 0.3 compared to the state-of-the-art on the Short
Answer Feedback dataset in a bilingual, multi-domain, and multi-question
training setup. This result shows that our approach provides a promising
direction for generating high-quality grades and accompanying explanations for
future research in ASAG and educational NLP.
|
[
-0.7006921172142029,
-0.8259240388870239,
0.4483637511730194,
-0.042718637734651566,
-0.18056543171405792,
-0.38772445917129517,
-0.22536423802375793,
-0.2817398011684418,
0.29527202248573303,
0.19283099472522736,
-0.6760002374649048,
-0.45607322454452515,
-0.6631833910942078,
0.37557780742645264,
-0.1997142732143402,
1.3483664989471436,
-0.05120380222797394,
0.2803784906864166,
-0.41402581334114075,
-0.44442451000213623,
-0.6406034231185913,
-0.4568573236465454,
-1.066314697265625,
-0.5976200699806213,
0.6011400818824768,
0.6000133752822876,
0.6490673422813416,
0.6605266332626343,
0.30834144353866577,
0.2922719120979309,
0.024157637730240822,
0.1457616537809372,
0.3235892057418823,
-0.008535120636224747,
-0.29814982414245605,
-0.46180522441864014,
-0.745423436164856,
-0.07052864879369736,
0.4066142439842224,
0.7909468412399292,
0.16338679194450378,
0.33383795619010925,
0.12155681103467941,
0.5308395028114319,
-0.4386211931705475,
0.2278296947479248,
-0.17541800439357758,
0.02550906129181385,
-0.008333960548043251,
-0.14695465564727783,
-0.6970455646514893,
-0.4375627338886261,
0.31597602367401123,
-0.7243092060089111,
0.31462225317955017,
-0.0839909166097641,
0.9692878127098083,
0.41593024134635925,
-0.6175217628479004,
-0.25093984603881836,
-0.32507219910621643,
0.8125878572463989,
-0.5784856081008911,
-0.09077247232198715,
0.49806883931159973,
0.7109107971191406,
0.39310434460639954,
-0.6351723074913025,
-0.476993590593338,
0.026372777298092842,
-0.3569112718105316,
0.19598276913166046,
0.03715059161186218,
0.16967667639255524,
0.3109535872936249,
0.28977131843566895,
-0.33968275785446167,
0.1921752393245697,
-0.31779971718788147,
-0.33131143450737,
0.7095120549201965,
0.16171258687973022,
0.09456545114517212,
-0.5101289749145508,
-0.3426259756088257,
0.010894384235143661,
-0.5926073789596558,
0.12135954946279526,
0.39917099475860596,
0.44399651885032654,
0.15210695564746857,
0.5618690848350525,
-0.0843358114361763,
0.5922850966453552,
0.07102696597576141,
0.1603536158800125,
0.19761747121810913,
-0.1587761789560318,
-0.0018197848694399,
0.15605910122394562,
0.6486514806747437,
0.4204546809196472,
0.2776162624359131,
0.032740071415901184,
-0.23564429581165314,
0.3325718939304352,
0.39338910579681396,
-0.7641264200210571,
-0.23885495960712433,
0.17421399056911469,
-0.3992951810359955,
-0.27233657240867615,
-0.3079105615615845,
-0.791107714176178,
-0.4048772156238556,
-0.8194907903671265,
0.6208702325820923,
-0.316832959651947,
0.14324407279491425,
0.016183754429221153,
-0.21831262111663818,
0.3788414001464844,
0.7445642352104187,
-0.7076377868652344,
0.2799726724624634,
0.39505818486213684,
0.6585611701011658,
-0.25477609038352966,
-0.3935011923313141,
-0.4055391848087311,
-0.13718459010124207,
-0.08017607033252716,
1.1342129707336426,
-0.2941453456878662,
0.06833449751138687,
-0.1726994663476944,
0.16231676936149597,
-0.0541362501680851,
-0.4702775478363037,
0.8818344473838806,
-0.42207956314086914,
0.6698397994041443,
-0.2478228509426117,
-0.5221607089042664,
-0.5381786823272705,
0.4493577778339386,
-0.4557197093963623,
0.8095928430557251,
-0.051458414644002914,
-0.6583364009857178,
0.3840465843677521,
-0.8816016912460327,
-0.5780646800994873,
0.08671410381793976,
0.020126713439822197,
-0.4108602702617645,
-0.025978071615099907,
0.6142120957374573,
0.34697970747947693,
-0.29167410731315613,
0.47068333625793457,
-0.11099347472190857,
-0.45260924100875854,
-0.040186602622270584,
-0.5747760534286499,
0.7330052852630615,
-0.04836253821849823,
-0.29004397988319397,
0.3831966817378998,
-0.8139763474464417,
0.08170870691537857,
-0.061134640127420425,
-0.03997437655925751,
-0.3130054771900177,
0.12447332590818405,
-0.16489167511463165,
0.49925458431243896,
0.11553552746772766,
-0.3053954541683197,
-0.01657501608133316,
-0.2755550444126129,
0.3571011424064636,
1.0288065671920776,
-0.005893697030842304,
0.6054904460906982,
-0.3892054259777069,
0.7265437841415405,
0.14668256044387817,
0.16963253915309906,
-0.1955103725194931,
-0.43518561124801636,
-0.988385021686554,
-0.23330587148666382,
0.36174386739730835,
0.40673500299453735,
-0.8092198371887207,
0.26318079233169556,
-0.14666123688220978,
-0.15530233085155487,
-0.796205997467041,
0.09856267273426056,
0.3565552234649658,
1.0322480201721191,
0.9702440500259399,
-0.17361626029014587,
-0.39359360933303833,
-1.1671059131622314,
-0.26546478271484375,
-0.19459684193134308,
-0.23709897696971893,
0.455869197845459,
0.5101326107978821,
0.05254317447543144,
0.8633733987808228,
-0.523963212966919,
-0.5271440744400024,
-0.18876022100448608,
0.3642844259738922,
0.23382921516895294,
0.37904149293899536,
0.33878618478775024,
-0.659846305847168,
-0.31323835253715515,
-0.39591655135154724,
-0.8863808512687683,
-0.26884186267852783,
-0.10436209291219711,
-0.3431306779384613,
0.04259167239069939,
0.37338176369667053,
-0.4524245262145996,
0.29264360666275024,
-0.12906600534915924,
-0.28422170877456665,
0.8031194806098938,
0.14338579773902893,
0.06581617146730423,
-0.8080489039421082,
-0.1977003812789917,
0.33814600110054016,
-0.07745026051998138,
-0.4587748348712921,
0.008302401751279831,
0.016969667747616768,
0.09576655179262161,
-0.6202432513237,
0.4925193190574646,
-0.09619084745645523,
0.30114251375198364,
-0.4858531057834625,
0.26023435592651367,
0.20668838918209076,
0.7703616619110107,
0.27408406138420105,
0.53817218542099,
0.8298873901367188,
-0.690893292427063,
0.36380815505981445,
0.41998493671417236,
0.17497467994689941,
1.0190436840057373,
-1.0269843339920044,
-0.14588572084903717,
-0.43171918392181396,
0.5196201801300049,
-0.9083276987075806,
-0.266964852809906,
0.07587438821792603,
-0.5291764140129089,
0.04334724321961403,
-0.7631219625473022,
-0.3531990945339203,
-0.26301196217536926,
-0.23502705991268158,
0.4473057687282562,
0.4621604084968567,
-0.9315032958984375,
0.7752878665924072,
0.13948804140090942,
-0.09620396792888641,
-0.5887778997421265,
-0.6015265583992004,
-0.13802790641784668,
-0.6340734958648682,
-0.6952000260353088,
0.13276737928390503,
0.04681340605020523,
-0.1682269126176834,
-0.2251778542995453,
-0.2969916760921478,
-0.18570204079151154,
0.17339053750038147,
0.20628194510936737,
0.45726191997528076,
-0.6391372680664062,
0.3632502555847168,
0.3626707196235657,
-0.3045152425765991,
0.6059020161628723,
-0.24763861298561096,
0.13036878407001495,
-0.4531242549419403,
-0.24026022851467133,
-0.4219247102737427,
0.3057529032230377,
0.4713943302631378,
-0.202362522482872,
0.650583028793335,
0.43091294169425964,
-0.4609181582927704,
-0.5279632210731506,
-0.11964069306850433,
-0.5922902822494507,
-0.4687689542770386,
0.04163239151239395,
-0.27336570620536804,
-0.6360248327255249,
0.4701095521450043,
-0.17483548820018768,
0.15473376214504242,
0.6090701818466187,
0.38165420293807983,
-0.23126406967639923,
1.3632023334503174,
0.19014431536197662,
0.4204045236110687,
0.15637941658496857,
-0.2523348331451416,
0.3167772889137268,
-0.7615164518356323,
-0.31753629446029663,
-0.48355019092559814,
-0.5492382645606995,
-0.3741246461868286,
0.014407850801944733,
0.2866559326648712,
0.28383058309555054,
-0.16429075598716736,
0.20347531139850616,
-0.7604332566261292,
0.7434878945350647,
0.38012340664863586,
0.02137436531484127,
0.1283344179391861,
-0.3727300465106964,
-0.05578691139817238,
-0.024449177086353302,
-0.4480130672454834,
-0.835598886013031,
0.8058922290802002,
0.30377018451690674,
0.5498840808868408,
0.04355490952730179,
0.6462973356246948,
0.11728822439908981,
0.5515471696853638,
-1.2052162885665894,
0.6383346915245056,
0.008217813447117805,
-0.6251094937324524,
-0.32606062293052673,
-0.2337643951177597,
-0.6552674770355225,
0.7374503016471863,
-0.05577902868390083,
-0.4971114695072174,
-0.07315041869878769,
0.29600271582603455,
-0.33921879529953003,
-0.11653584241867065,
-1.1848983764648438,
1.201951265335083,
-0.10829703509807587,
-0.49575966596603394,
0.06522657722234726,
-0.8584678173065186,
0.3654186427593231,
0.08155107498168945,
0.2206651270389557,
-0.1921498030424118,
0.29473814368247986,
0.989526629447937,
-0.7460796236991882,
0.6862999796867371,
-0.483605295419693,
-0.0056337532587349415,
0.4756039083003998,
-0.08353545516729355,
0.2403435856103897,
0.3678947687149048,
-0.2555480897426605,
-0.15162575244903564,
-0.21055136620998383,
-0.3569093644618988,
-0.8019225597381592,
0.7064648270606995,
-0.5896185040473938,
-0.667710542678833,
-0.5247226357460022,
-0.6459166407585144,
-0.4546838104724884,
0.08134634792804718,
0.14340174198150635,
0.35907259583473206,
0.40501612424850464,
-0.17813698947429657,
0.5678101181983948,
0.052051760256290436,
0.44138699769973755,
0.365806519985199,
0.17754587531089783,
-0.1822972148656845,
0.9403208494186401,
-0.10254130512475967,
0.018924906849861145,
-0.04328857734799385,
0.429033100605011,
-0.6717697978019714,
-0.39169108867645264,
-0.5341379642486572,
0.21585127711296082,
-1.1834393739700317,
-0.39625298976898193,
-0.5040821433067322,
-0.03373360633850098,
-0.17349568009376526,
-0.33995646238327026,
-0.04066704213619232,
-0.8183046579360962,
-0.3401224911212921,
-0.29375380277633667,
0.375357061624527,
0.43358278274536133,
0.16012558341026306,
0.559704065322876,
-0.5233300924301147,
0.43716615438461304,
0.2095445990562439,
0.3028135895729065,
0.1300126612186432,
-0.8197060227394104,
-0.1300823837518692,
0.11362423747777939,
-0.5306433439254761,
-0.6382673978805542,
0.12088756263256073,
0.2939491868019104,
0.30584844946861267,
0.26938188076019287,
0.1363285332918167,
0.8289266228675842,
-0.49930036067962646,
0.9354490041732788,
0.048896268010139465,
-1.1306906938552856,
1.038458228111267,
-0.08134045451879501,
0.16821523010730743,
0.7130532264709473,
0.5920751094818115,
-0.20555713772773743,
-0.44153711199760437,
-0.5922060012817383,
-1.1530144214630127,
1.0124682188034058,
-0.1615140587091446,
-0.019722310826182365,
-0.24983742833137512,
0.09986931830644608,
0.29275959730148315,
-0.0008706941734999418,
-0.8506226539611816,
-0.4707868695259094,
-0.4431811273097992,
-0.23249788582324982,
0.08505889773368835,
0.20297418534755707,
-0.2850860357284546,
-0.4211566746234894,
0.8803169131278992,
-0.6182994246482849,
-0.10678006708621979,
-0.020603463053703308,
-0.40420207381248474,
0.2946542501449585,
0.5950449705123901,
0.44025036692619324,
0.5522148013114929,
0.019082218408584595,
0.3877641558647156,
0.3105888068675995,
-0.19274558126926422,
0.21127109229564667,
0.1249585673213005,
-0.16236595809459686,
0.13422173261642456,
0.32617995142936707,
0.6072428226470947,
-0.28360873460769653,
-0.4040375351905823,
0.7316840291023254,
-0.2449101358652115,
-0.31389838457107544,
-0.3326025605201721,
-0.14955654740333557,
-0.24962593615055084,
-0.07887930423021317,
0.3247569799423218,
0.38372308015823364,
0.26740172505378723,
0.021452615037560463,
0.19791346788406372,
0.152487650513649,
-0.3638814687728882,
-0.30000680685043335,
0.7280921936035156,
0.11524637043476105,
-0.01478826068341732,
0.6927007436752319,
-0.07453230768442154,
-0.4983457326889038,
0.7533555030822754,
0.5311503410339355,
0.7713732719421387,
0.14235259592533112,
0.4218693971633911,
0.5642886161804199,
0.09376900643110275,
-0.1812889575958252,
0.1438664197921753,
-0.45076245069503784,
-0.41175377368927,
-0.47853535413742065,
-0.5438460111618042,
-0.4645829200744629,
-0.030993327498435974,
-0.8898884057998657,
0.4966048002243042,
-0.5163490176200867,
-0.1946021467447281,
0.3596794605255127,
-0.3665177524089813,
-0.34635457396507263,
0.5938687324523926,
0.03515344858169556,
0.5789233446121216,
-1.1975370645523071,
0.6562116146087646,
0.8927134275436401,
-0.7710368037223816,
-0.9129540324211121,
-0.1185443252325058,
-0.03324931859970093,
-0.595238983631134,
0.7113547325134277,
0.41215258836746216,
-0.2040129154920578,
-0.29482603073120117,
-0.40181782841682434,
-0.2687637507915497,
0.8249800205230713,
0.27251654863357544,
0.2172827422618866,
-0.1430089920759201,
0.021760616451501846,
0.8826015591621399,
0.02452513575553894,
0.7514175772666931,
0.4459220767021179,
0.514395534992218,
0.09112437814474106,
-0.4690707325935364,
0.15618044137954712,
-0.4275805950164795,
-0.3379775881767273,
0.3582227826118469,
-0.32116538286209106,
0.3769770860671997,
-0.17248490452766418,
-0.033670175820589066,
-0.3137626349925995,
0.8393537998199463,
0.375042200088501,
0.5198138952255249,
0.48510241508483887,
0.7062682509422302,
0.5889713764190674,
-0.4732512831687927,
0.9356208443641663,
-0.02527434006333351,
0.10339034348726273,
1.1585100889205933,
0.04021740332245827,
0.5350852012634277,
0.7702634334564209,
0.16256996989250183,
0.6931430697441101,
0.6156323552131653,
-0.09539844840765,
0.3382800817489624,
0.4659877121448517,
-0.24695254862308502,
-0.48924893140792847,
-0.467831552028656,
-0.0699702650308609,
0.33321282267570496,
0.2633485496044159,
-0.36963918805122375,
-0.3845503628253937,
0.0801171362400055,
-0.2223748117685318,
0.2002168893814087,
-0.5274723172187805,
0.6459324955940247,
0.23696614801883698,
-1.0975335836410522,
0.6565158367156982,
0.11900514364242554,
0.7477178573608398,
-0.4649655222892761,
-0.10581385344266891,
-0.2969081997871399,
0.3123821020126343,
-0.712609589099884,
-0.8857795596122742,
0.46717092394828796,
0.10337550938129425,
-0.20998527109622955,
-0.5480883121490479,
0.3792150318622589,
-0.3415873944759369,
-0.20769767463207245,
0.030097052454948425,
0.34043923020362854,
0.06409167498350143,
0.2094070315361023,
-0.5651832222938538,
-0.4945357143878937,
-0.427680641412735,
-0.032717879861593246,
0.15160739421844482,
0.6322551369667053,
-0.34381765127182007,
0.6146535277366638,
0.38538333773612976,
-0.25329646468162537,
0.030383041128516197,
0.4627399444580078,
0.4794352352619171,
-0.3235659599304199,
-0.5584483742713928,
-0.8189809322357178,
0.6748374104499817,
0.021492788568139076,
-0.4220384657382965,
1.029072642326355,
0.42992541193962097,
0.8588927388191223,
-0.052873384207487106,
0.5699014663696289,
0.04861941188573837,
0.3328441083431244,
-0.3201053738594055,
0.5405813455581665,
-0.6002033948898315,
0.35416674613952637,
-0.23550739884376526,
-0.5821206569671631,
-0.4605032503604889,
0.8029588460922241,
-0.3868643641471863,
0.1004323959350586,
1.0824447870254517,
0.4585146903991699,
-0.09347891062498093,
0.3827013075351715,
-0.20903806388378143,
-0.26960688829421997,
0.39412280917167664,
0.6827273964881897,
0.9988961219787598,
-0.6131529808044434,
0.5396733283996582,
-0.34732145071029663,
-0.014536320231854916,
0.23857320845127106,
-0.7678784132003784,
-1.0919415950775146,
-0.4034307599067688,
-0.8212997317314148,
-0.6151907444000244,
-0.28922173380851746,
0.8675975203514099,
0.5417975187301636,
-0.9573348760604858,
-0.0037077646702528,
-0.15824247896671295,
0.3818083703517914,
-0.38933178782463074,
-0.3329949378967285,
0.6246252655982971,
-0.41801297664642334,
-0.5272111892700195,
0.36602509021759033,
-0.0070165786892175674,
0.11491736769676208,
0.21943438053131104,
-0.1274554282426834,
-0.08334411680698395,
0.07400605827569962,
0.6224294900894165,
0.2093781977891922,
-0.758252739906311,
-0.3359094262123108,
-0.11617923527956009,
0.002613314427435398,
0.29991060495376587,
0.6205285787582397,
-0.8331217169761658,
0.007100667804479599,
0.42280858755111694,
0.6215946078300476,
0.2900286912918091,
0.315613329410553,
0.39016878604888916,
-1.0495378971099854,
-0.12302090227603912,
0.6707708239555359,
0.4396721422672272,
0.30782315135002136,
-0.21176405251026154,
0.3133184611797333,
0.17882348597049713,
-0.5175482034683228,
-0.8621294498443604,
0.17572741210460663,
-0.9749034643173218,
-0.2541337013244629,
0.9377256631851196,
-0.22282859683036804,
-0.11456437408924103,
-0.17738457024097443,
-0.2051394134759903,
0.15125682950019836,
-0.22217874228954315,
0.871333658695221,
0.9210729598999023,
-0.35205039381980896,
-0.19414444267749786,
-0.16846968233585358,
0.5338396430015564,
0.9210982322692871,
-1.1725330352783203,
0.0045708962716162205,
0.768671989440918,
-0.014353292062878609,
0.30632710456848145,
0.31276869773864746,
-0.3073466718196869,
0.6583817601203918,
-0.3814188539981842,
-0.1657434105873108,
-0.18439923226833344,
-0.6380833387374878,
-0.7243499159812927,
0.3997516930103302,
-0.059538304805755615,
-0.1759280115365982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01777v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01777v2
|
NPHardEval4V: A Dynamic Reasoning Benchmark of Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-03-04T07:10:31 | 2024-03-05T18:26:04 |
Lizhou Fan, Wenyue Hua, Xiang Li, Kaijie Zhu, Mingyu Jin, Lingyao Li, Haoyang Ling, Jinkui Chi, Jindong Wang, Xin Ma, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Understanding the reasoning capabilities of Multimodal Large Language Models
(MLLMs) is an important area of research. In this study, we introduce a dynamic
benchmark, NPHardEval4V, aimed at addressing the existing gaps in evaluating
the pure reasoning abilities of MLLMs. Our benchmark aims to provide a venue to
disentangle the effect of various factors such as image recognition and
instruction following, from the overall performance of the models, allowing us
to focus solely on evaluating their reasoning abilities. It is built by
converting textual description of questions from NPHardEval to image
representations. Our findings reveal significant discrepancies in reasoning
abilities across different models and highlight the relatively weak performance
of MLLMs compared to LLMs in terms of reasoning. We also investigate the impact
of different prompting styles, including visual, text, and combined visual and
text prompts, on the reasoning abilities of MLLMs, demonstrating the different
impacts of multimodal inputs in model performance. Unlike traditional
benchmarks, which focus primarily on static evaluations, our benchmark will be
updated monthly to prevent overfitting and ensure a more authentic and
fine-grained evaluation of the models. We believe that this benchmark can aid
in understanding and guide the further development of reasoning abilities in
MLLMs. The benchmark dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/lizhouf/NPHardEval4V
|
[
-0.23853842914104462,
-0.7399441003799438,
0.5882449746131897,
0.410037100315094,
-0.14664027094841003,
0.21623390913009644,
-0.4043939411640167,
-0.2808561623096466,
-0.5413419604301453,
0.18745017051696777,
-0.405678927898407,
-0.4707199037075043,
-0.3376070261001587,
0.2807314097881317,
-0.1994125247001648,
0.37373775243759155,
-0.2836697995662689,
0.09043055772781372,
-0.6539958119392395,
-0.24644581973552704,
-0.6159672737121582,
-0.3277471959590912,
-0.1596488654613495,
-0.21320413053035736,
0.5691604614257812,
0.033604394644498825,
0.534590482711792,
0.48120740056037903,
0.4675428569316864,
0.426762193441391,
-0.17722654342651367,
0.26165422797203064,
-0.28280097246170044,
0.7458139061927795,
-0.17946882545948029,
-0.3225921392440796,
-0.2556990087032318,
-0.060834240168333054,
0.96709805727005,
0.20018860697746277,
-0.037952277809381485,
0.27787962555885315,
-0.16211359202861786,
0.5713434219360352,
-0.781316876411438,
0.32241350412368774,
-0.7052727937698364,
0.05158216506242752,
-0.30104860663414,
-0.2578808069229126,
-0.4683409333229065,
-0.3906921148300171,
0.08683250099420547,
-0.4659683108329773,
-0.02952956221997738,
0.0048268381506204605,
0.7080141305923462,
0.4251549541950226,
-0.47712093591690063,
-0.16476665437221527,
-0.3805386424064636,
1.0029383897781372,
-0.6547545194625854,
0.6122115254402161,
0.26452669501304626,
0.6356149315834045,
0.10085636377334595,
-0.6924912929534912,
-0.5670825839042664,
-0.49137377738952637,
0.1904696375131607,
-0.18110071122646332,
-0.26203855872154236,
-0.3014836311340332,
0.6316270232200623,
0.03277444466948509,
-0.5882061123847961,
-0.06309333443641663,
-0.11936026811599731,
-0.3521350622177124,
0.42132821679115295,
0.24697919189929962,
-0.07846276462078094,
-0.27215972542762756,
-0.3203682005405426,
-0.23486994206905365,
-0.6091558933258057,
0.205960214138031,
0.3315889537334442,
0.006622412707656622,
-0.26291799545288086,
0.39232078194618225,
-0.19435147941112518,
0.8805183172225952,
-0.1218714714050293,
-0.3661734163761139,
0.6640451550483704,
-0.46083369851112366,
-0.07641047239303589,
-0.10976321995258331,
0.6202338933944702,
0.4853898882865906,
0.3444761335849762,
0.17468306422233582,
-0.18525245785713196,
0.04290388897061348,
0.08912570029497147,
-0.9020313620567322,
-0.3269330859184265,
0.04658950865268707,
-0.5905730128288269,
-0.1920323520898819,
-0.422454833984375,
-0.8651046752929688,
-0.592435896396637,
-0.41746702790260315,
0.16894777119159698,
-0.4851378798484802,
-0.5441811084747314,
-0.15709182620048523,
-0.1079929918050766,
0.28791624307632446,
0.7991660833358765,
-0.5427004098892212,
-0.06893273442983627,
0.5270980596542358,
0.7525829672813416,
-0.2630945146083832,
-0.31163105368614197,
-0.7128589153289795,
-0.10950808972120285,
-0.2968769967556,
0.9067894816398621,
-0.6925379037857056,
-0.037983257323503494,
0.08406282961368561,
-0.10875137895345688,
-0.09659572690725327,
-0.5971038341522217,
0.44213512539863586,
-0.5340977311134338,
-0.1551029086112976,
-0.34475526213645935,
-0.29793477058410645,
-0.3264278173446655,
0.8017788529396057,
-0.6757298111915588,
1.0391467809677124,
-0.027251875028014183,
-0.6161026954650879,
0.3425707221031189,
-0.2621871531009674,
-0.24234607815742493,
0.4465768337249756,
-0.5904310941696167,
-0.2872540056705475,
-0.13524414598941803,
0.11888222396373749,
0.45774173736572266,
-0.4753264784812927,
0.49417468905448914,
-0.5464704632759094,
-0.26955267786979675,
0.5014632344245911,
-0.8775426149368286,
0.5451796054840088,
-0.05041782930493355,
-0.5162309408187866,
0.38019201159477234,
-0.7928932905197144,
0.277328222990036,
0.1485658586025238,
-0.5060898065567017,
0.025010354816913605,
0.10925524681806564,
-0.09932233393192291,
0.4291684031486511,
0.30454006791114807,
-0.26683831214904785,
0.23128098249435425,
0.05421881750226021,
0.4213482141494751,
0.8999474048614502,
-0.2612047493457794,
0.10897424817085266,
0.0010878635803237557,
0.6051404476165771,
-0.15965205430984497,
0.14478398859500885,
-0.3543547987937927,
-0.5983084440231323,
-0.48263466358184814,
-0.44999757409095764,
0.37131187319755554,
0.4902424216270447,
-1.1536911725997925,
-0.2547392249107361,
-0.09266967326402664,
-0.3841167688369751,
-0.43855777382850647,
0.35776862502098083,
0.6022021174430847,
0.5253873467445374,
0.43112167716026306,
0.16651424765586853,
-0.40055084228515625,
-0.94158536195755,
-0.20389388501644135,
-0.15515471994876862,
0.126877099275589,
0.34503883123397827,
0.5779820680618286,
0.04612761735916138,
0.44958850741386414,
-0.06535723060369492,
0.1081419289112091,
-0.37451469898223877,
0.17065386474132538,
0.1859203726053238,
0.23956605792045593,
0.5074206590652466,
-0.9823971390724182,
-0.5174837708473206,
-0.029627762734889984,
-1.0033646821975708,
-0.1226007267832756,
-0.13247208297252655,
-0.054600175470113754,
0.24516701698303223,
0.5539576411247253,
-0.6209301352500916,
0.5299549102783203,
0.6192433834075928,
-0.39535167813301086,
0.9329728484153748,
-0.32850298285484314,
0.42743876576423645,
-0.34304437041282654,
0.03525102883577347,
0.09432309120893478,
-0.10928383469581604,
-0.5043641328811646,
0.039164233952760696,
0.4634917974472046,
0.11267546564340591,
-0.66920006275177,
0.7170988917350769,
-0.7467630505561829,
-0.09548875689506531,
-0.04325035959482193,
0.08078593760728836,
0.180507093667984,
0.3942277431488037,
0.0298734400421381,
0.7466573715209961,
0.7684323191642761,
-0.38011378049850464,
0.6850652694702148,
0.09507808834314346,
-0.6531980633735657,
0.7962248921394348,
-0.7681422829627991,
-0.14315566420555115,
-0.0014334433944895864,
0.30143263936042786,
-0.7229546904563904,
-0.012663517147302628,
0.031433481723070145,
-0.32877570390701294,
0.36321085691452026,
-0.316141813993454,
-0.7860597968101501,
-0.31800368428230286,
-0.2964029610157013,
0.5413519144058228,
0.3712623715400696,
-0.4272558391094208,
0.8178527355194092,
0.027964293956756592,
0.014878934249281883,
-0.4547399878501892,
-0.4190804362297058,
0.14622029662132263,
-0.13527725636959076,
-0.7777330875396729,
0.31170687079429626,
-0.3557108938694,
-0.46195149421691895,
-0.05804183706641197,
0.023813685402274132,
0.00835646316409111,
-0.0684695690870285,
0.2564593553543091,
0.4406597316265106,
-0.41904085874557495,
0.1597093939781189,
-0.1166219711303711,
-0.07170317322015762,
0.08618267625570297,
0.1637209951877594,
0.512958824634552,
-0.5503111481666565,
-0.4876742660999298,
-0.45623961091041565,
0.08999940752983093,
0.7056814432144165,
-0.5881235599517822,
0.7163453102111816,
0.6063910126686096,
-0.1469791680574417,
-0.003646297613158822,
-0.7809829711914062,
0.04827379435300827,
-0.5122569799423218,
0.25626862049102783,
-0.5976389050483704,
-0.6951608657836914,
0.26528459787368774,
0.019726717844605446,
-0.025609850883483887,
0.3357715904712677,
0.9474642276763916,
-0.057987768203020096,
1.3060921430587769,
-0.0689217820763588,
0.6019397377967834,
0.16329951584339142,
-0.12872877717018127,
-0.10044017434120178,
-0.9609531760215759,
-0.67706298828125,
-0.2744388282299042,
-0.26897597312927246,
-0.47608333826065063,
-0.9023353457450867,
0.22269383072853088,
0.02067306637763977,
-0.3338054120540619,
-0.040461570024490356,
-0.38475364446640015,
0.38635313510894775,
0.3880399465560913,
-0.19787156581878662,
0.1125689223408699,
-0.2818841338157654,
-0.38252168893814087,
-0.16377073526382446,
-0.5557733178138733,
-0.47571390867233276,
0.8415587544441223,
0.28272268176078796,
0.565568208694458,
0.40191328525543213,
0.13150784373283386,
0.30585283041000366,
0.22830349206924438,
-0.4218732416629791,
0.8059213161468506,
0.10689673572778702,
-0.5751399993896484,
0.03852441534399986,
-0.6368041634559631,
-0.7766114473342896,
0.7383273243904114,
-0.5222752690315247,
-0.4412699341773987,
0.16278383135795593,
0.2934491038322449,
-0.18898911774158478,
0.31442803144454956,
-0.6327245831489563,
1.0914123058319092,
-0.6911898255348206,
-0.7452048063278198,
-0.1664777249097824,
-0.4969339072704315,
0.36117348074913025,
0.09770593047142029,
0.18846763670444489,
-0.5759984254837036,
0.07010641694068909,
0.4594007432460785,
-0.01930946297943592,
0.5462438464164734,
-0.30070632696151733,
0.11508648842573166,
0.06269767135381699,
0.16282981634140015,
0.3253374695777893,
0.05300399288535118,
-0.3558647632598877,
0.35011255741119385,
0.1250901222229004,
-0.2950405478477478,
-0.6007819175720215,
0.9666295647621155,
-0.5029053092002869,
-0.46589869260787964,
-0.6174404621124268,
-0.6152058243751526,
-0.30578941106796265,
0.27049529552459717,
-0.26918721199035645,
0.8467110991477966,
0.10401185601949692,
0.6269635558128357,
0.8073214888572693,
-0.49452337622642517,
0.37226754426956177,
0.5760549902915955,
-0.20330515503883362,
-0.243787482380867,
0.8579190969467163,
-0.014907082542777061,
0.17117562890052795,
0.2740158438682556,
0.25723594427108765,
-0.5973702669143677,
-0.764619767665863,
-0.7435628175735474,
0.22890250384807587,
-1.0421948432922363,
-0.18312272429466248,
-0.5956945419311523,
0.11006482690572739,
-0.3692183196544647,
0.05322878062725067,
-0.2913982570171356,
-0.07508262246847153,
-0.2671668827533722,
0.27069488167762756,
0.2000477910041809,
0.4714740514755249,
0.2157924771308899,
-0.34467190504074097,
-0.6315951943397522,
0.36692574620246887,
0.31326955556869507,
0.36076876521110535,
0.2409430593252182,
-0.5044550895690918,
0.1387091428041458,
-0.19963853061199188,
-0.2460792511701584,
-0.8003307580947876,
0.2392503023147583,
0.04738229885697365,
1.0164604187011719,
0.38516417145729065,
-0.0761217251420021,
0.6053034067153931,
-0.8012729287147522,
0.6671485900878906,
0.2731606364250183,
-0.8131862282752991,
0.4733283221721649,
-0.4127061665058136,
0.8280331492424011,
0.64274001121521,
0.2651095986366272,
-0.18684132397174835,
-0.07776133716106415,
-0.35033053159713745,
-0.6339191198348999,
0.41306567192077637,
0.33838388323783875,
-0.04945792630314827,
-0.007963369600474834,
-0.06185689941048622,
-0.0419808030128479,
0.41036659479141235,
-0.5268926024436951,
-0.019110102206468582,
-0.3995855450630188,
-0.01787254586815834,
0.20071415603160858,
-0.3322177231311798,
0.07573249936103821,
-0.547244131565094,
0.4801064431667328,
-0.1807536482810974,
0.02776290662586689,
-0.3054670989513397,
-0.28812116384506226,
0.2508627772331238,
0.10815143585205078,
0.9393548369407654,
0.9699860215187073,
-0.23262472450733185,
0.3846515119075775,
0.22743616998195648,
-0.11942169070243835,
-0.09162810444831848,
0.2117711305618286,
0.22822222113609314,
-0.054992079734802246,
0.6647701859474182,
0.9934291839599609,
0.4365059733390808,
-1.0727423429489136,
0.6856787204742432,
-0.40132302045822144,
-0.31268009543418884,
-0.24477356672286987,
-0.05998264625668526,
0.15289132297039032,
0.5350260734558105,
0.2787988781929016,
0.18178421258926392,
-0.17891736328601837,
-0.46838822960853577,
0.03813795745372772,
0.4272819757461548,
-0.0857769325375557,
-0.3020188510417938,
0.5437647104263306,
0.22008180618286133,
-0.3193776607513428,
0.7857804298400879,
-0.33592042326927185,
-0.5659852623939514,
0.4443514347076416,
0.21852603554725647,
0.3061937689781189,
-0.25507766008377075,
0.2832547426223755,
0.3878786265850067,
0.3072849214076996,
0.015630146488547325,
0.22031176090240479,
-0.2481473982334137,
-0.5506741404533386,
-0.6331785917282104,
-0.5926954746246338,
-0.3365696370601654,
0.017137935385107994,
-0.5198424458503723,
0.23493891954421997,
-0.45346570014953613,
-0.11465770751237869,
0.20846737921237946,
-0.3642481565475464,
-0.8087392449378967,
0.038594335317611694,
0.3475131690502167,
0.8604758977890015,
-0.5371540188789368,
0.7633042931556702,
0.4901736378669739,
-0.26942873001098633,
-0.5134372115135193,
-0.18909387290477753,
0.3879469335079193,
-0.807268500328064,
1.0180985927581787,
0.42478078603744507,
-0.2072904258966446,
-0.41675078868865967,
-0.387054979801178,
-0.8148762583732605,
0.9569951891899109,
0.41379472613334656,
-0.4171138107776642,
0.12647360563278198,
-0.17810986936092377,
0.5416014194488525,
-0.3060859143733978,
0.4663026034832001,
0.36705297231674194,
0.7476412057876587,
0.45784860849380493,
-0.8543683886528015,
0.00849075149744749,
-0.6711741089820862,
0.0009989755926653743,
0.20227329432964325,
-0.21782124042510986,
0.9877393245697021,
-0.07911814749240875,
0.02167675830423832,
-0.005546123255044222,
0.49798306822776794,
0.6229338049888611,
0.2717372477054596,
0.5309861302375793,
0.30176109075546265,
0.6523853540420532,
-0.27858927845954895,
1.1655975580215454,
-0.07663343101739883,
0.03470732644200325,
1.067918300628662,
-0.635221540927887,
0.9836152791976929,
0.3664315938949585,
-0.05663418397307396,
0.850830078125,
0.38413679599761963,
-0.19214726984500885,
0.49157285690307617,
0.2856297492980957,
-0.243820920586586,
-0.5104853510856628,
0.014284766279160976,
-0.4522453546524048,
0.43234726786613464,
0.36424195766448975,
-0.26143696904182434,
-0.2732393741607666,
0.123292937874794,
-0.20810343325138092,
0.1080755889415741,
-0.20547032356262207,
0.46518221497535706,
-0.21511656045913696,
-0.7274628281593323,
0.9174902439117432,
-0.059056200087070465,
0.5988609790802002,
-0.6249016523361206,
-0.3418809175491333,
0.15497951209545135,
0.31594711542129517,
-0.009114985354244709,
-1.0238078832626343,
0.04466073960065842,
0.1079770177602768,
-0.16800512373447418,
-0.5789980292320251,
0.7242339253425598,
-0.3209267854690552,
-0.5321578979492188,
0.1748584657907486,
0.28114473819732666,
0.16823025047779083,
-0.04384714737534523,
-1.1699777841567993,
0.6475481986999512,
-0.045620404183864594,
-0.1880526840686798,
0.38338714838027954,
0.4594918191432953,
-0.26873064041137695,
0.8761561512947083,
0.8187208771705627,
-0.006104199681431055,
0.10135303437709808,
0.3562600612640381,
0.809181272983551,
-0.4104517102241516,
-0.20637010037899017,
-0.9165331721305847,
0.5633673667907715,
-0.39989742636680603,
-0.44224387407302856,
1.0727007389068604,
0.4036765396595001,
0.46177104115486145,
0.07630713284015656,
0.4410555958747864,
0.06103363260626793,
0.4001007378101349,
-0.4771019220352173,
0.5840157270431519,
-0.6118195652961731,
0.1796869933605194,
-0.23323668539524078,
-0.7046796679496765,
-0.2879454493522644,
0.8631030321121216,
-0.5683310627937317,
0.16961722075939178,
0.7097945809364319,
0.6854168176651001,
0.05549323558807373,
0.04816116392612457,
0.44502970576286316,
0.2775663435459137,
0.46831855177879333,
0.2738856375217438,
1.2120791673660278,
0.16315889358520508,
0.4919610619544983,
-0.11697416007518768,
-0.22548127174377441,
-0.1652110368013382,
-1.3148537874221802,
-1.0493617057800293,
-0.5024256110191345,
-0.42203962802886963,
-0.34076419472694397,
0.09540106356143951,
0.6844310760498047,
0.6022810935974121,
-0.5369872450828552,
0.009029345586895943,
0.22213691473007202,
0.11538200080394745,
-0.24191196262836456,
-0.21494093537330627,
0.27334386110305786,
0.09895702451467514,
-0.31749892234802246,
0.5608599185943604,
0.5138764381408691,
-0.251140832901001,
-0.641180694103241,
-0.2032751441001892,
-0.5519825220108032,
-0.0017655192641541362,
0.8259576559066772,
0.12454076111316681,
-0.966738760471344,
-0.01042097620666027,
-0.003885491518303752,
0.16606730222702026,
0.042359478771686554,
0.7416213750839233,
-0.8539621829986572,
0.6992166042327881,
0.5927919149398804,
0.5702225565910339,
0.6198469400405884,
-0.18422363698482513,
0.27093300223350525,
-0.5128130912780762,
0.14730243384838104,
0.4675413966178894,
0.3845900893211365,
0.6629314422607422,
0.11191393435001373,
0.10914435237646103,
0.16104958951473236,
-0.48376137018203735,
-1.0962516069412231,
0.15955238044261932,
-0.8252184987068176,
-0.32580482959747314,
1.3782503604888916,
-0.18000955879688263,
-0.21880792081356049,
-0.22094254195690155,
-0.10768533498048782,
-0.2134290188550949,
-0.3885401785373688,
0.22491972148418427,
0.7216566801071167,
-0.22837422788143158,
-0.6093994975090027,
-0.8874985575675964,
0.3408720791339874,
0.2976016700267792,
-0.9048823714256287,
0.03418533131480217,
0.7584851384162903,
0.20654414594173431,
0.02748698927462101,
0.49554184079170227,
-0.09541021287441254,
0.5048497319221497,
-0.09168753772974014,
-0.11359551548957825,
-0.28831779956817627,
-0.37976568937301636,
-0.26316800713539124,
0.3373236656188965,
-0.04470120370388031,
0.2166500687599182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01774v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01774v2
|
WebCiteS: Attributed Query-Focused Summarization on Chinese Web Search Results with Citations
| 2024-03-04T07:06:41 | 2024-05-29T02:45:11 |
Haolin Deng, Chang Wang, Xin Li, Dezhang Yuan, Junlang Zhan, Tianhua Zhou, Jin Ma, Jun Gao, Ruifeng Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Enhancing the attribution in large language models (LLMs) is a crucial task.
One feasible approach is to enable LLMs to cite external sources that support
their generations. However, existing datasets and evaluation methods in this
domain still exhibit notable limitations. In this work, we formulate the task
of attributed query-focused summarization (AQFS) and present WebCiteS, a
Chinese dataset featuring 7k human-annotated summaries with citations. WebCiteS
derives from real-world user queries and web search results, offering a
valuable resource for model training and evaluation. Prior works in attribution
evaluation do not differentiate between groundedness errors and citation
errors. They also fall short in automatically verifying sentences that draw
partial support from multiple sources. We tackle these issues by developing
detailed metrics and enabling the automatic evaluator to decompose the
sentences into sub-claims for fine-grained verification. Our comprehensive
evaluation of both open-source and proprietary models on WebCiteS highlights
the challenge LLMs face in correctly citing sources, underscoring the necessity
for further improvement. The dataset and code will be open-sourced to
facilitate further research in this crucial field.
|
[
0.08950864523649216,
-0.05357342213392258,
0.37219712138175964,
0.6804629564285278,
-0.28349706530570984,
-0.1152024045586586,
-0.25785359740257263,
-0.20350441336631775,
0.05289575085043907,
0.35811153054237366,
-0.4557111859321594,
-0.3318922221660614,
-0.2650780975818634,
0.36249059438705444,
-0.574386477470398,
0.7188768982887268,
0.18126079440116882,
0.2180115282535553,
-0.6138753890991211,
0.01951717771589756,
0.11565595120191574,
-0.47690513730049133,
-0.39161917567253113,
-0.34424537420272827,
0.6164186000823975,
0.21571694314479828,
0.4328301250934601,
0.4476296901702881,
0.5244723558425903,
0.1196964681148529,
-0.024022499099373817,
0.3439416289329529,
-0.5148535370826721,
0.18083210289478302,
-0.30620479583740234,
-0.37842243909835815,
-0.233893483877182,
0.007503739092499018,
0.7570201754570007,
0.7240862846374512,
-0.17976944148540497,
0.2691144645214081,
0.23803983628749847,
0.521112322807312,
-0.9372683167457581,
0.1311749666929245,
-0.7461828589439392,
-0.2032848298549652,
-0.036322783678770065,
-0.32122042775154114,
-0.5600634217262268,
-0.8177804350852966,
-0.037397611886262894,
-0.7025101780891418,
0.20778824388980865,
-0.03701884299516678,
0.6867355704307556,
0.3352207839488983,
-0.6429277658462524,
-0.23574338853359222,
-0.2436612844467163,
0.8770041465759277,
-0.884280800819397,
0.12645332515239716,
0.39534085988998413,
0.18565970659255981,
-0.1300361156463623,
-0.9010030627250671,
-0.16216710209846497,
-0.09859341382980347,
-0.4277042746543884,
0.05588500574231148,
-0.05957603082060814,
-0.19405345618724823,
-0.0006294853519648314,
0.3482579290866852,
-0.618303120136261,
0.1364872008562088,
-0.22063258290290833,
-0.3470190763473511,
0.7701895236968994,
0.28788840770721436,
0.05338889732956886,
-0.38977929949760437,
-0.3259821832180023,
0.12001749128103256,
-1.0477665662765503,
-0.06015205383300781,
0.18270638585090637,
0.6495041251182556,
-0.01826612465083599,
0.5675676465034485,
-0.46120181679725647,
0.48804059624671936,
-0.11359135806560516,
0.16548483073711395,
0.08547873049974442,
-0.45601993799209595,
0.14319586753845215,
0.046688832342624664,
0.9313431978225708,
0.5164594650268555,
0.33284878730773926,
-0.35171836614608765,
-0.08859137445688248,
-0.43563345074653625,
0.05391446128487587,
-1.0584951639175415,
-0.20135731995105743,
0.3654736876487732,
-0.6468234062194824,
-0.22438162565231323,
0.3283863067626953,
-0.3142637610435486,
-0.7465352416038513,
0.0628201812505722,
-0.056283872574567795,
0.06440068781375885,
-0.14170730113983154,
-0.1877489984035492,
-0.5578930377960205,
0.2007245123386383,
0.4198884963989258,
-0.6241697072982788,
0.12348010390996933,
0.48414599895477295,
0.956778883934021,
-0.34162354469299316,
-0.2807035446166992,
-0.5015980005264282,
0.4170630872249603,
-0.08288735896348953,
0.9865240454673767,
-0.31567028164863586,
-0.41429609060287476,
0.3620215356349945,
0.004166845232248306,
0.02353908307850361,
-0.6937751770019531,
0.8601731657981873,
-0.47897082567214966,
0.12037182599306107,
-0.6766468286514282,
-0.4703684151172638,
-0.03293781727552414,
0.3143361210823059,
-0.6339928507804871,
0.835751473903656,
-0.09200089424848557,
-0.8832524418830872,
-0.04078931361436844,
-0.6594157814979553,
-0.625501275062561,
0.15984657406806946,
-0.027445530518889427,
-0.13616475462913513,
0.15077102184295654,
0.38906627893447876,
0.3581683933734894,
-0.6952944397926331,
0.24422617256641388,
-0.3037400543689728,
-0.43273335695266724,
0.2126745581626892,
-0.1493259072303772,
1.3743563890457153,
0.18219086527824402,
-0.018603242933750153,
0.29729267954826355,
-0.9173756837844849,
0.05562320724129677,
0.23958048224449158,
-0.3396979868412018,
-0.6643944978713989,
0.3901301622390747,
0.10640580207109451,
0.05056997016072273,
0.27413323521614075,
-0.5550995469093323,
0.2406555414199829,
-0.21935246884822845,
0.5147992968559265,
0.41695234179496765,
0.012848726473748684,
0.19125302135944366,
-0.16661909222602844,
0.4523971676826477,
-0.29801344871520996,
-0.006554546300321817,
-0.456924170255661,
-0.1609223186969757,
-0.430026650428772,
-0.13451363146305084,
0.2540474534034729,
0.5307117700576782,
-0.7283362150192261,
0.2010023295879364,
-0.6081568598747253,
-0.4825892746448517,
-0.2147931009531021,
0.07461854815483093,
0.24539442360401154,
0.4690253734588623,
0.42731863260269165,
-0.09149809926748276,
-0.6753121018409729,
-0.7599291801452637,
-0.5107865929603577,
-0.2456037849187851,
-0.5667586922645569,
0.32120203971862793,
0.4358641505241394,
0.22455516457557678,
1.0345875024795532,
-0.7611514329910278,
-0.5010397434234619,
-0.17075641453266144,
0.25191283226013184,
-0.06065545976161957,
0.3940962255001068,
0.5090839266777039,
-0.8168034553527832,
-0.6080253720283508,
-0.33993834257125854,
-0.8183075785636902,
-0.3418886065483093,
0.07752754539251328,
-0.009214126504957676,
-0.33154773712158203,
0.3979814946651459,
-0.5840409994125366,
0.17406563460826874,
0.21813912689685822,
-0.3180301785469055,
0.7123225927352905,
0.2574111819267273,
0.16696174442768097,
-0.7433298230171204,
0.25018438696861267,
0.11996167153120041,
-0.15152084827423096,
-0.17841345071792603,
0.4428299367427826,
0.3933067321777344,
0.13252027332782745,
-0.49088963866233826,
0.5685338377952576,
-0.5767291784286499,
-0.06548337638378143,
-0.4086642563343048,
0.2656227946281433,
0.1368633657693863,
0.3164587616920471,
-0.17386333644390106,
0.7800214290618896,
0.2560441792011261,
-0.6223846077919006,
0.8481322526931763,
0.42142316699028015,
-0.2613525092601776,
0.3430904746055603,
-0.7628050446510315,
-0.108139768242836,
0.12578259408473969,
0.6722733974456787,
-0.9345403909683228,
-0.3246023654937744,
-0.10333508998155594,
-0.5767617225646973,
-0.2610774636268616,
-0.07514920085668564,
-0.568489670753479,
-0.2123032510280609,
-0.8464478850364685,
0.3105120360851288,
-0.012854824773967266,
-0.6984592080116272,
0.6108725070953369,
0.16555283963680267,
-0.18570785224437714,
-0.6533571481704712,
-0.6861626505851746,
0.25069302320480347,
-0.1009756550192833,
-0.6619935035705566,
0.5632057785987854,
0.13491395115852356,
-0.3379383981227875,
0.2559424340724945,
0.16294783353805542,
-0.2542126774787903,
0.3658876121044159,
-0.04448660835623741,
0.10314885526895523,
-0.22087210416793823,
0.026350921019911766,
-0.007499370723962784,
0.2446637898683548,
0.24103452265262604,
-0.17456910014152527,
0.34864115715026855,
0.29118654131889343,
-0.2258266657590866,
-0.33519095182418823,
0.26210349798202515,
0.37885361909866333,
-0.4494568407535553,
0.6607659459114075,
0.46703702211380005,
-0.5299952030181885,
0.04085911437869072,
-0.42564836144447327,
-0.07850215584039688,
-0.4184701144695282,
0.2709186375141144,
-0.10061205923557281,
-0.6227812170982361,
0.822347104549408,
0.11521398276090622,
0.3076992928981781,
0.8585755825042725,
0.5581195950508118,
-0.006976467557251453,
0.8857747912406921,
0.3849959671497345,
-0.2064668834209442,
0.41335922479629517,
0.07677093893289566,
-0.24654926359653473,
-0.9367613196372986,
-0.27285006642341614,
-0.7650004625320435,
-0.05545198544859886,
-0.3511861264705658,
-0.1736927479505539,
0.2355041354894638,
-0.22398900985717773,
-0.11445429921150208,
0.04069685935974121,
-0.19764570891857147,
0.4477770924568176,
0.5669994950294495,
-0.06405405700206757,
0.65230792760849,
-0.13419947028160095,
0.05340462177991867,
0.14018666744232178,
-0.3193988800048828,
-0.3222784698009491,
1.1496251821517944,
-0.060531072318553925,
0.9007383584976196,
0.35449257493019104,
0.45378512144088745,
0.5229173302650452,
0.3217477798461914,
-0.7625536322593689,
0.43135708570480347,
-0.22370053827762604,
-0.7613633871078491,
-0.31478291749954224,
-0.5025017261505127,
-0.8988401889801025,
0.5299921631813049,
-0.01521302666515112,
-0.6264396905899048,
0.07054642587900162,
0.14495588839054108,
-0.4851836562156677,
-0.11910703033208847,
-0.6320014595985413,
0.689307451248169,
-0.2048569917678833,
-0.6045511364936829,
-0.23319458961486816,
-0.5915632247924805,
0.6275604963302612,
0.18804386258125305,
0.12440190464258194,
-0.05590886250138283,
-0.03741865232586861,
0.6853688955307007,
-0.35058557987213135,
0.6835837364196777,
-0.2792681157588959,
-0.21456857025623322,
0.3977533280849457,
-0.3289481997489929,
0.6643690466880798,
-0.05357259511947632,
-0.20304569602012634,
-0.19277596473693848,
-0.09164250642061234,
-0.4080914258956909,
-0.5385998487472534,
0.7684826254844666,
-0.3640499413013458,
-0.6486620306968689,
-0.43000853061676025,
-0.5433182716369629,
-0.31133925914764404,
0.2928588092327118,
0.16725116968154907,
0.28673410415649414,
-0.2427205592393875,
0.5717284083366394,
0.38375627994537354,
-0.22466138005256653,
0.5047776103019714,
0.414218544960022,
-0.2541132867336273,
-0.3717099726200104,
0.8836713433265686,
-0.002334431279450655,
0.03775135427713394,
0.31100863218307495,
0.2354109287261963,
-0.34928080439567566,
-0.5983258485794067,
-0.45660144090652466,
0.20888373255729675,
-0.7213922739028931,
-0.32712337374687195,
-0.4791242480278015,
-0.2350793033838272,
-0.9175225496292114,
0.25056901574134827,
-0.27859941124916077,
-0.8094833493232727,
-0.3702442944049835,
-0.0757051631808281,
-0.01967925764620304,
0.5439814329147339,
0.121249720454216,
0.27498659491539,
-0.9190952777862549,
0.22797206044197083,
0.13999465107917786,
0.206162691116333,
0.38889220356941223,
-0.5600776076316833,
-0.6236472129821777,
-0.00970765296369791,
-0.49971750378608704,
-0.8027303814888,
0.3934571444988251,
0.3663693368434906,
0.6454132795333862,
0.351104199886322,
0.3638322353363037,
0.7509099245071411,
-0.3781015872955322,
1.1506117582321167,
0.06605780869722366,
-0.7586899399757385,
0.5349014401435852,
-0.48716774582862854,
0.26756998896598816,
0.3905014395713806,
0.47674742341041565,
-0.3530237674713135,
-0.24575965106487274,
-0.2243562787771225,
-1.048997402191162,
0.7196128368377686,
0.3035067021846771,
0.03713957220315933,
0.24876272678375244,
0.37540993094444275,
-0.1068837121129036,
0.004708897788077593,
-0.7831587195396423,
-0.41906818747520447,
-0.2963012456893921,
-0.32458990812301636,
0.05495839565992355,
-0.3143453001976013,
-0.15018975734710693,
-0.24587807059288025,
0.9310478568077087,
-0.21795567870140076,
-0.10084635764360428,
0.19343657791614532,
-0.5505514740943909,
-0.056260816752910614,
0.0800342783331871,
0.5424941182136536,
0.7872763872146606,
-0.1511859893798828,
0.13610510528087616,
-0.10014598816633224,
-0.3189040720462799,
-0.17204686999320984,
0.44985121488571167,
-0.3167189359664917,
0.031382348388433456,
0.4285696744918823,
0.3271176517009735,
0.02125098928809166,
-0.9100340604782104,
0.7286596298217773,
-0.24185921251773834,
0.13450050354003906,
-0.4339883029460907,
-0.2647700309753418,
0.2933207154273987,
0.11173620820045471,
1.1925623416900635,
-0.5241442322731018,
0.537628710269928,
-0.4482629597187042,
0.12028902024030685,
0.44983038306236267,
-0.11977509409189224,
-0.36261048913002014,
0.7725640535354614,
0.5262053608894348,
0.21752607822418213,
0.5199858546257019,
-0.20077888667583466,
-0.6129195690155029,
0.40838897228240967,
0.48652443289756775,
0.9395484328269958,
-0.18089714646339417,
-0.09788212925195694,
0.6436352729797363,
0.27956730127334595,
-0.2191159874200821,
-0.08281411975622177,
-0.016505397856235504,
-0.557356059551239,
-0.4419492483139038,
-0.3689083755016327,
-0.6277996897697449,
-0.05035370588302612,
-0.7679842114448547,
0.26572519540786743,
-0.20947782695293427,
0.02731763757765293,
-0.10344244539737701,
-0.04956777021288872,
0.0388793908059597,
0.15564994513988495,
0.14308029413223267,
0.7190856337547302,
-0.7939761877059937,
0.5585874915122986,
0.6687846779823303,
-0.6679195165634155,
-0.5231462121009827,
0.13817642629146576,
0.14359606802463531,
-0.6282439231872559,
0.6000428795814514,
-0.016060933470726013,
-0.00041887376573868096,
0.02172129973769188,
-0.7476726770401001,
-0.8728988766670227,
1.1817196607589722,
0.5760157704353333,
-0.03519874066114426,
-0.2707662880420685,
-0.2100357860326767,
0.3205428421497345,
-0.3427911102771759,
0.4425061345100403,
0.3056572675704956,
0.2570905387401581,
0.18792606890201569,
-0.9976699352264404,
0.3587348461151123,
-0.18500837683677673,
-0.2886083126068115,
-0.28209179639816284,
-0.8698391914367676,
0.9082663655281067,
-0.18883685767650604,
-0.2430817037820816,
0.10354813933372498,
0.8510075807571411,
0.2513912320137024,
0.10691516101360321,
0.3615502715110779,
0.22895072400569916,
0.7020223140716553,
-0.02053929679095745,
0.9982410669326782,
-0.18648794293403625,
0.42513445019721985,
1.329288125038147,
-0.1552850753068924,
0.8978398442268372,
0.3793867528438568,
-0.34464597702026367,
0.6627925634384155,
0.5489552617073059,
-0.12274663150310516,
0.49820277094841003,
0.19019681215286255,
-0.10818784683942795,
-0.23553842306137085,
-0.5474140644073486,
-0.29902249574661255,
0.3658525049686432,
0.2789861559867859,
-0.5906587839126587,
-0.388471782207489,
-0.31235256791114807,
-0.11619415134191513,
0.13412436842918396,
-0.2886771559715271,
0.5850722789764404,
0.12369194626808167,
-0.7301581501960754,
0.5043498873710632,
0.19482870399951935,
0.7191846966743469,
-0.5199913382530212,
0.06003601849079132,
-0.3331129550933838,
0.12504005432128906,
-0.7305987477302551,
-0.410739541053772,
0.17611050605773926,
0.35920166969299316,
-0.122818723320961,
-0.1277220994234085,
0.8377997875213623,
-0.31042370200157166,
-0.34298038482666016,
-0.005296541843563318,
0.3948994576931,
0.13694341480731964,
-0.5348193645477295,
-0.3286948800086975,
-0.1893996298313141,
0.2061079442501068,
-0.41478222608566284,
0.2485131472349167,
0.3118114769458771,
-0.20065025985240936,
0.7617066502571106,
0.6000193357467651,
0.1243884339928627,
0.2029893696308136,
0.37867268919944763,
1.0001708269119263,
-0.8735145330429077,
-0.396698534488678,
-0.917323648929596,
0.4311922490596771,
-0.2793457806110382,
-0.050663892179727554,
0.9685037732124329,
0.9952875971794128,
0.5237501263618469,
0.09419351816177368,
1.0843946933746338,
-0.04764685034751892,
0.6699824333190918,
-0.31649601459503174,
0.7657181620597839,
-0.7646200656890869,
0.3342142701148987,
-0.05683720111846924,
-0.7979796528816223,
-0.40411365032196045,
0.5180264115333557,
0.12861375510692596,
-0.19091589748859406,
0.6193647980690002,
0.4371545612812042,
0.1564512550830841,
-0.045980773866176605,
-0.07378584891557693,
0.2247578203678131,
0.5078233480453491,
0.3978827893733978,
0.8388494253158569,
-0.4330190122127533,
0.8928990364074707,
-0.18383744359016418,
-0.0461060032248497,
-0.4016123414039612,
-1.0384044647216797,
-0.6442254185676575,
-0.4376906454563141,
-0.2977498769760132,
-0.181956946849823,
-0.15811707079410553,
1.0462251901626587,
0.22831620275974274,
-0.8839015960693359,
-0.36129170656204224,
0.23143920302391052,
0.19793377816677094,
-0.16046889126300812,
-0.21248029172420502,
0.48774421215057373,
-0.36935219168663025,
-0.8605635762214661,
0.22715602815151215,
0.003430248238146305,
-0.18926191329956055,
-0.4832940697669983,
0.02504010498523712,
-0.38843008875846863,
-0.07595980912446976,
0.6191533207893372,
0.2005475014448166,
-0.8119760155677795,
-0.06171157956123352,
0.07226380705833435,
-0.26335781812667847,
-0.025959497317671776,
0.9900259971618652,
-0.6687080264091492,
0.13218392431735992,
0.4971344470977783,
0.5022221207618713,
0.4346705675125122,
0.4768791198730469,
0.5996018648147583,
-0.8048277497291565,
-0.11550214886665344,
0.3230735957622528,
0.4160190224647522,
0.6517488956451416,
-0.3109356164932251,
0.6618706583976746,
0.32210493087768555,
-0.2324407696723938,
-1.017965316772461,
-0.13993506133556366,
-0.9110201001167297,
-0.32050463557243347,
1.4170312881469727,
-0.584172248840332,
0.09308935701847076,
0.003010086715221405,
0.04410530999302864,
0.27802273631095886,
-0.35521912574768066,
0.7262162566184998,
0.894310474395752,
-0.18473787605762482,
0.04804374650120735,
-0.09503858536481857,
0.3003953993320465,
0.26671287417411804,
-0.6493929624557495,
0.615308403968811,
0.6943621039390564,
0.18768224120140076,
0.13592025637626648,
0.5428231954574585,
-0.09118570387363434,
0.23224255442619324,
-0.09791173040866852,
0.09888262301683426,
-0.19518215954303741,
0.06740003079175949,
-0.1314302533864975,
0.35417523980140686,
0.12879233062267303,
-0.0167968962341547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01767v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01767v1
|
KeNet:Knowledge-enhanced Doc-Label Attention Network for Multi-label text classification
| 2024-03-04T06:52:19 | 2024-03-04T06:52:19 |
Bo Li, Yuyan Chen, Liang Zeng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-Label Text Classification (MLTC) is a fundamental task in the field of
Natural Language Processing (NLP) that involves the assignment of multiple
labels to a given text. MLTC has gained significant importance and has been
widely applied in various domains such as topic recognition, recommendation
systems, sentiment analysis, and information retrieval. However, traditional
machine learning and Deep neural network have not yet addressed certain issues,
such as the fact that some documents are brief but have a large number of
labels and how to establish relationships between the labels. It is imperative
to additionally acknowledge that the significance of knowledge is substantiated
in the realm of MLTC. To address this issue, we provide a novel approach known
as Knowledge-enhanced Doc-Label Attention Network (KeNet). Specifically, we
design an Attention Network that incorporates external knowledge, label
embedding, and a comprehensive attention mechanism. In contrast to conventional
methods, we use comprehensive representation of documents, knowledge and labels
to predict all labels for each single text. Our approach has been validated by
comprehensive research conducted on three multi-label datasets. Experimental
results demonstrate that our method outperforms state-of-the-art MLTC method.
Additionally, a case study is undertaken to illustrate the practical
implementation of KeNet.
|
[
-0.47574761509895325,
-0.617494523525238,
0.5649057626724243,
0.0495794303715229,
-0.1373112052679062,
0.11729796230792999,
-0.1779959499835968,
-0.494375616312027,
0.24276834726333618,
0.5333340167999268,
-0.4015393853187561,
-0.676842212677002,
-0.7982345819473267,
-0.04167633876204491,
-0.23075313866138458,
1.152047038078308,
-0.10246056318283081,
-0.37219759821891785,
-0.4202515482902527,
-0.26945969462394714,
-0.4145340621471405,
-0.4873102009296417,
-0.6601480841636658,
-0.28392425179481506,
0.9023051261901855,
0.4997083842754364,
-0.11317116022109985,
0.46701309084892273,
0.7885550260543823,
0.32020124793052673,
0.008011040277779102,
0.33933785557746887,
-0.2763098478317261,
0.31952884793281555,
0.2176925092935562,
-0.1739732027053833,
-0.43573513627052307,
-0.0069556813687086105,
0.6421427130699158,
0.5041597485542297,
0.06032746285200119,
0.03673351928591728,
0.28312015533447266,
0.8663660883903503,
-0.6876699924468994,
0.20542408525943756,
-0.4407968521118164,
0.24493983387947083,
-0.12547285854816437,
-0.19308887422084808,
-0.5155181884765625,
-0.4217681288719177,
0.3270506262779236,
-0.933803379535675,
0.14670172333717346,
0.048704057931900024,
0.8011085987091064,
0.3066219985485077,
-0.6339395642280579,
-0.35968437790870667,
-0.508002758026123,
0.5944242477416992,
-0.38361725211143494,
0.6221767663955688,
0.505963146686554,
0.3550107479095459,
0.23594968020915985,
-1.2119485139846802,
-0.5115491151809692,
-0.20484527945518494,
-0.13114158809185028,
0.7077040672302246,
0.2504661977291107,
0.14015460014343262,
0.18719637393951416,
0.28330203890800476,
-0.28582191467285156,
0.03810857981443405,
-0.22326447069644928,
-0.1807989776134491,
0.05680445209145546,
-0.18623119592666626,
-0.08250588923692703,
0.1648949533700943,
-0.7920031547546387,
-0.10292423516511917,
-0.06463982164859772,
0.08924316614866257,
0.10250895470380783,
0.06888209283351898,
0.2587115466594696,
0.35714197158813477,
-0.2909838855266571,
0.6508660912513733,
0.2727123498916626,
-0.1695774644613266,
0.3058224618434906,
-0.3005205988883972,
-0.4327195882797241,
0.653788685798645,
0.9218025803565979,
0.2529025375843048,
0.0024132486432790756,
-0.1969434767961502,
0.1600891351699829,
-0.1527329981327057,
0.5765725374221802,
-0.7565885186195374,
-0.1989869475364685,
0.1606282889842987,
-0.24328996241092682,
-0.7055558562278748,
0.017648814246058464,
-0.6827694177627563,
-0.6869960427284241,
-0.447416216135025,
0.28629517555236816,
-0.3529166281223297,
-0.05868058651685715,
-0.09475798904895782,
-0.1976589560508728,
-0.06628697365522385,
0.46979793906211853,
-0.6954811811447144,
0.07447244971990585,
0.512627124786377,
0.732154905796051,
0.111053965985775,
-0.2515053451061249,
-0.5632311701774597,
0.6178155541419983,
-0.08349549025297165,
1.0046831369400024,
-0.5765813589096069,
-0.09817031025886536,
-0.24413834512233734,
-0.04236418753862381,
-0.1488398015499115,
0.046952348202466965,
0.9568025469779968,
-0.7232967019081116,
0.21407337486743927,
-0.2054232358932495,
-0.8440724611282349,
-0.5150330066680908,
0.966485857963562,
-0.7504458427429199,
1.0140678882598877,
0.0096846679225564,
-1.3723077774047852,
0.2757679224014282,
-1.128931999206543,
-0.4609770178794861,
0.1451667994260788,
0.059484805911779404,
-0.6748179197311401,
-0.35499975085258484,
0.2841305434703827,
0.7218149900436401,
-0.1443391591310501,
0.27414071559906006,
-0.35742342472076416,
-0.081077441573143,
0.3374573886394501,
-0.43022894859313965,
0.519737958908081,
0.05599192529916763,
-0.2389453649520874,
0.11114199459552765,
-0.8532060384750366,
0.10548804700374603,
-0.02539164386689663,
-0.5310547947883606,
-0.7753850221633911,
-0.4510895907878876,
0.1341681331396103,
0.2656209468841553,
0.16234225034713745,
-0.6527737975120544,
0.27335506677627563,
-0.4303527772426605,
0.11826527118682861,
0.825036346912384,
0.13616155087947845,
0.46564435958862305,
-0.1286820024251938,
0.364752858877182,
0.06413639336824417,
0.24780166149139404,
-0.1099696159362793,
-0.6587004661560059,
-0.9441853165626526,
-0.13666346669197083,
0.6451247930526733,
0.6275180578231812,
-0.6431496143341064,
0.4283006489276886,
-0.37983939051628113,
-0.4493432939052582,
-0.7923691868782043,
0.19130966067314148,
0.2869858145713806,
0.8581218123435974,
0.36958131194114685,
-0.31950417160987854,
-0.30571430921554565,
-1.0166642665863037,
-0.021075457334518433,
0.19978463649749756,
0.11703314632177353,
0.5055076479911804,
0.2302212119102478,
-0.4269040524959564,
0.849812388420105,
-0.4608862102031708,
-0.7635441422462463,
0.03944629803299904,
0.344467431306839,
-0.0019772860687226057,
0.22904396057128906,
0.230860635638237,
-0.8573431372642517,
-1.0119667053222656,
0.6191307306289673,
-0.7605767846107483,
0.10495834052562714,
-0.22589987516403198,
-0.28291457891464233,
-0.02581728994846344,
0.4483732581138611,
-0.16765008866786957,
0.06892581284046173,
0.3083508014678955,
-0.09951842576265335,
0.6463126540184021,
-0.34691357612609863,
0.13877321779727936,
-1.2759655714035034,
0.33516690135002136,
0.09136945009231567,
-0.16977627575397491,
-0.6443909406661987,
-0.04955010861158371,
0.48385196924209595,
0.08064869791269302,
-0.14631924033164978,
0.3788701891899109,
-0.2352229356765747,
0.20619899034500122,
-0.23854541778564453,
0.18827717006206512,
0.55140620470047,
0.5114396810531616,
0.12141869962215424,
0.34123650193214417,
0.36210137605667114,
-0.6745107769966125,
0.5491126775741577,
0.2701118588447571,
-0.2124847173690796,
0.9822003245353699,
-0.2910026013851166,
0.3457189202308655,
-0.17185576260089874,
0.34675535559654236,
-0.7848055958747864,
0.006763264071196318,
0.42598778009414673,
-0.39310547709465027,
0.6802988648414612,
-0.07921561598777771,
-0.5516442060470581,
-0.38426727056503296,
-0.280328631401062,
-0.04939277470111847,
-0.1384466141462326,
-0.5331072807312012,
0.6734441518783569,
0.1854788362979889,
-0.1513194739818573,
-0.8985490202903748,
-0.6263723373413086,
0.2530837059020996,
-0.18868769705295563,
-0.3699404299259186,
0.19031843543052673,
-0.23570884764194489,
0.18067537248134613,
0.11077361553907394,
-0.07863910496234894,
-0.31825289130210876,
0.15415745973587036,
0.26133066415786743,
-0.1334349364042282,
-0.23609648644924164,
0.5836774706840515,
0.28001275658607483,
-0.3731386363506317,
-0.07733885198831558,
-0.7146690487861633,
0.07841145992279053,
-0.0825551301240921,
-0.13358427584171295,
-0.3257211744785309,
0.5218989253044128,
0.6406345963478088,
-0.5492511987686157,
0.617576003074646,
1.2055954933166504,
-0.1948195844888687,
-0.04285864531993866,
-0.7060739994049072,
-0.12143027037382126,
-0.4763147234916687,
0.3437311053276062,
-0.4497529864311218,
-0.6806811094284058,
0.12259145081043243,
-0.3996005952358246,
0.005904858931899071,
0.4550290107727051,
0.19906848669052124,
-0.6044060587882996,
0.5027257800102234,
0.6173587441444397,
-0.16013453900814056,
0.3246854245662689,
-0.16020508110523224,
0.08722972869873047,
-1.1824654340744019,
-0.24371236562728882,
-0.4728250205516815,
-0.37458348274230957,
-0.28677743673324585,
-0.2122218757867813,
0.21393926441669464,
0.018810467794537544,
-0.12951993942260742,
0.11822519451379776,
-0.9564521908760071,
0.5307132601737976,
0.896677553653717,
0.09561732411384583,
0.3681847155094147,
0.14513051509857178,
-0.523644208908081,
0.017431028187274933,
-0.7394725680351257,
-0.25201842188835144,
1.2040148973464966,
0.34262800216674805,
0.26923176646232605,
-0.14523100852966309,
0.6872480511665344,
0.30255618691444397,
0.6696839928627014,
-0.8251289129257202,
0.23709100484848022,
-0.2473713904619217,
-0.5995166897773743,
-0.255079984664917,
-0.39836880564689636,
-0.9723279476165771,
0.2026216685771942,
-0.1409025937318802,
-0.5518898367881775,
0.16501137614250183,
-0.13025125861167908,
-0.18096916377544403,
0.2825683057308197,
-0.9563927054405212,
0.8943824172019958,
-0.21643893420696259,
-0.17757165431976318,
0.0844326913356781,
-0.8782212138175964,
0.33326244354248047,
-0.42557308077812195,
0.2705097496509552,
0.13527904450893402,
0.12709881365299225,
1.04877769947052,
-0.15325096249580383,
1.034322738647461,
-0.13673244416713715,
-0.27732235193252563,
0.1966654360294342,
-0.31171509623527527,
0.7277348637580872,
0.025101441890001297,
0.09184440225362778,
-0.10825660079717636,
-0.15832528471946716,
-0.1340436488389969,
-0.4898580312728882,
0.8968278765678406,
-0.6676893830299377,
-0.08914130181074142,
-0.3125479817390442,
-0.5380845069885254,
-0.35677897930145264,
0.6374162435531616,
0.20304346084594727,
0.4849776327610016,
-0.12844660878181458,
0.3123968541622162,
0.9808136820793152,
-0.09781079739332199,
0.28793978691101074,
0.5614354610443115,
0.20885035395622253,
-0.5900984406471252,
1.1610089540481567,
0.23367835581302643,
0.2097264975309372,
0.7672120928764343,
0.3607785403728485,
-0.4721210300922394,
-0.24006006121635437,
-0.33072614669799805,
-0.12991751730442047,
-1.1060431003570557,
-0.23555579781532288,
-1.1647281646728516,
-0.252568781375885,
-0.4834514856338501,
-0.2715607285499573,
-0.2632305324077606,
-0.23129555583000183,
-0.1248067319393158,
-0.16734057664871216,
0.4087946116924286,
0.7132453322410583,
0.17495250701904297,
0.3623720705509186,
-0.9169569611549377,
0.37810805439949036,
0.7519127726554871,
0.6560587882995605,
0.10924295336008072,
-0.09148180484771729,
-0.35964521765708923,
-0.1410992592573166,
-0.4727012515068054,
-0.9664037823677063,
-0.02890239842236042,
0.24744701385498047,
0.6683411002159119,
0.6853815317153931,
0.3880804181098938,
0.13967999815940857,
-0.36632707715034485,
0.09128148853778839,
0.3469931483268738,
-0.4818216562271118,
0.5595560669898987,
-0.3878213167190552,
0.4580409526824951,
0.7568902969360352,
0.3331926465034485,
-0.8195847868919373,
-0.4911973774433136,
-0.7924373745918274,
-0.8571064472198486,
0.6463029980659485,
0.3217022120952606,
-0.2820909917354584,
0.37560781836509705,
0.03742559254169464,
0.25074732303619385,
0.2620949447154999,
-0.7767789959907532,
-0.45938050746917725,
-0.24937871098518372,
-0.5305623412132263,
0.07580462843179703,
-0.26867738366127014,
-0.114120714366436,
-0.07416743785142899,
0.8901849985122681,
-0.16514240205287933,
0.46484649181365967,
0.3079041540622711,
-0.14529825747013092,
0.2839966416358948,
0.6084940433502197,
0.5910781621932983,
0.08726920187473297,
-0.4770100712776184,
0.1917138248682022,
0.08725930005311966,
-0.9178205728530884,
0.10450128465890884,
0.4893511235713959,
-0.10514536499977112,
-0.008017024956643581,
0.09832605719566345,
0.7305412888526917,
0.05002101510763168,
0.059099286794662476,
0.26320841908454895,
-0.29376113414764404,
-0.4093300700187683,
-0.01818944700062275,
-0.3209609389305115,
0.2446404993534088,
0.03910652920603752,
0.12421086430549622,
0.3020276129245758,
0.3586776554584503,
0.016775721684098244,
0.21527397632598877,
0.06963984668254852,
-0.9230312705039978,
0.24361631274223328,
0.3740244209766388,
0.4894167482852936,
-0.0347863994538784,
0.548855721950531,
-0.24418286979198456,
-0.803046464920044,
0.8512830138206482,
0.33398351073265076,
0.7547977566719055,
-0.1529187262058258,
0.42160263657569885,
0.3809537887573242,
0.6190956234931946,
0.4036177396774292,
-0.248561292886734,
-0.31505611538887024,
-0.685061514377594,
-0.4097941815853119,
-0.5820527672767639,
-0.3065969944000244,
0.23561181128025055,
-0.5676620602607727,
-0.12131058424711227,
-0.30857956409454346,
-0.13633228838443756,
0.22169841825962067,
0.20001111924648285,
-0.874748945236206,
0.38599446415901184,
0.1614239662885666,
0.5933891534805298,
-0.5816797018051147,
1.148720622062683,
0.9110135436058044,
-0.1605227142572403,
-0.558795154094696,
-0.19085299968719482,
-0.1941501796245575,
-0.34682050347328186,
0.5783249735832214,
0.7078642249107361,
0.10511169582605362,
0.4907079339027405,
-0.13838699460029602,
-0.6112746000289917,
1.0172423124313354,
-0.20826759934425354,
-0.8469722867012024,
0.3613419234752655,
0.07957799732685089,
0.1981058567762375,
-0.10009697824716568,
0.2323557734489441,
0.24542151391506195,
1.0443222522735596,
-0.25318264961242676,
-0.7625110149383545,
-0.023185908794403076,
-0.285749614238739,
-0.3660813271999359,
0.3434375524520874,
-0.5193262100219727,
-0.005025189835578203,
-0.126700296998024,
0.04127000272274017,
-0.5757264494895935,
0.4086875915527344,
0.10992232710123062,
0.5768359303474426,
0.5179170370101929,
0.8220152854919434,
1.114896535873413,
0.0008970116032287478,
1.0992088317871094,
-0.023748641833662987,
0.33478134870529175,
1.2737786769866943,
-0.09759798645973206,
0.5367100834846497,
0.49709752202033997,
-0.1613161265850067,
0.290052205324173,
0.6007996797561646,
-0.19253022968769073,
0.61788010597229,
-0.040799472481012344,
-0.3784574270248413,
-0.20301254093647003,
-0.33792349696159363,
-0.7092676758766174,
0.13607029616832733,
0.49304094910621643,
-0.5590117573738098,
-0.0526510551571846,
0.2520275115966797,
-0.2517116963863373,
-0.32462942600250244,
-0.28633466362953186,
1.140670657157898,
0.15160825848579407,
-0.27861085534095764,
0.09206188470125198,
0.02880646474659443,
0.6531915068626404,
-0.6816781163215637,
0.053358111530542374,
0.008334781974554062,
0.36466366052627563,
0.03619445487856865,
-0.8543967008590698,
-0.07206093519926071,
-0.40263631939888,
-0.4951975643634796,
-0.22163815796375275,
1.2221791744232178,
-0.5095625519752502,
-0.7623808979988098,
0.28270015120506287,
0.1284138411283493,
-0.095601387321949,
-0.35529035329818726,
-0.764907956123352,
-0.4741194546222687,
-0.055458590388298035,
-0.27480462193489075,
0.3761976659297943,
0.6626842021942139,
0.29122909903526306,
0.5343374609947205,
0.7931117415428162,
-0.3448275327682495,
0.07892999798059464,
0.2633133828639984,
0.7321703433990479,
-0.3157943785190582,
-0.9140455722808838,
-0.4665515720844269,
0.5718125700950623,
-0.4585934579372406,
-0.21773885190486908,
0.6446545124053955,
0.49249619245529175,
0.43357178568840027,
-0.12266222387552261,
1.1313552856445312,
0.17389586567878723,
0.29464656114578247,
-0.3078034222126007,
1.1243757009506226,
-0.5189989805221558,
-0.09014299511909485,
-0.4061684310436249,
-0.8403290510177612,
-0.40221258997917175,
0.5089479684829712,
-0.05840285122394562,
-0.049247127026319504,
1.089884638786316,
0.2877058982849121,
-0.1922284960746765,
0.02722482569515705,
0.20020724833011627,
0.12992534041404724,
0.2695997357368469,
0.6436330080032349,
0.5530481934547424,
-0.43932145833969116,
0.9738940000534058,
-0.6212657690048218,
-0.060915522277355194,
-0.20399588346481323,
-0.8795643448829651,
-0.9283291697502136,
-0.7029094696044922,
-0.5253495573997498,
-0.18082362413406372,
0.08450890332460403,
0.3177773952484131,
0.672756016254425,
-0.730713963508606,
0.5295214653015137,
-0.04240789636969566,
0.053610965609550476,
-0.3543758988380432,
-0.21780046820640564,
0.8566216826438904,
-0.39878347516059875,
-0.41395413875579834,
0.340057373046875,
0.3713613450527191,
0.09447475522756577,
0.014601090922951698,
-0.04221980273723602,
-0.42624351382255554,
-0.34726378321647644,
0.7164393663406372,
-0.11846216022968292,
-0.3914228081703186,
0.1433992087841034,
-0.11340059340000153,
-0.3562273383140564,
0.10727189481258392,
0.6542589068412781,
-0.7277243137359619,
0.9421346187591553,
0.3796056807041168,
0.9401890635490417,
0.514293909072876,
-0.2269429713487625,
0.3925759196281433,
-1.2076634168624878,
-0.10903520882129669,
0.21123106777668,
0.04414121061563492,
0.2592897415161133,
-0.5423165559768677,
0.3592396378517151,
0.17892304062843323,
-0.5547056794166565,
-0.4607085585594177,
-0.00015911750961095095,
-1.151771903038025,
-0.19738274812698364,
0.8878241777420044,
-0.19779889285564423,
-0.12217624485492706,
-0.5726987719535828,
-0.5199188590049744,
0.3487302362918854,
-0.589950442314148,
0.7965768575668335,
0.8635318875312805,
0.4774015247821808,
-0.46307021379470825,
-0.9040141105651855,
0.17518630623817444,
0.2577754259109497,
-1.0151431560516357,
-0.013776728883385658,
0.13493241369724274,
0.05212594196200371,
0.469372034072876,
0.4733768701553345,
0.3814705014228821,
0.10537772625684738,
-0.07188280671834946,
0.1973179578781128,
-0.5624436736106873,
-0.29209625720977783,
0.03079550713300705,
0.5253230929374695,
-0.139884352684021,
-0.40548208355903625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01757v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01757v1
|
How Multimodal Integration Boost the Performance of LLM for Optimization: Case Study on Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problems
| 2024-03-04T06:24:21 | 2024-03-04T06:24:21 |
Yuxiao Huang, Wenjie Zhang, Liang Feng, Xingyu Wu, Kay Chen Tan
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.NE, math.OC
|
Recently, large language models (LLMs) have notably positioned them as
capable tools for addressing complex optimization challenges. Despite this
recognition, a predominant limitation of existing LLM-based optimization
methods is their struggle to capture the relationships among decision variables
when relying exclusively on numerical text prompts, especially in
high-dimensional problems. Keeping this in mind, we first propose to enhance
the optimization performance using multimodal LLM capable of processing both
textual and visual prompts for deeper insights of the processed optimization
problem. This integration allows for a more comprehensive understanding of
optimization problems, akin to human cognitive processes. We have developed a
multimodal LLM-based optimization framework that simulates human
problem-solving workflows, thereby offering a more nuanced and effective
analysis. The efficacy of this method is evaluated through extensive empirical
studies focused on a well-known combinatorial optimization problem, i.e.,
capacitated vehicle routing problem. The results are compared against those
obtained from the LLM-based optimization algorithms that rely solely on textual
prompts, demonstrating the significant advantages of our multimodal approach.
|
[
-0.636913537979126,
-0.9517131447792053,
0.9202542304992676,
0.49551674723625183,
-0.15581649541854858,
0.3253321945667267,
-0.6988293528556824,
-0.3011533319950104,
0.041284315288066864,
0.3772426247596741,
-0.9752538800239563,
-0.16365154087543488,
-0.18980757892131805,
-0.04748385027050972,
0.15627014636993408,
0.48873767256736755,
-0.11867795139551163,
0.3376927971839905,
-0.8530722856521606,
-0.13340650498867035,
-0.6062086224555969,
-0.5813324451446533,
-0.799923837184906,
-0.2994759976863861,
0.7030957341194153,
0.2539049983024597,
0.4249095320701599,
0.45664843916893005,
0.637774646282196,
0.32650837302207947,
0.029436780139803886,
0.6020252704620361,
-0.3986434042453766,
0.2548937499523163,
-0.09482429176568985,
-0.14768154919147491,
-0.08240560442209244,
-0.2272026091814041,
0.7229124903678894,
0.7859433889389038,
-0.19185099005699158,
-0.19545811414718628,
-0.06603182852268219,
0.4468115568161011,
-0.8301569223403931,
0.23268623650074005,
-0.2356613576412201,
0.037044305354356766,
-0.13901357352733612,
-0.6796437501907349,
-0.1733277142047882,
-0.24476662278175354,
0.03107714280486107,
-0.7989004254341125,
0.040224067866802216,
0.1653030663728714,
0.49443256855010986,
0.5916298031806946,
-0.49339836835861206,
-0.5483970642089844,
-0.9484120607376099,
1.2183183431625366,
-0.3281843662261963,
0.40668827295303345,
-0.0220751091837883,
0.2088775336742401,
-0.23282752931118011,
-0.3504229485988617,
-0.5958971381187439,
-0.26461032032966614,
0.18508823215961456,
0.2665368914604187,
-0.06843607127666473,
0.3054489493370056,
0.2438778132200241,
0.11251041293144226,
-0.5005976557731628,
0.27731654047966003,
-0.146116241812706,
-0.3838912844657898,
0.5523446202278137,
0.43148791790008545,
0.38620397448539734,
0.05869121477007866,
-0.6218197345733643,
-0.37540823221206665,
-0.12483221292495728,
0.31671151518821716,
0.26995179057121277,
0.2226943075656891,
-0.06558044254779816,
0.46363818645477295,
-0.0957784354686737,
0.6463870406150818,
-0.4483990967273712,
-0.5285765528678894,
0.49619877338409424,
-0.6573609709739685,
0.09805533289909363,
-0.2508244812488556,
0.7144566774368286,
0.5415832996368408,
0.22844985127449036,
-0.20020422339439392,
-0.24890564382076263,
0.21065273880958557,
0.1764017641544342,
-0.5498222708702087,
0.14424575865268707,
0.19676938652992249,
-0.3460777699947357,
-0.14059284329414368,
-0.3117700219154358,
-0.9850306510925293,
-0.020471615716814995,
-0.6658485531806946,
0.3039587438106537,
-0.4129613935947418,
0.02634098008275032,
0.3826698064804077,
-0.25390949845314026,
0.3896966576576233,
0.5142655968666077,
-0.7640923857688904,
0.17056070268154144,
0.5197068452835083,
0.8522531390190125,
-0.3054489195346832,
-0.19186100363731384,
-0.6681706309318542,
0.3524243235588074,
-0.06547398120164871,
0.9309723377227783,
-0.7912223935127258,
-0.4327772557735443,
-0.026328226551413536,
-0.25031477212905884,
-0.21231089532375336,
-0.265577107667923,
0.8114362359046936,
-0.6260623335838318,
-0.00942058302462101,
-0.5091463327407837,
-0.24892498552799225,
-0.37668976187705994,
0.41595757007598877,
-0.6755280494689941,
0.9399064779281616,
-0.28324490785598755,
-0.42177069187164307,
0.17844656109809875,
-0.9450121521949768,
-0.559444010257721,
-0.0015324456617236137,
-0.23982331156730652,
-0.35678455233573914,
0.03529027849435806,
0.519865095615387,
0.26343902945518494,
-0.6706984043121338,
0.1871698796749115,
-0.24763166904449463,
0.0178055576980114,
0.13147015869617462,
-0.6850103735923767,
0.642063319683075,
0.21212060749530792,
0.04718038812279701,
0.1697760969400406,
-0.45123371481895447,
0.015839049592614174,
-0.11393928527832031,
-0.5639062523841858,
-0.2449154257774353,
0.05868465453386307,
0.26863691210746765,
0.025396397337317467,
0.37411078810691833,
-0.2972096800804138,
0.37072092294692993,
-0.21642759442329407,
0.2895943820476532,
0.8133165836334229,
0.19319911301136017,
0.510514497756958,
-0.40305784344673157,
0.9716373085975647,
-0.18324169516563416,
0.20830348134040833,
-0.2941083312034607,
-0.576657772064209,
-0.6273601055145264,
-0.5299069285392761,
-0.03940752521157265,
0.6583495736122131,
-0.8548558950424194,
-0.18701544404029846,
0.08915543556213379,
-0.26865965127944946,
-0.0852513238787651,
0.2401922345161438,
0.2305169701576233,
0.45716118812561035,
0.20168158411979675,
-0.37340182065963745,
-0.4354616403579712,
-0.8512319326400757,
-0.01980249211192131,
-0.024105004966259003,
0.48718181252479553,
0.7069701552391052,
0.38982895016670227,
-0.5662828087806702,
0.8622986674308777,
-0.9220246076583862,
-0.24039097130298615,
-0.20658116042613983,
0.23959244787693024,
0.06557202339172363,
0.5390331745147705,
0.3880329728126526,
-0.8813614845275879,
-0.18020020425319672,
-0.02322261966764927,
-0.8180069327354431,
-0.24910032749176025,
-0.5725561380386353,
-0.2831108272075653,
-0.2393023520708084,
0.5214980244636536,
-0.8189568519592285,
0.0024867902975529432,
0.3856585621833801,
0.1175486221909523,
0.6565247178077698,
-0.5356302857398987,
0.06001179665327072,
-0.7253263592720032,
-0.14114509522914886,
0.17647935450077057,
-0.08183101564645767,
-0.40125203132629395,
-0.024216463789343834,
-0.14878980815410614,
-0.24268721044063568,
-0.32838770747184753,
0.4881344139575958,
-0.6914709806442261,
-0.13687829673290253,
0.02650551311671734,
0.2732695937156677,
0.05922786146402359,
0.7895527482032776,
-0.2611220180988312,
1.1504665613174438,
0.6083556413650513,
-0.6137188673019409,
0.6947027444839478,
0.2735321521759033,
-0.22046469151973724,
0.615305483341217,
-0.38820162415504456,
-0.07774019986391068,
-0.5776523351669312,
0.017630280926823616,
-1.213000774383545,
-0.3797056972980499,
0.14255866408348083,
0.015623769722878933,
0.3007027208805084,
0.40415868163108826,
-0.6439324021339417,
-0.14825700223445892,
-0.4684246778488159,
0.8686522841453552,
0.17371787130832672,
-0.36903679370880127,
0.8237956762313843,
0.35877612233161926,
-0.06343159824609756,
-0.3628275990486145,
-0.44966983795166016,
0.09852441400289536,
-0.3090973496437073,
-0.9156445264816284,
0.4668673574924469,
-0.3651740550994873,
-0.10081367194652557,
-0.5201814770698547,
0.12185045331716537,
0.0026537450030446053,
0.16418759524822235,
-0.009519224055111408,
0.2515045404434204,
-0.1508914679288864,
0.3972747027873993,
0.17169611155986786,
-0.22842776775360107,
0.10054141283035278,
-0.05054658278822899,
0.684270977973938,
-0.20544689893722534,
-0.5249636173248291,
-0.6212195158004761,
0.5378983616828918,
0.7859203815460205,
-0.5086703896522522,
0.5193070769309998,
0.6596772074699402,
-0.18699312210083008,
0.018619133159518242,
-0.7961596846580505,
-0.1709786206483841,
-0.5046226382255554,
0.3509141504764557,
-0.31070178747177124,
-0.6755610704421997,
0.2912268042564392,
-0.6385021209716797,
-0.22006408870220184,
0.059035513550043106,
0.6330630779266357,
-0.3304688632488251,
1.079583764076233,
0.6274420022964478,
0.18894164264202118,
0.6332156658172607,
-0.26269328594207764,
-0.007741830311715603,
-0.9856894016265869,
-0.5716477632522583,
-0.4640596807003021,
-0.34125494956970215,
-0.6174085736274719,
-0.8740260601043701,
0.8846909403800964,
0.03203931078314781,
0.14312893152236938,
-0.03049386665225029,
-0.20172862708568573,
0.4566962420940399,
0.5982171893119812,
0.21718968451023102,
0.3869645595550537,
0.22994717955589294,
-0.4007461369037628,
-0.1730274111032486,
-1.0345083475112915,
-0.3277064263820648,
0.7342818975448608,
0.12248387932777405,
0.9044606685638428,
0.06987365335226059,
0.3246614634990692,
0.34526997804641724,
0.11771319806575775,
-0.9115791320800781,
0.5621870756149292,
0.06606421619653702,
-0.35073214769363403,
-0.24475696682929993,
-0.5388217568397522,
-0.9986361861228943,
0.2353753000497818,
-0.350752592086792,
-0.7487871646881104,
0.28035613894462585,
-0.11285419017076492,
-0.3900587558746338,
0.08053354173898697,
-0.6437268853187561,
0.8715612888336182,
-0.7339586019515991,
-0.5735212564468384,
-0.34238097071647644,
-0.4785871207714081,
0.20068076252937317,
-0.20760007202625275,
0.6137516498565674,
0.0004535021726042032,
-0.32703229784965515,
0.6333650350570679,
-0.25261154770851135,
0.662920355796814,
0.10362649708986282,
-0.10092002898454666,
-0.014122272841632366,
-0.29989850521087646,
0.4355402886867523,
-0.016593914479017258,
0.029817286878824234,
-0.09182049334049225,
-0.3399890959262848,
-0.2703078091144562,
-0.7023944854736328,
0.8391613960266113,
-0.7309777140617371,
-0.507749617099762,
-0.2041884809732437,
-0.9015284776687622,
-0.4120852053165436,
0.15826009213924408,
-0.03938611224293709,
0.7096148729324341,
0.05129390209913254,
0.026624562218785286,
0.6776148676872253,
-0.45931053161621094,
0.9068769812583923,
0.015810756012797356,
-0.017960894852876663,
-0.6445918679237366,
0.8842017650604248,
-0.06464061141014099,
0.19056211411952972,
0.6575853228569031,
0.22614315152168274,
-0.4819132387638092,
-0.37058794498443604,
-0.4247629940509796,
0.45941874384880066,
-0.759886622428894,
-0.07308890670537949,
-0.7500523328781128,
0.2604278326034546,
0.03663872927427292,
-0.36447542905807495,
-0.3269660770893097,
-0.2776375710964203,
-0.37473395466804504,
0.35479483008384705,
0.12927088141441345,
0.29622530937194824,
-0.18104609847068787,
0.4952637255191803,
-0.627526044845581,
0.20916828513145447,
0.4646979868412018,
0.269022136926651,
0.23286981880664825,
0.13999049365520477,
-0.3259131610393524,
-0.002277614548802376,
-0.5529986023902893,
-0.6817688345909119,
0.2749336063861847,
0.04808850586414337,
0.8384820222854614,
0.47570306062698364,
-0.1503540426492691,
0.9790738821029663,
-0.25416162610054016,
0.4673396050930023,
0.3412838876247406,
-0.7087322473526001,
0.3653588891029358,
-0.34465503692626953,
0.35988807678222656,
0.4591922163963318,
0.40141168236732483,
-0.2871558368206024,
0.04637577757239342,
0.03290398418903351,
-0.8069444894790649,
0.620773196220398,
0.484998494386673,
0.1287396401166916,
-0.05510194972157478,
0.40359556674957275,
-0.21598197519779205,
0.42766186594963074,
-0.49572476744651794,
-0.11740417033433914,
0.2826787233352661,
-0.040739018470048904,
-0.06099078059196472,
-0.3859668970108032,
-0.1066795289516449,
-0.3075335621833801,
0.4463626742362976,
-0.20371289551258087,
0.33122768998146057,
0.18932192027568817,
-0.10741502791643143,
0.04856667295098305,
-0.03323376178741455,
1.1050535440444946,
0.6788288950920105,
-0.03677573427557945,
-0.03276752308011055,
0.2089354246854782,
-0.2564678192138672,
0.11878572404384613,
-0.22190505266189575,
0.10790549963712692,
-0.16548806428909302,
0.5297836065292358,
0.591859757900238,
0.248832568526268,
-1.0189759731292725,
0.5338653922080994,
0.01536184549331665,
0.127536341547966,
-0.3271985352039337,
-0.04146232828497887,
0.000379657547455281,
0.6742087006568909,
0.5021181702613831,
0.2688118517398834,
0.3124879002571106,
-0.2782056927680969,
-0.08493608236312866,
0.8811593651771545,
-0.1687878668308258,
0.0005946491146460176,
0.809808075428009,
0.3797611594200134,
-0.4861305058002472,
0.41184625029563904,
0.04533783718943596,
-0.6652784943580627,
0.620094895362854,
0.26723554730415344,
0.8539856672286987,
0.024457082152366638,
-0.0020387787371873856,
0.288801908493042,
0.41832467913627625,
0.06431372463703156,
0.1739141047000885,
-0.3377189040184021,
-0.723074197769165,
-0.9971137642860413,
-0.7095227837562561,
-0.46662044525146484,
-0.3346846103668213,
-0.5387656092643738,
0.31907400488853455,
-0.3718125522136688,
-0.43954744935035706,
-0.12420763075351715,
-0.2426992952823639,
-0.7378323078155518,
0.2088073045015335,
0.10489723086357117,
0.5638710260391235,
-0.5369502305984497,
0.23102174699306488,
0.8866194486618042,
-0.4756806492805481,
-0.1977948546409607,
0.0013858152087777853,
-0.1614256203174591,
-0.8293998837471008,
0.8201132416725159,
0.23804673552513123,
-0.5028187036514282,
-0.12368985265493393,
-0.40508532524108887,
-0.8656502366065979,
1.0476815700531006,
0.429117888212204,
-0.6641224026679993,
-0.2429724633693695,
0.279818594455719,
0.28849589824676514,
-0.5539867281913757,
0.2133554369211197,
0.19380410015583038,
0.5357927680015564,
0.16202865540981293,
-0.9199160933494568,
-0.07423260807991028,
0.12317319959402084,
0.4760831892490387,
0.30655360221862793,
-1.0181442499160767,
0.6997945308685303,
-0.15054714679718018,
-0.021847110241651535,
0.009058278985321522,
0.3739258944988251,
0.20040996372699738,
0.4160419702529907,
0.598778486251831,
0.5240292549133301,
0.7804936766624451,
0.14973720908164978,
1.0775281190872192,
-0.285031259059906,
0.4912494122982025,
0.7147266864776611,
-0.12621088325977325,
0.5406665205955505,
1.0143647193908691,
0.013500415720045567,
0.4339337646961212,
0.3497438430786133,
0.1696571558713913,
0.8551661968231201,
0.06216537579894066,
-0.5787692666053772,
-0.7951395511627197,
-0.21999609470367432,
-0.19072005152702332,
0.6531351804733276,
0.31984761357307434,
-0.12292824685573578,
-0.40631791949272156,
0.4523402452468872,
-0.0625998005270958,
0.028742363676428795,
-0.13625018298625946,
0.7664047479629517,
-0.16157300770282745,
-0.56507807970047,
0.3599761426448822,
0.16458255052566528,
0.510270893573761,
-0.40918678045272827,
-0.05206257849931717,
-0.0945412814617157,
0.1298518180847168,
0.07851468771696091,
-0.41868674755096436,
0.11769863963127136,
-0.38764485716819763,
-0.4057997465133667,
-0.5121436715126038,
0.5560380220413208,
-0.22532570362091064,
-0.5559337735176086,
0.22626729309558868,
0.6260948181152344,
0.04285208135843277,
0.04711763188242912,
-0.4925262928009033,
0.5491847395896912,
-0.04354654252529144,
-0.020747318863868713,
0.08461035043001175,
0.41720619797706604,
-0.05367429181933403,
1.0793092250823975,
1.0077319145202637,
-0.14732182025909424,
-0.1912471055984497,
-0.07737044245004654,
1.1868948936462402,
-0.7601295709609985,
-0.3348017930984497,
-1.1267589330673218,
0.5424767136573792,
-0.06295822560787201,
-0.26972752809524536,
0.545071542263031,
0.6829296350479126,
0.6051663160324097,
-0.13877882063388824,
0.6766031384468079,
0.41692835092544556,
-0.006368831265717745,
-0.8973973989486694,
0.22834162414073944,
-0.792288601398468,
0.7026599049568176,
-0.3418312966823578,
-1.0725358724594116,
-0.30713239312171936,
0.6396966576576233,
-0.3495686948299408,
0.09703878313302994,
0.5334895849227905,
0.9443028569221497,
-0.23283398151397705,
-0.15450584888458252,
0.18537406623363495,
-0.2374212145805359,
0.4210123121738434,
0.670387327671051,
0.9841380715370178,
-0.04678554832935333,
0.5646730065345764,
-0.20129500329494476,
-0.3802414536476135,
-0.42839065194129944,
-1.052344799041748,
-0.9713547825813293,
-0.4592120349407196,
-0.32125580310821533,
0.08140840381383896,
-0.09551338851451874,
0.9413530826568604,
0.7754982709884644,
-0.1518162041902542,
-0.4921318292617798,
0.005797324702143669,
0.27628791332244873,
-0.09830453246831894,
-0.2501012682914734,
-0.005125946365296841,
-0.6100266575813293,
-0.6770874261856079,
0.4927613437175751,
0.6480003595352173,
-0.16630525887012482,
-0.5486159920692444,
-0.1313924491405487,
-0.34794244170188904,
0.19179770350456238,
0.826994776725769,
-0.09371680021286011,
-0.6076838970184326,
-0.041816964745521545,
0.10194850713014603,
0.04832519590854645,
0.11260385811328888,
1.1296112537384033,
-0.6615201234817505,
0.8393929600715637,
0.3246913552284241,
0.8401983380317688,
0.8281041979789734,
0.09824473410844803,
0.6828888654708862,
-0.7368873357772827,
0.3080593943595886,
0.1454044133424759,
0.26210007071495056,
0.34254857897758484,
-0.20265482366085052,
0.29240429401397705,
0.44328033924102783,
-0.4808872640132904,
-0.6730850338935852,
0.36238977313041687,
-1.3693705797195435,
-0.12144987285137177,
1.1751893758773804,
0.34788498282432556,
-0.2635466754436493,
-0.04670705646276474,
-0.6223931312561035,
0.06113321706652641,
-0.494751513004303,
0.38809138536453247,
0.7727561593055725,
-0.4625985622406006,
-0.38496121764183044,
-0.7178672552108765,
0.20703242719173431,
0.5108928084373474,
-0.7722853422164917,
-0.29324057698249817,
0.5766130685806274,
-0.12703540921211243,
0.27365434169769287,
0.404939740896225,
0.34724336862564087,
0.27868714928627014,
-0.22061941027641296,
-0.08044520765542984,
-0.13656890392303467,
-0.17599789798259735,
-0.028739340603351593,
0.3123322129249573,
-0.038102440536022186,
-0.23751932382583618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01754v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01754v1
|
Derivative-Free Optimization for Low-Rank Adaptation in Large Language Models
| 2024-03-04T06:20:31 | 2024-03-04T06:20:31 |
Feihu Jin, Yin Liu, Ying Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Parameter-efficient tuning methods such as LoRA could achieve comparable
performance to model tuning by tuning a small portion of the parameters.
However, substantial computational resources are still required, as this
process involves calculating gradients and performing back-propagation
throughout the model. Much effort has recently been devoted to utilizing the
derivative-free optimization method to eschew the computation of gradients and
showcase an augmented level of robustness in few-shot settings. In this paper,
we prepend the low-rank modules into each self-attention layer of the model and
employ two derivative-free optimization methods to optimize these low-rank
modules at each layer alternately. Extensive results on various tasks and
language models demonstrate that our proposed method achieves substantial
improvement and exhibits clear advantages in memory usage and convergence speed
compared to existing gradient-based parameter-efficient tuning and
derivative-free optimization methods in few-shot settings.
|
[
-0.2977433204650879,
-0.6690272688865662,
0.30956777930259705,
0.09854283183813095,
-0.3835093677043915,
-0.1310524344444275,
-0.44527357816696167,
-0.3438328206539154,
0.0033428093884140253,
0.41515764594078064,
-0.6591686606407166,
-0.4119209349155426,
-0.534525990486145,
-0.22590047121047974,
-0.12789423763751984,
1.0808384418487549,
0.019081121310591698,
-0.15653973817825317,
0.019822919741272926,
-0.3415912091732025,
-0.16077011823654175,
-0.1601790487766266,
-0.8135956525802612,
-0.13135555386543274,
0.8661449551582336,
0.4477817714214325,
0.4199962913990021,
0.7886365652084351,
0.4541883170604706,
0.15456902980804443,
-0.03735927492380142,
0.011430952697992325,
-0.6893312931060791,
0.060728151351213455,
-0.19958001375198364,
-0.444915771484375,
-0.6795074343681335,
-0.24173229932785034,
0.8136926889419556,
0.3932236135005951,
0.07574938982725143,
0.485220342874527,
0.19065795838832855,
0.9145122766494751,
-1.059461236000061,
-0.09151153266429901,
-0.6271246671676636,
-0.02493016980588436,
-0.15859073400497437,
-0.13177528977394104,
-0.25382646918296814,
-0.1562054455280304,
-0.09663098305463791,
-0.8237450122833252,
0.013058239594101906,
-0.07976332306861877,
0.44118890166282654,
0.45317238569259644,
-0.08408240228891373,
0.3182147741317749,
-0.7358474135398865,
1.1096562147140503,
-0.8251712918281555,
0.20758037269115448,
0.48172518610954285,
0.23470014333724976,
0.01713833585381508,
-0.20949754118919373,
-0.1800205558538437,
-0.2615538239479065,
0.1915418952703476,
0.17410539090633392,
-0.22793573141098022,
0.0764736607670784,
0.14684951305389404,
-0.08534647524356842,
-0.2954131066799164,
0.4956294894218445,
-0.277580589056015,
-0.06850302964448929,
0.4159124493598938,
-0.147079735994339,
0.02020023763179779,
-0.0648687407374382,
-0.22211074829101562,
-0.10553647577762604,
-0.8385546803474426,
0.1346011459827423,
0.41755348443984985,
0.7764657139778137,
-0.3321794867515564,
0.3061438500881195,
-0.21402758359909058,
0.6742130517959595,
0.20257343351840973,
-0.2571240961551666,
-0.07376205921173096,
-0.28024664521217346,
-0.09834830462932587,
-0.171735480427742,
0.4023127257823944,
-0.03850920870900154,
0.27495622634887695,
-0.07524185627698898,
-0.29778510332107544,
-0.2370123714208603,
0.15112784504890442,
-0.8211671710014343,
-0.019441375508904457,
0.20408125221729279,
-0.5047667622566223,
-0.3025107681751251,
-0.5016684532165527,
-0.9377244710922241,
0.027774512767791748,
-0.16613183915615082,
0.924333393573761,
-0.14286568760871887,
-0.15877565741539001,
-0.04197952151298523,
0.2701469957828522,
0.19553934037685394,
0.46792298555374146,
-1.1744928359985352,
0.45581141114234924,
0.5431198477745056,
0.8088897466659546,
-0.44808444380760193,
-0.23262199759483337,
-1.2073196172714233,
0.40918785333633423,
-0.2165633887052536,
0.691769540309906,
-0.49413639307022095,
-0.3079097270965576,
-0.25079286098480225,
-0.19698835909366608,
-0.2784948945045471,
-0.4139423370361328,
0.45112335681915283,
-0.398910790681839,
-0.05314191058278084,
0.01620691828429699,
-0.06509021669626236,
0.04711584001779556,
-0.04125776141881943,
-0.5230746865272522,
1.228151559829712,
0.30827048420906067,
-0.6253790259361267,
0.06437671184539795,
-1.0288820266723633,
-0.512118399143219,
-0.3141946792602539,
0.2636859714984894,
-0.4385358393192291,
0.4859183728694916,
0.31821727752685547,
0.2203185260295868,
-0.24792419373989105,
-0.480601966381073,
-0.21979555487632751,
-0.4088154733181,
-0.03367842733860016,
0.0028500149492174387,
0.527532160282135,
0.03423738479614258,
-0.3230936825275421,
0.26040300726890564,
-0.7932330965995789,
0.03781722113490105,
-0.11228230595588684,
-0.37141191959381104,
-0.5726260542869568,
0.006926401052623987,
0.01010853797197342,
0.10931333154439926,
0.08920112252235413,
-0.26870062947273254,
0.2816034257411957,
-0.6927477121353149,
0.27956485748291016,
0.9890136122703552,
-0.13287843763828278,
0.7258386015892029,
-0.16889089345932007,
0.6526191234588623,
0.2686428725719452,
0.2920199930667877,
0.17794112861156464,
-0.2709769308567047,
-0.9567338228225708,
-0.632639467716217,
0.5086663365364075,
0.312911719083786,
-0.5463157296180725,
0.2792479395866394,
-0.2644347846508026,
-0.24107986688613892,
-0.6385910511016846,
0.3243532180786133,
0.3993523120880127,
0.5337969064712524,
0.601020336151123,
-0.22447848320007324,
-0.07422742992639542,
-0.9732456207275391,
-0.3382030427455902,
0.0821080356836319,
0.05263691395521164,
0.25902581214904785,
0.4722500443458557,
0.04588713496923447,
0.7696175575256348,
-0.5287377834320068,
-0.20229566097259521,
-0.24375265836715698,
0.034121546894311905,
0.08609426766633987,
0.716913104057312,
0.8509833812713623,
-0.17747753858566284,
-0.5893828868865967,
0.08487685769796371,
-0.06285004317760468,
-0.139433354139328,
0.19427840411663055,
-0.5288999676704407,
0.4121730625629425,
0.3000513017177582,
-0.3756747841835022,
0.36779776215553284,
0.6563247442245483,
0.1355215460062027,
0.16207462549209595,
-0.2575160264968872,
-0.1931799203157425,
-1.032556414604187,
0.3329974114894867,
0.09310489892959595,
-0.27941185235977173,
-0.7050419449806213,
0.18171623349189758,
0.011066379025578499,
-0.15598039329051971,
-0.4831058979034424,
0.938459575176239,
-0.5440431833267212,
-0.1344965100288391,
-0.3416668176651001,
0.3632981479167938,
-0.07566019892692566,
0.6565703749656677,
-0.2411329448223114,
0.7555687427520752,
0.8844681978225708,
-0.5531398057937622,
-0.11138664931058884,
-0.04801633208990097,
-0.3255593776702881,
0.31612536311149597,
-0.37457865476608276,
0.3741987645626068,
-0.29186397790908813,
-0.10316109657287598,
-0.8851092457771301,
0.002653316128998995,
0.3661898970603943,
0.03858671709895134,
0.3332391679286957,
-0.5245795845985413,
-0.2181979864835739,
-0.06477594375610352,
-0.6823706030845642,
0.6270021200180054,
0.6426023244857788,
-0.45882201194763184,
0.6274300813674927,
-0.024716081097722054,
-0.14243605732917786,
-0.6895961761474609,
-0.6704660058021545,
-0.45202988386154175,
-0.445041686296463,
-0.27124321460723877,
0.2528752386569977,
-0.22403396666049957,
0.03636731579899788,
-0.2113693654537201,
-0.27975985407829285,
-0.10237262398004532,
0.38961470127105713,
-0.12932957708835602,
0.008414709940552711,
-0.48104700446128845,
0.06357354670763016,
0.5014326572418213,
-0.3408609628677368,
-0.5040797591209412,
-0.407601922750473,
0.33175116777420044,
0.33299392461776733,
-0.3839929401874542,
-0.5448800325393677,
0.5321223139762878,
0.44077354669570923,
-0.2320152223110199,
0.7127017378807068,
0.6966120600700378,
-0.3117040693759918,
-0.6767167448997498,
-0.3622061312198639,
-0.2090723216533661,
-0.5177961587905884,
0.4512385427951813,
-0.3710562586784363,
-0.9056361317634583,
0.621284544467926,
-0.06355588883161545,
-0.1920190304517746,
0.47309422492980957,
0.6203703284263611,
0.10729072988033295,
0.7775129079818726,
0.8533329367637634,
-0.3048713207244873,
0.6321680545806885,
-0.040374740958213806,
0.21403928101062775,
-0.8777263164520264,
0.1673353761434555,
-0.7725274562835693,
-0.5713058710098267,
-0.6092031598091125,
-0.5006625652313232,
0.5418475866317749,
0.16424989700317383,
-0.21227185428142548,
0.2462388128042221,
-0.2959751486778259,
0.5999436378479004,
0.56564861536026,
0.02966243587434292,
0.3319123089313507,
0.34191834926605225,
0.039045706391334534,
-0.10419586300849915,
-0.587669312953949,
-0.011822582222521305,
0.9882204532623291,
0.13012216985225677,
0.9768047332763672,
0.3560989499092102,
0.6762353181838989,
0.14369618892669678,
0.1285652220249176,
-1.0038690567016602,
0.4875173270702362,
-0.5903028249740601,
-0.4343511462211609,
-0.4971785247325897,
-0.3133109509944916,
-0.7728676199913025,
0.234360009431839,
-0.039428502321243286,
-1.0050138235092163,
0.15901850163936615,
0.25276902318000793,
-0.7205209732055664,
0.06795834004878998,
-0.6700720191001892,
0.718510091304779,
-0.09685540199279785,
-0.5575297474861145,
-0.634381890296936,
-0.5071777701377869,
0.08045676350593567,
-0.47609376907348633,
0.05310647934675217,
-0.2665781080722809,
-0.2759504020214081,
0.7073829770088196,
-0.09130095690488815,
0.7953585982322693,
-0.3318031430244446,
-0.2829465866088867,
0.025539163500070572,
0.14245031774044037,
0.5243715047836304,
-0.008753116242587566,
-0.3899785876274109,
-0.14894840121269226,
0.23527853190898895,
-0.6263442039489746,
-0.6901260018348694,
0.8602950572967529,
-0.9826092720031738,
-0.7933028936386108,
-0.10260870307683945,
-0.4688008725643158,
-0.417238712310791,
0.30505505204200745,
-0.07351365685462952,
0.405582070350647,
-0.09637411683797836,
0.06857915967702866,
0.4124883711338043,
-0.2079187035560608,
0.8578551411628723,
0.46020108461380005,
-0.10802081972360611,
-0.272421658039093,
0.8402757048606873,
0.22026950120925903,
0.5754941701889038,
0.5384709239006042,
0.3633071482181549,
-0.06389053165912628,
-0.8009345531463623,
-0.48247548937797546,
0.34986209869384766,
-0.612267255783081,
-0.3180193305015564,
-0.3381839394569397,
-0.08160693198442459,
-0.17816010117530823,
-0.05867520719766617,
-0.565159022808075,
-0.8857977986335754,
-0.46234002709388733,
0.2745719254016876,
0.4262434244155884,
0.2371516078710556,
-0.17676863074302673,
0.5879794955253601,
-0.5617156624794006,
0.4997795820236206,
0.3541707694530487,
0.47020697593688965,
0.21242843568325043,
-0.6800036430358887,
-0.6647283434867859,
-0.12986460328102112,
-0.20251032710075378,
-0.25500258803367615,
0.19799233973026276,
0.652990460395813,
0.541130006313324,
0.31415531039237976,
0.027470072731375694,
0.6185812950134277,
-0.5095072984695435,
0.5054004192352295,
-0.12421504408121109,
-1.0314687490463257,
0.7356102466583252,
-0.5109875798225403,
0.38083502650260925,
0.621561586856842,
0.13995087146759033,
-0.05948944017291069,
-0.0002045284491032362,
-0.05828746780753136,
-0.6428156495094299,
1.037109613418579,
0.19084660708904266,
0.4720686674118042,
0.4612724184989929,
0.7005273103713989,
0.302971750497818,
0.0054496959783136845,
-0.6981897354125977,
-0.2023807018995285,
-0.10784231126308441,
-0.10655005276203156,
-0.045288510620594025,
-0.25231248140335083,
-0.38436824083328247,
-0.48819699883461,
0.6811025738716125,
-0.5439103841781616,
0.3417670726776123,
-0.1911081224679947,
-0.14676013588905334,
-0.33828336000442505,
0.3424219489097595,
0.8870307207107544,
0.49697208404541016,
-0.22662784159183502,
-0.05027150362730026,
0.2956225574016571,
-0.3545059263706207,
0.16384433209896088,
-0.06261174380779266,
-0.18914446234703064,
-0.33261480927467346,
0.06435669213533401,
0.8103615045547485,
0.2001691609621048,
-0.20360052585601807,
0.510124683380127,
0.32229378819465637,
0.01756921224296093,
0.2613103687763214,
0.34757083654403687,
-0.0019945111125707626,
0.28349125385284424,
0.34257519245147705,
0.04780786111950874,
-0.16839466989040375,
-0.32996582984924316,
-0.12731046974658966,
0.4654448628425598,
-0.14603528380393982,
-0.5132439136505127,
0.5343374609947205,
0.21471932530403137,
-0.12865212559700012,
0.08692051470279694,
0.30578121542930603,
0.04142565280199051,
0.41272810101509094,
0.7785114645957947,
1.1233314275741577,
-0.3657692074775696,
0.24442048370838165,
0.2879420816898346,
0.08599240332841873,
-0.11902855336666107,
0.16406495869159698,
-0.052307892590761185,
-0.6142716407775879,
-0.5548906922340393,
-0.7076018452644348,
-0.28433486819267273,
0.013063034974038601,
-0.5086801052093506,
0.361458420753479,
-0.7656839489936829,
-0.25544360280036926,
0.015859834849834442,
-0.14714020490646362,
-0.2935597896575928,
0.04904978349804878,
-0.05376638099551201,
0.8879339694976807,
-0.6176263689994812,
1.1051689386367798,
0.4517526924610138,
-0.2359350174665451,
-0.36958715319633484,
0.44872769713401794,
-0.31950128078460693,
-0.7861267328262329,
0.6992574334144592,
-0.19030481576919556,
-0.7889871597290039,
0.37539681792259216,
-0.4352579116821289,
-1.1551827192306519,
0.8613371253013611,
0.8429358601570129,
-0.2211371809244156,
-0.04764233157038689,
-0.0855330154299736,
0.6137111783027649,
-0.3954639136791229,
0.014724407345056534,
0.34272223711013794,
0.40466222167015076,
-0.13146735727787018,
-0.815211832523346,
0.0019459393806755543,
0.024485640227794647,
0.24613100290298462,
0.10904795676469803,
-1.0947028398513794,
0.6909772157669067,
-0.00034438614966347814,
-0.02437767945230007,
0.296161949634552,
0.5658256411552429,
-0.06475438922643661,
-0.23626534640789032,
0.410056471824646,
0.2623956501483917,
0.47053077816963196,
0.18048696219921112,
0.8119916915893555,
-0.38795918226242065,
0.43393632769584656,
0.7497398853302002,
-0.21027350425720215,
1.0333013534545898,
0.6636159420013428,
-0.08830700069665909,
0.6108217835426331,
0.3107370138168335,
0.2284121811389923,
0.911936342716217,
0.2470179796218872,
-0.35712572932243347,
-0.347655713558197,
-0.0794837549328804,
-0.35634735226631165,
0.5733428001403809,
0.1271897405385971,
-0.0915549173951149,
-0.26927506923675537,
0.009937621653079987,
-0.10039415955543518,
-0.26122111082077026,
-0.4821628928184509,
0.6409364342689514,
0.10709922015666962,
-0.5312463641166687,
0.8618311882019043,
0.17871275544166565,
0.6218975782394409,
-0.6039261817932129,
0.3881279230117798,
-0.4570353925228119,
0.3210926949977875,
-0.1111568734049797,
-0.08552432060241699,
0.0964306965470314,
0.022261330857872963,
-0.24046961963176727,
-0.05836069583892822,
0.6782553791999817,
-0.21678344905376434,
-0.6004858016967773,
0.4465996325016022,
0.6893728971481323,
-0.11789946258068085,
0.15786801278591156,
-0.6119575500488281,
-0.007190389558672905,
-0.2678019106388092,
-0.45924076437950134,
0.7903998494148254,
0.1487273871898651,
-0.16451199352741241,
0.6943669319152832,
0.46128761768341064,
0.1446412056684494,
-0.03632692992687225,
0.26190558075904846,
0.9835556149482727,
-0.6210949420928955,
-0.5267415642738342,
-0.8738670349121094,
0.5371644496917725,
0.40346527099609375,
-0.190604105591774,
0.34199681878089905,
0.47240176796913147,
0.4760989546775818,
-0.34162867069244385,
0.660469114780426,
0.32259270548820496,
0.4583970308303833,
-0.8889310956001282,
0.7090896368026733,
-0.9891520738601685,
0.12717880308628082,
-0.482258141040802,
-1.1510800123214722,
-0.5165820121765137,
0.5866369605064392,
-0.25620171427726746,
0.3726344704627991,
0.7289130687713623,
0.9239320158958435,
-0.6186108589172363,
-0.49064046144485474,
0.41302841901779175,
0.15747453272342682,
-0.1533105969429016,
0.5826534032821655,
0.578630268573761,
-0.37981730699539185,
0.28127673268318176,
-0.045084986835718155,
-0.11276307702064514,
-0.27431195974349976,
-1.1665518283843994,
-0.9203665852546692,
-0.26949530839920044,
-0.5029328465461731,
-0.16259360313415527,
0.2590990960597992,
0.8971757888793945,
0.9700116515159607,
-1.0365219116210938,
-0.20867261290550232,
0.3381756544113159,
0.10620325803756714,
-0.097285196185112,
-0.13167981803417206,
0.5981510877609253,
-0.16870687901973724,
-0.8563297390937805,
0.5982735753059387,
0.5945218205451965,
0.12312452495098114,
-0.3090619146823883,
0.039520759135484695,
-0.18363262712955475,
0.26996558904647827,
0.6646799445152283,
0.3824268579483032,
-0.7499008774757385,
-0.6445386409759521,
-0.13641609251499176,
-0.06337028741836548,
0.4028894007205963,
0.7672409415245056,
-0.6124134063720703,
0.18572509288787842,
0.4854246973991394,
0.7062088251113892,
0.8741697072982788,
0.32834315299987793,
0.3845657408237457,
-0.9805995225906372,
0.5452706217765808,
-0.08828825503587723,
-0.051196131855249405,
0.2499459832906723,
-0.26486286520957947,
0.41402187943458557,
0.0995786190032959,
-0.26595449447631836,
-0.7898808121681213,
0.23634763062000275,
-1.3344404697418213,
-0.12978865206241608,
1.1110010147094727,
-0.018177613615989685,
-0.31203219294548035,
0.19506512582302094,
-0.13476629555225372,
0.15877313911914825,
-0.5010839700698853,
0.806079626083374,
0.5137491226196289,
-0.34201371669769287,
-0.39756596088409424,
-0.5433167815208435,
0.7311614751815796,
0.631179690361023,
-0.8744621276855469,
0.08599194884300232,
0.15840193629264832,
0.2976030111312866,
-0.08098595589399338,
0.5275177955627441,
0.05009195953607559,
0.034883759915828705,
-0.4008946418762207,
-0.3744053840637207,
0.16171795129776,
-0.24849744141101837,
-0.5618298053741455,
0.10787507146596909,
0.45101505517959595,
-0.04176296293735504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01749v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01749v1
|
Differentially Private Synthetic Data via Foundation Model APIs 2: Text
| 2024-03-04T05:57:50 | 2024-03-04T05:57:50 |
Chulin Xie, Zinan Lin, Arturs Backurs, Sivakanth Gopi, Da Yu, Huseyin A Inan, Harsha Nori, Haotian Jiang, Huishuai Zhang, Yin Tat Lee, Bo Li, Sergey Yekhanin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text data has become extremely valuable due to the emergence of machine
learning algorithms that learn from it. A lot of high-quality text data
generated in the real world is private and therefore cannot be shared or used
freely due to privacy concerns. Generating synthetic replicas of private text
data with a formal privacy guarantee, i.e., differential privacy (DP), offers a
promising and scalable solution. However, existing methods necessitate DP
finetuning of large language models (LLMs) on private data to generate DP
synthetic data. This approach is not viable for proprietary LLMs (e.g.,
GPT-3.5) and also demands considerable computational resources for open-source
LLMs. Lin et al. (2024) recently introduced the Private Evolution (PE)
algorithm to generate DP synthetic images with only API access to diffusion
models. In this work, we propose an augmented PE algorithm, named Aug-PE, that
applies to the complex setting of text. We use API access to an LLM and
generate DP synthetic text without any model training. We conduct comprehensive
experiments on three benchmark datasets. Our results demonstrate that Aug-PE
produces DP synthetic text that yields competitive utility with the SOTA DP
finetuning baselines. This underscores the feasibility of relying solely on API
access of LLMs to produce high-quality DP synthetic texts, thereby facilitating
more accessible routes to privacy-preserving LLM applications. Our code and
data are available at https://github.com/AI-secure/aug-pe.
|
[
-0.22468578815460205,
-0.7747976183891296,
0.7154755592346191,
0.43068554997444153,
-0.14970368146896362,
0.2586190700531006,
-0.15116246044635773,
-0.6794013381004333,
0.07644364982843399,
0.6871399283409119,
-0.613774836063385,
-0.7291881442070007,
-0.5282823443412781,
0.3297290802001953,
-0.6008664965629578,
0.8670526742935181,
-0.0818953737616539,
-0.13962699472904205,
0.02340536192059517,
-0.0844845250248909,
0.2273624688386917,
-0.5300688743591309,
-0.3537357747554779,
0.010311017744243145,
0.15676933526992798,
-0.019684141501784325,
0.47378939390182495,
0.9719319343566895,
0.041395239531993866,
0.41590967774391174,
-0.26718869805336,
0.46739447116851807,
-0.6043524146080017,
0.21373659372329712,
-0.14528733491897583,
-0.2510427236557007,
-0.536835253238678,
0.12621350586414337,
0.9510749578475952,
0.6150161027908325,
0.3159308135509491,
-0.026045257225632668,
0.12971808016300201,
0.8604124188423157,
-0.4513692557811737,
0.3648452162742615,
-0.8065362572669983,
0.07138995826244354,
-0.17904992401599884,
-0.018116507679224014,
-0.35106998682022095,
-0.4556845724582672,
0.3647986650466919,
-0.5139942765235901,
0.23092176020145416,
-0.169204980134964,
0.6155049204826355,
0.1855834573507309,
-0.11323884129524231,
-0.13537631928920746,
-0.6668359637260437,
0.6133289933204651,
-0.5686389803886414,
0.4279852509498596,
0.35475462675094604,
0.040432099252939224,
-0.21334825456142426,
-0.7162865996360779,
-0.6305800676345825,
-0.22548165917396545,
-0.07862566411495209,
-0.11468534171581268,
-0.030376283451914787,
0.0016439213650301099,
-0.05518850311636925,
0.8426676988601685,
-0.14701727032661438,
0.1712028980255127,
-0.18530145287513733,
-0.14891323447227478,
0.9425088167190552,
0.06220683455467224,
0.1484835296869278,
0.055429987609386444,
-0.2563149333000183,
0.06717714667320251,
-0.723110556602478,
-0.031936176121234894,
0.925616443157196,
0.20198075473308563,
-0.3604772090911865,
0.6434571146965027,
-0.282084584236145,
0.3269309997558594,
0.17453941702842712,
-0.0032346572261303663,
0.39821261167526245,
-0.1865864098072052,
-0.16840125620365143,
-0.0347336120903492,
0.9134240746498108,
0.06369008123874664,
0.03985949978232384,
-0.32841411232948303,
-0.24916274845600128,
0.05453457683324814,
-0.1295611709356308,
-0.7368029356002808,
-0.22467201948165894,
0.23865024745464325,
-0.22029370069503784,
-0.5523410439491272,
-0.31701087951660156,
-1.1151740550994873,
-0.5950537919998169,
-0.4114406406879425,
0.3362320065498352,
-0.16215136647224426,
-0.2644430100917816,
0.1165844053030014,
0.06019439548254013,
-0.23973597586154938,
0.06522877514362335,
-0.8610942959785461,
0.4715935289859772,
0.5109192132949829,
0.9039117097854614,
-0.27627769112586975,
-0.14214816689491272,
-0.3845899999141693,
0.14840269088745117,
-0.2946459949016571,
0.4552217423915863,
-0.5557001829147339,
-0.6614433526992798,
-0.028432492166757584,
0.16576240956783295,
0.30762696266174316,
-0.36793020367622375,
0.3778320848941803,
-0.4819037914276123,
0.25468313694000244,
0.09025994688272476,
-0.4815606474876404,
-0.05891187861561775,
0.05726058781147003,
-0.6280675530433655,
0.768297553062439,
0.04311884567141533,
-0.6784828305244446,
-0.05423824116587639,
-0.8327413201332092,
-0.43562909960746765,
-0.12012379616498947,
-0.4181136190891266,
-0.6503872275352478,
-0.010154216550290585,
0.32284149527549744,
0.4556550979614258,
0.12909898161888123,
0.1615993231534958,
-0.4582088589668274,
-0.18431197106838226,
0.2578112781047821,
-0.5935889482498169,
0.756493091583252,
0.10159759223461151,
-0.6757836937904358,
-0.29909202456474304,
-1.2772778272628784,
-0.21024221181869507,
0.12816405296325684,
-0.45934736728668213,
-0.5985553860664368,
-0.10320834070444107,
-0.2508905827999115,
-0.20551158487796783,
0.4556593894958496,
-0.6690496802330017,
0.2527387738227844,
-0.9412218928337097,
0.4702655076980591,
1.2371653318405151,
0.030255474150180817,
0.9384584426879883,
-0.1037234365940094,
0.3453825116157532,
-0.22305510938167572,
0.03849855437874794,
-0.15329572558403015,
-0.6926811933517456,
-0.3344263434410095,
-0.622398853302002,
0.43605291843414307,
0.4312182664871216,
-0.3042382597923279,
0.45294633507728577,
-0.1093316376209259,
-0.41886988282203674,
-0.4283096194267273,
-0.07488661259412766,
0.4623807966709137,
0.5536623001098633,
0.18823866546154022,
-0.10490157455205917,
-0.41975098848342896,
-0.8595013618469238,
-0.15518903732299805,
0.22762151062488556,
0.10175742208957672,
0.7344045042991638,
0.20492535829544067,
-0.48272624611854553,
0.8800991177558899,
-0.5095405578613281,
-0.1739552915096283,
0.2476094663143158,
0.10341554880142212,
-0.00368228810839355,
0.6880064010620117,
0.6646523475646973,
-0.9128872156143188,
-0.6830412745475769,
-0.044373899698257446,
-0.5133969187736511,
-0.5316163301467896,
-0.0005227004876360297,
-0.5497519373893738,
0.3311159908771515,
-0.0082849757745862,
-0.4759315848350525,
0.4077128767967224,
1.103413462638855,
-0.32177719473838806,
0.364927738904953,
-0.3037494122982025,
0.15953923761844635,
-1.125482201576233,
0.01762564480304718,
0.010791737586259842,
-0.5030463933944702,
-0.4646837115287781,
0.22531579434871674,
-0.12161365896463394,
-0.32669398188591003,
-0.569317638874054,
0.8507593274116516,
-0.5013089179992676,
-0.07263652235269547,
-0.19766302406787872,
-0.1304652988910675,
0.09555581957101822,
0.33462074398994446,
0.23840704560279846,
0.8745436072349548,
0.7177884578704834,
-0.7394376397132874,
-0.07175857573747635,
0.36472153663635254,
0.06158161908388138,
0.1051345020532608,
-0.4011966586112976,
0.26403385400772095,
-0.08043981343507767,
0.1996821165084839,
-0.770970344543457,
-0.23907755315303802,
0.4831799566745758,
-0.16859577596187592,
0.3869565725326538,
-0.29354116320610046,
-0.4555984437465668,
0.13135012984275818,
-0.503042995929718,
0.2794538736343384,
0.860643208026886,
-0.8119246363639832,
0.6501203179359436,
0.6413006782531738,
-0.3615816533565521,
-0.6711462736129761,
-0.937189519405365,
-0.10932784527540207,
-0.10002486407756805,
-0.6945402026176453,
0.7580280900001526,
-0.3188624382019043,
-0.19640710949897766,
0.07953262329101562,
-0.048552416265010834,
-0.42832911014556885,
-0.02659793384373188,
0.41800209879875183,
0.09477262943983078,
-0.024245617911219597,
-0.2800053656101227,
0.7393434047698975,
-0.17627137899398804,
-0.07813506573438644,
-0.28184133768081665,
0.4377555847167969,
-0.0016325039323419333,
-0.06180012226104736,
-0.7257221937179565,
0.3086255192756653,
0.5404492616653442,
-0.11765296012163162,
0.7727914452552795,
0.1577262431383133,
-0.34635093808174133,
-0.39340901374816895,
-0.2451568841934204,
-0.09550683945417404,
-0.5733259320259094,
-0.06198799982666969,
-0.27649274468421936,
-0.8538037538528442,
0.5319589972496033,
-0.37806814908981323,
0.267738938331604,
0.31638815999031067,
0.6602738499641418,
0.3033735454082489,
1.1089210510253906,
0.7517704963684082,
0.09260910004377365,
0.48757004737854004,
-0.5278623104095459,
0.09874709695577621,
-0.5167464017868042,
-0.07489793747663498,
-0.403386652469635,
-0.4106464684009552,
-0.908576488494873,
-0.16825878620147705,
0.22660495340824127,
-0.04198379069566727,
-0.11628208309412003,
0.2078717201948166,
-0.7947268486022949,
0.6700998544692993,
0.3630882203578949,
0.303011417388916,
0.6728479862213135,
0.29351478815078735,
-0.02616216242313385,
-0.17883217334747314,
-0.03461689502000809,
-0.6298688650131226,
1.2374446392059326,
0.4680069088935852,
0.7819169759750366,
-0.042419593781232834,
1.1662288904190063,
0.26825734972953796,
0.30721887946128845,
-0.20851577818393707,
0.6507006287574768,
-0.5205637216567993,
-0.4873483180999756,
-0.11831352859735489,
-0.5255057215690613,
-0.667186975479126,
0.05391184985637665,
-0.2355770617723465,
-0.6868040561676025,
0.4814770817756653,
0.20739471912384033,
-0.07097510993480682,
0.14653941988945007,
-0.861052930355072,
0.4914679229259491,
-0.020742643624544144,
-0.6998688578605652,
0.06316080689430237,
-0.41483739018440247,
0.47144433856010437,
-0.4917629361152649,
0.26714029908180237,
-0.13786569237709045,
-0.17129085958003998,
0.3877001702785492,
-0.3939054012298584,
0.9563451409339905,
-0.36519181728363037,
-0.20901578664779663,
0.22009247541427612,
0.21340250968933105,
0.6815680265426636,
0.6128538250923157,
-0.1886678785085678,
0.44395411014556885,
-0.18418259918689728,
-0.19315235316753387,
-0.2570442259311676,
1.1951078176498413,
-0.9156152009963989,
-0.5465801358222961,
-0.28562188148498535,
-0.36054158210754395,
-0.14407087862491608,
0.40821316838264465,
0.1548788845539093,
0.24262207746505737,
0.10777659714221954,
0.10738053917884827,
0.6509965062141418,
-0.4600251615047455,
0.2669525742530823,
0.7199642658233643,
-0.1071440652012825,
-0.22201861441135406,
0.7579734325408936,
0.12329354137182236,
0.034430135041475296,
0.37211132049560547,
0.5223676562309265,
-0.7644204497337341,
-0.903599202632904,
-0.5171939730644226,
0.19814833998680115,
-0.39652392268180847,
-0.07745283097028732,
-0.9378239512443542,
-0.3716053068637848,
-0.36625781655311584,
-0.1748606562614441,
-0.6801685094833374,
-0.622869074344635,
-0.37170714139938354,
-0.12802854180335999,
0.5464305877685547,
0.4460863769054413,
-0.4611872136592865,
-0.022542353719472885,
-0.886718213558197,
0.5284172296524048,
0.1605442315340042,
0.5537492036819458,
-0.30448317527770996,
-0.19735996425151825,
0.22732014954090118,
0.3543813228607178,
-0.3803470730781555,
-0.7469039559364319,
0.4630146622657776,
0.22207318246364594,
0.4022071361541748,
-0.020415134727954865,
0.40547144412994385,
0.4473836123943329,
-0.7732279896736145,
0.886658251285553,
-0.2540113925933838,
-1.001826286315918,
0.31318220496177673,
-0.49066781997680664,
-0.4256323277950287,
0.41234302520751953,
0.43476518988609314,
0.2894264757633209,
-0.715325653553009,
-0.5955344438552856,
-0.9138133525848389,
0.5510582327842712,
0.5168905854225159,
0.6611601710319519,
0.22838467359542847,
0.6350111365318298,
0.6248507499694824,
0.30443841218948364,
-1.0537140369415283,
-0.40273934602737427,
-0.09241396933794022,
-0.43534529209136963,
0.25335943698883057,
-0.0007184785790741444,
-0.29910722374916077,
-0.1140301302075386,
0.6992996335029602,
0.12628476321697235,
0.18174931406974792,
0.3353879451751709,
0.2394772320985794,
0.06317921727895737,
0.19624817371368408,
0.390268474817276,
0.4970192015171051,
-0.050210196524858475,
-0.057206228375434875,
-0.201868936419487,
-0.5899460911750793,
0.29800793528556824,
0.6672147512435913,
-0.53435218334198,
0.05010498687624931,
-0.3041955530643463,
0.36445918679237366,
-0.06530272215604782,
-0.7400240302085876,
0.5497046113014221,
-0.12475893646478653,
-0.422017902135849,
-0.3355042338371277,
0.01830149069428444,
-0.07436040788888931,
0.5343673825263977,
0.05339030548930168,
0.044948261231184006,
0.3020487427711487,
-0.1983824372291565,
0.2437523752450943,
0.16042260825634003,
0.09494542330503464,
-0.5198233127593994,
0.9069082140922546,
0.40523484349250793,
-0.3624245226383209,
0.15786877274513245,
-0.26926445960998535,
-0.10762010514736176,
0.14892375469207764,
0.4702381491661072,
0.8567742109298706,
-0.1038919985294342,
0.2578432857990265,
-0.2005884051322937,
-0.12584556639194489,
-0.1594865471124649,
0.23166026175022125,
-0.08886224776506424,
-0.5405557751655579,
-0.4359780251979828,
-0.7803138494491577,
-0.3366287648677826,
0.5542492866516113,
-0.07917335629463196,
0.22559507191181183,
-0.7499021887779236,
0.10660582035779953,
-0.1363517791032791,
-0.11739040911197662,
-0.41903916001319885,
0.11883549392223358,
0.13666307926177979,
0.6316723823547363,
-0.6309601664543152,
0.6408953666687012,
0.3945966362953186,
-0.17796581983566284,
-0.5829390287399292,
0.09238141775131226,
-0.1153629943728447,
-0.8156553506851196,
0.4763869345188141,
0.11730683594942093,
-0.11501399427652359,
0.24692508578300476,
-0.4830220341682434,
-0.570068895816803,
0.9412021636962891,
0.6609663963317871,
-0.8446967601776123,
-0.10642217844724655,
0.31773898005485535,
0.6980940699577332,
-0.1897364854812622,
-0.4578550457954407,
0.12489362806081772,
0.31738024950027466,
-0.23918426036834717,
-0.543921709060669,
-0.015179281122982502,
-0.04906678572297096,
-0.144011989235878,
0.0901411920785904,
-0.5536311864852905,
0.8084092140197754,
0.22105637192726135,
-0.3350175619125366,
0.439551442861557,
0.2556222677230835,
0.427484929561615,
0.6164657473564148,
0.3233453333377838,
0.6571251153945923,
0.596420407295227,
0.11255836486816406,
0.9621910452842712,
-0.5934692025184631,
0.3670375347137451,
0.7160027623176575,
-0.24045419692993164,
0.6618684530258179,
0.3796663284301758,
-0.1335763782262802,
0.4363706111907959,
0.5545409321784973,
0.10662560164928436,
0.8865894079208374,
0.17706064879894257,
-0.4219653010368347,
0.22556565701961517,
0.1289183646440506,
-0.5953190326690674,
0.2673545777797699,
0.08861362934112549,
-0.7952629327774048,
-0.0013215444050729275,
-0.15463584661483765,
-0.1206434816122055,
0.5658679604530334,
-0.24866990745067596,
0.6140560507774353,
0.006275391671806574,
-0.05506196990609169,
0.4335034191608429,
0.22261159121990204,
0.8463912010192871,
-0.5029026865959167,
-0.10259624570608139,
-0.2149948626756668,
0.33048108220100403,
-0.1500067561864853,
-0.6172742247581482,
0.47265625,
0.30144330859184265,
-0.17375734448432922,
-0.40716996788978577,
0.6125115752220154,
-0.4107525944709778,
-0.4944137632846832,
0.13601164519786835,
0.3716900646686554,
0.15031270682811737,
0.01874302700161934,
-0.803209125995636,
0.002147113671526313,
-0.15550962090492249,
-0.479904443025589,
0.4931708872318268,
0.5159230828285217,
0.12279916554689407,
0.3483453094959259,
0.9087866544723511,
0.1848185658454895,
0.24504750967025757,
-0.05622057244181633,
1.0958982706069946,
-0.2543070614337921,
-0.9225930571556091,
-1.0652652978897095,
0.6310245990753174,
-0.12237802147865295,
-0.08112245798110962,
0.6028954982757568,
0.6123993992805481,
0.8006371855735779,
-0.1927536427974701,
1.0052021741867065,
0.13967856764793396,
0.7535094022750854,
-0.7171822190284729,
0.9245548248291016,
-0.5790637135505676,
0.4454953372478485,
-0.31391969323158264,
-0.9202589392662048,
-0.1696048229932785,
0.5554913878440857,
-0.33627423644065857,
-0.304913729429245,
0.30368369817733765,
0.8630834221839905,
-0.2946816384792328,
0.09282276779413223,
0.014466911554336548,
0.25924763083457947,
0.490121990442276,
0.1787387579679489,
0.7899520993232727,
-0.4413558840751648,
0.45430606603622437,
-0.6054306626319885,
-0.4158134460449219,
0.15282350778579712,
-1.075478196144104,
-0.8234545588493347,
-0.5752270817756653,
-0.34031182527542114,
-0.4075652062892914,
0.1742333322763443,
0.6456505060195923,
0.8243628740310669,
-0.4578125476837158,
0.23151099681854248,
-0.7570977807044983,
-0.05374304950237274,
0.15941201150417328,
-0.26396164298057556,
0.40408438444137573,
0.12031637132167816,
-1.2791692018508911,
0.5291451215744019,
0.32178300619125366,
0.6586220264434814,
-0.5022311210632324,
-0.19843867421150208,
0.2334498167037964,
0.08204637467861176,
0.40166589617729187,
0.3104187846183777,
-0.5005477666854858,
-0.08077934384346008,
-0.08971390128135681,
0.08380936086177826,
-0.029133567586541176,
0.6253747344017029,
-0.6104504466056824,
0.4439314007759094,
0.5800869464874268,
1.1173171997070312,
0.5215868949890137,
0.11226023733615875,
0.6153286695480347,
-1.0399072170257568,
0.5405967235565186,
0.4132033884525299,
0.2027386873960495,
0.269738107919693,
-0.8230802416801453,
0.2509738802909851,
0.4495379328727722,
-0.7129119634628296,
-1.0721789598464966,
0.293556272983551,
-0.8400934338569641,
-0.21416984498500824,
1.1085277795791626,
-0.3955148458480835,
-0.3631473481655121,
0.13098780810832977,
-0.31994152069091797,
0.010587962344288826,
-0.6747993230819702,
1.118384838104248,
0.2875112295150757,
-0.24412031471729279,
-0.00847549270838499,
-0.0944991260766983,
0.6252917647361755,
-0.1913752555847168,
-0.7067385315895081,
0.21966060996055603,
0.48481500148773193,
0.3475295305252075,
0.08579909056425095,
0.8156294822692871,
-0.47602957487106323,
-0.17607258260250092,
0.024251090362668037,
-0.5387686491012573,
-0.41224953532218933,
-0.20516835153102875,
-0.20029763877391815,
0.12140775471925735,
-0.1736438125371933,
-0.31728076934814453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01748v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01748v3
|
NeuSpeech: Decode Neural signal as Speech
| 2024-03-04T05:55:01 | 2024-06-03T16:58:04 |
Yiqian Yang, Yiqun Duan, Qiang Zhang, Hyejeong Jo, Jinni Zhou, Won Hee Lee, Renjing Xu, Hui Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Decoding language from brain dynamics is an important open direction in the
realm of brain-computer interface (BCI), especially considering the rapid
growth of large language models. Compared to invasive-based signals which
require electrode implantation surgery, non-invasive neural signals (e.g. EEG,
MEG) have attracted increasing attention considering their safety and
generality. However, the exploration is not adequate in three aspects: 1)
previous methods mainly focus on EEG but none of the previous works address
this problem on MEG with better signal quality; 2) prior works have
predominantly used $``teacher-forcing"$ during generative decoding, which is
impractical; 3) prior works are mostly $``BART-based"$ not fully
auto-regressive, which performs better in other sequence tasks. In this paper,
we explore the brain-to-text translation of MEG signals in a speech-decoding
formation. Here we are the first to investigate a cross-attention-based
``whisper" model for generating text directly from MEG signals without teacher
forcing. Our model achieves impressive BLEU-1 scores of 60.30 and 52.89 without
pretraining $\&$ teacher-forcing on two major datasets ($\textit{GWilliams}$
and $\textit{Schoffelen}$). This paper conducts a comprehensive review to
understand how speech decoding formation performs on the neural decoding tasks,
including pretraining initialization, training $\&$ evaluation set splitting,
augmentation, and scaling law. Code is available at
https://github.com/NeuSpeech/NeuSpeech1$.
|
[
-0.17949630320072174,
-1.0374723672866821,
0.31031534075737,
0.3269746005535126,
-0.44741255044937134,
-0.2056303769350052,
-0.29021987318992615,
-0.3445383310317993,
0.48457252979278564,
0.2538387179374695,
-0.649311900138855,
-0.5303905606269836,
-0.7617934346199036,
0.09855920821428299,
-0.503283679485321,
0.7840024828910828,
0.23162025213241577,
0.3954934775829315,
-0.2634015679359436,
0.28319528698921204,
-0.7413344979286194,
-0.6402729749679565,
-0.567045271396637,
-0.27753886580467224,
0.20263971388339996,
0.2698154151439667,
0.2508389353752136,
0.46157798171043396,
-0.0403594896197319,
0.17120592296123505,
-0.37801870703697205,
0.18674200773239136,
-0.3024265766143799,
0.17711105942726135,
0.05310502648353577,
-0.3355453908443451,
-0.4873414635658264,
-0.028038514778017998,
0.8187907934188843,
0.8666650056838989,
-0.4145583212375641,
0.0032949643209576607,
0.39520537853240967,
0.3344765603542328,
-0.6355496048927307,
0.2220814973115921,
-0.48945942521095276,
-0.0964457169175148,
-0.1794992834329605,
-0.1658967286348343,
-0.8411566615104675,
-0.30449894070625305,
0.23034034669399261,
-0.38270998001098633,
0.026216838508844376,
-0.08737059682607651,
0.7901881337165833,
-0.014221861027181149,
-0.26218751072883606,
-0.1567513793706894,
-0.5587941408157349,
0.9185060858726501,
-0.8001096844673157,
0.44382813572883606,
0.6684191823005676,
-0.06636685878038406,
-0.23939917981624603,
-0.644993782043457,
-0.6226027011871338,
-0.25016534328460693,
-0.01545585598796606,
0.17287038266658783,
-0.3147970736026764,
0.09997231513261795,
0.2710140645503998,
-0.07529175281524658,
-0.48045989871025085,
0.05433589220046997,
-0.21625131368637085,
-0.1866205632686615,
0.30274128913879395,
0.22080591320991516,
0.562605619430542,
-0.2917504608631134,
-0.07899262011051178,
-0.22890248894691467,
-0.5645619034767151,
-0.13162627816200256,
0.36437833309173584,
0.23786284029483795,
-0.4672161042690277,
0.29253333806991577,
-0.10430698841810226,
0.6625401377677917,
-0.03908682242035866,
0.21241942048072815,
0.38625210523605347,
-0.02575891837477684,
-0.024195052683353424,
0.20516906678676605,
0.7585258483886719,
0.23776784539222717,
0.2689976692199707,
-0.25531554222106934,
-0.00014769379049539566,
0.15822745859622955,
0.34353703260421753,
-0.6705905199050903,
-0.23479534685611725,
0.0413581021130085,
-0.5565889477729797,
-0.0033578104339540005,
-0.31582245230674744,
-0.7423155903816223,
0.01699703559279442,
-0.43133506178855896,
0.5084584355354309,
-0.7506167888641357,
-0.6400729417800903,
-0.0395064651966095,
0.043331123888492584,
0.4535231590270996,
0.14798271656036377,
-1.139046311378479,
0.5271248817443848,
0.5361159443855286,
0.8115131258964539,
0.0098135219886899,
-0.6010003089904785,
-0.5133671760559082,
-0.13109804689884186,
-0.487659215927124,
0.7397156357765198,
-0.375735342502594,
-0.484345406293869,
0.007256133947521448,
-0.07907664030790329,
-0.3226090967655182,
-0.4448842406272888,
0.41399237513542175,
-0.29868263006210327,
0.016608495265245438,
-0.23655125498771667,
-0.6378108859062195,
-0.2307365983724594,
-0.13045309484004974,
-0.3287126421928406,
0.5044239163398743,
-0.17228101193904877,
-0.54224693775177,
0.16739019751548767,
-0.6469319462776184,
-0.7634325623512268,
0.12262265384197235,
0.024348756298422813,
-0.19392015039920807,
0.3824602961540222,
0.4427015781402588,
0.30195358395576477,
-0.2484462857246399,
0.09238708764314651,
-0.1832384169101715,
-0.3524690568447113,
0.2963707447052002,
-0.6477661728858948,
0.8173725008964539,
-0.04745429381728172,
-0.42154255509376526,
-0.26757046580314636,
-0.4790535271167755,
0.3053567707538605,
0.1377275437116623,
0.03944242745637894,
-0.11364395916461945,
0.2635945677757263,
0.008190681226551533,
-0.1714157611131668,
-0.008630380034446716,
-0.7775217890739441,
-0.17556042969226837,
-0.7195637226104736,
0.6564798951148987,
0.3161803185939789,
0.15801386535167694,
0.5534314513206482,
-0.017925849184393883,
0.22758270800113678,
-0.10187648981809616,
0.19633075594902039,
-0.3950486183166504,
-0.5976923108100891,
-0.7859897017478943,
-0.06953952461481094,
0.582106351852417,
0.564337968826294,
-0.5337297320365906,
0.19182728230953217,
-0.3909347653388977,
-0.46136659383773804,
-0.8046753406524658,
-0.32369720935821533,
0.2855740189552307,
0.722474217414856,
0.5982984304428101,
-0.21046122908592224,
-0.36546725034713745,
-0.9347508549690247,
-0.0968068540096283,
-0.04841310903429985,
0.18594329059123993,
0.04562718793749809,
0.11702729016542435,
-0.12114845961332321,
0.5966050624847412,
-0.311723917722702,
0.03799912706017494,
-0.1561913639307022,
0.27029138803482056,
0.2759685516357422,
0.6693023443222046,
0.15680371224880219,
-0.3565181493759155,
-0.21397440135478973,
-0.06961305439472198,
-0.7270916104316711,
-0.09104043990373611,
0.09430909156799316,
-0.09759724885225296,
0.5395876169204712,
0.5283071994781494,
-0.8390605449676514,
0.5624040961265564,
0.5888011455535889,
-0.04577576741576195,
0.2693108320236206,
-0.24087972939014435,
0.14678336679935455,
-0.905399739742279,
0.07495588809251785,
-0.37630051374435425,
0.027433037757873535,
-0.8894776701927185,
-0.0591067336499691,
0.20020081102848053,
-0.15312643349170685,
-0.40718841552734375,
0.2772003412246704,
-0.690864086151123,
0.25371167063713074,
-0.6906391382217407,
0.11004311591386795,
-0.16993874311447144,
0.47868943214416504,
0.3204202651977539,
0.25608009099960327,
0.8228078484535217,
-0.6652514338493347,
-0.027606956660747528,
0.4656153619289398,
-0.11695001274347305,
0.46837368607521057,
-0.5761699080467224,
0.677681565284729,
-0.07104846835136414,
-0.01045147143304348,
-0.7794039249420166,
0.09092193096876144,
0.23756110668182373,
-0.9396967887878418,
0.47272637486457825,
-0.3266122043132782,
-0.6398820877075195,
0.08058007061481476,
0.17828451097011566,
0.4681949019432068,
0.8897379636764526,
-0.7171722650527954,
0.6779690980911255,
0.653295636177063,
-0.22672763466835022,
-0.48181799054145813,
-0.9262360334396362,
0.3131960928440094,
0.26344865560531616,
-0.5417777895927429,
0.07191234081983566,
0.0008898979867808521,
0.17679299414157867,
-0.07590469717979431,
-0.14325237274169922,
-0.029145559296011925,
-0.26298144459724426,
0.44292473793029785,
0.40463823080062866,
-0.08668158203363419,
0.03165849670767784,
0.5130429863929749,
-0.28314870595932007,
0.35127800703048706,
-0.15790767967700958,
0.7133342027664185,
0.19984722137451172,
-0.16036061942577362,
-0.48506784439086914,
0.6162449717521667,
0.32841140031814575,
-0.3067423105239868,
0.605685830116272,
0.4654432535171509,
-0.5338828563690186,
-0.4975365400314331,
-0.41493692994117737,
-0.5883028507232666,
-0.46842578053474426,
0.2394266426563263,
-0.2262389361858368,
-0.6955496668815613,
0.10671340674161911,
-0.10132169723510742,
-0.18558883666992188,
0.2864682972431183,
0.4621814787387848,
-0.15706320106983185,
1.068045735359192,
0.3984382450580597,
-0.005971087608486414,
0.18922755122184753,
-0.16319964826107025,
0.2633202075958252,
-0.7699944376945496,
-0.4516998529434204,
-0.2871229350566864,
-0.26577550172805786,
-0.21027855575084686,
-0.13044695556163788,
0.22434891760349274,
-0.020125625655055046,
0.3468378782272339,
0.3561131954193115,
-0.7404811978340149,
0.3578500747680664,
0.39381980895996094,
0.021773653104901314,
-0.12182418256998062,
0.13364112377166748,
-0.11898599565029144,
-0.2786424458026886,
-0.8049890995025635,
-0.23007196187973022,
1.0346184968948364,
0.15649013221263885,
0.6631227731704712,
-0.06634940207004547,
0.7911310195922852,
-0.12371322512626648,
0.33345964550971985,
-0.6329829096794128,
0.8576449751853943,
-0.20961719751358032,
-0.3098400831222534,
-0.193716898560524,
-0.520025908946991,
-1.2701036930084229,
0.21260908246040344,
-0.5541929006576538,
-0.7222520112991333,
0.2824510633945465,
0.02474069409072399,
-0.1918773502111435,
0.2364751696586609,
-1.0543665885925293,
0.5030595660209656,
0.11292922496795654,
-0.1974794715642929,
-0.48027610778808594,
-0.5262849926948547,
0.11138663440942764,
0.15564438700675964,
0.04538460075855255,
-0.02905089408159256,
-0.0007906168466433883,
0.7024412155151367,
-0.21111418306827545,
0.7861915230751038,
-0.4729239344596863,
-0.023030273616313934,
0.3665522038936615,
0.2223692685365677,
0.2946772575378418,
0.08968368172645569,
0.1502869427204132,
0.5921525359153748,
0.1500081568956375,
-0.31590354442596436,
-0.5964926481246948,
0.8144146203994751,
-0.6822302937507629,
-0.41342347860336304,
-0.32162708044052124,
-0.3616516590118408,
-0.20965471863746643,
0.15897521376609802,
0.6377127766609192,
0.5664043426513672,
-0.28198423981666565,
-0.12243208289146423,
0.7664759755134583,
-0.022286375984549522,
0.8727717995643616,
0.44602590799331665,
-0.05242808908224106,
-0.7863293290138245,
1.1183464527130127,
0.37084656953811646,
-0.024302568286657333,
0.4246918857097626,
-0.0018893721280619502,
-0.25540420413017273,
-0.8261944651603699,
-0.35888993740081787,
0.22757257521152496,
-0.3701545298099518,
-0.12738516926765442,
-0.7110740542411804,
-0.3566279113292694,
-0.43083998560905457,
0.19227029383182526,
-0.3675687909126282,
-0.052431460469961166,
-0.34773918986320496,
0.006613138597458601,
0.06527456641197205,
0.5198847651481628,
-0.23014789819717407,
0.4592646062374115,
-0.9028368592262268,
0.29816699028015137,
0.3436840772628784,
0.12413422018289566,
0.12360251694917679,
-0.3705401122570038,
-0.33530619740486145,
0.08563152700662613,
0.025420332327485085,
-1.262308955192566,
0.6284768581390381,
-0.05468323826789856,
0.4633573591709137,
-0.05930979922413826,
0.05783398449420929,
0.4465877413749695,
-0.6823010444641113,
0.688788890838623,
0.21643200516700745,
-1.3000562191009521,
0.6571913957595825,
-0.16924786567687988,
0.45518913865089417,
0.3379723131656647,
0.0686090886592865,
-0.5211442708969116,
-0.16571764647960663,
-0.7351670265197754,
-0.9376887083053589,
0.8378191590309143,
0.2887387275695801,
0.6131739616394043,
-0.3248201012611389,
0.47687259316444397,
0.08757194131612778,
0.07820922881364822,
-0.4219360649585724,
-0.24491655826568604,
-0.2637862265110016,
-0.05172580108046532,
-0.07776080816984177,
-0.2965482771396637,
0.04685123637318611,
-0.4401336908340454,
0.44464996457099915,
0.10761987417936325,
0.5337866544723511,
0.39997756481170654,
-0.229135662317276,
0.12064816802740097,
0.24258486926555634,
0.5077040791511536,
0.19549104571342468,
-0.01698031648993492,
0.02031976729631424,
0.5708202719688416,
-0.849806010723114,
0.0011688581435009837,
0.238268181681633,
-0.06373045593500137,
0.25064000487327576,
0.3064127564430237,
0.9214892983436584,
0.06246816739439964,
-0.4100988805294037,
0.7573469877243042,
-0.10207320004701614,
-0.46150708198547363,
-0.34876105189323425,
-0.08371279388666153,
0.0828026607632637,
0.049950145184993744,
0.1822662502527237,
0.039286062121391296,
0.04042419046163559,
-0.013511543162167072,
0.094023197889328,
0.3260708749294281,
-0.2537594735622406,
-0.5922235250473022,
0.47951769828796387,
0.21016155183315277,
-0.45520371198654175,
1.0879533290863037,
-0.198794424533844,
-0.013997179456055164,
0.23493273556232452,
0.8086763024330139,
1.1346641778945923,
-0.4651947021484375,
0.14052814245224,
0.43620914220809937,
0.5799394249916077,
0.08971088379621506,
0.607615053653717,
-0.17206014692783356,
-0.6229857802391052,
-0.862812876701355,
-0.4137669503688812,
-0.4724326729774475,
0.16874922811985016,
-0.5481324791908264,
0.28800907731056213,
-0.6693436503410339,
-0.4387255311012268,
-0.04662836715579033,
-0.44061779975891113,
-0.24677051603794098,
0.2974751591682434,
0.3881489634513855,
0.7276918292045593,
-0.4918769598007202,
0.8482226729393005,
0.6101371049880981,
0.0946592390537262,
-0.8608369827270508,
0.1415763795375824,
-0.31684261560440063,
-0.5704777836799622,
0.37414276599884033,
0.1294880360364914,
-0.34369251132011414,
0.25579893589019775,
-0.6746516823768616,
-0.6580082178115845,
0.5550732016563416,
0.8540569543838501,
-0.4558224678039551,
-0.044400036334991455,
0.010486404411494732,
0.29777196049690247,
-0.1607699990272522,
0.389374703168869,
0.33548665046691895,
0.38080909848213196,
-0.393809050321579,
-0.7668455243110657,
-0.1090012937784195,
-0.49775296449661255,
-0.18276527523994446,
0.3922143876552582,
-0.4245423674583435,
0.7197749018669128,
-0.032175399363040924,
-0.4778401553630829,
-0.023899586871266365,
0.7002130746841431,
-0.07595793157815933,
0.2642178237438202,
0.34920021891593933,
0.6630216240882874,
0.41415080428123474,
-0.12043218314647675,
0.8930974006652832,
-0.28162622451782227,
0.05117218941450119,
0.951027512550354,
0.19866108894348145,
1.2561439275741577,
0.5569759607315063,
0.0665043368935585,
0.6686229705810547,
0.25797581672668457,
0.06307079643011093,
0.561765193939209,
0.07189691066741943,
-0.20098130404949188,
-0.3208538591861725,
0.09239557385444641,
-0.22499443590641022,
0.5290205478668213,
0.4124617874622345,
-0.1611718237400055,
-0.178256556391716,
0.13338078558444977,
-0.030291931703686714,
0.13101309537887573,
-0.18266475200653076,
0.7811872959136963,
0.37605905532836914,
-0.57735276222229,
0.780185878276825,
-0.13337551057338715,
0.575829029083252,
-0.7008777260780334,
-0.30232933163642883,
0.018751904368400574,
-0.22508713603019714,
-0.14656022191047668,
-0.4499833583831787,
0.2700672745704651,
-0.19424450397491455,
-0.2030501663684845,
-0.11959224194288254,
0.6941801905632019,
-0.3697985112667084,
0.0807851031422615,
0.410045862197876,
0.5735625624656677,
0.27945762872695923,
-0.04993494600057602,
-0.2857287526130676,
0.07873906195163727,
-0.20963136851787567,
-0.032712940126657486,
0.20454035699367523,
-0.016171865165233612,
0.27711305022239685,
0.19929419457912445,
0.8199112415313721,
0.15355181694030762,
0.18303947150707245,
0.015092519111931324,
0.46985387802124023,
-0.7343948483467102,
-0.6557304263114929,
-1.0278151035308838,
0.49836331605911255,
0.0996333584189415,
-0.43082502484321594,
0.7506223320960999,
0.4160428047180176,
0.42986610531806946,
-0.0892605260014534,
0.4247879981994629,
0.15308037400245667,
0.3682734966278076,
-0.604729950428009,
0.9036518931388855,
-0.1773644983768463,
-0.25929877161979675,
-0.18939721584320068,
-0.8944704532623291,
-0.16038456559181213,
0.39844489097595215,
-0.3334841728210449,
-0.13191398978233337,
0.8648272156715393,
0.808833122253418,
0.15399618446826935,
0.5579123497009277,
0.4273316562175751,
0.14810575544834137,
-0.2483597695827484,
0.55863356590271,
1.0477608442306519,
-0.33875492215156555,
0.5507777333259583,
-0.05568769574165344,
-0.25848862528800964,
0.11446424573659897,
-0.5823792219161987,
-0.7574260830879211,
-0.6709045171737671,
-0.44205859303474426,
-0.4267536401748657,
0.004267557058483362,
0.5557746887207031,
1.1015421152114868,
-0.5293582677841187,
-0.35973691940307617,
-0.3126150369644165,
-0.04355781897902489,
-0.3702927529811859,
-0.09998434036970139,
0.32105332612991333,
-0.5934558510780334,
-1.0116913318634033,
0.8421807885169983,
0.19766971468925476,
0.10088223218917847,
0.12530741095542908,
-0.10668464004993439,
0.08988837897777557,
0.2211878001689911,
0.46355780959129333,
0.30105653405189514,
-0.39560091495513916,
0.05020691826939583,
0.14069247245788574,
0.11141769587993622,
0.011935250833630562,
0.5684360861778259,
-0.806563138961792,
0.4762997627258301,
0.5515671372413635,
0.7374343276023865,
0.7839500308036804,
-0.625469982624054,
0.5222312211990356,
-0.5714256167411804,
-0.004417280200868845,
0.295565664768219,
0.21921341121196747,
0.2885080575942993,
-0.2270757555961609,
0.06194061040878296,
0.24848495423793793,
-0.4842681586742401,
-0.818504810333252,
0.12974068522453308,
-1.0697054862976074,
-0.12926797568798065,
1.0026249885559082,
0.23501449823379517,
-0.6185436248779297,
0.10110379755496979,
-0.252031534910202,
0.34612950682640076,
-0.4119983911514282,
0.3879411220550537,
0.6110959053039551,
-0.20067842304706573,
-0.39516177773475647,
-0.48002541065216064,
0.30042263865470886,
0.9065691232681274,
-0.5759740471839905,
0.039057303220033646,
0.35218897461891174,
0.3165733814239502,
0.25552302598953247,
0.4638778269290924,
-0.2243194580078125,
0.43834197521209717,
0.4482702910900116,
0.34746265411376953,
-0.01699352078139782,
-0.050307661294937134,
-0.6201744079589844,
0.28456008434295654,
-0.013891465030610561,
-0.6351443529129028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01747v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01747v1
|
Towards Self-Contained Answers: Entity-Based Answer Rewriting in Conversational Search
| 2024-03-04T05:52:41 | 2024-03-04T05:52:41 |
Ivan Sekulić, Krisztian Balog, Fabio Crestani
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Conversational information-seeking (CIS) is an emerging paradigm for
knowledge acquisition and exploratory search. Traditional web search interfaces
enable easy exploration of entities, but this is limited in conversational
settings due to the limited-bandwidth interface. This paper explore ways to
rewrite answers in CIS, so that users can understand them without having to
resort to external services or sources. Specifically, we focus on salient
entities -- entities that are central to understanding the answer. As our first
contribution, we create a dataset of conversations annotated with entities for
saliency. Our analysis of the collected data reveals that the majority of
answers contain salient entities. As our second contribution, we propose two
answer rewriting strategies aimed at improving the overall user experience in
CIS. One approach expands answers with inline definitions of salient entities,
making the answer self-contained. The other approach complements answers with
follow-up questions, offering users the possibility to learn more about
specific entities. Results of a crowdsourcing-based study indicate that
rewritten answers are clearly preferred over the original ones. We also find
that inline definitions tend to be favored over follow-up questions, but this
choice is highly subjective, thereby providing a promising future direction for
personalization.
|
[
-0.525374174118042,
-0.7963354587554932,
0.8235410451889038,
0.07722816616296768,
-0.28242766857147217,
0.22669808566570282,
-0.18992672860622406,
-0.6708108186721802,
0.9165553450584412,
0.7641750574111938,
-1.0249054431915283,
-0.4769490361213684,
-0.08653298020362854,
0.20584982633590698,
-0.3949357867240906,
1.1041817665100098,
-0.042510610073804855,
-0.3684772551059723,
-0.6400250196456909,
0.019672531634569168,
-0.35365381836891174,
-0.47602128982543945,
-0.5881049036979675,
0.41811367869377136,
0.993664026260376,
0.6845381259918213,
0.8119550943374634,
0.7934980988502502,
0.37669238448143005,
0.29810795187950134,
0.13577531278133392,
0.005723509006202221,
-0.4577232897281647,
0.6507236957550049,
-0.3491564691066742,
-0.755569577217102,
-0.15992073714733124,
-0.27842557430267334,
0.36959102749824524,
1.1179051399230957,
-0.19550037384033203,
0.2003653347492218,
0.032451339066028595,
0.30750468373298645,
-0.7263185381889343,
0.1138848215341568,
-0.9188497066497803,
-0.030109908431768417,
-0.08868579566478729,
-0.21441251039505005,
-0.3331943452358246,
-0.22418370842933655,
0.5332411527633667,
-1.0196846723556519,
0.6553390026092529,
0.1122732162475586,
0.5526126623153687,
0.39098429679870605,
-0.43678390979766846,
-0.598986029624939,
-0.5973179936408997,
0.7495232224464417,
-0.13242022693157196,
0.5539276003837585,
0.2769007682800293,
0.1007462590932846,
-0.036368586122989655,
-0.8388157486915588,
-0.35320359468460083,
-0.12527154386043549,
-0.4039762318134308,
0.287158727645874,
-0.3045365810394287,
-0.01695067808032036,
-0.08686541765928268,
0.30398568511009216,
-0.5050954818725586,
-0.3709472119808197,
-0.37519288063049316,
-0.05326995626091957,
0.6155301928520203,
0.10517951846122742,
0.27826258540153503,
-0.187911257147789,
-0.3724100887775421,
0.27430713176727295,
-0.7359017729759216,
0.04165913164615631,
0.20477254688739777,
0.13788101077079773,
0.46010497212409973,
0.5810327529907227,
-0.5640048384666443,
0.24330249428749084,
0.4331359565258026,
0.31100887060165405,
-0.1135474294424057,
-0.46721744537353516,
-0.013236274011433125,
0.1153223067522049,
0.34443381428718567,
0.10653850436210632,
0.15621352195739746,
-0.4248623847961426,
0.03399581462144852,
-0.5369330644607544,
0.5469890832901001,
-0.5773308277130127,
-0.4151233732700348,
0.25141847133636475,
-0.3852868378162384,
0.06918853521347046,
-0.19726094603538513,
-0.6546278595924377,
0.1030145138502121,
-0.5424013137817383,
-0.049014996737241745,
-0.26296472549438477,
-0.11685479432344437,
-0.12160232663154602,
0.15886446833610535,
0.16296614706516266,
0.7532498836517334,
-0.9047257900238037,
0.49093273282051086,
0.6946232318878174,
0.5338584184646606,
-0.08099395036697388,
0.006340935826301575,
-0.2481907606124878,
0.3281082510948181,
-0.13939732313156128,
0.9708107709884644,
-0.5692461729049683,
-0.7240360379219055,
-0.020438959822058678,
-0.006735233124345541,
0.08189791440963745,
-0.34791064262390137,
0.49984875321388245,
-0.8785709738731384,
0.4711906313896179,
-0.5930945873260498,
-0.39739978313446045,
-0.15032361447811127,
0.12656919658184052,
-0.65069580078125,
0.8221348524093628,
-0.020977597683668137,
-0.6933354139328003,
0.2847091555595398,
-0.6821380853652954,
-0.42646992206573486,
0.16904690861701965,
-0.29023295640945435,
-0.2944324314594269,
0.25779643654823303,
0.317455530166626,
0.1969597190618515,
-0.15939021110534668,
0.0645676925778389,
-0.28960347175598145,
-0.2761448621749878,
0.5450842976570129,
-0.2942078411579132,
0.3652762174606323,
0.18725627660751343,
-0.5007232427597046,
-0.24748454988002777,
-0.4666852056980133,
0.19634412229061127,
-0.059497855603694916,
-0.22086335718631744,
-0.511483371257782,
-0.027200721204280853,
-0.3250831961631775,
-0.012436587363481522,
0.4693099558353424,
-0.6130974292755127,
0.038539182394742966,
-0.3029705584049225,
-0.009635635651648045,
0.7083923816680908,
0.3150302767753601,
0.4967361390590668,
-0.026831774041056633,
0.43310216069221497,
0.258163720369339,
0.22439301013946533,
-0.5508459806442261,
-0.4793955683708191,
-1.089072346687317,
0.0011224212357774377,
0.06331630796194077,
0.21240884065628052,
-0.85517418384552,
0.13497895002365112,
-0.40569692850112915,
-0.5398150682449341,
-0.9661341309547424,
0.32192033529281616,
0.5488046407699585,
0.7073230147361755,
0.6045428514480591,
-0.2671494781970978,
-0.396380752325058,
-1.317001461982727,
-0.465888649225235,
-0.45908552408218384,
-0.043661411851644516,
0.6973693370819092,
0.2815030515193939,
-0.03436940163373947,
0.9045603275299072,
-0.9284923076629639,
0.016736555844545364,
0.07341034710407257,
-0.01243277732282877,
-0.06014975160360336,
0.3655209243297577,
0.1117708683013916,
-1.214747667312622,
-0.36619457602500916,
-0.26035407185554504,
-0.7369030117988586,
-0.05819470062851906,
-0.1590820699930191,
-0.13963583111763,
-0.13486385345458984,
0.4136466383934021,
-0.6294221878051758,
0.5102787613868713,
-0.21868357062339783,
-0.05654660239815712,
0.16038432717323303,
0.057709310203790665,
0.2771676182746887,
-0.9154649972915649,
0.09939625859260559,
-0.008209203369915485,
-0.2103758454322815,
-0.7226668000221252,
0.2603711485862732,
-0.20317336916923523,
-0.08781777322292328,
-0.41097575426101685,
0.3617790639400482,
-0.8405423760414124,
-0.2491031438112259,
-0.14201727509498596,
0.6268191337585449,
0.10515659302473068,
0.7260419726371765,
0.24605914950370789,
0.8454952239990234,
0.20383472740650177,
-0.7253272533416748,
0.32530516386032104,
0.594612181186676,
0.05139235407114029,
0.6890518069267273,
-0.7971154451370239,
0.31885311007499695,
-0.5472338199615479,
0.35119614005088806,
-0.9594793915748596,
-0.24755650758743286,
0.284614235162735,
-0.5919222831726074,
-0.0664098709821701,
-0.2792956233024597,
-0.267498642206192,
0.05773421749472618,
-0.3485221564769745,
0.6140609979629517,
-0.04416833817958832,
-0.5239129066467285,
0.6907073855400085,
0.2777819335460663,
-0.5074742436408997,
-0.6818023324012756,
-0.6043213605880737,
0.207162007689476,
-0.14206679165363312,
-0.7011691927909851,
0.44328853487968445,
-0.31656259298324585,
-0.059461452066898346,
0.08617162704467773,
-0.118034228682518,
-0.1495698094367981,
0.3513062000274658,
0.29839417338371277,
0.2028774619102478,
-0.3838195502758026,
0.5268526077270508,
-0.04125982150435448,
-0.13156789541244507,
0.11839796602725983,
-0.17603419721126556,
0.3507523536682129,
-0.12529750168323517,
-0.5982974767684937,
-0.36963406205177307,
1.0236687660217285,
0.2934223711490631,
-0.44729354977607727,
0.5490577220916748,
0.33378034830093384,
-0.3305194079875946,
0.2020401954650879,
-0.6604451537132263,
-0.3543057441711426,
-0.43888190388679504,
0.053385280072689056,
-0.7201482057571411,
-1.1002037525177002,
0.6207811832427979,
0.04150641709566116,
0.1388956606388092,
0.3833429217338562,
0.5557345747947693,
-0.4830937683582306,
0.7359073162078857,
0.6162006855010986,
0.37626832723617554,
0.474334716796875,
0.01475601363927126,
0.3978065550327301,
-0.8831709027290344,
-0.6977613568305969,
-0.5435009598731995,
-0.2560611963272095,
-0.7952622175216675,
-0.14548338949680328,
0.40493443608283997,
-0.1536022126674652,
0.17720597982406616,
0.3263050317764282,
-0.5408225059509277,
0.2204517424106598,
0.86737060546875,
0.34429389238357544,
0.3669010400772095,
-0.1882058084011078,
0.2930600643157959,
-0.20805016160011292,
-0.39151981472969055,
-0.33830833435058594,
0.9496554732322693,
0.18038205802440643,
0.9930047392845154,
0.39516791701316833,
0.9268443584442139,
0.025417517870664597,
0.27828899025917053,
-0.48368334770202637,
0.5486752986907959,
0.3804298937320709,
-0.7767733335494995,
-0.4789597690105438,
-0.31029462814331055,
-1.0210318565368652,
0.32317548990249634,
-0.09380809962749481,
-0.7583223581314087,
0.5159330368041992,
0.327288955450058,
-0.44277575612068176,
-0.07134972512722015,
-0.8010390400886536,
0.670317530632019,
-0.36656463146209717,
-0.5866939425468445,
-0.0654456689953804,
-0.7343733310699463,
0.14379815757274628,
0.07008752971887589,
-0.23901145160198212,
0.014711495488882065,
-0.3463062047958374,
0.42554113268852234,
-0.1339598298072815,
0.796582818031311,
-0.029838308691978455,
-0.0595858097076416,
0.41891226172447205,
0.08154401183128357,
0.4643191993236542,
0.49602431058883667,
0.11038083583116531,
-0.2136111855506897,
0.027902329340577126,
-0.5567407608032227,
-1.0825591087341309,
0.911047101020813,
-0.6010895371437073,
-1.2410657405853271,
-0.11940759420394897,
-0.08270625025033951,
-0.030209051445126534,
0.287903368473053,
0.2210959494113922,
0.28611475229263306,
-0.29369214177131653,
0.3329830765724182,
1.2649190425872803,
0.0483798086643219,
0.16042248904705048,
0.6741167306900024,
0.0005882138502784073,
-0.1711355745792389,
0.39923790097236633,
0.0010401675244793296,
0.13295643031597137,
0.6961145997047424,
-0.29233741760253906,
-0.6363398432731628,
-0.20501741766929626,
-0.527765691280365,
0.23508957028388977,
-0.9379464387893677,
-0.093936987221241,
-1.1514886617660522,
0.13375069200992584,
-0.7176602482795715,
-0.13708966970443726,
-0.3553379476070404,
-0.2994207739830017,
-0.652610182762146,
-0.02905738726258278,
0.10869622975587845,
0.3623466491699219,
0.12573274970054626,
0.11767122894525528,
-0.44083163142204285,
0.3433420956134796,
0.5479608774185181,
0.35869428515434265,
-0.1880776435136795,
-0.1635228842496872,
-0.2645931541919708,
0.2859407365322113,
-0.1142253652215004,
-1.0914511680603027,
-0.06622413545846939,
0.10561829060316086,
0.5457422733306885,
0.14334750175476074,
0.2191494107246399,
1.0023221969604492,
-0.31971725821495056,
0.7467971444129944,
0.08644597232341766,
-0.8899721503257751,
0.911016047000885,
-0.08788229525089264,
0.09907042235136032,
1.0137540102005005,
0.4761834442615509,
-0.9336051940917969,
-0.25160345435142517,
-0.8456500172615051,
-0.9203982949256897,
0.4279423654079437,
0.4002472758293152,
0.42740345001220703,
-0.14547133445739746,
0.6296658515930176,
-0.020994313061237335,
0.36118632555007935,
-0.48379895091056824,
-0.47978076338768005,
-0.36954450607299805,
-0.006626649294048548,
0.24080950021743774,
-0.25981301069259644,
-0.07343136519193649,
0.2307152897119522,
0.6661165356636047,
-0.23966318368911743,
0.4407440721988678,
0.7159803509712219,
-0.19896280765533447,
-0.03406820446252823,
0.42053085565567017,
0.21584612131118774,
0.558326244354248,
-0.04883299022912979,
0.3439856171607971,
0.1759946048259735,
-0.21993491053581238,
-0.033496979624032974,
-0.0848197191953659,
-0.2810381054878235,
0.22636577486991882,
0.06578977406024933,
0.28646889328956604,
0.6369161605834961,
-0.5508944988250732,
0.6271811127662659,
-0.30351004004478455,
0.229820117354393,
-0.6441946625709534,
0.24544334411621094,
0.20986825227737427,
-0.07645727694034576,
0.34623125195503235,
-0.2710159420967102,
0.6408084034919739,
-0.7985159754753113,
0.17545336484909058,
0.439109206199646,
-0.547135591506958,
-0.29624342918395996,
0.6311044692993164,
0.2910553812980652,
-0.244061678647995,
0.6686179041862488,
0.19209523499011993,
-0.2938351631164551,
0.2430955320596695,
0.39254704117774963,
0.9208664894104004,
-0.42187222838401794,
0.28405216336250305,
0.015412858687341213,
0.1817609667778015,
0.49080199003219604,
-0.06216418743133545,
-0.6769930720329285,
-0.541664719581604,
-0.03300604224205017,
-0.0900711789727211,
-0.6873633861541748,
-0.17931082844734192,
-0.8637078404426575,
0.15031567215919495,
-0.3252555727958679,
0.08953189104795456,
0.4790298640727997,
-0.0162610225379467,
-0.7482345700263977,
0.5212621092796326,
-0.141904816031456,
0.8520229458808899,
-0.4363204836845398,
0.22299519181251526,
0.8696721196174622,
-0.747302770614624,
-0.5320951342582703,
0.042304884642362595,
-0.32431715726852417,
-0.605318546295166,
0.33387333154678345,
-0.17172643542289734,
-0.3015434443950653,
-0.1472947746515274,
-0.7102744579315186,
-1.2512013912200928,
1.2742010354995728,
0.3835339844226837,
-0.18722346425056458,
-0.2571226954460144,
0.09360930323600769,
0.6363350749015808,
-0.35727956891059875,
0.5748668909072876,
0.394506573677063,
0.21888592839241028,
0.29184019565582275,
-0.6336475014686584,
-0.06735529750585556,
-0.3125961422920227,
-0.049915727227926254,
0.08342663943767548,
-0.8358641862869263,
0.551018238067627,
-0.12367275357246399,
-0.5644068717956543,
0.06673430651426315,
1.037184238433838,
0.08668562024831772,
0.48612964153289795,
0.41295966506004333,
0.23848535120487213,
0.7610016465187073,
-0.0172700397670269,
0.8220905065536499,
-0.2739243805408478,
0.22562503814697266,
1.372808575630188,
-0.01172309648245573,
0.7502720952033997,
0.6971126198768616,
0.10697447508573532,
0.7240102291107178,
0.7357215285301208,
0.21689273416996002,
0.43970605731010437,
0.2916634976863861,
-0.6132383942604065,
-0.4988003671169281,
-0.31134092807769775,
-0.07133568078279495,
0.5826398134231567,
0.11914753913879395,
-0.4077374041080475,
-0.2386241853237152,
-0.2911558151245117,
0.253827303647995,
0.30014556646347046,
-0.126265749335289,
1.073430061340332,
0.009515289217233658,
-1.0904390811920166,
0.07925693690776825,
0.03276519477367401,
0.2128545492887497,
-0.21721485257148743,
-0.16867423057556152,
-0.5101353526115417,
-0.13805051147937775,
-0.2931312322616577,
-0.9805307984352112,
0.28431105613708496,
-0.003743264125660062,
-0.4665566086769104,
-0.23919075727462769,
0.8316276669502258,
-0.4509155750274658,
-0.2526954710483551,
-0.1053810864686966,
0.7494932413101196,
0.4212120771408081,
-0.23932163417339325,
-0.7598481774330139,
-0.4874412715435028,
0.35535022616386414,
-0.13631978631019592,
-0.06546664237976074,
0.5392799377441406,
-0.1302671879529953,
0.9956462383270264,
0.6863709688186646,
-0.42585015296936035,
0.16763810813426971,
-0.3410651683807373,
1.215593695640564,
-0.6454533934593201,
-0.6526378989219666,
-0.3767050802707672,
0.4365140199661255,
-0.1983618289232254,
-0.4424578547477722,
0.689395546913147,
0.7878929376602173,
0.9035402536392212,
0.07661940157413483,
0.6975437998771667,
0.16379708051681519,
0.6928972601890564,
-0.28907668590545654,
0.22073014080524445,
-0.3289669454097748,
0.40809085965156555,
-0.2657332718372345,
-0.7916793823242188,
-0.014052302576601505,
0.19508473575115204,
-0.3007246255874634,
0.12792250514030457,
0.3057492673397064,
0.7637600302696228,
-0.14495882391929626,
0.3271770477294922,
0.32776719331741333,
-0.10471780598163605,
0.36508750915527344,
0.5923815965652466,
0.9339801073074341,
-0.3899632692337036,
0.7159370183944702,
-0.1524185985326767,
-0.07962051779031754,
-0.29587796330451965,
-0.34093400835990906,
-0.48512837290763855,
-0.7364706993103027,
-0.5057030916213989,
-0.0658411756157875,
0.1122395396232605,
0.606322705745697,
0.5667747259140015,
-0.5938146114349365,
0.24047215282917023,
0.11113861203193665,
0.357215017080307,
0.3161180317401886,
-0.2018284797668457,
0.30588993430137634,
-0.38572975993156433,
-0.77006995677948,
0.2009061723947525,
0.4846021234989166,
0.06497397273778915,
-0.4709548354148865,
0.34885311126708984,
-0.1477809101343155,
0.05888849124312401,
0.15313203632831573,
0.39171698689460754,
-0.9399622082710266,
-0.49055615067481995,
0.6449335217475891,
-0.010593226179480553,
0.25231510400772095,
1.0711963176727295,
-0.8945912718772888,
0.5481200814247131,
-0.0712510347366333,
0.7048051357269287,
0.6564869284629822,
0.29839736223220825,
0.4360233247280121,
-0.9235138297080994,
-0.4438062906265259,
0.3793908953666687,
0.07836593687534332,
0.5362977981567383,
-0.8829924464225769,
0.40949752926826477,
0.09915865957736969,
-0.4205785095691681,
-0.24828845262527466,
0.4168891906738281,
-0.9559555053710938,
-0.12903372943401337,
0.8507168889045715,
-0.5304808020591736,
-0.2713051438331604,
-0.42571860551834106,
-0.1485573798418045,
0.17919312417507172,
-0.477116197347641,
0.8920559287071228,
0.30566707253456116,
-0.36509811878204346,
-0.4140978455543518,
-0.06407881528139114,
0.3049342930316925,
0.42198359966278076,
-0.9488595128059387,
0.2277866154909134,
0.4460555613040924,
0.5225543975830078,
0.6528201103210449,
0.7460507154464722,
0.005750699900090694,
0.47188884019851685,
-0.18368247151374817,
-0.021458305418491364,
0.2205965518951416,
-0.26962023973464966,
0.013842489570379257,
0.17954246699810028,
-0.1389653980731964,
-0.26416707038879395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01699v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01699v3
|
Brilla AI: AI Contestant for the National Science and Maths Quiz
| 2024-03-04T03:24:18 | 2024-04-30T19:22:36 |
George Boateng, Jonathan Abrefah Mensah, Kevin Takyi Yeboah, William Edor, Andrew Kojo Mensah-Onumah, Naafi Dasana Ibrahim, Nana Sam Yeboah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The African continent lacks enough qualified teachers which hampers the
provision of adequate learning support. An AI could potentially augment the
efforts of the limited number of teachers, leading to better learning outcomes.
Towards that end, this work describes and evaluates the first key output for
the NSMQ AI Grand Challenge, which proposes a robust, real-world benchmark for
such an AI: "Build an AI to compete live in Ghana's National Science and Maths
Quiz (NSMQ) competition and win - performing better than the best contestants
in all rounds and stages of the competition". The NSMQ is an annual live
science and mathematics competition for senior secondary school students in
Ghana in which 3 teams of 2 students compete by answering questions across
biology, chemistry, physics, and math in 5 rounds over 5 progressive stages
until a winning team is crowned for that year. In this work, we built Brilla
AI, an AI contestant that we deployed to unofficially compete remotely and live
in the Riddles round of the 2023 NSMQ Grand Finale, the first of its kind in
the 30-year history of the competition. Brilla AI is currently available as a
web app that livestreams the Riddles round of the contest, and runs 4 machine
learning systems: (1) speech to text (2) question extraction (3) question
answering and (4) text to speech that work together in real-time to quickly and
accurately provide an answer, and then say it with a Ghanaian accent. In its
debut, our AI answered one of the 4 riddles ahead of the 3 human contesting
teams, unofficially placing second (tied). Improvements and extensions of this
AI could potentially be deployed to offer science tutoring to students and
eventually enable millions across Africa to have one-on-one learning
interactions, democratizing science education.
|
[
-0.46657419204711914,
-0.634335458278656,
0.4112987518310547,
0.19872654974460602,
-0.14378999173641205,
0.5171904563903809,
0.184434175491333,
-0.2960597276687622,
0.4263938069343567,
0.16749119758605957,
-0.8419376611709595,
-0.2668295204639435,
-0.5132618546485901,
0.41215839982032776,
-0.45515134930610657,
0.7600861191749573,
0.07555639743804932,
-0.07891184091567993,
-0.7894014120101929,
0.14795644581317902,
-0.6221551299095154,
-0.43689605593681335,
-0.7973233461380005,
-0.28494420647621155,
0.5945321321487427,
0.7997480630874634,
0.6599194407463074,
0.06619910150766373,
0.49916642904281616,
0.36360347270965576,
0.15644629299640656,
0.6554484963417053,
-0.35775336623191833,
-0.09968199580907822,
-0.1269799917936325,
-0.6832714676856995,
-0.10447297245264053,
0.2801525592803955,
0.3383924663066864,
0.37485167384147644,
-0.26380935311317444,
0.35828909277915955,
-0.20824000239372253,
0.5662193894386292,
-0.33387401700019836,
0.17886170744895935,
-0.532871663570404,
0.07195506989955902,
-0.026777779683470726,
-0.20917892456054688,
-0.009382554329931736,
-0.5384925603866577,
-0.1001235768198967,
-0.5353859066963196,
0.22230063378810883,
-0.026580924168229103,
1.2198807001113892,
0.5950313210487366,
-0.22038547694683075,
-0.34614646434783936,
-0.7129271626472473,
0.7455970644950867,
-0.6801469326019287,
0.02857082709670067,
0.36633628606796265,
0.851586639881134,
-0.05551676079630852,
-0.927872896194458,
-0.543387234210968,
-0.22333689033985138,
0.21997754275798798,
0.45199769735336304,
0.0015592377167195082,
-0.26480820775032043,
0.03663382679224014,
0.15944944322109222,
-0.428891658782959,
-0.04536832123994827,
-0.7362839579582214,
-0.48537006974220276,
0.8960002660751343,
0.3431086838245392,
0.4469027817249298,
0.17151527106761932,
-0.03825527802109718,
0.3434664011001587,
-0.5873205065727234,
0.09473757445812225,
0.4376799464225769,
0.39841845631599426,
-0.17447729408740997,
0.5128515362739563,
-0.4143623113632202,
0.6918575167655945,
-0.19293946027755737,
-0.20956076681613922,
-0.03276617452502251,
-0.19915607571601868,
-0.009444205090403557,
0.32906296849250793,
0.7245703339576721,
-0.04416912794113159,
0.21159829199314117,
-0.08782044798135757,
0.0635310560464859,
0.5150800347328186,
0.32262688875198364,
-0.930982232093811,
-0.1890404224395752,
0.25866445899009705,
-0.013558954931795597,
-0.3033474087715149,
0.06189250573515892,
-0.6186805963516235,
-0.18900452554225922,
-0.2752070128917694,
0.7111632823944092,
-0.2344294935464859,
0.5027371048927307,
-0.10680118948221207,
-0.1652686893939972,
0.016972051933407784,
0.5564223527908325,
-0.7632911205291748,
0.2139495462179184,
0.6457688212394714,
1.0791314840316772,
0.2075018286705017,
-0.34206151962280273,
-0.4649675190448761,
-0.2792661488056183,
-0.011213619261980057,
0.5744455456733704,
-0.5472755432128906,
-0.587280809879303,
-0.33259713649749756,
-0.16192026436328888,
-0.20780177414417267,
-0.46779665350914,
0.6539018750190735,
-0.545499861240387,
0.40170818567276,
-0.42091742157936096,
-0.33760589361190796,
-0.17774157226085663,
0.19182461500167847,
-0.38733768463134766,
0.7931917309761047,
0.24389447271823883,
-0.5866589546203613,
-0.04201890528202057,
-0.8694193959236145,
-0.4094405174255371,
0.2964993417263031,
-0.1603781282901764,
-0.36218568682670593,
-0.11480692774057388,
0.5466008186340332,
0.14160028100013733,
-0.51881343126297,
0.1670013964176178,
-0.15349894762039185,
-0.6464797854423523,
0.4612978994846344,
-0.5071046948432922,
1.040931224822998,
0.0728573203086853,
-0.27954697608947754,
-0.12246822565793991,
-0.37746599316596985,
-0.11114095151424408,
0.1674807220697403,
-0.23764681816101074,
0.26151043176651,
-0.08710777014493942,
-0.5923853516578674,
0.17486530542373657,
0.22971567511558533,
-1.0164653062820435,
0.14393925666809082,
-0.41664814949035645,
0.6482710838317871,
0.6432709693908691,
0.24155069887638092,
0.02194531075656414,
-0.6126788854598999,
0.7891591787338257,
-0.4552466869354248,
0.43443575501441956,
0.2398783564567566,
-1.0787619352340698,
-0.7042006850242615,
-0.35393229126930237,
0.8588011860847473,
0.891318142414093,
-0.819826066493988,
0.044075511395931244,
-0.06551288813352585,
-0.6459227800369263,
-1.1749324798583984,
0.1910252571105957,
0.06082083284854889,
0.8045581579208374,
0.10543493926525116,
-0.21040278673171997,
-0.5832262635231018,
-0.8262174129486084,
-0.09203802794218063,
-0.14549124240875244,
-0.13704514503479004,
0.45191848278045654,
0.8255952000617981,
-0.26126742362976074,
1.0477269887924194,
-0.29240450263023376,
-0.4065921902656555,
0.09113038331270218,
0.10977666825056076,
0.29472512006759644,
0.11740120500326157,
0.4937630593776703,
-0.7735861539840698,
-0.5046738386154175,
0.26360172033309937,
-0.9727295637130737,
-0.3423798680305481,
0.12521427869796753,
-0.26014021039009094,
0.0537753663957119,
0.08570495247840881,
-0.5457855463027954,
0.7698459625244141,
0.4003404974937439,
-0.40143296122550964,
0.781793475151062,
-0.07428888976573944,
0.2469882071018219,
-0.5475603342056274,
0.16062095761299133,
-0.42427533864974976,
-0.08941425383090973,
-0.4234195351600647,
0.11308593302965164,
-0.2545045018196106,
-0.3988611102104187,
-0.426036536693573,
0.6544109582901001,
-0.06685104966163635,
-0.10180473327636719,
-0.06570981442928314,
0.25718313455581665,
-0.04582211375236511,
0.1693291962146759,
-0.35482925176620483,
0.9191911816596985,
0.2986261248588562,
-0.579957902431488,
0.6012119650840759,
0.5046212077140808,
-0.4190385639667511,
0.5896517038345337,
-0.9649856090545654,
0.12595269083976746,
-0.03962954878807068,
-0.011921311728656292,
-0.9107147455215454,
-0.24873846769332886,
0.055738747119903564,
-1.1227407455444336,
-0.0016838627634570003,
0.13556042313575745,
-0.3453860580921173,
-0.6748999357223511,
0.08083818852901459,
-0.08023537695407867,
0.6425368785858154,
-0.5650981664657593,
0.5261520743370056,
0.35117071866989136,
-0.49134260416030884,
-0.7658290863037109,
-0.6217076182365417,
0.1939636915922165,
-0.1209416538476944,
-0.7063904404640198,
0.12196063250303268,
-0.02735068090260029,
-0.13535794615745544,
0.07075174152851105,
0.0923314094543457,
-0.0518244132399559,
0.5672684907913208,
0.5339361429214478,
0.36883270740509033,
-0.06740794330835342,
-0.34211912751197815,
0.3705771267414093,
-0.06217202916741371,
0.3497319221496582,
-0.03842514753341675,
0.39556851983070374,
-0.16599582135677338,
-0.5209667086601257,
-0.6023682355880737,
0.20129695534706116,
0.5083136558532715,
-0.4575611650943756,
0.6388678550720215,
0.6254473924636841,
-0.3609127402305603,
-0.02612282894551754,
-0.125441312789917,
-0.18144260346889496,
-0.5265704393386841,
-0.05010506883263588,
-0.14673912525177002,
-0.9282590746879578,
0.5930440425872803,
0.0027837357483804226,
0.3221033811569214,
0.35381829738616943,
0.6027538776397705,
-0.3233722150325775,
1.1056039333343506,
0.20866389572620392,
-0.24382232129573822,
0.049018166959285736,
-0.5362273454666138,
0.12527664005756378,
-0.6234903931617737,
-0.6619383692741394,
-0.7680787444114685,
-0.8118788003921509,
-0.16065584123134613,
-0.3522813320159912,
0.6544552445411682,
-0.2795789837837219,
-0.5479052066802979,
-0.23399341106414795,
-0.4600832462310791,
0.41528117656707764,
1.0073682069778442,
0.3104533553123474,
0.04617626965045929,
0.05120707303285599,
-0.31507641077041626,
-0.19397972524166107,
-0.9365864396095276,
-0.3472691774368286,
0.9990723729133606,
0.06577105075120926,
0.44878894090652466,
0.28795167803764343,
1.0555018186569214,
0.4989832639694214,
0.6431041955947876,
-0.7646411657333374,
0.49232545495033264,
0.12634044885635376,
-0.7981053590774536,
-0.39578521251678467,
-0.5536748766899109,
-0.980509877204895,
-0.10128942131996155,
-0.15667253732681274,
-0.5615394115447998,
0.03930749371647835,
-0.1821867823600769,
-0.6187038421630859,
0.11444682627916336,
-0.33060750365257263,
0.8130711317062378,
-0.3565925657749176,
-0.4394417107105255,
0.08776985108852386,
-0.7973174452781677,
0.392015278339386,
0.03353540599346161,
0.3261582851409912,
0.08760016411542892,
0.045630212873220444,
0.8406711220741272,
-0.8380308747291565,
0.8904964327812195,
-0.45172372460365295,
0.39061978459358215,
0.7296828627586365,
0.14638423919677734,
-0.22587545216083527,
0.271188348531723,
-0.18616536259651184,
0.0021859772969037294,
-0.24975842237472534,
-0.6723729968070984,
-0.6541037559509277,
0.7825666069984436,
-1.133374571800232,
-0.567842960357666,
-0.5096482634544373,
-0.5312538146972656,
-0.23726077377796173,
0.09475656598806381,
0.15484170615673065,
0.5177512168884277,
-0.15157361328601837,
0.012906074523925781,
0.33282774686813354,
-0.12873436510562897,
0.33823543787002563,
0.101178839802742,
-0.3192843198776245,
-0.591076135635376,
1.1727855205535889,
0.12013363093137741,
0.02745606191456318,
0.24426285922527313,
0.2740289866924286,
-0.5171824097633362,
-0.41091787815093994,
-0.6263001561164856,
0.4731946587562561,
-0.5152785181999207,
-0.4088587462902069,
-0.34963399171829224,
-0.35132619738578796,
-0.3581676185131073,
-0.2931184768676758,
0.08089534193277359,
-0.5580074191093445,
-0.4190656542778015,
-0.06359981745481491,
0.22123132646083832,
0.718693733215332,
-0.10131591558456421,
0.4931062161922455,
-0.7245585322380066,
0.16486570239067078,
0.8688957095146179,
-0.10687831789255142,
-0.10082444548606873,
-0.8386837840080261,
-0.18584540486335754,
0.2072671353816986,
-0.5373818278312683,
-0.8093909025192261,
0.7088589072227478,
0.5120988488197327,
0.6242840886116028,
0.40529677271842957,
-0.11600609868764877,
0.6083747744560242,
-0.2721341848373413,
1.0004910230636597,
-0.27561745047569275,
-0.7751694321632385,
0.5766059756278992,
-0.1396530419588089,
0.3588991165161133,
0.7890408635139465,
0.7060793042182922,
-0.393612802028656,
-0.2758924067020416,
-0.5968148112297058,
-0.18311375379562378,
0.4321274161338806,
0.35134610533714294,
0.07504921406507492,
0.1574443280696869,
0.5432894825935364,
0.09540978819131851,
0.5281454920768738,
-0.1386139690876007,
-0.2865539789199829,
-0.15695856511592865,
-0.13079345226287842,
-0.03965694457292557,
0.14361310005187988,
-0.13662859797477722,
-0.5136837363243103,
0.9888922572135925,
-0.11355473846197128,
0.4586813449859619,
0.22869183123111725,
0.11602362245321274,
0.03514990955591202,
-0.10689478367567062,
0.4353194236755371,
0.6243218183517456,
-0.18125000596046448,
-0.3289507031440735,
0.16577833890914917,
-0.5370569825172424,
-0.016802452504634857,
0.15402710437774658,
-0.6726740002632141,
0.203256756067276,
0.3865375518798828,
0.8717811703681946,
0.03061794862151146,
-0.6391513347625732,
0.09764579683542252,
-0.33030185103416443,
-0.5373796224594116,
-0.13335616886615753,
0.24790053069591522,
0.12816578149795532,
0.11526954919099808,
0.4035991132259369,
0.02771061286330223,
0.2103312611579895,
-0.9424394965171814,
0.2956942319869995,
0.5615106821060181,
-0.34998586773872375,
-0.21636496484279633,
0.9153181314468384,
0.3349001407623291,
-0.7805902361869812,
0.8552406430244446,
-0.43839001655578613,
-1.130615472793579,
0.9869658350944519,
0.5840851664543152,
0.3986436128616333,
-0.5795517563819885,
0.8602348566055298,
0.4011770486831665,
0.5521764159202576,
0.3250214159488678,
1.0237786769866943,
0.059230122715234756,
-0.4540584087371826,
-0.20003078877925873,
-0.6349259614944458,
-0.9292309284210205,
-0.36391034722328186,
-0.3954949975013733,
0.30385130643844604,
-0.5871426463127136,
-0.07138275355100632,
-0.018965881317853928,
0.549018383026123,
-0.6906672716140747,
0.4154224395751953,
0.3367588520050049,
0.9775892496109009,
-0.8486544489860535,
0.4350481927394867,
0.7530228495597839,
-0.10215437412261963,
-0.6345173120498657,
-0.7306587100028992,
0.030441157519817352,
-0.8062164783477783,
0.3662700355052948,
0.15957148373126984,
0.1382388323545456,
0.06766628473997116,
-0.7870821952819824,
-0.6853146553039551,
1.2883050441741943,
0.30336993932724,
-0.25419092178344727,
-0.029561752453446388,
0.34827691316604614,
0.46551498770713806,
-0.49972835183143616,
0.5876538753509521,
0.48657530546188354,
0.6742756366729736,
0.3291604518890381,
-0.9265744090080261,
-0.2889736294746399,
-0.2992078959941864,
-0.44083669781684875,
0.24150831997394562,
-0.8289737105369568,
0.9312100410461426,
-0.54178786277771,
-0.40183350443840027,
0.3951546847820282,
0.9645244479179382,
0.3207094073295593,
0.9977312088012695,
0.010320816189050674,
0.7313273549079895,
1.1512778997421265,
-0.32377198338508606,
1.0556942224502563,
-0.10971097648143768,
0.17673279345035553,
0.9089200496673584,
-0.2920089364051819,
0.6515573263168335,
0.16125980019569397,
-0.484952449798584,
0.7696021795272827,
0.6971225738525391,
0.16740714013576508,
0.395966500043869,
0.18459314107894897,
-0.3173016309738159,
-0.24671582877635956,
-0.3158644437789917,
-0.40547975897789,
0.6462736129760742,
0.6623378992080688,
0.15075568854808807,
-0.19983777403831482,
-0.020921455696225166,
-0.19069676101207733,
0.2468174397945404,
-0.4911910891532898,
0.28423675894737244,
0.20361588895320892,
-0.5645533800125122,
0.4416094720363617,
-0.020558666437864304,
0.40275320410728455,
-0.5760917663574219,
-0.0730392262339592,
-0.45213451981544495,
-0.06893796473741531,
-0.2517208755016327,
-0.5267282724380493,
0.20621907711029053,
-0.04932824522256851,
0.28678539395332336,
0.44653573632240295,
0.6413998603820801,
-0.2784741222858429,
-0.7736650109291077,
-0.27019867300987244,
0.5645972490310669,
0.2907508611679077,
-0.09993583709001541,
-0.8559284806251526,
-0.040720921009778976,
-0.08679325878620148,
0.35786619782447815,
0.278012216091156,
0.30637016892433167,
-0.07589154690504074,
0.8549177646636963,
0.6604382991790771,
0.06827414035797119,
0.11085169017314911,
-0.07524995505809784,
0.6374809741973877,
-0.40326300263404846,
-0.6156154274940491,
-0.7187424302101135,
0.2552443742752075,
-0.17148040235042572,
-0.48253417015075684,
0.9796891808509827,
0.6944054961204529,
0.4172000288963318,
0.026422273367643356,
0.9424407482147217,
-0.02996513433754444,
0.4563254415988922,
-0.2113809585571289,
0.6612419486045837,
-0.4439217746257782,
-0.07569321244955063,
0.03708599880337715,
-0.687941312789917,
-0.1238463968038559,
0.4948413074016571,
-0.1582924723625183,
-0.16200776398181915,
0.4577929973602295,
0.5468641519546509,
0.10961305350065231,
0.3793545365333557,
0.21211279928684235,
0.0032258627470582724,
0.15143288671970367,
0.759917676448822,
1.0524922609329224,
-0.4990721344947815,
0.162435382604599,
-0.5306143760681152,
-0.33580413460731506,
-0.3487827181816101,
-0.4714055061340332,
-1.1002187728881836,
-0.2665404975414276,
-0.3042823374271393,
-0.2764144241809845,
0.06648214161396027,
0.6942213177680969,
0.36000946164131165,
-0.8232350945472717,
-0.2257213145494461,
0.4222240447998047,
0.3601369261741638,
-0.1804632693529129,
-0.2638046443462372,
0.06483947485685349,
0.2148895114660263,
-0.6763325333595276,
0.6187466382980347,
0.07373454421758652,
-0.19720719754695892,
-0.33195239305496216,
-0.16186697781085968,
-0.35491999983787537,
0.45362600684165955,
0.5726334452629089,
0.659055769443512,
-0.43967530131340027,
-0.3454161584377289,
0.30371609330177307,
0.25062504410743713,
-0.21557560563087463,
0.35971713066101074,
-1.0815684795379639,
0.33062776923179626,
0.34664133191108704,
1.015809416770935,
0.4138728380203247,
0.17145340144634247,
0.2888772189617157,
-0.5306239128112793,
-0.11831537634134293,
0.514568567276001,
0.16539080440998077,
0.23665788769721985,
-0.3997485339641571,
0.7359441518783569,
0.40910208225250244,
-0.925905704498291,
-1.0165444612503052,
0.02048489637672901,
-0.8856099843978882,
0.025393549352884293,
0.6145148277282715,
-0.020598670467734337,
-0.5892180800437927,
-0.056836992502212524,
-0.43500879406929016,
0.19483374059200287,
-0.3936004340648651,
1.0378235578536987,
0.563029944896698,
-0.2573499083518982,
0.16499122977256775,
-0.8173443675041199,
0.07719814777374268,
0.5089644193649292,
-1.0506539344787598,
-0.7286014556884766,
0.3164721429347992,
0.09080931544303894,
0.23483535647392273,
0.3548043668270111,
0.15683823823928833,
0.6228228807449341,
0.008542328141629696,
-0.13339661061763763,
-0.3651958703994751,
-0.7215689420700073,
-0.19367219507694244,
0.18591086566448212,
-0.18370665609836578,
-0.27304214239120483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01698v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01698v1
|
Hypertext Entity Extraction in Webpage
| 2024-03-04T03:21:40 | 2024-03-04T03:21:40 |
Yifei Yang, Tianqiao Liu, Bo Shao, Hai Zhao, Linjun Shou, Ming Gong, Daxin Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Webpage entity extraction is a fundamental natural language processing task
in both research and applications. Nowadays, the majority of webpage entity
extraction models are trained on structured datasets which strive to retain
textual content and its structure information. However, existing datasets all
overlook the rich hypertext features (e.g., font color, font size) which show
their effectiveness in previous works. To this end, we first collect a
\textbf{H}ypertext \textbf{E}ntity \textbf{E}xtraction \textbf{D}ataset
(\textit{HEED}) from the e-commerce domains, scraping both the text and the
corresponding explicit hypertext features with high-quality manual entity
annotations. Furthermore, we present the \textbf{Mo}E-based \textbf{E}ntity
\textbf{E}xtraction \textbf{F}ramework (\textit{MoEEF}), which efficiently
integrates multiple features to enhance model performance by Mixture of Experts
and outperforms strong baselines, including the state-of-the-art small-scale
models and GPT-3.5-turbo. Moreover, the effectiveness of hypertext features in
\textit{HEED} and several model components in \textit{MoEEF} are analyzed.
|
[
-0.7108235955238342,
-0.8871671557426453,
0.2898036539554596,
0.22452083230018616,
-0.31617704033851624,
-0.2428354024887085,
-0.1992114931344986,
-0.950490415096283,
0.07699562609195709,
0.37295153737068176,
-0.45037972927093506,
-0.5915161967277527,
-0.30378955602645874,
0.27883800864219666,
-0.4823080599308014,
1.118645191192627,
0.20578588545322418,
-0.31075140833854675,
0.012914767488837242,
-0.03194595128297806,
0.007204535882920027,
-0.2904585599899292,
-0.3421918451786041,
0.18632398545742035,
0.372660756111145,
0.2667514979839325,
0.5234338045120239,
0.9823335409164429,
0.5577722191810608,
0.2982771098613739,
0.24539373815059662,
0.10451610386371613,
-0.35931769013404846,
0.10417453199625015,
-0.41560888290405273,
-0.19710606336593628,
-0.759063720703125,
0.039301831275224686,
0.4064554274082184,
0.5839952826499939,
-0.3138684928417206,
0.3397354483604431,
0.2790752649307251,
0.3115161061286926,
-0.8173270225524902,
0.28223493695259094,
-0.730720043182373,
-0.25631213188171387,
-0.17430734634399414,
-0.11773034185171127,
-0.4266843795776367,
-0.08710896223783493,
0.3729361593723297,
-0.9514760375022888,
0.4744565188884735,
0.5043137669563293,
1.543097972869873,
0.061940938234329224,
-0.3694014251232147,
-0.1861913949251175,
-0.6243941187858582,
0.952441394329071,
-0.3752141296863556,
0.8878157138824463,
0.5700283050537109,
0.04780135676264763,
0.22282274067401886,
-0.8088691830635071,
-0.6795230507850647,
0.20798484981060028,
0.024557625874876976,
0.029871564358472824,
-0.48733529448509216,
-0.15458446741104126,
0.32768023014068604,
0.32860440015792847,
-0.5293155908584595,
0.17414981126785278,
-0.04699568450450897,
-0.17433081567287445,
0.4836851954460144,
-0.002515688305720687,
0.4268910884857178,
-0.5002941489219666,
-0.7525484561920166,
-0.2534750998020172,
-0.4812435805797577,
-0.3150094449520111,
0.0925949215888977,
0.15561819076538086,
-0.004954912234097719,
0.2946934700012207,
-0.2598097622394562,
0.5406398177146912,
0.10240105539560318,
-0.34821826219558716,
0.2103421688079834,
-0.1770176738500595,
-0.41612809896469116,
-0.1252870261669159,
0.8594312071800232,
0.24524803459644318,
0.439515084028244,
-0.15630576014518738,
-0.435484379529953,
-0.28337427973747253,
0.3077528774738312,
-0.8000056743621826,
-0.32869380712509155,
0.19918863475322723,
-0.7027860879898071,
-0.18838147819042206,
0.506999671459198,
-1.3915752172470093,
0.1242203339934349,
-0.24929869174957275,
0.1308433711528778,
-0.43134090304374695,
-0.28031349182128906,
-0.10070833563804626,
-0.5132580995559692,
0.15652421116828918,
0.4220733046531677,
-0.9667875170707703,
0.45778629183769226,
0.6362744569778442,
0.490252286195755,
-0.3308742344379425,
0.09691168367862701,
-0.14866109192371368,
0.6691835522651672,
0.33998483419418335,
0.9268407225608826,
-0.5538969039916992,
-0.2768228352069855,
0.12902656197547913,
0.05008925125002861,
-0.031728122383356094,
-0.6690459251403809,
0.6812994480133057,
-0.8345500230789185,
0.014605003409087658,
-0.14441965520381927,
-0.7091075778007507,
-0.360312819480896,
0.36822840571403503,
-1.0849241018295288,
0.8608906269073486,
0.00441728625446558,
-0.6780064105987549,
0.5626222491264343,
-0.43123915791511536,
-0.5824245810508728,
0.12835367023944855,
0.011971539817750454,
-0.527019202709198,
0.1459534615278244,
0.5457894206047058,
0.4740039110183716,
-0.46027255058288574,
-0.4807388484477997,
-0.6096286773681641,
-0.16452698409557343,
0.25731006264686584,
-0.6672103404998779,
0.7808715105056763,
0.17407967150211334,
-0.42856502532958984,
-0.5460222959518433,
-1.1619021892547607,
0.1514900177717209,
0.45238712430000305,
-0.6277881264686584,
-0.6431720852851868,
-0.18200746178627014,
0.8940454721450806,
0.11636199802160263,
0.2775019705295563,
-0.471481591463089,
0.047623973339796066,
-0.023473214358091354,
0.07437506318092346,
0.7291287779808044,
0.22951070964336395,
0.13265304267406464,
-0.05615423247218132,
0.4579019248485565,
-0.2760316729545593,
-0.11107581108808517,
0.05282219871878624,
-0.49050596356391907,
-0.6629216074943542,
-0.7167637348175049,
0.4865357279777527,
0.7114108204841614,
-0.5370011329650879,
0.5217770934104919,
-0.4710317552089691,
-0.3547840714454651,
-0.09230107814073563,
0.19476383924484253,
0.44514963030815125,
0.420664519071579,
0.5681039094924927,
-0.12071798741817474,
-0.3427131772041321,
-0.9092071056365967,
-0.2656395435333252,
-0.1401797980070114,
-0.14179974794387817,
0.20226696133613586,
0.41034629940986633,
-0.27978044748306274,
1.071964979171753,
-0.879032552242279,
-0.3370809257030487,
-0.3107690215110779,
0.41339805722236633,
-0.12964577972888947,
0.5295966267585754,
0.38884279131889343,
-1.1950032711029053,
-0.5279149413108826,
0.31252866983413696,
-0.7011406421661377,
-0.06985674798488617,
0.17478616535663605,
-0.2718464732170105,
-0.011111616156995296,
-0.03500174731016159,
-0.8099501132965088,
0.5757595300674438,
0.17794503271579742,
0.03513121232390404,
0.5838643908500671,
0.15058569610118866,
0.25816109776496887,
-0.9379065036773682,
0.14262624084949493,
0.8479902148246765,
-0.4247315227985382,
-0.34737974405288696,
-0.021422717720270157,
0.3576655089855194,
-0.07227481156587601,
-0.45435571670532227,
0.6315423846244812,
-0.7138174772262573,
-0.23550711572170258,
-0.2009434998035431,
0.35300523042678833,
0.4952399730682373,
0.6020914912223816,
0.0695568323135376,
0.6635177731513977,
-0.03677792102098465,
-0.90714031457901,
0.21061766147613525,
0.4647509455680847,
-0.0936826840043068,
0.7308897972106934,
-0.37746310234069824,
0.07798024266958237,
0.24101047217845917,
-0.16727948188781738,
-0.5860327482223511,
-0.19085831940174103,
0.17989887297153473,
-0.20156975090503693,
0.4874948561191559,
-0.21889877319335938,
-0.7558296918869019,
-0.16252358257770538,
-0.13071423768997192,
0.052631910890340805,
0.41328373551368713,
-0.38367727398872375,
0.41634854674339294,
0.6607223749160767,
-0.33129972219467163,
-0.2996985912322998,
-0.3210492730140686,
0.028534045442938805,
-0.2068498283624649,
-0.5487931966781616,
0.6387664675712585,
0.22384755313396454,
-0.281149685382843,
0.07628767937421799,
-0.1411300003528595,
-0.5798740983009338,
0.20609521865844727,
-0.15150223672389984,
0.39697107672691345,
-0.4147370159626007,
0.15013419091701508,
0.09767213463783264,
-0.19099105894565582,
-0.09016148746013641,
-0.3565864861011505,
0.4724923372268677,
0.01742454804480076,
-0.39322802424430847,
-0.9372897744178772,
0.2899463176727295,
0.3063008189201355,
-0.36041149497032166,
0.3709243834018707,
0.6455554962158203,
-0.8508572578430176,
-0.12973591685295105,
-0.6556181311607361,
-0.04427429661154747,
-0.4455658197402954,
0.5275029540061951,
-0.28153976798057556,
-0.27635815739631653,
0.28524404764175415,
-0.07652802020311356,
0.005223576910793781,
0.7498705983161926,
0.16954004764556885,
-0.3948194682598114,
1.0880203247070312,
0.9151629209518433,
0.023944031447172165,
0.4990593492984772,
-0.016236674040555954,
-0.02022646740078926,
-0.7088491320610046,
-0.047599874436855316,
-0.8086024522781372,
-0.2238159477710724,
-0.7468706369400024,
0.006643580738455057,
-0.023179514333605766,
0.2872579097747803,
0.16388793289661407,
0.6301668286323547,
-0.15611796081066132,
0.16339954733848572,
0.4946160912513733,
0.4013543128967285,
0.3524518311023712,
0.5858286619186401,
0.11549931764602661,
-0.1409088671207428,
-0.30146196484565735,
-0.7343732118606567,
1.0200527906417847,
0.2708330750465393,
0.6727167963981628,
0.21053507924079895,
0.6023852229118347,
0.3274800181388855,
0.1705796867609024,
-0.564698338508606,
0.5409412980079651,
-0.1386851817369461,
-0.656885027885437,
-0.2866996228694916,
-0.3929107189178467,
-1.038469910621643,
0.25568103790283203,
-0.26050496101379395,
-0.9641438126564026,
0.4295232892036438,
0.14441938698291779,
-0.23356737196445465,
0.2534467279911041,
-0.6172578930854797,
0.8891984820365906,
-0.2093041092157364,
-0.6675064563751221,
-0.051440875977277756,
-0.23735201358795166,
-0.05760256573557854,
0.05255229398608208,
0.13128827512264252,
-0.08896633237600327,
-0.10619805008172989,
0.7448164224624634,
-0.2775019407272339,
0.4862704575061798,
-0.00885336846113205,
-0.20429512858390808,
0.2015756368637085,
0.05157148092985153,
0.6297407746315002,
0.025470903143286705,
0.23797547817230225,
0.22106513381004333,
-0.2504308521747589,
-0.510837972164154,
-0.6677625179290771,
0.33798569440841675,
-0.4225936532020569,
-0.4325854778289795,
-0.1782153695821762,
-0.11468744277954102,
-0.41230812668800354,
0.36300548911094666,
0.24931149184703827,
0.5210195779800415,
-0.3670978248119354,
0.23974858224391937,
0.9603498578071594,
0.04507961869239807,
0.6509883999824524,
0.07505498081445694,
-0.09817231446504593,
-0.4177629053592682,
1.1495800018310547,
-0.1339041143655777,
0.11897209286689758,
0.7327999472618103,
0.05121854692697525,
-0.4371111989021301,
-0.4654504060745239,
-0.5601323843002319,
0.121841199696064,
-0.8367873430252075,
-0.2174021452665329,
-1.0260587930679321,
-0.021369069814682007,
-0.4428307116031647,
0.1351296752691269,
-0.11218361556529999,
-0.3534103333950043,
-0.5265083909034729,
-0.27960270643234253,
0.13309037685394287,
0.5461496710777283,
0.19203674793243408,
0.33870643377304077,
-1.3790172338485718,
0.44953036308288574,
0.3678547739982605,
-0.12699319422245026,
0.14653335511684418,
-0.003611019579693675,
-0.44459596276283264,
-0.06854315102100372,
-0.40029698610305786,
-1.1270908117294312,
0.42285895347595215,
0.1551877111196518,
0.7464151978492737,
0.9697887301445007,
-0.24506321549415588,
0.7847541570663452,
-0.3303087055683136,
0.5534343719482422,
0.20588649809360504,
-0.6941773891448975,
0.43327659368515015,
-0.4378616511821747,
-0.05201422795653343,
0.44647476077079773,
0.6767945289611816,
-0.2229139357805252,
-0.0022312484215945005,
-0.7315027117729187,
-0.9368019104003906,
0.42331281304359436,
0.42434161901474,
-0.19520263373851776,
-0.28786686062812805,
0.07274247705936432,
0.28283584117889404,
0.36743658781051636,
-0.7792595028877258,
-0.20048224925994873,
0.015462280251085758,
-0.5133278965950012,
0.4991051256656647,
-0.2883528172969818,
0.23002904653549194,
-0.022651923820376396,
0.7972522377967834,
0.03458445146679878,
0.17302069067955017,
0.12384302914142609,
-0.8589463829994202,
0.1846800595521927,
0.3095031678676605,
0.032616421580314636,
0.7301943302154541,
-0.11240159720182419,
0.03546290472149849,
-0.07381312549114227,
-0.6979456543922424,
-0.0942600816488266,
0.3516802191734314,
-0.04833243042230606,
-0.04496948793530464,
0.5002707242965698,
0.35899102687835693,
0.5286469459533691,
-0.563353955745697,
0.3793889880180359,
0.07045090198516846,
0.42838945984840393,
-0.1234249472618103,
0.015971001237630844,
-0.3045639097690582,
0.14855802059173584,
0.4979444146156311,
-0.12399061024188995,
0.6445184946060181,
-0.34213054180145264,
0.6494495868682861,
0.2453153133392334,
-0.4659905433654785,
-0.37271782755851746,
0.5239557027816772,
0.3739546835422516,
-0.14917324483394623,
0.797787606716156,
-0.2725678086280823,
-0.489496648311615,
0.5846573710441589,
0.748179018497467,
1.002371072769165,
0.14789459109306335,
-0.03813578933477402,
0.2676922380924225,
0.10081397742033005,
0.06661250442266464,
0.083894744515419,
-0.21963374316692352,
-0.6423832774162292,
0.0391475148499012,
-0.8781068921089172,
-0.13253675401210785,
-0.18890565633773804,
-0.9844855666160583,
0.3586915135383606,
-0.41419893503189087,
-0.32975098490715027,
-0.0448627844452858,
-0.05473414435982704,
-1.0143165588378906,
0.49946391582489014,
0.17947135865688324,
0.7246467471122742,
-0.5279691815376282,
0.5351729989051819,
0.6370492577552795,
-0.7330037951469421,
-0.42546144127845764,
0.4310736656188965,
0.23141074180603027,
-0.5471932291984558,
0.7731155753135681,
0.36139440536499023,
0.10638707876205444,
0.1707184910774231,
-0.22981619834899902,
-0.7167178392410278,
0.9039279818534851,
0.0014833788154646754,
-0.7522452473640442,
-0.1580590009689331,
0.00473784189671278,
0.17175042629241943,
-0.2018376886844635,
0.158284530043602,
0.3850004971027374,
0.5861777067184448,
-0.41430333256721497,
-0.8584428429603577,
0.17839522659778595,
-0.2553790509700775,
-0.1568182110786438,
0.18739363551139832,
-0.30010977387428284,
0.792564332485199,
0.19104230403900146,
-0.4432128667831421,
0.01843668892979622,
0.8958883285522461,
0.15790000557899475,
0.04421326890587807,
0.6569637656211853,
0.8432478904724121,
0.8773673176765442,
0.026946965605020523,
1.0658843517303467,
-0.06039339676499367,
0.6917638778686523,
0.8317221403121948,
-0.4433283805847168,
1.0749484300613403,
0.2551817297935486,
-0.2966839671134949,
0.5718140602111816,
0.43220028281211853,
-0.20600305497646332,
0.4048904776573181,
-0.21935993432998657,
-0.02017834410071373,
-0.3256007730960846,
0.14887164533138275,
-0.1741505116224289,
0.6513896584510803,
0.4496152102947235,
-0.24959959089756012,
-0.31385496258735657,
-0.16520623862743378,
0.1418861746788025,
-0.12405142188072205,
-0.17270000278949738,
0.7500572800636292,
0.039809565991163254,
-0.21575143933296204,
0.1277437061071396,
0.08239853382110596,
0.48037630319595337,
-0.4381270706653595,
-0.42297011613845825,
0.13636577129364014,
0.06762822717428207,
-0.10282687842845917,
-0.5338772535324097,
-0.1257515251636505,
0.15268997848033905,
-0.4038294553756714,
-0.1514766961336136,
0.9235526323318481,
-0.06685394793748856,
-0.4754135310649872,
0.2904047667980194,
0.6062266826629639,
-0.01957346312701702,
-0.4418972432613373,
-0.7041568160057068,
-0.12743672728538513,
0.047937601804733276,
-0.5061813592910767,
0.30571475625038147,
0.7758685350418091,
-0.003319690003991127,
0.4010573923587799,
0.8398969173431396,
-0.026399413123726845,
0.1434934437274933,
-0.1194961816072464,
0.6041563749313354,
-1.0303131341934204,
-0.7205594778060913,
-0.880905270576477,
0.5053207278251648,
-0.689170241355896,
-0.46552085876464844,
0.754428505897522,
0.6128554344177246,
0.7631016373634338,
0.0634840726852417,
0.8518598675727844,
0.018943116068840027,
0.2587777078151703,
-0.7330034375190735,
0.8976888656616211,
-0.5499306917190552,
-0.046029191464185715,
-0.567095935344696,
-1.3032913208007812,
0.025208234786987305,
0.5358550548553467,
0.20412757992744446,
0.22611309587955475,
0.870572030544281,
0.3081732392311096,
-0.40905603766441345,
0.277790904045105,
0.1928057074546814,
0.06703885644674301,
0.38285303115844727,
0.04784552752971649,
0.37484195828437805,
-0.46886759996414185,
0.7849030494689941,
-0.38941049575805664,
-0.436379611492157,
-0.4672955274581909,
-0.8147562146186829,
-0.5546068549156189,
-0.3760601282119751,
-0.619306206703186,
-0.1788487285375595,
-0.15774276852607727,
0.958658754825592,
0.9090503454208374,
-0.7631428241729736,
-0.029421035200357437,
0.28551122546195984,
-0.002017466351389885,
-0.424989253282547,
-0.31511199474334717,
0.4812823534011841,
-0.14348086714744568,
-0.9866555333137512,
0.10885350406169891,
0.4827083647251129,
0.3059409558773041,
0.04080425947904587,
0.4242338240146637,
-0.43363699316978455,
-0.09281978756189346,
0.5151931047439575,
0.2297927737236023,
-0.5386562347412109,
-0.33459997177124023,
0.025146640837192535,
-0.19572892785072327,
0.1658838838338852,
0.5119307637214661,
-0.49610158801078796,
-0.04382805898785591,
0.40364620089530945,
0.8870298266410828,
0.3650115728378296,
0.028299108147621155,
0.45912429690361023,
-0.7109208703041077,
0.0391823910176754,
0.054520782083272934,
0.691897988319397,
0.1679980456829071,
-0.3230645954608917,
0.2248242199420929,
0.6151735782623291,
-0.15118519961833954,
-0.4598037302494049,
0.10766356438398361,
-1.1039642095565796,
-0.2695831060409546,
1.1613889932632446,
-0.25820010900497437,
-0.5526579022407532,
-0.27379119396209717,
0.0019043011125177145,
0.2749190330505371,
-0.5092466473579407,
0.5560063719749451,
0.6876199841499329,
0.07660592347383499,
-0.1139073520898819,
-0.5495004653930664,
0.17712070047855377,
-0.10724898427724838,
-1.1253563165664673,
-0.11838779598474503,
0.5912947654724121,
0.26409441232681274,
0.2888273298740387,
0.21798628568649292,
-0.06521251052618027,
0.30768099427223206,
0.023053137585520744,
0.3139941394329071,
0.10819172114133835,
-0.47149407863616943,
0.11283192038536072,
0.40256989002227783,
-0.3494592308998108,
-0.35303205251693726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04788v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04788v1
|
Topic Modeling Analysis of Aviation Accident Reports: A Comparative Study between LDA and NMF Models
| 2024-03-04T01:41:07 | 2024-03-04T01:41:07 |
Aziida Nanyonga, Hassan Wasswa, Graham Wild
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, Topic Modeling, Aviation Safety, Aviation Accident Reports, Machine
Learning, LDA, NMF
|
Aviation safety is paramount in the modern world, with a continuous
commitment to reducing accidents and improving safety standards. Central to
this endeavor is the analysis of aviation accident reports, rich textual
resources that hold insights into the causes and contributing factors behind
aviation mishaps. This paper compares two prominent topic modeling techniques,
Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) and Non-negative Matrix Factorization (NMF),
in the context of aviation accident report analysis. The study leverages the
National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) Dataset with the primary objective
of automating and streamlining the process of identifying latent themes and
patterns within accident reports. The Coherence Value (C_v) metric was used to
evaluate the quality of generated topics. LDA demonstrates higher topic
coherence, indicating stronger semantic relevance among words within topics. At
the same time, NMF excelled in producing distinct and granular topics, enabling
a more focused analysis of specific aspects of aviation accidents.
|
[
-0.5254894495010376,
-0.8359013199806213,
0.5883838534355164,
0.31380215287208557,
-0.4550981819629669,
-0.02355201728641987,
0.5849510431289673,
-0.367923766374588,
0.5207475423812866,
0.5424111485481262,
-0.45201948285102844,
-0.13138505816459656,
-0.30201295018196106,
-0.3514755070209503,
-0.5988491773605347,
0.9386308193206787,
0.0704454705119133,
0.12522000074386597,
-0.519682765007019,
0.17220334708690643,
-0.7436373233795166,
-1.1236404180526733,
-0.5829171538352966,
0.2039930820465088,
0.7025983333587646,
0.21128149330615997,
0.21664796769618988,
0.29132071137428284,
1.1983941793441772,
0.2516900897026062,
-0.45422467589378357,
-0.08227426558732986,
-0.19386200606822968,
-0.19827833771705627,
-0.2516481578350067,
0.09338826686143875,
-0.8877339959144592,
0.022436408326029778,
0.3224412798881531,
1.0600743293762207,
-0.4865099787712097,
-0.36205819249153137,
-0.23329144716262817,
0.5716699957847595,
-0.7448723316192627,
-0.3422393202781677,
-0.3020932376384735,
0.08640364557504654,
0.1900516003370285,
-0.6928383111953735,
-0.11803431063890457,
-0.30035117268562317,
0.4685709774494171,
-0.31050142645835876,
0.3590148389339447,
0.10101596266031265,
0.8244076371192932,
0.07794710993766785,
-0.8627563118934631,
-0.5843361616134644,
-0.6360372304916382,
0.8681928515434265,
-0.5895682573318481,
0.5490434765815735,
0.25152021646499634,
-0.007759709842503071,
-0.2152927666902542,
-0.21235968172550201,
-0.30166012048721313,
-0.17992733418941498,
0.20462417602539062,
-0.021302100270986557,
0.004794325213879347,
-0.008510257117450237,
-0.20518600940704346,
0.3261142671108246,
-0.8168853521347046,
0.33777570724487305,
-0.26782459020614624,
-0.27907586097717285,
0.741576075553894,
0.6703326106071472,
0.6513400077819824,
-0.22120998799800873,
-0.35033151507377625,
-0.00420224666595459,
-0.74959397315979,
-0.3159821927547455,
0.33096638321876526,
0.28151199221611023,
-0.3383373022079468,
0.3450961410999298,
-0.41010749340057373,
0.6766420006752014,
-0.07224994152784348,
-0.4315769076347351,
0.3599523603916168,
-0.6915194988250732,
-0.1298699826002121,
0.49161750078201294,
0.3761539161205292,
0.7915228009223938,
-0.3703717589378357,
-0.4877622723579407,
-0.022270364686846733,
-0.13259419798851013,
0.33813416957855225,
-1.0048223733901978,
0.07238970696926117,
0.3579134941101074,
-0.583055317401886,
-0.536443293094635,
0.2735005021095276,
-0.8326982259750366,
-0.32998281717300415,
-0.33276602625846863,
0.23753668367862701,
0.21725039184093475,
-0.635851263999939,
0.12027376145124435,
-0.11952758580446243,
0.2102811485528946,
0.5693601965904236,
-0.48945149779319763,
-0.1724681258201599,
0.8996734023094177,
0.9719654321670532,
-0.3955457806587219,
0.020423395559191704,
-0.42201554775238037,
-0.1093471571803093,
-0.843424379825592,
1.1163545846939087,
-0.19244742393493652,
-0.552593469619751,
-0.10216948390007019,
0.053249210119247437,
0.15558680891990662,
-0.40854543447494507,
0.7200555801391602,
-0.670654833316803,
0.24746553599834442,
-0.5414599180221558,
-0.4249151945114136,
-0.3188442587852478,
0.027564965188503265,
-0.6072583794593811,
0.2878977358341217,
-0.11107368022203445,
-0.8549386858940125,
0.5860838294029236,
-0.5600124597549438,
-0.4458889067173004,
-0.5427761077880859,
-0.4178493022918701,
-0.6063158512115479,
0.2844967842102051,
-0.22891223430633545,
0.36798155307769775,
-0.4836753010749817,
0.8299487233161926,
-0.40205949544906616,
-0.1241598054766655,
0.13960207998752594,
-0.440971314907074,
0.5216541290283203,
0.04903791472315788,
0.2046385109424591,
0.24555164575576782,
-0.6357868909835815,
-0.29833337664604187,
0.02919120341539383,
-0.1862199604511261,
-0.3545507788658142,
0.2277781218290329,
0.4113050103187561,
0.5926513075828552,
0.06957526504993439,
-0.2559135854244232,
-0.5207109451293945,
-0.5005520582199097,
0.04014691337943077,
0.48706528544425964,
0.8526180386543274,
0.3425314724445343,
-0.4828795790672302,
0.3070421516895294,
0.7179877161979675,
-0.05905202403664589,
0.01668933406472206,
-0.35375314950942993,
-0.6708322167396545,
0.2767966091632843,
0.12218063324689865,
0.4379497766494751,
-0.5780356526374817,
0.5391327142715454,
-0.011839915066957474,
-0.45208540558815,
0.3624410033226013,
-0.40462592244148254,
0.09887523949146271,
0.7516716122627258,
0.046068187803030014,
-0.6112277507781982,
-0.4961641728878021,
-0.8381236791610718,
0.28452640771865845,
-0.3834865689277649,
0.2608223259449005,
0.14489227533340454,
0.2566886246204376,
0.2140336036682129,
0.7737390398979187,
-0.6490457653999329,
-0.1819775253534317,
-0.1608772575855255,
0.23366929590702057,
-0.005721654277294874,
0.9074731469154358,
1.0596588850021362,
-0.8483319878578186,
-0.3420601487159729,
-0.25463637709617615,
-0.832707941532135,
0.1558481901884079,
-0.1396220475435257,
-0.29874300956726074,
0.3692981004714966,
0.44623565673828125,
-0.09668148308992386,
0.5551583766937256,
0.18277421593666077,
-0.8756297826766968,
0.3255936801433563,
-0.07865957915782928,
0.2219330221414566,
-0.8965739607810974,
0.09086968749761581,
0.0020279381424188614,
0.2217501699924469,
-1.008354902267456,
-0.36377134919166565,
-0.33506953716278076,
-0.42180466651916504,
-0.5493831038475037,
0.2729477882385254,
-0.39039185643196106,
-0.20594827830791473,
-0.7847045660018921,
0.05934853106737137,
0.17524057626724243,
0.3388747572898865,
0.3130762577056885,
0.7805996537208557,
0.4475611448287964,
-0.4907214045524597,
-0.17825740575790405,
0.2387656569480896,
-0.1774110347032547,
0.4084438979625702,
-0.6986183524131775,
0.15219174325466156,
-0.24833525717258453,
0.013742739334702492,
-0.8433660268783569,
-0.16205760836601257,
0.1813029646873474,
-0.07685893774032593,
0.23008649051189423,
0.012744581326842308,
-0.1804639995098114,
0.2904021441936493,
-0.2721911370754242,
-0.11424826830625534,
0.13145971298217773,
-0.006883400958031416,
0.2829694449901581,
0.9867166876792908,
-0.5935776233673096,
-0.4182462990283966,
-0.4951786398887634,
0.34188246726989746,
-0.4762791693210602,
-0.4262497127056122,
0.08956779539585114,
-0.195113867521286,
-0.4482530951499939,
0.14555005729198456,
-0.5752285718917847,
-0.7168575525283813,
0.6382309794425964,
0.38062942028045654,
0.5861166715621948,
-0.6630874872207642,
0.09010965377092361,
-0.06608179211616516,
-0.27872854471206665,
0.12456893175840378,
0.37925997376441956,
0.3382857143878937,
-0.20880085229873657,
-0.09881019592285156,
-0.5014509558677673,
0.6826396584510803,
0.3725215196609497,
-0.19646324217319489,
1.1076014041900635,
-0.12893269956111908,
-0.32050076127052307,
0.2279508113861084,
-0.24892498552799225,
-0.3602431118488312,
-0.37377431988716125,
0.4716099500656128,
-0.011939827352762222,
-0.5360853672027588,
0.19223685562610626,
0.10190127044916153,
-0.07379675656557083,
0.723841667175293,
0.3771570920944214,
-0.15424925088882446,
0.33472323417663574,
1.023085355758667,
-0.1457764208316803,
0.6664139628410339,
-0.2187911719083786,
0.21815459430217743,
-0.6229956150054932,
-0.16351568698883057,
-0.7109822034835815,
0.25904780626296997,
-0.2883467972278595,
-0.39858508110046387,
0.24921558797359467,
0.036730390042066574,
0.03747829049825668,
-0.10008931905031204,
-0.39289408922195435,
0.46368321776390076,
-0.1569092720746994,
-0.33187437057495117,
0.3992053270339966,
0.25471651554107666,
0.3134138584136963,
0.0071213035844266415,
-0.6762157082557678,
-0.6406774520874023,
0.8612812161445618,
0.27446362376213074,
0.4238806664943695,
0.23530517518520355,
0.5129305720329285,
0.14086489379405975,
0.3256586492061615,
-0.3411666452884674,
0.6333253383636475,
-0.2878333628177643,
-0.9046606421470642,
-0.41878804564476013,
-0.4447582960128784,
-0.489025354385376,
0.4212738871574402,
-0.31537511944770813,
-0.5439229011535645,
0.8255795240402222,
-0.08936101943254471,
-0.2795892655849457,
0.1305638998746872,
-0.4973943829536438,
0.7236413359642029,
-0.2673407793045044,
-0.005935662426054478,
-0.17738007009029388,
-0.2921559810638428,
0.35922425985336304,
-0.455184668302536,
-0.00024003611179068685,
-0.5414338707923889,
-0.2475539743900299,
1.1279282569885254,
-0.34135597944259644,
0.715482771396637,
-0.180172860622406,
-0.40941935777664185,
0.4922366738319397,
-0.22264187037944794,
0.06458783149719238,
-0.003971447236835957,
-0.3004835546016693,
0.47554096579551697,
-0.17483727633953094,
-0.07661592215299606,
-0.37211909890174866,
0.7429444789886475,
-0.7194426655769348,
-0.3898153007030487,
-0.8351300954818726,
-0.39158010482788086,
-0.23088189959526062,
0.199561208486557,
-0.09171172976493835,
0.8549337387084961,
-0.3200420141220093,
0.19335484504699707,
0.3875129520893097,
-0.5092565417289734,
0.6524341106414795,
1.0542285442352295,
-0.13195161521434784,
-0.22796393930912018,
1.351885199546814,
0.5987298488616943,
-0.052610356360673904,
0.5658695101737976,
-0.053437188267707825,
0.03464489430189133,
-0.8995833992958069,
-0.09962339699268341,
0.046915892511606216,
-0.8950537443161011,
-0.16685958206653595,
-0.9792287945747375,
-0.557597815990448,
0.015823502093553543,
-0.1121998205780983,
-0.4205806255340576,
-0.699794590473175,
-0.49065762758255005,
-0.16515564918518066,
0.03528933227062225,
0.30962738394737244,
-0.08585312217473984,
0.3483158051967621,
-0.35306480526924133,
0.35650306940078735,
-0.09088290482759476,
0.18928325176239014,
0.26228824257850647,
-0.25763633847236633,
-0.34357917308807373,
-0.5391687154769897,
-0.540681004524231,
-0.8778842091560364,
0.1832903027534485,
-0.1822671741247177,
0.7980231642723083,
0.311341792345047,
0.36532455682754517,
0.46993255615234375,
-0.3422551155090332,
0.6810444593429565,
0.463813453912735,
-0.6368240714073181,
0.4436478018760681,
-0.28031763434410095,
-0.4449774920940399,
0.4605787694454193,
0.35390135645866394,
-0.3679705262184143,
-0.28028854727745056,
-0.5358652472496033,
-1.0168076753616333,
0.8344781994819641,
0.3824004530906677,
-0.0401451513171196,
0.01853502355515957,
0.1285252869129181,
-0.07370889186859131,
0.2235635221004486,
-0.19798186421394348,
-0.14625059068202972,
-0.2565145492553711,
0.016322514042258263,
-0.35365962982177734,
-0.6112081408500671,
-0.08493698388338089,
0.08422896265983582,
0.7396606206893921,
-0.04493093863129616,
0.5685290694236755,
0.23360899090766907,
-0.025895891711115837,
-0.32438936829566956,
0.1684664636850357,
1.0952153205871582,
1.161953091621399,
-0.5652429461479187,
0.22974704205989838,
-0.009325461462140083,
-0.48434141278266907,
0.47247180342674255,
-0.11981156468391418,
0.019610321149230003,
0.1075952798128128,
0.6788254380226135,
0.5306797027587891,
0.00374281732365489,
-0.5616772174835205,
0.4366309344768524,
-0.12094798684120178,
-0.018275121226906776,
-0.0774521455168724,
0.3278553783893585,
0.3475781977176666,
-0.1534399539232254,
0.3664717972278595,
-0.16722948849201202,
0.48493149876594543,
-0.5112321376800537,
0.4149889349937439,
0.11818971484899521,
-0.31683188676834106,
-0.040282782167196274,
0.4406815767288208,
0.6303836703300476,
-0.10213502496480942,
0.2916604280471802,
0.1140902191400528,
-0.051727261394262314,
1.1996501684188843,
0.167118638753891,
1.0648071765899658,
0.019545625895261765,
0.28049400448799133,
0.29483094811439514,
0.37866875529289246,
0.16574105620384216,
0.3654191493988037,
0.37424561381340027,
-0.5378968715667725,
-0.2623262107372284,
-0.5569740533828735,
-0.5163449645042419,
0.23167027533054352,
-0.5633877515792847,
-0.1911202222108841,
-0.46922799944877625,
-0.13578937947750092,
0.4127691686153412,
0.12291035056114197,
0.10347618907690048,
0.3773614168167114,
-0.17173078656196594,
0.7158949375152588,
-0.8911334276199341,
0.5290088057518005,
0.7466128468513489,
-0.5753647685050964,
-0.5257803797721863,
0.7056878209114075,
0.030196065083146095,
0.0037213750183582306,
0.8098427057266235,
0.058861300349235535,
0.21624788641929626,
-0.4041091501712799,
0.09913845360279083,
-0.9252957701683044,
0.8704971671104431,
0.2891288101673126,
-0.4693191647529602,
-0.025635728612542152,
0.2522745430469513,
0.34332677721977234,
-0.16006238758563995,
-0.15022605657577515,
-0.00987933948636055,
-0.06023293733596802,
0.07720381766557693,
-0.7503125071525574,
0.05607324466109276,
0.18918059766292572,
0.08234363794326782,
0.23002411425113678,
-0.6955543160438538,
0.7463381290435791,
-0.11483918875455856,
-0.1553678661584854,
-0.20143677294254303,
0.8703265190124512,
0.28442487120628357,
0.9474422931671143,
0.5256491303443909,
0.21732120215892792,
0.4212018549442291,
0.06856070458889008,
0.9534769058227539,
-0.12288368493318558,
0.4834080934524536,
1.22735595703125,
-0.3252183496952057,
0.6970426440238953,
0.6208358407020569,
0.017721161246299744,
0.1569061577320099,
0.7635567784309387,
0.28169625997543335,
1.0771398544311523,
-0.15536881983280182,
0.09021056443452835,
-0.19481408596038818,
-0.23970353603363037,
-0.6176761984825134,
0.30749478936195374,
0.0806960016489029,
-0.08000794798135757,
-0.6498220562934875,
0.0983358696103096,
-0.14585794508457184,
-0.4249277412891388,
-0.10021881759166718,
1.0109659433364868,
0.2916567325592041,
-0.33994054794311523,
0.302000492811203,
0.3636273443698883,
0.05026935786008835,
-0.2303565889596939,
-0.1253003478050232,
-0.5333828926086426,
-0.039116837084293365,
-0.06333093345165253,
-0.7713372707366943,
0.9303292036056519,
0.1246388703584671,
-0.4062149226665497,
0.19192561507225037,
0.7674031257629395,
-0.001631157356314361,
-0.5602022409439087,
-0.022050729021430016,
0.4435252249240875,
0.14327698945999146,
0.1630067676305771,
-0.5703667402267456,
0.33487725257873535,
-0.41892075538635254,
-0.10527203232049942,
0.5478730797767639,
0.19194912910461426,
-0.3275764584541321,
0.4442307949066162,
0.5203513503074646,
-0.13019120693206787,
-0.2876867353916168,
-0.15650616586208344,
0.9337038993835449,
-0.7925271987915039,
-1.017195463180542,
-0.5627409219741821,
0.49494874477386475,
0.04492054507136345,
-0.2082320600748062,
0.589613676071167,
0.5868321061134338,
0.17484135925769806,
0.017769239842891693,
0.3184734582901001,
-0.05884004384279251,
0.4358622133731842,
-0.7811065912246704,
0.7959485650062561,
-0.7831958532333374,
0.5594163537025452,
-0.3365045189857483,
-0.48565319180488586,
-0.20400305092334747,
0.6493263840675354,
-0.5099509358406067,
0.13564161956310272,
0.44744446873664856,
0.674526572227478,
-0.17441408336162567,
0.11084535717964172,
0.208779975771904,
0.010354728437960148,
0.6478845477104187,
0.31428200006484985,
1.10405433177948,
-0.2389369159936905,
0.1718020886182785,
-0.40977001190185547,
0.08407606929540634,
-0.7684699296951294,
-0.9697315096855164,
-0.9616800546646118,
-0.5782079696655273,
-0.7910022139549255,
-0.1363748461008072,
0.04865763708949089,
0.5482409000396729,
0.8906415700912476,
-0.8210999965667725,
-0.21780212223529816,
-0.15755122900009155,
0.5435943007469177,
0.08694002777338028,
-0.2603684663772583,
0.6164858341217041,
0.023810215294361115,
0.0022687807213515043,
0.3503910005092621,
0.5551291108131409,
0.3287624716758728,
-0.30529600381851196,
-0.05092756450176239,
-0.21025395393371582,
0.256305456161499,
0.44835996627807617,
-0.05943194776773453,
-0.507391095161438,
-0.1407165229320526,
-0.20629099011421204,
-0.2535284459590912,
0.007931373082101345,
0.7845687866210938,
-0.18241500854492188,
-0.06131758540868759,
0.6009774804115295,
0.6555348634719849,
0.041315626353025436,
-0.1438007950782776,
0.2857719659805298,
-0.3894980251789093,
0.4347847104072571,
-0.013528550043702126,
0.18274840712547302,
0.08801600337028503,
-0.6990275382995605,
0.5749873518943787,
0.3942270874977112,
-0.3658350706100464,
-1.5203561782836914,
-0.1343759149312973,
-1.1642831563949585,
-0.7046620845794678,
0.6802821159362793,
0.16081970930099487,
0.0656956359744072,
-0.30073779821395874,
-0.05823015049099922,
-0.05505578592419624,
-0.32311713695526123,
0.7435460686683655,
0.6095172762870789,
-0.25017061829566956,
-0.22168448567390442,
-0.7849384546279907,
0.3117762506008148,
0.09641515463590622,
-1.1532447338104248,
-0.2779541015625,
0.39218640327453613,
0.6234336495399475,
0.23952616751194,
0.7202513813972473,
0.07977348566055298,
0.5831296443939209,
-0.0010499577037990093,
-0.2567597031593323,
0.03393645957112312,
-0.8797891139984131,
-0.4079764783382416,
0.5474579334259033,
-0.033381976187229156,
-0.02482127770781517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.18843v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.18843v1
|
JEP-KD: Joint-Embedding Predictive Architecture Based Knowledge Distillation for Visual Speech Recognition
| 2024-03-04T00:30:24 | 2024-03-04T00:30:24 |
Chang Sun, Hong Yang, Bo Qin
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Visual Speech Recognition (VSR) tasks are generally recognized to have a
lower theoretical performance ceiling than Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR),
owing to the inherent limitations of conveying semantic information visually.
To mitigate this challenge, this paper introduces an advanced knowledge
distillation approach using a Joint-Embedding Predictive Architecture (JEPA),
named JEP-KD, designed to more effectively utilize audio features during model
training. Central to JEP-KD is the inclusion of a generative network within the
embedding layer, which enhances the video encoder's capacity for semantic
feature extraction and brings it into closer alignment with the audio features
from a pre-trained ASR model's encoder. This approach aims to progressively
reduce the performance gap between VSR and ASR. Moreover, a comprehensive
multimodal, multistage training regimen for the JEP-KD framework is
established, bolstering the robustness and efficacy of the training process.
Experiment results demonstrate that JEP-KD significantly improves the
performance of VSR models and demonstrates versatility across different VSR
platforms, indicating its potential for broader application within other
multimodal tasks.
|
[
-0.6148974895477295,
-0.7732576727867126,
0.5339770317077637,
-0.07875282317399979,
-0.3615855872631073,
0.23724305629730225,
-0.23585979640483856,
-0.24031813442707062,
0.13950011134147644,
0.23790884017944336,
-0.15984834730625153,
-0.39934027194976807,
-0.993155300617218,
-0.410112202167511,
-0.18097400665283203,
0.42836669087409973,
-0.022946123033761978,
0.46705758571624756,
-0.6615902781486511,
-0.2558608949184418,
-0.7118101119995117,
-0.3568616807460785,
-0.1901242434978485,
-0.5984507203102112,
0.2225840538740158,
0.18010392785072327,
0.3738771975040436,
0.7987249493598938,
0.4016561210155487,
0.4737226963043213,
-0.16954809427261353,
0.042926106601953506,
-0.04401381313800812,
0.4925638735294342,
0.14441832900047302,
-0.3347843289375305,
-0.35167738795280457,
-0.34958913922309875,
0.43144914507865906,
0.7139937281608582,
-0.3843684494495392,
0.19584321975708008,
0.3478132486343384,
0.6753582954406738,
-1.0063203573226929,
0.614255428314209,
-0.5726203322410583,
0.306650847196579,
-0.038087259978055954,
-0.3212137222290039,
0.0008655196870677173,
-0.10527315735816956,
0.7109350562095642,
-0.6444461941719055,
-0.06267297267913818,
-0.2534986436367035,
0.44483816623687744,
0.7445366382598877,
-0.26936930418014526,
-0.029624927788972855,
-0.9917940497398376,
0.3557460308074951,
-0.3132244944572449,
0.7734288573265076,
0.2539672553539276,
0.746418297290802,
0.09813427925109863,
-0.8239259123802185,
-0.8152051568031311,
-0.07174482941627502,
0.4001181125640869,
0.21366608142852783,
-0.16285067796707153,
0.19904640316963196,
0.29242831468582153,
0.2711595594882965,
-0.5144563317298889,
-0.3096197545528412,
-0.33958178758621216,
-0.016861911863088608,
0.17499186098575592,
-0.11724605411291122,
0.18563543260097504,
0.0630553737282753,
-0.5431020855903625,
-0.5160122513771057,
-0.208403542637825,
0.07746998220682144,
-0.08857223391532898,
0.334499329328537,
-0.24182574450969696,
0.6354938745498657,
-0.45759692788124084,
0.5009176731109619,
0.12026853114366531,
-0.5841165781021118,
0.6633696556091309,
0.03445655107498169,
-0.4828106760978699,
0.463702917098999,
0.5718821883201599,
0.2637002766132355,
0.3315874934196472,
0.06328488141298294,
-0.025126328691840172,
0.5196405053138733,
0.11502034217119217,
-0.6773351430892944,
-0.7447929382324219,
-0.059594377875328064,
-0.4858953654766083,
-0.22560074925422668,
-0.03837505355477333,
-0.7324337959289551,
-0.34323805570602417,
-0.747178852558136,
0.6981252431869507,
-0.5606720447540283,
-0.5047475695610046,
-0.02498920075595379,
-0.586138904094696,
-0.07898056507110596,
0.39458900690078735,
-0.7227866649627686,
0.2532743513584137,
0.39450719952583313,
0.688410222530365,
0.14829258620738983,
-0.2113632708787918,
-0.6610650420188904,
0.4976958632469177,
-0.10043955594301224,
0.35283052921295166,
-0.6797033548355103,
-0.31951820850372314,
-0.10758113861083984,
-0.3091290295124054,
-0.01603427529335022,
-0.5927533507347107,
0.08413281291723251,
-0.4103268086910248,
-0.15988583862781525,
-0.21534840762615204,
-0.589621365070343,
-0.3749987483024597,
0.2673734426498413,
-0.6056461334228516,
0.46381646394729614,
-0.27197694778442383,
-0.6720559597015381,
0.9155078530311584,
-0.499203085899353,
-0.1553414911031723,
0.09255480766296387,
-0.5270392298698425,
-0.5032941699028015,
0.09412966668605804,
0.49084383249282837,
0.5800547003746033,
-0.15981267392635345,
0.35981765389442444,
-0.6488447785377502,
0.031144550070166588,
-0.09200338274240494,
-0.7413021326065063,
0.308147132396698,
0.37380707263946533,
-0.22112257778644562,
-0.08147840201854706,
-1.11044180393219,
0.03711520507931709,
-0.0045689805410802364,
-0.3039182126522064,
-0.6375141143798828,
-0.00862747710198164,
-0.02430696040391922,
0.4042784869670868,
0.20162467658519745,
-0.589276134967804,
-0.11293966323137283,
-0.17695488035678864,
0.08306605368852615,
0.6174318194389343,
-0.03172243759036064,
0.5840383172035217,
0.12549634277820587,
0.6012032628059387,
0.3182390034198761,
0.08519820123910904,
0.025234591215848923,
-0.5120733976364136,
-0.5547849535942078,
-0.2677040100097656,
0.20673254132270813,
0.6192550659179688,
-1.2461183071136475,
0.46804869174957275,
-0.40977492928504944,
-0.5027679800987244,
-0.48065316677093506,
0.17322534322738647,
0.8120829463005066,
0.6878600716590881,
0.4897766709327698,
-0.3204975128173828,
-0.5101711750030518,
-0.67782062292099,
0.12946933507919312,
-0.26879996061325073,
0.021236171945929527,
0.265199214220047,
0.2478323131799698,
0.1914263218641281,
0.7921856045722961,
-0.5005329251289368,
-0.5422482490539551,
-0.1860218048095703,
0.04931442439556122,
-0.031697239726781845,
0.5190106630325317,
0.2531887888908386,
-1.1134233474731445,
-0.6339340806007385,
0.34674277901649475,
-0.89503014087677,
0.158131405711174,
0.13434895873069763,
0.25467225909233093,
-0.215092271566391,
0.5883388519287109,
-0.33058640360832214,
0.39923325181007385,
0.6444208025932312,
-0.13834352791309357,
0.10765150189399719,
-0.27411383390426636,
0.3240835666656494,
-1.176020860671997,
-0.12525402009487152,
0.030616221949458122,
-0.03798682987689972,
-0.49522149562835693,
-0.38352546095848083,
-0.10458222776651382,
-0.23428115248680115,
-0.4349639117717743,
-0.06706847250461578,
-0.45081251859664917,
-0.11637839674949646,
-0.24847309291362762,
-0.03710172697901726,
0.004471924155950546,
0.4813366234302521,
0.20446337759494781,
0.3997018337249756,
0.7714217305183411,
-0.6436779499053955,
0.538321316242218,
0.3935620188713074,
-0.4076616168022156,
0.5587774515151978,
-0.5411150455474854,
-0.18596433103084564,
-0.20429395139217377,
0.024600006639957428,
-0.90172278881073,
-0.06641937047243118,
-0.027538172900676727,
-0.6119614243507385,
0.6172317266464233,
-0.637563169002533,
-0.11459789425134659,
-0.21836407482624054,
0.09714537113904953,
0.4027174115180969,
0.5623560547828674,
-0.6621112823486328,
0.9078521728515625,
0.7981215715408325,
-0.2867291271686554,
-0.6748966574668884,
-0.6557893753051758,
-0.08761800080537796,
-0.3864336907863617,
-0.6447995901107788,
0.5489969253540039,
0.23211714625358582,
-0.05566314607858658,
0.19784747064113617,
-0.2960670292377472,
-0.1117701306939125,
-0.20134757459163666,
0.5108321309089661,
0.2419024258852005,
-0.20368380844593048,
0.0882905125617981,
0.03688276559114456,
-0.2653467655181885,
-0.012466414831578732,
-0.30414095520973206,
0.5746200084686279,
0.08661982417106628,
-0.632129967212677,
-0.5440027117729187,
0.23111996054649353,
0.7055912613868713,
-0.37082716822624207,
0.34460633993148804,
0.8790910243988037,
-0.30647173523902893,
-0.11095070838928223,
-0.6151774525642395,
0.05713020637631416,
-0.5436566472053528,
0.6262103915214539,
-0.6299750804901123,
-0.770808219909668,
0.3810729384422302,
-0.41731497645378113,
-0.5362359881401062,
0.0661320835351944,
0.47972941398620605,
-0.2666032016277313,
1.0841127634048462,
0.7179054617881775,
-0.16670829057693481,
0.8070461750030518,
-0.4166124165058136,
0.011780992150306702,
-0.7571802139282227,
-0.5934266448020935,
-0.2730357050895691,
-0.3628866374492645,
-0.6836391091346741,
-0.6375023126602173,
0.7677837014198303,
0.19324330985546112,
-0.10504434257745743,
0.2104002982378006,
-0.5165404081344604,
0.3310810923576355,
0.6758220791816711,
0.010261445306241512,
-0.02201290801167488,
0.12435036897659302,
-0.24237020313739777,
-0.03479403257369995,
-0.6654363870620728,
-0.105500228703022,
1.0810129642486572,
0.29023730754852295,
0.8877208828926086,
-0.15890435874462128,
0.668298065662384,
0.2414773404598236,
-0.6814578175544739,
-0.5310549139976501,
0.4595385789871216,
-0.1516507863998413,
-0.018666742369532585,
-0.3095575273036957,
-0.19677485525608063,
-0.34941357374191284,
0.3938026428222656,
-0.302866667509079,
-0.5242229104042053,
0.5645046830177307,
0.6156678199768066,
-0.186934694647789,
0.39608708024024963,
-0.8493974208831787,
0.7502774596214294,
-0.1745053082704544,
-0.03271672502160072,
-0.2698018550872803,
-0.7713742256164551,
0.11503713577985764,
0.28485971689224243,
-0.18747080862522125,
0.01699470542371273,
0.1340886801481247,
0.4526928961277008,
-0.378599613904953,
0.5510393977165222,
-0.7967981696128845,
0.20020492374897003,
0.21434959769248962,
-0.1891602724790573,
0.4842701852321625,
-0.02773844078183174,
0.34281402826309204,
0.01870928704738617,
0.03395189717411995,
0.19330263137817383,
-0.6943828463554382,
0.5419506430625916,
-0.6689556241035461,
-0.3196079432964325,
-0.19957120716571808,
-0.2579832673072815,
-0.40553900599479675,
-0.15853168070316315,
0.0886174738407135,
0.5119597315788269,
-0.17874029278755188,
0.5247809886932373,
0.8121116161346436,
-0.36303281784057617,
0.3418637216091156,
0.06677602231502533,
-0.1265234798192978,
-0.7098273038864136,
1.112486481666565,
0.1508551836013794,
0.3482710123062134,
0.7390196323394775,
0.1429564505815506,
-0.40986886620521545,
-0.635814368724823,
-0.45401471853256226,
-0.646817147731781,
-0.7537214756011963,
-0.19167783856391907,
-0.7563056945800781,
-0.2570936977863312,
-0.5251349210739136,
0.15280956029891968,
-0.709766685962677,
-0.347639799118042,
-0.24965843558311462,
-0.016038989648222923,
0.3778659999370575,
0.3210828900337219,
-0.04658661410212517,
0.07915514707565308,
-0.7310248017311096,
0.7428218722343445,
0.6557634472846985,
0.24291016161441803,
-0.09019608795642853,
-0.3873319923877716,
-0.22755694389343262,
-0.03471027687191963,
-0.2690339982509613,
-0.5720607042312622,
0.566188633441925,
0.4829449951648712,
0.5796085000038147,
0.482847660779953,
-0.01339008193463087,
1.1331827640533447,
-0.7096220850944519,
0.5705124735832214,
0.5308531522750854,
-0.7147000432014465,
0.8528522253036499,
-0.09797651320695877,
0.28555411100387573,
0.5477672219276428,
0.31445106863975525,
-0.1722605973482132,
-0.11703642457723618,
-0.29982486367225647,
-0.8256558179855347,
0.31303727626800537,
-0.12642154097557068,
-0.18803396821022034,
0.2150132954120636,
-0.16707094013690948,
-0.03316674008965492,
0.39304977655410767,
-0.371680349111557,
-0.30391547083854675,
-0.46320560574531555,
-0.16322845220565796,
0.12562957406044006,
-0.10550262778997421,
0.004905927460640669,
-0.6016482710838318,
0.5293930768966675,
-0.1919935792684555,
0.16336828470230103,
0.22239452600479126,
-0.11537737399339676,
0.0800078883767128,
0.1979297548532486,
0.16068297624588013,
0.4427049160003662,
-0.16373883187770844,
0.030454400926828384,
0.2531512379646301,
-0.5352282524108887,
0.1468174308538437,
0.1300623118877411,
0.19958005845546722,
-0.078093983232975,
0.2281772941350937,
1.1614367961883545,
-0.06243528425693512,
-0.39280572533607483,
0.6701584458351135,
0.0672963559627533,
-0.2758537828922272,
-0.6456586718559265,
0.204421728849411,
0.11129026114940643,
0.8846443891525269,
0.12470358610153198,
0.39638373255729675,
0.5725129246711731,
-0.32993176579475403,
0.2632981538772583,
0.3145495355129242,
-0.4304931163787842,
-0.1400102823972702,
0.7920653223991394,
0.17011919617652893,
0.08689539134502411,
0.3743700385093689,
-0.027467072010040283,
-0.42455509305000305,
0.493131160736084,
0.31163251399993896,
0.9915197491645813,
-0.376808762550354,
0.0405680350959301,
0.10777977108955383,
-0.2198866754770279,
0.2903776466846466,
0.6242138147354126,
-0.4924916625022888,
-0.7421709895133972,
-0.39942747354507446,
-0.9621101021766663,
-0.08692214637994766,
0.060893621295690536,
-1.00425386428833,
0.3376379907131195,
-0.3292365074157715,
-0.1812194287776947,
0.1059289500117302,
-0.42671456933021545,
-0.785082221031189,
0.26097217202186584,
0.5107959508895874,
0.45713114738464355,
-0.8661201000213623,
1.172714114189148,
0.5208260416984558,
-0.479252427816391,
-0.75746750831604,
-0.10601647943258286,
0.3080536723136902,
-0.6214900016784668,
0.7666139006614685,
-0.1149519756436348,
-0.14084455370903015,
-0.24199055135250092,
-0.016912924125790596,
-0.8396298885345459,
1.5241864919662476,
0.4907103478908539,
-1.0826374292373657,
0.04569076746702194,
0.1051764041185379,
0.45885932445526123,
-0.27185294032096863,
-0.24224692583084106,
0.4260461926460266,
0.3297271132469177,
0.4803601801395416,
-1.0972719192504883,
-0.37205976247787476,
-0.4485939145088196,
0.5053078532218933,
0.0740518569946289,
-0.06817738711833954,
0.6023262143135071,
-0.24535009264945984,
0.051154978573322296,
-0.23143737018108368,
0.6395309567451477,
0.3092775046825409,
0.3169534504413605,
0.7576625943183899,
0.8364309072494507,
0.4885287880897522,
-0.09855593740940094,
0.7657769918441772,
-0.215315043926239,
-0.16372525691986084,
1.4439451694488525,
-0.1617782562971115,
1.11016047000885,
0.7707929015159607,
-0.23960669338703156,
0.2898445129394531,
0.08843187242746353,
-0.1445956528186798,
1.3024238348007202,
0.06860808283090591,
-0.48049888014793396,
-0.31979939341545105,
-0.12103790789842606,
-0.6758225560188293,
1.0381163358688354,
0.30443471670150757,
-0.5474278926849365,
0.12259101122617722,
0.60890793800354,
-0.5417221784591675,
0.1326512098312378,
-0.28735145926475525,
1.2790818214416504,
0.025672243908047676,
-0.22978071868419647,
0.16713875532150269,
-0.5083675980567932,
0.6792938709259033,
-0.5610842704772949,
-0.45968765020370483,
0.5181446671485901,
0.3865664601325989,
0.08778616040945053,
-0.5860221982002258,
0.1520976424217224,
-0.2295837700366974,
-0.49679315090179443,
-0.2743617594242096,
0.9158213138580322,
-0.7944552898406982,
-0.3101564645767212,
0.554911196231842,
0.6420349478721619,
-0.17163020372390747,
-0.22362805902957916,
-0.5701892971992493,
0.12712839245796204,
-0.07271746546030045,
-0.05895126610994339,
0.4884248673915863,
0.628426194190979,
0.2902836799621582,
0.7336210608482361,
0.669784426689148,
0.39541754126548767,
0.08588100224733353,
0.4466376006603241,
1.0612504482269287,
-0.22166450321674347,
-0.7697648406028748,
-0.7813337445259094,
0.7382460236549377,
-0.1327267438173294,
0.011221016757190228,
0.42059120535850525,
0.38342058658599854,
1.0594769716262817,
-0.27835696935653687,
0.8727845549583435,
-0.21657627820968628,
0.29211053252220154,
-0.6094783544540405,
0.9179412722587585,
-0.48059603571891785,
0.2860158681869507,
-0.7558197975158691,
-0.8325907588005066,
0.010785606689751148,
0.549619197845459,
0.013771118596196175,
0.13265125453472137,
0.2614065110683441,
0.6122356057167053,
-0.19145838916301727,
0.023405738174915314,
0.7069147229194641,
0.0039036886300891638,
0.3157725930213928,
0.3424529731273651,
0.759601891040802,
-0.36637353897094727,
0.6510834693908691,
-0.6110532283782959,
-0.02895907126367092,
0.07421974837779999,
-0.7542160153388977,
-0.6235852241516113,
-1.030811071395874,
-0.4452652931213379,
0.036259982734918594,
0.24589328467845917,
0.9305970072746277,
0.8645236492156982,
-0.6090195775032043,
0.10651803761720657,
-0.19824069738388062,
-0.2581183612346649,
-0.23852375149726868,
-0.1669178456068039,
0.23657792806625366,
-0.14133456349372864,
-0.6522310972213745,
0.5488278269767761,
0.4999968111515045,
0.11727393418550491,
-0.11547432094812393,
-0.2979215085506439,
-0.0609431155025959,
-0.6129773259162903,
0.6536534428596497,
0.026519423350691795,
-0.732234537601471,
-0.3424796760082245,
-0.5246673226356506,
0.3610766530036926,
-0.04798963665962219,
0.5260599851608276,
-1.1234982013702393,
1.0443432331085205,
0.7741177082061768,
0.7204048037528992,
0.7720577716827393,
-0.16941791772842407,
0.8754367828369141,
-0.8818359375,
0.20454609394073486,
0.23559781908988953,
0.5658637285232544,
0.2732756733894348,
0.024644603952765465,
0.24512048065662384,
0.2047363519668579,
-0.3325159251689911,
-0.6625205874443054,
-0.12973754107952118,
-1.1849424839019775,
-0.050736360251903534,
0.7691611647605896,
-0.27043309807777405,
0.07653114944696426,
-0.11230719089508057,
-0.026329251006245613,
0.5490128397941589,
-0.3875904083251953,
0.5926808714866638,
0.3385413587093353,
-0.014923439361155033,
-0.3519088327884674,
-0.6157755255699158,
0.5533151030540466,
0.003976031206548214,
-0.5528500080108643,
-0.02628207579255104,
0.520039975643158,
0.27982422709465027,
0.36534956097602844,
0.367822527885437,
-0.24007974565029144,
0.5040463805198669,
0.42728033661842346,
0.2688218951225281,
-0.5110906958580017,
-0.7848424911499023,
-0.268696665763855,
0.3942181468009949,
-0.02880365401506424,
-0.8481525182723999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01643v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01643v2
|
You Need to Pay Better Attention: Rethinking the Mathematics of Attention Mechanism
| 2024-03-03T23:40:35 | 2024-05-30T17:46:22 |
Mehran Hosseini, Peyman Hosseini
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, 68T07 (Primary) 68T45, 68T50, 68T10, 15A03, 15A04 (Secondary), I.2.6; I.2.7; I.2.10; I.4.0; I.5.0; I.7.0
|
Scaled Dot Product Attention (SDPA) is the backbone of many modern
deep-learning models. It is so versatile that it has been used in natural
language, vision, and multi-modal domains with very little change compared to
its original formulation. This paper discusses why the current formulation is
inefficient by delving into the mathematical details of the attention
mechanism. We propose three improvements to mitigate these inefficiencies,
thereby, introducing three enhanced attention mechanisms: Optimised, Efficient,
and Super Attention. Optimised and Efficient Attention have one and two matrix
multiplications fewer per head, respectively, and 25% and 50% fewer parameters,
respectively, than standard SDPA, but perform similarly to standard SDPA in
both vision and natural language tasks. They can be used in all applications
where SDPA is used while offering smaller model sizes and faster training and
inference without noticeable loss in performance. Super Attention introduces a
new linear transformation on the values, transforming them from the left. It
outperforms standard SPDA on vision and natural language tasks by up to 17%
while having one fewer matrix multiplication per head and 25% fewer parameters
than standard SDPA. Consequently, it is also faster than standard SDPA. Super
Attention is ideal in applications where the attention layer's context length
is fixed, such as Vision Transformers. In addition to providing mathematical
reasoning, we evaluate the presented attention mechanisms on several datasets
including MNIST, CIFAR100, ImageNet, IMDB Movie Reviews, and Amazon Reviews
datasets, as well as combined Europarl and Anki English-Spanish datasets for
neural machine translation.
|
[
-0.4105120301246643,
-0.6005714535713196,
0.5796916484832764,
0.26267069578170776,
-0.33109793066978455,
-0.16895805299282074,
-0.16101695597171783,
-0.4116480350494385,
0.27343064546585083,
0.40954142808914185,
-0.6165468096733093,
0.14704878628253937,
-0.6527636051177979,
0.02530374564230442,
-0.1345841884613037,
0.7697073221206665,
0.01850302517414093,
0.16024954617023468,
-0.38930079340934753,
-0.3517732322216034,
-0.10437817126512527,
-0.40699201822280884,
-0.8049778342247009,
-0.3404448330402374,
0.7333354949951172,
0.15658316016197205,
0.8177135586738586,
0.5559841394424438,
1.1737067699432373,
0.2810664474964142,
-0.2685360610485077,
0.24132040143013,
-0.7732494473457336,
-0.22760440409183502,
0.03680312633514404,
-0.5146617889404297,
-0.6447713971138,
0.014200775884091854,
0.5074877738952637,
0.8083206415176392,
0.14853239059448242,
0.38641804456710815,
0.28630757331848145,
1.2212244272232056,
-0.9668676257133484,
0.17232772707939148,
-0.33667871356010437,
0.1048412024974823,
0.09649355709552765,
-0.15608321130275726,
-0.20726244151592255,
-0.3723529577255249,
0.28144559264183044,
-0.8774799108505249,
0.16306383907794952,
-0.284788578748703,
0.8982470631599426,
0.8318705558776855,
-0.19976507127285004,
-0.029282471165060997,
-0.722691535949707,
0.977736234664917,
-0.4759213328361511,
0.5343421697616577,
0.14497390389442444,
0.3908473253250122,
0.12465076148509979,
-0.7085156440734863,
-0.6273173093795776,
-0.19823944568634033,
0.23381228744983673,
0.09631874412298203,
-0.32445722818374634,
-0.05627540871500969,
0.5476744771003723,
0.4627813398838043,
-0.17262804508209229,
-0.02779255248606205,
-0.38547617197036743,
-0.0202914047986269,
0.4698554277420044,
0.25397661328315735,
-0.002327250549569726,
0.38792937994003296,
-0.534397304058075,
-0.28455570340156555,
-0.9929190278053284,
-0.027153411880135536,
0.35555222630500793,
0.07422775030136108,
0.04733632877469063,
0.5480562448501587,
-0.3911549746990204,
0.8264778256416321,
0.5914842486381531,
-0.10389450937509537,
0.23946358263492584,
-0.5304713845252991,
-0.47620517015457153,
-0.21645742654800415,
0.42661505937576294,
0.7255899310112,
0.6034154891967773,
-0.05863850936293602,
0.01436266116797924,
0.33923664689064026,
0.6244609355926514,
-0.7510466575622559,
-0.08035364001989365,
0.20368270576000214,
-0.3937763571739197,
-0.3172507882118225,
-0.46864941716194153,
-0.5137715339660645,
-0.14214101433753967,
-0.7743737101554871,
0.36841219663619995,
-0.28888610005378723,
0.004978356417268515,
0.358927845954895,
0.24619323015213013,
0.1915176659822464,
0.1540115624666214,
-1.176769733428955,
0.1718396097421646,
0.7082510590553284,
0.5327811241149902,
-0.022188952192664146,
-0.1984981894493103,
-0.4835910201072693,
0.2111022174358368,
-0.6989485025405884,
0.9681513905525208,
-0.7311744093894958,
0.14734122157096863,
-0.1927211731672287,
-0.36398032307624817,
-0.31661227345466614,
-0.6645709276199341,
0.550862729549408,
-0.6005252003669739,
0.18726857006549835,
-0.4401150643825531,
-0.39975854754447937,
-0.28612732887268066,
0.02884030155837536,
-0.7641040086746216,
1.0356332063674927,
-0.02055298164486885,
-0.6349948048591614,
0.6782549619674683,
-0.8784587383270264,
-0.42606350779533386,
-0.11917927116155624,
0.17513437569141388,
-0.4905906319618225,
0.3440493047237396,
0.5657676458358765,
0.5588135719299316,
-0.13887208700180054,
0.052355870604515076,
-0.5336321592330933,
-0.2762990891933441,
0.29485106468200684,
-0.126620814204216,
0.6237718462944031,
0.23747552931308746,
-0.22942110896110535,
0.028957264497876167,
-0.8752782344818115,
-0.002940987702459097,
0.009432436898350716,
-0.22617557644844055,
-0.27172115445137024,
-0.08261419832706451,
-0.1463649719953537,
0.38305211067199707,
0.19478516280651093,
-0.42100590467453003,
-0.14053583145141602,
-0.8147537708282471,
0.5742074251174927,
0.8260833024978638,
0.17750246822834015,
0.7438225150108337,
0.31259819865226746,
0.408974289894104,
-0.043586552143096924,
0.4121643304824829,
0.03432874754071236,
-0.18565477430820465,
-0.9191542267799377,
-0.36590510606765747,
0.24835850298404694,
0.14527647197246552,
-0.8520026206970215,
0.14893653988838196,
-0.3113718628883362,
-0.0002417822543065995,
-0.6630079746246338,
0.13798978924751282,
0.5746030211448669,
0.36029601097106934,
0.20845435559749603,
-0.5355547070503235,
-0.33869776129722595,
-1.0467454195022583,
-0.4234606921672821,
0.036585673689842224,
-0.1495092362165451,
0.24789448082447052,
0.16955295205116272,
-0.09631945192813873,
0.7567737102508545,
-0.590646505355835,
-0.5438774824142456,
-0.2774479389190674,
-0.21522141993045807,
0.18597924709320068,
0.06290091574192047,
0.530822217464447,
-0.7830384373664856,
-0.6820496320724487,
-0.04068664088845253,
-0.569965660572052,
0.07451803982257843,
-0.2533778250217438,
0.02487613447010517,
0.15684832632541656,
0.4569574296474457,
-0.794331431388855,
0.337822824716568,
0.14050479233264923,
-0.0032420996576547623,
0.19383504986763,
0.002221125178039074,
-0.2320474088191986,
-0.8737014532089233,
0.004399868659675121,
0.3987971842288971,
0.0985448881983757,
-0.8625684976577759,
0.5592296719551086,
0.28718996047973633,
-0.1192014291882515,
-0.6534926891326904,
0.2944912314414978,
-0.5493338108062744,
-0.12998920679092407,
-0.3245774507522583,
0.2946976125240326,
-0.05056797340512276,
0.9014487266540527,
-0.2372439205646515,
0.7896897196769714,
0.6478450298309326,
-0.9447656869888306,
0.4967857897281647,
0.023674575611948967,
-0.1749257743358612,
1.0025999546051025,
-0.8776161670684814,
0.13062041997909546,
-0.2493840605020523,
0.18212297558784485,
-1.0354424715042114,
-0.018980832770466805,
0.30182862281799316,
-0.5688074827194214,
0.5031976699829102,
0.24969954788684845,
-0.6320310235023499,
-0.4664818346500397,
-0.5102183222770691,
0.15805558860301971,
0.09508928656578064,
-0.7426920533180237,
0.5304945111274719,
0.35862013697624207,
0.029153209179639816,
-0.5118516683578491,
-0.5518151521682739,
0.23527246713638306,
-0.3024258017539978,
-0.49243441224098206,
0.14386717975139618,
-0.04599953070282936,
-0.22134798765182495,
-0.06469372659921646,
-0.38639241456985474,
-0.003717264859005809,
0.04547569528222084,
-0.2143338918685913,
0.062092654407024384,
-0.10153740644454956,
0.2334497570991516,
-0.17599014937877655,
-0.6169286966323853,
0.061687685549259186,
-0.20172522962093353,
0.29917317628860474,
0.0526430569589138,
-0.022044910117983818,
-0.7486934065818787,
0.2777974307537079,
0.751979410648346,
-0.45272308588027954,
0.3341442942619324,
0.664436399936676,
-0.2716541886329651,
-0.012971807271242142,
-0.3571409583091736,
-0.5282031297683716,
-0.483055055141449,
0.3775605261325836,
-0.5228478312492371,
-0.7109229564666748,
0.07420720905065536,
0.15477141737937927,
0.1175524964928627,
0.4057365953922272,
0.8854451775550842,
-0.07086147367954254,
1.291995882987976,
1.0336672067642212,
-0.053879573941230774,
0.6063160300254822,
-0.21779891848564148,
0.7084231376647949,
-1.248477816581726,
-0.13606718182563782,
-0.2552637457847595,
-0.6165018677711487,
-0.1283555030822754,
-0.4682939648628235,
0.18563657999038696,
-0.21812449395656586,
-0.019289912655949593,
0.6676052212715149,
-0.5743132829666138,
0.6015026569366455,
0.41938742995262146,
0.04687189683318138,
0.03901009261608124,
0.3123514950275421,
0.025250839069485664,
-0.45472705364227295,
-0.7341963052749634,
-0.45568570494651794,
1.4090553522109985,
0.6519638299942017,
0.9297860860824585,
-0.057722389698028564,
0.34205326437950134,
-0.025338953360915184,
0.13710512220859528,
-0.8622662425041199,
0.7092636823654175,
-0.15912991762161255,
-0.504708468914032,
-0.25917747616767883,
-0.2950397729873657,
-0.6740824580192566,
0.3050312101840973,
0.10721170902252197,
-0.636397123336792,
0.649246335029602,
0.15069672465324402,
-0.7367435693740845,
-0.08782193809747696,
-1.1342905759811401,
0.716642439365387,
0.1101190522313118,
-0.5377890467643738,
-0.5542399883270264,
-0.5171334147453308,
0.14665190875530243,
-0.09086019545793533,
-0.2886087894439697,
-0.08778955042362213,
-0.19657482206821442,
0.44251319766044617,
-0.20477688312530518,
1.0719094276428223,
0.015459832735359669,
-0.41209885478019714,
0.03916483372449875,
-0.24077734351158142,
0.5964968204498291,
-0.08199206739664078,
0.5158448219299316,
-0.057315707206726074,
-0.5297871232032776,
-0.40350955724716187,
-0.7326599359512329,
0.7223667502403259,
-0.4306049346923828,
-0.4254626929759979,
-0.17072473466396332,
-0.6019079089164734,
-0.25064218044281006,
0.0478363037109375,
-0.06740500777959824,
0.48781219124794006,
0.07474932074546814,
0.3908264636993408,
1.0801194906234741,
0.2706669569015503,
0.5241625905036926,
0.5433859825134277,
0.18192516267299652,
-0.36010459065437317,
1.118025302886963,
0.2627350389957428,
0.5389766693115234,
0.6862210631370544,
-0.23919686675071716,
-0.46492138504981995,
-0.2541978359222412,
-0.398111492395401,
0.368049681186676,
-0.6518946886062622,
-0.03629065677523613,
-0.9285975694656372,
0.15475401282310486,
-0.6207676529884338,
-0.043886225670576096,
-0.4078184962272644,
-0.6760481595993042,
-0.449818879365921,
-0.19160474836826324,
0.17255261540412903,
0.32039472460746765,
-0.1649935245513916,
0.08508601039648056,
-0.12793944776058197,
0.8909254670143127,
0.6749772429466248,
0.4958401322364807,
0.06240962818264961,
-0.40619415044784546,
-0.4490112066268921,
-0.11287826299667358,
-0.38338446617126465,
-0.528998076915741,
0.2821636497974396,
0.3255132734775543,
0.6094664931297302,
0.718224287033081,
-0.19201581180095673,
0.7128257751464844,
-0.7111261487007141,
0.49834302067756653,
0.28055328130722046,
-0.6409409642219543,
0.24794341623783112,
0.06679823249578476,
0.27722111344337463,
0.25762739777565,
0.2854599356651306,
-0.292458176612854,
-0.448830246925354,
-0.5446604490280151,
-0.6360384821891785,
0.7853344678878784,
0.30434519052505493,
0.2037443071603775,
0.11349707841873169,
0.1269267201423645,
-0.18719685077667236,
0.05055435746908188,
-0.42382606863975525,
-0.2708571255207062,
0.01024140976369381,
-0.06694542616605759,
-0.34869131445884705,
-0.5609755516052246,
-0.22426681220531464,
-0.12275906652212143,
0.6400354504585266,
-0.31339091062545776,
0.31961366534233093,
0.2638026773929596,
-0.006343118846416473,
-0.2864850163459778,
-0.07204613834619522,
0.7428060173988342,
0.8699368834495544,
-0.09181443601846695,
-0.019104206934571266,
0.03966287896037102,
-0.7318045496940613,
-0.13773660361766815,
-0.006393062882125378,
-0.2100268006324768,
-0.1339537352323532,
0.15444326400756836,
0.8876763582229614,
0.35613057017326355,
-0.33553650975227356,
0.15683084726333618,
-0.007086908910423517,
-0.24471966922283173,
0.2057863473892212,
-0.08933646976947784,
0.1445358842611313,
0.2875426709651947,
0.21573886275291443,
0.19194474816322327,
0.45930686593055725,
-0.34035274386405945,
0.11912526935338974,
0.28228962421417236,
-0.5827955603599548,
-0.1778251826763153,
0.854701578617096,
0.2640330195426941,
-0.2623147964477539,
-0.032176412642002106,
0.20489786565303802,
-0.4114205241203308,
0.6979642510414124,
0.3508498966693878,
1.1762721538543701,
-0.21148160099983215,
0.3551342189311981,
0.2905077338218689,
0.6558369994163513,
0.1506253182888031,
0.05111583322286606,
-0.27722010016441345,
-0.4700416922569275,
-0.6151803135871887,
-0.45717254281044006,
-0.4662972390651703,
-0.16566625237464905,
-0.6864238381385803,
-0.11645904183387756,
-0.46513259410858154,
-0.1847550868988037,
0.5742878913879395,
0.1032780185341835,
-0.5951194167137146,
0.3599068522453308,
0.080388642847538,
0.6130895614624023,
-0.760512113571167,
0.5810104608535767,
0.7663908004760742,
-0.46704933047294617,
-0.3130474090576172,
0.12416137754917145,
-0.25379639863967896,
-0.8834555149078369,
0.6014671921730042,
0.2706516981124878,
-0.2575417757034302,
0.03210632503032684,
-0.6972385048866272,
-1.1579699516296387,
0.6137526035308838,
0.4830746054649353,
-0.47130709886550903,
0.27197974920272827,
0.253375768661499,
0.8332875967025757,
-0.3866004943847656,
-0.1213582381606102,
0.6406834125518799,
0.1923963725566864,
-0.08212228119373322,
-0.5469876527786255,
-0.14642822742462158,
-0.22061583399772644,
0.4000149071216583,
0.1257385015487671,
-0.8752815127372742,
0.6530012488365173,
-0.4521576166152954,
-0.4373002052307129,
-0.24890919029712677,
0.6968356966972351,
0.08570893108844757,
0.26564985513687134,
0.2580423057079315,
1.0812126398086548,
0.35057154297828674,
-0.029812488704919815,
1.2556003332138062,
-0.07535439729690552,
0.4066472053527832,
0.874992847442627,
-0.5139350295066833,
0.7156087160110474,
0.9557880163192749,
-0.5394652485847473,
0.15533562004566193,
0.7620775699615479,
0.17835599184036255,
0.8014398813247681,
0.055722832679748535,
-0.0999944657087326,
-0.24530816078186035,
-0.08125920593738556,
-0.42901983857154846,
-0.04239344224333763,
0.26751765608787537,
-0.2858969271183014,
-0.17856334149837494,
0.0572921447455883,
-0.20315536856651306,
0.1798233538866043,
-0.3688817024230957,
0.9336373805999756,
0.2688497006893158,
-0.43829524517059326,
0.7783554196357727,
-0.1593492180109024,
0.1541168987751007,
-0.2909020185470581,
0.01949877291917801,
-0.5252872705459595,
0.7576102614402771,
0.1052994579076767,
-0.6200860738754272,
0.25170934200286865,
-0.04371121898293495,
-0.4984222948551178,
-0.2599042057991028,
0.5697165727615356,
-0.23684023320674896,
-0.6978172659873962,
0.08978372812271118,
-0.09498923271894455,
0.12944091856479645,
-0.33710530400276184,
-0.9178193807601929,
0.09111112356185913,
-0.054780520498752594,
-0.1999831646680832,
0.23172244429588318,
0.566720187664032,
0.042359717190265656,
0.8505853414535522,
0.8545520305633545,
-0.2794819474220276,
0.17751769721508026,
0.3862280249595642,
1.1130552291870117,
-0.3682330548763275,
-0.6295933127403259,
-0.7595949769020081,
0.13225893676280975,
-0.2968151569366455,
-0.40331360697746277,
0.8465207815170288,
0.35966554284095764,
0.7678024172782898,
-0.21428926289081573,
0.2093002051115036,
0.3320213556289673,
0.5735048055648804,
-0.5576063990592957,
0.46918830275535583,
-0.6493474245071411,
0.21348440647125244,
-0.3341084420681,
-1.3495088815689087,
-0.6059824228286743,
0.49641382694244385,
-0.3241131007671356,
-0.03636403754353523,
0.9512626528739929,
0.6642906069755554,
0.024762747809290886,
-0.2786167860031128,
0.4365955591201782,
0.1776696890592575,
0.163152277469635,
0.9959694147109985,
0.46225735545158386,
-0.48762956261634827,
0.5755115151405334,
-0.30848973989486694,
-0.15067632496356964,
-0.3791559636592865,
-0.5653656125068665,
-0.8873624801635742,
-0.28882041573524475,
-0.4858536720275879,
-0.047070521861314774,
0.06839307397603989,
0.2618963420391083,
0.766697883605957,
-0.7252562642097473,
0.2017427682876587,
-0.03175877034664154,
0.1522047519683838,
-0.6839950084686279,
-0.1760350912809372,
0.4787338972091675,
-0.639835774898529,
-0.9688000679016113,
0.3282373249530792,
0.7971250414848328,
-0.1861129254102707,
-0.5860142111778259,
0.07607799768447876,
-0.10435525327920914,
0.3236101269721985,
0.91399085521698,
0.2185995876789093,
-0.7306051850318909,
-0.0281918216496706,
0.1465292125940323,
-0.27312201261520386,
0.04787667840719223,
0.7658703327178955,
-0.6190803647041321,
0.6757771968841553,
0.4096035063266754,
0.7688350081443787,
0.4074546694755554,
-0.2372203916311264,
0.6764626502990723,
-0.575892984867096,
0.14580011367797852,
0.02686407044529915,
0.10202453285455704,
0.40267935395240784,
-0.5313732028007507,
0.7481611967086792,
0.2620011568069458,
-0.3166809678077698,
-0.7806574106216431,
0.4141778349876404,
-0.9456650614738464,
0.040904171764850616,
0.9861965179443359,
0.12371522933244705,
-0.5776448845863342,
0.02004634030163288,
-0.34279605746269226,
-0.21415188908576965,
-0.3643236756324768,
0.8599987626075745,
0.6833919286727905,
0.11932650953531265,
-0.24345411360263824,
-0.5304093360900879,
0.5560073852539062,
0.7545953989028931,
-0.5048723816871643,
0.20040254294872284,
0.3431013226509094,
-0.030375298112630844,
0.3177601397037506,
0.4551464319229126,
-0.34441593289375305,
0.6225689649581909,
-0.0360725000500679,
0.06732503324747086,
0.15336599946022034,
-0.6699225902557373,
-0.5912268161773682,
0.1655884087085724,
-0.5065440535545349,
-0.5026038885116577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.01638v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.01638v1
|
Multi-level Product Category Prediction through Text Classification
| 2024-03-03T23:10:36 | 2024-03-03T23:10:36 |
Wesley Ferreira Maia, Angelo Carmignani, Gabriel Bortoli, Lucas Maretti, David Luz, Daniel Camilo Fuentes Guzman, Marcos Jardel Henriques, Francisco Louzada Neto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This article investigates applying advanced machine learning models,
specifically LSTM and BERT, for text classification to predict multiple
categories in the retail sector. The study demonstrates how applying data
augmentation techniques and the focal loss function can significantly enhance
accuracy in classifying products into multiple categories using a robust
Brazilian retail dataset. The LSTM model, enriched with Brazilian word
embedding, and BERT, known for its effectiveness in understanding complex
contexts, were adapted and optimized for this specific task. The results showed
that the BERT model, with an F1 Macro Score of up to $99\%$ for segments,
$96\%$ for categories and subcategories and $93\%$ for name products,
outperformed LSTM in more detailed categories. However, LSTM also achieved high
performance, especially after applying data augmentation and focal loss
techniques. These results underscore the effectiveness of NLP techniques in
retail and highlight the importance of the careful selection of modelling and
preprocessing strategies. This work contributes significantly to the field of
NLP in retail, providing valuable insights for future research and practical
applications.
|
[
-0.18699190020561218,
-0.7938984036445618,
-0.027429427951574326,
0.4765439033508301,
0.008423595689237118,
0.42220354080200195,
-0.12832216918468475,
-1.020134687423706,
-0.3870214521884918,
0.3888148069381714,
-0.6295011043548584,
-0.7819064855575562,
-0.3444426357746124,
0.1705053299665451,
-0.527868390083313,
0.9921038746833801,
0.11066125333309174,
0.144093319773674,
-0.13722579181194305,
-0.14563357830047607,
-0.6193925738334656,
-1.038116693496704,
-0.7525284290313721,
-0.3457484245300293,
0.47740960121154785,
0.087381511926651,
0.5249759554862976,
0.1915578693151474,
0.5569819211959839,
0.350618839263916,
-0.011738411150872707,
0.28639212250709534,
-0.030605610460042953,
0.20781654119491577,
0.18851609528064728,
-0.5003462433815002,
-0.5329359769821167,
-0.3346698582172394,
0.1931765079498291,
0.3429694175720215,
-0.2981942296028137,
-0.03489680215716362,
0.23619043827056885,
0.6799842119216919,
-0.4339299499988556,
0.230119988322258,
-0.6773648262023926,
0.3829869329929352,
0.22891059517860413,
-0.020793218165636063,
-0.7406423091888428,
-0.1763879954814911,
0.4070621430873871,
-0.5633379817008972,
0.4674232304096222,
0.20400184392929077,
0.946576714515686,
0.18051442503929138,
-0.32517221570014954,
-0.455020934343338,
-1.0930688381195068,
0.9276239275932312,
-0.5956459641456604,
0.7336754202842712,
0.30450689792633057,
0.0801066979765892,
0.16846458613872528,
-0.6246764063835144,
-0.10555046796798706,
0.002247442491352558,
-0.29535552859306335,
0.1534719318151474,
-0.3327043056488037,
0.004325224086642265,
-0.1787462830543518,
0.38976120948791504,
-0.39760300517082214,
0.1779143214225769,
-0.4295423924922943,
0.4710395336151123,
0.5786057710647583,
0.021199507638812065,
-0.13471707701683044,
-0.007027973420917988,
-0.7878131866455078,
-0.1527770310640335,
-0.39009466767311096,
0.09256859123706818,
0.01939760334789753,
0.4991525113582611,
0.5686661601066589,
0.3965722918510437,
-0.03750252351164818,
0.8631044030189514,
-0.2563421428203583,
-0.5917819738388062,
0.4286303222179413,
-0.5513867139816284,
-0.7062070369720459,
0.27255144715309143,
0.33321523666381836,
0.3042071759700775,
0.14830581843852997,
-0.0021449474152177572,
-0.29851487278938293,
-0.3336036503314972,
0.4503006041049957,
-0.16817738115787506,
0.021721038967370987,
0.2742733061313629,
-0.5831990242004395,
-0.17979861795902252,
0.12635964155197144,
-0.5506696105003357,
-0.25879722833633423,
-0.2951652705669403,
0.23024843633174896,
-0.3239189088344574,
0.25153306126594543,
0.3427608609199524,
-0.13191498816013336,
-0.04356948658823967,
0.49852630496025085,
-0.6604369282722473,
0.4370397627353668,
0.7308340668678284,
0.7114126682281494,
0.05848732218146324,
-0.003999837674200535,
0.1430763155221939,
0.5622989535331726,
-0.2910884618759155,
0.6500940918922424,
-0.28492486476898193,
-0.10275746881961823,
0.5357348322868347,
0.040838103741407394,
0.09796340018510818,
-0.6077040433883667,
0.7900360226631165,
-0.5401697158813477,
0.26839306950569153,
0.23883993923664093,
-0.4551953375339508,
-0.6392284035682678,
0.6006900668144226,
-0.7281115651130676,
1.2482491731643677,
0.19152407348155975,
-0.5569779276847839,
0.8482784032821655,
-0.40340253710746765,
-0.6972193717956543,
0.18530409038066864,
0.38258302211761475,
-0.7740454077720642,
0.22164522111415863,
0.5778820514678955,
0.9588907361030579,
0.025519896298646927,
0.38905686140060425,
-0.34913527965545654,
-0.17729617655277252,
0.2618379294872284,
-0.42621228098869324,
0.11822336912155151,
0.24904809892177582,
-0.1710393726825714,
0.13401922583580017,
-0.6228410601615906,
-0.2922399640083313,
-0.22896212339401245,
-0.4452945590019226,
-0.4788144528865814,
0.26295703649520874,
0.3786340653896332,
0.2964980900287628,
0.26099908351898193,
-0.4624232053756714,
0.4914361238479614,
-0.20330575108528137,
0.18601252138614655,
0.750762403011322,
-0.21269182860851288,
0.272705078125,
-0.2590758204460144,
0.5376836657524109,
-0.17265619337558746,
0.5822091698646545,
-0.11092264950275421,
-0.7415662407875061,
-0.7766308784484863,
-0.22764630615711212,
0.3638221323490143,
0.7802548408508301,
-0.4861759841442108,
0.7489930987358093,
-0.11240875720977783,
-0.5514150261878967,
-0.302499383687973,
-0.059117186814546585,
0.04443108290433884,
0.2839714288711548,
0.5719476342201233,
-0.19812196493148804,
-0.6055141687393188,
-1.0254489183425903,
-0.2474668174982071,
-0.16063973307609558,
-0.12602098286151886,
0.4024865925312042,
-0.08216044306755066,
-0.540238618850708,
0.8510940670967102,
-0.853424072265625,
-1.0914491415023804,
-0.4591631591320038,
0.2497776746749878,
0.7013049125671387,
0.339937299489975,
0.4199271500110626,
-0.6295869946479797,
-0.48037248849868774,
0.3384564518928528,
-0.2840622067451477,
0.19129303097724915,
-0.27338680624961853,
0.3266506791114807,
0.46153488755226135,
0.34092170000076294,
-0.10211969166994095,
0.6493286490440369,
0.23842111229896545,
-0.2529401481151581,
0.3228434920310974,
-0.4489898085594177,
-0.0036309973802417517,
-1.0331867933273315,
-0.4313925504684448,
0.787045955657959,
-0.23666244745254517,
-0.666394054889679,
-0.3203085958957672,
0.08150088787078857,
0.043755706399679184,
-0.6572683453559875,
0.0316653810441494,
-0.06582752615213394,
-0.3684254288673401,
0.19238798320293427,
-0.6573042273521423,
0.3082312047481537,
0.36659422516822815,
0.4644700288772583,
0.5645599961280823,
0.2812393307685852,
-0.8262826800346375,
0.2987871766090393,
0.2804321348667145,
-0.7607855200767517,
0.3019765317440033,
-0.5909972190856934,
-0.5311558246612549,
-0.21472570300102234,
0.5092294812202454,
-1.0733460187911987,
0.1203206405043602,
0.07147426158189774,
-0.2448829859495163,
0.5400323271751404,
0.168265238404274,
-0.8783012628555298,
-0.7840553522109985,
-0.1619204580783844,
0.09622873365879059,
0.3171883225440979,
-0.5993288159370422,
0.3762514889240265,
0.16400673985481262,
-0.1741788536310196,
-0.7724520564079285,
-1.1340389251708984,
-0.12816636264324188,
-0.542732834815979,
-0.41501036286354065,
0.4538622796535492,
-0.06043238565325737,
0.2607510983943939,
-0.27052566409111023,
0.12532885372638702,
-0.18553678691387177,
0.15152278542518616,
-0.05799731984734535,
0.2487552911043167,
-0.028317345306277275,
0.613767147064209,
0.024907860904932022,
-0.10261949896812439,
-0.15260392427444458,
-0.2877728044986725,
0.579954206943512,
-0.35754939913749695,
-0.11021331697702408,
-0.42000308632850647,
0.31160593032836914,
-0.11667167395353317,
-0.028233367949724197,
0.8196269869804382,
1.0842030048370361,
-0.5285963416099548,
-0.35081321001052856,
-0.430003821849823,
0.13184872269630432,
-0.47687914967536926,
0.6903243064880371,
-0.2808944582939148,
-0.6680454015731812,
0.17498721182346344,
0.06075546517968178,
-0.07228386402130127,
0.42936697602272034,
0.5771014094352722,
-0.20532642304897308,
1.437877893447876,
0.865118682384491,
-0.045740626752376556,
0.6033124923706055,
-0.2586107552051544,
0.7269315719604492,
-0.5010114908218384,
-0.9871994256973267,
-0.7271300554275513,
-0.569087028503418,
-0.5788847208023071,
-0.3884115219116211,
0.551490843296051,
0.3047234117984772,
-0.4209190011024475,
0.4407180845737457,
-1.1532195806503296,
0.35003259778022766,
0.9222573041915894,
0.36744776368141174,
0.42234450578689575,
0.48203057050704956,
0.2054523080587387,
-0.10028918087482452,
-0.8691915273666382,
-0.19567610323429108,
1.0018709897994995,
0.9790220260620117,
1.0489740371704102,
-0.037897802889347076,
0.4356255829334259,
0.40181225538253784,
0.6324344277381897,
-1.1491036415100098,
0.06025557592511177,
-0.6578732132911682,
-0.5840898156166077,
-0.006395522505044937,
-0.09551352262496948,
-0.9188636541366577,
-0.0025443565100431442,
-0.19872573018074036,
-0.8298583030700684,
0.656928539276123,
-0.10407509654760361,
-0.4334211051464081,
0.26116546988487244,
-0.779772162437439,
0.6025063991546631,
-0.7315329313278198,
-0.1275627613067627,
0.00193792802747339,
-0.3718038499355316,
0.3351251482963562,
-0.32503706216812134,
0.4304693639278412,
-0.2234342396259308,
-0.2810898721218109,
0.9946660399436951,
-0.13151167333126068,
0.7117809653282166,
0.30673983693122864,
-0.4242275655269623,
-0.0022141276858747005,
-0.3248226046562195,
0.0254741869866848,
0.01605592481791973,
0.03278663381934166,
0.16335421800613403,
-0.07881661504507065,
-0.3254154920578003,
-0.46234679222106934,
0.5500244498252869,
-0.7624421715736389,
-0.18933875858783722,
-0.6522911787033081,
-0.3753328025341034,
-0.5899566411972046,
0.12471765279769897,
0.04257501661777496,
0.14837251603603363,
0.09855517745018005,
0.4854302406311035,
0.5507649779319763,
-0.38803619146347046,
0.7412163019180298,
0.17818616330623627,
-0.20510253310203552,
-0.7534182071685791,
0.7557217478752136,
0.011645887978374958,
-0.07922020554542542,
0.7463486194610596,
0.18897745013237,
-1.0075254440307617,
-0.3867148160934448,
-0.08352610468864441,
-0.1795838326215744,
-0.8445695638656616,
-0.7955809831619263,
-0.49520736932754517,
-0.21136997640132904,
-0.5622383952140808,
-0.24720172584056854,
0.061882685869932175,
-0.28818216919898987,
-0.3424892723560333,
-0.2430061250925064,
0.34078872203826904,
1.150835394859314,
0.05710417032241821,
0.7891035676002502,
-1.0736067295074463,
0.019357193261384964,
0.33317920565605164,
0.3846472203731537,
0.13900308310985565,
0.08223631978034973,
-0.5111266374588013,
-0.08318649232387543,
-0.48466429114341736,
-0.7575576305389404,
0.8403599858283997,
0.4063637852668762,
0.47101065516471863,
0.8048527240753174,
-0.03267868608236313,
0.7495195865631104,
-0.30465400218963623,
0.8042435050010681,
0.700547456741333,
-0.9214830994606018,
0.5009593367576599,
-0.2346287965774536,
0.12576889991760254,
0.34271126985549927,
0.8002920746803284,
-0.550446093082428,
0.026758810505270958,
-0.5671194791793823,
-1.146025538444519,
0.9449092745780945,
-0.0545337051153183,
0.11822603642940521,
0.11999687552452087,
-0.19934424757957458,
0.4514389634132385,
0.6342406272888184,
-1.0829695463180542,
-0.2565000355243683,
0.017451191321015358,
-0.2642638087272644,
-0.37215283513069153,
-0.3373554050922394,
0.15890395641326904,
-0.7114484310150146,
0.6079684495925903,
0.0092558478936553,
0.38280442357063293,
0.20607292652130127,
0.3252279758453369,
-0.06706207245588303,
0.2881154716014862,
0.3553958535194397,
0.7258874773979187,
-0.5875627398490906,
-0.15566308796405792,
-0.06443540006875992,
-0.22324338555335999,
0.018355080857872963,
0.061640508472919464,
0.2116081267595291,
0.2477199286222458,
0.3842167258262634,
0.6351156830787659,
0.02651878446340561,
-0.6513342261314392,
0.20530207455158234,
-0.014187626540660858,
-0.306243896484375,
-0.27078375220298767,
-0.32346001267433167,
-0.26826438307762146,
0.08664816617965698,
0.7888984680175781,
0.20325247943401337,
0.36766523122787476,
-0.6041338443756104,
0.5271681547164917,
0.06711087375879288,
-0.38984447717666626,
0.2446913719177246,
0.44990286231040955,
-0.02884208783507347,
-0.16430823504924774,
0.5936214327812195,
0.24596542119979858,
-0.805082380771637,
0.6954205632209778,
0.7331042289733887,
0.9345539808273315,
-0.4776890277862549,
0.5551721453666687,
0.2545415163040161,
0.46114805340766907,
-0.20240554213523865,
-0.004441551864147186,
0.007500646635890007,
-0.6115650534629822,
-0.3929913341999054,
-0.9028801918029785,
-0.30958688259124756,
0.23162610828876495,
-0.6288217902183533,
0.30716755986213684,
-0.3467249572277069,
-0.14087709784507751,
-0.03306569159030914,
0.20600081980228424,
-0.7281354069709778,
0.7460348010063171,
0.2935272455215454,
0.8437871336936951,
-0.894891619682312,
0.7926706075668335,
0.497566819190979,
-0.26624807715415955,
-0.5426875352859497,
-0.3212512731552124,
-0.5657858848571777,
-0.8765801191329956,
0.6037481427192688,
0.6128448843955994,
0.4842115342617035,
-0.45020660758018494,
-0.16894786059856415,
-0.7191451191902161,
0.7477392554283142,
-0.41380637884140015,
-0.8777785897254944,
-0.22561325132846832,
0.5387024879455566,
0.7645164728164673,
-0.6300271153450012,
0.210076242685318,
0.7244710326194763,
0.5301328301429749,
0.2875950336456299,
-0.7058067917823792,
-0.44982725381851196,
0.09299798309803009,
0.10698600858449936,
0.15362009406089783,
-0.23210299015045166,
0.7621563076972961,
0.21411316096782684,
0.19552989304065704,
0.09769172966480255,
0.3867540657520294,
0.25799980759620667,
0.7982386350631714,
0.5032077431678772,
0.7609993815422058,
0.5121294856071472,
-0.2977476418018341,
0.9228176474571228,
-0.006065738387405872,
0.5556154847145081,
0.923137903213501,
-0.013078599236905575,
1.1640064716339111,
0.004830490797758102,
-0.5028496980667114,
0.5835796594619751,
1.190916657447815,
-0.27508819103240967,
0.6334306597709656,
0.12767726182937622,
-0.10784704238176346,
0.011295398697257042,
-0.2591255307197571,
-0.5240262150764465,
0.2958401143550873,
0.8516497611999512,
-0.6608417630195618,
-0.17333351075649261,
0.2311468869447708,
-0.35064277052879333,
-0.31687191128730774,
-0.4719604253768921,
0.9602310061454773,
-0.0799265205860138,
-0.32602792978286743,
0.8770018815994263,
0.16299204528331757,
0.7794768810272217,
-0.473766565322876,
0.2389148473739624,
-0.020002858713269234,
0.6519979238510132,
-0.34901028871536255,
-0.7925375699996948,
0.4902757704257965,
-0.31039324402809143,
-0.07600675523281097,
-0.6792454123497009,
1.0120397806167603,
-0.568971574306488,
-1.0221892595291138,
0.35099729895591736,
0.45063158869743347,
-0.22373557090759277,
-0.11369549483060837,
-1.1645067930221558,
-0.16874751448631287,
0.04504752531647682,
-0.13138484954833984,
0.06164804473519325,
0.34812384843826294,
0.04737443849444389,
0.6291601657867432,
0.6077341437339783,
-0.2619214355945587,
0.20065872371196747,
0.04439415782690048,
0.5658695697784424,
-0.6376529932022095,
-0.48113444447517395,
-0.5243909955024719,
0.3858878016471863,
-0.19566603004932404,
-0.19272617995738983,
0.8363673686981201,
0.7837272882461548,
0.9438101649284363,
-0.42181771993637085,
0.5109459161758423,
0.44368019700050354,
0.4312756061553955,
-0.20077495276927948,
0.4868258237838745,
-0.7767365574836731,
0.28164389729499817,
-0.5809240937232971,
-1.248923897743225,
-0.6915535926818848,
0.45697829127311707,
-0.060202378779649734,
-0.011438964866101742,
0.5919024348258972,
0.27831757068634033,
0.06430487334728241,
-0.03408066928386688,
0.3346509337425232,
0.06560467928647995,
0.07715552300214767,
0.5463003516197205,
0.8482003808021545,
-0.5834461450576782,
0.5236765146255493,
-0.5833636522293091,
-0.00925812590867281,
-0.35102248191833496,
-0.7314789891242981,
-0.5984356999397278,
-0.4521915316581726,
-0.33930155634880066,
-0.27866464853286743,
-0.086624376475811,
0.49063363671302795,
1.0462970733642578,
-0.8805343508720398,
-0.4289366602897644,
-0.22063104808330536,
0.20970723032951355,
-0.5812138319015503,
-0.31697720289230347,
0.4030587077140808,
-0.4989001750946045,
-0.9335476160049438,
0.24465332925319672,
0.2740667164325714,
0.16793428361415863,
-0.15457861125469208,
0.1493002325296402,
-0.39946499466896057,
-0.019814347848296165,
1.0869197845458984,
-0.2718117833137512,
-0.848768949508667,
0.15415622293949127,
0.06994452327489853,
0.4606800377368927,
0.20462703704833984,
0.7697271108627319,
-0.9336951971054077,
0.24995000660419464,
0.4143012762069702,
0.5310174822807312,
0.25926345586776733,
0.2655479311943054,
0.5636862516403198,
-1.230717420578003,
0.02381480112671852,
0.4637626111507416,
0.3121812343597412,
0.21622441709041595,
-0.4751744568347931,
0.647147536277771,
0.11871539801359177,
-0.3841550350189209,
-0.6793270111083984,
0.03624445199966431,
-1.052025318145752,
-0.7180821895599365,
1.0151257514953613,
-0.0358380489051342,
-0.24787990748882294,
-0.3455527424812317,
-0.2811834514141083,
0.06412293761968613,
-0.5166345834732056,
0.7439603805541992,
0.6773430705070496,
-0.2344476878643036,
-0.24317745864391327,
-0.05913326516747475,
0.4275519549846649,
0.4127557575702667,
-0.9586971998214722,
-0.18102295696735382,
0.3682398200035095,
-0.40536558628082275,
0.273551881313324,
0.030155539512634277,
0.3330719470977783,
-0.17390944063663483,
-0.44504839181900024,
-0.0816311240196228,
0.2439621239900589,
-0.6436140537261963,
-0.29577407240867615,
0.5172410607337952,
-0.08434899896383286,
-0.35584351420402527
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.