id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05326v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05326v4
|
ChatASU: Evoking LLM's Reflexion to Truly Understand Aspect Sentiment in Dialogues
| 2024-03-08T14:05:36 | 2024-04-10T13:08:07 |
Yiding Liu, Jingjing Wang, Jiamin Luo, Tao Zeng, Guodong Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Aspect Sentiment Understanding (ASU) in interactive scenarios (e.g.,
Question-Answering and Dialogue) has attracted ever-more interest in recent
years and achieved important progresses. However, existing studies on
interactive ASU largely ignore the coreference issue for opinion targets (i.e.,
aspects), while this phenomenon is ubiquitous in interactive scenarios
especially dialogues, limiting the ASU performance. Recently, large language
models (LLMs) shows the powerful ability to integrate various NLP tasks with
the chat paradigm. In this way, this paper proposes a new Chat-based Aspect
Sentiment Understanding (ChatASU) task, aiming to explore LLMs' ability in
understanding aspect sentiments in dialogue scenarios. Particularly, this
ChatASU task introduces a sub-task, i.e., Aspect Chain Reasoning (ACR) task, to
address the aspect coreference issue. On this basis, we propose a Trusted
Self-reflexion Approach (TSA) with ChatGLM as backbone to ChatASU.
Specifically, this TSA treats the ACR task as an auxiliary task to boost the
performance of the primary ASU task, and further integrates trusted learning
into reflexion mechanisms to alleviate the LLMs-intrinsic factual hallucination
problem in TSA. Furthermore, a high-quality ChatASU dataset is annotated to
evaluate TSA, and extensive experiments show that our proposed TSA can
significantly outperform several state-of-the-art baselines, justifying the
effectiveness of TSA to ChatASU and the importance of considering the
coreference and hallucination issues in ChatASU.
|
[
-0.40052103996276855,
-0.7998022437095642,
0.5885921716690063,
0.2770196199417114,
-0.5418897867202759,
0.24305284023284912,
-0.14303120970726013,
-0.4593784809112549,
0.5474247932434082,
0.5588927865028381,
-0.6544149518013,
-0.4104499816894531,
-0.4663149416446686,
0.08262588828802109,
-0.14705462753772736,
0.949187159538269,
0.07521545886993408,
0.044580355286598206,
-0.3022032678127289,
-0.4270137846469879,
-0.1935424953699112,
-0.9934074878692627,
-0.7594314813613892,
-0.3518272042274475,
0.20333927869796753,
0.5910331010818481,
0.6238898038864136,
0.03956259414553642,
0.4578254520893097,
0.35172590613365173,
-0.17485126852989197,
0.2110598385334015,
-0.14680427312850952,
0.31686076521873474,
-0.2537231147289276,
-0.5696424841880798,
-0.6531632542610168,
-0.07310080528259277,
0.4578496217727661,
0.2506455183029175,
-0.09992767125368118,
0.026946214959025383,
0.4989984333515167,
0.7251275181770325,
-0.30891165137290955,
0.4718615710735321,
-0.5524392127990723,
0.15443575382232666,
0.27508091926574707,
-0.33217382431030273,
-0.3284013569355011,
-0.07934907078742981,
0.2161439210176468,
-0.33978235721588135,
0.19971783459186554,
0.1320458948612213,
0.8323455452919006,
0.32604414224624634,
-0.24774767458438873,
-0.24387170374393463,
-0.5955026149749756,
0.7981379628181458,
-0.9046968221664429,
0.2230624556541443,
0.18809588253498077,
-0.11703253537416458,
-0.14975498616695404,
-0.19127953052520752,
-0.736713707447052,
-0.08125007152557373,
-0.09494433552026749,
0.18112413585186005,
-0.043495066463947296,
0.36340075731277466,
-0.013290682807564735,
0.6889316439628601,
-0.1950274556875229,
-0.05577228590846062,
0.1158977597951889,
-0.11206308752298355,
0.3816460371017456,
0.07120311260223389,
0.11648164689540863,
-0.7718647718429565,
-0.4459258019924164,
0.11040594428777695,
-0.4419889450073242,
0.25011616945266724,
0.1578684002161026,
0.4008716940879822,
-0.12602967023849487,
0.3416998088359833,
-0.3202645778656006,
0.06451677531003952,
0.3049106299877167,
-0.09598658978939056,
0.3354381322860718,
-0.2564321756362915,
-0.2648726999759674,
-0.11056032031774521,
0.9834895730018616,
0.3810963034629822,
-0.06636146456003189,
0.024132242426276207,
0.013908193446695805,
-0.028159404173493385,
0.4443862736225128,
-0.495787650346756,
-0.14460478723049164,
0.5403441190719604,
-0.4268127977848053,
-0.4349612593650818,
-0.346248060464859,
-0.5797545313835144,
-0.31260839104652405,
-0.4035018980503082,
0.4638391137123108,
-0.5486796498298645,
-0.4612009823322296,
-0.22253374755382538,
0.3827413022518158,
0.5536495447158813,
0.42237409949302673,
-0.4964732527732849,
0.3019651770591736,
0.8985692858695984,
0.7953718304634094,
-0.27372878789901733,
-0.2457132786512375,
-0.34709206223487854,
-0.2600192129611969,
0.16481934487819672,
0.854081392288208,
-0.41672730445861816,
-0.7519776225090027,
-0.22977393865585327,
-0.10536442697048187,
-0.13689827919006348,
-0.18740025162696838,
0.7153312563896179,
-0.15285031497478485,
0.10819415748119354,
-0.2900501787662506,
-0.39664405584335327,
-0.6731720566749573,
0.6471506953239441,
-0.19935986399650574,
0.9124687314033508,
-0.44742700457572937,
-0.6471035480499268,
-0.040959618985652924,
-0.5134883522987366,
-0.4891710877418518,
-0.0916118249297142,
-0.406837522983551,
-0.35670006275177,
0.2404971718788147,
0.49177834391593933,
0.5351584553718567,
-0.01976769044995308,
0.2204534411430359,
-0.25887539982795715,
0.1494651585817337,
0.5821136832237244,
-0.2676679790019989,
0.24761968851089478,
0.07769052684307098,
-0.4164074957370758,
0.3500071167945862,
-0.19467706978321075,
0.009837252087891102,
-0.26540443301200867,
0.19079963862895966,
-0.3555881679058075,
0.14233212172985077,
-0.2851833999156952,
0.2306971549987793,
0.3600439131259918,
-0.5662105679512024,
0.05096344277262688,
-0.4217614531517029,
0.3145420551300049,
0.766123354434967,
0.2210487276315689,
0.4007309377193451,
0.020016707479953766,
0.38518157601356506,
0.3402477502822876,
0.5299762487411499,
0.060967426747083664,
-0.48970702290534973,
-1.2891457080841064,
0.05761942267417908,
-0.1986960768699646,
0.5060785412788391,
-0.9607885479927063,
0.696054220199585,
-0.09966713935136795,
-0.258871465921402,
-0.5972017645835876,
0.1086169108748436,
0.6915934681892395,
0.5958740711212158,
0.40689095854759216,
-0.6567913293838501,
-0.36830225586891174,
-1.0289125442504883,
-0.17022424936294556,
-0.6715746521949768,
0.21439798176288605,
0.5371266007423401,
0.15130329132080078,
0.03116423636674881,
0.8120249509811401,
-0.29658031463623047,
-0.5972568988800049,
-0.6128508448600769,
0.3098416328430176,
0.10209890455007553,
0.6013268232345581,
0.0582909993827343,
-0.5215151309967041,
-0.018498314544558525,
-0.11847848445177078,
-0.8093123435974121,
0.2111671417951584,
-0.12570402026176453,
-0.26470494270324707,
0.3036056458950043,
0.3034844398498535,
-0.6035725474357605,
0.27056294679641724,
0.5444836020469666,
-0.3582211434841156,
0.34007057547569275,
0.08891651034355164,
0.4765167534351349,
-1.2665947675704956,
-0.18944475054740906,
0.2305416762828827,
-0.4196414053440094,
-0.6070902943611145,
0.3591795563697815,
-0.23574534058570862,
-0.08635540306568146,
-0.5190912485122681,
0.29473215341567993,
-0.20741897821426392,
-0.04506067931652069,
-0.507736086845398,
0.16211268305778503,
0.08365973085165024,
0.8836819529533386,
0.4727846384048462,
0.4461902976036072,
0.6090793609619141,
-0.42907166481018066,
0.036185309290885925,
0.41883936524391174,
-0.04183201491832733,
0.5733377933502197,
-0.43200919032096863,
0.4408388137817383,
0.10601780563592911,
0.4306844472885132,
-0.9377617239952087,
0.2655787765979767,
0.41359978914260864,
-0.5640563368797302,
0.34101563692092896,
-0.41458117961883545,
-0.20869696140289307,
-0.08742482960224152,
-0.19337569177150726,
0.3598191440105438,
0.3668241500854492,
-0.5567874908447266,
1.2560667991638184,
0.4306882321834564,
-0.16769248247146606,
-0.8555288314819336,
-0.30889710783958435,
0.11874070018529892,
-0.28248775005340576,
-0.5247875452041626,
-0.13413606584072113,
0.14810113608837128,
-0.26304933428764343,
-0.3016786575317383,
-0.34876197576522827,
0.19314633309841156,
0.06819799542427063,
0.6328179836273193,
0.41603928804397583,
-0.21222543716430664,
-0.17022638022899628,
0.0010124299442395568,
-0.23330049216747284,
0.338728129863739,
-0.016298973932862282,
0.43823736906051636,
-0.6607930064201355,
-0.2940298020839691,
-0.6776863932609558,
0.22518669068813324,
0.25177738070487976,
-0.015822120010852814,
0.5104183554649353,
0.432319313287735,
0.06128092110157013,
-0.03943091258406639,
-0.8665773272514343,
-0.36424967646598816,
-0.5021129250526428,
0.13861021399497986,
-0.5286573171615601,
-1.0407825708389282,
0.49323326349258423,
0.1106463149189949,
0.2341698557138443,
0.23428936302661896,
0.4113789498806,
-0.24543523788452148,
0.572885274887085,
0.42824652791023254,
-0.39591190218925476,
0.3436485230922699,
-0.30840855836868286,
0.4915030598640442,
-1.1302905082702637,
-0.20424257218837738,
-0.36672595143318176,
-0.38500863313674927,
-0.36460256576538086,
-0.8062554597854614,
0.4194350838661194,
-0.0718488097190857,
0.24313661456108093,
0.14600521326065063,
-0.26637762784957886,
0.18744975328445435,
0.361025869846344,
0.43065184354782104,
0.534092128276825,
-0.2291204184293747,
0.09945496171712875,
0.12566857039928436,
-0.35194385051727295,
-0.42703181505203247,
0.6757158637046814,
0.5044397711753845,
0.8849090933799744,
0.027094272896647453,
0.7601326107978821,
0.3203260898590088,
0.24562527239322662,
-1.2812684774398804,
0.9226216673851013,
0.04197806119918823,
-0.2806059718132019,
-0.1987992227077484,
-0.4216722548007965,
-0.45818454027175903,
0.35389071702957153,
-0.16257181763648987,
-0.7744917869567871,
0.18544632196426392,
0.2467312067747116,
-0.42433810234069824,
0.300707072019577,
-0.6135171055793762,
0.4769865870475769,
-0.05866269767284393,
-0.2504151463508606,
-0.60112464427948,
-0.7181251049041748,
0.30887526273727417,
0.41160884499549866,
0.28588613867759705,
-0.40826356410980225,
0.1888943761587143,
0.7771087288856506,
-0.3457213044166565,
1.1002826690673828,
-0.21530099213123322,
-0.057654544711112976,
0.5298294425010681,
0.4140690267086029,
0.3224734663963318,
0.26203134655952454,
0.033657707273960114,
0.441714346408844,
-0.14234794676303864,
-0.20056991279125214,
-0.7452422976493835,
0.9398097991943359,
-0.8573636412620544,
-1.0689029693603516,
-0.5045903325080872,
-0.4108848571777344,
-0.47770270705223083,
-0.4010673463344574,
-0.0245631393045187,
0.5447226166725159,
-0.17576918005943298,
-0.05749154090881348,
0.6533921957015991,
-0.05387761443853378,
0.3727756142616272,
0.7277567982673645,
-0.2357657253742218,
-0.1681181788444519,
0.9023353457450867,
-0.37238484621047974,
0.23867323994636536,
0.3677304685115814,
0.26204583048820496,
-0.34856024384498596,
-0.44923314452171326,
-0.37424236536026,
0.3166164457798004,
-0.6319521069526672,
-0.32098832726478577,
-0.9010180830955505,
-0.39263758063316345,
-0.23034341633319855,
-0.06980684399604797,
-0.638656735420227,
-0.5175318717956543,
-0.149348184466362,
-0.3014228940010071,
0.6136678457260132,
0.44752129912376404,
-0.014137852005660534,
0.21220450103282928,
-0.8243142366409302,
0.2389039546251297,
0.20544567704200745,
0.06385908275842667,
0.20916348695755005,
-0.681495726108551,
0.017936302348971367,
-0.130991593003273,
-0.43038466572761536,
-0.5296388864517212,
0.42535436153411865,
0.03761700540781021,
0.4243771731853485,
0.5880711078643799,
0.2977119982242584,
0.538326621055603,
-0.21135184168815613,
1.0697704553604126,
0.15753987431526184,
-1.105016827583313,
0.7747170925140381,
-0.035373181104660034,
0.10777965188026428,
0.7660050988197327,
0.3009440004825592,
-0.46015605330467224,
-0.9143425226211548,
-0.8153358101844788,
-0.7348285913467407,
0.5409062504768372,
0.5541501045227051,
0.20897291600704193,
-0.06138305366039276,
0.37173402309417725,
0.12030142545700073,
0.024900240823626518,
-0.686173141002655,
-0.3843475580215454,
-0.23787911236286163,
-0.10536202788352966,
-0.11515836417675018,
-0.27806714177131653,
-0.008498811163008213,
-0.09419343620538712,
0.910475492477417,
-0.3311716616153717,
0.27012327313423157,
0.5561659932136536,
-0.0814107283949852,
-0.05471068620681763,
0.5238950252532959,
-0.036817219108343124,
0.2899937331676483,
-0.11360883712768555,
0.1421019583940506,
0.2905326783657074,
-0.5872293710708618,
0.016967613250017166,
-0.14952678978443146,
0.07778269052505493,
-0.10280875116586685,
0.04757285118103027,
0.7153170108795166,
0.27580025792121887,
-0.3290879428386688,
0.5237360000610352,
-0.19924305379390717,
0.10375317931175232,
-0.2549627125263214,
0.032530732452869415,
-0.20378808677196503,
0.30347514152526855,
0.42822182178497314,
0.07025899738073349,
0.4433029592037201,
-0.7067559957504272,
0.12094411998987198,
0.5282590985298157,
-0.7517623901367188,
-0.4661148488521576,
0.27700892090797424,
0.7309410572052002,
-0.10825403034687042,
0.4855193793773651,
-0.18063601851463318,
-0.8712062835693359,
0.34359127283096313,
0.10346781462430954,
1.1411709785461426,
-0.46288153529167175,
0.2579388916492462,
0.43890976905822754,
0.11183695495128632,
0.060735367238521576,
0.3851480185985565,
-0.3005630373954773,
-0.9837926626205444,
-0.4836564064025879,
-0.722152829170227,
-0.8147125840187073,
0.017801817506551743,
-0.8912474513053894,
0.04875533655285835,
-0.4285668730735779,
-0.2789284586906433,
-0.390022873878479,
0.0010715386597439647,
-0.37760624289512634,
0.33984458446502686,
0.2379613220691681,
0.43581071496009827,
-0.6311819553375244,
0.8429487347602844,
0.5642946362495422,
-0.2209940254688263,
-0.7532820105552673,
0.2509858012199402,
0.22040189802646637,
-0.9660797715187073,
0.11989162862300873,
0.2154165357351303,
-0.4680820107460022,
-0.27995988726615906,
-0.2971920967102051,
-0.6176896095275879,
0.702255129814148,
-0.29538509249687195,
-0.43868914246559143,
-0.07786287367343903,
-0.00465256255120039,
0.49103814363479614,
-0.3843704164028168,
0.3462456464767456,
0.6198599934577942,
-0.07408570498228073,
0.40744635462760925,
-0.9506174921989441,
0.28619036078453064,
-0.28311020135879517,
-0.2527454197406769,
0.11295479536056519,
-1.0763815641403198,
0.23068785667419434,
-0.21063928306102753,
-0.025112751871347427,
0.054098982363939285,
1.2660716772079468,
0.2860994040966034,
0.2729073464870453,
0.8202730417251587,
0.4045979082584381,
0.2819339632987976,
-0.0656401589512825,
0.7560200691223145,
-0.40841978788375854,
0.29329365491867065,
1.2822359800338745,
-0.0839238166809082,
1.1392384767532349,
0.6074232459068298,
-0.03090514987707138,
0.7257175445556641,
0.3300517499446869,
0.46698859333992004,
0.11753977835178375,
-0.18050295114517212,
-0.3396693766117096,
-0.5481070280075073,
-0.25204893946647644,
-0.09201394021511078,
0.5719835758209229,
0.6919556260108948,
-0.2921127378940582,
0.027230245992541313,
0.0980030968785286,
0.17631150782108307,
-0.08189115673303604,
-0.4235978424549103,
1.0651310682296753,
0.5784382820129395,
-0.6496305465698242,
0.0544159971177578,
-0.3450292646884918,
0.7962852716445923,
-0.5530175566673279,
0.2353302389383316,
-0.47885265946388245,
0.08175190538167953,
-0.18324197828769684,
-1.203760027885437,
0.4131026864051819,
-0.0056050545535981655,
0.27486157417297363,
-0.13214141130447388,
0.6523706316947937,
-0.17058023810386658,
-0.47772642970085144,
0.24155057966709137,
0.5559942722320557,
0.3426207900047302,
-0.33200177550315857,
-0.7771401405334473,
0.07121916860342026,
0.1114741787314415,
-0.2449115365743637,
0.30656108260154724,
0.5255077481269836,
0.3329257369041443,
0.7523061037063599,
0.2270715832710266,
-0.2743799686431885,
-0.6335664987564087,
0.2500568628311157,
0.925487220287323,
-0.70640629529953,
-0.7297050356864929,
-0.7828525900840759,
0.23034289479255676,
-0.0553688183426857,
-0.16311609745025635,
0.9203087687492371,
0.4953392744064331,
0.23587344586849213,
0.14564421772956848,
0.6689138412475586,
-0.1104135513305664,
0.46057236194610596,
-0.6716415286064148,
0.49535924196243286,
-0.2872454524040222,
0.20132283866405487,
-0.3063850402832031,
-0.7050828337669373,
0.14500591158866882,
0.5394608974456787,
-0.3602997064590454,
-0.3483079671859741,
0.79669588804245,
0.6831449866294861,
0.05789753049612045,
0.5040339231491089,
0.2151583582162857,
0.4091019034385681,
0.29911643266677856,
0.5583451986312866,
0.9447882175445557,
-0.33301910758018494,
0.5162315964698792,
-0.525040328502655,
-0.21926406025886536,
-0.019474782049655914,
-0.7261946201324463,
-1.0392972230911255,
-0.7004777789115906,
-0.6495154500007629,
-0.7173820734024048,
-0.215819850564003,
1.127837896347046,
0.5262174010276794,
-0.8942990303039551,
-0.2652762532234192,
0.1459919512271881,
0.20501366257667542,
-0.25257039070129395,
-0.29370322823524475,
0.26433199644088745,
-0.5185710191726685,
-0.6446831226348877,
0.30489301681518555,
0.3706423044204712,
-0.039099425077438354,
-0.45304399728775024,
0.07741859555244446,
0.022228803485631943,
0.2744438946247101,
0.6961274147033691,
0.2311771810054779,
-0.9962694048881531,
-0.6060135364532471,
-0.030224356800317764,
0.17493219673633575,
0.4076327681541443,
0.9786037802696228,
-0.8513860106468201,
0.34440508484840393,
0.16375024616718292,
0.30500781536102295,
0.460130900144577,
0.3171164095401764,
0.6792001128196716,
-0.7892397046089172,
0.02958115190267563,
0.22355860471725464,
0.3990332782268524,
0.45752936601638794,
-0.6356476545333862,
0.40957558155059814,
0.049183137714862823,
-0.5169127583503723,
-0.3191585838794708,
0.1376488357782364,
-1.6899077892303467,
-0.045099642127752304,
1.4732279777526855,
-0.2691059708595276,
-0.4280824065208435,
-0.2414674013853073,
-0.3789767920970917,
0.09962107241153717,
-0.8094640374183655,
1.0793687105178833,
0.48207563161849976,
-0.47354647517204285,
-0.23567475378513336,
0.10520976036787033,
0.5836065411567688,
0.6636516451835632,
-0.8828330039978027,
0.2085815668106079,
0.36922016739845276,
0.14438334107398987,
0.2955320477485657,
0.6401290893554688,
-0.013091407716274261,
-0.0804022029042244,
-0.29277700185775757,
0.0869818702340126,
0.2215050607919693,
-0.17088450491428375,
-0.12191624939441681,
-0.0354793444275856,
0.18470409512519836,
-0.32675471901893616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05313v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05313v1
|
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Horizon Generation
| 2024-03-08T13:42:19 | 2024-03-08T13:42:19 |
Zihao Wang, Anji Liu, Haowei Lin, Jiaqi Li, Xiaojian Ma, Yitao Liang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We explore how iterative revising a chain of thoughts with the help of
information retrieval significantly improves large language models' reasoning
and generation ability in long-horizon generation tasks, while hugely
mitigating hallucination. In particular, the proposed method --
*retrieval-augmented thoughts* (RAT) -- revises each thought step one by one
with retrieved information relevant to the task query, the current and the past
thought steps, after the initial zero-shot CoT is generated. Applying RAT to
GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and CodeLLaMA-7b substantially improves their performances on
various long-horizon generation tasks; on average of relatively increasing
rating scores by 13.63% on code generation, 16.96% on mathematical reasoning,
19.2% on creative writing, and 42.78% on embodied task planning. The demo page
can be found at https://craftjarvis.github.io/RAT
|
[
-0.6312713027000427,
-0.8862612843513489,
0.718059241771698,
0.1816968470811844,
-0.3397022485733032,
0.07879698276519775,
-0.6246800422668457,
-0.7979910373687744,
0.49914538860321045,
0.5226712226867676,
-0.4258914887905121,
-0.27382147312164307,
-0.215204656124115,
0.06375103443861008,
-0.3777341842651367,
1.1845232248306274,
0.17634983360767365,
-0.1949378401041031,
0.11257877200841904,
0.26436445116996765,
-0.8497867584228516,
-0.43630895018577576,
-0.5478324890136719,
-0.3777560889720917,
0.6850691437721252,
0.265146404504776,
0.7968452572822571,
-0.11135349422693253,
0.45601779222488403,
0.18444006145000458,
0.06913148611783981,
0.34755048155784607,
-0.7569836974143982,
0.43923547863960266,
-0.57142174243927,
-0.06261107325553894,
-0.4682176411151886,
-0.20039226114749908,
0.384561687707901,
0.5112361907958984,
0.17647618055343628,
0.02020072564482689,
0.04648846760392189,
1.1103252172470093,
-0.9601305723190308,
-0.17592667043209076,
-0.9304255843162537,
0.15152525901794434,
-0.049759987741708755,
-0.6993216276168823,
-0.5655344128608704,
-0.2070973813533783,
0.09420811384916306,
-0.8136793971061707,
0.2606562674045563,
0.027582205832004547,
0.4890477955341339,
0.2087828665971756,
-0.13425491750240326,
-0.48332878947257996,
-0.940761148929596,
0.7280369400978088,
-0.35335153341293335,
0.22063763439655304,
0.5011110901832581,
0.3955090343952179,
-0.5142345428466797,
-0.8715660572052002,
-0.6629699468612671,
-0.15207919478416443,
0.08529683947563171,
0.259309321641922,
0.2592792809009552,
0.1284574717283249,
0.4591338634490967,
0.6108567714691162,
-0.473003625869751,
-0.6042745113372803,
-0.5757225751876831,
-0.023039154708385468,
0.5658291578292847,
-0.2029336839914322,
-0.04917058348655701,
-0.13495631515979767,
-0.31638824939727783,
-0.04160361364483833,
-0.7190678715705872,
-0.1853468418121338,
0.04341205582022667,
0.30740609765052795,
0.5144258737564087,
0.6399180889129639,
-0.4100937843322754,
0.9722709059715271,
0.07329127192497253,
0.18833322823047638,
0.3304610848426819,
-0.2926032841205597,
-0.23345768451690674,
-0.007514570374041796,
0.2448502779006958,
0.36005493998527527,
0.10170192271471024,
-0.12484905868768692,
-0.5290821194648743,
0.12469696998596191,
0.7113639712333679,
-0.6183855533599854,
-0.317965030670166,
0.3607790470123291,
-0.2912415564060211,
-0.04335695877671242,
-0.1540471315383911,
-0.5337855219841003,
-0.32104259729385376,
-0.35009998083114624,
0.8179752826690674,
-0.680733859539032,
-0.27457141876220703,
0.5302422642707825,
-0.35140228271484375,
0.46237850189208984,
0.5365254878997803,
-0.7387993335723877,
-0.02346038818359375,
0.7763388752937317,
0.4676395356655121,
-0.2530761659145355,
-0.3100724518299103,
-0.47034239768981934,
0.15171514451503754,
-0.6723870038986206,
1.0467275381088257,
-0.5721343755722046,
-0.5162249207496643,
0.01619814708828926,
-0.3682658076286316,
0.13991118967533112,
-0.509275496006012,
0.38851115107536316,
-0.7080113291740417,
0.35798051953315735,
-0.6507465839385986,
-0.5402709245681763,
-0.008835351094603539,
0.6392049193382263,
-0.6161689162254333,
1.2818645238876343,
-0.1318046897649765,
-1.0019280910491943,
0.5233762264251709,
-0.8461397886276245,
-0.5272511839866638,
0.1293405443429947,
-0.4147450029850006,
-0.002470910083502531,
0.2011609971523285,
0.26940369606018066,
0.21848054230213165,
-0.11636697500944138,
0.24451513588428497,
0.003460334613919258,
-0.6451412439346313,
0.20147734880447388,
-0.1882299929857254,
0.5114046931266785,
0.5205735564231873,
-0.618796706199646,
0.23325645923614502,
-0.521570086479187,
0.3141288459300995,
0.08666186779737473,
-0.17693720757961273,
-0.28845158219337463,
-0.1534547656774521,
0.06034718453884125,
0.2555466890335083,
0.21816983819007874,
-0.4854258596897125,
0.37131768465042114,
-0.36676308512687683,
0.19946826994419098,
0.6016732454299927,
0.27134591341018677,
0.31418702006340027,
-0.45004802942276,
0.23597832024097443,
-0.08108486980199814,
0.11165152490139008,
-0.04828878492116928,
-0.6414804458618164,
-0.7277784943580627,
0.00719831557944417,
0.1525028496980667,
0.20318645238876343,
-1.194942831993103,
0.351494163274765,
-0.057291511446237564,
-0.2353992760181427,
-0.32282906770706177,
-0.060335077345371246,
0.37390244007110596,
0.5328838229179382,
0.5441186428070068,
-0.20525005459785461,
-0.5275518894195557,
-0.701942503452301,
-0.3552546203136444,
-0.09832554310560226,
0.09623004496097565,
-0.1296992301940918,
0.7461356520652771,
-0.2432447373867035,
1.0054627656936646,
-0.5676863193511963,
-0.03351829573512077,
-0.222621887922287,
0.25276777148246765,
0.07073121517896652,
0.5843229293823242,
0.3335445523262024,
-0.7981147170066833,
-0.2809407711029053,
-0.2669791281223297,
-0.7010160684585571,
0.33252185583114624,
-0.33637285232543945,
-0.7748464941978455,
0.09458818286657333,
0.3013198673725128,
-0.8819780349731445,
0.7759893536567688,
-0.0593879297375679,
-0.41985222697257996,
0.6563212871551514,
-0.3366958498954773,
0.3429303467273712,
-1.18325936794281,
0.20484250783920288,
-0.3973328471183777,
-0.15083524584770203,
-0.4640241265296936,
0.31309911608695984,
0.0232275128364563,
-0.0847804844379425,
-0.17747996747493744,
0.4699218273162842,
-0.615083634853363,
-0.3957475423812866,
-0.7259932160377502,
0.5067571997642517,
0.04741206020116806,
0.48451298475265503,
0.14712092280387878,
1.1448397636413574,
0.345276802778244,
-0.6044679284095764,
-0.021118562668561935,
0.20510467886924744,
-0.42870745062828064,
0.3936995267868042,
-0.31199538707733154,
0.5892729163169861,
-0.1888214349746704,
0.370505154132843,
-0.817855954170227,
-0.08255141228437424,
0.023797815665602684,
-0.7434093952178955,
0.14669080078601837,
0.5801584720611572,
-0.5156503915786743,
-0.31130552291870117,
-0.6040719151496887,
0.5526264905929565,
0.37281152606010437,
-0.7389765977859497,
0.5976290702819824,
0.1832437813282013,
0.0736442506313324,
-0.8946472406387329,
-0.6207583546638489,
0.2995104491710663,
0.031451188027858734,
-0.24660281836986542,
0.6825740933418274,
-0.3737766444683075,
-0.40727558732032776,
0.1006927490234375,
-0.003949709236621857,
0.31102609634399414,
-0.2084171324968338,
-0.08867143839597702,
0.07882857322692871,
0.14500805735588074,
0.4944116473197937,
0.06612376123666763,
-0.015220854431390762,
0.040018562227487564,
-0.47166991233825684,
0.49349939823150635,
-0.027057552710175514,
-0.1286984086036682,
0.2258044332265854,
0.4811215400695801,
0.43691131472587585,
-0.3579922020435333,
0.3514360189437866,
0.7218712568283081,
-0.6544429063796997,
-0.43584132194519043,
-0.7211031913757324,
-0.3302708864212036,
-0.42997249960899353,
0.22957037389278412,
-0.7345236539840698,
-0.8909469842910767,
0.5282114148139954,
-0.03982163965702057,
0.28894540667533875,
0.4349270462989807,
0.6850546598434448,
-0.05116304010152817,
0.7759221196174622,
0.704069972038269,
-0.05547778680920601,
0.5824827551841736,
-0.4735761284828186,
0.3204500377178192,
-1.2277649641036987,
-0.01548330020159483,
-0.14098818600177765,
-0.3723319172859192,
-0.50193852186203,
-0.8042297959327698,
0.35065510869026184,
0.1748703420162201,
-0.26380473375320435,
0.03133011981844902,
-0.9647984504699707,
0.5319774150848389,
0.5805498361587524,
0.39119085669517517,
0.3443607687950134,
-0.09677440673112869,
-0.17850477993488312,
0.09335849434137344,
-0.337281197309494,
-0.26195579767227173,
1.2342894077301025,
-0.13418902456760406,
0.49357661604881287,
-0.08255012333393097,
0.8906087875366211,
0.418556809425354,
0.4286618232727051,
-0.6846222877502441,
0.7461372017860413,
0.40051963925361633,
-0.98953777551651,
-0.30148935317993164,
-0.1268128901720047,
-0.9347192645072937,
0.3202328681945801,
-0.32656365633010864,
-0.6827865242958069,
0.04787318408489227,
0.03629118949174881,
-0.45791390538215637,
0.2384454756975174,
-0.3865104019641876,
0.42006030678749084,
-0.11297807097434998,
-0.5858199000358582,
-0.8088187575340271,
-0.567915141582489,
0.3732442855834961,
-0.14461612701416016,
-0.07077963650226593,
0.1705518215894699,
0.08611591905355453,
0.6360244154930115,
-0.4103800058364868,
0.41423773765563965,
-0.2568210959434509,
-0.2015547752380371,
0.727217972278595,
-0.030425362288951874,
0.5619014501571655,
0.16931691765785217,
-0.1114753857254982,
-0.3301162123680115,
-0.4409172534942627,
-0.48217079043388367,
-0.7501842379570007,
0.8385703563690186,
-0.5187397003173828,
-0.8266626596450806,
-0.5049511790275574,
-0.8509959578514099,
-0.3696706295013428,
0.26067209243774414,
0.444662868976593,
0.25866666436195374,
-0.14584624767303467,
0.07311985641717911,
0.7070093154907227,
-0.37320569157600403,
0.40705206990242004,
0.17249354720115662,
-0.6872552633285522,
-0.7215172052383423,
0.5101889371871948,
0.048580102622509,
0.2118152230978012,
0.3635704815387726,
-0.13231161236763,
-0.09284479916095734,
-0.34544268250465393,
-0.23277044296264648,
0.21443215012550354,
-0.8725115060806274,
-0.3595983684062958,
-0.5115366578102112,
-0.10382051765918732,
-0.16535542905330658,
-0.2866125702857971,
-0.44713568687438965,
-0.6600265502929688,
0.18043997883796692,
-0.26258736848831177,
0.586120069026947,
0.7981576919555664,
-0.13400417566299438,
-0.1593320220708847,
-0.26931142807006836,
0.5475951433181763,
0.36065489053726196,
0.33607199788093567,
0.02787083573639393,
-0.3137878477573395,
-0.38527193665504456,
0.05198712274432182,
-0.49325522780418396,
-0.7745447754859924,
0.18401971459388733,
-0.06632773578166962,
0.1657928228378296,
-0.020338593050837517,
0.1229800209403038,
0.9876559376716614,
-0.4162830412387848,
0.870823085308075,
0.12596920132637024,
-0.8508190512657166,
0.8490731120109558,
-0.3560006022453308,
0.6061238646507263,
0.6537591814994812,
-0.10366982966661453,
-0.2195635437965393,
-0.5934616327285767,
-0.3649698495864868,
-0.8312253952026367,
0.13502153754234314,
0.44821709394454956,
0.018388597294688225,
-0.3862399756908417,
0.7332183718681335,
0.11922839283943176,
0.2584822475910187,
-0.5009400844573975,
0.01872296631336212,
-0.06070095673203468,
0.18821096420288086,
-0.06574888527393341,
-0.28034287691116333,
-0.043793935328722,
-0.4613874852657318,
0.6863232254981995,
-0.18059740960597992,
0.8265407681465149,
0.6734353303909302,
0.003451865864917636,
-0.3511071503162384,
0.26055219769477844,
0.7937477827072144,
1.0185290575027466,
-0.4175727367401123,
0.13662447035312653,
0.1997046023607254,
-0.48028916120529175,
-0.180530846118927,
0.014902221970260143,
-0.13588252663612366,
0.05045681446790695,
0.12049765884876251,
0.4074896574020386,
0.12909424304962158,
-0.5667802095413208,
0.21605409681797028,
-0.15032625198364258,
-0.23916228115558624,
-0.7096360325813293,
-0.04642949253320694,
0.06020313501358032,
0.41615182161331177,
0.7074610590934753,
0.21103651821613312,
0.48663651943206787,
-0.6202953457832336,
0.301378458738327,
0.434845894575119,
-0.12529361248016357,
-0.18293343484401703,
0.6586576700210571,
-0.0031257527880370617,
-0.05547168850898743,
0.6999380588531494,
-0.40036943554878235,
-0.4028594195842743,
0.2136554718017578,
0.8033466339111328,
1.2801412343978882,
0.14047984778881073,
-0.052467431873083115,
0.5421600937843323,
0.18323707580566406,
-0.1754883974790573,
0.8414808511734009,
-0.41559332609176636,
-0.711929202079773,
-0.8474240303039551,
-0.3496192991733551,
-0.40073129534721375,
0.14724139869213104,
-0.5825629830360413,
0.08065521717071533,
-0.3306681215763092,
-0.6508214473724365,
-0.24936813116073608,
0.17732557654380798,
-0.568153977394104,
0.2949657738208771,
0.12769509851932526,
0.9785187840461731,
-0.3060625493526459,
1.0832974910736084,
0.7397804856300354,
-0.4029753804206848,
-0.5724374055862427,
0.30352094769477844,
-0.40338948369026184,
-0.4083324372768402,
0.6563596129417419,
0.28064489364624023,
-0.5921937227249146,
-0.1440926492214203,
-0.5284281969070435,
-0.9139536023139954,
1.0676642656326294,
0.15827018022537231,
-0.4119251072406769,
-0.10858216881752014,
-0.2644652724266052,
0.6689697504043579,
-0.40963801741600037,
0.03174831345677376,
0.36284059286117554,
0.364585280418396,
0.06518465280532837,
-0.8797258138656616,
-0.04293422773480415,
-0.6651606559753418,
0.05962187051773071,
0.36104443669319153,
-0.37510064244270325,
0.8046272397041321,
-0.5481030941009521,
-0.1155562773346901,
0.0957869216799736,
0.9310528635978699,
0.6001867055892944,
0.3652513921260834,
0.3788023591041565,
0.6513286828994751,
0.8171144127845764,
0.16469544172286987,
0.9215370416641235,
-0.7538557052612305,
0.17510239779949188,
1.143141746520996,
-0.2065688818693161,
1.2632652521133423,
0.6596576571464539,
0.30010101199150085,
0.5901029706001282,
0.4989495575428009,
0.6108277440071106,
0.7564656138420105,
0.10046449303627014,
-0.31863534450531006,
-0.180329829454422,
0.13013845682144165,
-0.6383203268051147,
0.1464269906282425,
0.5784252882003784,
-0.15117859840393066,
0.11260835081338882,
0.39092087745666504,
-0.0911099836230278,
0.14424677193164825,
-0.27577096223831177,
0.6213701963424683,
0.10840490460395813,
-1.1166290044784546,
0.9532016515731812,
-0.34024882316589355,
0.6692891120910645,
-0.2837717533111572,
-0.35329902172088623,
-0.17524555325508118,
0.39155662059783936,
-0.13750742375850677,
-0.8135286569595337,
0.32067540287971497,
0.11208974570035934,
-0.08609689027070999,
-0.23002824187278748,
0.9283142685890198,
-0.348939448595047,
-0.24160152673721313,
0.37657150626182556,
0.5384397506713867,
0.008745238184928894,
-0.2992897033691406,
-0.7972890734672546,
0.21607071161270142,
0.016040779650211334,
-0.5464429259300232,
0.21697455644607544,
0.5442267656326294,
-0.049464404582977295,
0.560955286026001,
0.42771437764167786,
0.03337142989039421,
-0.19692693650722504,
-0.030740169808268547,
1.2296222448349,
-1.109641432762146,
-0.45316293835639954,
-0.4869718849658966,
0.4683370292186737,
-0.2556026577949524,
-0.36519479751586914,
0.608857274055481,
0.7412915229797363,
1.0182876586914062,
-0.17480012774467468,
0.6846686601638794,
-0.15909886360168457,
0.5605019330978394,
-0.5056619644165039,
0.4634403586387634,
-0.47148817777633667,
0.3462933301925659,
-0.45555004477500916,
-1.3271703720092773,
-0.2939710319042206,
0.8384935855865479,
-0.7378341555595398,
0.20716850459575653,
0.9815394282341003,
0.7192803621292114,
0.17888738214969635,
0.13387054204940796,
0.36058205366134644,
-0.17422614991664886,
0.27375391125679016,
0.7728913426399231,
1.0217655897140503,
-0.5159933567047119,
0.2254110425710678,
-0.29288238286972046,
-0.07154500484466553,
-0.10581529140472412,
-0.5812773704528809,
-0.914695680141449,
-0.766676127910614,
-0.1334257274866104,
-0.5163463950157166,
0.31436455249786377,
1.1734031438827515,
0.37301546335220337,
-0.5382753014564514,
-0.29876911640167236,
-0.2763546109199524,
-0.2593329846858978,
-0.3215429484844208,
-0.23825493454933167,
0.43889153003692627,
-0.8587364554405212,
-0.43469130992889404,
0.3917577564716339,
0.3541952967643738,
-0.4011203348636627,
-0.36295679211616516,
-0.10773096233606339,
-0.3254772424697876,
0.16520823538303375,
0.9873431324958801,
0.07267391681671143,
-0.7690905332565308,
-0.5893089175224304,
0.10947999358177185,
-0.18210048973560333,
0.06725868582725525,
0.9734628200531006,
-1.1283804178237915,
0.9304032921791077,
0.5115426182746887,
0.4843934178352356,
0.7771769762039185,
0.07496920228004456,
0.7128838300704956,
-0.43516606092453003,
0.29822707176208496,
0.3950106203556061,
0.28732359409332275,
0.3853197395801544,
-0.45725539326667786,
0.7534541487693787,
-0.10510042309761047,
-0.8167957663536072,
-0.6416095495223999,
0.2974476218223572,
-0.8074119687080383,
-0.4925151467323303,
0.969480574131012,
0.20936261117458344,
-0.2887246906757355,
0.10490003973245621,
-0.5134455561637878,
0.23979243636131287,
-0.2395852655172348,
1.1224370002746582,
0.41616374254226685,
-0.33299416303634644,
0.1768803596496582,
-0.7564060688018799,
0.7463564872741699,
0.621236264705658,
-0.7240733504295349,
0.1724100410938263,
0.6639548540115356,
-0.1334834098815918,
0.4548725187778473,
0.9853420257568359,
-0.29830145835876465,
0.49370628595352173,
-0.002532003680244088,
0.2343439906835556,
0.2899761497974396,
-0.43520841002464294,
-0.0014899038942530751,
0.03141115978360176,
0.3494466543197632,
-0.1436261236667633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05303v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05303v1
|
ACLSum: A New Dataset for Aspect-based Summarization of Scientific Publications
| 2024-03-08T13:32:01 | 2024-03-08T13:32:01 |
Sotaro Takeshita, Tommaso Green, Ines Reinig, Kai Eckert, Simone Paolo Ponzetto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extensive efforts in the past have been directed toward the development of
summarization datasets. However, a predominant number of these resources have
been (semi)-automatically generated, typically through web data crawling,
resulting in subpar resources for training and evaluating summarization
systems, a quality compromise that is arguably due to the substantial costs
associated with generating ground-truth summaries, particularly for diverse
languages and specialized domains. To address this issue, we present ACLSum, a
novel summarization dataset carefully crafted and evaluated by domain experts.
In contrast to previous datasets, ACLSum facilitates multi-aspect summarization
of scientific papers, covering challenges, approaches, and outcomes in depth.
Through extensive experiments, we evaluate the quality of our resource and the
performance of models based on pretrained language models and state-of-the-art
large language models (LLMs). Additionally, we explore the effectiveness of
extractive versus abstractive summarization within the scholarly domain on the
basis of automatically discovered aspects. Our results corroborate previous
findings in the general domain and indicate the general superiority of
end-to-end aspect-based summarization. Our data is released at
https://github.com/sobamchan/aclsum.
|
[
-0.24820442497730255,
-0.3530697822570801,
0.4881659746170044,
-0.019210251048207283,
-0.24888134002685547,
0.44668084383010864,
-0.12787079811096191,
-0.4486997723579407,
0.44335442781448364,
0.3053669035434723,
-0.26518550515174866,
-0.6750556230545044,
-0.744466245174408,
0.35809507966041565,
-0.7298725247383118,
1.2986018657684326,
-0.07055360078811646,
-0.08086468279361725,
-0.5477219223976135,
-0.3521718382835388,
0.3740347623825073,
-0.5464840531349182,
-0.21024496853351593,
-0.3227481245994568,
0.5116853713989258,
0.1877555251121521,
0.5600363612174988,
0.8111640214920044,
0.8940175175666809,
0.2242181897163391,
-0.3446594476699829,
0.49149757623672485,
-0.1897231787443161,
0.12817882001399994,
-0.20004595816135406,
-0.19361254572868347,
-0.8168954849243164,
0.036765385419130325,
0.7628102898597717,
1.0032193660736084,
-0.1288030445575714,
0.23990298807621002,
0.09804708510637283,
1.1492209434509277,
-0.46602126955986023,
-0.033056240528821945,
-0.3372422754764557,
0.1824747622013092,
-0.06503112614154816,
-0.4514646828174591,
-0.2163209319114685,
-0.326412558555603,
0.07429926842451096,
-0.8133130669593811,
0.734588086605072,
0.1190156415104866,
0.7157800793647766,
0.05400695279240608,
-0.3209295868873596,
-0.5889053344726562,
-0.47486791014671326,
0.5857338309288025,
-0.7895616292953491,
0.29123741388320923,
0.09013963490724564,
0.004063006490468979,
0.11984336376190186,
-0.773688793182373,
-0.38369762897491455,
-0.017739903181791306,
-0.3273222744464874,
0.09939929842948914,
-0.11522995680570602,
-0.03910316154360771,
-0.10419684648513794,
0.8130896687507629,
-0.8794939517974854,
-0.27988001704216003,
-0.4180123507976532,
-0.10123448818922043,
0.6952924132347107,
0.209533229470253,
0.16909591853618622,
0.08300919830799103,
0.13894811272621155,
-0.08673552423715591,
-0.7908554673194885,
-0.11011742800474167,
0.3349584639072418,
0.46167656779289246,
-0.4004370868206024,
0.7310038208961487,
-0.46864378452301025,
0.6060317158699036,
-0.05816279724240303,
-0.08167602121829987,
0.2731572985649109,
-0.4338866174221039,
0.07140271365642548,
-0.06859137117862701,
0.7963895797729492,
0.31229743361473083,
-0.1803867667913437,
-0.3622007369995117,
-0.1700456440448761,
-0.3128442168235779,
0.13210546970367432,
-0.710941731929779,
-0.6964967250823975,
0.44959670305252075,
-0.5259663462638855,
-0.21145549416542053,
0.18489976227283478,
-0.643639326095581,
-0.5326583385467529,
-0.5108082294464111,
0.09984403848648071,
-0.38822492957115173,
-0.20335081219673157,
-0.16852779686450958,
-0.10021906346082687,
-0.2718859314918518,
0.5560184121131897,
-0.47179114818573,
0.45649072527885437,
0.8014150261878967,
1.340427041053772,
-0.6990063786506653,
-0.40122851729393005,
-0.4292234480381012,
0.16823828220367432,
-0.17808710038661957,
0.9941651225090027,
-0.3674839735031128,
-0.6080252528190613,
-0.17395548522472382,
-0.008454669266939163,
0.28303200006484985,
-0.4045412242412567,
0.11248336732387543,
-0.5699430704116821,
0.02798539772629738,
-0.35325172543525696,
-0.5336346626281738,
-0.31115707755088806,
0.3361152112483978,
-0.6201873421669006,
0.5405015349388123,
-0.12337607145309448,
-0.7727225422859192,
0.23005852103233337,
-0.7939752340316772,
-0.8089183568954468,
-0.09831704944372177,
-0.15251506865024567,
-0.5270739197731018,
0.2464297115802765,
0.2948373854160309,
0.2674851417541504,
-0.034022603183984756,
0.21819622814655304,
-0.15049980580806732,
0.15254008769989014,
0.4965212643146515,
-0.0811644047498703,
0.48687490820884705,
0.30673298239707947,
0.040719691663980484,
0.20618942379951477,
-0.5870512127876282,
-0.24356316030025482,
-0.011193164624273777,
-0.1419192999601364,
-0.3259352743625641,
0.08761278539896011,
-0.14868977665901184,
-0.09629687666893005,
0.4770641028881073,
-0.5042088627815247,
0.06483526527881622,
-0.12605787813663483,
0.17113390564918518,
0.36974143981933594,
0.2678995430469513,
0.49420517683029175,
-0.5855175256729126,
0.4287431836128235,
0.09311705082654953,
-0.014843328855931759,
-0.5962308645248413,
-0.0663626492023468,
-0.9146898984909058,
-0.16017940640449524,
0.2789669930934906,
0.04139676317572594,
-0.4771047532558441,
0.4323996305465698,
-0.385440468788147,
-0.6276435852050781,
-0.3121088147163391,
0.156839057803154,
0.5562092065811157,
0.38266950845718384,
0.5685749650001526,
-0.6076397895812988,
-0.2946374714374542,
-0.6935379505157471,
-0.1448492854833603,
-0.15392963588237762,
0.015225366689264774,
0.20520347356796265,
0.6443770527839661,
0.2552720606327057,
0.9947536587715149,
-0.6556124687194824,
-0.2864989638328552,
-0.22349682450294495,
0.38724029064178467,
0.09463103115558624,
0.3837989270687103,
0.4278865456581116,
-0.6313158273696899,
-0.2059975564479828,
0.08009126037359238,
-1.0765678882598877,
-0.053256165236234665,
-0.19364848732948303,
0.002994351089000702,
0.3107147514820099,
0.24241800606250763,
-0.3617747724056244,
0.09742534160614014,
0.4867096543312073,
-0.3126513361930847,
0.676604151725769,
-0.34060102701187134,
0.5309566259384155,
-0.7871381640434265,
0.5865399837493896,
0.2286444902420044,
-0.28474658727645874,
-0.2853485345840454,
0.3465973734855652,
0.09933998435735703,
-0.13970567286014557,
-0.37719306349754333,
0.4396919012069702,
-0.8181533813476562,
-0.25606903433799744,
-0.44188809394836426,
0.06512382626533508,
0.3977573812007904,
0.27009814977645874,
0.2979423403739929,
0.8522603511810303,
0.35605931282043457,
-0.7903811931610107,
0.08514856547117233,
0.36980509757995605,
-0.0036313862074166536,
0.3253990411758423,
-0.7303723096847534,
0.05787013843655586,
-0.15696200728416443,
0.33639222383499146,
-0.4134442210197449,
-0.363613486289978,
-0.14103713631629944,
-0.5235885381698608,
0.3041931390762329,
-0.01222240924835205,
-0.2647104561328888,
-0.014223802834749222,
-0.3743869662284851,
0.36113354563713074,
0.0808107778429985,
-0.33855944871902466,
0.4781210422515869,
0.8288336992263794,
-0.6248348355293274,
-0.42925363779067993,
-0.42880216240882874,
0.367249995470047,
-0.01769716665148735,
-0.07673845440149307,
0.2727299928665161,
-0.11853473633527756,
-0.4202944040298462,
0.17505484819412231,
-0.2656860649585724,
0.12019717693328857,
-0.09777013957500458,
0.17594638466835022,
0.0017979119438678026,
0.002026116941124201,
-0.23264266550540924,
0.334915429353714,
0.11858896166086197,
0.12918561697006226,
-0.16175547242164612,
0.4167144298553467,
-0.2412416636943817,
-0.6047802567481995,
-0.2250097095966339,
0.4471821188926697,
0.39874401688575745,
-0.3537451922893524,
0.26220521330833435,
-0.02216196246445179,
-0.2491629272699356,
0.040677666664123535,
-0.26662907004356384,
0.005338465794920921,
-0.40101051330566406,
0.4203735888004303,
0.05131126195192337,
-0.7481744885444641,
0.570042073726654,
0.2733652889728546,
0.6482029557228088,
0.5831273198127747,
0.2542744576931,
-0.0863213837146759,
0.6139857769012451,
0.6070010662078857,
-0.2080402374267578,
0.08733651787042618,
-0.4776133596897125,
0.03419940173625946,
-0.871226966381073,
-0.3667009770870209,
-0.6140062808990479,
-0.042200349271297455,
-0.11083945631980896,
-0.3454853296279907,
0.5842006206512451,
-0.165948286652565,
-0.049264147877693176,
0.1297295093536377,
-0.6687710285186768,
0.5323483347892761,
0.33703118562698364,
0.017742116004228592,
0.8872660994529724,
0.05683811381459236,
0.4261198937892914,
0.12982164323329926,
-0.4328289031982422,
-0.6775456666946411,
1.1899323463439941,
0.29035091400146484,
0.704001784324646,
0.21784546971321106,
0.6446943879127502,
0.8017649054527283,
0.4728659987449646,
-0.691027820110321,
0.5118587017059326,
-0.16080135107040405,
-0.32676056027412415,
-0.22604243457317352,
-0.5701618790626526,
-0.7349480390548706,
0.16989804804325104,
-0.14630866050720215,
-0.07309088855981827,
0.2010553926229477,
0.2850984036922455,
-0.36550626158714294,
0.3688686490058899,
-0.22338810563087463,
0.1806679517030716,
-0.3371196687221527,
-0.19625508785247803,
-0.3335631489753723,
-0.7573948502540588,
0.34332510828971863,
-0.0572066493332386,
0.5276997685432434,
-0.19797489047050476,
-0.13545812666416168,
1.0097402334213257,
-0.3907846510410309,
0.6399235129356384,
-0.08975037187337875,
-0.06283243000507355,
0.290852814912796,
0.2688462734222412,
0.22309128940105438,
0.36943432688713074,
-0.02479916252195835,
0.43326959013938904,
-0.03395634889602661,
-0.4131167232990265,
-0.28416407108306885,
0.8409006595611572,
-0.6007758975028992,
-0.368496298789978,
-0.8988866806030273,
-0.7637194395065308,
-0.16912396252155304,
0.2689509093761444,
0.19980670511722565,
0.5676091909408569,
-0.4539996087551117,
-0.12416703253984451,
0.5874789357185364,
-0.24655237793922424,
0.4807420074939728,
1.008310317993164,
-0.19558972120285034,
-0.6127386093139648,
1.0522634983062744,
-0.05357209965586662,
-0.05773279443383217,
0.31464460492134094,
-0.21759261190891266,
0.017233915627002716,
-0.9434379935264587,
-0.40246549248695374,
0.29892876744270325,
-0.48329874873161316,
-0.5715707540512085,
-0.9706600904464722,
-0.39527490735054016,
-0.5735397338867188,
-0.25913310050964355,
-0.29991671442985535,
-0.7287851572036743,
-0.2898159325122833,
-0.0719003826379776,
0.33178839087486267,
0.9300121068954468,
-0.17591194808483124,
0.2421344667673111,
-1.0427637100219727,
0.29392972588539124,
-0.09060531854629517,
0.14099742472171783,
0.08853103220462799,
-0.46675631403923035,
-0.5475172996520996,
0.05506283789873123,
-0.5053526163101196,
-0.5552184581756592,
0.6201047897338867,
0.6257469058036804,
0.3416823446750641,
0.33901122212409973,
0.13426677882671356,
0.3896053433418274,
-0.3713645935058594,
0.9614432454109192,
0.2601716220378876,
-0.684481143951416,
0.46770021319389343,
-0.45470738410949707,
0.3270840346813202,
0.8534099459648132,
0.25441858172416687,
-0.5709607601165771,
-0.6233139038085938,
-0.6062068939208984,
-1.1749013662338257,
0.5336716175079346,
0.08509143441915512,
-0.12056174129247665,
0.06584487110376358,
0.34480980038642883,
0.576348066329956,
0.44329527020454407,
-0.38743939995765686,
-0.3708330988883972,
-0.16331404447555542,
-0.26846686005592346,
-0.22572462260723114,
-0.0015321397222578526,
-0.45809075236320496,
-0.1266329288482666,
0.9832895398139954,
-0.18739043176174164,
0.0220731720328331,
0.4110672175884247,
-0.5171223878860474,
-0.09385831654071808,
0.1419128030538559,
0.5694835782051086,
0.9768791198730469,
-0.11057517677545547,
0.41661205887794495,
-0.0394618846476078,
-0.6916751265525818,
0.019345950335264206,
0.2825085520744324,
-0.30066514015197754,
0.1403273046016693,
0.6456175446510315,
0.35936272144317627,
-0.24421514570713043,
-0.7041783928871155,
0.42191582918167114,
-0.07584795355796814,
-0.20937584340572357,
-0.3764159083366394,
0.030477216467261314,
-0.29122447967529297,
0.04311255365610123,
0.758831262588501,
0.0722845047712326,
0.6385177373886108,
-0.21213611960411072,
0.2853900194168091,
0.3166748285293579,
-0.2472410500049591,
-0.6571400761604309,
0.4985973834991455,
0.288955956697464,
0.021974699571728706,
0.10493184626102448,
-0.3689784109592438,
-0.2688813805580139,
0.47247859835624695,
0.21817539632320404,
0.644798994064331,
0.08885066211223602,
0.3670564889907837,
0.25829586386680603,
0.15313312411308289,
0.0035608841571956873,
0.06287330389022827,
-0.10912265628576279,
-0.2530205547809601,
-0.4716663062572479,
-0.8992260694503784,
-0.8629451990127563,
-0.004202600102871656,
-0.7380362153053284,
-0.16084665060043335,
-0.2947571277618408,
0.13723385334014893,
-0.024876656010746956,
0.12168814241886139,
-0.19203364849090576,
0.26188579201698303,
-0.1206996738910675,
0.9064496159553528,
-0.9624063372612,
0.41895636916160583,
0.9862059354782104,
-0.32585105299949646,
-0.07101558893918991,
-0.07006073743104935,
0.1516057848930359,
-0.37401092052459717,
-0.029264649376273155,
-0.07790987938642502,
-0.17402228713035583,
-0.20905040204524994,
-0.5275990962982178,
-0.9639574289321899,
1.0196547508239746,
0.06700405478477478,
-0.46493637561798096,
-0.05250609666109085,
0.012392453849315643,
0.5576424598693848,
-0.30916622281074524,
0.0945238471031189,
0.48082655668258667,
0.17146320641040802,
0.009016040712594986,
-0.6548919677734375,
-0.01303898449987173,
-0.6679441928863525,
-0.3652127981185913,
0.15552106499671936,
-0.6658968329429626,
0.6430475115776062,
-0.3047837018966675,
-0.13467922806739807,
-0.07101232558488846,
1.308779239654541,
0.5402353405952454,
0.6045663356781006,
0.2216538041830063,
0.41406282782554626,
0.7899501323699951,
-0.08460122346878052,
0.7682073712348938,
-0.6303054690361023,
0.31479206681251526,
1.3312779664993286,
-0.15072156488895416,
0.4903610944747925,
0.5064910650253296,
-0.2884698212146759,
0.3717169463634491,
0.6687772870063782,
0.1186286211013794,
0.6253714561462402,
-0.15848194062709808,
-0.21190819144248962,
0.03147457540035248,
-0.20501531660556793,
-0.5631371140480042,
0.02005421556532383,
0.48740649223327637,
-0.3676268756389618,
-0.37796005606651306,
-0.1446836292743683,
0.1545879989862442,
0.23867937922477722,
-0.33065667748451233,
0.9286247491836548,
0.24565868079662323,
-0.5052754282951355,
0.059114713221788406,
-0.12407006323337555,
0.6555687189102173,
-0.44964221119880676,
0.08855362981557846,
-0.4757266044616699,
-0.2163315862417221,
-0.44013431668281555,
-0.8599454760551453,
0.5063687562942505,
0.32882240414619446,
-0.1983444094657898,
-0.009933752939105034,
0.23900413513183594,
-0.42064952850341797,
-0.6106832027435303,
-0.308083713054657,
0.5207052230834961,
0.26353371143341064,
0.07587643712759018,
-0.36206626892089844,
-0.16964693367481232,
-0.287750780582428,
-0.39588189125061035,
0.40405982732772827,
0.4720454216003418,
0.22671595215797424,
0.5129375457763672,
0.5690632462501526,
0.46628400683403015,
-0.3596464991569519,
0.008751439861953259,
0.9742555618286133,
-0.5835327506065369,
-0.6456503868103027,
-0.5519794225692749,
0.3447502553462982,
-0.3227177858352661,
-0.33263516426086426,
0.8275940418243408,
1.2695419788360596,
0.45850870013237,
0.1802820861339569,
1.175060749053955,
-0.19436031579971313,
0.6924864649772644,
-0.47448623180389404,
1.0416392087936401,
-0.6733835339546204,
0.34470683336257935,
-0.06060028076171875,
-0.7321327924728394,
-0.5099849700927734,
0.28560230135917664,
-0.0615030899643898,
0.029891587793827057,
0.773646891117096,
0.5110582113265991,
-0.2596113085746765,
0.06549177318811417,
-0.16671213507652283,
0.059919990599155426,
0.505010187625885,
0.04252967983484268,
0.3709176778793335,
-0.12475486099720001,
0.2719704210758209,
-0.43509969115257263,
-0.36614376306533813,
-0.20079028606414795,
-0.9109413027763367,
-0.7270944714546204,
-0.7927942872047424,
-0.428268164396286,
-0.35342222452163696,
0.33580514788627625,
0.8330801129341125,
0.3095359802246094,
-1.1181015968322754,
-0.21933668851852417,
-0.10755224525928497,
-0.21112485229969025,
-0.17013554275035858,
-0.17038676142692566,
0.7035214304924011,
-0.4090985953807831,
-0.4395997226238251,
0.4304616153240204,
0.3218173086643219,
0.11224693804979324,
-0.34618186950683594,
-0.09991522878408432,
0.036578819155693054,
-0.09924884885549545,
0.40248122811317444,
0.5670610666275024,
-0.33247411251068115,
0.07559093087911606,
0.13657283782958984,
-0.11062047630548477,
0.14165164530277252,
1.017830729484558,
-0.4648640751838684,
0.12557324767112732,
0.4343228042125702,
0.3630587160587311,
0.4856286346912384,
0.16364231705665588,
0.6074283719062805,
-0.765863835811615,
-0.032862260937690735,
0.293760746717453,
0.48376724123954773,
0.655933141708374,
-0.38908880949020386,
0.4918168783187866,
0.006431700196117163,
-0.5315407514572144,
-0.8808497190475464,
-0.09614286571741104,
-0.9557598829269409,
-0.3294214904308319,
1.2080843448638916,
-0.27961859107017517,
-0.268178254365921,
-0.1431807577610016,
0.022032056003808975,
0.4263112545013428,
-0.5765812397003174,
1.1501426696777344,
0.3650023937225342,
-0.3438478708267212,
0.09689508378505707,
0.0361187718808651,
0.5622804164886475,
0.33867889642715454,
-1.1270700693130493,
0.4825671315193176,
0.843708336353302,
0.10416870564222336,
0.26810964941978455,
0.5424072742462158,
-0.3121629059314728,
0.2127784639596939,
-0.3647049069404602,
0.35998210310935974,
-0.5240962505340576,
-0.592847466468811,
-0.517379641532898,
0.3911885917186737,
0.12183520197868347,
0.29020288586616516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05297v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05297v3
|
PEEB: Part-based Image Classifiers with an Explainable and Editable Language Bottleneck
| 2024-03-08T13:24:46 | 2024-04-12T20:10:29 |
Thang M. Pham, Peijie Chen, Tin Nguyen, Seunghyun Yoon, Trung Bui, Anh Totti Nguyen
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
CLIP-based classifiers rely on the prompt containing a {class name} that is
known to the text encoder. Therefore, they perform poorly on new classes or the
classes whose names rarely appear on the Internet (e.g., scientific names of
birds). For fine-grained classification, we propose PEEB - an explainable and
editable classifier to (1) express the class name into a set of text
descriptors that describe the visual parts of that class; and (2) match the
embeddings of the detected parts to their textual descriptors in each class to
compute a logit score for classification. In a zero-shot setting where the
class names are unknown, PEEB outperforms CLIP by a huge margin (~10x in top-1
accuracy). Compared to part-based classifiers, PEEB is not only the
state-of-the-art (SOTA) on the supervised-learning setting (88.80% and 92.20%
accuracy on CUB-200 and Dogs-120, respectively) but also the first to enable
users to edit the text descriptors to form a new classifier without any
re-training. Compared to concept bottleneck models, PEEB is also the SOTA in
both zero-shot and supervised-learning settings.
|
[
-0.5553646087646484,
-0.8672561645507812,
0.5943721532821655,
0.27252429723739624,
-0.3712629973888397,
0.1285838484764099,
-0.09611214697360992,
-0.8292280435562134,
-0.1637808084487915,
0.15378157794475555,
-0.19145822525024414,
-0.38808131217956543,
-0.6168994903564453,
-0.05766233801841736,
-0.6412186622619629,
0.9088821411132812,
0.10946479439735413,
0.03437812998890877,
-0.2755565047264099,
-0.10263324528932571,
-0.6432024836540222,
-0.2503511607646942,
-0.7488915920257568,
-0.21931113302707672,
0.4471736550331116,
0.3785873055458069,
0.8369007110595703,
0.8684099912643433,
0.5014647841453552,
0.2763078510761261,
-0.10369399189949036,
-0.19034501910209656,
-0.07545355707406998,
-0.025673674419522285,
-0.4414830803871155,
-0.7268341779708862,
-0.27575555443763733,
-0.3428613841533661,
0.16184180974960327,
0.44810882210731506,
0.24584929645061493,
0.04731724411249161,
-0.06850753724575043,
0.5419273972511292,
-0.8878424763679504,
0.5827452540397644,
-0.5842360258102417,
0.09598509967327118,
-0.3233585059642792,
-0.36839431524276733,
-0.5005132555961609,
-0.26109519600868225,
0.1686915010213852,
-0.542540967464447,
0.6281020045280457,
-0.022090042009949684,
1.224768877029419,
0.2888941764831543,
0.20489539206027985,
-0.27217093110084534,
-0.5112605690956116,
0.6167777180671692,
-0.09479308128356934,
0.4589070975780487,
0.1306745857000351,
0.41844189167022705,
-0.11180710792541504,
-0.7004680633544922,
-0.5902283787727356,
0.5451615452766418,
0.14891359210014343,
0.030509687960147858,
-0.05799783393740654,
0.2677440047264099,
0.02395600453019142,
0.4206247329711914,
-0.3108885586261749,
0.020573018118739128,
-0.4412015676498413,
-0.1830635666847229,
0.3652050793170929,
0.06718788295984268,
0.3739619255065918,
-0.09622982889413834,
-0.4561081528663635,
-0.004007311537861824,
-0.5486648082733154,
0.4212585985660553,
0.07097811251878738,
0.22450603544712067,
0.20126691460609436,
0.3586616516113281,
-0.14462794363498688,
0.7635779976844788,
0.37213268876075745,
-0.3423531949520111,
0.06747552752494812,
0.29934337735176086,
-0.2846077084541321,
0.2987672984600067,
0.8482400178909302,
0.5470952391624451,
0.20059983432292938,
-0.1356697678565979,
0.006191931199282408,
-0.014942682348191738,
0.013948453590273857,
-1.309831142425537,
-0.6930810213088989,
0.09300071746110916,
-0.48177844285964966,
-0.456037700176239,
0.013993802480399609,
-0.6280335783958435,
-0.2949405014514923,
0.0088443448767066,
0.8251293897628784,
-0.37530994415283203,
0.24060356616973877,
0.14218991994857788,
-0.35540568828582764,
0.44612282514572144,
0.7784224152565002,
-0.8626239895820618,
0.012677880004048347,
0.6489661335945129,
0.9926748275756836,
0.050895754247903824,
-0.42286112904548645,
-0.16857261955738068,
-0.07117773592472076,
-0.4240051209926605,
1.3730566501617432,
-0.9063124060630798,
-0.3340917229652405,
-0.39699307084083557,
0.12244958430528641,
0.15032745897769928,
-0.6752150058746338,
0.1290854811668396,
-0.2995339035987854,
0.30298009514808655,
-0.07993902266025543,
-0.6346068978309631,
-0.2109885960817337,
-0.006459152791649103,
-0.4089418053627014,
0.9975764751434326,
-0.073077492415905,
-1.0020231008529663,
0.6941964626312256,
-0.45802798867225647,
-0.3501632511615753,
0.27140286564826965,
-0.37121251225471497,
-0.4872164726257324,
0.14679685235023499,
0.25727754831314087,
0.8713639378547668,
-0.039452336728572845,
0.19100460410118103,
-0.5189828872680664,
-0.6058238744735718,
0.3087368309497833,
-0.29893970489501953,
0.517386794090271,
0.038083143532276154,
-0.26678282022476196,
0.06910734623670578,
-0.6244062185287476,
0.011747259646654129,
0.08370408415794373,
-0.31131526827812195,
-0.39226511120796204,
0.02064252458512783,
-0.024895984679460526,
-0.06196767836809158,
0.18676500022411346,
-0.7026284337043762,
0.17514358460903168,
0.20554335415363312,
0.45086851716041565,
0.733586847782135,
-0.15029948949813843,
0.32843005657196045,
-0.15274281799793243,
0.4526521861553192,
-0.249986469745636,
0.6155058741569519,
-0.5473344326019287,
-0.6636410355567932,
-1.0237646102905273,
-0.637622594833374,
0.5527036786079407,
0.538139283657074,
-0.42846211791038513,
0.24174562096595764,
0.005165844690054655,
-0.48459041118621826,
-0.4461055397987366,
-0.1602620780467987,
0.3259418308734894,
0.6491495966911316,
0.2560254633426666,
-0.4845520853996277,
-0.3522655963897705,
-0.9047800302505493,
-0.018880899995565414,
-0.36705857515335083,
-0.027959801256656647,
0.3883325159549713,
0.2458404153585434,
0.04111393541097641,
0.9954818487167358,
-0.5699722170829773,
-0.21884191036224365,
-0.06160448491573334,
0.18365123867988586,
-0.12644073367118835,
0.3028843402862549,
0.3845992088317871,
-0.8264108896255493,
-0.5964548587799072,
0.02193404920399189,
-0.6978524923324585,
-0.2889535427093506,
-0.20419594645500183,
-0.15169796347618103,
0.06456247717142105,
0.6388596892356873,
-0.460278183221817,
0.6056906580924988,
0.08088859170675278,
-0.3776713013648987,
0.726074755191803,
-0.0017549615586176515,
0.08623871952295303,
-0.6456316709518433,
-0.18680313229560852,
-0.14475694298744202,
-0.4867694675922394,
-0.3094902038574219,
0.17848385870456696,
0.3066156208515167,
-0.19668053090572357,
-0.749839186668396,
0.4553540349006653,
-0.27250033617019653,
-0.04064197838306427,
-0.5946423411369324,
0.11028271168470383,
0.3501102924346924,
0.5068727135658264,
0.3207316994667053,
0.7487947344779968,
1.0833697319030762,
-0.6964100003242493,
0.18177765607833862,
0.2920726239681244,
-0.3883504569530487,
0.7323992252349854,
-0.7007143497467041,
-0.15833750367164612,
-0.1795453578233719,
0.24293753504753113,
-0.5242262482643127,
-0.39219793677330017,
0.051113199442625046,
-0.335708349943161,
0.4608200192451477,
-0.3404100239276886,
-0.22778941690921783,
-0.1904127150774002,
-0.3702071011066437,
0.4685054421424866,
0.4770190119743347,
-0.9056970477104187,
0.3550068736076355,
0.3496902883052826,
-0.24612700939178467,
-0.6499428749084473,
-0.4319586157798767,
0.07116620987653732,
-0.1575891077518463,
-0.41496986150741577,
0.5418351292610168,
0.11500967293977737,
0.2530139684677124,
0.3528313636779785,
-0.3229771852493286,
-0.5060756206512451,
-0.030786210671067238,
0.6484205722808838,
0.26525846123695374,
-0.18439455330371857,
0.46425774693489075,
-0.12378914654254913,
-0.039433784782886505,
-0.09004472941160202,
0.1314081996679306,
0.47509896755218506,
-0.526752233505249,
-0.1938026398420334,
-0.541014552116394,
0.12394782155752182,
0.5446723699569702,
-0.025758711621165276,
0.2860603332519531,
0.781692624092102,
-0.1898990273475647,
-0.25109556317329407,
-0.3159862756729126,
0.08263624459505081,
-0.48368266224861145,
0.6207543015480042,
-0.6552150845527649,
-0.817001461982727,
0.6043084859848022,
-0.04488866776227951,
-0.12799915671348572,
0.20109860599040985,
0.3330974876880646,
-0.44693201780319214,
0.6959264278411865,
1.023169994354248,
0.19857469201087952,
0.911675751209259,
-0.1896883249282837,
0.3747967779636383,
-0.7570165395736694,
-0.660927951335907,
-0.42981773614883423,
-0.3505595624446869,
-0.590246856212616,
-0.7666922211647034,
0.04529307782649994,
0.6719074249267578,
0.06495779007673264,
0.4980717897415161,
-0.6199212670326233,
1.0809125900268555,
0.5934251546859741,
0.40478697419166565,
0.06915364414453506,
-0.247796431183815,
0.3407137393951416,
0.19452227652072906,
-0.686522364616394,
-0.5375246405601501,
0.8885785341262817,
0.4399775564670563,
1.3011258840560913,
-0.29604867100715637,
0.6317190527915955,
0.16506682336330414,
-0.044505152851343155,
-1.20848548412323,
0.6740577816963196,
-0.44621846079826355,
-0.6749850511550903,
-0.13842566311359406,
-0.012242624536156654,
-0.7124983668327332,
0.2765715420246124,
-0.12935474514961243,
-0.6698119640350342,
0.4245297610759735,
0.4835044741630554,
-0.19831572473049164,
0.45176538825035095,
-0.7759994864463806,
1.0354453325271606,
-0.38537415862083435,
-0.563614547252655,
-0.01774430461227894,
-0.26469284296035767,
0.2585426867008209,
-0.06762674450874329,
-0.06149209663271904,
-0.2881028354167938,
-0.05165283754467964,
0.6454285979270935,
-0.7417491674423218,
0.7564326524734497,
-0.4702109694480896,
0.38605332374572754,
0.3910912871360779,
0.0111937141045928,
0.1570550501346588,
-0.10946938395500183,
0.36540529131889343,
0.3249259889125824,
0.2110775262117386,
-0.5003671050071716,
-0.7796558737754822,
0.3925343155860901,
-0.36133891344070435,
-0.4322419762611389,
-0.3071650564670563,
-0.1749376505613327,
-0.10513604432344437,
0.10987446457147598,
0.40838655829429626,
0.5219084620475769,
0.07793563604354858,
0.24529537558555603,
0.7654279470443726,
-0.6264433860778809,
0.4020398259162903,
0.3497016131877899,
-0.5371116995811462,
-0.004885960835963488,
1.2758759260177612,
-0.3497580289840698,
-0.11570841819047928,
0.44330355525016785,
0.3899979293346405,
-0.24378930032253265,
-0.5162293910980225,
-0.6132469773292542,
-0.13529494404792786,
-0.6411160230636597,
-0.5127201080322266,
-0.5881027579307556,
-0.23837442696094513,
0.15224608778953552,
-0.4292730987071991,
-0.6358903646469116,
-0.5084137320518494,
-0.35403749346733093,
0.19599922001361847,
0.27332788705825806,
0.5691511631011963,
0.25647157430648804,
0.567781925201416,
-0.5750563740730286,
0.24323523044586182,
0.5403525233268738,
0.6673851609230042,
-0.2416100949048996,
-0.5877740979194641,
-0.1673268973827362,
-0.5003437995910645,
-0.444538950920105,
-0.6872740387916565,
0.009189697913825512,
0.7250117659568787,
0.19660910964012146,
0.7764186859130859,
-0.03519010171294212,
1.2222237586975098,
-0.5077757835388184,
0.5657877326011658,
0.43916577100753784,
-1.1830118894577026,
0.6543093919754028,
0.17563073337078094,
0.18490268290042877,
0.47932669520378113,
0.3701794743537903,
-0.2950247526168823,
-0.5748550891876221,
-0.31803807616233826,
-0.9490814208984375,
0.6764979958534241,
-0.10200967639684677,
0.06678058952093124,
0.18836718797683716,
0.21608464419841766,
0.6635389924049377,
0.1632469892501831,
-0.6954679489135742,
0.09659808874130249,
-0.44241344928741455,
-0.2874343693256378,
0.6025334000587463,
-0.2688104212284088,
0.4598541259765625,
-0.17515693604946136,
0.753277063369751,
-0.1661275327205658,
0.353068470954895,
0.27937498688697815,
-0.2672162652015686,
0.09161390364170074,
0.3894798755645752,
0.19147221744060516,
0.5766632556915283,
-0.48143213987350464,
0.2611536681652069,
-0.26751115918159485,
-0.5647764205932617,
-0.046422917395830154,
-0.19618482887744904,
-0.47423291206359863,
0.2106562703847885,
0.4816245436668396,
1.0697588920593262,
0.24123451113700867,
-0.8533570170402527,
0.8102020621299744,
-0.361687570810318,
-0.26760876178741455,
-0.08610653132200241,
0.3510773479938507,
-0.32629236578941345,
0.47096481919288635,
0.21579153835773468,
0.3227050006389618,
0.31008878350257874,
-0.5871003270149231,
0.02640012465417385,
0.3637066185474396,
-0.44475916028022766,
-0.4447411894798279,
0.5403444170951843,
0.3255018889904022,
-0.3401365280151367,
0.12855394184589386,
-0.3506166636943817,
-0.8709345459938049,
0.35580208897590637,
0.44778311252593994,
0.7656307220458984,
0.17573483288288116,
0.5409114956855774,
0.21838663518428802,
0.09108826518058777,
0.0032412647269666195,
0.23180119693279266,
-0.32651054859161377,
-0.6191993951797485,
-0.42269814014434814,
-0.926108181476593,
-0.7490478157997131,
0.3747878968715668,
-0.7024823427200317,
0.4120294153690338,
-0.7287923693656921,
-0.15841636061668396,
0.49442318081855774,
-0.3939700424671173,
-0.6933047771453857,
0.20395736396312714,
0.13555213809013367,
0.958059549331665,
-0.8474938273429871,
0.753573477268219,
0.9899928569793701,
-0.2402731031179428,
-0.6896586418151855,
-0.0019041708437725902,
-0.4612034857273102,
-0.6976280808448792,
0.7416415810585022,
0.6024488806724548,
0.006664452608674765,
-0.49833354353904724,
-0.46208447217941284,
-0.4554682672023773,
0.8046126961708069,
0.3672299087047577,
-0.6402050256729126,
-0.10918796807527542,
-0.12381838262081146,
0.41576939821243286,
-0.002691056579351425,
0.2732968032360077,
0.211494579911232,
0.27468353509902954,
0.029285721480846405,
-0.9342361688613892,
-0.1892460286617279,
-0.1446576565504074,
-0.22590307891368866,
0.3600950837135315,
-0.8640230894088745,
0.855976402759552,
-0.34972506761550903,
-0.41827237606048584,
-0.07725029438734055,
0.2659081220626831,
-0.09666386991739273,
0.6512691378593445,
0.5142000913619995,
0.43736398220062256,
0.6192273497581482,
-0.39695847034454346,
0.5390797257423401,
-0.14643990993499756,
0.3697074353694916,
1.3537272214889526,
0.18011735379695892,
0.9920858144760132,
0.5307911038398743,
-0.5104488730430603,
0.6401326656341553,
0.8536309003829956,
-0.33392518758773804,
0.6625094413757324,
-0.1679224967956543,
-0.29964542388916016,
-0.4531550407409668,
-0.053204070776700974,
-0.040613166987895966,
0.8898441791534424,
0.2810244560241699,
-0.39805305004119873,
-0.2935374677181244,
0.37944483757019043,
-0.25886258482933044,
-0.25553569197654724,
-0.40225568413734436,
0.6785770654678345,
-0.17430710792541504,
-0.25611695647239685,
0.37799277901649475,
-0.0127809913828969,
0.786629855632782,
-0.29034608602523804,
-0.05383576080203056,
-0.14460404217243195,
0.3008589446544647,
-0.5180858969688416,
-1.1316964626312256,
0.3617582619190216,
0.28069767355918884,
-0.3920168876647949,
-0.05185800790786743,
0.9654365181922913,
-0.2770768404006958,
-0.35493385791778564,
-0.05415348708629608,
0.029592929407954216,
0.636491596698761,
-0.36159706115722656,
-0.6478943228721619,
0.1985778510570526,
0.03340373560786247,
0.05284922942519188,
0.21591316163539886,
0.6123591661453247,
-0.18878798186779022,
0.9004251956939697,
0.15293438732624054,
0.1681625247001648,
0.33667880296707153,
-0.20542550086975098,
0.6453689932823181,
-0.694333553314209,
-0.2278689593076706,
-0.5764628648757935,
0.2196231186389923,
-0.0007660070550628006,
0.08779876679182053,
0.3833707571029663,
0.7257946729660034,
1.227081060409546,
-0.3931148052215576,
0.8464422225952148,
-0.5204288959503174,
0.07829735428094864,
-0.44820937514305115,
0.43376681208610535,
-0.47618260979652405,
-0.07561707496643066,
-0.22565560042858124,
-0.7822667360305786,
-0.26218968629837036,
0.8891381025314331,
-0.08567746728658676,
-0.29639849066734314,
0.8471253514289856,
0.7200983762741089,
-0.3297266960144043,
0.054458264261484146,
0.37981975078582764,
0.018966292962431908,
0.3648602366447449,
0.36420077085494995,
0.741274356842041,
-0.5212260484695435,
0.9066804051399231,
-0.7960290908813477,
-0.30841076374053955,
-0.41940736770629883,
-0.829082727432251,
-1.010359525680542,
-0.5158705711364746,
-0.7818498611450195,
0.1267991065979004,
0.01355077140033245,
0.305597722530365,
1.0550585985183716,
-0.8735781908035278,
0.2638750970363617,
-0.19835194945335388,
0.04862810671329498,
0.0507575199007988,
-0.3479824960231781,
0.4922013580799103,
-0.44137072563171387,
-0.8320494890213013,
-0.010878565721213818,
0.5935153365135193,
0.1653691977262497,
-0.004351393785327673,
0.07241461426019669,
0.3538092374801636,
-0.003511645132675767,
0.7601132988929749,
0.6128714084625244,
-0.8541561961174011,
-0.40605664253234863,
-0.2845040559768677,
0.14705228805541992,
0.10551351308822632,
0.6940799355506897,
-0.7813624143600464,
0.767202615737915,
0.44535356760025024,
0.602627158164978,
0.497755765914917,
0.20976465940475464,
-0.06536970287561417,
-0.6555987596511841,
0.2650967836380005,
0.010013007558882236,
0.29972514510154724,
0.42531082034111023,
-0.05371757224202156,
0.29001039266586304,
0.3748652935028076,
-0.662570059299469,
-0.8637551069259644,
0.08467862010002136,
-1.1992509365081787,
-0.5125624537467957,
0.5741274952888489,
-0.6068979501724243,
-0.5966825485229492,
-0.04875916987657547,
-0.4618137776851654,
0.23854321241378784,
-0.427408903837204,
1.0263029336929321,
0.4890110492706299,
-0.5389147996902466,
-0.16833971440792084,
-0.31350135803222656,
0.2738974690437317,
0.13016530871391296,
-0.8576620221138,
0.017164478078484535,
0.5383356809616089,
0.5852119326591492,
0.18605490028858185,
0.36456331610679626,
-0.2063082754611969,
0.37416213750839233,
0.13635915517807007,
0.4551659822463989,
-0.26898902654647827,
-0.6966427564620972,
0.08846785873174667,
0.16044916212558746,
0.2710709869861603,
-0.7214585542678833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05286v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05286v2
|
LLM4Decompile: Decompiling Binary Code with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-08T13:10:59 | 2024-06-19T02:45:03 |
Hanzhuo Tan, Qi Luo, Jing Li, Yuqun Zhang
|
cs.PL
|
cs.PL, cs.CL
|
Decompilation aims to convert binary code to high-level source code, but
traditional tools like Ghidra often produce results that are difficult to read
and execute. Motivated by the advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs), we
propose LLM4Decompile, the first and largest open-source LLM series (1.3B to
33B) trained to decompile binary code. We optimize the LLM training process and
introduce the LLM4Decompile-End models to decompile binary directly. The
resulting models significantly outperform GPT-4o and Ghidra on the HumanEval
and ExeBench benchmarks by over 100%. Additionally, we improve the standard
refinement approach to fine-tune the LLM4Decompile-Ref models, enabling them to
effectively refine the decompiled code from Ghidra and achieve a further 16.2%
improvement over the LLM4Decompile-End. LLM4Decompile demonstrates the
potential of LLMs to revolutionize binary code decompilation, delivering
remarkable improvements in readability and executability while complementing
conventional tools for optimal results. Our code, dataset, and models are
released at https://github.com/albertan017/LLM4Decompile
|
[
-0.33051797747612,
-0.22429269552230835,
0.5033848881721497,
-0.02356789819896221,
-0.3424990475177765,
0.16635580360889435,
-0.22741442918777466,
-0.6634246110916138,
-0.06311877816915512,
0.6116237044334412,
-0.3914039134979248,
-0.789014995098114,
-0.6371375918388367,
0.24135002493858337,
-0.45506715774536133,
0.7936490774154663,
-0.16737793385982513,
0.12262288480997086,
-0.10992652922868729,
0.000564378802664578,
-0.2797568440437317,
-0.8012256026268005,
-0.34565675258636475,
-0.14880234003067017,
0.2828507721424103,
0.41246870160102844,
0.5430883169174194,
0.7195121049880981,
0.5988831520080566,
0.3310687839984894,
-0.09082399308681488,
0.03903808817267418,
-0.8500428795814514,
0.028990451246500015,
-0.046731993556022644,
-0.6568402051925659,
-0.1786719113588333,
-0.09630368649959564,
0.5042257308959961,
0.18441322445869446,
-0.17984610795974731,
0.34886085987091064,
-0.3666587173938751,
0.5797284245491028,
-0.4335390627384186,
0.32295921444892883,
-0.568089485168457,
-0.0865536481142044,
-0.2528759837150574,
-0.2522617280483246,
-0.5281479954719543,
-0.7513589262962341,
-0.6790945529937744,
-0.11063087731599808,
0.31625983119010925,
0.06830555200576782,
0.5355727672576904,
0.5145049691200256,
-0.2760730981826782,
-0.28680822253227234,
-0.6497126221656799,
0.7169094085693359,
-1.0962506532669067,
0.5168554186820984,
0.28439947962760925,
0.14034275710582733,
-0.10499390959739685,
-0.8212958574295044,
-0.32643797993659973,
-0.10268951952457428,
0.492184042930603,
-0.21676547825336456,
-0.21644744277000427,
0.10353415459394455,
0.4290798306465149,
0.556454598903656,
-0.504804253578186,
0.4672355651855469,
-0.6829135417938232,
-0.21836359798908234,
0.432740718126297,
0.18563750386238098,
0.24394680559635162,
-0.030706115067005157,
-0.1845865249633789,
0.08792950958013535,
-1.0442348718643188,
-0.35793060064315796,
0.719125509262085,
-0.10616324096918106,
-0.12255696207284927,
0.5669639110565186,
0.09670362621545792,
0.43524259328842163,
-0.23623956739902496,
-0.08455052971839905,
0.36085206270217896,
-0.34375807642936707,
-0.006986644119024277,
0.06941860914230347,
0.4702743887901306,
0.47054851055145264,
0.026397446170449257,
-0.160101979970932,
-0.20697864890098572,
0.4196886420249939,
0.21592697501182556,
-1.4352762699127197,
-0.5677044987678528,
0.4775443375110626,
-0.623629629611969,
-0.31786614656448364,
-0.3885383605957031,
-0.3650825321674347,
-0.08823636919260025,
-0.4036169648170471,
0.2171623855829239,
-0.4561309218406677,
-0.23659957945346832,
0.4147831201553345,
0.024213027209043503,
0.3126932382583618,
0.34083613753318787,
-1.0728099346160889,
0.21780087053775787,
0.8180145025253296,
0.7207056283950806,
-0.02182888798415661,
-0.08703393489122391,
-0.5712023973464966,
0.11326476186513901,
-0.34140488505363464,
0.5995269417762756,
-0.39776936173439026,
-0.2156403660774231,
-0.17826737463474274,
-0.14718219637870789,
0.5175936222076416,
-0.8038525581359863,
0.42505979537963867,
-0.7064485549926758,
-0.24176743626594543,
-0.1314924657344818,
-0.6775237321853638,
-0.2688947916030884,
0.20833735167980194,
-0.977508008480072,
0.7558074593544006,
0.26255926489830017,
-0.8613163828849792,
0.012471212074160576,
-0.5705241560935974,
0.02554617077112198,
-0.08048506081104279,
-0.2063419669866562,
-0.375621497631073,
0.2591713070869446,
0.12506526708602905,
0.44724053144454956,
-0.6471713781356812,
0.11317189037799835,
-0.19366542994976044,
-0.5370985865592957,
0.05073723569512367,
-0.16208107769489288,
0.672512948513031,
0.3017115890979767,
-0.22582632303237915,
0.15564091503620148,
-0.5679178237915039,
-0.023853547871112823,
0.14454783499240875,
-0.5917181372642517,
0.06273189187049866,
-0.14817850291728973,
-0.2300696223974228,
0.11941207945346832,
0.5013588070869446,
-0.6687821745872498,
0.25647103786468506,
-0.4702928960323334,
0.5264465808868408,
1.0175964832305908,
0.006981974933296442,
0.27390769124031067,
-0.04971111938357353,
0.5106943249702454,
0.0012589424150064588,
0.12951627373695374,
-0.05708600580692291,
-0.419768750667572,
-0.43602821230888367,
-0.2585737109184265,
0.5089868307113647,
0.26910316944122314,
-0.746135413646698,
0.15091750025749207,
-0.2928628623485565,
-0.39687031507492065,
-0.511359453201294,
0.3652454614639282,
0.3851277232170105,
0.13108806312084198,
0.17233368754386902,
-0.26412084698677063,
-0.6504305005073547,
-0.8940412998199463,
0.12148816138505936,
0.01394741702824831,
0.08608649671077728,
-0.24770081043243408,
0.5524494647979736,
-0.7461224794387817,
0.6034006476402283,
-0.5220973491668701,
0.26974061131477356,
-0.44090235233306885,
0.07594744861125946,
0.393774151802063,
0.4594874083995819,
0.5492551922798157,
-0.49283891916275024,
-0.09042418748140335,
-0.04771685227751732,
-0.6162489056587219,
-0.18603970110416412,
0.4378921389579773,
-0.12004117667675018,
0.37287694215774536,
0.5268169045448303,
-0.25975948572158813,
0.12414861470460892,
1.1311808824539185,
-0.15601158142089844,
0.7536863684654236,
-0.3396039307117462,
-0.029493574053049088,
-0.9843090176582336,
0.19005097448825836,
-0.2963999807834625,
-0.4325954020023346,
-0.4486647844314575,
0.47869542241096497,
0.27472013235092163,
-0.20154450833797455,
-0.49255871772766113,
0.12432116270065308,
-0.6427191495895386,
-0.43310871720314026,
-0.2945404052734375,
-0.31487804651260376,
-0.2736801207065582,
0.44448402523994446,
-0.17421025037765503,
0.7427601218223572,
0.28971153497695923,
-0.4388374388217926,
0.5511086583137512,
0.23022925853729248,
-0.5012574195861816,
-0.32975369691848755,
-0.6206187009811401,
0.4266313314437866,
-0.021951718255877495,
0.24321573972702026,
-0.7993770837783813,
-0.3041180670261383,
0.25917497277259827,
-0.2207246869802475,
0.36183011531829834,
-0.3393979072570801,
-0.9186951518058777,
-0.3508531153202057,
-0.5502789616584778,
0.60063636302948,
0.6655905842781067,
-0.8672071695327759,
0.4118698835372925,
0.20868781208992004,
-0.2005317509174347,
-0.48749488592147827,
-0.6672345399856567,
0.05141429230570793,
-0.004809874575585127,
-0.539328932762146,
0.23554764688014984,
-0.6019011735916138,
-0.18231654167175293,
0.09498870372772217,
-0.24065040051937103,
0.0363629087805748,
-0.1434842199087143,
0.3034142851829529,
0.3895788788795471,
-0.05633511766791344,
-0.28293779492378235,
0.03317858651280403,
-0.39651066064834595,
0.17634564638137817,
0.0076259225606918335,
0.8789095878601074,
-0.22274699807167053,
-0.3620571494102478,
-0.219000443816185,
0.234707310795784,
0.48646628856658936,
-0.40364134311676025,
0.5340632796287537,
0.40659022331237793,
-0.18269629776477814,
-0.18413034081459045,
-0.5569749474525452,
0.006772736553102732,
-0.502373456954956,
0.2835627794265747,
-0.34630265831947327,
-1.252787470817566,
0.5360498428344727,
-0.3967592716217041,
0.2844606041908264,
0.0934000164270401,
0.6952535510063171,
0.44809791445732117,
0.8565606474876404,
0.8174225091934204,
-0.12709587812423706,
0.20382313430309296,
-0.5973854660987854,
0.11242079734802246,
-0.6594243049621582,
-0.08715959638357162,
-0.6326214075088501,
-0.36415132880210876,
-0.4702303111553192,
-0.7920159697532654,
0.018246423453092575,
-0.125156432390213,
-0.26328083872795105,
0.445885568857193,
-0.5997393131256104,
0.7943761944770813,
0.3133012652397156,
0.26566681265830994,
0.4284871816635132,
-0.07746288180351257,
0.005119543522596359,
0.0019879438914358616,
-0.36970826983451843,
-0.26395803689956665,
1.175707221031189,
0.5978383421897888,
0.9612297415733337,
0.3548840582370758,
1.207358717918396,
0.1854882836341858,
0.3208368718624115,
-0.8444516062736511,
0.5378420352935791,
-0.1321363002061844,
-0.6462759971618652,
0.07445887476205826,
-0.7355695962905884,
-0.7751882672309875,
-0.06643420457839966,
0.267782062292099,
-0.3450840711593628,
0.07833720743656158,
-0.027826502919197083,
-0.014053873717784882,
0.34401002526283264,
-0.6499205231666565,
0.8539732098579407,
-0.26540854573249817,
-0.22875294089317322,
-0.39101558923721313,
-0.6159361004829407,
0.7963215708732605,
-0.35772886872291565,
0.3926820755004883,
-0.27410128712654114,
-0.31208062171936035,
0.5601373314857483,
-0.5062361359596252,
0.8516331911087036,
-0.1211288720369339,
-0.6081416010856628,
0.03738243132829666,
0.33050134778022766,
0.4974764585494995,
-0.24950802326202393,
-0.3222289979457855,
0.4620625674724579,
-0.07217179983854294,
-0.3470104932785034,
-0.42184123396873474,
0.7689558863639832,
-0.9217904806137085,
-0.2575666010379791,
-0.2166021317243576,
-0.39212509989738464,
0.22153723239898682,
0.22892874479293823,
0.3846465051174164,
0.791419267654419,
0.02964361570775509,
0.0001337883877567947,
0.7554847598075867,
-0.3731217384338379,
0.34746670722961426,
0.3837437331676483,
-0.6060004830360413,
-0.6230495572090149,
0.6709955334663391,
-0.1996314525604248,
0.3131004869937897,
0.263785719871521,
-0.08135934919118881,
-0.4424610733985901,
-1.0285526514053345,
-0.13077333569526672,
0.4595869779586792,
-1.071548581123352,
-0.5617886185646057,
-0.3784569501876831,
-0.27804791927337646,
-0.23836348950862885,
-0.15312805771827698,
-0.5109177827835083,
-0.16386163234710693,
-0.07912332564592361,
-0.1736816018819809,
0.376776784658432,
1.131629228591919,
-0.3244817554950714,
0.23504607379436493,
-1.0244866609573364,
0.6690574288368225,
-0.04824022203683853,
0.37838074564933777,
-0.3220026195049286,
-0.5156314373016357,
-0.4191948473453522,
-0.23801104724407196,
-0.12228105217218399,
-0.8274509310722351,
0.6292622089385986,
-0.06622719764709473,
0.4411211311817169,
0.13824759423732758,
0.11089024692773819,
0.39814645051956177,
-0.5205960273742676,
0.6217549443244934,
0.39626529812812805,
-0.964293897151947,
0.37560656666755676,
-0.13649871945381165,
0.33453458547592163,
0.4982956647872925,
0.5467129945755005,
-0.014382357709109783,
-0.3993847370147705,
-0.41984719038009644,
-0.901304304599762,
0.7780022025108337,
0.008345180191099644,
0.057435788214206696,
-0.0993456020951271,
0.29356861114501953,
0.3591189980506897,
0.12392822653055191,
-0.7122101783752441,
0.05991199240088463,
0.0566457137465477,
-0.23041541874408722,
-0.11225177347660065,
-0.6578802466392517,
0.16539780795574188,
-0.2947573661804199,
0.5244030952453613,
-0.009880351833999157,
0.5440573692321777,
-0.2753184139728546,
-0.21133673191070557,
-0.07657835632562637,
0.12902548909187317,
0.43306243419647217,
0.7484880685806274,
-0.5082845687866211,
0.1362491101026535,
-0.0465659461915493,
-0.5135268568992615,
0.23968638479709625,
-0.10203836858272552,
0.10240841656923294,
-0.0514463447034359,
0.12594982981681824,
0.5994082093238831,
0.5657262206077576,
-0.6291687488555908,
0.37695321440696716,
-0.22748076915740967,
-0.29480090737342834,
-0.38231346011161804,
0.07999663800001144,
0.35966500639915466,
0.3743838667869568,
0.1780853122472763,
0.04148053750395775,
0.2612098753452301,
-0.6572166085243225,
0.220123291015625,
-0.021615859121084213,
0.346382737159729,
-0.29396259784698486,
0.7687529921531677,
0.288512647151947,
0.11777643859386444,
0.8007693290710449,
-0.3156287372112274,
-0.5646519660949707,
0.44302988052368164,
0.6810401082038879,
0.8517931699752808,
-0.30372628569602966,
-0.24899806082248688,
0.5491845607757568,
0.35407349467277527,
-0.24895185232162476,
0.5055233836174011,
0.03613613545894623,
-0.6273590326309204,
-0.870040237903595,
-0.8456975817680359,
-0.6514679789543152,
-0.034295789897441864,
-0.3821655213832855,
0.44632142782211304,
-0.7156637907028198,
-0.004659591242671013,
-0.36066076159477234,
-0.001979779452085495,
-0.38704514503479004,
-0.12190977483987808,
0.2777491807937622,
0.9963433742523193,
-0.4544343650341034,
0.9842675924301147,
0.28964099287986755,
-0.42918744683265686,
-0.8876791000366211,
-0.0486530102789402,
-0.056052010506391525,
-0.7041504979133606,
0.8762853741645813,
0.51448655128479,
-0.16500073671340942,
0.5332092046737671,
-0.8836135864257812,
-0.7572230696678162,
1.0215215682983398,
0.8790627717971802,
-0.6387340426445007,
-0.2234581708908081,
-0.021573685109615326,
0.11558757722377777,
-0.0500028096139431,
0.23972450196743011,
0.708810567855835,
0.37272876501083374,
0.4066397547721863,
-0.8998868465423584,
0.11544379591941833,
-0.34244272112846375,
0.09242432564496994,
0.5125414133071899,
-0.40004611015319824,
0.7933672666549683,
-0.2877223789691925,
-0.08979201316833496,
0.2356041669845581,
0.48727065324783325,
0.26312020421028137,
-0.10398370772600174,
-0.0005785214598290622,
0.8431119918823242,
0.5937443375587463,
0.015261414460837841,
1.04912269115448,
-0.5597608685493469,
0.27115970849990845,
0.835967481136322,
-0.2503945529460907,
1.086386799812317,
-0.008921454660594463,
-0.10521792620420456,
0.56504225730896,
0.582834780216217,
0.061841145157814026,
0.45942988991737366,
0.324569433927536,
-0.4092952013015747,
-0.1272566020488739,
0.3538818359375,
-0.48085302114486694,
0.47430646419525146,
0.40559297800064087,
-0.23037590086460114,
-0.4840176999568939,
-0.20834042131900787,
0.14890030026435852,
-0.2563512325286865,
-0.37891629338264465,
0.3879486620426178,
0.10615097731351852,
-0.13236767053604126,
1.0622671842575073,
0.29320958256721497,
0.9150767922401428,
-0.6920661330223083,
-0.046476759016513824,
-0.2926957607269287,
0.4154868423938751,
-0.4785424768924713,
-0.5841383337974548,
0.39435097575187683,
0.2634558379650116,
-0.07568415254354477,
-0.20428670942783356,
0.791903555393219,
-0.2267448753118515,
-0.1347261667251587,
0.461332768201828,
0.04474768415093422,
0.6295368075370789,
-0.2537791430950165,
-0.4643595516681671,
0.8055265545845032,
0.3540632128715515,
-0.03409815952181816,
0.30203351378440857,
0.41003915667533875,
0.3825056850910187,
0.590038537979126,
0.9002096056938171,
0.021626625210046768,
0.1424708217382431,
0.0016613281331956387,
1.074471116065979,
-0.8958846926689148,
-0.2923803925514221,
-0.842322826385498,
0.37263554334640503,
0.2873042821884155,
0.22822830080986023,
0.7669121026992798,
0.9628857374191284,
0.8067925572395325,
-0.32962125539779663,
0.6496649384498596,
-0.02741132862865925,
0.38834312558174133,
-0.7016736268997192,
0.48752322793006897,
-0.3783404231071472,
0.44136524200439453,
-0.07619300484657288,
-1.1141177415847778,
-0.2548926770687103,
0.35297489166259766,
-0.20158889889717102,
0.04025111347436905,
0.6886508464813232,
0.8804353475570679,
-0.050387486815452576,
-0.253562867641449,
0.4439297020435333,
0.23400984704494476,
0.5267449021339417,
0.8260429501533508,
0.887387752532959,
-0.1397414654493332,
0.653526782989502,
-0.2089667022228241,
-0.348722904920578,
-0.37748828530311584,
-1.0190110206604004,
-0.7743467092514038,
-0.10753172636032104,
-0.2450168877840042,
-0.1934453397989273,
-0.08913374692201614,
0.9041049480438232,
0.3399975001811981,
-0.5154943466186523,
-0.2941366136074066,
-0.14342519640922546,
-0.2751808166503906,
0.40059709548950195,
-0.13925977051258087,
-0.06538784503936768,
-0.41545718908309937,
-0.7752503752708435,
0.4012010991573334,
0.28037193417549133,
-0.0091096768155694,
-0.3687531650066376,
-0.3580474257469177,
0.10851934552192688,
-0.1030936986207962,
0.6823961138725281,
0.3269323408603668,
-0.37366360425949097,
-0.0632946565747261,
-0.23567509651184082,
-0.10063529014587402,
0.2736561596393585,
0.6459493637084961,
-0.5713337659835815,
0.1373903751373291,
0.5922645330429077,
0.81533282995224,
0.8141281008720398,
0.08064261823892593,
0.5390175580978394,
-0.5368382334709167,
0.09040194004774094,
0.23746828734874725,
0.33344995975494385,
0.29135093092918396,
-0.26561346650123596,
0.765949547290802,
0.12902489304542542,
-0.840341329574585,
-0.7317605018615723,
0.23454850912094116,
-0.9209615588188171,
-0.4709303379058838,
1.2099486589431763,
0.003988497890532017,
-0.5024586319923401,
0.08274973183870316,
-0.3539852797985077,
0.23650796711444855,
-0.36717331409454346,
0.30428650975227356,
0.4287002980709076,
-0.09417903423309326,
-0.3536486327648163,
-0.7064579129219055,
0.1415158361196518,
0.0015733088366687298,
-0.8365389108657837,
0.18591362237930298,
1.0095722675323486,
0.5777114629745483,
0.05221027508378029,
0.7042982578277588,
-0.4471100866794586,
0.32692256569862366,
0.2570160925388336,
0.6816016435623169,
-0.32378706336021423,
-0.3135907053947449,
-0.45078352093696594,
-0.07286081463098526,
0.41134417057037354,
-0.08344587683677673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09702v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09702v1
|
Generator-Guided Crowd Reaction Assessment
| 2024-03-08T13:05:44 | 2024-03-08T13:05:44 |
Sohom Ghosh, Chung-Chi Chen, Sudip Kumar Naskar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
In the realm of social media, understanding and predicting post reach is a
significant challenge. This paper presents a Crowd Reaction AssessMent (CReAM)
task designed to estimate if a given social media post will receive more
reaction than another, a particularly essential task for digital marketers and
content writers. We introduce the Crowd Reaction Estimation Dataset (CRED),
consisting of pairs of tweets from The White House with comparative measures of
retweet count. The proposed Generator-Guided Estimation Approach (GGEA)
leverages generative Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, FLAN-UL2,
and Claude, to guide classification models for making better predictions. Our
results reveal that a fine-tuned FLANG-RoBERTa model, utilizing a cross-encoder
architecture with tweet content and responses generated by Claude, performs
optimally. We further use a T5-based paraphraser to generate paraphrases of a
given post and demonstrate GGEA's ability to predict which post will elicit the
most reactions. We believe this novel application of LLMs provides a
significant advancement in predicting social media post reach.
|
[
-0.6070811152458191,
-0.9664381146430969,
0.581657886505127,
0.33832934498786926,
-0.31667739152908325,
0.36484482884407043,
-0.1601875275373459,
-0.27741169929504395,
0.37626224756240845,
0.18070293962955475,
-0.6169366240501404,
-0.38103044033050537,
-1.0507222414016724,
0.05376298353075981,
-0.8097166419029236,
0.5558269023895264,
-0.10818396508693695,
-0.3218740224838257,
0.11732186377048492,
0.06630897521972656,
-0.1183604821562767,
-0.2408151775598526,
-0.3598930835723877,
0.06086944043636322,
0.8172599673271179,
0.2834665775299072,
0.5053635239601135,
0.06989442557096481,
0.5208660364151001,
0.31044262647628784,
-0.015356125310063362,
0.2949216067790985,
-0.7033499479293823,
-0.23725976049900055,
-0.1259651631116867,
0.05697625130414963,
-0.09134926646947861,
0.0918007344007492,
0.36081376671791077,
0.34970709681510925,
-0.07263010740280151,
0.29223528504371643,
-0.0898519828915596,
0.5687069892883301,
-0.5812864899635315,
-0.13080982863903046,
-0.8340426683425903,
0.05816981941461563,
0.04451630637049675,
-0.07349531352519989,
-0.21961043775081635,
-0.5295529961585999,
0.1768428236246109,
-0.4257506728172302,
0.35888373851776123,
-0.027592265978455544,
0.5312939882278442,
-0.2519696056842804,
-0.5093142986297607,
-0.15632416307926178,
-0.5977545976638794,
0.6704221963882446,
-0.2169008105993271,
0.5809104442596436,
0.09643661230802536,
0.39209169149398804,
-0.21416476368904114,
-0.6637130379676819,
-0.8126934766769409,
-0.005207255017012358,
0.24026332795619965,
0.12783890962600708,
-0.40519219636917114,
-0.1855698972940445,
0.24675163626670837,
0.2096552699804306,
-0.47668367624282837,
-0.5267906188964844,
-0.4212692677974701,
-0.005687053315341473,
0.750122606754303,
0.09521820396184921,
0.17076808214187622,
-0.33772990107536316,
-0.6463026404380798,
0.024905038997530937,
-0.3127587139606476,
-0.14397473633289337,
0.3271234333515167,
0.20981718599796295,
-0.17767272889614105,
0.6872016787528992,
-0.38136762380599976,
0.8120362162590027,
0.2743052542209625,
0.3386751413345337,
-0.022437963634729385,
-0.24743425846099854,
-0.2143784761428833,
-0.2622550427913666,
1.0604982376098633,
0.7335396409034729,
0.6140929460525513,
-0.1323423981666565,
-0.1009138971567154,
0.32872793078422546,
0.30675429105758667,
-0.9050347208976746,
-0.017737187445163727,
0.1357245147228241,
-0.25990405678749084,
-0.3061574697494507,
0.5785886645317078,
-1.2301632165908813,
-0.7009609937667847,
-0.16701121628284454,
0.08631004393100739,
-0.17953741550445557,
-0.6179604530334473,
-0.04745486378669739,
-0.20779454708099365,
0.12991195917129517,
0.32661452889442444,
-0.5503466725349426,
0.3027753531932831,
0.9285945296287537,
1.0781419277191162,
-0.1896749883890152,
-0.04124300926923752,
-0.7909975647926331,
0.04994086176156998,
-0.6646418571472168,
1.0254971981048584,
-0.49544909596443176,
-0.3542058765888214,
0.350825697183609,
0.03545672073960304,
-0.05590690299868584,
-0.3524658679962158,
0.2941279113292694,
-0.9650362133979797,
0.05066082626581192,
-0.4211026132106781,
-0.6820493936538696,
-0.1680661141872406,
0.2545410990715027,
-0.6508334875106812,
0.4623478949069977,
0.4310924708843231,
-0.7575450539588928,
0.27991050481796265,
-0.20503538846969604,
-0.508753776550293,
0.02303696796298027,
0.13522443175315857,
-0.05454394966363907,
0.49925363063812256,
0.239170104265213,
0.34971150755882263,
-0.18077969551086426,
0.05738299712538719,
-0.701285719871521,
-0.06457903981208801,
0.42944467067718506,
-0.03963688760995865,
0.5345491170883179,
0.31244897842407227,
-0.06405866891145706,
0.38232943415641785,
-0.505556046962738,
0.04630619287490845,
0.04939759150147438,
-0.3418392837047577,
0.09661079943180084,
-0.012334014289081097,
0.24094972014427185,
0.34546178579330444,
-0.12266838550567627,
-0.6046096086502075,
-0.15422417223453522,
-0.09810120612382889,
0.3476788401603699,
0.7777261137962341,
0.4913124442100525,
0.3046729564666748,
-0.13835962116718292,
0.6627574563026428,
-0.281266987323761,
-0.007613987661898136,
0.24808281660079956,
-0.5372205376625061,
-0.2755829989910126,
0.408913791179657,
0.00535651296377182,
0.29970815777778625,
-0.6326417922973633,
0.27754732966423035,
-0.4022429585456848,
-0.7697160840034485,
-0.315238356590271,
0.28489893674850464,
0.10164263099431992,
0.336475670337677,
0.20450091361999512,
-0.041752640157938004,
-0.6047928333282471,
-0.291549414396286,
-0.7229996919631958,
-0.2971365451812744,
-0.28832733631134033,
0.025863638147711754,
0.02973053604364395,
-0.08859815448522568,
0.7358123660087585,
-0.6201586127281189,
-0.31077590584754944,
-0.5169682502746582,
0.15769125521183014,
-0.0422293022274971,
-0.23543715476989746,
0.2392197549343109,
-0.8509254455566406,
-0.7517328858375549,
0.15885122120380402,
-0.6001745462417603,
-0.2338254153728485,
0.257062703371048,
-0.26590248942375183,
-0.035172346979379654,
0.3960668444633484,
-0.8136897087097168,
0.3960602879524231,
0.8815821409225464,
-0.10194577276706696,
0.33668801188468933,
0.5819565653800964,
0.6160858869552612,
-1.167189121246338,
-0.30988189578056335,
0.5291472673416138,
-0.2650867700576782,
-0.717035710811615,
-0.14770612120628357,
0.06322029232978821,
-0.20211848616600037,
-0.5761433839797974,
0.5757375955581665,
-0.42619723081588745,
-0.2882857918739319,
-0.4286010265350342,
0.33758193254470825,
-0.20305036008358002,
0.2574823498725891,
0.17120875418186188,
0.5328662395477295,
0.35760459303855896,
-0.48723289370536804,
0.5596588850021362,
0.2241058349609375,
-0.7793311476707458,
0.4055137038230896,
-0.881745457649231,
0.450609028339386,
0.021811578422784805,
0.32091590762138367,
-1.4357025623321533,
-0.7720120549201965,
0.14089049398899078,
-0.8791965842247009,
-0.15771719813346863,
0.019181573763489723,
-0.32409539818763733,
-0.7059705853462219,
-0.25314438343048096,
0.18029536306858063,
0.5430120229721069,
-0.35217881202697754,
0.7657803893089294,
0.387856662273407,
0.11773721873760223,
0.005719004198908806,
-0.2127038985490799,
0.1969398409128189,
-0.2604009509086609,
-0.8206830620765686,
-0.02147841453552246,
0.13154107332229614,
-0.48378947377204895,
-0.2458915263414383,
0.00009021724690683186,
0.09945405274629593,
-0.19100293517112732,
0.2721414864063263,
-0.29907673597335815,
0.12805785238742828,
0.0077598681673407555,
-0.46184805035591125,
0.09239917248487473,
0.29881203174591064,
0.16275779902935028,
0.8625560998916626,
0.05585440248250961,
-0.2992950677871704,
-0.4811011552810669,
0.05132593587040901,
0.3821187913417816,
-0.11237408220767975,
0.416771799325943,
0.687205970287323,
-0.4490387439727783,
-0.06408936530351639,
-0.5174180269241333,
-0.16316711902618408,
-0.4673398435115814,
0.5453636050224304,
-0.12266669422388077,
-0.4344562590122223,
0.6200096607208252,
0.061950262635946274,
-0.07017876952886581,
0.4526902735233307,
0.513087809085846,
-0.042231399565935135,
1.1297787427902222,
0.2581997513771057,
-0.16459721326828003,
0.7159930467605591,
-0.13645170629024506,
-0.13282056152820587,
-0.5393029451370239,
-0.026850992813706398,
-0.3331829011440277,
-0.3803398311138153,
-0.41971877217292786,
-0.4934692680835724,
0.19728434085845947,
-0.07799053937196732,
0.01794554479420185,
0.49267473816871643,
-0.1878080815076828,
0.19035004079341888,
0.34784772992134094,
0.13538619875907898,
0.024665100499987602,
0.4808167517185211,
0.7161115407943726,
0.12473443895578384,
-0.296137273311615,
-0.22493964433670044,
0.7494644522666931,
0.1737353354692459,
0.830767810344696,
0.206659734249115,
0.44754236936569214,
0.5120700597763062,
0.9864378571510315,
-0.7369630932807922,
0.5871843695640564,
0.0983692854642868,
-0.5122063159942627,
-0.22433516383171082,
-0.49546635150909424,
-0.867100179195404,
0.15299992263317108,
0.01717320643365383,
-0.5359604358673096,
-0.3190905749797821,
-0.05786524713039398,
-0.26702970266342163,
0.26204171776771545,
-0.7316377758979797,
0.6378991603851318,
0.08283578604459763,
-0.25791752338409424,
-0.13728320598602295,
-0.48019611835479736,
0.48287054896354675,
-0.055721111595630646,
0.1784888505935669,
-0.22426119446754456,
-0.08759389817714691,
0.8846231698989868,
-0.49601873755455017,
0.5978093147277832,
-0.32467198371887207,
-0.06896429508924484,
0.8592817187309265,
0.014036979526281357,
0.5492138266563416,
-0.14617563784122467,
-0.14990736544132233,
-0.07071976363658905,
-0.44683319330215454,
-0.4597984254360199,
-0.5528950691223145,
0.789881706237793,
-0.6695570945739746,
-0.6837658882141113,
-0.010097098536789417,
-0.2802998423576355,
-0.4079440236091614,
-0.014750130474567413,
0.3826993405818939,
0.13686683773994446,
-0.5673622488975525,
0.1578853726387024,
0.18866483867168427,
0.08357428014278412,
0.3984942138195038,
0.4014126658439636,
-0.3449263870716095,
-0.8192200064659119,
0.5627351403236389,
0.18039530515670776,
0.5356402397155762,
0.2359592467546463,
0.3609030544757843,
-0.6040941476821899,
-0.4669766426086426,
-0.5976545214653015,
-0.0325106717646122,
-0.35826122760772705,
-0.20749925076961517,
-0.8339311480522156,
0.020500048995018005,
-0.7610399723052979,
-0.11447198688983917,
0.14407607913017273,
0.09840013086795807,
-0.2983122169971466,
-0.5965864658355713,
0.43430307507514954,
0.879206657409668,
0.030463654547929764,
0.7711537480354309,
-0.7535871863365173,
0.525275707244873,
0.44187280535697937,
0.23822270333766937,
0.011662088334560394,
-0.6318183541297913,
-0.009486946277320385,
0.1337219625711441,
-0.37392058968544006,
-1.6039013862609863,
0.43891289830207825,
0.03262391686439514,
0.15857993066310883,
0.5627190470695496,
0.1471230834722519,
0.791833758354187,
-0.2460302859544754,
0.6153373718261719,
0.48420777916908264,
-0.6721729636192322,
0.5222495794296265,
-0.7515515685081482,
0.22407181560993195,
0.24736954271793365,
0.3420883119106293,
-0.8326200246810913,
-0.4275302588939667,
-0.5677894949913025,
-0.5008014440536499,
0.3086949586868286,
-0.09645519405603409,
0.7050155401229858,
-0.658784806728363,
-0.14993613958358765,
-0.21100005507469177,
0.23736406862735748,
-0.35385140776634216,
0.3874993324279785,
0.021008336916565895,
-0.11085045337677002,
-0.10739542543888092,
-0.27789929509162903,
-0.0002880526299122721,
0.10252897441387177,
0.5113874673843384,
-0.014352107420563698,
0.06149555370211601,
-0.006655957084149122,
-0.12121976912021637,
-0.9284893870353699,
-0.13708941638469696,
0.3161289691925049,
1.0833890438079834,
-0.30299633741378784,
0.19086617231369019,
0.19119004905223846,
-0.24393905699253082,
0.10185321420431137,
0.22467976808547974,
-0.07273964583873749,
0.21598996222019196,
0.4793408513069153,
0.47170233726501465,
-0.15347139537334442,
-0.5354045033454895,
0.6511340737342834,
0.01933007501065731,
-0.3327518701553345,
-0.2244349867105484,
-0.22607284784317017,
0.33622196316719055,
0.06452805548906326,
0.6962722539901733,
-0.022870516404509544,
-0.09834358841180801,
-0.2922235429286957,
0.5087752938270569,
0.41900014877319336,
-0.9351922869682312,
-0.656608521938324,
0.7877749800682068,
0.36278799176216125,
-0.6552650332450867,
0.364624947309494,
-0.03918955847620964,
-0.5922574996948242,
0.7715921998023987,
0.1873493194580078,
1.1600277423858643,
-0.4971838891506195,
0.3601507842540741,
0.4872409701347351,
0.10492868721485138,
0.09250708669424057,
0.20104897022247314,
0.3610394597053528,
-0.7535057067871094,
-0.25431907176971436,
-0.7355853319168091,
-0.06192931905388832,
0.21986325085163116,
-0.40892618894577026,
0.3711068332195282,
-0.7346329689025879,
-0.4233071506023407,
0.26724880933761597,
0.06272098422050476,
-0.7067961096763611,
0.11814844608306885,
-0.0750512033700943,
0.9142839312553406,
-1.0262800455093384,
0.14942020177841187,
0.52720046043396,
-0.28527548909187317,
-0.8582805395126343,
0.4015747308731079,
0.10362698137760162,
-0.7269496321678162,
0.3253994882106781,
0.3545776307582855,
-0.0003343854914419353,
0.07582534104585648,
-0.6131575107574463,
-0.5870949029922485,
0.6881845593452454,
0.130110502243042,
-0.5595753192901611,
0.5127427577972412,
0.08179233223199844,
0.5680832862854004,
-0.25379347801208496,
0.13625921308994293,
0.20817101001739502,
0.3469325304031372,
0.42608216404914856,
-0.446792870759964,
0.11312131583690643,
0.1517239809036255,
0.059617649763822556,
0.24712277948856354,
-0.6748486757278442,
0.5569514036178589,
-0.4186927080154419,
-0.5562610030174255,
0.03845588490366936,
1.1881524324417114,
0.30049818754196167,
0.5815480947494507,
0.8304495215415955,
0.3759496510028839,
0.19549354910850525,
-0.012345131486654282,
1.2796075344085693,
-0.30529654026031494,
0.3170432448387146,
0.7686268091201782,
-0.3180534541606903,
0.9771096110343933,
0.42618104815483093,
-0.5785536766052246,
0.4415086507797241,
0.8670344948768616,
0.15249931812286377,
0.37861350178718567,
0.5146965980529785,
-0.5467881560325623,
-0.207998126745224,
-0.34701859951019287,
-0.32821154594421387,
0.21352936327457428,
0.21852841973304749,
-0.6099912524223328,
-0.27752044796943665,
-0.1689058244228363,
-0.019805800169706345,
0.2852630913257599,
-0.40628519654273987,
0.964032769203186,
0.026881640776991844,
-1.016292691230774,
0.3173740804195404,
-0.096451036632061,
0.2923183739185333,
-0.3765164315700531,
0.19935718178749084,
-0.3295131027698517,
0.2597804665565491,
-0.23404937982559204,
-0.9442100524902344,
0.36827078461647034,
0.08480936288833618,
-0.012506461702287197,
0.10712137818336487,
0.869795024394989,
-0.5878804326057434,
-0.9539029598236084,
0.5228351354598999,
0.6204085946083069,
-0.010483683086931705,
-0.4701857566833496,
-0.5893773436546326,
0.17400552332401276,
-0.01673814095556736,
-0.8194983601570129,
0.17868758738040924,
0.4530508816242218,
-0.18846428394317627,
0.4669242799282074,
0.765076756477356,
-0.13477769494056702,
0.20965461432933807,
0.23531919717788696,
0.9386405944824219,
-0.3923245668411255,
-0.26909711956977844,
-0.8472059369087219,
0.01326387282460928,
-0.2868610620498657,
-0.04933682084083557,
0.6391183137893677,
0.39751142263412476,
0.46307700872421265,
-0.21344125270843506,
1.1153435707092285,
-0.3610440194606781,
0.6905168294906616,
0.012666294351220131,
0.27125418186187744,
-0.34684109687805176,
-0.2042638212442398,
-0.5001164674758911,
-1.0968834161758423,
0.021034084260463715,
0.32129329442977905,
-0.6286033391952515,
0.35600411891937256,
0.23374490439891815,
0.8496978282928467,
-0.09264670312404633,
-0.002973091322928667,
0.22362126410007477,
0.09134689718484879,
0.4692072570323944,
0.5061140656471252,
1.0571815967559814,
-0.2257799655199051,
0.9072167873382568,
-0.03115370124578476,
-0.20021995902061462,
-0.0367698110640049,
-0.7423100471496582,
-0.7991862893104553,
-0.3066851496696472,
-0.1363692730665207,
-0.783089280128479,
0.016918804496526718,
0.6727647185325623,
0.6528847217559814,
-0.7870036959648132,
-0.1995161473751068,
-0.1585165411233902,
0.1902870386838913,
-0.2742171287536621,
-0.2964157462120056,
0.3162999749183655,
-0.07909376174211502,
-0.9263304471969604,
0.011848256923258305,
-0.11630173772573471,
0.08576460182666779,
-0.21842119097709656,
-0.0542195625603199,
-0.2205059826374054,
0.19668401777744293,
0.6484341621398926,
0.12285413593053818,
-0.5975396633148193,
-0.38741934299468994,
0.24355563521385193,
-0.07927034050226212,
-0.31805458664894104,
0.6036996245384216,
-0.39833348989486694,
0.23427839577198029,
0.9066781997680664,
0.5043800473213196,
0.44533511996269226,
0.9782293438911438,
0.632582426071167,
-0.7121757864952087,
-0.3114480674266815,
-0.03616882115602493,
-0.03866845741868019,
0.6057020425796509,
-0.16812355816364288,
0.6242705583572388,
0.390669584274292,
-0.32389333844184875,
-0.3698490858078003,
0.3449362516403198,
-0.973167359828949,
-0.06230985000729561,
1.736222267150879,
-0.18357756733894348,
-0.3118296265602112,
0.12343857437372208,
-0.1013958752155304,
0.31733933091163635,
-0.528368353843689,
0.9426650404930115,
0.7526471018791199,
0.13071976602077484,
-0.47083136439323425,
-0.4852912724018097,
0.5769283175468445,
-0.010432745330035686,
-0.8014378547668457,
0.3057648837566376,
0.7162361741065979,
0.43737828731536865,
0.19315046072006226,
0.8096424341201782,
0.25939080119132996,
0.15057863295078278,
-0.18700185418128967,
-0.3347964584827423,
0.06526248902082443,
-0.08212095499038696,
0.3104746341705322,
0.4754568934440613,
-0.3102397322654724,
-0.48168259859085083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05268v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05268v2
|
Deep Prompt Multi-task Network for Abuse Language Detection
| 2024-03-08T12:45:53 | 2024-06-24T13:15:33 |
Jian Zhu, Yuping Ruan, Jingfei Chang, Wenhui Sun, Hui Wan, Jian Long, Cheng Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The detection of abusive language remains a long-standing challenge with the
extensive use of social networks. The detection task of abusive language
suffers from limited accuracy. We argue that the existing detection methods
utilize the fine-tuning technique of the pre-trained language models (PLMs) to
handle downstream tasks. Hence, these methods fail to stimulate the general
knowledge of the PLMs. To address the problem, we propose a novel Deep Prompt
Multi-task Network (DPMN) for abuse language detection. Specifically, DPMN
first attempts to design two forms of deep prompt tuning and light prompt
tuning for the PLMs. The effects of different prompt lengths, tuning
strategies, and prompt initialization methods on detecting abusive language are
studied. In addition, we propose a Task Head based on Bi-LSTM and FFN, which
can be used as a short text classifier. Eventually, DPMN utilizes multi-task
learning to improve detection metrics further. The multi-task network has the
function of transferring effective knowledge. The proposed DPMN is evaluated
against eight typical methods on three public datasets: OLID, SOLID, and
AbuseAnalyzer. The experimental results show that our DPMN outperforms the
state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.09357797354459763,
-0.9225599765777588,
0.5585920214653015,
0.37717732787132263,
-0.4219784736633301,
0.10234477370977402,
-0.33048418164253235,
-0.2968401610851288,
-0.21452273428440094,
0.5466540455818176,
-0.6321220397949219,
-0.30434489250183105,
-0.8805981278419495,
0.31606656312942505,
-0.21832334995269775,
0.9830458164215088,
0.10495530813932419,
0.14004002511501312,
0.3642798662185669,
-0.06927142292261124,
-0.8249337673187256,
-0.3312329649925232,
-0.9924585223197937,
-0.2293652892112732,
0.938709020614624,
0.3144869804382324,
0.5803734064102173,
0.4519430696964264,
0.6883808970451355,
0.4321069121360779,
0.018645785748958588,
0.4177596867084503,
-0.42246973514556885,
0.3462907373905182,
-0.1398899108171463,
-0.0925959125161171,
-0.39912012219429016,
-0.22942863404750824,
0.3263300657272339,
0.2748394012451172,
0.08480027318000793,
0.02152090147137642,
0.19497574865818024,
0.5669403672218323,
-0.7140725255012512,
0.26037314534187317,
-0.6566722989082336,
-0.19006416201591492,
-0.6081246137619019,
-0.1741291582584381,
-0.2318902313709259,
0.08926740288734436,
-0.2787534296512604,
-0.2760750353336334,
-0.05729750171303749,
-0.021874302998185158,
0.17872752249240875,
0.18165066838264465,
-0.4116985499858856,
-0.38416001200675964,
-0.36490651965141296,
0.627223014831543,
-0.5841271281242371,
0.15952786803245544,
0.532660722732544,
0.1515425443649292,
-0.2583472430706024,
-0.5424811840057373,
-0.7299022674560547,
-0.5776218175888062,
-0.17102468013763428,
-0.08594382554292679,
-0.2779574990272522,
0.0941721722483635,
0.1503230780363083,
0.21119561791419983,
-0.44968417286872864,
0.5941200852394104,
-0.17555026710033417,
-0.16455873847007751,
0.4337349832057953,
0.48815640807151794,
0.40316617488861084,
-0.28755125403404236,
-0.6184987425804138,
0.07723691314458847,
-0.49268558621406555,
0.2766020894050598,
0.44886815547943115,
0.9734604954719543,
0.14671286940574646,
0.14278468489646912,
-0.009978600777685642,
0.48332303762435913,
-0.0021382663398981094,
-0.14032229781150818,
0.3418138921260834,
-0.3823010325431824,
-0.2190374881029129,
-0.05778668075799942,
1.1066460609436035,
0.5287386178970337,
0.3039425015449524,
0.04970718175172806,
-0.3688527047634125,
0.18104219436645508,
0.3285551965236664,
-0.8165571689605713,
-0.10389886051416397,
-0.11276721954345703,
-0.42021697759628296,
-0.5444924235343933,
-0.3577856719493866,
-0.7671286463737488,
-0.9915910959243774,
-0.398009717464447,
0.33809641003608704,
-0.5836061835289001,
-0.6874688267707825,
0.16004134714603424,
-0.03968050703406334,
-0.13647644221782684,
0.26983699202537537,
-0.5572910904884338,
0.35086625814437866,
0.6784257888793945,
0.817074716091156,
-0.51319420337677,
-0.5103111267089844,
-0.6623860001564026,
-0.2800438404083252,
-0.10201997309923172,
0.3766706585884094,
-0.518568754196167,
0.013848638162016869,
0.19187915325164795,
0.18443018198013306,
0.02941841073334217,
-0.6611222624778748,
0.8058029413223267,
-0.6880708336830139,
-0.04408443719148636,
-0.414898544549942,
-0.03813757747411728,
0.036546941846609116,
0.2831009328365326,
-0.5371376872062683,
0.8951958417892456,
-0.019618529826402664,
-0.6579288244247437,
0.3546210527420044,
-0.6573759317398071,
-0.5691666603088379,
0.16759581863880157,
0.2668347656726837,
-0.5039043426513672,
-0.22084294259548187,
0.34965184330940247,
0.6149396300315857,
-0.03610200062394142,
0.705335259437561,
-0.5011501312255859,
-0.47117871046066284,
0.08536018431186676,
-0.6815438866615295,
1.0935455560684204,
0.37475037574768066,
-0.3964211344718933,
0.2913263738155365,
-0.460974782705307,
-0.3746904730796814,
0.2035655975341797,
-0.23772232234477997,
-0.6069573163986206,
-0.15636815130710602,
0.08309950679540634,
0.356584370136261,
0.059681180864572525,
-0.7441362738609314,
-0.1936967968940735,
-0.28557559847831726,
0.3254043459892273,
0.8867723941802979,
-0.24171391129493713,
0.2581053078174591,
-0.2806469798088074,
0.5447797775268555,
0.22091376781463623,
-0.018788177520036697,
-0.42522308230400085,
-0.09088165313005447,
-0.36639857292175293,
-0.21218693256378174,
-0.25998198986053467,
0.6015148758888245,
-0.7640694975852966,
0.5654301643371582,
-0.156930610537529,
-0.09112398326396942,
-0.4113355576992035,
0.28346747159957886,
0.7309002876281738,
0.6393690705299377,
0.6051150560379028,
-0.011733477003872395,
-0.4001843333244324,
-0.7659907341003418,
-0.5996232032775879,
-0.009073526598513126,
0.1862695813179016,
0.33844906091690063,
0.5325780510902405,
-0.05267176404595375,
0.6074320077896118,
-0.018405133858323097,
-0.6713658571243286,
-0.19696290791034698,
0.13435831665992737,
0.295888751745224,
0.4635511040687561,
0.8797996640205383,
-0.6728699803352356,
-0.6129013895988464,
-0.2508450746536255,
-0.42783603072166443,
-0.42491868138313293,
0.19551096856594086,
0.1958893984556198,
-0.32644322514533997,
0.4716494679450989,
-0.2886798679828644,
-0.026426129043102264,
0.18373264372348785,
-0.42978471517562866,
0.5613324046134949,
0.04710021987557411,
0.2558728754520416,
-1.0713592767715454,
-0.1145639643073082,
0.08208201080560684,
-0.38765406608581543,
-0.8199926018714905,
-0.08793101459741592,
0.09224581718444824,
-0.27894270420074463,
-0.612996518611908,
0.5109296441078186,
-0.45527714490890503,
0.5521942377090454,
-0.6024430394172668,
0.09873556345701218,
-0.189061239361763,
0.7005979418754578,
-0.18213409185409546,
0.7800226807594299,
0.6455240249633789,
-0.5520395040512085,
0.8420619964599609,
0.14792874455451965,
-0.12738776206970215,
0.6531466841697693,
-0.4363551735877991,
0.2912229895591736,
-0.4804907441139221,
0.1762404441833496,
-1.0114734172821045,
0.13735444843769073,
0.7321020364761353,
-0.14890334010124207,
0.26562613248825073,
-0.18433550000190735,
-0.4021390378475189,
-0.5231696963310242,
-0.4142412841320038,
0.507183313369751,
-0.04545081779360771,
-0.6409807801246643,
0.04481054097414017,
0.2650602459907532,
-0.3966614007949829,
-0.86822110414505,
-0.4204882085323334,
0.29479655623435974,
-0.21155902743339539,
-0.42392006516456604,
0.24804995954036713,
-0.01869047060608864,
-0.09853257983922958,
-0.11162596195936203,
0.011551355011761189,
-0.1531541347503662,
0.20657522976398468,
0.2935464084148407,
-0.056268200278282166,
-0.21322503685951233,
0.3219165802001953,
0.221602663397789,
0.032560426741838455,
0.3463996946811676,
0.09789144992828369,
0.5919157266616821,
-0.28876373171806335,
-0.17377008497714996,
-0.6101396083831787,
0.599912166595459,
0.6427618861198425,
-0.45615848898887634,
0.3378101587295532,
0.6059338450431824,
-0.4018900692462921,
-0.3165731132030487,
-0.2685771882534027,
-0.18125441670417786,
-0.5125414729118347,
0.6589695811271667,
-0.2629755139350891,
-1.0598458051681519,
0.28288334608078003,
-0.20015108585357666,
-0.15497450530529022,
0.025203606113791466,
0.5832488536834717,
-0.1158476173877716,
0.9104079604148865,
0.4312288165092468,
-0.4045710265636444,
0.7446721792221069,
0.11009927839040756,
0.05525345727801323,
-0.4071858823299408,
0.027144793421030045,
-0.540033221244812,
-0.48063746094703674,
-0.12082604318857193,
-0.16757483780384064,
0.20504474639892578,
0.15643544495105743,
-0.5040882229804993,
0.4468061029911041,
-0.2987465560436249,
0.48526692390441895,
0.17253945767879486,
0.4540066421031952,
0.20117419958114624,
-0.07769807428121567,
-0.03397722914814949,
-0.0007249493501149118,
-0.2879250943660736,
-0.43393200635910034,
0.6557518243789673,
0.5158903002738953,
0.4667719304561615,
-0.03401954099535942,
0.29575371742248535,
0.5817229747772217,
0.31106773018836975,
-0.7523375749588013,
0.3740193545818329,
-0.3411960005760193,
-0.5788666605949402,
-0.470290869474411,
-0.27949512004852295,
-1.1237417459487915,
0.452201783657074,
0.0697183758020401,
-0.5239007472991943,
0.19269776344299316,
0.13962523639202118,
-0.5953264236450195,
0.37568044662475586,
-0.5725185871124268,
0.9216440916061401,
-0.4981476068496704,
-0.06931746751070023,
-0.25597646832466125,
-0.4977402687072754,
0.32419535517692566,
0.003757287049666047,
0.41134750843048096,
-0.5094333291053772,
0.12181262671947479,
0.6503816843032837,
-0.6204350590705872,
1.2566791772842407,
-0.6425676941871643,
-0.1869421899318695,
0.22553256154060364,
0.01959991827607155,
0.5714801549911499,
0.21784448623657227,
-0.21372775733470917,
-0.13217921555042267,
-0.48795655369758606,
-0.13316817581653595,
-0.33180853724479675,
0.5876960754394531,
-0.3763006329536438,
-0.46430525183677673,
-0.18226662278175354,
-0.5173907279968262,
-0.2978813648223877,
0.5636230707168579,
0.16876092553138733,
0.5737817287445068,
-0.05183299258351326,
0.17631570994853973,
0.27159029245376587,
-0.10762370377779007,
0.6883929371833801,
0.4980020523071289,
-0.13373374938964844,
-0.29479700326919556,
0.7918257117271423,
-0.2881908118724823,
-0.19870179891586304,
0.2449103146791458,
0.4677179157733917,
-0.17027021944522858,
-0.6532683372497559,
-0.5668940544128418,
-0.19609282910823822,
-0.28155970573425293,
-0.6934197545051575,
-0.5640350580215454,
-0.002975484589114785,
-0.40189191699028015,
0.2852243483066559,
-0.31157535314559937,
0.3742152154445648,
-0.1410883069038391,
-0.007572473492473364,
0.41555124521255493,
0.4764827489852905,
0.02219015546143055,
0.664240300655365,
-0.7850488424301147,
0.5681435465812683,
0.4488071799278259,
0.5618203282356262,
-0.04850374534726143,
-0.624006450176239,
0.04411202296614647,
0.3339710533618927,
-0.09243626147508621,
-1.138407826423645,
0.13120263814926147,
0.31485697627067566,
0.41062960028648376,
0.5215927958488464,
0.38920921087265015,
0.4437754154205322,
-0.5391209721565247,
0.43639373779296875,
0.46727126836776733,
-0.5951935052871704,
0.4890103340148926,
-0.5939505696296692,
-0.027044929563999176,
0.7788021564483643,
0.39520710706710815,
-0.627936601638794,
-0.3353416323661804,
0.004198505077511072,
-0.6025825142860413,
0.9774757623672485,
0.08967290818691254,
0.6947793960571289,
-0.14371852576732635,
0.05581558495759964,
0.28979283571243286,
0.47155216336250305,
-0.8013434410095215,
-0.5468361973762512,
-0.24506425857543945,
-0.07752533257007599,
0.13882264494895935,
-0.3712645173072815,
-0.02988557517528534,
-0.38517457246780396,
0.3064262270927429,
-0.13301222026348114,
0.11165022850036621,
-0.23406365513801575,
-0.4228571355342865,
-0.11269485950469971,
0.42545631527900696,
0.49776801466941833,
0.5612508058547974,
0.13887663185596466,
0.11685764789581299,
0.23187227547168732,
-0.6357936263084412,
0.22018864750862122,
0.13032077252864838,
0.10135260969400406,
-0.02463732473552227,
0.43333205580711365,
1.2629446983337402,
0.14735643565654755,
-0.3807610869407654,
1.1353254318237305,
0.03111349418759346,
-0.007186879403889179,
-0.29505524039268494,
-0.01602477766573429,
-0.18006381392478943,
0.31153833866119385,
0.33347055315971375,
0.19963258504867554,
0.16331394016742706,
-0.3085997700691223,
0.2417299598455429,
0.3745289146900177,
-0.5787782073020935,
-0.255624920129776,
0.34074079990386963,
0.42915505170822144,
-0.5604257583618164,
0.4805540144443512,
-0.48102062940597534,
-0.7053266167640686,
0.49857252836227417,
0.7067717909812927,
0.7470128536224365,
-0.33718401193618774,
0.27531835436820984,
0.214930459856987,
0.24539944529533386,
0.2002503126859665,
0.4670650064945221,
-0.13394670188426971,
-0.9288129210472107,
-0.4924359619617462,
-0.6366007924079895,
0.14834657311439514,
0.7534359693527222,
-0.4098220765590668,
0.2361297905445099,
-0.4755421280860901,
-0.12675048410892487,
-0.07207052409648895,
-0.1334603726863861,
-0.6583302617073059,
0.0811794251203537,
0.277497798204422,
0.6446754932403564,
-1.0100456476211548,
0.6766748428344727,
0.5868757963180542,
-0.2574053108692169,
-0.7274285554885864,
-0.22097505629062653,
0.10625996440649033,
-1.0150343179702759,
0.5853208303451538,
0.4357626736164093,
-0.3050764799118042,
-0.010352024808526039,
-0.5214717984199524,
-0.28401094675064087,
0.6413716077804565,
0.5601811408996582,
-0.6773616075515747,
0.11617106199264526,
0.020344354212284088,
0.5580264925956726,
-0.2742346525192261,
-0.022188425064086914,
0.539124071598053,
0.6447043418884277,
-0.4467593729496002,
-0.9348969459533691,
0.19877171516418457,
-0.4135288596153259,
-0.21152687072753906,
0.2897631824016571,
-0.40450870990753174,
0.6751039624214172,
-0.020166810601949692,
-0.3214764893054962,
-0.04087657108902931,
0.3860497772693634,
0.06566059589385986,
0.4195321798324585,
0.9976098537445068,
0.33501294255256653,
0.6478758454322815,
-0.059399764984846115,
0.6666683554649353,
0.029276099056005478,
0.06984756886959076,
1.1450344324111938,
-0.20061329007148743,
0.40861982107162476,
0.2786383330821991,
-0.17261666059494019,
0.43997788429260254,
0.37035858631134033,
-0.19117355346679688,
0.4238782823085785,
0.487123042345047,
-0.24173875153064728,
-0.35686978697776794,
-0.3980441689491272,
-0.32621732354164124,
0.6240418553352356,
0.2400621622800827,
-0.4536605179309845,
-0.5188229084014893,
0.5855358839035034,
0.24254783987998962,
0.40224769711494446,
-0.6276872158050537,
0.6593093276023865,
0.15757562220096588,
-0.33497416973114014,
0.35419347882270813,
0.08983411639928818,
1.0179040431976318,
-0.3400815427303314,
0.10268522799015045,
0.05749163031578064,
0.25733211636543274,
-0.03305135294795036,
-0.8051053881645203,
0.0734313353896141,
0.03195289522409439,
-0.10328307747840881,
-0.7158669829368591,
1.2484338283538818,
-0.5294535756111145,
-0.09473327547311783,
0.6934800148010254,
0.6180857419967651,
-0.06054195389151573,
-0.671866238117218,
-0.8445624709129333,
-0.16007070243358612,
-0.5575708150863647,
-0.21420013904571533,
0.30475562810897827,
0.6323511600494385,
-0.05916396528482437,
0.36363017559051514,
0.8262794613838196,
0.06553081423044205,
0.1656445860862732,
0.42459550499916077,
0.9963904023170471,
-0.38027793169021606,
-0.5798049569129944,
-1.0781173706054688,
0.2809673249721527,
-0.19010581076145172,
-0.5472046136856079,
0.479848712682724,
0.2023906707763672,
0.6744681000709534,
-0.1533326804637909,
0.5483416318893433,
0.020594120025634766,
0.6651584506034851,
-0.23311534523963928,
0.7783002853393555,
-0.33192911744117737,
-0.08557025343179703,
-0.5134609341621399,
-0.6377782225608826,
-0.3460162878036499,
0.2204737663269043,
-0.06377647817134857,
0.1829322725534439,
0.6452094912528992,
0.8138933777809143,
-0.12544195353984833,
0.022912517189979553,
0.2637091875076294,
0.004095370881259441,
0.18511971831321716,
0.34978240728378296,
0.9331507086753845,
-0.2884907126426697,
0.8090130090713501,
-0.3332233428955078,
-0.16856569051742554,
-0.20132309198379517,
-0.9706602692604065,
-0.9384676814079285,
-0.4736557602882385,
-0.07953817397356033,
-0.15087610483169556,
0.2662234604358673,
0.9250093698501587,
0.659450352191925,
-1.0452369451522827,
0.03165376931428909,
-0.03903467580676079,
0.0824965313076973,
-0.5197446346282959,
-0.2142784595489502,
0.2548808455467224,
-0.5801581144332886,
-0.6329261064529419,
0.8158876895904541,
0.17852242290973663,
-0.4819487929344177,
0.013035359792411327,
-0.18735988438129425,
-0.22255125641822815,
-0.5754607319831848,
0.7390627264976501,
-0.016024570912122726,
-0.5126516222953796,
-0.3588433861732483,
0.1414904147386551,
-0.3809591829776764,
0.004083657171577215,
1.1679325103759766,
-0.608140766620636,
0.2863318920135498,
0.48530811071395874,
0.940474271774292,
-0.1109706461429596,
-0.0875915065407753,
0.43767857551574707,
-1.0962297916412354,
-0.07344669103622437,
0.5251128673553467,
0.4807553291320801,
0.08685911446809769,
-0.5217781066894531,
-0.20425578951835632,
0.27251365780830383,
-0.42615920305252075,
-0.7764834761619568,
0.4779318869113922,
-0.6775500774383545,
-0.4337313771247864,
1.044983983039856,
-0.21075868606567383,
-0.06505510210990906,
-0.627682089805603,
-0.5304255485534668,
0.26842212677001953,
-0.7862953543663025,
0.5972302556037903,
0.4566831588745117,
0.14251765608787537,
-0.2433771789073944,
-0.34251752495765686,
0.658574640750885,
0.4476158618927002,
-0.5012685656547546,
0.5255175828933716,
0.42597874999046326,
0.2813371419906616,
0.15240317583084106,
0.7820209264755249,
-0.04282935708761215,
0.33931347727775574,
-0.40676969289779663,
-0.21214601397514343,
-0.7044450640678406,
-0.4934777617454529,
-0.5642127394676208,
0.28017547726631165,
-0.3655656576156616,
-0.33221471309661865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05266v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05266v1
|
ERBench: An Entity-Relationship based Automatically Verifiable Hallucination Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-08T12:42:36 | 2024-03-08T12:42:36 |
Jio Oh, Soyeon Kim, Junseok Seo, Jindong Wang, Ruochen Xu, Xing Xie, Steven Euijong Whang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved unprecedented performance in
various applications, yet their evaluation remains a critical issue. Existing
hallucination benchmarks are either static or lack adjustable complexity for
thorough analysis. We contend that utilizing existing relational databases is a
promising approach for constructing benchmarks due to their accurate knowledge
description via functional dependencies. We propose ERBench to automatically
convert any relational database into a benchmark based on the
entity-relationship (ER) model. Our key idea is to construct questions using
the database schema, records, and functional dependencies such that they can be
automatically verified. In addition, we use foreign key constraints to join
relations and construct multihop questions, which can be arbitrarily complex
and used to debug the intermediate answers of LLMs. Finally, ERBench supports
continuous evaluation, multimodal questions, and various prompt engineering
techniques. In our experiments, we construct an LLM benchmark using databases
of multiple domains and make an extensive comparison of contemporary LLMs. We
observe that better LLMs like GPT-4 can handle a larger variety of question
types, but are by no means perfect. Also, correct answers do not necessarily
imply correct rationales, which is an important evaluation that ERBench does
better than other benchmarks for various question types. Code is available at
https: //github.com/DILAB-KAIST/ERBench.
|
[
-0.6733811497688293,
-1.2428830862045288,
0.8232131600379944,
0.20133550465106964,
-0.043700095266103745,
-0.19940073788166046,
-0.5289763808250427,
-0.7462510466575623,
0.3146255314350128,
0.5582118630409241,
-0.3485679030418396,
-0.6084703207015991,
-0.15058691799640656,
0.35855647921562195,
-0.7017977237701416,
0.4443363845348358,
-0.24497848749160767,
-0.014387223869562149,
-0.3107662796974182,
-0.2277146875858307,
-0.2997756898403168,
-0.5939784646034241,
-0.4396229386329651,
-0.27229979634284973,
0.374432772397995,
0.17318293452262878,
0.4622408151626587,
0.6215173006057739,
0.529529333114624,
0.37160584330558777,
0.2053895890712738,
0.19145607948303223,
-0.34909939765930176,
0.5712715983390808,
-0.16288602352142334,
-0.3883618414402008,
-0.2832447588443756,
-0.4044167101383209,
0.5423951148986816,
0.7935472726821899,
-0.49819549918174744,
0.30273252725601196,
-0.2536701261997223,
0.5400182008743286,
-0.5707987546920776,
0.20795108377933502,
-0.858634352684021,
0.0849190354347229,
-0.19925202429294586,
0.02163805067539215,
-0.37898221611976624,
-0.6026026606559753,
-0.16668258607387543,
-0.17309944331645966,
0.11235418170690536,
0.4307187497615814,
1.2088396549224854,
0.4832613170146942,
-0.24316295981407166,
-0.019759856164455414,
-0.8244256973266602,
0.4008239805698395,
-0.41396287083625793,
0.8611816763877869,
0.3240238428115845,
0.6049033999443054,
-0.20397040247917175,
-0.8012647032737732,
-0.6805001497268677,
-0.4845420718193054,
-0.026312876492738724,
-0.17070163786411285,
0.12366365641355515,
-0.08849862217903137,
0.5050177574157715,
0.5107078552246094,
-0.6623405814170837,
-0.16328932344913483,
-0.010387993417680264,
-0.08529964089393616,
0.3120400607585907,
0.19638223946094513,
0.2803586423397064,
-0.2914701998233795,
-0.15043173730373383,
-0.09804194420576096,
-0.8041244149208069,
-0.41282933950424194,
0.1243617981672287,
0.04715729132294655,
0.359988808631897,
0.6049428582191467,
-0.2644698917865753,
0.771906316280365,
-0.15060819685459137,
0.31705111265182495,
0.3676389455795288,
-0.0511799156665802,
-0.25774213671684265,
0.11343999952077866,
0.6693958640098572,
0.30344435572624207,
0.37983208894729614,
-0.5045164227485657,
-0.2983566224575043,
0.011932470835745335,
0.36774110794067383,
-0.8968037366867065,
-0.16234128177165985,
0.31117039918899536,
-0.13824017345905304,
0.006062128581106663,
0.06505190581083298,
-0.9348642230033875,
-0.33061492443084717,
-0.34673255681991577,
0.30245712399482727,
-0.45730331540107727,
-0.22934260964393616,
-0.10854021459817886,
0.33432066440582275,
0.4228246510028839,
0.25175243616104126,
-0.7807485461235046,
0.7170267701148987,
0.7741831541061401,
0.7677834630012512,
-0.2354266345500946,
-0.5274076461791992,
-0.46853378415107727,
0.25417715311050415,
-0.2791668474674225,
0.9450312852859497,
-0.38732439279556274,
-0.08012977987527847,
0.04432845860719681,
0.14323170483112335,
-0.0008268414530903101,
-0.8481329679489136,
0.4353097677230835,
-0.6181474328041077,
-0.11353891342878342,
-0.3535090386867523,
-0.6487278938293457,
-0.17330977320671082,
0.5900155901908875,
-0.913002610206604,
1.2431570291519165,
0.17922252416610718,
-0.4659491181373596,
0.3468742072582245,
-0.3067649304866791,
-0.4937129318714142,
-0.007508715149015188,
-0.6595994830131531,
-0.44353416562080383,
0.05389411002397537,
0.20250439643859863,
0.2896781265735626,
-0.772843062877655,
0.34627631306648254,
-0.6003597378730774,
-0.4223269820213318,
0.34933173656463623,
-0.009311722591519356,
0.5470100045204163,
-0.00032618717523291707,
-0.6345911026000977,
-0.06743789464235306,
-0.998871922492981,
0.2978864312171936,
0.24509155750274658,
-0.1461121141910553,
-0.1768111288547516,
-0.03582398220896721,
-0.08168229460716248,
0.007246527820825577,
0.02060525119304657,
-0.2317802459001541,
-0.09497840702533722,
-0.3406737446784973,
0.029577674344182014,
0.7161681652069092,
0.09269358217716217,
-0.01001210417598486,
-0.13714013993740082,
0.38236764073371887,
-0.26669126749038696,
-0.20669658482074738,
0.20976540446281433,
-0.1234988421201706,
-1.0733389854431152,
-0.06611522287130356,
0.39159873127937317,
0.4707871079444885,
-0.4010854959487915,
0.7065907716751099,
-0.399126797914505,
-0.35699233412742615,
-0.21250905096530914,
0.16252268850803375,
0.15782290697097778,
0.490582138299942,
0.5135347843170166,
-0.4123605489730835,
-0.5354380011558533,
-0.8973231911659241,
-0.28810590505599976,
-0.42875760793685913,
-0.16473089158535004,
0.4821561574935913,
0.6201008558273315,
0.0924454927444458,
0.5127090811729431,
-0.42655473947525024,
-0.3948090970516205,
-0.04970051348209381,
0.055859506130218506,
0.15372002124786377,
0.21698540449142456,
0.32222259044647217,
-0.4508614242076874,
-0.5530421137809753,
0.0036299563944339752,
-1.032551884651184,
-0.10336916148662567,
0.02047954499721527,
-0.12528355419635773,
0.2668554484844208,
0.7218770980834961,
-0.7674936056137085,
0.1623516082763672,
0.21772463619709015,
-0.13508781790733337,
0.5725802779197693,
-0.04026041924953461,
0.43508079648017883,
-0.7185012698173523,
0.21910785138607025,
-0.33760061860084534,
-0.280468225479126,
-0.26977697014808655,
0.29863521456718445,
0.11649734526872635,
-0.0032317356672137976,
-0.041131746023893356,
0.2832041382789612,
-0.5478118062019348,
-0.4124051630496979,
0.16913540661334991,
0.24182936549186707,
-0.2618383467197418,
0.3746100068092346,
0.09098770469427109,
0.5596848130226135,
0.4852844774723053,
-0.5274738669395447,
0.7241372466087341,
0.17642492055892944,
-0.6499642729759216,
0.8228846788406372,
-0.7338375449180603,
0.345990389585495,
0.13667553663253784,
0.0949903056025505,
-0.7931075096130371,
-0.4571511745452881,
0.21497361361980438,
-0.23730361461639404,
0.19683723151683807,
-0.13315920531749725,
-0.8530076742172241,
-0.2884834408760071,
-0.10180843621492386,
-0.04151686653494835,
0.4064345955848694,
-0.6910578608512878,
0.9715210199356079,
0.26628240942955017,
-0.21149250864982605,
-0.5374994277954102,
-0.6545805335044861,
0.15803733468055725,
-0.21297615766525269,
-0.7412154078483582,
0.3804117739200592,
0.008843238465487957,
-0.3019266724586487,
0.20454251766204834,
-0.2764330804347992,
-0.2096426784992218,
0.023041406646370888,
0.3567274510860443,
0.3526470959186554,
-0.3252878487110138,
0.475241094827652,
-0.09919143468141556,
0.03158760815858841,
0.3599029779434204,
0.03906860575079918,
0.6832333207130432,
-0.43602675199508667,
-0.70637446641922,
0.03804151341319084,
0.16846676170825958,
0.5082864165306091,
-0.31785309314727783,
0.7181844711303711,
0.40005606412887573,
-0.5803447961807251,
-0.5686456561088562,
-1.026226282119751,
-0.4184630811214447,
-0.40509527921676636,
0.5684577822685242,
-0.851542055606842,
-0.7727829813957214,
0.6747046113014221,
-0.2062564492225647,
-0.0515398234128952,
0.10980420559644699,
0.5977253317832947,
0.38882380723953247,
0.6910060048103333,
0.3037998378276825,
0.02709730714559555,
0.18919147551059723,
0.22677981853485107,
0.17903567850589752,
-0.46001961827278137,
-0.11985262483358383,
-0.7630976438522339,
-0.06006348505616188,
-0.2676734924316406,
-0.3649463653564453,
0.1929563283920288,
0.10280044376850128,
-0.4207472801208496,
0.42072340846061707,
-0.45808419585227966,
0.6411482691764832,
0.08195378631353378,
0.03577098622918129,
0.5077369809150696,
0.11776460707187653,
-0.1827138215303421,
-0.008183030411601067,
-0.15662215650081635,
-0.5264027118682861,
1.08926260471344,
0.2317449152469635,
0.7820792198181152,
0.30046823620796204,
0.9163329005241394,
-0.014931702986359596,
0.4759629964828491,
-0.5165925025939941,
0.820304811000824,
0.34680214524269104,
-0.9875756502151489,
-0.5423488020896912,
-0.5834535360336304,
-0.6407919526100159,
0.5340743660926819,
0.023664357140660286,
-0.9636484980583191,
0.015446517616510391,
0.031139006838202477,
-0.18984615802764893,
0.10366213321685791,
-0.47292405366897583,
0.9424302577972412,
-0.38387998938560486,
-0.6894826889038086,
-0.2459828108549118,
-0.4063948094844818,
0.3839243948459625,
-0.19749031960964203,
0.004115295130759478,
-0.2295728325843811,
-0.02473694644868374,
0.5692269206047058,
-0.487110435962677,
0.37374991178512573,
-0.013662831857800484,
-0.058498773723840714,
0.051756180822849274,
0.3522500991821289,
0.6612894535064697,
0.2983919382095337,
-0.27317124605178833,
-0.03185315802693367,
-0.008813178166747093,
0.03624080866575241,
-0.6833823919296265,
1.024279236793518,
-0.5773394703865051,
-0.6351011395454407,
-0.3570922315120697,
-0.1531779021024704,
-0.5244138836860657,
0.31718727946281433,
-0.16723887622356415,
0.07523559778928757,
-0.4941190481185913,
0.09908099472522736,
0.6754484176635742,
-0.14595423638820648,
-0.023606233298778534,
0.6466801762580872,
-0.6531813740730286,
-0.3225002884864807,
0.6831265091896057,
0.026615332812070847,
0.07864938676357269,
0.22385619580745697,
-0.30528268218040466,
-0.40516021847724915,
-0.47413522005081177,
-0.4708195626735687,
0.3688177764415741,
-1.0817288160324097,
-0.14332154393196106,
-0.7904466986656189,
-0.1438596248626709,
-0.2614096999168396,
0.1684342920780182,
-0.605238139629364,
-0.29324907064437866,
0.25294944643974304,
-0.2849511206150055,
0.2559690475463867,
0.5190916061401367,
0.030845612287521362,
-0.3801529109477997,
-0.4509587287902832,
0.4984469413757324,
0.5242348313331604,
0.6391128897666931,
0.005930670537054539,
-0.3426263630390167,
0.08060035109519958,
-0.5074911117553711,
-0.1256197690963745,
-0.9697898626327515,
0.08864999562501907,
0.15050102770328522,
0.6563052535057068,
0.15115103125572205,
0.09946458041667938,
0.7603060007095337,
-0.6804195046424866,
0.4168836772441864,
-0.040626924484968185,
-1.0132479667663574,
0.2927246689796448,
0.14359015226364136,
-0.2520092725753784,
1.0337374210357666,
0.31919556856155396,
-0.35339275002479553,
-0.37423932552337646,
-0.4119698405265808,
-0.9229314923286438,
0.46635565161705017,
0.07768195122480392,
-0.19171330332756042,
-0.08065351098775864,
0.20255213975906372,
-0.023463493213057518,
0.2231166809797287,
-0.8366087675094604,
-0.3814409375190735,
0.07095619291067123,
-0.02335147000849247,
0.20393089950084686,
-0.07579325139522552,
-0.1884499341249466,
-0.20894798636436462,
0.60378497838974,
0.0797758400440216,
0.17880702018737793,
0.19232077896595,
-0.498361736536026,
-0.295570433139801,
0.42628663778305054,
0.1693466454744339,
0.8997410535812378,
-0.5123858451843262,
0.3758525848388672,
0.5387141704559326,
0.006017214152961969,
0.21372464299201965,
0.4644680619239807,
-0.04946168139576912,
0.2633112370967865,
0.09226401895284653,
0.5586529970169067,
0.13554194569587708,
-0.6916194558143616,
0.34693410992622375,
-0.1713254749774933,
-0.15211398899555206,
-0.6401536464691162,
-0.08393079787492752,
0.3916889727115631,
0.13706016540527344,
0.05680561810731888,
-0.46715012192726135,
0.1028929278254509,
-0.5330032110214233,
0.4046338200569153,
0.24530956149101257,
-0.3150479793548584,
-0.05975041538476944,
0.7368658781051636,
0.14888440072536469,
-0.13959434628486633,
0.8624034523963928,
-0.12631212174892426,
-0.45107796788215637,
0.5750770568847656,
0.3588517904281616,
0.7931205034255981,
-0.4173737168312073,
0.06270834803581238,
0.5794424414634705,
0.5430207848548889,
-0.25868725776672363,
0.44971001148223877,
-0.034921709448099136,
-0.594332754611969,
-0.2665335237979889,
-0.6717942953109741,
-0.5190339684486389,
0.1925928294658661,
-0.5434669256210327,
0.4212084412574768,
-0.46232613921165466,
-0.04685777798295021,
0.13855840265750885,
-0.2872953712940216,
-0.6955140233039856,
-0.06420907378196716,
0.02814520336687565,
0.7128441333770752,
-0.5352243185043335,
0.7279728651046753,
0.6449569463729858,
-0.7019779682159424,
-0.8020089864730835,
-0.1037362813949585,
-0.059172373265028,
-0.6848027110099792,
0.7602889537811279,
0.3693534731864929,
-0.13045939803123474,
0.026834797114133835,
-0.256653368473053,
-0.5516699552536011,
0.9866130352020264,
0.5760222673416138,
-0.8460366725921631,
-0.011157314293086529,
0.3207452595233917,
0.4755670726299286,
-0.29355987906455994,
0.3903118073940277,
0.7498801946640015,
0.7187791466712952,
-0.17961953580379486,
-0.8910694718360901,
0.5442855954170227,
-0.12546536326408386,
-0.14120785892009735,
0.3574886918067932,
-0.3726813793182373,
0.682266891002655,
-0.14220377802848816,
-0.31023073196411133,
0.11390797048807144,
0.580096960067749,
0.25801384449005127,
0.05846164748072624,
0.7436510324478149,
0.7073785066604614,
0.785189688205719,
-0.21006427705287933,
0.8321293592453003,
-0.5520615577697754,
0.4310656785964966,
1.4274377822875977,
-0.8196167349815369,
1.019434928894043,
0.7239706516265869,
-0.5060821175575256,
0.6011480689048767,
0.38605013489723206,
-0.3579210042953491,
0.17301717400550842,
0.7374178171157837,
-0.21014957129955292,
-0.45179933309555054,
0.09564258903265,
-0.6816720962524414,
0.09418182820081711,
0.2885277271270752,
-0.4132504165172577,
-0.25840821862220764,
-0.3575056195259094,
-0.1867164522409439,
0.0204414464533329,
0.373945027589798,
0.6588378548622131,
0.15080031752586365,
-0.8103121519088745,
0.8127548694610596,
-0.111101895570755,
0.10219541937112808,
-0.6485607028007507,
-0.0858655571937561,
-0.19702376425266266,
0.3697203993797302,
-0.045951828360557556,
-0.43476030230522156,
0.1297001838684082,
-0.1589968055486679,
0.1257723718881607,
0.19033843278884888,
0.6631969809532166,
-0.4470181167125702,
-0.23412029445171356,
0.4432907998561859,
0.7772002816200256,
0.41972365975379944,
-0.3049981892108917,
-0.7045607566833496,
0.3839978575706482,
-0.17493405938148499,
-0.5218840837478638,
0.1938723474740982,
0.6023487448692322,
0.11965513229370117,
0.6746986508369446,
0.3251398503780365,
0.11869384348392487,
-0.03507300466299057,
0.39190924167633057,
0.8548492789268494,
-0.8602375984191895,
-0.21271049976348877,
-0.8488081097602844,
0.1123690977692604,
-0.39992934465408325,
-0.07632891088724136,
0.6853793263435364,
0.5658831596374512,
0.8376979231834412,
-0.12039419263601303,
0.6309689283370972,
-0.32004472613334656,
0.5784837007522583,
-0.43529585003852844,
0.691886842250824,
-0.4925370216369629,
0.4892883896827698,
-0.300284743309021,
-1.434511423110962,
-0.31548935174942017,
0.8110038638114929,
-0.19682365655899048,
0.21919049322605133,
1.2199548482894897,
1.1269186735153198,
-0.049378227442502975,
0.0431668683886528,
0.3602950870990753,
0.23876670002937317,
0.3257173001766205,
0.5347499251365662,
0.9956582188606262,
-0.2200973778963089,
0.8317295908927917,
-0.3857494294643402,
-0.1848764419555664,
-0.15233300626277924,
-0.7409759163856506,
-1.1874754428863525,
-0.49601778388023376,
-0.4220319390296936,
-0.517518162727356,
0.31070035696029663,
0.8750410676002502,
0.46122878789901733,
-0.9098359942436218,
-0.3851816952228546,
-0.24445003271102905,
0.12384548038244247,
-0.19468413293361664,
-0.23573452234268188,
0.48395439982414246,
-0.40202072262763977,
-0.5254278182983398,
0.1886904388666153,
0.2319539189338684,
-0.10530319064855576,
-0.49431800842285156,
0.06665752083063126,
-0.0863681212067604,
-0.0936119481921196,
0.35693928599357605,
0.23698532581329346,
-0.7513550519943237,
-0.32201242446899414,
0.04048502445220947,
-0.09971403330564499,
0.020196013152599335,
0.7110302448272705,
-0.6311135292053223,
0.2659626603126526,
0.4513222575187683,
0.8582646250724792,
0.6031485199928284,
-0.11069591343402863,
0.5041747689247131,
-0.29003456234931946,
-0.2212396264076233,
0.19189102947711945,
0.5456088185310364,
0.3160824775695801,
-0.06560606509447098,
0.9506346583366394,
0.046622153371572495,
-0.632738471031189,
-1.1434977054595947,
0.2809811234474182,
-0.81788569688797,
-0.1669670194387436,
0.9718806147575378,
-0.19956746697425842,
-0.38757410645484924,
-0.3196331858634949,
-0.00551144452765584,
0.025829635560512543,
-0.30096879601478577,
1.0171537399291992,
0.9574610590934753,
-0.09313812106847763,
-0.29381099343299866,
-0.5969403982162476,
0.2993858754634857,
0.6178386211395264,
-1.1930795907974243,
0.49793022871017456,
0.7707569599151611,
0.3234896659851074,
0.12475979328155518,
0.4648935794830322,
-0.3547486662864685,
0.2525307238101959,
0.09644634276628494,
0.32569238543510437,
-0.09264510869979858,
-0.2743387818336487,
0.0881069228053093,
0.40899333357810974,
0.3401700556278229,
0.2009129524230957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05257v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05257v1
|
Cross-lingual Transfer or Machine Translation? On Data Augmentation for Monolingual Semantic Textual Similarity
| 2024-03-08T12:28:15 | 2024-03-08T12:28:15 |
Sho Hoshino, Akihiko Kato, Soichiro Murakami, Peinan Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Learning better sentence embeddings leads to improved performance for natural
language understanding tasks including semantic textual similarity (STS) and
natural language inference (NLI). As prior studies leverage large-scale labeled
NLI datasets for fine-tuning masked language models to yield sentence
embeddings, task performance for languages other than English is often left
behind. In this study, we directly compared two data augmentation techniques as
potential solutions for monolingual STS: (a) cross-lingual transfer that
exploits English resources alone as training data to yield non-English sentence
embeddings as zero-shot inference, and (b) machine translation that coverts
English data into pseudo non-English training data in advance. In our
experiments on monolingual STS in Japanese and Korean, we find that the two
data techniques yield performance on par. Rather, we find a superiority of the
Wikipedia domain over the NLI domain for these languages, in contrast to prior
studies that focused on NLI as training data. Combining our findings, we
demonstrate that the cross-lingual transfer of Wikipedia data exhibits improved
performance, and that native Wikipedia data can further improve performance for
monolingual STS.
|
[
-0.439585417509079,
-0.8047943711280823,
0.2924511730670929,
0.16508248448371887,
-0.36128970980644226,
0.06435965746641159,
-0.38695549964904785,
-0.9202346205711365,
0.4174155294895172,
0.458462119102478,
-0.5777725577354431,
-0.44995003938674927,
-0.34248360991477966,
0.33495795726776123,
-0.3876233994960785,
0.8784186840057373,
-0.19240760803222656,
0.15212973952293396,
-0.5960454344749451,
-0.14772309362888336,
-0.4055779278278351,
-0.4180769622325897,
-0.5484983325004578,
-0.37385979294776917,
0.4732471704483032,
0.4167766571044922,
0.9436327815055847,
0.7233919501304626,
0.3351008892059326,
0.26770469546318054,
0.38869819045066833,
0.18469616770744324,
-0.4848257601261139,
-0.14582425355911255,
-0.33988556265830994,
-0.45192113518714905,
-0.03745131194591522,
-0.04723304510116577,
0.5397258400917053,
1.1270794868469238,
0.554495632648468,
0.11796283721923828,
-0.005488468334078789,
0.6603865027427673,
-0.5966670513153076,
-0.015495196916162968,
-0.28272849321365356,
0.43465158343315125,
-0.13029132783412933,
-0.21396346390247345,
-0.36891084909439087,
-0.19335076212882996,
0.3313705623149872,
-0.9897399544715881,
0.26362237334251404,
0.15584039688110352,
0.8108423352241516,
0.23474688827991486,
-0.6099011898040771,
-0.34163936972618103,
-0.6291772723197937,
0.8354820609092712,
-0.4945067763328552,
0.6300633549690247,
0.1922851800918579,
-0.09928584843873978,
0.28625771403312683,
-0.4280622899532318,
-0.6531597375869751,
-0.40674978494644165,
-0.43859341740608215,
0.18977603316307068,
-0.2630685865879059,
-0.2467263787984848,
0.2560488283634186,
0.2753538489341736,
-0.9026183485984802,
0.3106888234615326,
-0.4804903268814087,
-0.13932429254055023,
0.6569017171859741,
-0.09119200706481934,
0.5558947324752808,
-0.5574590563774109,
-0.634991466999054,
-0.2935839593410492,
-0.6675432324409485,
-0.10611425340175629,
0.345645546913147,
0.3888586461544037,
-0.1677270531654358,
0.7133928537368774,
-0.37811869382858276,
0.6112358570098877,
-0.16806431114673615,
0.04047249257564545,
0.5194608569145203,
-0.7945985198020935,
0.009902089834213257,
0.48586949706077576,
0.7120243906974792,
0.5260058045387268,
0.7416941523551941,
-0.6185523867607117,
0.24474835395812988,
0.06559325009584427,
0.08544006198644638,
-0.5599128603935242,
-0.08390425145626068,
-0.16217391192913055,
-0.5026842951774597,
0.01749391108751297,
0.2796623110771179,
-0.5854524970054626,
-0.05711489915847778,
-0.511401891708374,
0.5030648112297058,
-0.5649934411048889,
-0.20976263284683228,
0.021876482293009758,
-0.3162643015384674,
0.20764802396297455,
0.07685364782810211,
-0.7153922915458679,
0.26333799958229065,
0.7150359749794006,
0.8204802870750427,
-0.4163884222507477,
-0.6663963198661804,
-0.38555365800857544,
0.2320217490196228,
-0.6583559513092041,
0.5780047178268433,
-0.4180285632610321,
-0.3046560287475586,
-0.11337096244096756,
0.0738680511713028,
-0.25641700625419617,
-0.4952218532562256,
0.5099548101425171,
-0.26368123292922974,
0.5475150346755981,
-0.3047165870666504,
-0.5699313282966614,
-0.1840355396270752,
-0.023562699556350708,
-0.7607652544975281,
1.0533337593078613,
0.024336157366633415,
-0.8905987739562988,
0.6528501510620117,
-0.6824616193771362,
-0.8492312431335449,
-0.21199491620063782,
0.13375820219516754,
-0.048368483781814575,
0.13117989897727966,
0.2629985511302948,
0.33863234519958496,
-0.12084387242794037,
-0.08091775327920914,
-0.37953370809555054,
-0.4493776261806488,
0.19236263632774353,
-0.4995904266834259,
0.599088191986084,
0.20701485872268677,
-0.19418984651565552,
-0.29027059674263,
-0.6549685001373291,
0.11652898043394089,
0.034847158938646317,
-0.011469686403870583,
-0.8560047149658203,
-0.3086048364639282,
0.20901156961917877,
0.2955983281135559,
0.2914573550224304,
-0.7140164971351624,
-0.17898981273174286,
-0.4817652106285095,
-0.009360143914818764,
0.4485013484954834,
-0.20733089745044708,
0.8260009288787842,
-0.3787941336631775,
0.3965512812137604,
0.09157860279083252,
-0.15251286327838898,
-0.18315021693706512,
-0.4084538519382477,
-0.5680184960365295,
-0.0995478555560112,
0.6783096194267273,
0.8025175929069519,
-1.1785246133804321,
0.2061014175415039,
-0.9180041551589966,
-0.31733623147010803,
-0.9132726192474365,
0.30642858147621155,
0.3369469940662384,
0.6853432059288025,
0.4484676122665405,
-0.25318893790245056,
-0.6245636343955994,
-1.1090961694717407,
-0.4098447561264038,
-0.08801107108592987,
-0.16418303549289703,
0.2528645694255829,
0.26619499921798706,
0.07133365422487259,
0.701920747756958,
-0.1771884709596634,
-0.11849946528673172,
-0.23307687044143677,
0.21346814930438995,
-0.03465914726257324,
0.5276256799697876,
0.6326151490211487,
-0.9501757621765137,
-0.9675977826118469,
0.4986891746520996,
-0.9733406901359558,
-0.19145779311656952,
-0.28467294573783875,
-0.19527505338191986,
0.5442700386047363,
0.39871490001678467,
-0.5472930669784546,
0.4165417551994324,
0.4822225272655487,
-0.264264851808548,
0.09063240140676498,
-0.26913371682167053,
0.698223888874054,
-1.0860884189605713,
0.17444664239883423,
-0.13315676152706146,
-0.4251936078071594,
-0.8141279220581055,
-0.10848087072372437,
0.13689585030078888,
-0.06211816892027855,
-0.49530816078186035,
0.6008919477462769,
-0.41270333528518677,
-0.18082095682621002,
-0.29195642471313477,
0.4450826048851013,
-0.08912946283817291,
0.2976687550544739,
0.2288009375333786,
0.8284316658973694,
0.6135823726654053,
-0.45305395126342773,
0.2887457311153412,
0.3087352216243744,
-0.37431442737579346,
0.5625471472740173,
-0.47901663184165955,
0.09205007553100586,
-0.1710059493780136,
0.019477475434541702,
-0.7850954532623291,
-0.013885547406971455,
0.20925848186016083,
-0.5197076797485352,
0.34096843004226685,
0.00839800015091896,
-0.38315361738204956,
-0.08628492802381516,
-0.5332462787628174,
0.33633142709732056,
0.45609134435653687,
-0.6084839701652527,
0.192361980676651,
0.08322527259588242,
-0.2671468257904053,
-0.7414554357528687,
-1.1555685997009277,
0.41268402338027954,
-0.24416163563728333,
-0.710637092590332,
0.5717725157737732,
0.22341926395893097,
-0.050434935837984085,
0.5010259747505188,
-0.12559354305267334,
-0.008327597752213478,
-0.12228766083717346,
0.02053290605545044,
0.43374231457710266,
-0.42983129620552063,
0.05367007106542587,
0.24155651032924652,
-0.2798185348510742,
-0.07360083609819412,
-0.44885820150375366,
0.24558039009571075,
0.4033200144767761,
-0.41104215383529663,
-0.2790028750896454,
0.6853898763656616,
0.3360944092273712,
0.034845124930143356,
0.8325421214103699,
0.744999885559082,
-0.1671709269285202,
-0.008877543732523918,
-0.38017797470092773,
-0.08169606328010559,
-0.3316650092601776,
0.24889281392097473,
-0.6311059594154358,
-0.8198609948158264,
0.12263767421245575,
0.07428932189941406,
-0.034990571439266205,
0.4344634413719177,
0.11577984690666199,
-0.14514032006263733,
0.7433419227600098,
0.7159518599510193,
-0.35646867752075195,
0.496942937374115,
-0.005234443582594395,
0.25721144676208496,
-0.36123138666152954,
-0.004974501207470894,
-0.5296227335929871,
-0.43318042159080505,
-0.9960485696792603,
-0.5814893841743469,
0.2663680613040924,
-0.008912287652492523,
0.23449188470840454,
0.6542087197303772,
-0.06416650861501694,
0.47479936480522156,
0.6060953140258789,
0.04032069444656372,
0.5654134750366211,
0.3877043128013611,
0.06544040143489838,
-0.3472159206867218,
-1.0084837675094604,
-0.29007062315940857,
1.1116275787353516,
-0.011560726910829544,
0.6307337284088135,
-0.07233059406280518,
0.5318971872329712,
0.23125582933425903,
-0.010927174240350723,
-0.47466379404067993,
0.35606345534324646,
-0.5393533706665039,
-0.26871687173843384,
-0.31286558508872986,
-0.7299845218658447,
-0.9994249939918518,
0.2934780418872833,
-0.4010099172592163,
-0.3359872102737427,
0.14651194214820862,
-0.22009055316448212,
0.39782702922821045,
0.21848183870315552,
-0.9557045102119446,
0.909203052520752,
-0.20405450463294983,
-0.32583603262901306,
-0.3734813928604126,
-0.6558481454849243,
0.023365816101431847,
-0.17707189917564392,
0.12792019546031952,
0.26640814542770386,
-0.30432024598121643,
0.5735347867012024,
-0.15554296970367432,
0.4969569742679596,
-0.08660315722227097,
-0.06435461342334747,
-0.05172569677233696,
-0.1963329017162323,
0.40662890672683716,
-0.147434264421463,
-0.11218723654747009,
0.3738453984260559,
-0.07817568629980087,
-0.6609277725219727,
-0.9347971081733704,
0.9682186245918274,
-0.6192112565040588,
-0.3650989830493927,
-0.04870636388659477,
-0.6563738584518433,
-0.23431967198848724,
0.0811634361743927,
0.37239232659339905,
0.21079707145690918,
-0.1951584666967392,
0.23520442843437195,
0.5928685665130615,
-0.2390461415052414,
0.3584795594215393,
0.4675273001194,
-0.1784418523311615,
-0.08427675068378448,
0.9747914671897888,
0.28858137130737305,
0.38505277037620544,
0.7209723591804504,
-0.21563325822353363,
-0.3937041461467743,
-0.3533490002155304,
-0.8618514537811279,
0.23019741475582123,
-0.5857815146446228,
0.14396198093891144,
-0.6792972683906555,
-0.08039967715740204,
-0.5911385416984558,
-0.28002652525901794,
-0.2687424421310425,
-0.8098315596580505,
0.04943418130278587,
-0.22624416649341583,
0.37064990401268005,
0.397040992975235,
-0.2580614984035492,
-0.2595694065093994,
-0.725679337978363,
0.5405974388122559,
-0.045935165137052536,
0.07319081574678421,
-0.3032539486885071,
-0.4494856595993042,
-0.4116135835647583,
0.19462499022483826,
0.20182663202285767,
-0.6956669688224792,
0.17377379536628723,
0.26188141107559204,
0.47137683629989624,
0.0545869804918766,
0.04922090470790863,
1.0957368612289429,
-0.5717236995697021,
0.5862261652946472,
0.1628374606370926,
-0.7997714877128601,
0.3478514552116394,
0.13163137435913086,
0.38176536560058594,
0.5786256790161133,
0.7377682328224182,
-0.8084285855293274,
-0.5139428377151489,
-0.305746853351593,
-0.674446702003479,
0.6833941340446472,
0.19956856966018677,
0.4106054902076721,
0.14688126742839813,
0.10853805392980576,
0.40191078186035156,
0.0563771016895771,
-0.6260439157485962,
-0.37044757604599,
-0.1282726377248764,
-0.2035098820924759,
-0.41264858841896057,
0.3596090078353882,
0.3112468123435974,
-0.2862880825996399,
0.5035936832427979,
-0.22714252769947052,
0.08072534948587418,
0.5495727062225342,
-0.5750498175621033,
-0.22064734995365143,
0.29645857214927673,
0.145249143242836,
0.5408152341842651,
0.26306313276290894,
0.1245778426527977,
0.6046172380447388,
-0.29617831110954285,
-0.07607836276292801,
0.3419720232486725,
-0.2859898805618286,
0.4320797324180603,
0.6488135457038879,
0.9863912463188171,
0.4383540153503418,
-0.6720317602157593,
0.35962623357772827,
0.2801564037799835,
-0.1705743670463562,
0.1921670287847519,
-0.03639990836381912,
-0.009955449029803276,
0.04556751623749733,
0.3231451213359833,
0.016457535326480865,
0.2477589249610901,
-0.7333770990371704,
0.21429219841957092,
0.4505513310432434,
-0.2692934274673462,
-0.07882392406463623,
0.41162148118019104,
-0.13627056777477264,
-0.11035546660423279,
0.42580196261405945,
0.045515816658735275,
-0.40846094489097595,
0.32427993416786194,
0.5892503261566162,
0.4538498520851135,
-0.029115840792655945,
0.4533211886882782,
0.3951224684715271,
0.4690375030040741,
0.28365805745124817,
0.04837225750088692,
-0.41399577260017395,
-0.49412426352500916,
-0.8148185014724731,
-0.2772537171840668,
-0.3561590611934662,
-0.2659890353679657,
-0.6406373977661133,
0.2434837967157364,
0.16554374992847443,
0.3170885741710663,
0.0013856810983270407,
0.08116854727268219,
-0.6793083548545837,
0.13896732032299042,
0.3576849699020386,
0.9330070614814758,
-0.9558414220809937,
0.8931169509887695,
0.8697477579116821,
-0.205828458070755,
-0.40095949172973633,
-0.07244271039962769,
-0.3890220522880554,
-0.3727109134197235,
0.4536275267601013,
0.061300840228796005,
-0.07153523713350296,
-0.13307875394821167,
-0.1486091911792755,
-0.728477418422699,
0.9801747798919678,
0.5729265213012695,
-0.3041827082633972,
-0.10336417704820633,
0.7717946767807007,
0.6853796243667603,
-0.2823866605758667,
0.07366219162940979,
0.32883045077323914,
0.49095356464385986,
-0.1746593415737152,
-1.0894883871078491,
-0.004778773058205843,
-0.29651013016700745,
0.09365743398666382,
0.24226997792720795,
-0.2726583480834961,
0.4292689263820648,
0.02930041216313839,
-0.37151873111724854,
-0.03555649518966675,
0.6850799322128296,
-0.21404719352722168,
0.6142358779907227,
0.4691217839717865,
0.6238980889320374,
0.5780929923057556,
0.011286702938377857,
1.1933075189590454,
-0.19251318275928497,
0.14406533539295197,
0.94852614402771,
-0.266571581363678,
0.8442316055297852,
0.5875742435455322,
-0.04449966549873352,
0.4539056122303009,
0.4574352204799652,
0.0068295858800411224,
0.5109639763832092,
-0.3144570291042328,
-0.06986890733242035,
-0.0024659985210746527,
-0.22925937175750732,
-0.3393253982067108,
0.40720388293266296,
-0.021875452250242233,
-0.27538803219795227,
-0.3064199686050415,
0.5166968703269958,
0.04758124053478241,
0.249337837100029,
-0.12055789679288864,
0.9212867021560669,
-0.07552144676446915,
-0.8682511448860168,
0.6680656671524048,
-0.048865173012018204,
0.7273778915405273,
-0.6135124564170837,
0.09970222413539886,
-0.3505885601043701,
-0.21956239640712738,
-0.1878909021615982,
-0.6894990801811218,
0.5470378398895264,
0.27470383048057556,
-0.3134111166000366,
-0.4211719334125519,
0.872711718082428,
-0.7035907506942749,
-0.4246695041656494,
0.5684475898742676,
0.6992289423942566,
0.24619394540786743,
0.21099010109901428,
-0.7349643111228943,
-0.31982502341270447,
-0.015565289184451103,
-0.01489664614200592,
0.45660120248794556,
0.48350852727890015,
-0.24562251567840576,
0.4981893002986908,
0.7872879505157471,
0.14760687947273254,
0.3570922017097473,
-0.013112704269587994,
0.6502630114555359,
-0.5498205423355103,
-0.35020074248313904,
-0.6501216292381287,
0.2219768911600113,
-0.3217568099498749,
-0.15174023807048798,
1.1512829065322876,
0.855525016784668,
1.3605517148971558,
-0.27589207887649536,
0.7327235341072083,
-0.1280404031276703,
0.47166600823402405,
-0.7389782667160034,
0.4775448739528656,
-0.6755838394165039,
-0.21741652488708496,
-0.3302001357078552,
-0.9265016913414001,
-0.1833021640777588,
0.37987223267555237,
-0.2746688425540924,
-0.07430548220872879,
0.9290973544120789,
0.8273651599884033,
-0.43065664172172546,
0.10469010472297668,
0.48817235231399536,
-0.016322631388902664,
-0.4189775586128235,
0.7108802795410156,
0.7551523447036743,
-0.660328209400177,
0.5505763292312622,
-0.5480021238327026,
-0.008968619629740715,
0.21609218418598175,
-0.6187997460365295,
-0.6817249059677124,
-0.6161826848983765,
-0.3834036588668823,
0.001887358957901597,
0.10064706951379776,
0.7952027916908264,
0.6791749000549316,
-0.8366613388061523,
-0.15150751173496246,
-0.03409832715988159,
0.2716689109802246,
-0.20433077216148376,
-0.24994173645973206,
0.2656603157520294,
-0.49723416566848755,
-1.0809210538864136,
0.6938097476959229,
0.30193546414375305,
-0.14337414503097534,
-0.02470286563038826,
-0.11287522315979004,
-0.2854604423046112,
0.018327128142118454,
0.6320723295211792,
0.12451040744781494,
-0.5238538980484009,
-0.19854630529880524,
0.2289026528596878,
-0.15323922038078308,
0.02288902923464775,
0.9177536368370056,
-0.811380922794342,
0.5251949429512024,
0.5581399202346802,
1.027972936630249,
0.6450170874595642,
-0.03179308772087097,
0.5024112462997437,
-0.7341964244842529,
0.28202396631240845,
-0.21192318201065063,
0.12681743502616882,
0.49813398718833923,
-0.3936077356338501,
0.6356951594352722,
0.2842305302619934,
-0.09797418117523193,
-0.710780918598175,
-0.059165049344301224,
-0.8126609921455383,
-0.4174729585647583,
0.8569320440292358,
-0.20072872936725616,
-0.2579706013202667,
-0.21811982989311218,
-0.12422532588243484,
0.3510519564151764,
0.08535876125097275,
0.5318909287452698,
0.7938503623008728,
0.14476782083511353,
-0.01907408982515335,
-0.7690609097480774,
0.28643327951431274,
0.7231497168540955,
-0.8500099778175354,
-0.21717803180217743,
0.4619719088077545,
0.18929794430732727,
0.3217356204986572,
0.25042441487312317,
-0.07654448598623276,
0.49411633610725403,
0.04838317632675171,
-0.311220645904541,
0.04191068187355995,
-0.27892038226127625,
-0.3527398109436035,
0.14465630054473877,
-0.47966188192367554,
-0.3048649728298187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05217v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05217v1
|
Harnessing Multi-Role Capabilities of Large Language Models for Open-Domain Question Answering
| 2024-03-08T11:09:13 | 2024-03-08T11:09:13 |
Hongda Sun, Yuxuan Liu, Chengwei Wu, Haiyu Yan, Cheng Tai, Xin Gao, Shuo Shang, Rui Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Open-domain question answering (ODQA) has emerged as a pivotal research
spotlight in information systems. Existing methods follow two main paradigms to
collect evidence: (1) The \textit{retrieve-then-read} paradigm retrieves
pertinent documents from an external corpus; and (2) the
\textit{generate-then-read} paradigm employs large language models (LLMs) to
generate relevant documents. However, neither can fully address multifaceted
requirements for evidence. To this end, we propose LLMQA, a generalized
framework that formulates the ODQA process into three basic steps: query
expansion, document selection, and answer generation, combining the superiority
of both retrieval-based and generation-based evidence. Since LLMs exhibit their
excellent capabilities to accomplish various tasks, we instruct LLMs to play
multiple roles as generators, rerankers, and evaluators within our framework,
integrating them to collaborate in the ODQA process. Furthermore, we introduce
a novel prompt optimization algorithm to refine role-playing prompts and steer
LLMs to produce higher-quality evidence and answers. Extensive experimental
results on widely used benchmarks (NQ, WebQ, and TriviaQA) demonstrate that
LLMQA achieves the best performance in terms of both answer accuracy and
evidence quality, showcasing its potential for advancing ODQA research and
applications.
|
[
-0.5471233129501343,
-0.8478132486343384,
0.9457014203071594,
-0.2099221795797348,
0.012775124981999397,
-0.05016644299030304,
0.0575970783829689,
-0.2338142693042755,
-0.14936670660972595,
0.5410494208335876,
-0.6264239549636841,
-0.33999085426330566,
-0.4449307322502136,
0.11973273754119873,
-0.08107753843069077,
0.860102117061615,
-0.23541925847530365,
0.21396128833293915,
-0.3221847116947174,
-0.17219892144203186,
-0.3427729606628418,
-0.518277108669281,
-0.6593714952468872,
-0.0022324486635625362,
0.4830220341682434,
0.6435123085975647,
0.7284682989120483,
0.33224499225616455,
0.13807456195354462,
0.13335557281970978,
0.2089952677488327,
0.4925098419189453,
-0.5580475330352783,
0.4584222435951233,
-0.19092321395874023,
-0.4246402978897095,
-0.6577844023704529,
-0.01493788231164217,
0.5075008869171143,
0.6209755539894104,
-0.2947414219379425,
0.3261839747428894,
-0.06964313983917236,
0.12664011120796204,
-0.7383764982223511,
-0.00570312375202775,
-0.5096364617347717,
-0.3687240183353424,
-0.0012843433069065213,
-0.3940087556838989,
-0.39597657322883606,
-0.43079620599746704,
0.1849178522825241,
-0.8077885508537292,
-0.0054069883190095425,
0.1319228559732437,
0.5481597185134888,
-0.045449722558259964,
-0.5599988698959351,
-0.5209478139877319,
-0.4796241819858551,
0.768822193145752,
-0.682533323764801,
0.2422858625650406,
0.29002052545547485,
0.309013307094574,
-0.24177394807338715,
-0.5681565999984741,
-0.6558151841163635,
0.06004628539085388,
0.2439577728509903,
0.0793164074420929,
0.09255732595920563,
-0.014087436720728874,
0.17735546827316284,
0.3500044643878937,
-0.5408750176429749,
0.17574883997440338,
-0.2120974212884903,
-0.05104544758796692,
0.47504183650016785,
0.24636991322040558,
0.35887590050697327,
0.09791183471679688,
-0.35600993037223816,
0.1747906506061554,
-0.8606708645820618,
0.35123008489608765,
0.14768168330192566,
0.3243654668331146,
0.4310276508331299,
0.9483545422554016,
-0.30242857336997986,
0.5119120478630066,
0.0735163614153862,
-0.06728079915046692,
-0.2851372957229614,
-0.3851836323738098,
-0.2847198247909546,
-0.008569249883294106,
0.5452870726585388,
0.283118337392807,
0.07805933058261871,
-0.11306388676166534,
-0.18631920218467712,
-0.13837794959545135,
0.23689091205596924,
-0.9751095175743103,
0.18349407613277435,
0.6391182541847229,
-0.4573896825313568,
0.05355949327349663,
0.1323125958442688,
-0.82635098695755,
-0.46361586451530457,
-0.2897985577583313,
0.7512869834899902,
-0.3733161687850952,
-0.4203149080276489,
0.4243975281715393,
-0.16319869458675385,
0.1931803971529007,
0.4740440249443054,
-0.4694501757621765,
0.4811747074127197,
0.7800140380859375,
0.4896184802055359,
-0.30164116621017456,
-0.09393581748008728,
-1.2105001211166382,
-0.08278565108776093,
-0.38245874643325806,
0.5636954307556152,
-0.5512889623641968,
-0.2684190273284912,
0.42794308066368103,
-0.13883069157600403,
-0.0886039063334465,
-0.4705258011817932,
0.7682543396949768,
-1.1735719442367554,
0.6088716387748718,
-0.22938530147075653,
-0.47756800055503845,
0.02348172292113304,
0.3026590645313263,
-0.7108206748962402,
1.0990723371505737,
0.026273122057318687,
-0.5611928105354309,
0.4693383276462555,
-0.9340687394142151,
-0.04089805856347084,
-0.04947851225733757,
-0.15038053691387177,
-0.006366677116602659,
0.23611481487751007,
0.5021597743034363,
0.4730331599712372,
-0.766237735748291,
0.35787537693977356,
-0.15267354249954224,
-0.21548472344875336,
0.2906319499015808,
-0.11860200017690659,
0.815952479839325,
0.10729628801345825,
-0.21483087539672852,
0.12651093304157257,
-0.6677956581115723,
0.23202699422836304,
0.15806184709072113,
-0.6690956354141235,
-0.4877597391605377,
0.0539664700627327,
-0.2894763946533203,
0.22967404127120972,
-0.06482855975627899,
-0.9535361528396606,
0.3183209002017975,
-0.21069584786891937,
0.5151442885398865,
0.47781217098236084,
0.2723475694656372,
0.533711850643158,
-0.3806673586368561,
0.6595138311386108,
-0.11209486424922943,
0.05462058261036873,
-0.2459104359149933,
-0.608151912689209,
-0.3779459595680237,
-0.4281722605228424,
0.2534487843513489,
0.3737491965293884,
-1.1772406101226807,
0.10589487105607986,
-0.3105655014514923,
-0.07099521905183792,
-0.6888039708137512,
-0.24262124300003052,
0.25473904609680176,
0.3626314699649811,
0.5694055557250977,
-0.2554751932621002,
-0.22659990191459656,
-0.5763929486274719,
-0.08227792382240295,
-0.35478174686431885,
-0.26859602332115173,
0.3073616623878479,
0.498907208442688,
0.1921214908361435,
1.0215853452682495,
-0.5865669250488281,
-0.30909833312034607,
-0.07332418113946915,
0.08870018273591995,
0.3391032814979553,
0.12471538037061691,
0.30832725763320923,
-0.8890954256057739,
-0.08951152861118317,
-0.2866833508014679,
-0.7029345631599426,
-0.15937940776348114,
0.16221587359905243,
-0.496772825717926,
0.1354714334011078,
0.45839250087738037,
-0.8839256763458252,
0.30094432830810547,
0.22976481914520264,
-0.3696838617324829,
0.536740243434906,
0.11417774111032486,
0.437745064496994,
-0.9163464307785034,
0.1910787671804428,
-0.44289934635162354,
-0.004170128144323826,
-0.7676454186439514,
0.44114479422569275,
0.055806927382946014,
-0.08630707859992981,
-0.20761263370513916,
0.7224277853965759,
-0.6069750785827637,
0.015921518206596375,
-0.08059632033109665,
0.4621267020702362,
0.2218734622001648,
0.3613712787628174,
0.05707351490855217,
0.8375722169876099,
0.41800543665885925,
-0.7322254776954651,
0.14665015041828156,
0.5150878429412842,
-0.5610940456390381,
0.7817421555519104,
-0.5231966972351074,
-0.0036526350304484367,
-0.26273244619369507,
0.16190823912620544,
-1.0414291620254517,
-0.39405563473701477,
0.12066712975502014,
-0.42356133460998535,
0.11303804069757462,
-0.05968943238258362,
-0.5780798196792603,
-0.37080755829811096,
-0.29775866866111755,
0.536008894443512,
0.2080955058336258,
-0.7387860417366028,
0.8355695009231567,
0.4198785424232483,
-0.5569988489151001,
-0.8396891951560974,
-0.2535105347633362,
-0.09152355790138245,
-0.09650847315788269,
-0.7915441393852234,
0.38941001892089844,
-0.1251809149980545,
-0.35014608502388,
0.019073888659477234,
-0.2730068564414978,
-0.3453039526939392,
0.07486527413129807,
0.04792392626404762,
0.2582269310951233,
-0.5836740136146545,
0.37976664304733276,
-0.016580497846007347,
0.248416006565094,
0.2134004831314087,
-0.44431576132774353,
0.31666430830955505,
0.3361434042453766,
-0.5569422245025635,
0.16335181891918182,
0.878911554813385,
0.643990695476532,
-0.5666931867599487,
0.6655152440071106,
0.2707763910293579,
-0.3529658317565918,
-0.4002944231033325,
-0.47835084795951843,
-0.1593332439661026,
-0.39800745248794556,
0.2789638340473175,
-0.5408373475074768,
-1.1240320205688477,
0.260896772146225,
-0.0021305843256413937,
0.5854120850563049,
0.3682059347629547,
0.5491635799407959,
0.24347162246704102,
1.0066542625427246,
0.4625319540500641,
0.26563140749931335,
0.07118700444698334,
0.09108193963766098,
0.15681025385856628,
-0.8288530111312866,
-0.16295327246189117,
-0.7169127464294434,
0.13510441780090332,
0.04563169553875923,
-0.7079312205314636,
0.6627074480056763,
0.27993157505989075,
-0.5405150055885315,
-0.11460494995117188,
-0.22396554052829742,
0.22826042771339417,
0.7294134497642517,
0.03194229304790497,
0.5188771486282349,
-0.11241055279970169,
-0.37517982721328735,
0.2543075382709503,
-0.846839189529419,
-0.6483767032623291,
1.1411124467849731,
0.3231963813304901,
0.6912760734558105,
0.6486375331878662,
0.6289817094802856,
0.14490222930908203,
0.3060316741466522,
-0.7233456373214722,
0.6107085347175598,
0.3187900185585022,
-0.8796982765197754,
-0.6376742124557495,
-0.2817082107067108,
-0.9364554286003113,
0.4492453634738922,
-0.24770383536815643,
-0.6164655089378357,
0.14950115978717804,
-0.1492036134004593,
-0.6521640419960022,
0.21938064694404602,
-0.3658241629600525,
0.7293892502784729,
-0.13074685633182526,
-0.43711090087890625,
0.09122437238693237,
-0.4885122776031494,
0.5483863353729248,
-0.11217006295919418,
0.18085375428199768,
0.17469395697116852,
-0.2924937903881073,
0.5629882216453552,
-0.23019134998321533,
0.5319540500640869,
-0.4858580231666565,
-0.5068210959434509,
0.5391474962234497,
0.21138322353363037,
0.3309885263442993,
0.3556564152240753,
-0.46925804018974304,
-0.25968262553215027,
0.33082184195518494,
-0.4004271328449249,
-0.5626645088195801,
0.47137516736984253,
-0.5420578122138977,
-0.8606289625167847,
-0.3200610280036926,
-0.31522583961486816,
-0.5342282652854919,
0.15818211436271667,
-0.03253202140331268,
0.576442539691925,
-0.5842697620391846,
0.21752212941646576,
0.9340378046035767,
-0.3547552525997162,
0.3164360523223877,
0.7104713320732117,
-0.31220024824142456,
-0.4079734683036804,
0.45859143137931824,
-0.06680040806531906,
0.38772445917129517,
0.5599232316017151,
-0.034095700830221176,
-0.5159809589385986,
-0.5938730239868164,
-0.7725744247436523,
0.10817128419876099,
-0.7347038388252258,
-0.2971125841140747,
-0.8481383919715881,
-0.153436079621315,
-0.40598148107528687,
0.2605603337287903,
0.16183754801750183,
-0.44462278485298157,
-0.14606180787086487,
0.008748478256165981,
0.13082419335842133,
0.5329254269599915,
0.18256571888923645,
0.016446983441710472,
-0.8836312294006348,
0.6597086191177368,
0.5116473436355591,
0.3104894161224365,
0.09403511136770248,
-0.3792257010936737,
-0.08323322236537933,
0.03880849480628967,
-0.23797136545181274,
-0.8930798172950745,
-0.10667792707681656,
0.3780888617038727,
0.8783929944038391,
0.14286062121391296,
0.5876473784446716,
0.3844781517982483,
-0.631955087184906,
1.0585461854934692,
-0.11255133897066116,
-0.6951252222061157,
0.19395816326141357,
-0.38426855206489563,
0.21023087203502655,
0.5429883599281311,
0.7462273240089417,
-0.3043503761291504,
-0.23559220135211945,
-0.20457017421722412,
-0.8464898467063904,
0.9035142660140991,
0.15546606481075287,
-0.12187588959932327,
-0.14151589572429657,
0.261730432510376,
0.3253871202468872,
0.5020790100097656,
-0.3668862283229828,
0.13928772509098053,
-0.06894867867231369,
-0.14453260600566864,
0.04886246845126152,
-0.3937603831291199,
-0.46807563304901123,
0.3227211833000183,
0.6703301072120667,
-0.494886577129364,
0.48371750116348267,
0.5416014790534973,
-0.13847212493419647,
-0.19201909005641937,
0.65694260597229,
0.37767577171325684,
0.6937050223350525,
-0.05129282921552658,
0.05100275203585625,
-0.14942586421966553,
-0.3082648813724518,
0.16059988737106323,
0.16927562654018402,
-0.15727326273918152,
-0.24305008351802826,
0.2997303605079651,
0.3872614800930023,
-0.22908397018909454,
-0.8506900072097778,
0.6114358305931091,
-0.14976130425930023,
-0.4757424592971802,
-0.08974205702543259,
0.11985055357217789,
-0.006873682141304016,
0.47293612360954285,
0.7772944569587708,
-0.42572781443595886,
0.14507710933685303,
-0.7896125912666321,
0.1969306617975235,
0.4955449402332306,
-0.1763373464345932,
-0.02438889816403389,
0.760065495967865,
0.12568946182727814,
-0.17458845674991608,
0.3365746736526489,
0.11522644758224487,
-0.3298664093017578,
0.5741574764251709,
0.2706397771835327,
0.670018196105957,
-0.25644999742507935,
0.4338529407978058,
0.28245842456817627,
0.040648192167282104,
-0.23037996888160706,
0.8248712420463562,
0.04251796752214432,
-0.570222795009613,
-0.5319625735282898,
-0.669251024723053,
-0.5193052887916565,
0.16127902269363403,
-0.7848197221755981,
-0.010552437044680119,
-0.11674827337265015,
-0.09006070345640182,
0.16988512873649597,
-0.11697205901145935,
-0.49067530035972595,
0.21290645003318787,
-0.25780969858169556,
1.026041030883789,
-0.3109833002090454,
0.5152084827423096,
0.6944580078125,
-0.4729622006416321,
-0.5534961223602295,
0.19423262774944305,
0.032154954969882965,
-0.6292306184768677,
0.6526011824607849,
0.05394018441438675,
-0.1449398249387741,
0.05502655357122421,
-0.5516696572303772,
-0.6888741850852966,
1.1770292520523071,
0.07351560145616531,
0.0411081500351429,
-0.23964206874370575,
0.0588703416287899,
0.42285457253456116,
-0.8317505717277527,
0.39091184735298157,
0.29345449805259705,
0.37716445326805115,
0.06623233109712601,
-0.8258237838745117,
0.3066101670265198,
-0.12244313210248947,
-0.31058257818222046,
0.12389002740383148,
-0.22598397731781006,
1.081896424293518,
-0.2813820242881775,
-0.4354013502597809,
0.5801507830619812,
0.49093085527420044,
0.25118499994277954,
0.2505923807621002,
0.53531414270401,
0.14835317432880402,
0.7630606889724731,
0.13329951465129852,
0.765021562576294,
-0.04446344077587128,
-0.2032582312822342,
1.284157156944275,
-0.5934224724769592,
0.9784399271011353,
0.2841029167175293,
0.09689069539308548,
0.44948020577430725,
0.5908458232879639,
0.3726544976234436,
0.3371396064758301,
0.36318355798721313,
-0.3654314875602722,
-0.48096421360969543,
-0.3116772174835205,
-0.27938011288642883,
0.2562732994556427,
0.3631553649902344,
-0.3330407440662384,
-0.4409071207046509,
0.004220420960336924,
-0.11159132421016693,
0.21078598499298096,
-0.4407084882259369,
0.6973373889923096,
-0.04942639172077179,
-1.2750217914581299,
0.5285466909408569,
0.07873909175395966,
0.23516477644443512,
-0.549435019493103,
-0.32473820447921753,
-0.07713627815246582,
0.0259553212672472,
0.024780558422207832,
-1.0680718421936035,
-0.14536979794502258,
0.1166791245341301,
-0.319631427526474,
-0.2473643273115158,
0.5354446172714233,
-0.41919922828674316,
0.1416611671447754,
0.3181028962135315,
0.9972809553146362,
-0.0729684829711914,
-0.24434630572795868,
-0.22696536779403687,
-0.2585698068141937,
-0.4076743423938751,
-0.2655501365661621,
0.4120829105377197,
0.8195658326148987,
-0.3358253240585327,
0.4633541703224182,
0.6640188097953796,
-0.1772087663412094,
0.02987324632704258,
0.021937120705842972,
1.0816736221313477,
-0.29900062084198,
-0.42707470059394836,
-0.3843329846858978,
0.5793644189834595,
-0.1582185924053192,
-0.209867924451828,
0.5813745856285095,
0.49524667859077454,
0.6634577512741089,
0.030147530138492584,
0.8320914506912231,
-0.2535949945449829,
0.8602719902992249,
-0.7152820825576782,
0.29103896021842957,
-0.7282053828239441,
0.22801704704761505,
-0.05480476841330528,
-0.8737744092941284,
-0.07983279228210449,
0.01177061628550291,
-0.15550200641155243,
-0.1097964495420456,
0.6543323993682861,
0.7496294975280762,
-0.0011787319090217352,
0.14689843356609344,
0.23003366589546204,
0.08871476352214813,
0.42976078391075134,
0.6806225776672363,
1.0612833499908447,
-0.341103196144104,
0.7171902656555176,
0.6160667538642883,
-0.41385242342948914,
-0.16703568398952484,
-0.704096794128418,
-1.0314832925796509,
-0.5396628379821777,
-0.01663617230951786,
-0.49919962882995605,
0.040173787623643875,
0.9380808472633362,
0.5401802062988281,
-0.6421463489532471,
-0.07695280760526657,
0.3076164722442627,
0.06372953951358795,
-0.3373095989227295,
-0.21046438813209534,
0.2520962357521057,
-0.2013264298439026,
-0.5687577128410339,
0.5548807382583618,
0.11829698830842972,
-0.3725801110267639,
-0.2500453591346741,
-0.07870312035083771,
-0.4551294445991516,
0.46639516949653625,
0.7630684971809387,
0.3729233741760254,
-0.812915027141571,
-0.24513953924179077,
0.46034812927246094,
-0.23828139901161194,
-0.011361420154571533,
0.9663647413253784,
-0.5976824164390564,
0.42393800616264343,
0.5723980069160461,
1.059118628501892,
0.2884216904640198,
0.314556360244751,
0.7786498665809631,
-0.5821586847305298,
-0.6716004014015198,
0.2877840995788574,
0.07378475368022919,
-0.05598606541752815,
-0.2732422947883606,
0.6159189939498901,
-0.2706489562988281,
-0.6712139248847961,
-0.8512698411941528,
0.4199032485485077,
-0.8442821502685547,
-0.49498170614242554,
1.2483047246932983,
-0.30055058002471924,
-0.1104029193520546,
-0.5662551522254944,
-0.45942509174346924,
-0.07558269798755646,
-0.49264106154441833,
0.42453688383102417,
0.6311832666397095,
-0.0966758206486702,
-0.2656630575656891,
-0.7797005772590637,
0.49926677346229553,
0.1456739455461502,
-0.8041325211524963,
0.19409829378128052,
0.8344462513923645,
0.08555645495653152,
0.3118554949760437,
0.9084906578063965,
-0.2334088534116745,
0.32484838366508484,
-0.13763006031513214,
-0.04517103731632233,
-0.15667350590229034,
-0.43108218908309937,
-0.1667163372039795,
0.8134591579437256,
0.2078389823436737,
-0.1512446254491806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05216v1
|
SocialPET: Socially Informed Pattern Exploiting Training for Few-Shot Stance Detection in Social Media
| 2024-03-08T11:00:09 | 2024-03-08T11:00:09 |
Parisa Jamadi Khiabani, Arkaitz Zubiaga
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Stance detection, as the task of determining the viewpoint of a social media
post towards a target as 'favor' or 'against', has been understudied in the
challenging yet realistic scenario where there is limited labeled data for a
certain target. Our work advances research in few-shot stance detection by
introducing SocialPET, a socially informed approach to leveraging language
models for the task. Our proposed approach builds on the Pattern Exploiting
Training (PET) technique, which addresses classification tasks as cloze
questions through the use of language models. To enhance the approach with
social awareness, we exploit the social network structure surrounding social
media posts. We prove the effectiveness of SocialPET on two stance datasets,
Multi-target and P-Stance, outperforming competitive stance detection models as
well as the base model, PET, where the labeled instances for the target under
study is as few as 100. When we delve into the results, we observe that
SocialPET is comparatively strong in identifying instances of the `against'
class, where baseline models underperform.
|
[
-0.2509040832519531,
-0.6855672597885132,
0.46916264295578003,
0.43668463826179504,
-0.5193919539451599,
0.05179653689265251,
-0.18548834323883057,
-0.364865243434906,
0.47648391127586365,
0.15018831193447113,
-0.32805418968200684,
-0.6891084313392639,
-1.0505282878875732,
-0.22398047149181366,
-0.15881264209747314,
0.6958490610122681,
0.25436902046203613,
0.3450179100036621,
-0.02729855664074421,
-0.3560776114463806,
-0.08624251186847687,
-0.43204522132873535,
-0.8924852609634399,
-0.36861371994018555,
0.5595675706863403,
0.5827935934066772,
0.22313882410526276,
0.27654847502708435,
0.27838972210884094,
0.19889827072620392,
-0.3021126985549927,
-0.08648712933063507,
-0.8854285478591919,
-0.1306634098291397,
-0.188471257686615,
-0.4019051790237427,
-0.40071576833724976,
0.2672226130962372,
0.7375327348709106,
0.4498853385448456,
0.2573316693305969,
0.2565743923187256,
0.2643941342830658,
0.5876234173774719,
-0.7584916353225708,
-0.025475434958934784,
-0.6818700432777405,
0.15424716472625732,
-0.3040349781513214,
0.030388707295060158,
-0.4137941598892212,
-0.2591317296028137,
-0.2669171392917633,
-0.42420053482055664,
0.14319336414337158,
-0.17826540768146515,
0.5702711939811707,
-0.17882506549358368,
-0.27393072843551636,
0.04642309248447418,
-0.47197097539901733,
0.7564812302589417,
-0.48274484276771545,
0.357999324798584,
0.670590877532959,
0.42803487181663513,
-0.16044151782989502,
-0.33235278725624084,
-0.4919239282608032,
0.22993607819080353,
0.04964858293533325,
0.08364295214414597,
-0.17427726089954376,
-0.021957822144031525,
0.296005517244339,
0.07269395142793655,
-0.5275906920433044,
-0.10873845964670181,
-0.23496165871620178,
-0.0768502801656723,
0.7642825245857239,
-0.2397243231534958,
0.17134056985378265,
-0.49995115399360657,
-0.5469585061073303,
-0.004419401753693819,
-0.5800808668136597,
0.6419840455055237,
0.39814016222953796,
0.39496779441833496,
-0.28705936670303345,
0.687379002571106,
-0.44950345158576965,
0.26950541138648987,
0.6546247005462646,
-0.028627945110201836,
0.05984143167734146,
-0.034015413373708725,
-0.048176512122154236,
0.2944068908691406,
0.8454564213752747,
0.6126543283462524,
0.2061804085969925,
0.17558662593364716,
-0.0537421889603138,
0.26627588272094727,
0.12804363667964935,
-0.606896162033081,
0.05082942172884941,
0.07040587812662125,
-0.8350730538368225,
-0.902711808681488,
-0.005785602610558271,
-0.5988630652427673,
-1.160139560699463,
0.009247539564967155,
0.20292598009109497,
-0.3659309148788452,
-0.5813179612159729,
0.11526329070329666,
-0.6004295349121094,
0.9333516359329224,
0.37895846366882324,
-0.7533420920372009,
0.274272620677948,
1.2615972757339478,
0.9518986940383911,
0.2130599468946457,
-0.36447298526763916,
-0.6103137135505676,
0.037999771535396576,
-0.44175371527671814,
1.1360207796096802,
-0.8078741431236267,
-0.49282070994377136,
-0.13542303442955017,
0.17153942584991455,
0.16007353365421295,
-0.08370381593704224,
0.11306754499673843,
-0.34163016080856323,
-0.23431088030338287,
-0.571365237236023,
-0.7140130400657654,
0.027031628414988518,
0.8950631022453308,
-0.5238234996795654,
0.980732798576355,
-0.23436883091926575,
-0.8184666037559509,
0.8350448608398438,
-0.3837713897228241,
-0.4245641231536865,
0.23063264787197113,
-0.34888437390327454,
-0.39127618074417114,
0.1062597930431366,
-0.1380750983953476,
0.7049283981323242,
0.31230810284614563,
-0.09595286101102829,
-1.0345009565353394,
-0.3722343444824219,
-0.13941140472888947,
0.013355032540857792,
0.8949599862098694,
-0.16165252029895782,
-0.4462355375289917,
0.23241466283798218,
-0.5324947834014893,
-0.2638237178325653,
0.4453223645687103,
-0.2152881771326065,
-0.849490225315094,
0.16152948141098022,
-0.37829098105430603,
0.2648753821849823,
0.0008453181362710893,
-0.677986204624176,
0.34878551959991455,
-0.2995503544807434,
0.14386597275733948,
0.8154739141464233,
0.1771128922700882,
0.7265548706054688,
-0.25439053773880005,
0.5164040327072144,
-0.5141966342926025,
0.5008662343025208,
0.5889260172843933,
-0.6108940839767456,
-0.22309333086013794,
0.03106883354485035,
0.09017333388328552,
0.206961527466774,
-0.41972988843917847,
0.002002313267439604,
-0.06303003430366516,
-0.6389791369438171,
-0.2881051301956177,
0.3331264853477478,
0.26004794239997864,
0.1388128697872162,
-0.08258058875799179,
-0.4266979992389679,
-0.651796817779541,
-0.5741850137710571,
-0.48641932010650635,
-0.4541924297809601,
0.5087997317314148,
0.29249921441078186,
0.3827325105667114,
0.07731238752603531,
0.7015933394432068,
-0.15066692233085632,
-0.1975114643573761,
-0.6468008160591125,
0.37029141187667847,
-0.18031780421733856,
0.11556948721408844,
0.9019371867179871,
-0.8553521633148193,
-1.0329248905181885,
-0.15913552045822144,
-0.6356390714645386,
0.14255644381046295,
-0.02706903964281082,
-0.38449692726135254,
0.053547415882349014,
0.642180323600769,
-0.5504797101020813,
0.45943981409072876,
0.4189507067203522,
-0.22737671434879303,
0.4535382091999054,
0.6838516592979431,
0.25417792797088623,
-1.07144296169281,
-0.08128433674573898,
0.39900442957878113,
-0.45601174235343933,
-0.7397931218147278,
-0.28915876150131226,
-0.14105477929115295,
-0.19714614748954773,
-0.9739754796028137,
0.6923366189002991,
-0.1438077688217163,
-0.19253551959991455,
-0.5200243592262268,
-0.06196913495659828,
0.022405235096812248,
0.23702703416347504,
0.621740996837616,
0.15867383778095245,
0.6698507070541382,
-0.3118355870246887,
0.1322760283946991,
0.2011650949716568,
-0.22630514204502106,
0.7970386147499084,
-0.5773574709892273,
0.47178277373313904,
-0.3737580180168152,
0.24062980711460114,
-1.0545077323913574,
-0.3498583436012268,
0.5487450361251831,
-0.7804586291313171,
0.18561385571956635,
-0.9474302530288696,
-0.21599192917346954,
-0.29500195384025574,
-0.8803070783615112,
0.1761721968650818,
0.07831857353448868,
-0.3438030779361725,
0.42450568079948425,
0.548222541809082,
0.08307524025440216,
-0.928215742111206,
-0.2076045125722885,
-0.202001690864563,
-0.391269713640213,
-0.5617285966873169,
0.058030661195516586,
0.1837584227323532,
-0.42118918895721436,
-0.11662396788597107,
-0.04004061594605446,
0.036955319344997406,
0.05478299409151077,
0.2851577699184418,
-0.2750400900840759,
-0.2779541611671448,
0.060226716101169586,
-0.2076147496700287,
0.022736486047506332,
0.008956934325397015,
0.23154225945472717,
0.9023924469947815,
-0.19369365274906158,
-0.33181262016296387,
-0.40060505270957947,
0.40741845965385437,
0.6355562210083008,
-0.022122124210000038,
0.5826472640037537,
0.6653190851211548,
-0.5092809796333313,
-0.45680737495422363,
-0.29677337408065796,
-0.2579096853733063,
-0.5188989639282227,
0.09429311752319336,
-0.11190154403448105,
-0.5537855625152588,
0.28355172276496887,
-0.13875971734523773,
-0.2194511592388153,
0.03354789689183235,
0.21219512820243835,
-0.49861741065979004,
1.2132697105407715,
0.8447611331939697,
-0.6426964998245239,
0.873753011226654,
-0.2988545298576355,
-0.017877837643027306,
-0.4895142912864685,
0.08906877040863037,
-0.16658388078212738,
-0.5770283341407776,
-0.3674837648868561,
-0.2368117868900299,
0.14963257312774658,
0.22952836751937866,
-0.21358507871627808,
0.38717371225357056,
-0.3845047652721405,
0.6143345832824707,
0.46437981724739075,
0.4648725688457489,
-0.01669805496931076,
0.011087304912507534,
0.39672231674194336,
0.016188908368349075,
-0.5659598708152771,
-0.4607750177383423,
0.9970573782920837,
0.30308058857917786,
0.5869885683059692,
0.07839298993349075,
0.9951682090759277,
0.6219278573989868,
0.23770472407341003,
-1.427222728729248,
0.9066052436828613,
-0.30543771386146545,
-0.5187686085700989,
-0.2681500017642975,
0.2568887174129486,
-0.8348793387413025,
0.06933946162462234,
-0.4329335391521454,
-0.5183937549591064,
0.41035768389701843,
0.47308045625686646,
-0.4029024541378021,
0.2889927923679352,
-0.3814915418624878,
1.1293096542358398,
-0.33233749866485596,
-0.6011583805084229,
-0.3884727656841278,
-0.6763328313827515,
0.18961936235427856,
0.35236024856567383,
-0.0010782493045553565,
-0.17890048027038574,
0.4664827585220337,
0.5536503791809082,
-0.413757860660553,
1.4942010641098022,
-0.6293776631355286,
0.3695872128009796,
0.35877087712287903,
-0.12051673978567123,
0.7161768674850464,
-0.17031636834144592,
-0.023983433842658997,
-0.006261994130909443,
-0.37313610315322876,
-0.4193184971809387,
-0.31869375705718994,
0.4155094623565674,
-0.5927378535270691,
-0.35103273391723633,
-0.43627139925956726,
0.21682210266590118,
-0.3121914267539978,
0.35287025570869446,
0.2511153519153595,
0.20487357676029205,
-0.6776514053344727,
0.346443235874176,
0.5733283758163452,
-0.0756823793053627,
0.24960435926914215,
0.4671984612941742,
0.11383159458637238,
-0.1106175035238266,
0.7188171148300171,
-0.18328535556793213,
0.1908085197210312,
0.06895382702350616,
0.7119009494781494,
-0.3021802604198456,
-0.3779986798763275,
-0.07074633240699768,
0.31213194131851196,
-0.7854350209236145,
0.09445470571517944,
-0.4278530776500702,
0.07422920316457748,
-0.8117105960845947,
-0.6308521628379822,
-0.5478124022483826,
-0.18907178938388824,
0.07285193353891373,
-0.0816153734922409,
0.37723761796951294,
0.8340252637863159,
-0.39963725209236145,
0.6678935289382935,
-0.39925041794776917,
0.3661603629589081,
0.4985670745372772,
0.3931503891944885,
-0.29998070001602173,
-0.21620266139507294,
0.10917452722787857,
-0.07008575648069382,
-0.15919233858585358,
-1.254972219467163,
0.14448148012161255,
0.11047980934381485,
0.6883106827735901,
0.614196240901947,
0.006073231343179941,
0.5483816862106323,
-0.35746464133262634,
0.46546128392219543,
0.1478576362133026,
-0.7350272536277771,
0.9909809827804565,
-0.5952494144439697,
-0.09287421405315399,
0.8128653168678284,
0.7261690497398376,
-0.6300954222679138,
-0.27910539507865906,
-0.684998095035553,
-0.5972633957862854,
0.7614424228668213,
-0.22048866748809814,
0.07638540118932724,
-0.03494520112872124,
0.2388935685157776,
-0.2120172381401062,
0.3200555443763733,
-0.9686091542243958,
0.11992701888084412,
-0.4095299541950226,
0.044630661606788635,
0.13843438029289246,
-0.26379111409187317,
0.004851609002798796,
-0.3648652732372284,
0.6285139322280884,
-0.19042803347110748,
0.1058136597275734,
-0.0956304669380188,
-0.338943749666214,
-0.18091003596782684,
0.17524249851703644,
0.27462735772132874,
0.1460428684949875,
-0.2056742012500763,
0.04333572834730148,
0.00585962412878871,
-0.343973308801651,
0.01961800642311573,
-0.11249583959579468,
-0.23414787650108337,
-0.011560027487576008,
0.0073540653102099895,
0.5957435965538025,
0.21566055715084076,
0.04965470731258392,
0.8825486302375793,
0.00805413443595171,
-0.23793111741542816,
-0.446511447429657,
-0.06312166899442673,
0.025672653689980507,
0.43368038535118103,
-0.23879189789295197,
-0.08590441197156906,
0.3589290380477905,
-0.6600657105445862,
0.281716912984848,
0.7842978835105896,
-0.5793963670730591,
-0.4370253384113312,
0.37321555614471436,
0.15058913826942444,
-0.21731163561344147,
-0.11555486917495728,
-0.45177018642425537,
-0.7468017339706421,
0.7210609912872314,
0.4117707908153534,
0.7432583570480347,
-0.1789521872997284,
0.596802830696106,
0.3627606928348541,
0.13731901347637177,
-0.39838331937789917,
0.37446141242980957,
-0.2784455716609955,
-1.1242352724075317,
-0.08595450222492218,
-0.42807433009147644,
-0.5208145976066589,
0.39037030935287476,
-0.5447291135787964,
0.7882925271987915,
-0.8254739046096802,
-0.3468535542488098,
0.41054975986480713,
-0.02755705825984478,
-0.3049556314945221,
-0.18930508196353912,
0.4985087215900421,
0.6124159097671509,
-1.236042857170105,
0.7208937406539917,
1.2490476369857788,
-0.26818209886550903,
-0.8102473616600037,
0.15476280450820923,
0.6796637177467346,
-0.8230133652687073,
0.5348195433616638,
0.2906975746154785,
-0.6146179437637329,
-0.11998234689235687,
-1.052890419960022,
-0.3887779414653778,
0.7410820126533508,
0.007230895105749369,
-0.23363852500915527,
0.28503838181495667,
0.2284580022096634,
0.371378093957901,
-0.1406068354845047,
-0.35514727234840393,
0.2528921365737915,
0.3306930363178253,
0.03445182368159294,
-0.429562509059906,
-0.10475019365549088,
-0.4371689260005951,
-0.44681552052497864,
-0.011961488053202629,
-1.1350911855697632,
0.4335196018218994,
0.15838776528835297,
-0.1451694220304489,
-0.4419223666191101,
0.1352142095565796,
0.5216472148895264,
0.6639068126678467,
0.971423864364624,
0.28031131625175476,
0.5359765887260437,
0.20246613025665283,
0.9716489911079407,
-0.13678321242332458,
0.4505007863044739,
0.8775619864463806,
-0.5302899479866028,
0.9377809762954712,
0.22804032266139984,
0.12548193335533142,
0.3726779818534851,
0.7514020800590515,
0.02371467649936676,
0.6147188544273376,
-0.134637251496315,
-0.3571374714374542,
-0.6931189894676208,
-0.14798864722251892,
-0.11084207147359848,
0.8715175986289978,
0.40544360876083374,
-0.2866878807544708,
-0.26656293869018555,
-0.11005685478448868,
0.11336812376976013,
0.040391337126493454,
-0.6383547782897949,
1.0187406539916992,
0.1946132332086563,
-0.3249686062335968,
0.23070868849754333,
-0.19183900952339172,
0.7203035354614258,
-0.5611233115196228,
-0.043229177594184875,
-0.13599497079849243,
0.1848493069410324,
-0.22788284718990326,
-0.7393509745597839,
0.26116564869880676,
0.07990165799856186,
-0.14648835361003876,
-0.40722399950027466,
1.6925396919250488,
-0.20571745932102203,
-0.33451956510543823,
0.35093453526496887,
0.300316721200943,
0.1435636729001999,
-0.32614579796791077,
-0.9477384686470032,
-0.16125085949897766,
-0.27911025285720825,
-0.25532248616218567,
0.340680867433548,
0.4376852810382843,
-0.21708446741104126,
0.24942940473556519,
0.46399596333503723,
0.10927177965641022,
-0.20469984412193298,
0.236490860581398,
0.8461382389068604,
-0.4854844808578491,
-0.5097766518592834,
-0.9927965402603149,
0.37926438450813293,
-0.6503071784973145,
-0.0515936017036438,
0.9043256044387817,
0.34529268741607666,
0.7659799456596375,
0.17132410407066345,
0.8993319869041443,
-0.16830067336559296,
0.5058205127716064,
-0.06283434480428696,
0.87420654296875,
-0.6783866286277771,
-0.019309230148792267,
-0.4298221468925476,
-0.3820803761482239,
-0.1720256805419922,
0.7834081053733826,
-0.6819747686386108,
-0.38124579191207886,
0.19441697001457214,
0.8204243183135986,
-0.29206961393356323,
-0.04100535437464714,
0.13074858486652374,
-0.12106481939554214,
0.041575878858566284,
0.23538362979888916,
1.111000895500183,
0.0063865771517157555,
0.45329198241233826,
-0.6308391094207764,
-0.20069335401058197,
-0.34372109174728394,
-0.7959093451499939,
-1.2000583410263062,
-0.09036742895841599,
-0.3652271330356598,
-0.5443963408470154,
0.16851073503494263,
1.0938284397125244,
0.9490811228752136,
-0.8193333745002747,
-0.07650325447320938,
-0.042033709585666656,
0.2964005768299103,
-0.24646726250648499,
-0.2047240436077118,
0.16182906925678253,
-0.18393829464912415,
-0.5510718822479248,
0.4660753905773163,
0.14434975385665894,
-0.001964192371815443,
0.022364385426044464,
-0.029659129679203033,
-0.363982230424881,
-0.011960032396018505,
0.9809930920600891,
0.7026627659797668,
-0.2899995446205139,
-0.43249189853668213,
0.42378365993499756,
-0.13377395272254944,
0.20981751382350922,
0.8177822828292847,
-0.2952377200126648,
0.4341200590133667,
0.7987754940986633,
0.4254828989505768,
0.46124619245529175,
0.5397090315818787,
0.394631952047348,
-1.2412084341049194,
0.28571856021881104,
0.19761091470718384,
0.4423007369041443,
0.3401234745979309,
-0.4923776090145111,
0.3555741310119629,
0.6944612860679626,
-0.15943792462348938,
-0.7153123617172241,
0.26754331588745117,
-0.9944628477096558,
-0.5125191807746887,
1.6592433452606201,
0.17930807173252106,
-0.3412921726703644,
-0.3002493977546692,
-0.22532647848129272,
0.15078052878379822,
-0.5471740961074829,
0.801785945892334,
0.6932798624038696,
-0.15427809953689575,
-0.23351222276687622,
-0.3054402768611908,
0.6440154910087585,
0.36466726660728455,
-0.3391372859477997,
-0.16593918204307556,
0.4864821135997772,
0.36266812682151794,
-0.04141474887728691,
1.2385966777801514,
0.09293705224990845,
0.4781378209590912,
-0.10646174848079681,
-0.009606441482901573,
0.330544650554657,
-0.2080356925725937,
-0.31170982122421265,
0.21685272455215454,
0.2040439397096634,
-0.44268181920051575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05189v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05189v1
|
Tracing the Roots of Facts in Multilingual Language Models: Independent, Shared, and Transferred Knowledge
| 2024-03-08T10:09:57 | 2024-03-08T10:09:57 |
Xin Zhao, Naoki Yoshinaga, Daisuke Oba
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Acquiring factual knowledge for language models (LMs) in low-resource
languages poses a serious challenge, thus resorting to cross-lingual transfer
in multilingual LMs (ML-LMs). In this study, we ask how ML-LMs acquire and
represent factual knowledge. Using the multilingual factual knowledge probing
dataset, mLAMA, we first conducted a neuron investigation of ML-LMs
(specifically, multilingual BERT). We then traced the roots of facts back to
the knowledge source (Wikipedia) to identify the ways in which ML-LMs acquire
specific facts. We finally identified three patterns of acquiring and
representing facts in ML-LMs: language-independent, cross-lingual shared and
transferred, and devised methods for differentiating them. Our findings
highlight the challenge of maintaining consistent factual knowledge across
languages, underscoring the need for better fact representation learning in
ML-LMs.
|
[
-0.4268083870410919,
-0.7424730658531189,
0.7643728852272034,
0.07058683782815933,
0.011283819563686848,
0.03815074265003204,
-0.41351455450057983,
-0.5886918902397156,
0.12013683468103409,
0.1648155003786087,
-0.5647718906402588,
-0.28521135449409485,
-0.7378312349319458,
0.048105388879776,
-0.12669308483600616,
1.0827957391738892,
0.06433356553316116,
0.275126188993454,
-0.46659398078918457,
-0.5717592835426331,
-0.23334361612796783,
-0.7917769551277161,
-0.36042705178260803,
-0.5292903780937195,
1.0299879312515259,
0.5657731294631958,
0.5801042914390564,
0.39815932512283325,
0.2692965865135193,
0.17865754663944244,
0.03193267434835434,
0.32668399810791016,
-0.45491477847099304,
-0.04312123358249664,
-0.344464510679245,
-0.696681797504425,
0.0677695944905281,
-0.004508495330810547,
0.6668116450309753,
0.9084724187850952,
-0.08450599014759064,
0.3339412212371826,
-0.13800042867660522,
0.5610086917877197,
-0.6174304485321045,
0.401732861995697,
-0.5085775256156921,
0.019974645227193832,
-0.09916504472494125,
-0.19722460210323334,
-0.5971634984016418,
-0.5761668682098389,
0.2528057396411896,
-0.4413045644760132,
0.4205324053764343,
-0.14360229671001434,
1.0064491033554077,
-0.25096258521080017,
-0.6771352291107178,
-0.5361135005950928,
-0.7340230941772461,
0.6634349226951599,
-0.3666827380657196,
0.6014396548271179,
0.180333212018013,
0.12257120758295059,
0.24031852185726166,
-0.5135654807090759,
-0.7259537577629089,
-0.2935192883014679,
-0.5417894721031189,
-0.35328954458236694,
-0.10719167441129684,
-0.6003890037536621,
0.2366476207971573,
-0.11881861835718155,
-0.27197349071502686,
0.03180994838476181,
-0.6125434637069702,
-0.4053032398223877,
0.5652604103088379,
-0.15164907276630402,
0.47069311141967773,
-0.19234779477119446,
-0.5922254920005798,
0.016568439081311226,
-1.1051112413406372,
0.1656043827533722,
0.11573609709739685,
0.5464709401130676,
-0.18376314640045166,
0.46857982873916626,
0.3284573256969452,
0.5645062923431396,
-0.26345282793045044,
-0.48705625534057617,
0.29406484961509705,
-0.5675861239433289,
0.13667474687099457,
0.32348230481147766,
0.6806793212890625,
0.03157402575016022,
0.5682090520858765,
-0.2957908809185028,
-0.0818973183631897,
-0.40885454416275024,
0.03173098340630531,
-0.5652848482131958,
-0.050522029399871826,
-0.332966685295105,
-0.3063190281391144,
0.05929499864578247,
-0.26661452651023865,
-0.5804301500320435,
-0.43205076456069946,
-0.39971041679382324,
0.6812896728515625,
-0.4845675230026245,
-0.5166392922401428,
-0.20172370970249176,
-0.03923169523477554,
0.3055911064147949,
0.26273858547210693,
-0.9372614026069641,
0.21226459741592407,
0.4565255343914032,
0.7752552032470703,
-0.17951619625091553,
-0.3657294511795044,
-0.1827055662870407,
0.10995866358280182,
-0.5184264779090881,
0.7026569247245789,
-0.1483863890171051,
-0.059862323105335236,
0.06431012600660324,
0.16026389598846436,
-0.2904398441314697,
-0.25974762439727783,
0.4263145327568054,
-0.8743079900741577,
0.19265207648277283,
-0.8464754819869995,
-0.5635479688644409,
-0.6122806072235107,
0.39739274978637695,
-0.6820599436759949,
0.8519413471221924,
-0.4305291771888733,
-0.8940169811248779,
0.3565802574157715,
-0.5285770893096924,
-0.5448256731033325,
-0.237540602684021,
-0.3982507586479187,
-0.11871423572301865,
0.23467037081718445,
0.06254298985004425,
0.6278083920478821,
-0.19894492626190186,
0.1298750340938568,
-0.34471601247787476,
0.0076597100123763084,
0.4607338309288025,
-0.5949004292488098,
1.046530842781067,
0.07056081295013428,
-0.22449342906475067,
-0.13747723400592804,
-0.8630871772766113,
-0.3113466501235962,
0.3068053424358368,
-0.41735994815826416,
-0.5433188080787659,
0.20123346149921417,
-0.3646486699581146,
0.5032469630241394,
0.2500266432762146,
-0.6339706182479858,
0.15918844938278198,
0.1453535407781601,
-0.0763159692287445,
0.6064596772193909,
0.011087262071669102,
0.36968427896499634,
-0.16122128069400787,
-0.024506717920303345,
0.3558620512485504,
-0.18038691580295563,
-0.12647566199302673,
-0.6077049374580383,
-1.1435705423355103,
0.0019892212003469467,
0.2878192663192749,
0.5128703713417053,
-0.6589259505271912,
-0.2271183878183365,
-0.36970898509025574,
-0.48254531621932983,
-0.5527607798576355,
0.25381365418434143,
0.03496099263429642,
0.5753645300865173,
0.4111870527267456,
0.0939699113368988,
-0.24730871617794037,
-1.1205683946609497,
-0.0460604764521122,
-0.22422374784946442,
0.3993786871433258,
0.3123875558376312,
0.4950093924999237,
-0.12540006637573242,
0.9742636680603027,
-0.3519318997859955,
0.06545497477054596,
-0.3412744700908661,
0.4931837320327759,
0.2561344802379608,
0.3387850224971771,
0.7116532325744629,
-0.8931363224983215,
-0.4611436426639557,
0.28000015020370483,
-0.9557099938392639,
0.07357773929834366,
-0.2621971070766449,
-0.019174983724951744,
0.38762354850769043,
0.3978191316127777,
-0.934205174446106,
0.1282375007867813,
0.6408742070198059,
-0.1514073759317398,
0.6954910159111023,
-0.3265390694141388,
0.015154466032981873,
-0.8981556296348572,
0.34380102157592773,
-0.1979053020477295,
-0.2783176898956299,
-0.7049216032028198,
-0.052675165235996246,
0.21355561912059784,
0.21048013865947723,
-0.28756076097488403,
0.4598811864852905,
-0.7996618151664734,
-0.2475011944770813,
-0.11874737590551376,
0.22389435768127441,
-0.030605576932430267,
0.6848921775817871,
0.2309391349554062,
0.6318812966346741,
0.6622419953346252,
-0.992325484752655,
0.44265130162239075,
-0.1736707240343094,
-0.5919983983039856,
0.3616322875022888,
-0.36368775367736816,
0.14519484341144562,
-0.3412306010723114,
-0.3225066661834717,
-0.8552600145339966,
0.22396740317344666,
0.22458483278751373,
-0.3797639310359955,
0.44600000977516174,
-0.3686523735523224,
-0.5415130257606506,
0.23980320990085602,
0.3077627420425415,
0.22335433959960938,
0.29618996381759644,
-0.5921759009361267,
0.6990299820899963,
0.5627520084381104,
-0.4916624128818512,
-0.8652372360229492,
-0.6224240064620972,
-0.0021020998246967793,
-0.07877626270055771,
-0.6803834438323975,
0.08484549820423126,
0.05925588682293892,
-0.48984625935554504,
0.16482874751091003,
-0.004981404636055231,
-0.10148550570011139,
0.041257359087467194,
-0.10163284838199615,
0.13155466318130493,
-0.5404000282287598,
0.525841474533081,
-0.20551371574401855,
0.13071556389331818,
0.4606160521507263,
-0.07041499763727188,
0.4177778959274292,
0.05191180482506752,
-0.5101578235626221,
0.09170947968959808,
0.388305127620697,
0.5725792050361633,
-0.14800284802913666,
1.099428653717041,
0.7378013730049133,
-0.3260575830936432,
-0.37175071239471436,
-0.49998921155929565,
-0.14302650094032288,
-0.3287874758243561,
0.2548770308494568,
-0.5744786262512207,
-0.6368336081504822,
0.6852557063102722,
-0.07798705250024796,
0.14646859467029572,
0.555745542049408,
0.7168964147567749,
-0.1606181263923645,
0.7350156307220459,
0.8585231900215149,
-0.11035145074129105,
0.06006806343793869,
-0.14855332672595978,
0.17342373728752136,
-0.2823529541492462,
-0.5466737151145935,
-0.5447785258293152,
-0.15056978166103363,
-0.517234742641449,
-0.5748672485351562,
0.3771410584449768,
0.2734626829624176,
0.015308390371501446,
0.17593234777450562,
0.29979637265205383,
0.33019840717315674,
0.5779250860214233,
-0.045191992074251175,
0.4197530448436737,
0.2110602855682373,
-0.6009092330932617,
-0.03917792811989784,
-1.025774598121643,
-0.35756710171699524,
0.7846055626869202,
0.47812753915786743,
0.6771366596221924,
0.5514769554138184,
0.42079222202301025,
0.17518115043640137,
0.4182426929473877,
-0.8421059846878052,
0.3554970622062683,
0.10687032341957092,
-0.9445827603340149,
-0.024613363668322563,
-0.6023745536804199,
-0.7130823731422424,
0.3662015497684479,
-0.2109663039445877,
-0.6893724799156189,
0.5738564133644104,
-0.062462933361530304,
-0.2581547200679779,
0.4079343378543854,
-0.696672797203064,
0.8414884805679321,
-0.4480653703212738,
-0.5350692272186279,
-0.37520328164100647,
-0.704602062702179,
0.46072569489479065,
-0.12682440876960754,
0.5547929406166077,
-0.0874074324965477,
0.32469379901885986,
0.6817346215248108,
0.044056765735149384,
1.0077004432678223,
-0.10897032171487808,
-0.5662559270858765,
0.4071804881095886,
0.4025381803512573,
0.356062650680542,
0.07558901607990265,
0.15593880414962769,
0.3194642961025238,
-0.08208364993333817,
-0.31877484917640686,
-0.5710683465003967,
0.7100913524627686,
-0.9443705081939697,
-0.570662796497345,
-0.658636212348938,
-0.48651689291000366,
-0.2624909281730652,
0.2028750479221344,
0.05400010198354721,
0.3139583170413971,
-0.3409634530544281,
0.16624198853969574,
0.8250324726104736,
-0.1750577837228775,
0.6462734937667847,
0.9619254469871521,
-0.4183332622051239,
0.11068940162658691,
1.1261094808578491,
0.3546803295612335,
0.2577355206012726,
0.46262824535369873,
0.08141857385635376,
-0.4975607693195343,
-0.28676408529281616,
-0.5657606720924377,
0.3734630346298218,
-1.211829423904419,
0.07750645279884338,
-0.6502024531364441,
-0.2781708538532257,
-0.3321208357810974,
0.45698049664497375,
-0.4818248152732849,
-0.4973559081554413,
-0.23731648921966553,
-0.33855903148651123,
0.3629361689090729,
0.9836893081665039,
-0.49565237760543823,
-0.11624114960432053,
-1.0358831882476807,
0.2690593898296356,
0.436796098947525,
0.10509512573480606,
-0.05164935067296028,
-0.38018056750297546,
-0.5599304437637329,
0.17589427530765533,
0.1657743602991104,
-1.165894627571106,
0.2542097866535187,
0.18285983800888062,
0.8644929528236389,
0.3580189347267151,
-0.16710010170936584,
0.5470543503761292,
-0.6180317997932434,
0.6997873783111572,
0.1261858344078064,
-0.7013227343559265,
-0.04016198590397835,
0.14266419410705566,
-0.009686724282801151,
0.21047832071781158,
0.9684925675392151,
-0.8431536555290222,
0.26665812730789185,
-0.31629976630210876,
-0.47394925355911255,
0.795061469078064,
-0.03790438920259476,
0.20152972638607025,
0.07822593301534653,
0.18099765479564667,
0.27347129583358765,
0.09951337426900864,
-1.0277591943740845,
-0.5578770041465759,
-0.09698591381311417,
0.15148143470287323,
-0.3817545473575592,
-0.38997218012809753,
-0.45717838406562805,
-0.12852659821510315,
0.573830783367157,
-0.3071805238723755,
0.2535822093486786,
0.24299204349517822,
-0.6215883493423462,
0.08199251443147659,
0.35660940408706665,
0.8056491017341614,
0.804583728313446,
-0.12936069071292877,
0.7059828042984009,
0.12432902306318283,
-0.12715497612953186,
0.10934426635503769,
0.026636198163032532,
-0.13991980254650116,
0.5258082151412964,
0.5501465201377869,
1.0935890674591064,
0.15597708523273468,
-0.3316971957683563,
0.4575752317905426,
0.06302434951066971,
0.0984620675444603,
-0.1132093071937561,
-0.1786089539527893,
0.4736575186252594,
0.03998972102999687,
0.4575709104537964,
0.15585798025131226,
-0.1367763727903366,
-0.7382926344871521,
0.3414125442504883,
0.2270011156797409,
-0.2092750519514084,
-0.6165362596511841,
-0.07119855284690857,
0.022786226123571396,
0.09872068464756012,
0.6435062289237976,
-0.10051553696393967,
-0.6594284176826477,
0.34896352887153625,
0.6812574863433838,
0.4429066479206085,
-0.14687266945838928,
0.428263783454895,
0.524773120880127,
0.4422909617424011,
0.07239169627428055,
0.32576632499694824,
-0.15250813961029053,
-1.188704490661621,
-0.5596263408660889,
-0.5138005018234253,
-0.1579148769378662,
-0.09826663136482239,
-0.620084285736084,
0.22170747816562653,
-0.22450725734233856,
-0.014069342985749245,
0.001387083437293768,
-0.18055085837841034,
-0.718047022819519,
0.09217385947704315,
0.5499960780143738,
0.9623821973800659,
-0.8464341759681702,
1.0163315534591675,
0.458590567111969,
-0.5062593221664429,
-0.8193762898445129,
-0.22401577234268188,
-0.026258768513798714,
-1.090701699256897,
1.2083021402359009,
-0.06967215985059738,
-0.3327992856502533,
-0.19850948452949524,
-0.5112951993942261,
-1.0202594995498657,
0.6290884613990784,
0.5206666588783264,
-0.46402594447135925,
-0.04936245083808899,
0.2861379384994507,
0.4016055762767792,
-0.31348469853401184,
0.06799839437007904,
0.38925623893737793,
0.462810218334198,
-0.014692690223455429,
-0.7030748128890991,
0.010972504504024982,
-0.1702972799539566,
-0.48192864656448364,
-0.10042592883110046,
-0.44436150789260864,
1.1563706398010254,
-0.6114677786827087,
-0.5194681882858276,
-0.4405689835548401,
0.6600915789604187,
0.2148042768239975,
0.16443340480327606,
0.27035635709762573,
0.4057273864746094,
0.8389917016029358,
-0.0918242558836937,
1.0542221069335938,
-0.41581836342811584,
0.5204523205757141,
0.9972221851348877,
-0.19012528657913208,
0.7780112028121948,
0.6910784244537354,
0.09364940226078033,
0.893246591091156,
0.42166373133659363,
0.11163526028394699,
0.49753472208976746,
0.04292209446430206,
-0.33093613386154175,
-0.2975398898124695,
-0.1272670179605484,
-0.35335513949394226,
0.542534351348877,
0.45236703753471375,
-0.3265981376171112,
-0.3477623462677002,
-0.2619516849517822,
0.33129188418388367,
-0.23708859086036682,
-0.310613214969635,
0.8343926072120667,
0.1714656949043274,
-0.7749528884887695,
0.6715303659439087,
0.05790320411324501,
0.3071415424346924,
-0.8808861374855042,
-0.13906025886535645,
-0.2647264003753662,
0.10827026516199112,
-0.10270260274410248,
-0.865564227104187,
0.24728956818580627,
-0.0081388670951128,
-0.389075368642807,
-0.32501181960105896,
0.7898257374763489,
-0.7003694176673889,
-0.4312785565853119,
0.6092354655265808,
0.9053723216056824,
0.14812639355659485,
0.24290738999843597,
-0.6436243653297424,
0.00033607298973947763,
-0.12122046947479248,
-0.15665708482265472,
0.2177276313304901,
0.6952117681503296,
0.00039970874786376953,
0.6103720664978027,
0.7525681257247925,
0.18251951038837433,
0.5305050611495972,
0.12192600220441818,
0.5540394186973572,
-0.6551039218902588,
-0.27207833528518677,
-1.035415530204773,
0.3806544244289398,
0.09149821847677231,
-0.12978847324848175,
1.013800024986267,
0.3355054259300232,
0.8851516246795654,
-0.14085303246974945,
0.7112314105033875,
-0.1997988373041153,
0.3871059715747833,
-0.6984946727752686,
0.9619279503822327,
-0.6202284097671509,
0.013942672871053219,
0.1689845472574234,
-0.5301661491394043,
-0.04435334727168083,
0.6418470740318298,
-0.12671595811843872,
-0.16425193846225739,
0.6575296521186829,
0.5761621594429016,
-0.08234348893165588,
-0.1638060063123703,
0.2937893867492676,
0.504934549331665,
0.14431533217430115,
0.3202272355556488,
0.9703236818313599,
-0.22710742056369781,
0.49937355518341064,
-0.4616508483886719,
0.044320832937955856,
-0.09392061084508896,
-0.8689001798629761,
-0.5803076028823853,
-0.5473562479019165,
-0.25546738505363464,
-0.20593143999576569,
-0.12492678314447403,
0.9345531463623047,
0.830186128616333,
-0.9848010540008545,
-0.5414053201675415,
0.18973110616207123,
0.582050621509552,
-0.19746249914169312,
-0.21856795251369476,
0.4132394790649414,
-0.773210883140564,
-0.4903692603111267,
0.6162872910499573,
0.09036857634782791,
0.042905617505311966,
-0.38826054334640503,
-0.1975213587284088,
-0.7670933604240417,
0.06984244287014008,
0.6811439394950867,
0.4314572513103485,
-0.45584505796432495,
-0.3593926429748535,
0.2079019695520401,
-0.44763243198394775,
0.16751304268836975,
1.0224146842956543,
-0.5960598587989807,
0.4754231870174408,
0.6720179319381714,
0.7501358985900879,
0.3651610314846039,
-0.41850316524505615,
0.7307358980178833,
-1.0543683767318726,
0.05972490832209587,
-0.016676591709256172,
0.6547013521194458,
0.5878274440765381,
-0.17482978105545044,
0.09703709185123444,
0.7016114592552185,
-0.1922362744808197,
-0.7402035593986511,
0.20097953081130981,
-0.7639726400375366,
-0.5363039374351501,
1.0882562398910522,
-0.3742539882659912,
-0.1485876739025116,
-0.14675487577915192,
0.03162273019552231,
0.3643164038658142,
0.09160345792770386,
0.6230978965759277,
1.0460830926895142,
-0.06382527947425842,
-0.48675939440727234,
-0.3410545289516449,
0.666937530040741,
0.29145362973213196,
-0.5210577249526978,
-0.017840590327978134,
0.38332170248031616,
0.6255592703819275,
0.7614033222198486,
0.3467711806297302,
-0.03648832440376282,
0.10828626900911331,
0.026070892810821533,
0.1972532719373703,
0.08024602383375168,
-0.7371093034744263,
-0.18966132402420044,
0.48866763710975647,
0.011455094441771507,
-0.12435714900493622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05188v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05188v1
|
CommitBench: A Benchmark for Commit Message Generation
| 2024-03-08T09:56:45 | 2024-03-08T09:56:45 |
Maximilian Schall, Tamara Czinczoll, Gerard de Melo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SE
|
Writing commit messages is a tedious daily task for many software developers,
and often remains neglected. Automating this task has the potential to save
time while ensuring that messages are informative. A high-quality dataset and
an objective benchmark are vital preconditions for solid research and
evaluation towards this goal. We show that existing datasets exhibit various
problems, such as the quality of the commit selection, small sample sizes,
duplicates, privacy issues, and missing licenses for redistribution. This can
lead to unusable models and skewed evaluations, where inferior models achieve
higher evaluation scores due to biases in the data. We compile a new
large-scale dataset, CommitBench, adopting best practices for dataset creation.
We sample commits from diverse projects with licenses that permit
redistribution and apply our filtering and dataset enhancements to improve the
quality of generated commit messages. We use CommitBench to compare existing
models and show that other approaches are outperformed by a Transformer model
pretrained on source code. We hope to accelerate future research by publishing
the source code( https://github.com/Maxscha/commitbench ).
|
[
-0.29659491777420044,
-0.14775480329990387,
0.2763351500034332,
0.17454376816749573,
-0.22251294553279877,
-0.07423757016658783,
-0.18637049198150635,
-0.11380067467689514,
0.05058284476399422,
0.7438001036643982,
-0.5496203303337097,
-0.6975257992744446,
-0.46600764989852905,
-0.1514068841934204,
-0.8094342947006226,
1.2602468729019165,
-0.0828373059630394,
-0.1484869420528412,
-0.3719281256198883,
-0.3954196572303772,
-0.7750899791717529,
-0.22883181273937225,
-0.13991235196590424,
-0.1474154144525528,
0.11908750236034393,
0.37686771154403687,
0.6271992921829224,
0.8361838459968567,
1.0503029823303223,
0.2015029788017273,
0.0317082516849041,
-0.33479782938957214,
-0.7946157455444336,
0.3020102381706238,
-0.23431511223316193,
-0.3856327533721924,
-0.20742574334144592,
0.19092106819152832,
0.5328696370124817,
0.5887000560760498,
-0.268059641122818,
0.4579927325248718,
-0.15239454805850983,
0.9209277033805847,
-0.877234160900116,
0.06968314945697784,
-0.4311215877532959,
0.10348188132047653,
-0.42339155077934265,
0.5123522281646729,
-0.4999103546142578,
-0.9773937463760376,
-0.183608740568161,
-0.4404488503932953,
0.3492158055305481,
-0.04479319602251053,
0.720067024230957,
0.28395143151283264,
-0.3698367476463318,
-0.2975265681743622,
-0.8604795932769775,
0.5115804672241211,
-0.6689600944519043,
0.3542262017726898,
0.027877533808350563,
0.6500797271728516,
-0.18215438723564148,
-0.6240978240966797,
-0.025046920403838158,
-0.3823648989200592,
-0.01180348638445139,
0.06596135348081589,
-0.055912863463163376,
-0.37533435225486755,
0.3925844430923462,
0.6604137420654297,
-0.7306137084960938,
-0.021545156836509705,
-0.43512654304504395,
-0.441419392824173,
0.6761595606803894,
0.33262744545936584,
-0.23773382604122162,
-0.09848807007074356,
-0.3020159900188446,
-0.6357561349868774,
-0.7937719821929932,
-0.12796108424663544,
0.6376243829727173,
-0.006983315572142601,
-0.04385418817400932,
0.4633693993091583,
-0.10560521483421326,
0.6052423119544983,
-0.02728841081261635,
0.4392014443874359,
0.28047746419906616,
-0.5597982406616211,
0.1618911772966385,
-0.22680991888046265,
0.8141297101974487,
0.4806479513645172,
0.048002440482378006,
-0.3036787509918213,
-0.22909316420555115,
0.5170093178749084,
0.6071260571479797,
-0.8095681071281433,
-0.5445645451545715,
0.2592495083808899,
-0.5418137907981873,
-0.5012050271034241,
0.4417170584201813,
-0.8983840942382812,
-0.5516660213470459,
-0.19745774567127228,
-0.03135189041495323,
-0.3514024615287781,
-0.34540846943855286,
-0.15401658415794373,
-0.1881502866744995,
0.10937196761369705,
0.13500137627124786,
-0.23532722890377045,
0.16955670714378357,
0.7588807344436646,
0.5123307108879089,
-0.48883509635925293,
-0.3193182945251465,
-0.5179615616798401,
0.2982722222805023,
-0.6090735197067261,
0.6962680816650391,
-0.31033608317375183,
-0.44847768545150757,
-0.04500427469611168,
-0.08779985457658768,
0.4140467941761017,
-0.7924848794937134,
0.4741944372653961,
-0.3032005727291107,
-0.06567967683076859,
-0.21179157495498657,
-0.8332768678665161,
0.13319598138332367,
0.10196954756975174,
-0.9337306618690491,
0.8518375158309937,
0.7151458263397217,
-0.2273772805929184,
0.5531395673751831,
-0.38541871309280396,
-0.42794179916381836,
-0.016809705644845963,
0.007741284091025591,
-0.5699308514595032,
0.22250519692897797,
-0.06547408550977707,
0.17737413942813873,
-0.7006005048751831,
0.46617892384529114,
-0.17943713068962097,
-0.10012292861938477,
0.4590909481048584,
-0.10471773892641068,
0.5369413495063782,
0.4204949736595154,
-0.5419532060623169,
0.10466484725475311,
-0.5832192897796631,
0.0973813533782959,
0.06565913558006287,
-0.13663676381111145,
0.10348593443632126,
0.0033022556453943253,
-0.002111208625137806,
0.13068516552448273,
0.1079113781452179,
-0.6139660477638245,
0.1760973483324051,
-0.04412798956036568,
0.3141500651836395,
0.7554798722267151,
0.059441305696964264,
0.38679125905036926,
-0.3229290843009949,
0.3190813958644867,
0.23637470602989197,
0.5485533475875854,
-0.17363834381103516,
0.043670833110809326,
-0.4573800265789032,
0.23533272743225098,
0.6117188930511475,
0.32479578256607056,
-0.2549099028110504,
0.39164668321609497,
-0.4960167706012726,
-0.8888901472091675,
-0.3507852852344513,
0.4056422710418701,
0.6750493049621582,
0.2510465085506439,
0.10257941484451294,
-0.764820396900177,
-0.35416650772094727,
-0.9092943072319031,
-0.3928661644458771,
-0.16477401554584503,
0.0757456123828888,
0.19030076265335083,
0.44703665375709534,
-0.08953550457954407,
0.8912177085876465,
-0.9535070061683655,
-0.35452938079833984,
-0.012109608389437199,
0.12499087303876877,
0.033243000507354736,
0.5438326597213745,
0.5739027857780457,
-0.6809831857681274,
-0.2699800729751587,
-0.4498520791530609,
-0.7073100209236145,
-0.007731878198683262,
-0.1849873661994934,
-0.4210001528263092,
-0.041651684790849686,
0.6017534732818604,
-0.35904818773269653,
0.2504768371582031,
0.6141875386238098,
-0.30161985754966736,
0.5277624726295471,
-0.06594421714544296,
0.36530745029449463,
-0.8923746943473816,
0.06908167898654938,
-0.15404434502124786,
-0.30616527795791626,
-0.29566699266433716,
0.1526583880186081,
0.3894098997116089,
-0.5338888764381409,
-0.39866092801094055,
-0.04153306782245636,
-0.43300706148147583,
-0.2224312275648117,
-0.05362320691347122,
0.18963997066020966,
-0.12803462147712708,
0.036227140575647354,
-0.4557936191558838,
0.6888267993927002,
0.17808887362480164,
-0.48000189661979675,
0.4623880982398987,
0.5120382905006409,
-0.5542633533477783,
0.6988083124160767,
-0.7961447834968567,
0.26898691058158875,
0.15193532407283783,
0.3756903111934662,
-0.7010722756385803,
-0.34519681334495544,
0.1229172945022583,
-0.3786773979663849,
0.1387346386909485,
-0.21600089967250824,
-0.4721922278404236,
-0.702143132686615,
-0.26338914036750793,
0.040649719536304474,
0.5834676623344421,
-0.2778240740299225,
0.02900976873934269,
0.6174311637878418,
0.2803315222263336,
-0.04164597764611244,
-0.6950277090072632,
0.07656921446323395,
0.052951913326978683,
-0.49694502353668213,
0.22495795786380768,
-0.04167565330862999,
0.09863050282001495,
0.14870579540729523,
-0.15325462818145752,
-0.025034049525856972,
-0.08784134685993195,
0.5206605792045593,
0.13099797070026398,
-0.15860843658447266,
0.03662900999188423,
-0.2142282873392105,
-0.41344374418258667,
0.2319517582654953,
-0.229885071516037,
0.3025605380535126,
0.03615745157003403,
-0.646172821521759,
-0.05349535867571831,
0.1818983256816864,
0.8123607635498047,
-0.35192692279815674,
0.6175548434257507,
0.1679953634738922,
-0.03720274195075035,
-0.2263898104429245,
-0.632760226726532,
-0.3900524377822876,
-0.3871360421180725,
0.12952059507369995,
0.052105922251939774,
-0.6984756588935852,
0.42288392782211304,
-0.43145209550857544,
0.3510418236255646,
0.3898735046386719,
0.3220883905887604,
0.05165696144104004,
0.6709574460983276,
0.390717476606369,
-0.2768042981624603,
0.5725192427635193,
-0.2144676148891449,
0.05096274986863136,
-0.5800828337669373,
0.1689758449792862,
-0.7477372288703918,
-0.21405117213726044,
-0.5119925141334534,
-0.47438880801200867,
0.2040254771709442,
0.0942932739853859,
-0.25946810841560364,
0.9033689498901367,
-0.9144402742385864,
0.5429219007492065,
0.43972158432006836,
-0.1293310523033142,
0.03723957762122154,
-0.4338340759277344,
0.31378185749053955,
0.015855014324188232,
-0.28554683923721313,
-0.5572975277900696,
1.403310775756836,
-0.13566358387470245,
0.7660585045814514,
0.0722593143582344,
0.8038578033447266,
0.45530301332473755,
0.5040773153305054,
0.01391442772001028,
0.4845951497554779,
-0.21813717484474182,
-0.8645359873771667,
-0.24730917811393738,
-0.7264968156814575,
-1.0046181678771973,
-0.005080889910459518,
-0.03763670101761818,
-0.3857918381690979,
0.06228954717516899,
0.32840973138809204,
0.03955983370542526,
0.08640500158071518,
-0.756791353225708,
1.2057881355285645,
0.1024545207619667,
-0.10185117274522781,
-0.19083449244499207,
-0.585828423500061,
0.3382820188999176,
-0.1291355937719345,
0.2936738133430481,
-0.3783636689186096,
0.24879425764083862,
0.5870212912559509,
-0.5598871111869812,
0.47945308685302734,
-0.5307386517524719,
0.14773081243038177,
0.47781264781951904,
0.3853333592414856,
0.9012773036956787,
0.004594211466610432,
-0.26472505927085876,
-0.027204200625419617,
-0.04589909315109253,
-0.2051381915807724,
-0.4320738613605499,
0.7470744848251343,
-0.645695149898529,
-0.2341105341911316,
-0.018163634464144707,
-0.4670344889163971,
-0.00783402007073164,
0.12479507178068161,
0.43822693824768066,
0.3111915588378906,
-0.5367751121520996,
0.46563664078712463,
0.5524899959564209,
0.06073692813515663,
0.2838992178440094,
0.6854377388954163,
-0.08327516168355942,
-0.5780774354934692,
0.8701229095458984,
0.2522408068180084,
0.25952595472335815,
-0.17832769453525543,
-0.03004823625087738,
0.04520624876022339,
-0.7206421494483948,
-0.4809548258781433,
-0.010184703394770622,
-0.6196078658103943,
-0.6034961342811584,
-0.3595210313796997,
-0.05943743884563446,
-0.4888598322868347,
-0.23943857848644257,
-0.860280454158783,
-0.3945135474205017,
0.03346240147948265,
-0.009230894036591053,
0.4099631607532501,
0.8630298972129822,
0.03228157386183739,
0.20944848656654358,
-1.0540227890014648,
0.43701934814453125,
-0.14922644197940826,
0.6358869671821594,
-0.2709743082523346,
-0.11149308830499649,
-0.3186400830745697,
0.053361810743808746,
-0.5885436534881592,
-1.0426801443099976,
0.03067496046423912,
-0.07067282497882843,
0.6350305080413818,
-0.08264899998903275,
0.5561890602111816,
0.23752185702323914,
-0.29633739590644836,
0.6615152955055237,
-0.0018472865922376513,
-1.1266670227050781,
1.0117744207382202,
-0.3433331251144409,
0.4129466712474823,
1.1049610376358032,
0.03552727401256561,
-0.46367403864860535,
-0.8925616145133972,
-0.6008456349372864,
-0.9310479760169983,
0.7167073488235474,
0.5378150343894958,
-0.003402461763471365,
0.18783357739448547,
0.4722178876399994,
0.16974282264709473,
0.3496597111225128,
-0.615602433681488,
-0.2858002781867981,
-0.26095423102378845,
-0.15999723970890045,
-0.17540952563285828,
0.08018849790096283,
-0.1891363561153412,
0.037128474563360214,
0.6603228449821472,
-0.03531206399202347,
0.08332852274179459,
-0.13814692199230194,
-0.47513923048973083,
-0.20356030762195587,
0.1307605803012848,
0.346402108669281,
0.7141951322555542,
-0.062445081770420074,
-0.2739019989967346,
0.07059064507484436,
-0.649307131767273,
0.42958399653434753,
0.019204387441277504,
-0.39757171273231506,
0.015296812169253826,
0.17305512726306915,
0.6718137860298157,
0.05198598653078079,
-0.3174002766609192,
0.6508538126945496,
-0.04958272725343704,
-0.2518022358417511,
-0.1241346076130867,
0.2779923379421234,
0.21847176551818848,
-0.03398561850190163,
0.073458231985569,
0.026187105104327202,
0.1374393105506897,
-0.24239112436771393,
0.23168401420116425,
0.09972277283668518,
-0.6184422373771667,
-0.08991823345422745,
0.5820547342300415,
0.23107342422008514,
-0.11470063030719757,
0.9084145426750183,
-0.14303654432296753,
-0.19879716634750366,
0.7949137687683105,
0.1407565474510193,
0.8632750511169434,
-0.3157595694065094,
0.3923659026622772,
0.47455501556396484,
0.5012087821960449,
-0.2128315418958664,
0.027212876826524734,
0.09582149237394333,
-0.3176346719264984,
-0.2614787518978119,
-0.34387460350990295,
-0.6631532907485962,
-0.2860323488712311,
-0.9025802612304688,
0.28458741307258606,
-0.2900487184524536,
-0.28443923592567444,
0.14909161627292633,
-0.24735897779464722,
-0.43829545378685,
0.0247965045273304,
-0.32039061188697815,
0.7434695959091187,
-0.9493595957756042,
0.5396357774734497,
0.6002860069274902,
-0.2837827205657959,
-0.5967614650726318,
-0.15913265943527222,
0.14078669250011444,
-0.16265851259231567,
0.177493616938591,
0.1543615162372589,
0.3455316722393036,
-0.24093353748321533,
-0.44914764165878296,
-0.7646462917327881,
0.8430070877075195,
0.6533644795417786,
-0.8331664204597473,
0.30784520506858826,
0.4297342002391815,
0.46471846103668213,
-0.13277043402194977,
0.07103777676820755,
0.5868850350379944,
0.5174890160560608,
-0.09488511830568314,
-0.47125715017318726,
0.21931394934654236,
-0.13648180663585663,
0.14281333982944489,
0.8079802393913269,
-0.6660248041152954,
0.7711283564567566,
0.08751103281974792,
-0.08557160943746567,
-0.26159462332725525,
0.5741053819656372,
0.09191443771123886,
0.06674326211214066,
0.5277614593505859,
0.48415836691856384,
0.5033167600631714,
-0.5127310156822205,
1.1848355531692505,
-0.5206360220909119,
0.48331600427627563,
1.216092586517334,
-0.5609626770019531,
0.5691822171211243,
0.21936091780662537,
-0.253984659910202,
0.4853309392929077,
0.41634678840637207,
-0.40740740299224854,
0.35358986258506775,
0.5596157312393188,
0.18007710576057434,
-0.15225762128829956,
0.03056451492011547,
-0.5367215871810913,
0.10921966284513474,
-0.05131230503320694,
-0.3000737130641937,
-0.2684297263622284,
0.09296192973852158,
-0.2184285819530487,
0.04203393682837486,
0.14544861018657684,
1.0929882526397705,
-0.09660674631595612,
-0.7923579812049866,
0.32040539383888245,
-0.37867432832717896,
0.23655526340007782,
-0.5830858945846558,
0.19476109743118286,
-0.38339099287986755,
0.6741400957107544,
-0.03530992940068245,
-0.8971278071403503,
0.6157692670822144,
-0.0038322184700518847,
-0.3792766034603119,
-0.28660035133361816,
0.5330700278282166,
-0.045637160539627075,
-0.30982083082199097,
0.26705002784729004,
0.08549172431230545,
0.16392281651496887,
-0.14413292706012726,
-0.6561874151229858,
0.4049147367477417,
0.024838581681251526,
-0.4744647443294525,
0.34325334429740906,
0.3954172432422638,
-0.19127361476421356,
0.3561122715473175,
0.6978825926780701,
-0.0018024112796410918,
-0.12348498404026031,
0.03149986267089844,
1.0627888441085815,
-0.6564592123031616,
-0.3219262659549713,
-0.5222729444503784,
0.4405158460140228,
-0.38374820351600647,
-0.4976528584957123,
0.8708458542823792,
0.9182608723640442,
0.7582952380180359,
-0.12248538434505463,
0.47061195969581604,
-0.061323415488004684,
0.5802930593490601,
-0.13499920070171356,
0.7507851123809814,
-0.07210350781679153,
0.12867330014705658,
-0.47887253761291504,
-1.2956730127334595,
-0.10123182088136673,
0.3302666246891022,
0.009690895676612854,
-0.04420062154531479,
0.6228960156440735,
0.8466956615447998,
0.1661185920238495,
0.24177587032318115,
0.07185456901788712,
0.01495605893433094,
0.5219960808753967,
0.6193382740020752,
0.8039328455924988,
-0.790027916431427,
0.9382096529006958,
-0.46938207745552063,
-0.05419674143195152,
-0.17929819226264954,
-1.0015963315963745,
-0.5455336570739746,
-0.5722525119781494,
-0.6808592081069946,
-0.40815067291259766,
0.22401055693626404,
0.4297398626804352,
0.9664769768714905,
-1.0531203746795654,
-0.359711229801178,
-0.5835356712341309,
0.0853537991642952,
-0.14870262145996094,
-0.21278321743011475,
0.040410179644823074,
-0.4066196084022522,
-0.1711607277393341,
0.09341569244861603,
0.02247566543519497,
0.11698224395513535,
-0.2350759208202362,
0.06171662360429764,
0.2808033525943756,
-0.11447121948003769,
0.00625425623729825,
0.07171052694320679,
-0.029076959937810898,
-0.07819001376628876,
-0.05051565542817116,
-0.5326942205429077,
0.11214996874332428,
1.1833215951919556,
-0.5504869222640991,
0.13451506197452545,
0.5106460452079773,
0.3772273361682892,
0.9103257656097412,
-0.1486293375492096,
0.8258889317512512,
-0.5016552209854126,
-0.10371637344360352,
0.3592139482498169,
0.04152826964855194,
0.4246910512447357,
-0.38630610704421997,
0.8748221397399902,
-0.16413195431232452,
-0.7646602988243103,
-0.9808642268180847,
0.1295487880706787,
-0.4343174993991852,
-0.33990684151649475,
0.8396844863891602,
-0.3353893458843231,
-0.2711758315563202,
0.01883147656917572,
-0.20173421502113342,
0.2899532616138458,
-0.38783472776412964,
0.4529995024204254,
0.7066461443901062,
0.22574976086616516,
0.07423575222492218,
-0.40265047550201416,
0.4764294922351837,
0.4145037829875946,
-1.1513593196868896,
0.741529107093811,
0.8599786758422852,
0.11501352488994598,
0.2313990294933319,
0.2880644202232361,
-0.3941044509410858,
0.4915798008441925,
0.30926114320755005,
0.3136684000492096,
-0.04561244696378708,
-0.2354745864868164,
-0.10754808038473129,
0.42853936553001404,
0.0815335065126419,
-0.06220962852239609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05186v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05186v1
|
ROUGE-K: Do Your Summaries Have Keywords?
| 2024-03-08T09:54:56 | 2024-03-08T09:54:56 |
Sotaro Takeshita, Simone Paolo Ponzetto, Kai Eckert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Keywords, that is, content-relevant words in summaries play an important role
in efficient information conveyance, making it critical to assess if
system-generated summaries contain such informative words during evaluation.
However, existing evaluation metrics for extreme summarization models do not
pay explicit attention to keywords in summaries, leaving developers ignorant of
their presence. To address this issue, we present a keyword-oriented evaluation
metric, dubbed ROUGE-K, which provides a quantitative answer to the question of
-- \textit{How well do summaries include keywords?} Through the lens of this
keyword-aware metric, we surprisingly find that a current strong baseline model
often misses essential information in their summaries. Our analysis reveals
that human annotators indeed find the summaries with more keywords to be more
relevant to the source documents. This is an important yet previously
overlooked aspect in evaluating summarization systems. Finally, to enhance
keyword inclusion, we propose four approaches for incorporating word importance
into a transformer-based model and experimentally show that it enables guiding
models to include more keywords while keeping the overall quality. Our code is
released at https://github.com/sobamchan/rougek.
|
[
-0.21486665308475494,
0.01677406206727028,
0.5358765721321106,
0.15799567103385925,
-0.7096045017242432,
0.4746896028518677,
-0.053220853209495544,
-0.023450082167983055,
0.48754799365997314,
0.5752676725387573,
-0.23093707859516144,
-0.6663152575492859,
-0.8822740316390991,
-0.006916229613125324,
-0.5323765873908997,
1.2573798894882202,
0.18504977226257324,
-0.22356091439723969,
-0.11962441354990005,
-0.3824099004268646,
-0.24561651051044464,
-0.4460145831108093,
0.013969743624329567,
-0.34965500235557556,
0.3634248375892639,
0.24458763003349304,
1.001051425933838,
0.7223522067070007,
0.9036423563957214,
0.1791737973690033,
-0.38953694701194763,
0.08989299088716507,
-0.539849042892456,
0.2534432113170624,
-0.034326303750276566,
-0.5154116153717041,
-0.9152535200119019,
0.04116124287247658,
0.5093411803245544,
0.5343084931373596,
0.13352122902870178,
0.4890109598636627,
0.07887933403253555,
0.8842794299125671,
-1.1380201578140259,
0.26342591643333435,
-0.3920876681804657,
-0.05468982458114624,
0.06388679146766663,
-0.138246089220047,
-0.05445697531104088,
-0.25028371810913086,
0.08806780725717545,
-0.46352145075798035,
0.2584359049797058,
-0.36083826422691345,
1.0627490282058716,
0.3033387362957001,
-0.446626752614975,
-0.24531185626983643,
-0.4158490300178528,
0.2668381631374359,
-0.6311725974082947,
0.3904792070388794,
0.3741123676300049,
0.24183812737464905,
0.2575938403606415,
-0.6762939691543579,
-0.5258219242095947,
-0.1603766530752182,
-0.35812270641326904,
0.6843233108520508,
-0.13295824825763702,
0.5265886783599854,
0.019562648609280586,
0.3629598319530487,
-0.3221018314361572,
-0.2516930401325226,
-0.3099415600299835,
-0.3858817517757416,
0.7164883017539978,
0.5989069938659668,
0.22780878841876984,
-0.438459575176239,
0.06686637550592422,
-0.21388886868953705,
-0.6381572484970093,
0.0499066486954689,
0.48840874433517456,
0.17439009249210358,
-0.3296288549900055,
0.6082457900047302,
-0.09839962422847748,
0.4262658655643463,
-0.2528636157512665,
-0.11839423328638077,
0.07405099272727966,
-0.5596144199371338,
0.008420723490417004,
-0.15116342902183533,
0.5677550435066223,
0.7860047221183777,
0.2589116096496582,
-0.49944597482681274,
-0.297095388174057,
-0.02474796026945114,
0.3740910589694977,
-0.6633203029632568,
-0.5096787810325623,
0.2896902561187744,
-0.4941195845603943,
-0.5161837339401245,
0.2942460775375366,
-0.7810350060462952,
-0.7186123728752136,
0.07070843875408173,
0.5799419283866882,
0.043999746441841125,
-0.3855527639389038,
-0.3948056399822235,
-0.8251169919967651,
0.3544931709766388,
0.2673953175544739,
-0.5885071754455566,
0.4348130524158478,
0.8797993659973145,
1.1370171308517456,
-0.1888757199048996,
-0.20530672371387482,
-0.5599345564842224,
-0.10049910098314285,
-0.8702472448348999,
0.7725188732147217,
-0.5846912860870361,
-0.806120753288269,
-0.01706778071820736,
0.10003398358821869,
0.03720450773835182,
-0.6377667784690857,
0.5630111694335938,
-0.5623763799667358,
-0.3272295296192169,
-0.40693485736846924,
-0.5376346707344055,
-0.3701789081096649,
0.01746249571442604,
-0.6738035082817078,
0.627659022808075,
0.3284085988998413,
-0.5644230246543884,
0.5616680979728699,
-0.5202563405036926,
-0.5811195373535156,
0.1929975152015686,
0.1608535349369049,
-0.4110398292541504,
0.48369136452674866,
-0.12795811891555786,
0.3915168344974518,
-0.09272493422031403,
0.13064032793045044,
-0.00038760618190281093,
-0.4825848340988159,
0.26081886887550354,
0.02969677932560444,
0.33818164467811584,
-0.21751248836517334,
-0.056789398193359375,
0.2751098573207855,
-0.3766951858997345,
-0.0417112372815609,
-0.10020095854997635,
-0.26793259382247925,
-0.468801885843277,
-0.11458878219127655,
0.2537378668785095,
-0.07922176271677017,
0.11614836007356644,
-0.09646431356668472,
0.16184349358081818,
-0.2529720664024353,
0.15925909578800201,
0.5679993033409119,
0.07563434541225433,
0.7224311828613281,
-0.18544965982437134,
0.8432645201683044,
-0.1723034381866455,
-0.16459491848945618,
-0.741550087928772,
-0.4654979407787323,
-0.8757642507553101,
-0.23360919952392578,
0.6567413806915283,
0.5209944844245911,
-0.04881398379802704,
0.559877872467041,
-0.6382999420166016,
-0.6737341284751892,
-0.4760730564594269,
0.06969291716814041,
0.39711084961891174,
0.18218199908733368,
0.14281447231769562,
-0.051830824464559555,
-0.33911192417144775,
-0.9932136535644531,
-0.6009209752082825,
-0.10036013275384903,
-0.15601077675819397,
0.15749113261699677,
0.6436956524848938,
-0.06609630584716797,
0.8934330344200134,
-0.7912846803665161,
-0.34836438298225403,
-0.7827655076980591,
0.18104013800621033,
0.06197480112314224,
-0.24827814102172852,
0.38654565811157227,
-0.8415819406509399,
-0.5491605997085571,
-0.13409878313541412,
-0.3981753885746002,
-0.24584411084651947,
-0.23213030397891998,
0.07554154843091965,
-0.4581056535243988,
0.3284521698951721,
-0.7289149761199951,
0.40536850690841675,
0.4205281138420105,
-0.24363447725772858,
0.3080953061580658,
-0.2891959249973297,
0.013486675918102264,
-1.019097924232483,
0.22189843654632568,
-0.267433762550354,
-0.2955493927001953,
-0.645915150642395,
0.31791365146636963,
0.5010029673576355,
-0.15400731563568115,
0.052700866013765335,
0.8864315152168274,
-0.48854291439056396,
-0.018443401902914047,
-0.588186502456665,
0.7914414405822754,
0.1032397598028183,
0.3370465040206909,
-0.061437565833330154,
0.6847629547119141,
0.4712695777416229,
-0.7199626564979553,
0.11805670708417892,
0.04167534410953522,
0.04221348091959953,
0.1883382648229599,
-0.6213787198066711,
-0.04258852079510689,
-0.18870927393436432,
0.33870619535446167,
-1.0682408809661865,
-0.41609567403793335,
0.004501792602241039,
-0.5595176815986633,
0.2810268700122833,
-0.1724318414926529,
-0.5381709933280945,
-0.20708727836608887,
-0.4683659076690674,
-0.09104198217391968,
0.7335962057113647,
-0.24939480423927307,
0.5685798525810242,
0.7775478959083557,
-0.015222104266285896,
-0.5523332953453064,
-0.3243999481201172,
0.39234381914138794,
-0.2969134747982025,
-0.16293324530124664,
0.3617856800556183,
0.3876175582408905,
-0.32177647948265076,
-0.014343314804136753,
-0.4899306297302246,
0.011225521564483643,
0.23193003237247467,
0.4426002502441406,
0.20485468208789825,
0.08925230801105499,
0.25929781794548035,
0.20020239055156708,
-0.27817055583000183,
0.07155855000019073,
-0.04936743527650833,
0.15146367251873016,
-0.058469370007514954,
0.000811504025477916,
-0.12273532152175903,
0.036748386919498444,
0.883226752281189,
-0.28549885749816895,
0.3159405291080475,
0.5428773760795593,
-0.22226440906524658,
-0.11254878342151642,
-0.31874141097068787,
-0.24950328469276428,
-0.3435286283493042,
0.7643513083457947,
0.004552739672362804,
-0.5750503540039062,
0.7273036241531372,
0.010573127306997776,
0.10283525288105011,
0.6402785181999207,
0.20215822756290436,
-0.11621984839439392,
1.0113545656204224,
0.9067491888999939,
-0.12266616523265839,
0.09479725360870361,
-0.47013455629348755,
0.42475926876068115,
-1.1410259008407593,
0.10975844413042068,
-0.3762718439102173,
-0.6265166401863098,
-0.669389009475708,
-0.30125412344932556,
0.4106683135032654,
0.429842472076416,
0.24260728061199188,
0.5288310647010803,
-0.3049165606498718,
0.40686357021331787,
0.1132342666387558,
-0.2044728547334671,
0.3257492184638977,
-0.6723048686981201,
0.20153802633285522,
0.020908409729599953,
-0.44829419255256653,
-0.5560585856437683,
1.2156124114990234,
0.17583850026130676,
0.5463626384735107,
-0.002345642074942589,
0.5367911458015442,
0.4847758412361145,
0.5633171200752258,
-0.9701293110847473,
0.6352298855781555,
-0.20586983859539032,
-0.4131295084953308,
-0.12603110074996948,
-0.03892016410827637,
-0.6490283012390137,
0.28652215003967285,
0.2086150199174881,
-0.6727638840675354,
-0.045370351523160934,
0.032132312655448914,
-0.6649477481842041,
-0.003102281829342246,
-0.4951844811439514,
0.7575291991233826,
-0.10386359691619873,
0.2328234314918518,
-0.359391450881958,
-0.6835166811943054,
0.3562023341655731,
-0.1509273797273636,
0.14421921968460083,
-0.2761669158935547,
-0.7282257676124573,
0.9422056078910828,
-0.5066362619400024,
0.5473006367683411,
-0.08341608941555023,
0.18494465947151184,
0.3549172878265381,
0.1370481252670288,
0.48985928297042847,
0.09213434159755707,
0.4664648473262787,
0.22204478085041046,
-0.18731912970542908,
-0.16414475440979004,
-0.8377360701560974,
0.3442201614379883,
-0.2791791260242462,
-0.5585082173347473,
-0.25604403018951416,
-0.4569685757160187,
0.009404019452631474,
0.00208079069852829,
0.6103556156158447,
0.23160874843597412,
-0.050020087510347366,
0.20003943145275116,
0.39711621403694153,
-0.12084967643022537,
0.5364612936973572,
0.4480392038822174,
-0.23930442333221436,
-0.4161241948604584,
0.8730295300483704,
0.2995697557926178,
0.22378137707710266,
0.619478166103363,
0.521692156791687,
-0.1378219574689865,
-0.36548328399658203,
-0.7113651633262634,
0.30507567524909973,
-0.6696459054946899,
-0.42592334747314453,
-1.096024990081787,
-0.4519616663455963,
-0.25524571537971497,
-0.33675363659858704,
-0.2548002004623413,
-0.6236231327056885,
0.1482401043176651,
-0.22526927292346954,
0.5079980492591858,
0.6448440551757812,
-0.030130580067634583,
0.7743118405342102,
-1.089474081993103,
0.5885191559791565,
0.10269037634134293,
0.21466320753097534,
0.019418952986598015,
-0.8085052967071533,
-0.6404080986976624,
-0.16392235457897186,
-0.404725044965744,
-1.2078320980072021,
0.36309754848480225,
0.37290942668914795,
0.5765256881713867,
0.5171075463294983,
0.10370362550020218,
0.38727548718452454,
-0.12086375802755356,
1.0906263589859009,
-0.02373935654759407,
-0.8035149574279785,
0.5494739413261414,
-0.39174091815948486,
0.6844974756240845,
0.7133424282073975,
0.330741286277771,
-0.668593168258667,
-0.8058103919029236,
-0.8107395172119141,
-0.9744351506233215,
0.468278706073761,
0.2855943441390991,
0.6071508526802063,
0.04680279642343521,
0.15613125264644623,
-0.09390839189291,
0.4500388503074646,
-0.49541160464286804,
-0.3614340126514435,
-0.023380113765597343,
0.13675667345523834,
0.0231158584356308,
-0.2450045496225357,
0.11794549971818924,
0.21177314221858978,
0.43309807777404785,
0.060349904000759125,
-0.09405733644962311,
-0.047992363572120667,
-0.4508841633796692,
0.027905095368623734,
0.257007360458374,
0.5796574950218201,
0.5445600748062134,
-0.2152000516653061,
-0.01616555266082287,
0.202739879488945,
-1.1685124635696411,
-0.09242428094148636,
-0.35350099205970764,
-0.13718150556087494,
0.5433595776557922,
0.7381250858306885,
0.5499721765518188,
0.36079439520835876,
-0.7848820090293884,
0.8381496667861938,
0.12907999753952026,
0.30601048469543457,
0.0799114853143692,
0.18803174793720245,
0.09736809134483337,
-0.15987814962863922,
0.5896111130714417,
0.14492683112621307,
0.36305785179138184,
-0.40850532054901123,
0.1748950183391571,
0.40498149394989014,
-0.6877301931381226,
-0.5581461787223816,
0.4116571247577667,
0.3360007405281067,
-0.5770079493522644,
0.31179675459861755,
-0.3257642388343811,
-1.0781933069229126,
0.7696275115013123,
-0.005815411452203989,
1.6178048849105835,
-0.2727823853492737,
0.20240634679794312,
0.528138279914856,
0.5625249147415161,
0.05792851001024246,
0.06887541711330414,
-0.32138723134994507,
-0.41647496819496155,
-0.21098265051841736,
-0.6163924932479858,
-0.31732627749443054,
0.04148825258016586,
-0.3187466263771057,
0.6852623820304871,
-0.10950008034706116,
-0.330809623003006,
-0.19190998375415802,
-0.24939969182014465,
-0.4061599373817444,
0.07849739491939545,
-0.20938095450401306,
0.8731397986412048,
-0.9123605489730835,
0.14212815463542938,
0.5171987414360046,
-0.4632255434989929,
-0.5978027582168579,
0.48227739334106445,
-0.056502580642700195,
-0.4211009740829468,
0.5925430655479431,
0.0785256177186966,
-0.09304282814264297,
-0.26738274097442627,
-0.05827045068144798,
-0.7033276557922363,
0.9921901822090149,
-0.03802863508462906,
-0.2587352395057678,
-0.2883320152759552,
-0.09381633251905441,
0.7103219032287598,
-0.21596938371658325,
0.4489981532096863,
0.5183886885643005,
0.6545088291168213,
-0.1286202222108841,
-0.9259490370750427,
-0.2949080169200897,
-0.27715036273002625,
-0.33146628737449646,
0.4702751636505127,
-0.6199542880058289,
0.3673325181007385,
-0.7544845938682556,
-0.3137337565422058,
-0.16635090112686157,
0.43121570348739624,
-0.1892784684896469,
0.31378281116485596,
0.23895494639873505,
0.44159165024757385,
0.3207736015319824,
-0.06640975922346115,
1.0606188774108887,
-0.5423853993415833,
0.3409087657928467,
1.2960093021392822,
0.1025094985961914,
0.6155864000320435,
-0.010606280528008938,
-0.29681891202926636,
0.1147914007306099,
0.5489053130149841,
0.10740260034799576,
0.511474072933197,
0.12829716503620148,
0.02496519312262535,
-0.14330251514911652,
-0.04254206642508507,
-0.22824347019195557,
0.7248253226280212,
0.30547186732292175,
-0.6360839009284973,
-0.5338826179504395,
-0.212074413895607,
0.10318566858768463,
-0.09876596182584763,
-0.1921101063489914,
1.0219733715057373,
0.19710007309913635,
-0.5893935561180115,
0.2603369653224945,
-0.011174073442816734,
0.3193528950214386,
-0.8076432943344116,
-0.08461971580982208,
-0.5895425081253052,
-0.1799425482749939,
-0.294516384601593,
-0.788585364818573,
0.3820924460887909,
0.04946853220462799,
0.08812905848026276,
0.14554674923419952,
0.6112024188041687,
-0.1827707439661026,
-0.44733360409736633,
0.293455570936203,
0.6047945618629456,
0.15113846957683563,
-0.39670059084892273,
-0.21065615117549896,
-0.2863578796386719,
-0.3747122287750244,
-0.1297791600227356,
0.24618713557720184,
0.32522568106651306,
-0.017276650294661522,
0.5181995630264282,
0.23962338268756866,
0.4733789563179016,
-0.2795030176639557,
0.23947976529598236,
0.7964949607849121,
-0.48512718081474304,
-0.8091322779655457,
-1.0902104377746582,
0.744921863079071,
-0.20155756175518036,
-0.478922963142395,
0.8915166854858398,
0.809454619884491,
0.24909622967243195,
-0.011949708685278893,
0.9916641712188721,
0.13046328723430634,
0.24875682592391968,
0.02675706520676613,
1.1883230209350586,
-0.5992563962936401,
0.1299288272857666,
-0.7549809217453003,
-1.328383445739746,
-0.20993763208389282,
0.17734944820404053,
-0.14487037062644958,
-0.13614675402641296,
0.557555079460144,
0.5498737692832947,
-0.01512480340898037,
0.011860625818371773,
0.5295566916465759,
0.030926447361707687,
-0.06228197365999222,
-0.06904448568820953,
0.6309381127357483,
-0.6083137392997742,
0.5839768052101135,
-0.12399568408727646,
-0.4574398398399353,
-0.48375681042671204,
-0.8699749112129211,
-0.714961051940918,
-0.8343225121498108,
-0.30874207615852356,
-0.2615772485733032,
0.17673693597316742,
0.5020397305488586,
0.526566743850708,
-0.5638200640678406,
-0.23830361664295197,
0.0756046250462532,
0.442674458026886,
-0.3659454882144928,
-0.2397705316543579,
0.4700843393802643,
-0.3054494559764862,
-0.39033547043800354,
-0.10133931040763855,
0.7451539039611816,
-0.12056110799312592,
-0.2466239482164383,
0.013830549083650112,
0.3315727710723877,
0.2671329975128174,
0.411734014749527,
-0.20748022198677063,
-0.6706677079200745,
0.010714537464082241,
0.4667935371398926,
-0.011356638744473457,
-0.07877837121486664,
1.1303515434265137,
-0.6751028895378113,
0.640192985534668,
0.760741114616394,
0.5960771441459656,
0.16509512066841125,
0.24018193781375885,
0.5241292715072632,
-0.3042755126953125,
-0.30120381712913513,
0.5036159157752991,
0.10536017268896103,
0.21029135584831238,
-0.4515262246131897,
0.5927419066429138,
0.12352235615253448,
-0.4086447060108185,
-0.8624106049537659,
0.08406708389520645,
-0.6819796562194824,
0.041140053421258926,
1.2287635803222656,
-0.11111404746770859,
0.004828868433833122,
-0.10750427842140198,
0.03021874465048313,
0.1935129314661026,
-0.3085634410381317,
0.8823604583740234,
0.8904109001159668,
-0.009644865989685059,
-0.15389728546142578,
-0.5077253580093384,
0.6752473711967468,
-0.014685506001114845,
-0.5864921808242798,
0.5553572177886963,
0.19490210711956024,
0.024043865501880646,
0.5650177597999573,
0.6152845621109009,
-0.053017508238554,
0.5257853269577026,
0.1623106151819229,
-0.21078400313854218,
0.16216975450515747,
-0.4557496905326843,
-0.21926987171173096,
-0.06090210750699043,
-0.10257786512374878,
-0.09808605909347534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05152v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05152v1
|
Towards a Psychology of Machines: Large Language Models Predict Human Memory
| 2024-03-08T08:41:14 | 2024-03-08T08:41:14 |
Markus Huff, Elanur Ulakçı
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) are demonstrating remarkable capabilities across
various tasks despite lacking a foundation in human cognition. This raises the
question: can these models, beyond simply mimicking human language patterns,
offer insights into the mechanisms underlying human cognition? This study
explores the ability of ChatGPT to predict human performance in a
language-based memory task. Building upon theories of text comprehension, we
hypothesize that recognizing ambiguous sentences (e.g., "Because Bill drinks
wine is never kept in the house") is facilitated by preceding them with
contextually relevant information. Participants, both human and ChatGPT, were
presented with pairs of sentences. The second sentence was always a garden-path
sentence designed to be inherently ambiguous, while the first sentence either
provided a fitting (e.g., "Bill has chronic alcoholism") or an unfitting
context (e.g., "Bill likes to play golf"). We measured both human's and
ChatGPT's ratings of sentence relatedness, ChatGPT's memorability ratings for
the garden-path sentences, and humans' spontaneous memory for the garden-path
sentences. The results revealed a striking alignment between ChatGPT's
assessments and human performance. Sentences deemed more related and assessed
as being more memorable by ChatGPT were indeed better remembered by humans,
even though ChatGPT's internal mechanisms likely differ significantly from
human cognition. This finding, which was confirmed with a robustness check
employing synonyms, underscores the potential of generative AI models to
predict human performance accurately. We discuss the broader implications of
these findings for leveraging LLMs in the development of psychological theories
and for gaining a deeper understanding of human cognition.
|
[
-0.2642260193824768,
-0.8706445097923279,
0.7317259311676025,
0.05318679288029671,
-0.02242228016257286,
0.057777971029281616,
-0.3853379189968109,
-0.47045546770095825,
-0.11675368994474411,
0.32313272356987,
-0.5790086984634399,
-0.024402275681495667,
-0.4462420344352722,
-0.04437348246574402,
-0.38533690571784973,
0.7797245979309082,
0.05671488493680954,
-0.01089373417198658,
-0.397612601518631,
0.10388106852769852,
-0.7466942071914673,
-0.8311021327972412,
-0.6062908172607422,
-0.8558840155601501,
0.4926607310771942,
0.007138833869248629,
0.764336884021759,
0.47891679406166077,
0.4197368323802948,
0.2968350946903229,
-0.05778581649065018,
-0.12482563406229019,
-0.5039032101631165,
0.2771041989326477,
-0.1651155799627304,
-0.9074767231941223,
-0.23753109574317932,
0.061033301055431366,
0.47390517592430115,
0.6739972233772278,
-0.1600087732076645,
-0.22336933016777039,
0.2931545674800873,
0.7977196574211121,
-0.3690592050552368,
0.44042590260505676,
-0.8547632694244385,
0.09506908059120178,
-0.10666438192129135,
-0.3670085072517395,
-0.43555086851119995,
0.03839357569813728,
0.2929651141166687,
-0.4036104083061218,
0.3135967552661896,
0.31850817799568176,
0.7520363926887512,
0.27563318610191345,
-0.32797548174858093,
-0.3919787108898163,
-0.7131519317626953,
0.48927760124206543,
-0.27312514185905457,
0.3644571304321289,
0.6902788877487183,
0.19003435969352722,
-0.44842326641082764,
-0.403068870306015,
-0.5656278133392334,
-0.6162108778953552,
-0.3276614844799042,
0.2283792793750763,
-0.1295289695262909,
0.2066938430070877,
0.5057811737060547,
0.3275999128818512,
-0.7012573480606079,
-0.09774809330701828,
-0.31060588359832764,
-0.22860726714134216,
0.35098111629486084,
0.4019022583961487,
0.5123310685157776,
-0.06998342275619507,
-0.2242041975259781,
-0.05580892041325569,
-0.48668980598449707,
0.08631027489900589,
0.04698693007230759,
0.09307585656642914,
-0.04260692372918129,
0.6776725053787231,
-0.045589786022901535,
0.50188809633255,
-0.25885432958602905,
0.06931231915950775,
0.01692609302699566,
0.03258243948221207,
-0.11694993823766708,
0.04222215339541435,
0.7617341876029968,
0.18876726925373077,
0.7494229078292847,
-0.4904860556125641,
-0.16908830404281616,
0.5610226392745972,
0.29166945815086365,
-0.6916794776916504,
-0.6601146459579468,
-0.10635323822498322,
-0.4270613193511963,
-0.00859956257045269,
0.04172705486416817,
-0.4625658392906189,
-0.45384693145751953,
-0.3176610469818115,
0.37239423394203186,
-0.7762959003448486,
-0.050369132310152054,
0.07695775479078293,
-0.2854402959346771,
0.06997822970151901,
0.0815105140209198,
-0.9477552771568298,
0.45026060938835144,
0.744867205619812,
0.8389989733695984,
-0.10691745579242706,
-0.6304476261138916,
-0.2999556362628937,
0.19240790605545044,
-0.26101499795913696,
0.8255458474159241,
-0.6053795218467712,
-0.31401193141937256,
-0.14234064519405365,
-0.20653411746025085,
-0.2710804045200348,
-0.5148342847824097,
0.40349623560905457,
-0.6024894118309021,
0.37309521436691284,
-0.26204535365104675,
-0.7341787219047546,
-0.2788524031639099,
0.3430340886116028,
-0.594776451587677,
0.8108564019203186,
-0.090025894343853,
-0.825571596622467,
0.3159535229206085,
-0.6224980354309082,
-0.5904918909072876,
-0.10505150258541107,
-0.38156986236572266,
-0.26894986629486084,
0.09648869931697845,
-0.028088554739952087,
0.48594167828559875,
-0.26696738600730896,
0.39699307084083557,
-0.27087873220443726,
-0.6069073677062988,
0.8155115246772766,
-0.7768391966819763,
0.5530606508255005,
-0.058079734444618225,
-0.20701511204242706,
-0.15128381550312042,
-0.43916890025138855,
-0.15171033143997192,
0.1007472574710846,
-0.5030185580253601,
-0.1878354847431183,
0.29248297214508057,
-0.11267297714948654,
0.1972571164369583,
0.1382056027650833,
-0.25163501501083374,
0.0883779227733612,
-0.3116907477378845,
0.6604292988777161,
0.7772637009620667,
-0.06250311434268951,
0.30405762791633606,
-0.6793704628944397,
0.5033851861953735,
-0.07595725357532501,
-0.2742265462875366,
-0.5007155537605286,
-0.6214569211006165,
-0.5491757988929749,
-0.16818083822727203,
0.017371034249663353,
0.8403868079185486,
-0.20885388553142548,
0.2079004943370819,
-0.24510084092617035,
-0.2566937804222107,
-0.06908052414655685,
0.11962885409593582,
0.31960397958755493,
0.3371589183807373,
0.15777122974395752,
-0.44811877608299255,
-0.5450551509857178,
-0.817262589931488,
-0.5620060563087463,
-0.5459229350090027,
-0.27171358466148376,
0.6155223846435547,
0.3934177756309509,
-0.30936163663864136,
0.9641703367233276,
-0.6059277653694153,
-0.23217521607875824,
-0.09418296813964844,
0.14239294826984406,
0.1364135891199112,
0.1822272539138794,
0.12512004375457764,
-0.7070783972740173,
-0.13401417434215546,
-0.05034366622567177,
-0.6247690916061401,
0.1640833169221878,
-0.22190827131271362,
0.06761949509382248,
0.10468635708093643,
0.46329227089881897,
-1.0209749937057495,
0.29436856508255005,
0.31749600172042847,
-0.4965492784976959,
0.49569323658943176,
-0.5314052104949951,
-0.009419599547982216,
-0.8979589343070984,
0.0577225387096405,
-0.08293581753969193,
-0.0054790908470749855,
-0.3390510678291321,
-0.4825167953968048,
-0.08618687838315964,
-0.09284564107656479,
0.08412882685661316,
0.46186333894729614,
-0.44302985072135925,
-0.25518500804901123,
-0.1831614375114441,
0.09539400041103363,
-0.17474767565727234,
0.51617032289505,
-0.056108348071575165,
0.9232590198516846,
0.5481266379356384,
-0.5281432271003723,
0.15688292682170868,
0.07070537656545639,
-0.4019829332828522,
0.41440045833587646,
-0.4447672367095947,
0.1289205700159073,
-0.37735748291015625,
0.34638309478759766,
-1.2842758893966675,
-0.3625904619693756,
0.016946284100413322,
-0.6594094038009644,
0.2710611820220947,
0.28813645243644714,
-0.5186977386474609,
-0.20029985904693604,
0.24866057932376862,
0.21223221719264984,
0.8111989498138428,
-0.17207157611846924,
0.5954158306121826,
0.23934406042099,
0.03316338360309601,
-0.13672202825546265,
-0.7417194843292236,
0.1796911507844925,
-0.3856937289237976,
-0.5510803461074829,
0.2944572865962982,
0.025844095274806023,
-0.4108370542526245,
-0.012561572715640068,
-0.0027251741848886013,
-0.15198907256126404,
0.24135874211788177,
0.6094833016395569,
0.45639488101005554,
-0.2941369414329529,
0.5972424745559692,
-0.6139177083969116,
-0.019847407937049866,
0.2487831562757492,
-0.311421662569046,
0.7234907746315002,
-0.30583661794662476,
-0.10316810011863708,
-0.4482247829437256,
0.08136693388223648,
0.5575535297393799,
-0.1098596528172493,
0.6920127272605896,
0.5504344701766968,
-0.24113483726978302,
0.10895280539989471,
-0.4811243414878845,
-0.33381396532058716,
-0.43353304266929626,
0.53468257188797,
-0.466113805770874,
-1.0702362060546875,
0.4671790897846222,
-0.07188159972429276,
-0.3921915292739868,
0.2329464554786682,
0.6250276565551758,
-0.450855016708374,
0.8789658546447754,
0.47043320536613464,
-0.4257478713989258,
0.5674372911453247,
0.043773818761110306,
0.22415412962436676,
-0.8469477295875549,
-0.1222185418009758,
-0.35435065627098083,
-0.25475013256073,
-0.8344048857688904,
-0.34725067019462585,
0.14052045345306396,
0.13786624372005463,
-0.5187623500823975,
0.10592781007289886,
-0.24073196947574615,
0.5297077894210815,
0.4775456488132477,
0.18031074106693268,
0.14225243031978607,
-0.05206428840756416,
-0.12983380258083344,
0.15881934762001038,
-0.6499030590057373,
-0.6388178467750549,
0.9365449547767639,
0.2048429399728775,
0.6353602409362793,
-0.11996176838874817,
0.442374587059021,
0.46426835656166077,
0.29219454526901245,
-0.6812624335289001,
0.6790338158607483,
-0.08782267570495605,
-0.7458755970001221,
-0.2538333237171173,
-0.3413679003715515,
-1.3615717887878418,
0.22401168942451477,
-0.0945238471031189,
-1.2657331228256226,
-0.4988241493701935,
0.1585107147693634,
-0.19363068044185638,
0.2516191005706787,
-0.8733751773834229,
0.8028827905654907,
-0.3920671343803406,
-0.1935897022485733,
-0.40001562237739563,
-0.5312421917915344,
0.36264529824256897,
0.054418787360191345,
0.18459315598011017,
-0.2726452648639679,
-0.10625524818897247,
0.6808580756187439,
0.08538271486759186,
0.9563860893249512,
0.23808148503303528,
0.2664106488227844,
0.135154590010643,
0.22688962519168854,
0.36954405903816223,
-0.2347203940153122,
-0.06987334787845612,
0.005675578024238348,
-0.04026186466217041,
-0.32000234723091125,
-0.6935927271842957,
0.5667361617088318,
-0.785843551158905,
-0.7319998145103455,
-0.29621422290802,
-0.736218273639679,
-0.36419782042503357,
0.03975018113851547,
0.10123886913061142,
0.14647433161735535,
-0.410190612077713,
-0.024237828329205513,
0.5637041330337524,
-0.1716317981481552,
0.278814435005188,
0.19293053448200226,
-0.20784157514572144,
-0.05294289439916611,
0.7441452145576477,
-0.07982012629508972,
0.23625195026397705,
0.7296876311302185,
0.2990555763244629,
-0.14860378205776215,
-0.2101905792951584,
-0.12965326011180878,
0.17196784913539886,
-0.5504237413406372,
0.20157521963119507,
-0.6142833828926086,
-0.1233208179473877,
-0.063937246799469,
-0.036502208560705185,
0.005769127048552036,
-0.1978936493396759,
-0.25292739272117615,
-0.07260356843471527,
0.45287439227104187,
0.8347602486610413,
0.20086313784122467,
0.30832502245903015,
-0.5091540813446045,
0.3087102174758911,
0.33872607350349426,
0.3239527940750122,
0.2361292988061905,
-0.3092726171016693,
0.0022853808477520943,
0.14200688898563385,
-0.41999855637550354,
-0.8145562410354614,
0.21406100690364838,
0.21041631698608398,
0.49086692929267883,
0.43027621507644653,
-0.3108866512775421,
0.6653962135314941,
-0.5614898800849915,
0.7310134768486023,
0.22720842063426971,
-0.6018317937850952,
0.39078137278556824,
-0.4998660385608673,
0.2884189486503601,
0.2599096894264221,
0.16636131703853607,
-0.7132063508033752,
-0.2840685248374939,
-0.5818876624107361,
-0.5098502039909363,
0.6292572617530823,
0.35882246494293213,
0.2867682874202728,
-0.18350118398666382,
0.3842596411705017,
-0.10830745100975037,
-0.021470114588737488,
-0.5835826992988586,
-0.030969813466072083,
0.18878695368766785,
0.06037302315235138,
-0.4573528468608856,
-0.1661812961101532,
0.20621633529663086,
-0.15015943348407745,
0.338876336812973,
0.14744716882705688,
0.5406783223152161,
0.12996050715446472,
0.16143302619457245,
-0.07016612589359283,
0.3241191804409027,
0.4689827859401703,
0.5181552171707153,
-0.2730182707309723,
0.21073965728282928,
0.18157978355884552,
-0.41337770223617554,
0.09720296412706375,
-0.07006511837244034,
-0.020798275247216225,
-0.253359317779541,
0.53741854429245,
0.7628029584884644,
0.25325092673301697,
-0.9150382280349731,
0.2673979103565216,
-0.1405167430639267,
0.006227307487279177,
-0.522507905960083,
0.412402480840683,
0.37239766120910645,
0.4593256711959839,
0.1835421323776245,
0.21141819655895233,
0.053042441606521606,
-1.0361813306808472,
0.3495245575904846,
0.622053861618042,
-0.6474839448928833,
-0.2354043573141098,
0.7403339743614197,
-0.2727009057998657,
-0.8578312397003174,
0.9648014903068542,
0.030511651188135147,
-0.7952094674110413,
0.5753094553947449,
0.5148125886917114,
0.9112644195556641,
-0.114914670586586,
-0.06767303496599197,
0.27807819843292236,
0.1639920175075531,
-0.21228991448879242,
0.04915342107415199,
-0.21102012693881989,
-0.885448157787323,
-0.3269195854663849,
-0.5417636632919312,
-0.08261944353580475,
-0.07575985789299011,
-0.49113699793815613,
-0.08898186683654785,
-0.10281277447938919,
-0.3232365846633911,
-0.028226828202605247,
-0.10499410331249237,
-0.7343171238899231,
0.1800014227628708,
0.3043389916419983,
0.5927234888076782,
-0.7667112350463867,
1.0178614854812622,
0.5999649167060852,
-0.29616501927375793,
-0.8269529342651367,
0.4262728989124298,
-0.21836702525615692,
-0.9404280185699463,
0.6673827767372131,
0.3593970835208893,
-0.01987830176949501,
-0.20752795040607452,
-0.10092707723379135,
-0.7138674259185791,
1.1242249011993408,
0.3038255572319031,
-0.4097442328929901,
-0.20405222475528717,
0.16685082018375397,
0.5884600281715393,
-0.2845260500907898,
0.29332101345062256,
0.7520533800125122,
0.28385430574417114,
0.2112119346857071,
-1.0531401634216309,
0.08766715973615646,
-0.11007522791624069,
0.12425506860017776,
0.3980318307876587,
-0.5208279490470886,
0.9681392312049866,
-0.40318021178245544,
-0.08040458709001541,
0.1378232091665268,
0.3859564960002899,
0.372955858707428,
0.2984691262245178,
0.29239848256111145,
0.3982584476470947,
0.9986368417739868,
0.11032170802354813,
1.324467420578003,
-0.09494353830814362,
0.17872928082942963,
1.103448748588562,
-0.2909097373485565,
0.8912039995193481,
0.5108436942100525,
-0.49675750732421875,
0.5808824896812439,
0.49828070402145386,
0.14882323145866394,
0.4651349186897278,
0.4263181686401367,
-0.19327788054943085,
-0.33437132835388184,
0.0869147926568985,
-0.03748162090778351,
0.5730317234992981,
0.43550005555152893,
-0.6348950862884521,
0.006163090001791716,
-0.0736239105463028,
-0.13514845073223114,
-0.008286816999316216,
-0.16739024221897125,
0.8235663771629333,
0.2771088182926178,
-1.1009529829025269,
0.4964115023612976,
-0.21826474368572235,
0.4583536982536316,
-0.32644757628440857,
-0.0020497709047049284,
0.02781110256910324,
0.44579651951789856,
0.1467968374490738,
-0.8789666295051575,
0.19347931444644928,
-0.2338746041059494,
-0.2784971594810486,
-0.1385483592748642,
0.7763859629631042,
-0.22354744374752045,
-0.31532225012779236,
0.23336076736450195,
0.592275083065033,
0.40383273363113403,
-0.26658132672309875,
-0.6468585729598999,
-0.09750592708587646,
0.08723445236682892,
-0.20504434406757355,
0.5391388535499573,
0.5474998354911804,
-0.11396297067403793,
0.9237469434738159,
0.497963547706604,
0.027839848771691322,
-0.01756923459470272,
-0.18978381156921387,
0.573536217212677,
-0.857111930847168,
-0.4837944805622101,
-1.3850393295288086,
0.140336811542511,
0.11269226670265198,
-0.15425902605056763,
0.5966554284095764,
0.7116239666938782,
0.6855779886245728,
-0.015925029292702675,
0.8933723568916321,
0.10125520825386047,
0.16731426119804382,
-0.5075763463973999,
0.6559569835662842,
-0.3371219336986542,
0.22463949024677277,
-0.24106526374816895,
-0.7050674557685852,
-0.14306844770908356,
0.6456579566001892,
-0.6654617786407471,
0.10009635984897614,
0.7025188207626343,
0.86069655418396,
-0.02422843687236309,
0.25736895203590393,
0.5225070714950562,
0.2488088458776474,
0.21925239264965057,
0.8614582419395447,
1.0832105875015259,
-0.10065243393182755,
0.6323907971382141,
0.043302614241838455,
-0.06711212545633316,
-0.164352148771286,
-0.5871050953865051,
-1.2068496942520142,
-0.7673571109771729,
-0.04619970545172691,
-0.2794772684574127,
0.09850303828716278,
0.720338761806488,
0.5723739266395569,
-0.3685103952884674,
-0.41683638095855713,
-0.4868762791156769,
0.023878511041402817,
-0.158937469124794,
-0.2163224220275879,
0.41380611062049866,
-0.36425304412841797,
-0.25800883769989014,
0.056417886167764664,
0.45788758993148804,
0.07861623913049698,
-0.17395362257957458,
-0.24085894227027893,
0.05239132419228554,
0.06443357467651367,
0.6184067726135254,
0.030647672712802887,
-1.0242528915405273,
-0.21584035456180573,
0.008363207802176476,
-0.1801520586013794,
0.19478288292884827,
0.978899359703064,
-0.967953622341156,
0.24360956251621246,
0.34230735898017883,
0.48984721302986145,
0.5240094661712646,
0.019947627559304237,
0.6302762031555176,
-0.2622818648815155,
0.10568909347057343,
0.3861200213432312,
0.45076635479927063,
0.18562151491641998,
-0.4090219736099243,
0.42879292368888855,
0.1671445667743683,
-0.6960853338241577,
-0.45406535267829895,
0.27844464778900146,
-0.8920961022377014,
-0.3586684763431549,
1.0747150182724,
-0.08263592422008514,
-0.3498508632183075,
-0.12184073776006699,
-0.47816357016563416,
0.29694369435310364,
-0.3435920774936676,
1.1031709909439087,
0.9888149499893188,
-0.5012354850769043,
-0.25853168964385986,
-0.8585755228996277,
0.33697324991226196,
0.5272024273872375,
-0.5222600102424622,
0.25353944301605225,
0.4793427288532257,
0.19595180451869965,
0.021713998168706894,
0.7432300448417664,
0.3053775131702423,
0.23384244740009308,
0.11462154984474182,
-0.18360765278339386,
0.29523608088493347,
0.14350971579551697,
0.088707335293293,
0.1919398009777069,
0.17419496178627014,
-0.1549481749534607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07937v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.07937v1
|
Speech Robust Bench: A Robustness Benchmark For Speech Recognition
| 2024-03-08T08:10:29 | 2024-03-08T08:10:29 |
Muhammad A. Shah, David Solans Noguero, Mikko A. Heikkila, Nicolas Kourtellis
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
As Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) models become ever more pervasive, it
is important to ensure that they make reliable predictions under corruptions
present in the physical and digital world. We propose Speech Robust Bench
(SRB), a comprehensive benchmark for evaluating the robustness of ASR models to
diverse corruptions. SRB is composed of 69 input perturbations which are
intended to simulate various corruptions that ASR models may encounter in the
physical and digital world. We use SRB to evaluate the robustness of several
state-of-the-art ASR models and observe that model size and certain modeling
choices such as discrete representations, and self-training appear to be
conducive to robustness. We extend this analysis to measure the robustness of
ASR models on data from various demographic subgroups, namely English and
Spanish speakers, and males and females, and observed noticeable disparities in
the model's robustness across subgroups. We believe that SRB will facilitate
future research towards robust ASR models, by making it easier to conduct
comprehensive and comparable robustness evaluations.
|
[
-0.18496347963809967,
-0.5355112552642822,
-0.05463964492082596,
0.34549039602279663,
-0.1783692091703415,
0.07967977225780487,
0.01718336157500744,
-0.5722518563270569,
-0.1632501631975174,
0.3280447721481323,
-0.34216150641441345,
-0.1378091275691986,
-0.5961611866950989,
0.11116264760494232,
-0.8409156203269958,
0.4508782625198364,
0.3893214464187622,
0.6292275190353394,
-0.292409211397171,
-0.11210720241069794,
-0.6569632291793823,
-0.5782210230827332,
-0.51176518201828,
-0.3131609261035919,
0.04371734336018562,
0.07500369846820831,
0.34711700677871704,
1.0325722694396973,
0.6320119500160217,
0.3508452773094177,
-0.10174071043729782,
-0.3721987307071686,
-0.3483482003211975,
0.4374438524246216,
-0.1684245616197586,
-0.17861108481884003,
-0.3862031102180481,
-0.1714124232530594,
0.9633200168609619,
0.5203016996383667,
-0.3481191098690033,
0.2796972095966339,
0.17269743978977203,
0.4378179609775543,
-0.5365415215492249,
-0.013908137567341328,
-0.8805038332939148,
-0.23227134346961975,
-0.44697585701942444,
0.10934276878833771,
-0.09907273948192596,
-0.33006757497787476,
0.008723217993974686,
0.00437281746417284,
0.38133248686790466,
-0.23628565669059753,
0.6614469289779663,
0.6949008107185364,
-0.22163501381874084,
-0.0605153851211071,
-0.8569049835205078,
0.6050897240638733,
-0.503042459487915,
0.7658646106719971,
0.5446587204933167,
0.7502260208129883,
-0.1009492427110672,
-0.9096508026123047,
-0.3862758278846741,
-0.42699116468429565,
0.35944467782974243,
0.1625649780035019,
-0.24733957648277283,
-0.31486475467681885,
0.2547513246536255,
0.3859843909740448,
-0.6798248887062073,
0.12546291947364807,
-0.22601237893104553,
-0.5424445271492004,
0.5577171444892883,
-0.04736344888806343,
0.19692055881023407,
0.03149452060461044,
-0.29393449425697327,
-0.3659304976463318,
-0.47394779324531555,
0.1804955154657364,
0.5630134344100952,
0.6768482327461243,
-0.13887397944927216,
0.32283201813697815,
-0.11648155003786087,
0.7704322934150696,
-0.1184854507446289,
-0.33825117349624634,
0.17089959979057312,
-0.6050336956977844,
0.03479772433638573,
0.11234349757432938,
0.7296040058135986,
-0.14161273837089539,
0.2680003046989441,
-0.042145177721977234,
-0.3526116907596588,
0.4451274275779724,
0.3371790945529938,
-0.5695334672927856,
-0.3915300965309143,
-0.0426056832075119,
-0.6226140856742859,
-0.28266099095344543,
0.09344907850027084,
-0.7167483568191528,
-0.597495436668396,
-0.16103658080101013,
0.28940245509147644,
-0.42100241780281067,
-0.22369863092899323,
-0.27330416440963745,
-0.130239799618721,
0.10376477241516113,
0.15260733664035797,
-0.724743127822876,
0.6197669506072998,
0.5723656415939331,
0.575450599193573,
-0.06685900688171387,
-0.2937026023864746,
-0.7517934441566467,
-0.01993430405855179,
-0.04939963296055794,
0.9779480695724487,
-0.6583784818649292,
-0.7142989039421082,
-0.2215833216905594,
-0.3686125874519348,
-0.10103185474872589,
-0.9344205260276794,
0.8185188174247742,
-0.01699812524020672,
-0.3850696384906769,
-0.2960544526576996,
-0.24267879128456116,
0.2902005612850189,
0.10665075480937958,
-0.6385231018066406,
0.9109792113304138,
-0.18045154213905334,
-0.4848518669605255,
0.5598201155662537,
-0.2138795405626297,
-0.44536352157592773,
-0.05033155903220177,
-0.43740376830101013,
-0.6006328463554382,
0.0061338068917393684,
0.17599980533123016,
-0.0457332544028759,
-0.275696337223053,
0.1995670199394226,
-0.4844021499156952,
-0.3970278799533844,
0.5305740237236023,
-0.7376825213432312,
0.7756155133247375,
0.19432292878627777,
-0.2226116806268692,
0.1693968027830124,
-0.9982302784919739,
0.016166694462299347,
-0.11090369522571564,
-0.48940309882164,
-0.14193491637706757,
0.2197776436805725,
0.3397389054298401,
0.1455611288547516,
0.06384072452783585,
-0.6090389490127563,
-0.30418461561203003,
-0.2037600427865982,
0.5617884397506714,
0.7973410487174988,
-0.22294120490550995,
-0.08990570902824402,
-0.5499790906906128,
0.33578789234161377,
-0.12759241461753845,
0.019670622423291206,
0.08803459256887436,
-0.38165801763534546,
-0.3148497939109802,
-0.7204970121383667,
0.8740350604057312,
0.6159206032752991,
-0.11738690733909607,
0.528523325920105,
-0.332133948802948,
-0.6828314661979675,
-0.4045082926750183,
-0.016683241352438927,
0.5648844838142395,
0.6824191212654114,
0.20475107431411743,
-0.5991908311843872,
-0.7427915930747986,
-0.8775140047073364,
-0.5370582938194275,
-0.5320741534233093,
-0.20365233719348907,
0.3750278651714325,
0.44469839334487915,
-0.2360767424106598,
0.8876660466194153,
0.341420441865921,
-0.5813795328140259,
0.02613169327378273,
0.19307999312877655,
-0.20789457857608795,
0.6871547102928162,
0.405842661857605,
-0.7886701822280884,
-0.4422435760498047,
-0.3391339182853699,
-0.3731154501438141,
-0.4178144633769989,
0.17164087295532227,
0.3008555769920349,
0.04691515117883682,
0.4982752501964569,
-0.07562076300382614,
0.556019127368927,
0.5645720958709717,
-0.21931137144565582,
0.6974884867668152,
0.05128933861851692,
-0.006179579067975283,
-0.7930800318717957,
0.28961509466171265,
-0.12467814981937408,
-0.4095197916030884,
-0.5842167735099792,
-0.23428469896316528,
0.0881907120347023,
-0.3462686240673065,
-0.1436050832271576,
0.2884049117565155,
-0.19762471318244934,
-0.37169259786605835,
-0.1445956528186798,
-0.01454177126288414,
-0.4231327772140503,
-0.22512561082839966,
0.010137397795915604,
0.9897899627685547,
0.4770519435405731,
-0.40952447056770325,
0.34045758843421936,
0.35766035318374634,
-0.3642454743385315,
0.7323453426361084,
-0.9798160195350647,
0.19782069325447083,
0.02631852962076664,
0.23793603479862213,
-0.970750093460083,
-0.3119162917137146,
-0.1629074364900589,
-0.8473792672157288,
0.5061177611351013,
-0.1866796910762787,
-0.3476845324039459,
-0.26914504170417786,
-0.020238397642970085,
0.33935704827308655,
0.4347541928291321,
-0.2992517054080963,
0.7286000847816467,
0.7957175374031067,
-0.33883872628211975,
-0.70144122838974,
-0.691787600517273,
0.060221243649721146,
-0.15537641942501068,
-0.5689932703971863,
0.2861851453781128,
-0.02436320297420025,
-0.2513827979564667,
-0.1915876418352127,
-0.5147521495819092,
-0.31972408294677734,
0.0835859552025795,
0.44077804684638977,
0.04012114927172661,
-0.03725771978497505,
-0.23525118827819824,
-0.49453219771385193,
-0.20317284762859344,
-0.02971794269979,
0.11351329833269119,
0.7238920331001282,
-0.32863616943359375,
-0.5529728531837463,
-0.5977375507354736,
0.3450854420661926,
0.683662474155426,
-0.4265832304954529,
0.16496846079826355,
0.4241207540035248,
-0.5968801975250244,
-0.004235452972352505,
-0.6645292639732361,
-0.2268562614917755,
-0.46605831384658813,
0.4150618016719818,
-0.48929357528686523,
-0.5333544015884399,
0.9296844005584717,
0.18924765288829803,
-0.08357909321784973,
0.1442040354013443,
0.5009939670562744,
-0.06576024740934372,
0.9903280138969421,
0.44082435965538025,
-0.2508704662322998,
0.6245552897453308,
0.31124624609947205,
0.003913029562681913,
-0.593403697013855,
-0.22278587520122528,
-1.1791867017745972,
-0.18175895512104034,
-0.5073482990264893,
-0.311711847782135,
0.2721811830997467,
-0.1360708624124527,
-0.3012155592441559,
0.19611068069934845,
-0.45231184363365173,
0.13905759155750275,
0.8007062077522278,
-0.05574753135442734,
0.1645943820476532,
0.03844992443919182,
-0.06803981214761734,
-0.3118288815021515,
-0.505990207195282,
-0.5260334014892578,
0.9921279549598694,
0.39305558800697327,
1.0794005393981934,
0.2087375819683075,
0.6073141098022461,
0.43256282806396484,
0.03712402284145355,
-0.5808680057525635,
0.4155179262161255,
-0.46205729246139526,
-0.7453238368034363,
-0.30187559127807617,
-0.5677871108055115,
-0.8522624969482422,
-0.03746163100004196,
-0.27313822507858276,
-0.8338607549667358,
0.5870641469955444,
0.4590587317943573,
-0.34896767139434814,
-0.015743056312203407,
-0.45437291264533997,
0.756896436214447,
-0.2642253637313843,
-0.09949187934398651,
-0.11783012002706528,
-0.795718252658844,
0.17193488776683807,
-0.13947848975658417,
0.06314269453287125,
-0.12756966054439545,
0.18953697383403778,
0.7800420522689819,
-0.3196909725666046,
0.6179821491241455,
-0.26169735193252563,
0.338845431804657,
0.06461201608181,
0.006421766709536314,
0.445454865694046,
-0.11536739766597748,
-0.24569278955459595,
0.2500719726085663,
0.2661342918872833,
-0.26904523372650146,
-0.16096386313438416,
0.5728585720062256,
-0.8931176662445068,
-0.23276719450950623,
-0.729452908039093,
-0.6312839388847351,
-0.6381742358207703,
0.26053377985954285,
0.23381130397319794,
0.816500723361969,
-0.32788515090942383,
0.6531053185462952,
0.6035999655723572,
-0.04658316448330879,
0.3203223645687103,
0.5854418277740479,
0.24548940360546112,
-0.533888041973114,
0.8463285565376282,
0.3497084379196167,
0.07473050057888031,
0.09576703608036041,
0.2310594618320465,
-0.7081449031829834,
-0.8069514632225037,
-0.28794485330581665,
0.05080656334757805,
-0.5766006708145142,
-0.32036155462265015,
-0.3564555048942566,
-0.389010488986969,
-0.8116718530654907,
0.16603636741638184,
-0.6077750325202942,
-0.3218928575515747,
-0.055386584252119064,
0.21208734810352325,
-0.07801898568868637,
0.4451962113380432,
-0.2825746238231659,
0.03909428045153618,
-0.6186416149139404,
0.5258116126060486,
0.5839278697967529,
0.5427082180976868,
-0.37746191024780273,
-0.8518235683441162,
0.26715555787086487,
0.0355081781744957,
-0.15533562004566193,
-0.724442720413208,
0.3075443506240845,
0.6847992539405823,
0.8096672296524048,
0.5146456956863403,
0.3586887717247009,
0.9350870251655579,
-0.48144233226776123,
0.6231393814086914,
-0.052476003766059875,
-1.0874892473220825,
0.7033212780952454,
-0.40614742040634155,
0.21558409929275513,
0.8808010816574097,
-0.051195789128541946,
-0.13456039130687714,
-0.44108277559280396,
-0.5783835053443909,
-0.8332637548446655,
0.5157414078712463,
0.14423830807209015,
0.00003511756585794501,
0.34827327728271484,
0.09377553313970566,
-0.004355241544544697,
0.21050618588924408,
-0.6928049325942993,
-0.14825744926929474,
-0.6096627116203308,
-0.22009605169296265,
0.20611101388931274,
-0.347101628780365,
-0.3313474655151367,
-0.05778467655181885,
0.624054491519928,
0.1426403820514679,
0.2794588506221771,
0.13617075979709625,
0.034834399819374084,
-0.17049306631088257,
0.13149504363536835,
0.5801932215690613,
0.6390439867973328,
-0.37698379158973694,
0.2120317667722702,
0.10588892549276352,
-0.8276205062866211,
0.07441257685422897,
0.5471739172935486,
-0.18938012421131134,
-0.10867064446210861,
0.2513718008995056,
0.5003438591957092,
-0.01416056975722313,
-0.9383087754249573,
0.37780097126960754,
-0.5174830555915833,
0.004174056462943554,
-0.49266308546066284,
0.03501449525356293,
-0.20224609971046448,
0.22759605944156647,
0.36884647607803345,
0.4378548860549927,
0.19299505650997162,
-0.674813449382782,
0.3997991383075714,
0.6136350631713867,
-0.695688009262085,
0.004889064002782106,
0.8954885601997375,
0.11393734812736511,
-0.590629518032074,
0.6124024987220764,
0.173148974776268,
-0.45405811071395874,
0.35359540581703186,
0.8094666600227356,
0.6376804113388062,
-0.6912288069725037,
-0.20826195180416107,
0.3244923949241638,
0.5014181733131409,
-0.19456663727760315,
0.31817856431007385,
-0.052323997020721436,
-0.5933999419212341,
-0.029336106032133102,
-0.7292603254318237,
-0.6405813694000244,
0.1757032424211502,
-0.9547478556632996,
0.14008602499961853,
-0.4629554748535156,
-0.4643571674823761,
0.03634030744433403,
-0.012481057085096836,
-0.1854318231344223,
0.31681302189826965,
0.07152969390153885,
1.0417197942733765,
-0.8476018309593201,
0.9548342227935791,
0.8154516816139221,
-0.07007110863924026,
-0.7691736221313477,
0.09945802390575409,
0.2737716734409332,
-0.8117347955703735,
0.313589483499527,
0.09029388427734375,
-0.32720786333084106,
-0.12198149412870407,
-0.3409816324710846,
-0.8661612868309021,
0.863599419593811,
0.7404413223266602,
-0.5708935260772705,
0.41677790880203247,
0.08842306584119797,
0.5612663626670837,
-0.039490606635808945,
-0.24523122608661652,
0.5710180997848511,
0.33920106291770935,
0.11647486686706543,
-1.3135395050048828,
-0.11756168305873871,
-0.5067116618156433,
0.1774379462003708,
-0.1707768589258194,
-0.4754766821861267,
0.6778604984283447,
0.14120911061763763,
-0.2940809428691864,
0.3835109770298004,
0.5815087556838989,
0.6718290448188782,
0.2567853331565857,
0.747481644153595,
0.5727447271347046,
0.8492347002029419,
-0.5461218357086182,
0.8890390396118164,
-0.27012163400650024,
-0.0419803224503994,
1.1745092868804932,
-0.44461536407470703,
1.0923333168029785,
0.2609575688838959,
-0.2801208794116974,
0.20545822381973267,
0.4491879642009735,
-0.10738643258810043,
0.6543014645576477,
0.14519254863262177,
-0.1944558322429657,
-0.2932754456996918,
-0.2988552153110504,
-0.6086530685424805,
0.8109068274497986,
0.32599076628685,
-0.13323093950748444,
0.06392185389995575,
-0.15140540897846222,
-0.3580750823020935,
0.3178517520427704,
-0.23038767278194427,
0.7910752892494202,
0.040318332612514496,
-0.39112183451652527,
0.4968109130859375,
-0.17773868143558502,
0.426105797290802,
-0.8236801624298096,
0.24282918870449066,
0.01636476069688797,
0.42663538455963135,
-0.042288925498723984,
-0.5025699734687805,
0.5527549386024475,
0.21014873683452606,
-0.2661603093147278,
-0.22783967852592468,
0.9970444440841675,
-0.24891063570976257,
-0.4465457797050476,
0.1371934562921524,
0.2740042507648468,
0.11246076971292496,
-0.10200805962085724,
-0.6820800304412842,
0.5192930698394775,
-0.22134147584438324,
0.33400633931159973,
0.39062803983688354,
-0.008374003693461418,
-0.01822681352496147,
0.8883745074272156,
0.6654603481292725,
0.4179776906967163,
0.2619570195674896,
0.2419116348028183,
0.6435635685920715,
-0.3852117657661438,
-0.5542106032371521,
-0.559260904788971,
0.44107306003570557,
-0.2256019562482834,
-0.1970369815826416,
0.8279092907905579,
0.5175577402114868,
0.5932700634002686,
0.18381771445274353,
0.8273605108261108,
-0.06337319314479828,
0.8316621780395508,
-0.067626953125,
0.9149781465530396,
-0.23653854429721832,
0.2896447479724884,
-0.39039650559425354,
-0.8232383131980896,
-0.3972381353378296,
1.1048024892807007,
-0.12863458693027496,
0.18006864190101624,
0.1373840868473053,
0.8044782280921936,
-0.048387058079242706,
0.1073613315820694,
0.3267535865306854,
0.2499220073223114,
0.21801668405532837,
-0.0425976887345314,
0.7715013027191162,
-0.3906969428062439,
0.9043676853179932,
-0.26657482981681824,
-0.3521999418735504,
-0.10720575600862503,
-0.8612462282180786,
-0.47600752115249634,
-0.5677502155303955,
-0.3188304007053375,
-0.46651405096054077,
0.2060922235250473,
0.7193223237991333,
0.9606990814208984,
-1.1484578847885132,
-0.40142184495925903,
-0.09279695898294449,
-0.11154142022132874,
-0.4936458170413971,
-0.1455969512462616,
0.06073373183608055,
0.08752336353063583,
-0.6047112941741943,
0.6061174273490906,
0.12384757399559021,
0.21601611375808716,
-0.09972186386585236,
0.13314183056354523,
0.09196624159812927,
0.10428588837385178,
0.16548427939414978,
0.5645023584365845,
-0.5547769069671631,
-0.31318098306655884,
-0.09366478025913239,
0.01327050756663084,
-0.09728647768497467,
0.6643232703208923,
-0.8273882269859314,
0.7870468497276306,
0.5530030727386475,
0.5867288112640381,
0.33816972374916077,
0.3286966383457184,
0.6237990260124207,
-0.8561823964118958,
0.13460329174995422,
0.6154798865318298,
0.5265219211578369,
0.6255325078964233,
0.28354963660240173,
0.40844300389289856,
0.27407369017601013,
-0.782415509223938,
-1.4552823305130005,
0.2580811381340027,
-1.0001089572906494,
0.18528203666210175,
0.8167501091957092,
-0.15873107314109802,
0.21008232235908508,
-0.4789767563343048,
-0.04084859788417816,
0.35200241208076477,
-0.4752293527126312,
1.0630563497543335,
0.4869866371154785,
-0.18430045247077942,
-0.1872486025094986,
-0.2785106599330902,
0.3691807687282562,
0.2562444508075714,
-0.5824515223503113,
0.19152095913887024,
0.5664781928062439,
0.4090737998485565,
0.23442861437797546,
0.6589989066123962,
-0.37206846475601196,
0.45545122027397156,
0.4622388780117035,
-0.23164211213588715,
-0.1743471622467041,
-0.3384629189968109,
-0.5602208971977234,
0.24988405406475067,
0.20337052643299103,
-0.05035113915801048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05132v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05132v1
|
ChatUIE: Exploring Chat-based Unified Information Extraction using Large Language Models
| 2024-03-08T07:59:19 | 2024-03-08T07:59:19 |
Jun Xu, Mengshu Sun, Zhiqiang Zhang, Jun Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in large language models have shown impressive
performance in general chat. However, their domain-specific capabilities,
particularly in information extraction, have certain limitations. Extracting
structured information from natural language that deviates from known schemas
or instructions has proven challenging for previous prompt-based methods. This
motivated us to explore domain-specific modeling in chat-based language models
as a solution for extracting structured information from natural language. In
this paper, we present ChatUIE, an innovative unified information extraction
framework built upon ChatGLM. Simultaneously, reinforcement learning is
employed to improve and align various tasks that involve confusing and limited
samples. Furthermore, we integrate generation constraints to address the issue
of generating elements that are not present in the input. Our experimental
results demonstrate that ChatUIE can significantly improve the performance of
information extraction with a slight decrease in chatting ability.
|
[
-0.1808723658323288,
-1.036116600036621,
0.23781254887580872,
0.25214308500289917,
-0.12931740283966064,
0.21673272550106049,
-0.3150881230831146,
-0.39848244190216064,
-0.032774507999420166,
0.6281846761703491,
-0.6126944422721863,
-0.37930184602737427,
-0.6213628053665161,
-0.13675419986248016,
-0.2644110321998596,
0.9881607890129089,
0.3120173215866089,
-0.13899798691272736,
-0.07607610523700714,
0.17530977725982666,
-0.7504875659942627,
-0.4705270826816559,
-0.6726486086845398,
-0.19977015256881714,
0.3922852873802185,
0.6412743926048279,
0.6269358396530151,
0.304372102022171,
0.4675874412059784,
0.3828704357147217,
0.24309180676937103,
0.365797758102417,
-0.7507310509681702,
0.422443151473999,
-0.25020208954811096,
-0.44157013297080994,
-0.03201759606599808,
0.04123571887612343,
0.6715463399887085,
0.6934376955032349,
-0.2822285294532776,
0.023419024422764778,
0.03145645931363106,
0.38238489627838135,
-0.6103774905204773,
0.6173573732376099,
-0.824368417263031,
-0.0360371433198452,
-0.08652719110250473,
-0.4585314393043518,
-0.6869198679924011,
-0.22289496660232544,
0.4167288541793823,
-0.7699878811836243,
0.05802961066365242,
0.15611746907234192,
1.2483044862747192,
0.023407835513353348,
-0.3913328945636749,
-0.3539869487285614,
-1.0028502941131592,
0.87308269739151,
-0.6105427145957947,
0.4116162657737732,
-0.07984501868486404,
0.27400586009025574,
-0.8080112934112549,
-0.8184887766838074,
-0.5228850245475769,
-0.1750013381242752,
-0.11963115632534027,
0.03717345371842384,
-0.32211965322494507,
0.032345306128263474,
0.230218768119812,
0.12402981519699097,
-0.3657321333885193,
0.1269775927066803,
-0.2832052409648895,
-0.046654537320137024,
0.6416842937469482,
-0.15960046648979187,
0.6123336553573608,
-0.40726134181022644,
-0.5769701600074768,
-0.20522700250148773,
-0.5493621826171875,
0.16116322576999664,
0.03786968067288399,
0.4684329330921173,
0.2831103205680847,
0.4926699995994568,
-0.09934064000844955,
0.18306472897529602,
0.01802229695022106,
-0.2161412090063095,
0.04996655508875847,
0.2810197174549103,
-0.319149911403656,
-0.12410054355859756,
1.0433837175369263,
-0.06304679811000824,
0.22648608684539795,
-0.5837264060974121,
0.05306770280003548,
-0.253633052110672,
0.11195714771747589,
-0.8928208351135254,
-0.3403847813606262,
0.24040894210338593,
-0.26611313223838806,
-0.4268744885921478,
0.3449276089668274,
-1.007502555847168,
-0.4553541839122772,
-0.2134929895401001,
0.22511084377765656,
-0.6523312330245972,
-0.5453054308891296,
-0.06809021532535553,
-0.347843199968338,
0.35673755407333374,
0.4670446813106537,
-0.9327535629272461,
0.48016607761383057,
0.5779316425323486,
0.5193155407905579,
-0.6817470192909241,
0.07538509368896484,
-1.0915918350219727,
0.05571097880601883,
-0.14874789118766785,
0.7698161602020264,
-0.8158319592475891,
-0.4947096109390259,
-0.13582424819469452,
0.03516152501106262,
-0.23653019964694977,
-0.5695667266845703,
0.3436080515384674,
-0.7102050185203552,
0.5087482333183289,
0.1528908610343933,
-0.8562495112419128,
-0.11774834245443344,
-0.05670184642076492,
-0.6968989968299866,
1.111081600189209,
0.12735269963741302,
-0.5643178224563599,
0.12189619988203049,
-0.9468995928764343,
-0.21392035484313965,
0.5411447882652283,
-0.47026997804641724,
-0.28548774123191833,
0.01435730792582035,
0.11051934957504272,
0.2892855107784271,
-0.38622793555259705,
0.5354982614517212,
-0.25481122732162476,
-0.029718240723013878,
0.44592687487602234,
-0.5432859063148499,
0.7401583194732666,
0.37016481161117554,
-0.1891820877790451,
0.10107879340648651,
-0.7905229926109314,
0.23288090527057648,
0.35526666045188904,
-0.3875502645969391,
-0.20987918972969055,
0.17688094079494476,
-0.041228797286748886,
0.2708437442779541,
0.1896895170211792,
-0.5830583572387695,
0.4365426301956177,
-0.3509816527366638,
0.21480989456176758,
0.6202859878540039,
0.26847758889198303,
0.7362749576568604,
-0.006899895146489143,
0.48250776529312134,
0.09055940806865692,
-0.021097615361213684,
0.011169920675456524,
-0.3738900423049927,
-0.6106606125831604,
-0.5881624221801758,
0.6571187973022461,
0.8216518759727478,
-0.8216169476509094,
0.37565818428993225,
-0.2956252992153168,
-0.11905372887849808,
-0.4105047583580017,
0.24562108516693115,
0.11273753643035889,
0.4269334077835083,
0.24212029576301575,
-0.328735888004303,
-0.7274484634399414,
-0.6265528798103333,
-0.05201307684183121,
-0.19374194741249084,
-0.31775009632110596,
0.2884041666984558,
0.15225166082382202,
-0.1811123937368393,
1.2521404027938843,
-0.5360204577445984,
-0.015441291965544224,
-0.5832228660583496,
0.5709038376808167,
0.04288554936647415,
0.4226120412349701,
0.012478085234761238,
-1.1046522855758667,
-0.21468660235404968,
0.24079756438732147,
-0.8928988575935364,
-0.11753570288419724,
-0.31053194403648376,
-0.39513665437698364,
0.00604022154584527,
0.5492087006568909,
-0.8503038883209229,
0.47338709235191345,
0.23557811975479126,
0.05047408491373062,
0.4441077709197998,
-0.05148106440901756,
-0.04855513200163841,
-1.0137138366699219,
0.058205462992191315,
0.1057496890425682,
-0.4029528498649597,
-0.71409672498703,
0.03486490249633789,
-0.02695690654218197,
-0.2897287607192993,
-0.3498377799987793,
0.6582972407341003,
-0.5475635528564453,
0.007158879190683365,
-0.3808046877384186,
0.6034613847732544,
0.16481153666973114,
0.8543322682380676,
0.28783872723579407,
0.40981778502464294,
0.3648572564125061,
-0.7772496938705444,
0.378984272480011,
0.2941156029701233,
-0.1207483783364296,
0.1849261075258255,
-0.4678012728691101,
0.2052294909954071,
-0.1624191850423813,
-0.022056955844163895,
-0.795468807220459,
-0.2963876724243164,
0.20638222992420197,
-0.5356399416923523,
0.5921645164489746,
-0.2595616281032562,
-0.1955217868089676,
-0.1607857644557953,
0.018759213387966156,
-0.12393645942211151,
0.5803892612457275,
-0.6907877922058105,
0.6677848696708679,
0.7785124182701111,
-0.5109696388244629,
-0.47939813137054443,
0.02073700539767742,
0.08325937390327454,
-0.25364503264427185,
-0.6442458033561707,
0.22610634565353394,
-0.0988842025399208,
-0.36007028818130493,
-0.09625886380672455,
-0.15596921741962433,
-0.3558643162250519,
0.38394397497177124,
0.2936672866344452,
0.5870572328567505,
-0.24625252187252045,
0.46925297379493713,
-0.2512836456298828,
0.0944715067744255,
-0.10739266127347946,
-0.21382345259189606,
0.5892793536186218,
-0.06788748502731323,
-0.09423847496509552,
-0.5166076421737671,
0.543632447719574,
0.19253672659397125,
-0.3006843030452728,
0.586977481842041,
0.525841236114502,
-0.28143399953842163,
-0.2461356371641159,
-0.4721102714538574,
-0.053784698247909546,
-0.4930514991283417,
0.5284823775291443,
-0.2713427245616913,
-0.9060224890708923,
0.15575948357582092,
-0.5376939177513123,
0.4896467626094818,
0.40715062618255615,
0.14794480800628662,
-0.1919681280851364,
1.2767059803009033,
0.8980268836021423,
-0.14970725774765015,
0.773029625415802,
0.0398561954498291,
0.21288485825061798,
-0.3653755187988281,
-0.37656843662261963,
-0.5934581756591797,
-0.007038322277367115,
-0.5151135921478271,
-0.12438715994358063,
-0.01992722600698471,
0.40195131301879883,
0.037186793982982635,
0.23153109848499298,
-0.18750473856925964,
0.37909409403800964,
0.5611299872398376,
-0.12586790323257446,
0.26669567823410034,
0.07239444553852081,
0.04254806041717529,
0.11476825177669525,
-0.7416380047798157,
-0.5981985926628113,
0.7014116048812866,
0.16879267990589142,
0.7250773310661316,
0.04701431840658188,
0.5979629755020142,
0.2972116470336914,
0.2814139127731323,
-0.7184755206108093,
0.4622163474559784,
0.11313948035240173,
-0.3334050178527832,
-0.5293025374412537,
-0.9117857217788696,
-1.369826316833496,
0.44337159395217896,
-0.43600791692733765,
-1.2118167877197266,
0.07378242909908295,
-0.22248493134975433,
-0.1487901657819748,
0.1776464730501175,
-0.8982486128807068,
0.7594993114471436,
-0.10826942324638367,
-0.10122064501047134,
0.2205391377210617,
-0.5204739570617676,
0.3103054165840149,
0.09334392845630646,
0.4087566137313843,
-0.33790692687034607,
0.31112435460090637,
0.6638354063034058,
-0.37764766812324524,
0.692166805267334,
-0.13360950350761414,
-0.08583170175552368,
0.37146762013435364,
0.2798043191432953,
0.6642132997512817,
0.24373874068260193,
0.16696135699748993,
-0.06850585341453552,
0.031633149832487106,
-0.4297100007534027,
-0.8868029713630676,
0.3734106719493866,
-0.7691386938095093,
-0.6000882983207703,
-0.2720003128051758,
-0.5691884160041809,
-0.46875613927841187,
0.22182707488536835,
0.1844959706068039,
0.48711422085762024,
-0.5797509551048279,
0.1857702136039734,
0.7332128286361694,
-0.2525295317173004,
0.45159992575645447,
0.6764320731163025,
-0.42692577838897705,
0.0061963386833667755,
1.0343629121780396,
-0.3435922861099243,
0.1412205547094345,
0.6066187024116516,
0.20293974876403809,
-0.18542125821113586,
-0.14262475073337555,
-0.267290323972702,
-0.016986092552542686,
-0.3833024203777313,
-0.26191088557243347,
-0.6720144748687744,
-0.5986429452896118,
-0.3727229833602905,
0.38669201731681824,
-0.3658197224140167,
-0.43547043204307556,
-0.32606977224349976,
0.03313606232404709,
0.06790664792060852,
0.681252658367157,
0.06273754686117172,
0.4139419496059418,
-0.98921138048172,
0.3623180687427521,
0.4712945520877838,
-0.07573271542787552,
-0.3572973906993866,
-0.24780389666557312,
0.06058529391884804,
0.30815833806991577,
-0.40629279613494873,
-0.781123697757721,
0.5279293060302734,
0.3112139105796814,
0.7164362072944641,
0.38812488317489624,
0.1087329089641571,
0.5679608583450317,
-0.3906671702861786,
0.6188041567802429,
0.2732689678668976,
-0.6707062721252441,
0.580366849899292,
-0.10654653608798981,
0.1761479675769806,
0.2983946204185486,
0.2291031926870346,
-0.798211932182312,
-0.5778727531433105,
-1.020208716392517,
-0.6290132403373718,
0.7375924587249756,
0.40280216932296753,
-0.07632295042276382,
-0.1530085951089859,
0.1754644513130188,
0.17677877843379974,
0.1609635055065155,
-0.7610399127006531,
0.10057657957077026,
0.2019874006509781,
-0.2110135704278946,
0.4681226909160614,
-0.12102494388818741,
0.2572645843029022,
0.16361860930919647,
0.8199975490570068,
-0.031260982155799866,
0.26015591621398926,
0.027864333242177963,
-0.5205404758453369,
-0.14039026200771332,
0.5006810426712036,
-0.004513683263212442,
0.3763427734375,
-0.04838930815458298,
-0.19372840225696564,
-0.004534667357802391,
-0.2695542573928833,
-0.30973345041275024,
0.21785996854305267,
-0.06879736483097076,
0.0457746721804142,
0.1615237295627594,
0.7997587323188782,
0.5150331258773804,
-0.8768673539161682,
0.7076293230056763,
-0.5324961543083191,
-0.11694137006998062,
-0.17997416853904724,
0.4566708207130432,
-0.19033895432949066,
0.3819832503795624,
0.46715879440307617,
-0.01613294705748558,
0.09642473608255386,
-0.5159481167793274,
0.37455451488494873,
0.5674473643302917,
-0.43843069672584534,
-0.22393852472305298,
0.4255143404006958,
0.20828098058700562,
-0.3745875358581543,
0.89766526222229,
-0.23431651294231415,
-0.11477579176425934,
0.42249956727027893,
0.4595772922039032,
0.7095935940742493,
-0.19878895580768585,
0.6423479914665222,
0.24099454283714294,
-0.12880897521972656,
0.0017073593335226178,
0.11131942272186279,
-0.15556122362613678,
-0.8871639966964722,
-0.5740944147109985,
-0.5265833735466003,
-0.5649242401123047,
0.3253748118877411,
-0.6389642953872681,
0.341678649187088,
-0.15273535251617432,
0.14640891551971436,
0.12028653174638748,
0.12378361076116562,
-0.7344788312911987,
-0.087222620844841,
0.3460281491279602,
0.5495268702507019,
-0.3041819632053375,
0.8916415572166443,
0.14770282804965973,
-0.4301818013191223,
-0.9203537702560425,
-0.3449990153312683,
-0.05454694479703903,
-0.6208786964416504,
0.47027960419654846,
0.18199656903743744,
-0.01041948702186346,
-0.09549420326948166,
-0.9934217929840088,
-0.9010875225067139,
0.9062358736991882,
0.38019517064094543,
-0.42101868987083435,
-0.3843158185482025,
-0.012200466357171535,
0.31729376316070557,
-0.5441809296607971,
0.3034195601940155,
0.5404819846153259,
0.14172208309173584,
0.4498649537563324,
-0.6348503232002258,
-0.24901938438415527,
-0.5146723985671997,
-0.10275832563638687,
0.27793076634407043,
-0.2807449400424957,
0.58783358335495,
-0.02610480599105358,
-0.7624638080596924,
0.053280603140592575,
0.9798054099082947,
-0.003260175697505474,
-0.23249736428260803,
0.5364202260971069,
0.028810899704694748,
1.3380048274993896,
0.14966394007205963,
0.7457334995269775,
0.11215037107467651,
0.22076281905174255,
1.3914120197296143,
-0.477384477853775,
0.8655652403831482,
0.1558939814567566,
0.15551938116550446,
0.7746890187263489,
0.3383994996547699,
0.2272891253232956,
0.33200061321258545,
0.03421926125884056,
-0.3580355942249298,
-0.26235559582710266,
-0.1774715781211853,
0.017252696678042412,
0.7126633524894714,
0.5686166286468506,
0.053117141127586365,
-0.413971871137619,
-0.07192835211753845,
0.2291668951511383,
-0.24694286286830902,
-0.09255426377058029,
1.2710082530975342,
-0.04892076551914215,
-0.8566379547119141,
0.3093797266483307,
-0.05208856239914894,
0.3281225264072418,
-0.7898975610733032,
-0.28786176443099976,
-0.13228565454483032,
-0.029767349362373352,
0.018534725531935692,
-0.2996101975440979,
-0.04369872808456421,
-0.002642666455358267,
0.15039876103401184,
-0.12836246192455292,
1.053676962852478,
-0.6914998292922974,
-0.22498947381973267,
0.12718316912651062,
0.5902397036552429,
0.2516297399997711,
-0.17361266911029816,
-0.6105429530143738,
-0.3625129759311676,
0.17890673875808716,
-0.37226739525794983,
0.4812960624694824,
0.9025930166244507,
0.0952145904302597,
0.6419623494148254,
0.7595791220664978,
0.044432491064071655,
0.13435381650924683,
-0.06131017953157425,
0.8535207509994507,
-0.6422017216682434,
-0.5107716917991638,
-0.713401734828949,
0.4525163769721985,
-0.703464150428772,
-0.1552528738975525,
0.5567095875740051,
0.47207361459732056,
0.43221238255500793,
0.2636811435222626,
0.9829298853874207,
-0.150931715965271,
0.5786719918251038,
-0.48581796884536743,
0.25723451375961304,
-0.28808140754699707,
0.30658650398254395,
-0.23766876757144928,
-0.793316662311554,
-0.07844564318656921,
0.4231841266155243,
-0.08548600226640701,
-0.4772755801677704,
0.7257370948791504,
0.7100062966346741,
0.0282906387001276,
0.42504751682281494,
0.2895689606666565,
0.1460566520690918,
0.6205763816833496,
0.5647217631340027,
0.8212850689888,
-0.18075533211231232,
0.9771586656570435,
-0.01782182604074478,
-0.36416706442832947,
-0.17585738003253937,
-0.7320057153701782,
-0.8740376234054565,
-0.6047760844230652,
-0.35281902551651,
-0.24890685081481934,
-0.19040599465370178,
1.0715965032577515,
0.7170564532279968,
-0.8013592958450317,
-0.1083846464753151,
-0.10353127866983414,
0.30024999380111694,
0.02087395265698433,
-0.3419836759567261,
0.13441841304302216,
-0.8670931458473206,
-0.6911378502845764,
0.6671411395072937,
0.3740820288658142,
-0.030238693580031395,
0.21095189452171326,
0.07238674908876419,
-0.353849858045578,
0.2554645240306854,
0.48335209488868713,
0.8206946849822998,
-0.24891120195388794,
-0.5433957576751709,
-0.12965378165245056,
-0.31244921684265137,
0.4110701382160187,
0.7232158184051514,
-0.7029451727867126,
0.28320589661598206,
0.28846627473831177,
0.6714865565299988,
0.6479998826980591,
0.16180887818336487,
0.8303380608558655,
-1.0860148668289185,
0.14885875582695007,
0.08156543970108032,
0.3512086272239685,
0.1564643234014511,
-0.3816288709640503,
0.3997957408428192,
0.055733878165483475,
-0.5138710141181946,
-0.4224863648414612,
0.3142586648464203,
-0.9510989785194397,
-0.41556090116500854,
1.3077857494354248,
-0.1676427274942398,
-0.5576827526092529,
-0.3168506324291229,
-0.5569606423377991,
0.414523720741272,
-0.6070238351821899,
0.7556700110435486,
0.6060895323753357,
0.005819927901029587,
-0.06924816220998764,
-0.5157982110977173,
0.48481422662734985,
0.12374478578567505,
-1.1281616687774658,
0.14084334671497345,
0.5641345977783203,
0.2887634336948395,
0.10207398980855942,
0.6576585173606873,
-0.14787574112415314,
0.18200713396072388,
-0.20564915239810944,
0.273502916097641,
0.2764962911605835,
-0.37748995423316956,
0.05264103412628174,
0.44461381435394287,
-0.07620341330766678,
-0.21758434176445007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05606v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05606v1
|
A Concept-based Interpretable Model for the Diagnosis of Choroid Neoplasias using Multimodal Data
| 2024-03-08T07:15:53 | 2024-03-08T07:15:53 |
Yifan Wu, Yang Liu, Yue Yang, Michael S. Yao, Wenli Yang, Xuehui Shi, Lihong Yang, Dongjun Li, Yueming Liu, James C. Gee, Xuan Yang, Wenbin Wei, Shi Gu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Diagnosing rare diseases presents a common challenge in clinical practice,
necessitating the expertise of specialists for accurate identification. The
advent of machine learning offers a promising solution, while the development
of such technologies is hindered by the scarcity of data on rare conditions and
the demand for models that are both interpretable and trustworthy in a clinical
context. Interpretable AI, with its capacity for human-readable outputs, can
facilitate validation by clinicians and contribute to medical education. In the
current work, we focus on choroid neoplasias, the most prevalent form of eye
cancer in adults, albeit rare with 5.1 per million. We built the so-far largest
dataset consisting of 750 patients, incorporating three distinct imaging
modalities collected from 2004 to 2022. Our work introduces a concept-based
interpretable model that distinguishes between three types of choroidal tumors,
integrating insights from domain experts via radiological reports. Remarkably,
this model not only achieves an F1 score of 0.91, rivaling that of black-box
models, but also boosts the diagnostic accuracy of junior doctors by 42%. This
study highlights the significant potential of interpretable machine learning in
improving the diagnosis of rare diseases, laying a groundwork for future
breakthroughs in medical AI that could tackle a wider array of complex health
scenarios.
|
[
0.025465520098805428,
-0.6980873942375183,
0.5640196204185486,
-0.0011958086397498846,
-0.5005587935447693,
0.26962652802467346,
-0.008005819283425808,
-0.7789099812507629,
0.30900561809539795,
0.6369463205337524,
-0.6407240033149719,
-0.518703043460846,
-0.7041053771972656,
0.06841875612735748,
-0.21575891971588135,
0.8196836709976196,
0.1539561152458191,
0.4734615981578827,
-0.15194155275821686,
-0.18806889653205872,
-0.20130369067192078,
0.26664578914642334,
-0.6199503540992737,
-0.3387031555175781,
0.2834356427192688,
0.48579084873199463,
0.7351363897323608,
0.8969866633415222,
0.8105849027633667,
0.22743479907512665,
-0.19993194937705994,
0.6748144030570984,
-0.20248045027256012,
0.026530636474490166,
0.12392637133598328,
-0.39056500792503357,
-0.6880029439926147,
0.03085331991314888,
0.14476649463176727,
1.1761833429336548,
-0.2271319478750229,
-0.4917031526565552,
-0.06494871526956558,
0.6100296378135681,
-0.10492414236068726,
0.24884992837905884,
-0.5255539417266846,
0.4730120301246643,
-0.20265376567840576,
-0.4254111051559448,
-0.23975081741809845,
-0.19074298441410065,
0.19593898952007294,
-1.2821853160858154,
0.3005109131336212,
-0.00974343717098236,
0.6021531224250793,
0.3400266766548157,
-0.5544402003288269,
-0.5564191937446594,
-0.6549460291862488,
0.8937600255012512,
-0.3920985162258148,
0.1433570683002472,
0.0747934952378273,
0.5489509701728821,
0.08404123783111572,
-0.7110057473182678,
-0.32193464040756226,
-0.32668325304985046,
-0.12071157991886139,
0.35524705052375793,
0.11942548304796219,
-0.04119433835148811,
-0.03094465844333172,
0.4262516498565674,
-0.8442904949188232,
0.16563057899475098,
-0.5190316438674927,
-0.03665834292769432,
0.3957808017730713,
0.5804423689842224,
0.28947192430496216,
-0.23367485404014587,
-0.3441634774208069,
0.13093461096286774,
-0.49102434515953064,
-0.34009185433387756,
0.04512336105108261,
0.4179188311100006,
-0.01811251975595951,
0.36083588004112244,
-0.6897037625312805,
0.944331169128418,
0.3229573965072632,
-0.09877514839172363,
0.26573044061660767,
-0.16829705238342285,
-0.12975597381591797,
0.1444600373506546,
0.5529165863990784,
0.25187209248542786,
0.04915241152048111,
0.06948935985565186,
0.3266064524650574,
0.04699274152517319,
0.2930435240268707,
-0.6344166398048401,
-0.37184494733810425,
0.45261552929878235,
-0.7151201367378235,
-0.7297388315200806,
-0.02783092111349106,
-0.8473607301712036,
-0.6629961729049683,
-0.05620036646723747,
0.0842091292142868,
-0.2868223190307617,
-0.32158592343330383,
0.22274069488048553,
0.020623525604605675,
-0.6182674765586853,
0.573341429233551,
-0.8043553829193115,
0.027760427445173264,
0.4858095347881317,
0.48382678627967834,
-0.1763506531715393,
-0.05650300532579422,
-0.39480727910995483,
0.33130747079849243,
-0.47718873620033264,
0.702528178691864,
-0.7757509350776672,
-0.3858087360858917,
-0.39114832878112793,
0.09942394495010376,
-0.1710072010755539,
-0.7376067042350769,
0.3811706304550171,
-0.31089529395103455,
0.027543986216187477,
0.3163270056247711,
-0.27567917108535767,
-0.2674790918827057,
0.23403191566467285,
-0.8280876874923706,
0.37443608045578003,
0.31461626291275024,
-0.4520232081413269,
0.5940714478492737,
-0.6899328231811523,
-0.19921891391277313,
0.5176565051078796,
-0.18836674094200134,
-0.32215553522109985,
0.303876668214798,
0.08610968291759491,
0.5894147157669067,
-0.4182918667793274,
0.33880868554115295,
-0.5304276347160339,
0.03304509073495865,
0.19375446438789368,
-0.34757810831069946,
0.5211665630340576,
0.5841734409332275,
-0.17516222596168518,
0.1395176351070404,
-1.0821938514709473,
0.5263965129852295,
0.024734867736697197,
-0.0290635097771883,
-0.35229068994522095,
-0.1545901745557785,
-0.04502984881401062,
0.21396759152412415,
0.1436331868171692,
-0.4311434030532837,
0.11166917532682419,
-0.2727266550064087,
0.3623647093772888,
0.5529927611351013,
-0.18540947139263153,
0.02199181169271469,
-0.24243229627609253,
0.5835860967636108,
0.6885881423950195,
0.45149677991867065,
0.03651807829737663,
-0.8662368655204773,
-0.20284445583820343,
-0.44894319772720337,
0.25529348850250244,
0.4876163899898529,
-0.6454593539237976,
-0.08517205715179443,
-0.33184874057769775,
-0.4398736357688904,
-0.6167087554931641,
0.16142307221889496,
0.12445231527090073,
0.7026616334915161,
0.16347388923168182,
-0.26342546939849854,
-0.3518368601799011,
-0.9266984462738037,
-0.09610705822706223,
0.01630856655538082,
0.20525851845741272,
0.6177466511726379,
0.30246180295944214,
-0.3246782124042511,
0.35164713859558105,
-0.7385463714599609,
-0.5516427159309387,
-0.09439225494861603,
0.3680627644062042,
0.21818506717681885,
0.572803795337677,
-0.12412425130605698,
-1.0614603757858276,
-0.5586163401603699,
0.7596717476844788,
-1.3758586645126343,
0.10134508460760117,
-0.0644826665520668,
0.3553861081600189,
-0.3266846835613251,
0.3875246047973633,
-0.4393448531627655,
0.46751683950424194,
0.5881833434104919,
-0.29338183999061584,
0.18421749770641327,
-0.4455881416797638,
0.24134518206119537,
-0.6628158688545227,
0.21499966084957123,
0.007515910547226667,
-0.4071212708950043,
-0.4176466464996338,
0.08235760033130646,
0.18048828840255737,
-0.21202868223190308,
-0.2707112431526184,
0.35215839743614197,
-0.2409863919019699,
-0.04500509053468704,
0.05037108063697815,
-0.03136222064495087,
0.17756842076778412,
-0.032658226788043976,
0.22104206681251526,
0.200856551527977,
0.5754392147064209,
-0.5565416216850281,
0.3845944404602051,
0.013591837137937546,
-0.621266782283783,
0.8023321628570557,
-0.5113571286201477,
-0.10174574702978134,
0.16721875965595245,
0.11441831290721893,
-0.29817211627960205,
-0.471285343170166,
0.2407844513654709,
-0.6518202424049377,
0.2999376952648163,
0.020002570003271103,
-0.23908409476280212,
-0.4360201954841614,
0.2360144704580307,
0.5843361616134644,
0.049311306327581406,
-0.39510631561279297,
0.7256947755813599,
0.18897360563278198,
-0.12159881740808487,
-0.7396567463874817,
-0.9017079472541809,
-0.15689633786678314,
-0.21589429676532745,
-0.7397481203079224,
0.24601241946220398,
-0.2028818577528,
-0.23519505560398102,
0.37465986609458923,
0.2519199550151825,
-0.5507840514183044,
0.2533823847770691,
0.3193427324295044,
0.16384074091911316,
-0.42519623041152954,
0.1249118372797966,
-0.05248478427529335,
-0.31871092319488525,
-0.3892444670200348,
-0.23601745069026947,
0.17113801836967468,
-0.16353726387023926,
-0.37198635935783386,
-0.543035626411438,
0.40783241391181946,
0.6688117980957031,
0.031124070286750793,
0.25551098585128784,
0.5086935758590698,
-0.5427691340446472,
-0.2807241976261139,
0.07211146503686905,
-0.07820550352334976,
-0.425550252199173,
0.47011399269104004,
-0.26448893547058105,
-0.5282399654388428,
0.5247588753700256,
-0.3334227204322815,
-0.3455237150192261,
0.40748491883277893,
0.42877933382987976,
-0.14726410806179047,
1.4035941362380981,
0.7901394963264465,
0.6863808631896973,
-0.02814576029777527,
-0.24344536662101746,
0.21673469245433807,
-0.8303864002227783,
-0.5416228175163269,
-0.018492016941308975,
-0.025247883051633835,
-0.5667724609375,
-0.43821150064468384,
0.5466282367706299,
-0.13004617393016815,
0.4081137776374817,
-0.47637611627578735,
-0.838546633720398,
0.32615646719932556,
0.122533418238163,
0.5202450156211853,
0.5406680703163147,
-0.023302774876356125,
-0.06508064270019531,
-0.20241683721542358,
-0.7204009890556335,
-0.23630855977535248,
1.5366665124893188,
0.017269667237997055,
0.5133369565010071,
-0.03433552384376526,
0.29895052313804626,
0.4894559681415558,
0.4761550724506378,
-0.828728199005127,
0.07810945063829422,
-0.5692546367645264,
-1.246993899345398,
-0.22415857017040253,
-0.6365759372711182,
-0.9649796485900879,
0.13954918086528778,
-0.11627543717622757,
-0.47910138964653015,
0.41785621643066406,
0.3149697780609131,
-0.6153678894042969,
0.3395744264125824,
-0.41608598828315735,
1.2180838584899902,
-0.44380125403404236,
-0.2886475622653961,
-0.49921146035194397,
-0.481668084859848,
0.7259611487388611,
-0.342080682516098,
0.5176432132720947,
0.07678163796663284,
-0.06658629328012466,
0.5924484133720398,
-0.3890390694141388,
0.7379166483879089,
0.06858201324939728,
0.34995701909065247,
-0.03458351641893387,
-0.15391063690185547,
0.08882312476634979,
0.17718437314033508,
0.026768213137984276,
-0.013360065408051014,
0.01128520630300045,
-0.5982462167739868,
-0.5374654531478882,
0.726194441318512,
-0.5513656139373779,
-0.17566098272800446,
-0.6204172968864441,
-0.8941545486450195,
-0.3839907646179199,
0.29253432154655457,
0.0909094586968422,
0.6718574166297913,
-0.21241365373134613,
0.15389128029346466,
0.7843738198280334,
-0.09556854516267776,
-0.08658522367477417,
0.3245031535625458,
-0.16490477323532104,
-0.19648458063602448,
1.2487356662750244,
-0.03480910137295723,
0.2729748487472534,
0.37679240107536316,
0.2814449965953827,
0.08766960352659225,
-0.6900981664657593,
-0.6246702671051025,
0.10569360852241516,
-0.773697018623352,
0.04596740007400513,
-0.5583305358886719,
0.08962935209274292,
-0.06190323829650879,
-0.1785896271467209,
-0.5108920931816101,
-0.49359503388404846,
-0.4728222191333771,
0.18532095849514008,
0.12147882580757141,
0.7675344347953796,
-0.4878874719142914,
0.22315572202205658,
-0.4209998846054077,
0.5260464549064636,
0.5247703194618225,
0.3662382662296295,
-0.03205930441617966,
-0.2580639719963074,
-0.20016831159591675,
0.1440182626247406,
-0.232608824968338,
-0.39910411834716797,
0.5961418151855469,
0.310994029045105,
0.3054429292678833,
0.8860685229301453,
-0.14191250503063202,
0.824505627155304,
0.1942547857761383,
0.4630783498287201,
0.46716219186782837,
-0.6880368590354919,
0.5521776080131531,
-0.273355096578598,
0.06896134465932846,
0.3824826776981354,
0.37272074818611145,
-0.3848649561405182,
-0.08911778777837753,
-0.8613808751106262,
-0.5319315791130066,
1.0287870168685913,
-0.1908499002456665,
-0.35243144631385803,
0.08039200305938721,
0.07922355830669403,
0.4994441866874695,
0.21037551760673523,
-0.2699362337589264,
-0.28406256437301636,
-0.43103650212287903,
-0.5731852054595947,
-0.47903743386268616,
0.15788358449935913,
-0.39246729016304016,
-0.20372100174427032,
0.5429199934005737,
-0.39859098196029663,
0.21280239522457123,
0.14372918009757996,
-0.25761547684669495,
-0.34021830558776855,
0.14439547061920166,
0.6610738635063171,
0.8104574084281921,
-0.4858461320400238,
0.05252687260508537,
-0.2650480270385742,
-0.8752982020378113,
-0.2417592704296112,
0.25073349475860596,
-0.1670634150505066,
0.08810091018676758,
0.25848299264907837,
0.5335900783538818,
0.22025693953037262,
-0.9809624552726746,
0.379655659198761,
-0.2235293984413147,
-0.2870977818965912,
-0.2069830745458603,
-0.26041021943092346,
0.05869540944695473,
0.13024300336837769,
0.5571011304855347,
0.5381760001182556,
0.2456880658864975,
-0.6904004812240601,
0.07398191839456558,
0.4280240833759308,
-0.9955334067344666,
-0.31767135858535767,
0.777911365032196,
0.23756110668182373,
0.1047409176826477,
0.7523707151412964,
-0.18000759184360504,
-0.32152286171913147,
0.9578232765197754,
0.22464798390865326,
0.32784900069236755,
-0.03255262225866318,
0.608806312084198,
0.023287149146199226,
0.2786698043346405,
-0.02368059754371643,
0.2732852101325989,
0.34296298027038574,
-0.5834842324256897,
-0.14181208610534668,
-0.3112032413482666,
-0.35253995656967163,
0.3955489993095398,
-0.6902905702590942,
0.008929906412959099,
-0.67857825756073,
-0.05244928225874901,
0.5876026749610901,
0.2086431384086609,
-0.5071225166320801,
0.743376612663269,
0.06710018962621689,
0.34670668840408325,
-0.7076418399810791,
0.824125349521637,
0.8258223533630371,
-0.16471286118030548,
-0.40464863181114197,
-0.435176283121109,
0.07224723696708679,
-1.0275368690490723,
0.899810791015625,
0.06170139089226723,
0.17178714275360107,
-0.006163998041301966,
-0.44751089811325073,
-0.5637173652648926,
0.9574013948440552,
-0.05583924800157547,
-0.33606529235839844,
0.09370598942041397,
0.15412423014640808,
0.646464467048645,
-0.8172271847724915,
0.34404677152633667,
0.10234355926513672,
0.5843275189399719,
0.11810872703790665,
-0.8852968811988831,
-0.07812171429395676,
-0.18339239060878754,
-0.3719436526298523,
0.07900422066450119,
-0.24797306954860687,
1.000546932220459,
-0.4849483072757721,
-0.13520514965057373,
0.22185832262039185,
0.0373491607606411,
0.2550777792930603,
1.0151692628860474,
0.3417588174343109,
0.7033178806304932,
1.0212223529815674,
-0.021367404609918594,
1.157084345817566,
-0.44517526030540466,
0.019424743950366974,
0.40169405937194824,
0.044141754508018494,
0.4916486144065857,
0.2871027886867523,
0.058362144976854324,
0.2494012713432312,
0.6311142444610596,
0.10440179705619812,
0.6311303377151489,
-0.27646327018737793,
-0.00974656455218792,
-0.8228693604469299,
-0.2706984579563141,
-0.45419082045555115,
0.34196096658706665,
0.7957175970077515,
-0.46747350692749023,
0.08145815134048462,
-0.06017616018652916,
-0.4175648093223572,
-0.13541826605796814,
-0.5012851357460022,
0.46743306517601013,
0.21821415424346924,
-0.37828466296195984,
0.5093441009521484,
-0.2713027894496918,
0.6197103261947632,
-0.5515845417976379,
-0.08751192688941956,
-0.0645315870642662,
0.6213276386260986,
-0.46870478987693787,
-0.5898798704147339,
0.25946491956710815,
-0.3353923261165619,
-0.4848892390727997,
0.20916448533535004,
0.28209125995635986,
-0.20554539561271667,
-0.9079214930534363,
0.05146724730730057,
0.7732757925987244,
0.31764841079711914,
0.13102608919143677,
-0.6999853849411011,
0.012089736759662628,
0.084246926009655,
0.36693838238716125,
0.3644511103630066,
0.6113837361335754,
-0.19756393134593964,
1.014803171157837,
0.5943120121955872,
0.29226356744766235,
-0.1622520387172699,
-0.3837173879146576,
0.5783302783966064,
-0.5477356910705566,
-0.5568671822547913,
-0.13884827494621277,
0.42425206303596497,
-0.10257155448198318,
-0.7196420431137085,
0.33459794521331787,
0.3676741421222687,
0.49777159094810486,
-0.051621463149785995,
0.6300800442695618,
0.15705788135528564,
0.736650824546814,
-0.3373073637485504,
0.7613906860351562,
-0.9753737449645996,
0.3606273829936981,
-0.127254918217659,
-0.16388030350208282,
-0.42574724555015564,
0.5610261559486389,
-0.23671600222587585,
0.13246531784534454,
0.9033591151237488,
0.5600811839103699,
-0.428822785615921,
0.18040844798088074,
0.5807724595069885,
0.5236154198646545,
0.01341719925403595,
0.6919379830360413,
0.8021800518035889,
-0.29873955249786377,
0.7579304575920105,
-0.5745176076889038,
-0.22536733746528625,
-0.6394522786140442,
-0.5752581357955933,
-0.5045808553695679,
-0.4515600800514221,
-0.554440975189209,
-0.03929243981838226,
0.29344144463539124,
0.2375011295080185,
1.1866157054901123,
-0.7041590213775635,
0.021111460402607918,
0.004449818283319473,
0.4344416558742523,
-0.836732804775238,
-0.14728820323944092,
0.42965391278266907,
0.18621090054512024,
-0.5686249732971191,
0.36364614963531494,
0.19085483253002167,
-0.21686458587646484,
-0.13690538704395294,
-0.05527869984507561,
0.08759113401174545,
-0.32790809869766235,
0.5660959482192993,
0.4513428211212158,
-0.8890802264213562,
0.23864974081516266,
-0.037968821823596954,
-0.068364217877388,
0.20212551951408386,
0.5677592158317566,
-1.0419585704803467,
0.8167665600776672,
0.03418993204832077,
0.2765220105648041,
0.26053503155708313,
-0.20429092645645142,
0.41729891300201416,
0.02282029390335083,
-0.016402488574385643,
0.6543858051300049,
0.0913599506020546,
0.4610646665096283,
-0.5205526351928711,
0.44005656242370605,
0.5879244208335876,
-0.26616114377975464,
-1.0258612632751465,
0.09786979854106903,
-1.219462513923645,
-0.5411077737808228,
0.6017704010009766,
-0.30476608872413635,
-0.31817978620529175,
-0.5958476066589355,
0.3645029067993164,
0.09855316579341888,
-0.38814228773117065,
0.8828951120376587,
0.2087513506412506,
-0.3607254922389984,
-0.3306530714035034,
-0.6304721236228943,
0.5464612245559692,
0.50424724817276,
-0.8916026949882507,
-0.12466350197792053,
0.3682948648929596,
0.37319228053092957,
0.11062385886907578,
0.22118888795375824,
-0.3400477468967438,
0.8578625917434692,
0.2354474812746048,
-0.24795787036418915,
-0.37475454807281494,
-0.30958500504493713,
-0.35658395290374756,
0.3811247944831848,
-0.21553516387939453,
0.08582963794469833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05101v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05101v3
|
Rule-driven News Captioning
| 2024-03-08T07:06:43 | 2024-03-14T08:00:51 |
Ning Xu, Tingting Zhang, Hongshuo Tian, An-An Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
News captioning task aims to generate sentences by describing named entities
or concrete events for an image with its news article. Existing methods have
achieved remarkable results by relying on the large-scale pre-trained models,
which primarily focus on the correlations between the input news content and
the output predictions. However, the news captioning requires adhering to some
fundamental rules of news reporting, such as accurately describing the
individuals and actions associated with the event. In this paper, we propose
the rule-driven news captioning method, which can generate image descriptions
following designated rule signal. Specifically, we first design the news-aware
semantic rule for the descriptions. This rule incorporates the primary action
depicted in the image (e.g., "performing") and the roles played by named
entities involved in the action (e.g., "Agent" and "Place"). Second, we inject
this semantic rule into the large-scale pre-trained model, BART, with the
prefix-tuning strategy, where multiple encoder layers are embedded with
news-aware semantic rule. Finally, we can effectively guide BART to generate
news sentences that comply with the designated rule. Extensive experiments on
two widely used datasets (i.e., GoodNews and NYTimes800k) demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.28742849826812744,
-0.7524798512458801,
0.5530474781990051,
0.5360523462295532,
-0.9106277227401733,
-0.29017749428749084,
-0.07243002206087112,
-0.20767755806446075,
0.5784667730331421,
0.7226018905639648,
-0.9097414612770081,
-0.5419092178344727,
-0.46576690673828125,
0.2611251175403595,
-0.6443899273872375,
1.2128124237060547,
-0.12888383865356445,
0.03429510071873665,
-0.24110139906406403,
0.1110898032784462,
-0.6919465065002441,
0.0223110169172287,
-0.3718757629394531,
0.371171236038208,
0.7252310514450073,
0.3746320307254791,
0.8052369952201843,
1.0409696102142334,
0.6474273800849915,
0.2115122377872467,
0.19619205594062805,
0.4508509933948517,
-0.31061092019081116,
-0.1540880650281906,
-0.07876035571098328,
-0.1908886730670929,
-0.2548366189002991,
0.24431143701076508,
0.4469960927963257,
0.25924715399742126,
0.132350891828537,
0.15237650275230408,
-0.3437134623527527,
0.6181231737136841,
-0.2600252330303192,
0.5787804126739502,
-0.6205731630325317,
0.14446572959423065,
-0.07887805998325348,
-0.6935622096061707,
-0.38224127888679504,
-0.35544613003730774,
-0.1263536661863327,
-1.0448793172836304,
0.20319625735282898,
0.4173067510128021,
1.2669692039489746,
0.22527746856212616,
-0.5087267160415649,
-0.3024909496307373,
-0.4313882887363434,
0.3110028803348541,
-0.7143696546554565,
0.12444346398115158,
0.16367092728614807,
0.17395378649234772,
-0.20956602692604065,
-0.6149771213531494,
-0.6267171502113342,
0.0007285152096301317,
-0.4890129566192627,
0.12306924909353256,
0.03945044428110123,
-0.006448825821280479,
0.2768119275569916,
0.1651444435119629,
-0.3035021126270294,
-0.05845474451780319,
-0.5133305788040161,
-0.03367041051387787,
0.6557472944259644,
0.08123847842216492,
0.06031724438071251,
-0.34995657205581665,
-0.598308265209198,
-0.04176924750208855,
-0.7116553783416748,
-0.1284271627664566,
0.24130624532699585,
0.4557347297668457,
-0.12155835330486298,
0.6972589492797852,
-0.5739580988883972,
0.6760317087173462,
0.2014976292848587,
-0.22749511897563934,
0.1889762133359909,
-0.34030020236968994,
-0.04193730279803276,
0.2871323823928833,
0.5509186387062073,
1.0767316818237305,
0.3403658866882324,
-0.3344740867614746,
-0.27017778158187866,
-0.07452166080474854,
0.45576927065849304,
-0.8656435608863831,
0.16072022914886475,
-0.1677902787923813,
-0.5038699507713318,
-0.6161344051361084,
0.3791767656803131,
-0.82771897315979,
-0.32207781076431274,
-0.7972812056541443,
0.8161495923995972,
0.01569337584078312,
-0.14271681010723114,
-0.015888500958681107,
-0.13770215213298798,
0.4725683927536011,
0.19474822282791138,
-0.5786720514297485,
0.4312175512313843,
0.4220412075519562,
0.6115772724151611,
-0.05318364128470421,
-0.20962491631507874,
-1.0061962604522705,
0.5117120742797852,
-0.531338632106781,
0.6036718487739563,
-0.27532848715782166,
0.4078488051891327,
0.06401080638170242,
-0.03522833064198494,
0.13403214514255524,
-0.11022575944662094,
0.3647412061691284,
-0.9928300976753235,
-0.018593458458781242,
-0.06482312828302383,
-0.6468439102172852,
-0.21621902287006378,
0.05957959219813347,
-0.7415729761123657,
0.19005045294761658,
-0.1400764137506485,
-0.8090663552284241,
0.6360765099525452,
-0.8825197219848633,
-1.1261823177337646,
-0.04840070381760597,
-0.06730017811059952,
-0.6389107704162598,
0.22020888328552246,
0.7049192190170288,
0.6707896590232849,
0.09006433188915253,
0.47248855233192444,
0.22767873108386993,
-0.1829984337091446,
0.08980489522218704,
-0.11586444079875946,
0.13579106330871582,
0.1130308210849762,
-0.28697308897972107,
0.4130575954914093,
-0.6064538359642029,
-0.1252206265926361,
0.31406599283218384,
-0.14225275814533234,
-0.07349499315023422,
0.22544141113758087,
-0.05802391096949577,
0.14189817011356354,
-0.1339016556739807,
-0.47885823249816895,
-0.02284996584057808,
-0.013219691812992096,
0.4842032194137573,
0.4858250617980957,
0.26404425501823425,
0.5326645970344543,
-0.2714329957962036,
0.29210126399993896,
0.0835263580083847,
0.30555635690689087,
-0.6778445839881897,
-0.03783562779426575,
-0.5348526239395142,
-0.2522047758102417,
0.4930129051208496,
0.3350367546081543,
-0.7759224772453308,
0.5668821930885315,
-0.4795578122138977,
-0.22816595435142517,
-0.2643105089664459,
-0.042995259165763855,
0.21045330166816711,
0.46416717767715454,
0.3782671391963959,
-0.24339967966079712,
-0.5655615329742432,
-0.8937991261482239,
-0.07938677817583084,
0.19492217898368835,
0.4768287241458893,
0.216594859957695,
0.07686848938465118,
0.1263643503189087,
0.9791117906570435,
-0.4964219331741333,
-0.613160252571106,
-0.33325085043907166,
0.2524447441101074,
0.10427916795015335,
0.28398069739341736,
0.3398231267929077,
-1.2924411296844482,
-0.0961805135011673,
-0.26371800899505615,
-0.48228317499160767,
-0.20215995609760284,
-0.6306613683700562,
-0.24993157386779785,
0.3397774398326874,
0.8584322929382324,
-0.7391080856323242,
0.6849127411842346,
0.24894534051418304,
-0.2811252474784851,
0.6367279887199402,
-0.05826755240559578,
0.16434374451637268,
-0.9318339824676514,
-0.3617296516895294,
0.06159232184290886,
-0.5734962821006775,
-0.21657279133796692,
0.21153458952903748,
-0.00920425821095705,
-0.1510114222764969,
-0.3793066442012787,
0.33426401019096375,
-0.6063909530639648,
-0.21884150803089142,
-0.48348960280418396,
-0.00364651158452034,
0.029525164514780045,
0.4900577962398529,
0.5121162533760071,
0.17024795711040497,
0.909430742263794,
-0.7928686141967773,
0.42817533016204834,
0.19532866775989532,
-0.47909268736839294,
0.22077561914920807,
-0.4858134686946869,
-0.33815863728523254,
-0.4010227620601654,
0.3131011426448822,
-0.7449470162391663,
-0.35673996806144714,
0.10596439242362976,
-0.2716617286205292,
0.19649064540863037,
-0.04753071442246437,
-0.9736049175262451,
-0.3966499865055084,
0.011077534407377243,
0.09736612439155579,
0.5027867555618286,
-0.3142704665660858,
0.6034868955612183,
0.022641172632575035,
-0.180567666888237,
-0.15052443742752075,
-0.5053907632827759,
0.22953155636787415,
-0.3433551490306854,
-0.4381736218929291,
0.424002468585968,
0.20728200674057007,
0.13434581458568573,
0.22471773624420166,
-0.06454770267009735,
-0.0414087176322937,
-0.05827575549483299,
0.35426944494247437,
0.13625720143318176,
-0.13605448603630066,
0.2409728467464447,
0.17092642188072205,
0.0610843263566494,
0.10164134204387665,
0.05628032609820366,
0.4087601900100708,
0.13742683827877045,
-0.19193439185619354,
-0.6763449907302856,
0.5336344838142395,
0.6794897317886353,
-0.6832956075668335,
0.44058236479759216,
0.6041592359542847,
-0.07969387620687485,
-0.09690278023481369,
-0.2859114110469818,
-0.5412355065345764,
-0.417603075504303,
0.3988715708255768,
-0.16446126997470856,
-0.551119863986969,
0.3088156580924988,
-0.10026713460683823,
0.07422589510679245,
0.2715491056442261,
0.2584093511104584,
-0.14078906178474426,
0.9411300420761108,
0.4974789321422577,
0.04372096806764603,
0.524980366230011,
0.10313039273023605,
0.2427448034286499,
-0.25192365050315857,
0.09661330282688141,
0.07385730743408203,
-0.553783118724823,
-0.3829405903816223,
-0.14965848624706268,
0.37785443663597107,
0.03365969657897949,
-0.1080356165766716,
0.39053910970687866,
-0.24596303701400757,
0.6409767270088196,
0.7524829506874084,
0.14261747896671295,
0.33126625418663025,
0.26862820982933044,
0.24931611120700836,
0.06686298549175262,
-0.6955738663673401,
-0.312695175409317,
0.8509224653244019,
0.19387349486351013,
1.0358740091323853,
-0.08390223979949951,
0.7441118955612183,
0.39714857935905457,
0.20143190026283264,
-0.630419135093689,
0.7075942158699036,
-0.021733760833740234,
-0.4021744430065155,
-0.25586408376693726,
-0.47777611017227173,
-0.8849763870239258,
-0.04997588321566582,
-0.3041365444660187,
-0.11986713111400604,
-0.3088138997554779,
-0.04955550655722618,
-0.3485255241394043,
-0.007531547453254461,
-0.4293082356452942,
0.7126607298851013,
-0.28980350494384766,
0.1343982070684433,
-0.42560967803001404,
-0.8966085314750671,
0.20508255064487457,
0.1568746566772461,
0.42835646867752075,
-0.05255252867937088,
0.06665781140327454,
0.5501052737236023,
-0.2944818139076233,
1.0415953397750854,
-0.2593364715576172,
0.10804169625043869,
0.4370555877685547,
-0.011473534628748894,
0.4714641571044922,
0.12201233953237534,
0.58912593126297,
-0.35379719734191895,
-0.16153137385845184,
-0.17854100465774536,
-0.44992685317993164,
0.36335161328315735,
-0.45167726278305054,
-0.6945791244506836,
-0.19409608840942383,
-0.6505427956581116,
0.06391295790672302,
0.3900968134403229,
0.3289116322994232,
0.8444927930831909,
-0.018691174685955048,
0.036636848002672195,
0.3885892629623413,
0.11325951665639877,
0.6842730045318604,
0.8178824782371521,
-0.3508414328098297,
-0.38902032375335693,
0.874284565448761,
-0.09258430451154709,
-0.011700468137860298,
0.6271079182624817,
0.008480536751449108,
-0.2530573308467865,
-0.5876957774162292,
-0.6709581017494202,
0.21650035679340363,
-0.32534703612327576,
-0.6144240498542786,
-0.3787764310836792,
-0.18384601175785065,
-0.32433557510375977,
-0.29840177297592163,
-0.28308412432670593,
-0.24488534033298492,
-0.19386176764965057,
-0.1512441635131836,
0.49488362669944763,
0.5083936452865601,
0.13806195557117462,
0.37392154335975647,
-0.812311053276062,
0.6568027138710022,
0.34886443614959717,
0.38368648290634155,
-0.18334628641605377,
-0.2236248254776001,
-0.14187365770339966,
-0.06608285009860992,
-0.3154277205467224,
-0.7687737941741943,
0.3906400501728058,
0.16205811500549316,
0.5880647897720337,
0.5138452649116516,
0.4965202212333679,
0.530040442943573,
-0.8723641037940979,
0.5691111087799072,
0.23063305020332336,
-0.803560733795166,
0.8751828074455261,
-0.457520991563797,
-0.025052880868315697,
0.23980936408042908,
0.05186495929956436,
-0.24523182213306427,
-0.7346009612083435,
-0.47268927097320557,
-0.7816413044929504,
0.6250073313713074,
0.19470639526844025,
0.5778840184211731,
-0.24202705919742584,
0.41469326615333557,
0.1439942568540573,
0.4184844493865967,
-0.9439371228218079,
0.09096749871969223,
-0.31119057536125183,
-0.2955295145511627,
0.1801256388425827,
-0.01031602080911398,
-0.18035638332366943,
-0.26560771465301514,
0.5306447148323059,
-0.3286252021789551,
0.18709787726402283,
0.3716309070587158,
-0.35107502341270447,
-0.1771765649318695,
0.10157763212919235,
0.7604172825813293,
0.6547700762748718,
0.011605809442698956,
-0.023255454376339912,
-0.5756127238273621,
-0.07757235318422318,
-0.05459516495466232,
0.46420788764953613,
-0.28150424361228943,
0.10090356320142746,
0.2789994776248932,
0.9535147547721863,
0.22142872214317322,
-0.6283241510391235,
0.7813696265220642,
-0.07208435237407684,
-0.3678293228149414,
-0.13163939118385315,
0.04848702996969223,
-0.07497265934944153,
0.26294252276420593,
0.5781766772270203,
0.02579166553914547,
0.08351418375968933,
-0.5495890378952026,
0.27638134360313416,
0.22575116157531738,
-0.17479683458805084,
-0.15044139325618744,
0.7461985349655151,
0.4106708765029907,
0.17582596838474274,
0.47404053807258606,
-0.4910273551940918,
-0.3593786358833313,
0.8470944762229919,
0.6800076365470886,
0.5161023139953613,
0.46526092290878296,
0.5334666967391968,
0.18896445631980896,
0.25728917121887207,
-0.13510297238826752,
0.22681492567062378,
0.04207811877131462,
-0.7115384936332703,
-0.7591387629508972,
-0.5565330386161804,
0.021648941561579704,
-0.048192352056503296,
-0.7279255986213684,
0.29457151889801025,
-0.2242913544178009,
0.09074386954307556,
0.3043660819530487,
-0.141886368393898,
-0.4626351594924927,
0.27051031589508057,
0.4480234682559967,
1.1199334859848022,
-0.9266993999481201,
0.3400667905807495,
0.9141051769256592,
-0.45776447653770447,
-0.787063479423523,
0.20466595888137817,
-0.24594701826572418,
-0.4511253237724304,
0.5017219185829163,
0.4813699424266815,
0.35395628213882446,
0.23603077232837677,
-0.7242505550384521,
-0.6785988807678223,
1.164865255355835,
0.2355041801929474,
-0.3713321387767792,
0.14939139783382416,
-0.028694601729512215,
0.19692854583263397,
-0.8980239629745483,
-0.37133359909057617,
0.012992371805012226,
0.7344716787338257,
0.28456127643585205,
-0.7916856408119202,
0.10267246514558792,
0.057244736701250076,
-0.09147926419973373,
0.1350025087594986,
-0.6672271490097046,
0.49177122116088867,
-0.7073356509208679,
-0.20919537544250488,
0.225847527384758,
1.0683040618896484,
-0.10957027226686478,
0.4252643585205078,
0.6120243668556213,
0.4658186137676239,
0.3590919077396393,
-0.0935305505990982,
1.233528971672058,
-0.0741201639175415,
0.04532057046890259,
0.9995927810668945,
-0.14009550213813782,
0.3958722651004791,
0.25260087847709656,
0.22730018198490143,
0.614048421382904,
0.4788277745246887,
-0.26065170764923096,
1.0664857625961304,
0.22034773230552673,
0.10815326124429703,
-0.35300785303115845,
-0.2428508996963501,
0.10209785401821136,
0.5608346462249756,
0.10328900814056396,
-0.7310190200805664,
-0.48066210746765137,
0.21094264090061188,
-0.02205432951450348,
0.19327419996261597,
-1.052162766456604,
1.0654939413070679,
-0.30804842710494995,
-0.6839613318443298,
0.08387894928455353,
0.10829608887434006,
0.331301748752594,
-0.5108347535133362,
-0.010005312040448189,
0.039004135876894,
-0.18034538626670837,
-0.06479275226593018,
-0.8788090348243713,
0.20281651616096497,
-0.1199459508061409,
-0.4483306109905243,
-0.19690506160259247,
0.6784238219261169,
-0.7216507196426392,
-0.4948544204235077,
-0.2206336110830307,
0.3399741053581238,
0.12383074313402176,
-0.1783892661333084,
-0.09546586126089096,
-0.1173272654414177,
-0.1734170764684677,
-0.2517048716545105,
0.07440606504678726,
0.49974533915519714,
-0.4254548251628876,
0.2987949252128601,
0.38906678557395935,
0.0040397983975708485,
0.1394253522157669,
0.2816353440284729,
0.91990727186203,
-0.5962691903114319,
-0.8916239142417908,
-0.6455905437469482,
0.2888752520084381,
-0.11890231817960739,
-0.05839475244283676,
0.36151567101478577,
0.603561520576477,
0.4280618727207184,
-0.4710732698440552,
0.5941898226737976,
-0.252215176820755,
0.2052961140871048,
-0.7268415689468384,
0.4727309048175812,
-0.3706757128238678,
-0.3839981257915497,
0.0032117825467139482,
-0.8017503023147583,
-0.4330224096775055,
0.1641114056110382,
0.010918154381215572,
-0.1807817965745926,
0.5148902535438538,
0.7226832509040833,
0.0406993106007576,
0.07755322754383087,
0.08806014806032181,
0.06839413195848465,
-0.006104234140366316,
0.15210731327533722,
0.5881743431091309,
-0.11783000081777573,
0.6022104620933533,
-0.1765189915895462,
0.0027582894545048475,
-0.22552697360515594,
-1.2584823369979858,
-0.8189517259597778,
-0.5494053959846497,
-0.7314407825469971,
0.125596284866333,
0.09216933697462082,
0.5907320380210876,
1.0498539209365845,
-0.5707292556762695,
0.4055381119251251,
-0.37120532989501953,
0.23370712995529175,
-0.6406909823417664,
-0.27537012100219727,
0.5238431692123413,
-0.6396041512489319,
-0.5221375226974487,
-0.011458944529294968,
-0.027315065264701843,
0.05884166434407234,
0.11563768237829208,
0.02151702158153057,
0.08713444322347641,
0.21687881648540497,
0.5326011776924133,
-0.00821016263216734,
-0.6116803288459778,
-0.32712283730506897,
-0.31318384408950806,
-0.20869648456573486,
-0.1301630586385727,
0.8993750214576721,
-0.7492316961288452,
0.07486473768949509,
0.04391578584909439,
0.36875295639038086,
0.37828072905540466,
0.4183885455131531,
0.4478539824485779,
-1.135453701019287,
-0.043454620987176895,
0.004551892634481192,
0.07888856530189514,
0.2612605094909668,
-0.44870591163635254,
0.29000282287597656,
0.12634065747261047,
-0.30851510167121887,
-0.3797204792499542,
0.05593102425336838,
-1.3054598569869995,
-0.16543224453926086,
1.2981032133102417,
0.18440069258213043,
-0.270528644323349,
0.4790232479572296,
-0.34399551153182983,
0.17792046070098877,
-0.422305166721344,
0.5532567501068115,
0.406640887260437,
0.05673987790942192,
-0.5036918520927429,
-0.4577538073062897,
0.4547915756702423,
-0.06216361001133919,
-0.6590041518211365,
0.137887641787529,
0.7027779221534729,
0.2727457284927368,
0.07149028033018112,
0.23470500111579895,
-0.32293668389320374,
0.5311548709869385,
-0.27184760570526123,
0.14086970686912537,
-0.6567151546478271,
-0.47322922945022583,
0.19508938491344452,
-0.02966456115245819,
-0.3855280876159668,
-0.5568252205848694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05065v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05065v1
|
Can we obtain significant success in RST discourse parsing by using Large Language Models?
| 2024-03-08T05:34:29 | 2024-03-08T05:34:29 |
Aru Maekawa, Tsutomu Hirao, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Manabu Okumura
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, decoder-only pre-trained large language models (LLMs), with several
tens of billion parameters, have significantly impacted a wide range of natural
language processing (NLP) tasks. While encoder-only or encoder-decoder
pre-trained language models have already proved to be effective in discourse
parsing, the extent to which LLMs can perform this task remains an open
research question. Therefore, this paper explores how beneficial such LLMs are
for Rhetorical Structure Theory (RST) discourse parsing. Here, the parsing
process for both fundamental top-down and bottom-up strategies is converted
into prompts, which LLMs can work with. We employ Llama 2 and fine-tune it with
QLoRA, which has fewer parameters that can be tuned. Experimental results on
three benchmark datasets, RST-DT, Instr-DT, and the GUM corpus, demonstrate
that Llama 2 with 70 billion parameters in the bottom-up strategy obtained
state-of-the-art (SOTA) results with significant differences. Furthermore, our
parsers demonstrated generalizability when evaluated on RST-DT, showing that,
in spite of being trained with the GUM corpus, it obtained similar performances
to those of existing parsers trained with RST-DT.
|
[
-0.16742174327373505,
-0.5865676403045654,
0.8296495079994202,
0.23998472094535828,
-0.7563663721084595,
0.16420085728168488,
-0.13994824886322021,
-0.13890701532363892,
0.046768590807914734,
0.38563162088394165,
-0.12337837368249893,
-0.371753990650177,
-0.6436529159545898,
0.3084023892879486,
-0.18472057580947876,
0.8152384161949158,
0.2945541739463806,
0.2561724781990051,
0.05084557831287384,
0.14244838058948517,
-0.504603922367096,
-0.686699390411377,
-0.7173101902008057,
-0.26885536313056946,
0.7363004684448242,
0.3274253010749817,
0.4770728647708893,
0.6922073364257812,
0.21761873364448547,
0.21617116034030914,
-0.6498084664344788,
0.1334267407655716,
-0.5068879723548889,
0.4085690677165985,
-0.36354830861091614,
-0.6161983609199524,
-0.28221726417541504,
-0.2013871669769287,
0.8713408708572388,
0.6404221653938293,
-0.14049409329891205,
0.08694270998239517,
0.22512859106063843,
0.5144619345664978,
-0.37754639983177185,
-0.011627734638750553,
-0.8021117448806763,
0.05962492525577545,
-0.4093944728374481,
-0.6294838190078735,
-0.7213141322135925,
-0.4540724754333496,
-0.008500915952026844,
-0.38329842686653137,
-0.30997174978256226,
0.297966331243515,
0.8862196207046509,
0.10981503874063492,
-0.48088502883911133,
-0.3014141321182251,
-0.4567917585372925,
0.7396839261054993,
-0.7933282256126404,
0.20832957327365875,
0.2464994490146637,
0.19442389905452728,
-0.2792317867279053,
-0.591896116733551,
-0.15495511889457703,
-0.3389640152454376,
-0.18960978090763092,
-0.20190563797950745,
-0.29599636793136597,
0.19745084643363953,
0.45389607548713684,
0.37249669432640076,
-0.6713538765907288,
0.32636281847953796,
-0.261602520942688,
0.04830649495124817,
0.05986440181732178,
0.06159379705786705,
0.17198258638381958,
-0.5795755982398987,
-0.37401142716407776,
-0.05306572839617729,
-1.137420654296875,
0.10303738713264465,
0.11051400750875473,
0.44923073053359985,
0.0048285010270774364,
0.6407153010368347,
0.1722690910100937,
0.6234381794929504,
0.014396918006241322,
-0.18184241652488708,
-0.3548431098461151,
-0.14719650149345398,
-0.4323204755783081,
-0.1346145123243332,
0.5872384905815125,
-0.11257331073284149,
0.31644758582115173,
-0.11849597096443176,
-0.15686443448066711,
0.0667499452829361,
-0.08777189254760742,
-0.9267561435699463,
-0.06453369557857513,
0.006877541076391935,
-0.35741060972213745,
-0.11402121931314468,
-0.2942138612270355,
-0.5396770238876343,
-0.39081284403800964,
-0.5012126564979553,
-0.1360706388950348,
-0.5068380832672119,
-0.24507099390029907,
0.3551417291164398,
-0.0008746612584218383,
0.7259082794189453,
0.2754802107810974,
-0.7833254933357239,
0.464565247297287,
1.0057036876678467,
0.9729994535446167,
-0.0584622360765934,
0.13403230905532837,
-0.8809273838996887,
0.034994203597307205,
-0.4775424301624298,
1.1813418865203857,
-0.7683229446411133,
-0.20464517176151276,
-0.10321369767189026,
-0.33788782358169556,
-0.15401698648929596,
-0.6048992276191711,
0.6932988166809082,
-0.7490338087081909,
0.03676636517047882,
-0.6440233588218689,
-0.5158644914627075,
-0.004172120708972216,
0.5255212783813477,
-0.43007832765579224,
0.8281136155128479,
0.028399180620908737,
-0.6724181771278381,
-0.06744614243507385,
-0.377030611038208,
-0.4994649887084961,
0.018687622621655464,
-0.22294986248016357,
-0.14810052514076233,
0.29955437779426575,
0.292881578207016,
0.4305214285850525,
-0.6493920683860779,
0.6361537575721741,
-0.08439238369464874,
-0.25163671374320984,
0.2691023647785187,
-0.4446770250797272,
0.8676703572273254,
0.17834916710853577,
-0.10458597540855408,
0.21070370078086853,
-0.7227110266685486,
0.05210437625646591,
0.11291090399026871,
-0.444216251373291,
-0.2284671515226364,
-0.23536476492881775,
-0.1352103352546692,
0.3117406368255615,
-0.0686771348118782,
-0.44204118847846985,
0.1927938461303711,
-0.7227464318275452,
0.7380964159965515,
0.8221743106842041,
-0.01084090769290924,
0.1747387796640396,
-0.1853599101305008,
0.7514111995697021,
-0.07479804754257202,
-0.5605311989784241,
-0.4601131081581116,
-0.3368123173713684,
-0.6750497817993164,
-0.3299998641014099,
0.5760590434074402,
0.5208674669265747,
-0.5191460251808167,
0.32334989309310913,
-0.21535925567150116,
-0.3118227422237396,
-0.33515504002571106,
-0.0673251673579216,
0.6116320490837097,
0.5161683559417725,
0.2952137291431427,
-0.1278495043516159,
-0.9026075601577759,
-0.8476653695106506,
-0.36610275506973267,
-0.10733760893344879,
-0.1403498500585556,
-0.07668399810791016,
0.3052256107330322,
0.38852402567863464,
0.9154008626937866,
-0.47580721974372864,
-0.08680184930562973,
-0.5977972149848938,
0.008012339472770691,
0.22172214090824127,
0.23786316812038422,
0.5300176739692688,
-0.37822315096855164,
-0.49421021342277527,
-0.07497484236955643,
-0.4771175682544708,
-0.2111533135175705,
0.04394228011369705,
-0.18029911816120148,
-0.08049488812685013,
0.4575798809528351,
-1.005308747291565,
0.15437264740467072,
0.2881942689418793,
-0.19784598052501678,
0.4781041145324707,
-0.10597836971282959,
-0.15164722502231598,
-1.200612187385559,
0.02819409780204296,
0.13378524780273438,
-0.4431539475917816,
-0.6418769955635071,
0.07238761335611343,
0.033704955130815506,
-0.16149857640266418,
-0.5559500455856323,
0.31286147236824036,
-0.45577290654182434,
-0.4858170449733734,
-0.24268023669719696,
0.12017274647951126,
0.2376246452331543,
0.5661078691482544,
0.08399473875761032,
0.8849858045578003,
0.4236835539340973,
-0.5233291387557983,
-0.015203109942376614,
0.16772790253162384,
-0.3652450740337372,
0.5666114091873169,
-0.9998016953468323,
0.30634334683418274,
-0.1958227902650833,
0.5004808902740479,
-1.370168924331665,
-0.06059686094522476,
0.31451141834259033,
-0.08181557059288025,
0.35362809896469116,
-0.12461850047111511,
-0.49482712149620056,
-0.04496772214770317,
-0.41627025604248047,
0.4965459108352661,
0.39162203669548035,
-0.5533580780029297,
0.5056904554367065,
0.27431055903434753,
-0.3884437680244446,
-0.4718738794326782,
-0.6362500190734863,
0.36881017684936523,
-0.38987571001052856,
-0.5395745635032654,
0.3859306573867798,
0.11606719344854355,
-0.2865121066570282,
-0.3559255003929138,
0.10711966454982758,
0.20026370882987976,
0.014295697212219238,
0.15961496531963348,
0.04233831912279129,
-0.6528288722038269,
0.10392455011606216,
0.16298896074295044,
-0.3505317270755768,
-0.018229911103844643,
-0.21710683405399323,
0.9299443364143372,
-0.33845940232276917,
-0.26866474747657776,
-0.7430868744850159,
0.2470693141222,
0.3376932144165039,
-0.41331273317337036,
0.584044873714447,
-0.014995007775723934,
-0.13940481841564178,
0.013805934228003025,
-0.46272310614585876,
-0.044838253408670425,
-0.43142619729042053,
0.17093782126903534,
-0.4748246967792511,
-1.1146235466003418,
0.316765159368515,
-0.360853374004364,
0.05980388820171356,
0.31303462386131287,
0.41596290469169617,
0.030166300013661385,
0.8474161624908447,
0.19342422485351562,
-0.07539436966180801,
0.1880466639995575,
-0.000997909577563405,
0.2769710123538971,
-0.9993823766708374,
0.12869112193584442,
-0.7794570922851562,
-0.13782426714897156,
-0.332767128944397,
-0.39542242884635925,
0.24494722485542297,
0.006410347763448954,
-0.3992055356502533,
0.2255675345659256,
-0.4208432137966156,
0.6945978999137878,
0.31331393122673035,
-0.16685910522937775,
0.4652674198150635,
0.13517163693904877,
-0.009618480689823627,
-0.2516588866710663,
-0.48727765679359436,
-0.8392901420593262,
0.8089309930801392,
0.6090357303619385,
0.4663236439228058,
0.05861986428499222,
0.3997035622596741,
0.06616483628749847,
0.170309379696846,
-0.8948877453804016,
0.8750489354133606,
-0.25162333250045776,
-0.11892003566026688,
-0.1466795951128006,
-0.2038886845111847,
-1.066297173500061,
0.7427710890769958,
0.13784784078598022,
-0.41854697465896606,
0.12106213718652725,
0.03016294725239277,
-0.5662504434585571,
0.34177613258361816,
-0.30730968713760376,
0.5098087191581726,
-0.22323167324066162,
-0.17508380115032196,
-0.019156446680426598,
-0.5990506410598755,
0.34790825843811035,
0.22425004839897156,
0.13138265907764435,
-0.12867239117622375,
-0.08542703092098236,
0.6875966787338257,
-0.08216410130262375,
0.9548770785331726,
-0.11557435989379883,
-0.42883792519569397,
0.2664879560470581,
0.20962731540203094,
0.4353369474411011,
0.050130460411310196,
-0.2023831158876419,
0.05076150968670845,
-0.1258733570575714,
-0.24036653339862823,
-0.5778897404670715,
0.3879455029964447,
-0.7280101776123047,
-0.8255963921546936,
-0.413889080286026,
-0.2897566556930542,
-0.17877674102783203,
0.14143095910549164,
0.06741277128458023,
0.4760664105415344,
-0.18189695477485657,
0.47122493386268616,
0.6329120397567749,
-0.04872169718146324,
0.27349579334259033,
0.34303659200668335,
-0.10087231546640396,
-0.4675111472606659,
0.5884523987770081,
0.059079840779304504,
0.0658382847905159,
0.6021244525909424,
0.48602327704429626,
-0.3252784013748169,
-0.7394198775291443,
-0.4387195408344269,
0.41073188185691833,
-0.7797549366950989,
-0.5299893021583557,
-0.6449768543243408,
-0.2832578718662262,
-0.2732356786727905,
0.004115002695471048,
-0.2607424259185791,
-0.5628091096878052,
-0.48101499676704407,
-0.4227135479450226,
-0.04991355165839195,
0.8091058135032654,
0.05725069344043732,
0.6439624428749084,
-0.48049941658973694,
0.32320642471313477,
0.21491405367851257,
0.009621325880289078,
0.029817096889019012,
-0.6778618693351746,
0.24066410958766937,
-0.05749787762761116,
-0.39982447028160095,
-0.9392921924591064,
0.4757249653339386,
0.08894038200378418,
0.16777056455612183,
0.46181848645210266,
-0.17006053030490875,
0.7963201999664307,
-0.6385625600814819,
0.7982304096221924,
0.050375860184431076,
-0.9442528486251831,
0.5866811871528625,
-0.5584415793418884,
0.23792260885238647,
0.4278601109981537,
0.2506508231163025,
-0.37831687927246094,
-0.2625844478607178,
-0.22805973887443542,
-0.6334402561187744,
0.7531952857971191,
0.0011289175599813461,
0.1826486438512802,
-0.1667405068874359,
0.5133406519889832,
0.19176362454891205,
0.13903678953647614,
-0.8312616944313049,
0.24083901941776276,
-0.025989746674895287,
0.021589670330286026,
0.1753368228673935,
-0.8602195978164673,
-0.02759593538939953,
-0.2515040338039398,
0.4997837245464325,
-0.017823562026023865,
-0.15249212086200714,
-0.1284817010164261,
-0.04324064776301384,
-0.06986735761165619,
0.8129669427871704,
0.7340543270111084,
0.7444719076156616,
0.021815253421664238,
0.34854137897491455,
0.23947879672050476,
-0.10499229282140732,
0.40082472562789917,
-0.1823696494102478,
-0.21412286162376404,
-0.1350158303976059,
0.3587004542350769,
0.8939195275306702,
0.6869677305221558,
-0.5856615900993347,
0.42547228932380676,
-0.06899504363536835,
-0.2409183830022812,
-0.15560996532440186,
-0.04317918047308922,
0.29820558428764343,
0.30221420526504517,
0.3639323115348816,
-0.0937594547867775,
-0.08990246057510376,
-0.43394753336906433,
-0.02509586699306965,
0.536586582660675,
0.13469547033309937,
-0.460542768239975,
0.3192974627017975,
-0.032378412783145905,
-0.4568556547164917,
0.2974100410938263,
-0.12126778811216354,
-0.453916072845459,
0.4277496039867401,
0.9830617904663086,
0.6353446245193481,
-0.38310375809669495,
0.3115641474723816,
0.29943984746932983,
0.15186679363250732,
-0.3255525231361389,
0.14701344072818756,
-0.0330469012260437,
-0.5474050641059875,
-0.7092941999435425,
-0.7516756653785706,
-0.5855261087417603,
0.3631764054298401,
-0.6659974455833435,
0.21384239196777344,
-0.7169131636619568,
-0.08011993765830994,
-0.17030733823776245,
-0.04676216095685959,
-0.401523619890213,
-0.06997215002775192,
0.09021691232919693,
0.6727043390274048,
-0.5592864751815796,
0.6751608848571777,
0.5991324186325073,
-0.14259737730026245,
-0.8588411808013916,
-0.0986195057630539,
-0.22756926715373993,
-0.7907620072364807,
0.7776124477386475,
0.24731899797916412,
-0.3481334149837494,
-0.023299718275666237,
-0.44721582531929016,
-1.0546287298202515,
0.8394411206245422,
1.008795976638794,
-0.7198700904846191,
-0.41207364201545715,
0.42535921931266785,
0.6571147441864014,
-0.4225239157676697,
0.4168958365917206,
0.7675663232803345,
0.4352740943431854,
0.3800888657569885,
-0.7374408841133118,
0.29781436920166016,
0.08621786534786224,
0.37262222170829773,
-0.040278300642967224,
-0.5168929696083069,
1.1077500581741333,
0.031433410942554474,
-0.4858557879924774,
0.15557684004306793,
0.9547001719474792,
0.6636325120925903,
-0.011960715986788273,
0.34538403153419495,
0.5573002696037292,
0.810948371887207,
0.10730663686990738,
0.8580096960067749,
-0.1981080025434494,
-0.047696150839328766,
1.020574927330017,
-0.3919200301170349,
1.0818259716033936,
0.33999982476234436,
-0.29316115379333496,
0.6601073741912842,
0.6128343939781189,
0.3876161277294159,
0.3946163058280945,
0.41771984100341797,
0.059858594089746475,
-0.4229247272014618,
-0.1612614542245865,
-0.4018799662590027,
0.6333634853363037,
0.5296998620033264,
-0.278719961643219,
-0.640993058681488,
0.04984128102660179,
0.24294520914554596,
0.28384464979171753,
-0.335277259349823,
0.7655896544456482,
0.5106911063194275,
-0.7304551005363464,
0.7311674952507019,
0.16072630882263184,
0.6477645039558411,
-0.5501562356948853,
-0.06389236450195312,
-0.10707273334264755,
-0.10989490151405334,
-0.1374012529850006,
-0.6821318864822388,
0.2370687872171402,
0.1383122056722641,
0.228998601436615,
-0.39787280559539795,
1.0011203289031982,
-0.22536735236644745,
-0.23404307663440704,
0.1409754902124405,
0.5869665741920471,
0.11369674652814865,
-0.10275599360466003,
-0.27708134055137634,
0.2595142722129822,
-0.15999265015125275,
-0.560725212097168,
0.6223075985908508,
0.5017907023429871,
0.15191136300563812,
0.44272178411483765,
0.6881508827209473,
0.19786612689495087,
-0.23747718334197998,
0.08265361189842224,
1.233617901802063,
-0.8438287377357483,
-0.7109883427619934,
-1.121946096420288,
0.33356696367263794,
-0.0014784781960770488,
-0.2689375877380371,
0.6353392004966736,
0.5477404594421387,
0.46452105045318604,
0.15608647465705872,
0.5556601881980896,
0.43105581402778625,
0.7032419443130493,
-0.7140522003173828,
0.27867650985717773,
-0.16876384615898132,
0.5380746126174927,
0.049447908997535706,
-1.0442324876785278,
-0.34104248881340027,
0.7188770771026611,
-0.6103752255439758,
-0.08019990473985672,
0.6372333765029907,
0.5404821038246155,
0.01241359207779169,
0.3206411600112915,
0.32489490509033203,
0.25366225838661194,
0.5590550303459167,
0.6206561923027039,
1.0004609823226929,
-0.015012099407613277,
0.5202783346176147,
0.21359385550022125,
-0.09978197515010834,
-0.05969669297337532,
-0.8916659951210022,
-1.1159387826919556,
-0.2952231168746948,
0.032515719532966614,
-0.1629800945520401,
0.14145861566066742,
0.9525696635246277,
0.3820120394229889,
-0.618216335773468,
-0.30508458614349365,
-0.1260160356760025,
0.012117281556129456,
0.21976697444915771,
-0.15337157249450684,
0.48009198904037476,
-0.4596978425979614,
-0.37686800956726074,
0.722985565662384,
0.4978496730327606,
-0.15951694548130035,
-0.34189847111701965,
0.1779833883047104,
-0.1566801369190216,
0.2085813581943512,
0.9220578670501709,
0.30581218004226685,
-0.7576897144317627,
-0.2740341126918793,
-0.055387284606695175,
-0.15174342691898346,
0.4755694568157196,
1.025193214416504,
-0.8048940896987915,
-0.2842499613761902,
0.3777882158756256,
0.7410306930541992,
0.354751855134964,
0.3224610686302185,
0.512117862701416,
-0.7273256778717041,
0.10014061629772186,
0.4374011754989624,
0.448091596364975,
0.51052325963974,
-0.21361933648586273,
0.3681447505950928,
-0.14107707142829895,
-0.45988067984580994,
-1.0396817922592163,
0.32832685112953186,
-0.9116891026496887,
-0.27455419301986694,
1.4537771940231323,
-0.13513189554214478,
-0.4115278124809265,
-0.15074947476387024,
-0.579810619354248,
0.08849424123764038,
-0.37008535861968994,
0.46185365319252014,
0.5625314116477966,
-0.13666799664497375,
-0.3955378532409668,
-0.29306989908218384,
0.5415590405464172,
0.6997034549713135,
-0.944718599319458,
0.2420644760131836,
0.330157607793808,
0.2342492640018463,
-0.04248173534870148,
0.9910133481025696,
-0.08058524131774902,
0.0021376642398536205,
-0.19539691507816315,
-0.600764811038971,
-0.08420075476169586,
-0.31715378165245056,
-0.4314613342285156,
0.648280680179596,
0.28972792625427246,
0.2032374143600464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05045v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05045v1
|
Are Human Conversations Special? A Large Language Model Perspective
| 2024-03-08T04:44:25 | 2024-03-08T04:44:25 |
Toshish Jawale, Chaitanya Animesh, Sekhar Vallath, Kartik Talamadupula, Larry Heck
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This study analyzes changes in the attention mechanisms of large language
models (LLMs) when used to understand natural conversations between humans
(human-human). We analyze three use cases of LLMs: interactions over web
content, code, and mathematical texts. By analyzing attention distance,
dispersion, and interdependency across these domains, we highlight the unique
challenges posed by conversational data. Notably, conversations require nuanced
handling of long-term contextual relationships and exhibit higher complexity
through their attention patterns. Our findings reveal that while language
models exhibit domain-specific attention behaviors, there is a significant gap
in their ability to specialize in human conversations. Through detailed
attention entropy analysis and t-SNE visualizations, we demonstrate the need
for models trained with a diverse array of high-quality conversational data to
enhance understanding and generation of human-like dialogue. This research
highlights the importance of domain specialization in language models and
suggests pathways for future advancement in modeling human conversational
nuances.
|
[
-0.5161974430084229,
-1.0224156379699707,
0.5513781309127808,
0.20184606313705444,
-0.15652228891849518,
0.23711900413036346,
-0.3685036897659302,
-0.6914095878601074,
0.04967363178730011,
0.6889169812202454,
-0.5015132427215576,
-0.3964838683605194,
-0.372175008058548,
0.06962667405605316,
-0.37308695912361145,
0.7983223795890808,
0.4373590052127838,
-0.04449300095438957,
-0.4031333327293396,
-0.06947902590036392,
-0.2274230718612671,
-0.9671562314033508,
-0.47525840997695923,
-0.3420344889163971,
0.5899258255958557,
0.22833722829818726,
0.9304140210151672,
0.5158246159553528,
0.7977957129478455,
0.36517828702926636,
-0.22277474403381348,
0.006939457729458809,
-0.7462719082832336,
-0.0021583265624940395,
-0.2456459403038025,
-0.4740558862686157,
-0.4725651144981384,
-0.20053055882453918,
0.494648814201355,
1.3185080289840698,
-0.00022214373166207224,
0.00860025268048048,
0.09376426041126251,
0.5141926407814026,
-0.12217774987220764,
0.26748090982437134,
-0.6072866916656494,
0.01954163983464241,
-0.1882844716310501,
-0.15963730216026306,
-0.18370509147644043,
-0.1191658303141594,
0.7354863882064819,
-0.15453413128852844,
0.5369471311569214,
-0.05512889102101326,
0.872822642326355,
0.22241434454917908,
-0.6572218537330627,
-0.20039305090904236,
-0.8494742512702942,
0.9324430227279663,
-0.7330870032310486,
0.31411561369895935,
0.4394181966781616,
0.0897655114531517,
-0.1954221874475479,
-0.5456897616386414,
-0.36193975806236267,
-0.3200186491012573,
0.02225968986749649,
-0.32413816452026367,
-0.4373049736022949,
0.09680017083883286,
0.24936839938163757,
0.3686356842517853,
-0.27413350343704224,
0.3020801842212677,
-0.38814422488212585,
0.056079089641571045,
0.7956068515777588,
0.656027615070343,
0.36358702182769775,
0.14026768505573273,
-0.11630009859800339,
0.19704318046569824,
-0.5075236558914185,
-0.04218335449695587,
0.4156975746154785,
0.07473568618297577,
-0.3177869915962219,
0.19749248027801514,
-0.17840275168418884,
0.9639497995376587,
-0.11250283569097519,
-0.029915137216448784,
-0.09852635860443115,
-0.19681556522846222,
-0.2643589675426483,
-0.4344537556171417,
0.6955020427703857,
0.5384923815727234,
0.8144178986549377,
-0.2519223093986511,
0.14558930695056915,
-0.05710556358098984,
0.2653086483478546,
-0.5514200329780579,
-0.37742283940315247,
0.04369053617119789,
-0.280680775642395,
-0.2918785810470581,
-0.13587400317192078,
-0.5327285528182983,
-0.33759596943855286,
-0.5244667530059814,
-0.16658471524715424,
0.10109679400920868,
-0.1912776678800583,
0.3518742620944977,
0.11695580184459686,
0.04921587556600571,
0.3727496862411499,
-1.1313427686691284,
0.39353513717651367,
0.7183519005775452,
0.5064119100570679,
-0.4358570873737335,
-0.19177302718162537,
0.03277451917529106,
0.08500797301530838,
-0.294794499874115,
0.7697425484657288,
-0.6602886319160461,
-0.4561852812767029,
-0.050615545362234116,
-0.1454842984676361,
-0.12555857002735138,
-0.6067162156105042,
0.34899333119392395,
-0.5956836938858032,
0.04748248681426048,
-0.0686274990439415,
-0.43608909845352173,
-0.1145755723118782,
0.3061448633670807,
-0.4859105050563812,
0.45776328444480896,
0.03814003989100456,
-0.8955869674682617,
-0.2595822215080261,
-0.6650165319442749,
-0.4863544702529907,
0.24961994588375092,
-0.21697402000427246,
-0.16851158440113068,
0.24692849814891815,
-0.13825549185276031,
0.6247278451919556,
-0.6768759489059448,
0.34868481755256653,
-0.3644365072250366,
-0.16804112493991852,
0.9398483633995056,
-0.34974414110183716,
0.3600107729434967,
0.25392329692840576,
-0.18582576513290405,
0.037889547646045685,
-0.6597732305526733,
-0.023371919989585876,
0.2297009974718094,
-0.35078978538513184,
-0.3226441442966461,
0.003252326976507902,
0.12467984110116959,
0.16200605034828186,
0.2809883952140808,
-0.15013457834720612,
0.2748892605304718,
-0.6220932602882385,
0.810813844203949,
0.5813549757003784,
0.06664159148931503,
0.5220604538917542,
-0.07592454552650452,
0.4488031566143036,
0.2093973308801651,
0.04295537993311882,
-0.373653769493103,
-0.6702626347541809,
-0.8552531599998474,
0.09088346362113953,
0.17780537903308868,
0.37646883726119995,
-0.13627934455871582,
0.34556907415390015,
-0.3769857883453369,
-0.2502194046974182,
-0.26544642448425293,
0.06300497055053711,
0.40203985571861267,
0.2263416051864624,
-0.18031400442123413,
-0.43641242384910583,
-0.39974555373191833,
-1.1812045574188232,
-0.336791068315506,
-0.007651422638446093,
-0.13022013008594513,
0.5932806730270386,
0.2835788428783417,
-0.5493581891059875,
1.30166757106781,
-0.6872857809066772,
0.09737851470708847,
-0.3820962607860565,
0.08595502376556396,
-0.12529276311397552,
0.1593966782093048,
0.4344647526741028,
-0.8445943593978882,
-0.6744269728660583,
0.11643122136592865,
-0.6794692873954773,
-0.014294404536485672,
-0.09017956256866455,
-0.03583928197622299,
0.0720299780368805,
0.39373376965522766,
-0.5735287070274353,
0.42464300990104675,
0.5681554079055786,
-0.2763611376285553,
0.11006401479244232,
0.02495584823191166,
0.057530224323272705,
-0.9449546337127686,
-0.03811975568532944,
0.22824986279010773,
-0.13454563915729523,
-1.2143372297286987,
-0.15942607820034027,
-0.17774520814418793,
-0.3083803057670593,
-0.4595353901386261,
0.6582344174385071,
-0.44568338990211487,
-0.22179166972637177,
-0.2670600712299347,
0.24961139261722565,
-0.03592636436223984,
0.6249621510505676,
0.19374535977840424,
0.4205712378025055,
0.5249899625778198,
-0.7793411016464233,
0.42779862880706787,
0.3444904685020447,
-0.3807796835899353,
0.4302709996700287,
-0.8541061282157898,
0.5469332337379456,
0.060455501079559326,
0.0451628640294075,
-0.9736384749412537,
-0.5092800259590149,
-0.07239032536745071,
-0.4520414471626282,
0.21877999603748322,
0.021777639165520668,
-0.4468371570110321,
-0.31028276681900024,
0.0034369106870144606,
0.46282824873924255,
0.12174603343009949,
-0.09303633123636246,
0.23005369305610657,
0.7233402729034424,
-0.5660713315010071,
-0.1981966495513916,
-0.6971111297607422,
0.5050215125083923,
-0.21253666281700134,
-1.175140380859375,
0.05129490792751312,
-0.2757921516895294,
-0.7519157528877258,
-0.30657872557640076,
0.22215870022773743,
-0.3487148880958557,
0.2660776972770691,
0.18583206832408905,
0.16170063614845276,
-0.24091003835201263,
0.09475086629390717,
-0.5520147085189819,
-0.0530097559094429,
0.07236691564321518,
-0.09695638716220856,
0.6971660256385803,
-0.09739621728658676,
-0.4137953519821167,
-0.713242769241333,
0.6151074767112732,
0.682980477809906,
0.03829136863350868,
0.6045796871185303,
0.22730274498462677,
-0.2360723614692688,
0.1881132274866104,
-0.717166006565094,
-0.48304662108421326,
-0.46482667326927185,
0.65660560131073,
-0.3544633686542511,
-1.2245285511016846,
0.6416357159614563,
0.17604126036167145,
0.009831435978412628,
0.04002485051751137,
0.6605401635169983,
-0.14318589866161346,
1.2357430458068848,
0.7647624611854553,
-0.0409691222012043,
0.5248978734016418,
0.028556298464536667,
0.5209284424781799,
-0.6572861671447754,
-0.20698808133602142,
-0.40832430124282837,
-0.3191942572593689,
-0.32237982749938965,
-0.32844310998916626,
0.16553832590579987,
-0.12736305594444275,
-0.10715144127607346,
-0.03837532922625542,
-0.252789169549942,
0.6432766318321228,
0.2440846860408783,
-0.21205896139144897,
0.22056499123573303,
0.10578443109989166,
0.5207574963569641,
-0.5064437389373779,
-0.491513729095459,
-0.5985269546508789,
0.8638404011726379,
0.5943697690963745,
1.0172978639602661,
0.09658840298652649,
0.24705520272254944,
0.3380460739135742,
0.06315045058727264,
-0.8628092408180237,
0.5910145044326782,
0.14558807015419006,
-0.518630862236023,
-0.3715473413467407,
-0.5315361618995667,
-1.3428975343704224,
0.29788920283317566,
0.07404344528913498,
-0.9710399508476257,
-0.06553096324205399,
0.0015581907937303185,
-0.2887117862701416,
0.0766369178891182,
-0.8564713597297668,
0.9083321690559387,
-0.15155518054962158,
-0.24481597542762756,
-0.2963983714580536,
-0.78146892786026,
0.38496503233909607,
-0.051811885088682175,
0.22255688905715942,
-0.22522535920143127,
0.26133468747138977,
0.658376932144165,
-0.07158878445625305,
1.1693496704101562,
0.29693859815597534,
-0.41595712304115295,
0.30954650044441223,
0.1269417554140091,
0.5268993377685547,
0.01922549493610859,
0.3769611418247223,
0.26405763626098633,
-0.3883455693721771,
-0.43444186449050903,
-0.34745168685913086,
0.6575474739074707,
-0.9110748171806335,
-1.0759029388427734,
-0.2534765601158142,
-0.7433158755302429,
-0.38776034116744995,
-0.2193508893251419,
-0.050737787038087845,
0.3050479590892792,
-0.34787842631340027,
0.28782883286476135,
0.891133189201355,
-0.1901732087135315,
0.3208811283111572,
0.628229022026062,
0.1981288641691208,
-0.014911702834069729,
0.7186425924301147,
-0.16926510632038116,
0.5861690044403076,
0.3375245928764343,
0.10286696255207062,
-0.06316579878330231,
-0.401235431432724,
-0.07343830913305283,
0.47096899151802063,
-0.7979172468185425,
0.042954813688993454,
-1.11123788356781,
-0.1935180425643921,
-0.6572871208190918,
0.033553704619407654,
-0.1396249234676361,
-0.3498220145702362,
-0.6219050288200378,
0.05810258165001869,
0.29501277208328247,
0.9697924256324768,
0.25054046511650085,
0.26819467544555664,
-1.0985016822814941,
0.2895883321762085,
0.6244717836380005,
-0.0033936211839318275,
0.2570222020149231,
-0.7109189033508301,
-0.4299487769603729,
0.07809817045927048,
-0.347655326128006,
-0.7466965317726135,
0.49916020035743713,
0.21764881908893585,
0.5714576244354248,
0.48725080490112305,
-0.21035058796405792,
0.47784551978111267,
-0.3133779466152191,
0.8204266428947449,
0.24571919441223145,
-0.8911651968955994,
0.3896535634994507,
-0.6574699878692627,
0.5328401327133179,
0.046138301491737366,
0.2819353938102722,
-0.887963056564331,
-0.41471776366233826,
-0.7043670415878296,
-0.7065569162368774,
0.9741019010543823,
0.20729050040245056,
0.43319806456565857,
0.04582134634256363,
0.20484542846679688,
-0.24900412559509277,
0.1742277890443802,
-0.5507980585098267,
-0.1047879084944725,
0.38768163323402405,
-0.02793131396174431,
-0.01991460472345352,
-0.3864748179912567,
-0.36750778555870056,
-0.011570754460990429,
-0.07414361089468002,
-0.09238957613706589,
0.1845131665468216,
-0.10433949530124664,
-0.07792876660823822,
-0.1062222272157669,
0.3952481150627136,
0.8237347602844238,
0.7699650526046753,
0.062220510095357895,
0.01071143802255392,
0.28146418929100037,
-0.39626070857048035,
-0.18787939846515656,
-0.2997935712337494,
0.4196757972240448,
-0.26116418838500977,
0.34635308384895325,
0.8948274254798889,
0.5884888768196106,
-0.6291317939758301,
0.42792171239852905,
-0.23909641802310944,
-0.05402243137359619,
0.009564106352627277,
0.0070404005236923695,
0.5224679708480835,
0.3220462203025818,
0.32822078466415405,
0.12133998423814774,
0.13369670510292053,
-0.8279170393943787,
-0.05581432580947876,
0.20885293185710907,
-0.3139004111289978,
-0.6861521601676941,
0.45001059770584106,
0.6298614144325256,
-0.610685408115387,
0.5619393587112427,
0.19473454356193542,
-0.5533264875411987,
0.7531071305274963,
0.4341833293437958,
0.7833908796310425,
-0.22498269379138947,
0.03097258135676384,
-0.1061297357082367,
-0.12683379650115967,
0.06568349152803421,
-0.01618182845413685,
-0.23210158944129944,
-0.7266287207603455,
-0.1798182725906372,
-0.3962504267692566,
-0.649641752243042,
0.09785305708646774,
-0.6531009078025818,
0.0760500505566597,
-0.3801364600658417,
-0.37173861265182495,
0.22323738038539886,
-0.16288445889949799,
-0.8194856643676758,
0.06293206661939621,
0.3584984540939331,
0.3470745384693146,
-0.7202765941619873,
0.717492938041687,
0.6025978922843933,
-0.015756728127598763,
-0.22811171412467957,
-0.0005163862369954586,
-0.07335825264453888,
-0.573083758354187,
0.9903683662414551,
0.09687907993793488,
-0.14698007702827454,
0.03275415301322937,
-0.6198591589927673,
-0.8663872480392456,
0.658865213394165,
0.5134086608886719,
-0.7228466272354126,
-0.09377888590097427,
0.5048603415489197,
0.7901372909545898,
-0.5146597623825073,
0.03367522731423378,
0.6650082468986511,
0.14522378146648407,
-0.013983420096337795,
-1.047419786453247,
-0.35615089535713196,
-0.20188793540000916,
0.24360774457454681,
0.1267423927783966,
-0.9598526954650879,
0.7995011806488037,
-0.2595290541648865,
-0.39737632870674133,
-0.11141417920589447,
0.5396342873573303,
0.12957896292209625,
0.27225419878959656,
0.34752604365348816,
0.2728020250797272,
0.5408158302307129,
-0.023647256195545197,
0.9424572587013245,
-0.2630864679813385,
0.32034561038017273,
0.9545857906341553,
-0.5385329723358154,
0.645425021648407,
0.38525187969207764,
-0.35238754749298096,
0.2502921223640442,
0.6476786732673645,
0.21069888770580292,
0.19908393919467926,
0.47128352522850037,
-0.2962290644645691,
-0.47135379910469055,
-0.1111719086766243,
-0.363251656293869,
0.18390397727489471,
0.7218884825706482,
-0.1694403439760208,
0.10783763974905014,
0.051777184009552,
-0.15490977466106415,
0.04728851094841957,
-0.01586696319282055,
1.0038166046142578,
0.2905026376247406,
-0.559608519077301,
0.5517427921295166,
-0.032961905002593994,
0.6449875235557556,
-0.36162543296813965,
0.2076520174741745,
-0.3520837724208832,
0.22397634387016296,
-0.24441735446453094,
-0.8037040829658508,
0.12871798872947693,
0.12663012742996216,
-0.3650199770927429,
-0.04484133794903755,
0.48635005950927734,
-0.40342646837234497,
-0.1339697390794754,
0.264375776052475,
0.3968600034713745,
0.45427826046943665,
-0.13591542840003967,
-0.6037630438804626,
0.265082448720932,
0.1667550504207611,
-0.34955713152885437,
0.5473170876502991,
0.6757434010505676,
-0.2760498821735382,
0.7182377576828003,
0.6077709794044495,
-0.36131051182746887,
0.18394097685813904,
0.6590712070465088,
0.8929237723350525,
-0.9098851680755615,
-0.6279598474502563,
-0.8473929166793823,
0.35449934005737305,
-0.1349913328886032,
-0.3929165303707123,
0.6175917387008667,
0.26659247279167175,
0.5019657015800476,
-0.1909087747335434,
0.8123597502708435,
0.4992758631706238,
0.41792187094688416,
-0.21820123493671417,
0.5387479662895203,
-0.20838871598243713,
0.3766864538192749,
-0.013415792025625706,
-0.9520701766014099,
-0.41463884711265564,
0.5373361110687256,
-0.417238712310791,
-0.012201892212033272,
0.5772432684898376,
0.7496210932731628,
-0.1501902937889099,
0.11129441857337952,
0.6584652066230774,
0.15447133779525757,
0.3900626301765442,
0.6437721848487854,
1.2392253875732422,
-0.053280606865882874,
0.653553307056427,
0.2878866195678711,
-0.09095373004674911,
-0.5914031863212585,
-0.3755369782447815,
-1.2468280792236328,
-0.5669774413108826,
-0.509689211845398,
-0.04363764077425003,
-0.1046331599354744,
0.7816307544708252,
0.7937918901443481,
-0.6950756311416626,
-0.3844242990016937,
-0.03336885944008827,
-0.16785360872745514,
0.4994898736476898,
-0.29426926374435425,
0.10166292637586594,
-0.3742155134677887,
-1.0854740142822266,
0.2093534916639328,
0.5950239896774292,
0.38767945766448975,
-0.5039465427398682,
0.05089946463704109,
0.048942822962999344,
0.29522034525871277,
0.5827813744544983,
0.360323041677475,
-0.8182715773582458,
-0.05980193242430687,
0.12894722819328308,
-0.4503842294216156,
0.23595353960990906,
1.2290401458740234,
-0.3737110197544098,
0.2876797318458557,
0.4986101984977722,
0.6294504404067993,
0.5428391695022583,
-0.05224239453673363,
0.7290703058242798,
-0.7385552525520325,
0.42154639959335327,
0.31300264596939087,
0.21276767551898956,
0.6467490792274475,
-0.3984217345714569,
0.32784247398376465,
0.13044434785842896,
-0.8162329196929932,
-0.9542334675788879,
0.5155588388442993,
-0.9263562560081482,
-0.15786980092525482,
1.224034070968628,
-0.28551554679870605,
-0.17607565224170685,
-0.4934573173522949,
-0.33959800004959106,
-0.05125840753316879,
-0.34467238187789917,
0.9062456488609314,
0.9308891892433167,
-0.2693783640861511,
-0.22427019476890564,
-0.48214593529701233,
0.45658639073371887,
0.41495221853256226,
-0.8566241264343262,
0.29363787174224854,
0.24377833306789398,
0.1755678653717041,
0.2757027745246887,
0.5784056782722473,
0.054643671959638596,
0.019838333129882812,
-0.2685920298099518,
-0.07435541599988937,
0.4327085614204407,
-0.20140546560287476,
-0.3704336881637573,
0.10725152492523193,
0.09961913526058197,
0.11059358716011047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05023v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05023v1
|
Towards Multimodal Sentiment Analysis Debiasing via Bias Purification
| 2024-03-08T03:55:27 | 2024-03-08T03:55:27 |
Dingkang Yang, Mingcheng Li, Dongling Xiao, Yang Liu, Kun Yang, Zhaoyu Chen, Yuzheng Wang, Peng Zhai, Ke Li, Lihua Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Multimodal Sentiment Analysis (MSA) aims to understand human intentions by
integrating emotion-related clues from diverse modalities, such as visual,
language, and audio. Unfortunately, the current MSA task invariably suffers
from unplanned dataset biases, particularly multimodal utterance-level label
bias and word-level context bias. These harmful biases potentially mislead
models to focus on statistical shortcuts and spurious correlations, causing
severe performance bottlenecks. To alleviate these issues, we present a
Multimodal Counterfactual Inference Sentiment (MCIS) analysis framework based
on causality rather than conventional likelihood. Concretely, we first
formulate a causal graph to discover harmful biases from already-trained
vanilla models. In the inference phase, given a factual multimodal input, MCIS
imagines two counterfactual scenarios to purify and mitigate these biases.
Then, MCIS can make unbiased decisions from biased observations by comparing
factual and counterfactual outcomes. We conduct extensive experiments on
several standard MSA benchmarks. Qualitative and quantitative results show the
effectiveness of the proposed framework.
|
[
-0.8192699551582336,
-0.8680664896965027,
0.8068727254867554,
0.2338135540485382,
-0.49737268686294556,
-0.210975781083107,
0.06893667578697205,
-0.15717370808124542,
0.37075337767601013,
0.3922595977783203,
-0.8685250282287598,
-0.28096893429756165,
-0.6544987559318542,
-0.1195577010512352,
0.042714376002550125,
0.9677006602287292,
0.21232128143310547,
0.3432232439517975,
-0.4860483705997467,
-0.38549450039863586,
-0.49264219403266907,
-0.34424301981925964,
-0.43206149339675903,
-0.07316630333662033,
0.7548232674598694,
0.3903563320636749,
0.6162208318710327,
-0.12471627444028854,
0.2287587821483612,
0.24209414422512054,
0.12258576601743698,
0.4066709578037262,
-0.334425687789917,
0.15911324322223663,
-0.335307240486145,
-0.17926426231861115,
-0.3670300841331482,
0.48554304242134094,
0.3006947636604309,
0.6155233383178711,
0.16547778248786926,
0.3046807646751404,
0.11900100111961365,
0.6150181889533997,
-1.0955904722213745,
0.10946547985076904,
-0.41800907254219055,
0.08928115665912628,
-0.05707789957523346,
-0.2771027684211731,
-0.5548113584518433,
-0.115826316177845,
-0.033010296523571014,
-0.38583847880363464,
-0.0369841642677784,
-0.15305064618587494,
0.630029559135437,
0.3404698967933655,
-0.8776134848594666,
0.06787198036909103,
-0.5592499375343323,
1.0566785335540771,
-0.7273017168045044,
0.41639164090156555,
0.25227004289627075,
0.10927494615316391,
0.000923010113183409,
-0.2692045569419861,
-0.7692366242408752,
0.02574083022773266,
-0.2278597354888916,
0.2854861319065094,
-0.4287607967853546,
0.09377412497997284,
0.4136245846748352,
-0.2139057219028473,
-0.5662510991096497,
-0.35635876655578613,
-0.24329353868961334,
-0.19405314326286316,
0.38135799765586853,
0.01858648471534252,
0.37526437640190125,
-0.5570963621139526,
-0.5356001257896423,
-0.1361839473247528,
-0.47500211000442505,
0.049523185938596725,
0.3067682981491089,
0.1917605996131897,
0.04769611731171608,
0.507932722568512,
-0.19420932233333588,
0.3675594627857208,
0.11812906712293625,
-0.05466974526643753,
0.5281176567077637,
-0.2789169251918793,
-0.34690576791763306,
-0.05330988019704819,
0.7720192670822144,
0.6764222383499146,
0.1269228309392929,
-0.07287215441465378,
0.10796234756708145,
0.6486461758613586,
0.43285468220710754,
-0.8693157434463501,
-0.03734005242586136,
0.5531874895095825,
-0.5802717208862305,
-0.39522334933280945,
-0.059813376516103745,
-1.3036781549453735,
-0.6119226217269897,
-0.44500622153282166,
0.38885149359703064,
-0.1083616241812706,
-0.3816754221916199,
-0.27416926622390747,
-0.33333978056907654,
-0.25629934668540955,
0.03653031960129738,
-0.361050009727478,
-0.24140538275241852,
0.29463353753089905,
0.5447573661804199,
0.21642811596393585,
-0.05397850275039673,
-0.655500054359436,
0.14505502581596375,
-0.2230689376592636,
0.8181945085525513,
-0.8239350318908691,
-0.43700331449508667,
-0.13379773497581482,
-0.10916302353143692,
-0.2384377121925354,
-0.36044594645500183,
0.6636677980422974,
-0.6054724454879761,
0.16445939242839813,
-0.6074174642562866,
-0.028577107936143875,
-0.5540022253990173,
0.5829722285270691,
-0.7348313927650452,
0.6463197469711304,
-0.44127127528190613,
-0.9331661462783813,
0.6822718381881714,
-0.5320051312446594,
-0.3240419626235962,
-0.7621020674705505,
0.00028361889417283237,
-0.38967078924179077,
0.2705381214618683,
0.466940701007843,
0.4650375247001648,
-0.23824603855609894,
0.801136314868927,
-1.0652252435684204,
0.02040131762623787,
0.25222718715667725,
-0.8574603796005249,
0.6075186729431152,
0.6093218326568604,
-0.3844260275363922,
0.20683546364307404,
-0.8462626934051514,
-0.1291152387857437,
-0.42351457476615906,
0.13602665066719055,
-0.6041475534439087,
0.2537902891635895,
0.10946133732795715,
0.9325100183486938,
-0.3046073913574219,
-0.7380629777908325,
-0.056856486946344376,
0.021333009004592896,
0.16499604284763336,
0.7661600708961487,
0.1264895647764206,
0.3548727333545685,
0.035840682685375214,
0.2891635596752167,
0.8978767991065979,
0.5044722557067871,
0.027809210121631622,
-0.4674888253211975,
-0.5682294964790344,
-0.7331743836402893,
-0.3196709454059601,
0.32961568236351013,
-0.9758917689323425,
-0.03868405893445015,
-0.16082678735256195,
-0.2735452353954315,
-0.3736037015914917,
0.17747262120246887,
0.4672054946422577,
0.5921888947486877,
0.5545185804367065,
-0.4145839512348175,
-0.6941816806793213,
-1.1156755685806274,
-0.3658459186553955,
0.03397255018353462,
0.21740680932998657,
0.12109514325857162,
0.33168187737464905,
-0.5373687148094177,
1.1021435260772705,
-0.46820491552352905,
-0.35575833916664124,
0.09023880213499069,
0.6592321991920471,
0.06002592295408249,
0.4542841613292694,
0.5953782796859741,
-0.9151130318641663,
0.021784091368317604,
-0.5163241624832153,
-0.9562905430793762,
-0.21602904796600342,
-0.24449121952056885,
-0.26316899061203003,
0.07937141507863998,
0.5160466432571411,
-0.6900938153266907,
0.5152323246002197,
0.43152275681495667,
-0.5344235301017761,
0.15563306212425232,
0.26579567790031433,
0.5370442271232605,
-1.015748143196106,
0.26210200786590576,
0.33342960476875305,
0.07749602943658829,
-0.5936744213104248,
-0.4714653193950653,
-0.2189817577600479,
-0.07278604060411453,
-0.37686648964881897,
0.4183059334754944,
-0.28474441170692444,
0.10443764925003052,
-0.12593138217926025,
0.29653599858283997,
0.20332419872283936,
0.6810914278030396,
0.058625802397727966,
0.3397366404533386,
0.20561927556991577,
-0.24396151304244995,
-0.10421250015497208,
-0.09528741240501404,
0.023342492058873177,
0.9663330316543579,
-0.2820028066635132,
-0.10272059589624405,
-0.5246099233627319,
0.42572975158691406,
-1.310632348060608,
0.12702637910842896,
0.46265530586242676,
-0.2932637333869934,
0.145248144865036,
-0.18083636462688446,
-0.2037413865327835,
-0.1269485354423523,
-0.5541284680366516,
0.6011204719543457,
0.12863928079605103,
-0.5836750268936157,
0.9926352500915527,
0.3244801163673401,
0.1430429369211197,
-0.9457268118858337,
-0.4896121919155121,
0.015727147459983826,
-0.28217923641204834,
-0.4935697913169861,
-0.2784440815448761,
-0.10323905199766159,
-0.4145021140575409,
-0.08635635673999786,
-0.05195013806223869,
0.048291243612766266,
-0.12539364397525787,
0.6817293167114258,
0.344983845949173,
0.10274989902973175,
0.06600258499383926,
0.4050830006599426,
-0.20376263558864594,
0.3190024793148041,
0.033177200704813004,
0.19400374591350555,
0.14223609864711761,
-0.41365060210227966,
-0.47095343470573425,
0.40209540724754333,
0.9985525608062744,
-0.26973408460617065,
0.635665774345398,
0.9324231147766113,
-0.1782684326171875,
0.0783773884177208,
-0.8405842781066895,
-0.1704435497522354,
-0.3858396112918854,
0.20550552010536194,
-0.4592630863189697,
-0.27103444933891296,
0.4188428521156311,
-0.05938413366675377,
-0.17350634932518005,
0.35104191303253174,
0.28861382603645325,
-0.07675125449895859,
1.451271414756775,
0.10517209768295288,
-0.2698376476764679,
0.5307595729827881,
-0.2188294380903244,
0.30498915910720825,
-0.7332646250724792,
-0.17534595727920532,
-0.23717372119426727,
-0.29846104979515076,
-0.4731062650680542,
-0.3795769214630127,
0.4132014513015747,
-0.047045040875673294,
-0.19573454558849335,
-0.26869699358940125,
0.08143100887537003,
0.18263207376003265,
0.587533712387085,
0.29739513993263245,
0.07360363006591797,
-0.005423883441835642,
-0.21826782822608948,
-0.029126347973942757,
-0.3348096013069153,
-0.4581480920314789,
0.9071948528289795,
0.2623139023780823,
0.43253201246261597,
0.12571123242378235,
0.2719072997570038,
0.3499695956707001,
0.6110294461250305,
-0.37058112025260925,
0.36604633927345276,
-0.11860779672861099,
-0.8808954358100891,
0.10741952806711197,
-0.366000235080719,
-0.36719590425491333,
0.7678993344306946,
-0.48404648900032043,
-0.5494401454925537,
0.7079232931137085,
0.3703637421131134,
-0.043972354382276535,
0.3378782868385315,
-0.8352348208427429,
1.0309202671051025,
0.28079596161842346,
-0.8038590550422668,
-0.5820368528366089,
-0.764363169670105,
0.7861835956573486,
0.19811414182186127,
0.737421452999115,
-0.15146835148334503,
0.4195506274700165,
0.5982065796852112,
-0.182413250207901,
1.1923998594284058,
-0.7093090415000916,
-0.10762939602136612,
0.24326057732105255,
0.10925519466400146,
0.3008081912994385,
0.274448037147522,
0.1579146832227707,
0.31666120886802673,
0.08051984012126923,
-0.4868175983428955,
-0.746753990650177,
0.7885251641273499,
-0.622864842414856,
-0.2196788638830185,
-0.34667396545410156,
-0.447416752576828,
-0.6614167094230652,
0.13134250044822693,
0.04901443049311638,
0.6530575156211853,
-0.33891740441322327,
-0.20027734339237213,
0.5920630693435669,
-0.21290577948093414,
0.5840775370597839,
0.28213563561439514,
0.08744262158870697,
-0.6452219486236572,
0.9919713735580444,
-0.048720914870500565,
0.06258350610733032,
0.19058725237846375,
0.11290868371725082,
-0.29357409477233887,
-0.11450401693582535,
-0.5869793891906738,
0.08686325699090958,
-0.7337175607681274,
-0.05320889130234718,
-0.7574005722999573,
0.6075722575187683,
-0.4875068962574005,
0.0197394248098135,
-0.4117639660835266,
-0.19874964654445648,
-0.3048169016838074,
-0.1310248076915741,
-0.09475183486938477,
0.4443891644477844,
-0.3634936213493347,
0.11280789971351624,
-0.876770555973053,
0.639641284942627,
0.3962603807449341,
0.03188072890043259,
0.09427673369646072,
-0.18063203990459442,
0.07568228244781494,
0.2574102580547333,
-0.42741692066192627,
-0.8462368249893188,
0.4518173336982727,
-0.14810234308242798,
0.3132612705230713,
1.0285626649856567,
0.1742389053106308,
0.7675283551216125,
-0.30739521980285645,
0.7643432021141052,
0.45829522609710693,
-0.9192139506340027,
0.5103413462638855,
-0.255048930644989,
0.07633627206087112,
0.6452634334564209,
0.4366641342639923,
-0.42786094546318054,
-0.3365030884742737,
-0.34913012385368347,
-0.7789422273635864,
0.499057412147522,
-0.0819408968091011,
-0.037134572863578796,
-0.4025942385196686,
-0.06346822530031204,
-0.08344282954931259,
0.35498180985450745,
-0.5608376860618591,
-0.1869177371263504,
-0.5427002906799316,
-0.48043563961982727,
-0.5521392226219177,
-0.694283127784729,
-0.3678440451622009,
-0.015918530523777008,
0.778927206993103,
-0.11901231855154037,
-0.04573814198374748,
0.17059580981731415,
-0.5735706686973572,
-0.05146601051092148,
0.4903896152973175,
0.7055535912513733,
0.4977656900882721,
-0.39978328347206116,
0.5327937602996826,
0.027345186099410057,
-0.40421944856643677,
0.21015599370002747,
-0.08585569262504578,
-0.0008672749972902238,
-0.2187822014093399,
0.37224599719047546,
0.5557258725166321,
0.23039351403713226,
-0.6063879132270813,
0.7206475138664246,
-0.05184822902083397,
0.26239892840385437,
0.006970388349145651,
-0.3722747266292572,
-0.137254536151886,
0.448174387216568,
0.10641641914844513,
0.4737394154071808,
0.5483774542808533,
-0.5940968990325928,
0.23563234508037567,
0.712538480758667,
-0.872177004814148,
-0.5044971704483032,
0.5238949060440063,
0.38835182785987854,
0.6766150593757629,
0.5140421390533447,
-0.07028552889823914,
-0.34186211228370667,
0.3018047511577606,
0.11786068975925446,
1.057647466659546,
-0.07654285430908203,
0.3199445605278015,
0.35766538977622986,
0.33136236667633057,
0.1946171522140503,
0.31300604343414307,
-0.1299012154340744,
-0.7267084121704102,
-0.36569854617118835,
-0.5041882991790771,
0.006524399388581514,
-0.23242516815662384,
-0.8352829813957214,
-0.05346514657139778,
-0.25492534041404724,
-0.4882073700428009,
-0.002775531494989991,
-0.3436230421066284,
-0.41583138704299927,
0.6137821674346924,
0.2376680225133896,
0.4328552186489105,
-1.2816712856292725,
0.48490703105926514,
0.5159817934036255,
-0.6023105382919312,
-0.28973889350891113,
-0.24189597368240356,
0.48549553751945496,
-0.3660729229450226,
0.9205136299133301,
0.15329554677009583,
-0.5944348573684692,
-0.5365404486656189,
-0.4617115259170532,
-0.46690869331359863,
0.7652832269668579,
0.3187335431575775,
-0.3441343903541565,
0.3033364713191986,
0.010977335274219513,
0.31900542974472046,
-0.22412993013858795,
0.5934325456619263,
0.41999438405036926,
0.6194043755531311,
0.0014217165298759937,
-0.382223516702652,
0.24390888214111328,
-0.4632926881313324,
-0.03306584060192108,
0.04766847938299179,
-0.46618375182151794,
0.6537253260612488,
-0.14374804496765137,
-0.016819853335618973,
-0.3461313545703888,
0.5733082294464111,
0.08481217920780182,
0.7470160722732544,
0.8181512951850891,
0.7706508040428162,
0.4137421250343323,
0.01512422226369381,
0.8029058575630188,
-0.12524278461933136,
0.30544373393058777,
1.0332053899765015,
-0.33894082903862,
0.6662119626998901,
1.0540000200271606,
0.09619539231061935,
0.670219361782074,
0.4474707245826721,
0.338987797498703,
0.7211138010025024,
-0.14447997510433197,
-0.3207186758518219,
-0.5058673024177551,
-0.26532304286956787,
-0.12338005751371384,
0.49035146832466125,
0.22847357392311096,
-0.4804074466228485,
-0.15114077925682068,
0.4843350946903229,
0.31128448247909546,
-0.16090244054794312,
-0.19882525503635406,
0.7511003613471985,
-0.025643499568104744,
-0.6730093359947205,
0.08973470330238342,
-0.27446505427360535,
0.6325426697731018,
-0.3674381673336029,
0.02775617316365242,
-0.2889082431793213,
0.4191434681415558,
-0.265358567237854,
-0.2561919689178467,
0.3919508457183838,
-0.22434057295322418,
-0.6025190353393555,
-0.03726844862103462,
0.49842461943626404,
-0.3328206539154053,
-0.403352826833725,
0.49056774377822876,
0.35406890511512756,
-0.22013260424137115,
-0.28946956992149353,
-0.48471540212631226,
0.07916848361492157,
-0.11215046048164368,
-0.47559666633605957,
0.3068252503871918,
0.22724971175193787,
-0.15500865876674652,
0.5273566842079163,
0.6603007316589355,
-0.28369560837745667,
-0.1189042329788208,
0.40360167622566223,
0.9389126896858215,
-0.6396477818489075,
-0.41814178228378296,
-0.9756372570991516,
0.7451258897781372,
-0.16217167675495148,
-0.19113977253437042,
0.7475663423538208,
0.2155250459909439,
0.5167486071586609,
-0.24707208573818207,
0.5229707956314087,
0.17602644860744476,
0.23303961753845215,
-0.5221691727638245,
0.7267077565193176,
-0.7250768542289734,
0.102925606071949,
-0.7988461256027222,
-0.7205049991607666,
-0.3421231806278229,
0.21519158780574799,
-0.4352259635925293,
0.07784022390842438,
0.5954592823982239,
0.8471368551254272,
-0.18074187636375427,
0.21987709403038025,
0.3443966805934906,
0.25767913460731506,
0.39598163962364197,
0.2410583198070526,
0.8813261389732361,
-0.2335122674703598,
0.3661310076713562,
-0.2726636230945587,
-0.356747031211853,
0.03756202757358551,
-0.8991958498954773,
-0.9246837496757507,
-0.43486833572387695,
-0.278119832277298,
-0.34416499733924866,
-0.1056896299123764,
0.8340670466423035,
0.773109495639801,
-0.9359564781188965,
0.08982907235622406,
0.3067491948604584,
0.3122798204421997,
-0.3122696578502655,
-0.290854811668396,
0.21566371619701385,
-0.48510533571243286,
-0.6810256838798523,
0.29937803745269775,
0.27311643958091736,
-0.3706607520580292,
-0.18649683892726898,
0.24001964926719666,
-0.4812403619289398,
0.47664058208465576,
1.0300769805908203,
-0.14296086132526398,
-0.734244704246521,
-0.4071770906448364,
-0.3729135990142822,
0.10080500692129135,
-0.14902959764003754,
1.0333203077316284,
-0.7759132385253906,
0.7721475958824158,
0.5955843925476074,
0.16220322251319885,
0.27907508611679077,
0.06030702218413353,
0.3991386592388153,
-0.7949408888816833,
0.21673554182052612,
-0.2663889229297638,
0.5205292105674744,
0.07411810010671616,
-0.19459320604801178,
0.23026405274868011,
0.44862431287765503,
-0.056800879538059235,
-0.8532077670097351,
0.29963740706443787,
-1.188433051109314,
-0.555788516998291,
1.053531289100647,
-0.022712785750627518,
-0.1465289443731308,
-0.19509561359882355,
-0.39172279834747314,
0.3418123126029968,
-0.3532971143722534,
0.7463289499282837,
0.592155933380127,
-0.0338108092546463,
0.0988527461886406,
-0.36094972491264343,
0.3115653693675995,
0.46970874071121216,
-0.7510579228401184,
0.050309598445892334,
0.959178626537323,
0.2717834711074829,
0.3899008333683014,
0.5003304481506348,
-0.23656192421913147,
0.17300011217594147,
0.1424100548028946,
0.20606929063796997,
-0.04157707095146179,
-0.503726065158844,
-0.3387649953365326,
0.4865584373474121,
-0.34479013085365295,
-0.42668047547340393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05020v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05020v3
|
Is this the real life? Is this just fantasy? The Misleading Success of Simulating Social Interactions With LLMs
| 2024-03-08T03:49:17 | 2024-04-18T18:55:07 |
Xuhui Zhou, Zhe Su, Tiwalayo Eisape, Hyunwoo Kim, Maarten Sap
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advances in large language models (LLM) have enabled richer social
simulations, allowing for the study of various social phenomena. However, most
recent work has used a more omniscient perspective on these simulations (e.g.,
single LLM to generate all interlocutors), which is fundamentally at odds with
the non-omniscient, information asymmetric interactions that involve humans and
AI agents in the real world. To examine these differences, we develop an
evaluation framework to simulate social interactions with LLMs in various
settings (omniscient, non-omniscient). Our experiments show that LLMs perform
better in unrealistic, omniscient simulation settings but struggle in ones that
more accurately reflect real-world conditions with information asymmetry. Our
findings indicate that addressing information asymmetry remains a fundamental
challenge for LLM-based agents.
|
[
-0.07878674566745758,
-1.0435559749603271,
0.6316269040107727,
0.3735070824623108,
-0.12500053644180298,
0.5657815933227539,
-0.3084561824798584,
-0.7069950103759766,
0.610487699508667,
0.26238584518432617,
-0.657232403755188,
-0.09015727043151855,
-0.4784066677093506,
0.049070872366428375,
-0.19474509358406067,
0.46876710653305054,
0.019727155566215515,
0.25666549801826477,
-0.6656410694122314,
0.030750025063753128,
0.16889269649982452,
-0.8550286889076233,
-0.8127775192260742,
-0.6227031946182251,
0.43550440669059753,
0.23174013197422028,
0.8823996782302856,
0.4294355511665344,
0.3784870505332947,
0.34108081459999084,
0.15894478559494019,
0.37407398223876953,
-0.7989779114723206,
0.01616808772087097,
0.044199928641319275,
-0.2950684130191803,
-0.12643708288669586,
0.45084425806999207,
0.6688065528869629,
0.7634959816932678,
0.08787140250205994,
0.23525497317314148,
0.3875690698623657,
0.46576929092407227,
-0.5634745359420776,
0.1983426958322525,
-0.1919916272163391,
0.07842617481946945,
0.09511962532997131,
-0.30241891741752625,
-0.07455754280090332,
-0.35505884885787964,
0.1372479945421219,
-0.4491380751132965,
-0.149099200963974,
0.36441925168037415,
1.010191559791565,
0.06766234338283539,
-0.3541449308395386,
-0.324162095785141,
-1.1702018976211548,
0.4795660972595215,
-0.7320157885551453,
0.1390843689441681,
0.24006995558738708,
0.4652054011821747,
-0.2956187129020691,
-0.2609558701515198,
-0.844899594783783,
-0.5192784070968628,
0.3166483938694,
0.17896637320518494,
-0.08374956995248795,
0.18930353224277496,
0.35892391204833984,
-0.3471422791481018,
-0.18056754767894745,
0.09244866669178009,
-0.5142546892166138,
0.11801314353942871,
0.8291981816291809,
0.4214526414871216,
0.13854838907718658,
-0.03704816475510597,
-0.4292457103729248,
-0.2197168618440628,
-0.6037973761558533,
0.2207479327917099,
0.684524416923523,
0.2121056616306305,
-0.2948526442050934,
0.8654101490974426,
0.07487991452217102,
0.31623274087905884,
-0.08457644283771515,
-0.16225776076316833,
0.08320333063602448,
-0.19885550439357758,
-0.2638537585735321,
0.06129733473062515,
0.8194760680198669,
0.7492176294326782,
0.6092809438705444,
-0.17461976408958435,
-0.003194056684151292,
0.19281397759914398,
0.3778783082962036,
-0.6195521950721741,
0.3258126974105835,
0.2677493691444397,
-0.3000391125679016,
-0.5789418816566467,
0.22547517716884613,
-0.6679874658584595,
-0.6068166494369507,
-0.2259078323841095,
0.5547822117805481,
-0.27051618695259094,
-0.21747300028800964,
0.16455243527889252,
-0.20715650916099548,
0.2257574498653412,
0.5378621220588684,
-0.1466321349143982,
0.422059029340744,
0.6196306943893433,
0.7375374436378479,
-0.2310735434293747,
-0.775754988193512,
-0.27209988236427307,
0.2313259243965149,
-0.35483431816101074,
0.7332672476768494,
-0.6482499241828918,
-0.5729383230209351,
0.006266482640057802,
-0.2463686168193817,
-0.13289663195610046,
-0.4707332253456116,
0.18950437009334564,
-0.41210848093032837,
-0.2509230971336365,
-0.4846678674221039,
-0.5286858677864075,
0.3436585068702698,
0.5255808234214783,
-0.4887070059776306,
0.5406713485717773,
-0.264533668756485,
-0.5550009608268738,
0.28017711639404297,
-0.7181735038757324,
-0.25707292556762695,
-0.09408122301101685,
-0.47978800535202026,
-0.021771904081106186,
0.004446515813469887,
-0.5420731902122498,
0.2238297313451767,
-0.5861485600471497,
0.30933383107185364,
-0.5899182558059692,
-0.7226980328559875,
0.6661914587020874,
-0.7680066823959351,
0.5453817844390869,
0.3200298845767975,
-0.3089047074317932,
-0.036915987730026245,
-0.4547559916973114,
-0.04694492742419243,
0.23776009678840637,
-0.42568880319595337,
-0.32494187355041504,
0.12607614696025848,
-0.16591398417949677,
0.195774108171463,
0.1959356814622879,
-0.9011631011962891,
0.20099104940891266,
-0.24023133516311646,
0.2306116223335266,
0.7887783050537109,
-0.14756350219249725,
0.5829728245735168,
-0.6600062251091003,
0.6632403135299683,
-0.016826994717121124,
0.15166988968849182,
0.5859441757202148,
-0.40336090326309204,
-0.511909544467926,
-0.14390183985233307,
0.2547374367713928,
0.42719346284866333,
-0.9022172093391418,
0.08177964389324188,
-0.38748571276664734,
-0.3754127621650696,
-0.5395111441612244,
-0.19684046506881714,
0.5973790287971497,
-0.00425896467640996,
-0.1148102656006813,
-0.09585724771022797,
-0.42313292622566223,
-0.6869469881057739,
-0.8728316426277161,
-0.4384453296661377,
0.11075442284345627,
0.3957788050174713,
0.31574198603630066,
-0.4500042796134949,
0.9159191846847534,
-0.12412426620721817,
0.04494931548833847,
-0.4942665696144104,
0.11739617586135864,
-0.1701297014951706,
0.361057311296463,
0.27864140272140503,
-0.6047801375389099,
-0.3786523938179016,
-0.1193196251988411,
-0.8978267312049866,
-0.014801710844039917,
-0.14543473720550537,
0.10616515576839447,
0.280412495136261,
0.593231737613678,
-0.6495373249053955,
0.6523632407188416,
0.400026798248291,
-0.34771057963371277,
0.7166357040405273,
-0.3338860869407654,
0.4156167805194855,
-0.7435590028762817,
-0.07122086733579636,
0.03486145660281181,
-0.15571968257427216,
-0.5910228490829468,
-0.12953923642635345,
-0.09840612858533859,
-0.01874373108148575,
-0.48723119497299194,
0.973392903804779,
-0.6734067797660828,
-0.1785118728876114,
-0.1953640878200531,
0.26747655868530273,
-0.010284395888447762,
0.17193837463855743,
-0.13454563915729523,
0.6912238597869873,
0.3548874258995056,
-0.42808496952056885,
0.5617778301239014,
-0.2919864356517792,
-0.396685928106308,
0.5249625444412231,
-0.6311596632003784,
-0.06852812319993973,
-0.5077113509178162,
0.24895037710666656,
-0.641507625579834,
-0.4923950433731079,
0.3984207510948181,
-0.5178263783454895,
0.08856289833784103,
0.18562749028205872,
-0.8011363744735718,
-0.44311046600341797,
-0.5735340118408203,
0.5056082606315613,
0.5158873796463013,
-0.42199474573135376,
0.9234217405319214,
0.40453222393989563,
0.16344353556632996,
-0.6379638314247131,
-0.6540338397026062,
0.2743408679962158,
-0.24832980334758759,
-0.6975498199462891,
-0.10778853297233582,
-0.10349225252866745,
-1.046028971672058,
0.0647769421339035,
0.01556431408971548,
0.05307728424668312,
-0.0683278888463974,
0.4705429673194885,
0.17278940975666046,
0.035207126289606094,
-0.2246706187725067,
-0.055834826081991196,
0.22468054294586182,
0.1641198992729187,
0.13322454690933228,
0.5453220009803772,
0.00753510557115078,
-0.9331924915313721,
-0.4553985297679901,
0.30144357681274414,
0.44401219487190247,
0.3689970076084137,
0.8465266823768616,
-0.008101307787001133,
-0.40223219990730286,
-0.078591488301754,
-0.7528394460678101,
-0.12670239806175232,
-0.4993097186088562,
0.2629774510860443,
-0.3872866630554199,
-0.6565091013908386,
0.4520476162433624,
-0.10317366570234299,
0.1401289999485016,
-0.20119619369506836,
0.1000661849975586,
-0.44379422068595886,
0.946945071220398,
0.495521605014801,
0.14078325033187866,
0.19338029623031616,
-0.006208241917192936,
0.2469911128282547,
-0.5387223362922668,
-0.3995935320854187,
-0.36271241307258606,
-0.49841561913490295,
-0.29409652948379517,
-0.6926601529121399,
0.42573803663253784,
0.0029821153730154037,
-0.20725813508033752,
0.13840346038341522,
0.1303865760564804,
0.6578203439712524,
0.47107264399528503,
-0.08048852533102036,
0.45894351601600647,
0.14806385338306427,
-0.06966838240623474,
-0.1265302449464798,
-0.8687118887901306,
-0.8561261892318726,
0.8304314017295837,
0.28764665126800537,
1.2939125299453735,
0.15257525444030762,
0.5425019264221191,
0.36044520139694214,
0.5481588840484619,
-0.4258732795715332,
0.5808255672454834,
0.2392861247062683,
-0.5052338242530823,
-0.35653409361839294,
-0.5510445833206177,
-1.0608645677566528,
0.2760750651359558,
-0.35969990491867065,
-0.7584909796714783,
0.28796496987342834,
0.2216530442237854,
-0.3814508318901062,
0.4661843776702881,
-0.6782251596450806,
0.6906176805496216,
-0.3007582128047943,
-0.4203673005104065,
-0.0496821254491806,
-0.7390310168266296,
0.1939089149236679,
0.1122700497508049,
0.5168232917785645,
-0.23701894283294678,
0.00833758432418108,
0.3707541227340698,
-0.4733482301235199,
1.148414134979248,
-0.10194946825504303,
-0.006071467883884907,
0.382453590631485,
0.23517224192619324,
0.5927448272705078,
0.004324976820498705,
-0.36454957723617554,
0.13078564405441284,
0.18025504052639008,
-0.5083768367767334,
-0.6482663154602051,
0.7912601232528687,
-1.1164182424545288,
-0.6679688692092896,
-0.5379218459129333,
-0.5442467331886292,
-0.21862930059432983,
-0.1879817396402359,
0.25719213485717773,
0.32502099871635437,
-0.6327739357948303,
-0.15334908664226532,
0.2605527937412262,
-0.2473505288362503,
0.1855931282043457,
0.6074731349945068,
-0.299098402261734,
-0.009342953562736511,
0.957973301410675,
0.33568111062049866,
0.6399911046028137,
-0.05356527492403984,
0.02709338068962097,
-0.2837781012058258,
0.000904398038983345,
-0.4985824227333069,
0.5838199853897095,
-0.5976603031158447,
0.22968199849128723,
-0.675686240196228,
-0.4045048952102661,
-0.491734117269516,
-0.2848924398422241,
-0.3626648187637329,
-0.16793175041675568,
-0.2100059539079666,
-0.05244617536664009,
-0.046935830265283585,
0.9749372005462646,
-0.20933188498020172,
0.2574561834335327,
-0.5859285593032837,
0.04453704506158829,
0.2829383313655853,
0.19811251759529114,
0.1318518966436386,
-0.4041668772697449,
-0.055710308253765106,
0.4603821337223053,
-0.11760489642620087,
-0.8354983925819397,
0.316144198179245,
-0.007755163125693798,
0.5401261448860168,
0.5746936798095703,
0.22126086056232452,
0.8974370360374451,
-0.5324190855026245,
0.6440615057945251,
-0.012616738677024841,
-0.6379385590553284,
-0.11288043111562729,
-0.1361493319272995,
0.03223235905170441,
0.560721218585968,
0.3148374855518341,
-0.46430471539497375,
-0.5309699177742004,
-0.9702597856521606,
-0.6349841952323914,
0.8016718626022339,
0.2603234350681305,
0.3118637204170227,
-0.011547640897333622,
0.40926462411880493,
-0.20547910034656525,
0.5125829577445984,
-0.8314179182052612,
-0.36349084973335266,
0.02130492404103279,
-0.045457951724529266,
-0.13218244910240173,
-0.4484694004058838,
-0.18418113887310028,
0.08066685497760773,
0.411881685256958,
0.11406556516885757,
0.36695435643196106,
0.1942864954471588,
0.17572705447673798,
-0.48364338278770447,
-0.17501187324523926,
0.3878478705883026,
0.5131024718284607,
-0.1229671761393547,
0.3775518536567688,
0.15000320971012115,
-0.11969271302223206,
0.1323603093624115,
-0.16177856922149658,
-0.012181335128843784,
-0.01734054647386074,
0.2993662655353546,
0.7563208341598511,
0.09223620593547821,
-1.0945253372192383,
0.8005109429359436,
-0.2535262107849121,
-0.25087398290634155,
-0.5806125998497009,
0.10011957585811615,
0.37087783217430115,
0.7157683372497559,
0.2495853155851364,
0.09708881378173828,
-0.06912917643785477,
-0.9689581394195557,
-0.23761582374572754,
0.8710512518882751,
-0.4427323341369629,
-0.33020541071891785,
0.5371360182762146,
0.2171524614095688,
-0.886286735534668,
0.2347269207239151,
-0.3666343688964844,
-0.18531423807144165,
1.0695414543151855,
0.5739069581031799,
0.5723045468330383,
-0.037999700754880905,
0.14989519119262695,
-0.08908779174089432,
0.48781588673591614,
-0.19477257132530212,
0.2954687476158142,
0.0584787055850029,
-0.9756208062171936,
-0.1602150946855545,
-0.5751866698265076,
-0.6826077699661255,
0.05248159542679787,
-0.3455129563808441,
0.2745744585990906,
-0.43026164174079895,
-0.06829403340816498,
-0.23910608887672424,
-0.24979019165039062,
-0.5572620630264282,
-0.14259076118469238,
-0.060723356902599335,
0.8077596426010132,
-0.728287398815155,
0.8553967475891113,
0.947259247303009,
-0.10500578582286835,
-0.574113130569458,
0.490149587392807,
0.07742936164140701,
-0.7656378746032715,
0.622016966342926,
0.23214983940124512,
-0.5783838629722595,
-0.19566774368286133,
-0.7740875482559204,
-0.6354650855064392,
0.9953770041465759,
0.6171669960021973,
-0.3042007386684418,
-0.38488703966140747,
0.6201546788215637,
0.7898281812667847,
-0.48422953486442566,
0.1762557178735733,
0.3522506356239319,
0.5106185674667358,
0.20897537469863892,
-0.9660526514053345,
-0.07474283128976822,
-0.41093018651008606,
0.037698253989219666,
-0.3249983787536621,
-0.9044959545135498,
0.6472375392913818,
-0.26889583468437195,
-0.5857616662979126,
0.034148529171943665,
0.6151648759841919,
0.5382410287857056,
0.4502027928829193,
0.4211880564689636,
-0.009935497306287289,
0.31515127420425415,
0.1469508558511734,
1.226155161857605,
-0.3657461106777191,
0.11405684798955917,
0.9064792394638062,
-0.6955702900886536,
0.38137054443359375,
0.5011155009269714,
-0.1349620223045349,
-0.11624334752559662,
0.5741848349571228,
0.4278915226459503,
0.0768299251794815,
0.39221999049186707,
-0.3610514998435974,
-0.30994829535484314,
-0.030552715063095093,
-0.19608362019062042,
0.2380528301000595,
0.32528674602508545,
0.07181304693222046,
-0.23202820122241974,
-0.05853985995054245,
0.08902903646230698,
0.27007633447647095,
0.011030497960746288,
0.5034188628196716,
0.13073568046092987,
-0.403621107339859,
0.3557192385196686,
0.12155338376760483,
0.8479951024055481,
-0.4260127544403076,
-0.015846427530050278,
0.06289993226528168,
-0.08701714128255844,
0.014832660555839539,
-0.5792354941368103,
0.33987706899642944,
-0.013858887366950512,
0.05159582197666168,
-0.09283183515071869,
0.7083343863487244,
-0.4507254362106323,
-0.41688278317451477,
0.6168344616889954,
0.7410857081413269,
0.4357403516769409,
-0.01133359782397747,
-0.628126323223114,
0.1993962824344635,
-0.08139271289110184,
-0.26585254073143005,
0.45742106437683105,
0.6297916769981384,
-0.006483213044703007,
0.9367873072624207,
0.5661446452140808,
0.31507906317710876,
0.0253448523581028,
-0.0651131346821785,
0.8616607189178467,
-0.6167550086975098,
-0.33448728919029236,
-1.0715100765228271,
0.07873362302780151,
-0.36604732275009155,
-0.11390446871519089,
0.8255060911178589,
0.35748597979545593,
0.6797533631324768,
0.027375195175409317,
0.733154296875,
0.1158682256937027,
0.4666106104850769,
-0.22542253136634827,
0.7123497724533081,
-0.6503632068634033,
0.62200528383255,
-0.4343680739402771,
-0.8177041411399841,
0.12486060708761215,
0.5909872651100159,
-0.3358785808086395,
0.09740053862333298,
0.38909345865249634,
0.6870213747024536,
-0.03691573441028595,
0.11240844428539276,
0.717125654220581,
0.41893526911735535,
0.062259070575237274,
0.1312619000673294,
1.3859765529632568,
0.0429614894092083,
0.29352155327796936,
0.03466333448886871,
-0.25644081830978394,
-0.2596781253814697,
-0.6062653064727783,
-1.016165852546692,
-0.2791212797164917,
0.1103697121143341,
-0.47487473487854004,
0.4737376868724823,
1.4583326578140259,
0.2672179639339447,
-0.15919014811515808,
-0.7633627653121948,
0.3211495876312256,
0.051972441375255585,
0.18592913448810577,
-0.24458250403404236,
-0.31881099939346313,
-0.08546015620231628,
-0.8641397356987,
0.3089069426059723,
0.39790481328964233,
0.179429292678833,
-0.5497627854347229,
-0.357729971408844,
-0.06830861419439316,
0.6914156079292297,
0.5133466124534607,
0.2959987223148346,
-0.5775690674781799,
-0.3100017011165619,
-0.1216292679309845,
-0.4744757115840912,
0.05563626065850258,
0.5406691431999207,
-0.6778488755226135,
0.23305244743824005,
0.15932781994342804,
0.4938129782676697,
0.21246924996376038,
0.3227551579475403,
0.6459559202194214,
-0.4061712324619293,
0.1050109788775444,
0.12280143797397614,
0.046528372913599014,
0.17750784754753113,
-0.5643119215965271,
0.32508721947669983,
0.2769521176815033,
-0.47573214769363403,
-1.0080575942993164,
0.23806363344192505,
-0.5162712931632996,
-0.3454461395740509,
1.600691556930542,
-0.12391989678144455,
-0.433172345161438,
-0.2244841605424881,
-0.16584526002407074,
0.13226382434368134,
-0.4860623776912689,
0.8628321290016174,
0.5932405591011047,
-0.3246271312236786,
0.2659026086330414,
-0.6546239256858826,
0.4798407256603241,
0.1806204915046692,
-0.7793155312538147,
-0.05049630627036095,
0.43590959906578064,
0.261582612991333,
0.13781137764453888,
0.8718176484107971,
0.05348849669098854,
-0.08651917427778244,
-0.05491407960653305,
0.05089816823601723,
-0.01950853131711483,
-0.34066858887672424,
-0.1551940143108368,
-0.03447762131690979,
0.26419007778167725,
0.33724167943000793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05004v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05004v1
|
Can't Remember Details in Long Documents? You Need Some R&R
| 2024-03-08T03:03:20 | 2024-03-08T03:03:20 |
Devanshu Agrawal, Shang Gao, Martin Gajek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Long-context large language models (LLMs) hold promise for tasks such as
question-answering (QA) over long documents, but they tend to miss important
information in the middle of context documents (arXiv:2307.03172v3). Here, we
introduce $\textit{R&R}$ -- a combination of two novel prompt-based methods
called $\textit{reprompting}$ and $\textit{in-context retrieval}$ (ICR) -- to
alleviate this effect in document-based QA. In reprompting, we repeat the
prompt instructions periodically throughout the context document to remind the
LLM of its original task. In ICR, rather than instructing the LLM to answer the
question directly, we instruct it to retrieve the top $k$ passage numbers most
relevant to the given question, which are then used as an abbreviated context
in a second QA prompt. We test R&R with GPT-4 Turbo and Claude-2.1 on documents
up to 80k tokens in length and observe a 16-point boost in QA accuracy on
average. Our further analysis suggests that R&R improves performance on long
document-based QA because it reduces the distance between relevant context and
the instructions. Finally, we show that compared to short-context chunkwise
methods, R&R enables the use of larger chunks that cost fewer LLM calls and
output tokens, while minimizing the drop in accuracy.
|
[
-0.3370256721973419,
-0.7791370749473572,
0.8754726648330688,
0.12183357030153275,
-0.3612847328186035,
0.133465975522995,
-0.2077346295118332,
-0.48755937814712524,
0.24438534677028656,
0.5275996923446655,
-0.5964630246162415,
-0.2562955319881439,
-0.40882253646850586,
0.3210355341434479,
-0.3775501847267151,
0.9707026481628418,
-0.16072320938110352,
-0.02448047325015068,
-0.48595955967903137,
-0.2743493616580963,
-0.6765156388282776,
-0.5576844811439514,
-0.9085529446601868,
-0.3360379934310913,
0.9692265391349792,
0.5039457082748413,
0.2582249641418457,
0.7026234269142151,
0.5114102363586426,
0.18352314829826355,
-0.09612786769866943,
0.16641083359718323,
-0.4850451350212097,
0.5946025848388672,
-0.3220216631889343,
-0.6085422039031982,
-0.21925026178359985,
-0.2113744169473648,
0.7416132688522339,
0.2841397225856781,
0.07032616436481476,
-0.010145955719053745,
-0.0936109721660614,
0.9064384698867798,
-0.48596376180648804,
0.08162897080183029,
-0.14872640371322632,
-0.035589829087257385,
0.03836020082235336,
-0.6666404604911804,
-0.4231286644935608,
-0.24770599603652954,
0.011759786866605282,
-0.5830885171890259,
0.2732355296611786,
0.12890475988388062,
0.8232800960540771,
0.2193206548690796,
-0.3064829409122467,
-0.4485310912132263,
-0.8744797110557556,
0.8624101281166077,
-0.5981807112693787,
0.5507298707962036,
0.4057255983352661,
0.09237711131572723,
-0.32169872522354126,
-0.8584513068199158,
-0.6430578827857971,
-0.13538172841072083,
-0.11706822365522385,
0.0839206725358963,
0.07098256051540375,
-0.09929097443819046,
0.5845743417739868,
0.1365555077791214,
-0.34092432260513306,
-0.016918472945690155,
-0.4374736547470093,
-0.16315209865570068,
0.3491654396057129,
0.19726909697055817,
0.17140793800354004,
-0.04610354080796242,
-0.5248701572418213,
-0.4305421710014343,
-0.7693479061126709,
0.24260295927524567,
-0.09458468854427338,
0.09248936176300049,
0.21161237359046936,
0.5243209004402161,
-0.2406032383441925,
0.6635058522224426,
0.23931124806404114,
-0.4139198958873749,
-0.08740874379873276,
-0.38195735216140747,
0.056614622473716736,
-0.35028696060180664,
0.47463274002075195,
0.28105592727661133,
0.28445398807525635,
-0.2024775594472885,
-0.3082701563835144,
-0.5497132539749146,
0.23518534004688263,
-1.0087766647338867,
-0.01568283513188362,
0.29283538460731506,
-0.2615196406841278,
0.3371720612049103,
0.10784488171339035,
-0.7940835952758789,
-0.2949901819229126,
-0.45707687735557556,
0.3468683362007141,
-0.5147014260292053,
0.24611631035804749,
-0.16781863570213318,
-0.2966165840625763,
0.6003177762031555,
0.576126217842102,
-0.7286533713340759,
0.24974395334720612,
0.8944953680038452,
0.7142294645309448,
-0.2563505470752716,
-0.4460892677307129,
-0.8164422512054443,
-0.0032844378147274256,
-0.15778136253356934,
0.9455599784851074,
-0.5557076930999756,
-0.4904034733772278,
-0.22359105944633484,
0.13523919880390167,
-0.20441533625125885,
-0.4039849042892456,
0.4093833565711975,
-0.8866382837295532,
0.6197646856307983,
-0.5381708741188049,
-0.5776666402816772,
-0.19368094205856323,
0.46394088864326477,
-0.6597561836242676,
1.0511633157730103,
0.1362057328224182,
-0.7883419990539551,
0.2755938470363617,
-0.2922339141368866,
-0.5056462287902832,
-0.06846447288990021,
-0.3336990475654602,
-0.33406731486320496,
-0.0003212170267943293,
0.30483925342559814,
0.3547232747077942,
-0.13819456100463867,
-0.05776279792189598,
-0.06292519718408585,
-0.631903350353241,
0.39865466952323914,
-0.3352663516998291,
0.2821536958217621,
-0.02116166241466999,
-0.11625272780656815,
0.18267302215099335,
-0.5259243845939636,
0.12416063994169235,
-0.0210478063672781,
-0.6925941705703735,
-0.4841389060020447,
-0.2013818919658661,
-0.14975003898143768,
0.1698555052280426,
0.291840136051178,
-0.5276389122009277,
0.15800172090530396,
-0.07649509608745575,
0.5428760647773743,
0.3984777629375458,
0.2671717703342438,
0.4698607921600342,
-0.5649614930152893,
0.8694455027580261,
-0.07469141483306885,
-0.1754409372806549,
-0.4719037711620331,
-0.2372429072856903,
-0.5751917362213135,
-0.3107982277870178,
0.28719139099121094,
0.7049068808555603,
-0.6259390711784363,
0.247776061296463,
-0.37869757413864136,
-0.17101797461509705,
-0.3777633011341095,
-0.03806456923484802,
0.593304455280304,
0.7898638248443604,
0.4316518008708954,
-0.22471961379051208,
-0.3291389048099518,
-0.8216949701309204,
-0.20851010084152222,
-0.09498356282711029,
-0.07399667799472809,
0.3384401798248291,
0.5195705890655518,
-0.15232151746749878,
1.1654406785964966,
-0.5401759743690491,
-0.27938738465309143,
-0.23267461359500885,
0.032622452825307846,
0.04110746830701828,
0.31158769130706787,
0.1751704066991806,
-0.8765302896499634,
-0.28229913115501404,
-0.36000683903694153,
-0.42904308438301086,
0.10068545490503311,
-0.2425459921360016,
0.10957129299640656,
0.43875089287757874,
0.804709792137146,
-0.7773807644844055,
0.22915393114089966,
0.12053825706243515,
-0.3469087779521942,
0.45320194959640503,
-0.5131813287734985,
0.4245661795139313,
-1.2571537494659424,
0.33344948291778564,
-0.17760707437992096,
-0.4203937351703644,
-0.39934396743774414,
0.22342339158058167,
0.5047363042831421,
-0.2631186842918396,
-0.3706997036933899,
0.992382824420929,
-0.7127075791358948,
-0.05988838151097298,
-0.33887097239494324,
0.40535926818847656,
0.5275626182556152,
0.42104053497314453,
-0.05171835422515869,
1.165758490562439,
0.0063562337309122086,
-0.5523493885993958,
0.09220533072948456,
0.26300048828125,
-0.19992047548294067,
0.6621044874191284,
-0.5174593329429626,
0.40455591678619385,
-0.36087092757225037,
0.6193701028823853,
-0.9927977323532104,
-0.17639149725437164,
0.12236235290765762,
-0.4934483468532562,
0.6865899562835693,
-0.2070610225200653,
-0.3667340576648712,
-0.31557315587997437,
-0.40916717052459717,
0.5783084034919739,
0.45459169149398804,
-0.4498111605644226,
0.654205322265625,
0.0796983614563942,
-0.6042413115501404,
-0.7930861115455627,
-0.6130116581916809,
0.10427062213420868,
-0.2823752760887146,
-0.4851376712322235,
0.23002925515174866,
0.029597057029604912,
-0.10909061133861542,
-0.07792362570762634,
-0.22804297506809235,
-0.1731644719839096,
-0.06403243541717529,
0.2074488252401352,
0.016016263514757156,
-0.06419360637664795,
0.41058415174484253,
-0.046070344746112823,
-0.2754029631614685,
0.019283486530184746,
-0.02847723476588726,
0.5065504908561707,
-0.05237213894724846,
-0.3517419695854187,
-0.3718077540397644,
0.7215291261672974,
0.7625364065170288,
-0.3151474893093109,
0.43776845932006836,
0.4224575161933899,
-0.14194229245185852,
-0.17324192821979523,
-0.7500107288360596,
-0.4144664406776428,
-0.3833564519882202,
0.48049548268318176,
-0.3867293894290924,
-1.1615883111953735,
0.8168025016784668,
0.1607057750225067,
0.03556893393397331,
0.1651323437690735,
0.045921020209789276,
-0.2700645327568054,
0.4915652573108673,
0.583772599697113,
-0.1251826137304306,
0.7632783055305481,
-0.05243057385087013,
0.28168967366218567,
-1.0660622119903564,
-0.20719829201698303,
-0.6709597706794739,
-0.2584114670753479,
-0.19043202698230743,
-0.6630949974060059,
0.38492268323898315,
0.3936156630516052,
0.01791812665760517,
0.12557154893875122,
-0.37627846002578735,
0.6653035283088684,
0.6123192310333252,
0.17770762741565704,
0.3474975526332855,
-0.12446728348731995,
0.15630488097667694,
0.03280658647418022,
-0.7806066274642944,
-0.34248894453048706,
0.7946521043777466,
0.3327321410179138,
0.8152121901512146,
-0.28994423151016235,
0.8938082456588745,
-0.018794048577547073,
0.28195515275001526,
-0.9275215864181519,
0.6306312680244446,
0.11796903610229492,
-0.2776287794113159,
-0.6234219074249268,
-0.4915993809700012,
-1.031950831413269,
0.22579705715179443,
0.0908428505063057,
-0.301245778799057,
0.20391695201396942,
0.016960421577095985,
-0.5363329648971558,
0.16245895624160767,
-0.5346144437789917,
0.4857034385204315,
0.043383385986089706,
-0.26875239610671997,
-0.19158552587032318,
-0.6956633925437927,
0.1148390993475914,
-0.05604136362671852,
0.1750507354736328,
0.16329944133758545,
-0.1209171786904335,
0.8244869112968445,
-0.3924747705459595,
0.69575434923172,
-0.08579688519239426,
-0.08820445835590363,
0.2698422372341156,
-0.027785561978816986,
0.8891323208808899,
0.07966126501560211,
-0.003238607430830598,
-0.29932644963264465,
0.254493772983551,
-0.34607377648353577,
-0.8583939075469971,
0.8113713264465332,
-0.3025270402431488,
-0.7052770256996155,
-0.4589546024799347,
-0.6179174184799194,
-0.03883616626262665,
0.3449154496192932,
0.168559730052948,
0.7117632627487183,
-0.12780775129795074,
0.234378844499588,
0.9687814712524414,
-0.18961332738399506,
0.4090912938117981,
0.559330403804779,
-0.14169177412986755,
-0.5179972052574158,
0.5385329127311707,
0.08000603318214417,
0.24613182246685028,
0.7606474757194519,
0.08152613788843155,
-0.5141707062721252,
-0.5208721160888672,
-0.5314670205116272,
0.5314794182777405,
-0.8423328995704651,
-0.26568806171417236,
-0.8826983571052551,
-0.04041307792067528,
-0.3029981255531311,
-0.17725062370300293,
0.02656548283994198,
-0.528157114982605,
-0.4801342487335205,
-0.060243871062994,
0.5912925004959106,
0.5737969875335693,
0.06786075234413147,
-0.040128860622644424,
-0.9012001752853394,
0.4547343850135803,
0.3328295946121216,
0.2809223234653473,
0.09731676429510117,
-0.5674183964729309,
-0.2422630786895752,
-0.028912601992487907,
0.023029636591672897,
-0.573860764503479,
0.29783210158348083,
-0.036849044263362885,
0.19940374791622162,
-0.08130961656570435,
0.14057457447052002,
0.6658457517623901,
-0.544305145740509,
0.5671007037162781,
-0.11498378217220306,
-0.4845551550388336,
0.22686755657196045,
-0.22296272218227386,
0.5521004796028137,
0.8551971316337585,
0.11740407347679138,
-0.8297468423843384,
-0.4678095579147339,
-0.3012291491031647,
-1.0962669849395752,
0.49504148960113525,
-0.24817213416099548,
0.1128993034362793,
-0.30872297286987305,
0.7260521054267883,
-0.029285557568073273,
-0.025535594671964645,
-0.364740252494812,
0.042244452983140945,
0.15789809823036194,
-0.1433015763759613,
-0.032508011907339096,
-0.5751425623893738,
-0.22287192940711975,
0.06129392981529236,
0.45856377482414246,
-0.16588394343852997,
0.3184174597263336,
0.8947871327400208,
0.00023897262872196734,
-0.030348023399710655,
0.7079740762710571,
0.9204614162445068,
0.9823771119117737,
-0.3003145754337311,
0.17580102384090424,
0.12626178562641144,
-0.5194635391235352,
0.07711049169301987,
0.07091131061315536,
-0.20443351566791534,
-0.07683731615543365,
0.5281314253807068,
0.4424012303352356,
0.364244669675827,
-0.7304409146308899,
0.44307416677474976,
-0.18237705528736115,
-0.04477491229772568,
-0.4948633313179016,
-0.07916904240846634,
0.25776538252830505,
0.3494190275669098,
0.4978139102458954,
-0.3682301640510559,
-0.18539191782474518,
-0.5788981318473816,
0.4334135949611664,
0.34100624918937683,
-0.45527735352516174,
0.06388983130455017,
0.4085417687892914,
0.12804308533668518,
-0.5385743975639343,
0.7696441411972046,
-0.0015597986057400703,
-0.5242961049079895,
0.7431342005729675,
0.55243980884552,
0.7885475158691406,
0.1908346265554428,
0.041799042373895645,
0.2975090742111206,
-0.10304810851812363,
-0.42531818151474,
0.48584938049316406,
-0.10950277745723724,
-0.30452796816825867,
-0.5664756894111633,
-0.4700830280780792,
-0.5622691512107849,
-0.08581019937992096,
-0.8362615704536438,
-0.18120171129703522,
-0.47041118144989014,
-0.042131636291742325,
-0.2928245961666107,
0.1567477434873581,
-0.517818033695221,
0.1795610785484314,
-0.47758325934410095,
1.181997537612915,
-0.3459588587284088,
0.7868101000785828,
0.41600826382637024,
-0.3809196650981903,
-0.7958315014839172,
0.13123752176761627,
-0.4701467752456665,
-0.6057828664779663,
0.6308013796806335,
0.20858484506607056,
-0.2297007441520691,
0.05138880014419556,
-0.30510586500167847,
-0.9472026228904724,
1.4356327056884766,
-0.16012164950370789,
-0.8279932141304016,
-0.16904863715171814,
-0.22703182697296143,
0.6074053049087524,
-0.27758246660232544,
0.10159234702587128,
0.3675942122936249,
0.5738062262535095,
0.11617688089609146,
-0.6593985557556152,
0.3218417167663574,
-0.0102057671174407,
-0.13690225780010223,
0.5173239707946777,
-0.7556027770042419,
0.8138527870178223,
-0.5527028441429138,
-0.4613552987575531,
0.3146381378173828,
0.6258419752120972,
0.4961298108100891,
0.5237104296684265,
0.3569997251033783,
0.5867595672607422,
0.922301709651947,
0.0020097256638109684,
1.3448688983917236,
-0.23304475843906403,
0.20983529090881348,
1.339492917060852,
-0.2408992350101471,
1.0205479860305786,
0.7733944058418274,
0.11463900655508041,
0.4215935468673706,
0.32240620255470276,
0.21799057722091675,
0.4043341875076294,
0.1921396106481552,
-0.2732510268688202,
-0.1003650426864624,
0.12251709401607513,
-0.35162419080734253,
-0.22109059989452362,
0.13341757655143738,
-0.3232155442237854,
-0.18038974702358246,
0.08130045235157013,
0.25943681597709656,
0.18561413884162903,
-0.1939813792705536,
0.8897941708564758,
0.38550761342048645,
-0.9774760603904724,
0.5212581753730774,
-0.004892304539680481,
0.5693145990371704,
-0.6201947927474976,
-0.09147005528211594,
-0.5671690106391907,
0.22570431232452393,
0.0907764807343483,
-0.9395589232444763,
0.2164866179227829,
-0.1751580834388733,
-0.6877347826957703,
-0.39194050431251526,
0.6413285136222839,
-0.6806043386459351,
-0.22964641451835632,
0.2553236186504364,
0.4169285297393799,
0.1653098464012146,
-0.10099813342094421,
-0.4094772934913635,
-0.09699925780296326,
-0.03613978996872902,
-0.3988373279571533,
0.4788638949394226,
0.6296371221542358,
-0.31473374366760254,
0.9539236426353455,
0.48531851172447205,
-0.0723211020231247,
-0.13863401114940643,
0.007280390243977308,
0.9070008993148804,
-1.2102091312408447,
-0.4551406502723694,
-0.6976147294044495,
0.15634050965309143,
0.07922478765249252,
-0.3677056133747101,
0.6303613185882568,
0.5987805724143982,
0.7691437005996704,
-0.022742152214050293,
0.6107778549194336,
0.0312543623149395,
0.8718401193618774,
-0.7670813202857971,
0.5283970832824707,
-0.38732823729515076,
0.14124421775341034,
0.13131143152713776,
-0.7710251212120056,
-0.3175976872444153,
0.2649484872817993,
-0.3395361304283142,
-0.050993192940950394,
0.9023844599723816,
0.8263631463050842,
0.023623093962669373,
-0.21474258601665497,
0.2201630175113678,
0.07602868974208832,
0.48613637685775757,
0.6462361216545105,
0.8607166409492493,
-0.3770691156387329,
0.5410352945327759,
-0.06872261315584183,
-0.102248914539814,
-0.3903312087059021,
-0.7629762887954712,
-0.855259358882904,
-0.5373451709747314,
-0.07786659151315689,
-0.4457626938819885,
0.12075824290513992,
0.7016977667808533,
0.5071583390235901,
-0.5955846905708313,
0.12195464968681335,
0.20697307586669922,
0.3861551284790039,
-0.17353086173534393,
-0.2646487057209015,
0.4817928969860077,
-0.4289930462837219,
-0.41613373160362244,
0.6571904420852661,
0.294803649187088,
0.23871473968029022,
-0.12245568633079529,
0.040109824389219284,
-0.09196460992097855,
0.11987629532814026,
0.5597091317176819,
0.6957728862762451,
-0.6020991206169128,
-0.6885376572608948,
0.12527628242969513,
-0.3153393864631653,
0.15493696928024292,
0.9962984919548035,
-0.8480427265167236,
0.13928765058517456,
0.8253044486045837,
0.6427001357078552,
0.5414574146270752,
0.5981900691986084,
0.6825851202011108,
-0.5811090469360352,
-0.14015911519527435,
0.44454362988471985,
0.18883194029331207,
0.37495654821395874,
-0.4587480425834656,
0.4161945581436157,
-0.06722573190927505,
-0.8558216691017151,
-0.640864372253418,
0.32612690329551697,
-1.1818673610687256,
-0.46455734968185425,
1.2165127992630005,
-0.33315151929855347,
-0.33485016226768494,
-0.24519005417823792,
-0.3408806324005127,
0.025288686156272888,
-0.6216456294059753,
0.909990131855011,
0.7464380264282227,
-0.15776866674423218,
-0.2842945158481598,
-0.35936856269836426,
0.4913118779659271,
0.37353330850601196,
-0.7160826921463013,
0.36104369163513184,
0.6497809290885925,
0.6767120361328125,
0.20706814527511597,
0.8830994367599487,
-0.16918258368968964,
0.20184534788131714,
-0.2770427167415619,
-0.1315162479877472,
-0.3230752646923065,
-0.5285181999206543,
-0.5365466475486755,
0.32838043570518494,
0.06931904703378677,
-0.04156273230910301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04997v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04997v1
|
DiffChat: Learning to Chat with Text-to-Image Synthesis Models for Interactive Image Creation
| 2024-03-08T02:24:27 | 2024-03-08T02:24:27 |
Jiapeng Wang, Chengyu Wang, Tingfeng Cao, Jun Huang, Lianwen Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
We present DiffChat, a novel method to align Large Language Models (LLMs) to
"chat" with prompt-as-input Text-to-Image Synthesis (TIS) models (e.g., Stable
Diffusion) for interactive image creation. Given a raw prompt/image and a
user-specified instruction, DiffChat can effectively make appropriate
modifications and generate the target prompt, which can be leveraged to create
the target image of high quality. To achieve this, we first collect an
instruction-following prompt engineering dataset named InstructPE for the
supervised training of DiffChat. Next, we propose a reinforcement learning
framework with the feedback of three core criteria for image creation, i.e.,
aesthetics, user preference, and content integrity. It involves an action-space
dynamic modification technique to obtain more relevant positive samples and
harder negative samples during the off-policy sampling. Content integrity is
also introduced into the value estimation function for further improvement of
produced images. Our method can exhibit superior performance than baseline
models and strong competitors based on both automatic and human evaluations,
which fully demonstrates its effectiveness.
|
[
-0.4383336305618286,
-1.05815851688385,
0.5571807026863098,
0.3518872857093811,
-0.2755397856235504,
0.4122501015663147,
-0.12114172428846359,
-0.4124806225299835,
0.18309657275676727,
0.1467156708240509,
-0.8044766187667847,
-0.4092971682548523,
-0.4071209132671356,
-0.0701429694890976,
-0.3048727512359619,
0.7147793173789978,
-0.07183508574962616,
0.11126749217510223,
-0.26560384035110474,
0.21014370024204254,
-0.6855884790420532,
-0.05049542337656021,
-1.0950424671173096,
-0.09480522572994232,
0.40495455265045166,
0.4300459623336792,
0.7178909182548523,
0.3155587315559387,
0.4205555021762848,
0.433226615190506,
-0.08617523312568665,
0.5284449458122253,
-0.648734986782074,
0.45603063702583313,
-0.12147808074951172,
-0.20387624204158783,
-0.1546100378036499,
-0.004220228176563978,
0.4773157835006714,
0.37771472334861755,
-0.06266448646783829,
-0.29344817996025085,
0.14313849806785583,
0.6967483162879944,
-0.2103879749774933,
0.12066487967967987,
-0.6260710954666138,
0.1455247849225998,
0.22090789675712585,
-0.34038567543029785,
-0.5611973404884338,
-0.3717900216579437,
-0.017523109912872314,
-0.8211689591407776,
-0.21469669044017792,
0.1020955890417099,
0.7049617171287537,
0.4627399146556854,
-0.4934201240539551,
-0.49813762307167053,
-0.8070765137672424,
0.5639150738716125,
-0.501723051071167,
0.22292321920394897,
0.09494296461343765,
0.5446995496749878,
-0.5540889501571655,
-0.8827720880508423,
-0.6840600967407227,
-0.3860355615615845,
0.11894509941339493,
0.30371424555778503,
-0.21379075944423676,
0.07034652680158615,
0.0683983713388443,
0.2214035987854004,
-0.22197586297988892,
0.24381257593631744,
-0.17654986679553986,
-0.2028312385082245,
0.6138907670974731,
0.18677954375743866,
0.6564398407936096,
0.23642633855342865,
-0.42866817116737366,
-0.40685030817985535,
-0.5808688402175903,
-0.10393655300140381,
0.3588981628417969,
0.162420392036438,
-0.09873731434345245,
0.44708821177482605,
0.10775157064199448,
0.4331374168395996,
0.4313710629940033,
0.0014396992046386003,
0.03426818922162056,
-0.1706014722585678,
0.04373660683631897,
0.017544671893119812,
0.9184170961380005,
0.6055312752723694,
-0.2885359525680542,
0.29704180359840393,
-0.24616214632987976,
0.013724061660468578,
0.10877077281475067,
-0.8805174231529236,
-0.26112183928489685,
-0.06157773733139038,
-0.2010333091020584,
-0.7121008038520813,
-0.17408297955989838,
-0.7108088135719299,
-0.5138096809387207,
-0.3670429289340973,
0.3289375305175781,
-0.37369468808174133,
-0.2707812786102295,
-0.16175220906734467,
0.03341608867049217,
0.06437892466783524,
0.8151889443397522,
-0.6059833765029907,
0.31860634684562683,
0.016490157693624496,
0.7832641005516052,
-0.3979399502277374,
-0.20595405995845795,
-0.7345308661460876,
-0.00475268391892314,
-0.7775059342384338,
0.8894481658935547,
-0.5265315175056458,
-0.5039762854576111,
-0.052121564745903015,
-0.18233221769332886,
0.5161426067352295,
-0.3580169677734375,
0.10588948428630829,
-0.5863828063011169,
0.45488882064819336,
-0.012496136128902435,
-0.662809431552887,
0.0574830062687397,
0.20542463660240173,
-0.6749433875083923,
1.056681513786316,
0.07589948177337646,
-0.6913034319877625,
0.15794168412685394,
-0.9122402667999268,
-0.2915823459625244,
0.2283855378627777,
-0.32544761896133423,
-0.38446441292762756,
-0.16101154685020447,
0.24138155579566956,
0.28376296162605286,
0.12289594113826752,
0.09435345232486725,
-0.3580890893936157,
-0.18051056563854218,
0.6572087407112122,
-0.6656779050827026,
0.3601255714893341,
0.4283427894115448,
-0.16679871082305908,
0.13367578387260437,
-0.40438219904899597,
-0.12312924861907959,
0.23396719992160797,
-0.3032917082309723,
-0.12213890999555588,
0.08123143762350082,
0.1655115932226181,
0.2563931345939636,
0.12833094596862793,
-0.44521501660346985,
0.4222029745578766,
-0.11319202184677124,
0.5087540745735168,
0.7105676531791687,
0.24488011002540588,
0.5761849880218506,
-0.3769310712814331,
0.39695945382118225,
0.231470987200737,
0.2621939778327942,
-0.6332946419715881,
-0.35890766978263855,
-0.6332815289497375,
-0.3824353516101837,
0.3117726743221283,
0.5479366779327393,
-1.3000816106796265,
0.15734444558620453,
-0.02925570122897625,
-0.3826686441898346,
-0.14587733149528503,
-0.07955663651227951,
0.1825745552778244,
0.511501133441925,
0.20390622317790985,
-0.4761503338813782,
-0.40036821365356445,
-0.5860640406608582,
0.4096035659313202,
-0.3365553915500641,
-0.039548758417367935,
0.2367352694272995,
0.26955199241638184,
-0.137367844581604,
0.7536797523498535,
-0.569970965385437,
-0.0817514955997467,
-0.09767938405275345,
0.35334303975105286,
-0.15439514815807343,
0.5784664750099182,
0.7603609561920166,
-0.7753985524177551,
-0.9025591015815735,
-0.06642156839370728,
-0.48044443130493164,
-0.13720962405204773,
-0.38897985219955444,
-0.48322221636772156,
0.32818296551704407,
0.8813220262527466,
-0.5482109189033508,
0.4104940593242645,
0.6051209568977356,
0.010396289639174938,
0.37079453468322754,
-0.2551411986351013,
0.7474431991577148,
-1.437325358390808,
-0.34369957447052,
0.1388556957244873,
-0.5934281945228577,
-0.38671138882637024,
-0.19914305210113525,
-0.13498875498771667,
-0.3145860731601715,
-0.5953530669212341,
0.5335840582847595,
-0.5926065444946289,
0.05157933384180069,
-0.5293378233909607,
0.07917533814907074,
0.05007928982377052,
0.6056044697761536,
0.1605067402124405,
0.779038667678833,
0.775630533695221,
-0.5078332424163818,
0.578626275062561,
0.450962096452713,
-0.4484996497631073,
0.8295181393623352,
-0.6088195443153381,
0.32220152020454407,
0.04084848240017891,
0.5456820726394653,
-1.4849202632904053,
-0.3383037745952606,
0.3356391489505768,
-0.4471113383769989,
0.46914657950401306,
-0.3217434287071228,
-0.48358187079429626,
-0.07679487019777298,
-0.113701730966568,
0.3563535511493683,
0.9174991846084595,
-0.6564537882804871,
0.210833340883255,
0.3928891122341156,
-0.366694837808609,
-0.2943704426288605,
-0.7071631550788879,
0.2039666473865509,
-0.21097570657730103,
-0.5605940818786621,
0.6343549489974976,
-0.39437851309776306,
0.040682628750801086,
0.1890069991350174,
0.13600164651870728,
-0.2617949843406677,
0.03946205601096153,
0.2256794422864914,
0.4133264124393463,
0.07850382477045059,
0.21294398605823517,
0.34405550360679626,
0.11397172510623932,
-0.22047056257724762,
-0.13404245674610138,
0.3833121955394745,
0.16378343105316162,
-0.8391689658164978,
-0.714354395866394,
0.37212684750556946,
0.45605969429016113,
0.055083151906728745,
0.2888208329677582,
0.3804360330104828,
-0.15322493016719818,
-0.29651549458503723,
-0.23271876573562622,
-0.37712037563323975,
-0.5817050933837891,
0.37581759691238403,
0.0725315734744072,
-0.8181975483894348,
0.4177631437778473,
-0.3892836570739746,
0.5441594123840332,
-0.021691275760531425,
0.4557080566883087,
-0.6190565824508667,
1.1031899452209473,
0.4781229496002197,
0.34687694907188416,
1.1176217794418335,
0.10741926729679108,
0.017557380720973015,
-0.1993044912815094,
0.06606683135032654,
-0.01667267642915249,
-0.5329710245132446,
-0.6074854135513306,
-0.6565368175506592,
0.4168875515460968,
-0.10709154605865479,
-0.1690445840358734,
-0.03796767070889473,
-0.48716363310813904,
0.6776344180107117,
0.38987788558006287,
0.5046118497848511,
0.23004864156246185,
0.23760879039764404,
0.020486734807491302,
-0.1652919352054596,
-0.42301249504089355,
-0.4774070680141449,
0.6563432216644287,
0.2654118239879608,
1.0308904647827148,
-0.005196479149162769,
0.8138116002082825,
0.548647403717041,
0.26527756452560425,
-0.8464277386665344,
0.5830127596855164,
0.1277955025434494,
-0.15123651921749115,
-0.30394601821899414,
-0.43300652503967285,
-0.8782660365104675,
-0.13666783273220062,
-0.46271342039108276,
-0.282900333404541,
-0.3299275040626526,
0.4708971083164215,
-0.15166111290454865,
0.20884086191654205,
-0.7551631331443787,
0.5023155808448792,
-0.37739649415016174,
-0.4874243140220642,
-0.17819951474666595,
-0.4690735638141632,
0.30804118514060974,
0.16995874047279358,
0.18183550238609314,
0.07569460570812225,
-0.028928974643349648,
0.19812563061714172,
-0.3420347571372986,
1.111029863357544,
-0.21813838183879852,
-0.034227143973112106,
0.4782046377658844,
0.5043621063232422,
0.5456759929656982,
-0.02171015366911888,
0.16524629294872284,
-0.1895741969347,
-0.022302471101284027,
-0.23229913413524628,
-0.907785952091217,
0.5154548287391663,
-0.7366560101509094,
-0.3840101659297943,
-0.046383630484342575,
-0.483531653881073,
-0.20152361690998077,
0.0011398210190236568,
0.07460623979568481,
0.3884963393211365,
-0.5672166347503662,
0.03833384811878204,
0.7198754549026489,
-0.597290575504303,
0.38254314661026,
0.2864076793193817,
-0.47040700912475586,
-0.6001508831977844,
0.7316333651542664,
-0.19045695662498474,
0.4478534758090973,
0.4229600429534912,
0.07756955176591873,
-0.3320494592189789,
-0.4498444199562073,
-0.5318715572357178,
-0.07141655683517456,
-0.8472338318824768,
-0.27497294545173645,
-0.22387641668319702,
-0.4248049855232239,
-0.11590396612882614,
-0.2247275859117508,
-0.5633339285850525,
-0.33113083243370056,
-0.3607516884803772,
0.09315559267997742,
0.6334360837936401,
0.672208845615387,
-0.07874955981969833,
0.5279187560081482,
-0.8626205921173096,
-0.03553003817796707,
0.4537103772163391,
0.2184285670518875,
-0.28038424253463745,
-0.6832330822944641,
-0.09871603548526764,
0.27249467372894287,
-0.7998726963996887,
-0.8710113763809204,
0.33692294359207153,
0.19947892427444458,
0.6756895184516907,
0.1354316771030426,
0.14123037457466125,
0.5347437858581543,
-0.6429365277290344,
0.8147842884063721,
0.6570454239845276,
-0.8244464993476868,
0.7263885140419006,
-0.2644352912902832,
0.18105942010879517,
0.3160678744316101,
0.3412823975086212,
-0.6604097485542297,
-0.4438799321651459,
-0.6426122784614563,
-0.6930719614028931,
0.47943568229675293,
0.36729133129119873,
0.4443109333515167,
-0.06904131174087524,
0.24004854261875153,
0.09647058695554733,
-0.009286937303841114,
-0.7179256081581116,
-0.012533717788755894,
-0.2587879002094269,
-0.5157642364501953,
0.37073132395744324,
0.015382068231701851,
-0.14204485714435577,
-0.04269368574023247,
0.6361857056617737,
-0.2535143792629242,
0.28350478410720825,
0.023080822080373764,
-0.0797383040189743,
-0.07366940379142761,
0.010070756077766418,
0.568875253200531,
0.22195450961589813,
0.26534831523895264,
0.009782676585018635,
0.05173203721642494,
-0.1869140863418579,
0.23164670169353485,
-0.21591997146606445,
0.04097534716129303,
-0.0657055452466011,
-0.053952690213918686,
1.1365306377410889,
0.1140809953212738,
-0.5857553482055664,
0.5885711312294006,
-0.39159005880355835,
-0.4432235658168793,
-0.10140496492385864,
0.14516884088516235,
0.17015115916728973,
0.49396276473999023,
0.12459729611873627,
0.062033623456954956,
0.12289102375507355,
-0.3408207297325134,
0.30995163321495056,
0.3322905898094177,
-0.4069022834300995,
-0.2548861503601074,
0.49401360750198364,
0.5246909260749817,
-0.3004012405872345,
0.7884984016418457,
-0.38223132491111755,
-0.14055468142032623,
0.5890495777130127,
0.3706510365009308,
0.6900522708892822,
-0.23800335824489594,
0.6195254921913147,
0.3738616406917572,
0.008981152437627316,
-0.12196670472621918,
0.17699648439884186,
-0.0745023861527443,
-0.7467793822288513,
-0.4029715657234192,
-0.2521725594997406,
-0.6726011037826538,
0.12591807544231415,
-0.2650129795074463,
0.574919581413269,
-0.3109920620918274,
-0.2748745381832123,
-0.03753852844238281,
-0.266975075006485,
-0.37881988286972046,
-0.11912217736244202,
0.31497955322265625,
0.5895785093307495,
-0.8273403644561768,
0.6146544814109802,
0.786290168762207,
-0.4720804691314697,
-0.7981972098350525,
0.03821710869669914,
-0.01450008898973465,
-0.5752325654029846,
0.577764630317688,
0.12499094754457474,
0.07919580489397049,
0.1660785675048828,
-1.0316239595413208,
-0.6157945990562439,
1.0363399982452393,
0.6605160236358643,
-0.5733991265296936,
0.20237377285957336,
-0.06651890277862549,
0.43725115060806274,
-0.3762670159339905,
0.4354863166809082,
-0.16428235173225403,
0.17350652813911438,
0.8976281881332397,
-0.6930326223373413,
-0.11584410071372986,
-0.2903240919113159,
0.1659819781780243,
0.025063255801796913,
-0.3861143887042999,
0.4179229140281677,
-0.1666659414768219,
-0.45665082335472107,
0.006197513546794653,
0.7634081840515137,
0.3489367961883545,
0.1551886796951294,
0.8656324744224548,
0.2066068798303604,
0.5999112129211426,
0.03090246021747589,
0.5843830704689026,
-0.14900359511375427,
0.09251612424850464,
1.1222444772720337,
-0.30506059527397156,
0.5464134812355042,
0.6316958665847778,
-0.1048184186220169,
0.4287988245487213,
1.1683745384216309,
0.00695645809173584,
0.8550428748130798,
0.1613496094942093,
-0.1205536425113678,
-0.3126245141029358,
-0.04641100391745567,
0.02573750913143158,
0.17100071907043457,
0.3645367920398712,
-0.11643212288618088,
-0.28264352679252625,
0.07157823443412781,
-0.3702193796634674,
0.25879916548728943,
0.04798826947808266,
1.0225709676742554,
-0.08260302245616913,
-0.6402130126953125,
0.4506392478942871,
-0.3340139389038086,
0.6157698631286621,
-0.46729063987731934,
-0.5032737851142883,
-0.43346893787384033,
-0.20438891649246216,
-0.1264466494321823,
-1.1768025159835815,
0.2741841971874237,
-0.06554779410362244,
0.14480018615722656,
-0.3557388186454773,
0.5326111912727356,
-0.7060844898223877,
-0.29853555560112,
-0.16584523022174835,
0.2827209234237671,
0.3269785940647125,
0.27942565083503723,
-0.9942360520362854,
0.2084921896457672,
0.09367136657238007,
-0.35837286710739136,
0.4497922956943512,
0.7425808310508728,
-0.18206988275051117,
0.536454439163208,
0.6167017817497253,
-0.14182278513908386,
-0.19294199347496033,
0.09628228843212128,
1.0278831720352173,
-0.12554439902305603,
-0.548194944858551,
-0.7560486197471619,
0.7609454989433289,
-0.27888599038124084,
0.11229521781206131,
0.1832062005996704,
0.22726422548294067,
0.6793429851531982,
-0.06474527716636658,
0.9449369311332703,
-0.12779855728149414,
0.00923032034188509,
-0.6658859848976135,
0.617353618144989,
-0.6608002781867981,
0.17165862023830414,
-0.3605416417121887,
-0.7901075482368469,
0.03522016853094101,
0.5651727914810181,
-0.041921477764844894,
-0.055125895887613297,
0.4701921045780182,
1.1257144212722778,
-0.33972203731536865,
-0.15374737977981567,
0.44353601336479187,
-0.15665753185749054,
0.663402795791626,
0.36295026540756226,
1.3855458498001099,
-0.3043990433216095,
0.7020564079284668,
-0.17422091960906982,
-0.39777839183807373,
-0.0696713775396347,
-1.2776447534561157,
-0.6773322224617004,
-0.9503376483917236,
-0.6392731070518494,
-0.12463249266147614,
-0.1908784955739975,
1.1057387590408325,
0.8005676865577698,
-0.4190678298473358,
-0.09327759593725204,
-0.3625694215297699,
-0.002100715646520257,
-0.16694511473178864,
-0.16601356863975525,
-0.044934142380952835,
-0.5316933989524841,
-1.0332289934158325,
0.35498666763305664,
0.2798506021499634,
0.636242151260376,
-0.20438456535339355,
-0.186997190117836,
0.12678340077400208,
0.28549426794052124,
0.5523806214332581,
0.2158563733100891,
-0.3326925039291382,
-0.14145062863826752,
-0.08851900696754456,
-0.40866905450820923,
0.2857644557952881,
0.5122772455215454,
-0.35110729932785034,
0.4188521206378937,
0.5566153526306152,
0.7926033735275269,
0.6675193905830383,
-0.11433535814285278,
0.5754843950271606,
-0.8987913131713867,
0.33792099356651306,
0.015580405481159687,
0.20531029999256134,
0.5664681792259216,
-0.4222638010978699,
0.17516256868839264,
0.044702544808387756,
-0.6675055027008057,
-0.8279404640197754,
0.4048997461795807,
-1.0885717868804932,
-0.3618556261062622,
1.1386390924453735,
-0.1396712213754654,
-0.25649046897888184,
0.36676985025405884,
-0.8032529354095459,
0.41623973846435547,
-0.5972957015037537,
0.936362087726593,
0.5196008682250977,
-0.15759266912937164,
-0.4553087651729584,
-0.20600491762161255,
0.41625186800956726,
-0.03650124743580818,
-1.0766124725341797,
-0.08409969508647919,
1.0234016180038452,
0.2819731831550598,
-0.0418841578066349,
0.6689741015434265,
-0.058313462883234024,
0.2873469293117523,
-0.07915621995925903,
0.36070001125335693,
-0.13238979876041412,
-0.13825401663780212,
0.08085764199495316,
-0.3812073767185211,
0.33372291922569275,
-0.44131213426589966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05602v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05602v1
|
Extracting Protein-Protein Interactions (PPIs) from Biomedical Literature using Attention-based Relational Context Information
| 2024-03-08T01:43:21 | 2024-03-08T01:43:21 |
Gilchan Park, Sean McCorkle, Carlos Soto, Ian Blaby, Shinjae Yoo
|
q-bio.BM
|
q-bio.BM, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Because protein-protein interactions (PPIs) are crucial to understand living
systems, harvesting these data is essential to probe disease development and
discern gene/protein functions and biological processes. Some curated datasets
contain PPI data derived from the literature and other sources (e.g., IntAct,
BioGrid, DIP, and HPRD). However, they are far from exhaustive, and their
maintenance is a labor-intensive process. On the other hand, machine learning
methods to automate PPI knowledge extraction from the scientific literature
have been limited by a shortage of appropriate annotated data. This work
presents a unified, multi-source PPI corpora with vetted interaction
definitions augmented by binary interaction type labels and a Transformer-based
deep learning method that exploits entities' relational context information for
relation representation to improve relation classification performance. The
model's performance is evaluated on four widely studied biomedical relation
extraction datasets, as well as this work's target PPI datasets, to observe the
effectiveness of the representation to relation extraction tasks in various
data. Results show the model outperforms prior state-of-the-art models. The
code and data are available at:
https://github.com/BNLNLP/PPI-Relation-Extraction
|
[
-0.3333265483379364,
-0.37194201350212097,
0.5220339894294739,
-0.0073545631021261215,
-0.1999470442533493,
-0.3853919208049774,
0.1078459843993187,
-0.6858418583869934,
0.2688441574573517,
0.4122576415538788,
-0.3975042998790741,
-0.31765276193618774,
-0.5379506349563599,
0.3914548456668854,
0.2392510622739792,
1.1488393545150757,
0.18649059534072876,
0.2001238465309143,
-0.5547199249267578,
-0.0034527082461863756,
-0.0008930526673793793,
-0.6155607104301453,
-0.09917160123586655,
-0.6462160348892212,
0.7766299843788147,
0.0959823876619339,
0.4592095613479614,
0.22245660424232483,
0.8226229548454285,
0.2555614709854126,
-0.0440811961889267,
0.2805493474006653,
-0.44795727729797363,
-0.05374804511666298,
-0.3997376561164856,
0.104065902531147,
-0.6253103017807007,
0.39606937766075134,
0.54137122631073,
1.1239373683929443,
0.33834022283554077,
0.17495402693748474,
-0.013963941484689713,
0.6655063629150391,
-0.8639180660247803,
0.4442026913166046,
-0.2968171536922455,
0.35280391573905945,
-0.09268172830343246,
-0.36839404702186584,
-0.6238771080970764,
0.14992600679397583,
0.5105935335159302,
-0.5942569375038147,
-0.16166655719280243,
-0.17867615818977356,
1.2146614789962769,
0.01910647563636303,
-0.7141039371490479,
-0.14404816925525665,
-0.4732319116592407,
0.6314123868942261,
-0.5748984813690186,
0.3199114501476288,
0.3888178765773773,
0.011330232955515385,
-0.36535462737083435,
-0.7074102163314819,
-0.2324053943157196,
0.02235369011759758,
-0.6400885581970215,
0.29951682686805725,
0.05321811884641647,
0.04970215633511543,
0.29420214891433716,
0.3013346791267395,
-0.281203955411911,
-0.24096599221229553,
-0.46066176891326904,
0.10977765172719955,
0.6245351433753967,
-0.21795615553855896,
0.32092925906181335,
-0.6910494565963745,
-0.03515680506825447,
0.15904802083969116,
-0.6296426057815552,
0.12988242506980896,
-0.03565486893057823,
0.15743443369865417,
0.08509242534637451,
0.5519353151321411,
0.2054760605096817,
0.6678245663642883,
0.17625050246715546,
0.16392911970615387,
0.46254926919937134,
-0.46865466237068176,
-0.38685062527656555,
-0.1823279708623886,
1.2207767963409424,
0.45192858576774597,
0.07844720035791397,
-0.529390811920166,
0.38610273599624634,
-0.37416064739227295,
0.2864162027835846,
-0.9045734405517578,
-0.49032869935035706,
0.42264971137046814,
-0.5828853845596313,
-0.3161607086658478,
0.40647172927856445,
-0.9707271456718445,
-0.16651977598667145,
-0.45094260573387146,
0.23048242926597595,
-0.7774527072906494,
-0.36191606521606445,
-0.29456475377082825,
-0.30935439467430115,
0.4917590916156769,
-0.049733035266399384,
-0.5798740983009338,
0.04392121732234955,
0.5320835113525391,
0.5637844800949097,
-0.27603238821029663,
-0.07354554533958435,
-0.8710540533065796,
0.6130182147026062,
0.008090857416391373,
0.5192241072654724,
-0.6411046385765076,
-0.30720359086990356,
-0.185161754488945,
0.31104955077171326,
-0.32673314213752747,
-0.40351569652557373,
0.42395028471946716,
-0.739951491355896,
0.08663110435009003,
-0.2556588649749756,
-0.7795397639274597,
0.051136597990989685,
-0.21102577447891235,
-0.6820445656776428,
0.48657429218292236,
0.1512812376022339,
-1.2542810440063477,
0.2655753791332245,
-0.724068284034729,
-0.5904183983802795,
0.3079855442047119,
-0.35056236386299133,
-0.4737448990345001,
0.09380750358104706,
0.1864633858203888,
0.6648100018501282,
-0.0807989165186882,
0.700524628162384,
-0.7183434367179871,
-0.12471120059490204,
0.4793547987937927,
0.2744234502315521,
0.8228336572647095,
0.14978526532649994,
0.02222457341849804,
0.12369802594184875,
-0.9437335729598999,
-0.11712408810853958,
-0.07113120704889297,
-0.13203667104244232,
-0.4520554840564728,
-0.026429491117596626,
-0.07830427587032318,
0.3943757712841034,
0.1123797819018364,
-0.5877078175544739,
0.2280561476945877,
-0.459915429353714,
0.501626193523407,
0.3301871716976166,
0.4256514310836792,
0.6474565863609314,
0.14011527597904205,
-0.12097584456205368,
0.31332966685295105,
0.11477784067392349,
-0.057146113365888596,
-0.3690449595451355,
-0.26630693674087524,
-0.18673335015773773,
0.4626629650592804,
0.34740522503852844,
-0.7200635075569153,
0.8659117817878723,
-0.42917323112487793,
-0.22380919754505157,
-0.42071956396102905,
0.030902473255991936,
0.3816821277141571,
0.7375180721282959,
0.5697528719902039,
-0.37217074632644653,
-0.4721009135246277,
-0.8770958185195923,
0.03281833976507187,
0.026973795145750046,
-0.6158924102783203,
0.4483405649662018,
0.3706435263156891,
-0.41097477078437805,
1.111981987953186,
-0.24419574439525604,
-0.22993628680706024,
-0.001622371724806726,
0.32837432622909546,
0.25460898876190186,
0.5494115948677063,
0.47906920313835144,
-1.070321798324585,
-0.31906917691230774,
0.21845024824142456,
-1.257209062576294,
-0.04672624543309212,
-0.008307079784572124,
-0.24728532135486603,
-0.18133677542209625,
0.3752591609954834,
-0.4584018588066101,
0.2959076464176178,
0.2625301480293274,
-0.20851773023605347,
0.39124763011932373,
-0.018359484151005745,
0.0004749164800159633,
-0.8926600813865662,
0.7124425768852234,
0.4155517518520355,
-0.049898453056812286,
-0.7239054441452026,
-0.15743279457092285,
0.1368255466222763,
-0.08453492820262909,
-0.4678650498390198,
0.17738614976406097,
-0.562262773513794,
-0.21388210356235504,
-0.12746910750865936,
-0.013332370668649673,
0.24964101612567902,
0.5211897492408752,
0.4559139311313629,
0.42335090041160583,
0.37386536598205566,
-0.6504870057106018,
-0.05228453129529953,
0.5196447968482971,
0.2438272386789322,
0.18372493982315063,
-0.5985593199729919,
0.17856378853321075,
-0.23976550996303558,
0.19057345390319824,
-0.6853334903717041,
-0.5108063817024231,
0.8136772513389587,
-0.36614057421684265,
0.6649454832077026,
-0.49949613213539124,
-0.25161468982696533,
-0.06764507293701172,
-0.43474358320236206,
0.10708636790513992,
0.07413008064031601,
-0.44071945548057556,
0.9985910654067993,
0.9134023189544678,
-0.116010881960392,
-0.6815015077590942,
-0.4724249243736267,
-0.026240743696689606,
0.020615754649043083,
-0.23151035606861115,
0.6524651646614075,
0.045929547399282455,
0.03529934212565422,
0.20398661494255066,
-0.17522373795509338,
-0.31059327721595764,
-0.23250339925289154,
0.4974364638328552,
0.4308209717273712,
0.1990821659564972,
0.15806899964809418,
0.1375112533569336,
-0.23045098781585693,
0.2169737070798874,
0.14899465441703796,
0.0759214386343956,
-0.1923779845237732,
0.014839435927569866,
-0.574845016002655,
0.5028236508369446,
0.6138893365859985,
-0.37184083461761475,
0.7702227234840393,
0.6525347828865051,
-0.23786339163780212,
0.5713512301445007,
-0.221173956990242,
-0.006960283499211073,
-0.390646755695343,
0.33669403195381165,
-0.7442781925201416,
-0.4913868308067322,
0.19584351778030396,
-0.5179309844970703,
0.032460376620292664,
0.4183395802974701,
-0.10850349813699722,
-0.17630121111869812,
0.6480684876441956,
0.7331816554069519,
-0.239816352725029,
0.24707233905792236,
-0.3017300069332123,
0.18452173471450806,
-1.348081350326538,
-0.3678143620491028,
-0.2849985361099243,
-0.04759987071156502,
-0.5228683352470398,
-0.25148913264274597,
0.2563624680042267,
0.4178926348686218,
-0.05288143455982208,
0.4665733873844147,
-0.5210440158843994,
0.14535477757453918,
0.3265273869037628,
0.403099924325943,
0.34354454278945923,
0.1012614294886589,
0.016331039369106293,
-0.2722090482711792,
-0.8470965027809143,
-0.40805819630622864,
1.1164469718933105,
0.41338327527046204,
0.22458723187446594,
0.04857286810874939,
0.6554669141769409,
-0.1932315230369568,
0.7993764877319336,
-0.6567767858505249,
0.26510632038116455,
-0.09416057914495468,
-0.06545252352952957,
-0.17828303575515747,
-0.8285036683082581,
-1.155584454536438,
0.036562755703926086,
-0.41256964206695557,
-0.9008837938308716,
0.7016584873199463,
-0.16700178384780884,
-0.25910112261772156,
0.036253657191991806,
-0.7669708728790283,
0.9385273456573486,
-0.08034487068653107,
-0.6137092709541321,
0.06376733630895615,
-1.0777335166931152,
0.28572049736976624,
-0.0022974738385528326,
0.33380118012428284,
0.10708551853895187,
0.09155308455228806,
0.6570942401885986,
-0.1053643673658371,
0.6886761784553528,
0.03424781188368797,
0.08604194968938828,
0.10541554540395737,
-0.015405144542455673,
0.15790067613124847,
0.34418728947639465,
-0.2835855484008789,
0.4010557532310486,
0.18373949825763702,
-0.36162295937538147,
-0.47286373376846313,
0.5794233679771423,
-0.8140684366226196,
-0.07588691264390945,
-0.35719650983810425,
-0.37304797768592834,
-0.2975550889968872,
0.1428588628768921,
0.24273239076137543,
0.23855023086071014,
-0.08474916219711304,
0.12552116811275482,
0.6132898330688477,
-0.2602875232696533,
0.4114644229412079,
0.48813021183013916,
-0.20743219554424286,
-0.5884774923324585,
0.9652336239814758,
-0.06497395783662796,
-0.31889253854751587,
0.6128186583518982,
-0.04668628051877022,
-0.14458779990673065,
-0.21250464022159576,
-0.02814893051981926,
0.519441545009613,
-0.30653420090675354,
-0.2768264710903168,
-0.8406776189804077,
-0.4504464864730835,
-0.522041380405426,
0.19895130395889282,
-0.17784975469112396,
0.01711258478462696,
-0.3906484842300415,
0.0978158637881279,
-0.04674263298511505,
0.4067048728466034,
-0.025376375764608383,
-0.12833504378795624,
-1.2291425466537476,
0.30662229657173157,
0.21777503192424774,
0.3124282956123352,
-0.2026677131652832,
-0.21124781668186188,
-0.09100694209337234,
-0.39829570055007935,
-0.24389590322971344,
-1.334441065788269,
0.42245057225227356,
0.3659207820892334,
0.43010571599006653,
0.42239323258399963,
0.09403522312641144,
0.49271008372306824,
-0.38763588666915894,
0.30434438586235046,
0.25780412554740906,
-0.6459593176841736,
0.5636016130447388,
-0.2409219741821289,
0.19930116832256317,
0.5555076599121094,
0.9338898658752441,
-0.22364351153373718,
-0.035478051751852036,
-0.6810401678085327,
-1.0158519744873047,
0.7614033222198486,
0.3230106234550476,
-0.42328667640686035,
-0.11791452020406723,
0.8122725486755371,
-0.011345544829964638,
0.25407707691192627,
-0.8442087769508362,
-0.21848472952842712,
0.04985981434583664,
-0.22038008272647858,
0.19225862622261047,
-0.3583504855632782,
-0.19514326751232147,
-0.389113187789917,
0.7325855493545532,
-0.19719599187374115,
0.27279818058013916,
0.5934655666351318,
-0.3989259600639343,
-0.3045188784599304,
0.1317698359489441,
-0.15895302593708038,
0.5608928799629211,
-0.5161136984825134,
0.12992824614048004,
-0.3260878026485443,
-0.22788745164871216,
-0.2537998855113983,
0.6384038925170898,
-0.15407493710517883,
-0.13774102926254272,
0.5678964853286743,
0.26450854539871216,
0.21276222169399261,
-0.5905744433403015,
0.5166513323783875,
-0.14780057966709137,
0.017886312678456306,
-0.1503310352563858,
-0.14987468719482422,
0.15847553312778473,
0.21892541646957397,
0.36341023445129395,
0.0495055690407753,
0.5235116481781006,
-0.30541330575942993,
0.6803284883499146,
0.31556519865989685,
-0.4709260165691376,
-0.3177836537361145,
0.2766129672527313,
0.4830872714519501,
-0.07771003991365433,
0.6854567527770996,
-0.16339881718158722,
-0.03407125547528267,
0.3383382558822632,
0.13712896406650543,
0.4125141203403473,
-0.009790400974452496,
0.30716532468795776,
0.7012872695922852,
-0.2621282935142517,
0.6014938950538635,
-0.27479076385498047,
-0.17221030592918396,
-0.6720489263534546,
-0.8463752865791321,
-0.6494461297988892,
-0.38423287868499756,
0.6941879391670227,
-0.7584686875343323,
0.21383051574230194,
-0.11111768335103989,
-0.2121383100748062,
0.6980459690093994,
0.2422710806131363,
-0.5672181844711304,
-0.2085910439491272,
0.1094851866364479,
0.42992207407951355,
-0.8336693048477173,
0.9892093539237976,
0.8672001361846924,
-0.7848970890045166,
-0.47017109394073486,
0.007153294514864683,
-0.3171952962875366,
0.19692948460578918,
0.6853271722793579,
0.40634050965309143,
0.2586182951927185,
-0.1031867265701294,
-0.4146697521209717,
-0.7171880602836609,
0.7563987374305725,
0.3766951858997345,
-0.768213152885437,
-0.06645005941390991,
0.021000521257519722,
0.5437509417533875,
-0.46107611060142517,
0.40979018807411194,
0.5310285687446594,
0.41545623540878296,
-0.04686783254146576,
-0.4709787368774414,
-0.06878868490457535,
-0.6935036182403564,
-0.15838496387004852,
0.0589989610016346,
-0.4151467978954315,
0.23435814678668976,
0.057156577706336975,
-0.07233662158250809,
-0.2677234709262848,
0.7557350397109985,
0.20702190697193146,
0.3676820695400238,
0.1800621896982193,
0.31014391779899597,
0.6083430051803589,
0.11644819378852844,
0.9632768034934998,
-0.37551647424697876,
0.33172228932380676,
1.151774287223816,
-0.4328180253505707,
0.6810144186019897,
0.6851995587348938,
-0.2749807834625244,
0.39518097043037415,
0.5751218795776367,
-0.23262351751327515,
0.335742324590683,
-0.14670099318027496,
-0.11587256193161011,
-0.18532943725585938,
-0.16675053536891937,
-0.14842619001865387,
0.08369801938533783,
0.4532391130924225,
-0.44660651683807373,
-0.0927935242652893,
-0.05289072170853615,
-0.19962723553180695,
-0.03444679453969002,
0.04192133620381355,
1.0701793432235718,
0.17511215806007385,
-0.5853609442710876,
0.23752526938915253,
-0.4086003005504608,
0.36913445591926575,
-0.5138124227523804,
-0.30791136622428894,
0.09109368175268173,
0.0027137761935591698,
-0.2691979706287384,
-0.658050000667572,
0.2783468961715698,
-0.3448655903339386,
-0.5734289288520813,
0.2938671112060547,
0.9957969188690186,
-0.6457268595695496,
-0.4325824975967407,
0.7260013222694397,
0.5402933955192566,
0.17063812911510468,
0.11203952878713608,
-0.7622204422950745,
0.022229477763175964,
-0.10322567820549011,
-0.4145749509334564,
0.7588188052177429,
0.4020116925239563,
0.2566816508769989,
0.3167664110660553,
0.4655965566635132,
0.07358874380588531,
-0.5859242677688599,
0.03779255598783493,
0.9588250517845154,
-0.494087278842926,
0.0845063179731369,
-0.6255978941917419,
0.4305671751499176,
-0.6501553058624268,
0.050412971526384354,
0.32542431354522705,
0.44306936860084534,
0.39885157346725464,
-0.29138386249542236,
0.649817943572998,
-0.18409062922000885,
0.2647894620895386,
-0.10330209881067276,
0.6396631598472595,
-0.19994576275348663,
0.07420343160629272,
-0.3890964388847351,
-0.5990850329399109,
-0.4622826874256134,
0.6619625687599182,
-0.5237566232681274,
-0.0733090192079544,
0.7882351279258728,
0.38698914647102356,
-0.1429881453514099,
-0.011750946752727032,
-0.018603885546326637,
0.13721932470798492,
0.40958213806152344,
0.759894073009491,
0.2681468725204468,
-0.7149012684822083,
0.42985934019088745,
-0.4235803186893463,
-0.5437924861907959,
0.05881648138165474,
-1.0594655275344849,
-0.8787041306495667,
-0.42629802227020264,
-0.7259793281555176,
-0.20113199949264526,
0.18585680425167084,
0.8542761206626892,
0.866409182548523,
-0.8472481966018677,
0.01588400825858116,
-0.1595909744501114,
-0.05800043046474457,
-0.22169271111488342,
-0.2896782457828522,
0.7392003536224365,
-0.5448330640792847,
-0.6003516316413879,
0.3448241055011749,
0.4038214087486267,
-0.07871785759925842,
0.2324601262807846,
0.014274665154516697,
-0.69968581199646,
-0.39779752492904663,
0.7783957719802856,
0.42883604764938354,
-0.22567684948444366,
0.04353558272123337,
-0.3579246997833252,
-0.0415373295545578,
0.21597632765769958,
0.6769618988037109,
-0.7347598671913147,
0.21679170429706573,
0.24420325458049774,
0.7080672979354858,
0.5237168669700623,
0.02306317910552025,
0.7964014410972595,
-0.7902415990829468,
0.09014613181352615,
0.16094210743904114,
0.20003843307495117,
0.32865095138549805,
-0.6458168029785156,
0.7660472989082336,
0.40206098556518555,
-0.5428886413574219,
-0.4484892189502716,
0.07628262042999268,
-1.0536165237426758,
-0.5384257435798645,
0.9092326164245605,
-0.36753976345062256,
-0.5157601237297058,
-0.1501770317554474,
-0.06686889380216599,
0.5018465518951416,
-0.3814726769924164,
0.8472836017608643,
0.40621545910835266,
-0.5327884554862976,
-0.2380502074956894,
-0.27803555130958557,
0.6463926434516907,
0.22441530227661133,
-0.8958985805511475,
0.1671617180109024,
0.4398402273654938,
0.13652731478214264,
0.4647887051105499,
0.48777931928634644,
-0.5202287435531616,
0.13229846954345703,
-0.475002259016037,
0.20923328399658203,
-0.0641254186630249,
-0.3693074584007263,
-0.2418515682220459,
0.5518287420272827,
-0.4130308926105499,
0.19098377227783203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04964v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04964v2
|
Tell me the truth: A system to measure the trustworthiness of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-08T00:27:57 | 2024-03-11T18:41:29 |
Carlo Lipizzi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Large Language Models (LLM) have taken the front seat in most of the news
since November 2022, when ChatGPT was introduced. After more than one year, one
of the major reasons companies are resistant to adopting them is the limited
confidence they have in the trustworthiness of those systems. In a study by
(Baymard, 2023), ChatGPT-4 showed an 80.1% false-positive error rate in
identifying usability issues on websites. A Jan. '24 study by JAMA Pediatrics
found that ChatGPT has an accuracy rate of 17% percent when diagnosing
pediatric medical cases (Barile et al., 2024). But then, what is "trust"? Trust
is a relative, subject condition that can change based on culture, domain,
individuals. And then, given a domain, how can the trustworthiness of a system
be measured? In this paper, I present a systematic approach to measure
trustworthiness based on a predefined ground truth, represented as a knowledge
graph of the domain. The approach is a process with humans in the loop to
validate the representation of the domain and to fine-tune the system.
Measuring the trustworthiness would be essential for all the entities
operating in critical environments, such as healthcare, defense, finance, but
it would be very relevant for all the users of LLMs.
|
[
-0.33536869287490845,
-0.7822099924087524,
0.8126764893531799,
0.030594920739531517,
-0.17237555980682373,
0.23212023079395294,
-0.06678459793329239,
-0.47880157828330994,
-0.1168217808008194,
0.22908522188663483,
-0.3699931204319,
-0.5183786153793335,
-0.8411950469017029,
-0.2979584336280823,
-0.36227402091026306,
0.9687789082527161,
-0.20507310330867767,
0.05809543654322624,
-0.26436129212379456,
-0.12803998589515686,
-0.18893015384674072,
-0.8296921849250793,
-0.641217052936554,
-0.7420156598091125,
0.266253799200058,
0.3920767307281494,
1.0171085596084595,
0.4585486948490143,
0.733557939529419,
0.19605886936187744,
-0.025485539808869362,
0.004083366598933935,
-0.6511893272399902,
0.09260010719299316,
-0.25823691487312317,
-0.4668427109718323,
-0.5798434019088745,
0.4327879548072815,
0.238961324095726,
0.58077073097229,
-0.18598584830760956,
0.2829454839229584,
0.31025463342666626,
0.559332013130188,
-0.19298319518566132,
0.3997771441936493,
-0.5222631692886353,
-0.011324355378746986,
0.09890537708997726,
-0.2984539866447449,
-0.35776838660240173,
-0.7370813488960266,
0.4167403280735016,
-0.5892113447189331,
-0.14006571471691132,
0.4433155655860901,
1.0468496084213257,
0.09894059598445892,
-0.4518186151981354,
-0.38236579298973083,
-0.6712959408760071,
0.8215658068656921,
-0.6797391772270203,
0.48691654205322266,
0.3576458990573883,
0.38682499527931213,
-0.25471824407577515,
-0.7155367732048035,
-0.5555679798126221,
-0.6250096559524536,
-0.04229360818862915,
0.002831295831128955,
-0.2943066656589508,
0.003413217607885599,
0.1826421171426773,
0.28851497173309326,
-0.6716775298118591,
-0.2898455560207367,
-0.07698444277048111,
-0.5748260617256165,
0.26065024733543396,
-0.07333865016698837,
0.4799082279205322,
0.20585446059703827,
-0.5781320333480835,
-0.07935762405395508,
-0.828586220741272,
-0.18050748109817505,
0.31818467378616333,
-0.11015377193689346,
-0.03044956550002098,
0.5961212515830994,
-0.1140512153506279,
0.39242854714393616,
-0.030138885602355003,
-0.5641204714775085,
-0.054391082376241684,
-0.2287476658821106,
-0.3977695405483246,
0.012929060496389866,
0.766581654548645,
0.5211925506591797,
0.6347479224205017,
-0.24076497554779053,
-0.11259207874536514,
0.4236842691898346,
0.1270401030778885,
-0.7123920917510986,
-0.2959376275539398,
-0.04605477303266525,
-0.4522947371006012,
-0.3935191035270691,
-0.08581239730119705,
-0.4312590956687927,
-0.5832304358482361,
-0.3286094665527344,
0.6028332114219666,
-0.8628974556922913,
-0.22883158922195435,
0.001471122377552092,
0.12162353843450546,
0.3375159800052643,
0.43025800585746765,
-0.37905654311180115,
0.3902541697025299,
0.8795045614242554,
0.9899104237556458,
-0.2023049294948578,
-0.2815015912055969,
-0.2756830155849457,
0.10789427161216736,
-0.3758249878883362,
0.6121447086334229,
-0.39235952496528625,
-0.3751200735569,
-0.1669691652059555,
-0.2674030363559723,
-0.12944567203521729,
-0.32295921444892883,
0.7686578035354614,
-0.6573545336723328,
-0.023870866745710373,
-0.3520050644874573,
-0.9143208861351013,
-0.1885964721441269,
0.8527842164039612,
-0.166786789894104,
0.6229572296142578,
0.08515313267707825,
-0.7678804993629456,
0.27325621247291565,
-0.637360155582428,
-0.11734465509653091,
-0.21285350620746613,
0.061259735375642776,
-0.2426554262638092,
-0.22793418169021606,
0.005511169321835041,
0.43486660718917847,
-0.14493058621883392,
0.4181722402572632,
-0.5335084795951843,
-0.33045533299446106,
0.6439590454101562,
-0.7668524384498596,
0.7422771453857422,
0.36328384280204773,
-0.20139312744140625,
-0.26405277848243713,
-0.5988093614578247,
0.1930813491344452,
-0.029980022460222244,
-0.366844117641449,
-0.21804457902908325,
-0.12268106639385223,
-0.1329311728477478,
0.07920882850885391,
0.4854349195957184,
-0.5243728160858154,
-0.08906663209199905,
-0.28391361236572266,
0.37200766801834106,
0.7767854928970337,
0.1223338395357132,
0.17921960353851318,
-0.5958576202392578,
0.38327017426490784,
0.12590712308883667,
0.4136475622653961,
0.13366319239139557,
-0.5361757278442383,
-0.9122135639190674,
-0.08827835321426392,
0.4139786660671234,
0.4232039749622345,
-0.3494648039340973,
0.6198310852050781,
-0.5677449703216553,
-0.7150555849075317,
-0.11507340520620346,
-0.149947389960289,
0.38424086570739746,
0.6529235243797302,
0.15587718784809113,
-0.49040448665618896,
-0.2162199765443802,
-1.020195722579956,
-0.40235650539398193,
-0.6077095866203308,
0.025989199057221413,
0.3240097761154175,
0.5529312491416931,
-0.3069710433483124,
0.9014673829078674,
-0.47323188185691833,
-0.01748041994869709,
0.24795711040496826,
0.17557168006896973,
0.09430906176567078,
0.4389888346195221,
0.17767557501792908,
-0.5811017751693726,
-0.5034580230712891,
0.13702532649040222,
-0.8315873146057129,
0.1032974123954773,
0.3640366196632385,
0.07329927384853363,
0.07208333164453506,
0.22205114364624023,
-0.6999595761299133,
0.3084978461265564,
0.811245322227478,
-0.5498345494270325,
0.7546095848083496,
-0.3751291334629059,
0.351247638463974,
-0.9361770749092102,
0.11231917887926102,
-0.03910248726606369,
-0.5593346953392029,
-0.3649589717388153,
0.18765480816364288,
-0.15603238344192505,
-0.10151533037424088,
-0.18947428464889526,
0.3650314211845398,
-0.30230337381362915,
-0.2783394753932953,
0.00914921797811985,
0.3242655098438263,
0.07837669551372528,
0.12263472378253937,
-0.43310245871543884,
0.9232224822044373,
0.6245365738868713,
-0.7463744282722473,
0.548117995262146,
0.2915526330471039,
-0.5840042233467102,
1.2732999324798584,
-0.6623883247375488,
0.3170449733734131,
0.29956308007240295,
0.4316849410533905,
-0.8195834159851074,
-0.20383425056934357,
0.3383069336414337,
-0.820236325263977,
0.07767529040575027,
-0.17291170358657837,
-0.511310875415802,
-0.1492130607366562,
0.1589300036430359,
-0.11405545473098755,
0.6930006146430969,
-0.507382869720459,
0.5042625069618225,
0.5031896233558655,
0.04263046383857727,
-0.7004168629646301,
-0.490816205739975,
0.38200703263282776,
-0.06535627692937851,
-1.0893373489379883,
-0.11447624117136002,
-0.35417836904525757,
-0.5841383337974548,
0.11299469321966171,
-0.42108696699142456,
-0.4396267831325531,
0.3064216673374176,
0.44629690051078796,
0.23702651262283325,
-0.3883289396762848,
0.06734606623649597,
-0.37894612550735474,
-0.3379047214984894,
0.2022038996219635,
-0.36684247851371765,
0.491910845041275,
-0.6010963916778564,
-0.7167207598686218,
-0.4467432200908661,
-0.04084312543272972,
0.7871230244636536,
-0.07665366679430008,
0.7010997533798218,
0.343348890542984,
-0.23525923490524292,
-0.23510786890983582,
-0.6194949150085449,
-0.15524031221866608,
-0.4522581696510315,
0.02512924000620842,
-0.2872943878173828,
-1.034503698348999,
0.39664414525032043,
-0.38732782006263733,
-0.13536830246448517,
0.18681541085243225,
0.5656136870384216,
-0.038146596401929855,
0.7520588040351868,
0.5999332070350647,
-0.18317173421382904,
-0.26053646206855774,
0.3329920172691345,
0.7208381295204163,
-0.388532817363739,
-0.13285624980926514,
-0.5273553729057312,
-0.14923273026943207,
-0.4863796830177307,
-0.48511847853660583,
0.5154556035995483,
0.05289885401725769,
-0.3538329303264618,
0.17475008964538574,
-0.22047436237335205,
0.4744146168231964,
0.4608185291290283,
0.1951628178358078,
0.8159593343734741,
-0.1714911162853241,
-0.2765578329563141,
0.019814664497971535,
-0.2277318239212036,
-0.9555727243423462,
0.9491487741470337,
0.6225056052207947,
0.8700762391090393,
0.10953011363744736,
0.5260295867919922,
0.36771640181541443,
0.5699952840805054,
-0.9105501770973206,
0.5911234021186829,
0.1923852413892746,
-0.7982208132743835,
-0.4440940022468567,
-0.34486764669418335,
-0.4462229013442993,
0.016459977254271507,
-0.01733146607875824,
-0.6519551277160645,
-0.13490714132785797,
0.31394049525260925,
-0.2230340987443924,
0.31297874450683594,
-0.6583353877067566,
0.5691491961479187,
-0.08804304152727127,
-0.009144122712314129,
-0.3460385203361511,
-0.509194552898407,
0.4179682433605194,
-0.2832345962524414,
0.21373389661312103,
-0.3674033284187317,
0.08332189917564392,
0.7668020129203796,
-0.3789392411708832,
0.8553693890571594,
-0.01295377966016531,
-0.06177607178688049,
0.2731192708015442,
0.4908722937107086,
0.7367055416107178,
0.05064990371465683,
0.04768561199307442,
0.2840355336666107,
0.3028884828090668,
-0.20011372864246368,
-0.6424751281738281,
0.9003561735153198,
-0.8139278888702393,
-0.5167093873023987,
-0.728043794631958,
-0.3298744261264801,
-0.7725070118904114,
0.3355076313018799,
0.07921714335680008,
0.093544602394104,
-0.788538932800293,
0.386425256729126,
1.0938336849212646,
-0.25070062279701233,
0.060008011758327484,
0.7524584531784058,
-0.13267464935779572,
0.19655326008796692,
0.6913981437683105,
0.0858175978064537,
0.29033052921295166,
0.24592292308807373,
0.2973614037036896,
-0.26979199051856995,
-0.4188777506351471,
-0.08576768636703491,
0.1317167729139328,
-0.7977281212806702,
-0.07386627793312073,
-0.5365307927131653,
-0.3904498815536499,
-0.23454780876636505,
-0.04287182167172432,
-0.46155524253845215,
-0.2635568678379059,
0.06962157785892487,
-0.35415616631507874,
0.32465603947639465,
0.7100997567176819,
-0.03599480539560318,
0.4556955099105835,
-0.7070785760879517,
0.035918205976486206,
0.47299203276634216,
0.7404675483703613,
-0.3856522738933563,
-0.5984739065170288,
-0.03388305753469467,
0.16852021217346191,
-0.21999278664588928,
-0.6299389004707336,
0.2785640060901642,
-0.07271473854780197,
0.41493821144104004,
0.2542855739593506,
0.029667917639017105,
0.45898890495300293,
-0.5020772814750671,
0.7068887948989868,
0.3216661512851715,
-1.3363250494003296,
0.24358609318733215,
-0.3198399245738983,
-0.503686785697937,
0.43118974566459656,
0.4252399504184723,
-0.8411316871643066,
-0.31997352838516235,
-0.7875997424125671,
-0.25093474984169006,
0.22641773521900177,
0.18844513595104218,
0.1640016734600067,
0.3930407464504242,
0.3465331494808197,
0.04405014589428902,
0.1374208629131317,
-0.6057527661323547,
-0.41832464933395386,
-0.03900735452771187,
-0.24320416152477264,
-0.19658851623535156,
-0.3904387950897217,
-0.3859477937221527,
0.12741684913635254,
0.73409104347229,
-0.059799883514642715,
0.1621481478214264,
0.24927406013011932,
-0.136314257979393,
-0.2467842847108841,
0.49235257506370544,
0.2478710412979126,
1.3429127931594849,
-0.24222439527511597,
0.48204100131988525,
-0.06191826984286308,
-0.6641020774841309,
0.36459973454475403,
-0.21393811702728271,
-0.2639695107936859,
0.02130381017923355,
0.2649073898792267,
0.6455086469650269,
0.1628965139389038,
-0.44949254393577576,
0.9898800849914551,
0.00562667241320014,
-0.3451359272003174,
-0.450461745262146,
0.059538714587688446,
0.258474737405777,
0.23037104308605194,
0.06706127524375916,
0.24860379099845886,
0.01612652838230133,
-0.4906459152698517,
0.605883777141571,
0.4254578948020935,
-0.7520105242729187,
-0.30928874015808105,
0.30430787801742554,
0.10811220854520798,
-0.1443714052438736,
0.3800971806049347,
0.05435715988278389,
-0.5649139285087585,
0.34714534878730774,
0.4953189194202423,
0.6502996683120728,
-0.36645394563674927,
0.5102723836898804,
0.25834140181541443,
0.673801600933075,
-0.38937026262283325,
-0.1551235169172287,
0.535452663898468,
-1.1416376829147339,
-0.2856529653072357,
-0.5719459652900696,
-0.890620768070221,
0.23969228565692902,
-0.48814383149147034,
-0.04168270528316498,
-0.5520040988922119,
-0.19782371819019318,
-0.27224001288414,
0.20288443565368652,
-0.6513751149177551,
0.5748353004455566,
0.0687364786863327,
0.9547050595283508,
-0.773186981678009,
0.8301225900650024,
0.3565145432949066,
-0.08670705556869507,
-1.0444656610488892,
0.06027740612626076,
-0.020874833688139915,
-1.4621628522872925,
0.48446011543273926,
-0.11141332983970642,
-0.22049038112163544,
-0.12626156210899353,
-0.8905311226844788,
-0.8215541839599609,
1.0797805786132812,
0.36396828293800354,
-0.6159383058547974,
0.22245869040489197,
-0.005298580974340439,
0.5829839110374451,
-0.30443188548088074,
0.01802077703177929,
0.6679414510726929,
0.8702307343482971,
-0.027203485369682312,
-1.0882923603057861,
0.13690760731697083,
0.14218588173389435,
-0.2961214780807495,
-0.15771500766277313,
-0.6447423696517944,
0.8120601177215576,
-0.17470917105674744,
-0.294571191072464,
-0.3041597008705139,
0.3568824827671051,
0.28814977407455444,
0.38620924949645996,
0.7011224627494812,
0.5853393077850342,
1.1588882207870483,
-0.19197969138622284,
1.0887993574142456,
-0.4260619878768921,
0.5623813271522522,
0.9893378019332886,
-0.3316911458969116,
0.7148632407188416,
0.42590171098709106,
-0.22835269570350647,
0.30068373680114746,
0.44176748394966125,
0.056685999035835266,
0.17414416372776031,
0.29055055975914,
-0.1537989377975464,
-0.3935646116733551,
-0.1155725046992302,
-0.3681657314300537,
0.3472001254558563,
0.2951565384864807,
-0.39474812150001526,
-0.1559685319662094,
-0.4768535792827606,
0.6255174279212952,
-0.06541477143764496,
-0.02165585197508335,
0.4608868658542633,
0.4850211441516876,
-0.528216540813446,
0.3253520727157593,
-0.04948687180876732,
0.43639689683914185,
-0.7174515724182129,
0.09699366241693497,
-0.20593830943107605,
0.21130724251270294,
-0.0739978477358818,
-0.9722605347633362,
0.14730165898799896,
-0.039668917655944824,
0.03578778728842735,
-0.0898173525929451,
0.7983385324478149,
-0.14692805707454681,
-0.3512509763240814,
0.38405439257621765,
0.9257197976112366,
0.1974526345729828,
-0.26384592056274414,
-0.7367091178894043,
0.2497624307870865,
-0.046816855669021606,
-0.33935824036598206,
0.38160398602485657,
0.5408220887184143,
0.20746281743049622,
1.0859196186065674,
0.6854391694068909,
0.13548308610916138,
-0.10787690430879593,
-0.1150439903140068,
0.7024442553520203,
-0.40654513239860535,
-0.4568941295146942,
-0.9443469643592834,
0.028409738093614578,
-0.19746601581573486,
-0.15045210719108582,
1.0714315176010132,
0.3942350447177887,
0.44462284445762634,
0.25330036878585815,
1.228685736656189,
0.06266190856695175,
0.7686812281608582,
-0.30057311058044434,
0.9467032551765442,
-0.16291730105876923,
0.2567032277584076,
-0.17615346610546112,
-0.9019666910171509,
-0.2384646087884903,
0.6857987642288208,
-0.3226548731327057,
-0.11169310659170151,
1.0373252630233765,
0.8533492684364319,
-0.08097151666879654,
0.1046382412314415,
0.6493461728096008,
0.5596166253089905,
0.4473114013671875,
0.4143877625465393,
0.9680631756782532,
-0.3211343586444855,
0.7204786539077759,
-0.11869936436414719,
-0.5236496925354004,
-0.21905869245529175,
-1.075255036354065,
-0.73296719789505,
-0.3180992007255554,
-0.37514570355415344,
-0.8075914978981018,
0.22030970454216003,
0.5771978497505188,
0.6777937412261963,
-0.8266276121139526,
-0.10326118767261505,
0.19168171286582947,
0.15945477783679962,
-0.05439570173621178,
-0.14246723055839539,
0.2782253324985504,
-0.13365736603736877,
-0.26724696159362793,
0.28340473771095276,
0.3505738377571106,
0.01298746932297945,
-0.2978532314300537,
-0.24133576452732086,
0.30701425671577454,
0.3320541977882385,
0.4851175546646118,
-0.004452683497220278,
-0.5826662182807922,
-0.8355737924575806,
0.05934767797589302,
-0.3725128471851349,
0.13064278662204742,
0.7583872675895691,
-0.2614571750164032,
0.2984785735607147,
0.3006230592727661,
0.48143336176872253,
0.23914006352424622,
0.07494249939918518,
0.6866766214370728,
-0.2797895669937134,
-0.4169479310512543,
0.14759181439876556,
0.45501142740249634,
0.4804132282733917,
-0.40696555376052856,
0.5943379402160645,
0.338151216506958,
-0.8905532956123352,
-0.6803948283195496,
0.28702715039253235,
-1.1102622747421265,
-0.04158540442585945,
1.1155519485473633,
-0.4522912800312042,
-0.24221353232860565,
-0.5627475380897522,
-0.125273659825325,
0.1184738278388977,
-0.4551062285900116,
0.7076003551483154,
1.0311890840530396,
0.052575938403606415,
0.19972380995750427,
-0.5524826645851135,
0.5468087792396545,
-0.051658015698194504,
-0.6852927803993225,
0.08973973244428635,
0.4579508900642395,
0.8347678780555725,
0.34089192748069763,
0.871182382106781,
-0.2760748565196991,
-0.12391561269760132,
0.0867299735546112,
-0.14211848378181458,
0.08331213146448135,
-0.0641947016119957,
0.17105703055858612,
0.2461901158094406,
0.40243470668792725,
0.009716280736029148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04963v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04963v1
|
An In-depth Evaluation of GPT-4 in Sentence Simplification with Error-based Human Assessment
| 2024-03-08T00:19:24 | 2024-03-08T00:19:24 |
Xuanxin Wu, Yuki Arase
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Sentence simplification, which rewrites a sentence to be easier to read and
understand, is a promising technique to help people with various reading
difficulties. With the rise of advanced large language models (LLMs),
evaluating their performance in sentence simplification has become imperative.
Recent studies have used both automatic metrics and human evaluations to assess
the simplification abilities of LLMs. However, the suitability of existing
evaluation methodologies for LLMs remains in question. First, the suitability
of current automatic metrics on LLMs' simplification evaluation is still
uncertain. Second, current human evaluation approaches in sentence
simplification often fall into two extremes: they are either too superficial,
failing to offer a clear understanding of the models' performance, or overly
detailed, making the annotation process complex and prone to inconsistency,
which in turn affects the evaluation's reliability. To address these problems,
this study provides in-depth insights into LLMs' performance while ensuring the
reliability of the evaluation. We design an error-based human annotation
framework to assess the GPT-4's simplification capabilities. Results show that
GPT-4 generally generates fewer erroneous simplification outputs compared to
the current state-of-the-art. However, LLMs have their limitations, as seen in
GPT-4's struggles with lexical paraphrasing. Furthermore, we conduct
meta-evaluations on widely used automatic metrics using our human annotations.
We find that while these metrics are effective for significant quality
differences, they lack sufficient sensitivity to assess the overall
high-quality simplification by GPT-4.
|
[
-0.1440153867006302,
-0.7707224488258362,
0.9292202591896057,
0.4556882381439209,
-0.4366784393787384,
0.01900949329137802,
-0.3175712525844574,
-0.4363497495651245,
-0.18783847987651825,
-0.023061184212565422,
-0.5127853155136108,
-0.4476601779460907,
-0.5889941453933716,
0.7610477805137634,
-0.06886328011751175,
1.0365135669708252,
-0.3234303891658783,
0.10310301184654236,
-0.33509424328804016,
0.06014127656817436,
-0.4522475004196167,
-0.47232431173324585,
-0.37684211134910583,
-0.3214060366153717,
0.3485124111175537,
0.3780653476715088,
0.9047799110412598,
0.6447137594223022,
0.8132942318916321,
0.355726033449173,
-0.34013840556144714,
0.04045192524790764,
-0.3294578194618225,
-0.21379832923412323,
0.1876923143863678,
-0.2474529892206192,
-0.7160272002220154,
0.005969741847366095,
0.6042543649673462,
0.8487514853477478,
-0.06668756157159805,
0.11328571289777756,
0.10349265486001968,
0.45730963349342346,
-0.3670255243778229,
0.5153399705886841,
-0.28217315673828125,
0.11826183646917343,
-0.11506375670433044,
-0.10719503462314606,
-0.04198034852743149,
-0.6149200797080994,
0.15513987839221954,
-0.7247723937034607,
0.1819314956665039,
0.0067000677809119225,
0.705467939376831,
0.43377307057380676,
-0.3709316849708557,
-0.31546467542648315,
-0.5470752120018005,
0.6816092133522034,
-0.890156090259552,
0.009443601593375206,
0.1375633031129837,
0.28961098194122314,
-0.11690423637628555,
-0.7557486295700073,
-0.5572974681854248,
-0.3684237003326416,
-0.2882566750049591,
0.059638284146785736,
0.05170455947518349,
0.3084305226802826,
0.6532057523727417,
0.407769113779068,
-0.5447148084640503,
-0.2191224843263626,
-0.545548677444458,
-0.4639493227005005,
0.5983589887619019,
0.16514134407043457,
0.40682923793792725,
-0.5457285642623901,
-0.504242479801178,
0.18176250159740448,
-0.4785975515842438,
-0.21569573879241943,
0.4163636267185211,
0.080655537545681,
0.24294885993003845,
0.4960774779319763,
-0.4688602387905121,
0.3964520990848541,
-0.27662885189056396,
-0.18145668506622314,
0.6845331192016602,
-0.6694445013999939,
-0.27171942591667175,
-0.17042775452136993,
0.8987225890159607,
0.4928651452064514,
0.4212273061275482,
-0.2708991765975952,
-0.3331563472747803,
0.06924507021903992,
0.07830309867858887,
-0.7224265336990356,
0.0874219462275505,
0.10726886242628098,
-0.23108528554439545,
-0.17083051800727844,
0.08796875178813934,
-0.6752225756645203,
-0.08421409130096436,
-0.19750946760177612,
0.5628480911254883,
-0.43166354298591614,
0.13603845238685608,
0.36548465490341187,
-0.005459796171635389,
0.02967926673591137,
0.5613020062446594,
-0.5934863686561584,
0.4350467920303345,
0.7306267619132996,
0.8380839228630066,
-0.10079553723335266,
-0.6066024899482727,
-0.32034868001937866,
0.08732076734304428,
-0.11354830861091614,
0.6664938926696777,
-0.38426125049591064,
-0.22544345259666443,
-0.29005298018455505,
-0.21197451651096344,
-0.03821200132369995,
-0.5606045126914978,
1.2968074083328247,
-0.18725106120109558,
0.20995154976844788,
-0.5016215443611145,
-0.6575367450714111,
-0.25903135538101196,
0.2097967565059662,
-0.7400009632110596,
0.7326688766479492,
0.10499770939350128,
-0.9172545075416565,
0.38802075386047363,
-0.7923822402954102,
-0.3916381299495697,
0.20068995654582977,
-0.15358148515224457,
-0.638959527015686,
0.1067749410867691,
0.4327528476715088,
0.29036229848861694,
-0.38583678007125854,
0.33374348282814026,
-0.25053274631500244,
-0.924882173538208,
0.08986403048038483,
-0.6474123597145081,
0.44960537552833557,
0.09819422662258148,
-0.5353358387947083,
-0.03754662722349167,
-0.5477872490882874,
0.08673854172229767,
-0.12858888506889343,
-0.5227823853492737,
0.028203988447785378,
-0.3215458393096924,
-0.1928507536649704,
0.19931568205356598,
0.3919256329536438,
-0.4804724156856537,
0.20282123982906342,
-0.2802223265171051,
0.4653812348842621,
0.4133076071739197,
0.2543800175189972,
0.25367119908332825,
-0.210235133767128,
0.782937228679657,
-0.16877563297748566,
0.40013250708580017,
-0.16039986908435822,
-0.5451498627662659,
-0.5190017223358154,
-0.2233457863330841,
0.5142863392829895,
0.5967119336128235,
-0.6347399950027466,
0.3550523817539215,
-0.5784947872161865,
-0.3387746214866638,
-0.4319051206111908,
0.36884766817092896,
0.601478636264801,
0.3806208670139313,
0.5396905541419983,
-0.2148887813091278,
-0.3475897014141083,
-1.0328434705734253,
-0.7582857012748718,
-0.19490569829940796,
-0.10095880180597305,
-0.05344633013010025,
0.46472877264022827,
-0.3593866229057312,
0.8222804069519043,
-0.36717498302459717,
-0.19349879026412964,
-0.2859842777252197,
0.39640817046165466,
0.06147797405719757,
0.20823563635349274,
0.17465820908546448,
-0.6935604214668274,
-0.19222567975521088,
-0.37876683473587036,
-0.7929269075393677,
-0.4483853876590729,
-0.04578506946563721,
0.18021713197231293,
-0.010791447013616562,
0.523399829864502,
-0.8385078310966492,
0.5635662078857422,
0.2728300392627716,
-0.1969795823097229,
0.632988691329956,
-0.4610183835029602,
0.20254525542259216,
-0.48871609568595886,
-0.1448005884885788,
-0.04304603859782219,
-0.20692501962184906,
-0.4436761736869812,
-0.11381708830595016,
0.15304423868656158,
0.11618075519800186,
-0.23822157084941864,
0.21316184103488922,
-0.6225842237472534,
-0.32188454270362854,
0.07699433714151382,
0.20198753476142883,
-0.02232510969042778,
0.43055441975593567,
-0.41988763213157654,
0.6579131484031677,
0.022601787000894547,
-0.16363666951656342,
0.40212520956993103,
0.10583493858575821,
-0.25881966948509216,
0.3281746506690979,
-0.7572142481803894,
0.053955402225255966,
0.06589338928461075,
0.45443984866142273,
-1.0867832899093628,
-0.4803556501865387,
0.23027938604354858,
-0.1399705410003662,
0.02421751245856285,
0.11658234149217606,
-0.7997998595237732,
-0.2903729975223541,
-0.5446637868881226,
0.5353872776031494,
0.3666408658027649,
-0.25901269912719727,
0.6157249212265015,
-0.20570635795593262,
-0.4923757314682007,
-0.4303050935268402,
-0.7740498781204224,
0.28941044211387634,
-0.3354734480381012,
-0.7341766357421875,
0.12625472247600555,
-0.11181381344795227,
-0.2795291244983673,
-0.17823372781276703,
-0.19455274939537048,
0.09092746675014496,
0.10162974894046783,
0.1272927224636078,
0.10031010955572128,
0.08989640325307846,
0.1428333818912506,
0.12352852523326874,
-0.19086261093616486,
0.12650462985038757,
0.36223238706588745,
0.10846833139657974,
-0.46805283427238464,
-0.5380312204360962,
-0.7069153785705566,
0.09941297769546509,
0.5275967121124268,
0.08074060827493668,
0.0583377368748188,
0.5670375227928162,
-0.21528644859790802,
0.15741471946239471,
-0.6328126788139343,
-0.08375876396894455,
-0.4191471338272095,
0.4776376187801361,
-0.544701337814331,
-0.7119786739349365,
0.3726825714111328,
-0.3391900062561035,
-0.13006004691123962,
0.6304323673248291,
0.29056698083877563,
-0.04477546364068985,
0.6496103405952454,
0.32277700304985046,
0.16956619918346405,
0.047662265598773956,
0.10495524853467941,
0.22870875895023346,
-0.692122757434845,
-0.2428346574306488,
-0.22310951352119446,
-0.21031580865383148,
-0.5170267820358276,
-0.535849392414093,
0.4240279495716095,
0.18927627801895142,
-0.15866351127624512,
0.008136594668030739,
-0.13666291534900665,
0.5016128420829773,
0.1823747605085373,
0.08017246425151825,
0.7138428688049316,
-0.04840546473860741,
-0.13448092341423035,
-0.17488248646259308,
-0.3945440351963043,
-0.9466335773468018,
1.0995975732803345,
0.6250017285346985,
0.562157392501831,
0.17715996503829956,
0.6773369908332825,
0.20883576571941376,
0.4616994857788086,
-0.5647872090339661,
0.7387147545814514,
-0.027569327503442764,
-0.28548040986061096,
-0.5029417872428894,
-0.7397178411483765,
-0.49269822239875793,
0.366689532995224,
0.06427282094955444,
-0.4343782961368561,
-0.24713201820850372,
0.09244078397750854,
-0.5150659084320068,
-0.04264812171459198,
-1.161157488822937,
0.9318174123764038,
-0.3362385928630829,
-0.10373412817716599,
0.04764246940612793,
-0.7026957273483276,
0.4789573848247528,
-0.3921077847480774,
0.37148788571357727,
-0.006660534534603357,
-0.438731849193573,
0.5744456052780151,
-0.6063871383666992,
0.7476242184638977,
-0.1029096320271492,
-0.05444922670722008,
0.04463936761021614,
-0.0561956986784935,
0.49014198780059814,
0.006024153437465429,
-0.16901379823684692,
0.1856248825788498,
-0.269510954618454,
-0.3496592342853546,
-0.8551550507545471,
0.4837573170661926,
-0.6758101582527161,
-0.7289288640022278,
-0.36838552355766296,
-0.6151831746101379,
-0.28285810351371765,
0.1070101410150528,
0.15526385605335236,
0.2226809561252594,
-0.1973429173231125,
-0.08860982954502106,
0.13005906343460083,
-0.19206295907497406,
0.42821064591407776,
0.028826341032981873,
-0.11906840652227402,
-0.4901360273361206,
0.6066025495529175,
0.15646804869174957,
0.34793731570243835,
0.04599597677588463,
0.29689592123031616,
-0.3967358469963074,
-0.7056366205215454,
-0.43470731377601624,
0.42598575353622437,
-0.9485267400741577,
0.049819186329841614,
-0.5523990988731384,
0.10832369327545166,
-0.21726341545581818,
0.12955591082572937,
0.1540440320968628,
-0.6126478314399719,
-0.12094193696975708,
-0.3166944086551666,
0.12207919359207153,
0.988865852355957,
0.1009959727525711,
0.29492905735969543,
-0.3677893579006195,
0.2861790060997009,
0.4120619297027588,
0.2470621019601822,
-0.3149910271167755,
-0.6519440412521362,
0.07657144963741302,
-0.19862490892410278,
-0.3292401134967804,
-0.8025991320610046,
0.10206831246614456,
0.16136199235916138,
0.3930439054965973,
0.10840503871440887,
-0.2805541455745697,
0.8339411616325378,
-0.6017366647720337,
0.7173202037811279,
0.03478863090276718,
-1.2559008598327637,
0.1839609146118164,
-0.3788500428199768,
0.35338371992111206,
0.6515190005302429,
0.1913343071937561,
-0.28874102234840393,
-0.39871928095817566,
-0.7362428903579712,
-0.9986363649368286,
0.5732547640800476,
0.45276713371276855,
-0.07761398702859879,
0.18676041066646576,
0.8995102047920227,
-0.039334047585725784,
0.34573671221733093,
-0.8183330297470093,
-0.00544075109064579,
-0.14653204381465912,
-0.255320280790329,
-0.28697648644447327,
-0.542969286441803,
0.08065003901720047,
-0.1525975465774536,
0.47263219952583313,
-0.09469957649707794,
0.04304931312799454,
0.2014276534318924,
-0.2259063720703125,
-0.00448864558711648,
0.541031539440155,
0.6854211091995239,
0.9156859517097473,
-0.30275335907936096,
0.11304008215665817,
0.6216620206832886,
-0.4069034457206726,
0.09975191205739975,
0.24715323746204376,
-0.15782104432582855,
0.2272276133298874,
0.7884945273399353,
0.6549907922744751,
0.21288561820983887,
-0.5381428599357605,
0.9234631061553955,
-0.12612487375736237,
-0.2346130609512329,
-0.19054631888866425,
-0.1695796400308609,
0.20166270434856415,
0.10772667825222015,
0.3348992168903351,
0.05312506854534149,
0.4420047700405121,
-0.5775600075721741,
0.17944152653217316,
0.022364428266882896,
-0.06637673079967499,
-0.3586161434650421,
0.374230295419693,
0.2010529786348343,
-0.20295941829681396,
0.3256874978542328,
-0.4507545828819275,
-0.7099370360374451,
0.5222015976905823,
0.16449806094169617,
0.8488891124725342,
-0.26801130175590515,
0.005854473914951086,
0.2519236207008362,
0.6199907660484314,
-0.3672592043876648,
0.3946338891983032,
0.044898658990859985,
-0.2798059582710266,
-0.7502780556678772,
-0.5672257542610168,
-0.47568410634994507,
0.022388456389307976,
-0.5211036801338196,
0.36949190497398376,
-0.39179766178131104,
-0.21566380560398102,
-0.17037823796272278,
0.1369902640581131,
-0.6058895587921143,
0.40648922324180603,
-0.02392756938934326,
0.7487868070602417,
-1.0970124006271362,
0.4593983590602875,
0.6852049827575684,
-0.5789070129394531,
-0.9868348240852356,
0.5149372220039368,
-0.03155329078435898,
-0.3609362244606018,
0.8906520009040833,
0.36165857315063477,
-0.16978001594543457,
-0.260680615901947,
-0.1315401792526245,
-0.527833878993988,
1.2944871187210083,
0.6490486264228821,
-0.6791827082633972,
-0.2308662235736847,
0.40578991174697876,
0.8288893699645996,
-0.22474391758441925,
0.6877145171165466,
0.7183260917663574,
0.7629225254058838,
-0.05043451860547066,
-1.2640560865402222,
0.35651761293411255,
0.11627353727817535,
0.3282158076763153,
-0.14146991074085236,
-0.5746649503707886,
0.8753073215484619,
-0.3121494650840759,
-0.15351730585098267,
0.13101652264595032,
0.4746367335319519,
0.08385727554559708,
0.25968319177627563,
0.6841513514518738,
0.58018559217453,
0.8283364772796631,
-0.2299959808588028,
1.1558425426483154,
0.12837865948677063,
0.6489481329917908,
1.0711796283721924,
-0.14043615758419037,
0.7025653719902039,
0.4885208010673523,
-0.25843676924705505,
0.42537054419517517,
0.3924409747123718,
0.05863392353057861,
0.2905043959617615,
0.5887207984924316,
-0.22279231250286102,
-0.2467256486415863,
0.39966532588005066,
0.018850410357117653,
0.2507847249507904,
0.1869262158870697,
-0.35005220770835876,
-0.43855682015419006,
-0.20299147069454193,
0.1514343023300171,
0.0004287990741431713,
-0.17811468243598938,
0.639915943145752,
0.04566848278045654,
-0.5466967225074768,
0.4111569821834564,
0.11497316509485245,
0.6240425705909729,
-0.2976904809474945,
-0.09999212622642517,
-0.2527311146259308,
0.11850707978010178,
-0.40303656458854675,
-0.6496846079826355,
0.26430824398994446,
0.17436785995960236,
0.09172293543815613,
-0.056252699345350266,
0.4566260874271393,
-0.3549198806285858,
-0.48355355858802795,
0.27965375781059265,
0.5030206441879272,
0.46241727471351624,
-0.112647645175457,
-0.7621628642082214,
0.3611426055431366,
0.1575927883386612,
-0.3054821193218231,
-0.05670127272605896,
0.7631746530532837,
-0.19140677154064178,
0.7486532330513,
0.3372766077518463,
0.12082251906394958,
0.005072771105915308,
0.32906144857406616,
0.6887580752372742,
-0.7639657855033875,
-0.33500710129737854,
-1.0454844236373901,
0.23356477916240692,
-0.11898767948150635,
-0.2676617205142975,
0.7797384858131409,
0.6118199229240417,
0.5817787051200867,
0.10987377911806107,
1.0125452280044556,
0.36842918395996094,
0.5488499999046326,
-0.4620290994644165,
0.2948049306869507,
-0.403859943151474,
0.6593743562698364,
-0.6412608623504639,
-0.9699425101280212,
-0.5574702024459839,
0.5232172608375549,
-0.7116286754608154,
0.5681694149971008,
1.0090519189834595,
0.557002604007721,
-0.08477889746427536,
0.09350212663412094,
0.4551195204257965,
0.39556455612182617,
0.3451683521270752,
0.5630367994308472,
0.8725436925888062,
-0.52171391248703,
0.970001220703125,
-0.13401132822036743,
-0.31737881898880005,
-0.23648689687252045,
-1.0470082759857178,
-0.6499214172363281,
-0.15004819631576538,
-0.4275502562522888,
-0.013137640431523323,
0.16212962567806244,
0.6646301746368408,
0.15126119554042816,
-0.30751174688339233,
0.05796360969543457,
-0.10907880961894989,
-0.2289099544286728,
-0.038407035171985626,
-0.18360988795757294,
0.474755197763443,
-0.5104610919952393,
-0.7160831093788147,
0.17002668976783752,
0.38778236508369446,
-0.019795706495642662,
-0.3603591024875641,
-0.013728566467761993,
0.07877449691295624,
-0.043989378958940506,
0.36616387963294983,
-0.21646739542484283,
-1.0215147733688354,
-0.35779687762260437,
-0.3814958333969116,
-0.16551518440246582,
-0.004486491903662682,
0.6062005162239075,
-0.488067626953125,
0.4542406499385834,
0.362524151802063,
0.5727277398109436,
0.2375747561454773,
0.5016745924949646,
0.6243804097175598,
-0.6445216536521912,
-0.2677060663700104,
0.1994645595550537,
0.5789487361907959,
0.8263599872589111,
-0.3447059988975525,
0.5680320858955383,
0.3697628974914551,
-0.6395890116691589,
-0.6137368679046631,
0.06353239715099335,
-0.8873369097709656,
-0.08516103774309158,
1.4848682880401611,
-0.46863147616386414,
-0.16277292370796204,
-0.33014222979545593,
-0.35147082805633545,
0.11643020063638687,
-0.27838853001594543,
0.6142349243164062,
0.9263017177581787,
-0.22799399495124817,
-0.049051858484745026,
-0.7547975182533264,
0.6842889785766602,
0.6464592814445496,
-0.9289132952690125,
0.1436540186405182,
0.63543301820755,
0.6347630023956299,
0.2753593921661377,
0.5285849571228027,
-0.24160358309745789,
0.39543503522872925,
-0.2989426851272583,
0.15347717702388763,
-0.13805817067623138,
0.029262889176607132,
-0.7539092302322388,
0.18778608739376068,
0.17643067240715027,
0.09353501349687576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04960v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04960v1
|
SecGPT: An Execution Isolation Architecture for LLM-Based Systems
| 2024-03-08T00:02:30 | 2024-03-08T00:02:30 |
Yuhao Wu, Franziska Roesner, Tadayoshi Kohno, Ning Zhang, Umar Iqbal
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) extended as systems, such as ChatGPT, have begun
supporting third-party applications. These LLM apps leverage the de facto
natural language-based automated execution paradigm of LLMs: that is, apps and
their interactions are defined in natural language, provided access to user
data, and allowed to freely interact with each other and the system. These LLM
app ecosystems resemble the settings of earlier computing platforms, where
there was insufficient isolation between apps and the system. Because
third-party apps may not be trustworthy, and exacerbated by the imprecision of
the natural language interfaces, the current designs pose security and privacy
risks for users. In this paper, we propose SecGPT, an architecture for
LLM-based systems that aims to mitigate the security and privacy issues that
arise with the execution of third-party apps. SecGPT's key idea is to isolate
the execution of apps and more precisely mediate their interactions outside of
their isolated environments. We evaluate SecGPT against a number of case study
attacks and demonstrate that it protects against many security, privacy, and
safety issues that exist in non-isolated LLM-based systems. The performance
overhead incurred by SecGPT to improve security is under 0.3x for
three-quarters of the tested queries. To foster follow-up research, we release
SecGPT's source code at https://github.com/llm-platform-security/SecGPT.
|
[
-0.22997361421585083,
-0.7952317595481873,
0.5148341655731201,
0.309485524892807,
-0.20914608240127563,
0.3569942116737366,
0.006235150620341301,
-0.6944631338119507,
0.1526227593421936,
0.590101420879364,
-0.3803320825099945,
-0.7368115186691284,
-0.3296435475349426,
-0.13911223411560059,
-0.36479541659355164,
0.7517288327217102,
-0.04311523959040642,
-0.21734954416751862,
0.06391054391860962,
0.13958042860031128,
-0.20829126238822937,
-0.7287355661392212,
-0.5233573913574219,
-0.07330255955457687,
0.15660741925239563,
0.29570937156677246,
0.7273874282836914,
0.6301873326301575,
0.8963437676429749,
0.24900361895561218,
0.006742718163877726,
-0.28702083230018616,
-0.22647273540496826,
0.24148648977279663,
-0.18405571579933167,
-0.2377937287092209,
-0.4341621994972229,
-0.13810420036315918,
0.269338458776474,
-0.03532814607024193,
-0.3154468238353729,
0.023995637893676758,
0.0744204893708229,
0.5821718573570251,
-0.7812790274620056,
0.24349217116832733,
-0.4073063135147095,
-0.048480574041604996,
-0.26362287998199463,
-0.10297000408172607,
-0.32958781719207764,
-0.7244994044303894,
-0.09392963349819183,
-0.019687697291374207,
-0.21089111268520355,
0.16133937239646912,
0.5186202526092529,
0.16723361611366272,
-0.17644748091697693,
-0.23608015477657318,
-0.6471900343894958,
0.25647982954978943,
-0.604446530342102,
0.28307849168777466,
0.06385870277881622,
0.32933273911476135,
-0.2913278043270111,
-0.6933321356773376,
-0.3585766553878784,
-0.4476766288280487,
-0.2578652799129486,
0.04638161510229111,
-0.27893567085266113,
0.2060970664024353,
0.01962798461318016,
0.34365177154541016,
-0.6792333722114563,
0.27280092239379883,
-0.41264253854751587,
-0.230686217546463,
0.3144153952598572,
0.21717028319835663,
0.6788477897644043,
-0.09298740327358246,
-0.9215561151504517,
0.4592595398426056,
-1.3100045919418335,
0.07060451805591583,
0.5184729695320129,
0.3147869408130646,
-0.3134392499923706,
0.5880023241043091,
-0.4670543968677521,
0.285605251789093,
-0.39237990975379944,
0.06375868618488312,
-0.1642809361219406,
-0.13330985605716705,
-0.2362426370382309,
0.19659119844436646,
1.0954784154891968,
0.29731911420822144,
-0.11083769798278809,
-0.32810354232788086,
-0.3236670196056366,
0.15734493732452393,
0.12564729154109955,
-0.9715458154678345,
-0.2105405628681183,
0.3768377900123596,
-0.2762877643108368,
-0.5106264352798462,
-0.016777977347373962,
-0.5857353210449219,
-0.4432709515094757,
0.003252055263146758,
0.4533456265926361,
-0.5661020278930664,
-0.10537762194871902,
-0.10951752215623856,
0.19905626773834229,
0.5805001854896545,
-0.0367203950881958,
-0.7783915996551514,
0.8944724798202515,
1.3359367847442627,
0.958035409450531,
-0.3758663833141327,
-0.1584780216217041,
-0.5723702907562256,
0.4588624835014343,
-0.24480502307415009,
0.4679722189903259,
-0.5692975521087646,
-0.42710021138191223,
-0.2713842988014221,
-0.08475180715322495,
-0.10442869365215302,
-0.190411776304245,
0.5633715987205505,
-0.9004277586936951,
0.07579010725021362,
-0.05865082889795303,
-0.6092944145202637,
-0.15517516434192657,
0.1849120706319809,
-0.35339123010635376,
0.5551410913467407,
-0.26074156165122986,
-0.7973561882972717,
-0.06512754410505295,
-0.9175713658332825,
-0.39028334617614746,
0.3570989966392517,
-0.4024014174938202,
-0.0405513197183609,
0.0707404688000679,
0.33495229482650757,
0.22569242119789124,
-0.2138718217611313,
-0.15767338871955872,
-0.2958451807498932,
-0.6403473019599915,
0.009864375926554203,
-0.30569231510162354,
0.6810947060585022,
0.3617115914821625,
-0.4900248646736145,
-0.026676815003156662,
-0.2905022203922272,
0.24217559397220612,
-0.08624695986509323,
-0.14382031559944153,
-0.1321771740913391,
0.0745978131890297,
-0.3163491487503052,
-0.022061606869101524,
0.49044156074523926,
-0.6951619982719421,
-0.022321118041872978,
-0.5013129115104675,
0.5873673558235168,
0.8204894661903381,
0.22892656922340393,
0.5471606254577637,
0.08038131892681122,
0.7754021286964417,
-0.14899933338165283,
0.657883882522583,
-0.0926760882139206,
-0.29809898138046265,
-0.2779535949230194,
-0.5821058750152588,
0.03652723878622055,
0.9713056087493896,
-0.49727657437324524,
0.2825462222099304,
-0.28653451800346375,
-0.5143243074417114,
-0.04876543581485748,
0.14166001975536346,
0.5304564237594604,
0.4917687475681305,
-0.18959367275238037,
-0.25390782952308655,
-0.11649669706821442,
-1.227630615234375,
-0.21834123134613037,
-0.30640843510627747,
-0.04364679008722305,
0.3215755224227905,
0.22488273680210114,
-0.1840871125459671,
0.9879465699195862,
-0.5643799304962158,
-0.025132199749350548,
-0.07736856490373611,
-0.39613664150238037,
0.23434977233409882,
0.5103169083595276,
0.12110079079866409,
-0.5731538534164429,
-0.351445734500885,
0.22240261733531952,
-0.6873761415481567,
-0.38684219121932983,
0.29413163661956787,
-0.15874183177947998,
0.023931775242090225,
0.542221188545227,
-0.9493665099143982,
0.24896255135536194,
0.7418112754821777,
-0.15038368105888367,
0.5829439163208008,
-0.22011162340641022,
-0.1801103800535202,
-0.9643834233283997,
0.04746415466070175,
-0.4533611536026001,
-0.24564984440803528,
-0.6213861107826233,
0.3842220604419708,
0.21226605772972107,
-0.57999187707901,
-0.6679388284683228,
0.4232772886753082,
-0.3696126341819763,
-0.2874235212802887,
-0.24581597745418549,
0.14448799192905426,
0.11360862851142883,
0.1923629641532898,
0.09223011136054993,
1.1573699712753296,
0.556574285030365,
-0.5080047249794006,
0.20306752622127533,
0.15038734674453735,
-0.1771685779094696,
0.37705621123313904,
-0.8219054341316223,
0.42333436012268066,
0.40746399760246277,
0.18047037720680237,
-0.6749398112297058,
-0.4167942404747009,
0.5223421454429626,
-0.35883286595344543,
-0.0028076879680156708,
-0.3159618377685547,
-0.452885240316391,
0.042099129408597946,
-0.46888795495033264,
0.08794568479061127,
0.4584217965602875,
-0.5630113482475281,
0.5204224586486816,
0.46377432346343994,
-0.4032730162143707,
-0.6412817239761353,
-0.7000133991241455,
0.45793718099594116,
-0.39947831630706787,
-0.7540847063064575,
-0.0003358114627189934,
0.23409098386764526,
-0.4342024028301239,
-0.05737931281328201,
-0.10307612270116806,
-0.30919498205184937,
0.3889169692993164,
0.5189915895462036,
0.3635726273059845,
-0.30648842453956604,
-0.14496836066246033,
-0.0552995465695858,
-0.43781018257141113,
0.0762658342719078,
-0.11025486141443253,
0.3805488049983978,
-0.4592788815498352,
-0.7919471263885498,
-0.6283941864967346,
0.5611573457717896,
0.45416128635406494,
-0.25027281045913696,
0.646708071231842,
0.43877795338630676,
0.03513641282916069,
-0.0746636688709259,
-0.4097652733325958,
-0.35825005173683167,
-0.6066890954971313,
0.1578846573829651,
-0.3437994718551636,
-0.9930109977722168,
0.5599958300590515,
0.030904360115528107,
0.01480097509920597,
-0.15753142535686493,
0.6431686282157898,
0.04674945026636124,
0.43531718850135803,
0.5057480931282043,
-0.3938524127006531,
0.5231612324714661,
0.3572589159011841,
0.5815136432647705,
-0.9361540079116821,
0.07211291790008545,
-0.23781417310237885,
-0.12818409502506256,
-0.8658543825149536,
-0.11680114269256592,
0.35334691405296326,
0.18519890308380127,
-0.3231565058231354,
0.4954155683517456,
-0.6803414225578308,
0.844698429107666,
0.6866258978843689,
0.21424943208694458,
0.2976139783859253,
-0.33769360184669495,
0.07023533433675766,
0.24786686897277832,
-0.31021615862846375,
-0.7410759925842285,
0.7133865356445312,
0.3505258560180664,
1.1273829936981201,
0.6326373219490051,
1.1359059810638428,
0.3302718698978424,
0.33256277441978455,
-0.42791861295700073,
0.7311283946037292,
0.19347083568572998,
-0.5921045541763306,
-0.03361404314637184,
-0.4218619763851166,
-0.57269686460495,
0.510802149772644,
0.5619063377380371,
-1.2926050424575806,
0.05187205225229263,
-0.15437203645706177,
-0.5770677328109741,
0.17556120455265045,
-1.3276795148849487,
0.6446253657341003,
-0.27436649799346924,
-0.7000779509544373,
0.15180817246437073,
-0.7397471070289612,
0.7411067485809326,
0.0591278076171875,
-0.011156914755702019,
-0.16983157396316528,
-0.3063824474811554,
0.29073217511177063,
-0.483491986989975,
1.0626802444458008,
-0.13655774295330048,
-0.14476995170116425,
0.40885022282600403,
0.7198765277862549,
1.0561202764511108,
0.40143725275993347,
0.07880008220672607,
0.20833627879619598,
0.1267397403717041,
0.02694937214255333,
-0.3066314160823822,
0.9205703139305115,
-0.39138728380203247,
-0.9708343744277954,
-0.33355623483657837,
-0.3439784049987793,
0.007797621190547943,
0.16510601341724396,
-0.051111072301864624,
0.2627049684524536,
-0.09620297700166702,
0.259615033864975,
0.28406545519828796,
-0.43313106894493103,
0.6903342008590698,
0.6672035455703735,
-0.2777804136276245,
-0.3453977704048157,
0.6186613440513611,
-0.30304619669914246,
0.33449652791023254,
0.3298712372779846,
0.2702327072620392,
-0.44206932187080383,
-0.5678055286407471,
-0.28946515917778015,
-0.16917359828948975,
-0.4487553536891937,
-0.19898530840873718,
-0.5782265067100525,
-0.38775643706321716,
-0.2734382152557373,
-0.1745171695947647,
-0.32779228687286377,
-0.46689504384994507,
-0.04794139415025711,
-0.24414514005184174,
0.5119301080703735,
0.527357816696167,
-0.22733677923679352,
0.5827096700668335,
-0.9131099581718445,
0.09843815118074417,
0.12150740623474121,
0.5056637525558472,
-0.3589867651462555,
-0.11814646422863007,
0.10845194011926651,
-0.5196658968925476,
-0.3159216344356537,
-0.6818986535072327,
0.23312996327877045,
0.11534639447927475,
0.3260546326637268,
0.44846978783607483,
0.23211032152175903,
0.16935309767723083,
-0.5798169374465942,
0.9155927300453186,
-0.02962915599346161,
-0.9272370338439941,
0.35721680521965027,
-0.5303840041160583,
-0.024225693196058273,
0.49908342957496643,
-0.1765136420726776,
-0.599846363067627,
-0.42974257469177246,
-0.579265832901001,
-0.8684242367744446,
0.7556291818618774,
0.45499539375305176,
0.24708537757396698,
0.004608978051692247,
0.20177039504051208,
-0.088908851146698,
0.24818173050880432,
-0.7847923636436462,
0.13468214869499207,
0.3767699599266052,
0.0019108798587694764,
0.3514827489852905,
-0.30196887254714966,
-0.4569140076637268,
0.3137842118740082,
0.24387699365615845,
-0.008795679546892643,
0.30457359552383423,
-0.07401420921087265,
0.019965600222349167,
0.5717670321464539,
0.5064874887466431,
0.548076331615448,
0.3432962894439697,
-0.07359003275632858,
0.3843505084514618,
0.16831770539283752,
-0.6406934261322021,
0.10923393815755844,
-0.011164331808686256,
-0.3648885190486908,
-0.4467492699623108,
0.35887375473976135,
0.3694547414779663,
0.09824512898921967,
-0.4139426052570343,
0.6350722908973694,
-0.13824090361595154,
0.2868622839450836,
-0.38899722695350647,
0.3992723524570465,
0.28561270236968994,
0.5172023773193359,
0.00693275174126029,
-0.024805769324302673,
0.15078555047512054,
-0.18790274858474731,
0.43866485357284546,
0.4449489414691925,
-0.39042919874191284,
-0.4203891456127167,
0.5951002240180969,
0.28075823187828064,
-0.45235416293144226,
0.16864873468875885,
0.02048661932349205,
-0.6056681275367737,
0.4594842195510864,
0.5041876435279846,
1.313428282737732,
-0.15460753440856934,
0.035658132284879684,
-0.37580397725105286,
0.7897597551345825,
0.009216705337166786,
0.3998721241950989,
-0.2915036976337433,
-0.49551352858543396,
-0.17723816633224487,
-0.5527512431144714,
-0.8178255558013916,
-0.11381842195987701,
-0.1633240133523941,
0.142089381814003,
-0.686665415763855,
0.10978253185749054,
-0.7630067467689514,
-0.2706783711910248,
-0.17849460244178772,
-0.3258700668811798,
0.1371886283159256,
0.9781602621078491,
-0.5479455590248108,
0.7185638546943665,
0.24098943173885345,
-0.02828707918524742,
-0.6636255383491516,
0.04899643361568451,
0.11316516995429993,
-0.6971595883369446,
0.5484575629234314,
0.13313256204128265,
-0.46143847703933716,
-0.3828187882900238,
-0.20304447412490845,
-0.766701877117157,
0.9328130483627319,
0.5664229393005371,
-0.4561988115310669,
0.33762800693511963,
0.5181061625480652,
0.40900376439094543,
-0.1601647585630417,
0.23515811562538147,
0.5813103914260864,
0.36641380190849304,
-0.10982891172170639,
-0.625141441822052,
0.30490124225616455,
0.1385982632637024,
-0.10115905106067657,
0.1472722291946411,
-0.8277705907821655,
0.793422281742096,
-0.07687260210514069,
-0.480904221534729,
-0.18867485225200653,
0.233392134308815,
0.34611085057258606,
0.134319469332695,
0.05054112523794174,
0.34616008400917053,
0.5328177213668823,
-0.0045691789127886295,
1.1301770210266113,
-0.726565420627594,
0.12763726711273193,
1.4305979013442993,
-0.6599941849708557,
0.8868897557258606,
0.4611491858959198,
-0.15586230158805847,
0.045293841511011124,
0.6503081321716309,
0.5043798089027405,
0.6588242053985596,
0.07770523428916931,
-0.8288167715072632,
0.044681843370199203,
0.06929215788841248,
-0.4530150294303894,
0.4661467373371124,
0.3144073486328125,
-0.4299663007259369,
-0.49564090371131897,
-0.41862913966178894,
0.11498680710792542,
-0.3913328945636749,
0.10592982172966003,
0.8250780701637268,
0.4933936893939972,
-0.06401380151510239,
0.12546485662460327,
-0.1226479634642601,
0.2800443768501282,
-0.6572168469429016,
0.27905887365341187,
-0.37512367963790894,
0.28060397505760193,
-0.22721022367477417,
-0.7650905251502991,
0.388131707906723,
0.09647157043218613,
0.24345576763153076,
-0.09388255327939987,
0.8766605854034424,
0.19221262633800507,
-0.22008554637432098,
0.46038439869880676,
0.4340914785861969,
0.14188280701637268,
-0.18164321780204773,
-0.5530727505683899,
0.2951379120349884,
-0.17478562891483307,
-0.6964706182479858,
0.2828991413116455,
0.5640052556991577,
-0.07638333737850189,
0.948874294757843,
0.7640110850334167,
0.22715085744857788,
0.021239547058939934,
-0.1139453649520874,
0.9421790838241577,
-0.4276004135608673,
-0.876318097114563,
-1.5515981912612915,
-0.1213100329041481,
-0.13685445487499237,
0.10452745109796524,
0.7584434747695923,
0.8079461455345154,
0.1259036809206009,
0.19924212992191315,
0.6883149743080139,
-0.2534613311290741,
0.276300311088562,
-0.4984816312789917,
0.7630006670951843,
0.14952126145362854,
0.8479363918304443,
-0.14817294478416443,
-0.7479845881462097,
-0.2659103274345398,
-0.08244012296199799,
-0.5303307771682739,
-0.24339087307453156,
0.5285679697990417,
1.2710528373718262,
-0.1659267395734787,
0.34557271003723145,
0.29092249274253845,
-0.014069427736103535,
0.8015135526657104,
0.5294399857521057,
0.9946902394294739,
-0.09357699006795883,
0.5434350371360779,
-0.2303294837474823,
-0.33297571539878845,
0.04670708253979683,
-0.9907057285308838,
-0.5391553044319153,
-0.012091236189007759,
0.14659525454044342,
0.017730478197336197,
0.17640313506126404,
0.6754786968231201,
0.6160016655921936,
-0.6789720058441162,
-0.08888278901576996,
-0.1528216451406479,
0.20707237720489502,
-0.07143387943506241,
-0.21121862530708313,
0.5084706544876099,
-0.20908552408218384,
-0.35284626483917236,
0.703993022441864,
0.6677215099334717,
-0.15860216319561005,
-0.19372080266475677,
0.1501566618680954,
0.3469794690608978,
-0.010989095084369183,
0.426764577627182,
0.4009433090686798,
-0.4023180603981018,
-0.6273583173751831,
-0.22244521975517273,
-0.2544603943824768,
-0.015296717174351215,
0.6889985799789429,
-0.4305324852466583,
-0.016360322013497353,
0.45995309948921204,
0.8571552634239197,
0.11690916866064072,
0.4009782075881958,
0.5872566103935242,
-0.8608934879302979,
0.33530139923095703,
0.2714660167694092,
0.19385892152786255,
0.0787857323884964,
-0.690342903137207,
0.6499191522598267,
0.009328451007604599,
-0.6220370531082153,
-0.8094270825386047,
0.3670426905155182,
-0.687674343585968,
0.10087482631206512,
1.044301152229309,
-0.1782183200120926,
-0.6627187728881836,
-0.13123318552970886,
-0.05079372227191925,
-0.28372514247894287,
-0.6574684977531433,
0.7556602358818054,
0.5069620013237,
-0.41842222213745117,
-0.2785890996456146,
-0.7420849204063416,
0.4806464612483978,
-0.10500404238700867,
-0.8953639268875122,
0.559928297996521,
0.21860383450984955,
0.40364933013916016,
-0.10356410592794418,
0.725247859954834,
-0.5120747089385986,
0.016515322029590607,
-0.03452078625559807,
0.13483284413814545,
-0.052889999002218246,
0.060869377106428146,
-0.17894236743450165,
0.357113778591156,
0.0016670596087351441,
-0.6434057950973511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04945v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04945v3
|
MEIT: Multi-Modal Electrocardiogram Instruction Tuning on Large Language Models for Report Generation
| 2024-03-07T23:20:56 | 2024-06-18T07:15:09 |
Zhongwei Wan, Che Liu, Xin Wang, Chaofan Tao, Hui Shen, Zhenwu Peng, Jie Fu, Rossella Arcucci, Huaxiu Yao, Mi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.SP
|
Electrocardiogram (ECG) is the primary non-invasive diagnostic tool for
monitoring cardiac conditions and is crucial in assisting clinicians. Recent
studies have concentrated on classifying cardiac conditions using ECG data but
have overlooked ECG report generation, which is time-consuming and requires
clinical expertise. To automate ECG report generation and ensure its
versatility, we propose the Multimodal ECG Instruction Tuning (MEIT) framework,
the first attempt to tackle ECG report generation with LLMs and multimodal
instructions. To facilitate future research, we establish a benchmark to
evaluate MEIT with various LLMs backbones across two large-scale ECG datasets.
Our approach uniquely aligns the representations of the ECG signal and the
report, and we conduct extensive experiments to benchmark MEIT with nine
open-source LLMs using more than 800,000 ECG reports. MEIT's results underscore
the superior performance of instruction-tuned LLMs, showcasing their
proficiency in quality report generation, zero-shot capabilities, and
resilience to signal perturbation. These findings emphasize the efficacy of our
MEIT framework and its potential for real-world clinical application.
|
[
-0.24038350582122803,
-0.8532558679580688,
0.5856835246086121,
0.1704569309949875,
-0.4006919860839844,
-0.0961616188287735,
-0.29076653718948364,
-0.2106025516986847,
0.07925070077180862,
0.24884793162345886,
-0.8027951717376709,
-0.998757004737854,
-0.5256049633026123,
0.10070708394050598,
-0.036309000104665756,
0.9079382419586182,
-0.025296688079833984,
0.40290510654449463,
-0.3360269367694855,
-0.12964212894439697,
-0.7698097229003906,
-0.531525731086731,
-0.47109851241111755,
-0.09339497983455658,
0.32789042592048645,
0.6990318894386292,
0.24873822927474976,
0.7811793684959412,
0.7468315958976746,
0.1910097599029541,
0.5205396413803101,
0.26607173681259155,
-0.3510720729827881,
0.14600005745887756,
0.5000700950622559,
-0.5133564472198486,
-0.8922405242919922,
-0.14378836750984192,
0.6247989535331726,
0.2915947139263153,
-0.23112520575523376,
0.3689218759536743,
-0.24379846453666687,
0.7689470648765564,
-0.5019546151161194,
0.35967954993247986,
-0.060071222484111786,
-0.012721753679215908,
-0.1829153150320053,
-0.8358507752418518,
-0.6920062899589539,
-0.15617252886295319,
-0.14312390983104706,
-0.38210880756378174,
0.22457730770111084,
0.3022482395172119,
0.27477967739105225,
0.258965402841568,
-0.8207741379737854,
-0.23096013069152832,
-0.6586729884147644,
0.6203891634941101,
-0.537916362285614,
0.6326072812080383,
0.24414819478988647,
0.31039562821388245,
0.05167420580983162,
-0.5159739851951599,
0.029657214879989624,
-0.3394317626953125,
0.14422835409641266,
0.565060019493103,
-0.09003128856420517,
0.28616389632225037,
0.32924965023994446,
0.451221227645874,
-0.8618972897529602,
0.3038586378097534,
-0.22642947733402252,
-0.13983607292175293,
0.6913060545921326,
0.4258572459220886,
0.42526915669441223,
0.082831971347332,
-0.5747824311256409,
-0.04211326688528061,
-0.848105251789093,
-0.19267116487026215,
0.34293389320373535,
-0.14308315515518188,
-0.6476411819458008,
0.5070152878761292,
-0.12499970942735672,
0.5183368921279907,
0.25151240825653076,
-0.32505592703819275,
0.4826822876930237,
-0.24533115327358246,
0.0075341686606407166,
0.39156195521354675,
0.7429999709129333,
0.7156643271446228,
-0.24056696891784668,
-0.005584679078310728,
-0.3393756151199341,
-0.011528102681040764,
0.3298710584640503,
-0.7297000288963318,
-0.20760995149612427,
0.12232069671154022,
-0.5924043655395508,
-0.10416501015424728,
0.013720604591071606,
-0.8724251985549927,
-0.1461254209280014,
-0.31596678495407104,
0.4440861642360687,
-0.6049545407295227,
-0.16539467871189117,
0.029608221724629402,
0.20199386775493622,
0.11418304592370987,
0.06109036132693291,
-0.893961489200592,
-0.010905097238719463,
0.45418742299079895,
0.6661186814308167,
-0.017772790044546127,
-0.20253078639507294,
-0.6309059858322144,
0.0011345809325575829,
-0.167848601937294,
0.898585319519043,
-0.38793304562568665,
-0.6969199180603027,
-0.2552054524421692,
-0.13776645064353943,
-0.35145777463912964,
-0.2325812131166458,
0.49036407470703125,
-0.31587883830070496,
-0.006717934738844633,
-0.0061073810793459415,
-0.7594324946403503,
-0.1147913783788681,
0.2049906700849533,
-0.6860342621803284,
0.5325447916984558,
0.029551029205322266,
-0.5042436718940735,
0.25133296847343445,
-0.7634674906730652,
-0.7882089614868164,
-0.002395311137661338,
-0.25295528769493103,
-0.7137594223022461,
0.10896691679954529,
0.3535064160823822,
0.4015326201915741,
-0.5482142567634583,
-0.18024694919586182,
0.01750347390770912,
-0.25761744379997253,
0.3449719548225403,
-0.7255533337593079,
0.27201446890830994,
0.06307350844144821,
-0.26459717750549316,
0.47222810983657837,
-0.9278452396392822,
0.08937948197126389,
0.003374640131369233,
-0.36587539315223694,
0.12513364851474762,
0.2161044180393219,
0.1604490429162979,
-0.050195544958114624,
0.10685645043849945,
-0.6789495348930359,
0.21452127397060394,
-0.1360754370689392,
0.5568320155143738,
0.4994322955608368,
0.11578653752803802,
0.055844809859991074,
-0.9214110970497131,
0.8831946849822998,
0.0002252432459499687,
0.30538836121559143,
-0.6860045790672302,
-0.4268951117992401,
-0.6118631362915039,
-0.5425260663032532,
0.20963135361671448,
0.73346346616745,
-0.3960452675819397,
0.45335930585861206,
-0.23820139467716217,
-0.5807815790176392,
-0.6346845626831055,
0.01209460198879242,
0.21428290009498596,
0.659571647644043,
0.5029621124267578,
-0.12949460744857788,
-0.25807633996009827,
-0.934019148349762,
0.043957822024822235,
0.14248596131801605,
0.059350982308387756,
0.2180691659450531,
0.10508551448583603,
-0.1957855373620987,
0.1267053335905075,
-0.2742747664451599,
-0.14249077439308167,
-0.35725975036621094,
0.5365350246429443,
0.055512361228466034,
0.43893906474113464,
0.3526468276977539,
-0.39700064063072205,
-0.36925140023231506,
0.15162944793701172,
-0.4954809844493866,
-0.09341985732316971,
-0.2972703278064728,
-0.04068966582417488,
-0.03907940164208412,
0.6747382283210754,
-0.08235214650630951,
0.17056109011173248,
0.5981374382972717,
-0.21141082048416138,
0.5477075576782227,
-0.7307612895965576,
0.5006381273269653,
-0.9979902505874634,
-0.13793069124221802,
0.013386609964072704,
-0.40088364481925964,
-0.31172287464141846,
-0.0449029840528965,
0.44047069549560547,
-0.11244647204875946,
-0.1003454178571701,
0.17620980739593506,
-0.4866248667240143,
0.4099322557449341,
-0.035166993737220764,
-0.26380059123039246,
-0.19308724999427795,
0.17426611483097076,
-0.1346893608570099,
0.4283529222011566,
0.5846033096313477,
-0.5597420334815979,
0.4963417053222656,
0.15076741576194763,
-0.2795439660549164,
0.8777043223381042,
-0.4311572015285492,
0.10586925595998764,
-0.17381533980369568,
0.27276667952537537,
-0.8698595762252808,
-0.39576956629753113,
-0.08828726410865784,
-0.2630859911441803,
0.5815847516059875,
0.039253827184438705,
-0.6267882585525513,
-0.17799200117588043,
-0.390516996383667,
0.6091470718383789,
0.7735177874565125,
-0.4248618483543396,
0.6892920732498169,
0.09893587231636047,
-0.08808457106351852,
0.015892639756202698,
-0.7500888705253601,
-0.38608691096305847,
-0.2132577747106552,
-0.5050491094589233,
0.17506156861782074,
-0.49674588441848755,
0.30201366543769836,
-0.3253992199897766,
-0.09837064146995544,
0.06160739064216614,
-0.012942046858370304,
0.5330383777618408,
0.4402080178260803,
-0.4687398672103882,
0.4374784529209137,
0.34047144651412964,
-0.33450987935066223,
0.20808055996894836,
0.09757986664772034,
0.4207715392112732,
-0.10903435200452805,
-1.0220047235488892,
-0.890109121799469,
0.5031419396400452,
0.7850168347358704,
-0.5100737810134888,
0.35199689865112305,
0.8228414058685303,
-0.032028429210186005,
-0.21502618491649628,
-0.45864105224609375,
-0.08826857060194016,
-0.3989371657371521,
0.421791672706604,
0.07266498357057571,
-0.6240835189819336,
0.17691223323345184,
-0.24795246124267578,
0.1646970808506012,
0.3944111764431,
0.7125682830810547,
-0.16796159744262695,
1.5120452642440796,
0.5340439677238464,
0.09660747647285461,
0.5505797266960144,
-0.03316371515393257,
0.1205998882651329,
-0.9265740513801575,
-0.2722867727279663,
-0.1447027027606964,
-0.682856559753418,
-0.5118544697761536,
-0.23392273485660553,
1.098649501800537,
-0.084747813642025,
-0.001887299818918109,
-0.4267505407333374,
-0.4972115159034729,
0.4011682868003845,
0.34921765327453613,
0.4844970107078552,
0.3817458748817444,
-0.14259815216064453,
-0.08531365543603897,
-0.04163042828440666,
-0.9490311741828918,
-0.26627203822135925,
1.6350468397140503,
0.13681435585021973,
0.9199380874633789,
-0.008106202818453312,
0.8954548835754395,
0.2334846705198288,
0.6701468229293823,
-0.8223485350608826,
0.12999564409255981,
-0.06491634994745255,
-0.368095338344574,
0.13509994745254517,
-0.2472500056028366,
-0.8801823258399963,
-0.034883011132478714,
-0.4647292196750641,
-0.400444358587265,
-0.40467697381973267,
0.5431404709815979,
-0.6817306280136108,
0.10676064342260361,
-0.968030571937561,
0.923579216003418,
-0.78646320104599,
-0.22732803225517273,
-0.44487592577934265,
-0.5590294599533081,
0.39385443925857544,
-0.10340988636016846,
0.4344709515571594,
-0.13983049988746643,
-0.16843080520629883,
0.43492475152015686,
-0.24067066609859467,
0.8345330357551575,
0.17711667716503143,
-0.009897282347083092,
0.0820605680346489,
0.10216054320335388,
0.11382463574409485,
0.4538908004760742,
0.09053904563188553,
0.08700239658355713,
0.24512706696987152,
-0.20247603952884674,
-0.36268070340156555,
0.7538629174232483,
-0.5883728861808777,
-0.15914860367774963,
-0.16207434237003326,
-0.771759033203125,
-0.35245129466056824,
0.23323743045330048,
0.6641942262649536,
0.8475657105445862,
-0.36719250679016113,
0.17138876020908356,
0.8796986937522888,
-0.2849150598049164,
0.10242097079753876,
0.4945898950099945,
0.0002911511983256787,
-0.27890387177467346,
1.0568103790283203,
-0.058191314339637756,
0.33647555112838745,
0.558154284954071,
0.08432842791080475,
-0.0598086416721344,
-0.3986392021179199,
-0.6102558970451355,
0.1595902144908905,
-0.5017952919006348,
-0.4267394542694092,
-0.081920325756073,
-0.005148264579474926,
-0.18347416818141937,
-0.34465718269348145,
-0.48253095149993896,
0.02001289464533329,
-0.3465006351470947,
0.04430878534913063,
0.4215274751186371,
0.6958592534065247,
-0.16991645097732544,
0.3586876094341278,
-1.2595809698104858,
0.43412038683891296,
0.185530886054039,
0.5510644316673279,
-0.23447318375110626,
-0.14391417801380157,
-0.24190400540828705,
0.0638909712433815,
-0.37739425897598267,
-1.0425084829330444,
-0.011562318541109562,
0.13186752796173096,
0.5959072113037109,
0.44647306203842163,
-0.009450918063521385,
0.3207385838031769,
-0.5322834253311157,
0.5739781856536865,
0.38758984208106995,
-0.8686861395835876,
0.6362536549568176,
-0.3370835483074188,
0.5021646022796631,
0.2659265995025635,
0.10642185062170029,
-0.5096243023872375,
-0.08853711932897568,
-0.6803860068321228,
-0.8944137692451477,
0.5592837333679199,
-0.10514688491821289,
0.028145980089902878,
-0.2535429000854492,
0.19083549082279205,
0.2860102951526642,
0.05407513305544853,
-0.31017976999282837,
-0.3451859652996063,
-0.0890531912446022,
-0.6851919293403625,
-0.20832090079784393,
-0.13979558646678925,
-0.39320629835128784,
-0.278525173664093,
0.3927231729030609,
-0.07540716975927353,
0.555803120136261,
0.2362574338912964,
-0.367951363325119,
-0.3655359148979187,
0.4849433898925781,
0.8028143644332886,
0.5745763778686523,
0.022160664200782776,
0.12105120718479156,
0.10747133940458298,
-0.2667882442474365,
0.10542330145835876,
0.1061149314045906,
0.05051771551370621,
-0.27392578125,
0.6368626952171326,
0.8549097776412964,
0.4667886793613434,
-1.0070676803588867,
0.7342197299003601,
-0.18541213870048523,
-0.3894595801830292,
-0.16005268692970276,
0.28624236583709717,
0.23136276006698608,
0.1704711765050888,
-0.3177459239959717,
0.012280710972845554,
-0.17858688533306122,
-0.10473913699388504,
0.2628100514411926,
0.3622336983680725,
-0.15200339257717133,
-0.3931834399700165,
0.9257373809814453,
0.3820958137512207,
-0.27580198645591736,
0.6646754741668701,
-0.15251043438911438,
-0.1414552479982376,
0.7518930435180664,
0.6991400718688965,
0.7172073721885681,
-0.26344409584999084,
0.15845032036304474,
0.36805588006973267,
0.47932523488998413,
-0.0037038277368992567,
0.5634551048278809,
-0.07963551580905914,
-0.3784124255180359,
-0.4458771347999573,
-0.39820149540901184,
-0.37019839882850647,
0.15603011846542358,
-0.9876871109008789,
0.3688148856163025,
-0.7311023473739624,
-0.06661225110292435,
-0.20560741424560547,
-0.5169113874435425,
-0.8260882496833801,
-0.09239768236875534,
0.4580278694629669,
0.8170195817947388,
-0.6285483241081238,
0.5734729766845703,
0.8497855067253113,
-0.17429324984550476,
-0.7475149631500244,
-0.20509561896324158,
0.3694278597831726,
-0.8476783037185669,
0.08762241154909134,
0.25479191541671753,
-0.2287171334028244,
0.3225373327732086,
-0.3559970259666443,
-0.5040395855903625,
1.174367070198059,
0.29806384444236755,
-0.8182599544525146,
0.3301377296447754,
-0.020872510969638824,
0.47882595658302307,
-0.32000887393951416,
0.25826165080070496,
0.5367845892906189,
0.4498981535434723,
-0.3359849452972412,
-0.9167371392250061,
-0.0702962800860405,
-0.22448503971099854,
-0.3940763771533966,
0.3589201271533966,
-1.0774785280227661,
0.745095431804657,
-0.2399808019399643,
-0.09768719226121902,
-0.014318224042654037,
0.30661267042160034,
0.039345595985651016,
0.26894670724868774,
0.25625988841056824,
0.5269251465797424,
0.6323333382606506,
-0.04094177111983299,
1.1147011518478394,
-0.768019437789917,
0.29457512497901917,
0.8799741268157959,
-0.09643074125051498,
0.5184506773948669,
0.14894674718379974,
0.1280210018157959,
0.3539040982723236,
0.5370864868164062,
-0.029845641925930977,
0.22241277992725372,
-0.04128928482532501,
-0.28784942626953125,
-0.4365196228027344,
0.36427822709083557,
-0.6399497985839844,
0.4098224937915802,
0.5353220105171204,
-0.4417441785335541,
-0.31694498658180237,
0.10410994291305542,
-0.3032432794570923,
-0.09500008076429367,
-0.37139254808425903,
0.6092829704284668,
-0.12571267783641815,
-0.1527399718761444,
0.40946027636528015,
0.07252521812915802,
0.40592312812805176,
-0.7993776202201843,
-0.20278817415237427,
-0.08723951876163483,
-0.0284199807792902,
-0.18000660836696625,
-0.16979731619358063,
-0.1379958540201187,
-0.012517089024186134,
-0.24693667888641357,
-0.40826499462127686,
0.34261026978492737,
-0.4846208989620209,
-0.5144591927528381,
-0.05440181493759155,
0.54598069190979,
-0.13336575031280518,
0.1492404043674469,
-0.4181426465511322,
0.016688525676727295,
-0.01569620706140995,
-0.3221970498561859,
0.3076576888561249,
0.36782509088516235,
0.1662811040878296,
0.5203017592430115,
0.48637107014656067,
0.0992339625954628,
0.21037602424621582,
-0.009107561782002449,
0.592388927936554,
-0.6174221038818359,
-0.6188373565673828,
-0.6869666576385498,
0.6053085327148438,
0.2703377902507782,
-0.46308770775794983,
0.49533209204673767,
0.6005880236625671,
0.6939482688903809,
0.030560674145817757,
0.8445534110069275,
0.21306964755058289,
0.5011911392211914,
-0.894733190536499,
0.6087555289268494,
-0.5526109337806702,
0.2480996698141098,
0.24168361723423004,
-0.5727233290672302,
-0.47780880331993103,
0.39499396085739136,
-0.23071256279945374,
-0.04705313593149185,
0.8904651403427124,
0.6265794038772583,
-0.15565446019172668,
0.08057411015033722,
0.273056298494339,
0.09535013139247894,
0.32299450039863586,
0.6390721201896667,
0.7322339415550232,
-0.10712472349405289,
0.38496145606040955,
-0.17714789509773254,
-0.4730633795261383,
-0.5655355453491211,
-0.683802604675293,
-0.8201095461845398,
-0.20375674962997437,
-0.35059359669685364,
0.21397674083709717,
-0.22722257673740387,
1.0852843523025513,
0.6616637706756592,
-0.49770498275756836,
-0.07492102682590485,
0.13123178482055664,
0.15535075962543488,
-0.4385682940483093,
-0.12032264471054077,
0.3912869691848755,
-0.43321216106414795,
-0.4466981589794159,
0.726118266582489,
0.5807546973228455,
-0.03752301633358002,
-0.06680876016616821,
-0.06311684101819992,
0.2623906433582306,
-0.1920389086008072,
0.6223939061164856,
0.10921880602836609,
-0.34565654397010803,
-0.12321051955223083,
-0.0299990214407444,
-0.1096847876906395,
0.35200706124305725,
1.1683217287063599,
-0.2500629723072052,
0.6937731504440308,
0.3260159492492676,
0.7066990733146667,
0.23738448321819305,
-0.005766714923083782,
0.409006267786026,
-0.5648722052574158,
-0.040483586490154266,
0.22800001502037048,
0.2840544581413269,
0.09565777331590652,
-0.5823090672492981,
-0.08476801216602325,
0.09061306715011597,
-0.7492274641990662,
-0.48923954367637634,
0.32930073142051697,
-1.1332823038101196,
0.02343585714697838,
0.8789661526679993,
0.22808614373207092,
-0.07876098155975342,
0.1456764191389084,
-0.19852115213871002,
0.3218638598918915,
-0.3127891421318054,
0.7234411239624023,
0.6147905588150024,
-0.8969823122024536,
-0.12801997363567352,
-0.8857050538063049,
0.15739738941192627,
0.4973978102207184,
-0.9380738735198975,
-0.24020779132843018,
0.8094276785850525,
0.5235188603401184,
-0.3467947244644165,
0.47909781336784363,
-0.14756155014038086,
0.665357768535614,
0.03443032503128052,
0.21587973833084106,
-0.4225355386734009,
-0.09205465018749237,
-0.38899844884872437,
0.04306039586663246,
0.2038326859474182,
-0.42412692308425903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04931v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04931v2
|
A Survey on Human-AI Teaming with Large Pre-Trained Models
| 2024-03-07T22:37:49 | 2024-06-26T23:44:48 |
Vanshika Vats, Marzia Binta Nizam, Minghao Liu, Ziyuan Wang, Richard Ho, Mohnish Sai Prasad, Vincent Titterton, Sai Venkat Malreddy, Riya Aggarwal, Yanwen Xu, Lei Ding, Jay Mehta, Nathan Grinnell, Li Liu, Sijia Zhong, Devanathan Nallur Gandamani, Xinyi Tang, Rohan Ghosalkar, Celeste Shen, Rachel Shen, Nafisa Hussain, Kesav Ravichandran, James Davis
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
In the rapidly evolving landscape of artificial intelligence (AI), the
collaboration between human intelligence and AI systems, known as Human-AI
(HAI) Teaming, has emerged as a cornerstone for advancing problem-solving and
decision-making processes. The advent of Large Pre-trained Models (LPtM) has
significantly transformed this landscape, offering unprecedented capabilities
by leveraging vast amounts of data to understand and predict complex patterns.
This paper surveys the pivotal integration of LPtMs with HAI, emphasizing how
these models enhance collaborative intelligence beyond traditional approaches.
It examines the potential of LPtMs in augmenting human capabilities, discussing
this collaboration for AI model improvements, effective teaming, ethical
considerations, and their broad applied implications in various sectors.
Through this exploration, the study sheds light on the transformative impact of
LPtM-enhanced HAI Teaming, providing insights for future research, policy
development, and strategic implementations aimed at harnessing the full
potential of this collaboration for research and societal benefit.
|
[
-0.5953191518783569,
-0.22580663859844208,
0.5510656833648682,
-0.3206876516342163,
0.14085222780704498,
0.37049397826194763,
-0.149358332157135,
-0.8693945407867432,
-0.19591592252254486,
0.5338287949562073,
-0.6538040041923523,
0.11434435844421387,
-0.4116499722003937,
-0.03639319911599159,
-0.13059565424919128,
0.9001600742340088,
0.18431615829467773,
0.1807657778263092,
-0.2733822762966156,
-0.35215893387794495,
-0.40411972999572754,
-0.9120585322380066,
-0.4610230028629303,
-0.41825464367866516,
0.5620098114013672,
0.13210757076740265,
0.6786097288131714,
0.432253360748291,
0.8004542589187622,
0.36994314193725586,
0.33540332317352295,
0.13532903790473938,
-0.5338243842124939,
-0.2803434431552887,
-0.21452543139457703,
-0.33888745307922363,
-0.8868743777275085,
0.7143933773040771,
0.5756149291992188,
0.8640906810760498,
-0.10244166105985641,
0.3254339098930359,
0.1222766786813736,
0.42209094762802124,
-0.72421795129776,
-0.11037123203277588,
-0.4900921583175659,
0.17082172632217407,
-0.09744012355804443,
0.06521838903427124,
-0.2687203884124756,
-0.01956089399755001,
0.5680816173553467,
-0.6254181861877441,
0.020897381007671356,
0.34373918175697327,
0.3169301450252533,
0.7309313416481018,
-0.3218920826911926,
0.14918412268161774,
-1.0506871938705444,
1.0670115947723389,
-0.4812460243701935,
0.3923768699169159,
0.12100770324468613,
0.539050281047821,
-0.1143384575843811,
-0.7146751880645752,
-0.5237351655960083,
-0.34013572335243225,
0.12883657217025757,
0.30246615409851074,
0.05611785128712654,
0.2784573435783386,
0.29533955454826355,
0.13006426393985748,
-0.5278754830360413,
0.6194084882736206,
-0.46030136942863464,
-0.0550980307161808,
1.101566195487976,
0.10557615756988525,
0.5716069340705872,
0.33193108439445496,
-0.39774131774902344,
-0.21360145509243011,
-0.4136520028114319,
0.12459232658147812,
-0.037068627774715424,
0.18755900859832764,
-0.13295407593250275,
0.4414963126182556,
-0.007168997079133987,
0.5669913291931152,
-0.36786583065986633,
0.24283353984355927,
0.07675421983003616,
-0.7519524693489075,
-0.4004226326942444,
0.08355145156383514,
0.7460950613021851,
0.10834397375583649,
0.3394692838191986,
-0.30856338143348694,
-0.17616517841815948,
0.16362673044204712,
0.28524884581565857,
-0.41194650530815125,
-0.25610750913619995,
-0.1502356231212616,
-0.5810526013374329,
-0.11407216638326645,
0.3232274651527405,
-0.536415159702301,
-0.5627260804176331,
-0.5595262050628662,
0.47723832726478577,
-0.05050276964902878,
-0.6249691247940063,
0.06484495103359222,
-0.22728407382965088,
0.554277777671814,
0.36233019828796387,
-0.37758344411849976,
0.11346977949142456,
1.0293463468551636,
0.3810575604438782,
0.023022187873721123,
-0.7275189757347107,
-0.6977996826171875,
0.2930290400981903,
-0.26976755261421204,
0.37452811002731323,
-0.2920849025249481,
-0.4957132637500763,
-0.3731948137283325,
-0.5913894772529602,
-0.039960481226444244,
-0.5986116528511047,
0.3066919147968292,
-0.34711623191833496,
0.23410481214523315,
-0.24959537386894226,
-0.4032975435256958,
0.07967882603406906,
0.34515848755836487,
-0.6869114637374878,
0.5558140277862549,
0.08542697876691818,
-0.5335356593132019,
0.5347849726676941,
-1.3658350706100464,
-0.2943994402885437,
0.45030471682548523,
-0.32591480016708374,
-0.37488457560539246,
-0.2216063141822815,
0.2567805349826813,
0.48808786273002625,
-0.7069167494773865,
0.08635623753070831,
-0.45229625701904297,
-0.4048283100128174,
0.28439584374427795,
-0.17942260205745697,
0.9802418947219849,
-0.07967716455459595,
-0.31114280223846436,
0.6089078187942505,
-0.23310509324073792,
0.06302875280380249,
0.03334275260567665,
-0.028221087530255318,
-0.04662518575787544,
-0.17426836490631104,
-0.10761373490095139,
0.4422212541103363,
0.36399203538894653,
-0.24974873661994934,
0.03832833096385002,
-0.01249084621667862,
0.8045021295547485,
0.8651807308197021,
-0.1237180307507515,
0.918218195438385,
-0.7204086184501648,
0.47207972407341003,
-0.25948813557624817,
0.5959199666976929,
0.22685283422470093,
-0.4855896532535553,
-0.3356761932373047,
-0.27240806818008423,
0.13992789387702942,
0.5338817238807678,
-0.555634617805481,
0.6576096415519714,
-0.2911780774593353,
-0.5717323422431946,
-0.8105495572090149,
0.26358887553215027,
0.3388527035713196,
0.5655834674835205,
0.5171767473220825,
-0.0609973706305027,
-0.6334347724914551,
-0.8652603626251221,
-0.1928497552871704,
-0.08960568904876709,
-0.19012483954429626,
0.4541468322277069,
0.5919933319091797,
-0.5163654685020447,
1.0606646537780762,
-0.026600463315844536,
-0.43750330805778503,
-0.635141909122467,
0.11155358701944351,
-0.16831736266613007,
0.9479463696479797,
0.41440433263778687,
-1.2224647998809814,
-0.37811964750289917,
-0.18252241611480713,
-0.7534096240997314,
0.5368664860725403,
0.0451253317296505,
-0.2678568959236145,
-0.20780351758003235,
0.43276360630989075,
-0.6863745450973511,
0.4639253616333008,
0.33219319581985474,
-0.07389380782842636,
0.7408236265182495,
-0.22555814683437347,
0.23536184430122375,
-0.9080280661582947,
0.28888553380966187,
-0.05689886212348938,
-0.07062854617834091,
-0.6576725244522095,
-0.04732978716492653,
-0.3811034560203552,
-0.21381841599941254,
-0.30180367827415466,
0.5097712874412537,
-0.40854138135910034,
-0.5712566375732422,
0.15576697885990143,
-0.08501767367124557,
-0.3222609758377075,
0.24019460380077362,
-0.07704587280750275,
0.9471165537834167,
0.3434818983078003,
-0.528268039226532,
0.44706350564956665,
0.26574987173080444,
-0.25124698877334595,
0.5891321301460266,
-0.8181334137916565,
0.47153234481811523,
0.030800219625234604,
0.5848615169525146,
-0.294985294342041,
-0.3966462314128876,
0.1893187165260315,
-0.4561241567134857,
-0.012342766858637333,
0.19373467564582825,
-0.7183558344841003,
-0.5622700452804565,
-0.21469999849796295,
0.9058056473731995,
0.8510538935661316,
-0.2001483291387558,
0.7576690912246704,
0.5563945174217224,
0.25992241501808167,
-0.44263118505477905,
-0.495635986328125,
0.1604301631450653,
-0.30337420105934143,
-0.5470513701438904,
0.4441479444503784,
-0.18578965961933136,
-0.6003012657165527,
0.07429497689008713,
0.25635215640068054,
-0.308588445186615,
0.2419283390045166,
0.2901473939418793,
0.6581012606620789,
-0.3335134983062744,
-0.22228743135929108,
-0.6187941431999207,
-0.19875569641590118,
-0.05561274290084839,
-0.2894240617752075,
0.7441171407699585,
-0.2694686949253082,
-0.4182063639163971,
-0.9604238271713257,
0.24452777206897736,
0.7711286544799805,
-0.9016410708427429,
0.8489455580711365,
0.8554046750068665,
-0.376764714717865,
0.09973651170730591,
-0.5789235234260559,
-0.3881130814552307,
-0.46447840332984924,
0.3298186957836151,
0.14279530942440033,
-0.8225805759429932,
0.11269127577543259,
-0.2768992781639099,
-0.0093673225492239,
0.3588688373565674,
0.1574503481388092,
-0.629916250705719,
1.1406117677688599,
0.705605685710907,
-0.4562133252620697,
0.3619253635406494,
-0.38574352860450745,
0.0029217649716883898,
-0.9690937399864197,
-0.19428303837776184,
-0.14645962417125702,
-0.5841214656829834,
-0.41047000885009766,
-0.41242367029190063,
0.7019721865653992,
-0.16808807849884033,
-0.7002459764480591,
-0.029525574296712875,
-0.5305768251419067,
0.4453740417957306,
0.853299617767334,
0.22360588610172272,
0.05802580714225769,
-0.7713218331336975,
0.5434204936027527,
0.10781019181013107,
-0.8039582371711731,
-0.15569743514060974,
1.1657007932662964,
0.25034716725349426,
0.040605343878269196,
-0.019393129274249077,
0.6343271136283875,
0.4849306643009186,
0.35269665718078613,
-0.37041419744491577,
0.6030372977256775,
-0.1300487220287323,
-0.6107134819030762,
-0.6368106007575989,
-0.5224868655204773,
-0.7985809445381165,
-0.2721345126628876,
-0.6749981641769409,
-0.39898455142974854,
-0.29201632738113403,
0.09991657733917236,
-0.7356897592544556,
0.44477763772010803,
-0.5707864761352539,
0.8244372606277466,
-0.6858370900154114,
-0.22399583458900452,
-0.6933562159538269,
-0.8279231190681458,
0.46218141913414,
-0.05200127139687538,
0.1489790678024292,
-0.027399081736803055,
0.0004391490656416863,
0.9827816486358643,
-0.1650058478116989,
0.6406583189964294,
-0.19915659725666046,
0.23447594046592712,
0.05751034989953041,
-0.3838096261024475,
0.18684843182563782,
-0.04096463695168495,
-0.08847671002149582,
0.08717609196901321,
-0.44214823842048645,
-0.6921655535697937,
-0.37333762645721436,
0.2712880074977875,
-1.141938328742981,
-0.7242555618286133,
-0.17653284966945648,
-0.871638298034668,
-0.38089174032211304,
0.3433196246623993,
0.17424030601978302,
0.38843703269958496,
-0.1841876357793808,
0.2421151101589203,
0.506294846534729,
-0.08073842525482178,
0.47018298506736755,
-0.07400113344192505,
0.03841665759682655,
-0.15869757533073425,
0.7812626361846924,
-0.016784735023975372,
0.14629556238651276,
0.27120426297187805,
0.02030903287231922,
-0.19042496383190155,
-0.6699554324150085,
-0.15853852033615112,
0.23432070016860962,
-0.149423748254776,
0.13959041237831116,
-0.24294732511043549,
-0.5105696320533752,
-0.5659205317497253,
-0.4582565128803253,
-0.4113031029701233,
0.14327548444271088,
-0.3565951883792877,
0.28416240215301514,
-0.09596123546361923,
1.0820194482803345,
0.013983250595629215,
0.13000427186489105,
-1.081551194190979,
0.16316893696784973,
0.6951276659965515,
0.13359500467777252,
0.06355936080217361,
0.0028205905109643936,
-0.054793644696474075,
0.3206765651702881,
0.13402880728244781,
-0.4228014051914215,
0.10209652036428452,
-0.055279891937971115,
0.8973940014839172,
0.16623356938362122,
0.21725445985794067,
0.6511054039001465,
-0.26737287640571594,
0.6471571922302246,
0.31259721517562866,
-0.8704894781112671,
0.4919321537017822,
-0.5784967541694641,
0.1222807765007019,
0.5982553362846375,
0.46565455198287964,
-0.12459775805473328,
0.286990761756897,
-0.6199591159820557,
-0.35502147674560547,
0.6254743933677673,
0.21604807674884796,
-0.26441189646720886,
0.8754045367240906,
0.3161896765232086,
-0.26100385189056396,
0.1877087652683258,
-0.4586222767829895,
0.2978309094905853,
0.11157935112714767,
-0.14319774508476257,
-0.4336625933647156,
0.20461136102676392,
-0.235645592212677,
-0.5410841107368469,
0.31386154890060425,
0.2969346344470978,
-0.01836615614593029,
0.04369958117604256,
-0.19060121476650238,
0.17469161748886108,
0.05099974945187569,
0.390258252620697,
0.641284704208374,
-0.0672408863902092,
-0.23887136578559875,
0.3289811313152313,
-0.16944517195224762,
0.07700782269239426,
0.061664097011089325,
0.39229148626327515,
-0.9028910994529724,
0.7061781287193298,
0.35155513882637024,
0.15081702172756195,
-0.9119361042976379,
0.42555859684944153,
-0.03155503422021866,
-0.14527520537376404,
-0.4957166016101837,
0.44776642322540283,
-0.16872301697731018,
0.5141234993934631,
0.5205296874046326,
0.3310645818710327,
0.062125854194164276,
-0.7506723999977112,
0.2999860644340515,
0.5747363567352295,
-0.3559679687023163,
-0.317025750875473,
0.5744383931159973,
0.5502887964248657,
-0.6330394744873047,
0.9830857515335083,
-0.16562964022159576,
-0.9253363609313965,
0.8772990107536316,
0.0660688579082489,
0.5506534576416016,
-0.2872188091278076,
-0.0681987777352333,
0.04222988337278366,
0.2161685675382614,
-0.07923717796802521,
-0.32888075709342957,
-0.38045454025268555,
-0.9601454734802246,
-0.28183943033218384,
-0.18066611886024475,
-0.5598711371421814,
0.06136808544397354,
-0.6444056630134583,
0.12540872395038605,
-0.6578735113143921,
-0.03575332090258598,
0.0054041300900280476,
0.22715961933135986,
-0.9843788146972656,
0.11315939575433731,
0.40111660957336426,
0.6318449974060059,
-0.42067861557006836,
0.9259535670280457,
0.867759108543396,
-0.5038206577301025,
-0.7413015365600586,
0.11243966221809387,
-0.06991871446371078,
-0.8058849573135376,
0.7674590349197388,
0.2511897385120392,
-0.13699795305728912,
0.4769797921180725,
-0.5373815298080444,
-0.5878248810768127,
1.370355248451233,
-0.028278717771172523,
-0.45727023482322693,
-0.44791847467422485,
0.33482667803764343,
0.48102498054504395,
-0.4402373135089874,
0.03500602766871452,
0.6978499889373779,
0.5391606092453003,
-0.11159738898277283,
-1.417027473449707,
-0.23074673116207123,
-0.23984088003635406,
-0.17755411565303802,
0.012783044017851353,
-0.6040262579917908,
1.0969383716583252,
-0.38080140948295593,
0.007051732391119003,
0.01772160455584526,
0.479299396276474,
0.38742291927337646,
0.29983240365982056,
0.911064624786377,
0.357102632522583,
0.8818550109863281,
0.32157546281814575,
0.8951348066329956,
-0.13448505103588104,
-0.04591793194413185,
1.101078987121582,
-0.703562319278717,
0.7951617240905762,
0.0652591809630394,
-0.29917556047439575,
0.2891847789287567,
0.2304842472076416,
-0.0843428373336792,
0.093693807721138,
-0.03570466861128807,
-0.36020177602767944,
-0.5362077355384827,
-0.4101351201534271,
-0.47533687949180603,
0.7858760952949524,
0.3254980444908142,
0.05569947138428688,
0.21628351509571075,
0.14959073066711426,
-0.31399214267730713,
0.14464299380779266,
-0.6637398600578308,
0.8015020489692688,
-0.10658612847328186,
-0.7184768915176392,
0.04178527370095253,
-0.5740919709205627,
1.0385332107543945,
-0.17356960475444794,
0.03497953712940216,
0.34768179059028625,
0.2941386103630066,
-0.014739971607923508,
-0.7496553063392639,
0.0895528644323349,
-0.0759255588054657,
-0.14504259824752808,
-0.3660421073436737,
0.5623339414596558,
-0.1383054554462433,
-0.20118066668510437,
0.4576568603515625,
0.776557207107544,
-0.34929314255714417,
-0.15704067051410675,
-0.7942341566085815,
-0.05203628167510033,
-0.24560391902923584,
0.4125133454799652,
0.4719845950603485,
-0.07284132391214371,
0.19658978283405304,
0.6933346390724182,
0.9551985859870911,
-0.10566355288028717,
-0.11273109167814255,
-0.23549692332744598,
0.7456517815589905,
-0.6815548539161682,
-0.5178786516189575,
-0.8010286092758179,
0.5494446754455566,
-0.3655273914337158,
-0.24988675117492676,
0.38568028807640076,
0.33373987674713135,
0.6924026608467102,
0.22449347376823425,
0.9846652150154114,
0.22997932136058807,
0.4343172609806061,
-0.19603058695793152,
1.3284142017364502,
-0.39400583505630493,
0.050528667867183685,
-0.10190732777118683,
-0.7778560519218445,
-0.1856682151556015,
0.27473753690719604,
-0.44611120223999023,
0.2878590226173401,
-0.02573896199464798,
0.25983378291130066,
0.08840817213058472,
0.05357851833105087,
0.29741910099983215,
0.17050744593143463,
0.5394748449325562,
0.8285146951675415,
1.2009038925170898,
0.039376404136419296,
0.34423062205314636,
-0.22763021290302277,
-0.5041519403457642,
-0.21751347184181213,
-0.5405648946762085,
-0.9898077249526978,
-0.8133320212364197,
0.0059819468297064304,
0.21183206140995026,
-0.020002592355012894,
1.313401222229004,
1.0115338563919067,
-0.4043915569782257,
-0.22251930832862854,
-0.26949459314346313,
-0.0811881572008133,
0.06822654604911804,
-0.16880308091640472,
0.03362100198864937,
-0.17725147306919098,
-0.5743048787117004,
0.41962888836860657,
0.21376687288284302,
0.2734573483467102,
-0.5743353962898254,
-0.39840489625930786,
-0.30354782938957214,
-0.10225385427474976,
0.41978147625923157,
0.4794425368309021,
-0.4776889383792877,
-0.1188281998038292,
0.1380336731672287,
-0.09787927567958832,
-0.09909728169441223,
0.840226948261261,
-0.954572319984436,
0.012524445541203022,
0.2755957841873169,
0.9110094904899597,
-0.09412474185228348,
0.08191575855016708,
0.961612343788147,
-0.2370627224445343,
0.32330968976020813,
0.8271853923797607,
0.3174261748790741,
0.19474920630455017,
-0.3085053265094757,
0.6284825801849365,
0.17152227461338043,
-0.8850976228713989,
-1.2508206367492676,
0.1856531798839569,
-0.8335994482040405,
-0.2609269917011261,
0.5756756067276001,
-0.09227785468101501,
0.04286518692970276,
-0.1460248976945877,
-0.03636244684457779,
0.42388853430747986,
-0.07655462622642517,
0.7861445546150208,
0.2494259774684906,
-0.5344169735908508,
-0.19311481714248657,
-0.48023250699043274,
0.7305026054382324,
0.533482551574707,
-1.1355721950531006,
-0.2588299810886383,
0.1949406862258911,
-0.28105565905570984,
0.1169823706150055,
0.5325745344161987,
0.4546508491039276,
0.5332954525947571,
-0.18433095514774323,
-0.15682318806648254,
-0.1896912008523941,
-0.474867045879364,
-0.029410183429718018,
0.005096491426229477,
0.011831278912723064,
-0.09689538180828094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04894v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04894v1
|
ConstitutionalExperts: Training a Mixture of Principle-based Prompts
| 2024-03-07T20:58:04 | 2024-03-07T20:58:04 |
Savvas Petridis, Ben Wedin, Ann Yuan, James Wexler, Nithum Thain
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) are highly capable at a variety of tasks given
the right prompt, but writing one is still a difficult and tedious process. In
this work, we introduce ConstitutionalExperts, a method for learning a prompt
consisting of constitutional principles (i.e. rules), given a training dataset.
Unlike prior methods that optimize the prompt as a single entity, our method
incrementally improves the prompt by surgically editing individual principles.
We also show that we can improve overall performance by learning unique prompts
for different semantic regions of the training data and using a
mixture-of-experts (MoE) architecture to route inputs at inference time. We
compare our method to other state of the art prompt-optimization techniques
across six benchmark datasets. We also investigate whether MoE improves these
other techniques. Our results suggest that ConstitutionalExperts outperforms
other prompt optimization techniques by 10.9% (F1) and that mixture-of-experts
improves all techniques, suggesting its broad applicability.
|
[
-0.4125797748565674,
-0.8249456882476807,
0.6849464774131775,
0.22668543457984924,
-0.43144792318344116,
0.24598318338394165,
-0.5405763387680054,
0.2722921371459961,
0.26105996966362,
0.618221640586853,
-0.8056328296661377,
-0.3827727138996124,
-0.3942025303840637,
0.300029456615448,
-0.0856347531080246,
0.8441422581672668,
0.0876094251871109,
0.3782711923122406,
-0.07974504679441452,
0.022752812132239342,
-0.6654893159866333,
-0.38981810212135315,
-0.6919618844985962,
-0.02908678725361824,
0.44062232971191406,
0.6628391742706299,
0.22855301201343536,
0.7089442014694214,
0.11137085407972336,
0.3595448136329651,
-0.15440088510513306,
0.423631489276886,
-0.4327213168144226,
0.3164893090724945,
-0.3496745526790619,
-0.5975003242492676,
0.4000006914138794,
0.0969793051481247,
0.5099227428436279,
0.9234775900840759,
-0.5212593674659729,
-0.37623757123947144,
0.14861539006233215,
0.6072326302528381,
-0.5877642631530762,
0.14578284323215485,
-0.8079298138618469,
0.33239006996154785,
-0.0280326958745718,
-0.481885701417923,
-0.4071565866470337,
-0.6534795761108398,
0.35455039143562317,
-0.9026888608932495,
0.4134913980960846,
0.4447839558124542,
0.3270863890647888,
0.16001661121845245,
-0.24020041525363922,
-0.29865384101867676,
-0.19811886548995972,
0.6957163214683533,
-0.5055692791938782,
0.22985337674617767,
0.09869702905416489,
0.1308213770389557,
-0.5907608270645142,
-0.6261152029037476,
-0.6953246593475342,
-0.39044904708862305,
-0.07270072400569916,
0.22205506265163422,
0.28964561223983765,
0.3583027124404907,
0.38352346420288086,
0.3791160583496094,
-0.4095861613750458,
0.2578512132167816,
-0.22900640964508057,
-0.14647197723388672,
0.41081327199935913,
0.39152389764785767,
0.08713692426681519,
-0.3084428310394287,
-0.15740743279457092,
-0.19660437107086182,
-0.587023138999939,
0.6924557685852051,
0.5096186995506287,
0.41719356179237366,
-0.0028395350091159344,
0.6143231391906738,
-0.27276045083999634,
0.6243169903755188,
0.7695721983909607,
-0.20886561274528503,
-0.1924898624420166,
-0.04114110767841339,
0.03293848782777786,
-0.05149751901626587,
0.6638125777244568,
0.10854962468147278,
0.04338347539305687,
-0.3202202320098877,
-0.2964341640472412,
-0.28269705176353455,
0.2623404264450073,
-0.5963175296783447,
-0.34018346667289734,
0.2732129395008087,
-0.3140564262866974,
-0.30757543444633484,
0.2693841755390167,
-0.7359896898269653,
-0.8276482820510864,
-0.9250237345695496,
0.31581780314445496,
-0.7490989565849304,
0.09211158752441406,
0.23856589198112488,
-0.4112924039363861,
0.282642662525177,
0.6940635442733765,
-1.1636399030685425,
0.31845182180404663,
0.9823048710823059,
0.5791869163513184,
-0.19585105776786804,
-0.13634181022644043,
-0.8866968154907227,
-0.10614018887281418,
-0.574914276599884,
1.0030299425125122,
-0.7470369935035706,
-0.6966674327850342,
0.07541853934526443,
-0.19954711198806763,
-0.2655903697013855,
-0.5186894536018372,
0.8154815435409546,
-0.17213642597198486,
0.32563409209251404,
-0.5936878323554993,
-0.8722423315048218,
0.10142108052968979,
0.06871701031923294,
-0.43122774362564087,
0.9603034853935242,
-0.07861129194498062,
-0.5110798478126526,
0.7110998630523682,
-0.6253473162651062,
-0.46284911036491394,
-0.008887914940714836,
-0.49655207991600037,
-0.1611531525850296,
0.44648662209510803,
0.45176392793655396,
0.5325132012367249,
-0.11119913309812546,
0.43684715032577515,
-0.06629196554422379,
-0.0682549774646759,
0.2751138210296631,
0.03425963222980499,
0.7833269834518433,
0.05395223945379257,
-0.3675655424594879,
0.3625358045101166,
-0.7864803671836853,
-0.30284783244132996,
-0.20357654988765717,
-0.5112429261207581,
-0.2527581751346588,
0.02862676791846752,
-0.327083945274353,
-0.05147470906376839,
-0.007842210121452808,
-0.5402392148971558,
0.4479478895664215,
-0.3956144154071808,
0.28350818157196045,
1.265312671661377,
0.2807849943637848,
0.5143321752548218,
-0.540314793586731,
0.518805205821991,
0.15985873341560364,
0.08108505606651306,
-0.42167311906814575,
-0.36416247487068176,
-0.8310055136680603,
-0.476479172706604,
0.1284157782793045,
0.6994888782501221,
-0.8179610371589661,
0.8721398711204529,
-0.02037411741912365,
-0.5709962844848633,
-0.1942024677991867,
0.15830443799495697,
0.18376237154006958,
0.8049577474594116,
0.3437369167804718,
-0.06193476542830467,
-0.37581437826156616,
-0.7924356460571289,
-0.573101818561554,
-0.12519291043281555,
0.21362265944480896,
0.1466323882341385,
0.4083922207355499,
0.46044448018074036,
1.0249340534210205,
-0.32969528436660767,
0.06525576114654541,
-0.2962709665298462,
0.2751629054546356,
0.35862427949905396,
0.5813779234886169,
0.2760944664478302,
-0.48117855191230774,
-0.4558272659778595,
-0.20518359541893005,
-0.47384557127952576,
-0.21991880238056183,
-0.547224223613739,
0.03103637509047985,
-0.07535652816295624,
0.5530873537063599,
-0.5791559219360352,
-0.02031278982758522,
-0.07799714803695679,
-0.24070976674556732,
0.707615077495575,
-0.24859535694122314,
0.31229886412620544,
-1.054132103919983,
-0.4090575873851776,
0.1075793132185936,
-0.12952665984630585,
-0.42689722776412964,
0.04221085458993912,
0.13222184777259827,
-0.16727720201015472,
-0.2820495665073395,
0.4671131670475006,
-0.40451180934906006,
0.4710281193256378,
-0.13166892528533936,
-0.1421676129102707,
-0.09588745981454849,
0.5667226910591125,
0.12282437086105347,
0.888989269733429,
0.6983575820922852,
-0.6242780685424805,
0.5675010681152344,
0.5715057849884033,
-0.30524516105651855,
0.9433274269104004,
-0.5796895623207092,
0.14226575195789337,
-0.45889994502067566,
0.3670320212841034,
-1.10532546043396,
-0.289069801568985,
0.21616318821907043,
-0.09290114045143127,
0.4671834409236908,
-0.02033022977411747,
-0.4924919605255127,
-0.19773976504802704,
-0.6504510045051575,
-0.36385083198547363,
0.44771745800971985,
-0.6319220066070557,
0.788499116897583,
0.14932392537593842,
-0.3574051856994629,
-0.6583021879196167,
-0.3744814693927765,
0.2664695978164673,
-0.3978797197341919,
-0.4784195125102997,
0.26021483540534973,
0.038833484053611755,
-0.2290416657924652,
-0.21074454486370087,
0.0029797109309583902,
0.11472021788358688,
0.17412731051445007,
0.16964444518089294,
-0.11485946178436279,
-0.057675980031490326,
0.10658098012208939,
0.5767892599105835,
-0.08664426952600479,
-0.006485488265752792,
-0.36712178587913513,
0.4348594546318054,
0.211980938911438,
-0.220655158162117,
-0.8629041314125061,
0.6606310606002808,
0.028469420969486237,
-0.36778753995895386,
0.7458966374397278,
0.05139007419347763,
-0.18992719054222107,
-0.4864370822906494,
-0.8692654371261597,
-0.5314513444900513,
-0.5418550968170166,
0.1252831369638443,
-0.6058101058006287,
-0.9071807861328125,
0.4123362898826599,
-0.3136334717273712,
0.568152666091919,
0.22444893419742584,
0.36279231309890747,
-0.07863803207874298,
0.4950920045375824,
0.513615608215332,
0.19860868155956268,
0.6264931559562683,
-0.011758886277675629,
-0.0064516570419073105,
-0.6003983616828918,
-0.29980048537254333,
-0.8138567209243774,
-0.09645768254995346,
-0.34747838973999023,
-0.1555691957473755,
0.4967670440673828,
0.2761482000350952,
-0.1554558426141739,
0.27120241522789,
-0.3699246644973755,
0.6356292366981506,
0.9731687307357788,
0.4989207088947296,
0.020579949021339417,
0.10483692586421967,
-0.3894270062446594,
-0.20473065972328186,
-0.7735940217971802,
-0.559150218963623,
1.072165846824646,
-0.03452355042099953,
0.8707815408706665,
0.0543493889272213,
0.8988670110702515,
0.14581426978111267,
-0.1333143562078476,
-0.7055708765983582,
0.6289640069007874,
-0.2384127974510193,
-0.18752305209636688,
-0.2620738446712494,
-0.3813183903694153,
-0.6996389031410217,
0.13539017736911774,
-0.4427127540111542,
-0.42824479937553406,
0.5444445610046387,
0.2243184745311737,
-0.8090615272521973,
0.2152738720178604,
-0.6524734497070312,
0.6648736000061035,
-0.0043430631048977375,
-0.38543128967285156,
-0.2622130811214447,
-0.7635012865066528,
0.05593493953347206,
-0.21036438643932343,
-0.1552087366580963,
0.022590994834899902,
-0.32361000776290894,
0.7056947946548462,
-0.7345893979072571,
1.0029293298721313,
-0.29833945631980896,
0.06917679309844971,
0.13941620290279388,
-0.16237583756446838,
0.7352530360221863,
0.21422769129276276,
-0.1780501902103424,
-0.3862797021865845,
-0.16943961381912231,
-0.2773781716823578,
-0.69908207654953,
0.32725682854652405,
-0.7326620221138,
-0.8758744597434998,
-0.3162831962108612,
-0.3481895625591278,
-0.3960762023925781,
-0.11087851971387863,
0.3603365123271942,
0.8104464411735535,
-0.20735707879066467,
0.355440229177475,
1.0129618644714355,
-0.3481634259223938,
0.4154576361179352,
0.48889806866645813,
0.3876185119152069,
-0.5682470202445984,
0.49043402075767517,
0.10567496716976166,
0.027350036427378654,
0.6054521799087524,
0.5569897294044495,
-0.6279507279396057,
-0.7345663905143738,
-0.461602121591568,
0.005708449985831976,
-0.8424112200737,
-0.03179127350449562,
-1.0708250999450684,
0.24289703369140625,
-0.6205176711082458,
-0.38972774147987366,
-0.007809767499566078,
-0.6786978840827942,
-0.36837494373321533,
-0.03513297438621521,
0.5549975037574768,
0.24615487456321716,
-0.25780388712882996,
0.7224560976028442,
-0.4458423852920532,
0.5548239350318909,
0.5144038796424866,
-0.11167020350694656,
-0.4857695698738098,
-0.6640201210975647,
0.21280880272388458,
-0.17129077017307281,
-0.33419933915138245,
-0.836214005947113,
-0.11100074648857117,
0.4241970479488373,
0.9825316071510315,
0.44867387413978577,
0.26318472623825073,
0.7972031235694885,
-0.6978928446769714,
0.8591904044151306,
0.22869551181793213,
-1.0155370235443115,
0.6674790382385254,
-0.32743963599205017,
-0.1429436057806015,
0.8973045945167542,
0.15171460807323456,
-0.5780388116836548,
-0.5816406011581421,
-0.3617241084575653,
-0.617478609085083,
0.6654813289642334,
-0.10290494561195374,
0.5047176480293274,
-0.06121787428855896,
0.7114670276641846,
0.5059159398078918,
0.35381966829299927,
-0.18611344695091248,
-0.19377663731575012,
-0.28006505966186523,
-0.4240247905254364,
0.2139580249786377,
-0.13168436288833618,
-0.2411467283964157,
-0.33468806743621826,
0.7079108357429504,
-0.30098816752433777,
-0.016122056171298027,
0.3145471513271332,
-0.08751782029867172,
0.034504301846027374,
0.4041372835636139,
0.8213033676147461,
0.8094930052757263,
0.10226218402385712,
-0.19610312581062317,
0.15589052438735962,
-0.3858121931552887,
0.2730019986629486,
0.2433755099773407,
-0.22671441733837128,
-0.03697625547647476,
0.25242260098457336,
0.8499654531478882,
0.08750022202730179,
-0.4905823767185211,
0.5699421167373657,
-0.22832559049129486,
-0.18178781867027283,
-0.3390864133834839,
0.5266474485397339,
-0.18728062510490417,
0.27635079622268677,
0.5300300121307373,
0.08944743871688843,
0.1529879868030548,
-0.4943001866340637,
0.282624751329422,
0.3788527548313141,
0.0031841997988522053,
-0.00961323082447052,
0.6327804923057556,
0.38645586371421814,
-0.17534758150577545,
0.2117752581834793,
-0.01773725636303425,
-0.4614585041999817,
0.4778745174407959,
0.09149444103240967,
0.8959019780158997,
-0.45837512612342834,
0.16991211473941803,
0.33358827233314514,
0.3279018998146057,
-0.3206517696380615,
0.41105717420578003,
-0.05037399381399155,
-0.534859299659729,
-0.3239619731903076,
-0.3895242512226105,
-0.7865912914276123,
-0.14888079464435577,
-0.5013110637664795,
0.6240688562393188,
-0.9664585590362549,
0.08690369129180908,
0.08521047979593277,
0.10061109811067581,
-0.5144526958465576,
0.06454835087060928,
-0.43629300594329834,
1.0653297901153564,
-0.6477314233779907,
0.3941459357738495,
0.6958645582199097,
-0.3309372067451477,
-0.8812713623046875,
-0.20653337240219116,
0.059624362736940384,
-0.7201513051986694,
0.2041846513748169,
0.1377847045660019,
0.25368911027908325,
0.03962366655468941,
-0.6161563992500305,
-0.1154150441288948,
0.623030960559845,
0.41685569286346436,
-0.858283281326294,
0.01362392958253622,
0.06431441754102707,
0.16987328231334686,
-0.3627496063709259,
0.13166581094264984,
0.47983601689338684,
0.4184005856513977,
-0.07213767617940903,
-0.6743867993354797,
-0.050047509372234344,
0.07434768229722977,
-0.10125598311424255,
-0.04179641604423523,
-0.4525851607322693,
0.9528483748435974,
-0.11016356945037842,
0.02723114751279354,
0.31646108627319336,
0.8859432339668274,
0.40122243762016296,
-0.09033901989459991,
0.7030820846557617,
0.5100863575935364,
1.1462225914001465,
-0.23630963265895844,
1.01724374294281,
-0.35807791352272034,
0.08546214550733566,
1.08931565284729,
-0.23371946811676025,
0.3442069888114929,
0.6251030564308167,
0.061942264437675476,
0.38598936796188354,
0.9488617181777954,
0.008506285026669502,
0.6566973328590393,
0.38332343101501465,
-0.46939191222190857,
-0.4823516309261322,
-0.11942906677722931,
-0.30446767807006836,
0.06758348643779755,
0.24703313410282135,
-0.23840422928333282,
-0.21057793498039246,
0.23819497227668762,
0.19718371331691742,
0.4120553135871887,
-0.20097026228904724,
1.085434079170227,
-0.010329313576221466,
-0.7975354790687561,
0.23973448574543,
0.04695889726281166,
0.6766887307167053,
-0.6098159551620483,
-0.055678848177194595,
-0.4178725481033325,
-0.04539772495627403,
0.11233139038085938,
-0.8236403465270996,
-0.15689438581466675,
-0.09101051837205887,
-0.12169571965932846,
-0.22605495154857635,
0.15025517344474792,
-0.4115639925003052,
-0.4863660931587219,
-0.5358755588531494,
0.38963472843170166,
-0.07665775716304779,
-0.15044033527374268,
-0.821363091468811,
-0.3776417374610901,
-0.17803120613098145,
-0.34070640802383423,
-0.3484298884868622,
0.9225776195526123,
-0.07875178009271622,
0.4524955451488495,
0.7428516149520874,
0.13004513084888458,
0.25275126099586487,
-0.14500081539154053,
1.098185420036316,
-0.7052887082099915,
-0.861849308013916,
-0.8664007186889648,
0.5980732440948486,
-0.3657849431037903,
-0.636999249458313,
0.48426663875579834,
0.6611629724502563,
0.5614312291145325,
-0.15394459664821625,
0.8750908970832825,
0.12401186674833298,
0.7738267183303833,
-0.9939048886299133,
0.33445388078689575,
-0.22656728327274323,
0.10288069397211075,
-0.08229787647724152,
-0.9199456572532654,
-0.11895116418600082,
0.5167540907859802,
-0.27158334851264954,
-0.1108349859714508,
0.7584381699562073,
0.8848110437393188,
-0.06985288858413696,
0.3458186686038971,
0.16798695921897888,
-0.05565088242292404,
0.5940083265304565,
0.24302323162555695,
1.0589549541473389,
0.06560669094324112,
0.1383240669965744,
-0.6420000791549683,
-0.2914714217185974,
-0.07360301911830902,
-0.7510015368461609,
-1.137495756149292,
-0.5588666200637817,
-0.38218873739242554,
-0.07523299008607864,
0.1806938201189041,
1.5022759437561035,
0.7406505346298218,
-0.8281720280647278,
-0.010063053108751774,
-0.20477934181690216,
-0.1283569037914276,
-0.05022716149687767,
-0.13714267313480377,
0.45569926500320435,
-0.8001465201377869,
-0.6779425740242004,
0.5242313742637634,
0.12937328219413757,
-0.012924199923872948,
-0.03065110743045807,
0.06968853622674942,
0.08022820949554443,
0.32438066601753235,
0.3602156341075897,
0.10545534640550613,
-0.8575534224510193,
-0.3463062047958374,
0.02279588207602501,
-0.15919356048107147,
0.1230541244149208,
1.3593196868896484,
-0.6202028393745422,
0.3853236436843872,
0.6324326992034912,
0.947601318359375,
0.00019723882724065334,
0.23535263538360596,
0.5081425309181213,
-0.7285645604133606,
0.2998233139514923,
0.24906624853610992,
0.6800857186317444,
0.42025431990623474,
-0.45607900619506836,
0.3351692259311676,
0.47140252590179443,
-0.264848917722702,
-0.49331700801849365,
0.04818013310432434,
-1.1443055868148804,
-0.28012123703956604,
1.006500005722046,
-0.22698135673999786,
-0.20600274205207825,
-0.3757076859474182,
-0.666832685470581,
0.04679862782359123,
-0.7726060152053833,
0.846634030342102,
0.674770176410675,
-0.06127093732357025,
-0.4045756161212921,
-0.348197340965271,
0.5478719472885132,
0.5810319781303406,
-1.009764313697815,
-0.03852264583110809,
0.6579951643943787,
0.3651074469089508,
-0.23001940548419952,
0.4836864471435547,
0.06513986736536026,
0.35101935267448425,
-0.23219338059425354,
-0.17486874759197235,
-0.07302545011043549,
-0.18858620524406433,
-0.468779981136322,
0.16027741134166718,
-0.11809805780649185,
-0.03717605397105217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04890v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04890v1
|
Few shot chain-of-thought driven reasoning to prompt LLMs for open ended medical question answering
| 2024-03-07T20:48:40 | 2024-03-07T20:48:40 |
Ojas Gramopadhye, Saeel Sandeep Nachane, Prateek Chanda, Ganesh Ramakrishnan, Kshitij Sharad Jadhav, Yatin Nandwani, Dinesh Raghu, Sachindra Joshi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language models (LLMs) have demonstrated significant potential in
transforming healthcare by automating tasks such as clinical documentation,
information retrieval, and decision support. In this aspect, carefully
engineered prompts have emerged as a powerful tool for using LLMs for medical
scenarios, e.g., patient clinical scenarios. In this paper, we propose a
modified version of the MedQA-USMLE dataset, which is subjective, to mimic
real-life clinical scenarios. We explore the Chain of Thought (CoT) reasoning
based on subjective response generation for the modified MedQA-USMLE dataset
with appropriate LM-driven forward reasoning for correct responses to the
medical questions. Keeping in mind the importance of response verification in
the medical setting, we utilize a reward training mechanism whereby the
language model also provides an appropriate verified response for a particular
response to a clinical question. In this regard, we also include
human-in-the-loop for different evaluation aspects. We develop better
in-contrast learning strategies by modifying the 5-shot-codex-CoT-prompt from
arXiv:2207.08143 for the subjective MedQA dataset and developing our
incremental-reasoning prompt. Our evaluations show that the incremental
reasoning prompt performs better than the modified codex prompt in certain
scenarios. We also show that greedy decoding with the incremental reasoning
method performs better than other strategies, such as prompt chaining and
eliminative reasoning.
|
[
-0.3955262005329132,
-0.8404105305671692,
1.059981107711792,
-0.1954321414232254,
-0.37925440073013306,
0.05497788265347481,
-0.06659598648548126,
-0.24635279178619385,
0.05523037537932396,
0.6705435514450073,
-0.8759168982505798,
-0.6792961359024048,
-0.21378104388713837,
0.4461885392665863,
0.014784523285925388,
0.9105725884437561,
-0.3051973283290863,
0.3902524709701538,
-0.15724052488803864,
-0.23335009813308716,
-0.523826003074646,
-0.7845819592475891,
-0.7568804621696472,
-0.38741037249565125,
0.8528831601142883,
0.4867355227470398,
0.47637614607810974,
0.2715208828449249,
0.6660913825035095,
0.17255699634552002,
0.05603303760290146,
0.28902602195739746,
-0.31004902720451355,
0.24202723801136017,
-0.3861199915409088,
-0.5830135345458984,
-0.2842938303947449,
-0.11145149916410446,
0.25440719723701477,
0.6483473181724548,
-0.10324668884277344,
0.03931814059615135,
-0.23149144649505615,
0.7160406708717346,
-0.5666799545288086,
-0.3329443037509918,
-0.638009786605835,
0.29035109281539917,
0.24650706350803375,
-0.4593873918056488,
-0.6155535578727722,
-0.42026379704475403,
0.21391549706459045,
-0.3833101987838745,
-0.005411871708929539,
-0.021006816998124123,
0.5324497818946838,
0.25644704699516296,
-0.29483291506767273,
-0.5188754200935364,
-0.4563983082771301,
0.4812801778316498,
-0.875678539276123,
0.1840885877609253,
0.2564551830291748,
0.4523741900920868,
-0.22416149079799652,
-0.7501387596130371,
-0.5695067048072815,
-0.2657754719257355,
0.09566383063793182,
0.28865790367126465,
0.048538774251937866,
0.16143172979354858,
0.3258419334888458,
0.2713830769062042,
-0.6885439157485962,
0.17033760249614716,
-0.1458141803741455,
-0.11320493370294571,
0.4547465443611145,
0.6229714751243591,
0.1758730411529541,
0.06171085312962532,
-0.6153337359428406,
-0.0014515375951305032,
-1.0114837884902954,
0.09901495277881622,
-0.1399964839220047,
0.28491708636283875,
-0.08733571320772171,
0.6157569289207458,
-0.24920588731765747,
0.8433799147605896,
0.16465230286121368,
-0.31282302737236023,
0.12412135303020477,
-0.3053300678730011,
-0.3427759110927582,
0.04908610135316849,
0.6720704436302185,
0.42707133293151855,
0.24799464643001556,
0.04682463780045509,
-0.19508035480976105,
0.18073849380016327,
0.3736339211463928,
-0.585817277431488,
0.08215151727199554,
0.621688961982727,
-0.5823736190795898,
-0.2614087164402008,
-0.2579742670059204,
-0.530777096748352,
-0.45684781670570374,
-0.27373501658439636,
0.27634385228157043,
-0.4528734087944031,
0.18599295616149902,
0.42154133319854736,
0.0928596630692482,
0.38509422540664673,
0.5864366888999939,
-0.49051544070243835,
0.2766084671020508,
0.41038691997528076,
0.7221894860267639,
-0.23091234266757965,
0.07979828864336014,
-0.523303210735321,
-0.16802072525024414,
-0.3698994219303131,
1.0158010721206665,
-0.32978254556655884,
-0.3593823313713074,
0.023790081962943077,
-0.1952507495880127,
0.1096063181757927,
-0.5886750817298889,
0.4653078019618988,
-0.5373009443283081,
0.3773127794265747,
-0.41969212889671326,
-0.5952151417732239,
0.08473086357116699,
0.7583497762680054,
-0.33100858330726624,
0.6031662225723267,
0.18307779729366302,
-0.7292032837867737,
0.22063742578029633,
-0.6126017570495605,
-0.20153850317001343,
0.027687495574355125,
-0.508813202381134,
-0.1359422206878662,
-0.1383514106273651,
0.4495958387851715,
0.3563566505908966,
-0.4509897232055664,
0.3320406675338745,
-0.22630897164344788,
-0.3704746961593628,
0.6898154020309448,
-0.3544026017189026,
0.6860823035240173,
0.4474506080150604,
-0.2443855106830597,
0.24188341200351715,
-0.6127756834030151,
0.1008012667298317,
0.06965997815132141,
-0.2740762531757355,
-0.0479910746216774,
-0.1722872257232666,
-0.5371861457824707,
0.567872166633606,
-0.05258779972791672,
-0.545289158821106,
0.30371716618537903,
-0.4846818745136261,
0.11049036681652069,
0.8542672395706177,
0.4928620755672455,
0.17034000158309937,
-0.472852885723114,
0.7437192797660828,
0.45091643929481506,
0.42833536863327026,
-0.21268174052238464,
-0.5562666654586792,
-0.4800510108470917,
-0.24563485383987427,
0.06213902309536934,
0.6142116785049438,
-1.2959766387939453,
0.04356704652309418,
0.13123591244220734,
-0.0866858959197998,
-0.7380477786064148,
-0.2034328281879425,
0.4183299243450165,
1.0365474224090576,
0.5284214019775391,
-0.07996033132076263,
-0.49688777327537537,
-0.7947986721992493,
-0.12574872374534607,
-0.29460176825523376,
-0.012018312700092793,
0.46718019247055054,
0.42155611515045166,
-0.11777026951313019,
0.8315943479537964,
-0.739400327205658,
0.016082696616649628,
-0.32521772384643555,
-0.09692680090665817,
0.5449231863021851,
0.23019342124462128,
0.10058154165744781,
-0.44452643394470215,
-0.209029883146286,
-0.12818963825702667,
-0.9598388671875,
-0.1719859391450882,
-0.44700324535369873,
-0.1882418841123581,
0.11748436838388443,
0.43556222319602966,
-0.36959028244018555,
0.4408516585826874,
0.1305510550737381,
-0.34773287177085876,
0.7228035926818848,
-0.15709488093852997,
0.4284874200820923,
-0.9976579546928406,
-0.025269100442528725,
-0.14291167259216309,
-0.30827662348747253,
-0.38015076518058777,
0.28210633993148804,
-0.10232296586036682,
0.04157949984073639,
-0.8280110359191895,
0.6840161085128784,
-0.21947552263736725,
0.07732998579740524,
-0.4354283809661865,
0.19192463159561157,
-0.06614793837070465,
0.5030634999275208,
0.14861051738262177,
0.7298153042793274,
0.6181155443191528,
-0.6818894743919373,
0.455054372549057,
0.3106101453304291,
-0.24486114084720612,
0.6618854403495789,
-0.7033162117004395,
0.36928847432136536,
-0.27639803290367126,
0.4827739894390106,
-0.7219911217689514,
-0.07103139162063599,
0.36067214608192444,
-0.28665891289711,
-0.06053411588072777,
0.1665758639574051,
-0.5960928797721863,
-0.6015154719352722,
-0.4906406104564667,
0.4911082684993744,
0.48972561955451965,
-0.6170403957366943,
0.1187402606010437,
0.012867185287177563,
-0.06931354850530624,
-0.5334170460700989,
-0.6717503666877747,
0.0061833178624510765,
-0.06731370091438293,
-0.34094518423080444,
0.060839392244815826,
-0.33861005306243896,
-0.44796058535575867,
-0.25730100274086,
0.003927296958863735,
0.14721441268920898,
-0.15869863331317902,
0.023940611630678177,
0.6127488017082214,
-0.19786390662193298,
0.31788408756256104,
0.07792351394891739,
-0.018115170300006866,
0.09027031064033508,
-0.3425399959087372,
0.5296486020088196,
-0.035716865211725235,
-0.3906760513782501,
-0.310347318649292,
0.5420680046081543,
0.23033936321735382,
0.03563063219189644,
0.6378372311592102,
0.15988437831401825,
-0.3929423689842224,
-0.08754527568817139,
-0.3637659549713135,
-0.4518726170063019,
-0.4376487731933594,
-0.005956562235951424,
-0.55363929271698,
-1.0012353658676147,
0.47920259833335876,
-0.07337702810764313,
0.09254658967256546,
0.16204966604709625,
1.0842697620391846,
-0.37292441725730896,
1.0228036642074585,
-0.010277844965457916,
0.22353433072566986,
-0.049807604402303696,
-0.17278313636779785,
-0.00984490942209959,
-0.8326857089996338,
-0.41291090846061707,
-0.2767375409603119,
-0.3273531496524811,
-0.40658038854599,
-0.5656057000160217,
0.9427144527435303,
-0.1917722374200821,
-0.27377909421920776,
-0.14139564335346222,
-0.5168615579605103,
0.42918160557746887,
0.2553078532218933,
0.7243029475212097,
0.3519478142261505,
-0.25147420167922974,
-0.6231853365898132,
0.27415531873703003,
-0.8393005132675171,
-0.5504074096679688,
0.9795619249343872,
0.34950289130210876,
1.0331066846847534,
-0.019328860566020012,
0.7306293845176697,
0.12065152078866959,
0.20932944118976593,
-0.8511233925819397,
0.6066849231719971,
0.11887655407190323,
-0.4936068654060364,
0.021130701526999474,
-0.3788869380950928,
-0.8813470005989075,
0.1227119043469429,
-0.20103006064891815,
-0.5150324106216431,
0.15026497840881348,
0.07633916288614273,
-0.6880534887313843,
0.1656227558851242,
-0.31498104333877563,
0.4066692292690277,
-0.17862874269485474,
-0.33957570791244507,
-0.02359834872186184,
-1.0657432079315186,
0.32467886805534363,
0.19118519127368927,
-0.020081989467144012,
0.11288570612668991,
-0.18837842345237732,
0.41305676102638245,
-0.6935535073280334,
0.8598775863647461,
0.02216401882469654,
-0.31943008303642273,
0.6036757826805115,
-0.03846355155110359,
0.5143746733665466,
0.27404552698135376,
-0.16526326537132263,
-0.21073754131793976,
-0.11416231095790863,
-0.4813486337661743,
-0.7113831639289856,
0.6930787563323975,
-0.4806806445121765,
-0.6873760223388672,
-0.42787784337997437,
-0.5581918358802795,
-0.5833809971809387,
-0.2452709823846817,
0.4283221364021301,
0.7099894881248474,
-0.03725023940205574,
-0.38472458720207214,
0.7752200365066528,
-0.5446262359619141,
0.20973418653011322,
0.5363659858703613,
-0.2850418984889984,
-0.40721821784973145,
0.3003922998905182,
-0.3369520604610443,
0.4831932783126831,
0.49994954466819763,
0.2674045264720917,
-0.36270108819007874,
-0.4673890769481659,
-0.6585732698440552,
0.30543774366378784,
-0.9603128433227539,
-0.5300418734550476,
-0.5464824438095093,
-0.17245754599571228,
-0.1743779331445694,
-0.35117295384407043,
-0.025352662429213524,
-0.21472105383872986,
-0.19795933365821838,
-0.21398085355758667,
0.5048366785049438,
0.6223814487457275,
0.2637947201728821,
0.07943511754274368,
-0.8673908710479736,
0.4323786497116089,
0.2575782537460327,
0.24782760441303253,
-0.11344599723815918,
-0.3957046568393707,
-0.19956721365451813,
0.09753327071666718,
-0.33321434259414673,
-1.0184977054595947,
0.07302965968847275,
-0.3624960482120514,
0.40435266494750977,
0.2477657049894333,
0.14938199520111084,
0.5760641098022461,
-0.6079070568084717,
0.9125995635986328,
0.3569255769252777,
-0.607894241809845,
0.7224606871604919,
-0.2079855501651764,
0.5680035948753357,
0.7429754734039307,
0.4660637676715851,
-0.413078248500824,
-0.47876086831092834,
-0.5451817512512207,
-0.4986000657081604,
0.4227854013442993,
-0.0366959422826767,
-0.1436537802219391,
-0.3814965784549713,
0.6741409301757812,
0.4694436490535736,
0.030151275917887688,
-0.4871750771999359,
-0.22164130210876465,
0.2073114663362503,
-0.37695038318634033,
0.2699344754219055,
0.05593022704124451,
-0.06875426322221756,
-0.20304614305496216,
0.4531154930591583,
-0.45007750391960144,
0.282696008682251,
0.7539119124412537,
0.03848325461149216,
-0.16765685379505157,
0.5526017546653748,
0.5324791073799133,
0.5913897752761841,
-0.2555690109729767,
0.3310644030570984,
0.21830810606479645,
-0.20723856985569,
0.2925695478916168,
-0.5249058604240417,
-0.014466684311628342,
0.005485311150550842,
0.2869604527950287,
0.8270161151885986,
-0.14550036191940308,
-1.0244015455245972,
0.42820754647254944,
-0.014922370202839375,
-0.22661243379116058,
0.0414900965988636,
0.09427536278963089,
-0.13552436232566833,
0.33486247062683105,
0.03879188746213913,
0.013664434663951397,
0.27603912353515625,
-0.8220566511154175,
0.2026478797197342,
0.350713849067688,
-0.2888612747192383,
-0.16987749934196472,
0.43625351786613464,
0.04816358909010887,
-0.17838050425052643,
0.5247117280960083,
0.03254179283976555,
-0.4691559970378876,
0.3750742971897125,
0.6546807289123535,
0.6712080836296082,
-0.015692757442593575,
0.3320156931877136,
0.44613561034202576,
0.037852708250284195,
-0.06928093731403351,
0.714261531829834,
-0.030883749946951866,
-0.7155987024307251,
-0.46512532234191895,
-0.25283920764923096,
-0.6380962133407593,
0.0625823512673378,
-0.6067460179328918,
0.42283910512924194,
-0.5645482540130615,
-0.20047566294670105,
-0.2637839615345001,
-0.2827802002429962,
-0.6628799438476562,
0.5545432567596436,
0.24728389084339142,
1.1178001165390015,
-0.47147247195243835,
0.7591608166694641,
0.6954099535942078,
-0.5377925634384155,
-0.8352052569389343,
0.03676268458366394,
-0.09799370914697647,
-0.9993218779563904,
0.3687395751476288,
-0.09608768671751022,
-0.21891647577285767,
-0.21284709870815277,
-0.7560928463935852,
-0.336506724357605,
0.9768349528312683,
0.22614596784114838,
-0.5265728235244751,
-0.12240185588598251,
0.012609518133103848,
0.670300304889679,
-0.6179762482643127,
0.36774903535842896,
0.4534871578216553,
0.07783184945583344,
0.38012757897377014,
-0.7313715219497681,
0.3130728304386139,
0.03455375134944916,
-0.2050437480211258,
0.09889670461416245,
-0.3214610815048218,
0.7739169001579285,
-0.7402350902557373,
0.1134926974773407,
0.12900499999523163,
0.330241322517395,
0.7682686448097229,
0.4401819705963135,
0.3840445578098297,
0.4281754195690155,
0.7381454706192017,
0.25321492552757263,
1.335680603981018,
0.1334756761789322,
0.1455364227294922,
1.1344860792160034,
-0.5448170304298401,
0.8797576427459717,
0.7050807476043701,
-0.2593883275985718,
0.8750999569892883,
0.6975114345550537,
0.34826791286468506,
0.6759248375892639,
0.34381720423698425,
-0.5403372049331665,
-0.2653631567955017,
-0.1431903839111328,
-0.3821968734264374,
0.18447653949260712,
0.25386375188827515,
-0.4951516091823578,
-0.2209789901971817,
0.2306676208972931,
-0.13720768690109253,
0.044163547456264496,
-0.4868569076061249,
1.065549612045288,
0.3688619136810303,
-0.8639343976974487,
0.9613432288169861,
-0.1668841689825058,
0.4053876996040344,
-0.5123010277748108,
-0.09994346648454666,
-0.25545036792755127,
0.040346644818782806,
-0.15186096727848053,
-0.8781203031539917,
-0.000883322732988745,
0.3124658763408661,
-0.18129925429821014,
-0.12437166273593903,
0.6409416198730469,
-0.32662373781204224,
-0.3740687668323517,
-0.030167769640684128,
0.6627357006072998,
0.31489887833595276,
0.09008421748876572,
-0.8425421118736267,
-0.07195378094911575,
-0.026828916743397713,
-0.0700194463133812,
0.32918474078178406,
0.36096447706222534,
-0.12645083665847778,
0.762079656124115,
0.6047214269638062,
0.14332038164138794,
-0.25224176049232483,
0.3901347517967224,
1.0903208255767822,
-0.8035752773284912,
-0.5553305149078369,
-1.0412975549697876,
0.5052063465118408,
0.12340101599693298,
-0.2299635410308838,
0.32412007451057434,
0.35656407475471497,
0.39572596549987793,
-0.2491588145494461,
0.6577089428901672,
0.3757004141807556,
0.5706282258033752,
-0.9135717749595642,
0.2661038339138031,
-0.4133646488189697,
0.4755322337150574,
-0.21395668387413025,
-0.35511329770088196,
-0.30871424078941345,
0.4468647539615631,
-0.17128515243530273,
-0.042779915034770966,
1.088193655014038,
0.6453367471694946,
0.31675130128860474,
0.15316876769065857,
0.38845500349998474,
0.2606580853462219,
0.18446792662143707,
1.0527245998382568,
1.008355975151062,
-0.2967504560947418,
0.1607690453529358,
0.013594145886600018,
-0.3129582107067108,
0.022647973150014877,
-0.7613704800605774,
-0.9251111149787903,
-0.2849603295326233,
-0.35324910283088684,
-0.5899946093559265,
0.1798407882452011,
1.4263004064559937,
0.3514462113380432,
-0.7653863430023193,
-0.008116255514323711,
-0.1158560961484909,
-0.0008041707915253937,
-0.11256712675094604,
-0.19671212136745453,
0.278648316860199,
-0.48851969838142395,
-0.2285577356815338,
0.4852665662765503,
0.4336266815662384,
-0.006816915236413479,
-0.2030438333749771,
-0.16753366589546204,
-0.3156910240650177,
0.31457284092903137,
0.661040186882019,
0.051960576325654984,
-0.733444094657898,
-0.1649741679430008,
0.31124064326286316,
-0.2779160141944885,
0.3156522810459137,
1.1322181224822998,
-1.402068853378296,
0.41763779520988464,
0.29860612750053406,
0.6286901235580444,
0.3015710413455963,
0.055302202701568604,
0.616804301738739,
-0.6990023851394653,
0.03540012240409851,
0.606499969959259,
0.3802700638771057,
0.2726047933101654,
-0.47598960995674133,
0.47022750973701477,
0.04389004781842232,
-0.4031686782836914,
-0.647512674331665,
0.3129306733608246,
-1.089565396308899,
-0.5127957463264465,
1.195654273033142,
-0.2327418029308319,
-0.15325140953063965,
-0.22010914981365204,
-0.5623759031295776,
0.10800494253635406,
-0.22860269248485565,
0.6168429255485535,
0.5914841890335083,
-0.613498330116272,
-0.21566811203956604,
-0.22021819651126862,
0.29853904247283936,
0.45791828632354736,
-1.2041592597961426,
-0.3082137703895569,
0.4582921266555786,
0.142181396484375,
-0.2188955396413803,
0.9158021211624146,
-0.3125249445438385,
0.5294103622436523,
-0.24750040471553802,
-0.1504886895418167,
0.14927752315998077,
-0.13072890043258667,
-0.428157240152359,
0.035865023732185364,
0.19880571961402893,
-0.31352201104164124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04872v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04872v2
|
Code-Mixed Probes Show How Pre-Trained Models Generalise On Code-Switched Text
| 2024-03-07T19:46:03 | 2024-05-07T16:38:25 |
Frances A. Laureano De Leon, Harish Tayyar Madabushi, Mark Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Code-switching is a prevalent linguistic phenomenon in which multilingual
individuals seamlessly alternate between languages. Despite its widespread use
online and recent research trends in this area, research in code-switching
presents unique challenges, primarily stemming from the scarcity of labelled
data and available resources. In this study we investigate how pre-trained
Language Models handle code-switched text in three dimensions: a) the ability
of PLMs to detect code-switched text, b) variations in the structural
information that PLMs utilise to capture code-switched text, and c) the
consistency of semantic information representation in code-switched text. To
conduct a systematic and controlled evaluation of the language models in
question, we create a novel dataset of well-formed naturalistic code-switched
text along with parallel translations into the source languages. Our findings
reveal that pre-trained language models are effective in generalising to
code-switched text, shedding light on the abilities of these models to
generalise representations to CS corpora. We release all our code and data
including the novel corpus at https://github.com/francesita/code-mixed-probes.
|
[
-0.37452489137649536,
-0.5628815293312073,
0.4623161852359772,
0.39689314365386963,
-0.2866494357585907,
0.21723370254039764,
-0.29090186953544617,
-0.4561525881290436,
-0.033761776983737946,
0.867720365524292,
-0.22898386418819427,
-0.603927493095398,
-0.37551045417785645,
0.2784300744533539,
-0.7004576325416565,
1.1618257761001587,
-0.3692954480648041,
0.3251856863498688,
-0.00680307112634182,
-0.14866937696933746,
-0.18540434539318085,
-1.0507612228393555,
-0.06709741055965424,
-0.13917185366153717,
0.5703070759773254,
0.2004391849040985,
0.8810829520225525,
0.3894846439361572,
0.5379042625427246,
0.17102882266044617,
0.08035582304000854,
0.14337888360023499,
-0.4697035551071167,
-0.3816207945346832,
-0.014430291019380093,
-0.8099412322044373,
-0.24788662791252136,
0.41355207562446594,
0.7086102366447449,
0.8576933741569519,
0.1006406769156456,
0.0725933313369751,
0.11639441549777985,
0.32625019550323486,
-0.5933076739311218,
-0.015940263867378235,
-0.7465742826461792,
0.08825719356536865,
-0.47780537605285645,
-0.4938540756702423,
-0.7182095050811768,
-0.20498166978359222,
-0.032941486686468124,
-0.48763206601142883,
0.474688321352005,
-0.3131011724472046,
0.8213217258453369,
0.04987350106239319,
-0.6503939032554626,
-0.3551219701766968,
-0.9829511642456055,
0.7159398794174194,
-0.6045377254486084,
0.5272234082221985,
0.32036009430885315,
0.04760279506444931,
0.1927434504032135,
-0.8171334266662598,
-0.45421573519706726,
-0.24091550707817078,
-0.24388118088245392,
0.04111725091934204,
-0.0014589789789170027,
-0.08928408473730087,
0.14073921740055084,
0.20278525352478027,
-0.47449934482574463,
0.07155267149209976,
-0.3491036891937256,
-0.3021954894065857,
0.43582314252853394,
-0.012097951024770737,
0.5433712005615234,
0.12472520023584366,
-0.3775828778743744,
-0.2492217868566513,
-0.5875715613365173,
-0.07828522473573685,
0.5498340725898743,
0.265449583530426,
-0.3475998044013977,
0.45907190442085266,
0.11546318978071213,
1.0905799865722656,
-0.06560174375772476,
0.21142499148845673,
0.4226789176464081,
-0.6505697965621948,
-0.16232968866825104,
-0.21686296164989471,
0.6704118847846985,
0.15389525890350342,
0.404064416885376,
-0.22767147421836853,
-0.25090667605400085,
0.38233450055122375,
0.3178248107433319,
-0.5694120526313782,
-0.38888537883758545,
0.04692791774868965,
-0.6163327693939209,
-0.3206809163093567,
-0.0173123087733984,
-0.6242520213127136,
-0.08993709832429886,
-0.3546074628829956,
0.24006806313991547,
-0.3708890974521637,
-0.5392447710037231,
0.6627004742622375,
-0.10288720577955246,
0.26363465189933777,
0.048549484461545944,
-0.6080919504165649,
0.35864901542663574,
0.3402351140975952,
0.7077255845069885,
-0.3836708664894104,
-0.49627432227134705,
-0.4978940188884735,
0.007184038404375315,
-0.332986444234848,
0.554648756980896,
-0.8256528973579407,
-0.3703908920288086,
0.039785970002412796,
-0.13525067269802094,
-0.31687062978744507,
-0.5531958341598511,
0.1027304008603096,
-0.8837056756019592,
0.3553718328475952,
0.1946786493062973,
-0.2220759093761444,
0.1315615028142929,
0.2189491242170334,
-0.8650251626968384,
0.8849428296089172,
-0.05334353819489479,
-1.0125060081481934,
0.21207167208194733,
-0.3117966949939728,
-0.2650015354156494,
-0.19635488092899323,
-0.33241531252861023,
-0.4407069981098175,
0.07002799212932587,
0.04434897378087044,
0.28780943155288696,
0.09250492602586746,
0.0651293694972992,
-0.24515178799629211,
-0.4586762487888336,
0.6487588286399841,
-0.21582363545894623,
0.7176534533500671,
0.3695032298564911,
-0.0742298811674118,
0.06831526011228561,
-0.906236469745636,
0.1109878346323967,
0.06741797924041748,
-0.4560021460056305,
-0.5203878879547119,
-0.0005628211074508727,
0.30866703391075134,
0.3107577860355377,
0.43900617957115173,
-0.4126169681549072,
0.3338172435760498,
0.027636133134365082,
0.3464455306529999,
0.10538738965988159,
-0.2304997742176056,
0.6867089867591858,
-0.15315388143062592,
0.7883437275886536,
0.42698559165000916,
0.10781043767929077,
-0.008121645078063011,
-0.48064953088760376,
-0.5127354264259338,
-0.15411004424095154,
0.31927892565727234,
0.7210010290145874,
-0.9256591200828552,
-0.11340129375457764,
-0.002300923690199852,
-0.18206092715263367,
-0.5277443528175354,
0.054823752492666245,
0.4114331603050232,
-0.078559011220932,
0.5041030049324036,
-0.2924618124961853,
-0.4370492100715637,
-0.7942646741867065,
-0.6470142006874084,
-0.05029607191681862,
-0.04675585404038429,
0.17368419468402863,
0.4147712290287018,
-0.6329870820045471,
1.1178356409072876,
-0.45065611600875854,
0.25144821405410767,
-0.381697416305542,
0.5462571382522583,
0.1553904265165329,
0.5276943445205688,
0.42039015889167786,
-1.1491142511367798,
-0.24089139699935913,
0.018972773104906082,
-0.35906025767326355,
-0.3846766948699951,
-0.7200210690498352,
-0.06847427040338516,
0.001059740548953414,
0.7906903028488159,
-0.3498954176902771,
0.384575217962265,
0.9296729564666748,
-0.24778933823108673,
0.808367133140564,
-0.2964504063129425,
0.14055900275707245,
-0.8418662548065186,
0.08691408485174179,
-0.21438923478126526,
-0.25975048542022705,
-0.7449891567230225,
0.19954542815685272,
0.7364447116851807,
-0.026737825945019722,
-0.5482267141342163,
0.2450886070728302,
-0.8190063238143921,
-0.3813607692718506,
-0.30825790762901306,
-0.09658748656511307,
-0.03186764940619469,
0.49138399958610535,
0.2636512517929077,
0.7862429022789001,
0.2811894714832306,
-0.7493847608566284,
-0.09289350360631943,
0.18310900032520294,
-0.16904032230377197,
0.08622536063194275,
-0.4037603437900543,
0.4638555943965912,
0.13533006608486176,
0.16502320766448975,
-0.9257215857505798,
0.08371013402938843,
0.03490106388926506,
-0.41415390372276306,
0.2683234214782715,
-0.3693527579307556,
-0.6823931932449341,
-0.23462587594985962,
0.03457072749733925,
0.9397554993629456,
0.16838538646697998,
-0.46942028403282166,
0.5328922867774963,
0.2739376425743103,
0.03489484637975693,
-0.2842102348804474,
-0.9774368405342102,
0.08545342087745667,
-0.040729790925979614,
-0.4146295189857483,
0.4341011941432953,
-0.20787718892097473,
-0.16561661660671234,
-0.022601893171668053,
-0.10261499136686325,
-0.6321553587913513,
-0.042376939207315445,
-0.01842067390680313,
0.468671053647995,
-0.3033806383609772,
-0.17207208275794983,
-0.13411693274974823,
0.12637197971343994,
0.15141381323337555,
-0.3558277487754822,
0.8576312065124512,
-0.38736429810523987,
-0.42429158091545105,
-0.009924445301294327,
0.33481332659721375,
0.4421079754829407,
-0.7081573009490967,
0.6001233458518982,
0.3147623538970947,
-0.15749935805797577,
-0.20625582337379456,
-0.29862141609191895,
0.09698498249053955,
-0.453995943069458,
0.4240931272506714,
-0.538949191570282,
-1.0360277891159058,
0.7997390031814575,
-0.10914469510316849,
-0.09300940483808517,
0.1581488400697708,
0.4729306697845459,
0.09737692028284073,
1.0709218978881836,
0.959192156791687,
0.16529002785682678,
0.4963785707950592,
-0.120665542781353,
0.33264219760894775,
-0.37534987926483154,
-0.008713372983038425,
-0.5785718560218811,
-0.054293788969516754,
-0.793846070766449,
-0.7635223865509033,
0.20791137218475342,
0.24199235439300537,
0.10592436790466309,
0.41708120703697205,
-0.3406122922897339,
0.6159963011741638,
0.21014882624149323,
0.1929323822259903,
0.406911164522171,
-0.18098191916942596,
-0.32054403424263,
0.056568559259176254,
-0.680273711681366,
-0.39751189947128296,
1.1077425479888916,
0.38288164138793945,
0.8499986529350281,
-0.2628293037414551,
0.8234094977378845,
0.05901561304926872,
0.1895146667957306,
-0.4462849199771881,
0.5331351161003113,
-0.2503867745399475,
-0.5927135944366455,
0.1502397656440735,
-0.6745121479034424,
-0.9078706502914429,
0.18827605247497559,
0.10408536344766617,
-0.08033949136734009,
0.3736203908920288,
0.06512434780597687,
-0.15980415046215057,
0.4729466140270233,
-0.9089329838752747,
0.7431302070617676,
-0.4862443208694458,
-0.31139591336250305,
-0.2735668420791626,
-0.7754231691360474,
0.32740965485572815,
-0.33367717266082764,
0.32614800333976746,
0.39197245240211487,
-0.13889248669147491,
0.579197347164154,
-0.03462377190589905,
0.9998193383216858,
0.1551361232995987,
-0.3848338723182678,
0.11418639123439789,
0.4094081223011017,
0.07031288743019104,
0.0356554314494133,
0.2138144075870514,
0.42840689420700073,
0.08109505474567413,
-0.5407469868659973,
-0.27714869379997253,
0.4187641739845276,
-0.8463524580001831,
-0.22464293241500854,
-0.49464818835258484,
-0.6928849816322327,
-0.38028085231781006,
0.3963060677051544,
0.37186360359191895,
0.43865275382995605,
-0.23773989081382751,
-0.10844990611076355,
0.8527116775512695,
-0.6378880143165588,
0.18190811574459076,
0.941665768623352,
-0.598020076751709,
-0.009110621176660061,
0.7524811029434204,
-0.05141844227910042,
0.5159332752227783,
0.6056503653526306,
-0.1770247220993042,
-0.008080563507974148,
-0.5254433155059814,
-0.3712897300720215,
0.3322107791900635,
-0.5302114486694336,
0.013561049476265907,
-0.6746435165405273,
-0.32971706986427307,
-0.18261535465717316,
-0.27499303221702576,
-0.47665873169898987,
-0.10960109531879425,
-0.5169439911842346,
0.045002736151218414,
0.10016040503978729,
0.8710815906524658,
-0.03098958544433117,
0.23900152742862701,
-0.989761471748352,
0.46171554923057556,
0.09703585505485535,
0.6561574339866638,
-0.6433081030845642,
-0.33643463253974915,
-0.3629871904850006,
0.14004004001617432,
0.17230254411697388,
-1.2549163103103638,
0.3797222971916199,
-0.1419306993484497,
0.5485603213310242,
0.18126344680786133,
-0.21886615455150604,
0.1819387674331665,
-0.3520602583885193,
0.5794396996498108,
0.09251818060874939,
-1.0360676050186157,
0.27112728357315063,
-0.7043126225471497,
0.635491669178009,
0.5837500095367432,
0.3517075181007385,
-0.5980575084686279,
-0.5125489234924316,
-0.32702702283859253,
-0.5006710886955261,
0.6809618473052979,
0.24318425357341766,
0.04230060055851936,
-0.1439133584499359,
0.1087348610162735,
0.20196746289730072,
0.2248498648405075,
-1.0600942373275757,
-0.04389875382184982,
-0.4178353250026703,
-0.04819261282682419,
-0.07142458856105804,
-0.25425684452056885,
0.023544637486338615,
-0.10283838212490082,
-0.0690431222319603,
-0.07653472572565079,
0.35560905933380127,
0.012325683608651161,
-0.48028460144996643,
0.28709280490875244,
0.37501516938209534,
0.6135013699531555,
0.530141294002533,
-0.2791166305541992,
0.45797431468963623,
-0.12148264795541763,
-0.6414005160331726,
0.04690397158265114,
0.08146265149116516,
-0.04908398538827896,
0.21209515631198883,
0.28374233841896057,
0.6217251420021057,
0.46522289514541626,
-0.49520882964134216,
0.487089604139328,
-0.058494932949543,
-0.21094416081905365,
0.11254364997148514,
-0.194374218583107,
0.13750070333480835,
-0.19311241805553436,
0.014636707492172718,
0.4602089524269104,
-0.011658442206680775,
-0.5211918950080872,
0.32959672808647156,
0.1720864176750183,
0.053545642644166946,
-0.4219970703125,
0.5484660863876343,
0.3977079391479492,
-0.19241297245025635,
0.5400814414024353,
-0.16991053521633148,
-0.7111077308654785,
0.6595677137374878,
0.7281960248947144,
0.7972469925880432,
-0.17400871217250824,
0.4898820221424103,
-0.08121538907289505,
0.4773312509059906,
-0.12854444980621338,
0.3852318525314331,
-0.13996757566928864,
-1.1092156171798706,
-0.28697967529296875,
-0.3730120062828064,
-0.2878594696521759,
0.10044402629137039,
-0.9929227232933044,
0.36799684166908264,
-0.45961037278175354,
0.018777159973978996,
-0.4180183410644531,
-0.30063116550445557,
-0.9964979290962219,
0.2080298513174057,
0.4166174530982971,
1.0741214752197266,
-0.8641951084136963,
1.1600152254104614,
0.7431650161743164,
-0.2957199811935425,
-0.648877739906311,
0.25172293186187744,
-0.28052809834480286,
-0.9197268486022949,
0.6347773671150208,
0.1579274833202362,
-0.4138447940349579,
0.056564755737781525,
-0.7767163515090942,
-0.7941124439239502,
0.4894385039806366,
0.14154815673828125,
-0.5661385655403137,
0.02084212377667427,
0.6310542821884155,
0.7012912631034851,
-0.44375079870224,
0.307336688041687,
0.8219445943832397,
0.08859502524137497,
-0.42767301201820374,
-1.038275122642517,
-0.34373602271080017,
-0.5303385257720947,
-0.015348894521594048,
0.2633656859397888,
-0.4831331968307495,
1.1517311334609985,
-0.044518325477838516,
-0.3015553057193756,
-0.07172432541847229,
0.40265968441963196,
0.16542398929595947,
0.27697691321372986,
0.5165736675262451,
0.3472549617290497,
0.5148519277572632,
0.2544625997543335,
1.1282094717025757,
-0.5771498680114746,
0.24530045688152313,
1.1256052255630493,
-0.5404999852180481,
0.8067004084587097,
0.3788088858127594,
-0.07909370958805084,
0.6454399824142456,
0.5053467750549316,
0.056564249098300934,
0.5564286708831787,
0.1726667582988739,
-0.06614156812429428,
-0.294181227684021,
0.34941211342811584,
-0.6186510920524597,
0.5240164995193481,
0.3860557973384857,
-0.25648415088653564,
-0.2144356071949005,
0.12872405350208282,
0.06951508671045303,
0.11921676248311996,
-0.11101081222295761,
0.47860825061798096,
-0.13907301425933838,
-0.5365908145904541,
0.7055007815361023,
0.15415224432945251,
0.9169420599937439,
-0.8410782217979431,
0.060133468359708786,
-0.40962255001068115,
0.1833355575799942,
-0.15164972841739655,
-0.7088868618011475,
0.2286418229341507,
0.09357337653636932,
-0.27307724952697754,
-0.8166688680648804,
0.6072083711624146,
-0.6274557709693909,
-0.4655883312225342,
0.6171483993530273,
0.3996330797672272,
0.0687730461359024,
-0.0309811532497406,
-0.5026111006736755,
0.26411259174346924,
0.19435802102088928,
0.06868214905261993,
0.4146040380001068,
0.451761394739151,
-0.12932132184505463,
0.2402258664369583,
0.5259934663772583,
0.1494041532278061,
0.45774391293525696,
0.19666272401809692,
0.954330563545227,
-0.6684533357620239,
-0.8143340349197388,
-0.5029252767562866,
0.31388741731643677,
0.08039528876543045,
-0.5733271241188049,
0.8167297840118408,
0.828596830368042,
1.1780116558074951,
-0.3317551016807556,
0.806003987789154,
0.4200987219810486,
0.4687420725822449,
-0.7912502288818359,
0.708792507648468,
-0.30352547764778137,
0.4339766502380371,
-0.19589215517044067,
-0.5895286798477173,
-0.27230891585350037,
0.41765427589416504,
-0.5265849232673645,
0.057507045567035675,
0.853278398513794,
0.8434332609176636,
-0.3669899106025696,
0.05061279237270355,
0.15065708756446838,
0.3004567325115204,
0.27587980031967163,
0.5551978945732117,
0.9533023834228516,
-0.1008557602763176,
0.590197741985321,
0.05108979716897011,
-0.37789037823677063,
-0.22301806509494781,
-0.6634860038757324,
-0.9151660799980164,
-0.5467507243156433,
-0.2817840874195099,
-0.2777743339538574,
-0.13830658793449402,
0.33990678191185,
0.6431864500045776,
-0.7255558967590332,
-0.5157101154327393,
-0.3523869216442108,
-0.18720407783985138,
-0.02499415911734104,
-0.1929071545600891,
-0.16899244487285614,
-0.3471106290817261,
-0.3530966341495514,
0.35263901948928833,
0.10424300283193588,
0.1471795290708542,
-0.2133125513792038,
0.09518980979919434,
-0.22743773460388184,
0.21095627546310425,
0.3406786322593689,
0.26620906591415405,
-0.3469390869140625,
0.10154665261507034,
0.3466636836528778,
-0.6900987029075623,
-0.09833388775587082,
1.613811731338501,
-0.8542190790176392,
0.35747286677360535,
0.612183690071106,
0.7702651619911194,
0.6212678551673889,
-0.28731632232666016,
0.8334117531776428,
-0.864676296710968,
0.4651271402835846,
0.23901644349098206,
0.2403332144021988,
0.283762127161026,
-0.39059287309646606,
0.3122045695781708,
0.3182414770126343,
-0.3980391025543213,
-0.6907488703727722,
0.4160071909427643,
-0.9389995336532593,
-0.6207509636878967,
1.3896358013153076,
0.004666015040129423,
0.06002572178840637,
-0.26234766840934753,
-0.21949346363544464,
0.2557709217071533,
0.21700479090213776,
0.642980694770813,
0.7809241414070129,
0.0483444482088089,
-0.12453633546829224,
-0.531906247138977,
0.6176034808158875,
0.725344717502594,
-0.8170074820518494,
-0.13882805407047272,
0.5195897221565247,
0.277720183134079,
0.13541051745414734,
0.7671235203742981,
-0.24356749653816223,
0.23909620940685272,
-0.1334308534860611,
0.17302386462688446,
0.13368090987205505,
-0.4860328435897827,
-0.5485614538192749,
0.06930851191282272,
-0.32404330372810364,
-0.40536919236183167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04858v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04858v1
|
Evaluating Biases in Context-Dependent Health Questions
| 2024-03-07T19:15:40 | 2024-03-07T19:15:40 |
Sharon Levy, Tahilin Sanchez Karver, William D. Adler, Michelle R. Kaufman, Mark Dredze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chat-based large language models have the opportunity to empower individuals
lacking high-quality healthcare access to receive personalized information
across a variety of topics. However, users may ask underspecified questions
that require additional context for a model to correctly answer. We study how
large language model biases are exhibited through these contextual questions in
the healthcare domain. To accomplish this, we curate a dataset of sexual and
reproductive healthcare questions that are dependent on age, sex, and location
attributes. We compare models' outputs with and without demographic context to
determine group alignment among our contextual questions. Our experiments
reveal biases in each of these attributes, where young adult female users are
favored.
|
[
-0.13399061560630798,
-0.9127144813537598,
0.6521438360214233,
0.1381484568119049,
0.17153973877429962,
-0.44143906235694885,
-0.010355712845921516,
-0.6473898887634277,
0.07132626324892044,
0.6371749043464661,
-0.7086982727050781,
-0.20750562846660614,
-0.5128446817398071,
-0.13056442141532898,
0.02651320956647396,
0.9518114924430847,
0.21783792972564697,
0.4094381034374237,
-0.4542875289916992,
-0.3169359862804413,
-0.9269204139709473,
-0.6151139140129089,
-0.4233890175819397,
-0.2871694266796112,
0.4072394371032715,
0.394052654504776,
0.7731566429138184,
0.2321612536907196,
0.38723254203796387,
0.2179740071296692,
-0.255410373210907,
-0.12592481076717377,
-0.5364843606948853,
0.41293418407440186,
-0.4277995526790619,
-0.4423843026161194,
-0.3436615765094757,
0.039841752499341965,
0.4065712094306946,
1.1248371601104736,
-0.027246026322245598,
0.3309493064880371,
-0.17510229349136353,
0.47417476773262024,
-0.7889640927314758,
-0.22018250823020935,
-0.6275392770767212,
-0.009695691056549549,
-0.15752799808979034,
-0.3093934953212738,
-0.20204485952854156,
-0.13157613575458527,
0.7347749471664429,
-0.04148678481578827,
0.22855216264724731,
0.03825236111879349,
0.5982118844985962,
0.1701509803533554,
-1.1991370916366577,
-0.278624027967453,
-0.776674747467041,
0.686724066734314,
-0.624323844909668,
0.6246488690376282,
0.6903166174888611,
0.03749111294746399,
-0.1736091822385788,
-0.4352717697620392,
-0.027356518432497978,
-0.14572937786579132,
-0.5785635709762573,
-0.07728694379329681,
-0.3008299171924591,
-0.11981236934661865,
0.30248522758483887,
0.1932777613401413,
-0.5414613485336304,
0.10304589569568634,
-0.508115291595459,
-0.05803766846656799,
0.5969053506851196,
0.14813320338726044,
0.8397189974784851,
-0.4817003607749939,
-0.21056237816810608,
0.28989744186401367,
-0.699517548084259,
0.23574739694595337,
0.20477195084095,
0.26086917519569397,
-0.2156335711479187,
0.6537365913391113,
-0.1009209007024765,
0.5033533573150635,
0.3583785593509674,
-0.0688387006521225,
0.12101978808641434,
-0.3079890310764313,
-0.09706533700227737,
-0.020874248817563057,
0.6174299120903015,
0.5377134084701538,
-0.07084531337022781,
-0.011000532656908035,
0.046784475445747375,
-0.17085561156272888,
0.42573678493499756,
-0.8064063787460327,
0.19541697204113007,
0.6043670177459717,
-0.5690182447433472,
0.1142706498503685,
-0.2029675990343094,
-0.7259886264801025,
-0.6032862663269043,
-0.23112070560455322,
0.20474635064601898,
-0.03859493508934975,
-0.03618069738149643,
-0.13280197978019714,
-0.09842424839735031,
-0.03672000393271446,
0.3906591534614563,
-1.1638283729553223,
0.12292928248643875,
0.40971365571022034,
0.3464335799217224,
-0.21140743792057037,
0.20812064409255981,
-0.555156409740448,
-0.010490655899047852,
-0.20259179174900055,
0.6661561131477356,
-0.5984752178192139,
-0.5578485131263733,
0.09683175384998322,
0.3198045790195465,
-0.14266371726989746,
-0.601955235004425,
0.509922981262207,
-0.5323008894920349,
0.7114292979240417,
-0.9220981597900391,
-0.5596144795417786,
0.12246248126029968,
0.24228215217590332,
-0.3391519784927368,
0.5858256816864014,
0.14749793708324432,
-1.2638037204742432,
0.7360027432441711,
-0.5589755177497864,
-0.4035424590110779,
0.2322760969400406,
-0.5357064604759216,
-0.2513062059879303,
-0.048363447189331055,
0.5357146859169006,
0.37236157059669495,
-0.27025729417800903,
0.3644023537635803,
-0.3639410138130188,
0.04191795736551285,
0.5356694459915161,
-0.4691739082336426,
0.9085891246795654,
0.07571639865636826,
-0.3826705515384674,
0.36944517493247986,
-0.6138405203819275,
-0.03321610763669014,
-0.04633462429046631,
-0.12072742730379105,
-0.848327100276947,
0.33321481943130493,
0.133866548538208,
0.1610560119152069,
0.25783538818359375,
-0.49071037769317627,
0.09958891570568085,
-0.35405904054641724,
0.46739545464515686,
0.48407232761383057,
0.32368987798690796,
0.5250685214996338,
-0.31522268056869507,
0.49898964166641235,
0.10542075335979462,
0.39524707198143005,
0.045302968472242355,
-0.6111753582954407,
-0.26777276396751404,
0.09711181372404099,
-0.10915856063365936,
0.33915168046951294,
-0.4199821352958679,
0.20578691363334656,
-0.1347377449274063,
-0.2294946163892746,
-0.1505330204963684,
0.09130843728780746,
0.2414739727973938,
0.6046406626701355,
0.40914756059646606,
-0.2627648115158081,
-0.40098851919174194,
-1.1549206972122192,
-0.020363572984933853,
-0.26180675625801086,
-0.12413828819990158,
0.8553029298782349,
0.5895279049873352,
-0.4864348769187927,
0.9326112270355225,
-0.6068540215492249,
-0.06935812532901764,
-0.0851416140794754,
-0.03441343829035759,
-0.21543024480342865,
0.5589030981063843,
0.5863987803459167,
-1.0850251913070679,
-0.1570386290550232,
-0.17877086997032166,
-0.6086682081222534,
-0.3377622961997986,
0.1971520185470581,
-0.3614722490310669,
-0.08561085909605026,
0.2273954153060913,
-0.5218372344970703,
0.357831209897995,
0.8482167720794678,
-0.7109137773513794,
0.47952115535736084,
-0.12819607555866241,
0.2934313416481018,
-1.0268949270248413,
0.4122028946876526,
-0.0379507802426815,
0.021664606407284737,
-0.9357162714004517,
-0.002792712301015854,
0.008861254900693893,
-0.018693692982196808,
-0.5492845773696899,
0.7735989093780518,
-0.3424214720726013,
-0.19138653576374054,
-0.1797691434621811,
-0.27721527218818665,
0.08250465989112854,
-0.08454453200101852,
0.11907234787940979,
0.8708115220069885,
0.2077026218175888,
-0.4319876730442047,
-0.1319853514432907,
0.44749823212623596,
-0.21149133145809174,
0.7139965295791626,
-0.8762949705123901,
0.38095033168792725,
-0.15082180500030518,
0.5538136959075928,
-0.8060916066169739,
-0.6982187628746033,
0.07416163384914398,
-0.38733354210853577,
-0.13726289570331573,
-0.3387463092803955,
0.09059721231460571,
-0.422509104013443,
0.0500553697347641,
0.7733443975448608,
0.3350900113582611,
-0.14504757523536682,
0.29171615839004517,
0.7990427017211914,
-0.062494874000549316,
-0.8428484201431274,
-0.5071503520011902,
-0.3557470738887787,
-0.2706156075000763,
-0.6351430416107178,
0.19345837831497192,
-0.021982084959745407,
-0.6982176303863525,
-0.030690781772136688,
-0.06339753419160843,
-0.29726240038871765,
-0.028950423002243042,
0.46367180347442627,
0.19931551814079285,
-0.20304584503173828,
0.4135478436946869,
0.011375227011740208,
0.5036754012107849,
0.09072121232748032,
-0.2499077022075653,
0.6367053985595703,
0.033033695071935654,
-0.43784525990486145,
-0.18813686072826385,
0.7464917302131653,
0.6227143406867981,
-0.2623745799064636,
0.9935914874076843,
0.14282572269439697,
-0.5336849093437195,
0.10272829979658127,
-0.6741935014724731,
-0.36051511764526367,
-0.4222535192966461,
0.2850157618522644,
0.11574540287256241,
-1.3177672624588013,
0.8362421989440918,
0.5961396098136902,
0.10947196930646896,
0.3493204414844513,
0.8632772564888,
-0.12232764810323715,
1.3488439321517944,
0.42147159576416016,
0.15796807408332825,
0.2575145661830902,
0.11489780992269516,
-0.1005404144525528,
-0.642738938331604,
-0.15109948813915253,
-0.549078643321991,
-0.29729220271110535,
-0.7418203353881836,
-0.3531447947025299,
0.4349796772003174,
-0.2091854214668274,
-0.2921317219734192,
0.010461513884365559,
-0.4143792986869812,
0.05969332903623581,
0.5042423605918884,
0.43223801255226135,
0.044833119958639145,
-0.7013719081878662,
0.06146343797445297,
-0.18905305862426758,
-0.7173975706100464,
-0.353942334651947,
1.0372474193572998,
0.49304378032684326,
0.8222736120223999,
0.0395137295126915,
0.005451451055705547,
0.22940124571323395,
0.35283124446868896,
-0.6138601899147034,
0.12294378876686096,
-0.17148657143115997,
-1.318361759185791,
-0.4095669090747833,
-0.5789040327072144,
-1.3159065246582031,
0.3608432412147522,
-0.2769618630409241,
-1.0493817329406738,
0.5906851291656494,
0.33666184544563293,
-0.46774327754974365,
0.01979697123169899,
-0.6785110235214233,
0.8575206398963928,
-0.24843111634254456,
-0.3560207784175873,
0.21547478437423706,
-0.8049230575561523,
0.5161905288696289,
0.13686320185661316,
0.2573203444480896,
-0.3550526797771454,
0.2958085834980011,
0.7474220991134644,
-0.5142678022384644,
0.7101673483848572,
-0.08955325186252594,
-0.2551911175251007,
0.12427879124879837,
-0.18470807373523712,
-0.13110579550266266,
0.31500890851020813,
0.09756423532962799,
0.0436980240046978,
0.2625410258769989,
-0.38282376527786255,
-0.5635998249053955,
0.7832120060920715,
-0.8631200790405273,
-0.910737931728363,
-0.2506786584854126,
-0.6636464595794678,
-0.42951521277427673,
0.3126601278781891,
0.17311567068099976,
0.6997396945953369,
-0.22376029193401337,
0.3031562566757202,
0.4684779644012451,
-0.7213206887245178,
-0.16912752389907837,
0.46158427000045776,
-0.3925662338733673,
-0.00250555039383471,
-0.0665535032749176,
0.18940865993499756,
0.48739832639694214,
0.22289015352725983,
0.5339542627334595,
-0.3402393162250519,
-0.0014954993966966867,
-0.5106902718544006,
0.20939767360687256,
-0.7959239482879639,
0.06603983044624329,
-0.8309749960899353,
-0.40993431210517883,
-0.6197612285614014,
-0.027805818244814873,
-0.2781989574432373,
0.09539185464382172,
-0.2446349710226059,
0.06001245975494385,
0.10366696119308472,
0.6494258046150208,
0.5008644461631775,
0.15562716126441956,
-0.8574683666229248,
0.0721534863114357,
0.8423888683319092,
0.06199932098388672,
-0.08197528123855591,
-0.2383783906698227,
0.07834374159574509,
0.12827834486961365,
-0.26465776562690735,
-1.0966012477874756,
0.10330667346715927,
-0.14129644632339478,
0.5202650427818298,
0.5362173914909363,
0.15870019793510437,
0.3396322727203369,
-0.5537722110748291,
1.0115957260131836,
0.007897225208580494,
-0.8878095149993896,
0.7129914164543152,
-0.6451711058616638,
0.5382044315338135,
0.5801137685775757,
0.5606456995010376,
-0.821098804473877,
-0.13143177330493927,
-0.5384036898612976,
-0.6059861183166504,
0.3867095708847046,
0.1598653495311737,
0.33861595392227173,
-0.19882173836231232,
0.4174882769584656,
0.06376782059669495,
0.07546262443065643,
-0.7229362726211548,
-0.29380565881729126,
0.11647440493106842,
0.21000008285045624,
0.3089286983013153,
-0.5413087010383606,
-0.35556912422180176,
-0.2473069727420807,
0.1847214549779892,
-0.11920410394668579,
0.20528848469257355,
0.2741229832172394,
0.17116671800613403,
-0.40087535977363586,
0.7273565530776978,
0.7166890501976013,
1.0632418394088745,
-0.3206407427787781,
0.22313469648361206,
0.41245049238204956,
-0.4279399812221527,
0.20992715656757355,
-0.25247204303741455,
-0.42256882786750793,
-0.03785684332251549,
0.5193766355514526,
0.9459473490715027,
0.3654933273792267,
-0.6860724687576294,
0.7852931618690491,
-0.14581884443759918,
-0.016909772530198097,
-0.07218535244464874,
-0.1340647041797638,
0.17578551173210144,
-0.03907902166247368,
0.2991190254688263,
-0.20323212444782257,
0.20693345367908478,
-0.9096559882164001,
0.22622588276863098,
0.7188770771026611,
-0.7304156422615051,
-0.2621143162250519,
0.9001870155334473,
0.12396767735481262,
-0.21416336297988892,
0.5044565796852112,
0.6045398712158203,
-0.6653051376342773,
0.4258004426956177,
0.5544173121452332,
0.4805371165275574,
-0.417982816696167,
0.0060586873441934586,
0.30549201369285583,
0.16221393644809723,
0.14923584461212158,
0.28467315435409546,
0.26599085330963135,
-0.9555274844169617,
-0.38195762038230896,
-0.25645962357521057,
-0.4631407558917999,
0.23444044589996338,
-0.7557795643806458,
0.2697853446006775,
-0.20934073626995087,
-0.7763309478759766,
0.10107135772705078,
-0.17826063930988312,
-0.8010181188583374,
0.6474769711494446,
0.04739179462194443,
0.5928263068199158,
-0.8639158606529236,
0.5387321710586548,
0.8778154850006104,
-0.28134050965309143,
-0.6252228021621704,
0.32691115140914917,
0.06121954694390297,
-0.7021180391311646,
0.7778550982475281,
0.12564681470394135,
0.2351071685552597,
-0.6970008015632629,
-0.7464617490768433,
-0.9651615023612976,
0.6611312031745911,
0.24694135785102844,
-0.22166383266448975,
-0.29387521743774414,
0.03759157657623291,
0.6868096590042114,
-0.26695263385772705,
0.5579331517219543,
0.48190292716026306,
0.252819299697876,
0.018372448161244392,
-1.260527491569519,
-0.0972762182354927,
-0.14699921011924744,
0.04391094297170639,
0.033744875341653824,
-0.5172990560531616,
0.9968703389167786,
-0.045484669506549835,
-0.16397206485271454,
-0.24247877299785614,
0.4230751097202301,
0.1914297342300415,
0.2985534369945526,
0.7935895323753357,
0.17154741287231445,
0.6455584764480591,
-0.024873992428183556,
1.1696219444274902,
-0.22375933825969696,
0.23047484457492828,
1.2168629169464111,
-0.2815524935722351,
0.7131615281105042,
0.3823367655277252,
-0.0248106699436903,
0.490962952375412,
0.535653829574585,
0.4403946101665497,
0.19009491801261902,
0.14117400348186493,
-0.19252701103687286,
-0.009749041870236397,
-0.49881288409233093,
-0.6667860150337219,
0.7750173211097717,
0.3911300301551819,
-0.630772054195404,
0.037763722240924835,
0.16915279626846313,
0.27570009231567383,
-0.12451134622097015,
-0.03241855278611183,
0.723491907119751,
0.14172083139419556,
-0.8009684085845947,
0.1417052149772644,
-0.13998737931251526,
0.46395155787467957,
-0.7287744879722595,
0.2261340469121933,
-0.22294314205646515,
0.0020761373452842236,
-0.3067038059234619,
-0.6411599516868591,
0.22932001948356628,
0.009894796647131443,
-0.29995983839035034,
-0.12994615733623505,
0.8672032952308655,
-0.4792407751083374,
-0.49039268493652344,
0.14650818705558777,
0.728815495967865,
-0.06012139469385147,
0.18336276710033417,
-0.6931951642036438,
0.034654922783374786,
-0.23182816803455353,
-0.19460652768611908,
0.3491947650909424,
0.26049554347991943,
-0.39067864418029785,
0.7681158781051636,
0.6403650045394897,
0.2687883675098419,
-0.21973669528961182,
0.1843775510787964,
0.5606055855751038,
-0.26652950048446655,
-0.47447702288627625,
-0.8270060420036316,
0.4550302028656006,
-0.14351187646389008,
-0.6374634504318237,
1.0507025718688965,
0.1475658416748047,
0.4989810883998871,
0.1617237776517868,
0.5798879265785217,
-0.03894525393843651,
0.5648358464241028,
-0.3086695373058319,
0.9771072864532471,
-0.7628464102745056,
0.18556366860866547,
-0.4645894765853882,
-0.6549103260040283,
-0.16425980627536774,
0.4160766303539276,
-0.7589133977890015,
0.24247203767299652,
0.5514585971832275,
0.41479161381721497,
0.08132007718086243,
0.16940005123615265,
0.2639133930206299,
0.007015880197286606,
0.4967213571071625,
0.37283027172088623,
0.8720857501029968,
-0.18837860226631165,
-0.28588831424713135,
-0.2613776922225952,
-0.27348828315734863,
-0.13312698900699615,
-0.7745848298072815,
-0.8833287358283997,
-0.49546998739242554,
-0.24809478223323822,
-0.3651754856109619,
-0.011376156471669674,
1.2632696628570557,
0.9305516481399536,
-1.065050482749939,
-0.0062554627656936646,
0.4262392818927765,
0.10613290965557098,
0.22807729244232178,
-0.2556600570678711,
0.42870989441871643,
0.029348265379667282,
-0.6449388861656189,
0.13704419136047363,
0.02929028868675232,
-0.00825442373752594,
-0.554806113243103,
0.4503857493400574,
-0.23361636698246002,
0.15645776689052582,
0.37356868386268616,
0.04767509922385216,
-0.6530834436416626,
-0.5721014738082886,
0.246314138174057,
-0.3055407702922821,
0.1380685418844223,
0.9305861592292786,
-0.21023330092430115,
0.40269410610198975,
0.5311486124992371,
0.47571656107902527,
-0.014375247061252594,
0.4289935529232025,
0.8522926568984985,
-0.6111024022102356,
0.20254658162593842,
0.3969332277774811,
0.5315255522727966,
0.5189341306686401,
-0.7318171262741089,
0.17535331845283508,
0.1355263590812683,
-0.9346053600311279,
-0.58750319480896,
0.025244401767849922,
-0.7934519052505493,
-0.3281486928462982,
1.4675347805023193,
-0.043255724012851715,
0.10704096406698227,
-0.18779927492141724,
-0.4274424910545349,
-0.07629115879535675,
-0.19187217950820923,
0.7710707187652588,
0.7545956373214722,
-0.1540975421667099,
-0.1340382695198059,
-0.8494857549667358,
0.5222757458686829,
0.5551134943962097,
-0.9296769499778748,
-0.09410880506038666,
0.7322859764099121,
0.4485244154930115,
-0.1132412999868393,
0.9374803304672241,
-0.03251566365361214,
0.13610753417015076,
-0.3509839177131653,
-0.20546327531337738,
0.6823617815971375,
0.028869610279798508,
0.030719565227627754,
0.2494153529405594,
-0.17529445886611938,
0.19157488644123077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04746v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04746v1
|
LLMs in the Imaginarium: Tool Learning through Simulated Trial and Error
| 2024-03-07T18:50:51 | 2024-03-07T18:50:51 |
Boshi Wang, Hao Fang, Jason Eisner, Benjamin Van Durme, Yu Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Tools are essential for large language models (LLMs) to acquire up-to-date
information and take consequential actions in external environments. Existing
work on tool-augmented LLMs primarily focuses on the broad coverage of tools
and the flexibility of adding new tools. However, a critical aspect that has
surprisingly been understudied is simply how accurately an LLM uses tools for
which it has been trained. We find that existing LLMs, including GPT-4 and
open-source LLMs specifically fine-tuned for tool use, only reach a correctness
rate in the range of 30% to 60%, far from reliable use in practice. We propose
a biologically inspired method for tool-augmented LLMs, simulated trial and
error (STE), that orchestrates three key mechanisms for successful tool use
behaviors in the biological system: trial and error, imagination, and memory.
Specifically, STE leverages an LLM's 'imagination' to simulate plausible
scenarios for using a tool, after which the LLM interacts with the tool to
learn from its execution feedback. Both short-term and long-term memory are
employed to improve the depth and breadth of the exploration, respectively.
Comprehensive experiments on ToolBench show that STE substantially improves
tool learning for LLMs under both in-context learning and fine-tuning settings,
bringing a boost of 46.7% to Mistral-Instruct-7B and enabling it to outperform
GPT-4. We also show effective continual learning of tools via a simple
experience replay strategy.
|
[
-0.0847243145108223,
-1.015614628791809,
0.6875101327896118,
0.2963677942752838,
-0.39491263031959534,
0.6865288615226746,
-0.2542329430580139,
-0.3312828540802002,
0.04480976611375809,
-0.028658412396907806,
-0.5646307468414307,
-0.4945582151412964,
-0.4457440674304962,
0.31927525997161865,
-0.24780742824077606,
0.6890539526939392,
-0.3376147150993347,
0.5835296511650085,
-0.24375614523887634,
-0.18611252307891846,
-0.3956076502799988,
-0.5667839646339417,
-0.7197033762931824,
-0.643543004989624,
0.7842490077018738,
0.2463214099407196,
0.40204519033432007,
0.6018189787864685,
0.5135554671287537,
0.20525313913822174,
0.011607041582465172,
0.24303047358989716,
-0.5924695730209351,
-0.10627725720405579,
-0.34095802903175354,
-0.8939833045005798,
-0.2542968690395355,
0.23834814131259918,
0.5422621369361877,
0.571809709072113,
-0.21912682056427002,
-0.14118923246860504,
0.36492040753364563,
0.009007178246974945,
-0.2552385926246643,
0.00394235597923398,
-0.7771155834197998,
0.1674046516418457,
-0.2804875075817108,
-0.5174617767333984,
-0.4364595413208008,
-0.4148368239402771,
-0.04050784558057785,
-0.7548388242721558,
0.09956304728984833,
0.21043862402439117,
0.425520658493042,
0.1293899118900299,
-0.1377144157886505,
-0.4868382513523102,
-0.8153787851333618,
0.7608008980751038,
-0.8419135212898254,
0.2998794615268707,
0.18194949626922607,
0.19128109514713287,
-0.6747360229492188,
-0.7037991285324097,
-0.496064692735672,
-0.3906807005405426,
0.1704590916633606,
0.1250651776790619,
0.0692431777715683,
0.23519621789455414,
0.5634850263595581,
0.10541786998510361,
-0.26585403084754944,
0.2273225039243698,
-0.5183617472648621,
-0.20863503217697144,
0.1741628795862198,
0.08434788882732391,
0.26067492365837097,
0.20066553354263306,
-0.27913692593574524,
-0.494682639837265,
-0.9148293137550354,
-0.04573656991124153,
0.31713834404945374,
0.14672157168388367,
0.0758657455444336,
0.659000813961029,
0.26670652627944946,
0.3137999475002289,
-0.26461148262023926,
-0.40788793563842773,
0.29357022047042847,
-0.11454051733016968,
-0.23122568428516388,
0.08601177483797073,
0.49396228790283203,
0.13576720654964447,
0.11970971524715424,
-0.5235461592674255,
-0.3823752999305725,
0.2583146095275879,
0.5975033640861511,
-0.7337723970413208,
-0.10291798412799835,
0.14225858449935913,
0.019437206909060478,
-0.30826449394226074,
-0.1307513266801834,
-0.6028018593788147,
-0.3587602972984314,
-0.3721425533294678,
0.8564444780349731,
-0.7205995321273804,
-0.13532115519046783,
0.06567351520061493,
-0.19400639832019806,
0.11525027453899384,
0.6773011684417725,
-0.25393110513687134,
0.4828419089317322,
0.6458156704902649,
1.2400908470153809,
-0.3375990390777588,
-0.6244987845420837,
-0.819929301738739,
0.1742372065782547,
-0.49052125215530396,
0.5925540924072266,
-0.32875630259513855,
-0.8022390007972717,
-0.1736464947462082,
0.09090409427881241,
0.0694260448217392,
-0.6503981351852417,
0.14358456432819366,
-0.3667490482330322,
0.11093439906835556,
-0.30730387568473816,
-0.7067040205001831,
-0.3393564820289612,
0.302036851644516,
-0.5092838406562805,
0.9114742875099182,
0.24497748911380768,
-0.5978289246559143,
0.5875968933105469,
-0.9004257321357727,
-0.27477461099624634,
-0.12621092796325684,
-0.3292832374572754,
-0.290861576795578,
0.3299218416213989,
-0.22536464035511017,
0.1770232617855072,
-0.1642078310251236,
0.12434998154640198,
-0.7998278737068176,
-0.7730657458305359,
0.3677278757095337,
-0.32402303814888,
0.6204301118850708,
0.012653549201786518,
-0.5762346386909485,
0.07595244795084,
-0.42428192496299744,
-0.1828630119562149,
0.11901821196079254,
-0.5088821053504944,
-0.35599833726882935,
-0.052517712116241455,
-0.22262191772460938,
0.03156563639640808,
-0.11026827991008759,
-0.9432803392410278,
0.346043199300766,
-0.6094369292259216,
0.30864670872688293,
0.8737619519233704,
0.0617733858525753,
0.25306326150894165,
-0.39432621002197266,
0.614598274230957,
0.255450963973999,
0.05725373327732086,
-0.03323545306921005,
-0.03133721649646759,
-0.6180569529533386,
0.041579730808734894,
0.5498608350753784,
0.7221357226371765,
-0.9581680297851562,
-0.10931608080863953,
-0.17827929556369781,
-0.5987470149993896,
-0.43847399950027466,
0.5165662169456482,
0.47059378027915955,
0.1423642486333847,
0.25195738673210144,
-0.6280327439308167,
-0.381018728017807,
-0.6184210777282715,
-0.36103856563568115,
-0.029290596023201942,
-0.04152683913707733,
0.37456047534942627,
0.4716942012310028,
-0.2901529371738434,
0.7984371185302734,
-0.14233525097370148,
-0.26587679982185364,
-0.180994912981987,
0.3813588619232178,
0.22636879980564117,
0.5732458829879761,
0.3465774655342102,
-0.40515613555908203,
-0.07878857105970383,
0.027217164635658264,
-0.7979828119277954,
-0.0006684510153718293,
-0.21038630604743958,
0.006460841745138168,
0.16789433360099792,
0.6837506294250488,
-0.497848778963089,
0.42456570267677307,
0.37586426734924316,
0.025210220366716385,
0.6325815916061401,
-0.6440748572349548,
-0.0496392548084259,
-0.8330578207969666,
0.014116242527961731,
0.004388556350022554,
-0.2550223767757416,
-0.2598392963409424,
-0.08804693073034286,
0.3111857771873474,
0.3939749598503113,
-0.6965600848197937,
0.8236756920814514,
-0.5232760310173035,
-0.18186573684215546,
-0.4143300950527191,
0.04264708608388901,
-0.2532544434070587,
0.5837114453315735,
-0.42567139863967896,
1.1934101581573486,
0.31922978162765503,
-0.5161451101303101,
0.26244378089904785,
-0.15705719590187073,
-0.2370145171880722,
0.49239614605903625,
-0.6816830635070801,
0.2890380918979645,
-0.016616173088550568,
0.12648247182369232,
-0.6883519291877747,
-0.3613872230052948,
0.2132294476032257,
-0.13847900927066803,
0.4185395836830139,
-0.0010432156268507242,
-1.1421674489974976,
-0.23240679502487183,
-0.2717531621456146,
0.2761300504207611,
0.6702648997306824,
-0.5608778595924377,
0.9326831102371216,
0.13678722083568573,
0.032458771020174026,
-0.45885077118873596,
-0.3834139108657837,
0.08173801004886627,
-0.4333571493625641,
-0.1627490222454071,
0.17131638526916504,
-0.3085571229457855,
-0.3980402648448944,
-0.10847284644842148,
-0.20724749565124512,
0.43151262402534485,
0.42311927676200867,
0.34669968485832214,
0.018717743456363678,
0.11625281721353531,
0.29580825567245483,
0.15625330805778503,
0.19386188685894012,
0.14815783500671387,
-0.12387078255414963,
0.7015695571899414,
-0.05447382107377052,
-0.8331534266471863,
-0.0358552485704422,
-0.018405433744192123,
0.5378302335739136,
0.22543098032474518,
0.3649810254573822,
0.4891716241836548,
-0.4215266704559326,
-0.3128491938114166,
-0.5684097409248352,
-0.6257566213607788,
-0.4960864782333374,
0.31679221987724304,
-0.38840052485466003,
-0.6025584936141968,
0.4187990128993988,
-0.7299938797950745,
0.5043469071388245,
-0.10361743718385696,
0.3494003117084503,
-0.46523022651672363,
0.9303539395332336,
0.6863536834716797,
0.13865375518798828,
0.3637531101703644,
-0.19232532382011414,
-0.07229054719209671,
-1.0740132331848145,
-0.06425825506448746,
-0.09053637832403183,
-0.5606066584587097,
-0.1687530279159546,
-0.708756685256958,
0.7287241220474243,
0.24308505654335022,
-0.018822744488716125,
0.10623881220817566,
-0.023781348019838333,
0.47516387701034546,
0.9208449125289917,
0.47416016459465027,
0.304243803024292,
0.0757138729095459,
-0.7863060832023621,
-0.15349631011486053,
-0.7678655982017517,
-0.5010071992874146,
1.3100383281707764,
0.34943851828575134,
0.9244816899299622,
-0.18407462537288666,
0.8382769823074341,
0.16572071611881256,
0.7629222869873047,
-0.688781201839447,
0.35798218846321106,
0.11807244271039963,
-0.435295432806015,
-0.13073240220546722,
-0.10904420167207718,
-0.8313637971878052,
0.25275546312332153,
0.015041814185678959,
-0.5002859830856323,
-0.012281285598874092,
0.4572769105434418,
-0.30944621562957764,
0.5440845489501953,
-0.5552738904953003,
0.6658697724342346,
-0.5597895383834839,
-0.669404923915863,
-0.36791449785232544,
-0.5723638534545898,
0.2918378710746765,
-0.42845144867897034,
0.442117840051651,
0.1108180582523346,
-0.027811532840132713,
0.5444519519805908,
-0.09369923919439316,
1.168821930885315,
-0.1921636313199997,
-0.059853360056877136,
-0.006514518987387419,
0.5546839833259583,
0.7936882972717285,
0.07359561324119568,
0.001295774127356708,
-0.13207989931106567,
0.04054098576307297,
-0.21933382749557495,
-0.6613503694534302,
0.5023806691169739,
-0.7166436314582825,
-0.7593012452125549,
-0.5762408375740051,
-0.6486262679100037,
-0.3413407802581787,
0.20159856975078583,
0.05522589012980461,
0.45613887906074524,
-0.4019247889518738,
0.3367956280708313,
0.8362596035003662,
-0.3053414225578308,
0.15141920745372772,
0.38434064388275146,
-0.5172137022018433,
-0.3395910859107971,
0.7966590523719788,
0.1550881266593933,
0.4478094279766083,
-0.14030656218528748,
0.09669002890586853,
-0.11908160895109177,
-0.6557589173316956,
-0.37066856026649475,
0.46961337327957153,
-0.8158433437347412,
-0.13767701387405396,
-0.892181932926178,
-0.0835149958729744,
0.1324288696050644,
-0.18643613159656525,
-0.16001062095165253,
0.005513528361916542,
-0.33681127429008484,
-0.22470678389072418,
0.4438619613647461,
0.6525168418884277,
-0.2486574500799179,
0.5256403088569641,
-0.5246275067329407,
0.019857726991176605,
0.17795662581920624,
0.3113756775856018,
-0.23030972480773926,
-0.351824015378952,
-0.1799803078174591,
0.45869988203048706,
-0.4582540690898895,
-0.7651941776275635,
0.2869774401187897,
0.17401698231697083,
0.6386191844940186,
0.03430431708693504,
-0.3198342025279999,
0.6944335103034973,
-0.6478427052497864,
0.4119219481945038,
-0.19204488396644592,
-0.7802169322967529,
0.4050794839859009,
-0.3164607882499695,
0.36279353499412537,
0.5182572603225708,
0.23744472861289978,
-0.5022444725036621,
-0.7801641225814819,
-0.7817628979682922,
-0.6092182993888855,
0.6346795558929443,
0.007516812067478895,
0.20772244036197662,
0.17381328344345093,
0.5508578419685364,
0.2554508447647095,
0.2797369062900543,
-0.8484324216842651,
0.2644745111465454,
0.0771978497505188,
-0.17910221219062805,
-0.2115209698677063,
-0.021383602172136307,
-0.5327982306480408,
-0.15359336137771606,
0.8622997403144836,
-0.3923102617263794,
0.04078720137476921,
0.2173432558774948,
-0.3643698990345001,
-0.2685283422470093,
0.09574487805366516,
0.6060738563537598,
0.8140409588813782,
-0.35767731070518494,
0.29886624217033386,
0.6327800154685974,
-0.5124021768569946,
0.25149309635162354,
-0.25133851170539856,
0.041492387652397156,
0.06759097427129745,
0.15710391104221344,
0.6441560983657837,
0.585766077041626,
-0.9958149790763855,
0.31152671575546265,
0.008552217856049538,
-0.2614576816558838,
-0.47730374336242676,
0.425597220659256,
0.3353918492794037,
0.4299604892730713,
0.16895781457424164,
0.13811565935611725,
0.009803381748497486,
-0.6026328206062317,
0.26662832498550415,
0.5856407284736633,
-0.4597642719745636,
-0.34599971771240234,
0.6154873967170715,
-0.09450828284025192,
-0.3583037853240967,
0.36009445786476135,
-0.368945837020874,
-0.44192108511924744,
0.5654667019844055,
0.6925426125526428,
0.7250857353210449,
-0.044628821313381195,
-0.06282998621463776,
0.1518862247467041,
0.4998750686645508,
-0.28359803557395935,
0.3458515405654907,
0.2196725755929947,
-0.5467449426651001,
-0.3389206826686859,
-0.6877821087837219,
-0.7143328189849854,
0.0768674686551094,
-0.21322865784168243,
0.42474400997161865,
-0.7309250831604004,
-0.14711885154247284,
-0.37415558099746704,
-0.08072207123041153,
-0.7601136565208435,
-0.01056042592972517,
-0.3203202784061432,
1.193161129951477,
-0.579329788684845,
1.1506084203720093,
0.7107096910476685,
-0.08247881382703781,
-0.7869740724563599,
-0.18888916075229645,
0.29277732968330383,
-0.8292697668075562,
0.6258339285850525,
0.11102627962827682,
-0.3408660292625427,
0.2425066977739334,
-0.6707415580749512,
-0.8169463872909546,
1.3972134590148926,
0.24206997454166412,
-0.5709478259086609,
-0.12820126116275787,
-0.1242600530385971,
0.5658590197563171,
-0.3028951585292816,
0.045434821397066116,
0.4531611204147339,
0.3365241289138794,
0.22531849145889282,
-0.9394349455833435,
-0.06517529487609863,
-0.15599489212036133,
-0.07468438148498535,
0.050230447202920914,
-0.3208547532558441,
0.7621467709541321,
-0.35349705815315247,
-0.3594107925891876,
-0.07993694394826889,
0.42690497636795044,
0.7391023635864258,
0.18839992582798004,
0.5703867077827454,
0.4495803713798523,
0.4908210039138794,
-0.07747624069452286,
0.9856435060501099,
-0.14767277240753174,
0.01818780228495598,
1.0929582118988037,
-0.45493873953819275,
0.7179028987884521,
0.8434278964996338,
-0.0817205160856247,
0.32391592860221863,
0.7332034707069397,
-0.028658343479037285,
0.35875508189201355,
0.47864294052124023,
-0.16847170889377594,
-0.09848573803901672,
0.1619139015674591,
-0.08979858458042145,
0.2201913744211197,
0.6268667578697205,
-0.267020046710968,
-0.24475610256195068,
0.4767506718635559,
0.26824846863746643,
-0.12673720717430115,
0.025496862828731537,
0.8438287973403931,
0.3846186101436615,
-0.4835219383239746,
0.31299909949302673,
-0.17036564648151398,
0.8129091262817383,
-0.6362818479537964,
-0.13056576251983643,
-0.1486072838306427,
0.3189268410205841,
0.22941754758358002,
-0.525963544845581,
-0.02104467712342739,
-0.19965018332004547,
0.25776371359825134,
-0.015861203894019127,
0.4331510663032532,
-0.4053708612918854,
-0.6618045568466187,
0.4049113988876343,
0.6764143109321594,
0.17981314659118652,
0.14285019040107727,
-0.6309693455696106,
0.24765722453594208,
-0.180552676320076,
-0.21098925173282623,
0.3712066113948822,
0.5050667524337769,
0.03205869719386101,
0.8452265858650208,
0.7100071907043457,
0.47115954756736755,
0.15312066674232483,
-0.20513077080249786,
0.821413516998291,
-0.555155873298645,
-0.26664504408836365,
-0.9460883140563965,
0.2779757082462311,
-0.22814635932445526,
-0.05834706872701645,
0.7390761971473694,
0.5236694812774658,
1.134963035583496,
-0.12286487221717834,
0.8730887770652771,
0.17843547463417053,
0.7164369821548462,
-0.7245032787322998,
0.42971286177635193,
-0.7995131015777588,
0.39519134163856506,
-0.2544073462486267,
-0.9008070230484009,
-0.21226544678211212,
0.4296020567417145,
-0.2040431648492813,
-0.0015591827686876059,
0.8785881996154785,
0.8241114020347595,
-0.506272554397583,
-0.15380491316318512,
0.3717246353626251,
0.27705851197242737,
0.5850269198417664,
0.4069276452064514,
0.8055850267410278,
-0.17067435383796692,
0.2873147428035736,
-0.5374409556388855,
-0.31453901529312134,
-0.2445361167192459,
-0.8446100950241089,
-0.8289167284965515,
-0.3046208918094635,
-0.11775167286396027,
-0.3554821312427521,
0.2257308065891266,
1.3730453252792358,
0.3579109311103821,
-0.4786892235279083,
-0.6017211079597473,
-0.1255103200674057,
-0.1250477135181427,
-0.14847512543201447,
-0.1355275809764862,
0.034560173749923706,
-0.6665853261947632,
-0.714612603187561,
0.37479454278945923,
0.42076146602630615,
0.5084391236305237,
-0.42992690205574036,
-0.1343195140361786,
-0.060681287199258804,
0.1118115559220314,
0.37804728746414185,
0.2574955224990845,
-0.8637071251869202,
-0.23773731291294098,
0.148993581533432,
-0.07062418758869171,
0.18996843695640564,
0.9457932710647583,
-0.937140941619873,
0.5286807417869568,
0.052866313606500626,
0.6272181272506714,
0.3012276589870453,
-0.26838186383247375,
1.0137877464294434,
-0.529710054397583,
0.1802966296672821,
0.32231074571609497,
0.5262396335601807,
0.3034055531024933,
-0.26536163687705994,
0.7124448418617249,
0.25161030888557434,
-0.40539729595184326,
-1.1279882192611694,
0.02921381965279579,
-0.7374871373176575,
-0.40226247906684875,
1.1375043392181396,
-0.09803013503551483,
-0.35532495379447937,
-0.17066353559494019,
-0.5214594006538391,
0.33557072281837463,
-0.10513284802436829,
1.100399374961853,
0.8309139609336853,
-0.02684970572590828,
-0.0033582032192498446,
-0.8535369634628296,
0.7642337679862976,
0.40034469962120056,
-0.9144864082336426,
-0.08431704342365265,
0.35369035601615906,
0.6132659912109375,
0.1357906460762024,
0.4189104735851288,
-0.2605605721473694,
0.46448472142219543,
-0.19096438586711884,
0.060695040971040726,
0.016856491565704346,
-0.38193586468696594,
-0.24843063950538635,
-0.09487626701593399,
0.4051411747932434,
0.22542373836040497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04732v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04732v2
|
How Far Are We from Intelligent Visual Deductive Reasoning?
| 2024-03-07T18:35:54 | 2024-03-08T06:47:08 |
Yizhe Zhang, He Bai, Ruixiang Zhang, Jiatao Gu, Shuangfei Zhai, Josh Susskind, Navdeep Jaitly
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Vision-Language Models (VLMs) such as GPT-4V have recently demonstrated
incredible strides on diverse vision language tasks. We dig into vision-based
deductive reasoning, a more sophisticated but less explored realm, and find
previously unexposed blindspots in the current SOTA VLMs. Specifically, we
leverage Raven's Progressive Matrices (RPMs), to assess VLMs' abilities to
perform multi-hop relational and deductive reasoning relying solely on visual
clues. We perform comprehensive evaluations of several popular VLMs employing
standard strategies such as in-context learning, self-consistency, and
Chain-of-thoughts (CoT) on three diverse datasets, including the Mensa IQ test,
IntelligenceTest, and RAVEN. The results reveal that despite the impressive
capabilities of LLMs in text-based reasoning, we are still far from achieving
comparable proficiency in visual deductive reasoning. We found that certain
standard strategies that are effective when applied to LLMs do not seamlessly
translate to the challenges presented by visual reasoning tasks. Moreover, a
detailed analysis reveals that VLMs struggle to solve these tasks mainly
because they are unable to perceive and comprehend multiple, confounding
abstract patterns in RPM examples.
|
[
-0.31527969241142273,
-0.7865619659423828,
0.9343120455741882,
0.10064871609210968,
-0.24158701300621033,
0.14213374257087708,
0.23918947577476501,
-0.549409031867981,
-0.10745467990636826,
0.5333096385002136,
-0.780295193195343,
-0.5422349572181702,
-0.4534856975078583,
0.3141825199127197,
-0.28732192516326904,
0.38739249110221863,
0.04679819568991661,
-0.07305759936571121,
-0.34665733575820923,
-0.1869596391916275,
-0.48395901918411255,
-0.28415101766586304,
-0.2154873162508011,
-0.03361193835735321,
0.572927713394165,
0.36448419094085693,
0.5243390798568726,
0.5464158654212952,
1.046130657196045,
0.22038976848125458,
-0.10018368065357208,
0.4058041274547577,
-0.3052040934562683,
0.16479170322418213,
-0.30073675513267517,
-0.33129313588142395,
-0.31257835030555725,
-0.1364532858133316,
0.5849255919456482,
0.7990378141403198,
0.26811400055885315,
0.2119991034269333,
-0.10294262319803238,
1.1274135112762451,
-0.9973874688148499,
0.2189491242170334,
-0.8238862156867981,
0.15509672462940216,
-0.2525160610675812,
0.1538538932800293,
-0.33482304215431213,
-0.08752657473087311,
0.12123185396194458,
-0.4260839819908142,
-0.21471960842609406,
0.01666272059082985,
0.8280354142189026,
0.6518115997314453,
-0.3218691945075989,
0.06884051114320755,
-0.8030087947845459,
0.9152878522872925,
-0.29049235582351685,
0.42124003171920776,
0.4116058945655823,
0.5760382413864136,
-0.08364421874284744,
-0.9071171879768372,
-0.6167627573013306,
-0.26516270637512207,
0.41143524646759033,
0.20077303051948547,
-0.35241246223449707,
-0.16375187039375305,
0.6460793018341064,
0.03222683444619179,
-0.5537145733833313,
-0.054051198065280914,
-0.31176310777664185,
0.15270158648490906,
0.4581899642944336,
0.4986026883125305,
0.05721460282802582,
0.08057740330696106,
-0.639703094959259,
-0.09390898793935776,
-0.6775277853012085,
0.050652071833610535,
0.017242029309272766,
0.03211667016148567,
0.2191387265920639,
0.7218173742294312,
-0.39566463232040405,
1.1606335639953613,
-0.2844691574573517,
-0.004455318208783865,
0.10095519572496414,
-0.5533825159072876,
-0.5061700940132141,
-0.5035616755485535,
0.5439751148223877,
0.5749053955078125,
0.5752530694007874,
-0.07759129256010056,
-0.20706865191459656,
0.4487934410572052,
0.1540035456418991,
-0.302605003118515,
-0.18289756774902344,
-0.06725301593542099,
-0.4628514349460602,
-0.01966285891830921,
-0.2287532389163971,
-0.6526569128036499,
-0.6491851210594177,
-0.43648561835289,
0.5104790329933167,
-0.51659095287323,
-0.14966818690299988,
0.27494344115257263,
-0.373871773481369,
0.45411577820777893,
0.5765781402587891,
-0.6414675116539001,
-0.09402228146791458,
0.5201091170310974,
0.5736821293830872,
-0.08948619663715363,
-0.47012966871261597,
-0.4071388840675354,
0.04724571481347084,
-0.5390891432762146,
0.9046066403388977,
-0.8480215668678284,
0.03693568706512451,
-0.09296221286058426,
-0.27196162939071655,
-0.16313476860523224,
-0.5418545603752136,
0.2508711814880371,
-0.36841127276420593,
-0.19946520030498505,
-0.8383464813232422,
-0.14549057185649872,
-0.414031445980072,
0.7087897062301636,
-0.47082972526550293,
0.6395207643508911,
0.023072993382811546,
-0.8235080242156982,
0.5448986291885376,
-0.2637263238430023,
-0.15923216938972473,
0.24428236484527588,
-0.6854491829872131,
-0.11160411685705185,
0.038698501884937286,
0.10176911950111389,
0.4229756295681,
-0.32301807403564453,
-0.02697994001209736,
-0.4962348937988281,
-0.5558451414108276,
0.1901271790266037,
-0.4647243618965149,
0.915298342704773,
0.21844135224819183,
-0.579517126083374,
0.08744627237319946,
-1.024824619293213,
-0.08480717241764069,
0.09653477370738983,
0.021038752049207687,
-0.3755062520503998,
0.10723190754652023,
-0.4660595953464508,
0.17959298193454742,
-0.020260371267795563,
-0.24087455868721008,
0.2599921226501465,
-0.09330086410045624,
0.46931177377700806,
0.5726425647735596,
-0.4150601029396057,
0.15694484114646912,
-0.020546525716781616,
0.44660261273384094,
0.07856594771146774,
0.34793010354042053,
-0.09736299514770508,
-0.6580797433853149,
-0.9384172558784485,
-0.4838196933269501,
-0.2477739304304123,
0.7680224776268005,
-1.292122483253479,
-0.0233985036611557,
-0.12120379507541656,
-0.3959319293498993,
-0.0878688246011734,
-0.010985946282744408,
0.5062032341957092,
0.7228596806526184,
0.5770143270492554,
-0.22700460255146027,
-0.3167467713356018,
-0.8778462409973145,
-0.47222405672073364,
-0.3415795564651489,
0.17316526174545288,
-0.04973810166120529,
0.8865126371383667,
-0.418602854013443,
0.8615646362304688,
-0.12190217524766922,
-0.40199145674705505,
-0.3348444700241089,
-0.10349124670028687,
0.12686489522457123,
0.11670432239770889,
0.3686804175376892,
-0.7766252756118774,
-0.2790840268135071,
-0.2869979739189148,
-1.1925681829452515,
0.09842006117105484,
-0.1418733149766922,
0.15701696276664734,
0.24304738640785217,
0.6127748489379883,
-0.3870204985141754,
0.845947265625,
0.2458677738904953,
-0.6622017621994019,
0.5393470525741577,
-0.08576680719852448,
-0.11351364105939865,
-0.23468491435050964,
-0.12728676199913025,
0.08706560730934143,
-0.13405583798885345,
-0.40074384212493896,
0.12938587367534637,
-0.04595382511615753,
0.3472555875778198,
-0.4594404101371765,
0.5384923219680786,
-0.7303766012191772,
-0.274458646774292,
-0.028308963403105736,
-0.01825007051229477,
0.11811709403991699,
0.4661489725112915,
0.11006758362054825,
0.47725099325180054,
0.7366883754730225,
-0.5432407855987549,
0.5770332217216492,
0.10717477649450302,
-0.38256940245628357,
0.6104583740234375,
-0.44127413630485535,
-0.04469144344329834,
-0.4339790344238281,
-0.06233510375022888,
-1.0942946672439575,
0.15798677504062653,
0.4056752026081085,
-0.17370674014091492,
0.17473691701889038,
0.11755899339914322,
-0.21114082634449005,
-0.598378598690033,
-0.36108922958374023,
0.24057967960834503,
0.558752179145813,
-0.5064976811408997,
0.6453410387039185,
0.027082744985818863,
0.21020345389842987,
-0.972080409526825,
-1.027752161026001,
0.392798513174057,
-0.2691861391067505,
-0.7455083131790161,
0.03979625925421715,
0.2157626748085022,
-1.0021165609359741,
-0.11116133630275726,
-0.13135093450546265,
0.039222270250320435,
0.1735709011554718,
0.12771010398864746,
0.24754174053668976,
-0.030275359749794006,
0.15061643719673157,
-0.48774227499961853,
-0.06599973142147064,
-0.07182227075099945,
-0.3704371750354767,
-0.001631449325941503,
-0.7690709233283997,
-0.7411066889762878,
-0.20727349817752838,
0.26409628987312317,
0.6362823843955994,
-0.4981885552406311,
0.6327863335609436,
0.5027410984039307,
-0.21817326545715332,
-0.0903041660785675,
-0.6179467439651489,
-0.10942872613668442,
-0.3726513981819153,
0.35631152987480164,
-0.6385340094566345,
-0.72123122215271,
0.4791419208049774,
0.11798763275146484,
-0.09364181011915207,
0.37693819403648376,
0.5578753352165222,
-0.22368688881397247,
0.9124130010604858,
0.7575490474700928,
0.8398353457450867,
0.34555506706237793,
-0.5382519364356995,
0.06865838170051575,
-0.7337159514427185,
-0.6874310970306396,
-0.1162322536110878,
-0.35033679008483887,
-0.34145236015319824,
-0.5212922096252441,
0.22442489862442017,
0.16562354564666748,
-0.37229883670806885,
0.01654762774705887,
-0.6029584407806396,
0.4143335521221161,
0.7904354333877563,
0.009970110841095448,
0.4135300815105438,
-0.05990992859005928,
-0.21150599420070648,
-0.1975502371788025,
-0.6144767999649048,
-0.46113649010658264,
0.8601280450820923,
0.39343467354774475,
0.8060830235481262,
0.12766394019126892,
0.2910766303539276,
0.07344721257686615,
0.16568517684936523,
-0.6258864998817444,
0.7590487599372864,
-0.3596520721912384,
-0.40303918719291687,
-0.32066810131073,
-0.22278736531734467,
-0.664869487285614,
0.30650922656059265,
-0.13935118913650513,
-0.7916829586029053,
0.5808730125427246,
0.08167820423841476,
-0.3564380705356598,
0.2223285287618637,
-0.542375385761261,
1.1447315216064453,
-0.2583721876144409,
-0.8103864192962646,
0.21061454713344574,
-0.8741559982299805,
0.5589900016784668,
0.21230706572532654,
0.03330319747328758,
-0.17047692835330963,
-0.017150189727544785,
0.4262228012084961,
-0.4344444274902344,
0.907482922077179,
-0.18001370131969452,
-0.03824663907289505,
0.5141841173171997,
0.00898702535778284,
0.37608128786087036,
-0.1094859391450882,
0.3071499764919281,
0.3176026940345764,
-0.016514981165528297,
-0.338135302066803,
-0.4558035135269165,
0.3254167139530182,
-0.27255716919898987,
-0.8124619126319885,
-0.6585235595703125,
-0.3884793221950531,
-0.27722465991973877,
0.08751868456602097,
0.32787278294563293,
0.47799116373062134,
0.1448715776205063,
0.0595860555768013,
0.7092603445053101,
-0.11464577913284302,
0.6041168570518494,
0.43343326449394226,
-0.2735719084739685,
-0.25007715821266174,
1.0435041189193726,
0.2556377649307251,
0.12660084664821625,
0.40390050411224365,
-0.0014070331817492843,
-0.6229577660560608,
-0.8430969715118408,
-0.646755039691925,
0.11007973551750183,
-1.1007860898971558,
-0.015069674700498581,
-0.581159770488739,
-0.022389885038137436,
-0.14986445009708405,
0.07617634534835815,
-0.2152850329875946,
-0.40488091111183167,
-0.14879557490348816,
0.18872609734535217,
0.08358742296695709,
0.6182178854942322,
-0.04103093966841698,
-0.21213030815124512,
-0.6749406456947327,
0.45517346262931824,
0.8595970273017883,
0.19804754853248596,
-0.1815926432609558,
-0.35800832509994507,
0.011681564152240753,
-0.009623023681342602,
-0.2536695599555969,
-0.9314016103744507,
0.22116637229919434,
0.02609393373131752,
0.5541906952857971,
0.47375574707984924,
0.025753343477845192,
0.7732666730880737,
-0.5535999536514282,
0.9174215793609619,
0.3720909357070923,
-0.6976689100265503,
0.5253493189811707,
-0.22199194133281708,
0.23690712451934814,
0.49305492639541626,
0.10839628428220749,
0.06256935745477676,
-0.47127559781074524,
-0.243845596909523,
-0.5527347326278687,
0.12353108078241348,
0.23877646028995514,
-0.21192912757396698,
-0.20325765013694763,
0.21320150792598724,
0.008429810404777527,
-0.051613323390483856,
-0.6540233492851257,
0.00476824538782239,
-0.48974835872650146,
-0.1419430673122406,
0.2469240128993988,
-0.22008755803108215,
-0.05872723460197449,
-0.47533169388771057,
0.08517573773860931,
-0.29877322912216187,
0.07410259544849396,
0.4854823350906372,
0.07889245450496674,
0.2080877721309662,
0.16672684252262115,
0.8352404236793518,
1.0567892789840698,
-0.11351212114095688,
0.46744781732559204,
0.0540483333170414,
-0.5152992010116577,
0.03195760026574135,
0.06176888942718506,
-0.16928161680698395,
-0.05627625435590744,
0.6373705267906189,
0.8150402903556824,
-0.46920573711395264,
-0.9367429614067078,
0.5925912857055664,
-0.24393101036548615,
-0.31793737411499023,
-0.5554080605506897,
0.0562959648668766,
0.024508293718099594,
0.7534517049789429,
0.26316964626312256,
0.2826991379261017,
0.1783413290977478,
-0.6112551689147949,
-0.06981461495161057,
0.7774081826210022,
-0.6767300367355347,
-0.20957301557064056,
0.92243891954422,
0.09377597272396088,
-0.06941913068294525,
0.6747410297393799,
-0.2237502783536911,
-0.3875371217727661,
0.6689632534980774,
0.2063344269990921,
0.9334260821342468,
0.3091789186000824,
0.027874691411852837,
0.026569366455078125,
0.5416445136070251,
-0.32906922698020935,
0.7159739136695862,
-0.12109261006116867,
-0.769274115562439,
-0.800687313079834,
-0.5760900378227234,
-0.3366219997406006,
-0.03937767446041107,
-0.2736765444278717,
0.19038140773773193,
-0.47866418957710266,
-0.12975676357746124,
-0.08804254233837128,
-0.29772064089775085,
-0.701933741569519,
0.224400594830513,
0.4244041442871094,
1.1521427631378174,
-0.6608545780181885,
0.754530668258667,
0.902384877204895,
-0.6059999465942383,
-0.5155752897262573,
-0.17193198204040527,
-0.06948711723089218,
-1.0029892921447754,
1.2966817617416382,
0.30462712049484253,
-0.4220751225948334,
-0.03375555947422981,
-0.6526740193367004,
-0.5587016344070435,
0.9392211437225342,
0.5241807103157043,
-0.7285545468330383,
-0.10275554656982422,
-0.08494554460048676,
0.4927056133747101,
-0.14696845412254333,
0.2933416962623596,
0.580075740814209,
0.594674289226532,
0.46065640449523926,
-0.6699556708335876,
-0.08724367618560791,
-0.17789015173912048,
0.042124271392822266,
-0.06489516794681549,
-0.6316958665847778,
0.8979614973068237,
-0.7392824292182922,
-0.12376415729522705,
-0.04858968406915665,
0.5340878367424011,
0.44856932759284973,
0.6313789486885071,
0.4732278287410736,
0.8603139519691467,
0.48661869764328003,
-0.1145012304186821,
0.9749226570129395,
0.24285000562667847,
0.037356529384851456,
0.8296896815299988,
-0.4274604320526123,
0.7093163132667542,
0.7465994358062744,
-0.14824320375919342,
0.6376490592956543,
0.48004740476608276,
-0.1663244068622589,
0.659756064414978,
0.24343541264533997,
-0.06431569904088974,
-0.870942234992981,
-0.0386485829949379,
-0.3880119323730469,
0.7388016581535339,
0.3606627583503723,
-0.34717580676078796,
-0.12008991092443466,
0.09306652843952179,
-0.38860049843788147,
0.2490951418876648,
-0.38968268036842346,
0.6052560210227966,
0.274352490901947,
-0.6543384194374084,
0.8499272465705872,
-0.37577471137046814,
0.3850354850292206,
-0.25875943899154663,
-0.4229625165462494,
-0.23902662098407745,
0.5375679731369019,
-0.04053818807005882,
-0.9089604616165161,
0.5088928937911987,
0.06636721640825272,
-0.1125156506896019,
-0.41943874955177307,
0.8666176199913025,
-0.047314148396253586,
-0.5283690094947815,
0.2065792977809906,
0.8562565445899963,
0.23945224285125732,
-0.2761753797531128,
-0.5597624182701111,
0.14709211885929108,
0.006298319436609745,
-0.19160564243793488,
0.14658765494823456,
0.6069945096969604,
-0.2377384603023529,
1.0652711391448975,
0.3278432786464691,
0.07036922872066498,
0.0487988255918026,
0.1768973469734192,
0.7736254930496216,
-1.0109738111495972,
-0.19964130222797394,
-1.3434573411941528,
0.5242003798484802,
0.009382491931319237,
-0.2936243712902069,
0.7934392094612122,
0.10653220117092133,
0.5474996566772461,
-0.15581992268562317,
0.6603544354438782,
0.24032050371170044,
0.3255178928375244,
-0.680675745010376,
0.31623575091362,
-0.8962177038192749,
0.48260602355003357,
-0.25597381591796875,
-0.8811120986938477,
-0.5748243927955627,
0.8019508719444275,
-0.31601688265800476,
-0.17104493081569672,
0.7794812917709351,
0.3852401673793793,
0.29589635133743286,
-0.006884777918457985,
0.6250393390655518,
0.21249869465827942,
0.1866462379693985,
0.966688334941864,
1.5083386898040771,
-0.02887188084423542,
0.7387237548828125,
0.07917577028274536,
-0.3442617654800415,
-0.02509738691151142,
-0.9852110147476196,
-1.1723769903182983,
-0.35768139362335205,
-0.3570154309272766,
-0.19740167260169983,
0.250901460647583,
0.19900238513946533,
0.308309942483902,
-0.2642780840396881,
0.26656314730644226,
-0.6182460784912109,
0.27664268016815186,
-0.5193390846252441,
-0.17709679901599884,
0.20398946106433868,
-0.29344668984413147,
-0.3786395192146301,
0.2844339609146118,
0.7951900959014893,
0.0787135660648346,
-0.6717902421951294,
0.07165075093507767,
0.02436005137860775,
-0.10636729001998901,
0.6973405480384827,
0.2702823877334595,
-1.0336816310882568,
-0.33627888560295105,
0.4218451976776123,
-0.1759812831878662,
-0.13802407681941986,
0.22798822820186615,
-1.2863852977752686,
0.6369500756263733,
0.7744967937469482,
0.3904765844345093,
0.3033084571361542,
-0.2668168246746063,
0.324342280626297,
-0.12225021421909332,
0.07624900341033936,
0.5211151838302612,
0.3972887694835663,
0.39386817812919617,
0.15451167523860931,
0.6416605114936829,
0.6487704515457153,
-0.3515782952308655,
-0.773405134677887,
0.5492412447929382,
-0.9727315902709961,
-0.3701491355895996,
1.2523289918899536,
-0.15133008360862732,
-0.40327197313308716,
-0.43713006377220154,
-0.03487113490700722,
-0.20076212286949158,
0.2827872931957245,
0.632594108581543,
0.4727054834365845,
-0.48284754157066345,
-0.4304402768611908,
-0.528454601764679,
0.4723018407821655,
0.40035131573677063,
-0.5569332242012024,
0.011280333623290062,
0.5201276540756226,
0.01019395049661398,
0.31118258833885193,
0.805680513381958,
-0.04004018381237984,
0.3422110378742218,
0.3928411602973938,
-0.17337541282176971,
-0.4165695309638977,
-0.6036875247955322,
-0.21936926245689392,
0.10924167931079865,
0.056444499641656876,
-0.4399798810482025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04706v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04706v1
|
Common 7B Language Models Already Possess Strong Math Capabilities
| 2024-03-07T18:00:40 | 2024-03-07T18:00:40 |
Chen Li, Weiqi Wang, Jingcheng Hu, Yixuan Wei, Nanning Zheng, Han Hu, Zheng Zhang, Houwen Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Mathematical capabilities were previously believed to emerge in common
language models only at a very large scale or require extensive math-related
pre-training. This paper shows that the LLaMA-2 7B model with common
pre-training already exhibits strong mathematical abilities, as evidenced by
its impressive accuracy of 97.7% and 72.0% on the GSM8K and MATH benchmarks,
respectively, when selecting the best response from 256 random generations. The
primary issue with the current base model is the difficulty in consistently
eliciting its inherent mathematical capabilities. Notably, the accuracy for the
first answer drops to 49.5% and 7.9% on the GSM8K and MATH benchmarks,
respectively. We find that simply scaling up the SFT data can significantly
enhance the reliability of generating correct answers. However, the potential
for extensive scaling is constrained by the scarcity of publicly available math
questions. To overcome this limitation, we employ synthetic data, which proves
to be nearly as effective as real data and shows no clear saturation when
scaled up to approximately one million samples. This straightforward approach
achieves an accuracy of 82.6% on GSM8K and 40.6% on MATH using LLaMA-2 7B
models, surpassing previous models by 14.2% and 20.8%, respectively. We also
provide insights into scaling behaviors across different reasoning complexities
and error types.
|
[
-0.45091864466667175,
-0.8121922016143799,
0.6133532524108887,
0.5501871705055237,
-0.29599714279174805,
0.2424948513507843,
-0.24638070166110992,
-0.48643213510513306,
-0.0597199946641922,
0.4313122630119324,
-0.23705774545669556,
-0.15321972966194153,
-0.9041463732719421,
0.12084052711725235,
-0.22767573595046997,
0.7116394639015198,
0.19977986812591553,
0.18079401552677155,
-0.1372424066066742,
-0.2763628661632538,
-0.4380302131175995,
-0.7376241087913513,
-0.4368319809436798,
-0.4020361006259918,
0.24498525261878967,
0.2808367908000946,
1.017577886581421,
0.7076227068901062,
0.7939026951789856,
0.27122125029563904,
-0.3248097002506256,
0.12963131070137024,
-0.6331490874290466,
-0.3427417278289795,
-0.0811639130115509,
-0.7537529468536377,
-0.6813544034957886,
-0.1845438927412033,
0.6788965463638306,
1.0436205863952637,
-0.4368920922279358,
0.26197028160095215,
-0.18126793205738068,
0.6276777982711792,
-0.15999040007591248,
0.3581435978412628,
-1.037956953048706,
-0.5203813910484314,
-0.2814647853374481,
0.3409980535507202,
-0.34975162148475647,
-0.4574541747570038,
0.05279414728283882,
-0.7199098467826843,
0.23925204575061798,
-0.20625454187393188,
0.6178387403488159,
0.25574082136154175,
-0.5936676263809204,
-0.45690035820007324,
-0.4850625693798065,
0.9405601620674133,
-0.8089532256126404,
0.25078651309013367,
0.5142560601234436,
0.6739764213562012,
-0.3347838819026947,
-0.5770229697227478,
-0.5077081322669983,
-0.4384165108203888,
0.1942971646785736,
-0.04295157268643379,
-0.2556287348270416,
-0.0686647891998291,
0.5120553970336914,
0.25858816504478455,
-0.38571062684059143,
-0.08856206387281418,
-0.8227115869522095,
-0.06994380056858063,
0.6568859815597534,
0.1890084445476532,
0.3327856659889221,
-0.014180907048285007,
-0.018269380554556847,
0.007539155427366495,
-0.8829860687255859,
0.19454902410507202,
0.34319207072257996,
0.2524828016757965,
-0.11595633625984192,
0.7454392313957214,
-0.15717996656894684,
0.7748059034347534,
0.037130776792764664,
-0.3712652325630188,
0.23338286578655243,
-0.3127222955226898,
-0.05588480085134506,
-0.062235020101070404,
0.4566648304462433,
-0.00007981021190062165,
0.5048701167106628,
0.16157986223697662,
-0.18657155334949493,
0.48641225695610046,
0.30319392681121826,
-0.7888781428337097,
-0.08258777856826782,
-0.11676818132400513,
-0.24129562079906464,
-0.1566525399684906,
-0.1015971228480339,
-0.27954503893852234,
-0.16292136907577515,
-0.5533319115638733,
0.302243709564209,
-0.25733113288879395,
-0.47498995065689087,
0.3429641127586365,
0.2877660095691681,
0.011303635314106941,
0.5870310664176941,
-0.9485208988189697,
0.5801201462745667,
0.7561600804328918,
0.7277706265449524,
-0.1311796009540558,
-0.13800254464149475,
-0.3124484419822693,
-0.17562730610370636,
-0.561793863773346,
0.7767747640609741,
-0.5573291778564453,
-0.29348689317703247,
-0.43866002559661865,
-0.3931383788585663,
0.06255056709051132,
-0.7982998490333557,
0.3667983114719391,
-0.3941807746887207,
-0.22573590278625488,
-0.3726651072502136,
-0.10606151074171066,
-0.2858605682849884,
0.2951946258544922,
-0.8034262657165527,
1.0165343284606934,
0.40163928270339966,
-0.5325095057487488,
0.08341927826404572,
-0.5781588554382324,
-0.279481440782547,
-0.20026251673698425,
-0.18081557750701904,
-0.33141374588012695,
0.513587236404419,
0.3201327323913574,
0.3468898832798004,
-0.6498880386352539,
0.6931242942810059,
-0.7872222661972046,
-0.5846517086029053,
0.46899351477622986,
-0.8036432862281799,
0.8338034152984619,
0.23653453588485718,
-0.24039368331432343,
-0.4195312559604645,
-1.2568659782409668,
-0.00045936042442917824,
0.2708896994590759,
-0.3067031800746918,
-0.06192365661263466,
-0.3413134217262268,
-0.3550160527229309,
0.26808226108551025,
0.3555561900138855,
-0.4456407129764557,
0.18481552600860596,
-0.5322625637054443,
0.2921045124530792,
0.7339500188827515,
-0.4062248468399048,
0.4798385798931122,
-0.37055349349975586,
0.6075706481933594,
0.022471921518445015,
-0.044391728937625885,
0.07669597864151001,
-0.7075324058532715,
-0.4883105754852295,
-0.4136764109134674,
0.10513926297426224,
0.47879138588905334,
-0.3782956898212433,
0.23455464839935303,
-0.5340036153793335,
-0.8329908847808838,
-0.3251001834869385,
0.4328187108039856,
0.2807873487472534,
0.4854881167411804,
0.38572365045547485,
-0.1837455779314041,
-0.30908554792404175,
-0.9935634136199951,
-0.14397478103637695,
-0.11621809750795364,
-0.14262937009334564,
0.25972089171409607,
0.288920134305954,
-0.1061953604221344,
0.8906553387641907,
-0.4732998311519623,
0.23266510665416718,
-0.4909377992153168,
0.02184617519378662,
0.6841402649879456,
0.15328553318977356,
0.6027933955192566,
-0.9010804891586304,
-0.3540588319301605,
0.1762159764766693,
-0.7994179129600525,
-0.46736475825309753,
0.12003118544816971,
-0.02248891443014145,
-0.08248443156480789,
-0.08488341420888901,
-0.6584200859069824,
0.438169926404953,
0.6742565035820007,
-0.07576701045036316,
0.3022984564304352,
-0.12956424057483673,
-0.04623589292168617,
-1.2612290382385254,
-0.017165128141641617,
-0.04716848209500313,
0.07927843183279037,
-0.6398423314094543,
-0.19667981564998627,
0.2265491634607315,
-0.09478787332773209,
-0.3823605179786682,
0.5349072813987732,
-0.38389724493026733,
-0.2864113748073578,
-0.2004459649324417,
-0.19428177177906036,
-0.3667566478252411,
0.3637160658836365,
-0.1404809057712555,
0.8190691471099854,
0.2174919992685318,
-0.5443021059036255,
0.44459542632102966,
-0.016749953851103783,
-0.362490713596344,
0.4231310486793518,
-0.9522433876991272,
0.11637591570615768,
-0.05131883919239044,
0.34377866983413696,
-0.9994524717330933,
-0.42754891514778137,
-0.18771639466285706,
-0.6116917729377747,
-0.014299897477030754,
-0.18644055724143982,
-0.49088168144226074,
-0.5032885074615479,
0.05512517690658569,
0.4729989469051361,
0.5220906734466553,
-0.533072829246521,
0.8936872482299805,
0.2478182464838028,
-0.3361230790615082,
-0.7179512977600098,
-0.6402247548103333,
-0.1768800914287567,
-0.13717205822467804,
-1.0478053092956543,
-0.1821158528327942,
-0.21489426493644714,
-0.32744187116622925,
-0.23024554550647736,
-0.34180977940559387,
-0.20745201408863068,
0.3999495208263397,
0.3562542796134949,
0.5412551760673523,
-0.38434168696403503,
-0.06245286017656326,
0.17524561285972595,
-0.11975149810314178,
0.082933209836483,
0.037344928830862045,
0.790041983127594,
-0.4085922837257385,
-0.41021728515625,
-0.022280501201748848,
-0.0216904878616333,
0.7440853714942932,
-0.24821555614471436,
0.6963916420936584,
0.27172598242759705,
-0.5343019962310791,
0.016323206946253777,
-0.5863368511199951,
0.1267855316400528,
-0.49487388134002686,
0.45770010352134705,
-0.7555055022239685,
-0.8625257611274719,
0.8445191383361816,
-0.09618642181158066,
0.09194020181894302,
0.5166122913360596,
0.6973322629928589,
0.37842851877212524,
1.2035044431686401,
0.4170033037662506,
0.21487747132778168,
0.3579864799976349,
-0.14974962174892426,
0.25817108154296875,
-0.6455196738243103,
-0.20236794650554657,
-0.4773717224597931,
-0.13435392081737518,
-0.48671653866767883,
-0.4472438395023346,
0.39319872856140137,
0.3518548607826233,
-0.4532409906387329,
0.4332103729248047,
-0.31996262073516846,
0.6041790246963501,
0.40887513756752014,
0.057056400924921036,
0.34805139899253845,
0.31468722224235535,
-0.06253448873758316,
-0.07650252431631088,
-0.5193544030189514,
-0.5638406276702881,
1.5276877880096436,
0.3355291485786438,
0.8974584341049194,
0.3771519660949707,
0.634440004825592,
-0.13824953138828278,
0.8291523456573486,
-0.381246954202652,
0.4806903600692749,
-0.11288751661777496,
-0.7838891744613647,
-0.3225691020488739,
-0.7620106935501099,
-0.7214394211769104,
0.35678544640541077,
-0.11226323246955872,
-0.48394396901130676,
-0.22330842912197113,
0.22620171308517456,
-0.30131128430366516,
0.08626535534858704,
-1.0989240407943726,
0.3983834981918335,
-0.2547588050365448,
-0.2789682447910309,
-0.22945648431777954,
-0.5406147837638855,
0.5609992742538452,
-0.526045560836792,
0.4262755215167999,
-0.2881859540939331,
0.133680522441864,
0.5909842848777771,
-0.2886739671230316,
0.8256592154502869,
0.0990634560585022,
-0.21571674942970276,
0.5889865756034851,
0.17157690227031708,
0.5147940516471863,
0.29171210527420044,
-0.16883161664009094,
0.31263911724090576,
-0.0921366959810257,
-0.8027389645576477,
-1.0053551197052002,
0.597866952419281,
-0.9464632272720337,
-0.7017651200294495,
-0.43240755796432495,
-0.583508312702179,
-0.41564974188804626,
0.14106860756874084,
0.07552356272935867,
0.4199424684047699,
0.05070910230278969,
0.4724983274936676,
0.5154435038566589,
-0.05144740268588066,
0.11370351165533066,
0.40283218026161194,
-0.1916283220052719,
-0.818923830986023,
0.9243291616439819,
0.4959951341152191,
0.6204166412353516,
0.1015457734465599,
0.39942190051078796,
-0.47447049617767334,
-0.465485543012619,
-0.5476248860359192,
0.4423198997974396,
-0.615704357624054,
-0.36546608805656433,
-0.5434156060218811,
-0.1905812919139862,
-0.5162203907966614,
-0.3548409044742584,
-0.5300368666648865,
-0.6979488134384155,
-0.09574247151613235,
-0.3079477548599243,
0.2247592955827713,
0.9624843597412109,
-0.16256487369537354,
0.5793609023094177,
-0.8044373989105225,
0.4217037856578827,
0.20869557559490204,
0.21765433251857758,
0.15890072286128998,
-0.7733854055404663,
-0.12450052052736282,
0.4098963439464569,
-0.3627142310142517,
-0.5852028727531433,
0.3205276429653168,
-0.12470333278179169,
0.5609689950942993,
0.2623017430305481,
-0.30562788248062134,
0.6660915017127991,
-0.22044453024864197,
0.6588967442512512,
0.49221935868263245,
-0.9431036114692688,
0.3205931782722473,
-0.4661708474159241,
0.35823890566825867,
0.29956647753715515,
0.29709354043006897,
-0.17676468193531036,
-0.1252961903810501,
-0.8690177202224731,
-0.42990630865097046,
0.4420880675315857,
0.2550359070301056,
0.3539646863937378,
0.032538123428821564,
0.2853551208972931,
0.15335288643836975,
0.28517329692840576,
-0.8149212002754211,
0.07872948050498962,
-0.3500451445579529,
-0.5334948301315308,
-0.12402058392763138,
-0.05280604213476181,
0.17662997543811798,
-0.2849772572517395,
0.26264384388923645,
-0.14539873600006104,
-0.027124598622322083,
-0.2796408236026764,
-0.14809206128120422,
0.0089179752394557,
0.2878991961479187,
0.7947613596916199,
1.134139060974121,
-0.14090774953365326,
0.2584919333457947,
0.4651404619216919,
-0.9500946402549744,
0.36073800921440125,
0.20131002366542816,
0.07817935943603516,
-0.33565205335617065,
0.5443273186683655,
0.5746111273765564,
0.26063045859336853,
-0.6024075746536255,
0.2804497182369232,
0.05684870854020119,
-0.25454890727996826,
-0.13919565081596375,
0.2322789877653122,
0.3190527856349945,
0.0037787333130836487,
0.5255082249641418,
0.12223231792449951,
-0.1964970976114273,
-0.5286233425140381,
0.05179629847407341,
0.2016564905643463,
0.277052104473114,
-0.5703542828559875,
0.4379299581050873,
0.08939263969659805,
-0.2229456752538681,
0.5672895908355713,
-0.088434599339962,
-0.710665225982666,
0.9038567543029785,
1.0330132246017456,
0.04976833611726761,
-0.34124451875686646,
0.039291948080062866,
0.5089917778968811,
0.41479361057281494,
-0.5786410570144653,
0.2155710905790329,
0.07639258354902267,
-0.7171344757080078,
-0.36417156457901,
-0.7180882692337036,
-0.3498292863368988,
-0.04027750715613365,
-0.5265336036682129,
0.2759830057621002,
-0.8607947826385498,
-0.1586657613515854,
-0.25551483035087585,
0.384250670671463,
-0.6859886646270752,
0.4567353129386902,
-0.10711140185594559,
0.6202855706214905,
-0.7504396438598633,
0.7061241269111633,
0.5441409945487976,
-0.42356088757514954,
-1.242894172668457,
-0.67977374792099,
-0.16888108849525452,
-1.237930178642273,
0.6898566484451294,
0.28550782799720764,
-0.021035972982645035,
0.08311339467763901,
-0.7979084849357605,
-1.2146320343017578,
1.1949282884597778,
0.7218148708343506,
-0.7088443040847778,
-0.0620940662920475,
0.4183611273765564,
0.691849946975708,
-0.3049050569534302,
0.4775726795196533,
0.4438915550708771,
0.20395073294639587,
0.5124226212501526,
-1.0875952243804932,
-0.017278596758842468,
-0.1968793272972107,
0.012588544748723507,
0.3242443799972534,
-0.7282363772392273,
1.0022048950195312,
-0.4319826364517212,
-0.05634085834026337,
-0.06871283799409866,
0.8245559930801392,
0.6609899997711182,
0.5769741535186768,
0.4458669424057007,
0.7104601860046387,
0.8626868724822998,
0.03650297969579697,
0.8794939517974854,
-0.08166526257991791,
0.1850566416978836,
0.959952712059021,
-0.19226931035518646,
0.883883535861969,
0.18431468307971954,
-0.41684970259666443,
0.19818241894245148,
0.48426687717437744,
0.04626397415995598,
0.13534268736839294,
0.5431484580039978,
-0.2802915871143341,
-0.5036613941192627,
0.21759331226348877,
-0.5190287828445435,
0.3009994924068451,
0.48038068413734436,
-0.024246398359537125,
-0.2059318870306015,
-0.2299695760011673,
0.08757397532463074,
0.17254464328289032,
-0.32589638233184814,
0.25323233008384705,
0.4542069137096405,
-0.5808210372924805,
0.648023247718811,
-0.2036152482032776,
0.669106125831604,
-0.7039012312889099,
-0.20620623230934143,
-0.5105270147323608,
0.12510457634925842,
-0.04534538462758064,
-0.6493830680847168,
0.23649509251117706,
0.17607301473617554,
-0.0633111298084259,
0.2703065872192383,
0.5954243540763855,
-0.15125399827957153,
-0.9469111561775208,
0.03717676177620888,
0.4443812966346741,
0.1528991311788559,
-0.07978896051645279,
-0.42468708753585815,
0.18233078718185425,
-0.0783519521355629,
-0.09387025237083435,
0.39583417773246765,
0.641006588935852,
-0.3246329426765442,
0.966148316860199,
1.1594370603561401,
0.2911275029182434,
0.5021211504936218,
-0.16358371078968048,
0.8251661658287048,
-0.6740620136260986,
-0.3901752233505249,
-0.6750330328941345,
0.25600525736808777,
-0.11702612787485123,
-0.388694703578949,
0.4711604118347168,
0.41978922486305237,
0.8923189043998718,
0.11504421383142471,
0.7250038981437683,
0.20630139112472534,
0.4096706807613373,
-0.3719537854194641,
0.4997704029083252,
-0.3566921651363373,
0.36092260479927063,
-0.07514524459838867,
-1.1687132120132446,
-0.3982031047344208,
0.865310549736023,
-0.4598183035850525,
0.09814596176147461,
0.5963656902313232,
0.7317432165145874,
-0.3622060716152191,
-0.060261934995651245,
0.5863142609596252,
0.11448804289102554,
0.5828328728675842,
0.6945526003837585,
0.7311214208602905,
-0.30191776156425476,
0.8001137375831604,
-0.07868741452693939,
-0.34152308106422424,
-0.06159403547644615,
-0.49706995487213135,
-1.0823218822479248,
-0.19948561489582062,
0.2902664244174957,
-0.5063124299049377,
-0.2727370262145996,
1.0499966144561768,
0.3623437285423279,
-0.47420912981033325,
-0.2644956111907959,
-0.14762651920318604,
0.03936030715703964,
0.07556319981813431,
-0.09382367134094238,
0.26673343777656555,
-0.044036637991666794,
-0.4933125972747803,
0.108728788793087,
0.20641081035137177,
0.4164694845676422,
-0.05912129953503609,
-0.014839699491858482,
0.3312811851501465,
0.43631234765052795,
0.5978769063949585,
0.16716259717941284,
-0.7079200148582458,
-0.17062218487262726,
0.35400015115737915,
-0.22536133229732513,
0.026753274723887444,
0.6152941584587097,
-0.5756102204322815,
0.1424299031496048,
0.3605198860168457,
0.9263913035392761,
0.31431159377098083,
0.12820984423160553,
0.6804446578025818,
0.020479382947087288,
0.05419245734810829,
0.030320368707180023,
0.21938163042068481,
0.409883588552475,
-0.1772751361131668,
0.6465631723403931,
0.4541703760623932,
-0.3165196478366852,
-1.0121197700500488,
0.25511905550956726,
-1.199713110923767,
0.1542150378227234,
1.2209070920944214,
-0.10410065203905106,
-0.41078588366508484,
0.0678720623254776,
-0.3399900197982788,
0.05292028188705444,
-0.48173969984054565,
0.8349908590316772,
1.0299309492111206,
0.07314519584178925,
0.0868593379855156,
-0.44181033968925476,
0.035221345722675323,
0.5275881886482239,
-0.7799191474914551,
-0.04385315626859665,
0.38834458589553833,
0.41799303889274597,
0.2218896746635437,
0.7300627827644348,
-0.04140900447964668,
0.41937369108200073,
0.2468402087688446,
-0.4645974338054657,
-0.10594199597835541,
-0.3258506655693054,
-0.14613120257854462,
0.29041793942451477,
0.17571695148944855,
0.3693506121635437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04696v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04696v2
|
Fact-Checking the Output of Large Language Models via Token-Level Uncertainty Quantification
| 2024-03-07T17:44:17 | 2024-06-06T21:32:39 |
Ekaterina Fadeeva, Aleksandr Rubashevskii, Artem Shelmanov, Sergey Petrakov, Haonan Li, Hamdy Mubarak, Evgenii Tsymbalov, Gleb Kuzmin, Alexander Panchenko, Timothy Baldwin, Preslav Nakov, Maxim Panov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are notorious for hallucinating, i.e., producing
erroneous claims in their output. Such hallucinations can be dangerous, as
occasional factual inaccuracies in the generated text might be obscured by the
rest of the output being generally factually correct, making it extremely hard
for the users to spot them. Current services that leverage LLMs usually do not
provide any means for detecting unreliable generations. Here, we aim to bridge
this gap. In particular, we propose a novel fact-checking and hallucination
detection pipeline based on token-level uncertainty quantification. Uncertainty
scores leverage information encapsulated in the output of a neural network or
its layers to detect unreliable predictions, and we show that they can be used
to fact-check the atomic claims in the LLM output. Moreover, we present a novel
token-level uncertainty quantification method that removes the impact of
uncertainty about what claim to generate on the current step and what surface
form to use. Our method Claim Conditioned Probability (CCP) measures only the
uncertainty of a particular claim value expressed by the model. Experiments on
the task of biography generation demonstrate strong improvements for CCP
compared to the baselines for seven LLMs and four languages. Human evaluation
reveals that the fact-checking pipeline based on uncertainty quantification is
competitive with a fact-checking tool that leverages external knowledge.
|
[
-0.21563173830509186,
-0.8352257013320923,
0.8337720036506653,
-0.021256472915410995,
-0.12105067074298859,
0.2316138595342636,
-0.1708393096923828,
-0.3550110459327698,
0.1289103478193283,
0.5731021165847778,
-0.5202206969261169,
-0.6484034657478333,
-0.6830765604972839,
-0.07536796480417252,
-0.39232006669044495,
0.7948690056800842,
0.199053555727005,
-0.09346546977758408,
-0.40284931659698486,
0.1520509421825409,
-0.26102787256240845,
-0.5855607390403748,
-0.8854578733444214,
-0.09531452506780624,
0.3981259763240814,
0.22148165106773376,
0.7225375771522522,
0.5819481611251831,
0.2798992395401001,
0.34459999203681946,
-0.1379767507314682,
0.49973824620246887,
-0.21226629614830017,
0.2847340703010559,
-0.057382047176361084,
-0.46116387844085693,
-0.38524723052978516,
-0.3318061828613281,
0.6692138314247131,
0.5351629853248596,
-0.09127436578273773,
0.22759652137756348,
-0.16660542786121368,
0.5225520730018616,
-0.7041488885879517,
0.2052600085735321,
-0.9300850629806519,
0.2433946281671524,
-0.2381424605846405,
-0.2466561645269394,
-0.6126917600631714,
-0.4227346181869507,
-0.3126158118247986,
-0.16061757504940033,
0.2502518594264984,
0.3244810700416565,
0.7638494968414307,
0.442705363035202,
-0.504501461982727,
-0.28274279832839966,
-0.8274102807044983,
0.5708425641059875,
-0.9074353575706482,
0.544051468372345,
0.4908180832862854,
0.14210385084152222,
-0.23218697309494019,
-0.6693505048751831,
-0.751220703125,
-0.32917946577072144,
-0.10323002934455872,
-0.1705501228570938,
-0.06609746068716049,
0.14177897572517395,
0.37812340259552,
0.2831002473831177,
-0.5850584506988525,
0.10560790449380875,
-0.2183765172958374,
-0.9188578724861145,
0.4395168423652649,
-0.09174713492393494,
0.39987993240356445,
-0.3466828465461731,
-0.18497200310230255,
-0.12859104573726654,
-0.8349489569664001,
-0.2728981077671051,
0.6034965515136719,
0.28284114599227905,
0.09397155791521072,
0.6754019260406494,
-0.2725256383419037,
0.36689019203186035,
-0.1219666451215744,
-0.15500114858150482,
0.03585474193096161,
-0.22919727861881256,
-0.05607181787490845,
0.26137810945510864,
0.8241711854934692,
0.031703729182481766,
-0.12181496620178223,
-0.33424273133277893,
-0.4127162992954254,
-0.14668165147304535,
0.12909799814224243,
-0.7877569794654846,
0.06644348055124283,
0.49211421608924866,
-0.2790772318840027,
-0.3663206100463867,
0.17594461143016815,
-0.7436800599098206,
-0.784107506275177,
0.026586929336190224,
0.5325942635536194,
-0.39697206020355225,
-0.26730379462242126,
-0.11229559779167175,
-0.015975655987858772,
-0.047686830163002014,
0.07670951634645462,
-0.6785000562667847,
0.052905116230249405,
0.8120238184928894,
0.9296064972877502,
-0.1195048987865448,
-0.23635144531726837,
-0.9396654367446899,
-0.020919281989336014,
-0.58461594581604,
0.5929775238037109,
-0.19696715474128723,
0.10284307599067688,
0.14521412551403046,
-0.2949465215206146,
0.27601754665374756,
-0.6795770525932312,
0.6403826475143433,
-0.5510807037353516,
0.0539671890437603,
-0.1971534937620163,
-0.5694801807403564,
0.10791555792093277,
0.20724532008171082,
-0.6532450914382935,
1.0073140859603882,
0.15954601764678955,
-0.7597424387931824,
0.5173938870429993,
-0.17540167272090912,
-0.36227065324783325,
0.050613075494766235,
-0.32749471068382263,
-0.6238752603530884,
0.1454552412033081,
0.1515422761440277,
0.38603225350379944,
-0.1251245141029358,
0.7545608282089233,
-0.3972407579421997,
-0.17752259969711304,
0.44053736329078674,
-0.708525538444519,
0.735222339630127,
0.22912462055683136,
-0.6700056195259094,
0.1331338733434677,
-1.0850993394851685,
-0.07757590711116791,
-0.19755646586418152,
-0.3710782825946808,
-0.05278058722615242,
0.08110421895980835,
-0.36236757040023804,
0.2995372414588928,
0.2651499807834625,
-0.665795087814331,
0.0071797724813222885,
-0.24190397560596466,
0.4496723413467407,
0.7666928768157959,
0.10919901728630066,
0.0451405830681324,
-0.2515297532081604,
0.3199821412563324,
0.30359500646591187,
0.10121220350265503,
-0.14924244582653046,
-0.3988643288612366,
-1.1205739974975586,
-0.055452730506658554,
0.4327158033847809,
0.2948802709579468,
-0.8786967396736145,
0.7880653738975525,
-0.28744077682495117,
-0.3874182403087616,
-0.3479066491127014,
-0.0006508465157821774,
0.1400275081396103,
0.4995596706867218,
0.13997238874435425,
-0.050624363124370575,
-0.7339969873428345,
-0.6988003849983215,
-0.3255460858345032,
-0.7366461157798767,
-0.0613480880856514,
-0.0675724446773529,
0.5688422918319702,
-0.11970554292201996,
0.9307319521903992,
-0.32817888259887695,
0.04222482815384865,
0.043033622205257416,
0.330750435590744,
0.11904917657375336,
0.46499040722846985,
0.16011841595172882,
-0.6775817275047302,
0.045254241675138474,
-0.11440352350473404,
-0.7413349747657776,
0.020958397537469864,
-0.470816433429718,
-0.049134448170661926,
0.40257060527801514,
0.6175273060798645,
-0.8659662008285522,
0.29465824365615845,
0.5308233499526978,
-0.5523163676261902,
0.7250341773033142,
-0.2576911747455597,
0.07180626690387726,
-0.8506715297698975,
0.0028689049649983644,
-0.15553119778633118,
-0.49741265177726746,
-0.2959842383861542,
0.07510349899530411,
0.08264987170696259,
0.05330469831824303,
-0.27410006523132324,
0.3019770383834839,
-0.15263739228248596,
-0.26423847675323486,
-0.1753496676683426,
-0.09749878942966461,
-0.06755919754505157,
0.3874286711215973,
-0.005998457316309214,
0.6210211515426636,
0.44774413108825684,
-0.4289614260196686,
0.42125412821769714,
-0.07095678150653839,
-0.6131709218025208,
0.20773638784885406,
-0.2794598639011383,
0.18294407427310944,
-0.06016111373901367,
0.22617921233177185,
-1.0776994228363037,
-0.2930256724357605,
0.2218828797340393,
-0.5676814913749695,
0.12910623848438263,
0.0043944185599684715,
-0.7571097016334534,
-0.31404706835746765,
-0.12780354917049408,
0.057367708534002304,
0.4359706938266754,
-0.4931751787662506,
0.8057028651237488,
0.14692355692386627,
-0.2030615657567978,
-0.735861599445343,
-0.8201296925544739,
0.37973910570144653,
-0.13576862215995789,
-0.5835257768630981,
0.20866428315639496,
0.08570368587970734,
-0.3587261140346527,
-0.0945175513625145,
-0.4079586863517761,
-0.12573888897895813,
0.26560208201408386,
0.4000210762023926,
0.3088460862636566,
-0.20829612016677856,
0.16685263812541962,
0.21611227095127106,
0.038016535341739655,
0.4571087062358856,
-0.44230133295059204,
0.6660164594650269,
-0.027153709903359413,
-0.652852475643158,
-0.2977607548236847,
-0.03531767055392265,
0.8102902173995972,
-0.07221750915050507,
0.9575155973434448,
0.8504485487937927,
-0.6803275346755981,
-0.4723901152610779,
-0.7106998562812805,
-0.4021645188331604,
-0.45796313881874084,
0.4071904420852661,
-0.07980820536613464,
-0.8714843392372131,
0.6654127836227417,
-0.04244975745677948,
-0.08876100182533264,
0.7198687791824341,
0.6054378747940063,
0.24075503647327423,
0.9063134789466858,
0.2774182856082916,
0.10457837581634521,
0.06539913266897202,
-0.10327327251434326,
0.49857816100120544,
-0.4370482265949249,
-0.33351239562034607,
-0.4653322696685791,
0.03895966708660126,
-0.5187564492225647,
-0.37447816133499146,
0.3823738694190979,
-0.020685337483882904,
-0.3681340515613556,
-0.0032859856728464365,
-0.25019827485084534,
0.33428460359573364,
0.6962622404098511,
0.21114365756511688,
0.5331035852432251,
-0.07561090588569641,
-0.10393843054771423,
0.12817683815956116,
-0.5651690363883972,
-0.5586356520652771,
0.9517648220062256,
0.44061461091041565,
0.34698179364204407,
0.1854550689458847,
0.7088546752929688,
0.6512489318847656,
0.19290652871131897,
-0.6900249123573303,
0.5806276202201843,
0.11875572800636292,
-0.7113956212997437,
-0.4992999732494354,
-0.7791085243225098,
-0.4233029782772064,
0.12256673723459244,
-0.4325656294822693,
-0.7200069427490234,
0.1345500648021698,
0.23478177189826965,
-0.6638014912605286,
0.6490768790245056,
-0.36631542444229126,
0.6947655081748962,
-0.33319059014320374,
-0.29993757605552673,
-0.13988825678825378,
-0.5331302285194397,
0.5797451734542847,
-0.2610023319721222,
0.30144232511520386,
0.02418060228228569,
0.25605711340904236,
0.5163934826850891,
-0.5520431995391846,
1.010216236114502,
-0.1712726205587387,
-0.28735336661338806,
0.2881007790565491,
0.457968533039093,
0.6621395945549011,
0.2505313754081726,
-0.20380179584026337,
0.25919151306152344,
-0.11357472091913223,
-0.03460177034139633,
-0.5040781497955322,
0.6246802806854248,
-0.6808563470840454,
-0.6516420245170593,
-0.5072588920593262,
-0.5465601682662964,
-0.2882917523384094,
0.28217291831970215,
0.4221062958240509,
0.3186686038970947,
-0.1039004847407341,
0.16393521428108215,
0.5280267596244812,
-0.4945184588432312,
0.2602696716785431,
0.23283225297927856,
-0.29032593965530396,
-0.3315318524837494,
1.153935194015503,
0.18272806704044342,
0.22419743239879608,
0.3326472342014313,
0.322258859872818,
-0.35461708903312683,
-0.8116783499717712,
-0.4151555299758911,
0.07109038531780243,
-0.816066563129425,
-0.35457634925842285,
-0.5979782938957214,
-0.39228707551956177,
-0.5350075364112854,
0.30058375000953674,
-0.4089016020298004,
-0.5215330123901367,
-0.12699759006500244,
-0.24339830875396729,
0.13479377329349518,
0.6837494373321533,
-0.2440236657857895,
0.12247218936681747,
-0.6248833537101746,
0.37056413292884827,
0.41996341943740845,
0.26047849655151367,
-0.061882566660642624,
-0.548994243144989,
-0.07978197187185287,
0.22955407202243805,
-0.35110241174697876,
-0.5633074641227722,
0.2716835141181946,
0.18068301677703857,
0.20389820635318756,
0.622645914554596,
0.2652548551559448,
0.32508689165115356,
-0.30392974615097046,
0.9283753633499146,
0.03347152844071388,
-1.2615574598312378,
0.3356824815273285,
-0.007423545699566603,
-0.19692258536815643,
0.33629485964775085,
0.14329636096954346,
-0.6697449684143066,
-0.668510913848877,
-0.7421800494194031,
-0.8385511636734009,
0.5875211358070374,
0.14283692836761475,
0.04663795232772827,
-0.08981523662805557,
0.4537949860095978,
0.14865058660507202,
0.41947805881500244,
-0.7282047271728516,
-0.20579589903354645,
-0.18221789598464966,
-0.2563936412334442,
0.12204849720001221,
-0.31333932280540466,
0.04123661667108536,
-0.04326664283871651,
0.7264893651008606,
-0.10765249282121658,
0.03391378000378609,
0.13812856376171112,
-0.11067996919155121,
-0.2537396252155304,
0.23494264483451843,
0.5707451105117798,
0.7585238814353943,
-0.2804446518421173,
0.6999740600585938,
0.16733518242835999,
-0.2983672320842743,
0.1749337911605835,
-0.29620689153671265,
-0.3811846077442169,
0.2781869173049927,
0.5707247853279114,
0.9158797860145569,
-0.09412120282649994,
-0.7613971829414368,
0.6581429243087769,
0.06662625074386597,
-0.03919108211994171,
-0.4873332977294922,
0.04011021554470062,
0.12512312829494476,
0.16953521966934204,
0.43452689051628113,
0.3029232323169708,
0.07487780600786209,
-0.705686092376709,
0.4141690731048584,
0.3852097690105438,
-0.12721967697143555,
-0.25231072306632996,
0.7051504254341125,
-0.0769134983420372,
-0.2362733781337738,
0.7235524654388428,
-0.4425887167453766,
-0.5529066920280457,
0.730512261390686,
0.5820245742797852,
0.7301022410392761,
0.020653000101447105,
0.5109021067619324,
0.39943671226501465,
0.4611544609069824,
-0.27642667293548584,
0.11159013211727142,
0.18155382573604584,
-0.8776350617408752,
-0.6578167676925659,
-0.6942892670631409,
-0.4047461450099945,
0.49452006816864014,
-0.5246763825416565,
0.14237749576568604,
-0.5804880857467651,
-0.2558727562427521,
-0.036706529557704926,
-0.2358095496892929,
-0.5512528419494629,
0.20144324004650116,
0.42012855410575867,
0.6547457575798035,
-0.9604512453079224,
0.5780394673347473,
0.13944795727729797,
-0.3476848006248474,
-0.6004003882408142,
0.28546905517578125,
0.054643888026475906,
-0.83040452003479,
0.8954669237136841,
0.05381051078438759,
-0.270467072725296,
-0.04038587212562561,
-0.6169095039367676,
-0.7477458715438843,
0.8566907644271851,
0.8490095734596252,
-0.65782630443573,
-0.08463594317436218,
0.2752629816532135,
0.43489301204681396,
-0.1615355908870697,
0.0920526534318924,
0.5097141861915588,
0.6133861541748047,
0.1238797977566719,
-0.4706094563007355,
0.30573317408561707,
0.17635013163089752,
-0.21387992799282074,
0.017040560021996498,
-0.5283238887786865,
0.856305718421936,
-0.2975562512874603,
-0.3581950068473816,
0.111660897731781,
0.9537543058395386,
0.3467097878456116,
0.32391196489334106,
0.6512032151222229,
0.4804006516933441,
1.130819320678711,
-0.15902186930179596,
0.8902407884597778,
-0.5389806628227234,
0.43300750851631165,
0.9962642788887024,
-0.2266649603843689,
0.8398247361183167,
0.5422487854957581,
-0.10302632302045822,
0.5799551606178284,
0.6611889004707336,
-0.08694710582494736,
0.11948812752962112,
0.4540823698043823,
-0.2525582015514374,
-0.5898845195770264,
-0.16793549060821533,
-0.04140230268239975,
0.397007554769516,
0.3503144085407257,
-0.24595916271209717,
0.062187451869249344,
-0.12524443864822388,
0.1545114666223526,
-0.11423949152231216,
-0.036262184381484985,
0.5750699043273926,
-0.07801824063062668,
-0.811913788318634,
0.5911925435066223,
-0.02009964920580387,
0.6485632061958313,
-0.4185364842414856,
-0.1070544645190239,
-0.22292762994766235,
-0.01739961840212345,
-0.3273610472679138,
-0.49005264043807983,
0.3134649097919464,
-0.003954541403800249,
0.019533688202500343,
0.05854788050055504,
0.6344310641288757,
-0.5402829051017761,
-0.5758538842201233,
0.011962388642132282,
0.6107584834098816,
0.11494363844394684,
-0.32183435559272766,
-0.3219674527645111,
0.2925318777561188,
-0.027551108971238136,
-0.07348453998565674,
0.052986033260822296,
0.5854678750038147,
0.017065852880477905,
0.7790019512176514,
0.5518950819969177,
0.4844719469547272,
0.0442068912088871,
0.05740923434495926,
0.5539726614952087,
-0.3792485296726227,
-0.17744910717010498,
-1.1198474168777466,
0.2789127826690674,
-0.13475146889686584,
-0.39500218629837036,
0.692541778087616,
0.6587442755699158,
0.7889497876167297,
0.02719210274517536,
0.9558331966400146,
-0.026702452450990677,
0.18661189079284668,
-0.7225372791290283,
0.8437262177467346,
-0.3894515037536621,
0.372792512178421,
-0.029102381318807602,
-0.8259668946266174,
-0.4060385823249817,
0.43959784507751465,
0.009619060903787613,
-0.04063418135046959,
0.8449975848197937,
0.8911306262016296,
-0.0026739761233329773,
-0.15417127311229706,
0.38904687762260437,
0.481776624917984,
0.25508013367652893,
0.2415977418422699,
0.9366461038589478,
-0.31456300616264343,
0.5301712155342102,
-0.25149834156036377,
0.025283869355916977,
-0.1829153448343277,
-1.0758949518203735,
-0.7708579897880554,
-0.6590231657028198,
-0.43727460503578186,
-0.7880386710166931,
-0.045499760657548904,
0.9228410720825195,
0.6489822864532471,
-1.0051331520080566,
0.011018048040568829,
-0.2531781494617462,
0.3604845702648163,
-0.20693284273147583,
-0.21282848715782166,
0.6218343377113342,
-0.3519851863384247,
-0.5802094340324402,
0.33316031098365784,
0.22035333514213562,
-0.09921129047870636,
-0.7025696039199829,
-0.013307071290910244,
0.20011287927627563,
0.07588500529527664,
0.44962823390960693,
0.03937342390418053,
-0.8590777516365051,
-0.6347039937973022,
-0.11662132292985916,
-0.05660778284072876,
-0.0626668632030487,
0.9450042843818665,
-0.5346002578735352,
0.3893832564353943,
0.5034584999084473,
0.8452621102333069,
0.2722368538379669,
-0.24755030870437622,
0.47665199637413025,
-0.9901231527328491,
-0.15347984433174133,
0.21430815756320953,
0.6043956875801086,
0.5195555686950684,
-0.5997632741928101,
0.2297346442937851,
0.38628944754600525,
-0.47333356738090515,
-1.0491960048675537,
0.24007418751716614,
-0.7413784861564636,
-0.3401530683040619,
1.1596202850341797,
-0.09354158490896225,
-0.2430228292942047,
-0.13138428330421448,
-0.07333314418792725,
0.47341370582580566,
-0.33670803904533386,
1.2633748054504395,
0.8905729055404663,
0.24016812443733215,
0.07760707288980484,
-0.5238385796546936,
0.5884043574333191,
0.3656489849090576,
-0.7674336433410645,
0.31193113327026367,
0.4882332980632782,
0.09083227068185806,
0.3755797743797302,
0.32493263483047485,
0.013106942176818848,
0.04200218245387077,
0.11260197311639786,
0.22256547212600708,
-0.15138515830039978,
-0.4334222674369812,
-0.0630437359213829,
0.2562800347805023,
0.24174544215202332,
0.05948730930685997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04671v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04671v1
|
Greater than the sum of its parts: The role of minority and majority status in collaborative problem-solving communication
| 2024-03-07T17:17:20 | 2024-03-07T17:17:20 |
Jacqueline G. Cavazos, Nia Nixon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Collaborative problem-solving (CPS) is a vital skill used both in the
workplace and in educational environments. CPS is useful in tackling
increasingly complex global, economic, and political issues and is considered a
central 21st century skill. The increasingly connected global community
presents a fruitful opportunity for creative and collaborative problem-solving
interactions and solutions that involve diverse perspectives. Unfortunately,
women and underrepresented minorities (URMs) often face obstacles during
collaborative interactions that hinder their key participation in these
problem-solving conversations. Here, we explored the communication patterns of
minority and non-minority individuals working together in a CPS task. Group
Communication Analysis (GCA), a temporally-sensitive computational linguistic
tool, was used to examine how URM status impacts individuals' sociocognitive
linguistic patterns. Results show differences across racial/ethnic groups in
key sociocognitive features that indicate fruitful collaborative interactions.
We also investigated how the groups' racial/ethnic composition impacts both
individual and group communication patterns. In general, individuals in more
demographically diverse groups displayed more productive communication
behaviors than individuals who were in majority-dominated groups. We discuss
the implications of individual and group diversity on communication patterns
that emerge during CPS and how these patterns can impact collaborative
outcomes.
|
[
-0.4551678001880646,
-0.5429790616035461,
0.2799409329891205,
0.6857360005378723,
-0.117535300552845,
0.9804835319519043,
-0.3094499111175537,
-0.6428980231285095,
0.42436572909355164,
0.03704584017395973,
-0.5390949845314026,
-0.488836407661438,
-0.9408127665519714,
0.22561535239219666,
0.02585950493812561,
0.8512362837791443,
0.010210682637989521,
0.008920458145439625,
-0.17625509202480316,
-0.28395208716392517,
-0.8283684253692627,
-0.7907321453094482,
-0.4305284023284912,
-0.1295403391122818,
0.2692592144012451,
0.6207254528999329,
0.5334883332252502,
0.23634977638721466,
0.44557052850723267,
0.39655786752700806,
-0.41130658984184265,
-0.04694148525595665,
-0.7294278740882874,
0.25424087047576904,
-0.19872477650642395,
-0.46604639291763306,
-0.06114260107278824,
-0.08105142414569855,
0.2616005539894104,
1.4888209104537964,
-0.4976752698421478,
0.12479017674922943,
0.44728076457977295,
0.6333138942718506,
-0.6342588067054749,
0.27962109446525574,
-0.5554168224334717,
0.12329407036304474,
-0.30993199348449707,
0.3867218494415283,
-0.022626202553510666,
-0.27802589535713196,
0.16334612667560577,
-0.659264087677002,
0.498617559671402,
-0.026000291109085083,
0.12446358799934387,
0.16587454080581665,
-0.3631365895271301,
-0.1383763551712036,
-0.5972649455070496,
0.7467724084854126,
-0.10975668579339981,
0.07208441197872162,
0.5593999028205872,
0.00609900476410985,
-0.5910895466804504,
0.019727863371372223,
-0.2361942082643509,
0.6203112602233887,
-0.18401212990283966,
0.22155028581619263,
-0.22432062029838562,
-0.1631367951631546,
0.05672978237271309,
0.29026225209236145,
-0.36707621812820435,
0.15216758847236633,
-0.8457551002502441,
-0.15313871204853058,
0.5922289490699768,
0.5442713499069214,
0.38291406631469727,
0.025594139471650124,
0.2182035595178604,
0.46583887934684753,
0.17971427738666534,
0.45361003279685974,
0.0583014078438282,
0.5209248661994934,
-0.6885296106338501,
0.3001355528831482,
-0.23182722926139832,
0.4686957895755768,
-0.06705088168382645,
-0.017345266416668892,
0.05362297594547272,
-0.7093361020088196,
-0.07897977530956268,
-0.04217487573623657,
0.36943838000297546,
0.22621867060661316,
0.2638400197029114,
-0.1747683584690094,
0.44025182723999023,
0.11622950434684753,
-0.013318672776222229,
-0.27631086111068726,
-0.12185777723789215,
-0.21788693964481354,
-0.7744007706642151,
0.01344451867043972,
0.05560080707073212,
-0.752277672290802,
-0.46903562545776367,
-0.25791165232658386,
-0.3965206742286682,
0.10641440004110336,
-0.5757544636726379,
0.021843580529093742,
-0.39270466566085815,
-0.14180442690849304,
0.42544135451316833,
-1.1028146743774414,
0.6421357989311218,
0.7086163759231567,
0.9046968817710876,
-0.2722828686237335,
-0.24036787450313568,
-0.11691931635141373,
0.16952596604824066,
-0.2591221034526825,
0.31200727820396423,
-0.5930473804473877,
-1.010114312171936,
-0.4350883364677429,
-0.1935877650976181,
-0.31233179569244385,
-0.8198515772819519,
0.24501657485961914,
0.07650822401046753,
0.13918755948543549,
-0.7101070880889893,
-0.09684285521507263,
0.05024062842130661,
-0.1328575164079666,
-0.4252583980560303,
0.5430632829666138,
0.1512361764907837,
-0.6400869488716125,
0.3844889998435974,
-0.3724994957447052,
-0.40087151527404785,
0.5521795153617859,
-0.5851415991783142,
-0.2899165451526642,
0.323727011680603,
-0.060380879789590836,
0.11051788926124573,
-0.05035239830613136,
0.11906246095895767,
-0.26989707350730896,
-0.5857007503509521,
0.23262888193130493,
0.1882583349943161,
1.0638097524642944,
-0.11916784942150116,
-0.4437315762042999,
-0.09035762399435043,
-0.1834823042154312,
-0.26073792576789856,
0.26222434639930725,
-0.2699659466743469,
-0.4679424464702606,
-0.06981290876865387,
-0.46701574325561523,
0.16439193487167358,
0.02232668548822403,
-0.40204158425331116,
0.06421193480491638,
0.3252702057361603,
0.16295015811920166,
0.8048936128616333,
0.07054086774587631,
0.25115230679512024,
-0.30599841475486755,
0.4955393075942993,
-0.21095317602157593,
0.32718348503112793,
0.23349535465240479,
-1.01592218875885,
-0.49893414974212646,
-0.3240320682525635,
-0.13515159487724304,
0.5525043606758118,
-0.44333118200302124,
0.2979153096675873,
0.0886443480849266,
-0.5831799507141113,
-0.2535114288330078,
0.3284206986427307,
0.47827738523483276,
0.1733679175376892,
0.3387318551540375,
-0.6661489009857178,
-0.6743549108505249,
-0.6638262271881104,
-0.14303015172481537,
-0.2596454322338104,
0.33386102318763733,
0.3514445424079895,
0.4528772532939911,
0.06743503361940384,
0.8593542575836182,
-0.4443027079105377,
-0.5667481422424316,
-0.5090785026550293,
0.3285612165927887,
0.19744403660297394,
0.5560499429702759,
0.2296503782272339,
-0.822999119758606,
-0.6699858903884888,
-0.26475587487220764,
-0.5558016896247864,
-0.19492214918136597,
0.27783283591270447,
-0.1679726541042328,
0.3726041615009308,
0.5646216869354248,
-0.011743474751710892,
0.7103071808815002,
0.9342191815376282,
-0.6094473600387573,
0.5561058521270752,
0.09985526651144028,
0.35157346725463867,
-0.6938925385475159,
-0.435453325510025,
0.06773823499679565,
0.4415455162525177,
-0.3552446663379669,
-0.5625487565994263,
-0.6503645181655884,
-0.15186059474945068,
-0.11725299805402756,
-0.028508754447102547,
-0.7299668788909912,
-0.2893429398536682,
0.13469918072223663,
-0.07717708498239517,
-0.46298569440841675,
0.4792981743812561,
0.061405036598443985,
0.6360297203063965,
0.4306998550891876,
-0.3445379436016083,
-0.1778760403394699,
0.3764621317386627,
-0.4041140079498291,
0.5372966527938843,
-0.5341354012489319,
0.18197789788246155,
-0.0775291845202446,
0.06297861784696579,
-0.8170080780982971,
0.05120088905096054,
0.13033825159072876,
-0.4809126853942871,
-0.17773176729679108,
-0.25632336735725403,
-0.3308658301830292,
-0.44519829750061035,
0.07954626530408859,
0.8217984437942505,
0.24119330942630768,
0.2543155252933502,
0.5160817503929138,
0.747193455696106,
-0.6680371165275574,
-0.43076226115226746,
-0.6889016032218933,
-0.015543649904429913,
0.019298046827316284,
-0.793521523475647,
0.36118900775909424,
-0.153633251786232,
-0.70953768491745,
-0.16338278353214264,
-0.14316408336162567,
-0.1537402719259262,
0.47958484292030334,
0.5535532236099243,
0.2622780203819275,
0.31655001640319824,
-0.19327755272388458,
-0.14544427394866943,
-0.11812776327133179,
-0.21766570210456848,
0.2622542381286621,
0.6534759402275085,
-0.20965304970741272,
-0.4763866066932678,
-0.02195035293698311,
1.0322058200836182,
0.4997295141220093,
-0.41134142875671387,
1.2014862298965454,
0.2579193413257599,
-0.2967330813407898,
0.21105965971946716,
-0.42335906624794006,
-0.049262505024671555,
-0.4475269019603729,
0.3281947076320648,
-0.02680855616927147,
-1.347755789756775,
0.9096413254737854,
0.3020240068435669,
-0.19117078185081482,
-0.2545118033885956,
0.4219542145729065,
-0.3128109872341156,
0.5993773341178894,
1.0423754453659058,
-0.10313127934932709,
0.5595600605010986,
-0.09321752935647964,
0.1941087543964386,
-0.6722913980484009,
-0.7131252288818359,
-0.6113201379776001,
-0.38840800523757935,
-0.4235100746154785,
-0.580588698387146,
0.6089945435523987,
0.31890007853507996,
-0.015059045515954494,
0.08118107914924622,
-0.6574699282646179,
0.4865179657936096,
0.4123970568180084,
-0.14866594970226288,
0.42392227053642273,
-0.020481113344430923,
-0.09871123731136322,
-0.5561496615409851,
-0.6678879261016846,
-0.15738771855831146,
0.7553447484970093,
-0.08478530496358871,
0.38405147194862366,
0.5988805890083313,
0.748749852180481,
0.45862680673599243,
0.21229495108127594,
-0.36484619975090027,
0.6638407111167908,
-0.34084630012512207,
-0.41254594922065735,
-0.22467392683029175,
-0.40793418884277344,
-1.1911747455596924,
0.47944122552871704,
-0.392898291349411,
-0.9452881813049316,
0.4580628573894501,
-0.18333306908607483,
-0.053234413266181946,
0.22621065378189087,
-0.6379396915435791,
0.8994194269180298,
0.02908826433122158,
-0.11855682730674744,
-0.4482977092266083,
-0.46792206168174744,
0.12344928830862045,
-0.0169315654784441,
0.5584272742271423,
-0.3469328284263611,
0.07801268249750137,
0.7210997939109802,
-0.2228488177061081,
0.9806623458862305,
-0.03756833076477051,
0.10021614283323288,
0.3501817286014557,
0.25139129161834717,
0.05285669490695,
-0.1667264848947525,
-0.0005836706259287894,
0.6273218989372253,
-0.7071583867073059,
-0.6673275828361511,
-0.2545310854911804,
0.2500128746032715,
-0.9031399488449097,
-0.8899839520454407,
-0.38228264451026917,
-0.5053659677505493,
0.14699240028858185,
-0.040454547852277756,
0.2491723895072937,
0.20401674509048462,
-0.19052435457706451,
0.11933518946170807,
0.30376937985420227,
0.24391330778598785,
0.6602944135665894,
0.6838451623916626,
0.21301263570785522,
-0.24802200496196747,
0.5427830815315247,
0.4485170543193817,
0.5006080269813538,
-0.2516721189022064,
-0.271770179271698,
0.2677818238735199,
-0.8077185750007629,
0.20620432496070862,
0.38596081733703613,
-0.5910707116127014,
0.23859287798404694,
-0.8431314826011658,
0.11390189081430435,
-0.3406296968460083,
-0.5654198527336121,
0.07607338577508926,
-0.26850974559783936,
-0.15111805498600006,
0.03932769596576691,
-0.161381334066391,
0.4880021810531616,
-0.21821407973766327,
-0.21990513801574707,
-0.7777644991874695,
0.1072235107421875,
0.6027829647064209,
0.09906818717718124,
0.24375447630882263,
-0.04256899282336235,
-0.468939870595932,
-0.24834273755550385,
-0.20514018833637238,
-0.9055735468864441,
0.001946339150890708,
-0.3282860815525055,
0.8866380453109741,
-0.3149757385253906,
0.030213551595807076,
0.5710204839706421,
-0.013524587266147137,
0.9371631145477295,
0.2838281989097595,
-1.0801762342453003,
0.36439844965934753,
-0.34410667419433594,
0.2914959788322449,
0.5946854948997498,
0.1693769246339798,
-0.9624005556106567,
-0.8248451352119446,
-0.40698668360710144,
-0.8583874106407166,
0.6822823286056519,
0.6857524514198303,
-0.24084573984146118,
-0.029186435043811798,
-0.11276783794164658,
-0.01674013026058674,
0.07622829079627991,
-0.4987794756889343,
-0.41540735960006714,
-0.16758012771606445,
0.1835571974515915,
0.1678466945886612,
-0.10193825513124466,
-0.3628314137458801,
-0.3567862808704376,
0.08376161009073257,
-0.12627367675304413,
0.1481124311685562,
0.14616678655147552,
0.20875298976898193,
-0.47840505838394165,
0.6463842391967773,
0.5667783617973328,
0.6260857582092285,
0.15463101863861084,
-0.11832720041275024,
0.21102190017700195,
-0.46969369053840637,
0.30016809701919556,
0.15916718542575836,
0.3408116400241852,
-0.3511772155761719,
0.5534916520118713,
0.21236982941627502,
-0.2151280790567398,
-0.2687267065048218,
0.18379686772823334,
-0.4261666536331177,
-0.12753751873970032,
-0.0685836523771286,
0.33399197459220886,
0.2720327079296112,
0.15777190029621124,
0.8425344228744507,
0.42181655764579773,
-0.03340572118759155,
-0.7625219225883484,
-0.19854043424129486,
0.36296430230140686,
-0.2984817922115326,
-0.015887824818491936,
0.13602113723754883,
0.6095560789108276,
-0.35150524973869324,
0.604070246219635,
-0.28097081184387207,
-0.7864779233932495,
0.9688423275947571,
0.3844969570636749,
0.663116455078125,
-0.010519308038055897,
0.30036628246307373,
-0.004328034818172455,
0.4172819256782532,
0.26625654101371765,
0.17740166187286377,
-0.3305068016052246,
-0.9360471367835999,
-0.47637057304382324,
-0.07427223771810532,
-0.6451011300086975,
-0.48480933904647827,
-0.7163276076316833,
-0.19598810374736786,
-0.36207568645477295,
-0.25800830125808716,
0.055734965950250626,
-0.055568575859069824,
-0.35453835129737854,
-0.0987543985247612,
0.32675987482070923,
0.3540850579738617,
-0.8310362100601196,
0.029167423024773598,
0.6756753921508789,
-0.11371255666017532,
-0.8392913341522217,
0.09321516007184982,
0.4203032851219177,
-0.45310842990875244,
0.83437180519104,
-0.09277796745300293,
-0.1849077045917511,
-0.31324976682662964,
-0.28845223784446716,
-0.7771435976028442,
0.9654386639595032,
0.19936615228652954,
-0.515023946762085,
0.3565290570259094,
0.1503886878490448,
0.5494546294212341,
-0.3569447994232178,
-0.05490487813949585,
0.35668835043907166,
0.3543625771999359,
-0.12493112683296204,
-1.581583023071289,
0.1060972660779953,
-0.43263372778892517,
0.043652378022670746,
0.28832337260246277,
-1.2015739679336548,
1.105026364326477,
-0.6142258048057556,
-0.3054669201374054,
-0.06390168517827988,
0.4478849470615387,
0.7015829682350159,
0.25770118832588196,
0.6163507699966431,
0.32662439346313477,
0.8168253302574158,
-0.2963182032108307,
0.6803397536277771,
0.23559699952602386,
-0.0002536653191782534,
0.9036429524421692,
-0.23957565426826477,
-0.005196059122681618,
0.10649603605270386,
-0.16537423431873322,
0.8474168181419373,
0.30075863003730774,
0.1756451427936554,
0.3167167603969574,
0.252134770154953,
-0.505037784576416,
-0.5040591955184937,
-0.5536744594573975,
-0.5910184979438782,
0.46398672461509705,
0.44192230701446533,
-0.06718581914901733,
0.1379234790802002,
-0.15030667185783386,
-0.051180414855480194,
0.49967747926712036,
-0.6316565871238708,
0.7121763825416565,
0.17512953281402588,
-0.556919515132904,
0.31437766551971436,
-0.16043420135974884,
0.7723020315170288,
-0.23535698652267456,
-0.1315287947654724,
-0.16629688441753387,
-0.047090794891119,
-0.6001939177513123,
-0.9347923994064331,
0.4732027053833008,
-0.09816519916057587,
-0.6310958862304688,
0.05019063875079155,
0.444324791431427,
-0.43364644050598145,
-0.20416496694087982,
0.7239620089530945,
0.7293734550476074,
-0.10414911806583405,
0.16369816660881042,
-0.6673799157142639,
0.3343488276004791,
0.23120439052581787,
0.6079662442207336,
0.2970554530620575,
0.38469192385673523,
-0.49620524048805237,
0.7256009578704834,
0.6883801817893982,
0.06640078127384186,
0.059333913028240204,
0.2932291328907013,
0.8604783415794373,
-0.5183684229850769,
-0.7654030323028564,
-0.653114378452301,
0.6009764671325684,
-0.24231529235839844,
-0.35243654251098633,
0.6951196789741516,
0.34278157353401184,
0.8496828079223633,
0.32066214084625244,
0.794868528842926,
-0.09104570746421814,
0.26308315992355347,
-0.12717384099960327,
0.3303176760673523,
-0.07432424277067184,
0.15899604558944702,
-0.6563441157341003,
-0.7413715720176697,
-0.05812714621424675,
0.3312542736530304,
-0.27722853422164917,
0.16676759719848633,
0.5073721408843994,
0.37088972330093384,
0.4050023555755615,
0.5750313997268677,
0.017493605613708496,
-0.0901770070195198,
0.46721625328063965,
0.6302663683891296,
0.8648754358291626,
0.32178929448127747,
0.8353677988052368,
-0.29204562306404114,
-0.3340604901313782,
0.06242767348885536,
-0.4745411276817322,
-0.9003749489784241,
-0.438864529132843,
-0.5002615451812744,
-0.082881860435009,
0.08969691395759583,
0.9009470343589783,
0.61594557762146,
-0.634611964225769,
-0.4485771954059601,
-0.005203575827181339,
0.4967651963233948,
-0.23843075335025787,
-0.2960243225097656,
-0.20741716027259827,
0.12513865530490875,
-0.47085699439048767,
0.18985523283481598,
0.4549109637737274,
0.4393154978752136,
-0.03961274027824402,
-0.12857666611671448,
0.06023401394486427,
-0.3095218539237976,
0.29258018732070923,
0.45686283707618713,
-0.4214784801006317,
0.1604786515235901,
-0.0456511527299881,
-0.16165927052497864,
-0.05810737609863281,
1.2944362163543701,
-0.49665194749832153,
0.33815354108810425,
0.14941279590129852,
0.281175434589386,
0.2446848452091217,
0.12019316107034683,
0.5599730610847473,
-0.6660367846488953,
0.39694181084632874,
0.4617680609226227,
0.45423653721809387,
0.5542565584182739,
-0.47034841775894165,
0.46300339698791504,
0.7938528060913086,
-0.5048338174819946,
-0.4926924705505371,
0.19292713701725006,
-0.7649360299110413,
-0.329968124628067,
0.7108376622200012,
-0.09493468701839447,
0.1747966706752777,
-1.0666524171829224,
-0.26928389072418213,
0.17005838453769684,
-0.7497710585594177,
0.7757744789123535,
0.7214862704277039,
-0.5241948366165161,
-0.36390402913093567,
0.14843401312828064,
0.29854467511177063,
0.8565821051597595,
-0.7532898187637329,
-0.08218026906251907,
0.3549630343914032,
-0.04393201693892479,
0.4939557611942291,
1.123262882232666,
-0.050461020320653915,
0.4498988389968872,
-0.24552074074745178,
-0.12694095075130463,
-0.1056547462940216,
-0.21657657623291016,
0.02534281462430954,
0.26281556487083435,
-0.25052911043167114,
-0.05841777101159096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04666v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04666v2
|
Telecom Language Models: Must They Be Large?
| 2024-03-07T17:13:12 | 2024-06-25T09:28:43 |
Nicola Piovesan, Antonio De Domenico, Fadhel Ayed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The increasing interest in Large Language Models (LLMs) within the
telecommunications sector underscores their potential to revolutionize
operational efficiency. However, the deployment of these sophisticated models
is often hampered by their substantial size and computational demands, raising
concerns about their viability in resource-constrained environments. Addressing
this challenge, recent advancements have seen the emergence of small language
models that surprisingly exhibit performance comparable to their larger
counterparts in many tasks, such as coding and common-sense reasoning. Phi-2, a
compact yet powerful model, exemplifies this new wave of efficient small
language models. This paper conducts a comprehensive evaluation of Phi-2's
intrinsic understanding of the telecommunications domain. Recognizing the
scale-related limitations, we enhance Phi-2's capabilities through a
Retrieval-Augmented Generation approach, meticulously integrating an extensive
knowledge base specifically curated with telecom standard specifications. The
enhanced Phi-2 model demonstrates a profound improvement in accuracy, answering
questions about telecom standards with a precision that closely rivals the more
resource-intensive GPT-3.5. The paper further explores the refined capabilities
of Phi-2 in addressing problem-solving scenarios within the telecom sector,
highlighting its potential and limitations.
|
[
-0.291068971157074,
-0.6728242635726929,
0.4967021048069,
0.2274179607629776,
-0.3501269519329071,
-0.3370034396648407,
-0.20243802666664124,
-0.7469595670700073,
-0.018638797104358673,
0.5376128554344177,
-0.2593323588371277,
0.2854374051094055,
-0.5691568851470947,
0.12863709032535553,
-0.36699461936950684,
0.37857311964035034,
0.4024094343185425,
-0.008430899120867252,
0.2295401394367218,
-0.04707012325525284,
-0.238877534866333,
-0.4427156448364258,
-0.7102407217025757,
-0.6790472865104675,
0.18347901105880737,
0.6489475965499878,
0.8564711809158325,
0.6357399225234985,
0.7659162878990173,
0.23183539509773254,
-0.2301834672689438,
0.11046597361564636,
-0.5324799418449402,
-0.043541405349969864,
-0.06767863035202026,
-0.5170366764068604,
-0.6424482464790344,
-0.15514078736305237,
0.7945701479911804,
1.0306129455566406,
-0.2184707671403885,
0.29715508222579956,
0.10857037454843521,
0.7311198115348816,
-0.3619115352630615,
0.21373718976974487,
-0.7026591300964355,
-0.17320193350315094,
-0.43796655535697937,
0.037096790969371796,
-0.43281084299087524,
-0.17639055848121643,
0.4992090165615082,
-0.5126420259475708,
-0.11066398024559021,
0.16983437538146973,
0.6164236664772034,
0.23103930056095123,
-0.8054383397102356,
-0.32474541664123535,
-0.8354418873786926,
0.8375184535980225,
-0.5207152962684631,
0.6200450658798218,
0.43478918075561523,
0.5035951733589172,
0.062260355800390244,
-0.8863011002540588,
-0.509084165096283,
-0.11369674652814865,
0.3201267123222351,
-0.10044605284929276,
-0.5180553793907166,
0.02182079665362835,
0.3919042944908142,
0.49939656257629395,
-0.16381879150867462,
0.44662705063819885,
-0.8147818446159363,
-0.10255061089992523,
0.3890376091003418,
0.13160529732704163,
0.20320141315460205,
-0.2033117562532425,
0.21556921303272247,
0.5290044546127319,
-0.9525882601737976,
-0.16837166249752045,
0.29882732033729553,
0.2639389634132385,
-0.21489611268043518,
0.9536231756210327,
-0.31704893708229065,
0.5562176704406738,
-0.04206627979874611,
-0.021315911784768105,
-0.2790931165218353,
-0.07608931511640549,
-0.4255158007144928,
-0.050391145050525665,
0.44855865836143494,
0.24847511947155,
0.3761817216873169,
-0.11834608763456345,
-0.12601828575134277,
-0.17635580897331238,
0.26445430517196655,
-0.9185886979103088,
-0.2902285158634186,
0.29238826036453247,
-0.6144078373908997,
-0.11320115625858307,
-0.13710740208625793,
-0.6090097427368164,
-0.4096110463142395,
-0.14696812629699707,
0.056089069694280624,
-0.2651439309120178,
-0.7108474373817444,
0.3498162627220154,
0.09005836397409439,
0.4890141487121582,
0.38886409997940063,
-1.104324460029602,
0.43070200085639954,
0.896221935749054,
0.8240386247634888,
0.1191149353981018,
0.20410004258155823,
-0.4564882814884186,
0.005804682150483131,
-0.5841826796531677,
0.433614045381546,
-0.3355720639228821,
-0.5317716598510742,
0.08150897920131683,
-0.24341537058353424,
0.2671510577201843,
-0.7569935321807861,
0.6753741502761841,
-0.9201538562774658,
0.11440505087375641,
-0.47595033049583435,
-0.3701595664024353,
-0.17278289794921875,
-0.170026496052742,
-0.7910174131393433,
0.8617954850196838,
0.43639788031578064,
-0.6319173574447632,
-0.0168423131108284,
-0.47903087735176086,
-0.29173603653907776,
0.11108846217393875,
-0.06337376683950424,
-0.30938413739204407,
0.6138856410980225,
-0.31371086835861206,
0.06394779682159424,
-0.9717363119125366,
0.013273535296320915,
-0.4520152509212494,
-0.30653882026672363,
0.18149107694625854,
-0.1719007045030594,
0.9588303565979004,
0.3965604901313782,
-0.32905304431915283,
-0.4721285402774811,
-0.7175683379173279,
0.2829141616821289,
0.0627724751830101,
-0.36767110228538513,
-0.2593821585178375,
-0.1209653913974762,
0.04257309064269066,
0.19206005334854126,
0.3045230507850647,
-0.4165560007095337,
0.08131761103868484,
-0.5646399259567261,
0.6476029753684998,
0.4327794313430786,
-0.2520131468772888,
0.7978830933570862,
-0.13789619505405426,
0.28544241189956665,
-0.13630570471286774,
0.047690995037555695,
-0.010686375200748444,
-0.471051424741745,
-1.0272318124771118,
-0.020927730947732925,
0.25482285022735596,
0.4680282175540924,
-0.6305509805679321,
0.08741137385368347,
-0.5996831059455872,
-0.5615567564964294,
-0.14179638028144836,
0.18090738356113434,
0.1830587238073349,
0.44012975692749023,
0.3007363975048065,
-0.12765775620937347,
-0.5007839798927307,
-1.2180627584457397,
-0.10778432339429855,
-0.2532100975513458,
-0.130301833152771,
0.48492568731307983,
0.22402609884738922,
-0.2662341892719269,
0.8810548186302185,
-0.38602104783058167,
-0.16702072322368622,
-0.5348352193832397,
-0.2053041011095047,
0.05276454612612724,
0.33487915992736816,
0.35409611463546753,
-0.8303396105766296,
-0.13140282034873962,
0.11970944702625275,
-0.7586392164230347,
-0.34801730513572693,
0.10462193191051483,
0.4332713484764099,
0.00040137325413525105,
0.18403898179531097,
-0.603584349155426,
0.003955052699893713,
0.4502396881580353,
-0.05121989548206329,
0.6170508861541748,
-0.33208346366882324,
-0.20843571424484253,
-0.7464762330055237,
0.036638665944337845,
0.25224003195762634,
-0.007915710099041462,
-0.7865621447563171,
0.14438869059085846,
0.25480231642723083,
-0.5304409861564636,
-0.3435511589050293,
0.4974404573440552,
-0.522505521774292,
-0.5849955677986145,
-0.3761412799358368,
0.10401298850774765,
-0.18695604801177979,
0.29024529457092285,
-0.004826533142477274,
1.0798954963684082,
0.45381486415863037,
-0.7268726825714111,
0.4193460941314697,
0.081404909491539,
-0.6379579305648804,
0.28591859340667725,
-0.9936379790306091,
0.16463349759578705,
0.17157867550849915,
0.08027128875255585,
-0.717930793762207,
-0.5201601982116699,
-0.08539967983961105,
-0.04151303693652153,
0.06585144251585007,
-0.25410839915275574,
-0.756288468837738,
-0.25680890679359436,
0.03606708347797394,
0.7692089676856995,
0.5558529496192932,
-0.43993017077445984,
0.5423856377601624,
0.636860728263855,
-0.3457525372505188,
-0.17895691096782684,
-0.7988444566726685,
0.19642654061317444,
-0.34164756536483765,
-0.9315013289451599,
0.1610655039548874,
0.41921505331993103,
-0.5043073296546936,
-0.399954229593277,
-0.21973636746406555,
-0.45780161023139954,
0.07586444914340973,
-0.04398193210363388,
0.061264604330062866,
-0.35829198360443115,
0.23515820503234863,
-0.010198986157774925,
-0.1634100079536438,
0.21012040972709656,
-0.5482020974159241,
0.4384818971157074,
-0.30699479579925537,
-0.2617495656013489,
-0.6532005071640015,
0.3430408239364624,
0.7582684755325317,
-0.3862076699733734,
0.32022127509117126,
0.1723122000694275,
-0.48059630393981934,
-0.18506722152233124,
-0.8000209927558899,
-0.17786531150341034,
-0.5181167721748352,
0.4514728784561157,
-0.5474884510040283,
-0.9330126047134399,
0.5412326455116272,
-0.5932538509368896,
-0.0958266630768776,
0.4182751178741455,
0.4082482159137726,
0.06471534818410873,
0.7759988903999329,
0.8938828110694885,
0.10869836062192917,
0.3537205457687378,
-0.38145458698272705,
0.42299044132232666,
-0.9006452560424805,
-0.3061853349208832,
-0.6184197068214417,
0.03262464702129364,
-0.5236592292785645,
-0.5023412704467773,
0.5238938927650452,
0.2546033561229706,
-0.36194488406181335,
0.33531051874160767,
-0.12289756536483765,
0.2230728566646576,
0.2863653302192688,
0.037857502698898315,
0.39772650599479675,
0.2972676753997803,
0.10329350084066391,
-0.1070215180516243,
-0.7800690531730652,
-0.6075887084007263,
1.0829055309295654,
0.652228593826294,
0.7072627544403076,
0.8124794363975525,
0.17361044883728027,
0.09985285252332687,
-0.07218580693006516,
-0.8813437819480896,
0.4661271274089813,
-0.3637387454509735,
-0.4725622534751892,
-0.34571269154548645,
-0.5790262222290039,
-0.6919890642166138,
-0.0242854543030262,
0.1246909573674202,
-0.9148645997047424,
0.2984215319156647,
0.09673379361629486,
-0.5753525495529175,
0.19079235196113586,
-0.7299767136573792,
0.5063206553459167,
-0.11317997425794601,
-0.5152235627174377,
-0.504952073097229,
-0.1539490818977356,
0.6256323456764221,
-0.36273273825645447,
0.0771724060177803,
0.0430249460041523,
-0.4481774866580963,
0.5289592742919922,
-0.5594708919525146,
0.603722095489502,
0.16818484663963318,
-0.40784206986427307,
0.4709981083869934,
0.24451293051242828,
0.5122904181480408,
0.04955630376935005,
-0.5581137537956238,
0.15720801055431366,
-0.01791028305888176,
-0.3542897701263428,
-0.6650466918945312,
0.5520187616348267,
-0.7470952868461609,
-0.5525459051132202,
-0.062185171991586685,
-0.3133854269981384,
-0.3116501271724701,
0.3626350462436676,
0.45404770970344543,
0.8684284687042236,
0.10690343379974365,
0.4747774004936218,
0.938022792339325,
-0.3691599667072296,
0.1568387746810913,
0.3860153257846832,
-0.2636106610298157,
-0.04247064143419266,
0.6732462048530579,
0.4088796079158783,
0.3201769292354584,
0.1706710159778595,
-0.031891025602817535,
-0.6896489858627319,
-0.601753294467926,
-0.31073400378227234,
0.34454765915870667,
-0.5270193815231323,
-0.0683414489030838,
-0.6127647161483765,
-0.20925448834896088,
-0.2351321280002594,
0.20141790807247162,
-0.572371244430542,
-0.9049944877624512,
-0.20244352519512177,
0.20051118731498718,
0.010818994604051113,
0.6108883023262024,
-0.05985252559185028,
0.7307890057563782,
-0.49678653478622437,
0.36667585372924805,
0.5040490627288818,
0.691114068031311,
-0.06734564900398254,
-0.7246533632278442,
-0.23445552587509155,
-0.0014873233158141375,
-0.3692193031311035,
-0.8738214373588562,
0.07750561833381653,
0.19038967788219452,
0.24681338667869568,
0.30118703842163086,
0.0436379499733448,
0.3266069293022156,
-0.47040945291519165,
0.7349261045455933,
0.2507821023464203,
-0.9618977904319763,
0.48450422286987305,
-0.6044295430183411,
0.1434277594089508,
0.0945618748664856,
-0.08438186347484589,
-0.39489316940307617,
0.09456119686365128,
-0.7016757726669312,
-0.4842459559440613,
0.5689270496368408,
0.2829119563102722,
0.42720144987106323,
0.13180755078792572,
0.5426060557365417,
-0.3748476207256317,
0.03743525594472885,
-0.5278490781784058,
-0.19709643721580505,
0.1044793576002121,
0.16099479794502258,
0.36642369627952576,
-0.881713330745697,
0.14985749125480652,
0.05183067172765732,
0.4970051348209381,
0.06411846727132797,
0.3428693413734436,
-0.02110716886818409,
0.0012916545383632183,
-0.22568775713443756,
0.37587010860443115,
0.51053786277771,
0.9929254055023193,
0.025123734027147293,
0.007241941522806883,
0.34907880425453186,
-0.3035220503807068,
0.050205130130052567,
-0.03934183344244957,
0.04995797947049141,
-0.04903978854417801,
0.14594054222106934,
0.24458950757980347,
0.30879297852516174,
-0.6351557374000549,
0.3778601586818695,
0.12279374897480011,
0.15610922873020172,
-0.42549291253089905,
0.05693165212869644,
0.05053263157606125,
0.20422609150409698,
0.6521987915039062,
-0.0870959684252739,
0.28241026401519775,
-0.5710885524749756,
0.20869503915309906,
0.36753374338150024,
-0.17409729957580566,
-0.1689337193965912,
0.680799663066864,
0.5147073864936829,
-0.48162686824798584,
0.8491687178611755,
-0.23217107355594635,
-0.501510739326477,
0.7028319239616394,
0.45578017830848694,
0.5830336809158325,
-0.17189529538154602,
-0.08205543458461761,
0.264014333486557,
0.49692502617836,
-0.44253668189048767,
0.22154836356639862,
0.09039746224880219,
-0.6684567332267761,
-0.3980060815811157,
-0.24464426934719086,
-0.3538212180137634,
0.3136391341686249,
-0.5406181216239929,
0.3901340365409851,
-0.7090312242507935,
-0.4265126585960388,
0.019160056486725807,
0.4054936468601227,
-0.6405759453773499,
0.10632054507732391,
-0.04741806909441948,
1.3002387285232544,
-0.20996206998825073,
1.2427319288253784,
0.4109206199645996,
-0.03579993546009064,
-0.9961339235305786,
-0.0984048992395401,
0.13565683364868164,
-0.6529101133346558,
0.9919374585151672,
0.04604247584939003,
-0.23660847544670105,
0.21254582703113556,
0.060402851551771164,
-0.6310084462165833,
1.1128666400909424,
0.5138670206069946,
-0.6686856746673584,
-0.14698755741119385,
0.30413326621055603,
0.4453100562095642,
-0.26091140508651733,
0.2670159935951233,
0.6348448991775513,
0.06082861125469208,
-0.1443289816379547,
-1.459964394569397,
-0.2606273889541626,
-0.09960012882947922,
0.21008211374282837,
0.06100734323263168,
-0.8954532146453857,
0.8075340390205383,
-0.4518723487854004,
-0.3178858458995819,
0.24229402840137482,
0.6520094275474548,
0.07302630692720413,
0.07597663998603821,
0.46664106845855713,
0.306087464094162,
0.7265262603759766,
-0.11802854388952255,
1.030813455581665,
-0.4137793481349945,
0.36066630482673645,
1.0081859827041626,
-0.33559033274650574,
0.7826261520385742,
0.3701471984386444,
-0.18080101907253265,
0.11968138813972473,
0.525833010673523,
0.19828227162361145,
0.21678422391414642,
0.13086220622062683,
-0.30340924859046936,
-0.4312836229801178,
-0.10468260943889618,
-0.44362545013427734,
0.8041017055511475,
0.4313618540763855,
-0.24344488978385925,
-0.33646148443222046,
-0.3040555417537689,
-0.18256573379039764,
0.0731927901506424,
-0.28574416041374207,
0.4965634346008301,
0.3655160069465637,
-0.4927532970905304,
0.46859821677207947,
0.4952789843082428,
0.3592255115509033,
-0.5598779320716858,
0.14244510233402252,
-0.28776705265045166,
0.25873512029647827,
0.004425989929586649,
-0.5582813620567322,
0.557069718837738,
0.2073993980884552,
0.014778846874833107,
-0.006500303279608488,
0.6425071358680725,
-0.10724896192550659,
-0.4821642339229584,
0.2298431694507599,
0.5464993715286255,
0.1050398200750351,
-0.09895598888397217,
-0.5902653336524963,
0.3470473885536194,
-0.11442198604345322,
0.1069585308432579,
0.2100939303636551,
0.5834836363792419,
0.13064922392368317,
1.034197211265564,
0.3791767954826355,
0.36604374647140503,
-0.033891305327415466,
-0.1172897219657898,
0.7301854491233826,
-0.17329031229019165,
-0.6485445499420166,
-0.5354956388473511,
0.17680944502353668,
-0.2668150067329407,
-0.2237841784954071,
0.6194682717323303,
0.9168718457221985,
0.4969593584537506,
0.18464526534080505,
0.782703697681427,
0.07553987950086594,
0.3502216637134552,
-0.322780042886734,
0.3923938572406769,
-0.5133430361747742,
0.9961702227592468,
0.09856598824262619,
-1.0055310726165771,
0.03126213699579239,
0.6553897261619568,
-0.6737580895423889,
-0.03423269838094711,
0.3024022877216339,
0.8592421412467957,
-0.4564109444618225,
0.355270117521286,
0.2959662973880768,
0.06249314174056053,
0.3490050733089447,
0.6250250935554504,
0.704352855682373,
-0.6181555390357971,
0.8041088581085205,
-0.26111915707588196,
-0.3743411898612976,
-0.4284653067588806,
-0.6462178230285645,
-0.5598345398902893,
-0.4965793788433075,
-0.1999426931142807,
-0.3874667286872864,
-0.014550712890923023,
0.7494367361068726,
0.8477820754051208,
-0.44700655341148376,
-0.489762544631958,
-0.009040841832756996,
0.08201945573091507,
-0.020452488213777542,
-0.17054985463619232,
0.20930346846580505,
-0.42781397700309753,
-0.681928813457489,
0.10294117033481598,
0.5211111307144165,
0.23744253814220428,
-0.3023874759674072,
0.044173870235681534,
0.4783121347427368,
0.16904905438423157,
0.8178760409355164,
0.3405388593673706,
-0.7774540185928345,
-0.2668451964855194,
0.09964996576309204,
-0.3508433401584625,
-0.3573000133037567,
1.2651393413543701,
-0.4569840431213379,
0.22085778415203094,
0.2919178307056427,
0.7725239992141724,
0.2259167581796646,
-0.13355374336242676,
0.7935923337936401,
-0.44396284222602844,
0.2376083880662918,
0.11887751519680023,
0.519166111946106,
0.30694445967674255,
-0.367087185382843,
0.5873695015907288,
0.11176743358373642,
-0.5455402135848999,
-0.82297283411026,
0.7245192527770996,
-1.0462812185287476,
-0.23788049817085266,
1.4145535230636597,
0.14259546995162964,
0.2799108028411865,
-0.35785818099975586,
-0.09078451246023178,
0.11987205594778061,
-0.14102040231227875,
0.8090261220932007,
0.5509822964668274,
-0.023358698934316635,
-0.4513833820819855,
-0.8026142716407776,
0.5124238133430481,
0.38191238045692444,
-0.6542208194732666,
0.44793957471847534,
0.5048030614852905,
0.2873581647872925,
0.09206069260835648,
0.9171134233474731,
-0.0846385657787323,
0.40499454736709595,
0.07255639135837555,
-0.769841194152832,
-0.1759483367204666,
-0.2888505756855011,
-0.2880202531814575,
0.29621490836143494,
0.2644038498401642,
0.18187002837657928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04656v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04656v2
|
Chain of Thought Explanation for Dialogue State Tracking
| 2024-03-07T16:59:55 | 2024-03-09T15:37:36 |
Lin Xu, Ningxin Peng, Daquan Zhou, See-Kiong Ng, Jinlan Fu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dialogue state tracking (DST) aims to record user queries and goals during a
conversational interaction achieved by maintaining a predefined set of slots
and their corresponding values. Current approaches decide slot values opaquely,
while humans usually adopt a more deliberate approach by collecting information
from relevant dialogue turns and then reasoning the appropriate values. In this
work, we focus on the steps needed to figure out slot values by proposing a
model named Chain-of-Thought-Explanation (CoTE) for the DST task. CoTE, which
is built on the generative DST framework, is designed to create detailed
explanations step by step after determining the slot values. This process leads
to more accurate and reliable slot values. More-over, to improve the reasoning
ability of the CoTE, we further construct more fluent and high-quality
explanations with automatic paraphrasing, leading the method CoTE-refined.
Experimental results on three widely recognized DST benchmarks-MultiWOZ 2.2,
WoZ 2.0, and M2M-demonstrate the remarkable effectiveness of the CoTE.
Furthermore, through a meticulous fine-grained analysis, we observe significant
benefits of our CoTE on samples characterized by longer dialogue turns, user
responses, and reasoning steps.
|
[
-0.8311471939086914,
-1.0079071521759033,
0.8697470426559448,
-0.24519188702106476,
-0.48106324672698975,
0.07983113080263138,
0.11098697036504745,
-0.32356470823287964,
0.3974438011646271,
0.6740837097167969,
-1.1653664112091064,
-0.30298811197280884,
-0.2424708753824234,
-0.13481199741363525,
-0.5087736248970032,
1.328540325164795,
-0.014979338273406029,
-0.3064362704753876,
0.10320587456226349,
0.11535648256540298,
-0.4087095856666565,
-0.5441678166389465,
-0.7115232348442078,
-0.33020877838134766,
0.6487438082695007,
0.006518369074910879,
0.6880301833152771,
0.3097926080226898,
0.15325699746608734,
0.23012779653072357,
-0.13783253729343414,
0.2475823611021042,
-0.3997042775154114,
0.022031564265489578,
-0.36894387006759644,
-0.3433265686035156,
-0.862835705280304,
-0.04496932402253151,
0.30668407678604126,
0.5805882811546326,
-0.26952600479125977,
0.09459589421749115,
0.01900361478328705,
0.88945072889328,
-0.46007001399993896,
0.07565680146217346,
-0.507366955280304,
0.007075518369674683,
-0.05799077823758125,
-0.40284109115600586,
-0.22315087914466858,
-0.44833773374557495,
0.5076634883880615,
-0.43106114864349365,
0.30242493748664856,
0.030389532446861267,
0.676453173160553,
0.18656207621097565,
-0.5356916189193726,
-0.25372326374053955,
-0.8978214263916016,
0.5734548568725586,
-0.5280122756958008,
0.19425547122955322,
0.36444148421287537,
0.288504034280777,
-0.1552223265171051,
-0.5635246634483337,
-0.8203755021095276,
0.05426037311553955,
0.10595816373825073,
0.34302499890327454,
0.0022621378302574158,
0.4108848571777344,
0.6615552306175232,
0.5119842290878296,
-0.3356401324272156,
-0.2262016087770462,
-0.2296748012304306,
-0.23641304671764374,
0.6554587483406067,
0.3320535719394684,
0.19979988038539886,
-0.19779716432094574,
-0.6995078921318054,
0.20150278508663177,
-0.6248666644096375,
0.2141268104314804,
0.251572847366333,
0.12417740374803543,
0.07100402563810349,
0.3968609869480133,
-0.22162240743637085,
1.0264917612075806,
0.029626667499542236,
0.06765703856945038,
-0.31502005457878113,
-0.5897228717803955,
-0.21461249887943268,
0.07982588559389114,
0.7812609076499939,
0.6363224983215332,
-0.05162932723760605,
0.03233221173286438,
-0.30770570039749146,
0.14004558324813843,
0.44190162420272827,
-0.5199676156044006,
-0.13926662504673004,
0.25847214460372925,
-0.42842456698417664,
-0.16479693353176117,
-0.20964457094669342,
-0.7930246591567993,
-0.2656135857105255,
-0.6004313826560974,
0.33253538608551025,
-0.3650382459163666,
-0.565499484539032,
0.21079257130622864,
-0.14324118196964264,
0.018398940563201904,
0.6664363741874695,
-0.8348073959350586,
0.578805148601532,
0.613415539264679,
0.9522520899772644,
-0.36893779039382935,
0.19566412270069122,
-0.1712809056043625,
-0.028416676446795464,
-0.2569792866706848,
1.01119065284729,
-0.13620412349700928,
-0.22313964366912842,
-0.3031166195869446,
-0.14952461421489716,
-0.2967589497566223,
-0.04580229893326759,
0.44918060302734375,
-0.6045799255371094,
0.15042033791542053,
-0.7063553333282471,
-0.7260374426841736,
-0.29083868861198425,
0.3150996267795563,
-0.7493979930877686,
0.9475892186164856,
-0.06716632843017578,
-0.8117498755455017,
0.1649525910615921,
-0.7331011295318604,
-0.20864622294902802,
0.07417702674865723,
-0.18166369199752808,
-0.07603048533201218,
0.19172140955924988,
0.15312612056732178,
0.24138261377811432,
-0.4925377368927002,
0.3116978108882904,
-0.23013857007026672,
-0.35673195123672485,
0.7083892226219177,
-0.6349877715110779,
0.8151758909225464,
0.23885194957256317,
-0.4137992262840271,
-0.05221736803650856,
-0.6182067394256592,
0.2038635015487671,
-0.39221009612083435,
0.19498784840106964,
-0.24599963426589966,
0.3243117034435272,
-0.35829487442970276,
0.574954628944397,
-0.16312019526958466,
-0.6025044918060303,
-0.08415079861879349,
-0.21146519482135773,
0.6532601118087769,
0.9496614933013916,
0.4083130359649658,
0.07426665723323822,
-0.43786099553108215,
0.6934676170349121,
0.06379714608192444,
0.14874938130378723,
-0.1232152208685875,
-0.5650718212127686,
-0.7138893604278564,
0.04156265780329704,
0.015899764373898506,
0.3333669900894165,
-0.9213476777076721,
0.3947564959526062,
-0.029891440644860268,
-0.17895716428756714,
-0.4244665205478668,
-0.42423415184020996,
0.36458855867385864,
0.6865730285644531,
0.3085290789604187,
-0.41497156023979187,
-0.31952497363090515,
-0.8639734387397766,
-0.15492354333400726,
-0.1299600899219513,
0.12309037894010544,
0.14020191133022308,
0.6176986694335938,
0.17380134761333466,
1.171250343322754,
-0.8448318839073181,
0.17560680210590363,
-0.5211572051048279,
0.2577390670776367,
0.14449933171272278,
0.3826752007007599,
0.0005016739596612751,
-0.8028430938720703,
-0.2452586591243744,
-0.11521357297897339,
-0.38849061727523804,
0.15589217841625214,
-0.3938677906990051,
-0.3708128035068512,
-0.07228107750415802,
0.32906901836395264,
-0.4907245635986328,
0.9410496950149536,
0.23780134320259094,
-0.07091011852025986,
0.8421046733856201,
0.09172769635915756,
0.252794474363327,
-1.1387368440628052,
-0.14177311956882477,
0.18150223791599274,
-0.27311113476753235,
-0.6321681141853333,
-0.5209804177284241,
-0.12160199880599976,
-0.2254185676574707,
-0.3660220801830292,
0.12344755232334137,
-0.16381068527698517,
-0.33008062839508057,
-0.2198382019996643,
0.5770167112350464,
0.0515657514333725,
0.8642907738685608,
0.11579578369855881,
0.8693931102752686,
0.37656843662261963,
-0.9794381260871887,
0.596604585647583,
0.2240176945924759,
-0.48317718505859375,
0.9411286115646362,
-0.7651543021202087,
0.37363338470458984,
-0.028590818867087364,
0.6450862884521484,
-1.1917097568511963,
0.1827123463153839,
-0.05174737423658371,
-0.23264352977275848,
-0.23841159045696259,
-0.2571755051612854,
-0.27557963132858276,
-0.5491349101066589,
-0.13229131698608398,
0.31471627950668335,
0.36855190992355347,
-0.5260672569274902,
0.3927418291568756,
0.48248565196990967,
0.12387658655643463,
-0.20761312544345856,
-0.3484622538089752,
-0.03961566463112831,
-0.26064592599868774,
-0.6410828232765198,
0.5191938281059265,
-0.10010475665330887,
-0.1956886649131775,
-0.2560625374317169,
-0.6100588440895081,
-0.1494542956352234,
0.0823495015501976,
-0.03533681482076645,
0.38211512565612793,
-0.0392313227057457,
0.2750575840473175,
0.09102461487054825,
-0.2966468632221222,
0.3092151880264282,
-0.5953943133354187,
0.5285255908966064,
-0.2667666971683502,
-0.30629631876945496,
-1.0009548664093018,
0.2572370767593384,
0.5085182785987854,
-0.11934871226549149,
0.5866507887840271,
0.3476959764957428,
-0.28444620966911316,
-0.3728466331958771,
-0.4378405809402466,
-0.2633408308029175,
-0.4492286443710327,
-0.0077887955121695995,
-0.795529305934906,
-0.5685426592826843,
0.6650524735450745,
-0.32323718070983887,
-0.05717620998620987,
0.38652628660202026,
0.24210955202579498,
-0.5676803588867188,
1.3028144836425781,
0.29800501465797424,
0.2007942944765091,
0.48486998677253723,
-0.3994758129119873,
0.36815640330314636,
-1.3531094789505005,
-0.14026962220668793,
-0.3123277723789215,
-0.31687772274017334,
-0.5538230538368225,
-0.27974486351013184,
0.4801842272281647,
0.15398535132408142,
-0.008262068033218384,
0.6290626525878906,
-0.3907177448272705,
0.36367267370224,
0.4874885380268097,
0.4059223532676697,
0.2953799068927765,
-0.23859098553657532,
-0.17883236706256866,
0.02799275331199169,
-0.6383153796195984,
-0.3573150932788849,
0.7066195011138916,
0.03930459916591644,
0.9408601522445679,
0.10157987475395203,
0.6640714406967163,
0.4911617934703827,
-0.25471243262290955,
-0.699013352394104,
0.7789071798324585,
0.06366220861673355,
-0.665843665599823,
-0.3498212695121765,
-0.3063105046749115,
-0.7688800096511841,
0.4004479646682739,
0.12518519163131714,
-1.1723408699035645,
-0.064816415309906,
0.3537835478782654,
-0.6568471789360046,
0.34945249557495117,
-0.3832886517047882,
0.6890227794647217,
-0.2460804581642151,
-0.42971742153167725,
-0.5502146482467651,
-0.7143313884735107,
0.41526103019714355,
0.2646693289279938,
-0.12692339718341827,
-0.1867140680551529,
0.38498276472091675,
0.8799902200698853,
-0.8144851922988892,
0.8945371508598328,
-0.08015212416648865,
-0.30620965361595154,
0.6549753546714783,
0.06543587893247604,
0.5269538164138794,
-0.02204645425081253,
0.01307629607617855,
-0.11044836789369583,
0.044915005564689636,
-0.2143741101026535,
-0.9305279850959778,
0.611900806427002,
-0.45655596256256104,
-0.647877037525177,
-0.4787531793117523,
-0.5516595244407654,
-0.11142461746931076,
-0.013480473309755325,
0.3108622431755066,
1.0468207597732544,
-0.2531893253326416,
-0.20659582316875458,
1.0387383699417114,
-0.2281610369682312,
0.33915895223617554,
0.4005131721496582,
-0.13128547370433807,
-0.23844435811042786,
0.7868461012840271,
0.057676706463098526,
0.7415734529495239,
0.5213881134986877,
0.11746755987405777,
-0.5904092192649841,
-0.3004816174507141,
-0.575056791305542,
0.057891447097063065,
-0.5418472290039062,
0.03379269689321518,
-0.6345888376235962,
-0.22787480056285858,
-0.14831283688545227,
-0.025000644847750664,
-0.3805667757987976,
-0.7431623935699463,
0.06424183398485184,
-0.30665159225463867,
0.29235607385635376,
0.8811862468719482,
0.3069007694721222,
0.32444748282432556,
-0.46364375948905945,
0.5248100161552429,
0.4182162284851074,
0.4314574897289276,
0.1403532475233078,
-0.18226684629917145,
-0.2541278302669525,
0.47196003794670105,
-0.5576689839363098,
-0.9934044480323792,
0.059163883328437805,
-0.09430471062660217,
0.5163607597351074,
0.3525581955909729,
0.22093412280082703,
1.1272327899932861,
-0.2459179013967514,
1.060254454612732,
0.41609206795692444,
-1.2865232229232788,
1.0272574424743652,
-0.44197922945022583,
0.3329639434814453,
0.32187843322753906,
0.13423877954483032,
-0.7948096990585327,
-0.36443623900413513,
-0.7088191509246826,
-0.5459978580474854,
0.9962397813796997,
0.30494213104248047,
-0.35727009177207947,
-0.19755984842777252,
0.36760470271110535,
0.046200696378946304,
0.23384666442871094,
-0.531127393245697,
-0.15957821905612946,
-0.11476808041334152,
0.11382964253425598,
0.10452685505151749,
-0.12949898838996887,
-0.30514392256736755,
-0.21000999212265015,
0.6525652408599854,
-0.20397640764713287,
0.6297089457511902,
0.31509658694267273,
-0.28930023312568665,
-0.05000646039843559,
0.3711937665939331,
0.8252589106559753,
1.032686471939087,
-0.11733319610357285,
0.2618529200553894,
0.14775559306144714,
-0.1044289693236351,
0.03958362340927124,
-0.21412473917007446,
-0.27948951721191406,
-0.02442440576851368,
0.09537140280008316,
1.16409170627594,
0.07461387664079666,
-0.23972584307193756,
0.443912535905838,
-0.09564463794231415,
-0.13024719059467316,
-0.37724360823631287,
0.1840399205684662,
-0.011705930344760418,
0.1322554349899292,
0.008552627637982368,
0.2700810134410858,
0.40942466259002686,
-0.5322427749633789,
0.15210828185081482,
0.27936550974845886,
-0.7581978440284729,
-0.6370182037353516,
0.4976029098033905,
0.4721437692642212,
-0.34632188081741333,
0.7892379760742188,
-0.237113356590271,
-0.8398047089576721,
0.6801038384437561,
0.6167630553245544,
1.0834133625030518,
-0.03161526843905449,
0.62246173620224,
0.3633241653442383,
0.08699460327625275,
-0.3220375180244446,
0.40314093232154846,
-0.5522844791412354,
-0.8646835684776306,
-0.48481205105781555,
-0.39847809076309204,
-0.4372459352016449,
0.12296456843614578,
-1.3089938163757324,
-0.01550041139125824,
-0.19849178194999695,
-0.5288407206535339,
0.07790739089250565,
-0.0900348573923111,
-0.7228561639785767,
0.23652277886867523,
0.042825084179639816,
0.8642299175262451,
-0.8245164155960083,
0.8581534624099731,
0.21516643464565277,
-0.4493478536605835,
-0.5868669748306274,
0.17492809891700745,
0.28865960240364075,
-0.7703790664672852,
0.4430650770664215,
0.1690070480108261,
-0.6279717683792114,
-0.009209970012307167,
-0.21856412291526794,
-0.8556430339813232,
1.0224242210388184,
-0.15824440121650696,
-0.8402533531188965,
0.0077780429273843765,
-0.17290061712265015,
0.690694272518158,
-0.23671193420886993,
0.4297655522823334,
0.9154711365699768,
0.09674117714166641,
0.06612774729728699,
-0.936471164226532,
0.14531397819519043,
0.012462764978408813,
0.35849058628082275,
0.617660403251648,
-0.5687152147293091,
0.685053288936615,
-0.2757980525493622,
-0.3112052083015442,
0.04158701002597809,
0.5113909244537354,
-0.10820205509662628,
0.34971883893013,
0.8072476387023926,
0.5377858877182007,
0.8625051975250244,
-0.29412370920181274,
1.1208229064941406,
-0.20802822709083557,
0.30339136719703674,
1.2362161874771118,
-0.3293517231941223,
0.46681103110313416,
0.4209703505039215,
-0.4182979166507721,
0.9735478162765503,
0.7644177675247192,
0.43703433871269226,
0.6304785013198853,
0.40479913353919983,
-0.46247991919517517,
-0.17914019525051117,
-0.021876731887459755,
-0.20314060151576996,
0.151497021317482,
0.6744011640548706,
-0.19335584342479706,
0.00024344222038052976,
0.22475896775722504,
-0.1467968225479126,
-0.1775209903717041,
-0.40821170806884766,
1.0647246837615967,
0.12627758085727692,
-1.2327899932861328,
0.47747430205345154,
-0.4726094901561737,
0.09392155706882477,
-0.5285937190055847,
0.017201805487275124,
-0.09025172144174576,
0.33354631066322327,
-0.05654585734009743,
-0.8694614171981812,
0.12017841637134552,
0.031225571408867836,
-0.0693589299917221,
-0.5316122174263,
0.43696513772010803,
-0.5031532049179077,
-0.2339213341474533,
0.11262086778879166,
0.3686527907848358,
0.3707457482814789,
-0.009071671403944492,
-0.880635142326355,
0.05003711208701134,
0.2516365945339203,
-0.09054998308420181,
0.04706836864352226,
0.46239379048347473,
-0.3162243366241455,
0.6690233945846558,
0.5156171321868896,
0.02651112712919712,
-0.2592732906341553,
0.2835228145122528,
0.932908296585083,
-0.8974829316139221,
-0.8116113543510437,
-0.9037941694259644,
0.5177088975906372,
-0.4726874530315399,
-0.48037558794021606,
0.577191948890686,
0.372602254152298,
0.6430685520172119,
0.2497047781944275,
0.8962517976760864,
-0.1965995728969574,
0.6095420718193054,
-0.7109336256980896,
0.18980549275875092,
-0.15266533195972443,
0.6269305944442749,
-0.5292471647262573,
-0.925378680229187,
0.42569994926452637,
0.7376279234886169,
-0.24429930746555328,
-0.2246929258108139,
1.2182222604751587,
0.550821840763092,
0.05423944443464279,
0.7005560994148254,
0.03633929416537285,
0.12946875393390656,
0.5558562874794006,
0.6235057711601257,
1.12275230884552,
-0.3116356432437897,
0.2961015999317169,
-0.3744621276855469,
-0.44678565859794617,
0.13893166184425354,
-0.7586732506752014,
-0.9101806879043579,
-0.7692525386810303,
-0.5554613471031189,
-0.5572608113288879,
0.0762450248003006,
0.9012715816497803,
0.7939003705978394,
-0.6631202697753906,
-0.4346773028373718,
-0.47905611991882324,
0.2856924533843994,
-0.8173584342002869,
-0.24124716222286224,
0.3412303626537323,
-0.3076857626438141,
-0.4535369277000427,
0.364784836769104,
0.34325528144836426,
0.011571022681891918,
-0.21119169890880585,
0.09643559902906418,
-0.2533409893512726,
0.13992992043495178,
0.6670026183128357,
0.010827996768057346,
-0.9954760074615479,
-0.28589463233947754,
-0.2017187476158142,
0.06049954891204834,
-0.08441761136054993,
1.2749838829040527,
-0.7695448398590088,
0.8185122609138489,
0.4124634563922882,
0.14921914041042328,
1.1613014936447144,
0.29232513904571533,
1.092675805091858,
-0.5129655599594116,
-0.1874884068965912,
0.23910407721996307,
0.19326913356781006,
0.020654549822211266,
-0.33885806798934937,
0.378569632768631,
0.12907806038856506,
-0.5132728219032288,
-0.6665756106376648,
0.7485361099243164,
-1.1587791442871094,
-0.13159805536270142,
0.8133363723754883,
-0.2884069085121155,
-0.1154320016503334,
-0.4036797881126404,
-0.3279676139354706,
0.2779511511325836,
-0.49731117486953735,
0.9142871499061584,
0.8084272146224976,
-0.6684280037879944,
-0.15487079322338104,
-0.43760788440704346,
0.8974254727363586,
0.10400307178497314,
-0.9086241126060486,
0.11919195204973221,
0.29029402136802673,
0.0959555059671402,
0.0502639003098011,
1.0404304265975952,
0.048675164580345154,
0.3274242579936981,
-0.0757952481508255,
-0.297078400850296,
0.303644061088562,
-0.16718162596225739,
-0.06240483745932579,
-0.290864497423172,
-0.5075834393501282,
-0.37467336654663086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04652v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04652v1
|
Yi: Open Foundation Models by 01.AI
| 2024-03-07T16:52:49 | 2024-03-07T16:52:49 |
01. AI, :, Alex Young, Bei Chen, Chao Li, Chengen Huang, Ge Zhang, Guanwei Zhang, Heng Li, Jiangcheng Zhu, Jianqun Chen, Jing Chang, Kaidong Yu, Peng Liu, Qiang Liu, Shawn Yue, Senbin Yang, Shiming Yang, Tao Yu, Wen Xie, Wenhao Huang, Xiaohui Hu, Xiaoyi Ren, Xinyao Niu, Pengcheng Nie, Yuchi Xu, Yudong Liu, Yue Wang, Yuxuan Cai, Zhenyu Gu, Zhiyuan Liu, Zonghong Dai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce the Yi model family, a series of language and multimodal models
that demonstrate strong multi-dimensional capabilities. The Yi model family is
based on 6B and 34B pretrained language models, then we extend them to chat
models, 200K long context models, depth-upscaled models, and vision-language
models. Our base models achieve strong performance on a wide range of
benchmarks like MMLU, and our finetuned chat models deliver strong human
preference rate on major evaluation platforms like AlpacaEval and Chatbot
Arena. Building upon our scalable super-computing infrastructure and the
classical transformer architecture, we attribute the performance of Yi models
primarily to its data quality resulting from our data-engineering efforts. For
pretraining, we construct 3.1 trillion tokens of English and Chinese corpora
using a cascaded data deduplication and quality filtering pipeline. For
finetuning, we polish a small scale (less than 10K) instruction dataset over
multiple iterations such that every single instance has been verified directly
by our machine learning engineers. For vision-language, we combine the chat
language model with a vision transformer encoder and train the model to align
visual representations to the semantic space of the language model. We further
extend the context length to 200K through lightweight continual pretraining and
demonstrate strong needle-in-a-haystack retrieval performance. We show that
extending the depth of the pretrained checkpoint through continual pretraining
further improves performance. We believe that given our current results,
continuing to scale up model parameters using thoroughly optimized data will
lead to even stronger frontier models.
|
[
-0.31362226605415344,
-0.5971202254295349,
0.2728762626647949,
0.10575056821107864,
0.10788518190383911,
-0.2072886824607849,
-0.18668092787265778,
-0.5723302960395813,
-0.24234463274478912,
0.6308596134185791,
-0.5423353314399719,
-0.2945103645324707,
-0.28978702425956726,
-0.2433001548051834,
-0.4596576392650604,
0.8793275356292725,
0.1756211370229721,
-0.0020977258682250977,
-0.047603413462638855,
-0.358432799577713,
-0.2359572947025299,
-0.3367825150489807,
-0.7319024801254272,
-0.24602407217025757,
0.4591445028781891,
0.3475489914417267,
1.0775489807128906,
0.8992433547973633,
0.5240499973297119,
0.300711989402771,
0.14962267875671387,
0.009547160007059574,
-0.7048407196998596,
-0.2879517078399658,
0.009174364618957043,
-0.44706082344055176,
-0.6142503619194031,
-0.14427828788757324,
0.6213662624359131,
0.9075668454170227,
-0.05037742480635643,
0.11591838300228119,
-0.041174016892910004,
0.6936517357826233,
-0.7097150087356567,
0.37855151295661926,
-0.44937407970428467,
-0.033314622938632965,
-0.4950312674045563,
0.2970866560935974,
-0.46881869435310364,
-0.16163140535354614,
0.4271119236946106,
-0.7587042450904846,
0.14381162822246552,
-0.01713087409734726,
1.0581891536712646,
0.13213761150836945,
-0.46646082401275635,
0.12209481000900269,
-0.9739368557929993,
0.7281185388565063,
-0.7476705312728882,
0.8594850897789001,
0.08193213492631912,
0.36311206221580505,
0.02277435176074505,
-1.0420078039169312,
-0.7100692391395569,
-0.2910606861114502,
-0.11057131737470627,
-0.002313785720616579,
-0.07199577987194061,
0.49799013137817383,
0.2630240321159363,
0.7210073471069336,
-0.7095017433166504,
0.08531343191862106,
-0.3994601368904114,
0.034740615636110306,
0.6504445672035217,
0.22397272288799286,
0.4695030152797699,
0.2675655484199524,
-0.2718183100223541,
-0.3405815064907074,
-0.7128780484199524,
0.1515602469444275,
0.16873054206371307,
0.4127844572067261,
-0.10920190811157227,
0.48071467876434326,
-0.6367981433868408,
0.8363237380981445,
-0.13726001977920532,
-0.323941171169281,
0.20716999471187592,
-0.6178322434425354,
-0.3633810877799988,
-0.5203452110290527,
0.8233762383460999,
0.07809906452894211,
0.23067842423915863,
-0.3327217400074005,
-0.1617983877658844,
-0.02574354037642479,
0.22700154781341553,
-0.7402226328849792,
-0.2736365795135498,
0.11963944137096405,
-0.7521892189979553,
-0.009728733450174332,
0.22689729928970337,
-0.7720703482627869,
-0.15836688876152039,
-0.37245631217956543,
0.654923141002655,
-0.4947901964187622,
-0.4899463951587677,
0.47642582654953003,
0.23780149221420288,
0.29475364089012146,
0.2490060031414032,
-1.0063121318817139,
0.4050906002521515,
0.4925753176212311,
0.7611639499664307,
-0.029828565195202827,
-0.4084570109844208,
-0.3358607292175293,
-0.008391368202865124,
-0.5839887857437134,
0.4719350039958954,
-0.4300333559513092,
-0.18292249739170074,
0.13182707130908966,
-0.11116909235715866,
-0.18972277641296387,
-0.34773916006088257,
0.470260351896286,
-0.6403740048408508,
0.20566318929195404,
-0.03852158039808273,
-0.28814002871513367,
-0.2902640104293823,
-0.0006488602957688272,
-0.9635655879974365,
0.8757484555244446,
0.44025009870529175,
-0.5120880007743835,
0.5035486817359924,
-0.9864574670791626,
-0.1466970294713974,
0.24214673042297363,
-0.05798264592885971,
-0.23073196411132812,
0.09000514447689056,
0.18883691728115082,
0.24857302010059357,
-0.46762609481811523,
0.24634334444999695,
-0.35686585307121277,
-0.34787023067474365,
-0.17825736105442047,
-0.37049028277397156,
0.8832054138183594,
0.373783141374588,
-0.3027486205101013,
0.4133813679218292,
-0.8668279647827148,
0.13887929916381836,
-0.015598027966916561,
-0.07836258411407471,
-0.29256486892700195,
-0.012288479134440422,
0.18148869276046753,
0.25385531783103943,
0.16702257096767426,
-0.4621593952178955,
0.23109954595565796,
-0.6557770371437073,
0.3611084222793579,
0.4670354127883911,
-0.4468763470649719,
0.4529815912246704,
-0.0861143097281456,
0.442478209733963,
0.12755070626735687,
0.2715959846973419,
-0.5735918879508972,
-0.3071528971195221,
-1.0389021635055542,
-0.23986811935901642,
0.31317338347435,
0.4088364839553833,
-0.7562267184257507,
0.290938138961792,
-0.4881839454174042,
-0.4873102903366089,
-0.6543503999710083,
-0.03219457343220711,
0.48590725660324097,
0.2976599931716919,
0.3487052023410797,
-0.33558031916618347,
-0.1963038295507431,
-1.036790132522583,
0.054508574306964874,
-0.3332504332065582,
-0.03014816716313362,
0.3519705832004547,
0.4392724633216858,
-0.3004508912563324,
1.0079901218414307,
-0.5100549459457397,
-0.1415509730577469,
-0.429230660200119,
0.03232065960764885,
0.10822266340255737,
0.3627105951309204,
0.7862508893013,
-1.0901318788528442,
-0.3861556053161621,
0.18240270018577576,
-0.7158301472663879,
0.177322655916214,
-0.015328659676015377,
-0.13309797644615173,
0.09335070103406906,
0.3012934923171997,
-0.7947365641593933,
0.5704809427261353,
0.44994956254959106,
-0.3767058849334717,
0.5494334101676941,
-0.02237989753484726,
0.2672145664691925,
-1.079052209854126,
0.15071545541286469,
-0.008356336504220963,
0.10319829732179642,
-0.8035272359848022,
0.46769431233406067,
0.03327609598636627,
-0.3380213975906372,
-0.5597139596939087,
0.7354045510292053,
-0.3864290416240692,
-0.1716892123222351,
-0.04009798541665077,
-0.011185983195900917,
0.086780846118927,
0.47338613867759705,
0.07140661031007767,
0.7226070761680603,
0.6075265407562256,
-0.7266603708267212,
0.5705316066741943,
0.29888463020324707,
-0.5808078050613403,
0.3096165657043457,
-0.8079187273979187,
0.024806568399071693,
0.04092401638627052,
0.07183833420276642,
-0.8538545370101929,
-0.4920516908168793,
-0.09752178192138672,
-0.3078005611896515,
0.165888249874115,
0.0666772797703743,
-0.5022196173667908,
-0.5955612063407898,
-0.044443000108003616,
0.4559953808784485,
0.19119121134281158,
-0.7514946460723877,
0.6655651330947876,
0.14355194568634033,
0.0715743750333786,
-0.7125188708305359,
-0.4961543083190918,
-0.07503741979598999,
-0.09479143470525742,
-1.0152394771575928,
0.49742555618286133,
-0.18172641098499298,
-0.18909749388694763,
0.17826715111732483,
0.13454821705818176,
-0.3442879021167755,
0.1670943796634674,
0.17891699075698853,
0.40784797072410583,
-0.5942644476890564,
0.09018386155366898,
-0.37506812810897827,
-0.0733187347650528,
-0.15986007452011108,
-0.511447548866272,
0.5462051033973694,
-0.30082646012306213,
-0.4809095561504364,
-0.3790714740753174,
0.08098845928907394,
0.6680908799171448,
-0.590185821056366,
1.0820642709732056,
0.5183327198028564,
-0.7264344096183777,
-0.1606479287147522,
-0.37630319595336914,
-0.008171730674803257,
-0.44872045516967773,
0.6012117862701416,
-0.6282232403755188,
-0.9312452077865601,
0.5662546157836914,
0.18974454700946808,
0.35598471760749817,
0.41514942049980164,
0.4001735746860504,
0.39491865038871765,
1.2083256244659424,
1.143255591392517,
-0.3611496686935425,
0.49615278840065,
-0.2568643391132355,
0.4446925222873688,
-0.3472369313240051,
-0.2079680860042572,
-0.5992191433906555,
0.06326932460069656,
-0.379056453704834,
-0.16463737189769745,
0.20030279457569122,
0.3246879279613495,
-0.37308499217033386,
0.380005419254303,
-0.14653365314006805,
0.38998931646347046,
0.6313335299491882,
-0.08398822695016861,
0.31336528062820435,
-0.197037011384964,
0.09667380899190903,
0.08714669942855835,
-0.7005704641342163,
-0.3899015486240387,
1.1596708297729492,
0.51706463098526,
0.8478061556816101,
-0.01879459246993065,
0.2888556718826294,
-0.13059942424297333,
0.20715780556201935,
-0.5821477770805359,
0.37304553389549255,
-0.3046685755252838,
-0.7489175796508789,
-0.43022626638412476,
-0.4412393867969513,
-0.5305996537208557,
0.0711667612195015,
-0.2752836048603058,
-0.8203945755958557,
0.05011402815580368,
0.13575023412704468,
-0.5536198019981384,
0.4341157376766205,
-0.5926288366317749,
1.2607203722000122,
-0.3074505925178528,
-0.37429311871528625,
-0.23335199058055878,
-0.4643039405345917,
0.691694438457489,
-0.06468553096055984,
-0.029194779694080353,
0.2533925473690033,
0.3433912992477417,
0.569818913936615,
-0.25397390127182007,
0.45775502920150757,
-0.05785531923174858,
0.13390032947063446,
0.2683376669883728,
-0.09816630929708481,
0.03359316289424896,
0.03298274427652359,
-0.04612909257411957,
0.270045667886734,
0.025385165587067604,
-0.20922809839248657,
-0.6332045793533325,
0.5646588802337646,
-1.0449589490890503,
-0.4623996913433075,
-0.06542859971523285,
-0.5452703833580017,
-0.2037501484155655,
0.5276944637298584,
0.222190722823143,
0.688475489616394,
-0.3465532660484314,
0.7156305313110352,
0.6896932721138,
-0.41089412569999695,
0.1914137899875641,
0.35759633779525757,
-0.3867686986923218,
-0.28062868118286133,
0.7947031259536743,
0.11673291027545929,
0.38532283902168274,
0.4945831000804901,
-0.0652005597949028,
-0.19599978625774384,
-0.5685526132583618,
-0.7990391850471497,
0.06142662465572357,
-0.4887481927871704,
-0.1499558538198471,
-0.7742790579795837,
-0.5968739986419678,
-0.6727864742279053,
0.06818506121635437,
-0.6371679306030273,
-0.22174671292304993,
0.015642227604985237,
-0.08319570869207382,
0.07385818660259247,
0.8366908431053162,
0.1424846351146698,
0.6345807313919067,
-0.8472499251365662,
0.512687623500824,
0.23630815744400024,
0.7903900146484375,
0.07147596031427383,
-0.31175801157951355,
-0.6367367506027222,
0.24076634645462036,
-0.3082556426525116,
-0.5371215343475342,
0.2638343870639801,
0.36335742473602295,
0.759371817111969,
0.7985182404518127,
-0.03071480616927147,
0.8670657873153687,
-0.38242822885513306,
0.9640365242958069,
-0.018961338326334953,
-0.885282576084137,
0.4062010645866394,
-0.3768153190612793,
0.18828636407852173,
0.47662654519081116,
0.4834901988506317,
-0.45802462100982666,
-0.15162871778011322,
-0.5233030319213867,
-0.7038294672966003,
0.9749706387519836,
0.010870900005102158,
0.09295062720775604,
0.11996732652187347,
0.5311146974563599,
0.042342253029346466,
0.09242174029350281,
-0.9497274160385132,
-0.30834895372390747,
-0.438690721988678,
-0.3851219117641449,
-0.10409148782491684,
-0.16951905190944672,
0.078316330909729,
0.017736762762069702,
0.5936645865440369,
-0.30163243412971497,
0.14386670291423798,
-0.1978374719619751,
0.06600337475538254,
-0.10743675380945206,
0.07047319412231445,
0.2379884123802185,
0.8220670819282532,
-0.06163414567708969,
-0.43958553671836853,
-0.048707108944654465,
-0.3781490623950958,
-0.11611852794885635,
0.21211500465869904,
-0.276215523481369,
-0.30564382672309875,
0.5838514566421509,
1.0957814455032349,
0.11335141211748123,
-0.7040514349937439,
0.4846683442592621,
-0.113568514585495,
-0.14326292276382446,
-0.24396024644374847,
0.3590339422225952,
0.0014158515259623528,
0.268334299325943,
0.33335497975349426,
-0.1845158189535141,
0.26217934489250183,
-0.6285701990127563,
0.22300773859024048,
0.5419985055923462,
-0.3061434328556061,
-0.4836955964565277,
0.8737941980361938,
0.03465752303600311,
-0.08425330370664597,
0.9510354399681091,
0.09427773952484131,
-0.44725510478019714,
0.5110895037651062,
0.5220980048179626,
0.8226511478424072,
-0.17205557227134705,
0.16160228848457336,
0.5305780172348022,
0.2785674035549164,
-0.44700887799263,
0.01782793551683426,
0.05637941136956215,
-0.932318925857544,
-0.37893304228782654,
-0.7490056157112122,
-0.44032856822013855,
0.43054160475730896,
-0.7316316962242126,
0.4564894437789917,
-0.2729686498641968,
-0.011427249759435654,
-0.1761612445116043,
0.17623889446258545,
-0.8317824006080627,
0.49322420358657837,
0.19519279897212982,
1.1984915733337402,
-0.7039243578910828,
0.9590595960617065,
0.5799576640129089,
-0.6139818429946899,
-0.9955683946609497,
-0.04313140735030174,
-0.057090383023023605,
-0.3773018717765808,
0.7111576199531555,
0.35061752796173096,
-0.019939756020903587,
0.08220870047807693,
-0.5526900291442871,
-1.0975520610809326,
1.2123980522155762,
0.2598855793476105,
-0.47363901138305664,
-0.39319419860839844,
0.1453678160905838,
0.6136128306388855,
-0.5607963800430298,
0.3902996778488159,
0.47409626841545105,
0.1633591502904892,
-0.047480806708335876,
-1.0116064548492432,
-0.37076467275619507,
-0.2793485224246979,
0.08797338604927063,
0.09826759994029999,
-0.8005656003952026,
1.2074624300003052,
-0.33175012469291687,
-0.408096045255661,
0.37553367018699646,
0.9633243680000305,
0.17041559517383575,
0.35855045914649963,
0.6037321090698242,
0.6194866299629211,
0.4404837191104889,
-0.2718961536884308,
0.8705599308013916,
-0.6523299813270569,
0.12766031920909882,
0.8713057041168213,
-0.41134265065193176,
0.788638710975647,
-0.1338588297367096,
-0.11747909337282181,
0.5301921963691711,
0.5331728458404541,
0.22696073353290558,
0.4834842383861542,
-0.13782884180545807,
-0.11891964077949524,
-0.0877949446439743,
-0.08443746715784073,
-0.3321712017059326,
0.6228111982345581,
0.32616907358169556,
-0.11947104334831238,
0.009062129072844982,
0.15031418204307556,
-0.26303353905677795,
0.08745132386684418,
-0.2676156163215637,
0.5853204131126404,
-0.10472418367862701,
-0.6807897090911865,
0.18338043987751007,
0.204135000705719,
0.5555382370948792,
-0.8443783521652222,
-0.05967336893081665,
-0.29578834772109985,
0.4266899824142456,
-0.07617151737213135,
-0.5180282592773438,
0.2525518238544464,
-0.29384487867355347,
-0.09957363456487656,
-0.06374670565128326,
0.750274121761322,
-0.4062597453594208,
-0.36598411202430725,
0.484496146440506,
0.4958750605583191,
-0.1867348700761795,
0.09622542560100555,
-0.5875964164733887,
0.12122417986392975,
-0.11178843677043915,
-0.5083571076393127,
0.24317032098770142,
0.6367266774177551,
-0.2505277693271637,
0.8674330711364746,
0.7276903986930847,
0.07590136677026749,
0.03943035006523132,
0.10782327502965927,
1.0209300518035889,
-0.6395267248153687,
-0.5796974301338196,
-0.5707125067710876,
0.4937376081943512,
0.07441539317369461,
-0.43191608786582947,
0.5758552551269531,
0.5322802066802979,
1.2901337146759033,
0.002762486692517996,
0.7054261565208435,
-0.19326192140579224,
0.3815039396286011,
-0.4446457326412201,
0.8391503691673279,
-0.7087929844856262,
-0.04832625761628151,
-0.3391369879245758,
-0.9066703915596008,
-0.2568994462490082,
0.5996905565261841,
-0.08490900695323944,
0.15965299308300018,
0.32556313276290894,
0.8038804531097412,
-0.09919869899749756,
0.0670534148812294,
0.46001142263412476,
0.103566013276577,
0.4951196312904358,
0.722802460193634,
0.5745477676391602,
-0.5399078130722046,
0.5945050716400146,
-0.3503970205783844,
-0.45840969681739807,
-0.07523868978023529,
-0.549221932888031,
-0.9077393412590027,
-0.7643306851387024,
-0.09690840542316437,
-0.11802425235509872,
0.06421875208616257,
0.712973415851593,
1.0248721837997437,
-0.6820886135101318,
-0.27087634801864624,
0.03358152136206627,
-0.11919724941253662,
-0.2918102443218231,
-0.2841705083847046,
0.2436632513999939,
-0.325038880109787,
-0.7111015915870667,
0.3791721761226654,
0.2524954378604889,
-0.08120766282081604,
-0.6259258389472961,
-0.24204544723033905,
-0.06252454966306686,
0.02182037942111492,
0.6480692028999329,
0.292406290769577,
-0.5720146298408508,
-0.37940549850463867,
0.24111537635326385,
-0.24765968322753906,
-0.17291760444641113,
0.6260543465614319,
-0.8262803554534912,
0.49680712819099426,
0.5075899362564087,
0.7582875490188599,
0.31277725100517273,
0.016714798286557198,
0.7670539021492004,
-0.2861892879009247,
0.16555596888065338,
-0.018223397433757782,
0.3714790642261505,
0.2161111980676651,
-0.20619243383407593,
0.6250724196434021,
0.0928996354341507,
-0.481646329164505,
-0.8526538610458374,
0.2176346629858017,
-0.5870314240455627,
-0.16402463614940643,
0.6697884798049927,
-0.4899998903274536,
-0.2064409852027893,
-0.02107090875506401,
0.03782877326011658,
0.23968128859996796,
0.04105694964528084,
0.6891034841537476,
0.8058525919914246,
-0.014550103805959225,
-0.3210887610912323,
-0.7523230910301208,
0.5122857093811035,
0.14085909724235535,
-0.7429063320159912,
0.15629823505878448,
0.5826882719993591,
0.07249078154563904,
0.3630155920982361,
0.8118323683738708,
-0.3533378839492798,
0.39265549182891846,
0.27585095167160034,
0.13453525304794312,
-0.09853562712669373,
-0.908153772354126,
-0.17443080246448517,
0.21361015737056732,
0.17867636680603027,
-0.02099517732858658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04643v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04643v2
|
QAQ: Quality Adaptive Quantization for LLM KV Cache
| 2024-03-07T16:42:37 | 2024-04-12T13:00:25 |
Shichen Dong, Wen Cheng, Jiayu Qin, Wei Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The emergence of LLMs has ignited a fresh surge of breakthroughs in NLP
applications, particularly in domains such as question-answering systems and
text generation. As the need for longer context grows, a significant bottleneck
in model deployment emerges due to the linear expansion of the Key-Value (KV)
cache with the context length. Existing methods primarily rely on various
hypotheses, such as sorting the KV cache based on attention scores for
replacement or eviction, to compress the KV cache and improve model throughput.
However, heuristics used by these strategies may wrongly evict essential KV
cache, which can significantly degrade model performance. In this paper, we
propose QAQ, a Quality Adaptive Quantization scheme for the KV cache. We
theoretically demonstrate that key cache and value cache exhibit distinct
sensitivities to quantization, leading to the formulation of separate
quantization strategies for their non-uniform quantization. Through the
integration of dedicated outlier handling, as well as an improved
attention-aware approach, QAQ achieves up to 10x the compression ratio of the
KV cache size with a neglectable impact on model performance. QAQ significantly
reduces the practical hurdles of deploying LLMs, opening up new possibilities
for longer-context applications. The code is available at
github.com/ClubieDong/KVCacheQuantization.
|
[
-0.03826892748475075,
-0.33902686834335327,
0.5840189456939697,
0.4764881730079651,
-0.5696176290512085,
0.2520149350166321,
0.12195979058742523,
-0.18569856882095337,
0.129421666264534,
0.4151171147823334,
-0.2933851182460785,
-0.44126999378204346,
-0.31667670607566833,
-0.3206767439842224,
-0.37270334362983704,
0.6291740536689758,
-0.012927240692079067,
-0.14793023467063904,
-0.7252727746963501,
-0.5399238467216492,
-0.8028514385223389,
-0.5644477605819702,
-0.6986708045005798,
0.19793114066123962,
0.23884837329387665,
0.3751223683357239,
0.7809429168701172,
0.37951019406318665,
0.5303592681884766,
0.19744421541690826,
-0.12768623232841492,
0.24725976586341858,
-0.46603459119796753,
0.5836082100868225,
0.0018551984103396535,
-0.6719605922698975,
-0.8195785284042358,
-0.4975568354129791,
0.9152093529701233,
-0.09856526553630829,
-0.40838152170181274,
0.26502546668052673,
-0.06918036937713623,
1.0360571146011353,
-1.0946658849716187,
-0.018110768869519234,
-0.692131519317627,
-0.1605212688446045,
-0.08127912878990173,
-0.3493167459964752,
-0.3758178651332855,
-0.41750219464302063,
-0.01920759119093418,
-0.9299055337905884,
-0.020489955320954323,
0.08924152702093124,
0.7069797515869141,
0.6384510397911072,
-0.29544952511787415,
0.0730530396103859,
-0.48901382088661194,
0.9296334385871887,
-0.8720824122428894,
0.28128546476364136,
0.3312595784664154,
0.38706645369529724,
-0.18953074514865875,
-0.9146865010261536,
-0.5255402326583862,
0.22109924256801605,
0.31800228357315063,
0.3313487768173218,
-0.15109331905841827,
0.008159547112882137,
0.09969214349985123,
0.502892017364502,
-0.635701596736908,
0.015141808427870274,
-0.10187061131000519,
-0.19476313889026642,
0.3616030514240265,
0.44939282536506653,
0.14967112243175507,
0.12022985517978668,
-0.3088969588279724,
-0.2913500964641571,
-0.6811157464981079,
0.356971800327301,
0.2015371471643448,
-0.08019977062940598,
-0.012146609835326672,
0.19828380644321442,
-0.6053699851036072,
0.3446841537952423,
0.007323333993554115,
0.010015228763222694,
0.06050972267985344,
-0.4024173319339752,
-0.3053320348262787,
-0.02560875006020069,
0.4692032039165497,
0.35577142238616943,
0.002773464657366276,
-0.00047131982864812016,
-0.33070608973503113,
-0.1034904345870018,
0.5545670390129089,
-1.1030267477035522,
-0.4712379574775696,
0.5710937976837158,
-0.4861409664154053,
-0.1917586326599121,
-0.5232070088386536,
-0.5516294240951538,
-0.1024760976433754,
0.12498204410076141,
0.8174747824668884,
-0.2508041560649872,
-0.05359024927020073,
0.18554970622062683,
-0.09309901297092438,
0.17571240663528442,
0.39341679215431213,
-0.7045730948448181,
0.22527585923671722,
0.5345170497894287,
0.8165233731269836,
-0.21757780015468597,
0.2345568984746933,
-0.6740018725395203,
-0.032766859978437424,
-0.4003923535346985,
0.5674294233322144,
-0.39517122507095337,
-0.4287647008895874,
-0.19815947115421295,
-0.31843215227127075,
0.3160035014152527,
-0.6662248969078064,
0.5447290539741516,
-1.2581700086593628,
-0.07036535441875458,
-0.5575507283210754,
-0.4270659387111664,
-0.026733586564660072,
0.2190212607383728,
-0.7322955131530762,
1.3119785785675049,
0.38336098194122314,
-0.5454821586608887,
0.33354663848876953,
-0.5010629296302795,
-0.12805745005607605,
0.129569873213768,
0.23235097527503967,
-0.8157689571380615,
0.37392714619636536,
0.5474779605865479,
0.12254613637924194,
-0.3222023844718933,
0.19260846078395844,
-0.18504130840301514,
-0.49176791310310364,
0.4382440447807312,
-0.512855589389801,
0.6233786344528198,
0.12495612353086472,
-0.01642264425754547,
0.3317820429801941,
-0.8237214088439941,
0.5106630921363831,
-0.11719853430986404,
-0.36486098170280457,
-0.36130058765411377,
0.07232972979545593,
-0.06135766580700874,
0.18344634771347046,
0.1536046713590622,
-0.046485237777233124,
0.279193252325058,
-0.4412994980812073,
0.5495447516441345,
0.7794504761695862,
0.3180144429206848,
0.6285561323165894,
-0.4023289680480957,
0.6600418090820312,
0.19904887676239014,
0.5228114724159241,
-0.15879519283771515,
-0.3515090048313141,
-0.9806557893753052,
-0.3494465947151184,
0.6616547107696533,
0.24409402906894684,
-1.0562320947647095,
-0.031199123710393906,
-0.4756646454334259,
-0.10471285879611969,
-0.8644314408302307,
-0.016765709966421127,
0.3595674932003021,
0.2752639353275299,
0.5603224039077759,
-0.5918986201286316,
-0.18093538284301758,
-0.6792646646499634,
-0.1780291646718979,
-0.45790645480155945,
-0.09910187870264053,
0.2176085263490677,
0.27402907609939575,
-0.0006970941904000938,
1.0736730098724365,
-0.2492237091064453,
-0.19925586879253387,
0.49794164299964905,
0.15776850283145905,
-0.10301800817251205,
0.5057505965232849,
0.28811636567115784,
-0.7379225492477417,
-0.40511369705200195,
-0.45246610045433044,
-0.424075186252594,
-0.1267285794019699,
-0.13422973453998566,
-0.4635850191116333,
0.19269901514053345,
0.39987704157829285,
-0.49216508865356445,
0.4653826951980591,
0.6214966177940369,
-0.003545343643054366,
0.6568735837936401,
-0.1789519488811493,
0.12194378674030304,
-1.1496288776397705,
-0.06043699383735657,
-0.568227231502533,
-0.3466644585132599,
-0.36372092366218567,
0.45100247859954834,
0.46253880858421326,
0.21164804697036743,
-0.6103317737579346,
0.5973657369613647,
-0.19853703677654266,
-0.2947332262992859,
-0.4078426659107208,
-0.02490563876926899,
0.3819977641105652,
0.5184149742126465,
-0.1487324833869934,
0.9555121660232544,
0.2451186329126358,
-0.6992678046226501,
0.2003004252910614,
0.10065043717622757,
-0.3769453465938568,
0.709558367729187,
-0.5930814743041992,
0.16596786677837372,
0.015343062579631805,
0.3575425446033478,
-1.0001002550125122,
0.1465814858675003,
0.08323120325803757,
-0.5748091340065002,
0.16585378348827362,
-0.2134486734867096,
-0.6404720544815063,
0.0396026186645031,
-0.44940492510795593,
1.0752958059310913,
0.5667936205863953,
-0.606472909450531,
0.545004665851593,
0.09271816909313202,
0.02755814976990223,
-0.5500535368919373,
-0.28639617562294006,
0.08549737930297852,
-0.3792242109775543,
-0.5563473701477051,
0.5424171090126038,
-0.33038395643234253,
-0.012337058782577515,
-0.0014776429161429405,
-0.44456547498703003,
-0.32687678933143616,
0.3222806751728058,
0.23809963464736938,
-0.019400306046009064,
-0.4800661504268646,
0.6263538002967834,
0.362363338470459,
-0.1782076209783554,
0.13325084745883942,
-0.5480474829673767,
0.20460638403892517,
0.06429620087146759,
-0.1781199723482132,
-0.4725770354270935,
0.14180026948451996,
0.7826919555664062,
-0.2987942397594452,
0.6469453573226929,
0.6598984599113464,
-0.3191158175468445,
-0.17464624345302582,
-0.4278123676776886,
-0.22802872955799103,
-0.5125849843025208,
0.26917561888694763,
-0.31432831287384033,
-0.962777316570282,
0.6659178137779236,
-0.05143478512763977,
0.09811805933713913,
0.31914088129997253,
0.6394961476325989,
-0.3125903308391571,
0.8607034683227539,
0.48598694801330566,
-0.24707169830799103,
0.3711136281490326,
-0.18621419370174408,
0.12810608744621277,
-1.2561513185501099,
0.13044078648090363,
-0.25455063581466675,
-0.4602922201156616,
-0.5755382776260376,
-0.8217869400978088,
0.6101643443107605,
0.4339984953403473,
-0.24276946485042572,
-0.06551091372966766,
-0.37705057859420776,
0.2706698179244995,
0.4984184205532074,
0.18663673102855682,
0.40299034118652344,
-0.19411644339561462,
0.07750152051448822,
-0.09695279598236084,
-0.7507420778274536,
-0.15710456669330597,
1.1024413108825684,
0.26878368854522705,
0.6122435331344604,
0.4272997975349426,
0.3419204354286194,
0.43609926104545593,
0.3325391709804535,
-0.6977468729019165,
0.26791247725486755,
0.21312905848026276,
-0.49417752027511597,
-0.5149354338645935,
-0.3982096314430237,
-0.6336565613746643,
0.2967122793197632,
-0.07590975612401962,
-0.45098942518234253,
0.4315059185028076,
0.31144729256629944,
-0.8785173296928406,
-0.0021796307992190123,
-0.30253055691719055,
0.6546826362609863,
-0.018283532932400703,
-0.3860439360141754,
-0.36855176091194153,
-0.5481336116790771,
0.36802366375923157,
-0.26588812470436096,
-0.010092661716043949,
-0.17893198132514954,
-0.18409326672554016,
0.6766180396080017,
-0.5670339465141296,
0.5113188028335571,
-0.10274778306484222,
-0.10482420027256012,
0.4560452997684479,
0.23255594074726105,
0.8041470646858215,
0.626095712184906,
0.027976257726550102,
-0.05090487003326416,
0.3054453730583191,
-0.7093513607978821,
-0.895680844783783,
0.6436248421669006,
-0.7484734654426575,
-0.538445234298706,
-0.15213094651699066,
-0.6237737536430359,
-0.3407977819442749,
-0.14678704738616943,
0.19677893817424774,
0.134074866771698,
0.11362659931182861,
0.1142764613032341,
0.8108262419700623,
-0.3527584671974182,
0.5702036023139954,
0.5740444660186768,
0.09608110785484314,
-0.4984671473503113,
1.0207531452178955,
-0.09171861410140991,
0.5802538394927979,
0.5772882103919983,
-0.03882118687033653,
-0.3337218463420868,
-0.6560224294662476,
-0.38057222962379456,
-0.18283520638942719,
-0.7564297914505005,
-0.6641604900360107,
-0.6287763118743896,
-0.2015683948993683,
-0.11459632962942123,
-0.05123866721987724,
-0.6272562742233276,
-0.6278777122497559,
-0.5017516016960144,
0.3043062388896942,
0.6267716288566589,
-0.18947385251522064,
0.257891982793808,
0.8292665481567383,
-0.8234062790870667,
0.35950443148612976,
0.6907182931900024,
0.3620721101760864,
0.17715410888195038,
-0.9564271569252014,
-0.5043227076530457,
0.11023077368736267,
-0.4823002219200134,
-0.4983746111392975,
0.5933725833892822,
0.30457133054733276,
0.03841957822442055,
0.18967118859291077,
0.39373213052749634,
1.0007429122924805,
-0.05760379135608673,
0.7221136689186096,
-0.2455500066280365,
-1.0425761938095093,
0.2264403998851776,
-0.08230799436569214,
0.5402123332023621,
0.5880811810493469,
0.10345419496297836,
-0.4555680453777313,
-0.2831048369407654,
-0.45959338545799255,
-1.1435085535049438,
0.39275434613227844,
0.31519168615341187,
0.23028500378131866,
0.19343829154968262,
0.6861717104911804,
-0.27417007088661194,
0.31455740332603455,
-0.673768937587738,
0.04408663138747215,
-0.04675377905368805,
-0.10391358286142349,
0.23760348558425903,
-0.5388770699501038,
0.2840006351470947,
-0.025601711124181747,
0.6937076449394226,
-0.4272440969944,
0.3992899954319,
0.11284578591585159,
-0.44408008456230164,
-0.24651657044887543,
0.20825760066509247,
0.5608413219451904,
0.5985875725746155,
-0.2732415497303009,
-0.06948766112327576,
0.2849866449832916,
-0.33543387055397034,
0.14916060864925385,
-0.5250310897827148,
-0.11604539304971695,
-0.1962212473154068,
-0.031402166932821274,
0.7313517332077026,
0.3135406970977783,
-0.6596066355705261,
0.574188232421875,
-0.4072130024433136,
-0.024799492210149765,
-0.13690632581710815,
0.007389453239738941,
0.1023842915892601,
0.5299294590950012,
0.2699998915195465,
-0.24094943702220917,
0.23566336929798126,
-0.3273527920246124,
-0.01858912594616413,
0.442412406206131,
-0.43074333667755127,
-0.21517570316791534,
0.6977227330207825,
-0.030680470168590546,
0.03651896119117737,
1.0390681028366089,
-0.27429306507110596,
-0.5264473557472229,
0.6184514164924622,
0.3299032747745514,
0.9136096835136414,
-0.23229993879795074,
0.004906552843749523,
0.26973381638526917,
0.20051121711730957,
-0.14257295429706573,
0.41202110052108765,
-0.25115418434143066,
-0.6926417350769043,
-0.6815718412399292,
-0.7916675209999084,
-0.3373161554336548,
0.12447628378868103,
-0.8035048246383667,
0.11838719993829727,
-0.3338920474052429,
-0.15869271755218506,
-0.37666457891464233,
-0.09082884341478348,
-0.46082985401153564,
0.2936233878135681,
-0.2278653234243393,
0.7672134637832642,
-0.6607118248939514,
1.1401069164276123,
0.1387721747159958,
-0.030154259875416756,
-0.32685723900794983,
0.07897412031888962,
-0.3207160234451294,
-0.7549829483032227,
0.44605591893196106,
-0.2810137867927551,
0.38657283782958984,
0.27223849296569824,
-0.23746252059936523,
-1.1706048250198364,
1.2802547216415405,
0.1659335345029831,
-0.546070396900177,
0.02851288393139839,
-0.13739706575870514,
0.5767892003059387,
0.006873631849884987,
0.2470415234565735,
0.4341251850128174,
0.2566116154193878,
-0.05395723134279251,
-0.640381395816803,
0.21834343671798706,
-0.038930896669626236,
0.3092462122440338,
0.39462119340896606,
-0.7612152695655823,
0.6142588257789612,
-0.18278180062770844,
-0.32061874866485596,
0.48343798518180847,
0.8800243139266968,
0.32693764567375183,
0.18115048110485077,
0.19007988274097443,
0.7433305978775024,
0.6779668927192688,
0.016814090311527252,
0.7871238589286804,
-0.2894550859928131,
0.25117817521095276,
1.1574665307998657,
-0.03447967395186424,
1.0777616500854492,
0.5462911128997803,
-0.37371826171875,
0.34465962648391724,
0.7867109179496765,
0.3660232722759247,
0.7525360584259033,
0.38045385479927063,
-0.4024755358695984,
-0.21713750064373016,
0.08852015435695648,
-0.3004160225391388,
0.21240471303462982,
0.5958614945411682,
-0.10021053999662399,
0.05133267864584923,
-0.15719927847385406,
-0.5231804251670837,
-0.4212036728858948,
-0.32182013988494873,
0.7231863141059875,
0.18579845130443573,
-0.5075929164886475,
0.7741119861602783,
0.11034756898880005,
0.46706512570381165,
-0.11395420134067535,
-0.028829481452703476,
-0.32798531651496887,
-0.08027710765600204,
0.020267996937036514,
-0.37117999792099,
0.16977694630622864,
-0.5406240224838257,
-0.5100494027137756,
-0.17603375017642975,
0.4670354723930359,
-0.1982077658176422,
-0.12803377211093903,
-0.1400308459997177,
0.35679054260253906,
-0.014239486306905746,
-0.55010586977005,
-0.5254354476928711,
0.08192335814237595,
-0.29261061549186707,
-0.11855963617563248,
0.764965832233429,
0.44725847244262695,
-0.6014813184738159,
0.7676613926887512,
0.7161744236946106,
-0.2770729660987854,
0.22006934881210327,
-0.09175410121679306,
0.9315522313117981,
-0.5501736998558044,
-0.5809615850448608,
-0.7305281162261963,
0.5992122292518616,
0.2852765917778015,
-0.3362089693546295,
0.3867945671081543,
0.39093726873397827,
0.5389809012413025,
0.1832755208015442,
0.3703242540359497,
0.5322922468185425,
-0.09078044444322586,
-0.6596269607543945,
0.6435927152633667,
-0.6192930936813354,
0.5253286361694336,
-0.057242196053266525,
-0.9749355316162109,
-0.25923818349838257,
0.28288254141807556,
0.18469272553920746,
0.011446813121438026,
0.6264731287956238,
0.8327439427375793,
0.15611553192138672,
-0.24497199058532715,
0.5247139930725098,
0.17763958871364594,
0.3076053261756897,
0.7890062928199768,
0.8802478909492493,
-0.8342993855476379,
0.4530354142189026,
-0.012686893343925476,
-0.03683796152472496,
-0.5465437173843384,
-1.0045042037963867,
-0.3511272072792053,
-0.6339272856712341,
-0.5720396041870117,
-0.4144919514656067,
0.28153014183044434,
0.402595192193985,
0.7315035462379456,
-0.6810283660888672,
0.19582846760749817,
-0.0954824909567833,
0.2164037972688675,
-0.29524317383766174,
-0.3037649989128113,
0.6072575449943542,
-0.40015122294425964,
-0.3954634666442871,
0.2636631429195404,
0.6358337998390198,
0.0004639352555386722,
-0.2060116082429886,
-0.16897256672382355,
0.3542383015155792,
0.27083882689476013,
0.6371303796768188,
0.2495942860841751,
-0.7386696338653564,
-0.1836615949869156,
0.08826328068971634,
-0.10064460337162018,
0.270963579416275,
0.752724289894104,
-1.1567950248718262,
0.8336001038551331,
0.5209344029426575,
0.7198135852813721,
0.5710774064064026,
-0.04110134392976761,
0.39866307377815247,
-1.0765173435211182,
-0.03876664116978645,
0.41272515058517456,
0.06178354471921921,
0.05843428894877434,
-0.4500821828842163,
0.13873063027858734,
0.07082713395357132,
-0.7784923315048218,
-0.9918678402900696,
-0.04743155092000961,
-1.0949372053146362,
-0.1886659562587738,
0.8985240459442139,
-0.05639161542057991,
-0.186592698097229,
0.002475971356034279,
0.018019018694758415,
0.12078776210546494,
-0.5056837201118469,
1.1708921194076538,
0.5938409566879272,
0.1609269380569458,
-0.39353078603744507,
-0.6718428134918213,
0.6331629753112793,
0.7092422246932983,
-0.6475429534912109,
-0.025949601083993912,
0.13131436705589294,
0.10119102895259857,
-0.1504479944705963,
0.7598044872283936,
-0.22651703655719757,
0.8329605460166931,
-0.31075066328048706,
0.1974121332168579,
0.3443892300128937,
-0.13281570374965668,
-0.537107527256012,
-0.02311614714562893,
0.45038145780563354,
-0.24204742908477783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04639v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04639v2
|
MaCmS: Magahi Code-mixed Dataset for Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-03-07T16:29:19 | 2024-03-22T17:28:42 |
Priya Rani, Gaurav Negi, Theodorus Fransen, John P. McCrae
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The present paper introduces new sentiment data, MaCMS, for
Magahi-Hindi-English (MHE) code-mixed language, where Magahi is a
less-resourced minority language. This dataset is the first
Magahi-Hindi-English code-mixed dataset for sentiment analysis tasks. Further,
we also provide a linguistics analysis of the dataset to understand the
structure of code-mixing and a statistical study to understand the language
preferences of speakers with different polarities. With these analyses, we also
train baseline models to evaluate the dataset's quality.
|
[
-0.8737273812294006,
-0.33949771523475647,
-0.23861795663833618,
0.5517288446426392,
-0.4601118266582489,
0.45765259861946106,
-0.11892465502023697,
-0.0870794802904129,
0.7757273316383362,
0.579801082611084,
-0.8358263373374939,
-0.7900230884552002,
-0.7238175868988037,
0.2847784757614136,
-0.04237568378448486,
1.1194286346435547,
0.07245302945375443,
0.32598406076431274,
0.06966443359851837,
-0.7261227369308472,
-0.30071237683296204,
-0.9958968758583069,
-0.25949999690055847,
-0.12562346458435059,
0.472086101770401,
1.0035265684127808,
1.0674703121185303,
-0.002446974627673626,
0.8241283297538757,
0.0698087215423584,
0.08434292674064636,
0.35749560594558716,
-0.23915037512779236,
-0.3171858489513397,
0.22275280952453613,
-0.4507048726081848,
-0.7715684175491333,
0.22878168523311615,
0.4960537254810333,
0.7679176926612854,
-0.2771299183368683,
0.4173734188079834,
-0.1956482231616974,
0.9146446585655212,
-0.7894638776779175,
0.011390123516321182,
-0.5308548808097839,
0.403156578540802,
-0.2756251096725464,
-0.16928167641162872,
-0.35826539993286133,
-0.3852483928203583,
-0.3847489356994629,
-0.00560400728136301,
-0.008585094474256039,
0.20150887966156006,
0.7250635027885437,
0.09893446415662766,
-0.6011963486671448,
-0.39234834909439087,
-0.31597408652305603,
1.2830805778503418,
-1.0119928121566772,
0.18619966506958008,
0.49948036670684814,
0.19906269013881683,
0.013966848142445087,
0.04877438768744469,
-0.8972994089126587,
-0.13960739970207214,
-0.08518247306346893,
0.3422695994377136,
-0.12933644652366638,
-0.21352756023406982,
0.0764148160815239,
0.8673624992370605,
-0.4619457423686981,
-0.07230883091688156,
-0.25293585658073425,
-0.060882724821567535,
0.7300485372543335,
0.37676307559013367,
0.5403016209602356,
-0.6743393540382385,
-0.24007980525493622,
0.014349773526191711,
-0.4657564163208008,
-0.18893152475357056,
0.52955561876297,
0.49943920969963074,
-0.43981313705444336,
0.9509011507034302,
-0.2894158959388733,
0.6560402512550354,
-0.4271310865879059,
-0.4184744954109192,
0.8648664355278015,
-0.34196391701698303,
-0.6489274501800537,
-0.07251501828432083,
0.9125761985778809,
0.6855083703994751,
0.4081524908542633,
0.2281961441040039,
-0.3863043785095215,
0.25377899408340454,
0.019099919125437737,
-0.8285260796546936,
-0.1870950311422348,
0.12851715087890625,
-0.8775596618652344,
-0.533760130405426,
0.16593855619430542,
-0.9112118482589722,
-0.331717312335968,
-0.21885785460472107,
-0.13676917552947998,
-0.2351631075143814,
-0.6262263655662537,
0.10906746238470078,
0.04344756901264191,
0.32061249017715454,
-0.20056506991386414,
-0.7629997134208679,
0.6256007552146912,
0.43126872181892395,
0.9736112356185913,
-0.20867040753364563,
-0.1634359210729599,
-0.31669822335243225,
-0.2892897427082062,
-0.26692819595336914,
0.16093286871910095,
-0.7271341681480408,
-0.9370442628860474,
-0.13831272721290588,
-0.07431776821613312,
0.028675930574536324,
-0.8124876618385315,
0.5803667902946472,
-0.41327589750289917,
0.3586694300174713,
-0.21746870875358582,
-0.2540957033634186,
-0.4435807168483734,
0.38533467054367065,
-0.7526559829711914,
1.1578292846679688,
0.2510172426700592,
-1.1259337663650513,
0.40024709701538086,
-0.820442259311676,
-0.5315501093864441,
-0.4017525613307953,
0.11008337140083313,
-0.4949154257774353,
0.27567848563194275,
0.353299081325531,
0.39468035101890564,
-0.10330454260110855,
0.16361768543720245,
-0.32744693756103516,
-0.27367496490478516,
0.4251903295516968,
-0.32554566860198975,
0.6728534698486328,
0.7369158267974854,
0.0037349334452301264,
-0.2784164547920227,
-1.105867624282837,
-0.06725198030471802,
0.03910470008850098,
-0.22897225618362427,
-0.25654691457748413,
0.2616427540779114,
0.4397349953651428,
0.3660494089126587,
0.2597084939479828,
-0.6855770945549011,
0.3008144795894623,
-0.1535101681947708,
-0.088530533015728,
0.42942014336586,
-0.023594878613948822,
0.3013625741004944,
-0.23325741291046143,
0.8081058263778687,
0.49875137209892273,
0.2228991687297821,
0.23938268423080444,
-0.6390560269355774,
-0.8835353851318359,
-0.1662376970052719,
0.15652523934841156,
0.9342122673988342,
-0.6426346302032471,
0.2452058345079422,
-0.1918828934431076,
-0.2786059081554413,
-0.7272763848304749,
0.34554314613342285,
0.10773075371980667,
0.12005594372749329,
0.4410184919834137,
-0.4686720669269562,
-0.8072535991668701,
-1.1496973037719727,
0.10200783610343933,
-0.04416045546531677,
0.06572509557008743,
0.35079604387283325,
0.31018829345703125,
-0.850264847278595,
0.8725393414497375,
-0.5130797624588013,
-0.0637599527835846,
-0.37532007694244385,
0.3760561943054199,
0.5383411049842834,
0.3283883333206177,
0.6349854469299316,
-0.6535080075263977,
-0.3771422505378723,
0.07400929927825928,
-0.5443299412727356,
-0.2981547713279724,
0.2755739092826843,
-0.24804893136024475,
0.004481152165681124,
0.08257706463336945,
-0.1570829153060913,
0.05669200047850609,
1.0714709758758545,
-0.14698776602745056,
0.3445752263069153,
0.42105239629745483,
0.6385770440101624,
-1.4220157861709595,
-0.10526185482740402,
0.10403010994195938,
-0.1476420909166336,
-0.5443797707557678,
-0.07322100549936295,
-0.21091876924037933,
-0.2185218185186386,
-0.5929687023162842,
0.19737845659255981,
-0.4338366985321045,
-0.09681667387485504,
-0.6272382140159607,
0.026036996394395828,
-0.30569443106651306,
0.6217529773712158,
-0.051040615886449814,
0.914581835269928,
0.6164463758468628,
-0.30810078978538513,
0.2029976099729538,
0.2301768809556961,
-0.23698662221431732,
0.2660566568374634,
-0.39312300086021423,
0.06246514618396759,
-0.07471012324094772,
-0.384599894285202,
-0.8109092116355896,
-0.11733584851026535,
0.5733016133308411,
-0.47713130712509155,
0.25875425338745117,
-0.06184505298733711,
-0.5680171251296997,
-0.35566800832748413,
-0.37217122316360474,
0.5466194152832031,
0.5197511911392212,
-0.30977606773376465,
0.323415070772171,
0.5771153569221497,
-0.18389390408992767,
-0.867542564868927,
-1.0313607454299927,
0.09298716485500336,
-0.156740203499794,
-0.2554299831390381,
-0.17758817970752716,
-0.03002818115055561,
-0.4365250766277313,
-0.0828840434551239,
0.04014090821146965,
-0.26854565739631653,
-0.059182267636060715,
0.5654259920120239,
0.5189176201820374,
-0.3589576184749603,
-0.2766895592212677,
0.32106703519821167,
-0.14617496728897095,
0.06498249620199203,
0.05962647497653961,
0.5584619045257568,
-0.24541066586971283,
-0.27380475401878357,
-0.191644549369812,
0.6564589142799377,
0.7389527559280396,
-0.22445204854011536,
0.9469714760780334,
0.6291909217834473,
-0.19244635105133057,
0.09508371353149414,
-0.28266042470932007,
0.3654114007949829,
-0.3925214111804962,
0.2804339826107025,
-0.46740221977233887,
-1.000054955482483,
0.46008187532424927,
0.08405489474534988,
-0.034375838935375214,
0.42395028471946716,
0.8089156150817871,
-0.051213640719652176,
1.3505665063858032,
0.6723559498786926,
-1.0755027532577515,
0.3301566541194916,
-0.05037595331668854,
0.19260811805725098,
-0.6118350028991699,
-0.017790071666240692,
-0.36857864260673523,
-0.5284600257873535,
-0.8757044672966003,
-0.2215358316898346,
-0.09716212749481201,
0.035328663885593414,
-0.07829400151968002,
-0.0814787819981575,
-0.5215785503387451,
0.44747766852378845,
0.3208356201648712,
0.08605112880468369,
0.24064356088638306,
0.21060824394226074,
-0.19671227037906647,
-0.1132073849439621,
-0.6523990631103516,
-0.7969908118247986,
1.0150885581970215,
0.26820313930511475,
0.9222146272659302,
0.12955009937286377,
0.7009121179580688,
0.6466994285583496,
0.497608482837677,
-0.8493649363517761,
0.522631049156189,
-0.338306188583374,
-0.39305707812309265,
0.31216105818748474,
-0.7027463316917419,
-0.5271587371826172,
0.28578102588653564,
-0.033055681735277176,
-0.17717118561267853,
0.2812318503856659,
-0.25638607144355774,
0.1266905516386032,
0.4115362763404846,
-0.7422666549682617,
0.7079741358757019,
0.02955755777657032,
0.5714167952537537,
-0.15290609002113342,
-0.5606502890586853,
0.7827655076980591,
0.031054764986038208,
0.6198354363441467,
-0.4815976619720459,
0.11098939925432205,
0.929147481918335,
-0.5976052284240723,
0.6731495261192322,
-0.1281624734401703,
0.03586047142744064,
0.47062668204307556,
0.07566837966442108,
-0.03590647503733635,
0.3033811151981354,
-0.27960705757141113,
0.423227995634079,
0.02414262294769287,
-0.8725136518478394,
-0.3636808693408966,
0.6366235017776489,
-1.0530058145523071,
-0.2678072452545166,
-0.42879948019981384,
-0.4514275789260864,
-0.3129850924015045,
-0.22219164669513702,
0.2034401297569275,
0.3362491726875305,
-0.03426442667841911,
-0.13888125121593475,
0.27940112352371216,
-0.12656432390213013,
0.3589767813682556,
0.49067580699920654,
-0.5358510613441467,
-0.6108654141426086,
0.9396178722381592,
-0.09540516883134842,
0.14581134915351868,
0.26333820819854736,
0.04296915978193283,
0.26089605689048767,
-0.29655149579048157,
-0.4094574451446533,
0.12932094931602478,
-0.6970930695533752,
-0.26225563883781433,
-0.5367292761802673,
-0.0977986603975296,
0.159235879778862,
0.006014359649270773,
-0.2641187906265259,
-0.24553358554840088,
-0.23132607340812683,
-0.13078323006629944,
0.5087264776229858,
0.6347681283950806,
0.2067537158727646,
0.4839860200881958,
-1.1618231534957886,
0.4119972884654999,
0.1253790408372879,
0.17941580712795258,
-0.25525200366973877,
-0.31066611409187317,
-0.3920336067676544,
0.23185208439826965,
-0.11760266125202179,
-1.1597039699554443,
0.6021997332572937,
0.059798043221235275,
0.3318220376968384,
0.439399778842926,
-0.2947767674922943,
0.3393625319004059,
-0.2051793783903122,
0.9346451163291931,
0.329213410615921,
-1.1575026512145996,
0.8422526121139526,
-0.0044330270029604435,
0.2480417937040329,
0.8361691236495972,
0.4084776043891907,
-0.691803514957428,
-0.589495062828064,
-0.34825873374938965,
-0.366242378950119,
0.665262758731842,
0.2551373541355133,
0.2598280608654022,
-0.4177382290363312,
0.20293015241622925,
0.36757892370224,
0.5136383771896362,
-0.898499071598053,
-0.7756930589675903,
-0.44913390278816223,
-0.6609141230583191,
-0.13362044095993042,
-0.5585514903068542,
0.06652923673391342,
-0.5033540725708008,
0.679057240486145,
-0.15288685262203217,
0.3408365249633789,
-0.17124752700328827,
-0.2848452627658844,
-0.11032486706972122,
0.5014626383781433,
0.4618977904319763,
0.3475801944732666,
-0.35984164476394653,
0.18272416293621063,
0.38937824964523315,
-0.8963748216629028,
0.3780655860900879,
-0.42844730615615845,
-0.060617949813604355,
0.3231290876865387,
0.04223969206213951,
0.7325507402420044,
-0.17850393056869507,
-0.6242178678512573,
0.4943208396434784,
0.017076918855309486,
-0.08371864259243011,
0.2351715862751007,
0.0406884141266346,
-0.18194089829921722,
-0.20594322681427002,
0.3069649040699005,
0.35644611716270447,
0.30515408515930176,
-0.5927209258079529,
0.14112898707389832,
0.481623113155365,
-0.45196786522865295,
-0.21123744547367096,
0.0220148004591465,
0.11966954171657562,
0.03545400872826576,
0.6695420742034912,
-0.5293099284172058,
-0.6289070844650269,
0.47131043672561646,
0.33220934867858887,
0.72475665807724,
-0.12235415726900101,
0.36935603618621826,
0.1801578551530838,
0.5964770317077637,
0.2680087983608246,
0.8267650008201599,
-0.07322198152542114,
-0.8705224394798279,
-0.399956077337265,
-0.7954806685447693,
-0.7065991163253784,
-0.2380564659833908,
-0.9666339755058289,
0.2921023666858673,
-0.4781500995159149,
-0.3459869623184204,
-0.4859549105167389,
0.16543565690517426,
-0.40206319093704224,
0.7175463438034058,
0.13255056738853455,
0.698536217212677,
-0.8885675668716431,
0.9796233177185059,
0.7347691059112549,
-0.3680071532726288,
-0.6320603489875793,
-0.1365891546010971,
-0.1298622190952301,
-0.8522383570671082,
0.5798627138137817,
0.050623632967472076,
-0.33583083748817444,
-0.19999626278877258,
-0.6939730048179626,
-0.600200891494751,
0.6964229345321655,
-0.11194383352994919,
-0.4253331124782562,
0.661949098110199,
0.2952108681201935,
0.27377116680145264,
-0.6169204115867615,
0.19058609008789062,
0.6132144927978516,
0.3340380787849426,
-0.10485771298408508,
-0.441692054271698,
-0.3169105648994446,
-0.7340114116668701,
-0.2532742917537689,
0.6163700819015503,
-0.6649607419967651,
0.8970126509666443,
0.06733211874961853,
-0.3369790315628052,
-0.24389928579330444,
0.8080929517745972,
0.04447461664676666,
0.4685076177120209,
0.2872408628463745,
0.7035101056098938,
0.7308156490325928,
-0.20482438802719116,
1.003772497177124,
-0.34523847699165344,
0.5757359266281128,
0.774904727935791,
-0.2934713065624237,
1.025982141494751,
0.4853692650794983,
-0.5078768730163574,
0.911156952381134,
0.7014286518096924,
-0.1525871753692627,
0.5179872512817383,
0.08043396472930908,
-0.24444489181041718,
-0.07245985418558121,
-0.05231839418411255,
-0.5281588435173035,
0.34818023443222046,
0.02910574898123741,
-0.3512378931045532,
0.07024640589952469,
0.32049429416656494,
0.06038665771484375,
-0.21905770897865295,
-0.4029526114463806,
0.6608827114105225,
0.19982169568538666,
0.028495993465185165,
0.5334349274635315,
0.43926581740379333,
1.221747636795044,
-0.3607833683490753,
0.4281650483608246,
-0.5622150897979736,
-0.41648706793785095,
-0.535300612449646,
-0.8527746200561523,
0.6059115529060364,
0.21080052852630615,
-0.7405923008918762,
0.38471025228500366,
0.503662109375,
-0.3108898401260376,
-0.892880380153656,
0.08597490191459656,
0.6707737445831299,
0.06606101989746094,
0.07446963340044022,
-0.7941548824310303,
0.010589919984340668,
0.07049795985221863,
-0.06125170364975929,
0.14767016470432281,
0.2390875369310379,
0.16891084611415863,
0.5648744106292725,
0.6135702729225159,
0.17754757404327393,
0.24347424507141113,
0.6385616660118103,
0.7061049342155457,
-0.9737049341201782,
-0.41676032543182373,
-1.088500738143921,
0.20725591480731964,
0.03607405349612236,
-0.2982378900051117,
1.0702929496765137,
0.6627821326255798,
0.4459991753101349,
-0.3036051392555237,
0.8036386966705322,
0.15960809588432312,
0.4199380576610565,
-0.5611498355865479,
0.6198570132255554,
-0.5912454724311829,
0.03889476880431175,
-0.3726636469364166,
-1.0187338590621948,
-0.364236444234848,
0.4212883710861206,
-0.05558934435248375,
0.10663638263940811,
0.5007835626602173,
0.8794859647750854,
-0.15188394486904144,
0.3038152754306793,
0.22277355194091797,
-0.24516555666923523,
-0.20778276026248932,
0.5888538360595703,
1.133162021636963,
-0.5373375415802002,
0.23090974986553192,
-0.19639156758785248,
-0.17256231606006622,
-0.1774284839630127,
-0.6048724055290222,
-0.9948427677154541,
0.0588841512799263,
-0.4228905141353607,
-0.2582797110080719,
-0.45714789628982544,
1.011940836906433,
0.6295463442802429,
-1.2207331657409668,
-0.4194328784942627,
0.03371768072247505,
0.28064265847206116,
-0.11318600922822952,
-0.34358102083206177,
-0.04691590741276741,
-0.26573044061660767,
-0.6889687776565552,
0.16180714964866638,
0.4926537275314331,
0.08570630103349686,
-0.19016088545322418,
-0.3082946836948395,
-0.154547318816185,
0.5065045952796936,
0.7496454119682312,
-0.07261224091053009,
-0.45207643508911133,
0.21203427016735077,
0.1940276175737381,
-0.5580598711967468,
0.5026215314865112,
1.0598127841949463,
-0.3580095171928406,
0.4533928334712982,
0.29789355397224426,
0.39501598477363586,
0.21691128611564636,
0.0054406761191785336,
0.2263069748878479,
-1.0503956079483032,
0.3846741318702698,
-0.04399676248431206,
0.592315137386322,
0.36329153180122375,
-0.17200171947479248,
0.3412189781665802,
0.21293817460536957,
-0.29279884696006775,
-0.5769214034080505,
0.017872801050543785,
-1.2925440073013306,
-0.050158657133579254,
1.0908632278442383,
0.31494393944740295,
-0.14365850389003754,
0.11518760025501251,
-0.5752429962158203,
0.18057672679424286,
-0.2780793011188507,
0.5031329989433289,
1.047445297241211,
0.1430760622024536,
-0.2945335805416107,
-0.4172497093677521,
0.2302960455417633,
0.664972722530365,
-0.9235051274299622,
-0.4842351973056793,
0.3874111473560333,
-0.020214544609189034,
0.11140066385269165,
0.5723040699958801,
-0.1691576987504959,
0.20181722939014435,
0.08825188875198364,
0.2052336186170578,
0.12409766763448715,
-0.10943449288606644,
-0.368064284324646,
0.32273951172828674,
0.13043884932994843,
-0.6595351099967957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04626v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04626v2
|
MedFLIP: Medical Vision-and-Language Self-supervised Fast Pre-Training with Masked Autoencoder
| 2024-03-07T16:11:43 | 2024-05-31T00:12:59 |
Lei Li, Tianfang Zhang, Xinglin Zhang, Jiaqi Liu, Bingqi Ma, Yan Luo, Tao Chen
|
eess.IV
|
eess.IV, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Within the domain of medical analysis, extensive research has explored the
potential of mutual learning between Masked Autoencoders(MAEs) and multimodal
data. However, the impact of MAEs on intermodality remains a key challenge. We
introduce MedFLIP, a Fast Language-Image Pre-training method for Medical
analysis. We explore MAEs for zero-shot learning with crossed domains, which
enhances the model's ability to learn from limited data, a common scenario in
medical diagnostics. We verify that masking an image does not affect
inter-modal learning. Furthermore, we propose the SVD loss to enhance the
representation learning for characteristics of medical images, aiming to
improve classification accuracy by leveraging the structural intricacies of
such data. Our theory posits that masking encourages semantic preservation,
robust feature extraction, regularization, domain adaptation, and invariance
learning. Lastly, we validate using language will improve the zero-shot
performance for the medical image analysis. MedFLIP's scaling of the masking
process marks an advancement in the field, offering a pathway to rapid and
precise medical image analysis without the traditional computational
bottlenecks. Through experiments and validation, MedFLIP demonstrates efficient
performance improvements, helps for future research and application in medical
diagnostics.
|
[
-0.43771496415138245,
-0.4222051501274109,
0.22387562692165375,
0.17558357119560242,
-0.48699021339416504,
0.2261403501033783,
0.24183696508407593,
-0.5230353474617004,
0.7022871971130371,
0.44179755449295044,
-0.43669581413269043,
-0.34186962246894836,
-1.0523102283477783,
-0.15748055279254913,
-0.16865164041519165,
0.9528466463088989,
-0.14161691069602966,
0.44013479351997375,
-0.3518826961517334,
-0.4832354485988617,
-0.2169363647699356,
-0.7398002743721008,
-0.42189058661460876,
-0.08468993008136749,
0.2728220224380493,
0.30091166496276855,
0.7652820348739624,
0.7446588277816772,
0.7586454749107361,
0.2224232256412506,
0.7484743595123291,
0.01628596894443035,
-0.15191049873828888,
0.12948229908943176,
0.030082155019044876,
-0.27741456031799316,
-0.40521255135536194,
0.22710168361663818,
0.5020723342895508,
0.7758222222328186,
0.06065012142062187,
0.06101218983530998,
-0.4049866795539856,
0.5260893702507019,
-0.7668334245681763,
0.24802853167057037,
-0.2709258496761322,
0.452861487865448,
-0.3550978899002075,
-0.527098536491394,
-0.047009605914354324,
0.04851890355348587,
-0.01641954854130745,
-0.5183958411216736,
0.27028247714042664,
-0.10706228762865067,
0.7951962351799011,
0.5520305037498474,
-0.33581259846687317,
-0.0547824501991272,
-0.5166086554527283,
0.37405428290367126,
-0.34964606165885925,
0.5887882709503174,
0.09667684137821198,
0.7450878620147705,
0.10772956907749176,
-0.9258020520210266,
-0.4206719696521759,
0.11186112463474274,
0.07962865382432938,
0.2124846875667572,
0.08780728280544281,
0.16880518198013306,
-0.002094872761517763,
0.2517976760864258,
-0.4185311496257782,
0.16099844872951508,
-0.5352876782417297,
-0.3392004370689392,
0.5372155904769897,
0.18144865334033966,
0.5233862400054932,
0.2266656905412674,
-0.6724103093147278,
-0.2459717094898224,
-0.5849573612213135,
-0.09461496770381927,
-0.3588676452636719,
-0.33737725019454956,
-0.24253016710281372,
0.4986119270324707,
0.07280227541923523,
0.41260769963264465,
0.17450812458992004,
-0.46587520837783813,
0.5306148529052734,
-0.14937229454517365,
-0.19155901670455933,
-0.2638416886329651,
0.795233428478241,
0.4597218632698059,
0.14824451506137848,
0.0872642993927002,
-0.17296317219734192,
0.2039780467748642,
0.03669103607535362,
-0.8469337224960327,
-0.39338746666908264,
0.06578049808740616,
-0.7805871963500977,
-0.26529890298843384,
0.09805210679769516,
-0.8012033104896545,
-0.29472601413726807,
-0.21699801087379456,
0.5992818474769592,
-0.2722860276699066,
-0.1965397596359253,
0.5367467999458313,
0.03374144062399864,
0.16816727817058563,
0.18083614110946655,
-0.6482658386230469,
0.6775124669075012,
0.4754152297973633,
0.8143481612205505,
-0.2826581597328186,
-0.3474483788013458,
-0.8190748691558838,
0.0484611801803112,
-0.30485644936561584,
0.772436261177063,
-0.5214059948921204,
-0.2480163276195526,
-0.09433930367231369,
-0.0944150909781456,
-0.2062629610300064,
-0.6264840364456177,
-0.010782722383737564,
-0.0710393413901329,
0.2821161150932312,
0.30460435152053833,
-0.5185720324516296,
0.03267078846693039,
-0.09357623755931854,
-0.5220686197280884,
0.6091499328613281,
0.15553903579711914,
-0.5584836006164551,
0.6070374846458435,
-0.8468160629272461,
-0.6250073909759521,
0.23125037550926208,
-0.8494020700454712,
-0.5688839554786682,
0.12394855916500092,
0.440692663192749,
0.8433506488800049,
-0.12029440701007843,
0.2594214677810669,
-0.406507283449173,
-0.06625314801931381,
0.15687066316604614,
-0.12074079364538193,
0.6268800497055054,
0.19653433561325073,
-0.4043132960796356,
-0.080937959253788,
-0.6741350889205933,
0.007947509177029133,
0.32391855120658875,
0.2118416279554367,
-0.24395860731601715,
-0.21602019667625427,
-0.1284194439649582,
0.5749618411064148,
-0.23228655755519867,
-0.6424390077590942,
0.21773257851600647,
-0.33107930421829224,
0.17860037088394165,
0.2786298096179962,
0.09823492914438248,
0.19765639305114746,
-0.263756662607193,
0.9803948402404785,
0.3697526156902313,
0.7497754096984863,
-0.3542451858520508,
-0.539509117603302,
-0.6439617872238159,
-0.803182065486908,
0.429197758436203,
0.47565627098083496,
-1.0625393390655518,
0.10873973369598389,
-0.11423459649085999,
-0.3082274794578552,
-1.046814203262329,
-0.09284242242574692,
0.6774036288261414,
0.7665282487869263,
0.49708741903305054,
-0.8258251547813416,
-0.36937177181243896,
-1.0136998891830444,
-0.0767512172460556,
0.24902857840061188,
-0.00672966567799449,
0.252851665019989,
0.37366345524787903,
-0.40753865242004395,
0.718086302280426,
-0.7119924426078796,
-0.9025910496711731,
0.0077536278404295444,
0.2438935488462448,
0.0722561776638031,
0.48894646763801575,
1.075400471687317,
-0.7575080394744873,
-0.740661084651947,
-0.23171378672122955,
-0.4811493158340454,
-0.344591349363327,
-0.18065790832042694,
0.1471744179725647,
0.11633571237325668,
0.6651220321655273,
-0.26847997307777405,
0.5679147839546204,
0.6260071992874146,
-0.31014150381088257,
0.3059628903865814,
-0.570258378982544,
0.2094908207654953,
-0.6636087894439697,
0.02982126735150814,
-0.2105693221092224,
-0.41763585805892944,
-0.6352311372756958,
-0.09516571462154388,
0.1413029581308365,
-0.3257003426551819,
-0.6089503765106201,
0.7117035388946533,
-0.6443459391593933,
-0.03538370132446289,
-0.1996665894985199,
-0.37951236963272095,
0.1387539803981781,
0.15284913778305054,
0.2917371690273285,
0.6301871538162231,
0.8248524069786072,
-0.3648638427257538,
-0.0540759414434433,
0.12767820060253143,
-0.11104285717010498,
0.6348052024841309,
-0.42299020290374756,
0.07850942760705948,
-0.27093884348869324,
0.15658162534236908,
-0.6940879225730896,
-0.12567053735256195,
0.29872435331344604,
-0.5031360387802124,
0.7069997191429138,
-0.18806082010269165,
-0.3051019012928009,
-0.42754876613616943,
-0.4194600582122803,
0.6868101358413696,
0.41916415095329285,
-0.4612042307853699,
0.5158238410949707,
0.9089978337287903,
0.04905054718255997,
-0.6363668441772461,
-0.5780903100967407,
-0.02691527083516121,
0.15152893960475922,
-0.33710235357284546,
0.2733948230743408,
-0.21684011816978455,
0.10511844605207443,
-0.05804211646318436,
-0.09206299483776093,
-0.5716624855995178,
-0.16773980855941772,
0.40389207005500793,
0.3638995885848999,
-0.2367039918899536,
0.24924954771995544,
0.12774816155433655,
-0.4200354516506195,
0.020812172442674637,
-0.04401965066790581,
0.3577139973640442,
-0.08929113298654556,
-0.43996280431747437,
-0.18009786307811737,
0.5075223445892334,
0.7600417137145996,
-0.3744637370109558,
0.41512376070022583,
0.45763853192329407,
-0.34000131487846375,
0.15229646861553192,
-0.6935911774635315,
-0.09864853322505951,
-0.49068912863731384,
0.32598966360092163,
-0.447512149810791,
-0.6920725107192993,
0.14714467525482178,
-0.1692756712436676,
-0.23307940363883972,
0.5722073316574097,
0.43815624713897705,
-0.5252743363380432,
0.8290486931800842,
1.0590711832046509,
-0.045178767293691635,
0.23162513971328735,
-0.27600377798080444,
0.08186500519514084,
-0.30186837911605835,
-0.3910061717033386,
-0.10056116431951523,
-0.2091323435306549,
-0.24672994017601013,
-0.6730759143829346,
0.6865139603614807,
-0.25192713737487793,
0.16000373661518097,
-0.26240670680999756,
-0.6042523384094238,
0.7417859435081482,
0.3138987421989441,
0.005341745913028717,
0.007494294550269842,
0.035028040409088135,
-0.23560050129890442,
-0.4202714264392853,
-0.7622008919715881,
0.14998053014278412,
1.1415350437164307,
0.4598431885242462,
0.8553024530410767,
-0.5784385800361633,
0.6853736042976379,
0.40465089678764343,
0.41253072023391724,
-0.6669461131095886,
0.28780484199523926,
-0.5430247783660889,
-0.38682082295417786,
0.12694695591926575,
-0.053828440606594086,
-0.8042336702346802,
0.3483242392539978,
-0.5974579453468323,
0.1603545844554901,
0.363241970539093,
0.2525183856487274,
-0.3375285863876343,
0.22596189379692078,
-0.6771101951599121,
0.8464168906211853,
-0.5740306377410889,
0.18005022406578064,
-0.07154714316129684,
-1.1484938859939575,
0.23133543133735657,
-0.2368679642677307,
0.31645599007606506,
-0.06343787163496017,
-0.29702267050743103,
0.7016049027442932,
-0.5865883827209473,
0.89107346534729,
-0.4877910614013672,
0.2838783264160156,
-0.10703425109386444,
0.07071366906166077,
-0.31574028730392456,
-0.18969550728797913,
0.5965158343315125,
0.5568928718566895,
0.39807581901550293,
-0.4031132459640503,
-0.7187038064002991,
0.2456381767988205,
-0.43077078461647034,
-0.3165993094444275,
-0.5819584131240845,
-0.3825237452983856,
-0.3011605441570282,
0.161943256855011,
0.30771514773368835,
0.5696654319763184,
0.10134882479906082,
-0.034189607948064804,
0.4380760192871094,
-0.15456698834896088,
0.2779468297958374,
0.4437335133552551,
-0.4003385901451111,
-0.6788153648376465,
0.8625755906105042,
0.3254863917827606,
0.22274629771709442,
0.3648976981639862,
0.21316559612751007,
-0.0614037960767746,
-0.49438026547431946,
-0.3879246115684509,
0.7641153335571289,
-0.6396819949150085,
-0.3202486038208008,
-0.6705713272094727,
-0.4460088014602661,
-0.37765634059906006,
-0.26814618706703186,
-0.6120390295982361,
-0.5453782677650452,
-0.06692799180746078,
0.17500737309455872,
0.044102467596530914,
0.434455543756485,
-0.31510719656944275,
0.20012624561786652,
-0.739636242389679,
0.532775342464447,
-0.01042124442756176,
0.45353472232818604,
-0.5451125502586365,
-0.19309768080711365,
-0.1519128680229187,
-0.43579328060150146,
0.02273162268102169,
-0.599705159664154,
0.3357602655887604,
0.4628671705722809,
0.5456558465957642,
0.9418518543243408,
0.1090841069817543,
0.7309558987617493,
-0.7561778426170349,
0.4674663543701172,
0.6895517706871033,
-0.7500134706497192,
0.5184983611106873,
0.29293206334114075,
0.24942752718925476,
0.5879246592521667,
0.6969088315963745,
-0.4021647274494171,
-0.2581225037574768,
-0.5511074662208557,
-0.4382016658782959,
0.02812958136200905,
-0.26490795612335205,
0.006361714098602533,
-0.0013202647678554058,
0.4526285231113434,
0.5061061978340149,
0.2162664532661438,
-0.5960364937782288,
-0.4443711042404175,
-0.4125860035419464,
-0.3925412595272064,
-0.08584440499544144,
-0.25647202134132385,
-0.2851436734199524,
-0.8054991960525513,
0.1066022589802742,
-0.44787007570266724,
0.39698705077171326,
0.4627290666103363,
-0.3027016520500183,
0.06264866888523102,
-0.1613493263721466,
0.697809100151062,
0.36165955662727356,
0.11854530870914459,
0.35685995221138,
-0.16609835624694824,
-0.970192015171051,
0.1889306753873825,
0.019246485084295273,
0.18205319344997406,
0.17805121839046478,
0.4759630262851715,
0.6321713924407959,
0.14013448357582092,
-0.6887230277061462,
1.2383664846420288,
-0.08362817764282227,
-0.4140034317970276,
-0.021939042955636978,
-0.08493100851774216,
-0.5604872107505798,
0.22367188334465027,
0.21195903420448303,
0.13065847754478455,
0.22822855412960052,
-0.21936318278312683,
0.582602858543396,
0.5245950818061829,
-0.4029539227485657,
-0.4714456796646118,
0.7552691698074341,
0.20617736876010895,
-0.03943531587719917,
0.3522309958934784,
0.27166345715522766,
-0.5394132733345032,
0.5050173401832581,
0.5405756831169128,
0.6723015308380127,
-0.4807397127151489,
0.29947665333747864,
-0.10266870260238647,
0.27271610498428345,
0.42616331577301025,
0.30529382824897766,
-0.09590059518814087,
-0.509335458278656,
-0.3547672927379608,
-0.21478277444839478,
-0.35952144861221313,
0.11715728789567947,
-0.4178260266780853,
0.36602309346199036,
-0.6329533457756042,
-0.09511338174343109,
0.04957478865981102,
-0.20567624270915985,
-0.6714755296707153,
0.5320376753807068,
0.059459421783685684,
0.8590742349624634,
-0.8565446734428406,
0.9584503769874573,
0.46288228034973145,
-0.34493914246559143,
-0.1396089494228363,
-0.09154035151004791,
-0.07807917147874832,
-1.0581918954849243,
0.8439890742301941,
0.3358181118965149,
-0.1712477058172226,
-0.2881685495376587,
-0.6119109392166138,
-0.6310440301895142,
0.7252476811408997,
0.3004855811595917,
-0.4034721553325653,
0.02787133678793907,
0.22234365344047546,
0.5405067205429077,
-0.7926726341247559,
0.1534235030412674,
0.2546599805355072,
-0.1461581140756607,
0.03946438804268837,
-1.0739332437515259,
-0.06063488870859146,
-0.21260133385658264,
-0.34051254391670227,
0.25116682052612305,
-0.40012326836586,
0.6461488008499146,
-0.4787987768650055,
-0.08074145019054413,
-0.5176615118980408,
0.37752145528793335,
-0.2572278678417206,
0.4912615120410919,
0.6772223711013794,
0.3422223627567291,
0.43007227778434753,
0.3008826971054077,
1.0085124969482422,
-0.4016874432563782,
0.14829595386981964,
0.9983896613121033,
-0.27027302980422974,
0.7196531891822815,
0.5932238698005676,
-0.03084251657128334,
0.3038109242916107,
0.27572181820869446,
-0.03987185284495354,
0.7411553263664246,
-0.13114599883556366,
-0.3109239935874939,
-0.14240628480911255,
0.10187849402427673,
-0.5942306518554688,
0.5743116736412048,
0.4618048667907715,
-0.28900888562202454,
-0.2154185175895691,
0.7377153038978577,
-0.021633906289935112,
-0.290357381105423,
-0.15675006806850433,
0.6029793620109558,
0.17617595195770264,
-0.1830764263868332,
0.6038986444473267,
-0.5150939226150513,
0.6502358317375183,
-0.6959435343742371,
-0.29441797733306885,
-0.10333491116762161,
0.2850443422794342,
-0.0900178924202919,
-0.5460497140884399,
0.391898512840271,
-0.5766655206680298,
0.012054665014147758,
-0.22813186049461365,
0.9453855752944946,
-0.3769567012786865,
-0.3022315502166748,
0.3761191666126251,
0.47119590640068054,
0.4330407679080963,
0.162465900182724,
-0.7972930073738098,
-0.05242620036005974,
-0.30139580368995667,
0.1872435212135315,
0.4807870090007782,
0.27928441762924194,
-0.011639685370028019,
0.7641663551330566,
0.5205856561660767,
0.26613858342170715,
0.20262183248996735,
-0.08696388453245163,
0.9140347242355347,
-0.44788384437561035,
-0.31764209270477295,
-0.519940972328186,
0.25905176997184753,
-0.11873333901166916,
-0.14371727406978607,
0.28266507387161255,
0.6475810408592224,
0.8731362223625183,
-0.4283697307109833,
0.3331851661205292,
0.24960483610630035,
0.5972877144813538,
-0.5039175748825073,
0.9377737045288086,
-0.5503005385398865,
-0.27539965510368347,
-0.049286771565675735,
-0.2844145596027374,
-0.9571827054023743,
0.5582244992256165,
0.013252890668809414,
-0.14799043536186218,
0.8351845145225525,
0.4436333477497101,
-0.3878974914550781,
-0.6471296548843384,
0.7044066786766052,
0.1278020739555359,
0.25686830282211304,
0.25931811332702637,
0.38574668765068054,
-0.3471382260322571,
0.1871640384197235,
-0.4896094501018524,
-0.7108120918273926,
-0.32951620221138,
-0.7058968544006348,
-0.9312745332717896,
-0.6115552186965942,
-0.5874355435371399,
-0.13215678930282593,
-0.12724876403808594,
0.7455318570137024,
1.0665478706359863,
-0.5174233317375183,
-0.05242272466421127,
0.5573725700378418,
-0.3294767439365387,
-0.12093160301446915,
-0.17199939489364624,
0.5850279331207275,
-0.43074852228164673,
-0.34617194533348083,
0.4369926154613495,
0.8163989782333374,
0.21649782359600067,
-0.31718146800994873,
-0.07430648058652878,
-0.04086880385875702,
0.009866297245025635,
0.6435182690620422,
0.6566259860992432,
-0.44927409291267395,
-0.028006920590996742,
-0.11498956382274628,
-0.0954911857843399,
0.5578941106796265,
1.1312599182128906,
-0.9960600733757019,
0.9741160273551941,
-0.003645731834694743,
0.8051044940948486,
0.5706003308296204,
-0.2808452248573303,
0.3793621361255646,
-0.45213305950164795,
0.45736145973205566,
0.2582220435142517,
0.37410658597946167,
0.04711413383483887,
-0.35281211137771606,
0.5429245829582214,
0.4849473237991333,
-0.3236589729785919,
-0.7262521982192993,
0.15980002284049988,
-0.7865522503852844,
-0.213766410946846,
0.5805833339691162,
-0.14273206889629364,
-0.19577647745609283,
-0.3581326901912689,
-0.310256689786911,
-0.02720717340707779,
0.18372191488742828,
0.6691407561302185,
0.17430682480335236,
-0.6007304191589355,
-0.4543185234069824,
-0.45557716488838196,
0.6221252679824829,
0.5810310244560242,
-0.9078682661056519,
-0.6312093138694763,
0.31877636909484863,
0.6338290572166443,
0.06100684404373169,
1.2863487005233765,
-0.48747745156288147,
0.36357957124710083,
-0.23679478466510773,
0.2144017517566681,
-0.22339220345020294,
-0.661250114440918,
-0.5160492062568665,
0.24480657279491425,
-0.17083977162837982,
-0.8523956537246704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04618v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04618v3
|
Strong Priority and Determinacy in Timed CCS
| 2024-03-07T16:02:31 | 2024-05-02T15:45:37 |
Luigi Liquori, Michael Mendler
|
cs.PL
|
cs.PL, cs.CL
|
Building on the standard theory of process algebra with priorities, we
identify a new scheduling mechanism, called "constructive reduction" which is
designed to capture the essence of synchronous programming. The distinctive
property of this evaluation strategy is to achieve determinacy-by-construction
for multi-cast concurrent communication with shared memory. In the technical
setting of CCS extended by clocks and priorities, we prove for a large class of
"coherent" processes a confluence property for constructive reductions. We show
that under some restrictions, called "pivotability", coherence is preserved by
the operators of prefix, summation, parallel composition, restriction and
hiding. Since this permits memory and sharing, we are able to cover a strictly
larger class of processes compared to those in Milner's classical confluence
theory for CCS without priorities.
|
[
-0.6810243725776672,
-0.4096122086048126,
0.5035799741744995,
0.47546884417533875,
-0.2686295211315155,
0.23964689671993256,
-0.40339159965515137,
-0.43595340847969055,
0.6334923505783081,
0.27952519059181213,
-0.7448493242263794,
0.004917960613965988,
-0.5334253907203674,
-0.10639721900224686,
-0.5436108112335205,
0.8991703391075134,
-0.3331659436225891,
0.07213683426380157,
-0.10828182846307755,
-0.2260666787624359,
-0.3231832981109619,
-0.7711250185966492,
-0.3618548512458801,
-0.1378205269575119,
0.4889514446258545,
0.35127124190330505,
1.1048393249511719,
0.3546302020549774,
0.6923694610595703,
0.2878570556640625,
-0.22595293819904327,
-0.20164254307746887,
-0.5486518144607544,
0.5459664463996887,
-0.42546844482421875,
-0.3842046558856964,
-0.33377277851104736,
0.24844004213809967,
0.9783511161804199,
1.0724544525146484,
-0.033412959426641464,
0.03753730654716492,
0.19277437031269073,
0.7583274245262146,
-1.207175850868225,
0.2295481264591217,
-0.3064992427825928,
0.4933907985687256,
-0.500718891620636,
-0.2887020409107208,
-0.43847522139549255,
-0.11203162372112274,
-0.21417775750160217,
-0.5255928635597229,
0.13251325488090515,
-0.23328155279159546,
0.5807921290397644,
0.32235315442085266,
-0.08499570935964584,
0.06481911242008209,
-0.9101161360740662,
1.157829999923706,
0.1654873639345169,
0.3071672320365906,
0.31689929962158203,
0.29673463106155396,
0.07414599508047104,
-0.5653781890869141,
-0.35346877574920654,
0.1672522872686386,
-0.006258184090256691,
0.5518320798873901,
0.2246670424938202,
0.21253009140491486,
0.5111256241798401,
0.796739399433136,
-0.18206346035003662,
-0.16897791624069214,
-0.30191531777381897,
-0.24563485383987427,
0.515785813331604,
0.5405043363571167,
0.113583043217659,
0.17822232842445374,
-0.45575976371765137,
0.3621608018875122,
-0.42879927158355713,
0.18903303146362305,
-0.03734907880425453,
-0.1704137772321701,
-0.10220268368721008,
0.4085024297237396,
-0.3774218261241913,
0.32202380895614624,
0.20655176043510437,
0.2614765465259552,
-0.35519909858703613,
-0.4604426622390747,
-0.04366040974855423,
-0.14568690955638885,
0.2642260491847992,
0.15699245035648346,
-0.2112364023923874,
-0.31397587060928345,
-0.05835030600428581,
0.42569372057914734,
0.15297463536262512,
-0.7281544804573059,
-0.33888548612594604,
0.11080329120159149,
-0.544896125793457,
-0.07527611404657364,
0.1312219798564911,
0.05149073153734207,
0.27930864691734314,
-0.6164810657501221,
-0.1948447972536087,
0.01718476042151451,
-0.05351291969418526,
-0.30618754029273987,
-0.1572140008211136,
0.08774027973413467,
0.3972259759902954,
-0.8333786725997925,
0.6969621181488037,
1.061951994895935,
0.7169399857521057,
-0.5278069376945496,
-0.17566131055355072,
-0.8571407794952393,
0.38668087124824524,
-0.5203672051429749,
0.6767274737358093,
-0.5765658617019653,
-0.30558133125305176,
-0.3805323541164398,
-0.11830383539199829,
-0.12433584779500961,
-0.47490328550338745,
0.3600505590438843,
-0.6512643694877625,
0.015824725851416588,
-0.5737224817276001,
-0.2623313367366791,
0.1578570008277893,
-0.038913603872060776,
-0.7505422830581665,
0.5857266783714294,
0.1917838156223297,
-0.611251950263977,
0.41889384388923645,
-0.22342418134212494,
-0.5307978987693787,
0.1911393254995346,
0.014488562010228634,
-0.4263249933719635,
0.27013272047042847,
-0.4501630663871765,
0.051327984780073166,
-0.05937572568655014,
0.5648629069328308,
-0.7318722009658813,
-0.5052473545074463,
0.14883439242839813,
-0.21711966395378113,
0.9972075819969177,
0.9759314656257629,
-0.13128282129764557,
0.08841605484485626,
-0.33687838912010193,
0.4719744920730591,
-0.49396267533302307,
-0.12090910971164703,
-0.10845959931612015,
0.4820002019405365,
-0.2570357918739319,
0.4658398926258087,
0.46575284004211426,
-0.22090986371040344,
0.3621865212917328,
-0.11649775505065918,
0.4802106022834778,
0.6632698774337769,
-0.033123914152383804,
0.5735887885093689,
-0.5071684122085571,
0.2433103322982788,
-0.1243954673409462,
0.8049653172492981,
0.30417171120643616,
-0.20187534391880035,
-1.0920017957687378,
-0.5301257967948914,
-0.31399670243263245,
0.5112412571907043,
-0.5922678112983704,
0.3749399185180664,
-0.08211266994476318,
-0.14940564334392548,
0.11257679760456085,
-0.09236180037260056,
0.5543925762176514,
-0.5255816578865051,
0.22054113447666168,
-1.1644772291183472,
-0.5455431342124939,
-0.7687135338783264,
-0.030213171616196632,
-0.12195021659135818,
0.2773214280605316,
-0.04115227982401848,
-0.08942051976919174,
0.3528643548488617,
0.6473757028579712,
-0.4642179608345032,
0.19124966859817505,
-0.13020643591880798,
0.29712843894958496,
0.49134835600852966,
0.504856288433075,
0.1773897111415863,
-0.5134165287017822,
-0.5694846510887146,
-0.6158624291419983,
-0.6686418652534485,
-0.19065387547016144,
-0.15978243947029114,
-0.36498919129371643,
0.27973252534866333,
0.3855416476726532,
-0.5345404148101807,
0.7837940454483032,
0.44975319504737854,
-0.2804781198501587,
0.7207454442977905,
0.16484130918979645,
0.10526082664728165,
-0.6059954762458801,
0.018283575773239136,
-1.0577775239944458,
-0.33412960171699524,
-0.6681363582611084,
0.3645537197589874,
-0.4244181513786316,
-0.43949881196022034,
-0.48264920711517334,
0.12185781449079514,
-0.5741272568702698,
-0.5982768535614014,
-0.2577916979789734,
-0.24565866589546204,
-0.14105089008808136,
0.331390380859375,
0.32377445697784424,
0.5287474989891052,
0.502748966217041,
-0.8920886516571045,
-0.018796706572175026,
0.23730123043060303,
0.022725911810994148,
0.9098256826400757,
-0.4238757789134979,
-0.07653848826885223,
0.11466486752033234,
-0.016574319452047348,
-0.3795188367366791,
0.43780529499053955,
0.0818060040473938,
-0.05028475075960159,
0.14593949913978577,
-0.10371677577495575,
-0.19493284821510315,
-0.29501646757125854,
-0.3849976658821106,
0.4469617009162903,
0.08112186938524246,
-0.10732702165842056,
-0.14017553627490997,
0.32880061864852905,
-0.23580463230609894,
-0.4442322850227356,
-0.49345192313194275,
0.1455865353345871,
0.3858431577682495,
-0.5636539459228516,
0.7365923523902893,
-0.45294657349586487,
-0.5351454019546509,
0.24323198199272156,
-0.2164272964000702,
-0.3878800570964813,
0.5293247103691101,
0.3269057869911194,
0.14197449386119843,
0.38693785667419434,
-0.05818323791027069,
0.0895933210849762,
-0.529548168182373,
-0.14438141882419586,
0.000652693270239979,
0.6875640153884888,
0.14422625303268433,
-0.5692272186279297,
-0.722248911857605,
0.8065398931503296,
0.653581440448761,
-0.1952836513519287,
0.8687830567359924,
0.5901354551315308,
-0.11338377743959427,
-0.0016525983810424805,
-0.2686764597892761,
-0.3196567893028259,
-0.43961814045906067,
-0.12984006106853485,
-0.3307907283306122,
-1.1832972764968872,
0.7914872765541077,
0.33630725741386414,
0.06036584451794624,
0.5146151185035706,
0.5400763750076294,
0.21743230521678925,
0.9836325645446777,
0.29939913749694824,
-0.17482970654964447,
0.8739357590675354,
-0.30611157417297363,
0.5337990522384644,
-0.6953604817390442,
0.0815759152173996,
-0.44857075810432434,
-0.3810712695121765,
-0.6914106011390686,
-0.2739342749118805,
0.23453335464000702,
0.637246310710907,
-0.7134631276130676,
0.3085450530052185,
-0.7767056822776794,
0.41323497891426086,
0.4738498330116272,
-0.257140189409256,
0.40690669417381287,
-0.2425890862941742,
-0.07898487895727158,
-0.23080191016197205,
-0.7336233854293823,
-0.19952000677585602,
0.28214529156684875,
-0.27077463269233704,
0.4212273955345154,
0.11753714829683304,
1.1026076078414917,
0.3565894663333893,
0.4175334572792053,
-0.4537580609321594,
0.6899489164352417,
-0.2946451008319855,
-0.8764517903327942,
-0.12859301269054413,
-0.41161152720451355,
-0.9004811644554138,
0.021841775625944138,
-0.3063009977340698,
-0.5584108829498291,
0.2980332672595978,
-0.09411643445491791,
-0.19368445873260498,
0.23788002133369446,
-0.4404350519180298,
0.48918652534484863,
-0.027516191825270653,
-0.9470740556716919,
-0.8509895205497742,
-0.3807148039340973,
0.4521181881427765,
0.4157688617706299,
-0.036042019724845886,
-0.33416616916656494,
0.22222529351711273,
0.5881824493408203,
-1.0675716400146484,
0.6374980211257935,
-0.1108299195766449,
0.5553943514823914,
0.5287402272224426,
0.5713552832603455,
0.4070301651954651,
0.16174288094043732,
0.009144906885921955,
0.07632381469011307,
0.12645475566387177,
-0.5446763634681702,
-0.39580225944519043,
0.7653340697288513,
-0.7135005593299866,
-0.5203978419303894,
-0.6241834759712219,
-0.5155835747718811,
0.4233981668949127,
0.24924777448177338,
0.07098303735256195,
0.27358680963516235,
-0.09941401332616806,
-0.030726216733455658,
-0.013755165971815586,
0.15243691205978394,
0.7364695072174072,
0.2881791293621063,
-0.05710580199956894,
-0.4321272373199463,
0.5262003540992737,
0.45802199840545654,
0.4738924205303192,
0.26482954621315,
-0.31090444326400757,
0.20633135735988617,
-0.49307680130004883,
0.5293614864349365,
-0.027747470885515213,
-0.42763158679008484,
0.005176975857466459,
-0.29739516973495483,
-0.646470308303833,
-0.16470682621002197,
-0.7827864289283752,
-0.69864821434021,
-1.1230287551879883,
-0.22982157766819,
0.4035043716430664,
-0.02424800582230091,
0.4520396590232849,
-0.15179979801177979,
0.050234291702508926,
-0.7382287979125977,
0.33585307002067566,
0.46856433153152466,
0.5911809802055359,
-0.08106613904237747,
-0.03929191082715988,
-0.559709370136261,
-0.27854660153388977,
-0.8870105743408203,
-0.4080370366573334,
0.5578576922416687,
-0.03660884127020836,
0.6222724318504333,
0.5662277340888977,
0.49521419405937195,
0.9656687378883362,
-0.26294511556625366,
0.8011130094528198,
0.4134840667247772,
-1.441225528717041,
0.23689739406108856,
-0.16629602015018463,
0.2799873650074005,
0.6613932251930237,
0.16170118749141693,
-0.6913329362869263,
-0.6644375920295715,
-0.8427271246910095,
-0.7702228426933289,
0.5354462265968323,
0.6060194969177246,
-0.4190501868724823,
-0.37604042887687683,
0.17203472554683685,
-0.21500200033187866,
0.2302008867263794,
-0.5174362659454346,
-0.23201315104961395,
-0.0366845466196537,
0.2066607028245926,
0.1332090198993683,
-0.4995448589324951,
-0.1533689796924591,
-0.1769346296787262,
0.3491019904613495,
0.32759860157966614,
0.5052528977394104,
0.3051898181438446,
-0.1504017859697342,
-0.04278925433754921,
0.5867847204208374,
0.3895057439804077,
0.7959627509117126,
0.05098465457558632,
0.42851072549819946,
-0.009882351383566856,
-0.3103864789009094,
0.11350502818822861,
-0.018541596829891205,
-0.2580226957798004,
-0.1835688203573227,
0.31419506669044495,
0.35247838497161865,
0.3673449456691742,
0.12914282083511353,
0.23637792468070984,
0.18056443333625793,
0.1100715696811676,
-0.4639326333999634,
-0.005733659956604242,
-0.2555121183395386,
0.33069783449172974,
0.21235015988349915,
0.36937546730041504,
0.29145556688308716,
-0.7227516770362854,
0.259192556142807,
0.4890974760055542,
-0.5618258714675903,
-0.5385120511054993,
0.5153920650482178,
0.2922084629535675,
-0.19438651204109192,
0.6098920702934265,
-0.7199053168296814,
-0.6718825697898865,
0.2873501181602478,
0.2743174135684967,
0.8873332142829895,
-0.3251064717769623,
0.0756227970123291,
0.40397319197654724,
0.021355444565415382,
-0.1905258744955063,
0.6720743775367737,
-0.6304160356521606,
-0.5504825711250305,
-0.6710935235023499,
-0.2851565182209015,
-0.7795183658599854,
-0.6557433605194092,
-0.8923658132553101,
0.25732624530792236,
-0.8348809480667114,
-0.5191508531570435,
-0.01646171323955059,
0.2529224753379822,
-0.42373040318489075,
-0.5105722546577454,
-0.013307742774486542,
0.2240886688232422,
-0.5228090286254883,
0.6043597459793091,
0.06447417289018631,
-0.2183300256729126,
-0.40891656279563904,
-0.42381954193115234,
-0.08874960988759995,
-0.384364515542984,
0.945198655128479,
-0.03370959684252739,
-0.07985050231218338,
-0.3521190881729126,
-0.4791729152202606,
-1.1251460313796997,
0.9434937834739685,
0.41926446557044983,
-0.588045597076416,
0.23715220391750336,
-0.20010198652744293,
0.29439204931259155,
-0.0028883740305900574,
0.17779791355133057,
-0.017119862139225006,
0.5625006556510925,
0.14581212401390076,
-1.1278862953186035,
0.044884998351335526,
-0.175278902053833,
-0.1369381546974182,
0.7647508978843689,
-1.0524699687957764,
1.0971711874008179,
-0.24877382814884186,
-0.8574159741401672,
0.20677262544631958,
0.43018174171447754,
0.1841055154800415,
0.5434788465499878,
0.2028375118970871,
0.8621006608009338,
0.41079646348953247,
-0.4703856110572815,
0.9697306156158447,
-0.5740861892700195,
0.506682813167572,
0.7644262313842773,
-0.5643283128738403,
0.5969173312187195,
0.595199704170227,
-0.6222630143165588,
0.6345667839050293,
0.1628744900226593,
0.44594326615333557,
0.5300861597061157,
0.28749150037765503,
-0.6218200922012329,
-0.7386795878410339,
-0.4722883701324463,
-0.13501092791557312,
0.27690064907073975,
0.19259504973888397,
-0.13960298895835876,
-0.12516236305236816,
-0.4942077398300171,
0.18559035658836365,
0.025549786165356636,
-0.4571649730205536,
0.5307164788246155,
0.3265056610107422,
-1.0099694728851318,
0.6447887420654297,
-0.2182990461587906,
0.21682220697402954,
-0.3084412217140198,
0.11133250594139099,
0.070772685110569,
0.3399104177951813,
-0.4307965338230133,
-0.7507231831550598,
1.0541497468948364,
-0.39249518513679504,
-0.4466547966003418,
-0.4570920765399933,
0.43557316064834595,
-0.2678278982639313,
-0.1295681744813919,
0.23082561790943146,
0.18902650475502014,
0.09683087468147278,
0.23617425560951233,
-0.500018835067749,
0.184206023812294,
-0.2937260568141937,
0.07365161180496216,
0.16396920382976532,
0.0874156504869461,
-0.44519802927970886,
0.5883206725120544,
0.6539720892906189,
0.20989297330379486,
-0.16090582311153412,
0.08848052471876144,
0.9854480028152466,
-0.9204133152961731,
-0.6552187204360962,
-0.5629397034645081,
0.10779793560504913,
-0.2313964068889618,
0.20618997514247894,
0.7089470028877258,
0.7296468615531921,
0.7265217900276184,
0.20103411376476288,
0.3899763226509094,
-0.022314151749014854,
0.1924370527267456,
-0.4005626440048218,
0.5445948839187622,
0.024167291820049286,
0.27824410796165466,
-0.3644745945930481,
-0.9547678232192993,
-0.5689171552658081,
0.515017032623291,
-0.5598806142807007,
-0.10605891048908234,
1.1837420463562012,
0.3608664572238922,
0.32401734590530396,
-0.03178736940026283,
0.34828412532806396,
-0.2557707726955414,
0.2657502591609955,
1.0764466524124146,
0.9342360496520996,
0.03088971972465515,
0.14968904852867126,
-0.4719727635383606,
-0.2175157517194748,
-0.15662474930286407,
-0.7936635613441467,
-0.5840213894844055,
-0.599288821220398,
-0.4097403585910797,
-0.005034379195421934,
0.3616754412651062,
0.5285801291465759,
0.9177829027175903,
-0.7391719222068787,
-0.35108664631843567,
-0.1809757947921753,
0.3644742965698242,
-0.6544302701950073,
-0.2263907939195633,
0.1897008866071701,
-0.5053612589836121,
-0.4780193567276001,
-0.0546233095228672,
0.6918985843658447,
-0.16844160854816437,
-0.0908859521150589,
-0.19820089638233185,
0.09752009063959122,
-0.15801885724067688,
0.8127321600914001,
0.46267056465148926,
-0.21182867884635925,
-0.287624716758728,
0.0957798883318901,
0.10045335441827774,
-0.06070250645279884,
1.3185440301895142,
-0.3566339313983917,
0.5400325059890747,
0.9048607349395752,
-0.06629517674446106,
0.8896297216415405,
-0.17736226320266724,
0.23170118033885956,
-0.3772592544555664,
0.4751668870449066,
0.45177868008613586,
0.4077037572860718,
-0.11803135275840759,
-0.23059682548046112,
0.279184490442276,
0.7101654410362244,
-0.7862697243690491,
-0.33491235971450806,
0.7386900782585144,
-1.3834707736968994,
-0.11590160429477692,
0.5418331623077393,
-0.0982302874326706,
-0.0067760273814201355,
-0.46134164929389954,
0.3770136833190918,
0.3796851336956024,
-0.3028985559940338,
0.780207097530365,
0.782260537147522,
-0.44771820306777954,
-0.03610944375395775,
-0.14409440755844116,
0.22287344932556152,
0.6012606024742126,
-0.5329891443252563,
0.1916169375181198,
0.6243472099304199,
-0.15839006006717682,
0.478534996509552,
0.8774024844169617,
-0.5294589400291443,
0.5458001494407654,
-0.2061842530965805,
0.2895979881286621,
-0.02983105555176735,
-0.39250218868255615,
0.019354330375790596,
0.21699972450733185,
0.4111943542957306,
0.07597804814577103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04577v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04577v1
|
Wiki-TabNER:Advancing Table Interpretation Through Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-03-07T15:22:07 | 2024-03-07T15:22:07 |
Aneta Koleva, Martin Ringsquandl, Ahmed Hatem, Thomas Runkler, Volker Tresp
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Web tables contain a large amount of valuable knowledge and have inspired
tabular language models aimed at tackling table interpretation (TI) tasks. In
this paper, we analyse a widely used benchmark dataset for evaluation of TI
tasks, particularly focusing on the entity linking task. Our analysis reveals
that this dataset is overly simplified, potentially reducing its effectiveness
for thorough evaluation and failing to accurately represent tables as they
appear in the real-world. To overcome this drawback, we construct and annotate
a new more challenging dataset. In addition to introducing the new dataset, we
also introduce a novel problem aimed at addressing the entity linking task:
named entity recognition within cells. Finally, we propose a prompting
framework for evaluating the newly developed large language models (LLMs) on
this novel TI task. We conduct experiments on prompting LLMs under various
settings, where we use both random and similarity-based selection to choose the
examples presented to the models. Our ablation study helps us gain insights
into the impact of the few-shot examples. Additionally, we perform qualitative
analysis to gain insights into the challenges encountered by the models and to
understand the limitations of the proposed dataset.
|
[
-0.3986458480358124,
-0.6105185151100159,
0.5799542665481567,
-0.08959663659334183,
-0.33140289783477783,
-0.14253748953342438,
-0.2616459131240845,
-0.6426259279251099,
-0.18030467629432678,
0.35463985800743103,
-0.545138955116272,
-0.585328996181488,
-0.25521138310432434,
0.5358617305755615,
-0.840229332447052,
1.088726282119751,
-0.2171565592288971,
0.14978618919849396,
-0.305184006690979,
0.025624388828873634,
-0.3070266544818878,
0.3692547082901001,
-0.567755937576294,
-0.5462440252304077,
0.8169840574264526,
0.5703336596488953,
0.4463067352771759,
0.9543399214744568,
0.6881003975868225,
0.2720884382724762,
-0.08339456468820572,
0.009534575045108795,
-0.31003978848457336,
0.10527560114860535,
-0.12868550419807434,
-0.472822368144989,
-0.26851752400398254,
-0.2006046324968338,
0.6868158578872681,
0.9608538746833801,
-0.24037374556064606,
0.5130895972251892,
0.0013923298101872206,
0.6699864864349365,
-0.2858370542526245,
0.3884239196777344,
-1.0517535209655762,
0.08892319351434708,
-0.4872843027114868,
0.07630941271781921,
-0.7270985245704651,
-0.316837877035141,
0.16929106414318085,
-0.5155959725379944,
0.4085695743560791,
0.38454195857048035,
0.9262366890907288,
0.21061033010482788,
-0.32601475715637207,
-0.38535580039024353,
-0.7017730474472046,
0.3012368083000183,
-0.3927675187587738,
0.7320382595062256,
0.025484437122941017,
0.3751643896102905,
-0.3555034101009369,
-0.9360644817352295,
-0.9709476828575134,
-0.5059614777565002,
-0.0030875324737280607,
-0.2582426965236664,
-0.35918959975242615,
0.004249418154358864,
0.5643397569656372,
0.08756358176469803,
-0.5840668082237244,
0.2359941303730011,
-0.41670864820480347,
-0.053964801132678986,
0.12798099219799042,
0.20623145997524261,
0.40201225876808167,
-0.20275373756885529,
-0.3596864938735962,
0.0014089071191847324,
-0.7844631671905518,
-0.05928241088986397,
0.14533917605876923,
0.41381537914276123,
-0.06087789684534073,
0.6859027743339539,
-0.3270457088947296,
0.9144585728645325,
-0.09707438945770264,
0.22228403389453888,
0.16879712045192719,
0.19208753108978271,
-0.3352716267108917,
0.09543905407190323,
0.5519517064094543,
0.3223561942577362,
0.43419426679611206,
-0.5592434406280518,
0.06484156101942062,
0.029214899986982346,
0.38236913084983826,
-0.6833536624908447,
-0.43726569414138794,
0.22383955121040344,
-0.28516507148742676,
-0.15925215184688568,
-0.03606389835476875,
-1.0416913032531738,
-0.5905873775482178,
-0.25958696007728577,
0.3334518074989319,
-0.13703995943069458,
-0.05574517324566841,
-0.2922185957431793,
-0.12686938047409058,
0.18759296834468842,
0.3825909197330475,
-0.7680904269218445,
0.3877094089984894,
0.5105624794960022,
0.5625064373016357,
-0.3738352060317993,
-0.2460174411535263,
-0.443504273891449,
0.3733315169811249,
-0.34962353110313416,
1.2672909498214722,
-0.5352991819381714,
-0.32978159189224243,
-0.21794670820236206,
-0.008987193927168846,
0.16237103939056396,
-0.6742540001869202,
0.5022464990615845,
-0.4991699755191803,
-0.3043619990348816,
-0.60906982421875,
-0.4995519816875458,
-0.10976285487413406,
0.15900112688541412,
-1.164426326751709,
0.7711564302444458,
0.02565312385559082,
-0.7282991409301758,
0.8606691956520081,
-0.891705334186554,
-0.2836083471775055,
0.24804691970348358,
-0.3658706247806549,
-0.5124000906944275,
0.14800462126731873,
0.040065210312604904,
0.34717199206352234,
-0.5189219117164612,
0.24058757722377777,
-0.29022637009620667,
-0.09218935668468475,
0.5375286936759949,
-0.1725158840417862,
0.38415855169296265,
0.1614568829536438,
-0.30078402161598206,
0.09348069131374359,
-0.872489869594574,
0.10376299172639847,
0.04047705605626106,
-0.26285529136657715,
-0.05462929233908653,
-0.019835427403450012,
-0.015945713967084885,
0.03546436131000519,
-0.04040749371051788,
-0.4882504940032959,
0.19297702610492706,
-0.10377883911132812,
0.258176326751709,
0.518349289894104,
0.06254275888204575,
0.2189462035894394,
-0.10182704031467438,
0.3451162278652191,
0.04672359302639961,
-0.13449153304100037,
0.2792007029056549,
-0.3651300370693207,
-0.8440690636634827,
0.07046852260828018,
0.6905182600021362,
0.37394189834594727,
-1.0365079641342163,
-0.170917809009552,
-0.6906455159187317,
-0.6790513396263123,
-0.3689819276332855,
0.1662423014640808,
0.49660831689834595,
0.8418430089950562,
0.6406093835830688,
0.06839369982481003,
-0.5556131601333618,
-1.2831335067749023,
-0.45157262682914734,
-0.1800500899553299,
-0.15228383243083954,
0.2917729318141937,
0.5656085014343262,
0.013450070284307003,
0.8129919767379761,
-0.3834852874279022,
-0.134800985455513,
-0.4846067428588867,
0.3037303686141968,
0.21731159090995789,
0.3883073627948761,
0.015797588974237442,
-0.8447051644325256,
-0.6058184504508972,
0.19210520386695862,
-0.6214841604232788,
-0.2016328126192093,
-0.04038147255778313,
0.06447742879390717,
-0.09068187326192856,
0.4501160979270935,
-0.8557151556015015,
0.2251739352941513,
0.13758514821529388,
-0.07587265223264694,
0.5676330924034119,
0.2390354722738266,
0.19115835428237915,
-0.704317569732666,
0.43842777609825134,
0.283977746963501,
0.019050275906920433,
-0.9649604558944702,
-0.06351794302463531,
0.2199450582265854,
-0.1776796281337738,
-0.474540114402771,
0.7345388531684875,
-0.7463899254798889,
-0.3742498457431793,
-0.09496506303548813,
0.24753643572330475,
-0.058400459587574005,
0.34303200244903564,
-0.10062827914953232,
0.7736203670501709,
0.1651337444782257,
-0.6090017557144165,
0.30659720301628113,
0.6157713532447815,
-0.4603138566017151,
0.4927711486816406,
-0.44035348296165466,
0.014645506627857685,
-0.1586323082447052,
0.13049237430095673,
-0.8394893407821655,
-0.42046600580215454,
0.2796701192855835,
-0.4795246422290802,
0.5676084160804749,
-0.055083032697439194,
-0.4418751299381256,
-0.5209226012229919,
0.05061120167374611,
0.13325488567352295,
0.09362470358610153,
-0.654915988445282,
0.5485785603523254,
0.3181116580963135,
-0.05941757187247276,
-0.6499091386795044,
-0.5797244310379028,
0.27811765670776367,
-0.42630404233932495,
-0.21458369493484497,
0.5580750703811646,
0.2192687690258026,
-0.3484119176864624,
0.15321232378482819,
-0.6101483106613159,
-0.23358291387557983,
0.09258580207824707,
0.27688246965408325,
0.22530342638492584,
-0.014935405924916267,
0.4115724563598633,
-0.06907356530427933,
-0.09545249491930008,
0.20409294962882996,
0.08928535878658295,
0.4009721577167511,
0.08209732919931412,
-0.11192581057548523,
-0.6914343237876892,
-0.023222221061587334,
0.14539216458797455,
-0.13613702356815338,
0.571560263633728,
0.61094069480896,
-0.5999350547790527,
-0.23137402534484863,
-0.7171752452850342,
0.010372559539973736,
-0.46086975932121277,
0.3164784610271454,
-0.7037385702133179,
-0.34665927290916443,
0.5766158103942871,
-0.18870796263217926,
0.03440644592046738,
0.4817776381969452,
0.4001936912536621,
-0.20125991106033325,
0.6534937620162964,
0.36883148550987244,
0.16004447638988495,
0.3743520677089691,
-0.10172579437494278,
0.03845709562301636,
-0.9568808674812317,
-0.45801740884780884,
-0.9887803196907043,
-0.3180907666683197,
-0.482214093208313,
-0.28222528100013733,
0.19226467609405518,
-0.08376647531986237,
0.13251720368862152,
0.6059681177139282,
-0.37558960914611816,
0.5381643176078796,
0.18346276879310608,
0.2822135388851166,
0.3293261229991913,
0.1689392626285553,
-0.26735204458236694,
0.14024163782596588,
-0.41725683212280273,
-0.6703528165817261,
0.987981379032135,
0.18200218677520752,
0.7337751984596252,
-0.029864834621548653,
0.6413508653640747,
0.39526766538619995,
0.7426801919937134,
-0.55411696434021,
0.789673924446106,
-0.020847713574767113,
-0.7659239768981934,
-0.5104380249977112,
-0.5956152081489563,
-1.195861577987671,
0.06776490062475204,
-0.3071412742137909,
-1.251570463180542,
0.00680194515734911,
0.23674680292606354,
-0.13934828341007233,
0.252079576253891,
-0.6632828116416931,
1.1571978330612183,
0.13192684948444366,
-0.5154615640640259,
-0.008564812131226063,
-0.31442657113075256,
0.2886645197868347,
0.008002649992704391,
0.1691051572561264,
-0.2371709644794464,
-0.0370662659406662,
0.7994174957275391,
0.041623592376708984,
0.38213515281677246,
-0.36505430936813354,
0.08442503213882446,
0.31789538264274597,
0.045718491077423096,
0.5876292586326599,
-0.06785891950130463,
-0.3709048330783844,
-0.049959298223257065,
-0.08657665550708771,
-0.11282692104578018,
-0.4990873634815216,
0.6862158179283142,
-0.25808393955230713,
-0.6753649711608887,
-0.046467363834381104,
-0.4197254478931427,
-0.5030055046081543,
0.21229484677314758,
0.1235278844833374,
0.5141744017601013,
-0.17220795154571533,
0.3226338326931,
0.5464019775390625,
-0.1477922797203064,
0.2193051129579544,
0.4451185464859009,
-0.1164201945066452,
-0.10536326467990875,
0.7546326518058777,
0.09006195515394211,
-0.0804472416639328,
0.5278093218803406,
-0.18242046236991882,
-0.5687726736068726,
-1.0311899185180664,
-0.8002283573150635,
0.10414203256368637,
-0.8265019655227661,
-0.4050300121307373,
-0.7122185230255127,
0.13225309550762177,
-0.0647563710808754,
0.2688109874725342,
0.08859001845121384,
-0.2635548710823059,
-0.3342379629611969,
-0.3413853943347931,
0.31459176540374756,
0.6501019597053528,
0.3976120948791504,
0.3005027174949646,
-0.8266391754150391,
0.5348985195159912,
0.2260933220386505,
0.7553809881210327,
0.20242823660373688,
-0.04950857535004616,
-0.3094060719013214,
-0.25866904854774475,
-0.044817931950092316,
-1.4890424013137817,
0.10083412379026413,
0.1571754813194275,
0.9938105344772339,
0.08211234211921692,
-0.024998484179377556,
0.8286094069480896,
-0.8082364201545715,
0.33643457293510437,
0.010155616328120232,
-0.9366446733474731,
0.34395503997802734,
-0.1855415254831314,
0.16590382158756256,
0.7850221395492554,
0.40347421169281006,
-0.3874913156032562,
-0.17526288330554962,
-0.43947070837020874,
-0.6630537509918213,
0.4551334083080292,
0.20416763424873352,
-0.22909875214099884,
-0.14449208974838257,
0.6203846335411072,
0.21952398121356964,
0.1950494796037674,
-1.105519413948059,
-0.22594374418258667,
0.38793250918388367,
-0.3757149875164032,
0.27342158555984497,
-0.11986078321933746,
0.08570791780948639,
-0.03617241233587265,
0.7138528227806091,
-0.04529741778969765,
0.2598715126514435,
0.16153740882873535,
-0.6372842788696289,
-0.4129024147987366,
0.5674557685852051,
0.2421324998140335,
0.6438935995101929,
0.08614872395992279,
-0.012670783326029778,
0.5886662006378174,
-0.3672809302806854,
-0.02358854189515114,
0.3870256543159485,
-0.07739133387804031,
0.18026986718177795,
0.1542181670665741,
0.7141595482826233,
0.3285614550113678,
-0.658449113368988,
-0.032246336340904236,
-0.03555707633495331,
0.16815702617168427,
-0.2161722630262375,
0.13205724954605103,
0.1812419891357422,
0.2689948081970215,
0.6394981741905212,
-0.48122432827949524,
0.5826808214187622,
-0.3686436712741852,
0.34065037965774536,
0.6142551898956299,
-0.4210645258426666,
-0.12222421914339066,
0.6891816258430481,
0.054611098021268845,
-0.30971837043762207,
0.5192217230796814,
-0.289095401763916,
-0.3357446789741516,
0.7214686274528503,
0.34830066561698914,
0.5927990674972534,
-0.14876732230186462,
0.13193495571613312,
0.3858233690261841,
0.2523888647556305,
0.060043491423130035,
0.24575810134410858,
-0.18313811719417572,
-0.5267581343650818,
-0.19544291496276855,
-0.7841646075248718,
-0.5877441763877869,
0.33858367800712585,
-0.8659971356391907,
0.4483181834220886,
-0.08597351610660553,
-0.33183881640434265,
0.7388367056846619,
0.10542676597833633,
-0.9510740637779236,
0.2121565192937851,
0.0971096083521843,
1.0004029273986816,
-0.7547528743743896,
0.9104607105255127,
0.7426814436912537,
-0.22296491265296936,
-0.8108198046684265,
-0.07150339335203171,
0.018917977809906006,
-0.5030925869941711,
0.6374638080596924,
0.41943052411079407,
0.37142834067344666,
0.3070896565914154,
-0.24575315415859222,
-0.658623218536377,
1.0544090270996094,
0.14114905893802643,
-0.6524670720100403,
-0.356557697057724,
0.3333696126937866,
0.5558725595474243,
-0.2332564741373062,
0.17974141240119934,
0.7843760251998901,
0.7006134986877441,
-0.12553007900714874,
-1.0408222675323486,
0.2878659963607788,
-0.24633897840976715,
-0.16091158986091614,
0.547161877155304,
-0.02769901044666767,
0.7325135469436646,
-0.28057435154914856,
-0.5453817844390869,
0.1035396158695221,
0.5613073706626892,
0.17762307822704315,
0.42352840304374695,
0.7004623413085938,
0.4508691728115082,
0.5611278414726257,
-0.2245892584323883,
0.6410363912582397,
-0.07676360011100769,
0.184116393327713,
1.2055667638778687,
-0.4793812930583954,
0.9018939137458801,
0.6481453776359558,
-0.4729076623916626,
0.4835699200630188,
0.5090915560722351,
-0.6666184067726135,
0.17607182264328003,
0.596609354019165,
-0.15476490557193756,
-0.042890068143606186,
-0.22505779564380646,
-0.19376204907894135,
0.4764803647994995,
0.6176480650901794,
-0.3292348384857178,
-0.6435161828994751,
0.025131797417998314,
-0.3200869560241699,
-0.00959150679409504,
-0.38482216000556946,
0.8764044642448425,
-0.05195894092321396,
-0.5719539523124695,
0.16152390837669373,
-0.3266654908657074,
-0.013943529687821865,
-0.2240581065416336,
-0.29742494225502014,
0.09796083718538284,
-0.2522270679473877,
-0.3335804343223572,
-0.7100095152854919,
0.10618078708648682,
0.42951950430870056,
-0.002423612866550684,
0.10275475680828094,
0.6372779607772827,
-0.3914443552494049,
-0.2570869028568268,
0.08969298005104065,
0.706046462059021,
0.43832284212112427,
0.11625257879495621,
-0.6504167914390564,
0.2059788554906845,
0.11235806345939636,
-0.3382897675037384,
0.14991402626037598,
0.4000450670719147,
-0.1201915293931961,
0.8763540983200073,
0.5646448135375977,
-0.0239099133759737,
-0.1269581913948059,
0.15892082452774048,
0.8297842741012573,
-0.8474523425102234,
-0.2552349865436554,
-0.8127191662788391,
0.5680281519889832,
-0.09216783940792084,
0.032178353518247604,
0.46865391731262207,
0.6639394760131836,
0.627582311630249,
-0.18497492372989655,
0.4141380786895752,
-0.12692470848560333,
0.6315332055091858,
-0.6559740900993347,
0.7109284400939941,
-0.4048667252063751,
0.4106769859790802,
-0.395516961812973,
-1.0236117839813232,
-0.28204360604286194,
0.33755600452423096,
-0.3377227783203125,
-0.003636835142970085,
0.7142951488494873,
0.5371949076652527,
0.09292356669902802,
0.1309327334165573,
0.30711987614631653,
0.3668699562549591,
0.22906385362148285,
0.23448577523231506,
0.7750483751296997,
-0.16896404325962067,
0.9535806775093079,
-0.2423994094133377,
0.1877077966928482,
-0.2102264016866684,
-0.9571519494056702,
-0.843317449092865,
-0.7470094561576843,
-0.3478509485721588,
-0.18456244468688965,
0.17118188738822937,
0.9663981795310974,
0.284270703792572,
-0.8670758605003357,
0.0007512658485211432,
-0.19301515817642212,
0.15918803215026855,
0.018182657659053802,
-0.1934487372636795,
0.2943314015865326,
-0.22438479959964752,
-0.7184921503067017,
0.2309652417898178,
0.0005554407835006714,
0.18367232382297516,
-0.03170768544077873,
0.5813642740249634,
-0.10475973784923553,
-0.33911052346229553,
0.16537071764469147,
0.3271316885948181,
-0.8083387017250061,
-0.29272645711898804,
-0.12681612372398376,
-0.05681268498301506,
0.28930047154426575,
0.6168757081031799,
-0.7625728249549866,
0.2700462341308594,
0.1895817667245865,
0.6112887859344482,
0.6654316186904907,
-0.05939651280641556,
0.30084288120269775,
-0.46974608302116394,
-0.19835352897644043,
0.20911310613155365,
0.5100786685943604,
0.4844648838043213,
-0.3094758093357086,
0.4921444356441498,
-0.26109036803245544,
-0.28775790333747864,
-1.1901458501815796,
0.25754013657569885,
-1.102504849433899,
-0.14434267580509186,
0.9493801593780518,
-0.1196688786149025,
-0.4990168511867523,
-0.17891907691955566,
0.05562003701925278,
0.6501034498214722,
-0.4262259602546692,
1.0520412921905518,
0.669379472732544,
-0.2680915296077728,
-0.3157018721103668,
-0.7947620153427124,
0.7193816900253296,
0.02259134314954281,
-1.174019694328308,
0.22210435569286346,
0.5729649066925049,
0.3997174799442291,
0.199893057346344,
0.17018936574459076,
0.04134614020586014,
0.38951846957206726,
0.14342030882835388,
0.2762620151042938,
-0.11314152181148529,
-0.4751615822315216,
-0.30998191237449646,
0.13310913741588593,
0.3239711821079254,
0.14574027061462402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04521v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04521v2
|
Uncertainty-Aware Relational Graph Neural Network for Few-Shot Knowledge Graph Completion
| 2024-03-07T14:23:25 | 2024-03-21T04:28:45 |
Qian Li, Shu Guo, Yinjia Chen, Cheng Ji, Jiawei Sheng, Jianxin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Few-shot knowledge graph completion (FKGC) aims to query the unseen facts of
a relation given its few-shot reference entity pairs. The side effect of noises
due to the uncertainty of entities and triples may limit the few-shot learning,
but existing FKGC works neglect such uncertainty, which leads them more
susceptible to limited reference samples with noises. In this paper, we propose
a novel uncertainty-aware few-shot KG completion framework (UFKGC) to model
uncertainty for a better understanding of the limited data by learning
representations under Gaussian distribution. Uncertainty representation is
first designed for estimating the uncertainty scope of the entity pairs after
transferring feature representations into a Gaussian distribution. Further, to
better integrate the neighbors with uncertainty characteristics for entity
features, we design an uncertainty-aware relational graph neural network
(UR-GNN) to conduct convolution operations between the Gaussian distributions.
Then, multiple random samplings are conducted for reference triples within the
Gaussian distribution to generate smooth reference representations during the
optimization. The final completion score for each query instance is measured by
the designed uncertainty optimization to make our approach more robust to the
noises in few-shot scenarios. Experimental results show that our approach
achieves excellent performance on two benchmark datasets compared to its
competitors.
|
[
-0.21857860684394836,
-0.6678668856620789,
0.6420432329177856,
-0.31752070784568787,
-0.4389093518257141,
0.010425867512822151,
-0.04005909338593483,
-0.49738025665283203,
0.04781920462846756,
0.23230428993701935,
-0.5545472502708435,
-0.8235868215560913,
-0.5166098475456238,
-0.15604476630687714,
0.11493461579084396,
0.6315223574638367,
0.16284316778182983,
-0.06299321353435516,
-0.1767127960920334,
-0.05382244661450386,
0.10774195194244385,
-0.08943995088338852,
-0.5651750564575195,
-0.6264983415603638,
0.4676346182823181,
0.45759090781211853,
0.9440957307815552,
0.4630361497402191,
0.41979876160621643,
0.1478424370288849,
0.06474520266056061,
0.29029878973960876,
-0.7917797565460205,
0.016133518889546394,
0.3103277087211609,
-0.27569836378097534,
-0.19561314582824707,
-0.24733708798885345,
0.642589807510376,
0.9586421251296997,
-0.15062804520130157,
-0.0030951867811381817,
0.08628086745738983,
0.6503317356109619,
-0.8974671363830566,
0.5179223418235779,
-0.5096173882484436,
0.44688719511032104,
-0.1806788444519043,
0.3686247169971466,
-0.12400924414396286,
-0.12297200411558151,
0.23451285064220428,
-1.0321526527404785,
0.16041624546051025,
0.1093483492732048,
0.7975098490715027,
0.25942376255989075,
-0.45118066668510437,
0.1615719199180603,
-0.7508438229560852,
0.404763787984848,
-0.36867108941078186,
0.4972606301307678,
0.5377682447433472,
0.4232598543167114,
-0.3955886662006378,
-0.8393910527229309,
-0.32299843430519104,
0.045811329036951065,
-0.0930967703461647,
0.36901339888572693,
-0.07130705565214157,
0.4600971043109894,
0.05138280615210533,
-0.12722265720367432,
-0.4130091965198517,
-0.15693610906600952,
-0.10534907132387161,
-0.370184987783432,
0.4569380283355713,
0.16555051505565643,
-0.3104885518550873,
-0.4386455714702606,
-0.2719031572341919,
0.08986487239599228,
-0.5595988631248474,
-0.05151446908712387,
0.6875895857810974,
0.5290559530258179,
0.14360569417476654,
0.29597634077072144,
-0.7534598708152771,
0.8732975721359253,
-0.0606260672211647,
-0.34954074025154114,
0.157710462808609,
-0.3056756854057312,
-0.37022289633750916,
-0.03944208472967148,
1.0684436559677124,
0.06581669300794601,
0.21572737395763397,
-0.28712213039398193,
0.2543576955795288,
-0.5339847803115845,
0.16330677270889282,
-0.6576463580131531,
-0.6015850305557251,
0.16785010695457458,
-0.29303890466690063,
-0.3261917531490326,
-0.07996675372123718,
-0.5290479063987732,
-0.2623623311519623,
-0.04017292335629463,
0.28420770168304443,
-0.6949988603591919,
-0.1785745471715927,
-0.13877561688423157,
0.08811526000499725,
-0.3843207359313965,
0.38081586360931396,
-0.777643620967865,
0.19368812441825867,
0.4404078423976898,
0.6859331130981445,
0.21211469173431396,
-0.1753644347190857,
-0.26269614696502686,
0.5295327305793762,
-0.3306104838848114,
0.5824571847915649,
-0.45323362946510315,
-0.3663874566555023,
-0.1574520319700241,
-0.6593388319015503,
0.08467435836791992,
-0.16861961781978607,
0.478840708732605,
-0.7988093495368958,
-0.3077784478664398,
-0.2223179191350937,
-0.763639509677887,
-0.4518735408782959,
0.39878007769584656,
-0.47498637437820435,
0.9935401082038879,
0.535280168056488,
-0.8917958736419678,
0.8117536902427673,
-0.1020926982164383,
-0.1318686306476593,
0.2573907971382141,
-0.4408126771450043,
-0.8068521022796631,
-0.2216111570596695,
0.2702283263206482,
0.5070001482963562,
0.10130465030670166,
-0.09300713986158371,
-0.8826839327812195,
-0.43045663833618164,
-0.11262831836938858,
-0.21629095077514648,
0.5766090750694275,
0.14014460146427155,
0.28596678376197815,
-0.33851194381713867,
-0.8238797783851624,
0.5283739566802979,
-0.21398305892944336,
-0.2391980141401291,
-0.06039310619235039,
-0.340472549200058,
-0.13372552394866943,
0.05887534096837044,
-0.08135876804590225,
-0.24372175335884094,
0.37584996223449707,
-0.22289203107357025,
0.054797835648059845,
0.45379194617271423,
0.5195242762565613,
0.6897023320198059,
-0.0884561687707901,
0.543540358543396,
0.2678070664405823,
0.3344475030899048,
0.48781511187553406,
-0.7287638187408447,
-0.16901375353336334,
-0.3346094787120819,
0.5302897095680237,
0.4498000741004944,
-0.587499737739563,
0.13328543305397034,
-0.27581122517585754,
-0.37677741050720215,
-0.16339661180973053,
0.504432201385498,
0.07727213203907013,
0.8656696677207947,
0.18716102838516235,
-0.12774713337421417,
-0.5417505502700806,
-0.5158937573432922,
0.14057765901088715,
-0.49104395508766174,
-0.15663009881973267,
0.6526319980621338,
0.464905321598053,
-0.06714161485433578,
1.0582842826843262,
-0.4977127015590668,
-0.8402291536331177,
0.001327548990957439,
0.24325616657733917,
0.27131497859954834,
0.2948729693889618,
0.5425537824630737,
-0.6716198921203613,
-0.6474568247795105,
-0.0733901634812355,
-0.8835569620132446,
0.516435444355011,
-0.019989704713225365,
-0.3407720625400543,
-0.15948554873466492,
0.26126331090927124,
-0.7915189266204834,
0.5816035866737366,
0.029438193887472153,
0.25707104802131653,
0.4311823546886444,
-0.05339641124010086,
-0.005194035358726978,
-0.7891596555709839,
-0.31996697187423706,
-0.2758648097515106,
-0.36953863501548767,
-0.27681535482406616,
-0.23102572560310364,
-0.05835690349340439,
0.009416207671165466,
-0.432539165019989,
-0.06169724464416504,
-0.4591291844844818,
-0.12252654135227203,
0.0866098627448082,
0.23920714855194092,
0.001528024673461914,
0.43720579147338867,
-0.20431172847747803,
0.21304595470428467,
0.794847309589386,
-0.6094973683357239,
0.5201652646064758,
0.3329432010650635,
-0.27533966302871704,
0.6099454164505005,
-0.3095478415489197,
0.2365603744983673,
-0.3804868459701538,
0.29717138409614563,
-0.8579666018486023,
-0.5077537894248962,
0.741829514503479,
-0.559710681438446,
0.5283986926078796,
-0.8506394028663635,
-0.4154248833656311,
-0.5128647685050964,
0.07032232731580734,
0.23687304556369781,
0.22639115154743195,
-0.10118059068918228,
0.5875309109687805,
-0.09675900638103485,
0.40174418687820435,
-0.9265770316123962,
-0.784770667552948,
-0.17074930667877197,
0.07486262917518616,
-0.7321153283119202,
0.3163508474826813,
0.31701600551605225,
0.20938444137573242,
0.47502103447914124,
-0.28224921226501465,
-0.26187166571617126,
0.010857177898287773,
0.420773983001709,
0.018824392929673195,
-0.14086008071899414,
0.41659092903137207,
-0.07623834908008575,
-0.10408627241849899,
-0.1420314460992813,
-0.8080260753631592,
0.08492698520421982,
0.05489527806639671,
-0.480265736579895,
-0.27418676018714905,
0.13668784499168396,
-0.15492424368858337,
0.4558710753917694,
0.6413076519966125,
1.029236912727356,
-0.5948128700256348,
-0.05847470834851265,
-0.168405219912529,
-0.19657845795154572,
-0.3710234761238098,
0.36788079142570496,
-0.5821289420127869,
-0.8417764902114868,
0.6467579007148743,
-0.11772036552429199,
-0.6232523918151855,
0.3239068388938904,
0.08571851998567581,
-0.5220231413841248,
0.6797705292701721,
0.40205147862434387,
-0.3156270980834961,
0.28274282813072205,
-0.6565987467765808,
0.14533013105392456,
-0.6034460663795471,
-0.19127923250198364,
-0.25028344988822937,
-0.3981105089187622,
-0.4229332208633423,
-0.3138720393180847,
0.5948727130889893,
0.8114389777183533,
-0.43993237614631653,
0.021945474669337273,
-0.3597264885902405,
0.5420916080474854,
0.7505267262458801,
0.4170913100242615,
0.38796818256378174,
0.23738546669483185,
-0.5323496460914612,
0.004561261739581823,
-0.86641925573349,
-0.01934376172721386,
1.3805979490280151,
-0.09685219079256058,
0.7943553328514099,
0.03765468671917915,
1.0939756631851196,
0.03185981884598732,
0.01811123639345169,
-0.7881632447242737,
0.10893311351537704,
0.23791445791721344,
-0.6360223293304443,
-0.5268134474754333,
-0.7743268013000488,
-0.6588647961616516,
0.045427676290273666,
-0.3759032189846039,
-1.260425090789795,
0.14176443219184875,
0.2623473107814789,
-0.7625870704650879,
0.3207399845123291,
-0.3820832073688507,
0.6460984945297241,
0.283246785402298,
-0.29838651418685913,
0.07613811641931534,
-0.8866609930992126,
0.4661882221698761,
0.26159733533859253,
-0.20049473643302917,
-0.15551577508449554,
0.12842945754528046,
0.36420440673828125,
-0.6201843619346619,
0.6747351288795471,
-0.3453555703163147,
0.5903412103652954,
0.8715614080429077,
0.11045518517494202,
0.9000583291053772,
0.6687938570976257,
-0.1621430665254593,
0.2211826890707016,
-0.3952975869178772,
-0.3299892544746399,
-0.7389124035835266,
0.37014028429985046,
-0.8472818732261658,
-0.2159537822008133,
-0.20552456378936768,
-0.637531042098999,
-0.4754209816455841,
0.4642227292060852,
0.7469518780708313,
-0.03536585718393326,
-0.11497492343187332,
-0.05162753909826279,
0.5008541941642761,
0.5363642573356628,
0.2927391827106476,
0.0042508188635110855,
-0.017063839361071587,
-0.7098780274391174,
0.6038944721221924,
0.46540215611457825,
0.16762717068195343,
0.2881377041339874,
-0.0891270786523819,
-0.3719426989555359,
-0.809786856174469,
-0.5639037489891052,
0.025504615157842636,
-0.7932600975036621,
-0.7165367007255554,
-0.8121155500411987,
-0.2678202688694,
-0.7293092608451843,
0.0742078423500061,
-0.2943776547908783,
-0.41053280234336853,
-0.6412999033927917,
-0.2624433636665344,
0.664542555809021,
0.5757201313972473,
-0.4355201721191406,
0.7761805057525635,
-0.6921549439430237,
0.3386489748954773,
0.6502596735954285,
0.5614199638366699,
-0.1356232911348343,
-0.2485833615064621,
-0.25125211477279663,
0.29387781023979187,
-0.35292401909828186,
-0.8102314472198486,
0.03369428589940071,
0.5045503377914429,
0.4029814600944519,
0.7578856348991394,
0.09342598170042038,
0.6950380206108093,
-0.08134563267230988,
0.3757421374320984,
0.22527635097503662,
-0.6118625402450562,
0.33234256505966187,
-0.560321569442749,
0.11059043556451797,
0.8844864368438721,
0.5672378540039062,
-0.25810712575912476,
-0.17375831305980682,
-0.8172398805618286,
-0.6017380356788635,
0.7560414671897888,
0.4784219264984131,
-0.22313781082630157,
0.21652518212795258,
0.6302259564399719,
-0.43081238865852356,
0.3237285614013672,
-0.2249879539012909,
-0.5110793709754944,
-0.22100654244422913,
-0.23517264425754547,
0.4673011302947998,
-0.14368192851543427,
-0.2110576033592224,
-0.05581023544073105,
0.7262903451919556,
-0.5329004526138306,
0.5089818239212036,
0.18632903695106506,
-0.1034892350435257,
-0.34445321559906006,
0.07631240785121918,
0.12005497515201569,
0.3029240071773529,
-0.644740104675293,
-0.050505805760622025,
0.266875684261322,
-0.57711261510849,
0.20934061706066132,
0.34472423791885376,
-0.5400479435920715,
0.009673870168626308,
0.31580233573913574,
0.5808088183403015,
0.018219226971268654,
0.25924190878868103,
0.44897812604904175,
0.1081668958067894,
-0.23110224306583405,
-0.24376443028450012,
0.011931175366044044,
0.3207477927207947,
0.2281455248594284,
0.42243024706840515,
0.4744233191013336,
0.4092261493206024,
-0.1120157390832901,
0.32158535718917847,
0.38103675842285156,
-0.7353429198265076,
0.049273379147052765,
0.6667921543121338,
-0.3180900812149048,
0.29932308197021484,
1.020108699798584,
-0.8907963037490845,
-0.5150156617164612,
0.6298955678939819,
0.33877795934677124,
0.3810485005378723,
0.2305838167667389,
0.4345927834510803,
0.4781176447868347,
0.19731150567531586,
0.027943123131990433,
0.4317958652973175,
-0.13721118867397308,
-1.0300800800323486,
-0.2668991982936859,
-0.40705204010009766,
-0.3309227228164673,
-0.22186307609081268,
-0.4148760437965393,
0.07243620604276657,
-0.6692642569541931,
-0.5122635960578918,
-0.2267538458108902,
0.1695239096879959,
-1.053485631942749,
0.2360827773809433,
0.12366978079080582,
0.4408999979496002,
-0.5497239828109741,
0.8226704597473145,
0.4128744602203369,
-0.6184796094894409,
-1.1045082807540894,
-0.36452269554138184,
0.2512747347354889,
-0.6285086274147034,
0.4891616702079773,
-0.14299696683883667,
0.08045569807291031,
-0.028914209455251694,
-0.5278539061546326,
-1.0492140054702759,
1.3093147277832031,
0.5239742994308472,
-0.35470378398895264,
-0.1018872857093811,
0.486892968416214,
0.29472818970680237,
-0.3754451870918274,
0.39969635009765625,
0.3321414589881897,
0.47448113560676575,
0.4622466266155243,
-0.35655003786087036,
-0.10450275242328644,
0.28981199860572815,
0.03714730218052864,
0.1983564794063568,
-0.792895495891571,
0.6122320294380188,
-0.5462530255317688,
-0.021150225773453712,
-0.04516780748963356,
0.9858607649803162,
0.1652173399925232,
0.18837623298168182,
0.3420531451702118,
0.9564308524131775,
1.2454508543014526,
-0.2287256121635437,
0.9051348567008972,
0.029835054650902748,
0.7130484580993652,
1.5257242918014526,
-0.14024344086647034,
0.4575817883014679,
0.19198420643806458,
-0.5400376915931702,
0.2713058292865753,
0.730430006980896,
0.1207575649023056,
0.5541968941688538,
0.22003266215324402,
-0.5665754079818726,
-0.6126155853271484,
-0.2601269781589508,
-0.39113205671310425,
0.40533027052879333,
0.4942522943019867,
-0.3387168347835541,
-0.38096633553504944,
-0.13423208892345428,
-0.14045654237270355,
-0.49614495038986206,
-0.20165282487869263,
0.6959207653999329,
0.2622511684894562,
0.004563615657389164,
0.23654161393642426,
-0.36151301860809326,
0.17167718708515167,
-0.5643256306648254,
0.07822959870100021,
-0.07796470075845718,
-0.1283002346754074,
-0.38238725066185,
-0.5671418905258179,
0.16350862383842468,
-0.7559407353401184,
-0.2675849199295044,
0.36490359902381897,
1.0072846412658691,
-0.5073592066764832,
-0.6041544675827026,
0.22265978157520294,
0.34153294563293457,
0.10854662209749222,
-0.44151780009269714,
-0.697413980960846,
-0.35602936148643494,
-0.21719947457313538,
-0.27483516931533813,
0.15691028535366058,
0.6404362320899963,
0.33235254883766174,
0.7411271929740906,
0.29692235589027405,
0.09611452370882034,
0.09310363233089447,
0.2910144627094269,
0.5832725167274475,
-0.18251541256904602,
-0.2626146972179413,
-0.5369095206260681,
0.3500135838985443,
-0.03617313504219055,
-0.3649657964706421,
0.35012030601501465,
0.3295493721961975,
0.7892864942550659,
0.0880640298128128,
0.7351181507110596,
-0.0663873553276062,
0.061793193221092224,
-0.4372989535331726,
1.023550033569336,
-0.08024390786886215,
-0.09372010082006454,
-0.45642170310020447,
-0.6919267177581787,
-0.5247780680656433,
0.5189386010169983,
0.02208518423140049,
0.29101529717445374,
0.5610239505767822,
0.7994941473007202,
-0.2538106441497803,
0.05729866027832031,
0.6107993125915527,
-0.027811070904135704,
-0.05806012451648712,
0.7511165142059326,
0.4398014545440674,
-0.9260817170143127,
1.1163709163665771,
-0.8715929985046387,
0.31749141216278076,
-0.11235448718070984,
-0.8798283338546753,
-0.5010910034179688,
-0.13972580432891846,
-0.5880300998687744,
-0.43799230456352234,
0.006059537176042795,
0.7264336347579956,
1.1344194412231445,
-0.6812711954116821,
0.4658803641796112,
-0.3064896762371063,
0.51462322473526,
-0.3369167745113373,
-0.23539219796657562,
0.4849103093147278,
-0.3115661144256592,
-0.37163543701171875,
0.18865810334682465,
0.20489130914211273,
0.2745926082134247,
0.11311419308185577,
-0.06179797276854515,
-0.2814100682735443,
-0.5078473091125488,
0.0943109393119812,
0.15577399730682373,
-0.29878735542297363,
-0.7178785800933838,
-0.17522893846035004,
-0.17963717877864838,
0.18101449310779572,
0.442293256521225,
-0.8434582948684692,
0.7742772102355957,
0.461365669965744,
0.5795263051986694,
0.7756232023239136,
-0.1479128897190094,
0.33247652649879456,
-1.2095404863357544,
0.2095271646976471,
0.3135586082935333,
0.4789947271347046,
0.23007355630397797,
-0.8995399475097656,
0.7282566428184509,
0.5143004059791565,
-0.49376264214515686,
-0.11920896172523499,
0.29246506094932556,
-0.9379439949989319,
0.15825535356998444,
0.8651594519615173,
-0.589123010635376,
-0.21247375011444092,
-0.2512606084346771,
0.2264256477355957,
0.5382149815559387,
-0.7355608940124512,
0.5004973411560059,
0.7698323130607605,
-0.33806389570236206,
-0.18697760999202728,
-0.2292392998933792,
0.5100120902061462,
0.18154671788215637,
-0.38865891098976135,
-0.4591807723045349,
0.5525268912315369,
0.2465539127588272,
0.12349586188793182,
0.8056644201278687,
0.1784089058637619,
0.384913831949234,
0.331385999917984,
-0.14769621193408966,
-0.2612296938896179,
-0.4013427793979645,
-0.011502380482852459,
0.4842129051685333,
0.15388710796833038,
-0.12358708679676056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04510v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04510v1
|
Where does In-context Translation Happen in Large Language Models
| 2024-03-07T14:12:41 | 2024-03-07T14:12:41 |
Suzanna Sia, David Mueller, Kevin Duh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Self-supervised large language models have demonstrated the ability to
perform Machine Translation (MT) via in-context learning, but little is known
about where the model performs the task with respect to prompt instructions and
demonstration examples. In this work, we attempt to characterize the region
where large language models transition from in-context learners to translation
models. Through a series of layer-wise context-masking experiments on
\textsc{GPTNeo2.7B}, \textsc{Bloom3B}, \textsc{Llama7b} and
\textsc{Llama7b-chat}, we demonstrate evidence of a "task recognition" point
where the translation task is encoded into the input representations and
attention to context is no longer necessary. We further observe correspondence
between the low performance when masking out entire layers, and the task
recognition layers. Taking advantage of this redundancy results in 45\%
computational savings when prompting with 5 examples, and task recognition
achieved at layer 14 / 32. Our layer-wise fine-tuning experiments indicate that
the most effective layers for MT fine-tuning are the layers critical to task
recognition.
|
[
-0.3992212116718292,
-0.7243872284889221,
0.7719013690948486,
0.28536590933799744,
-0.1185218095779419,
-0.19816100597381592,
-0.19505774974822998,
-0.4275677502155304,
-0.4178656041622162,
0.7005875110626221,
-0.6349267959594727,
-0.3128238320350647,
-0.6466513276100159,
0.03325086459517479,
-0.5201482176780701,
0.8334808349609375,
-0.4357519745826721,
-0.11626516282558441,
-0.23362880945205688,
0.08340507000684738,
-0.7559969425201416,
-0.7803027033805847,
-0.63581782579422,
-0.5320149064064026,
0.25647103786468506,
0.4992353022098541,
0.1747610718011856,
0.7561937570571899,
0.2738816738128662,
0.2679896354675293,
-0.05526963621377945,
0.11390560865402222,
-0.31306886672973633,
0.09277970343828201,
-0.21388846635818481,
-0.5735409259796143,
-0.334627240896225,
0.09085230529308319,
0.8048228025436401,
0.7094526886940002,
0.24546028673648834,
0.12661060690879822,
0.39321279525756836,
0.2962430715560913,
-0.5460245609283447,
0.06824082136154175,
-0.6042835116386414,
0.07290901243686676,
-0.27038145065307617,
-0.13637565076351166,
-0.594002366065979,
0.3067426383495331,
0.05976930260658264,
-0.16356807947158813,
0.19623468816280365,
-0.13786253333091736,
0.44646748900413513,
0.1420474648475647,
-0.7741594314575195,
-0.14374639093875885,
-0.7808886170387268,
0.770461916923523,
-0.6072781085968018,
0.17259491980075836,
0.5787948966026306,
0.3833117187023163,
-0.40534910559654236,
-0.5571283102035522,
-0.5079687833786011,
-0.04299091175198555,
-0.2882721722126007,
-0.011098038405179977,
-0.4471631646156311,
0.01797068491578102,
0.4393547475337982,
0.1666979044675827,
-0.19361557066440582,
0.22092865407466888,
-0.26354077458381653,
-0.14242832362651825,
0.1602756232023239,
0.12823301553726196,
0.10773792862892151,
-0.19040201604366302,
-0.3209628164768219,
-0.2286667823791504,
-0.7558165788650513,
0.1224672943353653,
-0.1899929940700531,
0.2600155472755432,
-0.24779674410820007,
0.3423944413661957,
-0.15994276106357574,
0.7474215030670166,
0.1297600269317627,
-0.09686936438083649,
0.258308470249176,
-0.28602340817451477,
-0.4950414001941681,
0.04507560655474663,
0.6582418084144592,
0.12285567820072174,
-0.017917092889547348,
-0.01802336610853672,
-0.5830850601196289,
-0.3085806369781494,
0.20506322383880615,
-0.8196375370025635,
-0.06753478199243546,
0.0044906106777489185,
-0.2634233832359314,
0.08266010135412216,
-0.22061371803283691,
0.022104009985923767,
-0.16012823581695557,
-0.25540485978126526,
0.4877232611179352,
-0.09187757223844528,
-0.08666858822107315,
-0.0366554819047451,
0.22287970781326294,
0.3367770314216614,
0.44269147515296936,
-0.7811627984046936,
0.32018592953681946,
0.571872889995575,
0.8750466704368591,
-0.28623831272125244,
-0.44165030121803284,
-0.7427290081977844,
0.3096499741077423,
-0.43125826120376587,
0.5578315258026123,
-0.2675776481628418,
-0.06465690582990646,
0.04012612998485565,
0.4213637113571167,
-0.43846645951271057,
-0.7000854015350342,
0.38865798711776733,
-0.5024636387825012,
0.24414502084255219,
-0.3910242021083832,
-0.410232812166214,
-0.4580881893634796,
0.24760106205940247,
-0.3405948877334595,
0.9473744630813599,
-0.07842274755239487,
-0.3811493515968323,
0.15041321516036987,
-0.753379762172699,
-0.6469703316688538,
-0.12323983758687973,
0.21098460257053375,
-0.13307511806488037,
0.40993747115135193,
0.23206627368927002,
0.8813490271568298,
-0.23108522593975067,
-0.036129679530858994,
-0.007088320329785347,
-0.4304670989513397,
0.6223629713058472,
-0.3820295035839081,
0.5235922932624817,
0.11867935955524445,
-0.6134728193283081,
0.19233383238315582,
-0.33269891142845154,
-0.1884695142507553,
0.14260075986385345,
-0.1525784730911255,
-0.39450889825820923,
-0.1032739207148552,
0.09529527276754379,
0.7109491229057312,
0.058523040264844894,
-0.41897276043891907,
0.2345195710659027,
-0.17175549268722534,
0.9550053477287292,
0.5122233629226685,
0.004408320877701044,
0.5784342885017395,
-0.0028794484678655863,
0.35401245951652527,
0.25189319252967834,
0.0160695668309927,
-0.15020161867141724,
-0.4827710688114166,
-0.7787381410598755,
-0.07725095003843307,
0.08152168244123459,
0.5104816555976868,
-0.6031568050384521,
0.28220033645629883,
-0.1502876728773117,
-0.23955203592777252,
-0.3096330165863037,
0.028179580345749855,
0.48588207364082336,
0.7461627125740051,
0.56329345703125,
-0.1523827165365219,
0.057279203087091446,
-1.1751563549041748,
0.052844177931547165,
0.18566356599330902,
-0.17733234167099,
0.25253012776374817,
0.7161256074905396,
-0.1995830237865448,
0.4480563700199127,
-0.18523354828357697,
-0.42903658747673035,
-0.4230788052082062,
-0.004113747738301754,
0.15905320644378662,
0.7753482460975647,
0.39382150769233704,
-0.7035199999809265,
-0.4568909704685211,
0.2530019283294678,
-0.5632452368736267,
-0.30725476145744324,
-0.2540138065814972,
-0.32846206426620483,
0.2621557414531708,
0.9665966033935547,
-0.4972427189350128,
0.2611320912837982,
0.7713016867637634,
-0.1056886613368988,
0.1355023831129074,
-0.4387475848197937,
0.25118282437324524,
-1.0505094528198242,
0.17321893572807312,
-0.2733192443847656,
-0.6188342571258545,
-0.8985791802406311,
0.04335711896419525,
0.5148133635520935,
0.12325165420770645,
-0.39047542214393616,
0.5506433844566345,
-0.6148122549057007,
-0.41179484128952026,
-0.577846109867096,
0.3307686150074005,
0.11212089657783508,
0.5619951486587524,
-0.052477069199085236,
0.8602145314216614,
0.46852901577949524,
-0.6113356351852417,
-0.12834997475147247,
0.09675909578800201,
-0.5255980491638184,
0.3747275471687317,
-0.6624823808670044,
0.4269315302371979,
0.29500892758369446,
0.4760427176952362,
-1.076884150505066,
-0.48582887649536133,
0.45596039295196533,
-0.09244401007890701,
0.42855599522590637,
-0.439764142036438,
-0.607621967792511,
-0.1755758821964264,
0.2213473916053772,
0.7887811660766602,
0.47781136631965637,
-0.4436066150665283,
0.2909684181213379,
0.3485882878303528,
0.18216250836849213,
-0.36668288707733154,
-1.0833520889282227,
0.19822801649570465,
-0.3034921884536743,
-0.3696063458919525,
0.448322057723999,
0.10256744921207428,
0.18064124882221222,
-0.3105165958404541,
-0.024666791781783104,
-0.10690347105264664,
0.3077026307582855,
0.2944711148738861,
-0.038804393261671066,
-0.14401093125343323,
-0.033323705196380615,
0.38361990451812744,
0.2605264186859131,
0.23541541397571564,
-0.34247928857803345,
0.6274494528770447,
0.06123010814189911,
-0.4187438488006592,
-0.4978007972240448,
0.31248024106025696,
0.6361103057861328,
-0.38604736328125,
0.8762336373329163,
0.40321052074432373,
-0.5588104724884033,
-0.21395812928676605,
-0.5347558259963989,
-0.12150346487760544,
-0.4154592454433441,
0.5967625379562378,
-0.6454862952232361,
-0.837492048740387,
0.8378663063049316,
0.13900916278362274,
-0.12704995274543762,
0.4931718707084656,
0.47220516204833984,
-0.28211233019828796,
1.0126758813858032,
0.27870601415634155,
0.1863890439271927,
0.7079982161521912,
-0.2949294149875641,
-0.012702081352472305,
-1.3190661668777466,
-0.026917871087789536,
-0.30816060304641724,
-0.5490344166755676,
-0.30488744378089905,
-0.6885372996330261,
0.5308682918548584,
0.3237115740776062,
-0.04962126910686493,
0.7034832239151001,
-0.31653106212615967,
0.6705794334411621,
0.49941641092300415,
0.13289213180541992,
0.19854235649108887,
-0.04230789467692375,
0.04228776693344116,
0.03729937598109245,
-0.7683114409446716,
-0.2818343937397003,
0.7240356206893921,
0.4027508497238159,
0.1317453682422638,
0.009302598424255848,
0.5951066017150879,
0.10931403934955597,
0.285521000623703,
-0.5167261362075806,
0.7046973705291748,
-0.2706654369831085,
-0.554215669631958,
-0.20486581325531006,
-0.38328105211257935,
-0.9864557385444641,
0.3668498694896698,
-0.03826846927404404,
-0.524280846118927,
0.18930338323116302,
0.2753107249736786,
-0.0271589495241642,
0.2384130209684372,
-0.8187310695648193,
1.3791481256484985,
-0.01583634316921234,
-0.21570539474487305,
-0.2942577004432678,
-0.6700817942619324,
0.26641714572906494,
-0.05690505728125572,
0.22867777943611145,
0.037988483905792236,
0.24664226174354553,
0.35153836011886597,
0.11438119411468506,
0.9342392683029175,
-0.22398413717746735,
-0.3901166617870331,
-0.03942789137363434,
0.48289549350738525,
0.5944382548332214,
-0.43211087584495544,
0.30202651023864746,
0.14452289044857025,
-0.23686781525611877,
-0.36474257707595825,
-0.5280532240867615,
0.7351658344268799,
-0.5485773086547852,
-0.6683987975120544,
-0.2001515030860901,
-0.6811574697494507,
-0.11829877644777298,
0.10623064637184143,
0.26563623547554016,
0.5768418312072754,
0.08983513712882996,
0.3001861572265625,
0.6210132241249084,
-0.2836454510688782,
0.34863629937171936,
0.26910409331321716,
-0.1496179848909378,
0.09589654952287674,
0.7879723906517029,
0.1688476949930191,
0.6642948985099792,
0.5742170810699463,
0.09995617717504501,
-0.24380797147750854,
-0.8115055561065674,
-0.7763704657554626,
0.24030691385269165,
-1.0394352674484253,
-0.1465226411819458,
-0.5925527811050415,
-0.304062157869339,
-0.25879305601119995,
-0.18376119434833527,
-0.2808777689933777,
-0.24067984521389008,
-0.2650492787361145,
0.035845860838890076,
-0.24739015102386475,
0.8398188352584839,
0.21919703483581543,
0.40592196583747864,
-0.7343325614929199,
-0.21218712627887726,
0.3203112781047821,
-0.08307800441980362,
-0.007010614965111017,
-1.0741562843322754,
-0.5733936429023743,
0.018465325236320496,
-0.2675621807575226,
-0.7457234263420105,
0.3368195593357086,
0.22405244410037994,
0.40869462490081787,
0.051794640719890594,
-0.1218583881855011,
0.7540562748908997,
-0.4879559278488159,
0.7189099788665771,
-0.14718499779701233,
-1.1865208148956299,
0.5056719183921814,
-0.47579604387283325,
0.7590765357017517,
0.20637834072113037,
0.04028345271945,
-0.7418550252914429,
-0.44412440061569214,
-0.11976339668035507,
-0.7171879410743713,
0.8766547441482544,
0.21978510916233063,
0.306302934885025,
-0.010234055109322071,
0.41053250432014465,
-0.04856555163860321,
0.217137411236763,
-0.9014816284179688,
0.0864972323179245,
0.019221141934394836,
0.1346738487482071,
-0.18600361049175262,
-0.15586097538471222,
-0.2858602702617645,
-0.03986044600605965,
0.22689737379550934,
-0.26760372519493103,
0.29154172539711,
0.17084670066833496,
-0.5238767266273499,
-0.10079902410507202,
0.2761048674583435,
1.0282186269760132,
0.6929550170898438,
0.032886043190956116,
0.37870022654533386,
0.27476948499679565,
-0.05918664112687111,
-0.05807310715317726,
-0.12251362204551697,
-0.2533947825431824,
-0.4291207492351532,
0.5349808931350708,
1.1240477561950684,
0.5512655377388,
-0.24181991815567017,
0.6090595126152039,
0.20825594663619995,
-0.09923084825277328,
-0.21168582141399384,
0.17496871948242188,
-0.12598343193531036,
0.5468695759773254,
0.308796226978302,
0.1044909805059433,
0.28676673769950867,
-0.6145381331443787,
-0.30424803495407104,
0.4234278202056885,
-0.2268020361661911,
-0.4062783420085907,
0.7470324635505676,
0.00230603595264256,
-0.026934506371617317,
0.5942984819412231,
-0.1294182687997818,
-0.6163554787635803,
0.3772326707839966,
0.862695574760437,
0.9871264100074768,
-0.12005019187927246,
0.05413849279284477,
0.336736261844635,
0.23873697221279144,
-0.193583145737648,
-0.3633299469947815,
-0.27281099557876587,
-0.5522339940071106,
-0.6627523899078369,
-0.37653079628944397,
-0.2685805857181549,
0.06047291308641434,
-0.5000613331794739,
-0.012202960439026356,
0.010088280774652958,
0.04622083902359009,
-0.2546379566192627,
-0.5089731812477112,
-0.6239510178565979,
0.09480182826519012,
0.40527546405792236,
0.6215389966964722,
-0.8098017573356628,
1.1241048574447632,
0.7587729692459106,
0.07215142995119095,
-0.37009042501449585,
0.15073224902153015,
-0.20497889816761017,
-0.6510884165763855,
0.859757125377655,
0.4031400680541992,
-0.3425459563732147,
0.0013428550446406007,
-0.5987100601196289,
-0.7226835489273071,
1.1088757514953613,
0.5748193264007568,
-0.24662941694259644,
-0.08764209598302841,
0.2534118890762329,
0.4965841472148895,
-0.5416584610939026,
0.037014588713645935,
0.4064300060272217,
0.2283320426940918,
-0.06757684797048569,
-1.194551944732666,
0.19419622421264648,
-0.043679844588041306,
0.21602706611156464,
0.19726361334323883,
-0.49202659726142883,
1.007452130317688,
0.15828409790992737,
-0.3031021058559418,
-0.14689220488071442,
0.5208837985992432,
-0.005234269425272942,
0.1222391426563263,
0.5711254477500916,
0.13110703229904175,
0.37241730093955994,
-0.18850970268249512,
1.1455588340759277,
-0.12255021184682846,
0.10957970470190048,
0.9946848154067993,
0.0011349166743457317,
1.0555181503295898,
0.49038612842559814,
0.06921505928039551,
0.4738953709602356,
0.5850397348403931,
0.2895854115486145,
0.5265327095985413,
0.040546875447034836,
-0.07550574839115143,
-0.4977257251739502,
-0.11721761524677277,
-0.22831319272518158,
0.3733021318912506,
0.41450145840644836,
-0.3494291305541992,
0.1526893526315689,
0.30892738699913025,
-0.010767245665192604,
-0.24485355615615845,
-0.42491739988327026,
0.6988918781280518,
0.13602881133556366,
-0.9190121293067932,
0.8462101221084595,
0.06443530321121216,
0.2567409574985504,
-0.6775722503662109,
-0.014306522905826569,
-0.4248499870300293,
0.275722473859787,
-0.02617434412240982,
-0.9666608572006226,
0.2425646036863327,
-0.2735256850719452,
-0.38839656114578247,
-0.631258487701416,
0.5418094992637634,
-0.7069486975669861,
-0.06980634480714798,
0.46779653429985046,
0.34857726097106934,
0.3441087603569031,
-0.4525424540042877,
-0.34770849347114563,
0.025828268378973007,
-0.17069025337696075,
-0.3514215350151062,
0.8459562063217163,
0.7558465003967285,
-0.30308833718299866,
0.5458665490150452,
0.4298650920391083,
-0.12592768669128418,
0.2397281378507614,
-0.0001693382509984076,
0.7425273060798645,
-0.41862693428993225,
-0.491472065448761,
-0.6383625268936157,
0.4354083836078644,
-0.008943828754127026,
-0.25909507274627686,
0.7612335085868835,
0.25160399079322815,
1.1158671379089355,
-0.3415135443210602,
0.2894028127193451,
0.0748087614774704,
0.07711982727050781,
-0.7413315773010254,
0.5854650139808655,
-0.8148199319839478,
0.08685746043920517,
-0.36594337224960327,
-1.1434800624847412,
-0.4150311350822449,
0.6186580061912537,
-0.4595131576061249,
-0.10928232222795486,
0.6646823287010193,
0.6093044281005859,
-0.4197665750980377,
-0.5207594633102417,
0.5884217619895935,
0.42543041706085205,
0.31852883100509644,
0.761063277721405,
0.5810343623161316,
-0.5397323369979858,
0.45305073261260986,
-0.26587164402008057,
-0.1510467529296875,
-0.2582036852836609,
-0.8059605360031128,
-0.9703909754753113,
-0.9059981107711792,
-0.2822329103946686,
-0.30536773800849915,
-0.1862247735261917,
0.9096663594245911,
0.7812397480010986,
-0.9623501896858215,
-0.5242416262626648,
-0.08655644953250885,
-0.16698405146598816,
-0.36613741517066956,
-0.1712075024843216,
0.32071128487586975,
-0.27831101417541504,
-0.791928768157959,
0.7882715463638306,
0.20956727862358093,
0.1619199961423874,
-0.27062347531318665,
0.10807494074106216,
0.04318947345018387,
-0.2713976800441742,
0.7059234380722046,
0.22627879679203033,
-0.7932668328285217,
-0.35892850160598755,
0.14850634336471558,
-0.3424241840839386,
0.04791872203350067,
0.7954993844032288,
-0.4233069121837616,
0.33554449677467346,
0.38488200306892395,
0.7771106958389282,
0.7502917647361755,
-0.21013985574245453,
0.6313068866729736,
-0.9659415483474731,
0.11727923154830933,
-0.10696091502904892,
0.39856693148612976,
0.435312420129776,
-0.12974078953266144,
0.3453233242034912,
0.153368279337883,
-0.8403885364532471,
-0.8815084099769592,
0.21453210711479187,
-1.0122050046920776,
-0.05281180515885353,
1.159680724143982,
-0.2204449325799942,
-0.2313862293958664,
-0.015277246944606304,
-0.240262970328331,
0.12215603142976761,
-0.09285079687833786,
0.704326868057251,
0.8501753211021423,
-0.07527168095111847,
-0.37458959221839905,
-1.0076240301132202,
0.4568261206150055,
0.44037574529647827,
-0.6487768888473511,
0.37442463636398315,
0.4781447947025299,
0.19292710721492767,
0.051086027175188065,
0.47602835297584534,
0.12887175381183624,
0.1749056726694107,
-0.5709766745567322,
-0.14196425676345825,
-0.005751157645136118,
-0.3780691921710968,
-0.39543288946151733,
0.01701294630765915,
0.04597233980894089,
-0.26500198245048523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04507v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04507v2
|
NLPre: a revised approach towards language-centric benchmarking of Natural Language Preprocessing systems
| 2024-03-07T14:07:00 | 2024-03-27T14:50:56 |
Martyna Wiącek, Piotr Rybak, Łukasz Pszenny, Alina Wróblewska
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the advancements of transformer-based architectures, we observe the rise
of natural language preprocessing (NLPre) tools capable of solving preliminary
NLP tasks (e.g. tokenisation, part-of-speech tagging, dependency parsing, or
morphological analysis) without any external linguistic guidance. It is arduous
to compare novel solutions to well-entrenched preprocessing toolkits, relying
on rule-based morphological analysers or dictionaries. Aware of the
shortcomings of existing NLPre evaluation approaches, we investigate a novel
method of reliable and fair evaluation and performance reporting. Inspired by
the GLUE benchmark, the proposed language-centric benchmarking system enables
comprehensive ongoing evaluation of multiple NLPre tools, while credibly
tracking their performance. The prototype application is configured for Polish
and integrated with the thoroughly assembled NLPre-PL benchmark. Based on this
benchmark, we conduct an extensive evaluation of a variety of Polish NLPre
systems. To facilitate the construction of benchmarking environments for other
languages, e.g. NLPre-GA for Irish or NLPre-ZH for Chinese, we ensure full
customization of the publicly released source code of the benchmarking system.
The links to all the resources (deployed platforms, source code, trained
models, datasets etc.) can be found on the project website:
https://sites.google.com/view/nlpre-benchmark.
|
[
-0.5509403944015503,
-0.5232721567153931,
0.22689390182495117,
0.7904859185218811,
-0.14588816463947296,
0.1084711030125618,
-0.6495137810707092,
-0.46946394443511963,
0.25424838066101074,
0.4347423017024994,
-0.6068664193153381,
-0.5341664552688599,
-0.3325578570365906,
0.6448686718940735,
-0.28502851724624634,
0.7402604818344116,
0.1995307356119156,
0.0680166706442833,
-0.5773342251777649,
-0.26028549671173096,
-0.22698181867599487,
-0.5779249668121338,
-0.3433939218521118,
-0.1563083678483963,
0.07076484709978104,
0.17587728798389435,
0.3160724341869354,
0.5815345048904419,
0.5180191993713379,
0.3158470094203949,
-0.0641750693321228,
0.0013868918176740408,
0.015705201774835587,
0.061403851956129074,
-0.36645975708961487,
-0.3689669072628021,
-0.7128267884254456,
-0.009078900329768658,
0.45014721155166626,
0.6314952969551086,
-0.33346617221832275,
0.31602784991264343,
0.22066663205623627,
0.5981479287147522,
-0.9102766513824463,
0.015982432290911674,
-0.661020040512085,
0.17923465371131897,
-0.39918088912963867,
-0.21827533841133118,
-0.5478318929672241,
-0.4279172420501709,
-0.023791994899511337,
-0.5754469037055969,
0.2086811065673828,
-0.23246951401233673,
0.4592493176460266,
0.2798393964767456,
0.23752780258655548,
-0.35931089520454407,
-0.4494049847126007,
0.909230649471283,
-1.0090843439102173,
0.4921226501464844,
-0.09025047719478607,
0.3983861804008484,
-0.07042472809553146,
-0.902756929397583,
-0.34789592027664185,
-0.11900638788938522,
-0.048579804599285126,
0.15888048708438873,
-0.22977229952812195,
-0.34557703137397766,
0.005972019396722317,
0.2991579473018646,
-0.7569708228111267,
0.04298218712210655,
0.0008900085231289268,
-0.3512798249721527,
0.4453100860118866,
-0.0782713070511818,
0.2351970672607422,
-0.06172243133187294,
-0.5661154389381409,
-0.24740678071975708,
-0.47146084904670715,
-0.20738019049167633,
0.3184375464916229,
0.721461832523346,
-0.013168574310839176,
0.29173994064331055,
-0.28832024335861206,
0.8169466853141785,
-0.11251674592494965,
-0.27139610052108765,
0.7464298605918884,
-0.26411014795303345,
-0.10184291005134583,
0.2601405084133148,
1.0227447748184204,
0.41165971755981445,
0.5317664742469788,
-0.3641916811466217,
-0.19267982244491577,
0.369012713432312,
0.3573854863643646,
-0.70041424036026,
-0.11391405016183853,
-0.12786553800106049,
0.03691868484020233,
-0.22966696321964264,
0.02607850916683674,
-0.9512348771095276,
0.08873157203197479,
-0.1930750012397766,
0.2708497643470764,
-0.30718162655830383,
-0.1769130975008011,
0.11561451852321625,
-0.08763012290000916,
0.0862540453672409,
-0.04368513077497482,
-0.6529005169868469,
0.9869972467422485,
1.013972520828247,
0.7100390791893005,
-0.3096647262573242,
-0.2770872414112091,
-0.6975429058074951,
-0.040221892297267914,
-0.2882893681526184,
1.0086699724197388,
-0.396816611289978,
-0.06603929400444031,
-0.06175373122096062,
0.015284835360944271,
-0.0895073190331459,
-0.860495388507843,
0.7920128107070923,
-0.283258318901062,
0.3590792119503021,
0.04464469105005264,
-0.5281770825386047,
0.21947379410266876,
0.4610137343406677,
-0.7093008160591125,
1.3417385816574097,
-0.10721378028392792,
-0.7209663987159729,
0.3864138126373291,
-0.46704182028770447,
-0.42251890897750854,
0.24111947417259216,
0.013784904032945633,
-0.07860194891691208,
-0.11451265960931778,
0.3532210886478424,
0.07667805254459381,
-0.3758827745914459,
0.41690805554389954,
-0.1489415317773819,
-0.39814627170562744,
-0.29904893040657043,
-0.3624001741409302,
0.7775648236274719,
-0.09304523468017578,
-0.35812485218048096,
0.11556600779294968,
-0.9546060562133789,
0.2755906581878662,
0.04023337736725807,
-0.14921683073043823,
-0.3357204794883728,
-0.05825906991958618,
0.028746765106916428,
0.22594106197357178,
0.6622703671455383,
-0.7750611305236816,
0.04798182100057602,
-0.5008827447891235,
0.15593761205673218,
0.47170230746269226,
-0.31123918294906616,
0.2988583743572235,
0.23111197352409363,
0.3845977187156677,
-0.4010758697986603,
0.5132303833961487,
0.048281893134117126,
-0.5249757170677185,
-0.7036603093147278,
0.0646030530333519,
0.477440744638443,
0.6975706219673157,
-0.5879687666893005,
0.4845983386039734,
-0.2593892812728882,
-0.5678589344024658,
-0.5947605967521667,
0.30595457553863525,
0.558471143245697,
0.7159133553504944,
0.4442678987979889,
-0.3806613087654114,
-0.8312606811523438,
-0.9837859272956848,
-0.5159701108932495,
-0.21572841703891754,
-0.14546887576580048,
-0.07363533973693848,
0.15747718513011932,
0.00031706973095424473,
0.9658986926078796,
-0.18042193353176117,
-0.277595579624176,
-0.3542647063732147,
0.11222109943628311,
0.5635933876037598,
0.3551669716835022,
0.48375335335731506,
-0.6929707527160645,
-0.5731347799301147,
0.06407490372657776,
-0.4689781963825226,
-0.571488082408905,
0.37774017453193665,
0.10008596628904343,
0.379484623670578,
0.7823531031608582,
-0.12034495174884796,
0.16444131731987,
0.8670055866241455,
-0.09628355503082275,
0.8738009333610535,
-0.1960824579000473,
-0.3836371898651123,
-0.5878570079803467,
0.4365396797657013,
-0.11579588055610657,
-0.33175987005233765,
-0.5168797373771667,
0.10122664272785187,
0.10288135707378387,
0.16912469267845154,
-0.6148168444633484,
0.5798883438110352,
0.015193096362054348,
-0.12360358983278275,
-0.24223566055297852,
0.3208238184452057,
0.324032723903656,
0.42425817251205444,
0.1152392029762268,
0.8968523740768433,
0.2149687111377716,
-0.469938188791275,
0.08619377017021179,
0.13201145827770233,
-0.35367125272750854,
0.43172910809516907,
-0.8317241072654724,
0.17806513607501984,
0.26795774698257446,
0.028710953891277313,
-0.4784015417098999,
0.2655965983867645,
0.11798033863306046,
-0.3843800723552704,
-0.015011753886938095,
-0.4033559262752533,
-0.7800147533416748,
-0.11190737783908844,
-0.3548368811607361,
0.10901188850402832,
0.31874406337738037,
-0.4357934296131134,
0.44870033860206604,
0.3622273802757263,
-0.26790937781333923,
-0.6793293356895447,
-0.5702612400054932,
0.1516961008310318,
-0.09211467951536179,
-0.43238452076911926,
0.5639219880104065,
-0.14305242896080017,
-0.30151259899139404,
0.10821498185396194,
-0.21318750083446503,
-0.21525053679943085,
0.06340909004211426,
-0.05341075360774994,
0.2182876467704773,
-0.3688015341758728,
-0.07176540791988373,
-0.32010307908058167,
-0.5325215458869934,
0.23676329851150513,
-0.09045755863189697,
0.673958957195282,
-0.5270518064498901,
-0.12798267602920532,
-0.0005059840041212738,
0.07699126750230789,
0.24491313099861145,
-0.34124383330345154,
0.5676150918006897,
0.6497073173522949,
-0.1750165820121765,
-0.3578323721885681,
-0.6013582348823547,
0.03955763950943947,
-0.48525092005729675,
-0.0896991416811943,
-0.10691817104816437,
-0.6120741963386536,
0.2979258596897125,
-0.21384841203689575,
0.09585028141736984,
0.5246565937995911,
0.38743171095848083,
0.21035535633563995,
0.6425769329071045,
0.8203645944595337,
-0.026781542226672173,
0.08976874500513077,
0.2310827672481537,
0.1713242381811142,
-0.8211548328399658,
-0.17819125950336456,
-0.5605655908584595,
-0.003362620249390602,
-0.699307382106781,
-0.31879428029060364,
0.18646149337291718,
0.19681045413017273,
0.012482745572924614,
0.9079833626747131,
-0.41963666677474976,
0.4192192852497101,
0.3749735951423645,
-0.5649253129959106,
0.5119814276695251,
-0.3335477113723755,
-0.48674720525741577,
-0.2816334366798401,
-0.8828644752502441,
-0.7404714822769165,
0.83474200963974,
-0.007466715760529041,
0.12617258727550507,
-0.23068059980869293,
0.7190923690795898,
0.0778360664844513,
0.4787016808986664,
-0.5454827547073364,
0.674686074256897,
-0.4092436134815216,
-0.4403747320175171,
-0.1635759472846985,
-0.4064066410064697,
-0.5773433446884155,
0.317654013633728,
-0.15588797628879547,
-0.6894572973251343,
0.22347725927829742,
0.053867969661951065,
-0.032872650772333145,
0.3018570840358734,
-0.5777515172958374,
1.1252622604370117,
-0.13536058366298676,
-0.43412989377975464,
0.18667390942573547,
-0.4726143479347229,
-0.012529200874269009,
-0.03882397711277008,
0.41694772243499756,
-0.3366270065307617,
-0.09118741750717163,
0.8947501182556152,
-0.5522900819778442,
0.49030637741088867,
-0.19547522068023682,
-0.19804653525352478,
0.12629298865795135,
0.08274552971124649,
0.2464933693408966,
0.007010715082287788,
-0.5253386497497559,
0.18262377381324768,
0.029241731390357018,
-0.05919475853443146,
-0.6519043445587158,
0.6580035090446472,
-0.08595822006464005,
-0.18851037323474884,
-0.2789987027645111,
-0.17196592688560486,
-0.4141596555709839,
0.3768830895423889,
0.23794971406459808,
0.3456755578517914,
-0.5382979512214661,
0.047762900590896606,
0.2592875063419342,
-0.30048704147338867,
0.5328599810600281,
0.6479034423828125,
-0.25664204359054565,
-0.3787347972393036,
0.8691310286521912,
-0.12947365641593933,
0.07804259657859802,
0.4764025807380676,
0.2587534189224243,
-0.19787420332431793,
-0.3770141005516052,
-0.15152348577976227,
0.14685818552970886,
-0.4846192002296448,
-0.2839849591255188,
-0.3713504672050476,
-0.03392715007066727,
-0.2602778375148773,
-0.058013156056404114,
-1.0168434381484985,
-0.26362207531929016,
0.32353878021240234,
0.2000458687543869,
0.22481124103069305,
0.5224561095237732,
-0.11993975192308426,
0.013735400512814522,
-0.49048876762390137,
0.2280518114566803,
0.16682599484920502,
0.8429859280586243,
-0.13135546445846558,
0.033334389328956604,
-0.1416105479001999,
-0.218838170170784,
-0.054768986999988556,
-0.3672610819339752,
0.43322113156318665,
0.18121010065078735,
0.462946355342865,
0.06841617822647095,
0.24389438331127167,
0.5913791656494141,
-0.8088850378990173,
0.43620529770851135,
-0.11232918500900269,
-1.065105676651001,
0.6924636363983154,
-0.043156933039426804,
0.3315752446651459,
1.1146955490112305,
0.03788786381483078,
-0.43109598755836487,
-0.40108823776245117,
-0.6729279160499573,
-1.172580599784851,
0.33498015999794006,
0.1639649122953415,
-0.2692689597606659,
-0.2913672924041748,
-0.1505795419216156,
0.20545418560504913,
0.23780596256256104,
-0.4812791049480438,
-0.12375947833061218,
-0.1099364161491394,
0.1745089441537857,
-0.16403356194496155,
0.023886803537607193,
0.08602893352508545,
-0.17848314344882965,
0.6247403025627136,
-0.19323019683361053,
-0.1727338582277298,
0.22070588171482086,
-0.2900502681732178,
0.28229424357414246,
0.41818350553512573,
0.2777584493160248,
0.6412762403488159,
-0.6201299428939819,
-0.08799608051776886,
0.22637732326984406,
-0.44202882051467896,
-0.1909235715866089,
-0.10120390355587006,
0.00808887742459774,
0.4849383533000946,
0.616801381111145,
0.3985231816768646,
0.5965381860733032,
-0.9935444593429565,
0.6369009613990784,
-0.222222700715065,
-0.21490857005119324,
-0.43519312143325806,
-0.08621194958686829,
0.18090775609016418,
-0.12429362535476685,
0.26985034346580505,
0.07911048084497452,
0.2286309450864792,
-0.4795129597187042,
0.4588863253593445,
0.12161468714475632,
-0.5049518942832947,
-0.4716005325317383,
0.3713333308696747,
0.10967861115932465,
-0.5235721468925476,
0.488253116607666,
-0.13534343242645264,
-0.4839678108692169,
0.4327869117259979,
0.6284956336021423,
0.7561630606651306,
-0.19065940380096436,
0.2508874237537384,
0.46484673023223877,
0.4372643530368805,
-0.009173596277832985,
0.22158977389335632,
-0.06130196526646614,
-0.6021257042884827,
-0.8488343954086304,
-0.7602359056472778,
-0.6831196546554565,
0.08425942808389664,
-1.089221477508545,
0.20575904846191406,
-0.5004677176475525,
-0.1267598420381546,
-0.10988201946020126,
-0.03026808239519596,
-0.6599304676055908,
0.24956178665161133,
0.18863321840763092,
1.424670696258545,
-0.8285320997238159,
0.6171619296073914,
0.6250220537185669,
0.29478201270103455,
-0.24428410828113556,
0.01231512613594532,
-0.08907576650381088,
-0.49862557649612427,
0.34533804655075073,
0.2469703108072281,
-0.20651277899742126,
-0.4714871644973755,
-0.04248350113630295,
-0.6398350596427917,
0.5856756567955017,
0.61626136302948,
-0.5900406241416931,
0.25605645775794983,
0.2665822505950928,
0.8999437689781189,
-0.1644793599843979,
0.10639432072639465,
0.731416642665863,
0.6640376448631287,
-0.4319554269313812,
-1.1411552429199219,
-0.11131935566663742,
-0.7849844098091125,
-0.24865655601024628,
0.2911914885044098,
-0.25273603200912476,
0.6345495581626892,
0.32212764024734497,
-0.37512701749801636,
0.019279316067695618,
0.29093679785728455,
0.3885456919670105,
0.08927133679389954,
0.6395471692085266,
0.7221442461013794,
0.3673907220363617,
-0.19280576705932617,
1.095329761505127,
-0.5034916996955872,
0.17869238555431366,
1.4284565448760986,
-0.47336897253990173,
1.2352545261383057,
0.7614285945892334,
-0.3007696568965912,
0.6237695813179016,
-0.2246265709400177,
0.038988400250673294,
0.5247809290885925,
0.11366108804941177,
-0.06947033852338791,
-0.18174393475055695,
-0.3303433060646057,
-0.27181705832481384,
0.45307302474975586,
0.23925170302391052,
0.2073967158794403,
-0.6891007423400879,
-0.2920439541339874,
-0.2722581923007965,
0.351824551820755,
0.18117672204971313,
0.8433953523635864,
0.030667567625641823,
-0.5201201438903809,
0.5808695554733276,
-0.0839507058262825,
0.8427656888961792,
-0.8566845059394836,
0.0566435344517231,
-0.06633909046649933,
0.2622246742248535,
-0.17098405957221985,
-0.7105862498283386,
0.6695355176925659,
0.3306059241294861,
-0.02495228499174118,
-0.3691965639591217,
0.4719253182411194,
-0.042194776237010956,
-0.4853629469871521,
0.7850790619850159,
0.6363222002983093,
-0.03808647394180298,
-0.06444158405065536,
-0.5675798058509827,
0.3378136456012726,
-0.27102935314178467,
-0.13395610451698303,
0.4004725217819214,
0.3347621560096741,
-0.11991428583860397,
0.6137956380844116,
0.6434844136238098,
0.1448003202676773,
-0.03694264963269234,
0.39519622921943665,
0.721801221370697,
-0.3867267668247223,
-0.4722396433353424,
-0.886823296546936,
0.3898853063583374,
-0.15492549538612366,
-0.42698749899864197,
0.9730884432792664,
0.7621845006942749,
1.0133711099624634,
0.07443892955780029,
0.45874541997909546,
-0.07324760407209396,
0.698745608329773,
-0.2922212481498718,
0.3782332241535187,
-0.3545692265033722,
0.288168728351593,
-0.7032889723777771,
-1.2782988548278809,
-0.426225483417511,
0.40916937589645386,
-0.2061614692211151,
-0.3416321873664856,
0.5137771368026733,
0.5199390649795532,
-0.08020845800638199,
0.05845660716295242,
0.0585394911468029,
-0.05571799352765083,
0.12540772557258606,
0.30870458483695984,
0.4020193815231323,
-0.4479893743991852,
0.4728882610797882,
-0.7135913372039795,
-0.13310539722442627,
-0.02492971159517765,
-1.327896237373352,
-0.473393976688385,
-0.37660735845565796,
-0.2543482780456543,
0.22347642481327057,
0.18558698892593384,
0.5255330204963684,
0.5313292145729065,
-0.9379845261573792,
-0.42945319414138794,
-0.1448654979467392,
-0.08518105745315552,
-0.409690260887146,
-0.2929207682609558,
0.2462591677904129,
-0.49839022755622864,
-0.5378539562225342,
0.8947430849075317,
0.47089242935180664,
-0.3923686444759369,
-0.04418671131134033,
0.04761812835931778,
-0.17755939066410065,
-0.22119858860969543,
0.5636444687843323,
0.352615088224411,
-0.4015146791934967,
0.29161500930786133,
0.01626691222190857,
0.17699648439884186,
0.3202686607837677,
0.7090578079223633,
-1.1788158416748047,
0.3460538685321808,
0.4105491042137146,
0.38942059874534607,
0.2218402475118637,
-0.1537298560142517,
0.8268483877182007,
-1.0841747522354126,
0.3752140402793884,
0.4651966989040375,
0.2961142659187317,
0.5146212577819824,
0.168075829744339,
0.7629410624504089,
-0.12910136580467224,
-0.04998039826750755,
-1.01680588722229,
-0.1003202348947525,
-0.9430129528045654,
-0.13403452932834625,
0.4838344156742096,
-0.1504199355840683,
-0.31047379970550537,
-0.027273070067167282,
0.24848595261573792,
0.09722132980823517,
-0.1252555400133133,
0.39203664660453796,
0.5193491578102112,
0.10536462068557739,
0.16764557361602783,
-0.6693049669265747,
0.40742227435112,
0.37559640407562256,
-0.743137538433075,
0.214885413646698,
-0.27370715141296387,
0.35649964213371277,
0.5416606664657593,
0.438897043466568,
-0.49563196301460266,
0.17334052920341492,
-0.13762523233890533,
0.2186211198568344,
-0.02392844669520855,
-0.4325442910194397,
-0.20683899521827698,
0.2083120346069336,
-0.20860056579113007,
0.19479675590991974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04819v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04819v1
|
Automating the Information Extraction from Semi-Structured Interview Transcripts
| 2024-03-07T13:53:03 | 2024-03-07T13:53:03 |
Angelina Parfenova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.IR, cs.SI
|
This paper explores the development and application of an automated system
designed to extract information from semi-structured interview transcripts.
Given the labor-intensive nature of traditional qualitative analysis methods,
such as coding, there exists a significant demand for tools that can facilitate
the analysis process. Our research investigates various topic modeling
techniques and concludes that the best model for analyzing interview texts is a
combination of BERT embeddings and HDBSCAN clustering. We present a
user-friendly software prototype that enables researchers, including those
without programming skills, to efficiently process and visualize the thematic
structure of interview data. This tool not only facilitates the initial stages
of qualitative analysis but also offers insights into the interconnectedness of
topics revealed, thereby enhancing the depth of qualitative analysis.
|
[
-0.34676042199134827,
-1.2649030685424805,
0.6485660076141357,
0.14170163869857788,
-0.17477427423000336,
0.5135722756385803,
0.06413304805755615,
-0.27945736050605774,
0.3037271201610565,
0.268144428730011,
-0.5381494164466858,
-0.7587350010871887,
-0.36431077122688293,
-0.10338904708623886,
-0.984158456325531,
0.9476675987243652,
0.2647719979286194,
-0.09215205162763596,
-0.20829768478870392,
0.2896461486816406,
-0.7056236267089844,
-0.23279014229774475,
-0.26775357127189636,
0.12562237679958344,
0.20029257237911224,
0.5725959539413452,
0.5809823870658875,
0.6800975203514099,
0.4005957841873169,
0.2818414866924286,
-0.0414673276245594,
-0.20194509625434875,
-0.5017010569572449,
0.49317240715026855,
-0.2159395068883896,
-0.28832316398620605,
-0.13648487627506256,
0.09466887265443802,
0.6496186852455139,
0.8207474946975708,
-0.278917133808136,
0.6612314581871033,
-0.07784159481525421,
0.02766432985663414,
-0.13249875605106354,
0.15966954827308655,
-0.48956191539764404,
0.2784000039100647,
-0.2008882761001587,
-0.6365383863449097,
-0.14664287865161896,
-0.5459299087524414,
0.38478511571884155,
-0.12843741476535797,
0.3626345694065094,
0.04459785297513008,
0.8155853748321533,
0.04475126042962074,
-0.11178147047758102,
-0.20351099967956543,
-0.9725706577301025,
0.764107346534729,
-0.59551602602005,
0.030170205980539322,
0.34316205978393555,
0.38903313875198364,
-0.05899075046181679,
-0.6388433575630188,
-0.42768624424934387,
0.2832100987434387,
-0.23601068556308746,
0.04420312121510506,
0.006467668805271387,
0.05389854311943054,
0.1173451766371727,
0.6521457433700562,
-0.6385088562965393,
0.2834261357784271,
-0.7871529459953308,
-0.10291718691587448,
0.614562451839447,
0.5194777846336365,
0.47071993350982666,
-0.45828452706336975,
-0.10220211744308472,
0.011325471103191376,
-0.16928966343402863,
0.10143870860338211,
0.16746853291988373,
-0.0778057724237442,
-0.035650815814733505,
0.6833361983299255,
-0.20034179091453552,
0.5977044105529785,
0.018296627327799797,
-0.18444915115833282,
0.035032063722610474,
-0.36719590425491333,
-0.13089710474014282,
0.14440308511257172,
0.632695198059082,
0.17297127842903137,
-0.37139326333999634,
-0.03998446464538574,
-0.16047403216362,
-0.20721080899238586,
0.4569745361804962,
-0.49059298634529114,
-0.3356385827064514,
0.7303515672683716,
-0.8184324502944946,
-0.48120877146720886,
0.13044928014278412,
-1.0830367803573608,
-0.2585318386554718,
-0.4155510663986206,
0.29576435685157776,
-0.2040286362171173,
0.03704819083213806,
-0.15742512047290802,
-0.5473099946975708,
0.2688826620578766,
0.4750860631465912,
-0.4021797776222229,
-0.010727902874350548,
0.4765186309814453,
0.8276038765907288,
-0.5748686790466309,
0.2940882742404938,
-0.08991588652133942,
0.17780494689941406,
-0.06633149832487106,
0.7942411303520203,
-0.7624184489250183,
-0.6138644814491272,
-0.026265772059559822,
0.14037978649139404,
0.37047556042671204,
-0.29614338278770447,
0.30432578921318054,
-0.44413840770721436,
0.3659328520298004,
0.1947660893201828,
-0.6621905565261841,
-0.007682161871343851,
0.24809542298316956,
-0.5925272703170776,
1.4789564609527588,
0.20792648196220398,
-0.7184752821922302,
0.057438790798187256,
-0.7148658633232117,
-0.18175750970840454,
0.23003864288330078,
-0.8653578758239746,
-0.23317866027355194,
0.07474812120199203,
0.08178382366895676,
0.6599295735359192,
-0.45058783888816833,
0.5183730721473694,
-0.06602849066257477,
-0.5768620371818542,
0.14838026463985443,
0.011457376182079315,
0.9107010364532471,
0.1327269971370697,
-0.2697833180427551,
0.15034550428390503,
-0.660132110118866,
-0.1773548275232315,
0.22309567034244537,
-0.43696120381355286,
-0.33052825927734375,
-0.06405147910118103,
0.02224147506058216,
0.23825104534626007,
0.149590402841568,
-0.6567694544792175,
0.12497210502624512,
-0.1594690978527069,
0.26017099618911743,
0.6344805955886841,
0.24864596128463745,
0.30854758620262146,
-0.01518368348479271,
0.702540397644043,
0.20588397979736328,
-0.05617508292198181,
-0.37035635113716125,
-0.22508065402507782,
-0.4620217978954315,
-0.4072093069553375,
0.47394120693206787,
0.6011083722114563,
-0.7060056328773499,
0.72368985414505,
-0.032408345490694046,
-0.7346407771110535,
-0.8495644927024841,
0.03631870821118355,
0.15044169127941132,
0.44932612776756287,
0.04557844251394272,
-0.503320574760437,
-0.6871801614761353,
-1.049311637878418,
0.11773397028446198,
0.02212195284664631,
-0.2557910978794098,
0.01725020259618759,
0.3847636282444,
0.18028058111667633,
1.4747951030731201,
-0.8077892065048218,
-0.0003313049382995814,
-0.5370689630508423,
0.8226598501205444,
0.4029941260814667,
0.7328195571899414,
0.3346041738986969,
-0.7891044616699219,
-0.28153344988822937,
-0.15689711272716522,
-0.9530031085014343,
-0.19110465049743652,
-0.23910613358020782,
-0.40654879808425903,
-0.47280848026275635,
0.47904789447784424,
-0.35140261054039,
0.8278138637542725,
0.1656145453453064,
-0.3041929006576538,
0.6475655436515808,
-0.019128309562802315,
0.004910846706479788,
-0.9915240406990051,
0.4182768166065216,
0.13945382833480835,
-0.17957636713981628,
-0.6598011255264282,
-0.2800317406654358,
-0.2099725306034088,
-0.4482704699039459,
-0.23476450145244598,
0.23622678220272064,
-0.4156714975833893,
-0.3474711775779724,
-0.1844860315322876,
-0.09657419472932816,
0.21920767426490784,
0.6069383025169373,
0.30540305376052856,
0.7688145041465759,
0.24223592877388,
-0.419498473405838,
0.35912033915519714,
0.7116854190826416,
-0.581199049949646,
0.2373102903366089,
-0.8169159293174744,
0.23096245527267456,
-0.36019396781921387,
0.009793141856789589,
-1.1682850122451782,
-0.05588272213935852,
-0.12628063559532166,
-0.3197569251060486,
0.18364250659942627,
-0.16822583973407745,
-0.5466577410697937,
-0.32963940501213074,
-0.44942131638526917,
0.23770512640476227,
0.6135309934616089,
0.015287427231669426,
0.46186208724975586,
1.0018852949142456,
-0.9678987860679626,
-0.02435980550944805,
-0.32531866431236267,
0.10336890071630478,
-0.36817434430122375,
-0.24789448082447052,
0.5571776032447815,
0.03654346242547035,
-0.3115262985229492,
-0.26622912287712097,
0.02955625019967556,
-0.5015884041786194,
0.22495365142822266,
0.13583800196647644,
0.638329803943634,
-0.05925719439983368,
0.048079703003168106,
0.4404882788658142,
0.013490188866853714,
0.11708582937717438,
-0.18907807767391205,
0.30976393818855286,
0.12507794797420502,
-0.0983249843120575,
-0.6559417843818665,
0.74728924036026,
0.3364681303501129,
-0.25942230224609375,
0.6535387635231018,
0.6888754367828369,
-0.2780183255672455,
0.10127119719982147,
-0.5866659283638,
-0.19644694030284882,
-0.3714517056941986,
0.3371436893939972,
0.1195409893989563,
-0.8865324258804321,
0.4067630469799042,
-0.07830881327390671,
0.21245844662189484,
0.3339168131351471,
0.8031614422798157,
-0.7160001397132874,
0.9809860587120056,
0.9736696481704712,
-0.0780709758400917,
0.7047068476676941,
-0.28709372878074646,
0.2383318394422531,
-0.43032026290893555,
-0.4510304927825928,
-0.7603855133056641,
-0.4674208462238312,
-0.21515928208827972,
-0.14496862888336182,
0.7195383906364441,
-0.3689955174922943,
0.22802883386611938,
0.11866206675767899,
-0.6566884517669678,
0.31062835454940796,
0.7016927003860474,
0.04905542731285095,
0.05562727525830269,
-0.07843627035617828,
0.10207587480545044,
-0.16234059631824493,
-0.48498645424842834,
-0.6077154278755188,
0.6389098763465881,
0.549919843673706,
0.8036728501319885,
-0.20220884680747986,
0.5473917722702026,
0.9349323511123657,
-0.284901887178421,
-0.5219686627388,
0.5451347231864929,
0.27753323316574097,
-0.7814666628837585,
-0.6339837908744812,
-0.007852901704609394,
-0.7956644892692566,
0.2228047400712967,
-0.27944672107696533,
-1.0646072626113892,
0.7075897455215454,
-0.22749006748199463,
-0.6520043015480042,
-0.11809088289737701,
-0.5372462272644043,
0.8735570311546326,
-0.1333579272031784,
-0.3536176383495331,
-0.03629744425415993,
-0.9893800616264343,
-0.022613119333982468,
-0.3129408061504364,
0.06138858571648598,
-0.19698554277420044,
0.4664984345436096,
1.1751952171325684,
-0.1947043538093567,
0.926829993724823,
-0.30431434512138367,
-0.05133714899420738,
0.4120576083660126,
0.23310932517051697,
-0.04185080900788307,
0.0576593317091465,
-0.21195515990257263,
0.1999407708644867,
0.6888906955718994,
-0.4661926031112671,
-0.7256951332092285,
-0.02304425649344921,
-0.4045060873031616,
-0.5891859531402588,
-0.17806163430213928,
-0.7449266314506531,
-0.047611527144908905,
0.23146963119506836,
-0.26075154542922974,
0.373603880405426,
-0.27236077189445496,
0.3120562732219696,
0.5753453373908997,
-0.48229390382766724,
0.13300298154354095,
0.2568397521972656,
-0.04709188640117645,
0.13746002316474915,
0.617344319820404,
-0.05216432362794876,
-0.22386977076530457,
0.39437785744667053,
0.20214074850082397,
0.02568311244249344,
-0.6467027068138123,
-0.07821164280176163,
0.07781115174293518,
-0.4888058006763458,
-0.14993922412395477,
-0.726856529712677,
-0.2758413255214691,
-0.4074462056159973,
0.037675220519304276,
-0.08916465938091278,
-0.7039405107498169,
-0.11306905746459961,
-0.3832060694694519,
0.13457757234573364,
0.6004951596260071,
0.13887740671634674,
0.5480785965919495,
-1.1448974609375,
0.2610456049442291,
0.056317396461963654,
-0.3302689790725708,
-0.1510961353778839,
-0.3356645405292511,
-0.5952556133270264,
-0.24192577600479126,
-0.45761603116989136,
-1.0227465629577637,
0.5007852911949158,
0.013661406934261322,
0.43913349509239197,
0.32246050238609314,
0.054224755614995956,
0.7339541912078857,
-0.010954702273011208,
0.8457143902778625,
-0.2373175323009491,
-0.71841961145401,
0.9718322157859802,
-0.4933598041534424,
0.1416877657175064,
0.8723076581954956,
0.46488842368125916,
-0.2554624080657959,
-0.5725223422050476,
-0.656272292137146,
-0.7249423265457153,
1.007163166999817,
0.5382632613182068,
-0.23815719783306122,
0.01781510002911091,
0.23240353167057037,
0.5588127970695496,
0.6347218155860901,
-0.19081802666187286,
0.17874830961227417,
0.11954136937856674,
-0.6497454047203064,
0.1841849833726883,
-0.5874611735343933,
-0.18948408961296082,
-0.5597884654998779,
0.3465738892555237,
0.12505623698234558,
0.6847038865089417,
0.18033279478549957,
-0.19844979047775269,
0.31246936321258545,
0.17876271903514862,
-0.05719339847564697,
0.6185991168022156,
-0.48610442876815796,
-0.022985979914665222,
-0.0946202278137207,
-0.36484721302986145,
-0.12991203367710114,
0.12448158860206604,
-0.0915326401591301,
0.20127716660499573,
0.3481903374195099,
0.2933228015899658,
0.22682125866413116,
-0.8809231519699097,
0.49363765120506287,
-0.11683230847120285,
0.164776012301445,
-0.3234926462173462,
-0.17266502976417542,
-0.12297558784484863,
0.25369858741760254,
0.4111376404762268,
-0.7145727276802063,
0.6438475251197815,
-0.7944512367248535,
0.35102537274360657,
0.05232594534754753,
-0.22693751752376556,
-0.3831161558628082,
0.24868038296699524,
0.26686376333236694,
-0.15820027887821198,
0.8252926468849182,
0.17410215735435486,
-0.43616047501564026,
0.6700245141983032,
0.34336602687835693,
0.5927969217300415,
-0.20004181563854218,
0.456685334444046,
0.08808355033397675,
-0.1629001498222351,
0.42334118485450745,
0.47768446803092957,
-0.4753616154193878,
-0.2915493845939636,
-0.15179239213466644,
-0.6617534160614014,
-0.4115499258041382,
-0.18068985641002655,
-0.8461084961891174,
0.14309222996234894,
-0.27561071515083313,
-0.04611292481422424,
0.1779329478740692,
-0.1689782589673996,
-0.6722610592842102,
0.2475421279668808,
-0.15384040772914886,
0.8043527007102966,
-0.9729458093643188,
0.7463779449462891,
0.7921909689903259,
-0.5444865822792053,
-0.45075395703315735,
-0.3877376914024353,
0.12135110795497894,
-0.7162278294563293,
0.6672405004501343,
-0.008779613301157951,
0.28029415011405945,
0.038314081728458405,
-0.47700634598731995,
-0.5367381572723389,
1.2503833770751953,
-0.10736355930566788,
-0.07262810319662094,
-0.5847551226615906,
0.14059679210186005,
0.5022194981575012,
-0.33447200059890747,
0.4287358820438385,
1.0667598247528076,
0.26093748211860657,
0.14312836527824402,
-0.769123375415802,
-0.1447249799966812,
-0.41628608107566833,
-0.06926868110895157,
0.16331826150417328,
0.052648015320301056,
0.5323828458786011,
0.41686832904815674,
-0.23331181704998016,
-0.04642126336693764,
0.6560282111167908,
-0.14145047962665558,
0.24786680936813354,
0.3962985575199127,
0.013941848650574684,
0.807791531085968,
0.08176592737436295,
0.6593255996704102,
-0.18170222640037537,
0.24487121403217316,
0.9824584722518921,
-0.1475132554769516,
0.45108121633529663,
0.527490496635437,
-0.1813303828239441,
0.677102267742157,
0.7880236506462097,
-0.16020382940769196,
0.44987425208091736,
0.0462816022336483,
0.19543761014938354,
-0.19493384659290314,
-0.2512599229812622,
0.04854830726981163,
0.7754315733909607,
0.6345229148864746,
-0.361141175031662,
-0.2913503348827362,
0.06575904041528702,
-0.27832767367362976,
-0.22705399990081787,
0.0469498336315155,
1.042077660560608,
0.0037849778309464455,
-0.4048861265182495,
0.025255197659134865,
0.026943521574139595,
0.1750277280807495,
-0.47289156913757324,
-0.4388403296470642,
-0.25122249126434326,
-0.3817572295665741,
-0.26500222086906433,
-1.099287986755371,
0.6067491769790649,
0.1851508766412735,
0.0018372883787378669,
-0.3940449655056,
0.8743307590484619,
-0.43063342571258545,
-0.3478081226348877,
-0.1253439337015152,
0.8172141909599304,
0.47762560844421387,
0.14275623857975006,
-0.7634304761886597,
0.15154215693473816,
0.03245317563414574,
-0.03431502357125282,
0.0993959978222847,
0.5060184001922607,
-0.08139948546886444,
0.4037976562976837,
0.4633830189704895,
-0.05284227430820465,
-0.11102158576250076,
-0.04860379919409752,
0.7533990740776062,
-1.1326549053192139,
-0.854759693145752,
-0.743222713470459,
0.7764254808425903,
-0.44890475273132324,
0.005674880929291248,
0.54966801404953,
0.5892937779426575,
0.33249881863594055,
0.023837722837924957,
0.8268192410469055,
-0.3216431736946106,
0.9368921518325806,
-0.49811652302742004,
0.43962785601615906,
-0.4793258607387543,
0.3856483995914459,
-0.4925417900085449,
-0.7375927567481995,
0.12249410897493362,
0.439784973859787,
-0.2143935263156891,
-0.23642435669898987,
0.6301414370536804,
0.661083459854126,
-0.14530345797538757,
0.2372717559337616,
0.019590236246585846,
0.17477846145629883,
0.3304004371166229,
-0.05553478002548218,
0.9173300266265869,
0.1316417157649994,
0.18051713705062866,
-0.2361198365688324,
-0.3588891625404358,
-0.26365241408348083,
-0.485942542552948,
-0.8656389713287354,
-0.8202134370803833,
-0.40040022134780884,
-0.0652189552783966,
-0.002448481507599354,
0.6627538204193115,
0.6606014966964722,
-0.6890293955802917,
-0.48174360394477844,
0.49720120429992676,
0.0358586423099041,
0.07809484004974365,
-0.31851673126220703,
0.5749897360801697,
0.01476419996470213,
-0.5845072865486145,
0.4496019184589386,
0.49030378460884094,
-0.02602100372314453,
-0.42571592330932617,
0.5991919636726379,
-0.39259928464889526,
-0.07946128398180008,
0.5041390657424927,
0.2658924460411072,
-0.3747106194496155,
-0.30505073070526123,
-0.18931512534618378,
-0.008050896227359772,
0.22763866186141968,
0.9621939659118652,
-0.7144285440444946,
0.5311163663864136,
0.6577246785163879,
0.9873980283737183,
0.3764451742172241,
0.5202119946479797,
0.9674156308174133,
-0.8496435284614563,
-0.0512407161295414,
0.27510279417037964,
0.11980555206537247,
0.041123177856206894,
-0.5476210713386536,
0.5185880064964294,
0.10018458962440491,
-0.2748270630836487,
-1.0039247274398804,
-0.16772064566612244,
-1.0942072868347168,
-0.3340275287628174,
0.8383738994598389,
0.02807733230292797,
-0.3291281461715698,
-0.6473913192749023,
-0.5485686659812927,
0.37978750467300415,
-0.29746314883232117,
1.0038212537765503,
0.6950675249099731,
-0.3340155780315399,
0.0660322904586792,
-0.5873028635978699,
-0.0029718708246946335,
0.3115597069263458,
-0.9263632893562317,
-0.38827893137931824,
0.3648022711277008,
0.01947508379817009,
0.0925530195236206,
0.6737500429153442,
-0.4244927763938904,
0.09904544800519943,
-0.3200121819972992,
0.21163715422153473,
0.14281046390533447,
-0.3332269787788391,
-0.29658034443855286,
0.18519936501979828,
-0.05516091361641884,
-0.2675359845161438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04483v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04483v2
|
GraphInstruct: Empowering Large Language Models with Graph Understanding and Reasoning Capability
| 2024-03-07T13:36:08 | 2024-04-02T07:57:16 |
Zihan Luo, Xiran Song, Hong Huang, Jianxun Lian, Chenhao Zhang, Jinqi Jiang, Xing Xie
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Evaluating and enhancing the general capabilities of large language models
(LLMs) has been an important research topic. Graph is a common data structure
in the real world, and understanding graph data is a crucial part for advancing
general intelligence. To evaluate and enhance the graph understanding abilities
of LLMs, in this paper, we propose a benchmark named GraphInstruct, which
comprehensively includes 21 classical graph reasoning tasks, providing diverse
graph generation pipelines and detailed reasoning steps. Based on
GraphInstruct, we further construct GraphLM through efficient
instruction-tuning, which shows prominent graph understanding capability. In
order to enhance the LLM with graph reasoning capability as well, we propose a
step mask training strategy, and construct a model named GraphLM+. As one of
the pioneering efforts to enhance the graph understanding and reasoning
abilities of LLMs, extensive experiments have demonstrated the superiority of
GraphLM and GraphLM+ over other LLMs. We look forward to more researchers
exploring the potential of LLMs in the graph data mining domain through
GraphInstruct. Our code for generating GraphInstruct is released publicly at:
https://github.com/CGCL-codes/GraphInstruct.
|
[
-0.3212380111217499,
-0.7348345518112183,
0.6221579909324646,
-0.09675692766904831,
-0.0686773955821991,
0.6679327487945557,
-0.04599755257368088,
-0.4752722978591919,
-0.29978615045547485,
0.6880906820297241,
-0.41578608751296997,
-0.9059286713600159,
-0.5922278165817261,
-0.15397876501083374,
-0.43801993131637573,
0.6525837779045105,
-0.20676344633102417,
0.25374066829681396,
-0.7161500453948975,
0.09509725868701935,
-0.264286607503891,
-0.33584168553352356,
-0.705383837223053,
-0.559493899345398,
-0.04119262844324112,
0.2593427300453186,
0.3783877193927765,
0.5916341543197632,
0.17255838215351105,
0.3448610305786133,
-0.21352773904800415,
0.5835961103439331,
-0.4944069981575012,
-0.19126230478286743,
-0.17479942739009857,
-0.21741630136966705,
-0.47954875230789185,
-0.04406517744064331,
0.8384039402008057,
0.8979215025901794,
0.23512482643127441,
0.3267296254634857,
0.22329828143119812,
0.4978522062301636,
-0.47267892956733704,
0.48038554191589355,
-0.6025868654251099,
-0.2010500729084015,
-0.09616674482822418,
0.19419679045677185,
-0.7887155413627625,
-0.4543895721435547,
-0.2543935775756836,
-0.4111698865890503,
0.1332239955663681,
0.3489377200603485,
0.7213489413261414,
-0.02776876464486122,
-0.4013788104057312,
-0.14331401884555817,
-0.16767442226409912,
0.3804803192615509,
-0.7340003252029419,
0.6235352754592896,
0.2990117073059082,
0.3709644675254822,
-0.27325695753097534,
-1.2169077396392822,
-0.1496758908033371,
-0.24147072434425354,
0.027639081701636314,
-0.09017302095890045,
-0.00613997969776392,
0.2895372211933136,
0.4247065484523773,
0.41372328996658325,
-0.7008041143417358,
0.400750994682312,
-0.16848549246788025,
-0.42142146825790405,
0.37931787967681885,
0.3361780643463135,
0.38537365198135376,
-0.1312260925769806,
-0.16514264047145844,
0.00738631933927536,
-0.9653047919273376,
0.09061472117900848,
0.6025646328926086,
0.33019739389419556,
0.026539668440818787,
0.288059800863266,
-0.38488298654556274,
0.9450479745864868,
-0.0647713765501976,
-0.07058446854352951,
0.23040062189102173,
-0.1724892258644104,
-0.468516081571579,
0.05499839037656784,
0.43365660309791565,
0.08304035663604736,
0.29182976484298706,
-0.3248711824417114,
-0.060850001871585846,
0.1464363932609558,
0.11089270561933517,
-1.1344410181045532,
-0.25967642664909363,
0.08102256059646606,
-0.3174847960472107,
-0.18623118102550507,
-0.030665498226881027,
-0.37153875827789307,
-0.3908427357673645,
-0.3978380262851715,
0.24227100610733032,
-0.6805397868156433,
0.03987254574894905,
0.3228238821029663,
-0.04007404297590256,
0.14055202901363373,
0.5475547313690186,
-0.5486769080162048,
0.6459140777587891,
1.0262387990951538,
0.7033014893531799,
0.009954780340194702,
-0.3279268145561218,
-0.7431685924530029,
0.08959362655878067,
-0.3471521735191345,
0.7286372780799866,
-0.7965373396873474,
-0.23959656059741974,
-0.05042967572808266,
0.14531028270721436,
-0.20468856394290924,
-0.5188618898391724,
0.5483340620994568,
-0.5403017401695251,
-0.0031617237254977226,
0.010393868200480938,
-1.078904151916504,
-0.6101651191711426,
0.3470732569694519,
-0.3400665819644928,
0.9432270526885986,
0.39645522832870483,
-0.6951454281806946,
0.05521337315440178,
-0.5089941024780273,
-0.7349402904510498,
0.49888038635253906,
-0.22385263442993164,
-0.42802295088768005,
-0.12111753225326538,
0.5431749224662781,
0.4826456606388092,
-0.2973826229572296,
0.1579645276069641,
-0.3770850598812103,
-0.6105069518089294,
0.05578098073601723,
-0.04848596453666687,
1.132555365562439,
-0.04160666465759277,
-0.2711111605167389,
0.1288052201271057,
-0.6232374906539917,
0.3269716501235962,
0.09705373644828796,
-0.07056427001953125,
-0.07582562416791916,
0.045125722885131836,
-0.4580003023147583,
-0.08282437920570374,
0.08269362151622772,
-0.5003531575202942,
0.06779398769140244,
-0.46692419052124023,
0.6315538287162781,
0.9207730293273926,
0.037206634879112244,
0.32691434025764465,
0.08828766644001007,
0.4770315885543823,
-0.48652172088623047,
0.38456451892852783,
-0.017825786024332047,
-0.38528192043304443,
-0.568858802318573,
-0.41682708263397217,
0.2240886390209198,
0.5288432836532593,
-0.7281080484390259,
0.24152076244354248,
-0.3211025297641754,
-0.49814751744270325,
-0.3892934024333954,
0.2857515811920166,
0.6530877947807312,
0.6878710985183716,
0.3197847008705139,
-0.11150781065225601,
-0.4533035457134247,
-0.7536001205444336,
-0.21908344328403473,
-0.06902563571929932,
0.06735096871852875,
0.440735787153244,
0.443158894777298,
-0.3585362434387207,
0.48833221197128296,
-0.6601716876029968,
0.13913480937480927,
-0.4330064356327057,
-0.2191982865333557,
0.2073460817337036,
0.15296176075935364,
0.42351874709129333,
-0.24375735223293304,
-0.5624706745147705,
0.07813556492328644,
-0.7225023508071899,
-0.09828148782253265,
0.36763906478881836,
-0.22110486030578613,
-0.07777469605207443,
0.8779106736183167,
-0.46532338857650757,
0.19981864094734192,
0.6055999994277954,
-0.2722741961479187,
0.5367820262908936,
0.009433150291442871,
0.050057604908943176,
-0.6488708257675171,
-0.1605924516916275,
-0.11467770487070084,
-0.5461085438728333,
-0.4469502568244934,
0.2360890656709671,
0.190560445189476,
-0.33359774947166443,
-0.27021896839141846,
0.4680158197879791,
-0.6323755383491516,
-0.18555216491222382,
-0.005321970209479332,
0.2770911753177643,
0.1723281592130661,
0.32346850633621216,
-0.3681282699108124,
0.5823567509651184,
0.7971958518028259,
-0.4452289938926697,
0.3253612220287323,
0.1441676914691925,
-0.9595631957054138,
0.35478150844573975,
-0.5253114104270935,
0.5083814859390259,
-0.11424127966165543,
0.22983981668949127,
-1.1439907550811768,
-0.2845516800880432,
0.32410913705825806,
-0.2156238555908203,
0.5809668302536011,
-0.49164819717407227,
-0.7237163186073303,
-0.55120450258255,
-0.1057291179895401,
0.13165679574012756,
0.4865225553512573,
-0.7773008942604065,
0.5606805086135864,
0.3350517451763153,
0.01188097894191742,
-0.3818112313747406,
-0.45691150426864624,
0.12897619605064392,
-0.14272359013557434,
-0.5762602090835571,
0.2347884327173233,
-0.21276569366455078,
-0.37117984890937805,
0.15591061115264893,
0.05086943879723549,
0.18677695095539093,
0.07790948450565338,
0.2526110112667084,
0.17516934871673584,
-0.009656364098191261,
0.1019812673330307,
0.194631427526474,
-0.13561533391475677,
0.10736677050590515,
-0.3755030632019043,
0.6822335720062256,
-0.10881048440933228,
-0.7404539585113525,
-0.3050113916397095,
-0.09287191182374954,
0.2966025471687317,
-0.3972078859806061,
0.2322414368391037,
0.33080390095710754,
-0.11685869842767715,
-0.5670723915100098,
-0.3225253224372864,
-0.05140465870499611,
-0.4904201328754425,
0.6685939431190491,
-0.33275797963142395,
-1.0105329751968384,
0.35655421018600464,
-0.5156934261322021,
-0.10555481910705566,
0.26207029819488525,
0.26674073934555054,
-0.024551652371883392,
1.133459448814392,
0.08659079670906067,
-0.1937931478023529,
0.27485865354537964,
-0.3948199152946472,
0.05625923350453377,
-0.921681821346283,
-0.15998384356498718,
-0.41575801372528076,
-0.0407162681221962,
-0.3166596293449402,
-0.5238364934921265,
0.08581173419952393,
0.05897781625390053,
-0.7753522992134094,
0.18646195530891418,
-0.7343561053276062,
0.533366322517395,
0.19918683171272278,
0.5514522790908813,
0.21728554368019104,
0.18194128572940826,
0.10541808605194092,
0.14136481285095215,
-0.6236646175384521,
-0.33101561665534973,
0.9637717008590698,
0.37785905599594116,
0.713668704032898,
-0.06270813196897507,
0.7268638610839844,
0.3062245547771454,
0.3793105483055115,
-0.6875748038291931,
0.7580099701881409,
-0.3675108850002289,
-0.24985143542289734,
-0.16874560713768005,
-0.39509040117263794,
-0.5784571170806885,
0.0759131982922554,
0.2323451191186905,
-0.8778325319290161,
-0.3240912854671478,
0.03880031034350395,
0.3163932263851166,
0.44230160117149353,
-0.6466478705406189,
0.878547191619873,
-0.4212297201156616,
-0.10165634751319885,
-0.3359164297580719,
-0.3641085624694824,
0.48931363224983215,
0.23029401898384094,
0.3900246024131775,
-0.1402108520269394,
0.17212678492069244,
0.527392566204071,
-0.46530768275260925,
1.0637660026550293,
-0.32040494680404663,
0.10180728137493134,
0.41793277859687805,
0.19497713446617126,
0.9518868327140808,
-0.0403825081884861,
-0.2671217620372772,
0.09045480936765671,
-0.44822147488594055,
-0.2079530954360962,
-0.6744608879089355,
0.7246601581573486,
-0.48170387744903564,
-0.7067304849624634,
0.06118839979171753,
-0.5907202959060669,
-0.27723628282546997,
0.18587425351142883,
0.12189289927482605,
0.8095034956932068,
-0.19134029746055603,
0.07814228534698486,
0.6664597988128662,
-0.0920904278755188,
0.2118625044822693,
0.10216448456048965,
-0.38723224401474,
-0.6683966517448425,
0.8914797902107239,
0.1765451729297638,
0.4846001863479614,
0.3436853289604187,
0.10961245745420456,
-0.20292842388153076,
-0.88185715675354,
-0.5482699275016785,
0.13794121146202087,
-1.0953922271728516,
-0.2930235266685486,
-0.46346864104270935,
-0.3963548541069031,
-0.2663283348083496,
-0.17430633306503296,
-0.20530115067958832,
-0.0802866667509079,
0.019347982481122017,
-0.2248501181602478,
0.4628259241580963,
0.8288440108299255,
0.28049495816230774,
0.09640160948038101,
-0.4221743643283844,
0.06441505253314972,
0.3214414715766907,
0.47563636302948,
0.15820951759815216,
-0.6478366255760193,
-0.511536180973053,
-0.1319539099931717,
-0.02082110568881035,
-0.4167446494102478,
-0.1511659175157547,
0.13564680516719818,
0.9428389072418213,
0.44185397028923035,
-0.1044657826423645,
0.6263933181762695,
-0.5447526574134827,
0.47936952114105225,
-0.045048635452985764,
-1.222174882888794,
0.38717013597488403,
0.003488217480480671,
0.3148292601108551,
0.40478241443634033,
0.19767101109027863,
-0.17804381251335144,
-0.4624103903770447,
-0.6517584323883057,
-0.6490123867988586,
0.4207089841365814,
0.052062805742025375,
0.025502342730760574,
0.15698184072971344,
0.4038524925708771,
0.11559895426034927,
-0.03937375545501709,
-0.5487446188926697,
-0.11711837351322174,
-0.2341768443584442,
-0.07247916609048843,
-0.06111493334174156,
-0.22162209451198578,
-0.045060139149427414,
-0.466212660074234,
0.6152238249778748,
-0.27392977476119995,
-0.030886121094226837,
-0.17869150638580322,
-0.35395902395248413,
0.29350709915161133,
-0.0665053203701973,
0.13735434412956238,
0.8712270855903625,
-0.059577781707048416,
0.3431859314441681,
0.44782140851020813,
-0.342516154050827,
-0.043594904243946075,
0.2952401340007782,
-0.17355260252952576,
-0.16689150035381317,
0.8537911176681519,
0.9262503981590271,
0.2976706027984619,
-0.540442168712616,
0.2718767523765564,
0.25125789642333984,
-0.18750140070915222,
0.10844287276268005,
0.19232423603534698,
0.4323493242263794,
0.3283414840698242,
0.06120569631457329,
-0.38326406478881836,
0.19728083908557892,
-0.39580869674682617,
0.09916911274194717,
0.514967143535614,
-0.34437406063079834,
-0.11322502046823502,
0.5455653667449951,
-0.02619939297437668,
-0.34886232018470764,
0.9027382135391235,
-0.5372045636177063,
-0.7245873808860779,
0.6276586055755615,
0.7599432468414307,
0.8040613532066345,
-0.19442345201969147,
0.25985202193260193,
0.48613110184669495,
0.23561632633209229,
0.25915616750717163,
0.14452475309371948,
0.027454135939478874,
-0.6835268139839172,
-0.8249521851539612,
-0.4378751814365387,
-0.5160403847694397,
-0.02978293038904667,
-0.21493005752563477,
0.1722121238708496,
-0.6381824016571045,
0.1233239471912384,
-0.09171288460493088,
0.07649937272071838,
-0.5352985858917236,
0.11540178954601288,
0.05381670221686363,
0.933468222618103,
-0.7499381303787231,
0.8250943422317505,
0.5317891240119934,
-0.16915547847747803,
-0.6392495632171631,
-0.19463901221752167,
-0.043502163141965866,
-0.8813896179199219,
0.9032670259475708,
0.28386154770851135,
-0.29077214002609253,
0.1558278650045395,
-0.9482212662696838,
-0.524968147277832,
0.9364945292472839,
0.7556020617485046,
-0.465645968914032,
0.2685616612434387,
0.06552428007125854,
0.24687150120735168,
-0.5152345895767212,
0.011899199336767197,
0.38708585500717163,
0.4769289791584015,
0.07780853658914566,
-0.4996895492076874,
0.24434679746627808,
-0.046096183359622955,
-0.06942184269428253,
0.2897750437259674,
-0.5065193772315979,
0.9159364104270935,
-0.1609095185995102,
-0.2881465256214142,
-0.1596411019563675,
0.5177772045135498,
0.36968183517456055,
0.2324557900428772,
0.5419815182685852,
0.6974383592605591,
0.9043580889701843,
0.03084460273385048,
1.0767937898635864,
-0.3067915439605713,
0.2735457718372345,
1.3646725416183472,
-0.17352606356143951,
0.43255212903022766,
-0.07413572072982788,
-0.4503960609436035,
0.7142455577850342,
0.8548857569694519,
-0.07957993447780609,
0.22793470323085785,
0.4406788945198059,
-0.2300376445055008,
-0.508918285369873,
-0.06603290885686874,
-0.26362234354019165,
0.48832014203071594,
0.3806995153427124,
-0.247491717338562,
-0.22565975785255432,
-0.15205460786819458,
0.25593748688697815,
0.1608244627714157,
-0.505196750164032,
0.46907633543014526,
0.044164396822452545,
-0.20629410445690155,
0.4415839910507202,
-0.3156488835811615,
-0.011781339533627033,
-0.645760178565979,
-0.2270893156528473,
-0.16590286791324615,
0.16420678794384003,
-0.32798439264297485,
-0.9852563142776489,
-0.005566307343542576,
-0.2976629137992859,
0.032326534390449524,
-0.022362038493156433,
0.8507224917411804,
-0.1139221265912056,
-0.6707356572151184,
0.5691033005714417,
0.25769922137260437,
0.2770569920539856,
-0.1800234466791153,
-0.5393930077552795,
0.18843233585357666,
0.16244204342365265,
0.02369452454149723,
0.3500703275203705,
0.4490445554256439,
-0.13335809111595154,
0.7077749371528625,
0.4889143109321594,
0.04306745156645775,
-0.3143967092037201,
0.5450469851493835,
0.9794651865959167,
-0.3716858923435211,
-0.2504187822341919,
-0.9394609332084656,
0.41976186633110046,
-0.463655561208725,
0.09164522588253021,
1.0207957029342651,
0.8843056559562683,
0.8260525465011597,
0.03570031002163887,
0.8951637148857117,
0.00905650109052658,
0.24614804983139038,
-0.6516521573066711,
0.4502045512199402,
-0.30695194005966187,
0.031224125996232033,
-0.47120675444602966,
-0.8245162963867188,
-0.3713734745979309,
0.277263343334198,
-0.408581405878067,
-0.0325113907456398,
0.5575815439224243,
0.8286800384521484,
-0.1332935094833374,
-0.21701747179031372,
0.08605068922042847,
0.13803263008594513,
0.4396669566631317,
0.5957295298576355,
0.7533504366874695,
-0.3021325469017029,
0.5973170399665833,
-0.15238718688488007,
-0.15553820133209229,
0.010953831486403942,
-0.900827944278717,
-1.2211580276489258,
-0.27862703800201416,
-0.45265915989875793,
-0.3929425776004791,
-0.05724301189184189,
0.5080661773681641,
0.6518259048461914,
-0.7540287971496582,
-0.2562709450721741,
-0.28702273964881897,
0.517820417881012,
-0.34003978967666626,
-0.1843200922012329,
0.8419657945632935,
-0.4389338493347168,
-0.9049013257026672,
0.694484531879425,
0.533456563949585,
-0.15321841835975647,
-0.30657148361206055,
-0.2801693379878998,
-0.1366148144006729,
-0.2784120440483093,
0.7994194626808167,
0.0976657047867775,
-0.524103581905365,
-0.6070597171783447,
-0.2080336958169937,
0.150968998670578,
0.07609938085079193,
0.7086532115936279,
-0.4786824882030487,
0.6668630242347717,
0.6226739883422852,
0.6862555742263794,
0.8747367858886719,
-0.03033306635916233,
0.33542534708976746,
-0.39826053380966187,
0.14477691054344177,
-0.0540676973760128,
0.6091644763946533,
0.49180710315704346,
-0.3744429647922516,
0.7697677612304688,
0.22576673328876495,
-0.52609783411026,
-0.8981549739837646,
0.4416436553001404,
-0.591423749923706,
-0.48388445377349854,
1.0004487037658691,
-0.155043363571167,
-0.0843186154961586,
-0.12395628541707993,
-0.21155229210853577,
0.3268361985683441,
-0.03551364690065384,
0.3073325753211975,
0.5380065441131592,
-0.44664499163627625,
-0.3438760042190552,
-0.5251405835151672,
0.2998611032962799,
-0.2080310881137848,
-0.9289699792861938,
0.09810804575681686,
0.4924910366535187,
0.21888525784015656,
-0.21748396754264832,
0.3170187175273895,
-0.11472970247268677,
-0.09413959085941315,
0.3348940908908844,
0.0893658697605133,
-0.4796733856201172,
-0.20383700728416443,
0.1456708014011383,
0.2871953547000885,
0.25033441185951233,
-0.20959347486495972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04481v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04481v3
|
Do Large Language Model Understand Multi-Intent Spoken Language ?
| 2024-03-07T13:30:52 | 2024-04-15T16:24:35 |
Shangjian Yin, Peijie Huang, Yuhong Xu, Haojing Huang, Jiatian Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This research signifies a considerable breakthrough in leveraging Large
Language Models (LLMs) for multi-intent spoken language understanding (SLU).
Our approach re-imagines the use of entity slots in multi-intent SLU
applications, making the most of the generative potential of LLMs within the
SLU landscape, leading to the development of the EN-LLM series. Furthermore, we
introduce the concept of Sub-Intent Instruction (SII) to amplify the analysis
and interpretation of complex, multi-intent communications, which further
supports the creation of the ENSI-LLM models series. Our novel datasets,
identified as LM-MixATIS and LM-MixSNIPS, are synthesized from existing
benchmarks. The study evidences that LLMs may match or even surpass the
performance of the current best multi-intent SLU models. We also scrutinize the
performance of LLMs across a spectrum of intent configurations and dataset
distributions. On top of this, we present two revolutionary metrics - Entity
Slot Accuracy (ESA) and Combined Semantic Accuracy (CSA) - to facilitate a
detailed assessment of LLM competence in this multifaceted field." Our code and
datasets are available at \url{https://github.com/SJY8460/SLM}.
|
[
-0.10008027404546738,
-0.8228117227554321,
0.8625586032867432,
0.21868500113487244,
-0.009859631769359112,
-0.06641978025436401,
-0.40112417936325073,
-0.44163382053375244,
0.3005591630935669,
0.6702935695648193,
-0.4636790454387665,
-0.6128048896789551,
-0.557755708694458,
-0.21739168465137482,
-0.29761210083961487,
0.341097891330719,
-0.03342268988490105,
0.41708552837371826,
-0.29400333762168884,
-0.29432302713394165,
-0.5685667991638184,
-0.25027430057525635,
-0.6611858010292053,
-0.3283019959926605,
0.46130406856536865,
0.47731494903564453,
0.4174329340457916,
0.1487005650997162,
0.31224924325942993,
0.28448498249053955,
-0.11451306939125061,
0.3140021860599518,
-0.4662720859050751,
0.11624571681022644,
0.1342688798904419,
-0.38492247462272644,
-0.7159000039100647,
-0.07536840438842773,
1.0921128988265991,
0.861998438835144,
-0.29350924491882324,
0.10934799164533615,
0.015457972884178162,
0.3695834279060364,
-0.4641505479812622,
0.2684747874736786,
-0.7084115743637085,
-0.08940934389829636,
-0.16478300094604492,
-0.16613800823688507,
-1.0259226560592651,
0.007847278378903866,
0.2195301204919815,
-0.5997239947319031,
-0.20115701854228973,
-0.003534498857334256,
0.33398154377937317,
0.32191866636276245,
-0.5228993892669678,
-0.48840752243995667,
-0.9342717528343201,
0.8807373046875,
-0.7669390439987183,
0.7715393304824829,
-0.06428810209035873,
0.07275719940662384,
-0.3371335566043854,
-0.5980610251426697,
-0.45826733112335205,
-0.11426126956939697,
0.05196831002831459,
0.050125230103731155,
0.16375915706157684,
0.10860168933868408,
0.1750040203332901,
0.25147679448127747,
-0.47846466302871704,
0.4506019949913025,
-0.2729468047618866,
0.05178483575582504,
0.6988875865936279,
0.17615923285484314,
0.35518762469291687,
0.3190709948539734,
-0.45605263113975525,
0.35780179500579834,
-0.8900004625320435,
0.007076278794556856,
0.1383720338344574,
0.20398958027362823,
-0.07343515753746033,
0.8337623476982117,
0.1677132099866867,
0.7959159016609192,
-0.18765224516391754,
-0.4296339452266693,
0.11599776148796082,
-0.34238484501838684,
-0.424815833568573,
0.16214334964752197,
0.629676103591919,
0.07914875447750092,
0.004856505431234837,
-0.2121487706899643,
-0.08268173038959503,
-0.2209465354681015,
0.09370966255664825,
-0.45165926218032837,
0.22672751545906067,
0.24342280626296997,
-0.31139233708381653,
0.25390222668647766,
-0.24014489352703094,
-0.17748282849788666,
-0.40284407138824463,
-0.5203613638877869,
0.30284520983695984,
-0.49327757954597473,
-0.29161155223846436,
0.5267473459243774,
0.15699277818202972,
0.559550940990448,
0.44116446375846863,
-0.6803066730499268,
0.3638913929462433,
0.988145649433136,
0.737212598323822,
-0.3161042630672455,
-0.5620157718658447,
-0.2706718146800995,
0.4462423324584961,
-0.13810184597969055,
0.5639654994010925,
-0.7298544049263,
-0.33984509110450745,
-0.032272618263959885,
-0.18421606719493866,
-0.5978636145591736,
-0.28407102823257446,
0.6194974780082703,
-0.5939934849739075,
0.03201755881309509,
-0.056503381580114365,
-0.8525272011756897,
-0.29595258831977844,
-0.020606301724910736,
-0.795390784740448,
0.8835260272026062,
-0.2655198276042938,
-0.3354264497756958,
0.38424238562583923,
-0.9265487194061279,
-0.4890674650669098,
0.32908302545547485,
-0.27659353613853455,
-0.09966589510440826,
0.24479185044765472,
0.011054971255362034,
0.4861740171909332,
-0.08386757969856262,
0.44261616468429565,
-0.40017566084861755,
-0.3561079800128937,
0.4792391359806061,
-0.6170720458030701,
0.5901539325714111,
-0.05974244698882103,
-0.07472603768110275,
0.2679313123226166,
-0.5670123100280762,
0.07905787229537964,
-0.02389432117342949,
-0.396977961063385,
-0.34222590923309326,
0.14509274065494537,
-0.0018523038597777486,
0.1514516919851303,
0.29818737506866455,
-0.649368405342102,
0.15396347641944885,
-0.20974180102348328,
0.5195544958114624,
0.6578011512756348,
-0.3278856873512268,
0.6783669590950012,
0.2250646948814392,
0.2569800317287445,
-0.007556403987109661,
0.2535237967967987,
-0.2813997268676758,
-0.493033766746521,
-0.6346935629844666,
-0.16451291739940643,
0.16201166808605194,
0.4940909743309021,
-0.4660676121711731,
0.2731810510158539,
-0.4784836769104004,
-0.38366201519966125,
-0.5448537468910217,
0.026092788204550743,
0.23151950538158417,
-0.016761714592576027,
0.16112282872200012,
-0.26367104053497314,
-0.35631126165390015,
-0.7449231743812561,
-0.23028962314128876,
0.03946267440915108,
0.3133430480957031,
0.7970690727233887,
0.2816818654537201,
-0.3015049695968628,
0.6475858092308044,
-0.3740781247615814,
-0.1550537645816803,
-0.6167677044868469,
-0.10049382597208023,
0.1826573759317398,
0.26063936948776245,
0.3516622483730316,
-0.8244742751121521,
-0.4201759696006775,
-0.14223219454288483,
-0.6803877949714661,
0.27033793926239014,
-0.12479893863201141,
-0.08041120320558548,
0.09743596613407135,
0.3846057057380676,
-0.9000847935676575,
0.17916397750377655,
0.6856850981712341,
-0.3030121326446533,
0.4865320920944214,
-0.149447962641716,
0.15155784785747528,
-0.9545917510986328,
-0.25377267599105835,
0.15145955979824066,
-0.024986624717712402,
-0.9517835974693298,
0.023304784670472145,
0.09552615135908127,
-0.01789073646068573,
-0.8344238996505737,
0.4035331606864929,
-0.6267830729484558,
-0.5684172511100769,
-0.16796405613422394,
0.2680329382419586,
0.017368856817483902,
0.2498694360256195,
0.09176216274499893,
0.9922524094581604,
0.60482257604599,
-0.6884088516235352,
0.2654591500759125,
0.11484990268945694,
-0.5167094469070435,
0.33225172758102417,
-0.7012139558792114,
0.16643428802490234,
-0.24503526091575623,
0.46931830048561096,
-0.9176025390625,
-0.30731096863746643,
-0.009162070229649544,
-0.12017253041267395,
0.49441272020339966,
-0.14210245013237,
-0.2381594181060791,
-0.016303809359669685,
0.0702534019947052,
0.40349045395851135,
0.026336148381233215,
-0.36272767186164856,
0.9352701306343079,
0.8702565431594849,
-0.21270355582237244,
-0.8646041750907898,
-0.5784642100334167,
0.08236974477767944,
-0.2210090160369873,
-0.845375120639801,
0.31120768189430237,
-0.12467169761657715,
-0.23737072944641113,
-0.1919528692960739,
0.039593301713466644,
-0.12423621863126755,
0.13533979654312134,
0.1768149733543396,
0.32077062129974365,
-0.5834025144577026,
0.21455290913581848,
-0.051379039883613586,
0.020088976249098778,
0.11850272864103317,
-0.4570511281490326,
0.7886195182800293,
-0.2966282367706299,
-0.7083998918533325,
-0.3905121088027954,
0.42858168482780457,
0.7937710285186768,
-0.2265883982181549,
0.9473473429679871,
0.6179583668708801,
-0.333810955286026,
0.030593767762184143,
-0.5291145443916321,
0.12560473382472992,
-0.4021448493003845,
0.32429900765419006,
-0.5874735116958618,
-1.0985366106033325,
0.3717394471168518,
-0.1768496334552765,
0.45497289299964905,
0.20535989105701447,
0.44172966480255127,
-0.03729076310992241,
0.9266564249992371,
0.6299499273300171,
-0.05482630431652069,
0.46030768752098083,
-0.24953259527683258,
0.36704203486442566,
-1.074040412902832,
-0.3557712733745575,
-0.2820139527320862,
-0.3235399127006531,
-0.21755115687847137,
-0.5856233835220337,
0.3631120026111603,
-0.08126498013734818,
0.10130299627780914,
0.14347846806049347,
-0.060309477150440216,
0.5562109351158142,
0.34438422322273254,
-0.0068065873347222805,
0.2392546683549881,
-0.2064768522977829,
0.13785351812839508,
-0.008900581859052181,
-0.6052965521812439,
-0.670556366443634,
1.0483789443969727,
0.6215482950210571,
1.1689776182174683,
0.33028993010520935,
0.6207606196403503,
0.03770052641630173,
0.12854443490505219,
-1.0251672267913818,
0.6238924264907837,
-0.16329814493656158,
-0.3648396134376526,
-0.6613507866859436,
-0.2551024258136749,
-0.902773916721344,
0.492197185754776,
0.0730305090546608,
-0.8394454717636108,
0.03792079538106918,
0.015560872852802277,
-0.31567758321762085,
0.3474971354007721,
-1.2060797214508057,
0.9075186252593994,
-0.5402788519859314,
-0.16976676881313324,
-0.3475635051727295,
-0.31756845116615295,
0.5180310010910034,
0.14907386898994446,
0.21077418327331543,
-0.3066389262676239,
-0.18746879696846008,
0.6901914477348328,
0.37797582149505615,
0.8325549960136414,
-0.140311598777771,
-0.4355357885360718,
0.33109381794929504,
-0.29337188601493835,
0.4981168210506439,
0.2027011662721634,
-0.19053985178470612,
0.1578013300895691,
-0.32940661907196045,
-0.32933077216148376,
-0.45421895384788513,
0.9972105026245117,
-0.5939865708351135,
-0.35084789991378784,
-0.19164477288722992,
-0.6168234348297119,
-0.12065832316875458,
0.20104658603668213,
-0.0550672709941864,
0.7152741551399231,
-0.40579307079315186,
0.3064326047897339,
1.2004612684249878,
-0.22926826775074005,
0.2986150085926056,
0.5667433142662048,
-0.00986175611615181,
0.041818439960479736,
0.7045342326164246,
0.03438848257064819,
0.36605262756347656,
0.4920233190059662,
-0.13665632903575897,
-0.7022179961204529,
-0.7648831605911255,
-0.7129819989204407,
0.35431960225105286,
-0.7557874917984009,
0.16360853612422943,
-0.8668347597122192,
-0.21719183027744293,
-0.5837054252624512,
0.06995484232902527,
-0.4522015154361725,
-0.21064506471157074,
-0.2646596133708954,
-0.016782334074378014,
-0.03868000954389572,
1.0047162771224976,
0.500580906867981,
0.4587884843349457,
-0.7732447385787964,
0.07619592547416687,
0.045385293662548065,
0.47537699341773987,
-0.12040609866380692,
-0.44388341903686523,
-0.19799841940402985,
0.07987477630376816,
0.07005081325769424,
-0.9236433506011963,
0.19099418818950653,
0.3919103145599365,
1.0930427312850952,
0.2528676688671112,
-0.3963518440723419,
0.6260300278663635,
-0.6691920161247253,
0.8005238771438599,
0.08992832899093628,
-0.933382511138916,
0.44492343068122864,
-0.12932704389095306,
0.2383364588022232,
0.4121234118938446,
0.3306051194667816,
-0.735766589641571,
-0.29279565811157227,
-0.6759293675422668,
-0.8869544863700867,
0.9194813370704651,
-0.1524832844734192,
0.028925178572535515,
0.21868537366390228,
0.2592439651489258,
0.09900270402431488,
0.09573578089475632,
-0.8767039775848389,
-0.47080522775650024,
0.3228321075439453,
-0.33478039503097534,
-0.26531341671943665,
-0.4670131802558899,
0.022317200899124146,
0.012171468697488308,
0.8337729573249817,
-0.15998432040214539,
0.32786616683006287,
-0.06839878857135773,
-0.5957018136978149,
0.036635614931583405,
0.7485610246658325,
0.8042284250259399,
0.9392218589782715,
0.11256284266710281,
0.16025568544864655,
0.24579499661922455,
-0.5905695557594299,
0.012606152333319187,
-0.055232882499694824,
-0.2812051475048065,
0.06379931420087814,
0.13029725849628448,
0.99718177318573,
0.5557279586791992,
-0.6725653409957886,
0.3125232756137848,
-0.2655937075614929,
0.16627083718776703,
-0.554541826248169,
0.08410362154245377,
0.23158346116542816,
0.17500171065330505,
0.07430344820022583,
-0.08408795297145844,
0.32689565420150757,
-0.48395010828971863,
0.11211728304624557,
0.5261217951774597,
-0.4451608657836914,
-0.2125704437494278,
0.17656908929347992,
0.3808177411556244,
-0.2650983929634094,
0.34347963333129883,
-0.17118887603282928,
-0.2755025625228882,
0.4637829661369324,
0.6610069274902344,
0.6331456303596497,
-0.29007023572921753,
0.2713513672351837,
0.14067675173282623,
0.4375821650028229,
-0.1018248051404953,
0.35627320408821106,
0.1996172070503235,
-0.9465885758399963,
-0.8238734006881714,
-0.4829883277416229,
-0.39733096957206726,
0.5878533720970154,
-0.5690783858299255,
0.1562359482049942,
-0.09723852574825287,
0.05714496597647667,
0.345684677362442,
-0.24727210402488708,
-0.5573999881744385,
-0.18487124145030975,
0.36700117588043213,
0.9389623403549194,
-0.8938644528388977,
0.8747289776802063,
0.9538842439651489,
0.13119331002235413,
-0.8625738620758057,
-0.1406022310256958,
-0.04911976307630539,
-0.7750710844993591,
0.2846897542476654,
0.21672551333904266,
-0.2673097550868988,
0.11080941557884216,
-0.4011663794517517,
-1.0379728078842163,
1.103569507598877,
0.09769844263792038,
-0.5950884819030762,
0.015705222263932228,
0.10215164721012115,
0.17053107917308807,
-0.6737952828407288,
0.5140405893325806,
0.8499507308006287,
0.38599643111228943,
-0.016836579889059067,
-0.8469362854957581,
-0.322143018245697,
0.014997015707194805,
-0.22510293126106262,
0.5111382007598877,
-0.5433518290519714,
0.5922551155090332,
-0.2836363911628723,
-0.21640616655349731,
-0.17470790445804596,
0.7780174612998962,
0.2816873788833618,
0.5714161992073059,
0.5524967312812805,
0.5754021406173706,
0.7189408540725708,
-0.19087530672550201,
0.7274985313415527,
-0.12427931278944016,
0.2314716875553131,
1.2108908891677856,
-0.6684363484382629,
0.9039261341094971,
0.49115797877311707,
-0.06307441741228104,
0.3260749280452728,
0.3936375677585602,
0.43934181332588196,
0.17275941371917725,
-0.10111706703901291,
-0.4949675500392914,
-0.29207849502563477,
-0.2075134813785553,
-0.09008646011352539,
0.579304039478302,
1.0499780178070068,
-0.2202172875404358,
-0.05321114510297775,
0.10141678154468536,
-0.2837862968444824,
-0.1322942078113556,
-0.320631742477417,
0.909575879573822,
0.21339765191078186,
-0.6072521805763245,
0.09937234967947006,
0.0793626606464386,
0.6483370065689087,
-0.5587329864501953,
0.06147770583629608,
0.16113723814487457,
0.19996558129787445,
-0.06592879444360733,
-1.232412338256836,
0.08717862516641617,
-0.23076996207237244,
-0.06010189279913902,
-0.21326151490211487,
1.0328155755996704,
-0.7540572285652161,
-0.23955431580543518,
0.21036939322948456,
0.5328357219696045,
0.3789338767528534,
0.26158571243286133,
-0.8358287215232849,
0.2599908709526062,
-0.06102418899536133,
0.01558728888630867,
0.12664245069026947,
0.43300163745880127,
-0.01474387850612402,
0.6280309557914734,
0.49481430649757385,
0.018102189525961876,
0.4012974798679352,
0.6650410294532776,
0.4932401478290558,
-0.5125489830970764,
-0.3536125123500824,
-0.671549916267395,
0.30061596632003784,
-0.20407642424106598,
-0.37889015674591064,
0.7212505340576172,
0.8038234114646912,
0.9232839345932007,
-0.06674467772245407,
0.6811257600784302,
0.09586123377084732,
0.27514705061912537,
-0.6877695918083191,
0.2398955374956131,
-0.32574278116226196,
0.4098980724811554,
0.022929035127162933,
-0.7072051763534546,
0.13717827200889587,
0.3602956533432007,
-0.4217161238193512,
-0.0568460077047348,
0.43568071722984314,
0.6895348429679871,
-0.2748866379261017,
0.30075985193252563,
0.24752311408519745,
0.10539852827787399,
0.31169378757476807,
0.6694322824478149,
1.1272773742675781,
-0.3781498968601227,
0.2798590362071991,
0.06117139756679535,
-0.2580946087837219,
-0.30331191420555115,
-0.42822059988975525,
-0.6321141719818115,
-0.3510008752346039,
-0.19609121978282928,
-0.049053940922021866,
-0.16385795176029205,
0.8112596273422241,
0.6349289417266846,
-0.5878656506538391,
-0.3918430805206299,
0.13208214938640594,
0.42964884638786316,
-0.22986337542533875,
-0.18040454387664795,
0.12371154874563217,
-0.3492030203342438,
-0.8229454755783081,
0.7253561019897461,
0.6273030042648315,
0.17687541246414185,
-0.46026355028152466,
-0.429291695356369,
-0.32851263880729675,
0.11458998918533325,
0.9769936203956604,
-0.01782493107020855,
-1.0310605764389038,
-0.048541951924562454,
0.316572904586792,
-0.21555408835411072,
-0.10484327375888824,
1.1359143257141113,
-0.25942039489746094,
0.10205734521150589,
0.37675657868385315,
0.633820116519928,
0.40111324191093445,
-0.27497002482414246,
0.36738330125808716,
-0.8242290616035461,
0.09837260097265244,
0.2322051078081131,
0.6454648971557617,
0.26535260677337646,
-0.5407924652099609,
0.31173428893089294,
-0.11869033426046371,
-0.4651254415512085,
-0.7642920613288879,
0.5122039318084717,
-1.3116363286972046,
-0.15875457227230072,
1.394288420677185,
-0.1791703701019287,
-0.36675548553466797,
-0.34921228885650635,
-0.1233363077044487,
0.13842681050300598,
-0.48083966970443726,
0.1916370689868927,
0.6288238763809204,
-0.23930983245372772,
-0.27977660298347473,
-0.6450086236000061,
0.10170923918485641,
0.3339126706123352,
-0.8683046698570251,
0.022995615378022194,
0.5151364803314209,
0.11717572808265686,
0.14502988755702972,
0.8238296508789062,
-0.08221616595983505,
0.2254936248064041,
-0.15337461233139038,
-0.03869667649269104,
0.09767767041921616,
-0.6843909621238708,
-0.26556944847106934,
-0.11476639658212662,
0.17955631017684937,
-0.17780636250972748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04460v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04460v4
|
Pearl: A Review-driven Persona-Knowledge Grounded Conversational Recommendation Dataset
| 2024-03-07T12:57:16 | 2024-06-08T17:40:14 |
Minjin Kim, Minju Kim, Hana Kim, Beong-woo Kwak, Soyeon Chun, Hyunseo Kim, SeongKu Kang, Youngjae Yu, Jinyoung Yeo, Dongha Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Conversational recommender system is an emerging area that has garnered an
increasing interest in the community, especially with the advancements in large
language models (LLMs) that enable diverse reasoning over conversational input.
Despite the progress, the field has many aspects left to explore. The currently
available public datasets for conversational recommendation lack specific user
preferences and explanations for recommendations, hindering high-quality
recommendations. To address such challenges, we present a novel conversational
recommendation dataset named PEARL, synthesized with persona- and
knowledge-augmented LLM simulators. We obtain detailed persona and knowledge
from real-world reviews and construct a large-scale dataset with over 57k
dialogues. Our experimental results demonstrate that utterances in PEARL
include more specific user preferences, show expertise in the target domain,
and provide recommendations more relevant to the dialogue context than those in
prior datasets.
|
[
-0.279665470123291,
-0.7838824987411499,
0.8118069767951965,
0.3815585970878601,
-0.1506083756685257,
0.27488377690315247,
-0.12346270680427551,
-0.1309741884469986,
0.5389187932014465,
0.7456364035606384,
-0.6055365800857544,
-0.6080779433250427,
-0.05209580436348915,
-0.29388517141342163,
-0.1311454325914383,
1.1285598278045654,
0.32221415638923645,
0.1334819197654724,
-0.4722309112548828,
0.05756200850009918,
-1.1149256229400635,
-0.5274540185928345,
-0.3654172122478485,
-0.349073588848114,
0.6003320217132568,
0.5703723430633545,
0.6638904809951782,
0.21413972973823547,
0.1414584070444107,
0.17805172502994537,
-0.08382536470890045,
0.3828272819519043,
-0.8662812113761902,
0.2728768289089203,
-0.27571630477905273,
-0.6467620134353638,
-0.601661741733551,
-0.1341690868139267,
0.20169872045516968,
0.8701086640357971,
0.025444764643907547,
0.008514721877872944,
0.12774495780467987,
0.6047878861427307,
-0.4565378725528717,
0.3592645227909088,
-0.5585274696350098,
0.15231338143348694,
-0.20295262336730957,
0.008238010108470917,
-0.44031837582588196,
-0.46616068482398987,
0.7338019013404846,
-0.8252426981925964,
-0.04580453783273697,
0.49933919310569763,
0.43940338492393494,
-0.3705649971961975,
-0.28673994541168213,
-0.026179403066635132,
-0.8099222779273987,
0.9602128267288208,
-0.34536030888557434,
0.3962932527065277,
0.5210174918174744,
0.4837152063846588,
-0.04902895539999008,
-0.15130750834941864,
-0.5408372282981873,
0.031798284500837326,
-0.11464053392410278,
0.1674381047487259,
0.13256840407848358,
-0.04558286443352699,
-0.10115795582532883,
0.7198774814605713,
-0.5038701295852661,
-0.2594642639160156,
-0.010049285367131233,
-0.22740335762500763,
0.5525170564651489,
0.31940603256225586,
0.2358042597770691,
-0.2254663109779358,
-0.22903147339820862,
0.030603507533669472,
-0.8613211512565613,
0.1973416805267334,
0.2677825689315796,
0.13667665421962738,
-0.3756435513496399,
0.5159477591514587,
-0.39229995012283325,
0.4844919443130493,
0.20504342019557953,
-0.34112778306007385,
0.23725555837154388,
0.0018191366689279675,
-0.2312486618757248,
0.02875656634569168,
0.7316464185714722,
0.8390194773674011,
0.44083911180496216,
-0.1558493822813034,
0.13360688090324402,
-0.06888789683580399,
0.1357656717300415,
-0.6336919665336609,
-0.6050494313240051,
0.21178655326366425,
-0.520101010799408,
-0.663720965385437,
0.054367002099752426,
-1.0127451419830322,
-0.7944580316543579,
-0.3836820125579834,
0.08261357247829437,
-0.26283514499664307,
-0.2510763108730316,
0.15541838109493256,
0.21068184077739716,
-0.08351901918649673,
0.5444734692573547,
-0.7755566239356995,
0.2010960876941681,
0.5446750521659851,
0.5568559765815735,
-0.36964166164398193,
-0.06295450031757355,
-0.27853602170944214,
0.022133994847536087,
-0.4929082989692688,
0.7234867811203003,
-0.9003729224205017,
-0.8282445669174194,
0.109073206782341,
-0.13763779401779175,
0.2601528465747833,
-0.43967846035957336,
0.4069032371044159,
-0.5641358494758606,
0.34908777475357056,
-0.7331894636154175,
-0.45926111936569214,
-0.3981245458126068,
0.4583292007446289,
-0.21205222606658936,
0.5215716361999512,
-0.026082521304488182,
-0.5041916370391846,
0.5082755088806152,
-0.49133092164993286,
-0.46131715178489685,
0.2697356343269348,
-0.22462984919548035,
-0.20061396062374115,
0.005759579129517078,
0.6866874098777771,
0.5952075123786926,
-0.39545175433158875,
0.7442361116409302,
-0.590421199798584,
-0.4007227122783661,
0.69312584400177,
-0.3632282018661499,
0.37412551045417786,
0.3120723068714142,
0.061305440962314606,
0.12743034958839417,
-0.7191324234008789,
-0.19342266023159027,
0.10166467726230621,
-0.20019447803497314,
-0.3018147051334381,
-0.06717897951602936,
0.0986451730132103,
-0.1946888417005539,
0.2274319976568222,
-0.6857691407203674,
0.23738287389278412,
-0.4953264892101288,
0.30286481976509094,
0.7715730667114258,
0.5361849665641785,
0.38992053270339966,
-0.6848796010017395,
0.39255014061927795,
0.2798217535018921,
-0.02904098853468895,
-0.7015575170516968,
-0.562791645526886,
-1.096444845199585,
0.0032163227442651987,
0.22915226221084595,
0.49113306403160095,
-0.5051764249801636,
0.5978692173957825,
-0.45393237471580505,
-0.37584948539733887,
-0.5678355097770691,
0.00970093160867691,
0.4838200807571411,
0.4977477490901947,
0.26144886016845703,
-0.29996272921562195,
-0.5189972519874573,
-1.031920075416565,
-0.15528374910354614,
-0.2012396901845932,
0.10569508373737335,
1.038501262664795,
0.016353635117411613,
-0.2802850008010864,
1.231469750404358,
-0.7957269549369812,
-0.31075519323349,
-0.5283326506614685,
-0.26830804347991943,
0.3949475586414337,
0.37743085622787476,
0.26437273621559143,
-0.4852752983570099,
-0.34345290064811707,
-0.10550689697265625,
-0.7494922876358032,
-0.0364692285656929,
-0.2860264182090759,
-0.326801061630249,
-0.6283535361289978,
0.12263844907283783,
-0.40981581807136536,
0.2514899671077728,
0.2755732834339142,
-0.1361772119998932,
0.36473166942596436,
-0.07242881506681442,
0.41114088892936707,
-1.3193849325180054,
-0.0894063413143158,
0.16594240069389343,
-0.3290580213069916,
-0.4513775408267975,
-0.16955846548080444,
-0.18421021103858948,
-0.49531084299087524,
-0.06208866462111473,
0.6145753264427185,
0.14023654162883759,
0.011675314977765083,
-0.10475233942270279,
0.1773468554019928,
0.29812732338905334,
0.7641509771347046,
0.21316955983638763,
0.7479783892631531,
0.7345854043960571,
-0.8073323965072632,
0.504706621170044,
0.8727040886878967,
-0.42218586802482605,
1.001017451286316,
-0.8737261891365051,
0.21246011555194855,
0.11197120696306229,
0.36642664670944214,
-0.9560514688491821,
-0.4538273811340332,
-0.019623298197984695,
-0.09203148633241653,
-0.16288502514362335,
-0.40604400634765625,
-0.24056868255138397,
-0.09127259254455566,
-0.17179523408412933,
0.39457520842552185,
0.5448516607284546,
-0.6212671995162964,
0.461980402469635,
0.6359159350395203,
-0.44385629892349243,
-0.02023177780210972,
-0.5560016632080078,
0.24218463897705078,
-0.18350982666015625,
-0.5046524405479431,
0.2718660831451416,
-0.47070005536079407,
-0.39657098054885864,
-0.45757174491882324,
0.2924189567565918,
0.17086760699748993,
-0.1819545030593872,
0.6957263946533203,
0.22218036651611328,
0.04493212699890137,
0.2838413715362549,
0.11755991727113724,
-0.08519294857978821,
0.03459309786558151,
-0.21454766392707825,
0.7590063810348511,
-0.10496746003627777,
-0.5923287272453308,
-0.6495391130447388,
-0.024736354127526283,
0.6844393014907837,
-0.08434004336595535,
0.2818540930747986,
0.3307373821735382,
-0.0023581681307405233,
-0.159859299659729,
-0.863161563873291,
-0.24034322798252106,
-0.4527983069419861,
0.16612395644187927,
-0.5069988369941711,
-0.7722399830818176,
0.4290742576122284,
-0.08039824664592743,
0.008676436729729176,
0.03553549200296402,
0.5507674813270569,
-0.1984327882528305,
0.9371545910835266,
0.28605371713638306,
-0.7222782373428345,
0.18195568025112152,
-0.03309671953320503,
0.45620250701904297,
-0.9419498443603516,
-0.3774513304233551,
0.028231250122189522,
-0.33932849764823914,
-0.18250565230846405,
-0.12937435507774353,
0.42684921622276306,
-0.22401131689548492,
-0.023113684728741646,
0.016956301406025887,
-0.1827174425125122,
0.48072800040245056,
0.5720410346984863,
0.47159543633461,
0.47243937849998474,
-0.06936739385128021,
-0.2315131425857544,
-0.30288106203079224,
-0.36541178822517395,
-0.3924712836742401,
1.4017727375030518,
0.4024205505847931,
0.7096715569496155,
-0.03044615313410759,
0.1440557837486267,
0.6196987628936768,
-0.1011902242898941,
-0.708255410194397,
0.6925992965698242,
0.18690665066242218,
-0.43797531723976135,
0.17570696771144867,
-0.22167888283729553,
-0.739077627658844,
-0.0721505880355835,
-0.4394412338733673,
-0.5466874241828918,
0.06640937179327011,
0.13328610360622406,
-0.5779242515563965,
0.10187754780054092,
-0.37278667092323303,
0.3585708737373352,
-0.09951227158308029,
-0.46420618891716003,
-0.4385761320590973,
-0.3343595266342163,
0.5591689348220825,
-0.14639782905578613,
0.24454304575920105,
-0.23567192256450653,
0.6735424995422363,
0.7025192975997925,
-0.6052387952804565,
0.7149507403373718,
-0.1651146411895752,
-0.08260234445333481,
0.2263353317975998,
0.6094644665718079,
0.4103318452835083,
0.6015759110450745,
0.03762965649366379,
-0.09144467860460281,
-0.3009665608406067,
-0.054767340421676636,
-0.41113683581352234,
1.095199704170227,
-0.7966463565826416,
-0.5984188914299011,
-0.15719202160835266,
-0.6010482311248779,
-0.7990984916687012,
0.006446413230150938,
0.046058569103479385,
0.622978150844574,
-0.35537660121917725,
0.3403095006942749,
1.0200480222702026,
-0.4620227813720703,
-0.10891509801149368,
0.47841066122055054,
-0.8719085454940796,
-0.6355600953102112,
1.039891004562378,
-0.2568371891975403,
-0.23706495761871338,
0.43058180809020996,
0.1748560518026352,
-0.19805918633937836,
-0.48987504839897156,
-0.5566645264625549,
0.13961541652679443,
-0.4880492091178894,
0.07703325152397156,
-0.7749703526496887,
0.15441343188285828,
-0.24670009315013885,
-0.23618903756141663,
-0.2670147716999054,
-0.12728078663349152,
-0.18027544021606445,
-0.250139981508255,
0.48021650314331055,
1.018432378768921,
0.6128841042518616,
0.38353297114372253,
-0.5441262722015381,
0.370272696018219,
0.7516392469406128,
0.5749235153198242,
-0.042841244488954544,
-0.37883615493774414,
-0.1700671911239624,
0.26057374477386475,
-0.22101640701293945,
-0.6529651284217834,
0.29241034388542175,
0.011528142727911472,
0.47839468717575073,
0.7965163588523865,
0.018078556284308434,
0.7877478003501892,
-0.0725460797548294,
1.1556414365768433,
0.008886278606951237,
-0.7619187235832214,
0.7978998422622681,
-0.8980260491371155,
0.1975547969341278,
0.7389119863510132,
-0.02351340278983116,
-0.6105367541313171,
-0.027416791766881943,
-0.44233888387680054,
-0.36004751920700073,
0.4234147071838379,
0.18580064177513123,
0.33637306094169617,
0.2603214979171753,
0.3558858633041382,
0.32666224241256714,
0.531497597694397,
-0.5754129886627197,
-0.11331506073474884,
-0.06325546652078629,
-0.11004968732595444,
-0.2170601636171341,
-0.5268348455429077,
-0.1380751132965088,
-0.02410423383116722,
0.8680223226547241,
-0.0365070216357708,
0.08275929093360901,
0.054081887006759644,
-0.2680813670158386,
-0.12626056373119354,
0.1700240969657898,
0.1852310448884964,
0.5765144228935242,
-0.27272507548332214,
-0.17134147882461548,
0.21941037476062775,
-0.2917849123477936,
-0.0473269559442997,
-0.27724969387054443,
-0.2059098333120346,
-0.28942036628723145,
-0.08455852419137955,
0.8372489809989929,
0.5625116229057312,
-0.7815878391265869,
0.6965485215187073,
-0.13577520847320557,
-0.013662696816027164,
-0.35335448384284973,
0.14276957511901855,
-0.04480096697807312,
0.002203576499596238,
0.15228162705898285,
0.2803663909435272,
0.15257929265499115,
-0.46461158990859985,
-0.11205637454986572,
0.29108867049217224,
-0.6043312549591064,
-0.37253689765930176,
0.49619701504707336,
0.6679003834724426,
-0.007430894300341606,
0.49435919523239136,
0.056478001177310944,
-0.20386335253715515,
-0.23727400600910187,
0.1313888132572174,
0.7062557339668274,
0.2095799744129181,
0.2047790139913559,
0.12196776270866394,
-0.33283916115760803,
0.03654966130852699,
0.07583405822515488,
-0.34024471044540405,
-0.8917974233627319,
-0.036295123398303986,
-0.6465622186660767,
-0.7339992523193359,
0.34937742352485657,
-0.5543886423110962,
0.42620235681533813,
-0.776317298412323,
-0.07524675875902176,
-0.3568573296070099,
-0.048550017178058624,
-0.5619258284568787,
0.2051267921924591,
-0.09241430461406708,
0.5009769797325134,
-0.8367310166358948,
0.5357905030250549,
0.39106884598731995,
-0.2576392590999603,
-0.5202605724334717,
-0.03685218468308449,
0.09451211243867874,
-0.7779529690742493,
0.25940603017807007,
0.03361842781305313,
0.006491799373179674,
-0.18896621465682983,
-0.21744263172149658,
-0.6374021768569946,
1.1035454273223877,
0.1640087515115738,
-0.7487267255783081,
0.29944390058517456,
0.16712941229343414,
0.4716695249080658,
-0.6208978295326233,
0.22847646474838257,
0.5071015357971191,
0.26061126589775085,
0.13722814619541168,
-0.882521390914917,
-0.39221206307411194,
-0.5436300039291382,
0.24550138413906097,
-0.33125102519989014,
-0.7244132161140442,
0.5767512917518616,
-0.00414244132116437,
0.30824974179267883,
0.242963045835495,
0.569520890712738,
0.7136012315750122,
0.26776036620140076,
0.38651469349861145,
0.6014863848686218,
0.6549251079559326,
-0.14498957991600037,
0.903368353843689,
-0.4474410116672516,
-0.059475433081388474,
1.106930136680603,
-0.6582034230232239,
0.6311057209968567,
-0.002762459684163332,
-0.3995085656642914,
0.9958253502845764,
0.6736301779747009,
-0.08424513041973114,
0.39465662837028503,
-0.04454484209418297,
-0.20943616330623627,
-0.5149266719818115,
-0.3443869650363922,
-0.37190380692481995,
0.2811298668384552,
0.30659687519073486,
-0.5017023682594299,
0.3207536041736603,
0.2337796539068222,
0.13386286795139313,
0.23413556814193726,
-0.34980618953704834,
1.1052336692810059,
-0.21973800659179688,
-0.7518433332443237,
0.03950902447104454,
-0.13983161747455597,
0.6372280716896057,
-0.5030451416969299,
-0.07274097949266434,
-0.3530293107032776,
0.12572677433490753,
-0.12747080624103546,
-0.7945147156715393,
-0.4070681929588318,
-0.04363482818007469,
-0.4086194932460785,
-0.44624075293540955,
0.9278375506401062,
-0.3674611449241638,
-0.492537260055542,
-0.25122570991516113,
0.6512788534164429,
0.19853264093399048,
-0.23442494869232178,
-0.30967575311660767,
-0.03340846300125122,
0.18552899360656738,
-0.13132336735725403,
0.20354165136814117,
0.14406424760818481,
0.17769969999790192,
0.8577853441238403,
0.8758994936943054,
0.1606593132019043,
-0.4753199815750122,
0.2039266973733902,
0.8724784851074219,
-0.4168347418308258,
-0.9780389666557312,
-0.5245154500007629,
0.5065513849258423,
-0.24140019714832306,
-0.3978760838508606,
1.03561270236969,
0.8470762372016907,
0.46515801548957825,
-0.13522693514823914,
1.1613909006118774,
0.4319479465484619,
1.0183042287826538,
-0.4634745419025421,
0.6626470685005188,
-0.014725173823535442,
0.7821519374847412,
-0.43181321024894714,
-0.9897943139076233,
-0.037388917058706284,
0.577596127986908,
-0.6559606194496155,
0.2397717833518982,
0.17685101926326752,
0.8355078101158142,
-0.11115424335002899,
0.5195465683937073,
0.3275150656700134,
0.1859208345413208,
0.530593752861023,
0.40644893050193787,
0.7655600905418396,
-0.31041866540908813,
0.26359161734580994,
-0.203062504529953,
0.014958356507122517,
-0.5550117492675781,
-0.6062804460525513,
-1.1929123401641846,
-0.5651988983154297,
-0.3103107810020447,
-0.295099139213562,
0.05784862861037254,
1.1361956596374512,
1.0704894065856934,
-0.9270496964454651,
-0.19520734250545502,
-0.4174211323261261,
-0.02313871867954731,
0.18621455132961273,
-0.2776525318622589,
0.07320145517587662,
-0.09502198547124863,
-0.48130881786346436,
0.8212946653366089,
0.3802996277809143,
0.1050259992480278,
-0.6837126016616821,
-0.20255813002586365,
0.28222131729125977,
0.15160144865512848,
0.5645673871040344,
-0.2103639841079712,
-0.6448724269866943,
-0.1247575506567955,
-0.09653235971927643,
0.23578251898288727,
0.06163617968559265,
1.0678062438964844,
-1.2203646898269653,
0.772241473197937,
0.21298861503601074,
0.36066266894340515,
0.5107200741767883,
0.005907649639993906,
0.9897245764732361,
-0.7686029672622681,
-0.13351169228553772,
0.11633015424013138,
0.5240678787231445,
0.2909732460975647,
-0.3893425762653351,
0.008832092396914959,
0.36091750860214233,
-0.521992564201355,
-0.5792624354362488,
0.31841275095939636,
-1.130997657775879,
0.037675511091947556,
1.2027961015701294,
-0.2593854069709778,
0.22078807651996613,
-0.40824514627456665,
-0.6711770296096802,
-0.37938228249549866,
-0.796491801738739,
0.7710824012756348,
0.6529268622398376,
0.07258101552724838,
-0.13181665539741516,
-0.061395104974508286,
0.4072439670562744,
0.2507930397987366,
-0.8786429166793823,
0.26518505811691284,
0.5142671465873718,
0.2976391911506653,
0.11167281121015549,
0.4510393738746643,
0.04280046746134758,
0.17672136425971985,
-0.2598390281200409,
-0.325574666261673,
-0.16246600449085236,
-0.44599586725234985,
-0.14025422930717468,
0.39764463901519775,
0.27050039172172546,
0.2136141061782837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04454v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04454v1
|
Low-Resource Court Judgment Summarization for Common Law Systems
| 2024-03-07T12:47:42 | 2024-03-07T12:47:42 |
Shuaiqi Liu, Jiannong Cao, Yicong Li, Ruosong Yang, Zhiyuan Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.7
|
Common law courts need to refer to similar precedents' judgments to inform
their current decisions. Generating high-quality summaries of court judgment
documents can facilitate legal practitioners to efficiently review previous
cases and assist the general public in accessing how the courts operate and how
the law is applied. Previous court judgment summarization research focuses on
civil law or a particular jurisdiction's judgments. However, judges can refer
to the judgments from all common law jurisdictions. Current summarization
datasets are insufficient to satisfy the demands of summarizing precedents
across multiple jurisdictions, especially when labeled data are scarce for many
jurisdictions. To address the lack of datasets, we present CLSum, the first
dataset for summarizing multi-jurisdictional common law court judgment
documents. Besides, this is the first court judgment summarization work
adopting large language models (LLMs) in data augmentation, summary generation,
and evaluation. Specifically, we design an LLM-based data augmentation method
incorporating legal knowledge. We also propose a legal knowledge enhanced
evaluation metric based on LLM to assess the quality of generated judgment
summaries. Our experimental results verify that the LLM-based summarization
methods can perform well in the few-shot and zero-shot settings. Our LLM-based
data augmentation method can mitigate the impact of low data resources.
Furthermore, we carry out comprehensive comparative experiments to find
essential model components and settings that are capable of enhancing
summarization performance.
|
[
-0.35419711470603943,
-0.4855071008205414,
0.7125316262245178,
0.008608336560428143,
-0.7955552935600281,
-0.3291594684123993,
-0.2707270085811615,
-0.31544649600982666,
0.431674599647522,
0.7979826927185059,
-0.07450658828020096,
-0.7025636434555054,
-0.47954726219177246,
-0.10287121683359146,
-0.4598839282989502,
0.9848277568817139,
0.32105472683906555,
0.14634719491004944,
-0.22848737239837646,
-0.3682749271392822,
-0.5056962966918945,
-0.6357833743095398,
0.07685421407222748,
-0.2033139318227768,
0.3628072440624237,
0.8865586519241333,
0.5580574870109558,
0.1411842256784439,
0.6214497685432434,
0.2399749755859375,
-0.3212191164493561,
0.23398910462856293,
-0.574897050857544,
-0.21216973662376404,
-0.08424688875675201,
-0.44874441623687744,
-0.7583211064338684,
-0.14582495391368866,
0.5005459785461426,
0.849174976348877,
-0.3022434115409851,
0.26839080452919006,
-0.15605026483535767,
0.9491751194000244,
-0.8730858564376831,
0.10382445901632309,
-0.6447394490242004,
0.23507969081401825,
-0.16579292714595795,
-0.2245585173368454,
-0.28593456745147705,
-0.7246095538139343,
0.06904478371143341,
-0.6400982141494751,
0.34381958842277527,
0.08954468369483948,
0.44617512822151184,
0.23640798032283783,
-0.6539735198020935,
-0.02308964729309082,
-0.5895662903785706,
0.6534727215766907,
-1.0513972043991089,
0.12229336053133011,
0.013792747631669044,
0.4684537649154663,
-0.028030987828969955,
-0.6360149383544922,
-0.4501248300075531,
-0.24726602435112,
-0.4623916447162628,
0.4380141794681549,
-0.07457545399665833,
0.10335986316204071,
0.26528987288475037,
0.3221092224121094,
-0.40960049629211426,
0.16618503630161285,
-0.5336534976959229,
-0.148491770029068,
0.6642693877220154,
0.4058869779109955,
0.05646231397986412,
-0.4490412175655365,
-0.27334102988243103,
0.015268274582922459,
-0.8206203579902649,
-0.02831743285059929,
0.11283867061138153,
0.43508443236351013,
-0.3005823493003845,
0.5532233119010925,
-0.4078894257545471,
0.7650142908096313,
-0.20411904156208038,
-0.387580931186676,
0.1314738243818283,
-0.49583739042282104,
-0.40192294120788574,
0.346388578414917,
0.6446592211723328,
0.9963663816452026,
0.1517944633960724,
0.27689456939697266,
-0.20782461762428284,
-0.3519657850265503,
-0.03868396580219269,
-0.7916507720947266,
0.1459452211856842,
0.018444404006004333,
-0.6035968065261841,
-0.2183878868818283,
0.2368304580450058,
-0.8273825645446777,
-0.8717041015625,
-0.6382032632827759,
-0.14709651470184326,
-0.09804277122020721,
0.1510016918182373,
0.2107332944869995,
-0.25601112842559814,
-0.09248458594083786,
0.7508500814437866,
-0.5459638833999634,
0.7316821217536926,
0.59075927734375,
0.675868809223175,
0.04603485390543938,
0.1457044780254364,
-0.5963059067726135,
0.14787830412387848,
-0.10334157198667526,
0.6529249548912048,
-0.16556911170482635,
-0.5610834956169128,
0.14372515678405762,
0.007240247447043657,
0.34589141607284546,
-0.5230457186698914,
0.7125216722488403,
-0.43816834688186646,
-0.08282959461212158,
-0.19872255623340607,
-0.5447784066200256,
-0.23193354904651642,
0.03954380378127098,
-0.8454416394233704,
0.2718845307826996,
-0.07262624800205231,
-0.8965258598327637,
0.7616201043128967,
-0.5820258855819702,
-0.8493849635124207,
0.17072218656539917,
-0.34713074564933777,
-0.39220184087753296,
0.4137226641178131,
0.2857508063316345,
0.42923828959465027,
-0.41233155131340027,
0.26642856001853943,
-0.19341975450515747,
-0.5564498901367188,
-0.2718343734741211,
-0.3863396942615509,
0.6377747058868408,
0.32870569825172424,
0.20681844651699066,
-0.0484343096613884,
-0.597917914390564,
-0.2689513564109802,
0.1899186372756958,
-0.3536587059497833,
-0.3784409165382385,
0.06436748802661896,
0.047172751277685165,
-0.010275842621922493,
0.46197837591171265,
-0.32919469475746155,
0.08287900686264038,
-0.5289598107337952,
-0.023582110181450844,
0.5312052965164185,
0.3799794614315033,
0.3534441292285919,
-0.5837280750274658,
0.3077760338783264,
0.2513635754585266,
0.008407373912632465,
-0.16732200980186462,
-0.17832055687904358,
-0.5399162173271179,
-0.007405235897749662,
0.4322219491004944,
0.46085211634635925,
-0.3934597671031952,
0.26116469502449036,
-0.8080968260765076,
-0.4760493338108063,
-0.18084849417209625,
0.09028661996126175,
0.15989713370800018,
0.4768511652946472,
0.23672331869602203,
-0.5152616500854492,
-0.737338662147522,
-1.0264389514923096,
-0.33421099185943604,
0.057460717856884,
0.1635611653327942,
0.6129758954048157,
0.46512192487716675,
0.42416125535964966,
0.9484990239143372,
-0.6479542851448059,
-0.3283654451370239,
-0.5046728253364563,
0.0020913369953632355,
0.7225260734558105,
0.019116273149847984,
0.7604097723960876,
-0.6624729633331299,
-0.3416097164154053,
0.10666817426681519,
-0.6487698554992676,
-0.005932339932769537,
-0.19902512431144714,
0.08829155564308167,
0.06798148155212402,
0.16627155244350433,
-0.1823517233133316,
0.578038215637207,
0.0824517011642456,
-0.3427864611148834,
0.5362727046012878,
-0.4235747456550598,
0.607591450214386,
-0.7166736721992493,
0.12400567531585693,
-0.04848790913820267,
-0.5538546442985535,
-0.5013424158096313,
-0.10200101137161255,
0.03928472846746445,
0.15341255068778992,
-0.7012040019035339,
0.4734111428260803,
-0.3017358183860779,
-0.38535603880882263,
-0.269209623336792,
0.5854451060295105,
0.06274715811014175,
0.2788504958152771,
0.07381793856620789,
0.4125523269176483,
0.0389457531273365,
-0.7227696776390076,
0.42987436056137085,
0.34191492199897766,
-0.5436983704566956,
0.6091463565826416,
-0.44438430666923523,
-0.22690998017787933,
-0.14251752197742462,
0.25484970211982727,
-0.2682154178619385,
-0.4661776125431061,
-0.03463778644800186,
0.03475663810968399,
0.1350172758102417,
-0.3936469256877899,
-0.7401129007339478,
-0.34030258655548096,
-0.2868078052997589,
0.23677031695842743,
0.5078706741333008,
-0.4298482835292816,
0.36551976203918457,
0.5667749643325806,
-0.32129359245300293,
-0.5782638788223267,
-0.7609589695930481,
0.18212436139583588,
-0.26978349685668945,
-0.45563533902168274,
0.17321503162384033,
0.05637851729989052,
-0.44574570655822754,
-0.14509548246860504,
0.036482930183410645,
-0.03706299141049385,
0.14134888350963593,
0.3035584092140198,
0.2459554523229599,
-0.07488511502742767,
0.2181200534105301,
0.15018616616725922,
0.24677567183971405,
0.014711175113916397,
0.1177554577589035,
0.3784284293651581,
0.14526604115962982,
-0.6744270920753479,
-0.2041817605495453,
0.3190947473049164,
0.39500248432159424,
0.04952791705727577,
0.199273481965065,
-0.21577125787734985,
-0.28926005959510803,
-0.07483070343732834,
-0.5101807117462158,
0.11700635403394699,
-0.3158629536628723,
0.13679182529449463,
-0.184771329164505,
-0.6727290153503418,
0.407671183347702,
-0.1304548680782318,
0.3580223023891449,
0.4859362542629242,
0.6844639182090759,
0.1435914784669876,
0.3472425937652588,
0.2966902554035187,
-0.49626636505126953,
0.4905474781990051,
0.02283787727355957,
0.09311474859714508,
-0.4412153363227844,
0.18129269778728485,
-0.3112051486968994,
-0.13881626725196838,
-0.3215530812740326,
-0.07370306551456451,
0.6100689172744751,
-0.017422305420041084,
-0.058012187480926514,
0.19130122661590576,
-0.3138757050037384,
0.6771582365036011,
0.6197760105133057,
0.332705557346344,
0.8277519345283508,
-0.10813747346401215,
-0.2073785364627838,
0.2295553833246231,
-0.635757327079773,
-0.5430664420127869,
1.2350081205368042,
-0.040555063635110855,
0.615729033946991,
0.28927871584892273,
1.0011674165725708,
0.6152597665786743,
0.16567863523960114,
-0.6270685791969299,
0.5837675333023071,
-0.4445701539516449,
-0.38181573152542114,
-0.11737263947725296,
-0.5721622705459595,
-0.7229025363922119,
0.2585518956184387,
-0.43716147541999817,
-0.41574424505233765,
0.22588661313056946,
0.09234532713890076,
-0.7431193590164185,
0.17130567133426666,
-0.5025970935821533,
0.27898818254470825,
-0.2015748769044876,
-0.3491123616695404,
-0.5784716606140137,
-0.6071836352348328,
0.9040905833244324,
-0.14648747444152832,
0.5203468203544617,
-0.01011811662465334,
0.24989674985408783,
0.512208104133606,
-0.8084461688995361,
0.7758997082710266,
-0.31653326749801636,
-0.03918091952800751,
0.5326018929481506,
0.05088473856449127,
0.3931921422481537,
0.10514567792415619,
-0.06428055465221405,
-0.21644693613052368,
0.01048979815095663,
-0.21417808532714844,
-0.6168299317359924,
0.6583096385002136,
-0.3281274437904358,
-0.4885141849517822,
-0.4251265525817871,
-0.4416905343532562,
-0.024905698373913765,
0.17105203866958618,
0.014700381085276604,
0.3667270839214325,
-0.43766188621520996,
0.04864121973514557,
0.19501936435699463,
-0.1962660849094391,
0.38036176562309265,
0.7645887136459351,
-0.03575700893998146,
-0.44915762543678284,
0.7070767283439636,
0.2580994665622711,
-0.05252651497721672,
0.020791450515389442,
0.04379584640264511,
-0.07682560384273529,
-0.5842847228050232,
-0.2053031027317047,
0.019695036113262177,
-0.9119441509246826,
-0.39518672227859497,
-0.18030782043933868,
-0.10970715433359146,
-0.4472220540046692,
-0.23588834702968597,
0.05002050846815109,
-0.8262642025947571,
0.030366217717528343,
-0.09634567052125931,
0.41636186838150024,
0.7667122483253479,
-0.14472264051437378,
0.3029209077358246,
-0.9811449646949768,
0.5332905054092407,
0.14897285401821136,
0.3296462595462799,
-0.015483756549656391,
-0.5542475581169128,
-0.35539883375167847,
-0.09137777239084244,
-0.11685407161712646,
-0.5554484128952026,
0.34193113446235657,
0.0073735397309064865,
0.5157492756843567,
0.4622889459133148,
0.29449209570884705,
0.7498040199279785,
-0.5679510235786438,
0.7921624779701233,
0.5373382568359375,
-0.6379180550575256,
0.6580142378807068,
-0.19125422835350037,
0.15666314959526062,
0.7745422124862671,
-0.273716002702713,
-0.40474775433540344,
-0.2498597800731659,
-0.5452809929847717,
-0.952632486820221,
0.7048296928405762,
0.02574899233877659,
0.03340049088001251,
0.1928456723690033,
0.24882522225379944,
0.1076480820775032,
0.281501829624176,
-0.29984715580940247,
-0.1165209412574768,
-0.08009674400091171,
-0.21002741158008575,
-0.07175192981958389,
-0.057529449462890625,
-0.3361984193325043,
-0.2941748797893524,
0.5057237148284912,
0.04175472632050514,
-0.2355419099330902,
0.15597249567508698,
-0.45237693190574646,
0.1307557076215744,
0.6408520936965942,
0.765100359916687,
0.5308574438095093,
-0.24129264056682587,
0.06936708092689514,
0.5101410746574402,
-0.3333341181278229,
0.009050714783370495,
0.03300178423523903,
-0.24736875295639038,
0.12393537163734436,
0.3629733622074127,
0.571248471736908,
0.39672333002090454,
-0.5627675652503967,
0.746127188205719,
-0.23535528779029846,
-0.18964777886867523,
-0.4826432466506958,
0.08583786338567734,
-0.16374479234218597,
0.1848698854446411,
0.14139622449874878,
0.09685583412647247,
0.476559042930603,
-0.4146290123462677,
0.32857781648635864,
0.13795384764671326,
-0.05239119753241539,
0.25981295108795166,
0.41700735688209534,
0.31879082322120667,
0.36007997393608093,
0.1992282271385193,
-0.11123469471931458,
-0.035468850284814835,
0.5650212168693542,
0.17484480142593384,
0.37728580832481384,
0.5498314499855042,
-0.28317344188690186,
0.48829978704452515,
0.013082314282655716,
-0.21849115192890167,
0.19382689893245697,
-0.18472136557102203,
-0.3441392779350281,
-0.38493120670318604,
-0.4504890739917755,
-0.5373697876930237,
-0.2655152380466461,
-0.5968740582466125,
0.5370379686355591,
-0.5740023851394653,
-0.2213928997516632,
-0.40092650055885315,
0.05389295890927315,
-0.7804649472236633,
0.1577187329530716,
0.2191159427165985,
0.8944409489631653,
-0.6561395525932312,
0.36911794543266296,
0.278333455324173,
-0.6436188220977783,
-0.27493616938591003,
-0.25178852677345276,
0.1876806765794754,
-0.5957520008087158,
0.4846501350402832,
-0.1993587464094162,
-0.21297207474708557,
-0.3600020110607147,
-0.6168622374534607,
-0.29219499230384827,
1.3731311559677124,
0.20069484412670135,
-0.9582254886627197,
0.0671406239271164,
0.24479471147060394,
0.41351255774497986,
-0.3752504289150238,
0.299719899892807,
0.6895530223846436,
0.6316346526145935,
0.10881723463535309,
-0.7915213108062744,
0.12585514783859253,
-0.1528812199831009,
-0.22406655550003052,
0.06454937160015106,
-0.5556715130805969,
0.5493109226226807,
-0.40106865763664246,
-0.30023670196533203,
-0.016173841431736946,
0.5592089295387268,
0.524186372756958,
0.4707975685596466,
0.4265458285808563,
0.7117121815681458,
0.7955605387687683,
-0.1688307374715805,
1.1067770719528198,
-0.6491122841835022,
0.23680423200130463,
1.7005863189697266,
-0.36529770493507385,
0.5876472592353821,
0.28736206889152527,
-0.04363605007529259,
0.21332482993602753,
0.18999004364013672,
-0.25494471192359924,
0.30780091881752014,
0.4187809228897095,
-0.2753952443599701,
-0.32246965169906616,
-0.34927061200141907,
-0.14534059166908264,
0.3017241358757019,
0.1294669210910797,
-0.5041199326515198,
-0.5882404446601868,
-0.4868203401565552,
-0.10556124150753021,
0.3201560378074646,
-0.5197626352310181,
1.032414436340332,
0.25201547145843506,
-0.2967711389064789,
0.22569496929645538,
-0.09839394688606262,
0.4545736312866211,
-0.23225343227386475,
-0.20121170580387115,
-0.3832654058933258,
-0.13570837676525116,
-0.4878833293914795,
-0.7377921938896179,
-0.07889942824840546,
0.3342949450016022,
-0.22700779139995575,
0.06903084367513657,
0.5487069487571716,
-0.024267664179205894,
-0.5155892968177795,
0.25948861241340637,
0.5616739988327026,
0.38780078291893005,
0.23067070543766022,
-0.1773526817560196,
-0.4406430125236511,
-0.34493979811668396,
-0.1346966177225113,
0.26478874683380127,
0.5956839919090271,
-0.11882521212100983,
0.4031029939651489,
0.446174681186676,
0.5489475727081299,
-0.0831177681684494,
0.8210424184799194,
0.9483323693275452,
-0.8509725332260132,
-0.4687047600746155,
-0.6296759843826294,
0.7109087109565735,
-0.458224892616272,
-0.06857293844223022,
0.3809475898742676,
0.7918875217437744,
0.3390007019042969,
0.028257595375180244,
1.0651873350143433,
-0.010317143984138966,
0.7739494442939758,
-0.7220876812934875,
0.760600745677948,
-0.5360212326049805,
0.32649675011634827,
-0.12335390597581863,
-0.7165799736976624,
-0.37818530201911926,
0.059322115033864975,
-0.317338764667511,
-0.1708577424287796,
0.42738789319992065,
0.5788410305976868,
-0.2545244097709656,
-0.1130017638206482,
0.5878121852874756,
0.07675282657146454,
-0.023182757198810577,
0.7201218605041504,
0.5247991681098938,
-0.2351064532995224,
0.4199160039424896,
-0.03643631190061569,
0.01813528873026371,
-0.6181187033653259,
-0.6963726878166199,
-0.6199820637702942,
-0.011513132601976395,
0.2332027703523636,
-0.0006054809200577438,
-0.1033022403717041,
0.9383589029312134,
0.3869129717350006,
-0.939230740070343,
-0.2492097020149231,
-0.05705563351511955,
0.14646638929843903,
0.2038850337266922,
-0.22161079943180084,
0.36452242732048035,
-0.3170146644115448,
-0.48343363404273987,
0.45683595538139343,
0.025070147588849068,
0.030240977182984352,
0.11371748894453049,
-0.09988261014223099,
-0.019301073625683784,
0.041958846151828766,
0.5544787049293518,
-0.02377251721918583,
-0.6505472660064697,
-0.1907503604888916,
-0.5485740900039673,
-0.19388489425182343,
0.244085893034935,
0.9521383047103882,
-0.6163892149925232,
0.3888859152793884,
0.5437374711036682,
0.21626199781894684,
0.4596283733844757,
0.3238257169723511,
0.6116346120834351,
-0.8153364062309265,
0.15332366526126862,
0.21237729489803314,
0.9979485869407654,
0.017762821167707443,
-0.17347155511379242,
0.5329614281654358,
-0.012206131592392921,
-0.37014463543891907,
-0.43538331985473633,
0.09433477371931076,
-1.0701619386672974,
-0.2100648432970047,
0.7910387516021729,
-0.19057580828666687,
-0.019101327285170555,
-0.08498221635818481,
-0.20643404126167297,
0.25682947039604187,
-0.6381300687789917,
0.61298668384552,
0.634332001209259,
0.01985027641057968,
-0.04273784160614014,
-0.5589767694473267,
0.2938975393772125,
0.18485479056835175,
-0.9874963760375977,
0.24771662056446075,
1.0634642839431763,
0.2498519867658615,
0.11513963341712952,
0.6214842200279236,
-0.3663535714149475,
0.3566170632839203,
-0.11313246190547943,
0.17750021815299988,
-0.06069768965244293,
-0.06487032026052475,
-0.4798848330974579,
0.3247782588005066,
-0.143732950091362,
0.27688249945640564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04451v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04451v1
|
Membership Inference Attacks and Privacy in Topic Modeling
| 2024-03-07T12:43:42 | 2024-03-07T12:43:42 |
Nico Manzonelli, Wanrong Zhang, Salil Vadhan
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent research shows that large language models are susceptible to privacy
attacks that infer aspects of the training data. However, it is unclear if
simpler generative models, like topic models, share similar vulnerabilities. In
this work, we propose an attack against topic models that can confidently
identify members of the training data in Latent Dirichlet Allocation. Our
results suggest that the privacy risks associated with generative modeling are
not restricted to large neural models. Additionally, to mitigate these
vulnerabilities, we explore differentially private (DP) topic modeling. We
propose a framework for private topic modeling that incorporates DP vocabulary
selection as a pre-processing step, and show that it improves privacy while
having limited effects on practical utility.
|
[
-0.25991374254226685,
-0.639541506767273,
0.45733577013015747,
-0.09886160492897034,
-0.15530934929847717,
0.10107147693634033,
0.30655428767204285,
-0.2723143696784973,
0.11543525755405426,
0.635123074054718,
-0.4894755482673645,
-0.5517364144325256,
-0.7561219930648804,
-0.3749683201313019,
-0.6852055788040161,
0.7176275849342346,
0.575563371181488,
0.10211355984210968,
-0.19277670979499817,
0.060503434389829636,
-0.07346849143505096,
-1.0447006225585938,
-0.3750874400138855,
0.02186664566397667,
0.7568687200546265,
-0.12886735796928406,
0.7208257913589478,
0.3416414260864258,
0.3887481689453125,
0.4081622064113617,
-0.3607119917869568,
-0.4862864911556244,
-0.5371294021606445,
0.30456453561782837,
-0.23532430827617645,
-0.7698372602462769,
-0.7203232049942017,
0.16834184527397156,
0.6219546794891357,
0.9069690704345703,
-0.0015422999858856201,
-0.23538272082805634,
0.056208737194538116,
0.5473330020904541,
-0.652406632900238,
-0.1841011494398117,
-0.8322170972824097,
0.2621878683567047,
-0.29106462001800537,
0.04056716337800026,
-0.4070548117160797,
-0.14905042946338654,
0.4286949038505554,
0.023708000779151917,
0.6353710293769836,
-0.24965958297252655,
0.7132006883621216,
0.1284428834915161,
-0.26608914136886597,
0.12571701407432556,
-0.46694809198379517,
0.534887433052063,
-0.5629165768623352,
0.333964467048645,
0.8397060632705688,
0.15953262150287628,
-0.16090241074562073,
-0.5281347036361694,
-0.48252636194229126,
-0.3468652367591858,
-0.25593259930610657,
-0.03418745473027229,
-0.3085672855377197,
0.2658878266811371,
0.3107260465621948,
0.6530650854110718,
-0.5179308652877808,
0.5058209300041199,
-0.2783149480819702,
0.06237452104687691,
0.8027763366699219,
0.025104498490691185,
0.28270941972732544,
-0.32428252696990967,
-0.29529398679733276,
0.0461384616792202,
-0.684989869594574,
-0.38992729783058167,
0.9660853147506714,
0.07613594830036163,
-0.4270763397216797,
0.7214661240577698,
-0.019657567143440247,
0.47746309638023376,
-0.13052961230278015,
0.26402395963668823,
-0.22255179286003113,
0.07030706107616425,
-0.2504017949104309,
-0.026737604290246964,
0.5706560015678406,
0.13289570808410645,
-0.14826397597789764,
-0.6152155995368958,
-0.043467696756124496,
0.10182712972164154,
0.259457528591156,
-0.6928470134735107,
-0.4351208209991455,
0.5288709402084351,
-0.4191681742668152,
-0.5783251523971558,
0.28825801610946655,
-1.051438570022583,
-0.6660143136978149,
0.13769544661045074,
0.2665337920188904,
-0.016097528859972954,
-0.3736438751220703,
0.04835925251245499,
-0.16791585087776184,
-0.07553704082965851,
0.28806769847869873,
-0.9972680807113647,
0.47086745500564575,
1.050567388534546,
0.8538051843643188,
-0.24241074919700623,
-0.13012409210205078,
-0.3111352324485779,
0.26160067319869995,
-0.4191766679286957,
0.3373456597328186,
-0.44204646348953247,
-0.895577609539032,
-0.2600246071815491,
0.04025023430585861,
0.010791398584842682,
-0.2498319447040558,
-0.17446932196617126,
-1.0105395317077637,
0.39258435368537903,
-0.1696258932352066,
-0.7119823694229126,
0.09861977398395538,
0.08692224323749542,
-0.7102324366569519,
0.2980767786502838,
0.043289560824632645,
-1.2799471616744995,
0.07102350145578384,
-0.5576350688934326,
-0.023156501352787018,
-0.0991298109292984,
-0.4383060336112976,
-0.5166560411453247,
0.3551093637943268,
-0.13285979628562927,
0.6825748682022095,
0.06603434681892395,
0.2050742655992508,
-0.474539190530777,
-0.09994055330753326,
0.6421412825584412,
-0.6497436165809631,
0.9037454724311829,
0.32082632184028625,
-0.3553195595741272,
0.25289618968963623,
-0.6785379648208618,
-0.3664592504501343,
0.12809324264526367,
0.20211949944496155,
-0.6235244870185852,
0.10152331739664078,
-0.5637405514717102,
-0.16398367285728455,
0.2185409814119339,
-0.3025444447994232,
0.13921362161636353,
-0.6403943300247192,
0.401998370885849,
1.1750143766403198,
0.30280473828315735,
0.6751464605331421,
-0.11842157691717148,
0.5852898359298706,
0.13426420092582703,
0.08493395149707794,
0.2209741771221161,
-0.6103564500808716,
-0.3579614758491516,
-0.5303909182548523,
0.7903710603713989,
0.32322031259536743,
-0.42481788992881775,
0.711911678314209,
0.012578579597175121,
-0.5486005544662476,
0.16123127937316895,
-0.4154301583766937,
0.29449471831321716,
0.23698394000530243,
-0.1092066615819931,
-0.42384785413742065,
0.17732706665992737,
-0.7409810423851013,
0.0012015316169708967,
-0.14725346863269806,
-0.14484110474586487,
0.3417123556137085,
0.36486855149269104,
-0.008376930840313435,
0.7735884189605713,
-0.8673771619796753,
-0.09380771964788437,
0.040604956448078156,
0.06674227863550186,
-0.07556027173995972,
0.8424915075302124,
0.8395428657531738,
-1.0800738334655762,
-0.3019335865974426,
-0.3780827224254608,
-0.6530593633651733,
0.20703022181987762,
-0.050199080258607864,
-0.28484347462654114,
-0.2198716402053833,
0.2619277834892273,
-0.687706470489502,
0.9047300219535828,
0.667829692363739,
-0.47230130434036255,
0.17338323593139648,
-0.3258456587791443,
-0.2013353854417801,
-1.2771109342575073,
-0.17270445823669434,
-0.06035982817411423,
-0.3606876730918884,
-0.5585350394248962,
0.35785284638404846,
-0.18305209279060364,
-0.7405766248703003,
-0.3993309438228607,
0.4731895327568054,
-0.3502171039581299,
-0.2269630879163742,
-0.3933245539665222,
-0.3609336316585541,
-0.015437993220984936,
0.34619635343551636,
0.24658553302288055,
0.7302210927009583,
1.0500500202178955,
-0.7101407051086426,
0.06823348253965378,
0.3670507073402405,
-0.20204071700572968,
0.12006904184818268,
-0.7432103157043457,
0.4767642021179199,
-0.25987914204597473,
0.14094123244285583,
-0.8876802325248718,
-0.41090846061706543,
0.5382291674613953,
-0.5070667266845703,
0.7632406949996948,
-0.5140582323074341,
-0.30083364248275757,
0.18339519202709198,
-0.33164867758750916,
0.08914129436016083,
0.3830859363079071,
-0.5236650705337524,
0.37849488854408264,
0.6936420202255249,
-0.30591559410095215,
-0.818975567817688,
-0.7020942568778992,
0.046018391847610474,
-0.5357652902603149,
-0.33980968594551086,
0.6750738024711609,
0.04303540289402008,
-0.33227914571762085,
0.1217745766043663,
-0.2626076638698578,
-0.5353649258613586,
0.6840713024139404,
0.5111733078956604,
0.09933380782604218,
0.059633493423461914,
-0.11263719946146011,
0.07083592563867569,
-0.29616019129753113,
0.04190119728446007,
0.05418038368225098,
0.6633867025375366,
0.24200722575187683,
-0.6252955198287964,
-0.653812050819397,
0.7664750218391418,
0.22345960140228271,
-0.49413833022117615,
0.9997623562812805,
-0.07972471415996552,
-0.5306137800216675,
-0.16740284860134125,
-0.17568214237689972,
-0.6372647285461426,
-0.5265761613845825,
0.6053780317306519,
-0.14111551642417908,
-0.8573927879333496,
0.5026888847351074,
0.15416909754276276,
0.049135368317365646,
0.12897391617298126,
0.3973304331302643,
0.12554055452346802,
0.7869962453842163,
0.8501812219619751,
-0.24999737739562988,
0.49307185411453247,
-0.3481670022010803,
0.26067110896110535,
-0.37138065695762634,
-0.11930976063013077,
-0.8152180910110474,
-0.19520103931427002,
-1.0007705688476562,
-0.406211793422699,
0.03118719533085823,
0.20038250088691711,
0.19328980147838593,
0.3065943419933319,
-0.4981674253940582,
0.45510703325271606,
0.4531538486480713,
0.21213607490062714,
0.11078579723834991,
0.3703209161758423,
0.22290630638599396,
-0.1374688446521759,
-0.511240541934967,
-0.4965541362762451,
0.9605008959770203,
0.6760607361793518,
1.0579452514648438,
0.38960984349250793,
1.0577527284622192,
0.3299083113670349,
0.23346570134162903,
-0.4681471288204193,
0.6368597745895386,
-0.38100117444992065,
-0.9108322262763977,
-0.2793891429901123,
-0.5917559266090393,
-0.7901514172554016,
0.418662965297699,
0.06975026428699493,
-1.2764712572097778,
0.8184539675712585,
0.016125690191984177,
-0.3826342225074768,
0.4651990830898285,
-0.6093591451644897,
0.8068806529045105,
-0.17121082544326782,
-0.5094893574714661,
-0.29649510979652405,
-0.5412864685058594,
0.2348516434431076,
-0.3318924307823181,
-0.15372946858406067,
-0.2357930690050125,
0.10140279680490494,
0.6312708258628845,
-0.4475778639316559,
1.2462126016616821,
-0.336794912815094,
-0.01947716996073723,
0.06519252061843872,
0.14948806166648865,
0.11301092803478241,
0.6435788869857788,
-0.20941273868083954,
0.6328317523002625,
-0.0957961454987526,
-0.4396885931491852,
-0.43835657835006714,
0.7722398042678833,
-0.8808757066726685,
-1.1375892162322998,
-0.8268663287162781,
-0.14113357663154602,
-0.18929457664489746,
0.01529383659362793,
0.32035186886787415,
0.12799227237701416,
-0.13712328672409058,
0.3724058270454407,
0.653307318687439,
-0.5381267666816711,
0.32554811239242554,
0.4972664713859558,
-0.066071055829525,
-0.13626930117607117,
0.8483314514160156,
0.05918393284082413,
0.1964820921421051,
0.3326546251773834,
0.23909752070903778,
-0.38079512119293213,
-0.8210047483444214,
-0.04027198627591133,
0.0723363384604454,
-0.5775524973869324,
-0.006491009145975113,
-1.0022881031036377,
-0.3239254355430603,
-0.419348806142807,
0.21010753512382507,
-0.5979015231132507,
-0.580336332321167,
-0.4851795732975006,
-0.28551703691482544,
0.2690992057323456,
0.3123944401741028,
-0.16590380668640137,
0.5557785034179688,
-0.6803800463676453,
0.43139487504959106,
0.5126698613166809,
0.2856195569038391,
-0.03944772481918335,
-0.3630918562412262,
0.41009441018104553,
-0.18711498379707336,
-0.3916802704334259,
-1.2625890970230103,
0.33618009090423584,
-0.043281640857458115,
0.6078547239303589,
0.4211598336696625,
0.2525407373905182,
0.13421253859996796,
-0.523910403251648,
0.9295260310173035,
0.11134883016347885,
-0.9256079792976379,
0.4435518682003021,
-0.27069172263145447,
-0.45175987482070923,
0.41925692558288574,
0.705721914768219,
0.06568247079849243,
-0.2601862847805023,
-0.958605945110321,
-0.6657739877700806,
0.6773014068603516,
0.4528437554836273,
0.7558932900428772,
0.0547577366232872,
0.5751519203186035,
0.12116105854511261,
0.5548661947250366,
-0.8555178642272949,
-0.49707478284835815,
-0.24875517189502716,
0.2734169065952301,
0.02062251605093479,
-0.5218808650970459,
-0.2529783844947815,
-0.1311986893415451,
0.3845759928226471,
0.1425376534461975,
0.42528629302978516,
0.012787064537405968,
0.40195560455322266,
0.16535624861717224,
0.06211578845977783,
0.31070321798324585,
0.845629870891571,
-0.16111527383327484,
0.02405623160302639,
-0.2695014476776123,
-0.22756433486938477,
0.26928991079330444,
0.5202230215072632,
-0.1972825974225998,
0.1876119077205658,
0.09935949742794037,
0.5645341873168945,
-0.11868580430746078,
-0.022991973906755447,
0.6694959998130798,
-0.3183884024620056,
-0.21399609744548798,
-0.29924583435058594,
0.2820570468902588,
0.18254482746124268,
0.13155022263526917,
-0.006759421434253454,
-0.09568081796169281,
0.0483289435505867,
-0.2917232811450958,
0.3953368067741394,
0.44292473793029785,
-0.5075180530548096,
-0.382671058177948,
0.9311795234680176,
-0.012678536586463451,
-0.22333964705467224,
0.4671711325645447,
0.13679683208465576,
-0.473091185092926,
0.6647389531135559,
0.1780344545841217,
0.8157855868339539,
-0.6014918088912964,
0.34435921907424927,
-0.1286344826221466,
0.006166951265186071,
0.20949260890483856,
0.10185625404119492,
-0.12457243353128433,
-0.6635108590126038,
-0.10802406072616577,
-0.587058424949646,
-0.48790979385375977,
0.5178543329238892,
-0.7602284550666809,
-0.09735109657049179,
-0.6502910852432251,
-0.37084540724754333,
0.25844815373420715,
-0.14356808364391327,
-0.17715923488140106,
0.2666251063346863,
0.11285517364740372,
0.46083515882492065,
-0.5151111483573914,
1.0938079357147217,
0.35021263360977173,
-0.13410262763500214,
-0.38636043667793274,
0.4824941158294678,
-0.17808806896209717,
-0.21103036403656006,
0.8914841413497925,
0.04061324521899223,
0.2467237263917923,
-0.22921928763389587,
-0.3215963840484619,
-0.5041584372520447,
0.6588872075080872,
0.5701488256454468,
-0.7552162408828735,
-0.24289138615131378,
0.27486082911491394,
0.40172719955444336,
0.17621687054634094,
-0.4493054747581482,
-0.12623801827430725,
-0.04527362436056137,
-0.08386580646038055,
-0.3576076924800873,
-0.20502892136573792,
0.21012897789478302,
-0.06257779151201248,
-0.11532081663608551,
-0.5987004041671753,
1.1698501110076904,
0.123793825507164,
-0.10250548273324966,
0.11909963935613632,
0.9170049428939819,
0.18256869912147522,
0.338504433631897,
0.6018732786178589,
0.27734628319740295,
0.7376545667648315,
0.14286909997463226,
1.1631011962890625,
-0.2972692549228668,
0.30754193663597107,
1.1408765316009521,
-0.5065734386444092,
0.40448111295700073,
0.2847517132759094,
-0.18797822296619415,
-0.03022196888923645,
0.8443763852119446,
-0.042251743376255035,
1.075210690498352,
0.46526652574539185,
-0.47722887992858887,
0.018085908144712448,
0.17562560737133026,
-0.8803936839103699,
0.5556703209877014,
0.35327014327049255,
-0.4984510838985443,
-0.18507282435894012,
-0.27126258611679077,
-0.03959639370441437,
0.12159673869609833,
0.05962185934185982,
0.8550950288772583,
0.4090765118598938,
-0.11017364263534546,
0.017833778634667397,
0.43968310952186584,
0.5194159746170044,
-0.8273383378982544,
0.025983843952417374,
-0.26121774315834045,
0.09854130446910858,
-0.05465153977274895,
-0.1982855498790741,
0.45954227447509766,
0.14641019701957703,
-0.0034833806566894054,
0.05057869106531143,
0.6939019560813904,
-0.08888055384159088,
-0.3153572380542755,
0.22692151367664337,
0.49913159012794495,
-0.013288292102515697,
-0.264906644821167,
-0.8815439343452454,
-0.2828060984611511,
-0.15560993552207947,
-0.5027240514755249,
0.7811170220375061,
0.2563169002532959,
-0.1510579138994217,
0.32176676392555237,
0.5067564249038696,
0.16195692121982574,
-0.09522595256567001,
0.11262115091085434,
1.0885741710662842,
-0.3187425434589386,
-1.0584063529968262,
-1.1092473268508911,
0.13703958690166473,
-0.27054792642593384,
-0.03198603540658951,
0.8247098922729492,
0.4260252118110657,
0.8625932931900024,
-0.0562325045466423,
0.6297804117202759,
0.17856255173683167,
0.44756370782852173,
-0.6454353332519531,
1.3666025400161743,
-0.5062959790229797,
0.6232824325561523,
-0.3287583291530609,
-0.7987119555473328,
-0.20630116760730743,
0.7651363015174866,
-0.6252146363258362,
0.13352909684181213,
0.2746031880378723,
0.8791149854660034,
-0.15256863832473755,
0.2998276948928833,
0.4989451467990875,
-0.018411699682474136,
0.5530387163162231,
-0.05987824872136116,
1.1890549659729004,
-0.10311905294656754,
-0.3649665117263794,
-0.8621039390563965,
-0.12112768739461899,
0.14486606419086456,
-0.9990962743759155,
-1.2600356340408325,
-0.37600937485694885,
-0.6342257261276245,
-0.3289489448070526,
0.08501116186380386,
0.33431917428970337,
1.0373916625976562,
-0.7492321729660034,
-0.003647424280643463,
-0.22721584141254425,
0.2052518129348755,
0.2420019805431366,
-0.20804330706596375,
0.671430230140686,
0.2599148154258728,
-0.7609365582466125,
0.4483945965766907,
-0.09539312869310379,
0.4319591522216797,
-0.5578283071517944,
0.3055848479270935,
0.010011349804699421,
-0.05157988518476486,
-0.008979630656540394,
0.020910954102873802,
-0.495677649974823,
-0.1306680291891098,
-0.3824251592159271,
-0.09849055111408234,
-0.03663543611764908,
1.024711012840271,
-0.15803846716880798,
0.16322943568229675,
0.30269405245780945,
0.8950112462043762,
0.4366530478000641,
0.13420185446739197,
0.5872676968574524,
-1.0789358615875244,
0.8554418683052063,
0.5117570161819458,
0.17936944961547852,
0.32899031043052673,
-0.9596548080444336,
0.3384603261947632,
0.21066804230213165,
-0.31117695569992065,
-1.0293819904327393,
0.36320286989212036,
-0.5828518271446228,
-0.6832247972488403,
0.551281213760376,
-0.7320585250854492,
-0.326640248298645,
0.003995929844677448,
0.0924905464053154,
0.07039301097393036,
-0.1684749871492386,
1.0164830684661865,
0.3979150056838989,
0.23175518214702606,
0.06473854929208755,
-0.6568082571029663,
0.5502315759658813,
0.36428263783454895,
-0.707267165184021,
0.13060477375984192,
0.3127543330192566,
0.33219608664512634,
-0.0016958632040768862,
0.5609262585639954,
-0.39603525400161743,
0.04371166229248047,
0.040435243397951126,
-0.5826175212860107,
-0.04366554692387581,
-0.4914310574531555,
-0.45564430952072144,
0.42829328775405884,
0.07941494137048721,
-0.4346393942832947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04445v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04445v1
|
Classist Tools: Social Class Correlates with Performance in NLP
| 2024-03-07T12:27:08 | 2024-03-07T12:27:08 |
Amanda Cercas Curry, Giuseppe Attanasio, Zeerak Talat, Dirk Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Since the foundational work of William Labov on the social stratification of
language (Labov, 1964), linguistics has made concentrated efforts to explore
the links between sociodemographic characteristics and language production and
perception. But while there is strong evidence for socio-demographic
characteristics in language, they are infrequently used in Natural Language
Processing (NLP). Age and gender are somewhat well represented, but Labov's
original target, socioeconomic status, is noticeably absent. And yet it
matters. We show empirically that NLP disadvantages less-privileged
socioeconomic groups. We annotate a corpus of 95K utterances from movies with
social class, ethnicity and geographical language variety and measure the
performance of NLP systems on three tasks: language modelling, automatic speech
recognition, and grammar error correction. We find significant performance
disparities that can be attributed to socioeconomic status as well as ethnicity
and geographical differences. With NLP technologies becoming ever more
ubiquitous and quotidian, they must accommodate all language varieties to avoid
disadvantaging already marginalised groups. We argue for the inclusion of
socioeconomic class in future language technologies.
|
[
-0.202103391289711,
-0.4461928904056549,
0.1663200855255127,
0.1664077192544937,
0.005394522566348314,
0.8553490042686462,
-0.250110000371933,
-0.6215876340866089,
0.2926831543445587,
0.2486768513917923,
0.1027524322271347,
-0.5308893918991089,
-0.7062758207321167,
-0.02326231077313423,
-0.48189762234687805,
0.6647648811340332,
0.4631035625934601,
-0.09529810398817062,
-0.37151071429252625,
-0.07319243997335434,
-0.037573982030153275,
-0.8802849054336548,
-0.588690996170044,
-0.3359936773777008,
0.3808296024799347,
0.48051369190216064,
1.0220130681991577,
0.6366325616836548,
0.21532519161701202,
0.3404844105243683,
-0.35623204708099365,
-0.21141430735588074,
-0.12318829447031021,
-0.01769554801285267,
-0.10819133371114731,
-0.46646279096603394,
-0.39384621381759644,
-0.05022088810801506,
0.8608406186103821,
1.1111782789230347,
-0.09329070150852203,
0.43558865785598755,
0.18262557685375214,
0.9975579977035522,
-0.4351191222667694,
0.1771237552165985,
-0.4029325246810913,
0.26954859495162964,
-0.49069008231163025,
-0.21789667010307312,
-0.2269515097141266,
-0.5818415284156799,
0.08499255776405334,
-0.2261095941066742,
0.532452404499054,
0.2087680697441101,
0.5965219140052795,
0.2076738029718399,
-0.17617100477218628,
0.06458113342523575,
-0.7798476219177246,
0.6271234750747681,
-0.5699814558029175,
0.2234935313463211,
0.6146009564399719,
0.28687259554862976,
0.050080861896276474,
-0.2353406846523285,
-0.370257169008255,
-0.010578814893960953,
-0.09489544481039047,
0.0963260680437088,
0.06013112515211105,
-0.016706746071577072,
0.306979238986969,
0.339253693819046,
-0.6051603555679321,
0.2816465198993683,
-0.9560546278953552,
-0.2279670238494873,
0.7298281788825989,
-0.03152582421898842,
0.2329287827014923,
-0.30184170603752136,
0.15373902022838593,
-0.08147331327199936,
-0.6049718260765076,
0.3463991582393646,
0.9333346486091614,
0.3813945949077606,
-0.15909776091575623,
0.6453103423118591,
-0.12805365025997162,
0.38389676809310913,
-0.3858747184276581,
-0.09291822463274002,
0.18259121477603912,
0.20480003952980042,
0.06458669155836105,
0.48229730129241943,
0.5222887396812439,
0.39475464820861816,
0.4461205005645752,
-0.23306845128536224,
-0.04502873495221138,
0.4637674391269684,
0.04159751161932945,
-0.2836696207523346,
-0.14222170412540436,
-0.007884157821536064,
-0.3076975345611572,
-0.4200853705406189,
-0.5092080235481262,
-1.0602917671203613,
-0.40283969044685364,
-0.08918049186468124,
0.00405910424888134,
-0.1467123180627823,
-0.2879180312156677,
-0.02154504880309105,
-0.4421897232532501,
0.39472416043281555,
0.10595470666885376,
-1.2166672945022583,
0.7377786636352539,
0.6660115718841553,
1.0323103666305542,
0.09275057166814804,
-0.2027929127216339,
-0.3170431852340698,
-0.03017476759850979,
-0.29594674706459045,
0.8622989058494568,
-0.8033124804496765,
-0.4440390467643738,
0.33574095368385315,
-0.17881926894187927,
0.04858933016657829,
-0.7586867809295654,
0.028657685965299606,
-0.3025605082511902,
0.03089771419763565,
-0.10933808982372284,
-0.2967033386230469,
0.1643587350845337,
-0.354233980178833,
-0.45637816190719604,
1.3326246738433838,
0.09921269118785858,
-0.5797712206840515,
0.6472474336624146,
-0.5305332541465759,
-0.6384340524673462,
0.42796310782432556,
-0.010514155961573124,
-0.16242235898971558,
0.1782160997390747,
-0.34475797414779663,
0.3435254693031311,
-0.010649717412889004,
0.5331542491912842,
-0.3674587309360504,
-0.4351504147052765,
0.12150390446186066,
-0.29017186164855957,
0.7064175009727478,
0.12411192804574966,
-0.39611557126045227,
-0.029796388000249863,
-0.9432898163795471,
-0.252043217420578,
0.03587165102362633,
-0.30724596977233887,
-0.4115857183933258,
0.41960376501083374,
0.1639094054698944,
0.11344567686319351,
0.08730943500995636,
-0.38697075843811035,
-0.07386268675327301,
-0.4463355243206024,
0.3620569109916687,
0.8661689758300781,
-0.6373366117477417,
0.577618420124054,
-0.3246816098690033,
0.48164328932762146,
-0.5941632390022278,
0.28575941920280457,
0.6131594777107239,
-0.5570504665374756,
-0.5665733814239502,
-0.042470064014196396,
0.34972670674324036,
0.58956378698349,
-0.7513079643249512,
0.301628440618515,
0.005476411432027817,
-0.6294316053390503,
-0.45964327454566956,
0.10759888589382172,
0.2091132402420044,
-0.07351791113615036,
0.206196591258049,
-0.5505425930023193,
-0.6457015872001648,
-0.9571377038955688,
-0.4089820384979248,
-0.49069637060165405,
-0.07186473160982132,
0.10779371857643127,
0.1490580290555954,
0.2208239585161209,
0.727706253528595,
-0.3634074628353119,
-0.21240529417991638,
-0.49682918190956116,
-0.09739303588867188,
-0.08075840026140213,
0.47098806500434875,
0.3593595027923584,
-0.48762455582618713,
-0.21972323954105377,
-0.2650904059410095,
-0.4383333921432495,
-0.46458011865615845,
0.5221129655838013,
0.08649937808513641,
0.5798103213310242,
0.5815984606742859,
0.047140009701251984,
0.42514950037002563,
0.6648769974708557,
-0.41743096709251404,
0.4190298020839691,
-0.3147974908351898,
-0.2645929455757141,
-0.6666418313980103,
0.021142080426216125,
0.3056381344795227,
-0.2881507873535156,
-0.5734695792198181,
-0.26186710596084595,
-0.2685609757900238,
-0.32326215505599976,
-0.43927040696144104,
0.3253041207790375,
-0.086450956761837,
-0.5891741514205933,
0.09741927683353424,
0.49430131912231445,
-0.28108862042427063,
0.36704692244529724,
0.1693648099899292,
0.542874813079834,
0.30911701917648315,
-0.4335165321826935,
0.07820361852645874,
-0.2441914826631546,
-0.3166128396987915,
0.3012795150279999,
-0.7414112687110901,
0.04302437603473663,
-0.22520922124385834,
-0.1901872754096985,
-0.9577035307884216,
-0.24497930705547333,
-0.07304206490516663,
-0.42753538489341736,
0.2905929982662201,
-0.07266492396593094,
-0.6475956439971924,
-0.10545554757118225,
-0.27890846133232117,
0.25725695490837097,
0.6311224102973938,
-0.04892067238688469,
0.3043210208415985,
0.9294668436050415,
-0.40605428814888,
-0.4480377733707428,
-0.3011200726032257,
0.13582126796245575,
-0.27467232942581177,
-0.4602851867675781,
0.22251379489898682,
0.1430915743112564,
-0.46230417490005493,
-0.09098585695028305,
-0.16685210168361664,
-0.12450045347213745,
0.4745008051395416,
0.25447848439216614,
0.439273476600647,
0.049165841192007065,
0.20743422210216522,
0.1986181139945984,
0.021482491865754128,
0.08935506641864777,
0.1650555282831192,
0.7885615229606628,
-0.2936033010482788,
0.1906730681657791,
0.19251492619514465,
0.30864518880844116,
0.32810455560684204,
-0.05490649864077568,
0.6425618529319763,
0.49008870124816895,
-0.23933151364326477,
-0.015138071961700916,
-0.6043079495429993,
0.13439986109733582,
-0.42279595136642456,
0.23175591230392456,
0.00658175116404891,
-1.0967909097671509,
0.44498223066329956,
0.018625332042574883,
-0.09307638555765152,
0.45739319920539856,
0.12754589319229126,
0.08329221606254578,
0.8524872660636902,
0.7676655650138855,
0.016148298978805542,
0.5931410193443298,
-0.11040519177913666,
0.17210374772548676,
-0.6823645830154419,
-0.16503070294857025,
-0.8671730756759644,
-0.29065531492233276,
-0.8706156611442566,
-0.0367860272526741,
0.10806942731142044,
-0.1135779395699501,
-0.04944583401083946,
0.24922913312911987,
-0.5463284850120544,
0.47293031215667725,
0.6074990630149841,
-0.32245010137557983,
0.25962120294570923,
0.01140855997800827,
-0.05226045474410057,
-0.0896899402141571,
-0.8674152493476868,
-1.1114139556884766,
0.9613347053527832,
0.2741814851760864,
0.4053739309310913,
0.31228697299957275,
0.7274335622787476,
0.6822069883346558,
0.3368335962295532,
-0.5210896730422974,
0.7591292262077332,
-0.5096447467803955,
-0.7719985246658325,
-0.390836238861084,
-0.2570110559463501,
-0.8411641120910645,
0.17842039465904236,
-0.3563428521156311,
-0.9521974921226501,
0.442117303609848,
0.19326798617839813,
-0.27391281723976135,
0.2375784069299698,
-0.8003012537956238,
0.9691244959831238,
0.13744856417179108,
-0.734380304813385,
-0.15064065158367157,
-0.9163485765457153,
0.2204439491033554,
0.07439357787370682,
0.7212302684783936,
-0.49612075090408325,
0.24026112258434296,
0.936852753162384,
-0.16107767820358276,
1.1327478885650635,
-0.29465118050575256,
0.19649407267570496,
-0.09020709246397018,
-0.018964126706123352,
-0.17942605912685394,
-0.07960712909698486,
-0.011454774998128414,
0.34631189703941345,
0.49404463171958923,
-0.5332276821136475,
-0.21133777499198914,
0.4754405617713928,
-0.925902247428894,
-0.6880794763565063,
-0.6485552787780762,
-0.30109742283821106,
0.0002982938021887094,
-0.005428390111774206,
-0.003862614743411541,
0.6348276734352112,
-0.1788957417011261,
0.2642791271209717,
0.3217548429965973,
-0.49735507369041443,
0.4995964765548706,
0.18419989943504333,
-0.5201804637908936,
-0.17986300587654114,
0.8901830911636353,
0.6199557781219482,
0.5420454740524292,
0.1262921839952469,
0.29584163427352905,
-0.22806429862976074,
-0.22777491807937622,
-0.39116835594177246,
0.12002286314964294,
-0.7088560461997986,
0.12590473890304565,
-0.7369781732559204,
-0.0165579654276371,
-0.6777271032333374,
-0.5074758529663086,
-0.22104015946388245,
-0.6174784302711487,
0.08659980446100235,
-0.01892918534576893,
0.21819175779819489,
0.586758553981781,
-0.43266648054122925,
0.21138416230678558,
-0.42357996106147766,
0.31542983651161194,
0.37499430775642395,
0.3896130621433258,
-0.12428350001573563,
-0.2893749475479126,
-0.19584789872169495,
-0.36591488122940063,
-0.14367851614952087,
-0.5770513415336609,
0.49204662442207336,
0.3244803547859192,
0.4195297956466675,
-0.16574634611606598,
0.23264653980731964,
0.32449185848236084,
-0.4537910223007202,
0.8678938150405884,
-0.12396669387817383,
-1.2037572860717773,
0.4973227381706238,
0.014595318585634232,
0.1841033399105072,
0.4991212487220764,
0.16043633222579956,
-0.9019654989242554,
-0.959372878074646,
-0.7022208571434021,
-1.1989299058914185,
0.687584638595581,
0.008804733864963055,
0.03485638275742531,
-0.172639861702919,
0.09431565552949905,
0.08965558558702469,
0.32149121165275574,
-0.7527228593826294,
-0.2888946831226349,
-0.30091360211372375,
-0.13969753682613373,
-0.3244748115539551,
-0.3099437952041626,
0.09572948515415192,
-0.29234910011291504,
0.44752201437950134,
-0.06084006279706955,
-0.023451412096619606,
0.3699318766593933,
-0.11439897119998932,
-0.07196613401174545,
0.55009526014328,
0.5018596649169922,
0.7078768610954285,
-0.5032407641410828,
0.5905292630195618,
0.06487475335597992,
-0.5053510069847107,
0.27548491954803467,
0.16601428389549255,
-0.04330819100141525,
0.11820878088474274,
0.1537146270275116,
0.36473798751831055,
0.2771921455860138,
-0.48737281560897827,
0.2112545371055603,
-0.07382091134786606,
-0.2344789057970047,
-0.6117886304855347,
0.27904072403907776,
-0.12147273123264313,
0.24877719581127167,
0.4137627184391022,
0.3475882112979889,
0.34987717866897583,
-0.9041466116905212,
-0.3099641501903534,
0.18164148926734924,
-0.5739008784294128,
-0.19004736840724945,
0.6956674456596375,
0.10612160712480545,
-0.7687093615531921,
-0.08837727457284927,
-0.3375445008277893,
-0.5077081322669983,
0.6280797123908997,
0.38037824630737305,
0.6867032647132874,
-0.23953942954540253,
0.5018213987350464,
0.11274752765893936,
0.6380560994148254,
-0.20096594095230103,
-0.017838088795542717,
-0.11315419524908066,
-0.6410014033317566,
-0.45756569504737854,
-0.7492639422416687,
-0.5233284831047058,
-0.37845176458358765,
-0.5482358336448669,
0.11796078085899353,
-0.579889714717865,
-0.23521371185779572,
0.26083359122276306,
0.030149048194289207,
-0.6959447264671326,
0.02139408141374588,
0.049982115626335144,
0.44542309641838074,
-1.038643717765808,
0.7150793075561523,
0.6006149053573608,
-0.22782455384731293,
-0.5298191905021667,
-0.26154130697250366,
0.14866361021995544,
-0.5884726047515869,
0.979149341583252,
0.1293494999408722,
-0.3428110182285309,
0.014565490186214447,
-0.2823493182659149,
-0.5765727162361145,
0.5787894129753113,
0.217619389295578,
-0.3568381071090698,
-0.11824671179056168,
0.3045863211154938,
0.8037911057472229,
-0.12532828748226166,
-0.09133414179086685,
0.567371666431427,
0.24647636711597443,
-0.13400337100028992,
-0.9516333937644958,
-0.11326687783002853,
-0.4090573489665985,
0.33466836810112,
0.10991621762514114,
-0.5523313879966736,
0.3734647333621979,
0.06095839664340019,
-0.46649229526519775,
-0.4296973943710327,
0.15369181334972382,
0.096190445125103,
0.5642319917678833,
0.48046305775642395,
0.04878458380699158,
0.5034357309341431,
-0.23922514915466309,
1.0531797409057617,
-0.24419420957565308,
0.06552057713270187,
0.6098259687423706,
-0.49997541308403015,
0.7185754776000977,
0.30434468388557434,
-0.6065269112586975,
0.28972506523132324,
0.5193125009536743,
0.29622113704681396,
0.41006195545196533,
0.40163883566856384,
-0.41647011041641235,
-0.13017822802066803,
-0.21040880680084229,
-0.32915180921554565,
0.5079522728919983,
0.2576840817928314,
-0.2012103646993637,
0.30141681432724,
-0.27283161878585815,
-0.015506179071962833,
0.43197041749954224,
-0.28142204880714417,
0.8802481889724731,
0.10936946421861649,
-0.428472101688385,
0.3476657569408417,
-0.25200653076171875,
0.6790935397148132,
-0.4046124815940857,
0.060227882117033005,
-0.18586544692516327,
-0.06595899909734726,
-0.306209534406662,
-0.5780370235443115,
0.753744900226593,
0.07381609827280045,
-0.10982590913772583,
-0.06448667496442795,
0.8812582492828369,
-0.3588430881500244,
-0.5622737407684326,
0.39476293325424194,
0.5322849750518799,
0.3690147399902344,
0.34261855483055115,
-0.15062306821346283,
0.05549929291009903,
-0.29425808787345886,
0.28140124678611755,
0.37880396842956543,
0.4321576952934265,
0.13528399169445038,
0.5392036437988281,
0.5933132767677307,
0.45530587434768677,
0.13052542507648468,
0.18607714772224426,
0.49917173385620117,
-0.6578201651573181,
-0.16381455957889557,
-0.9625276327133179,
0.3268418312072754,
-0.4091360867023468,
-0.3061784505844116,
0.6304805874824524,
0.7135618329048157,
1.0451136827468872,
0.1817106455564499,
0.6802024841308594,
-0.018858499825000763,
0.35343602299690247,
-0.3778343200683594,
0.6724684238433838,
-0.5033977627754211,
0.2944819927215576,
-0.7738589644432068,
-1.0354232788085938,
-0.6032017469406128,
0.6759905815124512,
-0.5913998484611511,
-0.17439843714237213,
0.5632951259613037,
0.6235496997833252,
0.4217224419116974,
0.054763853549957275,
0.6001713275909424,
-0.3328784704208374,
0.3361363112926483,
-0.08703071624040604,
0.8648577928543091,
-0.06461665779352188,
0.26945340633392334,
-0.35401907563209534,
-0.2691555917263031,
-0.33415281772613525,
-0.6946655511856079,
-0.7332859635353088,
-0.4207233190536499,
-0.3501470983028412,
-0.270948201417923,
0.31363943219184875,
1.075958490371704,
0.4409276843070984,
-0.3083358705043793,
-0.7471304535865784,
0.3238716125488281,
0.5109779238700867,
-0.263731449842453,
-0.2883364260196686,
0.17323485016822815,
-0.3889918029308319,
-0.6289926767349243,
0.015433092601597309,
0.6779778003692627,
-0.0475052185356617,
-0.32390519976615906,
0.2625868618488312,
-0.20359741151332855,
-0.010815600864589214,
0.8724960088729858,
0.23912416398525238,
-0.5423563122749329,
-0.40433114767074585,
-0.04444600269198418,
0.14521588385105133,
0.0787428468465805,
0.652616560459137,
-0.4160691797733307,
0.3547840714454651,
0.15180543065071106,
0.19329775869846344,
0.24778497219085693,
-0.534832775592804,
0.5275753736495972,
-0.7826653122901917,
0.2689574658870697,
0.18239542841911316,
0.48880091309547424,
0.5976163744926453,
-0.0864696055650711,
0.6281378269195557,
0.5354852676391602,
-0.7935322523117065,
-0.9542718529701233,
0.0356857106089592,
-0.6648640036582947,
-0.15016652643680573,
0.9767227172851562,
0.34842392802238464,
-0.42853665351867676,
-0.6755489706993103,
-0.25058361887931824,
0.44693610072135925,
-0.6309153437614441,
1.0380032062530518,
0.7472373843193054,
0.3340471386909485,
-0.3071184754371643,
-0.8278582692146301,
0.6109882593154907,
0.28212830424308777,
-0.6253935098648071,
0.1248878538608551,
0.5389851331710815,
-0.07399610430002213,
0.3563521206378937,
0.7097223997116089,
-0.2252788245677948,
0.03560337796807289,
0.07811682671308517,
0.43647778034210205,
0.37159380316734314,
-0.05296076834201813,
-0.176242396235466,
0.4166222810745239,
0.38806673884391785,
0.3123970627784729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04417v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04417v1
|
Promising and worth-to-try future directions for advancing state-of-the-art surrogates methods of agent-based models in social and health computational sciences
| 2024-03-07T11:30:56 | 2024-03-07T11:30:56 |
Atiyah Elsheikh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SY, eess.SY, math.DS
|
The execution and runtime performance of model-based analysis tools for
realistic large-scale ABMs (Agent-Based Models) can be excessively long. This
due to the computational demand exponentially proportional to the model size
(e.g. Population size) and the number of model parameters. Even the runtime of
a single simulation of a realistic ABM may demand huge computational resources
when attempting to employ realistic population size. The main aim of this
ad-hoc brief report is to highlight some of surrogate models that were adequate
and computationally less demanding for nonlinear dynamical models in various
modeling application areas.To the author knowledge, these methods have been
not, at least extensively, employed for ABMs within the field of (SHCS) Social
Health Computational Sciences, yet. Thus, they might be, but not necessarily,
useful in progressing state of the art for establishing surrogate models for
ABMs in the field of SHCS.
|
[
-0.36877304315567017,
-0.8572465181350708,
0.6109676957130432,
-0.18880702555179596,
0.03825780004262924,
0.4272806942462921,
0.09833762794733047,
-0.6010822057723999,
0.42552950978279114,
0.6252676248550415,
-0.6211109161376953,
-0.21382662653923035,
-0.3707333505153656,
0.29278454184532166,
-0.4187939763069153,
0.47559523582458496,
0.3514486253261566,
0.2547193467617035,
-0.4323870837688446,
-0.09174627810716629,
-0.19265730679035187,
-0.5083759427070618,
-0.8035348653793335,
-0.3751836121082306,
0.47683581709861755,
0.09988816827535629,
1.0083924531936646,
0.450927197933197,
0.6609278917312622,
0.19491887092590332,
-0.4035552144050598,
0.40381941199302673,
-0.5449127554893494,
0.28978031873703003,
-0.38445761799812317,
-0.011963030323386192,
-0.4624027609825134,
0.3075132966041565,
0.5748487710952759,
1.1046125888824463,
-0.23118677735328674,
0.18426309525966644,
-0.39684024453163147,
0.6667622327804565,
-0.806816041469574,
-0.21064741909503937,
-0.19366276264190674,
-0.24213425815105438,
0.20931042730808258,
0.023828279227018356,
-0.4701337218284607,
-0.4830647110939026,
0.33704471588134766,
-0.262774258852005,
0.06972506642341614,
-0.031966593116521835,
0.25202661752700806,
0.19342577457427979,
-0.7378013730049133,
-0.08390772342681885,
-0.9505496025085449,
0.7374777793884277,
-0.7778396010398865,
0.32685431838035583,
0.27446314692497253,
0.4746240973472595,
-0.8163938522338867,
-0.9346659779548645,
-0.12534461915493011,
-0.7009536623954773,
0.20452426373958588,
-0.10591554641723633,
-0.18889543414115906,
0.4844417870044708,
0.15725967288017273,
0.020258769392967224,
-0.2397782802581787,
0.009390336461365223,
-0.4465234577655792,
0.06350160390138626,
0.9259318709373474,
0.677486002445221,
0.11885891854763031,
0.12325060367584229,
-0.15529243648052216,
0.35672226548194885,
-0.6159135699272156,
-0.031684864312410355,
0.09845094382762909,
0.4028201997280121,
-0.39214855432510376,
0.44094544649124146,
-0.13358034193515778,
0.6177931427955627,
-0.21781553328037262,
-0.061526473611593246,
-0.15577392280101776,
-0.36638906598091125,
0.30820322036743164,
-0.39489033818244934,
0.28065624833106995,
0.31971272826194763,
0.11239209026098251,
-0.16548983752727509,
0.008703788742423058,
0.08648935705423355,
0.5343155264854431,
-0.9424929022789001,
0.006779095623642206,
0.4726388156414032,
-0.6968468427658081,
-0.25838929414749146,
-0.2558443248271942,
-1.0662436485290527,
-0.7396318316459656,
-0.30440571904182434,
0.39435139298439026,
-0.23158328235149384,
-0.30726441740989685,
0.10746681690216064,
-0.1098267212510109,
0.03836532682180405,
0.26380208134651184,
-0.2506222426891327,
0.5523327589035034,
0.4019269347190857,
0.9378052949905396,
-0.3074207007884979,
-0.09042978286743164,
-0.3766647279262543,
-0.11052431166172028,
-0.800279974937439,
0.673858642578125,
-0.9030696749687195,
-0.6124531626701355,
-0.045757729560136795,
0.05402714014053345,
-0.05478488653898239,
-0.5171669721603394,
0.16458739340305328,
-0.5799288153648376,
-0.6159693598747253,
-0.5027240514755249,
-0.4920419752597809,
-0.11732351034879684,
0.06735479831695557,
-0.8328056335449219,
0.6972237229347229,
0.1482633799314499,
-0.48498979210853577,
-0.024668587371706963,
-0.6629816293716431,
-0.44430774450302124,
0.07558386772871017,
-0.06413257867097855,
-0.3912651836872101,
0.4162622094154358,
-0.266946941614151,
0.4944271147251129,
-0.803231418132782,
0.25848817825317383,
-0.7345942258834839,
-0.5173715949058533,
0.2658805251121521,
-0.3747090697288513,
0.6510196924209595,
0.21907715499401093,
-0.07016265392303467,
0.02299889549612999,
-0.7843679189682007,
-0.06805600970983505,
0.07206732034683228,
0.1699821949005127,
-0.05078411102294922,
0.40290898084640503,
-0.18501122295856476,
0.12515489757061005,
0.2676059603691101,
-0.44217684864997864,
0.08466710150241852,
-0.0543709322810173,
0.5049626231193542,
0.4685136377811432,
0.19232861697673798,
-0.1305052936077118,
-0.6155201196670532,
1.0343834161758423,
-0.6355904340744019,
0.3122459053993225,
-0.013230598531663418,
-0.19027788937091827,
-0.10066597908735275,
-0.5357959270477295,
0.5347316265106201,
0.13779911398887634,
-0.9352384209632874,
-0.10862593352794647,
-0.05658534914255142,
-0.9305030703544617,
-0.07726927101612091,
-0.6632184982299805,
0.3287319839000702,
0.1780528724193573,
0.3531796932220459,
-0.16936513781547546,
-0.553367555141449,
-0.7399863004684448,
-0.1780175417661667,
-0.22746334969997406,
0.5516838431358337,
0.29540327191352844,
1.0174025297164917,
-0.4693959653377533,
0.7855051755905151,
-0.27634719014167786,
0.3270612359046936,
-0.27660071849823,
-0.09785836189985275,
0.1023876741528511,
0.32599183917045593,
0.68255215883255,
-0.8311761021614075,
-0.275814950466156,
-0.14837758243083954,
-0.5229254961013794,
-0.31751376390457153,
0.4424198269844055,
0.12368424981832504,
-0.16792429983615875,
0.38458043336868286,
-0.6382337212562561,
0.7088927626609802,
0.7213658690452576,
-0.0745745524764061,
1.1115634441375732,
-0.4074104428291321,
0.2954133152961731,
-0.7043042778968811,
0.4164279103279114,
-0.06803226470947266,
-0.2652615010738373,
-1.0544238090515137,
0.3841607868671417,
-0.16964808106422424,
-0.20435523986816406,
-0.412535697221756,
0.8602178692817688,
-0.6131653189659119,
-0.13003088533878326,
-0.5919516682624817,
-0.2722150683403015,
-0.29082924127578735,
0.2432572990655899,
-0.05532580614089966,
0.8380072712898254,
0.41116809844970703,
-0.5549757480621338,
0.5321155190467834,
-0.22428958117961884,
0.21681031584739685,
0.44653773307800293,
-0.8163005113601685,
0.08774935454130173,
-0.20299355685710907,
0.535865306854248,
-0.7996842265129089,
-0.38338178396224976,
-0.14127562940120697,
-0.4665946662425995,
0.1228405311703682,
-0.16492576897144318,
-0.4912586212158203,
-0.5666378736495972,
-0.45152974128723145,
0.6669507622718811,
0.5173946022987366,
-0.28577902913093567,
0.8725594282150269,
0.6574049592018127,
0.05425887554883957,
-0.29594531655311584,
-0.4096228778362274,
-0.03726247325539589,
-0.27770790457725525,
-0.29332634806632996,
0.30710428953170776,
0.15630732476711273,
-0.3404231071472168,
0.045760490000247955,
-0.10490494221448898,
0.019436031579971313,
-0.07889677584171295,
0.2043973058462143,
0.1883445829153061,
0.19205138087272644,
0.11080018430948257,
-0.07028257101774216,
-0.19259192049503326,
0.007794353645294905,
0.035657063126564026,
0.4130697548389435,
-0.04184068366885185,
-0.46075791120529175,
-0.2285407930612564,
0.6824670433998108,
0.993170440196991,
-0.30622008442878723,
0.9431357979774475,
-0.32556381821632385,
-0.8997963666915894,
-0.0941271185874939,
-0.5901914238929749,
-0.14522778987884521,
-0.4141748249530792,
0.41070395708084106,
0.01978890411555767,
-0.5749630331993103,
0.8859337568283081,
-0.48114514350891113,
0.07616069167852402,
0.3499535620212555,
0.46046122908592224,
0.19053149223327637,
1.0973494052886963,
0.41554123163223267,
0.21863886713981628,
0.23101520538330078,
-0.39345523715019226,
-0.0997353121638298,
-0.7041221261024475,
-0.2487267106771469,
-0.6646865010261536,
-0.03520498424768448,
-0.6185664534568787,
-0.6245564818382263,
0.8343386650085449,
-0.4122866988182068,
-0.37557289004325867,
0.16802585124969482,
-0.3706988990306854,
-0.0918118879199028,
0.10098404437303543,
0.120181605219841,
-0.08169078081846237,
-0.20203642547130585,
-0.08389513194561005,
0.10143130272626877,
-0.6891809105873108,
-0.31383681297302246,
1.0012025833129883,
0.32293030619621277,
0.8304272294044495,
-0.11557710915803909,
0.1897037923336029,
0.46529412269592285,
0.24393436312675476,
-0.5288003087043762,
0.5155438184738159,
-0.4904457926750183,
-1.0049563646316528,
-0.4855200946331024,
-0.4495547115802765,
-1.1978987455368042,
0.24399735033512115,
-0.019452061504125595,
-0.9172712564468384,
0.6253754496574402,
0.36275315284729004,
-0.619583249092102,
0.3307206928730011,
-0.3287712633609772,
0.6526677012443542,
-0.11150820553302765,
-0.6168031692504883,
-0.38960668444633484,
-0.7013896107673645,
-0.23937630653381348,
-0.17995981872081757,
0.3650576174259186,
-0.2596145570278168,
-0.35880595445632935,
0.4047636091709137,
-0.7569127678871155,
0.8048878312110901,
-0.2949260175228119,
0.0545671284198761,
0.5143768787384033,
-0.11232177168130875,
0.8812512755393982,
-0.20624367892742157,
-0.5388050675392151,
0.12487802654504776,
0.4650765061378479,
-0.5339439511299133,
-0.5675095319747925,
0.3546975255012512,
-0.418865442276001,
-0.46116089820861816,
-0.37740254402160645,
-0.1966588944196701,
-0.4523041546344757,
0.14334388077259064,
0.04400891065597534,
0.7502104640007019,
-0.1320752054452896,
0.43851813673973083,
0.5417739152908325,
-0.18220341205596924,
0.14171896874904633,
0.5469051003456116,
-0.17410381138324738,
-0.47285202145576477,
0.6363893747329712,
0.551315426826477,
0.36412015557289124,
0.04701285809278488,
0.22777338325977325,
-0.2861654460430145,
-0.6920915842056274,
-0.06657055020332336,
0.32646656036376953,
-0.16767393052577972,
-0.205145463347435,
-0.46958062052726746,
-0.3279540240764618,
-0.2943471074104309,
-0.2315753698348999,
-0.8868832588195801,
0.016293616965413094,
-0.0985320582985878,
0.13802598416805267,
0.5813602209091187,
0.39099496603012085,
-0.2633936107158661,
0.10964757204055786,
-0.5466449856758118,
0.5863552093505859,
-0.07939611375331879,
0.37357857823371887,
0.2537231147289276,
-0.20890559256076813,
-0.33883199095726013,
0.47921857237815857,
-0.1527324914932251,
-1.1811648607254028,
0.42315730452537537,
0.036920856684446335,
0.7732110619544983,
0.020795093849301338,
0.43485990166664124,
0.7851921916007996,
-0.2755691707134247,
0.617819607257843,
-0.0672854408621788,
-0.5749606490135193,
0.40315812826156616,
-0.48651719093322754,
0.01113586314022541,
0.5232287049293518,
0.5183508992195129,
-0.3235277533531189,
0.08385008573532104,
-0.5070466995239258,
-0.9817101359367371,
0.5003162026405334,
0.32565340399742126,
0.12258414179086685,
-0.032896462827920914,
0.8591634631156921,
0.05932091921567917,
0.2779897153377533,
-0.04984382912516594,
-0.2870400846004486,
0.4642111361026764,
0.09794094413518906,
0.041340649127960205,
-0.25274720788002014,
0.13565249741077423,
-0.13209258019924164,
0.7494252920150757,
-0.22297677397727966,
0.16473259031772614,
0.32405751943588257,
0.582098662853241,
-0.35051634907722473,
-0.0707191675901413,
0.44102901220321655,
0.5510375499725342,
-0.04520625248551369,
0.010051632300019264,
0.6056820154190063,
-0.5760750770568848,
0.5416234135627747,
0.36091348528862,
-0.021235674619674683,
-0.25781384110450745,
0.5384451150894165,
0.3689495921134949,
0.08712974935770035,
-1.03400456905365,
0.36062318086624146,
0.1624380648136139,
0.1393948644399643,
-0.5528671145439148,
0.14274415373802185,
0.03855893388390541,
0.47052904963493347,
0.44894999265670776,
-0.1683998852968216,
0.19516119360923767,
-0.664665699005127,
0.022673366591334343,
0.7292751669883728,
-0.559246838092804,
-0.29513639211654663,
0.5360231995582581,
0.14674358069896698,
-0.4213228225708008,
0.20156502723693848,
-0.0802958533167839,
-0.14135238528251648,
1.1296885013580322,
0.3037479817867279,
0.5599729418754578,
-0.46986696124076843,
0.11617990583181381,
0.04247208312153816,
0.12189139425754547,
-0.36021798849105835,
0.4571444094181061,
0.36682263016700745,
-0.3204788565635681,
-0.450543075799942,
-0.30244866013526917,
-0.6206883788108826,
0.36623406410217285,
-0.6584397554397583,
0.3543294370174408,
-0.12551969289779663,
-0.7105328440666199,
0.12001999467611313,
0.398211807012558,
-0.2541518807411194,
0.36408624053001404,
-0.28422120213508606,
0.8658425211906433,
-0.5441076755523682,
0.4196828305721283,
0.922979474067688,
0.10705187171697617,
-0.630678117275238,
-0.03243005648255348,
-0.10634452104568481,
-0.21626999974250793,
-0.15056978166103363,
-0.07216799259185791,
-0.470289409160614,
-0.18880735337734222,
-0.7075414657592773,
-1.094874382019043,
0.8843550682067871,
0.787742555141449,
-0.25223952531814575,
-0.38440409302711487,
0.19105933606624603,
1.0111823081970215,
-0.34069326519966125,
0.30200856924057007,
0.3960873782634735,
0.3718954026699066,
0.2756202518939972,
-0.9238544702529907,
0.07961748540401459,
-0.21656428277492523,
0.3199228346347809,
0.0231029000133276,
-1.158210039138794,
0.8971627950668335,
-0.3753327429294586,
0.020261621102690697,
0.4312685430049896,
0.4649212956428528,
0.673496425151825,
0.6766294240951538,
0.3034842908382416,
0.07358110696077347,
0.3857431709766388,
0.39924439787864685,
1.0326632261276245,
-0.44776806235313416,
0.5208860039710999,
0.6504941582679749,
-0.48229098320007324,
0.3147725462913513,
0.1776205450296402,
-0.5238612294197083,
0.021691199392080307,
0.7727228403091431,
0.010631139390170574,
0.3015488088130951,
0.4922216534614563,
-0.07763707637786865,
-0.3552315831184387,
-0.29603832960128784,
-0.5185601115226746,
0.21873284876346588,
0.5865818858146667,
-0.3255481719970703,
-0.07064372301101685,
0.010491715744137764,
-0.22737455368041992,
-0.015399732626974583,
-0.35633140802383423,
0.24512241780757904,
0.3505411446094513,
-0.5310372710227966,
0.5411572456359863,
0.05528457835316658,
0.27909567952156067,
-0.5301060676574707,
-0.44383305311203003,
-0.12690602242946625,
-0.11235718429088593,
0.02208186499774456,
-0.06902673840522766,
0.3850712180137634,
-0.08624552935361862,
0.10380267351865768,
0.42281264066696167,
0.9737204909324646,
0.1715988963842392,
-0.5234526991844177,
0.6341533064842224,
0.5047759413719177,
0.14113718271255493,
0.2586366832256317,
-0.32077160477638245,
-0.020417282357811928,
-0.42930513620376587,
-0.3471084237098694,
0.10383301973342896,
0.14812174439430237,
-0.4783030152320862,
1.224472999572754,
0.45172151923179626,
0.42022424936294556,
-0.12814761698246002,
-0.41678720712661743,
0.7665518522262573,
-0.7197455763816833,
-0.3460485637187958,
-0.822778582572937,
0.39011916518211365,
0.19927679002285004,
-0.010343172587454319,
0.3290065824985504,
0.5189974904060364,
0.046982984989881516,
0.15787427127361298,
0.676081657409668,
0.08105724304914474,
0.7471694946289062,
-0.26222407817840576,
0.5004174113273621,
-0.9263774156570435,
0.12571291625499725,
-0.472892701625824,
-0.4638451933860779,
-0.12458939850330353,
0.17853963375091553,
-0.23817536234855652,
0.4968622028827667,
0.41962671279907227,
0.6846593022346497,
0.3089577555656433,
0.09879397600889206,
0.48883935809135437,
0.07959989458322525,
0.29723164439201355,
0.2789858281612396,
1.0589712858200073,
0.07715743780136108,
-0.014181817881762981,
-0.17985422909259796,
-0.3277096152305603,
-0.4512495994567871,
-0.7947424650192261,
-0.7768214344978333,
-0.4350651800632477,
-0.2615182101726532,
-0.3445517122745514,
0.6753455400466919,
1.2066771984100342,
0.9401152729988098,
-0.5641381144523621,
-0.032554514706134796,
-0.04833613708615303,
-0.015261839143931866,
-0.539587140083313,
-0.10378728806972504,
0.36945056915283203,
0.38025978207588196,
-0.5121326446533203,
0.17582128942012787,
0.18711857497692108,
0.20366497337818146,
-0.4301661550998688,
0.16416597366333008,
-0.09689747542142868,
0.777008056640625,
0.4047017991542816,
0.5218797922134399,
-0.6076335310935974,
-0.1829201877117157,
-0.08455568552017212,
0.05113040283322334,
-0.3054921627044678,
0.7056436538696289,
-0.8214066624641418,
0.1876204013824463,
0.3439459204673767,
0.6281877160072327,
0.2135634869337082,
0.2514086663722992,
0.49607953429222107,
-0.2762499749660492,
-0.009229332208633423,
0.3821125030517578,
0.17944346368312836,
0.009104111231863499,
-0.6193581819534302,
0.7359352707862854,
0.22541972994804382,
-0.598113477230072,
-1.1585960388183594,
0.2198069840669632,
-0.6414617896080017,
-0.4620499610900879,
1.2289389371871948,
-0.1704624891281128,
-0.023748254403471947,
-0.25281232595443726,
-0.04453784227371216,
0.37717506289482117,
-0.27544254064559937,
0.8105195760726929,
0.41701653599739075,
-0.6089901328086853,
-0.08175679296255112,
-0.8056498169898987,
0.22545213997364044,
0.08477763086557388,
-0.8914704322814941,
0.24996574223041534,
0.5507155656814575,
-0.07931049913167953,
0.0671716183423996,
0.7617603540420532,
-0.17626835405826569,
0.5727999806404114,
0.17857955396175385,
-0.0860937312245369,
-0.13001635670661926,
-0.6500125527381897,
-0.2508631944656372,
0.2756420969963074,
-0.24893344938755035,
0.10564503818750381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04400v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04400v1
|
Exploring Continual Learning of Compositional Generalization in NLI
| 2024-03-07T10:54:27 | 2024-03-07T10:54:27 |
Xiyan Fu, Anette Frank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Compositional Natural Language Inference has been explored to assess the true
abilities of neural models to perform NLI. Yet, current evaluations assume
models to have full access to all primitive inferences in advance, in contrast
to humans that continuously acquire inference knowledge. In this paper, we
introduce the Continual Compositional Generalization in Inference (C2Gen NLI)
challenge, where a model continuously acquires knowledge of constituting
primitive inference tasks as a basis for compositional inferences. We explore
how continual learning affects compositional generalization in NLI, by
designing a continual learning setup for compositional NLI inference tasks. Our
experiments demonstrate that models fail to compositionally generalize in a
continual scenario. To address this problem, we first benchmark various
continual learning algorithms and verify their efficacy. We then further
analyze C2Gen, focusing on how to order primitives and compositional inference
types and examining correlations between subtasks. Our analyses show that by
learning subtasks continuously while observing their dependencies and
increasing degrees of difficulty, continual learning can enhance composition
generalization ability.
|
[
0.03108915127813816,
-0.7018884420394897,
0.6960448026657104,
0.6180189251899719,
-0.028867758810520172,
0.1664869785308838,
-0.5975052714347839,
-0.5758591294288635,
-0.23050174117088318,
0.37583547830581665,
-0.9359391331672668,
-0.542027473449707,
-0.5640745162963867,
0.272126704454422,
-0.08780881762504578,
0.9373891353607178,
0.11538001894950867,
-0.09036189317703247,
-0.45386457443237305,
-0.06559871882200241,
-1.1439489126205444,
-0.24926605820655823,
-1.0117712020874023,
-0.5327353477478027,
0.798348069190979,
0.3212100565433502,
0.3149591088294983,
0.47187352180480957,
0.09022960811853409,
0.336320698261261,
-0.015754930675029755,
0.2641907036304474,
-0.6024197340011597,
0.4620644450187683,
-0.11231669038534164,
-0.8710474967956543,
0.0937618613243103,
0.06679613888263702,
0.8049116134643555,
1.2690223455429077,
-0.21729835867881775,
-0.2292545735836029,
0.23975872993469238,
0.7344262599945068,
-0.862736701965332,
-0.08973989635705948,
-0.8952969908714294,
0.2199023962020874,
0.10076223313808441,
0.17827941477298737,
-0.684090793132782,
-0.14948010444641113,
0.5352996587753296,
-0.6932575106620789,
0.2961854040622711,
-0.025081465020775795,
0.6759189367294312,
0.26464420557022095,
-0.32469916343688965,
-0.5162807703018188,
-0.8648196458816528,
1.360177993774414,
-0.45946258306503296,
0.3768788278102875,
0.34324556589126587,
0.1200718879699707,
0.01716257818043232,
-0.796225905418396,
-0.5559263825416565,
-0.6612588167190552,
-0.18335604667663574,
0.3646921217441559,
-0.24832019209861755,
0.26685354113578796,
-0.0476384237408638,
0.28071892261505127,
-0.8199373483657837,
0.04258935898542404,
-0.14438606798648834,
-0.1485496163368225,
0.46667489409446716,
0.25982797145843506,
0.3938423693180084,
0.20875003933906555,
-0.2783935070037842,
0.24878036975860596,
-0.4017522633075714,
-0.16987688839435577,
0.21022440493106842,
-0.30348098278045654,
-0.18462726473808289,
0.3535658121109009,
-0.01637258380651474,
0.8586016297340393,
0.1267029345035553,
0.058293987065553665,
0.10223112255334854,
-0.3863735795021057,
-0.21289362013339996,
-0.046469949185848236,
0.6143651604652405,
0.14181265234947205,
0.4314587712287903,
-0.9675557613372803,
-0.046980127692222595,
0.2009846419095993,
0.5979036688804626,
-0.3086659014225006,
-0.12631067633628845,
0.5164178013801575,
-0.35510918498039246,
-0.07778123021125793,
0.09558260440826416,
-0.332016259431839,
0.05850997194647789,
-0.8425842523574829,
0.27436554431915283,
-0.5174646973609924,
-0.1675298660993576,
0.17275370657444,
-0.3705931007862091,
0.3206828534603119,
-0.028677061200141907,
-1.199893832206726,
0.369493305683136,
1.0994926691055298,
1.0540218353271484,
-0.6486644148826599,
-0.5383151173591614,
-0.30320584774017334,
0.30546602606773376,
-0.3919326364994049,
0.7643387317657471,
-0.6077524423599243,
-0.5889185070991516,
-0.12730690836906433,
0.052856720983982086,
-0.752453625202179,
-0.9563028812408447,
0.2216748595237732,
-0.3246227502822876,
0.10050985217094421,
-0.23379816114902496,
-0.8743067383766174,
0.13173891603946686,
0.4914282560348511,
-0.46162983775138855,
0.6358339190483093,
0.07255738228559494,
-0.6815635561943054,
0.3605038821697235,
-0.5595329403877258,
-0.30162546038627625,
0.10872707515954971,
-0.08215226978063583,
-0.3505999445915222,
0.3448411226272583,
-0.40779080986976624,
0.17569199204444885,
0.01216224767267704,
0.5139793753623962,
-0.3950096368789673,
-0.381686806678772,
0.33850371837615967,
-0.4216087758541107,
0.575156033039093,
-0.0066502997651696205,
-0.5147045254707336,
0.08063358813524246,
-0.6212334036827087,
-0.1655130237340927,
0.09788055717945099,
-0.3627406656742096,
-0.1961684376001358,
0.25546103715896606,
-0.22922158241271973,
-0.2726741135120392,
0.20140565931797028,
-0.6666616201400757,
0.10147273540496826,
-0.4220488369464874,
0.10696893185377121,
0.734115481376648,
0.426226943731308,
0.6644424796104431,
-0.5280335545539856,
0.3133782744407654,
-0.10534713417291641,
0.16698303818702698,
0.1205034926533699,
-0.4699361026287079,
-0.9787497520446777,
0.02283061109483242,
0.30633118748664856,
0.7037178874015808,
-0.5751091241836548,
0.4807247221469879,
-0.4868882894515991,
-0.3935690224170685,
0.1350005716085434,
0.35491129755973816,
0.47609782218933105,
0.4976707696914673,
0.382464200258255,
-0.10476815700531006,
-0.5785283446311951,
-0.7779948115348816,
0.03931877762079239,
-0.02118389680981636,
-0.5061766505241394,
0.0524088554084301,
0.532321035861969,
-0.6110970973968506,
1.007806658744812,
-0.37797772884368896,
0.017676355317234993,
-0.4690879285335541,
0.45771324634552,
0.014620985835790634,
0.7444310784339905,
0.473670095205307,
-0.6493790745735168,
-0.25559455156326294,
-0.006475399248301983,
-1.122515082359314,
0.06929509341716766,
-0.6385200619697571,
-0.4504738450050354,
0.00006345437577692792,
0.5155592560768127,
-0.5112453699111938,
0.08118797838687897,
0.6036379337310791,
-0.1500406563282013,
0.7736854553222656,
-0.15348079800605774,
-0.5445250272750854,
-0.7004578709602356,
0.2301938384771347,
-0.020085738971829414,
-0.06969521939754486,
-0.7447380423545837,
-0.03299376368522644,
-0.17531071603298187,
0.26355814933776855,
-0.05889994278550148,
0.3916253447532654,
-0.30371373891830444,
0.2378806471824646,
-0.4591207802295685,
-0.1137712150812149,
-0.07976361364126205,
0.49123114347457886,
0.2332114577293396,
0.5926180481910706,
0.4980076849460602,
-0.9754781126976013,
0.09898802638053894,
-0.1643245667219162,
-0.05049118399620056,
0.4715682566165924,
-0.9790006875991821,
0.20333921909332275,
-0.2825738787651062,
0.3748891353607178,
-0.7431842088699341,
0.026755744591355324,
0.26061922311782837,
-0.20674216747283936,
0.4177878499031067,
-0.001024423516355455,
-0.16778403520584106,
-0.004450546577572823,
0.1371515691280365,
0.18229623138904572,
0.23982878029346466,
-0.2927307188510895,
1.0768718719482422,
0.0553373359143734,
-0.008746063336730003,
-0.5465160012245178,
-0.7975814938545227,
0.2193985879421234,
-0.06915965676307678,
-0.43114960193634033,
0.6249974370002747,
-0.3377600312232971,
-0.3136789798736572,
-0.0762985497713089,
-0.3913456201553345,
0.008937433362007141,
0.24720290303230286,
0.2636410593986511,
0.06709150224924088,
-0.20548518002033234,
0.20188312232494354,
0.16198118031024933,
-0.15110234916210175,
0.2960522770881653,
-0.6183042526245117,
0.5284867882728577,
-0.11750124394893646,
-0.24448175728321075,
-0.45693567395210266,
0.597724974155426,
0.22873206436634064,
-0.10900309681892395,
0.7997419834136963,
0.6264239549636841,
-0.24753402173519135,
-0.3668419122695923,
-0.8308776617050171,
0.002243375638499856,
-0.43404680490493774,
0.05972984805703163,
-0.3946818709373474,
-0.9193429946899414,
0.48842260241508484,
-0.1451500505208969,
0.27057015895843506,
0.46214941143989563,
0.1469758301973343,
-0.39013728499412537,
0.5646963119506836,
0.6748189330101013,
-0.095367431640625,
0.4615241587162018,
-0.827716052532196,
-0.29585182666778564,
-0.7982903718948364,
-0.44005274772644043,
-0.3229578137397766,
-0.40519803762435913,
-0.3745531141757965,
0.002441953169181943,
0.21713852882385254,
-0.013059014454483986,
-0.1647501140832901,
0.09855560958385468,
-0.15792429447174072,
0.7872995138168335,
0.41987448930740356,
0.5649083256721497,
0.1892395317554474,
-0.1483776867389679,
-0.18498852849006653,
0.12204369157552719,
-0.5760498642921448,
-0.07261984795331955,
0.9546419978141785,
0.25465095043182373,
0.31922322511672974,
0.2010415494441986,
0.9066953063011169,
0.4180033802986145,
0.5406365990638733,
-0.8086633682250977,
0.37004896998405457,
-0.28017348051071167,
-0.2611321210861206,
-0.12805402278900146,
-0.57741379737854,
-1.2760188579559326,
0.05293886736035347,
0.04752478003501892,
-0.6917322874069214,
0.5343255400657654,
0.1754773110151291,
-0.19320422410964966,
-0.02480664663016796,
-0.6262059211730957,
0.991381049156189,
-0.10822634398937225,
-0.46754562854766846,
-0.315654993057251,
-0.8219863772392273,
0.4040966033935547,
0.1293884813785553,
-0.13321013748645782,
0.3277266025543213,
0.016591040417551994,
0.5035219788551331,
-0.16669410467147827,
1.1521189212799072,
-0.16046294569969177,
-0.027521291747689247,
0.4126049876213074,
0.04713854938745499,
0.14271625876426697,
0.29967978596687317,
0.012642019428312778,
0.04718349874019623,
-0.25739920139312744,
-0.8054396510124207,
-0.7896968126296997,
0.5375661253929138,
-0.6351147890090942,
-0.4255646765232086,
-0.33435341715812683,
-0.22833944857120514,
-0.48370352387428284,
-0.06423404812812805,
0.35627537965774536,
0.3400033116340637,
-0.39805474877357483,
0.23715199530124664,
1.0670684576034546,
0.007613287307322025,
0.5075104832649231,
0.1267540603876114,
0.2610752284526825,
-0.3031837046146393,
1.1240004301071167,
-0.2554788589477539,
0.4639037549495697,
0.3210289478302002,
0.3400607407093048,
-0.3024694323539734,
-0.7188885807991028,
-0.2816397547721863,
0.3401379883289337,
-0.7497444748878479,
0.1869746297597885,
-0.882632851600647,
-0.15407110750675201,
0.05879832059144974,
-0.1388847678899765,
-0.09900490194559097,
0.18501372635364532,
-0.4872862696647644,
0.0052274977788329124,
-0.3917474150657654,
0.6955217719078064,
-0.14353425800800323,
0.17310896515846252,
-0.7597250938415527,
0.3643721640110016,
0.813163697719574,
0.20740565657615662,
0.2685976028442383,
-0.5051254034042358,
-0.1430719494819641,
0.1141170859336853,
-0.33494219183921814,
-0.6438919901847839,
-0.10139519721269608,
0.6121013164520264,
0.6951785683631897,
0.46262967586517334,
-0.3596903681755066,
0.5593412518501282,
-0.3643989562988281,
0.8666835427284241,
0.016165653243660927,
-0.8960554003715515,
0.23912036418914795,
-0.3383767604827881,
0.8129211664199829,
0.9068067669868469,
0.42037233710289,
-0.8371044397354126,
-0.5141287446022034,
-0.30877652764320374,
-0.658194363117218,
-0.055907897651195526,
0.19012637436389923,
0.518548846244812,
-0.4794405698776245,
0.5939866900444031,
0.083326056599617,
0.08215132355690002,
-0.7614467740058899,
-0.06787391752004623,
-0.09131166338920593,
-0.22890667617321014,
0.08969845622777939,
-0.29058489203453064,
0.11538954079151154,
-0.26364943385124207,
0.5462250113487244,
-0.17216423153877258,
0.2310909628868103,
0.26738443970680237,
-0.4408262372016907,
0.30664122104644775,
0.13152503967285156,
0.7818359136581421,
0.8775112628936768,
-0.17597879469394684,
-0.04607057571411133,
0.3270474672317505,
-0.4624691307544708,
-0.03403251990675926,
-0.2352791279554367,
-0.06732340157032013,
0.10976298898458481,
0.7843487858772278,
0.7142100930213928,
0.46507394313812256,
-0.7248066067695618,
0.36238667368888855,
-0.20512358844280243,
-0.4202086329460144,
-0.7459805011749268,
0.16938193142414093,
0.2723824381828308,
-0.024303821846842766,
0.43424931168556213,
0.19070418179035187,
0.10855868458747864,
-0.5985344052314758,
0.25547561049461365,
0.36894115805625916,
-0.34287646412849426,
-0.13668864965438843,
0.3394138813018799,
-0.1279601901769638,
0.2486266791820526,
0.8678655624389648,
-0.3802662193775177,
-0.5044625401496887,
0.6945304870605469,
0.5797047019004822,
0.9783639907836914,
-0.003686147276312113,
0.2751532196998596,
0.4293873906135559,
0.19079653918743134,
-0.2136480063199997,
0.07754245400428772,
-0.4233924448490143,
-0.8006015419960022,
-0.7124463319778442,
-0.663855791091919,
-0.7021435499191284,
0.04971401393413544,
-0.47377392649650574,
-0.3487114906311035,
-0.48990166187286377,
0.17618660628795624,
0.007862318307161331,
-0.3039083778858185,
-0.566044807434082,
0.35119572281837463,
0.24533601105213165,
0.4648608863353729,
-0.7194284200668335,
0.5405364632606506,
0.23467287421226501,
-0.19800734519958496,
-0.4128996431827545,
0.3160479962825775,
-0.12833844125270844,
-0.27483856678009033,
0.7405456900596619,
0.37588462233543396,
-0.3239111602306366,
0.04866361618041992,
-0.8370392918586731,
-0.5432039499282837,
0.9361401796340942,
0.14264260232448578,
-0.5897641181945801,
-0.2848632335662842,
0.11997348070144653,
0.7054706811904907,
-0.3794406056404114,
-0.07251380383968353,
0.7818201184272766,
0.5760888457298279,
-0.0192402470856905,
-0.371990829706192,
-0.29749345779418945,
-0.23003114759922028,
0.20970508456230164,
-0.2150752693414688,
-0.3205191195011139,
0.42737317085266113,
0.0430157333612442,
-0.44564875960350037,
0.329315185546875,
0.9475793838500977,
0.24874237179756165,
0.6134405136108398,
0.7783942818641663,
0.7879989743232727,
0.5445758104324341,
-0.15895521640777588,
1.1299715042114258,
0.0006196945323608816,
0.20573346316814423,
1.3871678113937378,
-0.06857950240373611,
0.5986835360527039,
0.27398908138275146,
-0.016976024955511093,
0.8907553553581238,
0.5134264230728149,
-0.3049267530441284,
0.3485320508480072,
0.4287228584289551,
-0.8991003036499023,
-0.33052965998649597,
-0.18189938366413116,
-0.03424634411931038,
0.5768994688987732,
0.4356522560119629,
-0.1605762392282486,
-0.027585342526435852,
0.2494501918554306,
0.02401767298579216,
0.20283164083957672,
-0.017219197005033493,
1.1413670778274536,
-0.06564656645059586,
-1.06356942653656,
0.7529667019844055,
-0.12822923064231873,
0.8718366622924805,
-0.8214039206504822,
0.044005267322063446,
-0.3748510479927063,
-0.1397966891527176,
-0.0036474319640547037,
-0.29771456122398376,
0.7134048938751221,
-0.22377650439739227,
-0.3155340254306793,
0.16695627570152283,
0.2945649325847626,
-0.504601001739502,
-0.48744887113571167,
0.31784409284591675,
0.2408510148525238,
-0.2775357663631439,
-0.24158896505832672,
-0.6419461369514465,
-0.06528953462839127,
-0.18761374056339264,
-0.11537706851959229,
0.18582525849342346,
0.1652350276708603,
0.2376379519701004,
0.696202278137207,
0.6961874961853027,
-0.14982213079929352,
0.2120429128408432,
0.13055898249149323,
0.7352809309959412,
-0.43197354674339294,
-0.19741597771644592,
-0.9128476977348328,
0.5696115493774414,
-0.13338235020637512,
-0.327937513589859,
0.2861921489238739,
0.6412459015846252,
0.9233081340789795,
-0.3586355149745941,
0.8147479295730591,
0.04878072440624237,
0.06441155821084976,
-0.8904168605804443,
0.4641546607017517,
-0.47834157943725586,
-0.013696195557713509,
0.06328283995389938,
-0.9641903042793274,
-0.4337965250015259,
0.2454604059457779,
-0.3282824158668518,
0.03996013104915619,
1.0234692096710205,
0.5640289187431335,
-0.20444759726524353,
0.10248414427042007,
0.19494831562042236,
0.013544067740440369,
0.13726015388965607,
0.6156425476074219,
0.6675975322723389,
-0.09224144369363785,
0.21650345623493195,
-0.4583982527256012,
0.050145529210567474,
0.4475350081920624,
-0.6362663507461548,
-0.8093587756156921,
-0.41236549615859985,
-0.28468379378318787,
-0.20701533555984497,
0.24025921523571014,
0.782016932964325,
0.6110072731971741,
-0.9632065892219543,
-0.2345249503850937,
-0.8310084939002991,
0.04907866194844246,
-0.351535439491272,
-0.2965896725654602,
0.1388114094734192,
-0.9143742322921753,
-0.82039475440979,
0.7825708389282227,
0.16004876792430878,
-0.09979931265115738,
-0.071712426841259,
0.06588420271873474,
-0.33858543634414673,
-0.051468804478645325,
0.5092231631278992,
0.5027885437011719,
-0.6618826389312744,
-0.28823190927505493,
-0.0012567333178594708,
0.1097472608089447,
-0.037211667746305466,
1.0349828004837036,
-0.5460696220397949,
0.47474145889282227,
0.19569070637226105,
1.1226319074630737,
0.41843175888061523,
-0.0020435734186321497,
0.622492790222168,
-0.9192835092544556,
-0.0226274523884058,
0.3326147198677063,
0.23621869087219238,
0.2013428807258606,
-0.16692671179771423,
0.458099901676178,
0.5645561218261719,
-0.5989362001419067,
-0.33173516392707825,
0.4434574246406555,
-1.0614449977874756,
-0.3500015139579773,
0.9772751927375793,
-0.2945767045021057,
-0.24579909443855286,
-0.43767470121383667,
-0.020117998123168945,
0.22997412085533142,
0.06996449828147888,
0.7342780828475952,
0.6351785063743591,
0.008342591114342213,
-0.3076266050338745,
-0.5360313653945923,
0.22084537148475647,
0.7388203740119934,
-0.7920853495597839,
-0.18424555659294128,
0.36206746101379395,
0.5392308831214905,
0.15627066791057587,
0.33112093806266785,
0.19885118305683136,
0.37047383189201355,
-0.11680198460817337,
-0.1461561769247055,
0.25725802779197693,
-0.43826785683631897,
-0.3920430839061737,
0.18619464337825775,
-0.1611672341823578,
-0.0584239736199379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04395v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04395v1
|
SGNet: Folding Symmetrical Protein Complex with Deep Learning
| 2024-03-07T10:39:48 | 2024-03-07T10:39:48 |
Zhaoqun Li, Jingcheng Yu, Qiwei Ye
|
q-bio.BM
|
q-bio.BM, cs.CL
|
Deep learning has made significant progress in protein structure prediction,
advancing the development of computational biology. However, despite the high
accuracy achieved in predicting single-chain structures, a significant number
of large homo-oligomeric assemblies exhibit internal symmetry, posing a major
challenge in structure determination. The performances of existing deep
learning methods are limited since the symmetrical protein assembly usually has
a long sequence, making structural computation infeasible. In addition,
multiple identical subunits in symmetrical protein complex cause the issue of
supervision ambiguity in label assignment, requiring a consistent structure
modeling for the training. To tackle these problems, we propose a protein
folding framework called SGNet to model protein-protein interactions in
symmetrical assemblies. SGNet conducts feature extraction on a single subunit
and generates the whole assembly using our proposed symmetry module, which
largely mitigates computational problems caused by sequence length. Thanks to
the elaborate design of modeling symmetry consistently, we can model all global
symmetry types in quaternary protein structure prediction. Extensive
experimental results on a benchmark of symmetrical protein complexes further
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.12972351908683777,
-0.18040473759174347,
0.2927011251449585,
0.17820574343204498,
-0.2563117742538452,
0.024692978709936142,
0.2811838984489441,
-0.4692384600639343,
0.5215440392494202,
0.15547136962413788,
-0.7791915535926819,
-0.4580792188644409,
-0.5451639294624329,
0.17265775799751282,
-0.2614956498146057,
0.3315456211566925,
0.03953059762716293,
0.848461925983429,
-0.21972283720970154,
-0.2296236753463745,
0.2065281718969345,
-0.3647836744785309,
-0.5876445174217224,
-0.6792464852333069,
0.543152391910553,
0.13284386694431305,
0.6292501091957092,
0.8955586552619934,
0.6731917262077332,
0.5228891372680664,
-0.299925833940506,
0.14441508054733276,
-0.61568683385849,
0.09900497645139694,
0.25630730390548706,
-0.7588504552841187,
-0.9242526888847351,
0.15879404544830322,
0.7822499871253967,
1.0908143520355225,
-0.19905489683151245,
0.33232036232948303,
0.24855127930641174,
1.1271620988845825,
-0.1291273832321167,
0.35917171835899353,
-0.4838646948337555,
0.6004059910774231,
-0.12745483219623566,
0.33403855562210083,
0.09778138250112534,
0.040040284395217896,
-0.06460759788751602,
-0.3946393132209778,
0.25264501571655273,
-0.2920062839984894,
0.81166011095047,
0.19437499344348907,
-0.4479010999202728,
0.0767388716340065,
-0.18520495295524597,
0.401283860206604,
-0.7266663312911987,
0.32696178555488586,
0.25129276514053345,
0.6027262210845947,
-0.6226259469985962,
-0.7853662967681885,
-0.22915500402450562,
-0.12866154313087463,
0.17314289510250092,
0.4785681962966919,
0.3527926802635193,
0.3422362506389618,
0.06187098100781441,
0.5592806935310364,
-0.9107158780097961,
0.024502798914909363,
-0.5176871418952942,
0.3150290846824646,
0.7663844227790833,
0.266693651676178,
0.4643535912036896,
-0.04017413407564163,
-0.3613533079624176,
0.14631563425064087,
-0.41406163573265076,
0.1676502525806427,
0.5950819253921509,
0.5728328824043274,
-0.06333494931459427,
0.600067138671875,
-0.2253636121749878,
0.2495483011007309,
0.37236157059669495,
0.24334393441677094,
0.5366659164428711,
0.1790567934513092,
-0.6921606063842773,
0.34644949436187744,
0.7433324456214905,
0.2388027161359787,
-0.18726079165935516,
-0.13305841386318207,
0.03827589750289917,
-0.00600715447217226,
0.27405402064323425,
-0.9165558815002441,
-0.4327562749385834,
0.5652289390563965,
-0.8729664087295532,
-0.26396051049232483,
0.6927071213722229,
-0.5696380138397217,
-0.4142002761363983,
-0.4457089304924011,
0.5259448885917664,
-0.08787377178668976,
-0.028809962794184685,
0.6342541575431824,
-0.3212295174598694,
0.03161090984940529,
0.05353453382849693,
-0.5425452589988708,
0.23716914653778076,
0.9803467392921448,
0.8525974750518799,
-0.15560318529605865,
-0.5339730978012085,
-0.4818938374519348,
0.22616128623485565,
-0.013742008246481419,
0.14700980484485626,
-0.2814329266548157,
0.04304628074169159,
-0.33280298113822937,
0.25048285722732544,
0.2496471405029297,
-0.21005259454250336,
0.211017906665802,
-0.22718976438045502,
-0.04236428812146187,
-0.2714471220970154,
-0.6910726428031921,
-0.39424702525138855,
0.17130157351493835,
-0.8310539722442627,
0.1305246502161026,
-0.2339785397052765,
-0.6415382027626038,
-0.03665141388773918,
-0.049408573657274246,
-0.25287479162216187,
0.11377041786909103,
-0.5825332403182983,
-0.8010910749435425,
0.3135368824005127,
-0.07671115547418594,
0.4028857946395874,
-0.07085903733968735,
0.40916338562965393,
-1.0202951431274414,
-0.3826574683189392,
0.11003696918487549,
0.004021989181637764,
1.1135368347167969,
0.015513915568590164,
-0.17450904846191406,
0.18646679818630219,
-0.642491340637207,
0.10023587197065353,
0.0835188776254654,
0.00882934220135212,
0.04405553266406059,
-0.21766193211078644,
-0.7272929549217224,
0.10032445192337036,
0.18348459899425507,
-0.4440965950489044,
0.7178259491920471,
-0.4603634774684906,
0.37897226214408875,
0.9034522175788879,
-0.14563989639282227,
0.8261656165122986,
-0.07505272328853607,
0.23552259802818298,
0.18706756830215454,
0.4828687608242035,
0.25402262806892395,
-0.5675445795059204,
-0.5962314009666443,
-0.16662698984146118,
0.13513819873332977,
0.0643191859126091,
-0.25964978337287903,
0.2993564009666443,
-0.045097995549440384,
-0.5677399039268494,
-0.2345767617225647,
0.024301931262016296,
0.4774586856365204,
0.30785825848579407,
0.2733179032802582,
-0.5497276186943054,
-0.558835506439209,
-0.937555730342865,
-0.3511194884777069,
-0.16440165042877197,
-0.1041325107216835,
0.08356379717588425,
0.38392725586891174,
-0.22689372301101685,
0.2968432903289795,
-0.35729002952575684,
-0.41912969946861267,
0.06896696984767914,
0.3093613088130951,
0.695963442325592,
0.4971987009048462,
0.4440551996231079,
-1.0185261964797974,
-0.4124810993671417,
-0.0023782863281667233,
-1.1219544410705566,
0.22237735986709595,
-0.20201793313026428,
-0.167453333735466,
-0.23366332054138184,
0.4665394425392151,
-0.6010690331459045,
0.5302807688713074,
0.45905885100364685,
-0.03324982523918152,
0.5348960161209106,
0.04305095225572586,
-0.006599988788366318,
-0.9306644201278687,
-0.21233657002449036,
-0.08834921568632126,
-0.037835437804460526,
-0.56912761926651,
0.3034188151359558,
-0.01416775956749916,
-0.16323056817054749,
-0.20019277930259705,
0.16099563241004944,
-0.7229488492012024,
-0.06566156446933746,
-0.12480402737855911,
-0.5048238039016724,
0.000011844181244669016,
0.4070743918418884,
-0.4072679877281189,
0.2798774242401123,
0.6372323632240295,
-0.34766343235969543,
0.25519412755966187,
0.31844356656074524,
-0.05357499420642853,
-0.0811033621430397,
-0.7633868455886841,
-0.05715952813625336,
-0.45241495966911316,
0.3066053092479706,
-0.8290976881980896,
-0.4472384750843048,
0.5396917462348938,
-0.6143514513969421,
0.4913802146911621,
-0.4298895001411438,
0.24937626719474792,
-0.35661718249320984,
-0.6453039646148682,
0.3714652359485626,
-0.06056490167975426,
-0.48709791898727417,
1.0221383571624756,
0.49631068110466003,
0.06292732805013657,
-0.7676874995231628,
-1.076955795288086,
-0.07363677024841309,
0.12088604271411896,
-0.6755076050758362,
0.5359035134315491,
-0.10676734149456024,
0.04840802401304245,
-0.15819361805915833,
-0.8044579029083252,
-0.1241203173995018,
-0.02726493962109089,
0.8569732904434204,
-0.09103842824697495,
-0.4973476827144623,
0.02549455501139164,
0.11048666387796402,
-0.2775714099407196,
0.055650416761636734,
-0.5150055885314941,
0.5476437211036682,
-0.45657065510749817,
-0.3577542006969452,
-0.7322052121162415,
0.7228805422782898,
0.6912820935249329,
-0.13977010548114777,
0.6960535645484924,
0.42538654804229736,
-0.4383002817630768,
-0.26079198718070984,
0.00015284529945347458,
-0.17614710330963135,
-0.5812931060791016,
0.610414445400238,
-0.5494973659515381,
-0.40665403008461,
0.7350465655326843,
-0.043693870306015015,
-0.11753839999437332,
0.1277247965335846,
-0.006522535812109709,
-0.4779019355773926,
1.2088000774383545,
0.8122367262840271,
0.0067093162797391415,
0.3935207724571228,
-0.3009476661682129,
0.41817209124565125,
-0.4342447817325592,
-0.3991107642650604,
-0.5196755528450012,
-0.9234755039215088,
-0.42034777998924255,
-0.2810411751270294,
0.18959960341453552,
0.8930163979530334,
-0.6494238972663879,
0.35739240050315857,
-0.3912311792373657,
0.5460402965545654,
0.4862442910671234,
0.5379398465156555,
0.003972578328102827,
0.5163453817367554,
-0.33719107508659363,
0.09317198395729065,
-0.6756671667098999,
-0.1526670902967453,
0.5461785793304443,
0.3126526474952698,
0.8964006304740906,
0.07546517997980118,
0.9452866911888123,
-0.19465377926826477,
-0.015372763387858868,
-0.6404697299003601,
0.5964028835296631,
-0.7895673513412476,
0.04126279056072235,
-0.17508947849273682,
-0.9822437763214111,
-0.6880572438240051,
-0.1685253083705902,
-0.03896480053663254,
-0.44493359327316284,
0.5123440623283386,
0.09541696310043335,
0.11470481008291245,
0.41882461309432983,
-0.4204752743244171,
0.5564403533935547,
-0.4702463150024414,
0.1339888721704483,
-0.012353625148534775,
-0.8594791293144226,
0.3254804015159607,
0.43858641386032104,
-0.32876595854759216,
-0.04369865357875824,
0.18451166152954102,
0.251207172870636,
-0.4088835120201111,
0.9704625010490417,
0.08113675564527512,
0.20427174866199493,
-0.15258187055587769,
0.46217799186706543,
0.1445319652557373,
0.45316171646118164,
-0.4720914363861084,
0.6046929955482483,
-0.32589343190193176,
-0.5208911299705505,
-0.6253904104232788,
0.666995108127594,
-0.8007278442382812,
-0.4980849325656891,
-0.34920328855514526,
-0.22026239335536957,
0.02037067897617817,
0.4203296899795532,
0.4048406481742859,
0.4033259153366089,
0.1275799721479416,
0.05137922242283821,
0.3056701421737671,
0.15415216982364655,
0.2926686704158783,
-0.12780345976352692,
-0.4462691843509674,
-0.7961655855178833,
0.7176914215087891,
0.2754364609718323,
0.2007550746202469,
0.31463170051574707,
0.23281635344028473,
0.19313064217567444,
-0.5539345145225525,
-0.31126540899276733,
0.2385239601135254,
-0.5834389925003052,
-0.43283742666244507,
-0.45475372672080994,
-0.498738557100296,
-0.4155881404876709,
-0.20552614331245422,
-0.6242725253105164,
-0.49251997470855713,
-0.0877511203289032,
-0.1608370840549469,
-0.4410834312438965,
0.4511239528656006,
-0.013131000101566315,
0.012852995656430721,
-0.7489882111549377,
0.6550321578979492,
0.35558080673217773,
0.5171919465065002,
0.12879811227321625,
-0.0956767126917839,
-0.017825720831751823,
0.4017891585826874,
-0.11461329460144043,
-0.8490760326385498,
0.2108445167541504,
0.4825156331062317,
0.686260998249054,
0.6215407252311707,
-0.22973251342773438,
0.8666540384292603,
-0.47581911087036133,
0.5424538254737854,
0.5222911834716797,
-0.682608962059021,
0.2136625200510025,
-0.130003422498703,
0.36153584718704224,
0.30023661255836487,
0.7178635001182556,
-0.2487306445837021,
-0.18711835145950317,
-0.3998246192932129,
-1.1090872287750244,
0.43929433822631836,
0.28813838958740234,
-0.1282631903886795,
0.12931886315345764,
0.6983988285064697,
0.3628116250038147,
0.2389245331287384,
-0.8465633988380432,
-0.5485109090805054,
-0.2841966450214386,
-0.3455120623111725,
0.21480141580104828,
-0.1504058688879013,
-0.2440979778766632,
-0.24313443899154663,
0.705242931842804,
-0.3714589476585388,
0.5256819725036621,
0.2572314441204071,
0.003477908903732896,
-0.2263740599155426,
-0.4965415298938751,
0.38262179493904114,
0.5152522325515747,
-0.25785645842552185,
0.19344021379947662,
-0.40170788764953613,
-0.4708716571331024,
0.07934346050024033,
0.07547975331544876,
-0.41013428568840027,
-0.12498360127210617,
0.43189364671707153,
0.394828736782074,
-0.3537725508213043,
0.07967475801706314,
0.28154101967811584,
-0.372537761926651,
-0.4314038157463074,
-0.02443348802626133,
-0.006391651928424835,
0.21025453507900238,
0.6479803323745728,
0.3733062744140625,
0.3580465316772461,
0.29805466532707214,
-0.4013954997062683,
0.4273955225944519,
0.34804946184158325,
-0.6635788679122925,
-0.34854140877723694,
0.3937809467315674,
0.08701559156179428,
-0.38413986563682556,
0.6952816843986511,
-0.10217881202697754,
-0.7242172956466675,
0.98652583360672,
0.4540036916732788,
1.171667456626892,
-0.4400441348552704,
0.39501258730888367,
0.5294188857078552,
0.10134439915418625,
-0.21082749962806702,
0.4667513072490692,
0.19656112790107727,
-0.4713630974292755,
0.04987833648920059,
-0.8313583135604858,
0.18556977808475494,
-0.114007867872715,
-0.5002296566963196,
0.33375823497772217,
-0.5644674301147461,
-0.00476595526561141,
0.10535814613103867,
-0.0829559937119484,
-0.10384199768304825,
-0.18746118247509003,
0.5147609114646912,
0.8067664504051208,
-0.68063884973526,
0.5985026359558105,
0.8728595972061157,
-0.4420209228992462,
-0.6179865598678589,
-0.045960891991853714,
0.39977961778640747,
-0.31847816705703735,
0.6336159110069275,
0.7668142318725586,
-0.4962095320224762,
-0.42910268902778625,
-0.699126124382019,
-0.5432553291320801,
1.0115704536437988,
0.7138938307762146,
-0.8335263133049011,
-0.1688750833272934,
0.4541575610637665,
0.3155781924724579,
-0.44197383522987366,
-0.13634583353996277,
-0.41664788126945496,
0.3277945816516876,
-0.09903278201818466,
-0.43929553031921387,
-0.040016282349824905,
-0.3652825355529785,
-0.18397745490074158,
0.28338199853897095,
-0.7856623530387878,
1.0336265563964844,
0.13421697914600372,
-0.3446301221847534,
0.3363354504108429,
0.9180710315704346,
-0.16151843965053558,
0.1343294233083725,
0.21216733753681183,
0.5420979261398315,
0.9074954390525818,
0.1281583160161972,
0.45703282952308655,
0.049207065254449844,
0.4328148066997528,
1.1389732360839844,
-0.21106132864952087,
0.4988580644130707,
0.5233778357505798,
0.19108527898788452,
0.048207495361566544,
0.37603524327278137,
-0.2504931390285492,
0.28521060943603516,
0.3143446445465088,
0.022394519299268723,
-0.5553635954856873,
0.20946352183818817,
-0.5761687159538269,
0.361845463514328,
0.20079919695854187,
-0.2546946704387665,
-0.22994278371334076,
-0.1905568689107895,
-0.5301239490509033,
0.04789571836590767,
-0.6895084977149963,
0.47097814083099365,
0.6215691566467285,
0.002358647994697094,
0.268928587436676,
-0.13134406507015228,
0.37574997544288635,
-0.6282551288604736,
-0.1632600873708725,
-0.4635784924030304,
0.4479598104953766,
-0.2452155351638794,
-0.71964031457901,
0.24217811226844788,
-0.8152311444282532,
-0.5737163424491882,
-0.024258650839328766,
0.5642035007476807,
-0.5110287666320801,
-0.6888734698295593,
0.5483494400978088,
0.009452937170863152,
-0.17296355962753296,
-0.13587544858455658,
-1.0177041292190552,
0.03774188831448555,
-0.021601717919111252,
-0.11230549216270447,
0.49953439831733704,
0.4307391345500946,
0.12300069630146027,
0.8233234286308289,
0.44794872403144836,
-0.23158280551433563,
0.07585714757442474,
0.017315221950411797,
0.8393047451972961,
-0.7509154677391052,
-0.4882284104824066,
-0.7282423377037048,
0.5052292943000793,
-0.42474281787872314,
-0.21455945074558258,
0.3540630638599396,
0.4332115650177002,
0.766606867313385,
-0.3150845766067505,
0.10954798758029938,
0.3270581364631653,
-0.40087926387786865,
-0.4158882796764374,
0.9940328598022461,
-0.7517701983451843,
0.025741301476955414,
-0.15263113379478455,
-0.874545693397522,
-0.8976328372955322,
0.6922377943992615,
0.25267571210861206,
-0.07578501850366592,
0.5874931812286377,
0.8129104375839233,
-0.5085601806640625,
0.3630122244358063,
-0.007434581406414509,
0.5942765474319458,
0.5182285308837891,
0.4124875068664551,
0.4639967083930969,
-0.7216793894767761,
0.41245120763778687,
-0.5125563144683838,
-0.17547594010829926,
-0.3193739950656891,
-0.985990047454834,
-1.076340913772583,
-0.4952573776245117,
-0.2885129749774933,
-0.35535135865211487,
0.25022512674331665,
0.7692677974700928,
0.8599938154220581,
-0.8250905871391296,
-0.48489809036254883,
-0.4271368086338043,
-0.060239069163799286,
-0.5182042121887207,
-0.11072194576263428,
0.3549155294895172,
-0.2209547460079193,
-0.3836248815059662,
0.44355112314224243,
0.8346946239471436,
0.169786736369133,
0.11661700904369354,
-0.24293704330921173,
-0.14190050959587097,
-0.3602004051208496,
0.3220815658569336,
0.5227791666984558,
-0.5832909941673279,
-0.022510237991809845,
0.13801299035549164,
-0.5266863107681274,
0.0578811950981617,
0.5927810072898865,
-0.33910834789276123,
0.21719039976596832,
0.9994960427284241,
0.7919067740440369,
0.42120686173439026,
-0.06708381325006485,
1.0197086334228516,
-0.40712082386016846,
-0.10923348367214203,
0.2605496048927307,
0.41116994619369507,
-0.12074176967144012,
-0.567937433719635,
0.46932491660118103,
-0.024782178923487663,
-0.4793391227722168,
-0.5977298021316528,
0.6020782589912415,
-1.3787580728530884,
-0.5314319133758545,
0.4043034315109253,
-0.2881925702095032,
-0.721932590007782,
0.2971000075340271,
0.040846869349479675,
0.3839864134788513,
-0.08281544595956802,
0.9358746409416199,
0.18709012866020203,
-0.13625043630599976,
0.07496418058872223,
-0.02091877907514572,
0.4326121211051941,
0.5771432518959045,
-0.22018510103225708,
0.02447269670665264,
0.005735620856285095,
0.08661817759275436,
0.01993943564593792,
-0.18573056161403656,
-0.24277803301811218,
0.28870806097984314,
0.04314647987484932,
0.05649767443537712,
-0.64870685338974,
-0.7129114270210266,
-0.5120989084243774,
0.4442055821418762,
-0.4567565619945526,
-0.19176504015922546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04382v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04382v1
|
Acceleron: A Tool to Accelerate Research Ideation
| 2024-03-07T10:20:06 | 2024-03-07T10:20:06 |
Harshit Nigam, Manasi Patwardhan, Lovekesh Vig, Gautam Shroff
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Several tools have recently been proposed for assisting researchers during
various stages of the research life-cycle. However, these primarily concentrate
on tasks such as retrieving and recommending relevant literature, reviewing and
critiquing the draft, and writing of research manuscripts. Our investigation
reveals a significant gap in availability of tools specifically designed to
assist researchers during the challenging ideation phase of the research
life-cycle. To aid with research ideation, we propose `Acceleron', a research
accelerator for different phases of the research life cycle, and which is
specially designed to aid the ideation process. Acceleron guides researchers
through the formulation of a comprehensive research proposal, encompassing a
novel research problem. The proposals motivation is validated for novelty by
identifying gaps in the existing literature and suggesting a plausible list of
techniques to solve the proposed problem. We leverage the reasoning and
domain-specific skills of Large Language Models (LLMs) to create an agent-based
architecture incorporating colleague and mentor personas for LLMs. The LLM
agents emulate the ideation process undertaken by researchers, engaging
researchers in an interactive fashion to aid in the development of the research
proposal. Notably, our tool addresses challenges inherent in LLMs, such as
hallucinations, implements a two-stage aspect-based retrieval to manage
precision-recall trade-offs, and tackles issues of unanswerability. As
evaluation, we illustrate the execution of our motivation validation and method
synthesis workflows on proposals from the ML and NLP domain, given by 3
distinct researchers. Our observations and evaluations provided by the
researchers illustrate the efficacy of the tool in terms of assisting
researchers with appropriate inputs at distinct stages and thus leading to
improved time efficiency.
|
[
-0.48603856563568115,
-0.7047620415687561,
0.7311559319496155,
0.021187273785471916,
-0.1299448162317276,
0.3265628516674042,
-0.051841672509908676,
-0.5214422345161438,
0.3179990351200104,
0.03363244608044624,
-0.638913631439209,
-0.06586749851703644,
-0.13044433295726776,
0.11059531569480896,
-0.5962554812431335,
0.5581637620925903,
-0.3285053074359894,
0.004952855873852968,
-0.2660236954689026,
0.2444215565919876,
-0.40514686703681946,
-0.26197537779808044,
-1.0229301452636719,
-0.8538388609886169,
0.6514714360237122,
0.3667657971382141,
0.5593123435974121,
0.2978963851928711,
0.5412493944168091,
0.28798821568489075,
-0.14568033814430237,
0.09985272586345673,
-0.05924297869205475,
0.4597671926021576,
-0.08998408168554306,
-0.25953686237335205,
-0.5098558664321899,
-0.21892622113227844,
0.17588405311107635,
0.754274845123291,
-0.17853225767612457,
0.06787944585084915,
-0.0493764765560627,
0.5268297791481018,
-0.4581778943538666,
-0.12360722571611404,
-0.48681923747062683,
0.07741832733154297,
-0.03549722582101822,
-0.26064053177833557,
-0.17575600743293762,
-0.353787362575531,
-0.033819880336523056,
-0.7676577568054199,
0.2869264483451843,
0.062496475875377655,
0.5292161703109741,
0.09980883449316025,
0.23555275797843933,
-0.4222939610481262,
-0.8745321035385132,
0.2512562870979309,
-0.7446621656417847,
0.07066941261291504,
0.08177880942821503,
0.2933787405490875,
-0.2420518398284912,
-0.7907830476760864,
-0.6041622161865234,
-0.07205802202224731,
-0.07323453575372696,
-0.2414679080247879,
-0.010720771737396717,
0.052047669887542725,
-0.04539494216442108,
0.17491908371448517,
-0.6171741485595703,
-0.11092089861631393,
-0.08587124198675156,
-0.33898743987083435,
0.46549010276794434,
0.20284800231456757,
0.08592116087675095,
-0.04863657057285309,
0.1051560491323471,
-0.045916568487882614,
-0.5151010751724243,
-0.1156075969338417,
0.19380465149879456,
0.31607797741889954,
0.22068507969379425,
0.6227501630783081,
-0.24292103946208954,
0.39207524061203003,
0.12429793179035187,
0.4885895550251007,
0.3116130530834198,
-0.5609892010688782,
0.017563892528414726,
0.46042144298553467,
0.6164102554321289,
-0.1451505422592163,
-0.0787552148103714,
-0.2425795942544937,
-0.27680522203445435,
0.2790197432041168,
0.5638961791992188,
-0.9937563538551331,
-0.23138916492462158,
0.6359375715255737,
-0.19934900104999542,
-0.5374886989593506,
-0.20165716111660004,
-0.6290073990821838,
-0.39701637625694275,
-0.05376282334327698,
0.4486561417579651,
-0.5177522301673889,
-0.333880752325058,
0.03941768407821655,
-0.38083335757255554,
0.22683247923851013,
0.4142957627773285,
-0.5835710763931274,
0.1497870534658432,
0.6998882293701172,
0.936512291431427,
0.06088854745030403,
-0.33366137742996216,
-0.18426595628261566,
-0.09919240325689316,
-0.44505318999290466,
1.2602394819259644,
-0.9094579219818115,
-0.6927693486213684,
0.0681556835770607,
-0.03434839844703674,
0.07697098702192307,
-0.16915160417556763,
0.7161502838134766,
-0.5934020280838013,
0.08760730922222137,
-0.12496627867221832,
-0.4344642162322998,
-0.12629133462905884,
0.1698811799287796,
-0.4920671880245209,
1.0168890953063965,
0.25236818194389343,
-0.5692777037620544,
0.28890636563301086,
-0.8849837183952332,
-0.6481862664222717,
0.5259471535682678,
-0.40071114897727966,
-0.2591516673564911,
0.09936591237783432,
0.12724009156227112,
0.16228711605072021,
-0.49785906076431274,
0.17357560992240906,
0.06499035656452179,
-0.33573266863822937,
0.21964587271213531,
-0.021434692665934563,
0.5348301529884338,
0.2690199017524719,
-0.3317899703979492,
0.30438366532325745,
-0.6610360145568848,
-0.030799798667430878,
0.22983293235301971,
-0.02415565960109234,
-0.34503310918807983,
-0.17832879722118378,
0.06691451370716095,
0.11861627548933029,
0.226067915558815,
-0.5694727301597595,
0.16642366349697113,
-0.4594821631908417,
0.5735592246055603,
0.5341416001319885,
0.2914801836013794,
0.40942147374153137,
-0.41102924942970276,
0.9130465984344482,
-0.4384315609931946,
-0.15115347504615784,
-0.4423784911632538,
-0.3998132646083832,
-0.6008936166763306,
0.38604000210762024,
0.2570229470729828,
0.20086142420768738,
-0.8506322503089905,
0.38931724429130554,
0.14178068935871124,
-0.6714221835136414,
-0.8557730913162231,
-0.026621585711836815,
0.18980883061885834,
0.6045442223548889,
0.0895175039768219,
-0.3718584477901459,
-0.6186586618423462,
-0.6656140685081482,
-0.049932800233364105,
-0.12968023121356964,
0.00019719359988812357,
0.2411603331565857,
0.6165841817855835,
-0.13907526433467865,
0.7162868976593018,
-0.3480954170227051,
-0.17351949214935303,
-0.2964518368244171,
0.6159666180610657,
0.2137954980134964,
0.37605851888656616,
0.32850050926208496,
-0.8912994861602783,
-0.14044204354286194,
0.15638452768325806,
-0.7909790277481079,
-0.13678079843521118,
-0.15879885852336884,
-0.20068033039569855,
-0.27160730957984924,
0.39522480964660645,
-0.8745993375778198,
0.1941242814064026,
-0.019797636196017265,
-0.4055761396884918,
0.5329821705818176,
-0.26986902952194214,
0.44722023606300354,
-0.8537189364433289,
0.5325766801834106,
-0.24661725759506226,
0.02847437374293804,
-0.7457549571990967,
-0.1732216328382492,
0.08003992587327957,
-0.2895824611186981,
-0.4520415961742401,
0.643441915512085,
-0.23571431636810303,
0.24472549557685852,
-0.6461023092269897,
0.5673624277114868,
0.3207697570323944,
0.14212611317634583,
-0.05870196595788002,
1.0668449401855469,
0.3609515428543091,
-0.7950049638748169,
0.15459725260734558,
0.6341246962547302,
-0.4413229823112488,
0.45458781719207764,
-0.8514946103096008,
0.43847939372062683,
-0.07566868513822556,
0.08069267868995667,
-0.6943094730377197,
-0.1428627073764801,
0.10359802842140198,
-0.5860283970832825,
0.04952086880803108,
0.2645360231399536,
-0.3884061276912689,
-0.6328921318054199,
-0.3190397322177887,
0.573564350605011,
0.13348810374736786,
-0.1676664650440216,
0.7468234300613403,
0.47180137038230896,
-0.5623247027397156,
-0.3709142804145813,
-0.5762392282485962,
0.17690519988536835,
-0.09047524631023407,
-0.574767529964447,
0.8554562330245972,
-0.24245212972164154,
-0.37499722838401794,
0.33074188232421875,
0.15171460807323456,
0.22228842973709106,
0.15497708320617676,
0.11244785785675049,
0.3065016567707062,
0.17654775083065033,
0.23994646966457367,
0.032225240021944046,
-0.14423111081123352,
0.3348572254180908,
-0.21448595821857452,
0.7396678924560547,
0.09394745528697968,
-0.16840803623199463,
-0.12951640784740448,
0.1725948303937912,
0.33618849515914917,
-0.11129151284694672,
0.40197840332984924,
0.5035135746002197,
-0.3667275905609131,
-0.31495052576065063,
-0.33188754320144653,
-0.39878153800964355,
-0.49541914463043213,
0.1796417385339737,
-0.3257848024368286,
-0.521736204624176,
0.5237774848937988,
-0.24367327988147736,
0.3893131613731384,
0.30968719720840454,
0.7645928263664246,
0.2600038945674896,
0.7655232548713684,
0.522230327129364,
0.05880078673362732,
0.5427674055099487,
-0.4486917555332184,
0.21177691221237183,
-1.2035412788391113,
-0.34279417991638184,
-0.636863112449646,
-0.3362552225589752,
0.143313467502594,
-0.41812220215797424,
0.36574026942253113,
-0.39368849992752075,
0.04049251601099968,
0.38880616426467896,
-0.8226736783981323,
0.1891326904296875,
0.1587064564228058,
-0.2056671380996704,
0.28195929527282715,
-0.36303457617759705,
-0.2893159091472626,
0.23994947969913483,
-0.894325852394104,
-0.5511576533317566,
1.022557258605957,
-0.07414204627275467,
0.7432683706283569,
-0.316025972366333,
0.5845329761505127,
0.7643356323242188,
0.2661747932434082,
-0.9145110249519348,
0.5914861559867859,
0.6326152682304382,
-0.8218168020248413,
-0.26452168822288513,
-0.13026608526706696,
-1.2388545274734497,
0.3911776542663574,
-0.1186799705028534,
-0.6180811524391174,
0.46111834049224854,
-0.03829670697450638,
-0.47052305936813354,
0.04600207135081291,
-0.10258805006742477,
0.5475526452064514,
-0.3531948924064636,
-0.49159201979637146,
-0.3967801332473755,
-0.4240801930427551,
0.04655136540532112,
-0.39022916555404663,
0.4885607063770294,
-0.1867978572845459,
0.15949010848999023,
0.9587456583976746,
-0.31200698018074036,
0.2852391302585602,
-0.09754609316587448,
-0.013062497600913048,
0.5693798661231995,
0.2732546627521515,
0.581967294216156,
-0.057591814547777176,
-0.5189918279647827,
-0.22980636358261108,
-0.27753791213035583,
0.01659662090241909,
-0.4276934862136841,
0.7186649441719055,
-0.40554535388946533,
-0.5184082984924316,
-0.3329682946205139,
-0.8396710753440857,
-0.06729935854673386,
0.2966330945491791,
0.13878004252910614,
0.39182156324386597,
-0.6336286664009094,
-0.010664361529052258,
0.2634585201740265,
0.062011588364839554,
0.5889999866485596,
0.5219505429267883,
-0.28000709414482117,
-0.17040002346038818,
0.5183890461921692,
-0.21266598999500275,
-0.01676776260137558,
0.2905791103839874,
0.12079571187496185,
-0.0795036256313324,
-0.6492467522621155,
-0.35137638449668884,
0.17388461530208588,
-0.6338369250297546,
-0.22253456711769104,
-0.617099940776825,
-0.25333791971206665,
-0.5283043384552002,
-0.47718751430511475,
-0.5730701684951782,
-0.7387264966964722,
-0.14389000833034515,
-0.0915341004729271,
0.3265090584754944,
0.6019772887229919,
-0.17419913411140442,
0.13480894267559052,
-0.482365220785141,
0.25719913840293884,
0.04173026233911514,
-0.16202712059020996,
0.3938492238521576,
-0.6835898160934448,
-0.6103328466415405,
-0.07365395128726959,
-0.503216028213501,
-0.4751964807510376,
0.5393888354301453,
0.053607743233442307,
0.6756547093391418,
0.4138626754283905,
-0.028636472299695015,
0.35239270329475403,
-0.5753576159477234,
0.6473360061645508,
-0.051805127412080765,
-0.6439675092697144,
0.8645203709602356,
-0.2560827136039734,
0.27206531167030334,
0.8736400604248047,
0.3013000786304474,
-0.43656033277511597,
-0.28493618965148926,
-0.6461198329925537,
-1.065598964691162,
0.47278836369514465,
0.571502149105072,
-0.2066754549741745,
0.1697034239768982,
0.4528239965438843,
0.17186391353607178,
0.4871393144130707,
-0.30630701780319214,
-0.21928220987319946,
0.05508781224489212,
0.05964080989360809,
0.14324460923671722,
0.14033976197242737,
-0.5324236750602722,
-0.09792351722717285,
0.8914554119110107,
-0.05510051175951958,
0.3689713180065155,
0.46231257915496826,
0.056542448699474335,
-0.5984287858009338,
0.38230106234550476,
0.1896141618490219,
0.8833385705947876,
-0.22096967697143555,
0.0428222194314003,
-0.13549280166625977,
-0.34877532720565796,
0.4424762427806854,
0.499874085187912,
-0.4139612913131714,
0.048451829701662064,
0.2194737195968628,
0.3590448796749115,
0.2456342726945877,
-0.6966325044631958,
0.13049495220184326,
-0.2695709466934204,
-0.43074801564216614,
-0.4151468276977539,
0.22291193902492523,
0.14426681399345398,
0.33697444200515747,
0.5343834757804871,
0.09016335755586624,
0.25426819920539856,
-0.5925486087799072,
0.22174787521362305,
0.5514471530914307,
-0.3504464626312256,
-0.40377911925315857,
0.8222609758377075,
0.28923672437667847,
-0.9924402236938477,
0.23248186707496643,
-0.35779520869255066,
-0.29922401905059814,
0.7175593972206116,
0.46415191888809204,
1.0229192972183228,
-0.25982412695884705,
0.5153787732124329,
0.044586945325136185,
0.3107173442840576,
-0.06382057815790176,
0.3451662063598633,
-0.0020670408848673105,
-0.8858134150505066,
-0.10100498795509338,
-0.7177478671073914,
-0.6304331421852112,
0.11576054245233536,
-0.4513392448425293,
0.1985846757888794,
-0.15497201681137085,
-0.27255719900131226,
0.3519168496131897,
-0.023519685491919518,
-0.7924842238426208,
-0.19362150132656097,
-0.07168049365282059,
0.8407124876976013,
-0.5895006060600281,
0.7579373121261597,
0.9560537338256836,
-0.2440032809972763,
-0.561398446559906,
-0.3598206043243408,
0.10901810228824615,
-0.7242306470870972,
0.3493739068508148,
0.043671660125255585,
-0.47077882289886475,
0.0566629134118557,
-0.228853240609169,
-0.6423801779747009,
1.4652323722839355,
-0.20386648178100586,
-0.49114304780960083,
-0.1903253048658371,
-0.27715441584587097,
0.49905064702033997,
-0.9172433614730835,
0.1744934469461441,
0.6395134329795837,
0.6631827354431152,
0.332747220993042,
-0.5978913903236389,
0.14760875701904297,
-0.4713428318500519,
-0.29293105006217957,
0.37799492478370667,
-0.4396132230758667,
0.8123834133148193,
-0.29809439182281494,
-0.15012483298778534,
0.18328090012073517,
0.4160380959510803,
0.353534996509552,
0.5571607351303101,
0.3329716920852661,
0.380723237991333,
0.9281379580497742,
0.3967694044113159,
1.0288184881210327,
-0.6573846340179443,
-0.004216732457280159,
0.8072100281715393,
-0.47535252571105957,
0.5022647976875305,
0.5012378692626953,
-0.13348770141601562,
0.7038094997406006,
0.5036595463752747,
-0.07658487558364868,
0.5494245886802673,
-0.18692074716091156,
-0.3191884160041809,
-0.10159758478403091,
-0.433841347694397,
-0.40261736512184143,
0.08488394320011139,
0.669070303440094,
-0.28585466742515564,
-0.09172781556844711,
0.06622379273176193,
0.08424872159957886,
0.10065703094005585,
-0.2351921796798706,
0.4370867609977722,
0.3651324510574341,
-0.7097345590591431,
0.2545197606086731,
-0.17549657821655273,
0.2733815014362335,
-0.7407291531562805,
-0.010714273899793625,
-0.06356650590896606,
0.17601022124290466,
-0.04110867157578468,
-0.5863288044929504,
0.06588814407587051,
-0.199085533618927,
0.1398368626832962,
-0.022821467369794846,
0.8317229747772217,
-0.03146416321396828,
-0.7528414130210876,
0.3103291988372803,
0.8288125991821289,
0.08597077429294586,
0.02878144383430481,
-0.8534156680107117,
0.14231745898723602,
-0.2157272845506668,
-0.5087966322898865,
0.15947489440441132,
0.6085425019264221,
0.36952629685401917,
0.8514174818992615,
0.35772252082824707,
0.5112935900688171,
-0.638497531414032,
0.25926172733306885,
1.214232325553894,
-0.7776995301246643,
-0.21111169457435608,
-0.7052673101425171,
0.2085050791501999,
-0.07517789304256439,
-0.24095812439918518,
0.7020463347434998,
0.5437795519828796,
0.4120340645313263,
0.3182845711708069,
0.9664623737335205,
-0.2576148509979248,
0.3519344627857208,
-0.27867910265922546,
0.3607981503009796,
-0.5173586010932922,
0.5712794661521912,
-0.3084089159965515,
-0.896389901638031,
-0.15851137042045593,
0.8158862590789795,
-0.18028123676776886,
0.06119593232870102,
0.9664936661720276,
0.7472463250160217,
0.21673695743083954,
0.16529615223407745,
0.009380361065268517,
0.058409519493579865,
0.670159101486206,
0.37926042079925537,
0.8234777450561523,
-0.22197546064853668,
0.5274722576141357,
-0.23468226194381714,
-0.1673111617565155,
-0.261333703994751,
-0.6695469617843628,
-0.9488645195960999,
-0.3787124752998352,
-0.11331372708082199,
-0.23447482287883759,
0.11241108924150467,
0.9126995801925659,
0.5798706412315369,
-0.5096662044525146,
-0.41171786189079285,
-0.4527079463005066,
0.08768714219331741,
-0.38300052285194397,
-0.25379300117492676,
0.31390348076820374,
-0.5153504014015198,
-0.3297920525074005,
0.6986111402511597,
0.3448563814163208,
-0.19177988171577454,
-0.5350341200828552,
0.06280859559774399,
-0.46081092953681946,
0.3550140857696533,
0.32812175154685974,
0.21969492733478546,
-0.2560059130191803,
-0.10860056430101395,
-0.050081249326467514,
0.19433295726776123,
0.22955386340618134,
1.4076117277145386,
-1.0869253873825073,
0.43322616815567017,
0.278131902217865,
0.6610369086265564,
0.6507987976074219,
0.16656345129013062,
0.7420217394828796,
-0.3967196047306061,
0.3861156105995178,
0.6138308644294739,
0.37475672364234924,
0.46798327565193176,
-0.6144599914550781,
0.6751821041107178,
0.02301957830786705,
-1.053871989250183,
-0.6525272130966187,
0.11257678270339966,
-0.7990859150886536,
-0.642647922039032,
0.9293095469474792,
0.22597607970237732,
-0.2503832280635834,
-0.3246122896671295,
-0.3034346401691437,
0.1497395932674408,
-0.6910619139671326,
1.1618449687957764,
0.5867792367935181,
-0.5848859548568726,
0.039349328726530075,
-0.5396929979324341,
0.5559504628181458,
0.3597944974899292,
-0.88502037525177,
0.2218380570411682,
0.2589457333087921,
-0.3293473422527313,
0.5313758254051208,
0.7223868370056152,
-0.007118580862879753,
0.2449268400669098,
0.39209216833114624,
0.21035584807395935,
-0.20816107094287872,
-0.3143942654132843,
-0.11240729689598083,
0.2891303598880768,
0.38325342535972595,
0.13648539781570435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04376v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04376v1
|
Computational Modelling of Plurality and Definiteness in Chinese Noun Phrases
| 2024-03-07T10:06:54 | 2024-03-07T10:06:54 |
Yuqi Liu, Guanyi Chen, Kees van Deemter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Theoretical linguists have suggested that some languages (e.g., Chinese and
Japanese) are "cooler" than other languages based on the observation that the
intended meaning of phrases in these languages depends more on their contexts.
As a result, many expressions in these languages are shortened, and their
meaning is inferred from the context. In this paper, we focus on the omission
of the plurality and definiteness markers in Chinese noun phrases (NPs) to
investigate the predictability of their intended meaning given the contexts. To
this end, we built a corpus of Chinese NPs, each of which is accompanied by its
corresponding context, and by labels indicating its singularity/plurality and
definiteness/indefiniteness. We carried out corpus assessments and analyses.
The results suggest that Chinese speakers indeed drop plurality and
definiteness markers very frequently. Building on the corpus, we train a bank
of computational models using both classic machine learning models and
state-of-the-art pre-trained language models to predict the plurality and
definiteness of each NP. We report on the performance of these models and
analyse their behaviours.
|
[
-0.4300074279308319,
-0.7535865902900696,
0.555304229259491,
0.34093961119651794,
-0.4050843417644501,
-0.3118216395378113,
-0.3012234568595886,
-0.36728593707084656,
0.10406754165887833,
0.22583729028701782,
-0.3866937756538391,
-0.22764752805233002,
-0.3552613854408264,
0.4206053912639618,
-0.3966616690158844,
0.8529866933822632,
0.13040362298488617,
-0.035609886050224304,
-0.14344486594200134,
-0.046041302382946014,
-0.30565446615219116,
-0.7564774751663208,
-0.0168867539614439,
-0.22118546068668365,
0.613646388053894,
0.038653384894132614,
1.1132988929748535,
1.001973271369934,
0.7053442001342773,
0.32907167077064514,
-0.09335263818502426,
-0.1549200862646103,
-0.22397834062576294,
-0.1625490039587021,
0.025910524651408195,
-0.1760595589876175,
-0.1495264619588852,
0.022681359201669693,
1.051868200302124,
1.1888830661773682,
0.3886273503303528,
-0.1237192302942276,
-0.07773114740848541,
0.23382271826267242,
-0.6094372868537903,
0.08944722265005112,
-0.7675428986549377,
0.23150640726089478,
-0.3781214654445648,
0.1298913210630417,
-0.31623953580856323,
-0.293768048286438,
0.2203037142753601,
-0.4997844696044922,
0.2529454231262207,
-0.4737738072872162,
1.1019952297210693,
0.16909091174602509,
-0.3136153221130371,
0.046053845435380936,
-0.5640138387680054,
0.870154082775116,
-1.060733675956726,
-0.018801899626851082,
0.48527762293815613,
-0.1525522917509079,
-0.24471886456012726,
-0.5333170890808105,
-0.7093432545661926,
-0.3963107168674469,
-0.2300957292318344,
0.18639162182807922,
0.42926469445228577,
0.16838963329792023,
0.21426133811473846,
0.1097739115357399,
-0.3281305432319641,
0.30825403332710266,
-0.3189511001110077,
0.11425817757844925,
0.8229097723960876,
0.26115450263023376,
0.36322981119155884,
-0.5135794281959534,
-0.5330780744552612,
0.44643864035606384,
-0.6291478276252747,
0.1987384408712387,
0.19128842651844025,
0.6481943130493164,
-0.2192440778017044,
0.24986481666564941,
-0.015705114230513573,
0.7658155560493469,
-0.044228531420230865,
-0.4186631739139557,
0.2840667963027954,
-0.5017091631889343,
0.037232834845781326,
-0.1778634637594223,
0.8242291212081909,
-0.15129511058330536,
-0.03594425693154335,
-0.4758390486240387,
-0.1507314145565033,
0.10786266624927521,
-0.0019319236744195223,
-0.5617074370384216,
-0.4334873855113983,
0.36374956369400024,
-0.35505467653274536,
-0.10301659256219864,
0.29997357726097107,
0.13571499288082123,
-0.06420036405324936,
-0.4526503384113312,
0.17206887900829315,
-0.6078971028327942,
-0.5712930560112,
-0.06412211060523987,
-0.2848372459411621,
0.17968805134296417,
0.09792698174715042,
-0.7157015204429626,
0.19928932189941406,
0.8951078057289124,
0.7282487750053406,
-0.5415754318237305,
-0.6677276492118835,
-0.05367502197623253,
0.12795057892799377,
-0.5833993554115295,
0.4751153886318207,
-0.5551550984382629,
-0.6202248930931091,
-0.06619048863649368,
-0.16712713241577148,
-0.330830454826355,
-0.45767942070961,
0.6956923604011536,
-0.4277963936328888,
0.04895376041531563,
-0.41861703991889954,
-0.7514564990997314,
-0.3163769841194153,
0.20375756919384003,
-0.7443811893463135,
0.3527091145515442,
-0.05309450626373291,
-0.7243337631225586,
0.22832827270030975,
-0.34516286849975586,
-0.6374256014823914,
0.3734261095523834,
-0.4372060000896454,
-0.4975016713142395,
-0.0106040108948946,
-0.39716577529907227,
0.4847964942455292,
-0.1510644108057022,
0.6552329659461975,
-0.5242665410041809,
-0.47068825364112854,
0.5628067255020142,
-0.19353453814983368,
1.067915678024292,
0.23719243705272675,
-0.2815347909927368,
-0.10416315495967865,
-0.5246974229812622,
0.201092928647995,
0.008226877078413963,
-0.2850113809108734,
-0.415246844291687,
0.2307792603969574,
-0.051871158182621,
0.5070315003395081,
0.12558917701244354,
-0.3359074294567108,
0.1753993183374405,
-0.44837871193885803,
0.2617192268371582,
0.7011627554893494,
-0.09764574468135834,
0.4100508391857147,
-0.21894006431102753,
0.3772946000099182,
0.4220771789550781,
0.0839158222079277,
-0.24734194576740265,
-0.8417653441429138,
-0.5607905983924866,
-0.2708599865436554,
0.26424869894981384,
0.5874061584472656,
-0.6309574246406555,
0.5448252558708191,
-0.24894332885742188,
-0.33728525042533875,
-0.116444431245327,
0.06155633181333542,
0.567801833152771,
0.31138360500335693,
-0.13499140739440918,
-0.3431791365146637,
-0.5923248529434204,
-0.8649932742118835,
-0.08741443604230881,
-0.4619496166706085,
0.1911078244447708,
-0.1068093478679657,
0.6941781640052795,
0.005449740681797266,
1.4247714281082153,
-0.31420981884002686,
0.09150759130716324,
0.19112613797187805,
-0.06554118543863297,
0.35059496760368347,
0.4321015179157257,
0.6062443852424622,
-1.3035794496536255,
-0.195379838347435,
-0.028426412492990494,
-1.051891803741455,
0.24722358584403992,
-0.25701311230659485,
0.19841377437114716,
-0.027036678045988083,
0.17361877858638763,
-0.41837671399116516,
0.6074896454811096,
0.36248883605003357,
0.01905500516295433,
1.2999976873397827,
0.2577507793903351,
-0.32236629724502563,
-0.9893344640731812,
0.2646980881690979,
0.11472173035144806,
0.1535155326128006,
-0.9930164217948914,
0.0627673789858818,
-0.11240967363119125,
0.17397776246070862,
-0.5722061991691589,
0.6495625972747803,
-0.5271243453025818,
0.049267251044511795,
-0.33703258633613586,
0.41039127111434937,
-0.15857894718647003,
0.6463314294815063,
0.33734309673309326,
0.2764907777309418,
0.5001667737960815,
-1.1961220502853394,
0.24305181205272675,
-0.06404528021812439,
-0.34560850262641907,
-0.13865618407726288,
-0.6953094005584717,
-0.009347056970000267,
-0.22091367840766907,
-0.11766360700130463,
-1.0833042860031128,
-0.04796850308775902,
0.2865808606147766,
-0.3951916992664337,
-0.20475567877292633,
-0.11766841262578964,
-0.27081820368766785,
-0.3430638611316681,
-0.10146107524633408,
0.5796734690666199,
-0.021586226299405098,
-0.19057607650756836,
0.04394131898880005,
0.5622777938842773,
-0.022347306832671165,
-0.7326676845550537,
-0.6331965327262878,
0.04088796675205231,
-0.25363150238990784,
-0.537756085395813,
0.6304856538772583,
-0.24851642549037933,
-0.543043315410614,
0.08848616480827332,
0.48506295680999756,
-0.44375133514404297,
0.4530790448188782,
0.5337803959846497,
0.41671040654182434,
-0.28110945224761963,
0.3951350152492523,
-0.2003982663154602,
-0.15636758506298065,
0.08397916704416275,
-0.1888388693332672,
0.3472149670124054,
-0.4278336763381958,
-0.32671424746513367,
-0.3320506513118744,
0.1516677737236023,
-0.050891757011413574,
-0.08083165436983109,
0.7525215148925781,
0.5615295767784119,
-0.4558256268501282,
0.057207509875297546,
-0.12966741621494293,
-0.12392926216125488,
-0.47578734159469604,
0.4877614676952362,
-0.8010596036911011,
-0.7895370721817017,
0.8855046629905701,
0.16935089230537415,
0.3337785601615906,
0.5755351781845093,
0.41110357642173767,
0.2979445159435272,
0.8470428586006165,
0.5612447261810303,
-0.16950450837612152,
0.4133215546607971,
-0.26509276032447815,
0.3802418112754822,
-0.4214945435523987,
0.0843115970492363,
-0.5974680781364441,
0.04066736251115799,
-0.9208189249038696,
-0.29767799377441406,
0.41727524995803833,
0.1431272178888321,
-0.2288365215063095,
0.0761655941605568,
-0.25547948479652405,
0.5751699805259705,
0.41277796030044556,
-0.3210764229297638,
0.0700870230793953,
-0.2947130799293518,
-0.10156247019767761,
-0.16044852137565613,
-0.7111959457397461,
-0.4429079294204712,
0.34727951884269714,
-0.09996727108955383,
0.07753002643585205,
0.10790325701236725,
0.6850577592849731,
0.12582501769065857,
0.049388591200113297,
-0.8094662427902222,
0.6036892533302307,
-0.43429774045944214,
-0.7029739022254944,
-0.47234612703323364,
-0.46232351660728455,
-1.0749951601028442,
0.48120182752609253,
0.021891413256525993,
-0.607461154460907,
0.21015767753124237,
-0.28904154896736145,
-0.4135855734348297,
0.4888673722743988,
-0.1001526266336441,
0.8701183795928955,
-0.4416589140892029,
-0.2171606868505478,
0.22450855374336243,
-0.8051563501358032,
0.7381389141082764,
-0.13168682157993317,
0.2993505895137787,
-0.3162447512149811,
-0.15499380230903625,
0.6239014267921448,
-0.4266834557056427,
0.9651401042938232,
-0.09219536185264587,
-0.26630428433418274,
0.492576003074646,
0.10403944551944733,
0.028271200135350227,
-0.017706554383039474,
-0.5919684171676636,
0.39594656229019165,
0.011029920540750027,
-0.5391314625740051,
-0.26702895760536194,
0.5527094006538391,
-1.0544209480285645,
-0.42033419013023376,
-0.32538941502571106,
-0.1377144306898117,
0.15852144360542297,
0.3809817433357239,
0.5582931041717529,
0.4036131799221039,
-0.4662591218948364,
-0.20198898017406464,
0.22832760214805603,
-0.23897619545459747,
0.7332969307899475,
0.23597082495689392,
-0.40873998403549194,
-0.12425994127988815,
0.8505105376243591,
0.41121742129325867,
0.17935556173324585,
0.3713122308254242,
0.2635868787765503,
-0.15350595116615295,
-0.49761831760406494,
-0.24810108542442322,
0.26377519965171814,
-0.4756278097629547,
0.03948073461651802,
-0.3318599760532379,
-0.5284519791603088,
-0.7649549245834351,
-0.1063455119729042,
-0.2645691931247711,
-0.7656022310256958,
-0.34139254689216614,
0.036975957453250885,
0.08772770315408707,
0.48835042119026184,
-0.18636292219161987,
0.4108881652355194,
-0.7383390665054321,
0.43464329838752747,
0.08678963780403137,
0.21565364301204681,
0.03159595653414726,
-0.7620283365249634,
-0.4752613604068756,
0.12339518219232559,
-0.04810189828276634,
-0.789438784122467,
0.5121757388114929,
0.34720051288604736,
0.5774095058441162,
0.910848081111908,
0.15471939742565155,
0.788540244102478,
-0.20718662440776825,
1.0131030082702637,
0.2522895634174347,
-1.0140427350997925,
0.24331259727478027,
-0.5821634531021118,
0.4327945411205292,
0.3782937824726105,
0.30780333280563354,
-0.7928249835968018,
-0.1983252912759781,
-0.6168502569198608,
-0.9628477096557617,
0.6236276030540466,
0.036744873970746994,
0.0878836140036583,
-0.22659897804260254,
0.587067186832428,
0.36237624287605286,
0.19310283660888672,
-0.8268157243728638,
-0.7067071795463562,
-0.15047724545001984,
0.2262694239616394,
-0.10630505532026291,
-0.12757593393325806,
0.3204636871814728,
-0.0879783108830452,
0.7544122934341431,
-0.04309437423944473,
0.14726994931697845,
-0.1932559758424759,
0.061695646494627,
0.2159963697195053,
0.07921014726161957,
0.34116271138191223,
0.8830782771110535,
0.02215379849076271,
-0.0063202837482094765,
-0.05616563558578491,
-0.25937098264694214,
-0.03165889158844948,
-0.16561156511306763,
-0.7223374247550964,
0.6448565125465393,
0.19950252771377563,
0.8454987406730652,
-0.04216960817575455,
-0.5527464747428894,
0.2848179042339325,
0.15628682076931,
0.08001308143138885,
-1.013973593711853,
-0.2562616467475891,
0.05010378733277321,
-0.618220865726471,
0.34084460139274597,
0.07252224534749985,
0.4111521542072296,
-0.5622876286506653,
0.17130102217197418,
0.3387245237827301,
-0.3449309766292572,
-0.6891959309577942,
0.35956335067749023,
0.003112834645435214,
-0.05534454435110092,
0.8298622369766235,
-0.4808122217655182,
-0.8522329926490784,
0.8910179138183594,
0.4940554201602936,
0.9750483632087708,
-0.33745625615119934,
0.448100209236145,
0.44666481018066406,
0.20476248860359192,
-0.11791492998600006,
-0.06994485855102539,
0.1184437945485115,
-1.1586508750915527,
-0.43138450384140015,
-0.38560885190963745,
-0.4409480094909668,
-0.07648202776908875,
-0.5610024929046631,
0.21497489511966705,
-0.6090863347053528,
-0.6347710490226746,
0.34289777278900146,
0.021697338670492172,
-0.40365439653396606,
0.36789044737815857,
0.533427357673645,
0.06946412473917007,
-0.8289877772331238,
0.8995510339736938,
0.5453519225120544,
-0.441536545753479,
-0.8949442505836487,
-0.3280245363712311,
0.10798744112253189,
-0.3377712666988373,
0.6999801397323608,
0.2117415815591812,
-0.3040282428264618,
-0.5735223293304443,
-0.5863105058670044,
-0.9584588408470154,
0.4052209258079529,
0.3254220187664032,
-0.20315732061862946,
0.09002213925123215,
0.5988690853118896,
0.6161666512489319,
-0.19750598073005676,
0.22702142596244812,
0.43366384506225586,
0.6282921433448792,
-0.10059627890586853,
-0.9646815061569214,
-0.2103133499622345,
-0.6842399835586548,
0.07137220352888107,
0.09761674702167511,
-0.8132125735282898,
1.5821292400360107,
-0.3878231942653656,
-0.41775423288345337,
0.4245586097240448,
0.8647657036781311,
0.28217342495918274,
0.4104993939399719,
0.3986658453941345,
0.0668620690703392,
0.8286899924278259,
-0.18935485184192657,
0.9438941478729248,
-0.4021818935871124,
0.07766318321228027,
1.2284437417984009,
-0.44088229537010193,
0.7219293117523193,
0.22979818284511566,
-0.14261701703071594,
0.5489528775215149,
0.5311384201049805,
0.012193332426249981,
0.13701321184635162,
0.28878796100616455,
-0.4146675765514374,
-0.34509801864624023,
-0.2307615876197815,
-0.3454706072807312,
0.7431402206420898,
0.5282611846923828,
-0.18547430634498596,
0.34608015418052673,
-0.15363632142543793,
0.3172253668308258,
0.1688896268606186,
-0.2783798575401306,
0.6529849171638489,
0.3568854033946991,
-0.8833438754081726,
0.927496075630188,
0.43197351694107056,
0.7226013541221619,
-0.5042451620101929,
0.29415613412857056,
-0.31105002760887146,
0.20967258512973785,
-0.47265729308128357,
-0.5632801651954651,
0.0470842570066452,
-0.21145464479923248,
-0.2314726859331131,
0.04007339105010033,
0.6023877263069153,
-0.299564391374588,
-0.5871477127075195,
0.11483920365571976,
0.6195529699325562,
0.44503334164619446,
0.03230705112218857,
-0.7600579857826233,
-0.3267104923725128,
0.08295740932226181,
0.06181758642196655,
0.1664639115333557,
0.6078872084617615,
-0.2526615560054779,
0.5795260667800903,
0.3945107161998749,
0.18552915751934052,
0.3663676977157593,
0.19219669699668884,
0.5573291778564453,
-0.813942551612854,
-0.6505864858627319,
-1.0256872177124023,
0.1901852935552597,
0.08323533087968826,
-0.4381825625896454,
1.136237382888794,
0.6355428695678711,
0.818720281124115,
-0.12925580143928528,
1.135130524635315,
-0.07211919873952866,
0.3547191619873047,
-0.17607799172401428,
0.4471442401409149,
-0.3111763894557953,
0.23171576857566833,
-0.5418473482131958,
-0.5710193514823914,
-0.5830098986625671,
0.4320446848869324,
-0.4038134515285492,
0.21278992295265198,
0.33662882447242737,
0.5803525447845459,
0.23610182106494904,
0.16775137186050415,
0.27420228719711304,
0.21544098854064941,
0.23194901645183563,
0.41255104541778564,
0.9291255474090576,
-0.4257103502750397,
0.20561543107032776,
-0.7469075918197632,
0.18917414546012878,
-0.12209734320640564,
-0.626644492149353,
-0.397944837808609,
-0.9101665616035461,
-0.4468761682510376,
0.053051020950078964,
0.06606516987085342,
0.5221492052078247,
0.6169242858886719,
-0.8154079914093018,
-0.6596603393554688,
0.41736090183258057,
0.41678234934806824,
-0.44259390234947205,
-0.1567293256521225,
0.6763793230056763,
-0.4157121777534485,
-0.6920127868652344,
0.050277985632419586,
0.17766670882701874,
0.009631573222577572,
-0.17774510383605957,
-0.13659121096134186,
-0.3234139680862427,
-0.18355660140514374,
0.6659583449363708,
0.5202785134315491,
-0.7635518312454224,
-0.15009678900241852,
-0.10825368762016296,
-0.20774270594120026,
0.2143111228942871,
0.7616987228393555,
-0.8241713047027588,
0.3294409215450287,
0.5436370968818665,
0.20039133727550507,
-0.07909642159938812,
0.2790133059024811,
0.4890977740287781,
-0.7865269780158997,
0.45544880628585815,
0.3550204038619995,
0.2927010655403137,
0.4536413252353668,
-0.029450194910168648,
0.4206888973712921,
0.4060550928115845,
-0.2698889970779419,
-0.6945847272872925,
0.21524181962013245,
-0.8536465764045715,
-0.5246855020523071,
1.0891257524490356,
-0.42324313521385193,
-0.4734434187412262,
-0.3517822325229645,
0.19425243139266968,
0.3784373998641968,
-0.0013978799106553197,
0.9482550024986267,
0.47292137145996094,
0.03710835799574852,
0.3691389858722687,
-0.04139364883303642,
0.37851276993751526,
0.5112603306770325,
-0.40238478779792786,
0.016032444313168526,
0.5956897139549255,
-0.1290465146303177,
0.49052441120147705,
0.6324867010116577,
-0.027577873319387436,
0.40686824917793274,
0.1643439382314682,
0.04628812521696091,
0.2543228268623352,
-0.24129608273506165,
-0.17887957394123077,
0.31461429595947266,
0.18355713784694672,
-0.1469641625881195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.12083v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12083v1
|
Presenting Terrorizer: an algorithm for consolidating company names in patent assignees
| 2024-03-07T09:59:15 | 2024-03-07T09:59:15 |
Grazia Sveva Ascione, Valerio Sterzi
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, I.2; J.4
|
The problem of disambiguation of company names poses a significant challenge
in extracting useful information from patents. This issue biases research
outcomes as it mostly underestimates the number of patents attributed to
companies, particularly multinational corporations which file patents under a
plethora of names, including alternate spellings of the same entity and,
eventually, companies' subsidiaries. To date, addressing these challenges has
relied on labor-intensive dictionary based or string matching approaches,
leaving the problem of patents' assignee harmonization on large datasets mostly
unresolved. To bridge this gap, this paper describes the Terrorizer algorithm,
a text-based algorithm that leverages natural language processing (NLP),
network theory, and rule-based techniques to harmonize the variants of company
names recorded as patent assignees. In particular, the algorithm follows the
tripartite structure of its antecedents, namely parsing, matching and filtering
stage, adding an original "knowledge augmentation" phase which is used to
enrich the information available on each assignee name. We use Terrorizer on a
set of 325'917 companies' names who are assignees of patents granted by the
USPTO from 2005 to 2022. The performance of Terrorizer is evaluated on four
gold standard datasets. This validation step shows us two main things: the
first is that the performance of Terrorizer is similar over different kind of
datasets, proving that our algorithm generalizes well. Second, when comparing
its performance with the one of the algorithm currently used in PatentsView for
the same task (Monath et al., 2021), it achieves a higher F1 score. Finally, we
use the Tree-structured Parzen Estimator (TPE) optimization algorithm for the
hyperparameters' tuning. Our final result is a reduction in the initial set of
names of over 42%.
|
[
-0.2757953107357025,
-0.5388432145118713,
0.06145550683140755,
0.27492231130599976,
-0.47748446464538574,
0.7160122990608215,
0.03194770961999893,
-0.5880674719810486,
0.1872507631778717,
0.23978467285633087,
-0.332382470369339,
-0.36699098348617554,
-0.7990455627441406,
0.034783829003572464,
-0.03204416111111641,
1.1160554885864258,
0.26083698868751526,
-0.32845327258110046,
0.41781193017959595,
0.17056427896022797,
-0.40784114599227905,
-0.566604733467102,
-0.43911513686180115,
-0.2586008310317993,
0.4740530848503113,
0.19348475337028503,
1.0107762813568115,
0.6988259553909302,
0.9940778017044067,
0.4125754237174988,
-0.8048045635223389,
0.0573103204369545,
-0.3901618719100952,
-0.03510699048638344,
-0.2954839766025543,
-0.3828938603401184,
0.12766046822071075,
-0.23648814857006073,
0.15379713475704193,
0.6180879473686218,
-0.06284260749816895,
0.3612087666988373,
0.0513642281293869,
0.3466673195362091,
-0.5334523320198059,
-0.11975573748350143,
-0.7862954139709473,
0.23516878485679626,
-0.2631235420703888,
-0.47815176844596863,
-0.44820496439933777,
-0.5643637776374817,
0.21243461966514587,
-0.5251069068908691,
0.4945041835308075,
0.5765202641487122,
1.0150036811828613,
0.4643045663833618,
-0.02891981229186058,
-0.24835844337940216,
-0.7730485796928406,
1.0228064060211182,
-0.34543779492378235,
-0.021751701831817627,
-0.16729575395584106,
0.19759102165699005,
-0.4964783489704132,
-0.6655547618865967,
-0.31686505675315857,
0.06596338748931885,
0.027299970388412476,
-0.1929810643196106,
-0.42782220244407654,
0.2727188467979431,
0.41836005449295044,
0.5835941433906555,
-0.47015729546546936,
0.3125621974468231,
-0.7728773355484009,
-0.4617345631122589,
0.5444062352180481,
-0.18468137085437775,
0.551166296005249,
-0.27951663732528687,
-0.6350489258766174,
-0.08353990316390991,
-0.15705899894237518,
0.08993548154830933,
0.25648126006126404,
0.5530636310577393,
0.20599552989006042,
0.4591682255268097,
0.0010882039787247777,
0.4720233678817749,
0.3088732659816742,
-0.19218508899211884,
0.45340102910995483,
0.0742962583899498,
-0.4120713472366333,
0.6345696449279785,
0.6298899054527283,
0.41897204518318176,
0.10968507826328278,
-0.5078617334365845,
-0.16360370814800262,
0.036896850913763046,
0.3721064329147339,
-0.8870384693145752,
-0.2716805040836334,
0.33042651414871216,
-0.31720760464668274,
-0.4973528981208801,
0.0032520329114049673,
-1.1360081434249878,
-0.8286463022232056,
-0.19144228100776672,
0.7986294031143188,
-0.3655150830745697,
-0.05291394144296646,
0.03250117227435112,
-0.8969289660453796,
0.1826310008764267,
0.15505684912204742,
-0.6416706442832947,
0.17115819454193115,
1.191542148590088,
0.993636429309845,
-0.1227782592177391,
-0.14039967954158783,
-0.43000513315200806,
0.19397900998592377,
-0.39158254861831665,
0.7058762907981873,
-0.4646206498146057,
-0.5366237163543701,
-0.29801705479621887,
-0.39023536443710327,
-0.1290125697851181,
-0.9483540058135986,
0.7359791994094849,
-0.7335110306739807,
0.0981469675898552,
-0.1567276567220688,
-0.4673998951911926,
-0.1726958006620407,
0.1658373326063156,
-0.5264227390289307,
0.6831256747245789,
-0.11291356384754181,
-1.0957273244857788,
0.5222118496894836,
-0.5295976400375366,
-0.32107287645339966,
0.31149980425834656,
-0.1567392647266388,
-0.611685574054718,
0.5078150629997253,
0.24403803050518036,
0.15892232954502106,
-0.5183542370796204,
0.5258307456970215,
-0.1281447559595108,
-0.32228565216064453,
0.12012086808681488,
0.1517283022403717,
1.2542825937271118,
0.44113674759864807,
-0.1683443933725357,
-0.11262861639261246,
-0.4819476902484894,
-0.03480563312768936,
-0.09889459609985352,
0.11478291451931,
-0.569238543510437,
-0.04543035104870796,
-0.0402715690433979,
0.13389715552330017,
0.15365251898765564,
-0.7624708414077759,
0.154068261384964,
-0.6676151156425476,
0.11682264506816864,
1.0390959978103638,
0.563284695148468,
0.13126608729362488,
-0.5699661374092102,
0.6866793632507324,
0.1568831205368042,
0.509358286857605,
0.27072182297706604,
-0.5800308585166931,
-0.6031010150909424,
-0.6896035671234131,
0.6060336828231812,
0.578902542591095,
-0.6489448547363281,
0.304843008518219,
-0.5933207869529724,
-0.8974071145057678,
-0.35520094633102417,
0.05516395717859268,
0.4487006962299347,
0.4222208261489868,
0.3358312249183655,
-0.49176090955734253,
-0.8823599815368652,
-1.053550124168396,
-0.7998653650283813,
-0.13246561586856842,
0.03695783019065857,
-0.09547589719295502,
0.28556209802627563,
-0.30899304151535034,
0.9767935872077942,
-0.7092178463935852,
-0.4704985022544861,
-0.2101961374282837,
0.44882145524024963,
0.9029218554496765,
0.44259750843048096,
0.5593104362487793,
-0.8299694061279297,
-0.6229090690612793,
0.2191096544265747,
-0.24514929950237274,
-0.0445689931511879,
-0.11017520725727081,
-0.29219844937324524,
-0.4985390901565552,
0.1537022441625595,
-0.3987816274166107,
0.29186633229255676,
0.09397159516811371,
0.0753178820014,
0.41986268758773804,
0.06542955338954926,
0.014705338515341282,
-1.5478206872940063,
0.24047797918319702,
-0.03814159706234932,
0.21600759029388428,
-0.7392098903656006,
0.020802605897188187,
-0.3131844103336334,
-0.4278949499130249,
-0.4340824484825134,
0.4727262854576111,
-0.38817188143730164,
0.3347158133983612,
0.048891279846429825,
-0.0841396152973175,
-0.18948638439178467,
0.5071945786476135,
-0.6106762290000916,
0.850821852684021,
0.6038156747817993,
-0.6808099150657654,
0.48365867137908936,
0.44342559576034546,
-0.40167319774627686,
0.5511080622673035,
-0.47479718923568726,
-0.07666826993227005,
0.032299019396305084,
-0.18952038884162903,
-0.7928165197372437,
-0.19738847017288208,
0.11806749552488327,
-0.2564343810081482,
0.07468464225530624,
-0.2982097864151001,
-0.6722100377082825,
-0.7527185678482056,
-0.4144003093242645,
0.3066374659538269,
0.6059163808822632,
-0.8658599257469177,
0.7519243359565735,
0.6699182987213135,
-0.3245198130607605,
-0.8093793988227844,
-0.7604619264602661,
0.3550097346305847,
-0.7467343807220459,
-0.2523908317089081,
0.791729748249054,
-0.2088567018508911,
-0.1910465955734253,
-0.21306709945201874,
-0.3159099817276001,
-0.7510154247283936,
0.03274831175804138,
0.3626185953617096,
0.24959948658943176,
0.16920948028564453,
0.05595812201499939,
0.14176297187805176,
-0.20911672711372375,
0.04145200550556183,
-0.017625723034143448,
0.2706345319747925,
0.49320244789123535,
0.11946932226419449,
-0.8368168473243713,
0.010812828317284584,
0.5205560326576233,
-0.16435635089874268,
0.40482714772224426,
0.06884651631116867,
-0.4623800814151764,
-0.5748246908187866,
-0.45742517709732056,
0.32280221581459045,
-0.6078914403915405,
0.0992870107293129,
-0.612275242805481,
-0.4347936809062958,
0.7056371569633484,
-0.6419959664344788,
-0.03126245737075806,
0.5192034840583801,
0.38275146484375,
0.4267171621322632,
0.7075616121292114,
0.7981746792793274,
-0.6372338533401489,
0.3712189495563507,
-0.24413244426250458,
1.0806242227554321,
-0.49171170592308044,
-0.2151472419500351,
-0.7436229586601257,
-0.6715573072433472,
-0.5382581949234009,
-0.2445714920759201,
0.2919836938381195,
-0.0745144709944725,
0.08686506748199463,
0.5443100333213806,
-1.1604218482971191,
0.6826595664024353,
0.5209139585494995,
0.004767254460602999,
0.29538846015930176,
0.38276323676109314,
-0.37945038080215454,
-0.07246533036231995,
-0.26305875182151794,
-0.20750047266483307,
0.8146706223487854,
0.18297037482261658,
0.7292333841323853,
0.23110352456569672,
1.1167211532592773,
0.5077669620513916,
0.2253454476594925,
-0.9011330604553223,
0.48274749517440796,
-0.2956470549106598,
-0.7198590636253357,
0.20129849016666412,
-0.41464588046073914,
-0.776753306388855,
0.0710974931716919,
0.34833720326423645,
-0.9870129823684692,
0.8729127049446106,
0.15624773502349854,
-0.633798360824585,
0.14733093976974487,
-0.7663588523864746,
0.7160680294036865,
-0.38187289237976074,
-0.21619030833244324,
-0.2784424126148224,
-0.3056608736515045,
0.2338428795337677,
-0.5626242756843567,
0.12293625622987747,
-0.027615653350949287,
0.11465591937303543,
0.7636057138442993,
-0.5998349785804749,
0.4730471968650818,
-0.3265802264213562,
-0.04315657541155815,
0.09706158190965652,
0.012318781577050686,
0.2839164733886719,
-0.3328758478164673,
-0.6483428478240967,
0.09971854090690613,
0.07282324880361557,
-0.0896516963839531,
-0.6531277298927307,
0.5401287078857422,
-0.49084630608558655,
-0.4544208347797394,
-0.6882045269012451,
-0.3296808898448944,
-0.13845157623291016,
0.31883952021598816,
0.5380348563194275,
0.3481810390949249,
-0.17453555762767792,
0.19782955944538116,
0.361131489276886,
-0.2191842496395111,
0.13832928240299225,
0.18445071578025818,
-0.08691835403442383,
-0.7142809629440308,
1.081648588180542,
0.40098223090171814,
-0.30007317662239075,
0.5201044082641602,
0.11678379774093628,
-0.25681233406066895,
-0.5042985677719116,
0.0025009263772517443,
0.03611759468913078,
-0.4074729382991791,
-0.5616418719291687,
-0.5857674479484558,
-0.5076764822006226,
0.1520879715681076,
-0.17445559799671173,
-0.1014670878648758,
-0.43305084109306335,
0.03728490695357323,
0.021785665303468704,
0.2577045261859894,
0.35709258913993835,
-0.026541858911514282,
0.41772589087486267,
-0.18102289736270905,
0.6872814297676086,
0.3210083842277527,
0.5155520439147949,
-0.31450170278549194,
-0.6276138424873352,
-0.2559964656829834,
0.11123450845479965,
-0.5738744735717773,
-0.7356001138687134,
0.2554333508014679,
0.33726122975349426,
0.38697549700737,
0.5142930746078491,
0.4735163450241089,
1.2739605903625488,
-0.3114911615848541,
0.4274298846721649,
0.1812685877084732,
-1.0852257013320923,
0.6735718846321106,
0.10836054384708405,
-0.22851157188415527,
0.6444631814956665,
0.24806196987628937,
-0.43126171827316284,
-0.444425106048584,
-0.7452608942985535,
-0.8543455004692078,
0.881007194519043,
0.36146262288093567,
0.23908473551273346,
0.15493015944957733,
0.30763331055641174,
-0.10306117683649063,
0.29664111137390137,
-0.24772725999355316,
-0.059003833681344986,
0.2994304597377777,
-0.37663352489471436,
0.06816551089286804,
-0.35443875193595886,
-0.1531444489955902,
-0.25733304023742676,
0.9578700065612793,
0.44234922528266907,
0.0861654132604599,
0.10732311010360718,
-0.11007209867238998,
-0.03507160767912865,
0.3210877478122711,
0.06679864227771759,
0.39754483103752136,
-0.3619033396244049,
0.25982481241226196,
-0.11280756443738937,
-0.4810170829296112,
0.17620065808296204,
0.600795567035675,
-0.18477585911750793,
0.24359549582004547,
-0.0297685619443655,
0.4914325177669525,
-0.09610047936439514,
-0.7034798264503479,
0.45854252576828003,
-0.0014272836269810796,
-0.1191914975643158,
0.06658726930618286,
0.2107454091310501,
-0.6992599368095398,
0.2898207902908325,
0.6912104487419128,
0.36922383308410645,
0.5676974654197693,
-0.08197328448295593,
0.32656940817832947,
0.2955925464630127,
-0.25753432512283325,
-0.28833842277526855,
0.5659931302070618,
0.12687374651432037,
-0.4684874713420868,
0.3176645040512085,
-0.34258386492729187,
-0.7492983937263489,
0.9416671991348267,
0.4193304181098938,
1.2666685581207275,
-0.5655623078346252,
0.24153995513916016,
0.3005911111831665,
0.5269783139228821,
-0.16426189243793488,
0.08166307955980301,
-0.04546425864100456,
-0.502269446849823,
-0.04389430209994316,
-0.6762772798538208,
-0.6236566305160522,
0.10720132291316986,
-0.349765419960022,
0.32083860039711,
-0.7250649333000183,
-0.5786265134811401,
0.46408095955848694,
0.1647135615348816,
-0.545906662940979,
0.1298902928829193,
-0.13968947529792786,
0.7130393385887146,
-0.7972349524497986,
0.19524280726909637,
0.5667299628257751,
-0.3789535164833069,
-0.6306760907173157,
0.2707478106021881,
-0.02958008460700512,
-0.2810618579387665,
0.6812671422958374,
0.4491657316684723,
-0.035466041415929794,
0.2165200561285019,
-0.30679571628570557,
-0.8626895546913147,
0.5787500143051147,
0.516129732131958,
-0.3708968162536621,
0.20839230716228485,
0.3666740357875824,
0.8063059449195862,
0.11751283705234528,
-0.1747845858335495,
0.3246363699436188,
0.4249652624130249,
0.049921248108148575,
-0.9688079953193665,
-0.15015478432178497,
-0.8051713109016418,
0.2770111858844757,
0.17351484298706055,
-0.3552985191345215,
0.3465539515018463,
-0.09663426876068115,
-0.5027991533279419,
0.10374153405427933,
0.17236746847629547,
0.042409054934978485,
0.30290302634239197,
0.41605323553085327,
0.7071525454521179,
0.7796906232833862,
-0.024817124009132385,
0.606423020362854,
-0.5540504455566406,
0.6019384264945984,
1.1317065954208374,
-0.15672564506530762,
0.6209537982940674,
0.6184456944465637,
-0.26343461871147156,
0.40387970209121704,
0.5452481508255005,
-0.5479696393013,
0.4933133125305176,
0.4521626830101013,
-0.21925334632396698,
0.2761146128177643,
-0.6756983995437622,
-0.20025108754634857,
0.3682786226272583,
0.04283720627427101,
-0.5771727561950684,
-0.25210040807724,
-0.047497283667325974,
-0.10545241087675095,
-0.027987753972411156,
0.14415933191776276,
0.8351653218269348,
-0.1804901361465454,
-0.517992377281189,
0.6016392111778259,
0.12829752266407013,
0.42811906337738037,
-0.34723642468452454,
0.3423368036746979,
-0.18769007921218872,
0.5833067893981934,
-0.2255202680826187,
-0.3464999496936798,
0.3118470013141632,
0.30644363164901733,
-0.20729008316993713,
-0.18697544932365417,
0.18676893413066864,
-0.06600984930992126,
-0.6597692966461182,
0.3370376527309418,
0.07182633131742477,
-0.0020920170936733484,
-0.19548454880714417,
-0.7522386908531189,
0.05392531678080559,
0.0922950878739357,
0.1331857442855835,
-0.24167828261852264,
0.5116422176361084,
-0.0007161383982747793,
0.6430962681770325,
0.34032225608825684,
0.006948646157979965,
0.36763474345207214,
0.014208841137588024,
1.0898555517196655,
-0.49005380272865295,
-0.5374102592468262,
-0.7315891981124878,
0.5482708811759949,
-0.3877163529396057,
-0.3077491819858551,
0.6272794008255005,
1.3322192430496216,
0.40297675132751465,
-0.25057172775268555,
0.6202781200408936,
-0.1846272051334381,
0.6232255697250366,
0.048592399805784225,
0.5810982584953308,
-0.36769676208496094,
0.292795330286026,
-0.5904700756072998,
-1.0445153713226318,
-0.7557494044303894,
0.17509040236473083,
-0.30301809310913086,
-0.2841285467147827,
0.3900643289089203,
1.158037781715393,
-0.3710154592990875,
-0.3014148771762848,
-0.04246687516570091,
0.4064980149269104,
0.39533308148384094,
0.2475852072238922,
0.5609557628631592,
-0.7593873143196106,
0.5698643326759338,
-0.6605601906776428,
-0.2896377146244049,
-0.30135378241539,
-0.5236060619354248,
-0.6009132266044617,
-0.39401382207870483,
-0.5205442905426025,
0.08885721862316132,
0.29984790086746216,
0.8638601899147034,
0.48219364881515503,
-0.8812720775604248,
-0.1404399871826172,
-0.06662949174642563,
0.3845410645008087,
-0.3143131732940674,
-0.2216929793357849,
0.4131825566291809,
-0.5207884907722473,
-0.7568246722221375,
0.2496827393770218,
0.49735933542251587,
-0.14553263783454895,
0.3493432402610779,
0.22266201674938202,
0.10233918577432632,
0.3387186527252197,
0.23762498795986176,
0.23689045011997223,
-0.7910163998603821,
-0.08865433931350708,
-0.3762732446193695,
-0.04147891700267792,
0.14818048477172852,
0.6238304376602173,
-0.4813770055770874,
0.9828996062278748,
0.5163758397102356,
0.8293353915214539,
-0.13929598033428192,
0.4275575280189514,
0.3118060231208801,
-0.8840839266777039,
0.500176727771759,
0.13477694988250732,
0.07228770852088928,
0.2128080129623413,
-0.4652942419052124,
0.38477078080177307,
0.16921721398830414,
-0.3605691194534302,
-1.0630888938903809,
-0.08908040076494217,
-1.0013294219970703,
-0.11979477107524872,
0.5486181378364563,
0.36989307403564453,
-0.28241103887557983,
-0.1512899100780487,
-0.48694056272506714,
0.2695673108100891,
-0.3472827672958374,
1.3457664251327515,
0.4470701515674591,
0.18275493383407593,
0.027313925325870514,
0.10389591008424759,
0.7253929376602173,
0.24568387866020203,
-0.5815815329551697,
-0.032793086022138596,
0.30582356452941895,
-0.08373585343360901,
0.715287983417511,
0.36674144864082336,
-0.0960305705666542,
0.09305582195520401,
-0.21143339574337006,
0.3148099482059479,
0.1853567659854889,
-0.20811587572097778,
-0.24398882687091827,
0.31731921434402466,
0.09516066312789917,
-0.44713976979255676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04369v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04369v3
|
From Graph to Word Bag: Introducing Domain Knowledge to Confusing Charge Prediction
| 2024-03-07T09:57:42 | 2024-03-24T10:08:13 |
Ang Li, Qiangchao Chen, Yiquan Wu, Ming Cai, Xiang Zhou, Fei Wu, Kun Kuang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Confusing charge prediction is a challenging task in legal AI, which involves
predicting confusing charges based on fact descriptions. While existing charge
prediction methods have shown impressive performance, they face significant
challenges when dealing with confusing charges, such as Snatch and Robbery. In
the legal domain, constituent elements play a pivotal role in distinguishing
confusing charges. Constituent elements are fundamental behaviors underlying
criminal punishment and have subtle distinctions among charges. In this paper,
we introduce a novel From Graph to Word Bag (FWGB) approach, which introduces
domain knowledge regarding constituent elements to guide the model in making
judgments on confusing charges, much like a judge's reasoning process.
Specifically, we first construct a legal knowledge graph containing constituent
elements to help select keywords for each charge, forming a word bag.
Subsequently, to guide the model's attention towards the differentiating
information for each charge within the context, we expand the attention
mechanism and introduce a new loss function with attention supervision through
words in the word bag. We construct the confusing charges dataset from
real-world judicial documents. Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our
method, especially in maintaining exceptional performance in imbalanced label
distributions.
|
[
-0.3674919903278351,
-0.7256759405136108,
0.5938589572906494,
-0.13199463486671448,
-0.29792383313179016,
0.19498668611049652,
0.4034577012062073,
-0.698915958404541,
0.0160638727247715,
0.4016403257846832,
-0.4739553928375244,
-0.27052220702171326,
-0.6960634589195251,
-0.27120205760002136,
-0.4892003834247589,
1.1474041938781738,
0.04302412271499634,
0.02247956395149231,
-0.08645305782556534,
-0.2320948988199234,
-0.8789063692092896,
-0.40040427446365356,
-0.44803082942962646,
-0.8460160493850708,
0.8031376600265503,
0.14740367233753204,
0.38053005933761597,
0.21857057511806488,
0.4123755991458893,
0.26413193345069885,
-0.11112818121910095,
0.035662390291690826,
-0.4273254871368408,
-0.4259597361087799,
-0.6182394027709961,
-0.6544241905212402,
-0.43573540449142456,
-0.086427703499794,
-0.24716287851333618,
0.5981024503707886,
-0.21885673701763153,
-0.2300669401884079,
-0.15708397328853607,
0.8477055430412292,
-0.8991952538490295,
0.26874595880508423,
-0.8516792058944702,
0.22127199172973633,
-0.15890513360500336,
-0.34714215993881226,
-0.5711538195610046,
0.03883659467101097,
0.044617652893066406,
-0.9176332950592041,
0.4626258611679077,
0.5900930762290955,
0.897682249546051,
0.03742711618542671,
-0.5599935054779053,
-0.396587610244751,
-0.670628011226654,
0.2731761634349823,
-0.24433210492134094,
0.3677710294723511,
0.5766863822937012,
0.5990104675292969,
-0.2134801298379898,
-0.7308938503265381,
-0.800519585609436,
0.062287695705890656,
-0.22941796481609344,
0.2982834279537201,
-0.3325323164463043,
0.3511385917663574,
0.326456755399704,
0.14722409844398499,
-0.40122848749160767,
-0.2885340750217438,
-0.3477671444416046,
-0.3220171332359314,
0.843105137348175,
-0.025341378524899483,
0.36711546778678894,
-0.10786702483892441,
-0.287689745426178,
0.07554499059915543,
-0.7753103375434875,
0.33918631076812744,
0.5878825783729553,
0.39087730646133423,
-0.16944360733032227,
0.6822562217712402,
-0.15099070966243744,
0.5728631019592285,
0.5214563012123108,
-0.02521556057035923,
0.2698388993740082,
0.06993090361356735,
-0.45052796602249146,
0.636725664138794,
0.5055582523345947,
0.47710925340652466,
0.24194663763046265,
-0.29714739322662354,
-0.2489541471004486,
-0.3053685128688812,
0.6577951908111572,
-0.5238032937049866,
-0.6189149022102356,
0.38291195034980774,
-0.5231181979179382,
-0.37880203127861023,
0.013592666946351528,
-0.7286295890808105,
-0.8212330937385559,
-0.42811882495880127,
0.5769962072372437,
-0.6979078054428101,
0.019314924255013466,
0.23557023704051971,
-0.1829514056444168,
-0.17803651094436646,
0.6771646738052368,
-0.8316407799720764,
0.2435903698205948,
0.6147908568382263,
0.7452898621559143,
0.22207258641719818,
0.06974107772111893,
-0.6564884185791016,
0.5191118121147156,
-0.042252469807863235,
0.9119548797607422,
-0.6147898435592651,
-0.4582453668117523,
0.30915582180023193,
0.0028112696018069983,
0.053273480385541916,
-0.39986827969551086,
0.5984641909599304,
-0.6022356152534485,
-0.12949703633785248,
-0.30886632204055786,
-0.5473079681396484,
-0.5374230742454529,
0.4205579459667206,
-0.5037494897842407,
0.639212429523468,
0.2740307152271271,
-1.114266276359558,
0.7286018133163452,
-0.48774245381355286,
-0.5748677849769592,
0.540550172328949,
-0.2378501147031784,
-0.42590996623039246,
0.11997482180595398,
0.13247545063495636,
0.28852203488349915,
0.26566964387893677,
0.21802698075771332,
-0.4900941848754883,
-0.23698273301124573,
0.30112436413764954,
0.32157304883003235,
0.8292135000228882,
0.21758301556110382,
0.04448676109313965,
0.1774446964263916,
-0.6709807515144348,
-0.44725459814071655,
0.18100060522556305,
-0.2454954981803894,
-0.5264238119125366,
0.2350320816040039,
-0.00731252133846283,
-0.027908865362405777,
-0.12690141797065735,
-0.5703437328338623,
0.31753337383270264,
-0.3141317367553711,
0.46220239996910095,
0.7766175866127014,
0.00993599183857441,
0.30534791946411133,
-0.3927249312400818,
0.36645904183387756,
0.2754172086715698,
0.1057986244559288,
-0.04884430393576622,
-0.5517803430557251,
-0.6074478626251221,
0.06314944475889206,
0.4579702317714691,
0.7341523170471191,
-0.8582599759101868,
0.42952561378479004,
-0.1544574499130249,
-0.23136405646800995,
-0.2899252772331238,
-0.1423022300004959,
0.17153669893741608,
0.4317537844181061,
0.5100300312042236,
-0.18879017233848572,
-0.29394274950027466,
-0.5822906494140625,
-0.6968872547149658,
-0.5143498778343201,
0.04285123944282532,
0.498181015253067,
0.6157882809638977,
-0.08868978917598724,
1.101696491241455,
-0.7244669198989868,
-0.682193398475647,
-0.4994296133518219,
0.6686734557151794,
-0.12463490664958954,
0.30109766125679016,
0.611082136631012,
-0.769396960735321,
-0.0729735866189003,
0.21091917157173157,
-0.10651837289333344,
-0.10652269423007965,
-0.4153771698474884,
-0.309743195772171,
-0.2782314717769623,
0.582664430141449,
-0.4399109184741974,
0.6727374792098999,
-0.27538129687309265,
-0.5245776772499084,
0.6920855641365051,
-0.2713637351989746,
-0.1142474114894867,
-0.7666388750076294,
-0.029545309022068977,
0.1758543998003006,
-0.33787399530410767,
-0.6823943257331848,
0.13711996376514435,
0.3137640953063965,
0.04039447382092476,
-0.3592274487018585,
0.522084653377533,
-0.2785072922706604,
-0.01692245900630951,
-0.1806328296661377,
0.019946612417697906,
-0.038181520998477936,
0.6877634525299072,
-0.44464805722236633,
0.41606831550598145,
0.31747469305992126,
-0.7127457857131958,
0.3560420572757721,
0.42652517557144165,
-0.4223572015762329,
0.6635963916778564,
-0.2720538079738617,
-0.12216677516698837,
-0.4431939721107483,
0.12884122133255005,
-0.8129079341888428,
-0.13219179213047028,
0.47661757469177246,
-0.2526851296424866,
0.7591943740844727,
-0.43058544397354126,
-0.452992707490921,
-0.6028831005096436,
-0.021718326956033707,
0.7327656149864197,
0.04334596171975136,
-0.2386857271194458,
0.8356152176856995,
0.5467236638069153,
-0.129294291138649,
-0.6961562037467957,
-0.8472486138343811,
0.006969008594751358,
-0.15975835919380188,
0.007888701744377613,
0.7548365592956543,
0.1187465712428093,
-0.08499065786600113,
0.13809068500995636,
-0.22210508584976196,
-0.13262030482292175,
0.17904053628444672,
0.3582899272441864,
-0.006625432055443525,
0.30505505204200745,
0.6123812794685364,
0.14126500487327576,
0.14964085817337036,
0.29579901695251465,
-0.2620406746864319,
0.5333083868026733,
0.18878233432769775,
-0.39634940028190613,
-0.22736525535583496,
0.3055320680141449,
0.12045176327228546,
-0.32786041498184204,
0.023558808490633965,
0.15001900494098663,
-0.3958378732204437,
-0.35481226444244385,
-0.2540527284145355,
0.25617367029190063,
-0.4871610701084137,
0.28378474712371826,
-0.580750584602356,
-0.6241589188575745,
0.6262226104736328,
-0.1019623652100563,
-0.03277501091361046,
0.24131259322166443,
0.46557876467704773,
-0.07968589663505554,
0.8697683811187744,
0.9551523923873901,
-0.25153276324272156,
0.7430208325386047,
-0.044351693242788315,
0.9992193579673767,
-0.6694590449333191,
-0.6613905429840088,
-0.41646960377693176,
-0.5258983969688416,
-0.45797836780548096,
-0.39756426215171814,
0.2938968539237976,
0.33904314041137695,
-0.1739901900291443,
0.19732880592346191,
-0.4128403067588806,
0.5151506066322327,
0.3633626103401184,
0.20763376355171204,
0.17618030309677124,
0.22952178120613098,
-0.4660722613334656,
0.34479615092277527,
-0.5034489631652832,
0.008452639915049076,
1.1373343467712402,
0.12129099667072296,
0.7272937893867493,
0.09975388646125793,
0.6037431955337524,
0.6842933297157288,
0.1848381906747818,
-1.264480471611023,
0.5706709623336792,
-0.0225797388702631,
-0.36361950635910034,
0.08535538613796234,
-0.3730280101299286,
-1.1209545135498047,
0.30165666341781616,
-0.14990855753421783,
-1.1123963594436646,
0.2360774427652359,
0.07364806532859802,
-0.6250184774398804,
0.26039886474609375,
-0.3505289554595947,
0.6888952851295471,
-0.1829802542924881,
-0.1892128437757492,
-0.31895846128463745,
-0.5662597417831421,
0.6187285780906677,
0.1635320782661438,
0.2905574440956116,
-0.19474555552005768,
0.4265715777873993,
0.6218691468238831,
-0.638513445854187,
0.5757493376731873,
-0.18490342795848846,
-0.11876779794692993,
0.45264291763305664,
0.25972509384155273,
0.4691944420337677,
-0.07806743681430817,
0.3059467375278473,
-0.09946414083242416,
-0.22054563462734222,
-0.1571025252342224,
-0.6259286403656006,
0.25736069679260254,
-0.4479203522205353,
-0.6182364225387573,
-0.3828306496143341,
-0.9587407112121582,
-0.20463620126247406,
0.3630216717720032,
0.22115550935268402,
0.3185589015483856,
0.035098083317279816,
-0.3486722409725189,
0.6000638604164124,
-0.21362295746803284,
0.20196683704853058,
0.44349154829978943,
-0.35794371366500854,
-0.1509062498807907,
1.0463794469833374,
0.32531049847602844,
-0.3005029559135437,
0.4640972912311554,
0.22880792617797852,
-0.28907856345176697,
-0.4603680670261383,
-0.42771920561790466,
0.20298825204372406,
-0.7817791104316711,
-0.40788695216178894,
-1.047005534172058,
-0.07727200537919998,
-0.6283945441246033,
-0.04089765623211861,
0.2479676455259323,
-0.35893502831459045,
-0.008700008504092693,
-0.15825481712818146,
0.34604474902153015,
0.5540215969085693,
0.27071189880371094,
0.46185654401779175,
-0.6275966167449951,
0.2876903712749481,
0.29040995240211487,
0.23501430451869965,
-0.03662939369678497,
-0.4833018481731415,
-0.166533961892128,
-0.08888763189315796,
-0.6428305506706238,
-1.121050238609314,
0.2551240622997284,
0.00034712665365077555,
0.5574753880500793,
0.8365971446037292,
0.29542097449302673,
0.8085979223251343,
-0.6555495858192444,
0.5526081323623657,
0.4636463522911072,
-1.0232903957366943,
0.6145956516265869,
-0.15392358601093292,
-0.06777646392583847,
0.21677230298519135,
0.08835997432470322,
-0.644039511680603,
-0.41951170563697815,
-0.6579524278640747,
-1.0349217653274536,
0.9969135522842407,
0.3004031777381897,
-0.037853989750146866,
0.3784277141094208,
0.29720425605773926,
-0.005649148486554623,
0.38194477558135986,
-0.6840981841087341,
-0.19802404940128326,
-0.381664901971817,
-0.378985732793808,
0.25419580936431885,
-0.08351080119609833,
-0.36886823177337646,
-0.34272539615631104,
0.700141429901123,
-0.2108622044324875,
0.5142152309417725,
0.057588186115026474,
-0.11225535720586777,
0.031077081337571144,
0.1146441251039505,
0.6212087273597717,
0.34408819675445557,
-0.2307838350534439,
0.15027645230293274,
-0.03997143730521202,
-0.4123985469341278,
0.0850062370300293,
0.10226231813430786,
-0.33413684368133545,
-0.07470639050006866,
0.22168441116809845,
1.0242938995361328,
-0.15890146791934967,
-0.580936849117279,
0.6039501428604126,
-0.03091997653245926,
-0.6109704375267029,
-0.2140180468559265,
0.06589946895837784,
-0.04680689796805382,
0.07885907590389252,
0.1565140038728714,
0.14725805819034576,
0.5153937339782715,
-0.7155129909515381,
0.22943444550037384,
0.28273820877075195,
-0.42183005809783936,
-0.09481482952833176,
0.7139259576797485,
0.31781822443008423,
-0.15301617980003357,
0.24298571050167084,
-0.5969399213790894,
-0.8474077582359314,
0.6936773061752319,
0.44078466296195984,
0.9355375170707703,
-0.057098209857940674,
0.3564797043800354,
0.14859817922115326,
0.2412298321723938,
-0.08979026228189468,
0.2146507054567337,
-0.2564002573490143,
-0.7718844413757324,
0.12211579084396362,
-0.5179606676101685,
-0.11959860473871231,
0.30888399481773376,
-0.5965110063552856,
0.2765409052371979,
-0.6448081135749817,
-0.15487095713615417,
0.14994795620441437,
0.009063494391739368,
-0.5568950176239014,
0.2572735548019409,
0.16721895337104797,
0.8139824271202087,
-0.7460475564002991,
0.8498939275741577,
0.7558543086051941,
-0.4799386262893677,
-0.7849456071853638,
0.2912004590034485,
0.1698836237192154,
-0.6613907814025879,
0.8061015605926514,
0.4434642493724823,
-0.22416271269321442,
-0.32898852229118347,
-0.4288429021835327,
-0.6011242270469666,
0.7234995365142822,
-0.039772842079401016,
-0.6287369728088379,
-0.22629734873771667,
0.10957267135381699,
0.09934897720813751,
-0.3083550035953522,
-0.03328534960746765,
0.45822998881340027,
0.36208000779151917,
0.408915638923645,
-0.19592875242233276,
0.09249991923570633,
-0.22841264307498932,
-0.1444869041442871,
0.484353631734848,
-0.45950308442115784,
0.9842991232872009,
-0.361659973859787,
-0.5320940613746643,
-0.2871944010257721,
0.745928943157196,
-0.006108113098889589,
0.8078576922416687,
0.6752591133117676,
0.8807399272918701,
1.1290373802185059,
-0.18091683089733124,
0.8821046352386475,
-0.22865097224712372,
0.43211227655410767,
1.2379385232925415,
-0.6851842403411865,
0.4905315339565277,
0.5347121953964233,
-0.2386595904827118,
0.6274974942207336,
0.7061302661895752,
-0.4056524336338043,
0.5882178544998169,
0.5878468751907349,
-0.2118169218301773,
-0.2819203734397888,
-0.11436507105827332,
-0.10980238020420074,
0.2561356723308563,
0.4839855134487152,
-0.07231494039297104,
-0.4087611138820648,
0.034290000796318054,
-0.22861434519290924,
-0.11510682851076126,
-0.6714314818382263,
0.8448882102966309,
-0.10905972868204117,
-0.4430236518383026,
0.09374278038740158,
0.28657791018486023,
0.19003058969974518,
-0.30125176906585693,
-0.028241939842700958,
-0.1048957034945488,
0.2716739773750305,
-0.3312564492225647,
-0.7929598689079285,
0.13121703267097473,
-0.027920959517359734,
-0.2835098206996918,
-0.004534502513706684,
0.8265474438667297,
-0.5540752410888672,
-0.5904058814048767,
0.3114396035671234,
-0.060090869665145874,
0.16519121825695038,
-0.13298064470291138,
-0.9466599822044373,
-0.5133858919143677,
-0.03835035860538483,
0.006386736407876015,
0.29680338501930237,
0.6541634798049927,
-0.3622937500476837,
0.852224588394165,
0.44405385851860046,
0.014950553886592388,
0.10414362698793411,
0.13909555971622467,
0.8864947557449341,
-0.5004784464836121,
-0.8607231378555298,
-0.5221052765846252,
0.4924154579639435,
-0.3332260549068451,
-0.2326609194278717,
0.14693984389305115,
0.5063899159431458,
1.0373337268829346,
0.0831131562590599,
0.9005953669548035,
-0.22295959293842316,
0.32941630482673645,
-0.7350732684135437,
0.790208101272583,
-0.7936487197875977,
0.051929768174886703,
-0.06625065952539444,
-0.49496784806251526,
-0.08261363953351974,
0.5609599351882935,
-0.22818638384342194,
0.041478030383586884,
0.7544448971748352,
0.6643365025520325,
-0.32961505651474,
0.07388942688703537,
0.3839012384414673,
0.11145268380641937,
0.5189606547355652,
0.6737139225006104,
0.44116976857185364,
-0.5303068161010742,
0.6036353707313538,
-0.236051544547081,
0.21386678516864777,
-0.8642785549163818,
-0.6409662961959839,
-0.8496072292327881,
-0.3672541677951813,
-0.4083501696586609,
-0.2997635304927826,
-0.1825534999370575,
0.6362552642822266,
0.6851634383201599,
-0.8612900376319885,
0.00820369366556406,
-0.5797555446624756,
0.10183659195899963,
-0.3033353388309479,
-0.23729395866394043,
0.17575432360172272,
-0.5291036367416382,
-0.5608128309249878,
0.05280845984816551,
0.2860005497932434,
0.2091352343559265,
0.2837335467338562,
0.09160323441028595,
-0.18535947799682617,
0.30377745628356934,
0.4970843195915222,
-0.001050243736244738,
-0.886359691619873,
-0.3101162314414978,
-0.8255218267440796,
-0.16184823215007782,
-0.04923441633582115,
1.3333418369293213,
-0.7352567315101624,
0.5514208078384399,
0.6533767580986023,
0.7330951690673828,
0.528001606464386,
0.22896800935268402,
0.5777726173400879,
-0.7295840978622437,
0.2662152349948883,
0.18397663533687592,
0.7129446864128113,
0.09476592391729355,
-0.5397146344184875,
0.3984206020832062,
0.523959219455719,
-0.37602901458740234,
-0.6593591570854187,
0.7131808400154114,
-1.2266424894332886,
-0.7220820784568787,
0.5348761081695557,
-0.5023007988929749,
-0.5338214039802551,
-0.36234086751937866,
-0.4086219072341919,
0.45486631989479065,
-0.6362971067428589,
1.2227107286453247,
0.8339471817016602,
-0.06726846843957901,
-0.2219838798046112,
-0.44737374782562256,
0.6533322334289551,
0.5683462023735046,
-0.7230901122093201,
0.42775559425354004,
0.5056135654449463,
0.10314454883337021,
0.3922271430492401,
0.13789153099060059,
0.11916445195674896,
0.10959035158157349,
-0.08079376071691513,
0.2232499122619629,
-0.20811164379119873,
-0.36168554425239563,
-0.066550113260746,
0.3618066906929016,
-0.41494375467300415,
-0.20656533539295197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04327v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04327v2
|
ProMoAI: Process Modeling with Generative AI
| 2024-03-07T08:48:04 | 2024-04-29T12:24:24 |
Humam Kourani, Alessandro Berti, Daniel Schuster, Wil M. P. van der Aalst
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.CL
|
ProMoAI is a novel tool that leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to
automatically generate process models from textual descriptions, incorporating
advanced prompt engineering, error handling, and code generation techniques.
Beyond automating the generation of complex process models, ProMoAI also
supports process model optimization. Users can interact with the tool by
providing feedback on the generated model, which is then used for refining the
process model. ProMoAI utilizes the capabilities LLMs to offer a novel,
AI-driven approach to process modeling, significantly reducing the barrier to
entry for users without deep technical knowledge in process modeling.
|
[
-0.1423056274652481,
-0.5677856802940369,
0.46371138095855713,
0.1583625227212906,
-0.27424126863479614,
-0.10353200882673264,
-0.07454824447631836,
-0.05423428863286972,
0.2038629651069641,
0.6766481399536133,
-0.8992417454719543,
-0.5283867120742798,
-0.42497310042381287,
0.190584197640419,
-0.4013616442680359,
1.0353543758392334,
-0.016890937462449074,
0.26340654492378235,
-0.09240277111530304,
0.23227068781852722,
-0.044867973774671555,
-0.3617647886276245,
-1.084847092628479,
-0.4793460965156555,
0.6242310404777527,
0.43854770064353943,
0.5940719246864319,
0.3067343533039093,
0.63346928358078,
0.3072602152824402,
0.1336594820022583,
-0.11806406825780869,
-0.32549020648002625,
0.32104524970054626,
0.04343121498823166,
-0.827446699142456,
-0.6042940616607666,
0.03037698194384575,
0.2439107596874237,
0.41511717438697815,
-0.23672448098659515,
0.31398215889930725,
-0.2184474915266037,
0.5308850407600403,
-0.8034299612045288,
-0.049795087426900864,
-0.4971061050891876,
0.02629678137600422,
-0.3499036729335785,
-0.45067864656448364,
-0.3380254805088043,
-0.43540123105049133,
-0.10852177441120148,
-0.8354154229164124,
0.3487878143787384,
-0.2299872487783432,
0.7373546957969666,
0.4611878991127014,
-0.3574603796005249,
-0.6621275544166565,
-1.1190555095672607,
0.5878056287765503,
-0.8915410041809082,
-0.4077633321285248,
0.09108389168977737,
0.6080873608589172,
-0.38304343819618225,
-1.1572543382644653,
-0.8520431518554688,
-0.22185033559799194,
0.07710105180740356,
0.43029728531837463,
-0.1090756505727768,
0.3753158748149872,
0.4819025695323944,
0.6057485342025757,
-0.4851604998111725,
0.3312191963195801,
-0.5802464485168457,
0.062017232179641724,
0.737747073173523,
0.382697194814682,
0.6548336148262024,
-0.1269410103559494,
-0.3393176198005676,
-0.1731361299753189,
-0.6419602036476135,
-0.19053764641284943,
0.6630962491035461,
0.14425227046012878,
0.07558616250753403,
0.8091528415679932,
-0.1945486217737198,
0.6609485745429993,
-0.2472425252199173,
-0.4404582977294922,
-0.12826934456825256,
0.08208224922418594,
-0.7400357127189636,
-0.14508551359176636,
0.980984628200531,
0.10820968449115753,
0.26954999566078186,
0.024753883481025696,
-0.3632422685623169,
0.4512854814529419,
0.2599186897277832,
-0.8763689994812012,
-0.27192768454551697,
0.4392662048339844,
-0.41299524903297424,
-0.5830923914909363,
0.09385593235492706,
-0.5378075242042542,
-0.24744129180908203,
-0.278009831905365,
-0.16695718467235565,
-0.3042747378349304,
-0.34288257360458374,
-0.39638668298721313,
-0.5160207748413086,
0.6317826509475708,
0.34823957085609436,
-0.641403079032898,
0.060177434235811234,
0.8813040256500244,
0.9122570753097534,
-0.29437217116355896,
0.04201747104525566,
-0.5412622690200806,
0.2793637216091156,
-0.49008581042289734,
0.9396970272064209,
-0.9004465341567993,
-0.7734850645065308,
0.045042477548122406,
-0.15822167694568634,
-0.054288603365421295,
-0.700965404510498,
0.8326107859611511,
-0.912422239780426,
-0.23169457912445068,
0.40510454773902893,
-0.6934806704521179,
-0.21516145765781403,
0.3344930112361908,
-0.8559910655021667,
0.8051663041114807,
-0.07424484193325043,
-0.5393832921981812,
0.3697570860385895,
-0.9663740992546082,
-0.32548466324806213,
0.51719069480896,
-0.23107609152793884,
-0.3399161994457245,
0.3297618329524994,
0.11664877831935883,
0.44674181938171387,
-0.47802338004112244,
0.495535284280777,
-0.29973194003105164,
-0.00840360764414072,
0.40959471464157104,
-0.41367626190185547,
0.8514918684959412,
0.8396031260490417,
0.13069993257522583,
0.8418989181518555,
-0.9312931895256042,
-0.29517316818237305,
0.07479637116193771,
-0.4253826141357422,
-0.029478339478373528,
-0.2758921980857849,
0.20589597523212433,
0.22338038682937622,
0.144949272274971,
-0.2753452956676483,
0.5039507746696472,
-0.34444496035575867,
0.7431796789169312,
0.6981839537620544,
0.11381430178880692,
0.4740850031375885,
-0.3919602930545807,
1.224003553390503,
-0.033385131508111954,
0.1248754933476448,
-0.5086041688919067,
-0.6353321075439453,
-1.0019673109054565,
-0.3124117851257324,
0.21975451707839966,
0.7811358571052551,
-0.9558328986167908,
0.08444076776504517,
-0.22770342230796814,
-0.7762103080749512,
-0.4419618248939514,
0.37524843215942383,
0.05378241837024689,
0.3159131407737732,
-0.42487215995788574,
-0.1548246592283249,
-0.652768611907959,
-0.8890439867973328,
0.13803036510944366,
-0.25137704610824585,
-0.35889583826065063,
-0.15649671852588654,
0.3603672385215759,
-0.4747318923473358,
0.6533350944519043,
-0.45076221227645874,
-0.5047720670700073,
-0.5245859622955322,
0.46337905526161194,
0.42720821499824524,
0.2594135105609894,
0.2677844762802124,
-1.0079350471496582,
-0.49474480748176575,
-0.0574217289686203,
-0.7590479850769043,
-0.10018239170312881,
-0.21734167635440826,
-0.15470942854881287,
0.21592292189598083,
0.5823659300804138,
-0.5386658310890198,
0.5557121634483337,
0.7439155578613281,
0.10893043875694275,
0.8194765448570251,
-0.16917924582958221,
0.029248472303152084,
-1.5344058275222778,
0.3298211097717285,
0.32247409224510193,
0.03760354593396187,
-0.748961329460144,
0.5095759630203247,
-0.26947686076164246,
-0.7684460282325745,
-0.6192769408226013,
0.47535520792007446,
-0.4061984717845917,
-0.16603092849254608,
-0.5613009333610535,
-0.1130293607711792,
-0.1411244422197342,
0.5707537531852722,
0.26981136202812195,
1.228501319885254,
0.6885325908660889,
-0.8650186657905579,
0.5836440920829773,
0.04515199363231659,
-0.3453650176525116,
0.4796423316001892,
-0.7995743751525879,
0.07482785731554031,
0.12828755378723145,
0.06735459715127945,
-1.1901452541351318,
-0.6472401022911072,
0.2845766246318817,
-0.5127276182174683,
0.165622740983963,
-0.5214822888374329,
-0.4853096902370453,
-0.4920409023761749,
-0.13517962396144867,
0.35573655366897583,
0.7073207497596741,
-0.26127514243125916,
1.062926173210144,
0.3142073452472687,
-0.28716301918029785,
-0.1923103779554367,
-0.5618993043899536,
0.026142871007323265,
-0.5027046203613281,
-0.6290961503982544,
0.38181746006011963,
-0.09096398949623108,
-0.2938600182533264,
-0.28768980503082275,
0.3447844982147217,
-0.263560950756073,
0.16099411249160767,
0.4847334921360016,
0.3569616973400116,
-0.0597514845430851,
-0.026217054575681686,
-0.0148372333496809,
-0.25099819898605347,
0.10453181713819504,
-0.10277236998081207,
0.6505531668663025,
0.21533691883087158,
-0.2875984311103821,
-1.0267021656036377,
0.11510081589221954,
0.8586453199386597,
0.1538422852754593,
0.743234395980835,
0.4327067732810974,
-0.37972885370254517,
-0.0892501249909401,
-0.30084750056266785,
0.021743113175034523,
-0.5546984076499939,
-0.020804746076464653,
-0.7618233561515808,
-0.29666391015052795,
0.7661285400390625,
-0.5849416851997375,
0.07406719774007797,
0.5701454877853394,
0.795782208442688,
-0.1019444540143013,
1.0644328594207764,
0.7969696521759033,
0.1482105255126953,
0.3971216082572937,
-0.43212151527404785,
0.18039771914482117,
-1.0936073064804077,
-0.34359005093574524,
-0.606784462928772,
-0.20058904588222504,
-0.552139401435852,
-0.3614719808101654,
0.4102133512496948,
0.25514888763427734,
-0.10811853408813477,
0.21072328090667725,
-0.6503610014915466,
0.0589318573474884,
0.9168527126312256,
-0.2638687789440155,
0.40646621584892273,
0.006861304864287376,
-0.06764102727174759,
0.12385273724794388,
-0.8683054447174072,
-1.0288933515548706,
1.134013056755066,
0.15875209867954254,
1.1185553073883057,
0.0034648822620511055,
0.5799294710159302,
0.6112149357795715,
0.8949550986289978,
-1.1133993864059448,
0.5984700918197632,
-0.14180701971054077,
-0.3848843276500702,
-0.14256256818771362,
-0.18376465141773224,
-0.9047110080718994,
-0.2431325614452362,
-0.04006073996424675,
-0.346248596906662,
-0.0036944737657904625,
0.33870038390159607,
-0.3455691933631897,
0.4826418459415436,
-0.8521352410316467,
0.5116735100746155,
-0.2216769903898239,
0.04310839623212814,
-0.16976040601730347,
0.0833539366722107,
0.5737017393112183,
0.19780531525611877,
0.060798268765211105,
-0.18088389933109283,
0.0056448341347277164,
0.8915494680404663,
-0.7484955787658691,
1.0789107084274292,
0.0321584977209568,
-0.30657804012298584,
0.4251661002635956,
0.23298729956150055,
0.5379220843315125,
0.010549088940024376,
-0.3654940724372864,
-0.03730057179927826,
-0.10444369912147522,
-0.3166434168815613,
-0.7856295108795166,
0.7434204816818237,
-0.7844193577766418,
-0.8712276220321655,
-0.2882031202316284,
-0.18451738357543945,
0.19796442985534668,
0.04131974279880524,
0.47443732619285583,
0.03736642375588417,
-0.322251558303833,
-0.3976329565048218,
0.3545672595500946,
-0.3862772285938263,
0.409945547580719,
0.21906450390815735,
0.03367392718791962,
-0.46758177876472473,
0.6830469369888306,
-0.19890588521957397,
-0.10007686913013458,
0.42889371514320374,
-0.032454706728458405,
-0.006167692597955465,
-0.49689584970474243,
-0.4430300295352936,
0.11252320557832718,
-0.8993939757347107,
-0.3383474051952362,
-0.5240917801856995,
-0.4444853961467743,
-0.6265122890472412,
-0.3041722774505615,
-0.2409639060497284,
-0.33471572399139404,
-0.382405161857605,
-0.061819449067115784,
0.2989811599254608,
0.8279324769973755,
0.24253524839878082,
0.5606797337532043,
-0.6133925914764404,
0.3805411458015442,
0.43176281452178955,
0.1767951250076294,
0.08079871535301208,
-0.21304701268672943,
0.18870915472507477,
-0.08420030772686005,
-0.4865579903125763,
-0.9113839864730835,
0.626835823059082,
0.20592227578163147,
0.6282627582550049,
0.8230368494987488,
0.1174609363079071,
0.4351018965244293,
-0.188507542014122,
0.9975541234016418,
0.3123416304588318,
-0.8464082479476929,
1.1939250230789185,
-0.3257732391357422,
0.23928049206733704,
0.004876922350376844,
0.7023341655731201,
-0.4555250108242035,
-0.1487770527601242,
-0.5081321597099304,
-0.9105578660964966,
0.522603452205658,
0.18164874613285065,
0.16522076725959778,
-0.27196237444877625,
0.6046200394630432,
0.1653452068567276,
-0.008818055503070354,
-0.6149059534072876,
-0.03450127691030502,
0.04068665951490402,
-0.23482438921928406,
0.11086834967136383,
-0.5826641917228699,
-0.34329575300216675,
0.10542246699333191,
0.9963563680648804,
-0.19620804488658905,
0.32296693325042725,
0.09291955083608627,
-0.17770257592201233,
0.01568244956433773,
0.2205083817243576,
0.7048043012619019,
0.6314995884895325,
0.3026774525642395,
-0.2915668785572052,
0.03255690261721611,
-0.26973584294319153,
0.2192784547805786,
-0.11227494478225708,
-0.23497578501701355,
-0.2550634443759918,
0.4995822310447693,
0.9565353989601135,
-0.3263806998729706,
-0.7657448649406433,
0.11879634857177734,
-0.1713692843914032,
-0.3198132812976837,
-1.0044615268707275,
0.47845974564552307,
-0.06662851572036743,
0.12133969366550446,
0.48730120062828064,
0.09519929438829422,
0.2660819888114929,
-0.5879112482070923,
-0.010694804601371288,
0.2088056206703186,
-0.22949042916297913,
-0.339285671710968,
0.8881862759590149,
0.5293922424316406,
-0.7502827048301697,
1.0949804782867432,
-0.003569027641788125,
-0.1938125193119049,
0.8181148171424866,
0.3345794379711151,
1.1089566946029663,
-0.08666101843118668,
0.4373071789741516,
0.49778813123703003,
-0.07731408625841141,
0.1930399090051651,
0.013061345554888248,
-0.1602185070514679,
-0.7437189221382141,
-0.49049636721611023,
-0.7203216552734375,
-0.535761833190918,
0.36749136447906494,
-0.7691704630851746,
0.49014991521835327,
-0.557204008102417,
-0.47411808371543884,
0.07433862239122391,
-0.31801947951316833,
-0.7672809958457947,
0.18334421515464783,
0.14756092429161072,
1.0649536848068237,
-0.8368636965751648,
0.8796206116676331,
1.058148980140686,
-0.6926549673080444,
-0.6066233515739441,
0.15875181555747986,
-0.2212369292974472,
-0.8449264764785767,
1.0222159624099731,
0.12161625176668167,
-0.03847821429371834,
-0.11253740638494492,
-0.5150066614151001,
-0.5755319595336914,
1.1408324241638184,
0.30499136447906494,
-0.6243445873260498,
-0.1347118616104126,
0.13473963737487793,
0.6662818193435669,
-0.506442129611969,
0.2691066563129425,
0.5439995527267456,
0.25365716218948364,
0.5297438502311707,
-0.42330941557884216,
-0.05054964870214462,
-0.7394094467163086,
0.6406781077384949,
-0.23356162011623383,
-0.3870618939399719,
0.43236541748046875,
-0.18319791555404663,
-0.659209668636322,
0.2873964309692383,
0.8085070848464966,
0.45636439323425293,
0.22532136738300323,
0.2721034586429596,
0.7907060384750366,
0.5796297192573547,
-0.19849734008312225,
1.3981349468231201,
-0.4142853021621704,
-0.17445164918899536,
0.9271137714385986,
-0.490605890750885,
0.7597357034683228,
0.34582334756851196,
-0.07797043770551682,
0.8414934277534485,
0.6854586005210876,
0.003868814092129469,
0.29080846905708313,
0.24237170815467834,
-0.40057748556137085,
-0.14528222382068634,
0.03455289825797081,
0.250519335269928,
0.2850112020969391,
0.6360985040664673,
-0.3841009736061096,
-0.02491990476846695,
0.3698192238807678,
-0.2077033966779709,
0.20204192399978638,
-0.4313969910144806,
1.188002109527588,
0.0670676976442337,
-1.1243846416473389,
0.3437356650829315,
0.32288479804992676,
0.8766046762466431,
-0.6234928369522095,
-0.08670493215322495,
-0.3361871838569641,
0.1810888946056366,
-0.00914174597710371,
-0.7215889096260071,
0.7575796246528625,
0.1799747496843338,
-0.2315124124288559,
-0.08864059299230576,
0.7942233085632324,
-0.09481705725193024,
-0.7935779690742493,
0.1270214319229126,
0.015073790214955807,
0.19867601990699768,
-0.03384501487016678,
-0.8920534253120422,
0.22438496351242065,
-0.30713385343551636,
-0.2224712073802948,
-0.1034126728773117,
0.2742435336112976,
-0.26006215810775757,
1.212797999382019,
0.7601349949836731,
0.08123790472745895,
0.0359676331281662,
0.5173292756080627,
0.7100793123245239,
-0.5187894701957703,
-0.5840972661972046,
-0.7927038073539734,
0.4364444315433502,
-0.18331359326839447,
-0.24267859756946564,
0.4278026223182678,
0.5275055766105652,
0.7766134142875671,
-0.39201244711875916,
1.1727937459945679,
-0.032093483954668045,
0.031184107065200806,
-0.7044116854667664,
0.48745959997177124,
-0.35168832540512085,
0.3315542936325073,
0.011666289530694485,
-0.9445561170578003,
-0.24775244295597076,
0.36209917068481445,
-0.2680448293685913,
0.053950294852256775,
0.2090928852558136,
0.9371077418327332,
0.10320774465799332,
-0.3094419538974762,
0.44454750418663025,
-0.18137343227863312,
0.5494243502616882,
0.5250565409660339,
0.8606243133544922,
-0.3598412275314331,
0.6902369260787964,
-0.09234964102506638,
-0.3451915979385376,
-0.16709129512310028,
-0.7970921993255615,
-1.0211516618728638,
-0.6968472599983215,
-0.5372089743614197,
-0.08023932576179504,
-0.07007575035095215,
0.5944854617118835,
0.9675222039222717,
-0.9217022657394409,
-0.35598134994506836,
-0.5346457958221436,
-0.07873206585645676,
-0.17334185540676117,
-0.35611075162887573,
0.1229281947016716,
-0.5273569226264954,
-1.1700072288513184,
0.17829473316669464,
0.33182987570762634,
0.16580639779567719,
-0.6235253214836121,
-0.18044991791248322,
0.0011828828137367964,
0.3273817300796509,
0.2958276569843292,
0.3471906781196594,
-0.8696956038475037,
0.5452715754508972,
-0.20738686621189117,
0.12697847187519073,
-0.09336674213409424,
1.3763068914413452,
-0.5943260788917542,
0.2939417362213135,
0.680484414100647,
0.4972810447216034,
0.6030729413032532,
-0.20625802874565125,
1.1789631843566895,
-0.6729496121406555,
0.34907621145248413,
0.09460049867630005,
0.44608762860298157,
0.4733709692955017,
-0.6433177590370178,
0.5962077975273132,
0.07661506533622742,
-0.2893182039260864,
-0.5678189992904663,
0.6160717606544495,
-0.9143617153167725,
-0.3516969382762909,
1.1108280420303345,
-0.2682996392250061,
-0.3521851897239685,
0.23170308768749237,
-0.10298793762922287,
0.5627857446670532,
-0.2035617232322693,
0.8404873013496399,
0.5424339175224304,
-0.05842849984765053,
-0.4088064134120941,
-0.2894916534423828,
0.737930178642273,
0.03012833185493946,
-0.8207660913467407,
-0.2884175479412079,
0.10560085624456406,
0.2924131453037262,
0.22865030169487,
0.7180266380310059,
-0.12830132246017456,
0.2665558159351349,
-0.09323836117982864,
0.2541228234767914,
-0.08709373325109482,
-0.20495247840881348,
-0.14087022840976715,
0.3121732175350189,
0.2422538548707962,
-0.07280156761407852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04325v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04325v2
|
Measuring Meaning Composition in the Human Brain with Composition Scores from Large Language Models
| 2024-03-07T08:44:42 | 2024-03-18T11:17:48 |
Changjiang Gao, Jixing Li, Jiajun Chen, Shujian Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The process of meaning composition, wherein smaller units like morphemes or
words combine to form the meaning of phrases and sentences, is essential for
human sentence comprehension. Despite extensive neurolinguistic research into
the brain regions involved in meaning composition, a computational metric to
quantify the extent of composition is still lacking. Drawing on the key-value
memory interpretation of transformer feed-forward network blocks, we introduce
the Composition Score, a novel model-based metric designed to quantify the
degree of meaning composition during sentence comprehension. Experimental
findings show that this metric correlates with brain clusters associated with
word frequency, structural processing, and general sensitivity to words,
suggesting the multifaceted nature of meaning composition during human sentence
comprehension.
|
[
-0.42103099822998047,
-0.8607694506645203,
0.6345070004463196,
0.47286513447761536,
-0.33080577850341797,
0.050539273768663406,
-0.1196524128317833,
-0.3147031366825104,
0.39901626110076904,
0.3370971083641052,
-0.5418415665626526,
-0.27407485246658325,
-0.4854552447795868,
-0.15822665393352509,
-0.423213928937912,
0.8850147128105164,
0.12201014161109924,
-0.21724577248096466,
-0.7180275917053223,
-0.23639194667339325,
-0.8480997681617737,
-0.2761739194393158,
-0.4648004472255707,
-0.524833619594574,
0.8855584263801575,
-0.08398787677288055,
0.5098658204078674,
0.7559512257575989,
0.7086163759231567,
0.22621765732765198,
-0.09406331181526184,
-0.11853915452957153,
-0.08629509061574936,
0.25128328800201416,
-0.3132690489292145,
-0.7784028649330139,
-0.6622796058654785,
0.14914238452911377,
0.7464011311531067,
1.2828048467636108,
-0.12174218147993088,
-0.014850731007754803,
0.05802144110202789,
0.6873396039009094,
-0.7118221521377563,
0.1861933320760727,
-0.43297308683395386,
0.09807660430669785,
-0.07595226913690567,
-0.17062342166900635,
-0.2968796491622925,
-0.07830195873975754,
0.3216466009616852,
-0.1793530285358429,
-0.13501213490962982,
-0.026718128472566605,
0.42686930298805237,
0.32289695739746094,
-0.41972360014915466,
-0.24246998131275177,
-0.2978456914424896,
0.7998974323272705,
-0.3886467218399048,
0.23128032684326172,
0.30744224786758423,
-0.04256637394428253,
0.22886213660240173,
-0.6028635501861572,
-0.7972286939620972,
-0.06333032995462418,
-0.42280954122543335,
0.22911174595355988,
-0.2725428342819214,
0.1353447288274765,
-0.2032594084739685,
0.32558533549308777,
-0.6493353247642517,
-0.33188095688819885,
-0.476518452167511,
-0.3294733464717865,
0.49714481830596924,
0.7727241516113281,
0.7087489366531372,
-0.18624798953533173,
-0.1504053920507431,
-0.29017525911331177,
-0.2804977297782898,
-0.15755032002925873,
0.30093860626220703,
0.19526134431362152,
-0.1224709004163742,
0.5366286039352417,
0.20933254063129425,
1.019780158996582,
-0.41166603565216064,
-0.02697564847767353,
0.07423106580972672,
-0.3256685733795166,
-0.2517852783203125,
-0.14485999941825867,
0.8687739372253418,
0.4862658679485321,
0.1775227189064026,
-0.4068123400211334,
-0.15785545110702515,
0.38762617111206055,
0.6236772537231445,
-0.6834226846694946,
-0.41771820187568665,
0.025587188079953194,
-0.5041227340698242,
-0.218977153301239,
0.17505666613578796,
-0.4114401042461395,
-0.22548183798789978,
-0.3908153474330902,
0.5675936937332153,
-0.5104295611381531,
-0.3092072010040283,
0.20675167441368103,
-0.414052814245224,
0.14302045106887817,
-0.35251420736312866,
-0.9701856374740601,
0.3516343832015991,
0.6480585336685181,
1.0650815963745117,
-0.5550099015235901,
-0.5240916013717651,
-0.04361052066087723,
-0.04480922594666481,
-0.2764469087123871,
0.9399625658988953,
-0.4592336118221283,
-0.5085793137550354,
-0.531777560710907,
-0.11054151505231857,
-0.4508930444717407,
-0.5192357897758484,
0.2944261431694031,
-0.6070368885993958,
0.07320036739110947,
-0.24111565947532654,
-0.7723026871681213,
-0.3589616119861603,
0.2518939971923828,
-0.8436108231544495,
0.7214735150337219,
0.4058908522129059,
-0.5115176439285278,
0.09493142366409302,
-0.7409261465072632,
-0.9547817707061768,
0.24540939927101135,
0.0901058092713356,
0.11891821771860123,
0.6232081055641174,
-0.4144347906112671,
0.4017300605773926,
-0.1397078037261963,
0.03966508060693741,
-0.0302612092345953,
-0.36422333121299744,
1.025323748588562,
-0.3589380085468292,
0.5495569705963135,
0.01688026823103428,
-0.08518026769161224,
-0.044867753982543945,
-0.6276591420173645,
0.16835035383701324,
-0.24647676944732666,
-0.3137909173965454,
-0.3711293339729309,
0.27673837542533875,
-0.021392997354269028,
0.14478589594364166,
0.20209351181983948,
-0.3131505846977234,
-0.23363937437534332,
-0.482454776763916,
0.9106586575508118,
0.43044140934944153,
0.17574508488178253,
0.6120390892028809,
-0.7036281824111938,
0.43268299102783203,
0.18792971968650818,
-0.2398766130208969,
-0.41088858246803284,
-0.5344958305358887,
-0.5250096917152405,
-0.23649752140045166,
0.2731916606426239,
0.47473299503326416,
0.22854191064834595,
0.941020667552948,
-0.5630577802658081,
-0.4982335865497589,
-0.5218490362167358,
-0.20094741880893707,
-0.10310457646846771,
0.46748030185699463,
0.4133135974407196,
-0.37205177545547485,
-0.27481505274772644,
-1.058539867401123,
-0.24487754702568054,
-0.027581917122006416,
-0.2863369286060333,
0.06588731706142426,
0.647733747959137,
-0.08522086590528488,
0.9039385318756104,
-1.0739455223083496,
-0.48251619935035706,
0.05658511444926262,
0.1560513973236084,
0.004126261919736862,
0.12696920335292816,
0.18340635299682617,
-0.6419287323951721,
-0.3816642761230469,
-0.036190565675497055,
-0.44759929180145264,
-0.11626842617988586,
-0.04403311014175415,
-0.21996545791625977,
-0.16856594383716583,
0.3812357783317566,
-0.47895681858062744,
0.030668390914797783,
0.8689918518066406,
-0.6241421103477478,
0.4513242244720459,
0.016185274347662926,
0.24012534320354462,
-1.0076024532318115,
0.35735076665878296,
-0.31057095527648926,
0.1823827177286148,
-0.2842634618282318,
0.20705610513687134,
-0.1337946504354477,
0.22209475934505463,
-0.41745927929878235,
0.3114856481552124,
-0.27903950214385986,
0.09259625524282455,
-0.6049998998641968,
0.3336777687072754,
0.4003483057022095,
0.3040609657764435,
-0.16811706125736237,
0.5786365270614624,
0.36519017815589905,
-0.5341243743896484,
0.5833512544631958,
0.020583856850862503,
-0.5010549426078796,
1.0731315612792969,
-0.8292880654335022,
0.03202848881483078,
-0.2857033908367157,
0.027725189924240112,
-1.3548141717910767,
-0.29674363136291504,
-0.174775630235672,
-0.38291826844215393,
-0.2095777541399002,
0.3765396177768707,
-0.274416446685791,
-0.10437236726284027,
0.08667504787445068,
0.7151291370391846,
0.42752158641815186,
0.3230469524860382,
0.8183248043060303,
0.538280725479126,
0.14246660470962524,
-0.020022034645080566,
-1.3815999031066895,
0.0335458442568779,
-0.2613954246044159,
-0.9153333902359009,
0.6997465491294861,
-0.22697708010673523,
-0.2497103363275528,
0.25356850028038025,
0.11277516186237335,
-0.23242990672588348,
0.2185641974210739,
0.47661879658699036,
-0.014520957134664059,
-0.2582322657108307,
0.3340224623680115,
0.15691104531288147,
0.05348379909992218,
0.5644015073776245,
-0.17762717604637146,
0.6190594434738159,
-0.07429566234350204,
-0.25452613830566406,
-0.1549241542816162,
0.7642675638198853,
0.8455169200897217,
-0.23100224137306213,
0.9995766878128052,
0.36186620593070984,
-0.4615386426448822,
-0.3055003881454468,
-0.06495596468448639,
-0.3579026758670807,
-0.32847005128860474,
0.28448930382728577,
-0.40511688590049744,
-0.9596248865127563,
0.8565945029258728,
0.32569608092308044,
-0.38765689730644226,
0.5705336928367615,
0.37445172667503357,
-0.3886414170265198,
0.744099497795105,
0.12553472816944122,
-0.010337426327168941,
0.1451171636581421,
-0.09283475577831268,
0.30656906962394714,
-0.9308921694755554,
-0.24895735085010529,
-0.18951895833015442,
-0.9515994787216187,
-0.3295319080352783,
-0.3926384150981903,
0.42579537630081177,
-0.19231703877449036,
-0.057471245527267456,
0.13868887722492218,
-0.5120754837989807,
0.6810154914855957,
0.3273422420024872,
0.20540359616279602,
0.22393150627613068,
-0.21785613894462585,
-0.07064242660999298,
-0.08825218677520752,
-0.028624754399061203,
-0.17244058847427368,
0.8222250938415527,
-0.06001175194978714,
0.37237977981567383,
-0.03467816486954689,
0.21023407578468323,
0.2556900084018707,
0.051488906145095825,
-1.0532113313674927,
0.4389314353466034,
-0.18556278944015503,
-0.5605512261390686,
-0.07622730731964111,
-0.3376172184944153,
-0.8434957265853882,
0.2329396903514862,
-0.0711161196231842,
-0.7440178990364075,
-0.4202326238155365,
-0.12028291821479797,
-0.6221362948417664,
0.0007460033521056175,
-0.5461726188659668,
1.1604106426239014,
-0.1355082094669342,
0.3128984272480011,
-0.46606987714767456,
-0.6758586764335632,
0.3499320149421692,
-0.07983692735433578,
-0.0440424382686615,
-0.08169720321893692,
-0.10322654992341995,
0.8753383159637451,
-0.14994902908802032,
0.8153164982795715,
0.2884163558483124,
-0.003595905378460884,
0.4448004961013794,
0.15849417448043823,
-0.036293309181928635,
-0.31943604350090027,
-0.026806658133864403,
0.16196461021900177,
0.14841990172863007,
-0.23614400625228882,
-0.7018214464187622,
0.7088012099266052,
-0.7251657843589783,
-0.06428781151771545,
-0.060525063425302505,
-0.7942602038383484,
-0.04388819634914398,
0.11059433221817017,
0.3754129409790039,
0.1374274641275406,
-0.21797175705432892,
0.4926163852214813,
0.6758528351783752,
0.08648435026407242,
0.4931575655937195,
-0.01292545534670353,
0.1260770857334137,
-0.5239540338516235,
0.766987144947052,
0.18954437971115112,
0.38639432191848755,
0.7869889736175537,
0.40729835629463196,
-0.32604095339775085,
-0.25937074422836304,
0.02412666566669941,
0.0637025460600853,
-0.6317163705825806,
-0.17831408977508545,
-0.6899498105049133,
-0.3115048110485077,
0.13951681554317474,
-0.23016726970672607,
-0.19437718391418457,
-0.12162891775369644,
-0.32048946619033813,
-0.1922152042388916,
0.12403751164674759,
0.44789835810661316,
0.2251318246126175,
0.6725954413414001,
-0.9518249034881592,
0.18186642229557037,
0.376956582069397,
0.4199199080467224,
0.15940257906913757,
-0.501682698726654,
-0.39772993326187134,
0.3133760094642639,
-0.3747355341911316,
-1.0282926559448242,
0.22586415708065033,
0.389009028673172,
0.47167491912841797,
0.31837087869644165,
-0.4329105317592621,
0.5671278238296509,
-0.10833877325057983,
0.9971747994422913,
0.21621602773666382,
-1.3152614831924438,
0.425218403339386,
-0.18423998355865479,
0.6601732969284058,
0.5019991397857666,
0.13091973960399628,
-1.0899171829223633,
-0.23222383856773376,
-0.15878550708293915,
-0.6048869490623474,
0.22929516434669495,
-0.1883014291524887,
0.5170097947120667,
-0.2793383002281189,
0.26306989789009094,
-0.14049401879310608,
0.016566716134548187,
-0.6408766508102417,
-0.2321435660123825,
-0.01864028535783291,
-0.5100035071372986,
0.07785853743553162,
0.039478935301303864,
-0.15954624116420746,
-0.2414340227842331,
0.18020352721214294,
-0.26277559995651245,
0.4369341731071472,
-0.20839765667915344,
-0.32020512223243713,
-0.1790698766708374,
0.04455447942018509,
0.7529955506324768,
0.6606511473655701,
0.2424863576889038,
0.40199166536331177,
0.10913627594709396,
-0.6194257736206055,
0.1640135943889618,
-0.46803826093673706,
-0.07963953912258148,
-0.29143068194389343,
0.4873870313167572,
0.7264358997344971,
0.26193171739578247,
-0.5799237489700317,
0.6342098712921143,
0.06104420870542526,
-0.3743184208869934,
0.0517294704914093,
0.22013235092163086,
0.6668015718460083,
0.04991590976715088,
0.3754134476184845,
0.24658124148845673,
0.25766879320144653,
-0.5391088724136353,
0.1946607530117035,
0.3104828894138336,
-0.49262022972106934,
-0.6539939045906067,
0.44134581089019775,
-0.20452716946601868,
0.008670293726027012,
0.979322075843811,
-0.15349385142326355,
-0.4216037690639496,
0.5128329396247864,
0.5897008776664734,
0.9449388980865479,
-0.19721747934818268,
0.18634234368801117,
0.0830666795372963,
0.25161728262901306,
-0.022643735632300377,
0.43495309352874756,
-0.023384705185890198,
-1.015905737876892,
-0.8358700275421143,
-1.0107306241989136,
0.0765453577041626,
-0.06653193384408951,
-0.5511583089828491,
-0.12246310710906982,
-0.026226863265037537,
-0.28801241517066956,
0.17378686368465424,
-0.33352622389793396,
-0.43801042437553406,
0.4514206349849701,
0.2868969440460205,
0.580712080001831,
-1.2642896175384521,
0.555464506149292,
0.7802374958992004,
-0.3517703115940094,
-0.9852122664451599,
-0.15096911787986755,
-0.4444928765296936,
-0.4197944700717926,
0.6216246485710144,
0.27593570947647095,
-0.08003579825162888,
0.04647419974207878,
-0.16277292370796204,
-0.6603286862373352,
0.8633750677108765,
0.41727715730667114,
-0.024989759549498558,
-0.22390401363372803,
0.5215383172035217,
0.734438955783844,
-0.4217584431171417,
0.2861122786998749,
0.8609294295310974,
0.7055436372756958,
0.1188385859131813,
-0.48668450117111206,
0.22378858923912048,
-0.09673779457807541,
0.08418155461549759,
0.5780313014984131,
-0.23378486931324005,
0.9342125058174133,
0.3711502254009247,
-0.28243622183799744,
-0.21248027682304382,
0.7315976023674011,
-0.17106316983699799,
-0.04560328274965286,
0.3344450294971466,
0.7809224128723145,
0.6836850047111511,
-0.2266780436038971,
0.6456892490386963,
-0.4045637547969818,
0.057835232466459274,
0.7375240921974182,
0.223809152841568,
0.7498212456703186,
0.6519638895988464,
-0.3493683338165283,
0.7678156495094299,
0.28370487689971924,
0.06593901664018631,
0.5577756762504578,
0.5155968070030212,
-0.4563760459423065,
-0.13016881048679352,
0.03762388601899147,
0.18651054799556732,
0.9800439476966858,
0.5890259146690369,
-0.49292534589767456,
0.20362521708011627,
0.0984644740819931,
-0.17757341265678406,
0.1825522482395172,
-0.0942276120185852,
0.8599338531494141,
0.3329506814479828,
-1.1297043561935425,
0.16511096060276031,
0.005740531720221043,
0.3872464895248413,
-0.4784984886646271,
0.2089357227087021,
-0.2300974428653717,
0.1602524071931839,
-0.30869200825691223,
-1.1521507501602173,
1.039409875869751,
-0.569974422454834,
-0.443550169467926,
-0.05240590125322342,
0.19221417605876923,
-0.4972262382507324,
-0.1545865535736084,
0.2061644196510315,
0.487783282995224,
-0.000015972582332324237,
-0.6647902131080627,
-0.2501522898674011,
0.12116166204214096,
-0.5198689699172974,
-0.1399552971124649,
0.274284303188324,
0.42951637506484985,
0.09107915312051773,
0.20650675892829895,
0.4317365288734436,
0.14419029653072357,
0.2923039495944977,
0.024396320804953575,
0.4500722587108612,
-0.8873435258865356,
-0.7573496103286743,
-1.3251187801361084,
0.6625412106513977,
0.12435464560985565,
-0.5007992386817932,
0.35611218214035034,
0.3555756211280823,
0.5385648012161255,
-0.177170068025589,
0.6951109170913696,
-0.15317368507385254,
-0.17896205186843872,
-0.2506428360939026,
0.7665802836418152,
-0.4016670286655426,
-0.3099915385246277,
-0.004927420988678932,
-1.2382805347442627,
-0.5642963647842407,
0.554661750793457,
0.021489836275577545,
-0.20480337738990784,
1.042845606803894,
0.7737381458282471,
-0.12022164463996887,
0.2227925956249237,
0.5066784620285034,
-0.09904613345861435,
0.03500475361943245,
0.6841586232185364,
0.8023423552513123,
-0.3540044128894806,
0.4253275990486145,
0.08385463804006577,
-0.08963410556316376,
-0.018020767718553543,
-0.8442772030830383,
-0.565157949924469,
-0.9358003735542297,
-0.20078323781490326,
-0.10557419061660767,
-0.38894057273864746,
0.42938128113746643,
0.6968677043914795,
-0.5939066410064697,
-0.40985700488090515,
-0.4222852885723114,
-0.037741709500551224,
-0.6937614679336548,
-0.3348478674888611,
0.20810732245445251,
-0.3523533344268799,
-0.3658493459224701,
0.4086436629295349,
0.5150315165519714,
-0.20843300223350525,
-0.5721731185913086,
0.10973664373159409,
0.07470233738422394,
0.444388210773468,
0.688029944896698,
-0.4262567460536957,
-0.46988219022750854,
-0.28626835346221924,
0.26288747787475586,
-0.43895477056503296,
0.1213635727763176,
1.003266453742981,
-0.5171494483947754,
0.40104150772094727,
0.9828360080718994,
0.6546230912208557,
0.27137359976768494,
-0.16272421181201935,
0.6642231941223145,
-0.9625370502471924,
-0.34386056661605835,
0.341449111700058,
0.3279005289077759,
0.4182392954826355,
-0.22878782451152802,
0.05256379768252373,
0.4561280906200409,
-0.42338839173316956,
-0.30477532744407654,
0.40848395228385925,
-1.272759199142456,
-0.3668411672115326,
0.7176057696342468,
0.05679820850491524,
-0.6451367139816284,
0.30282214283943176,
0.07945860922336578,
0.09810017794370651,
0.09202569723129272,
0.6638564467430115,
1.0438816547393799,
-0.04962698742747307,
-0.05175153911113739,
-0.2565173804759979,
0.07034885883331299,
0.22926780581474304,
-0.8339985013008118,
-0.11059051007032394,
0.5741662979125977,
0.27582070231437683,
0.39203551411628723,
0.2967536449432373,
-0.008286740630865097,
0.21362732350826263,
0.15646594762802124,
-0.03433237597346306,
0.2744728922843933,
-0.1425917148590088,
-0.056028448045253754,
0.7157288789749146,
-0.42163756489753723,
-0.18458952009677887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04321v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04321v2
|
Discriminative Probing and Tuning for Text-to-Image Generation
| 2024-03-07T08:37:33 | 2024-03-14T08:02:29 |
Leigang Qu, Wenjie Wang, Yongqi Li, Hanwang Zhang, Liqiang Nie, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Despite advancements in text-to-image generation (T2I), prior methods often
face text-image misalignment problems such as relation confusion in generated
images. Existing solutions involve cross-attention manipulation for better
compositional understanding or integrating large language models for improved
layout planning. However, the inherent alignment capabilities of T2I models are
still inadequate. By reviewing the link between generative and discriminative
modeling, we posit that T2I models' discriminative abilities may reflect their
text-image alignment proficiency during generation. In this light, we advocate
bolstering the discriminative abilities of T2I models to achieve more precise
text-to-image alignment for generation. We present a discriminative adapter
built on T2I models to probe their discriminative abilities on two
representative tasks and leverage discriminative fine-tuning to improve their
text-image alignment. As a bonus of the discriminative adapter, a
self-correction mechanism can leverage discriminative gradients to better align
generated images to text prompts during inference. Comprehensive evaluations
across three benchmark datasets, including both in-distribution and
out-of-distribution scenarios, demonstrate our method's superior generation
performance. Meanwhile, it achieves state-of-the-art discriminative performance
on the two discriminative tasks compared to other generative models.
|
[
-0.34529054164886475,
-0.42900264263153076,
0.4550756514072418,
0.11406978964805603,
-0.37225133180618286,
-0.21365323662757874,
-0.15564042329788208,
-0.3674113154411316,
-0.43121787905693054,
0.4203585982322693,
-0.6908957362174988,
-0.32643458247184753,
-0.5705740451812744,
0.10206529498100281,
-0.26364171504974365,
0.9562760591506958,
-0.008788620121777058,
-0.15362632274627686,
-0.29728323221206665,
-0.10759645700454712,
-0.8582983613014221,
0.2641679048538208,
-0.722887396812439,
-0.2443726807832718,
0.36103951930999756,
0.446292519569397,
0.6972660422325134,
1.0225801467895508,
0.527218759059906,
0.1764388084411621,
0.24535731971263885,
0.5317333936691284,
-0.7138569951057434,
0.06267198175191879,
-0.5209924578666687,
-0.3976612389087677,
-0.18501703441143036,
-0.2300458699464798,
0.6125246286392212,
0.25065669417381287,
0.09286794811487198,
0.15011921525001526,
0.04711742699146271,
0.7233268618583679,
-0.7757822275161743,
-0.3517627716064453,
-0.7363560199737549,
-0.01109972596168518,
-0.2568134665489197,
-0.4471413195133209,
-0.6817904114723206,
-0.2973368167877197,
-0.061329469084739685,
-0.7781758904457092,
0.8886557221412659,
0.10848362743854523,
0.9489502310752869,
0.6891925930976868,
-0.636694610118866,
-0.30630919337272644,
-0.9398230910301208,
0.7563390135765076,
-0.49070432782173157,
0.273566871881485,
0.031074244529008865,
0.2610234320163727,
0.05203893035650253,
-0.63638836145401,
-0.5610522627830505,
0.3234728276729584,
-0.03962606564164162,
0.4311612546443939,
-0.13090404868125916,
-0.09163147956132889,
0.17886050045490265,
0.2883957326412201,
-0.5904290080070496,
0.33569929003715515,
-0.2103956937789917,
0.13625706732273102,
0.7404052019119263,
0.10275278240442276,
0.26517269015312195,
0.06887776404619217,
-0.3814306855201721,
-0.3916019797325134,
-0.6669737696647644,
-0.3691145181655884,
0.38888660073280334,
0.11323698610067368,
-0.08909248560667038,
0.684929370880127,
0.41959238052368164,
0.750819981098175,
0.7995164394378662,
0.07506867498159409,
-0.07259292900562286,
-0.5542329549789429,
0.0455888956785202,
0.15969140827655792,
0.7751546502113342,
0.866543173789978,
0.2597144842147827,
-0.09874723851680756,
-0.3303525745868683,
0.24658438563346863,
0.50795978307724,
-0.8580177426338196,
-0.30013135075569153,
0.21092306077480316,
-0.6376716494560242,
-0.4697854816913605,
-0.1008465364575386,
-0.9472391605377197,
-0.28385287523269653,
-0.20146813988685608,
0.3885989487171173,
-0.38001787662506104,
-0.40174752473831177,
-0.1511148363351822,
-0.43888935446739197,
0.4069557189941406,
0.028667422011494637,
-1.2495222091674805,
-0.05159054324030876,
0.5802424550056458,
0.6660754084587097,
-0.25780948996543884,
-0.11478493362665176,
-0.3091011643409729,
0.5932294130325317,
-0.7242617011070251,
1.1258518695831299,
-0.34370723366737366,
-0.34846314787864685,
0.3146408796310425,
-0.06268400698900223,
-0.11934272944927216,
-0.5990707874298096,
0.44300347566604614,
-0.4251522123813629,
0.3750871419906616,
-0.23682531714439392,
-0.6436665654182434,
0.21233293414115906,
0.09531807899475098,
-0.6963093876838684,
1.0591151714324951,
0.16081196069717407,
-1.0390868186950684,
0.5579732656478882,
-0.5880357027053833,
-0.5737016201019287,
0.019343530759215355,
-0.2842141389846802,
-0.861788272857666,
0.3463038206100464,
0.34041455388069153,
0.32440561056137085,
-0.2909850776195526,
0.29497888684272766,
-0.1917140930891037,
-0.19328410923480988,
0.09793908894062042,
-0.26290297508239746,
0.6230827569961548,
0.20326794683933258,
-0.3469555377960205,
-0.03040226735174656,
-0.7027171850204468,
-0.13054858148097992,
0.29100674390792847,
0.03707136586308479,
-0.24994193017482758,
0.29725632071495056,
0.16457976400852203,
0.20923493802547455,
0.2412896603345871,
-0.4349431097507477,
0.027680298313498497,
-0.3493417203426361,
0.2914842665195465,
0.46954262256622314,
0.20813241600990295,
0.7617741823196411,
-0.36273378133773804,
0.3185984790325165,
0.11008961498737335,
-0.09082808345556259,
-0.2660713195800781,
-0.22579985857009888,
-0.7407113909721375,
0.08838934451341629,
0.3015308082103729,
0.5869686007499695,
-0.8351801037788391,
0.4023281931877136,
-0.49662286043167114,
-0.4714116156101227,
-0.5995379090309143,
-0.08924471586942673,
0.6650285124778748,
0.6452224254608154,
0.29701825976371765,
-0.19832974672317505,
-0.24948112666606903,
-0.7734636664390564,
-0.1535208821296692,
-0.022369811311364174,
-0.19366861879825592,
0.2970751225948334,
0.32715120911598206,
0.025312574580311775,
0.8353660702705383,
-0.601283609867096,
-0.34543341398239136,
0.07961641997098923,
0.2977865934371948,
-0.3876187801361084,
0.6082720160484314,
0.7938973903656006,
-0.7893364429473877,
-0.3835327923297882,
0.2588977515697479,
-0.6905844807624817,
-0.1880624145269394,
-0.3656400144100189,
-0.3603261411190033,
0.3434983193874359,
0.4846225082874298,
-0.5297476649284363,
0.26898786425590515,
0.4343230426311493,
-0.3605143427848816,
0.28992408514022827,
-0.3826897144317627,
0.1005459725856781,
-1.473400592803955,
0.2005583643913269,
0.4129562973976135,
-0.11074178665876389,
-0.7523854970932007,
0.1713298261165619,
0.4147464334964752,
-0.09858769178390503,
-0.12447633594274521,
0.44296684861183167,
-0.6668315529823303,
-0.18266527354717255,
-0.4759915769100189,
0.1840786635875702,
0.24354030191898346,
0.001654844731092453,
0.10017473250627518,
1.0626857280731201,
0.37359851598739624,
-0.6533147692680359,
0.0740714892745018,
0.5821452736854553,
-0.24551859498023987,
0.9608233571052551,
-0.6014138460159302,
0.27860331535339355,
-0.2808651924133301,
0.12413943558931351,
-1.2233823537826538,
-0.291079044342041,
0.18743537366390228,
-0.3690664768218994,
0.6689803600311279,
0.17504706978797913,
-0.4547513425350189,
-0.27566832304000854,
-0.16202129423618317,
0.8245206475257874,
0.45809194445610046,
-0.9103193283081055,
0.7306327223777771,
-0.0751151517033577,
0.03226258233189583,
-0.3467080593109131,
-0.647030770778656,
0.004796450491994619,
-0.3575299382209778,
-0.7761237621307373,
0.8230963349342346,
0.14341183006763458,
-0.008679911494255066,
-0.27500268816947937,
0.17685474455356598,
0.09381520003080368,
-0.18985232710838318,
-0.041240792721509933,
0.22381636500358582,
-0.2787906229496002,
0.2767674922943115,
0.4611932337284088,
-0.1169218122959137,
-0.06599343568086624,
-0.255138099193573,
0.29196879267692566,
0.6726779937744141,
-0.052085746079683304,
-0.4702915847301483,
0.472450315952301,
0.28142058849334717,
-0.6357521414756775,
0.3155938684940338,
0.5526964068412781,
-0.22495807707309723,
-0.12449304014444351,
-0.5938654541969299,
-0.033145833760499954,
-0.48427602648735046,
0.4194640517234802,
-0.5582785606384277,
-0.4471479058265686,
0.1792534589767456,
-0.31319114565849304,
0.21259868144989014,
0.6205373406410217,
0.5430060625076294,
-0.38070935010910034,
1.289149284362793,
0.7457314729690552,
0.2573468089103699,
0.49929818511009216,
-0.07208503037691116,
0.18053996562957764,
-0.8599741458892822,
-0.10844361037015915,
-0.6121054291725159,
-0.3649235665798187,
-0.695849597454071,
-0.273271769285202,
0.13079917430877686,
-0.17627958953380585,
-0.19901493191719055,
0.2676835060119629,
-0.7741813063621521,
0.40121492743492126,
0.27617257833480835,
0.34881219267845154,
0.08168473839759827,
0.22645370662212372,
0.4015432894229889,
-0.3474539816379547,
-0.4751897156238556,
-0.4646298289299011,
0.8288357853889465,
0.2619802951812744,
0.7011510729789734,
0.03180975094437599,
0.45422691106796265,
0.005340588744729757,
0.1323028951883316,
-0.5655643343925476,
0.3566337823867798,
-0.7982021570205688,
-0.4325758218765259,
-0.08508416265249252,
-0.1168363019824028,
-0.798263669013977,
-0.19152873754501343,
-0.21497225761413574,
-0.4017212390899658,
0.5419988036155701,
0.5206913948059082,
-0.19078151881694794,
0.09246626496315002,
-0.748785138130188,
0.9359883069992065,
-0.23982983827590942,
-0.4716576933860779,
-0.16518966853618622,
-0.5907784700393677,
0.27647414803504944,
-0.1722116470336914,
-0.16441300511360168,
0.2201356589794159,
-0.14730742573738098,
0.31007394194602966,
-0.14231766760349274,
0.8753753304481506,
-0.16322869062423706,
-0.689145028591156,
0.12142869085073471,
0.0076863085851073265,
0.4704861342906952,
-0.2951187491416931,
-0.17397333681583405,
-0.1786670982837677,
-0.28111013770103455,
-0.3615112900733948,
-0.7170379161834717,
0.4644460678100586,
-0.6601737141609192,
-0.46241915225982666,
0.15132567286491394,
-0.6338019967079163,
-0.0006162005593068898,
0.02984989993274212,
1.0324853658676147,
0.27784302830696106,
-0.3572308123111725,
-0.26555949449539185,
0.8162720203399658,
0.026237240061163902,
0.43210506439208984,
0.038120757788419724,
0.10245953500270844,
-0.40305662155151367,
1.1617300510406494,
-0.3481012284755707,
0.523743212223053,
0.6542059183120728,
-0.03795701637864113,
-0.44895508885383606,
-0.45564061403274536,
-0.7004691362380981,
0.33245643973350525,
-0.4718587398529053,
-0.41059428453445435,
-0.3304944336414337,
-0.01947355642914772,
-0.45818597078323364,
-0.3398175537586212,
-0.24445639550685883,
-0.32779237627983093,
-0.813416600227356,
0.09566444903612137,
0.2114742398262024,
0.5720885396003723,
0.11543895304203033,
0.5740301609039307,
-0.48834460973739624,
0.4315965473651886,
0.27524906396865845,
0.07801153510808945,
-0.15788722038269043,
-0.6310676336288452,
0.09507602453231812,
-0.058840181678533554,
-0.7764700055122375,
-0.8883147835731506,
0.16899091005325317,
0.6129108667373657,
-0.12374045699834824,
0.6970035433769226,
-0.009462852030992508,
0.8652807474136353,
-0.6084079146385193,
0.6653906106948853,
0.2927144169807434,
-0.7469491362571716,
0.894368052482605,
-0.4502353370189667,
0.29577571153640747,
0.3475147783756256,
0.02924131415784359,
-0.18060171604156494,
-0.5399700403213501,
-0.2746579945087433,
-0.4527965784072876,
0.6238734126091003,
0.17388767004013062,
0.21310627460479736,
-0.02775854617357254,
0.7334264516830444,
0.13056889176368713,
-0.09252524375915527,
-0.5144550204277039,
0.14727197587490082,
-0.4959080219268799,
-0.6607435941696167,
-0.1250396966934204,
-0.28196313977241516,
-0.13932204246520996,
0.07761748135089874,
0.5287574529647827,
-0.3433178961277008,
0.33519867062568665,
0.20742443203926086,
0.1115693673491478,
-0.48541826009750366,
0.05596578121185303,
0.6731440424919128,
0.3855399191379547,
0.22883464395999908,
-0.02834717556834221,
-0.07060062140226364,
-0.24124056100845337,
0.2927735447883606,
0.3050617575645447,
-0.49642056226730347,
-0.031206341460347176,
0.17750142514705658,
1.0107442140579224,
-0.13570265471935272,
-0.23391671478748322,
0.5895904898643494,
-0.06087857484817505,
-0.5493394136428833,
-0.08460717648267746,
0.16865672171115875,
-0.09781450033187866,
0.2884916067123413,
0.2948545515537262,
0.05258966237306595,
0.20122408866882324,
-0.09595796465873718,
0.01016821525990963,
0.589557945728302,
-0.313639372587204,
-0.2651171386241913,
0.9506694078445435,
0.28315040469169617,
-0.5298713445663452,
0.7274571061134338,
-0.08022657036781311,
-0.1548076570034027,
0.8247376084327698,
1.169631838798523,
0.8616505265235901,
-0.42828068137168884,
0.32066309452056885,
0.5532339215278625,
0.1395115852355957,
-0.08729639649391174,
0.17007917165756226,
-0.1142818033695221,
-0.8261561393737793,
-0.2546195685863495,
0.02498343028128147,
0.01935744285583496,
-0.11157078295946121,
-0.6889415383338928,
0.30930808186531067,
-0.17795208096504211,
-0.2879629135131836,
0.21301676332950592,
-0.2733120918273926,
-0.4850972592830658,
0.5716114044189453,
-0.014590529724955559,
0.8051651120185852,
-0.941519021987915,
0.4601883888244629,
0.8117899298667908,
-0.16051357984542847,
-0.6434493064880371,
0.4464694857597351,
-0.32972651720046997,
-0.640813946723938,
0.451210618019104,
0.405443012714386,
-0.030363386496901512,
0.44120946526527405,
-0.6533569693565369,
-0.44575342535972595,
1.27925705909729,
0.3694250285625458,
-0.7996918559074402,
-0.2874709367752075,
0.30663037300109863,
0.5523185133934021,
-0.4364704191684723,
0.12447530776262283,
0.5828973054885864,
0.25878608226776123,
0.09263083338737488,
-0.5885009765625,
0.2620169520378113,
-0.2328934669494629,
0.6526162028312683,
0.5558772087097168,
-0.7565345168113708,
0.24480797350406647,
-0.3715404272079468,
-0.49798762798309326,
0.4908791184425354,
0.8360369801521301,
0.31276562809944153,
0.44680899381637573,
0.5390186905860901,
0.8231871128082275,
0.4303303360939026,
-0.21432733535766602,
0.8732019662857056,
-0.3068406283855438,
0.1618022620677948,
0.9380600452423096,
-0.28403472900390625,
0.659148097038269,
0.6139278411865234,
0.27965298295021057,
0.3345301151275635,
0.6590794324874878,
-0.4321897327899933,
0.7832784056663513,
-0.10064244270324707,
-0.41892287135124207,
-0.23970285058021545,
-0.3673998713493347,
-0.17288608849048615,
0.29842430353164673,
0.3224901258945465,
-0.6637917757034302,
-0.20251256227493286,
0.022655455395579338,
-0.45505380630493164,
0.439395546913147,
-0.11377671360969543,
1.02054762840271,
-0.259587824344635,
-1.1102906465530396,
0.3716583251953125,
-0.04782193526625633,
0.5291545987129211,
-0.05206694453954697,
-0.1833430677652359,
-0.17282730340957642,
0.3076098561286926,
-0.2945955693721771,
-0.9551077485084534,
0.2413405328989029,
-0.11425042152404785,
-0.5174383521080017,
-0.1373286247253418,
0.8534461855888367,
-0.528070867061615,
-0.47505712509155273,
0.15517273545265198,
-0.029620110988616943,
-0.24839270114898682,
0.2863331735134125,
-0.4378909766674042,
0.0016903753858059645,
0.19344064593315125,
0.14608220756053925,
0.03672254830598831,
0.6611540913581848,
0.06343652307987213,
0.20367082953453064,
0.22628650069236755,
-0.2879517674446106,
-0.027235521003603935,
0.27419325709342957,
0.5354430079460144,
-0.42251428961753845,
-0.23297761380672455,
-0.732333779335022,
0.5660159587860107,
-0.15521077811717987,
-0.5565671324729919,
0.1613893210887909,
0.6539334654808044,
0.8098568320274353,
-0.33052995800971985,
0.6900755167007446,
0.055347274988889694,
0.2546496093273163,
-0.6281358003616333,
0.5591369271278381,
-0.6948774456977844,
-0.3186982274055481,
-0.1456475704908371,
-1.0087745189666748,
-0.16469460725784302,
0.5300957560539246,
-0.24930426478385925,
0.03757854923605919,
0.5016730427742004,
0.9639442563056946,
-0.25085338950157166,
-0.04242626577615738,
0.058793168514966965,
-0.08874908089637756,
0.3933662176132202,
0.4507501423358917,
0.6949428915977478,
-0.7911149263381958,
0.5951747298240662,
-0.12038277089595795,
-0.17479176819324493,
0.10732205957174301,
-0.9010709524154663,
-0.9236589670181274,
-0.7154483795166016,
-0.5276373624801636,
-0.22587214410305023,
0.20686142146587372,
0.14452753961086273,
0.6368709206581116,
-0.4693526327610016,
0.01604543998837471,
-0.6445314288139343,
-0.49066242575645447,
-0.139222651720047,
-0.2753785252571106,
0.34252187609672546,
-0.4601357579231262,
-0.8487481474876404,
-0.041504163295030594,
0.16156984865665436,
0.4681798815727234,
-0.02394946478307247,
0.030731458216905594,
0.17888036370277405,
-0.11399950087070465,
0.38288769125938416,
0.2746795117855072,
-0.6245917081832886,
-0.11527955532073975,
-0.0360124371945858,
-0.21884110569953918,
0.28269311785697937,
0.7727118730545044,
-0.35998600721359253,
0.4685966670513153,
0.20927780866622925,
0.6906310319900513,
0.555449903011322,
0.4569995403289795,
0.8083187937736511,
-1.0499424934387207,
-0.017314771190285683,
-0.11724395304918289,
-0.0894554927945137,
0.5821578502655029,
-0.6622943878173828,
0.31978747248649597,
-0.2545679211616516,
-0.7559921741485596,
-0.4975540339946747,
0.478519082069397,
-0.7933925986289978,
-0.0018462731968611479,
0.9250003695487976,
0.2625640332698822,
-0.09041129052639008,
0.29885557293891907,
-0.43786466121673584,
0.7361603379249573,
-0.16838787496089935,
0.9623562693595886,
0.4344255030155182,
0.1365591138601303,
-0.5191882252693176,
-0.12079408764839172,
0.42537787556648254,
0.7130672931671143,
-0.9903277158737183,
0.01874609850347042,
0.5768840909004211,
0.11918419599533081,
0.24470748007297516,
0.43704965710639954,
-0.0891951248049736,
0.5068535804748535,
-0.1040038913488388,
0.05286485329270363,
0.39381498098373413,
-0.15986867249011993,
-0.26762375235557556,
-0.24392913281917572,
0.021705225110054016,
-0.49958088994026184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04317v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04317v1
|
Online Adaptation of Language Models with a Memory of Amortized Contexts
| 2024-03-07T08:34:57 | 2024-03-07T08:34:57 |
Jihoon Tack, Jaehyung Kim, Eric Mitchell, Jinwoo Shin, Yee Whye Teh, Jonathan Richard Schwarz
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Due to the rapid generation and dissemination of information, large language
models (LLMs) quickly run out of date despite enormous development costs. Due
to this crucial need to keep models updated, online learning has emerged as a
critical necessity when utilizing LLMs for real-world applications. However,
given the ever-expanding corpus of unseen documents and the large parameter
space of modern LLMs, efficient adaptation is essential. To address these
challenges, we propose Memory of Amortized Contexts (MAC), an efficient and
effective online adaptation framework for LLMs with strong knowledge retention.
We propose an amortized feature extraction and memory-augmentation approach to
compress and extract information from new documents into compact modulations
stored in a memory bank. When answering questions, our model attends to and
extracts relevant knowledge from this memory bank. To learn informative
modulations in an efficient manner, we utilize amortization-based
meta-learning, which substitutes the optimization process with a single forward
pass of the encoder. Subsequently, we learn to choose from and aggregate
selected documents into a single modulation by conditioning on the question,
allowing us to adapt a frozen language model during test time without requiring
further gradient updates. Our experiment demonstrates the superiority of MAC in
multiple aspects, including online adaptation performance, time, and memory
efficiency. Code is available at: https://github.com/jihoontack/MAC.
|
[
-0.33525213599205017,
-1.0239441394805908,
0.515633225440979,
0.11882643401622772,
-0.14706526696681976,
0.12989561259746552,
-0.3538471758365631,
-0.5052109360694885,
0.3211826682090759,
0.631780207157135,
-0.11916030198335648,
-0.2773933708667755,
-0.4245278239250183,
-0.24126164615154266,
-0.16202539205551147,
1.1193265914916992,
-0.32636207342147827,
-0.21469616889953613,
-0.5588085651397705,
-0.2247922718524933,
0.1634947955608368,
-0.32381555438041687,
-0.5959585309028625,
-0.01576901786029339,
-0.029988298192620277,
0.2690865695476532,
0.24530373513698578,
0.6400302052497864,
0.516743540763855,
0.2617855966091156,
0.16682229936122894,
0.3376733958721161,
-0.4008113145828247,
0.16278208792209625,
0.07847602665424347,
-0.6140261888504028,
-0.6043825745582581,
-0.3632964491844177,
0.4239647388458252,
0.4844505786895752,
-0.483410507440567,
-0.022394463419914246,
-0.024849090725183487,
0.5857034921646118,
-0.9886255860328674,
0.229683980345726,
-0.9487923383712769,
-0.04966481029987335,
0.19308432936668396,
-0.4526050090789795,
-0.38307300209999084,
-0.3996720314025879,
0.20329773426055908,
-0.7746740579605103,
-0.07496147602796555,
0.015080911107361317,
0.7220774292945862,
0.3620317578315735,
-0.0927416980266571,
-0.42156732082366943,
-0.7436705231666565,
0.5399585962295532,
-0.48799872398376465,
0.36123645305633545,
0.8559346199035645,
0.18770985305309296,
0.21860599517822266,
-0.6263050436973572,
-0.03807599097490311,
-0.1634158045053482,
0.34008660912513733,
0.3803751468658447,
-0.16364991664886475,
0.09426502138376236,
-0.08777009695768356,
0.5098562836647034,
-0.23614224791526794,
-0.1673620194196701,
-0.2742481827735901,
-0.29196619987487793,
0.12902814149856567,
-0.04893803969025612,
0.33007729053497314,
0.20207469165325165,
-0.479910284280777,
0.024812856689095497,
-0.23631839454174042,
-0.04881634563207626,
0.1406855583190918,
-0.08984829485416412,
-0.28648641705513,
0.1423293650150299,
0.10155431926250458,
0.641994059085846,
0.12308371067047119,
-0.32356980443000793,
0.310345858335495,
0.22141627967357635,
-0.08720148354768753,
-0.002942011458799243,
0.4810623526573181,
0.29244229197502136,
0.21539005637168884,
-0.3422893285751343,
-0.3215932250022888,
-0.1083986684679985,
0.3252059519290924,
-0.7771819233894348,
-0.1464071124792099,
-0.02550170011818409,
-0.13395260274410248,
-0.08993294090032578,
-0.11203166097402573,
-0.5556192398071289,
-0.04609391465783119,
0.16613851487636566,
0.5838314890861511,
-0.7655120491981506,
-0.03662678971886635,
0.08483698964118958,
-0.1215699315071106,
-0.17909455299377441,
0.3506847023963928,
-1.1565004587173462,
0.6065391898155212,
0.3620626926422119,
1.0278798341751099,
-0.29567456245422363,
0.023995766416192055,
-0.459336519241333,
0.35273751616477966,
-0.1689283400774002,
0.5366957783699036,
-0.5497928261756897,
-0.12462321668863297,
-0.19316644966602325,
-0.25569769740104675,
-0.23109371960163116,
-0.6389155387878418,
0.1859406977891922,
-0.8148382902145386,
0.14765630662441254,
0.395691454410553,
-0.46794864535331726,
-0.207039937376976,
0.6351510882377625,
-0.7316779494285583,
1.1085563898086548,
0.42620065808296204,
-0.7539224028587341,
0.008333643898367882,
-0.7877830266952515,
-0.2965075671672821,
-0.24771064519882202,
0.25465643405914307,
-0.3675847053527832,
0.3546966016292572,
0.47581255435943604,
0.35203003883361816,
-0.14890635013580322,
0.3012056350708008,
-0.40282052755355835,
-0.07779733091592789,
0.3890259265899658,
-0.4116683900356293,
0.35153740644454956,
0.26764172315597534,
-0.07359737902879715,
-0.20236486196517944,
-0.916625440120697,
-0.2185191959142685,
0.014495398849248886,
-0.8826537728309631,
-0.6876205801963806,
0.19801369309425354,
-0.09046418219804764,
-0.07398510724306107,
0.293770432472229,
-0.49447232484817505,
0.09147300571203232,
-0.6472846865653992,
0.5375413298606873,
0.5965543389320374,
0.0983213558793068,
0.6828404068946838,
-0.40009185671806335,
0.5732483267784119,
0.3202696144580841,
0.010234746150672436,
-0.6905637383460999,
-0.09511346369981766,
-1.011963963508606,
-0.3124690055847168,
0.1768917739391327,
0.6552770137786865,
-0.9121289849281311,
0.019087644293904305,
-0.4071122109889984,
-0.13794268667697906,
-0.49601760506629944,
0.18933694064617157,
0.10877839475870132,
0.4905044138431549,
0.43070149421691895,
-0.5084168314933777,
-0.350167840719223,
-0.660865843296051,
-0.039639800786972046,
-0.2278199940919876,
0.008620485663414001,
0.8141928911209106,
0.27701300382614136,
-0.43289661407470703,
1.1489224433898926,
-0.37112608551979065,
-0.19609230756759644,
-0.13601958751678467,
0.21280339360237122,
-0.1558125615119934,
0.2509978413581848,
0.4293278157711029,
-0.6708982586860657,
-0.25741955637931824,
0.1425372064113617,
-0.4312296211719513,
-0.22801975905895233,
-0.3003535270690918,
0.07429640740156174,
0.28690096735954285,
0.6229633092880249,
-0.1547122597694397,
-0.2722876965999603,
0.8128005266189575,
0.03445351496338844,
0.03862987831234932,
-0.5448086261749268,
0.011552251875400543,
-1.3678853511810303,
-0.029338913038372993,
-0.16430705785751343,
-0.7391862869262695,
-0.4083916246891022,
0.06740908324718475,
0.4846199154853821,
-0.045755065977573395,
-0.6011180877685547,
0.6686633825302124,
-0.7491208910942078,
-0.1468762904405594,
-0.27093827724456787,
0.3435570299625397,
-0.030307959765195847,
0.5152369141578674,
0.00785848218947649,
0.6022105813026428,
0.7194880843162537,
-0.8355897068977356,
0.05212422087788582,
-0.09236964583396912,
-0.5043689608573914,
0.03874192759394646,
0.07431893050670624,
0.10678114742040634,
-0.45440858602523804,
0.28742727637290955,
-0.48619145154953003,
-0.22437967360019684,
0.18163904547691345,
-0.23284876346588135,
0.3240720331668854,
-0.12182825058698654,
-0.05584147945046425,
0.1511579006910324,
-0.2980637848377228,
0.3433375358581543,
0.3470066487789154,
-0.3975315988063812,
1.0481034517288208,
0.6685703992843628,
-0.13669052720069885,
-0.4058457911014557,
-0.8033679127693176,
-0.041598059237003326,
-0.2471100240945816,
-0.41518303751945496,
0.5725237131118774,
-0.014347814954817295,
-0.3034822642803192,
0.21384297311306,
-0.0626414492726326,
-0.32537078857421875,
0.5304253697395325,
0.14079894125461578,
0.2707838714122772,
-0.46938300132751465,
0.2880118489265442,
0.30787408351898193,
-0.04600956663489342,
-0.12827250361442566,
-0.46847519278526306,
0.5813711881637573,
-0.14302651584148407,
-0.1990056186914444,
0.11319257318973541,
0.10874787718057632,
0.8703417181968689,
-0.22395193576812744,
0.8693888783454895,
0.581881046295166,
-0.487785667181015,
-0.2565353512763977,
-0.591944694519043,
-0.07354792952537537,
-0.4380961060523987,
0.563128650188446,
-0.3294227719306946,
-1.2221802473068237,
0.64649897813797,
-0.472029447555542,
0.019504692405462265,
0.4021705985069275,
0.49664291739463806,
0.022509343922138214,
0.5979450345039368,
0.872586727142334,
-0.2516942322254181,
0.7518993616104126,
-0.08096744865179062,
-0.143101766705513,
-1.0992799997329712,
-0.0744868740439415,
-0.038489267230033875,
-0.09520713239908218,
-0.2042124718427658,
-0.7967129349708557,
0.41878044605255127,
0.4516502916812897,
0.06699852645397186,
0.2613654136657715,
0.04453565180301666,
0.5430631637573242,
-0.014151524752378464,
0.3565085530281067,
0.13139493763446808,
0.04441902041435242,
-0.30388325452804565,
0.20313341915607452,
-0.781565248966217,
-0.1504550725221634,
1.0358141660690308,
0.5836704969406128,
1.0822036266326904,
0.15930956602096558,
0.5383859872817993,
0.15364205837249756,
0.4603493809700012,
-0.7313215136528015,
0.16882067918777466,
0.041281890124082565,
-0.5746673345565796,
-0.1397182047367096,
-0.5263814926147461,
-0.6137283444404602,
0.2469233274459839,
-0.16425904631614685,
-1.01722252368927,
-0.028484787791967392,
0.23967039585113525,
-0.531561553478241,
0.36442631483078003,
-0.6619064807891846,
0.6453192830085754,
-0.6166638731956482,
-0.3806813955307007,
-0.2876155972480774,
-0.45029550790786743,
0.43682989478111267,
-0.5402806997299194,
0.5045145750045776,
-0.19035011529922485,
-0.35853102803230286,
0.6556575894355774,
-0.007170479744672775,
0.8724749684333801,
0.052196186035871506,
0.1732363998889923,
0.212392657995224,
0.19233438372612,
0.6954043507575989,
-0.058282434940338135,
-0.22695380449295044,
-0.06892859935760498,
-0.17566926777362823,
-0.07456283271312714,
-0.5990149974822998,
0.6289186477661133,
-0.6976873278617859,
-0.5239514112472534,
-0.16465449333190918,
-0.8467915654182434,
-0.40761175751686096,
-0.14766626060009003,
-0.05262107029557228,
0.5501688718795776,
-0.4288000166416168,
0.17741785943508148,
0.7908411026000977,
-0.5467069149017334,
0.7859522104263306,
0.5860354900360107,
-0.4294961392879486,
-0.43597838282585144,
0.9943380951881409,
-0.2124299705028534,
0.6983502507209778,
0.7991207838058472,
0.36765098571777344,
-0.18003125488758087,
-0.45767447352409363,
-0.6266936659812927,
0.09413480013608932,
-0.766872763633728,
0.0337989367544651,
-1.1176929473876953,
-0.11532852053642273,
-0.41634905338287354,
-0.3288590610027313,
-0.47597047686576843,
-0.5364963412284851,
-0.6826310157775879,
-0.0015885420143604279,
0.4558525085449219,
0.08170544356107712,
-0.013789935037493706,
0.24011436104774475,
-1.063661813735962,
0.2498844861984253,
0.1544547826051712,
0.19931767880916595,
-0.13169130682945251,
-0.7824790477752686,
-0.5489426851272583,
-0.16420817375183105,
-0.3445989191532135,
-0.7499620914459229,
0.6235290169715881,
0.8588674664497375,
0.5413984060287476,
0.7292801141738892,
0.16882440447807312,
0.7898093461990356,
-0.35327771306037903,
0.3830673396587372,
0.07512014359235764,
-0.9128047823905945,
0.38477420806884766,
-0.1623397022485733,
0.3744184970855713,
0.5868585109710693,
0.604271650314331,
-0.5695457458496094,
-0.5275273323059082,
-0.4894789457321167,
-1.0662040710449219,
0.8387423157691956,
-0.22111085057258606,
0.46245139837265015,
-0.11589325219392776,
0.3310631215572357,
0.07624556124210358,
0.019809124991297722,
-0.852546751499176,
-0.018947919830679893,
-0.01538134552538395,
-0.195469468832016,
0.027265137061476707,
-0.35016798973083496,
0.14138107001781464,
0.026252692565321922,
0.65023273229599,
-0.40759512782096863,
0.32384511828422546,
0.06426826119422913,
-0.733332097530365,
-0.054847948253154755,
0.3323989510536194,
0.6426860094070435,
0.6071337461471558,
-0.2734481394290924,
0.4408387541770935,
0.5524891018867493,
-0.4737389087677002,
-0.05187590792775154,
-0.23705646395683289,
-0.11742575466632843,
-0.2274605631828308,
0.14955393970012665,
1.2466026544570923,
0.7168729901313782,
-0.8141341805458069,
0.37367820739746094,
0.021461162716150284,
0.030823897570371628,
-0.2537403702735901,
0.16033434867858887,
0.22373518347740173,
0.17110800743103027,
0.274432897567749,
0.15522398054599762,
-0.12379835546016693,
-0.9339408278465271,
0.3312121331691742,
0.29191455245018005,
-0.6078210473060608,
-0.106989286839962,
0.5752829909324646,
0.19774675369262695,
-0.3281918466091156,
0.39626914262771606,
-0.016177263110876083,
-0.6728196740150452,
0.3157004415988922,
1.0096333026885986,
0.8197519779205322,
-0.2848692238330841,
0.20087796449661255,
0.3364102244377136,
0.18558062613010406,
-0.1880023181438446,
-0.13253556191921234,
-0.5333215594291687,
-1.0389683246612549,
-0.21224647760391235,
-1.0760892629623413,
-0.35149672627449036,
-0.05757511779665947,
-0.6320337057113647,
-0.037824247032403946,
-0.47487375140190125,
-0.02634485252201557,
-0.4625745713710785,
-0.5438914895057678,
0.014004489406943321,
0.18014803528785706,
0.1670488715171814,
0.8602290749549866,
-0.7658485174179077,
1.1143523454666138,
0.4579859673976898,
-0.025737829506397247,
-0.3414537310600281,
-0.009344985708594322,
-0.11951127648353577,
-0.918768048286438,
0.23189662396907806,
0.05685887113213539,
0.003633800894021988,
0.30249908566474915,
-0.06921720504760742,
-1.0726972818374634,
1.0192621946334839,
0.5542975068092346,
-0.5710309743881226,
0.15329010784626007,
-0.18538124859333038,
0.3415929079055786,
-0.5991033911705017,
0.5543127655982971,
0.3983844816684723,
0.15945272147655487,
0.06664098054170609,
-0.6815369725227356,
-0.29130882024765015,
-0.1879086196422577,
-0.1530260145664215,
0.46958133578300476,
-0.3621363639831543,
0.7694833278656006,
-0.16766542196273804,
-0.21377375721931458,
-0.3577757477760315,
0.48832210898399353,
0.03178178891539574,
0.04466327652335167,
0.4265434145927429,
0.7550813555717468,
0.7525057792663574,
0.05105751007795334,
1.058641791343689,
-0.5995792150497437,
0.35574573278427124,
0.9265781044960022,
-0.13468889892101288,
0.9981970191001892,
0.4944935739040375,
0.12001218646764755,
0.5765533447265625,
0.6043428778648376,
0.307026743888855,
0.6646116971969604,
0.08698492497205734,
-0.440219521522522,
-0.3805555999279022,
0.1399696171283722,
-0.11143651604652405,
0.3362977206707001,
0.5307544469833374,
-0.5317050218582153,
-0.30803224444389343,
0.44614309072494507,
-0.0750623568892479,
-0.224792942404747,
-0.3876270055770874,
0.9562278389930725,
0.16912588477134705,
-0.6072282195091248,
0.3877505958080292,
0.3844972848892212,
0.7099350690841675,
-0.637150764465332,
0.32321956753730774,
-0.19346864521503448,
0.3218534290790558,
0.030917370691895485,
-0.16720709204673767,
0.4983240067958832,
0.09507405757904053,
-0.24543961882591248,
-0.3924701511859894,
0.7589723467826843,
-0.5348482728004456,
-0.5778595805168152,
0.33223941922187805,
0.4935305714607239,
0.2667665183544159,
-0.10507173836231232,
-0.60699462890625,
0.03359844163060188,
-0.1320432871580124,
-0.38466691970825195,
0.6320667266845703,
0.20544710755348206,
-0.24432450532913208,
0.8767591118812561,
0.5745074152946472,
0.11207395792007446,
0.22596968710422516,
-0.1283666491508484,
0.812718391418457,
-0.471751868724823,
-0.6221734881401062,
-0.959909975528717,
0.39176246523857117,
0.2946828007698059,
-0.24983279407024384,
0.5843193531036377,
0.7839504480361938,
0.8054248094558716,
-0.004131886176764965,
0.6742626428604126,
0.07097529619932175,
0.1266232132911682,
-0.7933233976364136,
0.8072364926338196,
-0.6698941588401794,
0.28000688552856445,
-0.13680197298526764,
-0.9107263088226318,
-0.2515362501144409,
0.6610381007194519,
-0.30609214305877686,
-0.18248574435710907,
0.7789628505706787,
0.7939938902854919,
-0.40645119547843933,
-0.23983435332775116,
0.5821044445037842,
0.10797104984521866,
-0.06551636755466461,
0.7438758611679077,
0.6486278772354126,
-0.41389286518096924,
0.5076301097869873,
-0.07967579364776611,
-0.2929321229457855,
-0.3296520709991455,
-0.8802782893180847,
-0.6679553985595703,
-0.5938417911529541,
-0.4200395941734314,
0.015889780595898628,
-0.008949262090027332,
1.0108076333999634,
0.7256523966789246,
-0.5933600068092346,
-0.16783113777637482,
-0.10472384840250015,
0.03206143528223038,
-0.08230523020029068,
-0.1493745595216751,
0.18782071769237518,
-0.3118453919887543,
-0.6391938328742981,
0.6136107444763184,
0.7673370242118835,
0.0015653343871235847,
-0.14645949006080627,
-0.22852109372615814,
-0.14162161946296692,
0.35993173718452454,
0.5119187235832214,
0.2356531172990799,
-0.5167816281318665,
-0.14507809281349182,
-0.04163505136966705,
-0.17649880051612854,
0.41234132647514343,
0.8224198818206787,
-0.8357879519462585,
0.6791465878486633,
0.35129761695861816,
1.0515326261520386,
1.1074073314666748,
0.08410602062940598,
0.33667972683906555,
-0.408063679933548,
0.060662709176540375,
0.20216484367847443,
0.285402774810791,
0.3250133991241455,
-0.16688759624958038,
0.11847837269306183,
0.20177438855171204,
-0.2182498723268509,
-0.5308797955513,
-0.01895555481314659,
-0.9510564804077148,
-0.41132989525794983,
1.1240434646606445,
-0.417794406414032,
-0.5943668484687805,
-0.18866580724716187,
0.054633721709251404,
0.13647286593914032,
-0.26401299238204956,
0.9808750152587891,
0.6348112225532532,
0.017347082495689392,
-0.6099966764450073,
-0.41507962346076965,
0.1330353170633316,
0.1652451753616333,
-1.0896766185760498,
-0.055194828659296036,
0.39283910393714905,
0.3133575916290283,
0.0774298757314682,
0.7651014924049377,
-0.07319004088640213,
0.05313384532928467,
0.061334699392318726,
0.16040560603141785,
-0.24183852970600128,
-0.27023983001708984,
-0.41409337520599365,
0.42314809560775757,
-0.02368449606001377,
-0.17811952531337738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04314v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04314v1
|
Can Your Model Tell a Negation from an Implicature? Unravelling Challenges With Intent Encoders
| 2024-03-07T08:32:17 | 2024-03-07T08:32:17 |
Yuwei Zhang, Siffi Singh, Sailik Sengupta, Igor Shalyminov, Hang Su, Hwanjun Song, Saab Mansour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Conversational systems often rely on embedding models for intent
classification and intent clustering tasks. The advent of Large Language Models
(LLMs), which enable instructional embeddings allowing one to adjust semantics
over the embedding space using prompts, are being viewed as a panacea for these
downstream conversational tasks. However, traditional evaluation benchmarks
rely solely on task metrics that don't particularly measure gaps related to
semantic understanding. Thus, we propose an intent semantic toolkit that gives
a more holistic view of intent embedding models by considering three tasks --
(1) intent classification, (2) intent clustering, and (3) a novel triplet task.
The triplet task gauges the model's understanding of two semantic concepts
paramount in real-world conversational systems -- negation and implicature. We
observe that current embedding models fare poorly in semantic understanding of
these concepts. To address this, we propose a pre-training approach to improve
the embedding model by leveraging augmentation with data generated by an
auto-regressive model and a contrastive loss term. Our approach improves the
semantic understanding of the intent embedding model on the aforementioned
linguistic dimensions while slightly effecting their performance on downstream
task metrics.
|
[
-0.17911867797374725,
-0.8604593276977539,
0.7862093448638916,
-0.0886329934000969,
-0.11571889370679855,
-0.16334281861782074,
-0.09136641025543213,
-0.2128121256828308,
0.08079519867897034,
0.8069524168968201,
-0.6694236993789673,
-0.5098986625671387,
-0.6303620934486389,
-0.10805429518222809,
-0.4013488292694092,
0.913920521736145,
-0.15916144847869873,
0.10615216940641403,
-0.5556384921073914,
0.04461440443992615,
-1.1222546100616455,
-0.15518781542778015,
-0.4344157576560974,
-0.312161386013031,
0.11872945725917816,
0.820520281791687,
0.6085754036903381,
0.2649225890636444,
0.4714747667312622,
0.20419244468212128,
0.12732946872711182,
0.03220110386610031,
-0.4768204092979431,
0.2744186222553253,
-0.04587596654891968,
-0.5343635678291321,
-0.26559948921203613,
0.15687046945095062,
0.49308401346206665,
0.8591902852058411,
0.04130607098340988,
0.08566918969154358,
0.2513432800769806,
0.31385812163352966,
-0.6524398326873779,
0.09659572690725327,
-0.5865969657897949,
0.054634299129247665,
0.3242141604423523,
-0.1432744711637497,
-0.6025152206420898,
-0.3435034453868866,
0.5458883047103882,
-0.4918784499168396,
0.25368547439575195,
0.013927559368312359,
0.7380126118659973,
0.5854768753051758,
-0.3382161855697632,
-0.47238481044769287,
-0.666066586971283,
0.6548832058906555,
-0.8753769397735596,
0.4433577060699463,
0.4010480046272278,
0.12886428833007812,
-0.2715441882610321,
-0.5237940549850464,
-0.6462199687957764,
-0.5478427410125732,
-0.27747270464897156,
-0.1014745905995369,
0.044275425374507904,
0.20225265622138977,
0.13692009449005127,
0.3669883608818054,
-0.4869173765182495,
0.05403506010770798,
-0.1125139370560646,
-0.08209791779518127,
0.4570314586162567,
0.2880871295928955,
0.262416273355484,
0.09774606674909592,
-0.3610149621963501,
-0.0703594833612442,
-0.7470089793205261,
-0.16660691797733307,
0.4996306598186493,
0.1434636116027832,
-0.1837746948003769,
0.7640683650970459,
-0.047087736427783966,
0.7501041889190674,
0.30541545152664185,
0.16460448503494263,
0.2157224416732788,
-0.2587698996067047,
-0.3005625605583191,
0.3052724599838257,
0.4627991318702698,
0.16977542638778687,
-0.12323237955570221,
-0.17150579392910004,
0.11836850643157959,
0.18504659831523895,
0.5062956213951111,
-0.601131021976471,
-0.09319739788770676,
0.22790026664733887,
-0.31622934341430664,
-0.0890907272696495,
-0.13672024011611938,
-0.10136255621910095,
-0.27667251229286194,
-0.47833073139190674,
0.8023792505264282,
-0.648267924785614,
-0.046456947922706604,
0.41443172097206116,
-0.0385102778673172,
0.4117199182510376,
0.34335121512413025,
-0.7134003639221191,
0.4406426250934601,
0.8504484295845032,
0.6606188416481018,
0.1165180504322052,
-0.3261532783508301,
-0.3740607500076294,
0.2212962508201599,
-0.43288058042526245,
0.45537716150283813,
-0.9833977222442627,
-0.3216330111026764,
-0.14562349021434784,
0.0764717236161232,
-0.3179456889629364,
-0.24113260209560394,
0.36289510130882263,
-0.40196213126182556,
0.3307291269302368,
0.17671674489974976,
-0.936613917350769,
-0.842216968536377,
0.4905855357646942,
-0.45644891262054443,
0.7033241391181946,
0.051844146102666855,
-0.25114819407463074,
0.5060526728630066,
-0.8735828995704651,
-0.2899869978427887,
0.20985005795955658,
-0.1056678518652916,
-0.1773798018693924,
0.37687891721725464,
-0.03671630844473839,
0.5564124584197998,
-0.22071413695812225,
0.4291323125362396,
-0.32069122791290283,
-0.4139072895050049,
0.14144644141197205,
-0.5947777032852173,
0.2860252857208252,
-0.35890817642211914,
-0.34980714321136475,
0.15132386982440948,
-0.3746480941772461,
-0.24539552628993988,
-0.08584365248680115,
0.0012683620443567634,
-0.4225667715072632,
-0.0015934341354295611,
-0.6297765374183655,
0.17806699872016907,
0.2699286639690399,
-0.8750011920928955,
-0.07330412417650223,
-0.6085878610610962,
0.2556619942188263,
0.5766398310661316,
-0.04360194504261017,
0.5710214972496033,
-0.17851676046848297,
0.46756425499916077,
0.08029966801404953,
0.3255774974822998,
-0.3004624545574188,
-0.7275986075401306,
-0.9308685660362244,
0.0977233499288559,
-0.09481411427259445,
0.25848233699798584,
-0.4429713487625122,
0.4609443247318268,
-0.48326408863067627,
-0.43057799339294434,
-0.5613415241241455,
-0.0314265601336956,
0.5578620433807373,
0.5701198577880859,
0.4378550350666046,
-0.16796991229057312,
-0.07238133251667023,
-1.0570874214172363,
-0.42267513275146484,
-0.009094043634831905,
0.3252370059490204,
0.43161332607269287,
0.6225036978721619,
-0.1568584144115448,
0.892370343208313,
-0.5188744068145752,
-0.41371726989746094,
-0.2876555621623993,
0.20987002551555634,
0.2546021342277527,
0.6074435710906982,
0.10624822229146957,
-0.9363332390785217,
-0.5433023571968079,
-0.09971464425325394,
-0.557712197303772,
0.1341536045074463,
0.01836778037250042,
-0.04409319907426834,
-0.033606503158807755,
0.6950632929801941,
-0.32874488830566406,
0.8211832046508789,
0.3779069781303406,
-0.5109988451004028,
0.3382822871208191,
-0.33833375573158264,
0.05618930608034134,
-0.7434532642364502,
-0.4376227557659149,
-0.31581413745880127,
0.02668214589357376,
-0.7822083830833435,
-0.30020812153816223,
0.25599992275238037,
-0.06338082253932953,
-0.5414664149284363,
0.5225361585617065,
-0.3780336380004883,
0.06738074123859406,
-0.20677028596401215,
-0.02831875905394554,
0.2850077748298645,
0.39450180530548096,
0.14540836215019226,
0.45237430930137634,
0.3939434885978699,
-0.9311280846595764,
0.17684517800807953,
0.5088614225387573,
-0.2227380871772766,
0.4710899889469147,
-0.5394408702850342,
0.2253972440958023,
-0.27460500597953796,
0.2270333468914032,
-1.1458301544189453,
-0.33709096908569336,
0.4585334062576294,
-0.5133671760559082,
0.4420754015445709,
-0.3786585032939911,
-0.3165062665939331,
-0.2995013892650604,
-0.12803170084953308,
0.5210724472999573,
0.2188640981912613,
-0.49424949288368225,
0.7521191239356995,
0.27777767181396484,
-0.059771791100502014,
-0.5847557187080383,
-0.841570258140564,
0.09960111975669861,
-0.3021410405635834,
-0.5798056125640869,
0.6439971327781677,
-0.009109622798860073,
0.15040315687656403,
0.2795186936855316,
0.13615037500858307,
0.022476524114608765,
0.10058775544166565,
0.47293221950531006,
0.2881195545196533,
-0.19010338187217712,
0.4884873926639557,
0.03164074197411537,
-0.2968095541000366,
0.1264325976371765,
-0.5003833770751953,
0.5157162547111511,
-0.04997522383928299,
-0.8662430047988892,
-0.49720531702041626,
0.30396199226379395,
0.4594214856624603,
-0.15405453741550446,
0.7948853969573975,
0.40805697441101074,
-0.21065211296081543,
-0.13814102113246918,
-0.7489814758300781,
-0.4044044315814972,
-0.4096145033836365,
0.16748034954071045,
-0.35226479172706604,
-1.005563735961914,
0.20883981883525848,
0.13453538715839386,
0.15411843359470367,
0.1473608762025833,
0.23293256759643555,
0.1865098774433136,
1.1331896781921387,
0.6956395506858826,
0.4456832706928253,
0.3882831335067749,
-0.32923781871795654,
0.702180027961731,
-1.0854148864746094,
-0.432172030210495,
-0.21045565605163574,
-0.29431238770484924,
-0.4372333288192749,
-0.48123061656951904,
0.4214972257614136,
-0.33270925283432007,
-0.21135790646076202,
0.3681391775608063,
-0.5568748116493225,
0.358076274394989,
0.42291709780693054,
0.1674463301897049,
0.043748266994953156,
-0.2697025537490845,
0.10663831233978271,
-0.052259381860494614,
-0.6709789037704468,
-0.6940911412239075,
1.21766996383667,
0.3024762272834778,
0.7795866131782532,
0.24638274312019348,
0.7489780783653259,
-0.007165036164224148,
0.3142857253551483,
-0.9743860960006714,
0.5733030438423157,
-0.1533339023590088,
-0.5935176610946655,
-0.28863316774368286,
-0.1438901424407959,
-0.6824591755867004,
0.4237897992134094,
0.06795238703489304,
-0.6746030449867249,
0.44759783148765564,
0.2320028692483902,
-0.41160547733306885,
0.21249300241470337,
-1.0556073188781738,
1.1430751085281372,
-0.18998560309410095,
-0.4544815421104431,
-0.3134930431842804,
-0.39459413290023804,
0.3606308698654175,
0.165423184633255,
0.04315550997853279,
-0.41304677724838257,
-0.2340436726808548,
0.646045446395874,
-0.3996196389198303,
1.00037682056427,
-0.29731085896492004,
-0.13424867391586304,
0.27315622568130493,
0.224470317363739,
0.5176246166229248,
-0.1328936517238617,
-0.08205793052911758,
-0.176783487200737,
-0.2897511124610901,
-0.15675882995128632,
-0.8139255046844482,
0.7182624340057373,
-0.23992379009723663,
-0.6869075298309326,
-0.10037313401699066,
-0.5744128823280334,
-0.3286607265472412,
-0.009301762096583843,
0.11694971472024918,
0.7352198362350464,
-0.3208015263080597,
0.25361502170562744,
0.6872131824493408,
-0.3241594135761261,
0.3658648133277893,
0.6164155006408691,
0.16098898649215698,
0.18542732298374176,
0.8609566688537598,
0.002942076651379466,
0.5063818693161011,
0.3661883771419525,
0.27099668979644775,
-0.5305942296981812,
-0.6485981941223145,
-0.2501596212387085,
0.17265698313713074,
-0.9005825519561768,
-0.02408984676003456,
-0.8954360485076904,
0.014743576757609844,
-0.5317513942718506,
-0.2890849709510803,
-0.24914343655109406,
-0.12243755906820297,
-0.34109508991241455,
-0.10016705095767975,
0.42594200372695923,
1.0529305934906006,
0.022301245480775833,
0.5740234851837158,
-0.7127684354782104,
0.15813839435577393,
0.16990596055984497,
0.32224127650260925,
-0.006568021606653929,
-0.7983745336532593,
-0.18496528267860413,
0.18940626084804535,
-0.07680371403694153,
-0.850185215473175,
0.5297987461090088,
0.24316279590129852,
0.6389212012290955,
0.3285226821899414,
0.021041912958025932,
0.6927198767662048,
-0.41643962264060974,
0.7452748417854309,
0.04613471403717995,
-0.8824253678321838,
0.7156385779380798,
-0.012730579823255539,
0.20136159658432007,
0.7333059310913086,
0.42674344778060913,
-0.410849004983902,
-0.34978699684143066,
-0.7858833074569702,
-0.903654932975769,
1.0445637702941895,
-0.03835287317633629,
0.5052608847618103,
-0.18163734674453735,
0.16662517189979553,
0.3612610399723053,
0.21589069068431854,
-0.6692604422569275,
-0.025783661752939224,
-0.08749397099018097,
-0.33280032873153687,
-0.09933124482631683,
-0.4877408444881439,
0.10907436162233353,
-0.18449606001377106,
0.824005126953125,
-0.06520632654428482,
0.15712088346481323,
0.20295003056526184,
-0.5405671000480652,
0.440457820892334,
0.20630967617034912,
0.24410420656204224,
0.1919916421175003,
-0.1874104142189026,
0.0086126197129488,
0.16507737338542938,
-0.5353825092315674,
0.22991283237934113,
0.003987550735473633,
-0.12069912999868393,
-0.016984866932034492,
0.3105652332305908,
0.936133086681366,
0.6825780868530273,
-0.41685307025909424,
0.8438277244567871,
-0.20768232643604279,
-0.02777862176299095,
-0.4040646255016327,
0.13076280057430267,
-0.14413073658943176,
-0.2221965193748474,
-0.07166948914527893,
-0.1786935180425644,
0.3941025733947754,
-0.35905319452285767,
0.02268134616315365,
0.4319416284561157,
-0.9452331066131592,
-0.0799197256565094,
0.14854086935520172,
0.1603727638721466,
-0.12926344573497772,
0.37560927867889404,
-0.4103506803512573,
-0.5452865362167358,
0.6873335838317871,
0.554546058177948,
1.1309000253677368,
-0.37722256779670715,
0.31400731205940247,
0.315950870513916,
0.3560115098953247,
0.14108818769454956,
0.19665929675102234,
-0.25455769896507263,
-0.7339538335800171,
-0.42265236377716064,
-0.39201968908309937,
-0.4120050370693207,
0.0524454191327095,
-0.45661652088165283,
0.3058452606201172,
-0.13329480588436127,
0.106008380651474,
0.11520508676767349,
-0.4372018873691559,
-0.8173415660858154,
0.07286466658115387,
0.04599017649888992,
0.5098792910575867,
-0.6982067823410034,
0.3888954818248749,
0.7364867925643921,
-0.2932821810245514,
-0.7753996253013611,
-0.005709695164114237,
-0.05133291706442833,
-0.6625534296035767,
0.7486432194709778,
0.5186729431152344,
-0.37999799847602844,
0.16346149146556854,
-0.5446680784225464,
-1.013672113418579,
0.7703856229782104,
0.18299449980258942,
-0.29796889424324036,
0.04177732765674591,
0.0739503800868988,
0.06612326204776764,
-0.7925596833229065,
0.536319375038147,
0.570800244808197,
0.46244320273399353,
0.001968824304640293,
-0.7398486137390137,
0.07800093293190002,
-0.02263477072119713,
-0.2467900961637497,
0.21897728741168976,
-0.059335868805646896,
0.8373280167579651,
-0.23202623426914215,
-0.3549391031265259,
-0.23048530519008636,
0.2978724241256714,
-0.26501238346099854,
0.14954420924186707,
0.4624755084514618,
0.6100070476531982,
0.4433116018772125,
-0.054835379123687744,
1.0807029008865356,
-0.23832209408283234,
-0.010926272720098495,
1.5080270767211914,
-0.3563511073589325,
0.6053265929222107,
0.3727934956550598,
0.16938447952270508,
0.6795523166656494,
0.38132020831108093,
0.2985962927341461,
0.4411785304546356,
-0.014547869563102722,
-0.37212514877319336,
-0.2839113473892212,
-0.38854968547821045,
-0.233047217130661,
0.6540181040763855,
1.0856069326400757,
-0.3755927085876465,
-0.3887019157409668,
0.34199583530426025,
-0.1277724802494049,
-0.03404141217470169,
-0.1313585340976715,
1.0921813249588013,
0.0030701293144375086,
-0.8140532970428467,
0.32449549436569214,
-0.34624141454696655,
0.5586731433868408,
-0.6510298252105713,
-0.36876460909843445,
0.21735960245132446,
0.3160803020000458,
-0.18605530261993408,
-0.9347484111785889,
0.34568852186203003,
-0.303072452545166,
0.007168594282120466,
-0.1999051570892334,
0.732330322265625,
-0.5218029022216797,
-0.24300988018512726,
0.51789391040802,
0.26353946328163147,
0.30299079418182373,
-0.12271235883235931,
-0.5445066094398499,
-0.17674849927425385,
-0.09430933743715286,
0.0633377879858017,
-0.10858337581157684,
0.29567351937294006,
-0.03342755511403084,
0.6918742656707764,
0.7435805797576904,
-0.24954168498516083,
0.10785821080207825,
0.22647550702095032,
0.696018636226654,
-0.5511434078216553,
-0.6781360507011414,
-0.8910007476806641,
0.3634651005268097,
-0.10450290143489838,
-0.23888619244098663,
0.8478105068206787,
0.4783075749874115,
0.8008266091346741,
0.09062746167182922,
0.7553629279136658,
-0.025713978335261345,
0.5441810488700867,
-0.43174469470977783,
0.26260289549827576,
-0.4667149782180786,
0.25538909435272217,
-0.08425216376781464,
-0.732944905757904,
-0.12235154211521149,
0.3907538950443268,
-0.9274356365203857,
-0.0437215119600296,
0.5923389196395874,
0.9432446360588074,
-0.1987278163433075,
0.3466043770313263,
0.37218472361564636,
0.17463603615760803,
0.22632330656051636,
0.6785091161727905,
1.3021968603134155,
-0.3681243658065796,
0.3308241665363312,
-0.28614023327827454,
-0.19587817788124084,
-0.5920794606208801,
-0.8510012030601501,
-0.6421542763710022,
-0.5927882790565491,
-0.30147430300712585,
-0.1475343108177185,
-0.034781962633132935,
0.7089609503746033,
0.7981675267219543,
-0.620244026184082,
-0.05339519679546356,
-0.4376235902309418,
0.371911883354187,
0.08532155305147171,
-0.23100975155830383,
0.13389034569263458,
-0.6112294793128967,
-0.5818720459938049,
0.6371028423309326,
0.409708708524704,
0.33106982707977295,
-0.24953100085258484,
-0.052272431552410126,
-0.2902876138687134,
-0.0007767279748804867,
0.5250042676925659,
-0.08661279827356339,
-0.7832176685333252,
-0.4201377034187317,
-0.0703025683760643,
0.16378426551818848,
-0.07723961770534515,
0.8391707539558411,
-0.9084953665733337,
0.6098299622535706,
0.4103684425354004,
0.519200325012207,
0.515835702419281,
-0.142331063747406,
0.7942091822624207,
-0.43523311614990234,
0.09835876524448395,
0.5828925371170044,
0.19497936964035034,
0.580546498298645,
-0.49873030185699463,
0.4320618808269501,
-0.23163768649101257,
-0.281147837638855,
-0.672903299331665,
0.4245450496673584,
-0.4769704043865204,
-0.34379616379737854,
0.9510049819946289,
-0.1499483585357666,
-0.35198885202407837,
-0.6706007719039917,
-0.04717230796813965,
0.1349942982196808,
-0.28254708647727966,
0.1500052660703659,
0.6547948122024536,
-0.32031968235969543,
0.1847030371427536,
-0.6996614336967468,
0.4732110798358917,
0.6873936653137207,
-0.39956003427505493,
0.08580434322357178,
0.5324490070343018,
0.08208297938108444,
0.2211201936006546,
0.4482609033584595,
-0.1985195279121399,
0.2908320426940918,
0.08549121767282486,
0.01814744621515274,
-0.11803866922855377,
-0.4164438545703888,
-0.45541635155677795,
-0.1534288227558136,
-0.13292382657527924,
-0.541918933391571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04311v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04311v1
|
ALTO: An Efficient Network Orchestrator for Compound AI Systems
| 2024-03-07T08:30:26 | 2024-03-07T08:30:26 |
Keshav Santhanam, Deepti Raghavan, Muhammad Shahir Rahman, Thejas Venkatesh, Neha Kunjal, Pratiksha Thaker, Philip Levis, Matei Zaharia
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DC, cs.IR
|
We present ALTO, a network orchestrator for efficiently serving compound AI
systems such as pipelines of language models. ALTO achieves high throughput and
low latency by taking advantage of an optimization opportunity specific to
generative language models: streaming intermediate outputs. As language models
produce outputs token by token, ALTO exposes opportunities to stream
intermediate outputs between stages when possible. We highlight two new
challenges of correctness and load balancing which emerge when streaming
intermediate data across distributed pipeline stage instances. We also motivate
the need for an aggregation-aware routing interface and distributed
prompt-aware scheduling to address these challenges. We demonstrate the impact
of ALTO's partial output streaming on a complex chatbot verification pipeline,
increasing throughput by up to 3x for a fixed latency target of 4 seconds /
request while also reducing tail latency by 1.8x compared to a baseline serving
approach.
|
[
-0.4445849061012268,
-0.8136473894119263,
0.17221832275390625,
0.3522774875164032,
0.09348264336585999,
0.2385551780462265,
0.17737886309623718,
-0.34277644753456116,
0.33060580492019653,
0.6341726183891296,
-0.6359204053878784,
-0.010205371305346489,
-0.5731094479560852,
0.15673436224460602,
-0.9867011904716492,
1.0526140928268433,
0.41054201126098633,
-0.13621129095554352,
-0.09691313654184341,
0.1322663128376007,
-0.3911783695220947,
-0.27300190925598145,
-1.8712080717086792,
-0.4824073314666748,
0.636221706867218,
0.4991072714328766,
0.6488057374954224,
0.9265559315681458,
0.6829612851142883,
0.5204021334648132,
0.19101713597774506,
0.29210135340690613,
-0.6093335151672363,
0.4826744496822357,
0.007163320202380419,
-0.46535807847976685,
-0.6703681945800781,
-0.5690906047821045,
0.6958447694778442,
0.8503981828689575,
-0.39284396171569824,
-0.0013305970933288336,
-0.18699268996715546,
0.8475799560546875,
-0.46307384967803955,
0.32972878217697144,
-0.6931349039077759,
-0.1561179906129837,
-0.6105893850326538,
0.26273366808891296,
-0.3582688570022583,
0.08743305504322052,
-0.04470531642436981,
-0.8459185361862183,
-0.09204459935426712,
0.504224419593811,
0.7066046595573425,
0.5396971702575684,
-0.21530884504318237,
-0.23831261694431305,
-0.9842578172683716,
0.48335686326026917,
-0.44277605414390564,
0.06203155592083931,
0.12175172567367554,
0.901103675365448,
-0.032681655138731,
-1.2615066766738892,
-0.9461279511451721,
0.05902676656842232,
-0.042578671127557755,
0.13616548478603363,
-0.41199541091918945,
0.34706056118011475,
0.00907306931912899,
0.5944505333900452,
-0.39968734979629517,
0.2723991274833679,
-0.3283708691596985,
-0.14052653312683105,
0.5507107377052307,
0.3349638879299164,
0.41810503602027893,
0.18457619845867157,
-0.037470974028110504,
0.060549475252628326,
-0.7078341245651245,
0.05214601755142212,
0.76692134141922,
0.28618913888931274,
-0.10298124700784683,
0.5662420988082886,
-0.44268935918807983,
0.6747759580612183,
0.016484515741467476,
0.6240348815917969,
0.047409940510988235,
-0.33888646960258484,
-0.11177283525466919,
0.16669613122940063,
0.6625489592552185,
-0.0698484405875206,
-0.25048235058784485,
0.059565603733062744,
-0.49825578927993774,
0.09487050026655197,
0.3929845988750458,
-0.5597034096717834,
-0.3805605471134186,
0.4593799114227295,
-0.1969345360994339,
-0.13177667558193207,
-0.0916028842329979,
-0.6525242328643799,
-0.20745588839054108,
-0.21036583185195923,
0.3443260192871094,
-0.3242585361003876,
-0.025732381269335747,
-0.32395225763320923,
-0.37457525730133057,
-0.10609819740056992,
0.5028188824653625,
-0.9459302425384521,
1.1505646705627441,
1.2312501668930054,
1.0601879358291626,
-0.16874776780605316,
-0.18605735898017883,
-1.40666663646698,
0.2721046209335327,
-0.44527241587638855,
0.6999738216400146,
-0.313484251499176,
-0.11399148404598236,
-0.0735139474272728,
-0.22598345577716827,
-0.08092472702264786,
-0.3662755489349365,
0.8142738938331604,
-0.7429598569869995,
-0.09526143968105316,
0.30076006054878235,
-0.6855592131614685,
-0.039851345121860504,
-0.022824451327323914,
-0.6701049208641052,
0.587655782699585,
0.05716128647327423,
-0.35763493180274963,
-0.18934699892997742,
-0.978844404220581,
-0.5125218629837036,
0.3241584300994873,
-0.10258007049560547,
-0.007142245303839445,
-0.20749440789222717,
0.3477208614349365,
0.2031729817390442,
-0.3049902617931366,
0.06146487221121788,
-0.018023589625954628,
-0.5350974798202515,
-0.07598330080509186,
-0.6511892676353455,
0.6149730682373047,
0.3939591646194458,
-0.052823107689619064,
0.2764199376106262,
-0.8576071262359619,
-0.2839750647544861,
-0.24831219017505646,
-0.13234341144561768,
-0.09779543429613113,
0.4904487133026123,
-0.0059011210687458515,
-0.2976852357387543,
0.03125931695103645,
-0.538261890411377,
0.12629316747188568,
-0.6338018774986267,
0.5607770681381226,
1.1441305875778198,
-0.35677406191825867,
0.4356403052806854,
-0.48231810331344604,
0.6269305348396301,
-0.06940373033285141,
0.1948205679655075,
-0.6073420643806458,
-0.48259782791137695,
-1.1382538080215454,
-0.6262639760971069,
0.1879824846982956,
0.5375681519508362,
-1.1089168787002563,
0.3801775872707367,
-0.3525412678718567,
-0.5411746501922607,
-0.849097728729248,
0.1374633014202118,
0.4642098546028137,
0.8539696335792542,
-0.019324133172631264,
-0.282038152217865,
-0.4053868353366852,
-1.1007248163223267,
0.3177765905857086,
-0.15485282242298126,
-0.13847783207893372,
0.38896259665489197,
0.18532751500606537,
-0.21310240030288696,
0.6479334235191345,
-0.4035082459449768,
-0.227144256234169,
-0.21622318029403687,
0.5072734355926514,
0.5403228998184204,
0.4693405032157898,
0.4991298019886017,
-0.8125457763671875,
-0.6835712790489197,
0.4052985608577728,
-0.36911457777023315,
-0.4095957577228546,
0.008353120647370815,
-0.07382458448410034,
0.1827486902475357,
0.1562952697277069,
-0.5494242310523987,
-0.03284209966659546,
1.0353343486785889,
-0.024788836017251015,
0.3304995894432068,
-0.20630842447280884,
0.2022102028131485,
-0.7405937314033508,
-0.2034725546836853,
-0.4301866292953491,
-0.33737510442733765,
-0.7157257199287415,
-0.12586909532546997,
-0.633389413356781,
-0.4548080861568451,
-0.5379251837730408,
0.5877600312232971,
-0.08506947755813599,
-0.4201914668083191,
-0.32856619358062744,
0.01910679042339325,
-0.019187936559319496,
0.516689121723175,
-0.3048924505710602,
1.0286470651626587,
1.0727672576904297,
-0.8654807806015015,
0.8249885439872742,
0.01755145564675331,
0.038682229816913605,
0.7842263579368591,
-1.144110083580017,
0.21297597885131836,
-0.009822187013924122,
0.5565754771232605,
-0.9222683310508728,
-0.36663609743118286,
0.4939136803150177,
-0.4628410041332245,
0.14505377411842346,
-0.2970389723777771,
-0.4432951807975769,
-0.18100407719612122,
0.0786447748541832,
0.3404836654663086,
0.5176697373390198,
-0.4612477719783783,
0.8186016082763672,
0.3247828483581543,
-0.13826699554920197,
-0.42989790439605713,
-0.48794278502464294,
0.13154928386211395,
-0.11359809339046478,
-1.1021912097930908,
0.4583078622817993,
0.10256224870681763,
-0.2816663980484009,
0.22681306302547455,
0.049193862825632095,
-0.3029088079929352,
0.16410741209983826,
0.4456014931201935,
-0.020085155963897705,
-0.15373821556568146,
-0.1525777280330658,
0.34267717599868774,
-0.22404949367046356,
-0.040432680398225784,
-0.46451953053474426,
0.7106918096542358,
-0.16145238280296326,
-0.7397187352180481,
-0.8938927054405212,
0.739401638507843,
0.6569788455963135,
-0.04064364358782768,
0.7815591096878052,
0.5797492861747742,
-0.20760135352611542,
-0.35358163714408875,
-0.19155243039131165,
-0.25726035237312317,
-0.567753791809082,
0.060140885412693024,
-0.4461685121059418,
-0.6128662824630737,
0.8174629807472229,
0.021205158904194832,
0.17579975724220276,
0.5304872393608093,
0.27517077326774597,
-0.5018013119697571,
1.1075397729873657,
0.1239900067448616,
0.06702825427055359,
0.6437697410583496,
-0.4647553563117981,
0.24928782880306244,
-0.8455584049224854,
0.1485685408115387,
-0.729580819606781,
-0.41709110140800476,
-0.5336340665817261,
-0.2786432206630707,
0.6997488737106323,
-0.20463000237941742,
-0.4874243140220642,
0.06927666068077087,
-0.1416601836681366,
0.21747943758964539,
0.9717488288879395,
-0.2673676609992981,
0.3444165587425232,
-0.2834304869174957,
0.46168747544288635,
0.5129449963569641,
-0.9286046624183655,
-0.4429265856742859,
0.8464343547821045,
0.12584485113620758,
0.31074365973472595,
0.32879284024238586,
0.5147336721420288,
0.8376043438911438,
0.13989034295082092,
-0.40643608570098877,
0.481902539730072,
-0.3574955463409424,
-0.5730433464050293,
-0.5586263537406921,
-0.5018579959869385,
-0.964637279510498,
0.2315824031829834,
0.07861373573541641,
-0.6942681670188904,
-0.17763958871364594,
0.26768389344215393,
-0.24284853041172028,
0.08887536078691483,
-0.7749337553977966,
0.5899859070777893,
-0.07212953269481659,
-0.18293917179107666,
-0.5313369631767273,
-0.7413811683654785,
0.3939756155014038,
0.0474272184073925,
0.18675597012043,
0.023346733301877975,
0.052241142839193344,
0.5018229484558105,
-0.9566666483879089,
0.6671213507652283,
-0.01558519247919321,
0.4454973042011261,
0.3679926097393036,
0.06059396266937256,
0.7452958822250366,
0.11005086451768875,
-0.15997959673404694,
0.2783799171447754,
-0.2754276394844055,
-0.48101699352264404,
-0.956281304359436,
0.7043154239654541,
-1.0396392345428467,
-0.8011541366577148,
-0.4638238549232483,
-0.229749858379364,
0.2492409348487854,
0.07521151751279831,
-0.2189800888299942,
0.4545537531375885,
0.1327604055404663,
0.4576230049133301,
0.29721418023109436,
0.12805067002773285,
0.6642647385597229,
0.09382122755050659,
-0.017322957515716553,
-0.25210899114608765,
0.9335231781005859,
-0.03870021551847458,
0.42222267389297485,
0.49733588099479675,
0.004647450055927038,
-0.05281945690512657,
-0.6078739762306213,
-0.7221308946609497,
-0.23771332204341888,
-0.32641783356666565,
0.027288254350423813,
-0.7504895925521851,
-0.47094371914863586,
-0.2881520092487335,
-0.22743497788906097,
-0.7362124919891357,
-0.5697733163833618,
-0.29631415009498596,
0.07469017803668976,
0.2665235102176666,
0.42296090722084045,
-0.2735355794429779,
1.084386944770813,
-0.8093291521072388,
0.2274063378572464,
0.48541539907455444,
0.1898515373468399,
0.12041649222373962,
-0.28864333033561707,
-0.1751813441514969,
-0.0287249106913805,
-0.3388245701789856,
-0.5290689468383789,
0.22497119009494781,
0.40805327892303467,
0.6099535226821899,
0.8076858520507812,
-0.07501916587352753,
0.6618155837059021,
-0.6717327833175659,
0.9384308457374573,
0.06393322348594666,
-1.304885745048523,
0.4586418569087982,
-0.5344050526618958,
-0.1946234107017517,
0.26036450266838074,
0.07854242622852325,
-0.7567245364189148,
-0.3880942761898041,
-0.4780403673648834,
-1.0399531126022339,
1.0775558948516846,
0.7671812176704407,
0.28915664553642273,
-0.0304566603153944,
0.04351094737648964,
0.015762362629175186,
0.45274293422698975,
-0.2829650342464447,
-0.3617362678050995,
-0.23159831762313843,
0.016398658975958824,
-0.1414642632007599,
0.2831058204174042,
-0.28266215324401855,
-0.0003760388062801212,
0.7265164256095886,
-0.12847523391246796,
0.026949910447001457,
0.030680827796459198,
0.3832497298717499,
0.15397153794765472,
-0.12067016959190369,
0.3208658695220947,
0.5125146508216858,
-0.02535143867135048,
-0.01368642132729292,
-0.2282400280237198,
0.004706025123596191,
0.055005379021167755,
0.22216634452342987,
-0.41171249747276306,
-0.041332948952913284,
0.47776392102241516,
1.1570185422897339,
-0.17466013133525848,
-0.8195372819900513,
0.3251023590564728,
-0.03044256381690502,
0.29837140440940857,
-0.41482165455818176,
0.5117037296295166,
-0.0008842229726724327,
0.25828540325164795,
0.3831440508365631,
0.22503143548965454,
0.46171823143959045,
-0.69473797082901,
0.03012646548449993,
0.18705585598945618,
-0.0976051613688469,
-0.25447818636894226,
0.7095113396644592,
0.7025853395462036,
-0.8377799391746521,
1.0832573175430298,
-0.2349807471036911,
-0.3188416063785553,
0.9283995628356934,
0.24781863391399384,
0.91061931848526,
-0.005327791906893253,
0.2526507079601288,
-0.1937534362077713,
-0.002909476403146982,
0.13545633852481842,
-0.11079175025224686,
-0.27814123034477234,
-0.776434063911438,
-0.3954431712627411,
-0.45946794748306274,
-0.622489869594574,
-0.48013120889663696,
-0.2848342955112457,
0.2078137993812561,
-0.16618137061595917,
-0.06567136198282242,
0.05728285387158394,
-0.16023634374141693,
-0.5653691291809082,
-0.0407261997461319,
-0.013107756152749062,
0.6101152896881104,
-0.872195839881897,
0.729946494102478,
0.5661933422088623,
-0.3449691832065582,
-0.5182108283042908,
-0.44595959782600403,
0.051122575998306274,
-0.6707205176353455,
0.8310719728469849,
-0.31289589405059814,
-0.44552066922187805,
0.053299155086278915,
-0.24275922775268555,
-0.8432030081748962,
1.11521577835083,
0.18615052103996277,
-0.602687656879425,
0.010675329715013504,
-0.12254466116428375,
0.6828523874282837,
-0.7005614638328552,
0.6852324604988098,
0.09077123552560806,
0.4611142873764038,
0.7941473722457886,
-0.6853390336036682,
-0.5255318284034729,
-0.25637704133987427,
0.13193213939666748,
0.11945317685604095,
-0.797944188117981,
1.0189976692199707,
0.3445033133029938,
-0.20128266513347626,
-0.15128111839294434,
1.0154532194137573,
0.28304266929626465,
0.7526368498802185,
0.7083315253257751,
0.4688374698162079,
0.8560802340507507,
-0.18051330745220184,
1.1580746173858643,
-0.15119223296642303,
-0.24124574661254883,
1.2829551696777344,
-0.4373154938220978,
0.5855061411857605,
0.7030309438705444,
-0.11246680468320847,
0.4496857225894928,
0.6570430397987366,
0.3479062616825104,
0.606846272945404,
0.5320236086845398,
-0.24493594467639923,
0.23521284759044647,
-0.4482833743095398,
-0.04368254169821739,
0.5354649424552917,
0.44481900334358215,
0.04872779920697212,
0.09251407533884048,
-0.11576366424560547,
-0.1287466287612915,
0.04350491240620613,
-0.5857591032981873,
0.7711301445960999,
-0.10034970939159393,
-0.9266003966331482,
0.046313121914863586,
-0.06913161277770996,
0.3870032727718353,
-0.5233271718025208,
-0.20292934775352478,
-0.5130486488342285,
0.13788831233978271,
-0.04793362691998482,
-0.43887564539909363,
0.7728658318519592,
-0.04766296595335007,
0.044731687754392624,
-0.3312552571296692,
0.19376136362552643,
0.0017450822051614523,
-0.4547030031681061,
0.16067087650299072,
0.32722222805023193,
0.1574462503194809,
0.055158812552690506,
-0.3582887649536133,
0.4084937572479248,
-0.4122239053249359,
-0.19657643139362335,
-0.08739965409040451,
0.699123740196228,
0.10311730206012726,
1.0539023876190186,
0.7715593576431274,
0.43082094192504883,
0.3709394633769989,
0.09234870970249176,
0.8767180442810059,
0.039678484201431274,
-0.5772283673286438,
-0.5783969163894653,
0.6274101138114929,
-0.4455336630344391,
-0.2509164810180664,
0.437106728553772,
0.4006185531616211,
1.0244255065917969,
0.2876936197280884,
0.38716936111450195,
-0.1552363485097885,
0.23863360285758972,
-0.38966402411460876,
0.5321708917617798,
-0.5253236889839172,
0.6091295480728149,
0.09085005521774292,
-0.767407238483429,
0.0785311684012413,
0.08165045827627182,
0.1974232792854309,
-0.24205203354358673,
0.4709080755710602,
0.676207423210144,
-0.10582509636878967,
0.12192010134458542,
0.1370992362499237,
0.2083546221256256,
0.617633581161499,
0.3680592477321625,
0.6435451507568359,
-0.32414165139198303,
0.3290574252605438,
-0.26918157935142517,
-0.27523744106292725,
-0.18539048731327057,
-0.6903679966926575,
-0.508055567741394,
-0.7217003107070923,
-0.31087860465049744,
0.12427327781915665,
0.4659949839115143,
0.7147518992424011,
1.0624834299087524,
-0.6205245852470398,
-0.5579712986946106,
-0.5365282297134399,
0.47850894927978516,
-0.7434605360031128,
-0.27342870831489563,
0.17692780494689941,
-0.4883236587047577,
-1.2604681253433228,
0.3534899950027466,
0.35828834772109985,
-0.2713909447193146,
-0.4021126925945282,
-0.1240985244512558,
-0.06309077888727188,
0.3738597631454468,
0.34252238273620605,
0.18890853226184845,
-0.5834178328514099,
-0.2999420464038849,
-0.32535359263420105,
0.06941959261894226,
-0.029405223205685616,
0.5939540266990662,
-0.42848700284957886,
0.4378098249435425,
0.7026498913764954,
0.9721452593803406,
0.7580617666244507,
0.13518665730953217,
0.8739979863166809,
-0.7913038730621338,
0.09424157440662384,
0.5006474852561951,
0.26426956057548523,
0.009422392584383488,
-0.37002068758010864,
0.4658520817756653,
0.15991276502609253,
-0.7673898935317993,
-0.8206723928451538,
0.349801629781723,
-1.0390894412994385,
0.04707721993327141,
0.4558970332145691,
-0.2840742766857147,
-0.3072696030139923,
0.14658600091934204,
0.03490337356925011,
0.38833558559417725,
-0.8095637559890747,
0.7230310440063477,
0.7596298456192017,
-0.4530574083328247,
-0.3880961835384369,
-0.512942373752594,
0.2376231998205185,
0.22969874739646912,
-0.8738142848014832,
-0.2993800938129425,
0.6529453992843628,
-0.5395083427429199,
0.08760742098093033,
0.7501199245452881,
0.3394911587238312,
-0.049195796251297,
0.14890910685062408,
-0.36887413263320923,
-0.10081710666418076,
-0.6517495512962341,
-0.03936746343970299,
0.23623532056808472,
-0.389522910118103,
-0.6817599534988403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04307v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04307v2
|
HaluEval-Wild: Evaluating Hallucinations of Language Models in the Wild
| 2024-03-07T08:25:46 | 2024-05-06T06:10:23 |
Zhiying Zhu, Yiming Yang, Zhiqing Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hallucinations pose a significant challenge to the reliability of large
language models (LLMs) in critical domains. Recent benchmarks designed to
assess LLM hallucinations within conventional NLP tasks, such as
knowledge-intensive question answering (QA) and summarization, are insufficient
for capturing the complexities of user-LLM interactions in dynamic, real-world
settings. To address this gap, we introduce HaluEval-Wild, the first benchmark
specifically designed to evaluate LLM hallucinations in the wild. We
meticulously collect challenging (adversarially filtered by Alpaca) user
queries from existing real-world user-LLM interaction datasets, including
ShareGPT, to evaluate the hallucination rates of various LLMs. Upon analyzing
the collected queries, we categorize them into five distinct types, which
enables a fine-grained analysis of the types of hallucinations LLMs exhibit,
and synthesize the reference answers with the powerful GPT-4 model and
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). Our benchmark offers a novel approach
towards enhancing our comprehension and improvement of LLM reliability in
scenarios reflective of real-world interactions. Our benchmark is available at
https://github.com/Dianezzy/HaluEval-Wild.
|
[
-0.40650349855422974,
-0.9675069451332092,
0.4857664108276367,
0.3896542489528656,
-0.16980181634426117,
-0.0066526224836707115,
-0.3529396653175354,
-0.6254251599311829,
0.3638434410095215,
0.678425669670105,
-0.46652060747146606,
-0.6011324524879456,
-0.5027239918708801,
0.06052323430776596,
-0.5383267402648926,
0.8436856865882874,
0.12586550414562225,
-0.1901867836713791,
-0.06958027929067612,
-0.37754321098327637,
-0.515132486820221,
-0.9669268131256104,
-0.2677437365055084,
0.06604759395122528,
0.516470193862915,
-0.1341182291507721,
1.0353710651397705,
0.11762493848800659,
0.5322531461715698,
0.16603173315525055,
-0.1206679418683052,
0.3993895351886749,
-0.8580992221832275,
0.5424880385398865,
0.014016970060765743,
-0.10612966120243073,
-0.3758282959461212,
-0.011709596961736679,
0.3277120590209961,
0.8771757483482361,
-0.5010618567466736,
-0.062072236090898514,
-0.0033271859865635633,
0.4597787857055664,
-0.6558581590652466,
0.1808529943227768,
-1.108618140220642,
0.07088904082775116,
-0.2639738917350769,
-0.229637011885643,
-0.3149920701980591,
-0.587449312210083,
0.05902956798672676,
-0.5435283184051514,
0.18334683775901794,
0.12779685854911804,
0.8528172373771667,
0.3535889983177185,
-0.21784397959709167,
-0.44421181082725525,
-0.7351702451705933,
0.5278022289276123,
-0.5292644500732422,
0.5208226442337036,
0.5826898813247681,
0.48271551728248596,
-0.3427436351776123,
-0.6940820813179016,
-0.5566534399986267,
-0.47864407300949097,
0.07613512873649597,
-0.2383645623922348,
-0.38112127780914307,
-0.12999609112739563,
0.262861967086792,
0.40014633536338806,
-0.7376281023025513,
-0.09860324114561081,
-0.3598548471927643,
-0.31186845898628235,
0.5275930166244507,
0.27217355370521545,
0.20087872445583344,
-0.03855486586689949,
-0.0774165689945221,
-0.20088684558868408,
-0.5250707268714905,
-0.23549343645572662,
0.3152987062931061,
0.08183523267507553,
0.30381888151168823,
0.5018478631973267,
0.07099377363920212,
0.5826058983802795,
-0.29380834102630615,
0.11818476766347885,
0.2825963497161865,
-0.07990609854459763,
-0.13206161558628082,
-0.16193898022174835,
0.6161002516746521,
0.4396727681159973,
0.4322148859500885,
-0.6021161675453186,
-0.3412363529205322,
0.04715868830680847,
0.5138927102088928,
-0.6513593792915344,
-0.28363075852394104,
0.12797796726226807,
-0.22145135700702667,
-0.301753968000412,
-0.21497458219528198,
-0.9129147529602051,
-0.8471823334693909,
-0.022943004965782166,
0.5409498810768127,
-0.413277804851532,
-0.2601514160633087,
0.19392332434654236,
0.22584940493106842,
0.18593265116214752,
0.23066413402557373,
-0.8085852861404419,
0.43154671788215637,
0.768997848033905,
0.7163276076316833,
-0.4840501546859741,
-0.5874925851821899,
-0.5552838444709778,
-0.16721895337104797,
-0.47653111815452576,
0.9240710139274597,
-0.5087715983390808,
-0.36697840690612793,
0.2644639015197754,
-0.017671823501586914,
-0.09230246394872665,
-1.1140090227127075,
0.7526592016220093,
-0.6354296207427979,
-0.3193167746067047,
-0.34423843026161194,
-0.273909330368042,
-0.23664306104183197,
0.474129855632782,
-0.6814789175987244,
1.0061447620391846,
-0.0014948762254789472,
-0.6791015863418579,
0.3498198688030243,
-0.24004411697387695,
-0.2842324674129486,
0.31752878427505493,
-0.3664093017578125,
-0.26562997698783875,
0.2607053518295288,
0.14851589500904083,
0.3954576849937439,
-0.2968887984752655,
0.6046200394630432,
-0.5168341398239136,
-0.4624861776828766,
0.48623040318489075,
-0.6149817109107971,
0.4648890495300293,
-0.005205593071877956,
-0.23664459586143494,
0.13000701367855072,
-0.8467605710029602,
0.0075102681294083595,
0.147843599319458,
0.056544750928878784,
-0.432208389043808,
-0.07750938832759857,
0.01319129578769207,
-0.0030920959543436766,
0.05422639474272728,
-0.0850265845656395,
0.1557864248752594,
-0.2736051380634308,
0.1707915961742401,
0.5777011513710022,
0.2176932394504547,
-0.048864684998989105,
-0.4405475854873657,
0.5507395267486572,
-0.19926458597183228,
0.24229495227336884,
0.16004841029644012,
-0.3868314027786255,
-0.647331714630127,
-0.19444270431995392,
-0.08909102529287338,
0.2555789053440094,
-0.4951111674308777,
0.18993696570396423,
-0.1897526979446411,
-0.548444926738739,
-0.4540661573410034,
-0.14639781415462494,
0.1404535174369812,
0.27858924865722656,
0.5357851386070251,
-0.19922667741775513,
-0.5503444671630859,
-0.8751989006996155,
-0.44923779368400574,
-0.17815405130386353,
-0.07807257771492004,
0.5396568775177002,
0.4423731565475464,
-0.6168749928474426,
0.687102198600769,
-0.3687826097011566,
-0.3632974624633789,
-0.05299210175871849,
0.33732175827026367,
0.08684056252241135,
0.14350159466266632,
0.26077529788017273,
-0.6004149913787842,
-0.25011879205703735,
-0.21955335140228271,
-0.927869975566864,
-0.2920908033847809,
-0.08789987117052078,
-0.07926253974437714,
0.31142064929008484,
0.24022050201892853,
-0.6516118049621582,
0.37867826223373413,
0.6888875961303711,
-0.28118976950645447,
0.8928638696670532,
-0.015456372871994972,
0.33263665437698364,
-0.49229323863983154,
0.23811346292495728,
-0.5070160031318665,
0.043346818536520004,
-0.5589539408683777,
0.19347557425498962,
-0.19782952964305878,
-0.11395426094532013,
-0.22537563741207123,
0.4156847596168518,
-0.3779335021972656,
-0.27664339542388916,
-0.0486307255923748,
0.1980634182691574,
-0.23367302119731903,
0.5132943987846375,
-0.08341971039772034,
0.8937605619430542,
0.48950424790382385,
-0.36030516028404236,
0.2188718020915985,
0.13808882236480713,
-0.3563869595527649,
0.1896924078464508,
-0.4345856308937073,
0.42928704619407654,
0.1386587768793106,
0.11273613572120667,
-0.6256300806999207,
-0.29890647530555725,
0.12464165687561035,
-0.21929235756397247,
0.02074061892926693,
-0.01680818386375904,
-0.707436203956604,
-0.06362785398960114,
-0.31736481189727783,
0.36931416392326355,
0.4655752182006836,
-0.5531278848648071,
0.6319457292556763,
0.5224133133888245,
-0.04659894108772278,
-0.5460368990898132,
-0.4339182674884796,
0.4939135015010834,
-0.16169996559619904,
-0.5551304817199707,
0.09264203906059265,
-0.26678189635276794,
-0.5432983040809631,
-0.13026867806911469,
-0.2861206531524658,
-0.044097427278757095,
0.19380900263786316,
0.5280933976173401,
0.1314435601234436,
-0.040166400372982025,
-0.13669629395008087,
0.0530233271420002,
0.04656512662768364,
0.2687099874019623,
-0.0640086755156517,
0.8061927556991577,
-0.4797367453575134,
-0.34639254212379456,
0.002564830705523491,
0.26700296998023987,
0.6326280236244202,
-0.012272694148123264,
0.7749272584915161,
0.3504437804222107,
-0.5948933959007263,
-0.39700570702552795,
-0.8313582539558411,
-0.3298225402832031,
-0.406436026096344,
0.3638504445552826,
-0.4451007843017578,
-0.9485809803009033,
0.7818706035614014,
0.0726691484451294,
0.00672279903665185,
0.28624048829078674,
0.5379171967506409,
0.16188687086105347,
0.8255349397659302,
0.4183860421180725,
0.18658891320228577,
-0.235134556889534,
-0.08683258295059204,
0.16248202323913574,
-0.5435956120491028,
-0.3957253396511078,
-0.338972806930542,
0.07754058390855789,
-0.42962220311164856,
-0.62437903881073,
0.47468987107276917,
0.333117812871933,
0.019807299599051476,
0.13915389776229858,
-0.3852722942829132,
0.4767308235168457,
0.16433948278427124,
-0.0679255798459053,
0.46463221311569214,
-0.008319191634654999,
-0.07389983534812927,
-0.3782869875431061,
-0.3806341290473938,
-0.7026234865188599,
0.9674092531204224,
0.2730197608470917,
0.6475686430931091,
0.15049295127391815,
0.5865057110786438,
0.3930676579475403,
0.528332531452179,
-0.7165778875350952,
0.7438130974769592,
0.10109683126211166,
-0.5883350968360901,
-0.3328351378440857,
-0.3916557729244232,
-0.8698590397834778,
0.5686163306236267,
-0.2478349208831787,
-0.8572260737419128,
0.12434715777635574,
0.027638999745249748,
-0.3278599679470062,
0.16241596639156342,
-0.17435690760612488,
0.7879316210746765,
-0.03253790736198425,
-0.320525199174881,
-0.21676191687583923,
-0.4329085052013397,
0.787891685962677,
-0.4060434401035309,
0.25614234805107117,
-0.1889098882675171,
0.11054274439811707,
0.6966918706893921,
-0.3368186950683594,
0.763152003288269,
-0.034034036099910736,
-0.29168227314949036,
0.25457751750946045,
0.6350876092910767,
0.5902367830276489,
0.15645287930965424,
-0.17929379642009735,
0.49587559700012207,
0.09014458954334259,
-0.10446133464574814,
-0.5344216823577881,
0.896539032459259,
-0.6626284122467041,
-0.6122357845306396,
-0.6212524175643921,
-0.6252833604812622,
-0.4887124300003052,
-0.05678771063685417,
0.061914656311273575,
0.23246940970420837,
-0.4244879186153412,
0.10469984263181686,
0.6844253540039062,
-0.32683688402175903,
0.14732743799686432,
0.4897875487804413,
-0.5060445070266724,
-0.4014941453933716,
0.8437573313713074,
0.18600164353847504,
-0.02610783651471138,
-0.10050143301486969,
0.09628994762897491,
-0.1611206829547882,
-0.7894210815429688,
-0.26706361770629883,
0.24710460007190704,
-0.8851081132888794,
-0.11157745122909546,
-1.126911997795105,
-0.39200207591056824,
-0.24202308058738708,
-0.08488822728395462,
-0.3052261173725128,
-0.11822094768285751,
-0.1432967483997345,
-0.02893325872719288,
0.2998597323894501,
0.5947301983833313,
-0.12005923688411713,
-0.12996725738048553,
-0.8124222755432129,
0.35597875714302063,
0.4306425154209137,
0.25337135791778564,
0.11043769121170044,
-0.6111304759979248,
0.06662185490131378,
-0.19026310741901398,
-0.14769907295703888,
-0.8281227350234985,
0.621675968170166,
0.11662644892930984,
0.580390214920044,
0.17217978835105896,
0.316444456577301,
0.7067168951034546,
-0.4753778576850891,
0.8153790831565857,
-0.16986067593097687,
-0.7705962657928467,
0.17832326889038086,
-0.2033834308385849,
0.003465913701802492,
0.839266836643219,
0.5246562361717224,
-0.6110592484474182,
-0.6173206567764282,
-0.3973633944988251,
-0.8603326082229614,
0.3552721440792084,
0.28791943192481995,
0.12155655026435852,
-0.09210702031850815,
0.41059544682502747,
0.43381044268608093,
0.1214580312371254,
-0.7630971074104309,
-0.16304294764995575,
-0.11760646849870682,
0.11025162041187286,
0.052577193826436996,
-0.5423109531402588,
-0.2540096044540405,
-0.12101822346448898,
0.4907536506652832,
-0.06778594106435776,
-0.05898687615990639,
0.04486138001084328,
-0.35749202966690063,
-0.22165249288082123,
0.16074062883853912,
0.6859998106956482,
0.8766379952430725,
-0.5519757270812988,
0.4305974841117859,
0.38433676958084106,
-0.559944748878479,
-0.2024359554052353,
0.21463991701602936,
0.003203789936378598,
-0.018322497606277466,
0.4946269989013672,
0.7854762673377991,
0.2235894799232483,
-1.0780830383300781,
0.5433552265167236,
-0.38921058177948,
-0.1901772916316986,
-0.4458886384963989,
0.0007920946227386594,
-0.10207410156726837,
0.2650546729564667,
0.5787718892097473,
0.11213205754756927,
0.3691900670528412,
-0.599655032157898,
0.39831826090812683,
0.33754962682724,
-0.3867972791194916,
-0.5533347725868225,
0.7313824892044067,
-0.14313581585884094,
-0.38677990436553955,
0.5672029256820679,
-0.3752877414226532,
-0.6391538977622986,
0.2937088906764984,
0.4957234859466553,
1.0675503015518188,
0.06119218468666077,
0.0961088016629219,
0.3378497362136841,
0.47097811102867126,
0.012188979424536228,
0.27675122022628784,
-0.03372126817703247,
-0.5569257140159607,
-0.28560787439346313,
-0.864877462387085,
-0.5952977538108826,
0.4470389187335968,
-0.6063694953918457,
0.05254503712058067,
-0.21258985996246338,
0.022921090945601463,
-0.20297135412693024,
-0.02479131706058979,
-0.46891945600509644,
-0.1782359778881073,
0.1282075047492981,
0.594745397567749,
-0.7080695033073425,
0.8515214323997498,
0.20707769691944122,
-0.25840920209884644,
-0.56969153881073,
0.39286357164382935,
-0.09271454066038132,
-0.8236984014511108,
0.554967999458313,
0.2846246659755707,
-0.23237453401088715,
-0.1350633203983307,
-0.6025646328926086,
-0.5705633163452148,
0.8928740620613098,
0.14703629910945892,
-0.7493900060653687,
0.1870628446340561,
0.14510007202625275,
0.7779600620269775,
-0.1318962275981903,
0.09991516917943954,
0.7979568839073181,
0.38429972529411316,
0.18399398028850555,
-0.9063498377799988,
0.2500225305557251,
-0.10222107172012329,
-0.15669670701026917,
-0.00916283018887043,
-0.365121990442276,
0.5396952629089355,
-0.2411739081144333,
-0.2959543466567993,
-0.009883072227239609,
0.6272178888320923,
0.6991115212440491,
0.4540155529975891,
0.666001558303833,
0.4450799524784088,
0.8321043252944946,
0.0826120674610138,
0.8240925669670105,
-0.40887290239334106,
0.21789076924324036,
1.088377833366394,
-0.5831001400947571,
0.9128651022911072,
0.3667680323123932,
-0.058346718549728394,
0.10182701051235199,
0.503722071647644,
-0.01371016539633274,
0.5757335424423218,
0.5479333400726318,
-0.23461616039276123,
-0.26805856823921204,
-0.07974637299776077,
-0.48508375883102417,
0.13795733451843262,
0.4382094442844391,
0.1995547115802765,
-0.09406285732984543,
0.18195287883281708,
0.08546076714992523,
0.1398002952337265,
0.16284389793872833,
0.6543669700622559,
0.13492831587791443,
-0.702728271484375,
1.066606044769287,
-0.31827181577682495,
0.7074077725410461,
-0.5443959832191467,
-0.07722709327936172,
-0.6116663813591003,
0.05776349455118179,
0.046755652874708176,
-0.5226626396179199,
0.5543344020843506,
0.1770584136247635,
0.019231311976909637,
0.07129678875207901,
0.4536946713924408,
-0.37906235456466675,
-0.24345828592777252,
0.5928974151611328,
0.2794249653816223,
0.6262120604515076,
-0.28835639357566833,
-0.5798067450523376,
0.7312809228897095,
-0.20704130828380585,
-0.33935633301734924,
0.4236530065536499,
0.5165688991546631,
-0.19090497493743896,
0.7679123282432556,
0.6608904004096985,
0.07929159700870514,
0.21738681197166443,
0.28562691807746887,
1.0115962028503418,
-0.6542727947235107,
0.04051500931382179,
-0.6851518750190735,
0.07039128988981247,
0.03111143782734871,
-0.44184932112693787,
0.6646042466163635,
0.5779396891593933,
0.6228445768356323,
0.11305343359708786,
0.5476421117782593,
0.09238334745168686,
0.41461268067359924,
-0.27067747712135315,
1.0252907276153564,
-0.5061562061309814,
0.49775269627571106,
-0.1315821409225464,
-0.9712321162223816,
-0.5598046183586121,
0.4702069163322449,
-0.14458951354026794,
-0.17693816125392914,
0.7498935461044312,
1.073951244354248,
0.09989554435014725,
-0.0011446517892181873,
0.704312801361084,
0.5385757088661194,
0.4131017327308655,
0.3391852080821991,
1.1257612705230713,
-0.2641908824443817,
0.689550518989563,
-0.29776495695114136,
-0.25481507182121277,
-0.2549739480018616,
-0.7548054456710815,
-1.0255268812179565,
-0.6471942663192749,
-0.2621068060398102,
-0.5498408675193787,
0.2953141927719116,
0.8549460172653198,
0.48002779483795166,
-0.8765468597412109,
-0.17696696519851685,
0.05221666768193245,
-0.1644090861082077,
-0.25078892707824707,
-0.2243346869945526,
0.5149361491203308,
-0.4105018973350525,
-0.4401516914367676,
0.5254313349723816,
0.3061426281929016,
-0.025474315509200096,
-0.588416576385498,
-0.08601443469524384,
0.12805652618408203,
0.27609899640083313,
0.6268948912620544,
0.11941980570554733,
-0.962464451789856,
-0.19620852172374725,
0.18087267875671387,
-0.24924179911613464,
-0.1606210470199585,
0.7075605988502502,
-0.6953138709068298,
0.33041492104530334,
0.11462512612342834,
0.7060293555259705,
0.5384734272956848,
-0.14776895940303802,
0.27833741903305054,
-0.35903793573379517,
-0.09242556989192963,
0.6057648658752441,
0.10904458165168762,
0.25007662177085876,
-0.23128479719161987,
0.5815834999084473,
0.23761719465255737,
-0.6691955924034119,
-1.3183467388153076,
-0.06317614018917084,
-1.1080211400985718,
-0.2201671004295349,
1.263717532157898,
-0.12794587016105652,
-0.042440153658390045,
-0.19580546021461487,
-0.2106047421693802,
-0.1186712309718132,
-0.17674900591373444,
1.162279725074768,
0.6477982997894287,
0.01427560392767191,
-0.03656225651502609,
-0.7635456919670105,
0.6878610849380493,
0.4274323880672455,
-0.8237186670303345,
0.5196734070777893,
0.6417967677116394,
-0.013036922551691532,
0.051803555339574814,
0.5233978629112244,
-0.059755679219961166,
-0.08042565733194351,
0.1328369677066803,
0.10687042772769928,
-0.04465985670685768,
-0.4108206331729889,
-0.31039097905158997,
0.4697292745113373,
0.15124207735061646,
0.14689940214157104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04283v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04283v1
|
Proxy-RLHF: Decoupling Generation and Alignment in Large Language Model with Proxy
| 2024-03-07T07:31:00 | 2024-03-07T07:31:00 |
Yu Zhu, Chuxiong Sun, Wenfei Yang, Wenqiang Wei, Bo Tang, Tianzhu Zhang, Zhiyu Li, Shifeng Zhang, Feiyu Xiong, Jie Hu, Mingchuan yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is the prevailing approach
to ensure Large Language Models (LLMs) align with human values. However,
existing RLHF methods require a high computational cost, one main reason being
that RLHF assigns both the generation and alignment tasks to the LLM
simultaneously. In this paper, we introduce Proxy-RLHF, which decouples the
generation and alignment processes of LLMs, achieving alignment with human
values at a much lower computational cost. We start with a novel Markov
Decision Process (MDP) designed for the alignment process and employ
Reinforcement Learning (RL) to train a streamlined proxy model that oversees
the token generation of the LLM, without altering the LLM itself. Experiments
show that our method achieves a comparable level of alignment with only 1\% of
the training parameters of other methods.
|
[
-0.3861871361732483,
-0.6462435126304626,
0.44618889689445496,
0.08061110973358154,
-0.37090611457824707,
0.34876570105552673,
-0.06364759802818298,
-0.3284244239330292,
0.39237385988235474,
0.6607826948165894,
-0.9654173254966736,
-0.3933916985988617,
-0.37645789980888367,
-0.07239583134651184,
-0.05757676064968109,
0.9082809686660767,
-0.01499246433377266,
0.066716767847538,
-0.05292873829603195,
-0.17766383290290833,
-0.22300781309604645,
-0.37426891922950745,
-1.0751914978027344,
-0.587826132774353,
0.5964992046356201,
0.27394214272499084,
0.8038550019264221,
1.2999541759490967,
0.23375895619392395,
0.26627153158187866,
0.17968185245990753,
0.45868951082229614,
-0.43776434659957886,
0.316592276096344,
-0.58954918384552,
-0.06193586066365242,
-0.4586133360862732,
-0.16682690382003784,
0.8825352191925049,
0.6866611242294312,
-0.574211061000824,
0.27507421374320984,
-0.09544051438570023,
0.9607284069061279,
-0.7189828157424927,
0.2774997055530548,
-0.5966841578483582,
0.03320339694619179,
-0.11063593626022339,
0.055197443813085556,
-0.3867397904396057,
-0.3003574013710022,
-0.010251517407596111,
-0.4007008373737335,
0.15205609798431396,
0.2630760967731476,
0.8856318593025208,
0.29139000177383423,
-0.6177926659584045,
0.01023893617093563,
-0.38609498739242554,
0.674344539642334,
-0.6919199228286743,
0.45989668369293213,
0.09216177463531494,
0.1217338889837265,
-0.7398881912231445,
-0.4739334285259247,
-0.7252639532089233,
0.0036810918245464563,
0.3481427729129791,
0.12582848966121674,
0.3717763423919678,
0.23654361069202423,
-0.019879810512065887,
-0.00018144641944672912,
-0.5249660015106201,
0.3818979561328888,
-0.1925320327281952,
-0.2758745849132538,
0.7162702679634094,
0.33636295795440674,
0.23673115670681,
-0.10279951989650726,
-0.5092382431030273,
-0.4097174108028412,
-0.9081336259841919,
0.03663041442632675,
0.727886974811554,
0.5897229909896851,
0.027292195707559586,
0.379363477230072,
-0.1665111482143402,
0.5737708210945129,
0.26112860441207886,
-0.535373866558075,
0.1021905168890953,
0.09846363961696625,
-0.08479928970336914,
0.3648470342159271,
0.8300621509552002,
0.24176688492298126,
0.17267093062400818,
-0.058696482330560684,
-0.3213542103767395,
0.19171035289764404,
0.3707065284252167,
-0.6797184944152832,
-0.025927579030394554,
0.15454985201358795,
-0.3891661465167999,
-0.33320748805999756,
0.17717300355434418,
-0.6979825496673584,
-0.29628628492355347,
-0.2691858112812042,
0.27426719665527344,
0.03974400833249092,
-0.4117981493473053,
0.027301669120788574,
-0.027461886405944824,
0.32098421454429626,
0.21423815190792084,
-0.9819555282592773,
0.4111798107624054,
0.9701141119003296,
0.584921658039093,
-0.5674342513084412,
-0.6240308284759521,
-1.119127631187439,
0.27652817964553833,
-0.5718473792076111,
0.6120108962059021,
-0.33551251888275146,
-0.22436349093914032,
0.32645922899246216,
0.063334621489048,
0.03788802772760391,
-0.6884316205978394,
0.47352516651153564,
-0.8027124404907227,
0.12290961295366287,
-0.12649066746234894,
-0.5055404305458069,
0.04930974170565605,
0.09621918946504593,
-0.8714762330055237,
0.9715848565101624,
0.0362720862030983,
-0.6460469365119934,
0.468676894903183,
-0.49092748761177063,
-0.3608569800853729,
-0.05230496823787689,
0.009647161699831486,
-0.6345921754837036,
-0.14351092278957367,
0.2508196532726288,
0.3075895309448242,
-0.2884027063846588,
0.5689074397087097,
-0.5260123014450073,
-0.15137073397636414,
0.3270496129989624,
-0.31652140617370605,
0.5405550003051758,
0.4226363003253937,
-0.3214089870452881,
0.30600085854530334,
-0.8595167994499207,
-0.004345670808106661,
-0.030830493196845055,
-0.8896884918212891,
-0.0021640032064169645,
0.2277568280696869,
-0.20011866092681885,
0.5850746631622314,
0.007334410212934017,
-0.37848594784736633,
0.3975108563899994,
-0.5754731893539429,
0.33222198486328125,
0.8177525401115417,
0.21460139751434326,
0.5451056957244873,
-0.2828521728515625,
0.617185652256012,
0.08978927135467529,
-0.005088513717055321,
0.061249468475580215,
-0.22958120703697205,
-0.7505958080291748,
-0.43181848526000977,
0.3774145245552063,
0.29919105768203735,
-0.823785126209259,
0.29353824257850647,
-0.2504904270172119,
-0.09684892743825912,
-0.9582279324531555,
0.258235365152359,
0.7589902877807617,
0.6665185689926147,
0.22513265907764435,
-0.2372780591249466,
-0.6091983914375305,
-0.9216769337654114,
-0.2859511375427246,
-0.4413302540779114,
0.11125533282756805,
-0.09275763481855392,
0.382853239774704,
-0.3034254014492035,
0.7880017161369324,
-0.3055189549922943,
-0.02676708623766899,
-0.14367663860321045,
0.3293119966983795,
0.11870699375867844,
0.5609813928604126,
-0.023582937195897102,
-0.5141785740852356,
-0.30273088812828064,
-0.04627660661935806,
-0.18434888124465942,
-0.3949390649795532,
-0.1471123993396759,
-0.32641884684562683,
0.7613796591758728,
0.5500901937484741,
-0.6120656728744507,
0.11504997313022614,
0.7536858916282654,
-0.32810577750205994,
0.4543364942073822,
-0.31171077489852905,
0.05912729352712631,
-1.0789669752120972,
-0.01558573916554451,
0.006832495331764221,
-0.6418226361274719,
-0.38753700256347656,
0.29325830936431885,
0.23577085137367249,
0.05387580394744873,
-0.6376012563705444,
0.7271623611450195,
-0.538670003414154,
-0.19157879054546356,
-0.5086877942085266,
0.3352716267108917,
-0.1512131243944168,
0.7552770972251892,
0.3603597581386566,
0.6009992361068726,
0.15056350827217102,
-0.6466645002365112,
0.3878691792488098,
0.013150998391211033,
-0.2813948094844818,
0.33586159348487854,
-0.41046279668807983,
-0.029504800215363503,
-0.16218574345111847,
0.40116024017333984,
-0.8446000218391418,
-0.3014841377735138,
0.2988576292991638,
-0.15273278951644897,
0.19290892779827118,
-0.2979690432548523,
-0.3848506510257721,
-0.13671521842479706,
-0.34931114315986633,
0.3498589098453522,
0.5802132487297058,
-0.966205894947052,
0.44944629073143005,
0.6632009744644165,
-0.10445408523082733,
-0.8035832643508911,
-0.2253170758485794,
0.02271299995481968,
-0.34623226523399353,
-0.4639154076576233,
0.4363800585269928,
0.23470745980739594,
-0.08776754140853882,
-0.10196533054113388,
-0.12556879222393036,
0.1700393408536911,
-0.0856255367398262,
0.31825873255729675,
0.3784228265285492,
0.032362956553697586,
0.20734471082687378,
0.10002902895212173,
-0.2169230878353119,
0.12028560042381287,
-0.47214794158935547,
0.5217691659927368,
0.11367167532444,
-0.4565730690956116,
-0.399270623922348,
0.2297804206609726,
0.6138667464256287,
-0.12336108833551407,
0.7761808633804321,
0.5198173522949219,
-0.03491612896323204,
-0.5367279052734375,
-0.6088415384292603,
-0.13980747759342194,
-0.4164464473724365,
0.3326283395290375,
-0.3301774859428406,
-0.8441406488418579,
0.4424893856048584,
-0.4963209927082062,
0.10706302523612976,
0.38015615940093994,
0.6244611740112305,
0.08768927305936813,
1.4861098527908325,
0.5266609191894531,
-0.085456483066082,
0.362819641828537,
0.32878729701042175,
-0.006820552982389927,
-0.7020775675773621,
-0.23180215060710907,
-0.5084701180458069,
-0.3286288380622864,
-0.7355972528457642,
-0.2651401460170746,
0.13039854168891907,
0.34213387966156006,
-0.7113147377967834,
0.1529085785150528,
-0.22364820539951324,
0.40188348293304443,
0.7139683365821838,
-0.030676105991005898,
0.2557818591594696,
-0.16582277417182922,
-0.4481571614742279,
0.11032740771770477,
-0.8034963011741638,
-0.4214932918548584,
0.7756249308586121,
0.4114935100078583,
0.9095345735549927,
0.2740201950073242,
0.972438633441925,
0.16487430036067963,
0.18142026662826538,
-0.6488114595413208,
0.5568370223045349,
0.2598717510700226,
-0.15256568789482117,
-0.4889886677265167,
-0.5460293292999268,
-1.0438504219055176,
0.5133218765258789,
-0.4179936349391937,
-0.5586677193641663,
-0.07843038439750671,
0.297456830739975,
-0.04342721775174141,
0.19637832045555115,
-0.33955103158950806,
0.7676544189453125,
-0.0342775359749794,
-0.4741522967815399,
-0.18360953032970428,
-0.8186110258102417,
0.5659481287002563,
-0.023381192237138748,
0.28045397996902466,
-0.057318706065416336,
-0.2202305942773819,
0.7968299984931946,
-0.6630607843399048,
0.7760742902755737,
-0.16879676282405853,
-0.43399491906166077,
0.14257241785526276,
0.2565911114215851,
0.8753628134727478,
0.06855867803096771,
0.11693164706230164,
-0.239400714635849,
0.1322460025548935,
-0.3160630166530609,
-0.5925571918487549,
0.6782470345497131,
-0.79331374168396,
-0.7403679490089417,
-0.4394708275794983,
-0.42674243450164795,
-0.127859428524971,
-0.0022742333821952343,
-0.1240067332983017,
0.07663615792989731,
-0.06347211450338364,
-0.18978288769721985,
0.7268909811973572,
-0.1604924499988556,
0.5089913010597229,
0.5397148132324219,
-0.5692494511604309,
-0.884251058101654,
0.8133603930473328,
-0.29086169600486755,
0.45354607701301575,
0.32337453961372375,
0.2398812174797058,
-0.6064444780349731,
-0.11620885133743286,
-0.48335209488868713,
0.4473145008087158,
-0.5699727535247803,
-0.17507150769233704,
-0.342135488986969,
-0.07223550230264664,
-0.5713974237442017,
0.04616346210241318,
-0.5922544598579407,
-0.4760756492614746,
-0.11180925369262695,
-0.07517246901988983,
-0.04144211485981941,
0.5096228718757629,
-0.24419111013412476,
0.1861904263496399,
-0.9389117956161499,
0.41508373618125916,
0.39313817024230957,
0.28518378734588623,
-0.005800328217446804,
-0.36616232991218567,
-0.1515735685825348,
0.031220488250255585,
-0.265240341424942,
-0.8150380849838257,
0.5059162974357605,
0.15120665729045868,
0.3954625725746155,
0.6562607884407043,
0.261303573846817,
1.0357145071029663,
-0.5827142596244812,
0.7563867568969727,
0.3495040535926819,
-1.1457985639572144,
0.29759785532951355,
-0.20874948799610138,
0.3746442496776581,
0.3140806257724762,
0.17513850331306458,
-0.8056924939155579,
-0.30269855260849,
-0.5786355137825012,
-0.8009925484657288,
0.7460072636604309,
-0.3852475881576538,
-0.20934385061264038,
-0.27654555439949036,
0.5912362337112427,
0.02371886558830738,
0.14697261154651642,
-0.7203126549720764,
-0.02473779208958149,
0.11968352645635605,
-0.2827053964138031,
0.13417771458625793,
-0.13060249388217926,
-0.1806318163871765,
-0.08384224027395248,
1.0363051891326904,
-0.33390140533447266,
-0.2342412918806076,
-0.04529911279678345,
-0.06754236668348312,
-0.35277876257896423,
0.18152767419815063,
0.6596233248710632,
0.5159967541694641,
0.0743785873055458,
0.386148065328598,
0.13930624723434448,
-0.30622100830078125,
0.3317566215991974,
-0.47303664684295654,
0.0006747948355041444,
-0.3513262867927551,
0.43231213092803955,
0.746990442276001,
0.2246898114681244,
-0.8671939969062805,
0.3942408263683319,
0.023551980033516884,
-0.4189269542694092,
-0.15253333747386932,
0.32933729887008667,
0.31127840280532837,
0.5666744709014893,
0.027915293350815773,
-0.40629419684410095,
-0.30334123969078064,
-0.5863558650016785,
0.2572234272956848,
0.5289009809494019,
-0.3211577236652374,
-0.09251680970191956,
0.6002310514450073,
0.2152375876903534,
-0.5162903070449829,
0.8593224287033081,
-0.22756047546863556,
-0.5199185609817505,
0.3593848943710327,
0.8301701545715332,
0.7980166673660278,
-0.23927311599254608,
0.437570720911026,
0.3273483216762543,
-0.09227228164672852,
-0.5638526082038879,
0.34101957082748413,
-0.10249784588813782,
-0.7679262161254883,
-0.7432385087013245,
-0.8016582727432251,
-0.5165106058120728,
0.07597370445728302,
-0.811683714389801,
0.14237792789936066,
-0.43756741285324097,
-0.14250816404819489,
-0.36266469955444336,
0.1160811111330986,
-0.2794232666492462,
-0.009657829999923706,
-0.04900728166103363,
0.582725465297699,
-0.8241275548934937,
1.067035436630249,
0.5669437050819397,
-0.3609151840209961,
-0.7771063446998596,
-0.04551342502236366,
0.162788987159729,
-0.6831064820289612,
1.0573841333389282,
-0.16351479291915894,
-0.37425509095191956,
0.07786373794078827,
-0.5198742151260376,
-0.913329541683197,
0.9622012376785278,
0.5597839951515198,
-0.4755927622318268,
0.00023368195979855955,
0.14562809467315674,
0.40961888432502747,
-0.45608827471733093,
-0.29229551553726196,
0.6717581152915955,
0.4886220097541809,
0.18253177404403687,
-0.7292095422744751,
0.190416157245636,
0.019046030938625336,
0.27999407052993774,
0.5758269429206848,
-0.5978968143463135,
0.8246150016784668,
-0.09100167453289032,
-0.6193812489509583,
-0.019120121374726295,
0.7824947237968445,
0.5459262132644653,
-0.19355835020542145,
0.44985437393188477,
0.8376900553703308,
0.6274457573890686,
0.11457524448633194,
0.5986025929450989,
-0.23759375512599945,
0.3009754419326782,
1.2177352905273438,
-0.49956804513931274,
1.0899317264556885,
0.7912927865982056,
-0.0839090421795845,
0.47612136602401733,
0.5986191630363464,
0.25253260135650635,
0.5006051659584045,
0.6145574450492859,
-0.31853413581848145,
-0.4770120084285736,
0.03380749002099037,
0.15700265765190125,
0.21189077198505402,
0.024897651746869087,
0.015596238896250725,
-0.3310777246952057,
-0.10909321904182434,
0.12060067802667618,
0.22214557230472565,
-0.3304235637187958,
1.063606858253479,
-0.07650791108608246,
-1.2892707586288452,
0.4888514578342438,
0.2914094626903534,
0.4487542510032654,
-0.465061217546463,
-0.33375269174575806,
-0.13139362633228302,
0.3260422646999359,
-0.1402609646320343,
-0.5924383401870728,
0.10308900475502014,
-0.264750599861145,
-0.22604089975357056,
-0.35218194127082825,
0.5146056413650513,
-0.7543326616287231,
-0.039903320372104645,
0.3728216290473938,
0.37456029653549194,
0.0545489676296711,
0.2320650964975357,
-0.6655481457710266,
0.17395997047424316,
-0.18193034827709198,
-0.1410256177186966,
0.6029195785522461,
0.26909419894218445,
-0.11829043924808502,
0.8057268857955933,
0.8216641545295715,
0.49709510803222656,
0.1247146800160408,
0.17323337495326996,
0.47919851541519165,
-0.7298257350921631,
-0.48543307185173035,
-0.95175701379776,
0.35184335708618164,
0.0071498556062579155,
-0.22329196333885193,
0.31428468227386475,
0.19798806309700012,
0.9730473160743713,
-0.05652476102113724,
0.5321851372718811,
0.45350995659828186,
0.5187351703643799,
-0.8502935767173767,
0.5729220509529114,
-0.31065303087234497,
0.16558818519115448,
-0.20746338367462158,
-1.0165122747421265,
-0.2905983328819275,
0.5768229365348816,
0.19004549086093903,
-0.2389286309480667,
0.7229771614074707,
1.0335584878921509,
0.07609077543020248,
-0.34700024127960205,
0.28623729944229126,
-0.19629989564418793,
0.5565140843391418,
0.5411384105682373,
0.8215607404708862,
-0.12894050776958466,
0.351561039686203,
0.05971135199069977,
-0.17996284365653992,
-0.14771786332130432,
-1.230771780014038,
-0.9088317155838013,
-0.7779439687728882,
-0.49545249342918396,
-0.47577759623527527,
0.11099129915237427,
1.400963544845581,
0.6045250296592712,
-0.669044017791748,
-0.4400194585323334,
-0.22271539270877838,
0.3406587541103363,
-0.5043283700942993,
-0.23708151280879974,
0.5505373477935791,
-0.6607457995414734,
-0.7627100944519043,
0.2781481146812439,
0.36461785435676575,
-0.09823775291442871,
-0.4909268915653229,
-0.5892429947853088,
-0.40045616030693054,
0.20026804506778717,
0.3737841546535492,
0.5994329452514648,
-0.8655002117156982,
-0.3732333779335022,
-0.5449392199516296,
-0.23258718848228455,
-0.0785086452960968,
0.8165673613548279,
-0.9020277857780457,
0.2511516809463501,
0.6184611916542053,
1.027207851409912,
0.49391913414001465,
0.20933929085731506,
0.6913933753967285,
-0.7287484407424927,
-0.1559562385082245,
-0.18621322512626648,
0.38259410858154297,
-0.07565899193286896,
-0.13664840161800385,
0.3221854865550995,
0.10590042173862457,
-0.6633443236351013,
-0.7580954432487488,
0.588992714881897,
-0.7770271301269531,
-0.38965463638305664,
0.9800270795822144,
-0.07431904226541519,
-0.4506138861179352,
-0.04807083681225777,
-0.2165338695049286,
0.5379722118377686,
-0.4551887810230255,
1.00990891456604,
0.5811142921447754,
-0.09395866096019745,
-0.2514500021934509,
-0.20300434529781342,
0.6918616890907288,
0.27968332171440125,
-0.753119170665741,
0.1809939444065094,
0.6562108397483826,
0.2482106238603592,
-0.022626440972089767,
0.4299914240837097,
-0.17679330706596375,
0.15728986263275146,
-0.16177810728549957,
0.2877127528190613,
-0.07403720915317535,
-0.36703091859817505,
-0.43843162059783936,
0.3679410219192505,
0.13923324644565582,
-0.09236948937177658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04280v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04280v2
|
A New Benchmark for Evaluating Automatic Speech Recognition in the Arabic Call Domain
| 2024-03-07T07:24:32 | 2024-05-30T12:17:51 |
Qusai Abo Obaidah, Muhy Eddin Za'ter, Adnan Jaljuli, Ali Mahboub, Asma Hakouz, Bashar Al-Rfooh, Yazan Estaitia
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This work is an attempt to introduce a comprehensive benchmark for Arabic
speech recognition, specifically tailored to address the challenges of
telephone conversations in Arabic language. Arabic, characterized by its rich
dialectal diversity and phonetic complexity, presents a number of unique
challenges for automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems. These challenges are
further amplified in the domain of telephone calls, where audio quality,
background noise, and conversational speech styles negatively affect
recognition accuracy. Our work aims to establish a robust benchmark that not
only encompasses the broad spectrum of Arabic dialects but also emulates the
real-world conditions of call-based communications. By incorporating diverse
dialectical expressions and accounting for the variable quality of call
recordings, this benchmark seeks to provide a rigorous testing ground for the
development and evaluation of ASR systems capable of navigating the
complexities of Arabic speech in telephonic contexts. This work also attempts
to establish a baseline performance evaluation using state-of-the-art ASR
technologies.
|
[
-0.36469557881355286,
-0.4103710949420929,
-0.10350239276885986,
0.08066336065530777,
-0.17514106631278992,
0.4358050525188446,
-0.11349566280841827,
-0.6218004822731018,
-0.04133838415145874,
0.24011778831481934,
-0.213622584939003,
-0.4680604636669159,
-0.5424402952194214,
0.2857119143009186,
-0.5372009873390198,
0.37120112776756287,
-0.07988878339529037,
0.20394323766231537,
0.2662788927555084,
-0.45799359679222107,
-0.45623064041137695,
-0.619896411895752,
-0.6130548119544983,
-0.26309502124786377,
0.027997639030218124,
0.4708288908004761,
0.8522397875785828,
0.4392627477645874,
0.24539677798748016,
0.35537591576576233,
0.03346691653132439,
0.06278334558010101,
0.1043076366186142,
0.12532152235507965,
0.13680802285671234,
0.1162412241101265,
-0.4324650764465332,
-0.13652652502059937,
0.9187284111976624,
0.689957857131958,
-0.30871930718421936,
0.29793110489845276,
-0.15467949211597443,
0.5185551047325134,
-0.6007015705108643,
0.2066832184791565,
-0.673954427242279,
-0.02770213410258293,
-0.4804670810699463,
0.04013054817914963,
0.13506732881069183,
-0.61500483751297,
0.21147789061069489,
0.00006396389653673396,
0.13288234174251556,
-0.09881806373596191,
0.8558579087257385,
0.18039852380752563,
-0.47889095544815063,
-0.4699574410915375,
-0.8703180551528931,
0.5090231895446777,
-0.5716849565505981,
0.6409152746200562,
0.5860073566436768,
1.006911277770996,
0.22554875910282135,
-0.5132784247398376,
-0.6276705861091614,
-0.21728146076202393,
0.312328577041626,
0.030875006690621376,
-0.3819858133792877,
-0.22227202355861664,
0.12070031464099884,
0.44706714153289795,
-0.4755730926990509,
-0.24942073225975037,
-0.27731406688690186,
-0.4304467439651489,
0.6490786075592041,
0.12652640044689178,
0.04342126101255417,
0.46084287762641907,
0.12165664881467819,
0.020646914839744568,
-0.43543070554733276,
0.4102352559566498,
0.34954971075057983,
0.476866215467453,
-0.2029118537902832,
0.3186922073364258,
-0.398027628660202,
0.48100194334983826,
-0.04442053288221359,
0.1137886643409729,
0.5921366810798645,
-0.036110684275627136,
-0.08935319632291794,
0.4497740864753723,
0.6093302965164185,
0.2131332904100418,
0.22322440147399902,
-0.07243662327528,
-0.4364721179008484,
0.006642781663686037,
0.3518255650997162,
-0.8728195428848267,
-0.12929360568523407,
-0.01875472068786621,
-0.4093639850616455,
0.20339573919773102,
0.0540599450469017,
-0.6098793148994446,
-0.10125939548015594,
-0.320217102766037,
0.4284812808036804,
-0.40144726634025574,
-0.16925564408302307,
0.15542861819267273,
0.20838816463947296,
0.5128651857376099,
0.4252268075942993,
-0.5107753276824951,
0.7985780835151672,
0.34321358799934387,
0.7338010668754578,
0.10842657089233398,
0.10766823589801788,
-0.6175776124000549,
0.025025488808751106,
-0.2959044873714447,
0.5612490177154541,
-0.694899320602417,
-0.7830600142478943,
0.2744187116622925,
-0.42189186811447144,
-0.009014904499053955,
-1.2857015132904053,
1.0124928951263428,
-0.6090958714485168,
-0.24411624670028687,
-0.07996764779090881,
-0.35656052827835083,
-0.3508467972278595,
-0.010131527669727802,
-0.6276996731758118,
0.7096753120422363,
0.04878084361553192,
-0.21081620454788208,
0.24861449003219604,
-0.5163816213607788,
-0.550835132598877,
0.2165701985359192,
-0.3891882598400116,
-0.7049543261528015,
-0.13215170800685883,
-0.023697135969996452,
-0.09603140503168106,
-0.544622540473938,
-0.10964886844158173,
-0.03128606081008911,
-0.5237287282943726,
0.6475602388381958,
-0.49826541543006897,
0.5795320868492126,
0.4730440676212311,
-0.49946388602256775,
-0.12476396560668945,
-0.9853948950767517,
0.538734495639801,
-0.13531535863876343,
-0.2251891791820526,
0.10519880801439285,
-0.06834787875413895,
0.4197548031806946,
0.11872439086437225,
0.2760753035545349,
-0.5069253444671631,
-0.23112677037715912,
-0.23606489598751068,
0.013145224191248417,
0.24738900363445282,
-0.3041023910045624,
-0.10165271162986755,
-0.40365350246429443,
0.25320082902908325,
0.024594547227025032,
-0.12628673017024994,
0.23686765134334564,
-0.19072063267230988,
-0.9746314883232117,
-0.3869032561779022,
0.7412044405937195,
0.6177067160606384,
-0.18815800547599792,
0.6623573303222656,
-0.2633958160877228,
-0.496328204870224,
-0.6198815107345581,
0.12459870427846909,
0.6501983404159546,
0.24697226285934448,
0.47609180212020874,
-0.9147412180900574,
-0.73949134349823,
-0.9043217897415161,
-0.2296941876411438,
-0.21584239602088928,
-0.02031720243394375,
0.599560022354126,
0.1745002418756485,
-0.35000133514404297,
0.8981025218963623,
0.03702578693628311,
-0.47380244731903076,
-0.002845705719664693,
0.2803070843219757,
0.24785315990447998,
0.3677944839000702,
0.2838829755783081,
-0.7140869498252869,
-0.6731999516487122,
0.00008676925062900409,
-0.39227715134620667,
-0.4841221272945404,
0.3406103551387787,
0.38134753704071045,
0.03981027752161026,
0.3147035241127014,
-0.2613627016544342,
0.6563594341278076,
0.30753713846206665,
-0.4026324450969696,
0.7874152064323425,
0.04120616614818573,
0.3437686264514923,
-0.44359853863716125,
0.24772538244724274,
-0.3112882971763611,
-0.25331735610961914,
-0.8010545969009399,
-0.5085135698318481,
0.04731295257806778,
-0.2494920939207077,
-0.20823457837104797,
0.24319308996200562,
-0.40577781200408936,
-0.4399551749229431,
-0.2997223436832428,
-0.4269723892211914,
-0.3475649058818817,
0.021804694086313248,
0.011166655458509922,
1.1722967624664307,
0.5993790030479431,
-0.4841739237308502,
0.284206360578537,
0.3222545087337494,
-0.4549395442008972,
0.7299410700798035,
-0.8884536027908325,
0.4301575720310211,
0.34788864850997925,
0.0881412997841835,
-0.9560423493385315,
0.1247808188199997,
0.1451132893562317,
-0.565313458442688,
0.17981354892253876,
0.02256755717098713,
-0.3526894748210907,
-0.16856126487255096,
0.16273534297943115,
0.768105685710907,
0.5777033567428589,
-0.21579137444496155,
0.7107733488082886,
0.5391519069671631,
-0.4521770477294922,
-0.40358561277389526,
-0.011968218721449375,
0.24714982509613037,
-0.3162391483783722,
-0.33867350220680237,
0.43966057896614075,
0.15009567141532898,
-0.48163777589797974,
-0.45835092663764954,
-0.4509214758872986,
-0.5379595756530762,
-0.042940378189086914,
0.5266976356506348,
-0.09354172646999359,
-0.36282628774642944,
-0.36143189668655396,
-0.17638763785362244,
-0.18059974908828735,
0.19753947854042053,
-0.22561651468276978,
0.7242842316627502,
-0.20369844138622284,
-0.4540625214576721,
-0.9210744500160217,
0.553176760673523,
0.46917879581451416,
-0.2902050018310547,
0.10819593071937561,
0.510313093662262,
-0.4363848567008972,
0.014530607499182224,
-0.791263222694397,
0.1395944058895111,
-0.4916999340057373,
0.24230416119098663,
-0.8449788093566895,
-0.39123663306236267,
0.588051438331604,
-0.23745211958885193,
-0.16859734058380127,
0.19704988598823547,
0.38337263464927673,
0.06047510355710983,
0.5857083797454834,
0.23675912618637085,
-0.4776552617549896,
0.20076040923595428,
-0.026485994458198547,
-0.054423149675130844,
-0.47557035088539124,
0.016628384590148926,
-0.9334049820899963,
-0.11373760551214218,
-0.2687479555606842,
-0.620083749294281,
0.5359640121459961,
-0.054916832596063614,
-0.6161253452301025,
0.39244982600212097,
-0.043597910553216934,
0.14775893092155457,
0.607200026512146,
-0.012797816656529903,
0.3483016788959503,
-0.06769482791423798,
-0.0746871754527092,
-0.09665918350219727,
-0.19063207507133484,
-0.8791948556900024,
0.8463481068611145,
0.25851431488990784,
0.5267609357833862,
0.4989716410636902,
0.5301862359046936,
0.7968612313270569,
0.056414734572172165,
-0.5534896850585938,
0.4764294922351837,
-0.047534357756376266,
-0.29530027508735657,
-0.2352483719587326,
-0.43403980135917664,
-0.8927359580993652,
0.07905113697052002,
0.2018837332725525,
-0.7384046912193298,
0.1935465931892395,
0.029517509043216705,
-0.6310082674026489,
-0.10071923583745956,
-0.3450019955635071,
0.5310475826263428,
-0.11372016370296478,
-0.08964752405881882,
-0.35560792684555054,
-0.6418946981430054,
-0.36898109316825867,
-0.0021051608491688967,
0.08897491544485092,
-0.3380134701728821,
-0.007579995784908533,
0.7830793857574463,
-0.3327672481536865,
0.6358398795127869,
-0.18297123908996582,
0.050922468304634094,
0.40994012355804443,
0.08682332187891006,
0.04867053031921387,
-0.2964969277381897,
-0.3251303434371948,
0.5796027779579163,
0.057905908674001694,
-0.3751978576183319,
-0.17784607410430908,
0.29589226841926575,
-1.19174325466156,
-0.3225483000278473,
-0.4913722276687622,
-0.4014977216720581,
-0.6010505557060242,
0.06062935292720795,
-0.10339301079511642,
0.7865347862243652,
-0.5727103352546692,
-0.09720046818256378,
0.15660956501960754,
-0.16499513387680054,
0.33022862672805786,
0.848619282245636,
-0.023765649646520615,
-0.6725066304206848,
0.8667492270469666,
0.25374525785446167,
0.07978368550539017,
0.07373276352882385,
-0.21633599698543549,
-0.6708197593688965,
-0.7930741310119629,
-0.6307770013809204,
-0.08815281093120575,
-0.5922265648841858,
-0.2554219663143158,
-0.5083087086677551,
-0.6181392669677734,
-0.3518175780773163,
0.13848744332790375,
-0.4043527841567993,
-0.3500612676143646,
0.01082494668662548,
0.4375922381877899,
0.13455811142921448,
0.5192283391952515,
0.025123322382569313,
0.21032783389091492,
-0.7462021112442017,
0.39799460768699646,
0.479035347700119,
0.3205297291278839,
-0.20217281579971313,
-0.9086716771125793,
-0.28616955876350403,
0.07853920012712479,
-0.5449973940849304,
-0.6529823541641235,
0.46735185384750366,
0.5654501914978027,
0.44773149490356445,
0.3575419783592224,
0.20826603472232819,
0.6578986048698425,
-0.8758595585823059,
0.5225356817245483,
0.1269933432340622,
-1.4074031114578247,
0.36512720584869385,
-0.18997739255428314,
0.33322083950042725,
0.7748638987541199,
0.11971176415681839,
-0.5092187523841858,
-0.12384867668151855,
-0.5359487533569336,
-0.765906810760498,
0.2512968182563782,
0.5391481518745422,
-0.012239665724337101,
0.46230682730674744,
0.002777678659185767,
0.17514444887638092,
0.36888158321380615,
-0.08479205518960953,
-0.48884493112564087,
-0.2917647361755371,
-0.18609948456287384,
-0.028923748061060905,
-0.26671698689460754,
-0.30001625418663025,
-0.2910540997982025,
0.4008200466632843,
0.06160170957446098,
0.46546614170074463,
0.03763842582702637,
-0.16283933818340302,
-0.21598827838897705,
0.43464574217796326,
0.4216110408306122,
0.5770441293716431,
-0.36524686217308044,
0.18432706594467163,
0.4830075204372406,
-0.5373621582984924,
0.36489543318748474,
0.817318320274353,
-0.061956848949193954,
0.3867150843143463,
0.07559243589639664,
0.620280921459198,
-0.010364451445639133,
-0.8727250099182129,
0.2854025363922119,
0.0023890193551778793,
-0.04979896545410156,
-0.8481343388557434,
0.08187493681907654,
-0.35040655732154846,
0.37176549434661865,
0.7836793065071106,
0.09076064079999924,
0.5731610059738159,
-0.5271655321121216,
0.5863564610481262,
0.5154958367347717,
-0.5589025020599365,
-0.22514602541923523,
0.5011496543884277,
0.45653393864631653,
-0.8630194664001465,
0.33625611662864685,
-0.2138386368751526,
-0.6397504210472107,
0.5965366959571838,
0.3759087324142456,
0.847366213798523,
-0.6363789439201355,
-0.007237348705530167,
0.27863237261772156,
-0.33140379190444946,
0.32778215408325195,
0.4753582775592804,
-0.2857930064201355,
-0.8985179662704468,
0.238791823387146,
-0.531056821346283,
-0.8711602091789246,
-0.12397575378417969,
-0.654628574848175,
0.19986802339553833,
-0.5835357904434204,
-0.3736632168292999,
0.2121303677558899,
0.29345452785491943,
-0.4755805730819702,
0.42775294184684753,
0.4100867509841919,
0.7187457084655762,
-0.3916824460029602,
0.895591676235199,
0.624508798122406,
-0.1610889881849289,
-0.4582335352897644,
0.2550637125968933,
0.25588467717170715,
-0.7969299554824829,
0.8691924810409546,
0.506050705909729,
-0.8395402431488037,
0.012632985599339008,
-0.008332779631018639,
-0.5465400218963623,
0.8544366955757141,
0.06672658026218414,
-0.49006369709968567,
0.47096747159957886,
0.5405937433242798,
0.3387370705604553,
-0.3330058753490448,
0.46531161665916443,
0.5665985345840454,
0.2310033142566681,
0.11111830174922943,
-1.6418113708496094,
0.025238879024982452,
-0.5364203453063965,
0.05437924712896347,
0.023059086874127388,
-0.7615544199943542,
0.6370915770530701,
0.028582382947206497,
-0.4867810904979706,
0.5317034125328064,
0.7483524680137634,
0.0794643759727478,
0.5232871174812317,
0.7211690545082092,
0.36652758717536926,
0.5035637617111206,
-0.21648626029491425,
0.43764013051986694,
-0.2565062940120697,
-0.08295153826475143,
0.9645106196403503,
-0.7259070873260498,
0.9744794964790344,
0.1416638046503067,
-0.5838718414306641,
0.44036611914634705,
0.2668627202510834,
0.2808721959590912,
0.6136654615402222,
0.5992511510848999,
-0.8673743009567261,
-0.07504767924547195,
-0.3960358500480652,
-0.6573011875152588,
0.7683154344558716,
0.43162283301353455,
-0.03071039542555809,
-0.1841377317905426,
-0.44148674607276917,
-0.2502387464046478,
0.31938689947128296,
-0.19945256412029266,
0.8512914776802063,
-0.059627994894981384,
-0.1432614028453827,
0.9603292346000671,
-0.031811002641916275,
0.458331435918808,
-0.4705505669116974,
0.010667435824871063,
0.2093171775341034,
0.3911975920200348,
0.03636011853814125,
-0.2984641492366791,
0.5432541370391846,
0.1491367518901825,
0.028189916163682938,
-0.08513768762350082,
0.3669874966144562,
-0.39353159070014954,
-0.3371957838535309,
0.09448571503162384,
0.5600245594978333,
0.2810826301574707,
-0.14509935677051544,
-0.6782793998718262,
0.5015511512756348,
-0.16060355305671692,
0.39117109775543213,
0.055977705866098404,
0.47404661774635315,
0.30692553520202637,
0.6371212601661682,
0.4152432978153229,
0.24337415397167206,
-0.2541341781616211,
0.30487558245658875,
0.6903935670852661,
-0.8446036577224731,
-0.3770972192287445,
-0.6041322946548462,
0.3578701913356781,
-0.19253471493721008,
-0.48464497923851013,
0.5798751711845398,
0.8802990317344666,
0.5287615656852722,
0.08020132035017014,
0.7296106219291687,
-0.04728051647543907,
0.7366769313812256,
-0.19196118414402008,
0.741977334022522,
-0.14294731616973877,
0.19877780973911285,
-0.4536220133304596,
-0.45687827467918396,
-0.28541800379753113,
0.9587488174438477,
-0.30844464898109436,
0.13733963668346405,
0.28771618008613586,
0.8241183757781982,
0.012980282306671143,
0.37751269340515137,
0.45546987652778625,
-0.021728290244936943,
0.1476842612028122,
0.3923945128917694,
1.1493889093399048,
-0.6703366637229919,
0.49267861247062683,
-0.05632171407341957,
-0.08397480845451355,
-0.2888055741786957,
-0.40814876556396484,
-0.6368665099143982,
-0.721005380153656,
-0.46682706475257874,
-0.44543957710266113,
0.5744063854217529,
1.2499151229858398,
0.7472513318061829,
-1.2388383150100708,
-0.9458575248718262,
0.2969963252544403,
-0.40310922265052795,
-0.5583556294441223,
-0.16149847209453583,
0.24190205335617065,
-0.015631861984729767,
-0.7156865000724792,
0.289191871881485,
0.1339682936668396,
0.24617373943328857,
0.2917650640010834,
-0.22696556150913239,
0.227030411362648,
-0.03911532089114189,
0.30034515261650085,
0.49708640575408936,
-0.4813016653060913,
-0.3122611939907074,
-0.25951382517814636,
-0.1304769515991211,
0.21122153103351593,
0.7657535076141357,
-0.7098948359489441,
0.28049835562705994,
-0.2624599039554596,
0.8749669194221497,
0.2829134464263916,
0.15360374748706818,
0.7676532864570618,
-0.4601934850215912,
0.10593588650226593,
0.6442708969116211,
0.3174745440483093,
0.5766319036483765,
0.20661596953868866,
0.38901862502098083,
0.08894020318984985,
-0.4658430814743042,
-0.7341848611831665,
0.37256819009780884,
-1.0067236423492432,
0.4591328799724579,
0.9449931979179382,
-0.26685699820518494,
0.5969498753547668,
-0.8174004554748535,
-0.4523593783378601,
0.3072848916053772,
-0.8080605268478394,
0.9377195835113525,
0.4383341372013092,
-0.35622313618659973,
-0.25333917140960693,
-0.4287235140800476,
0.4130634665489197,
0.4505400061607361,
-0.6857859492301941,
0.023021165281534195,
0.644244909286499,
0.1312602162361145,
0.051816437393426895,
0.5980777740478516,
-0.09803714603185654,
0.4503823220729828,
0.06914588063955307,
-0.05888857692480087,
0.3050917088985443,
-0.06916894763708115,
-0.36713704466819763,
0.3369348645210266,
0.3819304406642914,
-0.4588770270347595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04261v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04261v1
|
Advancing Biomedical Text Mining with Community Challenges
| 2024-03-07T06:52:51 | 2024-03-07T06:52:51 |
Hui Zong, Rongrong Wu, Jiaxue Cha, Erman Wu, Jiakun Li, Liang Tao, Zuofeng Li, Buzhou Tang, Bairong Shen
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The field of biomedical research has witnessed a significant increase in the
accumulation of vast amounts of textual data from various sources such as
scientific literatures, electronic health records, clinical trial reports, and
social media. However, manually processing and analyzing these extensive and
complex resources is time-consuming and inefficient. To address this challenge,
biomedical text mining, also known as biomedical natural language processing,
has garnered great attention. Community challenge evaluation competitions have
played an important role in promoting technology innovation and
interdisciplinary collaboration in biomedical text mining research. These
challenges provide platforms for researchers to develop state-of-the-art
solutions for data mining and information processing in biomedical research. In
this article, we review the recent advances in community challenges specific to
Chinese biomedical text mining. Firstly, we collect the information of these
evaluation tasks, such as data sources and task types. Secondly, we conduct
systematic summary and comparative analysis, including named entity
recognition, entity normalization, attribute extraction, relation extraction,
event extraction, text classification, text similarity, knowledge graph
construction, question answering, text generation, and large language model
evaluation. Then, we summarize the potential clinical applications of these
community challenge tasks from translational informatics perspective. Finally,
we discuss the contributions and limitations of these community challenges,
while highlighting future directions in the era of large language models.
|
[
0.18114350736141205,
-0.7099583745002747,
0.7933129072189331,
-0.01637619361281395,
0.08148900419473648,
0.37823134660720825,
-0.3047041594982147,
-0.7156882286071777,
0.22050638496875763,
0.48569297790527344,
-0.5871946811676025,
-0.5854373574256897,
-0.8669657707214355,
0.5835598111152649,
-0.13340608775615692,
0.9965147972106934,
-0.11785077303647995,
0.15027932822704315,
-0.34227216243743896,
-0.44769564270973206,
-0.4405386745929718,
-0.7001385688781738,
-0.7100982666015625,
-0.4072989523410797,
0.5221880674362183,
0.2572391927242279,
0.266253799200058,
0.5711904168128967,
0.9292315244674683,
0.3754745423793793,
-0.33631405234336853,
0.3813362121582031,
-0.28588756918907166,
0.24831756949424744,
-0.2480342835187912,
-0.3498244285583496,
-0.3568073511123657,
-0.19722259044647217,
0.507093071937561,
1.1023887395858765,
-0.0026061483658850193,
0.13182640075683594,
-0.020269520580768585,
0.7837201952934265,
-0.25401678681373596,
0.14519871771335602,
-0.5489396452903748,
0.0855996236205101,
-0.8019163012504578,
-0.2147744745016098,
-0.07349953800439835,
-0.43251490592956543,
0.3018175959587097,
-0.3632199764251709,
0.616542637348175,
-0.11005605757236481,
0.6763413548469543,
0.2227061688899994,
-0.4092387855052948,
-0.5881850123405457,
-0.38625988364219666,
0.8484115600585938,
-0.6041144132614136,
0.025832653045654297,
0.3057324290275574,
0.21045681834220886,
-0.5847128033638,
-0.6734254360198975,
-0.21152573823928833,
0.04862078279256821,
-0.2009742558002472,
0.015567128546535969,
-0.4408046007156372,
-0.006280752830207348,
0.06655857712030411,
0.5856403112411499,
-0.5614808797836304,
0.17730681598186493,
-0.6712102293968201,
-0.2668512761592865,
0.5771432518959045,
0.4953896403312683,
0.27747249603271484,
-0.5487807989120483,
-0.09093595296144485,
0.11308418214321136,
-0.5106242299079895,
-0.03290214017033577,
-0.3830122649669647,
0.15114626288414001,
0.23049649596214294,
0.23723310232162476,
-0.26013484597206116,
0.4477714002132416,
-0.24184590578079224,
0.008897917345166206,
0.5097116827964783,
-0.5957314372062683,
0.061837710440158844,
-0.17717915773391724,
0.8469023704528809,
0.19019313156604767,
-0.3265858590602875,
-0.11558429151773453,
0.07053550332784653,
-0.21922820806503296,
-0.0031717976089566946,
-0.5314826965332031,
-0.13775983452796936,
0.4801500737667084,
-1.0170118808746338,
-0.33335667848587036,
-0.20103590190410614,
-0.9256426692008972,
-0.6470617055892944,
0.13025739789009094,
0.017279092222452164,
-0.36787286400794983,
-0.3602431118488312,
0.26732146739959717,
-0.4094937741756439,
0.1185884028673172,
0.4795379042625427,
-0.7461540102958679,
0.3350726068019867,
0.7627598643302917,
1.1784886121749878,
-0.34073927998542786,
0.13264286518096924,
-0.5192452669143677,
0.1748269647359848,
0.1809336245059967,
0.9046133756637573,
-0.5460659265518188,
-0.3610037863254547,
-0.2047273963689804,
0.072308249771595,
-0.25788432359695435,
-0.9159411191940308,
0.5062257051467896,
-0.02812539041042328,
-0.16437336802482605,
-0.48379677534103394,
-0.45512545108795166,
0.24045208096504211,
0.34524771571159363,
-0.7884590029716492,
0.9389563798904419,
0.20669302344322205,
-0.784453809261322,
0.21722500026226044,
-0.7510382533073425,
-0.6124186515808105,
0.45390960574150085,
-0.2263011634349823,
-0.3381611108779907,
0.07933754473924637,
0.2774614989757538,
0.4278874397277832,
-0.5292428731918335,
0.23334935307502747,
-0.3420965373516083,
-0.010142357088625431,
0.271076500415802,
0.17086568474769592,
0.8133366107940674,
0.2752611041069031,
-0.19778090715408325,
0.0572325773537159,
-0.44891977310180664,
-0.22826752066612244,
0.026995845139026642,
-0.18786108493804932,
-0.4841328561306,
0.42810213565826416,
0.24233436584472656,
0.06901993602514267,
0.21348178386688232,
-0.7189220786094666,
0.233041450381279,
-0.5252590775489807,
0.7915313243865967,
0.5941783785820007,
0.2261284738779068,
0.10938199609518051,
-0.25894448161125183,
0.3198518753051758,
-0.09618033468723297,
0.23950247466564178,
-0.20566044747829437,
-0.9129591584205627,
-0.16843342781066895,
-0.038651466369628906,
0.4835456311702728,
0.605560302734375,
-0.9013907313346863,
0.48803192377090454,
-0.2791264057159424,
-0.6961613297462463,
-0.9744963645935059,
0.09494983404874802,
0.08032902330160141,
0.47629907727241516,
0.5844523906707764,
-0.3763101398944855,
-0.3945791721343994,
-0.7819153070449829,
-0.17186081409454346,
-0.10215166956186295,
-0.10835275799036026,
0.22235539555549622,
0.48252978920936584,
-0.33958005905151367,
0.8342704772949219,
-0.747908890247345,
-0.5617143511772156,
-0.4362010061740875,
0.4135436415672302,
0.3136155605316162,
0.5688762664794922,
0.25824835896492004,
-0.9082544445991516,
-0.35234150290489197,
0.6288106441497803,
-0.7744574546813965,
-0.43780362606048584,
0.1227807030081749,
0.24210059642791748,
0.03360537439584732,
0.4887790083885193,
-0.29595422744750977,
0.5047923922538757,
0.3808136284351349,
-0.22901269793510437,
0.35637328028678894,
-0.2011498063802719,
0.38363298773765564,
-0.7613056898117065,
0.259991854429245,
0.03812992200255394,
-0.32500842213630676,
-0.6564034819602966,
0.10805979371070862,
-0.2934545874595642,
0.0305685605853796,
0.2578403651714325,
0.5535406470298767,
-0.2776808738708496,
0.2683040499687195,
-0.5259488224983215,
0.019387440755963326,
-0.12021636962890625,
-0.13187476992607117,
0.2522032558917999,
-0.027837567031383514,
0.13913457095623016,
-0.48882824182510376,
0.5267578363418579,
0.3857481777667999,
-0.33140990138053894,
0.14584219455718994,
-0.6180170774459839,
0.030866794288158417,
-0.1637084037065506,
0.3464784026145935,
-0.7021223902702332,
-0.2016773521900177,
0.17996132373809814,
-0.775108814239502,
-0.0772319957613945,
0.24754251539707184,
-0.7080230116844177,
-0.562045156955719,
-0.3387293219566345,
0.31507381796836853,
0.41819024085998535,
-0.2097751945257187,
0.13741406798362732,
0.562976598739624,
-0.4255981147289276,
-0.3673875033855438,
-0.6084800958633423,
0.15487825870513916,
0.026060570031404495,
-0.5111299753189087,
0.4875418245792389,
-0.10280299186706543,
-0.2016625851392746,
0.2832646071910858,
0.1566675752401352,
-0.3383536636829376,
0.2139650136232376,
-0.02932262048125267,
0.22423669695854187,
0.005127738695591688,
0.3097069263458252,
0.2452840358018875,
-0.18369896709918976,
0.12304216623306274,
0.10904031246900558,
0.21939849853515625,
0.05465337261557579,
-0.16809338331222534,
-0.02635451778769493,
0.5238177180290222,
-0.05536181107163429,
-0.3589302897453308,
0.6034882068634033,
0.5411174893379211,
-0.8070566654205322,
0.20374518632888794,
-0.6078906059265137,
-0.09638805687427521,
-0.42829272150993347,
0.6399688720703125,
0.2655187249183655,
-1.243191123008728,
0.3468942940235138,
-0.3550126850605011,
0.22166049480438232,
0.5224499106407166,
0.785755455493927,
0.014009421691298485,
0.7541403770446777,
0.4111805856227875,
-0.2863091826438904,
-0.09757150709629059,
0.4329317808151245,
0.05680304393172264,
-0.4200413227081299,
-0.1886066496372223,
-0.8483178019523621,
-0.35964009165763855,
-0.5340108871459961,
-0.609346330165863,
0.6861510872840881,
-0.26226186752319336,
0.18206624686717987,
0.40061280131340027,
-0.5273687243461609,
0.3033648133277893,
0.35700735449790955,
0.5101550817489624,
0.628277599811554,
-0.1805771291255951,
0.32270124554634094,
-0.2177104949951172,
-0.7743803858757019,
-0.35500064492225647,
0.9806897640228271,
0.4142940044403076,
0.1033836230635643,
-0.08929940313100815,
0.6962672472000122,
0.2572064995765686,
0.6851584911346436,
-0.5646094083786011,
0.2306353747844696,
-0.4712406098842621,
-0.9425508379936218,
-0.22923752665519714,
-0.7076522707939148,
-1.3050051927566528,
-0.0922037810087204,
-0.5761361122131348,
-0.7514616250991821,
0.14630185067653656,
-0.2369193583726883,
-0.4485219120979309,
0.4182353615760803,
-0.22443988919258118,
0.7845380306243896,
0.05325891450047493,
-0.08391343802213669,
-0.18641090393066406,
-0.7384966611862183,
0.23850853741168976,
-0.2725229263305664,
0.6335973739624023,
0.05571556091308594,
0.22872523963451385,
0.6420631408691406,
-0.33719775080680847,
0.5826553106307983,
-0.02232147753238678,
0.3143543004989624,
0.19943124055862427,
-0.33974727988243103,
-0.027417203411459923,
0.04393373057246208,
-0.2223583310842514,
0.2786449193954468,
0.46311041712760925,
-0.5743314623832703,
-0.18410877883434296,
0.3897407352924347,
-0.3127625286579132,
-0.4754590094089508,
-0.437649667263031,
-0.12197796255350113,
-0.08136791735887527,
0.13279768824577332,
0.3932436406612396,
0.3742859661579132,
-0.31955718994140625,
0.12039699405431747,
0.7469406723976135,
-0.738001823425293,
0.18695534765720367,
0.314083993434906,
-0.14669832587242126,
-0.4348207414150238,
1.005041241645813,
-0.09991781413555145,
0.14153437316417694,
0.6046549677848816,
0.2004767656326294,
0.10810192674398422,
-0.9331446886062622,
-0.3043507933616638,
0.21130186319351196,
-0.5065982937812805,
-0.3262600600719452,
-0.5647521615028381,
-0.1547223925590515,
-0.6415156126022339,
0.004581457003951073,
-0.19851690530776978,
-0.006181132514029741,
-0.11465567350387573,
0.03419400751590729,
0.15290363132953644,
0.987775444984436,
-0.1431131362915039,
0.0015887052286416292,
-1.4770280122756958,
0.35127973556518555,
-0.20836974680423737,
0.3322699964046478,
0.10010704398155212,
0.17522390186786652,
-0.56048983335495,
-0.426719069480896,
-0.3193984925746918,
-1.073449730873108,
0.34140250086784363,
-0.11679713428020477,
0.5411825776100159,
0.24869930744171143,
-0.02729521319270134,
0.489462673664093,
-0.4297999441623688,
0.6109471917152405,
0.019080130383372307,
-0.7492252588272095,
0.6722745895385742,
-0.3107590675354004,
0.1473054736852646,
0.9541258811950684,
0.22847624123096466,
-0.9148234724998474,
-0.37046578526496887,
-0.47123846411705017,
-0.8805039525032043,
0.43665897846221924,
0.5107321739196777,
-0.3097444772720337,
-0.26101982593536377,
0.7076125144958496,
0.2651008367538452,
-0.0075479536317288876,
-0.7899713516235352,
-0.30625203251838684,
0.23709097504615784,
-0.30303189158439636,
0.27442505955696106,
0.24999143183231354,
0.11338259279727936,
-0.3156285881996155,
0.47181177139282227,
-0.07186678797006607,
0.1182747557759285,
0.738735020160675,
-0.05939942225813866,
-0.1887471079826355,
0.2788386344909668,
0.006159508600831032,
0.10036836564540863,
-0.24861976504325867,
-0.3677220642566681,
0.2474377304315567,
-0.48047304153442383,
-0.210471972823143,
0.2204618901014328,
-0.09439161419868469,
0.17878614366054535,
0.8011459708213806,
0.25487521290779114,
0.2439897656440735,
-1.0080550909042358,
0.5547993779182434,
-0.020336030051112175,
-0.37332841753959656,
-0.1769542545080185,
-0.21892675757408142,
0.042247310280799866,
0.1885758489370346,
0.48503684997558594,
-0.037045352160930634,
0.7029242515563965,
-0.45875871181488037,
0.03312244638800621,
0.34078243374824524,
-0.6785476803779602,
-0.1684643030166626,
0.5855825543403625,
0.25940224528312683,
0.08954644203186035,
0.5950905084609985,
-0.12394203245639801,
-0.4685417115688324,
0.8210241198539734,
0.1929890662431717,
0.7624171376228333,
-0.1630241572856903,
0.038449726998806,
0.5067375898361206,
0.39455610513687134,
-0.09464000910520554,
-0.06842432916164398,
0.2100316882133484,
-0.5587336421012878,
-0.5725224018096924,
-0.6395506858825684,
-0.6122336983680725,
0.12267876416444778,
-0.48307475447654724,
0.42098769545555115,
-0.2328532487154007,
-0.03307202830910683,
0.20672479271888733,
0.03875786438584328,
-0.33676087856292725,
0.0465841107070446,
0.41422510147094727,
0.9193881154060364,
-0.44966286420822144,
0.8202721476554871,
0.8117374181747437,
0.03574073687195778,
-0.19927246868610382,
-0.36789003014564514,
0.15323211252689362,
-0.24478857219219208,
0.4617578685283661,
0.37914904952049255,
0.42115703225135803,
-0.3713063895702362,
-0.5253989696502686,
-0.46720248460769653,
1.1366031169891357,
-0.2263050526380539,
-0.4376692473888397,
-0.1619405895471573,
0.2089322954416275,
0.803207516670227,
-0.20142389833927155,
0.20860880613327026,
0.7893335819244385,
0.686976969242096,
0.00356177962385118,
-1.142275333404541,
0.15782591700553894,
-0.6244979500770569,
-0.3430967628955841,
0.18583235144615173,
-0.6946645975112915,
0.8427270650863647,
0.17975136637687683,
-0.24015824496746063,
0.4250571131706238,
0.5337762832641602,
0.48725831508636475,
0.7709749341011047,
0.4586677551269531,
0.3040345311164856,
0.9300431609153748,
-0.03227716684341431,
0.88772052526474,
0.28953468799591064,
0.44545778632164,
0.5368181467056274,
-0.5539684295654297,
0.5454333424568176,
0.0910344123840332,
-0.4537425637245178,
0.4891219139099121,
0.7443503737449646,
-0.15272971987724304,
0.14109495282173157,
0.1538735330104828,
-0.5083274245262146,
-0.35220062732696533,
-0.21784824132919312,
-0.4480505585670471,
0.27554187178611755,
0.6187032461166382,
-0.28325074911117554,
-0.4193934500217438,
0.13788141310214996,
-0.16188602149486542,
0.4740035831928253,
-0.5882088541984558,
0.7551011443138123,
0.1527649313211441,
-0.3903115689754486,
-0.07177432626485825,
0.3589283227920532,
0.6790445446968079,
-0.6588671803474426,
-0.2605627179145813,
0.04344874620437622,
0.10307949036359787,
-0.42325231432914734,
-0.4219091236591339,
0.5276769399642944,
0.12658527493476868,
-0.35407954454421997,
0.024708697572350502,
1.076904058456421,
-0.18614521622657776,
-0.4878058135509491,
0.3794015347957611,
0.39498481154441833,
0.22682170569896698,
-0.20381082594394684,
-0.7483901977539062,
-0.19892586767673492,
0.018120961263775826,
-0.14545558393001556,
0.3683352768421173,
0.5905060172080994,
-0.1731037199497223,
0.5069676637649536,
0.5896284580230713,
0.30861201882362366,
-0.2507272958755493,
-0.23540866374969482,
0.8495485782623291,
-1.112410068511963,
-0.16019167006015778,
-1.0515944957733154,
-0.06583230942487717,
-0.2898790240287781,
-0.19600050151348114,
0.2625429034233093,
0.5226699709892273,
0.30913206934928894,
0.16346190869808197,
1.234102725982666,
-0.32897812128067017,
1.1044434309005737,
-0.4305236339569092,
0.9750688076019287,
-0.3801642060279846,
0.15870580077171326,
-0.4641343653202057,
-0.30500084161758423,
-0.5171852111816406,
0.19964875280857086,
-0.23516316711902618,
-0.2163781225681305,
0.9284602999687195,
0.2218475043773651,
0.4670889973640442,
0.21289999783039093,
-0.185385599732399,
0.166336327791214,
0.5446015000343323,
1.0847686529159546,
0.3309426009654999,
-0.4934763014316559,
0.4699993431568146,
-0.1494748741388321,
-0.5616763830184937,
0.06478603184223175,
-0.690003514289856,
-0.8819750547409058,
-0.7296904921531677,
-0.25518113374710083,
-0.39892539381980896,
-0.12371977418661118,
1.1477755308151245,
0.3617754876613617,
-0.980503261089325,
-0.19800260663032532,
0.05812583491206169,
0.25393545627593994,
-0.33289071917533875,
-0.23986871540546417,
0.311959445476532,
-0.2813281714916229,
-0.7972325086593628,
0.35770732164382935,
0.5309603810310364,
-0.4025996923446655,
0.043950557708740234,
0.20962102711200714,
-0.3436588943004608,
-0.3040798604488373,
0.44857341051101685,
0.42836910486221313,
-0.20842505991458893,
0.06156652048230171,
0.1372499316930771,
-0.22186657786369324,
0.14838942885398865,
0.8682324290275574,
-0.8306925296783447,
0.3493157923221588,
0.3579200208187103,
0.9489814639091492,
0.48009565472602844,
-0.1275809407234192,
0.6323105692863464,
-0.38402026891708374,
-0.25891992449760437,
0.3076094388961792,
0.18809817731380463,
0.4063606560230255,
-0.49305444955825806,
0.7017672657966614,
0.6664819717407227,
-0.6371567845344543,
-0.6156465411186218,
0.05583503097295761,
-0.9710196256637573,
-0.6052188873291016,
0.7736298441886902,
-0.12416081130504608,
-0.4319602847099304,
-0.6809780597686768,
-0.20257613062858582,
0.22649741172790527,
-0.06957240402698517,
0.9483183026313782,
1.0227712392807007,
-0.25740769505500793,
0.13588352501392365,
-0.7682616710662842,
0.519226610660553,
0.30852603912353516,
-1.0361063480377197,
0.1969601809978485,
0.13717079162597656,
0.023856541141867638,
0.002125139581039548,
1.1597678661346436,
-0.5827256441116333,
0.3435969650745392,
-0.5503713488578796,
0.0285138301551342,
0.299017071723938,
0.35334375500679016,
-0.4346809685230255,
0.23546691238880157,
-0.049781668931245804,
0.6113404035568237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04260v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04260v2
|
Can Small Language Models be Good Reasoners for Sequential Recommendation?
| 2024-03-07T06:49:37 | 2024-03-28T11:55:32 |
Yuling Wang, Changxin Tian, Binbin Hu, Yanhua Yu, Ziqi Liu, Zhiqiang Zhang, Jun Zhou, Liang Pang, Xiao Wang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) open up new horizons for sequential
recommendations, owing to their remarkable language comprehension and
generation capabilities. However, there are still numerous challenges that
should be addressed to successfully implement sequential recommendations
empowered by LLMs. Firstly, user behavior patterns are often complex, and
relying solely on one-step reasoning from LLMs may lead to incorrect or
task-irrelevant responses. Secondly, the prohibitively resource requirements of
LLM (e.g., ChatGPT-175B) are overwhelmingly high and impractical for real
sequential recommender systems. In this paper, we propose a novel Step-by-step
knowLedge dIstillation fraMework for recommendation (SLIM), paving a promising
path for sequential recommenders to enjoy the exceptional reasoning
capabilities of LLMs in a "slim" (i.e., resource-efficient) manner. We
introduce CoT prompting based on user behavior sequences for the larger teacher
model. The rationales generated by the teacher model are then utilized as
labels to distill the downstream smaller student model (e.g., LLaMA2-7B). In
this way, the student model acquires the step-by-step reasoning capabilities in
recommendation tasks. We encode the generated rationales from the student model
into a dense vector, which empowers recommendation in both ID-based and
ID-agnostic scenarios. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of
SLIM over state-of-the-art baselines, and further analysis showcasing its
ability to generate meaningful recommendation reasoning at affordable costs.
|
[
-0.3006209135055542,
-0.5010999441146851,
1.1948944330215454,
0.10469883680343628,
-0.3594568371772766,
-0.005923218093812466,
-0.3236653208732605,
0.04317767918109894,
-0.016874050721526146,
0.45765385031700134,
-0.8231067657470703,
-0.40028566122055054,
-0.31387972831726074,
0.0046326289884746075,
-0.4963817000389099,
1.0621459484100342,
0.01730613224208355,
0.21527351438999176,
-0.17010273039340973,
0.1290096938610077,
-0.9531780481338501,
-0.17739006876945496,
-0.7958487868309021,
-0.5597083568572998,
0.797461211681366,
0.8648476600646973,
0.6199195981025696,
0.35971876978874207,
0.09271194040775299,
0.39251166582107544,
-0.03938981890678406,
0.2600190341472626,
-0.6538727283477783,
0.3378434479236603,
-0.48024463653564453,
-0.5215063691139221,
-0.111513152718544,
-0.142284095287323,
0.23445722460746765,
0.7337554693222046,
-0.4036489427089691,
0.0696394145488739,
0.14066968858242035,
0.924994170665741,
-0.3946569561958313,
-0.2500112056732178,
-0.6276136636734009,
-0.11923270672559738,
-0.14740511775016785,
0.07952699810266495,
-0.6117135286331177,
-0.3754664361476898,
0.40976113080978394,
-0.4830772876739502,
0.09673413634300232,
0.5633449554443359,
0.34892457723617554,
0.2566106915473938,
-0.36603137850761414,
-0.4706651270389557,
-0.8162240982055664,
0.7169269323348999,
-0.6337198615074158,
0.2928079068660736,
0.4674621522426605,
0.48115578293800354,
-0.33519336581230164,
-0.8890604972839355,
-0.6853955388069153,
-0.15923166275024414,
-0.23169513046741486,
-0.33806222677230835,
0.12576736509799957,
-0.1883162260055542,
0.329475998878479,
0.39339396357536316,
-0.43072494864463806,
0.11692775785923004,
-0.43135231733322144,
-0.0249425508081913,
0.3974853456020355,
0.310251921415329,
0.14168107509613037,
-0.032639775425195694,
-0.4231676757335663,
0.05820801109075546,
-0.5246882438659668,
-0.08351516723632812,
0.34004998207092285,
0.2446531355381012,
-0.2168993502855301,
0.5939196348190308,
-0.14193546772003174,
0.5943166613578796,
0.5666742920875549,
-0.3567410111427307,
-0.13858366012573242,
-0.47977185249328613,
-0.1313871592283249,
0.13983580470085144,
0.8805376291275024,
0.18942943215370178,
0.5891888737678528,
0.0788574367761612,
-0.2379884570837021,
-0.29033899307250977,
0.018590910360217094,
-1.0779919624328613,
-0.5113539695739746,
0.34095051884651184,
-0.4158206582069397,
-0.15487705171108246,
0.02729012258350849,
-0.6224900484085083,
-0.774859607219696,
-0.44465693831443787,
0.1989128440618515,
-0.6653818488121033,
-0.02306218445301056,
0.184642493724823,
-0.07022397220134735,
-0.12458039820194244,
0.5436115860939026,
-1.0367070436477661,
0.3494947850704193,
0.5436551570892334,
0.9608355760574341,
-0.1272238790988922,
-0.1820921152830124,
-0.39199110865592957,
0.10426196455955505,
-0.0920543223619461,
0.6989673376083374,
-0.5611950159072876,
-0.6077709794044495,
-0.27142414450645447,
-0.11751546710729599,
0.142441064119339,
-0.5530086159706116,
0.5185777544975281,
-0.3284485638141632,
0.1691465675830841,
-0.4019573926925659,
-0.5467143058776855,
-0.05004674568772316,
0.07892651110887527,
-0.41233062744140625,
0.8396766781806946,
-0.08159642666578293,
-0.47927433252334595,
0.49808764457702637,
-0.1596130132675171,
-0.3756249248981476,
0.18129085004329681,
-0.1799781769514084,
0.0059718056581914425,
0.11713797599077225,
0.33777356147766113,
0.4271266460418701,
-0.5857645869255066,
0.46034494042396545,
-0.3659140169620514,
-0.48499080538749695,
0.12077552080154419,
-0.4162937104701996,
0.5390510559082031,
0.36607426404953003,
0.07543822377920151,
0.2900519073009491,
-0.6064460873603821,
-0.09861306846141815,
0.21505586802959442,
-0.11049053072929382,
-0.5287579894065857,
0.09324456751346588,
-0.282576322555542,
0.10058191418647766,
0.35316717624664307,
-0.1902778297662735,
0.3722318410873413,
-0.2686975300312042,
0.5633462071418762,
0.9782588481903076,
0.08736790716648102,
0.7444314360618591,
-0.4167459309101105,
0.37547188997268677,
0.12218964844942093,
-0.11369682848453522,
-0.5952074527740479,
-0.5020920038223267,
-0.6151555180549622,
-0.525823712348938,
0.2883441150188446,
0.43311211466789246,
-0.7353512048721313,
0.424233615398407,
0.04344244301319122,
-0.38419774174690247,
-0.2415783703327179,
0.3990422487258911,
0.08558273315429688,
0.363724946975708,
0.13783282041549683,
-0.061846956610679626,
-0.5537581443786621,
-0.524825930595398,
0.006462268065661192,
-0.28502893447875977,
0.00397084653377533,
0.41375237703323364,
0.35923564434051514,
-0.2256324738264084,
0.8894726634025574,
-0.6699250340461731,
-0.303276002407074,
-0.4281855523586273,
-0.2685719132423401,
0.6110390424728394,
0.22355429828166962,
0.47142377495765686,
-0.5859975218772888,
-0.568304717540741,
-0.32450082898139954,
-0.39859217405319214,
-0.16199083626270294,
-0.19537663459777832,
-0.3100743889808655,
-0.33722615242004395,
0.33691927790641785,
-0.5313311219215393,
0.1084534078836441,
0.19325104355812073,
-0.5324262976646423,
0.491192489862442,
-0.3722080588340759,
-0.06819711625576019,
-0.9416586756706238,
-0.2157234102487564,
0.12128432840108871,
-0.44972506165504456,
-0.20388177037239075,
-0.3170202970504761,
-0.24573971331119537,
-0.09507236629724503,
-0.2606288194656372,
0.7833933234214783,
-0.17587792873382568,
0.3218802809715271,
-0.4045293927192688,
0.24693436920642853,
0.013455364853143692,
0.5445394515991211,
-0.15580567717552185,
0.4458675682544708,
0.4225784242153168,
-0.5969951152801514,
0.33761152625083923,
0.24203284084796906,
-0.45684102177619934,
0.6893724799156189,
-0.83378666639328,
0.04442852735519409,
-0.07418060302734375,
0.5325177311897278,
-1.1733781099319458,
-0.02479204721748829,
0.18654091656208038,
0.21994395554065704,
0.04008582606911659,
-0.42872199416160583,
-0.5383073687553406,
-0.5665513277053833,
-0.20669721066951752,
0.5245025157928467,
0.7881917357444763,
-0.7526359558105469,
0.47908255457878113,
0.12685813009738922,
-0.24532249569892883,
-0.30628496408462524,
-0.28891250491142273,
-0.23096027970314026,
-0.1931159347295761,
-0.5234559178352356,
0.17999118566513062,
-0.3756447434425354,
-0.3595339059829712,
-0.11414943635463715,
-0.33228224515914917,
0.16693656146526337,
0.007305399980396032,
0.46084174513816833,
0.46210870146751404,
-0.01294329110532999,
0.037441935390233994,
0.014748302288353443,
-0.14299283921718597,
-0.11785077303647995,
-0.8907004594802856,
0.4441949427127838,
0.02594030648469925,
-0.24539756774902344,
-0.3333592712879181,
0.07352502644062042,
0.6059960126876831,
0.12869982421398163,
0.6021344065666199,
0.5969196557998657,
-0.16100411117076874,
-0.7435604333877563,
-0.6451247334480286,
-0.5738478302955627,
-0.5519005060195923,
0.06906614452600479,
-0.3664293587207794,
-0.9261448383331299,
0.2843543291091919,
-0.3088427782058716,
-0.004070061258971691,
0.0528845451772213,
0.8916517496109009,
-0.09022217988967896,
0.9289904236793518,
0.4328252673149109,
0.03888142481446266,
0.5366270542144775,
-0.20704609155654907,
0.3741374909877777,
-0.47317132353782654,
-0.311851441860199,
-0.2726353704929352,
-0.4461238384246826,
-0.35187578201293945,
-0.3397710621356964,
0.1764877587556839,
0.3155999779701233,
-0.31131014227867126,
0.03309083729982376,
-0.4854555130004883,
0.74009770154953,
0.6275352239608765,
0.1164407953619957,
0.320573091506958,
-0.19802738726139069,
-0.6414993405342102,
0.11374281346797943,
-0.7310629487037659,
-0.5853137969970703,
0.7706315517425537,
0.2648744583129883,
0.9793962836265564,
0.12142784148454666,
0.734537661075592,
0.39787453413009644,
0.02506367675960064,
-1.02435302734375,
0.7642377018928528,
-0.43677157163619995,
-0.42913657426834106,
-0.2121233344078064,
-0.2826296091079712,
-0.5644492506980896,
0.41272416710853577,
-0.10470961034297943,
-0.9033693671226501,
0.3217897415161133,
0.2461206167936325,
-0.6278699040412903,
0.07469076663255692,
-0.886059582233429,
0.7754180431365967,
-0.2546521723270416,
-0.6226352453231812,
-0.24577124416828156,
-0.4675649404525757,
0.6182456016540527,
-0.24806299805641174,
0.25085702538490295,
-0.5219489336013794,
0.09598829597234726,
0.6895086765289307,
-1.108883261680603,
0.8119779825210571,
-0.319525808095932,
-0.08812129497528076,
0.520995020866394,
0.29008758068084717,
0.6957919001579285,
0.42744338512420654,
-0.19855572283267975,
-0.10859623551368713,
0.26341208815574646,
0.0962752252817154,
-0.606293797492981,
0.9647452235221863,
-0.5290104746818542,
-0.9677888751029968,
-0.3690352439880371,
-0.35380327701568604,
-0.2533988654613495,
0.4160957932472229,
-0.0674208402633667,
0.2681255638599396,
0.22940722107887268,
0.05731698498129845,
0.5602817535400391,
0.0762048065662384,
0.25423213839530945,
0.7044273018836975,
-0.5339534282684326,
-0.3661871552467346,
0.954645037651062,
-0.15901702642440796,
-0.0810975432395935,
0.21407942473888397,
0.6250433325767517,
-0.47276437282562256,
-0.6117601990699768,
-0.4226601719856262,
0.35698747634887695,
-0.6082043051719666,
-0.036094460636377335,
-0.4968053996562958,
0.14519885182380676,
-0.05558735504746437,
-0.21965809166431427,
-0.128851518034935,
-0.36989063024520874,
-0.21926027536392212,
-0.08974821865558624,
0.4544120728969574,
0.8523819446563721,
0.1021377295255661,
0.42165878415107727,
-0.44541195034980774,
0.5217445492744446,
0.4090213477611542,
0.34281793236732483,
0.15719428658485413,
-0.6206235289573669,
-0.2732129991054535,
-0.12378231436014175,
-0.26949283480644226,
-0.609535813331604,
0.2799087464809418,
0.014548629522323608,
0.35231587290763855,
0.6291652917861938,
0.3177357316017151,
0.7120419144630432,
-0.9377216100692749,
0.7277564406394958,
0.2251593917608261,
-0.6607276797294617,
0.6045674085617065,
-0.22859817743301392,
0.4548133611679077,
0.7464585304260254,
0.4418486952781677,
-0.18904748558998108,
-0.27260932326316833,
-0.22063201665878296,
-0.9354060888290405,
0.9071616530418396,
-0.11883701384067535,
-0.06647787243127823,
-0.0010522942757233977,
0.39453479647636414,
0.39977964758872986,
0.183426171541214,
-0.2425605207681656,
-0.3469507396221161,
-0.07341556251049042,
-0.3674629032611847,
-0.1407775729894638,
-0.5112736821174622,
0.07387597113847733,
-0.16606228053569794,
0.7361451983451843,
-0.16924205422401428,
-0.36470258235931396,
-0.0357452929019928,
0.08427467197179794,
0.00665835989639163,
0.3136649429798126,
0.32063668966293335,
0.4875229597091675,
-0.2455667108297348,
-0.09716431051492691,
0.05796068534255028,
-0.330420583486557,
0.42370134592056274,
0.04418541491031647,
-0.1806204915046692,
-0.20791922509670258,
-0.15032537281513214,
0.7261450290679932,
0.45294132828712463,
-0.6427135467529297,
0.4303991496562958,
-0.27212944626808167,
0.0069733550772070885,
-0.37241819500923157,
0.22569717466831207,
0.09578058868646622,
0.27201515436172485,
0.2453194409608841,
0.18387813866138458,
0.169001966714859,
-0.6484752893447876,
0.07886374741792679,
0.19071096181869507,
-0.2168353945016861,
-0.1482214331626892,
0.6353887319564819,
0.5282917022705078,
-0.09816516935825348,
0.7077017426490784,
-0.04357001185417175,
-0.16268208622932434,
0.23988176882266998,
0.47606244683265686,
0.8010737895965576,
0.17793139815330505,
0.18195794522762299,
0.4296804368495941,
-0.08485894650220871,
-0.6232572197914124,
0.09558885544538498,
-0.4801040589809418,
-0.7388474941253662,
-0.19326826930046082,
-0.7366430759429932,
-0.4248051643371582,
-0.18350839614868164,
-0.38423630595207214,
0.6593095064163208,
-0.7780193090438843,
-0.2201211303472519,
0.14478614926338196,
-0.07738549262285233,
-0.6593949198722839,
0.013671212829649448,
0.3789551258087158,
0.9518355131149292,
-0.3819030523300171,
0.8903990387916565,
0.6133182048797607,
-0.37036392092704773,
-0.9009787440299988,
-0.032052669674158096,
0.3227412700653076,
-0.65007084608078,
0.6394509077072144,
0.09402276575565338,
-0.2265990525484085,
-0.009456231258809566,
-0.3137345612049103,
-0.5477650165557861,
1.2046394348144531,
0.4947783350944519,
-1.1265852451324463,
-0.20724652707576752,
-0.34093594551086426,
0.3920002579689026,
-0.3801075220108032,
0.41196033358573914,
0.47221317887306213,
0.41999727487564087,
0.69162517786026,
-0.7470138072967529,
0.33913591504096985,
0.027637826278805733,
0.09586768597364426,
0.07388876378536224,
-0.6446728110313416,
0.6872629523277283,
-0.9594622254371643,
-0.29486921429634094,
0.37025579810142517,
0.6353583335876465,
0.7128920555114746,
0.34978583455085754,
0.7260473966598511,
0.3040268123149872,
0.9924365282058716,
-0.012751935049891472,
1.0614053010940552,
-0.2880341112613678,
-0.05196143314242363,
1.5350348949432373,
-0.6650123596191406,
0.6922109723091125,
0.5007550716400146,
-0.2948532998561859,
1.0231082439422607,
0.673154354095459,
-0.02503856085240841,
0.5984339714050293,
0.33859705924987793,
-0.15564553439617157,
-0.42866063117980957,
-0.13688288629055023,
-0.046875230967998505,
0.12798599898815155,
0.3859863877296448,
-0.3010403513908386,
0.0562325157225132,
0.046085480600595474,
-0.1155918762087822,
0.1297188699245453,
-0.3540581464767456,
0.9063030481338501,
0.4532516896724701,
-0.8106032013893127,
0.27577975392341614,
0.1118752509355545,
0.7140332460403442,
-0.8586795926094055,
-0.09004750102758408,
-0.15500366687774658,
0.4013928472995758,
-0.263107568025589,
-0.6793492436408997,
-0.213359072804451,
0.020198440179228783,
-0.5687961578369141,
-0.4678669273853302,
0.6500135660171509,
-0.5250807404518127,
-0.5650714635848999,
-0.034893665462732315,
0.5882772207260132,
0.07694493979215622,
0.31157854199409485,
-0.5096510052680969,
-0.10551518201828003,
0.02471320331096649,
-0.004686305765062571,
0.22769209742546082,
0.6220664381980896,
-0.13545072078704834,
0.8915238380432129,
0.6774771213531494,
0.20291674137115479,
-0.27248668670654297,
0.4060901701450348,
0.648944079875946,
-0.5990057587623596,
-0.8082556128501892,
-1.0016860961914062,
0.5017287731170654,
0.14353854954242706,
0.002413655398413539,
0.8162083625793457,
0.22450345754623413,
0.7469123601913452,
-0.009844329208135605,
0.6962689757347107,
-0.11256016790866852,
0.2903394401073456,
-0.5324723124504089,
0.4646551311016083,
-0.36381036043167114,
0.9859306216239929,
0.074573814868927,
-0.8046772480010986,
0.2291162759065628,
0.3692872226238251,
-0.5150376558303833,
0.4330698549747467,
0.815096378326416,
0.6068980693817139,
0.09507472068071365,
0.22762522101402283,
0.33283698558807373,
0.3960306942462921,
0.17070049047470093,
0.5455842614173889,
0.9079942107200623,
-0.020028628408908844,
0.4551764726638794,
-0.1911265254020691,
-0.1364479809999466,
-0.22572313249111176,
-0.7629678249359131,
-1.0636307001113892,
-0.4857109487056732,
-0.39862918853759766,
-0.3638066351413727,
0.07792531698942184,
1.2658381462097168,
0.8120622038841248,
-0.9519140720367432,
-0.17896991968154907,
-0.14035367965698242,
0.6025070548057556,
-0.1355447769165039,
-0.24502445757389069,
0.05013935640454292,
-0.28554990887641907,
-0.6861191987991333,
0.5037961602210999,
0.08174524456262589,
0.05640533193945885,
-0.5231159925460815,
-0.12725695967674255,
0.029365209862589836,
0.09853106737136841,
0.49277177453041077,
0.04420652985572815,
-0.818062961101532,
-0.06553028523921967,
-0.4244992733001709,
-0.07351890206336975,
-0.4407315254211426,
1.3575383424758911,
-1.1952011585235596,
0.3273247480392456,
0.5234434604644775,
0.10924606770277023,
0.37741848826408386,
-0.09662268310785294,
0.8086190223693848,
-0.6804725527763367,
0.07598337531089783,
0.023492557927966118,
0.7433252930641174,
0.23673880100250244,
-0.36043378710746765,
0.39553800225257874,
0.262178897857666,
-0.5261532068252563,
-0.8844212889671326,
0.15165527164936066,
-0.9735808372497559,
-0.21290840208530426,
1.3087631464004517,
-0.17049822211265564,
0.05477256700396538,
-0.06774894148111343,
-0.5532836318016052,
-0.3449883460998535,
-0.8220914602279663,
0.5213003754615784,
0.5781669020652771,
0.039712708443403244,
-0.11746241897344589,
-0.15342184901237488,
0.32483476400375366,
0.1895715892314911,
-0.25881463289260864,
0.042241454124450684,
0.6077982783317566,
0.4283531904220581,
-0.1659260094165802,
0.6998886466026306,
0.057312313467264175,
0.04356442764401436,
-0.10640264302492142,
-0.5601781010627747,
-0.2897018790245056,
-0.46425092220306396,
-0.06019295006990433,
0.255134642124176,
0.29372039437294006,
0.14058585464954376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04247v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04247v2
|
UltraWiki: Ultra-fine-grained Entity Set Expansion with Negative Seed Entities
| 2024-03-07T06:10:02 | 2024-04-23T08:29:51 |
Yangning Li, Qingsong Lv, Tianyu Yu, Yinghui Li, Shulin Huang, Tingwei Lu, Xuming Hu, Wenhao JIang, Hai-Tao Zheng, Hui Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Entity Set Expansion (ESE) aims to identify new entities belonging to the
same semantic class as a given set of seed entities. Traditional methods
primarily relied on positive seed entities to represent a target semantic
class, which poses challenge for the representation of ultra-fine-grained
semantic classes. Ultra-fine-grained semantic classes are defined based on
fine-grained semantic classes with more specific attribute constraints.
Describing it with positive seed entities alone cause two issues: (i) Ambiguity
among ultra-fine-grained semantic classes. (ii) Inability to define "unwanted"
semantic. Due to these inherent shortcomings, previous methods struggle to
address the ultra-fine-grained ESE (Ultra-ESE). To solve this issue, we first
introduce negative seed entities in the inputs, which belong to the same
fine-grained semantic class as the positive seed entities but differ in certain
attributes. Negative seed entities eliminate the semantic ambiguity by contrast
between positive and negative attributes. Meanwhile, it provide a
straightforward way to express "unwanted". To assess model performance in
Ultra-ESE, we constructed UltraWiki, the first large-scale dataset tailored for
Ultra-ESE. UltraWiki encompasses 236 ultra-fine-grained semantic classes, where
each query of them is represented with 3-5 positive and negative seed entities.
A retrieval-based framework RetExpan and a generation-based framework GenExpan
are proposed to comprehensively assess the efficacy of large language models
from two different paradigms in Ultra-ESE. Moreover, we devised three
strategies to enhance models' comprehension of ultra-fine-grained entities
semantics: contrastive learning, retrieval augmentation, and chain-of-thought
reasoning. Extensive experiments confirm the effectiveness of our proposed
strategies and also reveal that there remains a large space for improvement in
Ultra-ESE.
|
[
-0.827297031879425,
-0.9414985179901123,
0.31340694427490234,
-0.1419045329093933,
-0.12821614742279053,
-0.03869270160794258,
-0.24163818359375,
-0.7643411159515381,
0.31970661878585815,
0.6314480304718018,
-0.5772835612297058,
-0.5508558750152588,
-0.49851223826408386,
0.21717619895935059,
-0.8993206024169922,
0.9744980931282043,
0.18938006460666656,
-0.476760596036911,
0.042070403695106506,
0.04353561997413635,
-0.12848709523677826,
-0.09930144995450974,
-0.47895482182502747,
-0.36153078079223633,
0.5230361819267273,
0.7689187526702881,
0.9281109571456909,
0.7522291541099548,
0.3018617033958435,
0.29249462485313416,
-0.23020264506340027,
0.1432894617319107,
-0.7167456746101379,
0.053444359451532364,
-0.417120099067688,
-0.2778654098510742,
-0.24667727947235107,
-0.14864985644817352,
0.49290430545806885,
0.8720042705535889,
-0.12371362745761871,
0.381571888923645,
-0.10829727351665497,
0.4792940616607666,
-0.9346988201141357,
-0.1447417289018631,
-0.8154453039169312,
0.15403498709201813,
-0.32885080575942993,
-0.335385799407959,
-0.4528661370277405,
0.21966631710529327,
0.14395210146903992,
-1.0915387868881226,
0.33425450325012207,
-0.026230357587337494,
1.1338040828704834,
-0.16703692078590393,
-0.274535596370697,
-0.08675286173820496,
-0.8379222750663757,
0.6561586856842041,
-0.613476037979126,
0.6006126999855042,
0.12292895466089249,
-0.07227714359760284,
-0.5054246187210083,
-0.669471800327301,
-0.9159627556800842,
-0.1374426782131195,
0.24235965311527252,
0.08871911466121674,
-0.16454489529132843,
0.24654513597488403,
0.3433534502983093,
0.40572014451026917,
-0.3441750109195709,
0.5456622838973999,
-0.16650047898292542,
-0.11784420162439346,
0.42823806405067444,
0.13522067666053772,
0.5200574994087219,
-0.30803099274635315,
-0.5112748742103577,
-0.012704555876553059,
-0.7748692631721497,
-0.4777209460735321,
0.2507447302341461,
0.2850419282913208,
0.25564736127853394,
0.9327973127365112,
-0.5520789623260498,
0.5220755338668823,
0.028173187747597694,
0.1517145037651062,
0.11148335784673691,
-0.12710925936698914,
-0.36042219400405884,
0.005817389115691185,
0.610085666179657,
0.6125901341438293,
0.21518801152706146,
-0.408587247133255,
-0.30999326705932617,
0.1255602389574051,
-0.0198032408952713,
-0.8605436682701111,
0.062066711485385895,
0.2608594298362732,
-0.570532500743866,
-0.5906329154968262,
-0.13862134516239166,
-1.1820672750473022,
-0.49299171566963196,
-0.1533101201057434,
0.6219738125801086,
-0.38291412591934204,
-0.3176778554916382,
-0.022787166759371758,
-0.4166575074195862,
0.2645314335823059,
0.13581204414367676,
-0.9985869526863098,
0.3631405532360077,
0.6562552452087402,
0.25913137197494507,
0.1877330094575882,
-0.4915325343608856,
-0.0030483370646834373,
0.562289297580719,
-0.43668699264526367,
0.9518721699714661,
-0.8401373028755188,
-0.5330521464347839,
0.07369371503591537,
0.17854773998260498,
0.35693907737731934,
-0.38521671295166016,
0.6103441715240479,
-0.7133172750473022,
0.015732748433947563,
-0.2785760462284088,
-1.0699232816696167,
-0.042929381132125854,
0.09077903628349304,
-0.44373655319213867,
1.0255125761032104,
0.13706111907958984,
-0.7489084601402283,
0.5685276389122009,
-0.7011549472808838,
-0.2080899029970169,
0.35818636417388916,
-0.19089379906654358,
-0.13746099174022675,
0.44282111525535583,
-0.03015867993235588,
0.43996262550354004,
-0.61845463514328,
-0.04238394647836685,
-0.480354368686676,
-0.4047155976295471,
0.08576581627130508,
-0.6304035782814026,
0.5520398020744324,
0.14451096951961517,
-0.43775060772895813,
-0.16301672160625458,
-1.1023765802383423,
0.16042008996009827,
0.3650379776954651,
0.07172774523496628,
-0.8682704567909241,
-0.034063052386045456,
-0.021792102605104446,
0.12359270453453064,
0.17037871479988098,
-0.6923855543136597,
0.2531663477420807,
-0.5799616575241089,
0.11633338034152985,
0.8190053105354309,
0.1733778566122055,
0.41054630279541016,
0.23322175443172455,
0.1619940847158432,
0.03928735479712486,
0.3562350571155548,
-0.1954895704984665,
-0.50341796875,
-0.9073449373245239,
0.34704890847206116,
0.41246920824050903,
0.48891332745552063,
-0.7559099793434143,
0.437263548374176,
-0.3229016065597534,
-0.5045779347419739,
-0.27033814787864685,
0.15629328787326813,
0.2870022654533386,
0.4461607336997986,
0.5486816763877869,
-0.10468434542417526,
-0.45769351720809937,
-1.051680326461792,
-0.09242311865091324,
-0.07520663738250732,
0.000019073486328125,
0.20104418694972992,
0.6514338254928589,
-0.4548364579677582,
0.6059056520462036,
-0.6039267182350159,
0.11120546609163284,
-0.003624068107455969,
0.22848717868328094,
-0.0433797761797905,
0.5480096936225891,
0.08091429620981216,
-0.9685511589050293,
-0.5017278790473938,
0.2218887358903885,
-0.6040877103805542,
-0.0063139148987829685,
-0.0506417490541935,
-0.21428698301315308,
-0.06198249012231827,
0.33796098828315735,
-0.6415975689888,
0.4014609456062317,
0.18163172900676727,
-0.5496471524238586,
0.5469027757644653,
-0.19149824976921082,
0.16786915063858032,
-1.1868938207626343,
-0.16122651100158691,
-0.020974736660718918,
0.11490936577320099,
-0.6999427080154419,
0.389180988073349,
0.1437426656484604,
-0.24115967750549316,
-0.44069311022758484,
0.5474109649658203,
-0.40122389793395996,
-0.06473144888877869,
-0.34677577018737793,
0.3910408616065979,
-0.0279249120503664,
0.17656269669532776,
-0.09463315457105637,
0.7611070275306702,
0.5008934140205383,
-0.7451370358467102,
0.4234367907047272,
0.10140931606292725,
0.14105460047721863,
0.7519040703773499,
-0.2847437858581543,
-0.02709762006998062,
-0.23804333806037903,
0.10850097239017487,
-0.46239542961120605,
-0.15891262888908386,
-0.23324690759181976,
-0.36771997809410095,
0.5682753324508667,
0.07294682413339615,
-0.19810378551483154,
-0.6907755136489868,
-0.422691285610199,
0.0531984306871891,
0.13125889003276825,
-0.7039124369621277,
0.5220512747764587,
0.28926584124565125,
0.3203917443752289,
-0.9101876020431519,
-0.40180057287216187,
0.37433338165283203,
-0.2088645100593567,
-0.37129291892051697,
0.48044949769973755,
0.20879249274730682,
-0.1743173897266388,
0.6623584628105164,
-0.2628420889377594,
-0.04954962059855461,
0.07372771948575974,
0.10025227814912796,
0.28979000449180603,
-0.2222079485654831,
0.24969278275966644,
0.15440167486667633,
-0.4138542711734772,
-0.22034837305545807,
-0.7376419901847839,
0.45204877853393555,
0.133299320936203,
-0.016231505200266838,
-0.4544464945793152,
0.5754060745239258,
0.5730152726173401,
-0.13064125180244446,
1.0387694835662842,
0.6044861674308777,
-0.6826306581497192,
-0.3345540165901184,
-0.6737057566642761,
-0.09990009665489197,
-0.4393332004547119,
0.6484536528587341,
-0.6517471075057983,
-0.723046600818634,
0.6191099882125854,
-0.19260145723819733,
0.16459186375141144,
0.9723984003067017,
0.28883370757102966,
-0.2105139046907425,
0.9314970970153809,
0.8718827366828918,
0.11004657298326492,
0.44074997305870056,
-0.5923764109611511,
-0.05087187886238098,
-1.140296459197998,
-0.23670919239521027,
-0.6614158749580383,
-0.1368073970079422,
-0.980926513671875,
-0.16551710665225983,
-0.21239323914051056,
0.26322638988494873,
-0.18164131045341492,
0.6547634601593018,
-0.4580060541629791,
0.7533932328224182,
0.448022723197937,
-0.12022629380226135,
0.2494341880083084,
-0.03537866845726967,
-0.10349443554878235,
0.20531150698661804,
-0.38544830679893494,
-0.5733316540718079,
1.306061029434204,
0.17590543627738953,
0.7235755324363708,
0.050842735916376114,
0.8462145924568176,
0.362304151058197,
0.33323243260383606,
-0.7198155522346497,
0.6980563402175903,
-0.5959066152572632,
-0.9031562805175781,
-0.6189678311347961,
-0.6135615110397339,
-0.9629879593849182,
0.2849043607711792,
-0.48812729120254517,
-0.877924919128418,
0.5312692523002625,
0.07932779937982559,
-0.35522615909576416,
0.5665602087974548,
-0.9587793350219727,
0.8973850011825562,
0.023017792031168938,
-0.3782762289047241,
-0.30891165137290955,
-0.40976572036743164,
0.14989058673381805,
-0.013961544260382652,
0.0854913517832756,
-0.06148660555481911,
-0.2218679040670395,
0.8962630033493042,
-0.34658941626548767,
0.5551729202270508,
-0.17547684907913208,
-0.2207975536584854,
0.27654287219047546,
0.10119742900133133,
0.8031107187271118,
0.08121221512556076,
0.06962524354457855,
0.07292814552783966,
0.040884830057621,
-0.5848492383956909,
-0.716449499130249,
0.9896682500839233,
-0.8629802465438843,
-0.5655278563499451,
-0.0028972793370485306,
-0.1619996279478073,
-0.4336816966533661,
0.6628035306930542,
0.33423498272895813,
0.6401672959327698,
-0.31644871830940247,
0.33698582649230957,
0.947676420211792,
-0.3800569176673889,
0.2596365213394165,
0.9225925803184509,
-0.13346053659915924,
-0.15329505503177643,
1.137449026107788,
0.3626297414302826,
0.3835427761077881,
0.7225468158721924,
0.1441296637058258,
-0.24632450938224792,
-0.6025391221046448,
-0.4458078444004059,
-0.01383267343044281,
-0.735638439655304,
-0.2623996138572693,
-0.8099579811096191,
-0.02382930926978588,
-0.29843831062316895,
-0.14665859937667847,
-0.5275269746780396,
-0.5750328302383423,
-0.19904090464115143,
-0.16604655981063843,
0.08913994580507278,
0.6729471683502197,
0.08765438199043274,
0.11980558931827545,
-0.705447256565094,
0.5128133296966553,
0.3420354723930359,
0.6120344400405884,
0.00007563574035884812,
-0.23354600369930267,
-0.07867321372032166,
-0.11544248461723328,
-0.135719895362854,
-1.2414495944976807,
-0.21583512425422668,
0.04256753996014595,
0.44199275970458984,
0.6117107272148132,
0.0034714224748313427,
0.8053116202354431,
-0.7055781483650208,
0.7940539121627808,
0.28575825691223145,
-0.7144748568534851,
0.5181823968887329,
-0.1535976380109787,
-0.09971385449171066,
0.5708962082862854,
0.21072615683078766,
-0.6885814070701599,
-0.45798251032829285,
-1.0751229524612427,
-1.0156548023223877,
0.3400866687297821,
0.15084023773670197,
0.38495612144470215,
-0.3298336863517761,
0.7307018041610718,
0.052755892276763916,
-0.02465714141726494,
-0.5501831769943237,
-0.6031762361526489,
-0.07924763858318329,
-0.029703889042139053,
0.036268193274736404,
-0.6177119016647339,
0.06828470528125763,
-0.10752875357866287,
1.1903064250946045,
-0.06130116805434227,
0.24282754957675934,
0.1397978514432907,
0.003172249300405383,
-0.39466553926467896,
0.6275875568389893,
0.173386350274086,
0.38985830545425415,
-0.13800740242004395,
0.3463734984397888,
0.3235205113887787,
-0.4959922134876251,
0.17405788600444794,
0.27411389350891113,
-0.5167331099510193,
-0.20141610503196716,
0.3121398091316223,
0.7553257346153259,
0.32778799533843994,
-0.2831324338912964,
0.32595518231391907,
0.11419778317213058,
-0.01252957247197628,
-0.10053171217441559,
0.04198065027594566,
-0.01289024855941534,
-0.044390514492988586,
0.27886641025543213,
-0.13248467445373535,
0.4587898254394531,
-0.5831699967384338,
0.27738749980926514,
0.423736572265625,
-0.3492690622806549,
-0.24390177428722382,
0.4805224537849426,
0.3635576665401459,
-0.06661079078912735,
0.5333376526832581,
-0.3731409013271332,
-0.39918282628059387,
0.5172808766365051,
0.8473315238952637,
0.872846245765686,
-0.14191153645515442,
0.35602959990501404,
0.24788491427898407,
0.5937085151672363,
0.18554605543613434,
0.13012994825839996,
-0.09405560046434402,
-0.979790449142456,
-0.39209285378456116,
-0.6463518738746643,
-0.11281459033489227,
0.39233481884002686,
-0.4631497859954834,
0.11712663620710373,
-0.085262730717659,
-0.11166191846132278,
0.2716328799724579,
0.3599128723144531,
-0.56804358959198,
0.4754100441932678,
0.06839459389448166,
1.3348453044891357,
-0.9049712419509888,
0.7149642705917358,
0.6516505479812622,
-0.664368748664856,
-0.9069610238075256,
-0.01439658086746931,
-0.05583978816866875,
-0.6470043063163757,
0.21360474824905396,
-0.0286555178463459,
0.0751151591539383,
0.23958294093608856,
-0.19238843023777008,
-0.8418212532997131,
0.8219878673553467,
0.0721534788608551,
-0.6604820489883423,
-0.0008222450269386172,
0.07997595518827438,
0.46603232622146606,
0.031243816018104553,
0.25200343132019043,
0.36015036702156067,
0.5906682014465332,
0.007817931473255157,
-0.5848458409309387,
0.01653810776770115,
-0.1461723893880844,
0.3018561601638794,
0.7033541798591614,
-0.4849286675453186,
0.3896714150905609,
-0.07752121984958649,
-0.26338881254196167,
0.012037212029099464,
0.8747563362121582,
-0.34289515018463135,
0.04400426894426346,
0.5794796347618103,
0.9191319346427917,
0.7450506091117859,
-0.07786187529563904,
1.0018781423568726,
-0.292590856552124,
0.6732541918754578,
1.1615840196609497,
-0.1545521765947342,
0.9041798710823059,
0.5993890762329102,
-0.23067496716976166,
0.4105764925479889,
0.499363511800766,
0.000362261722330004,
0.15412141382694244,
0.02479461394250393,
-0.31010863184928894,
-0.22021172940731049,
-0.3657743036746979,
-0.47797462344169617,
0.3207847774028778,
0.5130149126052856,
-0.3798046410083771,
-0.3417811691761017,
0.10296117514371872,
-0.11396175622940063,
0.08296535909175873,
-0.28946319222450256,
0.8099477291107178,
-0.15461893379688263,
-0.29718583822250366,
0.13185708224773407,
0.203695610165596,
0.6294241547584534,
-0.47342371940612793,
-0.09801951795816422,
-0.22578707337379456,
0.03929268568754196,
-0.3910929560661316,
-0.8701668381690979,
0.10900550335645676,
-0.015109127387404442,
-0.2095964103937149,
0.3742651045322418,
0.8477527499198914,
-0.22245316207408905,
-0.4614565372467041,
0.4363152086734772,
0.1691986620426178,
-0.11089245975017548,
0.26759305596351624,
-0.7324094176292419,
-0.15125082433223724,
-0.16839776933193207,
-0.5585912466049194,
0.16333141922950745,
0.783158540725708,
-0.168429434299469,
0.4309655427932739,
0.6868224740028381,
0.15913595259189606,
0.026641778647899628,
0.2810831069946289,
0.8198003172874451,
-0.664396345615387,
-0.3136753737926483,
-0.7834145426750183,
0.1021699607372284,
-0.4322580397129059,
-0.2659943401813507,
0.8182860612869263,
0.6197074055671692,
0.9499898552894592,
0.24221006035804749,
0.4320879578590393,
-0.36189576983451843,
0.17059974372386932,
-0.33001625537872314,
0.25655707716941833,
-0.7252698540687561,
0.21473932266235352,
-0.4957560896873474,
-1.1097145080566406,
-0.276524156332016,
0.25554001331329346,
-0.06704150885343552,
-0.03377947211265564,
0.6444061994552612,
0.7135673761367798,
-0.027767257764935493,
0.360531210899353,
0.49227774143218994,
0.5217798948287964,
0.4499773383140564,
0.3413626253604889,
0.8292007446289062,
-0.5191485285758972,
0.41545671224594116,
-0.5207254886627197,
-0.5521398186683655,
0.01349350530654192,
-0.6476901769638062,
-0.5259817838668823,
-0.47776755690574646,
-0.21123778820037842,
-0.26011988520622253,
0.15997113287448883,
0.9983869791030884,
0.6633720397949219,
-0.7893806099891663,
0.24730555713176727,
-0.27333906292915344,
0.108139269053936,
-0.22407257556915283,
-0.2968532145023346,
0.28041625022888184,
-0.22022876143455505,
-0.5321947336196899,
0.2245159149169922,
0.4856961667537689,
0.09880305081605911,
-0.431424617767334,
0.07639221847057343,
-0.14281535148620605,
0.38827452063560486,
0.6263338327407837,
0.45844101905822754,
-0.5225890278816223,
-0.3634312152862549,
-0.11974278837442398,
0.08377265185117722,
-0.43439698219299316,
0.6488094925880432,
-0.4332539737224579,
0.6017782688140869,
0.2579399347305298,
0.6507677435874939,
0.27322936058044434,
-0.29365038871765137,
0.2288973182439804,
-0.47602102160453796,
0.16717474162578583,
-0.12924155592918396,
0.25719237327575684,
0.030486885458230972,
-0.6000382900238037,
0.3687785565853119,
0.38882049918174744,
-0.29270878434181213,
-0.7087891101837158,
0.3051109313964844,
-0.4538209140300751,
-0.4847840368747711,
1.0154731273651123,
0.18570083379745483,
-0.3755872845649719,
-0.07012294977903366,
0.06842215359210968,
0.22953324019908905,
-0.2432083636522293,
0.7101590037345886,
0.63744056224823,
0.015719961374998093,
0.12115959078073502,
-0.5401408672332764,
0.2099883258342743,
0.37599778175354004,
-0.8124644756317139,
0.268225759267807,
0.38612475991249084,
0.10673311352729797,
0.4780201315879822,
0.5946029424667358,
-0.3124639093875885,
0.29493585228919983,
0.11065525561571121,
0.10888698697090149,
-0.03325899690389633,
-0.47511738538742065,
0.08313717693090439,
0.39122331142425537,
-0.024600377306342125,
-0.016566326841711998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04233v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04233v2
|
DEEP-ICL: Definition-Enriched Experts for Language Model In-Context Learning
| 2024-03-07T05:26:41 | 2024-06-16T06:44:50 |
Xingwei Qu, Yiming Liang, Yucheng Wang, Tianyu Zheng, Tommy Yue, Lei Ma, Stephen W. Huang, Jiajun Zhang, Yinan Shi, Chenghua Lin, Jie Fu, Ge Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
It has long been assumed that the sheer number of parameters in large
language models (LLMs) drives in-context learning (ICL) capabilities, enabling
remarkable performance improvements by leveraging task-specific demonstrations.
Challenging this hypothesis, we introduce DEEP-ICL, a novel task Definition
Enriched ExPert Ensembling methodology for ICL. DEEP-ICL explicitly extracts
task definitions from given demonstrations and generates responses through
learning task-specific examples. We argue that improvement from ICL does not
directly rely on model size, but essentially stems from understanding task
definitions and task-guided learning. Inspired by this, DEEP-ICL combines two
3B models with distinct roles (one for concluding task definitions and the
other for learning task demonstrations) and achieves comparable performance to
LLaMA2-13B. Furthermore, our framework outperforms conventional ICL by
overcoming pretraining sequence length limitations, by supporting unlimited
demonstrations. We contend that DEEP-ICL presents a novel alternative for
achieving efficient few-shot learning, extending beyond the conventional ICL.
|
[
-0.4536283612251282,
-0.765058159828186,
0.5271762013435364,
-0.03277473896741867,
-0.27546611428260803,
0.4572718143463135,
-0.3693154752254486,
-0.5340051651000977,
-0.41296306252479553,
0.417103111743927,
-0.5413877367973328,
-0.5078930258750916,
-0.6343851089477539,
-0.06108666956424713,
-0.3950209319591522,
1.064638614654541,
0.06377903372049332,
0.0080427136272192,
-0.2797091603279114,
0.2242739051580429,
-0.31800585985183716,
-0.07389245182275772,
-0.5614217519760132,
-0.40291815996170044,
0.4120376408100128,
0.9229780435562134,
0.34003621339797974,
0.5989347100257874,
0.4369884729385376,
0.1753981113433838,
0.024851281195878983,
0.4954788088798523,
-0.4138161838054657,
-0.0030190469697117805,
0.017533505335450172,
-0.18287980556488037,
-0.40897396206855774,
-0.0814611166715622,
0.5508796572685242,
0.9638079404830933,
0.049956969916820526,
0.04764394462108612,
0.5510143041610718,
0.5892177224159241,
-0.8592792749404907,
0.050740551203489304,
-0.8036124110221863,
0.06624246388673782,
-0.3271581530570984,
0.067869633436203,
-0.503128170967102,
0.18902398645877838,
0.30788180232048035,
-0.24942244589328766,
0.054431263357400894,
-0.2954612076282501,
0.5409572124481201,
0.4914805293083191,
-0.5309293270111084,
-0.18333180248737335,
-0.6449170112609863,
0.646869421005249,
-1.0459176301956177,
0.4137079417705536,
0.23447498679161072,
0.3488777279853821,
0.06261162459850311,
-0.7986401319503784,
-0.5220809578895569,
-0.4784724712371826,
-0.14428958296775818,
-0.07156005501747131,
0.04153764992952347,
0.26976293325424194,
0.2336200773715973,
0.17677535116672516,
-0.32678499817848206,
0.5514458417892456,
-0.19069074094295502,
0.1683308631181717,
0.6345279216766357,
0.1457800418138504,
0.05576235055923462,
0.32801640033721924,
-0.45839184522628784,
0.3019461929798126,
-1.1997543573379517,
0.19102779030799866,
0.023322196677327156,
0.4246579110622406,
-0.24228903651237488,
0.3144650459289551,
-0.49912673234939575,
0.5819423198699951,
0.4024534523487091,
-0.10716527700424194,
0.0643957257270813,
0.14185909926891327,
-0.4654041528701782,
0.17367640137672424,
0.48404982686042786,
-0.11030764132738113,
-0.03941847383975983,
-0.41851726174354553,
-0.13101309537887573,
-0.466755747795105,
-0.003040678333491087,
-1.0695602893829346,
-0.28742823004722595,
0.04085104539990425,
-0.2452009916305542,
-0.09464432299137115,
0.060930896550416946,
-0.3700824975967407,
-0.44835788011550903,
-0.5271393656730652,
0.40349408984184265,
-0.2661420702934265,
-0.21496523916721344,
0.07840996235609055,
0.14296367764472961,
0.2871394157409668,
0.30121973156929016,
-0.7681612372398376,
0.531548798084259,
0.9421898126602173,
0.3828392028808594,
-0.34497198462486267,
-0.400916188955307,
-0.7284433245658875,
0.25033456087112427,
-0.6179083585739136,
0.5689422488212585,
-0.7529001832008362,
-0.054886333644390106,
-0.044633977115154266,
-0.4152907133102417,
0.2976749837398529,
-0.5269412994384766,
0.0047583747655153275,
-0.6069804430007935,
-0.07156149297952652,
-0.14397868514060974,
-0.7162784337997437,
-0.22504983842372894,
0.18654297292232513,
-0.36830127239227295,
0.9611706733703613,
-0.03206919506192207,
-0.31986722350120544,
0.7242947220802307,
-0.7723149657249451,
-0.5733175277709961,
0.5695576071739197,
-0.379122793674469,
-0.10476305335760117,
0.19757841527462006,
0.2333214432001114,
0.9376678466796875,
-0.3271554410457611,
0.35565152764320374,
-0.40771788358688354,
-0.5520861148834229,
0.2612902522087097,
-0.48074352741241455,
0.6500986814498901,
0.18258021771907806,
-0.6639115810394287,
-0.02270856313407421,
-0.4817996919155121,
-0.018651224672794342,
-0.3709378242492676,
-0.44929540157318115,
-0.19026753306388855,
0.06834209710359573,
-0.20101545751094818,
0.29651808738708496,
0.27534234523773193,
-0.4343796968460083,
0.0911196693778038,
-0.7438845634460449,
0.20272065699100494,
0.6380783915519714,
-0.15354448556900024,
0.45907849073410034,
0.20967814326286316,
0.29036954045295715,
0.08450251817703247,
0.03453288972377777,
-0.10487920045852661,
-0.05370156094431877,
-0.8499768972396851,
-0.3878120481967926,
0.12527135014533997,
0.29952460527420044,
-0.5710052847862244,
0.401239275932312,
-0.18625882267951965,
-0.5075603127479553,
-0.6184899806976318,
0.5741183757781982,
0.7479633688926697,
0.6295806765556335,
0.4748133718967438,
-0.054027896374464035,
-0.45170727372169495,
-1.1260114908218384,
-0.24123705923557281,
0.08702436834573746,
0.06858238577842712,
0.3832522928714752,
0.6330093741416931,
-0.09744267165660858,
0.8585343360900879,
-0.29585760831832886,
-0.2862693667411804,
-0.5274948477745056,
-0.015337338671088219,
0.21387797594070435,
0.5434637069702148,
0.39121320843696594,
-0.5178935527801514,
-0.909350574016571,
0.10839086025953293,
-0.5710124373435974,
0.15154564380645752,
-0.05889357998967171,
0.13551735877990723,
0.17767497897148132,
0.7232751846313477,
-0.6658737659454346,
0.3893914520740509,
0.1489768773317337,
-0.1328631490468979,
0.29642096161842346,
-0.16990642249584198,
-0.18424342572689056,
-0.8934863805770874,
-0.15175631642341614,
-0.10648278892040253,
-0.11872617900371552,
-0.7269974946975708,
0.5350071787834167,
0.2303152233362198,
0.036044228821992874,
-0.7522901296615601,
0.5839145183563232,
-0.4741293489933014,
-0.04729778692126274,
-0.48568326234817505,
0.1447068303823471,
-0.09083963185548782,
0.518161952495575,
-0.0236197579652071,
0.6308315396308899,
0.9247630834579468,
-0.5490416288375854,
0.0052253203466534615,
0.13169613480567932,
-0.4511738419532776,
0.1429564207792282,
-0.5181947350502014,
0.4998420774936676,
-0.0272708497941494,
0.22797907888889313,
-1.0653332471847534,
-0.3354915678501129,
0.14730358123779297,
-0.2124921828508377,
0.5926361680030823,
-0.22351796925067902,
-0.4941295385360718,
-0.08039647340774536,
-0.011244464665651321,
0.476057231426239,
0.5296291708946228,
-0.6832152009010315,
0.41155925393104553,
0.2517283856868744,
0.016707153990864754,
-0.8321101069450378,
-0.814861536026001,
0.40715843439102173,
-0.24119292199611664,
-0.17495757341384888,
0.5738580822944641,
-0.303527295589447,
-0.4505265951156616,
-0.18663527071475983,
0.01398136280477047,
-0.2142670601606369,
0.41669782996177673,
0.12214108556509018,
-0.060914166271686554,
-0.3432866930961609,
0.3232628107070923,
0.28133425116539,
0.09709522128105164,
-0.026879271492362022,
-0.09744685888290405,
0.41377565264701843,
-0.25499868392944336,
-0.489596962928772,
-0.6073952913284302,
0.6196300983428955,
0.29456597566604614,
-0.4186292886734009,
0.40585416555404663,
0.5375837087631226,
-0.4203515946865082,
-0.361583411693573,
-0.6909877061843872,
-0.26871514320373535,
-0.48775362968444824,
0.5197427272796631,
-0.5258834958076477,
-0.9736396670341492,
0.15493793785572052,
-0.09731403738260269,
0.08430801331996918,
0.22634750604629517,
0.46584638953208923,
-0.10173329710960388,
1.2757571935653687,
0.9346325397491455,
-0.07531784474849701,
0.23637162148952484,
-0.3882001042366028,
0.22007326781749725,
-0.7955655455589294,
-0.274478554725647,
-0.27451059222221375,
-0.4468574821949005,
-0.17712800204753876,
-0.2700299620628357,
0.14472369849681854,
0.26891547441482544,
-0.6845101714134216,
0.07057898491621017,
-0.1839396208524704,
0.7566036581993103,
0.3661551773548126,
0.37880077958106995,
0.10612494498491287,
-0.23540450632572174,
0.1376609355211258,
0.015198185108602047,
-0.5346392393112183,
-0.40370362997055054,
0.9734044075012207,
0.32228049635887146,
0.6620087027549744,
0.11037151515483856,
0.8027252554893494,
0.13521640002727509,
0.33533433079719543,
-0.801379919052124,
0.6672428250312805,
-0.426435649394989,
-0.45911166071891785,
-0.29888400435447693,
0.14067578315734863,
-0.5280774831771851,
0.017541976645588875,
-0.02901812270283699,
-0.7103354930877686,
0.07323429733514786,
0.27249735593795776,
-0.6790840029716492,
0.2456509917974472,
-0.42885735630989075,
0.7327439785003662,
-0.40004464983940125,
-0.357239693403244,
-0.5266364216804504,
-0.6483114957809448,
0.34151479601860046,
-0.006914589554071426,
-0.12043245881795883,
-0.08349011093378067,
-0.4993940591812134,
0.46291640400886536,
-0.24982379376888275,
1.2508692741394043,
-0.24836236238479614,
-0.11261250823736191,
0.10132911056280136,
0.28289350867271423,
0.5885863900184631,
0.230984628200531,
-0.03849389776587486,
-0.17610777914524078,
-0.5980470180511475,
-0.41651076078414917,
-0.6380287408828735,
0.8579678535461426,
-0.6608866453170776,
-0.7953519225120544,
0.2126072347164154,
-0.5245726108551025,
-0.35459887981414795,
0.13559412956237793,
0.11358796805143356,
0.756927490234375,
0.13965056836605072,
0.6609640717506409,
0.7939514517784119,
0.014928269200026989,
0.719567060470581,
0.6397561430931091,
0.25647568702697754,
-0.05340217053890228,
0.5924438238143921,
-0.04964539036154747,
0.2246847152709961,
0.6391929388046265,
0.08514157682657242,
-0.20145457983016968,
-1.0232634544372559,
-0.33564865589141846,
-0.2021489441394806,
-0.8690398335456848,
-0.2969622313976288,
-0.6929373741149902,
-0.15867017209529877,
-0.333803653717041,
-0.3826821744441986,
-0.3957570195198059,
-0.07208877056837082,
-0.5544220805168152,
-0.3510151505470276,
0.0435016006231308,
0.6855927109718323,
0.06780343502759933,
0.38801729679107666,
-0.4789671301841736,
0.14392000436782837,
0.5489971041679382,
0.31365063786506653,
0.20242911577224731,
-0.5744929313659668,
-0.45503395795822144,
0.027382904663681984,
-0.16986897587776184,
-0.7217564582824707,
0.3165859282016754,
0.5553705096244812,
0.7124127745628357,
0.6856775879859924,
-0.04039217159152031,
1.0844863653182983,
-0.5937490463256836,
0.8655935525894165,
-0.02552778087556362,
-1.0859540700912476,
0.438833624124527,
-0.0795418918132782,
0.28561726212501526,
0.5700330138206482,
0.3900702893733978,
-0.31729862093925476,
-0.4285027086734772,
-0.507460355758667,
-0.862280547618866,
0.5396177768707275,
-0.4039457440376282,
0.4464247226715088,
-0.08404405415058136,
0.41788437962532043,
0.5492054224014282,
0.15289323031902313,
-0.6640151739120483,
0.013251411728560925,
0.02485221065580845,
-0.2195540815591812,
-0.24030818045139313,
-0.31141042709350586,
-0.0654611587524414,
-0.3959137499332428,
0.5529264807701111,
-0.49640175700187683,
-0.04990176483988762,
0.0769103616476059,
-0.5448235273361206,
-0.07408946752548218,
0.29635900259017944,
0.47675958275794983,
0.9091339707374573,
0.10203082859516144,
0.2826533019542694,
0.6555052399635315,
0.04063648357987404,
-0.15833508968353271,
0.11282552778720856,
0.07304830104112625,
-0.3773669898509979,
0.6256638765335083,
0.8933213353157043,
0.48538991808891296,
-0.8980937600135803,
0.5469437837600708,
0.3283931314945221,
-0.09422698616981506,
-0.39445921778678894,
0.1302909106016159,
-0.07522784918546677,
0.5940109491348267,
0.7619343996047974,
0.022623417899012566,
0.43616151809692383,
-0.41595447063446045,
0.43615710735321045,
0.6197406053543091,
-0.7461758255958557,
-0.16219280660152435,
0.533814013004303,
0.16830167174339294,
-0.3448483943939209,
0.5138269066810608,
-0.21316426992416382,
-0.26672419905662537,
0.709129273891449,
0.49492090940475464,
1.144932508468628,
0.11326704174280167,
0.1322992891073227,
-0.05078114569187164,
0.10603095591068268,
0.2022620439529419,
0.15857216715812683,
-0.40843358635902405,
-0.5823535323143005,
-0.8917164206504822,
-0.17428985238075256,
-0.2440214455127716,
0.4324263632297516,
-0.5419803857803345,
0.3081705570220947,
-0.4835679531097412,
0.4931221008300781,
-0.11486463993787766,
0.2197648286819458,
-0.9524467587471008,
0.14616213738918304,
0.4966566860675812,
1.1520410776138306,
-0.6625606417655945,
1.0052697658538818,
0.48449525237083435,
-0.18859168887138367,
-0.7636002898216248,
0.20779502391815186,
-0.11355271190404892,
-0.49433767795562744,
1.2065306901931763,
0.3942303955554962,
-0.1724703311920166,
0.189067542552948,
-0.8745564222335815,
-0.7181209921836853,
1.1007370948791504,
0.4104856550693512,
-0.5565028190612793,
0.031370799988508224,
0.05354970321059227,
0.49281537532806396,
-0.8102028965950012,
0.3029730021953583,
0.5500995516777039,
0.2532670497894287,
-0.2666334807872772,
-0.6539876461029053,
0.0992249995470047,
-0.11379371583461761,
-0.14015911519527435,
-0.09826499223709106,
-0.45580175518989563,
0.691022515296936,
-0.3656052350997925,
-0.00890522263944149,
0.20291738212108612,
0.9085155725479126,
0.09815527498722076,
0.1857140213251114,
0.44977444410324097,
0.24611203372478485,
0.5099920630455017,
0.17963215708732605,
0.9153375029563904,
-0.2639685869216919,
-0.022113831713795662,
1.3321020603179932,
-0.3969627916812897,
1.0001091957092285,
0.42125481367111206,
0.12705819308757782,
0.535793125629425,
0.7449665665626526,
0.17784175276756287,
0.5907599925994873,
-0.1915518343448639,
-0.3633663058280945,
-0.7489603757858276,
-0.054595306515693665,
-0.12751267850399017,
0.6782726049423218,
0.524278998374939,
-0.24754972755908966,
-0.4317406415939331,
0.1930929273366928,
-0.09759774059057236,
0.10178857296705246,
-0.36934053897857666,
0.9557897448539734,
0.026063084602355957,
-0.6729850769042969,
0.510308027267456,
-0.26455625891685486,
0.6226387619972229,
-0.370389461517334,
-0.2643353044986725,
-0.21758559346199036,
0.33435532450675964,
-0.07235221564769745,
-0.8703095316886902,
-0.008536488749086857,
-0.09579885751008987,
0.026377035304903984,
-0.2623065412044525,
0.6791669726371765,
-0.6689696311950684,
-0.20954661071300507,
0.2509414851665497,
0.5542781352996826,
0.06107303500175476,
-0.01737309992313385,
-0.7345014810562134,
-0.407420814037323,
-0.2297973930835724,
-0.12585841119289398,
0.398311585187912,
0.337322860956192,
0.14216990768909454,
0.7360431551933289,
0.3287113308906555,
-0.20983269810676575,
-0.06186729669570923,
0.0839538425207138,
0.9820302724838257,
-0.34245023131370544,
-0.2634586691856384,
-1.1034059524536133,
0.8845121264457703,
-0.13659046590328217,
-0.49857476353645325,
0.6305285692214966,
0.6738194823265076,
1.1616263389587402,
-0.21910041570663452,
0.8045639395713806,
0.00017353160365018994,
0.37229716777801514,
-0.5589196085929871,
0.4951549470424652,
-0.6044847965240479,
0.3155650198459625,
-0.19035688042640686,
-0.46878859400749207,
-0.44196492433547974,
0.16323401033878326,
-0.25201743841171265,
-0.027390019968152046,
0.5008605718612671,
0.8219829797744751,
-0.28191065788269043,
-0.3611098825931549,
0.414182186126709,
0.1535135805606842,
0.4933278262615204,
0.7229452729225159,
0.9171866178512573,
-0.05114515498280525,
0.576057493686676,
-0.49765971302986145,
-0.1711689978837967,
-0.4499010741710663,
-0.9657274484634399,
-1.150526762008667,
-0.5793729424476624,
-0.41681843996047974,
0.16605669260025024,
0.1464540809392929,
1.2549177408218384,
0.9971615076065063,
-0.74537593126297,
-0.33133262395858765,
-0.14983564615249634,
0.04233517125248909,
-0.5585390329360962,
-0.14627774059772491,
0.38699832558631897,
-0.6584504842758179,
-0.7686750292778015,
0.9385989904403687,
0.36682766675949097,
-0.1243155226111412,
-0.38147541880607605,
-0.2538192868232727,
-0.029261300340294838,
-0.16437028348445892,
0.786303699016571,
0.1614740788936615,
-0.948186457157135,
-0.28695109486579895,
-0.12884864211082458,
-0.03166762739419937,
-0.07853180170059204,
0.7902941107749939,
-0.9971292614936829,
0.21200518310070038,
0.4150142967700958,
0.9236170649528503,
0.41270193457603455,
-0.41540005803108215,
0.4263143837451935,
-0.9856130480766296,
0.1341341733932495,
0.329892635345459,
0.24133650958538055,
0.207443505525589,
-0.3652409315109253,
0.33413606882095337,
-0.26125234365463257,
-0.3453015983104706,
-0.9144323468208313,
0.46312451362609863,
-0.7861688733100891,
-0.5734829306602478,
1.0743017196655273,
-0.11200951784849167,
0.2259947806596756,
-0.05814279243350029,
-0.2113543003797531,
0.08782652765512466,
-0.334853857755661,
0.8088300228118896,
0.25741341710090637,
-0.1595662385225296,
-0.39058977365493774,
-0.6252496242523193,
0.7518248558044434,
0.23553168773651123,
-0.7208084464073181,
0.0463690347969532,
0.20740710198879242,
0.1130879819393158,
-0.24837130308151245,
0.21950381994247437,
0.1937400847673416,
0.43475469946861267,
-0.48106318712234497,
-0.14197814464569092,
-0.37568849325180054,
-0.6915408968925476,
-0.2799759805202484,
0.29036763310432434,
0.2891082167625427,
0.020143425092101097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04814v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04814v3
|
Evaluation of LLMs on Syntax-Aware Code Fill-in-the-Middle Tasks
| 2024-03-07T05:05:56 | 2024-06-23T01:17:48 |
Linyuan Gong, Sida Wang, Mostafa Elhoushi, Alvin Cheung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SE
|
We introduce Syntax-Aware Fill-In-the-Middle (SAFIM), a new benchmark for
evaluating Large Language Models (LLMs) on the code Fill-in-the-Middle (FIM)
task. This benchmark focuses on syntax-aware completions of program structures
such as code blocks and conditional expressions, and includes 17,720 examples
from multiple programming languages, sourced from recent code submissions after
April 2022 to minimize data contamination. SAFIM provides a robust framework
with various prompt designs and novel syntax-aware post-processing techniques,
facilitating accurate and fair comparisons across LLMs. Our comprehensive
evaluation of 15 LLMs shows that FIM pretraining not only enhances FIM
proficiency but also improves Left-to-Right (L2R) inference using LLMs. Our
findings challenge conventional beliefs and suggest that pretraining methods
and data quality have more impact than model size. SAFIM thus serves as a
foundational platform for future research in effective pretraining strategies
for code LLMs. The evaluation toolkit and dataset are available at
https://github.com/gonglinyuan/safim, and the leaderboard is available at
https://safimbenchmark.com.
|
[
-0.34882307052612305,
-0.5668364763259888,
0.3878301680088043,
0.5720996260643005,
-0.15009772777557373,
0.2805437743663788,
-0.43448522686958313,
-0.2948859632015228,
0.10671452432870865,
0.5875555276870728,
-0.3753940165042877,
-0.5143436193466187,
-0.5610854029655457,
0.15443003177642822,
-0.7457668781280518,
0.7579527497291565,
-0.19404706358909607,
0.2708896994590759,
-0.9941385984420776,
-0.09146792441606522,
-0.5360094904899597,
-0.7094731330871582,
-0.22551855444908142,
-0.2648381292819977,
0.22542919218540192,
0.6325036883354187,
0.566312849521637,
0.49843528866767883,
0.6188589930534363,
0.3008546829223633,
0.10995928943157196,
-0.045771293342113495,
-0.5040441751480103,
-0.007841900922358036,
0.10245180130004883,
-0.6142236590385437,
-0.3339695930480957,
0.22580701112747192,
0.8063924312591553,
0.7039689421653748,
-0.19651323556900024,
0.25238677859306335,
-0.10191835463047028,
1.0416674613952637,
-0.6641615629196167,
0.13614758849143982,
-0.6151899695396423,
-0.02788475714623928,
-0.41605862975120544,
-0.270423948764801,
-0.33503854274749756,
-0.5053998827934265,
-0.008540529757738113,
-0.2268805354833603,
0.12412353605031967,
-0.04076753929257393,
0.519336462020874,
0.6034420132637024,
-0.42618539929389954,
-0.25032201409339905,
-0.4410676956176758,
0.5479078888893127,
-0.5105975270271301,
0.7570266723632812,
0.4785207211971283,
0.29182878136634827,
-0.29736328125,
-0.9077211618423462,
-0.5452983379364014,
-0.29115718603134155,
-0.10992532223463058,
0.15640957653522491,
-0.08564940094947815,
0.19879482686519623,
0.4028858244419098,
0.4362391233444214,
-0.5049333572387695,
-0.12880964577198029,
-0.3165506422519684,
-0.07468712329864502,
0.7154914736747742,
-0.07662110030651093,
0.12964777648448944,
0.3029639422893524,
-0.6267899870872498,
0.32189464569091797,
-0.9182142615318298,
-0.01704905740916729,
0.2523254156112671,
-0.06373756378889084,
-0.23858556151390076,
0.48779335618019104,
-0.241963192820549,
1.014549970626831,
-0.2608005106449127,
0.050990499556064606,
0.37089094519615173,
-0.5101705193519592,
-0.4575325548648834,
-0.2953678071498871,
0.582450270652771,
0.40590086579322815,
0.4855780005455017,
-0.21840204298496246,
-0.41096943616867065,
0.034766316413879395,
0.17719359695911407,
-0.6045800447463989,
-0.07886150479316711,
0.04882470518350601,
-0.35305917263031006,
-0.015559853985905647,
-0.04213782399892807,
-0.4910934269428253,
-0.4127616882324219,
-0.34352269768714905,
0.26320067048072815,
-0.10597914457321167,
-0.1333923488855362,
0.29235005378723145,
0.16295920312404633,
0.43102186918258667,
0.23590023815631866,
-0.4464207887649536,
0.36404699087142944,
0.8298628330230713,
0.7210778594017029,
-0.20322047173976898,
-0.32848381996154785,
-0.8693276047706604,
-0.17791420221328735,
-0.38277414441108704,
0.7940547466278076,
-0.6673761606216431,
-0.28041309118270874,
0.00030507531482726336,
-0.41202405095100403,
-0.23549307882785797,
-0.7166203856468201,
0.37065985798835754,
-0.6214923858642578,
0.0763426423072815,
-0.2913558781147003,
-0.8023584485054016,
0.06817543506622314,
0.00947724562138319,
-0.5765483975410461,
1.3614437580108643,
0.29588285088539124,
-0.5226885676383972,
0.10463287681341171,
-0.5496945381164551,
-0.45550262928009033,
0.11516514420509338,
-0.6037685871124268,
-0.23767003417015076,
-0.0035514207556843758,
-0.09514404088258743,
0.4690466821193695,
-0.39318373799324036,
0.36129364371299744,
-0.29517683386802673,
-0.7546051740646362,
0.5442913770675659,
-0.05250002071261406,
0.4528399705886841,
0.22589923441410065,
-0.11837992072105408,
0.26498234272003174,
-0.4921836256980896,
-0.03805960714817047,
0.005337451584637165,
-0.2218715399503708,
0.2266843169927597,
-0.12182750552892685,
-0.0019128938438370824,
0.3765224516391754,
0.32455897331237793,
-0.32926759123802185,
0.12346553802490234,
-0.2027425467967987,
0.3026066720485687,
0.7636409401893616,
-0.2056884765625,
0.4226182997226715,
-0.44796222448349,
0.8033072352409363,
-0.32040897011756897,
0.26546603441238403,
-0.1647469699382782,
-0.15375298261642456,
-1.0196154117584229,
-0.4308311939239502,
0.5183020234107971,
0.620894193649292,
-0.5781494975090027,
0.5305471420288086,
0.040201056748628616,
-0.5641881823539734,
-0.1958429515361786,
0.3482876718044281,
0.4852784276008606,
0.34003105759620667,
0.23150451481342316,
-0.35345059633255005,
-0.6002480387687683,
-0.7046124935150146,
-0.4384486675262451,
-0.06897495687007904,
0.37706106901168823,
0.1638166457414627,
0.45655572414398193,
-0.3040018379688263,
0.8640413880348206,
-0.3927847146987915,
-0.2719321846961975,
-0.33882442116737366,
-0.3847474753856659,
0.25579479336738586,
0.5541843175888062,
0.7524446845054626,
-0.5803162455558777,
-0.6455288529396057,
-0.4229971766471863,
-0.4443213641643524,
-0.39138081669807434,
-0.031636424362659454,
-0.2402561753988266,
0.11710739135742188,
0.994883120059967,
-0.5376318097114563,
0.3608473837375641,
0.5142034888267517,
-0.4296218454837799,
0.5345566272735596,
0.10725296288728714,
0.09753021597862244,
-0.7033995985984802,
0.11204234510660172,
-0.2821328043937683,
-0.35641297698020935,
-0.6449980735778809,
0.07535935938358307,
0.177235946059227,
-0.06527462601661682,
-0.5305270552635193,
0.5755037069320679,
-0.499337762594223,
-0.5179448127746582,
-0.13297918438911438,
0.0008475477225147188,
-0.029598131775856018,
0.3993668854236603,
-0.2757123112678528,
1.1800261735916138,
0.4141162633895874,
-0.10283990949392319,
-0.04214150831103325,
0.03422974795103073,
-0.5754086971282959,
0.1026373878121376,
-0.6184408068656921,
0.22564488649368286,
0.03976113349199295,
0.38511842489242554,
-1.1235791444778442,
-0.15411809086799622,
0.019608337432146072,
-0.3749788999557495,
0.2635466456413269,
-0.26569560170173645,
-0.695527970790863,
-0.07013977319002151,
-0.21575574576854706,
0.45606493949890137,
0.5319145321846008,
-0.365207314491272,
0.48314160108566284,
0.2221808135509491,
-0.33118361234664917,
-0.6427551507949829,
-0.5749921798706055,
-0.026588790118694305,
-0.01667151413857937,
-0.48217979073524475,
0.2698234021663666,
-0.3544659912586212,
-0.044560279697179794,
-0.3088667690753937,
-0.48817405104637146,
-0.058610811829566956,
0.5479730367660522,
0.3348180055618286,
0.4657016694545746,
0.018904095515608788,
0.09788738936185837,
-0.07660210877656937,
-0.20379026234149933,
0.1335291713476181,
-0.016440480947494507,
0.6830528378486633,
-0.48639288544654846,
-0.5668437480926514,
-0.21683675050735474,
0.242804616689682,
0.43297716975212097,
-0.4994032382965088,
0.2779305577278137,
0.4258628487586975,
-0.5416801571846008,
0.03550930693745613,
-0.9265566468238831,
0.2465795874595642,
-0.4319092929363251,
0.18300792574882507,
-0.15206387639045715,
-1.1464738845825195,
0.35576480627059937,
-0.11070526391267776,
-0.08296960592269897,
0.2215372771024704,
0.4058312773704529,
-0.18434739112854004,
0.669907808303833,
0.7291229367256165,
-0.0495864637196064,
0.8370671272277832,
-0.405875563621521,
0.08923374861478806,
-0.35521143674850464,
-0.24844937026500702,
-0.6955048441886902,
-0.10848090797662735,
-0.1342059224843979,
-0.7396144866943359,
0.13010527193546295,
0.7225633859634399,
-0.2645191252231598,
-0.012574640102684498,
-0.1904909908771515,
0.9464533925056458,
0.30287015438079834,
-0.0740351602435112,
0.22806090116500854,
0.040862925350666046,
-0.11301872879266739,
0.18226687610149384,
-0.7524235844612122,
-0.43509212136268616,
1.1976063251495361,
0.2597339451313019,
0.48756203055381775,
-0.11844168603420258,
0.7997947931289673,
0.5777004957199097,
0.4553399384021759,
-0.601033627986908,
0.6095389723777771,
-0.18409892916679382,
-0.24469976127147675,
0.09034193307161331,
-0.30654600262641907,
-0.47933149337768555,
-0.08897139132022858,
-0.2475062906742096,
-0.4191941022872925,
-0.01807413436472416,
0.05109896510839462,
-0.4393308758735657,
-0.11208292096853256,
-0.7395287752151489,
0.8389943838119507,
-0.40128129720687866,
-0.22413025796413422,
-0.2701350450515747,
-0.7002043724060059,
0.17663262784481049,
-0.2578311860561371,
0.08696025609970093,
-0.3360821008682251,
-0.29489532113075256,
0.7880096435546875,
-0.4368496537208557,
0.6341297030448914,
-0.3398291766643524,
0.10050304234027863,
0.23544128239154816,
-0.1765027642250061,
0.3400322496891022,
0.09874255210161209,
-0.1276136338710785,
0.34597018361091614,
-0.02583833411335945,
-0.6117246150970459,
-0.6129376292228699,
0.5754174590110779,
-0.6314826011657715,
-0.4737522304058075,
-0.6616045236587524,
-0.5220523476600647,
-0.43177905678749084,
0.3855445981025696,
0.06289196014404297,
0.43908414244651794,
-0.08709332346916199,
0.3056265413761139,
0.6719804406166077,
-0.034814558923244476,
0.2543259263038635,
0.4656289517879486,
-0.503618597984314,
-0.5525823831558228,
0.6393638849258423,
0.07129122316837311,
0.28062134981155396,
0.1383221596479416,
-0.18723270297050476,
-0.28519320487976074,
-0.8192787170410156,
-0.3836752772331238,
0.17961464822292328,
-0.6949583292007446,
-0.5400217175483704,
-0.5877597332000732,
-0.35154634714126587,
-0.17135676741600037,
-0.44255849719047546,
-0.3369376063346863,
-0.3713296353816986,
0.017103416845202446,
-0.0043788994662463665,
0.36023297905921936,
0.6489963531494141,
0.14105671644210815,
0.5216132998466492,
-0.7985999584197998,
0.06608259677886963,
-0.03476116806268692,
0.7761821746826172,
-0.1661401242017746,
-0.19797568023204803,
-0.602347731590271,
-0.0670771449804306,
0.050693102180957794,
-0.5301358699798584,
-0.18296432495117188,
0.12325422465801239,
0.7643930315971375,
0.23840364813804626,
-0.2301797717809677,
0.623974084854126,
-0.27628639340400696,
0.7496374249458313,
0.3622151017189026,
-0.9656055569648743,
0.339101642370224,
-0.021383685991168022,
0.2123674750328064,
0.904541015625,
0.22864829003810883,
-0.457845538854599,
-0.31121572852134705,
-0.3617240786552429,
-0.5430668592453003,
0.4785621166229248,
0.23371820151805878,
-0.16266997158527374,
-0.09827529639005661,
0.4758632183074951,
0.19424304366111755,
0.30893370509147644,
-0.45944902300834656,
-0.25662752985954285,
-0.00919910054653883,
-0.27290573716163635,
-0.10497374832630157,
-0.34680473804473877,
-0.10249503701925278,
-0.2395736128091812,
0.5178516507148743,
-0.14302454888820648,
0.39613333344459534,
0.0851302370429039,
-0.47061973810195923,
0.04731649160385132,
0.22521482408046722,
0.5540030002593994,
0.802349328994751,
-0.06794120371341705,
-0.10769473761320114,
0.1944407969713211,
-0.35462987422943115,
0.009110457263886929,
0.45272910594940186,
-0.1637037992477417,
-0.09795045852661133,
0.5536684393882751,
0.5269231796264648,
0.08222159743309021,
-0.9952629208564758,
0.9140031933784485,
-0.20854750275611877,
-0.04601458087563515,
-0.40062034130096436,
0.31458714604377747,
-0.0022035036236047745,
0.48300832509994507,
0.4662817418575287,
0.27117493748664856,
0.033986520022153854,
-0.266484797000885,
0.1808178424835205,
0.38603752851486206,
-0.3589288592338562,
-0.04630032926797867,
0.46584612131118774,
0.24472947418689728,
-0.071682870388031,
0.43089497089385986,
-0.007811559364199638,
-0.6453866958618164,
0.7469770312309265,
0.5539442896842957,
0.8353191614151001,
0.08609471470117569,
-0.2182377427816391,
-0.0465959832072258,
0.17970499396324158,
0.04680647701025009,
0.7931888699531555,
-0.3010176122188568,
-0.5695629715919495,
-0.5880194306373596,
-0.6093987226486206,
-0.24237914383411407,
-0.09436448663473129,
-0.6276541948318481,
0.344010591506958,
-0.5529773235321045,
-0.0890345498919487,
-0.37946203351020813,
0.27563250064849854,
-0.8259800672531128,
0.14209987223148346,
0.05814998596906662,
1.5387262105941772,
-0.7819298505783081,
0.8604834675788879,
0.661831259727478,
-0.2568380534648895,
-0.4835214614868164,
0.09844975918531418,
-0.20493894815444946,
-0.7320159673690796,
0.23501448333263397,
0.49799472093582153,
-0.17493540048599243,
-0.04801759868860245,
-0.5312190651893616,
-0.8747422099113464,
1.234604001045227,
0.5662251114845276,
-0.5789077877998352,
0.08208531886339188,
0.24976934492588043,
0.36639586091041565,
-0.5236501097679138,
0.2346160113811493,
0.8940669298171997,
0.2593159079551697,
-0.19736458361148834,
-0.6755432486534119,
-0.11153544485569,
-0.404361367225647,
0.021360857412219048,
0.35226067900657654,
-0.9118581414222717,
0.5213388800621033,
-0.26080429553985596,
-0.2426437884569168,
0.33572080731391907,
0.7489106059074402,
0.4031887948513031,
0.5246224403381348,
0.8241831064224243,
0.44651561975479126,
0.8328882455825806,
-0.20263901352882385,
0.7794163823127747,
-0.6298247575759888,
0.1347193568944931,
1.2740817070007324,
-0.4919056296348572,
0.7917293310165405,
0.5278607606887817,
-0.24983640015125275,
0.35227566957473755,
0.7495183944702148,
0.14772050082683563,
0.40475672483444214,
0.3465323746204376,
-0.2738571763038635,
-0.2791619896888733,
-0.2802654802799225,
-0.8754037618637085,
0.46240684390068054,
0.3950958847999573,
-0.08542823046445847,
0.10394029319286346,
-0.2944137156009674,
0.012331532314419746,
0.20583973824977875,
-0.20318137109279633,
0.6766327023506165,
0.10096073150634766,
-0.5895295143127441,
0.5282338857650757,
-0.10210009664297104,
0.549473226070404,
-0.7193358540534973,
-0.011756558902561665,
-0.6642517447471619,
-0.12883330881595612,
-0.3423827588558197,
-0.696833610534668,
0.33965083956718445,
0.2345530241727829,
-0.16042442619800568,
-0.3312288224697113,
0.8490422964096069,
-0.6887093782424927,
-0.292782723903656,
0.39062559604644775,
0.6049718260765076,
0.08307624608278275,
0.009009642526507378,
-0.6799727082252502,
0.25813350081443787,
-0.029407134279608727,
-0.05827244743704796,
0.25415411591529846,
0.12241484224796295,
-0.10484929382801056,
0.6119080781936646,
0.811989426612854,
-0.0257028229534626,
0.07070785760879517,
0.30523940920829773,
0.901406466960907,
-0.6802113652229309,
-0.37206611037254333,
-0.7301803827285767,
0.28731122612953186,
0.017147203907370567,
-0.1375584751367569,
0.5632469058036804,
0.978237509727478,
1.1874324083328247,
0.030890218913555145,
0.7124928832054138,
0.16817545890808105,
0.2978381812572479,
-0.7023559212684631,
0.7088409066200256,
-0.43924203515052795,
0.3750772178173065,
-0.19761686027050018,
-1.0070748329162598,
-0.37093791365623474,
0.39985084533691406,
-0.1846567839384079,
0.13140226900577545,
0.5067143440246582,
0.9038048386573792,
0.11470586806535721,
-0.03785765916109085,
0.16185644268989563,
-0.02201223373413086,
0.08377699553966522,
0.4418173134326935,
1.1238117218017578,
-0.3400164544582367,
0.44791102409362793,
-0.27035874128341675,
-0.3978555500507355,
-0.3610418140888214,
-0.8856827616691589,
-0.769606351852417,
-0.41459473967552185,
-0.1985635757446289,
-0.3702945113182068,
0.020564233884215355,
1.2810637950897217,
0.4816220998764038,
-0.5931294560432434,
-0.43447861075401306,
-0.04067995771765709,
0.24427026510238647,
-0.1597009003162384,
-0.1355406641960144,
0.16698184609413147,
-0.4343872666358948,
-0.34818610548973083,
0.5519325733184814,
0.40401241183280945,
-0.02224324271082878,
-0.06770042330026627,
-0.41600918769836426,
-0.4415792226791382,
0.12766478955745697,
0.6876192688941956,
0.039067432284355164,
-0.545680582523346,
-0.13897860050201416,
0.145097553730011,
-0.33225464820861816,
0.03679326921701431,
1.0605294704437256,
-0.6487306356430054,
0.3885875940322876,
0.6846922039985657,
0.9646950364112854,
0.37475281953811646,
-0.08423759043216705,
0.5149274468421936,
-0.7512238025665283,
0.0041033606976270676,
0.044931188225746155,
0.6721716523170471,
0.26057863235473633,
-0.24305012822151184,
0.9285874366760254,
0.25454777479171753,
-0.5307945609092712,
-1.0160222053527832,
0.10234591364860535,
-0.8948969841003418,
0.08651363849639893,
0.9231213331222534,
-0.17742151021957397,
0.15051499009132385,
0.028029751032590866,
-0.00892440602183342,
0.41762951016426086,
-0.16896675527095795,
0.30689117312431335,
0.7172497510910034,
-0.1659441590309143,
0.10853294283151627,
-0.525648295879364,
0.5504109859466553,
0.7030370831489563,
-0.8573988676071167,
0.09791084378957748,
0.5845339298248291,
0.28097453713417053,
-0.3506637513637543,
1.0917335748672485,
-0.11781631410121918,
0.6468315124511719,
-0.3985542058944702,
0.17223165929317474,
-0.2888660132884979,
-0.6207199692726135,
-0.47646790742874146,
-0.30786898732185364,
0.16541434824466705,
-0.01248389296233654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04224v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04224v3
|
Aligners: Decoupling LLMs and Alignment
| 2024-03-07T04:54:56 | 2024-06-16T15:59:11 |
Lilian Ngweta, Mayank Agarwal, Subha Maity, Alex Gittens, Yuekai Sun, Mikhail Yurochkin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) need to be aligned with human expectations to
ensure their safety and utility in most applications. Alignment is challenging,
costly, and needs to be repeated for every LLM and alignment criterion. We
propose to decouple LLMs and alignment by training aligner models that can be
used to align any LLM for a given criteria on an as-needed basis, thus also
reducing the potential negative impacts of alignment on performance. Our recipe
for training the aligner models solely relies on synthetic data generated with
a (prompted) LLM and can be easily adjusted for a variety of alignment
criteria. We use the same synthetic data to train inspectors, binary
miss-alignment classification models to guide a "squad" of multiple aligners.
Our empirical results demonstrate consistent improvements when applying aligner
squad to various LLMs, including chat-aligned models, across several
instruction-following and red-teaming datasets.
|
[
-0.02702372707426548,
-0.21649880707263947,
0.39911046624183655,
0.01827550120651722,
0.04263376072049141,
0.43775370717048645,
-0.19368748366832733,
-0.5946325659751892,
-0.06413411349058151,
0.4113309979438782,
-0.7686872482299805,
-0.20582349598407745,
-0.44440579414367676,
0.24992546439170837,
-0.5574740767478943,
0.8126899003982544,
-0.2738252878189087,
0.2219463288784027,
-0.32557979226112366,
-0.2124662697315216,
-0.665320634841919,
-0.25291797518730164,
-0.67404705286026,
-0.5525678992271423,
0.4617346227169037,
0.3740038573741913,
0.5653912425041199,
0.8507232666015625,
0.4623800814151764,
0.39440616965293884,
0.10023459792137146,
0.30029425024986267,
-0.7500947713851929,
0.15966637432575226,
-0.3308846056461334,
-0.41155534982681274,
-0.5150248408317566,
0.1197500005364418,
0.7372609972953796,
0.6970486044883728,
-0.3288189768791199,
0.05573180317878723,
0.06565269082784653,
0.5373693704605103,
-0.585613489151001,
0.1335739940404892,
-0.7123415470123291,
-0.1781550496816635,
0.36056163907051086,
0.10777554661035538,
-0.45535168051719666,
-0.5347872376441956,
-0.06230032444000244,
-0.6004570722579956,
0.18655337393283844,
0.12193663418292999,
0.8374785780906677,
0.34190240502357483,
-0.40350866317749023,
-0.07972624897956848,
-0.7453709840774536,
0.8906482458114624,
-0.44471219182014465,
0.6322048306465149,
-0.11130139976739883,
0.2559226155281067,
-0.15176038444042206,
-0.2544194161891937,
-0.6619831919670105,
0.09917078912258148,
-0.13006266951560974,
0.2847782373428345,
0.02519485168159008,
0.013963834382593632,
-0.19044962525367737,
0.15226101875305176,
-0.5325800180435181,
0.6992849707603455,
-0.4578799903392792,
-0.2395378053188324,
0.893700361251831,
0.3449747860431671,
0.47254908084869385,
0.31423231959342957,
-0.637488603591919,
-0.29647231101989746,
-0.9119120240211487,
-0.26167887449264526,
0.2617450952529907,
0.3809576630592346,
-0.22675156593322754,
0.5935816168785095,
-0.011257266625761986,
0.6428925395011902,
0.26281052827835083,
-0.41271042823791504,
0.12977318465709686,
-0.4451190233230591,
-0.1469583362340927,
0.3295624852180481,
0.7684544920921326,
0.49379411339759827,
0.20906341075897217,
-0.4179520606994629,
-0.5532495379447937,
0.33092546463012695,
0.3351062834262848,
-0.5913996696472168,
-0.24006390571594238,
0.20485413074493408,
-0.06490329653024673,
-0.38638052344322205,
-0.007992084138095379,
-0.3939034044742584,
-0.37503325939178467,
-0.8636513948440552,
0.37499552965164185,
-0.3315766155719757,
-0.18140649795532227,
0.07664801925420761,
-0.1999359279870987,
0.8182086944580078,
0.2712840139865875,
-1.2046912908554077,
0.3267366290092468,
0.9473490715026855,
0.5610408782958984,
-0.3814760446548462,
-0.4381520450115204,
-0.4728999733924866,
0.41630005836486816,
-0.35538703203201294,
0.7477900981903076,
-0.5333322882652283,
-0.2564394474029541,
0.1683022677898407,
0.12520849704742432,
-0.33980512619018555,
-0.52593594789505,
0.3186347186565399,
-0.36336448788642883,
0.2761867046356201,
-0.02418028749525547,
-0.7578343749046326,
0.05141696706414223,
0.46559348702430725,
-0.7171055674552917,
0.6934819221496582,
0.3070380389690399,
-0.16761785745620728,
0.4215236306190491,
-0.49107789993286133,
-0.29427361488342285,
0.06365764886140823,
-0.1947346329689026,
-0.5349628925323486,
0.03653610125184059,
0.37504878640174866,
0.27388274669647217,
-0.24905046820640564,
0.18118351697921753,
-0.17318974435329437,
-0.5136842727661133,
0.1872316598892212,
-0.1859617978334427,
0.6380088329315186,
-0.03224050626158714,
0.07005149126052856,
0.3451986312866211,
-0.7537519931793213,
-0.01245530229061842,
0.009404576383531094,
-0.7665277123451233,
0.023032670840620995,
0.061380524188280106,
-0.05128045380115509,
0.0507512092590332,
0.2777934968471527,
-0.47804105281829834,
0.17856071889400482,
-0.610987663269043,
0.3473167419433594,
0.8817510008811951,
-0.1862962543964386,
0.8517239689826965,
-0.5175809860229492,
0.5676043629646301,
-0.04380115866661072,
-0.1346571296453476,
-0.008524219505488873,
0.07072197645902634,
-0.8444656729698181,
-0.5334280133247375,
0.321195513010025,
0.6932235360145569,
-0.37704673409461975,
0.7965853214263916,
-0.5144144296646118,
-0.47370800375938416,
-0.8784235119819641,
0.3993764817714691,
0.5627119541168213,
0.3859894871711731,
0.17973430454730988,
0.0013882492203265429,
-0.8726300597190857,
-0.7176046371459961,
-0.33044761419296265,
-0.12041933089494705,
-0.10456602275371552,
-0.22496072947978973,
0.33207646012306213,
-0.43537190556526184,
0.9165024161338806,
-0.21631772816181183,
-0.2161281257867813,
-0.48442864418029785,
-0.25561052560806274,
-0.0935029536485672,
0.562283992767334,
0.28097817301750183,
-0.5395582318305969,
-0.30641019344329834,
0.08875881880521774,
-0.7253534197807312,
0.050802167505025864,
-0.1880231499671936,
-0.21079424023628235,
0.3631908893585205,
0.7113615870475769,
-0.57599276304245,
0.08237921446561813,
0.7791550755500793,
0.09806396812200546,
0.44349205493927,
-0.04576526954770088,
-0.04886898025870323,
-1.3217521905899048,
-0.0464937649667263,
0.12529177963733673,
-0.37226566672325134,
-0.6794664859771729,
0.08969639986753464,
0.20045650005340576,
-0.21920813620090485,
-0.4287456274032593,
0.6713054776191711,
-0.6575600504875183,
0.06016586348414421,
-0.17600947618484497,
0.32705923914909363,
0.07440976053476334,
0.177297905087471,
0.07175759971141815,
0.8488391041755676,
0.3940249979496002,
-0.513142466545105,
0.4135165810585022,
0.5784148573875427,
-0.4084942042827606,
0.5897588729858398,
-0.764560341835022,
0.08287400007247925,
-0.20756670832633972,
0.23497241735458374,
-1.026876449584961,
-0.5705644488334656,
0.10255089402198792,
-0.020930545404553413,
0.5696544647216797,
-0.11756744980812073,
-0.359852135181427,
-0.11676213890314102,
-0.3263587951660156,
0.38145720958709717,
0.5774754285812378,
-0.8527918457984924,
0.7712002992630005,
0.4583945572376251,
0.1342940777540207,
-0.6109482645988464,
-0.4518953263759613,
-0.12147781252861023,
-0.49724432826042175,
-0.5329105854034424,
0.503212571144104,
0.13880197703838348,
-0.17865590751171112,
-0.06912319362163544,
-0.28457480669021606,
0.013514929451048374,
0.18011677265167236,
0.30088627338409424,
0.581730842590332,
-0.15928131341934204,
0.2582187056541443,
-0.17991015315055847,
-0.17181651294231415,
0.07203266769647598,
-0.15469448268413544,
0.47250670194625854,
0.046053480356931686,
-0.3741246163845062,
-0.5347905158996582,
0.2995016276836395,
0.5116442441940308,
-0.2318935990333557,
1.0597424507141113,
0.451062947511673,
-0.2910608649253845,
-0.09843581914901733,
-0.7161802649497986,
-0.3346051275730133,
-0.5180439949035645,
0.4497582018375397,
-0.10721134394407272,
-0.8674418926239014,
0.41025209426879883,
-0.14675839245319366,
0.2946290671825409,
0.12792076170444489,
0.4582225978374481,
-0.378616064786911,
1.148065209388733,
0.8642276525497437,
-0.3525449335575104,
0.5609138607978821,
0.1595931351184845,
0.4419524371623993,
-0.8521544337272644,
-0.33611491322517395,
-0.3977543115615845,
-0.5240939855575562,
-0.5493245720863342,
-0.0182635560631752,
0.10958825796842575,
0.10132253915071487,
-0.3681783080101013,
0.4745299220085144,
-0.5314753651618958,
0.9991186261177063,
0.30989977717399597,
0.20205743610858917,
0.04974457249045372,
-0.15332400798797607,
0.247115820646286,
0.2347157746553421,
-0.6817933917045593,
-0.572897732257843,
0.9036730527877808,
0.23920828104019165,
1.0673905611038208,
0.19624613225460052,
1.0881558656692505,
-0.3306649327278137,
0.4334380328655243,
-0.9417697787284851,
0.5274766087532043,
-0.08077193051576614,
-0.4722868800163269,
-0.1096077635884285,
-0.48817574977874756,
-1.1089699268341064,
0.15169578790664673,
-0.35721534490585327,
-0.6799435019493103,
-0.0671781674027443,
0.34170258045196533,
-0.3186034858226776,
0.032648246735334396,
-0.8641374111175537,
1.0188941955566406,
-0.2984403073787689,
0.012132139876484871,
0.02819576859474182,
-0.6988445520401001,
0.6893424391746521,
-0.2132836878299713,
-0.012768321670591831,
-0.24301159381866455,
0.0037227158900350332,
0.5552725195884705,
-0.2713055908679962,
1.1643242835998535,
0.23288866877555847,
-0.2204553186893463,
0.04220365732908249,
0.01604606956243515,
0.5212201476097107,
-0.30245891213417053,
0.03586455434560776,
-0.08928908407688141,
-0.04407632350921631,
-0.2790563106536865,
-0.6128963232040405,
0.6403881907463074,
-1.022666096687317,
-0.7481875419616699,
-0.27339044213294983,
-0.823970377445221,
-0.16293710470199585,
0.10726701468229294,
-0.044728852808475494,
0.28689852356910706,
-0.21023711562156677,
0.017766140401363373,
0.566567063331604,
0.18986450135707855,
0.37059229612350464,
0.4569927155971527,
0.041468296200037,
-0.4648546576499939,
0.7627473473548889,
-0.26242464780807495,
0.5321343541145325,
0.4608747661113739,
0.031096477061510086,
-0.5571683049201965,
-0.46269842982292175,
0.06039439141750336,
0.318738728761673,
-0.6831181645393372,
-0.3496994972229004,
-0.19066065549850464,
-0.3436955213546753,
-0.5005359649658203,
-0.32596486806869507,
-0.27480024099349976,
-0.41946908831596375,
-0.4646706283092499,
-0.16584298014640808,
0.21170109510421753,
0.5989493727684021,
0.033022139221429825,
0.5633490085601807,
-1.0744099617004395,
0.0756705105304718,
0.2077278047800064,
0.21776962280273438,
-0.39931631088256836,
-0.554953932762146,
-0.09778536856174469,
0.06268933415412903,
-0.3340660631656647,
-0.6321102976799011,
0.3784262239933014,
0.22030818462371826,
0.7124977707862854,
0.35968253016471863,
-0.0021194485016167164,
0.9158608317375183,
-0.5255827307701111,
0.47527435421943665,
0.4664873778820038,
-0.9600059390068054,
0.5186595320701599,
-0.12150885164737701,
0.20291642844676971,
0.6097846627235413,
0.4317157566547394,
-0.4216575622558594,
-0.3392397165298462,
-0.2537866532802582,
-0.6674683094024658,
0.7521792054176331,
-0.029834261164069176,
0.15590183436870575,
-0.04810899496078491,
0.4227580428123474,
-0.10299508273601532,
-0.023188823834061623,
-0.7502503991127014,
0.23998641967773438,
0.22175638377666473,
-0.8631052374839783,
-0.17765550315380096,
-0.13346683979034424,
-0.46621647477149963,
-0.07691339403390884,
0.6414327025413513,
-0.14912331104278564,
-0.005465122405439615,
-0.23047085106372833,
-0.3538280129432678,
-0.017901437357068062,
0.1508386880159378,
0.5555702447891235,
0.6006118059158325,
-0.024713436141610146,
0.07850681990385056,
0.30747678875923157,
-0.13040103018283844,
0.4517284333705902,
-0.19167576730251312,
0.030039064586162567,
-0.39275410771369934,
0.37994125485420227,
0.5144679546356201,
0.5183473229408264,
-0.7560136318206787,
0.29378029704093933,
0.11816326528787613,
-0.13789020478725433,
-0.3087969422340393,
0.45598888397216797,
0.2962591350078583,
0.2617691457271576,
-0.3187370002269745,
0.19197721779346466,
-0.3739044964313507,
-0.6397950649261475,
0.17668133974075317,
0.5319764614105225,
-0.3346928060054779,
-0.24500371515750885,
0.5510033965110779,
0.46846655011177063,
-0.423883855342865,
0.8673222661018372,
-0.034652289003133774,
-0.7094683647155762,
0.4290085732936859,
0.8049806356430054,
0.7022426724433899,
-0.48738497495651245,
-0.1751699596643448,
0.3957747220993042,
0.3347983658313751,
-0.5509565472602844,
0.03005676530301571,
0.2792271673679352,
-1.1655288934707642,
-0.4965578615665436,
-0.3770732283592224,
-0.46507570147514343,
-0.11743637919425964,
-0.6837916374206543,
0.5443606376647949,
-0.26795220375061035,
0.10110104084014893,
-0.060480501502752304,
-0.1722867786884308,
-0.6109300255775452,
-0.03838402405381203,
0.1581086814403534,
0.6949589848518372,
-0.9407804608345032,
0.505641520023346,
0.6939505338668823,
-0.4583949148654938,
-0.9782193899154663,
-0.21232186257839203,
0.3097677528858185,
-1.0531255006790161,
0.4309452474117279,
0.34593629837036133,
-0.1460101455450058,
-0.01669829525053501,
-0.5277589559555054,
-0.737545907497406,
1.145500659942627,
0.5600589513778687,
-0.8202084898948669,
-0.20698262751102448,
0.24038231372833252,
0.2799323797225952,
-0.5123604536056519,
-0.12377744913101196,
0.9375215768814087,
0.21480965614318848,
0.0549037866294384,
-0.8665222525596619,
0.12891609966754913,
0.10073060542345047,
-0.09467437118291855,
0.4358360171318054,
-0.6293461918830872,
0.5359238386154175,
-0.17001695930957794,
-0.469264417886734,
0.24090009927749634,
0.32295265793800354,
0.4681873619556427,
-0.07796689122915268,
0.37784698605537415,
0.6279861927032471,
0.8615849614143372,
-0.24225275218486786,
0.8490136861801147,
-0.2989393472671509,
0.16627779603004456,
1.4346338510513306,
-0.6305685043334961,
0.9620275497436523,
0.47339433431625366,
0.024033477529883385,
0.3195360004901886,
0.4473237991333008,
-0.1780337542295456,
0.33131301403045654,
0.09211033582687378,
-0.28727319836616516,
-0.6355301737785339,
0.047154564410448074,
0.0246119387447834,
0.6947954893112183,
0.23956187069416046,
-0.1821422129869461,
-0.22548791766166687,
-0.35368672013282776,
-0.09234810620546341,
0.17819741368293762,
-0.2048468291759491,
1.1167072057724,
0.01987697370350361,
-0.8270003795623779,
0.6096494197845459,
-0.13533756136894226,
0.33391138911247253,
-0.5223764181137085,
0.012840403243899345,
-0.24477031826972961,
0.4877115488052368,
-0.3003135621547699,
-0.7873318791389465,
0.23445942997932434,
-0.1679401993751526,
-0.13915294408798218,
-0.31162044405937195,
0.7088931798934937,
-0.8681925535202026,
-0.5261924862861633,
-0.029193079099059105,
0.35657137632369995,
0.02333988808095455,
0.2561359703540802,
-0.4317474663257599,
0.2560684382915497,
-0.02631269581615925,
0.2493470311164856,
0.34200844168663025,
0.2786487936973572,
0.14670874178409576,
0.7674646377563477,
0.5880059599876404,
-0.042907536029815674,
0.029305467382073402,
0.08280695229768753,
0.9469699859619141,
-0.6375829577445984,
-0.11640069633722305,
-1.021196961402893,
0.7052946090698242,
-0.14418362081050873,
-0.0887218713760376,
0.6419007778167725,
0.6221094727516174,
0.8557458519935608,
-0.06475811451673508,
0.6564207673072815,
0.4565356373786926,
0.34508371353149414,
-0.7189762592315674,
0.6630464792251587,
-0.31482940912246704,
0.38615164160728455,
0.29830828309059143,
-1.109551191329956,
-0.3786180317401886,
0.6472457051277161,
0.027273032814264297,
-0.08134450763463974,
0.3531310260295868,
0.9432181715965271,
-0.1774074286222458,
-0.12188524007797241,
0.15454386174678802,
-0.22207054495811462,
0.5863577127456665,
0.6928693056106567,
1.1121172904968262,
-0.4639817178249359,
0.6073301434516907,
-0.03417769446969032,
-0.03385326266288757,
-0.1435529887676239,
-0.8975394368171692,
-1.1362881660461426,
-0.27482283115386963,
-0.6253273487091064,
-0.13529598712921143,
0.025119157508015633,
1.1646360158920288,
0.7296337485313416,
-0.8102061748504639,
-0.26454028487205505,
-0.08623018860816956,
0.1902390420436859,
-0.16209055483341217,
-0.1499064713716507,
0.017165470868349075,
-0.6921790242195129,
-0.7301244735717773,
0.6316042542457581,
0.08427231013774872,
0.463239461183548,
-0.09026539325714111,
-0.15316154062747955,
0.08019908517599106,
0.09834974259138107,
0.43136802315711975,
0.33434438705444336,
-0.7799702882766724,
-0.5288616418838501,
-0.017823008820414543,
-0.1367439180612564,
0.14312979578971863,
0.5978456735610962,
-0.7148148417472839,
0.24326026439666748,
0.30602261424064636,
0.7785463333129883,
0.030669905245304108,
0.3222696781158447,
0.9690283536911011,
-1.122380256652832,
-0.05660489946603775,
0.11535770446062088,
0.5550878643989563,
0.3681158721446991,
-0.08759735524654388,
0.5737094879150391,
-0.13222381472587585,
-0.6167815327644348,
-0.9898681044578552,
0.2838772237300873,
-1.0073291063308716,
0.041125573217868805,
1.122976541519165,
-0.052744120359420776,
-0.28100496530532837,
0.13069531321525574,
-0.03311105817556381,
0.27109193801879883,
-0.1923997700214386,
0.8677247166633606,
0.5644705295562744,
0.01497594267129898,
-0.32256248593330383,
0.06274913996458054,
0.3857785165309906,
0.2387184053659439,
-1.0606086254119873,
0.18896858394145966,
0.5317253470420837,
0.5235263705253601,
0.08897130936384201,
-0.004637561272829771,
-0.09393071383237839,
0.16470198333263397,
-0.04338471218943596,
0.1463431566953659,
0.11212856322526932,
-0.3407553732395172,
-0.5532171726226807,
-0.226348876953125,
-0.0012976160505786538,
-0.3413218557834625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04222v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04222v1
|
Self-Evaluation of Large Language Model based on Glass-box Features
| 2024-03-07T04:50:38 | 2024-03-07T04:50:38 |
Hui Huang, Yingqi Qu, Jing Liu, Muyun Yang, Tiejun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The proliferation of open-source Large Language Models (LLMs) underscores the
pressing need for evaluation methods. Existing works primarily rely on external
evaluators, focusing on training and prompting strategies. However, a crucial
aspect - model-aware glass-box features - is overlooked. In this study, we
explore the utility of glass-box features under the scenario of
self-evaluation, namely applying an LLM to evaluate its own output. We
investigate various glass-box feature groups and discovered that the softmax
distribution serves as a reliable indicator for quality evaluation.
Furthermore, we propose two strategies to enhance the evaluation by
incorporating features derived from references. Experimental results on public
benchmarks validate the feasibility of self-evaluation of LLMs using glass-box
features.
|
[
-0.571139931678772,
-0.48841726779937744,
0.6409198641777039,
0.3086544871330261,
-0.22693297266960144,
-0.14657841622829437,
-0.40571293234825134,
-0.3184596002101898,
-0.05113162100315094,
0.5253676176071167,
-0.427132248878479,
-0.4503229856491089,
-0.45630013942718506,
0.2910129129886627,
-0.6276017427444458,
1.039994478225708,
0.04046458378434181,
0.041472867131233215,
-0.18062259256839752,
-0.24251854419708252,
-0.4421911835670471,
-0.4496006667613983,
-0.06955404579639435,
-0.26848453283309937,
0.19640573859214783,
0.2371380627155304,
0.8026393055915833,
0.5563667416572571,
0.47259458899497986,
0.35942506790161133,
0.027478668838739395,
-0.13408063352108002,
-0.5294955968856812,
0.04137202724814415,
-0.14803916215896606,
-0.29083460569381714,
-0.4563215672969818,
0.3136846721172333,
1.0893447399139404,
0.4096195697784424,
-0.06433311104774475,
0.42525210976600647,
0.4552314877510071,
0.6288314461708069,
-0.5652446150779724,
0.2168138474225998,
-0.4891993999481201,
0.3983287513256073,
-0.09345009177923203,
-0.16723577678203583,
-0.30461427569389343,
-0.45333951711654663,
0.12288718670606613,
-0.0075129116885364056,
0.2946200966835022,
-0.10209082067012787,
0.5236672163009644,
0.02326582372188568,
-0.33097338676452637,
-0.3008490800857544,
-0.7097292542457581,
0.6421083807945251,
-0.6452332735061646,
0.5098457336425781,
0.12448561191558838,
0.42296090722084045,
-0.07820528745651245,
-0.2781914174556732,
-0.3668934404850006,
-0.6680732369422913,
-0.02354767546057701,
0.06462833285331726,
-0.1568858027458191,
-0.23309947550296783,
-0.2338741421699524,
0.6740483045578003,
-0.4433976709842682,
0.16345931589603424,
-0.35089975595474243,
-0.19799993932247162,
0.8122676014900208,
0.20341654121875763,
-0.02207034081220627,
-0.3215865194797516,
-0.5399946570396423,
-0.08297862857580185,
-0.5376098155975342,
-0.21535106003284454,
0.2741197347640991,
0.2466779202222824,
-0.0032407448161393404,
0.7085514664649963,
-0.2940322756767273,
0.34113094210624695,
-0.08209773153066635,
-0.1401473879814148,
0.6161458492279053,
-0.3722973167896271,
-0.1657997965812683,
-0.21567830443382263,
0.9516000151634216,
0.028627077117562294,
0.3326658308506012,
-0.2675034701824188,
-0.5858391523361206,
-0.15253929793834686,
0.02155458927154541,
-0.791296124458313,
0.08009351789951324,
0.16858309507369995,
-0.7717264294624329,
-0.3800048232078552,
-0.18987558782100677,
-0.7719317674636841,
-0.3440902829170227,
0.13211046159267426,
0.5225561261177063,
-0.07017681002616882,
-0.5475907921791077,
-0.0842970758676529,
-0.02635023556649685,
-0.03613104671239853,
0.3499024510383606,
-0.6619282364845276,
0.2857924699783325,
0.7019646167755127,
1.0101372003555298,
-0.36993107199668884,
-0.1807565838098526,
-0.6429557800292969,
-0.03114917315542698,
-0.4391307830810547,
0.8862186670303345,
-0.7750796675682068,
-0.4113471508026123,
0.05717451870441437,
-0.032918788492679596,
0.3274427056312561,
-0.7384371161460876,
0.18170367181301117,
-0.20948238670825958,
0.5287619233131409,
0.27277734875679016,
-0.6076840758323669,
0.09926892071962357,
0.1826181560754776,
-0.4941422939300537,
0.9010729193687439,
0.17161676287651062,
-0.4684470295906067,
0.30165794491767883,
-0.7027006149291992,
-0.30579274892807007,
0.3450450301170349,
-0.3107560873031616,
-0.550277829170227,
0.45852264761924744,
0.006932055577635765,
0.7032749652862549,
-0.3151898682117462,
0.2814238965511322,
-0.7366223931312561,
-0.24405346810817719,
0.5570551156997681,
-1.0946485996246338,
0.5186419486999512,
0.3883984386920929,
-0.39547887444496155,
0.19649922847747803,
-0.8619033694267273,
0.15064716339111328,
0.15478862822055817,
-0.3949064016342163,
-0.20602215826511383,
-0.2723029851913452,
0.027310190722346306,
-0.10023155808448792,
0.31668946146965027,
-0.3767741322517395,
0.04220392182469368,
-0.29455092549324036,
0.24688172340393066,
0.9346569776535034,
-0.16034790873527527,
0.34110358357429504,
-0.00868454109877348,
0.896466851234436,
-0.18429678678512573,
0.5233612656593323,
-0.07044456154108047,
-0.3433757424354553,
-0.4125611484050751,
-0.3146979510784149,
0.3572986423969269,
0.41475293040275574,
-0.34674420952796936,
0.4975273013114929,
0.016171054914593697,
-0.6223003268241882,
-0.33828291296958923,
0.8406078815460205,
0.5965330004692078,
-0.0040250481106340885,
0.044549692422151566,
-0.6851834058761597,
0.10495784133672714,
-1.0062801837921143,
-0.030289731919765472,
0.010557521134614944,
-0.09901583194732666,
0.2825426459312439,
0.28193920850753784,
-0.1142195612192154,
1.0106943845748901,
-0.5024418830871582,
-0.5107263922691345,
-0.2651415467262268,
0.011763953603804111,
0.2531546652317047,
0.22925619781017303,
0.37544670701026917,
-0.4779311418533325,
-0.15767641365528107,
-0.2769705355167389,
-0.7315371632575989,
-0.3620617389678955,
0.22640259563922882,
0.012349438853561878,
0.14716361463069916,
0.4167599678039551,
-0.40362441539764404,
0.15520848333835602,
0.9045422077178955,
-0.3279606103897095,
0.7677842378616333,
-0.3720739781856537,
0.01832086592912674,
-0.8193027973175049,
-0.1746208369731903,
0.3409075438976288,
-0.3916928768157959,
-0.1995602250099182,
-0.09312319755554199,
0.13759203255176544,
-0.25890207290649414,
-0.39818689227104187,
0.611247718334198,
-0.7756329774856567,
-0.28115004301071167,
-0.41831550002098083,
0.39249691367149353,
0.061512112617492676,
0.1578845977783203,
0.008565366268157959,
0.8795468211174011,
0.2916702926158905,
-0.33560967445373535,
0.4049495756626129,
-0.06913667172193527,
-0.7653502225875854,
0.45543232560157776,
-0.4399314820766449,
0.06853049248456955,
-0.14710558950901031,
0.0008111782954074442,
-1.0534402132034302,
0.17685279250144958,
0.3215163052082062,
-0.09621438384056091,
0.3229725956916809,
-0.17801222205162048,
-0.30002421140670776,
-0.4524228572845459,
-0.45474785566329956,
0.08177844434976578,
0.4834931194782257,
-0.31235772371292114,
0.38026830554008484,
0.3922271728515625,
-0.1298092156648636,
-0.45159611105918884,
-0.5155682563781738,
0.1008615791797638,
-0.47506681084632874,
-0.607059121131897,
-0.0542648583650589,
-0.22713527083396912,
-0.14912444353103638,
0.20881511270999908,
-0.018097810447216034,
0.11919790506362915,
0.2477644979953766,
0.22053831815719604,
0.1420028805732727,
-0.442036509513855,
0.3549957871437073,
-0.3888048827648163,
-0.3100845217704773,
-0.1467881202697754,
-0.09105105698108673,
0.4779958724975586,
-0.6774353384971619,
-0.40636444091796875,
-0.18706375360488892,
0.018857847899198532,
0.424369215965271,
-0.3786655068397522,
0.4777418375015259,
0.6181846857070923,
-0.11248914897441864,
-0.43093448877334595,
-0.9956142902374268,
-0.25965332984924316,
-0.5423277616500854,
0.5733518600463867,
-0.49863073229789734,
-1.0235861539840698,
0.2736548185348511,
-0.08917940407991409,
-0.3158532977104187,
0.37189024686813354,
0.58906489610672,
-0.03537234291434288,
0.8977866768836975,
0.8552832007408142,
-0.1232789158821106,
0.6098019480705261,
0.022387288510799408,
0.24564386904239655,
-1.021712064743042,
-0.055846139788627625,
-0.5472955107688904,
0.1871865689754486,
-0.5618364810943604,
-0.41139957308769226,
0.5640127062797546,
0.03236598148941994,
0.10791286826133728,
0.2574271559715271,
-0.34671178460121155,
0.2635782063007355,
0.3194183111190796,
0.07916425913572311,
0.5472234487533569,
0.13248266279697418,
0.02378731034696102,
0.2814550995826721,
-0.7720827460289001,
-0.7223078012466431,
1.0308865308761597,
0.9133789539337158,
1.1540331840515137,
-0.08128111064434052,
0.7148354649543762,
0.5412787199020386,
0.5705814361572266,
-0.6905823945999146,
0.7783047556877136,
-0.10299132764339447,
-0.6308485865592957,
-0.6583172678947449,
-0.7322423458099365,
-0.9612749218940735,
0.3508549630641937,
-0.21992020308971405,
-0.6092349290847778,
0.08251380920410156,
0.09496929496526718,
-0.28935813903808594,
-0.2099340707063675,
-1.0206468105316162,
1.1394226551055908,
-0.546454668045044,
-0.35465264320373535,
-0.33961760997772217,
0.1749325394630432,
0.36551201343536377,
-0.2097242921590805,
0.42676204442977905,
-0.513738214969635,
-0.008641854859888554,
0.5089775919914246,
-0.3544113039970398,
0.8140027523040771,
-0.033272840082645416,
-0.46522635221481323,
0.2770010828971863,
0.38372012972831726,
0.1767984926700592,
0.028574427589774132,
-0.045644279569387436,
0.2823590338230133,
0.0651317611336708,
0.012322485446929932,
-0.8170714974403381,
0.7237462997436523,
-0.5734012722969055,
-1.100197196006775,
-0.2875460088253021,
-0.27993565797805786,
-0.38950464129447937,
0.04250213876366615,
-0.07348643243312836,
0.6628949046134949,
-0.17857396602630615,
0.36071324348449707,
0.2609151005744934,
-0.30258163809776306,
0.5056094527244568,
0.6242037415504456,
-0.6590350270271301,
-0.3420466482639313,
0.9176532626152039,
0.37542805075645447,
0.5076740980148315,
-0.12030202150344849,
0.7373244762420654,
-0.3675439953804016,
-0.6422283053398132,
-0.69780033826828,
0.25389033555984497,
-0.8744170665740967,
-0.16338516771793365,
-0.2465079426765442,
-0.2808281183242798,
-0.33351758122444153,
0.17771275341510773,
-0.6819034814834595,
-0.19491834938526154,
0.10543719679117203,
-0.056340236216783524,
0.2392345666885376,
0.9772940278053284,
0.0072548650205135345,
-0.14128714799880981,
-0.7885067462921143,
0.1446886956691742,
0.5497502684593201,
0.9105349183082581,
0.0864805057644844,
-0.591839075088501,
-0.26611101627349854,
-0.26723411679267883,
-0.25261613726615906,
-0.916377067565918,
0.2182074934244156,
0.14007508754730225,
0.7935885787010193,
0.5040067434310913,
-0.16525010764598846,
0.31795868277549744,
-0.49763166904449463,
0.5602296590805054,
0.19283175468444824,
-0.9870820641517639,
0.4717565178871155,
-0.05011599138379097,
0.3158600926399231,
0.34550756216049194,
0.21158480644226074,
-0.31506192684173584,
-0.5593971610069275,
-0.41162335872650146,
-0.45700547099113464,
0.40386876463890076,
0.29686471819877625,
0.44616732001304626,
-0.055492062121629715,
0.02957240492105484,
0.2386658787727356,
0.3451599180698395,
-1.1091920137405396,
-0.03639175370335579,
-0.16913829743862152,
-0.2855524718761444,
-0.19794288277626038,
-0.5342615842819214,
0.0006176593014970422,
0.17408429086208344,
0.6428438425064087,
-0.16216033697128296,
-0.022097229957580566,
0.12316137552261353,
-0.13509482145309448,
0.0029171775095164776,
0.6154040694236755,
0.2156543880701065,
0.8801063895225525,
-0.1426866352558136,
0.20349299907684326,
0.27822527289390564,
-0.1295202374458313,
0.24057959020137787,
-0.10989426076412201,
-0.18050481379032135,
-0.043527115136384964,
0.16311000287532806,
0.614641010761261,
0.14654409885406494,
-0.682852029800415,
0.8111472129821777,
0.1554422825574875,
0.33411386609077454,
-0.3961957097053528,
0.24590778350830078,
0.026629967615008354,
0.5224581956863403,
0.3313135802745819,
-0.3218627870082855,
0.4314267337322235,
-0.9127806425094604,
0.16078220307826996,
0.7943269610404968,
-0.4352297782897949,
0.07956862449645996,
0.28490984439849854,
0.23944495618343353,
-0.3829509913921356,
0.28377360105514526,
-0.15974408388137817,
-0.5300074815750122,
0.6119749546051025,
0.5944819450378418,
0.9689456820487976,
-0.3184683322906494,
0.3817358613014221,
-0.0049330019392073154,
0.520939290523529,
-0.024477461352944374,
-0.12276995182037354,
-0.09084588289260864,
-0.798740565776825,
-0.3654407858848572,
-0.8263067007064819,
-0.3728718161582947,
0.16444692015647888,
-0.3064221441745758,
0.46927976608276367,
-0.33394452929496765,
-0.2183765470981598,
-0.28596848249435425,
-0.2311638444662094,
-0.7924999594688416,
0.2154580056667328,
0.4572543501853943,
0.8902992606163025,
-0.8010257482528687,
0.7183384299278259,
0.07413306832313538,
-0.3257422149181366,
-0.5877101421356201,
-0.09338218718767166,
-0.1766175478696823,
-1.0259631872177124,
0.576451301574707,
0.29327166080474854,
-0.44545623660087585,
-0.3991366922855377,
-0.14653994143009186,
-0.9776923060417175,
0.7717519998550415,
0.3756396174430847,
-0.8641520738601685,
0.43789762258529663,
0.133710116147995,
0.6365278959274292,
-0.5847437381744385,
0.6136846542358398,
0.35299745202064514,
0.375443696975708,
-0.1884889453649521,
-1.1325364112854004,
0.16203220188617706,
-0.33273065090179443,
0.34448134899139404,
0.00011345444363541901,
-0.9530115127563477,
0.2291264533996582,
-0.049672726541757584,
-0.1976645141839981,
-0.18589724600315094,
0.7658631801605225,
-0.004133719485253096,
0.0478479228913784,
0.7823030352592468,
0.2042442113161087,
0.5637422800064087,
0.22548334300518036,
1.1603525876998901,
-0.31697192788124084,
0.5219675302505493,
1.0750306844711304,
-0.312263160943985,
1.0706692934036255,
0.1585603505373001,
-0.2823735475540161,
0.42927953600883484,
0.1610153317451477,
-0.42521265149116516,
0.4358755350112915,
0.3418688476085663,
-0.2083008885383606,
-0.23414663970470428,
0.1672557145357132,
-0.4873044490814209,
0.7711731791496277,
0.14246082305908203,
-0.4631217122077942,
-0.15187135338783264,
0.40984904766082764,
-0.0123983109369874,
-0.036077167838811874,
-0.3592173159122467,
0.7522611618041992,
0.14887763559818268,
-0.4898666739463806,
0.44381827116012573,
0.008749122731387615,
0.8177395462989807,
-0.6697619557380676,
0.07372536510229111,
-0.20853376388549805,
0.0987481027841568,
-0.18171326816082,
-1.1043009757995605,
0.20608647167682648,
0.09509559720754623,
0.07935204356908798,
-0.31921815872192383,
0.733162522315979,
-0.3314903676509857,
-0.7695075869560242,
0.5284563899040222,
0.4522149860858917,
0.31317129731178284,
-0.22414183616638184,
-0.55303555727005,
0.24941547214984894,
-0.2394418716430664,
-0.5861901044845581,
0.33037105202674866,
0.3929445743560791,
0.1170838475227356,
1.0049800872802734,
0.3528061807155609,
0.15360897779464722,
0.026248952373862267,
0.3048575520515442,
0.5143864750862122,
-0.6168879866600037,
-0.2322794497013092,
-0.9540237188339233,
0.2809450328350067,
0.04205990955233574,
-0.43191975355148315,
0.9231168031692505,
0.625710129737854,
0.8719673156738281,
-0.16905251145362854,
0.9578772783279419,
0.31808722019195557,
0.29261597990989685,
-0.5984340310096741,
0.6362013220787048,
-0.4914926290512085,
0.2732504904270172,
-0.3505536913871765,
-1.383476972579956,
0.06666316837072372,
0.760170042514801,
-0.4412938952445984,
0.3763844072818756,
0.5995953679084778,
0.8534384965896606,
-0.1198301613330841,
-0.0267044547945261,
0.5957754254341125,
0.4888664484024048,
0.1224677637219429,
0.2635670602321625,
0.9415814280509949,
-0.1160968691110611,
0.8034573197364807,
-0.37319353222846985,
-0.5221986770629883,
-0.2067502737045288,
-1.2100342512130737,
-0.9585576057434082,
-0.6345256567001343,
-0.5479113459587097,
-0.5705826282501221,
-0.05015682056546211,
0.9828916192054749,
0.780417799949646,
-0.6803990006446838,
-0.45109277963638306,
0.37329623103141785,
0.1481129676103592,
0.003121771151199937,
-0.24910180270671844,
0.22995656728744507,
-0.4404987096786499,
-0.5403342843055725,
0.5240887999534607,
0.6562694907188416,
0.0014140757266432047,
-1.1023563146591187,
0.07152202725410461,
0.5331031084060669,
0.07433989644050598,
0.6384478211402893,
-0.1088360920548439,
-0.5372710227966309,
-0.48206397891044617,
-0.319852739572525,
-0.11393922567367554,
0.2957310080528259,
0.6111081838607788,
-0.6682016253471375,
0.5381584167480469,
0.30770453810691833,
0.29917001724243164,
0.6480568647384644,
-0.1881904900074005,
0.7092412710189819,
-0.2035619020462036,
-0.053660161793231964,
0.02795674279332161,
0.5251264572143555,
0.4254409372806549,
-0.3105267286300659,
0.5356976389884949,
0.16918893158435822,
-0.46827882528305054,
-0.7121875286102295,
0.002369535155594349,
-0.6850936412811279,
-0.2267550677061081,
1.2628947496414185,
-0.18999138474464417,
-0.44370216131210327,
0.042766060680150986,
-0.06719524413347244,
-0.18471185863018036,
-0.23296307027339935,
1.0927832126617432,
0.8516959547996521,
0.043057747185230255,
-0.5181984305381775,
-0.5951138734817505,
0.18236693739891052,
0.3931191861629486,
-0.8245526552200317,
0.012957279570400715,
0.462760865688324,
0.7533420324325562,
0.13451683521270752,
0.5703707337379456,
-0.4066144526004791,
0.022097697481513023,
-0.16751542687416077,
0.11687065660953522,
-0.15908187627792358,
-0.4737575948238373,
-0.5411332249641418,
0.6272100806236267,
0.36055681109428406,
-0.01471153274178505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04212v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04212v1
|
Persona Extraction Through Semantic Similarity for Emotional Support Conversation Generation
| 2024-03-07T04:33:11 | 2024-03-07T04:33:11 |
Seunghee Han, Se Jin Park, Chae Won Kim, Yong Man Ro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Providing emotional support through dialogue systems is becoming increasingly
important in today's world, as it can support both mental health and social
interactions in many conversation scenarios. Previous works have shown that
using persona is effective for generating empathetic and supportive responses.
They have often relied on pre-provided persona rather than inferring them
during conversations. However, it is not always possible to obtain a user
persona before the conversation begins. To address this challenge, we propose
PESS (Persona Extraction through Semantic Similarity), a novel framework that
can automatically infer informative and consistent persona from dialogues. We
devise completeness loss and consistency loss based on semantic similarity
scores. The completeness loss encourages the model to generate missing persona
information, and the consistency loss guides the model to distinguish between
consistent and inconsistent persona. Our experimental results demonstrate that
high-quality persona information inferred by PESS is effective in generating
emotionally supportive responses.
|
[
-0.39218997955322266,
-0.6609360575675964,
0.9874140620231628,
0.4639981687068939,
-0.05882350355386734,
-0.07384436577558517,
-0.06671150028705597,
-0.37935665249824524,
0.6487223505973816,
0.6903159022331238,
-1.1272624731063843,
-0.22315728664398193,
-0.4079892635345459,
0.2758078873157501,
-0.10756345093250275,
0.9275076389312744,
0.1501976102590561,
0.054545290768146515,
-0.4482657015323639,
0.06685958057641983,
-0.5168523788452148,
-0.2248261719942093,
-0.7018016576766968,
-0.3082011640071869,
0.5276545286178589,
0.5093728303909302,
0.3462923765182495,
0.12565523386001587,
0.3250587582588196,
0.37996453046798706,
0.30121615529060364,
0.11974228918552399,
-0.506275475025177,
0.6169329881668091,
-0.29855138063430786,
-0.18293718993663788,
-0.5642726421356201,
-0.08623156696557999,
0.5180274248123169,
0.7747828960418701,
-0.20150138437747955,
0.13482491672039032,
0.4576639235019684,
0.4311208128929138,
-0.7097264528274536,
0.25217944383621216,
-0.6520765423774719,
0.2934916615486145,
-0.087567538022995,
-0.11480768769979477,
-0.45527973771095276,
-0.2957756221294403,
0.3867890536785126,
-0.6472843885421753,
-0.1736132800579071,
0.014859325252473354,
0.9035512804985046,
0.04328290745615959,
-0.2784051299095154,
-0.15450818836688995,
-0.6441227793693542,
0.7280955910682678,
-0.5186323523521423,
0.20417164266109467,
0.4757626950740814,
0.28891968727111816,
-0.233988419175148,
-0.5471336841583252,
-0.6874293088912964,
0.008976863697171211,
-0.17591600120067596,
0.23281213641166687,
-0.354682058095932,
0.13296088576316833,
0.27476853132247925,
0.004655775614082813,
-0.45801764726638794,
-0.41802823543548584,
0.1632136106491089,
-0.2746509611606598,
0.3724682927131653,
0.4218176007270813,
0.4103025197982788,
-0.3815158009529114,
-0.357347697019577,
-0.05821378901600838,
-0.4637753367424011,
0.01156601682305336,
0.3226456940174103,
0.06348048895597458,
0.07367242127656937,
0.4905151426792145,
-0.17833870649337769,
0.16668948531150818,
0.43777933716773987,
-0.24397745728492737,
0.3657885193824768,
0.17716622352600098,
-0.2799232602119446,
0.05711418017745018,
0.7591562271118164,
0.4934871196746826,
0.362048864364624,
-0.1438051462173462,
0.1053549200296402,
0.22912609577178955,
0.24638672173023224,
-0.8051303029060364,
-0.4246484339237213,
0.04448895901441574,
-0.807137131690979,
-0.18239134550094604,
0.33046358823776245,
-1.0604735612869263,
-0.5872235298156738,
-0.4490382671356201,
0.06032722443342209,
-0.5032041668891907,
-0.4293113648891449,
-0.03388939052820206,
0.10363827645778656,
0.4142492115497589,
0.35052332282066345,
-0.7251623272895813,
0.6523216962814331,
0.8000591993331909,
0.690863311290741,
-0.12075430899858475,
-0.01758899912238121,
-0.879956066608429,
0.33087751269340515,
-0.01606193371117115,
0.795509397983551,
-0.8612145781517029,
-0.26316604018211365,
-0.1569374054670334,
0.15990856289863586,
-0.04727828502655029,
-0.5129821300506592,
0.657734215259552,
-0.00039486048626713455,
0.30042189359664917,
-0.3816896975040436,
-0.7523324489593506,
0.2845342457294464,
0.2848933935165405,
-0.35581520199775696,
0.7923819422721863,
0.13395372033119202,
-0.8063845634460449,
0.16921837627887726,
-0.336622029542923,
-0.196996808052063,
0.24935901165008545,
-0.26228344440460205,
-0.43276241421699524,
0.20704138278961182,
0.007980604656040668,
0.6301699876785278,
-0.2940923571586609,
0.09887183457612991,
-0.7529041171073914,
-0.10607577115297318,
0.3036058247089386,
0.04890082776546478,
0.454481840133667,
0.18120555579662323,
-0.4446907639503479,
-0.13649238646030426,
-0.6790128350257874,
0.26550576090812683,
0.17948822677135468,
0.2717415988445282,
-0.5821774005889893,
0.14159446954727173,
-0.010983334854245186,
0.3964031934738159,
0.22453166544437408,
-1.1707501411437988,
-0.2957848906517029,
-0.4368477761745453,
0.17165471613407135,
0.8068153858184814,
0.17503568530082703,
0.4416041374206543,
-0.3594605028629303,
0.3590938448905945,
0.025665955618023872,
0.09588506817817688,
-0.36448535323143005,
-0.5919060707092285,
-0.51897794008255,
-0.46650683879852295,
-0.2027115821838379,
0.6369178295135498,
-0.47719863057136536,
0.6660295128822327,
-0.2466035634279251,
-0.42173370718955994,
-0.43209579586982727,
-0.018392393365502357,
0.6805565357208252,
0.8874270915985107,
0.0348941870033741,
-0.4970479905605316,
-0.7301581501960754,
-1.0431283712387085,
-0.35273921489715576,
-0.40751081705093384,
-0.3208293318748474,
0.6131508946418762,
0.12644314765930176,
-0.09874425828456879,
1.01561439037323,
-0.6394354701042175,
-0.11775106191635132,
-0.05392928421497345,
-0.07229111343622208,
-0.32954829931259155,
0.45739588141441345,
0.547697126865387,
-0.77820885181427,
-0.683652400970459,
-0.22657477855682373,
-0.6850089430809021,
-0.53932124376297,
-0.026511942967772484,
-0.5688264966011047,
-0.11429550498723984,
0.15420088171958923,
-0.662625789642334,
0.37140658497810364,
0.31374064087867737,
-0.6384469270706177,
0.31194987893104553,
0.04668748006224632,
0.26778003573417664,
-1.2480285167694092,
0.0925891101360321,
0.13175266981124878,
-0.5367562174797058,
-0.5042247772216797,
-0.5967702865600586,
-0.1685117930173874,
-0.2743743658065796,
-0.37691035866737366,
0.571123480796814,
-0.218190535902977,
-0.1644698828458786,
-0.13971267640590668,
0.28935107588768005,
0.29185789823532104,
0.5086829662322998,
0.11630096286535263,
0.410517156124115,
0.5798402428627014,
-0.21022215485572815,
0.5936363935470581,
0.7640669941902161,
-0.027641603723168373,
1.5610032081604004,
-0.5616124272346497,
0.3469946086406708,
-0.2814689576625824,
0.45617231726646423,
-0.9678608179092407,
-0.29444658756256104,
0.5534719228744507,
-0.3209327161312103,
0.1251509189605713,
0.07017461955547333,
-0.3241177797317505,
-0.2060847282409668,
-0.2158380150794983,
-0.08695007860660553,
0.6566134095191956,
-0.2864234149456024,
0.7672211527824402,
0.6323354244232178,
-0.7769341468811035,
0.012892207130789757,
-0.4234427809715271,
0.1448684185743332,
-0.4574725031852722,
-0.8216193914413452,
0.5753471851348877,
-0.195464625954628,
-0.4076645076274872,
0.06907849758863449,
0.009541815146803856,
-0.1693568229675293,
-0.15531592071056366,
0.5715088844299316,
0.1290685087442398,
-0.1260111778974533,
0.2052687108516693,
0.14525461196899414,
-0.1519627720117569,
0.3245568573474884,
-0.1135176569223404,
0.6150297522544861,
-0.33419954776763916,
-0.4181898534297943,
-0.7929364442825317,
1.0262839794158936,
0.6231376528739929,
-0.10503373295068741,
0.7711492776870728,
0.3461720049381256,
-0.5485675930976868,
0.10004092752933502,
-0.7763530015945435,
-0.30558136105537415,
-0.45871812105178833,
0.21569618582725525,
-0.5765917897224426,
-0.5849983096122742,
0.8425540328025818,
-0.26339396834373474,
-0.21622292697429657,
0.22581708431243896,
0.3001546859741211,
-0.3500000536441803,
1.2942304611206055,
0.5614636540412903,
0.22291821241378784,
0.6736465096473694,
0.3434350788593292,
0.16457873582839966,
-0.6875341534614563,
-0.6827813982963562,
-0.4367409348487854,
-0.37187567353248596,
-0.2602007985115051,
0.12514585256576538,
0.0257102083414793,
-0.4803858697414398,
-0.4291013479232788,
0.35307076573371887,
-0.27039504051208496,
0.2614799737930298,
0.24410925805568695,
0.450539767742157,
0.03488372266292572,
0.024022173136472702,
0.11418482661247253,
-0.7803551554679871,
-0.14070868492126465,
-0.7582827210426331,
0.5430760979652405,
0.19138959050178528,
0.6592393517494202,
0.13121215999126434,
0.831956684589386,
0.23442162573337555,
0.15663933753967285,
-0.5108702778816223,
0.8243585824966431,
0.08210130780935287,
-0.07480725646018982,
0.015348597429692745,
-0.5595531463623047,
-0.9055588841438293,
-0.0875658169388771,
-0.38242897391319275,
-1.2760910987854004,
0.1861788034439087,
0.007225257344543934,
-0.35055220127105713,
0.048480741679668427,
-0.5982576608657837,
0.8356946110725403,
0.030226625502109528,
-0.32281821966171265,
0.09505908191204071,
-1.1026420593261719,
-0.07268251478672028,
-0.21697545051574707,
-0.2833477556705475,
-0.3676761984825134,
0.09436332434415817,
0.8663389682769775,
-0.7252122759819031,
0.7756905555725098,
-0.29066523909568787,
0.042335957288742065,
0.19407370686531067,
0.27673283219337463,
0.4392768442630768,
-0.04773964732885361,
-0.06694235652685165,
-0.2805066406726837,
0.15214891731739044,
-0.4299420714378357,
-0.9835124611854553,
0.9266127347946167,
-0.7237597703933716,
-0.431702584028244,
-0.041269451379776,
-0.21531537175178528,
-0.5007449984550476,
0.17824973165988922,
0.08997053653001785,
0.17868292331695557,
-0.36730116605758667,
0.12711101770401,
0.8400624990463257,
-0.21725338697433472,
0.17319205403327942,
0.33307209610939026,
0.12873686850070953,
-0.36855512857437134,
0.7094088196754456,
-0.345814049243927,
0.028437620028853416,
0.20456166565418243,
0.2099902182817459,
-0.24334625899791718,
0.4111403226852417,
-0.16739045083522797,
0.38785484433174133,
-0.5509364008903503,
-0.22367537021636963,
-0.915452778339386,
0.05701062083244324,
-0.5970508456230164,
-0.28531816601753235,
-0.4793337881565094,
-0.16105356812477112,
-0.23656973242759705,
-0.07990096509456635,
0.2736959457397461,
0.662731945514679,
0.2867964208126068,
0.17128457129001617,
-0.9213091731071472,
0.07113508135080338,
0.36132436990737915,
0.2733266353607178,
-0.14652912318706512,
-0.16838696599006653,
0.23926416039466858,
0.08309856057167053,
-0.5325841903686523,
-1.479286789894104,
0.4505363404750824,
0.6608884930610657,
0.6368171572685242,
0.536821722984314,
0.2172466665506363,
0.9258867502212524,
-0.595618486404419,
0.6831711530685425,
0.43954017758369446,
-1.1399139165878296,
0.9349786043167114,
-0.41638264060020447,
-0.09794892370700836,
0.8197039365768433,
0.089592844247818,
-0.6698036193847656,
-0.29784029722213745,
-0.9755820631980896,
-0.6270235180854797,
0.6598675847053528,
0.4462864398956299,
0.39629995822906494,
-0.2216058075428009,
0.5430124998092651,
0.12316439300775528,
0.22963197529315948,
-0.4361454248428345,
-0.15765520930290222,
-0.1136941984295845,
-0.6108494997024536,
0.3655856251716614,
-0.23598480224609375,
-0.010995812714099884,
0.010835428722202778,
0.5675816535949707,
-0.04681231454014778,
0.583588719367981,
0.3569035828113556,
0.24042463302612305,
-0.3920876085758209,
0.09338560700416565,
0.03307501971721649,
0.028208183124661446,
0.07080411911010742,
0.006047550123184919,
0.17232900857925415,
-0.3064640164375305,
0.06560736149549484,
-0.0881921723484993,
0.1337398737668991,
-0.029794691130518913,
-0.15564396977424622,
0.7315675616264343,
0.5062325596809387,
-0.8540815711021423,
0.9412238597869873,
-0.23433943092823029,
0.07210852205753326,
-0.5547573566436768,
-0.030567798763513565,
-0.012302534654736519,
0.452771931886673,
0.057363007217645645,
-0.07168952375650406,
0.1926242560148239,
-0.5922026038169861,
0.5086731314659119,
0.398276150226593,
-0.5848937630653381,
-0.39319750666618347,
0.44105958938598633,
0.3909018933773041,
-0.6086240410804749,
0.7473720908164978,
0.0024947484489530325,
-0.3746931552886963,
0.38793298602104187,
0.7517611384391785,
1.1163653135299683,
-0.4648005962371826,
0.5016219019889832,
0.19846491515636444,
-0.509171187877655,
-0.034469813108444214,
0.34196820855140686,
-0.2928973436355591,
-0.4807519018650055,
-0.3185478746891022,
-0.5277254581451416,
-0.6873396039009094,
-0.05993621423840523,
-0.9438464045524597,
0.3403613567352295,
-0.32668158411979675,
-0.18589618802070618,
-0.17198006808757782,
-0.03919375687837601,
-0.5624898672103882,
0.07094325125217438,
0.44271382689476013,
0.518750011920929,
-1.1154087781906128,
0.47968369722366333,
0.8903071880340576,
-0.133061021566391,
-0.9935200214385986,
0.011036732234060764,
0.26029711961746216,
-0.2740476727485657,
0.5743356943130493,
0.2699681520462036,
-0.19818033277988434,
-0.10891859978437424,
-0.38652223348617554,
-0.6891613006591797,
1.090961217880249,
0.7806735038757324,
-0.2270410656929016,
-0.2130119353532791,
0.07285995036363602,
0.6070543527603149,
-0.9247105717658997,
0.25200217962265015,
0.3436290919780731,
0.30894002318382263,
0.3621450364589691,
-0.8575348854064941,
0.08728218078613281,
-0.6921695470809937,
-0.026153583079576492,
0.09857504069805145,
-0.534976065158844,
0.658060610294342,
0.1434999704360962,
-0.176150381565094,
0.46721723675727844,
0.6276776194572449,
0.37044578790664673,
0.4111923277378082,
0.704176127910614,
0.45123669505119324,
0.8873537182807922,
-0.04810775816440582,
0.8066237568855286,
-0.18090423941612244,
0.42765703797340393,
1.1569265127182007,
-0.8197745084762573,
0.7751811742782593,
0.4667859673500061,
0.1177627444267273,
0.9349518418312073,
0.565579891204834,
0.17651711404323578,
0.5668378472328186,
-0.06395850330591202,
-0.42909833788871765,
-0.5602121949195862,
-0.28893449902534485,
-0.07723674923181534,
0.5263857245445251,
0.4179958999156952,
-0.5897155404090881,
-0.1343567967414856,
0.17991575598716736,
0.25707608461380005,
0.2779539227485657,
-0.05152441933751106,
0.9628152847290039,
0.09736631065607071,
-0.8264300227165222,
-0.1558188945055008,
-0.35109972953796387,
0.23123331367969513,
-0.5372828841209412,
-0.2599986493587494,
-0.08969172090291977,
0.21314729750156403,
-0.2096920758485794,
-0.733284056186676,
0.46889162063598633,
0.14776059985160828,
-0.1411716490983963,
-0.46943479776382446,
1.176996111869812,
-0.4367111623287201,
-0.3108227550983429,
0.30087360739707947,
0.6591254472732544,
0.3257523477077484,
-0.18285050988197327,
-0.7736824750900269,
-0.140835240483284,
-0.2756863534450531,
-0.30254754424095154,
0.39625298976898193,
0.5366144180297852,
0.18669180572032928,
0.6247981190681458,
0.35965919494628906,
0.0007878387696109712,
-0.26026785373687744,
-0.09755191951990128,
0.8890916705131531,
-0.3673039972782135,
-0.7323589324951172,
-0.9252001643180847,
0.3914773166179657,
-0.6194602847099304,
-0.2225314825773239,
0.8904890418052673,
0.2923901379108429,
0.5203746557235718,
-0.06789731979370117,
0.5016878247261047,
-0.18720638751983643,
0.7164530754089355,
-0.054130300879478455,
0.5645804405212402,
-0.36478036642074585,
0.050971489399671555,
-1.181004285812378,
-1.207797884941101,
-0.15468662977218628,
0.9757352471351624,
-0.255088210105896,
-0.060234565287828445,
0.5218173861503601,
0.7505466938018799,
-0.011842788197100163,
0.2702798843383789,
0.30738168954849243,
0.06279517710208893,
0.3704639673233032,
0.9338048696517944,
0.8928200006484985,
-0.18417009711265564,
0.42206472158432007,
-0.177723690867424,
-0.3786921501159668,
-0.00199523544870317,
-0.889096200466156,
-0.6786029934883118,
-0.729503870010376,
-0.5688128471374512,
-0.5430474281311035,
0.03544938191771507,
1.136212944984436,
0.7522566914558411,
-0.5684307217597961,
0.28375720977783203,
-0.11161496490240097,
-0.35367995500564575,
0.05234803631901741,
-0.24700379371643066,
0.03293090686202049,
0.024497738108038902,
-0.8538363575935364,
0.08839351683855057,
0.4512230455875397,
-0.03466740623116493,
-0.220004603266716,
-0.2942454516887665,
0.1982390284538269,
0.34240809082984924,
0.3524572551250458,
0.3573001027107239,
-0.6443995237350464,
-0.4968549609184265,
0.25366875529289246,
-0.1716282218694687,
0.12295232713222504,
0.919440507888794,
-0.9723280668258667,
0.4019433856010437,
0.5064654350280762,
0.5955541133880615,
0.12450370192527771,
0.1750486195087433,
0.6399962306022644,
-0.7512255907058716,
0.0340956375002861,
0.38137930631637573,
0.5584765076637268,
0.6195482015609741,
-0.5659618377685547,
0.24513301253318787,
0.3922865688800812,
-0.5768908858299255,
-0.6118555665016174,
0.6208882331848145,
-1.2690361738204956,
0.2241903841495514,
1.2686835527420044,
-0.7941573262214661,
-0.32169100642204285,
-0.1944112479686737,
-0.6395227909088135,
0.09727752208709717,
-0.627247154712677,
0.5397175550460815,
0.6073083877563477,
-0.4475333094596863,
-0.2746886610984802,
0.1544252634048462,
0.25794515013694763,
0.5820642709732056,
-0.9362632632255554,
0.019498828798532486,
0.6253218650817871,
0.3802715241909027,
0.1727115958929062,
0.7629713416099548,
-0.22695806622505188,
0.08638640493154526,
-0.10155200213193893,
-0.09207747876644135,
0.2473352700471878,
-0.12801147997379303,
0.12453024089336395,
0.27281028032302856,
-0.4113977551460266,
-0.04478351026773453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04204v1
|
On the Essence and Prospect: An Investigation of Alignment Approaches for Big Models
| 2024-03-07T04:19:13 | 2024-03-07T04:19:13 |
Xinpeng Wang, Shitong Duan, Xiaoyuan Yi, Jing Yao, Shanlin Zhou, Zhihua Wei, Peng Zhang, Dongkuan Xu, Maosong Sun, Xing Xie
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Big models have achieved revolutionary breakthroughs in the field of AI, but
they might also pose potential concerns. Addressing such concerns, alignment
technologies were introduced to make these models conform to human preferences
and values. Despite considerable advancements in the past year, various
challenges lie in establishing the optimal alignment strategy, such as data
cost and scalable oversight, and how to align remains an open question. In this
survey paper, we comprehensively investigate value alignment approaches. We
first unpack the historical context of alignment tracing back to the 1920s
(where it comes from), then delve into the mathematical essence of alignment
(what it is), shedding light on the inherent challenges. Following this
foundation, we provide a detailed examination of existing alignment methods,
which fall into three categories: Reinforcement Learning, Supervised
Fine-Tuning, and In-context Learning, and demonstrate their intrinsic
connections, strengths, and limitations, helping readers better understand this
research area. In addition, two emerging topics, personal alignment, and
multimodal alignment, are also discussed as novel frontiers in this field.
Looking forward, we discuss potential alignment paradigms and how they could
handle remaining challenges, prospecting where future alignment will go.
|
[
-0.16823799908161163,
-0.5738845467567444,
0.6991319060325623,
-0.33581119775772095,
0.34154173731803894,
0.13593672215938568,
-0.026903709396719933,
-0.6183068156242371,
0.060702938586473465,
0.08180876076221466,
-0.8746737837791443,
0.016160739585757256,
-0.492116779088974,
-0.29596570134162903,
-0.24724602699279785,
0.9561982154846191,
-0.09439509361982346,
0.04958944767713547,
-0.4117165803909302,
-0.4979305863380432,
-0.8505285978317261,
-0.39121532440185547,
-0.42226672172546387,
-0.15549367666244507,
0.4836956560611725,
0.3469788134098053,
0.9640684127807617,
1.101169228553772,
0.8964282274246216,
0.2808237075805664,
-0.18079234659671783,
0.13103307783603668,
-0.30740588903427124,
0.05252740532159805,
-0.3889644742012024,
-0.3574790358543396,
-0.48532626032829285,
0.21966971457004547,
0.7364382743835449,
0.8223035335540771,
0.008454372175037861,
0.2413557469844818,
-0.16021956503391266,
0.8388277292251587,
-0.9036380648612976,
-0.015711428597569466,
-0.6469938158988953,
0.010250035673379898,
-0.35057568550109863,
0.13762104511260986,
-0.03841402754187584,
-0.3465019166469574,
0.29957351088523865,
-0.6864127516746521,
-0.22627538442611694,
0.2235347479581833,
1.3587723970413208,
0.629594087600708,
-0.6389750838279724,
-0.28173336386680603,
-0.9212093353271484,
1.1589471101760864,
-0.38572779297828674,
0.25463396310806274,
-0.004340988118201494,
0.8884322643280029,
0.04132569953799248,
-0.6104788780212402,
-0.6238681077957153,
0.24737325310707092,
0.05570710822939873,
-0.041692666709423065,
-0.23211774230003357,
-0.1987733095884323,
0.3047298192977905,
0.517874538898468,
-0.430734246969223,
0.49946731328964233,
-0.3268758952617645,
-0.024541672319173813,
0.9350420832633972,
0.43366292119026184,
0.17905773222446442,
0.1864076554775238,
-0.38708949089050293,
-0.34601929783821106,
-0.8250920176506042,
0.2715901732444763,
0.43664461374282837,
0.25892990827560425,
0.12303947657346725,
0.7926381230354309,
-0.10426708310842514,
0.9631055593490601,
0.4571877717971802,
-0.32315731048583984,
0.06834569573402405,
-0.6718498468399048,
-0.08236076682806015,
0.32763537764549255,
0.36016297340393066,
0.4503309428691864,
-0.008879130706191063,
0.0033539305441081524,
-0.1875067949295044,
-0.17558375000953674,
0.6898364424705505,
-0.5065738558769226,
0.10642793029546738,
0.35968148708343506,
-0.4458214044570923,
-0.43211209774017334,
-0.013473576866090298,
-0.48730266094207764,
-0.42832791805267334,
-1.0510307550430298,
0.7483243942260742,
-0.49165335297584534,
-0.042024970054626465,
-0.08799423277378082,
-0.07771851867437363,
0.7790003418922424,
0.4886520504951477,
-1.3263201713562012,
0.015601965598762035,
1.242800235748291,
0.6827676892280579,
-0.11158891022205353,
-0.11373169720172882,
-0.4028465747833252,
0.24653542041778564,
-0.5027960538864136,
0.590969443321228,
-0.5002881288528442,
0.042707446962594986,
-0.057663410902023315,
-0.22535474598407745,
0.13574199378490448,
-0.28704527020454407,
0.44241830706596375,
-0.4963630735874176,
0.3450644314289093,
-0.5011498928070068,
-0.7211273908615112,
-0.28464025259017944,
0.4878455102443695,
-0.6619842648506165,
0.6841390132904053,
0.19622094929218292,
-0.6805047988891602,
0.7052216529846191,
-0.9539973735809326,
-0.3319883644580841,
-0.11253159493207932,
-0.18505780398845673,
-0.5807999968528748,
0.1509617418050766,
0.16032198071479797,
0.21192346513271332,
-0.2918851375579834,
0.21506430208683014,
-0.22975723445415497,
-0.19011035561561584,
0.24696992337703705,
-0.23073916137218475,
0.8263734579086304,
0.28037557005882263,
-0.39248889684677124,
0.4646685719490051,
-0.5852807760238647,
0.07785751670598984,
0.13714441657066345,
0.44224756956100464,
-0.38782262802124023,
0.20407654345035553,
-0.2405891865491867,
0.2944548726081848,
0.4130977392196655,
-0.1827729046344757,
0.6358315348625183,
-0.40062469244003296,
0.7302364706993103,
0.9922785758972168,
-0.3268541395664215,
0.7375763654708862,
-0.45141229033470154,
0.4282430410385132,
-0.11954576522111893,
0.3900722563266754,
-0.22743460536003113,
-0.12286494672298431,
-0.3448456823825836,
-0.28815606236457825,
0.6452025771141052,
0.24125982820987701,
-0.037728480994701385,
0.6797448396682739,
-0.5701136589050293,
-0.5569318532943726,
-0.9973885416984558,
-0.1366569995880127,
0.23871378600597382,
0.6272289752960205,
0.4129447042942047,
-0.08800910413265228,
-0.3902384042739868,
-1.1343976259231567,
-0.2750548720359802,
-0.019038835540413857,
0.015762070193886757,
0.34916606545448303,
0.46863964200019836,
-0.177823007106781,
1.2121272087097168,
-0.6201719641685486,
-0.14530079066753387,
0.22705036401748657,
-0.03994898498058319,
0.018747983500361443,
0.6502390503883362,
0.40704095363616943,
-1.3893309831619263,
-0.28873252868652344,
0.37650391459465027,
-0.4666673541069031,
0.3366295397281647,
-0.16287954151630402,
-0.2156020998954773,
0.02298837900161743,
0.25266799330711365,
-0.44367173314094543,
0.2541626989841461,
0.3950445353984833,
-0.04160265624523163,
0.36100760102272034,
0.06212954968214035,
0.19225722551345825,
-1.314812421798706,
0.305248886346817,
0.08024828881025314,
0.19399145245552063,
-0.540159285068512,
-0.02211025543510914,
0.12402834743261337,
0.007664996664971113,
-0.223775252699852,
0.6605437397956848,
-0.36294201016426086,
-0.448642760515213,
-0.07373493909835815,
0.04589289426803589,
0.004608479794114828,
0.1418159455060959,
0.007690490689128637,
0.7023867964744568,
0.22358651459217072,
-0.4385276436805725,
0.477750688791275,
0.5125067234039307,
-0.23740322887897491,
1.1490998268127441,
-0.4555814266204834,
0.15043580532073975,
-0.18876969814300537,
0.2068125605583191,
-0.979214072227478,
-0.42338961362838745,
0.05150078609585762,
-0.4414908289909363,
0.57646244764328,
-0.27879413962364197,
-0.11772623658180237,
-0.19808393716812134,
-0.1363065242767334,
0.6517915725708008,
0.5780131220817566,
-0.6666516065597534,
0.7395174503326416,
0.3786568343639374,
-0.027945872396230698,
-0.9441025853157043,
-0.3520718514919281,
0.15944965183734894,
-0.7163776755332947,
-0.7978680729866028,
0.8963300585746765,
-0.003118939697742462,
-0.4944717586040497,
0.022584721446037292,
-0.2820992171764374,
0.1323447823524475,
0.305345743894577,
0.10788966715335846,
0.5529736280441284,
-0.3003632128238678,
0.04236135259270668,
-0.13059724867343903,
-0.23279999196529388,
-0.22347892820835114,
-0.7093967199325562,
0.13963057100772858,
-0.15669932961463928,
-0.35275715589523315,
-0.5886121988296509,
0.08068542182445526,
0.5601619482040405,
-0.5342010855674744,
0.5370919704437256,
0.46324068307876587,
-0.4771994650363922,
0.234303817152977,
-0.5758420825004578,
0.0604812391102314,
-0.4191484749317169,
0.25147151947021484,
-0.25546592473983765,
-0.8248969912528992,
0.23953793942928314,
-0.19552846252918243,
0.4254838526248932,
0.6371245980262756,
0.5985329151153564,
-0.29076826572418213,
1.2247211933135986,
0.8480021357536316,
-0.011804533191025257,
0.5260868668556213,
-0.17356272041797638,
0.5066392421722412,
-1.0340639352798462,
-0.37141552567481995,
-0.5881839394569397,
-0.8986080288887024,
-0.4474063217639923,
0.007300713565200567,
0.3415391147136688,
0.12059999257326126,
-0.5259132385253906,
0.49500522017478943,
-0.608500063419342,
0.31444889307022095,
0.6436895728111267,
-0.3084646165370941,
0.11261733621358871,
-0.4409252405166626,
0.43555137515068054,
-0.16934728622436523,
-0.4773780107498169,
-0.5766133069992065,
1.2192145586013794,
0.3544864356517792,
0.47424858808517456,
0.26723089814186096,
0.37217527627944946,
-0.01815189979970455,
0.265827476978302,
-1.0626859664916992,
-0.04936009272933006,
0.3277967572212219,
-0.8625478744506836,
-0.6490002870559692,
-0.2057366818189621,
-0.9620318412780762,
-0.017584320157766342,
-0.3392521142959595,
-0.8646655082702637,
0.14321808516979218,
0.41660478711128235,
-0.7949365973472595,
0.26291826367378235,
-0.4513704180717468,
1.3918468952178955,
-0.8366815447807312,
-0.4139196276664734,
-0.021878235042095184,
-1.0794483423233032,
0.39381006360054016,
-0.15524815022945404,
0.03917244076728821,
0.020904408767819405,
-0.0034615956246852875,
0.46062925457954407,
-0.011505592614412308,
0.3658941686153412,
0.17734454572200775,
-0.24681347608566284,
0.04073825478553772,
-0.19107171893119812,
0.41188862919807434,
-0.3407908082008362,
0.2131332904100418,
0.09860771149396896,
0.30019500851631165,
-0.5208918452262878,
-0.7189179062843323,
0.5147185325622559,
-0.6848145723342896,
-0.5172862410545349,
-0.4544878304004669,
-0.6847583651542664,
-0.3226988911628723,
0.18346503376960754,
0.016651660203933716,
0.3006105124950409,
-0.4793717861175537,
0.2419234961271286,
0.7242251038551331,
0.06492701917886734,
0.340644896030426,
-0.0037169428542256355,
0.05397559702396393,
-0.387474000453949,
0.9811120629310608,
0.08533830940723419,
0.40294602513313293,
0.7489535212516785,
0.289255827665329,
-0.5215068459510803,
-0.4494101107120514,
-0.600836455821991,
-0.0547560453414917,
-0.23437698185443878,
-0.2566784620285034,
-0.36462312936782837,
-0.002669606590643525,
-0.6619551181793213,
-0.5619146823883057,
-0.6540297269821167,
-0.3148445188999176,
-0.23294731974601746,
0.07778110355138779,
0.07871053367853165,
0.5681069493293762,
0.043596912175416946,
0.14041900634765625,
-0.7899163365364075,
-0.05752330273389816,
0.3863005042076111,
0.09824113547801971,
-0.08448732644319534,
-0.3318283259868622,
-0.36882755160331726,
0.37199339270591736,
-0.7131836414337158,
-0.3271130621433258,
0.2087567299604416,
-0.1951950043439865,
0.4070108234882355,
0.7905867099761963,
0.01859118603169918,
0.8803610801696777,
-0.5410870313644409,
0.797759473323822,
0.29697608947753906,
-1.025053858757019,
0.4513947665691376,
-0.11986089497804642,
-0.18689320981502533,
0.6092427968978882,
0.728338897228241,
-0.6200010180473328,
0.6690278053283691,
-0.7689265012741089,
-0.7092611193656921,
0.45916661620140076,
0.09420160949230194,
-0.10933104157447815,
0.5161717534065247,
0.5138671398162842,
0.0972449854016304,
0.3515677750110626,
-0.26695916056632996,
0.05086638778448105,
-0.10014227777719498,
-0.6380622386932373,
-0.11641409993171692,
0.2986030876636505,
-0.4939124882221222,
-0.20939302444458008,
0.40324652194976807,
-0.36539798974990845,
-0.014998714439570904,
-0.18146520853042603,
0.034422148019075394,
-0.2925691306591034,
0.12878496944904327,
0.7372457981109619,
0.9117864370346069,
-0.08450604975223541,
-0.4092780351638794,
-0.052577678114175797,
0.16806769371032715,
0.30909523367881775,
0.020919466391205788,
-0.11538100242614746,
-0.6439936757087708,
0.2754715383052826,
0.9261924624443054,
0.21076835691928864,
-0.6773492693901062,
0.7300835251808167,
0.2693195641040802,
-0.24865283071994781,
-0.4596721827983856,
-0.015990227460861206,
-0.07619430124759674,
0.5358718633651733,
0.2335670292377472,
-0.033675480633974075,
0.03704182058572769,
-0.8599016070365906,
-0.14880090951919556,
0.9121102094650269,
-0.6884991526603699,
-0.35062384605407715,
0.9626964926719666,
-0.1710561364889145,
-0.35179463028907776,
0.7291882038116455,
0.15498358011245728,
-0.5552288293838501,
0.583277702331543,
0.3051425516605377,
0.8573489189147949,
-0.0749233216047287,
-0.23767191171646118,
0.17653600871562958,
0.01594000868499279,
-0.2746674120426178,
-0.25938594341278076,
-0.04999873787164688,
-0.7713527083396912,
-0.5036430954933167,
-0.48280319571495056,
-0.6066852807998657,
-0.21237598359584808,
-0.7457845211029053,
0.4493803083896637,
-0.1506791114807129,
-0.04491828754544258,
0.41110044717788696,
0.2196619212627411,
-0.5744830965995789,
0.07237374037504196,
0.17958113551139832,
0.5639622807502747,
-0.7435895800590515,
0.4125770032405853,
0.7925819158554077,
-0.5237151384353638,
-0.7962872385978699,
0.08372502028942108,
0.4898335337638855,
-0.7075989246368408,
0.7086591720581055,
0.11960646510124207,
0.2792770564556122,
-0.021677521988749504,
-0.742542028427124,
-1.2358214855194092,
1.3353545665740967,
0.1369732767343521,
-0.46021768450737,
-0.5839069485664368,
-0.2590741515159607,
0.24657469987869263,
-0.410445898771286,
-0.04534774273633957,
0.7839944958686829,
0.7942530512809753,
0.3551410436630249,
-0.8471522927284241,
-0.3033995032310486,
0.14726361632347107,
0.054092615842819214,
0.6098843216896057,
-0.799998939037323,
0.6324324607849121,
-0.13109709322452545,
-0.0016507990658283234,
0.24777160584926605,
0.7664843797683716,
-0.08364789932966232,
0.5194169282913208,
0.250776082277298,
0.8403034806251526,
0.789726197719574,
-0.2483234703540802,
0.7971357703208923,
-0.19378027319908142,
0.202475905418396,
0.8028852939605713,
-0.5710197687149048,
0.4385168254375458,
0.464625746011734,
-0.34669962525367737,
0.25634366273880005,
0.8933151960372925,
-0.27175918221473694,
0.48242366313934326,
0.14484098553657532,
0.09469644725322723,
-0.10018133372068405,
0.005097553599625826,
-0.3307024836540222,
0.7166607975959778,
0.32051336765289307,
-0.04561349377036095,
0.120883509516716,
-0.2493208646774292,
-0.22484536468982697,
0.12323461472988129,
-0.4190923273563385,
1.0968804359436035,
-0.338181734085083,
-0.8708871603012085,
0.08941062539815903,
-0.09790050983428955,
0.3593682646751404,
-0.597933828830719,
-0.21684964001178741,
0.08254952728748322,
0.3051477074623108,
0.0005490247858688235,
-0.7013774514198303,
0.3199232816696167,
-0.4489534795284271,
-0.19352242350578308,
-0.31563907861709595,
0.29403921961784363,
-0.2768814265727997,
-0.21653857827186584,
-0.4011245369911194,
0.13187001645565033,
-0.15435661375522614,
0.06412197649478912,
-0.6743603348731995,
0.02673998661339283,
-0.07143325358629227,
0.20528443157672882,
0.5401014685630798,
0.5889511704444885,
-0.17388193309307098,
0.42003488540649414,
0.5061497092247009,
-0.23824696242809296,
-0.368042528629303,
-0.6851346492767334,
0.4558497369289398,
-0.8677678108215332,
-0.33105772733688354,
-0.9054344892501831,
0.6713647246360779,
-0.21086028218269348,
-0.7328534722328186,
0.6182575225830078,
0.6648410558700562,
0.9278566241264343,
0.39902815222740173,
0.45288577675819397,
-0.059312161058187485,
0.30441129207611084,
-0.6659289002418518,
0.3600505590438843,
-0.8059921860694885,
-0.1938028782606125,
-0.49535590410232544,
-1.0592118501663208,
-0.29893478751182556,
0.5258074402809143,
-0.3559810519218445,
-0.02738668955862522,
0.47656115889549255,
0.4849409759044647,
-0.01421534363180399,
0.03028849884867668,
0.08011666685342789,
-0.18463917076587677,
0.4765806794166565,
0.4840877056121826,
0.8687558174133301,
-0.3315701186656952,
0.12341668456792831,
-0.07343204319477081,
-0.3241528570652008,
-0.5204479694366455,
-1.0782955884933472,
-0.23738688230514526,
-0.7796933650970459,
-0.3535650372505188,
-0.4847707748413086,
-0.0014272540574893355,
1.1464598178863525,
0.756269633769989,
-0.6889675259590149,
-0.04617151618003845,
0.22288024425506592,
0.15997186303138733,
-0.7320745587348938,
-0.08138923346996307,
0.7179136276245117,
-0.3730011284351349,
-0.9497578740119934,
0.1701912134885788,
0.4153366982936859,
0.2342504858970642,
-0.2639118731021881,
0.04272863268852234,
-0.06619411706924438,
0.02924918383359909,
0.36829277873039246,
0.6146514415740967,
-0.607507586479187,
-0.4726129174232483,
0.1160430833697319,
-0.12672434747219086,
0.32613641023635864,
0.8728002309799194,
-0.30027639865875244,
0.38223153352737427,
0.11542443931102753,
1.2685974836349487,
0.2987727224826813,
0.5817177295684814,
0.7405437231063843,
-0.26716679334640503,
-0.16711989045143127,
0.560352087020874,
0.35857924818992615,
0.22870177030563354,
-0.4042382836341858,
0.5602359175682068,
0.08711908012628555,
-0.7328025698661804,
-0.9330307841300964,
0.4832136034965515,
-0.9886835813522339,
-0.29706907272338867,
0.6467547416687012,
0.2231701910495758,
-0.2736823558807373,
0.3381563723087311,
-0.22412464022636414,
0.0927136018872261,
0.19420184195041656,
0.9016820192337036,
0.8243581056594849,
-0.312483012676239,
0.2555248737335205,
-0.39884814620018005,
0.591423511505127,
0.4491756558418274,
-0.6024399995803833,
0.04085606336593628,
0.9141587018966675,
-0.08257191628217697,
0.35138189792633057,
-0.13945196568965912,
-0.3109356164932251,
0.13265812397003174,
-0.254189133644104,
0.19766052067279816,
0.21372592449188232,
-0.45813727378845215,
-0.5790935754776001,
0.013821369968354702,
0.12074500322341919,
-0.09916912764310837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04197v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04197v2
|
Large Language Models are In-Context Molecule Learners
| 2024-03-07T03:58:28 | 2024-04-16T05:07:52 |
Jiatong Li, Wei Liu, Zhihao Ding, Wenqi Fan, Yuqiang Li, Qing Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional performance in
biochemical tasks, especially the molecule caption translation task, which aims
to bridge the gap between molecules and natural language texts. However,
previous methods in adapting LLMs to the molecule-caption translation task
required extra domain-specific pre-training stages, suffered weak alignment
between molecular and textual spaces, or imposed stringent demands on the scale
of LLMs. To resolve the challenges, we propose In-Context Molecule Adaptation
(ICMA), as a new paradigm allowing LLMs to learn the molecule-text alignment
from context examples via In-Context Molecule Tuning. Specifically, ICMA
incorporates the following three stages: Hybrid Context Retrieval,
Post-retrieval Re-ranking, and In-context Molecule Tuning. Initially, Hybrid
Context Retrieval utilizes BM25 Caption Retrieval and Molecule Graph Retrieval
to retrieve informative context examples. Additionally, we also propose
Post-retrieval Re-ranking with Sequence Reversal and Random Walk to further
improve the quality of retrieval results. Finally, In-Context Molecule Tuning
unlocks the in-context molecule learning capability of LLMs with retrieved
examples and adapts the parameters of LLMs for the molecule-caption translation
task. Experimental results demonstrate that ICMT can empower LLMs to achieve
state-of-the-art or comparable performance without extra training corpora and
intricate structures, showing that LLMs are inherently in-context molecule
learners.
|
[
-0.15108926594257355,
-0.5789781808853149,
0.7649586200714111,
-0.12747910618782043,
-0.5830569267272949,
0.5740850567817688,
-0.4034305810928345,
-0.4236651360988617,
-0.13897527754306793,
0.47634637355804443,
-0.22638745605945587,
-0.6040951609611511,
-0.600067138671875,
0.42441320419311523,
-0.0949905514717102,
1.0563876628875732,
-0.0979970395565033,
0.4383155107498169,
-0.5257713794708252,
-0.15186923742294312,
-0.18382103741168976,
-0.3543439209461212,
-0.41873449087142944,
-0.3836551904678345,
0.4526149332523346,
0.6710905432701111,
0.16786368191242218,
0.5569713115692139,
0.7579690217971802,
0.27412065863609314,
-0.07017378509044647,
0.2627037465572357,
-0.4948223829269409,
-0.16880562901496887,
-0.4907666742801666,
-0.4749124050140381,
-0.5732715129852295,
0.19882428646087646,
0.8019288778305054,
0.6919814348220825,
-0.003595331683754921,
-0.07932867109775543,
-0.047318004071712494,
0.6485105752944946,
-0.3396083414554596,
0.0867195650935173,
-1.030754804611206,
-0.15886661410331726,
-0.005655836779624224,
-0.4934486448764801,
-0.49851301312446594,
0.06622877717018127,
0.3196864426136017,
-0.6400983929634094,
0.01888505555689335,
0.411024272441864,
0.8137215375900269,
0.10936291515827179,
-0.6976427435874939,
-0.35051429271698,
-0.39891451597213745,
0.47626206278800964,
-0.893882691860199,
0.1079002171754837,
-0.1689649075269699,
0.4331216514110565,
-0.6016613245010376,
-0.6311794519424438,
-0.6136425733566284,
-0.5941927433013916,
-0.01145639456808567,
0.00934072956442833,
0.25779229402542114,
0.4532569944858551,
0.020957952365279198,
0.504239022731781,
-0.4636935293674469,
0.19673259556293488,
-0.33728083968162537,
-0.09246285259723663,
0.290227472782135,
0.00100455223582685,
0.4206385910511017,
0.0009551533730700612,
-0.633154571056366,
-0.13039979338645935,
-0.8477084040641785,
-0.23219828307628632,
-0.06560959666967392,
0.5786885023117065,
-0.05457058176398277,
0.6100467443466187,
0.13339312374591827,
0.7985361218452454,
0.0466696172952652,
-0.11551040410995483,
0.07003353536128998,
-0.33612462878227234,
-0.44920241832733154,
0.6878836154937744,
0.5263651609420776,
0.18393847346305847,
0.1960710734128952,
-0.1790107935667038,
-0.14158368110656738,
-0.19529154896736145,
0.20817501842975616,
-1.1937124729156494,
-0.1341642141342163,
0.17670266330242157,
-0.1745583564043045,
-0.07793642580509186,
-0.015015595592558384,
-0.893365740776062,
-0.1831960827112198,
-0.4304822087287903,
0.8603696227073669,
-0.4632655084133148,
0.28033357858657837,
0.12559367716312408,
-0.1611335128545761,
0.07568348199129105,
0.2032078504562378,
-0.9151976108551025,
0.41756588220596313,
0.5017743110656738,
1.125361680984497,
-0.5313116312026978,
-0.2722023129463196,
-0.5779306292533875,
0.6933385729789734,
-0.06158338114619255,
0.7283113598823547,
-0.711527407169342,
-0.28155583143234253,
-0.3787490725517273,
0.20757558941841125,
-0.25653108954429626,
-0.9316591024398804,
-0.009134919382631779,
-0.5088940858840942,
-0.01940041594207287,
-0.05163374915719032,
-0.7212234735488892,
-0.12588636577129364,
-0.036483123898506165,
-0.19462911784648895,
0.5481842160224915,
0.32241007685661316,
-0.1595303863286972,
0.5123859643936157,
-0.874112606048584,
-0.589188277721405,
-0.0687817707657814,
-0.06191280111670494,
-0.39651715755462646,
0.22613103687763214,
0.11131954193115234,
0.5447022914886475,
-0.28802451491355896,
0.1235794946551323,
-0.4634195864200592,
-0.2943808138370514,
0.4392762780189514,
0.1730804294347763,
0.5381868481636047,
-0.020001854747533798,
-0.2403174787759781,
0.3902212977409363,
-0.7521589994430542,
-0.2325383424758911,
-0.28679943084716797,
-0.6710340976715088,
-0.1063229888677597,
-0.1440056413412094,
0.07488401234149933,
0.4865381419658661,
-0.07208026945590973,
-0.5338723063468933,
0.5121136903762817,
-0.43921950459480286,
1.0187046527862549,
0.8295605778694153,
0.1581692397594452,
0.653203010559082,
-0.0405777208507061,
0.3072396516799927,
0.3601875603199005,
-0.38842663168907166,
-0.050156716257333755,
-0.2141454666852951,
-0.7147465348243713,
-0.5196775794029236,
0.028339719399809837,
0.39430010318756104,
-0.4849480390548706,
0.450824111700058,
-0.4970216155052185,
-0.4342626631259918,
-0.32022562623023987,
0.4455125033855438,
0.39464691281318665,
0.7295050024986267,
0.6124556064605713,
-0.49344056844711304,
-0.30764228105545044,
-0.8703855872154236,
-0.334549218416214,
-0.03218729794025421,
0.08195145428180695,
0.4694751799106598,
0.8182353377342224,
-0.3440892994403839,
0.5933920741081238,
-0.19939374923706055,
-0.355178564786911,
-0.2500203847885132,
-0.29678112268447876,
0.2408781796693802,
0.6228039264678955,
0.3457649350166321,
-0.6790874004364014,
-0.48314541578292847,
0.4551645517349243,
-0.3802413046360016,
0.024359960108995438,
-0.04073658585548401,
-0.5811163783073425,
-0.01333320327103138,
0.9209309220314026,
-0.5960695147514343,
-0.07288502156734467,
0.4796229302883148,
-0.23719756305217743,
0.1099327802658081,
-0.13473080098628998,
-0.08884595334529877,
-1.3860996961593628,
0.13479116559028625,
-0.0699613019824028,
-0.5151100158691406,
-0.4624936282634735,
-0.16618528962135315,
0.18058085441589355,
-0.1683279126882553,
-0.48796945810317993,
0.6837998032569885,
-0.5075588822364807,
-0.1460612416267395,
-0.4176788032054901,
0.10170907527208328,
-0.06501690298318863,
0.4269877076148987,
0.011445583775639534,
0.8441100716590881,
0.48239463567733765,
-0.7122237086296082,
-0.0546518974006176,
0.18864160776138306,
-0.5128452181816101,
0.379153847694397,
-0.3499164283275604,
0.08144161850214005,
-0.09190816432237625,
0.5762073993682861,
-1.238742709159851,
-0.6001892685890198,
0.184470072388649,
-0.19565850496292114,
0.6468367576599121,
-0.058792050927877426,
-0.4410911202430725,
0.07124371081590652,
0.15093477070331573,
0.4370523989200592,
0.22775718569755554,
-0.6744326949119568,
0.6238266229629517,
0.29474279284477234,
0.0486891083419323,
-0.017481014132499695,
-0.5439391136169434,
0.17379304766654968,
-0.4761573374271393,
-0.17207644879817963,
0.6433218717575073,
-0.09599652886390686,
-0.01573941297829151,
-0.31566405296325684,
-0.4201184809207916,
0.0774286761879921,
0.12236285954713821,
-0.02360958606004715,
0.12946724891662598,
-0.18176600337028503,
0.1606389880180359,
0.21039649844169617,
0.03010123036801815,
-0.040376368910074234,
-0.5274577140808105,
0.32148438692092896,
-0.122211754322052,
0.12100668996572495,
-0.2573307454586029,
0.15822915732860565,
0.9652397632598877,
-0.19815266132354736,
0.7478834986686707,
0.2206466645002365,
-0.17113076150417328,
-0.34001415967941284,
0.004942741245031357,
-0.46517378091812134,
-0.4848952293395996,
0.6065429449081421,
-0.1752566248178482,
-0.9907280206680298,
0.15354588627815247,
-0.5042713284492493,
-0.33703041076660156,
0.023535292595624924,
0.7090086936950684,
-0.30777209997177124,
0.7130259275436401,
0.6806402206420898,
-0.02343396097421646,
0.5526885390281677,
0.011644973419606686,
0.43610385060310364,
-1.011838674545288,
-0.13800369203090668,
-0.367599755525589,
-0.596345841884613,
-0.37191030383110046,
-0.39979857206344604,
0.7872829437255859,
0.31877121329307556,
-0.3692369759082794,
0.5122859477996826,
-0.24195173382759094,
0.504285991191864,
0.1999276727437973,
0.365435391664505,
0.18088117241859436,
0.34074488282203674,
-0.2734837532043457,
0.22507859766483307,
-0.6738057136535645,
-0.48113566637039185,
1.0899899005889893,
0.08366572856903076,
0.3636721968650818,
0.32155564427375793,
0.2892343997955322,
-0.18116548657417297,
0.6577821373939514,
-0.8094622492790222,
0.551067590713501,
-0.11876289546489716,
-0.7313727736473083,
-0.05844908207654953,
-0.41834399104118347,
-0.6473568081855774,
0.25699251890182495,
-0.16007040441036224,
-0.7851610779762268,
0.03141458332538605,
0.20977571606636047,
-0.23994338512420654,
0.24551761150360107,
-0.6928801536560059,
1.0024853944778442,
-0.3030988276004791,
-0.3883167505264282,
-0.223695769906044,
-1.0125999450683594,
0.3490604758262634,
-0.3242546021938324,
0.16301332414150238,
-0.20422571897506714,
-0.22094665467739105,
0.335174560546875,
-0.3662722408771515,
0.7508161664009094,
0.10917019844055176,
-0.08245107531547546,
0.11474300920963287,
0.1715291440486908,
0.2928759455680847,
0.15664030611515045,
0.030541403219103813,
-0.057632073760032654,
-0.05974096059799194,
-0.5803653001785278,
-0.6017950773239136,
0.7501102685928345,
-0.6089628338813782,
-0.6383060812950134,
-0.416640967130661,
-0.6280496716499329,
-0.49123039841651917,
0.25727230310440063,
0.2622084617614746,
0.14934837818145752,
0.005738852079957724,
0.3217478096485138,
0.6668294668197632,
-0.25962355732917786,
0.46822935342788696,
0.6304639577865601,
-0.16849790513515472,
-0.458012193441391,
0.8854265213012695,
-0.34829193353652954,
0.8265870809555054,
0.9666686654090881,
0.16825833916664124,
-0.1037399023771286,
-0.6949346661567688,
-0.6723293662071228,
0.24955178797245026,
-0.6652033925056458,
-0.2629832625389099,
-0.535892128944397,
-0.013977604918181896,
-0.1522754728794098,
-0.3674341142177582,
-0.18952327966690063,
-0.20268839597702026,
-0.47032079100608826,
-0.18300871551036835,
0.4960289001464844,
0.23904173076152802,
0.195804625749588,
0.3279970586299896,
-0.810600996017456,
0.3342781066894531,
0.1994917392730713,
0.256759911775589,
-0.2480717897415161,
-0.7675919532775879,
-0.407916396856308,
-0.2640111744403839,
-0.2975163459777832,
-0.8240754008293152,
0.21340125799179077,
0.8465824127197266,
0.3392135202884674,
0.17204950749874115,
-0.616975724697113,
0.6961274743080139,
-0.6035836935043335,
0.4624403715133667,
-0.1970675140619278,
-0.8923829793930054,
0.5034137964248657,
-0.4800340533256531,
0.33988767862319946,
0.7123748064041138,
0.46065086126327515,
-0.3702729642391205,
-0.13963641226291656,
0.02676188014447689,
-0.9225453734397888,
0.4735267162322998,
0.06480412930250168,
0.12448469549417496,
0.06101122871041298,
0.7413823008537292,
0.12240785360336304,
0.44844749569892883,
-0.8622717261314392,
-0.02799653448164463,
0.05206732451915741,
-0.22520914673805237,
-0.6074351072311401,
0.21485216915607452,
-0.12824688851833344,
-0.6894048452377319,
0.7989564538002014,
-0.5415815711021423,
0.13323450088500977,
0.27802059054374695,
-0.33911600708961487,
-0.19882044196128845,
0.2302420288324356,
0.6752506494522095,
0.6576778292655945,
-0.5458676218986511,
0.21622413396835327,
0.11267226189374924,
-0.4433610141277313,
0.46033957600593567,
0.05803028494119644,
0.17177507281303406,
-0.33282044529914856,
0.2716427445411682,
0.6827667951583862,
0.5031315684318542,
-1.0257489681243896,
0.2995779812335968,
0.30177170038223267,
0.04806385934352875,
0.14761589467525482,
0.24955983459949493,
0.2461213916540146,
0.058610428124666214,
0.21729767322540283,
0.11729708313941956,
-0.013116341084241867,
-0.9800674915313721,
0.21104297041893005,
0.3807114362716675,
-0.5081332325935364,
-0.24431978166103363,
0.7224154472351074,
0.003058121306821704,
-0.032605983316898346,
0.41718265414237976,
0.10138393193483353,
-0.38556626439094543,
0.6298642158508301,
0.9199738502502441,
0.9126998782157898,
-0.17860844731330872,
-0.06114674732089043,
0.3223574459552765,
0.154010608792305,
0.13078294694423676,
0.14038483798503876,
-0.022303521633148193,
-0.5310644507408142,
-0.12329097837209702,
-0.8438628911972046,
-0.1623876839876175,
-0.07189089059829712,
-0.3813079297542572,
0.30193468928337097,
-0.595727264881134,
0.28611770272254944,
0.11711468547582626,
-0.25025975704193115,
-0.34768545627593994,
0.19726602733135223,
-0.09020265191793442,
1.0409014225006104,
-0.6800394654273987,
1.084363341331482,
0.9447668790817261,
-0.19964967668056488,
-0.3301681876182556,
-0.0449087917804718,
0.09982367604970932,
-0.42809128761291504,
0.5433951616287231,
0.3792373836040497,
-0.032729048281908035,
0.31210416555404663,
-0.6910398006439209,
-1.0642255544662476,
1.147505283355713,
0.5336304903030396,
-0.8248028755187988,
0.10831384360790253,
0.11013320088386536,
0.6971091628074646,
-0.6658102869987488,
-0.032765284180641174,
0.7468735575675964,
0.3477568030357361,
-0.13692620396614075,
-0.7765000462532043,
0.2131020426750183,
-0.12515422701835632,
0.005161027889698744,
0.1595122367143631,
-0.9374562501907349,
0.7386941313743591,
-0.12082475423812866,
0.014542377553880215,
0.2675590515136719,
0.5257912278175354,
0.4909350872039795,
0.04248455911874771,
0.16591186821460724,
0.45384231209754944,
0.513791024684906,
0.08460260927677155,
1.1074720621109009,
-0.2871939539909363,
0.03557872772216797,
1.0480155944824219,
-0.33714136481285095,
0.9252627491950989,
0.9512643814086914,
-0.07736248522996902,
0.588958740234375,
0.782889723777771,
0.07859732955694199,
0.7283796072006226,
0.628318190574646,
-0.4488244950771332,
-0.3159376084804535,
0.04337434098124504,
-0.17688602209091187,
0.5121069550514221,
0.7312644124031067,
-0.5757818222045898,
-0.11443720757961273,
0.15222376585006714,
-0.1375160664319992,
0.05592697486281395,
-0.4780304729938507,
0.719779372215271,
0.39415639638900757,
-0.6192469000816345,
0.5864214301109314,
-0.025188583880662918,
0.2953663468360901,
-0.5054264068603516,
-0.193956196308136,
-0.07998410612344742,
0.27469828724861145,
0.05473200976848602,
-0.3302261531352997,
-0.14631517231464386,
-0.40655070543289185,
-0.19344273209571838,
-0.009543982334434986,
0.39965125918388367,
-0.6411542296409607,
-0.5698662996292114,
0.4052976071834564,
0.08824022114276886,
0.22068673372268677,
-0.10090208053588867,
-0.5443229079246521,
-0.20354297757148743,
-0.04590019956231117,
0.00012033033999614418,
0.6051294803619385,
0.30644047260284424,
-0.05224587023258209,
0.578776478767395,
0.4959638714790344,
-0.1592680811882019,
-0.061837974935770035,
-0.29273873567581177,
0.9597815275192261,
-0.7144503593444824,
-0.08306863158941269,
-0.9802267551422119,
0.30145853757858276,
0.3027728497982025,
-0.42506834864616394,
0.6265516877174377,
0.7756251096725464,
1.1756449937820435,
-0.31253355741500854,
0.6485397219657898,
0.27852118015289307,
0.09726489335298538,
-0.9603843688964844,
0.6060906052589417,
-0.8348394632339478,
0.12533104419708252,
-0.41588953137397766,
-1.0918067693710327,
-0.4347638487815857,
0.32850897312164307,
-0.07906771451234818,
0.1425592303276062,
0.7847198247909546,
1.0244457721710205,
-0.4241347014904022,
-0.2580001652240753,
0.10316447168588638,
0.4742570221424103,
0.4865109622478485,
0.8671907782554626,
0.5264540910720825,
-0.4161812365055084,
0.251600056886673,
-0.03079748898744583,
-0.046081651002168655,
-0.5193120837211609,
-0.9766006469726562,
-1.0871843099594116,
-0.5117296576499939,
-0.21746009588241577,
-0.3991089165210724,
-0.04166484996676445,
1.3065791130065918,
0.8090556263923645,
-1.0154939889907837,
-0.49964457750320435,
-0.46776309609413147,
-0.19605518877506256,
0.020414555445313454,
-0.18864616751670837,
0.31029531359672546,
-0.2309247851371765,
-0.7918569445610046,
0.840552568435669,
0.9004519581794739,
0.41710224747657776,
-0.01575668714940548,
0.04424229636788368,
-0.43148407340049744,
-0.020274322479963303,
0.6126742362976074,
0.2785322368144989,
-0.7462227940559387,
-0.19862937927246094,
-0.20668503642082214,
-0.2244371622800827,
0.5139068365097046,
0.9393309354782104,
-0.566924512386322,
0.5811004042625427,
0.29786622524261475,
0.7294409871101379,
0.5626204609870911,
-0.09070917963981628,
0.8670454025268555,
-0.6459738612174988,
0.10958769917488098,
0.1984885036945343,
0.2653521001338959,
0.39943015575408936,
-0.4009133577346802,
0.14473164081573486,
0.23730668425559998,
-0.5467857718467712,
-0.8022533655166626,
0.1358802169561386,
-1.2784210443496704,
-0.5738664269447327,
1.0537641048431396,
0.20393989980220795,
-0.4481683075428009,
0.16852135956287384,
-0.28660497069358826,
0.29840999841690063,
-0.4578322470188141,
0.8869336843490601,
0.7990009188652039,
-0.16314740478992462,
0.038443513214588165,
-0.5305898189544678,
0.8274226784706116,
0.6588408350944519,
-0.9952471852302551,
-0.15647099912166595,
0.32487407326698303,
0.41141727566719055,
-0.08109083026647568,
0.201729878783226,
-0.18241342902183533,
0.22246944904327393,
-0.6092393398284912,
-0.11223657429218292,
0.2134740650653839,
-0.46866312623023987,
-0.4543118476867676,
-0.16331762075424194,
0.08926977217197418,
0.14160726964473724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04190v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04190v1
|
Generative AI for Synthetic Data Generation: Methods, Challenges and the Future
| 2024-03-07T03:38:44 | 2024-03-07T03:38:44 |
Xu Guo, Yiqiang Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.0
|
The recent surge in research focused on generating synthetic data from large
language models (LLMs), especially for scenarios with limited data
availability, marks a notable shift in Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI).
Their ability to perform comparably to real-world data positions this approach
as a compelling solution to low-resource challenges. This paper delves into
advanced technologies that leverage these gigantic LLMs for the generation of
task-specific training data. We outline methodologies, evaluation techniques,
and practical applications, discuss the current limitations, and suggest
potential pathways for future research.
|
[
-0.27767807245254517,
-0.9149710536003113,
0.7037210464477539,
-0.011075945571064949,
0.06880958378314972,
0.28620943427085876,
-0.3242985010147095,
-0.4850913882255554,
0.13909472525119781,
0.47972968220710754,
-0.9085109233856201,
-0.312851220369339,
-0.47842997312545776,
0.43005767464637756,
-0.7934635281562805,
0.717586100101471,
-0.04938630387187004,
0.04649411886930466,
-0.6302022933959961,
0.03624291718006134,
-0.3714650869369507,
-0.8376421332359314,
-0.7654802799224854,
-0.41713637113571167,
0.4737069010734558,
0.5598160624504089,
0.5158132910728455,
0.7190799713134766,
0.5846087336540222,
0.3380054831504822,
0.18624219298362732,
0.41828274726867676,
-0.45337486267089844,
0.3420324921607971,
0.12113934755325317,
-0.6324101686477661,
-0.2772311568260193,
-0.000408999971114099,
0.7535783648490906,
0.8967839479446411,
0.024827497079968452,
0.14943286776542664,
-0.24305805563926697,
0.5975421667098999,
-0.4059359133243561,
0.13693825900554657,
-0.8193458914756775,
0.4785916209220886,
-0.43946486711502075,
-0.24815700948238373,
-0.2165479212999344,
-0.2895546555519104,
0.02526671811938286,
-0.6726006269454956,
0.6887667775154114,
0.1272762417793274,
0.3794157803058624,
0.4414984881877899,
-0.18380506336688995,
-0.2632700204849243,
-1.1294679641723633,
0.9063403010368347,
-0.6201385259628296,
0.2874307632446289,
0.2860119640827179,
0.3970845639705658,
-0.32251402735710144,
-0.8941870331764221,
-0.8003242611885071,
-0.55816650390625,
0.2859398126602173,
0.09657672792673111,
0.08636903762817383,
-0.056371916085481644,
0.5005214214324951,
0.5287326574325562,
-0.5151258111000061,
0.38946548104286194,
-0.38946282863616943,
0.1327827423810959,
0.8618584275245667,
0.5948765277862549,
0.30529820919036865,
0.0557769350707531,
-0.042620882391929626,
-0.0791778489947319,
-1.023794412612915,
-0.5683405995368958,
0.40131786465644836,
0.38692641258239746,
-0.053909629583358765,
0.9687653183937073,
-0.34403207898139954,
0.7282218933105469,
-0.1052807942032814,
0.01996966451406479,
0.17628808319568634,
-0.4351375699043274,
-0.10720253735780716,
-0.08267167955636978,
0.7411776185035706,
-0.007995839230716228,
0.010564968921244144,
-0.22440572082996368,
-0.3337573707103729,
0.10808134824037552,
0.36986637115478516,
-0.5837730765342712,
-0.11799240857362747,
0.19403868913650513,
-0.2574786841869354,
-0.3057602643966675,
-0.19945956766605377,
-0.8192512392997742,
-0.5218462944030762,
-0.5295706987380981,
0.04210649058222771,
-0.27133631706237793,
-0.19974656403064728,
-0.26476436853408813,
-0.19525066018104553,
0.28469714522361755,
0.13115271925926208,
-1.0846550464630127,
0.03915650025010109,
0.5416916012763977,
0.8860715627670288,
-0.5156431794166565,
-0.19728201627731323,
-0.41431379318237305,
0.3005313277244568,
-0.4917827546596527,
0.6595163941383362,
-0.5374739766120911,
-0.6170107126235962,
0.16238199174404144,
-0.19488370418548584,
0.03721926361322403,
-0.9397569894790649,
0.29365867376327515,
-0.33672189712524414,
-0.17339757084846497,
-0.016235733404755592,
-0.5222651362419128,
0.3272107243537903,
0.28241726756095886,
-0.781220018863678,
1.0269014835357666,
0.2780440151691437,
-0.384796142578125,
0.1726858913898468,
-0.7954122424125671,
-0.6832218766212463,
0.30422312021255493,
-0.45010092854499817,
-0.4656655192375183,
0.2906858026981354,
0.12193155288696289,
0.3889728784561157,
-0.6933713555335999,
0.3129083812236786,
-0.16370873153209686,
-0.11207965761423111,
0.4995683431625366,
-0.6399194598197937,
0.41341057419776917,
0.397754967212677,
-0.18574883043766022,
0.13244211673736572,
-0.8743791580200195,
-0.11842257529497147,
0.4215555191040039,
-0.3639465272426605,
0.0788438469171524,
0.26165807247161865,
0.088006891310215,
0.013345579616725445,
0.19403941929340363,
-0.45483970642089844,
0.3271615505218506,
-0.36226990818977356,
0.722062349319458,
0.7482292056083679,
-0.18019576370716095,
0.3716006278991699,
-0.5264446139335632,
0.9247196316719055,
-0.14968973398208618,
-0.01169616263359785,
0.0460008829832077,
-0.36718347668647766,
-1.007148265838623,
-0.051414214074611664,
0.19770288467407227,
0.5741283297538757,
-0.9537768959999084,
0.42546120285987854,
-0.3694058060646057,
-0.5387681722640991,
-0.5571046471595764,
0.3682432174682617,
0.14766108989715576,
0.38980844616889954,
0.3010639250278473,
0.03002595156431198,
-0.8422638177871704,
-0.8015940189361572,
0.13047607243061066,
0.09278447926044464,
-0.09871570765972137,
0.23085519671440125,
0.41212567687034607,
-0.41792061924934387,
0.8821978569030762,
-0.49163150787353516,
-0.03624231740832329,
-0.7044675946235657,
0.13825659453868866,
-0.03915783762931824,
0.574903666973114,
0.3675810694694519,
-0.9111762642860413,
-0.292238712310791,
-0.04068321734666824,
-1.0047208070755005,
0.06407440453767776,
-0.31658798456192017,
-0.03793550655245781,
0.2266313135623932,
0.703478991985321,
-0.9121671319007874,
0.14405302703380585,
0.6159681677818298,
0.2270495742559433,
0.5349368453025818,
-0.10032819211483002,
-0.11081292480230331,
-1.133141040802002,
0.06285528838634491,
0.034684862941503525,
-0.11502144485712051,
-0.8180848956108093,
-0.08138740062713623,
-0.40669992566108704,
-0.4936775267124176,
-0.35655540227890015,
0.6163085103034973,
-0.4145445227622986,
-0.17483007907867432,
-0.1996401995420456,
-0.07999085634946823,
-0.5663888454437256,
0.07497994601726532,
0.11458766460418701,
0.9272559285163879,
0.3963865637779236,
-0.6231293678283691,
0.8874954581260681,
0.32097357511520386,
-0.4088999032974243,
0.3597644865512848,
-0.5038637518882751,
0.3745128810405731,
-0.11241369694471359,
0.21250760555267334,
-0.6571342945098877,
-0.7098724842071533,
0.14802341163158417,
-0.3501496911048889,
0.24902936816215515,
0.09261494129896164,
-0.6473444700241089,
-0.5660978555679321,
-0.07250406593084335,
0.6168609857559204,
0.7771609425544739,
-0.5788541436195374,
0.5235323905944824,
0.43260788917541504,
-0.2946951687335968,
-0.20937037467956543,
-0.7481065988540649,
0.3784421384334564,
-0.37205278873443604,
-0.37601104378700256,
0.5624366998672485,
-0.16820016503334045,
-0.31747522950172424,
-0.02226838655769825,
0.16731323301792145,
0.09680236876010895,
0.12080889195203781,
0.31189823150634766,
0.23356954753398895,
-0.010304917581379414,
0.10498693585395813,
-0.04035879299044609,
-0.09782209247350693,
0.1097753718495369,
-0.27853551506996155,
0.6641307473182678,
0.22509770095348358,
-0.3815625011920929,
-0.4390716850757599,
0.4870672821998596,
0.4242692291736603,
-0.002898002974689007,
0.6548111438751221,
0.4554174542427063,
-0.41881227493286133,
-0.5914173126220703,
-0.34591490030288696,
-0.07082799822092056,
-0.5022860169410706,
0.5460668206214905,
-0.21459659934043884,
-0.7695004343986511,
0.19777868688106537,
-0.3416186273097992,
-0.04460274055600166,
0.40461719036102295,
0.8945865035057068,
-0.1731276959180832,
1.1510810852050781,
0.5807494521141052,
-0.10577651113271713,
0.5725154876708984,
-0.46498987078666687,
0.3153252601623535,
-0.5866928696632385,
-0.3563312292098999,
-0.4068797826766968,
-0.3008235692977905,
-0.6887621283531189,
-0.3964562714099884,
0.6042995452880859,
-0.2098456621170044,
-0.2557338774204254,
0.008149961940944195,
-0.4510294497013092,
0.3121664524078369,
0.82005375623703,
-0.07465378195047379,
0.19899338483810425,
0.14475296437740326,
0.43442684412002563,
0.218221515417099,
-0.854318380355835,
-0.4141990840435028,
1.320175051689148,
-0.008190035820007324,
0.6260422468185425,
-0.12325499951839447,
0.5385582447052002,
0.5658940076828003,
0.4231574833393097,
-0.8022149205207825,
0.8569599390029907,
-0.19216753542423248,
-0.5192573070526123,
-0.41976889967918396,
-0.48161131143569946,
-1.0318485498428345,
-0.2854854166507721,
-0.4619804322719574,
-0.21303874254226685,
-0.34850558638572693,
0.24583807587623596,
-0.15855376422405243,
0.23230697214603424,
-0.5062750577926636,
0.576124906539917,
-0.3851693272590637,
-0.05974090099334717,
-0.25111153721809387,
-0.4425410330295563,
0.39248329401016235,
-0.2886793315410614,
-0.07697252929210663,
-0.0982227697968483,
0.04886379837989807,
0.6220542788505554,
-0.5117377638816833,
0.9026901125907898,
-0.08259423077106476,
-0.13739538192749023,
0.4027070701122284,
-0.2865692377090454,
0.5967786908149719,
-0.06697296351194382,
-0.05821295827627182,
0.09316519647836685,
-0.41424426436424255,
-0.43553486466407776,
-0.4892010986804962,
0.710490345954895,
-0.7182723879814148,
-0.7310934066772461,
-0.3100081980228424,
-0.9260322451591492,
-0.5556822419166565,
-0.053219977766275406,
0.4098424017429352,
0.1825464516878128,
-0.30004897713661194,
0.05558085814118385,
0.4438585042953491,
-0.33766263723373413,
0.3217886686325073,
0.017069077119231224,
0.1763952523469925,
-0.2946762442588806,
1.2707369327545166,
0.14184561371803284,
0.20136021077632904,
0.2843043804168701,
-0.22237087786197662,
-0.26749923825263977,
-0.8941071629524231,
-0.5587882995605469,
0.04983137920498848,
-0.46347537636756897,
-0.25022462010383606,
-0.2912667989730835,
-0.5902994871139526,
-0.32036828994750977,
-0.26766324043273926,
-0.39387112855911255,
-0.5277107357978821,
-0.42777174711227417,
-0.2074742168188095,
0.38114994764328003,
0.865881621837616,
0.0755959078669548,
0.18579064309597015,
-0.704426109790802,
0.5077316164970398,
0.39342373609542847,
0.00927341915667057,
-0.13283780217170715,
-0.15817171335220337,
-0.3040039837360382,
0.12678541243076324,
-0.34707340598106384,
-0.5275334715843201,
0.5626991391181946,
0.21296870708465576,
0.4997774064540863,
0.03634064272046089,
-0.09306205809116364,
0.40845486521720886,
-0.49002721905708313,
0.8497874140739441,
0.21333588659763336,
-0.612836480140686,
0.7597845196723938,
-0.3767216205596924,
0.026961758732795715,
0.18066583573818207,
0.4224347174167633,
-0.3217516243457794,
-0.28653836250305176,
-0.3889574408531189,
-0.845679759979248,
0.5758054852485657,
0.19086405634880066,
0.49865299463272095,
-0.004031899385154247,
0.6214323043823242,
0.26751330494880676,
0.2539898455142975,
-0.4223708510398865,
-0.13923978805541992,
-0.09770409017801285,
-0.5472821593284607,
-0.14672528207302094,
0.015575794503092766,
-0.2241157591342926,
-0.2667299211025238,
0.5378682613372803,
-0.26178303360939026,
0.4498845636844635,
-0.10075941681861877,
0.04107237979769707,
-0.021690059453248978,
0.210576593875885,
0.5347568988800049,
0.523331344127655,
0.13733898103237152,
-0.06514827162027359,
0.42572468519210815,
-0.3854042589664459,
0.3839680552482605,
0.1855161190032959,
-0.3603464663028717,
-0.23256570100784302,
0.3649083077907562,
0.7517660856246948,
-0.41343954205513,
-1.2077313661575317,
0.10585355758666992,
0.19490346312522888,
-0.33354681730270386,
-0.837026834487915,
0.35911622643470764,
0.03623579069972038,
0.3297491669654846,
0.39023685455322266,
-0.16286998987197876,
-0.11675319820642471,
-0.707122266292572,
-0.19830666482448578,
0.5918764472007751,
0.05140030011534691,
-0.3787975311279297,
0.753038763999939,
0.27386409044265747,
-0.23854851722717285,
1.1167140007019043,
-0.12390241026878357,
-0.10980958491563797,
0.9035153388977051,
0.7668779492378235,
0.9068394899368286,
-0.11374189704656601,
0.0846836268901825,
0.09699743241071701,
-0.05635978654026985,
-0.06607931852340698,
0.33281397819519043,
0.0036685026716440916,
-0.8521398305892944,
-0.38111457228660583,
-0.7231242060661316,
-0.6090980172157288,
0.5104935765266418,
-0.4337151348590851,
-0.005305922590196133,
-0.5996261835098267,
-0.20714588463306427,
0.004360746126621962,
-0.21665170788764954,
-0.7121577262878418,
0.23628981411457062,
0.2923872470855713,
0.575786292552948,
-0.6699612140655518,
0.8020051717758179,
0.7357166409492493,
-0.2769269347190857,
-0.27281081676483154,
-0.043874677270650864,
-0.09330680966377258,
-0.8887448310852051,
0.8357142806053162,
-0.02141074649989605,
0.04613630101084709,
0.13157828152179718,
-0.7514766454696655,
-0.7335659265518188,
1.1236445903778076,
0.5819981694221497,
-0.5984037518501282,
-0.3176819384098053,
0.6297968029975891,
0.6089997291564941,
-0.40021803975105286,
-0.358196496963501,
0.8186865448951721,
0.44115108251571655,
0.022858470678329468,
-0.5655279159545898,
-0.10473210364580154,
-0.3417188823223114,
0.33633196353912354,
0.11575300991535187,
-0.6089844703674316,
0.655992329120636,
-0.18438862264156342,
-0.2660558819770813,
0.33273062109947205,
0.7677673101425171,
0.3483799695968628,
0.2216896265745163,
0.2841528058052063,
0.6256484389305115,
0.6239320635795593,
-0.16912934184074402,
1.2146230936050415,
-0.15155276656150818,
0.041455402970314026,
0.8012399673461914,
-0.44555899500846863,
0.7075140476226807,
0.33544787764549255,
-0.38031402230262756,
0.3270825147628784,
0.5427384376525879,
-0.35731780529022217,
0.33432409167289734,
0.5032647252082825,
-0.635880708694458,
-0.35633766651153564,
-0.4055752158164978,
-0.24045497179031372,
0.5470277667045593,
0.6056802868843079,
-0.24746374785900116,
0.17309783399105072,
0.22623516619205475,
-0.4404192566871643,
0.05919630825519562,
-0.3591131865978241,
0.722817599773407,
0.0708475261926651,
-0.6383119225502014,
0.5103901028633118,
-0.010045581497251987,
0.525628924369812,
-0.4129107594490051,
-0.30866849422454834,
-0.21030059456825256,
0.08055391162633896,
-0.12713764607906342,
-0.576790452003479,
0.41669008135795593,
0.29936909675598145,
-0.23729535937309265,
-0.27277591824531555,
0.5562883615493774,
-0.3162286579608917,
-0.638831377029419,
-0.02149168960750103,
0.594470202922821,
0.05438877269625664,
0.21279890835285187,
-0.4841626286506653,
0.124567911028862,
-0.22663146257400513,
-0.11579079180955887,
0.4680948257446289,
0.1440790891647339,
-0.05154620110988617,
0.9151241779327393,
0.7146966457366943,
0.34030333161354065,
0.22451478242874146,
0.057844992727041245,
0.8271135687828064,
-0.8811131715774536,
-0.16047027707099915,
-0.64593106508255,
0.07617993652820587,
0.06556740403175354,
-0.20287320017814636,
0.5500167012214661,
0.5284010767936707,
0.9797910451889038,
-0.2123359888792038,
1.3858177661895752,
-0.19231492280960083,
0.42578190565109253,
-0.8501589298248291,
0.45521146059036255,
-0.5028181076049805,
0.17464861273765564,
0.2744870185852051,
-0.8863340020179749,
-0.26679301261901855,
0.327921599149704,
-0.15962490439414978,
0.2186308205127716,
0.35979515314102173,
0.7325241565704346,
0.08078039437532425,
-0.03858161345124245,
0.28522852063179016,
0.12052960693836212,
0.4086321294307709,
0.6870719194412231,
1.1759265661239624,
-0.003154079196974635,
0.42044615745544434,
-0.11334872245788574,
0.13892582058906555,
-0.18037395179271698,
-0.6102949380874634,
-0.8284579515457153,
-0.8127098679542542,
-0.2016245722770691,
-0.04516012966632843,
0.1603826880455017,
0.9464504718780518,
0.7108789086341858,
-0.767987847328186,
-0.161245658993721,
-0.7029458284378052,
-0.21390391886234283,
-0.06850054860115051,
-0.22481779754161835,
0.26273825764656067,
-0.4938301146030426,
-1.1369712352752686,
0.8219860792160034,
0.059688933193683624,
0.4210011959075928,
-0.5407353639602661,
-0.17580565810203552,
0.21837611496448517,
0.09226568043231964,
0.66969895362854,
0.5187939405441284,
-0.49014046788215637,
-0.14209125936031342,
-0.19068720936775208,
-0.0018455623649060726,
-0.07815378904342651,
0.9114888310432434,
-0.8739439845085144,
0.21488840878009796,
0.5172873139381409,
1.0055325031280518,
0.5860198140144348,
0.09139429777860641,
0.7945141792297363,
-0.7850489020347595,
0.187882199883461,
0.5058254599571228,
0.1210663840174675,
0.47560325264930725,
-0.26674675941467285,
0.5954653024673462,
0.45019760727882385,
-0.44548824429512024,
-0.9776930809020996,
0.4105401039123535,
-0.8245465755462646,
-0.10829319804906845,
1.1210201978683472,
0.1681128889322281,
0.01032576709985733,
-0.019107511267066002,
0.08460401743650436,
0.3394688665866852,
0.004929522518068552,
0.9850221872329712,
0.46693986654281616,
-0.5596666932106018,
-0.07142506539821625,
-0.8754801154136658,
0.7174973487854004,
0.4246160686016083,
-1.2730317115783691,
0.15829315781593323,
0.6445486545562744,
-0.008824518881738186,
0.013814540579915047,
0.5184342861175537,
0.1586487591266632,
0.10543053597211838,
0.18678925931453705,
-0.1524672955274582,
-0.03030211851000786,
-0.5053577423095703,
-0.24445703625679016,
0.10799962282180786,
0.15568482875823975,
0.0105384336784482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04182v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04182v2
|
Metric-aware LLM inference for regression and scoring
| 2024-03-07T03:24:34 | 2024-04-04T13:48:19 |
Michal Lukasik, Harikrishna Narasimhan, Aditya Krishna Menon, Felix Yu, Sanjiv Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated strong results on a range of
NLP tasks. Typically, outputs are obtained via autoregressive sampling from the
LLM's underlying distribution. Building on prior work on Minimum Bayes Risk
Decoding, we show that this inference strategy can be suboptimal for a range of
regression and scoring tasks, and associated evaluation metrics. As a remedy,
we propose metric aware LLM inference: a decision theoretic approach optimizing
for custom regression and scoring metrics at inference time. We report
improvements over baselines on academic benchmarks and publicly available
models.
|
[
-0.04113354533910751,
-0.6676917672157288,
0.7266652584075928,
0.23812048137187958,
0.2402946949005127,
0.017565153539180756,
-0.05589665472507477,
-0.38758090138435364,
0.1940498948097229,
0.5897045731544495,
-0.6360947489738464,
-0.8776410222053528,
-0.6103906035423279,
-0.28279203176498413,
-0.1778898388147354,
0.9503850340843201,
0.32457032799720764,
0.024026528000831604,
-0.3834134340286255,
0.0043341065756976604,
-0.23372311890125275,
-0.4962747097015381,
-0.9107686877250671,
-0.22680969536304474,
0.4683656096458435,
0.21691492199897766,
0.458214670419693,
0.5247716307640076,
0.697665274143219,
0.2253536432981491,
0.08225198090076447,
0.0495663546025753,
-0.3268243372440338,
-0.026256052777171135,
-0.17444290220737457,
-0.9812576174736023,
-0.6284103989601135,
0.3060429096221924,
0.7223551273345947,
0.8202720880508423,
-0.207721546292305,
0.6720398664474487,
-0.061493881046772,
0.7855333685874939,
-1.0165992975234985,
0.1752815544605255,
-0.7221842408180237,
0.228975310921669,
0.06971874833106995,
-0.1190834566950798,
-0.8337718844413757,
-0.3684903681278229,
-0.006572504062205553,
-0.33861950039863586,
0.1705743670463562,
0.059858355671167374,
0.38387012481689453,
0.6116234660148621,
-0.35052669048309326,
0.07455082982778549,
-0.8156553506851196,
1.0922831296920776,
-0.7204206585884094,
0.4264306426048279,
0.6195122003555298,
0.4590735137462616,
-0.22574666142463684,
-0.43908777832984924,
-0.05011940747499466,
-0.20859846472740173,
-0.015462583862245083,
0.3278075158596039,
-0.33766961097717285,
0.14483468234539032,
0.3859860599040985,
0.05655374750494957,
-0.46539774537086487,
0.4995330274105072,
0.0511554591357708,
-0.19024735689163208,
0.9167838096618652,
0.3010355532169342,
-0.4040602743625641,
-0.43870148062705994,
-0.32896482944488525,
0.10888472944498062,
-0.7371498346328735,
-0.10646716505289078,
0.37737366557121277,
0.21475552022457123,
0.021011972799897194,
0.5180712342262268,
-0.041015081107616425,
0.7177382707595825,
-0.3224411904811859,
-0.3827812969684601,
0.04675055667757988,
-0.30857938528060913,
-0.5003493428230286,
-0.3710954487323761,
0.7482743859291077,
0.34070977568626404,
0.23211027681827545,
-0.1711176633834839,
-0.20830269157886505,
0.08354033529758453,
0.10976555943489075,
-0.13033874332904816,
-0.19905565679073334,
0.3301961123943329,
-0.47349607944488525,
0.049747806042432785,
-0.16573020815849304,
-0.7362092733383179,
-0.4645715057849884,
-0.2595904767513275,
0.5980921983718872,
-0.2794216275215149,
0.004868654068559408,
0.3296661972999573,
-0.24323487281799316,
0.2119874358177185,
0.35738083720207214,
-0.6449431777000427,
0.43970662355422974,
0.6527718305587769,
0.7611852884292603,
-0.06578806787729263,
0.14079391956329346,
-0.6823111772537231,
0.17355865240097046,
-0.5206962823867798,
0.8637235164642334,
-0.15632089972496033,
-0.41856786608695984,
-0.10033829510211945,
-0.3940664827823639,
-0.16621311008930206,
-0.5837069749832153,
0.4556691348552704,
-0.32722291350364685,
0.05911774933338165,
0.060115594416856766,
-0.9280810356140137,
-0.16110265254974365,
0.07892880588769913,
-0.5230389833450317,
1.0779175758361816,
0.2618055045604706,
-0.7008528709411621,
0.6094386577606201,
-0.4937132000923157,
-0.11111359298229218,
-0.010640138760209084,
0.0385398231446743,
-0.3186897337436676,
0.37985777854919434,
0.37290894985198975,
0.7007281184196472,
-0.28219112753868103,
0.23546811938285828,
-0.36206793785095215,
-0.09939316660165787,
0.032171424478292465,
-0.6479997038841248,
0.621863842010498,
0.2211388498544693,
-0.015923386439681053,
-0.025034558027982712,
-0.765415608882904,
0.10060282796621323,
-0.07445189356803894,
-0.34059852361679077,
-0.4783790111541748,
0.42720088362693787,
-0.3053005337715149,
-0.21111507713794708,
0.24317899346351624,
-0.4399420917034149,
0.0010720659047365189,
-0.20007237792015076,
0.09223650395870209,
0.8379735350608826,
0.022988013923168182,
0.4543652832508087,
-0.3743321895599365,
0.6495717167854309,
-0.3599633574485779,
0.22672632336616516,
0.43702057003974915,
-0.2948615849018097,
-0.6581472754478455,
-0.6880902051925659,
0.31306540966033936,
0.8281798362731934,
-0.45506882667541504,
0.606700599193573,
-0.0933145210146904,
-0.6516768932342529,
-0.7031579613685608,
0.0880638137459755,
0.3902416229248047,
0.45733800530433655,
0.24961444735527039,
0.08519487082958221,
-0.6059398055076599,
-0.9205389022827148,
-0.5843604207038879,
-0.5172467231750488,
-0.19530434906482697,
0.44125697016716003,
0.4025621712207794,
-0.08548475056886673,
1.0797117948532104,
-0.7669630646705627,
-0.3743894696235657,
-0.5576526522636414,
0.15660104155540466,
0.5809012651443481,
0.4525721073150635,
0.6560666561126709,
-0.3350938856601715,
-0.42146429419517517,
-0.5201706886291504,
-0.48218074440956116,
-0.4007396697998047,
-0.29823732376098633,
-0.15533196926116943,
0.2029765397310257,
0.7556732296943665,
-0.3184994161128998,
0.28901058435440063,
0.6227697730064392,
-0.21716022491455078,
0.7944492697715759,
-0.21682435274124146,
-0.13990283012390137,
-0.8793651461601257,
-0.17869164049625397,
0.5877676010131836,
-0.7725809216499329,
-0.35760340094566345,
-0.08954676240682602,
-0.21451394259929657,
0.4925672113895416,
-0.18073099851608276,
0.7105612754821777,
-0.3270837068557739,
-0.4535634219646454,
-0.09909215569496155,
0.10329866409301758,
-0.038174133747816086,
0.037431128323078156,
0.3275652825832367,
0.5320920348167419,
0.4546566307544708,
-0.6990052461624146,
0.036613088101148605,
0.05458707734942436,
-0.759441077709198,
0.44542497396469116,
-0.37439680099487305,
-0.29796868562698364,
-0.2533964514732361,
0.17279189825057983,
-0.9711533188819885,
-0.044853128492832184,
-0.14886300265789032,
-0.5103868842124939,
0.23997360467910767,
-0.3155341148376465,
-0.5017930865287781,
-0.5131131410598755,
-0.24537892639636993,
-0.03402599319815636,
0.7383540868759155,
-0.5124009251594543,
0.4750415086746216,
0.5890392065048218,
-0.06366966664791107,
-0.6770119071006775,
-0.8635957837104797,
-0.16438284516334534,
-0.470947265625,
-0.1514362394809723,
-0.052090197801589966,
-0.0335962176322937,
-0.4884631931781769,
-0.25356438755989075,
-0.05776021629571915,
-0.013236144557595253,
0.3517686128616333,
0.06451563537120819,
0.28396156430244446,
-0.38203006982803345,
0.2272697538137436,
-0.22982721030712128,
-0.32728341221809387,
0.2512144446372986,
-0.2525325417518616,
0.2723512053489685,
0.0940467044711113,
-0.5546254515647888,
-0.5505102872848511,
0.2909117639064789,
0.17321328818798065,
0.026344478130340576,
0.685099184513092,
0.6272904276847839,
-0.4830736815929413,
-0.4500720500946045,
-0.8548697233200073,
-0.09941661357879639,
-0.4242095947265625,
0.515461266040802,
-0.21539729833602905,
-0.782188355922699,
0.4784279763698578,
-0.12553206086158752,
0.085965096950531,
0.5422717332839966,
0.5196627974510193,
-0.2995288074016571,
1.2013887166976929,
0.877071738243103,
-0.3273851275444031,
0.5139761567115784,
-0.29942792654037476,
0.25035786628723145,
-0.8684696555137634,
-0.0565565824508667,
-0.5877572894096375,
-0.18128252029418945,
-0.6413915157318115,
-0.6739025712013245,
0.5115165710449219,
-0.07736054062843323,
-0.3773330748081207,
0.00917690061032772,
-0.10461893677711487,
0.539280116558075,
0.811178982257843,
0.17750047147274017,
0.3887403905391693,
-0.20406650006771088,
0.08747168630361557,
-0.25985512137413025,
-0.880706250667572,
-0.5537712574005127,
1.0101242065429688,
0.6107783913612366,
1.1130092144012451,
0.16234301030635834,
0.803649365901947,
0.3180329203605652,
0.5930200815200806,
-1.0756828784942627,
0.4643711745738983,
-0.4457123875617981,
-0.74058997631073,
-0.18418310582637787,
-0.7647368907928467,
-0.5855114459991455,
0.13861331343650818,
-0.3888885974884033,
-1.254040241241455,
-0.04540133476257324,
0.19673039019107819,
-0.5506361126899719,
0.3477754294872284,
-0.705409586429596,
0.7797973155975342,
-0.050669603049755096,
-0.0018727967981249094,
-0.2138870805501938,
-0.32389354705810547,
0.6407371163368225,
-0.06577400118112564,
0.3838338553905487,
-0.4994027614593506,
-0.27251341938972473,
0.9105055928230286,
-0.1067255288362503,
1.0777349472045898,
-0.3357844054698944,
0.003786869114264846,
0.23693178594112396,
0.36286666989326477,
0.35701772570610046,
0.3767164945602417,
-0.3919498026371002,
0.00868614949285984,
0.10438823699951172,
-0.32587364315986633,
-0.4889368414878845,
0.297946035861969,
-0.4900501072406769,
-0.8931198716163635,
-0.3493151366710663,
-0.7106905579566956,
-0.6122682690620422,
-0.10872159153223038,
0.18525467813014984,
0.035638123750686646,
-0.19391942024230957,
-0.047965578734874725,
0.4679828882217407,
-0.3082706332206726,
0.37149515748023987,
0.9166041016578674,
-0.09273529052734375,
-0.2323516458272934,
0.5054423809051514,
-0.07410864531993866,
0.4039665162563324,
0.538617730140686,
0.34818360209465027,
-0.5368307828903198,
-0.765730082988739,
0.06300509721040726,
0.4890318512916565,
-0.7623652219772339,
-0.3660541772842407,
-0.4760448634624481,
-0.2285931557416916,
-0.3616638481616974,
-0.3136369585990906,
-0.5621235966682434,
-0.3043586313724518,
-0.26683366298675537,
-0.3175061047077179,
0.48262205719947815,
0.8655247092247009,
-0.4803253412246704,
0.6080103516578674,
-0.9151943922042847,
0.09668656438589096,
-0.08190538734197617,
0.3943486511707306,
-0.05700893700122833,
-0.6807981133460999,
-0.21609434485435486,
-0.23513703048229218,
0.18800640106201172,
-0.42938804626464844,
0.4877071678638458,
0.29461079835891724,
0.806850016117096,
0.40158140659332275,
0.010614237748086452,
0.5534617900848389,
-0.5348415970802307,
0.6783632040023804,
0.1846267580986023,
-0.9321034550666809,
0.6506807804107666,
-0.18916741013526917,
0.19421660900115967,
0.5765388607978821,
0.5591219067573547,
-0.498985230922699,
-0.6768773794174194,
-0.5440975427627563,
-0.5978607535362244,
0.4475349187850952,
-0.3473857641220093,
-0.0039014816284179688,
-0.19715741276741028,
0.5126960873603821,
0.19338040053844452,
-0.059454891830682755,
-0.8296507000923157,
-0.14418688416481018,
0.4697645902633667,
-0.4032976031303406,
-0.6655176877975464,
-0.35658982396125793,
0.019303588196635246,
-0.23753617703914642,
0.627846896648407,
-0.23890158534049988,
0.2005627304315567,
0.20574641227722168,
-0.12143472582101822,
0.20810820162296295,
-0.09064777940511703,
0.03756755217909813,
0.5587028861045837,
-0.38992440700531006,
0.03347763791680336,
0.3109324872493744,
-0.3256974518299103,
0.16807493567466736,
-0.23491574823856354,
0.010793528519570827,
0.011447381228208542,
0.7472811937332153,
0.5424490571022034,
0.03505667671561241,
-0.6493054032325745,
0.45014649629592896,
-0.09642203152179718,
-0.3121718764305115,
-0.42940855026245117,
0.2337218075990677,
0.20696856081485748,
0.5052279829978943,
0.2926301062107086,
-0.1572107970714569,
0.12939485907554626,
-0.24205587804317474,
0.35050567984580994,
0.7684186100959778,
-0.38646650314331055,
-0.06803327053785324,
0.6864501237869263,
-0.21911928057670593,
-0.046839796006679535,
0.31118276715278625,
-0.14622141420841217,
-0.25652480125427246,
0.7035213708877563,
0.6335965991020203,
0.6939910650253296,
-0.27653488516807556,
0.4673975706100464,
0.6007993817329407,
0.480899840593338,
-0.1922139972448349,
0.5338127613067627,
0.18941113352775574,
-0.7716626524925232,
-0.7524306774139404,
-1.0351364612579346,
-0.4549074172973633,
0.1128769963979721,
-0.671377420425415,
0.1168801411986351,
-0.5068548321723938,
-0.3992159068584442,
0.028665298596024513,
-0.05076742544770241,
-0.6225326061248779,
0.36797335743904114,
0.18536266684532166,
1.2224578857421875,
-1.0302008390426636,
0.4164406955242157,
0.2140418142080307,
-0.05498071014881134,
-0.6595340967178345,
-0.2180565893650055,
0.1527731567621231,
-1.0123775005340576,
0.730421781539917,
-0.14228013157844543,
-0.09687793999910355,
0.10473814606666565,
-0.2300940304994583,
-1.162773847579956,
0.7794978022575378,
0.5798165798187256,
-0.432239294052124,
-0.022117018699645996,
0.08816047012805939,
0.4151396155357361,
-0.42640209197998047,
0.27326422929763794,
0.8853483200073242,
0.449572890996933,
-0.224531352519989,
-0.6680487990379333,
-0.1460643708705902,
0.3890629708766937,
-0.021686239168047905,
0.19782193005084991,
-0.41374969482421875,
0.39315342903137207,
-0.3138623535633087,
-0.0475335456430912,
0.13879604637622833,
0.6868910789489746,
0.058314550668001175,
0.1703396886587143,
0.4902039170265198,
0.6818508505821228,
0.9200925827026367,
-0.013750731945037842,
1.198653221130371,
0.05522169545292854,
0.3482707142829895,
1.1475931406021118,
-0.027868621051311493,
1.1915043592453003,
0.21570982038974762,
-0.6653286218643188,
0.2602042257785797,
0.9799305200576782,
-0.049163397401571274,
0.3871704339981079,
0.33975866436958313,
-0.2692911922931671,
-0.46495670080184937,
-0.05614658072590828,
0.1678125411272049,
0.9222506284713745,
0.6712655425071716,
-0.49077969789505005,
-0.31198692321777344,
-0.3811083734035492,
-0.1567203849554062,
0.012524483725428581,
-0.5508949160575867,
0.9394046068191528,
0.3298110067844391,
-0.47338515520095825,
0.23751893639564514,
-0.12183310091495514,
0.619758129119873,
-0.556822657585144,
0.31832826137542725,
-0.09961375594139099,
0.19233758747577667,
-0.21637050807476044,
-0.7704994678497314,
0.5231817364692688,
0.046777334064245224,
-0.2165939211845398,
-0.06457524001598358,
0.47628939151763916,
-0.20660527050495148,
-0.7976841330528259,
0.5640857815742493,
0.9768637418746948,
0.32922986149787903,
0.06578373908996582,
-0.5436012744903564,
-0.5899451375007629,
-0.1654898226261139,
-0.34570714831352234,
0.24806620180606842,
0.23095165193080902,
0.07568183541297913,
0.8463526368141174,
0.45747771859169006,
0.4479212462902069,
0.07635674625635147,
0.43920278549194336,
0.10967211425304413,
-0.697837233543396,
-0.35147392749786377,
-1.0175719261169434,
0.256506085395813,
0.17911899089813232,
-0.05506737157702446,
0.7468335628509521,
0.5360468626022339,
0.5765196681022644,
-0.09876144677400589,
0.8279904723167419,
0.3719012439250946,
0.7240360975265503,
-0.8565797805786133,
0.6218813061714172,
-0.6051742434501648,
0.1508822739124298,
-0.13828139007091522,
-0.969099223613739,
-0.6561765670776367,
0.6296554207801819,
-0.5914782285690308,
-0.023803457617759705,
0.5109949707984924,
0.5780324935913086,
0.08051570504903793,
-0.28621625900268555,
0.4691455662250519,
0.07924371212720871,
0.19745926558971405,
0.7693897485733032,
0.65519779920578,
-0.07983481138944626,
0.11332688480615616,
-0.06396856158971786,
-0.382544606924057,
-0.2673705816268921,
-1.3089253902435303,
-0.6219848394393921,
-0.20067191123962402,
-0.43688544631004333,
-0.12107053399085999,
-0.1543714702129364,
0.6595751047134399,
0.6659682393074036,
-0.6168553829193115,
-0.2883644104003906,
-0.005736310966312885,
0.3692864775657654,
-0.25689825415611267,
-0.2344958633184433,
0.30159667134284973,
-0.6344737410545349,
-0.7609776854515076,
0.2647186517715454,
0.18488700687885284,
0.07323934882879257,
-0.2650826573371887,
0.1339385062456131,
-0.25160011649131775,
0.34350141882896423,
0.6137495636940002,
-0.015106478706002235,
-0.415681391954422,
-0.4441602826118469,
-0.2528016269207001,
-0.04024696350097656,
0.13376814126968384,
0.5380664467811584,
-0.7526054382324219,
0.05132512003183365,
0.522969663143158,
0.7175244688987732,
0.309292197227478,
-0.054015375673770905,
0.7380807995796204,
-0.75520920753479,
0.027635887265205383,
0.4002867341041565,
0.6795772910118103,
0.3333195447921753,
-0.38332366943359375,
0.6552728414535522,
0.08535321801900864,
-0.5089961886405945,
-0.6615563035011292,
0.44195282459259033,
-0.6569837331771851,
-0.3200185000896454,
1.0559017658233643,
-0.31264814734458923,
-0.3991563618183136,
0.04609949141740799,
0.2829051613807678,
0.13358910381793976,
-0.0048187715001404285,
0.6458184719085693,
0.6943311095237732,
-0.3550201952457428,
-0.030298611149191856,
-0.9159286022186279,
0.5931001901626587,
0.5326628684997559,
-0.7644779682159424,
0.27649834752082825,
0.40532436966896057,
0.329213410615921,
-0.015358843840658665,
0.7783884406089783,
0.06529074162244797,
0.14302891492843628,
0.2355455607175827,
-0.09604306519031525,
0.47200220823287964,
-0.3245617747306824,
-0.24696017801761627,
-0.11459427326917648,
0.2905556261539459,
-0.024717053398489952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04178v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04178v1
|
Attempt Towards Stress Transfer in Speech-to-Speech Machine Translation
| 2024-03-07T03:21:19 | 2024-03-07T03:21:19 |
Sai Akarsh, Vamshi Raghusimha, Anindita Mondal, Anil Vuppala
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The language diversity in India's education sector poses a significant
challenge, hindering inclusivity. Despite the democratization of knowledge
through online educational content, the dominance of English, as the internet's
lingua franca, limits accessibility, emphasizing the crucial need for
translation into Indian languages. Despite existing Speech-to-Speech Machine
Translation (SSMT) technologies, the lack of intonation in these systems gives
monotonous translations, leading to a loss of audience interest and
disengagement from the content. To address this, our paper introduces a dataset
with stress annotations in Indian English and also a Text-to-Speech (TTS)
architecture capable of incorporating stress into synthesized speech. This
dataset is used for training a stress detection model, which is then used in
the SSMT system for detecting stress in the source speech and transferring it
into the target language speech. The TTS architecture is based on FastPitch and
can modify the variances based on stressed words given. We present an Indian
English-to-Hindi SSMT system that can transfer stress and aim to enhance the
overall quality and engagement of educational content.
|
[
-0.1716289222240448,
-0.6647957563400269,
0.011175268329679966,
0.5669704675674438,
-0.7131401896476746,
0.311396986246109,
-0.3174975514411926,
-0.38431546092033386,
0.1309419423341751,
0.012145140208303928,
-0.5317493677139282,
-0.16405074298381805,
-0.9316681027412415,
0.3740781545639038,
-0.7825832366943359,
0.9790551662445068,
-0.2146209329366684,
0.022315898910164833,
-0.007733469363301992,
0.08745573461055756,
-0.3616849184036255,
-0.43616682291030884,
-0.619291365146637,
-0.21742483973503113,
-0.013143535703420639,
0.4309110939502716,
0.47031542658805847,
0.42055195569992065,
0.6213812828063965,
0.16013455390930176,
-0.12373644858598709,
0.2891160547733307,
-0.24611841142177582,
0.3401242792606354,
-0.36529627442359924,
-0.22819867730140686,
0.04184522107243538,
-0.4547700583934784,
1.029408574104309,
0.27164244651794434,
-0.014769974164664745,
0.31670504808425903,
0.3393838703632355,
0.16264931857585907,
-0.3771498203277588,
0.1147821769118309,
-0.33911392092704773,
0.10298860818147659,
-0.5839295983314514,
-0.24961702525615692,
-0.4231981635093689,
-0.6524924039840698,
-0.027169935405254364,
-0.3384109437465668,
-0.34500202536582947,
-0.02020661160349846,
0.6087456941604614,
0.8286922574043274,
-0.4701079726219177,
-0.4329063892364502,
-1.0421700477600098,
0.5014978051185608,
-0.3391501307487488,
0.4946795403957367,
0.2196115255355835,
0.31790363788604736,
0.1920088529586792,
-0.35389524698257446,
-0.4010731875896454,
0.27552494406700134,
0.13320904970169067,
0.1413218379020691,
0.26816046237945557,
-0.38801512122154236,
-0.2759760618209839,
0.5000731945037842,
-0.3518699109554291,
0.1408763825893402,
-0.7642256617546082,
-0.0007429789402522147,
0.30748432874679565,
0.10897066444158554,
0.5119982361793518,
-0.3930206596851349,
-0.5503512024879456,
-0.3182176947593689,
-0.14790095388889313,
0.02835298515856266,
-0.09509099274873734,
0.8346786499023438,
-0.22217658162117004,
0.5181666612625122,
0.15029633045196533,
0.3217732310295105,
0.013716443441808224,
-0.23229926824569702,
0.31599241495132446,
-0.22517530620098114,
-0.20954154431819916,
0.6359921097755432,
0.6163151860237122,
-0.04737990349531174,
0.1297100931406021,
0.07921664416790009,
0.07588373869657516,
0.015722764655947685,
0.1886100172996521,
-0.7063284516334534,
0.6246922612190247,
-0.0739680677652359,
-0.11171574890613556,
-0.06217091903090477,
-0.39787259697914124,
-1.0995159149169922,
-0.45091041922569275,
-0.20627863705158234,
0.3655281960964203,
-0.7000477313995361,
-0.4276111423969269,
-0.05106402933597565,
0.10290329158306122,
0.4448535442352295,
0.19779370725154877,
-0.5267133712768555,
0.43160495162010193,
0.1922096610069275,
1.0336087942123413,
-0.517562747001648,
-0.051797911524772644,
-0.06182454898953438,
0.2205958515405655,
-0.20341306924819946,
0.7999231219291687,
-0.6345064043998718,
-0.9402891397476196,
0.027237992733716965,
-0.19494712352752686,
-0.25919944047927856,
-0.30698174238204956,
1.038717269897461,
-0.05499610677361488,
0.11665672063827515,
0.2518554627895355,
-0.5018898248672485,
0.030931252986192703,
0.1432013064622879,
-0.13491922616958618,
1.2823055982589722,
0.1771925389766693,
-0.51817786693573,
-0.08469951152801514,
-0.7769342660903931,
-0.8630602955818176,
0.10860557109117508,
0.09486490488052368,
-0.29630783200263977,
0.19001920521259308,
0.36061227321624756,
0.3074607849121094,
-0.544858455657959,
0.16950146853923798,
-0.09336331486701965,
-0.49960580468177795,
0.16326424479484558,
-0.2590843439102173,
0.6218149065971375,
0.633698582649231,
-0.3411833643913269,
-0.057477518916130066,
-0.5757905840873718,
0.12454593926668167,
0.06560402363538742,
-0.18499547243118286,
-0.4729084372520447,
-0.28891608119010925,
0.3217123746871948,
0.6235549449920654,
-0.17222099006175995,
-0.35238203406333923,
0.013641685247421265,
-0.24712632596492767,
0.392577201128006,
0.7527938485145569,
-0.009845394641160965,
0.08128286898136139,
0.024883318692445755,
0.5563932061195374,
0.03893900290131569,
0.2682175636291504,
0.2654859721660614,
-0.35559821128845215,
-0.4462255835533142,
-0.3706214427947998,
-0.08420208841562271,
0.8836312294006348,
-0.6472292542457581,
0.13964058458805084,
-0.42959582805633545,
-0.6478866338729858,
-1.2439923286437988,
-0.10576893389225006,
0.29834040999412537,
0.703603982925415,
0.7053173184394836,
-0.24992743134498596,
-0.506872296333313,
-0.742700457572937,
-0.38474342226982117,
0.038200508803129196,
0.17404603958129883,
-0.09822575002908707,
0.10778406262397766,
-0.15029321610927582,
0.5355280637741089,
-0.15052282810211182,
-0.6722333431243896,
0.048598647117614746,
0.25586527585983276,
-0.21921654045581818,
0.7585303783416748,
0.014235959388315678,
-0.7617796659469604,
-0.6563535332679749,
-0.15308593213558197,
-0.584044873714447,
-0.23718343675136566,
-0.21019744873046875,
-0.20357483625411987,
0.09475572407245636,
0.5776357054710388,
-0.7069529891014099,
0.5177435278892517,
0.49291670322418213,
-0.2282598614692688,
0.4987742006778717,
0.14656968414783478,
0.5834460258483887,
-1.605008840560913,
0.22054633498191833,
-0.2832808494567871,
-0.14729559421539307,
-0.4780844449996948,
-0.13860031962394714,
-0.20374277234077454,
-0.5953192114830017,
-0.7127761840820312,
0.7878717184066772,
-0.18469113111495972,
0.11809749156236649,
-0.3479473292827606,
0.4452700614929199,
-0.33531221747398376,
0.26935282349586487,
-0.152440145611763,
1.0412449836730957,
0.5821105241775513,
-0.4924773871898651,
-0.002451605862006545,
0.7624938488006592,
-0.13797681033611298,
1.210424542427063,
-0.2620406746864319,
0.10602764785289764,
0.05993486940860748,
0.08253712207078934,
-0.9710816740989685,
-0.24786770343780518,
0.4393225312232971,
-0.6431071162223816,
0.41223475337028503,
-0.005882386118173599,
-0.43407174944877625,
-0.25059255957603455,
0.006779768504202366,
0.37710514664649963,
0.8052980303764343,
-0.2733590304851532,
0.3950406312942505,
0.40558481216430664,
-0.4648765027523041,
-0.1483766883611679,
-1.1850858926773071,
0.2724670469760895,
-0.2634619474411011,
-0.241484597325325,
0.1795351654291153,
-0.10602971166372299,
0.014650306664407253,
0.3347858190536499,
-0.1749030500650406,
-0.4587344527244568,
0.041636135429143906,
0.5731421709060669,
0.14674219489097595,
-0.06913965195417404,
0.39658838510513306,
0.3912360668182373,
0.2611071467399597,
-0.10150313377380371,
-0.40004926919937134,
0.29065650701522827,
-0.08639468997716904,
-0.36983639001846313,
-0.7128931283950806,
0.5711495876312256,
0.7651920318603516,
-0.13766580820083618,
0.6171329021453857,
0.8853898644447327,
-0.49264129996299744,
-0.15199711918830872,
-0.19530139863491058,
-0.10274086892604828,
-0.3896576464176178,
0.36184778809547424,
-0.5169708728790283,
-0.9360816478729248,
0.11143014580011368,
-0.4984321594238281,
-0.3576536774635315,
0.6551830172538757,
0.6365901231765747,
-0.005635722540318966,
0.7536035776138306,
0.5968042016029358,
-0.16535034775733948,
0.48543018102645874,
0.4251883029937744,
0.26899150013923645,
-0.7801950573921204,
-0.14372777938842773,
-0.7606908082962036,
-0.20396891236305237,
-0.3998194634914398,
-0.5836142301559448,
0.2515679895877838,
-0.18941836059093475,
-0.12369176745414734,
0.18862809240818024,
-0.9117662310600281,
-0.019129520282149315,
0.37535279989242554,
-0.07266265898942947,
0.10175994783639908,
0.3291236460208893,
-0.011376594193279743,
-0.15711785852909088,
-0.3419071435928345,
-0.3594455122947693,
0.6636008620262146,
0.026675758883357048,
0.5163455605506897,
0.05585489794611931,
0.639552652835846,
0.4266701936721802,
0.4625939428806305,
-0.6102573871612549,
0.49886929988861084,
-0.5168548226356506,
-0.861957311630249,
-0.33259180188179016,
-0.43697455525398254,
-0.6716492176055908,
-0.02626662515103817,
-0.047528624534606934,
-0.5751829743385315,
0.09806554764509201,
-0.0426640585064888,
-0.2989521324634552,
0.366228312253952,
-0.7796087861061096,
0.4588770270347595,
-0.3582633137702942,
-0.421682745218277,
-0.4006136655807495,
-0.7721378207206726,
0.49326324462890625,
-0.1913122832775116,
0.5842576026916504,
-0.09688033908605576,
0.1219569519162178,
0.7391519546508789,
0.03855817764997482,
0.7868953943252563,
-0.05393947660923004,
0.09683139622211456,
0.4241003692150116,
0.10573207587003708,
0.31987810134887695,
-0.34371069073677063,
-0.2331433743238449,
-0.17898757755756378,
-0.17183199524879456,
-0.39691856503486633,
-0.3972338140010834,
0.5488894581794739,
-0.9984838962554932,
-0.45143625140190125,
-0.3127181828022003,
-0.7489365935325623,
-0.43467792868614197,
0.2170291692018509,
0.06363607197999954,
0.11032578349113464,
0.03346329554915428,
0.0918312519788742,
0.46564555168151855,
0.04066647216677666,
0.22713437676429749,
0.1789601743221283,
-0.11056242883205414,
-0.28676801919937134,
0.9281921982765198,
0.1554793268442154,
0.12567034363746643,
0.1651492863893509,
0.09340083599090576,
-0.6244929432868958,
-0.28804630041122437,
-0.46682482957839966,
0.11903919279575348,
-0.7889789938926697,
-0.013478073291480541,
-0.3798212707042694,
-0.41865286231040955,
-0.7643943428993225,
-0.3128245174884796,
-0.6942067742347717,
-0.4252794086933136,
-0.38417744636535645,
0.0185715202242136,
0.5246090888977051,
0.576238214969635,
-0.050228655338287354,
0.4001597464084625,
-0.9413760304450989,
0.12473849207162857,
0.20802494883537292,
0.45597174763679504,
-0.4412808418273926,
-1.1329233646392822,
-0.27163028717041016,
-0.25822746753692627,
-0.03924120217561722,
-0.7824090719223022,
0.2862432599067688,
0.4754409193992615,
0.1353752613067627,
0.02224671095609665,
0.33271998167037964,
0.9677948355674744,
-0.2874199450016022,
0.6864118576049805,
0.14828744530677795,
-1.2078417539596558,
0.6591728925704956,
0.13229870796203613,
0.2964460253715515,
0.6759917736053467,
0.6782479286193848,
-0.8230779767036438,
-0.5444657206535339,
-0.3856130838394165,
-1.0390205383300781,
0.5669129490852356,
0.1631978303194046,
0.08001367747783661,
0.2076064497232437,
0.20826669037342072,
0.13644526898860931,
0.10466304421424866,
-0.2063852846622467,
0.011787695810198784,
-0.5065051317214966,
-0.5078108906745911,
-0.04390854388475418,
0.006876267958432436,
0.1173955425620079,
-0.15043871104717255,
0.8006145358085632,
0.31136542558670044,
0.20703166723251343,
0.48584747314453125,
-0.46132490038871765,
-0.24853113293647766,
0.756098210811615,
0.8080213069915771,
-0.02642200142145157,
-0.33004286885261536,
0.4091588258743286,
0.24749210476875305,
-0.6237732768058777,
0.42296135425567627,
0.40959101915359497,
-0.13823851943016052,
0.05117752030491829,
-0.12399177998304367,
1.0496035814285278,
0.3475485146045685,
-0.5583699345588684,
-0.005021163262426853,
0.2600992023944855,
0.07345055043697357,
-0.008018702268600464,
-0.3333069980144501,
0.07880791276693344,
0.10796527564525604,
0.24421630799770355,
0.1410689651966095,
0.043321624398231506,
-0.2809598445892334,
0.4163395166397095,
-0.20866145193576813,
-0.7209283113479614,
-0.37782302498817444,
0.9461865425109863,
0.5439914464950562,
-0.6533858180046082,
0.4781455993652344,
-0.0925116166472435,
-0.5552448034286499,
0.044439807534217834,
0.7368307709693909,
0.9631756544113159,
-0.9063065052032471,
0.01704142428934574,
0.32733625173568726,
0.4662432372570038,
-0.24943985044956207,
0.2985815703868866,
0.16943393647670746,
-0.0618007592856884,
-0.45832279324531555,
-0.5475780367851257,
-0.6529725790023804,
-0.2402132749557495,
-0.6783462762832642,
0.395888090133667,
-0.29346200823783875,
-0.28149479627609253,
-0.5577407479286194,
-0.2795426547527313,
-0.5732093453407288,
0.46961429715156555,
0.4693261384963989,
0.7656070590019226,
-1.0483033657073975,
0.9996017217636108,
0.7188521027565002,
-0.4829157292842865,
-0.8753845691680908,
-0.11148657649755478,
-0.03529601916670799,
-0.8613422513008118,
0.6629151105880737,
-0.12355015426874161,
-0.43826034665107727,
0.41670966148376465,
-0.08791986852884293,
-0.9699041843414307,
0.559719979763031,
0.3291366696357727,
-0.2936018109321594,
0.22093947231769562,
0.5326293706893921,
0.5330204963684082,
-0.1543346792459488,
0.04678843542933464,
0.2500920593738556,
0.6023615598678589,
0.03463253378868103,
-0.8884214162826538,
0.2755899429321289,
-0.3664683401584625,
-0.2139493077993393,
0.08180207014083862,
-0.576115608215332,
0.8377680778503418,
0.29846978187561035,
-0.4981187880039215,
-0.5067891478538513,
0.5639804601669312,
-0.077700175344944,
0.187086284160614,
0.4561315178871155,
0.44133704900741577,
0.6380153298377991,
0.17038947343826294,
0.9233661890029907,
-0.3101942241191864,
0.1644294410943985,
1.2017334699630737,
-0.3161659240722656,
1.0565723180770874,
0.9068540334701538,
-0.17209507524967194,
0.1354590803384781,
0.6438000798225403,
0.16532297432422638,
0.28327658772468567,
0.26548486948013306,
-0.09495818614959717,
-0.04245002567768097,
-0.7190399169921875,
-0.5243257284164429,
0.42703181505203247,
0.5911802649497986,
-0.06174885481595993,
-0.4295364022254944,
0.5011097192764282,
0.010763094760477543,
0.2112160325050354,
-0.35848268866539,
0.3227490186691284,
0.24538633227348328,
-0.5393553376197815,
0.8250283598899841,
-0.42330703139305115,
0.7443238496780396,
-0.657509982585907,
0.20655618607997894,
-0.22984015941619873,
0.12014295905828476,
0.003886869177222252,
-0.819857656955719,
0.8067796230316162,
0.2325233370065689,
0.16038228571414948,
-0.6111670732498169,
0.8358547687530518,
-0.6554004549980164,
-0.5382124185562134,
0.3726884722709656,
0.5608043670654297,
0.6002780199050903,
0.0166022889316082,
-0.3899277448654175,
0.2732921838760376,
-0.281796395778656,
-0.17339690029621124,
0.42608514428138733,
0.4784984886646271,
-0.2032911777496338,
0.6006988883018494,
0.27234235405921936,
0.2863081693649292,
0.38347551226615906,
-0.2730870544910431,
0.4587184190750122,
-0.45432016253471375,
-0.46961796283721924,
-0.6107785701751709,
0.6226271986961365,
0.07026952505111694,
-0.5764531493186951,
0.6875280141830444,
0.28334924578666687,
0.5262919664382935,
-0.26365792751312256,
1.005692720413208,
-0.18411488831043243,
0.5306302905082703,
-0.1214509904384613,
0.7005246877670288,
-0.8309310078620911,
-0.33279791474342346,
-0.20957887172698975,
-0.41732093691825867,
-0.31792518496513367,
0.1736505627632141,
0.011225477792322636,
-0.5258201956748962,
0.8169423341751099,
0.4089841842651367,
0.046388182789087296,
-0.1139746755361557,
0.2500333786010742,
0.16691400110721588,
0.11620558053255081,
0.6032484173774719,
0.6131938099861145,
-0.4270908832550049,
1.1683545112609863,
-0.10308954864740372,
-0.06376521289348602,
-0.5021669864654541,
-0.694004476070404,
-0.40616440773010254,
-0.794999361038208,
-0.4021258056163788,
-0.3264250159263611,
0.16012224555015564,
1.1999880075454712,
0.6265134215354919,
-0.7554126977920532,
-0.45574629306793213,
0.33908337354660034,
0.13508574664592743,
-0.305617094039917,
-0.15845264494419098,
0.5606756210327148,
-0.5207730531692505,
-0.7551866769790649,
0.5446222424507141,
0.32533854246139526,
0.22653302550315857,
0.04925443232059479,
0.32534852623939514,
-0.5820266604423523,
0.4125533401966095,
0.505799412727356,
0.46005553007125854,
-0.409319132566452,
-0.42130938172340393,
-0.13055408000946045,
-0.36452940106391907,
0.1281023919582367,
0.6693912148475647,
-0.32400423288345337,
0.47352588176727295,
0.29170405864715576,
1.4030017852783203,
0.5299890041351318,
-0.24110428988933563,
0.07780547440052032,
-0.9704453349113464,
0.40162205696105957,
0.28076478838920593,
-0.20695456862449646,
0.5095245242118835,
-0.44536063075065613,
0.4600187838077545,
0.3979323208332062,
-0.32183733582496643,
-1.1440821886062622,
-0.014355991035699844,
-0.9466060400009155,
-0.14482174813747406,
0.8335896134376526,
-0.026926061138510704,
-0.4630596935749054,
-0.08900980651378632,
-0.2981124818325043,
1.0205885171890259,
-0.21055249869823456,
1.1342153549194336,
0.7479501366615295,
0.08651410788297653,
-0.2351657748222351,
-0.5132998824119568,
0.6146310567855835,
0.7529811859130859,
-1.1520684957504272,
0.03169803321361542,
-0.21400871872901917,
-0.02309047430753708,
0.3183164596557617,
0.5189495086669922,
-0.2079152762889862,
0.019881736487150192,
-0.02002856507897377,
0.43038952350616455,
0.029941493645310402,
0.004175036214292049,
-0.33891138434410095,
0.44134649634361267,
-0.15571632981300354,
-0.5566235184669495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13830v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13830v1
|
Bridging Text and Molecule: A Survey on Multimodal Frameworks for Molecule
| 2024-03-07T03:03:13 | 2024-03-07T03:03:13 |
Yi Xiao, Xiangxin Zhou, Qiang Liu, Liang Wang
|
q-bio.BM
|
q-bio.BM, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Artificial intelligence has demonstrated immense potential in scientific
research. Within molecular science, it is revolutionizing the traditional
computer-aided paradigm, ushering in a new era of deep learning. With recent
progress in multimodal learning and natural language processing, an emerging
trend has targeted at building multimodal frameworks to jointly model molecules
with textual domain knowledge. In this paper, we present the first systematic
survey on multimodal frameworks for molecules research. Specifically,we begin
with the development of molecular deep learning and point out the necessity to
involve textual modality. Next, we focus on recent advances in text-molecule
alignment methods, categorizing current models into two groups based on their
architectures and listing relevant pre-training tasks. Furthermore, we delves
into the utilization of large language models and prompting techniques for
molecular tasks and present significant applications in drug discovery.
Finally, we discuss the limitations in this field and highlight several
promising directions for future research.
|
[
-0.3010798692703247,
-0.9651031494140625,
0.8228182792663574,
-0.12446262687444687,
0.17649471759796143,
0.44674593210220337,
-0.38103142380714417,
-0.5636716485023499,
0.09967787563800812,
0.2399858832359314,
-0.5303264260292053,
-0.3780117332935333,
-0.7528091073036194,
0.33371415734291077,
-0.33604806661605835,
0.9167134165763855,
0.04819042980670929,
0.3569280207157135,
-0.6764804720878601,
-0.2361299842596054,
-0.022803358733654022,
-0.4574808180332184,
-0.2687331736087799,
-0.3477720618247986,
0.8871118426322937,
0.3134646713733673,
0.3295111656188965,
0.4507669508457184,
0.8261138796806335,
0.4256141483783722,
-0.12202296406030655,
0.21271401643753052,
-0.022597718983888626,
0.23914936184883118,
-0.15208348631858826,
-0.4082326591014862,
-0.5405063629150391,
0.09972990304231644,
0.49060702323913574,
1.0732582807540894,
0.14359140396118164,
-0.2685307264328003,
-0.1685696840286255,
0.6262115240097046,
-0.49076250195503235,
-0.030345065519213676,
-0.19014373421669006,
0.2056281417608261,
-0.23855020105838776,
-0.13993778824806213,
-0.2217526137828827,
0.26406151056289673,
0.6500331163406372,
-0.7216209173202515,
0.2448883205652237,
0.11466767638921738,
0.518215000629425,
0.007433435879647732,
-1.0530999898910522,
-0.7239482402801514,
-0.5519182682037354,
0.8781445622444153,
-0.520110011100769,
0.5447054505348206,
-0.005014494061470032,
0.34550169110298157,
-0.13170510530471802,
-0.9774097800254822,
-0.5800986886024475,
-0.6976215839385986,
0.045982908457517624,
0.09078827500343323,
0.0009588093380443752,
0.47527021169662476,
-0.29315900802612305,
0.45748990774154663,
-0.7015363574028015,
-0.0880621001124382,
-0.49435827136039734,
-0.2551140785217285,
0.3327792286872864,
-0.07001206278800964,
0.5755436420440674,
-0.13326552510261536,
-0.6583977937698364,
-0.14944429695606232,
-0.23367802798748016,
-0.16446295380592346,
0.046177834272384644,
0.3713889718055725,
0.1654154509305954,
0.9716429710388184,
0.04386909678578377,
0.7265100479125977,
-0.1895567923784256,
0.136271134018898,
0.15291649103164673,
-1.0886346101760864,
-0.39875873923301697,
0.35196056962013245,
0.8922882080078125,
0.3398464322090149,
0.1977071315050125,
0.07504233717918396,
0.01710880734026432,
0.11165142804384232,
0.30910322070121765,
-0.9288495182991028,
-0.2515856623649597,
0.3263310492038727,
-0.5436897277832031,
-0.21463558077812195,
-0.02037036046385765,
-1.1860710382461548,
-0.5473570227622986,
-0.277811735868454,
0.35513728857040405,
-0.5659043192863464,
-0.18479269742965698,
0.13036246597766876,
-0.40919849276542664,
-0.3210557699203491,
0.2520618438720703,
-1.129408836364746,
0.01294371485710144,
0.5682331323623657,
0.8513240814208984,
-0.18286924064159393,
-0.3836546242237091,
-0.24320249259471893,
0.3357499837875366,
-0.014950190670788288,
0.8839230537414551,
-0.7751484513282776,
-0.3905547857284546,
-0.17138628661632538,
-0.11919937282800674,
-0.08336932957172394,
-0.34369680285453796,
0.07590684294700623,
-0.23437905311584473,
0.5289901494979858,
-0.12409643828868866,
-0.6817830204963684,
-0.32626256346702576,
0.3806317448616028,
-0.6920926570892334,
0.5018417835235596,
0.0017699965974316,
-0.4417150914669037,
0.32583194971084595,
-0.8051319718360901,
-0.37660878896713257,
-0.21340207755565643,
-0.4335361421108246,
-0.33543661236763,
0.16415247321128845,
0.1967427283525467,
0.529023289680481,
-0.3917320668697357,
0.5305318832397461,
-0.2940636873245239,
0.14832782745361328,
0.6185720562934875,
-0.4596925973892212,
0.46093258261680603,
0.2089378982782364,
-0.24564269185066223,
0.4135547876358032,
-0.7716898918151855,
-0.20449818670749664,
-0.457856684923172,
-0.4382597506046295,
-0.10135065764188766,
-0.2203851342201233,
0.41323474049568176,
0.20688383281230927,
0.14177362620830536,
-0.39733579754829407,
0.49156278371810913,
-0.25314098596572876,
0.7738007307052612,
0.6275535225868225,
-0.06785693019628525,
0.8885977268218994,
-0.02492787316441536,
0.48683732748031616,
0.2431054562330246,
-0.2864360511302948,
-0.522293210029602,
-0.40865200757980347,
-0.4225195646286011,
-0.36225613951683044,
0.4132658839225769,
0.33667993545532227,
-0.6316478252410889,
0.16775749623775482,
-0.10667343437671661,
-0.383230060338974,
-0.31365862488746643,
0.3534894585609436,
0.21683742105960846,
0.25345346331596375,
0.5908085107803345,
-0.21995030343532562,
-0.4989422857761383,
-0.9276357293128967,
-0.3721407949924469,
-0.05014587566256523,
0.09014494717121124,
0.3875639736652374,
0.7005235552787781,
-0.7627457976341248,
0.8874675035476685,
-0.2502431869506836,
-0.4086310565471649,
-0.337647944688797,
0.2895302176475525,
-0.25331220030784607,
0.606755256652832,
0.4348163604736328,
-1.2546151876449585,
-0.22190621495246887,
0.25104016065597534,
-0.7601771354675293,
0.3102837800979614,
-0.043845392763614655,
-0.06379673629999161,
0.014992459677159786,
0.7965092062950134,
-0.7303013801574707,
-0.0065718749538064,
0.5058478116989136,
-0.4375275671482086,
-0.013697016052901745,
-0.057035673409700394,
0.3353946805000305,
-1.230501413345337,
0.23529821634292603,
0.32226645946502686,
-0.14562487602233887,
-0.8694794774055481,
-0.4472401738166809,
-0.1120087057352066,
-0.13018159568309784,
-0.25437942147254944,
0.7530279755592346,
-0.5396965146064758,
0.25338587164878845,
-0.316019743680954,
-0.012651745229959488,
0.13552281260490417,
0.299994558095932,
0.09404004365205765,
0.5210179090499878,
0.3849581778049469,
-0.47743815183639526,
0.43149206042289734,
0.2093922197818756,
-0.09751033037900925,
0.4419217109680176,
-0.42335301637649536,
-0.3376489579677582,
-0.29283761978149414,
0.22854197025299072,
-1.093459963798523,
-0.5483807325363159,
0.3067407011985779,
-0.6020973324775696,
0.3811905086040497,
0.06708629429340363,
-0.05115407332777977,
-0.10274752229452133,
-0.19082193076610565,
0.6598489284515381,
0.006256968714296818,
-0.03821020573377609,
0.920020341873169,
0.46169888973236084,
-0.11915954202413559,
-0.48417776823043823,
-0.9148852229118347,
0.0534987710416317,
-0.11176376789808273,
-0.48323553800582886,
0.5668801069259644,
-0.07711287587881088,
-0.24941027164459229,
-0.04227733984589577,
-0.33906033635139465,
-0.3571070432662964,
-0.183700293302536,
0.06169841066002846,
0.07145864516496658,
-0.3764319121837616,
0.3079163134098053,
-0.06909166276454926,
-0.06506020575761795,
0.06591913104057312,
-0.4001923203468323,
0.2534971237182617,
-0.1726587861776352,
0.03564656525850296,
-0.13124065101146698,
0.5454460382461548,
0.7870020866394043,
-0.3614221513271332,
0.46320679783821106,
0.660274863243103,
-0.2301275134086609,
0.11866091191768646,
-0.05768308416008949,
-0.3710688352584839,
-0.4835991859436035,
0.5351718664169312,
0.02697116881608963,
-1.0814746618270874,
-0.07976581901311874,
-0.4818451404571533,
-0.4174290895462036,
0.1627110093832016,
0.746595025062561,
-0.23250161111354828,
0.8362476229667664,
1.1358309984207153,
0.33166199922561646,
0.671318769454956,
-0.12456827610731125,
0.3482947051525116,
-0.48176297545433044,
-0.46502649784088135,
-0.37837591767311096,
-0.4086606800556183,
-0.4856080710887909,
-0.5442783832550049,
0.5374286770820618,
0.03837084770202637,
0.02485928125679493,
0.14383092522621155,
-0.45812079310417175,
0.26860859990119934,
0.47687575221061707,
0.003937326371669769,
0.08340276032686234,
0.07071707397699356,
-0.3554587960243225,
0.2434154748916626,
-0.7100481390953064,
-0.4936658442020416,
1.134353756904602,
0.18997308611869812,
0.5171881318092346,
0.06463959813117981,
0.26490333676338196,
0.1433515101671219,
0.10662946850061417,
-0.7227640748023987,
0.5064284801483154,
0.0587788000702858,
-0.9207651019096375,
-0.187360018491745,
-0.47789889574050903,
-0.9034663438796997,
0.0718255490064621,
-0.4659227430820465,
-0.3948318362236023,
0.4349515736103058,
0.24777951836585999,
-0.35957270860671997,
0.1558454930782318,
-0.6928750872612,
1.1753807067871094,
-0.516243040561676,
-0.3292071521282196,
-0.04654091224074364,
-1.0050770044326782,
0.24162648618221283,
0.1916816085577011,
0.15551966428756714,
-0.25101861357688904,
-0.27110615372657776,
0.5142958760261536,
-0.09370062500238419,
0.6090047359466553,
0.05700641870498657,
-0.22043560445308685,
0.24594466388225555,
-0.12306440621614456,
-0.28517985343933105,
0.08487255126237869,
0.209501251578331,
-0.09777233749628067,
0.15416167676448822,
-0.5088664889335632,
-0.5846773386001587,
0.6376753449440002,
-0.3125569820404053,
-0.12653334438800812,
-0.6753088235855103,
-0.49389514327049255,
-0.2840673327445984,
0.48456069827079773,
0.22984831035137177,
0.44459885358810425,
-0.1978047639131546,
0.3139772117137909,
0.6966409683227539,
-0.0861041247844696,
0.5476060509681702,
0.1491706222295761,
-0.3304665982723236,
-0.6420453786849976,
1.1453193426132202,
-0.13065007328987122,
0.19898764789104462,
0.8876556754112244,
0.1501384973526001,
-0.3080607056617737,
-0.4337485730648041,
-0.5618789196014404,
-0.07198622822761536,
-0.46294525265693665,
-0.12135197222232819,
-0.6418650150299072,
0.008752268739044666,
-0.47113901376724243,
-0.2077120542526245,
-0.4788585901260376,
-0.3754998445510864,
-0.24659842252731323,
-0.1922208070755005,
0.41135454177856445,
0.6366455554962158,
0.07888712733983994,
0.04115714877843857,
-1.0547149181365967,
0.5662115216255188,
0.2993396520614624,
0.23623168468475342,
-0.26060643792152405,
0.46188047528266907,
-0.3591686487197876,
0.1659037321805954,
-0.15457169711589813,
-0.8870761394500732,
0.13034354150295258,
0.3751697242259979,
0.43877288699150085,
0.25600695610046387,
-0.4222281575202942,
0.316916286945343,
-0.44535067677497864,
0.8333014249801636,
0.19181330502033234,
-0.6738840937614441,
0.513965904712677,
-0.42777538299560547,
0.15084350109100342,
0.6744863986968994,
0.6800202131271362,
-0.5684438943862915,
0.13050317764282227,
-0.159245103597641,
-1.0305651426315308,
0.10096032172441483,
0.27013877034187317,
-0.07307248562574387,
0.12910577654838562,
0.15842469036579132,
0.12225187569856644,
0.7049726247787476,
-0.6415216326713562,
-0.2290937304496765,
-0.2721756100654602,
-0.6783350110054016,
-0.3672718107700348,
0.0999201089143753,
-0.19893763959407806,
-0.2850671708583832,
0.3557872772216797,
-0.35732123255729675,
0.3699154555797577,
0.4235062301158905,
-0.42345625162124634,
0.24365146458148956,
0.4397270977497101,
0.8940847516059875,
0.4512964189052582,
-0.1385307013988495,
0.2981698513031006,
-0.5346838235855103,
-0.6861408948898315,
0.39896345138549805,
0.25915050506591797,
0.1306573897600174,
-0.2053520381450653,
0.5137615203857422,
0.5959790945053101,
0.1496097594499588,
-1.1600828170776367,
0.3882904648780823,
0.04753758758306503,
-0.21644076704978943,
0.06432680040597916,
-0.0052284193225204945,
-0.02560412324965,
0.45835819840431213,
0.2735229432582855,
0.38456737995147705,
0.3708227872848511,
-0.9086033701896667,
0.2094845026731491,
0.5295664668083191,
-0.6067327260971069,
-0.16482622921466827,
0.6660864353179932,
0.3338789641857147,
0.012347757816314697,
0.36874544620513916,
0.27985289692878723,
-0.45087242126464844,
0.5831634402275085,
0.23452968895435333,
0.7405686974525452,
-0.09205237776041031,
0.07258469611406326,
-0.007676079403609037,
0.09955234080553055,
0.3123873770236969,
0.10504533350467682,
-0.37081536650657654,
-0.5800005793571472,
0.0019084952073171735,
-0.5162409543991089,
-0.29662609100341797,
-0.3522046208381653,
-0.13955990970134735,
0.060751065611839294,
-0.23667602241039276,
-0.09667188674211502,
0.49072447419166565,
0.0672500878572464,
-0.19809643924236298,
0.27673104405403137,
0.32396200299263,
0.8552372455596924,
-0.5214222073554993,
0.7506802678108215,
0.926440417766571,
-0.4327933192253113,
-0.014660550281405449,
-0.18035563826560974,
0.4912586808204651,
-0.15447092056274414,
0.5745016932487488,
0.5166267156600952,
-0.21592654287815094,
0.0034239620435982943,
-0.5543841123580933,
-0.7099443674087524,
0.9639889597892761,
0.003634791588410735,
-0.5143279433250427,
-0.2289351522922516,
0.26958662271499634,
0.5781568884849548,
-0.3556135296821594,
0.3064483106136322,
0.5413796901702881,
0.6544997096061707,
0.008482648059725761,
-0.5490015745162964,
-0.323307067155838,
-0.6993777751922607,
-0.13624249398708344,
0.17337407171726227,
-0.5081486701965332,
0.9623284339904785,
-0.060080718249082565,
-0.0547708123922348,
0.24374689161777496,
0.7562466263771057,
0.19152262806892395,
0.5784085392951965,
0.0852033793926239,
0.38630151748657227,
0.7379612326622009,
-0.09749145060777664,
0.7716488838195801,
-0.20124496519565582,
0.17951425909996033,
0.64471036195755,
-0.3976534307003021,
0.5509181022644043,
0.8118554353713989,
-0.04393954575061798,
0.3668282926082611,
0.5903906226158142,
-0.19054047763347626,
0.37914687395095825,
0.09051286429166794,
-0.46486157178878784,
-0.17867890000343323,
-0.04110969603061676,
-0.29982832074165344,
0.4244179129600525,
0.615125834941864,
-0.3857332468032837,
-0.17563101649284363,
0.7062856554985046,
-0.31206291913986206,
0.17474044859409332,
-0.15754681825637817,
0.8262472748756409,
0.06772483140230179,
-0.4615733027458191,
-0.10962627828121185,
0.08152254670858383,
0.768551766872406,
-0.7074623107910156,
-0.23600788414478302,
-0.024210000410676003,
0.27561256289482117,
0.05597461760044098,
-0.6351951360702515,
0.01789410226047039,
-0.3615047335624695,
-0.49586814641952515,
-0.3633665442466736,
0.638619601726532,
-0.8057029247283936,
-0.5233845114707947,
0.2723512053489685,
0.4701714813709259,
-0.30948570370674133,
-0.05346717685461044,
-0.5545058846473694,
0.031693559139966965,
-0.06446605920791626,
-0.34236228466033936,
0.21668167412281036,
0.5300351977348328,
0.17211270332336426,
0.7449358105659485,
0.6133750677108765,
-0.41620945930480957,
0.1849750280380249,
-0.5059341788291931,
0.872672438621521,
-1.1454908847808838,
-0.03969423100352287,
-0.9698502421379089,
0.6372755169868469,
0.018355190753936768,
-0.44000571966171265,
0.8130415678024292,
0.8809126615524292,
0.7313043475151062,
-0.1680992990732193,
0.7507405281066895,
0.030683383345603943,
0.20412884652614594,
-0.7978006601333618,
0.7694137096405029,
-0.734199047088623,
-0.049093421548604965,
-0.23048369586467743,
-0.6079478859901428,
-0.4759160876274109,
0.4634268283843994,
0.24896638095378876,
0.33713415265083313,
0.82539302110672,
0.8591601252555847,
-0.24743956327438354,
0.22215630114078522,
-0.12253133952617645,
0.17210699617862701,
0.5365126132965088,
0.550017237663269,
0.8306235074996948,
-0.3777867555618286,
0.304448664188385,
-0.2821372449398041,
0.018512388691306114,
-0.3566182553768158,
-0.864012598991394,
-1.0196131467819214,
-0.8471994400024414,
-0.12517140805721283,
-0.200261190533638,
-0.1399608850479126,
1.0575803518295288,
0.7530621886253357,
-0.7544882297515869,
-0.28535178303718567,
-0.5396447777748108,
0.030324457213282585,
0.10696810483932495,
-0.13299894332885742,
0.12387026846408844,
-0.20735928416252136,
-0.8336592316627502,
0.7448219656944275,
0.626248836517334,
0.5808245539665222,
-0.33977386355400085,
0.13670863211154938,
-0.7236542701721191,
-0.04130606725811958,
0.7308996319770813,
0.4274611175060272,
-0.6081817150115967,
0.3394697606563568,
0.33119359612464905,
-0.3529515564441681,
0.20397955179214478,
1.3326503038406372,
-0.9057515859603882,
0.5650831460952759,
0.6141207218170166,
0.8543198108673096,
0.2945583164691925,
-0.23255480825901031,
0.997500479221344,
-0.515358030796051,
0.16588492691516876,
0.5759189128875732,
0.16327667236328125,
0.3213307857513428,
-0.28607192635536194,
0.3395456373691559,
0.28726792335510254,
-0.5942292809486389,
-0.7418051362037659,
0.24033375084400177,
-1.3737411499023438,
-0.7598087191581726,
0.6484168171882629,
0.4846891462802887,
-0.5267453789710999,
0.12453856319189072,
-0.44907432794570923,
0.15221495926380157,
-0.28613707423210144,
0.40732964873313904,
0.8866686224937439,
-0.3125750422477722,
-0.195424422621727,
-0.5940908789634705,
0.7619162201881409,
0.5073263645172119,
-1.0246037244796753,
-0.02079409547150135,
0.6363865733146667,
-0.2077339142560959,
0.35946032404899597,
0.4533402621746063,
0.10601343214511871,
0.2656359076499939,
-0.06677329540252686,
-0.14714407920837402,
-0.04513746127486229,
-0.95436030626297,
-0.44166383147239685,
0.24395354092121124,
-0.4260559678077698,
0.22196076810359955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04158v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04158v1
|
DA-Net: A Disentangled and Adaptive Network for Multi-Source Cross-Lingual Transfer Learning
| 2024-03-07T02:30:46 | 2024-03-07T02:30:46 |
Ling Ge, Chunming Hu, Guanghui Ma, Jihong Liu, Hong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multi-Source cross-lingual transfer learning deals with the transfer of task
knowledge from multiple labelled source languages to an unlabeled target
language under the language shift. Existing methods typically focus on
weighting the predictions produced by language-specific classifiers of
different sources that follow a shared encoder. However, all source languages
share the same encoder, which is updated by all these languages. The extracted
representations inevitably contain different source languages' information,
which may disturb the learning of the language-specific classifiers.
Additionally, due to the language gap, language-specific classifiers trained
with source labels are unable to make accurate predictions for the target
language. Both facts impair the model's performance. To address these
challenges, we propose a Disentangled and Adaptive Network (DA-Net). Firstly,
we devise a feedback-guided collaborative disentanglement method that seeks to
purify input representations of classifiers, thereby mitigating mutual
interference from multiple sources. Secondly, we propose a class-aware parallel
adaptation method that aligns class-level distributions for each source-target
language pair, thereby alleviating the language pairs' language gap.
Experimental results on three different tasks involving 38 languages validate
the effectiveness of our approach.
|
[
-0.4341842532157898,
-0.42230018973350525,
0.05786602199077606,
0.40412524342536926,
-0.08718384802341461,
0.4127444326877594,
-0.1869858056306839,
-0.2704212963581085,
0.2091863751411438,
0.06342951953411102,
-0.22775645554065704,
0.17394040524959564,
-1.056968092918396,
0.3567838966846466,
-0.14273233711719513,
0.6399606466293335,
-0.27422404289245605,
0.16646116971969604,
-0.08897317200899124,
-0.27129510045051575,
-0.5703983306884766,
-0.2417997419834137,
-0.8889107704162598,
-0.3670482039451599,
0.7071047425270081,
0.5195907354354858,
0.24018371105194092,
0.3091316223144531,
0.42524397373199463,
0.4332623779773712,
0.14721174538135529,
0.34181222319602966,
-0.4718587398529053,
-0.05907836928963661,
-0.5524584054946899,
-0.4085325300693512,
-0.3993261456489563,
-0.4141397178173065,
0.7051584124565125,
0.8812215924263,
-0.2320280224084854,
0.09829707443714142,
0.3645826578140259,
1.0672422647476196,
-0.8884660601615906,
0.19845861196517944,
-0.5528536438941956,
0.018042128533124924,
-0.18095755577087402,
0.004439790267497301,
-0.4528571367263794,
0.030967924743890762,
0.13109423220157623,
-0.8374630808830261,
-0.2063664346933365,
-0.18147574365139008,
0.4906480610370636,
0.33042946457862854,
-0.5579650402069092,
-0.15442289412021637,
-0.6208840608596802,
0.5552462935447693,
-0.38326627016067505,
0.3613838255405426,
0.425051748752594,
0.5810813307762146,
-0.048620402812957764,
-0.500689685344696,
-0.605355978012085,
0.20644012093544006,
0.0750599354505539,
0.4178881347179413,
-0.28249961137771606,
-0.3273138701915741,
-0.1754029244184494,
0.11966952681541443,
-0.4740734398365021,
0.27597710490226746,
-0.4985845685005188,
0.0036353967152535915,
0.6195955276489258,
-0.20859603583812714,
0.4696265161037445,
0.2849080264568329,
-0.6076456308364868,
-0.16177116334438324,
-0.16605281829833984,
-0.17107880115509033,
0.19206996262073517,
0.3775848150253296,
-0.24854901432991028,
-0.122364841401577,
-0.15948277711868286,
1.0169343948364258,
0.49074652791023254,
0.01964501664042473,
0.4024741053581238,
-0.16326317191123962,
-0.08132509142160416,
0.5747687220573425,
0.8051314949989319,
0.22085919976234436,
0.13334916532039642,
-0.27086514234542847,
0.1633429229259491,
-0.11079365015029907,
0.07327701151371002,
-0.5451684594154358,
-0.22815605998039246,
-0.2749650180339813,
-0.24491089582443237,
-0.0734441801905632,
-0.1007552519440651,
-0.7740466594696045,
-0.4329521954059601,
-0.38795071840286255,
0.5255005359649658,
-0.1536238044500351,
-0.8140022158622742,
0.4094945788383484,
-0.02767009101808071,
-0.27098795771598816,
0.3101184070110321,
-0.9802534580230713,
0.47377514839172363,
0.09395451843738556,
0.9961133003234863,
-0.4000036418437958,
-0.8657262325286865,
-0.4719199240207672,
0.3453759253025055,
-0.232934832572937,
0.48927223682403564,
-0.14477872848510742,
0.10071766376495361,
-0.2940830588340759,
0.28947073221206665,
-0.3548053503036499,
-0.24176061153411865,
-0.14863230288028717,
-0.8180391192436218,
0.06606622040271759,
-0.32302525639533997,
-0.4106737971305847,
-0.531609833240509,
0.20150400698184967,
-0.9296621680259705,
0.3842916488647461,
0.09107420593500137,
-0.7686920762062073,
0.19329045712947845,
-0.6381521821022034,
-0.3756314516067505,
-0.08696439117193222,
0.17194968461990356,
-0.1535528302192688,
-0.12140869349241257,
0.19097022712230682,
0.38960668444633484,
-0.29439422488212585,
0.20763780176639557,
-0.3592399060726166,
-0.38953879475593567,
0.16345344483852386,
-0.5581290125846863,
1.2292664051055908,
0.2759314775466919,
-0.47676587104797363,
-0.2815800607204437,
-0.7968757152557373,
-0.3338392376899719,
0.08192823082208633,
-0.3335762023925781,
-0.5518365502357483,
-0.3132636547088623,
0.05690635368227959,
0.47378748655319214,
0.12518398463726044,
-0.578762412071228,
0.13741353154182434,
-0.23167641460895538,
0.37450751662254333,
0.8655877709388733,
-0.2936720550060272,
0.6907736659049988,
-0.43695974349975586,
0.3935166597366333,
0.5404636859893799,
-0.14392966032028198,
0.2967241704463959,
-0.12326464056968689,
-0.694925844669342,
-0.024494726210832596,
0.5841622948646545,
0.4771612584590912,
-1.3920320272445679,
0.1987568885087967,
-0.35495302081108093,
-0.3387196362018585,
-0.5220069885253906,
0.3517208993434906,
0.268393874168396,
0.5617032051086426,
0.4025019705295563,
-0.5601896643638611,
-0.47754180431365967,
-0.5333322882652283,
-0.03917564079165459,
-0.03207910433411598,
0.2722683846950531,
-0.15576167404651642,
0.1980578899383545,
-0.06219044700264931,
0.51064133644104,
-0.22230719029903412,
-0.4955194592475891,
-0.05453457310795784,
0.14044860005378723,
-0.09704998880624771,
0.4664433002471924,
0.7233014106750488,
-1.022922158241272,
-1.1966643333435059,
0.2882230281829834,
-0.7585583329200745,
0.004117175005376339,
-0.28356674313545227,
-0.2408071607351303,
0.19783519208431244,
0.47438088059425354,
0.21280227601528168,
-0.004888050723820925,
1.0794142484664917,
-0.2501252591609955,
0.18418771028518677,
-0.41349542140960693,
0.1869414895772934,
-1.4675264358520508,
-0.096992127597332,
-0.08775153011083603,
-0.23052026331424713,
-0.5174354314804077,
-0.42511528730392456,
-0.05568164959549904,
0.12952156364917755,
-0.5385485887527466,
0.6418206095695496,
-0.8076080083847046,
0.04188879206776619,
-0.6557902097702026,
0.21857409179210663,
0.2526979446411133,
0.6042577624320984,
0.0012984026689082384,
0.5282863974571228,
1.236226201057434,
-0.710516631603241,
0.6592457294464111,
0.22805467247962952,
-0.20850345492362976,
0.7718856334686279,
-0.23927263915538788,
0.16033732891082764,
-0.16093061864376068,
0.2053031176328659,
-0.6542431116104126,
0.15214291214942932,
0.4426961839199066,
-0.16565446555614471,
0.4881136119365692,
-0.24202360212802887,
-0.0023780863266438246,
0.07124415785074234,
0.26675090193748474,
0.6557711362838745,
0.08432963490486145,
-0.8647511005401611,
0.5430756211280823,
0.4742372930049896,
0.038047000765800476,
-0.8666327595710754,
-1.003359317779541,
0.29308265447616577,
-0.11112973093986511,
-0.49857139587402344,
0.36083412170410156,
-0.0443577878177166,
0.052385956048965454,
0.32985493540763855,
-0.25987544655799866,
-0.5692937970161438,
0.2925129532814026,
-0.006106062792241573,
0.02053295075893402,
-0.09946948289871216,
0.0703374445438385,
0.2670780420303345,
-0.1411527395248413,
-0.05202220752835274,
-0.3618859052658081,
0.22378380596637726,
-0.15856565535068512,
-0.48491543531417847,
-0.15553978085517883,
0.4150676727294922,
0.5387741327285767,
-0.3787836730480194,
0.8662566542625427,
0.8022439479827881,
-0.3186088800430298,
-0.4480331838130951,
-0.1102554127573967,
0.0364244170486927,
-0.4978794753551483,
0.5719920992851257,
-0.5480948686599731,
-0.8778300881385803,
0.4340249300003052,
-0.3213123679161072,
-0.21231037378311157,
0.08462753891944885,
0.5444595813751221,
0.22168536484241486,
0.5964213609695435,
0.7211996912956238,
-0.16228388249874115,
0.5187435150146484,
-0.17543281614780426,
0.0033508564811199903,
-0.7476528286933899,
-0.027594707906246185,
-0.06264005601406097,
-0.5994277000427246,
-0.4864981770515442,
-0.393588662147522,
0.09217824786901474,
0.3952576220035553,
-0.09539835155010223,
0.6663870215415955,
-0.4128064811229706,
0.4629915654659271,
0.5724738240242004,
0.27893826365470886,
0.3207061290740967,
0.20290842652320862,
0.005417865701019764,
0.27013054490089417,
-0.8851214051246643,
0.13477599620819092,
0.9266035556793213,
0.02687264233827591,
0.6224451065063477,
0.669545590877533,
0.6519091129302979,
0.28059643507003784,
0.011944146826863289,
-0.4550374150276184,
0.22264975309371948,
-0.5080500245094299,
-0.39674463868141174,
-0.42525947093963623,
-0.7618322968482971,
-1.1177645921707153,
0.4884108901023865,
0.016987573355436325,
-0.5587118864059448,
0.6102762818336487,
-0.18921434879302979,
-0.015446198172867298,
0.5296151638031006,
-0.7016897201538086,
0.7242102026939392,
-0.37287822365760803,
-0.5854063630104065,
-0.27044299244880676,
-0.5433264970779419,
0.28127312660217285,
-0.5180419683456421,
0.2934636175632477,
-0.06387170404195786,
0.15685904026031494,
0.6555074453353882,
-0.031361401081085205,
0.8702106475830078,
-0.23674628138542175,
0.034458886831998825,
0.26610803604125977,
0.3344229757785797,
0.2370949685573578,
-0.0725366473197937,
-0.06424194574356079,
0.5087817311286926,
-0.05283347889780998,
-0.4534566104412079,
-0.6392481327056885,
0.7498317956924438,
-0.8071519732475281,
-0.438522607088089,
-0.5983657240867615,
-0.6320919394493103,
-0.30048155784606934,
0.4246845543384552,
-0.10643269866704941,
0.15292775630950928,
0.006540128495544195,
-0.0634525939822197,
0.3014620244503021,
-0.1275276243686676,
0.801184356212616,
0.8776226043701172,
-0.007698280271142721,
-0.3148348331451416,
1.1988794803619385,
0.1269690990447998,
0.44247597455978394,
0.578596293926239,
0.3148913085460663,
-0.206454798579216,
-0.43875229358673096,
-0.727800190448761,
0.027906494215130806,
-0.6890908479690552,
-0.09052342176437378,
-0.35319745540618896,
-0.17268216609954834,
-0.3534366190433502,
-0.056532759219408035,
-0.4010183811187744,
-0.27385807037353516,
-0.27062830328941345,
0.10588520020246506,
0.4615132212638855,
0.5003167986869812,
-0.5681226849555969,
0.17311832308769226,
-0.970160961151123,
0.29583099484443665,
0.5137019753456116,
0.7144337892532349,
0.2262902855873108,
-0.619993269443512,
-0.4774227440357208,
0.27274319529533386,
-0.056879859417676926,
-0.8687760233879089,
0.19710025191307068,
0.49010422825813293,
0.5912768840789795,
0.007173454388976097,
0.3650113344192505,
0.5161414742469788,
-0.5101460218429565,
0.3025234341621399,
0.7432742714881897,
-0.967742383480072,
0.009871532209217548,
0.05518205091357231,
0.3112697899341583,
0.46501708030700684,
0.6226197481155396,
-0.6462584733963013,
-0.003202109131962061,
-0.14409136772155762,
-0.42930763959884644,
1.1246663331985474,
-0.10228508710861206,
-0.11883562803268433,
0.13547593355178833,
-0.05613112822175026,
0.10511240363121033,
-0.17387112975120544,
-0.7169491052627563,
-0.27101773023605347,
-0.5176306962966919,
-0.18848556280136108,
-0.05365009233355522,
0.1357603222131729,
-0.029318666085600853,
-0.15011189877986908,
0.5443268418312073,
-0.33497774600982666,
-0.2052200436592102,
0.06932041049003601,
-0.41591426730155945,
-0.15665434300899506,
0.04908240586519241,
0.45688024163246155,
0.9523558020591736,
0.09477075934410095,
0.2272796779870987,
0.26701128482818604,
-0.5865122079849243,
0.6883904337882996,
0.1822153478860855,
0.18250799179077148,
0.08268499374389648,
0.021477680653333664,
1.007446050643921,
-0.017597056925296783,
-0.2734183967113495,
0.6289917826652527,
-0.2551015019416809,
-0.39332839846611023,
-0.005359790753573179,
-0.21876919269561768,
0.41185685992240906,
0.26393792033195496,
0.07908910512924194,
0.42019563913345337,
0.16121885180473328,
-0.1691238284111023,
0.4848180413246155,
-0.11933954060077667,
-0.40798377990722656,
-0.36838361620903015,
0.5118204951286316,
0.5001370906829834,
-0.12534664571285248,
0.34665077924728394,
-0.23841717839241028,
-0.3703795373439789,
0.6390314102172852,
0.5938111543655396,
0.939338743686676,
-0.5961856842041016,
0.49996575713157654,
0.4847888946533203,
0.06313113868236542,
-0.2535613179206848,
-0.13786323368549347,
0.014629608020186424,
-0.9022954702377319,
-0.742927610874176,
-0.6154041886329651,
-0.13945215940475464,
-0.15805275738239288,
-0.7803599238395691,
0.17097066342830658,
-0.09762762486934662,
0.1825471669435501,
-0.13887222111225128,
-0.2727639377117157,
-0.5069901347160339,
-0.013651900924742222,
0.17197570204734802,
0.5858073234558105,
-1.012579083442688,
1.0687456130981445,
0.8404926657676697,
-0.3340066075325012,
-0.8008454442024231,
-0.22199232876300812,
-0.012910325080156326,
-0.632286548614502,
0.9416401982307434,
-0.21888142824172974,
-0.24393661320209503,
0.06785743683576584,
0.3992563486099243,
-1.23760986328125,
0.980696976184845,
0.7541882395744324,
-0.9527119398117065,
0.14604976773262024,
0.28661566972732544,
0.3152778446674347,
0.0019512519938871264,
0.10691219568252563,
-0.031133240088820457,
0.3358956575393677,
0.15512646734714508,
-1.2471305131912231,
0.12907610833644867,
-0.15586502850055695,
0.03708653524518013,
0.07586026191711426,
-0.8284952044487,
0.9308183193206787,
0.22619640827178955,
-0.13184162974357605,
-0.6476550102233887,
0.43986308574676514,
0.048860467970371246,
0.19663944840431213,
0.7595364451408386,
0.3438379168510437,
0.5298129916191101,
0.2387632429599762,
0.39987289905548096,
-0.32699713110923767,
0.18016919493675232,
1.3447529077529907,
-0.3359679579734802,
0.518033504486084,
0.5300313830375671,
-0.12727901339530945,
0.43844589591026306,
0.43048515915870667,
0.17334140837192535,
0.7847821116447449,
0.4216788411140442,
-0.2803143262863159,
-0.046849388629198074,
0.038695864379405975,
-0.4127308130264282,
0.7469953894615173,
0.13840436935424805,
0.0051607792265713215,
-0.6628934741020203,
0.48832011222839355,
-0.28515416383743286,
0.22947637736797333,
-0.3970520794391632,
0.8294718265533447,
0.23947535455226898,
-0.5648235082626343,
0.8433447480201721,
-0.08699516952037811,
0.6814312934875488,
-0.42029309272766113,
-0.2012099176645279,
-0.31824567914009094,
0.3963039815425873,
-0.16913388669490814,
-0.4757671356201172,
0.41638514399528503,
-0.31551170349121094,
-0.28149962425231934,
-0.26036739349365234,
0.6592331528663635,
-0.7849293947219849,
-0.5236227512359619,
0.7296479940414429,
0.574256181716919,
-0.022620560601353645,
0.14584708213806152,
-0.9642059803009033,
0.0481097474694252,
-0.09769417345523834,
0.007661685813218355,
0.7681513428688049,
0.7921233773231506,
-0.022301748394966125,
0.459087610244751,
0.46838828921318054,
0.2920818030834198,
0.2826351523399353,
0.08437513560056686,
0.6962785124778748,
-0.02794799581170082,
-0.5652203559875488,
-0.6251978278160095,
0.3780306577682495,
0.0998912826180458,
-0.08058569580316544,
0.7574532628059387,
0.13388901948928833,
1.3624194860458374,
-0.0378892607986927,
0.7699580788612366,
-0.22468514740467072,
0.20258590579032898,
-0.34643739461898804,
1.0147660970687866,
-0.7798766493797302,
0.13478586077690125,
-0.278167724609375,
-0.8499467372894287,
-0.07624705135822296,
0.4451237618923187,
0.1368715614080429,
-0.060230500996112823,
0.5496993064880371,
0.5646523833274841,
-0.32432544231414795,
-0.2712801694869995,
0.4062635600566864,
-0.006781434174627066,
0.135864719748497,
0.9181216955184937,
0.5305714011192322,
-0.5410342812538147,
0.6932141780853271,
-0.578305184841156,
-0.4901052713394165,
0.02707741968333721,
-0.9649960994720459,
-0.7580772042274475,
-0.9050519466400146,
-0.6186925172805786,
-0.20930510759353638,
0.23113401234149933,
0.3442600965499878,
0.7673181891441345,
-0.7292931079864502,
-0.5093104839324951,
-0.3591524064540863,
0.17571479082107544,
-0.8755000233650208,
-0.15328721702098846,
0.6073598265647888,
-0.26151132583618164,
-0.9042712450027466,
0.4683516323566437,
0.12548096477985382,
-0.11296926438808441,
-0.19965745508670807,
-0.3223119080066681,
-0.6479929685592651,
-0.4431963860988617,
0.3501604199409485,
0.3188724219799042,
-0.33230388164520264,
-0.2236366719007492,
-0.2166656255722046,
-0.03950411453843117,
-0.15211395919322968,
0.34362781047821045,
-0.4274708330631256,
0.9305065274238586,
0.5079169869422913,
1.1635814905166626,
0.45118027925491333,
-0.4151150584220886,
0.6876004338264465,
-0.8086819648742676,
0.33920711278915405,
0.002771668368950486,
0.36248067021369934,
0.24895718693733215,
-0.18914565443992615,
0.21714335680007935,
0.2938727140426636,
-0.3959799110889435,
-0.6352810263633728,
0.12152955681085587,
-1.0188747644424438,
-0.7256473898887634,
0.8971372246742249,
-0.44346627593040466,
-0.397420197725296,
-0.3425881266593933,
0.07474181801080704,
0.5390923619270325,
-0.06794287264347076,
0.9301328659057617,
0.6402286291122437,
0.20365792512893677,
-0.4040013551712036,
-0.17904134094715118,
0.257049560546875,
0.4347035884857178,
-0.5658797025680542,
0.047010865062475204,
0.17942167818546295,
0.3228199779987335,
0.333861380815506,
0.4648869037628174,
0.16122375428676605,
0.3634151816368103,
0.17268793284893036,
0.08144813776016235,
-0.5678805112838745,
-0.4265228509902954,
-0.4704568386077881,
-0.19495908915996552,
-0.03410079702734947,
-0.732160747051239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04132v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04132v1
|
Chatbot Arena: An Open Platform for Evaluating LLMs by Human Preference
| 2024-03-07T01:22:38 | 2024-03-07T01:22:38 |
Wei-Lin Chiang, Lianmin Zheng, Ying Sheng, Anastasios Nikolas Angelopoulos, Tianle Li, Dacheng Li, Hao Zhang, Banghua Zhu, Michael Jordan, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Ion Stoica
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have unlocked new capabilities and applications;
however, evaluating the alignment with human preferences still poses
significant challenges. To address this issue, we introduce Chatbot Arena, an
open platform for evaluating LLMs based on human preferences. Our methodology
employs a pairwise comparison approach and leverages input from a diverse user
base through crowdsourcing. The platform has been operational for several
months, amassing over 240K votes. This paper describes the platform, analyzes
the data we have collected so far, and explains the tried-and-true statistical
methods we are using for efficient and accurate evaluation and ranking of
models. We confirm that the crowdsourced questions are sufficiently diverse and
discriminating and that the crowdsourced human votes are in good agreement with
those of expert raters. These analyses collectively establish a robust
foundation for the credibility of Chatbot Arena. Because of its unique value
and openness, Chatbot Arena has emerged as one of the most referenced LLM
leaderboards, widely cited by leading LLM developers and companies. Our demo is
publicly available at \url{https://chat.lmsys.org}.
|
[
-0.32815462350845337,
-0.5694746375083923,
0.3725266754627228,
0.4870026409626007,
-0.08874708414077759,
0.41291603446006775,
-0.6122021675109863,
-0.25002729892730713,
0.21775126457214355,
0.5244641304016113,
-0.23640884459018707,
-0.609817385673523,
-0.5127542614936829,
0.08319555222988129,
-0.3053364157676697,
0.704524040222168,
0.039063308387994766,
0.18819643557071686,
-0.77581787109375,
-0.2873607277870178,
-0.3263155221939087,
-0.8004747629165649,
-0.5978268384933472,
-0.3878713548183441,
0.62250816822052,
0.4485890865325928,
0.916862428188324,
0.5122655034065247,
0.6439723372459412,
0.46514812111854553,
-0.037257760763168335,
0.09168076515197754,
-0.7124727964401245,
0.14595425128936768,
0.03584033250808716,
-0.6060760617256165,
-0.5513176918029785,
0.26122015714645386,
0.3195076286792755,
0.5539447069168091,
-0.40166106820106506,
0.297538161277771,
0.15346862375736237,
0.6561197638511658,
-0.33184733986854553,
0.12444786727428436,
-0.8045095205307007,
0.0064968266524374485,
-0.3079374134540558,
-0.34104037284851074,
-0.3872869312763214,
-0.44436681270599365,
-0.03590214252471924,
-0.3813326060771942,
-0.06335058063268661,
0.309078574180603,
0.5078448057174683,
0.25031086802482605,
-0.21132229268550873,
-0.17373396456241608,
-0.6439800262451172,
0.7473929524421692,
-0.4426361322402954,
0.5938981175422668,
0.3469580113887787,
0.6194804310798645,
-0.3354342579841614,
-0.5393567681312561,
-0.5654323697090149,
-0.5662408471107483,
0.13042853772640228,
0.17358247935771942,
-0.5239665508270264,
-0.07120560109615326,
-0.09418128430843353,
0.046748481690883636,
-0.5986897945404053,
0.5847612023353577,
-0.23773330450057983,
-0.27733299136161804,
0.6514553427696228,
0.1533716470003128,
0.3969099521636963,
-0.09966021776199341,
-0.6062704920768738,
-0.0033458732068538666,
-0.44491615891456604,
0.14590173959732056,
0.6741045713424683,
0.33536508679389954,
-0.0990658700466156,
0.7173649668693542,
-0.18416771292686462,
0.582783579826355,
0.021957017481327057,
-0.20120947062969208,
0.22210459411144257,
0.19132526218891144,
-0.08640963584184647,
-0.053314127027988434,
1.1084107160568237,
0.7982276082038879,
0.03868654742836952,
-0.5052216053009033,
-0.17841623723506927,
0.3062363862991333,
0.22740699350833893,
-0.5103639364242554,
0.001150639378465712,
0.5303671956062317,
-0.498311847448349,
-0.4264002740383148,
-0.20416177809238434,
-0.6539486050605774,
-0.8447503447532654,
-0.21130098402500153,
0.22130431234836578,
0.09144721180200577,
-0.26559126377105713,
-0.13456620275974274,
-0.05185357481241226,
0.09603864699602127,
0.529118537902832,
-0.89103764295578,
0.3061942458152771,
1.1109371185302734,
0.904463529586792,
-0.46856117248535156,
-0.15334931015968323,
-0.5757893323898315,
-0.4203135371208191,
-0.24598941206932068,
1.0843318700790405,
-0.6617507338523865,
-0.44054022431373596,
-0.0332128070294857,
-0.3976285457611084,
0.2576080858707428,
-0.807921826839447,
0.5818116068840027,
-0.6321800947189331,
0.3191390633583069,
0.11897892504930496,
-0.8361660838127136,
0.36874881386756897,
0.442598432302475,
-0.6201801896095276,
0.8747056722640991,
-0.13958291709423065,
-0.42550238966941833,
0.32309046387672424,
-0.8417027592658997,
0.11717710644006729,
0.5156672596931458,
-0.220917209982872,
-0.12015974521636963,
-0.16966915130615234,
0.1695130616426468,
0.29900339245796204,
-0.21755799651145935,
0.36402803659439087,
-0.6567946672439575,
-0.17220664024353027,
0.8197243809700012,
-0.4681015610694885,
0.5890440344810486,
0.3601599633693695,
-0.10912785679101944,
0.6280718445777893,
-0.5349032282829285,
-0.021751083433628082,
-0.09940650314092636,
-0.4177497625350952,
-0.0648953840136528,
0.1966404914855957,
0.1821831613779068,
0.21043483912944794,
0.41078194975852966,
-0.570910632610321,
0.15202516317367554,
-0.28949084877967834,
0.545033872127533,
1.0099735260009766,
-0.30281198024749756,
0.6050547957420349,
-0.282861590385437,
0.7280329465866089,
-0.30442625284194946,
0.20489171147346497,
0.31733590364456177,
-0.6212770938873291,
-0.5276989340782166,
-0.3013901710510254,
0.39941465854644775,
0.44569408893585205,
-0.22413672506809235,
0.6830466985702515,
-0.2505861520767212,
-0.7794270515441895,
-1.034761667251587,
0.22949717938899994,
0.13364632427692413,
0.3830488920211792,
-0.09550347924232483,
-0.3609592914581299,
-0.48345810174942017,
-0.9568532705307007,
-0.17059952020645142,
-0.43580788373947144,
-0.3715035021305084,
0.59754478931427,
0.1720864474773407,
-0.23493190109729767,
1.0984972715377808,
-0.13775309920310974,
-0.24006745219230652,
-0.159088596701622,
-0.2065848559141159,
0.2639896273612976,
0.14821085333824158,
0.4200437664985657,
-0.7499481439590454,
-0.483010858297348,
0.08418114483356476,
-0.7369953989982605,
-0.2042332887649536,
0.3712317943572998,
-0.4078958332538605,
0.2730475962162018,
0.27192243933677673,
-0.5134264230728149,
0.18875667452812195,
0.9681864976882935,
-0.30505263805389404,
0.1295405775308609,
-0.08130566775798798,
0.3043322265148163,
-1.0575668811798096,
0.1951000988483429,
-0.15302146971225739,
-0.40466004610061646,
-0.38386210799217224,
0.056294869631528854,
-0.13292135298252106,
-0.2319258451461792,
-0.580635130405426,
0.894147515296936,
-0.02388833649456501,
-0.2802964150905609,
-0.45711013674736023,
0.8442906141281128,
-0.2195528894662857,
0.33949729800224304,
0.00038097958895377815,
0.6410694122314453,
0.31671538949012756,
-0.23039545118808746,
0.8575098514556885,
0.5211232304573059,
-0.4873020648956299,
0.502051055431366,
-0.6103076338768005,
0.5844005346298218,
0.12481245398521423,
0.3028953969478607,
-1.2242653369903564,
-0.24038906395435333,
0.4290049374103546,
-0.7390808463096619,
-0.2975534200668335,
-0.060313716530799866,
-0.5547530651092529,
-0.33027327060699463,
-0.20272471010684967,
-0.084500752389431,
0.5176348686218262,
-0.626259982585907,
0.23860540986061096,
0.9946824312210083,
-0.113855741918087,
-0.544809103012085,
-0.14689408242702484,
0.2807665467262268,
-0.30975618958473206,
-0.7412559390068054,
-0.005914501845836639,
-0.2336660474538803,
-0.6664994359016418,
-0.03421873226761818,
0.145072340965271,
0.03537430241703987,
0.2772722840309143,
0.6073402762413025,
0.46937042474746704,
-0.024477818980813026,
0.1756504625082016,
-0.48970210552215576,
-0.3621618151664734,
-0.12347456812858582,
-0.12415415793657303,
0.7751778364181519,
-0.3274308145046234,
-0.3320503532886505,
-0.36257535219192505,
-0.008287256583571434,
0.5035691857337952,
-0.24514974653720856,
0.4927501082420349,
0.3536361753940582,
-0.2702774107456207,
0.16506725549697876,
-0.6952299475669861,
0.024442393332719803,
-0.45471152663230896,
0.4125397503376007,
0.01244535855948925,
-1.2514636516571045,
0.5221163034439087,
0.07911494374275208,
0.32494980096817017,
0.27486106753349304,
1.0371893644332886,
-0.2041253298521042,
0.9837121367454529,
0.30430200695991516,
-0.4631347060203552,
0.21380290389060974,
0.3654283285140991,
-0.010750183835625648,
-0.45652297139167786,
-0.29079851508140564,
-0.729206919670105,
-0.7659392952919006,
-0.641365647315979,
-0.49168774485588074,
0.42455539107322693,
-0.052972812205553055,
0.06473425030708313,
0.046150121837854385,
-0.3323328495025635,
0.5993245840072632,
0.5443633198738098,
0.10542429983615875,
0.477455735206604,
-0.15781693160533905,
0.1944742351770401,
-0.09866417944431305,
-0.5301871299743652,
-0.9519977569580078,
1.231843113899231,
0.48197439312934875,
0.4745611250400543,
0.29212838411331177,
0.7417393326759338,
0.4516010284423828,
0.8091883659362793,
-0.887991189956665,
0.6475120782852173,
0.16282425820827484,
-0.833197832107544,
-0.6811561584472656,
-0.4217725396156311,
-1.169266700744629,
0.4086606502532959,
-0.5927912592887878,
-0.86875981092453,
-0.38832223415374756,
0.04558699205517769,
-0.24145764112472534,
0.41205209493637085,
-0.5736326575279236,
0.8917433619499207,
-0.45950672030448914,
-0.3573015630245209,
-0.23025082051753998,
-0.49075570702552795,
0.28715190291404724,
-0.1292785406112671,
0.31124207377433777,
-0.33931076526641846,
-0.1464444100856781,
0.819658100605011,
-0.4814949333667755,
0.7619750499725342,
-0.055009592324495316,
-0.10712549835443497,
0.27633869647979736,
-0.040625881403684616,
0.2479308396577835,
0.08861798793077469,
-0.312482088804245,
0.3085467219352722,
-0.35129716992378235,
-0.3311922550201416,
-0.7414276003837585,
0.9807894825935364,
-1.2013216018676758,
-0.5784784555435181,
-0.24246002733707428,
-0.378586083650589,
-0.38140764832496643,
0.048751696944236755,
-0.10642827302217484,
0.11790509521961212,
-0.6088655591011047,
0.35545089840888977,
0.10190217196941376,
-0.33658483624458313,
0.258806049823761,
0.5052201747894287,
-0.8203338384628296,
-0.44216015934944153,
0.6236684322357178,
-0.3066202998161316,
0.019994378089904785,
0.41274526715278625,
0.27659711241722107,
-0.5073809027671814,
-0.41123589873313904,
-0.5086954832077026,
-0.0316825695335865,
-0.5049366354942322,
-0.19491198658943176,
-0.55804842710495,
0.06356102973222733,
-0.33767926692962646,
-0.07401610910892487,
-0.4282621443271637,
-0.23643742501735687,
-0.017660290002822876,
-0.2044011503458023,
0.2663697600364685,
0.5945029854774475,
0.12075027823448181,
0.22568295896053314,
-0.7508823871612549,
0.18801560997962952,
0.48231226205825806,
0.6447279453277588,
-0.31748244166374207,
-0.4129975438117981,
0.17182765901088715,
-0.01715022139251232,
-0.2936684191226959,
-0.7078202366828918,
0.33506906032562256,
-0.27831533551216125,
0.7341338992118835,
0.43771669268608093,
-0.07413630187511444,
0.4223009943962097,
-0.301657497882843,
0.6747758984565735,
0.31625306606292725,
-0.7407858371734619,
0.23784300684928894,
-0.24779538810253143,
0.02636861987411976,
0.6993729472160339,
0.3007599711418152,
-0.7830778360366821,
-0.5456138849258423,
-0.7026381492614746,
-0.49573296308517456,
0.6608055830001831,
0.3525608479976654,
0.28927209973335266,
0.12279938906431198,
0.08299977332353592,
0.28389689326286316,
0.36878493428230286,
-0.6229091882705688,
-0.24837848544120789,
0.10334334522485733,
0.05393291637301445,
-0.23075024783611298,
-0.07242555916309357,
-0.1267527937889099,
0.03532237559556961,
0.4733354449272156,
0.1056746244430542,
0.010885835625231266,
-0.3718080520629883,
0.02402886562049389,
-0.41200605034828186,
0.4848824739456177,
0.3447672426700592,
0.8720337748527527,
-0.3458997309207916,
-0.041291967034339905,
0.15582866966724396,
-0.08976420760154724,
-0.0660322904586792,
0.02975463680922985,
-0.020471813157200813,
-0.05739430710673332,
0.26076969504356384,
0.8736507892608643,
0.35173270106315613,
-0.9918363690376282,
0.6324822902679443,
-0.2136838734149933,
-0.296205073595047,
-0.14891956746578217,
0.030712220817804337,
0.4727456867694855,
0.46555376052856445,
0.18423566222190857,
0.14644072949886322,
-0.043710339814424515,
-0.48314711451530457,
0.07452087104320526,
0.508417010307312,
-0.6589787602424622,
-0.158455491065979,
0.7241083383560181,
0.7438190579414368,
-0.8519229292869568,
0.5833956003189087,
0.006344549357891083,
-0.3842751979827881,
0.37466469407081604,
0.21176841855049133,
0.8214821815490723,
-0.15913714468479156,
0.3568378984928131,
0.10028699785470963,
0.1554051637649536,
0.08104196190834045,
-0.062088482081890106,
-0.006054844241589308,
-0.8303827047348022,
-0.21141360700130463,
-0.668571412563324,
-0.9861413836479187,
0.08756579458713531,
-0.3616977334022522,
0.45295143127441406,
-0.3197210729122162,
-0.2742478549480438,
0.04854932427406311,
0.04134143143892288,
-0.5505945682525635,
-0.3052898347377777,
0.4180701971054077,
0.8019465804100037,
-0.5081750750541687,
0.5331053137779236,
0.7063063383102417,
-0.03555818647146225,
-0.45654296875,
-0.36619943380355835,
0.15946198999881744,
-1.0766537189483643,
0.3803761601448059,
0.11011933535337448,
-0.012492521665990353,
-0.19783709943294525,
-0.8509918451309204,
-0.47270750999450684,
0.9532496333122253,
0.41877642273902893,
-0.8554880023002625,
0.18708914518356323,
0.3182578384876251,
0.7562653422355652,
-0.42832013964653015,
0.47845548391342163,
0.3014550805091858,
0.506742537021637,
0.03660565987229347,
-1.1280080080032349,
-0.37960222363471985,
-0.2911064326763153,
-0.3069615662097931,
0.13258519768714905,
-0.7865718603134155,
0.2833520174026489,
-0.09073684364557266,
-0.07562075555324554,
0.198876291513443,
0.7177882194519043,
0.5230981111526489,
0.48319515585899353,
0.7672328948974609,
0.31066393852233887,
0.9796561002731323,
-0.006393486633896828,
0.9069609045982361,
-0.45299845933914185,
0.3543075621128082,
0.8029627203941345,
-0.548643171787262,
1.2331258058547974,
0.4098425507545471,
-0.5579325556755066,
0.30034589767456055,
0.5707780122756958,
-0.011989531107246876,
0.08987849205732346,
0.4566146731376648,
-0.14729727804660797,
-0.5581557750701904,
-0.14223691821098328,
-0.2245270162820816,
0.7790272235870361,
-0.11517208069562912,
-0.07495269924402237,
-0.1685907393693924,
-0.11557222902774811,
0.017906270921230316,
0.3799314498901367,
-0.19609342515468597,
0.7891465425491333,
-0.004900649655610323,
-0.7721607685089111,
0.08994728326797485,
0.08252190798521042,
0.6454444527626038,
-0.5473763942718506,
0.1344478726387024,
-0.31736642122268677,
0.10395713150501251,
-0.15402385592460632,
-0.9436835646629333,
-0.19648824632167816,
0.30369114875793457,
0.2149573713541031,
-0.324649453163147,
0.745603084564209,
-0.3959667682647705,
-0.32919156551361084,
0.2407030165195465,
0.741814911365509,
0.35722094774246216,
-0.22252611815929413,
-0.6227075457572937,
0.245503231883049,
-0.21299701929092407,
-0.07143581658601761,
0.47105464339256287,
0.24104955792427063,
-0.06296999007463455,
0.7920280694961548,
0.7935420870780945,
-0.12352858483791351,
-0.29990047216415405,
0.07928527891635895,
0.7594724893569946,
-0.5347214341163635,
-0.4949280023574829,
-0.9609639048576355,
0.27911266684532166,
-0.18383684754371643,
-0.5227024555206299,
0.8360704183578491,
0.9551573991775513,
0.5781449675559998,
0.1748044341802597,
0.8102118968963623,
0.24359513819217682,
0.6047569513320923,
-0.06996428221464157,
0.8674091696739197,
-0.29928189516067505,
0.270988404750824,
-0.26141971349716187,
-1.0380367040634155,
-0.35769209265708923,
0.24810127913951874,
-0.28495651483535767,
-0.20755137503147125,
0.11017757654190063,
0.8695805072784424,
0.1406259685754776,
0.16130010783672333,
0.49709033966064453,
0.05531661957502365,
0.26602861285209656,
0.36483004689216614,
1.356321930885315,
0.061325524002313614,
0.8539371490478516,
-0.04104657471179962,
-0.6927585601806641,
-0.5096717476844788,
-0.7762734293937683,
-0.9772908091545105,
-0.5288470387458801,
-0.26171326637268066,
-0.35331976413726807,
-0.056203775107860565,
1.3498610258102417,
0.5115914940834045,
-0.6190752983093262,
-0.6333916783332825,
0.5097970962524414,
0.23236864805221558,
0.1121477335691452,
-0.18010403215885162,
0.0894758552312851,
-0.18879452347755432,
-0.9005498290061951,
0.38376104831695557,
0.4339751601219177,
-0.33951765298843384,
-0.4964201748371124,
-0.34279876947402954,
0.16828109323978424,
-0.11638779938220978,
0.6384896039962769,
0.2574806809425354,
-0.8569167256355286,
-0.30696433782577515,
0.3876326382160187,
-0.4454329311847687,
0.22968532145023346,
0.6419288516044617,
-0.7218689322471619,
0.5659799575805664,
0.4403422474861145,
0.5171427726745605,
0.18093712627887726,
0.02163623459637165,
0.5495556592941284,
-0.37460824847221375,
0.017249617725610733,
0.17870089411735535,
0.22286492586135864,
0.36082467436790466,
0.0974801555275917,
0.5435539484024048,
-0.005784612149000168,
-0.7353659868240356,
-0.785948634147644,
-0.19144251942634583,
-1.208007574081421,
0.015104908496141434,
1.3428575992584229,
0.21282795071601868,
-0.275551438331604,
0.013184316456317902,
-0.4614724814891815,
0.0873686894774437,
-0.7071390748023987,
1.0420273542404175,
0.7597870230674744,
-0.158353790640831,
0.22984571754932404,
-0.38620394468307495,
0.22572311758995056,
0.049364492297172546,
-0.8479259014129639,
0.07808477431535721,
0.4928323030471802,
0.07644230872392654,
0.15671031177043915,
0.9385632276535034,
-0.12526260316371918,
0.13380342721939087,
-0.33184316754341125,
0.2814955413341522,
0.12367627769708633,
0.07984266430139542,
-0.32373055815696716,
0.3171471655368805,
0.3009602725505829,
-0.23513974249362946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04123v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04123v1
|
Exploring LLM-based Agents for Root Cause Analysis
| 2024-03-07T00:44:01 | 2024-03-07T00:44:01 |
Devjeet Roy, Xuchao Zhang, Rashi Bhave, Chetan Bansal, Pedro Las-Casas, Rodrigo Fonseca, Saravan Rajmohan
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The growing complexity of cloud based software systems has resulted in
incident management becoming an integral part of the software development
lifecycle. Root cause analysis (RCA), a critical part of the incident
management process, is a demanding task for on-call engineers, requiring deep
domain knowledge and extensive experience with a team's specific services.
Automation of RCA can result in significant savings of time, and ease the
burden of incident management on on-call engineers. Recently, researchers have
utilized Large Language Models (LLMs) to perform RCA, and have demonstrated
promising results. However, these approaches are not able to dynamically
collect additional diagnostic information such as incident related logs,
metrics or databases, severely restricting their ability to diagnose root
causes. In this work, we explore the use of LLM based agents for RCA to address
this limitation. We present a thorough empirical evaluation of a ReAct agent
equipped with retrieval tools, on an out-of-distribution dataset of production
incidents collected at Microsoft. Results show that ReAct performs
competitively with strong retrieval and reasoning baselines, but with highly
increased factual accuracy. We then extend this evaluation by incorporating
discussions associated with incident reports as additional inputs for the
models, which surprisingly does not yield significant performance improvements.
Lastly, we conduct a case study with a team at Microsoft to equip the ReAct
agent with tools that give it access to external diagnostic services that are
used by the team for manual RCA. Our results show how agents can overcome the
limitations of prior work, and practical considerations for implementing such a
system in practice.
|
[
-0.3532734811306,
-0.7562436461448669,
0.8750430345535278,
0.1600126475095749,
-0.15016193687915802,
0.428993284702301,
0.12912499904632568,
-0.7614989280700684,
0.16615237295627594,
0.4053935706615448,
-0.7450690269470215,
-0.27528098225593567,
-0.2642173171043396,
0.1859096884727478,
-0.45566004514694214,
0.6816869378089905,
-0.10916657000780106,
-0.1761646717786789,
-0.31426265835762024,
-0.08999323099851608,
-0.6373273730278015,
-0.7069606781005859,
-0.906688928604126,
-0.2913285791873932,
0.3820437788963318,
0.639153242111206,
0.7478980422019958,
0.22547738254070282,
0.8214067220687866,
0.31612733006477356,
0.07995067536830902,
0.16638211905956268,
-0.36167123913764954,
0.3864181935787201,
-0.028943197801709175,
-0.5185470581054688,
-0.5602841973304749,
-0.31370097398757935,
0.3036838471889496,
0.2062584012746811,
-0.22006070613861084,
-0.06691812723875046,
-0.3434804379940033,
0.40231332182884216,
-0.6258485317230225,
0.13117554783821106,
-0.6950724720954895,
0.1906706541776657,
0.23602144420146942,
-0.3936876058578491,
-0.4934958815574646,
-0.11819734424352646,
-0.07397664338350296,
-0.5695400238037109,
0.41764554381370544,
-0.11101674288511276,
0.7180659174919128,
0.4484002888202667,
-0.42283597588539124,
-0.3566269874572754,
-0.8851543664932251,
0.6034247875213623,
-0.6842976212501526,
0.10456173866987228,
0.24529370665550232,
0.47179558873176575,
-0.34025120735168457,
-0.6341081857681274,
-0.41225236654281616,
-0.3010016679763794,
0.04840853437781334,
0.24902762472629547,
-0.4381502866744995,
-0.08674157410860062,
0.16753992438316345,
0.0800521969795227,
-0.5661600828170776,
0.5901345610618591,
0.08155792951583862,
-0.3087186813354492,
0.8599783778190613,
0.7782418727874756,
0.4814472794532776,
0.037141624838113785,
-0.3877798616886139,
0.09310919791460037,
-0.8547452092170715,
0.06291395425796509,
-0.21039415895938873,
0.3795570433139801,
0.011245712637901306,
0.3792323172092438,
-0.18195423483848572,
0.4377017617225647,
-0.1967131495475769,
0.036526624113321304,
-0.0729684829711914,
-0.010469339787960052,
-0.27113083004951477,
0.09378533065319061,
0.6240738034248352,
0.2955673038959503,
-0.06083852797746658,
-0.44357722997665405,
-0.4141331911087036,
0.12897764146327972,
0.5280390977859497,
-0.702819287776947,
0.03236226364970207,
0.632337749004364,
-0.09236593544483185,
-0.408444344997406,
-0.2351459413766861,
-0.4101519286632538,
-1.0284640789031982,
-0.4026113450527191,
0.21660317480564117,
-0.25970980525016785,
-0.4696183502674103,
-0.3713817000389099,
-0.17361219227313995,
0.3875419497489929,
0.47251179814338684,
-0.04675621911883354,
0.22214163839817047,
0.7639268636703491,
0.9001937508583069,
-0.17474882304668427,
-0.06508178263902664,
-0.7943838834762573,
-0.07754801213741302,
-0.6431115865707397,
1.0502748489379883,
-0.21700866520404816,
-0.41648879647254944,
0.24412967264652252,
-0.08144883066415787,
0.32507285475730896,
-0.8771599531173706,
0.2443968951702118,
-0.7910503149032593,
-0.6385473608970642,
-0.20104198157787323,
-0.24950359761714935,
0.09889231622219086,
0.43860429525375366,
-0.5670306086540222,
0.9925001859664917,
0.029297692701220512,
-0.4431473910808563,
0.31357255578041077,
-0.48910456895828247,
-0.3777535557746887,
0.2761230170726776,
-0.36472874879837036,
-0.38993051648139954,
0.25927045941352844,
0.07678128033876419,
0.5306631922721863,
-0.5353321433067322,
0.29497700929641724,
-0.17020124197006226,
-0.06900884211063385,
0.29684507846832275,
0.015900151804089546,
0.5368585586547852,
0.19344966113567352,
-0.21237117052078247,
0.30981600284576416,
-0.9409867525100708,
-0.09323757886886597,
0.12599286437034607,
-0.06546099483966827,
-0.3813527524471283,
0.1778416633605957,
-0.15501277148723602,
0.3468177318572998,
-0.06319773942232132,
-0.5462606549263,
0.050275202840566635,
-0.10860473662614822,
-0.038940783590078354,
0.7953718304634094,
0.29224324226379395,
0.21403609216213226,
-0.29488012194633484,
0.8411649465560913,
0.2758987247943878,
0.2766081690788269,
-0.029108168557286263,
-0.36952903866767883,
-0.6870473027229309,
-0.14983701705932617,
-0.35172951221466064,
0.6383011341094971,
-1.0282729864120483,
-0.14239029586315155,
-0.09017211198806763,
-0.526645302772522,
-0.23092935979366302,
-0.03430066257715225,
0.08435118943452835,
0.7030643820762634,
0.3040964901447296,
-0.28274720907211304,
-0.5571379661560059,
-0.9099059700965881,
-0.06973809003829956,
-0.30663198232650757,
0.0004996429197490215,
0.46598100662231445,
0.31455180048942566,
-0.4841366112232208,
1.4767199754714966,
-0.6715438365936279,
-0.35285013914108276,
-0.39502352476119995,
0.11753414571285248,
0.07825758308172226,
-0.0814838781952858,
0.41150325536727905,
-0.6701434850692749,
-0.41617366671562195,
0.22628901898860931,
-1.0162477493286133,
-0.3522270917892456,
-0.14193089306354523,
0.21895425021648407,
0.4568280875682831,
0.6038216948509216,
-0.6487430334091187,
0.6617180109024048,
0.375033438205719,
-0.39884477853775024,
0.8535295724868774,
-0.2696363627910614,
-0.0928335040807724,
-0.8289509415626526,
0.05392514169216156,
0.08558381348848343,
-0.2564191520214081,
-1.0519815683364868,
-0.09905841201543808,
0.10720683634281158,
-0.44753819704055786,
-0.6755788922309875,
0.3393367528915405,
-0.5408759117126465,
-0.34103238582611084,
-0.5930120944976807,
0.3230910897254944,
-0.11785973608493805,
0.27229955792427063,
-0.011208930052816868,
0.7742611169815063,
0.5437321066856384,
-0.8991432785987854,
0.5403085947036743,
0.1157531589269638,
-0.23123963177204132,
0.3818192183971405,
-0.6141839027404785,
0.14671584963798523,
-0.22159840166568756,
-0.028716254979372025,
-0.9358109831809998,
-0.016090676188468933,
0.09777123481035233,
-0.37233781814575195,
0.11812222003936768,
-0.18379881978034973,
-0.7033983469009399,
-0.07599848508834839,
0.006905030459165573,
0.12524354457855225,
0.3153042793273926,
-0.3388873040676117,
0.9379803538322449,
0.5232275724411011,
-0.4479505717754364,
-0.462384968996048,
-0.5405086278915405,
0.3188612163066864,
-0.3155866861343384,
-0.8477923274040222,
0.10091724991798401,
0.18575261533260345,
-0.7222984433174133,
0.033818963915109634,
-0.17980360984802246,
-0.38045135140419006,
0.44481828808784485,
0.5173652172088623,
0.32643648982048035,
-0.33088383078575134,
0.36510327458381653,
-0.30647584795951843,
-0.20075362920761108,
0.3255060613155365,
0.36070185899734497,
0.3446423411369324,
-0.2397838681936264,
-0.3061494529247284,
-0.17906001210212708,
0.42119503021240234,
0.8040177226066589,
-0.13817033171653748,
0.8342538475990295,
0.06880440562963486,
-0.15948474407196045,
-0.4913247227668762,
-0.580494225025177,
-0.3480239808559418,
-0.46275103092193604,
0.39183753728866577,
-0.1117982268333435,
-0.4622485339641571,
1.0330575704574585,
-0.33301350474357605,
0.07588177919387817,
0.4026370644569397,
0.4070907533168793,
-0.021226918324828148,
0.819113552570343,
0.6958363652229309,
-0.2568175494670868,
0.44733110070228577,
-0.3846161663532257,
0.13673919439315796,
-0.6895359754562378,
-0.13390325009822845,
-0.5125455260276794,
0.10849692672491074,
-0.13681554794311523,
-0.2714829742908478,
0.6351138949394226,
-0.29568177461624146,
-0.09641876071691513,
-0.01839863508939743,
-0.009927249513566494,
0.2189527153968811,
-0.04301534593105316,
-0.0761847123503685,
0.5073865056037903,
-0.13756471872329712,
0.13019844889640808,
0.2962285876274109,
-0.7840309739112854,
-0.36959147453308105,
0.6178661584854126,
0.4437134861946106,
0.6663123369216919,
0.3306484818458557,
0.36279404163360596,
0.6333447694778442,
0.7041102051734924,
-0.9777479767799377,
0.7177463173866272,
0.31741172075271606,
-0.5375335216522217,
-0.4034123420715332,
-0.5285387635231018,
-1.194579839706421,
0.4715452790260315,
0.055863287299871445,
-0.5389508605003357,
0.2073080986738205,
0.015354050323367119,
-0.1981988102197647,
-0.07246585190296173,
-0.6254221796989441,
0.5747973322868347,
-0.2881735563278198,
-0.1505783498287201,
-0.24892571568489075,
-0.35025909543037415,
0.26353394985198975,
-0.20151390135288239,
0.5246155261993408,
-0.018907396122813225,
0.055734340101480484,
0.611470103263855,
-0.8993726372718811,
1.0648876428604126,
-0.28535112738609314,
-0.4478677809238434,
0.6157892942428589,
0.14550170302391052,
0.9663728475570679,
-0.13529056310653687,
-0.09429464489221573,
-0.044869665056467056,
-0.2655929625034332,
-0.06799071282148361,
-0.8138861060142517,
0.5176125764846802,
-0.841876745223999,
-0.6813746094703674,
-0.5962727069854736,
-0.5610377192497253,
-0.49614447355270386,
0.12108293175697327,
-0.030694082379341125,
0.6418401002883911,
-0.05195922031998634,
-0.008597929030656815,
0.38520506024360657,
-0.3218570649623871,
0.7572981119155884,
1.3887919187545776,
-0.28373274207115173,
-0.14842765033245087,
0.7237110733985901,
0.2914682626724243,
0.21363091468811035,
0.045502543449401855,
0.21693378686904907,
-0.019818423315882683,
-0.51454758644104,
-0.1286829710006714,
0.3013710379600525,
-0.9444206953048706,
-0.3976227641105652,
-0.375059574842453,
-0.1660507470369339,
-0.22906729578971863,
-0.09607549756765366,
-0.4436420500278473,
-0.23270626366138458,
-0.409531831741333,
-0.27379924058914185,
0.43000972270965576,
0.6711634993553162,
0.047752365469932556,
0.42698442935943604,
-0.9269188642501831,
0.3895164132118225,
-0.10381181538105011,
0.2615797817707062,
0.1996879130601883,
-0.28283512592315674,
-0.44532331824302673,
-0.1456426978111267,
-0.4753921926021576,
-1.0557364225387573,
0.6136664748191833,
-0.03626760467886925,
0.7281914949417114,
0.270645409822464,
0.5302737951278687,
0.6189998388290405,
-0.41762930154800415,
0.6469622850418091,
0.023912915959954262,
-0.7942876219749451,
0.6238817572593689,
-0.3116183876991272,
-0.0451272577047348,
0.21677957475185394,
0.3768515884876251,
-0.5184434652328491,
-0.6540743708610535,
-0.5815377831459045,
-1.1252799034118652,
0.8277928829193115,
0.23310332000255585,
-0.32846689224243164,
0.10356472432613373,
0.19506309926509857,
-0.28918230533599854,
-0.12982375919818878,
-0.2285764217376709,
-0.36764514446258545,
0.17833437025547028,
0.16136498749256134,
-0.23529279232025146,
-0.1599363088607788,
-0.15113776922225952,
0.16092224419116974,
0.6969670653343201,
-0.10901477187871933,
0.10143642872571945,
0.43626177310943604,
-0.4283364415168762,
-0.24575605988502502,
0.27288442850112915,
0.6864244341850281,
0.8483097553253174,
-0.08740713447332382,
0.017228711396455765,
0.29747340083122253,
-0.46749237179756165,
0.18630769848823547,
-0.05151386559009552,
0.0007418526802212,
0.09735579788684845,
0.461789071559906,
0.4739592671394348,
-0.0592614971101284,
-0.9789445400238037,
0.42780449986457825,
-0.053814347833395004,
0.17914342880249023,
-0.5593082308769226,
-0.14695768058300018,
-0.1324760764837265,
0.3503240644931793,
0.8149054050445557,
-0.3975268602371216,
0.24180270731449127,
-0.727479100227356,
0.23186106979846954,
0.6150757074356079,
-0.5005236268043518,
-0.18566244840621948,
-0.034007277339696884,
0.3219682574272156,
-0.5894966125488281,
0.7696132659912109,
0.061504993587732315,
-0.5584148168563843,
1.2469269037246704,
0.6462059617042542,
0.9176498055458069,
-0.3007240891456604,
0.3236819803714752,
-0.26111048460006714,
0.5751729607582092,
0.2119828462600708,
0.3409636318683624,
0.3703661859035492,
-0.8116351366043091,
-0.6050429344177246,
-0.13339567184448242,
-0.8254901170730591,
0.30468568205833435,
-0.4683404564857483,
0.17497552931308746,
-0.3831652104854584,
-0.32458770275115967,
-0.33756306767463684,
-0.14374901354312897,
-0.4597436785697937,
0.2887820899486542,
-0.08921235054731369,
0.9696158170700073,
-0.9720636010169983,
0.23349320888519287,
0.8190428018569946,
-0.4041675925254822,
-0.9010292291641235,
-0.22377802431583405,
-0.0018021324649453163,
-0.6568629145622253,
0.7829835414886475,
-0.008500872179865837,
0.02404065988957882,
-0.22544465959072113,
-0.2620491683483124,
-0.7753073573112488,
1.1809860467910767,
0.2773866653442383,
-0.3020734488964081,
0.2915323078632355,
0.40825846791267395,
0.8231491446495056,
-0.2562563717365265,
0.4445076584815979,
0.44703006744384766,
0.1850557029247284,
0.14287088811397552,
-0.7416254878044128,
0.293693482875824,
-0.18965011835098267,
-0.18745526671409607,
0.3834398090839386,
-0.4922305941581726,
0.5850338935852051,
-0.15795311331748962,
-0.3072763979434967,
-0.6006417274475098,
0.4487227499485016,
0.29735568165779114,
0.9746078848838806,
0.18938258290290833,
0.38659629225730896,
0.7272166609764099,
0.27646496891975403,
1.3525511026382446,
-0.2026306688785553,
0.3234242796897888,
0.9815026521682739,
-0.4556705951690674,
0.7433929443359375,
0.44795113801956177,
-0.10129309445619583,
0.5530669689178467,
0.34391412138938904,
0.23483361303806305,
0.2503700852394104,
0.035948414355516434,
-0.35601097345352173,
-0.20583145320415497,
-0.21643702685832977,
-0.22402967512607574,
0.1251061111688614,
0.33613669872283936,
-0.2057896852493286,
-0.3431614935398102,
0.0036822601687163115,
-0.16700522601604462,
-0.4495791792869568,
-0.5822703242301941,
0.9374165534973145,
0.29311442375183105,
-0.4561110734939575,
0.4109594225883484,
-0.2015136182308197,
-0.04901101812720299,
-0.4869758188724518,
0.09040623903274536,
-0.4507215917110443,
0.3335649371147156,
-0.4370056390762329,
-0.6595818996429443,
0.6405619978904724,
0.11948267370462418,
-0.018644114956259727,
0.020752737298607826,
0.9821084141731262,
0.24880081415176392,
-0.2656494081020355,
0.3214457631111145,
0.46852442622184753,
0.16838984191417694,
-0.40758806467056274,
-0.1455189287662506,
0.21919311583042145,
-0.5534839630126953,
-0.22817501425743103,
0.4465606212615967,
0.5485284328460693,
-0.27785733342170715,
1.2053606510162354,
0.5626336932182312,
0.22752287983894348,
-0.013870556838810444,
0.11380311101675034,
1.0228103399276733,
-0.6019564270973206,
-0.4121687114238739,
-0.9590309262275696,
0.9136182069778442,
-0.024836227297782898,
0.08791036158800125,
0.7833632230758667,
0.4979807138442993,
-0.047271426767110825,
-0.20447933673858643,
0.9477214813232422,
0.16979043185710907,
0.3299432694911957,
-0.41483306884765625,
0.5839369893074036,
-0.5844000577926636,
0.5108305811882019,
-0.30362042784690857,
-0.5963739156723022,
-0.32731637358665466,
0.20265312492847443,
-0.3579091429710388,
-0.4000123143196106,
0.6083865761756897,
0.7464707493782043,
0.24532674252986908,
-0.1105731651186943,
0.4420683979988098,
0.4628629684448242,
0.8556315898895264,
0.2785116732120514,
1.3470438718795776,
-0.11107636988162994,
0.7092589139938354,
0.10058337450027466,
-0.39454367756843567,
-0.5617957711219788,
-0.9434759616851807,
-0.6595134735107422,
-0.34538283944129944,
-0.42157089710235596,
-0.2932429313659668,
-0.1283310055732727,
0.5674183368682861,
0.3614063560962677,
-0.6196406483650208,
-0.10807039588689804,
-0.33914807438850403,
0.274615079164505,
-0.09684661775827408,
-0.2657531201839447,
0.11022326350212097,
-0.5546786785125732,
0.14152008295059204,
0.544374406337738,
0.17029061913490295,
-0.08351007103919983,
-0.07960906624794006,
-0.04198340326547623,
0.21277479827404022,
0.13312019407749176,
0.8271083235740662,
0.5226109623908997,
-0.5514125227928162,
-0.3326406478881836,
0.07165810465812683,
-0.08708400279283524,
-0.03741896152496338,
0.9928901791572571,
-0.8498209118843079,
0.10538630932569504,
0.39577311277389526,
0.8413758277893066,
0.3308597803115845,
0.1945992261171341,
0.6490005850791931,
-0.7156268358230591,
-0.1760445535182953,
0.3819814920425415,
0.2745673358440399,
0.15163151919841766,
-0.724373459815979,
0.5523696541786194,
0.11757577210664749,
-0.7571732997894287,
-1.190062165260315,
0.3357847332954407,
-0.9099094867706299,
-0.3123154938220978,
1.319420576095581,
-0.03525473549962044,
0.16777563095092773,
-0.45000889897346497,
-0.2573440968990326,
0.30333539843559265,
-0.3652970492839813,
0.8995096683502197,
0.4370371103286743,
-0.6041505336761475,
-0.37502753734588623,
-0.23642556369304657,
0.26661717891693115,
0.13103073835372925,
-1.1984703540802002,
0.13361507654190063,
0.5800785422325134,
0.34844204783439636,
0.38352322578430176,
0.6575961112976074,
0.29647308588027954,
0.26633575558662415,
0.03403361514210701,
0.003493832889944315,
-0.2736930251121521,
-0.5614222884178162,
-0.524757444858551,
0.316184937953949,
0.24758565425872803,
-0.013780122622847557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04121v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04121v2
|
Can Large Language Models Reason and Plan?
| 2024-03-07T00:36:32 | 2024-03-08T19:51:14 |
Subbarao Kambhampati
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While humans sometimes do show the capability of correcting their own
erroneous guesses with self-critiquing, there seems to be no basis for that
assumption in the case of LLMs.
|
[
0.004617744125425816,
-0.8372043371200562,
1.085516333580017,
0.4402726888656616,
-0.07083474099636078,
-0.3110049366950989,
-0.34431537985801697,
-0.38426241278648376,
0.315214604139328,
0.6362720131874084,
-0.7347779870033264,
0.05044794827699661,
-0.2840208411216736,
0.21914635598659515,
-0.2423066347837448,
0.32175305485725403,
0.0451275072991848,
0.44364598393440247,
-0.02126520685851574,
-0.15216505527496338,
-0.44931894540786743,
-0.779565155506134,
-0.9861329793930054,
-0.663115382194519,
0.740290641784668,
0.6821805238723755,
0.6607547402381897,
0.5781632661819458,
0.23742803931236267,
0.27609479427337646,
-0.06793364137411118,
0.16419145464897156,
-0.2722998559474945,
0.18647143244743347,
-0.49163368344306946,
-0.915380597114563,
-0.3520627021789551,
0.061592940241098404,
0.4880774915218353,
0.727181077003479,
-0.3302046060562134,
-0.009188766591250896,
-0.25804436206817627,
0.847071647644043,
-0.459927499294281,
-0.12550131976604462,
-0.5969706773757935,
0.08569572865962982,
-0.016369912773370743,
-0.23896439373493195,
-0.4271271824836731,
0.14704012870788574,
0.05140107870101929,
-0.05666035786271095,
0.21294333040714264,
0.31521862745285034,
0.4676957130432129,
0.5211789011955261,
-0.4626741409301758,
-0.3660346567630768,
-0.8904173970222473,
0.8425226211547852,
-0.8541364669799805,
0.134482279419899,
0.6212271451950073,
0.5347200632095337,
-0.34112125635147095,
-0.46870073676109314,
-0.5880526304244995,
-0.35641759634017944,
0.02551286481320858,
-0.14604948461055756,
0.344730019569397,
0.09007306396961212,
0.7426270246505737,
0.15561604499816895,
-0.3433901071548462,
0.31361153721809387,
-0.42611849308013916,
-0.39434269070625305,
0.8645554780960083,
0.37371107935905457,
0.2880937159061432,
-0.18744386732578278,
-0.515733003616333,
0.0746307447552681,
-0.8779022693634033,
0.027117785066366196,
0.2572927176952362,
0.07458716630935669,
0.03406279534101486,
1.1417236328125,
-0.2052926868200302,
0.6514230370521545,
0.01853589527308941,
-0.06336626410484314,
-0.1256313920021057,
0.14356274902820587,
-0.814181923866272,
0.02272121235728264,
0.6244033575057983,
0.7046277523040771,
0.5227334499359131,
0.0539143830537796,
-0.45431703329086304,
0.1888064295053482,
0.08963677287101746,
-0.3590368926525116,
-0.30370596051216125,
0.39332860708236694,
-0.2550978660583496,
-0.04256245121359825,
-0.1414998471736908,
-0.5538729429244995,
-0.5522736310958862,
-0.3590277135372162,
0.4618787169456482,
-0.029186539351940155,
0.09743397682905197,
0.5264254212379456,
-0.09989377856254578,
0.0549326166510582,
0.604610800743103,
-0.6452444791793823,
0.08301850408315659,
0.2764491140842438,
0.45081424713134766,
-0.09877513349056244,
-0.6469984650611877,
0.07472370564937592,
0.15924547612667084,
-0.6289187669754028,
1.0447801351547241,
-0.3077660799026489,
-0.401075541973114,
-0.2009568214416504,
0.13272309303283691,
-0.16412195563316345,
-0.5062952637672424,
0.7590169310569763,
-0.554567277431488,
0.05326144024729729,
-0.8648713827133179,
-0.5680498480796814,
-0.2109128087759018,
0.257370263338089,
-0.5179920792579651,
0.4697256088256836,
-0.11526845395565033,
-0.559699296951294,
0.44931408762931824,
-0.2969706356525421,
-0.311225563287735,
-0.13468530774116516,
-0.46932581067085266,
-0.12868203222751617,
0.03594602644443512,
0.22026222944259644,
0.3929826617240906,
-0.3132505714893341,
0.41446495056152344,
-0.43425968289375305,
-0.14712807536125183,
0.5734072923660278,
-0.46671900153160095,
0.8198205232620239,
0.44513705372810364,
-0.5086252093315125,
0.10361778736114502,
-0.4856317341327667,
0.10239286720752716,
0.460024356842041,
-0.5412245988845825,
-0.09064996987581253,
0.4249340891838074,
-0.24782496690750122,
0.512875497341156,
0.4042302370071411,
-0.23395565152168274,
0.7098134160041809,
-0.10976406186819077,
0.6428140997886658,
0.6435753703117371,
-0.2287866175174713,
0.4841071367263794,
-0.7912124395370483,
0.6647123098373413,
0.042566437274217606,
-0.16560666263103485,
0.06157961115241051,
-0.5257082581520081,
-1.4053235054016113,
0.09946474432945251,
0.003786183428019285,
0.6362622976303101,
-0.38317805528640747,
0.16355112195014954,
0.06715996563434601,
-0.3649008572101593,
-0.03264736756682396,
0.20979167520999908,
0.23014095425605774,
0.2530672252178192,
0.3343392014503479,
0.01350247859954834,
-0.8981615304946899,
-1.0403237342834473,
-0.5523470640182495,
-0.20539964735507965,
-0.08738499134778976,
0.1862531453371048,
0.5310512185096741,
-0.35303857922554016,
0.8621423244476318,
-0.2855698764324188,
-0.10432557016611099,
-0.47778841853141785,
0.13159248232841492,
0.10989347100257874,
0.13166461884975433,
0.6010653972625732,
-0.56667560338974,
-0.26413461565971375,
-0.47612234950065613,
-0.6839154958724976,
-0.4060520827770233,
-0.15015935897827148,
0.11984661221504211,
0.37363672256469727,
0.8740218281745911,
-0.7664457559585571,
0.3529645502567291,
0.44551265239715576,
-0.6804521083831787,
0.8279016017913818,
-0.5327228903770447,
-0.1835201382637024,
-0.6743902564048767,
-0.3395180404186249,
-0.002485760720446706,
-0.38787439465522766,
-0.3896259069442749,
-0.10918429493904114,
0.0937979519367218,
0.33379003405570984,
-0.07504553347826004,
0.7963047623634338,
-0.6332719326019287,
-0.20705461502075195,
-0.6375172734260559,
0.023610472679138184,
-0.09100108593702316,
0.41410425305366516,
-0.0061633531004190445,
0.5580247044563293,
0.6627082824707031,
-0.8390614986419678,
0.18650509417057037,
-0.2654029130935669,
-0.23638823628425598,
0.6062238216400146,
-0.7060641050338745,
0.0863538533449173,
-0.3057617247104645,
0.30217158794403076,
-1.0384374856948853,
-0.8041516542434692,
0.21547548472881317,
-0.24921384453773499,
0.26595503091812134,
-0.14364971220493317,
-0.35712096095085144,
-0.5319594740867615,
0.046682264655828476,
0.18937402963638306,
0.331267386674881,
-0.5358949899673462,
0.4343665540218353,
0.33077892661094666,
-0.0975416749715805,
-0.5930218696594238,
-1.1574711799621582,
0.12861314415931702,
-0.2857050895690918,
-0.7843959331512451,
-0.19696661829948425,
-0.21070408821105957,
-0.9394776821136475,
-0.3507704734802246,
-0.04505693539977074,
-0.07530253380537033,
-0.13708846271038055,
0.3698357045650482,
0.11693015694618225,
-0.07208125293254852,
0.28626304864883423,
-0.38465267419815063,
0.04337764158844948,
0.2830897569656372,
0.25396764278411865,
0.5184937715530396,
0.02225297875702381,
-0.760010838508606,
-0.20727045834064484,
0.03996768966317177,
0.8144471645355225,
-0.005009430926293135,
0.39766210317611694,
-0.34709489345550537,
-0.37865906953811646,
-0.26952093839645386,
-1.0727274417877197,
0.000520202680490911,
-0.4179954528808594,
-0.054219648241996765,
-0.31906601786613464,
-1.0413504838943481,
0.7616099715232849,
0.197429820895195,
-0.28326746821403503,
0.8801352381706238,
0.6169872283935547,
-0.346158504486084,
1.2304736375808716,
0.23663447797298431,
-0.04162261262536049,
-0.02473713830113411,
0.04307335615158081,
-0.022409310564398766,
-0.7120676040649414,
0.02605409361422062,
-0.6060915589332581,
-0.40048184990882874,
-0.49134561419487,
-0.5005005598068237,
-0.08825014531612396,
0.15905651450157166,
-0.40796583890914917,
0.11789504438638687,
-0.2680579423904419,
0.6255375742912292,
0.52186119556427,
0.06320829689502716,
0.3506612777709961,
-0.18953347206115723,
-0.18131162226200104,
-0.018229279667139053,
-0.8315312266349792,
-0.6766687631607056,
0.8658108115196228,
0.33232319355010986,
0.9802881479263306,
0.008359686471521854,
0.387060284614563,
0.08815047144889832,
0.45871832966804504,
-0.8138099908828735,
0.7447326183319092,
0.36629778146743774,
-1.2127516269683838,
-0.7516733407974243,
-0.42946964502334595,
-0.9356058835983276,
0.2869144082069397,
-0.10525001585483551,
-0.8722524046897888,
0.2996489703655243,
0.09189775586128235,
-0.21339823305606842,
0.5872563719749451,
-0.8792887330055237,
0.7431795597076416,
-0.4892178773880005,
0.0041374992579221725,
-0.3696698546409607,
-0.4884655773639679,
0.3458700180053711,
-0.11139951646327972,
0.3528750240802765,
-0.28964555263519287,
0.09609507769346237,
0.7189266681671143,
-0.3990214765071869,
0.8757320642471313,
-0.005546246655285358,
-0.19809673726558685,
0.6965501308441162,
0.3941747546195984,
0.49045658111572266,
-0.1500273495912552,
-0.23512524366378784,
-0.04674961417913437,
-0.2568138837814331,
-0.34385305643081665,
-0.3850024938583374,
0.6847325563430786,
-0.6652611494064331,
-0.844265878200531,
-0.6024194955825806,
-0.4887085556983948,
-0.142525315284729,
0.1927100121974945,
0.4207985997200012,
0.1606454700231552,
-0.011758122593164444,
-0.09953486174345016,
0.0033404368441551924,
0.000467536534415558,
0.5146034955978394,
0.6004588007926941,
-0.3837340772151947,
-0.30136600136756897,
0.15357139706611633,
0.39669400453567505,
0.13184601068496704,
0.11430902779102325,
0.4072394073009491,
-0.3280799090862274,
-0.5325037240982056,
-0.047807760536670685,
0.7981577515602112,
-1.0315582752227783,
0.266786128282547,
-0.25129425525665283,
-0.12118364870548248,
-0.22130513191223145,
-0.20623527467250824,
-0.1858275979757309,
-0.4200771749019623,
-0.22087787091732025,
-0.07805942744016647,
0.09773325175046921,
1.4417058229446411,
-0.11432133615016937,
0.37725991010665894,
-0.6560963988304138,
0.04567863792181015,
0.5997952818870544,
0.2582518756389618,
0.056170105934143066,
-0.6994394659996033,
-0.0987880602478981,
0.25162893533706665,
-0.3243277370929718,
-0.9157187938690186,
0.4090500473976135,
-0.35837075114250183,
0.5769999027252197,
0.3608604669570923,
0.01726718805730343,
0.6600084900856018,
-0.4485008418560028,
0.8937382102012634,
0.1736936867237091,
-0.6887855529785156,
0.57486492395401,
-0.48008185625076294,
0.2592850923538208,
0.2560061514377594,
0.3691636621952057,
-0.6091570258140564,
-0.21863295137882233,
-0.8041728734970093,
-0.36469128727912903,
0.5845777988433838,
-0.12046784907579422,
-0.24660295248031616,
-0.2896183431148529,
0.530398428440094,
-0.34220898151397705,
-0.03930557519197464,
-0.9605820775032043,
-0.33892056345939636,
0.06718873232603073,
0.38731515407562256,
-0.39691513776779175,
-0.839868426322937,
-0.19051720201969147,
-0.30346888303756714,
0.5775179266929626,
-0.05504320189356804,
0.2208246886730194,
0.6677598357200623,
-0.054696835577487946,
-0.8373636603355408,
0.42650535702705383,
1.1268826723098755,
1.4912762641906738,
-0.05408788472414017,
0.3573508858680725,
0.4917929470539093,
0.06833755224943161,
0.12037412822246552,
-0.4209687411785126,
0.1050543338060379,
-0.34256187081336975,
0.42876994609832764,
0.6171327233314514,
0.24579232931137085,
-0.8034732341766357,
0.3529592752456665,
-0.186075359582901,
-0.528448224067688,
-0.6390126347541809,
0.1999146044254303,
0.4545355439186096,
0.6095128059387207,
0.2867078483104706,
-0.014870489947497845,
-0.2904358208179474,
-0.7923958897590637,
-0.2717368006706238,
0.41358134150505066,
-0.1553608775138855,
-0.19826236367225647,
0.9193534255027771,
-0.1228708028793335,
-0.6878207921981812,
0.7071114182472229,
-0.14511269330978394,
-0.674597442150116,
0.5257543921470642,
0.4188562035560608,
0.8020732402801514,
-0.3205232322216034,
-0.10712800920009613,
0.3180920481681824,
0.4109320044517517,
-0.5496499538421631,
0.45903047919273376,
0.4211600422859192,
-1.1287704706192017,
-0.9506089687347412,
-0.3925466239452362,
-0.5924268960952759,
0.3605121076107025,
-0.2319437563419342,
0.264769047498703,
-0.5097360014915466,
-0.19613315165042877,
-0.11138962209224701,
-0.2640433609485626,
-0.5238057971000671,
0.4923945963382721,
0.2564453184604645,
1.1631133556365967,
-0.5542084574699402,
0.8804743885993958,
0.8462380766868591,
-0.28181466460227966,
-1.083404302597046,
-0.12467411905527115,
0.009732403792440891,
-0.8464168310165405,
1.0562106370925903,
0.12912116944789886,
-0.08986931294202805,
-0.5447350144386292,
-0.9012022614479065,
-0.9180816411972046,
0.9017298221588135,
0.35890716314315796,
-0.7340459823608398,
-0.3879643976688385,
0.008430088870227337,
0.5074010491371155,
-0.27843064069747925,
0.14910010993480682,
0.21321113407611847,
0.701350748538971,
0.2630310356616974,
-1.1509922742843628,
-0.04472159966826439,
0.31960827112197876,
-0.34476202726364136,
0.12152697145938873,
-0.5470883250236511,
1.2249211072921753,
-0.6105077862739563,
-0.2083197981119156,
0.002429732820019126,
0.38155999779701233,
-0.03578587993979454,
0.3768046796321869,
0.7096496224403381,
1.0158413648605347,
0.5949199199676514,
-0.08052349835634232,
1.2645268440246582,
-0.2072923332452774,
0.4396432638168335,
1.178267240524292,
-0.3578704297542572,
0.6844611763954163,
0.383373886346817,
-0.4530104100704193,
0.2257888913154602,
0.7467724084854126,
0.3102059066295624,
0.10135364532470703,
0.11795590817928314,
-0.0692138820886612,
-1.0536116361618042,
0.4138181805610657,
-0.03486965224146843,
0.49333539605140686,
0.7230063080787659,
-0.3721133768558502,
-0.11867814511060715,
-0.5833154320716858,
-0.07081204652786255,
0.011974171735346317,
-0.5157172083854675,
0.504054605960846,
0.4339047968387604,
-1.1810739040374756,
0.5020729303359985,
0.1299445927143097,
0.6110360026359558,
-0.2744232416152954,
0.21923989057540894,
0.2117660939693451,
0.2135026752948761,
-0.25653550028800964,
-1.0407384634017944,
0.41058826446533203,
-0.4632568955421448,
0.011236457154154778,
-0.11719714105129242,
1.0726051330566406,
-0.09506654739379883,
-0.2753302752971649,
0.14333514869213104,
0.7654761672019958,
0.18905016779899597,
-0.26984092593193054,
-0.5555737018585205,
-0.40907227993011475,
0.05208180844783783,
-0.42388853430747986,
0.19420018792152405,
0.5723865628242493,
-0.17359159886837006,
1.2860679626464844,
0.48636844754219055,
0.3215678930282593,
0.14140965044498444,
-0.026076288893818855,
0.48304808139801025,
-1.0595238208770752,
-0.19956444203853607,
-1.2556253671646118,
0.17392969131469727,
-0.002136163879185915,
-0.24679653346538544,
0.8982160091400146,
0.3075057864189148,
0.8565039038658142,
-0.14943723380565643,
0.808130145072937,
0.1942562311887741,
0.6720181703567505,
-0.706589937210083,
0.32792073488235474,
-0.34853655099868774,
0.16750577092170715,
0.027767304331064224,
-0.8825730681419373,
-0.2230333536863327,
1.0040520429611206,
-0.7255364060401917,
0.19326329231262207,
0.8725893497467041,
0.7273750901222229,
0.29661327600479126,
0.1521303653717041,
0.5955361723899841,
0.4630597233772278,
0.05125267803668976,
0.3559721112251282,
1.2214395999908447,
0.28252464532852173,
0.13424968719482422,
-0.07956969738006592,
-0.07258128374814987,
-0.5236757397651672,
-0.9054582118988037,
-1.3053864240646362,
-0.35102400183677673,
-0.032978951930999756,
-0.21426142752170563,
-0.14774291217327118,
1.1638774871826172,
0.5007011890411377,
-0.416117787361145,
-0.29108065366744995,
-0.18032696843147278,
0.25333747267723083,
0.19312116503715515,
-0.08408990502357483,
0.02247552201151848,
-0.3202055096626282,
-0.27169403433799744,
0.5235971212387085,
0.1264345794916153,
0.4195214807987213,
-0.7320876717567444,
-0.11324720829725266,
-0.0740961879491806,
0.3188400864601135,
0.6257485747337341,
0.42237094044685364,
-0.8685324788093567,
-0.5806993246078491,
-0.03925289958715439,
-0.1931331753730774,
0.18197950720787048,
0.9139130115509033,
-0.33711594343185425,
0.229980006814003,
0.4894360899925232,
0.13005205988883972,
0.30218788981437683,
-0.2800317704677582,
0.47440290451049805,
-0.35453173518180847,
-0.09832321852445602,
0.13596874475479126,
0.9858558177947998,
0.23961910605430603,
-0.35963839292526245,
0.4241322875022888,
0.21487906575202942,
-1.256288766860962,
-0.4191901385784149,
0.5820723176002502,
-1.0709580183029175,
-0.26448264718055725,
1.3366162776947021,
0.07881811261177063,
-0.44736602902412415,
0.02722981944680214,
-0.6780110597610474,
-0.05230396240949631,
-0.015065989457070827,
0.7579720616340637,
1.1192909479141235,
-0.3386436104774475,
-0.003981069661676884,
-0.8656442165374756,
0.21177028119564056,
0.37204164266586304,
-0.5505815148353577,
0.27793797850608826,
0.6414614915847778,
0.571121335029602,
0.29317158460617065,
1.0756316184997559,
0.3878715932369232,
0.17442010343074799,
-0.2062937319278717,
-0.05723227933049202,
0.37957265973091125,
-0.2752198874950409,
-0.27925464510917664,
-0.26710420846939087,
0.7601593732833862,
0.5373832583427429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06643v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06643v1
|
Levels of AI Agents: from Rules to Large Language Models
| 2024-03-06T23:02:30 | 2024-03-06T23:02:30 |
Yu Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
AI agents are defined as artificial entities to perceive the environment,
make decisions and take actions. Inspired by the 6 levels of autonomous driving
by Society of Automotive Engineers, the AI agents are also categorized based on
utilities and strongness, as the following levels: L0, no AI, with tools taking
into account perception plus actions; L1, using rule-based AI; L2, making
rule-based AI replaced by IL/RL-based AI, with additional reasoning & decision
making; L3, applying LLM-based AI instead of IL/RL-based AI, additionally
setting up memory & reflection; L4, based on L3, facilitating autonomous
learning & generalization; L5, based on L4, appending personality of emotion
and character and collaborative behavior with multi-agents.
|
[
-0.5551891326904297,
-0.6039202809333801,
0.7616772651672363,
0.039732351899147034,
0.5608097314834595,
0.4689193069934845,
0.22555361688137054,
-0.8110013604164124,
-0.21118594706058502,
0.42121943831443787,
-0.4999794363975525,
-0.33627331256866455,
-0.3084518313407898,
0.280569463968277,
-0.44527000188827515,
0.9353191256523132,
0.11264687776565552,
0.07694403827190399,
-0.26184484362602234,
-0.16350674629211426,
-0.5206363201141357,
-0.2121421843767166,
-1.1218773126602173,
-0.5961725115776062,
0.7843411564826965,
0.3500445783138275,
0.8180572390556335,
0.7615914344787598,
0.4780624806880951,
0.5837559103965759,
0.1281764954328537,
-0.17793439328670502,
-0.06363096833229065,
0.13123755156993866,
-0.29635438323020935,
-0.592652440071106,
-0.557588517665863,
0.3564285933971405,
0.4557649493217468,
0.39622005820274353,
0.11485777795314789,
-0.20894843339920044,
-0.09596183151006699,
0.5056710243225098,
-0.3581503629684448,
0.6204617023468018,
-0.19886215031147003,
0.14128315448760986,
0.3892399072647095,
0.00032566062873229384,
-0.2184382975101471,
-0.19290682673454285,
-0.007625953759998083,
-0.7266786098480225,
-0.054586976766586304,
-0.033973366022109985,
0.7419165372848511,
0.6707884073257446,
-0.555158257484436,
-0.5527216196060181,
-0.9174082279205322,
0.6588554382324219,
-0.7731617093086243,
0.20824158191680908,
0.3103111982345581,
0.4059741795063019,
0.02852325141429901,
-0.4234635531902313,
-0.6507648229598999,
-0.6990687251091003,
-0.3242947459220886,
0.03019615262746811,
0.03904483839869499,
0.5404869318008423,
0.3428565263748169,
0.16087380051612854,
-0.2066783607006073,
0.41390982270240784,
-0.3365866541862488,
-0.0020801464561372995,
1.040911078453064,
0.4341453015804291,
0.6432172060012817,
0.3244687616825104,
-0.2669592499732971,
-0.1284354329109192,
-0.4103277027606964,
0.25161299109458923,
0.11807914823293686,
0.4397934675216675,
-0.23702767491340637,
0.3488236665725708,
-0.3538707494735718,
0.322287380695343,
0.1413341909646988,
-0.6014195084571838,
0.3457854092121124,
-0.44523611664772034,
-0.23211702704429626,
-0.0827493965625763,
0.5949931144714355,
0.0498349666595459,
0.46759846806526184,
-0.23551519215106964,
-0.5319639444351196,
-0.1189577579498291,
0.38554689288139343,
-0.32365232706069946,
0.24073149263858795,
0.06780574470758438,
-0.45927098393440247,
-0.49367621541023254,
-0.08268123865127563,
-0.30823662877082825,
-0.6902410387992859,
-0.747660756111145,
0.5736868381500244,
-0.27456793189048767,
-0.21299679577350616,
-0.44166770577430725,
-0.019694410264492035,
0.7542179822921753,
0.6661097407341003,
-0.48987165093421936,
0.4592441916465759,
0.5326421856880188,
0.4812479019165039,
-0.1602107137441635,
-0.8638807535171509,
0.25437963008880615,
0.2094305455684662,
-0.4651600122451782,
0.8878389596939087,
-0.6629433631896973,
-0.333006888628006,
-0.1968664973974228,
-0.03066333383321762,
-0.08933284133672714,
-0.43484142422676086,
0.14292585849761963,
-0.49250465631484985,
0.05880579352378845,
0.05791449546813965,
-0.4454250931739807,
-0.6106149554252625,
0.38857629895210266,
-0.721928060054779,
0.7419677376747131,
0.2788867950439453,
0.014564091339707375,
0.5881749987602234,
-1.1765416860580444,
-0.7702047824859619,
0.2662704586982727,
-0.3643779456615448,
0.06899505108594894,
-0.10302536934614182,
-0.16421160101890564,
0.37872374057769775,
-0.15411433577537537,
-0.19165761768817902,
0.16285201907157898,
0.018336594104766846,
-0.029522079974412918,
-0.2450057417154312,
0.7603455185890198,
0.24489334225654602,
-0.5173919796943665,
0.8324834108352661,
-0.7117704153060913,
-0.03674259036779404,
-0.18558387458324432,
-0.3509531319141388,
-0.21219311654567719,
0.49348998069763184,
-0.3261777460575104,
0.45313745737075806,
0.43977928161621094,
-0.23812374472618103,
0.43292972445487976,
-0.2849079668521881,
0.4868762493133545,
0.9962220191955566,
0.09403058141469955,
0.7598068118095398,
-0.4742744565010071,
0.7228553891181946,
0.07970412820577621,
0.14149683713912964,
0.32650384306907654,
-0.4842740595340729,
-0.9772232174873352,
-0.13967493176460266,
-0.3720147907733917,
0.781128466129303,
-0.670654833316803,
0.662741482257843,
0.13051189482212067,
-0.7121907472610474,
-0.6138714551925659,
0.04095280542969704,
0.22958630323410034,
0.08921447396278381,
0.2510116696357727,
0.2613884508609772,
0.009824578650295734,
-0.8639153838157654,
0.07303951680660248,
-0.4586135149002075,
0.295712411403656,
0.26620379090309143,
0.9653553366661072,
-0.3959263861179352,
0.6165002584457397,
0.03181850165128708,
-0.38202306628227234,
-0.6891679763793945,
0.008083081804215908,
-0.186625137925148,
0.3880024254322052,
0.3708605170249939,
-0.659696638584137,
-0.547852098941803,
0.2835177481174469,
-1.0239204168319702,
0.20480290055274963,
-0.4591729938983917,
0.025018781423568726,
0.08509127050638199,
0.6907215714454651,
-0.757659375667572,
0.6184800863265991,
-0.24289697408676147,
-0.47186797857284546,
0.13849496841430664,
-0.25571390986442566,
0.010026221163570881,
-0.7761189341545105,
-0.4043835997581482,
0.05247875303030014,
-0.30614957213401794,
-0.8090333342552185,
0.45854178071022034,
-0.572299063205719,
0.11741442233324051,
-0.4048667848110199,
0.6337841749191284,
-0.5928410887718201,
-0.4751482903957367,
-0.45454829931259155,
-0.08860845863819122,
-0.15497085452079773,
0.4844684898853302,
-0.21470414102077484,
0.8005144596099854,
1.0136703252792358,
-0.8620215058326721,
0.8598952889442444,
-0.1756194531917572,
-0.11341522634029388,
0.5774004459381104,
-0.6106566190719604,
0.14519910514354706,
-0.4967867434024811,
0.2721199095249176,
-0.5307057499885559,
-0.07370570302009583,
0.2397201955318451,
-0.30659598112106323,
-0.10320869088172913,
0.6536140441894531,
-0.5114626884460449,
-0.06143246591091156,
-0.03305871784687042,
0.4724268615245819,
0.3622305393218994,
0.17702309787273407,
1.0018749237060547,
0.3606971800327301,
0.05977118760347366,
-0.26730117201805115,
-0.227499321103096,
0.001958986511453986,
-0.2993207275867462,
-0.33481669425964355,
0.01828562468290329,
-0.22201921045780182,
-1.0348340272903442,
0.10828038305044174,
0.3512037992477417,
0.012939470820128918,
0.1981513500213623,
0.6112965941429138,
-0.18937420845031738,
-0.29639509320259094,
-0.00391807546839118,
-0.218182772397995,
-0.04190389811992645,
0.05318235233426094,
0.25456055998802185,
0.40131834149360657,
-0.39478033781051636,
-0.12482379376888275,
-0.8419040441513062,
0.5193317532539368,
0.981788158416748,
-0.42417919635772705,
0.8058177828788757,
0.3442149758338928,
-0.5072048902511597,
-0.351645290851593,
-0.09427408128976822,
-0.13949595391750336,
-0.44438931345939636,
0.23812320828437805,
-0.7775619626045227,
-0.5157473683357239,
0.7541482448577881,
0.41419538855552673,
0.15392659604549408,
0.8859819173812866,
0.8561736941337585,
-0.20739144086837769,
1.280255913734436,
0.5564552545547485,
-0.42035025358200073,
0.36100706458091736,
-0.2481018304824829,
0.1297534555196762,
-0.2991584241390228,
-0.4376674294471741,
-0.5582833290100098,
-0.5638940930366516,
-0.8289786577224731,
-0.021484375,
0.33839431405067444,
-0.40238770842552185,
-0.7562877535820007,
0.11249954998493195,
-0.42511147260665894,
0.5470629334449768,
0.852485179901123,
0.005982101429253817,
0.14559976756572723,
-0.27766063809394836,
0.5488252639770508,
0.7236167192459106,
-0.3657255470752716,
-0.4523179531097412,
0.6688597202301025,
0.683125376701355,
0.7903233170509338,
0.13453355431556702,
0.6028990745544434,
0.8985614776611328,
0.14981476962566376,
-0.9477860331535339,
0.9002820253372192,
0.3626704216003418,
-0.7244765162467957,
-0.7038324475288391,
-0.17275558412075043,
-1.0033711194992065,
-0.09280272573232651,
-0.18735750019550323,
-0.5202807784080505,
0.20870304107666016,
-0.5019080638885498,
-0.31237882375717163,
0.06077468395233154,
-0.2970711588859558,
0.7274137139320374,
-0.45219019055366516,
0.072353795170784,
-0.6970981955528259,
-0.7539891004562378,
-0.08076091855764389,
0.3060876429080963,
0.25963762402534485,
-0.3480876684188843,
-0.1708209216594696,
0.5637019872665405,
-0.42861348390579224,
0.6855951547622681,
-0.24407991766929626,
-0.2903353273868561,
0.5347740054130554,
-0.13459512591362,
0.2716381549835205,
-0.39807289838790894,
-0.09939282387495041,
-0.08535671979188919,
-0.08566606044769287,
-0.3141900897026062,
-0.639305055141449,
0.5697283744812012,
-1.5650769472122192,
-0.606037437915802,
-0.6194639205932617,
-0.7224364280700684,
0.1678401529788971,
0.4726826846599579,
-0.09128548204898834,
0.265755832195282,
0.032263174653053284,
0.01432320661842823,
0.20216988027095795,
-0.2330404818058014,
0.502730131149292,
0.6740301847457886,
-0.04414312541484833,
0.094594307243824,
1.109720230102539,
0.1000121608376503,
0.2609267830848694,
0.6131193041801453,
-0.04492020979523659,
-0.2503798305988312,
-0.6784316897392273,
0.027022184804081917,
-0.019634364172816277,
-0.8066686391830444,
-0.012269771657884121,
-0.30580469965934753,
-0.7159958481788635,
-0.583027184009552,
-0.14812889695167542,
-0.061695970594882965,
0.021964073181152344,
-0.42666298151016235,
-0.47794097661972046,
0.01112400833517313,
1.346738338470459,
-0.1254846751689911,
0.36754685640335083,
-0.24300915002822876,
0.43402427434921265,
0.2907787561416626,
0.1763514131307602,
-0.04879428446292877,
0.03668411076068878,
-0.3106669485569,
-0.08017009496688843,
-0.1802859753370285,
-0.8643732666969299,
0.24905303120613098,
0.2678043842315674,
0.9525192975997925,
0.6414485573768616,
0.020298564806580544,
0.3444667458534241,
-0.3175782263278961,
0.7149229645729065,
-0.2760331630706787,
-0.8061494827270508,
0.5009335279464722,
-0.17336173355579376,
-0.04364094138145447,
0.3877636790275574,
0.183661550283432,
-0.05429253727197647,
-0.6275308132171631,
-0.5220379829406738,
-0.6636589765548706,
0.6018998622894287,
0.16786180436611176,
0.04850458726286888,
0.24252623319625854,
0.4974766671657562,
-0.015585169196128845,
0.24179939925670624,
-1.0958589315414429,
-0.41303303837776184,
-0.18026411533355713,
-0.13250228762626648,
-0.251639187335968,
0.32820460200309753,
-0.011236492544412613,
-0.5041068196296692,
0.5981748104095459,
0.06818808615207672,
0.4783784747123718,
0.045000702142715454,
-0.0007248905603773892,
0.02344568632543087,
0.2502550780773163,
0.7738124132156372,
0.6074300408363342,
-0.03233470395207405,
0.09873449802398682,
-0.07954742759466171,
-0.06742152571678162,
0.6540582776069641,
-0.18963076174259186,
-0.1520502120256424,
-0.5975741744041443,
0.7145528197288513,
0.8486517071723938,
-0.7020477056503296,
-0.6566784381866455,
0.06784547865390778,
0.13127735257148743,
-0.04343506693840027,
-0.866810142993927,
0.6833736300468445,
-0.49576297402381897,
0.6715171337127686,
0.3904680609703064,
0.029963525012135506,
0.35636112093925476,
-1.171465516090393,
0.0986403375864029,
0.4904389977455139,
-0.4221517741680145,
-0.214190274477005,
0.5628852844238281,
0.47439977526664734,
-0.721448540687561,
0.6805068850517273,
-0.3562271296977997,
-0.18916335701942444,
1.1426427364349365,
0.21040396392345428,
0.967373251914978,
-0.09377095103263855,
0.24241258203983307,
0.06855064630508423,
0.5803715586662292,
0.15769065916538239,
0.20844615995883942,
0.10466060787439346,
-1.2117928266525269,
-0.07619427144527435,
-0.42097869515419006,
-0.29130011796951294,
0.2598114013671875,
-0.5162380337715149,
-0.135333850979805,
-0.831828236579895,
-0.05496018007397652,
0.28995242714881897,
0.14338892698287964,
-0.7746460437774658,
0.6726983189582825,
0.33771252632141113,
1.0638457536697388,
-0.47708532214164734,
0.7149222493171692,
1.006547212600708,
-0.8749902844429016,
-0.8312268257141113,
-0.006614846643060446,
0.07080955803394318,
-0.9464422464370728,
0.7166728973388672,
0.05017004534602165,
-0.15362946689128876,
0.1062723696231842,
-0.7650724649429321,
-0.7410141825675964,
1.2309073209762573,
-0.2684171497821808,
-0.04978535696864128,
-0.6960079669952393,
0.24238044023513794,
0.8996498584747314,
-0.9121165871620178,
0.46939194202423096,
0.6335148811340332,
0.7613511681556702,
-0.2670484781265259,
-0.8145968317985535,
-0.03699738159775734,
-0.5388067364692688,
-0.17871105670928955,
-0.18573486804962158,
-0.6819278001785278,
1.039082407951355,
-0.1640959233045578,
0.02580832876265049,
0.17618395388126373,
0.6703464984893799,
-0.030823899433016777,
0.42111754417419434,
0.6973676681518555,
0.19820624589920044,
0.4374726712703705,
-0.08655247837305069,
1.030513882637024,
-0.518473207950592,
-0.02099715545773506,
0.5999799370765686,
-0.4020860195159912,
0.43405288457870483,
0.011015491560101509,
-0.13450637459754944,
0.8337624073028564,
0.7225342988967896,
-0.002925741020590067,
0.3874343931674957,
0.0683605819940567,
-0.2991471290588379,
-0.2135670930147171,
-0.28442293405532837,
-0.1496010273694992,
0.8482409715652466,
0.5511220693588257,
-0.24707001447677612,
0.011692662723362446,
0.26922547817230225,
-0.26109281182289124,
-0.11929316818714142,
-0.9480730295181274,
1.359356164932251,
-0.2267121523618698,
-0.6531481146812439,
0.10159467905759811,
0.11196797341108322,
-0.013817214407026768,
-0.23578128218650818,
-0.19240766763687134,
-0.07445132732391357,
0.24401648342609406,
-0.32955342531204224,
-1.117927074432373,
0.05008210986852646,
-0.31061458587646484,
-0.33469051122665405,
-0.37271514534950256,
0.6999495625495911,
-0.05432198941707611,
-0.5168378353118896,
0.3311173915863037,
0.5470199584960938,
0.41797056794166565,
0.1470852792263031,
-0.9441443681716919,
-0.3794175386428833,
-0.11254847049713135,
-0.20775169134140015,
0.11197217553853989,
0.5423741340637207,
-0.1886710673570633,
0.9013780355453491,
0.09058179706335068,
-0.0217452272772789,
0.08088251203298569,
0.11504421383142471,
0.6503357291221619,
-0.9509781002998352,
-0.393217533826828,
-0.6297249794006348,
0.5795081853866577,
0.1093699112534523,
-0.11077334731817245,
0.5948053598403931,
0.2677425146102905,
0.5788769125938416,
0.10859271883964539,
1.1900445222854614,
-0.2450059950351715,
0.2943407893180847,
-0.3639998733997345,
0.5454103350639343,
-0.8088564872741699,
0.19999483227729797,
-0.149865984916687,
-0.8345435261726379,
-0.038780372589826584,
0.9072756767272949,
-0.19123706221580505,
0.5704408884048462,
0.21632587909698486,
0.594224214553833,
0.40797358751296997,
-0.38266193866729736,
0.45559218525886536,
0.6854868531227112,
0.5540279150009155,
0.4434130787849426,
1.0653131008148193,
0.05474265292286873,
-0.06284601986408234,
-0.06352312117815018,
-0.2679998278617859,
0.05491438880562782,
-0.055954091250896454,
-0.8768557906150818,
-0.4833064079284668,
-0.25919100642204285,
-0.2986825108528137,
-0.05665690079331398,
0.9014129638671875,
0.6183795928955078,
-0.7050763964653015,
-0.4822508692741394,
-0.43565917015075684,
0.5710228681564331,
-0.26951879262924194,
-0.3239159882068634,
-0.1102282777428627,
-0.47300809621810913,
-0.7247322201728821,
0.7355514764785767,
0.2096743881702423,
0.1295592486858368,
-0.8654901385307312,
-0.33899304270744324,
-0.1907276213169098,
0.37151479721069336,
0.7236089110374451,
0.3541187047958374,
-0.6979086399078369,
-0.5526737570762634,
-0.30747056007385254,
-0.3890148103237152,
-0.05176939070224762,
0.4078733026981354,
-0.6619125008583069,
-0.06767550110816956,
0.40117377042770386,
0.1522466540336609,
-0.2307608425617218,
-0.1298007369041443,
0.5918256044387817,
-0.17164160311222076,
0.16456599533557892,
0.3338916301727295,
0.12120033800601959,
-0.21695420145988464,
-0.3984127640724182,
0.4616878032684326,
0.07781355082988739,
-0.8010451197624207,
-0.44269657135009766,
0.511455237865448,
-0.9676066040992737,
-0.40246543288230896,
1.1635397672653198,
-0.0069823539815843105,
0.05535629019141197,
-0.10414517670869827,
-0.37845879793167114,
0.10750716924667358,
-0.6289136409759521,
0.5586236119270325,
0.4606676399707794,
-0.7442254424095154,
-0.7359678745269775,
-0.3642885088920593,
0.7599300146102905,
-0.14241817593574524,
-1.3429099321365356,
-0.6313290596008301,
0.6037408709526062,
-0.09547141939401627,
0.4045599699020386,
0.5495252013206482,
0.3738359212875366,
0.09040629863739014,
0.17641238868236542,
0.010067730210721493,
0.25332966446876526,
-0.8707197904586792,
-0.019760867580771446,
0.2682812213897705,
0.3389924168586731,
0.041273053735494614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04085v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04085v1
|
Don't Blame the Data, Blame the Model: Understanding Noise and Bias When Learning from Subjective Annotations
| 2024-03-06T22:30:04 | 2024-03-06T22:30:04 |
Abhishek Anand, Negar Mokhberian, Prathyusha Naresh Kumar, Anweasha Saha, Zihao He, Ashwin Rao, Fred Morstatter, Kristina Lerman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Researchers have raised awareness about the harms of aggregating labels
especially in subjective tasks that naturally contain disagreements among human
annotators. In this work we show that models that are only provided aggregated
labels show low confidence on high-disagreement data instances. While previous
studies consider such instances as mislabeled, we argue that the reason the
high-disagreement text instances have been hard-to-learn is that the
conventional aggregated models underperform in extracting useful signals from
subjective tasks. Inspired by recent studies demonstrating the effectiveness of
learning from raw annotations, we investigate classifying using Multiple Ground
Truth (Multi-GT) approaches. Our experiments show an improvement of confidence
for the high-disagreement instances.
|
[
-0.5541571974754333,
-0.7681242823600769,
0.654343843460083,
-0.06735727190971375,
-0.010825298726558685,
-0.10556366294622421,
-0.08044244349002838,
-0.6629083156585693,
-0.1963558942079544,
0.30570387840270996,
-0.3216749131679535,
-0.5929348468780518,
-1.059720516204834,
-0.12636061012744904,
-0.0011638677679002285,
1.4189424514770508,
0.2306286245584488,
0.16062131524085999,
-0.45685943961143494,
-0.3510664403438568,
-0.3425922989845276,
-0.9720025658607483,
-0.5439258813858032,
-0.4174932837486267,
0.9024428129196167,
0.6396293044090271,
0.647537350654602,
0.22673210501670837,
0.4156670570373535,
0.2730187773704529,
0.016767656430602074,
0.4677083492279053,
-0.2916747033596039,
0.12439126521348953,
-0.061105336993932724,
-0.458941251039505,
-0.5072900652885437,
0.431765615940094,
0.046690378338098526,
0.5955511927604675,
-0.011044003069400787,
0.214084193110466,
0.10026764869689941,
0.5007445812225342,
-0.7866179347038269,
0.41789567470550537,
-0.5689970254898071,
-0.004406437277793884,
-0.15666282176971436,
0.14422853291034698,
-0.6624385118484497,
-0.27159419655799866,
0.21120673418045044,
-0.7100690007209778,
0.471993625164032,
-0.07471156120300293,
0.9132979512214661,
0.542044997215271,
-0.5106719136238098,
-0.388519823551178,
-0.661526083946228,
1.0059821605682373,
-0.5167661309242249,
0.15204161405563354,
0.4871687889099121,
0.11553572118282318,
0.27688077092170715,
-0.33111080527305603,
-0.2561057507991791,
0.15073604881763458,
-0.20539504289627075,
0.17280638217926025,
-0.05820202827453613,
-0.052283190190792084,
0.4461054503917694,
0.21494774520397186,
-0.04316267743706703,
0.16983136534690857,
-0.3337356448173523,
-0.36350488662719727,
0.5207594037055969,
-0.1749141812324524,
0.1372939497232437,
0.023281605914235115,
-0.22389009594917297,
-0.12473759055137634,
-0.30864161252975464,
-0.09212490916252136,
0.26326560974121094,
0.4321077764034271,
-0.07002697139978409,
0.460063636302948,
0.03417434170842171,
0.8099009394645691,
0.304543137550354,
-0.33997437357902527,
0.5821519494056702,
0.08233815431594849,
-0.2835181951522827,
0.17922911047935486,
0.6973060965538025,
0.3380052149295807,
0.2088032364845276,
-0.42254963517189026,
-0.12848903238773346,
0.4320432245731354,
0.4452572762966156,
-0.43181148171424866,
-0.3744795024394989,
0.1703813374042511,
-0.34579163789749146,
-0.47734037041664124,
0.13022784888744354,
-0.8353322148323059,
-0.5038881301879883,
-0.7324782609939575,
0.6276994347572327,
-0.22038251161575317,
-0.17332570254802704,
-0.14945147931575775,
-0.09676450490951538,
-0.21329647302627563,
0.5630996227264404,
-0.5216093063354492,
0.11522272974252701,
0.5680435299873352,
0.9573390483856201,
0.09416733682155609,
-0.29097339510917664,
-0.46489882469177246,
0.06037617474794388,
-0.3862464129924774,
1.0491453409194946,
-0.2943633496761322,
-0.1547386646270752,
-0.29400983452796936,
-0.21162588894367218,
-0.012430544942617416,
-0.5419096350669861,
1.031408667564392,
-0.02311520092189312,
0.23111499845981598,
-0.6684761643409729,
-0.3924957811832428,
-0.31374451518058777,
0.21837954223155975,
-0.5626130104064941,
0.8802326917648315,
-0.030022824183106422,
-1.170026183128357,
0.7273544669151306,
-0.6444157361984253,
-0.48221880197525024,
-0.3952728807926178,
-0.2106664776802063,
-0.7536551356315613,
0.3261672556400299,
0.2718735337257385,
0.5760701298713684,
0.06373436748981476,
0.5515733361244202,
-0.5101391673088074,
-0.11624041944742203,
0.36089369654655457,
-0.38500985503196716,
0.6562843322753906,
0.20445576310157776,
-0.2523247003555298,
0.09875061362981796,
-0.737163245677948,
-0.2705096900463104,
-0.19509296119213104,
-0.2450169026851654,
-0.8053566217422485,
0.18227970600128174,
-0.16767318546772003,
0.37872636318206787,
-0.13947230577468872,
-0.533287525177002,
0.07463019341230392,
0.2581951320171356,
0.06088167801499367,
1.0392327308654785,
-0.28411030769348145,
0.37433820962905884,
-0.5337798595428467,
-0.17334546148777008,
0.6957413554191589,
0.16237545013427734,
0.25120818614959717,
-0.577427864074707,
-0.7707905769348145,
-0.03734072670340538,
0.32097893953323364,
0.06846648454666138,
-0.7201313972473145,
0.13888844847679138,
-0.24902138113975525,
-0.5947970151901245,
-0.28464779257774353,
0.005508325528353453,
0.2778153419494629,
1.034651279449463,
0.5101955533027649,
-0.31553560495376587,
-0.5498886108398438,
-0.8992930054664612,
-0.32218462228775024,
-0.4578726589679718,
0.14561741054058075,
0.49955400824546814,
0.38401347398757935,
-0.16137035191059113,
0.9106120467185974,
-0.5506777763366699,
-0.4539140462875366,
0.3457229733467102,
0.8784409761428833,
-0.09334072470664978,
0.5641488432884216,
0.6392531991004944,
-0.779780387878418,
-0.17855201661586761,
-0.24860242009162903,
-0.9819746017456055,
-0.2037925273180008,
0.1324562430381775,
-0.2237251102924347,
0.2128397524356842,
0.05287498980760574,
-0.4895176589488983,
0.27551478147506714,
0.3730800747871399,
-0.28205499053001404,
0.49441590905189514,
0.08760377019643784,
0.15473224222660065,
-0.6891196370124817,
-0.2898305356502533,
0.5619120597839355,
-0.05665494129061699,
-0.558532178401947,
-0.29389679431915283,
-0.20981676876544952,
0.3077138066291809,
-0.2503363788127899,
-0.04589510336518288,
-0.23684178292751312,
0.022711610421538353,
-0.3139054477214813,
-0.21931348741054535,
0.07154464721679688,
0.47778722643852234,
0.2806890904903412,
0.64870685338974,
0.660978376865387,
-0.960575520992279,
-0.08019714802503586,
0.30194389820098877,
-0.11623583734035492,
0.7647587060928345,
-0.3880331218242645,
0.3071213662624359,
-0.7009287476539612,
0.15191079676151276,
-0.8349190354347229,
-0.45479339361190796,
0.3755040168762207,
-0.61628258228302,
0.15704117715358734,
-0.355481892824173,
-0.13475723564624786,
-0.17699487507343292,
-0.008129425346851349,
0.27301526069641113,
0.2750067710876465,
-0.8098577857017517,
0.6787056922912598,
0.8881280422210693,
0.0011629536747932434,
-0.6929253339767456,
-0.9734084606170654,
-0.04868724197149277,
-0.4835107624530792,
-0.3304542303085327,
0.03479786589741707,
0.059368811547756195,
-0.5683548450469971,
-0.21185991168022156,
-0.273144006729126,
-0.44548532366752625,
0.04992383345961571,
0.6653836965560913,
0.053913719952106476,
-0.06517107784748077,
0.5559790134429932,
-0.3185364305973053,
-0.16683362424373627,
0.31577908992767334,
-0.20061804354190826,
0.15026208758354187,
-0.06738106161355972,
-0.2146630436182022,
-0.06157607585191727,
0.21738950908184052,
0.5361767411231995,
0.16565455496311188,
0.723138689994812,
0.6421563625335693,
-0.2773866355419159,
0.04888128861784935,
-0.6811438798904419,
-0.059130847454071045,
-0.3678987920284271,
0.15264642238616943,
-0.15580099821090698,
-0.6580224633216858,
0.3153054118156433,
-0.06418262422084808,
0.288931280374527,
0.5925409197807312,
0.34677550196647644,
-0.17721424996852875,
0.9992251396179199,
0.5126761198043823,
-0.3224117159843445,
0.25348424911499023,
0.05047524347901344,
-0.04934772104024887,
-0.49532583355903625,
-0.3761361539363861,
-0.8924553394317627,
-0.4158330261707306,
-0.4432505667209625,
-0.2082490473985672,
0.44218525290489197,
-0.14276093244552612,
-0.44613298773765564,
-0.24941954016685486,
-0.6956758499145508,
0.4413328766822815,
0.7248455286026001,
0.6183575987815857,
0.3613804578781128,
0.24102585017681122,
0.5220975279808044,
-0.3073378801345825,
-0.6018737554550171,
-0.3737339377403259,
1.2551920413970947,
0.23435431718826294,
0.8177768588066101,
0.10072486102581024,
0.7247234582901001,
0.17980816960334778,
0.6975063681602478,
-0.9123710989952087,
0.015479225665330887,
-0.3003804087638855,
-0.7645843029022217,
-0.04769337177276611,
-0.6944568753242493,
-0.563643753528595,
0.45556721091270447,
-0.21960610151290894,
-0.6844577193260193,
0.5595754981040955,
0.35058504343032837,
-0.2537316083908081,
0.4129200279712677,
-0.8404532670974731,
0.635557234287262,
-0.1199362576007843,
-0.39244213700294495,
0.22554156184196472,
-0.5227038860321045,
0.8281827569007874,
-0.04552876576781273,
0.7640491127967834,
-0.20725689828395844,
0.4228578805923462,
1.1876193284988403,
-0.2719612717628479,
1.142076849937439,
-0.4594154953956604,
-0.17762485146522522,
0.4243455231189728,
-0.2182753086090088,
0.37536779046058655,
0.015315481461584568,
0.06422238796949387,
0.4437645375728607,
-0.6080950498580933,
-0.4930308759212494,
-0.25067979097366333,
0.4909467399120331,
-0.990203857421875,
-0.34003475308418274,
-0.6048558950424194,
-0.33662721514701843,
-0.30636364221572876,
-0.12137610465288162,
0.559590220451355,
0.27151599526405334,
0.01327007357031107,
-0.05501953512430191,
0.8513601422309875,
0.11126819252967834,
0.43251869082450867,
0.17518313229084015,
-0.002288153860718012,
-0.2874985635280609,
0.933629035949707,
0.3951922059059143,
0.14683787524700165,
-0.30745598673820496,
0.16025157272815704,
0.030047519132494926,
-0.3025555908679962,
-0.2648392617702484,
-0.329779714345932,
-0.8041417002677917,
-0.40130308270454407,
-0.8573487401008606,
0.10228632390499115,
-0.31332308053970337,
0.09464886784553528,
-0.5119550824165344,
-0.3290002942085266,
-0.41910630464553833,
-0.4401084780693054,
0.25799456238746643,
0.8756428360939026,
-0.4269638657569885,
0.4661473035812378,
-0.7682817578315735,
0.3707999289035797,
0.47338181734085083,
0.11794987320899963,
0.08538474887609482,
-0.3609372079372406,
-0.4664687216281891,
0.1893877536058426,
-0.5577049851417542,
-0.944580078125,
0.2246602326631546,
0.01966715231537819,
0.4816659390926361,
0.3594718873500824,
0.11222022026777267,
0.6494229435920715,
-0.1016593798995018,
0.7359698414802551,
0.2556205987930298,
-1.0607062578201294,
0.4108204245567322,
-0.061837952584028244,
-0.11125122010707855,
0.6082080006599426,
0.4284055233001709,
-0.27060267329216003,
-0.27987876534461975,
-0.7932721376419067,
-0.7952812910079956,
0.715718686580658,
-0.1513805240392685,
-0.21028396487236023,
0.09110662341117859,
0.3515941798686981,
0.44679319858551025,
0.10774104297161102,
-1.0905874967575073,
-0.44387581944465637,
-0.4290026128292084,
-0.18034175038337708,
-0.3254862129688263,
-0.3908238708972931,
-0.3311116099357605,
-0.2880670130252838,
0.6488627195358276,
-0.31379199028015137,
0.23742757737636566,
0.34850603342056274,
-0.25435593724250793,
-0.22573037445545197,
0.3595982491970062,
0.3935551345348358,
0.5922262668609619,
-0.021526282653212547,
0.7017443180084229,
-0.10166437178850174,
-0.3732980489730835,
0.4467355012893677,
-0.0685063973069191,
-0.39323103427886963,
0.34306785464286804,
0.38442158699035645,
0.8797896504402161,
0.02984572947025299,
0.028033370152115822,
0.47144466638565063,
0.05015789717435837,
-0.4782763719558716,
-0.11402268707752228,
-0.11101904511451721,
-0.15855051577091217,
-0.11353179067373276,
0.30909714102745056,
0.6809355020523071,
0.3579638600349426,
-0.4789647161960602,
0.24169400334358215,
0.3184159994125366,
-0.6632806062698364,
-0.33168238401412964,
0.5205490589141846,
0.06495523452758789,
0.1891857534646988,
0.46748143434524536,
-0.03866107761859894,
-0.6622744798660278,
0.560722291469574,
0.20339269936084747,
0.5881908535957336,
-0.19003060460090637,
0.5581336617469788,
0.38018080592155457,
0.24943093955516815,
-0.49601060152053833,
-0.007868276908993721,
0.11101613193750381,
-1.048378348350525,
-0.6529813408851624,
-0.2771657705307007,
-0.5070840716362,
0.02909466251730919,
-0.8576709628105164,
-0.07938715070486069,
-0.33393633365631104,
-0.4937509000301361,
0.4210571050643921,
-0.2845807373523712,
-0.6200651526451111,
0.5985450744628906,
0.16932722926139832,
0.16916747391223907,
-1.3483901023864746,
0.5008424520492554,
0.660049319267273,
-0.5235755443572998,
-0.7805847525596619,
0.059004709124565125,
0.18837004899978638,
-0.3848334848880768,
0.8974429965019226,
0.2683784067630768,
0.12733221054077148,
-0.30826181173324585,
-1.1101466417312622,
-0.5603602528572083,
0.4925462603569031,
0.21524180471897125,
-0.4226517975330353,
0.19445699453353882,
-0.15855355560779572,
0.2800849676132202,
-0.23414729535579681,
0.3798615038394928,
0.27604690194129944,
0.8335641622543335,
0.02535293996334076,
-0.6344776153564453,
-0.2226373553276062,
0.15326467156410217,
-0.5971049070358276,
0.045951832085847855,
-0.7164331078529358,
1.4033234119415283,
-0.18320000171661377,
-0.02230808138847351,
-0.7698737978935242,
0.5693017840385437,
0.09136205911636353,
0.7532376646995544,
0.5941652655601501,
0.7406830191612244,
1.1248952150344849,
-0.47866925597190857,
0.834152102470398,
0.46193283796310425,
0.5419467687606812,
1.314436435699463,
-0.22646589577198029,
0.33291900157928467,
0.42683228850364685,
-0.21794220805168152,
0.4226705729961395,
0.6732515692710876,
0.040135812014341354,
0.49075546860694885,
0.09307146817445755,
-0.21201755106449127,
-0.5581222772598267,
-0.09229379892349243,
-0.30749544501304626,
0.28889885544776917,
0.4003203809261322,
-0.24713243544101715,
-0.2689054608345032,
-0.06912264227867126,
-0.08176882565021515,
-0.07273191213607788,
-0.5040907263755798,
1.1321642398834229,
0.07464823871850967,
-0.5174699425697327,
0.25318947434425354,
-0.2006845474243164,
0.9757626056671143,
0.16799817979335785,
0.05170644447207451,
0.03654933720827103,
0.08169855922460556,
-0.518930971622467,
-0.3849122226238251,
0.539039134979248,
-0.16805744171142578,
-0.49368953704833984,
0.01653176173567772,
0.7387497425079346,
-0.2651275396347046,
-0.6008909344673157,
0.1377478986978531,
0.6689030528068542,
0.2113807052373886,
-0.44165825843811035,
-0.4551031291484833,
0.019554274156689644,
0.056713469326496124,
-0.234434574842453,
0.41452255845069885,
0.5632389783859253,
0.06938554346561432,
0.3842387795448303,
0.5421612858772278,
-0.24022866785526276,
0.14495700597763062,
-0.08704941719770432,
0.8030133843421936,
-0.5925774574279785,
-0.13426698744297028,
-0.9999291300773621,
0.48469677567481995,
-0.3283144533634186,
-0.17098894715309143,
0.6280831694602966,
0.5579179525375366,
0.7839372754096985,
-0.15216666460037231,
1.1077662706375122,
0.0022824860643595457,
0.8236110806465149,
-0.5758848190307617,
0.4795977473258972,
-0.44746625423431396,
0.09844723343849182,
-0.25954219698905945,
-0.6754786372184753,
-0.4577891230583191,
0.8336679339408875,
-0.3498220145702362,
0.18858367204666138,
0.5233089327812195,
0.22720959782600403,
-0.10280358791351318,
0.3062995374202728,
0.17257092893123627,
0.41444942355155945,
0.2078002542257309,
0.6256253123283386,
0.903350293636322,
-0.39066174626350403,
0.2698175013065338,
-0.5346359610557556,
-0.2447357177734375,
0.06614391505718231,
-0.7015640735626221,
-0.8614003658294678,
-0.3206571638584137,
-0.7001673579216003,
-0.6047881841659546,
-0.07355654984712601,
0.6375440359115601,
0.9055550694465637,
-0.996987521648407,
0.1347951889038086,
-0.20036916434764862,
0.38487663865089417,
-0.05707486718893051,
-0.2864333391189575,
0.186018705368042,
-0.6498633027076721,
-0.8485249876976013,
0.021949751302599907,
-0.1310534030199051,
0.24267560243606567,
0.14779502153396606,
-0.07283059507608414,
-0.05719583109021187,
-0.254738450050354,
0.3743824362754822,
0.06274894624948502,
-0.5679957866668701,
-0.40523841977119446,
-0.5082389712333679,
-0.15764744579792023,
0.4719494581222534,
0.978458821773529,
-0.7429657578468323,
-0.0875086858868599,
0.22091582417488098,
0.3141903281211853,
0.31321021914482117,
0.34869518876075745,
0.2992081940174103,
-0.8928534984588623,
0.13710729777812958,
0.05454808473587036,
0.24144399166107178,
0.4521368741989136,
-0.6461109519004822,
0.6963388323783875,
0.33719387650489807,
-0.7911074757575989,
-0.7616371512413025,
0.10010737180709839,
-0.8317985534667969,
-0.5340374112129211,
0.9262807369232178,
-0.42674291133880615,
-0.17111736536026,
-0.4785309433937073,
-0.24255086481571198,
0.3877100646495819,
-0.5068510174751282,
0.9340681433677673,
1.0575910806655884,
-0.18972110748291016,
-0.1323844939470291,
-0.5011691451072693,
0.5026884078979492,
0.3413449823856354,
-0.7307985424995422,
0.2602589428424835,
1.030677318572998,
0.17779527604579926,
0.6139989495277405,
0.5271272659301758,
0.005363325588405132,
-0.13746382296085358,
0.09640856087207794,
0.2937326729297638,
-0.060963764786720276,
-0.43376052379608154,
-0.14911974966526031,
0.5329871773719788,
0.11449261754751205,
-0.1613750159740448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04080v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04080v1
|
Transformers and Language Models in Form Understanding: A Comprehensive Review of Scanned Document Analysis
| 2024-03-06T22:22:02 | 2024-03-06T22:22:02 |
Abdelrahman Abdallah, Daniel Eberharter, Zoe Pfister, Adam Jatowt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
This paper presents a comprehensive survey of research works on the topic of
form understanding in the context of scanned documents. We delve into recent
advancements and breakthroughs in the field, highlighting the significance of
language models and transformers in solving this challenging task. Our research
methodology involves an in-depth analysis of popular documents and forms of
understanding of trends over the last decade, enabling us to offer valuable
insights into the evolution of this domain. Focusing on cutting-edge models, we
showcase how transformers have propelled the field forward, revolutionizing
form-understanding techniques. Our exploration includes an extensive
examination of state-of-the-art language models designed to effectively tackle
the complexities of noisy scanned documents. Furthermore, we present an
overview of the latest and most relevant datasets, which serve as essential
benchmarks for evaluating the performance of selected models. By comparing and
contrasting the capabilities of these models, we aim to provide researchers and
practitioners with useful guidance in choosing the most suitable solutions for
their specific form understanding tasks.
|
[
-0.38717055320739746,
-0.7988776564598083,
0.6415672302246094,
0.11667624115943909,
-0.057261426001787186,
0.09167536348104477,
-0.017863662913441658,
-0.7327661514282227,
-0.2150377631187439,
0.586575984954834,
-0.7289906740188599,
-0.22038540244102478,
-0.9979341626167297,
0.07531202584505081,
-0.8731421828269958,
0.5056172013282776,
-0.2998170554637909,
0.3621983528137207,
-0.566638708114624,
0.016258301213383675,
-0.19350361824035645,
-0.4051712453365326,
-0.5235867500305176,
-0.3895653486251831,
-0.10893627256155014,
-0.0894467830657959,
0.7519869804382324,
0.24470064043998718,
0.7151055335998535,
0.3873615264892578,
-0.5079905986785889,
-0.08543597161769867,
-0.350941926240921,
0.6248140931129456,
0.027748100459575653,
-0.5959669351577759,
-0.31796807050704956,
0.13802187144756317,
0.7986446619033813,
0.927240252494812,
-0.04760800674557686,
-0.01446472853422165,
-0.18128976225852966,
0.38034573197364807,
-0.4200548231601715,
0.4693160951137543,
-0.5932291746139526,
0.07032670825719833,
-0.27295222878456116,
0.03216853365302086,
-0.6917815208435059,
-0.12742508947849274,
-0.1215943843126297,
-0.4865133464336395,
0.7306405901908875,
-0.3442500829696655,
1.0760953426361084,
0.13928531110286713,
-0.12169533222913742,
-0.5727101564407349,
-1.135878086090088,
0.5066193342208862,
-0.47165167331695557,
0.975846529006958,
0.4775310456752777,
0.6684491634368896,
-0.00108387041836977,
-1.0101048946380615,
-0.5611253380775452,
-0.1117936223745346,
0.013833044096827507,
0.3543434739112854,
-0.6336058378219604,
-0.011909081600606441,
0.2518429756164551,
0.7212207317352295,
-0.608370840549469,
0.26436835527420044,
-0.7481474280357361,
-0.2528529465198517,
0.48164013028144836,
0.19067814946174622,
0.57680743932724,
-0.15689636766910553,
0.04007792845368385,
-0.3948686718940735,
-0.11141449213027954,
0.13605628907680511,
0.3011229634284973,
0.09982167929410934,
-0.24482128024101257,
0.5275102257728577,
-0.1831526756286621,
0.8367568254470825,
-0.07181476056575775,
-0.0329260528087616,
-0.034620173275470734,
-0.4967659115791321,
-0.3649238049983978,
-0.33438268303871155,
0.562751293182373,
-0.1342935860157013,
0.04500735551118851,
-0.3567301034927368,
-0.41365107893943787,
-0.09422475844621658,
0.44349047541618347,
-0.6143592000007629,
0.2652287781238556,
-0.10321330279111862,
-0.8106175065040588,
-0.479584276676178,
0.1771983951330185,
-0.7229992747306824,
-0.6125935316085815,
-0.6221051216125488,
0.24677295982837677,
-0.37833791971206665,
-0.44065964221954346,
0.45946362614631653,
-0.24002999067306519,
0.7226462364196777,
0.6191303133964539,
-0.8669552803039551,
0.3206036686897278,
0.7414438128471375,
0.7819095253944397,
0.05290260910987854,
-0.01631595380604267,
-0.0666581466794014,
-0.1883469969034195,
-0.17516466975212097,
1.2889533042907715,
-0.7010142803192139,
-0.6395646929740906,
0.18057148158550262,
-0.02882460504770279,
-0.1752629280090332,
-0.44448500871658325,
0.8600848913192749,
-0.44809916615486145,
0.6712444424629211,
0.26540860533714294,
-0.20800122618675232,
-0.4241916239261627,
0.2192985862493515,
-1.0382150411605835,
1.1092714071273804,
0.5620205402374268,
-0.5509421229362488,
0.2874137759208679,
-0.4686293601989746,
-0.2785969078540802,
0.05569900572299957,
-0.20347543060779572,
-0.678581714630127,
0.5021430253982544,
0.1578730195760727,
0.5434526205062866,
-0.6134655475616455,
0.3534705340862274,
-0.09318674355745316,
-0.05215327441692352,
0.2089391052722931,
-0.5591192245483398,
0.966651976108551,
0.3006799817085266,
-0.06140299513936043,
0.19024218618869781,
-0.6260484457015991,
-0.48696544766426086,
0.2335529923439026,
0.05257556959986687,
-0.07183561474084854,
0.025830574333667755,
0.33198773860931396,
0.359540730714798,
0.12023556232452393,
-0.36507099866867065,
0.2713371217250824,
-0.45166081190109253,
0.4272134602069855,
0.30850568413734436,
-0.11848525702953339,
0.6690590381622314,
-0.3268471658229828,
1.0062273740768433,
-0.1139015406370163,
0.5020596981048584,
-0.21083560585975647,
-0.3418178856372833,
-0.46381932497024536,
-0.08277387917041779,
0.042806513607501984,
0.0466165766119957,
-0.26178836822509766,
0.11152283102273941,
-0.27169302105903625,
-0.9888198375701904,
-0.7264613509178162,
-0.20069710910320282,
-0.18009191751480103,
0.41397157311439514,
0.21640358865261078,
-0.26115682721138,
-0.6402759552001953,
-0.9322447776794434,
-0.2757621705532074,
-0.31013908982276917,
-0.03060194104909897,
0.14131084084510803,
0.1366519182920456,
-0.5480650067329407,
0.950206995010376,
-0.4695514142513275,
-0.12368791550397873,
-0.7211153507232666,
0.33183783292770386,
0.18984884023666382,
0.08431113511323929,
0.6072981357574463,
-1.002540111541748,
-0.14386799931526184,
-0.2911428213119507,
-0.5151760578155518,
-0.16379472613334656,
-0.45082777738571167,
-0.021872922778129578,
-0.013421393930912018,
0.7710873484611511,
-0.6930843591690063,
0.49927273392677307,
0.4638981819152832,
-0.4018884301185608,
0.46580007672309875,
0.00044904451351612806,
-0.014902806840837002,
-1.0264320373535156,
0.09939555823802948,
0.0844300389289856,
-0.1245766133069992,
-0.8714470863342285,
0.11259455233812332,
0.24100682139396667,
-0.5199822783470154,
-0.33453369140625,
0.395214319229126,
-0.7903912663459778,
-0.023953262716531754,
-0.06695876270532608,
-0.08018641173839569,
0.12064635008573532,
-0.04213031381368637,
0.07200907915830612,
0.8087485432624817,
0.6096839308738708,
-0.2323647141456604,
-0.07579714059829712,
0.4454554319381714,
-0.33480626344680786,
0.1712707132101059,
-0.5004900097846985,
0.026350688189268112,
-0.7638192772865295,
0.09950198978185654,
-1.2838231325149536,
-0.12846948206424713,
0.052450817078351974,
-0.6364343166351318,
0.7450848817825317,
-0.1012674942612648,
-0.355579137802124,
-0.35718706250190735,
-0.21513566374778748,
0.08305640518665314,
0.5236291289329529,
-0.11884278804063797,
1.2271618843078613,
0.5699906945228577,
-0.16961485147476196,
-0.23204371333122253,
-0.22702321410179138,
0.06603201478719711,
-0.01841336488723755,
-0.8817299008369446,
0.3268018662929535,
0.09236981719732285,
-0.41299960017204285,
-0.3139967918395996,
-0.498649924993515,
-0.5423071384429932,
0.40972843766212463,
0.33645719289779663,
0.2743998169898987,
-0.3426588177680969,
-0.07727231085300446,
0.01688307523727417,
-0.18663394451141357,
0.23787115514278412,
0.17068560421466827,
0.763763427734375,
0.1060413122177124,
-0.19796672463417053,
-0.3213293254375458,
0.3151037096977234,
1.202100396156311,
-0.5513179898262024,
0.7766981720924377,
0.6686067581176758,
-0.5332641005516052,
-0.13876590132713318,
-0.6434117555618286,
-0.05801788344979286,
-0.4535512626171112,
0.38650092482566833,
-0.60918128490448,
-0.5740995407104492,
0.6408129930496216,
-0.12690840661525726,
0.03362194448709488,
0.8982110619544983,
0.6499007344245911,
-0.14711609482765198,
0.8673194646835327,
1.0295641422271729,
0.1135353371500969,
0.7110369205474854,
-0.31926265358924866,
0.42774349451065063,
-0.6246994137763977,
-0.5922982096672058,
-1.1711976528167725,
0.2658150792121887,
-0.27103275060653687,
-0.37017324566841125,
0.14600440859794617,
0.16612060368061066,
0.36842086911201477,
0.41504326462745667,
-0.5985696911811829,
0.10487353801727295,
-0.05162258818745613,
-0.2103511393070221,
0.2624117136001587,
-0.05769139900803566,
0.14057157933712006,
0.1345241665840149,
-0.4762766659259796,
-0.6826977133750916,
0.7538753151893616,
0.573456346988678,
1.0007445812225342,
0.14994166791439056,
0.2225664258003235,
0.17957380414009094,
0.21710360050201416,
-1.056955337524414,
0.3241746127605438,
-0.09456934779882431,
-0.4733232855796814,
-0.3728004992008209,
0.09886205196380615,
-1.2914955615997314,
0.2833913266658783,
-0.11454567313194275,
-0.5170222520828247,
0.25276440382003784,
-0.4443926513195038,
-0.00929086934775114,
0.25696930289268494,
-0.5694422125816345,
0.724571943283081,
-0.11181429028511047,
0.12157411128282547,
-0.18941724300384521,
-0.3303682506084442,
0.41068097949028015,
-0.1549282968044281,
0.19497884809970856,
-0.04406367987394333,
0.12395212799310684,
0.888755202293396,
-0.019737564027309418,
0.778265118598938,
0.05320850387215614,
-0.34437209367752075,
0.14721393585205078,
0.2636963725090027,
0.11914849281311035,
-0.3076883554458618,
-0.36291560530662537,
0.21612931787967682,
0.2424280196428299,
-0.11725110560655594,
-0.8201175332069397,
0.09170713275671005,
-0.7758342027664185,
-0.3721155524253845,
-0.3366338312625885,
-0.3799789547920227,
-0.07289109379053116,
0.39334022998809814,
0.2840201258659363,
0.6061232089996338,
-0.2787713408470154,
0.14528639614582062,
0.6808119416236877,
-0.1245887279510498,
0.45667701959609985,
0.8061421513557434,
-0.0024466884788125753,
0.13789032399654388,
0.303921103477478,
0.17143593728542328,
0.047521352767944336,
0.5286328196525574,
0.024320540949702263,
-0.6878810524940491,
-0.6894594430923462,
-0.32256826758384705,
0.3974730372428894,
-0.82140052318573,
-0.11119633167982101,
-1.046841025352478,
-0.4044930338859558,
-0.8713265061378479,
-0.10041523724794388,
-0.31083351373672485,
-0.3809363543987274,
-0.25492963194847107,
-0.02659028023481369,
0.11048150062561035,
1.1761906147003174,
0.2818678617477417,
0.249324768781662,
-0.8072494268417358,
0.5710079669952393,
-0.06376964598894119,
0.6084235310554504,
0.1267949938774109,
-0.690221905708313,
-0.1364896297454834,
-0.3557156026363373,
-0.4787939190864563,
-1.2781192064285278,
0.3431081473827362,
-0.0917559489607811,
1.1524884700775146,
0.3423383831977844,
-0.27701324224472046,
0.44629424810409546,
-0.14541228115558624,
0.861491858959198,
-0.14078302681446075,
-0.9895489811897278,
0.601764976978302,
-0.3070184290409088,
0.28980857133865356,
0.5617914795875549,
0.42993950843811035,
-0.9192381501197815,
-0.31445255875587463,
-0.8950398564338684,
-0.7873113751411438,
0.76702880859375,
0.19453531503677368,
0.03637862950563431,
0.4896673560142517,
0.2591303586959839,
0.4019835591316223,
-0.037713635712862015,
-0.35673418641090393,
0.01833142153918743,
-0.06005748733878136,
-0.40830332040786743,
-0.052748508751392365,
-0.23599551618099213,
0.49757593870162964,
-0.19682539999485016,
0.5407126545906067,
0.1411912739276886,
0.5776893496513367,
0.05634988844394684,
-0.6242718696594238,
-0.021776897832751274,
0.24280287325382233,
0.8821752667427063,
0.6793156266212463,
-0.09227581322193146,
0.04943122714757919,
-0.08072897791862488,
-0.9507837295532227,
-0.004292658530175686,
0.23520509898662567,
-0.16073518991470337,
0.4140075147151947,
0.5714543461799622,
0.8307939767837524,
0.11397413909435272,
-0.40179428458213806,
0.5250617861747742,
-0.43181031942367554,
-0.19171816110610962,
-0.39927923679351807,
-0.042045678943395615,
-0.10574217140674591,
-0.3113538920879364,
0.24986912310123444,
0.31256943941116333,
0.2126101553440094,
-0.47816964983940125,
0.14810135960578918,
0.34939178824424744,
-0.6287577748298645,
-0.4597651958465576,
0.603728175163269,
0.03540913015604019,
-0.5103614926338196,
0.7903134226799011,
0.22305329144001007,
-0.5426833629608154,
0.7101196646690369,
0.5340620875358582,
1.203405499458313,
-0.185191348195076,
0.2491246461868286,
0.3242151737213135,
0.45611876249313354,
-0.10785247385501862,
0.16495387256145477,
-0.40033698081970215,
-0.8197659254074097,
-0.4448494017124176,
-0.7475895285606384,
-0.6068707704544067,
0.3824809193611145,
-0.7484263181686401,
0.33507606387138367,
-0.07783492654561996,
0.0695093497633934,
0.3026844561100006,
-0.16092492640018463,
-0.9497613310813904,
0.07157273590564728,
0.1618696004152298,
1.0987924337387085,
-1.07225501537323,
0.5926116704940796,
0.7435838580131531,
-0.9445357918739319,
-0.6919321417808533,
-0.02205415815114975,
-0.025998607277870178,
-0.8270724415779114,
0.5779247879981995,
0.12203244119882584,
-0.34100013971328735,
-0.09059615433216095,
-0.34729015827178955,
-1.016324520111084,
0.7929427027702332,
0.14281246066093445,
-0.2601833641529083,
-0.268873393535614,
0.25774624943733215,
0.5351514220237732,
0.03458232060074806,
0.9731165766716003,
0.6756827235221863,
0.5620085597038269,
-0.10922476649284363,
-0.9136161804199219,
-0.18612982332706451,
-0.453682541847229,
-0.023909416049718857,
0.30791395902633667,
-0.3678022623062134,
0.5775668621063232,
0.4549296498298645,
-0.5399905443191528,
0.0026527235750108957,
0.5774654746055603,
-0.13883934915065765,
0.16503915190696716,
0.36985304951667786,
0.23743633925914764,
0.6375531554222107,
-0.20007283985614777,
1.1149210929870605,
-0.18693244457244873,
0.29556065797805786,
0.6294394135475159,
0.010547768324613571,
0.4804280996322632,
0.38056737184524536,
-0.332980215549469,
0.3991895616054535,
0.5066065788269043,
-0.04339959844946861,
-0.10035649687051773,
0.179102823138237,
-0.07239239662885666,
-0.33224982023239136,
0.003921331372112036,
-0.27156689763069153,
0.8837565183639526,
0.4130219519138336,
-0.358446329832077,
-0.7304723262786865,
0.1551603227853775,
-0.30086129903793335,
0.212002694606781,
-0.18531246483325958,
0.9729541540145874,
-0.18967336416244507,
-0.5120434761047363,
0.3593481481075287,
0.0781303197145462,
0.5506336688995361,
-0.7254304885864258,
-0.042611654847860336,
-0.28587016463279724,
-0.13127444684505463,
-0.10258977115154266,
-1.0451679229736328,
0.6491559147834778,
0.0011548580368980765,
-0.5354363322257996,
-0.7743964195251465,
1.0974286794662476,
-0.08230800926685333,
-0.4764760732650757,
0.068020299077034,
0.6256504654884338,
0.34323856234550476,
-0.13926677405834198,
-0.6400426626205444,
0.36271312832832336,
-0.02069050818681717,
0.010728010907769203,
0.02111074887216091,
0.25460126996040344,
-0.25398048758506775,
0.6032199263572693,
0.4848771393299103,
-0.024950264021754265,
0.1039377972483635,
0.4538964331150055,
0.6565133929252625,
-0.5940499305725098,
-0.3800947368144989,
-0.4885117709636688,
0.7295133471488953,
-0.1079181432723999,
-0.273431658744812,
0.5383259057998657,
0.8015202879905701,
0.8342850804328918,
-0.3447057604789734,
0.6359097361564636,
0.1943313628435135,
0.49149107933044434,
-0.49948742985725403,
1.158964991569519,
-0.319663941860199,
-0.04471295326948166,
-0.14909712970256805,
-0.9156855344772339,
-0.5059633851051331,
0.6904613971710205,
-0.3098667562007904,
-0.09625975787639618,
0.4182184934616089,
0.8103089928627014,
-0.2881009578704834,
0.12839113175868988,
0.36684349179267883,
0.20898111164569855,
0.6474199891090393,
-0.009049119427800179,
1.0899511575698853,
-0.6492032408714294,
0.4020940959453583,
-0.05004042387008667,
0.03079025074839592,
-0.044822316616773605,
-0.43884095549583435,
-0.6340512037277222,
-1.088722586631775,
-0.21926851570606232,
-0.25200456380844116,
-0.4359515905380249,
0.4028289020061493,
0.6927201151847839,
-0.5678399205207825,
-0.1759566366672516,
-0.16397841274738312,
0.06473823636770248,
-0.03369520232081413,
-0.2348642498254776,
0.3422127664089203,
-0.4591626822948456,
-0.7494153380393982,
0.4566456377506256,
0.24114565551280975,
0.3648439049720764,
-0.41151827573776245,
0.28064122796058655,
0.11897701025009155,
0.2141410857439041,
0.6837229132652283,
0.1563483476638794,
-0.6564979553222656,
0.2360057532787323,
0.23200753331184387,
-0.4259289503097534,
0.21083912253379822,
1.1479482650756836,
-0.7189849019050598,
0.6021067500114441,
1.0450587272644043,
0.6823705434799194,
0.93133145570755,
-0.1991993486881256,
0.5847395062446594,
-0.09901383519172668,
0.08029965311288834,
0.42052900791168213,
0.4373595118522644,
0.3949327766895294,
-0.5150347352027893,
0.45430198311805725,
0.049732755869627,
-0.14633406698703766,
-0.8805451393127441,
0.2313482165336609,
-1.2474846839904785,
-0.5128858089447021,
0.8326923251152039,
0.5302160382270813,
-0.1962384432554245,
-0.3072090744972229,
-0.4148411452770233,
0.5548398494720459,
-0.012294331565499306,
0.740570604801178,
0.7328789830207825,
-0.15498359501361847,
-0.47160840034484863,
-0.4049732983112335,
0.3642466366291046,
0.39712047576904297,
-0.837630569934845,
-0.01388619001954794,
0.28114303946495056,
-0.005986861418932676,
0.09983506053686142,
0.5447052717208862,
-0.48381417989730835,
0.19297203421592712,
-0.02060036174952984,
0.07819464802742004,
-0.013601158745586872,
-0.16224151849746704,
-0.7503629922866821,
0.32900968194007874,
0.3393566608428955,
0.16608531773090363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04073v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04073v1
|
Semi-Supervised Dialogue Abstractive Summarization via High-Quality Pseudolabel Selection
| 2024-03-06T22:06:23 | 2024-03-06T22:06:23 |
Jianfeng He, Hang Su, Jason Cai, Igor Shalyminov, Hwanjun Song, Saab Mansour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Semi-supervised dialogue summarization (SSDS) leverages model-generated
summaries to reduce reliance on human-labeled data and improve the performance
of summarization models. While addressing label noise, previous works on
semi-supervised learning primarily focus on natural language understanding
tasks, assuming each sample has a unique label. However, these methods are not
directly applicable to SSDS, as it is a generative task, and each dialogue can
be summarized in different ways. In this work, we propose a novel scoring
approach, SiCF, which encapsulates three primary dimensions of summarization
model quality: Semantic invariance (indicative of model confidence), Coverage
(factual recall), and Faithfulness (factual precision). Using the SiCF score,
we select unlabeled dialogues with high-quality generated summaries to train
summarization models. Comprehensive experiments on three public datasets
demonstrate the effectiveness of SiCF scores in uncertainty estimation and
semi-supervised learning for dialogue summarization tasks. Our code is
available at \url{https://github.com/amazon-science/summarization-sicf-score}.
|
[
-0.33026427030563354,
-0.7157277464866638,
0.6020545959472656,
0.14508984982967377,
-0.6008952856063843,
0.42191192507743835,
0.047154203057289124,
-0.34537655115127563,
0.2517601549625397,
0.4784996509552002,
-0.29166069626808167,
-0.9826471209526062,
-0.3181624412536621,
0.07331150025129318,
-0.26634833216667175,
1.4230461120605469,
0.17232438921928406,
0.12771576642990112,
-0.5734461545944214,
-0.20958811044692993,
0.08651023358106613,
-0.4369312524795532,
-0.4073672592639923,
-0.1048109382390976,
0.23782701790332794,
0.3713493049144745,
0.5049795508384705,
0.29794010519981384,
0.330186128616333,
0.23680123686790466,
-0.36512407660484314,
0.23621603846549988,
-0.5166507959365845,
0.10877180099487305,
0.016296369954943657,
-0.38559165596961975,
-0.42796629667282104,
0.04311906918883324,
0.8117618560791016,
0.8766988515853882,
-0.24902188777923584,
0.2233952283859253,
0.19355043768882751,
0.3882528841495514,
-0.29946741461753845,
0.49261927604675293,
-0.21231164038181305,
0.13060569763183594,
0.11629212647676468,
-0.2112293392419815,
-0.4898129105567932,
-0.6945896744728088,
0.329470694065094,
-0.5308305621147156,
0.3805592954158783,
0.18314151465892792,
0.9263020157814026,
0.3042156398296356,
-0.3374502658843994,
-0.06439819931983948,
-0.8319178223609924,
0.9024309515953064,
-0.7722821831703186,
-0.19991575181484222,
0.3907313644886017,
0.17851746082305908,
-0.055720254778862,
-0.5985966920852661,
-0.15874437987804413,
0.044672172516584396,
-0.04042733833193779,
0.6284050941467285,
-0.1348080337047577,
0.3614688515663147,
0.09233871847391129,
0.66811203956604,
-0.45038020610809326,
0.075515016913414,
-0.5720049738883972,
-0.6678098440170288,
0.593923032283783,
0.18398244678974152,
-0.0676325187087059,
-0.1720082014799118,
-0.4152221083641052,
0.003277687355875969,
-0.4754766523838043,
0.26010990142822266,
0.43897566199302673,
0.4053577184677124,
-0.23410171270370483,
0.5872833728790283,
-0.28236278891563416,
0.7911691665649414,
-0.016852159053087234,
-0.3923557698726654,
0.14554144442081451,
-0.6332076787948608,
-0.15109841525554657,
0.39274537563323975,
0.9167459607124329,
0.6577897667884827,
-0.0074957795441150665,
-0.08829594403505325,
-0.17052675783634186,
-0.18893559277057648,
0.19527439773082733,
-0.7876084446907043,
-0.38884419202804565,
0.062494907528162,
-0.5360040068626404,
-0.5931152105331421,
-0.04335808753967285,
-0.7255785465240479,
-0.02653759904205799,
-0.24886630475521088,
0.326061874628067,
-0.2034323811531067,
0.04931937903165817,
-0.1666504293680191,
-0.23559585213661194,
-0.12406090646982193,
0.3068990409374237,
-0.3909839689731598,
0.3016783595085144,
0.100460484623909,
0.9205666780471802,
-0.16547830402851105,
0.06861943751573563,
-0.4923957288265228,
0.2136044055223465,
-0.6239942312240601,
0.9301981925964355,
-0.5716722011566162,
-0.8003734350204468,
-0.21363677084445953,
-0.32507312297821045,
0.11384264379739761,
-0.46245959401130676,
0.601168692111969,
-0.28665629029273987,
0.5435514450073242,
-0.15030604600906372,
-0.7067815065383911,
-0.31789731979370117,
-0.00130029849242419,
-0.4630785882472992,
1.259617805480957,
0.3361053168773651,
-0.7903911471366882,
0.39072278141975403,
-0.37684786319732666,
-0.6582790017127991,
-0.07973966747522354,
-0.010896478779613972,
-0.6428509950637817,
0.2597055733203888,
0.15676721930503845,
0.6422479152679443,
-0.15795426070690155,
0.3665453791618347,
-0.23078259825706482,
-0.38692688941955566,
0.09529747068881989,
-0.4084528684616089,
0.4589516818523407,
0.2087240368127823,
0.12598103284835815,
0.1369199901819229,
-0.7988160848617554,
0.007341886404901743,
-0.20108458399772644,
-0.2560705542564392,
-0.2025046944618225,
-0.00659826910123229,
-0.1542651504278183,
0.10848493874073029,
0.10997976362705231,
-0.45028698444366455,
-0.37122005224227905,
-0.5157209038734436,
-0.011357518844306469,
0.7002450227737427,
0.6175690293312073,
0.40179890394210815,
-0.31702563166618347,
0.48131030797958374,
0.1684088110923767,
0.06516149640083313,
-0.2353423535823822,
-0.47908133268356323,
-0.4867825210094452,
-0.6714295744895935,
0.5985164046287537,
0.3548775613307953,
-0.8573079705238342,
0.6830676794052124,
-0.09310885518789291,
-0.6580966114997864,
-0.435421347618103,
0.2274831235408783,
0.7198695540428162,
0.6507867574691772,
0.39879414439201355,
-0.44429346919059753,
-0.15527355670928955,
-0.8488360047340393,
0.03361298143863678,
-0.5816333293914795,
-0.17738212645053864,
0.19095563888549805,
0.22472181916236877,
0.3066677749156952,
1.2806169986724854,
-0.7058849334716797,
-0.5106313228607178,
-0.5294591188430786,
0.7384203672409058,
-0.013109449297189713,
0.2690085172653198,
0.4795457422733307,
-0.6431494355201721,
-0.34353139996528625,
-0.36067020893096924,
-0.7278934121131897,
-0.1257634162902832,
-0.2226215898990631,
-0.11847617477178574,
0.06007714197039604,
0.4354896545410156,
-0.561866044998169,
0.49893805384635925,
0.2683488726615906,
0.1531708985567093,
0.5263803005218506,
-0.4507286548614502,
0.15418073534965515,
-1.3436042070388794,
-0.2319282740354538,
0.37434354424476624,
-0.475774884223938,
-0.38869959115982056,
-0.5954611897468567,
-0.25380975008010864,
-0.029148682951927185,
-0.40032193064689636,
0.04003135859966278,
-0.3889751434326172,
-0.35750913619995117,
-0.16034479439258575,
0.1365721970796585,
0.06782752275466919,
0.6343243718147278,
0.34044066071510315,
0.9110197424888611,
0.3437938094139099,
-0.7943507432937622,
0.19868898391723633,
0.21419782936573029,
-0.5566334128379822,
0.5781558156013489,
-0.8638177514076233,
-0.10366952419281006,
-0.18754738569259644,
0.5847985148429871,
-1.2161865234375,
-0.23614805936813354,
-0.00867291260510683,
-0.5280013680458069,
0.3550252914428711,
-0.16706107556819916,
-0.36522024869918823,
0.02199036069214344,
-0.3449891209602356,
0.22893767058849335,
0.42812326550483704,
-0.3021872639656067,
0.5449754595756531,
0.8022825121879578,
-0.48357367515563965,
-0.21053694188594818,
-0.3649425506591797,
0.06749454140663147,
-0.12037158012390137,
-0.12143257260322571,
0.36212772130966187,
0.009285295382142067,
-0.07295870780944824,
-0.07243017852306366,
-0.46091073751449585,
0.18571273982524872,
0.030552871525287628,
0.14254328608512878,
0.4834522306919098,
-0.05551343783736229,
0.040847212076187134,
0.5029664039611816,
-0.39687442779541016,
0.12179901450872421,
-0.21782812476158142,
0.036919523030519485,
-0.062444064766168594,
-0.29215314984321594,
-0.4631565809249878,
0.35910138487815857,
0.4339355230331421,
-0.2414037436246872,
0.7854272723197937,
0.4028748869895935,
-0.25627559423446655,
-0.2849431037902832,
-0.17069891095161438,
-0.16491402685642242,
-0.33444374799728394,
0.45590078830718994,
-0.16058655083179474,
-0.9173917770385742,
0.38011616468429565,
-0.24969333410263062,
0.13321669399738312,
0.44529902935028076,
0.47572654485702515,
-0.6495233178138733,
1.1787474155426025,
0.4814184904098511,
-0.19336290657520294,
0.24467355012893677,
-0.1402774453163147,
0.6628332138061523,
-0.570857048034668,
-0.24977117776870728,
-0.5809241533279419,
-0.012737090699374676,
-0.4813714325428009,
-0.42260220646858215,
0.6909504532814026,
0.049326084554195404,
0.37124550342559814,
0.2374880313873291,
-0.4378483295440674,
0.6166942715644836,
0.5409700274467468,
0.004470989108085632,
0.367301344871521,
-0.07895422726869583,
-0.2456829845905304,
-0.005809424445033073,
-0.6084598898887634,
-0.7820267081260681,
0.8923479318618774,
0.2675061821937561,
0.7411536574363708,
0.12181460112333298,
0.7509539723396301,
0.7291040420532227,
-0.09960956871509552,
-0.5615015029907227,
0.7039816975593567,
0.09057380259037018,
-0.42676427960395813,
-0.4845955967903137,
-0.7306013107299805,
-0.5517988204956055,
0.16983632743358612,
-0.14654019474983215,
-0.8612346053123474,
-0.04092053696513176,
0.20623797178268433,
-0.6352346539497375,
0.025289732962846756,
-0.9335492253303528,
0.7398438453674316,
0.05758243054151535,
-0.05250364914536476,
-0.22386500239372253,
-0.9679633378982544,
0.3714506924152374,
0.03126125782728195,
0.1348193734884262,
-0.26786789298057556,
0.36753901839256287,
0.9314177632331848,
-0.2246539145708084,
1.0970379114151,
-0.24057307839393616,
0.06171628460288048,
0.42539462447166443,
0.020395301282405853,
0.3548549711704254,
0.20931795239448547,
0.23010408878326416,
0.057345934212207794,
0.24733367562294006,
-0.522106409072876,
-0.538135826587677,
0.4115919768810272,
-0.6177685856819153,
-0.3022595942020416,
-0.6801274418830872,
-0.323172926902771,
-0.3653450608253479,
-0.04874594882130623,
0.4259140193462372,
0.7199609875679016,
-0.513175904750824,
0.14096765220165253,
1.0574952363967896,
-0.2279999554157257,
0.2981956899166107,
0.2522314786911011,
0.06568099558353424,
-0.1429823338985443,
1.1562639474868774,
0.048992399126291275,
0.590923547744751,
0.43743792176246643,
-0.02802385948598385,
-0.6156144738197327,
-0.6282446384429932,
-0.4546280801296234,
0.023555899038910866,
-0.6955475211143494,
-0.3374239206314087,
-0.6565185785293579,
-0.35775551199913025,
-0.3003045618534088,
0.09127987176179886,
-0.4147551953792572,
-0.6061763167381287,
-0.4921865165233612,
-0.5826907753944397,
0.12052646279335022,
0.5592208504676819,
0.15343999862670898,
0.1401485800743103,
-0.8353315591812134,
0.6065666079521179,
0.020373748615384102,
0.24278248846530914,
-0.44215819239616394,
-0.723891019821167,
-0.31244364380836487,
0.060616765171289444,
-0.20363186299800873,
-0.7189160585403442,
0.17198143899440765,
0.21685250103473663,
0.6546384692192078,
0.41639840602874756,
0.6933505535125732,
0.47294336557388306,
0.013822918757796288,
0.9111914038658142,
0.3622073233127594,
-0.6989450454711914,
0.6333166360855103,
-0.12174756824970245,
0.43951064348220825,
0.7865331172943115,
0.3733685612678528,
-0.08579208701848984,
-0.9159606099128723,
-0.6333068609237671,
-0.6108296513557434,
0.8736216425895691,
0.33612868189811707,
0.09410885721445084,
0.11235544085502625,
-0.09713373333215714,
0.17854911088943481,
0.15005967020988464,
-0.2693154811859131,
-0.29252704977989197,
-0.226394385099411,
-0.6672800183296204,
-0.3163176476955414,
-0.3883945345878601,
-0.20963388681411743,
-0.1395406574010849,
0.9532663822174072,
-0.29760482907295227,
0.28266051411628723,
0.11529545485973358,
-0.24484960734844208,
0.1407240331172943,
0.2726432681083679,
0.5759063959121704,
0.4444640278816223,
-0.4074062407016754,
0.08403747528791428,
0.17671476304531097,
-0.3335082232952118,
0.10094236582517624,
0.1020151898264885,
-0.239075168967247,
0.2785581052303314,
0.35417670011520386,
0.739545464515686,
0.34996891021728516,
-0.5284580588340759,
0.5659885406494141,
-0.34327274560928345,
-0.2561124265193939,
-0.2142331600189209,
0.2932823598384857,
-0.0941547378897667,
0.005991007667034864,
0.2142031043767929,
0.403852641582489,
0.4014756381511688,
-0.517170250415802,
0.07180631160736084,
0.0778215155005455,
-0.7172827124595642,
-0.25671690702438354,
0.37519171833992004,
0.3021382689476013,
-0.09295673668384552,
0.3733846843242645,
-0.45207032561302185,
-0.37380826473236084,
0.22706101834774017,
0.28341710567474365,
0.6423053741455078,
-0.09019797295331955,
0.7678685784339905,
0.44170352816581726,
0.06564287841320038,
-0.12221245467662811,
-0.14709214866161346,
-0.6483172178268433,
-0.623443603515625,
-0.4125640094280243,
-0.6966167688369751,
-0.8057089447975159,
-0.4258776605129242,
-1.0443788766860962,
-0.08475903421640396,
-0.33727818727493286,
-0.2665541470050812,
0.14769570529460907,
-0.15384697914123535,
0.09733376652002335,
0.4366481304168701,
-0.12594221532344818,
0.4638606905937195,
-1.0064661502838135,
0.5114499926567078,
0.5247135758399963,
-0.3850069046020508,
-0.5937177538871765,
0.04670485854148865,
0.10698715597391129,
-0.11371494084596634,
-0.16566453874111176,
-0.08574347198009491,
-0.41446930170059204,
0.007024751510471106,
-0.37765389680862427,
-0.5612981915473938,
0.8522540330886841,
0.38067391514778137,
-0.1663353592157364,
0.08464311063289642,
0.050215404480695724,
0.6749966144561768,
-0.19054661691188812,
0.6114782094955444,
0.7950679659843445,
0.0859624594449997,
0.48345616459846497,
-0.5481316447257996,
-0.2996302545070648,
-0.3603619933128357,
0.1084156334400177,
0.09941614419221878,
-0.5029086470603943,
-0.08730929344892502,
-0.32503315806388855,
-0.2430173009634018,
0.08474794030189514,
1.0602372884750366,
0.2982576787471771,
0.49269238114356995,
0.40616607666015625,
0.3119184672832489,
0.8690745830535889,
-0.4614070951938629,
1.0048229694366455,
-0.03196355700492859,
0.2433113008737564,
1.3061391115188599,
-0.2894061505794525,
0.4600869417190552,
0.2939891219139099,
-0.25582507252693176,
0.16406065225601196,
0.9236923456192017,
0.09822163730859756,
0.7956041097640991,
0.12195485085248947,
-0.49121740460395813,
-0.46451181173324585,
-0.3156884014606476,
-0.06609492748975754,
0.5119277238845825,
0.2859087884426117,
-0.2335205376148224,
-0.3050808310508728,
0.03923564404249191,
-0.14351481199264526,
0.2725536823272705,
0.0716075748205185,
1.2639216184616089,
0.11603094637393951,
-0.7491540312767029,
0.178994819521904,
0.07107217609882355,
0.1788359135389328,
-0.48080724477767944,
-0.11568864434957504,
-0.22703608870506287,
-0.028983203694224358,
-0.08469460904598236,
-0.9528883695602417,
0.2598641812801361,
0.20771409571170807,
-0.23520421981811523,
-0.32827144861221313,
0.38334721326828003,
-0.4752264618873596,
-0.7429987788200378,
0.062393832951784134,
0.19927646219730377,
0.40413981676101685,
0.12321780622005463,
-0.3934423327445984,
-0.18715475499629974,
0.11964856088161469,
-0.04959966242313385,
0.40147143602371216,
0.37417885661125183,
-0.092076376080513,
0.4355747103691101,
0.6247012615203857,
-0.04964761808514595,
-0.2674931585788727,
0.47839784622192383,
0.7230532169342041,
-0.44701889157295227,
-0.669596254825592,
-0.4307861030101776,
0.4313563108444214,
-0.39404019713401794,
-0.49697747826576233,
0.6478246450424194,
0.8569055199623108,
0.7706587314605713,
0.1438336968421936,
0.7644897103309631,
0.22343279421329498,
0.8499643206596375,
-0.7022427320480347,
0.5178670883178711,
-0.28233203291893005,
0.2981167435646057,
-0.5714247226715088,
-1.059273600578308,
-0.3423807919025421,
0.640193521976471,
-0.2074246108531952,
0.1614103615283966,
0.5900861620903015,
0.978161096572876,
0.1322835087776184,
0.5011911392211914,
0.44454941153526306,
0.13511715829372406,
0.30073443055152893,
0.18528199195861816,
0.9969061017036438,
-0.18975238502025604,
0.5422232747077942,
-0.2759004533290863,
-0.2707838714122772,
-0.08950195461511612,
-0.6267597675323486,
-1.0686527490615845,
-0.7281039357185364,
-0.6357038021087646,
-0.17874164879322052,
-0.14889749884605408,
0.749194324016571,
0.7340072989463806,
-0.900700032711029,
0.02493247203528881,
0.08375569432973862,
0.21997980773448944,
-0.1936458945274353,
-0.23807455599308014,
0.33256107568740845,
-0.28023964166641235,
-0.691897451877594,
0.32204362750053406,
0.5317334532737732,
0.2597411870956421,
0.1227213442325592,
-0.1510782688856125,
-0.013128064572811127,
0.08019479364156723,
0.3505118787288666,
0.04194198548793793,
-0.5143396258354187,
-0.08498580753803253,
-0.3629065454006195,
-0.2107304483652115,
0.007848979905247688,
0.589239776134491,
-0.5781354904174805,
0.5104711055755615,
0.24458065629005432,
0.4155466556549072,
0.9100986123085022,
0.36362597346305847,
0.6786084175109863,
-0.8902124166488647,
-0.15482527017593384,
0.3605120778083801,
0.14313830435276031,
0.34501972794532776,
-0.3391275107860565,
0.1904192715883255,
0.12112382799386978,
-0.19332723319530487,
-0.8414890766143799,
-0.17226040363311768,
-1.0893981456756592,
-0.16394680738449097,
0.7701388597488403,
-0.33796343207359314,
-0.11584833264350891,
-0.4360167980194092,
-0.3185373544692993,
0.396950900554657,
-0.5037528872489929,
0.8356657028198242,
0.7097582221031189,
0.01039397343993187,
-0.13128210604190826,
-0.26525574922561646,
0.5433775186538696,
0.42507612705230713,
-0.8181270956993103,
-0.0728379413485527,
0.647525429725647,
-0.06818118691444397,
0.1298978328704834,
0.640376091003418,
-0.2594655454158783,
0.4253331422805786,
-0.18093955516815186,
-0.07544504851102829,
-0.06379431486129761,
-0.5143535137176514,
-0.07183180004358292,
0.19464971125125885,
-0.09119651466608047,
-0.2680530250072479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04811v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04811v1
|
Quantifying Contamination in Evaluating Code Generation Capabilities of Language Models
| 2024-03-06T21:45:35 | 2024-03-06T21:45:35 |
Martin Riddell, Ansong Ni, Arman Cohan
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While large language models have achieved remarkable performance on various
code generation benchmarks, there have been growing concerns regarding
potential contamination of these benchmarks as they may be leaked into
pretraining and finetuning data. While recent work has investigated
contamination in natural language generation and understanding tasks, there has
been less extensive research into how data contamination impacts the evaluation
of code generation, which is critical for understanding the robustness and
reliability of LLMs in programming contexts. In this work, we perform a
comprehensive study of data contamination of popular code generation
benchmarks, and precisely quantify their overlap with pretraining corpus
through both surface-level and semantic-level matching. In our experiments, we
show that there are substantial overlap between popular code generation
benchmarks and open training corpus, and models perform significantly better on
the subset of the benchmarks where similar solutions are seen during training.
We also conduct extensive analysis on the factors that affects model
memorization and generalization, such as model size, problem difficulty, and
question length. We release all resulting files from our matching pipeline for
future research.
|
[
-0.49901577830314636,
-0.6647325158119202,
0.5928748846054077,
0.05510188639163971,
-0.0026544586289674044,
0.09761206060647964,
-0.07509586960077286,
-0.7605603337287903,
-0.6175993084907532,
0.8724029064178467,
-0.20707376301288605,
-0.510637640953064,
-0.7206896543502808,
-0.05785468965768814,
-0.7455016374588013,
0.9276766777038574,
-0.24003104865550995,
-0.20712147653102875,
-0.7866525650024414,
0.03482355177402496,
-0.4289136826992035,
-0.6412070393562317,
-0.2104586958885193,
-0.06418677419424057,
0.0956876203417778,
0.2466096431016922,
0.5126781463623047,
0.8926262855529785,
0.7399768233299255,
0.38770365715026855,
-0.22291311621665955,
-0.018268540501594543,
-0.6980142593383789,
0.08186564594507217,
-0.255941778421402,
-0.5071232318878174,
-0.18184833228588104,
-0.11920974403619766,
0.439596563577652,
0.7362236380577087,
0.09067559987306595,
0.29262885451316833,
0.35368481278419495,
0.561794102191925,
-0.923754870891571,
-0.024583270773291588,
-0.8434510827064514,
-0.09118735790252686,
-0.31557297706604004,
-0.24955686926841736,
-0.2617312967777252,
-0.37856075167655945,
-0.035443056374788284,
-0.6147595047950745,
0.3446061909198761,
-0.24241863191127777,
0.9770395159721375,
0.49129214882850647,
-0.27020877599716187,
-0.3838569223880768,
-0.8462122082710266,
0.9080232977867126,
-0.89930659532547,
0.029839498922228813,
0.5907005667686462,
0.07833613455295563,
-0.1895296722650528,
-0.8065222501754761,
-0.3631696403026581,
-0.2359878271818161,
-0.020032132044434547,
-0.2560610771179199,
-0.3164502680301666,
0.06398450583219528,
0.537100613117218,
0.5454837679862976,
-0.5289214849472046,
0.14813537895679474,
-0.39522844552993774,
-0.3148671090602875,
0.5326229929924011,
0.14585137367248535,
0.6979022026062012,
-0.15597672760486603,
-0.47064074873924255,
-0.17363280057907104,
-1.0440260171890259,
-0.07097376883029938,
0.6256551742553711,
0.1559849977493286,
-0.02589588239789009,
0.4755726754665375,
-0.13715426623821259,
1.026593804359436,
-0.5257867574691772,
0.12491393834352493,
0.1456783413887024,
-0.9744262099266052,
-0.3278017044067383,
-0.28080275654792786,
0.6971501111984253,
0.28969380259513855,
0.5993914008140564,
-0.21758557856082916,
-0.03830660507082939,
-0.03402549400925636,
0.4799879193305969,
-0.8652846217155457,
-0.15520459413528442,
0.2226254642009735,
-0.14899204671382904,
-0.39876577258110046,
0.06529112160205841,
-0.4744776487350464,
-0.30460125207901,
-0.4234904646873474,
0.402010053396225,
-0.3872717022895813,
-0.2928479313850403,
0.13862214982509613,
-0.025874454528093338,
0.028196359053254128,
-0.05671333521604538,
-0.8305877447128296,
0.03502676263451576,
1.0063199996948242,
0.548971951007843,
-0.1108085885643959,
-0.2223227620124817,
-0.4605497717857361,
-0.019823191687464714,
-0.3139377534389496,
0.6505512595176697,
-0.4461328387260437,
-0.45692071318626404,
0.05438685044646263,
-0.3905490040779114,
-0.1625223308801651,
-1.0409828424453735,
0.4066563844680786,
-0.44832396507263184,
0.049818139523267746,
-0.015114584006369114,
-0.8855274319648743,
0.039596449583768845,
-0.015660321339964867,
-0.716985285282135,
1.0957008600234985,
0.2687437832355499,
-0.9961793422698975,
0.4980691373348236,
-0.13203971087932587,
-0.29417741298675537,
0.1429113894701004,
-0.3576483130455017,
-0.41099512577056885,
0.07739686220884323,
-0.0009676660993136466,
0.3633796274662018,
-0.1961110681295395,
0.2989930510520935,
-0.46756649017333984,
-0.4981473982334137,
0.27298596501350403,
-0.21365384757518768,
0.690808117389679,
0.44515261054039,
-0.31824013590812683,
0.14973975718021393,
-0.9664864540100098,
0.39795321226119995,
-0.10932638496160507,
-0.2294672131538391,
-0.5469892024993896,
-0.29783931374549866,
-0.08567933738231659,
0.37611791491508484,
0.23555636405944824,
-0.3835998773574829,
-0.138203963637352,
-0.09634998440742493,
0.4731306731700897,
0.6041692495346069,
0.4047437310218811,
0.26316800713539124,
-0.49106326699256897,
0.5264400243759155,
0.22964292764663696,
0.09813497215509415,
-0.27111539244651794,
-0.29964613914489746,
-0.6010848879814148,
-0.14276593923568726,
0.42619600892066956,
0.34661006927490234,
-0.5101810097694397,
0.5498766303062439,
-0.33638623356819153,
-0.6027621626853943,
-0.4535650312900543,
0.275412380695343,
0.7335406541824341,
0.5106651186943054,
0.3048573136329651,
-0.24085190892219543,
-0.5215678215026855,
-0.9041611552238464,
-0.5590561628341675,
0.014196225441992283,
-0.3641083538532257,
0.4311430752277374,
0.6197100877761841,
-0.1643216460943222,
1.2095731496810913,
-0.33849242329597473,
0.037661198526620865,
0.02547132596373558,
0.023666108027100563,
-0.043126557022333145,
0.8153142929077148,
0.5663800239562988,
-0.28715240955352783,
-0.5131121277809143,
-0.13027510046958923,
-0.8763992190361023,
-0.2811034619808197,
-0.01830478198826313,
-0.30547308921813965,
0.024487240239977837,
0.9260528087615967,
-0.1820526421070099,
0.39079394936561584,
0.7183733582496643,
-0.2194027155637741,
0.4834105968475342,
-0.2927408516407013,
0.15018753707408905,
-0.8618199229240417,
0.38081976771354675,
-0.2000291645526886,
-0.09064432233572006,
-0.7920327186584473,
0.40677282214164734,
0.24452808499336243,
0.012597635388374329,
-0.6896620988845825,
0.25126489996910095,
-0.3281194865703583,
-0.19745875895023346,
-0.10479588061571121,
0.2501813769340515,
0.1961904764175415,
0.06507665663957596,
-0.24373123049736023,
1.022882103919983,
0.4462003707885742,
-0.5475873947143555,
-0.19092974066734314,
0.12567047774791718,
-0.787826418876648,
0.08666921406984329,
-0.768397331237793,
0.2998422682285309,
0.2345769703388214,
-0.16896653175354004,
-0.8308950662612915,
0.045520346611738205,
-0.1626608520746231,
-0.308811753988266,
0.17901542782783508,
-0.22375857830047607,
-0.6571378707885742,
0.048280805349349976,
-0.07855813950300217,
0.6153431534767151,
0.37545064091682434,
-0.49286702275276184,
0.050828900188207626,
0.20811571180820465,
-0.07611837238073349,
-0.6058509349822998,
-0.611556351184845,
-0.1454630196094513,
-0.38200968503952026,
-0.8064272403717041,
0.24828189611434937,
-0.08817671239376068,
-0.44595271348953247,
-0.047958821058273315,
-0.3117741644382477,
-0.10506123304367065,
0.48622363805770874,
0.31014782190322876,
0.19078844785690308,
-0.14708054065704346,
-0.12804707884788513,
-0.06358078867197037,
0.0435221791267395,
0.19467945396900177,
0.1808762103319168,
0.7448007464408875,
0.06924298405647278,
-0.594862163066864,
-0.0356832779943943,
-0.05713636800646782,
0.4311979413032532,
-0.4652264416217804,
0.77192223072052,
0.31144893169403076,
-0.4088688790798187,
-0.21793504059314728,
-0.40420863032341003,
0.15494714677333832,
-0.5180621147155762,
0.5198735594749451,
-0.38083675503730774,
-0.6280536651611328,
0.7296187281608582,
0.1323879063129425,
-0.1199251189827919,
0.2691132128238678,
0.19586049020290375,
0.10255461186170578,
0.7303556203842163,
0.6494564414024353,
-0.02927457168698311,
0.46134546399116516,
-0.2560715675354004,
0.011371316388249397,
-0.6903125643730164,
-0.10722502321004868,
-0.7301580905914307,
0.09056797623634338,
-0.5058000087738037,
-0.5778548121452332,
-0.08383920788764954,
0.5903589725494385,
-0.3054133355617523,
0.4214758574962616,
-0.26781708002090454,
0.7711725234985352,
0.5163614153862,
-0.1491183638572693,
0.569753110408783,
-0.0999104455113411,
-0.26870980858802795,
0.03574468940496445,
-0.5428687334060669,
-0.6379095911979675,
1.3028714656829834,
0.3442283570766449,
0.5341813564300537,
0.02980267070233822,
0.989335298538208,
0.15678969025611877,
0.15474124252796173,
0.01570942997932434,
0.3887586295604706,
-0.18926431238651276,
-0.6166561841964722,
-0.16596496105194092,
-0.8712891936302185,
-1.055287480354309,
0.01621442660689354,
-0.04266640543937683,
-0.680864691734314,
0.03185340762138367,
-0.18301460146903992,
-0.2418232560157776,
0.24726387858390808,
-0.6869101524353027,
1.107527256011963,
-0.07968966662883759,
-0.3863682746887207,
-0.12097684293985367,
-0.4783700108528137,
0.6133518218994141,
-0.4331452548503876,
0.3237723410129547,
-0.18934950232505798,
0.12232339382171631,
0.6345866322517395,
-0.5073895454406738,
0.43634214997291565,
0.11292803287506104,
-0.46650832891464233,
0.24566969275474548,
0.25261467695236206,
0.06638841331005096,
-0.18039609491825104,
0.07791826874017715,
0.39767393469810486,
0.17626293003559113,
-0.47109299898147583,
-0.26256710290908813,
0.557131290435791,
-0.7232575416564941,
-0.3179270625114441,
-0.18246574699878693,
-0.6824105381965637,
-0.32790422439575195,
0.3318277895450592,
0.6787354946136475,
0.42846670746803284,
-0.12592121958732605,
0.2544076442718506,
0.7067809104919434,
-0.6346501111984253,
0.4817062020301819,
0.4152722954750061,
-0.34980010986328125,
-0.05625157058238983,
1.0350868701934814,
-0.13268747925758362,
0.8440552949905396,
0.1599566489458084,
-0.1568555384874344,
-0.07365240901708603,
-0.9137995839118958,
-0.2144363671541214,
0.09312903881072998,
-0.6443946957588196,
-0.3525734543800354,
-0.40347617864608765,
-0.41598251461982727,
-0.19912192225456238,
0.13100725412368774,
-0.29568618535995483,
-0.08981841057538986,
-0.3566323518753052,
-0.012583929114043713,
0.059116046875715256,
0.8846285343170166,
0.08890921622514725,
0.22380244731903076,
-1.0481607913970947,
0.21289943158626556,
-0.08973973989486694,
0.5962337255477905,
-0.09640581905841827,
-0.5489731431007385,
-0.3783584535121918,
0.10768885165452957,
-0.18349109590053558,
-0.741304874420166,
0.1483299732208252,
0.11365235596895218,
0.7742201685905457,
0.5052053928375244,
0.07387404888868332,
0.6004185080528259,
-0.10430439561605453,
0.6749337911605835,
-0.04872497171163559,
-1.1904441118240356,
0.5231742262840271,
-0.4495712220668793,
0.35527217388153076,
0.6985790133476257,
0.16180507838726044,
-0.42516711354255676,
-0.9945250153541565,
-0.6132107973098755,
-0.9637482166290283,
0.5416625738143921,
0.3777221441268921,
-0.11340426653623581,
0.03640890493988991,
0.30754774808883667,
-0.08504969626665115,
0.13220898807048798,
-0.4777834713459015,
-0.057072050869464874,
0.1209147572517395,
-0.0877671092748642,
-0.13900840282440186,
-0.1556897610425949,
-0.0545780248939991,
0.050569821149110794,
0.3192567229270935,
0.2020179033279419,
-0.10239103436470032,
-0.2883630692958832,
-0.5812714099884033,
-0.026038261130452156,
0.1414201259613037,
0.6855045557022095,
0.722204864025116,
-0.1718134880065918,
0.047864340245723724,
-0.015289231203496456,
-0.5956398844718933,
0.04677243158221245,
-0.05272654816508293,
-0.1012566089630127,
-0.23165905475616455,
0.750188410282135,
0.48379936814308167,
0.2596896290779114,
-1.0532044172286987,
0.51007479429245,
-0.08141690492630005,
-0.1651182770729065,
-0.03421393781900406,
0.41899925470352173,
0.23619961738586426,
-0.08127734810113907,
0.09743648022413254,
0.16041885316371918,
0.048860929906368256,
-0.6143683791160583,
0.5900564193725586,
0.3456830084323883,
-0.08042120933532715,
0.10607264190912247,
0.6295138597488403,
0.014064880087971687,
0.06816666573286057,
0.8208253979682922,
-0.06793096661567688,
-0.4098801910877228,
0.9340332746505737,
0.29720747470855713,
0.6047884821891785,
-0.14029879868030548,
-0.1710120588541031,
0.344558447599411,
0.25428178906440735,
0.1540682464838028,
0.11006422340869904,
0.0468837134540081,
-0.681951105594635,
-0.6417900323867798,
-0.646636426448822,
-0.18277613818645477,
0.3534899652004242,
-1.0074505805969238,
0.11194740235805511,
-0.34072816371917725,
-0.027649400755763054,
-0.09325563162565231,
0.05099435895681381,
-0.7278078198432922,
0.010623172856867313,
0.33276641368865967,
1.0307681560516357,
-0.976959228515625,
0.7869126200675964,
0.2173025906085968,
-0.643395721912384,
-0.8135243058204651,
0.06937514990568161,
-0.3152382969856262,
-0.7169663906097412,
0.570975661277771,
0.2467440962791443,
0.13278111815452576,
-0.1489182561635971,
-0.13089101016521454,
-0.9628961086273193,
0.8616294264793396,
0.5531958937644958,
-0.4961329996585846,
0.0017464285483583808,
0.5891194343566895,
0.6316069960594177,
-0.10099317878484726,
0.30154356360435486,
1.0223270654678345,
0.28443795442581177,
-0.29636695981025696,
-1.0159703493118286,
0.08447220176458359,
-0.32766589522361755,
0.11304999142885208,
0.29819822311401367,
-0.16960255801677704,
0.7387610673904419,
-0.025725720450282097,
-0.372010201215744,
0.4209635853767395,
0.24658389389514923,
0.43585705757141113,
0.20293733477592468,
0.38728660345077515,
0.7507771849632263,
0.5976952314376831,
-0.1740543246269226,
0.8158348798751831,
-0.6766071319580078,
0.4453445374965668,
1.3213657140731812,
-0.34535571932792664,
0.9770618081092834,
0.29891565442085266,
-0.32931622862815857,
0.4117877185344696,
0.55730801820755,
-0.0892617329955101,
0.3590102195739746,
0.716621994972229,
-0.2293756753206253,
0.07917293161153793,
-0.007857182994484901,
-0.6891442537307739,
0.3586358428001404,
0.2933018207550049,
-0.3839523196220398,
-0.3525516092777252,
0.007967746816575527,
-0.05332040414214134,
0.25462958216667175,
-0.11766558885574341,
0.9357423782348633,
-0.20125937461853027,
-0.7847246527671814,
0.7555025815963745,
-0.19125176966190338,
0.4787238538265228,
-0.4151306748390198,
0.03355378285050392,
-0.49848175048828125,
0.31420838832855225,
-0.4023883640766144,
-0.8349193334579468,
0.40619179606437683,
0.13154634833335876,
0.0976349487900734,
-0.30548495054244995,
0.6165995001792908,
-0.45623070001602173,
-0.09261429309844971,
0.5877720713615417,
0.7118747234344482,
0.29010188579559326,
-0.22998355329036713,
-0.3401891589164734,
0.39556214213371277,
0.043048448860645294,
-0.02718842774629593,
0.7514582872390747,
0.2242351919412613,
0.2329607754945755,
0.6291608810424805,
0.6736217737197876,
0.04080021753907204,
0.5229755640029907,
0.12462841719388962,
0.8430580496788025,
-0.4530072808265686,
-0.1897749900817871,
-0.8236427903175354,
0.45545727014541626,
0.10993516445159912,
-0.27025118470191956,
0.8423849940299988,
0.9387968182563782,
0.9662913680076599,
-0.03607014939188957,
0.6935468316078186,
0.19073747098445892,
0.3602892756462097,
-0.5611467361450195,
0.7173330783843994,
-0.22729718685150146,
0.5961824655532837,
-0.3525334894657135,
-1.1037993431091309,
-0.04302241653203964,
0.2837202847003937,
-0.21749883890151978,
0.20647147297859192,
0.6561254858970642,
0.7423218488693237,
-0.19003483653068542,
-0.0960097536444664,
0.2971184253692627,
0.054977722465991974,
0.4258404076099396,
0.7371538281440735,
0.8967558741569519,
-0.23242366313934326,
0.8251446485519409,
-0.44392862915992737,
-0.21870073676109314,
-0.08079051226377487,
-1.0038894414901733,
-0.629135012626648,
-0.5145778059959412,
-0.33626794815063477,
-0.4253348410129547,
-0.1491500735282898,
0.2852487564086914,
0.5384126901626587,
-0.7444939017295837,
-0.21225565671920776,
-0.624052107334137,
-0.0587640255689621,
-0.09819227457046509,
-0.23313121497631073,
0.23695531487464905,
-0.6953542828559875,
-0.6919667720794678,
0.24732735753059387,
-0.2890656888484955,
0.1290283054113388,
-0.2873108685016632,
0.15861670672893524,
0.10368268191814423,
0.021544629707932472,
0.3643830716609955,
0.2455306351184845,
-0.4259720742702484,
-0.24504369497299194,
0.00795508362352848,
-0.4291599988937378,
-0.07350853085517883,
0.9080227613449097,
-0.6666706204414368,
0.41940709948539734,
0.5899935960769653,
0.7310037612915039,
0.4849516749382019,
0.11506636440753937,
0.6867753267288208,
-1.0726494789123535,
-0.014160445891320705,
0.09416341036558151,
0.33816537261009216,
0.32461655139923096,
-0.3029114007949829,
0.6510505080223083,
-0.09995749592781067,
-0.6582980155944824,
-1.122614860534668,
0.31298568844795227,
-0.7084223628044128,
-0.45913073420524597,
1.203909993171692,
-0.428684264421463,
0.12915386259555817,
-0.17575523257255554,
0.2794879972934723,
0.3128573000431061,
0.2096836417913437,
0.650363564491272,
0.9568100571632385,
-0.04086583852767944,
0.12222900986671448,
-0.9370981454849243,
0.5313014984130859,
0.4010601341724396,
-1.0855082273483276,
0.36662188172340393,
0.4693089723587036,
0.5837916731834412,
0.14404088258743286,
0.300076961517334,
-0.37653040885925293,
0.17343977093696594,
0.238888680934906,
0.19111710786819458,
-0.17401854693889618,
-0.1453085094690323,
-0.5378997921943665,
0.032066941261291504,
0.2180718034505844,
-0.09968700259923935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04031v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04031v1
|
Can Large Language Models do Analytical Reasoning?
| 2024-03-06T20:22:08 | 2024-03-06T20:22:08 |
Yebowen Hu, Kaiqiang Song, Sangwoo Cho, Xiaoyang Wang, Hassan Foroosh, Dong Yu, Fei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper explores the cutting-edge Large Language Model with analytical
reasoning on sports. Our analytical reasoning embodies the tasks of letting
large language models count how many points each team scores in a quarter in
the NBA and NFL games. Our major discoveries are in two folds. Firstly, we find
among all the models we employed, GPT-4 stands out in effectiveness, followed
by Claude-2.1, with GPT-3.5, Gemini-Pro, and Llama-2-70b lagging behind.
Specifically, we compare three different prompting techniques and a
divide-and-conquer approach, we find that the latter was the most effective.
Our divide-and-conquer approach breaks down play-by-play data into smaller,
more manageable segments, solves each piece individually, and then aggregates
them together. Besides the divide-and-conquer approach, we also explore the
Chain of Thought (CoT) strategy, which markedly improves outcomes for certain
models, notably GPT-4 and Claude-2.1, with their accuracy rates increasing
significantly. However, the CoT strategy has negligible or even detrimental
effects on the performance of other models like GPT-3.5 and Gemini-Pro.
Secondly, to our surprise, we observe that most models, including GPT-4,
struggle to accurately count the total scores for NBA quarters despite showing
strong performance in counting NFL quarter scores. This leads us to further
investigate the factors that impact the complexity of analytical reasoning
tasks with extensive experiments, through which we conclude that task
complexity depends on the length of context, the information density, and the
presence of related information. Our research provides valuable insights into
the complexity of analytical reasoning tasks and potential directions for
developing future large language models.
|
[
-0.36009374260902405,
-1.0254578590393066,
1.1351171731948853,
0.21443432569503784,
-0.18762953579425812,
0.34765902161598206,
-0.18459364771842957,
-0.8661061525344849,
0.12592947483062744,
0.2802170515060425,
-0.27851447463035583,
-0.38270917534828186,
-0.6492257118225098,
0.04591445252299309,
-0.3972945213317871,
0.7070983052253723,
-0.03289557620882988,
-0.04030017927289009,
0.00639876676723361,
-0.3571918308734894,
-0.6956049203872681,
-0.5581855177879333,
-0.937736988067627,
-0.4864368736743927,
0.1692391037940979,
0.19677771627902985,
0.6897116899490356,
0.7562342286109924,
0.5959389209747314,
0.3448672592639923,
-0.0723336935043335,
0.2945362627506256,
-0.3270668089389801,
0.391821026802063,
-0.37904995679855347,
-0.5350254774093628,
-0.586820125579834,
-0.007240848150104284,
0.39033856987953186,
0.7516545653343201,
-0.30231353640556335,
0.058669351041316986,
-0.28773048520088196,
0.6899256706237793,
-0.30307286977767944,
0.1400722861289978,
-0.4856587052345276,
-0.16947385668754578,
-0.06822383403778076,
-0.3152393400669098,
-0.3785945475101471,
-0.10298288613557816,
0.24029193818569183,
-0.48040974140167236,
-0.00998071487993002,
0.08433334529399872,
0.5822647213935852,
0.09215298295021057,
-0.6370458006858826,
-0.4608685076236725,
-1.061683177947998,
0.9241172075271606,
-0.7572513818740845,
0.33725565671920776,
0.4022573232650757,
0.38727355003356934,
0.10049335658550262,
-0.31532007455825806,
-0.6112602949142456,
-0.24915827810764313,
0.3348925709724426,
0.34407415986061096,
-0.2745595872402191,
-0.08619818091392517,
0.4380062222480774,
0.03503366559743881,
-0.45038989186286926,
0.006839375011622906,
-0.499702125787735,
0.37383323907852173,
1.0327240228652954,
0.4506334662437439,
0.10608087480068207,
0.42133423686027527,
-0.3534582853317261,
0.3150659203529358,
-0.6130524277687073,
0.48780906200408936,
0.158663809299469,
0.012063822709023952,
-0.0040313685312867165,
0.5761523246765137,
-0.2814127206802368,
0.46892857551574707,
0.17390066385269165,
-0.0904398038983345,
-0.188920259475708,
-0.0824635922908783,
-0.11251379549503326,
0.024559013545513153,
0.6575254797935486,
0.4305064380168915,
0.32574352622032166,
-0.17900347709655762,
-0.24518230557441711,
0.051238059997558594,
0.12292919307947159,
-0.6531045436859131,
-0.414314866065979,
0.4507688283920288,
-0.2193187028169632,
0.017780592665076256,
-0.06112387776374817,
-0.3879176080226898,
-0.5209025144577026,
-0.7422186732292175,
0.41308677196502686,
-0.7669036984443665,
0.00182906084228307,
0.3932836651802063,
-0.09819497168064117,
0.521511435508728,
0.5214749574661255,
-0.7839409708976746,
0.4134698808193207,
0.9977459907531738,
0.7456780672073364,
0.06487689912319183,
-0.2276143878698349,
-0.5533384680747986,
0.09520149230957031,
-0.7290562987327576,
1.1707834005355835,
-0.6729269623756409,
-0.14130127429962158,
0.03255584090948105,
-0.5174351930618286,
0.04638228192925453,
-0.6149767637252808,
0.3984750509262085,
-0.4194256365299225,
-0.2567094564437866,
-0.6044554710388184,
-0.9199503660202026,
-0.24813924729824066,
0.5716925263404846,
-0.6201170682907104,
0.7909650802612305,
-0.24918009340763092,
-0.3809053897857666,
0.32078880071640015,
-0.719659149646759,
-0.5887142419815063,
0.12730169296264648,
-0.23004242777824402,
-0.06375241279602051,
0.33677273988723755,
0.18931032717227936,
0.1336604207754135,
-0.6989428997039795,
0.1850503832101822,
-0.3642942011356354,
-0.31472697854042053,
0.5247981548309326,
-0.04212214797735214,
0.6447985172271729,
0.0481693260371685,
-0.34166812896728516,
0.029084984213113785,
-0.5226014256477356,
0.0795108899474144,
0.13817892968654633,
-0.3283494710922241,
-0.2884206175804138,
0.4624461829662323,
-0.591191291809082,
0.2249889224767685,
-0.18999125063419342,
-0.34994933009147644,
0.2898373603820801,
-0.29808011651039124,
0.3338737487792969,
0.6599226593971252,
0.026496946811676025,
0.5313756465911865,
-0.2152135670185089,
0.719245433807373,
-0.09935909509658813,
0.20982268452644348,
0.028459060937166214,
-0.5536593794822693,
-0.4112022817134857,
-0.2589063048362732,
-0.05184467136859894,
0.5630711913108826,
-0.9048460125923157,
0.15828827023506165,
-0.14301815629005432,
-0.5555338859558105,
-0.25226840376853943,
-0.11064067482948303,
0.0915282666683197,
0.404742956161499,
0.2663620412349701,
0.23163273930549622,
-0.26481279730796814,
-0.7484202980995178,
-0.38940274715423584,
-0.10603038221597672,
0.26247358322143555,
0.18112553656101227,
0.7829247713088989,
0.3319130837917328,
0.8110371828079224,
-0.6761049628257751,
-0.11014047265052795,
-0.5580479502677917,
0.18722903728485107,
0.41411474347114563,
0.21405673027038574,
0.6953018307685852,
-0.7738540172576904,
-0.627957284450531,
0.10103873163461685,
-0.8660932183265686,
-0.07542424649000168,
0.03206954896450043,
-0.032493941485881805,
-0.06832060217857361,
0.3175661563873291,
-0.8341500163078308,
0.4859080910682678,
0.5519503355026245,
-0.7246292233467102,
0.898702085018158,
-0.07643124461174011,
0.2419135570526123,
-0.3911809027194977,
0.011058448813855648,
0.18287132680416107,
-0.13504558801651,
-0.9389888048171997,
0.1330428570508957,
-0.35680821537971497,
0.2590421140193939,
-0.08816813677549362,
0.5420839786529541,
-0.31606653332710266,
0.10494481772184372,
-0.591655433177948,
0.2294352650642395,
0.14096388220787048,
0.1518452763557434,
0.21281921863555908,
0.5426889061927795,
0.4863070845603943,
-0.6199089884757996,
0.6319105625152588,
-0.08072652667760849,
-0.6748623847961426,
0.7174031138420105,
-0.7159559726715088,
0.052938614040613174,
-0.2081393003463745,
0.4762634038925171,
-0.879547119140625,
-0.04130837321281433,
0.06221399083733559,
-0.4001924991607666,
0.046977441757917404,
0.10138294845819473,
-0.36910852789878845,
-0.4167528748512268,
-0.21557018160820007,
0.7482475638389587,
0.2765743136405945,
-0.21186497807502747,
0.7507826685905457,
0.39948633313179016,
-0.2798769772052765,
-0.29595330357551575,
-0.3874208331108093,
-0.14860472083091736,
-0.3490900695323944,
-0.5080985426902771,
0.01689477078616619,
-0.1994321197271347,
-0.7524430751800537,
-0.1070898175239563,
-0.2602676451206207,
-0.17785675823688507,
-0.0464312843978405,
-0.11703012138605118,
0.39625757932662964,
-0.35897889733314514,
0.18943606317043304,
-0.1990455985069275,
0.0668487474322319,
0.30765947699546814,
-0.49442583322525024,
0.5002719759941101,
-0.20085957646369934,
-0.24531656503677368,
-0.21127448976039886,
0.6449729204177856,
0.4424924850463867,
-0.5284461975097656,
0.8460696935653687,
0.2610664665699005,
-0.23594363033771515,
-0.3532545566558838,
-0.562544584274292,
-0.13467980921268463,
-0.3632146716117859,
0.23571431636810303,
-0.6560279726982117,
-0.9127506613731384,
0.7970554232597351,
0.08597360551357269,
0.041510727256536484,
0.49171677231788635,
0.5211904048919678,
-0.24626465141773224,
1.4966026544570923,
0.15502490103244781,
0.12535013258457184,
0.08713384717702866,
-0.5011780858039856,
0.6252707242965698,
-0.856212854385376,
-0.06921866536140442,
-0.5455344319343567,
-0.5079585313796997,
-0.23047000169754028,
-0.4494476318359375,
0.3666532635688782,
0.11224883794784546,
-0.5612409114837646,
-0.08020191639661789,
-0.3937038779258728,
0.9655865430831909,
0.3408151865005493,
0.29038986563682556,
0.2870384752750397,
-0.6398946046829224,
0.168834388256073,
0.12352672964334488,
-0.5613248348236084,
-0.10069174319505692,
0.8224380016326904,
0.3143703043460846,
0.4063473343849182,
0.5607835650444031,
0.5699536800384521,
0.14798185229301453,
0.44275274872779846,
-1.1471519470214844,
0.4477880001068115,
-0.09928861260414124,
-0.9978606104850769,
-0.5766816139221191,
-0.48546674847602844,
-0.7538307309150696,
0.2787483334541321,
-0.11460065096616745,
-1.0398359298706055,
0.16629114747047424,
0.11188466101884842,
-0.5882719159126282,
0.45645973086357117,
-0.45432984828948975,
0.5224583148956299,
-0.33934205770492554,
-0.49149107933044434,
-0.11599140614271164,
-0.3224891424179077,
0.7623253464698792,
-0.10710963606834412,
0.5992494821548462,
-0.11472389847040176,
-0.04514334350824356,
0.8237234354019165,
-0.37731677293777466,
0.5463390946388245,
-0.06533723324537277,
-0.2262112945318222,
0.7134602069854736,
0.483030766248703,
0.5864503979682922,
-0.1626628339290619,
-0.09812439233064651,
-0.23968161642551422,
0.2894335985183716,
-0.5657267570495605,
-0.7179843187332153,
0.5076669454574585,
-0.3605005145072937,
-0.8403977751731873,
-0.6508389711380005,
-0.6438878178596497,
-0.3298896849155426,
0.0709998607635498,
0.15445317327976227,
0.48547548055648804,
0.11396902799606323,
0.42773327231407166,
0.4337445795536041,
-0.10554344952106476,
0.2675562798976898,
0.46511057019233704,
-0.32988765835762024,
-0.19716180860996246,
0.6519954204559326,
0.19633658230304718,
0.12037020176649094,
0.3456505537033081,
0.525352418422699,
-0.5945665836334229,
-0.7647220492362976,
0.01284824125468731,
0.41625139117240906,
-0.7837574481964111,
-0.24060964584350586,
-0.019407324492931366,
0.058863986283540726,
-0.271596223115921,
0.030765822157263756,
-0.42384427785873413,
-0.10995913296937943,
0.4597398042678833,
-0.26311221718788147,
0.07552425563335419,
0.9235877394676208,
0.05715977028012276,
0.3285151422023773,
-0.7961848378181458,
0.12987399101257324,
0.12042349576950073,
0.49281054735183716,
0.423988938331604,
-0.4557534456253052,
-0.42652973532676697,
-0.02845391072332859,
-0.29026472568511963,
-0.970221996307373,
0.2731030583381653,
-0.16723747551441193,
0.38548436760902405,
0.452656090259552,
0.02580549754202366,
0.5374767184257507,
-0.5663955211639404,
0.8626226186752319,
0.3003992736339569,
-0.9695851802825928,
0.018866894766688347,
-0.6643506288528442,
0.42874547839164734,
0.33610811829566956,
0.263502836227417,
-0.2148423045873642,
-0.1916099339723587,
-0.5497492551803589,
-0.5790102481842041,
0.6028844714164734,
-0.015736201778054237,
-0.19453492760658264,
-0.24704676866531372,
0.19495555758476257,
-0.08931350708007812,
0.09226598590612411,
-0.4536328911781311,
0.0658009722828865,
0.24619834125041962,
-0.06603768467903137,
-0.10553321242332458,
-0.035995714366436005,
-0.10712108761072159,
-0.4883708655834198,
0.5691624879837036,
0.004594027530401945,
-0.15788480639457703,
0.07724305987358093,
0.3465138077735901,
0.06091921776533127,
0.0933515727519989,
0.7099786996841431,
1.0097510814666748,
0.015951013192534447,
0.022369353100657463,
0.18792586028575897,
-0.22820621728897095,
0.0634833499789238,
-0.10631275922060013,
-0.029257111251354218,
-0.17550420761108398,
0.766060471534729,
0.5663155317306519,
0.05228673666715622,
-0.8191717863082886,
0.38144776225090027,
0.2769356966018677,
-0.5697392225265503,
-0.29135701060295105,
-0.21674063801765442,
0.15750600397586823,
0.6576482057571411,
0.3204194903373718,
-0.17613756656646729,
0.3030170798301697,
-1.0181752443313599,
-0.16029857099056244,
0.4442889392375946,
-0.18230335414409637,
-0.41584715247154236,
0.6624913811683655,
0.06969848275184631,
-0.16458624601364136,
0.39464282989501953,
-0.2592651844024658,
-1.047181487083435,
0.6321054100990295,
0.3653828501701355,
0.49086275696754456,
-0.49444782733917236,
0.2715970575809479,
0.2083158791065216,
0.01349025871604681,
-0.38257095217704773,
0.36359354853630066,
-0.09988310188055038,
-0.7545828223228455,
-0.8721092343330383,
-0.543120265007019,
-0.3186012804508209,
0.05641280114650726,
-0.4315517544746399,
-0.25860950350761414,
-0.31747230887413025,
-0.3790489435195923,
0.47279247641563416,
-0.03875149041414261,
-0.7048210501670837,
0.21389514207839966,
0.16264580190181732,
0.774057924747467,
-0.8710687756538391,
0.5990163087844849,
0.7777642607688904,
-0.5088655352592468,
-1.142461895942688,
-0.21096698939800262,
0.12645961344242096,
-0.4664628505706787,
0.8006892204284668,
-0.20018833875656128,
-0.18923836946487427,
-0.10969313234090805,
-0.6973034143447876,
-0.6091692447662354,
0.7893470525741577,
-0.06478472054004669,
-0.28293973207473755,
-0.13894769549369812,
0.11888100206851959,
0.6391069889068604,
-0.32799944281578064,
0.2404603362083435,
1.075283408164978,
0.5638372302055359,
0.5714082717895508,
-0.8626982569694519,
-0.03794674202799797,
0.013951804488897324,
-0.4988580346107483,
0.4381563067436218,
-0.6926175951957703,
1.0224692821502686,
-0.37804681062698364,
0.08237224817276001,
0.013767457567155361,
0.5043752193450928,
0.47574928402900696,
0.5726712346076965,
0.4349234402179718,
0.385519415140152,
0.6728659868240356,
-0.14383716881275177,
1.1689380407333374,
0.07308521121740341,
0.29196086525917053,
1.095597505569458,
-0.8218502998352051,
0.8311356902122498,
0.38718196749687195,
-0.4442446231842041,
0.1867334395647049,
0.0635407567024231,
0.10682159662246704,
-0.020259076729416847,
0.3163244128227234,
-0.2195519655942917,
-0.6118250489234924,
0.0034159068018198013,
0.009627493098378181,
0.955957293510437,
0.28571373224258423,
-0.18704409897327423,
-0.10902982950210571,
-0.30203887820243835,
0.28941771388053894,
0.39046159386634827,
-0.17317485809326172,
0.7867815494537354,
0.24070873856544495,
-1.106542944908142,
0.21965083479881287,
-0.015732374042272568,
-0.062240395694971085,
-0.3518911600112915,
-0.14234191179275513,
-0.21492578089237213,
0.47980231046676636,
0.0928245410323143,
-1.1435372829437256,
0.18398407101631165,
0.1573096364736557,
-0.10690699517726898,
0.1996840387582779,
0.3374579846858978,
-0.33304473757743835,
-0.45347216725349426,
0.2740246057510376,
0.6116766929626465,
0.04428714141249657,
-0.46539172530174255,
-0.4683137834072113,
0.29368889331817627,
0.029684439301490784,
-0.3356292247772217,
0.2755912244319916,
0.8436522483825684,
-0.13170510530471802,
0.7667429447174072,
0.643450140953064,
0.454163521528244,
0.012449770234525204,
0.05697750672698021,
0.5841969847679138,
-0.6500509977340698,
-0.6530913710594177,
-1.1729248762130737,
0.3284904658794403,
-0.31837594509124756,
-0.06926122307777405,
0.42746424674987793,
0.824919581413269,
0.2594005763530731,
-0.07198494672775269,
0.6948221921920776,
0.030193787068128586,
0.6457743644714355,
-0.6202695965766907,
0.47203898429870605,
-0.40013501048088074,
0.4089806377887726,
0.07901003956794739,
-0.8757268190383911,
-0.3717729449272156,
0.43891647458076477,
-0.7819617986679077,
0.02577923610806465,
0.8338053822517395,
0.08473518490791321,
0.11700330674648285,
0.2454354614019394,
0.25247105956077576,
0.4526974558830261,
0.8341068625450134,
0.8476839065551758,
0.9634969234466553,
-0.05693255364894867,
0.5889769792556763,
-0.11468872427940369,
-0.5298619270324707,
-0.1557231992483139,
-0.5681899189949036,
-0.9125381112098694,
-0.5429906845092773,
-0.11296293139457703,
-0.27069467306137085,
-0.0014424087712541223,
0.7847851514816284,
0.47412246465682983,
-0.587997317314148,
-0.41468408703804016,
0.2548661231994629,
-0.17981410026550293,
-0.5352731347084045,
-0.22082817554473877,
0.5155832171440125,
-0.17572680115699768,
-0.6492480039596558,
0.2309616655111313,
0.2531277537345886,
-0.3136526048183441,
0.28977885842323303,
-0.06400959193706512,
-0.43744462728500366,
0.5321454405784607,
1.1268234252929688,
0.3426693081855774,
-0.8010381460189819,
-0.48053088784217834,
0.18529285490512848,
0.2637542188167572,
-0.10642499476671219,
0.7791511416435242,
-0.5765657424926758,
0.3739466369152069,
0.5344829559326172,
0.46341001987457275,
0.4472648799419403,
0.562272846698761,
0.5935459136962891,
-0.1934814304113388,
-0.013832859694957733,
0.4699222445487976,
0.3954021632671356,
-0.05248467996716499,
0.11570865660905838,
0.5772659778594971,
0.20670942962169647,
-0.6892714500427246,
-0.5887770056724548,
0.21618862450122833,
-0.973486602306366,
-0.42683401703834534,
1.1469805240631104,
0.05269584059715271,
-0.20504052937030792,
-0.005031674634665251,
-0.3014979660511017,
-0.014384277164936066,
-0.293384850025177,
0.8492326140403748,
1.091365933418274,
-0.6281378865242004,
-0.22240707278251648,
-0.7957239747047424,
0.49972960352897644,
0.05464446544647217,
-0.6342943906784058,
0.09574361890554428,
0.4848233759403229,
0.009945780038833618,
0.1568218320608139,
0.638064980506897,
0.19064082205295563,
0.252420574426651,
0.1453622728586197,
-0.4887659549713135,
0.03633855655789375,
-0.4518930912017822,
0.17850853502750397,
0.07935251295566559,
0.039372485131025314,
0.02258933335542679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04009v1
|
Media Bias Matters: Understanding the Impact of Politically Biased News on Vaccine Attitudes in Social Media
| 2024-03-06T19:41:02 | 2024-03-06T19:41:02 |
Bohan Jiang, Lu Cheng, Zhen Tan, Ruocheng Guo, Huan Liu
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.CY, physics.soc-ph
|
News media has been utilized as a political tool to stray from facts,
presenting biased claims without evidence. Amid the COVID-19 pandemic,
politically biased news (PBN) has significantly undermined public trust in
vaccines, despite strong medical evidence supporting their efficacy. In this
paper, we analyze: (i) how inherent vaccine stances subtly influence
individuals' selection of news sources and participation in social media
discussions; and (ii) the impact of exposure to PBN on users' attitudes toward
vaccines. In doing so, we first curate a comprehensive dataset that connects
PBN with related social media discourse. Utilizing advanced deep learning and
causal inference techniques, we reveal distinct user behaviors between social
media groups with various vaccine stances. Moreover, we observe that
individuals with moderate stances, particularly the vaccine-hesitant majority,
are more vulnerable to the influence of PBN compared to those with extreme
views. Our findings provide critical insights to foster this line of research.
|
[
-0.28159859776496887,
-0.821639895439148,
0.2727682590484619,
0.19914954900741577,
-0.2520911991596222,
0.05155545100569725,
0.0010401514591649175,
-0.12344206124544144,
0.5265627503395081,
-0.013822955079376698,
-0.15017712116241455,
-0.20143938064575195,
-1.0192488431930542,
-0.24330349266529083,
-0.04711601510643959,
1.0476676225662231,
0.44576743245124817,
0.3196854591369629,
0.003589548170566559,
0.10182534903287888,
0.166580468416214,
-0.472758412361145,
-0.3691231310367584,
-0.5193051695823669,
0.7984262108802795,
0.32506805658340454,
0.7537737488746643,
0.24143128097057343,
0.2563377618789673,
0.0645914375782013,
-0.4051518738269806,
-0.1965511441230774,
-0.570875346660614,
-0.10229280591011047,
-0.572742223739624,
-0.5526742935180664,
-0.36418673396110535,
0.3711148500442505,
0.34255650639533997,
0.41230839490890503,
0.04419978708028793,
0.37079763412475586,
0.0011145747266709805,
0.5046988725662231,
-0.6457644104957581,
-0.25419124960899353,
-0.7949085235595703,
0.28669261932373047,
-0.4292371869087219,
-0.4628434181213379,
-0.3585238754749298,
-0.02880142070353031,
0.20502851903438568,
-0.6017847061157227,
0.48518437147140503,
-0.48716962337493896,
0.7330880165100098,
-0.15737096965312958,
-1.1063648462295532,
0.04218960553407669,
-0.5932854413986206,
0.5608444809913635,
-0.45888230204582214,
0.03155456855893135,
0.654845118522644,
-0.05542336776852608,
-0.3047436773777008,
-0.4098818302154541,
-0.5282489657402039,
0.437386691570282,
0.4500042498111725,
0.31301549077033997,
-0.46954062581062317,
0.061665382236242294,
0.11564226448535919,
0.16600994765758514,
-0.29760268330574036,
-0.15228091180324554,
-0.6620829701423645,
-0.20432446897029877,
0.5650990605354309,
-0.22397199273109436,
0.41539132595062256,
-0.5045958757400513,
-0.0214602742344141,
0.04336315765976906,
-0.608424723148346,
0.4542693495750427,
0.5708230137825012,
0.08878034353256226,
-0.2764856815338135,
0.5029840469360352,
0.001556173781864345,
0.4575662612915039,
0.7168245315551758,
0.035780977457761765,
0.07361208647489548,
-0.32916876673698425,
-0.4156472682952881,
0.3499287962913513,
0.7717131972312927,
0.8586879968643188,
-0.1496560424566269,
0.5584210753440857,
0.5404151082038879,
0.09291645139455795,
0.44268694519996643,
-0.8022205829620361,
-0.15889902412891388,
0.002671312540769577,
-0.7366624474525452,
-0.5053273439407349,
0.30309173464775085,
-0.8852186799049377,
-1.1106746196746826,
0.07325809448957443,
0.15282680094242096,
0.13362203538417816,
-0.40619388222694397,
0.12003419548273087,
-0.6750331521034241,
0.27611368894577026,
0.5747136473655701,
-0.5589307546615601,
-0.15715445578098297,
0.9657595157623291,
0.660246729850769,
0.11311747133731842,
0.4737357497215271,
-0.5317647457122803,
-0.0019836549181491137,
-0.48391538858413696,
0.6827932000160217,
-0.695713460445404,
-0.27961787581443787,
0.05170885846018791,
-0.07483083754777908,
0.1894698292016983,
-0.6220319271087646,
0.3933297097682953,
-0.5628629326820374,
0.16746793687343597,
-0.7622727155685425,
-0.26151999831199646,
-0.07959894090890884,
0.07472115010023117,
-0.2542695999145508,
0.26800623536109924,
-0.29631155729293823,
-1.0963655710220337,
0.6722604036331177,
-0.0692988783121109,
-0.7427865266799927,
-0.2021709829568863,
-0.4510512948036194,
-0.6775140762329102,
0.36942145228385925,
0.32148146629333496,
0.3970668315887451,
-0.0020881202071905136,
0.43814796209335327,
-0.9552887678146362,
-0.010756582021713257,
0.17821931838989258,
-0.4046745002269745,
1.1605266332626343,
-0.17570579051971436,
-0.501725971698761,
0.0267423577606678,
-0.3201751112937927,
-0.7779034376144409,
-0.04091571271419525,
-0.08882247656583786,
-0.5085220336914062,
0.04105183854699135,
-0.173186257481575,
0.3975079655647278,
-0.47758376598358154,
-0.5943909287452698,
0.15465281903743744,
-0.2130720615386963,
0.49943670630455017,
0.7385427951812744,
0.497149258852005,
0.6034181714057922,
-0.38088539242744446,
0.5166637301445007,
0.4313832223415375,
0.5900536775588989,
0.34511667490005493,
-0.8275855779647827,
-0.38430893421173096,
0.02236342243850231,
-0.2139892578125,
0.33722954988479614,
-0.3553061783313751,
0.06783361732959747,
0.216277614235878,
-0.3955926299095154,
-0.5300601124763489,
-0.025454392656683922,
-0.12840543687343597,
0.5544382929801941,
0.09255493432283401,
-0.195151686668396,
-0.3717351257801056,
-0.994648277759552,
-0.7614334225654602,
-0.5052603483200073,
0.21200977265834808,
0.3049594759941101,
0.32128989696502686,
-0.010985062457621098,
0.6289123296737671,
-0.21360638737678528,
-0.2078334093093872,
0.07923942804336548,
0.31412574648857117,
0.4127468466758728,
0.1119123101234436,
0.5683633685112,
-0.9018983840942383,
-0.11312463134527206,
-0.05850483477115631,
-0.3150917589664459,
-0.2059362530708313,
-0.15282493829727173,
0.2106688767671585,
-0.07747220993041992,
0.31959816813468933,
-0.4513441026210785,
0.9226891398429871,
0.6568216681480408,
-0.49571916460990906,
0.3286285400390625,
0.1983589082956314,
0.23084203898906708,
-1.1277947425842285,
-0.21670222282409668,
0.4798448979854584,
-0.16782139241695404,
-0.6156288981437683,
-0.4127722382545471,
-0.17455627024173737,
0.06852049380540848,
-0.6916989088058472,
0.3449326157569885,
-0.10128239542245865,
0.027502089738845825,
-0.2700357139110565,
-0.27058249711990356,
0.43709704279899597,
-0.4041225016117096,
-0.10283315926790237,
0.5073661804199219,
0.6135702133178711,
-0.5210837125778198,
0.2544199526309967,
0.24036841094493866,
-0.42174142599105835,
0.36903029680252075,
-0.5564169883728027,
-0.13865400850772858,
-0.42915794253349304,
0.8003801703453064,
-0.6577951312065125,
-0.3931788504123688,
0.5787193179130554,
-0.6779069304466248,
-0.11595989018678665,
-0.08059430122375488,
-0.007108673918992281,
-0.3800767958164215,
-0.3378578722476959,
0.19221647083759308,
0.10369491577148438,
-0.2502909004688263,
0.2330547720193863,
1.0631563663482666,
-0.15862680971622467,
-0.631816565990448,
-0.8986961245536804,
0.23298439383506775,
-0.24966971576213837,
-0.42808908224105835,
0.3616035580635071,
0.360820472240448,
-0.6258910894393921,
0.0019013126147910953,
-0.42520633339881897,
-0.13554897904396057,
-0.0718008354306221,
0.3241727650165558,
-0.3916594088077545,
-0.11027110368013382,
0.35948842763900757,
0.3471726179122925,
0.21735380589962006,
0.19273467361927032,
0.07525389641523361,
0.2655434012413025,
-0.10598151385784149,
-0.4016093611717224,
-0.7993358969688416,
0.4957845211029053,
0.49995896220207214,
-0.05540890246629715,
0.6786264777183533,
0.5500993132591248,
-0.2683880925178528,
0.0318978987634182,
-0.41679614782333374,
-0.3201272189617157,
-0.3646640181541443,
0.36329954862594604,
0.3280358910560608,
-0.6425553560256958,
0.31540006399154663,
0.29856276512145996,
-0.2769742012023926,
0.4221656918525696,
0.7783228158950806,
-0.0738477036356926,
0.7673542499542236,
0.36105185747146606,
-0.232244074344635,
0.5105828046798706,
0.06794365495443344,
0.08830501139163971,
-0.3947131335735321,
-0.3779860734939575,
-0.3136613965034485,
-0.2662278711795807,
-0.4506664276123047,
-0.4655342996120453,
0.27892839908599854,
-0.09930722415447235,
-0.266508013010025,
-0.2597179412841797,
-0.5800169110298157,
0.1781953126192093,
0.6208465099334717,
0.6779700517654419,
0.07009535282850266,
0.12484798580408096,
0.284181147813797,
0.03228873759508133,
-1.0230478048324585,
0.0017892925534397364,
0.7838655114173889,
0.41267895698547363,
0.6355409622192383,
0.007236802950501442,
0.3034903407096863,
0.590531587600708,
0.151187464594841,
-0.6584146022796631,
0.15493710339069366,
-0.02674574963748455,
-0.9862029552459717,
0.13030727207660675,
-0.03949457406997681,
-0.9630662202835083,
-0.020892377942800522,
-0.22537551820278168,
-0.5305691361427307,
0.9347952604293823,
0.28416770696640015,
-0.5210994482040405,
0.24025462567806244,
-0.56353759765625,
0.40897074341773987,
-0.10798551142215729,
-0.5639129877090454,
-0.669043242931366,
-0.7042140364646912,
0.05983605980873108,
0.033828556537628174,
0.12251392751932144,
-0.3525919020175934,
0.03991902619600296,
0.5566506385803223,
-0.347229927778244,
1.1555752754211426,
-0.1661115288734436,
0.24072116613388062,
0.1813603788614273,
-0.38385242223739624,
-0.035885486751794815,
0.7472516298294067,
-0.33783426880836487,
0.26804912090301514,
-0.3468034863471985,
-0.6559385657310486,
0.0013283960288390517,
0.515898585319519,
-0.9026373028755188,
-0.9844372272491455,
-0.8558196425437927,
-0.25357815623283386,
0.14092476665973663,
0.018142076209187508,
0.2984788715839386,
0.15546786785125732,
-0.3267514109611511,
0.42608150839805603,
0.6991474032402039,
-0.5179885625839233,
0.2652265131473541,
0.24061031639575958,
-0.16888335347175598,
-0.4144573211669922,
0.25620290637016296,
0.44614946842193604,
0.13908164203166962,
0.13926397264003754,
0.6709208488464355,
0.18916462361812592,
-0.07572529464960098,
-0.10758835822343826,
-0.06113841384649277,
-0.3922443985939026,
-0.17767682671546936,
-0.5754818916320801,
-0.03763303533196449,
-0.8002398014068604,
-0.23962360620498657,
-0.21512842178344727,
-0.10690400004386902,
-0.5258303880691528,
-0.22171050310134888,
0.3641050457954407,
0.6676052808761597,
-0.17250007390975952,
0.40454116463661194,
-0.2578275501728058,
0.4181649684906006,
0.5448818802833557,
0.18196125328540802,
-0.30831778049468994,
-0.29685044288635254,
0.0777166411280632,
0.28150439262390137,
-0.44863465428352356,
-1.099185585975647,
0.09530754387378693,
0.04948456585407257,
0.28094375133514404,
0.9116246700286865,
0.24589671194553375,
0.5474454164505005,
-0.2751002013683319,
0.7608503103256226,
0.13939687609672546,
-0.7508087158203125,
0.6358618140220642,
-0.7950549721717834,
0.4421171545982361,
0.48468491435050964,
0.566117525100708,
-0.5042117834091187,
-0.4109651744365692,
-0.794802188873291,
-0.5775616765022278,
0.43942758440971375,
-0.008345035836100578,
0.11801838874816895,
-0.20960143208503723,
0.07554414123296738,
0.27891314029693604,
0.10576292872428894,
-0.4341101050376892,
-0.3056126534938812,
-0.644125759601593,
0.5378624796867371,
-0.026566313579678535,
-0.367631733417511,
-0.43598976731300354,
-0.7507984638214111,
0.6233595013618469,
0.2435985654592514,
0.1005505844950676,
0.4771187901496887,
0.1965218484401703,
-0.18598070740699768,
0.053607139736413956,
0.710627019405365,
0.7497197389602661,
-0.10444198548793793,
0.5062848925590515,
-0.4708079397678375,
-0.6280293464660645,
0.11365025490522385,
-0.03629283234477043,
-0.3607105314731598,
0.29222220182418823,
0.11608825623989105,
0.7785377502441406,
-0.3117314875125885,
-0.04497876018285751,
0.9954423308372498,
-0.017213240265846252,
-0.10639411211013794,
-0.08057350665330887,
-0.30130845308303833,
0.33286890387535095,
0.31265950202941895,
0.46391141414642334,
0.44102510809898376,
0.2947803735733032,
-0.6817432045936584,
0.37313878536224365,
0.5513869524002075,
-0.45652005076408386,
-0.6403985619544983,
0.6802480816841125,
0.3452603220939636,
-0.1499340981245041,
0.2688509523868561,
0.44750502705574036,
-0.22949567437171936,
0.8114203214645386,
0.5503986477851868,
0.5260026454925537,
-0.4389723241329193,
0.7618038654327393,
0.09617414325475693,
0.4615480303764343,
0.06331715732812881,
-0.11259819567203522,
0.3839918076992035,
-0.6353102326393127,
-0.3408859074115753,
-0.10132087767124176,
-0.1443103700876236,
0.44804123044013977,
-0.6111428141593933,
0.14866015315055847,
-0.5548998713493347,
-0.9834267497062683,
0.4179614782333374,
0.04758642241358757,
-0.49596118927001953,
0.05169631913304329,
0.3082669973373413,
0.8647341728210449,
-1.2493956089019775,
0.6043480038642883,
0.7753565311431885,
-0.14993301033973694,
-0.25040531158447266,
0.72919762134552,
0.54201340675354,
-0.531345546245575,
0.3662559390068054,
0.17894825339317322,
0.11077883839607239,
-0.5276904702186584,
-0.6437636613845825,
-0.4082654118537903,
0.607405424118042,
0.7221389412879944,
-0.18670251965522766,
0.3732045888900757,
0.34218382835388184,
0.17341262102127075,
-0.16064074635505676,
0.04027213528752327,
0.010788082145154476,
0.42685824632644653,
-0.18725351989269257,
-0.5989095568656921,
-0.22784209251403809,
-0.3814080059528351,
-0.19881251454353333,
-0.08438754081726074,
-0.9249296188354492,
0.4046091139316559,
-0.07778097689151764,
0.1844700574874878,
-0.8358966708183289,
0.7358916401863098,
-0.0707312673330307,
0.9782648682594299,
0.158379465341568,
0.18310894072055817,
0.6726901531219482,
0.23630604147911072,
1.0605933666229248,
0.01681828312575817,
0.07723533362150192,
0.8554453253746033,
-0.13228163123130798,
0.6167210936546326,
0.7784228920936584,
0.16114461421966553,
0.213887557387352,
0.6181195974349976,
0.14058110117912292,
0.3930267095565796,
0.10579903423786163,
-0.587074339389801,
-0.36495453119277954,
-0.5361073017120361,
-0.6182488799095154,
0.5348867774009705,
0.4729999601840973,
-0.5796264410018921,
-0.18114885687828064,
0.035654883831739426,
0.3745533525943756,
0.13281995058059692,
-0.5617914199829102,
0.49426382780075073,
0.2845710515975952,
-0.3992476761341095,
-0.08830580860376358,
-0.11633099615573883,
0.4010239839553833,
-0.20067951083183289,
0.25144505500793457,
-0.06360786408185959,
0.21569009125232697,
-0.4396297037601471,
-0.7731769680976868,
0.5488275289535522,
-0.2614184021949768,
-0.42029303312301636,
-0.2903291881084442,
1.1267098188400269,
-0.19980362057685852,
-0.3309108316898346,
0.12715092301368713,
0.5822747945785522,
-0.24559785425662994,
-0.269588440656662,
-0.8878297209739685,
0.3202836513519287,
-0.17549380660057068,
-0.4995560050010681,
0.4378465414047241,
0.23241004347801208,
-0.14141076803207397,
0.29665112495422363,
0.5199282765388489,
0.2150619775056839,
0.09916955977678299,
-0.005138627253472805,
0.765896737575531,
-0.14965157210826874,
-0.10708408057689667,
-1.1295835971832275,
0.19654648005962372,
-0.4150572717189789,
-0.3915293216705322,
1.0597138404846191,
0.6689671874046326,
0.5943194031715393,
0.023936526849865913,
0.8766922950744629,
0.11011318862438202,
-0.011464342474937439,
0.10963403433561325,
1.2000701427459717,
-0.3853784501552582,
-0.37005600333213806,
-0.2188095897436142,
-0.15338441729545593,
-0.714425802230835,
0.4853437542915344,
-0.6010990738868713,
-0.12485653162002563,
0.18769100308418274,
0.7928708791732788,
0.1461799144744873,
-0.13022442162036896,
-0.07805350422859192,
0.3404092788696289,
0.23762768507003784,
0.08013357222080231,
0.6902685165405273,
-0.04768221452832222,
0.2560829818248749,
-0.43308648467063904,
-0.34557515382766724,
-0.47390982508659363,
-1.0980476140975952,
-0.9271803498268127,
-0.3975379467010498,
-0.6086399555206299,
-0.8358193635940552,
0.4533611536026001,
1.02975332736969,
0.6048421859741211,
-0.6208837628364563,
-0.017752517014741898,
-0.09088817238807678,
0.370845228433609,
-0.15156984329223633,
-0.25935548543930054,
0.42368659377098083,
0.2691470682621002,
-0.46686726808547974,
-0.0036977233830839396,
0.44786885380744934,
-0.42060691118240356,
0.037599556148052216,
0.3715399205684662,
-0.578677237033844,
0.23354904353618622,
0.6939877867698669,
0.4002712666988373,
-0.7013068199157715,
-0.17423327267169952,
0.16792987287044525,
-0.4421641528606415,
0.2570764720439911,
0.6287898421287537,
-0.7359178066253662,
0.6148532032966614,
0.886149525642395,
0.653963029384613,
0.34359797835350037,
0.13652481138706207,
0.8594220876693726,
-0.32987579703330994,
0.19484148919582367,
0.20748955011367798,
0.048830293118953705,
0.2979308068752289,
-0.2697664499282837,
-0.131595641374588,
0.6263793706893921,
-0.45511895418167114,
-0.6158216595649719,
0.2818111181259155,
-1.0890849828720093,
-0.4119640290737152,
1.5831488370895386,
0.4106644093990326,
-0.4185991585254669,
-0.1832236647605896,
-0.1478687822818756,
0.5189627408981323,
-0.8415765762329102,
0.9824456572532654,
0.5920813083648682,
0.05740373954176903,
-0.2638210356235504,
-0.634560227394104,
0.4445081651210785,
0.4096926748752594,
-0.3530708849430084,
-0.2447323352098465,
0.2034885734319687,
0.0662946105003357,
-0.35855475068092346,
0.7748884558677673,
0.03280366584658623,
0.3437812328338623,
-0.19081628322601318,
-0.08314131200313568,
0.07841355353593826,
-0.12421824783086777,
-0.5887301564216614,
0.2047119438648224,
-0.2949022650718689,
-0.023527447134256363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.03956v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.03956v1
|
Backtracing: Retrieving the Cause of the Query
| 2024-03-06T18:59:02 | 2024-03-06T18:59:02 |
Rose E. Wang, Pawan Wirawarn, Omar Khattab, Noah Goodman, Dorottya Demszky
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Many online content portals allow users to ask questions to supplement their
understanding (e.g., of lectures). While information retrieval (IR) systems may
provide answers for such user queries, they do not directly assist content
creators -- such as lecturers who want to improve their content -- identify
segments that _caused_ a user to ask those questions. We introduce the task of
backtracing, in which systems retrieve the text segment that most likely caused
a user query. We formalize three real-world domains for which backtracing is
important in improving content delivery and communication: understanding the
cause of (a) student confusion in the Lecture domain, (b) reader curiosity in
the News Article domain, and (c) user emotion in the Conversation domain. We
evaluate the zero-shot performance of popular information retrieval methods and
language modeling methods, including bi-encoder, re-ranking and
likelihood-based methods and ChatGPT. While traditional IR systems retrieve
semantically relevant information (e.g., details on "projection matrices" for a
query "does projecting multiple times still lead to the same point?"), they
often miss the causally relevant context (e.g., the lecturer states "projecting
twice gets me the same answer as one projection"). Our results show that there
is room for improvement on backtracing and it requires new retrieval
approaches. We hope our benchmark serves to improve future retrieval systems
for backtracing, spawning systems that refine content generation and identify
linguistic triggers influencing user queries. Our code and data are
open-sourced: https://github.com/rosewang2008/backtracing.
|
[
-0.3392794728279114,
-0.9277227520942688,
0.6463261842727661,
0.17336121201515198,
-0.028167404234409332,
0.14041933417320251,
-0.09278243780136108,
-0.28824082016944885,
0.15195760130882263,
0.5929474234580994,
-0.596695065498352,
-0.4835244417190552,
-0.5841278433799744,
-0.12770596146583557,
-0.8201636075973511,
0.8793630599975586,
-0.0528530590236187,
-0.20231834053993225,
-0.2863985300064087,
-0.26549193263053894,
-0.7050790786743164,
-0.7210165858268738,
-0.708791196346283,
-0.10562362521886826,
0.8573238253593445,
0.7486369013786316,
0.3153771162033081,
0.27401259541511536,
0.4963717758655548,
0.1454664170742035,
0.1807095855474472,
-0.2600804269313812,
-0.8471927642822266,
0.5275901556015015,
-0.5752996206283569,
-0.5787185430526733,
0.2951793968677521,
-0.11832144111394882,
0.5368786454200745,
0.684920608997345,
-0.1869974434375763,
0.16451813280582428,
-0.11638062447309494,
0.9080702066421509,
-1.072645664215088,
-0.38320234417915344,
-0.4033784866333008,
0.041203051805496216,
-0.33439815044403076,
-0.6732104420661926,
-0.48719286918640137,
-0.5139845609664917,
0.25012052059173584,
-0.3750821053981781,
0.553761899471283,
0.15262968838214874,
0.9087987542152405,
0.1209336593747139,
-0.49555692076683044,
-0.516789436340332,
-0.6936330795288086,
0.6812252402305603,
-0.29472512006759644,
0.7126315832138062,
0.4021521806716919,
0.1494056135416031,
-0.022463908419013023,
-0.6836862564086914,
-0.611922025680542,
0.1615065187215805,
-0.0946083590388298,
0.19947105646133423,
-0.1739642322063446,
-0.45526593923568726,
0.22184748947620392,
0.257481187582016,
-0.7122554183006287,
-0.1627555638551712,
-0.4117700457572937,
-0.16309961676597595,
0.4853856563568115,
0.10933690518140793,
0.44506749510765076,
-0.2204235941171646,
-0.268698513507843,
-0.1716734766960144,
-1.0123876333236694,
-0.1336575299501419,
0.3841904103755951,
-0.08844400942325592,
0.3131314516067505,
0.63241046667099,
-0.1962238848209381,
0.6417859196662903,
-0.029284518212080002,
0.23748448491096497,
-0.11613099277019501,
-0.1896781325340271,
0.2040671557188034,
0.08532443642616272,
0.3713380992412567,
0.3525241017341614,
0.19873648881912231,
-0.05087928846478462,
0.05279200151562691,
-0.3480322062969208,
0.31680601835250854,
-0.756111741065979,
-0.2916926145553589,
0.1765221208333969,
-0.29937249422073364,
0.20845027267932892,
0.1273261159658432,
-0.9178299903869629,
-0.3557355999946594,
-0.10860083997249603,
0.5343813300132751,
-0.5213361978530884,
-0.3737044036388397,
-0.14128360152244568,
-0.25144970417022705,
0.3134707808494568,
0.3377576172351837,
-0.7505069971084595,
0.2568293511867523,
0.7205716371536255,
0.8849924206733704,
-0.4213574528694153,
-0.31879132986068726,
-0.5753012895584106,
0.07204730808734894,
-0.36386218667030334,
1.1587777137756348,
-0.41570964455604553,
-0.20519739389419556,
0.13964328169822693,
0.10228870064020157,
-0.2085614949464798,
-0.510073184967041,
0.4552706480026245,
-0.6978979110717773,
0.4822140634059906,
-0.42195621132850647,
-0.6999921798706055,
-0.2681124210357666,
0.3078736960887909,
-0.6002192497253418,
0.8299024701118469,
-0.07097838073968887,
-0.8424279093742371,
0.050682347267866135,
-0.27732086181640625,
-0.42495766282081604,
0.028609301894903183,
-0.18215692043304443,
-0.13068817555904388,
0.17907513678073883,
-0.019708560779690742,
0.21002507209777832,
-0.22997406125068665,
0.012713005766272545,
0.09570645540952682,
-0.5053313970565796,
0.2779451906681061,
-0.28330305218696594,
0.5125014185905457,
0.1366637796163559,
-0.14582309126853943,
-0.16853253543376923,
-0.7658838629722595,
-0.0384720079600811,
0.11693120002746582,
-0.40886762738227844,
-0.7114455699920654,
0.30083930492401123,
-0.18594881892204285,
0.05054584890604019,
-0.15466544032096863,
-0.7141929864883423,
-0.10733064264059067,
-0.24862025678157806,
-0.03805141523480415,
0.42708268761634827,
0.4087678790092468,
0.1927054524421692,
-0.10011827200651169,
0.4562293291091919,
0.03736867010593414,
-0.2792084515094757,
-0.45791095495224,
-0.5605093240737915,
-0.7496508955955505,
0.29850584268569946,
0.2611513137817383,
0.456254243850708,
-0.8165238499641418,
-0.304803729057312,
0.01792941987514496,
-0.38048383593559265,
-0.4722704589366913,
-0.1340765357017517,
0.4988527297973633,
0.7046850323677063,
0.42724472284317017,
-0.31722933053970337,
-0.4012480676174164,
-0.4537983536720276,
-0.7098782062530518,
-0.17915938794612885,
-0.19366495311260223,
0.30785247683525085,
0.36772680282592773,
0.11000508815050125,
0.7978261113166809,
-0.8942504525184631,
-0.26884832978248596,
-0.08500058203935623,
0.29734066128730774,
-0.22094938158988953,
0.41237643361091614,
0.21137359738349915,
-1.0090068578720093,
-0.41143038868904114,
-0.27964937686920166,
-0.6001375913619995,
-0.14042037725448608,
-0.04250498116016388,
-0.3669007122516632,
0.3841380178928375,
0.5236387848854065,
-0.5028045177459717,
0.6627366542816162,
0.4188229739665985,
-0.44053322076797485,
0.6109793782234192,
0.16357062757015228,
0.3519374430179596,
-0.6931519508361816,
0.2547324001789093,
-0.019418222829699516,
0.06953489035367966,
-0.46930620074272156,
0.16943226754665375,
-0.016194237396121025,
-0.2713790833950043,
-0.2421238124370575,
0.486465722322464,
-0.20907071232795715,
-0.2525029182434082,
-0.3001314401626587,
0.5894269943237305,
0.25389373302459717,
0.43400251865386963,
-0.02780996821820736,
0.6786215901374817,
0.209805428981781,
-0.6152529120445251,
0.5309478044509888,
0.251959890127182,
-0.2953452169895172,
0.8675472140312195,
-0.39919206500053406,
0.33075782656669617,
-0.219791442155838,
0.07481157034635544,
-1.2738268375396729,
-0.2810714840888977,
0.44078418612480164,
-0.7215347290039062,
0.1853068768978119,
-0.37819451093673706,
-0.17237569391727448,
-0.1982899308204651,
-0.13671258091926575,
0.34922850131988525,
0.031125737354159355,
-0.5413299202919006,
0.2925521433353424,
0.2194829136133194,
-0.3775281608104706,
-0.6351959109306335,
-0.5302402973175049,
0.12795928120613098,
0.11419209837913513,
-0.680736243724823,
0.36441314220428467,
-0.05918921157717705,
-0.23627889156341553,
0.13938383758068085,
-0.31077760457992554,
-0.3288252353668213,
0.0015471989754587412,
0.09738864749670029,
-0.11038216203451157,
-0.38886430859565735,
0.5369981527328491,
0.05078395456075668,
-0.1459246277809143,
0.1579587459564209,
-0.24643521010875702,
0.452708899974823,
0.23116755485534668,
-0.5502101182937622,
-0.33191874623298645,
0.8295571804046631,
0.14582455158233643,
-0.2676528990268707,
0.6551275253295898,
0.39645513892173767,
-0.20974327623844147,
0.005428333766758442,
-0.815331220626831,
-0.4248301684856415,
-0.3617013990879059,
0.1460559070110321,
-0.2761913537979126,
-0.7937982678413391,
0.41611024737358093,
0.08736252039670944,
-0.03911496698856354,
0.4145524501800537,
0.3818088471889496,
-0.053902942687273026,
0.9294898509979248,
0.8372402787208557,
0.30698132514953613,
0.5029355883598328,
-0.04987119883298874,
0.15943162143230438,
-0.5945755243301392,
-0.5645643472671509,
-0.8509653806686401,
-0.14925292134284973,
-0.5705757141113281,
-0.004438667558133602,
0.054619595408439636,
-0.04443245008587837,
0.2065972238779068,
0.03019082359969616,
-0.24260607361793518,
0.3790680170059204,
0.7372602224349976,
-0.0328841395676136,
0.5866392254829407,
0.1990477442741394,
-0.0809256061911583,
-0.03147862106561661,
-0.6338208913803101,
-0.14572572708129883,
0.7398667335510254,
0.029548292979598045,
0.990623950958252,
0.3445802628993988,
0.5738223791122437,
0.16663579642772675,
0.31895262002944946,
-0.7353897094726562,
0.33637791872024536,
0.18228401243686676,
-0.8346742987632751,
-0.2961362898349762,
-0.5728328227996826,
-1.128462553024292,
0.41206952929496765,
0.07000751048326492,
-0.8007932901382446,
0.3609559237957001,
0.13186584413051605,
-0.35396620631217957,
0.08180096745491028,
-0.7276681661605835,
0.935085117816925,
-0.03881332278251648,
-0.6303967237472534,
-0.30748170614242554,
-0.7146942615509033,
0.16245360672473907,
0.005391353275626898,
0.027482513338327408,
-0.046399667859077454,
0.26322847604751587,
0.8547536730766296,
-0.2313617467880249,
0.5302762389183044,
-0.10319080948829651,
-0.059180423617362976,
0.511483907699585,
0.30091601610183716,
0.16085542738437653,
-0.049015700817108154,
0.009275970980525017,
-0.11126422882080078,
0.28392449021339417,
-0.34747305512428284,
-0.7702495455741882,
0.88884437084198,
-0.60312420129776,
-0.8399587869644165,
-0.3679506480693817,
0.04013987258076668,
-0.09124480932950974,
0.15756087005138397,
0.47771140933036804,
0.43501004576683044,
0.0029092570766806602,
0.4416521489620209,
0.735541820526123,
-0.340350866317749,
0.49200835824012756,
0.9589594006538391,
-0.13492904603481293,
0.04131638631224632,
1.066038966178894,
0.2755497395992279,
0.0392586849629879,
0.4720303416252136,
0.09000034630298615,
-0.1841728538274765,
-0.3783605992794037,
-0.42407816648483276,
0.27858150005340576,
-0.6390255689620972,
-0.26027536392211914,
-0.6300867795944214,
-0.20784932374954224,
-0.392056941986084,
0.22221267223358154,
-0.4695432782173157,
-0.3081124424934387,
-0.4146007001399994,
-0.10112937539815903,
0.014579453505575657,
0.5963137149810791,
0.06167617440223694,
0.31371989846229553,
-0.9189004898071289,
0.07465605437755585,
0.2562706768512726,
0.40993279218673706,
0.053100671619176865,
-0.5176608562469482,
-0.476477712392807,
-0.19262798130512238,
-0.7470632791519165,
-1.1075061559677124,
0.5473840832710266,
0.10855875164270401,
0.4290030002593994,
0.07466398179531097,
0.1816231608390808,
0.6777116656303406,
-0.3523266911506653,
0.7409348487854004,
-0.047536853700876236,
-0.7475477457046509,
0.8399180173873901,
0.10206882655620575,
0.1282336711883545,
0.334749311208725,
0.846023678779602,
-1.1050999164581299,
-0.3086589574813843,
-0.39545613527297974,
-1.0114901065826416,
0.6334217190742493,
0.23536711931228638,
0.057942088693380356,
-0.12175162881612778,
0.4929021894931793,
0.10447626560926437,
0.1325191855430603,
-0.34157827496528625,
-0.042430222034454346,
-0.22323913872241974,
0.05685999244451523,
0.037365905940532684,
-0.5772675275802612,
0.07390715181827545,
0.24215757846832275,
0.5371233820915222,
-0.1348876804113388,
0.1738673448562622,
0.6309596300125122,
-0.4276631772518158,
-0.5927591323852539,
0.27644655108451843,
0.6105913519859314,
0.9736545085906982,
-0.25414037704467773,
0.14692874252796173,
-0.2686351239681244,
-0.4109947681427002,
-0.04595046117901802,
0.05737541988492012,
-0.21419967710971832,
0.2022799551486969,
0.22689515352249146,
0.42230093479156494,
0.25383421778678894,
-0.7361642718315125,
0.7007056474685669,
-0.18914653360843658,
0.23879209160804749,
-0.3532193899154663,
-0.009102062322199345,
-0.23651695251464844,
0.20240291953086853,
0.9620733261108398,
-0.30041244626045227,
0.2985020875930786,
-0.6405431032180786,
0.46517303586006165,
0.11147620528936386,
-0.4367609918117523,
-0.4780178964138031,
0.38762709498405457,
0.24955950677394867,
-0.5778682231903076,
0.8737042546272278,
0.3285146653652191,
-0.3835815191268921,
0.3557233214378357,
0.5110493302345276,
0.6838403940200806,
-0.38076967000961304,
0.27831292152404785,
0.24984362721443176,
-0.06240274757146835,
-0.019532088190317154,
0.3549782931804657,
-0.0016464506043121219,
-0.6667124629020691,
-0.7161738872528076,
-0.27499258518218994,
-0.6623483300209045,
-0.22189642488956451,
-0.8262116312980652,
0.0809890627861023,
-0.18408113718032837,
-0.08908902853727341,
0.044729527086019516,
0.045650362968444824,
-0.277285099029541,
0.18270111083984375,
0.11207688599824905,
0.793637216091156,
-0.5124605894088745,
0.5204062461853027,
0.5698195695877075,
-0.5288494229316711,
-0.4890996217727661,
0.2887905240058899,
0.12245272099971771,
-0.5277240872383118,
0.7403719425201416,
0.006969093810766935,
-0.14006036520004272,
0.0874769538640976,
-0.7505099773406982,
-0.8745278120040894,
0.7006576657295227,
0.12249384075403214,
-0.511176586151123,
-0.07607398927211761,
-0.17568624019622803,
0.4362732172012329,
-0.16453741490840912,
0.23581650853157043,
0.39301207661628723,
0.03684520348906517,
0.38662558794021606,
-0.49344658851623535,
0.09018032252788544,
0.1435604840517044,
-0.33490002155303955,
0.3000960946083069,
-0.5962219834327698,
0.8071105480194092,
-0.21822987496852875,
-0.41281986236572266,
0.07819210737943649,
0.5435172915458679,
0.10533395409584045,
0.8277082443237305,
0.005635162815451622,
0.389728307723999,
0.6512244939804077,
-0.14143501222133636,
1.0295438766479492,
-0.08431753516197205,
0.48688897490501404,
1.0124515295028687,
-0.12014994025230408,
1.045692801475525,
0.6324372291564941,
0.190218985080719,
0.8177218437194824,
0.3669380247592926,
0.22024239599704742,
0.5240705609321594,
0.037508416920900345,
-0.07866816967725754,
0.009065929800271988,
-0.0524912066757679,
-0.4272298514842987,
0.40638667345046997,
0.6170489192008972,
-0.250704824924469,
-0.37106746435165405,
0.16418136656284332,
0.08396187424659729,
-0.09723836183547974,
-0.07125364243984222,
0.7313877940177917,
0.08621881157159805,
-1.090882420539856,
0.4760672152042389,
0.02305150218307972,
0.1258208155632019,
-0.35711365938186646,
-0.15938207507133484,
-0.8918873071670532,
0.2058017998933792,
-0.3363095819950104,
-0.9408776164054871,
0.4410282373428345,
-0.1073855459690094,
0.06687010079622269,
-0.11736541241407394,
0.8997792601585388,
-0.3050660192966461,
-0.019523927941918373,
0.21339944005012512,
0.6421523094177246,
0.3227923810482025,
-0.41155797243118286,
-0.4088369309902191,
0.24400757253170013,
0.025622935965657234,
-0.49355942010879517,
0.26155316829681396,
0.6818963289260864,
-0.03384128212928772,
0.7036197185516357,
0.5796774625778198,
-0.14078183472156525,
0.1685839295387268,
0.09001519531011581,
0.8696509599685669,
-1.1639341115951538,
-0.292808473110199,
-0.7395337820053101,
0.2585190236568451,
-0.08599382638931274,
-0.35024696588516235,
0.9209029674530029,
0.5181474089622498,
0.931842029094696,
0.1765955090522766,
0.501133143901825,
0.020403912290930748,
0.8585065007209778,
-0.45038020610809326,
0.4819558262825012,
-0.6727315187454224,
0.3529964089393616,
-0.2641103267669678,
-0.795102596282959,
-0.3501562476158142,
0.37257570028305054,
-0.35476765036582947,
-0.3621198236942291,
0.7523660659790039,
0.658708930015564,
0.16151738166809082,
0.19094301760196686,
0.2900238335132599,
0.24016334116458893,
0.3863655626773834,
0.3700660765171051,
1.2604165077209473,
-0.3746170699596405,
1.0166115760803223,
-0.09692409634590149,
-0.16954976320266724,
-0.6434956789016724,
-0.41838714480400085,
-0.5625244379043579,
-0.44817909598350525,
-0.5017205476760864,
-0.4423922896385193,
0.46721330285072327,
0.445424348115921,
0.5793096423149109,
-0.8438968658447266,
-0.2396470159292221,
0.029216665774583817,
0.7710711359977722,
0.007688864134252071,
-0.274361789226532,
0.27826693654060364,
-0.43619030714035034,
-0.39663398265838623,
0.095476433634758,
0.29473796486854553,
-0.20161762833595276,
-0.19003328680992126,
0.29320138692855835,
-0.44840848445892334,
0.01647372357547283,
0.6612434387207031,
0.7951404452323914,
-0.520595908164978,
-0.619663417339325,
0.19807069003582,
-0.1307021677494049,
0.19144879281520844,
1.1829065084457397,
-0.8078731894493103,
0.3395974636077881,
0.5206573009490967,
0.5588204264640808,
0.8430519700050354,
0.21563494205474854,
0.5190299153327942,
-1.0031507015228271,
-0.18963545560836792,
0.2903507351875305,
-0.0602271668612957,
0.505474865436554,
-0.35531526803970337,
0.5268851518630981,
0.5859535932540894,
-0.6554403305053711,
-0.6196662783622742,
0.25903627276420593,
-0.49118345975875854,
-0.4945160746574402,
0.9846230745315552,
-0.29769372940063477,
-0.24547447264194489,
-0.18129758536815643,
-0.27982503175735474,
0.15109728276729584,
-0.23925790190696716,
0.8444639444351196,
0.7165747284889221,
-0.3082755208015442,
-0.5133277773857117,
-0.49432989954948425,
0.20629115402698517,
0.4335654079914093,
-0.45760419964790344,
-0.05463238060474396,
0.70176100730896,
0.4329478442668915,
0.32572489976882935,
0.44727349281311035,
0.023778581991791725,
0.12754930555820465,
-0.020830394700169563,
-0.1091361939907074,
0.5174283385276794,
-0.5450250506401062,
-0.007544999476522207,
0.5884835124015808,
-0.22111426293849945,
-0.2937530279159546
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.